diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_0/index_tensor([5387, 5387])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_0/index_tensor([5387, 5387])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..71f16a3302e19cc57206a1250a0d74e82106c1ce --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_0/index_tensor([5387, 5387])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic close-up tracking shot, viewed from a slightly upward angle, closely follows a massive mechanical suit as it plummets from the sky with unstoppable force. The suit's dark gray tungsten alloy armor dominates the frame, its intricate mechanical structure, hydraulic ducts, and radiator grilles clearly visible. As it streaks through the sky at breakneck speed, its rigid shell collides with the atmosphere, sending forth countless dazzling orange-red sparks. These cascades of sparks cascade down the armor's intricate edges and raised structures, instantly illuminating the metal surface, scarred by microscopic scratches and battle scars. Against the backdrop, a dense, shredded cloud layer races by, piercing through the cracks. Dazzling sunlight filters through the gaps, creating sharp metallic reflections on the suit's hull, a stark contrast to the faint blue energy glow emanating from the armor's seams. The entire scene is imbued with a breathtaking sense of speed and overwhelming pressure, creating a tense and spectacular sci-fi atmosphere.", + "seed": 9522, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_0/index_5387_seed_9522_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05683741583488881, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05683741583488881, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4000000238418577, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05683741583488881, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic close-up tracking shot following a massive mechanical suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle viewed from a slightly upward direction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical suit moving by plummeting from the sky at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are countless orange-red sparks visible cascading down the suit's armor due to atmospheric collision?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint blue energy glow emanating from the armor's seams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06318201869726181 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8131821155548096 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06318201869726181, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06318201869726181, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09255800396203995, + 0.04941735789179802, + 0.05045764893293381, + 0.06423760205507278, + 0.04144151136279106, + 0.0894409567117691, + 0.12195959687232971, + 0.03031584806740284, + 0.28030282258987427, + 0.17986860871315002 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06318201869726181 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic close-up tracking shot following a massive mechanical suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle viewed from a slightly upward direction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical suit moving by plummeting from the sky at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are countless orange-red sparks visible cascading down the suit's armor due to atmospheric collision?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint blue energy glow emanating from the armor's seams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026366282254457474 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513662338256836 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026366282254457474, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026366282254457474, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14147543907165527, + 0.0365988127887249, + 0.0886608436703682, + 0.09723195433616638, + 0.03197186812758446, + 0.029586585238575935, + 0.054729804396629333, + 0.07591547071933746, + 0.2355763465166092, + 0.2082529067993164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026366282254457474 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic close-up tracking shot following a massive mechanical suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle viewed from a slightly upward direction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical suit moving by plummeting from the sky at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are countless orange-red sparks visible cascading down the suit's armor due to atmospheric collision?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint blue energy glow emanating from the armor's seams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048663750290870667 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048663854598999 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048663750290870667, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048663750290870667, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.051597658544778824, + 0.03240383416414261, + 0.20685914158821106, + 0.05750887468457222, + 0.048769980669021606, + 0.11055392026901245, + 0.1124776229262352, + 0.09439294785261154, + 0.20958448946475983, + 0.07585151493549347 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048663750290870667 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic close-up tracking shot following a massive mechanical suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle viewed from a slightly upward direction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical suit moving by plummeting from the sky at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are countless orange-red sparks visible cascading down the suit's armor due to atmospheric collision?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint blue energy glow emanating from the armor's seams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003194113029167056 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753194332122803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003194113029167056, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003194113029167056, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06886173039674759, + 0.05855163559317589, + 0.03687494620680809, + 0.13950830698013306, + 0.13727840781211853, + 0.07352745532989502, + 0.06830262392759323, + 0.06602446734905243, + 0.2482164055109024, + 0.10285412520170212 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003194113029167056 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic close-up tracking shot following a massive mechanical suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle viewed from a slightly upward direction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical suit moving by plummeting from the sky at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are countless orange-red sparks visible cascading down the suit's armor due to atmospheric collision?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint blue energy glow emanating from the armor's seams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14278091490268707 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0177810192108154 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14278091490268707, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14278091490268707, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14564532041549683, + 0.06783433258533478, + 0.03501356393098831, + 0.03584926947951317, + 0.040492281317710876, + 0.040276773273944855, + 0.06443115323781967, + 0.14735834300518036, + 0.2661552131175995, + 0.15694378316402435 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14278091490268707 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic close-up tracking shot, viewed from a slightly upward angle, closely follows a massive mechanical suit as it plummets from the sky with unstoppable force. The suit's dark gray tungsten alloy armor dominates the frame, its intricate mechanical structure, hydraulic ducts, and radiator grilles clearly visible. As it streaks through the sky at breakneck speed, its rigid shell collides with the atmosphere, sending forth countless dazzling orange-red sparks. These cascades of sparks cascade down the armor's intricate edges and raised structures, instantly illuminating the metal surface, scarred by microscopic scratches and battle scars. Against the backdrop, a dense, shredded cloud layer races by, piercing through the cracks. Dazzling sunlight filters through the gaps, creating sharp metallic reflections on the suit's hull, a stark contrast to the faint blue energy glow emanating from the armor's seams. The entire scene is imbued with a breathtaking sense of speed and overwhelming pressure, creating a tense and spectacular sci-fi atmosphere.", + "seed": 9523, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_0/index_5387_seed_9523_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0992549903690815, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0992549903690815, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0992549903690815, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic close-up tracking shot following a massive mechanical suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle viewed from a slightly upward direction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical suit moving by plummeting from the sky at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are countless orange-red sparks visible cascading down the suit's armor due to atmospheric collision?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint blue energy glow emanating from the armor's seams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09046007692813873 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4654600620269775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09046007692813873, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09046007692813873, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12070388346910477, + 0.1893586814403534, + 0.0629812702536583, + 0.09226885437965393, + 0.05633050575852394, + 0.14238043129444122, + 0.11792092770338058, + 0.11649312824010849, + 0.03900221735239029, + 0.06256009638309479 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09046007692813873 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic close-up tracking shot following a massive mechanical suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle viewed from a slightly upward direction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical suit moving by plummeting from the sky at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are countless orange-red sparks visible cascading down the suit's armor due to atmospheric collision?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint blue energy glow emanating from the armor's seams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003326714038849 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695033311843872 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003326714038849, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003326714038849, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10988032072782516, + 0.45697322487831116, + 0.09163758158683777, + 0.04296348616480827, + 0.053395919501781464, + 0.06002964451909065, + 0.06139739230275154, + 0.017951322719454765, + 0.03324015066027641, + 0.07253098487854004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003326714038849 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic close-up tracking shot following a massive mechanical suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle viewed from a slightly upward direction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical suit moving by plummeting from the sky at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are countless orange-red sparks visible cascading down the suit's armor due to atmospheric collision?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint blue energy glow emanating from the armor's seams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009789789095520973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634789943695068 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009789789095520973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009789789095520973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32604721188545227, + 0.1199379488825798, + 0.18233805894851685, + 0.05815533176064491, + 0.05189073085784912, + 0.045498427003622055, + 0.0347769595682621, + 0.053703367710113525, + 0.050775542855262756, + 0.0768764317035675 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009789789095520973 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic close-up tracking shot following a massive mechanical suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle viewed from a slightly upward direction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical suit moving by plummeting from the sky at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are countless orange-red sparks visible cascading down the suit's armor due to atmospheric collision?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint blue energy glow emanating from the armor's seams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012543240562081337 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387543201446533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012543240562081337, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012543240562081337, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21800780296325684, + 0.03972368687391281, + 0.06398307532072067, + 0.05452379211783409, + 0.08341064304113388, + 0.1987062692642212, + 0.029967671260237694, + 0.05232208967208862, + 0.16383522748947144, + 0.09551967680454254 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012543240562081337 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic close-up tracking shot following a massive mechanical suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle viewed from a slightly upward direction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical suit moving by plummeting from the sky at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are countless orange-red sparks visible cascading down the suit's armor due to atmospheric collision?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint blue energy glow emanating from the armor's seams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31344857811927795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134485483169556 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31344857811927795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31344857811927795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09399721026420593, + 0.03993947058916092, + 0.028148634359240532, + 0.0474659763276577, + 0.03721412643790245, + 0.05644458532333374, + 0.025007983669638634, + 0.05837470665574074, + 0.07235939055681229, + 0.5410479307174683 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31344857811927795 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic close-up tracking shot, viewed from a slightly upward angle, closely follows a massive mechanical suit as it plummets from the sky with unstoppable force. The suit's dark gray tungsten alloy armor dominates the frame, its intricate mechanical structure, hydraulic ducts, and radiator grilles clearly visible. As it streaks through the sky at breakneck speed, its rigid shell collides with the atmosphere, sending forth countless dazzling orange-red sparks. These cascades of sparks cascade down the armor's intricate edges and raised structures, instantly illuminating the metal surface, scarred by microscopic scratches and battle scars. Against the backdrop, a dense, shredded cloud layer races by, piercing through the cracks. Dazzling sunlight filters through the gaps, creating sharp metallic reflections on the suit's hull, a stark contrast to the faint blue energy glow emanating from the armor's seams. The entire scene is imbued with a breathtaking sense of speed and overwhelming pressure, creating a tense and spectacular sci-fi atmosphere.", + "seed": 9524, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_0/index_5387_seed_9524_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06534025510773063, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06534025510773063, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06534025510773063, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic close-up tracking shot following a massive mechanical suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle viewed from a slightly upward direction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical suit moving by plummeting from the sky at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are countless orange-red sparks visible cascading down the suit's armor due to atmospheric collision?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint blue energy glow emanating from the armor's seams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02306571789085865 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8980658054351807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02306571789085865, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02306571789085865, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12062211334705353, + 0.08518168330192566, + 0.15269801020622253, + 0.13279536366462708, + 0.2630488872528076, + 0.1388975828886032, + 0.033502738922834396, + 0.030473535880446434, + 0.016759244725108147, + 0.026020824909210205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02306571789085865 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic close-up tracking shot following a massive mechanical suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle viewed from a slightly upward direction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical suit moving by plummeting from the sky at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are countless orange-red sparks visible cascading down the suit's armor due to atmospheric collision?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint blue energy glow emanating from the armor's seams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205388531088829 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812053918838501 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205388531088829, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205388531088829, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27124476432800293, + 0.038626983761787415, + 0.14033329486846924, + 0.04138446971774101, + 0.1477334201335907, + 0.15684692561626434, + 0.05806548893451691, + 0.04462636262178421, + 0.045235708355903625, + 0.05590248107910156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205388531088829 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic close-up tracking shot following a massive mechanical suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle viewed from a slightly upward direction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical suit moving by plummeting from the sky at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are countless orange-red sparks visible cascading down the suit's armor due to atmospheric collision?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint blue energy glow emanating from the armor's seams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496230721473694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929962396621704 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496230721473694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496230721473694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19577591121196747, + 0.12737666070461273, + 0.08743349462747574, + 0.0564856193959713, + 0.29012805223464966, + 0.10158231109380722, + 0.06300690770149231, + 0.024128925055265427, + 0.028593989089131355, + 0.025488216429948807 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496230721473694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic close-up tracking shot following a massive mechanical suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle viewed from a slightly upward direction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical suit moving by plummeting from the sky at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are countless orange-red sparks visible cascading down the suit's armor due to atmospheric collision?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint blue energy glow emanating from the armor's seams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006739267613738775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006739139556885 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006739267613738775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006739267613738775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10455825179815292, + 0.03299867361783981, + 0.039045870304107666, + 0.031281258910894394, + 0.16454032063484192, + 0.36141785979270935, + 0.1584300994873047, + 0.053961340337991714, + 0.023956025019288063, + 0.02981029637157917 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006739267613738775 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic close-up tracking shot following a massive mechanical suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle viewed from a slightly upward direction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical suit moving by plummeting from the sky at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are countless orange-red sparks visible cascading down the suit's armor due to atmospheric collision?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint blue energy glow emanating from the armor's seams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17988009750843048 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804880142211914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17988009750843048, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17988009750843048, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18157698214054108, + 0.02162873186171055, + 0.04259404540061951, + 0.028432201594114304, + 0.5228545665740967, + 0.0456819050014019, + 0.05181153118610382, + 0.04017324000597, + 0.03017936833202839, + 0.035067472606897354 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17988009750843048 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic close-up tracking shot, viewed from a slightly upward angle, closely follows a massive mechanical suit as it plummets from the sky with unstoppable force. The suit's dark gray tungsten alloy armor dominates the frame, its intricate mechanical structure, hydraulic ducts, and radiator grilles clearly visible. As it streaks through the sky at breakneck speed, its rigid shell collides with the atmosphere, sending forth countless dazzling orange-red sparks. These cascades of sparks cascade down the armor's intricate edges and raised structures, instantly illuminating the metal surface, scarred by microscopic scratches and battle scars. Against the backdrop, a dense, shredded cloud layer races by, piercing through the cracks. Dazzling sunlight filters through the gaps, creating sharp metallic reflections on the suit's hull, a stark contrast to the faint blue energy glow emanating from the armor's seams. The entire scene is imbued with a breathtaking sense of speed and overwhelming pressure, creating a tense and spectacular sci-fi atmosphere.", + "seed": 9525, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_0/index_5387_seed_9525_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10397271029651164, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10397271029651164, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7249999761581423, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10397271029651164, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic close-up tracking shot following a massive mechanical suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle viewed from a slightly upward direction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical suit moving by plummeting from the sky at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are countless orange-red sparks visible cascading down the suit's armor due to atmospheric collision?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint blue energy glow emanating from the armor's seams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12967881560325623 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.129678726196289 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12967881560325623, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12967881560325623, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08922713249921799, + 0.06155835837125778, + 0.05770236626267433, + 0.05360008776187897, + 0.2936716675758362, + 0.08177778869867325, + 0.037662241607904434, + 0.09988517314195633, + 0.014879142865538597, + 0.21003606915473938 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12967881560325623 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic close-up tracking shot following a massive mechanical suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle viewed from a slightly upward direction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical suit moving by plummeting from the sky at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are countless orange-red sparks visible cascading down the suit's armor due to atmospheric collision?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint blue energy glow emanating from the armor's seams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004226744174957 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695042371749878 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004226744174957, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004226744174957, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14552263915538788, + 0.060049738734960556, + 0.0441281832754612, + 0.0663410946726799, + 0.28405192494392395, + 0.06030349060893059, + 0.04901433736085892, + 0.15051189064979553, + 0.044086527079343796, + 0.09599009901285172 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004226744174957 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic close-up tracking shot following a massive mechanical suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle viewed from a slightly upward direction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical suit moving by plummeting from the sky at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are countless orange-red sparks visible cascading down the suit's armor due to atmospheric collision?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint blue energy glow emanating from the armor's seams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020600290969014168 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956003189086914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020600290969014168, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020600290969014168, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11817652732133865, + 0.043389130383729935, + 0.04794340953230858, + 0.0653361901640892, + 0.17367030680179596, + 0.08839304000139236, + 0.08550695329904556, + 0.168154776096344, + 0.059690210968256, + 0.14973942935466766 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020600290969014168 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic close-up tracking shot following a massive mechanical suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle viewed from a slightly upward direction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical suit moving by plummeting from the sky at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are countless orange-red sparks visible cascading down the suit's armor due to atmospheric collision?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint blue energy glow emanating from the armor's seams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018198776990175247 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0181989669799805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018198776990175247, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018198776990175247, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09077873826026917, + 0.05613618716597557, + 0.029794540256261826, + 0.054190341383218765, + 0.1253482848405838, + 0.07655356079339981, + 0.10083018988370895, + 0.15713129937648773, + 0.1609482318162918, + 0.14828863739967346 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018198776990175247 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a dynamic close-up tracking shot following a massive mechanical suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle viewed from a slightly upward direction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical suit moving by plummeting from the sky at high speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are countless orange-red sparks visible cascading down the suit's armor due to atmospheric collision?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint blue energy glow emanating from the armor's seams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28134340047836304 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063434600830078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28134340047836304, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28134340047836304, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14312048256397247, + 0.07212387025356293, + 0.04298809915781021, + 0.08511235564947128, + 0.09228654950857162, + 0.24754026532173157, + 0.10150884091854095, + 0.07022041082382202, + 0.060766320675611496, + 0.08433280885219574 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28134340047836304 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_1/index_tensor([8238, 8238])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_1/index_tensor([8238, 8238])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..61111cf0209b287d9ee277f94c7584b89529fac1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_1/index_tensor([8238, 8238])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "cinematic, slow-motion, low-angle tracking shot follows a traditional red sedan as it moves. The evening sun, streaming low from the end of the street, casts a dazzling golden hue on the sedan and its four bearers, creating a striking silhouette. The sedan is painted a vibrant crimson, its roof draped in richly embroidered silk. Golden tassels dangle from the corners, swaying as the sedan sways. The delicately carved wooden window panes are obscured by thin red silk curtains, adding a touch of mystery. The sedan travels along a narrow, ancient bluestone street, the pavement damp from recent rain, reflecting the warm glow of the fading sunlight. The street is lined with ancient wooden buildings with overhanging eaves, their red lanterns still unlit beneath the eaves. The scene is imbued with a tranquil and solemn atmosphere. Four sedan chair bearers, dressed in traditional dark shorts, tread with steady and powerful steps. Each step, treading on the slippery stone slabs, causes the sedan to pitch rhythmically and noticeably, with the curtains and tassels swaying violently, visualizing the dynamic process of \"bumping.\" The entire scene, dominated by a warm yellow hue, uses strong contrast between light and dark, along with slow motion, to create a unique aesthetic of solemnity and celebration, yet with a touch of historical vicissitudes, as if a classic moment frozen in time.", + "seed": 31698, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_1/index_8238_seed_31698_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0724807247519493, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0724807247519493, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0724807247519493, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following a traditional red sedan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sedan painted a vibrant crimson color with a roof draped in richly embroidered silk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are four bearers dressed in traditional dark shorts visible, treading with steady steps on the street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a narrow, ancient bluestone street lined with wooden buildings featuring unlit red lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the sedan swaying and pitching rhythmically with curtains and tassels swaying violently due to the bearers' steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08410473167896271 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5841047763824463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08410473167896271, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08410473167896271, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18062278628349304, + 0.2652584910392761, + 0.05868081748485565, + 0.07254406809806824, + 0.2229142189025879, + 0.040559105575084686, + 0.02921351231634617, + 0.04759002849459648, + 0.038178451359272, + 0.044438526034355164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08410473167896271 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following a traditional red sedan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sedan painted a vibrant crimson color with a roof draped in richly embroidered silk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are four bearers dressed in traditional dark shorts visible, treading with steady steps on the street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a narrow, ancient bluestone street lined with wooden buildings featuring unlit red lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the sedan swaying and pitching rhythmically with curtains and tassels swaying violently due to the bearers' steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08907774090766907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640777111053467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08907774090766907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08907774090766907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3680756986141205, + 0.07042829692363739, + 0.05972716957330704, + 0.06444543600082397, + 0.16745997965335846, + 0.02811163105070591, + 0.04371361806988716, + 0.06580191105604172, + 0.01882648840546608, + 0.11340980231761932 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08907774090766907 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following a traditional red sedan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sedan painted a vibrant crimson color with a roof draped in richly embroidered silk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are four bearers dressed in traditional dark shorts visible, treading with steady steps on the street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a narrow, ancient bluestone street lined with wooden buildings featuring unlit red lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the sedan swaying and pitching rhythmically with curtains and tassels swaying violently due to the bearers' steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08905996382236481 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464060068130493 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08905996382236481, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08905996382236481, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2150116264820099, + 0.10276959091424942, + 0.07063988596200943, + 0.07848421484231949, + 0.20659276843070984, + 0.03749299794435501, + 0.07941208779811859, + 0.0649649128317833, + 0.0460217222571373, + 0.09861017763614655 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08905996382236481 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following a traditional red sedan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sedan painted a vibrant crimson color with a roof draped in richly embroidered silk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are four bearers dressed in traditional dark shorts visible, treading with steady steps on the street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a narrow, ancient bluestone street lined with wooden buildings featuring unlit red lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the sedan swaying and pitching rhythmically with curtains and tassels swaying violently due to the bearers' steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062057919800281525 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120579719543457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062057919800281525, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062057919800281525, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2498566210269928, + 0.04729745164513588, + 0.05565381422638893, + 0.09502436965703964, + 0.10991107672452927, + 0.03959519788622856, + 0.2095014750957489, + 0.04986083135008812, + 0.0556592233479023, + 0.08763985335826874 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062057919800281525 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following a traditional red sedan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sedan painted a vibrant crimson color with a roof draped in richly embroidered silk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are four bearers dressed in traditional dark shorts visible, treading with steady steps on the street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a narrow, ancient bluestone street lined with wooden buildings featuring unlit red lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the sedan swaying and pitching rhythmically with curtains and tassels swaying violently due to the bearers' steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038103267550468445 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881033420562744 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038103267550468445, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038103267550468445, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1692531257867813, + 0.09278083592653275, + 0.08719252049922943, + 0.08872681111097336, + 0.18029949069023132, + 0.06273873150348663, + 0.06909127533435822, + 0.08588952571153641, + 0.0734611302614212, + 0.09056655317544937 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038103267550468445 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematic, slow-motion, low-angle tracking shot follows a traditional red sedan as it moves. The evening sun, streaming low from the end of the street, casts a dazzling golden hue on the sedan and its four bearers, creating a striking silhouette. The sedan is painted a vibrant crimson, its roof draped in richly embroidered silk. Golden tassels dangle from the corners, swaying as the sedan sways. The delicately carved wooden window panes are obscured by thin red silk curtains, adding a touch of mystery. The sedan travels along a narrow, ancient bluestone street, the pavement damp from recent rain, reflecting the warm glow of the fading sunlight. The street is lined with ancient wooden buildings with overhanging eaves, their red lanterns still unlit beneath the eaves. The scene is imbued with a tranquil and solemn atmosphere. Four sedan chair bearers, dressed in traditional dark shorts, tread with steady and powerful steps. Each step, treading on the slippery stone slabs, causes the sedan to pitch rhythmically and noticeably, with the curtains and tassels swaying violently, visualizing the dynamic process of \"bumping.\" The entire scene, dominated by a warm yellow hue, uses strong contrast between light and dark, along with slow motion, to create a unique aesthetic of solemnity and celebration, yet with a touch of historical vicissitudes, as if a classic moment frozen in time.", + "seed": 31699, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_1/index_8238_seed_31699_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.1200018871575594, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1200018871575594, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1200018871575594, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following a traditional red sedan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sedan painted a vibrant crimson color with a roof draped in richly embroidered silk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are four bearers dressed in traditional dark shorts visible, treading with steady steps on the street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a narrow, ancient bluestone street lined with wooden buildings featuring unlit red lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the sedan swaying and pitching rhythmically with curtains and tassels swaying violently due to the bearers' steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12845829129219055 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.128458261489868 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12845829129219055, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12845829129219055, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09443342685699463, + 0.12563860416412354, + 0.10404863208532333, + 0.08257851004600525, + 0.29181531071662903, + 0.07533148676156998, + 0.05270129442214966, + 0.07704344391822815, + 0.07149055600166321, + 0.02491879276931286 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12845829129219055 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following a traditional red sedan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sedan painted a vibrant crimson color with a roof draped in richly embroidered silk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are four bearers dressed in traditional dark shorts visible, treading with steady steps on the street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a narrow, ancient bluestone street lined with wooden buildings featuring unlit red lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the sedan swaying and pitching rhythmically with curtains and tassels swaying violently due to the bearers' steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17993606626987457 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049360513687134 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17993606626987457, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17993606626987457, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08988619595766068, + 0.07149701565504074, + 0.13160264492034912, + 0.0665094256401062, + 0.10782446712255478, + 0.03656260296702385, + 0.043114110827445984, + 0.3416568636894226, + 0.02277441881597042, + 0.0885721817612648 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17993606626987457 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following a traditional red sedan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sedan painted a vibrant crimson color with a roof draped in richly embroidered silk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are four bearers dressed in traditional dark shorts visible, treading with steady steps on the street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a narrow, ancient bluestone street lined with wooden buildings featuring unlit red lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the sedan swaying and pitching rhythmically with curtains and tassels swaying violently due to the bearers' steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11298664659261703 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379865646362305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11298664659261703, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11298664659261703, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06472024321556091, + 0.137799933552742, + 0.07265415787696838, + 0.044967107474803925, + 0.1232793778181076, + 0.1482132226228714, + 0.031044529750943184, + 0.15194588899612427, + 0.15496142208576202, + 0.07041414082050323 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11298664659261703 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following a traditional red sedan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sedan painted a vibrant crimson color with a roof draped in richly embroidered silk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are four bearers dressed in traditional dark shorts visible, treading with steady steps on the street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a narrow, ancient bluestone street lined with wooden buildings featuring unlit red lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the sedan swaying and pitching rhythmically with curtains and tassels swaying violently due to the bearers' steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16043035686016083 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104303121566772 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16043035686016083, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16043035686016083, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12620799243450165, + 0.06619662046432495, + 0.07672497630119324, + 0.21788670122623444, + 0.2098202258348465, + 0.025226548314094543, + 0.03469521924853325, + 0.04471081495285034, + 0.12800487875938416, + 0.07052601128816605 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16043035686016083 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following a traditional red sedan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sedan painted a vibrant crimson color with a roof draped in richly embroidered silk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are four bearers dressed in traditional dark shorts visible, treading with steady steps on the street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a narrow, ancient bluestone street lined with wooden buildings featuring unlit red lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the sedan swaying and pitching rhythmically with curtains and tassels swaying violently due to the bearers' steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018198074772953987 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018198013305664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018198074772953987, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018198074772953987, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06909157335758209, + 0.07682432979345322, + 0.2373226284980774, + 0.037208352237939835, + 0.16989406943321228, + 0.04264563322067261, + 0.032512012869119644, + 0.1058516725897789, + 0.16794228553771973, + 0.06070741266012192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018198074772953987 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematic, slow-motion, low-angle tracking shot follows a traditional red sedan as it moves. The evening sun, streaming low from the end of the street, casts a dazzling golden hue on the sedan and its four bearers, creating a striking silhouette. The sedan is painted a vibrant crimson, its roof draped in richly embroidered silk. Golden tassels dangle from the corners, swaying as the sedan sways. The delicately carved wooden window panes are obscured by thin red silk curtains, adding a touch of mystery. The sedan travels along a narrow, ancient bluestone street, the pavement damp from recent rain, reflecting the warm glow of the fading sunlight. The street is lined with ancient wooden buildings with overhanging eaves, their red lanterns still unlit beneath the eaves. The scene is imbued with a tranquil and solemn atmosphere. Four sedan chair bearers, dressed in traditional dark shorts, tread with steady and powerful steps. Each step, treading on the slippery stone slabs, causes the sedan to pitch rhythmically and noticeably, with the curtains and tassels swaying violently, visualizing the dynamic process of \"bumping.\" The entire scene, dominated by a warm yellow hue, uses strong contrast between light and dark, along with slow motion, to create a unique aesthetic of solemnity and celebration, yet with a touch of historical vicissitudes, as if a classic moment frozen in time.", + "seed": 31700, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_1/index_8238_seed_31700_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.2054791882634163, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2054791882634163, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.800000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2054791882634163, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following a traditional red sedan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sedan painted a vibrant crimson color with a roof draped in richly embroidered silk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are four bearers dressed in traditional dark shorts visible, treading with steady steps on the street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a narrow, ancient bluestone street lined with wooden buildings featuring unlit red lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the sedan swaying and pitching rhythmically with curtains and tassels swaying violently due to the bearers' steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2556782066822052 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5056781768798828 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2556782066822052, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2556782066822052, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11263381689786911, + 0.019642341881990433, + 0.17934483289718628, + 0.12052298337221146, + 0.031661953777074814, + 0.055223677307367325, + 0.0733102336525917, + 0.31378114223480225, + 0.05643058568239212, + 0.03744841739535332 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2556782066822052 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following a traditional red sedan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sedan painted a vibrant crimson color with a roof draped in richly embroidered silk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are four bearers dressed in traditional dark shorts visible, treading with steady steps on the street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a narrow, ancient bluestone street lined with wooden buildings featuring unlit red lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the sedan swaying and pitching rhythmically with curtains and tassels swaying violently due to the bearers' steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22563506662845612 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600635051727295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22563506662845612, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22563506662845612, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09283533692359924, + 0.021052014082670212, + 0.2257189303636551, + 0.06860290467739105, + 0.02179378643631935, + 0.05247911810874939, + 0.09009762853384018, + 0.3862440884113312, + 0.02289678156375885, + 0.018279504030942917 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22563506662845612 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following a traditional red sedan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sedan painted a vibrant crimson color with a roof draped in richly embroidered silk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are four bearers dressed in traditional dark shorts visible, treading with steady steps on the street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a narrow, ancient bluestone street lined with wooden buildings featuring unlit red lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the sedan swaying and pitching rhythmically with curtains and tassels swaying violently due to the bearers' steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07901092618703842 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790109634399414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07901092618703842, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07901092618703842, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27218636870384216, + 0.0440247543156147, + 0.13439643383026123, + 0.09307212382555008, + 0.05577241629362106, + 0.09414368122816086, + 0.07901022583246231, + 0.15272332727909088, + 0.04890380799770355, + 0.02576683647930622 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07901092618703842 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following a traditional red sedan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sedan painted a vibrant crimson color with a roof draped in richly embroidered silk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are four bearers dressed in traditional dark shorts visible, treading with steady steps on the street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a narrow, ancient bluestone street lined with wooden buildings featuring unlit red lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the sedan swaying and pitching rhythmically with curtains and tassels swaying violently due to the bearers' steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42894357442855835 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539436340332031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42894357442855835, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.6250000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42894357442855835, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16755011677742004, + 0.09557487070560455, + 0.12285425513982773, + 0.19575077295303345, + 0.05306900292634964, + 0.09798261523246765, + 0.1375446617603302, + 0.061126694083213806, + 0.0312618725001812, + 0.03728518635034561 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42894357442855835 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following a traditional red sedan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sedan painted a vibrant crimson color with a roof draped in richly embroidered silk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are four bearers dressed in traditional dark shorts visible, treading with steady steps on the street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a narrow, ancient bluestone street lined with wooden buildings featuring unlit red lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the sedan swaying and pitching rhythmically with curtains and tassels swaying violently due to the bearers' steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038128167390823364 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288128137588501 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038128167390823364, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038128167390823364, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09387898445129395, + 0.03038531355559826, + 0.04366760328412056, + 0.4335238039493561, + 0.029116922989487648, + 0.059148628264665604, + 0.06598113477230072, + 0.12386255711317062, + 0.07689676433801651, + 0.043538302183151245 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038128167390823364 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematic, slow-motion, low-angle tracking shot follows a traditional red sedan as it moves. The evening sun, streaming low from the end of the street, casts a dazzling golden hue on the sedan and its four bearers, creating a striking silhouette. The sedan is painted a vibrant crimson, its roof draped in richly embroidered silk. Golden tassels dangle from the corners, swaying as the sedan sways. The delicately carved wooden window panes are obscured by thin red silk curtains, adding a touch of mystery. The sedan travels along a narrow, ancient bluestone street, the pavement damp from recent rain, reflecting the warm glow of the fading sunlight. The street is lined with ancient wooden buildings with overhanging eaves, their red lanterns still unlit beneath the eaves. The scene is imbued with a tranquil and solemn atmosphere. Four sedan chair bearers, dressed in traditional dark shorts, tread with steady and powerful steps. Each step, treading on the slippery stone slabs, causes the sedan to pitch rhythmically and noticeably, with the curtains and tassels swaying violently, visualizing the dynamic process of \"bumping.\" The entire scene, dominated by a warm yellow hue, uses strong contrast between light and dark, along with slow motion, to create a unique aesthetic of solemnity and celebration, yet with a touch of historical vicissitudes, as if a classic moment frozen in time.", + "seed": 31701, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_1/index_8238_seed_31701_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06789509914815425, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06789509914815425, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06789509914815425, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following a traditional red sedan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sedan painted a vibrant crimson color with a roof draped in richly embroidered silk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are four bearers dressed in traditional dark shorts visible, treading with steady steps on the street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a narrow, ancient bluestone street lined with wooden buildings featuring unlit red lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the sedan swaying and pitching rhythmically with curtains and tassels swaying violently due to the bearers' steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06480228900909424 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8148021697998047 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06480228900909424, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06480228900909424, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27527448534965515, + 0.1384439319372177, + 0.13873010873794556, + 0.09998361766338348, + 0.09007613360881805, + 0.08224219083786011, + 0.047544341534376144, + 0.05738537758588791, + 0.018840491771697998, + 0.05147930979728699 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06480228900909424 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following a traditional red sedan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sedan painted a vibrant crimson color with a roof draped in richly embroidered silk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are four bearers dressed in traditional dark shorts visible, treading with steady steps on the street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a narrow, ancient bluestone street lined with wooden buildings featuring unlit red lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the sedan swaying and pitching rhythmically with curtains and tassels swaying violently due to the bearers' steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812621906399727 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288126230239868 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812621906399727, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812621906399727, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17757663130760193, + 0.10087192803621292, + 0.2269878089427948, + 0.08017276972532272, + 0.07635174691677094, + 0.08520682901144028, + 0.05391692742705345, + 0.06837008893489838, + 0.07803410291671753, + 0.052511170506477356 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812621906399727 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following a traditional red sedan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sedan painted a vibrant crimson color with a roof draped in richly embroidered silk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are four bearers dressed in traditional dark shorts visible, treading with steady steps on the street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a narrow, ancient bluestone street lined with wooden buildings featuring unlit red lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the sedan swaying and pitching rhythmically with curtains and tassels swaying violently due to the bearers' steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1129366084933281 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237936496734619 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1129366084933281, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1129366084933281, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3283838629722595, + 0.09535664319992065, + 0.1971275508403778, + 0.11093883961439133, + 0.0419602170586586, + 0.047419223934412, + 0.06169423460960388, + 0.065226249396801, + 0.027801336720585823, + 0.024091826751828194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1129366084933281 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following a traditional red sedan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sedan painted a vibrant crimson color with a roof draped in richly embroidered silk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are four bearers dressed in traditional dark shorts visible, treading with steady steps on the street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a narrow, ancient bluestone street lined with wooden buildings featuring unlit red lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the sedan swaying and pitching rhythmically with curtains and tassels swaying violently due to the bearers' steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10032067447900772 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.35032057762146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10032067447900772, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10032067447900772, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29715943336486816, + 0.12275178730487823, + 0.10277368128299713, + 0.141519233584404, + 0.10950502753257751, + 0.08570998162031174, + 0.04812831059098244, + 0.04491867497563362, + 0.021239489316940308, + 0.02629435807466507 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10032067447900772 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following a traditional red sedan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sedan painted a vibrant crimson color with a roof draped in richly embroidered silk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are four bearers dressed in traditional dark shorts visible, treading with steady steps on the street?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a narrow, ancient bluestone street lined with wooden buildings featuring unlit red lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the sedan swaying and pitching rhythmically with curtains and tassels swaying violently due to the bearers' steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02328970469534397 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773289680480957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02328970469534397, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02328970469534397, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22129036486148834, + 0.08965188264846802, + 0.23965533077716827, + 0.07073033601045609, + 0.10427681356668472, + 0.04878687858581543, + 0.03653040900826454, + 0.04911045730113983, + 0.053922709077596664, + 0.08604473620653152 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02328970469534397 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_10/index_tensor([8507, 8507])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_10/index_tensor([8507, 8507])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1ee3c96c483c460c62cff99a8dddc445874a9ac2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_10/index_tensor([8507, 8507])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "drone's wide-angle lens, captured from high above, slowly pans forward, capturing a long line of police cars in the dead of night. Atop these modern police vehicles, alternating red and blue warning lights flash in a rapid, rhythmic rhythm. Their glare reflects and stretches across the slightly damp asphalt, converging into a dazzling, flowing river of light. The convoy is traveling on an empty city highway, heading straight for the entrance of a vast, eerie concrete tunnel. As the lead police car steadily and decisively plunges into the darkness of the tunnel, the following vehicles follow closely behind, the river of light seemingly swallowed by the tunnel's vast mouth. The entire scene, pierced by red and blue light against a deep blue and black palette, creates a cinematic atmosphere of heightened tension, suspense, and urgency.", + "seed": 3371, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_10/index_8507_seed_3371_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.16559329964220523, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16559329964220523, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16559329964220523, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene viewed from a high-angle perspective using a wide-angle lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long line of modern police cars visible on an empty city highway at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do alternating red and blue warning lights flash rapidly on the police vehicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the convoy travel toward and enter a vast concrete tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.13793469965457916 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.637934684753418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.13793469965457916, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.13793469965457916, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23651835322380066, + 0.10100416839122772, + 0.0768648013472557, + 0.05328536033630371, + 0.06590156257152557, + 0.05563172698020935, + 0.11467190086841583, + 0.18414993584156036, + 0.052185796201229095, + 0.05978637933731079 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.13793469965457916 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene viewed from a high-angle perspective using a wide-angle lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long line of modern police cars visible on an empty city highway at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do alternating red and blue warning lights flash rapidly on the police vehicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the convoy travel toward and enter a vast concrete tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17988437414169312 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804884433746338 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17988437414169312, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17988437414169312, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10298147052526474, + 0.09997600317001343, + 0.04694165661931038, + 0.04176308214664459, + 0.04273032397031784, + 0.05620769411325455, + 0.12195765972137451, + 0.3401965796947479, + 0.06882580369710922, + 0.0784197598695755 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17988437414169312 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene viewed from a high-angle perspective using a wide-angle lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long line of modern police cars visible on an empty city highway at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do alternating red and blue warning lights flash rapidly on the police vehicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the convoy travel toward and enter a vast concrete tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520931363105774 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020930767059326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520931363105774, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520931363105774, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21789337694644928, + 0.08331730961799622, + 0.042252011597156525, + 0.03796571493148804, + 0.04237309470772743, + 0.07705993205308914, + 0.06775496900081635, + 0.15756027400493622, + 0.221823588013649, + 0.05199982225894928 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520931363105774 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene viewed from a high-angle perspective using a wide-angle lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long line of modern police cars visible on an empty city highway at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do alternating red and blue warning lights flash rapidly on the police vehicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the convoy travel toward and enter a vast concrete tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059540290385484695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130954265594482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059540290385484695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059540290385484695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2040221244096756, + 0.1026826947927475, + 0.07045993953943253, + 0.055082470178604126, + 0.033940769731998444, + 0.08323696255683899, + 0.15199440717697144, + 0.08983118832111359, + 0.1236293688416481, + 0.08512008190155029 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059540290385484695 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene viewed from a high-angle perspective using a wide-angle lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long line of modern police cars visible on an empty city highway at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do alternating red and blue warning lights flash rapidly on the police vehicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the convoy travel toward and enter a vast concrete tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25210025906562805 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021002292633057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25210025906562805, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25210025906562805, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19062595069408417, + 0.09041763842105865, + 0.09595215320587158, + 0.06419283151626587, + 0.07003869861364365, + 0.14972548186779022, + 0.07143803685903549, + 0.04839295148849487, + 0.13164712488651276, + 0.08756917715072632 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25210025906562805 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "drone's wide-angle lens, captured from high above, slowly pans forward, capturing a long line of police cars in the dead of night. Atop these modern police vehicles, alternating red and blue warning lights flash in a rapid, rhythmic rhythm. Their glare reflects and stretches across the slightly damp asphalt, converging into a dazzling, flowing river of light. The convoy is traveling on an empty city highway, heading straight for the entrance of a vast, eerie concrete tunnel. As the lead police car steadily and decisively plunges into the darkness of the tunnel, the following vehicles follow closely behind, the river of light seemingly swallowed by the tunnel's vast mouth. The entire scene, pierced by red and blue light against a deep blue and black palette, creates a cinematic atmosphere of heightened tension, suspense, and urgency.", + "seed": 3372, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_10/index_8507_seed_3372_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08533554775640369, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08533554775640369, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.949999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08533554775640369, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene viewed from a high-angle perspective using a wide-angle lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long line of modern police cars visible on an empty city highway at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do alternating red and blue warning lights flash rapidly on the police vehicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the convoy travel toward and enter a vast concrete tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.13202503323554993 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2570250034332275 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.13202503323554993, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.13202503323554993, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16192762553691864, + 0.03687155991792679, + 0.17729978263378143, + 0.1216197982430458, + 0.09237299859523773, + 0.17808938026428223, + 0.08482958376407623, + 0.04194880649447441, + 0.05124446004629135, + 0.05379598215222359 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.13202503323554993 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene viewed from a high-angle perspective using a wide-angle lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long line of modern police cars visible on an empty city highway at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do alternating red and blue warning lights flash rapidly on the police vehicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the convoy travel toward and enter a vast concrete tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14278443157672882 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017784357070923 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14278443157672882, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14278443157672882, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.053428664803504944, + 0.048886656761169434, + 0.1455085277557373, + 0.1733063906431198, + 0.05594029650092125, + 0.2394513338804245, + 0.056628718972206116, + 0.05689248815178871, + 0.05524340644478798, + 0.11471345275640488 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14278443157672882 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene viewed from a high-angle perspective using a wide-angle lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long line of modern police cars visible on an empty city highway at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do alternating red and blue warning lights flash rapidly on the police vehicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the convoy travel toward and enter a vast concrete tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11292265355587006 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379226684570312 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11292265355587006, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11292265355587006, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17687706649303436, + 0.13883773982524872, + 0.049606259912252426, + 0.04587603732943535, + 0.04657982289791107, + 0.3355490565299988, + 0.08449672907590866, + 0.03781505301594734, + 0.023297831416130066, + 0.06106444448232651 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11292265355587006 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene viewed from a high-angle perspective using a wide-angle lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long line of modern police cars visible on an empty city highway at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do alternating red and blue warning lights flash rapidly on the police vehicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the convoy travel toward and enter a vast concrete tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005256166215986013 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255256175994873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005256166215986013, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005256166215986013, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07312992960214615, + 0.15308877825737, + 0.04639606550335884, + 0.13750755786895752, + 0.05551711097359657, + 0.23359458148479462, + 0.12354099750518799, + 0.05863357335329056, + 0.03988751024007797, + 0.07870393991470337 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005256166215986013 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene viewed from a high-angle perspective using a wide-angle lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long line of modern police cars visible on an empty city highway at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do alternating red and blue warning lights flash rapidly on the police vehicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the convoy travel toward and enter a vast concrete tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033689454197883606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408689498901367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033689454197883606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033689454197883606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.029177920892834663, + 0.09357105940580368, + 0.021539784967899323, + 0.05796690285205841, + 0.0243556909263134, + 0.581525444984436, + 0.018310030922293663, + 0.013183321803808212, + 0.018496261909604073, + 0.1418735682964325 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033689454197883606 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "drone's wide-angle lens, captured from high above, slowly pans forward, capturing a long line of police cars in the dead of night. Atop these modern police vehicles, alternating red and blue warning lights flash in a rapid, rhythmic rhythm. Their glare reflects and stretches across the slightly damp asphalt, converging into a dazzling, flowing river of light. The convoy is traveling on an empty city highway, heading straight for the entrance of a vast, eerie concrete tunnel. As the lead police car steadily and decisively plunges into the darkness of the tunnel, the following vehicles follow closely behind, the river of light seemingly swallowed by the tunnel's vast mouth. The entire scene, pierced by red and blue light against a deep blue and black palette, creates a cinematic atmosphere of heightened tension, suspense, and urgency.", + "seed": 3373, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_10/index_8507_seed_3373_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.07744264099746942, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07744264099746942, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07744264099746942, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene viewed from a high-angle perspective using a wide-angle lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long line of modern police cars visible on an empty city highway at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do alternating red and blue warning lights flash rapidly on the police vehicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the convoy travel toward and enter a vast concrete tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09871065616607666 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.848710536956787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09871065616607666, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09871065616607666, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13526928424835205, + 0.10103385150432587, + 0.09386251866817474, + 0.108562171459198, + 0.0739426389336586, + 0.10309901833534241, + 0.06960994005203247, + 0.08547373861074448, + 0.050524283200502396, + 0.1786225587129593 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09871065616607666 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene viewed from a high-angle perspective using a wide-angle lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long line of modern police cars visible on an empty city highway at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do alternating red and blue warning lights flash rapidly on the police vehicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the convoy travel toward and enter a vast concrete tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11290647089481354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379064559936523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11290647089481354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11290647089481354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06347312033176422, + 0.04611262306571007, + 0.045237068086862564, + 0.2411339432001114, + 0.045365381985902786, + 0.27227696776390076, + 0.09938958287239075, + 0.07114621996879578, + 0.05390476435422897, + 0.06196031719446182 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11290647089481354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene viewed from a high-angle perspective using a wide-angle lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long line of modern police cars visible on an empty city highway at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do alternating red and blue warning lights flash rapidly on the police vehicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the convoy travel toward and enter a vast concrete tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16033439338207245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103343486785889 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16033439338207245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16033439338207245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16490621864795685, + 0.13311682641506195, + 0.09505888819694519, + 0.07447727024555206, + 0.09072295576334, + 0.12430335581302643, + 0.12328621745109558, + 0.05488201975822449, + 0.04360518977046013, + 0.09564104676246643 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16033439338207245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene viewed from a high-angle perspective using a wide-angle lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long line of modern police cars visible on an empty city highway at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do alternating red and blue warning lights flash rapidly on the police vehicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the convoy travel toward and enter a vast concrete tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007633681409060955 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882633686065674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007633681409060955, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007633681409060955, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14787517488002777, + 0.10815491527318954, + 0.08102310448884964, + 0.11958551406860352, + 0.05591754615306854, + 0.08465142548084259, + 0.08279825001955032, + 0.09932985156774521, + 0.045697249472141266, + 0.17496700584888458 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007633681409060955 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene viewed from a high-angle perspective using a wide-angle lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long line of modern police cars visible on an empty city highway at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do alternating red and blue warning lights flash rapidly on the police vehicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the convoy travel toward and enter a vast concrete tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076280031353235245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882627964019775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076280031353235245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076280031353235245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05396643280982971, + 0.043935611844062805, + 0.0862591341137886, + 0.3519134521484375, + 0.1325230747461319, + 0.15924929082393646, + 0.026478813961148262, + 0.03276542201638222, + 0.03758220002055168, + 0.0753265768289566 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076280031353235245 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "drone's wide-angle lens, captured from high above, slowly pans forward, capturing a long line of police cars in the dead of night. Atop these modern police vehicles, alternating red and blue warning lights flash in a rapid, rhythmic rhythm. Their glare reflects and stretches across the slightly damp asphalt, converging into a dazzling, flowing river of light. The convoy is traveling on an empty city highway, heading straight for the entrance of a vast, eerie concrete tunnel. As the lead police car steadily and decisively plunges into the darkness of the tunnel, the following vehicles follow closely behind, the river of light seemingly swallowed by the tunnel's vast mouth. The entire scene, pierced by red and blue light against a deep blue and black palette, creates a cinematic atmosphere of heightened tension, suspense, and urgency.", + "seed": 3374, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_10/index_8507_seed_3374_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1343746680766344, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1343746680766344, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1343746680766344, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene viewed from a high-angle perspective using a wide-angle lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long line of modern police cars visible on an empty city highway at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do alternating red and blue warning lights flash rapidly on the police vehicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the convoy travel toward and enter a vast concrete tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17162436246871948 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1716244220733643 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17162436246871948, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17162436246871948, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.056339871138334274, + 0.04111677408218384, + 0.04041800647974014, + 0.03206293657422066, + 0.021207179874181747, + 0.02918211556971073, + 0.21518650650978088, + 0.016752053052186966, + 0.5026451349258423, + 0.04508950188755989 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17162436246871948 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene viewed from a high-angle perspective using a wide-angle lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long line of modern police cars visible on an empty city highway at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do alternating red and blue warning lights flash rapidly on the police vehicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the convoy travel toward and enter a vast concrete tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20153798162937164 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015379667282104 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20153798162937164, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20153798162937164, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03811333701014519, + 0.0458064042031765, + 0.02553856372833252, + 0.04761025309562683, + 0.02148304134607315, + 0.1499919593334198, + 0.3425604999065399, + 0.056865058839321136, + 0.2443796843290329, + 0.027651188895106316 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20153798162937164 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene viewed from a high-angle perspective using a wide-angle lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long line of modern police cars visible on an empty city highway at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do alternating red and blue warning lights flash rapidly on the police vehicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the convoy travel toward and enter a vast concrete tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20153826475143433 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.701538324356079 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20153826475143433, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20153826475143433, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11535865068435669, + 0.04660087451338768, + 0.041777756065130234, + 0.06614769250154495, + 0.07859804481267929, + 0.03326358646154404, + 0.2304193675518036, + 0.02040843665599823, + 0.31391048431396484, + 0.053515102714300156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20153826475143433 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene viewed from a high-angle perspective using a wide-angle lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long line of modern police cars visible on an empty city highway at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do alternating red and blue warning lights flash rapidly on the police vehicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the convoy travel toward and enter a vast concrete tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819397695362568 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018194198608398 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819397695362568, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819397695362568, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.036847103387117386, + 0.034903138875961304, + 0.13036833703517914, + 0.0338919460773468, + 0.04649973660707474, + 0.050508931279182434, + 0.12041402608156204, + 0.0312923826277256, + 0.48645105957984924, + 0.02882344089448452 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819397695362568 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene viewed from a high-angle perspective using a wide-angle lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a long line of modern police cars visible on an empty city highway at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do alternating red and blue warning lights flash rapidly on the police vehicles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the convoy travel toward and enter a vast concrete tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0789787545800209 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789787769317627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0789787545800209, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0789787545800209, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21079197525978088, + 0.011110462248325348, + 0.021319346502423286, + 0.030515527352690697, + 0.026868656277656555, + 0.036546193063259125, + 0.22753861546516418, + 0.039007510989904404, + 0.33017274737358093, + 0.0661289319396019 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0789787545800209 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_11/index_tensor([3109, 3109])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_11/index_tensor([3109, 3109])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4049a885198d742c2afc1d9064eeb7b9da3f6d99 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_11/index_tensor([3109, 3109])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, medium shot, captured with the raw immediacy of a handheld documentary camera, the frame slightly shaken by the impact. Beneath the glaring African midday sun, a massive, adult male African elephant, its deeply wrinkled gray skin stained with dried mud and dust, its massive, slightly worn tusks gleaming white in the sunlight, its small, piercing eyes filled with unwavering determination. With its massive head lowered, muscles tensed, it charged forward with an unstoppable momentum, slamming into a sturdy fence composed of thick, dark wooden posts and beams. The sturdy beams, unable to withstand the devastating force, shattered instantly upon impact, sending countless sharp splinters of wood and dust flying in all directions in a chaotic explosion. The grain of each splintered piece was clearly visible in the high-speed filming. The bull elephant moves relentlessly through the destroyed gap, and the entire picture is filled with raw, rough energy. The high-contrast lighting and extreme capture of details together create an awe-inspiring, heart-pounding documentary-like real texture and tense atmosphere.", + "seed": 10551, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_11/index_3109_seed_10551_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.2108131878077984, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2108131878077984, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.849999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2108131878077984, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive adult male African elephant with wrinkled gray skin and white tusks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant charge forward and slam into a sturdy wooden fence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fence beams shatter instantly upon impact, sending wood splinters and dust flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera style handheld with a slightly shaken frame due to impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4290943145751953 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1790943145751953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4290943145751953, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4290943145751953, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16988877952098846, + 0.12171583622694016, + 0.09352820366621017, + 0.057064488530159, + 0.04642093926668167, + 0.13221831619739532, + 0.12489786744117737, + 0.051168497651815414, + 0.07000678777694702, + 0.1330902874469757 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4290943145751953 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive adult male African elephant with wrinkled gray skin and white tusks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant charge forward and slam into a sturdy wooden fence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fence beams shatter instantly upon impact, sending wood splinters and dust flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera style handheld with a slightly shaken frame due to impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048714615404605865 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0487146377563477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048714615404605865, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048714615404605865, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27860385179519653, + 0.20131810009479523, + 0.04435553029179573, + 0.16265861690044403, + 0.034819602966308594, + 0.046484436839818954, + 0.04437302052974701, + 0.048766281455755234, + 0.03831704705953598, + 0.100303515791893 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048714615404605865 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive adult male African elephant with wrinkled gray skin and white tusks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant charge forward and slam into a sturdy wooden fence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fence beams shatter instantly upon impact, sending wood splinters and dust flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera style handheld with a slightly shaken frame due to impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06206889823079109 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120689392089844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06206889823079109, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06206889823079109, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0626152902841568, + 0.10291507095098495, + 0.041827909648418427, + 0.0518549382686615, + 0.03625919297337532, + 0.06543943285942078, + 0.23441557586193085, + 0.15161433815956116, + 0.13460759818553925, + 0.11845063418149948 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06206889823079109 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive adult male African elephant with wrinkled gray skin and white tusks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant charge forward and slam into a sturdy wooden fence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fence beams shatter instantly upon impact, sending wood splinters and dust flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera style handheld with a slightly shaken frame due to impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38709932565689087 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137099266052246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38709932565689087, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38709932565689087, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10074459761381149, + 0.06273907423019409, + 0.03849179670214653, + 0.08127990365028381, + 0.11406069248914719, + 0.08843182027339935, + 0.059623416513204575, + 0.08427092432975769, + 0.05843052268028259, + 0.3119272291660309 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38709932565689087 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive adult male African elephant with wrinkled gray skin and white tusks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant charge forward and slam into a sturdy wooden fence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fence beams shatter instantly upon impact, sending wood splinters and dust flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera style handheld with a slightly shaken frame due to impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270887851715088 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127088785171509 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270887851715088, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270887851715088, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10888802260160446, + 0.17534562945365906, + 0.040333092212677, + 0.04113242030143738, + 0.11802507936954498, + 0.09928970038890839, + 0.09825967997312546, + 0.06659313291311264, + 0.0959673598408699, + 0.1561659276485443 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270887851715088 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, medium shot, captured with the raw immediacy of a handheld documentary camera, the frame slightly shaken by the impact. Beneath the glaring African midday sun, a massive, adult male African elephant, its deeply wrinkled gray skin stained with dried mud and dust, its massive, slightly worn tusks gleaming white in the sunlight, its small, piercing eyes filled with unwavering determination. With its massive head lowered, muscles tensed, it charged forward with an unstoppable momentum, slamming into a sturdy fence composed of thick, dark wooden posts and beams. The sturdy beams, unable to withstand the devastating force, shattered instantly upon impact, sending countless sharp splinters of wood and dust flying in all directions in a chaotic explosion. The grain of each splintered piece was clearly visible in the high-speed filming. The bull elephant moves relentlessly through the destroyed gap, and the entire picture is filled with raw, rough energy. The high-contrast lighting and extreme capture of details together create an awe-inspiring, heart-pounding documentary-like real texture and tense atmosphere.", + "seed": 10552, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_11/index_3109_seed_10552_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.13852374032139778, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13852374032139778, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13852374032139778, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive adult male African elephant with wrinkled gray skin and white tusks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant charge forward and slam into a sturdy wooden fence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fence beams shatter instantly upon impact, sending wood splinters and dust flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera style handheld with a slightly shaken frame due to impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1400848776102066 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.140084981918335 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1400848776102066, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1400848776102066, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18019895255565643, + 0.09871096163988113, + 0.0654379278421402, + 0.061353474855422974, + 0.06688318401575089, + 0.07999742031097412, + 0.0299533624202013, + 0.19931334257125854, + 0.13131588697433472, + 0.08683546632528305 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1400848776102066 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive adult male African elephant with wrinkled gray skin and white tusks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant charge forward and slam into a sturdy wooden fence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fence beams shatter instantly upon impact, sending wood splinters and dust flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera style handheld with a slightly shaken frame due to impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08911100029945374 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464111089706421 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08911100029945374, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08911100029945374, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07006985694169998, + 0.1269780993461609, + 0.03378225490450859, + 0.05828367546200752, + 0.05549551919102669, + 0.22830328345298767, + 0.04573386162519455, + 0.050477683544158936, + 0.24982582032680511, + 0.08104991912841797 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08911100029945374 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive adult male African elephant with wrinkled gray skin and white tusks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant charge forward and slam into a sturdy wooden fence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fence beams shatter instantly upon impact, sending wood splinters and dust flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera style handheld with a slightly shaken frame due to impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05498148873448372 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299814701080322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05498148873448372, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05498148873448372, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04013713449239731, + 0.02913433499634266, + 0.0510798804461956, + 0.053876910358667374, + 0.018172170966863632, + 0.09411560744047165, + 0.01355405617505312, + 0.034476060420274734, + 0.6281183958053589, + 0.03733550384640694 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05498148873448372 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive adult male African elephant with wrinkled gray skin and white tusks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant charge forward and slam into a sturdy wooden fence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fence beams shatter instantly upon impact, sending wood splinters and dust flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera style handheld with a slightly shaken frame due to impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270841658115387 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127084255218506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270841658115387, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270841658115387, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08237622678279877, + 0.039398275315761566, + 0.09707462042570114, + 0.03133375570178032, + 0.033443383872509, + 0.10859569162130356, + 0.03535383939743042, + 0.08079507201910019, + 0.3736991882324219, + 0.11792995780706406 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270841658115387 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive adult male African elephant with wrinkled gray skin and white tusks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant charge forward and slam into a sturdy wooden fence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fence beams shatter instantly upon impact, sending wood splinters and dust flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera style handheld with a slightly shaken frame due to impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28135716915130615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063571691513062 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28135716915130615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28135716915130615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07762428373098373, + 0.04995592683553696, + 0.08002948015928268, + 0.07489348202943802, + 0.05733248591423035, + 0.18370398879051208, + 0.042024239897727966, + 0.06839197129011154, + 0.22071240842342377, + 0.1453317105770111 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28135716915130615 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, medium shot, captured with the raw immediacy of a handheld documentary camera, the frame slightly shaken by the impact. Beneath the glaring African midday sun, a massive, adult male African elephant, its deeply wrinkled gray skin stained with dried mud and dust, its massive, slightly worn tusks gleaming white in the sunlight, its small, piercing eyes filled with unwavering determination. With its massive head lowered, muscles tensed, it charged forward with an unstoppable momentum, slamming into a sturdy fence composed of thick, dark wooden posts and beams. The sturdy beams, unable to withstand the devastating force, shattered instantly upon impact, sending countless sharp splinters of wood and dust flying in all directions in a chaotic explosion. The grain of each splintered piece was clearly visible in the high-speed filming. The bull elephant moves relentlessly through the destroyed gap, and the entire picture is filled with raw, rough energy. The high-contrast lighting and extreme capture of details together create an awe-inspiring, heart-pounding documentary-like real texture and tense atmosphere.", + "seed": 10553, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_11/index_3109_seed_10553_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.13895036280155182, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13895036280155182, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13895036280155182, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive adult male African elephant with wrinkled gray skin and white tusks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant charge forward and slam into a sturdy wooden fence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fence beams shatter instantly upon impact, sending wood splinters and dust flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera style handheld with a slightly shaken frame due to impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09871918708086014 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8487191200256348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09871918708086014, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09871918708086014, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11086887866258621, + 0.05636492744088173, + 0.3601786196231842, + 0.14086174964904785, + 0.036242950707674026, + 0.11562290042638779, + 0.030877020210027695, + 0.088201604783535, + 0.02617569826543331, + 0.03460564464330673 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09871918708086014 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive adult male African elephant with wrinkled gray skin and white tusks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant charge forward and slam into a sturdy wooden fence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fence beams shatter instantly upon impact, sending wood splinters and dust flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera style handheld with a slightly shaken frame due to impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0790518969297409 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579051971435547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0790518969297409, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0790518969297409, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05800129100680351, + 0.07303036749362946, + 0.1567976176738739, + 0.1339258849620819, + 0.09268813580274582, + 0.13973884284496307, + 0.05518760532140732, + 0.08608459681272507, + 0.06267879158258438, + 0.14186689257621765 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0790518969297409 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive adult male African elephant with wrinkled gray skin and white tusks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant charge forward and slam into a sturdy wooden fence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fence beams shatter instantly upon impact, sending wood splinters and dust flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera style handheld with a slightly shaken frame due to impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309605807065964 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680960655212402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309605807065964, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309605807065964, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05566893890500069, + 0.04199279844760895, + 0.10615532845258713, + 0.1704477220773697, + 0.08294137567281723, + 0.04158769175410271, + 0.03869461268186569, + 0.053680527955293655, + 0.0668058916926384, + 0.34202513098716736 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309605807065964 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive adult male African elephant with wrinkled gray skin and white tusks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant charge forward and slam into a sturdy wooden fence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fence beams shatter instantly upon impact, sending wood splinters and dust flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera style handheld with a slightly shaken frame due to impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31348052620887756 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134804964065552 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31348052620887756, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31348052620887756, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03851430118083954, + 0.025378737598657608, + 0.10755632072687149, + 0.1747111678123474, + 0.047806672751903534, + 0.035955626517534256, + 0.02510334551334381, + 0.0745568573474884, + 0.059051889926195145, + 0.4113650918006897 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31348052620887756 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive adult male African elephant with wrinkled gray skin and white tusks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant charge forward and slam into a sturdy wooden fence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fence beams shatter instantly upon impact, sending wood splinters and dust flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera style handheld with a slightly shaken frame due to impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16040414571762085 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104042053222656 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16040414571762085, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16040414571762085, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14835092425346375, + 0.06954419612884521, + 0.12020163238048553, + 0.08818427473306656, + 0.08422253280878067, + 0.07205438613891602, + 0.031413257122039795, + 0.054878540337085724, + 0.07621430605649948, + 0.2549359202384949 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16040414571762085 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, medium shot, captured with the raw immediacy of a handheld documentary camera, the frame slightly shaken by the impact. Beneath the glaring African midday sun, a massive, adult male African elephant, its deeply wrinkled gray skin stained with dried mud and dust, its massive, slightly worn tusks gleaming white in the sunlight, its small, piercing eyes filled with unwavering determination. With its massive head lowered, muscles tensed, it charged forward with an unstoppable momentum, slamming into a sturdy fence composed of thick, dark wooden posts and beams. The sturdy beams, unable to withstand the devastating force, shattered instantly upon impact, sending countless sharp splinters of wood and dust flying in all directions in a chaotic explosion. The grain of each splintered piece was clearly visible in the high-speed filming. The bull elephant moves relentlessly through the destroyed gap, and the entire picture is filled with raw, rough energy. The high-contrast lighting and extreme capture of details together create an awe-inspiring, heart-pounding documentary-like real texture and tense atmosphere.", + "seed": 10554, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_11/index_3109_seed_10554_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.14447594955563545, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14447594955563545, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14447594955563545, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive adult male African elephant with wrinkled gray skin and white tusks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant charge forward and slam into a sturdy wooden fence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fence beams shatter instantly upon impact, sending wood splinters and dust flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera style handheld with a slightly shaken frame due to impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3580833971500397 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3580833673477173 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3580833971500397, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3580833971500397, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15203098952770233, + 0.06139161065220833, + 0.09952551871538162, + 0.10188505798578262, + 0.030622409656643867, + 0.1251160353422165, + 0.0562286339700222, + 0.04847867414355278, + 0.18420541286468506, + 0.14051567018032074 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3580833971500397 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive adult male African elephant with wrinkled gray skin and white tusks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant charge forward and slam into a sturdy wooden fence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fence beams shatter instantly upon impact, sending wood splinters and dust flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera style handheld with a slightly shaken frame due to impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062141720205545425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8121416568756104 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062141720205545425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062141720205545425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17697037756443024, + 0.11421219259500504, + 0.05108082666993141, + 0.1080128401517868, + 0.03224297985434532, + 0.17626047134399414, + 0.04099927470088005, + 0.043378666043281555, + 0.10510948300361633, + 0.15173287689685822 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062141720205545425 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive adult male African elephant with wrinkled gray skin and white tusks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant charge forward and slam into a sturdy wooden fence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fence beams shatter instantly upon impact, sending wood splinters and dust flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera style handheld with a slightly shaken frame due to impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620795413851738 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812079429626465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620795413851738, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620795413851738, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09851768612861633, + 0.05168385058641434, + 0.05858415737748146, + 0.2295972853899002, + 0.027918783947825432, + 0.33090347051620483, + 0.027041858062148094, + 0.024255389347672462, + 0.08162301033735275, + 0.06987443566322327 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620795413851738 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive adult male African elephant with wrinkled gray skin and white tusks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant charge forward and slam into a sturdy wooden fence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fence beams shatter instantly upon impact, sending wood splinters and dust flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera style handheld with a slightly shaken frame due to impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11298345774412155 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237983465194702 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11298345774412155, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11298345774412155, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.055346693843603134, + 0.04818291217088699, + 0.04023350775241852, + 0.07062404602766037, + 0.026542903855443, + 0.4975617527961731, + 0.03687779977917671, + 0.032670389860868454, + 0.1207641139626503, + 0.07119590044021606 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11298345774412155 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive adult male African elephant with wrinkled gray skin and white tusks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant charge forward and slam into a sturdy wooden fence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fence beams shatter instantly upon impact, sending wood splinters and dust flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera style handheld with a slightly shaken frame due to impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12709163129329681 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127091646194458 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12709163129329681, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12709163129329681, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16296309232711792, + 0.06601511687040329, + 0.04023255035281181, + 0.22068160772323608, + 0.02762002684175968, + 0.18409095704555511, + 0.05825259909033775, + 0.04099326580762863, + 0.12107246369123459, + 0.07807832956314087 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12709163129329681 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_12/index_tensor([7027, 7027])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_12/index_tensor([7027, 7027])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..21d312796d83de3103197cdcd649c987956ed47e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_12/index_tensor([7027, 7027])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "powerful low-angle tracking shot follows the tank, its camera close to the ground, panning right in sync with a heavy main battle tank. The tank's heavy olive-green armor is coated in a thick layer of dried mud and crisscrossed with metal scratches, leaving mottled marks on the turret and hull, with some armor plates even chipped and broken at the edges. Its broad metal tracks, with unstoppable force, relentlessly crush the rubble of broken concrete, twisted rebar, and scattered brick and stone beneath them, shattering it into smaller fragments, kicking up a cloud of dust with each rotation. As the tank surges forward, its massive hull heaving slightly as it rolls over the uneven ground, it plunges into a devastated city block. The charred, collapsed skeletons of buildings flank the streets, their shattered windows staring out at the devastation like hollow eyes. The sky is shrouded in thick gray smoke, casting a dim and oppressive diffuse light. The dominant tones of the painting are icy grays and earth tones, punctuated only by the occasional flash of rusty red on the twisted rebar. The entire scene is imbued with a sense of primal, violent power, creating an apocalyptic, suffocating atmosphere of tension.", + "seed": 1344, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_12/index_7027_seed_1344_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.023930535279214384, + "vlm_logprob": -0.023930535279214384, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.023930535279214384, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy main battle tank with olive-green armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armor coated in thick dried mud and crisscrossed with metal scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's movement crush rubble, twisted rebar, and brick while kicking up a cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a devastated city block with charred collapsed buildings and thick gray smoke in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that pans right in sync with the moving tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.028808053582906723 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.653808116912842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.028808053582906723, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.028808053582906723, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6616845726966858, + 0.023697972297668457, + 0.024992944672703743, + 0.13388442993164062, + 0.04320396110415459, + 0.017055723816156387, + 0.020861100405454636, + 0.030267383903265, + 0.02617671713232994, + 0.018175145611166954 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.028808053582906723 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy main battle tank with olive-green armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armor coated in thick dried mud and crisscrossed with metal scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's movement crush rubble, twisted rebar, and brick while kicking up a cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a devastated city block with charred collapsed buildings and thick gray smoke in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that pans right in sync with the moving tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01820451207458973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018204689025879 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01820451207458973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01820451207458973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6924753189086914, + 0.03682044893503189, + 0.020670520141720772, + 0.07087509334087372, + 0.02508615329861641, + 0.02107216790318489, + 0.022823046892881393, + 0.0181393064558506, + 0.07946602255105972, + 0.012571964412927628 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01820451207458973 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy main battle tank with olive-green armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armor coated in thick dried mud and crisscrossed with metal scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's movement crush rubble, twisted rebar, and brick while kicking up a cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a devastated city block with charred collapsed buildings and thick gray smoke in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that pans right in sync with the moving tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370824456214905 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408708333969116 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370824456214905, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370824456214905, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5657898187637329, + 0.027158688753843307, + 0.0186248067766428, + 0.12479600310325623, + 0.09235496819019318, + 0.012424512766301632, + 0.015673596411943436, + 0.014307864010334015, + 0.09847129881381989, + 0.030398385599255562 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370824456214905 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy main battle tank with olive-green armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armor coated in thick dried mud and crisscrossed with metal scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's movement crush rubble, twisted rebar, and brick while kicking up a cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a devastated city block with charred collapsed buildings and thick gray smoke in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that pans right in sync with the moving tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005250592716038227 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255250453948975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005250592716038227, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005250592716038227, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32642775774002075, + 0.2810889482498169, + 0.18034100532531738, + 0.03800157085061073, + 0.05366714671254158, + 0.009490415453910828, + 0.03052368387579918, + 0.009131754748523235, + 0.041974905878305435, + 0.029352828860282898 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005250592716038227 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy main battle tank with olive-green armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armor coated in thick dried mud and crisscrossed with metal scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's movement crush rubble, twisted rebar, and brick while kicking up a cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a devastated city block with charred collapsed buildings and thick gray smoke in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that pans right in sync with the moving tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033681273460388184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086813926696777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033681273460388184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033681273460388184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5778884887695312, + 0.0321524478495121, + 0.019947359338402748, + 0.08194222301244736, + 0.03654533997178078, + 0.026059454306960106, + 0.06778623908758163, + 0.059736788272857666, + 0.05561721697449684, + 0.042324379086494446 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033681273460388184 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful low-angle tracking shot follows the tank, its camera close to the ground, panning right in sync with a heavy main battle tank. The tank's heavy olive-green armor is coated in a thick layer of dried mud and crisscrossed with metal scratches, leaving mottled marks on the turret and hull, with some armor plates even chipped and broken at the edges. Its broad metal tracks, with unstoppable force, relentlessly crush the rubble of broken concrete, twisted rebar, and scattered brick and stone beneath them, shattering it into smaller fragments, kicking up a cloud of dust with each rotation. As the tank surges forward, its massive hull heaving slightly as it rolls over the uneven ground, it plunges into a devastated city block. The charred, collapsed skeletons of buildings flank the streets, their shattered windows staring out at the devastation like hollow eyes. The sky is shrouded in thick gray smoke, casting a dim and oppressive diffuse light. The dominant tones of the painting are icy grays and earth tones, punctuated only by the occasional flash of rusty red on the twisted rebar. The entire scene is imbued with a sense of primal, violent power, creating an apocalyptic, suffocating atmosphere of tension.", + "seed": 1345, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_12/index_7027_seed_1345_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.022243791073560715, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022243791073560715, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022243791073560715, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy main battle tank with olive-green armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armor coated in thick dried mud and crisscrossed with metal scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's movement crush rubble, twisted rebar, and brick while kicking up a cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a devastated city block with charred collapsed buildings and thick gray smoke in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that pans right in sync with the moving tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02149103209376335 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.896491050720215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02149103209376335, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02149103209376335, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08439308404922485, + 0.10525097697973251, + 0.06881044059991837, + 0.07700316607952118, + 0.08146880567073822, + 0.13361401855945587, + 0.09506043046712875, + 0.22639153897762299, + 0.07116798311471939, + 0.05683949217200279 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02149103209376335 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy main battle tank with olive-green armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armor coated in thick dried mud and crisscrossed with metal scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's movement crush rubble, twisted rebar, and brick while kicking up a cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a devastated city block with charred collapsed buildings and thick gray smoke in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that pans right in sync with the moving tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023298904299736023 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773298978805542 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023298904299736023, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023298904299736023, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06908287853002548, + 0.08941714465618134, + 0.10033813118934631, + 0.13013218343257904, + 0.050161197781562805, + 0.13563893735408783, + 0.16228733956813812, + 0.09645151346921921, + 0.04788736253976822, + 0.11860331147909164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023298904299736023 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy main battle tank with olive-green armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armor coated in thick dried mud and crisscrossed with metal scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's movement crush rubble, twisted rebar, and brick while kicking up a cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a devastated city block with charred collapsed buildings and thick gray smoke in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that pans right in sync with the moving tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058347500860691 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895583391189575 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058347500860691, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058347500860691, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0819879099726677, + 0.07368908822536469, + 0.05561095103621483, + 0.09412972629070282, + 0.04484739527106285, + 0.0343409925699234, + 0.1695331186056137, + 0.1685941070318222, + 0.036568690091371536, + 0.24069803953170776 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058347500860691 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy main battle tank with olive-green armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armor coated in thick dried mud and crisscrossed with metal scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's movement crush rubble, twisted rebar, and brick while kicking up a cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a devastated city block with charred collapsed buildings and thick gray smoke in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that pans right in sync with the moving tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606214977800846 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141062259674072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606214977800846, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606214977800846, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1106061264872551, + 0.08331551402807236, + 0.06974169611930847, + 0.11815091222524643, + 0.07766635715961456, + 0.0657723918557167, + 0.0791335329413414, + 0.16208425164222717, + 0.06092188507318497, + 0.17260734736919403 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606214977800846 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy main battle tank with olive-green armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armor coated in thick dried mud and crisscrossed with metal scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's movement crush rubble, twisted rebar, and brick while kicking up a cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a devastated city block with charred collapsed buildings and thick gray smoke in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that pans right in sync with the moving tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029783394187688828 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297834873199463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029783394187688828, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029783394187688828, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04522364214062691, + 0.033502496778964996, + 0.08757849037647247, + 0.13391338288784027, + 0.07139348238706589, + 0.04515881836414337, + 0.07247471809387207, + 0.17963042855262756, + 0.2327754646539688, + 0.09834908694028854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029783394187688828 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful low-angle tracking shot follows the tank, its camera close to the ground, panning right in sync with a heavy main battle tank. The tank's heavy olive-green armor is coated in a thick layer of dried mud and crisscrossed with metal scratches, leaving mottled marks on the turret and hull, with some armor plates even chipped and broken at the edges. Its broad metal tracks, with unstoppable force, relentlessly crush the rubble of broken concrete, twisted rebar, and scattered brick and stone beneath them, shattering it into smaller fragments, kicking up a cloud of dust with each rotation. As the tank surges forward, its massive hull heaving slightly as it rolls over the uneven ground, it plunges into a devastated city block. The charred, collapsed skeletons of buildings flank the streets, their shattered windows staring out at the devastation like hollow eyes. The sky is shrouded in thick gray smoke, casting a dim and oppressive diffuse light. The dominant tones of the painting are icy grays and earth tones, punctuated only by the occasional flash of rusty red on the twisted rebar. The entire scene is imbued with a sense of primal, violent power, creating an apocalyptic, suffocating atmosphere of tension.", + "seed": 1346, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_12/index_7027_seed_1346_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.023639949364587666, + "vlm_logprob": -0.023639949364587666, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.099999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.023639949364587666, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy main battle tank with olive-green armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armor coated in thick dried mud and crisscrossed with metal scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's movement crush rubble, twisted rebar, and brick while kicking up a cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a devastated city block with charred collapsed buildings and thick gray smoke in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that pans right in sync with the moving tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04472922161221504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.169729232788086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04472922161221504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04472922161221504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1508893370628357, + 0.09376026690006256, + 0.03595096245408058, + 0.03970058634877205, + 0.06719422340393066, + 0.07414980232715607, + 0.03531605750322342, + 0.12035239487886429, + 0.31671851873397827, + 0.06596784293651581 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04472922161221504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy main battle tank with olive-green armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armor coated in thick dried mud and crisscrossed with metal scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's movement crush rubble, twisted rebar, and brick while kicking up a cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a devastated city block with charred collapsed buildings and thick gray smoke in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that pans right in sync with the moving tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023303797468543053 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773303747177124 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023303797468543053, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023303797468543053, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14997120201587677, + 0.03263862803578377, + 0.04345611110329628, + 0.068631611764431, + 0.0796910971403122, + 0.03134101256728172, + 0.06141366437077522, + 0.1314624547958374, + 0.16091109812259674, + 0.2404831200838089 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023303797468543053 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy main battle tank with olive-green armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armor coated in thick dried mud and crisscrossed with metal scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's movement crush rubble, twisted rebar, and brick while kicking up a cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a devastated city block with charred collapsed buildings and thick gray smoke in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that pans right in sync with the moving tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018188709393143654 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0181884765625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018188709393143654, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018188709393143654, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2204466611146927, + 0.0656103566288948, + 0.02899853140115738, + 0.11540034413337708, + 0.1199314072728157, + 0.08674580603837967, + 0.06318116188049316, + 0.10402876138687134, + 0.05831093341112137, + 0.13734599947929382 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018188709393143654 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy main battle tank with olive-green armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armor coated in thick dried mud and crisscrossed with metal scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's movement crush rubble, twisted rebar, and brick while kicking up a cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a devastated city block with charred collapsed buildings and thick gray smoke in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that pans right in sync with the moving tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021948551293462515 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127194881439209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021948551293462515, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021948551293462515, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18601712584495544, + 0.06582184880971909, + 0.07577913254499435, + 0.05874316394329071, + 0.10924389213323593, + 0.07712538540363312, + 0.07417720556259155, + 0.08539244532585144, + 0.09447140991687775, + 0.17322835326194763 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021948551293462515 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy main battle tank with olive-green armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armor coated in thick dried mud and crisscrossed with metal scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's movement crush rubble, twisted rebar, and brick while kicking up a cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a devastated city block with charred collapsed buildings and thick gray smoke in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that pans right in sync with the moving tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029783163219690323 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529783248901367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029783163219690323, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029783163219690323, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09422784298658371, + 0.13018567860126495, + 0.03271733596920967, + 0.04430389404296875, + 0.1223984807729721, + 0.22907133400440216, + 0.05200641229748726, + 0.03973967209458351, + 0.1299961656332016, + 0.12535317242145538 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029783163219690323 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful low-angle tracking shot follows the tank, its camera close to the ground, panning right in sync with a heavy main battle tank. The tank's heavy olive-green armor is coated in a thick layer of dried mud and crisscrossed with metal scratches, leaving mottled marks on the turret and hull, with some armor plates even chipped and broken at the edges. Its broad metal tracks, with unstoppable force, relentlessly crush the rubble of broken concrete, twisted rebar, and scattered brick and stone beneath them, shattering it into smaller fragments, kicking up a cloud of dust with each rotation. As the tank surges forward, its massive hull heaving slightly as it rolls over the uneven ground, it plunges into a devastated city block. The charred, collapsed skeletons of buildings flank the streets, their shattered windows staring out at the devastation like hollow eyes. The sky is shrouded in thick gray smoke, casting a dim and oppressive diffuse light. The dominant tones of the painting are icy grays and earth tones, punctuated only by the occasional flash of rusty red on the twisted rebar. The entire scene is imbued with a sense of primal, violent power, creating an apocalyptic, suffocating atmosphere of tension.", + "seed": 1347, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_12/index_7027_seed_1347_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.028548139706254007, + "vlm_logprob": -0.028548139706254007, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.028548139706254007, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy main battle tank with olive-green armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armor coated in thick dried mud and crisscrossed with metal scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's movement crush rubble, twisted rebar, and brick while kicking up a cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a devastated city block with charred collapsed buildings and thick gray smoke in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that pans right in sync with the moving tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01757863722741604 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.142578601837158 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01757863722741604, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01757863722741604, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12147217243909836, + 0.1404826045036316, + 0.09739412367343903, + 0.1217619925737381, + 0.07099928706884384, + 0.07324027270078659, + 0.02651306614279747, + 0.16805148124694824, + 0.12436039745807648, + 0.055724602192640305 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01757863722741604 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy main battle tank with olive-green armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armor coated in thick dried mud and crisscrossed with metal scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's movement crush rubble, twisted rebar, and brick while kicking up a cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a devastated city block with charred collapsed buildings and thick gray smoke in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that pans right in sync with the moving tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020595619454979897 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955955505371094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020595619454979897, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020595619454979897, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12181060016155243, + 0.11681195348501205, + 0.21758094429969788, + 0.13800303637981415, + 0.03563668951392174, + 0.041012294590473175, + 0.030249103903770447, + 0.16874457895755768, + 0.07449408620595932, + 0.05565669760107994 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020595619454979897 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy main battle tank with olive-green armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armor coated in thick dried mud and crisscrossed with metal scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's movement crush rubble, twisted rebar, and brick while kicking up a cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a devastated city block with charred collapsed buildings and thick gray smoke in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that pans right in sync with the moving tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495576187968254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299557209014893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495576187968254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495576187968254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08686880022287369, + 0.09409093111753464, + 0.2725123465061188, + 0.15448683500289917, + 0.03795141354203224, + 0.06828399002552032, + 0.028774453327059746, + 0.06598442047834396, + 0.13162221014499664, + 0.059424590319395065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495576187968254 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy main battle tank with olive-green armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armor coated in thick dried mud and crisscrossed with metal scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's movement crush rubble, twisted rebar, and brick while kicking up a cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a devastated city block with charred collapsed buildings and thick gray smoke in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that pans right in sync with the moving tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02328166924417019 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732815742492676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02328166924417019, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02328166924417019, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20051398873329163, + 0.20610755681991577, + 0.07288973778486252, + 0.25156405568122864, + 0.055301375687122345, + 0.020332185551524162, + 0.06369631737470627, + 0.04441113770008087, + 0.023470614105463028, + 0.0617130883038044 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02328166924417019 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy main battle tank with olive-green armor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armor coated in thick dried mud and crisscrossed with metal scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank's movement crush rubble, twisted rebar, and brick while kicking up a cloud of dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a devastated city block with charred collapsed buildings and thick gray smoke in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle tracking shot that pans right in sync with the moving tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026329010725021362 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513290405273438 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026329010725021362, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026329010725021362, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07646758109331131, + 0.1394381821155548, + 0.11136368662118912, + 0.19350339472293854, + 0.07297062128782272, + 0.060374367982149124, + 0.08233297616243362, + 0.062619648873806, + 0.16562986373901367, + 0.03529965132474899 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026329010725021362 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_13/index_tensor([3343, 3343])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_13/index_tensor([3343, 3343])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bef646b6c55fd9722dba85d8eb135a5f3b4fb212 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_13/index_tensor([3343, 3343])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, slightly low-angle close-up captures a realistic pigeon standing on a sun-bleached, richly textured concrete sidewalk. Every detail of the bird is rendered with exquisite clarity: its iridescent neck feathers shimmer with metallic purple and green hues in the midday sun, its plump gray body feathers are perfectly contoured, and its brilliant red-orange eyes have a sharp, intelligent glint. Its pink, scaly feet firmly grip the rough concrete surface, which is marked by hairline cracks and tiny embedded pebbles. The scene pauses for a moment in perfect silence before the transformation begins, subtle at first. The tips of the wing feathers begin to fray, becoming not wisps but tiny, glowing points of light. This deconstruction process steadily and deliberately accelerates, flowing through the pigeon's body like a stream of water. Its solid form loses cohesion, its physical structure disintegrating into a swirling, rising cloud of shimmering, iridescent particles. These particles, preserving the pigeon's original palette, radiate an ethereal inner light, catching direct sunlight and refracting it into a dazzling, kaleidoscopic display. The digital cloud of dust slowly drifted upwards and dissipated into the warm, bright air, leaving behind only a desolate, empty expanse of concrete where the bird once stood, creating an atmosphere of surreal, quietly magical atmosphere.", + "seed": 16089, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_13/index_3343_seed_16089_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05561201267992146, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05561201267992146, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05561201267992146, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic pigeon standing on a sun-bleached concrete sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon display iridescent neck feathers shimmering with metallic purple and green hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's wing feathers begin to fray into tiny, glowing points of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's solid form disintegrate into a swirling, rising cloud of shimmering, iridescent particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with the pigeon disappearing, leaving only an empty expanse of concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2073579877614975 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7073580026626587 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2073579877614975, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2073579877614975, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06587246805429459, + 0.027399817481637, + 0.011115554720163345, + 0.033943139016628265, + 0.043995220214128494, + 0.0250099990516901, + 0.03143037483096123, + 0.5220080614089966, + 0.042118966579437256, + 0.19710634648799896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2073579877614975 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic pigeon standing on a sun-bleached concrete sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon display iridescent neck feathers shimmering with metallic purple and green hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's wing feathers begin to fray into tiny, glowing points of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's solid form disintegrate into a swirling, rising cloud of shimmering, iridescent particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with the pigeon disappearing, leaving only an empty expanse of concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011116121895611286 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511116027832031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011116121895611286, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011116121895611286, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03441537171602249, + 0.017062727361917496, + 0.007339716423302889, + 0.04086733236908913, + 0.043710947036743164, + 0.030125977471470833, + 0.045597318559885025, + 0.5546947121620178, + 0.019550200551748276, + 0.20663566887378693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011116121895611286 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic pigeon standing on a sun-bleached concrete sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon display iridescent neck feathers shimmering with metallic purple and green hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's wing feathers begin to fray into tiny, glowing points of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's solid form disintegrate into a swirling, rising cloud of shimmering, iridescent particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with the pigeon disappearing, leaving only an empty expanse of concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016079159453511238 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141078948974609 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016079159453511238, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016079159453511238, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.013633904978632927, + 0.006228613201528788, + 0.008038018830120564, + 0.007312368135899305, + 0.004918757826089859, + 0.02022179216146469, + 0.014220399782061577, + 0.6986786127090454, + 0.03237223997712135, + 0.19437527656555176 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016079159453511238 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic pigeon standing on a sun-bleached concrete sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon display iridescent neck feathers shimmering with metallic purple and green hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's wing feathers begin to fray into tiny, glowing points of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's solid form disintegrate into a swirling, rising cloud of shimmering, iridescent particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with the pigeon disappearing, leaving only an empty expanse of concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00043871314846910536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.750438690185547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00043871314846910536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00043871314846910536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.022538695484399796, + 0.005631696432828903, + 0.007218513172119856, + 0.00248663779348135, + 0.010967349633574486, + 0.008314979262650013, + 0.016758877784013748, + 0.5404075980186462, + 0.016143344342708588, + 0.3695323169231415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00043871314846910536 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic pigeon standing on a sun-bleached concrete sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon display iridescent neck feathers shimmering with metallic purple and green hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's wing feathers begin to fray into tiny, glowing points of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's solid form disintegrate into a swirling, rising cloud of shimmering, iridescent particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with the pigeon disappearing, leaving only an empty expanse of concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306808114051819 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680681705474854 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306808114051819, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306808114051819, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.019554665312170982, + 0.010074758902192116, + 0.009653708897531033, + 0.01606880873441696, + 0.028677446767687798, + 0.02024378441274166, + 0.029169682413339615, + 0.5578297972679138, + 0.02232068032026291, + 0.2864066958427429 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306808114051819 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly low-angle close-up captures a realistic pigeon standing on a sun-bleached, richly textured concrete sidewalk. Every detail of the bird is rendered with exquisite clarity: its iridescent neck feathers shimmer with metallic purple and green hues in the midday sun, its plump gray body feathers are perfectly contoured, and its brilliant red-orange eyes have a sharp, intelligent glint. Its pink, scaly feet firmly grip the rough concrete surface, which is marked by hairline cracks and tiny embedded pebbles. The scene pauses for a moment in perfect silence before the transformation begins, subtle at first. The tips of the wing feathers begin to fray, becoming not wisps but tiny, glowing points of light. This deconstruction process steadily and deliberately accelerates, flowing through the pigeon's body like a stream of water. Its solid form loses cohesion, its physical structure disintegrating into a swirling, rising cloud of shimmering, iridescent particles. These particles, preserving the pigeon's original palette, radiate an ethereal inner light, catching direct sunlight and refracting it into a dazzling, kaleidoscopic display. The digital cloud of dust slowly drifted upwards and dissipated into the warm, bright air, leaving behind only a desolate, empty expanse of concrete where the bird once stood, creating an atmosphere of surreal, quietly magical atmosphere.", + "seed": 16090, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_13/index_3343_seed_16090_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06639077336294577, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06639077336294577, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06639077336294577, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic pigeon standing on a sun-bleached concrete sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon display iridescent neck feathers shimmering with metallic purple and green hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's wing feathers begin to fray into tiny, glowing points of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's solid form disintegrate into a swirling, rising cloud of shimmering, iridescent particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with the pigeon disappearing, leaving only an empty expanse of concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2914779782295227 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.416477918624878 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2914779782295227, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2914779782295227, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5542907118797302, + 0.01942373439669609, + 0.0141965476796031, + 0.012568484991788864, + 0.015346329659223557, + 0.035884790122509, + 0.042490337044000626, + 0.030367113649845123, + 0.051041264086961746, + 0.2243906855583191 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2914779782295227 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic pigeon standing on a sun-bleached concrete sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon display iridescent neck feathers shimmering with metallic purple and green hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's wing feathers begin to fray into tiny, glowing points of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's solid form disintegrate into a swirling, rising cloud of shimmering, iridescent particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with the pigeon disappearing, leaving only an empty expanse of concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00598554965108633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130985736846924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00598554965108633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00598554965108633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.020697614178061485, + 0.004507649224251509, + 0.0025869798846542835, + 0.0035678017884492874, + 0.002749970881268382, + 0.017869306728243828, + 0.014060123823583126, + 0.01679321378469467, + 0.018676018342375755, + 0.898491382598877 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00598554965108633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic pigeon standing on a sun-bleached concrete sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon display iridescent neck feathers shimmering with metallic purple and green hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's wing feathers begin to fray into tiny, glowing points of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's solid form disintegrate into a swirling, rising cloud of shimmering, iridescent particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with the pigeon disappearing, leaving only an empty expanse of concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007639596704393625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882639408111572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007639596704393625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007639596704393625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02213355153799057, + 0.00485488586127758, + 0.0020573309157043695, + 0.003029428655281663, + 0.002736539812758565, + 0.022393472492694855, + 0.021458303555846214, + 0.014693236909806728, + 0.019093990325927734, + 0.8875492811203003 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007639596704393625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic pigeon standing on a sun-bleached concrete sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon display iridescent neck feathers shimmering with metallic purple and green hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's wing feathers begin to fray into tiny, glowing points of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's solid form disintegrate into a swirling, rising cloud of shimmering, iridescent particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with the pigeon disappearing, leaving only an empty expanse of concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0004978132783435285 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.625497817993164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0004978132783435285, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0004978132783435285, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.018047627061605453, + 0.007094919681549072, + 0.002979768207296729, + 0.003939112648367882, + 0.003598762210458517, + 0.022977987304329872, + 0.012639947235584259, + 0.01621825620532036, + 0.018876848742365837, + 0.8936266303062439 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0004978132783435285 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic pigeon standing on a sun-bleached concrete sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon display iridescent neck feathers shimmering with metallic purple and green hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's wing feathers begin to fray into tiny, glowing points of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's solid form disintegrate into a swirling, rising cloud of shimmering, iridescent particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with the pigeon disappearing, leaving only an empty expanse of concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026352928951382637 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651352882385254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026352928951382637, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026352928951382637, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.030942467972636223, + 0.006829970516264439, + 0.0034665418788790703, + 0.0037220814265310764, + 0.002175647299736738, + 0.0055111488327383995, + 0.012802564539015293, + 0.013110670261085033, + 0.021629083901643753, + 0.8998098373413086 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026352928951382637 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly low-angle close-up captures a realistic pigeon standing on a sun-bleached, richly textured concrete sidewalk. Every detail of the bird is rendered with exquisite clarity: its iridescent neck feathers shimmer with metallic purple and green hues in the midday sun, its plump gray body feathers are perfectly contoured, and its brilliant red-orange eyes have a sharp, intelligent glint. Its pink, scaly feet firmly grip the rough concrete surface, which is marked by hairline cracks and tiny embedded pebbles. The scene pauses for a moment in perfect silence before the transformation begins, subtle at first. The tips of the wing feathers begin to fray, becoming not wisps but tiny, glowing points of light. This deconstruction process steadily and deliberately accelerates, flowing through the pigeon's body like a stream of water. Its solid form loses cohesion, its physical structure disintegrating into a swirling, rising cloud of shimmering, iridescent particles. These particles, preserving the pigeon's original palette, radiate an ethereal inner light, catching direct sunlight and refracting it into a dazzling, kaleidoscopic display. The digital cloud of dust slowly drifted upwards and dissipated into the warm, bright air, leaving behind only a desolate, empty expanse of concrete where the bird once stood, creating an atmosphere of surreal, quietly magical atmosphere.", + "seed": 16091, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_13/index_3343_seed_16091_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1290361272986047, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1290361272986047, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1290361272986047, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic pigeon standing on a sun-bleached concrete sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon display iridescent neck feathers shimmering with metallic purple and green hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's wing feathers begin to fray into tiny, glowing points of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's solid form disintegrate into a swirling, rising cloud of shimmering, iridescent particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with the pigeon disappearing, leaving only an empty expanse of concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5806414484977722 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8306414484977722 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5806414484977722, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5806414484977722, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16913066804409027, + 0.037468764930963516, + 0.02788453735411167, + 0.032898224890232086, + 0.06864314526319504, + 0.0634123682975769, + 0.02373972348868847, + 0.36916184425354004, + 0.0849037915468216, + 0.12275688350200653 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5806414484977722 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic pigeon standing on a sun-bleached concrete sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon display iridescent neck feathers shimmering with metallic purple and green hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's wing feathers begin to fray into tiny, glowing points of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's solid form disintegrate into a swirling, rising cloud of shimmering, iridescent particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with the pigeon disappearing, leaving only an empty expanse of concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009813398122787476 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63481330871582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009813398122787476, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009813398122787476, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15528063476085663, + 0.012973738834261894, + 0.014376129023730755, + 0.019081667065620422, + 0.029484687373042107, + 0.048213206231594086, + 0.059015028178691864, + 0.39423394203186035, + 0.11442410200834274, + 0.15291689336299896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009813398122787476 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic pigeon standing on a sun-bleached concrete sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon display iridescent neck feathers shimmering with metallic purple and green hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's wing feathers begin to fray into tiny, glowing points of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's solid form disintegrate into a swirling, rising cloud of shimmering, iridescent particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with the pigeon disappearing, leaving only an empty expanse of concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01109065767377615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110907554626465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01109065767377615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01109065767377615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08390728384256363, + 0.009575788863003254, + 0.00904974713921547, + 0.00802141148597002, + 0.01195716392248869, + 0.05672064051032066, + 0.023903721943497658, + 0.6877247095108032, + 0.05908815562725067, + 0.05005137622356415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01109065767377615 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic pigeon standing on a sun-bleached concrete sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon display iridescent neck feathers shimmering with metallic purple and green hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's wing feathers begin to fray into tiny, glowing points of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's solid form disintegrate into a swirling, rising cloud of shimmering, iridescent particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with the pigeon disappearing, leaving only an empty expanse of concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0005619138828478754 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.500561714172363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0005619138828478754, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0005619138828478754, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12066681683063507, + 0.01436733826994896, + 0.012107658199965954, + 0.023039372637867928, + 0.03356538340449333, + 0.029310913756489754, + 0.04050625488162041, + 0.5916929244995117, + 0.06344972550868988, + 0.07129360735416412 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0005619138828478754 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic pigeon standing on a sun-bleached concrete sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon display iridescent neck feathers shimmering with metallic purple and green hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's wing feathers begin to fray into tiny, glowing points of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's solid form disintegrate into a swirling, rising cloud of shimmering, iridescent particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with the pigeon disappearing, leaving only an empty expanse of concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307321831583977 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680731773376465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307321831583977, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307321831583977, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09150222688913345, + 0.023187650367617607, + 0.02506277896463871, + 0.03587421402335167, + 0.025319991633296013, + 0.08616051077842712, + 0.0781974121928215, + 0.2247190624475479, + 0.18855012953281403, + 0.2214260846376419 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307321831583977 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly low-angle close-up captures a realistic pigeon standing on a sun-bleached, richly textured concrete sidewalk. Every detail of the bird is rendered with exquisite clarity: its iridescent neck feathers shimmer with metallic purple and green hues in the midday sun, its plump gray body feathers are perfectly contoured, and its brilliant red-orange eyes have a sharp, intelligent glint. Its pink, scaly feet firmly grip the rough concrete surface, which is marked by hairline cracks and tiny embedded pebbles. The scene pauses for a moment in perfect silence before the transformation begins, subtle at first. The tips of the wing feathers begin to fray, becoming not wisps but tiny, glowing points of light. This deconstruction process steadily and deliberately accelerates, flowing through the pigeon's body like a stream of water. Its solid form loses cohesion, its physical structure disintegrating into a swirling, rising cloud of shimmering, iridescent particles. These particles, preserving the pigeon's original palette, radiate an ethereal inner light, catching direct sunlight and refracting it into a dazzling, kaleidoscopic display. The digital cloud of dust slowly drifted upwards and dissipated into the warm, bright air, leaving behind only a desolate, empty expanse of concrete where the bird once stood, creating an atmosphere of surreal, quietly magical atmosphere.", + "seed": 16092, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_13/index_3343_seed_16092_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07534658034564927, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07534658034564927, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07534658034564927, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic pigeon standing on a sun-bleached concrete sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon display iridescent neck feathers shimmering with metallic purple and green hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's wing feathers begin to fray into tiny, glowing points of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's solid form disintegrate into a swirling, rising cloud of shimmering, iridescent particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with the pigeon disappearing, leaving only an empty expanse of concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1672137975692749 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.917213797569275 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1672137975692749, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1672137975692749, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12893038988113403, + 0.0631331205368042, + 0.029572056606411934, + 0.02988600917160511, + 0.027253661304712296, + 0.02376563847064972, + 0.2533177435398102, + 0.18339064717292786, + 0.13697639107704163, + 0.12377440929412842 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1672137975692749 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic pigeon standing on a sun-bleached concrete sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon display iridescent neck feathers shimmering with metallic purple and green hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's wing feathers begin to fray into tiny, glowing points of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's solid form disintegrate into a swirling, rising cloud of shimmering, iridescent particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with the pigeon disappearing, leaving only an empty expanse of concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01611083187162876 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141110897064209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01611083187162876, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01611083187162876, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.045592766255140305, + 0.05140744522213936, + 0.07298136502504349, + 0.02475113794207573, + 0.018992088735103607, + 0.06930212676525116, + 0.2692926526069641, + 0.16974377632141113, + 0.07260490953922272, + 0.2053317129611969 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01611083187162876 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic pigeon standing on a sun-bleached concrete sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon display iridescent neck feathers shimmering with metallic purple and green hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's wing feathers begin to fray into tiny, glowing points of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's solid form disintegrate into a swirling, rising cloud of shimmering, iridescent particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with the pigeon disappearing, leaving only an empty expanse of concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012554542161524296 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38755464553833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012554542161524296, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012554542161524296, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06261742860078812, + 0.02888322062790394, + 0.017905615270137787, + 0.021774379536509514, + 0.027214087545871735, + 0.028722627088427544, + 0.07970356196165085, + 0.1158614531159401, + 0.3065983057022095, + 0.3107192814350128 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012554542161524296 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic pigeon standing on a sun-bleached concrete sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon display iridescent neck feathers shimmering with metallic purple and green hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's wing feathers begin to fray into tiny, glowing points of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's solid form disintegrate into a swirling, rising cloud of shimmering, iridescent particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with the pigeon disappearing, leaving only an empty expanse of concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0009234455064870417 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.0009236335754395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0009234455064870417, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0009234455064870417, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06394235789775848, + 0.028057029470801353, + 0.02416677586734295, + 0.02032659202814102, + 0.02704734355211258, + 0.017628436908125877, + 0.10113615542650223, + 0.1203029528260231, + 0.1757134646177292, + 0.4216788411140442 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0009234455064870417 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a realistic pigeon standing on a sun-bleached concrete sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon display iridescent neck feathers shimmering with metallic purple and green hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's wing feathers begin to fray into tiny, glowing points of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon's solid form disintegrate into a swirling, rising cloud of shimmering, iridescent particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with the pigeon disappearing, leaving only an empty expanse of concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17993028461933136 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804930329322815 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17993028461933136, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17993028461933136, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05146530643105507, + 0.023293424397706985, + 0.033729467540979385, + 0.024147894233465195, + 0.029244983568787575, + 0.021275151520967484, + 0.23621469736099243, + 0.16438600420951843, + 0.08739716559648514, + 0.32884594798088074 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17993028461933136 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_14/index_tensor([3777, 3777])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_14/index_tensor([3777, 3777])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2ef0e9f9f88250fcab710e429903b03eb47a4c66 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_14/index_tensor([3777, 3777])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a fluid tracking shot, the camera, at a slightly upward angle, closely follows a carved dragon eaves that has just been torn from a magnificent celestial residence atop a sea of clouds. The eaves are meticulously carved from dark, ancient wood. The auspicious dragon perched atop it is ferocious and majestic, each scale meticulously detailed. The remaining gilt glimmers with a last, faint, poignant glow in the sky dimmed by the impact of a mysterious force. As it streaks across the sky, the camera captures its slow, uncontrolled tumbling. Cracks in the wooden structure, caused by the immense stress, continue to spread, and tiny wood chips and dust peel away from the dragon's head, scattering in the thin air. In the background, the once-grand immortal residence undergoes a silent yet violent collapse: the vast white jade walls shatter like icebergs, shattering into countless gleaming crystals. Swathes of blue glazed tiles, unsupported, cascade down like a bursting dam, creating a magnificent yet deadly blue rainstorm. Along with countless shattered pavilions, towers, and jade railings, they plummet into the bottomless, swirling sea of clouds below. The entire scene is shrouded in a cold and saturated hue: the pure white of the shattered jade, the royal blue of the glazed tiles, and the dark brown of the ancient trees. Light penetrates the turbulent clouds, casting a cacophony of light and shadow, creating a supremely tragic elegy imbued with the charm of classical Chinese immortal chivalry, imbued with a tragic beauty amidst destruction.", + "seed": 11912, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_14/index_3777_seed_11912_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03568151090294123, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03568151090294123, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03568151090294123, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a carved dragon eaves structure torn from a celestial residence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure made of dark, ancient wood with a ferocious dragon perched on top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure shown tumbling slowly and uncontrolled while cracks spread and wood chips scatter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a collapsing residence with white jade walls shattering into crystals and blue glazed tiles cascading down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a fluid tracking shot from a slightly upward angle following the falling eaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05662792921066284 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9316279888153076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05662792921066284, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05662792921066284, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1323138028383255, + 0.22354766726493835, + 0.050770290195941925, + 0.06504273414611816, + 0.06474762409925461, + 0.1021740734577179, + 0.05376923456788063, + 0.17874042689800262, + 0.07753287255764008, + 0.05136127397418022 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05662792921066284 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a carved dragon eaves structure torn from a celestial residence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure made of dark, ancient wood with a ferocious dragon perched on top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure shown tumbling slowly and uncontrolled while cracks spread and wood chips scatter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a collapsing residence with white jade walls shattering into crystals and blue glazed tiles cascading down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a fluid tracking shot from a slightly upward angle following the falling eaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020605312660336494 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956053256988525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020605312660336494, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020605312660336494, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19739720225334167, + 0.07025181502103806, + 0.08179377019405365, + 0.07442670315504074, + 0.13554240763187408, + 0.10012181848287582, + 0.033044978976249695, + 0.13618871569633484, + 0.11197192966938019, + 0.059260718524456024 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020605312660336494 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a carved dragon eaves structure torn from a celestial residence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure made of dark, ancient wood with a ferocious dragon perched on top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure shown tumbling slowly and uncontrolled while cracks spread and wood chips scatter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a collapsing residence with white jade walls shattering into crystals and blue glazed tiles cascading down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a fluid tracking shot from a slightly upward angle following the falling eaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054943352937698364 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929943323135376 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054943352937698364, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054943352937698364, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05752883851528168, + 0.04506061226129532, + 0.0571616068482399, + 0.03499503433704376, + 0.04725266620516777, + 0.23273074626922607, + 0.037672217935323715, + 0.06835619360208511, + 0.35577425360679626, + 0.06346777826547623 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054943352937698364 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a carved dragon eaves structure torn from a celestial residence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure made of dark, ancient wood with a ferocious dragon perched on top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure shown tumbling slowly and uncontrolled while cracks spread and wood chips scatter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a collapsing residence with white jade walls shattering into crystals and blue glazed tiles cascading down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a fluid tracking shot from a slightly upward angle following the falling eaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012542887590825558 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387542724609375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012542887590825558, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012542887590825558, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13893736898899078, + 0.13808587193489075, + 0.05551137030124664, + 0.020816583186388016, + 0.04295558109879494, + 0.1950865089893341, + 0.06244480609893799, + 0.13920311629772186, + 0.16215841472148895, + 0.044800419360399246 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012542887590825558 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a carved dragon eaves structure torn from a celestial residence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure made of dark, ancient wood with a ferocious dragon perched on top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure shown tumbling slowly and uncontrolled while cracks spread and wood chips scatter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a collapsing residence with white jade walls shattering into crystals and blue glazed tiles cascading down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a fluid tracking shot from a slightly upward angle following the falling eaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368807211518288 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086880683898926 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368807211518288, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368807211518288, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0734996572136879, + 0.10038401931524277, + 0.03466275334358215, + 0.04610339179635048, + 0.10577917844057083, + 0.15974654257297516, + 0.10454634577035904, + 0.1311294138431549, + 0.20480217039585114, + 0.03934655711054802 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368807211518288 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a fluid tracking shot, the camera, at a slightly upward angle, closely follows a carved dragon eaves that has just been torn from a magnificent celestial residence atop a sea of clouds. The eaves are meticulously carved from dark, ancient wood. The auspicious dragon perched atop it is ferocious and majestic, each scale meticulously detailed. The remaining gilt glimmers with a last, faint, poignant glow in the sky dimmed by the impact of a mysterious force. As it streaks across the sky, the camera captures its slow, uncontrolled tumbling. Cracks in the wooden structure, caused by the immense stress, continue to spread, and tiny wood chips and dust peel away from the dragon's head, scattering in the thin air. In the background, the once-grand immortal residence undergoes a silent yet violent collapse: the vast white jade walls shatter like icebergs, shattering into countless gleaming crystals. Swathes of blue glazed tiles, unsupported, cascade down like a bursting dam, creating a magnificent yet deadly blue rainstorm. Along with countless shattered pavilions, towers, and jade railings, they plummet into the bottomless, swirling sea of clouds below. The entire scene is shrouded in a cold and saturated hue: the pure white of the shattered jade, the royal blue of the glazed tiles, and the dark brown of the ancient trees. Light penetrates the turbulent clouds, casting a cacophony of light and shadow, creating a supremely tragic elegy imbued with the charm of classical Chinese immortal chivalry, imbued with a tragic beauty amidst destruction.", + "seed": 11913, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_14/index_3777_seed_11913_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.019746414758265017, + "vlm_logprob": -0.019746414758265017, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.019746414758265017, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a carved dragon eaves structure torn from a celestial residence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure made of dark, ancient wood with a ferocious dragon perched on top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure shown tumbling slowly and uncontrolled while cracks spread and wood chips scatter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a collapsing residence with white jade walls shattering into crystals and blue glazed tiles cascading down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a fluid tracking shot from a slightly upward angle following the falling eaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01679987460374832 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1417999267578125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01679987460374832, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01679987460374832, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19958479702472687, + 0.11888238787651062, + 0.0365116149187088, + 0.047853995114564896, + 0.27946949005126953, + 0.06173330545425415, + 0.051287565380334854, + 0.06294968724250793, + 0.03801918402314186, + 0.10370803624391556 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01679987460374832 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a carved dragon eaves structure torn from a celestial residence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure made of dark, ancient wood with a ferocious dragon perched on top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure shown tumbling slowly and uncontrolled while cracks spread and wood chips scatter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a collapsing residence with white jade walls shattering into crystals and blue glazed tiles cascading down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a fluid tracking shot from a slightly upward angle following the falling eaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002500266768038273 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002500057220459 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002500266768038273, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002500266768038273, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17363300919532776, + 0.11692358553409576, + 0.06547290831804276, + 0.08431387692689896, + 0.17556235194206238, + 0.083938829600811, + 0.04100104793906212, + 0.11038893461227417, + 0.09508311003446579, + 0.05368231609463692 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002500266768038273 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a carved dragon eaves structure torn from a celestial residence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure made of dark, ancient wood with a ferocious dragon perched on top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure shown tumbling slowly and uncontrolled while cracks spread and wood chips scatter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a collapsing residence with white jade walls shattering into crystals and blue glazed tiles cascading down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a fluid tracking shot from a slightly upward angle following the falling eaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076287128031253815 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882628917694092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076287128031253815, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076287128031253815, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07371506839990616, + 0.040529586374759674, + 0.029814327135682106, + 0.12410534173250198, + 0.3923361897468567, + 0.08580069243907928, + 0.07735172659158707, + 0.05759682133793831, + 0.04432274401187897, + 0.074427530169487 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076287128031253815 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a carved dragon eaves structure torn from a celestial residence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure made of dark, ancient wood with a ferocious dragon perched on top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure shown tumbling slowly and uncontrolled while cracks spread and wood chips scatter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a collapsing residence with white jade walls shattering into crystals and blue glazed tiles cascading down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a fluid tracking shot from a slightly upward angle following the falling eaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009778574109077454 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347784996032715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009778574109077454, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009778574109077454, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03710048273205757, + 0.025680847465991974, + 0.02993881143629551, + 0.03080151230096817, + 0.49337291717529297, + 0.030256515368819237, + 0.09499777108430862, + 0.08009719103574753, + 0.05393025651574135, + 0.12382370233535767 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009778574109077454 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a carved dragon eaves structure torn from a celestial residence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure made of dark, ancient wood with a ferocious dragon perched on top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure shown tumbling slowly and uncontrolled while cracks spread and wood chips scatter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a collapsing residence with white jade walls shattering into crystals and blue glazed tiles cascading down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a fluid tracking shot from a slightly upward angle following the falling eaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06202464550733566 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120245933532715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06202464550733566, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06202464550733566, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10319682210683823, + 0.046281758695840836, + 0.054595425724983215, + 0.10404971241950989, + 0.3449379801750183, + 0.051564253866672516, + 0.11427149176597595, + 0.0713731199502945, + 0.05002371966838837, + 0.05970572307705879 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06202464550733566 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a fluid tracking shot, the camera, at a slightly upward angle, closely follows a carved dragon eaves that has just been torn from a magnificent celestial residence atop a sea of clouds. The eaves are meticulously carved from dark, ancient wood. The auspicious dragon perched atop it is ferocious and majestic, each scale meticulously detailed. The remaining gilt glimmers with a last, faint, poignant glow in the sky dimmed by the impact of a mysterious force. As it streaks across the sky, the camera captures its slow, uncontrolled tumbling. Cracks in the wooden structure, caused by the immense stress, continue to spread, and tiny wood chips and dust peel away from the dragon's head, scattering in the thin air. In the background, the once-grand immortal residence undergoes a silent yet violent collapse: the vast white jade walls shatter like icebergs, shattering into countless gleaming crystals. Swathes of blue glazed tiles, unsupported, cascade down like a bursting dam, creating a magnificent yet deadly blue rainstorm. Along with countless shattered pavilions, towers, and jade railings, they plummet into the bottomless, swirling sea of clouds below. The entire scene is shrouded in a cold and saturated hue: the pure white of the shattered jade, the royal blue of the glazed tiles, and the dark brown of the ancient trees. Light penetrates the turbulent clouds, casting a cacophony of light and shadow, creating a supremely tragic elegy imbued with the charm of classical Chinese immortal chivalry, imbued with a tragic beauty amidst destruction.", + "seed": 11914, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_14/index_3777_seed_11914_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.020651081949472426, + "vlm_logprob": -0.020651081949472426, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.020651081949472426, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a carved dragon eaves structure torn from a celestial residence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure made of dark, ancient wood with a ferocious dragon perched on top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure shown tumbling slowly and uncontrolled while cracks spread and wood chips scatter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a collapsing residence with white jade walls shattering into crystals and blue glazed tiles cascading down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a fluid tracking shot from a slightly upward angle following the falling eaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01671253889799118 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141712665557861 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01671253889799118, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01671253889799118, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6861715316772461, + 0.019064048305153847, + 0.02011970803141594, + 0.032664187252521515, + 0.04737408459186554, + 0.026538845151662827, + 0.019475482404232025, + 0.02689044550061226, + 0.018917730078101158, + 0.10278401523828506 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01671253889799118 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a carved dragon eaves structure torn from a celestial residence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure made of dark, ancient wood with a ferocious dragon perched on top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure shown tumbling slowly and uncontrolled while cracks spread and wood chips scatter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a collapsing residence with white jade walls shattering into crystals and blue glazed tiles cascading down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a fluid tracking shot from a slightly upward angle following the falling eaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008649149909615517 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586493492126465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008649149909615517, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008649149909615517, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.457149863243103, + 0.057455260306596756, + 0.07566458731889725, + 0.07178644090890884, + 0.03711852803826332, + 0.05465896427631378, + 0.02288963459432125, + 0.03328343480825424, + 0.02501998469233513, + 0.16497330367565155 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008649149909615517 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a carved dragon eaves structure torn from a celestial residence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure made of dark, ancient wood with a ferocious dragon perched on top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure shown tumbling slowly and uncontrolled while cracks spread and wood chips scatter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a collapsing residence with white jade walls shattering into crystals and blue glazed tiles cascading down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a fluid tracking shot from a slightly upward angle following the falling eaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011074859648942947 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511075019836426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011074859648942947, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011074859648942947, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15317197144031525, + 0.10633500665426254, + 0.1416516751050949, + 0.152283176779747, + 0.12463081628084183, + 0.08700934052467346, + 0.02953510731458664, + 0.05298950895667076, + 0.03036683239042759, + 0.12202659249305725 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011074859648942947 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a carved dragon eaves structure torn from a celestial residence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure made of dark, ancient wood with a ferocious dragon perched on top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure shown tumbling slowly and uncontrolled while cracks spread and wood chips scatter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a collapsing residence with white jade walls shattering into crystals and blue glazed tiles cascading down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a fluid tracking shot from a slightly upward angle following the falling eaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018181568011641502 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018181800842285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018181568011641502, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018181568011641502, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28304633498191833, + 0.06665610522031784, + 0.11431064456701279, + 0.04953980818390846, + 0.15242546796798706, + 0.10937020927667618, + 0.04602042958140373, + 0.05445556342601776, + 0.07252444326877594, + 0.051650989800691605 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018181568011641502 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a carved dragon eaves structure torn from a celestial residence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure made of dark, ancient wood with a ferocious dragon perched on top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure shown tumbling slowly and uncontrolled while cracks spread and wood chips scatter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a collapsing residence with white jade walls shattering into crystals and blue glazed tiles cascading down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a fluid tracking shot from a slightly upward angle following the falling eaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04863729327917099 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486373901367188 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04863729327917099, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04863729327917099, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5658848881721497, + 0.06737719476222992, + 0.07989828288555145, + 0.0720168799161911, + 0.05966590344905853, + 0.03825975954532623, + 0.03557988628745079, + 0.028737036511301994, + 0.017299888655543327, + 0.03528028726577759 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04863729327917099 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a fluid tracking shot, the camera, at a slightly upward angle, closely follows a carved dragon eaves that has just been torn from a magnificent celestial residence atop a sea of clouds. The eaves are meticulously carved from dark, ancient wood. The auspicious dragon perched atop it is ferocious and majestic, each scale meticulously detailed. The remaining gilt glimmers with a last, faint, poignant glow in the sky dimmed by the impact of a mysterious force. As it streaks across the sky, the camera captures its slow, uncontrolled tumbling. Cracks in the wooden structure, caused by the immense stress, continue to spread, and tiny wood chips and dust peel away from the dragon's head, scattering in the thin air. In the background, the once-grand immortal residence undergoes a silent yet violent collapse: the vast white jade walls shatter like icebergs, shattering into countless gleaming crystals. Swathes of blue glazed tiles, unsupported, cascade down like a bursting dam, creating a magnificent yet deadly blue rainstorm. Along with countless shattered pavilions, towers, and jade railings, they plummet into the bottomless, swirling sea of clouds below. The entire scene is shrouded in a cold and saturated hue: the pure white of the shattered jade, the royal blue of the glazed tiles, and the dark brown of the ancient trees. Light penetrates the turbulent clouds, casting a cacophony of light and shadow, creating a supremely tragic elegy imbued with the charm of classical Chinese immortal chivalry, imbued with a tragic beauty amidst destruction.", + "seed": 11915, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_14/index_3777_seed_11915_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.022336261626333, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022336261626333, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022336261626333, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a carved dragon eaves structure torn from a celestial residence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure made of dark, ancient wood with a ferocious dragon perched on top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure shown tumbling slowly and uncontrolled while cracks spread and wood chips scatter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a collapsing residence with white jade walls shattering into crystals and blue glazed tiles cascading down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a fluid tracking shot from a slightly upward angle following the falling eaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.027517056092619896 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.652517080307007 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.027517056092619896, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.027517056092619896, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08164285123348236, + 0.10048599541187286, + 0.16529618203639984, + 0.10202448070049286, + 0.1351812481880188, + 0.1433618813753128, + 0.0706172063946724, + 0.05441058427095413, + 0.061996940523386, + 0.08498264104127884 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.027517056092619896 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a carved dragon eaves structure torn from a celestial residence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure made of dark, ancient wood with a ferocious dragon perched on top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure shown tumbling slowly and uncontrolled while cracks spread and wood chips scatter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a collapsing residence with white jade walls shattering into crystals and blue glazed tiles cascading down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a fluid tracking shot from a slightly upward angle following the falling eaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052629257552325726 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255262851715088 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052629257552325726, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052629257552325726, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17915381491184235, + 0.21572893857955933, + 0.1200023740530014, + 0.09730920195579529, + 0.10605810582637787, + 0.046547386795282364, + 0.08286260068416595, + 0.05981355160474777, + 0.056262049823999405, + 0.03626198321580887 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052629257552325726 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a carved dragon eaves structure torn from a celestial residence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure made of dark, ancient wood with a ferocious dragon perched on top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure shown tumbling slowly and uncontrolled while cracks spread and wood chips scatter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a collapsing residence with white jade walls shattering into crystals and blue glazed tiles cascading down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a fluid tracking shot from a slightly upward angle following the falling eaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00977963674813509 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634779453277588 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00977963674813509, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00977963674813509, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12298671156167984, + 0.054720357060432434, + 0.26202815771102905, + 0.16975753009319305, + 0.08135418593883514, + 0.0800105482339859, + 0.05968553200364113, + 0.049358535557985306, + 0.05675220862030983, + 0.0633462518453598 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00977963674813509 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a carved dragon eaves structure torn from a celestial residence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure made of dark, ancient wood with a ferocious dragon perched on top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure shown tumbling slowly and uncontrolled while cracks spread and wood chips scatter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a collapsing residence with white jade walls shattering into crystals and blue glazed tiles cascading down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a fluid tracking shot from a slightly upward angle following the falling eaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014191539026796818 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264191627502441 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014191539026796818, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014191539026796818, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09595706313848495, + 0.08299298584461212, + 0.20605161786079407, + 0.07959669083356857, + 0.09780766069889069, + 0.05413178354501724, + 0.045998457819223404, + 0.16353601217269897, + 0.05334068089723587, + 0.12058701366186142 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014191539026796818 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a carved dragon eaves structure torn from a celestial residence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure made of dark, ancient wood with a ferocious dragon perched on top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the eaves structure shown tumbling slowly and uncontrolled while cracks spread and wood chips scatter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a collapsing residence with white jade walls shattering into crystals and blue glazed tiles cascading down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving in a fluid tracking shot from a slightly upward angle following the falling eaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054930150508880615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299302101135254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054930150508880615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054930150508880615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15385985374450684, + 0.0915704220533371, + 0.09748462587594986, + 0.07196949422359467, + 0.0914611965417862, + 0.1474308967590332, + 0.06352604180574417, + 0.09397340565919876, + 0.11593352258205414, + 0.07279051840305328 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054930150508880615 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_15/index_tensor([6303, 6303])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_15/index_tensor([6303, 6303])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f2d515224234cfdabd78bf44ee2f5826ac3adfcc --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_15/index_tensor([6303, 6303])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "This static, eye-level medium close-up, rendered in a classic film noir style, focuses on a man with dark, sleek hair with a subtle sheen and a carefully groomed mustache. He sits, wearing a dark, tailored suit and a crisp tie whose fabric absorbs the limited light. The setting is a dimly lit room, the only distinctive background element being heavy, dark green curtains, whose deep folds create an abyss of shadow behind him. The scene is defined by its dramatic, high-contrast lighting; a harsh key light, likely originating from an off-screen source, carves his features out of the darkness, illuminating one side of his face while casting the other in deep shadow. His mouth is slightly open, his gaze intensely focused, suggesting he is in the midst of a weighty or secretive conversation. This deliberate composition emphasizes the stark interplay of light and dark, creating an atmosphere of tension and mystery, drawing the viewer's full attention to the man's enigmatic expression and the unspoken conspiracy at play.", + "seed": 21748, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_15/index_6303_seed_21748_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.01653512129560113, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01653512129560113, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01653512129560113, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark tailored suit and a crisp tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are heavy dark green curtains visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting high-contrast with one side of the face illuminated and the other in deep shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man's mouth slightly open with an intense, focused gaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02819376438856125 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.903193950653076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02819376438856125, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02819376438856125, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.41257694363594055, + 0.059527333825826645, + 0.06318962574005127, + 0.07907640188932419, + 0.027336088940501213, + 0.028067706152796745, + 0.057634156197309494, + 0.04844139143824577, + 0.12990209460258484, + 0.0942482277750969 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02819376438856125 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark tailored suit and a crisp tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are heavy dark green curtains visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting high-contrast with one side of the face illuminated and the other in deep shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man's mouth slightly open with an intense, focused gaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011099381372332573 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511099338531494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011099381372332573, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011099381372332573, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2881414294242859, + 0.29574841260910034, + 0.09267372637987137, + 0.07586151361465454, + 0.06642571836709976, + 0.025216540321707726, + 0.025670917704701424, + 0.03606285899877548, + 0.035167209804058075, + 0.05903169885277748 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011099381372332573 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark tailored suit and a crisp tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are heavy dark green curtains visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting high-contrast with one side of the face illuminated and the other in deep shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man's mouth slightly open with an intense, focused gaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007632971741259098 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882633209228516 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007632971741259098, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007632971741259098, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2083938717842102, + 0.15335623919963837, + 0.1158856451511383, + 0.036514762789011, + 0.12463517487049103, + 0.10516176372766495, + 0.08620519191026688, + 0.035036444664001465, + 0.0504942312836647, + 0.08431672304868698 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007632971741259098 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark tailored suit and a crisp tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are heavy dark green curtains visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting high-contrast with one side of the face illuminated and the other in deep shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man's mouth slightly open with an intense, focused gaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005955332424491644 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130955219268799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005955332424491644, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005955332424491644, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.43590182065963745, + 0.15621936321258545, + 0.055728692561388016, + 0.045418284833431244, + 0.09847528487443924, + 0.03390573710203171, + 0.03550809994339943, + 0.04002648964524269, + 0.04530858248472214, + 0.053507670760154724 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005955332424491644 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark tailored suit and a crisp tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are heavy dark green curtains visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting high-contrast with one side of the face illuminated and the other in deep shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man's mouth slightly open with an intense, focused gaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029794156551361084 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529794216156006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029794156551361084, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029794156551361084, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3769630193710327, + 0.09671217203140259, + 0.10214604437351227, + 0.112184077501297, + 0.049049392342567444, + 0.03259004279971123, + 0.06170129030942917, + 0.038518231362104416, + 0.06911911815404892, + 0.06101663410663605 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029794156551361084 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This static, eye-level medium close-up, rendered in a classic film noir style, focuses on a man with dark, sleek hair with a subtle sheen and a carefully groomed mustache. He sits, wearing a dark, tailored suit and a crisp tie whose fabric absorbs the limited light. The setting is a dimly lit room, the only distinctive background element being heavy, dark green curtains, whose deep folds create an abyss of shadow behind him. The scene is defined by its dramatic, high-contrast lighting; a harsh key light, likely originating from an off-screen source, carves his features out of the darkness, illuminating one side of his face while casting the other in deep shadow. His mouth is slightly open, his gaze intensely focused, suggesting he is in the midst of a weighty or secretive conversation. This deliberate composition emphasizes the stark interplay of light and dark, creating an atmosphere of tension and mystery, drawing the viewer's full attention to the man's enigmatic expression and the unspoken conspiracy at play.", + "seed": 21749, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_15/index_6303_seed_21749_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.022700230684131385, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022700230684131385, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022700230684131385, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark tailored suit and a crisp tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are heavy dark green curtains visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting high-contrast with one side of the face illuminated and the other in deep shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man's mouth slightly open with an intense, focused gaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.027095170691609383 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.527095317840576 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.027095170691609383, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.027095170691609383, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.246269091963768, + 0.09282996505498886, + 0.06978203356266022, + 0.055012769997119904, + 0.02293430268764496, + 0.018996259197592735, + 0.06141321733593941, + 0.3422483503818512, + 0.03212155029177666, + 0.05839243158698082 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.027095170691609383 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark tailored suit and a crisp tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are heavy dark green curtains visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting high-contrast with one side of the face illuminated and the other in deep shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man's mouth slightly open with an intense, focused gaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05498679354786873 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299867153167725 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05498679354786873, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05498679354786873, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4810726046562195, + 0.1719772070646286, + 0.07930276542901993, + 0.031061556190252304, + 0.018420027568936348, + 0.016330653801560402, + 0.018860938027501106, + 0.09252653270959854, + 0.0323767326772213, + 0.058071013540029526 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05498679354786873 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark tailored suit and a crisp tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are heavy dark green curtains visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting high-contrast with one side of the face illuminated and the other in deep shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man's mouth slightly open with an intense, focused gaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004098943900316954 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504098892211914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004098943900316954, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004098943900316954, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23973369598388672, + 0.19729778170585632, + 0.12220951169729233, + 0.030162032693624496, + 0.0714438259601593, + 0.03482280299067497, + 0.03510615974664688, + 0.18505054712295532, + 0.02836129069328308, + 0.05581236258149147 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004098943900316954 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark tailored suit and a crisp tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are heavy dark green curtains visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting high-contrast with one side of the face illuminated and the other in deep shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man's mouth slightly open with an intense, focused gaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067444778978824615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006744384765625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067444778978824615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067444778978824615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22509416937828064, + 0.2596568465232849, + 0.06398911774158478, + 0.14726175367832184, + 0.08009470999240875, + 0.05868109315633774, + 0.050542037934064865, + 0.013532773591578007, + 0.05397776886820793, + 0.047169674187898636 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067444778978824615 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark tailored suit and a crisp tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are heavy dark green curtains visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting high-contrast with one side of the face illuminated and the other in deep shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man's mouth slightly open with an intense, focused gaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020575767382979393 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895575761795044 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020575767382979393, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020575767382979393, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3266073763370514, + 0.10078899562358856, + 0.08652666211128235, + 0.09517451375722885, + 0.035452116280794144, + 0.042937021702528, + 0.09246557205915451, + 0.05535148084163666, + 0.12048493325710297, + 0.04421140253543854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020575767382979393 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This static, eye-level medium close-up, rendered in a classic film noir style, focuses on a man with dark, sleek hair with a subtle sheen and a carefully groomed mustache. He sits, wearing a dark, tailored suit and a crisp tie whose fabric absorbs the limited light. The setting is a dimly lit room, the only distinctive background element being heavy, dark green curtains, whose deep folds create an abyss of shadow behind him. The scene is defined by its dramatic, high-contrast lighting; a harsh key light, likely originating from an off-screen source, carves his features out of the darkness, illuminating one side of his face while casting the other in deep shadow. His mouth is slightly open, his gaze intensely focused, suggesting he is in the midst of a weighty or secretive conversation. This deliberate composition emphasizes the stark interplay of light and dark, creating an atmosphere of tension and mystery, drawing the viewer's full attention to the man's enigmatic expression and the unspoken conspiracy at play.", + "seed": 21750, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_15/index_6303_seed_21750_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.013434716779738665, + "vlm_logprob": -0.013434716779738665, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.013434716779738665, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark tailored suit and a crisp tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are heavy dark green curtains visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting high-contrast with one side of the face illuminated and the other in deep shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man's mouth slightly open with an intense, focused gaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0220138318836689 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1470136642456055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0220138318836689, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0220138318836689, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2951872646808624, + 0.14111192524433136, + 0.107764832675457, + 0.06700393557548523, + 0.04881741851568222, + 0.03557479381561279, + 0.07430604100227356, + 0.045650821179151535, + 0.11218585819005966, + 0.07239706814289093 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0220138318836689 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark tailored suit and a crisp tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are heavy dark green curtains visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting high-contrast with one side of the face illuminated and the other in deep shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man's mouth slightly open with an intense, focused gaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014221273362636566 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26422119140625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014221273362636566, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014221273362636566, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4183586537837982, + 0.1570843756198883, + 0.07372535765171051, + 0.11276812106370926, + 0.0592946894466877, + 0.03440706804394722, + 0.03323610499501228, + 0.018208488821983337, + 0.048547957092523575, + 0.04436919838190079 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014221273362636566 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark tailored suit and a crisp tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are heavy dark green curtains visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting high-contrast with one side of the face illuminated and the other in deep shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man's mouth slightly open with an intense, focused gaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036187181249260902 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.6286187171936035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036187181249260902, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036187181249260902, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18148484826087952, + 0.15028056502342224, + 0.11382843554019928, + 0.2393961101770401, + 0.06030229106545448, + 0.03447478264570236, + 0.05036377161741257, + 0.04967905208468437, + 0.07162215560674667, + 0.04856796935200691 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036187181249260902 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark tailored suit and a crisp tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are heavy dark green curtains visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting high-contrast with one side of the face illuminated and the other in deep shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man's mouth slightly open with an intense, focused gaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006743175443261862 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00674295425415 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006743175443261862, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006743175443261862, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20241744816303253, + 0.19418859481811523, + 0.2583414912223816, + 0.12898898124694824, + 0.032596927136182785, + 0.021021131426095963, + 0.05022241175174713, + 0.02370922639966011, + 0.06959167122840881, + 0.018922096118330956 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006743175443261862 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark tailored suit and a crisp tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are heavy dark green curtains visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting high-contrast with one side of the face illuminated and the other in deep shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man's mouth slightly open with an intense, focused gaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020576585084199905 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955764770507812 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020576585084199905, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020576585084199905, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33099451661109924, + 0.11447019875049591, + 0.13848114013671875, + 0.16058339178562164, + 0.041629087179899216, + 0.025296160951256752, + 0.06122850254178047, + 0.03176003322005272, + 0.0604618638753891, + 0.03509506210684776 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020576585084199905 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This static, eye-level medium close-up, rendered in a classic film noir style, focuses on a man with dark, sleek hair with a subtle sheen and a carefully groomed mustache. He sits, wearing a dark, tailored suit and a crisp tie whose fabric absorbs the limited light. The setting is a dimly lit room, the only distinctive background element being heavy, dark green curtains, whose deep folds create an abyss of shadow behind him. The scene is defined by its dramatic, high-contrast lighting; a harsh key light, likely originating from an off-screen source, carves his features out of the darkness, illuminating one side of his face while casting the other in deep shadow. His mouth is slightly open, his gaze intensely focused, suggesting he is in the midst of a weighty or secretive conversation. This deliberate composition emphasizes the stark interplay of light and dark, creating an atmosphere of tension and mystery, drawing the viewer's full attention to the man's enigmatic expression and the unspoken conspiracy at play.", + "seed": 21751, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_15/index_6303_seed_21751_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.018286931701004504, + "vlm_logprob": -0.018286931701004504, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.018286931701004504, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark tailored suit and a crisp tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are heavy dark green curtains visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting high-contrast with one side of the face illuminated and the other in deep shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man's mouth slightly open with an intense, focused gaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043849822133779526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.293849945068359 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043849822133779526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043849822133779526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19131329655647278, + 0.2738913595676422, + 0.03835861012339592, + 0.2569368779659271, + 0.017865387722849846, + 0.0424334891140461, + 0.0496978722512722, + 0.014988322742283344, + 0.043122708797454834, + 0.07139211893081665 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043849822133779526 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark tailored suit and a crisp tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are heavy dark green curtains visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting high-contrast with one side of the face illuminated and the other in deep shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man's mouth slightly open with an intense, focused gaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01609945483505726 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141099452972412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01609945483505726, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01609945483505726, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12836596369743347, + 0.3440576195716858, + 0.1286797672510147, + 0.1820884793996811, + 0.012221175245940685, + 0.042442020028829575, + 0.07254838198423386, + 0.025596769526600838, + 0.01935475878417492, + 0.044645100831985474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01609945483505726 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark tailored suit and a crisp tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are heavy dark green curtains visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting high-contrast with one side of the face illuminated and the other in deep shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man's mouth slightly open with an intense, focused gaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010455148294568062 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.8760457038879395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010455148294568062, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010455148294568062, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05687466263771057, + 0.5622770190238953, + 0.04006734490394592, + 0.13980801403522491, + 0.010830803774297237, + 0.01738777570426464, + 0.10394692420959473, + 0.009187685325741768, + 0.017909301444888115, + 0.04171052575111389 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010455148294568062 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark tailored suit and a crisp tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are heavy dark green curtains visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting high-contrast with one side of the face illuminated and the other in deep shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man's mouth slightly open with an intense, focused gaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004102030768990517 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5041022300720215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004102030768990517, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004102030768990517, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27261948585510254, + 0.052233994007110596, + 0.04875202476978302, + 0.07128553092479706, + 0.048772040754556656, + 0.06894557178020477, + 0.2760128676891327, + 0.016549477353692055, + 0.08446253836154938, + 0.060366492718458176 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004102030768990517 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark tailored suit and a crisp tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are heavy dark green curtains visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting high-contrast with one side of the face illuminated and the other in deep shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man's mouth slightly open with an intense, focused gaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02633783593773842 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513378620147705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02633783593773842, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02633783593773842, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08295159786939621, + 0.3544408977031708, + 0.11557555198669434, + 0.18191443383693695, + 0.013057014904916286, + 0.01525751780718565, + 0.14841187000274658, + 0.00741436704993248, + 0.04650021344423294, + 0.03447653725743294 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02633783593773842 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_2/index_tensor([867, 867])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_2/index_tensor([867, 867])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b3a126c47aaf82fb05d86b43be5915b934b0ac37 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_2/index_tensor([867, 867])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An underwater medium close-up, rendered with hyper-real clarity, unfolds with a slow, graceful lens around a magnificent brook trout. The fish hangs almost motionless, its body a canvas of natural art: its olive-green back is intricately etched with unique, worm-like patterns, while its shimmering sides are dotted with vibrant red spots, each perfectly blurred against a delicate, ethereal blue. It rests serenely and steadily on a bed of smooth, rounded river rocks, its gray and brown surface softened by a carpet of deep green moss. The camera's deliberate movements capture the fish's minute, almost imperceptible adjustments to its pectoral and dorsal fins as it effortlessly maintains its position against the gentle, invisible current. Bright sunlight, penetrating the crystal-clear water from above, creates a mesmerizing ballet of patterns that ripple and shift across the trout's smooth scales and the mossy brook bottom, illuminating tiny particles drifting in the water. The atmosphere is one of profound stillness and focused peace, a genuine and captivating moment frozen in a pristine, sun-dappled aquatic world.", + "seed": 29546, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_2/index_867_seed_29546_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.009089500596746802, + "vlm_logprob": -0.009089500596746802, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.009089500596746802, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with crystal-clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a brook trout with an olive-green back and vibrant red spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the trout resting on a bed of smooth, rounded river rocks covered in deep green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the trout remain almost motionless with only minute adjustments to its pectoral and dorsal fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up with the camera moving slowly and gracefully around the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005361700896173716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.380361557006836 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005361700896173716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005361700896173716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22825880348682404, + 0.05273030325770378, + 0.2623966932296753, + 0.09033423662185669, + 0.02908092550933361, + 0.03758781775832176, + 0.08281990140676498, + 0.027656305581331253, + 0.07447510957717896, + 0.11465990543365479 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005361700896173716 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with crystal-clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a brook trout with an olive-green back and vibrant red spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the trout resting on a bed of smooth, rounded river rocks covered in deep green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the trout remain almost motionless with only minute adjustments to its pectoral and dorsal fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up with the camera moving slowly and gracefully around the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819257251918316 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018192768096924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819257251918316, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819257251918316, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14055472612380981, + 0.041630469262599945, + 0.372415155172348, + 0.08820898085832596, + 0.017244551330804825, + 0.07907429337501526, + 0.110688216984272, + 0.057502370327711105, + 0.040823258459568024, + 0.05185787007212639 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819257251918316 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with crystal-clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a brook trout with an olive-green back and vibrant red spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the trout resting on a bed of smooth, rounded river rocks covered in deep green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the trout remain almost motionless with only minute adjustments to its pectoral and dorsal fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up with the camera moving slowly and gracefully around the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004093007650226355 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504093170166016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004093007650226355, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004093007650226355, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12918131053447723, + 0.07042057812213898, + 0.26345908641815186, + 0.12072572112083435, + 0.13864566385746002, + 0.08025526255369186, + 0.03139282763004303, + 0.04704131931066513, + 0.046117234975099564, + 0.07276102900505066 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004093007650226355 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with crystal-clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a brook trout with an olive-green back and vibrant red spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the trout resting on a bed of smooth, rounded river rocks covered in deep green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the trout remain almost motionless with only minute adjustments to its pectoral and dorsal fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up with the camera moving slowly and gracefully around the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003614442190155387 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.62861442565918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003614442190155387, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003614442190155387, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23475401103496552, + 0.06037003919482231, + 0.21659652888774872, + 0.0627100020647049, + 0.057904087007045746, + 0.06634966284036636, + 0.14550265669822693, + 0.025312302634119987, + 0.06509698182344437, + 0.06540370732545853 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003614442190155387 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with crystal-clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a brook trout with an olive-green back and vibrant red spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the trout resting on a bed of smooth, rounded river rocks covered in deep green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the trout remain almost motionless with only minute adjustments to its pectoral and dorsal fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up with the camera moving slowly and gracefully around the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014185779727995396 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264185905456543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014185779727995396, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014185779727995396, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14174482226371765, + 0.055776823312044144, + 0.2651709318161011, + 0.062269944697618484, + 0.06570877879858017, + 0.05403383448719978, + 0.1083253026008606, + 0.08774489164352417, + 0.09023452550172806, + 0.06899011880159378 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014185779727995396 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An underwater medium close-up, rendered with hyper-real clarity, unfolds with a slow, graceful lens around a magnificent brook trout. The fish hangs almost motionless, its body a canvas of natural art: its olive-green back is intricately etched with unique, worm-like patterns, while its shimmering sides are dotted with vibrant red spots, each perfectly blurred against a delicate, ethereal blue. It rests serenely and steadily on a bed of smooth, rounded river rocks, its gray and brown surface softened by a carpet of deep green moss. The camera's deliberate movements capture the fish's minute, almost imperceptible adjustments to its pectoral and dorsal fins as it effortlessly maintains its position against the gentle, invisible current. Bright sunlight, penetrating the crystal-clear water from above, creates a mesmerizing ballet of patterns that ripple and shift across the trout's smooth scales and the mossy brook bottom, illuminating tiny particles drifting in the water. The atmosphere is one of profound stillness and focused peace, a genuine and captivating moment frozen in a pristine, sun-dappled aquatic world.", + "seed": 29547, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_2/index_867_seed_29547_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.015633660135790706, + "vlm_logprob": -0.015633660135790706, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.015633660135790706, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with crystal-clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a brook trout with an olive-green back and vibrant red spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the trout resting on a bed of smooth, rounded river rocks covered in deep green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the trout remain almost motionless with only minute adjustments to its pectoral and dorsal fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up with the camera moving slowly and gracefully around the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.027683231979608536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6526832580566406 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.027683231979608536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.027683231979608536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12780232727527618, + 0.03150153160095215, + 0.041902247816324234, + 0.13257932662963867, + 0.04359067231416702, + 0.02294035069644451, + 0.4955980181694031, + 0.0479896143078804, + 0.03493792563676834, + 0.021157991141080856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.027683231979608536 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with crystal-clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a brook trout with an olive-green back and vibrant red spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the trout resting on a bed of smooth, rounded river rocks covered in deep green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the trout remain almost motionless with only minute adjustments to its pectoral and dorsal fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up with the camera moving slowly and gracefully around the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016076931729912758 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141077041625977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016076931729912758, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016076931729912758, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34196269512176514, + 0.04488806426525116, + 0.12141808867454529, + 0.0909142941236496, + 0.026647254824638367, + 0.01596309430897236, + 0.11360298842191696, + 0.04421991482377052, + 0.08916211873292923, + 0.11122152209281921 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016076931729912758 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with crystal-clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a brook trout with an olive-green back and vibrant red spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the trout resting on a bed of smooth, rounded river rocks covered in deep green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the trout remain almost motionless with only minute adjustments to its pectoral and dorsal fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up with the camera moving slowly and gracefully around the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008639931678771973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758639812469482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008639931678771973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008639931678771973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25529351830482483, + 0.13890916109085083, + 0.036041051149368286, + 0.13368874788284302, + 0.07444248348474503, + 0.020390454679727554, + 0.12016496062278748, + 0.03383221477270126, + 0.026064017787575722, + 0.16117335855960846 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008639931678771973 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with crystal-clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a brook trout with an olive-green back and vibrant red spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the trout resting on a bed of smooth, rounded river rocks covered in deep green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the trout remain almost motionless with only minute adjustments to its pectoral and dorsal fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up with the camera moving slowly and gracefully around the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024895647075027227 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.0024895668029785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024895647075027227, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024895647075027227, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15168771147727966, + 0.06254799664020538, + 0.053280774503946304, + 0.08538822084665298, + 0.04889215901494026, + 0.0973835214972496, + 0.32786881923675537, + 0.06587480753660202, + 0.037013377994298935, + 0.07006260007619858 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024895647075027227 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with crystal-clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a brook trout with an olive-green back and vibrant red spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the trout resting on a bed of smooth, rounded river rocks covered in deep green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the trout remain almost motionless with only minute adjustments to its pectoral and dorsal fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up with the camera moving slowly and gracefully around the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02327864058315754 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732787132263184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02327864058315754, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02327864058315754, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1773296743631363, + 0.05681354179978371, + 0.03870195150375366, + 0.1870385706424713, + 0.060220155864953995, + 0.18228134512901306, + 0.06586973369121552, + 0.04218079894781113, + 0.10858635604381561, + 0.08097785711288452 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02327864058315754 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An underwater medium close-up, rendered with hyper-real clarity, unfolds with a slow, graceful lens around a magnificent brook trout. The fish hangs almost motionless, its body a canvas of natural art: its olive-green back is intricately etched with unique, worm-like patterns, while its shimmering sides are dotted with vibrant red spots, each perfectly blurred against a delicate, ethereal blue. It rests serenely and steadily on a bed of smooth, rounded river rocks, its gray and brown surface softened by a carpet of deep green moss. The camera's deliberate movements capture the fish's minute, almost imperceptible adjustments to its pectoral and dorsal fins as it effortlessly maintains its position against the gentle, invisible current. Bright sunlight, penetrating the crystal-clear water from above, creates a mesmerizing ballet of patterns that ripple and shift across the trout's smooth scales and the mossy brook bottom, illuminating tiny particles drifting in the water. The atmosphere is one of profound stillness and focused peace, a genuine and captivating moment frozen in a pristine, sun-dappled aquatic world.", + "seed": 29548, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_2/index_867_seed_29548_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.010959850996732712, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010959850996732712, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010959850996732712, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with crystal-clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a brook trout with an olive-green back and vibrant red spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the trout resting on a bed of smooth, rounded river rocks covered in deep green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the trout remain almost motionless with only minute adjustments to its pectoral and dorsal fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up with the camera moving slowly and gracefully around the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076646762900054455 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.132664680480957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076646762900054455, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076646762900054455, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11217646300792694, + 0.03521229699254036, + 0.03924377262592316, + 0.33887261152267456, + 0.048535432666540146, + 0.19043445587158203, + 0.08597701787948608, + 0.07133530080318451, + 0.04581869766116142, + 0.03239402547478676 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076646762900054455 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with crystal-clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a brook trout with an olive-green back and vibrant red spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the trout resting on a bed of smooth, rounded river rocks covered in deep green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the trout remain almost motionless with only minute adjustments to its pectoral and dorsal fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up with the camera moving slowly and gracefully around the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012547949329018593 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387547969818115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012547949329018593, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012547949329018593, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15540994703769684, + 0.05420432612299919, + 0.04960355907678604, + 0.08466231822967529, + 0.02363310568034649, + 0.032322075217962265, + 0.10096170008182526, + 0.3800327181816101, + 0.06385575979948044, + 0.05531454458832741 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012547949329018593 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with crystal-clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a brook trout with an olive-green back and vibrant red spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the trout resting on a bed of smooth, rounded river rocks covered in deep green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the trout remain almost motionless with only minute adjustments to its pectoral and dorsal fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up with the camera moving slowly and gracefully around the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046386257745325565 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379638671875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046386257745325565, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046386257745325565, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10206839442253113, + 0.10437599569559097, + 0.043610651046037674, + 0.23285400867462158, + 0.05674423277378082, + 0.14177203178405762, + 0.03488940745592117, + 0.1707623302936554, + 0.053558748215436935, + 0.05936421826481819 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046386257745325565 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with crystal-clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a brook trout with an olive-green back and vibrant red spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the trout resting on a bed of smooth, rounded river rocks covered in deep green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the trout remain almost motionless with only minute adjustments to its pectoral and dorsal fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up with the camera moving slowly and gracefully around the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036153923720121384 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628615379333496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036153923720121384, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036153923720121384, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06167195364832878, + 0.04295703396201134, + 0.04794105514883995, + 0.16056792438030243, + 0.04402763769030571, + 0.0505530908703804, + 0.05608104541897774, + 0.4022314250469208, + 0.09078222513198853, + 0.04318663105368614 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036153923720121384 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with crystal-clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a brook trout with an olive-green back and vibrant red spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the trout resting on a bed of smooth, rounded river rocks covered in deep green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the trout remain almost motionless with only minute adjustments to its pectoral and dorsal fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up with the camera moving slowly and gracefully around the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026332611218094826 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513326168060303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026332611218094826, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026332611218094826, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0835455134510994, + 0.042258333414793015, + 0.03917262703180313, + 0.14381824433803558, + 0.049254681915044785, + 0.1885388046503067, + 0.07733042538166046, + 0.28574204444885254, + 0.062406908720731735, + 0.027932344004511833 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026332611218094826 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An underwater medium close-up, rendered with hyper-real clarity, unfolds with a slow, graceful lens around a magnificent brook trout. The fish hangs almost motionless, its body a canvas of natural art: its olive-green back is intricately etched with unique, worm-like patterns, while its shimmering sides are dotted with vibrant red spots, each perfectly blurred against a delicate, ethereal blue. It rests serenely and steadily on a bed of smooth, rounded river rocks, its gray and brown surface softened by a carpet of deep green moss. The camera's deliberate movements capture the fish's minute, almost imperceptible adjustments to its pectoral and dorsal fins as it effortlessly maintains its position against the gentle, invisible current. Bright sunlight, penetrating the crystal-clear water from above, creates a mesmerizing ballet of patterns that ripple and shift across the trout's smooth scales and the mossy brook bottom, illuminating tiny particles drifting in the water. The atmosphere is one of profound stillness and focused peace, a genuine and captivating moment frozen in a pristine, sun-dappled aquatic world.", + "seed": 29549, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_2/index_867_seed_29549_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.013718317076563836, + "vlm_logprob": -0.013718317076563836, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.013718317076563836, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with crystal-clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a brook trout with an olive-green back and vibrant red spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the trout resting on a bed of smooth, rounded river rocks covered in deep green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the trout remain almost motionless with only minute adjustments to its pectoral and dorsal fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up with the camera moving slowly and gracefully around the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013723897747695446 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.388723850250244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013723897747695446, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013723897747695446, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13080644607543945, + 0.04228445515036583, + 0.1046341061592102, + 0.09789088368415833, + 0.11882402747869492, + 0.11276503652334213, + 0.182255819439888, + 0.03711633384227753, + 0.00887235440313816, + 0.1645505428314209 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013723897747695446 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with crystal-clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a brook trout with an olive-green back and vibrant red spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the trout resting on a bed of smooth, rounded river rocks covered in deep green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the trout remain almost motionless with only minute adjustments to its pectoral and dorsal fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up with the camera moving slowly and gracefully around the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023295294493436813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732954025268555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023295294493436813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023295294493436813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29234516620635986, + 0.10372578352689743, + 0.04763411357998848, + 0.12294762581586838, + 0.04638445004820824, + 0.05388248711824417, + 0.1664859801530838, + 0.04940366744995117, + 0.06632981449365616, + 0.05086091533303261 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023295294493436813 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with crystal-clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a brook trout with an olive-green back and vibrant red spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the trout resting on a bed of smooth, rounded river rocks covered in deep green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the trout remain almost motionless with only minute adjustments to its pectoral and dorsal fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up with the camera moving slowly and gracefully around the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009780935011804104 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347808837890625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009780935011804104, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009780935011804104, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13217009603977203, + 0.05574142560362816, + 0.06923072040081024, + 0.16257402300834656, + 0.04976025968790054, + 0.062311116605997086, + 0.37743550539016724, + 0.021370306611061096, + 0.03619531914591789, + 0.033211223781108856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009780935011804104 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with crystal-clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a brook trout with an olive-green back and vibrant red spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the trout resting on a bed of smooth, rounded river rocks covered in deep green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the trout remain almost motionless with only minute adjustments to its pectoral and dorsal fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up with the camera moving slowly and gracefully around the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036153923720121384 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628615379333496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036153923720121384, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036153923720121384, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09208744019269943, + 0.04578999802470207, + 0.0823136493563652, + 0.04502200335264206, + 0.020579462870955467, + 0.12467191368341446, + 0.3894442915916443, + 0.06770797818899155, + 0.04145127907395363, + 0.09093202650547028 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036153923720121384 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with crystal-clear water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a brook trout with an olive-green back and vibrant red spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the trout resting on a bed of smooth, rounded river rocks covered in deep green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the trout remain almost motionless with only minute adjustments to its pectoral and dorsal fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up with the camera moving slowly and gracefully around the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018176065757870674 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018176078796387 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018176065757870674, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018176065757870674, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07016928493976593, + 0.02502439357340336, + 0.03722195327281952, + 0.14489765465259552, + 0.061247531324625015, + 0.06581217795610428, + 0.2747247517108917, + 0.039138149470090866, + 0.05076061561703682, + 0.231003537774086 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018176065757870674 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_3/index_tensor([6174, 6174])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_3/index_tensor([6174, 6174])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a9772eec2e4d0fe99542f7d3daf4fa2460ad3c5d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_3/index_tensor([6174, 6174])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow-motion, low-angle shot zooms in on a city basketball court surrounded by a high, rusty barbed wire fence. In the center of the frame, two sweat-drenched teenagers engage in a fierce standoff. The boy in the foreground, with tanned skin and short, close-cropped black hair, wears a sweat-soaked, dark blue sleeveless basketball vest that clings to his heaving chest and muscular build. His jaw set, his eyes piercing like a hawk, he stands with his hands on his hips, leaning slightly forward in an aggressive stance. The other boy confronting him wears an equally drenched white vest, his bangs clinging to his forehead with sweat. His arms are crossed over his chest, his posture erect, his gaze firm and unyielding. The golden afterglow of the setting sun streams in at a sharp angle, filtering through the bars of the barbed wire fence and casting long, interlaced shadows on the cracked asphalt. The light outlines their youthful, powerful figures and illuminates every bead of sweat on their skin. The air seemed to freeze, the dilapidated red brick apartment building in the background became blurred, and all the focus was on the invisible space between the two teenagers, which was full of charge. Every breath in their chests and every silent exchange of eyes filled the whole scene with primitive competitive tension and a dramatic atmosphere that was about to break out.", + "seed": 3010, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_3/index_6174_seed_3010_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.38034006031230094, + "vlm_logprob": -0.38034006031230094, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.38034006031230094, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and zooming in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two sweat-drenched teenagers visible in a standoff in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy in the foreground wearing a dark blue sleeveless basketball vest and has short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the other boy wearing a white vest with his arms crossed over his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7718583941459656 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6468583941459656 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7718583941459656, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7718583941459656, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1838778257369995, + 0.14386719465255737, + 0.03167736902832985, + 0.13454385101795197, + 0.06786654889583588, + 0.17086726427078247, + 0.05543752759695053, + 0.07112018018960953, + 0.054437048733234406, + 0.08630520105361938 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7718583941459656 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and zooming in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two sweat-drenched teenagers visible in a standoff in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy in the foreground wearing a dark blue sleeveless basketball vest and has short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the other boy wearing a white vest with his arms crossed over his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.053911566734314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289115369319916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.053911566734314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.053911566734314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1691463142633438, + 0.06924581527709961, + 0.04390264302492142, + 0.10922074317932129, + 0.07998044043779373, + 0.12930886447429657, + 0.03711923584342003, + 0.0934496596455574, + 0.12240172177553177, + 0.14622455835342407 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.053911566734314 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and zooming in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two sweat-drenched teenagers visible in a standoff in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy in the foreground wearing a dark blue sleeveless basketball vest and has short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the other boy wearing a white vest with his arms crossed over his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978990737348795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634789943695068 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978990737348795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978990737348795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20391209423542023, + 0.07513093948364258, + 0.060284096747636795, + 0.25673288106918335, + 0.14611995220184326, + 0.09049773216247559, + 0.0352880135178566, + 0.052494022995233536, + 0.049666814506053925, + 0.029873501509428024 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978990737348795 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and zooming in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two sweat-drenched teenagers visible in a standoff in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy in the foreground wearing a dark blue sleeveless basketball vest and has short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the other boy wearing a white vest with his arms crossed over his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004097638186067343 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5040974617004395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004097638186067343, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004097638186067343, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10302853584289551, + 0.0893346294760704, + 0.08492682874202728, + 0.06481879949569702, + 0.15239828824996948, + 0.08229038864374161, + 0.03960816562175751, + 0.10167595744132996, + 0.17937588691711426, + 0.10254247486591339 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004097638186067343 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and zooming in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two sweat-drenched teenagers visible in a standoff in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy in the foreground wearing a dark blue sleeveless basketball vest and has short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the other boy wearing a white vest with his arms crossed over his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204279512166977 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812042713165283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204279512166977, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204279512166977, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1243436336517334, + 0.04301084578037262, + 0.05556679144501686, + 0.1420740932226181, + 0.21868270635604858, + 0.20146822929382324, + 0.06870801746845245, + 0.06886015832424164, + 0.031248269602656364, + 0.04603729397058487 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204279512166977 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion, low-angle shot zooms in on a city basketball court surrounded by a high, rusty barbed wire fence. In the center of the frame, two sweat-drenched teenagers engage in a fierce standoff. The boy in the foreground, with tanned skin and short, close-cropped black hair, wears a sweat-soaked, dark blue sleeveless basketball vest that clings to his heaving chest and muscular build. His jaw set, his eyes piercing like a hawk, he stands with his hands on his hips, leaning slightly forward in an aggressive stance. The other boy confronting him wears an equally drenched white vest, his bangs clinging to his forehead with sweat. His arms are crossed over his chest, his posture erect, his gaze firm and unyielding. The golden afterglow of the setting sun streams in at a sharp angle, filtering through the bars of the barbed wire fence and casting long, interlaced shadows on the cracked asphalt. The light outlines their youthful, powerful figures and illuminates every bead of sweat on their skin. The air seemed to freeze, the dilapidated red brick apartment building in the background became blurred, and all the focus was on the invisible space between the two teenagers, which was full of charge. Every breath in their chests and every silent exchange of eyes filled the whole scene with primitive competitive tension and a dramatic atmosphere that was about to break out.", + "seed": 3011, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_3/index_6174_seed_3011_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.3276961140334606, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3276961140334606, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3276961140334606, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and zooming in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two sweat-drenched teenagers visible in a standoff in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy in the foreground wearing a dark blue sleeveless basketball vest and has short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the other boy wearing a white vest with his arms crossed over his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7912864089012146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6662864089012146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7912864089012146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7912864089012146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5057050585746765, + 0.14724723994731903, + 0.03306537866592407, + 0.040064290165901184, + 0.02519729919731617, + 0.020248711109161377, + 0.051211751997470856, + 0.07326159626245499, + 0.0664563924074173, + 0.037542276084423065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7912864089012146 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and zooming in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two sweat-drenched teenagers visible in a standoff in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy in the foreground wearing a dark blue sleeveless basketball vest and has short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the other boy wearing a white vest with his arms crossed over his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.757854163646698 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.632854163646698 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.757854163646698, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.757854163646698, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4111391603946686, + 0.09801191836595535, + 0.04697492718696594, + 0.04053772985935211, + 0.06170746311545372, + 0.035917893052101135, + 0.0674596056342125, + 0.06324776262044907, + 0.06276476383209229, + 0.1122387945652008 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.757854163646698 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and zooming in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two sweat-drenched teenagers visible in a standoff in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy in the foreground wearing a dark blue sleeveless basketball vest and has short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the other boy wearing a white vest with his arms crossed over his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023297857493162155 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732977867126465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023297857493162155, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023297857493162155, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14360107481479645, + 0.19774967432022095, + 0.08696747571229935, + 0.08449897170066833, + 0.07365013659000397, + 0.043743960559368134, + 0.13444162905216217, + 0.031965240836143494, + 0.1177048459649086, + 0.08567705750465393 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023297857493162155 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and zooming in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two sweat-drenched teenagers visible in a standoff in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy in the foreground wearing a dark blue sleeveless basketball vest and has short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the other boy wearing a white vest with his arms crossed over his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011088181287050247 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110883712768555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011088181287050247, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011088181287050247, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.110772505402565, + 0.22613456845283508, + 0.06851863861083984, + 0.08885356038808823, + 0.084715336561203, + 0.05399145558476448, + 0.17451071739196777, + 0.023243822157382965, + 0.08347723633050919, + 0.08578214049339294 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011088181287050247 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and zooming in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two sweat-drenched teenagers visible in a standoff in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy in the foreground wearing a dark blue sleeveless basketball vest and has short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the other boy wearing a white vest with his arms crossed over his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054953958839178085 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299540519714355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054953958839178085, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054953958839178085, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12042955309152603, + 0.20888608694076538, + 0.07066258788108826, + 0.0449359267950058, + 0.08326127380132675, + 0.08231549710035324, + 0.03994976729154587, + 0.06522323936223984, + 0.07926435768604279, + 0.20507167279720306 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054953958839178085 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion, low-angle shot zooms in on a city basketball court surrounded by a high, rusty barbed wire fence. In the center of the frame, two sweat-drenched teenagers engage in a fierce standoff. The boy in the foreground, with tanned skin and short, close-cropped black hair, wears a sweat-soaked, dark blue sleeveless basketball vest that clings to his heaving chest and muscular build. His jaw set, his eyes piercing like a hawk, he stands with his hands on his hips, leaning slightly forward in an aggressive stance. The other boy confronting him wears an equally drenched white vest, his bangs clinging to his forehead with sweat. His arms are crossed over his chest, his posture erect, his gaze firm and unyielding. The golden afterglow of the setting sun streams in at a sharp angle, filtering through the bars of the barbed wire fence and casting long, interlaced shadows on the cracked asphalt. The light outlines their youthful, powerful figures and illuminates every bead of sweat on their skin. The air seemed to freeze, the dilapidated red brick apartment building in the background became blurred, and all the focus was on the invisible space between the two teenagers, which was full of charge. Every breath in their chests and every silent exchange of eyes filled the whole scene with primitive competitive tension and a dramatic atmosphere that was about to break out.", + "seed": 3012, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_3/index_6174_seed_3012_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.27827639421448114, + "vlm_logprob": -0.27827639421448114, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.27827639421448114, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and zooming in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two sweat-drenched teenagers visible in a standoff in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy in the foreground wearing a dark blue sleeveless basketball vest and has short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the other boy wearing a white vest with his arms crossed over his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7903916239738464 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6653916239738464 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7903916239738464, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7903916239738464, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16509079933166504, + 0.09359440952539444, + 0.0421907939016819, + 0.08260956406593323, + 0.18096698820590973, + 0.04233440384268761, + 0.06327694654464722, + 0.04202049970626831, + 0.038899995386600494, + 0.2490156590938568 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7903916239738464 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and zooming in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two sweat-drenched teenagers visible in a standoff in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy in the foreground wearing a dark blue sleeveless basketball vest and has short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the other boy wearing a white vest with his arms crossed over his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761978626251221 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261978626251221 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761978626251221, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761978626251221, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16703782975673676, + 0.054126352071762085, + 0.03588254749774933, + 0.12247679382562637, + 0.2367793768644333, + 0.12927600741386414, + 0.07773317396640778, + 0.03782828897237778, + 0.027697406709194183, + 0.11116226017475128 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761978626251221 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and zooming in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two sweat-drenched teenagers visible in a standoff in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy in the foreground wearing a dark blue sleeveless basketball vest and has short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the other boy wearing a white vest with his arms crossed over his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005956872832030058 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130956649780273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005956872832030058, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005956872832030058, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1543581783771515, + 0.07998304069042206, + 0.03611994907259941, + 0.054286811500787735, + 0.0500328429043293, + 0.0663149431347847, + 0.024216972291469574, + 0.05211467295885086, + 0.06325216591358185, + 0.4193204343318939 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005956872832030058 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and zooming in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two sweat-drenched teenagers visible in a standoff in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy in the foreground wearing a dark blue sleeveless basketball vest and has short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the other boy wearing a white vest with his arms crossed over his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00464289728552103 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379642963409424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00464289728552103, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00464289728552103, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11828383058309555, + 0.08764141798019409, + 0.07441329210996628, + 0.08466983586549759, + 0.37366238236427307, + 0.03653038665652275, + 0.028670474886894226, + 0.0503004714846611, + 0.05157024785876274, + 0.09425767511129379 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00464289728552103 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and zooming in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two sweat-drenched teenagers visible in a standoff in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy in the foreground wearing a dark blue sleeveless basketball vest and has short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the other boy wearing a white vest with his arms crossed over his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014192714355885983 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264192581176758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014192714355885983, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014192714355885983, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12892252206802368, + 0.060244303196668625, + 0.038426902145147324, + 0.07965293526649475, + 0.05175841599702835, + 0.06164459511637688, + 0.0322166308760643, + 0.0888618752360344, + 0.14780642092227936, + 0.31046542525291443 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014192714355885983 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion, low-angle shot zooms in on a city basketball court surrounded by a high, rusty barbed wire fence. In the center of the frame, two sweat-drenched teenagers engage in a fierce standoff. The boy in the foreground, with tanned skin and short, close-cropped black hair, wears a sweat-soaked, dark blue sleeveless basketball vest that clings to his heaving chest and muscular build. His jaw set, his eyes piercing like a hawk, he stands with his hands on his hips, leaning slightly forward in an aggressive stance. The other boy confronting him wears an equally drenched white vest, his bangs clinging to his forehead with sweat. His arms are crossed over his chest, his posture erect, his gaze firm and unyielding. The golden afterglow of the setting sun streams in at a sharp angle, filtering through the bars of the barbed wire fence and casting long, interlaced shadows on the cracked asphalt. The light outlines their youthful, powerful figures and illuminates every bead of sweat on their skin. The air seemed to freeze, the dilapidated red brick apartment building in the background became blurred, and all the focus was on the invisible space between the two teenagers, which was full of charge. Every breath in their chests and every silent exchange of eyes filled the whole scene with primitive competitive tension and a dramatic atmosphere that was about to break out.", + "seed": 3013, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_3/index_6174_seed_3013_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.25282674059271815, + "vlm_logprob": -0.25282674059271815, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.25282674059271815, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and zooming in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two sweat-drenched teenagers visible in a standoff in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy in the foreground wearing a dark blue sleeveless basketball vest and has short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the other boy wearing a white vest with his arms crossed over his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.601898193359375 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.851898193359375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.601898193359375, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.601898193359375, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25623825192451477, + 0.40174564719200134, + 0.04817806929349899, + 0.063265860080719, + 0.039403948932886124, + 0.02569667622447014, + 0.032503608614206314, + 0.032195404171943665, + 0.033752720803022385, + 0.06701984256505966 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.601898193359375 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and zooming in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two sweat-drenched teenagers visible in a standoff in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy in the foreground wearing a dark blue sleeveless basketball vest and has short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the other boy wearing a white vest with his arms crossed over his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233912467956543 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983912467956543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233912467956543, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233912467956543, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18326106667518616, + 0.07436200976371765, + 0.08342943340539932, + 0.11004596203565598, + 0.10296225547790527, + 0.06994137912988663, + 0.11649539321660995, + 0.10542479902505875, + 0.049685023725032806, + 0.10439267754554749 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233912467956543 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and zooming in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two sweat-drenched teenagers visible in a standoff in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy in the foreground wearing a dark blue sleeveless basketball vest and has short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the other boy wearing a white vest with his arms crossed over his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043068308383226395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680684089660645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043068308383226395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043068308383226395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2477860301733017, + 0.20643462240695953, + 0.1258312314748764, + 0.056760091334581375, + 0.05766260623931885, + 0.04501734673976898, + 0.05447032302618027, + 0.06979650259017944, + 0.0450536273419857, + 0.09118763357400894 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043068308383226395 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and zooming in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two sweat-drenched teenagers visible in a standoff in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy in the foreground wearing a dark blue sleeveless basketball vest and has short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the other boy wearing a white vest with his arms crossed over his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006742820143699646 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00674295425415 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006742820143699646, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006742820143699646, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22650831937789917, + 0.30649104714393616, + 0.04945259913802147, + 0.10264677554368973, + 0.04118404537439346, + 0.03451875224709511, + 0.045906584709882736, + 0.07209702581167221, + 0.06176401674747467, + 0.05943089351058006 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006742820143699646 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and zooming in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are two sweat-drenched teenagers visible in a standoff in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy in the foreground wearing a dark blue sleeveless basketball vest and has short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the other boy wearing a white vest with his arms crossed over his chest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08903313428163528 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640331268310547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08903313428163528, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08903313428163528, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35379520058631897, + 0.09977732598781586, + 0.12039725482463837, + 0.08344842493534088, + 0.07537097483873367, + 0.0482691153883934, + 0.0331420861184597, + 0.08579252660274506, + 0.04301268607378006, + 0.05699445679783821 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08903313428163528 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_4/index_tensor([2579, 2579])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_4/index_tensor([2579, 2579])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0fb25971adb9b07be5184ded1137b870f2e395ef --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_4/index_tensor([2579, 2579])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In the hyper-detailed and emotionally resonant Makoto Shinkai style, a low-angle tracking shot slowly slides from left to right, parallel to a dense row of evening primroses. The camera, positioned high above the ground, allows the blossoms to appear heroic against a breathtakingly saturated twilight sky, which melts from a deep, star-studded indigo at the summit to a vibrant purplish-red, ultimately bursting into a fiery orange glow on the distant horizon. As the camera moves, a magical, rapid-fire time-lapse sequence is triggered; the tightly closed green buds of the evening primroses tremble, then unfold with a smooth, accelerated grace. Their delicate, paper-thin yellow petals peel back to reveal the intricate stamens within, the entire movement imbued with a sense of life and wonder. Each newly opened flower catches the last traces of daylight, giving its edges an intense, warm glow. This light refracts through the lens, creating the signature soft, ethereal, anamorphic lens flare that sweeps horizontally across the frame, bathing the scene in a dreamy, poignant atmosphere and capturing a fleeting moment of sublime beauty.", + "seed": 64, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_4/index_2579_seed_64_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.19712620750069618, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19712620750069618, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19712620750069618, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are evening primroses visible as the main subject in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from deep indigo at the top to purplish-red and finally fiery orange at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the green buds of the evening primroses open rapidly in a time-lapse sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot sliding from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a soft, ethereal, anamorphic lens flare sweeping horizontally across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.045857928693294525 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1708579063415527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.045857928693294525, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.045857928693294525, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1569148302078247, + 0.07701559364795685, + 0.06945131719112396, + 0.025250021368265152, + 0.04507244750857353, + 0.06647622585296631, + 0.16954238712787628, + 0.052696000784635544, + 0.2928750813007355, + 0.04470611363649368 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.045857928693294525 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are evening primroses visible as the main subject in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from deep indigo at the top to purplish-red and finally fiery orange at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the green buds of the evening primroses open rapidly in a time-lapse sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot sliding from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a soft, ethereal, anamorphic lens flare sweeping horizontally across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02060554549098015 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956055641174316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02060554549098015, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02060554549098015, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06293278187513351, + 0.46983423829078674, + 0.04211069643497467, + 0.008364097215235233, + 0.01499195396900177, + 0.013729222118854523, + 0.06276267766952515, + 0.25936567783355713, + 0.04955826327204704, + 0.016350364312529564 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02060554549098015 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are evening primroses visible as the main subject in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from deep indigo at the top to purplish-red and finally fiery orange at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the green buds of the evening primroses open rapidly in a time-lapse sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot sliding from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a soft, ethereal, anamorphic lens flare sweeping horizontally across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054958585649728775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299585819244385 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054958585649728775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054958585649728775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12350334227085114, + 0.033456623554229736, + 0.04733707383275032, + 0.022875552996993065, + 0.03935432434082031, + 0.03466188162565231, + 0.01979665644466877, + 0.09600190818309784, + 0.557661235332489, + 0.025351401418447495 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054958585649728775 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are evening primroses visible as the main subject in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from deep indigo at the top to purplish-red and finally fiery orange at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the green buds of the evening primroses open rapidly in a time-lapse sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot sliding from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a soft, ethereal, anamorphic lens flare sweeping horizontally across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261024951934814 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761024951934814 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8261024951934814, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8261024951934814, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10327843576669693, + 0.14786796271800995, + 0.03225655481219292, + 0.025128211826086044, + 0.032120924443006516, + 0.03597144037485123, + 0.30182361602783203, + 0.05785813927650452, + 0.24250178039073944, + 0.021192941814661026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8261024951934814 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are evening primroses visible as the main subject in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from deep indigo at the top to purplish-red and finally fiery orange at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the green buds of the evening primroses open rapidly in a time-lapse sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot sliding from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a soft, ethereal, anamorphic lens flare sweeping horizontally across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810648247599602 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881064414978027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810648247599602, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810648247599602, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08403422683477402, + 0.10479050874710083, + 0.034499574452638626, + 0.017888285219669342, + 0.017046460881829262, + 0.015437377616763115, + 0.039490584284067154, + 0.04884393513202667, + 0.5986865162849426, + 0.03928247466683388 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810648247599602 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the hyper-detailed and emotionally resonant Makoto Shinkai style, a low-angle tracking shot slowly slides from left to right, parallel to a dense row of evening primroses. The camera, positioned high above the ground, allows the blossoms to appear heroic against a breathtakingly saturated twilight sky, which melts from a deep, star-studded indigo at the summit to a vibrant purplish-red, ultimately bursting into a fiery orange glow on the distant horizon. As the camera moves, a magical, rapid-fire time-lapse sequence is triggered; the tightly closed green buds of the evening primroses tremble, then unfold with a smooth, accelerated grace. Their delicate, paper-thin yellow petals peel back to reveal the intricate stamens within, the entire movement imbued with a sense of life and wonder. Each newly opened flower catches the last traces of daylight, giving its edges an intense, warm glow. This light refracts through the lens, creating the signature soft, ethereal, anamorphic lens flare that sweeps horizontally across the frame, bathing the scene in a dreamy, poignant atmosphere and capturing a fleeting moment of sublime beauty.", + "seed": 65, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_4/index_2579_seed_65_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.12260262127965689, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12260262127965689, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12260262127965689, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are evening primroses visible as the main subject in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from deep indigo at the top to purplish-red and finally fiery orange at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the green buds of the evening primroses open rapidly in a time-lapse sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot sliding from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a soft, ethereal, anamorphic lens flare sweeping horizontally across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0941837951540947 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4691836833953857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0941837951540947, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0941837951540947, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5746997594833374, + 0.04709051176905632, + 0.031067868694663048, + 0.02495616488158703, + 0.06115926057100296, + 0.104302778840065, + 0.0460188165307045, + 0.06165570020675659, + 0.03775746747851372, + 0.011291691102087498 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0941837951540947 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are evening primroses visible as the main subject in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from deep indigo at the top to purplish-red and finally fiery orange at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the green buds of the evening primroses open rapidly in a time-lapse sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot sliding from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a soft, ethereal, anamorphic lens flare sweeping horizontally across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014221861027181149 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264221668243408 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014221861027181149, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014221861027181149, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.8600589632987976, + 0.017647502943873405, + 0.016541339457035065, + 0.012911567464470863, + 0.011744927614927292, + 0.019722264260053635, + 0.014385438524186611, + 0.021141313016414642, + 0.009419428184628487, + 0.01642724499106407 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014221861027181149 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are evening primroses visible as the main subject in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from deep indigo at the top to purplish-red and finally fiery orange at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the green buds of the evening primroses open rapidly in a time-lapse sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot sliding from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a soft, ethereal, anamorphic lens flare sweeping horizontally across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11293639242649078 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237936496734619 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11293639242649078, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11293639242649078, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21204887330532074, + 0.06014605239033699, + 0.06919434666633606, + 0.0343378521502018, + 0.16644734144210815, + 0.16579478979110718, + 0.22099344432353973, + 0.034059084951877594, + 0.01561908982694149, + 0.021359141916036606 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11293639242649078 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are evening primroses visible as the main subject in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from deep indigo at the top to purplish-red and finally fiery orange at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the green buds of the evening primroses open rapidly in a time-lapse sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot sliding from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a soft, ethereal, anamorphic lens flare sweeping horizontally across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486049175262451 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236049175262451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486049175262451, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486049175262451, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6427489519119263, + 0.04187902808189392, + 0.015303223393857479, + 0.04529297724366188, + 0.054237816482782364, + 0.1138548031449318, + 0.03468996286392212, + 0.010100161656737328, + 0.0318169966340065, + 0.01007611583918333 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486049175262451 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are evening primroses visible as the main subject in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from deep indigo at the top to purplish-red and finally fiery orange at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the green buds of the evening primroses open rapidly in a time-lapse sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot sliding from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a soft, ethereal, anamorphic lens flare sweeping horizontally across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306614026427269 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680660247802734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306614026427269, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306614026427269, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5407909154891968, + 0.01849997602403164, + 0.0210567694157362, + 0.020217545330524445, + 0.04687939211726189, + 0.03552703559398651, + 0.23253750801086426, + 0.015286527574062347, + 0.022893261164426804, + 0.046311091631650925 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306614026427269 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the hyper-detailed and emotionally resonant Makoto Shinkai style, a low-angle tracking shot slowly slides from left to right, parallel to a dense row of evening primroses. The camera, positioned high above the ground, allows the blossoms to appear heroic against a breathtakingly saturated twilight sky, which melts from a deep, star-studded indigo at the summit to a vibrant purplish-red, ultimately bursting into a fiery orange glow on the distant horizon. As the camera moves, a magical, rapid-fire time-lapse sequence is triggered; the tightly closed green buds of the evening primroses tremble, then unfold with a smooth, accelerated grace. Their delicate, paper-thin yellow petals peel back to reveal the intricate stamens within, the entire movement imbued with a sense of life and wonder. Each newly opened flower catches the last traces of daylight, giving its edges an intense, warm glow. This light refracts through the lens, creating the signature soft, ethereal, anamorphic lens flare that sweeps horizontally across the frame, bathing the scene in a dreamy, poignant atmosphere and capturing a fleeting moment of sublime beauty.", + "seed": 66, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_4/index_2579_seed_66_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10064061880111694, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10064061880111694, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.999999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10064061880111694, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are evening primroses visible as the main subject in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from deep indigo at the top to purplish-red and finally fiery orange at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the green buds of the evening primroses open rapidly in a time-lapse sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot sliding from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a soft, ethereal, anamorphic lens flare sweeping horizontally across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0394391268491745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2894392013549805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0394391268491745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0394391268491745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1684088259935379, + 0.09040750563144684, + 0.06178958714008331, + 0.19448842108249664, + 0.16231876611709595, + 0.02965313009917736, + 0.02625950612127781, + 0.026007240638136864, + 0.027650220319628716, + 0.2130167931318283 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0394391268491745 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are evening primroses visible as the main subject in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from deep indigo at the top to purplish-red and finally fiery orange at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the green buds of the evening primroses open rapidly in a time-lapse sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot sliding from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a soft, ethereal, anamorphic lens flare sweeping horizontally across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02636825665831566 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513681411743164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02636825665831566, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02636825665831566, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2198265939950943, + 0.4209446310997009, + 0.049487270414829254, + 0.06755329668521881, + 0.05210959166288376, + 0.024600714445114136, + 0.0573277622461319, + 0.0667804703116417, + 0.019140396267175674, + 0.022229330614209175 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02636825665831566 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are evening primroses visible as the main subject in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from deep indigo at the top to purplish-red and finally fiery orange at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the green buds of the evening primroses open rapidly in a time-lapse sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot sliding from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a soft, ethereal, anamorphic lens flare sweeping horizontally across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020581021904945374 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895581007003784 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020581021904945374, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020581021904945374, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2922742962837219, + 0.2124033272266388, + 0.10681281983852386, + 0.06488525122404099, + 0.0675552561879158, + 0.018416794016957283, + 0.0322297140955925, + 0.0553884357213974, + 0.026409609243273735, + 0.1236245334148407 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020581021904945374 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are evening primroses visible as the main subject in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from deep indigo at the top to purplish-red and finally fiery orange at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the green buds of the evening primroses open rapidly in a time-lapse sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot sliding from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a soft, ethereal, anamorphic lens flare sweeping horizontally across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.387012779712677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370127201080322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.387012779712677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.387012779712677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16191378235816956, + 0.1379953771829605, + 0.13732881844043732, + 0.08806805312633514, + 0.04805383086204529, + 0.13299420475959778, + 0.19591322541236877, + 0.027675895020365715, + 0.016750240698456764, + 0.053306568413972855 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.387012779712677 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are evening primroses visible as the main subject in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from deep indigo at the top to purplish-red and finally fiery orange at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the green buds of the evening primroses open rapidly in a time-lapse sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot sliding from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a soft, ethereal, anamorphic lens flare sweeping horizontally across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029801908880472183 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529801845550537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029801908880472183, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029801908880472183, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.444366991519928, + 0.17157593369483948, + 0.04823929816484451, + 0.04088311269879341, + 0.10015497356653214, + 0.02949906326830387, + 0.053675998002290726, + 0.06009745970368385, + 0.020378559827804565, + 0.03112865798175335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029801908880472183 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the hyper-detailed and emotionally resonant Makoto Shinkai style, a low-angle tracking shot slowly slides from left to right, parallel to a dense row of evening primroses. The camera, positioned high above the ground, allows the blossoms to appear heroic against a breathtakingly saturated twilight sky, which melts from a deep, star-studded indigo at the summit to a vibrant purplish-red, ultimately bursting into a fiery orange glow on the distant horizon. As the camera moves, a magical, rapid-fire time-lapse sequence is triggered; the tightly closed green buds of the evening primroses tremble, then unfold with a smooth, accelerated grace. Their delicate, paper-thin yellow petals peel back to reveal the intricate stamens within, the entire movement imbued with a sense of life and wonder. Each newly opened flower catches the last traces of daylight, giving its edges an intense, warm glow. This light refracts through the lens, creating the signature soft, ethereal, anamorphic lens flare that sweeps horizontally across the frame, bathing the scene in a dreamy, poignant atmosphere and capturing a fleeting moment of sublime beauty.", + "seed": 67, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_4/index_2579_seed_67_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.12027034554630518, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12027034554630518, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12027034554630518, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are evening primroses visible as the main subject in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from deep indigo at the top to purplish-red and finally fiery orange at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the green buds of the evening primroses open rapidly in a time-lapse sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot sliding from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a soft, ethereal, anamorphic lens flare sweeping horizontally across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023067813366651535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8980677127838135 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023067813366651535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023067813366651535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10291064530611038, + 0.058030735701322556, + 0.10759913921356201, + 0.07159695029258728, + 0.15596075356006622, + 0.11969934403896332, + 0.09450258314609528, + 0.11483772844076157, + 0.06780476123094559, + 0.10705732554197311 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023067813366651535 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are evening primroses visible as the main subject in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from deep indigo at the top to purplish-red and finally fiery orange at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the green buds of the evening primroses open rapidly in a time-lapse sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot sliding from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a soft, ethereal, anamorphic lens flare sweeping horizontally across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012556425295770168 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387556552886963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012556425295770168, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012556425295770168, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22361566126346588, + 0.06498534977436066, + 0.032029785215854645, + 0.029799794778227806, + 0.030036045238375664, + 0.06582722812891006, + 0.10294453799724579, + 0.0709739625453949, + 0.09799642115831375, + 0.28179121017456055 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012556425295770168 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are evening primroses visible as the main subject in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from deep indigo at the top to purplish-red and finally fiery orange at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the green buds of the evening primroses open rapidly in a time-lapse sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot sliding from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a soft, ethereal, anamorphic lens flare sweeping horizontally across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026347937062382698 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513478755950928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026347937062382698, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026347937062382698, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19309501349925995, + 0.10220407694578171, + 0.10232125222682953, + 0.05734899640083313, + 0.07848063856363297, + 0.05945563316345215, + 0.193587988615036, + 0.11101909726858139, + 0.040209002792835236, + 0.06227820739150047 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026347937062382698 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are evening primroses visible as the main subject in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from deep indigo at the top to purplish-red and finally fiery orange at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the green buds of the evening primroses open rapidly in a time-lapse sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot sliding from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a soft, ethereal, anamorphic lens flare sweeping horizontally across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233029723167419 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983029723167419 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233029723167419, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233029723167419, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09692751616239548, + 0.04940475523471832, + 0.03448116034269333, + 0.05113077163696289, + 0.07404118031263351, + 0.09936632961034775, + 0.05298261716961861, + 0.054467834532260895, + 0.17316555976867676, + 0.31403225660324097 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233029723167419 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are evening primroses visible as the main subject in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from deep indigo at the top to purplish-red and finally fiery orange at the horizon?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the green buds of the evening primroses open rapidly in a time-lapse sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot sliding from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a soft, ethereal, anamorphic lens flare sweeping horizontally across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016076579689979553 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141076564788818 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016076579689979553, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016076579689979553, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10533241927623749, + 0.051659613847732544, + 0.04812292754650116, + 0.044387537986040115, + 0.033995844423770905, + 0.050716333091259, + 0.05884687229990959, + 0.05969832465052605, + 0.14274907112121582, + 0.40449103713035583 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016076579689979553 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_5/index_tensor([267, 267])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_5/index_tensor([267, 267])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1a72fc79c8281a9f84442fd49d1d940b71389d8e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_5/index_tensor([267, 267])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from an underwater eye-level, follows the fierce confrontation between two massive largemouth bass with a slow, steady pan. In the murky, yet sun-drenched, freshwater lake, shafts of light create a Tyndall effect in the deep green water, illuminating tiny suspended particles. The bass on the left, slightly larger, its olive-green scales gleaming metallically in the light. Its gill covers open wide in fury, revealing vibrant red gill filaments. It lunges forward with explosive force, its massive mouth stretched to its limit. Its opponent on the right, no less, slaps the current with its powerful tail fin, stirring up a small cloud of bottom mud and sand. It nimbly twists its body in the water to meet the impact sideways. The moment the two fish collide, the image is filled with a sense of power, with visible ripples in the water and a few silver scales falling and scattering in the chaos. Their movements are not chaotic, but full of primitive and strategic aggressiveness. Every collision and bite stirs up the swaying aquatic plants around them, creating a tense, fierce and primitive competitive atmosphere full of vitality.", + "seed": 25095, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_5/index_267_seed_25095_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03898454559966922, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03898454559966922, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03898454559966922, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive largemouth bass visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky, sun-drenched freshwater lake with deep green water and visible suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the left display olive-green metallic scales, open gill covers revealing red filaments, and lunge forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the right slap the current with its tail fin, stirring up mud and sand, and twist its body sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the action with a slow, steady pan while the fish collide, creating ripples and scattering silver scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0637778788805008 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8137779235839844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0637778788805008, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0637778788805008, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10746106505393982, + 0.06254753470420837, + 0.03477189689874649, + 0.15861819684505463, + 0.02185218222439289, + 0.0252427589148283, + 0.1170017197728157, + 0.32987383008003235, + 0.08476773649454117, + 0.057863082736730576 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0637778788805008 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive largemouth bass visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky, sun-drenched freshwater lake with deep green water and visible suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the left display olive-green metallic scales, open gill covers revealing red filaments, and lunge forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the right slap the current with its tail fin, stirring up mud and sand, and twist its body sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the action with a slow, steady pan while the fish collide, creating ripples and scattering silver scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004652389790862799 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379652500152588 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004652389790862799, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004652389790862799, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10644593089818954, + 0.06819622218608856, + 0.04788855090737343, + 0.24831287562847137, + 0.04054151475429535, + 0.030962646007537842, + 0.07629092782735825, + 0.16019275784492493, + 0.10231448709964752, + 0.1188541129231453 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004652389790862799 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive largemouth bass visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky, sun-drenched freshwater lake with deep green water and visible suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the left display olive-green metallic scales, open gill covers revealing red filaments, and lunge forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the right slap the current with its tail fin, stirring up mud and sand, and twist its body sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the action with a slow, steady pan while the fish collide, creating ripples and scattering silver scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014198355376720428 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264198303222656 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014198355376720428, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014198355376720428, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.044490665197372437, + 0.09212294220924377, + 0.02893088012933731, + 0.04692443460226059, + 0.01755242981016636, + 0.022196616977453232, + 0.09992951154708862, + 0.5436823964118958, + 0.047970958054065704, + 0.05619921535253525 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014198355376720428 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive largemouth bass visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky, sun-drenched freshwater lake with deep green water and visible suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the left display olive-green metallic scales, open gill covers revealing red filaments, and lunge forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the right slap the current with its tail fin, stirring up mud and sand, and twist its body sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the action with a slow, steady pan while the fish collide, creating ripples and scattering silver scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023282017558813095 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773282051086426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023282017558813095, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023282017558813095, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06962823867797852, + 0.05823412910103798, + 0.04570339620113373, + 0.07221461832523346, + 0.04297530651092529, + 0.06031803786754608, + 0.07083006203174591, + 0.4745497405529022, + 0.04435507953166962, + 0.061191365122795105 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023282017558813095 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive largemouth bass visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky, sun-drenched freshwater lake with deep green water and visible suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the left display olive-green metallic scales, open gill covers revealing red filaments, and lunge forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the right slap the current with its tail fin, stirring up mud and sand, and twist its body sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the action with a slow, steady pan while the fish collide, creating ripples and scattering silver scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08901208639144897 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640121459960938 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08901208639144897, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08901208639144897, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1010638177394867, + 0.0957028791308403, + 0.046863261610269547, + 0.14578446745872498, + 0.04282325878739357, + 0.08018861711025238, + 0.12208746373653412, + 0.17822003364562988, + 0.09270744770765305, + 0.09455875307321548 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08901208639144897 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from an underwater eye-level, follows the fierce confrontation between two massive largemouth bass with a slow, steady pan. In the murky, yet sun-drenched, freshwater lake, shafts of light create a Tyndall effect in the deep green water, illuminating tiny suspended particles. The bass on the left, slightly larger, its olive-green scales gleaming metallically in the light. Its gill covers open wide in fury, revealing vibrant red gill filaments. It lunges forward with explosive force, its massive mouth stretched to its limit. Its opponent on the right, no less, slaps the current with its powerful tail fin, stirring up a small cloud of bottom mud and sand. It nimbly twists its body in the water to meet the impact sideways. The moment the two fish collide, the image is filled with a sense of power, with visible ripples in the water and a few silver scales falling and scattering in the chaos. Their movements are not chaotic, but full of primitive and strategic aggressiveness. Every collision and bite stirs up the swaying aquatic plants around them, creating a tense, fierce and primitive competitive atmosphere full of vitality.", + "seed": 25096, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_5/index_267_seed_25096_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.022526036016643047, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022526036016643047, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022526036016643047, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive largemouth bass visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky, sun-drenched freshwater lake with deep green water and visible suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the left display olive-green metallic scales, open gill covers revealing red filaments, and lunge forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the right slap the current with its tail fin, stirring up mud and sand, and twist its body sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the action with a slow, steady pan while the fish collide, creating ripples and scattering silver scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015024710446596146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.265024662017822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015024710446596146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015024710446596146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08538353443145752, + 0.03602798655629158, + 0.05659008026123047, + 0.04878998175263405, + 0.5229001641273499, + 0.013106013648211956, + 0.024223068729043007, + 0.023122666403651237, + 0.07440274953842163, + 0.11545371264219284 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015024710446596146 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive largemouth bass visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky, sun-drenched freshwater lake with deep green water and visible suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the left display olive-green metallic scales, open gill covers revealing red filaments, and lunge forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the right slap the current with its tail fin, stirring up mud and sand, and twist its body sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the action with a slow, steady pan while the fish collide, creating ripples and scattering silver scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005259605124592781 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.2552595138549805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005259605124592781, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005259605124592781, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16557733714580536, + 0.09774132817983627, + 0.10703689604997635, + 0.06949284672737122, + 0.09063716977834702, + 0.055816128849983215, + 0.04788889363408089, + 0.055106788873672485, + 0.1049119085073471, + 0.20579072833061218 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005259605124592781 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive largemouth bass visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky, sun-drenched freshwater lake with deep green water and visible suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the left display olive-green metallic scales, open gill covers revealing red filaments, and lunge forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the right slap the current with its tail fin, stirring up mud and sand, and twist its body sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the action with a slow, steady pan while the fish collide, creating ripples and scattering silver scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011075212620198727 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511075019836426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011075212620198727, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011075212620198727, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13770462572574615, + 0.07167180627584457, + 0.195259690284729, + 0.05757100135087967, + 0.1133546307682991, + 0.03963799029588699, + 0.039118316024541855, + 0.05934241786599159, + 0.1679859608411789, + 0.11835350841283798 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011075212620198727 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive largemouth bass visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky, sun-drenched freshwater lake with deep green water and visible suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the left display olive-green metallic scales, open gill covers revealing red filaments, and lunge forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the right slap the current with its tail fin, stirring up mud and sand, and twist its body sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the action with a slow, steady pan while the fish collide, creating ripples and scattering silver scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026336325332522392 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651336431503296 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026336325332522392, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026336325332522392, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10638318210840225, + 0.05170931667089462, + 0.10795227438211441, + 0.054796550422906876, + 0.05857960507273674, + 0.03010978177189827, + 0.030135221779346466, + 0.03286665305495262, + 0.2188977152109146, + 0.30856961011886597 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026336325332522392 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive largemouth bass visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky, sun-drenched freshwater lake with deep green water and visible suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the left display olive-green metallic scales, open gill covers revealing red filaments, and lunge forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the right slap the current with its tail fin, stirring up mud and sand, and twist its body sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the action with a slow, steady pan while the fish collide, creating ripples and scattering silver scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05493432655930519 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.92993426322937 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05493432655930519, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05493432655930519, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10245352238416672, + 0.03124789148569107, + 0.051824603229761124, + 0.06618297845125198, + 0.27429497241973877, + 0.03650955855846405, + 0.06909819692373276, + 0.037761542946100235, + 0.1081433966755867, + 0.2224833369255066 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05493432655930519 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from an underwater eye-level, follows the fierce confrontation between two massive largemouth bass with a slow, steady pan. In the murky, yet sun-drenched, freshwater lake, shafts of light create a Tyndall effect in the deep green water, illuminating tiny suspended particles. The bass on the left, slightly larger, its olive-green scales gleaming metallically in the light. Its gill covers open wide in fury, revealing vibrant red gill filaments. It lunges forward with explosive force, its massive mouth stretched to its limit. Its opponent on the right, no less, slaps the current with its powerful tail fin, stirring up a small cloud of bottom mud and sand. It nimbly twists its body in the water to meet the impact sideways. The moment the two fish collide, the image is filled with a sense of power, with visible ripples in the water and a few silver scales falling and scattering in the chaos. Their movements are not chaotic, but full of primitive and strategic aggressiveness. Every collision and bite stirs up the swaying aquatic plants around them, creating a tense, fierce and primitive competitive atmosphere full of vitality.", + "seed": 25097, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_5/index_267_seed_25097_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.028451400436460973, + "vlm_logprob": -0.028451400436460973, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.028451400436460973, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive largemouth bass visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky, sun-drenched freshwater lake with deep green water and visible suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the left display olive-green metallic scales, open gill covers revealing red filaments, and lunge forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the right slap the current with its tail fin, stirring up mud and sand, and twist its body sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the action with a slow, steady pan while the fish collide, creating ripples and scattering silver scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.027546396479010582 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6525464057922363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.027546396479010582, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.027546396479010582, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1516595333814621, + 0.09541795402765274, + 0.051117002964019775, + 0.33436504006385803, + 0.021697169169783592, + 0.046898696571588516, + 0.05029544606804848, + 0.01116287149488926, + 0.13326416909694672, + 0.10412214696407318 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.027546396479010582 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive largemouth bass visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky, sun-drenched freshwater lake with deep green water and visible suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the left display olive-green metallic scales, open gill covers revealing red filaments, and lunge forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the right slap the current with its tail fin, stirring up mud and sand, and twist its body sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the action with a slow, steady pan while the fish collide, creating ripples and scattering silver scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004104761406779289 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5041046142578125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004104761406779289, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004104761406779289, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13215570151805878, + 0.06803468614816666, + 0.0559992715716362, + 0.08797985315322876, + 0.02621551975607872, + 0.12514810264110565, + 0.0386103130877018, + 0.28242799639701843, + 0.08375519514083862, + 0.099673330783844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004104761406779289 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive largemouth bass visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky, sun-drenched freshwater lake with deep green water and visible suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the left display olive-green metallic scales, open gill covers revealing red filaments, and lunge forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the right slap the current with its tail fin, stirring up mud and sand, and twist its body sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the action with a slow, steady pan while the fish collide, creating ripples and scattering silver scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011074741370975971 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511074542999268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011074741370975971, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011074741370975971, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18117445707321167, + 0.03053249977529049, + 0.1398232877254486, + 0.20854775607585907, + 0.028803149238228798, + 0.043639231473207474, + 0.0952272117137909, + 0.08696380257606506, + 0.04638321325182915, + 0.13890540599822998 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011074741370975971 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive largemouth bass visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky, sun-drenched freshwater lake with deep green water and visible suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the left display olive-green metallic scales, open gill covers revealing red filaments, and lunge forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the right slap the current with its tail fin, stirring up mud and sand, and twist its body sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the action with a slow, steady pan while the fish collide, creating ripples and scattering silver scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020572613924741745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955726623535156 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020572613924741745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020572613924741745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19261258840560913, + 0.059075258672237396, + 0.08296973258256912, + 0.08734940737485886, + 0.04287465289235115, + 0.04320060834288597, + 0.05360746011137962, + 0.0626654177904129, + 0.17435933649539948, + 0.2012854665517807 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020572613924741745 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive largemouth bass visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky, sun-drenched freshwater lake with deep green water and visible suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the left display olive-green metallic scales, open gill covers revealing red filaments, and lunge forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the right slap the current with its tail fin, stirring up mud and sand, and twist its body sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the action with a slow, steady pan while the fish collide, creating ripples and scattering silver scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07895848900079727 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578958511352539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07895848900079727, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07895848900079727, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15813519060611725, + 0.05458908900618553, + 0.08780118823051453, + 0.19029600918293, + 0.04579056799411774, + 0.070052869617939, + 0.07700226455926895, + 0.07944168895483017, + 0.15402157604694366, + 0.0828694999217987 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07895848900079727 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from an underwater eye-level, follows the fierce confrontation between two massive largemouth bass with a slow, steady pan. In the murky, yet sun-drenched, freshwater lake, shafts of light create a Tyndall effect in the deep green water, illuminating tiny suspended particles. The bass on the left, slightly larger, its olive-green scales gleaming metallically in the light. Its gill covers open wide in fury, revealing vibrant red gill filaments. It lunges forward with explosive force, its massive mouth stretched to its limit. Its opponent on the right, no less, slaps the current with its powerful tail fin, stirring up a small cloud of bottom mud and sand. It nimbly twists its body in the water to meet the impact sideways. The moment the two fish collide, the image is filled with a sense of power, with visible ripples in the water and a few silver scales falling and scattering in the chaos. Their movements are not chaotic, but full of primitive and strategic aggressiveness. Every collision and bite stirs up the swaying aquatic plants around them, creating a tense, fierce and primitive competitive atmosphere full of vitality.", + "seed": 25098, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_5/index_267_seed_25098_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.025463445018976925, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025463445018976925, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025463445018976925, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive largemouth bass visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky, sun-drenched freshwater lake with deep green water and visible suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the left display olive-green metallic scales, open gill covers revealing red filaments, and lunge forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the right slap the current with its tail fin, stirring up mud and sand, and twist its body sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the action with a slow, steady pan while the fish collide, creating ripples and scattering silver scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03965042531490326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2896504402160645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03965042531490326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03965042531490326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.01986817643046379, + 0.7708795666694641, + 0.09277338534593582, + 0.01237304788082838, + 0.042308226227760315, + 0.015714412555098534, + 0.008810590952634811, + 0.00865850504487753, + 0.010851435363292694, + 0.017762722447514534 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03965042531490326 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive largemouth bass visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky, sun-drenched freshwater lake with deep green water and visible suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the left display olive-green metallic scales, open gill covers revealing red filaments, and lunge forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the right slap the current with its tail fin, stirring up mud and sand, and twist its body sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the action with a slow, steady pan while the fish collide, creating ripples and scattering silver scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004111172165721655 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504111289978027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004111172165721655, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004111172165721655, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08503665030002594, + 0.7173442244529724, + 0.07589083909988403, + 0.014060608111321926, + 0.03664451837539673, + 0.014883867464959621, + 0.01838616468012333, + 0.014622678980231285, + 0.01018092967569828, + 0.012949544005095959 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004111172165721655 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive largemouth bass visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky, sun-drenched freshwater lake with deep green water and visible suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the left display olive-green metallic scales, open gill covers revealing red filaments, and lunge forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the right slap the current with its tail fin, stirring up mud and sand, and twist its body sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the action with a slow, steady pan while the fish collide, creating ripples and scattering silver scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012546772137284279 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387546539306641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012546772137284279, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012546772137284279, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11214656382799149, + 0.5821553468704224, + 0.05062931030988693, + 0.06110360100865364, + 0.08127893507480621, + 0.018192505463957787, + 0.03831833600997925, + 0.012154418975114822, + 0.023228945210576057, + 0.0207920353859663 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012546772137284279 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive largemouth bass visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky, sun-drenched freshwater lake with deep green water and visible suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the left display olive-green metallic scales, open gill covers revealing red filaments, and lunge forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the right slap the current with its tail fin, stirring up mud and sand, and twist its body sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the action with a slow, steady pan while the fish collide, creating ripples and scattering silver scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606426201760769 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141064167022705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606426201760769, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606426201760769, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0841597393155098, + 0.6490538120269775, + 0.047317106276750565, + 0.021559592336416245, + 0.05750133469700813, + 0.011111187748610973, + 0.03387710824608803, + 0.01301836408674717, + 0.04525132477283478, + 0.03715042769908905 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606426201760769 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive largemouth bass visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky, sun-drenched freshwater lake with deep green water and visible suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the left display olive-green metallic scales, open gill covers revealing red filaments, and lunge forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fish on the right slap the current with its tail fin, stirring up mud and sand, and twist its body sideways?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the action with a slow, steady pan while the fish collide, creating ripples and scattering silver scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05494459345936775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299445152282715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05494459345936775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05494459345936775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16193769872188568, + 0.23353755474090576, + 0.18268023431301117, + 0.07641543447971344, + 0.0778600424528122, + 0.05579034239053726, + 0.05620191991329193, + 0.03870823234319687, + 0.06994953006505966, + 0.04691901057958603 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05494459345936775 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_6/index_tensor([912, 912])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_6/index_tensor([912, 912])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ab19e20690e5cda4cced92508234346b80ab8198 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_6/index_tensor([912, 912])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The film begins with a medium-distance, horizontal shot of a classic black steam train, accompanied by a rhythmic clang of metal and a deafening whistle. It steadily and powerfully moves across a majestic railway bridge constructed of rusted steel trusses. The train body gleams with the metallic sheen of an industrial age, while its massive chimneys billow thick, billowing white steam and gray smoke, which rapidly diffuse in the cold morning air. The rising sun, shining golden from behind the distant mountains, dramatically outlines the billowing smoke and the steel bridge. Then, the camera quickly and smoothly pulls back, gradually shrinking the train from the dominant subject of the picture to a small dot moving in the grand natural landscape, revealing the entire breathtaking scene: below is a deep and vast valley, with a winding river running through it like a silver ribbon, the hillsides are covered with dense, green coniferous forests of varying shades, morning mist lingers in the forest and valley, some peaks are looming in the mist, and the sunlight penetrates the mist, forming clearly visible beams of light in the valley. The whole picture is full of an epic atmosphere of the power of the industrial age intertwined with the majesty of nature.", + "seed": 17517, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_6/index_912_seed_17517_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.045980080310255286, + "vlm_logprob": -0.045980080310255286, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.045980080310255286, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a classic black steam train visible moving across a railway bridge made of rusted steel trusses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the train's massive chimneys emit thick white steam and gray smoke that diffuses in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep valley with a winding river, green coniferous forests, and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show morning mist with visible beams of sunlight penetrating through it in the valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera quickly pull back from a medium-distance shot to reveal the entire landscape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.021074067801237106 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.896074056625366 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.021074067801237106, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.021074067801237106, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25109344720840454, + 0.13466337323188782, + 0.037170521914958954, + 0.02724425680935383, + 0.3019551634788513, + 0.04191338270902634, + 0.05550765246152878, + 0.05071936920285225, + 0.06931184232234955, + 0.030420992523431778 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.021074067801237106 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a classic black steam train visible moving across a railway bridge made of rusted steel trusses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the train's massive chimneys emit thick white steam and gray smoke that diffuses in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep valley with a winding river, green coniferous forests, and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show morning mist with visible beams of sunlight penetrating through it in the valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera quickly pull back from a medium-distance shot to reveal the entire landscape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004101437050849199 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504101276397705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004101437050849199, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004101437050849199, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2249683141708374, + 0.250984787940979, + 0.0843273252248764, + 0.02298031933605671, + 0.1533731073141098, + 0.04397512227296829, + 0.0586564801633358, + 0.03441078960895538, + 0.07432525604963303, + 0.05199851840734482 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004101437050849199 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a classic black steam train visible moving across a railway bridge made of rusted steel trusses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the train's massive chimneys emit thick white steam and gray smoke that diffuses in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep valley with a winding river, green coniferous forests, and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show morning mist with visible beams of sunlight penetrating through it in the valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera quickly pull back from a medium-distance shot to reveal the entire landscape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02978871762752533 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297887325286865 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02978871762752533, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02978871762752533, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2578274607658386, + 0.026613978669047356, + 0.06396433711051941, + 0.019175328314304352, + 0.07658058404922485, + 0.05917256698012352, + 0.4406668543815613, + 0.016161760315299034, + 0.02412511594593525, + 0.015711911022663116 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02978871762752533 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a classic black steam train visible moving across a railway bridge made of rusted steel trusses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the train's massive chimneys emit thick white steam and gray smoke that diffuses in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep valley with a winding river, green coniferous forests, and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show morning mist with visible beams of sunlight penetrating through it in the valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera quickly pull back from a medium-distance shot to reveal the entire landscape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11291041225194931 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237910509109497 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11291041225194931, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11291041225194931, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19470132887363434, + 0.1958591639995575, + 0.07852671295404434, + 0.052830301225185394, + 0.11374960839748383, + 0.046381961554288864, + 0.056317269802093506, + 0.022170457988977432, + 0.11897247284650803, + 0.12049073725938797 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11291041225194931 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a classic black steam train visible moving across a railway bridge made of rusted steel trusses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the train's massive chimneys emit thick white steam and gray smoke that diffuses in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep valley with a winding river, green coniferous forests, and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show morning mist with visible beams of sunlight penetrating through it in the valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera quickly pull back from a medium-distance shot to reveal the entire landscape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620257668197155 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812025785446167 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620257668197155, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620257668197155, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12821796536445618, + 0.08653928339481354, + 0.10262057930231094, + 0.03826545923948288, + 0.2997649013996124, + 0.12356529384851456, + 0.16188772022724152, + 0.015468581579625607, + 0.026812884956598282, + 0.01685733161866665 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620257668197155 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with a medium-distance, horizontal shot of a classic black steam train, accompanied by a rhythmic clang of metal and a deafening whistle. It steadily and powerfully moves across a majestic railway bridge constructed of rusted steel trusses. The train body gleams with the metallic sheen of an industrial age, while its massive chimneys billow thick, billowing white steam and gray smoke, which rapidly diffuse in the cold morning air. The rising sun, shining golden from behind the distant mountains, dramatically outlines the billowing smoke and the steel bridge. Then, the camera quickly and smoothly pulls back, gradually shrinking the train from the dominant subject of the picture to a small dot moving in the grand natural landscape, revealing the entire breathtaking scene: below is a deep and vast valley, with a winding river running through it like a silver ribbon, the hillsides are covered with dense, green coniferous forests of varying shades, morning mist lingers in the forest and valley, some peaks are looming in the mist, and the sunlight penetrates the mist, forming clearly visible beams of light in the valley. The whole picture is full of an epic atmosphere of the power of the industrial age intertwined with the majesty of nature.", + "seed": 17518, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_6/index_912_seed_17518_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.01377345873042941, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01377345873042941, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01377345873042941, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a classic black steam train visible moving across a railway bridge made of rusted steel trusses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the train's massive chimneys emit thick white steam and gray smoke that diffuses in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep valley with a winding river, green coniferous forests, and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show morning mist with visible beams of sunlight penetrating through it in the valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera quickly pull back from a medium-distance shot to reveal the entire landscape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02752876840531826 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.652528762817383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02752876840531826, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02752876840531826, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13772417604923248, + 0.20151308178901672, + 0.10718737542629242, + 0.020664261654019356, + 0.043324198573827744, + 0.05783459171652794, + 0.05982280522584915, + 0.16952601075172424, + 0.12029469758272171, + 0.08210877329111099 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02752876840531826 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a classic black steam train visible moving across a railway bridge made of rusted steel trusses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the train's massive chimneys emit thick white steam and gray smoke that diffuses in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep valley with a winding river, green coniferous forests, and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show morning mist with visible beams of sunlight penetrating through it in the valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera quickly pull back from a medium-distance shot to reveal the entire landscape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036283391527831554 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628628253936768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036283391527831554, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036283391527831554, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0951383113861084, + 0.319252610206604, + 0.13311220705509186, + 0.022981327027082443, + 0.020745903253555298, + 0.039885617792606354, + 0.047069475054740906, + 0.18592417240142822, + 0.10218518227338791, + 0.033705223351716995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036283391527831554 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a classic black steam train visible moving across a railway bridge made of rusted steel trusses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the train's massive chimneys emit thick white steam and gray smoke that diffuses in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep valley with a winding river, green coniferous forests, and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show morning mist with visible beams of sunlight penetrating through it in the valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera quickly pull back from a medium-distance shot to reveal the entire landscape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004634828772395849 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379634857177734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004634828772395849, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004634828772395849, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07437733560800552, + 0.11098680645227432, + 0.04791070520877838, + 0.01896810159087181, + 0.01715589314699173, + 0.039158858358860016, + 0.1161014586687088, + 0.09034182876348495, + 0.13974712789058685, + 0.3452518880367279 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004634828772395849 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a classic black steam train visible moving across a railway bridge made of rusted steel trusses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the train's massive chimneys emit thick white steam and gray smoke that diffuses in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep valley with a winding river, green coniferous forests, and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show morning mist with visible beams of sunlight penetrating through it in the valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera quickly pull back from a medium-distance shot to reveal the entire landscape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006733110640197992 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006732940673828 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006733110640197992, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006733110640197992, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08583995699882507, + 0.08403142541646957, + 0.04447527974843979, + 0.034425798803567886, + 0.025674615055322647, + 0.051723748445510864, + 0.09235460311174393, + 0.3108411133289337, + 0.1395387500524521, + 0.13109466433525085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006733110640197992 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a classic black steam train visible moving across a railway bridge made of rusted steel trusses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the train's massive chimneys emit thick white steam and gray smoke that diffuses in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep valley with a winding river, green coniferous forests, and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show morning mist with visible beams of sunlight penetrating through it in the valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera quickly pull back from a medium-distance shot to reveal the entire landscape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026342246681451797 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513421535491943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026342246681451797, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026342246681451797, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08822981268167496, + 0.0873996764421463, + 0.05101245641708374, + 0.07140649110078812, + 0.04095355421304703, + 0.04210641235113144, + 0.07671386003494263, + 0.3256947100162506, + 0.1813337355852127, + 0.03514934703707695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026342246681451797 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with a medium-distance, horizontal shot of a classic black steam train, accompanied by a rhythmic clang of metal and a deafening whistle. It steadily and powerfully moves across a majestic railway bridge constructed of rusted steel trusses. The train body gleams with the metallic sheen of an industrial age, while its massive chimneys billow thick, billowing white steam and gray smoke, which rapidly diffuse in the cold morning air. The rising sun, shining golden from behind the distant mountains, dramatically outlines the billowing smoke and the steel bridge. Then, the camera quickly and smoothly pulls back, gradually shrinking the train from the dominant subject of the picture to a small dot moving in the grand natural landscape, revealing the entire breathtaking scene: below is a deep and vast valley, with a winding river running through it like a silver ribbon, the hillsides are covered with dense, green coniferous forests of varying shades, morning mist lingers in the forest and valley, some peaks are looming in the mist, and the sunlight penetrates the mist, forming clearly visible beams of light in the valley. The whole picture is full of an epic atmosphere of the power of the industrial age intertwined with the majesty of nature.", + "seed": 17519, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_6/index_912_seed_17519_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.014152442337945104, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014152442337945104, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014152442337945104, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a classic black steam train visible moving across a railway bridge made of rusted steel trusses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the train's massive chimneys emit thick white steam and gray smoke that diffuses in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep valley with a winding river, green coniferous forests, and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show morning mist with visible beams of sunlight penetrating through it in the valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera quickly pull back from a medium-distance shot to reveal the entire landscape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02447647787630558 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7744765281677246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02447647787630558, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02447647787630558, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6708706617355347, + 0.04689071327447891, + 0.13205792009830475, + 0.03397997096180916, + 0.04218525439500809, + 0.02530321106314659, + 0.015075156465172768, + 0.009881648235023022, + 0.014991067349910736, + 0.00876450352370739 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02447647787630558 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a classic black steam train visible moving across a railway bridge made of rusted steel trusses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the train's massive chimneys emit thick white steam and gray smoke that diffuses in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep valley with a winding river, green coniferous forests, and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show morning mist with visible beams of sunlight penetrating through it in the valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera quickly pull back from a medium-distance shot to reveal the entire landscape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00764515670016408 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882645130157471 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00764515670016408, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00764515670016408, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.673031210899353, + 0.08799496293067932, + 0.041110917925834656, + 0.09644989669322968, + 0.011997322551906109, + 0.02514309622347355, + 0.01383757870644331, + 0.018655911087989807, + 0.020047087222337723, + 0.011732013896107674 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00764515670016408 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a classic black steam train visible moving across a railway bridge made of rusted steel trusses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the train's massive chimneys emit thick white steam and gray smoke that diffuses in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep valley with a winding river, green coniferous forests, and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show morning mist with visible beams of sunlight penetrating through it in the valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera quickly pull back from a medium-distance shot to reveal the entire landscape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028166405390948057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877816677093506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028166405390948057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028166405390948057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14396382868289948, + 0.038002315908670425, + 0.3479467034339905, + 0.04446326196193695, + 0.07462544739246368, + 0.07770208269357681, + 0.051490068435668945, + 0.03416278585791588, + 0.10346399247646332, + 0.08417957276105881 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028166405390948057 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a classic black steam train visible moving across a railway bridge made of rusted steel trusses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the train's massive chimneys emit thick white steam and gray smoke that diffuses in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep valley with a winding river, green coniferous forests, and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show morning mist with visible beams of sunlight penetrating through it in the valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera quickly pull back from a medium-distance shot to reveal the entire landscape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023284580558538437 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773284673690796 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023284580558538437, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023284580558538437, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.47034183144569397, + 0.027689656242728233, + 0.20621134340763092, + 0.05277935788035393, + 0.04415450245141983, + 0.05849960073828697, + 0.06120089814066887, + 0.025110026821494102, + 0.03546315059065819, + 0.018549643456935883 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023284580558538437 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a classic black steam train visible moving across a railway bridge made of rusted steel trusses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the train's massive chimneys emit thick white steam and gray smoke that diffuses in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep valley with a winding river, green coniferous forests, and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show morning mist with visible beams of sunlight penetrating through it in the valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera quickly pull back from a medium-distance shot to reveal the entire landscape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012539356015622616 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387539386749268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012539356015622616, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012539356015622616, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4983291029930115, + 0.03609306737780571, + 0.22431911528110504, + 0.061948731541633606, + 0.06142399087548256, + 0.04839857295155525, + 0.014989991672337055, + 0.016934029757976532, + 0.026369765400886536, + 0.011193722486495972 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012539356015622616 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with a medium-distance, horizontal shot of a classic black steam train, accompanied by a rhythmic clang of metal and a deafening whistle. It steadily and powerfully moves across a majestic railway bridge constructed of rusted steel trusses. The train body gleams with the metallic sheen of an industrial age, while its massive chimneys billow thick, billowing white steam and gray smoke, which rapidly diffuse in the cold morning air. The rising sun, shining golden from behind the distant mountains, dramatically outlines the billowing smoke and the steel bridge. Then, the camera quickly and smoothly pulls back, gradually shrinking the train from the dominant subject of the picture to a small dot moving in the grand natural landscape, revealing the entire breathtaking scene: below is a deep and vast valley, with a winding river running through it like a silver ribbon, the hillsides are covered with dense, green coniferous forests of varying shades, morning mist lingers in the forest and valley, some peaks are looming in the mist, and the sunlight penetrates the mist, forming clearly visible beams of light in the valley. The whole picture is full of an epic atmosphere of the power of the industrial age intertwined with the majesty of nature.", + "seed": 17520, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_6/index_912_seed_17520_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1301920520607382, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1301920520607382, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1301920520607382, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a classic black steam train visible moving across a railway bridge made of rusted steel trusses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the train's massive chimneys emit thick white steam and gray smoke that diffuses in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep valley with a winding river, green coniferous forests, and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show morning mist with visible beams of sunlight penetrating through it in the valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera quickly pull back from a medium-distance shot to reveal the entire landscape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06260339170694351 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.81260347366333 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06260339170694351, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06260339170694351, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09740982204675674, + 0.25962352752685547, + 0.29507502913475037, + 0.04346336051821709, + 0.04804098606109619, + 0.0359368734061718, + 0.019707590341567993, + 0.09203069657087326, + 0.06611379981040955, + 0.04259821027517319 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06260339170694351 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a classic black steam train visible moving across a railway bridge made of rusted steel trusses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the train's massive chimneys emit thick white steam and gray smoke that diffuses in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep valley with a winding river, green coniferous forests, and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show morning mist with visible beams of sunlight penetrating through it in the valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera quickly pull back from a medium-distance shot to reveal the entire landscape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014214222319424152 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264214038848877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014214222319424152, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014214222319424152, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07299940288066864, + 0.07171803712844849, + 0.39100679755210876, + 0.05199013277888298, + 0.035746388137340546, + 0.05544092133641243, + 0.017168892547488213, + 0.05060442537069321, + 0.22799979150295258, + 0.025325221940875053 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014214222319424152 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a classic black steam train visible moving across a railway bridge made of rusted steel trusses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the train's massive chimneys emit thick white steam and gray smoke that diffuses in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep valley with a winding river, green coniferous forests, and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show morning mist with visible beams of sunlight penetrating through it in the valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera quickly pull back from a medium-distance shot to reveal the entire landscape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021946171764284372 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127194404602051 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021946171764284372, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021946171764284372, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12508098781108856, + 0.12127945572137833, + 0.1056220754981041, + 0.053168293088674545, + 0.110904261469841, + 0.04203076288104057, + 0.03917248174548149, + 0.25507742166519165, + 0.08179325610399246, + 0.06587095558643341 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021946171764284372 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a classic black steam train visible moving across a railway bridge made of rusted steel trusses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the train's massive chimneys emit thick white steam and gray smoke that diffuses in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep valley with a winding river, green coniferous forests, and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show morning mist with visible beams of sunlight penetrating through it in the valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera quickly pull back from a medium-distance shot to reveal the entire landscape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864535480737686 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048645257949829 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864535480737686, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864535480737686, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09600022435188293, + 0.12201493978500366, + 0.07570960372686386, + 0.14017312228679657, + 0.2336241453886032, + 0.12944379448890686, + 0.05444309487938881, + 0.07963632047176361, + 0.027795933187007904, + 0.041158780455589294 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864535480737686 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a classic black steam train visible moving across a railway bridge made of rusted steel trusses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the train's massive chimneys emit thick white steam and gray smoke that diffuses in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep valley with a winding river, green coniferous forests, and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show morning mist with visible beams of sunlight penetrating through it in the valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera quickly pull back from a medium-distance shot to reveal the entire landscape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233026742935181 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983026742935181 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233026742935181, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233026742935181, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03689568117260933, + 0.0871637687087059, + 0.054158736020326614, + 0.0437399297952652, + 0.20229430496692657, + 0.237783744931221, + 0.038718465715646744, + 0.20450876653194427, + 0.06662584096193314, + 0.02811073139309883 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233026742935181 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_7/index_tensor([4618, 4618])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_7/index_tensor([4618, 4618])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6c8f9fd63a8ae52b2b8df27d4338b03aceaa4a6f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_7/index_tensor([4618, 4618])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "wide, low-angle shot captures an apocalyptic scene. In the sky, thick, inky storm clouds piled up, nearly reaching the sea level, only a hint of eerie cold light piercing the horizon. Beneath this oppressive canopy, a mountain-like wave relentlessly pressed against the rugged, rocky coastline. This towering wall of water, a deep turquoise, its surface wrinkled and creased, crowned by a roiling crest of chaotic white foam, resembles a moving, angry mountain range of crystal. As the wave crashes with thunderous force against the dark, slippery rocks, eroded by the sea, it erupts with astonishing force, sending up a massive column of white spray and foam that nearly touches the clouds. Countless tons of seawater are ripped into billions of crystalline droplets in the air, cascading down to rejoin the surging ocean below. The entire picture presents a cold monochrome tone in the dim light, with only the dazzling white flashing when the waves splash, creating a majestic, primitive and awe-inspiring tense atmosphere, full of the irresistible wild power of nature.", + "seed": 27257, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_7/index_4618_seed_27257_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.4413399047218263, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4413399047218263, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4413399047218263, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky filled with thick, inky storm clouds reaching near sea level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turquoise wave crashing against a rugged, rocky coastline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a massive column of white spray erupting from the wave crash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall tone of the video a cold monochrome with only dazzling white flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.24550406634807587 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6205040216445923 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.24550406634807587, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.24550406634807587, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14477387070655823, + 0.06602335721254349, + 0.1409817487001419, + 0.11270440369844437, + 0.04252726584672928, + 0.040822237730026245, + 0.1573665738105774, + 0.07247573882341385, + 0.024829624220728874, + 0.19749519228935242 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.24550406634807587 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky filled with thick, inky storm clouds reaching near sea level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turquoise wave crashing against a rugged, rocky coastline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a massive column of white spray erupting from the wave crash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall tone of the video a cold monochrome with only dazzling white flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370911598205566 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38709113001823425 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1370911598205566, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1370911598205566, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3719501495361328, + 0.05169292166829109, + 0.07909689843654633, + 0.13366572558879852, + 0.02871132455766201, + 0.025602208450436592, + 0.0993829071521759, + 0.02488020993769169, + 0.06796441227197647, + 0.11705326288938522 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1370911598205566 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky filled with thick, inky storm clouds reaching near sea level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turquoise wave crashing against a rugged, rocky coastline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a massive column of white spray erupting from the wave crash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall tone of the video a cold monochrome with only dazzling white flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12709929049015045 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270992755889893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12709929049015045, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12709929049015045, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25741496682167053, + 0.038299914449453354, + 0.31881624460220337, + 0.034354597330093384, + 0.07990434765815735, + 0.012469946406781673, + 0.12201561033725739, + 0.04714677855372429, + 0.04968341812491417, + 0.03989420458674431 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12709929049015045 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky filled with thick, inky storm clouds reaching near sea level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turquoise wave crashing against a rugged, rocky coastline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a massive column of white spray erupting from the wave crash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall tone of the video a cold monochrome with only dazzling white flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003626320045441389 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628626346588135 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003626320045441389, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003626320045441389, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19620229303836823, + 0.03686371445655823, + 0.06372334808111191, + 0.10066083073616028, + 0.07072743028402328, + 0.0727318748831749, + 0.13609622418880463, + 0.1538393795490265, + 0.05202888697385788, + 0.11712602525949478 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003626320045441389 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky filled with thick, inky storm clouds reaching near sea level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turquoise wave crashing against a rugged, rocky coastline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a massive column of white spray erupting from the wave crash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall tone of the video a cold monochrome with only dazzling white flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933786869049072 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933786869049072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6933786869049072, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6933786869049072, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2869548499584198, + 0.02629707381129265, + 0.06423480808734894, + 0.0913403183221817, + 0.08149608224630356, + 0.031388022005558014, + 0.035158608108758926, + 0.06503894180059433, + 0.21900516748428345, + 0.09908616542816162 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6933786869049072 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, low-angle shot captures an apocalyptic scene. In the sky, thick, inky storm clouds piled up, nearly reaching the sea level, only a hint of eerie cold light piercing the horizon. Beneath this oppressive canopy, a mountain-like wave relentlessly pressed against the rugged, rocky coastline. This towering wall of water, a deep turquoise, its surface wrinkled and creased, crowned by a roiling crest of chaotic white foam, resembles a moving, angry mountain range of crystal. As the wave crashes with thunderous force against the dark, slippery rocks, eroded by the sea, it erupts with astonishing force, sending up a massive column of white spray and foam that nearly touches the clouds. Countless tons of seawater are ripped into billions of crystalline droplets in the air, cascading down to rejoin the surging ocean below. The entire picture presents a cold monochrome tone in the dim light, with only the dazzling white flashing when the waves splash, creating a majestic, primitive and awe-inspiring tense atmosphere, full of the irresistible wild power of nature.", + "seed": 27258, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_7/index_4618_seed_27258_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.3145449053496122, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3145449053496122, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3145449053496122, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky filled with thick, inky storm clouds reaching near sea level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turquoise wave crashing against a rugged, rocky coastline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a massive column of white spray erupting from the wave crash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall tone of the video a cold monochrome with only dazzling white flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.21334610879421234 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8383461236953735 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.21334610879421234, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.21334610879421234, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11534295231103897, + 0.07496702671051025, + 0.14499686658382416, + 0.1566900908946991, + 0.10574066638946533, + 0.09237208217382431, + 0.114801324903965, + 0.03888994827866554, + 0.07716918736696243, + 0.07902985066175461 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.21334610879421234 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky filled with thick, inky storm clouds reaching near sea level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turquoise wave crashing against a rugged, rocky coastline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a massive column of white spray erupting from the wave crash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall tone of the video a cold monochrome with only dazzling white flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233733057975769 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983733057975769 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233733057975769, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233733057975769, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12644939124584198, + 0.18334856629371643, + 0.2587980329990387, + 0.14266246557235718, + 0.03173812851309776, + 0.0156274251639843, + 0.02440243773162365, + 0.1021348163485527, + 0.06576424837112427, + 0.049074478447437286 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233733057975769 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky filled with thick, inky storm clouds reaching near sea level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turquoise wave crashing against a rugged, rocky coastline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a massive column of white spray erupting from the wave crash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall tone of the video a cold monochrome with only dazzling white flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022077015601098537 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.1272077560424805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022077015601098537, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022077015601098537, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12909594178199768, + 0.06212371215224266, + 0.060894906520843506, + 0.03454763814806938, + 0.06717267632484436, + 0.03404013067483902, + 0.042977139353752136, + 0.09042974561452866, + 0.38180625438690186, + 0.09691182523965836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022077015601098537 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky filled with thick, inky storm clouds reaching near sea level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turquoise wave crashing against a rugged, rocky coastline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a massive column of white spray erupting from the wave crash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall tone of the video a cold monochrome with only dazzling white flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007638887036591768 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882638931274414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007638887036591768, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007638887036591768, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.045613523572683334, + 0.06855540722608566, + 0.09633054584264755, + 0.026277879253029823, + 0.07209408283233643, + 0.023911206051707268, + 0.027517005801200867, + 0.08379384130239487, + 0.5191011428833008, + 0.036805395036935806 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007638887036591768 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky filled with thick, inky storm clouds reaching near sea level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turquoise wave crashing against a rugged, rocky coastline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a massive column of white spray erupting from the wave crash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall tone of the video a cold monochrome with only dazzling white flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261585235595703 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761585235595703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8261585235595703, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8261585235595703, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08772094547748566, + 0.15519164502620697, + 0.23091697692871094, + 0.14095625281333923, + 0.07769212126731873, + 0.027950163930654526, + 0.02600143291056156, + 0.04117828235030174, + 0.0751924142241478, + 0.13719983398914337 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8261585235595703 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, low-angle shot captures an apocalyptic scene. In the sky, thick, inky storm clouds piled up, nearly reaching the sea level, only a hint of eerie cold light piercing the horizon. Beneath this oppressive canopy, a mountain-like wave relentlessly pressed against the rugged, rocky coastline. This towering wall of water, a deep turquoise, its surface wrinkled and creased, crowned by a roiling crest of chaotic white foam, resembles a moving, angry mountain range of crystal. As the wave crashes with thunderous force against the dark, slippery rocks, eroded by the sea, it erupts with astonishing force, sending up a massive column of white spray and foam that nearly touches the clouds. Countless tons of seawater are ripped into billions of crystalline droplets in the air, cascading down to rejoin the surging ocean below. The entire picture presents a cold monochrome tone in the dim light, with only the dazzling white flashing when the waves splash, creating a majestic, primitive and awe-inspiring tense atmosphere, full of the irresistible wild power of nature.", + "seed": 27259, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_7/index_4618_seed_27259_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1553010110743344, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1553010110743344, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1553010110743344, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky filled with thick, inky storm clouds reaching near sea level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turquoise wave crashing against a rugged, rocky coastline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a massive column of white spray erupting from the wave crash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall tone of the video a cold monochrome with only dazzling white flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09850218892097473 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5985021591186523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09850218892097473, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09850218892097473, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18525810539722443, + 0.05579802393913269, + 0.07422199845314026, + 0.08008617162704468, + 0.07204032689332962, + 0.06479085981845856, + 0.09482339024543762, + 0.048445310443639755, + 0.07580222934484482, + 0.24873358011245728 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09850218892097473 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky filled with thick, inky storm clouds reaching near sea level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turquoise wave crashing against a rugged, rocky coastline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a massive column of white spray erupting from the wave crash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall tone of the video a cold monochrome with only dazzling white flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08910423517227173 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464104175567627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08910423517227173, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08910423517227173, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4719724655151367, + 0.06561673432588577, + 0.11044088006019592, + 0.06081663817167282, + 0.04494445398449898, + 0.022449227049946785, + 0.031007420271635056, + 0.04630722105503082, + 0.025821566581726074, + 0.12062336504459381 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08910423517227173 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky filled with thick, inky storm clouds reaching near sea level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turquoise wave crashing against a rugged, rocky coastline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a massive column of white spray erupting from the wave crash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall tone of the video a cold monochrome with only dazzling white flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00410511763766408 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504105091094971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00410511763766408, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00410511763766408, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12250256538391113, + 0.2229641228914261, + 0.0625302866101265, + 0.0637832060456276, + 0.17632539570331573, + 0.033014267683029175, + 0.07577095180749893, + 0.06578188389539719, + 0.05250217020511627, + 0.1248251348733902 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00410511763766408 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky filled with thick, inky storm clouds reaching near sea level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turquoise wave crashing against a rugged, rocky coastline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a massive column of white spray erupting from the wave crash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall tone of the video a cold monochrome with only dazzling white flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008646076545119286 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758646011352539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008646076545119286, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008646076545119286, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07949771732091904, + 0.03761320933699608, + 0.07532808929681778, + 0.07587790489196777, + 0.08336161077022552, + 0.11790390312671661, + 0.06847458332777023, + 0.09207578748464584, + 0.2681175768375397, + 0.10174964368343353 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008646076545119286 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky filled with thick, inky storm clouds reaching near sea level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turquoise wave crashing against a rugged, rocky coastline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a massive column of white spray erupting from the wave crash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall tone of the video a cold monochrome with only dazzling white flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761474370956421 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261474370956421 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761474370956421, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761474370956421, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10022525489330292, + 0.036511071026325226, + 0.09209651499986649, + 0.024389469996094704, + 0.2908138036727905, + 0.1723286658525467, + 0.11136078089475632, + 0.03706848621368408, + 0.07082069665193558, + 0.06438528001308441 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761474370956421 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, low-angle shot captures an apocalyptic scene. In the sky, thick, inky storm clouds piled up, nearly reaching the sea level, only a hint of eerie cold light piercing the horizon. Beneath this oppressive canopy, a mountain-like wave relentlessly pressed against the rugged, rocky coastline. This towering wall of water, a deep turquoise, its surface wrinkled and creased, crowned by a roiling crest of chaotic white foam, resembles a moving, angry mountain range of crystal. As the wave crashes with thunderous force against the dark, slippery rocks, eroded by the sea, it erupts with astonishing force, sending up a massive column of white spray and foam that nearly touches the clouds. Countless tons of seawater are ripped into billions of crystalline droplets in the air, cascading down to rejoin the surging ocean below. The entire picture presents a cold monochrome tone in the dim light, with only the dazzling white flashing when the waves splash, creating a majestic, primitive and awe-inspiring tense atmosphere, full of the irresistible wild power of nature.", + "seed": 27260, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_7/index_4618_seed_27260_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.18320133225061, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18320133225061, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18320133225061, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky filled with thick, inky storm clouds reaching near sea level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turquoise wave crashing against a rugged, rocky coastline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a massive column of white spray erupting from the wave crash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall tone of the video a cold monochrome with only dazzling white flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.24342194199562073 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7434219121932983 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.24342194199562073, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.24342194199562073, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15601545572280884, + 0.08165600150823593, + 0.054566219449043274, + 0.27271950244903564, + 0.10085909068584442, + 0.06850973516702652, + 0.03660282865166664, + 0.049478109925985336, + 0.07291224598884583, + 0.10668075829744339 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.24342194199562073 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky filled with thick, inky storm clouds reaching near sea level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turquoise wave crashing against a rugged, rocky coastline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a massive column of white spray erupting from the wave crash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall tone of the video a cold monochrome with only dazzling white flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08911274373531342 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4641127586364746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08911274373531342, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08911274373531342, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2347051352262497, + 0.06293874979019165, + 0.051626045256853104, + 0.09497938305139542, + 0.049222204834222794, + 0.032857779413461685, + 0.08959338068962097, + 0.12426353991031647, + 0.08674385398626328, + 0.1730699986219406 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08911274373531342 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky filled with thick, inky storm clouds reaching near sea level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turquoise wave crashing against a rugged, rocky coastline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a massive column of white spray erupting from the wave crash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall tone of the video a cold monochrome with only dazzling white flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032043324317783117 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753204345703125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032043324317783117, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032043324317783117, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11069021373987198, + 0.14340810477733612, + 0.05382240563631058, + 0.18978844583034515, + 0.05426163226366043, + 0.09031276404857635, + 0.045537661761045456, + 0.09619219601154327, + 0.16997995972633362, + 0.046006619930267334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032043324317783117 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky filled with thick, inky storm clouds reaching near sea level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turquoise wave crashing against a rugged, rocky coastline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a massive column of white spray erupting from the wave crash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall tone of the video a cold monochrome with only dazzling white flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004102980252355337 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504103183746338 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004102980252355337, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004102980252355337, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05766351893544197, + 0.02943742275238037, + 0.03947163000702858, + 0.03895079717040062, + 0.05913766101002693, + 0.24400943517684937, + 0.09370279312133789, + 0.31795093417167664, + 0.07240691781044006, + 0.04726890102028847 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004102980252355337 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sky filled with thick, inky storm clouds reaching near sea level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive turquoise wave crashing against a rugged, rocky coastline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a massive column of white spray erupting from the wave crash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall tone of the video a cold monochrome with only dazzling white flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761646628379822 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261646628379822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761646628379822, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761646628379822, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17510470747947693, + 0.0590783916413784, + 0.04019593447446823, + 0.08909446746110916, + 0.03114025481045246, + 0.16099709272384644, + 0.23012234270572662, + 0.08873789757490158, + 0.04842425882816315, + 0.0771046057343483 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761646628379822 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_8/index_tensor([1986, 1986])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_8/index_tensor([1986, 1986])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..14a8bfc2ee48d5ecc55b9cf3022df319125587c3 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_8/index_tensor([1986, 1986])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up, static shot captured with a miniature effect, pinpoints the sharp focus of a loving mother hen. Her fluffy feathers are a warm white and soft brown, and beneath a small, healthy red comb, a pair of bright black eyes are filled with gentle concentration. Standing on the dry earth, she leans slightly forward, carefully and methodically dipping her sharp, pale yellow beak into a small pile of golden millet and mixed grains before her. With a series of delicate, gentle pecks and pushes, she spreads the grains evenly on the ground, preparing them for the upcoming feeding. Soft, diffused natural light evenly illuminates the scene, highlighting the fluffy texture of her feathers and making each grain shimmer. In the background, a beautifully blurred farmyard appears, its weathered wooden fence and scattered green grass rendered as soft, abstract blocks of color. The entire painting is lightly desaturated, with earthy browns, soft yellows, and soft whites dominating, creating a warm atmosphere of tranquility, peace, and maternal care.", + "seed": 27805, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_8/index_1986_seed_27805_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03048069793730974, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03048069793730974, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03048069793730974, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mother hen with fluffy white and soft brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hen standing on dry earth and leaning forward to dip her pale yellow beak into a pile of golden millet and mixed grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hen perform delicate, gentle pecks and pushes to spread the grains evenly on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred farmyard with a weathered wooden fence and scattered green grass rendered as soft, abstract blocks of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image style a miniature effect with soft, diffused natural light and a lightly desaturated palette of earthy browns, soft yellows, and soft whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043670449405908585 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168670415878296 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043670449405908585, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043670449405908585, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15316195785999298, + 0.12060903012752533, + 0.04295804351568222, + 0.07104364782571793, + 0.07204336673021317, + 0.29688990116119385, + 0.08673059195280075, + 0.05659760534763336, + 0.07568958401679993, + 0.02427636831998825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043670449405908585 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mother hen with fluffy white and soft brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hen standing on dry earth and leaning forward to dip her pale yellow beak into a pile of golden millet and mixed grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hen perform delicate, gentle pecks and pushes to spread the grains evenly on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred farmyard with a weathered wooden fence and scattered green grass rendered as soft, abstract blocks of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image style a miniature effect with soft, diffused natural light and a lightly desaturated palette of earthy browns, soft yellows, and soft whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007638413459062576 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882638454437256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007638413459062576, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007638413459062576, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15414544939994812, + 0.05574430152773857, + 0.03255387768149376, + 0.07189077138900757, + 0.04808000475168228, + 0.0512504018843174, + 0.21605472266674042, + 0.0895669087767601, + 0.2203981876373291, + 0.060315389186143875 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007638413459062576 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mother hen with fluffy white and soft brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hen standing on dry earth and leaning forward to dip her pale yellow beak into a pile of golden millet and mixed grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hen perform delicate, gentle pecks and pushes to spread the grains evenly on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred farmyard with a weathered wooden fence and scattered green grass rendered as soft, abstract blocks of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image style a miniature effect with soft, diffused natural light and a lightly desaturated palette of earthy browns, soft yellows, and soft whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07896047085523605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578960418701172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07896047085523605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07896047085523605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10495476424694061, + 0.05575460195541382, + 0.0341804139316082, + 0.03437785804271698, + 0.0340336374938488, + 0.20155473053455353, + 0.12384983152151108, + 0.07600854337215424, + 0.31627362966537476, + 0.01901192218065262 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07896047085523605 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mother hen with fluffy white and soft brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hen standing on dry earth and leaning forward to dip her pale yellow beak into a pile of golden millet and mixed grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hen perform delicate, gentle pecks and pushes to spread the grains evenly on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred farmyard with a weathered wooden fence and scattered green grass rendered as soft, abstract blocks of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image style a miniature effect with soft, diffused natural light and a lightly desaturated palette of earthy browns, soft yellows, and soft whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011067431420087814 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110673904418945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011067431420087814, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011067431420087814, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2501351535320282, + 0.0928071141242981, + 0.04765430837869644, + 0.05214622989296913, + 0.03423270210623741, + 0.05880767107009888, + 0.1359882801771164, + 0.13623066246509552, + 0.137010395526886, + 0.05498750880360603 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011067431420087814 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mother hen with fluffy white and soft brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hen standing on dry earth and leaning forward to dip her pale yellow beak into a pile of golden millet and mixed grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hen perform delicate, gentle pecks and pushes to spread the grains evenly on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred farmyard with a weathered wooden fence and scattered green grass rendered as soft, abstract blocks of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image style a miniature effect with soft, diffused natural light and a lightly desaturated palette of earthy browns, soft yellows, and soft whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011066724546253681 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511066913604736 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011066724546253681, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011066724546253681, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17504559457302094, + 0.056818824261426926, + 0.023790542036294937, + 0.009136349894106388, + 0.032136302441358566, + 0.2715637981891632, + 0.08462309092283249, + 0.18685929477214813, + 0.1292797029018402, + 0.03074643574655056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011066724546253681 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, static shot captured with a miniature effect, pinpoints the sharp focus of a loving mother hen. Her fluffy feathers are a warm white and soft brown, and beneath a small, healthy red comb, a pair of bright black eyes are filled with gentle concentration. Standing on the dry earth, she leans slightly forward, carefully and methodically dipping her sharp, pale yellow beak into a small pile of golden millet and mixed grains before her. With a series of delicate, gentle pecks and pushes, she spreads the grains evenly on the ground, preparing them for the upcoming feeding. Soft, diffused natural light evenly illuminates the scene, highlighting the fluffy texture of her feathers and making each grain shimmer. In the background, a beautifully blurred farmyard appears, its weathered wooden fence and scattered green grass rendered as soft, abstract blocks of color. The entire painting is lightly desaturated, with earthy browns, soft yellows, and soft whites dominating, creating a warm atmosphere of tranquility, peace, and maternal care.", + "seed": 27806, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_8/index_1986_seed_27806_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.030625149421393872, + "vlm_logprob": -0.030625149421393872, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.030625149421393872, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mother hen with fluffy white and soft brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hen standing on dry earth and leaning forward to dip her pale yellow beak into a pile of golden millet and mixed grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hen perform delicate, gentle pecks and pushes to spread the grains evenly on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred farmyard with a weathered wooden fence and scattered green grass rendered as soft, abstract blocks of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image style a miniature effect with soft, diffused natural light and a lightly desaturated palette of earthy browns, soft yellows, and soft whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01899060420691967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018990516662598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01899060420691967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01899060420691967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15044479072093964, + 0.12454201281070709, + 0.04640441760420799, + 0.09766063094139099, + 0.31061166524887085, + 0.05742110684514046, + 0.05232648551464081, + 0.07102257013320923, + 0.05930856987833977, + 0.030257752165198326 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01899060420691967 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mother hen with fluffy white and soft brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hen standing on dry earth and leaning forward to dip her pale yellow beak into a pile of golden millet and mixed grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hen perform delicate, gentle pecks and pushes to spread the grains evenly on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred farmyard with a weathered wooden fence and scattered green grass rendered as soft, abstract blocks of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image style a miniature effect with soft, diffused natural light and a lightly desaturated palette of earthy browns, soft yellows, and soft whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005260909907519817 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255260944366455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005260909907519817, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005260909907519817, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05054622143507004, + 0.018324371427297592, + 0.033913347870111465, + 0.01842550002038479, + 0.261617511510849, + 0.11397229135036469, + 0.1418350785970688, + 0.08519721776247025, + 0.20110617578029633, + 0.07506228983402252 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005260909907519817 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mother hen with fluffy white and soft brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hen standing on dry earth and leaning forward to dip her pale yellow beak into a pile of golden millet and mixed grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hen perform delicate, gentle pecks and pushes to spread the grains evenly on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred farmyard with a weathered wooden fence and scattered green grass rendered as soft, abstract blocks of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image style a miniature effect with soft, diffused natural light and a lightly desaturated palette of earthy browns, soft yellows, and soft whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10028519481420517 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350285291671753 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10028519481420517, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10028519481420517, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05780889466404915, + 0.01719607040286064, + 0.034847941249608994, + 0.027712441980838776, + 0.2662223279476166, + 0.08096080273389816, + 0.10620926320552826, + 0.047729820013046265, + 0.2798828184604645, + 0.08142966032028198 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10028519481420517 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mother hen with fluffy white and soft brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hen standing on dry earth and leaning forward to dip her pale yellow beak into a pile of golden millet and mixed grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hen perform delicate, gentle pecks and pushes to spread the grains evenly on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred farmyard with a weathered wooden fence and scattered green grass rendered as soft, abstract blocks of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image style a miniature effect with soft, diffused natural light and a lightly desaturated palette of earthy browns, soft yellows, and soft whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01605921797454357 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141059398651123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01605921797454357, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01605921797454357, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.027274398133158684, + 0.015641767531633377, + 0.009034903720021248, + 0.00959660205990076, + 0.6365054249763489, + 0.014525257050991058, + 0.041808728128671646, + 0.030242981389164925, + 0.19578351080417633, + 0.0195864699780941 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01605921797454357 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mother hen with fluffy white and soft brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hen standing on dry earth and leaning forward to dip her pale yellow beak into a pile of golden millet and mixed grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hen perform delicate, gentle pecks and pushes to spread the grains evenly on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred farmyard with a weathered wooden fence and scattered green grass rendered as soft, abstract blocks of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image style a miniature effect with soft, diffused natural light and a lightly desaturated palette of earthy browns, soft yellows, and soft whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012529820203781128 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875298500061035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012529820203781128, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012529820203781128, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05475939065217972, + 0.03249600902199745, + 0.014740221202373505, + 0.026672238484025, + 0.30337437987327576, + 0.03441767767071724, + 0.08024989068508148, + 0.11695045232772827, + 0.28772926330566406, + 0.04861048236489296 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012529820203781128 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, static shot captured with a miniature effect, pinpoints the sharp focus of a loving mother hen. Her fluffy feathers are a warm white and soft brown, and beneath a small, healthy red comb, a pair of bright black eyes are filled with gentle concentration. Standing on the dry earth, she leans slightly forward, carefully and methodically dipping her sharp, pale yellow beak into a small pile of golden millet and mixed grains before her. With a series of delicate, gentle pecks and pushes, she spreads the grains evenly on the ground, preparing them for the upcoming feeding. Soft, diffused natural light evenly illuminates the scene, highlighting the fluffy texture of her feathers and making each grain shimmer. In the background, a beautifully blurred farmyard appears, its weathered wooden fence and scattered green grass rendered as soft, abstract blocks of color. The entire painting is lightly desaturated, with earthy browns, soft yellows, and soft whites dominating, creating a warm atmosphere of tranquility, peace, and maternal care.", + "seed": 27807, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_8/index_1986_seed_27807_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.041299850773066284, + "vlm_logprob": -0.041299850773066284, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.041299850773066284, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mother hen with fluffy white and soft brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hen standing on dry earth and leaning forward to dip her pale yellow beak into a pile of golden millet and mixed grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hen perform delicate, gentle pecks and pushes to spread the grains evenly on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred farmyard with a weathered wooden fence and scattered green grass rendered as soft, abstract blocks of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image style a miniature effect with soft, diffused natural light and a lightly desaturated palette of earthy browns, soft yellows, and soft whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01669718138873577 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141697406768799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01669718138873577, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01669718138873577, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10726768523454666, + 0.23477576673030853, + 0.07242070138454437, + 0.04790402576327324, + 0.05812066048383713, + 0.18059298396110535, + 0.1144806295633316, + 0.0664583072066307, + 0.042904071509838104, + 0.07507512718439102 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01669718138873577 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mother hen with fluffy white and soft brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hen standing on dry earth and leaning forward to dip her pale yellow beak into a pile of golden millet and mixed grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hen perform delicate, gentle pecks and pushes to spread the grains evenly on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred farmyard with a weathered wooden fence and scattered green grass rendered as soft, abstract blocks of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image style a miniature effect with soft, diffused natural light and a lightly desaturated palette of earthy browns, soft yellows, and soft whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014206935651600361 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264206886291504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014206935651600361, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014206935651600361, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0874461755156517, + 0.13091404736042023, + 0.13462696969509125, + 0.21248859167099, + 0.12967292964458466, + 0.11732293665409088, + 0.038955479860305786, + 0.056446388363838196, + 0.060507964342832565, + 0.03161850944161415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014206935651600361 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mother hen with fluffy white and soft brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hen standing on dry earth and leaning forward to dip her pale yellow beak into a pile of golden millet and mixed grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hen perform delicate, gentle pecks and pushes to spread the grains evenly on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred farmyard with a weathered wooden fence and scattered green grass rendered as soft, abstract blocks of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image style a miniature effect with soft, diffused natural light and a lightly desaturated palette of earthy browns, soft yellows, and soft whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16034871339797974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910348653793335 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16034871339797974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16034871339797974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07887361943721771, + 0.05710790678858757, + 0.09632762521505356, + 0.18408159911632538, + 0.05571307986974716, + 0.0765799731016159, + 0.10134931653738022, + 0.20778188109397888, + 0.12073097378015518, + 0.021454056724905968 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16034871339797974 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mother hen with fluffy white and soft brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hen standing on dry earth and leaning forward to dip her pale yellow beak into a pile of golden millet and mixed grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hen perform delicate, gentle pecks and pushes to spread the grains evenly on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred farmyard with a weathered wooden fence and scattered green grass rendered as soft, abstract blocks of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image style a miniature effect with soft, diffused natural light and a lightly desaturated palette of earthy browns, soft yellows, and soft whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007623625919222832 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882623672485352 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007623625919222832, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007623625919222832, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23402725160121918, + 0.13248763978481293, + 0.060599807649850845, + 0.09884043037891388, + 0.05194190517067909, + 0.09342480450868607, + 0.048408396542072296, + 0.03580884262919426, + 0.21335825324058533, + 0.031102634966373444 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007623625919222832 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mother hen with fluffy white and soft brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hen standing on dry earth and leaning forward to dip her pale yellow beak into a pile of golden millet and mixed grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hen perform delicate, gentle pecks and pushes to spread the grains evenly on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred farmyard with a weathered wooden fence and scattered green grass rendered as soft, abstract blocks of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image style a miniature effect with soft, diffused natural light and a lightly desaturated palette of earthy browns, soft yellows, and soft whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007622797507792711 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882622718811035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007622797507792711, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007622797507792711, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16345620155334473, + 0.2020709216594696, + 0.06627557426691055, + 0.13724274933338165, + 0.10528702288866043, + 0.09414836019277573, + 0.06970792263746262, + 0.07251136004924774, + 0.0381128303706646, + 0.05118711665272713 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007622797507792711 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, static shot captured with a miniature effect, pinpoints the sharp focus of a loving mother hen. Her fluffy feathers are a warm white and soft brown, and beneath a small, healthy red comb, a pair of bright black eyes are filled with gentle concentration. Standing on the dry earth, she leans slightly forward, carefully and methodically dipping her sharp, pale yellow beak into a small pile of golden millet and mixed grains before her. With a series of delicate, gentle pecks and pushes, she spreads the grains evenly on the ground, preparing them for the upcoming feeding. Soft, diffused natural light evenly illuminates the scene, highlighting the fluffy texture of her feathers and making each grain shimmer. In the background, a beautifully blurred farmyard appears, its weathered wooden fence and scattered green grass rendered as soft, abstract blocks of color. The entire painting is lightly desaturated, with earthy browns, soft yellows, and soft whites dominating, creating a warm atmosphere of tranquility, peace, and maternal care.", + "seed": 27808, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_8/index_1986_seed_27808_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.05028900625184178, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05028900625184178, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05028900625184178, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mother hen with fluffy white and soft brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hen standing on dry earth and leaning forward to dip her pale yellow beak into a pile of golden millet and mixed grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hen perform delicate, gentle pecks and pushes to spread the grains evenly on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred farmyard with a weathered wooden fence and scattered green grass rendered as soft, abstract blocks of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image style a miniature effect with soft, diffused natural light and a lightly desaturated palette of earthy browns, soft yellows, and soft whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06263261288404465 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8126325607299805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06263261288404465, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06263261288404465, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.658398449420929, + 0.052226461470127106, + 0.0709788128733635, + 0.0200798399746418, + 0.05373961851000786, + 0.04127485305070877, + 0.024076053872704506, + 0.013412663713097572, + 0.019085217267274857, + 0.046728067100048065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06263261288404465 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mother hen with fluffy white and soft brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hen standing on dry earth and leaning forward to dip her pale yellow beak into a pile of golden millet and mixed grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hen perform delicate, gentle pecks and pushes to spread the grains evenly on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred farmyard with a weathered wooden fence and scattered green grass rendered as soft, abstract blocks of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image style a miniature effect with soft, diffused natural light and a lightly desaturated palette of earthy browns, soft yellows, and soft whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009790261276066303 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634790420532227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009790261276066303, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009790261276066303, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.8514265418052673, + 0.009441946633160114, + 0.03177102282643318, + 0.027282383292913437, + 0.01594841107726097, + 0.016911935061216354, + 0.013795037753880024, + 0.008894207887351513, + 0.010529725812375546, + 0.013998888432979584 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009790261276066303 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mother hen with fluffy white and soft brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hen standing on dry earth and leaning forward to dip her pale yellow beak into a pile of golden millet and mixed grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hen perform delicate, gentle pecks and pushes to spread the grains evenly on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred farmyard with a weathered wooden fence and scattered green grass rendered as soft, abstract blocks of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image style a miniature effect with soft, diffused natural light and a lightly desaturated palette of earthy browns, soft yellows, and soft whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603357046842575 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910335659980774 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603357046842575, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603357046842575, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6200867891311646, + 0.07094112038612366, + 0.12919305264949799, + 0.014372924342751503, + 0.013971433974802494, + 0.022706495597958565, + 0.030971864238381386, + 0.04554257169365883, + 0.03982719033956528, + 0.012386473827064037 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603357046842575 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mother hen with fluffy white and soft brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hen standing on dry earth and leaning forward to dip her pale yellow beak into a pile of golden millet and mixed grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hen perform delicate, gentle pecks and pushes to spread the grains evenly on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred farmyard with a weathered wooden fence and scattered green grass rendered as soft, abstract blocks of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image style a miniature effect with soft, diffused natural light and a lightly desaturated palette of earthy browns, soft yellows, and soft whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007621378172188997 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826212882995605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007621378172188997, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007621378172188997, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3177837133407593, + 0.038315702229738235, + 0.26262181997299194, + 0.05339672043919563, + 0.09113989770412445, + 0.02122591622173786, + 0.03559268265962601, + 0.10670008510351181, + 0.028066027909517288, + 0.04515735059976578 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007621378172188997 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a mother hen with fluffy white and soft brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hen standing on dry earth and leaning forward to dip her pale yellow beak into a pile of golden millet and mixed grains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hen perform delicate, gentle pecks and pushes to spread the grains evenly on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred farmyard with a weathered wooden fence and scattered green grass rendered as soft, abstract blocks of color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image style a miniature effect with soft, diffused natural light and a lightly desaturated palette of earthy browns, soft yellows, and soft whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011065074242651463 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110650062561035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011065074242651463, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011065074242651463, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7733672261238098, + 0.014253788627684116, + 0.05231233313679695, + 0.02025805413722992, + 0.055114973336458206, + 0.018191298469901085, + 0.008906656876206398, + 0.023245347663760185, + 0.012429528869688511, + 0.021920787170529366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011065074242651463 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_9/index_tensor([149, 149])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_9/index_tensor([149, 149])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9af3723108b27ba262192b9425af96e276fab729 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_9/index_tensor([149, 149])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "At dusk, a static, low-angle, wide-angle shot captures a lone figure on a Parisian basketball court, creating a scene of profound solitude and elegance. In the background, the iconic silhouette of the Eiffel Tower is clearly visible against the stunning sunset, its iron latticework appearing a stark black against the bright sky, tinged with hues of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and soft violet. In the foreground, the athlete, rendered almost in silhouette by the powerful backlight, maintains a low, focused stance in a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts. The figure deftly dribbles a classic orange basketball with fluid precision; the pebbled leather surface is barely discernible as it blurs, moving from a low, rhythmic thump on the worn asphalt court to a rapid cross between the legs. The warm, dramatic light of the setting sun casts long shadows and creates a bright rim light around the figure's body, highlighting their concentrated energy and the sweat on their brow. The atmosphere is one of quiet, solitary passion, blending the implicit rhythmic sound of the dribbling ball with the quiet grandeur of the city. As the last vibrant colors of sunset deepen into dusk, the entire scene slowly and steadily fades, light and image disappearing until only utter black remains.", + "seed": 23578, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_9/index_149_seed_23578_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.7240920137614012, + "vlm_logprob": -0.7240920137614012, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.7240920137614012, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a Parisian basketball court with the Eiffel Tower visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts while dribbling an orange basketball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the basketball move from a low dribble on the asphalt to a rapid cross between the legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene slowly and steadily fade to utter black as the sunset deepens into dusk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048964738845825 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048964716494083405 + ], + "logprob_reward": -3.048964738845825, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -3.048964738845825, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3856726586818695, + 0.09188562631607056, + 0.06404965370893478, + 0.1078239381313324, + 0.07996512949466705, + 0.08951881527900696, + 0.03725554794073105, + 0.10750662535429001, + 0.017287738621234894, + 0.019034240394830704 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -3.048964738845825 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a Parisian basketball court with the Eiffel Tower visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts while dribbling an orange basketball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the basketball move from a low dribble on the asphalt to a rapid cross between the legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene slowly and steadily fade to utter black as the sunset deepens into dusk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0622485876083374 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812248706817627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0622485876083374, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0622485876083374, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.412330687046051, + 0.08330141007900238, + 0.07370539009571075, + 0.06958641111850739, + 0.07043524086475372, + 0.0720881000161171, + 0.03869296610355377, + 0.09799923747777939, + 0.06092062592506409, + 0.020939955487847328 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0622485876083374 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a Parisian basketball court with the Eiffel Tower visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts while dribbling an orange basketball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the basketball move from a low dribble on the asphalt to a rapid cross between the legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene slowly and steadily fade to utter black as the sunset deepens into dusk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018218325451016426 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018218517303467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018218325451016426, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018218325451016426, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.43227171897888184, + 0.08383527398109436, + 0.06147221103310585, + 0.08265401422977448, + 0.07686716318130493, + 0.0735965222120285, + 0.04571183770895004, + 0.09818125516176224, + 0.021478652954101562, + 0.023931270465254784 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018218325451016426 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a Parisian basketball court with the Eiffel Tower visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts while dribbling an orange basketball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the basketball move from a low dribble on the asphalt to a rapid cross between the legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene slowly and steadily fade to utter black as the sunset deepens into dusk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062062401324510574 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120625019073486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062062401324510574, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062062401324510574, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35273870825767517, + 0.11491811275482178, + 0.05923512950539589, + 0.07708264887332916, + 0.051353637129068375, + 0.09093859046697617, + 0.04253552481532097, + 0.08647260069847107, + 0.03563205897808075, + 0.08909297734498978 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062062401324510574 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a Parisian basketball court with the Eiffel Tower visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts while dribbling an orange basketball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the basketball move from a low dribble on the asphalt to a rapid cross between the legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene slowly and steadily fade to utter black as the sunset deepens into dusk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289660155773163 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539660453796387 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4289660155773163, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4289660155773163, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27095547318458557, + 0.11299745738506317, + 0.04379240795969963, + 0.09267593920230865, + 0.08058854192495346, + 0.09487652033567429, + 0.046911634504795074, + 0.08122432976961136, + 0.09034119546413422, + 0.08563646674156189 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4289660155773163 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "At dusk, a static, low-angle, wide-angle shot captures a lone figure on a Parisian basketball court, creating a scene of profound solitude and elegance. In the background, the iconic silhouette of the Eiffel Tower is clearly visible against the stunning sunset, its iron latticework appearing a stark black against the bright sky, tinged with hues of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and soft violet. In the foreground, the athlete, rendered almost in silhouette by the powerful backlight, maintains a low, focused stance in a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts. The figure deftly dribbles a classic orange basketball with fluid precision; the pebbled leather surface is barely discernible as it blurs, moving from a low, rhythmic thump on the worn asphalt court to a rapid cross between the legs. The warm, dramatic light of the setting sun casts long shadows and creates a bright rim light around the figure's body, highlighting their concentrated energy and the sweat on their brow. The atmosphere is one of quiet, solitary passion, blending the implicit rhythmic sound of the dribbling ball with the quiet grandeur of the city. As the last vibrant colors of sunset deepen into dusk, the entire scene slowly and steadily fades, light and image disappearing until only utter black remains.", + "seed": 23579, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_9/index_149_seed_23579_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.28517591059207914, + "vlm_logprob": -0.28517591059207914, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.28517591059207914, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a Parisian basketball court with the Eiffel Tower visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts while dribbling an orange basketball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the basketball move from a low dribble on the asphalt to a rapid cross between the legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene slowly and steadily fade to utter black as the sunset deepens into dusk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12889599800109863 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1288959980010986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12889599800109863, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12889599800109863, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13606762886047363, + 0.0513075552880764, + 0.05038289353251457, + 0.09044454991817474, + 0.0956035777926445, + 0.13409429788589478, + 0.15421470999717712, + 0.05643710494041443, + 0.0724765881896019, + 0.15897110104560852 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12889599800109863 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a Parisian basketball court with the Eiffel Tower visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts while dribbling an orange basketball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the basketball move from a low dribble on the asphalt to a rapid cross between the legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene slowly and steadily fade to utter black as the sunset deepens into dusk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0337488129734993 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087488651275635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0337488129734993, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0337488129734993, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1609194576740265, + 0.1475309282541275, + 0.05449313297867775, + 0.13175521790981293, + 0.06045154482126236, + 0.04908540099859238, + 0.07511918246746063, + 0.09918278455734253, + 0.14049357175827026, + 0.08096875995397568 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0337488129734993 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a Parisian basketball court with the Eiffel Tower visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts while dribbling an orange basketball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the basketball move from a low dribble on the asphalt to a rapid cross between the legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene slowly and steadily fade to utter black as the sunset deepens into dusk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009802419692277908 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634802341461182 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009802419692277908, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009802419692277908, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08949218690395355, + 0.05921647325158119, + 0.04312867671251297, + 0.16574421525001526, + 0.06583482772111893, + 0.0981127917766571, + 0.13141657412052155, + 0.09199297428131104, + 0.18756559491157532, + 0.06749569624662399 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009802419692277908 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a Parisian basketball court with the Eiffel Tower visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts while dribbling an orange basketball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the basketball move from a low dribble on the asphalt to a rapid cross between the legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene slowly and steadily fade to utter black as the sunset deepens into dusk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029802370816469193 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298023223876953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029802370816469193, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029802370816469193, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0576326921582222, + 0.09858354181051254, + 0.07410711795091629, + 0.1718415468931198, + 0.05206699296832085, + 0.04457575082778931, + 0.1372625231742859, + 0.038489390164613724, + 0.2695799171924591, + 0.05586051940917969 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029802370816469193 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a Parisian basketball court with the Eiffel Tower visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts while dribbling an orange basketball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the basketball move from a low dribble on the asphalt to a rapid cross between the legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene slowly and steadily fade to utter black as the sunset deepens into dusk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236299514770508 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486299216747284 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2236299514770508, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2236299514770508, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09494383633136749, + 0.058407995849847794, + 0.06625709682703018, + 0.14313486218452454, + 0.04279699549078941, + 0.06419620662927628, + 0.04175318777561188, + 0.05324690416455269, + 0.24882102012634277, + 0.18644185364246368 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2236299514770508 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "At dusk, a static, low-angle, wide-angle shot captures a lone figure on a Parisian basketball court, creating a scene of profound solitude and elegance. In the background, the iconic silhouette of the Eiffel Tower is clearly visible against the stunning sunset, its iron latticework appearing a stark black against the bright sky, tinged with hues of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and soft violet. In the foreground, the athlete, rendered almost in silhouette by the powerful backlight, maintains a low, focused stance in a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts. The figure deftly dribbles a classic orange basketball with fluid precision; the pebbled leather surface is barely discernible as it blurs, moving from a low, rhythmic thump on the worn asphalt court to a rapid cross between the legs. The warm, dramatic light of the setting sun casts long shadows and creates a bright rim light around the figure's body, highlighting their concentrated energy and the sweat on their brow. The atmosphere is one of quiet, solitary passion, blending the implicit rhythmic sound of the dribbling ball with the quiet grandeur of the city. As the last vibrant colors of sunset deepen into dusk, the entire scene slowly and steadily fades, light and image disappearing until only utter black remains.", + "seed": 23580, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_9/index_149_seed_23580_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.4177575347945094, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4177575347945094, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4177575347945094, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a Parisian basketball court with the Eiffel Tower visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts while dribbling an orange basketball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the basketball move from a low dribble on the asphalt to a rapid cross between the legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene slowly and steadily fade to utter black as the sunset deepens into dusk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4069721698760986 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2819722294807434 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.4069721698760986, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -1.4069721698760986, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24731940031051636, + 0.04832574725151062, + 0.06615396589040756, + 0.34041208028793335, + 0.033450040966272354, + 0.010252576321363449, + 0.04453679919242859, + 0.16629450023174286, + 0.027397746220231056, + 0.015857139602303505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.4069721698760986 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a Parisian basketball court with the Eiffel Tower visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts while dribbling an orange basketball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the basketball move from a low dribble on the asphalt to a rapid cross between the legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene slowly and steadily fade to utter black as the sunset deepens into dusk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0550239123404026 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300239086151123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0550239123404026, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0550239123404026, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22023846209049225, + 0.12841662764549255, + 0.09515994042158127, + 0.26002100110054016, + 0.05012492090463638, + 0.04862264543771744, + 0.028996353968977928, + 0.10731964558362961, + 0.03639388829469681, + 0.024706516414880753 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0550239123404026 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a Parisian basketball court with the Eiffel Tower visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts while dribbling an orange basketball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the basketball move from a low dribble on the asphalt to a rapid cross between the legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene slowly and steadily fade to utter black as the sunset deepens into dusk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01255148183554411 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387551307678223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01255148183554411, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01255148183554411, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22981202602386475, + 0.09443358331918716, + 0.07068796455860138, + 0.2966511845588684, + 0.035335663706064224, + 0.02249317429959774, + 0.09326618909835815, + 0.06569136679172516, + 0.07051175087690353, + 0.02111707627773285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01255148183554411 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a Parisian basketball court with the Eiffel Tower visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts while dribbling an orange basketball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the basketball move from a low dribble on the asphalt to a rapid cross between the legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene slowly and steadily fade to utter black as the sunset deepens into dusk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038096725940704346 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880966663360596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038096725940704346, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038096725940704346, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13180498778820038, + 0.03616051375865936, + 0.10045126080513, + 0.17292271554470062, + 0.048653289675712585, + 0.03845936059951782, + 0.05465773120522499, + 0.24827849864959717, + 0.14265920221805573, + 0.02595243789255619 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038096725940704346 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a Parisian basketball court with the Eiffel Tower visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts while dribbling an orange basketball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the basketball move from a low dribble on the asphalt to a rapid cross between the legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene slowly and steadily fade to utter black as the sunset deepens into dusk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761433839797974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261433839797974 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761433839797974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761433839797974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15394550561904907, + 0.05847826600074768, + 0.08035805076360703, + 0.21970216929912567, + 0.03138481453061104, + 0.027123138308525085, + 0.038639865815639496, + 0.25672459602355957, + 0.07848105579614639, + 0.055162496864795685 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761433839797974 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "At dusk, a static, low-angle, wide-angle shot captures a lone figure on a Parisian basketball court, creating a scene of profound solitude and elegance. In the background, the iconic silhouette of the Eiffel Tower is clearly visible against the stunning sunset, its iron latticework appearing a stark black against the bright sky, tinged with hues of fiery orange, deep burgundy, and soft violet. In the foreground, the athlete, rendered almost in silhouette by the powerful backlight, maintains a low, focused stance in a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts. The figure deftly dribbles a classic orange basketball with fluid precision; the pebbled leather surface is barely discernible as it blurs, moving from a low, rhythmic thump on the worn asphalt court to a rapid cross between the legs. The warm, dramatic light of the setting sun casts long shadows and creates a bright rim light around the figure's body, highlighting their concentrated energy and the sweat on their brow. The atmosphere is one of quiet, solitary passion, blending the implicit rhythmic sound of the dribbling ball with the quiet grandeur of the city. As the last vibrant colors of sunset deepen into dusk, the entire scene slowly and steadily fades, light and image disappearing until only utter black remains.", + "seed": 23581, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000002/group_9/index_149_seed_23581_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.3157387154176831, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3157387154176831, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3157387154176831, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a Parisian basketball court with the Eiffel Tower visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts while dribbling an orange basketball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the basketball move from a low dribble on the asphalt to a rapid cross between the legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene slowly and steadily fade to utter black as the sunset deepens into dusk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47590500116348267 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9759050011634827 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47590500116348267, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47590500116348267, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09374222159385681, + 0.03920073062181473, + 0.07594890147447586, + 0.07131996750831604, + 0.14228321611881256, + 0.5066892504692078, + 0.01358327828347683, + 0.02393449656665325, + 0.01957455463707447, + 0.013723423704504967 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47590500116348267 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a Parisian basketball court with the Eiffel Tower visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts while dribbling an orange basketball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the basketball move from a low dribble on the asphalt to a rapid cross between the legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene slowly and steadily fade to utter black as the sunset deepens into dusk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07007727771997452 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950771808624268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07007727771997452, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07007727771997452, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08153966069221497, + 0.0337960422039032, + 0.26414868235588074, + 0.0954870879650116, + 0.025167526677250862, + 0.4284050166606903, + 0.010037864558398724, + 0.018000036478042603, + 0.018962683156132698, + 0.024455413222312927 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07007727771997452 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a Parisian basketball court with the Eiffel Tower visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts while dribbling an orange basketball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the basketball move from a low dribble on the asphalt to a rapid cross between the legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene slowly and steadily fade to utter black as the sunset deepens into dusk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978990737348795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634789943695068 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978990737348795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978990737348795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07603518664836884, + 0.03625427559018135, + 0.07666435092687607, + 0.116478331387043, + 0.11325155943632126, + 0.34771430492401123, + 0.025136031210422516, + 0.0799073800444603, + 0.08262700587511063, + 0.04593152552843094 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978990737348795 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a Parisian basketball court with the Eiffel Tower visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts while dribbling an orange basketball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the basketball move from a low dribble on the asphalt to a rapid cross between the legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene slowly and steadily fade to utter black as the sunset deepens into dusk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865194112062454 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048651933670044 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865194112062454, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865194112062454, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06896758824586868, + 0.03174183517694473, + 0.39047694206237793, + 0.06514415889978409, + 0.07606776803731918, + 0.16421714425086975, + 0.025332514196634293, + 0.039969488978385925, + 0.0578996017575264, + 0.0801829993724823 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865194112062454 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a Parisian basketball court with the Eiffel Tower visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a static, low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark sleeveless basketball jersey and shorts while dribbling an orange basketball?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the basketball move from a low dribble on the asphalt to a rapid cross between the legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene slowly and steadily fade to utter black as the sunset deepens into dusk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.974269449710846 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47426944971084595 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.974269449710846, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.974269449710846, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03697701171040535, + 0.030571047216653824, + 0.286192923784256, + 0.08000145107507706, + 0.03084251470863819, + 0.3950962424278259, + 0.012348347343504429, + 0.019488368183374405, + 0.022631919011473656, + 0.08585017919540405 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.974269449710846 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_0/index_tensor([9339, 9339])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_0/index_tensor([9339, 9339])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6e1a06576c2292e95c48737a23dff2f72006c8d1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_0/index_tensor([9339, 9339])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "macro close-up shot from a slight upward angle, completely still, as if silently observing a deep-sea probe, captures the scene of a giant Japanese spider crab on the inky black seabed. The entire image is rendered in a deeply desaturated black and white. A single, intense light source, emanating from outside the frame, sculpts the uneven texture of its carapace, riddled with nodules, pits, and the scars of time. This creates piercing highlights on the protrusions and deep shadows in the crevices. Its disproportionately long limbs, like delicate robotic arms, move steadily and methodically, each joint flexing and extending with an inorganic precision. When their pointed tips touch the soft seabed covered in fine sediment, they stir up tiny clouds of suspended dust. As its limbs found stable support points one by one, its huge body slowly sank, and finally settled in this quiet and oppressive alien world. The strong contrast of light and shadow outlined a majestic form that was both grotesque and full of primitive vitality, creating an awe-inspiring atmosphere of deep-sea loneliness.", + "seed": 18934, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_0/index_9339_seed_18934_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06562622739002108, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06562622739002108, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.274999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06562622739002108, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a giant Japanese spider crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an inky black seabed covered in fine sediment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire image rendered in a deeply desaturated black and white style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a single intense light source from outside the frame create piercing highlights and deep shadows on the crab's textured carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain completely still while the crab's limbs move methodically and its body slowly sinks to settle on the seabed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1471782922744751 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0221781730651855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1471782922744751, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1471782922744751, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14262203872203827, + 0.024438459426164627, + 0.030209528282284737, + 0.09716520458459854, + 0.14096136391162872, + 0.09859280288219452, + 0.04903377592563629, + 0.32349300384521484, + 0.05584164336323738, + 0.03764224797487259 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1471782922744751 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a giant Japanese spider crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an inky black seabed covered in fine sediment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire image rendered in a deeply desaturated black and white style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a single intense light source from outside the frame create piercing highlights and deep shadows on the crab's textured carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain completely still while the crab's limbs move methodically and its body slowly sinks to settle on the seabed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06208794564008713 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120880126953125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06208794564008713, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06208794564008713, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.100542351603508, + 0.13720618188381195, + 0.052874479442834854, + 0.0634848028421402, + 0.07025948911905289, + 0.04306786507368088, + 0.04150275141000748, + 0.3850730061531067, + 0.060065608471632004, + 0.04592344909906387 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06208794564008713 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a giant Japanese spider crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an inky black seabed covered in fine sediment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire image rendered in a deeply desaturated black and white style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a single intense light source from outside the frame create piercing highlights and deep shadows on the crab's textured carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain completely still while the crab's limbs move methodically and its body slowly sinks to settle on the seabed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01254948042333126 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38754940032959 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01254948042333126, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01254948042333126, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10006076097488403, + 0.05786411091685295, + 0.04723897576332092, + 0.05260225012898445, + 0.08543457835912704, + 0.10437162220478058, + 0.023243995383381844, + 0.2389567494392395, + 0.02881777472794056, + 0.2614092230796814 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01254948042333126 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a giant Japanese spider crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an inky black seabed covered in fine sediment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire image rendered in a deeply desaturated black and white style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a single intense light source from outside the frame create piercing highlights and deep shadows on the crab's textured carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain completely still while the crab's limbs move methodically and its body slowly sinks to settle on the seabed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005964338313788176 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130964279174805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005964338313788176, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005964338313788176, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18279045820236206, + 0.04323721304535866, + 0.039167262613773346, + 0.04629933834075928, + 0.19163382053375244, + 0.046857044100761414, + 0.02588127739727497, + 0.30462247133255005, + 0.07403738796710968, + 0.045473791658878326 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005964338313788176 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a giant Japanese spider crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an inky black seabed covered in fine sediment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire image rendered in a deeply desaturated black and white style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a single intense light source from outside the frame create piercing highlights and deep shadows on the crab's textured carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain completely still while the crab's limbs move methodically and its body slowly sinks to settle on the seabed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10035108029842377 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350351095199585 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10035108029842377, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10035108029842377, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11430928111076355, + 0.050666410475969315, + 0.05265713483095169, + 0.04150102660059929, + 0.2803484797477722, + 0.14692920446395874, + 0.046151258051395416, + 0.10674497485160828, + 0.1096421480178833, + 0.05105011537671089 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10035108029842377 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "macro close-up shot from a slight upward angle, completely still, as if silently observing a deep-sea probe, captures the scene of a giant Japanese spider crab on the inky black seabed. The entire image is rendered in a deeply desaturated black and white. A single, intense light source, emanating from outside the frame, sculpts the uneven texture of its carapace, riddled with nodules, pits, and the scars of time. This creates piercing highlights on the protrusions and deep shadows in the crevices. Its disproportionately long limbs, like delicate robotic arms, move steadily and methodically, each joint flexing and extending with an inorganic precision. When their pointed tips touch the soft seabed covered in fine sediment, they stir up tiny clouds of suspended dust. As its limbs found stable support points one by one, its huge body slowly sank, and finally settled in this quiet and oppressive alien world. The strong contrast of light and shadow outlined a majestic form that was both grotesque and full of primitive vitality, creating an awe-inspiring atmosphere of deep-sea loneliness.", + "seed": 18935, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_0/index_9339_seed_18935_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.10301470384001732, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10301470384001732, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10301470384001732, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a giant Japanese spider crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an inky black seabed covered in fine sediment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire image rendered in a deeply desaturated black and white style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a single intense light source from outside the frame create piercing highlights and deep shadows on the crab's textured carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain completely still while the crab's limbs move methodically and its body slowly sinks to settle on the seabed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08471190929412842 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.584712028503418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08471190929412842, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08471190929412842, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11618203669786453, + 0.06491514295339584, + 0.07171837985515594, + 0.37650734186172485, + 0.12151477485895157, + 0.03591879457235336, + 0.05781782418489456, + 0.03920178487896919, + 0.02532196417450905, + 0.09090196341276169 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08471190929412842 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a giant Japanese spider crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an inky black seabed covered in fine sediment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire image rendered in a deeply desaturated black and white style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a single intense light source from outside the frame create piercing highlights and deep shadows on the crab's textured carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain completely still while the crab's limbs move methodically and its body slowly sinks to settle on the seabed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.070045605301857 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950457096099854 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.070045605301857, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.070045605301857, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12974323332309723, + 0.08296053856611252, + 0.0817238911986351, + 0.18012933433055878, + 0.15545280277729034, + 0.054589930921792984, + 0.022147132083773613, + 0.04765086621046066, + 0.0352073572576046, + 0.21039488911628723 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.070045605301857 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a giant Japanese spider crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an inky black seabed covered in fine sediment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire image rendered in a deeply desaturated black and white style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a single intense light source from outside the frame create piercing highlights and deep shadows on the crab's textured carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain completely still while the crab's limbs move methodically and its body slowly sinks to settle on the seabed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2255660891532898 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005661487579346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2255660891532898, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2255660891532898, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08456817269325256, + 0.1301082968711853, + 0.1035948321223259, + 0.09788785129785538, + 0.14693094789981842, + 0.1364915817975998, + 0.025960704311728477, + 0.04993676766753197, + 0.041195813566446304, + 0.18332505226135254 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2255660891532898 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a giant Japanese spider crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an inky black seabed covered in fine sediment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire image rendered in a deeply desaturated black and white style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a single intense light source from outside the frame create piercing highlights and deep shadows on the crab's textured carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain completely still while the crab's limbs move methodically and its body slowly sinks to settle on the seabed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007647167891263962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826470375061035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007647167891263962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007647167891263962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08801765739917755, + 0.11565221101045609, + 0.10282104462385178, + 0.09664475917816162, + 0.11586679518222809, + 0.0985884889960289, + 0.0610416904091835, + 0.059548817574977875, + 0.03351696953177452, + 0.22830161452293396 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007647167891263962 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a giant Japanese spider crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an inky black seabed covered in fine sediment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire image rendered in a deeply desaturated black and white style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a single intense light source from outside the frame create piercing highlights and deep shadows on the crab's textured carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain completely still while the crab's limbs move methodically and its body slowly sinks to settle on the seabed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12710274755954742 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127102851867676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12710274755954742, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12710274755954742, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08704616874456406, + 0.049335259944200516, + 0.041278254240751266, + 0.08802955597639084, + 0.2115767002105713, + 0.05055389925837517, + 0.04566465690732002, + 0.19814153015613556, + 0.07416634261608124, + 0.15420764684677124 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12710274755954742 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "macro close-up shot from a slight upward angle, completely still, as if silently observing a deep-sea probe, captures the scene of a giant Japanese spider crab on the inky black seabed. The entire image is rendered in a deeply desaturated black and white. A single, intense light source, emanating from outside the frame, sculpts the uneven texture of its carapace, riddled with nodules, pits, and the scars of time. This creates piercing highlights on the protrusions and deep shadows in the crevices. Its disproportionately long limbs, like delicate robotic arms, move steadily and methodically, each joint flexing and extending with an inorganic precision. When their pointed tips touch the soft seabed covered in fine sediment, they stir up tiny clouds of suspended dust. As its limbs found stable support points one by one, its huge body slowly sank, and finally settled in this quiet and oppressive alien world. The strong contrast of light and shadow outlined a majestic form that was both grotesque and full of primitive vitality, creating an awe-inspiring atmosphere of deep-sea loneliness.", + "seed": 18936, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_0/index_9339_seed_18936_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.08446531044319272, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08446531044319272, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08446531044319272, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a giant Japanese spider crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an inky black seabed covered in fine sediment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire image rendered in a deeply desaturated black and white style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a single intense light source from outside the frame create piercing highlights and deep shadows on the crab's textured carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain completely still while the crab's limbs move methodically and its body slowly sinks to settle on the seabed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10756515711545944 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.35756516456604 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10756515711545944, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10756515711545944, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10231751203536987, + 0.08420763909816742, + 0.032472994178533554, + 0.22533461451530457, + 0.17758773267269135, + 0.1648683398962021, + 0.02085202746093273, + 0.055540017783641815, + 0.06870736926794052, + 0.06811175495386124 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10756515711545944 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a giant Japanese spider crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an inky black seabed covered in fine sediment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire image rendered in a deeply desaturated black and white style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a single intense light source from outside the frame create piercing highlights and deep shadows on the crab's textured carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain completely still while the crab's limbs move methodically and its body slowly sinks to settle on the seabed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07006716728210449 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950671672821045 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07006716728210449, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07006716728210449, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.164778932929039, + 0.07139711827039719, + 0.029391665011644363, + 0.03170240670442581, + 0.20180919766426086, + 0.03327922523021698, + 0.04297398403286934, + 0.1662050187587738, + 0.03907199576497078, + 0.21939049661159515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07006716728210449 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a giant Japanese spider crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an inky black seabed covered in fine sediment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire image rendered in a deeply desaturated black and white style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a single intense light source from outside the frame create piercing highlights and deep shadows on the crab's textured carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain completely still while the crab's limbs move methodically and its body slowly sinks to settle on the seabed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12705844640731812 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127058506011963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12705844640731812, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12705844640731812, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2799857258796692, + 0.155165895819664, + 0.11071566492319107, + 0.048902448266744614, + 0.15343856811523438, + 0.06242204084992409, + 0.015628894791007042, + 0.0733269676566124, + 0.05447884649038315, + 0.04593493044376373 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12705844640731812 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a giant Japanese spider crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an inky black seabed covered in fine sediment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire image rendered in a deeply desaturated black and white style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a single intense light source from outside the frame create piercing highlights and deep shadows on the crab's textured carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain completely still while the crab's limbs move methodically and its body slowly sinks to settle on the seabed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004653813783079386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.3796539306640625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004653813783079386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004653813783079386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20471246540546417, + 0.11485569179058075, + 0.13487862050533295, + 0.11748577654361725, + 0.14190950989723206, + 0.03963977470993996, + 0.019677912816405296, + 0.03251926600933075, + 0.06361118704080582, + 0.13070981204509735 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004653813783079386 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a giant Japanese spider crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an inky black seabed covered in fine sediment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire image rendered in a deeply desaturated black and white style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a single intense light source from outside the frame create piercing highlights and deep shadows on the crab's textured carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain completely still while the crab's limbs move methodically and its body slowly sinks to settle on the seabed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11298196762800217 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379820346832275 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11298196762800217, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11298196762800217, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17785263061523438, + 0.08774306625127792, + 0.07751227170228958, + 0.04784871265292168, + 0.1643303781747818, + 0.13959410786628723, + 0.06383214145898819, + 0.061443980783224106, + 0.10413794964551926, + 0.07570481300354004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11298196762800217 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "macro close-up shot from a slight upward angle, completely still, as if silently observing a deep-sea probe, captures the scene of a giant Japanese spider crab on the inky black seabed. The entire image is rendered in a deeply desaturated black and white. A single, intense light source, emanating from outside the frame, sculpts the uneven texture of its carapace, riddled with nodules, pits, and the scars of time. This creates piercing highlights on the protrusions and deep shadows in the crevices. Its disproportionately long limbs, like delicate robotic arms, move steadily and methodically, each joint flexing and extending with an inorganic precision. When their pointed tips touch the soft seabed covered in fine sediment, they stir up tiny clouds of suspended dust. As its limbs found stable support points one by one, its huge body slowly sank, and finally settled in this quiet and oppressive alien world. The strong contrast of light and shadow outlined a majestic form that was both grotesque and full of primitive vitality, creating an awe-inspiring atmosphere of deep-sea loneliness.", + "seed": 18937, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_0/index_9339_seed_18937_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.049069023109041154, + "vlm_logprob": -0.049069023109041154, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.049069023109041154, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a giant Japanese spider crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an inky black seabed covered in fine sediment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire image rendered in a deeply desaturated black and white style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a single intense light source from outside the frame create piercing highlights and deep shadows on the crab's textured carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain completely still while the crab's limbs move methodically and its body slowly sinks to settle on the seabed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06661702692508698 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.816617012023926 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06661702692508698, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06661702692508698, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08228424936532974, + 0.06886212527751923, + 0.2340105175971985, + 0.05341016873717308, + 0.19445165991783142, + 0.10107768326997757, + 0.05469762533903122, + 0.10961362719535828, + 0.07627162337303162, + 0.025320688262581825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06661702692508698 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a giant Japanese spider crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an inky black seabed covered in fine sediment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire image rendered in a deeply desaturated black and white style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a single intense light source from outside the frame create piercing highlights and deep shadows on the crab's textured carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain completely still while the crab's limbs move methodically and its body slowly sinks to settle on the seabed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029839860275387764 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298397541046143 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029839860275387764, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029839860275387764, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14515328407287598, + 0.07356906682252884, + 0.11520474404096603, + 0.04222327098250389, + 0.05492424592375755, + 0.0882052406668663, + 0.11332444846630096, + 0.04395938664674759, + 0.28986093401908875, + 0.03357531502842903 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029839860275387764 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a giant Japanese spider crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an inky black seabed covered in fine sediment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire image rendered in a deeply desaturated black and white style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a single intense light source from outside the frame create piercing highlights and deep shadows on the crab's textured carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain completely still while the crab's limbs move methodically and its body slowly sinks to settle on the seabed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001947531825862825 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251947402954102 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001947531825862825, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001947531825862825, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10072069615125656, + 0.07493624091148376, + 0.11394957453012466, + 0.01647271402180195, + 0.04519743472337723, + 0.04875817894935608, + 0.038135379552841187, + 0.03171968460083008, + 0.5076358914375305, + 0.022474270313978195 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001947531825862825 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a giant Japanese spider crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an inky black seabed covered in fine sediment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire image rendered in a deeply desaturated black and white style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a single intense light source from outside the frame create piercing highlights and deep shadows on the crab's textured carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain completely still while the crab's limbs move methodically and its body slowly sinks to settle on the seabed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004103455226868391 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504103660583496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004103455226868391, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004103455226868391, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08186672627925873, + 0.0702609121799469, + 0.3414877653121948, + 0.03439319506287575, + 0.0648198276758194, + 0.09549088776111603, + 0.08332264423370361, + 0.045664649456739426, + 0.15522485971450806, + 0.027468523010611534 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004103455226868391 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a giant Japanese spider crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on an inky black seabed covered in fine sediment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire image rendered in a deeply desaturated black and white style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a single intense light source from outside the frame create piercing highlights and deep shadows on the crab's textured carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain completely still while the crab's limbs move methodically and its body slowly sinks to settle on the seabed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14283724129199982 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178372859954834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14283724129199982, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14283724129199982, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19288434088230133, + 0.13888929784297943, + 0.18930584192276, + 0.03637658804655075, + 0.06258367002010345, + 0.05371002107858658, + 0.16711056232452393, + 0.0434049628674984, + 0.042028650641441345, + 0.07370604574680328 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14283724129199982 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_1/index_tensor([4634, 4634])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_1/index_tensor([4634, 4634])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..cceb1a0d3d4105a1bfd7e4a9bb699bcfcda32ca8 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_1/index_tensor([4634, 4634])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "high-angle, overhead shot slowly zooms out, initially focusing on a counselor clad in a dark-blue silk robe with a dark pattern. His hair is tied high in a bun, a few strands of graying hair blowing in the wind. His face is thin and serene. He stands alone, solemnly at the edge of a rocky cliff, his hands clasped behind his back, his gaze deep into the valley beyond. His robe is meticulously tailored, its collar and cuffs embroidered with intricate cloud patterns in silver thread. In the diffuse, cold light of the overcast sky, the silk reflects a subtle shimmer. A bitter wind howls up from the valley floor, stirring up dust and blowing his signature wide sleeves, which swell slowly and gracefully through the air like inky waves. As the camera zooms out, the vast landscape behind him gradually reveals itself: thousands of soldiers clad in black iron armor, arrayed in a meticulous formation, their spears immovable like a forest. Crimson battle flags flutter in the wind, creating a stark contrast between movement and stillness against the strategist's flowing sleeves. The entire scene, a desaturated, cool hue, imbued with the solemnity and awe of impending battle, underscores the strategist's composure and command of the situation before the vast enemy.", + "seed": 25609, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_1/index_4634_seed_25609_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.23120045587420462, + "vlm_logprob": -0.23120045587420462, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.23120045587420462, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle overhead view that slowly zooms out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a man wearing a dark-blue silk robe with silver cloud embroidery on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing alone at the edge of a rocky cliff with his hands clasped behind his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of soldiers in black iron armor visible in a formation behind the man, along with crimson battle flags?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a desaturated, cool hue with a bitter wind blowing dust and the man's sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0572998523712158 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4322998821735382 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0572998523712158, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0572998523712158, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2429625391960144, + 0.06405801326036453, + 0.04272552207112312, + 0.03910846635699272, + 0.039117421954870224, + 0.05786743015050888, + 0.21724094450473785, + 0.08435971289873123, + 0.0525587759912014, + 0.16000117361545563 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0572998523712158 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle overhead view that slowly zooms out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a man wearing a dark-blue silk robe with silver cloud embroidery on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing alone at the edge of a rocky cliff with his hands clasped behind his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of soldiers in black iron armor visible in a formation behind the man, along with crimson battle flags?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a desaturated, cool hue with a bitter wind blowing dust and the man's sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048716094344854355 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0487160682678223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048716094344854355, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048716094344854355, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21999293565750122, + 0.09130978584289551, + 0.06751703470945358, + 0.04731873795390129, + 0.16856306791305542, + 0.08910262584686279, + 0.07371723651885986, + 0.11583827435970306, + 0.04017999395728111, + 0.08646031469106674 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048716094344854355 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle overhead view that slowly zooms out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a man wearing a dark-blue silk robe with silver cloud embroidery on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing alone at the edge of a rocky cliff with his hands clasped behind his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of soldiers in black iron armor visible in a formation behind the man, along with crimson battle flags?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a desaturated, cool hue with a bitter wind blowing dust and the man's sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0263621024787426 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651362180709839 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0263621024787426, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0263621024787426, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1952948123216629, + 0.09031213074922562, + 0.03942662104964256, + 0.058966733515262604, + 0.0949769988656044, + 0.04495587199926376, + 0.24356882274150848, + 0.09739688783884048, + 0.05832795798778534, + 0.07677317410707474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0263621024787426 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle overhead view that slowly zooms out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a man wearing a dark-blue silk robe with silver cloud embroidery on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing alone at the edge of a rocky cliff with his hands clasped behind his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of soldiers in black iron armor visible in a formation behind the man, along with crimson battle flags?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a desaturated, cool hue with a bitter wind blowing dust and the man's sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011080518364906311 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511080741882324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011080518364906311, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011080518364906311, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11146757006645203, + 0.1647716909646988, + 0.040154095739126205, + 0.04420487955212593, + 0.08858633041381836, + 0.05983314290642738, + 0.13063043355941772, + 0.06321785598993301, + 0.04716324806213379, + 0.24997082352638245 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011080518364906311 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle overhead view that slowly zooms out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a man wearing a dark-blue silk robe with silver cloud embroidery on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing alone at the edge of a rocky cliff with his hands clasped behind his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of soldiers in black iron armor visible in a formation behind the man, along with crimson battle flags?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a desaturated, cool hue with a bitter wind blowing dust and the man's sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012543711811304092 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387543678283691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012543711811304092, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012543711811304092, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24132980406284332, + 0.07787292450666428, + 0.049486298114061356, + 0.03717980906367302, + 0.06734038889408112, + 0.04439722001552582, + 0.12389925122261047, + 0.06214161217212677, + 0.049774523824453354, + 0.2465781718492508 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012543711811304092 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-angle, overhead shot slowly zooms out, initially focusing on a counselor clad in a dark-blue silk robe with a dark pattern. His hair is tied high in a bun, a few strands of graying hair blowing in the wind. His face is thin and serene. He stands alone, solemnly at the edge of a rocky cliff, his hands clasped behind his back, his gaze deep into the valley beyond. His robe is meticulously tailored, its collar and cuffs embroidered with intricate cloud patterns in silver thread. In the diffuse, cold light of the overcast sky, the silk reflects a subtle shimmer. A bitter wind howls up from the valley floor, stirring up dust and blowing his signature wide sleeves, which swell slowly and gracefully through the air like inky waves. As the camera zooms out, the vast landscape behind him gradually reveals itself: thousands of soldiers clad in black iron armor, arrayed in a meticulous formation, their spears immovable like a forest. Crimson battle flags flutter in the wind, creating a stark contrast between movement and stillness against the strategist's flowing sleeves. The entire scene, a desaturated, cool hue, imbued with the solemnity and awe of impending battle, underscores the strategist's composure and command of the situation before the vast enemy.", + "seed": 25610, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_1/index_4634_seed_25610_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.15584971075877546, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15584971075877546, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15584971075877546, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle overhead view that slowly zooms out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a man wearing a dark-blue silk robe with silver cloud embroidery on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing alone at the edge of a rocky cliff with his hands clasped behind his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of soldiers in black iron armor visible in a formation behind the man, along with crimson battle flags?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a desaturated, cool hue with a bitter wind blowing dust and the man's sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6992160081863403 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6992160081863403 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6992160081863403, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6992160081863403, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5905808806419373, + 0.04417538642883301, + 0.04927355796098709, + 0.04567806050181389, + 0.03355623036623001, + 0.04415158927440643, + 0.047928161919116974, + 0.030227161943912506, + 0.08890039473772049, + 0.025528589263558388 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6992160081863403 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle overhead view that slowly zooms out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a man wearing a dark-blue silk robe with silver cloud embroidery on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing alone at the edge of a rocky cliff with his hands clasped behind his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of soldiers in black iron armor visible in a formation behind the man, along with crimson battle flags?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a desaturated, cool hue with a bitter wind blowing dust and the man's sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038137003779411316 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881369590759277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038137003779411316, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038137003779411316, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3083101511001587, + 0.07267403602600098, + 0.10380110889673233, + 0.038691092282533646, + 0.10250541567802429, + 0.036359045654535294, + 0.09157328307628632, + 0.07017720490694046, + 0.14554506540298462, + 0.030363598838448524 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038137003779411316 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle overhead view that slowly zooms out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a man wearing a dark-blue silk robe with silver cloud embroidery on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing alone at the edge of a rocky cliff with his hands clasped behind his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of soldiers in black iron armor visible in a formation behind the man, along with crimson battle flags?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a desaturated, cool hue with a bitter wind blowing dust and the man's sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016073646023869514 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141073703765869 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016073646023869514, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016073646023869514, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6068750619888306, + 0.08612240850925446, + 0.04796033725142479, + 0.08029311150312424, + 0.02588399313390255, + 0.04613075032830238, + 0.026461265981197357, + 0.03293770179152489, + 0.027103250846266747, + 0.02023211121559143 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016073646023869514 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle overhead view that slowly zooms out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a man wearing a dark-blue silk robe with silver cloud embroidery on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing alone at the edge of a rocky cliff with his hands clasped behind his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of soldiers in black iron armor visible in a formation behind the man, along with crimson battle flags?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a desaturated, cool hue with a bitter wind blowing dust and the man's sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018190698698163033 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018190860748291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018190698698163033, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018190698698163033, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.48616501688957214, + 0.0714888945221901, + 0.04332524910569191, + 0.09748432785272598, + 0.13504308462142944, + 0.05241483449935913, + 0.027096685022115707, + 0.04578018561005592, + 0.02404225617647171, + 0.017159491777420044 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018190698698163033 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle overhead view that slowly zooms out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a man wearing a dark-blue silk robe with silver cloud embroidery on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing alone at the edge of a rocky cliff with his hands clasped behind his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of soldiers in black iron armor visible in a formation behind the man, along with crimson battle flags?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a desaturated, cool hue with a bitter wind blowing dust and the man's sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007631197106093168 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882631301879883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007631197106093168, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007631197106093168, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7260448336601257, + 0.061669085174798965, + 0.025364156812429428, + 0.011532149277627468, + 0.040258441120386124, + 0.030511299148201942, + 0.0507974736392498, + 0.016615375876426697, + 0.019935322925448418, + 0.01727186143398285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007631197106093168 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-angle, overhead shot slowly zooms out, initially focusing on a counselor clad in a dark-blue silk robe with a dark pattern. His hair is tied high in a bun, a few strands of graying hair blowing in the wind. His face is thin and serene. He stands alone, solemnly at the edge of a rocky cliff, his hands clasped behind his back, his gaze deep into the valley beyond. His robe is meticulously tailored, its collar and cuffs embroidered with intricate cloud patterns in silver thread. In the diffuse, cold light of the overcast sky, the silk reflects a subtle shimmer. A bitter wind howls up from the valley floor, stirring up dust and blowing his signature wide sleeves, which swell slowly and gracefully through the air like inky waves. As the camera zooms out, the vast landscape behind him gradually reveals itself: thousands of soldiers clad in black iron armor, arrayed in a meticulous formation, their spears immovable like a forest. Crimson battle flags flutter in the wind, creating a stark contrast between movement and stillness against the strategist's flowing sleeves. The entire scene, a desaturated, cool hue, imbued with the solemnity and awe of impending battle, underscores the strategist's composure and command of the situation before the vast enemy.", + "seed": 25611, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_1/index_4634_seed_25611_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.15075470535084606, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15075470535084606, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15075470535084606, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle overhead view that slowly zooms out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a man wearing a dark-blue silk robe with silver cloud embroidery on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing alone at the edge of a rocky cliff with his hands clasped behind his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of soldiers in black iron armor visible in a formation behind the man, along with crimson battle flags?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a desaturated, cool hue with a bitter wind blowing dust and the man's sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6437830328941345 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7687830328941345 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6437830328941345, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6437830328941345, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2309437096118927, + 0.1068105399608612, + 0.27928078174591064, + 0.06569875776767731, + 0.03325597196817398, + 0.06334377080202103, + 0.05797145143151283, + 0.028022563084959984, + 0.07916054129600525, + 0.055511947721242905 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6437830328941345 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle overhead view that slowly zooms out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a man wearing a dark-blue silk robe with silver cloud embroidery on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing alone at the edge of a rocky cliff with his hands clasped behind his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of soldiers in black iron armor visible in a formation behind the man, along with crimson battle flags?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a desaturated, cool hue with a bitter wind blowing dust and the man's sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04311329871416092 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1681132316589355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04311329871416092, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04311329871416092, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2006688416004181, + 0.045894261449575424, + 0.07501859962940216, + 0.03244462609291077, + 0.08745960146188736, + 0.06848938763141632, + 0.03446885943412781, + 0.21396076679229736, + 0.03932562470436096, + 0.20226942002773285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04311329871416092 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle overhead view that slowly zooms out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a man wearing a dark-blue silk robe with silver cloud embroidery on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing alone at the edge of a rocky cliff with his hands clasped behind his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of soldiers in black iron armor visible in a formation behind the man, along with crimson battle flags?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a desaturated, cool hue with a bitter wind blowing dust and the man's sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0549725741147995 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299726486206055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0549725741147995, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0549725741147995, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1777569204568863, + 0.09215221554040909, + 0.17310501635074615, + 0.05152192711830139, + 0.027800336480140686, + 0.03706175461411476, + 0.09154373407363892, + 0.048228777945041656, + 0.039198096841573715, + 0.26163122057914734 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0549725741147995 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle overhead view that slowly zooms out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a man wearing a dark-blue silk robe with silver cloud embroidery on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing alone at the edge of a rocky cliff with his hands clasped behind his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of soldiers in black iron armor visible in a formation behind the man, along with crimson battle flags?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a desaturated, cool hue with a bitter wind blowing dust and the man's sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005950473714619875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130950450897217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005950473714619875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005950473714619875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1347901076078415, + 0.07661603391170502, + 0.15803377330303192, + 0.11474854499101639, + 0.17657087743282318, + 0.10831619054079056, + 0.06999397277832031, + 0.030881991609930992, + 0.04238365590572357, + 0.08766482770442963 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005950473714619875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle overhead view that slowly zooms out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a man wearing a dark-blue silk robe with silver cloud embroidery on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing alone at the edge of a rocky cliff with his hands clasped behind his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of soldiers in black iron armor visible in a formation behind the man, along with crimson battle flags?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a desaturated, cool hue with a bitter wind blowing dust and the man's sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005954147316515446 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130954265594482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005954147316515446, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005954147316515446, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2218310385942459, + 0.08282382041215897, + 0.053374458104372025, + 0.05614156648516655, + 0.09477708488702774, + 0.130034402012825, + 0.1611141562461853, + 0.07213342934846878, + 0.04787151515483856, + 0.07989853620529175 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005954147316515446 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-angle, overhead shot slowly zooms out, initially focusing on a counselor clad in a dark-blue silk robe with a dark pattern. His hair is tied high in a bun, a few strands of graying hair blowing in the wind. His face is thin and serene. He stands alone, solemnly at the edge of a rocky cliff, his hands clasped behind his back, his gaze deep into the valley beyond. His robe is meticulously tailored, its collar and cuffs embroidered with intricate cloud patterns in silver thread. In the diffuse, cold light of the overcast sky, the silk reflects a subtle shimmer. A bitter wind howls up from the valley floor, stirring up dust and blowing his signature wide sleeves, which swell slowly and gracefully through the air like inky waves. As the camera zooms out, the vast landscape behind him gradually reveals itself: thousands of soldiers clad in black iron armor, arrayed in a meticulous formation, their spears immovable like a forest. Crimson battle flags flutter in the wind, creating a stark contrast between movement and stillness against the strategist's flowing sleeves. The entire scene, a desaturated, cool hue, imbued with the solemnity and awe of impending battle, underscores the strategist's composure and command of the situation before the vast enemy.", + "seed": 25612, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_1/index_4634_seed_25612_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2362336039543152, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2362336039543152, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2362336039543152, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle overhead view that slowly zooms out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a man wearing a dark-blue silk robe with silver cloud embroidery on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing alone at the edge of a rocky cliff with his hands clasped behind his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of soldiers in black iron armor visible in a formation behind the man, along with crimson battle flags?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a desaturated, cool hue with a bitter wind blowing dust and the man's sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0607260465621948 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.43572601675987244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0607260465621948, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0607260465621948, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09621147811412811, + 0.07068975269794464, + 0.10411206632852554, + 0.055693164467811584, + 0.055378299206495285, + 0.041833169758319855, + 0.06434366106987, + 0.07196005433797836, + 0.11057425290346146, + 0.3292040228843689 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0607260465621948 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle overhead view that slowly zooms out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a man wearing a dark-blue silk robe with silver cloud embroidery on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing alone at the edge of a rocky cliff with his hands clasped behind his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of soldiers in black iron armor visible in a formation behind the man, along with crimson battle flags?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a desaturated, cool hue with a bitter wind blowing dust and the man's sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02061348780989647 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895613431930542 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02061348780989647, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02061348780989647, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21572987735271454, + 0.258876770734787, + 0.10413671284914017, + 0.08258964121341705, + 0.0552733913064003, + 0.04648251831531525, + 0.030785832554101944, + 0.02777004987001419, + 0.111023910343647, + 0.06733126938343048 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02061348780989647 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle overhead view that slowly zooms out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a man wearing a dark-blue silk robe with silver cloud embroidery on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing alone at the edge of a rocky cliff with his hands clasped behind his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of soldiers in black iron armor visible in a formation behind the man, along with crimson battle flags?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a desaturated, cool hue with a bitter wind blowing dust and the man's sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0381166934967041 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288116693496704 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0381166934967041, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0381166934967041, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07636990398168564, + 0.09927467256784439, + 0.17787368595600128, + 0.033571094274520874, + 0.07038380205631256, + 0.12875008583068848, + 0.05954386666417122, + 0.047988761216402054, + 0.1977280080318451, + 0.10851611196994781 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0381166934967041 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle overhead view that slowly zooms out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a man wearing a dark-blue silk robe with silver cloud embroidery on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing alone at the edge of a rocky cliff with his hands clasped behind his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of soldiers in black iron armor visible in a formation behind the man, along with crimson battle flags?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a desaturated, cool hue with a bitter wind blowing dust and the man's sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05497122183442116 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929971218109131 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05497122183442116, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05497122183442116, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06725823879241943, + 0.06106147915124893, + 0.24216297268867493, + 0.06688395887613297, + 0.1292572021484375, + 0.025475328788161278, + 0.03288932517170906, + 0.029555561020970345, + 0.32153764367103577, + 0.02391834184527397 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05497122183442116 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle overhead view that slowly zooms out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure a man wearing a dark-blue silk robe with silver cloud embroidery on the collar and cuffs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing alone at the edge of a rocky cliff with his hands clasped behind his back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of soldiers in black iron armor visible in a formation behind the man, along with crimson battle flags?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a desaturated, cool hue with a bitter wind blowing dust and the man's sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006740570068359375 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006740570068359 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006740570068359375, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006740570068359375, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2005385160446167, + 0.08003050833940506, + 0.08627251535654068, + 0.058087512850761414, + 0.08791938424110413, + 0.07987375557422638, + 0.034008320420980453, + 0.03589629381895065, + 0.08872880786657333, + 0.2486443966627121 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006740570068359375 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_10/index_tensor([8958, 8958])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_10/index_tensor([8958, 8958])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..dafd9eeec6f848e2e63f25e19ae6669bd6994eca --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_10/index_tensor([8958, 8958])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, moving medium shot delicately captures a tranquil family laundry room. A young woman, her hair casually tied in a warm, brown bun, dressed in a loose white cotton T-shirt and gray yoga pants, hunches slightly over a gleaming, white, drum-type washing machine, its round glass door open. Above her head, a simple, white, three-bladed ceiling fan spins silently and slowly, its rotation barely creating any wind, adding a subtle touch of movement to the otherwise still image. Soft afternoon sunlight slants in through an off-screen window, sculpting wisps of dust in the air and casting a warm, comforting golden glow over the entire scene. Carefully, she reaches deep into the washing machine's damp drum, grasping a tangled mass of heavy, wet white sheets with her fingers. Steadily and deliberately, she pulls them out, sending a few drops of clear water dripping from the sheets onto the polished tile floor. Her focused expression and gentle movements, complemented by the slowly rotating ceiling fan and warm light, create a focused and peaceful atmosphere of daily life, full of slow, peaceful and healing atmosphere.", + "seed": 4820, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_10/index_8958_seed_4820_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.09289011117070914, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09289011117070914, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09289011117070914, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a laundry room with a young woman wearing a white T-shirt and gray yoga pants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white drum-type washing machine with an open round glass door visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman reach into the washing machine and pull out a tangled mass of heavy, wet white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do clear water drops drip from the sheets onto a polished tile floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a white three-bladed ceiling fan spinning slowly above the woman's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05178980156779289 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0517897605895996 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05178980156779289, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05178980156779289, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12379417568445206, + 0.04088044539093971, + 0.07057472318410873, + 0.03265530243515968, + 0.05676918849349022, + 0.07498056441545486, + 0.09011766314506531, + 0.35055011510849, + 0.11579100787639618, + 0.043886810541152954 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05178980156779289 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a laundry room with a young woman wearing a white T-shirt and gray yoga pants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white drum-type washing machine with an open round glass door visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman reach into the washing machine and pull out a tangled mass of heavy, wet white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do clear water drops drip from the sheets onto a polished tile floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a white three-bladed ceiling fan spinning slowly above the woman's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009804426692426205 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6348042488098145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009804426692426205, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009804426692426205, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11694520711898804, + 0.13097020983695984, + 0.10710412263870239, + 0.08057789504528046, + 0.07660273462533951, + 0.09647031128406525, + 0.10506130009889603, + 0.14817428588867188, + 0.07846225053071976, + 0.05963166058063507 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009804426692426205 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a laundry room with a young woman wearing a white T-shirt and gray yoga pants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white drum-type washing machine with an open round glass door visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman reach into the washing machine and pull out a tangled mass of heavy, wet white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do clear water drops drip from the sheets onto a polished tile floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a white three-bladed ceiling fan spinning slowly above the woman's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1798747181892395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048746585845947 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1798747181892395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1798747181892395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13169822096824646, + 0.1339552402496338, + 0.16082774102687836, + 0.06550013273954391, + 0.11460239440202713, + 0.08413945138454437, + 0.07345414161682129, + 0.11991696059703827, + 0.0625104010105133, + 0.05339530110359192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1798747181892395 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a laundry room with a young woman wearing a white T-shirt and gray yoga pants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white drum-type washing machine with an open round glass door visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman reach into the washing machine and pull out a tangled mass of heavy, wet white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do clear water drops drip from the sheets onto a polished tile floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a white three-bladed ceiling fan spinning slowly above the woman's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17991535365581512 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049153089523315 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17991535365581512, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17991535365581512, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16732081770896912, + 0.3208618760108948, + 0.05259915441274643, + 0.10776906460523605, + 0.073247030377388, + 0.09533360600471497, + 0.07059598714113235, + 0.056040726602077484, + 0.033697452396154404, + 0.022534312680363655 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17991535365581512 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a laundry room with a young woman wearing a white T-shirt and gray yoga pants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white drum-type washing machine with an open round glass door visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman reach into the washing machine and pull out a tangled mass of heavy, wet white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do clear water drops drip from the sheets onto a polished tile floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a white three-bladed ceiling fan spinning slowly above the woman's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306625574827194 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680662631988525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306625574827194, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306625574827194, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6642404794692993, + 0.035418521612882614, + 0.017447102814912796, + 0.03124340996146202, + 0.027413399890065193, + 0.12579357624053955, + 0.027601134032011032, + 0.024142662063241005, + 0.02573910355567932, + 0.02096058428287506 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306625574827194 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, moving medium shot delicately captures a tranquil family laundry room. A young woman, her hair casually tied in a warm, brown bun, dressed in a loose white cotton T-shirt and gray yoga pants, hunches slightly over a gleaming, white, drum-type washing machine, its round glass door open. Above her head, a simple, white, three-bladed ceiling fan spins silently and slowly, its rotation barely creating any wind, adding a subtle touch of movement to the otherwise still image. Soft afternoon sunlight slants in through an off-screen window, sculpting wisps of dust in the air and casting a warm, comforting golden glow over the entire scene. Carefully, she reaches deep into the washing machine's damp drum, grasping a tangled mass of heavy, wet white sheets with her fingers. Steadily and deliberately, she pulls them out, sending a few drops of clear water dripping from the sheets onto the polished tile floor. Her focused expression and gentle movements, complemented by the slowly rotating ceiling fan and warm light, create a focused and peaceful atmosphere of daily life, full of slow, peaceful and healing atmosphere.", + "seed": 4821, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_10/index_8958_seed_4821_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04666461646556854, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04666461646556854, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04666461646556854, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a laundry room with a young woman wearing a white T-shirt and gray yoga pants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white drum-type washing machine with an open round glass door visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman reach into the washing machine and pull out a tangled mass of heavy, wet white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do clear water drops drip from the sheets onto a polished tile floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a white three-bladed ceiling fan spinning slowly above the woman's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02479911595582962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.774799108505249 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02479911595582962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02479911595582962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1625051349401474, + 0.05024285987019539, + 0.05842631310224533, + 0.028676392510533333, + 0.0652356818318367, + 0.049223631620407104, + 0.44940224289894104, + 0.04939694330096245, + 0.03699108958244324, + 0.04989974573254585 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02479911595582962 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a laundry room with a young woman wearing a white T-shirt and gray yoga pants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white drum-type washing machine with an open round glass door visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman reach into the washing machine and pull out a tangled mass of heavy, wet white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do clear water drops drip from the sheets onto a polished tile floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a white three-bladed ceiling fan spinning slowly above the woman's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008648322895169258 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75864839553833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008648322895169258, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008648322895169258, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0780850350856781, + 0.041182249784469604, + 0.2265625298023224, + 0.035320501774549484, + 0.056505657732486725, + 0.0477617122232914, + 0.3805293142795563, + 0.05133552849292755, + 0.04257915914058685, + 0.04013830050826073 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008648322895169258 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a laundry room with a young woman wearing a white T-shirt and gray yoga pants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white drum-type washing machine with an open round glass door visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman reach into the washing machine and pull out a tangled mass of heavy, wet white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do clear water drops drip from the sheets onto a polished tile floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a white three-bladed ceiling fan spinning slowly above the woman's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07896950840950012 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789694786071777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07896950840950012, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07896950840950012, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1798095554113388, + 0.053553204983472824, + 0.08246921002864838, + 0.04510999098420143, + 0.16180771589279175, + 0.05946863442659378, + 0.11564548313617706, + 0.133030965924263, + 0.08289353549480438, + 0.08621165156364441 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07896950840950012 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a laundry room with a young woman wearing a white T-shirt and gray yoga pants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white drum-type washing machine with an open round glass door visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman reach into the washing machine and pull out a tangled mass of heavy, wet white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do clear water drops drip from the sheets onto a polished tile floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a white three-bladed ceiling fan spinning slowly above the woman's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10032207518815994 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503220081329346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10032207518815994, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10032207518815994, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2022695392370224, + 0.038120370358228683, + 0.16175517439842224, + 0.06884623318910599, + 0.11386814713478088, + 0.06015162169933319, + 0.1558060497045517, + 0.06649889796972275, + 0.025739848613739014, + 0.10694410651922226 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10032207518815994 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a laundry room with a young woman wearing a white T-shirt and gray yoga pants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white drum-type washing machine with an open round glass door visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman reach into the washing machine and pull out a tangled mass of heavy, wet white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do clear water drops drip from the sheets onto a polished tile floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a white three-bladed ceiling fan spinning slowly above the woman's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058405987918377 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955841064453125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058405987918377, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058405987918377, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10704126209020615, + 0.42889994382858276, + 0.11117450147867203, + 0.024665413424372673, + 0.039093878120183945, + 0.026126189157366753, + 0.14712633192539215, + 0.04623512551188469, + 0.02636500634253025, + 0.04327234998345375 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058405987918377 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, moving medium shot delicately captures a tranquil family laundry room. A young woman, her hair casually tied in a warm, brown bun, dressed in a loose white cotton T-shirt and gray yoga pants, hunches slightly over a gleaming, white, drum-type washing machine, its round glass door open. Above her head, a simple, white, three-bladed ceiling fan spins silently and slowly, its rotation barely creating any wind, adding a subtle touch of movement to the otherwise still image. Soft afternoon sunlight slants in through an off-screen window, sculpting wisps of dust in the air and casting a warm, comforting golden glow over the entire scene. Carefully, she reaches deep into the washing machine's damp drum, grasping a tangled mass of heavy, wet white sheets with her fingers. Steadily and deliberately, she pulls them out, sending a few drops of clear water dripping from the sheets onto the polished tile floor. Her focused expression and gentle movements, complemented by the slowly rotating ceiling fan and warm light, create a focused and peaceful atmosphere of daily life, full of slow, peaceful and healing atmosphere.", + "seed": 4822, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_10/index_8958_seed_4822_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1326786631718278, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1326786631718278, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1326786631718278, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a laundry room with a young woman wearing a white T-shirt and gray yoga pants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white drum-type washing machine with an open round glass door visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman reach into the washing machine and pull out a tangled mass of heavy, wet white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do clear water drops drip from the sheets onto a polished tile floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a white three-bladed ceiling fan spinning slowly above the woman's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02012629061937332 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0201263427734375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02012629061937332, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02012629061937332, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14109715819358826, + 0.09174446016550064, + 0.04842923581600189, + 0.05321434140205383, + 0.07476693391799927, + 0.10553208738565445, + 0.048463065177202225, + 0.1040022075176239, + 0.08917795121669769, + 0.24357254803180695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02012629061937332 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a laundry room with a young woman wearing a white T-shirt and gray yoga pants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white drum-type washing machine with an open round glass door visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman reach into the washing machine and pull out a tangled mass of heavy, wet white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do clear water drops drip from the sheets onto a polished tile floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a white three-bladed ceiling fan spinning slowly above the woman's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014215514995157719 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264215469360352 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014215514995157719, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014215514995157719, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12515781819820404, + 0.03708289936184883, + 0.04235941916704178, + 0.02650010958313942, + 0.07014001905918121, + 0.021601565182209015, + 0.027349133044481277, + 0.11901410669088364, + 0.07418067753314972, + 0.4566141963005066 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014215514995157719 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a laundry room with a young woman wearing a white T-shirt and gray yoga pants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white drum-type washing machine with an open round glass door visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman reach into the washing machine and pull out a tangled mass of heavy, wet white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do clear water drops drip from the sheets onto a polished tile floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a white three-bladed ceiling fan spinning slowly above the woman's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38706862926483154 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370686292648315 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38706862926483154, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38706862926483154, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1201726496219635, + 0.07138051837682724, + 0.04345452040433884, + 0.04360126703977585, + 0.17217834293842316, + 0.026878010481595993, + 0.028398064896464348, + 0.1548304557800293, + 0.08339796215295792, + 0.2557082176208496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38706862926483154 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a laundry room with a young woman wearing a white T-shirt and gray yoga pants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white drum-type washing machine with an open round glass door visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman reach into the washing machine and pull out a tangled mass of heavy, wet white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do clear water drops drip from the sheets onto a polished tile floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a white three-bladed ceiling fan spinning slowly above the woman's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17991723120212555 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049172163009644 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17991723120212555, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17991723120212555, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12293531000614166, + 0.06785549968481064, + 0.05040976405143738, + 0.04313518479466438, + 0.18589934706687927, + 0.04888168349862099, + 0.03981020674109459, + 0.15298767387866974, + 0.10727909952402115, + 0.18080618977546692 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17991723120212555 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a laundry room with a young woman wearing a white T-shirt and gray yoga pants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white drum-type washing machine with an open round glass door visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman reach into the washing machine and pull out a tangled mass of heavy, wet white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do clear water drops drip from the sheets onto a polished tile floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a white three-bladed ceiling fan spinning slowly above the woman's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06206564977765083 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812065601348877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06206564977765083, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06206564977765083, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17783740162849426, + 0.04214698448777199, + 0.097389355301857, + 0.05197184532880783, + 0.47933444380760193, + 0.030669234693050385, + 0.010995655320584774, + 0.02903563156723976, + 0.02647061087191105, + 0.05414879322052002 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06206564977765083 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, moving medium shot delicately captures a tranquil family laundry room. A young woman, her hair casually tied in a warm, brown bun, dressed in a loose white cotton T-shirt and gray yoga pants, hunches slightly over a gleaming, white, drum-type washing machine, its round glass door open. Above her head, a simple, white, three-bladed ceiling fan spins silently and slowly, its rotation barely creating any wind, adding a subtle touch of movement to the otherwise still image. Soft afternoon sunlight slants in through an off-screen window, sculpting wisps of dust in the air and casting a warm, comforting golden glow over the entire scene. Carefully, she reaches deep into the washing machine's damp drum, grasping a tangled mass of heavy, wet white sheets with her fingers. Steadily and deliberately, she pulls them out, sending a few drops of clear water dripping from the sheets onto the polished tile floor. Her focused expression and gentle movements, complemented by the slowly rotating ceiling fan and warm light, create a focused and peaceful atmosphere of daily life, full of slow, peaceful and healing atmosphere.", + "seed": 4823, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_10/index_8958_seed_4823_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.08436317620798946, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08436317620798946, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.875000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08436317620798946, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a laundry room with a young woman wearing a white T-shirt and gray yoga pants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white drum-type washing machine with an open round glass door visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman reach into the washing machine and pull out a tangled mass of heavy, wet white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do clear water drops drip from the sheets onto a polished tile floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a white three-bladed ceiling fan spinning slowly above the woman's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.040889933705329895 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2908899784088135 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.040889933705329895, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.040889933705329895, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21252043545246124, + 0.07357870042324066, + 0.13953423500061035, + 0.06959596276283264, + 0.04881766811013222, + 0.057613473385572433, + 0.04632578790187836, + 0.17479535937309265, + 0.04995846748352051, + 0.12725995481014252 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.040889933705329895 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a laundry room with a young woman wearing a white T-shirt and gray yoga pants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white drum-type washing machine with an open round glass door visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman reach into the washing machine and pull out a tangled mass of heavy, wet white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do clear water drops drip from the sheets onto a polished tile floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a white three-bladed ceiling fan spinning slowly above the woman's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007645511534065008 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882645606994629 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007645511534065008, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007645511534065008, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1954914629459381, + 0.13404865562915802, + 0.08477714657783508, + 0.07814498990774155, + 0.06485173106193542, + 0.08107582479715347, + 0.04415005445480347, + 0.04120557755231857, + 0.07384749501943588, + 0.20240716636180878 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007645511534065008 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a laundry room with a young woman wearing a white T-shirt and gray yoga pants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white drum-type washing machine with an open round glass door visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman reach into the washing machine and pull out a tangled mass of heavy, wet white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do clear water drops drip from the sheets onto a polished tile floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a white three-bladed ceiling fan spinning slowly above the woman's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002726197242737 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950273513793945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002726197242737, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002726197242737, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20228351652622223, + 0.22017672657966614, + 0.04769761115312576, + 0.025675339624285698, + 0.033656008541584015, + 0.054331474006175995, + 0.04458162933588028, + 0.04276539385318756, + 0.05615547299385071, + 0.2726767957210541 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002726197242737 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a laundry room with a young woman wearing a white T-shirt and gray yoga pants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white drum-type washing machine with an open round glass door visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman reach into the washing machine and pull out a tangled mass of heavy, wet white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do clear water drops drip from the sheets onto a polished tile floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a white three-bladed ceiling fan spinning slowly above the woman's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14286628365516663 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017866373062134 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14286628365516663, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14286628365516663, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20445942878723145, + 0.09055181592702866, + 0.04283440485596657, + 0.0333140529692173, + 0.03562438488006592, + 0.029918543994426727, + 0.06744664907455444, + 0.02090415172278881, + 0.029921207576990128, + 0.44502535462379456 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14286628365516663 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a laundry room with a young woman wearing a white T-shirt and gray yoga pants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white drum-type washing machine with an open round glass door visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman reach into the washing machine and pull out a tangled mass of heavy, wet white sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do clear water drops drip from the sheets onto a polished tile floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a white three-bladed ceiling fan spinning slowly above the woman's head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16038689017295837 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103869199752808 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16038689017295837, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16038689017295837, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4911125600337982, + 0.049836933612823486, + 0.06419266015291214, + 0.04446442052721977, + 0.06559910625219345, + 0.038897015154361725, + 0.021827029064297676, + 0.03337971493601799, + 0.07726381719112396, + 0.11342669278383255 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16038689017295837 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_11/index_tensor([8903, 8903])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_11/index_tensor([8903, 8903])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..119954bd677d4db2ab5cdcda16ddb2daa63c18c0 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_11/index_tensor([8903, 8903])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium-long tracking shot, shot from the side and slightly tilted upward, slowly follows the figure of an elderly farmer returning home in the fading light of sunset. His face is etched with deep wrinkles, carved by time and sunlight. Beneath his sparse graying hair, his expression is peaceful yet slightly weary. He wears a washed-out, blue-gray coarse cloth shirt, the edges slightly frayed. Steadily resting on his shoulder is an old hoe, its wooden handle worn smooth and shiny from years of gripping. The metal blade is still stained with moist, freshly turned earth. He walks steadily and unhurriedly along the narrow path between fields, each step firm and rhythmic. His mud-stained old cloth shoes press against the firm earth, and his body sways slightly with each step. The sun has already sunk below the horizon, but the sky remains stained with a magnificent gradient of hues, from fiery orange to soft pink and purple. The final rays of the setting sun cast a warm golden hue over his figure, casting a long, solitary shadow behind him. Beside him lies an endless expanse of harvested rice paddies, their golden stubble swaying gently in the evening breeze. The outline of a distant village appears quiet and blurred in the twilight, with wisps of smoke rising from cooking fires. The entire scene is imbued with a tranquil, simple poetic quality, conveying a sense of satisfaction after labor and a deep attachment to home, creating a dynamic rural landscape with the texture of an oil painting.", + "seed": 12166, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_11/index_8903_seed_12166_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05289911599829793, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05289911599829793, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05289911599829793, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer with deep wrinkles and sparse graying hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer wearing a washed-out blue-gray coarse cloth shirt with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an old hoe with a worn wooden handle and a metal blade stained with moist earth resting on the farmer's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in harvested rice paddies with golden stubble swaying in the breeze during sunset?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from the side, slightly tilted upward, and slowly following the farmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1621439903974533 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9121439456939697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1621439903974533, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1621439903974533, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22153981029987335, + 0.043234970420598984, + 0.056223854422569275, + 0.03850381076335907, + 0.0662531703710556, + 0.2503787577152252, + 0.13406988978385925, + 0.05177311599254608, + 0.04700218513607979, + 0.09102043509483337 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1621439903974533 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer with deep wrinkles and sparse graying hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer wearing a washed-out blue-gray coarse cloth shirt with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an old hoe with a worn wooden handle and a metal blade stained with moist earth resting on the farmer's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in harvested rice paddies with golden stubble swaying in the breeze during sunset?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from the side, slightly tilted upward, and slowly following the farmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026361405849456787 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513614654541016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026361405849456787, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026361405849456787, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14259573817253113, + 0.08485276997089386, + 0.06164029985666275, + 0.03574247285723686, + 0.0811215341091156, + 0.10500092059373856, + 0.1504080891609192, + 0.04322260990738869, + 0.08506384491920471, + 0.21035180985927582 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026361405849456787 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer with deep wrinkles and sparse graying hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer wearing a washed-out blue-gray coarse cloth shirt with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an old hoe with a worn wooden handle and a metal blade stained with moist earth resting on the farmer's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in harvested rice paddies with golden stubble swaying in the breeze during sunset?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from the side, slightly tilted upward, and slowly following the farmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867907613515854 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486791133880615 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867907613515854, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867907613515854, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1891472041606903, + 0.13692837953567505, + 0.04360852763056755, + 0.037819452583789825, + 0.04136761277914047, + 0.12339962273836136, + 0.2632148265838623, + 0.03646967187523842, + 0.0424153208732605, + 0.08562939614057541 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867907613515854 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer with deep wrinkles and sparse graying hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer wearing a washed-out blue-gray coarse cloth shirt with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an old hoe with a worn wooden handle and a metal blade stained with moist earth resting on the farmer's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in harvested rice paddies with golden stubble swaying in the breeze during sunset?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from the side, slightly tilted upward, and slowly following the farmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020577168092131615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955771923065186 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020577168092131615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020577168092131615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11108516156673431, + 0.046259477734565735, + 0.041898325085639954, + 0.030901562422513962, + 0.03337954729795456, + 0.14178429543972015, + 0.4119443893432617, + 0.07836756855249405, + 0.03818221762776375, + 0.06619749963283539 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020577168092131615 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer with deep wrinkles and sparse graying hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer wearing a washed-out blue-gray coarse cloth shirt with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an old hoe with a worn wooden handle and a metal blade stained with moist earth resting on the farmer's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in harvested rice paddies with golden stubble swaying in the breeze during sunset?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from the side, slightly tilted upward, and slowly following the farmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067339395172894 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067338943481445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067339395172894, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067339395172894, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13766628503799438, + 0.09669901430606842, + 0.0645851269364357, + 0.07904156297445297, + 0.061658844351768494, + 0.1283705234527588, + 0.1125386655330658, + 0.13951057195663452, + 0.11564987152814865, + 0.06427965313196182 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067339395172894 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium-long tracking shot, shot from the side and slightly tilted upward, slowly follows the figure of an elderly farmer returning home in the fading light of sunset. His face is etched with deep wrinkles, carved by time and sunlight. Beneath his sparse graying hair, his expression is peaceful yet slightly weary. He wears a washed-out, blue-gray coarse cloth shirt, the edges slightly frayed. Steadily resting on his shoulder is an old hoe, its wooden handle worn smooth and shiny from years of gripping. The metal blade is still stained with moist, freshly turned earth. He walks steadily and unhurriedly along the narrow path between fields, each step firm and rhythmic. His mud-stained old cloth shoes press against the firm earth, and his body sways slightly with each step. The sun has already sunk below the horizon, but the sky remains stained with a magnificent gradient of hues, from fiery orange to soft pink and purple. The final rays of the setting sun cast a warm golden hue over his figure, casting a long, solitary shadow behind him. Beside him lies an endless expanse of harvested rice paddies, their golden stubble swaying gently in the evening breeze. The outline of a distant village appears quiet and blurred in the twilight, with wisps of smoke rising from cooking fires. The entire scene is imbued with a tranquil, simple poetic quality, conveying a sense of satisfaction after labor and a deep attachment to home, creating a dynamic rural landscape with the texture of an oil painting.", + "seed": 12167, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_11/index_8903_seed_12167_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.05454387553036213, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05454387553036213, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05454387553036213, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer with deep wrinkles and sparse graying hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer wearing a washed-out blue-gray coarse cloth shirt with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an old hoe with a worn wooden handle and a metal blade stained with moist earth resting on the farmer's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in harvested rice paddies with golden stubble swaying in the breeze during sunset?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from the side, slightly tilted upward, and slowly following the farmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2033132165670395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7033132314682007 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2033132165670395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2033132165670395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21818098425865173, + 0.057287804782390594, + 0.21949289739131927, + 0.12597092986106873, + 0.05784190446138382, + 0.08515989035367966, + 0.12325167655944824, + 0.030479783192276955, + 0.034906256943941116, + 0.047427862882614136 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2033132165670395 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer with deep wrinkles and sparse graying hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer wearing a washed-out blue-gray coarse cloth shirt with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an old hoe with a worn wooden handle and a metal blade stained with moist earth resting on the farmer's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in harvested rice paddies with golden stubble swaying in the breeze during sunset?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from the side, slightly tilted upward, and slowly following the farmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023308223113417625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773308277130127 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023308223113417625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023308223113417625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2078288197517395, + 0.06864097714424133, + 0.17734572291374207, + 0.10214540362358093, + 0.05269051343202591, + 0.05052657052874565, + 0.22616109251976013, + 0.05004245415329933, + 0.019877756014466286, + 0.044740691781044006 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023308223113417625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer with deep wrinkles and sparse graying hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer wearing a washed-out blue-gray coarse cloth shirt with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an old hoe with a worn wooden handle and a metal blade stained with moist earth resting on the farmer's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in harvested rice paddies with golden stubble swaying in the breeze during sunset?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from the side, slightly tilted upward, and slowly following the farmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023299021646380424 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773298978805542 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023299021646380424, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023299021646380424, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32980817556381226, + 0.07021716237068176, + 0.0761832445859909, + 0.08969657123088837, + 0.12140105664730072, + 0.05657746642827988, + 0.0983426570892334, + 0.029469789937138557, + 0.04417632520198822, + 0.08412741869688034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023299021646380424 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer with deep wrinkles and sparse graying hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer wearing a washed-out blue-gray coarse cloth shirt with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an old hoe with a worn wooden handle and a metal blade stained with moist earth resting on the farmer's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in harvested rice paddies with golden stubble swaying in the breeze during sunset?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from the side, slightly tilted upward, and slowly following the farmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006735123693943024 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006735324859619 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006735123693943024, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006735123693943024, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1051199808716774, + 0.07698021084070206, + 0.14263300597667694, + 0.15936769545078278, + 0.17001724243164062, + 0.08070133626461029, + 0.10252959281206131, + 0.02927490882575512, + 0.1021096333861351, + 0.031266387552022934 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006735123693943024 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer with deep wrinkles and sparse graying hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer wearing a washed-out blue-gray coarse cloth shirt with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an old hoe with a worn wooden handle and a metal blade stained with moist earth resting on the farmer's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in harvested rice paddies with golden stubble swaying in the breeze during sunset?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from the side, slightly tilted upward, and slowly following the farmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016063792631030083 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141063690185547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016063792631030083, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016063792631030083, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1527007669210434, + 0.06096313148736954, + 0.3394846022129059, + 0.09427598118782043, + 0.11619776487350464, + 0.02806207351386547, + 0.06743989139795303, + 0.022156257182359695, + 0.012217647396028042, + 0.10650178790092468 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016063792631030083 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium-long tracking shot, shot from the side and slightly tilted upward, slowly follows the figure of an elderly farmer returning home in the fading light of sunset. His face is etched with deep wrinkles, carved by time and sunlight. Beneath his sparse graying hair, his expression is peaceful yet slightly weary. He wears a washed-out, blue-gray coarse cloth shirt, the edges slightly frayed. Steadily resting on his shoulder is an old hoe, its wooden handle worn smooth and shiny from years of gripping. The metal blade is still stained with moist, freshly turned earth. He walks steadily and unhurriedly along the narrow path between fields, each step firm and rhythmic. His mud-stained old cloth shoes press against the firm earth, and his body sways slightly with each step. The sun has already sunk below the horizon, but the sky remains stained with a magnificent gradient of hues, from fiery orange to soft pink and purple. The final rays of the setting sun cast a warm golden hue over his figure, casting a long, solitary shadow behind him. Beside him lies an endless expanse of harvested rice paddies, their golden stubble swaying gently in the evening breeze. The outline of a distant village appears quiet and blurred in the twilight, with wisps of smoke rising from cooking fires. The entire scene is imbued with a tranquil, simple poetic quality, conveying a sense of satisfaction after labor and a deep attachment to home, creating a dynamic rural landscape with the texture of an oil painting.", + "seed": 12168, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_11/index_8903_seed_12168_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05916385119780898, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05916385119780898, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05916385119780898, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer with deep wrinkles and sparse graying hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer wearing a washed-out blue-gray coarse cloth shirt with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an old hoe with a worn wooden handle and a metal blade stained with moist earth resting on the farmer's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in harvested rice paddies with golden stubble swaying in the breeze during sunset?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from the side, slightly tilted upward, and slowly following the farmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11435655504465103 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.239356517791748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11435655504465103, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11435655504465103, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28116628527641296, + 0.09387587010860443, + 0.048809900879859924, + 0.03463948145508766, + 0.2569747865200043, + 0.06257994472980499, + 0.09057725965976715, + 0.01491765957325697, + 0.03278898820281029, + 0.08366980403661728 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11435655504465103 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer with deep wrinkles and sparse graying hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer wearing a washed-out blue-gray coarse cloth shirt with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an old hoe with a worn wooden handle and a metal blade stained with moist earth resting on the farmer's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in harvested rice paddies with golden stubble swaying in the breeze during sunset?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from the side, slightly tilted upward, and slowly following the farmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029819034039974213 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298190116882324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029819034039974213, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029819034039974213, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19146107137203217, + 0.1481960117816925, + 0.09715636819601059, + 0.0749550312757492, + 0.19181539118289948, + 0.058218736201524734, + 0.035988740622997284, + 0.03798682242631912, + 0.05292767286300659, + 0.11129413545131683 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029819034039974213 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer with deep wrinkles and sparse graying hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer wearing a washed-out blue-gray coarse cloth shirt with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an old hoe with a worn wooden handle and a metal blade stained with moist earth resting on the farmer's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in harvested rice paddies with golden stubble swaying in the breeze during sunset?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from the side, slightly tilted upward, and slowly following the farmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05498058721423149 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929980516433716 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05498058721423149, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05498058721423149, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14703673124313354, + 0.11440303921699524, + 0.05145954340696335, + 0.06077268347144127, + 0.13569322228431702, + 0.06401989609003067, + 0.05952692776918411, + 0.11569328606128693, + 0.14912740886211395, + 0.10226725041866302 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05498058721423149 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer with deep wrinkles and sparse graying hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer wearing a washed-out blue-gray coarse cloth shirt with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an old hoe with a worn wooden handle and a metal blade stained with moist earth resting on the farmer's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in harvested rice paddies with golden stubble swaying in the breeze during sunset?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from the side, slightly tilted upward, and slowly following the farmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890367329120636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464036703109741 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0890367329120636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0890367329120636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2869807183742523, + 0.03340088576078415, + 0.029833385720849037, + 0.07668100297451019, + 0.14226433634757996, + 0.045902300626039505, + 0.05425233393907547, + 0.024298515170812607, + 0.048246122896671295, + 0.25814035534858704 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0890367329120636 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer with deep wrinkles and sparse graying hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer wearing a washed-out blue-gray coarse cloth shirt with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an old hoe with a worn wooden handle and a metal blade stained with moist earth resting on the farmer's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in harvested rice paddies with golden stubble swaying in the breeze during sunset?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from the side, slightly tilted upward, and slowly following the farmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007626346778124571 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882626533508301 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007626346778124571, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007626346778124571, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20906555652618408, + 0.08934225887060165, + 0.051807813346385956, + 0.10040652006864548, + 0.08372031152248383, + 0.15544664859771729, + 0.084330715239048, + 0.041668880730867386, + 0.08143860101699829, + 0.10277273505926132 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007626346778124571 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium-long tracking shot, shot from the side and slightly tilted upward, slowly follows the figure of an elderly farmer returning home in the fading light of sunset. His face is etched with deep wrinkles, carved by time and sunlight. Beneath his sparse graying hair, his expression is peaceful yet slightly weary. He wears a washed-out, blue-gray coarse cloth shirt, the edges slightly frayed. Steadily resting on his shoulder is an old hoe, its wooden handle worn smooth and shiny from years of gripping. The metal blade is still stained with moist, freshly turned earth. He walks steadily and unhurriedly along the narrow path between fields, each step firm and rhythmic. His mud-stained old cloth shoes press against the firm earth, and his body sways slightly with each step. The sun has already sunk below the horizon, but the sky remains stained with a magnificent gradient of hues, from fiery orange to soft pink and purple. The final rays of the setting sun cast a warm golden hue over his figure, casting a long, solitary shadow behind him. Beside him lies an endless expanse of harvested rice paddies, their golden stubble swaying gently in the evening breeze. The outline of a distant village appears quiet and blurred in the twilight, with wisps of smoke rising from cooking fires. The entire scene is imbued with a tranquil, simple poetic quality, conveying a sense of satisfaction after labor and a deep attachment to home, creating a dynamic rural landscape with the texture of an oil painting.", + "seed": 12169, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_11/index_8903_seed_12169_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1941924937069416, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1941924937069416, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1941924937069416, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer with deep wrinkles and sparse graying hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer wearing a washed-out blue-gray coarse cloth shirt with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an old hoe with a worn wooden handle and a metal blade stained with moist earth resting on the farmer's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in harvested rice paddies with golden stubble swaying in the breeze during sunset?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from the side, slightly tilted upward, and slowly following the farmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7586256265640259 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6336256265640259 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7586256265640259, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7586256265640259, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19254851341247559, + 0.06291405856609344, + 0.03411593288183212, + 0.24744533002376556, + 0.06812768429517746, + 0.05667838826775551, + 0.07509840279817581, + 0.07280734181404114, + 0.14631536602973938, + 0.04394896328449249 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7586256265640259 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer with deep wrinkles and sparse graying hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer wearing a washed-out blue-gray coarse cloth shirt with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an old hoe with a worn wooden handle and a metal blade stained with moist earth resting on the farmer's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in harvested rice paddies with golden stubble swaying in the breeze during sunset?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from the side, slightly tilted upward, and slowly following the farmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062071140855550766 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120710849761963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062071140855550766, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062071140855550766, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12121903896331787, + 0.04287838935852051, + 0.05809624493122101, + 0.317985862493515, + 0.05329355597496033, + 0.05265205353498459, + 0.09549219161272049, + 0.05970669165253639, + 0.15871086716651917, + 0.03996507078409195 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062071140855550766 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer with deep wrinkles and sparse graying hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer wearing a washed-out blue-gray coarse cloth shirt with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an old hoe with a worn wooden handle and a metal blade stained with moist earth resting on the farmer's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in harvested rice paddies with golden stubble swaying in the breeze during sunset?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from the side, slightly tilted upward, and slowly following the farmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08907392621040344 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464073896408081 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08907392621040344, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08907392621040344, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15282638370990753, + 0.06806343793869019, + 0.06508149206638336, + 0.31846433877944946, + 0.07868429273366928, + 0.06459365785121918, + 0.062221378087997437, + 0.03027430921792984, + 0.10067052394151688, + 0.059120163321495056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08907392621040344 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer with deep wrinkles and sparse graying hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer wearing a washed-out blue-gray coarse cloth shirt with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an old hoe with a worn wooden handle and a metal blade stained with moist earth resting on the farmer's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in harvested rice paddies with golden stubble swaying in the breeze during sunset?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from the side, slightly tilted upward, and slowly following the farmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048654891550540924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048654794692993 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048654891550540924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048654891550540924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10928761214017868, + 0.044004976749420166, + 0.022756032645702362, + 0.10699117928743362, + 0.046343665570020676, + 0.03614962100982666, + 0.05043360963463783, + 0.12896251678466797, + 0.3751247525215149, + 0.07994610071182251 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048654891550540924 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer with deep wrinkles and sparse graying hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer wearing a washed-out blue-gray coarse cloth shirt with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an old hoe with a worn wooden handle and a metal blade stained with moist earth resting on the farmer's shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in harvested rice paddies with golden stubble swaying in the breeze during sunset?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from the side, slightly tilted upward, and slowly following the farmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012536883354187012 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387537002563477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012536883354187012, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012536883354187012, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16026455163955688, + 0.057286351919174194, + 0.061697207391262054, + 0.14532752335071564, + 0.13890017569065094, + 0.06917153298854828, + 0.1010122150182724, + 0.06598231196403503, + 0.11367667466402054, + 0.08668139576911926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012536883354187012 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_12/index_tensor([219, 219])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_12/index_tensor([219, 219])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8270f60ed863b8a22013f6ff321a4373efc907ab --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_12/index_tensor([219, 219])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "tracking zoom shot, seamlessly transitioning from distant vista to extreme macro, begins with a solitary, crystal-clear snowflake, gracefully and slowly swirling down from a deep, softly out-of-focus, deep blue night sky. As the camera steadily and relentlessly pans forward, the frame becomes completely focused on this natural work of art, while the surrounding world gradually blurs into a pure block of color. As the lens zooms in, its unparalleled hexagonal symmetry is revealed with breathtaking clarity, each fern-like branching crystal displaying an intricate intertwining of icy branches beyond the reach of the naked eye. Illuminated by the faint, cool ambient light, the snowflake's translucent surface shimmers with a diamond-like glimmer, light refracting and dancing across its intricate geometric facets, highlighting its near-perfect natural form. The entire sequence is a smooth and poetic process, dominated by a palette of deep, cool blues and pure, icy whites, creating a visual atmosphere of profound tranquility, imbued with scientific beauty and awe, immersing the viewer in this fleeting microscopic miracle.", + "seed": 6180, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_12/index_219_seed_6180_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.15961628817021847, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15961628817021847, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15961628817021847, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a solitary snowflake falling from a deep blue night sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth transition from a distant vista to an extreme macro close-up of the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snowflake shown with high clarity revealing hexagonal symmetry and intricate fern-like branching structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background gradually blur into a block of color as the camera focuses on the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by deep cool blues and pure icy whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6937724947929382 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6937724947929382 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6937724947929382, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6937724947929382, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06670346111059189, + 0.021203620359301567, + 0.02872868999838829, + 0.02504483051598072, + 0.06752292066812515, + 0.5036516785621643, + 0.10912371426820755, + 0.09293000400066376, + 0.03221547231078148, + 0.0528755709528923 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6937724947929382 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a solitary snowflake falling from a deep blue night sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth transition from a distant vista to an extreme macro close-up of the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snowflake shown with high clarity revealing hexagonal symmetry and intricate fern-like branching structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background gradually blur into a block of color as the camera focuses on the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by deep cool blues and pure icy whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016102856025099754 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1411027908325195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016102856025099754, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016102856025099754, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05125189200043678, + 0.029629778116941452, + 0.12033011764287949, + 0.022741829976439476, + 0.08858420699834824, + 0.1310167908668518, + 0.2950524687767029, + 0.10268758237361908, + 0.03942668065428734, + 0.11927866190671921 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016102856025099754 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a solitary snowflake falling from a deep blue night sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth transition from a distant vista to an extreme macro close-up of the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snowflake shown with high clarity revealing hexagonal symmetry and intricate fern-like branching structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background gradually blur into a block of color as the camera focuses on the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by deep cool blues and pure icy whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024972939863801003 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.00249719619751 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024972939863801003, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024972939863801003, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06237197294831276, + 0.022311538457870483, + 0.039126038551330566, + 0.04537467285990715, + 0.08383136987686157, + 0.3091171681880951, + 0.19594934582710266, + 0.11545676738023758, + 0.033484578132629395, + 0.09297655522823334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024972939863801003 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a solitary snowflake falling from a deep blue night sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth transition from a distant vista to an extreme macro close-up of the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snowflake shown with high clarity revealing hexagonal symmetry and intricate fern-like branching structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background gradually blur into a block of color as the camera focuses on the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by deep cool blues and pure icy whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07896917313337326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789692401885986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07896917313337326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07896917313337326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07112704962491989, + 0.03568578138947487, + 0.24399574100971222, + 0.032016411423683167, + 0.1645481139421463, + 0.23468907177448273, + 0.05408770963549614, + 0.06020074710249901, + 0.03328816592693329, + 0.07036112993955612 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07896917313337326 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a solitary snowflake falling from a deep blue night sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth transition from a distant vista to an extreme macro close-up of the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snowflake shown with high clarity revealing hexagonal symmetry and intricate fern-like branching structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background gradually blur into a block of color as the camera focuses on the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by deep cool blues and pure icy whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006739622913300991 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006739616394043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006739622913300991, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006739622913300991, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05453743040561676, + 0.0246825460344553, + 0.023085499182343483, + 0.04133302718400955, + 0.0939454734325409, + 0.4109218120574951, + 0.1620851457118988, + 0.11090314388275146, + 0.03354116901755333, + 0.044964782893657684 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006739622913300991 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "tracking zoom shot, seamlessly transitioning from distant vista to extreme macro, begins with a solitary, crystal-clear snowflake, gracefully and slowly swirling down from a deep, softly out-of-focus, deep blue night sky. As the camera steadily and relentlessly pans forward, the frame becomes completely focused on this natural work of art, while the surrounding world gradually blurs into a pure block of color. As the lens zooms in, its unparalleled hexagonal symmetry is revealed with breathtaking clarity, each fern-like branching crystal displaying an intricate intertwining of icy branches beyond the reach of the naked eye. Illuminated by the faint, cool ambient light, the snowflake's translucent surface shimmers with a diamond-like glimmer, light refracting and dancing across its intricate geometric facets, highlighting its near-perfect natural form. The entire sequence is a smooth and poetic process, dominated by a palette of deep, cool blues and pure, icy whites, creating a visual atmosphere of profound tranquility, imbued with scientific beauty and awe, immersing the viewer in this fleeting microscopic miracle.", + "seed": 6181, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_12/index_219_seed_6181_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03332539432449266, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03332539432449266, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.674999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03332539432449266, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a solitary snowflake falling from a deep blue night sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth transition from a distant vista to an extreme macro close-up of the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snowflake shown with high clarity revealing hexagonal symmetry and intricate fern-like branching structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background gradually blur into a block of color as the camera focuses on the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by deep cool blues and pure icy whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1273285448551178 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127328634262085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1273285448551178, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1273285448551178, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18063771724700928, + 0.05722665786743164, + 0.11478056758642197, + 0.31291893124580383, + 0.08623071014881134, + 0.03212599456310272, + 0.03692500665783882, + 0.050222333520650864, + 0.08161702007055283, + 0.047315098345279694 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1273285448551178 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a solitary snowflake falling from a deep blue night sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth transition from a distant vista to an extreme macro close-up of the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snowflake shown with high clarity revealing hexagonal symmetry and intricate fern-like branching structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background gradually blur into a block of color as the camera focuses on the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by deep cool blues and pure icy whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018197957426309586 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018198013305664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018197957426309586, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018197957426309586, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09501677751541138, + 0.12944446504116058, + 0.07023389637470245, + 0.1939515620470047, + 0.09024195373058319, + 0.054671499878168106, + 0.032150253653526306, + 0.11864020675420761, + 0.0883273333311081, + 0.12732204794883728 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018197957426309586 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a solitary snowflake falling from a deep blue night sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth transition from a distant vista to an extreme macro close-up of the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snowflake shown with high clarity revealing hexagonal symmetry and intricate fern-like branching structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background gradually blur into a block of color as the camera focuses on the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by deep cool blues and pure icy whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00220104050822556 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127201080322266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00220104050822556, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00220104050822556, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2665163278579712, + 0.0379243865609169, + 0.11974794417619705, + 0.12206484377384186, + 0.07256093621253967, + 0.06297679990530014, + 0.02960687316954136, + 0.12651896476745605, + 0.09195717424154282, + 0.07012584805488586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00220104050822556 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a solitary snowflake falling from a deep blue night sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth transition from a distant vista to an extreme macro close-up of the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snowflake shown with high clarity revealing hexagonal symmetry and intricate fern-like branching structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background gradually blur into a block of color as the camera focuses on the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by deep cool blues and pure icy whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0181814506649971 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018181324005127 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0181814506649971, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0181814506649971, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18996524810791016, + 0.07186519354581833, + 0.10886144638061523, + 0.3181946575641632, + 0.10460861027240753, + 0.047547370195388794, + 0.041627563536167145, + 0.03807288035750389, + 0.039142243564128876, + 0.040114808827638626 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0181814506649971 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a solitary snowflake falling from a deep blue night sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth transition from a distant vista to an extreme macro close-up of the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snowflake shown with high clarity revealing hexagonal symmetry and intricate fern-like branching structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background gradually blur into a block of color as the camera focuses on the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by deep cool blues and pure icy whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0007179781678132713 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.250718116760254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0007179781678132713, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0007179781678132713, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2696687579154968, + 0.11193767935037613, + 0.126339390873909, + 0.09050945192575455, + 0.046092648059129715, + 0.0483965165913105, + 0.03844765946269035, + 0.12430459260940552, + 0.06777436286211014, + 0.07652900367975235 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0007179781678132713 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "tracking zoom shot, seamlessly transitioning from distant vista to extreme macro, begins with a solitary, crystal-clear snowflake, gracefully and slowly swirling down from a deep, softly out-of-focus, deep blue night sky. As the camera steadily and relentlessly pans forward, the frame becomes completely focused on this natural work of art, while the surrounding world gradually blurs into a pure block of color. As the lens zooms in, its unparalleled hexagonal symmetry is revealed with breathtaking clarity, each fern-like branching crystal displaying an intricate intertwining of icy branches beyond the reach of the naked eye. Illuminated by the faint, cool ambient light, the snowflake's translucent surface shimmers with a diamond-like glimmer, light refracting and dancing across its intricate geometric facets, highlighting its near-perfect natural form. The entire sequence is a smooth and poetic process, dominated by a palette of deep, cool blues and pure, icy whites, creating a visual atmosphere of profound tranquility, imbued with scientific beauty and awe, immersing the viewer in this fleeting microscopic miracle.", + "seed": 6182, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_12/index_219_seed_6182_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.013221792096737772, + "vlm_logprob": -0.013221792096737772, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.013221792096737772, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a solitary snowflake falling from a deep blue night sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth transition from a distant vista to an extreme macro close-up of the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snowflake shown with high clarity revealing hexagonal symmetry and intricate fern-like branching structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background gradually blur into a block of color as the camera focuses on the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by deep cool blues and pure icy whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04900512471795082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0490050315856934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04900512471795082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04900512471795082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11909662187099457, + 0.16635248064994812, + 0.12865577638149261, + 0.047728922218084335, + 0.051535192877054214, + 0.2632735073566437, + 0.034496769309043884, + 0.08387919515371323, + 0.06445079296827316, + 0.0405307412147522 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04900512471795082 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a solitary snowflake falling from a deep blue night sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth transition from a distant vista to an extreme macro close-up of the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snowflake shown with high clarity revealing hexagonal symmetry and intricate fern-like branching structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background gradually blur into a block of color as the camera focuses on the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by deep cool blues and pure icy whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004655237775295973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379655361175537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004655237775295973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004655237775295973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09221787005662918, + 0.10381998121738434, + 0.08934462815523148, + 0.03444995358586311, + 0.07393979281187057, + 0.21226802468299866, + 0.04198936000466347, + 0.04977486655116081, + 0.2610708773136139, + 0.041124697774648666 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004655237775295973 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a solitary snowflake falling from a deep blue night sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth transition from a distant vista to an extreme macro close-up of the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snowflake shown with high clarity revealing hexagonal symmetry and intricate fern-like branching structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background gradually blur into a block of color as the camera focuses on the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by deep cool blues and pure icy whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019488405669108033 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251948833465576 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019488405669108033, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019488405669108033, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09733723849058151, + 0.10692446678876877, + 0.328191876411438, + 0.08301074802875519, + 0.07209083437919617, + 0.083936907351017, + 0.043471939861774445, + 0.04596996307373047, + 0.07277742028236389, + 0.06628851592540741 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019488405669108033 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a solitary snowflake falling from a deep blue night sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth transition from a distant vista to an extreme macro close-up of the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snowflake shown with high clarity revealing hexagonal symmetry and intricate fern-like branching structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background gradually blur into a block of color as the camera focuses on the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by deep cool blues and pure icy whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009779873304069042 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634779930114746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009779873304069042, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009779873304069042, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1717069298028946, + 0.17891602218151093, + 0.11994952708482742, + 0.02721380814909935, + 0.17243145406246185, + 0.07992854714393616, + 0.02855817601084709, + 0.022017644718289375, + 0.09086939692497253, + 0.10840847343206406 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009779873304069042 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a solitary snowflake falling from a deep blue night sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth transition from a distant vista to an extreme macro close-up of the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snowflake shown with high clarity revealing hexagonal symmetry and intricate fern-like branching structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background gradually blur into a block of color as the camera focuses on the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by deep cool blues and pure icy whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0007198841194622219 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.250720024108887 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0007198841194622219, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0007198841194622219, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08435924351215363, + 0.14941494166851044, + 0.11381775140762329, + 0.03795831650495529, + 0.03668786585330963, + 0.41217169165611267, + 0.04386890307068825, + 0.015483247116208076, + 0.05273088067770004, + 0.05350711941719055 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0007198841194622219 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "tracking zoom shot, seamlessly transitioning from distant vista to extreme macro, begins with a solitary, crystal-clear snowflake, gracefully and slowly swirling down from a deep, softly out-of-focus, deep blue night sky. As the camera steadily and relentlessly pans forward, the frame becomes completely focused on this natural work of art, while the surrounding world gradually blurs into a pure block of color. As the lens zooms in, its unparalleled hexagonal symmetry is revealed with breathtaking clarity, each fern-like branching crystal displaying an intricate intertwining of icy branches beyond the reach of the naked eye. Illuminated by the faint, cool ambient light, the snowflake's translucent surface shimmers with a diamond-like glimmer, light refracting and dancing across its intricate geometric facets, highlighting its near-perfect natural form. The entire sequence is a smooth and poetic process, dominated by a palette of deep, cool blues and pure, icy whites, creating a visual atmosphere of profound tranquility, imbued with scientific beauty and awe, immersing the viewer in this fleeting microscopic miracle.", + "seed": 6183, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_12/index_219_seed_6183_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.012750788615085185, + "vlm_logprob": -0.012750788615085185, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.012750788615085185, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a solitary snowflake falling from a deep blue night sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth transition from a distant vista to an extreme macro close-up of the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snowflake shown with high clarity revealing hexagonal symmetry and intricate fern-like branching structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background gradually blur into a block of color as the camera focuses on the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by deep cool blues and pure icy whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026917291805148125 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6519172191619873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026917291805148125, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026917291805148125, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1643587201833725, + 0.07612428814172745, + 0.09888060390949249, + 0.21163876354694366, + 0.11223991215229034, + 0.04801492765545845, + 0.053549084812402725, + 0.0368499793112278, + 0.13010664284229279, + 0.0682370588183403 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026917291805148125 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a solitary snowflake falling from a deep blue night sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth transition from a distant vista to an extreme macro close-up of the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snowflake shown with high clarity revealing hexagonal symmetry and intricate fern-like branching structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background gradually blur into a block of color as the camera focuses on the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by deep cool blues and pure icy whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046571362763643265 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.37965726852417 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046571362763643265, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046571362763643265, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13207024335861206, + 0.07088510692119598, + 0.055272024124860764, + 0.12379103153944016, + 0.045740485191345215, + 0.07865960150957108, + 0.11396753042936325, + 0.06621809303760529, + 0.13752306997776031, + 0.17587275803089142 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046571362763643265 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a solitary snowflake falling from a deep blue night sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth transition from a distant vista to an extreme macro close-up of the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snowflake shown with high clarity revealing hexagonal symmetry and intricate fern-like branching structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background gradually blur into a block of color as the camera focuses on the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by deep cool blues and pure icy whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019458661554381251 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251945972442627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019458661554381251, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019458661554381251, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11388841271400452, + 0.05565467104315758, + 0.10371880233287811, + 0.15410496294498444, + 0.0709356814622879, + 0.09949441254138947, + 0.060647714883089066, + 0.10899009555578232, + 0.11924365907907486, + 0.11332158744335175 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019458661554381251 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a solitary snowflake falling from a deep blue night sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth transition from a distant vista to an extreme macro close-up of the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snowflake shown with high clarity revealing hexagonal symmetry and intricate fern-like branching structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background gradually blur into a block of color as the camera focuses on the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by deep cool blues and pure icy whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029791956767439842 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529792070388794 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029791956767439842, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029791956767439842, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10395775735378265, + 0.08577512949705124, + 0.09657521545886993, + 0.10450679063796997, + 0.04529254883527756, + 0.10753240436315536, + 0.0954642966389656, + 0.11566787213087082, + 0.10303977876901627, + 0.1421881914138794 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029791956767439842 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a solitary snowflake falling from a deep blue night sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth transition from a distant vista to an extreme macro close-up of the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snowflake shown with high clarity revealing hexagonal symmetry and intricate fern-like branching structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background gradually blur into a block of color as the camera focuses on the snowflake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by deep cool blues and pure icy whites?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00044169207103550434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.750441551208496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00044169207103550434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00044169207103550434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.252517431974411, + 0.06830374896526337, + 0.04528414085507393, + 0.09815778583288193, + 0.11364994198083878, + 0.07642548531293869, + 0.07662288844585419, + 0.07926708459854126, + 0.08899088203907013, + 0.10078059881925583 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00044169207103550434 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_13/index_tensor([8866, 8866])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_13/index_tensor([8866, 8866])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fc1cd3f36b0621b2d2b97cfd180b66c9778909de --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_13/index_tensor([8866, 8866])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "From a low angle, a static, medium shot captures an elderly woman as she slowly straightens in her simple hospital bed. Her thinning gray hair rests slightly against the pillows, and she wears a standard-issue light blue hospital gown that hangs loosely around her frail frame. The room is illuminated by the cool, sterile glow of overhead fluorescent lights, casting soft, flat shadows and highlighting the cold, metallic sheen of the bedside railings. Her wrinkled face is etched with painful determination, and her trembling, veiny hands rest firmly on the mattress. Then, steadily and deliberately, she applies her weight, her arms shaking with effort as her torso lifts from the pillows. As she rises, the freshly taut, smooth, pristine white sheets wrinkle deeply around her hips, the movement of the fabric a visual testament to her quiet, arduous struggle in the cold, impersonal surroundings. The atmosphere is tense and deeply personal, utterly focused on the immense effort involved in this single, monumental act.", + "seed": 20340, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_13/index_8866_seed_20340_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0746666930615902, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0746666930615902, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1499999523162843, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0746666930615902, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, medium shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly woman wearing a light blue hospital gown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly straighten and lift her torso from the pillows to a sitting position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the white sheets shown wrinkling deeply around her hips as she rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the room illuminated by cool, sterile overhead fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.23456309735774994 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7345631122589111 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.23456309735774994, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.23456309735774994, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1367308348417282, + 0.055768247693777084, + 0.033536147326231, + 0.05828119069337845, + 0.049348387867212296, + 0.06684176623821259, + 0.3067846894264221, + 0.09930213540792465, + 0.07381218671798706, + 0.11959445476531982 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.23456309735774994 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, medium shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly woman wearing a light blue hospital gown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly straighten and lift her torso from the pillows to a sitting position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the white sheets shown wrinkling deeply around her hips as she rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the room illuminated by cool, sterile overhead fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02334444224834442 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733445167541504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02334444224834442, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02334444224834442, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19407227635383606, + 0.09213222563266754, + 0.03145827353000641, + 0.016340771690011024, + 0.03702843561768532, + 0.0451512336730957, + 0.09304014593362808, + 0.34055888652801514, + 0.06706738471984863, + 0.08315043151378632 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02334444224834442 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, medium shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly woman wearing a light blue hospital gown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly straighten and lift her torso from the pillows to a sitting position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the white sheets shown wrinkling deeply around her hips as she rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the room illuminated by cool, sterile overhead fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018200064077973366 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018199920654297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018200064077973366, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018200064077973366, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05014646425843239, + 0.040143102407455444, + 0.039134904742240906, + 0.03201153501868248, + 0.02752295322716236, + 0.09120070189237595, + 0.2355104684829712, + 0.27719637751579285, + 0.09052356332540512, + 0.11660990864038467 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018200064077973366 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, medium shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly woman wearing a light blue hospital gown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly straighten and lift her torso from the pillows to a sitting position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the white sheets shown wrinkling deeply around her hips as she rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the room illuminated by cool, sterile overhead fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018196435645222664 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0181965827941895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018196435645222664, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018196435645222664, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07767082750797272, + 0.12771205604076385, + 0.07020291686058044, + 0.10154909640550613, + 0.11713684350252151, + 0.10614696145057678, + 0.14254309237003326, + 0.1245642900466919, + 0.05140351876616478, + 0.08107047528028488 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018196435645222664 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, medium shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly woman wearing a light blue hospital gown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly straighten and lift her torso from the pillows to a sitting position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the white sheets shown wrinkling deeply around her hips as she rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the room illuminated by cool, sterile overhead fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07902942597866058 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790293216705322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07902942597866058, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07902942597866058, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2764149010181427, + 0.20643189549446106, + 0.09324151277542114, + 0.07495333254337311, + 0.051767498254776, + 0.040306609123945236, + 0.07181956619024277, + 0.0852971225976944, + 0.04433181509375572, + 0.05543571338057518 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07902942597866058 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "From a low angle, a static, medium shot captures an elderly woman as she slowly straightens in her simple hospital bed. Her thinning gray hair rests slightly against the pillows, and she wears a standard-issue light blue hospital gown that hangs loosely around her frail frame. The room is illuminated by the cool, sterile glow of overhead fluorescent lights, casting soft, flat shadows and highlighting the cold, metallic sheen of the bedside railings. Her wrinkled face is etched with painful determination, and her trembling, veiny hands rest firmly on the mattress. Then, steadily and deliberately, she applies her weight, her arms shaking with effort as her torso lifts from the pillows. As she rises, the freshly taut, smooth, pristine white sheets wrinkle deeply around her hips, the movement of the fabric a visual testament to her quiet, arduous struggle in the cold, impersonal surroundings. The atmosphere is tense and deeply personal, utterly focused on the immense effort involved in this single, monumental act.", + "seed": 20341, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_13/index_8866_seed_20341_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06774875950068235, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06774875950068235, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06774875950068235, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, medium shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly woman wearing a light blue hospital gown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly straighten and lift her torso from the pillows to a sitting position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the white sheets shown wrinkling deeply around her hips as she rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the room illuminated by cool, sterile overhead fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.15447716414928436 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.154477119445801 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.15447716414928436, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.15447716414928436, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03969280794262886, + 0.037201061844825745, + 0.11204096674919128, + 0.1600533425807953, + 0.3244325816631317, + 0.04210124537348747, + 0.028461270034313202, + 0.07971402257680893, + 0.04027935862541199, + 0.13602332770824432 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.15447716414928436 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, medium shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly woman wearing a light blue hospital gown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly straighten and lift her torso from the pillows to a sitting position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the white sheets shown wrinkling deeply around her hips as she rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the room illuminated by cool, sterile overhead fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03374189883470535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087419509887695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03374189883470535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03374189883470535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05883004516363144, + 0.03977179527282715, + 0.030671684071421623, + 0.21099910140037537, + 0.4180101156234741, + 0.027424439787864685, + 0.015371874906122684, + 0.015770060941576958, + 0.04435012862086296, + 0.13880068063735962 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03374189883470535 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, medium shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly woman wearing a light blue hospital gown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly straighten and lift her torso from the pillows to a sitting position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the white sheets shown wrinkling deeply around her hips as she rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the room illuminated by cool, sterile overhead fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005260554142296314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255260467529297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005260554142296314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005260554142296314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03305398300290108, + 0.048052117228507996, + 0.05963640660047531, + 0.2490929365158081, + 0.33281129598617554, + 0.11044897884130478, + 0.014224792830646038, + 0.05085834860801697, + 0.02432212047278881, + 0.07749904692173004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005260554142296314 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, medium shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly woman wearing a light blue hospital gown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly straighten and lift her torso from the pillows to a sitting position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the white sheets shown wrinkling deeply around her hips as she rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the room illuminated by cool, sterile overhead fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819397695362568 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018194198608398 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819397695362568, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819397695362568, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05071612074971199, + 0.02092551626265049, + 0.06994210928678513, + 0.09194937348365784, + 0.09735207259654999, + 0.14526796340942383, + 0.039870113134384155, + 0.07182912528514862, + 0.12394952028989792, + 0.2881981432437897 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819397695362568 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, medium shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly woman wearing a light blue hospital gown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly straighten and lift her torso from the pillows to a sitting position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the white sheets shown wrinkling deeply around her hips as she rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the room illuminated by cool, sterile overhead fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12707020342350006 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127070188522339 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12707020342350006, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12707020342350006, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06292300671339035, + 0.04711109772324562, + 0.010897262953221798, + 0.15283915400505066, + 0.18133437633514404, + 0.09435306489467621, + 0.18558619916439056, + 0.12660400569438934, + 0.016541922464966774, + 0.1218099296092987 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12707020342350006 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "From a low angle, a static, medium shot captures an elderly woman as she slowly straightens in her simple hospital bed. Her thinning gray hair rests slightly against the pillows, and she wears a standard-issue light blue hospital gown that hangs loosely around her frail frame. The room is illuminated by the cool, sterile glow of overhead fluorescent lights, casting soft, flat shadows and highlighting the cold, metallic sheen of the bedside railings. Her wrinkled face is etched with painful determination, and her trembling, veiny hands rest firmly on the mattress. Then, steadily and deliberately, she applies her weight, her arms shaking with effort as her torso lifts from the pillows. As she rises, the freshly taut, smooth, pristine white sheets wrinkle deeply around her hips, the movement of the fabric a visual testament to her quiet, arduous struggle in the cold, impersonal surroundings. The atmosphere is tense and deeply personal, utterly focused on the immense effort involved in this single, monumental act.", + "seed": 20342, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_13/index_8866_seed_20342_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.13064910769462584, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13064910769462584, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.175000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13064910769462584, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, medium shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly woman wearing a light blue hospital gown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly straighten and lift her torso from the pillows to a sitting position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the white sheets shown wrinkling deeply around her hips as she rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the room illuminated by cool, sterile overhead fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4576560854911804 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0826561450958252 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4576560854911804, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.6250000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4576560854911804, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07578443735837936, + 0.040211938321590424, + 0.10280974954366684, + 0.06845416873693466, + 0.10674538463354111, + 0.15640494227409363, + 0.054635562002658844, + 0.15889190137386322, + 0.1828678846359253, + 0.05319397523999214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4576560854911804 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, medium shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly woman wearing a light blue hospital gown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly straighten and lift her torso from the pillows to a sitting position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the white sheets shown wrinkling deeply around her hips as she rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the room illuminated by cool, sterile overhead fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014231615699827671 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2642316818237305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014231615699827671, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014231615699827671, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09542442113161087, + 0.07927770912647247, + 0.10277612507343292, + 0.048031847923994064, + 0.08309434354305267, + 0.041794758290052414, + 0.04246138408780098, + 0.04691131040453911, + 0.047084834426641464, + 0.41314324736595154 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014231615699827671 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, medium shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly woman wearing a light blue hospital gown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly straighten and lift her torso from the pillows to a sitting position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the white sheets shown wrinkling deeply around her hips as she rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the room illuminated by cool, sterile overhead fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067444778978824615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006744384765625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067444778978824615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067444778978824615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0506889782845974, + 0.048002101480960846, + 0.029484229162335396, + 0.03908857703208923, + 0.06866122037172318, + 0.03368725627660751, + 0.04877766966819763, + 0.0673183873295784, + 0.07738714665174484, + 0.536904513835907 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067444778978824615 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, medium shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly woman wearing a light blue hospital gown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly straighten and lift her torso from the pillows to a sitting position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the white sheets shown wrinkling deeply around her hips as she rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the room illuminated by cool, sterile overhead fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014204937033355236 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264204978942871 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014204937033355236, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014204937033355236, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03887200728058815, + 0.02288203313946724, + 0.15692026913166046, + 0.051734112203121185, + 0.0447099544107914, + 0.02417726255953312, + 0.021129824221134186, + 0.05941690877079964, + 0.1825132817029953, + 0.3976443409919739 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014204937033355236 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, medium shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly woman wearing a light blue hospital gown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly straighten and lift her torso from the pillows to a sitting position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the white sheets shown wrinkling deeply around her hips as she rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the room illuminated by cool, sterile overhead fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16040842235088348 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104083776474 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16040842235088348, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16040842235088348, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25998127460479736, + 0.0847533792257309, + 0.08835393190383911, + 0.09031077474355698, + 0.07473553717136383, + 0.06376425921916962, + 0.027535224333405495, + 0.03884819149971008, + 0.03238118812441826, + 0.239336296916008 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16040842235088348 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "From a low angle, a static, medium shot captures an elderly woman as she slowly straightens in her simple hospital bed. Her thinning gray hair rests slightly against the pillows, and she wears a standard-issue light blue hospital gown that hangs loosely around her frail frame. The room is illuminated by the cool, sterile glow of overhead fluorescent lights, casting soft, flat shadows and highlighting the cold, metallic sheen of the bedside railings. Her wrinkled face is etched with painful determination, and her trembling, veiny hands rest firmly on the mattress. Then, steadily and deliberately, she applies her weight, her arms shaking with effort as her torso lifts from the pillows. As she rises, the freshly taut, smooth, pristine white sheets wrinkle deeply around her hips, the movement of the fabric a visual testament to her quiet, arduous struggle in the cold, impersonal surroundings. The atmosphere is tense and deeply personal, utterly focused on the immense effort involved in this single, monumental act.", + "seed": 20343, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_13/index_8866_seed_20343_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.08881499860435724, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08881499860435724, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08881499860435724, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, medium shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly woman wearing a light blue hospital gown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly straighten and lift her torso from the pillows to a sitting position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the white sheets shown wrinkling deeply around her hips as she rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the room illuminated by cool, sterile overhead fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.19473674893379211 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9447367191314697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.19473674893379211, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.19473674893379211, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29962068796157837, + 0.06509780883789062, + 0.19859901070594788, + 0.04300452023744583, + 0.0487443283200264, + 0.03262222185730934, + 0.0720619186758995, + 0.08434426784515381, + 0.07049804925918579, + 0.08540715277194977 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.19473674893379211 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, medium shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly woman wearing a light blue hospital gown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly straighten and lift her torso from the pillows to a sitting position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the white sheets shown wrinkling deeply around her hips as she rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the room illuminated by cool, sterile overhead fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026387181133031845 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513872146606445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026387181133031845, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026387181133031845, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31974297761917114, + 0.08609474450349808, + 0.07599692791700363, + 0.13323639333248138, + 0.08809331059455872, + 0.01856594905257225, + 0.08089098334312439, + 0.041516900062561035, + 0.0700329840183258, + 0.08582884073257446 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026387181133031845 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, medium shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly woman wearing a light blue hospital gown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly straighten and lift her torso from the pillows to a sitting position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the white sheets shown wrinkling deeply around her hips as she rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the room illuminated by cool, sterile overhead fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005262688733637333 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255262851715088 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005262688733637333, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005262688733637333, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18054305016994476, + 0.06703637540340424, + 0.0327952541410923, + 0.09921066462993622, + 0.046128518879413605, + 0.05267670750617981, + 0.18045206367969513, + 0.048344045877456665, + 0.04638328403234482, + 0.24643003940582275 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005262688733637333 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, medium shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly woman wearing a light blue hospital gown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly straighten and lift her torso from the pillows to a sitting position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the white sheets shown wrinkling deeply around her hips as she rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the room illuminated by cool, sterile overhead fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016077987849712372 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141077995300293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016077987849712372, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016077987849712372, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06495141983032227, + 0.06959334760904312, + 0.20264501869678497, + 0.024436479434370995, + 0.08096758276224136, + 0.03524554520845413, + 0.22078531980514526, + 0.06332850456237793, + 0.09456409513950348, + 0.14348265528678894 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016077987849712372 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, medium shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly woman wearing a light blue hospital gown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly straighten and lift her torso from the pillows to a sitting position?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the white sheets shown wrinkling deeply around her hips as she rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the room illuminated by cool, sterile overhead fluorescent lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20161038637161255 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016103267669678 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20161038637161255, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20161038637161255, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33645012974739075, + 0.042067792266607285, + 0.23254968225955963, + 0.0715848058462143, + 0.06919560581445694, + 0.042465079575777054, + 0.04788147658109665, + 0.04917309805750847, + 0.056166186928749084, + 0.05246605724096298 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20161038637161255 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_14/index_tensor([1431, 1431])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_14/index_tensor([1431, 1431])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a26192c573237bcea3687122b93fa844544aa7e2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_14/index_tensor([1431, 1431])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium shot, taken at eye level, captures a lively indoor interaction between two men. The first man, with shaggy brown hair and wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold, horizontal navy and white stripes, speaks with energy. He briskly picks up a dark T-shirt from a pile on the sofa next to him and playfully tosses it into the air. Across from him, a second man, wearing a simple heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt, breaks into a hearty laugh, his shoulders shaking with laughter. He responds verbally while deliberately pushing his thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand. The camera then begins a smooth move away, transitioning to a wide-angle shot, revealing the full backdrop of a modern, comfortably cluttered living room bathed in the warm, soft glow of a floor lamp. As the frame widens, a third man, wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a rich, dark green botanical pattern, enters the scene from the left. He moves purposefully to the right, across the wooden floor, then suddenly and decisively stops, turning his head to observe the other two men with a curious expression, creating a dynamic scene of candid, friendly interaction within the comfortable, atmospheric space.", + "seed": 22137, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_14/index_1431_seed_22137_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08470467254519462, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08470467254519462, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08470467254519462, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot taken at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the first man wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold horizontal navy and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the second man wear a heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt and push thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly move away to transition into a wide-angle shot revealing a modern living room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a third man wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a dark green botanical pattern enter from the left and move across the wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1768909990787506 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9268909692764282 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1768909990787506, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1768909990787506, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5777987837791443, + 0.03786688670516014, + 0.16239643096923828, + 0.02244465798139572, + 0.035079509019851685, + 0.03465643525123596, + 0.034975260496139526, + 0.02100745216012001, + 0.03260365128517151, + 0.04117092862725258 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1768909990787506 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot taken at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the first man wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold horizontal navy and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the second man wear a heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt and push thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly move away to transition into a wide-angle shot revealing a modern living room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a third man wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a dark green botanical pattern enter from the left and move across the wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03816809877753258 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.28816819190979 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03816809877753258, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03816809877753258, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.39768272638320923, + 0.12260487675666809, + 0.04900277033448219, + 0.08658144623041153, + 0.04815692827105522, + 0.06226944178342819, + 0.03770057484507561, + 0.06699340790510178, + 0.0571751594543457, + 0.07183270156383514 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03816809877753258 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot taken at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the first man wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold horizontal navy and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the second man wear a heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt and push thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly move away to transition into a wide-angle shot revealing a modern living room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a third man wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a dark green botanical pattern enter from the left and move across the wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10035032778978348 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503503799438477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10035032778978348, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10035032778978348, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21353402733802795, + 0.08828231692314148, + 0.05960191413760185, + 0.06892354041337967, + 0.04359092563390732, + 0.04317500814795494, + 0.05929184705018997, + 0.06623188406229019, + 0.14684812724590302, + 0.21052038669586182 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10035032778978348 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot taken at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the first man wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold horizontal navy and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the second man wear a heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt and push thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly move away to transition into a wide-angle shot revealing a modern living room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a third man wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a dark green botanical pattern enter from the left and move across the wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038105905055999756 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881059646606445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038105905055999756, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038105905055999756, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2597600519657135, + 0.028016796335577965, + 0.04752449691295624, + 0.07951243966817856, + 0.04827979579567909, + 0.2586379051208496, + 0.05610828474164009, + 0.059936847537755966, + 0.04051007702946663, + 0.12171334773302078 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038105905055999756 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot taken at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the first man wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold horizontal navy and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the second man wear a heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt and push thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly move away to transition into a wide-angle shot revealing a modern living room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a third man wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a dark green botanical pattern enter from the left and move across the wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000803202390671 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950080394744873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000803202390671, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000803202390671, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09149523079395294, + 0.035987526178359985, + 0.04086064174771309, + 0.04510869085788727, + 0.05053820461034775, + 0.025481611490249634, + 0.05120822414755821, + 0.13390623033046722, + 0.37643301486968994, + 0.14898060262203217 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000803202390671 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, taken at eye level, captures a lively indoor interaction between two men. The first man, with shaggy brown hair and wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold, horizontal navy and white stripes, speaks with energy. He briskly picks up a dark T-shirt from a pile on the sofa next to him and playfully tosses it into the air. Across from him, a second man, wearing a simple heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt, breaks into a hearty laugh, his shoulders shaking with laughter. He responds verbally while deliberately pushing his thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand. The camera then begins a smooth move away, transitioning to a wide-angle shot, revealing the full backdrop of a modern, comfortably cluttered living room bathed in the warm, soft glow of a floor lamp. As the frame widens, a third man, wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a rich, dark green botanical pattern, enters the scene from the left. He moves purposefully to the right, across the wooden floor, then suddenly and decisively stops, turning his head to observe the other two men with a curious expression, creating a dynamic scene of candid, friendly interaction within the comfortable, atmospheric space.", + "seed": 22138, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_14/index_1431_seed_22138_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04851495120674372, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04851495120674372, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04851495120674372, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot taken at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the first man wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold horizontal navy and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the second man wear a heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt and push thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly move away to transition into a wide-angle shot revealing a modern living room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a third man wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a dark green botanical pattern enter from the left and move across the wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10410450398921967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.604104518890381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10410450398921967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10410450398921967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22519977390766144, + 0.10749776661396027, + 0.1907014399766922, + 0.07753206044435501, + 0.018286019563674927, + 0.05427554249763489, + 0.1415441781282425, + 0.08812025934457779, + 0.046697039157152176, + 0.05014590919017792 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10410450398921967 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot taken at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the first man wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold horizontal navy and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the second man wear a heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt and push thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly move away to transition into a wide-angle shot revealing a modern living room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a third man wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a dark green botanical pattern enter from the left and move across the wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04871075600385666 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048710823059082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04871075600385666, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04871075600385666, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11028467118740082, + 0.17495213449001312, + 0.09500961005687714, + 0.1246752142906189, + 0.043808214366436005, + 0.07690180838108063, + 0.1375277191400528, + 0.0921626165509224, + 0.09865173697471619, + 0.046026311814785004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04871075600385666 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot taken at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the first man wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold horizontal navy and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the second man wear a heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt and push thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly move away to transition into a wide-angle shot revealing a modern living room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a third man wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a dark green botanical pattern enter from the left and move across the wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054984647780656815 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299845695495605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054984647780656815, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054984647780656815, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1179928183555603, + 0.16856396198272705, + 0.1365886777639389, + 0.20731784403324127, + 0.05784006789326668, + 0.054853517562150955, + 0.060627758502960205, + 0.06641307473182678, + 0.04708215594291687, + 0.08272003382444382 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054984647780656815 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot taken at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the first man wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold horizontal navy and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the second man wear a heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt and push thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly move away to transition into a wide-angle shot revealing a modern living room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a third man wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a dark green botanical pattern enter from the left and move across the wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014202234335243702 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264202117919922 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014202234335243702, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014202234335243702, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1331833153963089, + 0.061779364943504333, + 0.10201233625411987, + 0.09755091369152069, + 0.03998485580086708, + 0.043863728642463684, + 0.11468139290809631, + 0.19141866266727448, + 0.0543547086417675, + 0.16117073595523834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014202234335243702 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot taken at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the first man wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold horizontal navy and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the second man wear a heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt and push thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly move away to transition into a wide-angle shot revealing a modern living room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a third man wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a dark green botanical pattern enter from the left and move across the wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020572613924741745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955726623535156 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020572613924741745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020572613924741745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04216119647026062, + 0.034494902938604355, + 0.029644658789038658, + 0.046831317245960236, + 0.02952820621430874, + 0.043082404881715775, + 0.08136866986751556, + 0.14732162654399872, + 0.23816636204719543, + 0.307400643825531 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020572613924741745 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, taken at eye level, captures a lively indoor interaction between two men. The first man, with shaggy brown hair and wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold, horizontal navy and white stripes, speaks with energy. He briskly picks up a dark T-shirt from a pile on the sofa next to him and playfully tosses it into the air. Across from him, a second man, wearing a simple heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt, breaks into a hearty laugh, his shoulders shaking with laughter. He responds verbally while deliberately pushing his thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand. The camera then begins a smooth move away, transitioning to a wide-angle shot, revealing the full backdrop of a modern, comfortably cluttered living room bathed in the warm, soft glow of a floor lamp. As the frame widens, a third man, wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a rich, dark green botanical pattern, enters the scene from the left. He moves purposefully to the right, across the wooden floor, then suddenly and decisively stops, turning his head to observe the other two men with a curious expression, creating a dynamic scene of candid, friendly interaction within the comfortable, atmospheric space.", + "seed": 22139, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_14/index_1431_seed_22139_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06780881211161613, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06780881211161613, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06780881211161613, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot taken at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the first man wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold horizontal navy and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the second man wear a heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt and push thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly move away to transition into a wide-angle shot revealing a modern living room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a third man wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a dark green botanical pattern enter from the left and move across the wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12992726266384125 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.254927158355713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12992726266384125, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12992726266384125, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23466873168945312, + 0.05625150352716446, + 0.09460585564374924, + 0.10252548009157181, + 0.15887831151485443, + 0.058358367532491684, + 0.07530372589826584, + 0.13659046590328217, + 0.02784864418208599, + 0.05496897175908089 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12992726266384125 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot taken at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the first man wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold horizontal navy and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the second man wear a heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt and push thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly move away to transition into a wide-angle shot revealing a modern living room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a third man wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a dark green botanical pattern enter from the left and move across the wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07006771862506866 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950676441192627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07006771862506866, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07006771862506866, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4047856330871582, + 0.03975507244467735, + 0.031623709946870804, + 0.10238997638225555, + 0.20521916449069977, + 0.04005911573767662, + 0.02457757107913494, + 0.09633113443851471, + 0.01624211296439171, + 0.03901653364300728 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07006771862506866 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot taken at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the first man wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold horizontal navy and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the second man wear a heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt and push thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly move away to transition into a wide-angle shot revealing a modern living room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a third man wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a dark green botanical pattern enter from the left and move across the wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900739461183548 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579007387161255 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900739461183548, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900739461183548, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19827520847320557, + 0.09744775295257568, + 0.09016341716051102, + 0.09582990407943726, + 0.23668727278709412, + 0.03851805627346039, + 0.04146357625722885, + 0.06032676622271538, + 0.04330432415008545, + 0.097983717918396 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900739461183548 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot taken at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the first man wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold horizontal navy and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the second man wear a heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt and push thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly move away to transition into a wide-angle shot revealing a modern living room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a third man wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a dark green botanical pattern enter from the left and move across the wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026351768523454666 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513516902923584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026351768523454666, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026351768523454666, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21790911257266998, + 0.04389781504869461, + 0.05458801984786987, + 0.07553298771381378, + 0.1697399765253067, + 0.0949539914727211, + 0.1439308077096939, + 0.09021621942520142, + 0.057433903217315674, + 0.051797203719615936 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026351768523454666 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot taken at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the first man wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold horizontal navy and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the second man wear a heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt and push thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly move away to transition into a wide-angle shot revealing a modern living room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a third man wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a dark green botanical pattern enter from the left and move across the wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033689916133880615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086899757385254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033689916133880615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033689916133880615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1547630876302719, + 0.038441188633441925, + 0.05245361104607582, + 0.06454763561487198, + 0.18629464507102966, + 0.0644868016242981, + 0.07885768264532089, + 0.09399881958961487, + 0.12285935878753662, + 0.1432972252368927 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033689916133880615 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, taken at eye level, captures a lively indoor interaction between two men. The first man, with shaggy brown hair and wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold, horizontal navy and white stripes, speaks with energy. He briskly picks up a dark T-shirt from a pile on the sofa next to him and playfully tosses it into the air. Across from him, a second man, wearing a simple heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt, breaks into a hearty laugh, his shoulders shaking with laughter. He responds verbally while deliberately pushing his thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand. The camera then begins a smooth move away, transitioning to a wide-angle shot, revealing the full backdrop of a modern, comfortably cluttered living room bathed in the warm, soft glow of a floor lamp. As the frame widens, a third man, wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a rich, dark green botanical pattern, enters the scene from the left. He moves purposefully to the right, across the wooden floor, then suddenly and decisively stops, turning his head to observe the other two men with a curious expression, creating a dynamic scene of candid, friendly interaction within the comfortable, atmospheric space.", + "seed": 22140, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_14/index_1431_seed_22140_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1659601226449013, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1659601226449013, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1659601226449013, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot taken at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the first man wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold horizontal navy and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the second man wear a heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt and push thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly move away to transition into a wide-angle shot revealing a modern living room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a third man wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a dark green botanical pattern enter from the left and move across the wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20048974454402924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8254897594451904 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20048974454402924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20048974454402924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11962183564901352, + 0.05956592038273811, + 0.0540602020919323, + 0.0504414327442646, + 0.04211152344942093, + 0.16153192520141602, + 0.13742928206920624, + 0.09602727741003036, + 0.23100216686725616, + 0.04820839688181877 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20048974454402924 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot taken at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the first man wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold horizontal navy and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the second man wear a heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt and push thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly move away to transition into a wide-angle shot revealing a modern living room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a third man wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a dark green botanical pattern enter from the left and move across the wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28144174814224243 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4064416885375977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28144174814224243, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28144174814224243, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29353025555610657, + 0.09779943525791168, + 0.09704235196113586, + 0.034777335822582245, + 0.05948428809642792, + 0.11967840790748596, + 0.11746597290039062, + 0.06424183398485184, + 0.08057990670204163, + 0.035400256514549255 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28144174814224243 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot taken at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the first man wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold horizontal navy and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the second man wear a heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt and push thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly move away to transition into a wide-angle shot revealing a modern living room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a third man wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a dark green botanical pattern enter from the left and move across the wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11299601942300797 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379961013793945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11299601942300797, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11299601942300797, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11818654090166092, + 0.19189368188381195, + 0.08241108804941177, + 0.025848178192973137, + 0.06456261873245239, + 0.10613524913787842, + 0.20228157937526703, + 0.046911220997571945, + 0.03973056375980377, + 0.12203928828239441 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11299601942300797 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot taken at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the first man wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold horizontal navy and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the second man wear a heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt and push thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly move away to transition into a wide-angle shot revealing a modern living room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a third man wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a dark green botanical pattern enter from the left and move across the wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05497866868972778 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929978609085083 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05497866868972778, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05497866868972778, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10370758175849915, + 0.08792043477296829, + 0.051653049886226654, + 0.04487224295735359, + 0.09119384735822678, + 0.33069103956222534, + 0.11492499709129333, + 0.0424954853951931, + 0.08309650421142578, + 0.049444809556007385 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05497866868972778 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot taken at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the first man wearing a long-sleeved cotton shirt with bold horizontal navy and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the second man wear a heather-gray crewneck sweatshirt and push thick-framed black glasses back onto his nose with his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly move away to transition into a wide-angle shot revealing a modern living room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a third man wearing a short-sleeved button-down shirt with a dark green botanical pattern enter from the left and move across the wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17989443242549896 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048944473266602 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17989443242549896, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17989443242549896, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06832216680049896, + 0.09437146782875061, + 0.034429874271154404, + 0.030230432748794556, + 0.06721776723861694, + 0.04748237133026123, + 0.41001129150390625, + 0.08146253228187561, + 0.1078420877456665, + 0.05862997844815254 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17989443242549896 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_15/index_tensor([9102, 9102])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_15/index_tensor([9102, 9102])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5f89a0e06e6c064d3e41ba428dc02aed0fe5ae84 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_15/index_tensor([9102, 9102])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "wide shot of a sun-drenched baseball field under a bright blue sky begins with a smooth, steady zoom-in, focusing on the action unfolding on the vibrant green grass. The warm late afternoon sun casts long, dramatic shadows. In the outfield, a male player with short, dark hair, wearing a white pinstriped jersey and matching pants, sprints fiercely, heading directly toward the camera. His eyes are fixed intently on a small, white baseball flying down from the sky. As the camera continues to zoom, it captures the firm grip of his jaw and the powerful roll of his legs. He extends his left arm, revealing a well-worn brown leather baseball glove, and at the last moment, the ball drops resoundingly and decisively into the glove pocket. His momentum is so great that after catching the ball with his right hand, he executes a fluid, athletic 360-degree spin across the turf, stopping with a poised, triumphant satisfaction. The entire scene exudes an aura of peak sportsmanship and focused energy.", + "seed": 26352, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_15/index_9102_seed_26352_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.021048664301633834, + "vlm_logprob": -0.021048664301633834, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0749999523162845, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.021048664301633834, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a wide shot of a sun-drenched baseball field under a bright blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a smooth, steady zoom-in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a male player wearing a white pinstriped jersey and matching pants visible sprinting toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the player catch a white baseball with his right hand and execute a fluid 360-degree spin across the turf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long shadows cast by the warm late afternoon sun visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018819935619831085 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018819808959961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018819935619831085, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018819935619831085, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.722121000289917, + 0.09690739959478378, + 0.03420545905828476, + 0.029200272634625435, + 0.026346759870648384, + 0.01709790714085102, + 0.021177083253860474, + 0.016659880056977272, + 0.023574214428663254, + 0.012710042297840118 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018819935619831085 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a wide shot of a sun-drenched baseball field under a bright blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a smooth, steady zoom-in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a male player wearing a white pinstriped jersey and matching pants visible sprinting toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the player catch a white baseball with his right hand and execute a fluid 360-degree spin across the turf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long shadows cast by the warm late afternoon sun visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306294396519661 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168062925338745 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306294396519661, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306294396519661, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3831343650817871, + 0.11104165762662888, + 0.0699150338768959, + 0.05842946097254753, + 0.03154771029949188, + 0.056002818048000336, + 0.1064552441239357, + 0.10264195501804352, + 0.04189145937561989, + 0.03894028067588806 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306294396519661 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a wide shot of a sun-drenched baseball field under a bright blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a smooth, steady zoom-in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a male player wearing a white pinstriped jersey and matching pants visible sprinting toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the player catch a white baseball with his right hand and execute a fluid 360-degree spin across the turf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long shadows cast by the warm late afternoon sun visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107108686119318 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51107120513916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107108686119318, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107108686119318, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1060020849108696, + 0.09889601916074753, + 0.0860087126493454, + 0.08296012133359909, + 0.05834558606147766, + 0.06208660826086998, + 0.1499241292476654, + 0.1973080188035965, + 0.1366507112979889, + 0.021817950531840324 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107108686119318 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a wide shot of a sun-drenched baseball field under a bright blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a smooth, steady zoom-in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a male player wearing a white pinstriped jersey and matching pants visible sprinting toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the player catch a white baseball with his right hand and execute a fluid 360-degree spin across the turf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long shadows cast by the warm late afternoon sun visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634456939995289 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513445377349854 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634456939995289, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634456939995289, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15735401213169098, + 0.1200466975569725, + 0.07002466171979904, + 0.0788692981004715, + 0.1118600144982338, + 0.2210116982460022, + 0.038589876145124435, + 0.049709614366292953, + 0.11951868236064911, + 0.03301533684134483 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634456939995289 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a wide shot of a sun-drenched baseball field under a bright blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a smooth, steady zoom-in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a male player wearing a white pinstriped jersey and matching pants visible sprinting toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the player catch a white baseball with his right hand and execute a fluid 360-degree spin across the turf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long shadows cast by the warm late afternoon sun visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005944785661995411 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130944728851318 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005944785661995411, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005944785661995411, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6112518310546875, + 0.05600620433688164, + 0.04403693228960037, + 0.05795089900493622, + 0.0381002314388752, + 0.06459467113018036, + 0.022480707615613937, + 0.05471392720937729, + 0.01999487541615963, + 0.030869711190462112 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005944785661995411 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide shot of a sun-drenched baseball field under a bright blue sky begins with a smooth, steady zoom-in, focusing on the action unfolding on the vibrant green grass. The warm late afternoon sun casts long, dramatic shadows. In the outfield, a male player with short, dark hair, wearing a white pinstriped jersey and matching pants, sprints fiercely, heading directly toward the camera. His eyes are fixed intently on a small, white baseball flying down from the sky. As the camera continues to zoom, it captures the firm grip of his jaw and the powerful roll of his legs. He extends his left arm, revealing a well-worn brown leather baseball glove, and at the last moment, the ball drops resoundingly and decisively into the glove pocket. His momentum is so great that after catching the ball with his right hand, he executes a fluid, athletic 360-degree spin across the turf, stopping with a poised, triumphant satisfaction. The entire scene exudes an aura of peak sportsmanship and focused energy.", + "seed": 26353, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_15/index_9102_seed_26353_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0314403286203742, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0314403286203742, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0314403286203742, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a wide shot of a sun-drenched baseball field under a bright blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a smooth, steady zoom-in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a male player wearing a white pinstriped jersey and matching pants visible sprinting toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the player catch a white baseball with his right hand and execute a fluid 360-degree spin across the turf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long shadows cast by the warm late afternoon sun visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007173732854425907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.007173538208008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007173732854425907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007173732854425907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19455775618553162, + 0.04200921207666397, + 0.10555704683065414, + 0.06035647913813591, + 0.051837630569934845, + 0.15836288034915924, + 0.1648709774017334, + 0.14544734358787537, + 0.04059942439198494, + 0.036401230841875076 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007173732854425907 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a wide shot of a sun-drenched baseball field under a bright blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a smooth, steady zoom-in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a male player wearing a white pinstriped jersey and matching pants visible sprinting toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the player catch a white baseball with his right hand and execute a fluid 360-degree spin across the turf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long shadows cast by the warm late afternoon sun visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08902092278003693 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640209674835205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08902092278003693, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08902092278003693, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1822292059659958, + 0.11730639636516571, + 0.22766868770122528, + 0.07048400491476059, + 0.05251123756170273, + 0.11791188269853592, + 0.17970535159111023, + 0.024482712149620056, + 0.014935369603335857, + 0.01276519987732172 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08902092278003693 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a wide shot of a sun-drenched baseball field under a bright blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a smooth, steady zoom-in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a male player wearing a white pinstriped jersey and matching pants visible sprinting toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the player catch a white baseball with his right hand and execute a fluid 360-degree spin across the turf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long shadows cast by the warm late afternoon sun visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020573314279317856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895573377609253 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020573314279317856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020573314279317856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17169253528118134, + 0.06896793842315674, + 0.19720184803009033, + 0.2358902096748352, + 0.06051876023411751, + 0.06679581105709076, + 0.0824761614203453, + 0.04409192502498627, + 0.03592207655310631, + 0.03644275292754173 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020573314279317856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a wide shot of a sun-drenched baseball field under a bright blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a smooth, steady zoom-in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a male player wearing a white pinstriped jersey and matching pants visible sprinting toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the player catch a white baseball with his right hand and execute a fluid 360-degree spin across the turf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long shadows cast by the warm late afternoon sun visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033703286200761795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408703327178955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033703286200761795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033703286200761795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11176891624927521, + 0.04806201905012131, + 0.13311822712421417, + 0.15665432810783386, + 0.08273780345916748, + 0.11043359339237213, + 0.26272112131118774, + 0.044158801436424255, + 0.030492331832647324, + 0.019852841272950172 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033703286200761795 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a wide shot of a sun-drenched baseball field under a bright blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a smooth, steady zoom-in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a male player wearing a white pinstriped jersey and matching pants visible sprinting toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the player catch a white baseball with his right hand and execute a fluid 360-degree spin across the turf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long shadows cast by the warm late afternoon sun visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006730386987328529 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006730556488037 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006730386987328529, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006730386987328529, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1453857570886612, + 0.056228701025247574, + 0.10326971858739853, + 0.043107252568006516, + 0.03702673316001892, + 0.05100921168923378, + 0.14863578975200653, + 0.052932411432266235, + 0.10560540854930878, + 0.25679895281791687 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006730386987328529 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide shot of a sun-drenched baseball field under a bright blue sky begins with a smooth, steady zoom-in, focusing on the action unfolding on the vibrant green grass. The warm late afternoon sun casts long, dramatic shadows. In the outfield, a male player with short, dark hair, wearing a white pinstriped jersey and matching pants, sprints fiercely, heading directly toward the camera. His eyes are fixed intently on a small, white baseball flying down from the sky. As the camera continues to zoom, it captures the firm grip of his jaw and the powerful roll of his legs. He extends his left arm, revealing a well-worn brown leather baseball glove, and at the last moment, the ball drops resoundingly and decisively into the glove pocket. His momentum is so great that after catching the ball with his right hand, he executes a fluid, athletic 360-degree spin across the turf, stopping with a poised, triumphant satisfaction. The entire scene exudes an aura of peak sportsmanship and focused energy.", + "seed": 26354, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_15/index_9102_seed_26354_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03343727020546794, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03343727020546794, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03343727020546794, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a wide shot of a sun-drenched baseball field under a bright blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a smooth, steady zoom-in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a male player wearing a white pinstriped jersey and matching pants visible sprinting toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the player catch a white baseball with his right hand and execute a fluid 360-degree spin across the turf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long shadows cast by the warm late afternoon sun visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002434268593788147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.252434253692627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002434268593788147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002434268593788147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1355232447385788, + 0.03650391474366188, + 0.07315340638160706, + 0.11738839000463486, + 0.08784880489110947, + 0.07453341782093048, + 0.18368878960609436, + 0.20513422787189484, + 0.044973619282245636, + 0.04125211760401726 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002434268593788147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a wide shot of a sun-drenched baseball field under a bright blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a smooth, steady zoom-in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a male player wearing a white pinstriped jersey and matching pants visible sprinting toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the player catch a white baseball with his right hand and execute a fluid 360-degree spin across the turf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long shadows cast by the warm late afternoon sun visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07896454632282257 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789644718170166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07896454632282257, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07896454632282257, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05757181718945503, + 0.018845085054636, + 0.05278291925787926, + 0.03446435555815697, + 0.11589384824037552, + 0.1050306037068367, + 0.12915430963039398, + 0.03016812354326248, + 0.033140186220407486, + 0.4229487180709839 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07896454632282257 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a wide shot of a sun-drenched baseball field under a bright blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a smooth, steady zoom-in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a male player wearing a white pinstriped jersey and matching pants visible sprinting toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the player catch a white baseball with his right hand and execute a fluid 360-degree spin across the turf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long shadows cast by the warm late afternoon sun visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03808651491999626 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288086414337158 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03808651491999626, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03808651491999626, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0617060512304306, + 0.0874977558851242, + 0.11530432850122452, + 0.03348845615983009, + 0.0930292159318924, + 0.08823815733194351, + 0.17331303656101227, + 0.23510563373565674, + 0.02674196846783161, + 0.0855754166841507 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03808651491999626 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a wide shot of a sun-drenched baseball field under a bright blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a smooth, steady zoom-in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a male player wearing a white pinstriped jersey and matching pants visible sprinting toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the player catch a white baseball with his right hand and execute a fluid 360-degree spin across the turf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long shadows cast by the warm late afternoon sun visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306785389780998 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680679321289062 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306785389780998, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306785389780998, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05459790676832199, + 0.029094384983181953, + 0.059722159057855606, + 0.043457429856061935, + 0.14696168899536133, + 0.10080811381340027, + 0.07487313449382782, + 0.2160826176404953, + 0.022093189880251884, + 0.2523093521595001 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306785389780998 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a wide shot of a sun-drenched baseball field under a bright blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a smooth, steady zoom-in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a male player wearing a white pinstriped jersey and matching pants visible sprinting toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the player catch a white baseball with his right hand and execute a fluid 360-degree spin across the turf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long shadows cast by the warm late afternoon sun visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004633167292922735 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379632949829102 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004633167292922735, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004633167292922735, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10079093277454376, + 0.031615570187568665, + 0.035612959414720535, + 0.0447893962264061, + 0.07193175703287125, + 0.3235315978527069, + 0.057468343526124954, + 0.03929030895233154, + 0.048364877700805664, + 0.2466042935848236 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004633167292922735 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide shot of a sun-drenched baseball field under a bright blue sky begins with a smooth, steady zoom-in, focusing on the action unfolding on the vibrant green grass. The warm late afternoon sun casts long, dramatic shadows. In the outfield, a male player with short, dark hair, wearing a white pinstriped jersey and matching pants, sprints fiercely, heading directly toward the camera. His eyes are fixed intently on a small, white baseball flying down from the sky. As the camera continues to zoom, it captures the firm grip of his jaw and the powerful roll of his legs. He extends his left arm, revealing a well-worn brown leather baseball glove, and at the last moment, the ball drops resoundingly and decisively into the glove pocket. His momentum is so great that after catching the ball with his right hand, he executes a fluid, athletic 360-degree spin across the turf, stopping with a poised, triumphant satisfaction. The entire scene exudes an aura of peak sportsmanship and focused energy.", + "seed": 26355, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_15/index_9102_seed_26355_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.027961372490972282, + "vlm_logprob": -0.027961372490972282, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.027961372490972282, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a wide shot of a sun-drenched baseball field under a bright blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a smooth, steady zoom-in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a male player wearing a white pinstriped jersey and matching pants visible sprinting toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the player catch a white baseball with his right hand and execute a fluid 360-degree spin across the turf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long shadows cast by the warm late afternoon sun visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013172862119972706 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.388172626495361 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013172862119972706, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013172862119972706, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20605026185512543, + 0.10644274204969406, + 0.058136604726314545, + 0.14239516854286194, + 0.09518487006425858, + 0.11642509698867798, + 0.15405398607254028, + 0.04232800379395485, + 0.04587211832404137, + 0.033111147582530975 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013172862119972706 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a wide shot of a sun-drenched baseball field under a bright blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a smooth, steady zoom-in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a male player wearing a white pinstriped jersey and matching pants visible sprinting toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the player catch a white baseball with his right hand and execute a fluid 360-degree spin across the turf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long shadows cast by the warm late afternoon sun visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897534221410751 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789754390716553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897534221410751, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897534221410751, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2018095850944519, + 0.06752752512693405, + 0.07698356360197067, + 0.2099512368440628, + 0.09042294323444366, + 0.1630156934261322, + 0.042353756725788116, + 0.026327181607484818, + 0.06140837073326111, + 0.06020011752843857 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897534221410751 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a wide shot of a sun-drenched baseball field under a bright blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a smooth, steady zoom-in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a male player wearing a white pinstriped jersey and matching pants visible sprinting toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the player catch a white baseball with his right hand and execute a fluid 360-degree spin across the turf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long shadows cast by the warm late afternoon sun visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026337021961808205 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651336908340454 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026337021961808205, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026337021961808205, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21924467384815216, + 0.17482103407382965, + 0.11870712041854858, + 0.07836022228002548, + 0.11824272572994232, + 0.09272677451372147, + 0.03545728325843811, + 0.04211140796542168, + 0.06547050923109055, + 0.05485820397734642 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026337021961808205 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a wide shot of a sun-drenched baseball field under a bright blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a smooth, steady zoom-in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a male player wearing a white pinstriped jersey and matching pants visible sprinting toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the player catch a white baseball with his right hand and execute a fluid 360-degree spin across the turf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long shadows cast by the warm late afternoon sun visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016073059290647507 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141073226928711 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016073059290647507, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016073059290647507, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2069896012544632, + 0.07681409269571304, + 0.08361642062664032, + 0.21215026080608368, + 0.056461483240127563, + 0.15382397174835205, + 0.04891249164938927, + 0.04617137834429741, + 0.04475913941860199, + 0.0703011155128479 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016073059290647507 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a wide shot of a sun-drenched baseball field under a bright blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a smooth, steady zoom-in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a male player wearing a white pinstriped jersey and matching pants visible sprinting toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the player catch a white baseball with his right hand and execute a fluid 360-degree spin across the turf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long shadows cast by the warm late afternoon sun visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005248576868325472 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255248546600342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005248576868325472, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005248576868325472, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10966905951499939, + 0.1448245793581009, + 0.15250259637832642, + 0.06677919626235962, + 0.04463087022304535, + 0.2806101143360138, + 0.044735852628946304, + 0.04782022163271904, + 0.06453104317188263, + 0.04389646649360657 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005248576868325472 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_2/index_tensor([2357, 2357])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_2/index_tensor([2357, 2357])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5683212bd8297ca774c20154b8a27fb9cf3105e6 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_2/index_tensor([2357, 2357])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "Rendered in perfectly photorealistic 3D animation, a high-angle close-up smoothly tracks a solid yellow billiard ball as it rolls with steady momentum across the rich emerald green of the pool table. The ball's surface is a perfect, high-gloss sphere, its polished surface reflecting sharp, circular highlights from a single, focused overhead light source, creating ray-traced reflections and casting soft, elongated shadows that glide along the velvety texture of the felt. The camera maintains a constant distance as the ball moves in a perfectly straight line toward the table's padded railing, its dark polished mahogany coming into view. In a physically accurate moment, the ball makes firm contact with the rail, causing the rubber padding to visibly compress for a split second. Immediately after the collision, the opposing force is transferred back to the ball, causing it to rebound cleanly and roll in a new, precise direction, with a slight decrease in speed but still perfectly smooth rotation, capturing the quiet, focused atmosphere of pure physical motion.", + "seed": 14891, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_2/index_2357_seed_14891_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0381050861440599, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0381050861440599, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0381050861440599, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a solid yellow billiard ball with a high-gloss, perfectly spherical surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ball rolling across a pool table covered in rich emerald green felt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a single focused overhead light source creating sharp circular highlights and soft elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ball make firm contact with the table's dark polished mahogany padded railing, causing the rubber padding to visibly compress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a high-angle close-up view at a constant distance while tracking the ball's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02446880005300045 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7744688987731934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02446880005300045, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02446880005300045, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3217436671257019, + 0.10596936196088791, + 0.039739783853292465, + 0.039342690259218216, + 0.029118383303284645, + 0.11529941856861115, + 0.05129966512322426, + 0.05141434445977211, + 0.1626282036304474, + 0.08344443142414093 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02446880005300045 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a solid yellow billiard ball with a high-gloss, perfectly spherical surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ball rolling across a pool table covered in rich emerald green felt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a single focused overhead light source creating sharp circular highlights and soft elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ball make firm contact with the table's dark polished mahogany padded railing, causing the rubber padding to visibly compress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a high-angle close-up view at a constant distance while tracking the ball's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003198272082954645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753198146820068 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003198272082954645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003198272082954645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2585965096950531, + 0.07351526618003845, + 0.07978975027799606, + 0.0317438468337059, + 0.03457828238606453, + 0.17865729331970215, + 0.08524194359779358, + 0.0805087685585022, + 0.07949958741664886, + 0.09786871820688248 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003198272082954645 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a solid yellow billiard ball with a high-gloss, perfectly spherical surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ball rolling across a pool table covered in rich emerald green felt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a single focused overhead light source creating sharp circular highlights and soft elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ball make firm contact with the table's dark polished mahogany padded railing, causing the rubber padding to visibly compress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a high-angle close-up view at a constant distance while tracking the ball's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007628831081092358 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882628917694092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007628831081092358, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007628831081092358, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29270029067993164, + 0.07485576719045639, + 0.06292933225631714, + 0.05529484897851944, + 0.04597153514623642, + 0.272734135389328, + 0.04895053058862686, + 0.04344945400953293, + 0.03815636783838272, + 0.06495772302150726 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007628831081092358 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a solid yellow billiard ball with a high-gloss, perfectly spherical surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ball rolling across a pool table covered in rich emerald green felt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a single focused overhead light source creating sharp circular highlights and soft elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ball make firm contact with the table's dark polished mahogany padded railing, causing the rubber padding to visibly compress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a high-angle close-up view at a constant distance while tracking the ball's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1002957671880722 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3502957820892334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1002957671880722, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1002957671880722, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18785804510116577, + 0.12888221442699432, + 0.04093385860323906, + 0.11723264306783676, + 0.027254045009613037, + 0.07369353622198105, + 0.05764152109622955, + 0.04191061854362488, + 0.19615186750888824, + 0.12844164669513702 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1002957671880722 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a solid yellow billiard ball with a high-gloss, perfectly spherical surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ball rolling across a pool table covered in rich emerald green felt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a single focused overhead light source creating sharp circular highlights and soft elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ball make firm contact with the table's dark polished mahogany padded railing, causing the rubber padding to visibly compress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a high-angle close-up view at a constant distance while tracking the ball's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054933760315179825 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929933786392212 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054933760315179825, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054933760315179825, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11918789148330688, + 0.027391953393816948, + 0.03892774507403374, + 0.03793724998831749, + 0.03304244950413704, + 0.40337949991226196, + 0.09567639976739883, + 0.052612900733947754, + 0.1315862089395523, + 0.06025775149464607 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054933760315179825 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Rendered in perfectly photorealistic 3D animation, a high-angle close-up smoothly tracks a solid yellow billiard ball as it rolls with steady momentum across the rich emerald green of the pool table. The ball's surface is a perfect, high-gloss sphere, its polished surface reflecting sharp, circular highlights from a single, focused overhead light source, creating ray-traced reflections and casting soft, elongated shadows that glide along the velvety texture of the felt. The camera maintains a constant distance as the ball moves in a perfectly straight line toward the table's padded railing, its dark polished mahogany coming into view. In a physically accurate moment, the ball makes firm contact with the rail, causing the rubber padding to visibly compress for a split second. Immediately after the collision, the opposing force is transferred back to the ball, causing it to rebound cleanly and roll in a new, precise direction, with a slight decrease in speed but still perfectly smooth rotation, capturing the quiet, focused atmosphere of pure physical motion.", + "seed": 14892, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_2/index_2357_seed_14892_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.01550040568690747, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01550040568690747, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01550040568690747, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a solid yellow billiard ball with a high-gloss, perfectly spherical surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ball rolling across a pool table covered in rich emerald green felt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a single focused overhead light source creating sharp circular highlights and soft elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ball make firm contact with the table's dark polished mahogany padded railing, causing the rubber padding to visibly compress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a high-angle close-up view at a constant distance while tracking the ball's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00779515178874135 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.007795333862305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00779515178874135, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00779515178874135, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05886247754096985, + 0.6396922469139099, + 0.017869753763079643, + 0.016487974673509598, + 0.03919605538249016, + 0.0806809663772583, + 0.047060076147317886, + 0.05948522314429283, + 0.011547781527042389, + 0.029117386788129807 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00779515178874135 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a solid yellow billiard ball with a high-gloss, perfectly spherical surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ball rolling across a pool table covered in rich emerald green felt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a single focused overhead light source creating sharp circular highlights and soft elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ball make firm contact with the table's dark polished mahogany padded railing, causing the rubber padding to visibly compress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a high-angle close-up view at a constant distance while tracking the ball's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017245433991774917 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376724720001221 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017245433991774917, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017245433991774917, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04058288037776947, + 0.262029767036438, + 0.05949704721570015, + 0.043027784675359726, + 0.09626053273677826, + 0.07413476705551147, + 0.05596141889691353, + 0.27492645382881165, + 0.03935322165489197, + 0.0542261116206646 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017245433991774917 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a solid yellow billiard ball with a high-gloss, perfectly spherical surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ball rolling across a pool table covered in rich emerald green felt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a single focused overhead light source creating sharp circular highlights and soft elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ball make firm contact with the table's dark polished mahogany padded railing, causing the rubber padding to visibly compress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a high-angle close-up view at a constant distance while tracking the ball's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006741635967046022 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006741523742676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006741635967046022, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006741635967046022, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.035735175013542175, + 0.3798101544380188, + 0.018910560756921768, + 0.02014487236738205, + 0.05768803879618645, + 0.08480960875749588, + 0.04847929999232292, + 0.1534534990787506, + 0.1470869928598404, + 0.05388180911540985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006741635967046022 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a solid yellow billiard ball with a high-gloss, perfectly spherical surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ball rolling across a pool table covered in rich emerald green felt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a single focused overhead light source creating sharp circular highlights and soft elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ball make firm contact with the table's dark polished mahogany padded railing, causing the rubber padding to visibly compress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a high-angle close-up view at a constant distance while tracking the ball's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018188944086432457 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018188953399658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018188944086432457, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018188944086432457, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.01343048457056284, + 0.15177594125270844, + 0.02400147169828415, + 0.01823919638991356, + 0.012655052356421947, + 0.21924439072608948, + 0.04975712671875954, + 0.3447696566581726, + 0.07141653448343277, + 0.09471006691455841 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018188944086432457 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a solid yellow billiard ball with a high-gloss, perfectly spherical surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ball rolling across a pool table covered in rich emerald green felt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a single focused overhead light source creating sharp circular highlights and soft elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ball make firm contact with the table's dark polished mahogany padded railing, causing the rubber padding to visibly compress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a high-angle close-up view at a constant distance while tracking the ball's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305175319314003 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680517196655273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305175319314003, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305175319314003, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.015668198466300964, + 0.28126269578933716, + 0.013987780548632145, + 0.010282901115715504, + 0.01744946837425232, + 0.2064981609582901, + 0.05428490787744522, + 0.3473477363586426, + 0.02158919908106327, + 0.03162892162799835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305175319314003 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Rendered in perfectly photorealistic 3D animation, a high-angle close-up smoothly tracks a solid yellow billiard ball as it rolls with steady momentum across the rich emerald green of the pool table. The ball's surface is a perfect, high-gloss sphere, its polished surface reflecting sharp, circular highlights from a single, focused overhead light source, creating ray-traced reflections and casting soft, elongated shadows that glide along the velvety texture of the felt. The camera maintains a constant distance as the ball moves in a perfectly straight line toward the table's padded railing, its dark polished mahogany coming into view. In a physically accurate moment, the ball makes firm contact with the rail, causing the rubber padding to visibly compress for a split second. Immediately after the collision, the opposing force is transferred back to the ball, causing it to rebound cleanly and roll in a new, precise direction, with a slight decrease in speed but still perfectly smooth rotation, capturing the quiet, focused atmosphere of pure physical motion.", + "seed": 14893, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_2/index_2357_seed_14893_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03673396359663457, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03673396359663457, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03673396359663457, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a solid yellow billiard ball with a high-gloss, perfectly spherical surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ball rolling across a pool table covered in rich emerald green felt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a single focused overhead light source creating sharp circular highlights and soft elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ball make firm contact with the table's dark polished mahogany padded railing, causing the rubber padding to visibly compress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a high-angle close-up view at a constant distance while tracking the ball's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02727220393717289 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6522722244262695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02727220393717289, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02727220393717289, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1126466765999794, + 0.14059650897979736, + 0.11826669424772263, + 0.08131544291973114, + 0.08595860749483109, + 0.05268390104174614, + 0.1918533444404602, + 0.12307806313037872, + 0.05531509593129158, + 0.03828563168644905 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02727220393717289 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a solid yellow billiard ball with a high-gloss, perfectly spherical surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ball rolling across a pool table covered in rich emerald green felt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a single focused overhead light source creating sharp circular highlights and soft elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ball make firm contact with the table's dark polished mahogany padded railing, causing the rubber padding to visibly compress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a high-angle close-up view at a constant distance while tracking the ball's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019461041083559394 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251945972442627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019461041083559394, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019461041083559394, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.309005469083786, + 0.15916100144386292, + 0.06466543674468994, + 0.09863054007291794, + 0.10603532940149307, + 0.04564927518367767, + 0.03352877497673035, + 0.05730685964226723, + 0.05036412551999092, + 0.07565323263406754 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019461041083559394 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a solid yellow billiard ball with a high-gloss, perfectly spherical surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ball rolling across a pool table covered in rich emerald green felt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a single focused overhead light source creating sharp circular highlights and soft elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ball make firm contact with the table's dark polished mahogany padded railing, causing the rubber padding to visibly compress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a high-angle close-up view at a constant distance while tracking the ball's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016070714220404625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14107084274292 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016070714220404625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016070714220404625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.43198537826538086, + 0.06615500897169113, + 0.13584290444850922, + 0.12686669826507568, + 0.02602112479507923, + 0.027818802744150162, + 0.04160052910447121, + 0.058685049414634705, + 0.05254385620355606, + 0.032480668276548386 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016070714220404625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a solid yellow billiard ball with a high-gloss, perfectly spherical surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ball rolling across a pool table covered in rich emerald green felt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a single focused overhead light source creating sharp circular highlights and soft elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ball make firm contact with the table's dark polished mahogany padded railing, causing the rubber padding to visibly compress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a high-angle close-up view at a constant distance while tracking the ball's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038092367351055145 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880923748016357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038092367351055145, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038092367351055145, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2713317573070526, + 0.06070363149046898, + 0.1556326448917389, + 0.09202440828084946, + 0.08045843243598938, + 0.030787598341703415, + 0.03697076812386513, + 0.04602644219994545, + 0.07478111982345581, + 0.15128318965435028 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038092367351055145 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a solid yellow billiard ball with a high-gloss, perfectly spherical surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ball rolling across a pool table covered in rich emerald green felt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a single focused overhead light source creating sharp circular highlights and soft elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ball make firm contact with the table's dark polished mahogany padded railing, causing the rubber padding to visibly compress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a high-angle close-up view at a constant distance while tracking the ball's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10028842836618423 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3502883911132812 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10028842836618423, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10028842836618423, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21896512806415558, + 0.0716436356306076, + 0.13263331353664398, + 0.11815664917230606, + 0.06040706858038902, + 0.03242885321378708, + 0.05342034995555878, + 0.06786695122718811, + 0.19629675149917603, + 0.04818130284547806 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10028842836618423 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Rendered in perfectly photorealistic 3D animation, a high-angle close-up smoothly tracks a solid yellow billiard ball as it rolls with steady momentum across the rich emerald green of the pool table. The ball's surface is a perfect, high-gloss sphere, its polished surface reflecting sharp, circular highlights from a single, focused overhead light source, creating ray-traced reflections and casting soft, elongated shadows that glide along the velvety texture of the felt. The camera maintains a constant distance as the ball moves in a perfectly straight line toward the table's padded railing, its dark polished mahogany coming into view. In a physically accurate moment, the ball makes firm contact with the rail, causing the rubber padding to visibly compress for a split second. Immediately after the collision, the opposing force is transferred back to the ball, causing it to rebound cleanly and roll in a new, precise direction, with a slight decrease in speed but still perfectly smooth rotation, capturing the quiet, focused atmosphere of pure physical motion.", + "seed": 14894, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_2/index_2357_seed_14894_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03410009723156691, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03410009723156691, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03410009723156691, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a solid yellow billiard ball with a high-gloss, perfectly spherical surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ball rolling across a pool table covered in rich emerald green felt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a single focused overhead light source creating sharp circular highlights and soft elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ball make firm contact with the table's dark polished mahogany padded railing, causing the rubber padding to visibly compress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a high-angle close-up view at a constant distance while tracking the ball's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.035410765558481216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4104108810424805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.035410765558481216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.035410765558481216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13401883840560913, + 0.18979912996292114, + 0.08354582637548447, + 0.055672839283943176, + 0.045436371117830276, + 0.13448598980903625, + 0.02446829341351986, + 0.04921784624457359, + 0.19503171741962433, + 0.08832315355539322 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.035410765558481216 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a solid yellow billiard ball with a high-gloss, perfectly spherical surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ball rolling across a pool table covered in rich emerald green felt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a single focused overhead light source creating sharp circular highlights and soft elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ball make firm contact with the table's dark polished mahogany padded railing, causing the rubber padding to visibly compress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a high-angle close-up view at a constant distance while tracking the ball's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024980073794722557 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002498149871826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024980073794722557, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024980073794722557, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21527348458766937, + 0.10799047350883484, + 0.056516777724027634, + 0.08297387510538101, + 0.11527765542268753, + 0.08584707975387573, + 0.05983356758952141, + 0.10504913330078125, + 0.12065070867538452, + 0.05058727040886879 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024980073794722557 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a solid yellow billiard ball with a high-gloss, perfectly spherical surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ball rolling across a pool table covered in rich emerald green felt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a single focused overhead light source creating sharp circular highlights and soft elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ball make firm contact with the table's dark polished mahogany padded railing, causing the rubber padding to visibly compress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a high-angle close-up view at a constant distance while tracking the ball's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007633090019226074 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882633209228516 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007633090019226074, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007633090019226074, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35249266028404236, + 0.231047123670578, + 0.06025956943631172, + 0.04679865390062332, + 0.028437530621886253, + 0.05063232406973839, + 0.037576429545879364, + 0.04049407318234444, + 0.10142194479703903, + 0.050839636474847794 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007633090019226074 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a solid yellow billiard ball with a high-gloss, perfectly spherical surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ball rolling across a pool table covered in rich emerald green felt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a single focused overhead light source creating sharp circular highlights and soft elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ball make firm contact with the table's dark polished mahogany padded railing, causing the rubber padding to visibly compress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a high-angle close-up view at a constant distance while tracking the ball's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0700145959854126 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695014476776123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0700145959854126, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0700145959854126, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2369818240404129, + 0.1259756088256836, + 0.07572521269321442, + 0.07344476133584976, + 0.09622397273778915, + 0.10469094663858414, + 0.07163263857364655, + 0.05257778242230415, + 0.11264874786138535, + 0.050098538398742676 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0700145959854126 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a solid yellow billiard ball with a high-gloss, perfectly spherical surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the ball rolling across a pool table covered in rich emerald green felt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a single focused overhead light source creating sharp circular highlights and soft elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ball make firm contact with the table's dark polished mahogany padded railing, causing the rubber padding to visibly compress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a high-angle close-up view at a constant distance while tracking the ball's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054944027215242386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299440383911133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054944027215242386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054944027215242386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2994774878025055, + 0.08213650435209274, + 0.04272902384400368, + 0.06747724860906601, + 0.039826225489377975, + 0.058628182858228683, + 0.041150446981191635, + 0.025639070197939873, + 0.3004443943500519, + 0.04249146208167076 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054944027215242386 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_3/index_tensor([2533, 2533])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_3/index_tensor([2533, 2533])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ff6ec9664ea6728374f02b82784faa6ff46fd8c9 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_3/index_tensor([2533, 2533])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a somber, painterly style defined by dramatic black-and-white contrasts and rich, deep shadows, a tightly framed shot begins at a high angle, then slowly and deliberately tilts downward to lock onto a once-charming figure. They slump in a chair, their pose a portrait of utter defeat, their shoulders rounded, their heads bent slightly forward. Their faces are a canvas of despair, their once-perfect hairstyles now tangled in limp braids. Expensive, heavy makeup is tragically ruined; thick black mascara leaves visible tear marks on their pale cheeks, while bold lipstick is smeared and cracked around their mouths. Their eyes, wide but completely empty, stare absently into the middle distance, their expressions a blank mask of sorrow. They sit directly in front of a large, modern ring light, its circular shape a cold, black silhouette in the darkness, its unlit bulbs like dead eyes, mocking their own extinguished light. The oppressive darkness of the room enveloped them, only a harsh, critical light shone from one side carving their features out of the darkness, casting long, twisted shadows that crept up the wall behind them, emphasizing the tangible, stifling atmosphere of their inner collapse.", + "seed": 16467, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_3/index_2533_seed_16467_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.09299873858690262, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09299873858690262, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09299873858690262, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a black-and-white style with dramatic contrasts and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially framed at a high angle before tilting downward to focus on the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject sitting in a chair with slumped shoulders and a head bent forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a large, modern ring light visible as a black silhouette behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the subject's face showing ruined makeup with smeared lipstick and tear marks from mascara?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013568085618317127 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.888567924499512 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013568085618317127, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013568085618317127, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04430476203560829, + 0.040672220289707184, + 0.04310792312026024, + 0.0757964551448822, + 0.05535449832677841, + 0.017786232754588127, + 0.04331914335489273, + 0.03595422953367233, + 0.09217123687267303, + 0.5515334010124207 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013568085618317127 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a black-and-white style with dramatic contrasts and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially framed at a high angle before tilting downward to focus on the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject sitting in a chair with slumped shoulders and a head bent forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a large, modern ring light visible as a black silhouette behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the subject's face showing ruined makeup with smeared lipstick and tear marks from mascara?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34863731265068054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223637342453003 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34863731265068054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34863731265068054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05632319301366806, + 0.09514649212360382, + 0.05942542850971222, + 0.07010696083307266, + 0.12363468110561371, + 0.10043255984783173, + 0.3937609791755676, + 0.021912073716521263, + 0.04530348256230354, + 0.03395414724946022 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34863731265068054 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a black-and-white style with dramatic contrasts and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially framed at a high angle before tilting downward to focus on the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject sitting in a chair with slumped shoulders and a head bent forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a large, modern ring light visible as a black silhouette behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the subject's face showing ruined makeup with smeared lipstick and tear marks from mascara?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865795746445656 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486578941345215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865795746445656, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865795746445656, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.047914523631334305, + 0.04801376536488533, + 0.08783014118671417, + 0.03210026025772095, + 0.037962209433317184, + 0.15167072415351868, + 0.30009138584136963, + 0.05056392028927803, + 0.07755118608474731, + 0.16630184650421143 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865795746445656 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a black-and-white style with dramatic contrasts and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially framed at a high angle before tilting downward to focus on the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject sitting in a chair with slumped shoulders and a head bent forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a large, modern ring light visible as a black silhouette behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the subject's face showing ruined makeup with smeared lipstick and tear marks from mascara?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011069907806813717 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110697746276855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011069907806813717, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011069907806813717, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11605969071388245, + 0.12851718068122864, + 0.19570258259773254, + 0.02597385086119175, + 0.07936111837625504, + 0.05939874425530434, + 0.18818433582782745, + 0.05024068430066109, + 0.08243178576231003, + 0.07413002103567123 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011069907806813717 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a black-and-white style with dramatic contrasts and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially framed at a high angle before tilting downward to focus on the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject sitting in a chair with slumped shoulders and a head bent forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a large, modern ring light visible as a black silhouette behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the subject's face showing ruined makeup with smeared lipstick and tear marks from mascara?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306042939424515 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168060541152954 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306042939424515, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306042939424515, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05553227663040161, + 0.07257094234228134, + 0.12833313643932343, + 0.05322832614183426, + 0.04910273104906082, + 0.058501794934272766, + 0.4644465148448944, + 0.06149197369813919, + 0.021051842719316483, + 0.03574046120047569 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306042939424515 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a somber, painterly style defined by dramatic black-and-white contrasts and rich, deep shadows, a tightly framed shot begins at a high angle, then slowly and deliberately tilts downward to lock onto a once-charming figure. They slump in a chair, their pose a portrait of utter defeat, their shoulders rounded, their heads bent slightly forward. Their faces are a canvas of despair, their once-perfect hairstyles now tangled in limp braids. Expensive, heavy makeup is tragically ruined; thick black mascara leaves visible tear marks on their pale cheeks, while bold lipstick is smeared and cracked around their mouths. Their eyes, wide but completely empty, stare absently into the middle distance, their expressions a blank mask of sorrow. They sit directly in front of a large, modern ring light, its circular shape a cold, black silhouette in the darkness, its unlit bulbs like dead eyes, mocking their own extinguished light. The oppressive darkness of the room enveloped them, only a harsh, critical light shone from one side carving their features out of the darkness, casting long, twisted shadows that crept up the wall behind them, emphasizing the tangible, stifling atmosphere of their inner collapse.", + "seed": 16468, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_3/index_2533_seed_16468_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.039881098177284004, + "vlm_logprob": -0.039881098177284004, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.039881098177284004, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a black-and-white style with dramatic contrasts and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially framed at a high angle before tilting downward to focus on the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject sitting in a chair with slumped shoulders and a head bent forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a large, modern ring light visible as a black silhouette behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the subject's face showing ruined makeup with smeared lipstick and tear marks from mascara?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005558510776609182 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.255558490753174 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005558510776609182, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005558510776609182, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3546973168849945, + 0.1308775693178177, + 0.03620466962456703, + 0.1400635689496994, + 0.07341065257787704, + 0.09170792251825333, + 0.04971260577440262, + 0.08376077562570572, + 0.019619032740592957, + 0.01994585432112217 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005558510776609182 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a black-and-white style with dramatic contrasts and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially framed at a high angle before tilting downward to focus on the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject sitting in a chair with slumped shoulders and a head bent forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a large, modern ring light visible as a black silhouette behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the subject's face showing ruined makeup with smeared lipstick and tear marks from mascara?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08905996382236481 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464060068130493 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08905996382236481, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08905996382236481, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16985832154750824, + 0.0975421667098999, + 0.13755731284618378, + 0.3331088125705719, + 0.08033748716115952, + 0.04782121255993843, + 0.019722072407603264, + 0.04409895837306976, + 0.0373174324631691, + 0.03263618052005768 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08905996382236481 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a black-and-white style with dramatic contrasts and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially framed at a high angle before tilting downward to focus on the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject sitting in a chair with slumped shoulders and a head bent forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a large, modern ring light visible as a black silhouette behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the subject's face showing ruined makeup with smeared lipstick and tear marks from mascara?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634967863559723 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513497829437256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634967863559723, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634967863559723, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14627531170845032, + 0.06934607028961182, + 0.0595470666885376, + 0.13522091507911682, + 0.2667404115200043, + 0.0414251908659935, + 0.050954073667526245, + 0.1525837481021881, + 0.018862223252654076, + 0.059044964611530304 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634967863559723 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a black-and-white style with dramatic contrasts and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially framed at a high angle before tilting downward to focus on the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject sitting in a chair with slumped shoulders and a head bent forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a large, modern ring light visible as a black silhouette behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the subject's face showing ruined makeup with smeared lipstick and tear marks from mascara?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04863797500729561 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048637866973877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04863797500729561, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04863797500729561, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13581843674182892, + 0.21449781954288483, + 0.13766726851463318, + 0.1350436955690384, + 0.10869181156158447, + 0.07226977497339249, + 0.09458568692207336, + 0.05384358763694763, + 0.02291283570230007, + 0.02466912940144539 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04863797500729561 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a black-and-white style with dramatic contrasts and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially framed at a high angle before tilting downward to focus on the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject sitting in a chair with slumped shoulders and a head bent forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a large, modern ring light visible as a black silhouette behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the subject's face showing ruined makeup with smeared lipstick and tear marks from mascara?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029799362644553185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529799461364746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029799362644553185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029799362644553185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12819857895374298, + 0.14119578897953033, + 0.3039831817150116, + 0.07571294158697128, + 0.07217000424861908, + 0.058587696403265, + 0.03348027914762497, + 0.03841708227992058, + 0.037380483001470566, + 0.11087395995855331 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029799362644553185 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a somber, painterly style defined by dramatic black-and-white contrasts and rich, deep shadows, a tightly framed shot begins at a high angle, then slowly and deliberately tilts downward to lock onto a once-charming figure. They slump in a chair, their pose a portrait of utter defeat, their shoulders rounded, their heads bent slightly forward. Their faces are a canvas of despair, their once-perfect hairstyles now tangled in limp braids. Expensive, heavy makeup is tragically ruined; thick black mascara leaves visible tear marks on their pale cheeks, while bold lipstick is smeared and cracked around their mouths. Their eyes, wide but completely empty, stare absently into the middle distance, their expressions a blank mask of sorrow. They sit directly in front of a large, modern ring light, its circular shape a cold, black silhouette in the darkness, its unlit bulbs like dead eyes, mocking their own extinguished light. The oppressive darkness of the room enveloped them, only a harsh, critical light shone from one side carving their features out of the darkness, casting long, twisted shadows that crept up the wall behind them, emphasizing the tangible, stifling atmosphere of their inner collapse.", + "seed": 16469, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_3/index_2533_seed_16469_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.0407747364602983, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0407747364602983, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0407747364602983, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a black-and-white style with dramatic contrasts and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially framed at a high angle before tilting downward to focus on the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject sitting in a chair with slumped shoulders and a head bent forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a large, modern ring light visible as a black silhouette behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the subject's face showing ruined makeup with smeared lipstick and tear marks from mascara?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0069702561013400555 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.381970405578613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0069702561013400555, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0069702561013400555, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12278985977172852, + 0.14127734303474426, + 0.023913782089948654, + 0.06394486874341965, + 0.2237139344215393, + 0.01788659393787384, + 0.06015419214963913, + 0.07791858911514282, + 0.03186454251408577, + 0.23653626441955566 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0069702561013400555 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a black-and-white style with dramatic contrasts and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially framed at a high angle before tilting downward to focus on the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject sitting in a chair with slumped shoulders and a head bent forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a large, modern ring light visible as a black silhouette behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the subject's face showing ruined makeup with smeared lipstick and tear marks from mascara?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048674650490283966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486745834350586 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048674650490283966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048674650490283966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0785815492272377, + 0.11282791942358017, + 0.0915863960981369, + 0.07415387034416199, + 0.05325622111558914, + 0.08054622262716293, + 0.06671174615621567, + 0.3459208905696869, + 0.018968896940350533, + 0.07744629681110382 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048674650490283966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a black-and-white style with dramatic contrasts and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially framed at a high angle before tilting downward to focus on the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject sitting in a chair with slumped shoulders and a head bent forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a large, modern ring light visible as a black silhouette behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the subject's face showing ruined makeup with smeared lipstick and tear marks from mascara?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12705561518669128 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270556449890137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12705561518669128, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12705561518669128, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.042376283556222916, + 0.19503802061080933, + 0.03308062255382538, + 0.06851112842559814, + 0.051936034113168716, + 0.028641758486628532, + 0.08618796616792679, + 0.388465940952301, + 0.03536384925246239, + 0.07039831578731537 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12705561518669128 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a black-and-white style with dramatic contrasts and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially framed at a high angle before tilting downward to focus on the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject sitting in a chair with slumped shoulders and a head bent forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a large, modern ring light visible as a black silhouette behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the subject's face showing ruined makeup with smeared lipstick and tear marks from mascara?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01253464724868536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875346183776855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01253464724868536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01253464724868536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17957982420921326, + 0.20054739713668823, + 0.043164778500795364, + 0.144452303647995, + 0.07069908082485199, + 0.03512939438223839, + 0.12391508370637894, + 0.1273309737443924, + 0.016193553805351257, + 0.05898766219615936 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01253464724868536 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a black-and-white style with dramatic contrasts and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially framed at a high angle before tilting downward to focus on the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject sitting in a chair with slumped shoulders and a head bent forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a large, modern ring light visible as a black silhouette behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the subject's face showing ruined makeup with smeared lipstick and tear marks from mascara?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008638513274490833 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758638381958008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008638513274490833, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008638513274490833, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05226699262857437, + 0.036252908408641815, + 0.047147996723651886, + 0.05057692527770996, + 0.055025432258844376, + 0.04691636189818382, + 0.18259306252002716, + 0.41175949573516846, + 0.04966811463236809, + 0.06779271364212036 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008638513274490833 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a somber, painterly style defined by dramatic black-and-white contrasts and rich, deep shadows, a tightly framed shot begins at a high angle, then slowly and deliberately tilts downward to lock onto a once-charming figure. They slump in a chair, their pose a portrait of utter defeat, their shoulders rounded, their heads bent slightly forward. Their faces are a canvas of despair, their once-perfect hairstyles now tangled in limp braids. Expensive, heavy makeup is tragically ruined; thick black mascara leaves visible tear marks on their pale cheeks, while bold lipstick is smeared and cracked around their mouths. Their eyes, wide but completely empty, stare absently into the middle distance, their expressions a blank mask of sorrow. They sit directly in front of a large, modern ring light, its circular shape a cold, black silhouette in the darkness, its unlit bulbs like dead eyes, mocking their own extinguished light. The oppressive darkness of the room enveloped them, only a harsh, critical light shone from one side carving their features out of the darkness, casting long, twisted shadows that crept up the wall behind them, emphasizing the tangible, stifling atmosphere of their inner collapse.", + "seed": 16470, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_3/index_2533_seed_16470_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.02482500486075878, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02482500486075878, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02482500486075878, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a black-and-white style with dramatic contrasts and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially framed at a high angle before tilting downward to focus on the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject sitting in a chair with slumped shoulders and a head bent forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a large, modern ring light visible as a black silhouette behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the subject's face showing ruined makeup with smeared lipstick and tear marks from mascara?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009549414739012718 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.884549617767334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009549414739012718, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009549414739012718, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5434117913246155, + 0.043385352939367294, + 0.023422585800290108, + 0.030859721824526787, + 0.06220921874046326, + 0.04318128898739815, + 0.03228818625211716, + 0.06380298733711243, + 0.037097856402397156, + 0.12034102529287338 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009549414739012718 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a black-and-white style with dramatic contrasts and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially framed at a high angle before tilting downward to focus on the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject sitting in a chair with slumped shoulders and a head bent forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a large, modern ring light visible as a black silhouette behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the subject's face showing ruined makeup with smeared lipstick and tear marks from mascara?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0097969900816679 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634797096252441 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0097969900816679, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0097969900816679, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31501147150993347, + 0.06584271788597107, + 0.10626022517681122, + 0.1277490109205246, + 0.07141660153865814, + 0.07332075387239456, + 0.06645750254392624, + 0.05543984845280647, + 0.02985374443233013, + 0.08864814788103104 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0097969900816679 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a black-and-white style with dramatic contrasts and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially framed at a high angle before tilting downward to focus on the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject sitting in a chair with slumped shoulders and a head bent forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a large, modern ring light visible as a black silhouette behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the subject's face showing ruined makeup with smeared lipstick and tear marks from mascara?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029797164723277092 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529797077178955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029797164723277092, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029797164723277092, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1650954633951187, + 0.05093933269381523, + 0.038085658103227615, + 0.0776611790060997, + 0.07383313775062561, + 0.046576712280511856, + 0.10773641616106033, + 0.20509320497512817, + 0.06093152239918709, + 0.1740473508834839 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029797164723277092 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a black-and-white style with dramatic contrasts and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially framed at a high angle before tilting downward to focus on the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject sitting in a chair with slumped shoulders and a head bent forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a large, modern ring light visible as a black silhouette behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the subject's face showing ruined makeup with smeared lipstick and tear marks from mascara?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04863990470767021 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048640012741089 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04863990470767021, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04863990470767021, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4654650390148163, + 0.11786206811666489, + 0.04239531606435776, + 0.06465069949626923, + 0.03899243474006653, + 0.03914026916027069, + 0.07460886240005493, + 0.04541798308491707, + 0.04081523045897484, + 0.07065214961767197 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04863990470767021 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in a black-and-white style with dramatic contrasts and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera initially framed at a high angle before tilting downward to focus on the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject sitting in a chair with slumped shoulders and a head bent forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a large, modern ring light visible as a black silhouette behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the subject's face showing ruined makeup with smeared lipstick and tear marks from mascara?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026341550052165985 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651341438293457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026341550052165985, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026341550052165985, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3323831856250763, + 0.0453394390642643, + 0.03936221823096275, + 0.04642212390899658, + 0.04835104942321777, + 0.036171864718198776, + 0.05984725430607796, + 0.1486421823501587, + 0.14222107827663422, + 0.10125960409641266 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026341550052165985 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_4/index_tensor([1420, 1420])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_4/index_tensor([1420, 1420])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f2a690171f5b128a17a4908fcc8a3f67a1a8d4c7 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_4/index_tensor([1420, 1420])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The scene begins with a close-up shot from a level angle, focusing on a woman with a gentle, slightly melancholic expression. Her long, raven-black hair flows like a waterfall, a few strands gently brushing against her softly contoured face. A subtle sadness lingers in her clear eyes. She wears a simple white silk dress, the material shimmering softly under the light from behind. Then, the camera begins to pull back in an extremely slow and steady rhythm. As the camera pans, the background behind her gradually becomes clear, revealing a shimmering galaxy, a delicate digital artwork. This galaxy is not a physical cosmic scene, but rather a woven fabric of countless shimmering geometric points of light, flowing energy lines, and translucent data streams, swirling and blending within it. Deep blue, mysterious purple, and fiery gold swirl and merge. As her figure shrinks against the vast cosmic backdrop, her outline becomes translucent, and the edges of her white dress gradually disintegrate into countless tiny points of light, drifting away like stardust. Ultimately, her physical form completely dissipated, gently merging into the swirling nebula of code and light, leaving behind only a faint humanoid shadow, which then vanished. Under the cool light of the digital galaxy, the entire scene created a tranquil, dreamy, and poetic atmosphere with a hint of fate.", + "seed": 11422, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_4/index_1420_seed_11422_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04915011264383793, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04915011264383793, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04915011264383793, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a woman with long, raven-black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple white silk dress that shimmers under backlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back slowly and steadily while panning to reveal a background of a shimmering galaxy made of geometric points and data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's physical form gradually become translucent and disintegrate into tiny points of light before vanishing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with only a faint humanoid shadow remaining before it also vanishes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03396500647068024 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4089651107788086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03396500647068024, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03396500647068024, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1456347107887268, + 0.5068134069442749, + 0.02343256212770939, + 0.014274238608777523, + 0.01942911185324192, + 0.209695503115654, + 0.01764359138906002, + 0.013901488855481148, + 0.025032151490449905, + 0.024143218994140625 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03396500647068024 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a woman with long, raven-black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple white silk dress that shimmers under backlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back slowly and steadily while panning to reveal a background of a shimmering galaxy made of geometric points and data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's physical form gradually become translucent and disintegrate into tiny points of light before vanishing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with only a faint humanoid shadow remaining before it also vanishes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10034213215112686 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350342035293579 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10034213215112686, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10034213215112686, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09019628167152405, + 0.5996631383895874, + 0.023976461961865425, + 0.01850142329931259, + 0.016946790739893913, + 0.12073458731174469, + 0.05508774146437645, + 0.029182137921452522, + 0.024567609652876854, + 0.02114376798272133 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10034213215112686 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a woman with long, raven-black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple white silk dress that shimmers under backlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back slowly and steadily while panning to reveal a background of a shimmering galaxy made of geometric points and data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's physical form gradually become translucent and disintegrate into tiny points of light before vanishing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with only a faint humanoid shadow remaining before it also vanishes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00249396450817585 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002493858337402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00249396450817585, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00249396450817585, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14589713513851166, + 0.08264858275651932, + 0.02062884345650673, + 0.05879432335495949, + 0.04093713313341141, + 0.2815829813480377, + 0.07310878485441208, + 0.09926421195268631, + 0.09492895752191544, + 0.10220897197723389 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00249396450817585 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a woman with long, raven-black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple white silk dress that shimmers under backlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back slowly and steadily while panning to reveal a background of a shimmering galaxy made of geometric points and data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's physical form gradually become translucent and disintegrate into tiny points of light before vanishing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with only a faint humanoid shadow remaining before it also vanishes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008640758693218231 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758640766143799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008640758693218231, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008640758693218231, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.078925222158432, + 0.15252485871315002, + 0.025323545560240746, + 0.028047172352671623, + 0.021768419072031975, + 0.07382124662399292, + 0.11431171000003815, + 0.16475151479244232, + 0.23248553276062012, + 0.10804082453250885 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008640758693218231 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a woman with long, raven-black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple white silk dress that shimmers under backlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back slowly and steadily while panning to reveal a background of a shimmering galaxy made of geometric points and data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's physical form gradually become translucent and disintegrate into tiny points of light before vanishing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with only a faint humanoid shadow remaining before it also vanishes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10030870139598846 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350308656692505 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10030870139598846, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10030870139598846, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0871276780962944, + 0.11647696793079376, + 0.02955818362534046, + 0.02794787473976612, + 0.024254299700260162, + 0.27799278497695923, + 0.05644891411066055, + 0.08496911823749542, + 0.1961805671453476, + 0.0990435779094696 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10030870139598846 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene begins with a close-up shot from a level angle, focusing on a woman with a gentle, slightly melancholic expression. Her long, raven-black hair flows like a waterfall, a few strands gently brushing against her softly contoured face. A subtle sadness lingers in her clear eyes. She wears a simple white silk dress, the material shimmering softly under the light from behind. Then, the camera begins to pull back in an extremely slow and steady rhythm. As the camera pans, the background behind her gradually becomes clear, revealing a shimmering galaxy, a delicate digital artwork. This galaxy is not a physical cosmic scene, but rather a woven fabric of countless shimmering geometric points of light, flowing energy lines, and translucent data streams, swirling and blending within it. Deep blue, mysterious purple, and fiery gold swirl and merge. As her figure shrinks against the vast cosmic backdrop, her outline becomes translucent, and the edges of her white dress gradually disintegrate into countless tiny points of light, drifting away like stardust. Ultimately, her physical form completely dissipated, gently merging into the swirling nebula of code and light, leaving behind only a faint humanoid shadow, which then vanished. Under the cool light of the digital galaxy, the entire scene created a tranquil, dreamy, and poetic atmosphere with a hint of fate.", + "seed": 11423, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_4/index_1420_seed_11423_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02995159402489662, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02995159402489662, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02995159402489662, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a woman with long, raven-black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple white silk dress that shimmers under backlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back slowly and steadily while panning to reveal a background of a shimmering galaxy made of geometric points and data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's physical form gradually become translucent and disintegrate into tiny points of light before vanishing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with only a faint humanoid shadow remaining before it also vanishes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014372635632753372 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264372825622559 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014372635632753372, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014372635632753372, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2939675450325012, + 0.10557018965482712, + 0.08677483350038528, + 0.02704470232129097, + 0.04728289321064949, + 0.04209641367197037, + 0.05501348525285721, + 0.2575438320636749, + 0.04698421061038971, + 0.03772183507680893 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014372635632753372 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a woman with long, raven-black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple white silk dress that shimmers under backlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back slowly and steadily while panning to reveal a background of a shimmering galaxy made of geometric points and data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's physical form gradually become translucent and disintegrate into tiny points of light before vanishing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with only a faint humanoid shadow remaining before it also vanishes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055008795112371445 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.930008888244629 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055008795112371445, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055008795112371445, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05741710960865021, + 0.029075374826788902, + 0.20550881326198578, + 0.08725401014089584, + 0.12908107042312622, + 0.06834695488214493, + 0.07283030450344086, + 0.28088629245758057, + 0.044997815042734146, + 0.02460227906703949 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055008795112371445 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a woman with long, raven-black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple white silk dress that shimmers under backlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back slowly and steadily while panning to reveal a background of a shimmering galaxy made of geometric points and data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's physical form gradually become translucent and disintegrate into tiny points of light before vanishing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with only a faint humanoid shadow remaining before it also vanishes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006747792940586805 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006747722625732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006747792940586805, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006747792940586805, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05162058398127556, + 0.029755981639027596, + 0.08116835355758667, + 0.1462147980928421, + 0.1050650104880333, + 0.16842029988765717, + 0.13570168614387512, + 0.060328830033540726, + 0.09901208430528641, + 0.12271235138177872 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006747792940586805 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a woman with long, raven-black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple white silk dress that shimmers under backlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back slowly and steadily while panning to reveal a background of a shimmering galaxy made of geometric points and data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's physical form gradually become translucent and disintegrate into tiny points of light before vanishing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with only a faint humanoid shadow remaining before it also vanishes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036168177612125874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628616809844971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036168177612125874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036168177612125874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11387179791927338, + 0.054447825998067856, + 0.17783218622207642, + 0.07288321852684021, + 0.0793987438082695, + 0.05634591728448868, + 0.09031488746404648, + 0.07753699272871017, + 0.1282522976398468, + 0.1491161286830902 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036168177612125874 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a woman with long, raven-black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple white silk dress that shimmers under backlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back slowly and steadily while panning to reveal a background of a shimmering galaxy made of geometric points and data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's physical form gradually become translucent and disintegrate into tiny points of light before vanishing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with only a faint humanoid shadow remaining before it also vanishes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0700119286775589 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695011854171753 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0700119286775589, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0700119286775589, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.047590482980012894, + 0.022926729172468185, + 0.08197330683469772, + 0.06676522642374039, + 0.04049720987677574, + 0.048088155686855316, + 0.04571305587887764, + 0.2959112823009491, + 0.0772843286395073, + 0.27325016260147095 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0700119286775589 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene begins with a close-up shot from a level angle, focusing on a woman with a gentle, slightly melancholic expression. Her long, raven-black hair flows like a waterfall, a few strands gently brushing against her softly contoured face. A subtle sadness lingers in her clear eyes. She wears a simple white silk dress, the material shimmering softly under the light from behind. Then, the camera begins to pull back in an extremely slow and steady rhythm. As the camera pans, the background behind her gradually becomes clear, revealing a shimmering galaxy, a delicate digital artwork. This galaxy is not a physical cosmic scene, but rather a woven fabric of countless shimmering geometric points of light, flowing energy lines, and translucent data streams, swirling and blending within it. Deep blue, mysterious purple, and fiery gold swirl and merge. As her figure shrinks against the vast cosmic backdrop, her outline becomes translucent, and the edges of her white dress gradually disintegrate into countless tiny points of light, drifting away like stardust. Ultimately, her physical form completely dissipated, gently merging into the swirling nebula of code and light, leaving behind only a faint humanoid shadow, which then vanished. Under the cool light of the digital galaxy, the entire scene created a tranquil, dreamy, and poetic atmosphere with a hint of fate.", + "seed": 11424, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_4/index_1420_seed_11424_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.0604342351667583, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0604342351667583, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0604342351667583, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a woman with long, raven-black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple white silk dress that shimmers under backlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back slowly and steadily while panning to reveal a background of a shimmering galaxy made of geometric points and data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's physical form gradually become translucent and disintegrate into tiny points of light before vanishing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with only a faint humanoid shadow remaining before it also vanishes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011296833865344524 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51129674911499 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011296833865344524, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011296833865344524, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12573611736297607, + 0.04753458872437477, + 0.03778398409485817, + 0.0569220669567585, + 0.08253668993711472, + 0.5206294655799866, + 0.03063463233411312, + 0.037766750901937485, + 0.02744317427277565, + 0.033012524247169495 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011296833865344524 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a woman with long, raven-black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple white silk dress that shimmers under backlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back slowly and steadily while panning to reveal a background of a shimmering galaxy made of geometric points and data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's physical form gradually become translucent and disintegrate into tiny points of light before vanishing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with only a faint humanoid shadow remaining before it also vanishes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17995129525661469 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049513101577759 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17995129525661469, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17995129525661469, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06234363839030266, + 0.0825301930308342, + 0.08631099760532379, + 0.1613370180130005, + 0.1535414606332779, + 0.2616441249847412, + 0.10140211135149002, + 0.029227370396256447, + 0.025650976225733757, + 0.03601206839084625 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17995129525661469 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a woman with long, raven-black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple white silk dress that shimmers under backlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back slowly and steadily while panning to reveal a background of a shimmering galaxy made of geometric points and data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's physical form gradually become translucent and disintegrate into tiny points of light before vanishing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with only a faint humanoid shadow remaining before it also vanishes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004649423528462648 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379649639129639 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004649423528462648, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004649423528462648, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06459913402795792, + 0.019281426444649696, + 0.029086166992783546, + 0.2226320207118988, + 0.1009066253900528, + 0.1281953603029251, + 0.11745437979698181, + 0.0684976577758789, + 0.15679246187210083, + 0.0925547257065773 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004649423528462648 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a woman with long, raven-black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple white silk dress that shimmers under backlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back slowly and steadily while panning to reveal a background of a shimmering galaxy made of geometric points and data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's physical form gradually become translucent and disintegrate into tiny points of light before vanishing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with only a faint humanoid shadow remaining before it also vanishes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059540290385484695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130954265594482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059540290385484695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059540290385484695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.024772649630904198, + 0.020505718886852264, + 0.042644791305065155, + 0.05604659020900726, + 0.03763870149850845, + 0.554692804813385, + 0.04065188392996788, + 0.03650006279349327, + 0.0707346573472023, + 0.11581218242645264 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059540290385484695 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a woman with long, raven-black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple white silk dress that shimmers under backlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back slowly and steadily while panning to reveal a background of a shimmering galaxy made of geometric points and data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's physical form gradually become translucent and disintegrate into tiny points of light before vanishing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with only a faint humanoid shadow remaining before it also vanishes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10031959414482117 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503196239471436 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10031959414482117, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10031959414482117, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05494579300284386, + 0.035516366362571716, + 0.019158635288476944, + 0.08398757874965668, + 0.04068886861205101, + 0.5049954652786255, + 0.039950840175151825, + 0.025518838316202164, + 0.07218481600284576, + 0.12305284291505814 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10031959414482117 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene begins with a close-up shot from a level angle, focusing on a woman with a gentle, slightly melancholic expression. Her long, raven-black hair flows like a waterfall, a few strands gently brushing against her softly contoured face. A subtle sadness lingers in her clear eyes. She wears a simple white silk dress, the material shimmering softly under the light from behind. Then, the camera begins to pull back in an extremely slow and steady rhythm. As the camera pans, the background behind her gradually becomes clear, revealing a shimmering galaxy, a delicate digital artwork. This galaxy is not a physical cosmic scene, but rather a woven fabric of countless shimmering geometric points of light, flowing energy lines, and translucent data streams, swirling and blending within it. Deep blue, mysterious purple, and fiery gold swirl and merge. As her figure shrinks against the vast cosmic backdrop, her outline becomes translucent, and the edges of her white dress gradually disintegrate into countless tiny points of light, drifting away like stardust. Ultimately, her physical form completely dissipated, gently merging into the swirling nebula of code and light, leaving behind only a faint humanoid shadow, which then vanished. Under the cool light of the digital galaxy, the entire scene created a tranquil, dreamy, and poetic atmosphere with a hint of fate.", + "seed": 11425, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_4/index_1420_seed_11425_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06250737840309739, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06250737840309739, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06250737840309739, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a woman with long, raven-black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple white silk dress that shimmers under backlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back slowly and steadily while panning to reveal a background of a shimmering galaxy made of geometric points and data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's physical form gradually become translucent and disintegrate into tiny points of light before vanishing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with only a faint humanoid shadow remaining before it also vanishes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01136130653321743 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511361122131348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01136130653321743, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01136130653321743, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07169770449399948, + 0.03042779676616192, + 0.09318926930427551, + 0.0934036448597908, + 0.18144764006137848, + 0.029589340090751648, + 0.052337512373924255, + 0.04249245673418045, + 0.3701595664024353, + 0.03525503724813461 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01136130653321743 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a woman with long, raven-black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple white silk dress that shimmers under backlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back slowly and steadily while panning to reveal a background of a shimmering galaxy made of geometric points and data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's physical form gradually become translucent and disintegrate into tiny points of light before vanishing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with only a faint humanoid shadow remaining before it also vanishes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20175069570541382 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7017507553100586 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20175069570541382, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20175069570541382, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.014747637324035168, + 0.028527559712529182, + 0.09442848712205887, + 0.04277924448251724, + 0.559881329536438, + 0.01784457080066204, + 0.023562807589769363, + 0.013943806290626526, + 0.197402223944664, + 0.0068823592737317085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20175069570541382 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a woman with long, raven-black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple white silk dress that shimmers under backlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back slowly and steadily while panning to reveal a background of a shimmering galaxy made of geometric points and data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's physical form gradually become translucent and disintegrate into tiny points of light before vanishing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with only a faint humanoid shadow remaining before it also vanishes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003629883285611868 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628629684448242 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003629883285611868, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003629883285611868, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06367702782154083, + 0.04455805942416191, + 0.06560291349887848, + 0.11074991524219513, + 0.05001584812998772, + 0.07348044216632843, + 0.06353357434272766, + 0.08794800937175751, + 0.41838327050209045, + 0.022050926461815834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003629883285611868 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a woman with long, raven-black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple white silk dress that shimmers under backlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back slowly and steadily while panning to reveal a background of a shimmering galaxy made of geometric points and data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's physical form gradually become translucent and disintegrate into tiny points of light before vanishing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with only a faint humanoid shadow remaining before it also vanishes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00674376729875803 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006743907928467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00674376729875803, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00674376729875803, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.015223613008856773, + 0.008361978456377983, + 0.13100744783878326, + 0.05941123515367508, + 0.34423893690109253, + 0.011153473518788815, + 0.03593555837869644, + 0.042516253888607025, + 0.3419174551963806, + 0.010234070010483265 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00674376729875803 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a woman with long, raven-black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple white silk dress that shimmers under backlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back slowly and steadily while panning to reveal a background of a shimmering galaxy made of geometric points and data streams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's physical form gradually become translucent and disintegrate into tiny points of light before vanishing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene end with only a faint humanoid shadow remaining before it also vanishes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08905123919248581 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640512466430664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08905123919248581, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08905123919248581, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02657405100762844, + 0.010475306771695614, + 0.20118245482444763, + 0.04799966886639595, + 0.2583999037742615, + 0.020326638594269753, + 0.04477694258093834, + 0.034101881086826324, + 0.31119921803474426, + 0.044963981956243515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08905123919248581 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_5/index_tensor([7232, 7232])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_5/index_tensor([7232, 7232])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..947c77cb6d06c7927fc67eb1b6d8812a5f35e807 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_5/index_tensor([7232, 7232])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow-motion macro lens, positioned at a slightly high angle and held still, focuses on a metal coin spinning on a smooth, dark, polished wooden table. Initially, the silver coin spins at a hypnotic pace on its reeded edge, its shape casting long, soft shadows from the side against a single, warm light source. As friction steadily and deliberately dissipates its angular momentum, the rotation degenerates into a graceful, ever-expanding oscillation, its upper edge tracing a captivating spiral pattern in the air as its reflection dances across the polished tabletop. Highlights from the lamp flicker erratically on its polished, reflective surface. Then, as the coin loses its last vestiges of energy, the oscillation accelerates into a frantic, chaotic chatter against the dark wood before it finally clinks, lying completely flat and peacefully ending, its embossed surface now still, face up, catching the last glimmer of soft light. An atmosphere of focused, contemplative thought.", + "seed": 8914, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_5/index_7232_seed_8914_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.09568297658115625, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09568297658115625, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09568297658115625, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed with a macro lens at a slightly high angle showing a metal coin on a dark polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a silver coin spinning on its reeded edge under a single warm light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the coin's motion transition from spinning to an expanding oscillation that traces a spiral pattern in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do highlights flicker erratically on the coin's reflective surface while the camera remains held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the coin lying flat, face up, and still after a chaotic chatter motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12613393366336823 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.251133918762207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12613393366336823, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12613393366336823, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18231528997421265, + 0.4176013171672821, + 0.1336020976305008, + 0.035627465695142746, + 0.12219321727752686, + 0.037163663655519485, + 0.032609060406684875, + 0.010393780656158924, + 0.011751568876206875, + 0.016742592677474022 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12613393366336823 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed with a macro lens at a slightly high angle showing a metal coin on a dark polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a silver coin spinning on its reeded edge under a single warm light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the coin's motion transition from spinning to an expanding oscillation that traces a spiral pattern in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do highlights flicker erratically on the coin's reflective surface while the camera remains held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the coin lying flat, face up, and still after a chaotic chatter motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012571376748383045 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387571334838867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012571376748383045, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012571376748383045, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.239026740193367, + 0.21915102005004883, + 0.0826260894536972, + 0.1335422545671463, + 0.09841994196176529, + 0.10246704518795013, + 0.027780523523688316, + 0.021447325125336647, + 0.0433708056807518, + 0.032168276607990265 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012571376748383045 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed with a macro lens at a slightly high angle showing a metal coin on a dark polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a silver coin spinning on its reeded edge under a single warm light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the coin's motion transition from spinning to an expanding oscillation that traces a spiral pattern in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do highlights flicker erratically on the coin's reflective surface while the camera remains held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the coin lying flat, face up, and still after a chaotic chatter motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16037683188915253 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910376787185669 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16037683188915253, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16037683188915253, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14941105246543884, + 0.14857396483421326, + 0.20136670768260956, + 0.1395260989665985, + 0.15265411138534546, + 0.1015227660536766, + 0.023556025698781013, + 0.033097121864557266, + 0.021520273759961128, + 0.028771832585334778 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16037683188915253 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed with a macro lens at a slightly high angle showing a metal coin on a dark polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a silver coin spinning on its reeded edge under a single warm light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the coin's motion transition from spinning to an expanding oscillation that traces a spiral pattern in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do highlights flicker erratically on the coin's reflective surface while the camera remains held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the coin lying flat, face up, and still after a chaotic chatter motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07902414351701736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579024076461792 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07902414351701736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07902414351701736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1364176720380783, + 0.14380837976932526, + 0.38095125555992126, + 0.06097424030303955, + 0.08721038699150085, + 0.063535675406456, + 0.054738882929086685, + 0.02877844125032425, + 0.018075084313750267, + 0.025509996339678764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07902414351701736 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed with a macro lens at a slightly high angle showing a metal coin on a dark polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a silver coin spinning on its reeded edge under a single warm light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the coin's motion transition from spinning to an expanding oscillation that traces a spiral pattern in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do highlights flicker erratically on the coin's reflective surface while the camera remains held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the coin lying flat, face up, and still after a chaotic chatter motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10030859708786011 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350308656692505 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10030859708786011, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10030859708786011, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09465274959802628, + 0.12132382392883301, + 0.2808155417442322, + 0.06795594841241837, + 0.1837267428636551, + 0.11723780632019043, + 0.030112072825431824, + 0.03442971035838127, + 0.01967506669461727, + 0.05007049813866615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10030859708786011 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion macro lens, positioned at a slightly high angle and held still, focuses on a metal coin spinning on a smooth, dark, polished wooden table. Initially, the silver coin spins at a hypnotic pace on its reeded edge, its shape casting long, soft shadows from the side against a single, warm light source. As friction steadily and deliberately dissipates its angular momentum, the rotation degenerates into a graceful, ever-expanding oscillation, its upper edge tracing a captivating spiral pattern in the air as its reflection dances across the polished tabletop. Highlights from the lamp flicker erratically on its polished, reflective surface. Then, as the coin loses its last vestiges of energy, the oscillation accelerates into a frantic, chaotic chatter against the dark wood before it finally clinks, lying completely flat and peacefully ending, its embossed surface now still, face up, catching the last glimmer of soft light. An atmosphere of focused, contemplative thought.", + "seed": 8915, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_5/index_7232_seed_8915_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.058368195220828055, + "vlm_logprob": -0.058368195220828055, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.074999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.058368195220828055, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed with a macro lens at a slightly high angle showing a metal coin on a dark polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a silver coin spinning on its reeded edge under a single warm light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the coin's motion transition from spinning to an expanding oscillation that traces a spiral pattern in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do highlights flicker erratically on the coin's reflective surface while the camera remains held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the coin lying flat, face up, and still after a chaotic chatter motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02855575643479824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.153555870056152 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02855575643479824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02855575643479824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15063230693340302, + 0.06870496273040771, + 0.03831418231129646, + 0.05889198184013367, + 0.2688036262989044, + 0.24094614386558533, + 0.0641084834933281, + 0.0322214812040329, + 0.02994667924940586, + 0.04743006452918053 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02855575643479824 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed with a macro lens at a slightly high angle showing a metal coin on a dark polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a silver coin spinning on its reeded edge under a single warm light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the coin's motion transition from spinning to an expanding oscillation that traces a spiral pattern in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do highlights flicker erratically on the coin's reflective surface while the camera remains held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the coin lying flat, face up, and still after a chaotic chatter motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309308901429176 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168093204498291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309308901429176, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309308901429176, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1656453162431717, + 0.06776044517755508, + 0.07285436987876892, + 0.04921239987015724, + 0.3277743458747864, + 0.21421943604946136, + 0.039202503859996796, + 0.022668184712529182, + 0.014258123002946377, + 0.026404930278658867 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309308901429176 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed with a macro lens at a slightly high angle showing a metal coin on a dark polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a silver coin spinning on its reeded edge under a single warm light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the coin's motion transition from spinning to an expanding oscillation that traces a spiral pattern in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do highlights flicker erratically on the coin's reflective surface while the camera remains held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the coin lying flat, face up, and still after a chaotic chatter motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12709151208400726 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127091407775879 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12709151208400726, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12709151208400726, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13189640641212463, + 0.14967548847198486, + 0.07173376530408859, + 0.06357914209365845, + 0.20851680636405945, + 0.20133058726787567, + 0.07552339881658554, + 0.027255743741989136, + 0.03546992689371109, + 0.03501875326037407 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12709151208400726 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed with a macro lens at a slightly high angle showing a metal coin on a dark polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a silver coin spinning on its reeded edge under a single warm light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the coin's motion transition from spinning to an expanding oscillation that traces a spiral pattern in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do highlights flicker erratically on the coin's reflective surface while the camera remains held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the coin lying flat, face up, and still after a chaotic chatter motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038140904158353806 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881410121917725 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038140904158353806, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038140904158353806, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08059997856616974, + 0.06614166498184204, + 0.10774272680282593, + 0.051991187036037445, + 0.26680096983909607, + 0.23976780474185944, + 0.05055210366845131, + 0.0523349903523922, + 0.023633893579244614, + 0.06043468043208122 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038140904158353806 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed with a macro lens at a slightly high angle showing a metal coin on a dark polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a silver coin spinning on its reeded edge under a single warm light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the coin's motion transition from spinning to an expanding oscillation that traces a spiral pattern in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do highlights flicker erratically on the coin's reflective surface while the camera remains held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the coin lying flat, face up, and still after a chaotic chatter motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495971441268921 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929959774017334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495971441268921, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495971441268921, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08616223186254501, + 0.0653216689825058, + 0.06292875856161118, + 0.09592217206954956, + 0.207076758146286, + 0.304762601852417, + 0.1054387167096138, + 0.02924899011850357, + 0.024306464940309525, + 0.018831629306077957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495971441268921 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion macro lens, positioned at a slightly high angle and held still, focuses on a metal coin spinning on a smooth, dark, polished wooden table. Initially, the silver coin spins at a hypnotic pace on its reeded edge, its shape casting long, soft shadows from the side against a single, warm light source. As friction steadily and deliberately dissipates its angular momentum, the rotation degenerates into a graceful, ever-expanding oscillation, its upper edge tracing a captivating spiral pattern in the air as its reflection dances across the polished tabletop. Highlights from the lamp flicker erratically on its polished, reflective surface. Then, as the coin loses its last vestiges of energy, the oscillation accelerates into a frantic, chaotic chatter against the dark wood before it finally clinks, lying completely flat and peacefully ending, its embossed surface now still, face up, catching the last glimmer of soft light. An atmosphere of focused, contemplative thought.", + "seed": 8916, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_5/index_7232_seed_8916_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11131355799734592, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11131355799734592, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11131355799734592, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed with a macro lens at a slightly high angle showing a metal coin on a dark polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a silver coin spinning on its reeded edge under a single warm light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the coin's motion transition from spinning to an expanding oscillation that traces a spiral pattern in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do highlights flicker erratically on the coin's reflective surface while the camera remains held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the coin lying flat, face up, and still after a chaotic chatter motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0192792359739542 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3942790031433105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0192792359739542, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0192792359739542, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05647515505552292, + 0.029727477580308914, + 0.03097783960402012, + 0.2933858633041382, + 0.17674347758293152, + 0.1831130087375641, + 0.05566553771495819, + 0.09318774193525314, + 0.04500831291079521, + 0.03571555018424988 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0192792359739542 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed with a macro lens at a slightly high angle showing a metal coin on a dark polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a silver coin spinning on its reeded edge under a single warm light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the coin's motion transition from spinning to an expanding oscillation that traces a spiral pattern in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do highlights flicker erratically on the coin's reflective surface while the camera remains held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the coin lying flat, face up, and still after a chaotic chatter motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048698607832193375 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048698663711548 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048698607832193375, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048698607832193375, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05175008997321129, + 0.032832320779561996, + 0.021317142993211746, + 0.07475145161151886, + 0.15654830634593964, + 0.3763440251350403, + 0.10104687511920929, + 0.06621009856462479, + 0.09452883899211884, + 0.02467079646885395 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048698607832193375 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed with a macro lens at a slightly high angle showing a metal coin on a dark polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a silver coin spinning on its reeded edge under a single warm light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the coin's motion transition from spinning to an expanding oscillation that traces a spiral pattern in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do highlights flicker erratically on the coin's reflective surface while the camera remains held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the coin lying flat, face up, and still after a chaotic chatter motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3135286271572113 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3135286569595337 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3135286271572113, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3135286271572113, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06880415230989456, + 0.04491732642054558, + 0.007627351675182581, + 0.2564692795276642, + 0.06776127219200134, + 0.32975372672080994, + 0.08224120736122131, + 0.03156813606619835, + 0.08660952746868134, + 0.024248072877526283 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3135286271572113 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed with a macro lens at a slightly high angle showing a metal coin on a dark polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a silver coin spinning on its reeded edge under a single warm light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the coin's motion transition from spinning to an expanding oscillation that traces a spiral pattern in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do highlights flicker erratically on the coin's reflective surface while the camera remains held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the coin lying flat, face up, and still after a chaotic chatter motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06209937110543251 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120994567871094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06209937110543251, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06209937110543251, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06044713780283928, + 0.05649598315358162, + 0.019555648788809776, + 0.34143441915512085, + 0.07981819659471512, + 0.25201448798179626, + 0.06074044853448868, + 0.018338214606046677, + 0.09713036566972733, + 0.014025075361132622 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06209937110543251 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed with a macro lens at a slightly high angle showing a metal coin on a dark polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a silver coin spinning on its reeded edge under a single warm light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the coin's motion transition from spinning to an expanding oscillation that traces a spiral pattern in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do highlights flicker erratically on the coin's reflective surface while the camera remains held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the coin lying flat, face up, and still after a chaotic chatter motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11296194791793823 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237962007522583 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11296194791793823, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11296194791793823, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08771885186433792, + 0.042005375027656555, + 0.030275462195277214, + 0.06579384952783585, + 0.05960715189576149, + 0.5408373475074768, + 0.08121558278799057, + 0.01639123633503914, + 0.05828702077269554, + 0.017868131399154663 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11296194791793823 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion macro lens, positioned at a slightly high angle and held still, focuses on a metal coin spinning on a smooth, dark, polished wooden table. Initially, the silver coin spins at a hypnotic pace on its reeded edge, its shape casting long, soft shadows from the side against a single, warm light source. As friction steadily and deliberately dissipates its angular momentum, the rotation degenerates into a graceful, ever-expanding oscillation, its upper edge tracing a captivating spiral pattern in the air as its reflection dances across the polished tabletop. Highlights from the lamp flicker erratically on its polished, reflective surface. Then, as the coin loses its last vestiges of energy, the oscillation accelerates into a frantic, chaotic chatter against the dark wood before it finally clinks, lying completely flat and peacefully ending, its embossed surface now still, face up, catching the last glimmer of soft light. An atmosphere of focused, contemplative thought.", + "seed": 8917, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_5/index_7232_seed_8917_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.09500993378460407, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09500993378460407, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09500993378460407, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed with a macro lens at a slightly high angle showing a metal coin on a dark polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a silver coin spinning on its reeded edge under a single warm light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the coin's motion transition from spinning to an expanding oscillation that traces a spiral pattern in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do highlights flicker erratically on the coin's reflective surface while the camera remains held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the coin lying flat, face up, and still after a chaotic chatter motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019706184044480324 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5197062492370605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019706184044480324, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019706184044480324, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14988699555397034, + 0.07842755317687988, + 0.28734877705574036, + 0.15121595561504364, + 0.10894276201725006, + 0.02585523948073387, + 0.05498329550027847, + 0.03643502667546272, + 0.01948033645749092, + 0.08742409199476242 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019706184044480324 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed with a macro lens at a slightly high angle showing a metal coin on a dark polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a silver coin spinning on its reeded edge under a single warm light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the coin's motion transition from spinning to an expanding oscillation that traces a spiral pattern in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do highlights flicker erratically on the coin's reflective surface while the camera remains held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the coin lying flat, face up, and still after a chaotic chatter motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620870478451252 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812087059020996 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620870478451252, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620870478451252, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13980600237846375, + 0.09792772680521011, + 0.25303956866264343, + 0.2656247615814209, + 0.07016313076019287, + 0.09092962741851807, + 0.02003217115998268, + 0.010897058062255383, + 0.008291530422866344, + 0.0432884655892849 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620870478451252 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed with a macro lens at a slightly high angle showing a metal coin on a dark polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a silver coin spinning on its reeded edge under a single warm light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the coin's motion transition from spinning to an expanding oscillation that traces a spiral pattern in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do highlights flicker erratically on the coin's reflective surface while the camera remains held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the coin lying flat, face up, and still after a chaotic chatter motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521687150001526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021686553955078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521687150001526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521687150001526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.126835435628891, + 0.05829104036092758, + 0.23716402053833008, + 0.289286732673645, + 0.123867467045784, + 0.04479055851697922, + 0.028437983244657516, + 0.009596106596291065, + 0.025604059919714928, + 0.056126564741134644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521687150001526 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed with a macro lens at a slightly high angle showing a metal coin on a dark polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a silver coin spinning on its reeded edge under a single warm light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the coin's motion transition from spinning to an expanding oscillation that traces a spiral pattern in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do highlights flicker erratically on the coin's reflective surface while the camera remains held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the coin lying flat, face up, and still after a chaotic chatter motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07903372496366501 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579033613204956 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07903372496366501, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07903372496366501, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22523385286331177, + 0.11484605818986893, + 0.13145749270915985, + 0.15459541976451874, + 0.10351979732513428, + 0.07886072993278503, + 0.09134671837091446, + 0.022200174629688263, + 0.028039341792464256, + 0.04990042746067047 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07903372496366501 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed with a macro lens at a slightly high angle showing a metal coin on a dark polished wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a silver coin spinning on its reeded edge under a single warm light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the coin's motion transition from spinning to an expanding oscillation that traces a spiral pattern in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do highlights flicker erratically on the coin's reflective surface while the camera remains held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the coin lying flat, face up, and still after a chaotic chatter motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062053997069597244 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812053918838501 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062053997069597244, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062053997069597244, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13235260546207428, + 0.05248864367604256, + 0.3595520853996277, + 0.2530539929866791, + 0.056223202496767044, + 0.038572996854782104, + 0.02418307028710842, + 0.03190227225422859, + 0.013860642910003662, + 0.03781043365597725 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062053997069597244 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_6/index_tensor([5420, 5420])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_6/index_tensor([5420, 5420])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5506adad50b3013c85ada041c0a0622a5bcbaef6 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_6/index_tensor([5420, 5420])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, static shot, set at water level, brings the viewer uncomfortably close to its subject. Sharp focus is locked on the menacing eye of a massive crocodile: a cold, unblinking golden orb with a razor-thin, vertical black pupil that seems to absorb all light. The surrounding skin is a rugged, ancient landscape of thick, leathery scales, scarred and weathered, with beads clinging to deep crevices. Just beneath the murky, algae-filled surface, a massive, powerful body coils, its dark, mossy green and brown bone hide forming a formidable ridge that hints at the creature's immense size. The water is a still, opaque broth of sediment and decaying leaves, disturbed only by the faintest ripples emanating from the creature's underwater form. Spotted, damp sunlight filters through the unseen jungle canopy, casting shifting, high-contrast patterns of light and shadow across the crocodile's damp fur and the water's surface. The creature remains in absolute, deliberate stillness, a terrifying potential energy about to overtake it, creating an atmosphere of raw tension and breathless suspense.", + "seed": 27393, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_6/index_5420_seed_27393_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.5008339412510395, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5008339412510395, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5008339412510395, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the eye of a massive crocodile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crocodile's eye depicted as a golden orb with a razor-thin vertical black pupil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding skin shown as rugged, leathery scales with beads in deep crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water below the surface murky, algae-filled, and opaque with sediment and decaying leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with no movement throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.406662106513977 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28166213631629944 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.406662106513977, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -1.406662106513977, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09151201695203781, + 0.01813073642551899, + 0.03564142435789108, + 0.025936605408787727, + 0.01625494845211506, + 0.3565162420272827, + 0.07256404310464859, + 0.30517470836639404, + 0.024857284501194954, + 0.053412001579999924 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.406662106513977 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the eye of a massive crocodile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crocodile's eye depicted as a golden orb with a razor-thin vertical black pupil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding skin shown as rugged, leathery scales with beads in deep crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water below the surface murky, algae-filled, and opaque with sediment and decaying leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with no movement throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08919037878513336 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4641904830932617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08919037878513336, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08919037878513336, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12038858979940414, + 0.029364217072725296, + 0.03746871277689934, + 0.02729588933289051, + 0.04789888486266136, + 0.06599608063697815, + 0.08836648613214493, + 0.44487059116363525, + 0.061367738991975784, + 0.07698280364274979 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08919037878513336 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the eye of a massive crocodile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crocodile's eye depicted as a golden orb with a razor-thin vertical black pupil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding skin shown as rugged, leathery scales with beads in deep crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water below the surface murky, algae-filled, and opaque with sediment and decaying leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with no movement throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054974380880594254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929974317550659 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054974380880594254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054974380880594254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0859040692448616, + 0.014614148065447807, + 0.051327913999557495, + 0.026568423956632614, + 0.040818993002176285, + 0.5428646802902222, + 0.06799852848052979, + 0.08601851016283035, + 0.03391100466251373, + 0.04997372254729271 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054974380880594254 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the eye of a massive crocodile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crocodile's eye depicted as a golden orb with a razor-thin vertical black pupil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding skin shown as rugged, leathery scales with beads in deep crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water below the surface murky, algae-filled, and opaque with sediment and decaying leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with no movement throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12709467113018036 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270947456359863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12709467113018036, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12709467113018036, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07876424491405487, + 0.008093662559986115, + 0.016090339049696922, + 0.029563020914793015, + 0.03969961777329445, + 0.3592120409011841, + 0.04032771289348602, + 0.1605895608663559, + 0.08230272680521011, + 0.18535704910755157 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12709467113018036 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the eye of a massive crocodile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crocodile's eye depicted as a golden orb with a razor-thin vertical black pupil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding skin shown as rugged, leathery scales with beads in deep crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water below the surface murky, algae-filled, and opaque with sediment and decaying leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with no movement throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8262481689453125 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5762481689453125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8262481689453125, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8262481689453125, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05851113051176071, + 0.03244299814105034, + 0.13808687031269073, + 0.04538584128022194, + 0.02814360149204731, + 0.3514530062675476, + 0.04239482805132866, + 0.0750730112195015, + 0.1771167367696762, + 0.051391880959272385 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8262481689453125 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, static shot, set at water level, brings the viewer uncomfortably close to its subject. Sharp focus is locked on the menacing eye of a massive crocodile: a cold, unblinking golden orb with a razor-thin, vertical black pupil that seems to absorb all light. The surrounding skin is a rugged, ancient landscape of thick, leathery scales, scarred and weathered, with beads clinging to deep crevices. Just beneath the murky, algae-filled surface, a massive, powerful body coils, its dark, mossy green and brown bone hide forming a formidable ridge that hints at the creature's immense size. The water is a still, opaque broth of sediment and decaying leaves, disturbed only by the faintest ripples emanating from the creature's underwater form. Spotted, damp sunlight filters through the unseen jungle canopy, casting shifting, high-contrast patterns of light and shadow across the crocodile's damp fur and the water's surface. The creature remains in absolute, deliberate stillness, a terrifying potential energy about to overtake it, creating an atmosphere of raw tension and breathless suspense.", + "seed": 27394, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_6/index_5420_seed_27394_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.13707073424011468, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13707073424011468, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13707073424011468, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the eye of a massive crocodile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crocodile's eye depicted as a golden orb with a razor-thin vertical black pupil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding skin shown as rugged, leathery scales with beads in deep crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water below the surface murky, algae-filled, and opaque with sediment and decaying leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with no movement throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12830102443695068 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1283011436462402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12830102443695068, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12830102443695068, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1724729835987091, + 0.37196463346481323, + 0.08936266601085663, + 0.04520620033144951, + 0.06598436832427979, + 0.04792382940649986, + 0.05754757300019264, + 0.10426115244626999, + 0.02080390229821205, + 0.024472655728459358 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12830102443695068 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the eye of a massive crocodile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crocodile's eye depicted as a golden orb with a razor-thin vertical black pupil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding skin shown as rugged, leathery scales with beads in deep crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water below the surface murky, algae-filled, and opaque with sediment and decaying leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with no movement throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04312722757458687 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1681272983551025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04312722757458687, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04312722757458687, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2368757277727127, + 0.2413901686668396, + 0.14778293669223785, + 0.03472239151597023, + 0.06596101075410843, + 0.048292070627212524, + 0.07682497054338455, + 0.1103016659617424, + 0.01919427141547203, + 0.018654773011803627 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04312722757458687 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the eye of a massive crocodile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crocodile's eye depicted as a golden orb with a razor-thin vertical black pupil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding skin shown as rugged, leathery scales with beads in deep crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water below the surface murky, algae-filled, and opaque with sediment and decaying leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with no movement throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978719163686037 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634787082672119 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978719163686037, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978719163686037, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27159053087234497, + 0.25969383120536804, + 0.14083026349544525, + 0.04781074449419975, + 0.05448025465011597, + 0.0433785505592823, + 0.05731843784451485, + 0.07553893327713013, + 0.020314082503318787, + 0.02904442884027958 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978719163686037 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the eye of a massive crocodile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crocodile's eye depicted as a golden orb with a razor-thin vertical black pupil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding skin shown as rugged, leathery scales with beads in deep crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water below the surface murky, algae-filled, and opaque with sediment and decaying leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with no movement throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02981891855597496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298190116882324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02981891855597496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02981891855597496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4040969908237457, + 0.1083080843091011, + 0.057584963738918304, + 0.0571405403316021, + 0.05279320105910301, + 0.05685049295425415, + 0.03567282110452652, + 0.10098852217197418, + 0.042227208614349365, + 0.08433715999126434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02981891855597496 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the eye of a massive crocodile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crocodile's eye depicted as a golden orb with a razor-thin vertical black pupil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding skin shown as rugged, leathery scales with beads in deep crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water below the surface murky, algae-filled, and opaque with sediment and decaying leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with no movement throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47431930899620056 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.974319338798523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47431930899620056, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47431930899620056, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0980420857667923, + 0.05969216302037239, + 0.022949781268835068, + 0.11724696308374405, + 0.03605232015252113, + 0.033248111605644226, + 0.07788911461830139, + 0.23821482062339783, + 0.04454867169260979, + 0.27211594581604004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47431930899620056 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, static shot, set at water level, brings the viewer uncomfortably close to its subject. Sharp focus is locked on the menacing eye of a massive crocodile: a cold, unblinking golden orb with a razor-thin, vertical black pupil that seems to absorb all light. The surrounding skin is a rugged, ancient landscape of thick, leathery scales, scarred and weathered, with beads clinging to deep crevices. Just beneath the murky, algae-filled surface, a massive, powerful body coils, its dark, mossy green and brown bone hide forming a formidable ridge that hints at the creature's immense size. The water is a still, opaque broth of sediment and decaying leaves, disturbed only by the faintest ripples emanating from the creature's underwater form. Spotted, damp sunlight filters through the unseen jungle canopy, casting shifting, high-contrast patterns of light and shadow across the crocodile's damp fur and the water's surface. The creature remains in absolute, deliberate stillness, a terrifying potential energy about to overtake it, creating an atmosphere of raw tension and breathless suspense.", + "seed": 27395, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_6/index_5420_seed_27395_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.23360263109207152, + "vlm_logprob": -0.23360263109207152, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.23360263109207152, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the eye of a massive crocodile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crocodile's eye depicted as a golden orb with a razor-thin vertical black pupil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding skin shown as rugged, leathery scales with beads in deep crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water below the surface murky, algae-filled, and opaque with sediment and decaying leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with no movement throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7591767311096191 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6341767311096191 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7591767311096191, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7591767311096191, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4749697744846344, + 0.18217402696609497, + 0.040674444288015366, + 0.14092954993247986, + 0.04582776501774788, + 0.009315851144492626, + 0.020731015130877495, + 0.013794922269880772, + 0.03194654732942581, + 0.03963615372776985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7591767311096191 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the eye of a massive crocodile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crocodile's eye depicted as a golden orb with a razor-thin vertical black pupil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding skin shown as rugged, leathery scales with beads in deep crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water below the surface murky, algae-filled, and opaque with sediment and decaying leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with no movement throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.070109061896801 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6951091289520264 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.070109061896801, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.070109061896801, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3109542429447174, + 0.28912603855133057, + 0.033469051122665405, + 0.13640418648719788, + 0.05118964985013008, + 0.06514182686805725, + 0.02882998250424862, + 0.0260012149810791, + 0.025417830795049667, + 0.033465951681137085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.070109061896801 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the eye of a massive crocodile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crocodile's eye depicted as a golden orb with a razor-thin vertical black pupil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding skin shown as rugged, leathery scales with beads in deep crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water below the surface murky, algae-filled, and opaque with sediment and decaying leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with no movement throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307607561349869 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680760383605957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307607561349869, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307607561349869, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33971157670021057, + 0.2169075459241867, + 0.055941589176654816, + 0.18830116093158722, + 0.05637175217270851, + 0.04948492348194122, + 0.01867879368364811, + 0.02481129579246044, + 0.018862774595618248, + 0.030928608030080795 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307607561349869 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the eye of a massive crocodile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crocodile's eye depicted as a golden orb with a razor-thin vertical black pupil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding skin shown as rugged, leathery scales with beads in deep crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water below the surface murky, algae-filled, and opaque with sediment and decaying leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with no movement throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07005360722541809 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950535774230957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07005360722541809, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07005360722541809, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21532607078552246, + 0.16957908868789673, + 0.1318007856607437, + 0.20919692516326904, + 0.15292389690876007, + 0.0627046674489975, + 0.007935354486107826, + 0.018519634380936623, + 0.016681943088769913, + 0.015331569127738476 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07005360722541809 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the eye of a massive crocodile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crocodile's eye depicted as a golden orb with a razor-thin vertical black pupil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding skin shown as rugged, leathery scales with beads in deep crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water below the surface murky, algae-filled, and opaque with sediment and decaying leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with no movement throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22559767961502075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600597620010376 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22559767961502075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22559767961502075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19070692360401154, + 0.462470144033432, + 0.023952161893248558, + 0.18541477620601654, + 0.02890823967754841, + 0.025714335963129997, + 0.02179480716586113, + 0.027394473552703857, + 0.019612349569797516, + 0.014031791128218174 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22559767961502075 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, static shot, set at water level, brings the viewer uncomfortably close to its subject. Sharp focus is locked on the menacing eye of a massive crocodile: a cold, unblinking golden orb with a razor-thin, vertical black pupil that seems to absorb all light. The surrounding skin is a rugged, ancient landscape of thick, leathery scales, scarred and weathered, with beads clinging to deep crevices. Just beneath the murky, algae-filled surface, a massive, powerful body coils, its dark, mossy green and brown bone hide forming a formidable ridge that hints at the creature's immense size. The water is a still, opaque broth of sediment and decaying leaves, disturbed only by the faintest ripples emanating from the creature's underwater form. Spotted, damp sunlight filters through the unseen jungle canopy, casting shifting, high-contrast patterns of light and shadow across the crocodile's damp fur and the water's surface. The creature remains in absolute, deliberate stillness, a terrifying potential energy about to overtake it, creating an atmosphere of raw tension and breathless suspense.", + "seed": 27396, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_6/index_5420_seed_27396_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.5408753231167793, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5408753231167793, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5408753231167793, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the eye of a massive crocodile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crocodile's eye depicted as a golden orb with a razor-thin vertical black pupil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding skin shown as rugged, leathery scales with beads in deep crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water below the surface murky, algae-filled, and opaque with sediment and decaying leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with no movement throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3140472173690796 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.314047247171402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.3140472173690796, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.3140472173690796, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09639673680067062, + 0.08510024845600128, + 0.05628802999854088, + 0.042405351996421814, + 0.06771649420261383, + 0.1025366485118866, + 0.07727513462305069, + 0.03328212723135948, + 0.08561388403177261, + 0.3533853590488434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.3140472173690796 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the eye of a massive crocodile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crocodile's eye depicted as a golden orb with a razor-thin vertical black pupil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding skin shown as rugged, leathery scales with beads in deep crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water below the surface murky, algae-filled, and opaque with sediment and decaying leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with no movement throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07014940679073334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6951494216918945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07014940679073334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07014940679073334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16889993846416473, + 0.060211606323719025, + 0.06074044108390808, + 0.04339447245001793, + 0.08894415199756622, + 0.03697557374835014, + 0.045940011739730835, + 0.07748177647590637, + 0.13234035670757294, + 0.28507164120674133 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07014940679073334 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the eye of a massive crocodile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crocodile's eye depicted as a golden orb with a razor-thin vertical black pupil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding skin shown as rugged, leathery scales with beads in deep crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water below the surface murky, algae-filled, and opaque with sediment and decaying leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with no movement throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07005137950181961 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695051431655884 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07005137950181961, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07005137950181961, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11739590018987656, + 0.13632237911224365, + 0.07164455950260162, + 0.022812752053141594, + 0.09430688619613647, + 0.0385599285364151, + 0.09393467009067535, + 0.018942762166261673, + 0.04606360197067261, + 0.36001652479171753 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07005137950181961 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the eye of a massive crocodile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crocodile's eye depicted as a golden orb with a razor-thin vertical black pupil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding skin shown as rugged, leathery scales with beads in deep crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water below the surface murky, algae-filled, and opaque with sediment and decaying leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with no movement throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11299644410610199 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379963397979736 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11299644410610199, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11299644410610199, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22723054885864258, + 0.11257380247116089, + 0.035421352833509445, + 0.023941854014992714, + 0.11212825030088425, + 0.05905766040086746, + 0.07021444290876389, + 0.10713430494070053, + 0.07330478727817535, + 0.17899300158023834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11299644410610199 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focused on the eye of a massive crocodile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crocodile's eye depicted as a golden orb with a razor-thin vertical black pupil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the surrounding skin shown as rugged, leathery scales with beads in deep crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the water below the surface murky, algae-filled, and opaque with sediment and decaying leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static with no movement throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137132167816162 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3871321678161621 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.137132167816162, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.137132167816162, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12439469248056412, + 0.1443420946598053, + 0.08471924066543579, + 0.1256246268749237, + 0.05002875626087189, + 0.0683404952287674, + 0.06893966346979141, + 0.026443423703312874, + 0.15207546949386597, + 0.15509147942066193 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.137132167816162 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_7/index_tensor([9763, 9763])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_7/index_tensor([9763, 9763])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..142c3422e6c28000de1e1b6e928027b3d28a93e8 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_7/index_tensor([9763, 9763])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "wide, low-angle, stationary shot captures the Yellow River's majestic grandeur with striking perspective. In the foreground, the thick, muddy, ochre-yellow water surges forward with unstoppable force, its surface swirling with vast eddies and stirring up layers of turbid waves. The steep, loess-lined banks on either side form two powerful diagonal lines, their weathered textures strikingly clear in the diffuse light of the overcast sky. Sparse, withered grass dotted across them, adding a sense of desolation. These two leading lines steadily and firmly draw the viewer's eye deep into the frame, to the distant horizon where the river blurs into the gray-white skyline. The entire scene is enveloped in a desaturated ochre hue. Absent bright spots of light, the light is even and heavy, creating an epic atmosphere imbued with a solemnity, awe, and a sense of primal power.", + "seed": 21216, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_7/index_9763_seed_21216_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.021658139349892736, + "vlm_logprob": -0.021658139349892736, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.021658139349892736, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, low-angle view of the Yellow River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water thick, muddy, ochre-yellow, and surging forward with visible eddies and turbid waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are steep, loess-lined banks visible on both sides forming two powerful diagonal lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a desaturated ochre hue with sparse, withered grass on the banks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary with even, heavy diffuse light under an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03977450355887413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2897744178771973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03977450355887413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03977450355887413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1497783660888672, + 0.04983232170343399, + 0.5491669774055481, + 0.027209585532546043, + 0.008793726563453674, + 0.007025780156254768, + 0.01952255703508854, + 0.02416207268834114, + 0.021551284939050674, + 0.14295732975006104 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03977450355887413 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, low-angle view of the Yellow River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water thick, muddy, ochre-yellow, and surging forward with visible eddies and turbid waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are steep, loess-lined banks visible on both sides forming two powerful diagonal lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a desaturated ochre hue with sparse, withered grass on the banks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary with even, heavy diffuse light under an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048683051019907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486831665039062 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048683051019907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048683051019907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20535561442375183, + 0.06553630530834198, + 0.32987913489341736, + 0.05153041332960129, + 0.018401561304926872, + 0.013515587896108627, + 0.01841593347489834, + 0.03615853935480118, + 0.022250236943364143, + 0.23895668983459473 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048683051019907 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, low-angle view of the Yellow River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water thick, muddy, ochre-yellow, and surging forward with visible eddies and turbid waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are steep, loess-lined banks visible on both sides forming two powerful diagonal lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a desaturated ochre hue with sparse, withered grass on the banks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary with even, heavy diffuse light under an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005251185968518257 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255251407623291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005251185968518257, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005251185968518257, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11895696818828583, + 0.3187257945537567, + 0.37675467133522034, + 0.030708180740475655, + 0.012098020873963833, + 0.010340051725506783, + 0.019366975873708725, + 0.02786390110850334, + 0.01447985414415598, + 0.07070557773113251 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005251185968518257 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, low-angle view of the Yellow River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water thick, muddy, ochre-yellow, and surging forward with visible eddies and turbid waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are steep, loess-lined banks visible on both sides forming two powerful diagonal lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a desaturated ochre hue with sparse, withered grass on the banks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary with even, heavy diffuse light under an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.000387831823900342 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.875387668609619 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.000387831823900342, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.000387831823900342, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07007861137390137, + 0.2611287832260132, + 0.4298388659954071, + 0.013448063284158707, + 0.0066680219024419785, + 0.007284549064934254, + 0.016496501863002777, + 0.016811061650514603, + 0.023255733773112297, + 0.1549898386001587 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.000387831823900342 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, low-angle view of the Yellow River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water thick, muddy, ochre-yellow, and surging forward with visible eddies and turbid waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are steep, loess-lined banks visible on both sides forming two powerful diagonal lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a desaturated ochre hue with sparse, withered grass on the banks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary with even, heavy diffuse light under an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01419412437826395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264194011688232 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01419412437826395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01419412437826395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06800305843353271, + 0.07094210386276245, + 0.3918991684913635, + 0.018882641568779945, + 0.032071102410554886, + 0.016543660312891006, + 0.03217853605747223, + 0.022654201835393906, + 0.013787399977445602, + 0.3330380916595459 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01419412437826395 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, low-angle, stationary shot captures the Yellow River's majestic grandeur with striking perspective. In the foreground, the thick, muddy, ochre-yellow water surges forward with unstoppable force, its surface swirling with vast eddies and stirring up layers of turbid waves. The steep, loess-lined banks on either side form two powerful diagonal lines, their weathered textures strikingly clear in the diffuse light of the overcast sky. Sparse, withered grass dotted across them, adding a sense of desolation. These two leading lines steadily and firmly draw the viewer's eye deep into the frame, to the distant horizon where the river blurs into the gray-white skyline. The entire scene is enveloped in a desaturated ochre hue. Absent bright spots of light, the light is even and heavy, creating an epic atmosphere imbued with a solemnity, awe, and a sense of primal power.", + "seed": 21217, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_7/index_9763_seed_21217_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.016563478927128016, + "vlm_logprob": -0.016563478927128016, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.016563478927128016, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, low-angle view of the Yellow River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water thick, muddy, ochre-yellow, and surging forward with visible eddies and turbid waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are steep, loess-lined banks visible on both sides forming two powerful diagonal lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a desaturated ochre hue with sparse, withered grass on the banks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary with even, heavy diffuse light under an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018256602808833122 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.143256664276123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018256602808833122, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018256602808833122, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6108477115631104, + 0.23368526995182037, + 0.024107975885272026, + 0.032045796513557434, + 0.011039710603654385, + 0.007027763407677412, + 0.015136086381971836, + 0.011793820187449455, + 0.016921356320381165, + 0.03739449754357338 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018256602808833122 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, low-angle view of the Yellow River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water thick, muddy, ochre-yellow, and surging forward with visible eddies and turbid waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are steep, loess-lined banks visible on both sides forming two powerful diagonal lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a desaturated ochre hue with sparse, withered grass on the banks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary with even, heavy diffuse light under an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004657017532736063 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379656791687012 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004657017532736063, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004657017532736063, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.457363486289978, + 0.235963836312294, + 0.08192995190620422, + 0.031003599986433983, + 0.06042023375630379, + 0.022843997925519943, + 0.027225203812122345, + 0.025133244693279266, + 0.021348463371396065, + 0.03676795959472656 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004657017532736063 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, low-angle view of the Yellow River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water thick, muddy, ochre-yellow, and surging forward with visible eddies and turbid waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are steep, loess-lined banks visible on both sides forming two powerful diagonal lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a desaturated ochre hue with sparse, withered grass on the banks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary with even, heavy diffuse light under an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036162238102406263 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.6286163330078125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036162238102406263, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036162238102406263, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.519044816493988, + 0.26368701457977295, + 0.05033017694950104, + 0.01099902018904686, + 0.026735806837677956, + 0.013323471881449223, + 0.007788758259266615, + 0.008192433975636959, + 0.008269911631941795, + 0.09162865579128265 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036162238102406263 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, low-angle view of the Yellow River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water thick, muddy, ochre-yellow, and surging forward with visible eddies and turbid waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are steep, loess-lined banks visible on both sides forming two powerful diagonal lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a desaturated ochre hue with sparse, withered grass on the banks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary with even, heavy diffuse light under an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013388964580371976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626338958740234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013388964580371976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013388964580371976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42896926403045654, + 0.07769237458705902, + 0.10552386194467545, + 0.027788057923316956, + 0.039802003651857376, + 0.0116281071677804, + 0.019268708303570747, + 0.0763772577047348, + 0.015847213566303253, + 0.19710320234298706 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013388964580371976 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, low-angle view of the Yellow River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water thick, muddy, ochre-yellow, and surging forward with visible eddies and turbid waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are steep, loess-lined banks visible on both sides forming two powerful diagonal lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a desaturated ochre hue with sparse, withered grass on the banks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary with even, heavy diffuse light under an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054948654025793076 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929948568344116 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054948654025793076, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054948654025793076, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23099248111248016, + 0.410793274641037, + 0.056127216666936874, + 0.02347124181687832, + 0.018994955345988274, + 0.022462021559476852, + 0.016906268894672394, + 0.027410445734858513, + 0.010950439609587193, + 0.18189170956611633 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054948654025793076 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, low-angle, stationary shot captures the Yellow River's majestic grandeur with striking perspective. In the foreground, the thick, muddy, ochre-yellow water surges forward with unstoppable force, its surface swirling with vast eddies and stirring up layers of turbid waves. The steep, loess-lined banks on either side form two powerful diagonal lines, their weathered textures strikingly clear in the diffuse light of the overcast sky. Sparse, withered grass dotted across them, adding a sense of desolation. These two leading lines steadily and firmly draw the viewer's eye deep into the frame, to the distant horizon where the river blurs into the gray-white skyline. The entire scene is enveloped in a desaturated ochre hue. Absent bright spots of light, the light is even and heavy, creating an epic atmosphere imbued with a solemnity, awe, and a sense of primal power.", + "seed": 21218, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_7/index_9763_seed_21218_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.006140381784643978, + "vlm_logprob": -0.006140381784643978, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.6999999523162845, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.006140381784643978, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, low-angle view of the Yellow River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water thick, muddy, ochre-yellow, and surging forward with visible eddies and turbid waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are steep, loess-lined banks visible on both sides forming two powerful diagonal lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a desaturated ochre hue with sparse, withered grass on the banks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary with even, heavy diffuse light under an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0054294029250741005 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.505429267883301 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0054294029250741005, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0054294029250741005, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3822992742061615, + 0.0803486704826355, + 0.04102354869246483, + 0.07348766922950745, + 0.07614010572433472, + 0.05619135871529579, + 0.06579828262329102, + 0.0528099462389946, + 0.05405497923493385, + 0.11784624308347702 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0054294029250741005 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, low-angle view of the Yellow River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water thick, muddy, ochre-yellow, and surging forward with visible eddies and turbid waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are steep, loess-lined banks visible on both sides forming two powerful diagonal lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a desaturated ochre hue with sparse, withered grass on the banks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary with even, heavy diffuse light under an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004655593540519476 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379655361175537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004655593540519476, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004655593540519476, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37117934226989746, + 0.11333484202623367, + 0.04638243094086647, + 0.05320963263511658, + 0.02534765563905239, + 0.04050677269697189, + 0.023624693974852562, + 0.1897018402814865, + 0.06219746917486191, + 0.07451523840427399 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004655593540519476 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, low-angle view of the Yellow River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water thick, muddy, ochre-yellow, and surging forward with visible eddies and turbid waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are steep, loess-lined banks visible on both sides forming two powerful diagonal lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a desaturated ochre hue with sparse, withered grass on the banks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary with even, heavy diffuse light under an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017131189815700054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376713275909424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017131189815700054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017131189815700054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3351467549800873, + 0.07449290156364441, + 0.103907011449337, + 0.057991594076156616, + 0.09564122557640076, + 0.06734409183263779, + 0.039106544107198715, + 0.07427768409252167, + 0.08070643246173859, + 0.07138574123382568 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017131189815700054 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, low-angle view of the Yellow River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water thick, muddy, ochre-yellow, and surging forward with visible eddies and turbid waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are steep, loess-lined banks visible on both sides forming two powerful diagonal lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a desaturated ochre hue with sparse, withered grass on the banks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary with even, heavy diffuse light under an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0007198841194622219 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.250720024108887 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0007198841194622219, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0007198841194622219, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3060426115989685, + 0.13972045481204987, + 0.07009846717119217, + 0.13262230157852173, + 0.08296337723731995, + 0.04709326848387718, + 0.045821413397789, + 0.06877806782722473, + 0.039611220359802246, + 0.0672488585114479 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0007198841194622219 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, low-angle view of the Yellow River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water thick, muddy, ochre-yellow, and surging forward with visible eddies and turbid waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are steep, loess-lined banks visible on both sides forming two powerful diagonal lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a desaturated ochre hue with sparse, withered grass on the banks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary with even, heavy diffuse light under an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018183909356594086 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018183708190918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018183909356594086, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018183909356594086, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20766247808933258, + 0.16049739718437195, + 0.07910546660423279, + 0.04905369132757187, + 0.09483616799116135, + 0.07783082127571106, + 0.08890163153409958, + 0.04230427369475365, + 0.15988412499427795, + 0.03992394357919693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018183909356594086 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, low-angle, stationary shot captures the Yellow River's majestic grandeur with striking perspective. In the foreground, the thick, muddy, ochre-yellow water surges forward with unstoppable force, its surface swirling with vast eddies and stirring up layers of turbid waves. The steep, loess-lined banks on either side form two powerful diagonal lines, their weathered textures strikingly clear in the diffuse light of the overcast sky. Sparse, withered grass dotted across them, adding a sense of desolation. These two leading lines steadily and firmly draw the viewer's eye deep into the frame, to the distant horizon where the river blurs into the gray-white skyline. The entire scene is enveloped in a desaturated ochre hue. Absent bright spots of light, the light is even and heavy, creating an epic atmosphere imbued with a solemnity, awe, and a sense of primal power.", + "seed": 21219, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_7/index_9763_seed_21219_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.005995849031023681, + "vlm_logprob": -0.005995849031023681, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.005995849031023681, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, low-angle view of the Yellow River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water thick, muddy, ochre-yellow, and surging forward with visible eddies and turbid waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are steep, loess-lined banks visible on both sides forming two powerful diagonal lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a desaturated ochre hue with sparse, withered grass on the banks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary with even, heavy diffuse light under an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010115430690348148 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.885115623474121 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010115430690348148, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010115430690348148, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2633208632469177, + 0.03626934811472893, + 0.018231378868222237, + 0.4649059474468231, + 0.02041216380894184, + 0.02083723247051239, + 0.06426408141851425, + 0.03170318156480789, + 0.057235438376665115, + 0.022820299491286278 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010115430690348148 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, low-angle view of the Yellow River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water thick, muddy, ochre-yellow, and surging forward with visible eddies and turbid waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are steep, loess-lined banks visible on both sides forming two powerful diagonal lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a desaturated ochre hue with sparse, withered grass on the banks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary with even, heavy diffuse light under an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032137196976691484 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753213882446289 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032137196976691484, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032137196976691484, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2657967209815979, + 0.061372287571430206, + 0.0689830332994461, + 0.09185626357793808, + 0.030835047364234924, + 0.043252892792224884, + 0.08377546072006226, + 0.04571887478232384, + 0.23421478271484375, + 0.07419461756944656 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032137196976691484 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, low-angle view of the Yellow River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water thick, muddy, ochre-yellow, and surging forward with visible eddies and turbid waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are steep, loess-lined banks visible on both sides forming two powerful diagonal lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a desaturated ochre hue with sparse, withered grass on the banks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary with even, heavy diffuse light under an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003615867579355836 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628615856170654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003615867579355836, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003615867579355836, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2052842676639557, + 0.05599532648921013, + 0.07931327074766159, + 0.08614569902420044, + 0.025597961619496346, + 0.18130946159362793, + 0.10747013241052628, + 0.11894158273935318, + 0.05826247110962868, + 0.08167976140975952 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003615867579355836 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, low-angle view of the Yellow River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water thick, muddy, ochre-yellow, and surging forward with visible eddies and turbid waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are steep, loess-lined banks visible on both sides forming two powerful diagonal lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a desaturated ochre hue with sparse, withered grass on the banks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary with even, heavy diffuse light under an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0004979324294254184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.625497817993164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0004979324294254184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0004979324294254184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09832052141427994, + 0.02223721332848072, + 0.028997061774134636, + 0.1950397938489914, + 0.025101525709033012, + 0.05091996490955353, + 0.4334027171134949, + 0.07175495475530624, + 0.04402489215135574, + 0.03020131029188633 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0004979324294254184 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide, low-angle view of the Yellow River?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water thick, muddy, ochre-yellow, and surging forward with visible eddies and turbid waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are steep, loess-lined banks visible on both sides forming two powerful diagonal lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a desaturated ochre hue with sparse, withered grass on the banks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera stationary with even, heavy diffuse light under an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012536294758319855 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387536525726318 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012536294758319855, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012536294758319855, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0772726982831955, + 0.03602003678679466, + 0.04281719774007797, + 0.2795616686344147, + 0.015741746872663498, + 0.04029290750622749, + 0.3271220326423645, + 0.0373656302690506, + 0.09835239499807358, + 0.045453667640686035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012536294758319855 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_8/index_tensor([7272, 7272])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_8/index_tensor([7272, 7272])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..362e1cd89600dd58c3ceb1ad03dd70056c735ee1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_8/index_tensor([7272, 7272])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a surreal macro photography aesthetic, the camera executes a slow, continuous 360-degree orbit at subject-level, capturing extreme close-ups with breathtaking detail. The focal point is a prickly pigeon pea seed, partially buried in fertile, dark, moist soil. The seed's surface resembles a black fossil artifact, its microscopic fidelity etched in its woody, dark-brown shell covered in intricate jagged ridges and sharp corners, creating deep shadows under a single spotlight. As the camera rotates smoothly, a powerful, silent event unfolds: the solid shell begins to crack, the spiderweb forming microscopic fissures on its surface before breaking apart with deliberate, unstoppable force. From within this gap, a tender, vibrant green sprout reaches upward, its stem gleaming with light and covered in nearly invisible, crystalline trichomes. The camera’s track captures the climactic moment as the sprout’s first two leaves, or cotyledons, gracefully unfold, revealing their delicate texture and fresh, almost translucent quality, shimmering against the dark, out-of-focus background, creating an atmosphere of focused, reverent new life emerging.", + "seed": 13529, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_8/index_7272_seed_13529_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.051469826302491126, + "vlm_logprob": -0.051469826302491126, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.051469826302491126, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a prickly pigeon pea seed partially buried in dark, moist soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the seed's shell appear black and fossil-like with jagged ridges and sharp corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the solid shell crack and break apart to reveal a vibrant green sprout inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout's stem gleam with light and show nearly invisible crystalline trichomes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, continuous 360-degree orbit at subject-level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011149720288813114 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.761149883270264 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011149720288813114, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011149720288813114, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4681289792060852, + 0.09126723557710648, + 0.0986567959189415, + 0.020883794873952866, + 0.02868173085153103, + 0.03010067716240883, + 0.04613727703690529, + 0.11312159150838852, + 0.036034755408763885, + 0.06698718667030334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011149720288813114 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a prickly pigeon pea seed partially buried in dark, moist soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the seed's shell appear black and fossil-like with jagged ridges and sharp corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the solid shell crack and break apart to reveal a vibrant green sprout inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout's stem gleam with light and show nearly invisible crystalline trichomes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, continuous 360-degree orbit at subject-level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009807850234210491 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63480806350708 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009807850234210491, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009807850234210491, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10309667885303497, + 0.2680724561214447, + 0.07935784012079239, + 0.03870281204581261, + 0.046884965151548386, + 0.029887940734624863, + 0.08688540756702423, + 0.2491232305765152, + 0.04174166917800903, + 0.05624702200293541 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009807850234210491 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a prickly pigeon pea seed partially buried in dark, moist soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the seed's shell appear black and fossil-like with jagged ridges and sharp corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the solid shell crack and break apart to reveal a vibrant green sprout inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout's stem gleam with light and show nearly invisible crystalline trichomes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, continuous 360-degree orbit at subject-level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015206689713522792 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.50152063369751 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015206689713522792, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015206689713522792, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3082653284072876, + 0.07990395277738571, + 0.054806873202323914, + 0.044969215989112854, + 0.022558635100722313, + 0.03185600787401199, + 0.0877629891037941, + 0.23482321202754974, + 0.08880466967821121, + 0.04624917730689049 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015206689713522792 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a prickly pigeon pea seed partially buried in dark, moist soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the seed's shell appear black and fossil-like with jagged ridges and sharp corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the solid shell crack and break apart to reveal a vibrant green sprout inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout's stem gleam with light and show nearly invisible crystalline trichomes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, continuous 360-degree orbit at subject-level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055016692727804184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300167560577393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055016692727804184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055016692727804184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5302953720092773, + 0.029198212549090385, + 0.04709138348698616, + 0.03667495772242546, + 0.019089268520474434, + 0.016178347170352936, + 0.10166198015213013, + 0.11361121386289597, + 0.07607898861169815, + 0.030120206996798515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055016692727804184 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a prickly pigeon pea seed partially buried in dark, moist soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the seed's shell appear black and fossil-like with jagged ridges and sharp corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the solid shell crack and break apart to reveal a vibrant green sprout inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout's stem gleam with light and show nearly invisible crystalline trichomes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, continuous 360-degree orbit at subject-level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17985419929027557 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804854154586792 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17985419929027557, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17985419929027557, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34873348474502563, + 0.06587301194667816, + 0.09699872136116028, + 0.13815927505493164, + 0.02432946488261223, + 0.02209354005753994, + 0.12264292687177658, + 0.04509340599179268, + 0.10196693986654282, + 0.0341092124581337 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17985419929027557 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a surreal macro photography aesthetic, the camera executes a slow, continuous 360-degree orbit at subject-level, capturing extreme close-ups with breathtaking detail. The focal point is a prickly pigeon pea seed, partially buried in fertile, dark, moist soil. The seed's surface resembles a black fossil artifact, its microscopic fidelity etched in its woody, dark-brown shell covered in intricate jagged ridges and sharp corners, creating deep shadows under a single spotlight. As the camera rotates smoothly, a powerful, silent event unfolds: the solid shell begins to crack, the spiderweb forming microscopic fissures on its surface before breaking apart with deliberate, unstoppable force. From within this gap, a tender, vibrant green sprout reaches upward, its stem gleaming with light and covered in nearly invisible, crystalline trichomes. The camera’s track captures the climactic moment as the sprout’s first two leaves, or cotyledons, gracefully unfold, revealing their delicate texture and fresh, almost translucent quality, shimmering against the dark, out-of-focus background, creating an atmosphere of focused, reverent new life emerging.", + "seed": 13530, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_8/index_7272_seed_13530_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06988704856485128, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06988704856485128, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06988704856485128, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a prickly pigeon pea seed partially buried in dark, moist soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the seed's shell appear black and fossil-like with jagged ridges and sharp corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the solid shell crack and break apart to reveal a vibrant green sprout inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout's stem gleam with light and show nearly invisible crystalline trichomes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, continuous 360-degree orbit at subject-level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01427286583930254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.389272689819336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01427286583930254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01427286583930254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06876787543296814, + 0.045628439635038376, + 0.08027894049882889, + 0.07366463541984558, + 0.04062391072511673, + 0.04246192425489426, + 0.11598781496286392, + 0.10526757687330246, + 0.3797836899757385, + 0.047535259276628494 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01427286583930254 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a prickly pigeon pea seed partially buried in dark, moist soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the seed's shell appear black and fossil-like with jagged ridges and sharp corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the solid shell crack and break apart to reveal a vibrant green sprout inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout's stem gleam with light and show nearly invisible crystalline trichomes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, continuous 360-degree orbit at subject-level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012562076561152935 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387562274932861 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012562076561152935, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012562076561152935, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0877552479505539, + 0.14926379919052124, + 0.1534515917301178, + 0.17574144899845123, + 0.04832220822572708, + 0.024376163259148598, + 0.14147597551345825, + 0.0731411725282669, + 0.07071604579687119, + 0.07575637102127075 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012562076561152935 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a prickly pigeon pea seed partially buried in dark, moist soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the seed's shell appear black and fossil-like with jagged ridges and sharp corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the solid shell crack and break apart to reveal a vibrant green sprout inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout's stem gleam with light and show nearly invisible crystalline trichomes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, continuous 360-degree orbit at subject-level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032027876004576683 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.75320291519165 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032027876004576683, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032027876004576683, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11309688538312912, + 0.03382148966193199, + 0.10380100458860397, + 0.1750098317861557, + 0.07747960090637207, + 0.04892381653189659, + 0.04474702104926109, + 0.08043095469474792, + 0.21470916271209717, + 0.1079801619052887 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032027876004576683 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a prickly pigeon pea seed partially buried in dark, moist soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the seed's shell appear black and fossil-like with jagged ridges and sharp corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the solid shell crack and break apart to reveal a vibrant green sprout inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout's stem gleam with light and show nearly invisible crystalline trichomes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, continuous 360-degree orbit at subject-level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812197223305702 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881219387054443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812197223305702, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812197223305702, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1264834702014923, + 0.05903949961066246, + 0.08104810118675232, + 0.23204970359802246, + 0.050592489540576935, + 0.026259152218699455, + 0.15668906271457672, + 0.022115373983979225, + 0.19217775762081146, + 0.05354542285203934 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812197223305702 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a prickly pigeon pea seed partially buried in dark, moist soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the seed's shell appear black and fossil-like with jagged ridges and sharp corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the solid shell crack and break apart to reveal a vibrant green sprout inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout's stem gleam with light and show nearly invisible crystalline trichomes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, continuous 360-degree orbit at subject-level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28127554059028625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4062755107879639 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28127554059028625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28127554059028625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06353852152824402, + 0.056245364248752594, + 0.0950741171836853, + 0.19552291929721832, + 0.1297951191663742, + 0.05413850024342537, + 0.22797417640686035, + 0.03414535149931908, + 0.03720723092556, + 0.10635869204998016 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28127554059028625 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a surreal macro photography aesthetic, the camera executes a slow, continuous 360-degree orbit at subject-level, capturing extreme close-ups with breathtaking detail. The focal point is a prickly pigeon pea seed, partially buried in fertile, dark, moist soil. The seed's surface resembles a black fossil artifact, its microscopic fidelity etched in its woody, dark-brown shell covered in intricate jagged ridges and sharp corners, creating deep shadows under a single spotlight. As the camera rotates smoothly, a powerful, silent event unfolds: the solid shell begins to crack, the spiderweb forming microscopic fissures on its surface before breaking apart with deliberate, unstoppable force. From within this gap, a tender, vibrant green sprout reaches upward, its stem gleaming with light and covered in nearly invisible, crystalline trichomes. The camera’s track captures the climactic moment as the sprout’s first two leaves, or cotyledons, gracefully unfold, revealing their delicate texture and fresh, almost translucent quality, shimmering against the dark, out-of-focus background, creating an atmosphere of focused, reverent new life emerging.", + "seed": 13531, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_8/index_7272_seed_13531_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11513166367076337, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11513166367076337, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.2250000119209288, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11513166367076337, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a prickly pigeon pea seed partially buried in dark, moist soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the seed's shell appear black and fossil-like with jagged ridges and sharp corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the solid shell crack and break apart to reveal a vibrant green sprout inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout's stem gleam with light and show nearly invisible crystalline trichomes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, continuous 360-degree orbit at subject-level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015933571383357048 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.265933513641357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015933571383357048, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015933571383357048, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1550927609205246, + 0.06368634104728699, + 0.0650939866900444, + 0.04857353866100311, + 0.10649414360523224, + 0.0696602314710617, + 0.03097856417298317, + 0.048503048717975616, + 0.3477420210838318, + 0.06417534500360489 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015933571383357048 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a prickly pigeon pea seed partially buried in dark, moist soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the seed's shell appear black and fossil-like with jagged ridges and sharp corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the solid shell crack and break apart to reveal a vibrant green sprout inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout's stem gleam with light and show nearly invisible crystalline trichomes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, continuous 360-degree orbit at subject-level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03813459351658821 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881345748901367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03813459351658821, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03813459351658821, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07895106822252274, + 0.11982503533363342, + 0.07116807252168655, + 0.03874482214450836, + 0.14424681663513184, + 0.026417557150125504, + 0.043571021407842636, + 0.036518644541502, + 0.17034117877483368, + 0.2702156901359558 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03813459351658821 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a prickly pigeon pea seed partially buried in dark, moist soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the seed's shell appear black and fossil-like with jagged ridges and sharp corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the solid shell crack and break apart to reveal a vibrant green sprout inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout's stem gleam with light and show nearly invisible crystalline trichomes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, continuous 360-degree orbit at subject-level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003628576872870326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628628730773926 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003628576872870326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003628576872870326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10622848570346832, + 0.06985079497098923, + 0.08001503348350525, + 0.07709822803735733, + 0.05000785365700722, + 0.031009474769234657, + 0.09297756105661392, + 0.10124756395816803, + 0.11676366627216339, + 0.2748013138771057 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003628576872870326 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a prickly pigeon pea seed partially buried in dark, moist soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the seed's shell appear black and fossil-like with jagged ridges and sharp corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the solid shell crack and break apart to reveal a vibrant green sprout inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout's stem gleam with light and show nearly invisible crystalline trichomes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, continuous 360-degree orbit at subject-level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08909453451633453 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464094638824463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08909453451633453, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08909453451633453, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04596158117055893, + 0.06352394074201584, + 0.20718571543693542, + 0.07750588655471802, + 0.051846943795681, + 0.08129020035266876, + 0.032013095915317535, + 0.03519834205508232, + 0.16477183997631073, + 0.24070249497890472 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08909453451633453 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a prickly pigeon pea seed partially buried in dark, moist soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the seed's shell appear black and fossil-like with jagged ridges and sharp corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the solid shell crack and break apart to reveal a vibrant green sprout inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout's stem gleam with light and show nearly invisible crystalline trichomes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, continuous 360-degree orbit at subject-level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42886704206466675 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0538671016693115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42886704206466675, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.6250000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42886704206466675, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03125457465648651, + 0.035496845841407776, + 0.06942681968212128, + 0.06517161428928375, + 0.017674526199698448, + 0.0309921707957983, + 0.05979398265480995, + 0.05817331746220589, + 0.4739513397216797, + 0.1580648422241211 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42886704206466675 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a surreal macro photography aesthetic, the camera executes a slow, continuous 360-degree orbit at subject-level, capturing extreme close-ups with breathtaking detail. The focal point is a prickly pigeon pea seed, partially buried in fertile, dark, moist soil. The seed's surface resembles a black fossil artifact, its microscopic fidelity etched in its woody, dark-brown shell covered in intricate jagged ridges and sharp corners, creating deep shadows under a single spotlight. As the camera rotates smoothly, a powerful, silent event unfolds: the solid shell begins to crack, the spiderweb forming microscopic fissures on its surface before breaking apart with deliberate, unstoppable force. From within this gap, a tender, vibrant green sprout reaches upward, its stem gleaming with light and covered in nearly invisible, crystalline trichomes. The camera’s track captures the climactic moment as the sprout’s first two leaves, or cotyledons, gracefully unfold, revealing their delicate texture and fresh, almost translucent quality, shimmering against the dark, out-of-focus background, creating an atmosphere of focused, reverent new life emerging.", + "seed": 13532, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_8/index_7272_seed_13532_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0957196888513863, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0957196888513863, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0957196888513863, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a prickly pigeon pea seed partially buried in dark, moist soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the seed's shell appear black and fossil-like with jagged ridges and sharp corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the solid shell crack and break apart to reveal a vibrant green sprout inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout's stem gleam with light and show nearly invisible crystalline trichomes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, continuous 360-degree orbit at subject-level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009982778690755367 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.759982585906982 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009982778690755367, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009982778690755367, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19457978010177612, + 0.05985765904188156, + 0.022087018936872482, + 0.02613593451678753, + 0.026483919471502304, + 0.4896494746208191, + 0.02843402326107025, + 0.01713062822818756, + 0.08898763358592987, + 0.046653926372528076 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009982778690755367 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a prickly pigeon pea seed partially buried in dark, moist soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the seed's shell appear black and fossil-like with jagged ridges and sharp corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the solid shell crack and break apart to reveal a vibrant green sprout inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout's stem gleam with light and show nearly invisible crystalline trichomes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, continuous 360-degree orbit at subject-level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009798052720725536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634798049926758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009798052720725536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009798052720725536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3537381589412689, + 0.0673285648226738, + 0.014302910305559635, + 0.022846363484859467, + 0.031036298722028732, + 0.3853129744529724, + 0.02303914539515972, + 0.04339320585131645, + 0.03259790688753128, + 0.026404405012726784 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009798052720725536 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a prickly pigeon pea seed partially buried in dark, moist soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the seed's shell appear black and fossil-like with jagged ridges and sharp corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the solid shell crack and break apart to reveal a vibrant green sprout inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout's stem gleam with light and show nearly invisible crystalline trichomes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, continuous 360-degree orbit at subject-level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017190692014992237 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376718997955322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017190692014992237, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017190692014992237, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1019139364361763, + 0.07490628212690353, + 0.02306978963315487, + 0.0223255455493927, + 0.06237337365746498, + 0.5238239765167236, + 0.025257311761379242, + 0.04243134707212448, + 0.08650337159633636, + 0.03739504516124725 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017190692014992237 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a prickly pigeon pea seed partially buried in dark, moist soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the seed's shell appear black and fossil-like with jagged ridges and sharp corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the solid shell crack and break apart to reveal a vibrant green sprout inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout's stem gleam with light and show nearly invisible crystalline trichomes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, continuous 360-degree orbit at subject-level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07006794214248657 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695067882537842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07006794214248657, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07006794214248657, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17078490555286407, + 0.09829249233007431, + 0.042514678090810776, + 0.04738793149590492, + 0.04726969450712204, + 0.07760170847177505, + 0.08977273106575012, + 0.2087375372648239, + 0.13823533058166504, + 0.07940292358398438 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07006794214248657 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a prickly pigeon pea seed partially buried in dark, moist soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the seed's shell appear black and fossil-like with jagged ridges and sharp corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the solid shell crack and break apart to reveal a vibrant green sprout inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout's stem gleam with light and show nearly invisible crystalline trichomes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, continuous 360-degree orbit at subject-level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38703060150146484 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370306015014648 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38703060150146484, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38703060150146484, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16378554701805115, + 0.1275583803653717, + 0.02647140808403492, + 0.0405246838927269, + 0.03514508530497551, + 0.21150027215480804, + 0.1407993882894516, + 0.06394186615943909, + 0.16501028835773468, + 0.02526307851076126 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38703060150146484 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_9/index_tensor([818, 818])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_9/index_tensor([818, 818])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..48fbe3e58348476ab351f617d30cce813cdba0f3 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_9/index_tensor([818, 818])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a documentary-style medium close-up, the camera slowly inched closer on a female scientist in her forties, her dark hair adorned with a few silver braids, pulled back into a practical bun. Thin-framed glasses perched on her nose, she wore a simple gray turtleneck sweater over a crisp white lab coat. As she worked on the antistatic mat on her workbench, she leaned forward in concentration, her brow furrowed slightly. The robot's faceplate was a smooth matte white polymer, but the side panels had been removed, revealing a breathtakingly complex mesh of gleaming microservos, bundled fiber optics, and polished copper wires. With unwavering precision, the scientist carefully positioned a tiny, iridescent microchip on the exposed green circuit board with a pair of pointed tweezers in her right hand, her left hand steady to illuminate the intricate task. The surrounding lab was a blur of organized chaos: trays of components stacked on shelves, softly glowing green readouts on endoscopes, and out-of-focus schematics on a large monitor in the background. The scene is lit by a cool, unfocused overhead fluorescent light cut by the warm, focused cone of light from her task lamp, creating a dramatic interplay of light and shadow that accentuates the texture of the metal components and the focused determination on her face. The atmosphere is one of profound, quiet focus, capturing a pivotal moment of creation at the cutting edge of technology.", + "seed": 23132, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_9/index_818_seed_23132_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.13650712370872498, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13650712370872498, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13650712370872498, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a documentary-style medium close-up of a female scientist in her forties?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scientist have dark hair with silver braids pulled back into a bun, and is she wearing thin-framed glasses, a gray turtleneck, and a white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist leaning forward in concentration while using tweezers in her right hand to position a tiny iridescent microchip on a green circuit board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the robot's exposed internal structure visible, showing a smooth matte white faceplate, removed side panels, gleaming microservos, fiber optics, and polished copper wires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly inch closer on the scientist throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04526394233107567 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1702640056610107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04526394233107567, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04526394233107567, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1404711902141571, + 0.06402169913053513, + 0.03756285458803177, + 0.07429202646017075, + 0.07217617332935333, + 0.05030536279082298, + 0.06999656558036804, + 0.27481013536453247, + 0.01901036500930786, + 0.1973535269498825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04526394233107567 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a documentary-style medium close-up of a female scientist in her forties?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scientist have dark hair with silver braids pulled back into a bun, and is she wearing thin-framed glasses, a gray turtleneck, and a white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist leaning forward in concentration while using tweezers in her right hand to position a tiny iridescent microchip on a green circuit board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the robot's exposed internal structure visible, showing a smooth matte white faceplate, removed side panels, gleaming microservos, fiber optics, and polished copper wires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly inch closer on the scientist throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01421128399670124 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264211177825928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01421128399670124, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01421128399670124, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2457953840494156, + 0.16029790043830872, + 0.06421012431383133, + 0.08454391360282898, + 0.15145088732242584, + 0.03692927584052086, + 0.031978633254766464, + 0.06627751141786575, + 0.04562827944755554, + 0.11288808286190033 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01421128399670124 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a documentary-style medium close-up of a female scientist in her forties?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scientist have dark hair with silver braids pulled back into a bun, and is she wearing thin-framed glasses, a gray turtleneck, and a white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist leaning forward in concentration while using tweezers in her right hand to position a tiny iridescent microchip on a green circuit board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the robot's exposed internal structure visible, showing a smooth matte white faceplate, removed side panels, gleaming microservos, fiber optics, and polished copper wires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly inch closer on the scientist throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020583124831318855 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895583152770996 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020583124831318855, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020583124831318855, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13782252371311188, + 0.1822153478860855, + 0.1172032430768013, + 0.10747041553258896, + 0.10054834187030792, + 0.077585369348526, + 0.03920077160000801, + 0.1610012650489807, + 0.03607496991753578, + 0.04087778925895691 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020583124831318855 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a documentary-style medium close-up of a female scientist in her forties?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scientist have dark hair with silver braids pulled back into a bun, and is she wearing thin-framed glasses, a gray turtleneck, and a white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist leaning forward in concentration while using tweezers in her right hand to position a tiny iridescent microchip on a green circuit board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the robot's exposed internal structure visible, showing a smooth matte white faceplate, removed side panels, gleaming microservos, fiber optics, and polished copper wires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly inch closer on the scientist throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5235025882720947 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8985025882720947 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5235025882720947, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5235025882720947, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09695379436016083, + 0.05942907556891441, + 0.10043807327747345, + 0.1344030648469925, + 0.16766516864299774, + 0.02233217842876911, + 0.058366671204566956, + 0.2883746922016144, + 0.03188886120915413, + 0.040148355066776276 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5235025882720947 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a documentary-style medium close-up of a female scientist in her forties?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scientist have dark hair with silver braids pulled back into a bun, and is she wearing thin-framed glasses, a gray turtleneck, and a white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist leaning forward in concentration while using tweezers in her right hand to position a tiny iridescent microchip on a green circuit board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the robot's exposed internal structure visible, showing a smooth matte white faceplate, removed side panels, gleaming microservos, fiber optics, and polished copper wires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly inch closer on the scientist throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897467911243439 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578974723815918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897467911243439, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897467911243439, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12203941494226456, + 0.1311376988887787, + 0.05328918620944023, + 0.08434587717056274, + 0.1322157382965088, + 0.031128020957112312, + 0.10501443594694138, + 0.13071008026599884, + 0.1011255607008934, + 0.10899399220943451 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897467911243439 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a documentary-style medium close-up, the camera slowly inched closer on a female scientist in her forties, her dark hair adorned with a few silver braids, pulled back into a practical bun. Thin-framed glasses perched on her nose, she wore a simple gray turtleneck sweater over a crisp white lab coat. As she worked on the antistatic mat on her workbench, she leaned forward in concentration, her brow furrowed slightly. The robot's faceplate was a smooth matte white polymer, but the side panels had been removed, revealing a breathtakingly complex mesh of gleaming microservos, bundled fiber optics, and polished copper wires. With unwavering precision, the scientist carefully positioned a tiny, iridescent microchip on the exposed green circuit board with a pair of pointed tweezers in her right hand, her left hand steady to illuminate the intricate task. The surrounding lab was a blur of organized chaos: trays of components stacked on shelves, softly glowing green readouts on endoscopes, and out-of-focus schematics on a large monitor in the background. The scene is lit by a cool, unfocused overhead fluorescent light cut by the warm, focused cone of light from her task lamp, creating a dramatic interplay of light and shadow that accentuates the texture of the metal components and the focused determination on her face. The atmosphere is one of profound, quiet focus, capturing a pivotal moment of creation at the cutting edge of technology.", + "seed": 23133, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_9/index_818_seed_23133_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.12109286785125732, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12109286785125732, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12109286785125732, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a documentary-style medium close-up of a female scientist in her forties?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scientist have dark hair with silver braids pulled back into a bun, and is she wearing thin-framed glasses, a gray turtleneck, and a white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist leaning forward in concentration while using tweezers in her right hand to position a tiny iridescent microchip on a green circuit board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the robot's exposed internal structure visible, showing a smooth matte white faceplate, removed side panels, gleaming microservos, fiber optics, and polished copper wires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly inch closer on the scientist throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10131631791591644 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.351316213607788 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10131631791591644, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10131631791591644, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37670275568962097, + 0.06974352151155472, + 0.07035021483898163, + 0.061453260481357574, + 0.07754185795783997, + 0.037114135921001434, + 0.08930201083421707, + 0.04298290237784386, + 0.10499805957078934, + 0.06981129199266434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10131631791591644 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a documentary-style medium close-up of a female scientist in her forties?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scientist have dark hair with silver braids pulled back into a bun, and is she wearing thin-framed glasses, a gray turtleneck, and a white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist leaning forward in concentration while using tweezers in her right hand to position a tiny iridescent microchip on a green circuit board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the robot's exposed internal structure visible, showing a smooth matte white faceplate, removed side panels, gleaming microservos, fiber optics, and polished copper wires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly inch closer on the scientist throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02331031858921051 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773310422897339 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02331031858921051, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02331031858921051, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31358152627944946, + 0.08376739919185638, + 0.049448829144239426, + 0.04116818681359291, + 0.05944786220788956, + 0.03485262393951416, + 0.13860808312892914, + 0.06192490831017494, + 0.13134340941905975, + 0.08585713803768158 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02331031858921051 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a documentary-style medium close-up of a female scientist in her forties?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scientist have dark hair with silver braids pulled back into a bun, and is she wearing thin-framed glasses, a gray turtleneck, and a white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist leaning forward in concentration while using tweezers in her right hand to position a tiny iridescent microchip on a green circuit board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the robot's exposed internal structure visible, showing a smooth matte white faceplate, removed side panels, gleaming microservos, fiber optics, and polished copper wires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly inch closer on the scientist throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305894672870636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680588722229004 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305894672870636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305894672870636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3736896812915802, + 0.06787464767694473, + 0.051390066742897034, + 0.04700291529297829, + 0.04366437345743179, + 0.0445365346968174, + 0.04133748263120651, + 0.047353070229291916, + 0.13510377705097198, + 0.14804746210575104 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305894672870636 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a documentary-style medium close-up of a female scientist in her forties?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scientist have dark hair with silver braids pulled back into a bun, and is she wearing thin-framed glasses, a gray turtleneck, and a white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist leaning forward in concentration while using tweezers in her right hand to position a tiny iridescent microchip on a green circuit board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the robot's exposed internal structure visible, showing a smooth matte white faceplate, removed side panels, gleaming microservos, fiber optics, and polished copper wires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly inch closer on the scientist throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34874245524406433 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2237424850463867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34874245524406433, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34874245524406433, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5091302394866943, + 0.041763100773096085, + 0.04489138349890709, + 0.04422447085380554, + 0.025656837970018387, + 0.0455574207007885, + 0.04470547288656235, + 0.05929214134812355, + 0.12298701703548431, + 0.06179196015000343 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34874245524406433 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a documentary-style medium close-up of a female scientist in her forties?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scientist have dark hair with silver braids pulled back into a bun, and is she wearing thin-framed glasses, a gray turtleneck, and a white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist leaning forward in concentration while using tweezers in her right hand to position a tiny iridescent microchip on a green circuit board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the robot's exposed internal structure visible, showing a smooth matte white faceplate, removed side panels, gleaming microservos, fiber optics, and polished copper wires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly inch closer on the scientist throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08903630077838898 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464036226272583 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08903630077838898, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08903630077838898, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15852846205234528, + 0.06353136152029037, + 0.041729144752025604, + 0.043777946382761, + 0.04034649208188057, + 0.0554443895816803, + 0.09863663464784622, + 0.08082080632448196, + 0.0996372401714325, + 0.3175475299358368 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08903630077838898 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a documentary-style medium close-up, the camera slowly inched closer on a female scientist in her forties, her dark hair adorned with a few silver braids, pulled back into a practical bun. Thin-framed glasses perched on her nose, she wore a simple gray turtleneck sweater over a crisp white lab coat. As she worked on the antistatic mat on her workbench, she leaned forward in concentration, her brow furrowed slightly. The robot's faceplate was a smooth matte white polymer, but the side panels had been removed, revealing a breathtakingly complex mesh of gleaming microservos, bundled fiber optics, and polished copper wires. With unwavering precision, the scientist carefully positioned a tiny, iridescent microchip on the exposed green circuit board with a pair of pointed tweezers in her right hand, her left hand steady to illuminate the intricate task. The surrounding lab was a blur of organized chaos: trays of components stacked on shelves, softly glowing green readouts on endoscopes, and out-of-focus schematics on a large monitor in the background. The scene is lit by a cool, unfocused overhead fluorescent light cut by the warm, focused cone of light from her task lamp, creating a dramatic interplay of light and shadow that accentuates the texture of the metal components and the focused determination on her face. The atmosphere is one of profound, quiet focus, capturing a pivotal moment of creation at the cutting edge of technology.", + "seed": 23134, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_9/index_818_seed_23134_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1520949088037014, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1520949088037014, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1520949088037014, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a documentary-style medium close-up of a female scientist in her forties?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scientist have dark hair with silver braids pulled back into a bun, and is she wearing thin-framed glasses, a gray turtleneck, and a white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist leaning forward in concentration while using tweezers in her right hand to position a tiny iridescent microchip on a green circuit board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the robot's exposed internal structure visible, showing a smooth matte white faceplate, removed side panels, gleaming microservos, fiber optics, and polished copper wires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly inch closer on the scientist throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0717528834939003 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6967527866363525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0717528834939003, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0717528834939003, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1215270385146141, + 0.023680631071329117, + 0.023445580154657364, + 0.024814466014504433, + 0.017448944970965385, + 0.03115883469581604, + 0.033585790544748306, + 0.06150871515274048, + 0.03153827786445618, + 0.6312917470932007 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0717528834939003 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a documentary-style medium close-up of a female scientist in her forties?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scientist have dark hair with silver braids pulled back into a bun, and is she wearing thin-framed glasses, a gray turtleneck, and a white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist leaning forward in concentration while using tweezers in her right hand to position a tiny iridescent microchip on a green circuit board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the robot's exposed internal structure visible, showing a smooth matte white faceplate, removed side panels, gleaming microservos, fiber optics, and polished copper wires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly inch closer on the scientist throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02060507982969284 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956050872802734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02060507982969284, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02060507982969284, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06933069974184036, + 0.02296077460050583, + 0.016599370166659355, + 0.014236212708055973, + 0.01905108615756035, + 0.01708292029798031, + 0.0610288605093956, + 0.061678167432546616, + 0.054536689072847366, + 0.6634951829910278 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02060507982969284 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a documentary-style medium close-up of a female scientist in her forties?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scientist have dark hair with silver braids pulled back into a bun, and is she wearing thin-framed glasses, a gray turtleneck, and a white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist leaning forward in concentration while using tweezers in her right hand to position a tiny iridescent microchip on a green circuit board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the robot's exposed internal structure visible, showing a smooth matte white faceplate, removed side panels, gleaming microservos, fiber optics, and polished copper wires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly inch closer on the scientist throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048665110021829605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486650466918945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048665110021829605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048665110021829605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1013442873954773, + 0.03718431666493416, + 0.022626018151640892, + 0.02689965069293976, + 0.023638112470507622, + 0.028651459142565727, + 0.22415585815906525, + 0.04946126043796539, + 0.03897784277796745, + 0.4470611810684204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048665110021829605 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a documentary-style medium close-up of a female scientist in her forties?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scientist have dark hair with silver braids pulled back into a bun, and is she wearing thin-framed glasses, a gray turtleneck, and a white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist leaning forward in concentration while using tweezers in her right hand to position a tiny iridescent microchip on a green circuit board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the robot's exposed internal structure visible, showing a smooth matte white faceplate, removed side panels, gleaming microservos, fiber optics, and polished copper wires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly inch closer on the scientist throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5763882994651794 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8263882994651794 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5763882994651794, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5763882994651794, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0654873251914978, + 0.01802300661802292, + 0.018014388158917427, + 0.015887020155787468, + 0.010053847916424274, + 0.010175374336540699, + 0.06902594119310379, + 0.027016354724764824, + 0.06732799112796783, + 0.698988676071167 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5763882994651794 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a documentary-style medium close-up of a female scientist in her forties?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scientist have dark hair with silver braids pulled back into a bun, and is she wearing thin-framed glasses, a gray turtleneck, and a white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist leaning forward in concentration while using tweezers in her right hand to position a tiny iridescent microchip on a green circuit board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the robot's exposed internal structure visible, showing a smooth matte white faceplate, removed side panels, gleaming microservos, fiber optics, and polished copper wires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly inch closer on the scientist throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043063171207904816 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168063163757324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043063171207904816, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043063171207904816, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05615584924817085, + 0.02270827814936638, + 0.037921421229839325, + 0.017163492739200592, + 0.025759417563676834, + 0.03671439364552498, + 0.43084102869033813, + 0.14442381262779236, + 0.14095984399318695, + 0.08735247701406479 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043063171207904816 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a documentary-style medium close-up, the camera slowly inched closer on a female scientist in her forties, her dark hair adorned with a few silver braids, pulled back into a practical bun. Thin-framed glasses perched on her nose, she wore a simple gray turtleneck sweater over a crisp white lab coat. As she worked on the antistatic mat on her workbench, she leaned forward in concentration, her brow furrowed slightly. The robot's faceplate was a smooth matte white polymer, but the side panels had been removed, revealing a breathtakingly complex mesh of gleaming microservos, bundled fiber optics, and polished copper wires. With unwavering precision, the scientist carefully positioned a tiny, iridescent microchip on the exposed green circuit board with a pair of pointed tweezers in her right hand, her left hand steady to illuminate the intricate task. The surrounding lab was a blur of organized chaos: trays of components stacked on shelves, softly glowing green readouts on endoscopes, and out-of-focus schematics on a large monitor in the background. The scene is lit by a cool, unfocused overhead fluorescent light cut by the warm, focused cone of light from her task lamp, creating a dramatic interplay of light and shadow that accentuates the texture of the metal components and the focused determination on her face. The atmosphere is one of profound, quiet focus, capturing a pivotal moment of creation at the cutting edge of technology.", + "seed": 23135, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000008/group_9/index_818_seed_23135_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0827393602579832, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0827393602579832, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.749999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0827393602579832, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a documentary-style medium close-up of a female scientist in her forties?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scientist have dark hair with silver braids pulled back into a bun, and is she wearing thin-framed glasses, a gray turtleneck, and a white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist leaning forward in concentration while using tweezers in her right hand to position a tiny iridescent microchip on a green circuit board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the robot's exposed internal structure visible, showing a smooth matte white faceplate, removed side panels, gleaming microservos, fiber optics, and polished copper wires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly inch closer on the scientist throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11363762617111206 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.238637685775757 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11363762617111206, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11363762617111206, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13284678757190704, + 0.04319854453206062, + 0.07458758354187012, + 0.07446767389774323, + 0.05794724076986313, + 0.17835579812526703, + 0.1356656402349472, + 0.07171415537595749, + 0.19766423106193542, + 0.03355242684483528 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11363762617111206 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a documentary-style medium close-up of a female scientist in her forties?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scientist have dark hair with silver braids pulled back into a bun, and is she wearing thin-framed glasses, a gray turtleneck, and a white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist leaning forward in concentration while using tweezers in her right hand to position a tiny iridescent microchip on a green circuit board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the robot's exposed internal structure visible, showing a smooth matte white faceplate, removed side panels, gleaming microservos, fiber optics, and polished copper wires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly inch closer on the scientist throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01608525961637497 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141085147857666 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01608525961637497, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01608525961637497, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09687763452529907, + 0.0658845379948616, + 0.03933602571487427, + 0.04811203107237816, + 0.05700159817934036, + 0.4264916479587555, + 0.09748557955026627, + 0.06222197040915489, + 0.06997738033533096, + 0.03661160543560982 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01608525961637497 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a documentary-style medium close-up of a female scientist in her forties?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scientist have dark hair with silver braids pulled back into a bun, and is she wearing thin-framed glasses, a gray turtleneck, and a white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist leaning forward in concentration while using tweezers in her right hand to position a tiny iridescent microchip on a green circuit board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the robot's exposed internal structure visible, showing a smooth matte white faceplate, removed side panels, gleaming microservos, fiber optics, and polished copper wires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly inch closer on the scientist throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02979959361255169 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529799699783325 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02979959361255169, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02979959361255169, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12906382977962494, + 0.04910154268145561, + 0.031843703240156174, + 0.04919377341866493, + 0.05299020931124687, + 0.46874454617500305, + 0.0675940215587616, + 0.07337985932826996, + 0.0469474233686924, + 0.03114107809960842 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02979959361255169 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a documentary-style medium close-up of a female scientist in her forties?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scientist have dark hair with silver braids pulled back into a bun, and is she wearing thin-framed glasses, a gray turtleneck, and a white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist leaning forward in concentration while using tweezers in her right hand to position a tiny iridescent microchip on a green circuit board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the robot's exposed internal structure visible, showing a smooth matte white faceplate, removed side panels, gleaming microservos, fiber optics, and polished copper wires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly inch closer on the scientist throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12713980674743652 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1271398067474365 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12713980674743652, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12713980674743652, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23352287709712982, + 0.08044575899839401, + 0.06248145550489426, + 0.08403517305850983, + 0.0559009350836277, + 0.20141644775867462, + 0.08243991434574127, + 0.06053287163376808, + 0.08973091840744019, + 0.04949362576007843 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12713980674743652 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a documentary-style medium close-up of a female scientist in her forties?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scientist have dark hair with silver braids pulled back into a bun, and is she wearing thin-framed glasses, a gray turtleneck, and a white lab coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scientist leaning forward in concentration while using tweezers in her right hand to position a tiny iridescent microchip on a green circuit board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the robot's exposed internal structure visible, showing a smooth matte white faceplate, removed side panels, gleaming microservos, fiber optics, and polished copper wires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly inch closer on the scientist throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270345151424408 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270344257354736 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270345151424408, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270345151424408, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09580657631158829, + 0.061628133058547974, + 0.04237351939082146, + 0.051236558705568314, + 0.05435556173324585, + 0.3885091245174408, + 0.050801705569028854, + 0.08519149571657181, + 0.03535041585564613, + 0.13474684953689575 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270345151424408 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_0/index_tensor([8075, 8075])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_0/index_tensor([8075, 8075])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6b12847b08dc24817457687bd1cb7118d1bece08 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_0/index_tensor([8075, 8075])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from directly above focuses steadily on a vintage comic book lying open on a dark wood tabletop. A warm light from a desk lamp shines diagonally from the side, casting soft shadows on the pages, highlighting the yellowed, slightly rough texture of the paper. As if pulled by an invisible force, the right-hand page smoothly and gracefully rises from the corner, tracing a light arc through the air before silently covering the left-hand page. As the pages turn, a new, vibrant illustration and several hand-painted white speech bubbles emerge. The illustration, characterized by bold black outlines and signature Ben-Day halftone dots, exudes a retro visual impact. The entire process is steady and continuous, creating an immersive atmosphere of tranquility, nostalgia, and a touch of fantasy.", + "seed": 1736, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_0/index_8075_seed_1736_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07232456728816032, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07232456728816032, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07232456728816032, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot directly above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vintage comic book lying open on a dark wood tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm light from a desk lamp shine diagonally from the side, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right-hand page rise from the corner in a smooth arc to cover the left-hand page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the revealed pages feature bold black outlines, Ben-Day halftone dots, and white speech bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.24334652721881866 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6183465719223022 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.24334652721881866, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.24334652721881866, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17477478086948395, + 0.20870834589004517, + 0.27061882615089417, + 0.0959508866071701, + 0.043827008455991745, + 0.0430021658539772, + 0.09700597077608109, + 0.05068310722708702, + 0.008682223036885262, + 0.006746729835867882 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.24334652721881866 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot directly above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vintage comic book lying open on a dark wood tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm light from a desk lamp shine diagonally from the side, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right-hand page rise from the corner in a smooth arc to cover the left-hand page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the revealed pages feature bold black outlines, Ben-Day halftone dots, and white speech bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018229328095912933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0182294845581055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018229328095912933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018229328095912933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2180202454328537, + 0.15085262060165405, + 0.29115644097328186, + 0.0371418222784996, + 0.1125364676117897, + 0.05579683184623718, + 0.057795699685811996, + 0.032107990235090256, + 0.02367483451962471, + 0.020917031913995743 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018229328095912933 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot directly above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vintage comic book lying open on a dark wood tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm light from a desk lamp shine diagonally from the side, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right-hand page rise from the corner in a smooth arc to cover the left-hand page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the revealed pages feature bold black outlines, Ben-Day halftone dots, and white speech bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023304495960474014 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733044624328613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023304495960474014, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023304495960474014, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4491567313671112, + 0.16417762637138367, + 0.15315654873847961, + 0.07234939187765121, + 0.05269164219498634, + 0.029371721670031548, + 0.0299967210739851, + 0.017734065651893616, + 0.016030125319957733, + 0.01533535122871399 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023304495960474014 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot directly above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vintage comic book lying open on a dark wood tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm light from a desk lamp shine diagonally from the side, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right-hand page rise from the corner in a smooth arc to cover the left-hand page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the revealed pages feature bold black outlines, Ben-Day halftone dots, and white speech bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033691875636577606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408691883087158 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033691875636577606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033691875636577606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12611742317676544, + 0.16995640099048615, + 0.3373671770095825, + 0.1614706963300705, + 0.05367302522063255, + 0.09893153607845306, + 0.0158190056681633, + 0.01764487847685814, + 0.011642077006399632, + 0.0073777311481535435 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033691875636577606 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot directly above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vintage comic book lying open on a dark wood tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm light from a desk lamp shine diagonally from the side, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right-hand page rise from the corner in a smooth arc to cover the left-hand page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the revealed pages feature bold black outlines, Ben-Day halftone dots, and white speech bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0430506095290184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168050527572632 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0430506095290184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0430506095290184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13077595829963684, + 0.1306309551000595, + 0.21964764595031738, + 0.09888438135385513, + 0.13695617020130157, + 0.07584290951490402, + 0.09405793249607086, + 0.03883279860019684, + 0.03608419746160507, + 0.038287028670310974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0430506095290184 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from directly above focuses steadily on a vintage comic book lying open on a dark wood tabletop. A warm light from a desk lamp shines diagonally from the side, casting soft shadows on the pages, highlighting the yellowed, slightly rough texture of the paper. As if pulled by an invisible force, the right-hand page smoothly and gracefully rises from the corner, tracing a light arc through the air before silently covering the left-hand page. As the pages turn, a new, vibrant illustration and several hand-painted white speech bubbles emerge. The illustration, characterized by bold black outlines and signature Ben-Day halftone dots, exudes a retro visual impact. The entire process is steady and continuous, creating an immersive atmosphere of tranquility, nostalgia, and a touch of fantasy.", + "seed": 1737, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_0/index_8075_seed_1737_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0631298677995801, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0631298677995801, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0631298677995801, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot directly above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vintage comic book lying open on a dark wood tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm light from a desk lamp shine diagonally from the side, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right-hand page rise from the corner in a smooth arc to cover the left-hand page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the revealed pages feature bold black outlines, Ben-Day halftone dots, and white speech bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1438617706298828 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.143861770629883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1438617706298828, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1438617706298828, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4258051812648773, + 0.0329570472240448, + 0.02500496245920658, + 0.031201554462313652, + 0.03325703740119934, + 0.032117459923028946, + 0.21476374566555023, + 0.09414400160312653, + 0.0937013179063797, + 0.01704772561788559 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1438617706298828 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot directly above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vintage comic book lying open on a dark wood tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm light from a desk lamp shine diagonally from the side, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right-hand page rise from the corner in a smooth arc to cover the left-hand page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the revealed pages feature bold black outlines, Ben-Day halftone dots, and white speech bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006762475706636906 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006762504577637 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006762475706636906, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006762475706636906, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.356386661529541, + 0.07797785848379135, + 0.08447407931089401, + 0.08108910173177719, + 0.04697035253047943, + 0.043267302215099335, + 0.10324975848197937, + 0.06051954999566078, + 0.11965221911668777, + 0.02641311101615429 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006762475706636906 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot directly above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vintage comic book lying open on a dark wood tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm light from a desk lamp shine diagonally from the side, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right-hand page rise from the corner in a smooth arc to cover the left-hand page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the revealed pages feature bold black outlines, Ben-Day halftone dots, and white speech bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016082562506198883 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141082763671875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016082562506198883, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016082562506198883, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.428325891494751, + 0.08621947467327118, + 0.05509824678301811, + 0.03342357650399208, + 0.02539498545229435, + 0.011550473980605602, + 0.13421466946601868, + 0.12182862311601639, + 0.07859541475772858, + 0.02534870244562626 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016082562506198883 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot directly above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vintage comic book lying open on a dark wood tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm light from a desk lamp shine diagonally from the side, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right-hand page rise from the corner in a smooth arc to cover the left-hand page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the revealed pages feature bold black outlines, Ben-Day halftone dots, and white speech bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10029479116201401 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350294828414917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10029479116201401, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10029479116201401, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.168235644698143, + 0.0648798868060112, + 0.08777100592851639, + 0.08570387959480286, + 0.05448322370648384, + 0.036996446549892426, + 0.07707950472831726, + 0.2896168828010559, + 0.10270655155181885, + 0.032527003437280655 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10029479116201401 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot directly above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vintage comic book lying open on a dark wood tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm light from a desk lamp shine diagonally from the side, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right-hand page rise from the corner in a smooth arc to cover the left-hand page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the revealed pages feature bold black outlines, Ben-Day halftone dots, and white speech bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864773899316788 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.04864764213562 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864773899316788, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864773899316788, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22923396527767181, + 0.047250449657440186, + 0.05745339393615723, + 0.03431827574968338, + 0.05630314350128174, + 0.09082664549350739, + 0.08745092898607254, + 0.295425146818161, + 0.05935854837298393, + 0.042379483580589294 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864773899316788 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from directly above focuses steadily on a vintage comic book lying open on a dark wood tabletop. A warm light from a desk lamp shines diagonally from the side, casting soft shadows on the pages, highlighting the yellowed, slightly rough texture of the paper. As if pulled by an invisible force, the right-hand page smoothly and gracefully rises from the corner, tracing a light arc through the air before silently covering the left-hand page. As the pages turn, a new, vibrant illustration and several hand-painted white speech bubbles emerge. The illustration, characterized by bold black outlines and signature Ben-Day halftone dots, exudes a retro visual impact. The entire process is steady and continuous, creating an immersive atmosphere of tranquility, nostalgia, and a touch of fantasy.", + "seed": 1738, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_0/index_8075_seed_1738_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10694316760636866, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10694316760636866, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10694316760636866, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot directly above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vintage comic book lying open on a dark wood tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm light from a desk lamp shine diagonally from the side, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right-hand page rise from the corner in a smooth arc to cover the left-hand page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the revealed pages feature bold black outlines, Ben-Day halftone dots, and white speech bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3785063624382019 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3785064220428467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3785063624382019, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3785063624382019, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15770742297172546, + 0.08387643843889236, + 0.1314944475889206, + 0.15219902992248535, + 0.08797752857208252, + 0.10942979156970978, + 0.11689946800470352, + 0.05391647666692734, + 0.06282272189855576, + 0.04367676377296448 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3785063624382019 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot directly above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vintage comic book lying open on a dark wood tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm light from a desk lamp shine diagonally from the side, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right-hand page rise from the corner in a smooth arc to cover the left-hand page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the revealed pages feature bold black outlines, Ben-Day halftone dots, and white speech bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046682897955179214 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379668235778809 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046682897955179214, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046682897955179214, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1422657072544098, + 0.06072821840643883, + 0.18188898265361786, + 0.17675073444843292, + 0.17304857075214386, + 0.05396885424852371, + 0.08060643821954727, + 0.040250975638628006, + 0.029701435938477516, + 0.060790158808231354 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046682897955179214 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot directly above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vintage comic book lying open on a dark wood tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm light from a desk lamp shine diagonally from the side, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right-hand page rise from the corner in a smooth arc to cover the left-hand page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the revealed pages feature bold black outlines, Ben-Day halftone dots, and white speech bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028269824106246233 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877827167510986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028269824106246233, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028269824106246233, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2515726089477539, + 0.17297695577144623, + 0.04612495005130768, + 0.05852785333991051, + 0.12282592058181763, + 0.17441822588443756, + 0.05367131903767586, + 0.03720742091536522, + 0.0339447520673275, + 0.04872993007302284 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028269824106246233 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot directly above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vintage comic book lying open on a dark wood tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm light from a desk lamp shine diagonally from the side, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right-hand page rise from the corner in a smooth arc to cover the left-hand page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the revealed pages feature bold black outlines, Ben-Day halftone dots, and white speech bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14277048408985138 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017770528793335 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14277048408985138, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14277048408985138, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07159514725208282, + 0.04581625759601593, + 0.2059853971004486, + 0.06512129306793213, + 0.20044125616550446, + 0.10031023621559143, + 0.11004709452390671, + 0.04128598794341087, + 0.03834635391831398, + 0.12105097621679306 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14277048408985138 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot directly above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vintage comic book lying open on a dark wood tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm light from a desk lamp shine diagonally from the side, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right-hand page rise from the corner in a smooth arc to cover the left-hand page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the revealed pages feature bold black outlines, Ben-Day halftone dots, and white speech bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005943719297647476 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130943775177002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005943719297647476, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005943719297647476, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05422437563538551, + 0.03880682587623596, + 0.09615121781826019, + 0.215548574924469, + 0.18502886593341827, + 0.11399935185909271, + 0.10119012743234634, + 0.06287664920091629, + 0.05572482943534851, + 0.07644923031330109 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005943719297647476 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from directly above focuses steadily on a vintage comic book lying open on a dark wood tabletop. A warm light from a desk lamp shines diagonally from the side, casting soft shadows on the pages, highlighting the yellowed, slightly rough texture of the paper. As if pulled by an invisible force, the right-hand page smoothly and gracefully rises from the corner, tracing a light arc through the air before silently covering the left-hand page. As the pages turn, a new, vibrant illustration and several hand-painted white speech bubbles emerge. The illustration, characterized by bold black outlines and signature Ben-Day halftone dots, exudes a retro visual impact. The entire process is steady and continuous, creating an immersive atmosphere of tranquility, nostalgia, and a touch of fantasy.", + "seed": 1739, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_0/index_8075_seed_1739_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04687925642356276, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04687925642356276, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04687925642356276, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot directly above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vintage comic book lying open on a dark wood tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm light from a desk lamp shine diagonally from the side, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right-hand page rise from the corner in a smooth arc to cover the left-hand page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the revealed pages feature bold black outlines, Ben-Day halftone dots, and white speech bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0904354676604271 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.21543550491333 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0904354676604271, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0904354676604271, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.43128496408462524, + 0.17865228652954102, + 0.08266197890043259, + 0.04827846959233284, + 0.06368232518434525, + 0.05427506938576698, + 0.024354951456189156, + 0.06423100084066391, + 0.011452186852693558, + 0.04112683981657028 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0904354676604271 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot directly above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vintage comic book lying open on a dark wood tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm light from a desk lamp shine diagonally from the side, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right-hand page rise from the corner in a smooth arc to cover the left-hand page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the revealed pages feature bold black outlines, Ben-Day halftone dots, and white speech bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003230117727071047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753230094909668 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003230117727071047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003230117727071047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1600131094455719, + 0.31737712025642395, + 0.14545480906963348, + 0.06470482796430588, + 0.1263117492198944, + 0.04734402522444725, + 0.033869072794914246, + 0.03477446734905243, + 0.02229424938559532, + 0.04785657674074173 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003230117727071047 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot directly above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vintage comic book lying open on a dark wood tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm light from a desk lamp shine diagonally from the side, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right-hand page rise from the corner in a smooth arc to cover the left-hand page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the revealed pages feature bold black outlines, Ben-Day halftone dots, and white speech bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006748977117240429 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006749153137207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006748977117240429, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006748977117240429, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09987582266330719, + 0.6716281175613403, + 0.06477478891611099, + 0.01359434425830841, + 0.02905968949198723, + 0.020514801144599915, + 0.048611804842948914, + 0.03031080774962902, + 0.009911478497087955, + 0.011718371883034706 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006748977117240429 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot directly above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vintage comic book lying open on a dark wood tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm light from a desk lamp shine diagonally from the side, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right-hand page rise from the corner in a smooth arc to cover the left-hand page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the revealed pages feature bold black outlines, Ben-Day halftone dots, and white speech bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10029307007789612 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3502931594848633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10029307007789612, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10029307007789612, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33352506160736084, + 0.15577372908592224, + 0.15860724449157715, + 0.058812424540519714, + 0.03038049302995205, + 0.027960238978266716, + 0.06790969520807266, + 0.07101627439260483, + 0.021003736183047295, + 0.07501108199357986 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10029307007789612 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot directly above the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vintage comic book lying open on a dark wood tabletop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a warm light from a desk lamp shine diagonally from the side, casting soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the right-hand page rise from the corner in a smooth arc to cover the left-hand page?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the revealed pages feature bold black outlines, Ben-Day halftone dots, and white speech bubbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368864953517914 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408688545227051 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368864953517914, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368864953517914, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19167619943618774, + 0.07792136073112488, + 0.301750123500824, + 0.08840379863977432, + 0.03441314026713371, + 0.02798406220972538, + 0.11384419351816177, + 0.07474120706319809, + 0.02052801288664341, + 0.0687379315495491 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368864953517914 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_1/index_tensor([7076, 7076])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_1/index_tensor([7076, 7076])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c6e63e0a422e482416c767ada6d6587978cec486 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_1/index_tensor([7076, 7076])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The shot begins with a close-up shot from a level angle, the camera remaining static, focusing on a solid wood dining table with warm wood grain. A freshly folded white cotton shirt lies neatly in the center. With a hand-drawn quality reminiscent of Ghibli animations, each crease of the shirt is crisp and soft, shimmering with a sun-soaked milky sheen. The camera then begins an incredibly slow and smooth shift in focus, the outline of the shirt in the foreground gradually fading into a soft blur. The focus steadily moves back through the bright wooden window, finally settling on the cherry blossom petals slowly falling outside. Each pale pink petal twirls and dances gracefully in the air, against a backdrop of hazy neighboring rooftops and a vibrant blue sky. Warm afternoon sunlight slants across the cozy kitchen, casting distinct golden beams in the air. Tiny dust particles dance gracefully within these beams, casting a soft glow on the wooden cabinets and the small potted plant on the windowsill. The whole picture is dominated by warm wood color and soft beige, dotted with pale pink cherry blossoms, creating a poetic atmosphere that is tranquil, nostalgic and full of life.", + "seed": 4934, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_1/index_7076_seed_4934_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.046570318285375834, + "vlm_logprob": -0.046570318285375834, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.046570318285375834, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a solid wood dining table with warm wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly folded white cotton shirt visible in the center of the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shift focus from the shirt in the foreground to the cherry blossom petals outside the window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pale pink cherry blossom petals shown falling outside against a backdrop of hazy rooftops and a blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting golden beams with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20244385302066803 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7024438381195068 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20244385302066803, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20244385302066803, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05650743097066879, + 0.039352305233478546, + 0.034585315734148026, + 0.013747243210673332, + 0.03254719078540802, + 0.49842649698257446, + 0.25004228949546814, + 0.03588854521512985, + 0.027043182402849197, + 0.011860009282827377 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20244385302066803 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a solid wood dining table with warm wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly folded white cotton shirt visible in the center of the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shift focus from the shirt in the foreground to the cherry blossom petals outside the window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pale pink cherry blossom petals shown falling outside against a backdrop of hazy rooftops and a blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting golden beams with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009794747456908226 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63479471206665 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009794747456908226, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009794747456908226, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09850126504898071, + 0.04934524744749069, + 0.026604972779750824, + 0.011104049161076546, + 0.04019331932067871, + 0.5766098499298096, + 0.06350072473287582, + 0.0999966412782669, + 0.022881437093019485, + 0.011262470856308937 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009794747456908226 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a solid wood dining table with warm wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly folded white cotton shirt visible in the center of the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shift focus from the shirt in the foreground to the cherry blossom petals outside the window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pale pink cherry blossom petals shown falling outside against a backdrop of hazy rooftops and a blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting golden beams with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009785657748579979 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347856521606445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009785657748579979, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009785657748579979, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09940871596336365, + 0.05155084654688835, + 0.041228972375392914, + 0.06936395913362503, + 0.10030245035886765, + 0.24692648649215698, + 0.07798318564891815, + 0.22569118440151215, + 0.05650949850678444, + 0.031034696847200394 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009785657748579979 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a solid wood dining table with warm wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly folded white cotton shirt visible in the center of the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shift focus from the shirt in the foreground to the cherry blossom petals outside the window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pale pink cherry blossom petals shown falling outside against a backdrop of hazy rooftops and a blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting golden beams with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002193665597587824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127193450927734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002193665597587824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002193665597587824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0462445430457592, + 0.020768243819475174, + 0.017829349264502525, + 0.023069478571414948, + 0.04321705922484398, + 0.674689531326294, + 0.06604013592004776, + 0.07163408398628235, + 0.013911820948123932, + 0.022595718502998352 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002193665597587824 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a solid wood dining table with warm wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly folded white cotton shirt visible in the center of the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shift focus from the shirt in the foreground to the cherry blossom petals outside the window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pale pink cherry blossom petals shown falling outside against a backdrop of hazy rooftops and a blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting golden beams with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008633667603135109 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758633613586426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008633667603135109, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008633667603135109, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.01934291422367096, + 0.01671414077281952, + 0.011998479254543781, + 0.01114131510257721, + 0.025086535140872, + 0.7747650742530823, + 0.031152978539466858, + 0.06393803656101227, + 0.023222818970680237, + 0.02263762056827545 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008633667603135109 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The shot begins with a close-up shot from a level angle, the camera remaining static, focusing on a solid wood dining table with warm wood grain. A freshly folded white cotton shirt lies neatly in the center. With a hand-drawn quality reminiscent of Ghibli animations, each crease of the shirt is crisp and soft, shimmering with a sun-soaked milky sheen. The camera then begins an incredibly slow and smooth shift in focus, the outline of the shirt in the foreground gradually fading into a soft blur. The focus steadily moves back through the bright wooden window, finally settling on the cherry blossom petals slowly falling outside. Each pale pink petal twirls and dances gracefully in the air, against a backdrop of hazy neighboring rooftops and a vibrant blue sky. Warm afternoon sunlight slants across the cozy kitchen, casting distinct golden beams in the air. Tiny dust particles dance gracefully within these beams, casting a soft glow on the wooden cabinets and the small potted plant on the windowsill. The whole picture is dominated by warm wood color and soft beige, dotted with pale pink cherry blossoms, creating a poetic atmosphere that is tranquil, nostalgic and full of life.", + "seed": 4935, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_1/index_7076_seed_4935_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.09617956769652665, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09617956769652665, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09617956769652665, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a solid wood dining table with warm wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly folded white cotton shirt visible in the center of the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shift focus from the shirt in the foreground to the cherry blossom petals outside the window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pale pink cherry blossom petals shown falling outside against a backdrop of hazy rooftops and a blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting golden beams with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4300869405269623 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0550869703292847 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4300869405269623, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4300869405269623, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2765125036239624, + 0.09356199949979782, + 0.07320541888475418, + 0.06138494238257408, + 0.107927106320858, + 0.06380520761013031, + 0.034682322293519974, + 0.1887507438659668, + 0.03457777202129364, + 0.06559202075004578 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4300869405269623 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a solid wood dining table with warm wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly folded white cotton shirt visible in the center of the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shift focus from the shirt in the foreground to the cherry blossom petals outside the window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pale pink cherry blossom petals shown falling outside against a backdrop of hazy rooftops and a blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting golden beams with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01256160531193018 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387561798095703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01256160531193018, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01256160531193018, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05213433504104614, + 0.026820432394742966, + 0.06620556116104126, + 0.10195822268724442, + 0.2948627769947052, + 0.287203311920166, + 0.016007544472813606, + 0.0842718854546547, + 0.04682667925953865, + 0.023709245026111603 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01256160531193018 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a solid wood dining table with warm wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly folded white cotton shirt visible in the center of the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shift focus from the shirt in the foreground to the cherry blossom petals outside the window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pale pink cherry blossom petals shown falling outside against a backdrop of hazy rooftops and a blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting golden beams with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02981625683605671 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529816150665283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02981625683605671, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02981625683605671, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2632021903991699, + 0.08403726667165756, + 0.05327429622411728, + 0.062068793922662735, + 0.19689014554023743, + 0.054316192865371704, + 0.031265098601579666, + 0.09923537075519562, + 0.038739483803510666, + 0.11697109043598175 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02981625683605671 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a solid wood dining table with warm wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly folded white cotton shirt visible in the center of the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shift focus from the shirt in the foreground to the cherry blossom petals outside the window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pale pink cherry blossom petals shown falling outside against a backdrop of hazy rooftops and a blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting golden beams with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002486353972926736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002486228942871 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002486353972926736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002486353972926736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11527805775403976, + 0.05560220032930374, + 0.04613342136144638, + 0.06378082931041718, + 0.2352743297815323, + 0.28951403498649597, + 0.01816919445991516, + 0.0757596418261528, + 0.05548509955406189, + 0.04500317946076393 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002486353972926736 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a solid wood dining table with warm wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly folded white cotton shirt visible in the center of the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shift focus from the shirt in the foreground to the cherry blossom petals outside the window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pale pink cherry blossom petals shown falling outside against a backdrop of hazy rooftops and a blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting golden beams with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005946681834757328 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130946636199951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005946681834757328, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005946681834757328, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16497363150119781, + 0.040351636707782745, + 0.026556305587291718, + 0.07009507715702057, + 0.1673491895198822, + 0.2769550681114197, + 0.016665445640683174, + 0.1290297508239746, + 0.04155709967017174, + 0.06646678596735 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005946681834757328 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The shot begins with a close-up shot from a level angle, the camera remaining static, focusing on a solid wood dining table with warm wood grain. A freshly folded white cotton shirt lies neatly in the center. With a hand-drawn quality reminiscent of Ghibli animations, each crease of the shirt is crisp and soft, shimmering with a sun-soaked milky sheen. The camera then begins an incredibly slow and smooth shift in focus, the outline of the shirt in the foreground gradually fading into a soft blur. The focus steadily moves back through the bright wooden window, finally settling on the cherry blossom petals slowly falling outside. Each pale pink petal twirls and dances gracefully in the air, against a backdrop of hazy neighboring rooftops and a vibrant blue sky. Warm afternoon sunlight slants across the cozy kitchen, casting distinct golden beams in the air. Tiny dust particles dance gracefully within these beams, casting a soft glow on the wooden cabinets and the small potted plant on the windowsill. The whole picture is dominated by warm wood color and soft beige, dotted with pale pink cherry blossoms, creating a poetic atmosphere that is tranquil, nostalgic and full of life.", + "seed": 4936, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_1/index_7076_seed_4936_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.08630442027933896, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08630442027933896, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08630442027933896, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a solid wood dining table with warm wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly folded white cotton shirt visible in the center of the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shift focus from the shirt in the foreground to the cherry blossom petals outside the window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pale pink cherry blossom petals shown falling outside against a backdrop of hazy rooftops and a blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting golden beams with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34943267703056335 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2244327068328857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34943267703056335, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34943267703056335, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24519149959087372, + 0.11117919534444809, + 0.03474550321698189, + 0.06481999158859253, + 0.09653107076883316, + 0.09109716862440109, + 0.09717272967100143, + 0.07778250426054001, + 0.07153009623289108, + 0.10995016247034073 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34943267703056335 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a solid wood dining table with warm wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly folded white cotton shirt visible in the center of the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shift focus from the shirt in the foreground to the cherry blossom petals outside the window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pale pink cherry blossom petals shown falling outside against a backdrop of hazy rooftops and a blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting golden beams with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023306358605623245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773306369781494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023306358605623245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023306358605623245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.48120346665382385, + 0.17193551361560822, + 0.037618812173604965, + 0.018407871946692467, + 0.03255358338356018, + 0.0329144187271595, + 0.07736434787511826, + 0.04264511913061142, + 0.08294395357370377, + 0.022412922233343124 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023306358605623245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a solid wood dining table with warm wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly folded white cotton shirt visible in the center of the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shift focus from the shirt in the foreground to the cherry blossom petals outside the window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pale pink cherry blossom petals shown falling outside against a backdrop of hazy rooftops and a blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting golden beams with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048672378063201904 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486724376678467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048672378063201904, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048672378063201904, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3530615568161011, + 0.23079779744148254, + 0.03154768422245979, + 0.04232097044587135, + 0.027142949402332306, + 0.04308399185538292, + 0.07448652386665344, + 0.0816052109003067, + 0.08668024837970734, + 0.02927307039499283 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048672378063201904 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a solid wood dining table with warm wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly folded white cotton shirt visible in the center of the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shift focus from the shirt in the foreground to the cherry blossom petals outside the window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pale pink cherry blossom petals shown falling outside against a backdrop of hazy rooftops and a blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting golden beams with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002485997276380658 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002486228942871 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002485997276380658, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002485997276380658, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2452978491783142, + 0.11998214572668076, + 0.08991989493370056, + 0.12761782109737396, + 0.07845617830753326, + 0.06460442394018173, + 0.04905210807919502, + 0.06914959847927094, + 0.0868285745382309, + 0.06909144669771194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002485997276380658 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a solid wood dining table with warm wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly folded white cotton shirt visible in the center of the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shift focus from the shirt in the foreground to the cherry blossom petals outside the window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pale pink cherry blossom petals shown falling outside against a backdrop of hazy rooftops and a blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting golden beams with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007624690420925617 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882624626159668 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007624690420925617, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007624690420925617, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4124605655670166, + 0.15641625225543976, + 0.04852105304598808, + 0.0712038204073906, + 0.048155274242162704, + 0.049704864621162415, + 0.07246636599302292, + 0.044775135815143585, + 0.05433523654937744, + 0.041961438953876495 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007624690420925617 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The shot begins with a close-up shot from a level angle, the camera remaining static, focusing on a solid wood dining table with warm wood grain. A freshly folded white cotton shirt lies neatly in the center. With a hand-drawn quality reminiscent of Ghibli animations, each crease of the shirt is crisp and soft, shimmering with a sun-soaked milky sheen. The camera then begins an incredibly slow and smooth shift in focus, the outline of the shirt in the foreground gradually fading into a soft blur. The focus steadily moves back through the bright wooden window, finally settling on the cherry blossom petals slowly falling outside. Each pale pink petal twirls and dances gracefully in the air, against a backdrop of hazy neighboring rooftops and a vibrant blue sky. Warm afternoon sunlight slants across the cozy kitchen, casting distinct golden beams in the air. Tiny dust particles dance gracefully within these beams, casting a soft glow on the wooden cabinets and the small potted plant on the windowsill. The whole picture is dominated by warm wood color and soft beige, dotted with pale pink cherry blossoms, creating a poetic atmosphere that is tranquil, nostalgic and full of life.", + "seed": 4937, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_1/index_7076_seed_4937_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.05152217051945627, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05152217051945627, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05152217051945627, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a solid wood dining table with warm wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly folded white cotton shirt visible in the center of the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shift focus from the shirt in the foreground to the cherry blossom petals outside the window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pale pink cherry blossom petals shown falling outside against a backdrop of hazy rooftops and a blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting golden beams with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20261237025260925 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7026124000549316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20261237025260925, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20261237025260925, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1833885759115219, + 0.037039946764707565, + 0.026831934228539467, + 0.0571281760931015, + 0.1798848956823349, + 0.07188321650028229, + 0.11974859982728958, + 0.021052662283182144, + 0.14033913612365723, + 0.16270287334918976 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20261237025260925 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a solid wood dining table with warm wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly folded white cotton shirt visible in the center of the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shift focus from the shirt in the foreground to the cherry blossom petals outside the window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pale pink cherry blossom petals shown falling outside against a backdrop of hazy rooftops and a blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting golden beams with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018204044550657272 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018204212188721 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018204044550657272, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018204044550657272, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12891238927841187, + 0.07830445468425751, + 0.07528646290302277, + 0.10693168640136719, + 0.03449924662709236, + 0.07417239248752594, + 0.06833374500274658, + 0.09420836716890335, + 0.306510865688324, + 0.03284038230776787 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018204044550657272 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a solid wood dining table with warm wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly folded white cotton shirt visible in the center of the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shift focus from the shirt in the foreground to the cherry blossom petals outside the window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pale pink cherry blossom petals shown falling outside against a backdrop of hazy rooftops and a blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting golden beams with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02635536715388298 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651355266571045 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02635536715388298, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02635536715388298, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.133665069937706, + 0.0945182666182518, + 0.04944566264748573, + 0.06812164932489395, + 0.11488957703113556, + 0.09510429948568344, + 0.058263033628463745, + 0.12466952204704285, + 0.1943625956773758, + 0.06696031987667084 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02635536715388298 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a solid wood dining table with warm wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly folded white cotton shirt visible in the center of the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shift focus from the shirt in the foreground to the cherry blossom petals outside the window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pale pink cherry blossom petals shown falling outside against a backdrop of hazy rooftops and a blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting golden beams with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028140253853052855 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877813816070557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028140253853052855, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028140253853052855, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17014291882514954, + 0.08832923322916031, + 0.04948089271783829, + 0.05647474527359009, + 0.1738930195569992, + 0.06292348355054855, + 0.0626935213804245, + 0.12127300351858139, + 0.10633942484855652, + 0.10844981670379639 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028140253853052855 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a close-up of a solid wood dining table with warm wood grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly folded white cotton shirt visible in the center of the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera shift focus from the shirt in the foreground to the cherry blossom petals outside the window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pale pink cherry blossom petals shown falling outside against a backdrop of hazy rooftops and a blue sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight casting golden beams with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007625045254826546 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882625102996826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007625045254826546, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007625045254826546, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2714367210865021, + 0.07598568499088287, + 0.042036741971969604, + 0.03862105309963226, + 0.11345002055168152, + 0.04855240881443024, + 0.07790230959653854, + 0.08911427855491638, + 0.15023384988307953, + 0.09266692399978638 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007625045254826546 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_10/index_tensor([2339, 2339])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_10/index_tensor([2339, 2339])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..457f089c791ef094ab1c700ff181e1806ac3122b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_10/index_tensor([2339, 2339])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, static medium shot captures a female tennis player, her body a study in spiraling kinetic energy as she crouches at the baseline of a vibrant blue hard court. Her dark brown hair is pulled back into a tight ponytail, a few damp strands clinging to her sweat-soaked temples in the midday sun. Her focus is absolute, her narrowed eyes fixed intently on her unseen opponent across the net, her jaw set with fierce determination. She wears a sleeveless white blazer and matching white tennis skirt made of breathable, textured fabric, her tanned, muscular legs tensed, ready to spring. Her right hand expertly grips a modern graphite tennis racket with black and neon yellow accents, holding it far back behind her, maintaining a perfect textbook position for a powerful shot. The harsh, direct sunlight casts a sharp shadow of her poised form on the worn court surface, while the net at midcourt appears softly blurred, emphasizing the player's singular focus. The whole scene is filled with an air of intense focus, a frozen moment of peak athleticism before the action explodes.", + "seed": 12084, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_10/index_2339_seed_12084_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.24169196197763085, + "vlm_logprob": -0.24169196197763085, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.3500000119209288, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.24169196197763085, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female tennis player wearing a sleeveless white blazer and matching white tennis skirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the player holding a graphite tennis racket with black and neon yellow accents behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vibrant blue hard court with the net appearing softly blurred in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6639337539672852 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7889337539672852 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6639337539672852, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6639337539672852, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09434296190738678, + 0.01544511504471302, + 0.04325607791543007, + 0.025590773671865463, + 0.38386231660842896, + 0.025439122691750526, + 0.21896804869174957, + 0.05357218161225319, + 0.11166510730981827, + 0.027858305722475052 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6639337539672852 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female tennis player wearing a sleeveless white blazer and matching white tennis skirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the player holding a graphite tennis racket with black and neon yellow accents behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vibrant blue hard court with the net appearing softly blurred in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42894476652145386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539448261260986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42894476652145386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.6250000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42894476652145386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05132993310689926, + 0.022206686437129974, + 0.022839374840259552, + 0.01692952960729599, + 0.5470064282417297, + 0.018555425107479095, + 0.056535087525844574, + 0.024610383436083794, + 0.21924827992916107, + 0.020738821476697922 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42894476652145386 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female tennis player wearing a sleeveless white blazer and matching white tennis skirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the player holding a graphite tennis racket with black and neon yellow accents behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vibrant blue hard court with the net appearing softly blurred in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029822388663887978 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.52982234954834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029822388663887978, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029822388663887978, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11503826081752777, + 0.03147123008966446, + 0.10657577961683273, + 0.025986574590206146, + 0.14226865768432617, + 0.036057248711586, + 0.1235794648528099, + 0.03674515709280968, + 0.22246183454990387, + 0.15981583297252655 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029822388663887978 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female tennis player wearing a sleeveless white blazer and matching white tennis skirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the player holding a graphite tennis racket with black and neon yellow accents behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vibrant blue hard court with the net appearing softly blurred in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07902579009532928 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790257453918457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07902579009532928, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07902579009532928, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04640595242381096, + 0.024414315819740295, + 0.10183660686016083, + 0.04668319225311279, + 0.09988974779844284, + 0.03064129687845707, + 0.3788493275642395, + 0.09160837531089783, + 0.16606663167476654, + 0.013604589737951756 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07902579009532928 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female tennis player wearing a sleeveless white blazer and matching white tennis skirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the player holding a graphite tennis racket with black and neon yellow accents behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vibrant blue hard court with the net appearing softly blurred in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006733110640197992 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006732940673828 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006733110640197992, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006733110640197992, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.059315942227840424, + 0.03957240283489227, + 0.10322682559490204, + 0.00937324482947588, + 0.3952968418598175, + 0.012710953131318092, + 0.10693146288394928, + 0.020190073177218437, + 0.223338320851326, + 0.03004397638142109 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006733110640197992 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, static medium shot captures a female tennis player, her body a study in spiraling kinetic energy as she crouches at the baseline of a vibrant blue hard court. Her dark brown hair is pulled back into a tight ponytail, a few damp strands clinging to her sweat-soaked temples in the midday sun. Her focus is absolute, her narrowed eyes fixed intently on her unseen opponent across the net, her jaw set with fierce determination. She wears a sleeveless white blazer and matching white tennis skirt made of breathable, textured fabric, her tanned, muscular legs tensed, ready to spring. Her right hand expertly grips a modern graphite tennis racket with black and neon yellow accents, holding it far back behind her, maintaining a perfect textbook position for a powerful shot. The harsh, direct sunlight casts a sharp shadow of her poised form on the worn court surface, while the net at midcourt appears softly blurred, emphasizing the player's singular focus. The whole scene is filled with an air of intense focus, a frozen moment of peak athleticism before the action explodes.", + "seed": 12085, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_10/index_2339_seed_12085_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.26255790069699286, + "vlm_logprob": -0.26255790069699286, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.26255790069699286, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female tennis player wearing a sleeveless white blazer and matching white tennis skirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the player holding a graphite tennis racket with black and neon yellow accents behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vibrant blue hard court with the net appearing softly blurred in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7153472304344177 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8403472304344177 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7153472304344177, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7153472304344177, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34842413663864136, + 0.07000157982110977, + 0.038850076496601105, + 0.060139141976833344, + 0.1069943755865097, + 0.05435166880488396, + 0.10675086826086044, + 0.08602802455425262, + 0.08251640945672989, + 0.04594369977712631 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7153472304344177 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female tennis player wearing a sleeveless white blazer and matching white tennis skirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the player holding a graphite tennis racket with black and neon yellow accents behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vibrant blue hard court with the net appearing softly blurred in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25219234824180603 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021923780441284 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25219234824180603, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25219234824180603, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22354653477668762, + 0.049712929874658585, + 0.045027680695056915, + 0.08438551425933838, + 0.07396695762872696, + 0.11504428088665009, + 0.1086127981543541, + 0.13079477846622467, + 0.09454811364412308, + 0.07436037063598633 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25219234824180603 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female tennis player wearing a sleeveless white blazer and matching white tennis skirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the player holding a graphite tennis racket with black and neon yellow accents behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vibrant blue hard court with the net appearing softly blurred in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812725096940994 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881271839141846 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812725096940994, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812725096940994, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3108622431755066, + 0.0858791321516037, + 0.05341830849647522, + 0.03796935826539993, + 0.056546732783317566, + 0.15136376023292542, + 0.03185339272022247, + 0.038455091416835785, + 0.18119637668132782, + 0.05245554819703102 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812725096940994 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female tennis player wearing a sleeveless white blazer and matching white tennis skirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the player holding a graphite tennis racket with black and neon yellow accents behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vibrant blue hard court with the net appearing softly blurred in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521750330924988 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021750926971436 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521750330924988, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521750330924988, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18246495723724365, + 0.07118261605501175, + 0.045336686074733734, + 0.059252556413412094, + 0.07068329304456711, + 0.2964763939380646, + 0.06973421573638916, + 0.043383192270994186, + 0.103519968688488, + 0.05796611309051514 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521750330924988 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female tennis player wearing a sleeveless white blazer and matching white tennis skirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the player holding a graphite tennis racket with black and neon yellow accents behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vibrant blue hard court with the net appearing softly blurred in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054947640746831894 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299476146698 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054947640746831894, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054947640746831894, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20246116816997528, + 0.12496108561754227, + 0.05426962673664093, + 0.0689225047826767, + 0.09306119382381439, + 0.2170678973197937, + 0.07435128092765808, + 0.025495832785964012, + 0.04835972562432289, + 0.09104958176612854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054947640746831894 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, static medium shot captures a female tennis player, her body a study in spiraling kinetic energy as she crouches at the baseline of a vibrant blue hard court. Her dark brown hair is pulled back into a tight ponytail, a few damp strands clinging to her sweat-soaked temples in the midday sun. Her focus is absolute, her narrowed eyes fixed intently on her unseen opponent across the net, her jaw set with fierce determination. She wears a sleeveless white blazer and matching white tennis skirt made of breathable, textured fabric, her tanned, muscular legs tensed, ready to spring. Her right hand expertly grips a modern graphite tennis racket with black and neon yellow accents, holding it far back behind her, maintaining a perfect textbook position for a powerful shot. The harsh, direct sunlight casts a sharp shadow of her poised form on the worn court surface, while the net at midcourt appears softly blurred, emphasizing the player's singular focus. The whole scene is filled with an air of intense focus, a frozen moment of peak athleticism before the action explodes.", + "seed": 12086, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_10/index_2339_seed_12086_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.31912206718698144, + "vlm_logprob": -0.31912206718698144, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.31912206718698144, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female tennis player wearing a sleeveless white blazer and matching white tennis skirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the player holding a graphite tennis racket with black and neon yellow accents behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vibrant blue hard court with the net appearing softly blurred in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07499384880065918 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.699993848800659 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07499384880065918, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07499384880065918, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19423401355743408, + 0.1332995891571045, + 0.053849004209041595, + 0.0609242208302021, + 0.07479435205459595, + 0.08535780757665634, + 0.14374542236328125, + 0.10881554335355759, + 0.03546585887670517, + 0.10951420664787292 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07499384880065918 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female tennis player wearing a sleeveless white blazer and matching white tennis skirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the player holding a graphite tennis racket with black and neon yellow accents behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vibrant blue hard court with the net appearing softly blurred in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063018560409546 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813018262386322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.4063018560409546, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -1.4063018560409546, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12816879153251648, + 0.09701327234506607, + 0.07276049256324768, + 0.07164817303419113, + 0.04598059132695198, + 0.06461045145988464, + 0.04336605966091156, + 0.059168778359889984, + 0.3235952854156494, + 0.09368811547756195 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.4063018560409546 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female tennis player wearing a sleeveless white blazer and matching white tennis skirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the player holding a graphite tennis racket with black and neon yellow accents behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vibrant blue hard court with the net appearing softly blurred in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0205991230905056 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895599126815796 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0205991230905056, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0205991230905056, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17564554512500763, + 0.18814148008823395, + 0.06142764165997505, + 0.05401729419827461, + 0.04906454309821129, + 0.10602010041475296, + 0.05720803886651993, + 0.0390990786254406, + 0.1145179346203804, + 0.1548583209514618 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0205991230905056 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female tennis player wearing a sleeveless white blazer and matching white tennis skirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the player holding a graphite tennis racket with black and neon yellow accents behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vibrant blue hard court with the net appearing softly blurred in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08907806873321533 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464077949523926 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08907806873321533, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08907806873321533, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18324825167655945, + 0.06223099306225777, + 0.2043045461177826, + 0.056940704584121704, + 0.06770557910203934, + 0.11950299888849258, + 0.0524650439620018, + 0.06865107268095016, + 0.12954869866371155, + 0.05540206655859947 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08907806873321533 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female tennis player wearing a sleeveless white blazer and matching white tennis skirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the player holding a graphite tennis racket with black and neon yellow accents behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vibrant blue hard court with the net appearing softly blurred in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004637439269572496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379637241363525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004637439269572496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004637439269572496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13159316778182983, + 0.05291573330760002, + 0.067763552069664, + 0.05296076834201813, + 0.071938656270504, + 0.08535033464431763, + 0.11052197962999344, + 0.08718110620975494, + 0.238740935921669, + 0.1010337695479393 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004637439269572496 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, static medium shot captures a female tennis player, her body a study in spiraling kinetic energy as she crouches at the baseline of a vibrant blue hard court. Her dark brown hair is pulled back into a tight ponytail, a few damp strands clinging to her sweat-soaked temples in the midday sun. Her focus is absolute, her narrowed eyes fixed intently on her unseen opponent across the net, her jaw set with fierce determination. She wears a sleeveless white blazer and matching white tennis skirt made of breathable, textured fabric, her tanned, muscular legs tensed, ready to spring. Her right hand expertly grips a modern graphite tennis racket with black and neon yellow accents, holding it far back behind her, maintaining a perfect textbook position for a powerful shot. The harsh, direct sunlight casts a sharp shadow of her poised form on the worn court surface, while the net at midcourt appears softly blurred, emphasizing the player's singular focus. The whole scene is filled with an air of intense focus, a frozen moment of peak athleticism before the action explodes.", + "seed": 12087, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_10/index_2339_seed_12087_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.12664278969168663, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12664278969168663, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12664278969168663, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female tennis player wearing a sleeveless white blazer and matching white tennis skirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the player holding a graphite tennis racket with black and neon yellow accents behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vibrant blue hard court with the net appearing softly blurred in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.33200639486312866 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3320064544677734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.33200639486312866, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.33200639486312866, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3788493275642395, + 0.0981423631310463, + 0.04560413584113121, + 0.07685521245002747, + 0.03850413113832474, + 0.049927789717912674, + 0.07785389572381973, + 0.017527088522911072, + 0.06240631639957428, + 0.1543297916650772 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.33200639486312866 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female tennis player wearing a sleeveless white blazer and matching white tennis skirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the player holding a graphite tennis racket with black and neon yellow accents behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vibrant blue hard court with the net appearing softly blurred in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16040730476379395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910407304763794 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16040730476379395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16040730476379395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21153131127357483, + 0.056763216853141785, + 0.06628317385911942, + 0.1898585706949234, + 0.054046597331762314, + 0.0319470576941967, + 0.12804734706878662, + 0.029991615563631058, + 0.05220523104071617, + 0.1793259084224701 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16040730476379395 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female tennis player wearing a sleeveless white blazer and matching white tennis skirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the player holding a graphite tennis racket with black and neon yellow accents behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vibrant blue hard court with the net appearing softly blurred in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371020406484604 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408710241317749 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371020406484604, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371020406484604, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33322450518608093, + 0.10648208856582642, + 0.06998971104621887, + 0.08122684061527252, + 0.05125267058610916, + 0.03546856343746185, + 0.08193078637123108, + 0.05061698704957962, + 0.10310940444469452, + 0.0866984948515892 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371020406484604 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female tennis player wearing a sleeveless white blazer and matching white tennis skirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the player holding a graphite tennis racket with black and neon yellow accents behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vibrant blue hard court with the net appearing softly blurred in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1003565788269043 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503565788269043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1003565788269043, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1003565788269043, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16998356580734253, + 0.16123995184898376, + 0.09600090235471725, + 0.14722700417041779, + 0.07044112682342529, + 0.11420827358961105, + 0.08893095701932907, + 0.07118523120880127, + 0.03705688565969467, + 0.0437261201441288 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1003565788269043 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the female tennis player wearing a sleeveless white blazer and matching white tennis skirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the player holding a graphite tennis racket with black and neon yellow accents behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vibrant blue hard court with the net appearing softly blurred in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006733465939760208 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006733417510986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006733465939760208, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006733465939760208, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2940795123577118, + 0.07119715213775635, + 0.06550908833742142, + 0.3016745448112488, + 0.055082742124795914, + 0.024201124906539917, + 0.03467448428273201, + 0.09703352302312851, + 0.016827847808599472, + 0.03972001001238823 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006733465939760208 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_11/index_tensor([3228, 3228])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_11/index_tensor([3228, 3228])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7a0dd8f4eeb213e50e09c99dd6facf9ea3f30e57 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_11/index_tensor([3228, 3228])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "stunning macro close-up captures a Zen-like moment from a level perspective. At the center of the frame is a juicy, emerald green bamboo leaf, its parallel veins clearly visible. A thin film of water covers its surface, shimmering in the soft, diffused sunlight filtering through the bamboo canopy. At the very tip of the leaf, a crystal-clear, nearly perfectly spherical drop of water hangs suspended. Its surface, like a convex lens, distorts and reflects the green bamboo silhouette in the background, blurred into a soft halo (bokeh). As gravity pulls at its invisible force, the drop's shape gradually elongates, its point of connection to the leaf tip becoming increasingly thin due to surface tension. Finally, at a critical moment, the drop silently and decisively separates from the leaf tip, briefly maintaining its perfect spherical shape in mid-air before plummeting and rapidly disappearing below the camera lens. At the moment the water droplets break away, the tips of the bamboo leaves bounce upwards slightly and elastically due to the loss of weight. The whole process appears slow and poetic under the extremely magnified field of view, creating an extremely tranquil, focused and vital atmosphere. The main color is a fresh and natural cool green.", + "seed": 10882, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_11/index_3228_seed_10882_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0936057394137606, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0936057394137606, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0936057394137606, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a bamboo leaf with parallel veins visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green and covered in a thin film of water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a nearly perfectly spherical water drop hanging from the tip of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the drop elongate and separate from the leaf before falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo leaf tips bounce upwards elastically when the drop falls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007467807270586491 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.882467746734619 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007467807270586491, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007467807270586491, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10249154269695282, + 0.06775783002376556, + 0.07377918809652328, + 0.0477713942527771, + 0.2676359713077545, + 0.07728798687458038, + 0.04903058707714081, + 0.2112669050693512, + 0.061216000467538834, + 0.041762575507164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007467807270586491 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a bamboo leaf with parallel veins visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green and covered in a thin film of water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a nearly perfectly spherical water drop hanging from the tip of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the drop elongate and separate from the leaf before falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo leaf tips bounce upwards elastically when the drop falls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006768987979739904 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006769180297852 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006768987979739904, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006768987979739904, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13907881081104279, + 0.18800710141658783, + 0.16097858548164368, + 0.07067924737930298, + 0.13380703330039978, + 0.10293857008218765, + 0.08233048021793365, + 0.055277250707149506, + 0.03873031213879585, + 0.028172604739665985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006768987979739904 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a bamboo leaf with parallel veins visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green and covered in a thin film of water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a nearly perfectly spherical water drop hanging from the tip of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the drop elongate and separate from the leaf before falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo leaf tips bounce upwards elastically when the drop falls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001522811478935182 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501523017883301 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001522811478935182, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001522811478935182, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09446042776107788, + 0.10247237235307693, + 0.14030012488365173, + 0.12882274389266968, + 0.15657037496566772, + 0.19299355149269104, + 0.0691009908914566, + 0.06514348834753036, + 0.03201749548316002, + 0.01811836287379265 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001522811478935182 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a bamboo leaf with parallel veins visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green and covered in a thin film of water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a nearly perfectly spherical water drop hanging from the tip of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the drop elongate and separate from the leaf before falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo leaf tips bounce upwards elastically when the drop falls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023299021646380424 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773298978805542 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023299021646380424, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023299021646380424, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05227424204349518, + 0.024678144603967667, + 0.08459217846393585, + 0.04587254300713539, + 0.24397233128547668, + 0.20156759023666382, + 0.07344818115234375, + 0.2237059772014618, + 0.03223114088177681, + 0.017657598480582237 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023299021646380424 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a bamboo leaf with parallel veins visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green and covered in a thin film of water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a nearly perfectly spherical water drop hanging from the tip of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the drop elongate and separate from the leaf before falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo leaf tips bounce upwards elastically when the drop falls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.428970068693161 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539700984954834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.428970068693161, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.428970068693161, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08240653574466705, + 0.10493510961532593, + 0.05696484073996544, + 0.039371199905872345, + 0.10992633551359177, + 0.23025111854076385, + 0.06707858294248581, + 0.1891659051179886, + 0.06791254878044128, + 0.051987823098897934 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.428970068693161 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning macro close-up captures a Zen-like moment from a level perspective. At the center of the frame is a juicy, emerald green bamboo leaf, its parallel veins clearly visible. A thin film of water covers its surface, shimmering in the soft, diffused sunlight filtering through the bamboo canopy. At the very tip of the leaf, a crystal-clear, nearly perfectly spherical drop of water hangs suspended. Its surface, like a convex lens, distorts and reflects the green bamboo silhouette in the background, blurred into a soft halo (bokeh). As gravity pulls at its invisible force, the drop's shape gradually elongates, its point of connection to the leaf tip becoming increasingly thin due to surface tension. Finally, at a critical moment, the drop silently and decisively separates from the leaf tip, briefly maintaining its perfect spherical shape in mid-air before plummeting and rapidly disappearing below the camera lens. At the moment the water droplets break away, the tips of the bamboo leaves bounce upwards slightly and elastically due to the loss of weight. The whole process appears slow and poetic under the extremely magnified field of view, creating an extremely tranquil, focused and vital atmosphere. The main color is a fresh and natural cool green.", + "seed": 10883, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_11/index_3228_seed_10883_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.16571112596429885, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16571112596429885, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16571112596429885, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a bamboo leaf with parallel veins visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green and covered in a thin film of water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a nearly perfectly spherical water drop hanging from the tip of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the drop elongate and separate from the leaf before falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo leaf tips bounce upwards elastically when the drop falls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0038378408644348383 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.628838062286377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0038378408644348383, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0038378408644348383, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14782948791980743, + 0.14757749438285828, + 0.0950392335653305, + 0.15312416851520538, + 0.08288425207138062, + 0.06851804256439209, + 0.11916185170412064, + 0.05272417142987251, + 0.06213446706533432, + 0.07100680470466614 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0038378408644348383 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a bamboo leaf with parallel veins visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green and covered in a thin film of water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a nearly perfectly spherical water drop hanging from the tip of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the drop elongate and separate from the leaf before falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo leaf tips bounce upwards elastically when the drop falls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016099924221634865 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14109992980957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016099924221634865, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016099924221634865, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22022005915641785, + 0.09343444555997849, + 0.08638239651918411, + 0.31175467371940613, + 0.038469213992357254, + 0.03046424873173237, + 0.049856752157211304, + 0.03862117603421211, + 0.06698392331600189, + 0.06381307542324066 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016099924221634865 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a bamboo leaf with parallel veins visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green and covered in a thin film of water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a nearly perfectly spherical water drop hanging from the tip of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the drop elongate and separate from the leaf before falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo leaf tips bounce upwards elastically when the drop falls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006748740561306477 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006748676300049 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006748740561306477, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006748740561306477, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06830712407827377, + 0.08874358236789703, + 0.05642612278461456, + 0.4569287896156311, + 0.10601906478404999, + 0.042757876217365265, + 0.07581133395433426, + 0.02948462776839733, + 0.03976834565401077, + 0.03575311601161957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006748740561306477 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a bamboo leaf with parallel veins visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green and covered in a thin film of water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a nearly perfectly spherical water drop hanging from the tip of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the drop elongate and separate from the leaf before falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo leaf tips bounce upwards elastically when the drop falls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5762225389480591 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8262225389480591 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5762225389480591, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5762225389480591, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08225546032190323, + 0.1029173731803894, + 0.04769910126924515, + 0.3139006495475769, + 0.2096329778432846, + 0.0832359790802002, + 0.03361102566123009, + 0.028227074071764946, + 0.05838252976536751, + 0.040137894451618195 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5762225389480591 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a bamboo leaf with parallel veins visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green and covered in a thin film of water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a nearly perfectly spherical water drop hanging from the tip of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the drop elongate and separate from the leaf before falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo leaf tips bounce upwards elastically when the drop falls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22564658522605896 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006466150283813 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22564658522605896, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22564658522605896, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14624479413032532, + 0.09692122042179108, + 0.09861951321363449, + 0.12944284081459045, + 0.1678549200296402, + 0.10361392050981522, + 0.05030486360192299, + 0.048063259571790695, + 0.107931949198246, + 0.05100272223353386 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22564658522605896 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning macro close-up captures a Zen-like moment from a level perspective. At the center of the frame is a juicy, emerald green bamboo leaf, its parallel veins clearly visible. A thin film of water covers its surface, shimmering in the soft, diffused sunlight filtering through the bamboo canopy. At the very tip of the leaf, a crystal-clear, nearly perfectly spherical drop of water hangs suspended. Its surface, like a convex lens, distorts and reflects the green bamboo silhouette in the background, blurred into a soft halo (bokeh). As gravity pulls at its invisible force, the drop's shape gradually elongates, its point of connection to the leaf tip becoming increasingly thin due to surface tension. Finally, at a critical moment, the drop silently and decisively separates from the leaf tip, briefly maintaining its perfect spherical shape in mid-air before plummeting and rapidly disappearing below the camera lens. At the moment the water droplets break away, the tips of the bamboo leaves bounce upwards slightly and elastically due to the loss of weight. The whole process appears slow and poetic under the extremely magnified field of view, creating an extremely tranquil, focused and vital atmosphere. The main color is a fresh and natural cool green.", + "seed": 10884, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_11/index_3228_seed_10884_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.054665856342762706, + "vlm_logprob": -0.054665856342762706, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.054665856342762706, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a bamboo leaf with parallel veins visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green and covered in a thin film of water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a nearly perfectly spherical water drop hanging from the tip of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the drop elongate and separate from the leaf before falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo leaf tips bounce upwards elastically when the drop falls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004532658960670233 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.629532814025879 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004532658960670233, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004532658960670233, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2177305370569229, + 0.12441163510084152, + 0.06187091022729874, + 0.04036256670951843, + 0.13680897653102875, + 0.12814484536647797, + 0.07044556736946106, + 0.07785362005233765, + 0.07193778455257416, + 0.0704336166381836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004532658960670233 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a bamboo leaf with parallel veins visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green and covered in a thin film of water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a nearly perfectly spherical water drop hanging from the tip of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the drop elongate and separate from the leaf before falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo leaf tips bounce upwards elastically when the drop falls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014222566038370132 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264222621917725 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014222566038370132, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014222566038370132, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18496361374855042, + 0.052616097033023834, + 0.06457671523094177, + 0.03601833060383797, + 0.3548646867275238, + 0.07173676043748856, + 0.08227843791246414, + 0.04254874959588051, + 0.04503635689616203, + 0.06536020338535309 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014222566038370132 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a bamboo leaf with parallel veins visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green and covered in a thin film of water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a nearly perfectly spherical water drop hanging from the tip of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the drop elongate and separate from the leaf before falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo leaf tips bounce upwards elastically when the drop falls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004645507782697678 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379645347595215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004645507782697678, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004645507782697678, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13824209570884705, + 0.04856608062982559, + 0.07672397047281265, + 0.04147178307175636, + 0.17385254800319672, + 0.299212247133255, + 0.09310168027877808, + 0.06327255070209503, + 0.03661707788705826, + 0.028940025717020035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004645507782697678 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a bamboo leaf with parallel veins visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green and covered in a thin film of water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a nearly perfectly spherical water drop hanging from the tip of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the drop elongate and separate from the leaf before falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo leaf tips bounce upwards elastically when the drop falls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07001848518848419 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950185298919678 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07001848518848419, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07001848518848419, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2020968794822693, + 0.04623018577694893, + 0.06957025080919266, + 0.03983045741915703, + 0.17720675468444824, + 0.09722058475017548, + 0.2412990927696228, + 0.05531340464949608, + 0.026995034888386726, + 0.04423733800649643 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07001848518848419 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a bamboo leaf with parallel veins visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green and covered in a thin film of water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a nearly perfectly spherical water drop hanging from the tip of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the drop elongate and separate from the leaf before falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo leaf tips bounce upwards elastically when the drop falls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1799100637435913 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049100637435913 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1799100637435913, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1799100637435913, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16573594510555267, + 0.06322374939918518, + 0.07812096923589706, + 0.0599190816283226, + 0.14190788567066193, + 0.24463680386543274, + 0.0790652260184288, + 0.04492952674627304, + 0.04068142548203468, + 0.08177933841943741 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1799100637435913 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning macro close-up captures a Zen-like moment from a level perspective. At the center of the frame is a juicy, emerald green bamboo leaf, its parallel veins clearly visible. A thin film of water covers its surface, shimmering in the soft, diffused sunlight filtering through the bamboo canopy. At the very tip of the leaf, a crystal-clear, nearly perfectly spherical drop of water hangs suspended. Its surface, like a convex lens, distorts and reflects the green bamboo silhouette in the background, blurred into a soft halo (bokeh). As gravity pulls at its invisible force, the drop's shape gradually elongates, its point of connection to the leaf tip becoming increasingly thin due to surface tension. Finally, at a critical moment, the drop silently and decisively separates from the leaf tip, briefly maintaining its perfect spherical shape in mid-air before plummeting and rapidly disappearing below the camera lens. At the moment the water droplets break away, the tips of the bamboo leaves bounce upwards slightly and elastically due to the loss of weight. The whole process appears slow and poetic under the extremely magnified field of view, creating an extremely tranquil, focused and vital atmosphere. The main color is a fresh and natural cool green.", + "seed": 10885, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_11/index_3228_seed_10885_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07705336431972683, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07705336431972683, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07705336431972683, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a bamboo leaf with parallel veins visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green and covered in a thin film of water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a nearly perfectly spherical water drop hanging from the tip of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the drop elongate and separate from the leaf before falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo leaf tips bounce upwards elastically when the drop falls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004444008227437735 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.254444122314453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004444008227437735, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004444008227437735, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2466127574443817, + 0.14438758790493011, + 0.08957879990339279, + 0.227371945977211, + 0.04963144287467003, + 0.038681771606206894, + 0.05128023400902748, + 0.05990543216466904, + 0.07107603549957275, + 0.02147393301129341 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004444008227437735 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a bamboo leaf with parallel veins visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green and covered in a thin film of water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a nearly perfectly spherical water drop hanging from the tip of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the drop elongate and separate from the leaf before falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo leaf tips bounce upwards elastically when the drop falls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006767448503524065 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006767272949219 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006767448503524065, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006767448503524065, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28160905838012695, + 0.2819755971431732, + 0.09963705390691757, + 0.10113390535116196, + 0.03637833893299103, + 0.03922891989350319, + 0.032033927738666534, + 0.08175957202911377, + 0.029990511015057564, + 0.016253124922513962 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006767448503524065 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a bamboo leaf with parallel veins visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green and covered in a thin film of water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a nearly perfectly spherical water drop hanging from the tip of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the drop elongate and separate from the leaf before falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo leaf tips bounce upwards elastically when the drop falls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003628814360126853 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628628730773926 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003628814360126853, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003628814360126853, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1478744000196457, + 0.2285723239183426, + 0.0986778736114502, + 0.05474269017577171, + 0.17401622235774994, + 0.06378697603940964, + 0.06282562762498856, + 0.07759403437376022, + 0.021179091185331345, + 0.0707307681441307 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003628814360126853 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a bamboo leaf with parallel veins visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green and covered in a thin film of water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a nearly perfectly spherical water drop hanging from the tip of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the drop elongate and separate from the leaf before falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo leaf tips bounce upwards elastically when the drop falls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890500396490097 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464050054550171 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0890500396490097, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0890500396490097, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14541205763816833, + 0.17243140935897827, + 0.028080405667424202, + 0.07992856949567795, + 0.05431557446718216, + 0.10183209180831909, + 0.12391848862171173, + 0.11662311106920242, + 0.01937154494225979, + 0.15808679163455963 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0890500396490097 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a bamboo leaf with parallel veins visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green and covered in a thin film of water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a nearly perfectly spherical water drop hanging from the tip of the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the drop elongate and separate from the leaf before falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the bamboo leaf tips bounce upwards elastically when the drop falls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28137651085853577 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063764810562134 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28137651085853577, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28137651085853577, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1270599216222763, + 0.06157710403203964, + 0.10293716192245483, + 0.3282195031642914, + 0.04546727240085602, + 0.05473703891038895, + 0.09863738715648651, + 0.039798710495233536, + 0.06019460782408714, + 0.08137131482362747 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28137651085853577 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_12/index_tensor([9552, 9552])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_12/index_tensor([9552, 9552])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d85d5e6166798cf7d91a46fb42c90c2f4edf9962 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_12/index_tensor([9552, 9552])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "steady, eye-level tracking shot follows a solitary figure, a young woman with wavy, shoulder-length brown hair, as she walks along a restored cobblestone path perfectly centered in the frame. She wears a simple, pale yellow, knee-length sundress, a small brown leather bag slung over her shoulder, and her expression is one of calm contentment. The camera maintains a steady pace, following her unhurried, graceful gait. The scene is set in a historic neighborhood lined with old, beautifully maintained wooden buildings with terracotta roofs. These buildings now house new shops adorned with charming hand-painted signs and vibrant flower boxes overflowing with colorful morning glories and geraniums. The entire scene is depicted in a lush Studio Ghibli style, bathed in the soft, warm glow of afternoon sunlight, creating a painterly effect on the rich textures of the stone and wood. It is a peaceful atmosphere of harmonious renewal, as the gentle play of light and saturated, natural color palette evokes a profound sense of tranquility and whimsical charm.", + "seed": 17146, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_12/index_9552_seed_17146_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03603182137012482, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03603182137012482, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.999999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03603182137012482, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with wavy, shoulder-length brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale yellow, knee-length sundress with a small brown leather bag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a restored cobblestone path lined with old wooden buildings and terracotta roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings adorned with hand-painted signs and flower boxes containing morning glories and geraniums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, eye-level tracking shot that keeps the woman perfectly centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009136416018009186 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.759136199951172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009136416018009186, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009136416018009186, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10639084130525589, + 0.3131849765777588, + 0.025894658640027046, + 0.1086505800485611, + 0.050208188593387604, + 0.011969500221312046, + 0.055014416575431824, + 0.06842900812625885, + 0.17034979164600372, + 0.08990801125764847 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009136416018009186 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with wavy, shoulder-length brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale yellow, knee-length sundress with a small brown leather bag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a restored cobblestone path lined with old wooden buildings and terracotta roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings adorned with hand-painted signs and flower boxes containing morning glories and geraniums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, eye-level tracking shot that keeps the woman perfectly centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004649067297577858 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.3796491622924805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004649067297577858, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004649067297577858, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09327267855405807, + 0.5580441951751709, + 0.014864626340568066, + 0.05719412490725517, + 0.018237849697470665, + 0.010179531760513783, + 0.03305995091795921, + 0.048050276935100555, + 0.1079133003950119, + 0.05918349325656891 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004649067297577858 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with wavy, shoulder-length brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale yellow, knee-length sundress with a small brown leather bag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a restored cobblestone path lined with old wooden buildings and terracotta roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings adorned with hand-painted signs and flower boxes containing morning glories and geraniums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, eye-level tracking shot that keeps the woman perfectly centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016062619164586067 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410627365112305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016062619164586067, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016062619164586067, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15653511881828308, + 0.31644895672798157, + 0.01531270332634449, + 0.16580648720264435, + 0.02777898870408535, + 0.009381254203617573, + 0.027628319337964058, + 0.03832812234759331, + 0.04682060331106186, + 0.1959594190120697 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016062619164586067 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with wavy, shoulder-length brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale yellow, knee-length sundress with a small brown leather bag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a restored cobblestone path lined with old wooden buildings and terracotta roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings adorned with hand-painted signs and flower boxes containing morning glories and geraniums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, eye-level tracking shot that keeps the woman perfectly centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023298438638448715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773298501968384 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023298438638448715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023298438638448715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1508990079164505, + 0.3198269307613373, + 0.024925123900175095, + 0.07570667564868927, + 0.024571040645241737, + 0.012694349512457848, + 0.08605223149061203, + 0.06067492440342903, + 0.07764308154582977, + 0.16700661182403564 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023298438638448715 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with wavy, shoulder-length brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale yellow, knee-length sundress with a small brown leather bag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a restored cobblestone path lined with old wooden buildings and terracotta roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings adorned with hand-painted signs and flower boxes containing morning glories and geraniums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, eye-level tracking shot that keeps the woman perfectly centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12701256573200226 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270124912261963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12701256573200226, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12701256573200226, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06356891989707947, + 0.2678528428077698, + 0.01964023895561695, + 0.14384879171848297, + 0.022388948127627373, + 0.01741902157664299, + 0.06507226079702377, + 0.038158200681209564, + 0.21009880304336548, + 0.15195195376873016 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12701256573200226 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "steady, eye-level tracking shot follows a solitary figure, a young woman with wavy, shoulder-length brown hair, as she walks along a restored cobblestone path perfectly centered in the frame. She wears a simple, pale yellow, knee-length sundress, a small brown leather bag slung over her shoulder, and her expression is one of calm contentment. The camera maintains a steady pace, following her unhurried, graceful gait. The scene is set in a historic neighborhood lined with old, beautifully maintained wooden buildings with terracotta roofs. These buildings now house new shops adorned with charming hand-painted signs and vibrant flower boxes overflowing with colorful morning glories and geraniums. The entire scene is depicted in a lush Studio Ghibli style, bathed in the soft, warm glow of afternoon sunlight, creating a painterly effect on the rich textures of the stone and wood. It is a peaceful atmosphere of harmonious renewal, as the gentle play of light and saturated, natural color palette evokes a profound sense of tranquility and whimsical charm.", + "seed": 17147, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_12/index_9552_seed_17147_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.1177470425143838, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1177470425143838, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1177470425143838, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with wavy, shoulder-length brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale yellow, knee-length sundress with a small brown leather bag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a restored cobblestone path lined with old wooden buildings and terracotta roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings adorned with hand-painted signs and flower boxes containing morning glories and geraniums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, eye-level tracking shot that keeps the woman perfectly centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02372646890580654 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773726463317871 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02372646890580654, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02372646890580654, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1615656465291977, + 0.03681448847055435, + 0.13640935719013214, + 0.08855646103620529, + 0.043613649904727936, + 0.022038640454411507, + 0.4013616144657135, + 0.02352324314415455, + 0.060754626989364624, + 0.02536221407353878 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02372646890580654 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with wavy, shoulder-length brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale yellow, knee-length sundress with a small brown leather bag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a restored cobblestone path lined with old wooden buildings and terracotta roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings adorned with hand-painted signs and flower boxes containing morning glories and geraniums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, eye-level tracking shot that keeps the woman perfectly centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00864903163164854 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758648872375488 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00864903163164854, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00864903163164854, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1796986609697342, + 0.02611461468040943, + 0.09944018721580505, + 0.14176855981349945, + 0.04151130095124245, + 0.023377489298582077, + 0.17083889245986938, + 0.13989003002643585, + 0.13751289248466492, + 0.03984740003943443 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00864903163164854 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with wavy, shoulder-length brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale yellow, knee-length sundress with a small brown leather bag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a restored cobblestone path lined with old wooden buildings and terracotta roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings adorned with hand-painted signs and flower boxes containing morning glories and geraniums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, eye-level tracking shot that keeps the woman perfectly centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006731215864419937 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006731033325195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006731215864419937, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006731215864419937, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1474532037973404, + 0.06972584873437881, + 0.19463121891021729, + 0.12425485998392105, + 0.06685597449541092, + 0.019646884873509407, + 0.16041117906570435, + 0.04434458166360855, + 0.13937057554721832, + 0.033305633813142776 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006731215864419937 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with wavy, shoulder-length brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale yellow, knee-length sundress with a small brown leather bag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a restored cobblestone path lined with old wooden buildings and terracotta roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings adorned with hand-painted signs and flower boxes containing morning glories and geraniums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, eye-level tracking shot that keeps the woman perfectly centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026354670524597168 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513547897338867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026354670524597168, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026354670524597168, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12715357542037964, + 0.032967839390039444, + 0.06996727734804153, + 0.4254772663116455, + 0.03297105431556702, + 0.027351707220077515, + 0.11030735075473785, + 0.045170001685619354, + 0.10907379537820816, + 0.019560087472200394 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026354670524597168 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with wavy, shoulder-length brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale yellow, knee-length sundress with a small brown leather bag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a restored cobblestone path lined with old wooden buildings and terracotta roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings adorned with hand-painted signs and flower boxes containing morning glories and geraniums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, eye-level tracking shot that keeps the woman perfectly centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5232738256454468 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8982738256454468 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5232738256454468, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5232738256454468, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11118367314338684, + 0.05663608759641647, + 0.21408183872699738, + 0.2702646553516388, + 0.03595665469765663, + 0.012364364229142666, + 0.07189711183309555, + 0.03806685283780098, + 0.11021769791841507, + 0.07933107018470764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5232738256454468 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "steady, eye-level tracking shot follows a solitary figure, a young woman with wavy, shoulder-length brown hair, as she walks along a restored cobblestone path perfectly centered in the frame. She wears a simple, pale yellow, knee-length sundress, a small brown leather bag slung over her shoulder, and her expression is one of calm contentment. The camera maintains a steady pace, following her unhurried, graceful gait. The scene is set in a historic neighborhood lined with old, beautifully maintained wooden buildings with terracotta roofs. These buildings now house new shops adorned with charming hand-painted signs and vibrant flower boxes overflowing with colorful morning glories and geraniums. The entire scene is depicted in a lush Studio Ghibli style, bathed in the soft, warm glow of afternoon sunlight, creating a painterly effect on the rich textures of the stone and wood. It is a peaceful atmosphere of harmonious renewal, as the gentle play of light and saturated, natural color palette evokes a profound sense of tranquility and whimsical charm.", + "seed": 17148, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_12/index_9552_seed_17148_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.01705031581223011, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01705031581223011, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01705031581223011, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with wavy, shoulder-length brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale yellow, knee-length sundress with a small brown leather bag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a restored cobblestone path lined with old wooden buildings and terracotta roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings adorned with hand-painted signs and flower boxes containing morning glories and geraniums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, eye-level tracking shot that keeps the woman perfectly centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007812066003680229 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882812023162842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007812066003680229, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007812066003680229, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13653965294361115, + 0.2029259204864502, + 0.05495430901646614, + 0.13319408893585205, + 0.0426408126950264, + 0.05869457498192787, + 0.08311519771814346, + 0.0962231382727623, + 0.17158745229244232, + 0.02012493461370468 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007812066003680229 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with wavy, shoulder-length brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale yellow, knee-length sundress with a small brown leather bag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a restored cobblestone path lined with old wooden buildings and terracotta roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings adorned with hand-painted signs and flower boxes containing morning glories and geraniums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, eye-level tracking shot that keeps the woman perfectly centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004102030768990517 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5041022300720215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004102030768990517, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004102030768990517, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10909031331539154, + 0.2041090726852417, + 0.07258352637290955, + 0.03334683179855347, + 0.05319027975201607, + 0.025730838999152184, + 0.29238373041152954, + 0.14029133319854736, + 0.05302334204316139, + 0.016250725835561752 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004102030768990517 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with wavy, shoulder-length brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale yellow, knee-length sundress with a small brown leather bag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a restored cobblestone path lined with old wooden buildings and terracotta roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings adorned with hand-painted signs and flower boxes containing morning glories and geraniums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, eye-level tracking shot that keeps the woman perfectly centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00863177701830864 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758631706237793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00863177701830864, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00863177701830864, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.208672434091568, + 0.15744048357009888, + 0.09212099015712738, + 0.07712721824645996, + 0.04877251386642456, + 0.08625645935535431, + 0.17499814927577972, + 0.08621710538864136, + 0.05339161306619644, + 0.015003086067736149 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00863177701830864 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with wavy, shoulder-length brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale yellow, knee-length sundress with a small brown leather bag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a restored cobblestone path lined with old wooden buildings and terracotta roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings adorned with hand-painted signs and flower boxes containing morning glories and geraniums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, eye-level tracking shot that keeps the woman perfectly centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607341133058071 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141073226928711 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607341133058071, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607341133058071, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17681321501731873, + 0.2873898446559906, + 0.05145857110619545, + 0.07704722136259079, + 0.04364015907049179, + 0.05571725592017174, + 0.07698927819728851, + 0.10828429460525513, + 0.061920277774333954, + 0.06073998287320137 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607341133058071 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with wavy, shoulder-length brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale yellow, knee-length sundress with a small brown leather bag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a restored cobblestone path lined with old wooden buildings and terracotta roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings adorned with hand-painted signs and flower boxes containing morning glories and geraniums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, eye-level tracking shot that keeps the woman perfectly centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048632293939590454 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486323833465576 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048632293939590454, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048632293939590454, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08077942579984665, + 0.3982096314430237, + 0.05445128679275513, + 0.0382189005613327, + 0.03679743781685829, + 0.04225534945726395, + 0.11547905951738358, + 0.06495214253664017, + 0.13744080066680908, + 0.03141595795750618 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048632293939590454 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "steady, eye-level tracking shot follows a solitary figure, a young woman with wavy, shoulder-length brown hair, as she walks along a restored cobblestone path perfectly centered in the frame. She wears a simple, pale yellow, knee-length sundress, a small brown leather bag slung over her shoulder, and her expression is one of calm contentment. The camera maintains a steady pace, following her unhurried, graceful gait. The scene is set in a historic neighborhood lined with old, beautifully maintained wooden buildings with terracotta roofs. These buildings now house new shops adorned with charming hand-painted signs and vibrant flower boxes overflowing with colorful morning glories and geraniums. The entire scene is depicted in a lush Studio Ghibli style, bathed in the soft, warm glow of afternoon sunlight, creating a painterly effect on the rich textures of the stone and wood. It is a peaceful atmosphere of harmonious renewal, as the gentle play of light and saturated, natural color palette evokes a profound sense of tranquility and whimsical charm.", + "seed": 17149, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_12/index_9552_seed_17149_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0814478407613933, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0814478407613933, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.674999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0814478407613933, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with wavy, shoulder-length brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale yellow, knee-length sundress with a small brown leather bag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a restored cobblestone path lined with old wooden buildings and terracotta roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings adorned with hand-painted signs and flower boxes containing morning glories and geraniums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, eye-level tracking shot that keeps the woman perfectly centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02097076177597046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8959708213806152 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02097076177597046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02097076177597046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04561832547187805, + 0.024650447070598602, + 0.2535569667816162, + 0.1052703782916069, + 0.020583325996994972, + 0.1489715278148651, + 0.07386824488639832, + 0.11926611512899399, + 0.10380290448665619, + 0.10441170632839203 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02097076177597046 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with wavy, shoulder-length brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale yellow, knee-length sundress with a small brown leather bag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a restored cobblestone path lined with old wooden buildings and terracotta roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings adorned with hand-painted signs and flower boxes containing morning glories and geraniums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, eye-level tracking shot that keeps the woman perfectly centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006751345470547676 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006751537322998 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006751345470547676, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006751345470547676, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04444798082113266, + 0.020830612629652023, + 0.098333939909935, + 0.0533592626452446, + 0.014942079782485962, + 0.041289523243904114, + 0.060202792286872864, + 0.08788280934095383, + 0.03629706799983978, + 0.5424139499664307 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006751345470547676 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with wavy, shoulder-length brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale yellow, knee-length sundress with a small brown leather bag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a restored cobblestone path lined with old wooden buildings and terracotta roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings adorned with hand-painted signs and flower boxes containing morning glories and geraniums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, eye-level tracking shot that keeps the woman perfectly centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076261102221906185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882626056671143 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076261102221906185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076261102221906185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06898658722639084, + 0.04949972406029701, + 0.11160381883382797, + 0.05212176963686943, + 0.03977350518107414, + 0.14998048543930054, + 0.03709962218999863, + 0.023618649691343307, + 0.2028440684080124, + 0.26447170972824097 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076261102221906185 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with wavy, shoulder-length brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale yellow, knee-length sundress with a small brown leather bag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a restored cobblestone path lined with old wooden buildings and terracotta roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings adorned with hand-painted signs and flower boxes containing morning glories and geraniums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, eye-level tracking shot that keeps the woman perfectly centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023299837484955788 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732999324798584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023299837484955788, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023299837484955788, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06801141798496246, + 0.053717754781246185, + 0.08844102919101715, + 0.04932563379406929, + 0.04218272119760513, + 0.14635778963565826, + 0.04744572192430496, + 0.06301739811897278, + 0.17965683341026306, + 0.2618437111377716 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023299837484955788 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with wavy, shoulder-length brown hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale yellow, knee-length sundress with a small brown leather bag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a restored cobblestone path lined with old wooden buildings and terracotta roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings adorned with hand-painted signs and flower boxes containing morning glories and geraniums?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a steady, eye-level tracking shot that keeps the woman perfectly centered in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.348591148853302 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2235910892486572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.348591148853302, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8749999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.348591148853302, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.039558157324790955, + 0.01629563793540001, + 0.12772783637046814, + 0.1010325700044632, + 0.01690390706062317, + 0.1288023293018341, + 0.07269428670406342, + 0.024527249857783318, + 0.10051248222589493, + 0.37194564938545227 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.348591148853302 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_13/index_tensor([876, 876])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_13/index_tensor([876, 876])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fd255cc7e4c99784b1353fc40edc6cdfebf56d27 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_13/index_tensor([876, 876])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a scene imbued with the gentle aesthetic of a Ghibli animation, a static close-up shot from a slightly overhead angle initially focuses on a single emerald green leaf floating serenely on the surface of clear water. The leaf's surface is covered in a velvety, downy velvet that shimmers in the soft light, its veins clearly visible. Then, an invisible force slowly and calmly pulls the leaf downward, its edges gracefully plunging into the water. The surface tension breaks, and clear liquid slowly soaks the fuzzy surface. As the leaf steadily and relentlessly sinks into the murky depths, the camera's focus seamlessly shifts downward, transitioning from the initially clear surface to the profound, mysterious underwater world. As soft sunlight penetrates the rippling water, fleeting, dreamy flickers of light appear across the lens, like shattered stars. Light beams cast swaying paths across the darkening azure water, illuminating suspended particles and creating an atmosphere of tranquility, depth, and a sense of wonder.", + "seed": 5366, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_13/index_876_seed_5366_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03483303007669747, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03483303007669747, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03483303007669747, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli animation aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green with visible veins and a velvety, downy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sink into murky depths while the camera focus shifts downward to reveal an underwater world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are soft sunlight beams and suspended particles visible in the darkening azure water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1460571587085724 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.02105712890625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1460571587085724, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1460571587085724, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1518619805574417, + 0.09360063821077347, + 0.05871879309415817, + 0.11771034449338913, + 0.2614215612411499, + 0.07691705226898193, + 0.06198396906256676, + 0.049553535878658295, + 0.05967681109905243, + 0.0685553029179573 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1460571587085724 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli animation aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green with visible veins and a velvety, downy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sink into murky depths while the camera focus shifts downward to reveal an underwater world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are soft sunlight beams and suspended particles visible in the darkening azure water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008654349483549595 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586541175842285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008654349483549595, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008654349483549595, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05896869674324989, + 0.08004105091094971, + 0.2980474531650543, + 0.06441791355609894, + 0.13325797021389008, + 0.18306973576545715, + 0.02823784574866295, + 0.05372441187500954, + 0.06625953316688538, + 0.03397538512945175 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008654349483549595 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli animation aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green with visible veins and a velvety, downy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sink into murky depths while the camera focus shifts downward to reveal an underwater world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are soft sunlight beams and suspended particles visible in the darkening azure water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007631433662027121 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882631301879883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007631433662027121, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007631433662027121, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1580299586057663, + 0.08155127614736557, + 0.11683620512485504, + 0.2355443686246872, + 0.05569681152701378, + 0.07853274047374725, + 0.028020231053233147, + 0.11298034340143204, + 0.0442102774977684, + 0.08859781920909882 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007631433662027121 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli animation aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green with visible veins and a velvety, downy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sink into murky depths while the camera focus shifts downward to reveal an underwater world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are soft sunlight beams and suspended particles visible in the darkening azure water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031909046228975058 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753190994262695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031909046228975058, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031909046228975058, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.059477295726537704, + 0.08094367384910583, + 0.0419108048081398, + 0.07079222798347473, + 0.1540287286043167, + 0.10746835917234421, + 0.04704143479466438, + 0.08351718634366989, + 0.08941445499658585, + 0.2654058635234833 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031909046228975058 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli animation aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green with visible veins and a velvety, downy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sink into murky depths while the camera focus shifts downward to reveal an underwater world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are soft sunlight beams and suspended particles visible in the darkening azure water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008631303906440735 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758631229400635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008631303906440735, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008631303906440735, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.040868017822504044, + 0.15055543184280396, + 0.03772826865315437, + 0.02901221625506878, + 0.024937663227319717, + 0.06266041845083237, + 0.062006667256355286, + 0.3526555001735687, + 0.05265040695667267, + 0.18692541122436523 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008631303906440735 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a scene imbued with the gentle aesthetic of a Ghibli animation, a static close-up shot from a slightly overhead angle initially focuses on a single emerald green leaf floating serenely on the surface of clear water. The leaf's surface is covered in a velvety, downy velvet that shimmers in the soft light, its veins clearly visible. Then, an invisible force slowly and calmly pulls the leaf downward, its edges gracefully plunging into the water. The surface tension breaks, and clear liquid slowly soaks the fuzzy surface. As the leaf steadily and relentlessly sinks into the murky depths, the camera's focus seamlessly shifts downward, transitioning from the initially clear surface to the profound, mysterious underwater world. As soft sunlight penetrates the rippling water, fleeting, dreamy flickers of light appear across the lens, like shattered stars. Light beams cast swaying paths across the darkening azure water, illuminating suspended particles and creating an atmosphere of tranquility, depth, and a sense of wonder.", + "seed": 5367, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_13/index_876_seed_5367_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06904819160699845, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06904819160699845, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06904819160699845, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli animation aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green with visible veins and a velvety, downy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sink into murky depths while the camera focus shifts downward to reveal an underwater world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are soft sunlight beams and suspended particles visible in the darkening azure water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3176615238189697 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3176615238189697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3176615238189697, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3176615238189697, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08484179526567459, + 0.2235206961631775, + 0.05231013894081116, + 0.07683172821998596, + 0.2635824680328369, + 0.017014669254422188, + 0.031307365745306015, + 0.11887743324041367, + 0.08351974189281464, + 0.04819400608539581 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3176615238189697 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli animation aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green with visible veins and a velvety, downy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sink into murky depths while the camera focus shifts downward to reveal an underwater world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are soft sunlight beams and suspended particles visible in the darkening azure water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005964931100606918 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130964756011963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005964931100606918, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005964931100606918, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061580583453178406, + 0.6447868943214417, + 0.03829696774482727, + 0.014484885148704052, + 0.1356583833694458, + 0.024942979216575623, + 0.03347655013203621, + 0.011979794129729271, + 0.02700613997876644, + 0.007786794565618038 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005964931100606918 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli animation aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green with visible veins and a velvety, downy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sink into murky depths while the camera focus shifts downward to reveal an underwater world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are soft sunlight beams and suspended particles visible in the darkening azure water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008644777350127697 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586445808410645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008644777350127697, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008644777350127697, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04626695439219475, + 0.47741782665252686, + 0.05094636604189873, + 0.030208773910999298, + 0.17329616844654083, + 0.018664663657546043, + 0.07172663509845734, + 0.03021671622991562, + 0.06474120169878006, + 0.03651459887623787 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008644777350127697 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli animation aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green with visible veins and a velvety, downy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sink into murky depths while the camera focus shifts downward to reveal an underwater world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are soft sunlight beams and suspended particles visible in the darkening azure water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031925681978464127 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.75319242477417 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031925681978464127, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031925681978464127, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03919830173254013, + 0.27850642800331116, + 0.041722219437360764, + 0.02968275174498558, + 0.2652483582496643, + 0.034286778420209885, + 0.0332120917737484, + 0.09466221183538437, + 0.0967898815870285, + 0.0866909921169281 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031925681978464127 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli animation aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green with visible veins and a velvety, downy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sink into murky depths while the camera focus shifts downward to reveal an underwater world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are soft sunlight beams and suspended particles visible in the darkening azure water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009777157567441463 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634777069091797 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009777157567441463, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009777157567441463, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.025857780128717422, + 0.38991686701774597, + 0.045012038201093674, + 0.024789055809378624, + 0.2551315426826477, + 0.02163240872323513, + 0.05488186329603195, + 0.060683950781822205, + 0.07689575105905533, + 0.045198630541563034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009777157567441463 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a scene imbued with the gentle aesthetic of a Ghibli animation, a static close-up shot from a slightly overhead angle initially focuses on a single emerald green leaf floating serenely on the surface of clear water. The leaf's surface is covered in a velvety, downy velvet that shimmers in the soft light, its veins clearly visible. Then, an invisible force slowly and calmly pulls the leaf downward, its edges gracefully plunging into the water. The surface tension breaks, and clear liquid slowly soaks the fuzzy surface. As the leaf steadily and relentlessly sinks into the murky depths, the camera's focus seamlessly shifts downward, transitioning from the initially clear surface to the profound, mysterious underwater world. As soft sunlight penetrates the rippling water, fleeting, dreamy flickers of light appear across the lens, like shattered stars. Light beams cast swaying paths across the darkening azure water, illuminating suspended particles and creating an atmosphere of tranquility, depth, and a sense of wonder.", + "seed": 5368, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_13/index_876_seed_5368_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03959009861573577, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03959009861573577, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03959009861573577, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli animation aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green with visible veins and a velvety, downy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sink into murky depths while the camera focus shifts downward to reveal an underwater world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are soft sunlight beams and suspended particles visible in the darkening azure water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14699678122997284 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0219967365264893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14699678122997284, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14699678122997284, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09016004949808121, + 0.04061472788453102, + 0.1408883035182953, + 0.020637277513742447, + 0.060444723814725876, + 0.03988567739725113, + 0.12511397898197174, + 0.03168138116598129, + 0.32063907384872437, + 0.12993478775024414 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14699678122997284 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli animation aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green with visible veins and a velvety, downy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sink into murky depths while the camera focus shifts downward to reveal an underwater world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are soft sunlight beams and suspended particles visible in the darkening azure water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012557720765471458 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387557506561279 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012557720765471458, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012557720765471458, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1605316400527954, + 0.13806943595409393, + 0.05517760291695595, + 0.02418820746243, + 0.04795438423752785, + 0.0264951940625906, + 0.01851920783519745, + 0.03316415473818779, + 0.29709911346435547, + 0.19880107045173645 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012557720765471458 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli animation aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green with visible veins and a velvety, downy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sink into murky depths while the camera focus shifts downward to reveal an underwater world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are soft sunlight beams and suspended particles visible in the darkening azure water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011087356135249138 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511087417602539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011087356135249138, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011087356135249138, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08401179313659668, + 0.03578808903694153, + 0.04210551455616951, + 0.02991105429828167, + 0.04479527100920677, + 0.024836769327521324, + 0.12983624637126923, + 0.07238452881574631, + 0.4152279198169708, + 0.12110286951065063 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011087356135249138 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli animation aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green with visible veins and a velvety, downy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sink into murky depths while the camera focus shifts downward to reveal an underwater world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are soft sunlight beams and suspended particles visible in the darkening azure water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057623490691185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895576238632202 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057623490691185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057623490691185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06663407385349274, + 0.019333217293024063, + 0.02137051150202751, + 0.0158992949873209, + 0.016703370958566666, + 0.015636416152119637, + 0.0217440165579319, + 0.04249151423573494, + 0.4530237019062042, + 0.32716384530067444 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057623490691185 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli animation aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green with visible veins and a velvety, downy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sink into murky depths while the camera focus shifts downward to reveal an underwater world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are soft sunlight beams and suspended particles visible in the darkening azure water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006732400041073561 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00673246383667 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006732400041073561, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006732400041073561, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03824895992875099, + 0.014917319640517235, + 0.02929471619427204, + 0.005588154774159193, + 0.02458517998456955, + 0.01703818328678608, + 0.053898267447948456, + 0.013589229434728622, + 0.278595894575119, + 0.5242440700531006 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006732400041073561 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a scene imbued with the gentle aesthetic of a Ghibli animation, a static close-up shot from a slightly overhead angle initially focuses on a single emerald green leaf floating serenely on the surface of clear water. The leaf's surface is covered in a velvety, downy velvet that shimmers in the soft light, its veins clearly visible. Then, an invisible force slowly and calmly pulls the leaf downward, its edges gracefully plunging into the water. The surface tension breaks, and clear liquid slowly soaks the fuzzy surface. As the leaf steadily and relentlessly sinks into the murky depths, the camera's focus seamlessly shifts downward, transitioning from the initially clear surface to the profound, mysterious underwater world. As soft sunlight penetrates the rippling water, fleeting, dreamy flickers of light appear across the lens, like shattered stars. Light beams cast swaying paths across the darkening azure water, illuminating suspended particles and creating an atmosphere of tranquility, depth, and a sense of wonder.", + "seed": 5369, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_13/index_876_seed_5369_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.02735165844205767, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02735165844205767, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02735165844205767, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli animation aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green with visible veins and a velvety, downy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sink into murky depths while the camera focus shifts downward to reveal an underwater world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are soft sunlight beams and suspended particles visible in the darkening azure water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1172339916229248 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.242233991622925 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1172339916229248, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1172339916229248, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10198573768138885, + 0.11092765629291534, + 0.05134374648332596, + 0.04598237946629524, + 0.14953014254570007, + 0.06520556658506393, + 0.10676341503858566, + 0.1614791303873062, + 0.03742479532957077, + 0.16935738921165466 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1172339916229248 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli animation aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green with visible veins and a velvety, downy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sink into murky depths while the camera focus shifts downward to reveal an underwater world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are soft sunlight beams and suspended particles visible in the darkening azure water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006755134556442499 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006755352020264 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006755134556442499, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006755134556442499, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1061333417892456, + 0.15394864976406097, + 0.07199392467737198, + 0.03852349892258644, + 0.17999568581581116, + 0.11526382714509964, + 0.07572046667337418, + 0.05008290335536003, + 0.03756486251950264, + 0.17077277600765228 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006755134556442499 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli animation aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green with visible veins and a velvety, downy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sink into murky depths while the camera focus shifts downward to reveal an underwater world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are soft sunlight beams and suspended particles visible in the darkening azure water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009787782095372677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634787559509277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009787782095372677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009787782095372677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10019265115261078, + 0.08832640945911407, + 0.053544096648693085, + 0.03796825557947159, + 0.18340569734573364, + 0.12236154079437256, + 0.10612411051988602, + 0.16661544144153595, + 0.03924005478620529, + 0.10222172737121582 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009787782095372677 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli animation aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green with visible veins and a velvety, downy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sink into murky depths while the camera focus shifts downward to reveal an underwater world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are soft sunlight beams and suspended particles visible in the darkening azure water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010424185311421752 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876042366027832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010424185311421752, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010424185311421752, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06961999088525772, + 0.07460930198431015, + 0.05254947766661644, + 0.02261454053223133, + 0.10261857509613037, + 0.041736483573913574, + 0.08202429860830307, + 0.17176686227321625, + 0.05452551692724228, + 0.32793498039245605 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010424185311421752 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a Ghibli animation aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf emerald green with visible veins and a velvety, downy texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sink into murky depths while the camera focus shifts downward to reveal an underwater world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are soft sunlight beams and suspended particles visible in the darkening azure water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00193896540440619 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251938819885254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00193896540440619, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00193896540440619, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03619993478059769, + 0.046768639236688614, + 0.05665241926908493, + 0.042799364775419235, + 0.18426871299743652, + 0.06143904849886894, + 0.04793817922472954, + 0.13650420308113098, + 0.08548375219106674, + 0.3019457757472992 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00193896540440619 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_14/index_tensor([5830, 5830])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_14/index_tensor([5830, 5830])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0d0fca26d35e6a9d7316d9d7858bfe8fc276338f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_14/index_tensor([5830, 5830])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "cinematic close-up reveals the weathered hands of an elderly Southeast Asian man. His skin is a rich, sun-kissed brown, etched with a delicate map, its deep wrinkles and prominent veins auguring his long life. His fingers gently yet firmly hold a small, handleless ceramic cup, its surface a soft celadon green, its glaze a network of fine cracks. As he steadily and deliberately lifts the cup from a dark, polished wooden table, delicate wisps of white steam curl gracefully from the hot tea. Then, as the cup rises, the camera smoothly tilts upward, revealing his serene face. His deep, kind eyes are framed by gentle crow's feet, his thinning, graying hair is neatly combed, and his face bears a soft, calm expression. As he brings the cup to his lips, he takes a slow, focused sip, his eyes closing for a moment in silent appreciation. The scene is bathed in soft, warm, directional light, as if streaming through a nearby window in the late afternoon, creating a gentle play of light and shadow that accentuates the texture of his skin and the rising steam, all of which creates an atmosphere of deep calm and contemplation, with the shallow depth of field gently blurring the simple, uncluttered background.", + "seed": 32639, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_14/index_5830_seed_32639_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05549660660326481, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05549660660326481, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05549660660326481, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Southeast Asian man with sun-kissed brown skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold a small, handleless ceramic cup with a soft celadon green glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man lift the cup from a dark, polished wooden table and take a slow sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible wisps of white steam rising from the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt upward from the hands to reveal the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08025718480348587 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5802571773529053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08025718480348587, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08025718480348587, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15430279076099396, + 0.049202851951122284, + 0.1718689501285553, + 0.04549289122223854, + 0.06184706091880798, + 0.06436315923929214, + 0.033428966999053955, + 0.03476990759372711, + 0.19990135729312897, + 0.18482205271720886 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08025718480348587 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Southeast Asian man with sun-kissed brown skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold a small, handleless ceramic cup with a soft celadon green glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man lift the cup from a dark, polished wooden table and take a slow sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible wisps of white steam rising from the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt upward from the hands to reveal the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02060823142528534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956081867218018 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02060823142528534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02060823142528534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.38499581813812256, + 0.09046299010515213, + 0.1288629025220871, + 0.09951571375131607, + 0.07649064809083939, + 0.047528404742479324, + 0.028479399159550667, + 0.011919721029698849, + 0.04233451187610626, + 0.08940994739532471 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02060823142528534 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Southeast Asian man with sun-kissed brown skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold a small, handleless ceramic cup with a soft celadon green glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man lift the cup from a dark, polished wooden table and take a slow sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible wisps of white steam rising from the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt upward from the hands to reveal the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307733103632927 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168077230453491 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307733103632927, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307733103632927, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2882547080516815, + 0.06912297755479813, + 0.07477450370788574, + 0.04883074760437012, + 0.24219949543476105, + 0.13603468239307404, + 0.03270174562931061, + 0.014856742694973946, + 0.04542945697903633, + 0.047794848680496216 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307733103632927 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Southeast Asian man with sun-kissed brown skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold a small, handleless ceramic cup with a soft celadon green glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man lift the cup from a dark, polished wooden table and take a slow sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible wisps of white steam rising from the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt upward from the hands to reveal the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11296556890010834 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379655838012695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11296556890010834, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11296556890010834, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23135527968406677, + 0.418906033039093, + 0.11227741092443466, + 0.08111479133367538, + 0.035533249378204346, + 0.017297714948654175, + 0.023723918944597244, + 0.01310308463871479, + 0.016481244936585426, + 0.05020720884203911 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11296556890010834 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Southeast Asian man with sun-kissed brown skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold a small, handleless ceramic cup with a soft celadon green glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man lift the cup from a dark, polished wooden table and take a slow sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible wisps of white steam rising from the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt upward from the hands to reveal the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020574716851115227 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955748081207275 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020574716851115227, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020574716851115227, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19598565995693207, + 0.06162751093506813, + 0.10108103603124619, + 0.056276991963386536, + 0.10717134922742844, + 0.03294041007757187, + 0.17643165588378906, + 0.03575209900736809, + 0.186571404337883, + 0.04616184160113335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020574716851115227 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematic close-up reveals the weathered hands of an elderly Southeast Asian man. His skin is a rich, sun-kissed brown, etched with a delicate map, its deep wrinkles and prominent veins auguring his long life. His fingers gently yet firmly hold a small, handleless ceramic cup, its surface a soft celadon green, its glaze a network of fine cracks. As he steadily and deliberately lifts the cup from a dark, polished wooden table, delicate wisps of white steam curl gracefully from the hot tea. Then, as the cup rises, the camera smoothly tilts upward, revealing his serene face. His deep, kind eyes are framed by gentle crow's feet, his thinning, graying hair is neatly combed, and his face bears a soft, calm expression. As he brings the cup to his lips, he takes a slow, focused sip, his eyes closing for a moment in silent appreciation. The scene is bathed in soft, warm, directional light, as if streaming through a nearby window in the late afternoon, creating a gentle play of light and shadow that accentuates the texture of his skin and the rising steam, all of which creates an atmosphere of deep calm and contemplation, with the shallow depth of field gently blurring the simple, uncluttered background.", + "seed": 32640, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_14/index_5830_seed_32640_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07521729189902544, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07521729189902544, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07521729189902544, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Southeast Asian man with sun-kissed brown skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold a small, handleless ceramic cup with a soft celadon green glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man lift the cup from a dark, polished wooden table and take a slow sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible wisps of white steam rising from the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt upward from the hands to reveal the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03070981241762638 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.530709743499756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03070981241762638, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03070981241762638, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09157255291938782, + 0.025449713692069054, + 0.08043984323740005, + 0.026897121220827103, + 0.025892123579978943, + 0.21061259508132935, + 0.08199308812618256, + 0.06519809365272522, + 0.12374560534954071, + 0.26819929480552673 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03070981241762638 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Southeast Asian man with sun-kissed brown skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold a small, handleless ceramic cup with a soft celadon green glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man lift the cup from a dark, polished wooden table and take a slow sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible wisps of white steam rising from the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt upward from the hands to reveal the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009799114428460598 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634799003601074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009799114428460598, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009799114428460598, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15762841701507568, + 0.16212604939937592, + 0.12366747856140137, + 0.034349050372838974, + 0.06978531181812286, + 0.12283700704574585, + 0.16142591834068298, + 0.06812883168458939, + 0.0413946658372879, + 0.05865729600191116 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009799114428460598 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Southeast Asian man with sun-kissed brown skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold a small, handleless ceramic cup with a soft celadon green glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man lift the cup from a dark, polished wooden table and take a slow sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible wisps of white steam rising from the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt upward from the hands to reveal the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10032649338245392 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503265380859375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10032649338245392, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10032649338245392, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10327304899692535, + 0.15076299011707306, + 0.12028151005506516, + 0.04698704183101654, + 0.09253528714179993, + 0.2646908164024353, + 0.03992203623056412, + 0.06578300893306732, + 0.03521575406193733, + 0.0805484727025032 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10032649338245392 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Southeast Asian man with sun-kissed brown skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold a small, handleless ceramic cup with a soft celadon green glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man lift the cup from a dark, polished wooden table and take a slow sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible wisps of white steam rising from the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt upward from the hands to reveal the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20156584680080414 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015658617019653 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20156584680080414, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20156584680080414, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16544514894485474, + 0.06856134533882141, + 0.09615223854780197, + 0.06681227684020996, + 0.06980843842029572, + 0.24090354144573212, + 0.06642976403236389, + 0.02936074137687683, + 0.04318060725927353, + 0.15334592759609222 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20156584680080414 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Southeast Asian man with sun-kissed brown skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold a small, handleless ceramic cup with a soft celadon green glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man lift the cup from a dark, polished wooden table and take a slow sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible wisps of white steam rising from the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt upward from the hands to reveal the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033685192465782166 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086852073669434 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033685192465782166, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033685192465782166, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0685671865940094, + 0.051758989691734314, + 0.05933709442615509, + 0.05184565484523773, + 0.044092632830142975, + 0.4347613751888275, + 0.15182122588157654, + 0.034160856157541275, + 0.020707903429865837, + 0.08294706791639328 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033685192465782166 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematic close-up reveals the weathered hands of an elderly Southeast Asian man. His skin is a rich, sun-kissed brown, etched with a delicate map, its deep wrinkles and prominent veins auguring his long life. His fingers gently yet firmly hold a small, handleless ceramic cup, its surface a soft celadon green, its glaze a network of fine cracks. As he steadily and deliberately lifts the cup from a dark, polished wooden table, delicate wisps of white steam curl gracefully from the hot tea. Then, as the cup rises, the camera smoothly tilts upward, revealing his serene face. His deep, kind eyes are framed by gentle crow's feet, his thinning, graying hair is neatly combed, and his face bears a soft, calm expression. As he brings the cup to his lips, he takes a slow, focused sip, his eyes closing for a moment in silent appreciation. The scene is bathed in soft, warm, directional light, as if streaming through a nearby window in the late afternoon, creating a gentle play of light and shadow that accentuates the texture of his skin and the rising steam, all of which creates an atmosphere of deep calm and contemplation, with the shallow depth of field gently blurring the simple, uncluttered background.", + "seed": 32641, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_14/index_5830_seed_32641_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.09272008799016476, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09272008799016476, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09272008799016476, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Southeast Asian man with sun-kissed brown skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold a small, handleless ceramic cup with a soft celadon green glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man lift the cup from a dark, polished wooden table and take a slow sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible wisps of white steam rising from the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt upward from the hands to reveal the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10083500295877457 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350835084915161 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10083500295877457, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10083500295877457, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12610571086406708, + 0.11503589898347855, + 0.044749386608600616, + 0.14920422434806824, + 0.05240638181567192, + 0.08744311332702637, + 0.1961623877286911, + 0.06532187759876251, + 0.0555097870528698, + 0.10806124657392502 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10083500295877457 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Southeast Asian man with sun-kissed brown skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold a small, handleless ceramic cup with a soft celadon green glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man lift the cup from a dark, polished wooden table and take a slow sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible wisps of white steam rising from the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt upward from the hands to reveal the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012557132169604301 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387557029724121 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012557132169604301, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012557132169604301, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18013408780097961, + 0.0765572041273117, + 0.08480159938335419, + 0.04302610829472542, + 0.08203217387199402, + 0.11185962706804276, + 0.10103494673967361, + 0.07113276422023773, + 0.17599324882030487, + 0.0734281912446022 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012557132169604301 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Southeast Asian man with sun-kissed brown skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold a small, handleless ceramic cup with a soft celadon green glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man lift the cup from a dark, polished wooden table and take a slow sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible wisps of white steam rising from the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt upward from the hands to reveal the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10032045841217041 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350320339202881 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10032045841217041, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10032045841217041, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23759838938713074, + 0.12475143373012543, + 0.06473437696695328, + 0.03981149569153786, + 0.07981041818857193, + 0.017527570948004723, + 0.1861855834722519, + 0.060713812708854675, + 0.10036174207925797, + 0.08850521594285965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10032045841217041 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Southeast Asian man with sun-kissed brown skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold a small, handleless ceramic cup with a soft celadon green glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man lift the cup from a dark, polished wooden table and take a slow sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible wisps of white steam rising from the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt upward from the hands to reveal the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17988348007202148 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048834800720215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17988348007202148, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17988348007202148, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19452625513076782, + 0.08918244391679764, + 0.11706418544054031, + 0.07192365825176239, + 0.04076563939452171, + 0.051005471497774124, + 0.05913456529378891, + 0.08566118776798248, + 0.07686708867549896, + 0.21386946737766266 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17988348007202148 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Southeast Asian man with sun-kissed brown skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold a small, handleless ceramic cup with a soft celadon green glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man lift the cup from a dark, polished wooden table and take a slow sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible wisps of white steam rising from the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt upward from the hands to reveal the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000436633825302 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695004463195801 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000436633825302, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000436633825302, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06734541803598404, + 0.12001659721136093, + 0.056800466030836105, + 0.1315433233976364, + 0.05714639276266098, + 0.16563038527965546, + 0.06181181222200394, + 0.018098333850502968, + 0.0768047422170639, + 0.2448025643825531 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000436633825302 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematic close-up reveals the weathered hands of an elderly Southeast Asian man. His skin is a rich, sun-kissed brown, etched with a delicate map, its deep wrinkles and prominent veins auguring his long life. His fingers gently yet firmly hold a small, handleless ceramic cup, its surface a soft celadon green, its glaze a network of fine cracks. As he steadily and deliberately lifts the cup from a dark, polished wooden table, delicate wisps of white steam curl gracefully from the hot tea. Then, as the cup rises, the camera smoothly tilts upward, revealing his serene face. His deep, kind eyes are framed by gentle crow's feet, his thinning, graying hair is neatly combed, and his face bears a soft, calm expression. As he brings the cup to his lips, he takes a slow, focused sip, his eyes closing for a moment in silent appreciation. The scene is bathed in soft, warm, directional light, as if streaming through a nearby window in the late afternoon, creating a gentle play of light and shadow that accentuates the texture of his skin and the rising steam, all of which creates an atmosphere of deep calm and contemplation, with the shallow depth of field gently blurring the simple, uncluttered background.", + "seed": 32642, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_14/index_5830_seed_32642_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04108518436551094, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04108518436551094, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04108518436551094, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Southeast Asian man with sun-kissed brown skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold a small, handleless ceramic cup with a soft celadon green glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man lift the cup from a dark, polished wooden table and take a slow sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible wisps of white steam rising from the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt upward from the hands to reveal the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06246150657534599 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8124616146087646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06246150657534599, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06246150657534599, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06122228130698204, + 0.023255357518792152, + 0.06868749856948853, + 0.01664918288588524, + 0.42373543977737427, + 0.07409872859716415, + 0.03975894674658775, + 0.13026101887226105, + 0.05744089558720589, + 0.10489073395729065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06246150657534599 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Southeast Asian man with sun-kissed brown skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold a small, handleless ceramic cup with a soft celadon green glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man lift the cup from a dark, polished wooden table and take a slow sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible wisps of white steam rising from the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt upward from the hands to reveal the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016084907576441765 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141084671020508 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016084907576441765, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016084907576441765, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05534612387418747, + 0.05426058918237686, + 0.05962590128183365, + 0.04574696347117424, + 0.07771717011928558, + 0.028028592467308044, + 0.03202473744750023, + 0.03154250979423523, + 0.3799118101596832, + 0.23579557240009308 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016084907576441765 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Southeast Asian man with sun-kissed brown skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold a small, handleless ceramic cup with a soft celadon green glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man lift the cup from a dark, polished wooden table and take a slow sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible wisps of white steam rising from the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt upward from the hands to reveal the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023294946178793907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732949256896973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023294946178793907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023294946178793907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12615279853343964, + 0.09837129712104797, + 0.11883413046598434, + 0.01856873743236065, + 0.2797276973724365, + 0.08002809435129166, + 0.07790525257587433, + 0.05605880543589592, + 0.0808018371462822, + 0.06355133652687073 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023294946178793907 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Southeast Asian man with sun-kissed brown skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold a small, handleless ceramic cup with a soft celadon green glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man lift the cup from a dark, polished wooden table and take a slow sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible wisps of white steam rising from the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt upward from the hands to reveal the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495249107480049 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929952383041382 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495249107480049, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495249107480049, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.048407163470983505, + 0.07436753064393997, + 0.5299373269081116, + 0.015031957067549229, + 0.07175654917955399, + 0.028941776603460312, + 0.034007761627435684, + 0.02923419326543808, + 0.11395251750946045, + 0.0543631874024868 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495249107480049 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly Southeast Asian man with sun-kissed brown skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the man hold a small, handleless ceramic cup with a soft celadon green glaze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man lift the cup from a dark, polished wooden table and take a slow sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible wisps of white steam rising from the cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly tilt upward from the hands to reveal the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048632070422172546 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486321449279785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048632070422172546, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048632070422172546, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05406133085489273, + 0.04588725417852402, + 0.02590467967092991, + 0.05731664597988129, + 0.19265517592430115, + 0.042657557874917984, + 0.08486046642065048, + 0.03279636427760124, + 0.1160341426730156, + 0.34782636165618896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048632070422172546 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_15/index_tensor([144, 144])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_15/index_tensor([144, 144])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ab632446dfc488e0bc8e1ba1f9f8a86b8821a376 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_15/index_tensor([144, 144])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An unsettling Dutch angle close-up focuses the viewer's attention on a gigantic Brazilian centipede. Its deep black chitinous carapace, illuminated by a single, harsh overhead light, reflects a sickly, clammy sheen, while countless pairs of orange-yellow limbs on its sides paddle futilely through the air like frantic oars. The monster, with its massive, scythe-like fangs, ferociously bites into its unrecognizable prey. Each brutal rip pierces the bloody tissue, sending goo flying. Sharp contrasts of light and dark cast vast expanses of inky shadow across its writhing form, against a backdrop of murky, unrecognizable, rough rock. The image, replete with coarse grain and simulated film scratches, and desaturated colors, perfectly captures the rich style of Showa-era monster films, creating a tense atmosphere of raw, brutality, and a retro horror aesthetic.", + "seed": 13714, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_15/index_144_seed_13714_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.10030235517770052, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10030235517770052, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10030235517770052, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gigantic Brazilian centipede?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's carapace deep black with a sickly, clammy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the centipede's limbs orange-yellow and are they moving frantically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede ferociously biting into prey, causing bloody tissue to rip and goo to fly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a Dutch angle close-up with harsh overhead lighting, inky shadows, and a Showa-era monster film aesthetic including coarse grain and simulated film scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0903211161494255 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4653210639953613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0903211161494255, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0903211161494255, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19252780079841614, + 0.0711972787976265, + 0.09724953025579453, + 0.06507540494203568, + 0.09437492489814758, + 0.06387566030025482, + 0.12572459876537323, + 0.07418549060821533, + 0.13135157525539398, + 0.08443773537874222 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0903211161494255 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gigantic Brazilian centipede?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's carapace deep black with a sickly, clammy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the centipede's limbs orange-yellow and are they moving frantically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede ferociously biting into prey, causing bloody tissue to rip and goo to fly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a Dutch angle close-up with harsh overhead lighting, inky shadows, and a Showa-era monster film aesthetic including coarse grain and simulated film scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048693157732486725 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486931800842285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048693157732486725, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048693157732486725, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0715360939502716, + 0.05767305940389633, + 0.12700968980789185, + 0.06418053060770035, + 0.2784540057182312, + 0.08790575712919235, + 0.02639814466238022, + 0.166351780295372, + 0.0871967002749443, + 0.03329426422715187 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048693157732486725 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gigantic Brazilian centipede?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's carapace deep black with a sickly, clammy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the centipede's limbs orange-yellow and are they moving frantically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede ferociously biting into prey, causing bloody tissue to rip and goo to fly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a Dutch angle close-up with harsh overhead lighting, inky shadows, and a Showa-era monster film aesthetic including coarse grain and simulated film scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043085210025310516 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680850982666016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043085210025310516, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043085210025310516, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06961569935083389, + 0.12223367393016815, + 0.10238128155469894, + 0.054060447961091995, + 0.27156537771224976, + 0.07762939482927322, + 0.05889221653342247, + 0.07884068042039871, + 0.12140750139951706, + 0.04337369278073311 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043085210025310516 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gigantic Brazilian centipede?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's carapace deep black with a sickly, clammy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the centipede's limbs orange-yellow and are they moving frantically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede ferociously biting into prey, causing bloody tissue to rip and goo to fly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a Dutch angle close-up with harsh overhead lighting, inky shadows, and a Showa-era monster film aesthetic including coarse grain and simulated film scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134581446647644 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134582042694092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134581446647644, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134581446647644, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05488941818475723, + 0.1036742776632309, + 0.10036515444517136, + 0.1594676822423935, + 0.06000674143433571, + 0.12244823575019836, + 0.06537707149982452, + 0.15780775249004364, + 0.1363682895898819, + 0.039595358073711395 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134581446647644 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gigantic Brazilian centipede?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's carapace deep black with a sickly, clammy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the centipede's limbs orange-yellow and are they moving frantically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede ferociously biting into prey, causing bloody tissue to rip and goo to fly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a Dutch angle close-up with harsh overhead lighting, inky shadows, and a Showa-era monster film aesthetic including coarse grain and simulated film scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005954147316515446 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130954265594482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005954147316515446, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005954147316515446, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07156307995319366, + 0.19752320647239685, + 0.05203567445278168, + 0.0637725219130516, + 0.040326859802007675, + 0.08394575119018555, + 0.05922384560108185, + 0.1258733868598938, + 0.22645868360996246, + 0.07927694171667099 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005954147316515446 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An unsettling Dutch angle close-up focuses the viewer's attention on a gigantic Brazilian centipede. Its deep black chitinous carapace, illuminated by a single, harsh overhead light, reflects a sickly, clammy sheen, while countless pairs of orange-yellow limbs on its sides paddle futilely through the air like frantic oars. The monster, with its massive, scythe-like fangs, ferociously bites into its unrecognizable prey. Each brutal rip pierces the bloody tissue, sending goo flying. Sharp contrasts of light and dark cast vast expanses of inky shadow across its writhing form, against a backdrop of murky, unrecognizable, rough rock. The image, replete with coarse grain and simulated film scratches, and desaturated colors, perfectly captures the rich style of Showa-era monster films, creating a tense atmosphere of raw, brutality, and a retro horror aesthetic.", + "seed": 13715, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_15/index_144_seed_13715_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.09572983775287866, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09572983775287866, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09572983775287866, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gigantic Brazilian centipede?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's carapace deep black with a sickly, clammy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the centipede's limbs orange-yellow and are they moving frantically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede ferociously biting into prey, causing bloody tissue to rip and goo to fly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a Dutch angle close-up with harsh overhead lighting, inky shadows, and a Showa-era monster film aesthetic including coarse grain and simulated film scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09068514406681061 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4656851291656494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09068514406681061, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09068514406681061, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07138390094041824, + 0.10302538424730301, + 0.39603182673454285, + 0.028843039646744728, + 0.05251728370785713, + 0.0575295127928257, + 0.028478404507040977, + 0.08848331868648529, + 0.11931011080741882, + 0.05439715459942818 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09068514406681061 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gigantic Brazilian centipede?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's carapace deep black with a sickly, clammy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the centipede's limbs orange-yellow and are they moving frantically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede ferociously biting into prey, causing bloody tissue to rip and goo to fly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a Dutch angle close-up with harsh overhead lighting, inky shadows, and a Showa-era monster film aesthetic including coarse grain and simulated film scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029830604791641235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298306941986084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029830604791641235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029830604791641235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08806533366441727, + 0.0373847670853138, + 0.2836889326572418, + 0.04401661455631256, + 0.05952001363039017, + 0.05156470090150833, + 0.03213215246796608, + 0.22506412863731384, + 0.14798352122306824, + 0.030579909682273865 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029830604791641235 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gigantic Brazilian centipede?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's carapace deep black with a sickly, clammy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the centipede's limbs orange-yellow and are they moving frantically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede ferociously biting into prey, causing bloody tissue to rip and goo to fly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a Dutch angle close-up with harsh overhead lighting, inky shadows, and a Showa-era monster film aesthetic including coarse grain and simulated film scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07005216181278229 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695052146911621 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07005216181278229, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07005216181278229, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10362331569194794, + 0.04368439316749573, + 0.3047967553138733, + 0.032512225210666656, + 0.04580526798963547, + 0.04006916284561157, + 0.08572358638048172, + 0.11691028624773026, + 0.15590009093284607, + 0.07097489386796951 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07005216181278229 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gigantic Brazilian centipede?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's carapace deep black with a sickly, clammy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the centipede's limbs orange-yellow and are they moving frantically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede ferociously biting into prey, causing bloody tissue to rip and goo to fly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a Dutch angle close-up with harsh overhead lighting, inky shadows, and a Showa-era monster film aesthetic including coarse grain and simulated film scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.281339168548584 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.406339168548584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.281339168548584, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.281339168548584, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04563102126121521, + 0.04013587161898613, + 0.49543389678001404, + 0.039525263011455536, + 0.024207212030887604, + 0.014035995118319988, + 0.05133948475122452, + 0.06693737208843231, + 0.19688276946544647, + 0.025871049612760544 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.281339168548584 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gigantic Brazilian centipede?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's carapace deep black with a sickly, clammy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the centipede's limbs orange-yellow and are they moving frantically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede ferociously biting into prey, causing bloody tissue to rip and goo to fly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a Dutch angle close-up with harsh overhead lighting, inky shadows, and a Showa-era monster film aesthetic including coarse grain and simulated film scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006742109544575214 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006742000579834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006742109544575214, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006742109544575214, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2032010704278946, + 0.03266267850995064, + 0.12088122218847275, + 0.026746071875095367, + 0.037523359060287476, + 0.10962747782468796, + 0.024281905964016914, + 0.12808918952941895, + 0.20054803788661957, + 0.11643894761800766 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006742109544575214 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An unsettling Dutch angle close-up focuses the viewer's attention on a gigantic Brazilian centipede. Its deep black chitinous carapace, illuminated by a single, harsh overhead light, reflects a sickly, clammy sheen, while countless pairs of orange-yellow limbs on its sides paddle futilely through the air like frantic oars. The monster, with its massive, scythe-like fangs, ferociously bites into its unrecognizable prey. Each brutal rip pierces the bloody tissue, sending goo flying. Sharp contrasts of light and dark cast vast expanses of inky shadow across its writhing form, against a backdrop of murky, unrecognizable, rough rock. The image, replete with coarse grain and simulated film scratches, and desaturated colors, perfectly captures the rich style of Showa-era monster films, creating a tense atmosphere of raw, brutality, and a retro horror aesthetic.", + "seed": 13716, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_15/index_144_seed_13716_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05794501677155495, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05794501677155495, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05794501677155495, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gigantic Brazilian centipede?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's carapace deep black with a sickly, clammy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the centipede's limbs orange-yellow and are they moving frantically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede ferociously biting into prey, causing bloody tissue to rip and goo to fly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a Dutch angle close-up with harsh overhead lighting, inky shadows, and a Showa-era monster film aesthetic including coarse grain and simulated film scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10332279652357101 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.353322744369507 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10332279652357101, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10332279652357101, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17190717160701752, + 0.06579582393169403, + 0.10281297564506531, + 0.058385271579027176, + 0.061831455677747726, + 0.28922900557518005, + 0.12487268447875977, + 0.027557943016290665, + 0.05133729428052902, + 0.04627031832933426 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10332279652357101 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gigantic Brazilian centipede?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's carapace deep black with a sickly, clammy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the centipede's limbs orange-yellow and are they moving frantically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede ferociously biting into prey, causing bloody tissue to rip and goo to fly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a Dutch angle close-up with harsh overhead lighting, inky shadows, and a Showa-era monster film aesthetic including coarse grain and simulated film scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054989952594041824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.92999005317688 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054989952594041824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054989952594041824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11977516859769821, + 0.2346239984035492, + 0.08320649713277817, + 0.05078656226396561, + 0.044891104102134705, + 0.16949069499969482, + 0.08898637443780899, + 0.04616925120353699, + 0.11690524965524673, + 0.04516512528061867 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054989952594041824 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gigantic Brazilian centipede?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's carapace deep black with a sickly, clammy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the centipede's limbs orange-yellow and are they moving frantically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede ferociously biting into prey, causing bloody tissue to rip and goo to fly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a Dutch angle close-up with harsh overhead lighting, inky shadows, and a Showa-era monster film aesthetic including coarse grain and simulated film scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03372115269303322 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087212085723877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03372115269303322, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03372115269303322, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06493814289569855, + 0.060496021062135696, + 0.09605927765369415, + 0.050886113196611404, + 0.048747848719358444, + 0.26620516180992126, + 0.04502055048942566, + 0.026780271902680397, + 0.30120158195495605, + 0.0396650955080986 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03372115269303322 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gigantic Brazilian centipede?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's carapace deep black with a sickly, clammy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the centipede's limbs orange-yellow and are they moving frantically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede ferociously biting into prey, causing bloody tissue to rip and goo to fly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a Dutch angle close-up with harsh overhead lighting, inky shadows, and a Showa-era monster film aesthetic including coarse grain and simulated film scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08904829621315002 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464048385620117 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08904829621315002, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08904829621315002, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2348431646823883, + 0.055362261831760406, + 0.1563495695590973, + 0.056571122258901596, + 0.019225522875785828, + 0.25591933727264404, + 0.02504001185297966, + 0.029506763443350792, + 0.13922789692878723, + 0.02795439586043358 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08904829621315002 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gigantic Brazilian centipede?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's carapace deep black with a sickly, clammy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the centipede's limbs orange-yellow and are they moving frantically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede ferociously biting into prey, causing bloody tissue to rip and goo to fly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a Dutch angle close-up with harsh overhead lighting, inky shadows, and a Showa-era monster film aesthetic including coarse grain and simulated film scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008642885833978653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758642673492432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008642885833978653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008642885833978653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16712859272956848, + 0.06786756217479706, + 0.11994611471891403, + 0.03543713688850403, + 0.04821157455444336, + 0.23618556559085846, + 0.03266015276312828, + 0.028743963688611984, + 0.1745873987674713, + 0.0892319604754448 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008642885833978653 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An unsettling Dutch angle close-up focuses the viewer's attention on a gigantic Brazilian centipede. Its deep black chitinous carapace, illuminated by a single, harsh overhead light, reflects a sickly, clammy sheen, while countless pairs of orange-yellow limbs on its sides paddle futilely through the air like frantic oars. The monster, with its massive, scythe-like fangs, ferociously bites into its unrecognizable prey. Each brutal rip pierces the bloody tissue, sending goo flying. Sharp contrasts of light and dark cast vast expanses of inky shadow across its writhing form, against a backdrop of murky, unrecognizable, rough rock. The image, replete with coarse grain and simulated film scratches, and desaturated colors, perfectly captures the rich style of Showa-era monster films, creating a tense atmosphere of raw, brutality, and a retro horror aesthetic.", + "seed": 13717, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_15/index_144_seed_13717_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.061819666903465985, + "vlm_logprob": -0.061819666903465985, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.061819666903465985, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gigantic Brazilian centipede?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's carapace deep black with a sickly, clammy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the centipede's limbs orange-yellow and are they moving frantically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede ferociously biting into prey, causing bloody tissue to rip and goo to fly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a Dutch angle close-up with harsh overhead lighting, inky shadows, and a Showa-era monster film aesthetic including coarse grain and simulated film scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10174625366926193 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3517463207244873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10174625366926193, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10174625366926193, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05022882670164108, + 0.08401887118816376, + 0.03170087933540344, + 0.026231583207845688, + 0.06683220714330673, + 0.09586234390735626, + 0.4906874895095825, + 0.06779875606298447, + 0.06869190186262131, + 0.017947189509868622 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10174625366926193 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gigantic Brazilian centipede?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's carapace deep black with a sickly, clammy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the centipede's limbs orange-yellow and are they moving frantically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede ferociously biting into prey, causing bloody tissue to rip and goo to fly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a Dutch angle close-up with harsh overhead lighting, inky shadows, and a Showa-era monster film aesthetic including coarse grain and simulated film scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06207719072699547 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812077283859253 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06207719072699547, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06207719072699547, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10115127265453339, + 0.19035157561302185, + 0.025017812848091125, + 0.03132699802517891, + 0.09797749668359756, + 0.10211087018251419, + 0.12918321788311005, + 0.21189247071743011, + 0.04421667382121086, + 0.06677167862653732 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06207719072699547 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gigantic Brazilian centipede?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's carapace deep black with a sickly, clammy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the centipede's limbs orange-yellow and are they moving frantically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede ferociously biting into prey, causing bloody tissue to rip and goo to fly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a Dutch angle close-up with harsh overhead lighting, inky shadows, and a Showa-era monster film aesthetic including coarse grain and simulated film scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026369765400886536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.65136981010437 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026369765400886536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026369765400886536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08544372767210007, + 0.06299078464508057, + 0.05969219654798508, + 0.08340330421924591, + 0.12639278173446655, + 0.11508367210626602, + 0.10385039448738098, + 0.18151403963565826, + 0.12722262740135193, + 0.05440647527575493 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026369765400886536 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gigantic Brazilian centipede?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's carapace deep black with a sickly, clammy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the centipede's limbs orange-yellow and are they moving frantically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede ferociously biting into prey, causing bloody tissue to rip and goo to fly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a Dutch angle close-up with harsh overhead lighting, inky shadows, and a Showa-era monster film aesthetic including coarse grain and simulated film scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11295417696237564 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379541397094727 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11295417696237564, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11295417696237564, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09552657604217529, + 0.10361380875110626, + 0.01665707677602768, + 0.07228568196296692, + 0.259296715259552, + 0.07060151547193527, + 0.14109471440315247, + 0.11109814047813416, + 0.08812858164310455, + 0.04169720038771629 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11295417696237564 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gigantic Brazilian centipede?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's carapace deep black with a sickly, clammy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the centipede's limbs orange-yellow and are they moving frantically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede ferociously biting into prey, causing bloody tissue to rip and goo to fly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a Dutch angle close-up with harsh overhead lighting, inky shadows, and a Showa-era monster film aesthetic including coarse grain and simulated film scratches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005950947757810354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130950927734375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005950947757810354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005950947757810354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19299264252185822, + 0.06118900701403618, + 0.05259367823600769, + 0.22640067338943481, + 0.05256204307079315, + 0.05375384911894798, + 0.08021823316812515, + 0.07904479652643204, + 0.12002100050449371, + 0.08122405409812927 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005950947757810354 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_2/index_tensor([2816, 2816])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_2/index_tensor([2816, 2816])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c833b8d256ef91979da2fd9a69d787489caf693c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_2/index_tensor([2816, 2816])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly overhead angle, the camera remains still, focused on a dark ceramic pot. Inside, a clear broth simmers violently, countless tiny bubbles rising from the bottom, a hazy layer of white steam lingering on the surface. A plump, white, handmade dumpling with a round belly slowly descends from the top of the frame, the delicate wrinkles of its dough visible, a thin layer of dry flour still covering its surface. The instant the dumpling touches the boiling broth, it splashes a crown-shaped, shimmering, crystal-clear droplet that seems frozen in mid-air before gracefully descending. Then, the dumpling steadily and calmly sinks into the broth, leaving a fleeting vortex in the water. The entire dynamic process is imbued with a unique stop-motion quality, each frame imbued with a lovely pause. Under the warm, bright kitchen light, the scene creates a deeply soothing atmosphere imbued with the warmth of handmade craftsmanship and the essence of life.", + "seed": 29602, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_2/index_2816_seed_29602_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.26176181621849537, + "vlm_logprob": -0.26176181621849537, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.4750000119209288, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.26176181621849537, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle focused on a dark ceramic pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera remaining still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a plump, white, handmade dumpling with visible wrinkles and dry flour descend into the simmering broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dumpling splash a crown-shaped, shimmering, crystal-clear droplet that appears frozen in mid-air before descending?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a unique stop-motion quality with a lovely pause in each frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04436482861638069 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1693649291992188 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04436482861638069, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04436482861638069, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12637579441070557, + 0.09978684037923813, + 0.22966326773166656, + 0.16984882950782776, + 0.09372436255216599, + 0.1017468199133873, + 0.030476164072752, + 0.06995260715484619, + 0.049950581043958664, + 0.028474722057580948 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04436482861638069 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle focused on a dark ceramic pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera remaining still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a plump, white, handmade dumpling with visible wrinkles and dry flour descend into the simmering broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dumpling splash a crown-shaped, shimmering, crystal-clear droplet that appears frozen in mid-air before descending?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a unique stop-motion quality with a lovely pause in each frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137077808380127 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38707786798477173 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.137077808380127, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -1.137077808380127, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.056196652352809906, + 0.05267111584544182, + 0.17070382833480835, + 0.20196761190891266, + 0.14765934646129608, + 0.08162643760442734, + 0.03700565546751022, + 0.11092168092727661, + 0.0433913916349411, + 0.09785626083612442 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.137077808380127 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle focused on a dark ceramic pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera remaining still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a plump, white, handmade dumpling with visible wrinkles and dry flour descend into the simmering broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dumpling splash a crown-shaped, shimmering, crystal-clear droplet that appears frozen in mid-air before descending?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a unique stop-motion quality with a lovely pause in each frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014217277988791466 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264217376708984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014217277988791466, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014217277988791466, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1492166370153427, + 0.08247891068458557, + 0.2201411873102188, + 0.0939345508813858, + 0.1873760223388672, + 0.1065620705485344, + 0.03815251216292381, + 0.036041319370269775, + 0.04049001261591911, + 0.04560677707195282 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014217277988791466 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle focused on a dark ceramic pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera remaining still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a plump, white, handmade dumpling with visible wrinkles and dry flour descend into the simmering broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dumpling splash a crown-shaped, shimmering, crystal-clear droplet that appears frozen in mid-air before descending?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a unique stop-motion quality with a lovely pause in each frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07008005678653717 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695080041885376 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07008005678653717, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07008005678653717, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10223179310560226, + 0.20506882667541504, + 0.10007566958665848, + 0.23511426150798798, + 0.07596243917942047, + 0.07824301719665527, + 0.03493049740791321, + 0.08132326602935791, + 0.02785187028348446, + 0.059198375791311264 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07008005678653717 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle focused on a dark ceramic pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera remaining still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a plump, white, handmade dumpling with visible wrinkles and dry flour descend into the simmering broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dumpling splash a crown-shaped, shimmering, crystal-clear droplet that appears frozen in mid-air before descending?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a unique stop-motion quality with a lovely pause in each frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043069109320640564 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680691242218018 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043069109320640564, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043069109320640564, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05108502134680748, + 0.05035317316651344, + 0.1848657876253128, + 0.1235126182436943, + 0.21401110291481018, + 0.09015204757452011, + 0.018865035846829414, + 0.06705604493618011, + 0.11188974231481552, + 0.08820950984954834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043069109320640564 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly overhead angle, the camera remains still, focused on a dark ceramic pot. Inside, a clear broth simmers violently, countless tiny bubbles rising from the bottom, a hazy layer of white steam lingering on the surface. A plump, white, handmade dumpling with a round belly slowly descends from the top of the frame, the delicate wrinkles of its dough visible, a thin layer of dry flour still covering its surface. The instant the dumpling touches the boiling broth, it splashes a crown-shaped, shimmering, crystal-clear droplet that seems frozen in mid-air before gracefully descending. Then, the dumpling steadily and calmly sinks into the broth, leaving a fleeting vortex in the water. The entire dynamic process is imbued with a unique stop-motion quality, each frame imbued with a lovely pause. Under the warm, bright kitchen light, the scene creates a deeply soothing atmosphere imbued with the warmth of handmade craftsmanship and the essence of life.", + "seed": 29603, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_2/index_2816_seed_29603_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.28480111341923475, + "vlm_logprob": -0.28480111341923475, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.28480111341923475, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle focused on a dark ceramic pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera remaining still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a plump, white, handmade dumpling with visible wrinkles and dry flour descend into the simmering broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dumpling splash a crown-shaped, shimmering, crystal-clear droplet that appears frozen in mid-air before descending?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a unique stop-motion quality with a lovely pause in each frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20398955047130585 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7039895057678223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20398955047130585, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20398955047130585, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09369335323572159, + 0.06636234372854233, + 0.05971549078822136, + 0.05682375282049179, + 0.12116110324859619, + 0.040500883013010025, + 0.3058098554611206, + 0.22043760120868683, + 0.02099420689046383, + 0.014501378871500492 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20398955047130585 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle focused on a dark ceramic pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera remaining still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a plump, white, handmade dumpling with visible wrinkles and dry flour descend into the simmering broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dumpling splash a crown-shaped, shimmering, crystal-clear droplet that appears frozen in mid-air before descending?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a unique stop-motion quality with a lovely pause in each frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137086272239685 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38708627223968506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.137086272239685, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.137086272239685, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08598577976226807, + 0.09471242874860764, + 0.16432717442512512, + 0.16291527450084686, + 0.08471520990133286, + 0.05278324335813522, + 0.10165274888277054, + 0.12507204711437225, + 0.10148423165082932, + 0.026351885870099068 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.137086272239685 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle focused on a dark ceramic pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera remaining still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a plump, white, handmade dumpling with visible wrinkles and dry flour descend into the simmering broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dumpling splash a crown-shaped, shimmering, crystal-clear droplet that appears frozen in mid-air before descending?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a unique stop-motion quality with a lovely pause in each frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004648949019610882 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.3796491622924805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004648949019610882, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004648949019610882, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.150438129901886, + 0.1178884506225586, + 0.13424240052700043, + 0.08809133619070053, + 0.07760980725288391, + 0.08681050688028336, + 0.11798200756311417, + 0.09462910890579224, + 0.09356851875782013, + 0.03873966261744499 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004648949019610882 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle focused on a dark ceramic pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera remaining still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a plump, white, handmade dumpling with visible wrinkles and dry flour descend into the simmering broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dumpling splash a crown-shaped, shimmering, crystal-clear droplet that appears frozen in mid-air before descending?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a unique stop-motion quality with a lovely pause in each frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023311715573072433 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733116149902344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023311715573072433, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023311715573072433, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07795891165733337, + 0.14293348789215088, + 0.3640350103378296, + 0.047308485954999924, + 0.11639027297496796, + 0.049095094203948975, + 0.047010425478219986, + 0.05407198891043663, + 0.07875178009271622, + 0.022444557398557663 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023311715573072433 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle focused on a dark ceramic pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera remaining still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a plump, white, handmade dumpling with visible wrinkles and dry flour descend into the simmering broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dumpling splash a crown-shaped, shimmering, crystal-clear droplet that appears frozen in mid-air before descending?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a unique stop-motion quality with a lovely pause in each frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496907979249954 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929969072341919 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496907979249954, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496907979249954, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07944133132696152, + 0.10786007344722748, + 0.0720696672797203, + 0.06239433214068413, + 0.23867420852184296, + 0.05856511369347572, + 0.17518751323223114, + 0.04753989353775978, + 0.11582648009061813, + 0.04244137182831764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496907979249954 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly overhead angle, the camera remains still, focused on a dark ceramic pot. Inside, a clear broth simmers violently, countless tiny bubbles rising from the bottom, a hazy layer of white steam lingering on the surface. A plump, white, handmade dumpling with a round belly slowly descends from the top of the frame, the delicate wrinkles of its dough visible, a thin layer of dry flour still covering its surface. The instant the dumpling touches the boiling broth, it splashes a crown-shaped, shimmering, crystal-clear droplet that seems frozen in mid-air before gracefully descending. Then, the dumpling steadily and calmly sinks into the broth, leaving a fleeting vortex in the water. The entire dynamic process is imbued with a unique stop-motion quality, each frame imbued with a lovely pause. Under the warm, bright kitchen light, the scene creates a deeply soothing atmosphere imbued with the warmth of handmade craftsmanship and the essence of life.", + "seed": 29604, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_2/index_2816_seed_29604_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.4189544506371021, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4189544506371021, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4189544506371021, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle focused on a dark ceramic pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera remaining still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a plump, white, handmade dumpling with visible wrinkles and dry flour descend into the simmering broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dumpling splash a crown-shaped, shimmering, crystal-clear droplet that appears frozen in mid-air before descending?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a unique stop-motion quality with a lovely pause in each frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0559418201446533 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4309418499469757 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0559418201446533, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0559418201446533, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16423384845256805, + 0.202342689037323, + 0.037652645260095596, + 0.15151198208332062, + 0.36467432975769043, + 0.013163517229259014, + 0.01459936797618866, + 0.01757442206144333, + 0.025964822620153427, + 0.008282337337732315 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0559418201446533 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle focused on a dark ceramic pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera remaining still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a plump, white, handmade dumpling with visible wrinkles and dry flour descend into the simmering broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dumpling splash a crown-shaped, shimmering, crystal-clear droplet that appears frozen in mid-air before descending?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a unique stop-motion quality with a lovely pause in each frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983679413795471 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233679413795471 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8983679413795471, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8983679413795471, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10276371240615845, + 0.08323926478624344, + 0.05129491165280342, + 0.07792151719331741, + 0.5482497811317444, + 0.04324054718017578, + 0.02888954058289528, + 0.014317025430500507, + 0.02767934463918209, + 0.022404244169592857 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8983679413795471 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle focused on a dark ceramic pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera remaining still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a plump, white, handmade dumpling with visible wrinkles and dry flour descend into the simmering broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dumpling splash a crown-shaped, shimmering, crystal-clear droplet that appears frozen in mid-air before descending?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a unique stop-motion quality with a lovely pause in each frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048686683177948 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486867427825928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048686683177948, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048686683177948, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21216778457164764, + 0.16408196091651917, + 0.06951205432415009, + 0.2360425740480423, + 0.08653303980827332, + 0.031430136412382126, + 0.07606356590986252, + 0.04125764220952988, + 0.054228249937295914, + 0.02868296578526497 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048686683177948 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle focused on a dark ceramic pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera remaining still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a plump, white, handmade dumpling with visible wrinkles and dry flour descend into the simmering broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dumpling splash a crown-shaped, shimmering, crystal-clear droplet that appears frozen in mid-air before descending?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a unique stop-motion quality with a lovely pause in each frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04870133101940155 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048701286315918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04870133101940155, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04870133101940155, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16753096878528595, + 0.33529436588287354, + 0.08028168231248856, + 0.08321356773376465, + 0.18417666852474213, + 0.02673392742872238, + 0.03598058223724365, + 0.0379837229847908, + 0.03235515207052231, + 0.016449349001049995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04870133101940155 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle focused on a dark ceramic pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera remaining still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a plump, white, handmade dumpling with visible wrinkles and dry flour descend into the simmering broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dumpling splash a crown-shaped, shimmering, crystal-clear droplet that appears frozen in mid-air before descending?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a unique stop-motion quality with a lovely pause in each frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307447746396065 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168074369430542 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307447746396065, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307447746396065, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20207147300243378, + 0.1932372748851776, + 0.12912987172603607, + 0.06597205996513367, + 0.1730058342218399, + 0.10185997188091278, + 0.045397769659757614, + 0.02843550778925419, + 0.035141389816999435, + 0.025748852640390396 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307447746396065 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly overhead angle, the camera remains still, focused on a dark ceramic pot. Inside, a clear broth simmers violently, countless tiny bubbles rising from the bottom, a hazy layer of white steam lingering on the surface. A plump, white, handmade dumpling with a round belly slowly descends from the top of the frame, the delicate wrinkles of its dough visible, a thin layer of dry flour still covering its surface. The instant the dumpling touches the boiling broth, it splashes a crown-shaped, shimmering, crystal-clear droplet that seems frozen in mid-air before gracefully descending. Then, the dumpling steadily and calmly sinks into the broth, leaving a fleeting vortex in the water. The entire dynamic process is imbued with a unique stop-motion quality, each frame imbued with a lovely pause. Under the warm, bright kitchen light, the scene creates a deeply soothing atmosphere imbued with the warmth of handmade craftsmanship and the essence of life.", + "seed": 29605, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_2/index_2816_seed_29605_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2343262154608965, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2343262154608965, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2343262154608965, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle focused on a dark ceramic pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera remaining still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a plump, white, handmade dumpling with visible wrinkles and dry flour descend into the simmering broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dumpling splash a crown-shaped, shimmering, crystal-clear droplet that appears frozen in mid-air before descending?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a unique stop-motion quality with a lovely pause in each frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11474967747926712 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2397496700286865 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11474967747926712, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11474967747926712, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21500402688980103, + 0.06478937715291977, + 0.2737683355808258, + 0.07189316302537918, + 0.07875722646713257, + 0.027847450226545334, + 0.023969722911715508, + 0.07787119597196579, + 0.1461353749036789, + 0.019964097067713737 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11474967747926712 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle focused on a dark ceramic pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera remaining still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a plump, white, handmade dumpling with visible wrinkles and dry flour descend into the simmering broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dumpling splash a crown-shaped, shimmering, crystal-clear droplet that appears frozen in mid-air before descending?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a unique stop-motion quality with a lovely pause in each frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983696699142456 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233696699142456 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8983696699142456, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8983696699142456, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21349985897541046, + 0.0463189035654068, + 0.13752374053001404, + 0.19232358038425446, + 0.02291080541908741, + 0.10648053884506226, + 0.012257338501513004, + 0.05182332545518875, + 0.19912686944007874, + 0.017735062167048454 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8983696699142456 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle focused on a dark ceramic pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera remaining still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a plump, white, handmade dumpling with visible wrinkles and dry flour descend into the simmering broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dumpling splash a crown-shaped, shimmering, crystal-clear droplet that appears frozen in mid-air before descending?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a unique stop-motion quality with a lovely pause in each frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026373596861958504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513736248016357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026373596861958504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026373596861958504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05708816647529602, + 0.051055584102869034, + 0.16903629899024963, + 0.11261482536792755, + 0.04652082920074463, + 0.20926734805107117, + 0.032346729189157486, + 0.07475578039884567, + 0.2421455681324005, + 0.005168799310922623 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026373596861958504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle focused on a dark ceramic pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera remaining still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a plump, white, handmade dumpling with visible wrinkles and dry flour descend into the simmering broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dumpling splash a crown-shaped, shimmering, crystal-clear droplet that appears frozen in mid-air before descending?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a unique stop-motion quality with a lovely pause in each frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07007505744695663 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695075035095215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07007505744695663, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07007505744695663, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12532934546470642, + 0.02169741690158844, + 0.09087782353162766, + 0.05200964957475662, + 0.06068858131766319, + 0.39235445857048035, + 0.019706150516867638, + 0.0352640338242054, + 0.19436968863010406, + 0.007702832575887442 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07007505744695663 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle focused on a dark ceramic pot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera remaining still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a plump, white, handmade dumpling with visible wrinkles and dry flour descend into the simmering broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the dumpling splash a crown-shaped, shimmering, crystal-clear droplet that appears frozen in mid-air before descending?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a unique stop-motion quality with a lovely pause in each frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062063075602054596 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812062978744507 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062063075602054596, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062063075602054596, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0674235075712204, + 0.03884100168943405, + 0.05845457315444946, + 0.04673939570784569, + 0.10901300609111786, + 0.3705593943595886, + 0.017286665737628937, + 0.05158400535583496, + 0.22021441161632538, + 0.019884036853909492 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062063075602054596 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_3/index_tensor([9721, 9721])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_3/index_tensor([9721, 9721])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a0baf10fbc23f2e9f6aacb3a9a6f7bcee7a719de --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_3/index_tensor([9721, 9721])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow-motion tracking close-up shot from a slightly upward angle captures a monarch butterfly, orange and black with white spots, gracefully dancing in the air. A meadow of wildflowers appears blurred and out of focus in the warm afternoon sunlight. Its wings flutter up and down in a slow, rhythmic rhythm, its slender black body tracing an invisible, graceful arc through the air, sometimes spiraling upwards, sometimes gently descending. Golden sunlight filters through its translucent wings, casting a captivating halo around the edges. The entire image has a warm, vintage film quality, with slightly desaturated colors and a subtle grain. A soft, golden lens flare occasionally appears, and the dominant colors are warm gold and orange, interspersed with soft greens and purples in the background, creating a tranquil, nostalgic, dreamlike atmosphere.", + "seed": 27079, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_3/index_9721_seed_27079_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.016513035353273153, + "vlm_logprob": -0.016513035353273153, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.016513035353273153, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a monarch butterfly with orange and black wings featuring white spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly's motion characterized by slow, rhythmic wing fluttering and a graceful arc through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred meadow of wildflowers illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a slow-motion tracking close-up shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a warm vintage film quality with desaturated colors, subtle grain, and occasional golden lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03871883824467659 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2887189388275146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03871883824467659, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03871883824467659, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1527494490146637, + 0.034569788724184036, + 0.020733634009957314, + 0.06530178338289261, + 0.13617576658725739, + 0.038901276886463165, + 0.31338879466056824, + 0.07499657571315765, + 0.1051250770688057, + 0.05805782601237297 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03871883824467659 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a monarch butterfly with orange and black wings featuring white spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly's motion characterized by slow, rhythmic wing fluttering and a graceful arc through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred meadow of wildflowers illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a slow-motion tracking close-up shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a warm vintage film quality with desaturated colors, subtle grain, and occasional golden lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00864217709749937 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758642196655273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00864217709749937, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00864217709749937, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10514558106660843, + 0.04111117124557495, + 0.045069996267557144, + 0.05683742091059685, + 0.1811346858739853, + 0.05102479085326195, + 0.3062601685523987, + 0.05054425820708275, + 0.08346228301525116, + 0.07940960675477982 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00864217709749937 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a monarch butterfly with orange and black wings featuring white spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly's motion characterized by slow, rhythmic wing fluttering and a graceful arc through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred meadow of wildflowers illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a slow-motion tracking close-up shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a warm vintage film quality with desaturated colors, subtle grain, and occasional golden lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018181568011641502 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018181800842285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018181568011641502, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018181568011641502, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14398396015167236, + 0.03409691900014877, + 0.02850375510752201, + 0.06537187099456787, + 0.1783091276884079, + 0.0640522688627243, + 0.3112264573574066, + 0.037056419998407364, + 0.012781781144440174, + 0.12461739033460617 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018181568011641502 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a monarch butterfly with orange and black wings featuring white spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly's motion characterized by slow, rhythmic wing fluttering and a graceful arc through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred meadow of wildflowers illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a slow-motion tracking close-up shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a warm vintage film quality with desaturated colors, subtle grain, and occasional golden lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005944904405623674 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130944728851318 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005944904405623674, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005944904405623674, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1298215538263321, + 0.06384797394275665, + 0.05182681605219841, + 0.06970915198326111, + 0.14029239118099213, + 0.05682997405529022, + 0.222666397690773, + 0.06015144661068916, + 0.07221520692110062, + 0.1326390951871872 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005944904405623674 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a monarch butterfly with orange and black wings featuring white spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly's motion characterized by slow, rhythmic wing fluttering and a graceful arc through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred meadow of wildflowers illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a slow-motion tracking close-up shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a warm vintage film quality with desaturated colors, subtle grain, and occasional golden lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107768900692463 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511077880859375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107768900692463, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107768900692463, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15199925005435944, + 0.049055904150009155, + 0.04347160831093788, + 0.09935098886489868, + 0.12165649235248566, + 0.06094225123524666, + 0.09862211346626282, + 0.04799444600939751, + 0.0632035955786705, + 0.26370325684547424 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107768900692463 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion tracking close-up shot from a slightly upward angle captures a monarch butterfly, orange and black with white spots, gracefully dancing in the air. A meadow of wildflowers appears blurred and out of focus in the warm afternoon sunlight. Its wings flutter up and down in a slow, rhythmic rhythm, its slender black body tracing an invisible, graceful arc through the air, sometimes spiraling upwards, sometimes gently descending. Golden sunlight filters through its translucent wings, casting a captivating halo around the edges. The entire image has a warm, vintage film quality, with slightly desaturated colors and a subtle grain. A soft, golden lens flare occasionally appears, and the dominant colors are warm gold and orange, interspersed with soft greens and purples in the background, creating a tranquil, nostalgic, dreamlike atmosphere.", + "seed": 27080, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_3/index_9721_seed_27080_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.007276161573827267, + "vlm_logprob": -0.007276161573827267, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.174999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.007276161573827267, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a monarch butterfly with orange and black wings featuring white spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly's motion characterized by slow, rhythmic wing fluttering and a graceful arc through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred meadow of wildflowers illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a slow-motion tracking close-up shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a warm vintage film quality with desaturated colors, subtle grain, and occasional golden lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018750324845314026 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018750190734863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018750324845314026, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018750324845314026, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14887656271457672, + 0.08360704034566879, + 0.0302193071693182, + 0.052115485072135925, + 0.12214057892560959, + 0.383243203163147, + 0.037883587181568146, + 0.023925799876451492, + 0.04513383284211159, + 0.0728546530008316 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018750324845314026 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a monarch butterfly with orange and black wings featuring white spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly's motion characterized by slow, rhythmic wing fluttering and a graceful arc through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred meadow of wildflowers illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a slow-motion tracking close-up shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a warm vintage film quality with desaturated colors, subtle grain, and occasional golden lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00525581045076251 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255255699157715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00525581045076251, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00525581045076251, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11348149925470352, + 0.041578661650419235, + 0.02561335638165474, + 0.0876326709985733, + 0.2540532350540161, + 0.2759072184562683, + 0.04187718778848648, + 0.047203220427036285, + 0.06615279614925385, + 0.04650016501545906 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00525581045076251 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a monarch butterfly with orange and black wings featuring white spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly's motion characterized by slow, rhythmic wing fluttering and a graceful arc through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred meadow of wildflowers illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a slow-motion tracking close-up shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a warm vintage film quality with desaturated colors, subtle grain, and occasional golden lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028145008254796267 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877814292907715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028145008254796267, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028145008254796267, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24305443465709686, + 0.07321063429117203, + 0.10538478195667267, + 0.07681470364332199, + 0.03270450234413147, + 0.2735406458377838, + 0.08368073403835297, + 0.032076649367809296, + 0.015032697468996048, + 0.06450022011995316 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028145008254796267 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a monarch butterfly with orange and black wings featuring white spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly's motion characterized by slow, rhythmic wing fluttering and a graceful arc through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred meadow of wildflowers illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a slow-motion tracking close-up shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a warm vintage film quality with desaturated colors, subtle grain, and occasional golden lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003612541826441884 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628612518310547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003612541826441884, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003612541826441884, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06659117341041565, + 0.031110169366002083, + 0.015274392440915108, + 0.03991224616765976, + 0.16135185956954956, + 0.5655704140663147, + 0.053049180656671524, + 0.011706455610692501, + 0.019967317581176758, + 0.03546677529811859 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003612541826441884 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a monarch butterfly with orange and black wings featuring white spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly's motion characterized by slow, rhythmic wing fluttering and a graceful arc through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred meadow of wildflowers illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a slow-motion tracking close-up shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a warm vintage film quality with desaturated colors, subtle grain, and occasional golden lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005947629921138287 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130947589874268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005947629921138287, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005947629921138287, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16451933979988098, + 0.030155053362250328, + 0.014597914181649685, + 0.04164022207260132, + 0.04771479219198227, + 0.6102213263511658, + 0.030532944947481155, + 0.013031953945755959, + 0.0157148577272892, + 0.031871650367975235 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005947629921138287 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion tracking close-up shot from a slightly upward angle captures a monarch butterfly, orange and black with white spots, gracefully dancing in the air. A meadow of wildflowers appears blurred and out of focus in the warm afternoon sunlight. Its wings flutter up and down in a slow, rhythmic rhythm, its slender black body tracing an invisible, graceful arc through the air, sometimes spiraling upwards, sometimes gently descending. Golden sunlight filters through its translucent wings, casting a captivating halo around the edges. The entire image has a warm, vintage film quality, with slightly desaturated colors and a subtle grain. A soft, golden lens flare occasionally appears, and the dominant colors are warm gold and orange, interspersed with soft greens and purples in the background, creating a tranquil, nostalgic, dreamlike atmosphere.", + "seed": 27081, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_3/index_9721_seed_27081_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.010082606878131627, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010082606878131627, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010082606878131627, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a monarch butterfly with orange and black wings featuring white spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly's motion characterized by slow, rhythmic wing fluttering and a graceful arc through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred meadow of wildflowers illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a slow-motion tracking close-up shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a warm vintage film quality with desaturated colors, subtle grain, and occasional golden lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.017116209492087364 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.142116069793701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.017116209492087364, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.017116209492087364, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4223996698856354, + 0.03809108957648277, + 0.09195912629365921, + 0.06867814809083939, + 0.0492386668920517, + 0.18229041993618011, + 0.04602723941206932, + 0.014224061742424965, + 0.05134253576397896, + 0.03574906289577484 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.017116209492087364 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a monarch butterfly with orange and black wings featuring white spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly's motion characterized by slow, rhythmic wing fluttering and a graceful arc through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred meadow of wildflowers illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a slow-motion tracking close-up shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a warm vintage film quality with desaturated colors, subtle grain, and occasional golden lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008644895628094673 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758645057678223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008644895628094673, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008644895628094673, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6115017533302307, + 0.07909205555915833, + 0.04674573987722397, + 0.044540777802467346, + 0.029571594670414925, + 0.040362898260354996, + 0.05194465443491936, + 0.0229970533400774, + 0.053924448788166046, + 0.01931905373930931 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008644895628094673 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a monarch butterfly with orange and black wings featuring white spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly's motion characterized by slow, rhythmic wing fluttering and a graceful arc through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred meadow of wildflowers illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a slow-motion tracking close-up shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a warm vintage film quality with desaturated colors, subtle grain, and occasional golden lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011072618886828423 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511072635650635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011072618886828423, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011072618886828423, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6328886151313782, + 0.0390440933406353, + 0.04896168038249016, + 0.05891964212059975, + 0.07829803973436356, + 0.056022897362709045, + 0.030217763036489487, + 0.012115944176912308, + 0.027269814163446426, + 0.016261527314782143 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011072618886828423 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a monarch butterfly with orange and black wings featuring white spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly's motion characterized by slow, rhythmic wing fluttering and a graceful arc through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred meadow of wildflowers illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a slow-motion tracking close-up shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a warm vintage film quality with desaturated colors, subtle grain, and occasional golden lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00762575538828969 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882625579833984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00762575538828969, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00762575538828969, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7560582160949707, + 0.026919005438685417, + 0.033204395323991776, + 0.03250570967793465, + 0.02527184970676899, + 0.02012886106967926, + 0.026425881311297417, + 0.030085844919085503, + 0.032022491097450256, + 0.017377687618136406 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00762575538828969 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a monarch butterfly with orange and black wings featuring white spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly's motion characterized by slow, rhythmic wing fluttering and a graceful arc through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred meadow of wildflowers illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a slow-motion tracking close-up shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a warm vintage film quality with desaturated colors, subtle grain, and occasional golden lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00595355499535799 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130953788757324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00595355499535799, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00595355499535799, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2977074682712555, + 0.14161768555641174, + 0.11834267526865005, + 0.06747289001941681, + 0.09288692474365234, + 0.11934041976928711, + 0.03706615790724754, + 0.04108501225709915, + 0.03783431649208069, + 0.04664648696780205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00595355499535799 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion tracking close-up shot from a slightly upward angle captures a monarch butterfly, orange and black with white spots, gracefully dancing in the air. A meadow of wildflowers appears blurred and out of focus in the warm afternoon sunlight. Its wings flutter up and down in a slow, rhythmic rhythm, its slender black body tracing an invisible, graceful arc through the air, sometimes spiraling upwards, sometimes gently descending. Golden sunlight filters through its translucent wings, casting a captivating halo around the edges. The entire image has a warm, vintage film quality, with slightly desaturated colors and a subtle grain. A soft, golden lens flare occasionally appears, and the dominant colors are warm gold and orange, interspersed with soft greens and purples in the background, creating a tranquil, nostalgic, dreamlike atmosphere.", + "seed": 27082, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_3/index_9721_seed_27082_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.00874240966513753, + "vlm_logprob": -0.00874240966513753, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.00874240966513753, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a monarch butterfly with orange and black wings featuring white spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly's motion characterized by slow, rhythmic wing fluttering and a graceful arc through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred meadow of wildflowers illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a slow-motion tracking close-up shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a warm vintage film quality with desaturated colors, subtle grain, and occasional golden lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004005624447017908 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.754005432128906 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004005624447017908, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004005624447017908, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05714096128940582, + 0.06645667552947998, + 0.039599496871232986, + 0.017572691664099693, + 0.4922983646392822, + 0.062340762466192245, + 0.030865119770169258, + 0.02184818871319294, + 0.19857871532440186, + 0.01329896505922079 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004005624447017908 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a monarch butterfly with orange and black wings featuring white spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly's motion characterized by slow, rhythmic wing fluttering and a graceful arc through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred meadow of wildflowers illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a slow-motion tracking close-up shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a warm vintage film quality with desaturated colors, subtle grain, and occasional golden lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008643004111945629 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75864315032959 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008643004111945629, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008643004111945629, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08085121214389801, + 0.061254698783159256, + 0.031966447830200195, + 0.11720142513513565, + 0.3073207139968872, + 0.12320005893707275, + 0.03660460561513901, + 0.07428326457738876, + 0.11265750229358673, + 0.054660044610500336 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008643004111945629 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a monarch butterfly with orange and black wings featuring white spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly's motion characterized by slow, rhythmic wing fluttering and a graceful arc through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred meadow of wildflowers illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a slow-motion tracking close-up shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a warm vintage film quality with desaturated colors, subtle grain, and occasional golden lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005251185968518257 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255251407623291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005251185968518257, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005251185968518257, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11995192617177963, + 0.06269054859876633, + 0.03476756811141968, + 0.12415780872106552, + 0.11418849229812622, + 0.0640132799744606, + 0.02742473967373371, + 0.035000525414943695, + 0.37144044041633606, + 0.04636465013027191 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005251185968518257 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a monarch butterfly with orange and black wings featuring white spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly's motion characterized by slow, rhythmic wing fluttering and a graceful arc through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred meadow of wildflowers illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a slow-motion tracking close-up shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a warm vintage film quality with desaturated colors, subtle grain, and occasional golden lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007625163532793522 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882625102996826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007625163532793522, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007625163532793522, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09629851579666138, + 0.08207041025161743, + 0.021313484758138657, + 0.11603347212076187, + 0.10039503127336502, + 0.19531787931919098, + 0.07811497896909714, + 0.14373356103897095, + 0.13263161480426788, + 0.034090977162122726 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007625163532793522 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a monarch butterfly with orange and black wings featuring white spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the butterfly's motion characterized by slow, rhythmic wing fluttering and a graceful arc through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred meadow of wildflowers illuminated by warm afternoon sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a slow-motion tracking close-up shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a warm vintage film quality with desaturated colors, subtle grain, and occasional golden lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818707026541233 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187046051025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818707026541233, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818707026541233, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.034970473498106, + 0.01751754991710186, + 0.018495261669158936, + 0.08339647948741913, + 0.4828726053237915, + 0.12304040044546127, + 0.018332207575440407, + 0.015965476632118225, + 0.17159602046012878, + 0.0338134691119194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818707026541233 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_4/index_tensor([4456, 4456])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_4/index_tensor([4456, 4456])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..636f9e68aaf6990e1a8d1a209b341769bbe38e4b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_4/index_tensor([4456, 4456])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from behind the passenger seat of a car, slightly upward, focuses on a pendant hanging below the rearview mirror. As the car steadily drives along a flat country road, it oscillates in a slow and graceful rhythm, from left to right, then back again. The pendant is a delicate lotus pod meticulously carved from warm, dark mahogany. The surface is meticulously polished to a silky sheen, and the carving's flowing, Zen-like lines suspend it from a red silk thread, tied at the end with a delicate heart-shaped knot. Through the wide front windshield, the country road scenery beyond is rendered like a flowing classical oil painting. On either side of the road, golden birch groves and crimson maple trees line the road, and fallen leaves gently tumble across the asphalt. The shallow depth of field creates a blurred, dreamlike effect. The afternoon sun shines through the sparse autumn leaves, creating mottled and soft spots of light. With every swing of the pendant, light and shadow flow gently on its carved surface, creating an extremely tranquil, warm and poetic atmosphere. The main colors of the entire picture are warm amber and gold, full of classical autumn poetry.", + "seed": 7311, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_4/index_4456_seed_7311_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.20080685699358583, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20080685699358583, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20080685699358583, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant carved from warm, dark mahogany with a silky sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant suspended from a red silk thread tied with a heart-shaped knot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the car oscillate in a slow, graceful rhythm from left to right and back again?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scenery through the windshield rendered like a flowing classical oil painting with golden birch and crimson maple trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by warm amber and gold tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8308646082878113 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5808646082878113 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8308646082878113, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8308646082878113, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11179126799106598, + 0.031542014330625534, + 0.026995748281478882, + 0.016736771911382675, + 0.0938837081193924, + 0.007027029525488615, + 0.01614587940275669, + 0.009004618041217327, + 0.021051086485385895, + 0.6658218502998352 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8308646082878113 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant carved from warm, dark mahogany with a silky sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant suspended from a red silk thread tied with a heart-shaped knot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the car oscillate in a slow, graceful rhythm from left to right and back again?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scenery through the windshield rendered like a flowing classical oil painting with golden birch and crimson maple trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by warm amber and gold tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07005449384450912 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695054531097412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07005449384450912, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07005449384450912, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1495649218559265, + 0.21572338044643402, + 0.06571189314126968, + 0.05718797817826271, + 0.054932620376348495, + 0.03746405988931656, + 0.03969297930598259, + 0.025177134200930595, + 0.05034083500504494, + 0.30420419573783875 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07005449384450912 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant carved from warm, dark mahogany with a silky sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant suspended from a red silk thread tied with a heart-shaped knot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the car oscillate in a slow, graceful rhythm from left to right and back again?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scenery through the windshield rendered like a flowing classical oil painting with golden birch and crimson maple trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by warm amber and gold tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898415625095367 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578984260559082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898415625095367, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898415625095367, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.44581055641174316, + 0.04209974780678749, + 0.03898266702890396, + 0.026905272156000137, + 0.09687597304582596, + 0.08703245222568512, + 0.12720851600170135, + 0.011557419784367085, + 0.020392905920743942, + 0.10313449054956436 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898415625095367 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant carved from warm, dark mahogany with a silky sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant suspended from a red silk thread tied with a heart-shaped knot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the car oscillate in a slow, graceful rhythm from left to right and back again?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scenery through the windshield rendered like a flowing classical oil painting with golden birch and crimson maple trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by warm amber and gold tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818707026541233 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187046051025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818707026541233, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818707026541233, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.44388800859451294, + 0.028219155967235565, + 0.036651983857154846, + 0.022257637232542038, + 0.029692698270082474, + 0.02675512805581093, + 0.023804206401109695, + 0.06322850286960602, + 0.005483840126544237, + 0.32001885771751404 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818707026541233 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant carved from warm, dark mahogany with a silky sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant suspended from a red silk thread tied with a heart-shaped knot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the car oscillate in a slow, graceful rhythm from left to right and back again?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scenery through the windshield rendered like a flowing classical oil painting with golden birch and crimson maple trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by warm amber and gold tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005943956319242716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130943775177002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005943956319242716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005943956319242716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19911614060401917, + 0.04140292480587959, + 0.0414402075111866, + 0.02083677425980568, + 0.04685211926698685, + 0.026071812957525253, + 0.040967635810375214, + 0.021939732134342194, + 0.019810037687420845, + 0.5415626168251038 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005943956319242716 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from behind the passenger seat of a car, slightly upward, focuses on a pendant hanging below the rearview mirror. As the car steadily drives along a flat country road, it oscillates in a slow and graceful rhythm, from left to right, then back again. The pendant is a delicate lotus pod meticulously carved from warm, dark mahogany. The surface is meticulously polished to a silky sheen, and the carving's flowing, Zen-like lines suspend it from a red silk thread, tied at the end with a delicate heart-shaped knot. Through the wide front windshield, the country road scenery beyond is rendered like a flowing classical oil painting. On either side of the road, golden birch groves and crimson maple trees line the road, and fallen leaves gently tumble across the asphalt. The shallow depth of field creates a blurred, dreamlike effect. The afternoon sun shines through the sparse autumn leaves, creating mottled and soft spots of light. With every swing of the pendant, light and shadow flow gently on its carved surface, creating an extremely tranquil, warm and poetic atmosphere. The main colors of the entire picture are warm amber and gold, full of classical autumn poetry.", + "seed": 7312, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_4/index_4456_seed_7312_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2695221928413957, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2695221928413957, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2695221928413957, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant carved from warm, dark mahogany with a silky sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant suspended from a red silk thread tied with a heart-shaped knot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the car oscillate in a slow, graceful rhythm from left to right and back again?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scenery through the windshield rendered like a flowing classical oil painting with golden birch and crimson maple trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by warm amber and gold tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1389468908309937 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38894689083099365 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1389468908309937, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1389468908309937, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3471158444881439, + 0.06814119219779968, + 0.0485139824450016, + 0.07996103912591934, + 0.05520091578364372, + 0.023605944588780403, + 0.11240331083536148, + 0.050473473966121674, + 0.19436751306056976, + 0.02021677792072296 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1389468908309937 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant carved from warm, dark mahogany with a silky sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant suspended from a red silk thread tied with a heart-shaped knot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the car oscillate in a slow, graceful rhythm from left to right and back again?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scenery through the windshield rendered like a flowing classical oil painting with golden birch and crimson maple trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by warm amber and gold tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08907010406255722 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640700817108154 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08907010406255722, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08907010406255722, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19689686596393585, + 0.25134479999542236, + 0.20569457113742828, + 0.02608606405556202, + 0.07268593460321426, + 0.01773013547062874, + 0.027896085754036903, + 0.036785852164030075, + 0.14418457448482513, + 0.02069513313472271 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08907010406255722 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant carved from warm, dark mahogany with a silky sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant suspended from a red silk thread tied with a heart-shaped knot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the car oscillate in a slow, graceful rhythm from left to right and back again?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scenery through the windshield rendered like a flowing classical oil painting with golden birch and crimson maple trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by warm amber and gold tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07899627089500427 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578996181488037 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07899627089500427, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07899627089500427, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2002272754907608, + 0.21308238804340363, + 0.15909996628761292, + 0.04780307039618492, + 0.026087943464517593, + 0.06346701830625534, + 0.07913034409284592, + 0.03321617469191551, + 0.1445700228214264, + 0.033315788954496384 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07899627089500427 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant carved from warm, dark mahogany with a silky sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant suspended from a red silk thread tied with a heart-shaped knot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the car oscillate in a slow, graceful rhythm from left to right and back again?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scenery through the windshield rendered like a flowing classical oil painting with golden birch and crimson maple trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by warm amber and gold tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811003640294075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881100177764893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811003640294075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811003640294075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1596229374408722, + 0.4640576243400574, + 0.08741254359483719, + 0.05735515058040619, + 0.025221429765224457, + 0.0175581406801939, + 0.026114201173186302, + 0.10413016378879547, + 0.04391587898135185, + 0.014611991122364998 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811003640294075 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant carved from warm, dark mahogany with a silky sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant suspended from a red silk thread tied with a heart-shaped knot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the car oscillate in a slow, graceful rhythm from left to right and back again?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scenery through the windshield rendered like a flowing classical oil painting with golden birch and crimson maple trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by warm amber and gold tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024876620154827833 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002487659454346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024876620154827833, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024876620154827833, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1521717607975006, + 0.3097226321697235, + 0.2023235559463501, + 0.04019252210855484, + 0.02321234717965126, + 0.023978037759661674, + 0.058671992272138596, + 0.09968844056129456, + 0.06205141916871071, + 0.027987278997898102 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024876620154827833 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from behind the passenger seat of a car, slightly upward, focuses on a pendant hanging below the rearview mirror. As the car steadily drives along a flat country road, it oscillates in a slow and graceful rhythm, from left to right, then back again. The pendant is a delicate lotus pod meticulously carved from warm, dark mahogany. The surface is meticulously polished to a silky sheen, and the carving's flowing, Zen-like lines suspend it from a red silk thread, tied at the end with a delicate heart-shaped knot. Through the wide front windshield, the country road scenery beyond is rendered like a flowing classical oil painting. On either side of the road, golden birch groves and crimson maple trees line the road, and fallen leaves gently tumble across the asphalt. The shallow depth of field creates a blurred, dreamlike effect. The afternoon sun shines through the sparse autumn leaves, creating mottled and soft spots of light. With every swing of the pendant, light and shadow flow gently on its carved surface, creating an extremely tranquil, warm and poetic atmosphere. The main colors of the entire picture are warm amber and gold, full of classical autumn poetry.", + "seed": 7313, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_4/index_4456_seed_7313_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.24079420864582063, + "vlm_logprob": -0.24079420864582063, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.199999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.24079420864582063, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant carved from warm, dark mahogany with a silky sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant suspended from a red silk thread tied with a heart-shaped knot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the car oscillate in a slow, graceful rhythm from left to right and back again?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scenery through the windshield rendered like a flowing classical oil painting with golden birch and crimson maple trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by warm amber and gold tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7602654099464417 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6352654099464417 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7602654099464417, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7602654099464417, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11185324937105179, + 0.04548023268580437, + 0.23647037148475647, + 0.15072417259216309, + 0.04896058887243271, + 0.20406083762645721, + 0.02264881506562233, + 0.01878981851041317, + 0.13660594820976257, + 0.024405943229794502 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7602654099464417 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant carved from warm, dark mahogany with a silky sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant suspended from a red silk thread tied with a heart-shaped knot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the car oscillate in a slow, graceful rhythm from left to right and back again?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scenery through the windshield rendered like a flowing classical oil painting with golden birch and crimson maple trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by warm amber and gold tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22560995817184448 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006100177764893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22560995817184448, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22560995817184448, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07555181533098221, + 0.2192264348268509, + 0.3065694570541382, + 0.19905157387256622, + 0.032447751611471176, + 0.02869034931063652, + 0.018325872719287872, + 0.027577955275774002, + 0.0642208382487297, + 0.02833796851336956 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22560995817184448 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant carved from warm, dark mahogany with a silky sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant suspended from a red silk thread tied with a heart-shaped knot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the car oscillate in a slow, graceful rhythm from left to right and back again?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scenery through the windshield rendered like a flowing classical oil painting with golden birch and crimson maple trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by warm amber and gold tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14281140267848969 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178112983703613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14281140267848969, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14281140267848969, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06986255198717117, + 0.07060877233743668, + 0.04737275838851929, + 0.07366171479225159, + 0.04831046238541603, + 0.06401113420724869, + 0.03627198189496994, + 0.019226770848035812, + 0.5475960969924927, + 0.023077834397554398 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14281140267848969 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant carved from warm, dark mahogany with a silky sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant suspended from a red silk thread tied with a heart-shaped knot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the car oscillate in a slow, graceful rhythm from left to right and back again?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scenery through the windshield rendered like a flowing classical oil painting with golden birch and crimson maple trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by warm amber and gold tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003415375947952 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950342655181885 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003415375947952, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003415375947952, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15808279812335968, + 0.08085561543703079, + 0.13387632369995117, + 0.18303292989730835, + 0.01952599547803402, + 0.020835919305682182, + 0.009298780001699924, + 0.024196937680244446, + 0.34643304347991943, + 0.023861689493060112 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003415375947952 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant carved from warm, dark mahogany with a silky sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant suspended from a red silk thread tied with a heart-shaped knot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the car oscillate in a slow, graceful rhythm from left to right and back again?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scenery through the windshield rendered like a flowing classical oil painting with golden birch and crimson maple trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by warm amber and gold tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005250118672847748 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255249977111816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005250118672847748, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005250118672847748, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13360492885112762, + 0.06939055025577545, + 0.09777627140283585, + 0.2652950882911682, + 0.01932995207607746, + 0.17740017175674438, + 0.008605720475316048, + 0.031170304864645004, + 0.16598568856716156, + 0.03144124895334244 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005250118672847748 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from behind the passenger seat of a car, slightly upward, focuses on a pendant hanging below the rearview mirror. As the car steadily drives along a flat country road, it oscillates in a slow and graceful rhythm, from left to right, then back again. The pendant is a delicate lotus pod meticulously carved from warm, dark mahogany. The surface is meticulously polished to a silky sheen, and the carving's flowing, Zen-like lines suspend it from a red silk thread, tied at the end with a delicate heart-shaped knot. Through the wide front windshield, the country road scenery beyond is rendered like a flowing classical oil painting. On either side of the road, golden birch groves and crimson maple trees line the road, and fallen leaves gently tumble across the asphalt. The shallow depth of field creates a blurred, dreamlike effect. The afternoon sun shines through the sparse autumn leaves, creating mottled and soft spots of light. With every swing of the pendant, light and shadow flow gently on its carved surface, creating an extremely tranquil, warm and poetic atmosphere. The main colors of the entire picture are warm amber and gold, full of classical autumn poetry.", + "seed": 7314, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_4/index_4456_seed_7314_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.5493679046630859, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5493679046630859, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5493679046630859, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant carved from warm, dark mahogany with a silky sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant suspended from a red silk thread tied with a heart-shaped knot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the car oscillate in a slow, graceful rhythm from left to right and back again?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scenery through the windshield rendered like a flowing classical oil painting with golden birch and crimson maple trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by warm amber and gold tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3506860733032227 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10068615525960922 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.3506860733032227, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -2.3506860733032227, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1118319034576416, + 0.03485756367444992, + 0.22133074700832367, + 0.07874731719493866, + 0.04692581295967102, + 0.03345492482185364, + 0.013805451802909374, + 0.04403097182512283, + 0.03231845051050186, + 0.38269683718681335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.3506860733032227 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant carved from warm, dark mahogany with a silky sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant suspended from a red silk thread tied with a heart-shaped knot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the car oscillate in a slow, graceful rhythm from left to right and back again?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scenery through the windshield rendered like a flowing classical oil painting with golden birch and crimson maple trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by warm amber and gold tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1800670027732849 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8050670623779297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1800670027732849, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1800670027732849, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10828592628240585, + 0.044677261263132095, + 0.14049600064754486, + 0.05073493346571922, + 0.06187158450484276, + 0.055985111743211746, + 0.029293905943632126, + 0.07261781394481659, + 0.03922951966524124, + 0.3968079686164856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1800670027732849 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant carved from warm, dark mahogany with a silky sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant suspended from a red silk thread tied with a heart-shaped knot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the car oscillate in a slow, graceful rhythm from left to right and back again?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scenery through the windshield rendered like a flowing classical oil painting with golden birch and crimson maple trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by warm amber and gold tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14288395643234253 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178840160369873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14288395643234253, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14288395643234253, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1863868534564972, + 0.09824840724468231, + 0.10383350402116776, + 0.11068903654813766, + 0.08401213586330414, + 0.07288606464862823, + 0.038497526198625565, + 0.07959075272083282, + 0.05240783840417862, + 0.1734478920698166 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14288395643234253 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant carved from warm, dark mahogany with a silky sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant suspended from a red silk thread tied with a heart-shaped knot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the car oscillate in a slow, graceful rhythm from left to right and back again?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scenery through the windshield rendered like a flowing classical oil painting with golden birch and crimson maple trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by warm amber and gold tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0550006702542305 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300007820129395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0550006702542305, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0550006702542305, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10475219786167145, + 0.0391298308968544, + 0.29863715171813965, + 0.10295785218477249, + 0.20819635689258575, + 0.05229019746184349, + 0.007535537239164114, + 0.011024925857782364, + 0.012505386024713516, + 0.16297055780887604 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0550006702542305 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant carved from warm, dark mahogany with a silky sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant suspended from a red silk thread tied with a heart-shaped knot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the car oscillate in a slow, graceful rhythm from left to right and back again?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scenery through the windshield rendered like a flowing classical oil painting with golden birch and crimson maple trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette dominated by warm amber and gold tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01820182055234909 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01820182800293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01820182055234909, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01820182055234909, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15030913054943085, + 0.042812544852495193, + 0.10476509481668472, + 0.14716462790966034, + 0.15077656507492065, + 0.03629714995622635, + 0.02106703445315361, + 0.027853528037667274, + 0.016071602702140808, + 0.30288270115852356 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01820182055234909 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_5/index_tensor([5925, 5925])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_5/index_tensor([5925, 5925])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9e97057afade39b0e509d1b7563f77b599428865 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_5/index_tensor([5925, 5925])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, captured with the calm, objective perspective of a documentary, slowly pans left, revealing the interior of a majestic orbital dock, its massive skeletal structure looming against the vast backdrop of space. At the center of the scene, a massive, disc-shaped starship hovers silently, its once-smooth, pearlescent white alloy hull now covered in tiny scratches and the marks of interstellar travel. Harsh, cold white highlights cast a powerful light from every corner of the dock, creating sharp highlights and deep shadows on the ship's curved surfaces, creating a clinical atmosphere reminiscent of an operating room. The scene then cuts to a rapid-fire montage: first a close-up of a plasma cutter at the end of a massive automated robotic arm, slicing through the hull with ruthless precision, sending out a shower of dazzling orange sparks. Next, a medium shot shows a massive magnetic clamp firmly grasping a section of the severed hull and carefully peeling it away, like peeling back a layer of skin, revealing a breathtakingly complex interior—a maze of shimmering blue energy conduits, layers of crystalline data cores, and a spiderweb of structural support ribs. Another rapid overhead shot captures the massive, stripped-away hull slowly drifting toward the recovery area, its sheer size emphasizing the systematic and monumental nature of the disassembly process. The entire montage is calm and methodical, devoid of any hint of chaos, showcasing the beauty of industrial, systematic deconstruction, as if composing a solemn and chilling visual elegy for the end of this magnificent starship.", + "seed": 28752, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_5/index_5925_seed_28752_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.039763605780899526, + "vlm_logprob": -0.039763605780899526, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.039763605780899526, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle shot of an orbital dock interior featuring a massive skeletal structure against space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive disc-shaped starship visible with a pearlescent white alloy hull covered in scratches and marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a rapid montage showing a plasma cutter on a robotic arm slicing the hull and sending out orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a medium shot shown where a magnetic clamp peels away a hull section to reveal blue energy conduits and crystalline data cores?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature an overhead shot of the stripped hull drifting toward a recovery area?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.034145552664995193 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4091455936431885 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.034145552664995193, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.034145552664995193, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26942113041877747, + 0.13883469998836517, + 0.025410106405615807, + 0.1172817200422287, + 0.018500475212931633, + 0.01931285671889782, + 0.19889098405838013, + 0.036072950810194016, + 0.126736581325531, + 0.049538418650627136 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.034145552664995193 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle shot of an orbital dock interior featuring a massive skeletal structure against space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive disc-shaped starship visible with a pearlescent white alloy hull covered in scratches and marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a rapid montage showing a plasma cutter on a robotic arm slicing the hull and sending out orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a medium shot shown where a magnetic clamp peels away a hull section to reveal blue energy conduits and crystalline data cores?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature an overhead shot of the stripped hull drifting toward a recovery area?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01256466656923294 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387564659118652 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01256466656923294, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01256466656923294, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12080959230661392, + 0.09546947479248047, + 0.02257436513900757, + 0.1622408628463745, + 0.031378597021102905, + 0.040681250393390656, + 0.3661872446537018, + 0.041898734867572784, + 0.06063176319003105, + 0.058128125965595245 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01256466656923294 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle shot of an orbital dock interior featuring a massive skeletal structure against space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive disc-shaped starship visible with a pearlescent white alloy hull covered in scratches and marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a rapid montage showing a plasma cutter on a robotic arm slicing the hull and sending out orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a medium shot shown where a magnetic clamp peels away a hull section to reveal blue energy conduits and crystalline data cores?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature an overhead shot of the stripped hull drifting toward a recovery area?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205030158162117 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120503425598145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205030158162117, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205030158162117, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1273777186870575, + 0.28449928760528564, + 0.03214741125702858, + 0.3118802011013031, + 0.10263346135616302, + 0.009561382234096527, + 0.054099153727293015, + 0.026651110500097275, + 0.010183091275393963, + 0.040967267006635666 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205030158162117 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle shot of an orbital dock interior featuring a massive skeletal structure against space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive disc-shaped starship visible with a pearlescent white alloy hull covered in scratches and marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a rapid montage showing a plasma cutter on a robotic arm slicing the hull and sending out orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a medium shot shown where a magnetic clamp peels away a hull section to reveal blue energy conduits and crystalline data cores?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature an overhead shot of the stripped hull drifting toward a recovery area?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011080400086939335 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511080265045166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011080400086939335, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011080400086939335, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08201459795236588, + 0.10234628617763519, + 0.051925402134656906, + 0.04315122216939926, + 0.044773805886507034, + 0.05893704295158386, + 0.4176556169986725, + 0.04567582532763481, + 0.12335079908370972, + 0.030169358476996422 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011080400086939335 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle shot of an orbital dock interior featuring a massive skeletal structure against space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive disc-shaped starship visible with a pearlescent white alloy hull covered in scratches and marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a rapid montage showing a plasma cutter on a robotic arm slicing the hull and sending out orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a medium shot shown where a magnetic clamp peels away a hull section to reveal blue energy conduits and crystalline data cores?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature an overhead shot of the stripped hull drifting toward a recovery area?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897710800170898 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578977108001709 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897710800170898, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897710800170898, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11821556091308594, + 0.05225425213575363, + 0.08457516133785248, + 0.15067116916179657, + 0.03893667086958885, + 0.038353364914655685, + 0.2617912292480469, + 0.09371304512023926, + 0.02649729885160923, + 0.13499224185943604 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897710800170898 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, captured with the calm, objective perspective of a documentary, slowly pans left, revealing the interior of a majestic orbital dock, its massive skeletal structure looming against the vast backdrop of space. At the center of the scene, a massive, disc-shaped starship hovers silently, its once-smooth, pearlescent white alloy hull now covered in tiny scratches and the marks of interstellar travel. Harsh, cold white highlights cast a powerful light from every corner of the dock, creating sharp highlights and deep shadows on the ship's curved surfaces, creating a clinical atmosphere reminiscent of an operating room. The scene then cuts to a rapid-fire montage: first a close-up of a plasma cutter at the end of a massive automated robotic arm, slicing through the hull with ruthless precision, sending out a shower of dazzling orange sparks. Next, a medium shot shows a massive magnetic clamp firmly grasping a section of the severed hull and carefully peeling it away, like peeling back a layer of skin, revealing a breathtakingly complex interior—a maze of shimmering blue energy conduits, layers of crystalline data cores, and a spiderweb of structural support ribs. Another rapid overhead shot captures the massive, stripped-away hull slowly drifting toward the recovery area, its sheer size emphasizing the systematic and monumental nature of the disassembly process. The entire montage is calm and methodical, devoid of any hint of chaos, showcasing the beauty of industrial, systematic deconstruction, as if composing a solemn and chilling visual elegy for the end of this magnificent starship.", + "seed": 28753, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_5/index_5925_seed_28753_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.18151435237377883, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18151435237377883, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18151435237377883, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle shot of an orbital dock interior featuring a massive skeletal structure against space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive disc-shaped starship visible with a pearlescent white alloy hull covered in scratches and marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a rapid montage showing a plasma cutter on a robotic arm slicing the hull and sending out orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a medium shot shown where a magnetic clamp peels away a hull section to reveal blue energy conduits and crystalline data cores?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature an overhead shot of the stripped hull drifting toward a recovery area?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3502882421016693 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2252882719039917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3502882421016693, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3502882421016693, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18912410736083984, + 0.08462218195199966, + 0.04883690923452377, + 0.17018583416938782, + 0.15610761940479279, + 0.03822701796889305, + 0.06064557656645775, + 0.053388550877571106, + 0.133336141705513, + 0.06552603840827942 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3502882421016693 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle shot of an orbital dock interior featuring a massive skeletal structure against space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive disc-shaped starship visible with a pearlescent white alloy hull covered in scratches and marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a rapid montage showing a plasma cutter on a robotic arm slicing the hull and sending out orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a medium shot shown where a magnetic clamp peels away a hull section to reveal blue energy conduits and crystalline data cores?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature an overhead shot of the stripped hull drifting toward a recovery area?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01824021525681019 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018240451812744 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01824021525681019, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01824021525681019, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2774598002433777, + 0.07183992862701416, + 0.11809074878692627, + 0.06888764351606369, + 0.0991077795624733, + 0.027183035388588905, + 0.034332454204559326, + 0.070949025452137, + 0.1329623907804489, + 0.09918717294931412 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01824021525681019 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle shot of an orbital dock interior featuring a massive skeletal structure against space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive disc-shaped starship visible with a pearlescent white alloy hull covered in scratches and marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a rapid montage showing a plasma cutter on a robotic arm slicing the hull and sending out orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a medium shot shown where a magnetic clamp peels away a hull section to reveal blue energy conduits and crystalline data cores?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature an overhead shot of the stripped hull drifting toward a recovery area?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.428899884223938 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.053899884223938 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.428899884223938, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.428899884223938, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08764144778251648, + 0.11589424312114716, + 0.06901541352272034, + 0.145106241106987, + 0.16841332614421844, + 0.03615865483880043, + 0.06241646781563759, + 0.19138406217098236, + 0.0647604763507843, + 0.059209682047367096 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.428899884223938 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle shot of an orbital dock interior featuring a massive skeletal structure against space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive disc-shaped starship visible with a pearlescent white alloy hull covered in scratches and marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a rapid montage showing a plasma cutter on a robotic arm slicing the hull and sending out orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a medium shot shown where a magnetic clamp peels away a hull section to reveal blue energy conduits and crystalline data cores?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature an overhead shot of the stripped hull drifting toward a recovery area?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00979935098439455 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634799480438232 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00979935098439455, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00979935098439455, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15106481313705444, + 0.07355083525180817, + 0.08150048553943634, + 0.0432140938937664, + 0.198459193110466, + 0.02782956138253212, + 0.062224745750427246, + 0.13519011437892914, + 0.1082114577293396, + 0.1187547817826271 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00979935098439455 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle shot of an orbital dock interior featuring a massive skeletal structure against space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive disc-shaped starship visible with a pearlescent white alloy hull covered in scratches and marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a rapid montage showing a plasma cutter on a robotic arm slicing the hull and sending out orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a medium shot shown where a magnetic clamp peels away a hull section to reveal blue energy conduits and crystalline data cores?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature an overhead shot of the stripped hull drifting toward a recovery area?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10034406930208206 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350344181060791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10034406930208206, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10034406930208206, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08516445010900497, + 0.07926889508962631, + 0.07479101419448853, + 0.13930386304855347, + 0.2160620391368866, + 0.09725026041269302, + 0.03497016057372093, + 0.10269148647785187, + 0.05513501167297363, + 0.11536281555891037 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10034406930208206 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, captured with the calm, objective perspective of a documentary, slowly pans left, revealing the interior of a majestic orbital dock, its massive skeletal structure looming against the vast backdrop of space. At the center of the scene, a massive, disc-shaped starship hovers silently, its once-smooth, pearlescent white alloy hull now covered in tiny scratches and the marks of interstellar travel. Harsh, cold white highlights cast a powerful light from every corner of the dock, creating sharp highlights and deep shadows on the ship's curved surfaces, creating a clinical atmosphere reminiscent of an operating room. The scene then cuts to a rapid-fire montage: first a close-up of a plasma cutter at the end of a massive automated robotic arm, slicing through the hull with ruthless precision, sending out a shower of dazzling orange sparks. Next, a medium shot shows a massive magnetic clamp firmly grasping a section of the severed hull and carefully peeling it away, like peeling back a layer of skin, revealing a breathtakingly complex interior—a maze of shimmering blue energy conduits, layers of crystalline data cores, and a spiderweb of structural support ribs. Another rapid overhead shot captures the massive, stripped-away hull slowly drifting toward the recovery area, its sheer size emphasizing the systematic and monumental nature of the disassembly process. The entire montage is calm and methodical, devoid of any hint of chaos, showcasing the beauty of industrial, systematic deconstruction, as if composing a solemn and chilling visual elegy for the end of this magnificent starship.", + "seed": 28754, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_5/index_5925_seed_28754_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05212238160893321, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05212238160893321, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05212238160893321, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle shot of an orbital dock interior featuring a massive skeletal structure against space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive disc-shaped starship visible with a pearlescent white alloy hull covered in scratches and marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a rapid montage showing a plasma cutter on a robotic arm slicing the hull and sending out orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a medium shot shown where a magnetic clamp peels away a hull section to reveal blue energy conduits and crystalline data cores?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature an overhead shot of the stripped hull drifting toward a recovery area?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05599262937903404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.930992603302002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05599262937903404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05599262937903404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2870362401008606, + 0.10277601331472397, + 0.1254131942987442, + 0.05538902431726456, + 0.06275978684425354, + 0.1050928458571434, + 0.10742351412773132, + 0.05441417545080185, + 0.055252328515052795, + 0.044442832469940186 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05599262937903404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle shot of an orbital dock interior featuring a massive skeletal structure against space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive disc-shaped starship visible with a pearlescent white alloy hull covered in scratches and marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a rapid montage showing a plasma cutter on a robotic arm slicing the hull and sending out orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a medium shot shown where a magnetic clamp peels away a hull section to reveal blue energy conduits and crystalline data cores?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature an overhead shot of the stripped hull drifting toward a recovery area?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0111106988042593 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511110782623291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0111106988042593, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0111106988042593, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27009907364845276, + 0.08948974311351776, + 0.10406532138586044, + 0.06425564736127853, + 0.08081170171499252, + 0.11649256944656372, + 0.029479999095201492, + 0.08591965585947037, + 0.09410358965396881, + 0.06528269499540329 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0111106988042593 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle shot of an orbital dock interior featuring a massive skeletal structure against space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive disc-shaped starship visible with a pearlescent white alloy hull covered in scratches and marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a rapid montage showing a plasma cutter on a robotic arm slicing the hull and sending out orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a medium shot shown where a magnetic clamp peels away a hull section to reveal blue energy conduits and crystalline data cores?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature an overhead shot of the stripped hull drifting toward a recovery area?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307219386100769 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.16807222366333 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307219386100769, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307219386100769, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03826988860964775, + 0.03442830592393875, + 0.06056800112128258, + 0.0724753737449646, + 0.15476791560649872, + 0.5318094491958618, + 0.04686330258846283, + 0.02121366374194622, + 0.01956474594771862, + 0.020039372146129608 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307219386100769 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle shot of an orbital dock interior featuring a massive skeletal structure against space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive disc-shaped starship visible with a pearlescent white alloy hull covered in scratches and marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a rapid montage showing a plasma cutter on a robotic arm slicing the hull and sending out orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a medium shot shown where a magnetic clamp peels away a hull section to reveal blue energy conduits and crystalline data cores?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature an overhead shot of the stripped hull drifting toward a recovery area?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007635101210325956 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882635116577148 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007635101210325956, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007635101210325956, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08475449681282043, + 0.08607757836580276, + 0.04656539484858513, + 0.03186071291565895, + 0.06973536312580109, + 0.2925710678100586, + 0.1473870426416397, + 0.048693545162677765, + 0.14979593455791473, + 0.04255887493491173 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007635101210325956 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle shot of an orbital dock interior featuring a massive skeletal structure against space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive disc-shaped starship visible with a pearlescent white alloy hull covered in scratches and marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a rapid montage showing a plasma cutter on a robotic arm slicing the hull and sending out orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a medium shot shown where a magnetic clamp peels away a hull section to reveal blue energy conduits and crystalline data cores?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature an overhead shot of the stripped hull drifting toward a recovery area?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14280128479003906 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017801284790039 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14280128479003906, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14280128479003906, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07404544949531555, + 0.09641321748495102, + 0.1324593722820282, + 0.04951160028576851, + 0.1004430428147316, + 0.14294356107711792, + 0.0486019030213356, + 0.0934651792049408, + 0.11701123416423798, + 0.1451054811477661 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14280128479003906 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, captured with the calm, objective perspective of a documentary, slowly pans left, revealing the interior of a majestic orbital dock, its massive skeletal structure looming against the vast backdrop of space. At the center of the scene, a massive, disc-shaped starship hovers silently, its once-smooth, pearlescent white alloy hull now covered in tiny scratches and the marks of interstellar travel. Harsh, cold white highlights cast a powerful light from every corner of the dock, creating sharp highlights and deep shadows on the ship's curved surfaces, creating a clinical atmosphere reminiscent of an operating room. The scene then cuts to a rapid-fire montage: first a close-up of a plasma cutter at the end of a massive automated robotic arm, slicing through the hull with ruthless precision, sending out a shower of dazzling orange sparks. Next, a medium shot shows a massive magnetic clamp firmly grasping a section of the severed hull and carefully peeling it away, like peeling back a layer of skin, revealing a breathtakingly complex interior—a maze of shimmering blue energy conduits, layers of crystalline data cores, and a spiderweb of structural support ribs. Another rapid overhead shot captures the massive, stripped-away hull slowly drifting toward the recovery area, its sheer size emphasizing the systematic and monumental nature of the disassembly process. The entire montage is calm and methodical, devoid of any hint of chaos, showcasing the beauty of industrial, systematic deconstruction, as if composing a solemn and chilling visual elegy for the end of this magnificent starship.", + "seed": 28755, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_5/index_5925_seed_28755_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.12283672634512185, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12283672634512185, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12283672634512185, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle shot of an orbital dock interior featuring a massive skeletal structure against space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive disc-shaped starship visible with a pearlescent white alloy hull covered in scratches and marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a rapid montage showing a plasma cutter on a robotic arm slicing the hull and sending out orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a medium shot shown where a magnetic clamp peels away a hull section to reveal blue energy conduits and crystalline data cores?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature an overhead shot of the stripped hull drifting toward a recovery area?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47578203678131104 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.975782036781311 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47578203678131104, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47578203678131104, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2915509045124054, + 0.10109760612249374, + 0.2559601068496704, + 0.08432570099830627, + 0.08080580085515976, + 0.03551717847585678, + 0.03682616353034973, + 0.021416079252958298, + 0.05676752328872681, + 0.035732921212911606 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47578203678131104 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle shot of an orbital dock interior featuring a massive skeletal structure against space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive disc-shaped starship visible with a pearlescent white alloy hull covered in scratches and marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a rapid montage showing a plasma cutter on a robotic arm slicing the hull and sending out orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a medium shot shown where a magnetic clamp peels away a hull section to reveal blue energy conduits and crystalline data cores?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature an overhead shot of the stripped hull drifting toward a recovery area?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016117870807647705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141118049621582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016117870807647705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016117870807647705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08871487528085709, + 0.10914702713489532, + 0.25447291135787964, + 0.08418962359428406, + 0.09073198586702347, + 0.0652652457356453, + 0.05096583440899849, + 0.06621720641851425, + 0.11291489750146866, + 0.0773804560303688 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016117870807647705 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle shot of an orbital dock interior featuring a massive skeletal structure against space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive disc-shaped starship visible with a pearlescent white alloy hull covered in scratches and marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a rapid montage showing a plasma cutter on a robotic arm slicing the hull and sending out orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a medium shot shown where a magnetic clamp peels away a hull section to reveal blue energy conduits and crystalline data cores?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature an overhead shot of the stripped hull drifting toward a recovery area?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06206262484192848 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120627403259277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06206262484192848, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06206262484192848, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04091320559382439, + 0.03109137713909149, + 0.7025133371353149, + 0.03839349001646042, + 0.033634454011917114, + 0.030894501134753227, + 0.01527052279561758, + 0.059713758528232574, + 0.019835572689771652, + 0.02773982472717762 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06206262484192848 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle shot of an orbital dock interior featuring a massive skeletal structure against space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive disc-shaped starship visible with a pearlescent white alloy hull covered in scratches and marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a rapid montage showing a plasma cutter on a robotic arm slicing the hull and sending out orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a medium shot shown where a magnetic clamp peels away a hull section to reveal blue energy conduits and crystalline data cores?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature an overhead shot of the stripped hull drifting toward a recovery area?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005259131081402302 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255259037017822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005259131081402302, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005259131081402302, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11595233529806137, + 0.04301377385854721, + 0.26684239506721497, + 0.08338948339223862, + 0.1045350581407547, + 0.05129166692495346, + 0.04753842204809189, + 0.14682716131210327, + 0.07484414428472519, + 0.06576555222272873 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005259131081402302 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a wide-angle shot of an orbital dock interior featuring a massive skeletal structure against space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive disc-shaped starship visible with a pearlescent white alloy hull covered in scratches and marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video include a rapid montage showing a plasma cutter on a robotic arm slicing the hull and sending out orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a medium shot shown where a magnetic clamp peels away a hull section to reveal blue energy conduits and crystalline data cores?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature an overhead shot of the stripped hull drifting toward a recovery area?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496196821331978 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929961919784546 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496196821331978, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496196821331978, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06005920097231865, + 0.08031531423330307, + 0.16126595437526703, + 0.059878453612327576, + 0.08124526590108871, + 0.034167248755693436, + 0.04091335088014603, + 0.2591307759284973, + 0.08416375517845154, + 0.13886065781116486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496196821331978 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_6/index_tensor([2034, 2034])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_6/index_tensor([2034, 2034])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..afdc3faf0f242c97e1fd80218417280ff421971f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_6/index_tensor([2034, 2034])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "majestic, high-angle, wide shot begins, the camera tracking smoothly parallel to a cable car as it silently glides across a vast, deep chasm. The car is a modern cabin with a sleek red paint job that reflects the evening sunlight. Through the large, crystal-clear windows, the dark silhouettes of several passengers are visible, each leaning eagerly against the glass, their postures conveying a sense of silent awe. Below them, a rugged, gray-stone terrain dotted with clusters of dark pine trees descends steeply into a valley completely filled with a thick, cotton-like mist that gently swirls. In the distance, a spectacular mountain range unfolds, its jagged peaks gleaming golden in the low-hanging sunlight, casting long, dramatic shadows across the landscape. The scene is imbued with a refreshing, tranquil atmosphere, the play of warm light against the cool mountains and mist evoking a sense of majestic tranquility and the whispered promise of adventure hidden within the winding paths and unseen lakes below.", + "seed": 1420, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_6/index_2034_seed_1420_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04887258866801858, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04887258866801858, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04887258866801858, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle wide shot of a cable car gliding across a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cable car a modern cabin with a sleek red paint job reflecting sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark silhouettes of several passengers visible inside the car leaning against the windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the terrain below rugged gray stone dotted with dark pine trees descending into a valley filled with thick mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly parallel to the cable car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09244561940431595 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4674456119537354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09244561940431595, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09244561940431595, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2303376942873001, + 0.05398872122168541, + 0.29500070214271545, + 0.03758969530463219, + 0.1166735589504242, + 0.03943705931305885, + 0.04518948495388031, + 0.0365118682384491, + 0.030955011025071144, + 0.1143161877989769 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09244561940431595 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle wide shot of a cable car gliding across a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cable car a modern cabin with a sleek red paint job reflecting sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark silhouettes of several passengers visible inside the car leaning against the windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the terrain below rugged gray stone dotted with dark pine trees descending into a valley filled with thick mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly parallel to the cable car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043075501918792725 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680755615234375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043075501918792725, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043075501918792725, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1589917540550232, + 0.18080300092697144, + 0.16046369075775146, + 0.09819180518388748, + 0.11076078563928604, + 0.031496595591306686, + 0.03561009466648102, + 0.05969128757715225, + 0.10186465829610825, + 0.06212630867958069 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043075501918792725 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle wide shot of a cable car gliding across a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cable car a modern cabin with a sleek red paint job reflecting sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark silhouettes of several passengers visible inside the car leaning against the windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the terrain below rugged gray stone dotted with dark pine trees descending into a valley filled with thick mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly parallel to the cable car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865795746445656 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486578941345215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865795746445656, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865795746445656, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.39360764622688293, + 0.08281439542770386, + 0.13341084122657776, + 0.05061934515833855, + 0.05727945268154144, + 0.038035523146390915, + 0.036432113498449326, + 0.059223394840955734, + 0.06869949400424957, + 0.07987784594297409 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865795746445656 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle wide shot of a cable car gliding across a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cable car a modern cabin with a sleek red paint job reflecting sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark silhouettes of several passengers visible inside the car leaning against the windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the terrain below rugged gray stone dotted with dark pine trees descending into a valley filled with thick mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly parallel to the cable car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005252134520560503 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255252361297607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005252134520560503, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005252134520560503, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4378991425037384, + 0.07183430343866348, + 0.17222818732261658, + 0.019720304757356644, + 0.06558531522750854, + 0.03966702148318291, + 0.04204351082444191, + 0.04258647561073303, + 0.03747577592730522, + 0.07095997780561447 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005252134520560503 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle wide shot of a cable car gliding across a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cable car a modern cabin with a sleek red paint job reflecting sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark silhouettes of several passengers visible inside the car leaning against the windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the terrain below rugged gray stone dotted with dark pine trees descending into a valley filled with thick mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly parallel to the cable car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05493173003196716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929931640625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05493173003196716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05493173003196716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34509897232055664, + 0.06119030714035034, + 0.09943896532058716, + 0.0600418858230114, + 0.07803696393966675, + 0.03200969472527504, + 0.09712273627519608, + 0.05110366269946098, + 0.05635923519730568, + 0.11959758400917053 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05493173003196716 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "majestic, high-angle, wide shot begins, the camera tracking smoothly parallel to a cable car as it silently glides across a vast, deep chasm. The car is a modern cabin with a sleek red paint job that reflects the evening sunlight. Through the large, crystal-clear windows, the dark silhouettes of several passengers are visible, each leaning eagerly against the glass, their postures conveying a sense of silent awe. Below them, a rugged, gray-stone terrain dotted with clusters of dark pine trees descends steeply into a valley completely filled with a thick, cotton-like mist that gently swirls. In the distance, a spectacular mountain range unfolds, its jagged peaks gleaming golden in the low-hanging sunlight, casting long, dramatic shadows across the landscape. The scene is imbued with a refreshing, tranquil atmosphere, the play of warm light against the cool mountains and mist evoking a sense of majestic tranquility and the whispered promise of adventure hidden within the winding paths and unseen lakes below.", + "seed": 1421, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_6/index_2034_seed_1421_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0492154804058373, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0492154804058373, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0492154804058373, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle wide shot of a cable car gliding across a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cable car a modern cabin with a sleek red paint job reflecting sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark silhouettes of several passengers visible inside the car leaning against the windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the terrain below rugged gray stone dotted with dark pine trees descending into a valley filled with thick mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly parallel to the cable car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.030596861615777016 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.530596971511841 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.030596861615777016, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.030596861615777016, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13175269961357117, + 0.05380644649267197, + 0.1469448357820511, + 0.2584480941295624, + 0.09066449850797653, + 0.08373324573040009, + 0.09883365035057068, + 0.05930442363023758, + 0.04117114841938019, + 0.03534095361828804 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.030596861615777016 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle wide shot of a cable car gliding across a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cable car a modern cabin with a sleek red paint job reflecting sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark silhouettes of several passengers visible inside the car leaning against the windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the terrain below rugged gray stone dotted with dark pine trees descending into a valley filled with thick mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly parallel to the cable car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10033199936151505 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350332021713257 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10033199936151505, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10033199936151505, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11725786328315735, + 0.044367384165525436, + 0.29691383242607117, + 0.09412623196840286, + 0.0966269001364708, + 0.15484552085399628, + 0.0357200987637043, + 0.02942027524113655, + 0.08399298787117004, + 0.04672893136739731 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10033199936151505 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle wide shot of a cable car gliding across a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cable car a modern cabin with a sleek red paint job reflecting sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark silhouettes of several passengers visible inside the car leaning against the windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the terrain below rugged gray stone dotted with dark pine trees descending into a valley filled with thick mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly parallel to the cable car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496366322040558 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299635887145996 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496366322040558, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496366322040558, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1975957602262497, + 0.038527317345142365, + 0.14815008640289307, + 0.09905854612588882, + 0.0748862698674202, + 0.1373874843120575, + 0.09547172486782074, + 0.06955747306346893, + 0.06588028371334076, + 0.07348505407571793 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496366322040558 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle wide shot of a cable car gliding across a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cable car a modern cabin with a sleek red paint job reflecting sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark silhouettes of several passengers visible inside the car leaning against the windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the terrain below rugged gray stone dotted with dark pine trees descending into a valley filled with thick mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly parallel to the cable car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005252134520560503 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255252361297607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005252134520560503, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005252134520560503, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1330852210521698, + 0.04164768010377884, + 0.30229899287223816, + 0.11973532289266586, + 0.06693839281797409, + 0.09259369224309921, + 0.04709898680448532, + 0.07356831431388855, + 0.05980353802442551, + 0.06322991102933884 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005252134520560503 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle wide shot of a cable car gliding across a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cable car a modern cabin with a sleek red paint job reflecting sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark silhouettes of several passengers visible inside the car leaning against the windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the terrain below rugged gray stone dotted with dark pine trees descending into a valley filled with thick mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly parallel to the cable car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054932743310928345 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299328327178955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054932743310928345, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054932743310928345, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1084706261754036, + 0.0718262642621994, + 0.06956475228071213, + 0.09241742640733719, + 0.11101323366165161, + 0.10382386296987534, + 0.18977925181388855, + 0.07747509330511093, + 0.09007368981838226, + 0.0855557769536972 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054932743310928345 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "majestic, high-angle, wide shot begins, the camera tracking smoothly parallel to a cable car as it silently glides across a vast, deep chasm. The car is a modern cabin with a sleek red paint job that reflects the evening sunlight. Through the large, crystal-clear windows, the dark silhouettes of several passengers are visible, each leaning eagerly against the glass, their postures conveying a sense of silent awe. Below them, a rugged, gray-stone terrain dotted with clusters of dark pine trees descends steeply into a valley completely filled with a thick, cotton-like mist that gently swirls. In the distance, a spectacular mountain range unfolds, its jagged peaks gleaming golden in the low-hanging sunlight, casting long, dramatic shadows across the landscape. The scene is imbued with a refreshing, tranquil atmosphere, the play of warm light against the cool mountains and mist evoking a sense of majestic tranquility and the whispered promise of adventure hidden within the winding paths and unseen lakes below.", + "seed": 1422, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_6/index_2034_seed_1422_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04448834182694554, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04448834182694554, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04448834182694554, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle wide shot of a cable car gliding across a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cable car a modern cabin with a sleek red paint job reflecting sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark silhouettes of several passengers visible inside the car leaning against the windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the terrain below rugged gray stone dotted with dark pine trees descending into a valley filled with thick mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly parallel to the cable car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05052044615149498 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.050520420074463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05052044615149498, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05052044615149498, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29603081941604614, + 0.10411075502634048, + 0.23898319900035858, + 0.0821588784456253, + 0.02157033048570156, + 0.02851014770567417, + 0.036233872175216675, + 0.085855633020401, + 0.07434851676225662, + 0.03219791501760483 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05052044615149498 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle wide shot of a cable car gliding across a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cable car a modern cabin with a sleek red paint job reflecting sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark silhouettes of several passengers visible inside the car leaning against the windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the terrain below rugged gray stone dotted with dark pine trees descending into a valley filled with thick mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly parallel to the cable car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10033857077360153 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503384590148926 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10033857077360153, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10033857077360153, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08055725693702698, + 0.1492653489112854, + 0.14901265501976013, + 0.024210231378674507, + 0.016706638038158417, + 0.04405951872467995, + 0.09368361532688141, + 0.05259758606553078, + 0.30836230516433716, + 0.08154484629631042 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10033857077360153 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle wide shot of a cable car gliding across a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cable car a modern cabin with a sleek red paint job reflecting sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark silhouettes of several passengers visible inside the car leaning against the windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the terrain below rugged gray stone dotted with dark pine trees descending into a valley filled with thick mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly parallel to the cable car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023289121687412262 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773289203643799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023289121687412262, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023289121687412262, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27327749133110046, + 0.05928928032517433, + 0.14046010375022888, + 0.11234214156866074, + 0.04967270419001579, + 0.07392723858356476, + 0.05432858690619469, + 0.034083425998687744, + 0.1377476453781128, + 0.06487135589122772 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023289121687412262 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle wide shot of a cable car gliding across a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cable car a modern cabin with a sleek red paint job reflecting sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark silhouettes of several passengers visible inside the car leaning against the windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the terrain below rugged gray stone dotted with dark pine trees descending into a valley filled with thick mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly parallel to the cable car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005251067224889994 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255250930786133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005251067224889994, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005251067224889994, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10883088409900665, + 0.19856570661067963, + 0.1575491577386856, + 0.0555143840610981, + 0.04393114149570465, + 0.0718306452035904, + 0.05649661272764206, + 0.061145611107349396, + 0.13542678952217102, + 0.11070910841226578 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005251067224889994 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle wide shot of a cable car gliding across a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cable car a modern cabin with a sleek red paint job reflecting sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark silhouettes of several passengers visible inside the car leaning against the windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the terrain below rugged gray stone dotted with dark pine trees descending into a valley filled with thick mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly parallel to the cable car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04304250329732895 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680424213409424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04304250329732895, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04304250329732895, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1863885074853897, + 0.20722249150276184, + 0.1421297937631607, + 0.05446269363164902, + 0.0698254182934761, + 0.08800872415304184, + 0.08256063610315323, + 0.053170736879110336, + 0.06608067452907562, + 0.0501503124833107 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04304250329732895 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "majestic, high-angle, wide shot begins, the camera tracking smoothly parallel to a cable car as it silently glides across a vast, deep chasm. The car is a modern cabin with a sleek red paint job that reflects the evening sunlight. Through the large, crystal-clear windows, the dark silhouettes of several passengers are visible, each leaning eagerly against the glass, their postures conveying a sense of silent awe. Below them, a rugged, gray-stone terrain dotted with clusters of dark pine trees descends steeply into a valley completely filled with a thick, cotton-like mist that gently swirls. In the distance, a spectacular mountain range unfolds, its jagged peaks gleaming golden in the low-hanging sunlight, casting long, dramatic shadows across the landscape. The scene is imbued with a refreshing, tranquil atmosphere, the play of warm light against the cool mountains and mist evoking a sense of majestic tranquility and the whispered promise of adventure hidden within the winding paths and unseen lakes below.", + "seed": 1423, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_6/index_2034_seed_1423_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.058893158892169596, + "vlm_logprob": -0.058893158892169596, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.058893158892169596, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle wide shot of a cable car gliding across a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cable car a modern cabin with a sleek red paint job reflecting sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark silhouettes of several passengers visible inside the car leaning against the windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the terrain below rugged gray stone dotted with dark pine trees descending into a valley filled with thick mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly parallel to the cable car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019225211814045906 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.144225120544434 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019225211814045906, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019225211814045906, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16201971471309662, + 0.10356473922729492, + 0.03393884748220444, + 0.1209789589047432, + 0.10035794228315353, + 0.04539217799901962, + 0.15202908217906952, + 0.14433182775974274, + 0.09516268223524094, + 0.0422239750623703 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019225211814045906 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle wide shot of a cable car gliding across a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cable car a modern cabin with a sleek red paint job reflecting sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark silhouettes of several passengers visible inside the car leaning against the windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the terrain below rugged gray stone dotted with dark pine trees descending into a valley filled with thick mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly parallel to the cable car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17991206049919128 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049120903015137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17991206049919128, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17991206049919128, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09982874244451523, + 0.06779392808675766, + 0.07052500545978546, + 0.05591464787721634, + 0.050293438136577606, + 0.07301227748394012, + 0.06010664254426956, + 0.07323366403579712, + 0.24866285920143127, + 0.20062881708145142 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17991206049919128 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle wide shot of a cable car gliding across a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cable car a modern cabin with a sleek red paint job reflecting sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark silhouettes of several passengers visible inside the car leaning against the windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the terrain below rugged gray stone dotted with dark pine trees descending into a valley filled with thick mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly parallel to the cable car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0430726483464241 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680727005004883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0430726483464241, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0430726483464241, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08349587023258209, + 0.12065580487251282, + 0.0640021562576294, + 0.09125074744224548, + 0.05080554634332657, + 0.08194304257631302, + 0.1002841666340828, + 0.11245017498731613, + 0.16415700316429138, + 0.13095548748970032 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0430726483464241 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle wide shot of a cable car gliding across a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cable car a modern cabin with a sleek red paint job reflecting sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark silhouettes of several passengers visible inside the car leaning against the windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the terrain below rugged gray stone dotted with dark pine trees descending into a valley filled with thick mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly parallel to the cable car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003615630092099309 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628615856170654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003615630092099309, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003615630092099309, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09476204961538315, + 0.08436484634876251, + 0.0483865812420845, + 0.03283264487981796, + 0.03718012571334839, + 0.068102166056633, + 0.0738879144191742, + 0.19496965408325195, + 0.27120402455329895, + 0.09431000053882599 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003615630092099309 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle wide shot of a cable car gliding across a deep chasm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cable car a modern cabin with a sleek red paint job reflecting sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark silhouettes of several passengers visible inside the car leaning against the windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the terrain below rugged gray stone dotted with dark pine trees descending into a valley filled with thick mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly parallel to the cable car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864024370908737 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048640251159668 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864024370908737, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864024370908737, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12183979898691177, + 0.13789039850234985, + 0.05378520488739014, + 0.06447850167751312, + 0.07910484075546265, + 0.09945645183324814, + 0.122118279337883, + 0.07061982154846191, + 0.15142087638378143, + 0.09928581118583679 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864024370908737 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_7/index_tensor([1115, 1115])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_7/index_tensor([1115, 1115])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..abab1c1dd007501a63b542a52e75d2a5a6f1fe79 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_7/index_tensor([1115, 1115])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a level angle, the camera slowly panning to the right, following the subject's movements. A hand, slightly dry and knuckled, cautiously reaches deep into the shadows of an old, dark mahogany bookshelf, its surface covered in a thin, uneven layer of dust. A beam of warm, focused light slants down from above and sideways, precisely illuminating this small area. The tiny dust particles raised by the hand's movement sparkle and dance like golden stardust. A finger gently rests on the spine of a thick, dark brown leather-bound book, the worn leather revealing the marks of age and faded gilt patterns. Then, with his fingers firmly grasping the upper edge of the book, he pulled it out from the tightly packed books with a slow and respectful force. As the book moved, it rubbed against the bookshelf, making a low rustling sound, and its heavy weight made his wrist slightly tense. The whole scene, in the dim light and shadow contrast, created a quiet, focused and historical mysterious atmosphere.", + "seed": 27292, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_7/index_1115_seed_27292_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.19954289868474007, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19954289868474007, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19954289868474007, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand reaching into the shadows of an old, dark mahogany bookshelf covered in dust visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, focused light slanting down from above and sideways illuminating the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a finger rest on and then pull out a thick, dark brown leather-bound book with faded gilt patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07571810483932495 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.325717926025391 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07571810483932495, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07571810483932495, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11960285156965256, + 0.040692590177059174, + 0.06028684973716736, + 0.05194029211997986, + 0.034720927476882935, + 0.20778541266918182, + 0.05869824066758156, + 0.1674177050590515, + 0.12208448350429535, + 0.13677066564559937 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07571810483932495 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand reaching into the shadows of an old, dark mahogany bookshelf covered in dust visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, focused light slanting down from above and sideways illuminating the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a finger rest on and then pull out a thick, dark brown leather-bound book with faded gilt patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983125686645508 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233125686645508 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8983125686645508, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8983125686645508, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0509624257683754, + 0.07493770122528076, + 0.09137757122516632, + 0.060474272817373276, + 0.03954244777560234, + 0.0867578461766243, + 0.05491108074784279, + 0.22600743174552917, + 0.2447809875011444, + 0.07024816423654556 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8983125686645508 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand reaching into the shadows of an old, dark mahogany bookshelf covered in dust visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, focused light slanting down from above and sideways illuminating the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a finger rest on and then pull out a thick, dark brown leather-bound book with faded gilt patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012551599182188511 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387551784515381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012551599182188511, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012551599182188511, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04345763474702835, + 0.03373659774661064, + 0.03957410156726837, + 0.06834053248167038, + 0.042018163949251175, + 0.14842362701892853, + 0.0420302152633667, + 0.07382908463478088, + 0.28302183747291565, + 0.22556822001934052 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012551599182188511 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand reaching into the shadows of an old, dark mahogany bookshelf covered in dust visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, focused light slanting down from above and sideways illuminating the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a finger rest on and then pull out a thick, dark brown leather-bound book with faded gilt patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024906350299715996 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002490520477295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024906350299715996, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024906350299715996, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08811325579881668, + 0.050607625395059586, + 0.02786731906235218, + 0.012209736742079258, + 0.038747116923332214, + 0.037387289106845856, + 0.12350445240736008, + 0.4119505286216736, + 0.04738427326083183, + 0.16222843527793884 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024906350299715996 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand reaching into the shadows of an old, dark mahogany bookshelf covered in dust visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, focused light slanting down from above and sideways illuminating the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a finger rest on and then pull out a thick, dark brown leather-bound book with faded gilt patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00864158570766449 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758641719818115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00864158570766449, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00864158570766449, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10071229934692383, + 0.053900036960840225, + 0.10331305861473083, + 0.02725893072783947, + 0.04224381595849991, + 0.17394576966762543, + 0.2266130894422531, + 0.05247875303030014, + 0.07831796258687973, + 0.1412162184715271 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00864158570766449 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a level angle, the camera slowly panning to the right, following the subject's movements. A hand, slightly dry and knuckled, cautiously reaches deep into the shadows of an old, dark mahogany bookshelf, its surface covered in a thin, uneven layer of dust. A beam of warm, focused light slants down from above and sideways, precisely illuminating this small area. The tiny dust particles raised by the hand's movement sparkle and dance like golden stardust. A finger gently rests on the spine of a thick, dark brown leather-bound book, the worn leather revealing the marks of age and faded gilt patterns. Then, with his fingers firmly grasping the upper edge of the book, he pulled it out from the tightly packed books with a slow and respectful force. As the book moved, it rubbed against the bookshelf, making a low rustling sound, and its heavy weight made his wrist slightly tense. The whole scene, in the dim light and shadow contrast, created a quiet, focused and historical mysterious atmosphere.", + "seed": 27293, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_7/index_1115_seed_27293_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.199019568040967, + "vlm_logprob": -0.199019568040967, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.199019568040967, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand reaching into the shadows of an old, dark mahogany bookshelf covered in dust visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, focused light slanting down from above and sideways illuminating the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a finger rest on and then pull out a thick, dark brown leather-bound book with faded gilt patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.058329470455646515 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.9333295822143555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.058329470455646515, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.058329470455646515, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08209129422903061, + 0.09518629312515259, + 0.09172505140304565, + 0.08755554258823395, + 0.07789445668458939, + 0.12419205904006958, + 0.04028087481856346, + 0.04920395091176033, + 0.05904177203774452, + 0.29282864928245544 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.058329470455646515 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand reaching into the shadows of an old, dark mahogany bookshelf covered in dust visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, focused light slanting down from above and sideways illuminating the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a finger rest on and then pull out a thick, dark brown leather-bound book with faded gilt patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983388543128967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233388543128967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8983388543128967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8983388543128967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06730622053146362, + 0.07264533638954163, + 0.09561699628829956, + 0.13807952404022217, + 0.08073491603136063, + 0.24393081665039062, + 0.05257541313767433, + 0.03359176591038704, + 0.08501021564006805, + 0.13050884008407593 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8983388543128967 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand reaching into the shadows of an old, dark mahogany bookshelf covered in dust visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, focused light slanting down from above and sideways illuminating the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a finger rest on and then pull out a thick, dark brown leather-bound book with faded gilt patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009796636179089546 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634796619415283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009796636179089546, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009796636179089546, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13113145530223846, + 0.09288512170314789, + 0.12812545895576477, + 0.09890719503164291, + 0.06074485555291176, + 0.10549759864807129, + 0.033067118376493454, + 0.059203263372182846, + 0.177162304520607, + 0.11327560245990753 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009796636179089546 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand reaching into the shadows of an old, dark mahogany bookshelf covered in dust visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, focused light slanting down from above and sideways illuminating the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a finger rest on and then pull out a thick, dark brown leather-bound book with faded gilt patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012554189190268517 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387554168701172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012554189190268517, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012554189190268517, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05999374762177467, + 0.11635513603687286, + 0.16680093109607697, + 0.11051584780216217, + 0.12434815615415573, + 0.1811634749174118, + 0.0394916869699955, + 0.035308849066495895, + 0.04816032946109772, + 0.11786184459924698 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012554189190268517 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand reaching into the shadows of an old, dark mahogany bookshelf covered in dust visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, focused light slanting down from above and sideways illuminating the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a finger rest on and then pull out a thick, dark brown leather-bound book with faded gilt patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016078690066933632 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141078472137451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016078690066933632, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016078690066933632, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22510218620300293, + 0.06914126873016357, + 0.09726130962371826, + 0.1075248122215271, + 0.05965111032128334, + 0.08970730751752853, + 0.07133703678846359, + 0.08343634754419327, + 0.06905675679445267, + 0.12778179347515106 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016078690066933632 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a level angle, the camera slowly panning to the right, following the subject's movements. A hand, slightly dry and knuckled, cautiously reaches deep into the shadows of an old, dark mahogany bookshelf, its surface covered in a thin, uneven layer of dust. A beam of warm, focused light slants down from above and sideways, precisely illuminating this small area. The tiny dust particles raised by the hand's movement sparkle and dance like golden stardust. A finger gently rests on the spine of a thick, dark brown leather-bound book, the worn leather revealing the marks of age and faded gilt patterns. Then, with his fingers firmly grasping the upper edge of the book, he pulled it out from the tightly packed books with a slow and respectful force. As the book moved, it rubbed against the bookshelf, making a low rustling sound, and its heavy weight made his wrist slightly tense. The whole scene, in the dim light and shadow contrast, created a quiet, focused and historical mysterious atmosphere.", + "seed": 27294, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_7/index_1115_seed_27294_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11335469223558903, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11335469223558903, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11335469223558903, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand reaching into the shadows of an old, dark mahogany bookshelf covered in dust visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, focused light slanting down from above and sideways illuminating the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a finger rest on and then pull out a thick, dark brown leather-bound book with faded gilt patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.13509640097618103 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.135096311569214 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.13509640097618103, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.13509640097618103, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22483818233013153, + 0.03737451881170273, + 0.06600885838270187, + 0.10730370134115219, + 0.030316762626171112, + 0.05317986384034157, + 0.06286301463842392, + 0.10160143673419952, + 0.21735996007919312, + 0.09915369749069214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.13509640097618103 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand reaching into the shadows of an old, dark mahogany bookshelf covered in dust visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, focused light slanting down from above and sideways illuminating the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a finger rest on and then pull out a thick, dark brown leather-bound book with faded gilt patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38709211349487305 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137092113494873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38709211349487305, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38709211349487305, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10716626048088074, + 0.03388531506061554, + 0.07237036526203156, + 0.11681021004915237, + 0.09853963553905487, + 0.10804756730794907, + 0.04909326881170273, + 0.1088261678814888, + 0.23004701733589172, + 0.07521411776542664 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38709211349487305 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand reaching into the shadows of an old, dark mahogany bookshelf covered in dust visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, focused light slanting down from above and sideways illuminating the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a finger rest on and then pull out a thick, dark brown leather-bound book with faded gilt patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059445157647133 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895594358444214 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059445157647133, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059445157647133, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2643810212612152, + 0.03522560000419617, + 0.10043803602457047, + 0.2888403534889221, + 0.026581084355711937, + 0.05220894515514374, + 0.030106695368885994, + 0.04254671931266785, + 0.048878081142902374, + 0.11079346388578415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059445157647133 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand reaching into the shadows of an old, dark mahogany bookshelf covered in dust visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, focused light slanting down from above and sideways illuminating the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a finger rest on and then pull out a thick, dark brown leather-bound book with faded gilt patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009789789095520973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634789943695068 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009789789095520973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009789789095520973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10178213566541672, + 0.21360968053340912, + 0.05946646258234978, + 0.05888441577553749, + 0.1873175948858261, + 0.041911426931619644, + 0.06053607538342476, + 0.08138154447078705, + 0.1321142464876175, + 0.06299643218517303 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009789789095520973 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand reaching into the shadows of an old, dark mahogany bookshelf covered in dust visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, focused light slanting down from above and sideways illuminating the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a finger rest on and then pull out a thick, dark brown leather-bound book with faded gilt patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014200706034898758 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264200687408447 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014200706034898758, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014200706034898758, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07563503831624985, + 0.0379471592605114, + 0.09320007264614105, + 0.2611800730228424, + 0.04151347652077675, + 0.18148785829544067, + 0.04566722363233566, + 0.06163046509027481, + 0.08462370187044144, + 0.11711491644382477 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014200706034898758 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a level angle, the camera slowly panning to the right, following the subject's movements. A hand, slightly dry and knuckled, cautiously reaches deep into the shadows of an old, dark mahogany bookshelf, its surface covered in a thin, uneven layer of dust. A beam of warm, focused light slants down from above and sideways, precisely illuminating this small area. The tiny dust particles raised by the hand's movement sparkle and dance like golden stardust. A finger gently rests on the spine of a thick, dark brown leather-bound book, the worn leather revealing the marks of age and faded gilt patterns. Then, with his fingers firmly grasping the upper edge of the book, he pulled it out from the tightly packed books with a slow and respectful force. As the book moved, it rubbed against the bookshelf, making a low rustling sound, and its heavy weight made his wrist slightly tense. The whole scene, in the dim light and shadow contrast, created a quiet, focused and historical mysterious atmosphere.", + "seed": 27295, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_7/index_1115_seed_27295_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.14565304196439682, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14565304196439682, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14565304196439682, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand reaching into the shadows of an old, dark mahogany bookshelf covered in dust visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, focused light slanting down from above and sideways illuminating the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a finger rest on and then pull out a thick, dark brown leather-bound book with faded gilt patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06674415618181229 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.441744089126587 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06674415618181229, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06674415618181229, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04224987328052521, + 0.0683232843875885, + 0.03770710900425911, + 0.09762381762266159, + 0.037105463445186615, + 0.03131936490535736, + 0.044934023171663284, + 0.05295922979712486, + 0.3204636871814728, + 0.2673141062259674 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06674415618181229 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand reaching into the shadows of an old, dark mahogany bookshelf covered in dust visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, focused light slanting down from above and sideways illuminating the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a finger rest on and then pull out a thick, dark brown leather-bound book with faded gilt patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.632813036441803 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.757813036441803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.632813036441803, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.632813036441803, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.027974428609013557, + 0.026915553957223892, + 0.06759913265705109, + 0.2522560656070709, + 0.03434458002448082, + 0.13398835062980652, + 0.01557284314185381, + 0.04737705737352371, + 0.22391432523727417, + 0.17005769908428192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.632813036441803 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand reaching into the shadows of an old, dark mahogany bookshelf covered in dust visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, focused light slanting down from above and sideways illuminating the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a finger rest on and then pull out a thick, dark brown leather-bound book with faded gilt patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012547479011118412 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387547492980957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012547479011118412, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012547479011118412, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.037399448454380035, + 0.026693034917116165, + 0.13283473253250122, + 0.08344753086566925, + 0.09791166335344315, + 0.04491369053721428, + 0.015501508489251137, + 0.16335685551166534, + 0.18458284437656403, + 0.21335864067077637 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012547479011118412 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand reaching into the shadows of an old, dark mahogany bookshelf covered in dust visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, focused light slanting down from above and sideways illuminating the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a finger rest on and then pull out a thick, dark brown leather-bound book with faded gilt patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003617767943069339 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628617763519287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003617767943069339, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003617767943069339, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05982701852917671, + 0.0653797835111618, + 0.06605532020330429, + 0.10294413566589355, + 0.026742661371827126, + 0.028504693880677223, + 0.03042593225836754, + 0.1836492121219635, + 0.09569477289915085, + 0.3407764434814453 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003617767943069339 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up filmed from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the subject's movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand reaching into the shadows of an old, dark mahogany bookshelf covered in dust visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm, focused light slanting down from above and sideways illuminating the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a finger rest on and then pull out a thick, dark brown leather-bound book with faded gilt patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012542770244181156 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387542724609375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012542770244181156, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012542770244181156, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02096235379576683, + 0.02798394486308098, + 0.033607084304094315, + 0.11805077642202377, + 0.03103122115135193, + 0.048642996698617935, + 0.020607462152838707, + 0.3790624439716339, + 0.12290279567241669, + 0.1971489042043686 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012542770244181156 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_8/index_tensor([1880, 1880])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_8/index_tensor([1880, 1880])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9f9409e16cbabf74ccff19d30bcc4b1b0319a6b2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_8/index_tensor([1880, 1880])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic low-angle tracking shot follows a tiny quadcopter drone as it executes a series of sharp, agile maneuvers. Constructed of matte black carbon fiber, the drone is equipped with four rapidly spinning propellers that become a transparent blur. It glides at incredible speed across a vast, smooth, dark gray surface, which tilts dramatically at a steep 45-degree angle within a minimalist studio setting. Bright, diffuse light from a large overhead studio softbox fills the scene, creating clean, elongated reflections that glide across the drone's chassis and polished ramp, casting soft but crisp shadows beneath the craft. The drone accelerates quickly and decisively up the slope, then aggressively banks in a tight, controlled arc, its body tilting almost parallel to the surface, demonstrating its extreme agility and creating an atmosphere of high-tech, focused, and energetic energy.", + "seed": 13839, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_8/index_1880_seed_13839_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.059536698670126495, + "vlm_logprob": -0.059536698670126495, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.059536698670126495, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tiny quadcopter drone constructed of matte black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the drone execute sharp, agile maneuvers including accelerating up a steep 45-degree slope and banking in a tight arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a minimalist studio setting with a vast, smooth, dark gray surface tilted at a 45-degree angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the propellers visible as a transparent blur due to rapid spinning, and are there clean, elongated reflections on the drone and ramp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic low-angle tracking shot illuminated by bright, diffuse light from a large overhead studio softbox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25394609570503235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.50394606590271 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25394609570503235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25394609570503235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03715343773365021, + 0.07504716515541077, + 0.09461700916290283, + 0.07742708176374435, + 0.016561394557356834, + 0.027094878256320953, + 0.024693284183740616, + 0.4273979067802429, + 0.10854320973157883, + 0.11146464198827744 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25394609570503235 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tiny quadcopter drone constructed of matte black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the drone execute sharp, agile maneuvers including accelerating up a steep 45-degree slope and banking in a tight arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a minimalist studio setting with a vast, smooth, dark gray surface tilted at a 45-degree angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the propellers visible as a transparent blur due to rapid spinning, and are there clean, elongated reflections on the drone and ramp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic low-angle tracking shot illuminated by bright, diffuse light from a large overhead studio softbox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011088770814239979 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511088848114014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011088770814239979, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011088770814239979, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02973727509379387, + 0.030985765159130096, + 0.09753895550966263, + 0.02283763326704502, + 0.012388620525598526, + 0.08672325313091278, + 0.06341235339641571, + 0.44836100935935974, + 0.07575824856758118, + 0.1322569102048874 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011088770814239979 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tiny quadcopter drone constructed of matte black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the drone execute sharp, agile maneuvers including accelerating up a steep 45-degree slope and banking in a tight arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a minimalist studio setting with a vast, smooth, dark gray surface tilted at a 45-degree angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the propellers visible as a transparent blur due to rapid spinning, and are there clean, elongated reflections on the drone and ramp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic low-angle tracking shot illuminated by bright, diffuse light from a large overhead studio softbox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01817934401333332 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018179416656494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01817934401333332, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01817934401333332, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04697718843817711, + 0.0908588245511055, + 0.2698940932750702, + 0.032205596566200256, + 0.007122947834432125, + 0.03466194495558739, + 0.07059275358915329, + 0.31480687856674194, + 0.10191795229911804, + 0.030961843207478523 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01817934401333332 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tiny quadcopter drone constructed of matte black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the drone execute sharp, agile maneuvers including accelerating up a steep 45-degree slope and banking in a tight arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a minimalist studio setting with a vast, smooth, dark gray surface tilted at a 45-degree angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the propellers visible as a transparent blur due to rapid spinning, and are there clean, elongated reflections on the drone and ramp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic low-angle tracking shot illuminated by bright, diffuse light from a large overhead studio softbox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019414640264585614 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251941680908203 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019414640264585614, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019414640264585614, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05329703167080879, + 0.045795682817697525, + 0.12922096252441406, + 0.02856517769396305, + 0.04914052039384842, + 0.038766421377658844, + 0.04411987587809563, + 0.3100264370441437, + 0.12864874303340912, + 0.17241908609867096 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019414640264585614 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tiny quadcopter drone constructed of matte black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the drone execute sharp, agile maneuvers including accelerating up a steep 45-degree slope and banking in a tight arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a minimalist studio setting with a vast, smooth, dark gray surface tilted at a 45-degree angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the propellers visible as a transparent blur due to rapid spinning, and are there clean, elongated reflections on the drone and ramp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic low-angle tracking shot illuminated by bright, diffuse light from a large overhead studio softbox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01252781879156828 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387527942657471 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01252781879156828, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01252781879156828, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.057706546038389206, + 0.052203468978405, + 0.12114512920379639, + 0.04258110746741295, + 0.046033378690481186, + 0.02225080132484436, + 0.04308440163731575, + 0.41210103034973145, + 0.10510098189115524, + 0.09779313206672668 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01252781879156828 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic low-angle tracking shot follows a tiny quadcopter drone as it executes a series of sharp, agile maneuvers. Constructed of matte black carbon fiber, the drone is equipped with four rapidly spinning propellers that become a transparent blur. It glides at incredible speed across a vast, smooth, dark gray surface, which tilts dramatically at a steep 45-degree angle within a minimalist studio setting. Bright, diffuse light from a large overhead studio softbox fills the scene, creating clean, elongated reflections that glide across the drone's chassis and polished ramp, casting soft but crisp shadows beneath the craft. The drone accelerates quickly and decisively up the slope, then aggressively banks in a tight, controlled arc, its body tilting almost parallel to the surface, demonstrating its extreme agility and creating an atmosphere of high-tech, focused, and energetic energy.", + "seed": 13840, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_8/index_1880_seed_13840_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.10394814624451101, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10394814624451101, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10394814624451101, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tiny quadcopter drone constructed of matte black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the drone execute sharp, agile maneuvers including accelerating up a steep 45-degree slope and banking in a tight arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a minimalist studio setting with a vast, smooth, dark gray surface tilted at a 45-degree angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the propellers visible as a transparent blur due to rapid spinning, and are there clean, elongated reflections on the drone and ramp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic low-angle tracking shot illuminated by bright, diffuse light from a large overhead studio softbox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.43464604020118713 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0596460103988647 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.43464604020118713, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.43464604020118713, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15980476140975952, + 0.04600886255502701, + 0.04800880327820778, + 0.029460281133651733, + 0.32848435640335083, + 0.1139531135559082, + 0.11266566812992096, + 0.0929400846362114, + 0.040600862354040146, + 0.02807326801121235 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.43464604020118713 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tiny quadcopter drone constructed of matte black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the drone execute sharp, agile maneuvers including accelerating up a steep 45-degree slope and banking in a tight arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a minimalist studio setting with a vast, smooth, dark gray surface tilted at a 45-degree angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the propellers visible as a transparent blur due to rapid spinning, and are there clean, elongated reflections on the drone and ramp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic low-angle tracking shot illuminated by bright, diffuse light from a large overhead studio softbox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06212368234992027 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8121237754821777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06212368234992027, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06212368234992027, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16000771522521973, + 0.039686981588602066, + 0.119165800511837, + 0.08280672132968903, + 0.10356704890727997, + 0.14407344162464142, + 0.10095681250095367, + 0.04548504203557968, + 0.10717769712209702, + 0.09707273542881012 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06212368234992027 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tiny quadcopter drone constructed of matte black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the drone execute sharp, agile maneuvers including accelerating up a steep 45-degree slope and banking in a tight arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a minimalist studio setting with a vast, smooth, dark gray surface tilted at a 45-degree angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the propellers visible as a transparent blur due to rapid spinning, and are there clean, elongated reflections on the drone and ramp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic low-angle tracking shot illuminated by bright, diffuse light from a large overhead studio softbox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005951303523033857 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130951404571533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005951303523033857, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005951303523033857, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1825554072856903, + 0.08652828633785248, + 0.0425918810069561, + 0.17349115014076233, + 0.3006492853164673, + 0.0664496123790741, + 0.034900497645139694, + 0.01751885749399662, + 0.027692805975675583, + 0.06762215495109558 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005951303523033857 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tiny quadcopter drone constructed of matte black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the drone execute sharp, agile maneuvers including accelerating up a steep 45-degree slope and banking in a tight arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a minimalist studio setting with a vast, smooth, dark gray surface tilted at a 45-degree angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the propellers visible as a transparent blur due to rapid spinning, and are there clean, elongated reflections on the drone and ramp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic low-angle tracking shot illuminated by bright, diffuse light from a large overhead studio softbox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028276958037167788 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778276443481445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028276958037167788, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028276958037167788, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13198363780975342, + 0.06444375962018967, + 0.055659811943769455, + 0.04803387075662613, + 0.3703865706920624, + 0.13486763834953308, + 0.04816960543394089, + 0.06062512472271919, + 0.026483632624149323, + 0.05934635549783707 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028276958037167788 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tiny quadcopter drone constructed of matte black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the drone execute sharp, agile maneuvers including accelerating up a steep 45-degree slope and banking in a tight arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a minimalist studio setting with a vast, smooth, dark gray surface tilted at a 45-degree angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the propellers visible as a transparent blur due to rapid spinning, and are there clean, elongated reflections on the drone and ramp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic low-angle tracking shot illuminated by bright, diffuse light from a large overhead studio softbox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014192009344696999 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2641921043396 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014192009344696999, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014192009344696999, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10721956938505173, + 0.13828441500663757, + 0.18505103886127472, + 0.08078036457300186, + 0.2717460095882416, + 0.07994358986616135, + 0.028026960790157318, + 0.013122259639203548, + 0.05264759436249733, + 0.04317820817232132 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014192009344696999 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic low-angle tracking shot follows a tiny quadcopter drone as it executes a series of sharp, agile maneuvers. Constructed of matte black carbon fiber, the drone is equipped with four rapidly spinning propellers that become a transparent blur. It glides at incredible speed across a vast, smooth, dark gray surface, which tilts dramatically at a steep 45-degree angle within a minimalist studio setting. Bright, diffuse light from a large overhead studio softbox fills the scene, creating clean, elongated reflections that glide across the drone's chassis and polished ramp, casting soft but crisp shadows beneath the craft. The drone accelerates quickly and decisively up the slope, then aggressively banks in a tight, controlled arc, its body tilting almost parallel to the surface, demonstrating its extreme agility and creating an atmosphere of high-tech, focused, and energetic energy.", + "seed": 13841, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_8/index_1880_seed_13841_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.036417868873104456, + "vlm_logprob": -0.036417868873104456, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.036417868873104456, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tiny quadcopter drone constructed of matte black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the drone execute sharp, agile maneuvers including accelerating up a steep 45-degree slope and banking in a tight arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a minimalist studio setting with a vast, smooth, dark gray surface tilted at a 45-degree angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the propellers visible as a transparent blur due to rapid spinning, and are there clean, elongated reflections on the drone and ramp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic low-angle tracking shot illuminated by bright, diffuse light from a large overhead studio softbox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1461220383644104 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0211219787597656 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1461220383644104, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1461220383644104, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3622342050075531, + 0.059181395918130875, + 0.11553874611854553, + 0.10602839291095734, + 0.05490689352154732, + 0.028133364394307137, + 0.027809176594018936, + 0.017652641981840134, + 0.020403137430548668, + 0.2081119567155838 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1461220383644104 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tiny quadcopter drone constructed of matte black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the drone execute sharp, agile maneuvers including accelerating up a steep 45-degree slope and banking in a tight arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a minimalist studio setting with a vast, smooth, dark gray surface tilted at a 45-degree angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the propellers visible as a transparent blur due to rapid spinning, and are there clean, elongated reflections on the drone and ramp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic low-angle tracking shot illuminated by bright, diffuse light from a large overhead studio softbox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014212341979146004 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264212131500244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014212341979146004, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014212341979146004, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6705672144889832, + 0.029520537704229355, + 0.02762703225016594, + 0.046737734228372574, + 0.017912395298480988, + 0.024376094341278076, + 0.03778893128037453, + 0.03618084639310837, + 0.07146622240543365, + 0.03782301023602486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014212341979146004 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tiny quadcopter drone constructed of matte black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the drone execute sharp, agile maneuvers including accelerating up a steep 45-degree slope and banking in a tight arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a minimalist studio setting with a vast, smooth, dark gray surface tilted at a 45-degree angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the propellers visible as a transparent blur due to rapid spinning, and are there clean, elongated reflections on the drone and ramp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic low-angle tracking shot illuminated by bright, diffuse light from a large overhead studio softbox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012534411624073982 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875346183776855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012534411624073982, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012534411624073982, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6234809756278992, + 0.053495924919843674, + 0.03468965366482735, + 0.04836667701601982, + 0.013155709952116013, + 0.06592895090579987, + 0.008040431886911392, + 0.017034035176038742, + 0.01141801755875349, + 0.1243896484375 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012534411624073982 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tiny quadcopter drone constructed of matte black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the drone execute sharp, agile maneuvers including accelerating up a steep 45-degree slope and banking in a tight arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a minimalist studio setting with a vast, smooth, dark gray surface tilted at a 45-degree angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the propellers visible as a transparent blur due to rapid spinning, and are there clean, elongated reflections on the drone and ramp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic low-angle tracking shot illuminated by bright, diffuse light from a large overhead studio softbox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024915861431509256 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002491474151611 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024915861431509256, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024915861431509256, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.45687246322631836, + 0.06010310351848602, + 0.07564805448055267, + 0.05676873028278351, + 0.032812923192977905, + 0.04359672963619232, + 0.02750127576291561, + 0.04994725063443184, + 0.025972334668040276, + 0.1707770973443985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024915861431509256 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tiny quadcopter drone constructed of matte black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the drone execute sharp, agile maneuvers including accelerating up a steep 45-degree slope and banking in a tight arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a minimalist studio setting with a vast, smooth, dark gray surface tilted at a 45-degree angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the propellers visible as a transparent blur due to rapid spinning, and are there clean, elongated reflections on the drone and ramp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic low-angle tracking shot illuminated by bright, diffuse light from a large overhead studio softbox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067289662547409534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067291259765625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067289662547409534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067289662547409534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.9214060306549072, + 0.014941058121621609, + 0.008613424375653267, + 0.011809243820607662, + 0.0033762010280042887, + 0.006182502023875713, + 0.002827901393175125, + 0.004064022097736597, + 0.004820158705115318, + 0.021959511563181877 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067289662547409534 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic low-angle tracking shot follows a tiny quadcopter drone as it executes a series of sharp, agile maneuvers. Constructed of matte black carbon fiber, the drone is equipped with four rapidly spinning propellers that become a transparent blur. It glides at incredible speed across a vast, smooth, dark gray surface, which tilts dramatically at a steep 45-degree angle within a minimalist studio setting. Bright, diffuse light from a large overhead studio softbox fills the scene, creating clean, elongated reflections that glide across the drone's chassis and polished ramp, casting soft but crisp shadows beneath the craft. The drone accelerates quickly and decisively up the slope, then aggressively banks in a tight, controlled arc, its body tilting almost parallel to the surface, demonstrating its extreme agility and creating an atmosphere of high-tech, focused, and energetic energy.", + "seed": 13842, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_8/index_1880_seed_13842_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04045066148974001, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04045066148974001, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.950000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04045066148974001, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tiny quadcopter drone constructed of matte black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the drone execute sharp, agile maneuvers including accelerating up a steep 45-degree slope and banking in a tight arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a minimalist studio setting with a vast, smooth, dark gray surface tilted at a 45-degree angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the propellers visible as a transparent blur due to rapid spinning, and are there clean, elongated reflections on the drone and ramp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic low-angle tracking shot illuminated by bright, diffuse light from a large overhead studio softbox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1482938677072525 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.023293972015381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1482938677072525, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1482938677072525, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11111198365688324, + 0.057263683527708054, + 0.0457073450088501, + 0.04614513739943504, + 0.3628787100315094, + 0.04373819753527641, + 0.03076627105474472, + 0.15248514711856842, + 0.04382503032684326, + 0.10607853531837463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1482938677072525 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tiny quadcopter drone constructed of matte black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the drone execute sharp, agile maneuvers including accelerating up a steep 45-degree slope and banking in a tight arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a minimalist studio setting with a vast, smooth, dark gray surface tilted at a 45-degree angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the propellers visible as a transparent blur due to rapid spinning, and are there clean, elongated reflections on the drone and ramp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic low-angle tracking shot illuminated by bright, diffuse light from a large overhead studio softbox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01608831062912941 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141088485717773 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01608831062912941, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01608831062912941, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11258803308010101, + 0.1094631478190422, + 0.058281105011701584, + 0.0571398064494133, + 0.3492700159549713, + 0.052190862596035004, + 0.01599649339914322, + 0.04539002105593681, + 0.15597590804100037, + 0.043704554438591 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01608831062912941 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tiny quadcopter drone constructed of matte black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the drone execute sharp, agile maneuvers including accelerating up a steep 45-degree slope and banking in a tight arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a minimalist studio setting with a vast, smooth, dark gray surface tilted at a 45-degree angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the propellers visible as a transparent blur due to rapid spinning, and are there clean, elongated reflections on the drone and ramp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic low-angle tracking shot illuminated by bright, diffuse light from a large overhead studio softbox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818777248263359 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187999725342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818777248263359, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818777248263359, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1508760005235672, + 0.09069117903709412, + 0.11063048243522644, + 0.1269354224205017, + 0.25619375705718994, + 0.0806528776884079, + 0.009949488565325737, + 0.04269113764166832, + 0.027113258838653564, + 0.104266457259655 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818777248263359 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tiny quadcopter drone constructed of matte black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the drone execute sharp, agile maneuvers including accelerating up a steep 45-degree slope and banking in a tight arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a minimalist studio setting with a vast, smooth, dark gray surface tilted at a 45-degree angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the propellers visible as a transparent blur due to rapid spinning, and are there clean, elongated reflections on the drone and ramp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic low-angle tracking shot illuminated by bright, diffuse light from a large overhead studio softbox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036207374650985003 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628620624542236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036207374650985003, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036207374650985003, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13129253685474396, + 0.07209330052137375, + 0.1516142636537552, + 0.0791407898068428, + 0.22287088632583618, + 0.08357185870409012, + 0.027125904336571693, + 0.0961758941411972, + 0.03690098971128464, + 0.09921354055404663 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036207374650985003 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a tiny quadcopter drone constructed of matte black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the drone execute sharp, agile maneuvers including accelerating up a steep 45-degree slope and banking in a tight arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a minimalist studio setting with a vast, smooth, dark gray surface tilted at a 45-degree angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the propellers visible as a transparent blur due to rapid spinning, and are there clean, elongated reflections on the drone and ramp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dynamic low-angle tracking shot illuminated by bright, diffuse light from a large overhead studio softbox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016062619164586067 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410627365112305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016062619164586067, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016062619164586067, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11583944410085678, + 0.06936176121234894, + 0.06085456535220146, + 0.08474703878164291, + 0.31958815455436707, + 0.0582083985209465, + 0.02161715365946293, + 0.06170346960425377, + 0.05081825703382492, + 0.15726174414157867 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016062619164586067 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_9/index_tensor([2120, 2120])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_9/index_tensor([2120, 2120])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0869504868ca2e6e1d1273e333ebdbd077278eb2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_9/index_tensor([2120, 2120])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An eye-level, static medium shot frames a young man with unkempt brown hair, dressed in a casual gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants, as he cleans a modern living room. Soft daylight streams in from an unseen window, casting gentle reflections on the polished hardwood floor. He initially holds a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand, moving it at a steady pace. His focused work is abruptly interrupted when he clumsily kicks the trailing black power cord with his left foot, tangling it. With a frustrated sigh, he deftly shifts the vacuum cleaner to his right hand, bending steadily at the waist and carefully picking up the loosened cord with his left hand before standing straight. To continue his work, he briefly presses his right foot on the base of the vacuum cleaner to stabilize it, then pushes it forward and resumes cleaning. Then, his attention shifts; he glances to his left, his face partially illuminated by the flickering, colorful glow of a television, playing a vibrant cartoon. As his eyes remain glued to the screen, his hands continue to vacuum back and forth, now more automatically and with less precision, perfectly capturing a moment of distracted, everyday family life.", + "seed": 2724, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_9/index_2120_seed_2724_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08604121040552855, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08604121040552855, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08604121040552855, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level, static medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man with unkempt brown hair wearing a gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man initially hold a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man kick the trailing black power cord with his left foot, causing it to tangle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man glance to his left at a television playing a vibrant cartoon while continuing to vacuum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3010868430137634 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6760869026184082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3010868430137634, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3010868430137634, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5602902173995972, + 0.026851998642086983, + 0.060557398945093155, + 0.22857260704040527, + 0.036545414477586746, + 0.03160592168569565, + 0.011457515880465508, + 0.009908482432365417, + 0.017117952927947044, + 0.017092540860176086 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3010868430137634 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level, static medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man with unkempt brown hair wearing a gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man initially hold a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man kick the trailing black power cord with his left foot, causing it to tangle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man glance to his left at a television playing a vibrant cartoon while continuing to vacuum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029823778197169304 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298237800598145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029823778197169304, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029823778197169304, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07826357334852219, + 0.03560974448919296, + 0.10465700179338455, + 0.6522507071495056, + 0.018897326663136482, + 0.05171813815832138, + 0.025017395615577698, + 0.0134586151689291, + 0.010478419251739979, + 0.009649026207625866 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029823778197169304 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level, static medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man with unkempt brown hair wearing a gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man initially hold a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man kick the trailing black power cord with his left foot, causing it to tangle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man glance to his left at a television playing a vibrant cartoon while continuing to vacuum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810613602399826 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881062030792236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810613602399826, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810613602399826, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7111552357673645, + 0.07585789263248444, + 0.07479625195264816, + 0.04725777730345726, + 0.03357517346739769, + 0.01393631286919117, + 0.013950077816843987, + 0.007787863723933697, + 0.011453772895038128, + 0.010229526087641716 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810613602399826 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level, static medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man with unkempt brown hair wearing a gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man initially hold a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man kick the trailing black power cord with his left foot, causing it to tangle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man glance to his left at a television playing a vibrant cartoon while continuing to vacuum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865511879324913 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486550331115723 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865511879324913, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865511879324913, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3911801278591156, + 0.09756558388471603, + 0.05386139824986458, + 0.28996118903160095, + 0.041407883167266846, + 0.034355975687503815, + 0.030285490676760674, + 0.019801685586571693, + 0.025492994114756584, + 0.01608765497803688 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865511879324913 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level, static medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man with unkempt brown hair wearing a gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man initially hold a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man kick the trailing black power cord with his left foot, causing it to tangle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man glance to his left at a television playing a vibrant cartoon while continuing to vacuum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012534175999462605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387534141540527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012534175999462605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012534175999462605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2595503628253937, + 0.05040588602423668, + 0.14250288903713226, + 0.17921032011508942, + 0.052314091473817825, + 0.04756185784935951, + 0.04288460686802864, + 0.04878843203186989, + 0.12682685256004333, + 0.049954675137996674 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012534175999462605 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An eye-level, static medium shot frames a young man with unkempt brown hair, dressed in a casual gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants, as he cleans a modern living room. Soft daylight streams in from an unseen window, casting gentle reflections on the polished hardwood floor. He initially holds a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand, moving it at a steady pace. His focused work is abruptly interrupted when he clumsily kicks the trailing black power cord with his left foot, tangling it. With a frustrated sigh, he deftly shifts the vacuum cleaner to his right hand, bending steadily at the waist and carefully picking up the loosened cord with his left hand before standing straight. To continue his work, he briefly presses his right foot on the base of the vacuum cleaner to stabilize it, then pushes it forward and resumes cleaning. Then, his attention shifts; he glances to his left, his face partially illuminated by the flickering, colorful glow of a television, playing a vibrant cartoon. As his eyes remain glued to the screen, his hands continue to vacuum back and forth, now more automatically and with less precision, perfectly capturing a moment of distracted, everyday family life.", + "seed": 2725, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_9/index_2120_seed_2725_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.056608479097485544, + "vlm_logprob": -0.056608479097485544, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.056608479097485544, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level, static medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man with unkempt brown hair wearing a gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man initially hold a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man kick the trailing black power cord with his left foot, causing it to tangle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man glance to his left at a television playing a vibrant cartoon while continuing to vacuum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16594234108924866 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.415942430496216 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16594234108924866, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16594234108924866, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11951808631420135, + 0.0712357610464096, + 0.05150443688035011, + 0.04119406268000603, + 0.21807898581027985, + 0.07431434839963913, + 0.07695935666561127, + 0.059289947152137756, + 0.22486639022827148, + 0.0630386620759964 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16594234108924866 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level, static medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man with unkempt brown hair wearing a gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man initially hold a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man kick the trailing black power cord with his left foot, causing it to tangle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man glance to his left at a television playing a vibrant cartoon while continuing to vacuum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02982667088508606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298266410827637 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02982667088508606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02982667088508606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11738027632236481, + 0.03788226842880249, + 0.028944222256541252, + 0.04296218976378441, + 0.07236527651548386, + 0.034107815474271774, + 0.3646801710128784, + 0.06567570567131042, + 0.1969386786222458, + 0.03906341269612312 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02982667088508606 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level, static medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man with unkempt brown hair wearing a gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man initially hold a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man kick the trailing black power cord with his left foot, causing it to tangle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man glance to his left at a television playing a vibrant cartoon while continuing to vacuum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810510411858559 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288105010986328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810510411858559, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810510411858559, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13759002089500427, + 0.0675443559885025, + 0.04334564134478569, + 0.02989818900823593, + 0.15345513820648193, + 0.0646430104970932, + 0.21761463582515717, + 0.0592297688126564, + 0.17951056361198425, + 0.047168582677841187 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810510411858559 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level, static medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man with unkempt brown hair wearing a gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man initially hold a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man kick the trailing black power cord with his left foot, causing it to tangle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man glance to his left at a television playing a vibrant cartoon while continuing to vacuum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809259459376335 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288092613220215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809259459376335, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809259459376335, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10049980133771896, + 0.05411619320511818, + 0.02529020793735981, + 0.0212851632386446, + 0.14404310286045074, + 0.04900699481368065, + 0.3400670886039734, + 0.07029325515031815, + 0.11205160617828369, + 0.08334658294916153 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809259459376335 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level, static medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man with unkempt brown hair wearing a gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man initially hold a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man kick the trailing black power cord with his left foot, causing it to tangle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man glance to his left at a television playing a vibrant cartoon while continuing to vacuum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011075684800744057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511075496673584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011075684800744057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011075684800744057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06459464877843857, + 0.028092453256249428, + 0.01428975723683834, + 0.021960042417049408, + 0.21630819141864777, + 0.034064654260873795, + 0.11185240000486374, + 0.10896635055541992, + 0.2053878903388977, + 0.1944836676120758 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011075684800744057 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An eye-level, static medium shot frames a young man with unkempt brown hair, dressed in a casual gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants, as he cleans a modern living room. Soft daylight streams in from an unseen window, casting gentle reflections on the polished hardwood floor. He initially holds a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand, moving it at a steady pace. His focused work is abruptly interrupted when he clumsily kicks the trailing black power cord with his left foot, tangling it. With a frustrated sigh, he deftly shifts the vacuum cleaner to his right hand, bending steadily at the waist and carefully picking up the loosened cord with his left hand before standing straight. To continue his work, he briefly presses his right foot on the base of the vacuum cleaner to stabilize it, then pushes it forward and resumes cleaning. Then, his attention shifts; he glances to his left, his face partially illuminated by the flickering, colorful glow of a television, playing a vibrant cartoon. As his eyes remain glued to the screen, his hands continue to vacuum back and forth, now more automatically and with less precision, perfectly capturing a moment of distracted, everyday family life.", + "seed": 2726, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_9/index_2120_seed_2726_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.07257266379892827, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07257266379892827, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07257266379892827, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level, static medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man with unkempt brown hair wearing a gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man initially hold a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man kick the trailing black power cord with his left foot, causing it to tangle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man glance to his left at a television playing a vibrant cartoon while continuing to vacuum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.230853870511055 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9808539152145386 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.230853870511055, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.230853870511055, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06551271677017212, + 0.055804744362831116, + 0.03139632195234299, + 0.15748311579227448, + 0.07842156291007996, + 0.1658666878938675, + 0.20669424533843994, + 0.08945975452661514, + 0.08284665644168854, + 0.06651421636343002 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.230853870511055 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level, static medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man with unkempt brown hair wearing a gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man initially hold a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man kick the trailing black power cord with his left foot, causing it to tangle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man glance to his left at a television playing a vibrant cartoon while continuing to vacuum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023304961621761322 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733049392700195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023304961621761322, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023304961621761322, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16212022304534912, + 0.07110162824392319, + 0.05361069366335869, + 0.19677475094795227, + 0.08946790546178818, + 0.0697447806596756, + 0.11927767843008041, + 0.09285110235214233, + 0.08540677279233932, + 0.0596444196999073 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023304961621761322 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level, static medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man with unkempt brown hair wearing a gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man initially hold a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man kick the trailing black power cord with his left foot, causing it to tangle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man glance to his left at a television playing a vibrant cartoon while continuing to vacuum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048662614077329636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486626625061035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048662614077329636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048662614077329636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0959903746843338, + 0.15684297680854797, + 0.10688945651054382, + 0.07038791477680206, + 0.11665230244398117, + 0.15253114700317383, + 0.06103998050093651, + 0.05277734249830246, + 0.07439230382442474, + 0.11249615997076035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048662614077329636 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level, static medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man with unkempt brown hair wearing a gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man initially hold a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man kick the trailing black power cord with his left foot, causing it to tangle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man glance to his left at a television playing a vibrant cartoon while continuing to vacuum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026345962658524513 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.65134596824646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026345962658524513, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026345962658524513, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06762968748807907, + 0.053557224571704865, + 0.027877235785126686, + 0.086153544485569, + 0.12120677530765533, + 0.07636912167072296, + 0.1291624754667282, + 0.2349402755498886, + 0.15487463772296906, + 0.04822903499007225 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026345962658524513 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level, static medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man with unkempt brown hair wearing a gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man initially hold a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man kick the trailing black power cord with his left foot, causing it to tangle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man glance to his left at a television playing a vibrant cartoon while continuing to vacuum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369591012597084 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408695936203003 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369591012597084, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369591012597084, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061092060059309006, + 0.038648948073387146, + 0.05470028519630432, + 0.07082118839025497, + 0.10792354494333267, + 0.08493058383464813, + 0.1784164309501648, + 0.08296900242567062, + 0.2218693494796753, + 0.09862861037254333 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369591012597084 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An eye-level, static medium shot frames a young man with unkempt brown hair, dressed in a casual gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants, as he cleans a modern living room. Soft daylight streams in from an unseen window, casting gentle reflections on the polished hardwood floor. He initially holds a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand, moving it at a steady pace. His focused work is abruptly interrupted when he clumsily kicks the trailing black power cord with his left foot, tangling it. With a frustrated sigh, he deftly shifts the vacuum cleaner to his right hand, bending steadily at the waist and carefully picking up the loosened cord with his left hand before standing straight. To continue his work, he briefly presses his right foot on the base of the vacuum cleaner to stabilize it, then pushes it forward and resumes cleaning. Then, his attention shifts; he glances to his left, his face partially illuminated by the flickering, colorful glow of a television, playing a vibrant cartoon. As his eyes remain glued to the screen, his hands continue to vacuum back and forth, now more automatically and with less precision, perfectly capturing a moment of distracted, everyday family life.", + "seed": 2727, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000030/group_9/index_2120_seed_2727_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.21473963167518378, + "vlm_logprob": -0.21473963167518378, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.21473963167518378, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level, static medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man with unkempt brown hair wearing a gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man initially hold a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man kick the trailing black power cord with his left foot, causing it to tangle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man glance to his left at a television playing a vibrant cartoon while continuing to vacuum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9404338002204895 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5654338002204895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9404338002204895, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9404338002204895, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16117550432682037, + 0.2888137400150299, + 0.1146574392914772, + 0.03256482258439064, + 0.10578794032335281, + 0.0906861275434494, + 0.08098818361759186, + 0.05571677163243294, + 0.05386931449174881, + 0.015740182250738144 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9404338002204895 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level, static medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man with unkempt brown hair wearing a gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man initially hold a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man kick the trailing black power cord with his left foot, causing it to tangle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man glance to his left at a television playing a vibrant cartoon while continuing to vacuum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023317888379096985 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773317813873291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023317888379096985, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023317888379096985, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13452613353729248, + 0.130878746509552, + 0.10710200667381287, + 0.03797256201505661, + 0.04950575530529022, + 0.06279706209897995, + 0.06110353395342827, + 0.07166828960180283, + 0.057402368634939194, + 0.2870434820652008 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023317888379096985 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level, static medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man with unkempt brown hair wearing a gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man initially hold a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man kick the trailing black power cord with his left foot, causing it to tangle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man glance to his left at a television playing a vibrant cartoon while continuing to vacuum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033713199198246 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087131023406982 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033713199198246, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033713199198246, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08480075001716614, + 0.42799901962280273, + 0.10540010780096054, + 0.05621932074427605, + 0.039029449224472046, + 0.06369677186012268, + 0.04812131077051163, + 0.06127147749066353, + 0.03675227239727974, + 0.07670947909355164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033713199198246 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level, static medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man with unkempt brown hair wearing a gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man initially hold a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man kick the trailing black power cord with his left foot, causing it to tangle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man glance to his left at a television playing a vibrant cartoon while continuing to vacuum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204290688037872 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120429515838623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204290688037872, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204290688037872, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13185422122478485, + 0.08215275406837463, + 0.27501967549324036, + 0.059287723153829575, + 0.051370855420827866, + 0.07461848855018616, + 0.10923297703266144, + 0.0412609800696373, + 0.11535071581602097, + 0.05985153466463089 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204290688037872 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level, static medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man with unkempt brown hair wearing a gray T-shirt and dark blue sweatpants?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man initially hold a sleek, dark blue upright vacuum cleaner in his left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man kick the trailing black power cord with his left foot, causing it to tangle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man glance to his left at a television playing a vibrant cartoon while continuing to vacuum?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014190363697707653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264190196990967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014190363697707653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014190363697707653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08898624777793884, + 0.11943265795707703, + 0.076502725481987, + 0.03949970006942749, + 0.10735125094652176, + 0.11276117712259293, + 0.1473984569311142, + 0.08734850585460663, + 0.15717145800590515, + 0.06354780495166779 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014190363697707653 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_0/index_tensor([841, 841])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_0/index_tensor([841, 841])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f3cb4b1daa29c11b39edfe9808b9cf402bc3de1d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_0/index_tensor([841, 841])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, initially static, captures a classic pink rubber eraser, its narrow, vertical edge precariously balanced on the finely textured surface of a light-colored wooden table, which is tilted slightly. Warm, direct light from a single, unseen source on the left casts long, sharp shadows, meticulously highlighting the rubber's matte texture and subtle graphite smudges from past use, while a shallow depth of field renders the background into a soft, blurred bokeh. A faint, almost imperceptible vibration suddenly travels through the table, causing the eraser to begin a slow, nervous lurch. As the camera inevitably loses its delicate balance, a smooth, subtle shot initiates, perfectly tracking the object's movement as it tilts and begins to tumble awkwardly from head to toe. Each rotation is a distinct and awkward flip, the eraser's corner striking the wood in a silent, rhythmic sequence before the movement ends with a final, gentle impact as the eraser finally settles on its widest, most stable side, now resting motionless in the focused light, creating an atmosphere of quiet, suspended observation.", + "seed": 31574, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_0/index_841_seed_31574_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.015015032421797515, + "vlm_logprob": -0.015015032421797515, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.015015032421797515, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a classic pink rubber eraser with visible graphite smudges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eraser initially balanced on its narrow vertical edge on a light-colored wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm direct light from the left casting long, sharp shadows and a shallow depth of field with blurred bokeh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eraser perform a slow, nervous lurch followed by a sequence of awkward flips and rotations before settling on its widest side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then smoothly track the eraser's movement as it tilts and tumbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.025235919281840324 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.775235891342163 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.025235919281840324, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.025235919281840324, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1666688174009323, + 0.10281004011631012, + 0.13574177026748657, + 0.1079198345541954, + 0.07677891105413437, + 0.10961365699768066, + 0.09184406697750092, + 0.09915908426046371, + 0.06065184250473976, + 0.04881199821829796 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.025235919281840324 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a classic pink rubber eraser with visible graphite smudges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eraser initially balanced on its narrow vertical edge on a light-colored wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm direct light from the left casting long, sharp shadows and a shallow depth of field with blurred bokeh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eraser perform a slow, nervous lurch followed by a sequence of awkward flips and rotations before settling on its widest side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then smoothly track the eraser's movement as it tilts and tumbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014214222319424152 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264214038848877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014214222319424152, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014214222319424152, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15056660771369934, + 0.17250670492649078, + 0.1874164342880249, + 0.11088542640209198, + 0.07180205732584, + 0.05139346793293953, + 0.0853538066148758, + 0.1014404445886612, + 0.03867148980498314, + 0.029963528737425804 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014214222319424152 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a classic pink rubber eraser with visible graphite smudges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eraser initially balanced on its narrow vertical edge on a light-colored wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm direct light from the left casting long, sharp shadows and a shallow depth of field with blurred bokeh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eraser perform a slow, nervous lurch followed by a sequence of awkward flips and rotations before settling on its widest side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then smoothly track the eraser's movement as it tilts and tumbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005259368102997541 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.2552595138549805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005259368102997541, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005259368102997541, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2073201984167099, + 0.09393458813428879, + 0.12405133247375488, + 0.0638006404042244, + 0.058023858815431595, + 0.11080344766378403, + 0.12253224849700928, + 0.10086345672607422, + 0.03149406239390373, + 0.08717616647481918 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005259368102997541 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a classic pink rubber eraser with visible graphite smudges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eraser initially balanced on its narrow vertical edge on a light-colored wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm direct light from the left casting long, sharp shadows and a shallow depth of field with blurred bokeh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eraser perform a slow, nervous lurch followed by a sequence of awkward flips and rotations before settling on its widest side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then smoothly track the eraser's movement as it tilts and tumbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009787782095372677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634787559509277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009787782095372677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009787782095372677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1330064982175827, + 0.12018822133541107, + 0.07335302978754044, + 0.0756368413567543, + 0.0654313936829567, + 0.0720420852303505, + 0.16828936338424683, + 0.11535274982452393, + 0.07234039902687073, + 0.10435938835144043 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009787782095372677 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a classic pink rubber eraser with visible graphite smudges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eraser initially balanced on its narrow vertical edge on a light-colored wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm direct light from the left casting long, sharp shadows and a shallow depth of field with blurred bokeh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eraser perform a slow, nervous lurch followed by a sequence of awkward flips and rotations before settling on its widest side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then smoothly track the eraser's movement as it tilts and tumbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020577870309352875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895577907562256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020577870309352875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020577870309352875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08018303662538528, + 0.11752285063266754, + 0.1279693841934204, + 0.22106924653053284, + 0.07113111764192581, + 0.04496601223945618, + 0.14929848909378052, + 0.12078474462032318, + 0.030626781284809113, + 0.03644830361008644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020577870309352875 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, initially static, captures a classic pink rubber eraser, its narrow, vertical edge precariously balanced on the finely textured surface of a light-colored wooden table, which is tilted slightly. Warm, direct light from a single, unseen source on the left casts long, sharp shadows, meticulously highlighting the rubber's matte texture and subtle graphite smudges from past use, while a shallow depth of field renders the background into a soft, blurred bokeh. A faint, almost imperceptible vibration suddenly travels through the table, causing the eraser to begin a slow, nervous lurch. As the camera inevitably loses its delicate balance, a smooth, subtle shot initiates, perfectly tracking the object's movement as it tilts and begins to tumble awkwardly from head to toe. Each rotation is a distinct and awkward flip, the eraser's corner striking the wood in a silent, rhythmic sequence before the movement ends with a final, gentle impact as the eraser finally settles on its widest, most stable side, now resting motionless in the focused light, creating an atmosphere of quiet, suspended observation.", + "seed": 31575, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_0/index_841_seed_31575_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.019430655986070633, + "vlm_logprob": -0.019430655986070633, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.019430655986070633, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a classic pink rubber eraser with visible graphite smudges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eraser initially balanced on its narrow vertical edge on a light-colored wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm direct light from the left casting long, sharp shadows and a shallow depth of field with blurred bokeh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eraser perform a slow, nervous lurch followed by a sequence of awkward flips and rotations before settling on its widest side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then smoothly track the eraser's movement as it tilts and tumbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04003142938017845 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2900314331054688 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04003142938017845, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04003142938017845, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2163870632648468, + 0.1034822016954422, + 0.10398386418819427, + 0.13706988096237183, + 0.08117955923080444, + 0.04080662131309509, + 0.036255594342947006, + 0.017779290676116943, + 0.17792631685733795, + 0.08512955904006958 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04003142938017845 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a classic pink rubber eraser with visible graphite smudges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eraser initially balanced on its narrow vertical edge on a light-colored wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm direct light from the left casting long, sharp shadows and a shallow depth of field with blurred bokeh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eraser perform a slow, nervous lurch followed by a sequence of awkward flips and rotations before settling on its widest side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then smoothly track the eraser's movement as it tilts and tumbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01608537696301937 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141085147857666 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01608537696301937, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01608537696301937, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1828608512878418, + 0.2870311141014099, + 0.06251358985900879, + 0.09964088350534439, + 0.038791291415691376, + 0.046176038682460785, + 0.042171236127614975, + 0.034990690648555756, + 0.04737408459186554, + 0.15845023095607758 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01608537696301937 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a classic pink rubber eraser with visible graphite smudges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eraser initially balanced on its narrow vertical edge on a light-colored wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm direct light from the left casting long, sharp shadows and a shallow depth of field with blurred bokeh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eraser perform a slow, nervous lurch followed by a sequence of awkward flips and rotations before settling on its widest side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then smoothly track the eraser's movement as it tilts and tumbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036202622577548027 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628620147705078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036202622577548027, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036202622577548027, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17930816113948822, + 0.16579823195934296, + 0.09646257758140564, + 0.07513464242219925, + 0.04647107794880867, + 0.11277838796377182, + 0.05178670957684517, + 0.030966991558670998, + 0.09703807532787323, + 0.14425520598888397 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036202622577548027 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a classic pink rubber eraser with visible graphite smudges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eraser initially balanced on its narrow vertical edge on a light-colored wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm direct light from the left casting long, sharp shadows and a shallow depth of field with blurred bokeh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eraser perform a slow, nervous lurch followed by a sequence of awkward flips and rotations before settling on its widest side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then smoothly track the eraser's movement as it tilts and tumbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011077099479734898 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511076927185059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011077099479734898, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011077099479734898, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.172197163105011, + 0.0914095789194107, + 0.12401871383190155, + 0.11575320363044739, + 0.05067829787731171, + 0.07714329659938812, + 0.0532238744199276, + 0.03504818305373192, + 0.2509477436542511, + 0.02957991510629654 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011077099479734898 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a classic pink rubber eraser with visible graphite smudges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eraser initially balanced on its narrow vertical edge on a light-colored wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm direct light from the left casting long, sharp shadows and a shallow depth of field with blurred bokeh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eraser perform a slow, nervous lurch followed by a sequence of awkward flips and rotations before settling on its widest side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then smoothly track the eraser's movement as it tilts and tumbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026339111849665642 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651339054107666 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026339111849665642, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026339111849665642, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14879077672958374, + 0.1245359256863594, + 0.055870894342660904, + 0.129791721701622, + 0.08032576739788055, + 0.1230027973651886, + 0.109129898250103, + 0.0335923507809639, + 0.15121130645275116, + 0.043748512864112854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026339111849665642 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, initially static, captures a classic pink rubber eraser, its narrow, vertical edge precariously balanced on the finely textured surface of a light-colored wooden table, which is tilted slightly. Warm, direct light from a single, unseen source on the left casts long, sharp shadows, meticulously highlighting the rubber's matte texture and subtle graphite smudges from past use, while a shallow depth of field renders the background into a soft, blurred bokeh. A faint, almost imperceptible vibration suddenly travels through the table, causing the eraser to begin a slow, nervous lurch. As the camera inevitably loses its delicate balance, a smooth, subtle shot initiates, perfectly tracking the object's movement as it tilts and begins to tumble awkwardly from head to toe. Each rotation is a distinct and awkward flip, the eraser's corner striking the wood in a silent, rhythmic sequence before the movement ends with a final, gentle impact as the eraser finally settles on its widest, most stable side, now resting motionless in the focused light, creating an atmosphere of quiet, suspended observation.", + "seed": 31576, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_0/index_841_seed_31576_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.011304241325706243, + "vlm_logprob": -0.011304241325706243, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.011304241325706243, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a classic pink rubber eraser with visible graphite smudges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eraser initially balanced on its narrow vertical edge on a light-colored wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm direct light from the left casting long, sharp shadows and a shallow depth of field with blurred bokeh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eraser perform a slow, nervous lurch followed by a sequence of awkward flips and rotations before settling on its widest side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then smoothly track the eraser's movement as it tilts and tumbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020135169848799706 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.020135402679443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020135169848799706, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020135169848799706, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.029685087502002716, + 0.015695178881287575, + 0.7450090646743774, + 0.03170158341526985, + 0.03555993735790253, + 0.01852245070040226, + 0.07932261377573013, + 0.02250305376946926, + 0.009431008249521255, + 0.012570000253617764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020135169848799706 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a classic pink rubber eraser with visible graphite smudges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eraser initially balanced on its narrow vertical edge on a light-colored wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm direct light from the left casting long, sharp shadows and a shallow depth of field with blurred bokeh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eraser perform a slow, nervous lurch followed by a sequence of awkward flips and rotations before settling on its widest side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then smoothly track the eraser's movement as it tilts and tumbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005966826807707548 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130966663360596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005966826807707548, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005966826807707548, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06269270926713943, + 0.03784412890672684, + 0.5366315245628357, + 0.07500090450048447, + 0.06117884814739227, + 0.05443175137042999, + 0.0643119141459465, + 0.05868536978960037, + 0.028294052928686142, + 0.020928816869854927 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005966826807707548 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a classic pink rubber eraser with visible graphite smudges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eraser initially balanced on its narrow vertical edge on a light-colored wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm direct light from the left casting long, sharp shadows and a shallow depth of field with blurred bokeh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eraser perform a slow, nervous lurch followed by a sequence of awkward flips and rotations before settling on its widest side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then smoothly track the eraser's movement as it tilts and tumbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024946779012680054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002494812011719 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024946779012680054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024946779012680054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.036913514137268066, + 0.027888942509889603, + 0.711868941783905, + 0.0875321552157402, + 0.018497442826628685, + 0.02874496951699257, + 0.04173252359032631, + 0.025684654712677002, + 0.008799495175480843, + 0.01233738660812378 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024946779012680054 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a classic pink rubber eraser with visible graphite smudges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eraser initially balanced on its narrow vertical edge on a light-colored wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm direct light from the left casting long, sharp shadows and a shallow depth of field with blurred bokeh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eraser perform a slow, nervous lurch followed by a sequence of awkward flips and rotations before settling on its widest side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then smoothly track the eraser's movement as it tilts and tumbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00464111752808094 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379641056060791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00464111752808094, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00464111752808094, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.01983073353767395, + 0.02191273868083954, + 0.8473671078681946, + 0.009895777329802513, + 0.00924642663449049, + 0.04824889078736305, + 0.008487168699502945, + 0.023251498118042946, + 0.005639705806970596, + 0.006119940429925919 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00464111752808094 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a classic pink rubber eraser with visible graphite smudges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eraser initially balanced on its narrow vertical edge on a light-colored wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm direct light from the left casting long, sharp shadows and a shallow depth of field with blurred bokeh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eraser perform a slow, nervous lurch followed by a sequence of awkward flips and rotations before settling on its widest side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then smoothly track the eraser's movement as it tilts and tumbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02328341454267502 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732834815979004 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02328341454267502, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02328341454267502, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.017490195110440254, + 0.011676779948174953, + 0.8640865683555603, + 0.019893908873200417, + 0.01690327189862728, + 0.030748434364795685, + 0.009386688470840454, + 0.020274024456739426, + 0.004491565749049187, + 0.0050485082902014256 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02328341454267502 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, initially static, captures a classic pink rubber eraser, its narrow, vertical edge precariously balanced on the finely textured surface of a light-colored wooden table, which is tilted slightly. Warm, direct light from a single, unseen source on the left casts long, sharp shadows, meticulously highlighting the rubber's matte texture and subtle graphite smudges from past use, while a shallow depth of field renders the background into a soft, blurred bokeh. A faint, almost imperceptible vibration suddenly travels through the table, causing the eraser to begin a slow, nervous lurch. As the camera inevitably loses its delicate balance, a smooth, subtle shot initiates, perfectly tracking the object's movement as it tilts and begins to tumble awkwardly from head to toe. Each rotation is a distinct and awkward flip, the eraser's corner striking the wood in a silent, rhythmic sequence before the movement ends with a final, gentle impact as the eraser finally settles on its widest, most stable side, now resting motionless in the focused light, creating an atmosphere of quiet, suspended observation.", + "seed": 31577, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_0/index_841_seed_31577_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.018867989629507066, + "vlm_logprob": -0.018867989629507066, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.018867989629507066, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a classic pink rubber eraser with visible graphite smudges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eraser initially balanced on its narrow vertical edge on a light-colored wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm direct light from the left casting long, sharp shadows and a shallow depth of field with blurred bokeh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eraser perform a slow, nervous lurch followed by a sequence of awkward flips and rotations before settling on its widest side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then smoothly track the eraser's movement as it tilts and tumbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03959473967552185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2895946502685547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03959473967552185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03959473967552185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16647548973560333, + 0.07771069556474686, + 0.03878973424434662, + 0.025881581008434296, + 0.08618836104869843, + 0.1564725637435913, + 0.16500915586948395, + 0.1501924693584442, + 0.07349441945552826, + 0.05978557467460632 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03959473967552185 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a classic pink rubber eraser with visible graphite smudges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eraser initially balanced on its narrow vertical edge on a light-colored wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm direct light from the left casting long, sharp shadows and a shallow depth of field with blurred bokeh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eraser perform a slow, nervous lurch followed by a sequence of awkward flips and rotations before settling on its widest side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then smoothly track the eraser's movement as it tilts and tumbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016082797199487686 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141082763671875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016082797199487686, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016082797199487686, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21024248003959656, + 0.2055371254682541, + 0.041135724633932114, + 0.057364750653505325, + 0.048766836524009705, + 0.04268237203359604, + 0.08812563121318817, + 0.23516280949115753, + 0.02566531114280224, + 0.04531698301434517 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016082797199487686 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a classic pink rubber eraser with visible graphite smudges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eraser initially balanced on its narrow vertical edge on a light-colored wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm direct light from the left casting long, sharp shadows and a shallow depth of field with blurred bokeh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eraser perform a slow, nervous lurch followed by a sequence of awkward flips and rotations before settling on its widest side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then smoothly track the eraser's movement as it tilts and tumbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067422278225421906 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006742000579834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067422278225421906, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067422278225421906, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.524248480796814, + 0.10362855345010757, + 0.06308797001838684, + 0.02254415489733219, + 0.04286813735961914, + 0.0501730814576149, + 0.03965205326676369, + 0.0815739780664444, + 0.02031998336315155, + 0.05190354585647583 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067422278225421906 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a classic pink rubber eraser with visible graphite smudges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eraser initially balanced on its narrow vertical edge on a light-colored wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm direct light from the left casting long, sharp shadows and a shallow depth of field with blurred bokeh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eraser perform a slow, nervous lurch followed by a sequence of awkward flips and rotations before settling on its widest side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then smoothly track the eraser's movement as it tilts and tumbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00863863155245781 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758638858795166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00863863155245781, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00863863155245781, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5609307885169983, + 0.08353736996650696, + 0.049768950790166855, + 0.03541937842965126, + 0.04617254436016083, + 0.043112613260746, + 0.0640651136636734, + 0.03500298038125038, + 0.03986446186900139, + 0.04212583228945732 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00863863155245781 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a classic pink rubber eraser with visible graphite smudges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the eraser initially balanced on its narrow vertical edge on a light-colored wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm direct light from the left casting long, sharp shadows and a shallow depth of field with blurred bokeh?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eraser perform a slow, nervous lurch followed by a sequence of awkward flips and rotations before settling on its widest side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then smoothly track the eraser's movement as it tilts and tumbles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023281551897525787 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732815742492676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023281551897525787, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023281551897525787, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4160698652267456, + 0.06787203252315521, + 0.03609926998615265, + 0.026462489739060402, + 0.07033982127904892, + 0.0978378877043724, + 0.08185496181249619, + 0.06352546811103821, + 0.04397005960345268, + 0.095968097448349 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023281551897525787 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_1/index_tensor([1448, 1448])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_1/index_tensor([1448, 1448])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5092b1486dd60a5f998ae51e9a83a19a881ce3a3 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_1/index_tensor([1448, 1448])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium close-up frames a man with salt-and-pepper gray hair and a full, carefully groomed beard, his face etched with fine lines of wisdom. He wears a simple, loose-fitting white robe made of soft, textured linen, its folds falling naturally around his shoulders as he sits in a relaxed yet dignified posture. His eyes are gently closed, his brow slightly furrowed, his lips set in a firm, neutral line, and his entire presence exudes a deep concentration. He remains almost completely still, the only perceptible movement being the slow, rhythmic rise and fall of his chest with each deep breath. The background is a plain, off-white plaster wall with a subtly textured surface, while a large, leafy green plant stands softly beside him, out of focus. The scene is illuminated by soft, diffused natural light, as if from a large, unseen window, gently sculpting the contours of his face and creating gentle shadows. This minimalist composition, combined with the gentle lighting, creates an atmosphere of calm, tranquility, and profound contemplation, focusing the viewer's attention entirely on the man's introspective inner world.", + "seed": 32258, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_1/index_1448_seed_32258_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.007421951577998698, + "vlm_logprob": -0.007421951577998698, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.007421951577998698, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with salt-and-pepper gray hair and a full, groomed beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting white robe made of textured linen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a plain, off-white plaster wall with a large, out-of-focus leafy green plant beside the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffused natural light creating gentle shadows on the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level in a static medium close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029987141489982605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529987096786499 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029987141489982605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029987141489982605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.436960905790329, + 0.06944822520017624, + 0.038767728954553604, + 0.038062531501054764, + 0.04676882550120354, + 0.06462857872247696, + 0.18736471235752106, + 0.04399171844124794, + 0.024154478684067726, + 0.04985222592949867 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029987141489982605 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with salt-and-pepper gray hair and a full, groomed beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting white robe made of textured linen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a plain, off-white plaster wall with a large, out-of-focus leafy green plant beside the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffused natural light creating gentle shadows on the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level in a static medium close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024969372898340225 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002496719360352 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024969372898340225, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024969372898340225, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28384697437286377, + 0.09298399090766907, + 0.07200673967599869, + 0.05136025324463844, + 0.09584437310695648, + 0.03994928300380707, + 0.12144778668880463, + 0.06003470718860626, + 0.05674638971686363, + 0.12577950954437256 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024969372898340225 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with salt-and-pepper gray hair and a full, groomed beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting white robe made of textured linen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a plain, off-white plaster wall with a large, out-of-focus leafy green plant beside the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffused natural light creating gentle shadows on the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level in a static medium close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0004936429904773831 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.62549352645874 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0004936429904773831, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0004936429904773831, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18132156133651733, + 0.2200310230255127, + 0.07690871506929398, + 0.05915916711091995, + 0.09103047102689743, + 0.03139951825141907, + 0.12437053769826889, + 0.05192643776535988, + 0.08151400834321976, + 0.08233850449323654 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0004936429904773831 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with salt-and-pepper gray hair and a full, groomed beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting white robe made of textured linen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a plain, off-white plaster wall with a large, out-of-focus leafy green plant beside the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffused natural light creating gentle shadows on the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level in a static medium close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00193813256919384 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251938343048096 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00193813256919384, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00193813256919384, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19154730439186096, + 0.08269011229276657, + 0.042386557906866074, + 0.023373166099190712, + 0.26594874262809753, + 0.0440075509250164, + 0.17476698756217957, + 0.03043379820883274, + 0.08474451303482056, + 0.06010128930211067 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00193813256919384 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with salt-and-pepper gray hair and a full, groomed beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting white robe made of textured linen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a plain, off-white plaster wall with a large, out-of-focus leafy green plant beside the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffused natural light creating gentle shadows on the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level in a static medium close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002193903550505638 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127193927764893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002193903550505638, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002193903550505638, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20666372776031494, + 0.07364467531442642, + 0.027422891929745674, + 0.02304774522781372, + 0.19114598631858826, + 0.07089227437973022, + 0.30193230509757996, + 0.02640133909881115, + 0.022454284131526947, + 0.0563947968184948 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002193903550505638 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium close-up frames a man with salt-and-pepper gray hair and a full, carefully groomed beard, his face etched with fine lines of wisdom. He wears a simple, loose-fitting white robe made of soft, textured linen, its folds falling naturally around his shoulders as he sits in a relaxed yet dignified posture. His eyes are gently closed, his brow slightly furrowed, his lips set in a firm, neutral line, and his entire presence exudes a deep concentration. He remains almost completely still, the only perceptible movement being the slow, rhythmic rise and fall of his chest with each deep breath. The background is a plain, off-white plaster wall with a subtly textured surface, while a large, leafy green plant stands softly beside him, out of focus. The scene is illuminated by soft, diffused natural light, as if from a large, unseen window, gently sculpting the contours of his face and creating gentle shadows. This minimalist composition, combined with the gentle lighting, creates an atmosphere of calm, tranquility, and profound contemplation, focusing the viewer's attention entirely on the man's introspective inner world.", + "seed": 32259, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_1/index_1448_seed_32259_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0031527588609606026, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0031527588609606026, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 6.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0031527588609606026, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with salt-and-pepper gray hair and a full, groomed beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting white robe made of textured linen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a plain, off-white plaster wall with a large, out-of-focus leafy green plant beside the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffused natural light creating gentle shadows on the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level in a static medium close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0020754244178533554 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.5020751953125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0020754244178533554, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0020754244178533554, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32214945554733276, + 0.09008651971817017, + 0.07327064126729965, + 0.07036290317773819, + 0.0865016058087349, + 0.13623575866222382, + 0.027616748586297035, + 0.027827583253383636, + 0.03094342350959778, + 0.13500533998012543 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0020754244178533554 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with salt-and-pepper gray hair and a full, groomed beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting white robe made of textured linen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a plain, off-white plaster wall with a large, out-of-focus leafy green plant beside the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffused natural light creating gentle shadows on the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level in a static medium close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00282817124389112 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877828121185303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00282817124389112, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00282817124389112, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1426079273223877, + 0.13957738876342773, + 0.11330781131982803, + 0.07488655298948288, + 0.04622732102870941, + 0.1261693388223648, + 0.06204639747738838, + 0.09641678631305695, + 0.04280795529484749, + 0.1559525579214096 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00282817124389112 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with salt-and-pepper gray hair and a full, groomed beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting white robe made of textured linen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a plain, off-white plaster wall with a large, out-of-focus leafy green plant beside the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffused natural light creating gentle shadows on the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level in a static medium close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0007183355046436191 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.250718116760254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0007183355046436191, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0007183355046436191, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.48522084951400757, + 0.08404561132192612, + 0.08095791935920715, + 0.053537748754024506, + 0.02969432808458805, + 0.15028095245361328, + 0.036743856966495514, + 0.01834469474852085, + 0.01724293641746044, + 0.043931130319833755 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0007183355046436191 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with salt-and-pepper gray hair and a full, groomed beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting white robe made of textured linen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a plain, off-white plaster wall with a large, out-of-focus leafy green plant beside the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffused natural light creating gentle shadows on the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level in a static medium close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015116228023543954 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501511573791504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015116228023543954, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015116228023543954, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20325346291065216, + 0.09550745785236359, + 0.09039845317602158, + 0.05845886096358299, + 0.06235521659255028, + 0.07084845751523972, + 0.08513166010379791, + 0.10073678195476532, + 0.020569998770952225, + 0.21273960173130035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015116228023543954 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with salt-and-pepper gray hair and a full, groomed beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting white robe made of textured linen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a plain, off-white plaster wall with a large, out-of-focus leafy green plant beside the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffused natural light creating gentle shadows on the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level in a static medium close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008630240336060524 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758630275726318 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008630240336060524, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008630240336060524, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0950099527835846, + 0.10870838910341263, + 0.06317991763353348, + 0.04952770844101906, + 0.12848512828350067, + 0.3205159902572632, + 0.09108196943998337, + 0.025137940421700478, + 0.04817642644047737, + 0.07017656415700912 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008630240336060524 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium close-up frames a man with salt-and-pepper gray hair and a full, carefully groomed beard, his face etched with fine lines of wisdom. He wears a simple, loose-fitting white robe made of soft, textured linen, its folds falling naturally around his shoulders as he sits in a relaxed yet dignified posture. His eyes are gently closed, his brow slightly furrowed, his lips set in a firm, neutral line, and his entire presence exudes a deep concentration. He remains almost completely still, the only perceptible movement being the slow, rhythmic rise and fall of his chest with each deep breath. The background is a plain, off-white plaster wall with a subtly textured surface, while a large, leafy green plant stands softly beside him, out of focus. The scene is illuminated by soft, diffused natural light, as if from a large, unseen window, gently sculpting the contours of his face and creating gentle shadows. This minimalist composition, combined with the gentle lighting, creates an atmosphere of calm, tranquility, and profound contemplation, focusing the viewer's attention entirely on the man's introspective inner world.", + "seed": 32260, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_1/index_1448_seed_32260_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.005257775797508657, + "vlm_logprob": -0.005257775797508657, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.005257775797508657, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with salt-and-pepper gray hair and a full, groomed beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting white robe made of textured linen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a plain, off-white plaster wall with a large, out-of-focus leafy green plant beside the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffused natural light creating gentle shadows on the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level in a static medium close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014502708800137043 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26450252532959 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014502708800137043, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014502708800137043, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15303000807762146, + 0.04977518692612648, + 0.06646465510129929, + 0.0942750796675682, + 0.16877245903015137, + 0.2403898388147354, + 0.04646299406886101, + 0.0732298195362091, + 0.046139054000377655, + 0.061460986733436584 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014502708800137043 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with salt-and-pepper gray hair and a full, groomed beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting white robe made of textured linen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a plain, off-white plaster wall with a large, out-of-focus leafy green plant beside the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffused natural light creating gentle shadows on the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level in a static medium close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004647287540137768 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379647254943848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004647287540137768, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004647287540137768, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.196339413523674, + 0.06537272036075592, + 0.06882107257843018, + 0.054407890886068344, + 0.12284842878580093, + 0.15093165636062622, + 0.1335727572441101, + 0.05679071322083473, + 0.040825724601745605, + 0.11008961498737335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004647287540137768 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with salt-and-pepper gray hair and a full, groomed beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting white robe made of textured linen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a plain, off-white plaster wall with a large, out-of-focus leafy green plant beside the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffused natural light creating gentle shadows on the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level in a static medium close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0003861635341309011 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.8753862380981445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0003861635341309011, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0003861635341309011, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0872155949473381, + 0.08584243059158325, + 0.0429801419377327, + 0.14631113409996033, + 0.13940545916557312, + 0.09930876642465591, + 0.08054067939519882, + 0.1859273761510849, + 0.08231198042631149, + 0.05015643313527107 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0003861635341309011 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with salt-and-pepper gray hair and a full, groomed beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting white robe made of textured linen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a plain, off-white plaster wall with a large, out-of-focus leafy green plant beside the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffused natural light creating gentle shadows on the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level in a static medium close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0008119623525999486 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.12581205368042 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0008119623525999486, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0008119623525999486, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27056780457496643, + 0.12295201420783997, + 0.06136380508542061, + 0.03249146044254303, + 0.11023017764091492, + 0.08631955832242966, + 0.04757761210203171, + 0.11701637506484985, + 0.06907381862401962, + 0.08240734785795212 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0008119623525999486 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with salt-and-pepper gray hair and a full, groomed beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting white robe made of textured linen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a plain, off-white plaster wall with a large, out-of-focus leafy green plant beside the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffused natural light creating gentle shadows on the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level in a static medium close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005940756760537624 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130940914154053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005940756760537624, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005940756760537624, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12045706063508987, + 0.1434260457754135, + 0.12296177446842194, + 0.06358195841312408, + 0.11310538649559021, + 0.06298881024122238, + 0.05848938971757889, + 0.1973695158958435, + 0.07086174190044403, + 0.04675832390785217 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005940756760537624 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium close-up frames a man with salt-and-pepper gray hair and a full, carefully groomed beard, his face etched with fine lines of wisdom. He wears a simple, loose-fitting white robe made of soft, textured linen, its folds falling naturally around his shoulders as he sits in a relaxed yet dignified posture. His eyes are gently closed, his brow slightly furrowed, his lips set in a firm, neutral line, and his entire presence exudes a deep concentration. He remains almost completely still, the only perceptible movement being the slow, rhythmic rise and fall of his chest with each deep breath. The background is a plain, off-white plaster wall with a subtly textured surface, while a large, leafy green plant stands softly beside him, out of focus. The scene is illuminated by soft, diffused natural light, as if from a large, unseen window, gently sculpting the contours of his face and creating gentle shadows. This minimalist composition, combined with the gentle lighting, creates an atmosphere of calm, tranquility, and profound contemplation, focusing the viewer's attention entirely on the man's introspective inner world.", + "seed": 32261, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_1/index_1448_seed_32261_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0022511545452289284, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0022511545452289284, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 6.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0022511545452289284, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with salt-and-pepper gray hair and a full, groomed beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting white robe made of textured linen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a plain, off-white plaster wall with a large, out-of-focus leafy green plant beside the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffused natural light creating gentle shadows on the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level in a static medium close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004851474892348051 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379851341247559 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004851474892348051, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004851474892348051, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31689298152923584, + 0.07256714254617691, + 0.03154135122895241, + 0.02677428536117077, + 0.03630761057138443, + 0.16894295811653137, + 0.06948847323656082, + 0.22502125799655914, + 0.021639011800289154, + 0.03082486242055893 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004851474892348051 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with salt-and-pepper gray hair and a full, groomed beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting white robe made of textured linen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a plain, off-white plaster wall with a large, out-of-focus leafy green plant beside the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffused natural light creating gentle shadows on the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level in a static medium close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011865011183544993 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751186370849609 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011865011183544993, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011865011183544993, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3139040470123291, + 0.08318600058555603, + 0.07777131348848343, + 0.06937645375728607, + 0.09044813364744186, + 0.08847763389348984, + 0.06546615809202194, + 0.09065066277980804, + 0.0717412680387497, + 0.0489782840013504 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011865011183544993 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with salt-and-pepper gray hair and a full, groomed beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting white robe made of textured linen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a plain, off-white plaster wall with a large, out-of-focus leafy green plant beside the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffused natural light creating gentle shadows on the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level in a static medium close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0004951919545419514 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.625494956970215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0004951919545419514, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0004951919545419514, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19165204465389252, + 0.10719512403011322, + 0.07992082089185715, + 0.20637871325016022, + 0.06049134209752083, + 0.026213811710476875, + 0.03208327665925026, + 0.026540057733654976, + 0.033952124416828156, + 0.23557262122631073 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0004951919545419514 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with salt-and-pepper gray hair and a full, groomed beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting white robe made of textured linen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a plain, off-white plaster wall with a large, out-of-focus leafy green plant beside the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffused natural light creating gentle shadows on the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level in a static medium close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0006331584881991148 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.375633239746094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0006331584881991148, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0006331584881991148, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27086523175239563, + 0.06996279954910278, + 0.05235278978943825, + 0.2275911122560501, + 0.10805398225784302, + 0.05620280280709267, + 0.027093255892395973, + 0.045697540044784546, + 0.06369850039482117, + 0.07848194986581802 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0006331584881991148 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with salt-and-pepper gray hair and a full, groomed beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, loose-fitting white robe made of textured linen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a plain, off-white plaster wall with a large, out-of-focus leafy green plant beside the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffused natural light creating gentle shadows on the face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye-level in a static medium close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004089446272701025 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.50408935546875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004089446272701025, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004089446272701025, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17160198092460632, + 0.062198445200920105, + 0.05818473920226097, + 0.2625790238380432, + 0.031371548771858215, + 0.0528760626912117, + 0.038365356624126434, + 0.07447262853384018, + 0.07543354481458664, + 0.1729166954755783 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004089446272701025 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_10/index_tensor([8008, 8008])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_10/index_tensor([8008, 8008])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8a02c5a4518643c7a3b746c099269c5416b1ccaf --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_10/index_tensor([8008, 8008])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle tracking shot follows a headless, cloaked knight as he rides a ghostly warhorse, violently bumping along a rugged forest path. The entire world, from characters to environments, is composed of sharp, low-polygons, imbued with a unique digital aesthetic. The knight's neck is bare, save for the collar of a tattered black cloak, itself composed of countless dark gray and black polygonal facets, fluttering violently with his violent movements. Beneath this, a geometric armor shimmers with a cold, obsidian sheen. His steed, a phantom composed of translucent, luminescent blue and white polygons, its mane and tail shaped like shards of crystal, its ghostly limbs seemingly crushing the brown and gray triangles of the ground with every footfall, stirring up clouds of polygonal debris. The forest they traverse is composed of sharp pyramidal and prismatic trees. Eerie moonlight filters through the gaps in these geometric treetops, casting sharp, dancing shadows on the knights' polygonal armor and the uneven path. Shot at a high frame rate, every bump, every flutter of a cloak, and every powerful stomp of the horse is rendered with unparalleled fluidity and clarity, creating a surreal and intensely tense chase atmosphere.", + "seed": 1296, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_10/index_8008_seed_1296_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08962597716599703, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08962597716599703, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08962597716599703, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the knight depicted as headless with a bare neck and a tattered black cloak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warhorse translucent, luminescent blue and white, with a mane and tail shaped like crystal shards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a sharp, low-polygon style with geometric trees and polygonal debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following the knight and horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the knight's movements violent, causing the cloak to flutter and the horse to bump along the path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22625607252120972 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6012561321258545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22625607252120972, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22625607252120972, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12779174745082855, + 0.033580467104911804, + 0.12742532789707184, + 0.25988680124282837, + 0.05730248987674713, + 0.04240350425243378, + 0.05352306365966797, + 0.13384833931922913, + 0.1440478414297104, + 0.02019033208489418 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22625607252120972 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the knight depicted as headless with a bare neck and a tattered black cloak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warhorse translucent, luminescent blue and white, with a mane and tail shaped like crystal shards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a sharp, low-polygon style with geometric trees and polygonal debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following the knight and horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the knight's movements violent, causing the cloak to flutter and the horse to bump along the path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005256996490061283 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.2552571296691895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005256996490061283, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005256996490061283, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.132205531001091, + 0.06138552352786064, + 0.18356570601463318, + 0.12478428333997726, + 0.13840894401073456, + 0.0672716498374939, + 0.11491052806377411, + 0.08607037365436554, + 0.05884203687310219, + 0.03255539759993553 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005256996490061283 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the knight depicted as headless with a bare neck and a tattered black cloak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warhorse translucent, luminescent blue and white, with a mane and tail shaped like crystal shards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a sharp, low-polygon style with geometric trees and polygonal debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following the knight and horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the knight's movements violent, causing the cloak to flutter and the horse to bump along the path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11293021589517593 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379302978515625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11293021589517593, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11293021589517593, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0597829706966877, + 0.038916632533073425, + 0.13590820133686066, + 0.3575749695301056, + 0.12859582901000977, + 0.04377957805991173, + 0.10869796574115753, + 0.06929239630699158, + 0.043236277997493744, + 0.01421522069722414 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11293021589517593 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the knight depicted as headless with a bare neck and a tattered black cloak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warhorse translucent, luminescent blue and white, with a mane and tail shaped like crystal shards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a sharp, low-polygon style with geometric trees and polygonal debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following the knight and horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the knight's movements violent, causing the cloak to flutter and the horse to bump along the path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368645906448364 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408686399459839 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368645906448364, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368645906448364, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13270676136016846, + 0.03515813499689102, + 0.10589511692523956, + 0.3133566975593567, + 0.0717594251036644, + 0.06747880578041077, + 0.08852996677160263, + 0.13088586926460266, + 0.03477025404572487, + 0.019458990544080734 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368645906448364 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the knight depicted as headless with a bare neck and a tattered black cloak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warhorse translucent, luminescent blue and white, with a mane and tail shaped like crystal shards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a sharp, low-polygon style with geometric trees and polygonal debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following the knight and horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the knight's movements violent, causing the cloak to flutter and the horse to bump along the path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000014185905457 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695000171661377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000014185905457, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000014185905457, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0701894611120224, + 0.02934710681438446, + 0.05531678721308708, + 0.46808263659477234, + 0.05132201313972473, + 0.03808578848838806, + 0.048454299569129944, + 0.09854813665151596, + 0.12427042424678802, + 0.0163833349943161 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000014185905457 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle tracking shot follows a headless, cloaked knight as he rides a ghostly warhorse, violently bumping along a rugged forest path. The entire world, from characters to environments, is composed of sharp, low-polygons, imbued with a unique digital aesthetic. The knight's neck is bare, save for the collar of a tattered black cloak, itself composed of countless dark gray and black polygonal facets, fluttering violently with his violent movements. Beneath this, a geometric armor shimmers with a cold, obsidian sheen. His steed, a phantom composed of translucent, luminescent blue and white polygons, its mane and tail shaped like shards of crystal, its ghostly limbs seemingly crushing the brown and gray triangles of the ground with every footfall, stirring up clouds of polygonal debris. The forest they traverse is composed of sharp pyramidal and prismatic trees. Eerie moonlight filters through the gaps in these geometric treetops, casting sharp, dancing shadows on the knights' polygonal armor and the uneven path. Shot at a high frame rate, every bump, every flutter of a cloak, and every powerful stomp of the horse is rendered with unparalleled fluidity and clarity, creating a surreal and intensely tense chase atmosphere.", + "seed": 1297, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_10/index_8008_seed_1297_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04523750860244036, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04523750860244036, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04523750860244036, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the knight depicted as headless with a bare neck and a tattered black cloak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warhorse translucent, luminescent blue and white, with a mane and tail shaped like crystal shards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a sharp, low-polygon style with geometric trees and polygonal debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following the knight and horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the knight's movements violent, causing the cloak to flutter and the horse to bump along the path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11360570788383484 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2386057376861572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11360570788383484, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11360570788383484, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14385882019996643, + 0.10349218547344208, + 0.09023447334766388, + 0.10826947540044785, + 0.0670953020453453, + 0.10001223534345627, + 0.1634051352739334, + 0.11559911072254181, + 0.04728304222226143, + 0.06075024977326393 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11360570788383484 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the knight depicted as headless with a bare neck and a tattered black cloak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warhorse translucent, luminescent blue and white, with a mane and tail shaped like crystal shards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a sharp, low-polygon style with geometric trees and polygonal debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following the knight and horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the knight's movements violent, causing the cloak to flutter and the horse to bump along the path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009786837734282017 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634786605834961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009786837734282017, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009786837734282017, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09807059913873672, + 0.10492734611034393, + 0.0754852294921875, + 0.07897356152534485, + 0.02717612311244011, + 0.4191727340221405, + 0.057820875197649, + 0.055187251418828964, + 0.02994394674897194, + 0.05324232205748558 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009786837734282017 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the knight depicted as headless with a bare neck and a tattered black cloak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warhorse translucent, luminescent blue and white, with a mane and tail shaped like crystal shards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a sharp, low-polygon style with geometric trees and polygonal debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following the knight and horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the knight's movements violent, causing the cloak to flutter and the horse to bump along the path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048653870820999146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486538410186768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048653870820999146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048653870820999146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06384460628032684, + 0.07543984800577164, + 0.1382187455892563, + 0.08448901027441025, + 0.04808998107910156, + 0.2786087095737457, + 0.08856014907360077, + 0.09538685530424118, + 0.05407208204269409, + 0.07329000532627106 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048653870820999146 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the knight depicted as headless with a bare neck and a tattered black cloak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warhorse translucent, luminescent blue and white, with a mane and tail shaped like crystal shards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a sharp, low-polygon style with geometric trees and polygonal debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following the knight and horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the knight's movements violent, causing the cloak to flutter and the horse to bump along the path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016058631241321564 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141058444976807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016058631241321564, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016058631241321564, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10658139735460281, + 0.05271134525537491, + 0.166360005736351, + 0.1832512766122818, + 0.07626669853925705, + 0.06903400272130966, + 0.23874644935131073, + 0.04592006653547287, + 0.025997966527938843, + 0.03513072803616524 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016058631241321564 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the knight depicted as headless with a bare neck and a tattered black cloak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warhorse translucent, luminescent blue and white, with a mane and tail shaped like crystal shards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a sharp, low-polygon style with geometric trees and polygonal debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following the knight and horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the knight's movements violent, causing the cloak to flutter and the horse to bump along the path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03808249533176422 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880825996398926 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03808249533176422, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03808249533176422, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1456032395362854, + 0.14990556240081787, + 0.19346608221530914, + 0.06026351451873779, + 0.049940284341573715, + 0.13350823521614075, + 0.12651211023330688, + 0.07248907536268234, + 0.027574067935347557, + 0.04073788598179817 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03808249533176422 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle tracking shot follows a headless, cloaked knight as he rides a ghostly warhorse, violently bumping along a rugged forest path. The entire world, from characters to environments, is composed of sharp, low-polygons, imbued with a unique digital aesthetic. The knight's neck is bare, save for the collar of a tattered black cloak, itself composed of countless dark gray and black polygonal facets, fluttering violently with his violent movements. Beneath this, a geometric armor shimmers with a cold, obsidian sheen. His steed, a phantom composed of translucent, luminescent blue and white polygons, its mane and tail shaped like shards of crystal, its ghostly limbs seemingly crushing the brown and gray triangles of the ground with every footfall, stirring up clouds of polygonal debris. The forest they traverse is composed of sharp pyramidal and prismatic trees. Eerie moonlight filters through the gaps in these geometric treetops, casting sharp, dancing shadows on the knights' polygonal armor and the uneven path. Shot at a high frame rate, every bump, every flutter of a cloak, and every powerful stomp of the horse is rendered with unparalleled fluidity and clarity, creating a surreal and intensely tense chase atmosphere.", + "seed": 1298, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_10/index_8008_seed_1298_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.0631237200461328, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0631237200461328, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0631237200461328, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the knight depicted as headless with a bare neck and a tattered black cloak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warhorse translucent, luminescent blue and white, with a mane and tail shaped like crystal shards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a sharp, low-polygon style with geometric trees and polygonal debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following the knight and horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the knight's movements violent, causing the cloak to flutter and the horse to bump along the path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07926192879676819 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5792620182037354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07926192879676819, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07926192879676819, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.44096919894218445, + 0.08368147164583206, + 0.15596184134483337, + 0.02870338037610054, + 0.045180708169937134, + 0.05325263738632202, + 0.049219146370887756, + 0.06564709544181824, + 0.02660556137561798, + 0.05077895522117615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07926192879676819 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the knight depicted as headless with a bare neck and a tattered black cloak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warhorse translucent, luminescent blue and white, with a mane and tail shaped like crystal shards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a sharp, low-polygon style with geometric trees and polygonal debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following the knight and horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the knight's movements violent, causing the cloak to flutter and the horse to bump along the path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00463957479223609 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379639625549316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00463957479223609, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00463957479223609, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24905090034008026, + 0.04004726558923721, + 0.2541571855545044, + 0.04647557809948921, + 0.09499818831682205, + 0.03473277390003204, + 0.06554864346981049, + 0.14577747881412506, + 0.04651077464222908, + 0.022701222449541092 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00463957479223609 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the knight depicted as headless with a bare neck and a tattered black cloak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warhorse translucent, luminescent blue and white, with a mane and tail shaped like crystal shards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a sharp, low-polygon style with geometric trees and polygonal debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following the knight and horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the knight's movements violent, causing the cloak to flutter and the horse to bump along the path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029799016192555428 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529798984527588 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029799016192555428, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029799016192555428, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3107665777206421, + 0.10661470890045166, + 0.1588180959224701, + 0.031067702919244766, + 0.08084247261285782, + 0.02488005720078945, + 0.06367693841457367, + 0.12224581092596054, + 0.057165052741765976, + 0.043922536075115204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029799016192555428 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the knight depicted as headless with a bare neck and a tattered black cloak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warhorse translucent, luminescent blue and white, with a mane and tail shaped like crystal shards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a sharp, low-polygon style with geometric trees and polygonal debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following the knight and horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the knight's movements violent, causing the cloak to flutter and the horse to bump along the path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08900511264801025 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640049934387207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08900511264801025, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08900511264801025, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18098993599414825, + 0.07262615859508514, + 0.12185065448284149, + 0.08667504042387009, + 0.13414883613586426, + 0.05272669345140457, + 0.10423345118761063, + 0.15020710229873657, + 0.05922684073448181, + 0.03731527552008629 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08900511264801025 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the knight depicted as headless with a bare neck and a tattered black cloak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warhorse translucent, luminescent blue and white, with a mane and tail shaped like crystal shards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a sharp, low-polygon style with geometric trees and polygonal debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following the knight and horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the knight's movements violent, causing the cloak to flutter and the horse to bump along the path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11291296780109406 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237912893295288 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11291296780109406, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11291296780109406, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2770138382911682, + 0.0668526366353035, + 0.2055734395980835, + 0.06812161207199097, + 0.07373631745576859, + 0.046931639313697815, + 0.08363813906908035, + 0.060629986226558685, + 0.059152670204639435, + 0.05834977328777313 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11291296780109406 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle tracking shot follows a headless, cloaked knight as he rides a ghostly warhorse, violently bumping along a rugged forest path. The entire world, from characters to environments, is composed of sharp, low-polygons, imbued with a unique digital aesthetic. The knight's neck is bare, save for the collar of a tattered black cloak, itself composed of countless dark gray and black polygonal facets, fluttering violently with his violent movements. Beneath this, a geometric armor shimmers with a cold, obsidian sheen. His steed, a phantom composed of translucent, luminescent blue and white polygons, its mane and tail shaped like shards of crystal, its ghostly limbs seemingly crushing the brown and gray triangles of the ground with every footfall, stirring up clouds of polygonal debris. The forest they traverse is composed of sharp pyramidal and prismatic trees. Eerie moonlight filters through the gaps in these geometric treetops, casting sharp, dancing shadows on the knights' polygonal armor and the uneven path. Shot at a high frame rate, every bump, every flutter of a cloak, and every powerful stomp of the horse is rendered with unparalleled fluidity and clarity, creating a surreal and intensely tense chase atmosphere.", + "seed": 1299, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_10/index_8008_seed_1299_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06769233522936702, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06769233522936702, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06769233522936702, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the knight depicted as headless with a bare neck and a tattered black cloak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warhorse translucent, luminescent blue and white, with a mane and tail shaped like crystal shards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a sharp, low-polygon style with geometric trees and polygonal debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following the knight and horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the knight's movements violent, causing the cloak to flutter and the horse to bump along the path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14336776733398438 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0183677673339844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14336776733398438, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14336776733398438, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03481508791446686, + 0.14838509261608124, + 0.06279266625642776, + 0.12887586653232574, + 0.09703394025564194, + 0.07428505271673203, + 0.02866264432668686, + 0.15733523666858673, + 0.1847921460866928, + 0.08302224427461624 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14336776733398438 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the knight depicted as headless with a bare neck and a tattered black cloak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warhorse translucent, luminescent blue and white, with a mane and tail shaped like crystal shards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a sharp, low-polygon style with geometric trees and polygonal debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following the knight and horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the knight's movements violent, causing the cloak to flutter and the horse to bump along the path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005955332424491644 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130955219268799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005955332424491644, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005955332424491644, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.057236768305301666, + 0.07359345257282257, + 0.06784865260124207, + 0.029897935688495636, + 0.04645399749279022, + 0.03818501532077789, + 0.034942422062158585, + 0.15690527856349945, + 0.15135708451271057, + 0.34357938170433044 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005955332424491644 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the knight depicted as headless with a bare neck and a tattered black cloak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warhorse translucent, luminescent blue and white, with a mane and tail shaped like crystal shards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a sharp, low-polygon style with geometric trees and polygonal debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following the knight and horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the knight's movements violent, causing the cloak to flutter and the horse to bump along the path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809443116188049 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880945205688477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809443116188049, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809443116188049, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0814286544919014, + 0.10527224838733673, + 0.09880676865577698, + 0.052744150161743164, + 0.07071718573570251, + 0.05683556944131851, + 0.038133490830659866, + 0.21637263894081116, + 0.2044772058725357, + 0.07521204650402069 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809443116188049 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the knight depicted as headless with a bare neck and a tattered black cloak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warhorse translucent, luminescent blue and white, with a mane and tail shaped like crystal shards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a sharp, low-polygon style with geometric trees and polygonal debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following the knight and horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the knight's movements violent, causing the cloak to flutter and the horse to bump along the path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062024421989917755 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120243549346924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062024421989917755, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062024421989917755, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03321066498756409, + 0.09592975676059723, + 0.04032423347234726, + 0.05502984672784805, + 0.10693759471178055, + 0.038628824055194855, + 0.03943067416548729, + 0.28997257351875305, + 0.2564951777458191, + 0.044040631502866745 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062024421989917755 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the knight depicted as headless with a bare neck and a tattered black cloak?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warhorse translucent, luminescent blue and white, with a mane and tail shaped like crystal shards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a sharp, low-polygon style with geometric trees and polygonal debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle tracking shot following the knight and horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the knight's movements violent, causing the cloak to flutter and the horse to bump along the path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08901972323656082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464019775390625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08901972323656082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08901972323656082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03339977189898491, + 0.09047304838895798, + 0.02098890393972397, + 0.04514973983168602, + 0.09260308742523193, + 0.03214923292398453, + 0.05427086725831032, + 0.47306305170059204, + 0.058318015187978745, + 0.09958425164222717 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08901972323656082 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_11/index_tensor([5905, 5905])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_11/index_tensor([5905, 5905])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a64f1455dee5a16eda6da6e767af5ffdf1e84016 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_11/index_tensor([5905, 5905])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "stunning macro close-up, captured using head-tracking stabilization technology, is fixed on a black plastic fragrance holder on a car's air conditioning vent. The amber-colored, translucent gel inside, bathed in the soft, indirect sunlight of the car, appears mirror-smooth, reflecting a sharp, tiny highlight. Suddenly, with the car accelerating without warning, a powerful inertial force instantly acts on the fragile gel. The camera precisely captures the gel's surface as it slightly dents, a nearly invisible ripple spreading from the front to the rear. The previously stationary highlight rapidly slides, stretches, and deforms, flowing across the gel like liquid metal, creating a captivating shift in sheen. At the same time, the camera always maintains absolute focus on the ointment, allowing the outline of the dashboard, the seat material and even the entire interior space in the background to completely disintegrate into a high-speed flowing, dynamic blurred light and shadow interwoven with warm and cold tones under the severe acceleration. The entire picture creates a strong visual impact and a tense atmosphere full of physical dynamic beauty in the extreme contrast between stillness and movement.", + "seed": 5556, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_11/index_5905_seed_5556_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03996802642941475, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03996802642941475, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03996802642941475, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black plastic fragrance holder located on a car's air conditioning vent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gel inside the holder amber-colored, translucent, and mirror-smooth with a sharp tiny highlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gel surface dent and show a ripple spreading from front to rear due to sudden acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the highlight on the gel slide, stretch, and deform like liquid metal while the camera maintains absolute focus on the ointment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background (dashboard, seat, interior) disintegrate into a high-speed blurred flow of warm and cold tones due to severe acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11735442280769348 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.242354393005371 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11735442280769348, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11735442280769348, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20969314873218536, + 0.07626934349536896, + 0.09266762435436249, + 0.04689740017056465, + 0.050889309495687485, + 0.091888926923275, + 0.09424261003732681, + 0.1328093260526657, + 0.1597452163696289, + 0.04489707574248314 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11735442280769348 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black plastic fragrance holder located on a car's air conditioning vent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gel inside the holder amber-colored, translucent, and mirror-smooth with a sharp tiny highlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gel surface dent and show a ripple spreading from front to rear due to sudden acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the highlight on the gel slide, stretch, and deform like liquid metal while the camera maintains absolute focus on the ointment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background (dashboard, seat, interior) disintegrate into a high-speed blurred flow of warm and cold tones due to severe acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008673612959682941 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758673667907715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008673612959682941, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008673612959682941, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15876160562038422, + 0.07193058729171753, + 0.12003469467163086, + 0.04317828267812729, + 0.04728376865386963, + 0.13247187435626984, + 0.1833924800157547, + 0.1446429193019867, + 0.029264165088534355, + 0.06903966516256332 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008673612959682941 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black plastic fragrance holder located on a car's air conditioning vent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gel inside the holder amber-colored, translucent, and mirror-smooth with a sharp tiny highlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gel surface dent and show a ripple spreading from front to rear due to sudden acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the highlight on the gel slide, stretch, and deform like liquid metal while the camera maintains absolute focus on the ointment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background (dashboard, seat, interior) disintegrate into a high-speed blurred flow of warm and cold tones due to severe acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043069567531347275 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.16806960105896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043069567531347275, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043069567531347275, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12901583313941956, + 0.05883725732564926, + 0.0343528613448143, + 0.034883495420217514, + 0.028679311275482178, + 0.3734056055545807, + 0.1546570211648941, + 0.060712557286024094, + 0.06297530233860016, + 0.062480710446834564 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043069567531347275 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black plastic fragrance holder located on a car's air conditioning vent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gel inside the holder amber-colored, translucent, and mirror-smooth with a sharp tiny highlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gel surface dent and show a ripple spreading from front to rear due to sudden acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the highlight on the gel slide, stretch, and deform like liquid metal while the camera maintains absolute focus on the ointment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background (dashboard, seat, interior) disintegrate into a high-speed blurred flow of warm and cold tones due to severe acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012550893239676952 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875508308410645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012550893239676952, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012550893239676952, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12283274531364441, + 0.058597382158041, + 0.060017943382263184, + 0.018331581726670265, + 0.026977306231856346, + 0.38533124327659607, + 0.15479975938796997, + 0.08899703621864319, + 0.06130712851881981, + 0.022807829082012177 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012550893239676952 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black plastic fragrance holder located on a car's air conditioning vent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gel inside the holder amber-colored, translucent, and mirror-smooth with a sharp tiny highlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gel surface dent and show a ripple spreading from front to rear due to sudden acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the highlight on the gel slide, stretch, and deform like liquid metal while the camera maintains absolute focus on the ointment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background (dashboard, seat, interior) disintegrate into a high-speed blurred flow of warm and cold tones due to severe acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018191635608673096 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018191814422607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018191635608673096, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018191635608673096, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07176899164915085, + 0.024195799604058266, + 0.021767795085906982, + 0.023668650537729263, + 0.013542931526899338, + 0.687248706817627, + 0.08610409498214722, + 0.033643100410699844, + 0.025605587288737297, + 0.012454332783818245 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018191635608673096 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning macro close-up, captured using head-tracking stabilization technology, is fixed on a black plastic fragrance holder on a car's air conditioning vent. The amber-colored, translucent gel inside, bathed in the soft, indirect sunlight of the car, appears mirror-smooth, reflecting a sharp, tiny highlight. Suddenly, with the car accelerating without warning, a powerful inertial force instantly acts on the fragile gel. The camera precisely captures the gel's surface as it slightly dents, a nearly invisible ripple spreading from the front to the rear. The previously stationary highlight rapidly slides, stretches, and deforms, flowing across the gel like liquid metal, creating a captivating shift in sheen. At the same time, the camera always maintains absolute focus on the ointment, allowing the outline of the dashboard, the seat material and even the entire interior space in the background to completely disintegrate into a high-speed flowing, dynamic blurred light and shadow interwoven with warm and cold tones under the severe acceleration. The entire picture creates a strong visual impact and a tense atmosphere full of physical dynamic beauty in the extreme contrast between stillness and movement.", + "seed": 5557, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_11/index_5905_seed_5557_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.12759209210053085, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12759209210053085, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12759209210053085, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black plastic fragrance holder located on a car's air conditioning vent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gel inside the holder amber-colored, translucent, and mirror-smooth with a sharp tiny highlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gel surface dent and show a ripple spreading from front to rear due to sudden acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the highlight on the gel slide, stretch, and deform like liquid metal while the camera maintains absolute focus on the ointment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background (dashboard, seat, interior) disintegrate into a high-speed blurred flow of warm and cold tones due to severe acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02916310727596283 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.654163122177124 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02916310727596283, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02916310727596283, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13302528858184814, + 0.041852958500385284, + 0.4006783366203308, + 0.14147695899009705, + 0.04017798602581024, + 0.03515845909714699, + 0.07019515335559845, + 0.02983454056084156, + 0.025324208661913872, + 0.0822761282324791 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02916310727596283 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black plastic fragrance holder located on a car's air conditioning vent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gel inside the holder amber-colored, translucent, and mirror-smooth with a sharp tiny highlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gel surface dent and show a ripple spreading from front to rear due to sudden acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the highlight on the gel slide, stretch, and deform like liquid metal while the camera maintains absolute focus on the ointment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background (dashboard, seat, interior) disintegrate into a high-speed blurred flow of warm and cold tones due to severe acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005274902563542128 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255274772644043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005274902563542128, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005274902563542128, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10140269249677658, + 0.09290973097085953, + 0.20321878790855408, + 0.20355962216854095, + 0.06853073835372925, + 0.057044632732868195, + 0.13574522733688354, + 0.050185833126306534, + 0.03958282992243767, + 0.047819893807172775 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005274902563542128 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black plastic fragrance holder located on a car's air conditioning vent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gel inside the holder amber-colored, translucent, and mirror-smooth with a sharp tiny highlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gel surface dent and show a ripple spreading from front to rear due to sudden acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the highlight on the gel slide, stretch, and deform like liquid metal while the camera maintains absolute focus on the ointment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background (dashboard, seat, interior) disintegrate into a high-speed blurred flow of warm and cold tones due to severe acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16037733852863312 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103773832321167 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16037733852863312, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16037733852863312, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.027707554399967194, + 0.044907812029123306, + 0.7789077758789062, + 0.02399110235273838, + 0.012769618071615696, + 0.024357134476304054, + 0.030372828245162964, + 0.013846698217093945, + 0.018207933753728867, + 0.024931518360972404 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16037733852863312 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black plastic fragrance holder located on a car's air conditioning vent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gel inside the holder amber-colored, translucent, and mirror-smooth with a sharp tiny highlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gel surface dent and show a ripple spreading from front to rear due to sudden acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the highlight on the gel slide, stretch, and deform like liquid metal while the camera maintains absolute focus on the ointment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background (dashboard, seat, interior) disintegrate into a high-speed blurred flow of warm and cold tones due to severe acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014213399030268192 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264213562011719 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014213399030268192, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014213399030268192, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09275708347558975, + 0.07229562848806381, + 0.28391963243484497, + 0.19228291511535645, + 0.06183817237615585, + 0.052053630352020264, + 0.08586970716714859, + 0.05899282917380333, + 0.03831516206264496, + 0.06167523190379143 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014213399030268192 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black plastic fragrance holder located on a car's air conditioning vent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gel inside the holder amber-colored, translucent, and mirror-smooth with a sharp tiny highlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gel surface dent and show a ripple spreading from front to rear due to sudden acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the highlight on the gel slide, stretch, and deform like liquid metal while the camera maintains absolute focus on the ointment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background (dashboard, seat, interior) disintegrate into a high-speed blurred flow of warm and cold tones due to severe acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42893171310424805 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.053931713104248 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42893171310424805, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42893171310424805, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09640514105558395, + 0.031682997941970825, + 0.12846873700618744, + 0.033026330173015594, + 0.0793195441365242, + 0.11065743118524551, + 0.1261288821697235, + 0.12345320731401443, + 0.047522757202386856, + 0.22333498299121857 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42893171310424805 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning macro close-up, captured using head-tracking stabilization technology, is fixed on a black plastic fragrance holder on a car's air conditioning vent. The amber-colored, translucent gel inside, bathed in the soft, indirect sunlight of the car, appears mirror-smooth, reflecting a sharp, tiny highlight. Suddenly, with the car accelerating without warning, a powerful inertial force instantly acts on the fragile gel. The camera precisely captures the gel's surface as it slightly dents, a nearly invisible ripple spreading from the front to the rear. The previously stationary highlight rapidly slides, stretches, and deforms, flowing across the gel like liquid metal, creating a captivating shift in sheen. At the same time, the camera always maintains absolute focus on the ointment, allowing the outline of the dashboard, the seat material and even the entire interior space in the background to completely disintegrate into a high-speed flowing, dynamic blurred light and shadow interwoven with warm and cold tones under the severe acceleration. The entire picture creates a strong visual impact and a tense atmosphere full of physical dynamic beauty in the extreme contrast between stillness and movement.", + "seed": 5558, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_11/index_5905_seed_5558_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.09187903832644224, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09187903832644224, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09187903832644224, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black plastic fragrance holder located on a car's air conditioning vent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gel inside the holder amber-colored, translucent, and mirror-smooth with a sharp tiny highlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gel surface dent and show a ripple spreading from front to rear due to sudden acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the highlight on the gel slide, stretch, and deform like liquid metal while the camera maintains absolute focus on the ointment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background (dashboard, seat, interior) disintegrate into a high-speed blurred flow of warm and cold tones due to severe acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1846807450056076 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.809680700302124 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1846807450056076, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1846807450056076, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15825167298316956, + 0.14798703789710999, + 0.049197666347026825, + 0.2048797309398651, + 0.09477017819881439, + 0.05516641587018967, + 0.023106038570404053, + 0.053663697093725204, + 0.19211772084236145, + 0.020859921351075172 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1846807450056076 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black plastic fragrance holder located on a car's air conditioning vent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gel inside the holder amber-colored, translucent, and mirror-smooth with a sharp tiny highlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gel surface dent and show a ripple spreading from front to rear due to sudden acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the highlight on the gel slide, stretch, and deform like liquid metal while the camera maintains absolute focus on the ointment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background (dashboard, seat, interior) disintegrate into a high-speed blurred flow of warm and cold tones due to severe acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01611235737800598 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141112327575684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01611235737800598, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01611235737800598, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.053221702575683594, + 0.6835567355155945, + 0.02082386426627636, + 0.12753739953041077, + 0.03290323540568352, + 0.015056848526000977, + 0.015941280871629715, + 0.01457663532346487, + 0.02606234699487686, + 0.010319925844669342 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01611235737800598 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black plastic fragrance holder located on a car's air conditioning vent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gel inside the holder amber-colored, translucent, and mirror-smooth with a sharp tiny highlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gel surface dent and show a ripple spreading from front to rear due to sudden acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the highlight on the gel slide, stretch, and deform like liquid metal while the camera maintains absolute focus on the ointment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background (dashboard, seat, interior) disintegrate into a high-speed blurred flow of warm and cold tones due to severe acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004037499427795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695040464401245 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004037499427795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004037499427795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09408260136842728, + 0.166716530919075, + 0.11650503426790237, + 0.37329497933387756, + 0.05212993174791336, + 0.056533146649599075, + 0.034223999828100204, + 0.01424738485366106, + 0.0647977814078331, + 0.027468618005514145 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004037499427795 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black plastic fragrance holder located on a car's air conditioning vent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gel inside the holder amber-colored, translucent, and mirror-smooth with a sharp tiny highlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gel surface dent and show a ripple spreading from front to rear due to sudden acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the highlight on the gel slide, stretch, and deform like liquid metal while the camera maintains absolute focus on the ointment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background (dashboard, seat, interior) disintegrate into a high-speed blurred flow of warm and cold tones due to severe acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008658013306558132 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758657932281494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008658013306558132, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008658013306558132, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11243881285190582, + 0.18676331639289856, + 0.21058110892772675, + 0.11594140529632568, + 0.06052238866686821, + 0.09296946227550507, + 0.0645575150847435, + 0.04490829259157181, + 0.05266701802611351, + 0.05865063890814781 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008658013306558132 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black plastic fragrance holder located on a car's air conditioning vent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gel inside the holder amber-colored, translucent, and mirror-smooth with a sharp tiny highlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gel surface dent and show a ripple spreading from front to rear due to sudden acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the highlight on the gel slide, stretch, and deform like liquid metal while the camera maintains absolute focus on the ointment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background (dashboard, seat, interior) disintegrate into a high-speed blurred flow of warm and cold tones due to severe acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17990370094776154 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049037456512451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17990370094776154, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17990370094776154, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12740640342235565, + 0.2924761474132538, + 0.01970439963042736, + 0.20786938071250916, + 0.07628820836544037, + 0.15344110131263733, + 0.0625804141163826, + 0.009611133486032486, + 0.026595691218972206, + 0.024027077481150627 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17990370094776154 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning macro close-up, captured using head-tracking stabilization technology, is fixed on a black plastic fragrance holder on a car's air conditioning vent. The amber-colored, translucent gel inside, bathed in the soft, indirect sunlight of the car, appears mirror-smooth, reflecting a sharp, tiny highlight. Suddenly, with the car accelerating without warning, a powerful inertial force instantly acts on the fragile gel. The camera precisely captures the gel's surface as it slightly dents, a nearly invisible ripple spreading from the front to the rear. The previously stationary highlight rapidly slides, stretches, and deforms, flowing across the gel like liquid metal, creating a captivating shift in sheen. At the same time, the camera always maintains absolute focus on the ointment, allowing the outline of the dashboard, the seat material and even the entire interior space in the background to completely disintegrate into a high-speed flowing, dynamic blurred light and shadow interwoven with warm and cold tones under the severe acceleration. The entire picture creates a strong visual impact and a tense atmosphere full of physical dynamic beauty in the extreme contrast between stillness and movement.", + "seed": 5559, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_11/index_5905_seed_5559_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10762012656778097, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10762012656778097, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.025000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10762012656778097, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black plastic fragrance holder located on a car's air conditioning vent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gel inside the holder amber-colored, translucent, and mirror-smooth with a sharp tiny highlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gel surface dent and show a ripple spreading from front to rear due to sudden acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the highlight on the gel slide, stretch, and deform like liquid metal while the camera maintains absolute focus on the ointment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background (dashboard, seat, interior) disintegrate into a high-speed blurred flow of warm and cold tones due to severe acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.028844652697443962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6538445949554443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.028844652697443962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.028844652697443962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40530914068222046, + 0.2115067094564438, + 0.047422800213098526, + 0.034256868064403534, + 0.07076339423656464, + 0.1365915685892105, + 0.03053918108344078, + 0.015437322668731213, + 0.009799676947295666, + 0.03837330639362335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.028844652697443962 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black plastic fragrance holder located on a car's air conditioning vent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gel inside the holder amber-colored, translucent, and mirror-smooth with a sharp tiny highlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gel surface dent and show a ripple spreading from front to rear due to sudden acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the highlight on the gel slide, stretch, and deform like liquid metal while the camera maintains absolute focus on the ointment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background (dashboard, seat, interior) disintegrate into a high-speed blurred flow of warm and cold tones due to severe acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009811627678573132 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6348114013671875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009811627678573132, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009811627678573132, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11306246370077133, + 0.18135246634483337, + 0.13590067625045776, + 0.05057968944311142, + 0.08091391623020172, + 0.1335148811340332, + 0.10664589703083038, + 0.1158779039978981, + 0.028545686975121498, + 0.05360644683241844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009811627678573132 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black plastic fragrance holder located on a car's air conditioning vent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gel inside the holder amber-colored, translucent, and mirror-smooth with a sharp tiny highlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gel surface dent and show a ripple spreading from front to rear due to sudden acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the highlight on the gel slide, stretch, and deform like liquid metal while the camera maintains absolute focus on the ointment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background (dashboard, seat, interior) disintegrate into a high-speed blurred flow of warm and cold tones due to severe acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890587642788887 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640588760375977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0890587642788887, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0890587642788887, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17569434642791748, + 0.13793650269508362, + 0.06803690642118454, + 0.10485999286174774, + 0.0549766905605793, + 0.23535218834877014, + 0.05150465667247772, + 0.11590737849473953, + 0.02020387165248394, + 0.035527437925338745 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0890587642788887 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black plastic fragrance holder located on a car's air conditioning vent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gel inside the holder amber-colored, translucent, and mirror-smooth with a sharp tiny highlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gel surface dent and show a ripple spreading from front to rear due to sudden acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the highlight on the gel slide, stretch, and deform like liquid metal while the camera maintains absolute focus on the ointment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background (dashboard, seat, interior) disintegrate into a high-speed blurred flow of warm and cold tones due to severe acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023309269919991493 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733092308044434 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023309269919991493, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023309269919991493, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28256550431251526, + 0.07202064245939255, + 0.06860670447349548, + 0.14075487852096558, + 0.07170901447534561, + 0.1048484593629837, + 0.08038340508937836, + 0.1365175098180771, + 0.015781940892338753, + 0.026811925694346428 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023309269919991493 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black plastic fragrance holder located on a car's air conditioning vent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the gel inside the holder amber-colored, translucent, and mirror-smooth with a sharp tiny highlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gel surface dent and show a ripple spreading from front to rear due to sudden acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the highlight on the gel slide, stretch, and deform like liquid metal while the camera maintains absolute focus on the ointment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background (dashboard, seat, interior) disintegrate into a high-speed blurred flow of warm and cold tones due to severe acceleration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38707631826400757 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370763778686523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38707631826400757, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7500000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38707631826400757, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15109498798847198, + 0.07019198685884476, + 0.06497266888618469, + 0.09562154859304428, + 0.04932859167456627, + 0.04541727900505066, + 0.14900748431682587, + 0.32436805963516235, + 0.011538653634488583, + 0.03845877945423126 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38707631826400757 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_12/index_tensor([9076, 9076])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_12/index_tensor([9076, 9076])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d5111b16aeb19dbbf041cd88b3b08d0ba39a295b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_12/index_tensor([9076, 9076])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, shot from a low, ground-level angle, employs a dreamy, soft-focus effect, the camera slowly following the subject upward. At the center of the frame is an anthropomorphic, 3D, cartoon-style college acceptance letter. Composed of thick, off-white matte paper, its fibrous texture clearly visible under the warm, golden sidelight of the setting sun. The lower half of the envelope, artfully folded into two short, powerful paper legs, exerts its full strength in a miniature climb, leaning forward and struggling to ascend the metal steps of a vintage, dark green passenger train. One leg is bent, resting on the cold carriage steps, while the other stretches upward, its paper form trembling slightly with the effort, evoking a charming yet determined clumsiness. A delicate crimson wax seal seals the envelope, reflecting a soft luster in the light, adding a touch of color to the image. The background depicts a train platform bathed in golden afterglow. A soft focus effect blurs the distant tracks and building outlines into a hazy, warm glow. The train is about to depart for an unknown destination. The entire image exudes a fairytale atmosphere of warmth, hope, and determination, as if a dream is about to take off.", + "seed": 21474, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_12/index_9076_seed_21474_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04778975280933082, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04778975280933082, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04778975280933082, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an anthropomorphic, 3D, cartoon-style college acceptance letter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the letter made of thick, off-white matte paper with visible fibrous texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lower half of the envelope fold into two paper legs that are climbing metal steps of a vintage, dark green train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate crimson wax seal on the envelope reflecting a soft luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a low, ground-level angle with the camera slowly following the subject upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20327390730381012 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.703273892402649 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20327390730381012, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20327390730381012, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12950773537158966, + 0.0874578133225441, + 0.04237916320562363, + 0.08635709434747696, + 0.07163985818624496, + 0.35024014115333557, + 0.02679792232811451, + 0.11995530128479004, + 0.03062397986650467, + 0.05504104867577553 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20327390730381012 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an anthropomorphic, 3D, cartoon-style college acceptance letter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the letter made of thick, off-white matte paper with visible fibrous texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lower half of the envelope fold into two paper legs that are climbing metal steps of a vintage, dark green train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate crimson wax seal on the envelope reflecting a soft luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a low, ground-level angle with the camera slowly following the subject upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059655450284481 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895596504211426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059655450284481, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059655450284481, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19579081237316132, + 0.1633191704750061, + 0.07416170090436935, + 0.22883924841880798, + 0.06027527526021004, + 0.05659967660903931, + 0.03900458663702011, + 0.07625732570886612, + 0.025591708719730377, + 0.08016053587198257 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059655450284481 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an anthropomorphic, 3D, cartoon-style college acceptance letter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the letter made of thick, off-white matte paper with visible fibrous texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lower half of the envelope fold into two paper legs that are climbing metal steps of a vintage, dark green train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate crimson wax seal on the envelope reflecting a soft luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a low, ground-level angle with the camera slowly following the subject upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00463993102312088 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379640102386475 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00463993102312088, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00463993102312088, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1544439047574997, + 0.056253980845212936, + 0.12030081450939178, + 0.056840747594833374, + 0.05018683895468712, + 0.22762960195541382, + 0.033204417675733566, + 0.0836561992764473, + 0.09097632020711899, + 0.1265072077512741 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00463993102312088 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an anthropomorphic, 3D, cartoon-style college acceptance letter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the letter made of thick, off-white matte paper with visible fibrous texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lower half of the envelope fold into two paper legs that are climbing metal steps of a vintage, dark green train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate crimson wax seal on the envelope reflecting a soft luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a low, ground-level angle with the camera slowly following the subject upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028161650989204645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877816200256348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028161650989204645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028161650989204645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07626282423734665, + 0.1354954093694687, + 0.2785961925983429, + 0.044385798275470734, + 0.06970041245222092, + 0.15906871855258942, + 0.030988436192274094, + 0.07343409210443497, + 0.026711098849773407, + 0.10535706579685211 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028161650989204645 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an anthropomorphic, 3D, cartoon-style college acceptance letter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the letter made of thick, off-white matte paper with visible fibrous texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lower half of the envelope fold into two paper legs that are climbing metal steps of a vintage, dark green train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate crimson wax seal on the envelope reflecting a soft luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a low, ground-level angle with the camera slowly following the subject upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00762220611795783 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882622241973877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00762220611795783, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00762220611795783, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12094346433877945, + 0.07423458993434906, + 0.08724474161863327, + 0.06754513084888458, + 0.06417358666658401, + 0.19736610352993011, + 0.05722625181078911, + 0.06305524706840515, + 0.1435355246067047, + 0.12467536330223083 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00762220611795783 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, shot from a low, ground-level angle, employs a dreamy, soft-focus effect, the camera slowly following the subject upward. At the center of the frame is an anthropomorphic, 3D, cartoon-style college acceptance letter. Composed of thick, off-white matte paper, its fibrous texture clearly visible under the warm, golden sidelight of the setting sun. The lower half of the envelope, artfully folded into two short, powerful paper legs, exerts its full strength in a miniature climb, leaning forward and struggling to ascend the metal steps of a vintage, dark green passenger train. One leg is bent, resting on the cold carriage steps, while the other stretches upward, its paper form trembling slightly with the effort, evoking a charming yet determined clumsiness. A delicate crimson wax seal seals the envelope, reflecting a soft luster in the light, adding a touch of color to the image. The background depicts a train platform bathed in golden afterglow. A soft focus effect blurs the distant tracks and building outlines into a hazy, warm glow. The train is about to depart for an unknown destination. The entire image exudes a fairytale atmosphere of warmth, hope, and determination, as if a dream is about to take off.", + "seed": 21475, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_12/index_9076_seed_21475_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.013692148495465517, + "vlm_logprob": -0.013692148495465517, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.013692148495465517, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an anthropomorphic, 3D, cartoon-style college acceptance letter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the letter made of thick, off-white matte paper with visible fibrous texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lower half of the envelope fold into two paper legs that are climbing metal steps of a vintage, dark green train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate crimson wax seal on the envelope reflecting a soft luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a low, ground-level angle with the camera slowly following the subject upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004728445317596197 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504728317260742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004728445317596197, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004728445317596197, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10804571956396103, + 0.06470182538032532, + 0.03542690351605415, + 0.2887595593929291, + 0.050667665898799896, + 0.045904677361249924, + 0.0837806835770607, + 0.04962974414229393, + 0.2247842699289322, + 0.04829901456832886 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004728445317596197 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an anthropomorphic, 3D, cartoon-style college acceptance letter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the letter made of thick, off-white matte paper with visible fibrous texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lower half of the envelope fold into two paper legs that are climbing metal steps of a vintage, dark green train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate crimson wax seal on the envelope reflecting a soft luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a low, ground-level angle with the camera slowly following the subject upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048662614077329636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486626625061035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048662614077329636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048662614077329636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16329869627952576, + 0.07355545461177826, + 0.07594097405672073, + 0.11362537741661072, + 0.08377578854560852, + 0.03930742293596268, + 0.19446344673633575, + 0.03799767792224884, + 0.19478356838226318, + 0.023251550272107124 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048662614077329636 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an anthropomorphic, 3D, cartoon-style college acceptance letter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the letter made of thick, off-white matte paper with visible fibrous texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lower half of the envelope fold into two paper legs that are climbing metal steps of a vintage, dark green train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate crimson wax seal on the envelope reflecting a soft luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a low, ground-level angle with the camera slowly following the subject upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002198542468249798 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127198696136475 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002198542468249798, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002198542468249798, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10370531678199768, + 0.06131457909941673, + 0.07132051140069962, + 0.07129587978124619, + 0.16138236224651337, + 0.034287914633750916, + 0.0747959166765213, + 0.024967173114418983, + 0.3257102966308594, + 0.0712200179696083 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002198542468249798 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an anthropomorphic, 3D, cartoon-style college acceptance letter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the letter made of thick, off-white matte paper with visible fibrous texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lower half of the envelope fold into two paper legs that are climbing metal steps of a vintage, dark green train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate crimson wax seal on the envelope reflecting a soft luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a low, ground-level angle with the camera slowly following the subject upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005249644163995981 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255249500274658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005249644163995981, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005249644163995981, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13783463835716248, + 0.2359107881784439, + 0.019367357715964317, + 0.19681310653686523, + 0.05423690378665924, + 0.09675054997205734, + 0.12685954570770264, + 0.013299885205924511, + 0.09099029004573822, + 0.027936935424804688 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005249644163995981 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an anthropomorphic, 3D, cartoon-style college acceptance letter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the letter made of thick, off-white matte paper with visible fibrous texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lower half of the envelope fold into two paper legs that are climbing metal steps of a vintage, dark green train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate crimson wax seal on the envelope reflecting a soft luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a low, ground-level angle with the camera slowly following the subject upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076214964501559734 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826212882995605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076214964501559734, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076214964501559734, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2533714175224304, + 0.10672993957996368, + 0.03261333331465721, + 0.21649037301540375, + 0.07188855111598969, + 0.02106589637696743, + 0.07329966872930527, + 0.026798877865076065, + 0.14332880079746246, + 0.05441313236951828 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076214964501559734 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, shot from a low, ground-level angle, employs a dreamy, soft-focus effect, the camera slowly following the subject upward. At the center of the frame is an anthropomorphic, 3D, cartoon-style college acceptance letter. Composed of thick, off-white matte paper, its fibrous texture clearly visible under the warm, golden sidelight of the setting sun. The lower half of the envelope, artfully folded into two short, powerful paper legs, exerts its full strength in a miniature climb, leaning forward and struggling to ascend the metal steps of a vintage, dark green passenger train. One leg is bent, resting on the cold carriage steps, while the other stretches upward, its paper form trembling slightly with the effort, evoking a charming yet determined clumsiness. A delicate crimson wax seal seals the envelope, reflecting a soft luster in the light, adding a touch of color to the image. The background depicts a train platform bathed in golden afterglow. A soft focus effect blurs the distant tracks and building outlines into a hazy, warm glow. The train is about to depart for an unknown destination. The entire image exudes a fairytale atmosphere of warmth, hope, and determination, as if a dream is about to take off.", + "seed": 21476, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_12/index_9076_seed_21476_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.020617664814926683, + "vlm_logprob": -0.020617664814926683, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.020617664814926683, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an anthropomorphic, 3D, cartoon-style college acceptance letter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the letter made of thick, off-white matte paper with visible fibrous texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lower half of the envelope fold into two paper legs that are climbing metal steps of a vintage, dark green train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate crimson wax seal on the envelope reflecting a soft luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a low, ground-level angle with the camera slowly following the subject upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03941024839878082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.289410352706909 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03941024839878082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03941024839878082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05562744289636612, + 0.05363377556204796, + 0.04829736426472664, + 0.0858684852719307, + 0.1379222571849823, + 0.018322549760341644, + 0.05071549490094185, + 0.01947304978966713, + 0.03399215266108513, + 0.49614739418029785 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03941024839878082 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an anthropomorphic, 3D, cartoon-style college acceptance letter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the letter made of thick, off-white matte paper with visible fibrous texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lower half of the envelope fold into two paper legs that are climbing metal steps of a vintage, dark green train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate crimson wax seal on the envelope reflecting a soft luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a low, ground-level angle with the camera slowly following the subject upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307733103632927 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168077230453491 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307733103632927, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307733103632927, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07616811245679855, + 0.08426327258348465, + 0.03045131079852581, + 0.08118544518947601, + 0.08171623200178146, + 0.02292175590991974, + 0.013770182617008686, + 0.026833128184080124, + 0.02041555568575859, + 0.5622749924659729 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307733103632927 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an anthropomorphic, 3D, cartoon-style college acceptance letter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the letter made of thick, off-white matte paper with visible fibrous texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lower half of the envelope fold into two paper legs that are climbing metal steps of a vintage, dark green train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate crimson wax seal on the envelope reflecting a soft luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a low, ground-level angle with the camera slowly following the subject upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006739149335771799 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006739139556885 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006739149335771799, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006739149335771799, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07895352691411972, + 0.04328685253858566, + 0.059467289596796036, + 0.03945406153798103, + 0.18149536848068237, + 0.07562968134880066, + 0.05051517114043236, + 0.06016068533062935, + 0.16121934354305267, + 0.24981798231601715 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006739149335771799 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an anthropomorphic, 3D, cartoon-style college acceptance letter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the letter made of thick, off-white matte paper with visible fibrous texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lower half of the envelope fold into two paper legs that are climbing metal steps of a vintage, dark green train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate crimson wax seal on the envelope reflecting a soft luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a low, ground-level angle with the camera slowly following the subject upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013336582342162728 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626333713531494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013336582342162728, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013336582342162728, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13075564801692963, + 0.06460089981555939, + 0.06766405701637268, + 0.08004454523324966, + 0.06315258890390396, + 0.050255123525857925, + 0.04097786545753479, + 0.043660394847393036, + 0.1316419243812561, + 0.3272469639778137 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013336582342162728 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an anthropomorphic, 3D, cartoon-style college acceptance letter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the letter made of thick, off-white matte paper with visible fibrous texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lower half of the envelope fold into two paper legs that are climbing metal steps of a vintage, dark green train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate crimson wax seal on the envelope reflecting a soft luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a low, ground-level angle with the camera slowly following the subject upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012527937069535255 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387527942657471 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012527937069535255, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012527937069535255, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08746658265590668, + 0.019757095724344254, + 0.07283474504947662, + 0.04521648958325386, + 0.03469856083393097, + 0.04899376630783081, + 0.03584246709942818, + 0.07217975705862045, + 0.08254684507846832, + 0.5004637241363525 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012527937069535255 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, shot from a low, ground-level angle, employs a dreamy, soft-focus effect, the camera slowly following the subject upward. At the center of the frame is an anthropomorphic, 3D, cartoon-style college acceptance letter. Composed of thick, off-white matte paper, its fibrous texture clearly visible under the warm, golden sidelight of the setting sun. The lower half of the envelope, artfully folded into two short, powerful paper legs, exerts its full strength in a miniature climb, leaning forward and struggling to ascend the metal steps of a vintage, dark green passenger train. One leg is bent, resting on the cold carriage steps, while the other stretches upward, its paper form trembling slightly with the effort, evoking a charming yet determined clumsiness. A delicate crimson wax seal seals the envelope, reflecting a soft luster in the light, adding a touch of color to the image. The background depicts a train platform bathed in golden afterglow. A soft focus effect blurs the distant tracks and building outlines into a hazy, warm glow. The train is about to depart for an unknown destination. The entire image exudes a fairytale atmosphere of warmth, hope, and determination, as if a dream is about to take off.", + "seed": 21477, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_12/index_9076_seed_21477_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.012706747790798546, + "vlm_logprob": -0.012706747790798546, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.012706747790798546, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an anthropomorphic, 3D, cartoon-style college acceptance letter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the letter made of thick, off-white matte paper with visible fibrous texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lower half of the envelope fold into two paper legs that are climbing metal steps of a vintage, dark green train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate crimson wax seal on the envelope reflecting a soft luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a low, ground-level angle with the camera slowly following the subject upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007293148431926966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.007293224334717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007293148431926966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007293148431926966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13100048899650574, + 0.14294008910655975, + 0.08417869359254837, + 0.07501863688230515, + 0.09172480553388596, + 0.14964833855628967, + 0.08594851940870285, + 0.032809436321258545, + 0.028086168691515923, + 0.17864488065242767 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007293148431926966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an anthropomorphic, 3D, cartoon-style college acceptance letter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the letter made of thick, off-white matte paper with visible fibrous texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lower half of the envelope fold into two paper legs that are climbing metal steps of a vintage, dark green train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate crimson wax seal on the envelope reflecting a soft luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a low, ground-level angle with the camera slowly following the subject upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043065570294857025 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680655479431152 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043065570294857025, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043065570294857025, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.194614976644516, + 0.22774487733840942, + 0.07257720082998276, + 0.04530758783221245, + 0.03878682851791382, + 0.06070138141512871, + 0.10363239794969559, + 0.06218797713518143, + 0.0684235617518425, + 0.12602314352989197 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043065570294857025 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an anthropomorphic, 3D, cartoon-style college acceptance letter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the letter made of thick, off-white matte paper with visible fibrous texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lower half of the envelope fold into two paper legs that are climbing metal steps of a vintage, dark green train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate crimson wax seal on the envelope reflecting a soft luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a low, ground-level angle with the camera slowly following the subject upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036170552484691143 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628617286682129 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036170552484691143, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036170552484691143, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1302689164876938, + 0.09367647767066956, + 0.024933993816375732, + 0.083511583507061, + 0.05463770031929016, + 0.030905229970812798, + 0.024587100371718407, + 0.35971537232398987, + 0.029660886153578758, + 0.16810275614261627 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036170552484691143 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an anthropomorphic, 3D, cartoon-style college acceptance letter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the letter made of thick, off-white matte paper with visible fibrous texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lower half of the envelope fold into two paper legs that are climbing metal steps of a vintage, dark green train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate crimson wax seal on the envelope reflecting a soft luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a low, ground-level angle with the camera slowly following the subject upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019368238281458616 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251936912536621 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019368238281458616, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019368238281458616, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10620107501745224, + 0.09573419392108917, + 0.13680477440357208, + 0.05582095682621002, + 0.1153053566813469, + 0.08482743799686432, + 0.10551891475915909, + 0.05248870700597763, + 0.03338849917054176, + 0.21391016244888306 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019368238281458616 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an anthropomorphic, 3D, cartoon-style college acceptance letter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the letter made of thick, off-white matte paper with visible fibrous texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the lower half of the envelope fold into two paper legs that are climbing metal steps of a vintage, dark green train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate crimson wax seal on the envelope reflecting a soft luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a low, ground-level angle with the camera slowly following the subject upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007621141150593758 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826212882995605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007621141150593758, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007621141150593758, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26474371552467346, + 0.07122217118740082, + 0.03742746636271477, + 0.039300337433815, + 0.029276788234710693, + 0.03466186299920082, + 0.02707841992378235, + 0.11026815325021744, + 0.03592616319656372, + 0.3500949442386627 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007621141150593758 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_13/index_tensor([6342, 6342])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_13/index_tensor([6342, 6342])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f4f7a2b64c03be1c61e2537e4840237566fc6a27 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_13/index_tensor([6342, 6342])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a bird's-eye view, the camera held still. Centered on a rough, white clothing design sketch, spread across a dark wooden workbench, lies a sparsely textured canvas. A warm yellow desk lamp casts a soft glow from the upper left, illuminating the fluid, black charcoal outlines of a woman's fashion. Suddenly, these static black lines begin to tremble slightly, then, as if imbued with life, gracefully lift and peel from the surface in the exquisitely smooth, seamless style of Motion Graphics (MG). They whirl through the air in rhythmic spirals, instantly imbued with vibrant colors like ruby red, royal blue, and emerald green. The original charcoal lines rapidly unwind and expand, miraculously transforming into strands of silky, flowing, multicolored fabric. These fabrics slowly dance and intertwine in the center of the frame, their delicate shimmering patterns captured by the soft light. The scene creates a dreamlike atmosphere of magical creativity and exquisite beauty.", + "seed": 33205, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_13/index_6342_seed_33205_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0140030262991786, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0140030262991786, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0140030262991786, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a bird's-eye view and held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene a close-up of a rough white clothing design sketch on a dark wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do black charcoal outlines of a woman's fashion lift from the surface and transform into silky, multicolored fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fabrics display vibrant colors including ruby red, royal blue, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a warm yellow desk lamp visible casting a soft glow from the upper left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03642498329281807 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5364248752593994 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03642498329281807, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03642498329281807, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1297692358493805, + 0.043026700615882874, + 0.06760283559560776, + 0.04609883204102516, + 0.020787518471479416, + 0.5084472298622131, + 0.09103243798017502, + 0.05229460075497627, + 0.012075449340045452, + 0.028865136206150055 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03642498329281807 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a bird's-eye view and held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene a close-up of a rough white clothing design sketch on a dark wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do black charcoal outlines of a woman's fashion lift from the surface and transform into silky, multicolored fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fabrics display vibrant colors including ruby red, royal blue, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a warm yellow desk lamp visible casting a soft glow from the upper left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012551716528832912 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387551784515381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012551716528832912, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012551716528832912, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10019601881504059, + 0.17715968191623688, + 0.11710803210735321, + 0.02225346304476261, + 0.016313616186380386, + 0.48413076996803284, + 0.026195863261818886, + 0.024910978972911835, + 0.016909640282392502, + 0.014821858145296574 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012551716528832912 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a bird's-eye view and held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene a close-up of a rough white clothing design sketch on a dark wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do black charcoal outlines of a woman's fashion lift from the surface and transform into silky, multicolored fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fabrics display vibrant colors including ruby red, royal blue, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a warm yellow desk lamp visible casting a soft glow from the upper left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024909917265176773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002490997314453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024909917265176773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024909917265176773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08609972894191742, + 0.035127490758895874, + 0.0418352410197258, + 0.04514553025364876, + 0.016328711062669754, + 0.6030174493789673, + 0.06562653928995132, + 0.04976309463381767, + 0.02393410913646221, + 0.033122044056653976 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024909917265176773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a bird's-eye view and held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene a close-up of a rough white clothing design sketch on a dark wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do black charcoal outlines of a woman's fashion lift from the surface and transform into silky, multicolored fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fabrics display vibrant colors including ruby red, royal blue, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a warm yellow desk lamp visible casting a soft glow from the upper left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024857595562934875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002485752105713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024857595562934875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024857595562934875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09609425067901611, + 0.14377625286579132, + 0.05932151526212692, + 0.028941884636878967, + 0.049517013132572174, + 0.19687387347221375, + 0.11562453955411911, + 0.08545415848493576, + 0.03921893611550331, + 0.18517765402793884 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024857595562934875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a bird's-eye view and held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene a close-up of a rough white clothing design sketch on a dark wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do black charcoal outlines of a woman's fashion lift from the surface and transform into silky, multicolored fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fabrics display vibrant colors including ruby red, royal blue, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a warm yellow desk lamp visible casting a soft glow from the upper left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016061680391430855 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141061782836914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016061680391430855, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016061680391430855, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23476330935955048, + 0.13540270924568176, + 0.12242481857538223, + 0.038361940532922745, + 0.039550501853227615, + 0.2585286796092987, + 0.05704239383339882, + 0.039206959307193756, + 0.026182834059000015, + 0.04853586480021477 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016061680391430855 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a bird's-eye view, the camera held still. Centered on a rough, white clothing design sketch, spread across a dark wooden workbench, lies a sparsely textured canvas. A warm yellow desk lamp casts a soft glow from the upper left, illuminating the fluid, black charcoal outlines of a woman's fashion. Suddenly, these static black lines begin to tremble slightly, then, as if imbued with life, gracefully lift and peel from the surface in the exquisitely smooth, seamless style of Motion Graphics (MG). They whirl through the air in rhythmic spirals, instantly imbued with vibrant colors like ruby red, royal blue, and emerald green. The original charcoal lines rapidly unwind and expand, miraculously transforming into strands of silky, flowing, multicolored fabric. These fabrics slowly dance and intertwine in the center of the frame, their delicate shimmering patterns captured by the soft light. The scene creates a dreamlike atmosphere of magical creativity and exquisite beauty.", + "seed": 33206, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_13/index_6342_seed_33206_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.020396192884072663, + "vlm_logprob": -0.020396192884072663, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.020396192884072663, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a bird's-eye view and held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene a close-up of a rough white clothing design sketch on a dark wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do black charcoal outlines of a woman's fashion lift from the surface and transform into silky, multicolored fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fabrics display vibrant colors including ruby red, royal blue, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a warm yellow desk lamp visible casting a soft glow from the upper left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03651026636362076 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.9115102291107178 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03651026636362076, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03651026636362076, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5277563333511353, + 0.0749860405921936, + 0.05299968644976616, + 0.029110947623848915, + 0.020495248958468437, + 0.08288520574569702, + 0.076115183532238, + 0.06771737337112427, + 0.0354248508810997, + 0.03250914439558983 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03651026636362076 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a bird's-eye view and held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene a close-up of a rough white clothing design sketch on a dark wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do black charcoal outlines of a woman's fashion lift from the surface and transform into silky, multicolored fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fabrics display vibrant colors including ruby red, royal blue, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a warm yellow desk lamp visible casting a soft glow from the upper left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01821516454219818 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018215179443359 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01821516454219818, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01821516454219818, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.477970689535141, + 0.12679211795330048, + 0.09957379847764969, + 0.06039443612098694, + 0.06266997009515762, + 0.029249632731080055, + 0.053522177040576935, + 0.03941607475280762, + 0.036425381898880005, + 0.013985739089548588 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01821516454219818 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a bird's-eye view and held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene a close-up of a rough white clothing design sketch on a dark wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do black charcoal outlines of a woman's fashion lift from the surface and transform into silky, multicolored fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fabrics display vibrant colors including ruby red, royal blue, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a warm yellow desk lamp visible casting a soft glow from the upper left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002494083484634757 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002493858337402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002494083484634757, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002494083484634757, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23028260469436646, + 0.09157617390155792, + 0.06309525668621063, + 0.04054909944534302, + 0.10808008164167404, + 0.056502290070056915, + 0.19655491411685944, + 0.12168464064598083, + 0.06776012480258942, + 0.023914717137813568 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002494083484634757 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a bird's-eye view and held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene a close-up of a rough white clothing design sketch on a dark wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do black charcoal outlines of a woman's fashion lift from the surface and transform into silky, multicolored fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fabrics display vibrant colors including ruby red, royal blue, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a warm yellow desk lamp visible casting a soft glow from the upper left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011070379056036472 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511070251464844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011070379056036472, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011070379056036472, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11225435882806778, + 0.08165457099676132, + 0.10687735676765442, + 0.12834201753139496, + 0.20393499732017517, + 0.07932744920253754, + 0.12753434479236603, + 0.08701494336128235, + 0.02368469350039959, + 0.04937530681490898 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011070379056036472 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a bird's-eye view and held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene a close-up of a rough white clothing design sketch on a dark wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do black charcoal outlines of a woman's fashion lift from the surface and transform into silky, multicolored fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fabrics display vibrant colors including ruby red, royal blue, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a warm yellow desk lamp visible casting a soft glow from the upper left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369107097387314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408691167831421 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369107097387314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369107097387314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3208858370780945, + 0.22968803346157074, + 0.08975744992494583, + 0.06216661259531975, + 0.11024358123540878, + 0.04087948799133301, + 0.07595063000917435, + 0.022926494479179382, + 0.02256217785179615, + 0.0249396450817585 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369107097387314 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a bird's-eye view, the camera held still. Centered on a rough, white clothing design sketch, spread across a dark wooden workbench, lies a sparsely textured canvas. A warm yellow desk lamp casts a soft glow from the upper left, illuminating the fluid, black charcoal outlines of a woman's fashion. Suddenly, these static black lines begin to tremble slightly, then, as if imbued with life, gracefully lift and peel from the surface in the exquisitely smooth, seamless style of Motion Graphics (MG). They whirl through the air in rhythmic spirals, instantly imbued with vibrant colors like ruby red, royal blue, and emerald green. The original charcoal lines rapidly unwind and expand, miraculously transforming into strands of silky, flowing, multicolored fabric. These fabrics slowly dance and intertwine in the center of the frame, their delicate shimmering patterns captured by the soft light. The scene creates a dreamlike atmosphere of magical creativity and exquisite beauty.", + "seed": 33207, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_13/index_6342_seed_33207_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.019547614315524698, + "vlm_logprob": -0.019547614315524698, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.019547614315524698, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a bird's-eye view and held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene a close-up of a rough white clothing design sketch on a dark wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do black charcoal outlines of a woman's fashion lift from the surface and transform into silky, multicolored fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fabrics display vibrant colors including ruby red, royal blue, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a warm yellow desk lamp visible casting a soft glow from the upper left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03726315498352051 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6622631549835205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03726315498352051, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03726315498352051, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09211316704750061, + 0.07317907363176346, + 0.033037569373846054, + 0.02459201216697693, + 0.04929272457957268, + 0.04387912526726723, + 0.27949008345603943, + 0.10077212750911713, + 0.025181012228131294, + 0.27846309542655945 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03726315498352051 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a bird's-eye view and held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene a close-up of a rough white clothing design sketch on a dark wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do black charcoal outlines of a woman's fashion lift from the surface and transform into silky, multicolored fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fabrics display vibrant colors including ruby red, royal blue, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a warm yellow desk lamp visible casting a soft glow from the upper left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012559369206428528 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387559413909912 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012559369206428528, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012559369206428528, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14469994604587555, + 0.1927826851606369, + 0.09890099614858627, + 0.05258920043706894, + 0.053621262311935425, + 0.08754940330982208, + 0.11426887661218643, + 0.17849043011665344, + 0.03271592780947685, + 0.04438130557537079 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012559369206428528 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a bird's-eye view and held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene a close-up of a rough white clothing design sketch on a dark wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do black charcoal outlines of a woman's fashion lift from the surface and transform into silky, multicolored fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fabrics display vibrant colors including ruby red, royal blue, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a warm yellow desk lamp visible casting a soft glow from the upper left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002203538315370679 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127203464508057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002203538315370679, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002203538315370679, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09786681085824966, + 0.09939584881067276, + 0.0349230021238327, + 0.03270355984568596, + 0.09680040925741196, + 0.13967302441596985, + 0.3722676634788513, + 0.05942605063319206, + 0.023097680881619453, + 0.04384595900774002 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002203538315370679 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a bird's-eye view and held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene a close-up of a rough white clothing design sketch on a dark wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do black charcoal outlines of a woman's fashion lift from the surface and transform into silky, multicolored fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fabrics display vibrant colors including ruby red, royal blue, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a warm yellow desk lamp visible casting a soft glow from the upper left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007624808698892593 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882624626159668 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007624808698892593, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007624808698892593, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04212845861911774, + 0.04627431929111481, + 0.02320626564323902, + 0.017177606001496315, + 0.044663265347480774, + 0.13331995904445648, + 0.5501810908317566, + 0.04067406803369522, + 0.050991952419281006, + 0.051383111625909805 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007624808698892593 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a bird's-eye view and held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene a close-up of a rough white clothing design sketch on a dark wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do black charcoal outlines of a woman's fashion lift from the surface and transform into silky, multicolored fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fabrics display vibrant colors including ruby red, royal blue, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a warm yellow desk lamp visible casting a soft glow from the upper left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03808720037341118 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880871295928955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03808720037341118, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03808720037341118, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2061731517314911, + 0.1746387630701065, + 0.041034355759620667, + 0.020808985456824303, + 0.06359528750181198, + 0.07006203383207321, + 0.30209478735923767, + 0.05593303218483925, + 0.028271254152059555, + 0.037388335913419724 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03808720037341118 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a bird's-eye view, the camera held still. Centered on a rough, white clothing design sketch, spread across a dark wooden workbench, lies a sparsely textured canvas. A warm yellow desk lamp casts a soft glow from the upper left, illuminating the fluid, black charcoal outlines of a woman's fashion. Suddenly, these static black lines begin to tremble slightly, then, as if imbued with life, gracefully lift and peel from the surface in the exquisitely smooth, seamless style of Motion Graphics (MG). They whirl through the air in rhythmic spirals, instantly imbued with vibrant colors like ruby red, royal blue, and emerald green. The original charcoal lines rapidly unwind and expand, miraculously transforming into strands of silky, flowing, multicolored fabric. These fabrics slowly dance and intertwine in the center of the frame, their delicate shimmering patterns captured by the soft light. The scene creates a dreamlike atmosphere of magical creativity and exquisite beauty.", + "seed": 33208, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_13/index_6342_seed_33208_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.028377836872823536, + "vlm_logprob": -0.028377836872823536, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.028377836872823536, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a bird's-eye view and held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene a close-up of a rough white clothing design sketch on a dark wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do black charcoal outlines of a woman's fashion lift from the surface and transform into silky, multicolored fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fabrics display vibrant colors including ruby red, royal blue, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a warm yellow desk lamp visible casting a soft glow from the upper left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04222036153078079 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4172203540802 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04222036153078079, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04222036153078079, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23144707083702087, + 0.10054679960012436, + 0.10071133822202682, + 0.08518235385417938, + 0.08591476082801819, + 0.1233510971069336, + 0.07009650021791458, + 0.11595175415277481, + 0.05419919639825821, + 0.03259914368391037 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04222036153078079 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a bird's-eye view and held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene a close-up of a rough white clothing design sketch on a dark wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do black charcoal outlines of a woman's fashion lift from the surface and transform into silky, multicolored fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fabrics display vibrant colors including ruby red, royal blue, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a warm yellow desk lamp visible casting a soft glow from the upper left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08905810862779617 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640581607818604 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08905810862779617, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08905810862779617, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40923184156417847, + 0.03769254684448242, + 0.034891530871391296, + 0.048075005412101746, + 0.040857743471860886, + 0.04556911438703537, + 0.09249795973300934, + 0.05794905498623848, + 0.20648039877414703, + 0.02675478346645832 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08905810862779617 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a bird's-eye view and held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene a close-up of a rough white clothing design sketch on a dark wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do black charcoal outlines of a woman's fashion lift from the surface and transform into silky, multicolored fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fabrics display vibrant colors including ruby red, royal blue, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a warm yellow desk lamp visible casting a soft glow from the upper left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010459910845384002 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876046180725098 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010459910845384002, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010459910845384002, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3084160089492798, + 0.06205745041370392, + 0.05579131469130516, + 0.06552223116159439, + 0.19055841863155365, + 0.07687674462795258, + 0.08173692226409912, + 0.05447763204574585, + 0.07491332292556763, + 0.029649987816810608 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010459910845384002 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a bird's-eye view and held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene a close-up of a rough white clothing design sketch on a dark wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do black charcoal outlines of a woman's fashion lift from the surface and transform into silky, multicolored fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fabrics display vibrant colors including ruby red, royal blue, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a warm yellow desk lamp visible casting a soft glow from the upper left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019394413102418184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251939296722412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019394413102418184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019394413102418184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07624822109937668, + 0.05530496686697006, + 0.055201344192028046, + 0.0605907179415226, + 0.3808037340641022, + 0.09180840104818344, + 0.05353155359625816, + 0.1256696581840515, + 0.05756271257996559, + 0.043278686702251434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019394413102418184 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a bird's-eye view and held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the initial scene a close-up of a rough white clothing design sketch on a dark wooden workbench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do black charcoal outlines of a woman's fashion lift from the surface and transform into silky, multicolored fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fabrics display vibrant colors including ruby red, royal blue, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a warm yellow desk lamp visible casting a soft glow from the upper left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007625281810760498 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882625102996826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007625281810760498, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007625281810760498, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18192292749881744, + 0.058711908757686615, + 0.049781814217567444, + 0.0372636578977108, + 0.19022022187709808, + 0.04223804920911789, + 0.10827043652534485, + 0.11453273147344589, + 0.1907574087381363, + 0.02630084566771984 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007625281810760498 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_14/index_tensor([5038, 5038])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_14/index_tensor([5038, 5038])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..357d6df6ede9ee8719388d18a5344db367ead732 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_14/index_tensor([5038, 5038])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "At dusk, a breathtaking high-angle, extreme-wide shot slowly sweeps across a sprawling city skyline. Positioned as if from a silently hovering drone, the camera captures an architectural canyon formed by towering skyscrapers composed of reflective glass, dark steel, and monolithic concrete. Below, a mesmerizing river of light meanders through the city's deep valleys; a hyper-lensed view of traffic, with individual vehicles blurred into continuous, flowing streaks of light. Brilliant golden-white headlight trails and crimson taillight streaks intertwine, depicting the complex curves of multi-layered highways and broad avenues. The last remnants of sunlight paint the horizon in a gradient of fiery red and soft fuchsia, transitioning to deep blue at its peak. This fading natural light contrasts sharply with the vibrant electric lights emanating from the city below, causing the glass facades of the buildings to shimmer with distorted reflections from the moving light trails. The scene, devoid of any specific text or logos, focuses solely on its imposing scale and kinetic energy, creating a powerful and majestic atmosphere, depicting the city as a living, breathing organism whose lifeblood is light.", + "seed": 17411, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_14/index_5038_seed_17411_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.049619076773524284, + "vlm_logprob": -0.049619076773524284, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.049619076773524284, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with a horizon showing a gradient of fiery red and soft fuchsia transitioning to deep blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers composed of reflective glass, dark steel, and monolithic concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a river of light formed by blurred vehicle streaks (golden-white headlights and crimson taillights) flowing through the city valleys?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the glass facades of the buildings show shimmering distorted reflections from the moving light trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle, extreme-wide view that slowly sweeps across the skyline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005885769613087177 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255885601043701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005885769613087177, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005885769613087177, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11095423996448517, + 0.11388503015041351, + 0.33352261781692505, + 0.058486923575401306, + 0.05104268342256546, + 0.0543682724237442, + 0.13231836259365082, + 0.05877986550331116, + 0.04076822102069855, + 0.04587377607822418 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005885769613087177 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with a horizon showing a gradient of fiery red and soft fuchsia transitioning to deep blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers composed of reflective glass, dark steel, and monolithic concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a river of light formed by blurred vehicle streaks (golden-white headlights and crimson taillights) flowing through the city valleys?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the glass facades of the buildings show shimmering distorted reflections from the moving light trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle, extreme-wide view that slowly sweeps across the skyline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1604582667350769 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104583263397217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1604582667350769, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1604582667350769, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10573998838663101, + 0.0812280923128128, + 0.2120853215456009, + 0.2586449086666107, + 0.09403267502784729, + 0.027067020535469055, + 0.019368475303053856, + 0.11242378503084183, + 0.04017481207847595, + 0.04923497512936592 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1604582667350769 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with a horizon showing a gradient of fiery red and soft fuchsia transitioning to deep blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers composed of reflective glass, dark steel, and monolithic concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a river of light formed by blurred vehicle streaks (golden-white headlights and crimson taillights) flowing through the city valleys?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the glass facades of the buildings show shimmering distorted reflections from the moving light trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle, extreme-wide view that slowly sweeps across the skyline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015150746330618858 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501514911651611 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015150746330618858, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015150746330618858, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13014450669288635, + 0.27758166193962097, + 0.05686646327376366, + 0.19567804038524628, + 0.047815803438425064, + 0.052940305322408676, + 0.058855462819337845, + 0.048158399760723114, + 0.09689334779977798, + 0.03506599739193916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015150746330618858 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with a horizon showing a gradient of fiery red and soft fuchsia transitioning to deep blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers composed of reflective glass, dark steel, and monolithic concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a river of light formed by blurred vehicle streaks (golden-white headlights and crimson taillights) flowing through the city valleys?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the glass facades of the buildings show shimmering distorted reflections from the moving light trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle, extreme-wide view that slowly sweeps across the skyline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062059152871370316 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812059164047241 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062059152871370316, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062059152871370316, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19090743362903595, + 0.11731322854757309, + 0.1403569132089615, + 0.15162354707717896, + 0.046147722750902176, + 0.05834101140499115, + 0.04920468106865883, + 0.054524172097444534, + 0.12025698274374008, + 0.07132423669099808 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062059152871370316 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with a horizon showing a gradient of fiery red and soft fuchsia transitioning to deep blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers composed of reflective glass, dark steel, and monolithic concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a river of light formed by blurred vehicle streaks (golden-white headlights and crimson taillights) flowing through the city valleys?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the glass facades of the buildings show shimmering distorted reflections from the moving light trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle, extreme-wide view that slowly sweeps across the skyline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01817712001502514 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018177032470703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01817712001502514, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01817712001502514, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08288197219371796, + 0.07485595345497131, + 0.14531093835830688, + 0.040331657975912094, + 0.06857962906360626, + 0.04748537391424179, + 0.22815494239330292, + 0.10440506786108017, + 0.15942919254302979, + 0.04856522008776665 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01817712001502514 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "At dusk, a breathtaking high-angle, extreme-wide shot slowly sweeps across a sprawling city skyline. Positioned as if from a silently hovering drone, the camera captures an architectural canyon formed by towering skyscrapers composed of reflective glass, dark steel, and monolithic concrete. Below, a mesmerizing river of light meanders through the city's deep valleys; a hyper-lensed view of traffic, with individual vehicles blurred into continuous, flowing streaks of light. Brilliant golden-white headlight trails and crimson taillight streaks intertwine, depicting the complex curves of multi-layered highways and broad avenues. The last remnants of sunlight paint the horizon in a gradient of fiery red and soft fuchsia, transitioning to deep blue at its peak. This fading natural light contrasts sharply with the vibrant electric lights emanating from the city below, causing the glass facades of the buildings to shimmer with distorted reflections from the moving light trails. The scene, devoid of any specific text or logos, focuses solely on its imposing scale and kinetic energy, creating a powerful and majestic atmosphere, depicting the city as a living, breathing organism whose lifeblood is light.", + "seed": 17412, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_14/index_5038_seed_17412_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.025122308637946844, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025122308637946844, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025122308637946844, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with a horizon showing a gradient of fiery red and soft fuchsia transitioning to deep blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers composed of reflective glass, dark steel, and monolithic concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a river of light formed by blurred vehicle streaks (golden-white headlights and crimson taillights) flowing through the city valleys?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the glass facades of the buildings show shimmering distorted reflections from the moving light trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle, extreme-wide view that slowly sweeps across the skyline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00801135040819645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.883011341094971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00801135040819645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00801135040819645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21680544316768646, + 0.2449779361486435, + 0.10191240161657333, + 0.042236924171447754, + 0.15946929156780243, + 0.0589531734585762, + 0.06813178211450577, + 0.05517173931002617, + 0.017793171107769012, + 0.03454810753464699 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00801135040819645 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with a horizon showing a gradient of fiery red and soft fuchsia transitioning to deep blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers composed of reflective glass, dark steel, and monolithic concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a river of light formed by blurred vehicle streaks (golden-white headlights and crimson taillights) flowing through the city valleys?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the glass facades of the buildings show shimmering distorted reflections from the moving light trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle, extreme-wide view that slowly sweeps across the skyline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05498690530657768 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299869537353516 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05498690530657768, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05498690530657768, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15168225765228271, + 0.14509513974189758, + 0.06539945304393768, + 0.07308510690927505, + 0.05842339247465134, + 0.2860885560512543, + 0.050789859145879745, + 0.04933417961001396, + 0.043541692197322845, + 0.07656040787696838 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05498690530657768 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with a horizon showing a gradient of fiery red and soft fuchsia transitioning to deep blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers composed of reflective glass, dark steel, and monolithic concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a river of light formed by blurred vehicle streaks (golden-white headlights and crimson taillights) flowing through the city valleys?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the glass facades of the buildings show shimmering distorted reflections from the moving light trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle, extreme-wide view that slowly sweeps across the skyline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001713952049612999 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376713752746582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001713952049612999, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001713952049612999, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5530851483345032, + 0.05728689581155777, + 0.024743931367993355, + 0.03486689180135727, + 0.05825437977910042, + 0.09265691787004471, + 0.05102437734603882, + 0.0550919771194458, + 0.0229466762393713, + 0.05004280060529709 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001713952049612999 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with a horizon showing a gradient of fiery red and soft fuchsia transitioning to deep blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers composed of reflective glass, dark steel, and monolithic concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a river of light formed by blurred vehicle streaks (golden-white headlights and crimson taillights) flowing through the city valleys?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the glass facades of the buildings show shimmering distorted reflections from the moving light trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle, extreme-wide view that slowly sweeps across the skyline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495869740843773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299585819244385 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495869740843773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495869740843773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07876403629779816, + 0.10023952275514603, + 0.06073381006717682, + 0.050069939345121384, + 0.05457612872123718, + 0.3777143359184265, + 0.10920466482639313, + 0.10056813061237335, + 0.028507418930530548, + 0.03962206095457077 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495869740843773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with a horizon showing a gradient of fiery red and soft fuchsia transitioning to deep blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers composed of reflective glass, dark steel, and monolithic concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a river of light formed by blurred vehicle streaks (golden-white headlights and crimson taillights) flowing through the city valleys?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the glass facades of the buildings show shimmering distorted reflections from the moving light trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle, extreme-wide view that slowly sweeps across the skyline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005940638016909361 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309404373168945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005940638016909361, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005940638016909361, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3264056444168091, + 0.017731960862874985, + 0.03784187510609627, + 0.030701814219355583, + 0.05433954298496246, + 0.3492929935455322, + 0.07095050066709518, + 0.05461976304650307, + 0.04715514928102493, + 0.010960826650261879 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005940638016909361 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "At dusk, a breathtaking high-angle, extreme-wide shot slowly sweeps across a sprawling city skyline. Positioned as if from a silently hovering drone, the camera captures an architectural canyon formed by towering skyscrapers composed of reflective glass, dark steel, and monolithic concrete. Below, a mesmerizing river of light meanders through the city's deep valleys; a hyper-lensed view of traffic, with individual vehicles blurred into continuous, flowing streaks of light. Brilliant golden-white headlight trails and crimson taillight streaks intertwine, depicting the complex curves of multi-layered highways and broad avenues. The last remnants of sunlight paint the horizon in a gradient of fiery red and soft fuchsia, transitioning to deep blue at its peak. This fading natural light contrasts sharply with the vibrant electric lights emanating from the city below, causing the glass facades of the buildings to shimmer with distorted reflections from the moving light trails. The scene, devoid of any specific text or logos, focuses solely on its imposing scale and kinetic energy, creating a powerful and majestic atmosphere, depicting the city as a living, breathing organism whose lifeblood is light.", + "seed": 17413, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_14/index_5038_seed_17413_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.12016736874356866, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12016736874356866, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12016736874356866, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with a horizon showing a gradient of fiery red and soft fuchsia transitioning to deep blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers composed of reflective glass, dark steel, and monolithic concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a river of light formed by blurred vehicle streaks (golden-white headlights and crimson taillights) flowing through the city valleys?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the glass facades of the buildings show shimmering distorted reflections from the moving light trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle, extreme-wide view that slowly sweeps across the skyline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005136745050549507 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.505136966705322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005136745050549507, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005136745050549507, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19786585867404938, + 0.1212005689740181, + 0.06435595452785492, + 0.02142493799328804, + 0.030874326825141907, + 0.42692169547080994, + 0.023220716044306755, + 0.03718137368559837, + 0.024330448359251022, + 0.052624162286520004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005136745050549507 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with a horizon showing a gradient of fiery red and soft fuchsia transitioning to deep blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers composed of reflective glass, dark steel, and monolithic concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a river of light formed by blurred vehicle streaks (golden-white headlights and crimson taillights) flowing through the city valleys?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the glass facades of the buildings show shimmering distorted reflections from the moving light trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle, extreme-wide view that slowly sweeps across the skyline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2522542178630829 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5022542476654053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2522542178630829, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2522542178630829, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24288302659988403, + 0.06028229743242264, + 0.031784866005182266, + 0.023812569677829742, + 0.013467310927808285, + 0.4872082769870758, + 0.026838744059205055, + 0.03361811488866806, + 0.027722777798771858, + 0.05238203704357147 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2522542178630829 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with a horizon showing a gradient of fiery red and soft fuchsia transitioning to deep blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers composed of reflective glass, dark steel, and monolithic concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a river of light formed by blurred vehicle streaks (golden-white headlights and crimson taillights) flowing through the city valleys?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the glass facades of the buildings show shimmering distorted reflections from the moving light trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle, extreme-wide view that slowly sweeps across the skyline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036183618940413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628618240356445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036183618940413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036183618940413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4029528498649597, + 0.0678819864988327, + 0.054277945309877396, + 0.03085608407855034, + 0.026932494714856148, + 0.054617103189229965, + 0.089166559278965, + 0.05733352527022362, + 0.06074625253677368, + 0.1552352011203766 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036183618940413 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with a horizon showing a gradient of fiery red and soft fuchsia transitioning to deep blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers composed of reflective glass, dark steel, and monolithic concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a river of light formed by blurred vehicle streaks (golden-white headlights and crimson taillights) flowing through the city valleys?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the glass facades of the buildings show shimmering distorted reflections from the moving light trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle, extreme-wide view that slowly sweeps across the skyline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134910762310028 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134911060333252 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134910762310028, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134910762310028, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06747952848672867, + 0.09695442765951157, + 0.02552690915763378, + 0.030715759843587875, + 0.06685413420200348, + 0.4223209321498871, + 0.07774747163057327, + 0.028747892007231712, + 0.026558080688118935, + 0.15709491074085236 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134910762310028 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with a horizon showing a gradient of fiery red and soft fuchsia transitioning to deep blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers composed of reflective glass, dark steel, and monolithic concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a river of light formed by blurred vehicle streaks (golden-white headlights and crimson taillights) flowing through the city valleys?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the glass facades of the buildings show shimmering distorted reflections from the moving light trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle, extreme-wide view that slowly sweeps across the skyline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026336442679166794 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651336431503296 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026336442679166794, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026336442679166794, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21689793467521667, + 0.05484592542052269, + 0.042658183723688126, + 0.05645272508263588, + 0.030732404440641403, + 0.20095974206924438, + 0.07422203570604324, + 0.1473279446363449, + 0.04319779947400093, + 0.1327052265405655 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026336442679166794 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "At dusk, a breathtaking high-angle, extreme-wide shot slowly sweeps across a sprawling city skyline. Positioned as if from a silently hovering drone, the camera captures an architectural canyon formed by towering skyscrapers composed of reflective glass, dark steel, and monolithic concrete. Below, a mesmerizing river of light meanders through the city's deep valleys; a hyper-lensed view of traffic, with individual vehicles blurred into continuous, flowing streaks of light. Brilliant golden-white headlight trails and crimson taillight streaks intertwine, depicting the complex curves of multi-layered highways and broad avenues. The last remnants of sunlight paint the horizon in a gradient of fiery red and soft fuchsia, transitioning to deep blue at its peak. This fading natural light contrasts sharply with the vibrant electric lights emanating from the city below, causing the glass facades of the buildings to shimmer with distorted reflections from the moving light trails. The scene, devoid of any specific text or logos, focuses solely on its imposing scale and kinetic energy, creating a powerful and majestic atmosphere, depicting the city as a living, breathing organism whose lifeblood is light.", + "seed": 17414, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_14/index_5038_seed_17414_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06470822296105325, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06470822296105325, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06470822296105325, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with a horizon showing a gradient of fiery red and soft fuchsia transitioning to deep blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers composed of reflective glass, dark steel, and monolithic concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a river of light formed by blurred vehicle streaks (golden-white headlights and crimson taillights) flowing through the city valleys?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the glass facades of the buildings show shimmering distorted reflections from the moving light trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle, extreme-wide view that slowly sweeps across the skyline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01188801322132349 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511888027191162 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01188801322132349, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01188801322132349, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25199320912361145, + 0.11220260709524155, + 0.11527185142040253, + 0.0638100877404213, + 0.07651789486408234, + 0.0569453127682209, + 0.16339711844921112, + 0.06814033538103104, + 0.020411543548107147, + 0.07131002098321915 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01188801322132349 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with a horizon showing a gradient of fiery red and soft fuchsia transitioning to deep blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers composed of reflective glass, dark steel, and monolithic concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a river of light formed by blurred vehicle streaks (golden-white headlights and crimson taillights) flowing through the city valleys?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the glass facades of the buildings show shimmering distorted reflections from the moving light trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle, extreme-wide view that slowly sweeps across the skyline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10040585696697235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3504059314727783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10040585696697235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10040585696697235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4328073263168335, + 0.04694429785013199, + 0.04345802590250969, + 0.060987625271081924, + 0.14103160798549652, + 0.038790263235569, + 0.0809742882847786, + 0.06358994543552399, + 0.0379362478852272, + 0.053480375558137894 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10040585696697235 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with a horizon showing a gradient of fiery red and soft fuchsia transitioning to deep blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers composed of reflective glass, dark steel, and monolithic concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a river of light formed by blurred vehicle streaks (golden-white headlights and crimson taillights) flowing through the city valleys?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the glass facades of the buildings show shimmering distorted reflections from the moving light trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle, extreme-wide view that slowly sweeps across the skyline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002200802555307746 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127200603485107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002200802555307746, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002200802555307746, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2698226571083069, + 0.03781109303236008, + 0.055600885301828384, + 0.19223091006278992, + 0.04712230712175369, + 0.061800744384527206, + 0.18037207424640656, + 0.05521966516971588, + 0.052596986293792725, + 0.04742269217967987 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002200802555307746 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with a horizon showing a gradient of fiery red and soft fuchsia transitioning to deep blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers composed of reflective glass, dark steel, and monolithic concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a river of light formed by blurred vehicle streaks (golden-white headlights and crimson taillights) flowing through the city valleys?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the glass facades of the buildings show shimmering distorted reflections from the moving light trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle, extreme-wide view that slowly sweeps across the skyline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16040699183940887 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104069471359253 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16040699183940887, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16040699183940887, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11307121068239212, + 0.03190123289823532, + 0.15006527304649353, + 0.057947009801864624, + 0.061318911612033844, + 0.04931778833270073, + 0.31577321887016296, + 0.06081853434443474, + 0.07558929175138474, + 0.0841975212097168 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16040699183940887 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dusk with a horizon showing a gradient of fiery red and soft fuchsia transitioning to deep blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers composed of reflective glass, dark steel, and monolithic concrete?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a river of light formed by blurred vehicle streaks (golden-white headlights and crimson taillights) flowing through the city valleys?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the glass facades of the buildings show shimmering distorted reflections from the moving light trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle, extreme-wide view that slowly sweeps across the skyline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0486394502222538 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486395359039307 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0486394502222538, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0486394502222538, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2778896689414978, + 0.04160945490002632, + 0.02818289026618004, + 0.10896964371204376, + 0.10935923457145691, + 0.10740446299314499, + 0.14764533936977386, + 0.11373695731163025, + 0.016177991405129433, + 0.04902438819408417 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0486394502222538 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_15/index_tensor([5634, 5634])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_15/index_tensor([5634, 5634])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4223d4eb1f4ec289e5a63d16075b0e0c621f9065 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_15/index_tensor([5634, 5634])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slight overhead angle, the camera held still, the viewer's gaze fixed on a pair of weathered yet remarkably steady hands. The elderly stonemason, dressed in a simple, dark blue linen jacket, sleeves rolled high, revealing sturdy forearms stained with white stone dust, leans over the gray railing of an ancient stone bridge. Soft, diffused morning light filters through the mist, illuminating his focused face and the work in his hands: his left hand grips a steel chisel, gleaming with a cold glow, pressing precisely against the stone face. In his right, he holds a heavy wooden mallet, carefully striking the handle with a steady, deliberate rhythm. Each blow is accompanied by a crisp, dull sound, and a small cloud of fine stone chips and dust bursts from the chisel tip, drifting down and leaving a fleeting trail in the air. Under his skillful hands, the originally flat surface of the stone is gradually revealing the outline of complex and smooth auspicious cloud patterns. The whole picture is full of the tranquil and focused spirit of craftsmanship, creating a quiet atmosphere as if time has stood still.", + "seed": 4595, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_15/index_5634_seed_4595_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04539177790284157, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04539177790284157, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04539177790284157, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slight overhead angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly stonemason wearing a dark blue linen jacket with sleeves rolled up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stonemason's forearms visible and stained with white stone dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stonemason holding a steel chisel in his left hand and a wooden mallet in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the gray railing of an ancient stone bridge with soft, diffused morning light and mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023627862334251404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.398627758026123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023627862334251404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023627862334251404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14536088705062866, + 0.05917220562696457, + 0.09354594349861145, + 0.08770877867937088, + 0.09488075971603394, + 0.042853549122810364, + 0.11486078798770905, + 0.09288724511861801, + 0.21889348328113556, + 0.04983639344573021 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023627862334251404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slight overhead angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly stonemason wearing a dark blue linen jacket with sleeves rolled up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stonemason's forearms visible and stained with white stone dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stonemason holding a steel chisel in his left hand and a wooden mallet in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the gray railing of an ancient stone bridge with soft, diffused morning light and mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05503632500767708 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300363063812256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05503632500767708, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05503632500767708, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18719510734081268, + 0.08753398805856705, + 0.06903266906738281, + 0.11710929125547409, + 0.253447026014328, + 0.03852225840091705, + 0.03938892483711243, + 0.12133839726448059, + 0.038934126496315, + 0.0474981851875782 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05503632500767708 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slight overhead angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly stonemason wearing a dark blue linen jacket with sleeves rolled up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stonemason's forearms visible and stained with white stone dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stonemason holding a steel chisel in his left hand and a wooden mallet in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the gray railing of an ancient stone bridge with soft, diffused morning light and mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020591415464878082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955914974212646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020591415464878082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020591415464878082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16964897513389587, + 0.09592389315366745, + 0.12425180524587631, + 0.18782173097133636, + 0.11893526464700699, + 0.07294513285160065, + 0.023176416754722595, + 0.12233540415763855, + 0.04200347512960434, + 0.042957838624715805 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020591415464878082 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slight overhead angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly stonemason wearing a dark blue linen jacket with sleeves rolled up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stonemason's forearms visible and stained with white stone dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stonemason holding a steel chisel in his left hand and a wooden mallet in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the gray railing of an ancient stone bridge with soft, diffused morning light and mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900343090295792 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.57900333404541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900343090295792, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900343090295792, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.178201824426651, + 0.12868723273277283, + 0.10088516026735306, + 0.06838823109865189, + 0.19018857181072235, + 0.05200058966875076, + 0.06933145225048065, + 0.07288305461406708, + 0.05613832548260689, + 0.083295539021492 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900343090295792 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slight overhead angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly stonemason wearing a dark blue linen jacket with sleeves rolled up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stonemason's forearms visible and stained with white stone dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stonemason holding a steel chisel in his left hand and a wooden mallet in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the gray railing of an ancient stone bridge with soft, diffused morning light and mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04869985580444336 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486998558044434 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04869985580444336, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04869985580444336, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2755472660064697, + 0.07336801290512085, + 0.2002013474702835, + 0.10228968411684036, + 0.10576838999986649, + 0.019919129088521004, + 0.1128140464425087, + 0.04260142147541046, + 0.047000426799058914, + 0.020490271970629692 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04869985580444336 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slight overhead angle, the camera held still, the viewer's gaze fixed on a pair of weathered yet remarkably steady hands. The elderly stonemason, dressed in a simple, dark blue linen jacket, sleeves rolled high, revealing sturdy forearms stained with white stone dust, leans over the gray railing of an ancient stone bridge. Soft, diffused morning light filters through the mist, illuminating his focused face and the work in his hands: his left hand grips a steel chisel, gleaming with a cold glow, pressing precisely against the stone face. In his right, he holds a heavy wooden mallet, carefully striking the handle with a steady, deliberate rhythm. Each blow is accompanied by a crisp, dull sound, and a small cloud of fine stone chips and dust bursts from the chisel tip, drifting down and leaving a fleeting trail in the air. Under his skillful hands, the originally flat surface of the stone is gradually revealing the outline of complex and smooth auspicious cloud patterns. The whole picture is full of the tranquil and focused spirit of craftsmanship, creating a quiet atmosphere as if time has stood still.", + "seed": 4596, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_15/index_5634_seed_4596_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03602165468037129, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03602165468037129, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03602165468037129, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slight overhead angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly stonemason wearing a dark blue linen jacket with sleeves rolled up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stonemason's forearms visible and stained with white stone dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stonemason holding a steel chisel in his left hand and a wooden mallet in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the gray railing of an ancient stone bridge with soft, diffused morning light and mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0250488743185997 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.400048732757568 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0250488743185997, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0250488743185997, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20761777460575104, + 0.10640620440244675, + 0.0771436095237732, + 0.03963446617126465, + 0.03235829994082451, + 0.06879257410764694, + 0.1580851674079895, + 0.08713376522064209, + 0.14167603850364685, + 0.08115212619304657 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0250488743185997 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slight overhead angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly stonemason wearing a dark blue linen jacket with sleeves rolled up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stonemason's forearms visible and stained with white stone dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stonemason holding a steel chisel in his left hand and a wooden mallet in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the gray railing of an ancient stone bridge with soft, diffused morning light and mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029821116477251053 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298211574554443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029821116477251053, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029821116477251053, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1273774653673172, + 0.06119469925761223, + 0.07090561091899872, + 0.07181812822818756, + 0.052397001534700394, + 0.11689352244138718, + 0.044111475348472595, + 0.15280066430568695, + 0.2601014971733093, + 0.04239986464381218 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029821116477251053 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slight overhead angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly stonemason wearing a dark blue linen jacket with sleeves rolled up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stonemason's forearms visible and stained with white stone dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stonemason holding a steel chisel in his left hand and a wooden mallet in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the gray railing of an ancient stone bridge with soft, diffused morning light and mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012546537443995476 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387546539306641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012546537443995476, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012546537443995476, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14909638464450836, + 0.07387964427471161, + 0.07888098061084747, + 0.07911812514066696, + 0.1934039145708084, + 0.043516241014003754, + 0.07982487231492996, + 0.08072652667760849, + 0.0663338154554367, + 0.15521951019763947 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012546537443995476 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slight overhead angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly stonemason wearing a dark blue linen jacket with sleeves rolled up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stonemason's forearms visible and stained with white stone dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stonemason holding a steel chisel in his left hand and a wooden mallet in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the gray railing of an ancient stone bridge with soft, diffused morning light and mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0789932981133461 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578993320465088 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0789932981133461, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0789932981133461, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31852322816848755, + 0.07789099216461182, + 0.04222602769732475, + 0.03912116587162018, + 0.04309040307998657, + 0.07489174604415894, + 0.06574568897485733, + 0.12034749984741211, + 0.04344414174556732, + 0.17471911013126373 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0789932981133461 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slight overhead angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly stonemason wearing a dark blue linen jacket with sleeves rolled up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stonemason's forearms visible and stained with white stone dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stonemason holding a steel chisel in his left hand and a wooden mallet in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the gray railing of an ancient stone bridge with soft, diffused morning light and mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369844704866409 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408698558807373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369844704866409, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369844704866409, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.39091140031814575, + 0.07985882461071014, + 0.04209818318486214, + 0.0399920828640461, + 0.03965429961681366, + 0.0726587325334549, + 0.0607847198843956, + 0.09303110092878342, + 0.12442533671855927, + 0.05658530071377754 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369844704866409 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slight overhead angle, the camera held still, the viewer's gaze fixed on a pair of weathered yet remarkably steady hands. The elderly stonemason, dressed in a simple, dark blue linen jacket, sleeves rolled high, revealing sturdy forearms stained with white stone dust, leans over the gray railing of an ancient stone bridge. Soft, diffused morning light filters through the mist, illuminating his focused face and the work in his hands: his left hand grips a steel chisel, gleaming with a cold glow, pressing precisely against the stone face. In his right, he holds a heavy wooden mallet, carefully striking the handle with a steady, deliberate rhythm. Each blow is accompanied by a crisp, dull sound, and a small cloud of fine stone chips and dust bursts from the chisel tip, drifting down and leaving a fleeting trail in the air. Under his skillful hands, the originally flat surface of the stone is gradually revealing the outline of complex and smooth auspicious cloud patterns. The whole picture is full of the tranquil and focused spirit of craftsmanship, creating a quiet atmosphere as if time has stood still.", + "seed": 4597, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_15/index_5634_seed_4597_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.049920948408544066, + "vlm_logprob": -0.049920948408544066, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.049920948408544066, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slight overhead angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly stonemason wearing a dark blue linen jacket with sleeves rolled up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stonemason's forearms visible and stained with white stone dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stonemason holding a steel chisel in his left hand and a wooden mallet in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the gray railing of an ancient stone bridge with soft, diffused morning light and mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.037366513162851334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6623666286468506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.037366513162851334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.037366513162851334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14114421606063843, + 0.055182427167892456, + 0.14161953330039978, + 0.11043713241815567, + 0.23653466999530792, + 0.022798683494329453, + 0.08435975760221481, + 0.0668172612786293, + 0.0802324041724205, + 0.060873907059431076 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.037366513162851334 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slight overhead angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly stonemason wearing a dark blue linen jacket with sleeves rolled up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stonemason's forearms visible and stained with white stone dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stonemason holding a steel chisel in his left hand and a wooden mallet in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the gray railing of an ancient stone bridge with soft, diffused morning light and mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0430884063243866 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168088436126709 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0430884063243866, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0430884063243866, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7713698148727417, + 0.03548609837889671, + 0.03688457980751991, + 0.016501329839229584, + 0.01464132685214281, + 0.006222648546099663, + 0.034708037972450256, + 0.02068897895514965, + 0.006811034865677357, + 0.05668601766228676 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0430884063243866 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slight overhead angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly stonemason wearing a dark blue linen jacket with sleeves rolled up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stonemason's forearms visible and stained with white stone dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stonemason holding a steel chisel in his left hand and a wooden mallet in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the gray railing of an ancient stone bridge with soft, diffused morning light and mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011081933043897152 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511081695556641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011081933043897152, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011081933043897152, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35787659883499146, + 0.08173257857561111, + 0.02983205020427704, + 0.04414111003279686, + 0.039814699441194534, + 0.038085345178842545, + 0.029492724686861038, + 0.07112187892198563, + 0.02312479354441166, + 0.2847781777381897 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011081933043897152 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slight overhead angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly stonemason wearing a dark blue linen jacket with sleeves rolled up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stonemason's forearms visible and stained with white stone dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stonemason holding a steel chisel in his left hand and a wooden mallet in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the gray railing of an ancient stone bridge with soft, diffused morning light and mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900497317314148 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579005002975464 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900497317314148, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900497317314148, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6755853891372681, + 0.038783784955739975, + 0.04401109740138054, + 0.03106202371418476, + 0.02564760111272335, + 0.04115808755159378, + 0.040123436599969864, + 0.03054138645529747, + 0.026944585144519806, + 0.046142712235450745 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900497317314148 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slight overhead angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly stonemason wearing a dark blue linen jacket with sleeves rolled up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stonemason's forearms visible and stained with white stone dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stonemason holding a steel chisel in his left hand and a wooden mallet in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the gray railing of an ancient stone bridge with soft, diffused morning light and mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07906291633844376 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790629386901855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07906291633844376, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07906291633844376, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6136821508407593, + 0.05278955027461052, + 0.053093623369932175, + 0.030388930812478065, + 0.022973742336034775, + 0.03641544654965401, + 0.036605995148420334, + 0.022075600922107697, + 0.016748733818531036, + 0.11522622406482697 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07906291633844376 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slight overhead angle, the camera held still, the viewer's gaze fixed on a pair of weathered yet remarkably steady hands. The elderly stonemason, dressed in a simple, dark blue linen jacket, sleeves rolled high, revealing sturdy forearms stained with white stone dust, leans over the gray railing of an ancient stone bridge. Soft, diffused morning light filters through the mist, illuminating his focused face and the work in his hands: his left hand grips a steel chisel, gleaming with a cold glow, pressing precisely against the stone face. In his right, he holds a heavy wooden mallet, carefully striking the handle with a steady, deliberate rhythm. Each blow is accompanied by a crisp, dull sound, and a small cloud of fine stone chips and dust bursts from the chisel tip, drifting down and leaving a fleeting trail in the air. Under his skillful hands, the originally flat surface of the stone is gradually revealing the outline of complex and smooth auspicious cloud patterns. The whole picture is full of the tranquil and focused spirit of craftsmanship, creating a quiet atmosphere as if time has stood still.", + "seed": 4598, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_15/index_5634_seed_4598_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03537271525710821, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03537271525710821, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03537271525710821, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slight overhead angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly stonemason wearing a dark blue linen jacket with sleeves rolled up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stonemason's forearms visible and stained with white stone dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stonemason holding a steel chisel in his left hand and a wooden mallet in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the gray railing of an ancient stone bridge with soft, diffused morning light and mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012273970991373062 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.637273788452148 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012273970991373062, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012273970991373062, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1828247308731079, + 0.11322063207626343, + 0.08054034411907196, + 0.21848291158676147, + 0.08642922341823578, + 0.054733507335186005, + 0.06163109466433525, + 0.03895105421543121, + 0.0791897177696228, + 0.08399676531553268 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012273970991373062 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slight overhead angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly stonemason wearing a dark blue linen jacket with sleeves rolled up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stonemason's forearms visible and stained with white stone dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stonemason holding a steel chisel in his left hand and a wooden mallet in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the gray railing of an ancient stone bridge with soft, diffused morning light and mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02981938049197197 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298194885253906 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02981938049197197, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02981938049197197, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22803112864494324, + 0.233812153339386, + 0.14686539769172668, + 0.08637569844722748, + 0.09789863228797913, + 0.0530892014503479, + 0.026490526273846626, + 0.023365585133433342, + 0.04392806068062782, + 0.060143597424030304 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02981938049197197 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slight overhead angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly stonemason wearing a dark blue linen jacket with sleeves rolled up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stonemason's forearms visible and stained with white stone dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stonemason holding a steel chisel in his left hand and a wooden mallet in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the gray railing of an ancient stone bridge with soft, diffused morning light and mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978058110922575 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634780406951904 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978058110922575, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978058110922575, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15239903330802917, + 0.15314103662967682, + 0.04567314311861992, + 0.1734488308429718, + 0.15558961033821106, + 0.14195933938026428, + 0.03462832793593407, + 0.03408338129520416, + 0.060554470866918564, + 0.04852291941642761 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978058110922575 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slight overhead angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly stonemason wearing a dark blue linen jacket with sleeves rolled up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stonemason's forearms visible and stained with white stone dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stonemason holding a steel chisel in his left hand and a wooden mallet in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the gray railing of an ancient stone bridge with soft, diffused morning light and mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496004968881607 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929960012435913 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496004968881607, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496004968881607, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09972147643566132, + 0.2128727287054062, + 0.09462346881628036, + 0.12043250352144241, + 0.29188302159309387, + 0.03954578936100006, + 0.03848198801279068, + 0.036602236330509186, + 0.026775093749165535, + 0.03906169906258583 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496004968881607 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slight overhead angle with the camera held still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly stonemason wearing a dark blue linen jacket with sleeves rolled up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stonemason's forearms visible and stained with white stone dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stonemason holding a steel chisel in his left hand and a wooden mallet in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the gray railing of an ancient stone bridge with soft, diffused morning light and mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0700295940041542 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950294971466064 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0700295940041542, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0700295940041542, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22841079533100128, + 0.07083377987146378, + 0.07892616093158722, + 0.23329585790634155, + 0.08681262284517288, + 0.06195957586169243, + 0.06951509416103363, + 0.027117151767015457, + 0.06510862708091736, + 0.07802030444145203 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0700295940041542 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_2/index_tensor([3711, 3711])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_2/index_tensor([3711, 3711])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..abb81719a99862c1b411c4143017fda0064e5347 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_2/index_tensor([3711, 3711])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "stunning macro close-up, captured in a slow, smooth pan, closely tracks the spectacle of a thick, moist carpet of deep emerald green moss deep within an ancient woodland. Countless golden coral fungi burst forth from the moss, their vibrant hues gradating from bright orange at the base to lemon yellow at the tips, resembling flaming flames. With a visible, almost magical speed, the delicate branches of these fungi rise, branching and interweaving gracefully and resolutely, rapidly forming a dense and intricate golden network, like a living golden tapestry. Soft beams of Tyndall light penetrate the dense forest canopy, precisely illuminating this microscopic landscape, illuminating tiny spores suspended in the air and reflecting shimmering golden highlights off the velvety, moist surfaces of the fungi. In the background, the roots of ancient trees and decaying leaves are vaguely visible, creating an atmosphere full of oriental fantasy, allowing the audience to immerse themselves in this quiet, mysterious and vibrant miracle of life.", + "seed": 5432, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_2/index_3711_seed_5432_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.22112419214099646, + "vlm_logprob": -0.22112419214099646, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.22112419214099646, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a thick, moist carpet of deep emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless golden coral fungi visible bursting from the moss with hues grading from bright orange to lemon yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the fungal branches visibly rise, branch, and interweave rapidly to form a dense golden network?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft beams of Tyndall light visible penetrating the canopy to illuminate tiny spores and create golden highlights on the fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, smooth pan tracking the spectacle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026852885261178017 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.65185284614563 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026852885261178017, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026852885261178017, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.292511910200119, + 0.20017936825752258, + 0.13277089595794678, + 0.045105669647455215, + 0.10080289095640182, + 0.03952724114060402, + 0.026576654985547066, + 0.033815424889326096, + 0.06523872911930084, + 0.06347125768661499 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026852885261178017 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a thick, moist carpet of deep emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless golden coral fungi visible bursting from the moss with hues grading from bright orange to lemon yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the fungal branches visibly rise, branch, and interweave rapidly to form a dense golden network?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft beams of Tyndall light visible penetrating the canopy to illuminate tiny spores and create golden highlights on the fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, smooth pan tracking the spectacle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005269684828817844 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255269527435303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005269684828817844, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005269684828817844, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16780975461006165, + 0.10251634567975998, + 0.07745886594057083, + 0.06386888772249222, + 0.12089547514915466, + 0.09176132082939148, + 0.14918391406536102, + 0.11655305325984955, + 0.05014500021934509, + 0.05980740115046501 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005269684828817844 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a thick, moist carpet of deep emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless golden coral fungi visible bursting from the moss with hues grading from bright orange to lemon yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the fungal branches visibly rise, branch, and interweave rapidly to form a dense golden network?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft beams of Tyndall light visible penetrating the canopy to illuminate tiny spores and create golden highlights on the fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, smooth pan tracking the spectacle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8984412550926208 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5234412550926208 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8984412550926208, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8984412550926208, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10464160889387131, + 0.10397162288427353, + 0.03418457880616188, + 0.057923801243305206, + 0.08535522222518921, + 0.15330791473388672, + 0.26389527320861816, + 0.086461141705513, + 0.07252514362335205, + 0.03773370012640953 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8984412550926208 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a thick, moist carpet of deep emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless golden coral fungi visible bursting from the moss with hues grading from bright orange to lemon yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the fungal branches visibly rise, branch, and interweave rapidly to form a dense golden network?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft beams of Tyndall light visible penetrating the canopy to illuminate tiny spores and create golden highlights on the fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, smooth pan tracking the spectacle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11300773173570633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2380077838897705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11300773173570633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11300773173570633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19148428738117218, + 0.1844012290239334, + 0.04436773434281349, + 0.07136846333742142, + 0.149429053068161, + 0.08264579623937607, + 0.03162344545125961, + 0.1590583175420761, + 0.03799043968319893, + 0.04763127490878105 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11300773173570633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a thick, moist carpet of deep emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless golden coral fungi visible bursting from the moss with hues grading from bright orange to lemon yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the fungal branches visibly rise, branch, and interweave rapidly to form a dense golden network?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft beams of Tyndall light visible penetrating the canopy to illuminate tiny spores and create golden highlights on the fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, smooth pan tracking the spectacle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204940378665924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812049388885498 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204940378665924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204940378665924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08095423877239227, + 0.03945428505539894, + 0.03122682496905327, + 0.04605919495224953, + 0.04907285422086716, + 0.08034643530845642, + 0.2094927728176117, + 0.23498095571994781, + 0.15049868822097778, + 0.07791375368833542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204940378665924 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning macro close-up, captured in a slow, smooth pan, closely tracks the spectacle of a thick, moist carpet of deep emerald green moss deep within an ancient woodland. Countless golden coral fungi burst forth from the moss, their vibrant hues gradating from bright orange at the base to lemon yellow at the tips, resembling flaming flames. With a visible, almost magical speed, the delicate branches of these fungi rise, branching and interweaving gracefully and resolutely, rapidly forming a dense and intricate golden network, like a living golden tapestry. Soft beams of Tyndall light penetrate the dense forest canopy, precisely illuminating this microscopic landscape, illuminating tiny spores suspended in the air and reflecting shimmering golden highlights off the velvety, moist surfaces of the fungi. In the background, the roots of ancient trees and decaying leaves are vaguely visible, creating an atmosphere full of oriental fantasy, allowing the audience to immerse themselves in this quiet, mysterious and vibrant miracle of life.", + "seed": 5433, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_2/index_3711_seed_5433_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.10387082560919225, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10387082560919225, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10387082560919225, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a thick, moist carpet of deep emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless golden coral fungi visible bursting from the moss with hues grading from bright orange to lemon yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the fungal branches visibly rise, branch, and interweave rapidly to form a dense golden network?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft beams of Tyndall light visible penetrating the canopy to illuminate tiny spores and create golden highlights on the fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, smooth pan tracking the spectacle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018695803359150887 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018695831298828 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018695803359150887, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018695803359150887, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12391997128725052, + 0.022542553022503853, + 0.021011866629123688, + 0.16486679017543793, + 0.057966843247413635, + 0.07243259251117706, + 0.15122470259666443, + 0.0478597953915596, + 0.17738325893878937, + 0.16079168021678925 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018695803359150887 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a thick, moist carpet of deep emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless golden coral fungi visible bursting from the moss with hues grading from bright orange to lemon yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the fungal branches visibly rise, branch, and interweave rapidly to form a dense golden network?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft beams of Tyndall light visible penetrating the canopy to illuminate tiny spores and create golden highlights on the fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, smooth pan tracking the spectacle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032051641028374434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753205299377441 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032051641028374434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032051641028374434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19817431271076202, + 0.04257713258266449, + 0.0400632843375206, + 0.0633518397808075, + 0.07738584280014038, + 0.2357599139213562, + 0.09921404719352722, + 0.039886415004730225, + 0.08617779612541199, + 0.11740943044424057 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032051641028374434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a thick, moist carpet of deep emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless golden coral fungi visible bursting from the moss with hues grading from bright orange to lemon yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the fungal branches visibly rise, branch, and interweave rapidly to form a dense golden network?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft beams of Tyndall light visible penetrating the canopy to illuminate tiny spores and create golden highlights on the fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, smooth pan tracking the spectacle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28138065338134766 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063806533813477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28138065338134766, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28138065338134766, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1306259036064148, + 0.028218617662787437, + 0.028634337708353996, + 0.309398353099823, + 0.06889883428812027, + 0.1989080011844635, + 0.07671356946229935, + 0.029671791940927505, + 0.04361887648701668, + 0.08531174808740616 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28138065338134766 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a thick, moist carpet of deep emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless golden coral fungi visible bursting from the moss with hues grading from bright orange to lemon yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the fungal branches visibly rise, branch, and interweave rapidly to form a dense golden network?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft beams of Tyndall light visible penetrating the canopy to illuminate tiny spores and create golden highlights on the fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, smooth pan tracking the spectacle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270582377910614 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127058267593384 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270582377910614, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270582377910614, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12829646468162537, + 0.02784324437379837, + 0.0350455641746521, + 0.09084063768386841, + 0.07281365990638733, + 0.2896706759929657, + 0.0652524009346962, + 0.043279677629470825, + 0.05314064770936966, + 0.19381706416606903 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270582377910614 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a thick, moist carpet of deep emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless golden coral fungi visible bursting from the moss with hues grading from bright orange to lemon yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the fungal branches visibly rise, branch, and interweave rapidly to form a dense golden network?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft beams of Tyndall light visible penetrating the canopy to illuminate tiny spores and create golden highlights on the fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, smooth pan tracking the spectacle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08901426941156387 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640142917633057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08901426941156387, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08901426941156387, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.136163592338562, + 0.04066694900393486, + 0.046386588364839554, + 0.2300661951303482, + 0.09953293949365616, + 0.13514132797718048, + 0.12936750054359436, + 0.05426735058426857, + 0.06263142079114914, + 0.06577613204717636 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08901426941156387 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning macro close-up, captured in a slow, smooth pan, closely tracks the spectacle of a thick, moist carpet of deep emerald green moss deep within an ancient woodland. Countless golden coral fungi burst forth from the moss, their vibrant hues gradating from bright orange at the base to lemon yellow at the tips, resembling flaming flames. With a visible, almost magical speed, the delicate branches of these fungi rise, branching and interweaving gracefully and resolutely, rapidly forming a dense and intricate golden network, like a living golden tapestry. Soft beams of Tyndall light penetrate the dense forest canopy, precisely illuminating this microscopic landscape, illuminating tiny spores suspended in the air and reflecting shimmering golden highlights off the velvety, moist surfaces of the fungi. In the background, the roots of ancient trees and decaying leaves are vaguely visible, creating an atmosphere full of oriental fantasy, allowing the audience to immerse themselves in this quiet, mysterious and vibrant miracle of life.", + "seed": 5434, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_2/index_3711_seed_5434_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.31262197252362967, + "vlm_logprob": -0.31262197252362967, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.31262197252362967, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a thick, moist carpet of deep emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless golden coral fungi visible bursting from the moss with hues grading from bright orange to lemon yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the fungal branches visibly rise, branch, and interweave rapidly to form a dense golden network?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft beams of Tyndall light visible penetrating the canopy to illuminate tiny spores and create golden highlights on the fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, smooth pan tracking the spectacle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11348407715559006 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2384841442108154 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11348407715559006, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11348407715559006, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.45982101559638977, + 0.12659643590450287, + 0.2040005326271057, + 0.05474608764052391, + 0.016224203631281853, + 0.033004280179739, + 0.01286145020276308, + 0.03072812408208847, + 0.015413502231240273, + 0.04660436511039734 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11348407715559006 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a thick, moist carpet of deep emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless golden coral fungi visible bursting from the moss with hues grading from bright orange to lemon yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the fungal branches visibly rise, branch, and interweave rapidly to form a dense golden network?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft beams of Tyndall light visible penetrating the canopy to illuminate tiny spores and create golden highlights on the fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, smooth pan tracking the spectacle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005275021307170391 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255275249481201 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005275021307170391, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005275021307170391, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6703333854675293, + 0.08382396399974823, + 0.11355462670326233, + 0.01925523392856121, + 0.014382417313754559, + 0.026800740510225296, + 0.008859961293637753, + 0.015108681283891201, + 0.027575328946113586, + 0.02030564844608307 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005275021307170391 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a thick, moist carpet of deep emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless golden coral fungi visible bursting from the moss with hues grading from bright orange to lemon yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the fungal branches visibly rise, branch, and interweave rapidly to form a dense golden network?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft beams of Tyndall light visible penetrating the canopy to illuminate tiny spores and create golden highlights on the fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, smooth pan tracking the spectacle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1371705532073975 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38717055320739746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1371705532073975, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1371705532073975, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34283196926116943, + 0.14855031669139862, + 0.17064669728279114, + 0.02497806027531624, + 0.053118959069252014, + 0.08728227019309998, + 0.04404526948928833, + 0.0323183499276638, + 0.05451855808496475, + 0.041709523648023605 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1371705532073975 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a thick, moist carpet of deep emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless golden coral fungi visible bursting from the moss with hues grading from bright orange to lemon yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the fungal branches visibly rise, branch, and interweave rapidly to form a dense golden network?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft beams of Tyndall light visible penetrating the canopy to illuminate tiny spores and create golden highlights on the fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, smooth pan tracking the spectacle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2522149682044983 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5022149085998535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2522149682044983, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2522149682044983, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6334152221679688, + 0.1028367131948471, + 0.07905910164117813, + 0.023088261485099792, + 0.021092401817440987, + 0.07998412847518921, + 0.0074104988016188145, + 0.01346054207533598, + 0.024937942624092102, + 0.014715183526277542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2522149682044983 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a thick, moist carpet of deep emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless golden coral fungi visible bursting from the moss with hues grading from bright orange to lemon yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the fungal branches visibly rise, branch, and interweave rapidly to form a dense golden network?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft beams of Tyndall light visible penetrating the canopy to illuminate tiny spores and create golden highlights on the fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, smooth pan tracking the spectacle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054965242743492126 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299652576446533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054965242743492126, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054965242743492126, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.785753071308136, + 0.028404487296938896, + 0.08316607773303986, + 0.007622821722179651, + 0.021733460947871208, + 0.004355179145932198, + 0.009688304737210274, + 0.010124958120286465, + 0.02995445765554905, + 0.019197113811969757 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054965242743492126 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning macro close-up, captured in a slow, smooth pan, closely tracks the spectacle of a thick, moist carpet of deep emerald green moss deep within an ancient woodland. Countless golden coral fungi burst forth from the moss, their vibrant hues gradating from bright orange at the base to lemon yellow at the tips, resembling flaming flames. With a visible, almost magical speed, the delicate branches of these fungi rise, branching and interweaving gracefully and resolutely, rapidly forming a dense and intricate golden network, like a living golden tapestry. Soft beams of Tyndall light penetrate the dense forest canopy, precisely illuminating this microscopic landscape, illuminating tiny spores suspended in the air and reflecting shimmering golden highlights off the velvety, moist surfaces of the fungi. In the background, the roots of ancient trees and decaying leaves are vaguely visible, creating an atmosphere full of oriental fantasy, allowing the audience to immerse themselves in this quiet, mysterious and vibrant miracle of life.", + "seed": 5435, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_2/index_3711_seed_5435_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2611730846576393, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2611730846576393, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2611730846576393, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a thick, moist carpet of deep emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless golden coral fungi visible bursting from the moss with hues grading from bright orange to lemon yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the fungal branches visibly rise, branch, and interweave rapidly to form a dense golden network?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft beams of Tyndall light visible penetrating the canopy to illuminate tiny spores and create golden highlights on the fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, smooth pan tracking the spectacle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018584763631224632 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018584728240967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018584763631224632, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018584763631224632, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.43012434244155884, + 0.07009589672088623, + 0.08606031537055969, + 0.03162067383527756, + 0.08742634952068329, + 0.06662925332784653, + 0.03513950854539871, + 0.045006249099969864, + 0.08734951913356781, + 0.06054779142141342 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018584763631224632 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a thick, moist carpet of deep emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless golden coral fungi visible bursting from the moss with hues grading from bright orange to lemon yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the fungal branches visibly rise, branch, and interweave rapidly to form a dense golden network?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft beams of Tyndall light visible penetrating the canopy to illuminate tiny spores and create golden highlights on the fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, smooth pan tracking the spectacle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046503725461661816 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379650592803955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046503725461661816, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046503725461661816, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.265116810798645, + 0.11805260926485062, + 0.04568246379494667, + 0.0496424101293087, + 0.08732210844755173, + 0.13597950339317322, + 0.06531469523906708, + 0.05575643107295036, + 0.12394632399082184, + 0.053186722099781036 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046503725461661816 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a thick, moist carpet of deep emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless golden coral fungi visible bursting from the moss with hues grading from bright orange to lemon yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the fungal branches visibly rise, branch, and interweave rapidly to form a dense golden network?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft beams of Tyndall light visible penetrating the canopy to illuminate tiny spores and create golden highlights on the fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, smooth pan tracking the spectacle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539950132369995 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289950430393219 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0539950132369995, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0539950132369995, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21922838687896729, + 0.058938369154930115, + 0.04200790822505951, + 0.08721248060464859, + 0.18390384316444397, + 0.07831333577632904, + 0.045949164777994156, + 0.09978719055652618, + 0.11967287957668304, + 0.0649864450097084 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0539950132369995 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a thick, moist carpet of deep emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless golden coral fungi visible bursting from the moss with hues grading from bright orange to lemon yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the fungal branches visibly rise, branch, and interweave rapidly to form a dense golden network?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft beams of Tyndall light visible penetrating the canopy to illuminate tiny spores and create golden highlights on the fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, smooth pan tracking the spectacle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17997947335243225 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049794435501099 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17997947335243225, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17997947335243225, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17672917246818542, + 0.0920415148139, + 0.0854569673538208, + 0.1613052487373352, + 0.07170552760362625, + 0.045541681349277496, + 0.07597887516021729, + 0.1173095554113388, + 0.12077660858631134, + 0.05315482243895531 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17997947335243225 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a thick, moist carpet of deep emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless golden coral fungi visible bursting from the moss with hues grading from bright orange to lemon yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the fungal branches visibly rise, branch, and interweave rapidly to form a dense golden network?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are soft beams of Tyndall light visible penetrating the canopy to illuminate tiny spores and create golden highlights on the fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, smooth pan tracking the spectacle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865580052137375 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486557483673096 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865580052137375, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865580052137375, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07440011948347092, + 0.062215860933065414, + 0.05407804995775223, + 0.06848105788230896, + 0.07969669997692108, + 0.17221951484680176, + 0.08704852312803268, + 0.21015317738056183, + 0.1428077071905136, + 0.048899274319410324 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865580052137375 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_3/index_tensor([6364, 6364])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_3/index_tensor([6364, 6364])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4683771cb3639016d36ca33a3efb1f898ef0452f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_3/index_tensor([6364, 6364])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle shot, filmed in cinematic slow motion, captures the violent collision of two thick stacks of old documents in mid-air. The paper, a mix of yellowed parchment and brittle fiber sheets, is frayed at the edges and wrinkled at the corners from decades of handling. As the stacks encounter a silent, immense force, they visibly compress for a fraction of a second before erupting in a chaotic explosion. The shockwave of paper bursts outward, sending individual sheets and entire sheets swirling through the air in an elegant yet destructive ballet. The camera carefully tracks the impact, capturing how some pages flutter and twist languidly, while others flip end over end. The entire event is starkly illuminated by a single, harsh overhead light source, creating a dramatic black-and-white contrast against a deep, dark, and blurred background, making the swirling dust and paper fragments shimmer like confetti. The color palette is a rich tapestry of tans, creams, and taupes, creating a tense and surreal atmosphere that transforms the moment of devastation into a vibrant visual poetry.", + "seed": 15592, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_3/index_6364_seed_15592_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.039167646877467634, + "vlm_logprob": -0.039167646877467634, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.039167646877467634, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two thick stacks of old documents shown colliding in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper depicted as yellowed parchment and brittle fiber sheets with frayed edges and wrinkled corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stacks visibly compress before erupting in a chaotic explosion of swirling paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in cinematic slow motion with a low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting stark black-and-white with a single harsh overhead source against a deep, dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11454962939023972 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2395496368408203 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11454962939023972, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11454962939023972, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05569402873516083, + 0.0720897689461708, + 0.04185760021209717, + 0.06422571837902069, + 0.07120692729949951, + 0.22092413902282715, + 0.045004989951848984, + 0.060001593083143234, + 0.3150339424610138, + 0.05396129935979843 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11454962939023972 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two thick stacks of old documents shown colliding in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper depicted as yellowed parchment and brittle fiber sheets with frayed edges and wrinkled corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stacks visibly compress before erupting in a chaotic explosion of swirling paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in cinematic slow motion with a low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting stark black-and-white with a single harsh overhead source against a deep, dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009802065789699554 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634801864624023 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009802065789699554, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009802065789699554, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06910808384418488, + 0.15615634620189667, + 0.07304821908473969, + 0.031016023829579353, + 0.06202908977866173, + 0.22012968361377716, + 0.04991750419139862, + 0.1282075196504593, + 0.15380561351776123, + 0.05658186599612236 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009802065789699554 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two thick stacks of old documents shown colliding in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper depicted as yellowed parchment and brittle fiber sheets with frayed edges and wrinkled corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stacks visibly compress before erupting in a chaotic explosion of swirling paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in cinematic slow motion with a low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting stark black-and-white with a single harsh overhead source against a deep, dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864955693483353 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048649549484253 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864955693483353, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864955693483353, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06646662205457687, + 0.12568655610084534, + 0.04248699173331261, + 0.0312722772359848, + 0.0871305763721466, + 0.4389895498752594, + 0.028942177072167397, + 0.09062078595161438, + 0.03756542131304741, + 0.05083894729614258 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864955693483353 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two thick stacks of old documents shown colliding in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper depicted as yellowed parchment and brittle fiber sheets with frayed edges and wrinkled corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stacks visibly compress before erupting in a chaotic explosion of swirling paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in cinematic slow motion with a low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting stark black-and-white with a single harsh overhead source against a deep, dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01419929601252079 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264199256896973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01419929601252079, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01419929601252079, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04160965606570244, + 0.16732415556907654, + 0.2430197298526764, + 0.040485285222530365, + 0.08838222920894623, + 0.1703437864780426, + 0.06528904289007187, + 0.05187435448169708, + 0.07979506999254227, + 0.05187661200761795 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01419929601252079 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two thick stacks of old documents shown colliding in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper depicted as yellowed parchment and brittle fiber sheets with frayed edges and wrinkled corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stacks visibly compress before erupting in a chaotic explosion of swirling paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in cinematic slow motion with a low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting stark black-and-white with a single harsh overhead source against a deep, dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008637686260044575 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75863790512085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008637686260044575, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008637686260044575, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04391251131892204, + 0.08526373654603958, + 0.07816105335950851, + 0.05291295796632767, + 0.08368132263422012, + 0.11752307415008545, + 0.0491563081741333, + 0.1385141760110855, + 0.22405613958835602, + 0.1268186867237091 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008637686260044575 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle shot, filmed in cinematic slow motion, captures the violent collision of two thick stacks of old documents in mid-air. The paper, a mix of yellowed parchment and brittle fiber sheets, is frayed at the edges and wrinkled at the corners from decades of handling. As the stacks encounter a silent, immense force, they visibly compress for a fraction of a second before erupting in a chaotic explosion. The shockwave of paper bursts outward, sending individual sheets and entire sheets swirling through the air in an elegant yet destructive ballet. The camera carefully tracks the impact, capturing how some pages flutter and twist languidly, while others flip end over end. The entire event is starkly illuminated by a single, harsh overhead light source, creating a dramatic black-and-white contrast against a deep, dark, and blurred background, making the swirling dust and paper fragments shimmer like confetti. The color palette is a rich tapestry of tans, creams, and taupes, creating a tense and surreal atmosphere that transforms the moment of devastation into a vibrant visual poetry.", + "seed": 15593, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_3/index_6364_seed_15593_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.030550944805145263, + "vlm_logprob": -0.030550944805145263, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.030550944805145263, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two thick stacks of old documents shown colliding in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper depicted as yellowed parchment and brittle fiber sheets with frayed edges and wrinkled corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stacks visibly compress before erupting in a chaotic explosion of swirling paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in cinematic slow motion with a low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting stark black-and-white with a single harsh overhead source against a deep, dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08084020763635635 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5808401107788086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08084020763635635, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08084020763635635, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22074736654758453, + 0.08851666003465652, + 0.059698671102523804, + 0.10581563413143158, + 0.08662235736846924, + 0.12032880634069443, + 0.11152473837137222, + 0.06958271563053131, + 0.039597466588020325, + 0.09756560623645782 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08084020763635635 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two thick stacks of old documents shown colliding in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper depicted as yellowed parchment and brittle fiber sheets with frayed edges and wrinkled corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stacks visibly compress before erupting in a chaotic explosion of swirling paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in cinematic slow motion with a low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting stark black-and-white with a single harsh overhead source against a deep, dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020601341500878334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895601272583008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020601341500878334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020601341500878334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2590397894382477, + 0.06813948601484299, + 0.08520324528217316, + 0.13312038779258728, + 0.07806496322154999, + 0.07079663127660751, + 0.1866416186094284, + 0.04815765842795372, + 0.021723434329032898, + 0.04911278933286667 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020601341500878334 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two thick stacks of old documents shown colliding in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper depicted as yellowed parchment and brittle fiber sheets with frayed edges and wrinkled corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stacks visibly compress before erupting in a chaotic explosion of swirling paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in cinematic slow motion with a low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting stark black-and-white with a single harsh overhead source against a deep, dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818285696208477 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018182754516602 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818285696208477, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818285696208477, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14083713293075562, + 0.08895952999591827, + 0.05354323238134384, + 0.06030597165226936, + 0.09652883559465408, + 0.07519479095935822, + 0.30219244956970215, + 0.08722876757383347, + 0.041757162660360336, + 0.05345218628644943 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818285696208477 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two thick stacks of old documents shown colliding in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper depicted as yellowed parchment and brittle fiber sheets with frayed edges and wrinkled corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stacks visibly compress before erupting in a chaotic explosion of swirling paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in cinematic slow motion with a low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting stark black-and-white with a single harsh overhead source against a deep, dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058943174779415 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955893516540527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058943174779415, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058943174779415, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14181090891361237, + 0.10020928829908371, + 0.08461027592420578, + 0.06842685490846634, + 0.13583378493785858, + 0.07391462475061417, + 0.20585326850414276, + 0.06527061760425568, + 0.0574561208486557, + 0.06661427021026611 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058943174779415 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two thick stacks of old documents shown colliding in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper depicted as yellowed parchment and brittle fiber sheets with frayed edges and wrinkled corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stacks visibly compress before erupting in a chaotic explosion of swirling paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in cinematic slow motion with a low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting stark black-and-white with a single harsh overhead source against a deep, dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012540886178612709 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387540817260742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012540886178612709, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012540886178612709, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0691889226436615, + 0.022938411682844162, + 0.018235469236969948, + 0.030931349843740463, + 0.05672105401754379, + 0.033589981496334076, + 0.6669921875, + 0.04599156230688095, + 0.012415332719683647, + 0.04299580305814743 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012540886178612709 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle shot, filmed in cinematic slow motion, captures the violent collision of two thick stacks of old documents in mid-air. The paper, a mix of yellowed parchment and brittle fiber sheets, is frayed at the edges and wrinkled at the corners from decades of handling. As the stacks encounter a silent, immense force, they visibly compress for a fraction of a second before erupting in a chaotic explosion. The shockwave of paper bursts outward, sending individual sheets and entire sheets swirling through the air in an elegant yet destructive ballet. The camera carefully tracks the impact, capturing how some pages flutter and twist languidly, while others flip end over end. The entire event is starkly illuminated by a single, harsh overhead light source, creating a dramatic black-and-white contrast against a deep, dark, and blurred background, making the swirling dust and paper fragments shimmer like confetti. The color palette is a rich tapestry of tans, creams, and taupes, creating a tense and surreal atmosphere that transforms the moment of devastation into a vibrant visual poetry.", + "seed": 15594, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_3/index_6364_seed_15594_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05977496691048145, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05977496691048145, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05977496691048145, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two thick stacks of old documents shown colliding in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper depicted as yellowed parchment and brittle fiber sheets with frayed edges and wrinkled corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stacks visibly compress before erupting in a chaotic explosion of swirling paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in cinematic slow motion with a low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting stark black-and-white with a single harsh overhead source against a deep, dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16156208515167236 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9115620851516724 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16156208515167236, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16156208515167236, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13462387025356293, + 0.1781209260225296, + 0.03619179502129555, + 0.1388399749994278, + 0.06945516914129257, + 0.05526948720216751, + 0.054531559348106384, + 0.09198200702667236, + 0.05322642624378204, + 0.1877588927745819 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16156208515167236 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two thick stacks of old documents shown colliding in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper depicted as yellowed parchment and brittle fiber sheets with frayed edges and wrinkled corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stacks visibly compress before erupting in a chaotic explosion of swirling paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in cinematic slow motion with a low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting stark black-and-white with a single harsh overhead source against a deep, dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023320218548178673 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773320198059082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023320218548178673, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023320218548178673, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12926311790943146, + 0.12162262201309204, + 0.07020897418260574, + 0.07733983546495438, + 0.37781766057014465, + 0.05773681774735451, + 0.06637552380561829, + 0.05167254060506821, + 0.020656298846006393, + 0.02730659395456314 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023320218548178673 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two thick stacks of old documents shown colliding in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper depicted as yellowed parchment and brittle fiber sheets with frayed edges and wrinkled corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stacks visibly compress before erupting in a chaotic explosion of swirling paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in cinematic slow motion with a low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting stark black-and-white with a single harsh overhead source against a deep, dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026346776634454727 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513466835021973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026346776634454727, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026346776634454727, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07362844049930573, + 0.1574682891368866, + 0.08254154026508331, + 0.14091986417770386, + 0.10150231420993805, + 0.04843021556735039, + 0.13761377334594727, + 0.10036185383796692, + 0.11495596915483475, + 0.04257772117853165 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026346776634454727 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two thick stacks of old documents shown colliding in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper depicted as yellowed parchment and brittle fiber sheets with frayed edges and wrinkled corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stacks visibly compress before erupting in a chaotic explosion of swirling paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in cinematic slow motion with a low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting stark black-and-white with a single harsh overhead source against a deep, dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07899979501962662 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789997577667236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07899979501962662, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07899979501962662, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13329680263996124, + 0.04268267750740051, + 0.036566294729709625, + 0.12764683365821838, + 0.08010216057300568, + 0.14560529589653015, + 0.11210852861404419, + 0.20318648219108582, + 0.03503083810210228, + 0.08377406746149063 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07899979501962662 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two thick stacks of old documents shown colliding in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper depicted as yellowed parchment and brittle fiber sheets with frayed edges and wrinkled corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stacks visibly compress before erupting in a chaotic explosion of swirling paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in cinematic slow motion with a low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting stark black-and-white with a single harsh overhead source against a deep, dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008645959198474884 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758646011352539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008645959198474884, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008645959198474884, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10186561197042465, + 0.1040668934583664, + 0.034946244210004807, + 0.1127803772687912, + 0.04507829248905182, + 0.0952710509300232, + 0.1487412452697754, + 0.07209119945764542, + 0.08543390780687332, + 0.1997252255678177 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008645959198474884 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle shot, filmed in cinematic slow motion, captures the violent collision of two thick stacks of old documents in mid-air. The paper, a mix of yellowed parchment and brittle fiber sheets, is frayed at the edges and wrinkled at the corners from decades of handling. As the stacks encounter a silent, immense force, they visibly compress for a fraction of a second before erupting in a chaotic explosion. The shockwave of paper bursts outward, sending individual sheets and entire sheets swirling through the air in an elegant yet destructive ballet. The camera carefully tracks the impact, capturing how some pages flutter and twist languidly, while others flip end over end. The entire event is starkly illuminated by a single, harsh overhead light source, creating a dramatic black-and-white contrast against a deep, dark, and blurred background, making the swirling dust and paper fragments shimmer like confetti. The color palette is a rich tapestry of tans, creams, and taupes, creating a tense and surreal atmosphere that transforms the moment of devastation into a vibrant visual poetry.", + "seed": 15595, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_3/index_6364_seed_15595_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03622259888797998, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03622259888797998, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03622259888797998, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two thick stacks of old documents shown colliding in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper depicted as yellowed parchment and brittle fiber sheets with frayed edges and wrinkled corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stacks visibly compress before erupting in a chaotic explosion of swirling paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in cinematic slow motion with a low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting stark black-and-white with a single harsh overhead source against a deep, dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08989930897951126 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4648993015289307 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08989930897951126, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08989930897951126, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19903212785720825, + 0.09016164392232895, + 0.11010898649692535, + 0.03345616161823273, + 0.03670120611786842, + 0.07993176579475403, + 0.158033549785614, + 0.06947144120931625, + 0.06395363807678223, + 0.15914952754974365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08989930897951126 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two thick stacks of old documents shown colliding in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper depicted as yellowed parchment and brittle fiber sheets with frayed edges and wrinkled corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stacks visibly compress before erupting in a chaotic explosion of swirling paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in cinematic slow motion with a low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting stark black-and-white with a single harsh overhead source against a deep, dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012560075148940086 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38755989074707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012560075148940086, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012560075148940086, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24446408450603485, + 0.08244513720273972, + 0.09064400941133499, + 0.04856971651315689, + 0.02978350780904293, + 0.07137046754360199, + 0.05840514972805977, + 0.07565262168645859, + 0.08914074301719666, + 0.2095245122909546 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012560075148940086 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two thick stacks of old documents shown colliding in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper depicted as yellowed parchment and brittle fiber sheets with frayed edges and wrinkled corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stacks visibly compress before erupting in a chaotic explosion of swirling paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in cinematic slow motion with a low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting stark black-and-white with a single harsh overhead source against a deep, dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026344917714595795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513450145721436 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026344917714595795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026344917714595795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27823391556739807, + 0.06038197875022888, + 0.04885587841272354, + 0.04128352552652359, + 0.04687889665365219, + 0.06052349507808685, + 0.08104518800973892, + 0.079816073179245, + 0.0925060510635376, + 0.21047496795654297 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026344917714595795 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two thick stacks of old documents shown colliding in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper depicted as yellowed parchment and brittle fiber sheets with frayed edges and wrinkled corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stacks visibly compress before erupting in a chaotic explosion of swirling paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in cinematic slow motion with a low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting stark black-and-white with a single harsh overhead source against a deep, dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810739889740944 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288107395172119 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810739889740944, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810739889740944, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34839925169944763, + 0.044247325509786606, + 0.08570225536823273, + 0.03910126909613609, + 0.023563044145703316, + 0.022199878469109535, + 0.051416702568531036, + 0.05799635499715805, + 0.11746636778116226, + 0.20990753173828125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810739889740944 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two thick stacks of old documents shown colliding in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper depicted as yellowed parchment and brittle fiber sheets with frayed edges and wrinkled corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the stacks visibly compress before erupting in a chaotic explosion of swirling paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in cinematic slow motion with a low-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting stark black-and-white with a single harsh overhead source against a deep, dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01420129369944334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2642011642456055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01420129369944334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01420129369944334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.44837304949760437, + 0.04861912131309509, + 0.01901688054203987, + 0.00984600093215704, + 0.00521414540708065, + 0.024572785943746567, + 0.009681668132543564, + 0.028998468071222305, + 0.14901244640350342, + 0.25666552782058716 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01420129369944334 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_4/index_tensor([315, 315])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_4/index_tensor([315, 315])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a40e6b4cb47f485263dc3fa2542ad072e56413b6 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_4/index_tensor([315, 315])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level close-up captures the scene against a clean, matte white background, illuminated by soft, even studio lighting. A woman's fair hand, with neatly manicured pale pink nails, enters the frame from the bottom and moves upward in a smooth, deliberate motion. Her fingers gracefully curl around the white paper strip of a large, round, rainbow-swirled lollipop, its smooth surface vividly reflecting the light in vibrant hues of red, yellow, and blue. The hand continues its ascent until it reaches the left side of the frame, gently and precisely placing the lollipop on the white surface, the candy on its side, the colored side tilted slightly toward the camera. After releasing the lollipop, the hand pauses briefly before retracting, then steadily moves downward, exiting the frame from the bottom, leaving the vibrantly colored lollipop as the sole, starkly contrasting subject in the minimalist and serene composition.", + "seed": 22933, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_4/index_315_seed_22933_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.017587076942436396, + "vlm_logprob": -0.017587076942436396, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.017587076942436396, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the background a clean, matte white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman's fair hand with neatly manicured pale pink nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large, round lollipop with a rainbow swirl pattern (red, yellow, and blue) visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand enter from the bottom, move upward to the left, place the lollipop on its side, and then exit downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006915089208632708 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.506915092468262 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006915089208632708, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006915089208632708, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08993979543447495, + 0.02197091653943062, + 0.020609889179468155, + 0.07300250232219696, + 0.007887359708547592, + 0.09857701510190964, + 0.07783930748701096, + 0.406147837638855, + 0.07441692799329758, + 0.1296083927154541 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006915089208632708 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the background a clean, matte white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman's fair hand with neatly manicured pale pink nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large, round lollipop with a rainbow swirl pattern (red, yellow, and blue) visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand enter from the bottom, move upward to the left, place the lollipop on its side, and then exit downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005960783455520868 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130960941314697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005960783455520868, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005960783455520868, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07382836192846298, + 0.08810146898031235, + 0.07831265777349472, + 0.17880931496620178, + 0.026502594351768494, + 0.2116871476173401, + 0.1894981861114502, + 0.0671706274151802, + 0.053380683064460754, + 0.03270893916487694 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005960783455520868 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the background a clean, matte white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman's fair hand with neatly manicured pale pink nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large, round lollipop with a rainbow swirl pattern (red, yellow, and blue) visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand enter from the bottom, move upward to the left, place the lollipop on its side, and then exit downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019422968616709113 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251942157745361 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019422968616709113, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019422968616709113, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1158323585987091, + 0.0469515360891819, + 0.05695518106222153, + 0.026931211352348328, + 0.04033064842224121, + 0.05016700550913811, + 0.1094452440738678, + 0.39981192350387573, + 0.08015896379947662, + 0.07341590523719788 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019422968616709113 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the background a clean, matte white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman's fair hand with neatly manicured pale pink nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large, round lollipop with a rainbow swirl pattern (red, yellow, and blue) visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand enter from the bottom, move upward to the left, place the lollipop on its side, and then exit downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0549396276473999 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299397468566895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0549396276473999, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0549396276473999, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05528949573636055, + 0.04978358745574951, + 0.0999431312084198, + 0.29844793677330017, + 0.024328604340553284, + 0.01038286928087473, + 0.05272737890481949, + 0.3428936004638672, + 0.0376281663775444, + 0.028575260192155838 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0549396276473999 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the background a clean, matte white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman's fair hand with neatly manicured pale pink nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large, round lollipop with a rainbow swirl pattern (red, yellow, and blue) visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand enter from the bottom, move upward to the left, place the lollipop on its side, and then exit downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018177587538957596 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018177509307861 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018177587538957596, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018177587538957596, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09214165806770325, + 0.028694001957774162, + 0.01641576923429966, + 0.12080568075180054, + 0.018177244812250137, + 0.07169440388679504, + 0.05748338624835014, + 0.47526678442955017, + 0.07407498359680176, + 0.04524604231119156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018177587538957596 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level close-up captures the scene against a clean, matte white background, illuminated by soft, even studio lighting. A woman's fair hand, with neatly manicured pale pink nails, enters the frame from the bottom and moves upward in a smooth, deliberate motion. Her fingers gracefully curl around the white paper strip of a large, round, rainbow-swirled lollipop, its smooth surface vividly reflecting the light in vibrant hues of red, yellow, and blue. The hand continues its ascent until it reaches the left side of the frame, gently and precisely placing the lollipop on the white surface, the candy on its side, the colored side tilted slightly toward the camera. After releasing the lollipop, the hand pauses briefly before retracting, then steadily moves downward, exiting the frame from the bottom, leaving the vibrantly colored lollipop as the sole, starkly contrasting subject in the minimalist and serene composition.", + "seed": 22934, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_4/index_315_seed_22934_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.022718487493693828, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022718487493693828, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022718487493693828, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the background a clean, matte white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman's fair hand with neatly manicured pale pink nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large, round lollipop with a rainbow swirl pattern (red, yellow, and blue) visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand enter from the bottom, move upward to the left, place the lollipop on its side, and then exit downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036311899311840534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753631114959717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036311899311840534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036311899311840534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2871587574481964, + 0.0513010211288929, + 0.1786782294511795, + 0.05428909882903099, + 0.07338206470012665, + 0.08776023983955383, + 0.17847977578639984, + 0.027625542134046555, + 0.03504745662212372, + 0.026277849450707436 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036311899311840534 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the background a clean, matte white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman's fair hand with neatly manicured pale pink nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large, round lollipop with a rainbow swirl pattern (red, yellow, and blue) visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand enter from the bottom, move upward to the left, place the lollipop on its side, and then exit downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023320917040109634 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733209133148193 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023320917040109634, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023320917040109634, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09811269491910934, + 0.06829499453306198, + 0.48696088790893555, + 0.03574639558792114, + 0.03896438330411911, + 0.08999118953943253, + 0.07590624690055847, + 0.027350077405571938, + 0.049529362469911575, + 0.02914372645318508 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023320917040109634 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the background a clean, matte white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman's fair hand with neatly manicured pale pink nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large, round lollipop with a rainbow swirl pattern (red, yellow, and blue) visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand enter from the bottom, move upward to the left, place the lollipop on its side, and then exit downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004100131336599588 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504100322723389 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004100131336599588, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004100131336599588, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06135740131139755, + 0.04572904109954834, + 0.3333216905593872, + 0.03650351241230965, + 0.030875494703650475, + 0.13759908080101013, + 0.09972529858350754, + 0.10383865237236023, + 0.11940424144268036, + 0.03164561092853546 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004100131336599588 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the background a clean, matte white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman's fair hand with neatly manicured pale pink nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large, round lollipop with a rainbow swirl pattern (red, yellow, and blue) visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand enter from the bottom, move upward to the left, place the lollipop on its side, and then exit downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000625878572464 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950063705444336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000625878572464, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000625878572464, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05664166435599327, + 0.07194013148546219, + 0.05742118880152702, + 0.041224587708711624, + 0.0740916058421135, + 0.10444432497024536, + 0.2787931263446808, + 0.07675005495548248, + 0.07532443851232529, + 0.16336891055107117 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000625878572464 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the background a clean, matte white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman's fair hand with neatly manicured pale pink nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large, round lollipop with a rainbow swirl pattern (red, yellow, and blue) visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand enter from the bottom, move upward to the left, place the lollipop on its side, and then exit downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012533940374851227 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387534141540527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012533940374851227, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012533940374851227, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07391759753227234, + 0.07678128033876419, + 0.30991414189338684, + 0.05155288055539131, + 0.049647316336631775, + 0.09256802499294281, + 0.09370368719100952, + 0.05202460289001465, + 0.12251805514097214, + 0.07737242430448532 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012533940374851227 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level close-up captures the scene against a clean, matte white background, illuminated by soft, even studio lighting. A woman's fair hand, with neatly manicured pale pink nails, enters the frame from the bottom and moves upward in a smooth, deliberate motion. Her fingers gracefully curl around the white paper strip of a large, round, rainbow-swirled lollipop, its smooth surface vividly reflecting the light in vibrant hues of red, yellow, and blue. The hand continues its ascent until it reaches the left side of the frame, gently and precisely placing the lollipop on the white surface, the candy on its side, the colored side tilted slightly toward the camera. After releasing the lollipop, the hand pauses briefly before retracting, then steadily moves downward, exiting the frame from the bottom, leaving the vibrantly colored lollipop as the sole, starkly contrasting subject in the minimalist and serene composition.", + "seed": 22935, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_4/index_315_seed_22935_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.040028843493200836, + "vlm_logprob": -0.040028843493200836, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3250000238418576, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.040028843493200836, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the background a clean, matte white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman's fair hand with neatly manicured pale pink nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large, round lollipop with a rainbow swirl pattern (red, yellow, and blue) visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand enter from the bottom, move upward to the left, place the lollipop on its side, and then exit downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00312067405320704 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.0031208992004395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00312067405320704, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00312067405320704, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2742563486099243, + 0.104839988052845, + 0.03735024109482765, + 0.037287551909685135, + 0.07014330476522446, + 0.06024305522441864, + 0.08577502518892288, + 0.1574019491672516, + 0.09165261685848236, + 0.08104990422725677 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00312067405320704 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the background a clean, matte white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman's fair hand with neatly manicured pale pink nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large, round lollipop with a rainbow swirl pattern (red, yellow, and blue) visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand enter from the bottom, move upward to the left, place the lollipop on its side, and then exit downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812231495976448 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881224155426025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812231495976448, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812231495976448, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21576948463916779, + 0.0705045759677887, + 0.07531651109457016, + 0.04167290776968002, + 0.07838151603937149, + 0.12349346280097961, + 0.1999829113483429, + 0.03456289693713188, + 0.11235738545656204, + 0.047958359122276306 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812231495976448 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the background a clean, matte white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman's fair hand with neatly manicured pale pink nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large, round lollipop with a rainbow swirl pattern (red, yellow, and blue) visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand enter from the bottom, move upward to the left, place the lollipop on its side, and then exit downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019444384379312396 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251944541931152 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019444384379312396, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019444384379312396, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1318151354789734, + 0.14655335247516632, + 0.15699967741966248, + 0.12162861973047256, + 0.0578039214015007, + 0.06825088709592819, + 0.06869921833276749, + 0.04035644978284836, + 0.13827228546142578, + 0.06962042301893234 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019444384379312396 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the background a clean, matte white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman's fair hand with neatly manicured pale pink nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large, round lollipop with a rainbow swirl pattern (red, yellow, and blue) visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand enter from the bottom, move upward to the left, place the lollipop on its side, and then exit downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1427692472934723 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0177693367004395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1427692472934723, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1427692472934723, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15880227088928223, + 0.18209397792816162, + 0.07120564579963684, + 0.06220703572034836, + 0.06084173172712326, + 0.0699177011847496, + 0.07990408688783646, + 0.11325928568840027, + 0.15941186249256134, + 0.04235637187957764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1427692472934723 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the background a clean, matte white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman's fair hand with neatly manicured pale pink nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large, round lollipop with a rainbow swirl pattern (red, yellow, and blue) visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand enter from the bottom, move upward to the left, place the lollipop on its side, and then exit downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014187542721629143 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264187335968018 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014187542721629143, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014187542721629143, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30448341369628906, + 0.07990346848964691, + 0.050290297716856, + 0.058567021042108536, + 0.06827109307050705, + 0.03302381560206413, + 0.042942460626363754, + 0.11285393685102463, + 0.16244274377822876, + 0.08722180873155594 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014187542721629143 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level close-up captures the scene against a clean, matte white background, illuminated by soft, even studio lighting. A woman's fair hand, with neatly manicured pale pink nails, enters the frame from the bottom and moves upward in a smooth, deliberate motion. Her fingers gracefully curl around the white paper strip of a large, round, rainbow-swirled lollipop, its smooth surface vividly reflecting the light in vibrant hues of red, yellow, and blue. The hand continues its ascent until it reaches the left side of the frame, gently and precisely placing the lollipop on the white surface, the candy on its side, the colored side tilted slightly toward the camera. After releasing the lollipop, the hand pauses briefly before retracting, then steadily moves downward, exiting the frame from the bottom, leaving the vibrantly colored lollipop as the sole, starkly contrasting subject in the minimalist and serene composition.", + "seed": 22936, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_4/index_315_seed_22936_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03007543059065938, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03007543059065938, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03007543059065938, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the background a clean, matte white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman's fair hand with neatly manicured pale pink nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large, round lollipop with a rainbow swirl pattern (red, yellow, and blue) visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand enter from the bottom, move upward to the left, place the lollipop on its side, and then exit downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007458696607500315 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.007458686828613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007458696607500315, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007458696607500315, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15140259265899658, + 0.16138175129890442, + 0.29924607276916504, + 0.03939134255051613, + 0.019927965477108955, + 0.0552918016910553, + 0.03831453621387482, + 0.017020175233483315, + 0.11329544335603714, + 0.1047283262014389 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007458696607500315 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the background a clean, matte white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman's fair hand with neatly manicured pale pink nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large, round lollipop with a rainbow swirl pattern (red, yellow, and blue) visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand enter from the bottom, move upward to the left, place the lollipop on its side, and then exit downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0086548225954175 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758654594421387 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0086548225954175, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0086548225954175, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12006594240665436, + 0.06474597007036209, + 0.09412098675966263, + 0.12386991083621979, + 0.03923303633928299, + 0.09814076870679855, + 0.05903834104537964, + 0.10697334259748459, + 0.1850089728832245, + 0.10880271345376968 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0086548225954175 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the background a clean, matte white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman's fair hand with neatly manicured pale pink nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large, round lollipop with a rainbow swirl pattern (red, yellow, and blue) visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand enter from the bottom, move upward to the left, place the lollipop on its side, and then exit downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00763320829719305 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882633209228516 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00763320829719305, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00763320829719305, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07425091415643692, + 0.037860650569200516, + 0.11588229238986969, + 0.06357231736183167, + 0.08495386689901352, + 0.0871327817440033, + 0.07083630561828613, + 0.0988837331533432, + 0.11015712469816208, + 0.2564699947834015 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00763320829719305 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the background a clean, matte white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman's fair hand with neatly manicured pale pink nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large, round lollipop with a rainbow swirl pattern (red, yellow, and blue) visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand enter from the bottom, move upward to the left, place the lollipop on its side, and then exit downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10029328614473343 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3502933979034424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10029328614473343, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10029328614473343, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04520052671432495, + 0.02155730500817299, + 0.03613018989562988, + 0.05534091964364052, + 0.024196339771151543, + 0.10898096859455109, + 0.08147621899843216, + 0.07044225186109543, + 0.3147355616092682, + 0.2419397383928299 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10029328614473343 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the background a clean, matte white surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman's fair hand with neatly manicured pale pink nails visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large, round lollipop with a rainbow swirl pattern (red, yellow, and blue) visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand enter from the bottom, move upward to the left, place the lollipop on its side, and then exit downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, eye-level close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026337139308452606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651337146759033 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026337139308452606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026337139308452606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11305256932973862, + 0.05578795075416565, + 0.05495777353644371, + 0.0690394937992096, + 0.03171581029891968, + 0.05137071758508682, + 0.04500499367713928, + 0.08163779973983765, + 0.41153398156166077, + 0.08589889854192734 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026337139308452606 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_5/index_tensor([5948, 5948])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_5/index_tensor([5948, 5948])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..757661009b1eba0e8ca7deba0b5c6d2dae2c0aaa --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_5/index_tensor([5948, 5948])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "tight close-up tracking shot, the camera steadily tilting and panning downward, remains locked in focus on a perfectly formed crimson maple leaf. A deep crimson, its edges curling gently to a caramel-gold. The veins are visible in the soft, diffused morning light, and a few glistening drops of morning dew linger on the blade, trembling slightly as it moves. Gently and deliberately, it glides down the curve of neatly laid, weathered, dark gray traditional Chinese tiles, covered in a thin layer of emerald green moss that contrasts sharply with the crimson of the maple leaf. As it glides, the tip of the leaf occasionally scrapes against the rough moss, as if pausing briefly in the cracks between the tiles before gravity carries it on its graceful journey, leaving a barely perceptible trail of moisture in its wake. In the background, the outline of the ancient courtyard is faintly visible in the soft light, presenting a soft out-of-focus effect. The whole picture is full of the tranquility and wabi-sabi beauty of oriental Zen. The main colors are crimson, dark gray and emerald green. The atmosphere is quiet and contemplative, with a delicate perception of the passage of time and the beauty of nature.", + "seed": 26950, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_5/index_5948_seed_26950_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.17806036351248622, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17806036351248622, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17806036351248622, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tight close-up focused on a perfectly formed crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily tilt and pan downward while remaining locked in focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf gliding down a surface of dark gray traditional Chinese tiles covered in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible glistening drops of morning dew on the leaf that tremble slightly as it moves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a faint, out-of-focus outline of an ancient courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22657079994678497 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6015708446502686 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22657079994678497, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22657079994678497, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12959684431552887, + 0.3078596293926239, + 0.06656516343355179, + 0.06596741080284119, + 0.10899276286363602, + 0.04644797369837761, + 0.04334983229637146, + 0.0778113529086113, + 0.10086365044116974, + 0.05254535749554634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22657079994678497 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tight close-up focused on a perfectly formed crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily tilt and pan downward while remaining locked in focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf gliding down a surface of dark gray traditional Chinese tiles covered in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible glistening drops of morning dew on the leaf that tremble slightly as it moves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a faint, out-of-focus outline of an ancient courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08906225860118866 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464062213897705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08906225860118866, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08906225860118866, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12226130068302155, + 0.28617000579833984, + 0.1804182380437851, + 0.11288215965032578, + 0.07834449410438538, + 0.030066626146435738, + 0.023415779694914818, + 0.040974922478199005, + 0.09559383243322372, + 0.029872605577111244 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08906225860118866 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tight close-up focused on a perfectly formed crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily tilt and pan downward while remaining locked in focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf gliding down a surface of dark gray traditional Chinese tiles covered in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible glistening drops of morning dew on the leaf that tremble slightly as it moves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a faint, out-of-focus outline of an ancient courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007635810878127813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882635593414307 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007635810878127813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007635810878127813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0924098938703537, + 0.16571387648582458, + 0.1330854892730713, + 0.06861171126365662, + 0.05577497556805611, + 0.021507136523723602, + 0.0968182384967804, + 0.11409719288349152, + 0.08677207678556442, + 0.16520938277244568 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007635810878127813 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tight close-up focused on a perfectly formed crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily tilt and pan downward while remaining locked in focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf gliding down a surface of dark gray traditional Chinese tiles covered in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible glistening drops of morning dew on the leaf that tremble slightly as it moves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a faint, out-of-focus outline of an ancient courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17992450296878815 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804924488067627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17992450296878815, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17992450296878815, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1439690738916397, + 0.08523964881896973, + 0.1160971000790596, + 0.027927672490477562, + 0.072176493704319, + 0.07863542437553406, + 0.023616621270775795, + 0.07642857730388641, + 0.12273795902729034, + 0.2531713843345642 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17992450296878815 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tight close-up focused on a perfectly formed crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily tilt and pan downward while remaining locked in focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf gliding down a surface of dark gray traditional Chinese tiles covered in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible glistening drops of morning dew on the leaf that tremble slightly as it moves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a faint, out-of-focus outline of an ancient courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3871084451675415 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1371084451675415 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3871084451675415, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3871084451675415, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2195911407470703, + 0.14490479230880737, + 0.15746241807937622, + 0.08004546910524368, + 0.0658431202173233, + 0.06541097164154053, + 0.09852316975593567, + 0.04781673476099968, + 0.04326469078660011, + 0.07713747024536133 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3871084451675415 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "tight close-up tracking shot, the camera steadily tilting and panning downward, remains locked in focus on a perfectly formed crimson maple leaf. A deep crimson, its edges curling gently to a caramel-gold. The veins are visible in the soft, diffused morning light, and a few glistening drops of morning dew linger on the blade, trembling slightly as it moves. Gently and deliberately, it glides down the curve of neatly laid, weathered, dark gray traditional Chinese tiles, covered in a thin layer of emerald green moss that contrasts sharply with the crimson of the maple leaf. As it glides, the tip of the leaf occasionally scrapes against the rough moss, as if pausing briefly in the cracks between the tiles before gravity carries it on its graceful journey, leaving a barely perceptible trail of moisture in its wake. In the background, the outline of the ancient courtyard is faintly visible in the soft light, presenting a soft out-of-focus effect. The whole picture is full of the tranquility and wabi-sabi beauty of oriental Zen. The main colors are crimson, dark gray and emerald green. The atmosphere is quiet and contemplative, with a delicate perception of the passage of time and the beauty of nature.", + "seed": 26951, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_5/index_5948_seed_26951_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.20979387480765582, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20979387480765582, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20979387480765582, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tight close-up focused on a perfectly formed crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily tilt and pan downward while remaining locked in focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf gliding down a surface of dark gray traditional Chinese tiles covered in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible glistening drops of morning dew on the leaf that tremble slightly as it moves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a faint, out-of-focus outline of an ancient courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08060664683580399 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.580606698989868 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08060664683580399, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08060664683580399, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07289797812700272, + 0.05207965150475502, + 0.06661675870418549, + 0.08072739094495773, + 0.028387445956468582, + 0.09331265091896057, + 0.2752889394760132, + 0.25274980068206787, + 0.04630386829376221, + 0.03163556382060051 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08060664683580399 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tight close-up focused on a perfectly formed crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily tilt and pan downward while remaining locked in focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf gliding down a surface of dark gray traditional Chinese tiles covered in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible glistening drops of morning dew on the leaf that tremble slightly as it moves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a faint, out-of-focus outline of an ancient courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003693282604218 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950368881225586 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003693282604218, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003693282604218, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05260615795850754, + 0.020525626838207245, + 0.03532108664512634, + 0.044229671359062195, + 0.022051427513360977, + 0.0578523650765419, + 0.11785657703876495, + 0.11856967210769653, + 0.4838719666004181, + 0.04711543023586273 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003693282604218 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tight close-up focused on a perfectly formed crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily tilt and pan downward while remaining locked in focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf gliding down a surface of dark gray traditional Chinese tiles covered in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible glistening drops of morning dew on the leaf that tremble slightly as it moves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a faint, out-of-focus outline of an ancient courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008640640415251255 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758640766143799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008640640415251255, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008640640415251255, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07853255420923233, + 0.060497164726257324, + 0.06782327592372894, + 0.044522106647491455, + 0.11410485208034515, + 0.07338699698448181, + 0.12986327707767487, + 0.3346734941005707, + 0.056884780526161194, + 0.03971150144934654 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008640640415251255 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tight close-up focused on a perfectly formed crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily tilt and pan downward while remaining locked in focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf gliding down a surface of dark gray traditional Chinese tiles covered in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible glistening drops of morning dew on the leaf that tremble slightly as it moves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a faint, out-of-focus outline of an ancient courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134860396385193 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.313486099243164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134860396385193, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134860396385193, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.039992790669202805, + 0.03451865166425705, + 0.03024955466389656, + 0.038026075810194016, + 0.021380851045250893, + 0.07192805409431458, + 0.24177826941013336, + 0.27882206439971924, + 0.22299017012119293, + 0.02031349018216133 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134860396385193 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tight close-up focused on a perfectly formed crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily tilt and pan downward while remaining locked in focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf gliding down a surface of dark gray traditional Chinese tiles covered in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible glistening drops of morning dew on the leaf that tremble slightly as it moves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a faint, out-of-focus outline of an ancient courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761991143226624 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261991143226624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761991143226624, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761991143226624, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08413128554821014, + 0.07479432970285416, + 0.06416869908571243, + 0.04153924062848091, + 0.07481662184000015, + 0.08834891766309738, + 0.10741576552391052, + 0.2381163388490677, + 0.19754014909267426, + 0.029128577560186386 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761991143226624 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "tight close-up tracking shot, the camera steadily tilting and panning downward, remains locked in focus on a perfectly formed crimson maple leaf. A deep crimson, its edges curling gently to a caramel-gold. The veins are visible in the soft, diffused morning light, and a few glistening drops of morning dew linger on the blade, trembling slightly as it moves. Gently and deliberately, it glides down the curve of neatly laid, weathered, dark gray traditional Chinese tiles, covered in a thin layer of emerald green moss that contrasts sharply with the crimson of the maple leaf. As it glides, the tip of the leaf occasionally scrapes against the rough moss, as if pausing briefly in the cracks between the tiles before gravity carries it on its graceful journey, leaving a barely perceptible trail of moisture in its wake. In the background, the outline of the ancient courtyard is faintly visible in the soft light, presenting a soft out-of-focus effect. The whole picture is full of the tranquility and wabi-sabi beauty of oriental Zen. The main colors are crimson, dark gray and emerald green. The atmosphere is quiet and contemplative, with a delicate perception of the passage of time and the beauty of nature.", + "seed": 26952, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_5/index_5948_seed_26952_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.3347743755206466, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3347743755206466, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3347743755206466, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tight close-up focused on a perfectly formed crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily tilt and pan downward while remaining locked in focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf gliding down a surface of dark gray traditional Chinese tiles covered in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible glistening drops of morning dew on the leaf that tremble slightly as it moves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a faint, out-of-focus outline of an ancient courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.758823573589325 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.633823573589325 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.758823573589325, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.758823573589325, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06831454485654831, + 0.07338091731071472, + 0.029595011845231056, + 0.03437516465783119, + 0.03325526416301727, + 0.15942297875881195, + 0.10779014229774475, + 0.4677949547767639, + 0.01568899303674698, + 0.01038200780749321 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.758823573589325 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tight close-up focused on a perfectly formed crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily tilt and pan downward while remaining locked in focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf gliding down a surface of dark gray traditional Chinese tiles covered in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible glistening drops of morning dew on the leaf that tremble slightly as it moves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a faint, out-of-focus outline of an ancient courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11300943046808243 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.238009452819824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11300943046808243, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11300943046808243, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.123368039727211, + 0.11513993889093399, + 0.07542425394058228, + 0.1276605874300003, + 0.0335705541074276, + 0.05436544120311737, + 0.053585607558488846, + 0.242582306265831, + 0.09933111816644669, + 0.07497220486402512 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11300943046808243 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tight close-up focused on a perfectly formed crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily tilt and pan downward while remaining locked in focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf gliding down a surface of dark gray traditional Chinese tiles covered in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible glistening drops of morning dew on the leaf that tremble slightly as it moves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a faint, out-of-focus outline of an ancient courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01420446764677763 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264204502105713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01420446764677763, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01420446764677763, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14214099943637848, + 0.1774364858865738, + 0.06287644803524017, + 0.11751396954059601, + 0.04346464201807976, + 0.06874383985996246, + 0.09590625017881393, + 0.18432559072971344, + 0.027684152126312256, + 0.0799076110124588 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01420446764677763 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tight close-up focused on a perfectly formed crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily tilt and pan downward while remaining locked in focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf gliding down a surface of dark gray traditional Chinese tiles covered in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible glistening drops of morning dew on the leaf that tremble slightly as it moves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a faint, out-of-focus outline of an ancient courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31348586082458496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.313485860824585 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31348586082458496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31348586082458496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12207314372062683, + 0.0457843653857708, + 0.05449569970369339, + 0.0801396444439888, + 0.024155203253030777, + 0.09450001269578934, + 0.025758961215615273, + 0.4873327612876892, + 0.022662250325083733, + 0.04309801757335663 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31348586082458496 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tight close-up focused on a perfectly formed crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily tilt and pan downward while remaining locked in focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf gliding down a surface of dark gray traditional Chinese tiles covered in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible glistening drops of morning dew on the leaf that tremble slightly as it moves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a faint, out-of-focus outline of an ancient courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4743485450744629 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9743485450744629 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4743485450744629, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4743485450744629, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08265787363052368, + 0.10757139325141907, + 0.06154771149158478, + 0.06908105313777924, + 0.12985526025295258, + 0.06900504231452942, + 0.07874688506126404, + 0.1377965658903122, + 0.21696342527866364, + 0.046774815768003464 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4743485450744629 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "tight close-up tracking shot, the camera steadily tilting and panning downward, remains locked in focus on a perfectly formed crimson maple leaf. A deep crimson, its edges curling gently to a caramel-gold. The veins are visible in the soft, diffused morning light, and a few glistening drops of morning dew linger on the blade, trembling slightly as it moves. Gently and deliberately, it glides down the curve of neatly laid, weathered, dark gray traditional Chinese tiles, covered in a thin layer of emerald green moss that contrasts sharply with the crimson of the maple leaf. As it glides, the tip of the leaf occasionally scrapes against the rough moss, as if pausing briefly in the cracks between the tiles before gravity carries it on its graceful journey, leaving a barely perceptible trail of moisture in its wake. In the background, the outline of the ancient courtyard is faintly visible in the soft light, presenting a soft out-of-focus effect. The whole picture is full of the tranquility and wabi-sabi beauty of oriental Zen. The main colors are crimson, dark gray and emerald green. The atmosphere is quiet and contemplative, with a delicate perception of the passage of time and the beauty of nature.", + "seed": 26953, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_5/index_5948_seed_26953_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.15331432772800327, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15331432772800327, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15331432772800327, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tight close-up focused on a perfectly formed crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily tilt and pan downward while remaining locked in focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf gliding down a surface of dark gray traditional Chinese tiles covered in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible glistening drops of morning dew on the leaf that tremble slightly as it moves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a faint, out-of-focus outline of an ancient courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07190277427434921 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6969027519226074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07190277427434921, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07190277427434921, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0688738003373146, + 0.18135395646095276, + 0.3426198959350586, + 0.05468078702688217, + 0.030741574242711067, + 0.13075388967990875, + 0.0302666537463665, + 0.023141667246818542, + 0.03637182340025902, + 0.10119599103927612 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07190277427434921 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tight close-up focused on a perfectly formed crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily tilt and pan downward while remaining locked in focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf gliding down a surface of dark gray traditional Chinese tiles covered in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible glistening drops of morning dew on the leaf that tremble slightly as it moves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a faint, out-of-focus outline of an ancient courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048686910420656204 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048686981201172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048686910420656204, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048686910420656204, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.043473124504089355, + 0.19159676134586334, + 0.18079045414924622, + 0.06541281193494797, + 0.0390629917383194, + 0.07608910650014877, + 0.25985339283943176, + 0.04026544466614723, + 0.042677875608205795, + 0.06077798455953598 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048686910420656204 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tight close-up focused on a perfectly formed crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily tilt and pan downward while remaining locked in focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf gliding down a surface of dark gray traditional Chinese tiles covered in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible glistening drops of morning dew on the leaf that tremble slightly as it moves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a faint, out-of-focus outline of an ancient courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006742583122104406 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006742477416992 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006742583122104406, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006742583122104406, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.015372658148407936, + 0.03229265287518501, + 0.8247909545898438, + 0.012692402116954327, + 0.02457757480442524, + 0.017314044758677483, + 0.03502354025840759, + 0.007132770027965307, + 0.005992728751152754, + 0.024810686707496643 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006742583122104406 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tight close-up focused on a perfectly formed crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily tilt and pan downward while remaining locked in focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf gliding down a surface of dark gray traditional Chinese tiles covered in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible glistening drops of morning dew on the leaf that tremble slightly as it moves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a faint, out-of-focus outline of an ancient courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.252125084400177 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021250247955322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.252125084400177, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.252125084400177, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06485211849212646, + 0.11245431005954742, + 0.14597433805465698, + 0.14012351632118225, + 0.09607759118080139, + 0.12919539213180542, + 0.1481708139181137, + 0.03023647703230381, + 0.04646093398332596, + 0.08645450323820114 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.252125084400177 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a tight close-up focused on a perfectly formed crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily tilt and pan downward while remaining locked in focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf gliding down a surface of dark gray traditional Chinese tiles covered in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible glistening drops of morning dew on the leaf that tremble slightly as it moves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a faint, out-of-focus outline of an ancient courtyard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3871142864227295 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1371142864227295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3871142864227295, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3871142864227295, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05856256186962128, + 0.05051833763718605, + 0.3087564706802368, + 0.04064130410552025, + 0.027594199404120445, + 0.16056962311267853, + 0.05259024724364281, + 0.03880485147237778, + 0.20252613723278046, + 0.059436265379190445 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3871142864227295 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_6/index_tensor([3662, 3662])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_6/index_tensor([3662, 3662])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..57d8a3d10bf18ec0c99d2f6578e6b3d77efa8a94 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_6/index_tensor([3662, 3662])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In the captivating, vibrant aesthetic of Pixar Studios films, the camera executes a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit, sweeping across a breathtaking expanse of rolling hills carved into meticulously crafted tea plantations at dawn. The scene is rendered in exquisitely detailed stylization: the hills form soft, undulating terraces, covered in incredibly neat rows of lush, emerald-green tea bushes, their leaves boasting a soft, velvety texture. Delicate, intricate spiderwebs, swirling like fine silver threads, drape among the plants, their every surface adorned with countless perfectly spherical droplets of morning dew. These magical, shimmering gems capture the soft golden light of the rising sun, each droplet like a tiny, crystal-clear prism, shimmering and shimmering with a rainbow of colors. As the camera steadily rotates, this warm, honey-colored light pours over the landscape from a low angle, casting long, gentle, purple shadows and radiating a tranquil, magical energy throughout the garden, creating an atmosphere of pure wonder and serene beauty.", + "seed": 17666, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_6/index_3662_seed_17666_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.13940129652619362, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13940129652619362, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13940129652619362, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a landscape of rolling hills covered with tea plantations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the tea bushes depicted as lush, emerald-green with neat rows and soft, velvety leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are delicate spiderwebs visible among the plants, adorned with perfectly spherical droplets of morning dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, honey-colored light from a low angle casting long, gentle purple shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01855749823153019 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018557548522949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01855749823153019, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01855749823153019, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03873289376497269, + 0.0278211310505867, + 0.06044085696339607, + 0.020842408761382103, + 0.0050902902148664, + 0.010155754163861275, + 0.01451222412288189, + 0.6477617621421814, + 0.08136465400457382, + 0.09327805787324905 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01855749823153019 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a landscape of rolling hills covered with tea plantations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the tea bushes depicted as lush, emerald-green with neat rows and soft, velvety leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are delicate spiderwebs visible among the plants, adorned with perfectly spherical droplets of morning dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, honey-colored light from a low angle casting long, gentle purple shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02330601029098034 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773305892944336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02330601029098034, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02330601029098034, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08287986367940903, + 0.019626934081315994, + 0.042767301201820374, + 0.01517694815993309, + 0.005281450226902962, + 0.008530238643288612, + 0.009810399264097214, + 0.6882006525993347, + 0.05012721195816994, + 0.07759904861450195 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02330601029098034 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a landscape of rolling hills covered with tea plantations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the tea bushes depicted as lush, emerald-green with neat rows and soft, velvety leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are delicate spiderwebs visible among the plants, adorned with perfectly spherical droplets of morning dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, honey-colored light from a low angle casting long, gentle purple shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.142815962433815 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178160667419434 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.142815962433815, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.142815962433815, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.021351167932152748, + 0.012794079259037971, + 0.06497058272361755, + 0.01591244712471962, + 0.01666460558772087, + 0.0066686347126960754, + 0.018062451854348183, + 0.7850454449653625, + 0.029443249106407166, + 0.029087334871292114 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.142815962433815 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a landscape of rolling hills covered with tea plantations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the tea bushes depicted as lush, emerald-green with neat rows and soft, velvety leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are delicate spiderwebs visible among the plants, adorned with perfectly spherical droplets of morning dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, honey-colored light from a low angle casting long, gentle purple shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809374198317528 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880938053131104 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809374198317528, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809374198317528, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.026653634384274483, + 0.021212970837950706, + 0.052199672907590866, + 0.05764079466462135, + 0.025696078315377235, + 0.0053899637423455715, + 0.014944620430469513, + 0.5044413208961487, + 0.022647446021437645, + 0.2691734731197357 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809374198317528 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a landscape of rolling hills covered with tea plantations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the tea bushes depicted as lush, emerald-green with neat rows and soft, velvety leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are delicate spiderwebs visible among the plants, adorned with perfectly spherical droplets of morning dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, honey-colored light from a low angle casting long, gentle purple shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4742332696914673 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742332696914673 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4742332696914673, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4742332696914673, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.016613293439149857, + 0.005933311302214861, + 0.005594384856522083, + 0.0034333900548517704, + 0.0024088595528155565, + 0.0034751570783555508, + 0.007745198905467987, + 0.9336853623390198, + 0.008735337294638157, + 0.012375682592391968 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4742332696914673 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the captivating, vibrant aesthetic of Pixar Studios films, the camera executes a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit, sweeping across a breathtaking expanse of rolling hills carved into meticulously crafted tea plantations at dawn. The scene is rendered in exquisitely detailed stylization: the hills form soft, undulating terraces, covered in incredibly neat rows of lush, emerald-green tea bushes, their leaves boasting a soft, velvety texture. Delicate, intricate spiderwebs, swirling like fine silver threads, drape among the plants, their every surface adorned with countless perfectly spherical droplets of morning dew. These magical, shimmering gems capture the soft golden light of the rising sun, each droplet like a tiny, crystal-clear prism, shimmering and shimmering with a rainbow of colors. As the camera steadily rotates, this warm, honey-colored light pours over the landscape from a low angle, casting long, gentle, purple shadows and radiating a tranquil, magical energy throughout the garden, creating an atmosphere of pure wonder and serene beauty.", + "seed": 17667, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_6/index_3662_seed_17667_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.1809005609713495, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1809005609713495, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1809005609713495, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a landscape of rolling hills covered with tea plantations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the tea bushes depicted as lush, emerald-green with neat rows and soft, velvety leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are delicate spiderwebs visible among the plants, adorned with perfectly spherical droplets of morning dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, honey-colored light from a low angle casting long, gentle purple shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007119760848581791 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.007119655609131 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007119760848581791, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007119760848581791, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.211859330534935, + 0.11820437014102936, + 0.15426602959632874, + 0.04422949254512787, + 0.05634286627173424, + 0.11268985271453857, + 0.11087259650230408, + 0.07168460637331009, + 0.064761683344841, + 0.055089160799980164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007119760848581791 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a landscape of rolling hills covered with tea plantations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the tea bushes depicted as lush, emerald-green with neat rows and soft, velvety leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are delicate spiderwebs visible among the plants, adorned with perfectly spherical droplets of morning dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, honey-colored light from a low angle casting long, gentle purple shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007648232858628035 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882648468017578 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007648232858628035, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007648232858628035, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18202373385429382, + 0.17934675514698029, + 0.12151331454515457, + 0.024652380496263504, + 0.0632057711482048, + 0.12869662046432495, + 0.06940167397260666, + 0.05838170275092125, + 0.10902785509824753, + 0.06375022977590561 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007648232858628035 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a landscape of rolling hills covered with tea plantations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the tea bushes depicted as lush, emerald-green with neat rows and soft, velvety leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are delicate spiderwebs visible among the plants, adorned with perfectly spherical droplets of morning dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, honey-colored light from a low angle casting long, gentle purple shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496829003095627 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299683570861816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496829003095627, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496829003095627, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09266198426485062, + 0.1434166431427002, + 0.21923547983169556, + 0.024536257609725, + 0.047682326287031174, + 0.12115859240293503, + 0.08538856357336044, + 0.06116926670074463, + 0.14068669080734253, + 0.06406412273645401 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496829003095627 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a landscape of rolling hills covered with tea plantations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the tea bushes depicted as lush, emerald-green with neat rows and soft, velvety leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are delicate spiderwebs visible among the plants, adorned with perfectly spherical droplets of morning dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, honey-colored light from a low angle casting long, gentle purple shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008638276718556881 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758638381958008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008638276718556881, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008638276718556881, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11439845710992813, + 0.09200100600719452, + 0.3562847375869751, + 0.03936544805765152, + 0.10391184687614441, + 0.1133822426199913, + 0.05430270731449127, + 0.04345419630408287, + 0.04467007890343666, + 0.03822929412126541 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008638276718556881 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a landscape of rolling hills covered with tea plantations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the tea bushes depicted as lush, emerald-green with neat rows and soft, velvety leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are delicate spiderwebs visible among the plants, adorned with perfectly spherical droplets of morning dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, honey-colored light from a low angle casting long, gentle purple shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261282444000244 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761282444000244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8261282444000244, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8261282444000244, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.137207493185997, + 0.09052576124668121, + 0.09988033771514893, + 0.06654811650514603, + 0.06435514241456985, + 0.1580197513103485, + 0.14288747310638428, + 0.11921212077140808, + 0.03753051534295082, + 0.08383329212665558 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8261282444000244 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the captivating, vibrant aesthetic of Pixar Studios films, the camera executes a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit, sweeping across a breathtaking expanse of rolling hills carved into meticulously crafted tea plantations at dawn. The scene is rendered in exquisitely detailed stylization: the hills form soft, undulating terraces, covered in incredibly neat rows of lush, emerald-green tea bushes, their leaves boasting a soft, velvety texture. Delicate, intricate spiderwebs, swirling like fine silver threads, drape among the plants, their every surface adorned with countless perfectly spherical droplets of morning dew. These magical, shimmering gems capture the soft golden light of the rising sun, each droplet like a tiny, crystal-clear prism, shimmering and shimmering with a rainbow of colors. As the camera steadily rotates, this warm, honey-colored light pours over the landscape from a low angle, casting long, gentle, purple shadows and radiating a tranquil, magical energy throughout the garden, creating an atmosphere of pure wonder and serene beauty.", + "seed": 17668, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_6/index_3662_seed_17668_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11672433018684387, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11672433018684387, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11672433018684387, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a landscape of rolling hills covered with tea plantations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the tea bushes depicted as lush, emerald-green with neat rows and soft, velvety leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are delicate spiderwebs visible among the plants, adorned with perfectly spherical droplets of morning dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, honey-colored light from a low angle casting long, gentle purple shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038521453738212585 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2885215282440186 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038521453738212585, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038521453738212585, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22669804096221924, + 0.051425933837890625, + 0.15012778341770172, + 0.11350155621767044, + 0.050088413059711456, + 0.19445158541202545, + 0.05467364564538002, + 0.03473108261823654, + 0.08768648654222488, + 0.036615412682294846 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038521453738212585 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a landscape of rolling hills covered with tea plantations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the tea bushes depicted as lush, emerald-green with neat rows and soft, velvety leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are delicate spiderwebs visible among the plants, adorned with perfectly spherical droplets of morning dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, honey-colored light from a low angle casting long, gentle purple shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308817908167839 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.16808819770813 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308817908167839, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308817908167839, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12917020916938782, + 0.05855704843997955, + 0.10538042336702347, + 0.08104152232408524, + 0.08531195670366287, + 0.15674637258052826, + 0.18928377330303192, + 0.07044972479343414, + 0.09509001672267914, + 0.02896896004676819 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308817908167839 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a landscape of rolling hills covered with tea plantations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the tea bushes depicted as lush, emerald-green with neat rows and soft, velvety leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are delicate spiderwebs visible among the plants, adorned with perfectly spherical droplets of morning dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, honey-colored light from a low angle casting long, gentle purple shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205993518233299 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120598793029785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205993518233299, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205993518233299, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13507184386253357, + 0.05603715777397156, + 0.2783060371875763, + 0.051170721650123596, + 0.04164261743426323, + 0.1066274344921112, + 0.07922086119651794, + 0.07813408970832825, + 0.1194203644990921, + 0.054368868470191956 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205993518233299 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a landscape of rolling hills covered with tea plantations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the tea bushes depicted as lush, emerald-green with neat rows and soft, velvety leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are delicate spiderwebs visible among the plants, adorned with perfectly spherical droplets of morning dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, honey-colored light from a low angle casting long, gentle purple shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011075802147388458 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511075973510742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011075802147388458, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011075802147388458, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11239763349294662, + 0.048172350972890854, + 0.2364591509103775, + 0.13430701196193695, + 0.1343204826116562, + 0.07018458098173141, + 0.05415359511971474, + 0.035494979470968246, + 0.15354569256305695, + 0.020964564755558968 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011075802147388458 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a landscape of rolling hills covered with tea plantations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the tea bushes depicted as lush, emerald-green with neat rows and soft, velvety leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are delicate spiderwebs visible among the plants, adorned with perfectly spherical droplets of morning dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, honey-colored light from a low angle casting long, gentle purple shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42887628078460693 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.053876280784607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42887628078460693, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42887628078460693, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05377637967467308, + 0.029754865914583206, + 0.5275626182556152, + 0.07620738446712494, + 0.0642814040184021, + 0.03646067529916763, + 0.029302630573511124, + 0.07647917419672012, + 0.0746762603521347, + 0.03149859234690666 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42887628078460693 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the captivating, vibrant aesthetic of Pixar Studios films, the camera executes a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit, sweeping across a breathtaking expanse of rolling hills carved into meticulously crafted tea plantations at dawn. The scene is rendered in exquisitely detailed stylization: the hills form soft, undulating terraces, covered in incredibly neat rows of lush, emerald-green tea bushes, their leaves boasting a soft, velvety texture. Delicate, intricate spiderwebs, swirling like fine silver threads, drape among the plants, their every surface adorned with countless perfectly spherical droplets of morning dew. These magical, shimmering gems capture the soft golden light of the rising sun, each droplet like a tiny, crystal-clear prism, shimmering and shimmering with a rainbow of colors. As the camera steadily rotates, this warm, honey-colored light pours over the landscape from a low angle, casting long, gentle, purple shadows and radiating a tranquil, magical energy throughout the garden, creating an atmosphere of pure wonder and serene beauty.", + "seed": 17669, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_6/index_3662_seed_17669_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.233387559466064, + "vlm_logprob": -0.233387559466064, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7750000059604645, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.233387559466064, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a landscape of rolling hills covered with tea plantations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the tea bushes depicted as lush, emerald-green with neat rows and soft, velvety leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are delicate spiderwebs visible among the plants, adorned with perfectly spherical droplets of morning dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, honey-colored light from a low angle casting long, gentle purple shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007895332761108875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882895469665527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007895332761108875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007895332761108875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12086282670497894, + 0.12588804960250854, + 0.04628720134496689, + 0.07361123710870743, + 0.24297375977039337, + 0.03225161135196686, + 0.084818996489048, + 0.022696800529956818, + 0.13967612385749817, + 0.1109333261847496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007895332761108875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a landscape of rolling hills covered with tea plantations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the tea bushes depicted as lush, emerald-green with neat rows and soft, velvety leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are delicate spiderwebs visible among the plants, adorned with perfectly spherical droplets of morning dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, honey-colored light from a low angle casting long, gentle purple shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00980076752603054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634800910949707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00980076752603054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00980076752603054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2886718809604645, + 0.08972866088151932, + 0.052344683557748795, + 0.0833677127957344, + 0.08667141944169998, + 0.028697166591882706, + 0.06471842527389526, + 0.0348697267472744, + 0.0716625452041626, + 0.19926777482032776 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00980076752603054 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a landscape of rolling hills covered with tea plantations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the tea bushes depicted as lush, emerald-green with neat rows and soft, velvety leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are delicate spiderwebs visible among the plants, adorned with perfectly spherical droplets of morning dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, honey-colored light from a low angle casting long, gentle purple shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11295044422149658 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237950325012207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11295044422149658, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11295044422149658, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06674440950155258, + 0.055743928998708725, + 0.04525098204612732, + 0.0868634432554245, + 0.18756252527236938, + 0.042418014258146286, + 0.07921049743890762, + 0.02868570387363434, + 0.1510545313358307, + 0.2564660608768463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11295044422149658 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a landscape of rolling hills covered with tea plantations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the tea bushes depicted as lush, emerald-green with neat rows and soft, velvety leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are delicate spiderwebs visible among the plants, adorned with perfectly spherical droplets of morning dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, honey-colored light from a low angle casting long, gentle purple shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062042009085416794 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812041997909546 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062042009085416794, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062042009085416794, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16785070300102234, + 0.12595440447330475, + 0.05414348468184471, + 0.05060851573944092, + 0.039979055523872375, + 0.25159135460853577, + 0.06051214411854744, + 0.01311259251087904, + 0.1903538554906845, + 0.045893918722867966 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062042009085416794 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a landscape of rolling hills covered with tea plantations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the tea bushes depicted as lush, emerald-green with neat rows and soft, velvety leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are delicate spiderwebs visible among the plants, adorned with perfectly spherical droplets of morning dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature warm, honey-colored light from a low angle casting long, gentle purple shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful 360-degree orbit around the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742492437362671 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4742492735385895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9742492437362671, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.4999999701976776, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9742492437362671, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1348978877067566, + 0.08006643503904343, + 0.08837893605232239, + 0.1569485068321228, + 0.2467227578163147, + 0.050803039222955704, + 0.09053938090801239, + 0.01923449896275997, + 0.030723586678504944, + 0.10168489813804626 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9742492437362671 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_7/index_tensor([8301, 8301])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_7/index_tensor([8301, 8301])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9c379aa8ec5dea70eda36f602dbd673be892651d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_7/index_tensor([8301, 8301])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up, static shot taken from a horizontal angle focuses on an exquisite Chinese round fan, suspended in the center of the frame. The fan features a handle made of smooth ebony, a deep, mellow hue. The fan's surface is stretched from a layer of translucent white silk, with a neat edge. At its heart is a vibrant embroidery: a pair of iridescent kingfishers perched atop a blooming pink lotus. The embroidery is meticulously stitched, and the lustrous silk thread perfectly recreates the shimmering hues of the kingfisher's feathers, from royal blue to emerald green, and the gentle transition from pink to white of the lotus petals. A pure, soft, light gray background ensures that all visual attention is focused on the fan itself. The fan sways gently from right to left in a steady, deliberate rhythm. As the fan moves, the silk threads of the embroidery, illuminated by the bright, even, soft light, reflect a subtle, flowing luster, bringing the pattern to life. The entire picture is presented in a clean and neat digital art style, with clear lines and pure colors, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, elegance and artistic beauty.", + "seed": 4154, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_7/index_8301_seed_4154_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05671404656022787, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05671404656022787, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05671404656022787, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an exquisite Chinese round fan suspended in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fan feature a handle made of smooth ebony with a deep, mellow hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fan's surface made of translucent white silk with a neat edge, featuring embroidery of iridescent kingfishers on a pink lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, soft, light gray color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the fan sway gently from right to left in a steady, deliberate rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00638611102476716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1313862800598145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00638611102476716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00638611102476716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.056162670254707336, + 0.047392334789037704, + 0.05454692989587784, + 0.017784666270017624, + 0.05759088695049286, + 0.02114775776863098, + 0.0607621856033802, + 0.05575539916753769, + 0.11396850645542145, + 0.5148887038230896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00638611102476716 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an exquisite Chinese round fan suspended in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fan feature a handle made of smooth ebony with a deep, mellow hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fan's surface made of translucent white silk with a neat edge, featuring embroidery of iridescent kingfishers on a pink lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, soft, light gray color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the fan sway gently from right to left in a steady, deliberate rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900453358888626 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790045261383057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900453358888626, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900453358888626, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.009177225641906261, + 0.007231150288134813, + 0.006936332210898399, + 0.0030719719361513853, + 0.003912488929927349, + 0.002759116468951106, + 0.007746235001832247, + 0.04727683588862419, + 0.023056233301758766, + 0.8888323903083801 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900453358888626 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an exquisite Chinese round fan suspended in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fan feature a handle made of smooth ebony with a deep, mellow hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fan's surface made of translucent white silk with a neat edge, featuring embroidery of iridescent kingfishers on a pink lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, soft, light gray color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the fan sway gently from right to left in a steady, deliberate rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006746609229594469 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006746768951416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006746609229594469, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006746609229594469, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03123246505856514, + 0.011555859819054604, + 0.009627404622733593, + 0.010443885810673237, + 0.017992032691836357, + 0.003063187701627612, + 0.01417803019285202, + 0.046529147773981094, + 0.01445193774998188, + 0.8409261107444763 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006746609229594469 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an exquisite Chinese round fan suspended in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fan feature a handle made of smooth ebony with a deep, mellow hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fan's surface made of translucent white silk with a neat edge, featuring embroidery of iridescent kingfishers on a pink lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, soft, light gray color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the fan sway gently from right to left in a steady, deliberate rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04863479360938072 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486347675323486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04863479360938072, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04863479360938072, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.028075702488422394, + 0.03107031062245369, + 0.040844690054655075, + 0.030049625784158707, + 0.14407093822956085, + 0.007077944930642843, + 0.008788864128291607, + 0.09072477370500565, + 0.07485435903072357, + 0.5444427728652954 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04863479360938072 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an exquisite Chinese round fan suspended in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fan feature a handle made of smooth ebony with a deep, mellow hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fan's surface made of translucent white silk with a neat edge, featuring embroidery of iridescent kingfishers on a pink lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, soft, light gray color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the fan sway gently from right to left in a steady, deliberate rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14279818534851074 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0177981853485107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14279818534851074, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14279818534851074, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.024463780224323273, + 0.013155849650502205, + 0.0249153021723032, + 0.005643307231366634, + 0.007556005381047726, + 0.004804782569408417, + 0.02177397906780243, + 0.08326908200979233, + 0.01804494671523571, + 0.7963728904724121 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14279818534851074 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, static shot taken from a horizontal angle focuses on an exquisite Chinese round fan, suspended in the center of the frame. The fan features a handle made of smooth ebony, a deep, mellow hue. The fan's surface is stretched from a layer of translucent white silk, with a neat edge. At its heart is a vibrant embroidery: a pair of iridescent kingfishers perched atop a blooming pink lotus. The embroidery is meticulously stitched, and the lustrous silk thread perfectly recreates the shimmering hues of the kingfisher's feathers, from royal blue to emerald green, and the gentle transition from pink to white of the lotus petals. A pure, soft, light gray background ensures that all visual attention is focused on the fan itself. The fan sways gently from right to left in a steady, deliberate rhythm. As the fan moves, the silk threads of the embroidery, illuminated by the bright, even, soft light, reflect a subtle, flowing luster, bringing the pattern to life. The entire picture is presented in a clean and neat digital art style, with clear lines and pure colors, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, elegance and artistic beauty.", + "seed": 4155, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_7/index_8301_seed_4155_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.057175460876896976, + "vlm_logprob": -0.057175460876896976, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.649999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.057175460876896976, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an exquisite Chinese round fan suspended in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fan feature a handle made of smooth ebony with a deep, mellow hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fan's surface made of translucent white silk with a neat edge, featuring embroidery of iridescent kingfishers on a pink lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, soft, light gray color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the fan sway gently from right to left in a steady, deliberate rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003205758286640048 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8782057762146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003205758286640048, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003205758286640048, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5424503087997437, + 0.0377957746386528, + 0.1597764641046524, + 0.09845554828643799, + 0.015549383126199245, + 0.08784198760986328, + 0.008377520367503166, + 0.013673804700374603, + 0.010701866820454597, + 0.0253772996366024 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003205758286640048 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an exquisite Chinese round fan suspended in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fan feature a handle made of smooth ebony with a deep, mellow hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fan's surface made of translucent white silk with a neat edge, featuring embroidery of iridescent kingfishers on a pink lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, soft, light gray color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the fan sway gently from right to left in a steady, deliberate rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900475710630417 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790047645568848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900475710630417, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900475710630417, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3834103047847748, + 0.05330410599708557, + 0.25387611985206604, + 0.03948607295751572, + 0.03766108304262161, + 0.1087610125541687, + 0.014141867868602276, + 0.05073748156428337, + 0.008213051594793797, + 0.05040895193815231 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900475710630417 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an exquisite Chinese round fan suspended in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fan feature a handle made of smooth ebony with a deep, mellow hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fan's surface made of translucent white silk with a neat edge, featuring embroidery of iridescent kingfishers on a pink lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, soft, light gray color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the fan sway gently from right to left in a steady, deliberate rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005952843930572271 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130952835083008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005952843930572271, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005952843930572271, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5063828229904175, + 0.04280390590429306, + 0.20980559289455414, + 0.10814881324768066, + 0.014104046858847141, + 0.08444131165742874, + 0.0050481525249779224, + 0.014261377975344658, + 0.003934962674975395, + 0.01106908917427063 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005952843930572271 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an exquisite Chinese round fan suspended in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fan feature a handle made of smooth ebony with a deep, mellow hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fan's surface made of translucent white silk with a neat edge, featuring embroidery of iridescent kingfishers on a pink lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, soft, light gray color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the fan sway gently from right to left in a steady, deliberate rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05493353679776192 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929933547973633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05493353679776192, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05493353679776192, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3465043306350708, + 0.04020385444164276, + 0.292148232460022, + 0.09136512875556946, + 0.010800947435200214, + 0.147168830037117, + 0.00496719591319561, + 0.051509466022253036, + 0.0052392794750630856, + 0.010092672891914845 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05493353679776192 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an exquisite Chinese round fan suspended in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fan feature a handle made of smooth ebony with a deep, mellow hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fan's surface made of translucent white silk with a neat edge, featuring embroidery of iridescent kingfishers on a pink lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, soft, light gray color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the fan sway gently from right to left in a steady, deliberate rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14278040826320648 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017780303955078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14278040826320648, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14278040826320648, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5291949510574341, + 0.022834736853837967, + 0.11452044546604156, + 0.014948854222893715, + 0.008633037097752094, + 0.2800862491130829, + 0.003047158708795905, + 0.00875735655426979, + 0.0063125393353402615, + 0.01166472863405943 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14278040826320648 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, static shot taken from a horizontal angle focuses on an exquisite Chinese round fan, suspended in the center of the frame. The fan features a handle made of smooth ebony, a deep, mellow hue. The fan's surface is stretched from a layer of translucent white silk, with a neat edge. At its heart is a vibrant embroidery: a pair of iridescent kingfishers perched atop a blooming pink lotus. The embroidery is meticulously stitched, and the lustrous silk thread perfectly recreates the shimmering hues of the kingfisher's feathers, from royal blue to emerald green, and the gentle transition from pink to white of the lotus petals. A pure, soft, light gray background ensures that all visual attention is focused on the fan itself. The fan sways gently from right to left in a steady, deliberate rhythm. As the fan moves, the silk threads of the embroidery, illuminated by the bright, even, soft light, reflect a subtle, flowing luster, bringing the pattern to life. The entire picture is presented in a clean and neat digital art style, with clear lines and pure colors, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, elegance and artistic beauty.", + "seed": 4156, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_7/index_8301_seed_4156_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.09402482770383358, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09402482770383358, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3999999880790712, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09402482770383358, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an exquisite Chinese round fan suspended in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fan feature a handle made of smooth ebony with a deep, mellow hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fan's surface made of translucent white silk with a neat edge, featuring embroidery of iridescent kingfishers on a pink lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, soft, light gray color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the fan sway gently from right to left in a steady, deliberate rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0048477970995008945 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379848003387451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0048477970995008945, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0048477970995008945, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04931142181158066, + 0.006116501986980438, + 0.01613946631550789, + 0.7198997139930725, + 0.0054359445348382, + 0.006629928946495056, + 0.009375403635203838, + 0.008339110761880875, + 0.026963509619235992, + 0.15178906917572021 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0048477970995008945 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an exquisite Chinese round fan suspended in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fan feature a handle made of smooth ebony with a deep, mellow hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fan's surface made of translucent white silk with a neat edge, featuring embroidery of iridescent kingfishers on a pink lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, soft, light gray color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the fan sway gently from right to left in a steady, deliberate rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05497449263930321 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299745559692383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05497449263930321, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05497449263930321, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14625966548919678, + 0.027057264000177383, + 0.016963360831141472, + 0.38023069500923157, + 0.03428567945957184, + 0.011102124117314816, + 0.009269775822758675, + 0.006432770751416683, + 0.028409188613295555, + 0.3399895131587982 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05497449263930321 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an exquisite Chinese round fan suspended in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fan feature a handle made of smooth ebony with a deep, mellow hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fan's surface made of translucent white silk with a neat edge, featuring embroidery of iridescent kingfishers on a pink lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, soft, light gray color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the fan sway gently from right to left in a steady, deliberate rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006743411999195814 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006743431091309 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006743411999195814, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006743411999195814, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03638174384832382, + 0.01050427183508873, + 0.02530224435031414, + 0.40133410692214966, + 0.02340385876595974, + 0.008882968686521053, + 0.0110875079408288, + 0.007759194355458021, + 0.04532530531287193, + 0.4300188422203064 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006743411999195814 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an exquisite Chinese round fan suspended in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fan feature a handle made of smooth ebony with a deep, mellow hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fan's surface made of translucent white silk with a neat edge, featuring embroidery of iridescent kingfishers on a pink lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, soft, light gray color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the fan sway gently from right to left in a steady, deliberate rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05493533983826637 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299354553222656 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05493533983826637, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05493533983826637, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.01738600991666317, + 0.021253839135169983, + 0.0051194592379033566, + 0.6676260232925415, + 0.010598592460155487, + 0.0057814475148916245, + 0.008550171740353107, + 0.0059717437252402306, + 0.030204370617866516, + 0.2275083214044571 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05493533983826637 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an exquisite Chinese round fan suspended in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fan feature a handle made of smooth ebony with a deep, mellow hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fan's surface made of translucent white silk with a neat edge, featuring embroidery of iridescent kingfishers on a pink lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, soft, light gray color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the fan sway gently from right to left in a steady, deliberate rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486230969429016 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236230373382568 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486230969429016, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8749999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486230969429016, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.011294456198811531, + 0.029142260551452637, + 0.002351241186261177, + 0.7675458192825317, + 0.007486365735530853, + 0.008857017382979393, + 0.007350517902523279, + 0.009535751305520535, + 0.010407606139779091, + 0.14602896571159363 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486230969429016 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, static shot taken from a horizontal angle focuses on an exquisite Chinese round fan, suspended in the center of the frame. The fan features a handle made of smooth ebony, a deep, mellow hue. The fan's surface is stretched from a layer of translucent white silk, with a neat edge. At its heart is a vibrant embroidery: a pair of iridescent kingfishers perched atop a blooming pink lotus. The embroidery is meticulously stitched, and the lustrous silk thread perfectly recreates the shimmering hues of the kingfisher's feathers, from royal blue to emerald green, and the gentle transition from pink to white of the lotus petals. A pure, soft, light gray background ensures that all visual attention is focused on the fan itself. The fan sways gently from right to left in a steady, deliberate rhythm. As the fan moves, the silk threads of the embroidery, illuminated by the bright, even, soft light, reflect a subtle, flowing luster, bringing the pattern to life. The entire picture is presented in a clean and neat digital art style, with clear lines and pure colors, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, elegance and artistic beauty.", + "seed": 4157, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_7/index_8301_seed_4157_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07848284654319286, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07848284654319286, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07848284654319286, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an exquisite Chinese round fan suspended in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fan feature a handle made of smooth ebony with a deep, mellow hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fan's surface made of translucent white silk with a neat edge, featuring embroidery of iridescent kingfishers on a pink lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, soft, light gray color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the fan sway gently from right to left in a steady, deliberate rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.050343628972768784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0503435134887695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.050343628972768784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.050343628972768784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13817362487316132, + 0.07508163899183273, + 0.06445866078138351, + 0.1651335060596466, + 0.19839151203632355, + 0.06785938143730164, + 0.14450106024742126, + 0.08481324464082718, + 0.030120884999632835, + 0.03146648779511452 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.050343628972768784 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an exquisite Chinese round fan suspended in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fan feature a handle made of smooth ebony with a deep, mellow hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fan's surface made of translucent white silk with a neat edge, featuring embroidery of iridescent kingfishers on a pink lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, soft, light gray color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the fan sway gently from right to left in a steady, deliberate rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05498216673731804 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299821853637695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05498216673731804, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05498216673731804, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23294582962989807, + 0.03579855337738991, + 0.2072935253381729, + 0.07785200327634811, + 0.08971735835075378, + 0.0728708878159523, + 0.04887800291180611, + 0.09099887311458588, + 0.057675961405038834, + 0.0859689861536026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05498216673731804 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an exquisite Chinese round fan suspended in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fan feature a handle made of smooth ebony with a deep, mellow hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fan's surface made of translucent white silk with a neat edge, featuring embroidery of iridescent kingfishers on a pink lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, soft, light gray color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the fan sway gently from right to left in a steady, deliberate rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018199829384684563 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018199920654297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018199829384684563, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018199829384684563, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22090964019298553, + 0.1318078339099884, + 0.09919251501560211, + 0.07614791393280029, + 0.08469069004058838, + 0.059075623750686646, + 0.027881385758519173, + 0.1663586050271988, + 0.02511477842926979, + 0.10882100462913513 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018199829384684563 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an exquisite Chinese round fan suspended in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fan feature a handle made of smooth ebony with a deep, mellow hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fan's surface made of translucent white silk with a neat edge, featuring embroidery of iridescent kingfishers on a pink lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, soft, light gray color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the fan sway gently from right to left in a steady, deliberate rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08901339769363403 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640133380889893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08901339769363403, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08901339769363403, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26316067576408386, + 0.21677055954933167, + 0.08364080637693405, + 0.08237188309431076, + 0.08596977591514587, + 0.10466481745243073, + 0.042310141026973724, + 0.0549788698554039, + 0.022499246522784233, + 0.043633244931697845 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08901339769363403 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an exquisite Chinese round fan suspended in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fan feature a handle made of smooth ebony with a deep, mellow hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fan's surface made of translucent white silk with a neat edge, featuring embroidery of iridescent kingfishers on a pink lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, soft, light gray color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the fan sway gently from right to left in a steady, deliberate rhythm?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1798752099275589 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048752546310425 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1798752099275589, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1798752099275589, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23168440163135529, + 0.07967458665370941, + 0.05264034494757652, + 0.06914117932319641, + 0.0655541867017746, + 0.12019676715135574, + 0.12228607386350632, + 0.14806780219078064, + 0.047724924981594086, + 0.06302966177463531 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1798752099275589 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_8/index_tensor([7811, 7811])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_8/index_tensor([7811, 7811])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1619271d7e82b956ac2213c03ffae6d021bee832 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_8/index_tensor([7811, 7811])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot follows a man as he walks at a steady, determined pace down a long hospital corridor. The camera, pressed close to the ground, captures meticulous detail in his well-worn brown leather shoes, their surface showing the faint wear and creases of use. With each deliberate step, his dark gray wool trouser legs brush against the tops of his shoes. The floor is a highly polished light gray linoleum, reflecting long, unbroken lines from the harsh, cool fluorescent lights overhead. On either side of the corridor, the lower portions of doors are visible, through which a blur of activity unfolds: the white ruffles of a doctor's lab coat sweep out of a room, the legs of a nurse in blue scrubs rush by, the slowly moving wheels of a gurney or a patient's IV stand momentarily pass through the frame. This constant peripheral movement of medical staff and patients creates a vibrant, busy atmosphere that contrasts sharply with the unwavering forward momentum of the central subject's journey, imbuing the scene with a quiet urgency and a focused sense of purpose.", + "seed": 14299, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_8/index_7811_seed_14299_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.09119983687996865, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09119983687996865, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09119983687996865, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a man walking with a steady, determined pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the man's shoes brown leather with visible wear and creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the floor a highly polished light gray linoleum reflecting long lines from overhead lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of medical staff (e.g., doctor's lab coat, nurse in blue scrubs) and equipment (e.g., gurney) in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05224959924817085 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6772496700286865 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05224959924817085, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05224959924817085, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13924624025821686, + 0.2802847921848297, + 0.0635886937379837, + 0.12707862257957458, + 0.056777473539114, + 0.06791196018457413, + 0.04806128144264221, + 0.06703485548496246, + 0.10242611914873123, + 0.047589901834726334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05224959924817085 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a man walking with a steady, determined pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the man's shoes brown leather with visible wear and creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the floor a highly polished light gray linoleum reflecting long lines from overhead lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of medical staff (e.g., doctor's lab coat, nurse in blue scrubs) and equipment (e.g., gurney) in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17999859154224396 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049986362457275 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17999859154224396, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17999859154224396, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18836086988449097, + 0.1330607831478119, + 0.06940162181854248, + 0.06908056885004044, + 0.10898581892251968, + 0.05854538083076477, + 0.13292379677295685, + 0.10612504929304123, + 0.07907969504594803, + 0.054436393082141876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17999859154224396 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a man walking with a steady, determined pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the man's shoes brown leather with visible wear and creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the floor a highly polished light gray linoleum reflecting long lines from overhead lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of medical staff (e.g., doctor's lab coat, nurse in blue scrubs) and equipment (e.g., gurney) in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1130073070526123 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2380073070526123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1130073070526123, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1130073070526123, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.043897438794374466, + 0.044135723263025284, + 0.05758948624134064, + 0.09641910344362259, + 0.38263553380966187, + 0.0770820751786232, + 0.1355505734682083, + 0.07180973887443542, + 0.06380634009838104, + 0.027074050158262253 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1130073070526123 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a man walking with a steady, determined pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the man's shoes brown leather with visible wear and creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the floor a highly polished light gray linoleum reflecting long lines from overhead lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of medical staff (e.g., doctor's lab coat, nurse in blue scrubs) and equipment (e.g., gurney) in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867658019065857 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486764907836914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867658019065857, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867658019065857, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06924173980951309, + 0.6621065735816956, + 0.049921195954084396, + 0.02369573712348938, + 0.035459306091070175, + 0.047571662813425064, + 0.053699880838394165, + 0.012527232058346272, + 0.029232803732156754, + 0.016543909907341003 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867658019065857 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a man walking with a steady, determined pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the man's shoes brown leather with visible wear and creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the floor a highly polished light gray linoleum reflecting long lines from overhead lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of medical staff (e.g., doctor's lab coat, nurse in blue scrubs) and equipment (e.g., gurney) in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06206710636615753 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120670318603516 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06206710636615753, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06206710636615753, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32143864035606384, + 0.21516169607639313, + 0.09273340553045273, + 0.10313702374696732, + 0.034913793206214905, + 0.028079334646463394, + 0.061848416924476624, + 0.03853992000222206, + 0.053261738270521164, + 0.05088606849312782 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06206710636615753 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot follows a man as he walks at a steady, determined pace down a long hospital corridor. The camera, pressed close to the ground, captures meticulous detail in his well-worn brown leather shoes, their surface showing the faint wear and creases of use. With each deliberate step, his dark gray wool trouser legs brush against the tops of his shoes. The floor is a highly polished light gray linoleum, reflecting long, unbroken lines from the harsh, cool fluorescent lights overhead. On either side of the corridor, the lower portions of doors are visible, through which a blur of activity unfolds: the white ruffles of a doctor's lab coat sweep out of a room, the legs of a nurse in blue scrubs rush by, the slowly moving wheels of a gurney or a patient's IV stand momentarily pass through the frame. This constant peripheral movement of medical staff and patients creates a vibrant, busy atmosphere that contrasts sharply with the unwavering forward momentum of the central subject's journey, imbuing the scene with a quiet urgency and a focused sense of purpose.", + "seed": 14300, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_8/index_7811_seed_14300_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06796996369957924, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06796996369957924, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06796996369957924, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a man walking with a steady, determined pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the man's shoes brown leather with visible wear and creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the floor a highly polished light gray linoleum reflecting long lines from overhead lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of medical staff (e.g., doctor's lab coat, nurse in blue scrubs) and equipment (e.g., gurney) in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03597027063369751 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.660970211029053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03597027063369751, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03597027063369751, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19420112669467926, + 0.0495343878865242, + 0.1947714239358902, + 0.06445171684026718, + 0.059495989233255386, + 0.10331670939922333, + 0.12676092982292175, + 0.10050088167190552, + 0.031325530260801315, + 0.07564132660627365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03597027063369751 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a man walking with a steady, determined pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the man's shoes brown leather with visible wear and creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the floor a highly polished light gray linoleum reflecting long lines from overhead lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of medical staff (e.g., doctor's lab coat, nurse in blue scrubs) and equipment (e.g., gurney) in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14284178614616394 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178418159484863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14284178614616394, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14284178614616394, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2356535792350769, + 0.11534695327281952, + 0.15886437892913818, + 0.031133359298110008, + 0.07617807388305664, + 0.053096238523721695, + 0.12488631904125214, + 0.0746716856956482, + 0.06761488318443298, + 0.06255452334880829 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14284178614616394 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a man walking with a steady, determined pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the man's shoes brown leather with visible wear and creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the floor a highly polished light gray linoleum reflecting long lines from overhead lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of medical staff (e.g., doctor's lab coat, nurse in blue scrubs) and equipment (e.g., gurney) in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08908188343048096 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640817642211914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08908188343048096, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08908188343048096, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20675569772720337, + 0.036127954721450806, + 0.2807977795600891, + 0.060500890016555786, + 0.0356559120118618, + 0.11976682394742966, + 0.048259057104587555, + 0.03384023904800415, + 0.15284335613250732, + 0.025452354922890663 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08908188343048096 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a man walking with a steady, determined pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the man's shoes brown leather with visible wear and creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the floor a highly polished light gray linoleum reflecting long lines from overhead lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of medical staff (e.g., doctor's lab coat, nurse in blue scrubs) and equipment (e.g., gurney) in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866454377770424 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486645698547363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866454377770424, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866454377770424, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1043531745672226, + 0.08667264878749847, + 0.06494338810443878, + 0.0444585382938385, + 0.034228384494781494, + 0.14575998485088348, + 0.049231141805648804, + 0.22505038976669312, + 0.07882289588451385, + 0.16647949814796448 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866454377770424 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a man walking with a steady, determined pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the man's shoes brown leather with visible wear and creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the floor a highly polished light gray linoleum reflecting long lines from overhead lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of medical staff (e.g., doctor's lab coat, nurse in blue scrubs) and equipment (e.g., gurney) in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329133450984955 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732913494110107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329133450984955, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329133450984955, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.45253974199295044, + 0.026633145287632942, + 0.03759599104523659, + 0.03568131849169731, + 0.1486884206533432, + 0.07284710556268692, + 0.058095064014196396, + 0.027206318452954292, + 0.05465180054306984, + 0.08606110513210297 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329133450984955 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot follows a man as he walks at a steady, determined pace down a long hospital corridor. The camera, pressed close to the ground, captures meticulous detail in his well-worn brown leather shoes, their surface showing the faint wear and creases of use. With each deliberate step, his dark gray wool trouser legs brush against the tops of his shoes. The floor is a highly polished light gray linoleum, reflecting long, unbroken lines from the harsh, cool fluorescent lights overhead. On either side of the corridor, the lower portions of doors are visible, through which a blur of activity unfolds: the white ruffles of a doctor's lab coat sweep out of a room, the legs of a nurse in blue scrubs rush by, the slowly moving wheels of a gurney or a patient's IV stand momentarily pass through the frame. This constant peripheral movement of medical staff and patients creates a vibrant, busy atmosphere that contrasts sharply with the unwavering forward momentum of the central subject's journey, imbuing the scene with a quiet urgency and a focused sense of purpose.", + "seed": 14301, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_8/index_7811_seed_14301_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10121731087565422, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10121731087565422, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10121731087565422, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a man walking with a steady, determined pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the man's shoes brown leather with visible wear and creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the floor a highly polished light gray linoleum reflecting long lines from overhead lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of medical staff (e.g., doctor's lab coat, nurse in blue scrubs) and equipment (e.g., gurney) in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04660404473543167 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.9216041564941406 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04660404473543167, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04660404473543167, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18429961800575256, + 0.05714396387338638, + 0.04389497637748718, + 0.06270594894886017, + 0.06144309043884277, + 0.24205702543258667, + 0.23458370566368103, + 0.0666942298412323, + 0.025233494117856026, + 0.021943936124444008 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04660404473543167 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a man walking with a steady, determined pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the man's shoes brown leather with visible wear and creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the floor a highly polished light gray linoleum reflecting long lines from overhead lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of medical staff (e.g., doctor's lab coat, nurse in blue scrubs) and equipment (e.g., gurney) in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3487760126590729 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2237759828567505 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3487760126590729, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3487760126590729, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06091272085905075, + 0.03981208801269531, + 0.025480302050709724, + 0.030842727050185204, + 0.10089029371738434, + 0.5894572138786316, + 0.07042800635099411, + 0.04990764334797859, + 0.013437310233712196, + 0.018831690773367882 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3487760126590729 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a man walking with a steady, determined pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the man's shoes brown leather with visible wear and creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the floor a highly polished light gray linoleum reflecting long lines from overhead lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of medical staff (e.g., doctor's lab coat, nurse in blue scrubs) and equipment (e.g., gurney) in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020611034706234932 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895611047744751 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020611034706234932, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020611034706234932, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09100943058729172, + 0.17695870995521545, + 0.06725103408098221, + 0.0262733343988657, + 0.2578417956829071, + 0.07305785268545151, + 0.04871029779314995, + 0.07918082177639008, + 0.15476204454898834, + 0.024954713881015778 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020611034706234932 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a man walking with a steady, determined pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the man's shoes brown leather with visible wear and creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the floor a highly polished light gray linoleum reflecting long lines from overhead lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of medical staff (e.g., doctor's lab coat, nurse in blue scrubs) and equipment (e.g., gurney) in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011082993820309639 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511083126068115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011082993820309639, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011082993820309639, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0868777483701706, + 0.061400607228279114, + 0.028018219396471977, + 0.03567672520875931, + 0.1472530961036682, + 0.11080526560544968, + 0.0634230524301529, + 0.42690548300743103, + 0.021122070029377937, + 0.018517734482884407 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011082993820309639 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a man walking with a steady, determined pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the man's shoes brown leather with visible wear and creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the floor a highly polished light gray linoleum reflecting long lines from overhead lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of medical staff (e.g., doctor's lab coat, nurse in blue scrubs) and equipment (e.g., gurney) in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07901246845722198 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579012393951416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07901246845722198, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07901246845722198, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05336397513747215, + 0.03867302089929581, + 0.03324778378009796, + 0.024550221860408783, + 0.37603405117988586, + 0.33412569761276245, + 0.08167383074760437, + 0.038615770637989044, + 0.010654955171048641, + 0.00906066969037056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07901246845722198 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot follows a man as he walks at a steady, determined pace down a long hospital corridor. The camera, pressed close to the ground, captures meticulous detail in his well-worn brown leather shoes, their surface showing the faint wear and creases of use. With each deliberate step, his dark gray wool trouser legs brush against the tops of his shoes. The floor is a highly polished light gray linoleum, reflecting long, unbroken lines from the harsh, cool fluorescent lights overhead. On either side of the corridor, the lower portions of doors are visible, through which a blur of activity unfolds: the white ruffles of a doctor's lab coat sweep out of a room, the legs of a nurse in blue scrubs rush by, the slowly moving wheels of a gurney or a patient's IV stand momentarily pass through the frame. This constant peripheral movement of medical staff and patients creates a vibrant, busy atmosphere that contrasts sharply with the unwavering forward momentum of the central subject's journey, imbuing the scene with a quiet urgency and a focused sense of purpose.", + "seed": 14302, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_8/index_7811_seed_14302_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07637448981404305, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07637448981404305, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07637448981404305, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a man walking with a steady, determined pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the man's shoes brown leather with visible wear and creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the floor a highly polished light gray linoleum reflecting long lines from overhead lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of medical staff (e.g., doctor's lab coat, nurse in blue scrubs) and equipment (e.g., gurney) in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05034952238202095 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.425349712371826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05034952238202095, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05034952238202095, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11162787675857544, + 0.1791757345199585, + 0.1477419137954712, + 0.09155238419771194, + 0.04911617934703827, + 0.14190948009490967, + 0.0371989868581295, + 0.11967607587575912, + 0.06151587888598442, + 0.06048552319407463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05034952238202095 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a man walking with a steady, determined pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the man's shoes brown leather with visible wear and creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the floor a highly polished light gray linoleum reflecting long lines from overhead lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of medical staff (e.g., doctor's lab coat, nurse in blue scrubs) and equipment (e.g., gurney) in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20164039731025696 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016403675079346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20164039731025696, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20164039731025696, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0602288544178009, + 0.08258497714996338, + 0.2558659315109253, + 0.05995512753725052, + 0.1956954002380371, + 0.049024518579244614, + 0.06374547630548477, + 0.06324874609708786, + 0.13782665133476257, + 0.031824301928281784 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20164039731025696 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a man walking with a steady, determined pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the man's shoes brown leather with visible wear and creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the floor a highly polished light gray linoleum reflecting long lines from overhead lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of medical staff (e.g., doctor's lab coat, nurse in blue scrubs) and equipment (e.g., gurney) in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043104276061058044 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1681041717529297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043104276061058044, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043104276061058044, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10069311410188675, + 0.03175349161028862, + 0.6004810333251953, + 0.027100134640932083, + 0.04315515607595444, + 0.01625736802816391, + 0.11604228615760803, + 0.013030613772571087, + 0.024215009063482285, + 0.027271755039691925 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043104276061058044 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a man walking with a steady, determined pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the man's shoes brown leather with visible wear and creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the floor a highly polished light gray linoleum reflecting long lines from overhead lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of medical staff (e.g., doctor's lab coat, nurse in blue scrubs) and equipment (e.g., gurney) in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038113825023174286 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288113832473755 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038113825023174286, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038113825023174286, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.015736673027276993, + 0.2509211599826813, + 0.46937841176986694, + 0.01799280010163784, + 0.017280448228120804, + 0.03373241797089577, + 0.04981609061360359, + 0.10130450874567032, + 0.031698159873485565, + 0.012139345519244671 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038113825023174286 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a man walking with a steady, determined pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the man's shoes brown leather with visible wear and creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the floor a highly polished light gray linoleum reflecting long lines from overhead lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of medical staff (e.g., doctor's lab coat, nurse in blue scrubs) and equipment (e.g., gurney) in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866442829370499 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486643314361572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866442829370499, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866442829370499, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.053780537098646164, + 0.13013587892055511, + 0.2516031563282013, + 0.11348624527454376, + 0.10067236423492432, + 0.12713196873664856, + 0.03830432891845703, + 0.0663166418671608, + 0.0391836054623127, + 0.07938528060913086 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866442829370499 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_9/index_tensor([4860, 4860])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_9/index_tensor([4860, 4860])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c6e5f7d6e3fe93b18035eda1c061f6e7b9333916 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_9/index_tensor([4860, 4860])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a single, unbroken shot, the camera begins from a low angle, nestled against the surging sea, rising slowly as a mountain-like, deep indigo wave rises. As the camera passes over the crest of the wave, a majestic mirage ship suddenly bursts into view, struggling to conquer the crest. Immersed in the fantastical aesthetic of Hayao Miyazaki's animations, the vessel possesses a warm, hand-painted quality. Its hull, reminiscent of a patchwork of ancient temples and sky-high pavilions, boasts multi-tiered eaves and intricate wood carvings, and rows of paper lanterns shimmering in a soft orange glow hang from its sides. As the ship glides from crest to trough, it is momentarily enveloped by a haze of mist and white foam, rendered translucent and dreamlike by the crashing waves. Only the light from the lanterns flickers tenaciously through the mist, perfectly embodying the essence of a mirage. Then, as it rises again from the next wave, its solid form returns. The ocean roars and surges, its rolling waves imbued with the depth and depth of hand-drawn animation. The sky is a sea of dramatic, swirling clouds, a palette of deep purple and gray. A few rays of golden sunlight penetrate the clouds, casting dappled, dynamic light across the undulating sea and the wet decks of the ships, creating an epic atmosphere that is both majestic and tinged with melancholy.", + "seed": 32313, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_9/index_4860_seed_32313_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.009358636010438204, + "vlm_logprob": -0.009358636010438204, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.009358636010438204, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ocean with surging waves and a sky filled with deep purple and gray swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ship visible that features a hull resembling a patchwork of ancient temples with multi-tiered eaves and intricate wood carvings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of paper lanterns hanging from the ship's sides, glowing with a soft orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a hand-painted, fantastical aesthetic reminiscent of Hayao Miyazaki's animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin at a low angle near the sea and rise slowly to pass over the crest of a large wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009071681648492813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7590718269348145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009071681648492813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009071681648492813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1078234389424324, + 0.08974765986204147, + 0.1931225061416626, + 0.09435371309518814, + 0.08160847425460815, + 0.1206715777516365, + 0.029633600264787674, + 0.04163811355829239, + 0.19786939024925232, + 0.043531544506549835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009071681648492813 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ocean with surging waves and a sky filled with deep purple and gray swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ship visible that features a hull resembling a patchwork of ancient temples with multi-tiered eaves and intricate wood carvings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of paper lanterns hanging from the ship's sides, glowing with a soft orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a hand-painted, fantastical aesthetic reminiscent of Hayao Miyazaki's animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin at a low angle near the sea and rise slowly to pass over the crest of a large wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022050845436751842 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127204895019531 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022050845436751842, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022050845436751842, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08032942563295364, + 0.054481957107782364, + 0.08354571461677551, + 0.03019770234823227, + 0.028825733810663223, + 0.09304733574390411, + 0.04274482652544975, + 0.02598874270915985, + 0.4760287404060364, + 0.08480985462665558 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022050845436751842 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ocean with surging waves and a sky filled with deep purple and gray swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ship visible that features a hull resembling a patchwork of ancient temples with multi-tiered eaves and intricate wood carvings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of paper lanterns hanging from the ship's sides, glowing with a soft orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a hand-painted, fantastical aesthetic reminiscent of Hayao Miyazaki's animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin at a low angle near the sea and rise slowly to pass over the crest of a large wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607704907655716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141077041625977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607704907655716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607704907655716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07848720997571945, + 0.030679084360599518, + 0.04168356955051422, + 0.07550409436225891, + 0.05011266469955444, + 0.060323409736156464, + 0.07084205746650696, + 0.053956370800733566, + 0.09624133259057999, + 0.44217029213905334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607704907655716 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ocean with surging waves and a sky filled with deep purple and gray swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ship visible that features a hull resembling a patchwork of ancient temples with multi-tiered eaves and intricate wood carvings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of paper lanterns hanging from the ship's sides, glowing with a soft orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a hand-painted, fantastical aesthetic reminiscent of Hayao Miyazaki's animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin at a low angle near the sea and rise slowly to pass over the crest of a large wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00525664072483778 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255256652832031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00525664072483778, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00525664072483778, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07078962028026581, + 0.0629110261797905, + 0.07923413813114166, + 0.06552799046039581, + 0.08780909329652786, + 0.09138517826795578, + 0.08976729214191437, + 0.04456835612654686, + 0.19384799897670746, + 0.21415935456752777 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00525664072483778 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ocean with surging waves and a sky filled with deep purple and gray swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ship visible that features a hull resembling a patchwork of ancient temples with multi-tiered eaves and intricate wood carvings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of paper lanterns hanging from the ship's sides, glowing with a soft orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a hand-painted, fantastical aesthetic reminiscent of Hayao Miyazaki's animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin at a low angle near the sea and rise slowly to pass over the crest of a large wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014182724058628082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2641825675964355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014182724058628082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014182724058628082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0965663492679596, + 0.09997809678316116, + 0.1012863963842392, + 0.07240034639835358, + 0.09037983417510986, + 0.09210199117660522, + 0.05306102707982063, + 0.1501716524362564, + 0.14804479479789734, + 0.0960095077753067 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014182724058628082 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a single, unbroken shot, the camera begins from a low angle, nestled against the surging sea, rising slowly as a mountain-like, deep indigo wave rises. As the camera passes over the crest of the wave, a majestic mirage ship suddenly bursts into view, struggling to conquer the crest. Immersed in the fantastical aesthetic of Hayao Miyazaki's animations, the vessel possesses a warm, hand-painted quality. Its hull, reminiscent of a patchwork of ancient temples and sky-high pavilions, boasts multi-tiered eaves and intricate wood carvings, and rows of paper lanterns shimmering in a soft orange glow hang from its sides. As the ship glides from crest to trough, it is momentarily enveloped by a haze of mist and white foam, rendered translucent and dreamlike by the crashing waves. Only the light from the lanterns flickers tenaciously through the mist, perfectly embodying the essence of a mirage. Then, as it rises again from the next wave, its solid form returns. The ocean roars and surges, its rolling waves imbued with the depth and depth of hand-drawn animation. The sky is a sea of dramatic, swirling clouds, a palette of deep purple and gray. A few rays of golden sunlight penetrate the clouds, casting dappled, dynamic light across the undulating sea and the wet decks of the ships, creating an epic atmosphere that is both majestic and tinged with melancholy.", + "seed": 32314, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_9/index_4860_seed_32314_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.011257116682827473, + "vlm_logprob": -0.011257116682827473, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.011257116682827473, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ocean with surging waves and a sky filled with deep purple and gray swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ship visible that features a hull resembling a patchwork of ancient temples with multi-tiered eaves and intricate wood carvings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of paper lanterns hanging from the ship's sides, glowing with a soft orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a hand-painted, fantastical aesthetic reminiscent of Hayao Miyazaki's animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin at a low angle near the sea and rise slowly to pass over the crest of a large wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006437635514885187 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1314377784729 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006437635514885187, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006437635514885187, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11026281863451004, + 0.1253213733434677, + 0.10769897699356079, + 0.11000102758407593, + 0.18657587468624115, + 0.061167966574430466, + 0.1249719113111496, + 0.03442344814538956, + 0.08753421902656555, + 0.05204232409596443 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006437635514885187 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ocean with surging waves and a sky filled with deep purple and gray swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ship visible that features a hull resembling a patchwork of ancient temples with multi-tiered eaves and intricate wood carvings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of paper lanterns hanging from the ship's sides, glowing with a soft orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a hand-painted, fantastical aesthetic reminiscent of Hayao Miyazaki's animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin at a low angle near the sea and rise slowly to pass over the crest of a large wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003197915619239211 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753198146820068 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003197915619239211, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003197915619239211, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07661856710910797, + 0.03308240696787834, + 0.033198654651641846, + 0.04309460148215294, + 0.029446952044963837, + 0.04816253483295441, + 0.411155104637146, + 0.11514025926589966, + 0.10543894022703171, + 0.10466191172599792 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003197915619239211 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ocean with surging waves and a sky filled with deep purple and gray swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ship visible that features a hull resembling a patchwork of ancient temples with multi-tiered eaves and intricate wood carvings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of paper lanterns hanging from the ship's sides, glowing with a soft orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a hand-painted, fantastical aesthetic reminiscent of Hayao Miyazaki's animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin at a low angle near the sea and rise slowly to pass over the crest of a large wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978341419249773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347832679748535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978341419249773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978341419249773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07247631996870041, + 0.02773042395710945, + 0.028768135234713554, + 0.06911945343017578, + 0.08256492763757706, + 0.05768711119890213, + 0.0415678434073925, + 0.07129084318876266, + 0.23961779475212097, + 0.3091771602630615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978341419249773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ocean with surging waves and a sky filled with deep purple and gray swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ship visible that features a hull resembling a patchwork of ancient temples with multi-tiered eaves and intricate wood carvings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of paper lanterns hanging from the ship's sides, glowing with a soft orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a hand-painted, fantastical aesthetic reminiscent of Hayao Miyazaki's animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin at a low angle near the sea and rise slowly to pass over the crest of a large wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003193875541910529 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531938552856445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003193875541910529, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003193875541910529, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26538869738578796, + 0.07263205945491791, + 0.07525265961885452, + 0.06773259490728378, + 0.06708455085754395, + 0.06289730966091156, + 0.1618688851594925, + 0.0634046420454979, + 0.07707519829273224, + 0.0866633802652359 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003193875541910529 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ocean with surging waves and a sky filled with deep purple and gray swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ship visible that features a hull resembling a patchwork of ancient temples with multi-tiered eaves and intricate wood carvings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of paper lanterns hanging from the ship's sides, glowing with a soft orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a hand-painted, fantastical aesthetic reminiscent of Hayao Miyazaki's animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin at a low angle near the sea and rise slowly to pass over the crest of a large wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033672742545604706 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.40867280960083 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033672742545604706, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033672742545604706, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15012474358081818, + 0.06791668385267258, + 0.09509735554456711, + 0.07949262112379074, + 0.07703981548547745, + 0.0845823734998703, + 0.2165447622537613, + 0.059883732348680496, + 0.10611569881439209, + 0.06320220232009888 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033672742545604706 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a single, unbroken shot, the camera begins from a low angle, nestled against the surging sea, rising slowly as a mountain-like, deep indigo wave rises. As the camera passes over the crest of the wave, a majestic mirage ship suddenly bursts into view, struggling to conquer the crest. Immersed in the fantastical aesthetic of Hayao Miyazaki's animations, the vessel possesses a warm, hand-painted quality. Its hull, reminiscent of a patchwork of ancient temples and sky-high pavilions, boasts multi-tiered eaves and intricate wood carvings, and rows of paper lanterns shimmering in a soft orange glow hang from its sides. As the ship glides from crest to trough, it is momentarily enveloped by a haze of mist and white foam, rendered translucent and dreamlike by the crashing waves. Only the light from the lanterns flickers tenaciously through the mist, perfectly embodying the essence of a mirage. Then, as it rises again from the next wave, its solid form returns. The ocean roars and surges, its rolling waves imbued with the depth and depth of hand-drawn animation. The sky is a sea of dramatic, swirling clouds, a palette of deep purple and gray. A few rays of golden sunlight penetrate the clouds, casting dappled, dynamic light across the undulating sea and the wet decks of the ships, creating an epic atmosphere that is both majestic and tinged with melancholy.", + "seed": 32315, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_9/index_4860_seed_32315_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.007149932370521128, + "vlm_logprob": -0.007149932370521128, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.007149932370521128, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ocean with surging waves and a sky filled with deep purple and gray swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ship visible that features a hull resembling a patchwork of ancient temples with multi-tiered eaves and intricate wood carvings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of paper lanterns hanging from the ship's sides, glowing with a soft orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a hand-painted, fantastical aesthetic reminiscent of Hayao Miyazaki's animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin at a low angle near the sea and rise slowly to pass over the crest of a large wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005514765623956919 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255514621734619 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005514765623956919, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005514765623956919, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04262472316622734, + 0.5194067358970642, + 0.2154041975736618, + 0.04190588742494583, + 0.0646153911948204, + 0.0177264753729105, + 0.04010164365172386, + 0.010477351024746895, + 0.017250852659344673, + 0.030486807227134705 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005514765623956919 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ocean with surging waves and a sky filled with deep purple and gray swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ship visible that features a hull resembling a patchwork of ancient temples with multi-tiered eaves and intricate wood carvings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of paper lanterns hanging from the ship's sides, glowing with a soft orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a hand-painted, fantastical aesthetic reminiscent of Hayao Miyazaki's animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin at a low angle near the sea and rise slowly to pass over the crest of a large wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002203062642365694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127202987670898 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002203062642365694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002203062642365694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03744887560606003, + 0.27856209874153137, + 0.32661736011505127, + 0.030800582841038704, + 0.07336895912885666, + 0.017920926213264465, + 0.04453256353735924, + 0.03296273946762085, + 0.03915838897228241, + 0.11862746626138687 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002203062642365694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ocean with surging waves and a sky filled with deep purple and gray swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ship visible that features a hull resembling a patchwork of ancient temples with multi-tiered eaves and intricate wood carvings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of paper lanterns hanging from the ship's sides, glowing with a soft orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a hand-painted, fantastical aesthetic reminiscent of Hayao Miyazaki's animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin at a low angle near the sea and rise slowly to pass over the crest of a large wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028208012226969004 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.87782096862793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028208012226969004, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028208012226969004, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03842078149318695, + 0.4887755215167999, + 0.06708142906427383, + 0.017980072647333145, + 0.03294738382101059, + 0.025437846779823303, + 0.019194580614566803, + 0.051255811005830765, + 0.050331395119428635, + 0.20857514441013336 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028208012226969004 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ocean with surging waves and a sky filled with deep purple and gray swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ship visible that features a hull resembling a patchwork of ancient temples with multi-tiered eaves and intricate wood carvings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of paper lanterns hanging from the ship's sides, glowing with a soft orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a hand-painted, fantastical aesthetic reminiscent of Hayao Miyazaki's animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin at a low angle near the sea and rise slowly to pass over the crest of a large wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001942058908753097 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251942157745361 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001942058908753097, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001942058908753097, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05832565203309059, + 0.36076614260673523, + 0.12341684848070145, + 0.030146319419145584, + 0.11373943090438843, + 0.017830509692430496, + 0.16502350568771362, + 0.03256066516041756, + 0.04233534634113312, + 0.05585556849837303 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001942058908753097 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ocean with surging waves and a sky filled with deep purple and gray swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ship visible that features a hull resembling a patchwork of ancient temples with multi-tiered eaves and intricate wood carvings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of paper lanterns hanging from the ship's sides, glowing with a soft orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a hand-painted, fantastical aesthetic reminiscent of Hayao Miyazaki's animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin at a low angle near the sea and rise slowly to pass over the crest of a large wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02326897345483303 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773268938064575 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02326897345483303, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02326897345483303, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10330622643232346, + 0.3706286549568176, + 0.3327089250087738, + 0.02667943947017193, + 0.051266301423311234, + 0.020167328417301178, + 0.02374517172574997, + 0.01955651491880417, + 0.010270937345921993, + 0.041670504957437515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02326897345483303 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a single, unbroken shot, the camera begins from a low angle, nestled against the surging sea, rising slowly as a mountain-like, deep indigo wave rises. As the camera passes over the crest of the wave, a majestic mirage ship suddenly bursts into view, struggling to conquer the crest. Immersed in the fantastical aesthetic of Hayao Miyazaki's animations, the vessel possesses a warm, hand-painted quality. Its hull, reminiscent of a patchwork of ancient temples and sky-high pavilions, boasts multi-tiered eaves and intricate wood carvings, and rows of paper lanterns shimmering in a soft orange glow hang from its sides. As the ship glides from crest to trough, it is momentarily enveloped by a haze of mist and white foam, rendered translucent and dreamlike by the crashing waves. Only the light from the lanterns flickers tenaciously through the mist, perfectly embodying the essence of a mirage. Then, as it rises again from the next wave, its solid form returns. The ocean roars and surges, its rolling waves imbued with the depth and depth of hand-drawn animation. The sky is a sea of dramatic, swirling clouds, a palette of deep purple and gray. A few rays of golden sunlight penetrate the clouds, casting dappled, dynamic light across the undulating sea and the wet decks of the ships, creating an epic atmosphere that is both majestic and tinged with melancholy.", + "seed": 32316, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000047/group_9/index_4860_seed_32316_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.012532811565324663, + "vlm_logprob": -0.012532811565324663, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.012532811565324663, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ocean with surging waves and a sky filled with deep purple and gray swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ship visible that features a hull resembling a patchwork of ancient temples with multi-tiered eaves and intricate wood carvings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of paper lanterns hanging from the ship's sides, glowing with a soft orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a hand-painted, fantastical aesthetic reminiscent of Hayao Miyazaki's animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin at a low angle near the sea and rise slowly to pass over the crest of a large wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007923717610538006 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882923603057861 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007923717610538006, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007923717610538006, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1254376471042633, + 0.061350636184215546, + 0.066900834441185, + 0.17351408302783966, + 0.21964631974697113, + 0.04687725380063057, + 0.20285196602344513, + 0.05568557605147362, + 0.025803634896874428, + 0.021932052448391914 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007923717610538006 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ocean with surging waves and a sky filled with deep purple and gray swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ship visible that features a hull resembling a patchwork of ancient temples with multi-tiered eaves and intricate wood carvings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of paper lanterns hanging from the ship's sides, glowing with a soft orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a hand-painted, fantastical aesthetic reminiscent of Hayao Miyazaki's animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin at a low angle near the sea and rise slowly to pass over the crest of a large wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001515550771728158 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.5015153884887695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001515550771728158, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001515550771728158, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10651563107967377, + 0.05046435445547104, + 0.06464263051748276, + 0.13047540187835693, + 0.059044238179922104, + 0.10543829947710037, + 0.18175087869167328, + 0.239975705742836, + 0.03125675022602081, + 0.030436119064688683 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001515550771728158 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ocean with surging waves and a sky filled with deep purple and gray swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ship visible that features a hull resembling a patchwork of ancient temples with multi-tiered eaves and intricate wood carvings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of paper lanterns hanging from the ship's sides, glowing with a soft orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a hand-painted, fantastical aesthetic reminiscent of Hayao Miyazaki's animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin at a low angle near the sea and rise slowly to pass over the crest of a large wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819327473640442 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018193244934082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819327473640442, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819327473640442, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04914182052016258, + 0.02947269380092621, + 0.08014923334121704, + 0.11465766280889511, + 0.09336382895708084, + 0.10853029787540436, + 0.2040407806634903, + 0.0959019884467125, + 0.19979847967624664, + 0.024943236261606216 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819327473640442 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ocean with surging waves and a sky filled with deep purple and gray swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ship visible that features a hull resembling a patchwork of ancient temples with multi-tiered eaves and intricate wood carvings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of paper lanterns hanging from the ship's sides, glowing with a soft orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a hand-painted, fantastical aesthetic reminiscent of Hayao Miyazaki's animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin at a low angle near the sea and rise slowly to pass over the crest of a large wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052535575814545155 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255253791809082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052535575814545155, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052535575814545155, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17505775392055511, + 0.09162380546331406, + 0.09731233865022659, + 0.16743357479572296, + 0.11919406056404114, + 0.07484182715415955, + 0.05677901953458786, + 0.06829284876585007, + 0.056436844170093536, + 0.09302787482738495 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052535575814545155 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ocean with surging waves and a sky filled with deep purple and gray swirling clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a ship visible that features a hull resembling a patchwork of ancient temples with multi-tiered eaves and intricate wood carvings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are rows of paper lanterns hanging from the ship's sides, glowing with a soft orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a hand-painted, fantastical aesthetic reminiscent of Hayao Miyazaki's animations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin at a low angle near the sea and rise slowly to pass over the crest of a large wave?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029777957126498222 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529778003692627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029777957126498222, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029777957126498222, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24387666583061218, + 0.13549698889255524, + 0.09821520000696182, + 0.09646675735712051, + 0.08245568722486496, + 0.038979653269052505, + 0.12439057976007462, + 0.0964449867606163, + 0.0582728311419487, + 0.025400694459676743 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029777957126498222 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_0/index_tensor([2964, 2964])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_0/index_tensor([2964, 2964])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..54e666a3897493ce951318badea7b1e8e6c6fbe2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_0/index_tensor([2964, 2964])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "shot begins from an overhead angle, then slowly tilts upward and zooms out to reveal a magnificent, ethereal fantasy. At the edge of a swirling sea of golden and purple clouds, a mountain-sized mother-of-pearl oyster slowly and majestically opens. Its shell, etched with ancient, flowing runes, reflects a rainbow of colors under the soft, celestial light. As the shell opens, a soft, milky glow pours from within. Then, in stunning slow motion and ethereal particle effects, countless pearls imbued with pure spiritual energy gracefully emerge from the shell's core. Each pearl, like a translucent glass orb, shimmers with a tranquil blue glow and trails a delicate trail of shimmering light. With an otherworldly rhythm, they trace a perfect spiral through the air, then, with unerring precision, they self-align and coalesce, building step by step into a softly luminous, suspended staircase leading deep into the endless sea of clouds. The entire scene is imbued with a sacred, tranquil, and awe-inspiring atmosphere.", + "seed": 16199, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_0/index_2964_seed_16199_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04789082547649741, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04789082547649741, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04789082547649741, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an overhead camera angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward and zoom out to reveal a mountain-sized mother-of-pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the oyster shell etched with ancient, flowing runes and reflecting a rainbow of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do translucent blue pearls emerge from the shell in slow motion, tracing a spiral and coalescing into a suspended staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at the edge of a swirling sea of golden and purple clouds with ethereal particle effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08008081465959549 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.58008074760437 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08008081465959549, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08008081465959549, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11394274979829788, + 0.08175232261419296, + 0.05076317861676216, + 0.18954968452453613, + 0.186013862490654, + 0.05116703733801842, + 0.07337670028209686, + 0.12715469300746918, + 0.08491154760122299, + 0.041368238627910614 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08008081465959549 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an overhead camera angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward and zoom out to reveal a mountain-sized mother-of-pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the oyster shell etched with ancient, flowing runes and reflecting a rainbow of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do translucent blue pearls emerge from the shell in slow motion, tracing a spiral and coalescing into a suspended staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at the edge of a swirling sea of golden and purple clouds with ethereal particle effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11294054239988327 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237940549850464 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11294054239988327, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11294054239988327, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07165412604808807, + 0.037560511380434036, + 0.08564324676990509, + 0.15305772423744202, + 0.18240956962108612, + 0.09261393547058105, + 0.0787600502371788, + 0.13573522865772247, + 0.068189337849617, + 0.09437629580497742 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11294054239988327 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an overhead camera angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward and zoom out to reveal a mountain-sized mother-of-pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the oyster shell etched with ancient, flowing runes and reflecting a rainbow of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do translucent blue pearls emerge from the shell in slow motion, tracing a spiral and coalescing into a suspended staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at the edge of a swirling sea of golden and purple clouds with ethereal particle effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370893374085426 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087090492248535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370893374085426, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370893374085426, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11256145685911179, + 0.08207128196954727, + 0.1674102544784546, + 0.1603691279888153, + 0.10374581813812256, + 0.10456462949514389, + 0.05250002071261406, + 0.07114514708518982, + 0.09130904823541641, + 0.054323215037584305 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370893374085426 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an overhead camera angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward and zoom out to reveal a mountain-sized mother-of-pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the oyster shell etched with ancient, flowing runes and reflecting a rainbow of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do translucent blue pearls emerge from the shell in slow motion, tracing a spiral and coalescing into a suspended staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at the edge of a swirling sea of golden and purple clouds with ethereal particle effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040924143977463245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504092216491699 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040924143977463245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040924143977463245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0873318463563919, + 0.04257674515247345, + 0.1411847174167633, + 0.05393272638320923, + 0.07053060829639435, + 0.06619478762149811, + 0.16165398061275482, + 0.1390036940574646, + 0.11277920752763748, + 0.12481173127889633 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040924143977463245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an overhead camera angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward and zoom out to reveal a mountain-sized mother-of-pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the oyster shell etched with ancient, flowing runes and reflecting a rainbow of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do translucent blue pearls emerge from the shell in slow motion, tracing a spiral and coalescing into a suspended staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at the edge of a swirling sea of golden and purple clouds with ethereal particle effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008631422184407711 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758631229400635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008631422184407711, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008631422184407711, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12175046652555466, + 0.1061052680015564, + 0.03704723343253136, + 0.12666749954223633, + 0.08290078490972519, + 0.1354520469903946, + 0.07079187035560608, + 0.16326497495174408, + 0.06957101076841354, + 0.0864487960934639 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008631422184407711 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shot begins from an overhead angle, then slowly tilts upward and zooms out to reveal a magnificent, ethereal fantasy. At the edge of a swirling sea of golden and purple clouds, a mountain-sized mother-of-pearl oyster slowly and majestically opens. Its shell, etched with ancient, flowing runes, reflects a rainbow of colors under the soft, celestial light. As the shell opens, a soft, milky glow pours from within. Then, in stunning slow motion and ethereal particle effects, countless pearls imbued with pure spiritual energy gracefully emerge from the shell's core. Each pearl, like a translucent glass orb, shimmers with a tranquil blue glow and trails a delicate trail of shimmering light. With an otherworldly rhythm, they trace a perfect spiral through the air, then, with unerring precision, they self-align and coalesce, building step by step into a softly luminous, suspended staircase leading deep into the endless sea of clouds. The entire scene is imbued with a sacred, tranquil, and awe-inspiring atmosphere.", + "seed": 16200, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_0/index_2964_seed_16200_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.018272033403627576, + "vlm_logprob": -0.018272033403627576, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.649999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.018272033403627576, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an overhead camera angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward and zoom out to reveal a mountain-sized mother-of-pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the oyster shell etched with ancient, flowing runes and reflecting a rainbow of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do translucent blue pearls emerge from the shell in slow motion, tracing a spiral and coalescing into a suspended staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at the edge of a swirling sea of golden and purple clouds with ethereal particle effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05594664067029953 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9309465885162354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05594664067029953, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05594664067029953, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1776733547449112, + 0.03946487605571747, + 0.1719343662261963, + 0.06986482441425323, + 0.3653574287891388, + 0.05145394057035446, + 0.031736452132463455, + 0.02047099731862545, + 0.035435449331998825, + 0.03660832345485687 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05594664067029953 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an overhead camera angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward and zoom out to reveal a mountain-sized mother-of-pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the oyster shell etched with ancient, flowing runes and reflecting a rainbow of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do translucent blue pearls emerge from the shell in slow motion, tracing a spiral and coalescing into a suspended staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at the edge of a swirling sea of golden and purple clouds with ethereal particle effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01108358334749937 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511083602905273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01108358334749937, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01108358334749937, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11843378096818924, + 0.020096054300665855, + 0.1959231197834015, + 0.026883559301495552, + 0.3166996240615845, + 0.1291721910238266, + 0.040919166058301926, + 0.027880163863301277, + 0.0631340891122818, + 0.06085827946662903 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01108358334749937 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an overhead camera angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward and zoom out to reveal a mountain-sized mother-of-pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the oyster shell etched with ancient, flowing runes and reflecting a rainbow of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do translucent blue pearls emerge from the shell in slow motion, tracing a spiral and coalescing into a suspended staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at the edge of a swirling sea of golden and purple clouds with ethereal particle effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018188124522566795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187999725342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018188124522566795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018188124522566795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19684578478336334, + 0.028476305305957794, + 0.1500440388917923, + 0.04494459554553032, + 0.14503008127212524, + 0.2771076560020447, + 0.0371093787252903, + 0.015958307310938835, + 0.05319011211395264, + 0.0512937568128109 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018188124522566795 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an overhead camera angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward and zoom out to reveal a mountain-sized mother-of-pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the oyster shell etched with ancient, flowing runes and reflecting a rainbow of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do translucent blue pearls emerge from the shell in slow motion, tracing a spiral and coalescing into a suspended staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at the edge of a swirling sea of golden and purple clouds with ethereal particle effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015099564334377646 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501510143280029 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015099564334377646, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015099564334377646, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2041594535112381, + 0.03032197803258896, + 0.08126239478588104, + 0.03630777820944786, + 0.2810988128185272, + 0.09825769811868668, + 0.04393837973475456, + 0.026191677898168564, + 0.10704125463962555, + 0.09142062067985535 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015099564334377646 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an overhead camera angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward and zoom out to reveal a mountain-sized mother-of-pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the oyster shell etched with ancient, flowing runes and reflecting a rainbow of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do translucent blue pearls emerge from the shell in slow motion, tracing a spiral and coalescing into a suspended staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at the edge of a swirling sea of golden and purple clouds with ethereal particle effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004631862044334412 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379631996154785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004631862044334412, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004631862044334412, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12387117743492126, + 0.016247672960162163, + 0.042462173849344254, + 0.038052476942539215, + 0.21594741940498352, + 0.3848632574081421, + 0.04919471964240074, + 0.01895759627223015, + 0.012593290768563747, + 0.09781023859977722 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004631862044334412 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shot begins from an overhead angle, then slowly tilts upward and zooms out to reveal a magnificent, ethereal fantasy. At the edge of a swirling sea of golden and purple clouds, a mountain-sized mother-of-pearl oyster slowly and majestically opens. Its shell, etched with ancient, flowing runes, reflects a rainbow of colors under the soft, celestial light. As the shell opens, a soft, milky glow pours from within. Then, in stunning slow motion and ethereal particle effects, countless pearls imbued with pure spiritual energy gracefully emerge from the shell's core. Each pearl, like a translucent glass orb, shimmers with a tranquil blue glow and trails a delicate trail of shimmering light. With an otherworldly rhythm, they trace a perfect spiral through the air, then, with unerring precision, they self-align and coalesce, building step by step into a softly luminous, suspended staircase leading deep into the endless sea of clouds. The entire scene is imbued with a sacred, tranquil, and awe-inspiring atmosphere.", + "seed": 16201, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_0/index_2964_seed_16201_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03218805529177189, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03218805529177189, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03218805529177189, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an overhead camera angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward and zoom out to reveal a mountain-sized mother-of-pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the oyster shell etched with ancient, flowing runes and reflecting a rainbow of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do translucent blue pearls emerge from the shell in slow motion, tracing a spiral and coalescing into a suspended staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at the edge of a swirling sea of golden and purple clouds with ethereal particle effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.044733211398124695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1697332859039307 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.044733211398124695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.044733211398124695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15359798073768616, + 0.07795751839876175, + 0.16729798913002014, + 0.03506264090538025, + 0.06036074459552765, + 0.04491131752729416, + 0.08335239440202713, + 0.06915788352489471, + 0.22143146395683289, + 0.08687010407447815 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.044733211398124695 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an overhead camera angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward and zoom out to reveal a mountain-sized mother-of-pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the oyster shell etched with ancient, flowing runes and reflecting a rainbow of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do translucent blue pearls emerge from the shell in slow motion, tracing a spiral and coalescing into a suspended staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at the edge of a swirling sea of golden and purple clouds with ethereal particle effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007640779484063387 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882640838623047 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007640779484063387, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007640779484063387, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09991539269685745, + 0.1091293916106224, + 0.04859469085931778, + 0.043289829045534134, + 0.1793738156557083, + 0.042644623667001724, + 0.06763046234846115, + 0.23338228464126587, + 0.08899149298667908, + 0.08704793453216553 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007640779484063387 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an overhead camera angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward and zoom out to reveal a mountain-sized mother-of-pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the oyster shell etched with ancient, flowing runes and reflecting a rainbow of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do translucent blue pearls emerge from the shell in slow motion, tracing a spiral and coalescing into a suspended staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at the edge of a swirling sea of golden and purple clouds with ethereal particle effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10032045841217041 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350320339202881 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10032045841217041, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10032045841217041, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10519328713417053, + 0.07330188900232315, + 0.13574054837226868, + 0.05664408206939697, + 0.1217900812625885, + 0.12384617328643799, + 0.08451279997825623, + 0.12156171351671219, + 0.10476923733949661, + 0.07264023274183273 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10032045841217041 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an overhead camera angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward and zoom out to reveal a mountain-sized mother-of-pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the oyster shell etched with ancient, flowing runes and reflecting a rainbow of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do translucent blue pearls emerge from the shell in slow motion, tracing a spiral and coalescing into a suspended staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at the edge of a swirling sea of golden and purple clouds with ethereal particle effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004633641801774502 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.37963342666626 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004633641801774502, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004633641801774502, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03396831825375557, + 0.033170174807310104, + 0.09823087602853775, + 0.04916222020983696, + 0.15347059071063995, + 0.02297113835811615, + 0.025710202753543854, + 0.06089170649647713, + 0.037264395505189896, + 0.4851604104042053 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004633641801774502 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an overhead camera angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward and zoom out to reveal a mountain-sized mother-of-pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the oyster shell etched with ancient, flowing runes and reflecting a rainbow of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do translucent blue pearls emerge from the shell in slow motion, tracing a spiral and coalescing into a suspended staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at the edge of a swirling sea of golden and purple clouds with ethereal particle effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00361218536272645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628612041473389 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00361218536272645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00361218536272645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06909540295600891, + 0.04565929248929024, + 0.13026706874370575, + 0.07875719666481018, + 0.052318375557661057, + 0.03588811308145523, + 0.02171213924884796, + 0.09427748620510101, + 0.08829495310783386, + 0.3837299048900604 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00361218536272645 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shot begins from an overhead angle, then slowly tilts upward and zooms out to reveal a magnificent, ethereal fantasy. At the edge of a swirling sea of golden and purple clouds, a mountain-sized mother-of-pearl oyster slowly and majestically opens. Its shell, etched with ancient, flowing runes, reflects a rainbow of colors under the soft, celestial light. As the shell opens, a soft, milky glow pours from within. Then, in stunning slow motion and ethereal particle effects, countless pearls imbued with pure spiritual energy gracefully emerge from the shell's core. Each pearl, like a translucent glass orb, shimmers with a tranquil blue glow and trails a delicate trail of shimmering light. With an otherworldly rhythm, they trace a perfect spiral through the air, then, with unerring precision, they self-align and coalesce, building step by step into a softly luminous, suspended staircase leading deep into the endless sea of clouds. The entire scene is imbued with a sacred, tranquil, and awe-inspiring atmosphere.", + "seed": 16202, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_0/index_2964_seed_16202_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.021754514938220382, + "vlm_logprob": -0.021754514938220382, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.021754514938220382, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an overhead camera angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward and zoom out to reveal a mountain-sized mother-of-pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the oyster shell etched with ancient, flowing runes and reflecting a rainbow of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do translucent blue pearls emerge from the shell in slow motion, tracing a spiral and coalescing into a suspended staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at the edge of a swirling sea of golden and purple clouds with ethereal particle effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03899621590971947 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2889962196350098 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03899621590971947, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03899621590971947, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1964365690946579, + 0.12391524761915207, + 0.09917370229959488, + 0.06507432460784912, + 0.043328188359737396, + 0.09188011288642883, + 0.08157642185688019, + 0.11966405063867569, + 0.13608811795711517, + 0.04286323860287666 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03899621590971947 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an overhead camera angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward and zoom out to reveal a mountain-sized mother-of-pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the oyster shell etched with ancient, flowing runes and reflecting a rainbow of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do translucent blue pearls emerge from the shell in slow motion, tracing a spiral and coalescing into a suspended staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at the edge of a swirling sea of golden and purple clouds with ethereal particle effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028267446905374527 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877826690673828 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028267446905374527, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028267446905374527, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09049557894468307, + 0.04113132879137993, + 0.1176789402961731, + 0.08112169057130814, + 0.13503655791282654, + 0.08285360038280487, + 0.061651553958654404, + 0.21126413345336914, + 0.09511753916740417, + 0.08364912122488022 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028267446905374527 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an overhead camera angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward and zoom out to reveal a mountain-sized mother-of-pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the oyster shell etched with ancient, flowing runes and reflecting a rainbow of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do translucent blue pearls emerge from the shell in slow motion, tracing a spiral and coalescing into a suspended staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at the edge of a swirling sea of golden and purple clouds with ethereal particle effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496196821331978 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929961919784546 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496196821331978, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496196821331978, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15517663955688477, + 0.10817371308803558, + 0.08817584812641144, + 0.07803895324468613, + 0.20382171869277954, + 0.03993610292673111, + 0.07683047652244568, + 0.03952129930257797, + 0.16298559308052063, + 0.047339729964733124 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496196821331978 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an overhead camera angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward and zoom out to reveal a mountain-sized mother-of-pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the oyster shell etched with ancient, flowing runes and reflecting a rainbow of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do translucent blue pearls emerge from the shell in slow motion, tracing a spiral and coalescing into a suspended staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at the edge of a swirling sea of golden and purple clouds with ethereal particle effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.000918681500479579 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.000918865203857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.000918681500479579, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.000918681500479579, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07380622625350952, + 0.02826479822397232, + 0.07114062458276749, + 0.06973639130592346, + 0.03887094557285309, + 0.037601299583911896, + 0.06410949677228928, + 0.12987108528614044, + 0.43683144450187683, + 0.0497676283121109 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.000918681500479579 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an overhead camera angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt upward and zoom out to reveal a mountain-sized mother-of-pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the oyster shell etched with ancient, flowing runes and reflecting a rainbow of colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do translucent blue pearls emerge from the shell in slow motion, tracing a spiral and coalescing into a suspended staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at the edge of a swirling sea of golden and purple clouds with ethereal particle effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011068964377045631 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511068820953369 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011068964377045631, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011068964377045631, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2245302051305771, + 0.0270558912307024, + 0.11089111119508743, + 0.09287334233522415, + 0.10627450793981552, + 0.05889797955751419, + 0.1031121090054512, + 0.07577522099018097, + 0.12542065978050232, + 0.07516898959875107 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011068964377045631 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_1/index_tensor([7451, 7451])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_1/index_tensor([7451, 7451])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ce3c2d152446fa7732b95d90d5ac7212dc7dc94e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_1/index_tensor([7451, 7451])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, slightly elevated wide-angle shot captures a panoramic coastal scene bathed in the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun. A classic, weathered fishing boat, its white hull and blue trim showing signs of age, with peeling paint and rust stains, glides steadily and purposefully across the frame from left to right. It slices through the calm, deep blue water, leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam trailing behind it, disrupting the otherwise glassy surface. The boat maintains a consistent course, approaching a long rock breakwater constructed of large, dark, moss-colored boulders. At its end stands a traditional lighthouse with a white cylindrical tower and a red lantern room. Against the static backdrop, a picturesque coastal town nestles at the foot of rolling green hills, its buildings a mix of whitewashed and terracotta-roofed. The low-hanging sun casts long, soft shadows and shimmering light across the water, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and majesty. The boat's deliberate movement is the only dynamic element in the serene and beautiful scenery.", + "seed": 5360, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_1/index_7451_seed_5360_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08319052038714289, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08319052038714289, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08319052038714289, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly elevated wide-angle view of a coastal scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a classic, weathered fishing boat with a white hull, blue trim, peeling paint, and rust stains visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat glide steadily from left to right, slicing through deep blue water and leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long rock breakwater made of large, dark, moss-colored boulders visible with a traditional lighthouse (white cylindrical tower, red lantern room) at its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a picturesque coastal town with whitewashed buildings and terracotta roofs nestled at the foot of rolling green hills in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012595979496836662 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.637596130371094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012595979496836662, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012595979496836662, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.49185338616371155, + 0.06436557322740555, + 0.035068389028310776, + 0.020388919860124588, + 0.03865354135632515, + 0.041858598589897156, + 0.02407318539917469, + 0.07700902968645096, + 0.03895377740263939, + 0.16777560114860535 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012595979496836662 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly elevated wide-angle view of a coastal scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a classic, weathered fishing boat with a white hull, blue trim, peeling paint, and rust stains visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat glide steadily from left to right, slicing through deep blue water and leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long rock breakwater made of large, dark, moss-colored boulders visible with a traditional lighthouse (white cylindrical tower, red lantern room) at its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a picturesque coastal town with whitewashed buildings and terracotta roofs nestled at the foot of rolling green hills in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018222656100988388 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018222808837891 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018222656100988388, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018222656100988388, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5418278574943542, + 0.028705894947052002, + 0.03582634776830673, + 0.041909266263246536, + 0.02816295251250267, + 0.03548310697078705, + 0.04146672412753105, + 0.05490872636437416, + 0.02569560706615448, + 0.16601353883743286 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018222656100988388 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly elevated wide-angle view of a coastal scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a classic, weathered fishing boat with a white hull, blue trim, peeling paint, and rust stains visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat glide steadily from left to right, slicing through deep blue water and leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long rock breakwater made of large, dark, moss-colored boulders visible with a traditional lighthouse (white cylindrical tower, red lantern room) at its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a picturesque coastal town with whitewashed buildings and terracotta roofs nestled at the foot of rolling green hills in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34863269329071045 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236326932907104 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34863269329071045, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34863269329071045, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.45216938853263855, + 0.055370498448610306, + 0.027214832603931427, + 0.04697325453162193, + 0.05299655348062515, + 0.06117921322584152, + 0.014603729359805584, + 0.057785604149103165, + 0.025013655424118042, + 0.20669323205947876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34863269329071045 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly elevated wide-angle view of a coastal scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a classic, weathered fishing boat with a white hull, blue trim, peeling paint, and rust stains visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat glide steadily from left to right, slicing through deep blue water and leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long rock breakwater made of large, dark, moss-colored boulders visible with a traditional lighthouse (white cylindrical tower, red lantern room) at its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a picturesque coastal town with whitewashed buildings and terracotta roofs nestled at the foot of rolling green hills in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002821038942784071 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.87782096862793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002821038942784071, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002821038942784071, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23839125037193298, + 0.060539714992046356, + 0.06667730957269669, + 0.0503804087638855, + 0.04109947383403778, + 0.12559066712856293, + 0.06016220524907112, + 0.11890494078397751, + 0.021958163008093834, + 0.21629580855369568 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002821038942784071 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly elevated wide-angle view of a coastal scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a classic, weathered fishing boat with a white hull, blue trim, peeling paint, and rust stains visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat glide steadily from left to right, slicing through deep blue water and leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long rock breakwater made of large, dark, moss-colored boulders visible with a traditional lighthouse (white cylindrical tower, red lantern room) at its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a picturesque coastal town with whitewashed buildings and terracotta roofs nestled at the foot of rolling green hills in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368023410439491 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086802005767822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368023410439491, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368023410439491, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2835955023765564, + 0.06466059386730194, + 0.07432910054922104, + 0.05326465144753456, + 0.03845507279038429, + 0.08673050254583359, + 0.035867735743522644, + 0.03648682311177254, + 0.02816130593419075, + 0.29844874143600464 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368023410439491 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly elevated wide-angle shot captures a panoramic coastal scene bathed in the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun. A classic, weathered fishing boat, its white hull and blue trim showing signs of age, with peeling paint and rust stains, glides steadily and purposefully across the frame from left to right. It slices through the calm, deep blue water, leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam trailing behind it, disrupting the otherwise glassy surface. The boat maintains a consistent course, approaching a long rock breakwater constructed of large, dark, moss-colored boulders. At its end stands a traditional lighthouse with a white cylindrical tower and a red lantern room. Against the static backdrop, a picturesque coastal town nestles at the foot of rolling green hills, its buildings a mix of whitewashed and terracotta-roofed. The low-hanging sun casts long, soft shadows and shimmering light across the water, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and majesty. The boat's deliberate movement is the only dynamic element in the serene and beautiful scenery.", + "seed": 5361, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_1/index_7451_seed_5361_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04190986566245556, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04190986566245556, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04190986566245556, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly elevated wide-angle view of a coastal scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a classic, weathered fishing boat with a white hull, blue trim, peeling paint, and rust stains visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat glide steadily from left to right, slicing through deep blue water and leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long rock breakwater made of large, dark, moss-colored boulders visible with a traditional lighthouse (white cylindrical tower, red lantern room) at its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a picturesque coastal town with whitewashed buildings and terracotta roofs nestled at the foot of rolling green hills in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006763541139662266 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.256763458251953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006763541139662266, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006763541139662266, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14241258800029755, + 0.15084928274154663, + 0.03755298629403114, + 0.05550944060087204, + 0.2109953761100769, + 0.08641351759433746, + 0.036580342799425125, + 0.027289092540740967, + 0.21528500318527222, + 0.03711237758398056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006763541139662266 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly elevated wide-angle view of a coastal scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a classic, weathered fishing boat with a white hull, blue trim, peeling paint, and rust stains visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat glide steadily from left to right, slicing through deep blue water and leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long rock breakwater made of large, dark, moss-colored boulders visible with a traditional lighthouse (white cylindrical tower, red lantern room) at its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a picturesque coastal town with whitewashed buildings and terracotta roofs nestled at the foot of rolling green hills in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014228325337171555 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264228343963623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014228325337171555, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014228325337171555, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16018466651439667, + 0.15713158249855042, + 0.037722453474998474, + 0.0387042798101902, + 0.21465080976486206, + 0.0627104714512825, + 0.04684099182486534, + 0.032170530408620834, + 0.20674622058868408, + 0.04313797876238823 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014228325337171555 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly elevated wide-angle view of a coastal scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a classic, weathered fishing boat with a white hull, blue trim, peeling paint, and rust stains visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat glide steadily from left to right, slicing through deep blue water and leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long rock breakwater made of large, dark, moss-colored boulders visible with a traditional lighthouse (white cylindrical tower, red lantern room) at its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a picturesque coastal town with whitewashed buildings and terracotta roofs nestled at the foot of rolling green hills in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16036079823970795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103608131408691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16036079823970795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16036079823970795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1631731390953064, + 0.21416634321212769, + 0.04065271466970444, + 0.05170860141515732, + 0.06567759066820145, + 0.1803201287984848, + 0.04127209633588791, + 0.048062290996313095, + 0.14818833768367767, + 0.04677877202630043 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16036079823970795 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly elevated wide-angle view of a coastal scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a classic, weathered fishing boat with a white hull, blue trim, peeling paint, and rust stains visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat glide steadily from left to right, slicing through deep blue water and leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long rock breakwater made of large, dark, moss-colored boulders visible with a traditional lighthouse (white cylindrical tower, red lantern room) at its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a picturesque coastal town with whitewashed buildings and terracotta roofs nestled at the foot of rolling green hills in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007629304192960262 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88262939453125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007629304192960262, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007629304192960262, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11802668124437332, + 0.07716525346040726, + 0.03727676719427109, + 0.10660355538129807, + 0.07800883799791336, + 0.29313385486602783, + 0.03744364529848099, + 0.021953385323286057, + 0.16437260806560516, + 0.06601548939943314 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007629304192960262 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly elevated wide-angle view of a coastal scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a classic, weathered fishing boat with a white hull, blue trim, peeling paint, and rust stains visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat glide steadily from left to right, slicing through deep blue water and leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long rock breakwater made of large, dark, moss-colored boulders visible with a traditional lighthouse (white cylindrical tower, red lantern room) at its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a picturesque coastal town with whitewashed buildings and terracotta roofs nestled at the foot of rolling green hills in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020567359402775764 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955674171447754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020567359402775764, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020567359402775764, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19226644933223724, + 0.1405765861272812, + 0.030742492526769638, + 0.11604081094264984, + 0.04745975881814957, + 0.11565732210874557, + 0.04714033007621765, + 0.04344680905342102, + 0.15222303569316864, + 0.11444638669490814 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020567359402775764 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly elevated wide-angle shot captures a panoramic coastal scene bathed in the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun. A classic, weathered fishing boat, its white hull and blue trim showing signs of age, with peeling paint and rust stains, glides steadily and purposefully across the frame from left to right. It slices through the calm, deep blue water, leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam trailing behind it, disrupting the otherwise glassy surface. The boat maintains a consistent course, approaching a long rock breakwater constructed of large, dark, moss-colored boulders. At its end stands a traditional lighthouse with a white cylindrical tower and a red lantern room. Against the static backdrop, a picturesque coastal town nestles at the foot of rolling green hills, its buildings a mix of whitewashed and terracotta-roofed. The low-hanging sun casts long, soft shadows and shimmering light across the water, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and majesty. The boat's deliberate movement is the only dynamic element in the serene and beautiful scenery.", + "seed": 5362, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_1/index_7451_seed_5362_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.01940089985728264, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01940089985728264, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01940089985728264, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly elevated wide-angle view of a coastal scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a classic, weathered fishing boat with a white hull, blue trim, peeling paint, and rust stains visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat glide steadily from left to right, slicing through deep blue water and leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long rock breakwater made of large, dark, moss-colored boulders visible with a traditional lighthouse (white cylindrical tower, red lantern room) at its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a picturesque coastal town with whitewashed buildings and terracotta roofs nestled at the foot of rolling green hills in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006428159773349762 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.256428241729736 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006428159773349762, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006428159773349762, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.509625256061554, + 0.058635562658309937, + 0.035209134221076965, + 0.056290410459041595, + 0.052814122289419174, + 0.12312625348567963, + 0.044329289346933365, + 0.018312746658921242, + 0.03744085505604744, + 0.06421635299921036 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006428159773349762 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly elevated wide-angle view of a coastal scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a classic, weathered fishing boat with a white hull, blue trim, peeling paint, and rust stains visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat glide steadily from left to right, slicing through deep blue water and leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long rock breakwater made of large, dark, moss-colored boulders visible with a traditional lighthouse (white cylindrical tower, red lantern room) at its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a picturesque coastal town with whitewashed buildings and terracotta roofs nestled at the foot of rolling green hills in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00980407278984785 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6348042488098145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00980407278984785, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00980407278984785, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30049100518226624, + 0.07934407889842987, + 0.03797071427106857, + 0.055561959743499756, + 0.07358817011117935, + 0.051236603409051895, + 0.07405971735715866, + 0.1110357791185379, + 0.080467589199543, + 0.13624434173107147 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00980407278984785 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly elevated wide-angle view of a coastal scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a classic, weathered fishing boat with a white hull, blue trim, peeling paint, and rust stains visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat glide steadily from left to right, slicing through deep blue water and leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long rock breakwater made of large, dark, moss-colored boulders visible with a traditional lighthouse (white cylindrical tower, red lantern room) at its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a picturesque coastal town with whitewashed buildings and terracotta roofs nestled at the foot of rolling green hills in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054957229644060135 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929957151412964 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054957229644060135, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054957229644060135, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.38053375482559204, + 0.05160262808203697, + 0.04105674475431442, + 0.047713153064250946, + 0.054989494383335114, + 0.05642448738217354, + 0.16691389679908752, + 0.07324838638305664, + 0.0765947550535202, + 0.050922758877277374 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054957229644060135 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly elevated wide-angle view of a coastal scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a classic, weathered fishing boat with a white hull, blue trim, peeling paint, and rust stains visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat glide steadily from left to right, slicing through deep blue water and leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long rock breakwater made of large, dark, moss-colored boulders visible with a traditional lighthouse (white cylindrical tower, red lantern room) at its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a picturesque coastal town with whitewashed buildings and terracotta roofs nestled at the foot of rolling green hills in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00525094848126173 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255250930786133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00525094848126173, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00525094848126173, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34145599603652954, + 0.21571099758148193, + 0.024996178224682808, + 0.07045648247003555, + 0.11260253190994263, + 0.043854545801877975, + 0.03582753986120224, + 0.05767512694001198, + 0.033777203410863876, + 0.06364347785711288 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00525094848126173 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly elevated wide-angle view of a coastal scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a classic, weathered fishing boat with a white hull, blue trim, peeling paint, and rust stains visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat glide steadily from left to right, slicing through deep blue water and leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long rock breakwater made of large, dark, moss-colored boulders visible with a traditional lighthouse (white cylindrical tower, red lantern room) at its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a picturesque coastal town with whitewashed buildings and terracotta roofs nestled at the foot of rolling green hills in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020564088597893715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895564079284668 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020564088597893715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020564088597893715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23487117886543274, + 0.09271319955587387, + 0.04017418250441551, + 0.05302248150110245, + 0.2502868175506592, + 0.037493690848350525, + 0.04133398085832596, + 0.09635407477617264, + 0.043341681361198425, + 0.11040864139795303 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020564088597893715 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly elevated wide-angle shot captures a panoramic coastal scene bathed in the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun. A classic, weathered fishing boat, its white hull and blue trim showing signs of age, with peeling paint and rust stains, glides steadily and purposefully across the frame from left to right. It slices through the calm, deep blue water, leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam trailing behind it, disrupting the otherwise glassy surface. The boat maintains a consistent course, approaching a long rock breakwater constructed of large, dark, moss-colored boulders. At its end stands a traditional lighthouse with a white cylindrical tower and a red lantern room. Against the static backdrop, a picturesque coastal town nestles at the foot of rolling green hills, its buildings a mix of whitewashed and terracotta-roofed. The low-hanging sun casts long, soft shadows and shimmering light across the water, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and majesty. The boat's deliberate movement is the only dynamic element in the serene and beautiful scenery.", + "seed": 5363, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_1/index_7451_seed_5363_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.025661395490169527, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025661395490169527, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025661395490169527, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly elevated wide-angle view of a coastal scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a classic, weathered fishing boat with a white hull, blue trim, peeling paint, and rust stains visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat glide steadily from left to right, slicing through deep blue water and leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long rock breakwater made of large, dark, moss-colored boulders visible with a traditional lighthouse (white cylindrical tower, red lantern room) at its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a picturesque coastal town with whitewashed buildings and terracotta roofs nestled at the foot of rolling green hills in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014256530441343784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.514256477355957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014256530441343784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014256530441343784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20057174563407898, + 0.04715666547417641, + 0.034364499151706696, + 0.037663817405700684, + 0.09282232820987701, + 0.05087677761912346, + 0.20984546840190887, + 0.10150856524705887, + 0.0606129951775074, + 0.1645771712064743 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014256530441343784 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly elevated wide-angle view of a coastal scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a classic, weathered fishing boat with a white hull, blue trim, peeling paint, and rust stains visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat glide steadily from left to right, slicing through deep blue water and leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long rock breakwater made of large, dark, moss-colored boulders visible with a traditional lighthouse (white cylindrical tower, red lantern room) at its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a picturesque coastal town with whitewashed buildings and terracotta roofs nestled at the foot of rolling green hills in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067633045837283134 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006763458251953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067633045837283134, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067633045837283134, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1130196750164032, + 0.13849283754825592, + 0.04413175582885742, + 0.01928156428039074, + 0.06669200211763382, + 0.08892317861318588, + 0.15785737335681915, + 0.13064929842948914, + 0.09489087760448456, + 0.14606145024299622 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067633045837283134 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly elevated wide-angle view of a coastal scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a classic, weathered fishing boat with a white hull, blue trim, peeling paint, and rust stains visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat glide steadily from left to right, slicing through deep blue water and leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long rock breakwater made of large, dark, moss-colored boulders visible with a traditional lighthouse (white cylindrical tower, red lantern room) at its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a picturesque coastal town with whitewashed buildings and terracotta roofs nestled at the foot of rolling green hills in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062048621475696564 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120486736297607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062048621475696564, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062048621475696564, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10113486647605896, + 0.03513307496905327, + 0.029123423621058464, + 0.02583972178399563, + 0.09751888364553452, + 0.17297768592834473, + 0.19312214851379395, + 0.15026605129241943, + 0.11106938123703003, + 0.08381478488445282 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062048621475696564 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly elevated wide-angle view of a coastal scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a classic, weathered fishing boat with a white hull, blue trim, peeling paint, and rust stains visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat glide steadily from left to right, slicing through deep blue water and leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long rock breakwater made of large, dark, moss-colored boulders visible with a traditional lighthouse (white cylindrical tower, red lantern room) at its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a picturesque coastal town with whitewashed buildings and terracotta roofs nestled at the foot of rolling green hills in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00219818577170372 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127198219299316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00219818577170372, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00219818577170372, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12579941749572754, + 0.12476927042007446, + 0.028900016099214554, + 0.08183084428310394, + 0.23014436662197113, + 0.03879886865615845, + 0.09818686544895172, + 0.14422717690467834, + 0.05954921990633011, + 0.06779400259256363 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00219818577170372 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly elevated wide-angle view of a coastal scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a classic, weathered fishing boat with a white hull, blue trim, peeling paint, and rust stains visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat glide steadily from left to right, slicing through deep blue water and leaving a clean, expanding V-shaped wake of white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a long rock breakwater made of large, dark, moss-colored boulders visible with a traditional lighthouse (white cylindrical tower, red lantern room) at its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a picturesque coastal town with whitewashed buildings and terracotta roofs nestled at the foot of rolling green hills in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043040335178375244 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680402755737305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043040335178375244, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043040335178375244, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1489662230014801, + 0.07434612512588501, + 0.04535357654094696, + 0.17616406083106995, + 0.32484519481658936, + 0.02056577242910862, + 0.07425032556056976, + 0.05758880078792572, + 0.03322342410683632, + 0.044696517288684845 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043040335178375244 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_10/index_tensor([6396, 6396])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_10/index_tensor([6396, 6396])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ab4a03698a82330e3dad7d67d1c134b9064f60f0 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_10/index_tensor([6396, 6396])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic, slightly tilted, circling medium shot captures the stunning spectacle of a heavily tattooed demon practicing in the night. His vibrant pink hair dances with his movements, contrasting sharply with his sharp, angular, demonic features. His bare torso and arms are covered in intricate, ancient blue runic tattoos that seem alive, emitting a faint inner glow in the light. The scene is dramatically torn between two contrasting light sources: on one side, a full moon hangs high in the night sky, casting a cool, eerie blue glow that outlines one side of his taut, muscled body; on the other, a blazing bonfire, its warm, leaping orange flames off-screen, illuminating the other side, creating a stark contrast of light and dark and a long, dancing shadow. He is engaged in a Tai Chi \"Cloud Hands\" pose, shifting his weight with a steady hand, his arms gliding through the air with a grace that seems slow but holds a terrifying power. Each seemingly gentle movement triggers a violent reaction in the surrounding environment—the dust and fallen leaves beneath his feet are swept up by invisible air currents, forming a miniature vortex around him, clearly demonstrating the destructive power precisely controlled in every subtle movement. The rotating camera intensifies this sense of turbulence, constantly interweaving the light and shadow of the cold moonlight and the warm campfire, creating an atmosphere that is both sacred and extremely dangerous, full of turbulence and mysterious power.", + "seed": 879, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_10/index_6396_seed_879_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.029025336168706416, + "vlm_logprob": -0.029025336168706416, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.029025336168706416, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily tattooed demon with vibrant pink hair and sharp, angular features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the subject's bare torso and arms covered in intricate blue runic tattoos that emit a faint inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by two contrasting light sources: a full moon casting cool blue light and a blazing bonfire casting warm orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the subject performing a Tai Chi 'Cloud Hands' pose with arms gliding through the air while shifting weight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a dynamic, slightly tilted, circling medium shot that rotates around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008803130127489567 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758803367614746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008803130127489567, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008803130127489567, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.037368983030319214, + 0.0177592895925045, + 0.018817588686943054, + 0.04275212436914444, + 0.015613328665494919, + 0.12807738780975342, + 0.023537173867225647, + 0.1314905881881714, + 0.5114629864692688, + 0.07312051951885223 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008803130127489567 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily tattooed demon with vibrant pink hair and sharp, angular features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the subject's bare torso and arms covered in intricate blue runic tattoos that emit a faint inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by two contrasting light sources: a full moon casting cool blue light and a blazing bonfire casting warm orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the subject performing a Tai Chi 'Cloud Hands' pose with arms gliding through the air while shifting weight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a dynamic, slightly tilted, circling medium shot that rotates around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012544536031782627 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387544631958008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012544536031782627, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012544536031782627, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03380173444747925, + 0.01566660962998867, + 0.01933765597641468, + 0.014813940972089767, + 0.012794973328709602, + 0.029862957075238228, + 0.014248962514102459, + 0.13515277206897736, + 0.6819505095481873, + 0.04236985370516777 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012544536031782627 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily tattooed demon with vibrant pink hair and sharp, angular features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the subject's bare torso and arms covered in intricate blue runic tattoos that emit a faint inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by two contrasting light sources: a full moon casting cool blue light and a blazing bonfire casting warm orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the subject performing a Tai Chi 'Cloud Hands' pose with arms gliding through the air while shifting weight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a dynamic, slightly tilted, circling medium shot that rotates around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006732163019478321 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006731986999512 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006732163019478321, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006732163019478321, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06843908131122589, + 0.06906598061323166, + 0.049806661903858185, + 0.017739824950695038, + 0.03415841981768608, + 0.029904870316386223, + 0.03993561863899231, + 0.12026412039995193, + 0.5450068712234497, + 0.025678429752588272 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006732163019478321 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily tattooed demon with vibrant pink hair and sharp, angular features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the subject's bare torso and arms covered in intricate blue runic tattoos that emit a faint inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by two contrasting light sources: a full moon casting cool blue light and a blazing bonfire casting warm orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the subject performing a Tai Chi 'Cloud Hands' pose with arms gliding through the air while shifting weight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a dynamic, slightly tilted, circling medium shot that rotates around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07896917313337326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789692401885986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07896917313337326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07896917313337326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.01956494338810444, + 0.015484746545553207, + 0.010396451689302921, + 0.013690339401364326, + 0.008366644382476807, + 0.030625391751527786, + 0.010157284326851368, + 0.04408154636621475, + 0.8261845111846924, + 0.021448131650686264 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07896917313337326 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily tattooed demon with vibrant pink hair and sharp, angular features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the subject's bare torso and arms covered in intricate blue runic tattoos that emit a faint inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by two contrasting light sources: a full moon casting cool blue light and a blazing bonfire casting warm orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the subject performing a Tai Chi 'Cloud Hands' pose with arms gliding through the air while shifting weight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a dynamic, slightly tilted, circling medium shot that rotates around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03807767853140831 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880775928497314 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03807767853140831, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03807767853140831, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04232737794518471, + 0.06176551431417465, + 0.0232072863727808, + 0.019300419837236404, + 0.03673724830150604, + 0.04885893315076828, + 0.0523538812994957, + 0.04103875905275345, + 0.6385401487350464, + 0.03587043657898903 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03807767853140831 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, slightly tilted, circling medium shot captures the stunning spectacle of a heavily tattooed demon practicing in the night. His vibrant pink hair dances with his movements, contrasting sharply with his sharp, angular, demonic features. His bare torso and arms are covered in intricate, ancient blue runic tattoos that seem alive, emitting a faint inner glow in the light. The scene is dramatically torn between two contrasting light sources: on one side, a full moon hangs high in the night sky, casting a cool, eerie blue glow that outlines one side of his taut, muscled body; on the other, a blazing bonfire, its warm, leaping orange flames off-screen, illuminating the other side, creating a stark contrast of light and dark and a long, dancing shadow. He is engaged in a Tai Chi \"Cloud Hands\" pose, shifting his weight with a steady hand, his arms gliding through the air with a grace that seems slow but holds a terrifying power. Each seemingly gentle movement triggers a violent reaction in the surrounding environment—the dust and fallen leaves beneath his feet are swept up by invisible air currents, forming a miniature vortex around him, clearly demonstrating the destructive power precisely controlled in every subtle movement. The rotating camera intensifies this sense of turbulence, constantly interweaving the light and shadow of the cold moonlight and the warm campfire, creating an atmosphere that is both sacred and extremely dangerous, full of turbulence and mysterious power.", + "seed": 880, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_10/index_6396_seed_880_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.09063230133615434, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09063230133615434, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09063230133615434, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily tattooed demon with vibrant pink hair and sharp, angular features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the subject's bare torso and arms covered in intricate blue runic tattoos that emit a faint inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by two contrasting light sources: a full moon casting cool blue light and a blazing bonfire casting warm orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the subject performing a Tai Chi 'Cloud Hands' pose with arms gliding through the air while shifting weight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a dynamic, slightly tilted, circling medium shot that rotates around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010175259783864021 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6351752281188965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010175259783864021, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010175259783864021, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26616498827934265, + 0.14212308824062347, + 0.07299228757619858, + 0.09394408017396927, + 0.04940417408943176, + 0.06438232213258743, + 0.1489318460226059, + 0.06010325253009796, + 0.027173500508069992, + 0.0747804343700409 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010175259783864021 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily tattooed demon with vibrant pink hair and sharp, angular features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the subject's bare torso and arms covered in intricate blue runic tattoos that emit a faint inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by two contrasting light sources: a full moon casting cool blue light and a blazing bonfire casting warm orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the subject performing a Tai Chi 'Cloud Hands' pose with arms gliding through the air while shifting weight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a dynamic, slightly tilted, circling medium shot that rotates around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02981266938149929 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298125743865967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02981266938149929, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02981266938149929, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14232735335826874, + 0.22988009452819824, + 0.09034008532762527, + 0.05798894912004471, + 0.0656391903758049, + 0.22359153628349304, + 0.06835250556468964, + 0.040860410779714584, + 0.043299462646245956, + 0.03772043436765671 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02981266938149929 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily tattooed demon with vibrant pink hair and sharp, angular features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the subject's bare torso and arms covered in intricate blue runic tattoos that emit a faint inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by two contrasting light sources: a full moon casting cool blue light and a blazing bonfire casting warm orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the subject performing a Tai Chi 'Cloud Hands' pose with arms gliding through the air while shifting weight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a dynamic, slightly tilted, circling medium shot that rotates around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002819255692884326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877819061279297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002819255692884326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002819255692884326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3768394887447357, + 0.12450117617845535, + 0.1140466034412384, + 0.06251032650470734, + 0.047718606889247894, + 0.10920581221580505, + 0.07127388566732407, + 0.030556485056877136, + 0.02219673991203308, + 0.04115086421370506 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002819255692884326 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily tattooed demon with vibrant pink hair and sharp, angular features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the subject's bare torso and arms covered in intricate blue runic tattoos that emit a faint inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by two contrasting light sources: a full moon casting cool blue light and a blazing bonfire casting warm orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the subject performing a Tai Chi 'Cloud Hands' pose with arms gliding through the air while shifting weight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a dynamic, slightly tilted, circling medium shot that rotates around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870764970779419 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137076497077942 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3870764970779419, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3870764970779419, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15601913630962372, + 0.1440572291612625, + 0.0934685468673706, + 0.1443173587322235, + 0.11677132546901703, + 0.06254314631223679, + 0.0935152992606163, + 0.0650969073176384, + 0.05078485235571861, + 0.07342617213726044 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3870764970779419 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily tattooed demon with vibrant pink hair and sharp, angular features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the subject's bare torso and arms covered in intricate blue runic tattoos that emit a faint inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by two contrasting light sources: a full moon casting cool blue light and a blazing bonfire casting warm orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the subject performing a Tai Chi 'Cloud Hands' pose with arms gliding through the air while shifting weight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a dynamic, slightly tilted, circling medium shot that rotates around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023277824744582176 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773277759552002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023277824744582176, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023277824744582176, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15710225701332092, + 0.15661878883838654, + 0.07829239219427109, + 0.11528369039297104, + 0.060025475919246674, + 0.18045495450496674, + 0.07978374511003494, + 0.03420206904411316, + 0.09277032315731049, + 0.045466262847185135 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023277824744582176 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, slightly tilted, circling medium shot captures the stunning spectacle of a heavily tattooed demon practicing in the night. His vibrant pink hair dances with his movements, contrasting sharply with his sharp, angular, demonic features. His bare torso and arms are covered in intricate, ancient blue runic tattoos that seem alive, emitting a faint inner glow in the light. The scene is dramatically torn between two contrasting light sources: on one side, a full moon hangs high in the night sky, casting a cool, eerie blue glow that outlines one side of his taut, muscled body; on the other, a blazing bonfire, its warm, leaping orange flames off-screen, illuminating the other side, creating a stark contrast of light and dark and a long, dancing shadow. He is engaged in a Tai Chi \"Cloud Hands\" pose, shifting his weight with a steady hand, his arms gliding through the air with a grace that seems slow but holds a terrifying power. Each seemingly gentle movement triggers a violent reaction in the surrounding environment—the dust and fallen leaves beneath his feet are swept up by invisible air currents, forming a miniature vortex around him, clearly demonstrating the destructive power precisely controlled in every subtle movement. The rotating camera intensifies this sense of turbulence, constantly interweaving the light and shadow of the cold moonlight and the warm campfire, creating an atmosphere that is both sacred and extremely dangerous, full of turbulence and mysterious power.", + "seed": 881, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_10/index_6396_seed_881_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.24155152663588525, + "vlm_logprob": -0.24155152663588525, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.24155152663588525, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily tattooed demon with vibrant pink hair and sharp, angular features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the subject's bare torso and arms covered in intricate blue runic tattoos that emit a faint inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by two contrasting light sources: a full moon casting cool blue light and a blazing bonfire casting warm orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the subject performing a Tai Chi 'Cloud Hands' pose with arms gliding through the air while shifting weight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a dynamic, slightly tilted, circling medium shot that rotates around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01622942090034485 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141229629516602 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01622942090034485, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01622942090034485, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04518336057662964, + 0.04512009024620056, + 0.03176303952932358, + 0.053112272173166275, + 0.02697555162012577, + 0.0761360302567482, + 0.039844926446676254, + 0.1453956812620163, + 0.30701392889022827, + 0.22945503890514374 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01622942090034485 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily tattooed demon with vibrant pink hair and sharp, angular features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the subject's bare torso and arms covered in intricate blue runic tattoos that emit a faint inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by two contrasting light sources: a full moon casting cool blue light and a blazing bonfire casting warm orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the subject performing a Tai Chi 'Cloud Hands' pose with arms gliding through the air while shifting weight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a dynamic, slightly tilted, circling medium shot that rotates around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029806653037667274 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529806613922119 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029806653037667274, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029806653037667274, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06500647217035294, + 0.037440795451402664, + 0.03850848227739334, + 0.052374694496393204, + 0.031342484056949615, + 0.2351667732000351, + 0.0769646167755127, + 0.05339738354086876, + 0.1952058970928192, + 0.2145923674106598 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029806653037667274 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily tattooed demon with vibrant pink hair and sharp, angular features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the subject's bare torso and arms covered in intricate blue runic tattoos that emit a faint inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by two contrasting light sources: a full moon casting cool blue light and a blazing bonfire casting warm orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the subject performing a Tai Chi 'Cloud Hands' pose with arms gliding through the air while shifting weight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a dynamic, slightly tilted, circling medium shot that rotates around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004094313830137253 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504094123840332 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004094313830137253, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004094313830137253, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06634635478258133, + 0.053161781281232834, + 0.10079669952392578, + 0.1300525963306427, + 0.06040734425187111, + 0.06507367640733719, + 0.028688132762908936, + 0.390474796295166, + 0.05983155593276024, + 0.045167047530412674 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004094313830137253 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily tattooed demon with vibrant pink hair and sharp, angular features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the subject's bare torso and arms covered in intricate blue runic tattoos that emit a faint inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by two contrasting light sources: a full moon casting cool blue light and a blazing bonfire casting warm orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the subject performing a Tai Chi 'Cloud Hands' pose with arms gliding through the air while shifting weight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a dynamic, slightly tilted, circling medium shot that rotates around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370521783828735 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870522081851959 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1370521783828735, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1370521783828735, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2506946623325348, + 0.0446130745112896, + 0.07755765318870544, + 0.02903396263718605, + 0.03366236761212349, + 0.05720273777842522, + 0.022384051233530045, + 0.09418730437755585, + 0.2767910659313202, + 0.11387306451797485 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1370521783828735 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily tattooed demon with vibrant pink hair and sharp, angular features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the subject's bare torso and arms covered in intricate blue runic tattoos that emit a faint inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by two contrasting light sources: a full moon casting cool blue light and a blazing bonfire casting warm orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the subject performing a Tai Chi 'Cloud Hands' pose with arms gliding through the air while shifting weight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a dynamic, slightly tilted, circling medium shot that rotates around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020575067028403282 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955750465393066 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020575067028403282, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020575067028403282, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13601866364479065, + 0.08365093916654587, + 0.05102186277508736, + 0.027924124151468277, + 0.027042539790272713, + 0.07335875183343887, + 0.030216285958886147, + 0.10038313269615173, + 0.36381101608276367, + 0.10657265782356262 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020575067028403282 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, slightly tilted, circling medium shot captures the stunning spectacle of a heavily tattooed demon practicing in the night. His vibrant pink hair dances with his movements, contrasting sharply with his sharp, angular, demonic features. His bare torso and arms are covered in intricate, ancient blue runic tattoos that seem alive, emitting a faint inner glow in the light. The scene is dramatically torn between two contrasting light sources: on one side, a full moon hangs high in the night sky, casting a cool, eerie blue glow that outlines one side of his taut, muscled body; on the other, a blazing bonfire, its warm, leaping orange flames off-screen, illuminating the other side, creating a stark contrast of light and dark and a long, dancing shadow. He is engaged in a Tai Chi \"Cloud Hands\" pose, shifting his weight with a steady hand, his arms gliding through the air with a grace that seems slow but holds a terrifying power. Each seemingly gentle movement triggers a violent reaction in the surrounding environment—the dust and fallen leaves beneath his feet are swept up by invisible air currents, forming a miniature vortex around him, clearly demonstrating the destructive power precisely controlled in every subtle movement. The rotating camera intensifies this sense of turbulence, constantly interweaving the light and shadow of the cold moonlight and the warm campfire, creating an atmosphere that is both sacred and extremely dangerous, full of turbulence and mysterious power.", + "seed": 882, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_10/index_6396_seed_882_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06159419985488057, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06159419985488057, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06159419985488057, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily tattooed demon with vibrant pink hair and sharp, angular features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the subject's bare torso and arms covered in intricate blue runic tattoos that emit a faint inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by two contrasting light sources: a full moon casting cool blue light and a blazing bonfire casting warm orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the subject performing a Tai Chi 'Cloud Hands' pose with arms gliding through the air while shifting weight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a dynamic, slightly tilted, circling medium shot that rotates around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004332561045885086 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504332542419434 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004332561045885086, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004332561045885086, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09287779778242111, + 0.06648417562246323, + 0.05573175102472305, + 0.10908662527799606, + 0.10919579118490219, + 0.09404505789279938, + 0.1183929368853569, + 0.13592153787612915, + 0.040381986647844315, + 0.17788240313529968 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004332561045885086 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily tattooed demon with vibrant pink hair and sharp, angular features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the subject's bare torso and arms covered in intricate blue runic tattoos that emit a faint inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by two contrasting light sources: a full moon casting cool blue light and a blazing bonfire casting warm orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the subject performing a Tai Chi 'Cloud Hands' pose with arms gliding through the air while shifting weight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a dynamic, slightly tilted, circling medium shot that rotates around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020588496699929237 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955883979797363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020588496699929237, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020588496699929237, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09335888922214508, + 0.10610056668519974, + 0.03914830833673477, + 0.12537536025047302, + 0.19442787766456604, + 0.07890185713768005, + 0.11289661377668381, + 0.11135400086641312, + 0.044346898794174194, + 0.09408962726593018 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020588496699929237 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily tattooed demon with vibrant pink hair and sharp, angular features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the subject's bare torso and arms covered in intricate blue runic tattoos that emit a faint inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by two contrasting light sources: a full moon casting cool blue light and a blazing bonfire casting warm orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the subject performing a Tai Chi 'Cloud Hands' pose with arms gliding through the air while shifting weight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a dynamic, slightly tilted, circling medium shot that rotates around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011797142215073109 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.7511796951293945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011797142215073109, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011797142215073109, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16218091547489166, + 0.14855192601680756, + 0.06329988688230515, + 0.10396022349596024, + 0.0727628692984581, + 0.13829024136066437, + 0.07460049539804459, + 0.08192714303731918, + 0.03569537773728371, + 0.11873083561658859 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011797142215073109 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily tattooed demon with vibrant pink hair and sharp, angular features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the subject's bare torso and arms covered in intricate blue runic tattoos that emit a faint inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by two contrasting light sources: a full moon casting cool blue light and a blazing bonfire casting warm orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the subject performing a Tai Chi 'Cloud Hands' pose with arms gliding through the air while shifting weight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a dynamic, slightly tilted, circling medium shot that rotates around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520872950553894 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020873546600342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520872950553894, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520872950553894, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06702826172113419, + 0.08732254058122635, + 0.0334366150200367, + 0.11797848343849182, + 0.14496496319770813, + 0.13425514101982117, + 0.06818804144859314, + 0.18622851371765137, + 0.029913853853940964, + 0.1306835412979126 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520872950553894 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily tattooed demon with vibrant pink hair and sharp, angular features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the subject's bare torso and arms covered in intricate blue runic tattoos that emit a faint inner glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by two contrasting light sources: a full moon casting cool blue light and a blazing bonfire casting warm orange light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the subject performing a Tai Chi 'Cloud Hands' pose with arms gliding through the air while shifting weight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a dynamic, slightly tilted, circling medium shot that rotates around the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029782932251691818 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529783010482788 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029782932251691818, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029782932251691818, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15206338465213776, + 0.052049797028303146, + 0.047819145023822784, + 0.208092600107193, + 0.12029556930065155, + 0.12758126854896545, + 0.04238155111670494, + 0.13122743368148804, + 0.045511312782764435, + 0.07297790050506592 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029782932251691818 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_11/index_tensor([529, 529])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_11/index_tensor([529, 529])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..05b0adb283e88bec93a112f3e70c232097b14982 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_11/index_tensor([529, 529])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In an extreme close-up, the camera follows a delicate, childish hand in a smooth, slow downward tilt. In the warm, intimate afternoon light, golden sunlight streams in from the side, imbuing the image with a soft, warm hue. The hand's skin is fair and delicate, with endearing dimples at the knuckles. The index finger gently, almost caressingly, glides down a dark wooden staircase banister. The banister's surface is crisscrossed with minute scratches and dents from time, reflecting an aged, warm patina in the light. Suddenly, as the finger glides over a worn grain, a nearly invisible, sharp splinter stubbornly rises, piercing the skin at the fingertip and halting its movement. The camera then makes a tiny, almost imperceptible pan adjustment, focusing precisely on this tiny accident: a tiny drop of bright red blood is slowly oozing out from a clear white scratch, contrasting sharply with the dark wood and golden light, capturing a quiet yet heart-wrenching moment of true innocence and the unexpected collision of the tiny dangers of the real world.", + "seed": 2432, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_11/index_529_seed_2432_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.025192640163004397, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025192640163004397, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025192640163004397, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a delicate, childish hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth, slow downward tilt followed by a tiny pan adjustment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the index finger shown gliding down a dark wooden staircase banister with visible scratches and dents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a sharp splinter rise from the wood and pierce the fingertip, causing a drop of bright red blood to ooze out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight streaming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.049438975751399994 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.049438953399658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.049438975751399994, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.049438975751399994, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04538528993725777, + 0.03387289121747017, + 0.10216321051120758, + 0.05152484029531479, + 0.09196776151657104, + 0.44722700119018555, + 0.0550614632666111, + 0.046298131346702576, + 0.040170323103666306, + 0.08632910996675491 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.049438975751399994 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a delicate, childish hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth, slow downward tilt followed by a tiny pan adjustment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the index finger shown gliding down a dark wooden staircase banister with visible scratches and dents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a sharp splinter rise from the wood and pierce the fingertip, causing a drop of bright red blood to ooze out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight streaming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371204808354378 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408712148666382 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371204808354378, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371204808354378, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07294899225234985, + 0.10748062282800674, + 0.03884100541472435, + 0.04107411950826645, + 0.08470980077981949, + 0.22507596015930176, + 0.0477452389895916, + 0.15952055156230927, + 0.15790164470672607, + 0.06470208615064621 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371204808354378 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a delicate, childish hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth, slow downward tilt followed by a tiny pan adjustment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the index finger shown gliding down a dark wooden staircase banister with visible scratches and dents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a sharp splinter rise from the wood and pierce the fingertip, causing a drop of bright red blood to ooze out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight streaming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016075288876891136 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141075134277344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016075288876891136, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016075288876891136, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06918901950120926, + 0.029869278892874718, + 0.03233475610613823, + 0.02645774744451046, + 0.06781948357820511, + 0.30849435925483704, + 0.1123133972287178, + 0.07167079299688339, + 0.09344064444303513, + 0.18841049075126648 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016075288876891136 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a delicate, childish hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth, slow downward tilt followed by a tiny pan adjustment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the index finger shown gliding down a dark wooden staircase banister with visible scratches and dents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a sharp splinter rise from the wood and pierce the fingertip, causing a drop of bright red blood to ooze out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight streaming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014198473654687405 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264198303222656 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014198473654687405, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014198473654687405, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.020413022488355637, + 0.01729421690106392, + 0.029408376663923264, + 0.03177783638238907, + 0.04526549577713013, + 0.14319975674152374, + 0.07254701852798462, + 0.05682452768087387, + 0.14619070291519165, + 0.43707898259162903 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014198473654687405 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a delicate, childish hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth, slow downward tilt followed by a tiny pan adjustment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the index finger shown gliding down a dark wooden staircase banister with visible scratches and dents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a sharp splinter rise from the wood and pierce the fingertip, causing a drop of bright red blood to ooze out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight streaming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01253841444849968 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387538433074951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01253841444849968, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01253841444849968, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14476722478866577, + 0.04559820145368576, + 0.04803598299622536, + 0.04646779224276543, + 0.029380835592746735, + 0.4982018768787384, + 0.07120106369256973, + 0.019781839102506638, + 0.041536860167980194, + 0.055028289556503296 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01253841444849968 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In an extreme close-up, the camera follows a delicate, childish hand in a smooth, slow downward tilt. In the warm, intimate afternoon light, golden sunlight streams in from the side, imbuing the image with a soft, warm hue. The hand's skin is fair and delicate, with endearing dimples at the knuckles. The index finger gently, almost caressingly, glides down a dark wooden staircase banister. The banister's surface is crisscrossed with minute scratches and dents from time, reflecting an aged, warm patina in the light. Suddenly, as the finger glides over a worn grain, a nearly invisible, sharp splinter stubbornly rises, piercing the skin at the fingertip and halting its movement. The camera then makes a tiny, almost imperceptible pan adjustment, focusing precisely on this tiny accident: a tiny drop of bright red blood is slowly oozing out from a clear white scratch, contrasting sharply with the dark wood and golden light, capturing a quiet yet heart-wrenching moment of true innocence and the unexpected collision of the tiny dangers of the real world.", + "seed": 2433, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_11/index_529_seed_2433_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.34883832819759847, + "vlm_logprob": -0.34883832819759847, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.825000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.34883832819759847, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a delicate, childish hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth, slow downward tilt followed by a tiny pan adjustment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the index finger shown gliding down a dark wooden staircase banister with visible scratches and dents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a sharp splinter rise from the wood and pierce the fingertip, causing a drop of bright red blood to ooze out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight streaming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.975364625453949 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.475364625453949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.975364625453949, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.975364625453949, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22238576412200928, + 0.04491782188415527, + 0.05264798924326897, + 0.16661962866783142, + 0.050649892538785934, + 0.102895587682724, + 0.10555610805749893, + 0.056887879967689514, + 0.11488557606935501, + 0.0825536698102951 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.975364625453949 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a delicate, childish hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth, slow downward tilt followed by a tiny pan adjustment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the index finger shown gliding down a dark wooden staircase banister with visible scratches and dents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a sharp splinter rise from the wood and pierce the fingertip, causing a drop of bright red blood to ooze out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight streaming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03373486548662186 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087347984313965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03373486548662186, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03373486548662186, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10799515247344971, + 0.07025723904371262, + 0.03501864895224571, + 0.1276330053806305, + 0.07740259170532227, + 0.06211107224225998, + 0.04514816403388977, + 0.09346041083335876, + 0.16657917201519012, + 0.21439459919929504 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03373486548662186 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a delicate, childish hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth, slow downward tilt followed by a tiny pan adjustment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the index finger shown gliding down a dark wooden staircase banister with visible scratches and dents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a sharp splinter rise from the wood and pierce the fingertip, causing a drop of bright red blood to ooze out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight streaming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016081975772976875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141081809997559 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016081975772976875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016081975772976875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13675634562969208, + 0.054134439677000046, + 0.06445056945085526, + 0.22200478613376617, + 0.0930594950914383, + 0.11004228889942169, + 0.05586584657430649, + 0.06813745200634003, + 0.08884739130735397, + 0.10670144855976105 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016081975772976875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a delicate, childish hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth, slow downward tilt followed by a tiny pan adjustment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the index finger shown gliding down a dark wooden staircase banister with visible scratches and dents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a sharp splinter rise from the wood and pierce the fingertip, causing a drop of bright red blood to ooze out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight streaming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761646628379822 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261646628379822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761646628379822, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761646628379822, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12468747794628143, + 0.03708161041140556, + 0.05525614321231842, + 0.30311551690101624, + 0.06106596067547798, + 0.04129232466220856, + 0.12641611695289612, + 0.060194045305252075, + 0.07006723433732986, + 0.12082353234291077 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761646628379822 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a delicate, childish hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth, slow downward tilt followed by a tiny pan adjustment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the index finger shown gliding down a dark wooden staircase banister with visible scratches and dents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a sharp splinter rise from the wood and pierce the fingertip, causing a drop of bright red blood to ooze out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight streaming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428455114364624 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017845630645752 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428455114364624, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428455114364624, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3984624743461609, + 0.133197620511055, + 0.060352127999067307, + 0.04142710193991661, + 0.11527606099843979, + 0.06383698433637619, + 0.025810137391090393, + 0.04487821087241173, + 0.04356105998158455, + 0.07319820672273636 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428455114364624 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In an extreme close-up, the camera follows a delicate, childish hand in a smooth, slow downward tilt. In the warm, intimate afternoon light, golden sunlight streams in from the side, imbuing the image with a soft, warm hue. The hand's skin is fair and delicate, with endearing dimples at the knuckles. The index finger gently, almost caressingly, glides down a dark wooden staircase banister. The banister's surface is crisscrossed with minute scratches and dents from time, reflecting an aged, warm patina in the light. Suddenly, as the finger glides over a worn grain, a nearly invisible, sharp splinter stubbornly rises, piercing the skin at the fingertip and halting its movement. The camera then makes a tiny, almost imperceptible pan adjustment, focusing precisely on this tiny accident: a tiny drop of bright red blood is slowly oozing out from a clear white scratch, contrasting sharply with the dark wood and golden light, capturing a quiet yet heart-wrenching moment of true innocence and the unexpected collision of the tiny dangers of the real world.", + "seed": 2434, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_11/index_529_seed_2434_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.28010755497962236, + "vlm_logprob": -0.28010755497962236, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.28010755497962236, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a delicate, childish hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth, slow downward tilt followed by a tiny pan adjustment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the index finger shown gliding down a dark wooden staircase banister with visible scratches and dents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a sharp splinter rise from the wood and pierce the fingertip, causing a drop of bright red blood to ooze out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight streaming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6354156136512756 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7604156136512756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6354156136512756, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6354156136512756, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1089591458439827, + 0.07682912051677704, + 0.08433006703853607, + 0.058786362409591675, + 0.0693553239107132, + 0.04889943078160286, + 0.0694015696644783, + 0.3189292550086975, + 0.11576241254806519, + 0.048747289925813675 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6354156136512756 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a delicate, childish hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth, slow downward tilt followed by a tiny pan adjustment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the index finger shown gliding down a dark wooden staircase banister with visible scratches and dents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a sharp splinter rise from the wood and pierce the fingertip, causing a drop of bright red blood to ooze out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight streaming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043078359216451645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680784225463867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043078359216451645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043078359216451645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23950722813606262, + 0.06433963775634766, + 0.0447191558778286, + 0.05168180540204048, + 0.05213874578475952, + 0.04998459666967392, + 0.061296168714761734, + 0.2579977214336395, + 0.11016391217708588, + 0.06817100197076797 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043078359216451645 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a delicate, childish hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth, slow downward tilt followed by a tiny pan adjustment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the index finger shown gliding down a dark wooden staircase banister with visible scratches and dents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a sharp splinter rise from the wood and pierce the fingertip, causing a drop of bright red blood to ooze out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight streaming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012547479011118412 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387547492980957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012547479011118412, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012547479011118412, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15785346925258636, + 0.04872860014438629, + 0.08457912504673004, + 0.05911388620734215, + 0.017942391335964203, + 0.04097878560423851, + 0.08334282785654068, + 0.26384660601615906, + 0.11530136317014694, + 0.12831290066242218 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012547479011118412 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a delicate, childish hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth, slow downward tilt followed by a tiny pan adjustment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the index finger shown gliding down a dark wooden staircase banister with visible scratches and dents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a sharp splinter rise from the wood and pierce the fingertip, causing a drop of bright red blood to ooze out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight streaming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016077283769845963 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141077518463135 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016077283769845963, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016077283769845963, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17538227140903473, + 0.09504832327365875, + 0.047598227858543396, + 0.03780949115753174, + 0.020652703940868378, + 0.015493002720177174, + 0.06035764887928963, + 0.2593439221382141, + 0.1715409755706787, + 0.11677348613739014 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016077283769845963 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a delicate, childish hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth, slow downward tilt followed by a tiny pan adjustment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the index finger shown gliding down a dark wooden staircase banister with visible scratches and dents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a sharp splinter rise from the wood and pierce the fingertip, causing a drop of bright red blood to ooze out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight streaming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6934190392494202 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6934190392494202 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6934190392494202, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6934190392494202, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36230871081352234, + 0.18583638966083527, + 0.036535926163196564, + 0.021702194586396217, + 0.018917204812169075, + 0.04617154225707054, + 0.0399768240749836, + 0.13875430822372437, + 0.09971138834953308, + 0.05008554831147194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6934190392494202 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In an extreme close-up, the camera follows a delicate, childish hand in a smooth, slow downward tilt. In the warm, intimate afternoon light, golden sunlight streams in from the side, imbuing the image with a soft, warm hue. The hand's skin is fair and delicate, with endearing dimples at the knuckles. The index finger gently, almost caressingly, glides down a dark wooden staircase banister. The banister's surface is crisscrossed with minute scratches and dents from time, reflecting an aged, warm patina in the light. Suddenly, as the finger glides over a worn grain, a nearly invisible, sharp splinter stubbornly rises, piercing the skin at the fingertip and halting its movement. The camera then makes a tiny, almost imperceptible pan adjustment, focusing precisely on this tiny accident: a tiny drop of bright red blood is slowly oozing out from a clear white scratch, contrasting sharply with the dark wood and golden light, capturing a quiet yet heart-wrenching moment of true innocence and the unexpected collision of the tiny dangers of the real world.", + "seed": 2435, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_11/index_529_seed_2435_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2793041460216045, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2793041460216045, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2793041460216045, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a delicate, childish hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth, slow downward tilt followed by a tiny pan adjustment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the index finger shown gliding down a dark wooden staircase banister with visible scratches and dents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a sharp splinter rise from the wood and pierce the fingertip, causing a drop of bright red blood to ooze out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight streaming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18243622779846191 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.807436227798462 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18243622779846191, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18243622779846191, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08035974949598312, + 0.1097395122051239, + 0.05013275146484375, + 0.13998933136463165, + 0.3154292404651642, + 0.06283991783857346, + 0.07320556789636612, + 0.09701066464185715, + 0.0305095836520195, + 0.040783680975437164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18243622779846191 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a delicate, childish hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth, slow downward tilt followed by a tiny pan adjustment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the index finger shown gliding down a dark wooden staircase banister with visible scratches and dents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a sharp splinter rise from the wood and pierce the fingertip, causing a drop of bright red blood to ooze out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight streaming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054997287690639496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929997205734253 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054997287690639496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054997287690639496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08202852308750153, + 0.042037636041641235, + 0.14779271185398102, + 0.04565973952412605, + 0.11331472545862198, + 0.04162506386637688, + 0.017590390518307686, + 0.03647962957620621, + 0.10901260375976562, + 0.36445891857147217 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054997287690639496 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a delicate, childish hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth, slow downward tilt followed by a tiny pan adjustment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the index finger shown gliding down a dark wooden staircase banister with visible scratches and dents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a sharp splinter rise from the wood and pierce the fingertip, causing a drop of bright red blood to ooze out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight streaming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0430944561958313 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680943965911865 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0430944561958313, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0430944561958313, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.051983874291181564, + 0.037876371294260025, + 0.2354520857334137, + 0.04219092056155205, + 0.38607022166252136, + 0.021776920184493065, + 0.061729539185762405, + 0.042629580944776535, + 0.033061426132917404, + 0.08722900599241257 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0430944561958313 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a delicate, childish hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth, slow downward tilt followed by a tiny pan adjustment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the index finger shown gliding down a dark wooden staircase banister with visible scratches and dents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a sharp splinter rise from the wood and pierce the fingertip, causing a drop of bright red blood to ooze out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight streaming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.053903579711914 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42890360951423645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.053903579711914, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.053903579711914, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17696097493171692, + 0.03374756872653961, + 0.07985257357358932, + 0.11094450205564499, + 0.1521204560995102, + 0.0632033497095108, + 0.21236932277679443, + 0.03793524578213692, + 0.04895884916186333, + 0.08390714973211288 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.053903579711914 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a delicate, childish hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a smooth, slow downward tilt followed by a tiny pan adjustment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the index finger shown gliding down a dark wooden staircase banister with visible scratches and dents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a sharp splinter rise from the wood and pierce the fingertip, causing a drop of bright red blood to ooze out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight streaming from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06208917871117592 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812089204788208 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06208917871117592, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06208917871117592, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1575498878955841, + 0.0959770455956459, + 0.20808836817741394, + 0.06484749168157578, + 0.06368965655565262, + 0.02867395430803299, + 0.0416480116546154, + 0.07099270820617676, + 0.023066604509949684, + 0.24546627700328827 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06208917871117592 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_12/index_tensor([7073, 7073])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_12/index_tensor([7073, 7073])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2331c29ebf60026fb3f53f2e169cb795cc6e0cfd --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_12/index_tensor([7073, 7073])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle shot, shot from the ground, reveals a powerful, adult African elephant. It stands tall in the vast African savannah, a backdrop of a cloudless blue sky and a few sparse acacia trees. The scorching midday sun casts sharp, deep shadows on its deeply wrinkled, dark gray hide, rough as cracked earth. Its massive, curved tusks, gleaming with a pale yellow luster honed by age, stand out against the sun. Suddenly, with explosive force, it curls its muscular, powerful trunk slightly, gathering momentum, then lashes it upward, pointing it high into the sky. Simultaneously, its massive paw stomps the ground, stirring up a thick cloud of reddish-brown dust that swirls and engulfs its lower body. Along with this movement, its entire huge body was tensed due to extreme force, its huge fan-shaped ears were fully spread out to both sides, and its small and deep eyes flashed with anger and warning, as if it was making a silent but visually impactful roar. The whole picture was full of primitive, wild tension and awe-inspiring deterrence.", + "seed": 14047, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_12/index_7073_seed_14047_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.361292932741344, + "vlm_logprob": -0.361292932741344, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.361292932741344, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, shot from the ground level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an adult African elephant with dark gray, deeply wrinkled hide?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant curl its trunk upward and stomp its paw to stir up reddish-brown dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the elephant's ears fully spread out to both sides while it stands in a savannah with sparse acacia trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a scorching midday sun casting sharp, deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.36977070569992065 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3697707653045654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.36977070569992065, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.36977070569992065, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11052094399929047, + 0.15018315613269806, + 0.036741726100444794, + 0.12032484263181686, + 0.04842844232916832, + 0.106510229408741, + 0.08035249263048172, + 0.08385773003101349, + 0.17037148773670197, + 0.09270893037319183 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.36977070569992065 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, shot from the ground level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an adult African elephant with dark gray, deeply wrinkled hide?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant curl its trunk upward and stomp its paw to stir up reddish-brown dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the elephant's ears fully spread out to both sides while it stands in a savannah with sparse acacia trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a scorching midday sun casting sharp, deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14285677671432495 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178568363189697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14285677671432495, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14285677671432495, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2688821852207184, + 0.1552680879831314, + 0.12116512656211853, + 0.06632139533758163, + 0.0453607402741909, + 0.09314320236444473, + 0.03085438720881939, + 0.09752348810434341, + 0.06315536051988602, + 0.058326054364442825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14285677671432495 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, shot from the ground level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an adult African elephant with dark gray, deeply wrinkled hide?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant curl its trunk upward and stomp its paw to stir up reddish-brown dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the elephant's ears fully spread out to both sides while it stands in a savannah with sparse acacia trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a scorching midday sun casting sharp, deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01422033365815878 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264220237731934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01422033365815878, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01422033365815878, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08338439464569092, + 0.07786018401384354, + 0.03507581353187561, + 0.04976659640669823, + 0.06570824235677719, + 0.14917448163032532, + 0.09224557131528854, + 0.11054360121488571, + 0.19501814246177673, + 0.14122293889522552 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01422033365815878 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, shot from the ground level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an adult African elephant with dark gray, deeply wrinkled hide?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant curl its trunk upward and stomp its paw to stir up reddish-brown dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the elephant's ears fully spread out to both sides while it stands in a savannah with sparse acacia trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a scorching midday sun casting sharp, deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.053961992263794 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42896199226379395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.053961992263794, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.053961992263794, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18049858510494232, + 0.14321517944335938, + 0.13995571434497833, + 0.06306556612253189, + 0.048775218427181244, + 0.15813010931015015, + 0.029773512855172157, + 0.09806348383426666, + 0.06882023066282272, + 0.06970244646072388 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.053961992263794 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, shot from the ground level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an adult African elephant with dark gray, deeply wrinkled hide?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant curl its trunk upward and stomp its paw to stir up reddish-brown dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the elephant's ears fully spread out to both sides while it stands in a savannah with sparse acacia trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a scorching midday sun casting sharp, deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22565485537052155 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006548404693604 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22565485537052155, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22565485537052155, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13403525948524475, + 0.11381727457046509, + 0.027843907475471497, + 0.029952650889754295, + 0.03618864342570305, + 0.04060816019773483, + 0.05293111130595207, + 0.020950092002749443, + 0.4690339267253876, + 0.07463899254798889 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22565485537052155 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle shot, shot from the ground, reveals a powerful, adult African elephant. It stands tall in the vast African savannah, a backdrop of a cloudless blue sky and a few sparse acacia trees. The scorching midday sun casts sharp, deep shadows on its deeply wrinkled, dark gray hide, rough as cracked earth. Its massive, curved tusks, gleaming with a pale yellow luster honed by age, stand out against the sun. Suddenly, with explosive force, it curls its muscular, powerful trunk slightly, gathering momentum, then lashes it upward, pointing it high into the sky. Simultaneously, its massive paw stomps the ground, stirring up a thick cloud of reddish-brown dust that swirls and engulfs its lower body. Along with this movement, its entire huge body was tensed due to extreme force, its huge fan-shaped ears were fully spread out to both sides, and its small and deep eyes flashed with anger and warning, as if it was making a silent but visually impactful roar. The whole picture was full of primitive, wild tension and awe-inspiring deterrence.", + "seed": 14048, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_12/index_7073_seed_14048_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.44343045726418495, + "vlm_logprob": -0.44343045726418495, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.3250000119209289, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.44343045726418495, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, shot from the ground level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an adult African elephant with dark gray, deeply wrinkled hide?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant curl its trunk upward and stomp its paw to stir up reddish-brown dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the elephant's ears fully spread out to both sides while it stands in a savannah with sparse acacia trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a scorching midday sun casting sharp, deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0736181735992432 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.44861823320388794 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0736181735992432, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.6249999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0736181735992432, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2927508056163788, + 0.07006919384002686, + 0.05437466874718666, + 0.06324655562639236, + 0.1619924157857895, + 0.10893916338682175, + 0.08400701731443405, + 0.04903186485171318, + 0.04195169359445572, + 0.07363667339086533 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0736181735992432 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, shot from the ground level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an adult African elephant with dark gray, deeply wrinkled hide?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant curl its trunk upward and stomp its paw to stir up reddish-brown dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the elephant's ears fully spread out to both sides while it stands in a savannah with sparse acacia trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a scorching midday sun casting sharp, deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08908089995384216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464080810546875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08908089995384216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08908089995384216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19306668639183044, + 0.0692327618598938, + 0.049072835594415665, + 0.04243124648928642, + 0.06258836388587952, + 0.05107683688402176, + 0.06019832566380501, + 0.07151056826114655, + 0.08780308812856674, + 0.313019335269928 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08908089995384216 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, shot from the ground level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an adult African elephant with dark gray, deeply wrinkled hide?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant curl its trunk upward and stomp its paw to stir up reddish-brown dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the elephant's ears fully spread out to both sides while it stands in a savannah with sparse acacia trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a scorching midday sun casting sharp, deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043098341673612595 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680984497070312 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043098341673612595, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043098341673612595, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09017239511013031, + 0.06650491058826447, + 0.03889841213822365, + 0.029726659879088402, + 0.052866436541080475, + 0.08699002861976624, + 0.31733301281929016, + 0.1561368852853775, + 0.0719744935631752, + 0.08939674496650696 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043098341673612595 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, shot from the ground level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an adult African elephant with dark gray, deeply wrinkled hide?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant curl its trunk upward and stomp its paw to stir up reddish-brown dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the elephant's ears fully spread out to both sides while it stands in a savannah with sparse acacia trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a scorching midday sun casting sharp, deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.898386538028717 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.523386538028717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.898386538028717, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.898386538028717, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1407746970653534, + 0.0746898278594017, + 0.05676313862204552, + 0.05553713068366051, + 0.046765584498643875, + 0.09992004185914993, + 0.12396454066038132, + 0.07973695546388626, + 0.07373704761266708, + 0.2481110394001007 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.898386538028717 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, shot from the ground level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an adult African elephant with dark gray, deeply wrinkled hide?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant curl its trunk upward and stomp its paw to stir up reddish-brown dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the elephant's ears fully spread out to both sides while it stands in a savannah with sparse acacia trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a scorching midday sun casting sharp, deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1129683330655098 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379684448242188 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1129683330655098, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1129683330655098, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17867010831832886, + 0.060996197164058685, + 0.03095691092312336, + 0.04840618371963501, + 0.08902385830879211, + 0.05772688612341881, + 0.21823261678218842, + 0.09768878668546677, + 0.08473724871873856, + 0.1335611641407013 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1129683330655098 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle shot, shot from the ground, reveals a powerful, adult African elephant. It stands tall in the vast African savannah, a backdrop of a cloudless blue sky and a few sparse acacia trees. The scorching midday sun casts sharp, deep shadows on its deeply wrinkled, dark gray hide, rough as cracked earth. Its massive, curved tusks, gleaming with a pale yellow luster honed by age, stand out against the sun. Suddenly, with explosive force, it curls its muscular, powerful trunk slightly, gathering momentum, then lashes it upward, pointing it high into the sky. Simultaneously, its massive paw stomps the ground, stirring up a thick cloud of reddish-brown dust that swirls and engulfs its lower body. Along with this movement, its entire huge body was tensed due to extreme force, its huge fan-shaped ears were fully spread out to both sides, and its small and deep eyes flashed with anger and warning, as if it was making a silent but visually impactful roar. The whole picture was full of primitive, wild tension and awe-inspiring deterrence.", + "seed": 14049, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_12/index_7073_seed_14049_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.37022047452628615, + "vlm_logprob": -0.37022047452628615, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.5499999940395355, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.37022047452628615, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, shot from the ground level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an adult African elephant with dark gray, deeply wrinkled hide?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant curl its trunk upward and stomp its paw to stir up reddish-brown dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the elephant's ears fully spread out to both sides while it stands in a savannah with sparse acacia trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a scorching midday sun casting sharp, deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4985770285129547 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9985769987106323 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4985770285129547, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.4999999701976776, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4985770285129547, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08487757295370102, + 0.23361609876155853, + 0.04657997563481331, + 0.0354929119348526, + 0.0863032117486, + 0.07495191693305969, + 0.049325838685035706, + 0.04638981074094772, + 0.2612380087375641, + 0.08122465759515762 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4985770285129547 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, shot from the ground level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an adult African elephant with dark gray, deeply wrinkled hide?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant curl its trunk upward and stomp its paw to stir up reddish-brown dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the elephant's ears fully spread out to both sides while it stands in a savannah with sparse acacia trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a scorching midday sun casting sharp, deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1799548864364624 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049548864364624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1799548864364624, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1799548864364624, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.037382256239652634, + 0.4916316568851471, + 0.027334898710250854, + 0.06302803009748459, + 0.018050778657197952, + 0.14358454942703247, + 0.04397645220160484, + 0.025849610567092896, + 0.04435653239488602, + 0.10480522364377975 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1799548864364624 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, shot from the ground level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an adult African elephant with dark gray, deeply wrinkled hide?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant curl its trunk upward and stomp its paw to stir up reddish-brown dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the elephant's ears fully spread out to both sides while it stands in a savannah with sparse acacia trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a scorching midday sun casting sharp, deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018218090757727623 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018218040466309 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018218090757727623, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018218090757727623, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05668022856116295, + 0.162602961063385, + 0.07261081039905548, + 0.0433109775185585, + 0.1386917233467102, + 0.11643315106630325, + 0.06929828971624374, + 0.0554879866540432, + 0.17948535084724426, + 0.10539856553077698 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018218090757727623 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, shot from the ground level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an adult African elephant with dark gray, deeply wrinkled hide?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant curl its trunk upward and stomp its paw to stir up reddish-brown dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the elephant's ears fully spread out to both sides while it stands in a savannah with sparse acacia trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a scorching midday sun casting sharp, deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539861917495728 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42898619174957275 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0539861917495728, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0539861917495728, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04260528087615967, + 0.38018903136253357, + 0.05682017281651497, + 0.11174682527780533, + 0.07304774969816208, + 0.1727306991815567, + 0.06195627525448799, + 0.01691511645913124, + 0.041507598012685776, + 0.04248123988509178 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0539861917495728 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, shot from the ground level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an adult African elephant with dark gray, deeply wrinkled hide?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant curl its trunk upward and stomp its paw to stir up reddish-brown dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the elephant's ears fully spread out to both sides while it stands in a savannah with sparse acacia trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a scorching midday sun casting sharp, deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10036617517471313 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503661155700684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10036617517471313, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10036617517471313, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05678186193108559, + 0.07733158767223358, + 0.06659658998250961, + 0.08606668561697006, + 0.11453010141849518, + 0.25747257471084595, + 0.07161169499158859, + 0.09707174450159073, + 0.11636615544557571, + 0.056171007454395294 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10036617517471313 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle shot, shot from the ground, reveals a powerful, adult African elephant. It stands tall in the vast African savannah, a backdrop of a cloudless blue sky and a few sparse acacia trees. The scorching midday sun casts sharp, deep shadows on its deeply wrinkled, dark gray hide, rough as cracked earth. Its massive, curved tusks, gleaming with a pale yellow luster honed by age, stand out against the sun. Suddenly, with explosive force, it curls its muscular, powerful trunk slightly, gathering momentum, then lashes it upward, pointing it high into the sky. Simultaneously, its massive paw stomps the ground, stirring up a thick cloud of reddish-brown dust that swirls and engulfs its lower body. Along with this movement, its entire huge body was tensed due to extreme force, its huge fan-shaped ears were fully spread out to both sides, and its small and deep eyes flashed with anger and warning, as if it was making a silent but visually impactful roar. The whole picture was full of primitive, wild tension and awe-inspiring deterrence.", + "seed": 14050, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_12/index_7073_seed_14050_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.3364456739276648, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3364456739276648, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.599999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3364456739276648, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, shot from the ground level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an adult African elephant with dark gray, deeply wrinkled hide?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant curl its trunk upward and stomp its paw to stir up reddish-brown dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the elephant's ears fully spread out to both sides while it stands in a savannah with sparse acacia trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a scorching midday sun casting sharp, deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.33503463864326477 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3350346088409424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.33503463864326477, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.33503463864326477, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10549270361661911, + 0.09399563074111938, + 0.0748300701379776, + 0.04661793261766434, + 0.1279265135526657, + 0.3020915985107422, + 0.06533563882112503, + 0.05958661809563637, + 0.09137217700481415, + 0.032751068472862244 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.33503463864326477 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, shot from the ground level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an adult African elephant with dark gray, deeply wrinkled hide?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant curl its trunk upward and stomp its paw to stir up reddish-brown dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the elephant's ears fully spread out to both sides while it stands in a savannah with sparse acacia trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a scorching midday sun casting sharp, deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428363174200058 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017836332321167 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428363174200058, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428363174200058, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09047172963619232, + 0.11471141129732132, + 0.13929957151412964, + 0.04536024481058121, + 0.041311852633953094, + 0.0421178936958313, + 0.06887869536876678, + 0.06491857767105103, + 0.3475446105003357, + 0.04538543522357941 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428363174200058 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, shot from the ground level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an adult African elephant with dark gray, deeply wrinkled hide?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant curl its trunk upward and stomp its paw to stir up reddish-brown dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the elephant's ears fully spread out to both sides while it stands in a savannah with sparse acacia trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a scorching midday sun casting sharp, deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023313580080866814 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773313522338867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023313580080866814, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023313580080866814, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.055234529078006744, + 0.06044777110219002, + 0.09626792371273041, + 0.24853655695915222, + 0.0724230632185936, + 0.08325152844190598, + 0.22863560914993286, + 0.04274915158748627, + 0.061571016907691956, + 0.050882790237665176 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023313580080866814 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, shot from the ground level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an adult African elephant with dark gray, deeply wrinkled hide?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant curl its trunk upward and stomp its paw to stir up reddish-brown dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the elephant's ears fully spread out to both sides while it stands in a savannah with sparse acacia trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a scorching midday sun casting sharp, deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.053960919380188 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289608895778656 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.053960919380188, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.053960919380188, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09760796278715134, + 0.11770155280828476, + 0.14214174449443817, + 0.0736510381102562, + 0.12137392163276672, + 0.05140920728445053, + 0.17154185473918915, + 0.06860271096229553, + 0.09675905108451843, + 0.059210967272520065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.053960919380188 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle, shot from the ground level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an adult African elephant with dark gray, deeply wrinkled hide?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the elephant curl its trunk upward and stomp its paw to stir up reddish-brown dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the elephant's ears fully spread out to both sides while it stands in a savannah with sparse acacia trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a scorching midday sun casting sharp, deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270829141139984 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270828247070312 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270829141139984, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270829141139984, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20720572769641876, + 0.1948159635066986, + 0.07130085676908493, + 0.1402437388896942, + 0.0568733774125576, + 0.04684197157621384, + 0.061206940561532974, + 0.05815793201327324, + 0.0892312228679657, + 0.07412226498126984 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270829141139984 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_13/index_tensor([4367, 4367])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_13/index_tensor([4367, 4367])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3828d8ba6b6d81af0c38a258b29d30d58fa119a9 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_13/index_tensor([4367, 4367])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide shot opens the scene, the camera steadily tilting upward, following a female construction worker in her early 40s as she scales a vast network of steel scaffolding. Her long, black hair, neatly tied in thick braids, sways gently with her movements. Her face, framed by a bright yellow hard hat, radiates focus and experience. She wears a high-visibility orange safety vest over a durable, dusty gray work shirt, and her hands, clad in sturdy work gloves, confidently grip the cold, galvanized metal beams. She ascends with a rhythmic, deliberate cadence, placing her heavy-duty work boots firmly on each beam before pulling herself upward. The scaffolding is bolted to the raw concrete skeleton of a half-built skyscraper, revealing exposed rebar and unfinished floorboards. As the camera continues to tilt upward, the background expands to reveal a vast, busy city skyline: a dense tapestry of glass and steel towers beneath a bright, clear sky. The intense midday sun cast long, sharp shadows from the scaffolding onto the building’s facade, creating stark geometric patterns and causing brilliant reflections of light off the metal surfaces, creating a powerful atmosphere of concentrated labor, human determination, and monumental scale.", + "seed": 26413, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_13/index_4367_seed_26413_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1398349104449153, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1398349104449153, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1398349104449153, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle wide shot that tilts upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female construction worker in her early 40s with long black hair tied in thick braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the worker wearing a bright yellow hard hat, a high-visibility orange safety vest, and a dusty gray work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the worker scaling a vast network of steel scaffolding bolted to a half-built skyscraper with exposed rebar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a busy city skyline with glass and steel towers under a bright clear sky with long sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.034349218010902405 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.534349203109741 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.034349218010902405, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.034349218010902405, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07267678529024124, + 0.06715837121009827, + 0.04310961812734604, + 0.03536101430654526, + 0.043336592614650726, + 0.06789431720972061, + 0.07355184108018875, + 0.11692792177200317, + 0.2700604200363159, + 0.20992310345172882 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.034349218010902405 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle wide shot that tilts upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female construction worker in her early 40s with long black hair tied in thick braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the worker wearing a bright yellow hard hat, a high-visibility orange safety vest, and a dusty gray work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the worker scaling a vast network of steel scaffolding bolted to a half-built skyscraper with exposed rebar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a busy city skyline with glass and steel towers under a bright clear sky with long sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.632829487323761 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.757829487323761 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.632829487323761, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.632829487323761, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.41578081250190735, + 0.07348484545946121, + 0.030311623588204384, + 0.03524981066584587, + 0.09204897284507751, + 0.2292999029159546, + 0.02212676778435707, + 0.023382408544421196, + 0.032598625868558884, + 0.0457163080573082 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.632829487323761 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle wide shot that tilts upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female construction worker in her early 40s with long black hair tied in thick braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the worker wearing a bright yellow hard hat, a high-visibility orange safety vest, and a dusty gray work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the worker scaling a vast network of steel scaffolding bolted to a half-built skyscraper with exposed rebar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a busy city skyline with glass and steel towers under a bright clear sky with long sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004094432573765516 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.50409460067749 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004094432573765516, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004094432573765516, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3295098543167114, + 0.06815455108880997, + 0.0383320078253746, + 0.03578851744532585, + 0.09643207490444183, + 0.1912166029214859, + 0.028985535725951195, + 0.03001420944929123, + 0.09390471130609512, + 0.08766193687915802 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004094432573765516 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle wide shot that tilts upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female construction worker in her early 40s with long black hair tied in thick braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the worker wearing a bright yellow hard hat, a high-visibility orange safety vest, and a dusty gray work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the worker scaling a vast network of steel scaffolding bolted to a half-built skyscraper with exposed rebar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a busy city skyline with glass and steel towers under a bright clear sky with long sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004631625022739172 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379631519317627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004631625022739172, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004631625022739172, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2314205765724182, + 0.09677744656801224, + 0.05188378691673279, + 0.03108477219939232, + 0.05828646570444107, + 0.1847640722990036, + 0.02570452354848385, + 0.06840480118989944, + 0.08594583719968796, + 0.16572774946689606 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004631625022739172 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle wide shot that tilts upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female construction worker in her early 40s with long black hair tied in thick braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the worker wearing a bright yellow hard hat, a high-visibility orange safety vest, and a dusty gray work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the worker scaling a vast network of steel scaffolding bolted to a half-built skyscraper with exposed rebar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a busy city skyline with glass and steel towers under a bright clear sky with long sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023269789293408394 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732698917388916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023269789293408394, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023269789293408394, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13255828619003296, + 0.03425465524196625, + 0.013087471015751362, + 0.017166906967759132, + 0.033478450030088425, + 0.08841277658939362, + 0.03139355033636093, + 0.06160939112305641, + 0.17176425457000732, + 0.41627421975135803 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023269789293408394 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide shot opens the scene, the camera steadily tilting upward, following a female construction worker in her early 40s as she scales a vast network of steel scaffolding. Her long, black hair, neatly tied in thick braids, sways gently with her movements. Her face, framed by a bright yellow hard hat, radiates focus and experience. She wears a high-visibility orange safety vest over a durable, dusty gray work shirt, and her hands, clad in sturdy work gloves, confidently grip the cold, galvanized metal beams. She ascends with a rhythmic, deliberate cadence, placing her heavy-duty work boots firmly on each beam before pulling herself upward. The scaffolding is bolted to the raw concrete skeleton of a half-built skyscraper, revealing exposed rebar and unfinished floorboards. As the camera continues to tilt upward, the background expands to reveal a vast, busy city skyline: a dense tapestry of glass and steel towers beneath a bright, clear sky. The intense midday sun cast long, sharp shadows from the scaffolding onto the building’s facade, creating stark geometric patterns and causing brilliant reflections of light off the metal surfaces, creating a powerful atmosphere of concentrated labor, human determination, and monumental scale.", + "seed": 26414, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_13/index_4367_seed_26414_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08336833454668521, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08336833454668521, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08336833454668521, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle wide shot that tilts upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female construction worker in her early 40s with long black hair tied in thick braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the worker wearing a bright yellow hard hat, a high-visibility orange safety vest, and a dusty gray work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the worker scaling a vast network of steel scaffolding bolted to a half-built skyscraper with exposed rebar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a busy city skyline with glass and steel towers under a bright clear sky with long sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06652210652828217 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8165221214294434 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06652210652828217, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06652210652828217, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1463187038898468, + 0.044593315571546555, + 0.05249668285250664, + 0.01870313100516796, + 0.041079841554164886, + 0.29677143692970276, + 0.14219926297664642, + 0.05826347693800926, + 0.15553362667560577, + 0.04404057189822197 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06652210652828217 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle wide shot that tilts upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female construction worker in her early 40s with long black hair tied in thick braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the worker wearing a bright yellow hard hat, a high-visibility orange safety vest, and a dusty gray work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the worker scaling a vast network of steel scaffolding bolted to a half-built skyscraper with exposed rebar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a busy city skyline with glass and steel towers under a bright clear sky with long sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1799553781747818 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049553632736206 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1799553781747818, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1799553781747818, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08474061638116837, + 0.1802748143672943, + 0.06640879064798355, + 0.09095482528209686, + 0.053564298897981644, + 0.0836220234632492, + 0.1633957326412201, + 0.07012355327606201, + 0.14224742352962494, + 0.06466789543628693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1799553781747818 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle wide shot that tilts upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female construction worker in her early 40s with long black hair tied in thick braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the worker wearing a bright yellow hard hat, a high-visibility orange safety vest, and a dusty gray work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the worker scaling a vast network of steel scaffolding bolted to a half-built skyscraper with exposed rebar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a busy city skyline with glass and steel towers under a bright clear sky with long sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004095263313502073 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504095077514648 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004095263313502073, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004095263313502073, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2382843792438507, + 0.0415666289627552, + 0.10097508132457733, + 0.06039554253220558, + 0.038534317165613174, + 0.047369834035634995, + 0.36618852615356445, + 0.022228125482797623, + 0.03848894685506821, + 0.04596865922212601 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004095263313502073 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle wide shot that tilts upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female construction worker in her early 40s with long black hair tied in thick braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the worker wearing a bright yellow hard hat, a high-visibility orange safety vest, and a dusty gray work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the worker scaling a vast network of steel scaffolding bolted to a half-built skyscraper with exposed rebar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a busy city skyline with glass and steel towers under a bright clear sky with long sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005942652467638254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309428215026855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005942652467638254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005942652467638254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.258049339056015, + 0.12420592457056046, + 0.08137861639261246, + 0.03762385994195938, + 0.08116673678159714, + 0.11513587087392807, + 0.09970448911190033, + 0.0900493860244751, + 0.05732516571879387, + 0.055360618978738785 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005942652467638254 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle wide shot that tilts upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female construction worker in her early 40s with long black hair tied in thick braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the worker wearing a bright yellow hard hat, a high-visibility orange safety vest, and a dusty gray work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the worker scaling a vast network of steel scaffolding bolted to a half-built skyscraper with exposed rebar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a busy city skyline with glass and steel towers under a bright clear sky with long sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603262722492218 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103262424468994 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603262722492218, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603262722492218, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25310057401657104, + 0.09900689870119095, + 0.13843613862991333, + 0.051190443336963654, + 0.043650828301906586, + 0.06831812858581543, + 0.1369137465953827, + 0.025238944217562675, + 0.06773737818002701, + 0.11640691012144089 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603262722492218 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide shot opens the scene, the camera steadily tilting upward, following a female construction worker in her early 40s as she scales a vast network of steel scaffolding. Her long, black hair, neatly tied in thick braids, sways gently with her movements. Her face, framed by a bright yellow hard hat, radiates focus and experience. She wears a high-visibility orange safety vest over a durable, dusty gray work shirt, and her hands, clad in sturdy work gloves, confidently grip the cold, galvanized metal beams. She ascends with a rhythmic, deliberate cadence, placing her heavy-duty work boots firmly on each beam before pulling herself upward. The scaffolding is bolted to the raw concrete skeleton of a half-built skyscraper, revealing exposed rebar and unfinished floorboards. As the camera continues to tilt upward, the background expands to reveal a vast, busy city skyline: a dense tapestry of glass and steel towers beneath a bright, clear sky. The intense midday sun cast long, sharp shadows from the scaffolding onto the building’s facade, creating stark geometric patterns and causing brilliant reflections of light off the metal surfaces, creating a powerful atmosphere of concentrated labor, human determination, and monumental scale.", + "seed": 26415, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_13/index_4367_seed_26415_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11287962938658894, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11287962938658894, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11287962938658894, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle wide shot that tilts upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female construction worker in her early 40s with long black hair tied in thick braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the worker wearing a bright yellow hard hat, a high-visibility orange safety vest, and a dusty gray work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the worker scaling a vast network of steel scaffolding bolted to a half-built skyscraper with exposed rebar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a busy city skyline with glass and steel towers under a bright clear sky with long sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2966940999031067 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.421694040298462 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2966940999031067, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2966940999031067, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1196288987994194, + 0.07152515649795532, + 0.09030948579311371, + 0.10143080353736877, + 0.08271081745624542, + 0.09003644436597824, + 0.15540124475955963, + 0.13317406177520752, + 0.0574873685836792, + 0.09829574078321457 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2966940999031067 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle wide shot that tilts upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female construction worker in her early 40s with long black hair tied in thick braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the worker wearing a bright yellow hard hat, a high-visibility orange safety vest, and a dusty gray work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the worker scaling a vast network of steel scaffolding bolted to a half-built skyscraper with exposed rebar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a busy city skyline with glass and steel towers under a bright clear sky with long sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22559082508087158 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005908250808716 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22559082508087158, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22559082508087158, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3042365610599518, + 0.06264366954565048, + 0.07561410218477249, + 0.16875994205474854, + 0.040679410099983215, + 0.029418690130114555, + 0.05448955297470093, + 0.1319511979818344, + 0.07647546380758286, + 0.0557313933968544 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22559082508087158 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle wide shot that tilts upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female construction worker in her early 40s with long black hair tied in thick braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the worker wearing a bright yellow hard hat, a high-visibility orange safety vest, and a dusty gray work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the worker scaling a vast network of steel scaffolding bolted to a half-built skyscraper with exposed rebar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a busy city skyline with glass and steel towers under a bright clear sky with long sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00249087275005877 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002490997314453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00249087275005877, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00249087275005877, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2979188561439514, + 0.06087175011634827, + 0.12793593108654022, + 0.06543192267417908, + 0.0544930025935173, + 0.025946881622076035, + 0.07417837530374527, + 0.17839857935905457, + 0.0415271557867527, + 0.07329753786325455 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00249087275005877 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle wide shot that tilts upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female construction worker in her early 40s with long black hair tied in thick braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the worker wearing a bright yellow hard hat, a high-visibility orange safety vest, and a dusty gray work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the worker scaling a vast network of steel scaffolding bolted to a half-built skyscraper with exposed rebar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a busy city skyline with glass and steel towers under a bright clear sky with long sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005944074597209692 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.13094425201416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005944074597209692, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005944074597209692, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14576438069343567, + 0.08876759558916092, + 0.12872685492038727, + 0.1313226968050003, + 0.05684678629040718, + 0.12616486847400665, + 0.11544277518987656, + 0.11285553872585297, + 0.0563921295106411, + 0.03771640732884407 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005944074597209692 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle wide shot that tilts upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female construction worker in her early 40s with long black hair tied in thick braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the worker wearing a bright yellow hard hat, a high-visibility orange safety vest, and a dusty gray work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the worker scaling a vast network of steel scaffolding bolted to a half-built skyscraper with exposed rebar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a busy city skyline with glass and steel towers under a bright clear sky with long sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03367827460169792 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086782932281494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03367827460169792, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03367827460169792, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20292744040489197, + 0.09486988931894302, + 0.10656502842903137, + 0.11460836976766586, + 0.035428695380687714, + 0.02753395587205887, + 0.2152189314365387, + 0.1324099600315094, + 0.03208742290735245, + 0.03835029527544975 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03367827460169792 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide shot opens the scene, the camera steadily tilting upward, following a female construction worker in her early 40s as she scales a vast network of steel scaffolding. Her long, black hair, neatly tied in thick braids, sways gently with her movements. Her face, framed by a bright yellow hard hat, radiates focus and experience. She wears a high-visibility orange safety vest over a durable, dusty gray work shirt, and her hands, clad in sturdy work gloves, confidently grip the cold, galvanized metal beams. She ascends with a rhythmic, deliberate cadence, placing her heavy-duty work boots firmly on each beam before pulling herself upward. The scaffolding is bolted to the raw concrete skeleton of a half-built skyscraper, revealing exposed rebar and unfinished floorboards. As the camera continues to tilt upward, the background expands to reveal a vast, busy city skyline: a dense tapestry of glass and steel towers beneath a bright, clear sky. The intense midday sun cast long, sharp shadows from the scaffolding onto the building’s facade, creating stark geometric patterns and causing brilliant reflections of light off the metal surfaces, creating a powerful atmosphere of concentrated labor, human determination, and monumental scale.", + "seed": 26416, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_13/index_4367_seed_26416_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1087666624225676, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1087666624225676, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1087666624225676, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle wide shot that tilts upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female construction worker in her early 40s with long black hair tied in thick braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the worker wearing a bright yellow hard hat, a high-visibility orange safety vest, and a dusty gray work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the worker scaling a vast network of steel scaffolding bolted to a half-built skyscraper with exposed rebar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a busy city skyline with glass and steel towers under a bright clear sky with long sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20756074786186218 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7075607776641846 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20756074786186218, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20756074786186218, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3068389296531677, + 0.08377136290073395, + 0.11618146300315857, + 0.16633638739585876, + 0.06619758158922195, + 0.07798490673303604, + 0.046479471027851105, + 0.034682221710681915, + 0.045270148664712906, + 0.05625755712389946 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20756074786186218 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle wide shot that tilts upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female construction worker in her early 40s with long black hair tied in thick braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the worker wearing a bright yellow hard hat, a high-visibility orange safety vest, and a dusty gray work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the worker scaling a vast network of steel scaffolding bolted to a half-built skyscraper with exposed rebar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a busy city skyline with glass and steel towers under a bright clear sky with long sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22563868761062622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006386280059814 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22563868761062622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22563868761062622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3728073537349701, + 0.09417133778333664, + 0.10503152757883072, + 0.023621516302227974, + 0.01931627281010151, + 0.07343591749668121, + 0.2080075740814209, + 0.0461394228041172, + 0.0250008013099432, + 0.03246833384037018 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22563868761062622 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle wide shot that tilts upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female construction worker in her early 40s with long black hair tied in thick braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the worker wearing a bright yellow hard hat, a high-visibility orange safety vest, and a dusty gray work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the worker scaling a vast network of steel scaffolding bolted to a half-built skyscraper with exposed rebar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a busy city skyline with glass and steel towers under a bright clear sky with long sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036168177612125874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628616809844971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036168177612125874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036168177612125874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37785401940345764, + 0.1036805510520935, + 0.07098111510276794, + 0.023833362385630608, + 0.02873709425330162, + 0.20976805686950684, + 0.07929877191781998, + 0.03776510804891586, + 0.020741913467645645, + 0.04733997583389282 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036168177612125874 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle wide shot that tilts upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female construction worker in her early 40s with long black hair tied in thick braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the worker wearing a bright yellow hard hat, a high-visibility orange safety vest, and a dusty gray work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the worker scaling a vast network of steel scaffolding bolted to a half-built skyscraper with exposed rebar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a busy city skyline with glass and steel towers under a bright clear sky with long sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006731215864419937 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006731033325195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006731215864419937, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006731215864419937, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3875153362751007, + 0.11599791795015335, + 0.09974544495344162, + 0.031092289835214615, + 0.012602284550666809, + 0.11431130021810532, + 0.06331519037485123, + 0.06585188210010529, + 0.06298628449440002, + 0.046582143753767014 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006731215864419937 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle wide shot that tilts upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a female construction worker in her early 40s with long black hair tied in thick braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the worker wearing a bright yellow hard hat, a high-visibility orange safety vest, and a dusty gray work shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the worker scaling a vast network of steel scaffolding bolted to a half-built skyscraper with exposed rebar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a busy city skyline with glass and steel towers under a bright clear sky with long sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1002858430147171 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350285768508911 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1002858430147171, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1002858430147171, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33409157395362854, + 0.11562921106815338, + 0.24960699677467346, + 0.04141588509082794, + 0.02336796745657921, + 0.06281637400388718, + 0.04463651403784752, + 0.04450303688645363, + 0.05723347142338753, + 0.026699010282754898 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1002858430147171 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_14/index_tensor([986, 986])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_14/index_tensor([986, 986])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..59339cf4ad97f260b090b8f832c34472ad93622a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_14/index_tensor([986, 986])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An intimate close-up, using head-tracking to create a natural, handheld selfie-like perspective, closely follows a furry red fox. The fox, with its shaggy, lustrous orange-red fur, speckled with pristine white on its chest and belly, playfully turns in front of the camera in a slow, fluid motion. Warm afternoon sunlight filters through the leaves, dappling its form and creating golden hues across its soft fur, making every hair distinct. As it leisurely turns, its enormous, fluffy tail, tipped with a signature white tinge, gracefully carves a magnificent arc across the frame, fully showcasing its allure. Its amber eyes sparkle with intelligence and curiosity, its black nose twitching slightly. From time to time, it tilts its head, gazing back at the camera with an almost ostentatious gesture, as if engaging directly and playfully with the viewer. The entire scene takes place in a tranquil forest clearing, with the background of emerald green vegetation blurred by the shallow depth of field, creating a relaxed, warm and peaceful atmosphere.", + "seed": 10867, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_14/index_986_seed_10867_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03154847314581275, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03154847314581275, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03154847314581275, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective a close-up with a shallow depth of field that blurs the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to follow a furry red fox in a handheld selfie-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's fur orange-red with white speckles on its chest and belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fox turn slowly and fluidly while its amber eyes sparkle and black nose twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm afternoon sunlight filtering through leaves to create dappled golden hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004404961597174406 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.1294050216674805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004404961597174406, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004404961597174406, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18356849253177643, + 0.05848154425621033, + 0.05377635732293129, + 0.04108094424009323, + 0.39643391966819763, + 0.061840228736400604, + 0.07388442754745483, + 0.02550317347049713, + 0.05522346869111061, + 0.05020745098590851 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004404961597174406 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective a close-up with a shallow depth of field that blurs the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to follow a furry red fox in a handheld selfie-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's fur orange-red with white speckles on its chest and belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fox turn slowly and fluidly while its amber eyes sparkle and black nose twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm afternoon sunlight filtering through leaves to create dappled golden hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05500800535082817 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300079345703125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05500800535082817, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05500800535082817, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08066654950380325, + 0.03825174272060394, + 0.09839391708374023, + 0.03974679484963417, + 0.20344550907611847, + 0.11686799675226212, + 0.15380461513996124, + 0.039564598351716995, + 0.14240139722824097, + 0.08685683459043503 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05500800535082817 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective a close-up with a shallow depth of field that blurs the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to follow a furry red fox in a handheld selfie-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's fur orange-red with white speckles on its chest and belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fox turn slowly and fluidly while its amber eyes sparkle and black nose twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm afternoon sunlight filtering through leaves to create dappled golden hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02635420672595501 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513543128967285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02635420672595501, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02635420672595501, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10033030807971954, + 0.03442995995283127, + 0.061155591160058975, + 0.08515210449695587, + 0.4106149673461914, + 0.05744494870305061, + 0.13079485297203064, + 0.024713242426514626, + 0.02326383627951145, + 0.07210016995668411 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02635420672595501 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective a close-up with a shallow depth of field that blurs the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to follow a furry red fox in a handheld selfie-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's fur orange-red with white speckles on its chest and belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fox turn slowly and fluidly while its amber eyes sparkle and black nose twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm afternoon sunlight filtering through leaves to create dappled golden hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023300884291529655 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773300886154175 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023300884291529655, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023300884291529655, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13524726033210754, + 0.06419337540864944, + 0.05719375982880592, + 0.21918976306915283, + 0.20691949129104614, + 0.08164995163679123, + 0.08432624489068985, + 0.035911738872528076, + 0.048710212111473083, + 0.06665818393230438 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023300884291529655 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective a close-up with a shallow depth of field that blurs the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to follow a furry red fox in a handheld selfie-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's fur orange-red with white speckles on its chest and belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fox turn slowly and fluidly while its amber eyes sparkle and black nose twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm afternoon sunlight filtering through leaves to create dappled golden hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867430776357651 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486743450164795 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867430776357651, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867430776357651, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20690156519412994, + 0.052259497344493866, + 0.04031364619731903, + 0.06524523347616196, + 0.40242114663124084, + 0.05190813168883324, + 0.07400839775800705, + 0.011592435650527477, + 0.04225996881723404, + 0.05308995023369789 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867430776357651 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An intimate close-up, using head-tracking to create a natural, handheld selfie-like perspective, closely follows a furry red fox. The fox, with its shaggy, lustrous orange-red fur, speckled with pristine white on its chest and belly, playfully turns in front of the camera in a slow, fluid motion. Warm afternoon sunlight filters through the leaves, dappling its form and creating golden hues across its soft fur, making every hair distinct. As it leisurely turns, its enormous, fluffy tail, tipped with a signature white tinge, gracefully carves a magnificent arc across the frame, fully showcasing its allure. Its amber eyes sparkle with intelligence and curiosity, its black nose twitching slightly. From time to time, it tilts its head, gazing back at the camera with an almost ostentatious gesture, as if engaging directly and playfully with the viewer. The entire scene takes place in a tranquil forest clearing, with the background of emerald green vegetation blurred by the shallow depth of field, creating a relaxed, warm and peaceful atmosphere.", + "seed": 10868, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_14/index_986_seed_10868_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.05751550402492285, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05751550402492285, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05751550402492285, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective a close-up with a shallow depth of field that blurs the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to follow a furry red fox in a handheld selfie-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's fur orange-red with white speckles on its chest and belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fox turn slowly and fluidly while its amber eyes sparkle and black nose twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm afternoon sunlight filtering through leaves to create dappled golden hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006299045868217945 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.131299018859863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006299045868217945, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006299045868217945, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20336735248565674, + 0.382869154214859, + 0.06767920404672623, + 0.02728450857102871, + 0.0647277906537056, + 0.07902396470308304, + 0.05574013665318489, + 0.0566483810544014, + 0.038499098271131516, + 0.024160446599125862 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006299045868217945 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective a close-up with a shallow depth of field that blurs the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to follow a furry red fox in a handheld selfie-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's fur orange-red with white speckles on its chest and belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fox turn slowly and fluidly while its amber eyes sparkle and black nose twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm afternoon sunlight filtering through leaves to create dappled golden hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11300155520439148 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.238001585006714 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11300155520439148, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11300155520439148, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21278317272663116, + 0.17981812357902527, + 0.09647763520479202, + 0.09740830212831497, + 0.058671627193689346, + 0.10549899190664291, + 0.05279724299907684, + 0.10621862858533859, + 0.050430212169885635, + 0.03989608213305473 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11300155520439148 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective a close-up with a shallow depth of field that blurs the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to follow a furry red fox in a handheld selfie-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's fur orange-red with white speckles on its chest and belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fox turn slowly and fluidly while its amber eyes sparkle and black nose twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm afternoon sunlight filtering through leaves to create dappled golden hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020586160942912102 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955862522125244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020586160942912102, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020586160942912102, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14692802727222443, + 0.34540125727653503, + 0.14560827612876892, + 0.04017745330929756, + 0.08386796712875366, + 0.04767630249261856, + 0.0615793839097023, + 0.06187712773680687, + 0.030512776225805283, + 0.03637143597006798 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020586160942912102 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective a close-up with a shallow depth of field that blurs the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to follow a furry red fox in a handheld selfie-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's fur orange-red with white speckles on its chest and belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fox turn slowly and fluidly while its amber eyes sparkle and black nose twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm afternoon sunlight filtering through leaves to create dappled golden hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020596086978912354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955960273742676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020596086978912354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020596086978912354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.068651482462883, + 0.08616000413894653, + 0.07182995229959488, + 0.11775973439216614, + 0.06524346768856049, + 0.11970001459121704, + 0.07750532776117325, + 0.18621709942817688, + 0.10143516212701797, + 0.10549776256084442 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020596086978912354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective a close-up with a shallow depth of field that blurs the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to follow a furry red fox in a handheld selfie-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's fur orange-red with white speckles on its chest and belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fox turn slowly and fluidly while its amber eyes sparkle and black nose twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm afternoon sunlight filtering through leaves to create dappled golden hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12709467113018036 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270947456359863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12709467113018036, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12709467113018036, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2655934691429138, + 0.18462954461574554, + 0.06325295567512512, + 0.0565931536257267, + 0.03938029333949089, + 0.06887160241603851, + 0.055080074816942215, + 0.16224730014801025, + 0.044007666409015656, + 0.06034395098686218 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12709467113018036 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An intimate close-up, using head-tracking to create a natural, handheld selfie-like perspective, closely follows a furry red fox. The fox, with its shaggy, lustrous orange-red fur, speckled with pristine white on its chest and belly, playfully turns in front of the camera in a slow, fluid motion. Warm afternoon sunlight filters through the leaves, dappling its form and creating golden hues across its soft fur, making every hair distinct. As it leisurely turns, its enormous, fluffy tail, tipped with a signature white tinge, gracefully carves a magnificent arc across the frame, fully showcasing its allure. Its amber eyes sparkle with intelligence and curiosity, its black nose twitching slightly. From time to time, it tilts its head, gazing back at the camera with an almost ostentatious gesture, as if engaging directly and playfully with the viewer. The entire scene takes place in a tranquil forest clearing, with the background of emerald green vegetation blurred by the shallow depth of field, creating a relaxed, warm and peaceful atmosphere.", + "seed": 10869, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_14/index_986_seed_10869_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.042210311815142634, + "vlm_logprob": -0.042210311815142634, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3749999523162844, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.042210311815142634, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective a close-up with a shallow depth of field that blurs the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to follow a furry red fox in a handheld selfie-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's fur orange-red with white speckles on its chest and belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fox turn slowly and fluidly while its amber eyes sparkle and black nose twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm afternoon sunlight filtering through leaves to create dappled golden hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023061756044626236 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.898061752319336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023061756044626236, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023061756044626236, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.01035598199814558, + 0.006124851293861866, + 0.01415321882814169, + 0.007863226346671581, + 0.9280716180801392, + 0.014037622138857841, + 0.0030329027213156223, + 0.010182046331465244, + 0.0038214351516216993, + 0.0023570668417960405 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023061756044626236 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective a close-up with a shallow depth of field that blurs the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to follow a furry red fox in a handheld selfie-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's fur orange-red with white speckles on its chest and belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fox turn slowly and fluidly while its amber eyes sparkle and black nose twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm afternoon sunlight filtering through leaves to create dappled golden hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10036930441856384 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503692150115967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10036930441856384, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10036930441856384, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.007809895556420088, + 0.006868529133498669, + 0.032104358077049255, + 0.021654320880770683, + 0.8194849491119385, + 0.07857964932918549, + 0.009880848228931427, + 0.008439406752586365, + 0.012069439515471458, + 0.0031085847876966 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10036930441856384 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective a close-up with a shallow depth of field that blurs the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to follow a furry red fox in a handheld selfie-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's fur orange-red with white speckles on its chest and belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fox turn slowly and fluidly while its amber eyes sparkle and black nose twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm afternoon sunlight filtering through leaves to create dappled golden hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02635200135409832 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513519287109375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02635200135409832, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02635200135409832, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.011722064577043056, + 0.0045830425806343555, + 0.012666543014347553, + 0.010495354421436787, + 0.9359368681907654, + 0.009516855701804161, + 0.0036587854847311974, + 0.00618191109970212, + 0.0018516534473747015, + 0.003386927302926779 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02635200135409832 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective a close-up with a shallow depth of field that blurs the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to follow a furry red fox in a handheld selfie-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's fur orange-red with white speckles on its chest and belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fox turn slowly and fluidly while its amber eyes sparkle and black nose twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm afternoon sunlight filtering through leaves to create dappled golden hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018195848912000656 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018195629119873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018195848912000656, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018195848912000656, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.004732364322990179, + 0.002439407166093588, + 0.003190853400155902, + 0.005356433801352978, + 0.9274224638938904, + 0.047440048307180405, + 0.005104741081595421, + 0.0024316133931279182, + 0.0006687771528959274, + 0.001213292358443141 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018195848912000656 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective a close-up with a shallow depth of field that blurs the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to follow a furry red fox in a handheld selfie-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's fur orange-red with white speckles on its chest and belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fox turn slowly and fluidly while its amber eyes sparkle and black nose twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm afternoon sunlight filtering through leaves to create dappled golden hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0430726483464241 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680727005004883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0430726483464241, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0430726483464241, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03621283546090126, + 0.03944692388176918, + 0.1315668821334839, + 0.01322533842176199, + 0.4642021954059601, + 0.2574016749858856, + 0.02572556398808956, + 0.00869743525981903, + 0.014007067307829857, + 0.009514085948467255 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0430726483464241 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An intimate close-up, using head-tracking to create a natural, handheld selfie-like perspective, closely follows a furry red fox. The fox, with its shaggy, lustrous orange-red fur, speckled with pristine white on its chest and belly, playfully turns in front of the camera in a slow, fluid motion. Warm afternoon sunlight filters through the leaves, dappling its form and creating golden hues across its soft fur, making every hair distinct. As it leisurely turns, its enormous, fluffy tail, tipped with a signature white tinge, gracefully carves a magnificent arc across the frame, fully showcasing its allure. Its amber eyes sparkle with intelligence and curiosity, its black nose twitching slightly. From time to time, it tilts its head, gazing back at the camera with an almost ostentatious gesture, as if engaging directly and playfully with the viewer. The entire scene takes place in a tranquil forest clearing, with the background of emerald green vegetation blurred by the shallow depth of field, creating a relaxed, warm and peaceful atmosphere.", + "seed": 10870, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_14/index_986_seed_10870_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07065953901037574, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07065953901037574, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07065953901037574, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective a close-up with a shallow depth of field that blurs the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to follow a furry red fox in a handheld selfie-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's fur orange-red with white speckles on its chest and belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fox turn slowly and fluidly while its amber eyes sparkle and black nose twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm afternoon sunlight filtering through leaves to create dappled golden hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005022290628403425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.1300225257873535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005022290628403425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005022290628403425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16521330177783966, + 0.04806489497423172, + 0.10884633660316467, + 0.09400752931833267, + 0.3085240125656128, + 0.04126729816198349, + 0.033551767468452454, + 0.04052027314901352, + 0.076976478099823, + 0.08302813768386841 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005022290628403425 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective a close-up with a shallow depth of field that blurs the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to follow a furry red fox in a handheld selfie-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's fur orange-red with white speckles on its chest and belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fox turn slowly and fluidly while its amber eyes sparkle and black nose twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm afternoon sunlight filtering through leaves to create dappled golden hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1799771785736084 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049771785736084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1799771785736084, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1799771785736084, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18247553706169128, + 0.05892306566238403, + 0.1086883395910263, + 0.08244206011295319, + 0.14892064034938812, + 0.08249259740114212, + 0.1437026709318161, + 0.03148908168077469, + 0.06282640993595123, + 0.09803959727287292 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1799771785736084 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective a close-up with a shallow depth of field that blurs the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to follow a furry red fox in a handheld selfie-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's fur orange-red with white speckles on its chest and belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fox turn slowly and fluidly while its amber eyes sparkle and black nose twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm afternoon sunlight filtering through leaves to create dappled golden hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029807809740304947 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298078060150146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029807809740304947, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029807809740304947, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11821030080318451, + 0.04038187861442566, + 0.12342926859855652, + 0.08096620440483093, + 0.2025856226682663, + 0.05789153277873993, + 0.17094917595386505, + 0.03132539242506027, + 0.023313967511057854, + 0.15094666182994843 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029807809740304947 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective a close-up with a shallow depth of field that blurs the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to follow a furry red fox in a handheld selfie-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's fur orange-red with white speckles on its chest and belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fox turn slowly and fluidly while its amber eyes sparkle and black nose twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm afternoon sunlight filtering through leaves to create dappled golden hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0381166934967041 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288116693496704 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0381166934967041, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0381166934967041, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14872460067272186, + 0.09463496506214142, + 0.04699607938528061, + 0.12498301267623901, + 0.060768287628889084, + 0.07056368142366409, + 0.07758595794439316, + 0.09257078915834427, + 0.13472408056259155, + 0.14844855666160583 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0381166934967041 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective a close-up with a shallow depth of field that blurs the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to follow a furry red fox in a handheld selfie-like perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's fur orange-red with white speckles on its chest and belly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fox turn slowly and fluidly while its amber eyes sparkle and black nose twitches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm afternoon sunlight filtering through leaves to create dappled golden hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10037372261285782 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503737449645996 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10037372261285782, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10037372261285782, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16874215006828308, + 0.07733311504125595, + 0.052929818630218506, + 0.09754348546266556, + 0.04660694673657417, + 0.08926604688167572, + 0.07985475659370422, + 0.0211916696280241, + 0.057673387229442596, + 0.3088586628437042 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10037372261285782 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_15/index_tensor([8335, 8335])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_15/index_tensor([8335, 8335])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..140526a67b0e47bd492bffc2a9239ea9cf71ede3 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_15/index_tensor([8335, 8335])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "perfectly still, fixed medium shot steadily draws the viewer's gaze deep into a surreal jungle composed of countless finely detailed voxel blocks. At the center of the frame, a tree frog, its skin composed entirely of vibrant green and emerald blocks, perches intently on a thick vine constructed from dark brown voxels. Its enormous, crimson eyes, like two blazing rubies, are composed of translucent red voxels, emanating a steady, intense glimmer from their cores, casting a soft red glow over the surrounding scene. The frog's body tenses slightly with concentration as it carefully executes a delicate creation with its long, distinct, blocky forelimbs. One paw gently grasps a flexible vein of luminescent golden voxels, peeled from a massive leaf, while the other deftly holds a spherical dewdrop composed of shimmering white and pale blue voxels. With a steady and leisurely rhythm, the frog skillfully twists and weaves the glowing leaf veins around these nodes of luminescent dewdrops. A complex and orderly nest structure, resembling a geodesic dome, gradually takes shape before it. The entire background is a deep, lush vegetation composed of dark green and black voxels. Only the light of the frog's eyes, the golden lines of the leaf veins, and the cool glow of the dewdrops penetrate this digital darkness, casting an ever-changing, sharp-edged pixelated light and shadow on the blocky leaves and branches, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and focused creation that is both primitive and futuristic.", + "seed": 7454, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_15/index_8335_seed_7454_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1784083940088749, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1784083940088749, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1784083940088749, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene composed of finely detailed voxel blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tree frog with vibrant green and emerald blocky skin visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture composed of translucent red voxels forming crimson eyes that emit a soft red glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the frog actively twisting and weaving glowing golden leaf veins around spherical white and pale blue dewdrop voxels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, lush vegetation of dark green and black voxels with sharp-edged pixelated light and shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2157367467880249 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.715736746788025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2157367467880249, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2157367467880249, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10527895390987396, + 0.26894742250442505, + 0.28751036524772644, + 0.01813392899930477, + 0.06564681231975555, + 0.0598859004676342, + 0.06068943068385124, + 0.011836979538202286, + 0.033540885895490646, + 0.08852938562631607 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2157367467880249 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene composed of finely detailed voxel blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tree frog with vibrant green and emerald blocky skin visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture composed of translucent red voxels forming crimson eyes that emit a soft red glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the frog actively twisting and weaving glowing golden leaf veins around spherical white and pale blue dewdrop voxels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, lush vegetation of dark green and black voxels with sharp-edged pixelated light and shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032055205665528774 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753205299377441 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032055205665528774, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032055205665528774, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07531069964170456, + 0.06959406286478043, + 0.1133275106549263, + 0.02727290242910385, + 0.10904773324728012, + 0.32007747888565063, + 0.13936886191368103, + 0.01907031424343586, + 0.05881136655807495, + 0.06811905652284622 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032055205665528774 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene composed of finely detailed voxel blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tree frog with vibrant green and emerald blocky skin visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture composed of translucent red voxels forming crimson eyes that emit a soft red glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the frog actively twisting and weaving glowing golden leaf veins around spherical white and pale blue dewdrop voxels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, lush vegetation of dark green and black voxels with sharp-edged pixelated light and shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038106709718704224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288106679916382 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038106709718704224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038106709718704224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09033801406621933, + 0.16562268137931824, + 0.08333981782197952, + 0.13282395899295807, + 0.19020035862922668, + 0.18420419096946716, + 0.06274551153182983, + 0.012989300303161144, + 0.01842600665986538, + 0.05931016430258751 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038106709718704224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene composed of finely detailed voxel blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tree frog with vibrant green and emerald blocky skin visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture composed of translucent red voxels forming crimson eyes that emit a soft red glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the frog actively twisting and weaving glowing golden leaf veins around spherical white and pale blue dewdrop voxels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, lush vegetation of dark green and black voxels with sharp-edged pixelated light and shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6327993273735046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7577993273735046 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6327993273735046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6327993273735046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1058957651257515, + 0.07812265306711197, + 0.15700268745422363, + 0.03810494393110275, + 0.1272851526737213, + 0.07652263343334198, + 0.17166577279567719, + 0.03893003985285759, + 0.04471798986196518, + 0.16175226867198944 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6327993273735046 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene composed of finely detailed voxel blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tree frog with vibrant green and emerald blocky skin visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture composed of translucent red voxels forming crimson eyes that emit a soft red glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the frog actively twisting and weaving glowing golden leaf veins around spherical white and pale blue dewdrop voxels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, lush vegetation of dark green and black voxels with sharp-edged pixelated light and shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002193665597587824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127193450927734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002193665597587824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002193665597587824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22235101461410522, + 0.1229625716805458, + 0.2048817276954651, + 0.03432072699069977, + 0.060838643461465836, + 0.09017616510391235, + 0.07614650577306747, + 0.08084230124950409, + 0.03226177766919136, + 0.075218565762043 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002193665597587824 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "perfectly still, fixed medium shot steadily draws the viewer's gaze deep into a surreal jungle composed of countless finely detailed voxel blocks. At the center of the frame, a tree frog, its skin composed entirely of vibrant green and emerald blocks, perches intently on a thick vine constructed from dark brown voxels. Its enormous, crimson eyes, like two blazing rubies, are composed of translucent red voxels, emanating a steady, intense glimmer from their cores, casting a soft red glow over the surrounding scene. The frog's body tenses slightly with concentration as it carefully executes a delicate creation with its long, distinct, blocky forelimbs. One paw gently grasps a flexible vein of luminescent golden voxels, peeled from a massive leaf, while the other deftly holds a spherical dewdrop composed of shimmering white and pale blue voxels. With a steady and leisurely rhythm, the frog skillfully twists and weaves the glowing leaf veins around these nodes of luminescent dewdrops. A complex and orderly nest structure, resembling a geodesic dome, gradually takes shape before it. The entire background is a deep, lush vegetation composed of dark green and black voxels. Only the light of the frog's eyes, the golden lines of the leaf veins, and the cool glow of the dewdrops penetrate this digital darkness, casting an ever-changing, sharp-edged pixelated light and shadow on the blocky leaves and branches, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and focused creation that is both primitive and futuristic.", + "seed": 7455, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_15/index_8335_seed_7455_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.1807290803641081, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1807290803641081, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1807290803641081, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene composed of finely detailed voxel blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tree frog with vibrant green and emerald blocky skin visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture composed of translucent red voxels forming crimson eyes that emit a soft red glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the frog actively twisting and weaving glowing golden leaf veins around spherical white and pale blue dewdrop voxels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, lush vegetation of dark green and black voxels with sharp-edged pixelated light and shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14902108907699585 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0240211486816406 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14902108907699585, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14902108907699585, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4303969442844391, + 0.10545981675386429, + 0.02935074269771576, + 0.030984556302428246, + 0.06414039433002472, + 0.07098103314638138, + 0.11792635917663574, + 0.056950729340314865, + 0.057171422988176346, + 0.03663801774382591 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14902108907699585 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene composed of finely detailed voxel blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tree frog with vibrant green and emerald blocky skin visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture composed of translucent red voxels forming crimson eyes that emit a soft red glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the frog actively twisting and weaving glowing golden leaf veins around spherical white and pale blue dewdrop voxels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, lush vegetation of dark green and black voxels with sharp-edged pixelated light and shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004107610322535038 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504107475280762 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004107610322535038, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004107610322535038, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25782719254493713, + 0.1924072802066803, + 0.05494653433561325, + 0.04044204205274582, + 0.07043584436178207, + 0.115359365940094, + 0.05567898228764534, + 0.04906662553548813, + 0.08237653225660324, + 0.08145956695079803 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004107610322535038 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene composed of finely detailed voxel blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tree frog with vibrant green and emerald blocky skin visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture composed of translucent red voxels forming crimson eyes that emit a soft red glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the frog actively twisting and weaving glowing golden leaf veins around spherical white and pale blue dewdrop voxels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, lush vegetation of dark green and black voxels with sharp-edged pixelated light and shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496366322040558 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299635887145996 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496366322040558, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496366322040558, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1749296337366104, + 0.23334352672100067, + 0.04697740823030472, + 0.06149306148290634, + 0.04867761209607124, + 0.2128661423921585, + 0.029235059395432472, + 0.041343457996845245, + 0.053878165781497955, + 0.0972558930516243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496366322040558 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene composed of finely detailed voxel blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tree frog with vibrant green and emerald blocky skin visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture composed of translucent red voxels forming crimson eyes that emit a soft red glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the frog actively twisting and weaving glowing golden leaf veins around spherical white and pale blue dewdrop voxels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, lush vegetation of dark green and black voxels with sharp-edged pixelated light and shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933586597442627 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933586597442627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6933586597442627, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6933586597442627, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19695697724819183, + 0.40127313137054443, + 0.08611776679754257, + 0.06703981012105942, + 0.046542827039957047, + 0.043236568570137024, + 0.030263785272836685, + 0.030485723167657852, + 0.026268426328897476, + 0.07181499153375626 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6933586597442627 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene composed of finely detailed voxel blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tree frog with vibrant green and emerald blocky skin visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture composed of translucent red voxels forming crimson eyes that emit a soft red glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the frog actively twisting and weaving glowing golden leaf veins around spherical white and pale blue dewdrop voxels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, lush vegetation of dark green and black voxels with sharp-edged pixelated light and shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021943794563412666 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127194404602051 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021943794563412666, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021943794563412666, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.504236102104187, + 0.1355445832014084, + 0.03305112197995186, + 0.05503183230757713, + 0.035173170268535614, + 0.04825201630592346, + 0.07807871699333191, + 0.052012380212545395, + 0.024375205859541893, + 0.03424487262964249 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021943794563412666 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "perfectly still, fixed medium shot steadily draws the viewer's gaze deep into a surreal jungle composed of countless finely detailed voxel blocks. At the center of the frame, a tree frog, its skin composed entirely of vibrant green and emerald blocks, perches intently on a thick vine constructed from dark brown voxels. Its enormous, crimson eyes, like two blazing rubies, are composed of translucent red voxels, emanating a steady, intense glimmer from their cores, casting a soft red glow over the surrounding scene. The frog's body tenses slightly with concentration as it carefully executes a delicate creation with its long, distinct, blocky forelimbs. One paw gently grasps a flexible vein of luminescent golden voxels, peeled from a massive leaf, while the other deftly holds a spherical dewdrop composed of shimmering white and pale blue voxels. With a steady and leisurely rhythm, the frog skillfully twists and weaves the glowing leaf veins around these nodes of luminescent dewdrops. A complex and orderly nest structure, resembling a geodesic dome, gradually takes shape before it. The entire background is a deep, lush vegetation composed of dark green and black voxels. Only the light of the frog's eyes, the golden lines of the leaf veins, and the cool glow of the dewdrops penetrate this digital darkness, casting an ever-changing, sharp-edged pixelated light and shadow on the blocky leaves and branches, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and focused creation that is both primitive and futuristic.", + "seed": 7456, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_15/index_8335_seed_7456_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.09112912626005709, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09112912626005709, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.424999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09112912626005709, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene composed of finely detailed voxel blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tree frog with vibrant green and emerald blocky skin visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture composed of translucent red voxels forming crimson eyes that emit a soft red glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the frog actively twisting and weaving glowing golden leaf veins around spherical white and pale blue dewdrop voxels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, lush vegetation of dark green and black voxels with sharp-edged pixelated light and shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20923888683319092 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.709238886833191 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20923888683319092, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20923888683319092, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2916056215763092, + 0.10022800415754318, + 0.0608583465218544, + 0.04549868032336235, + 0.04079598933458328, + 0.08824782818555832, + 0.08119726926088333, + 0.10447828471660614, + 0.07028664648532867, + 0.11680334061384201 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20923888683319092 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene composed of finely detailed voxel blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tree frog with vibrant green and emerald blocky skin visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture composed of translucent red voxels forming crimson eyes that emit a soft red glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the frog actively twisting and weaving glowing golden leaf veins around spherical white and pale blue dewdrop voxels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, lush vegetation of dark green and black voxels with sharp-edged pixelated light and shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036267952527850866 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628626823425293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036267952527850866, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036267952527850866, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1801898330450058, + 0.08918014913797379, + 0.07213769853115082, + 0.043715279549360275, + 0.040497418493032455, + 0.09812565892934799, + 0.1081182137131691, + 0.19500085711479187, + 0.11182773113250732, + 0.061207160353660583 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036267952527850866 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene composed of finely detailed voxel blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tree frog with vibrant green and emerald blocky skin visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture composed of translucent red voxels forming crimson eyes that emit a soft red glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the frog actively twisting and weaving glowing golden leaf veins around spherical white and pale blue dewdrop voxels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, lush vegetation of dark green and black voxels with sharp-edged pixelated light and shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11292733997106552 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379274368286133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11292733997106552, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11292733997106552, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20820024609565735, + 0.16268587112426758, + 0.09128694236278534, + 0.044652584940195084, + 0.041751373559236526, + 0.06871706992387772, + 0.06958355009555817, + 0.11559893190860748, + 0.11281638592481613, + 0.08470708131790161 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11292733997106552 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene composed of finely detailed voxel blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tree frog with vibrant green and emerald blocky skin visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture composed of translucent red voxels forming crimson eyes that emit a soft red glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the frog actively twisting and weaving glowing golden leaf veins around spherical white and pale blue dewdrop voxels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, lush vegetation of dark green and black voxels with sharp-edged pixelated light and shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12703882157802582 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270387172698975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12703882157802582, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12703882157802582, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2629574239253998, + 0.08258473873138428, + 0.044386688619852066, + 0.05861077085137367, + 0.10491183400154114, + 0.10543069243431091, + 0.0719442144036293, + 0.09734517335891724, + 0.061240263283252716, + 0.1105881780385971 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12703882157802582 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene composed of finely detailed voxel blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tree frog with vibrant green and emerald blocky skin visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture composed of translucent red voxels forming crimson eyes that emit a soft red glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the frog actively twisting and weaving glowing golden leaf veins around spherical white and pale blue dewdrop voxels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, lush vegetation of dark green and black voxels with sharp-edged pixelated light and shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002813787665218115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877813816070557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002813787665218115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002813787665218115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3160548806190491, + 0.18874317407608032, + 0.12366709858179092, + 0.04044834524393082, + 0.05297696217894554, + 0.04859844595193863, + 0.0265605878084898, + 0.10518494248390198, + 0.0752246230840683, + 0.022540951147675514 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002813787665218115 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "perfectly still, fixed medium shot steadily draws the viewer's gaze deep into a surreal jungle composed of countless finely detailed voxel blocks. At the center of the frame, a tree frog, its skin composed entirely of vibrant green and emerald blocks, perches intently on a thick vine constructed from dark brown voxels. Its enormous, crimson eyes, like two blazing rubies, are composed of translucent red voxels, emanating a steady, intense glimmer from their cores, casting a soft red glow over the surrounding scene. The frog's body tenses slightly with concentration as it carefully executes a delicate creation with its long, distinct, blocky forelimbs. One paw gently grasps a flexible vein of luminescent golden voxels, peeled from a massive leaf, while the other deftly holds a spherical dewdrop composed of shimmering white and pale blue voxels. With a steady and leisurely rhythm, the frog skillfully twists and weaves the glowing leaf veins around these nodes of luminescent dewdrops. A complex and orderly nest structure, resembling a geodesic dome, gradually takes shape before it. The entire background is a deep, lush vegetation composed of dark green and black voxels. Only the light of the frog's eyes, the golden lines of the leaf veins, and the cool glow of the dewdrops penetrate this digital darkness, casting an ever-changing, sharp-edged pixelated light and shadow on the blocky leaves and branches, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and focused creation that is both primitive and futuristic.", + "seed": 7457, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_15/index_8335_seed_7457_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10554736535996198, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10554736535996198, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10554736535996198, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene composed of finely detailed voxel blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tree frog with vibrant green and emerald blocky skin visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture composed of translucent red voxels forming crimson eyes that emit a soft red glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the frog actively twisting and weaving glowing golden leaf veins around spherical white and pale blue dewdrop voxels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, lush vegetation of dark green and black voxels with sharp-edged pixelated light and shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2869475185871124 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.41194748878479 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2869475185871124, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2869475185871124, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19127017259597778, + 0.05373397842049599, + 0.105838842689991, + 0.1373697817325592, + 0.11565699428319931, + 0.09765055775642395, + 0.07499460130929947, + 0.14421012997627258, + 0.04965875297784805, + 0.02961617335677147 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2869475185871124 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene composed of finely detailed voxel blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tree frog with vibrant green and emerald blocky skin visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture composed of translucent red voxels forming crimson eyes that emit a soft red glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the frog actively twisting and weaving glowing golden leaf veins around spherical white and pale blue dewdrop voxels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, lush vegetation of dark green and black voxels with sharp-edged pixelated light and shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023297857493162155 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732977867126465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023297857493162155, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023297857493162155, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.350419282913208, + 0.05137786641716957, + 0.16251277923583984, + 0.15476922690868378, + 0.04786207899451256, + 0.09501444548368454, + 0.035666778683662415, + 0.03223623335361481, + 0.06071566417813301, + 0.009425658732652664 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023297857493162155 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene composed of finely detailed voxel blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tree frog with vibrant green and emerald blocky skin visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture composed of translucent red voxels forming crimson eyes that emit a soft red glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the frog actively twisting and weaving glowing golden leaf veins around spherical white and pale blue dewdrop voxels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, lush vegetation of dark green and black voxels with sharp-edged pixelated light and shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003326714038849 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695033311843872 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003326714038849, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003326714038849, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18080304563045502, + 0.06227762997150421, + 0.14783228933811188, + 0.12483470141887665, + 0.12087191641330719, + 0.1858387440443039, + 0.025385107845067978, + 0.03303191810846329, + 0.0917501151561737, + 0.02737455628812313 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003326714038849 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene composed of finely detailed voxel blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tree frog with vibrant green and emerald blocky skin visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture composed of translucent red voxels forming crimson eyes that emit a soft red glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the frog actively twisting and weaving glowing golden leaf veins around spherical white and pale blue dewdrop voxels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, lush vegetation of dark green and black voxels with sharp-edged pixelated light and shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428237110376358 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178236961364746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428237110376358, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428237110376358, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3045765161514282, + 0.08305682986974716, + 0.18351787328720093, + 0.14477574825286865, + 0.06784918904304504, + 0.052266523241996765, + 0.031152425333857536, + 0.0393000990152359, + 0.05959809944033623, + 0.03390667960047722 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428237110376358 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene composed of finely detailed voxel blocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tree frog with vibrant green and emerald blocky skin visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture composed of translucent red voxels forming crimson eyes that emit a soft red glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the frog actively twisting and weaving glowing golden leaf veins around spherical white and pale blue dewdrop voxels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, lush vegetation of dark green and black voxels with sharp-edged pixelated light and shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004634472541511059 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379634380340576 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004634472541511059, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004634472541511059, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13081830739974976, + 0.03807791694998741, + 0.030819211155176163, + 0.09139221906661987, + 0.04561132192611694, + 0.044393882155418396, + 0.16969142854213715, + 0.3288690149784088, + 0.053521331399679184, + 0.06680542975664139 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004634472541511059 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_2/index_tensor([9613, 9613])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_2/index_tensor([9613, 9613])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0e98e7f27621c857465521ecaf42e7a7c1aca88e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_2/index_tensor([9613, 9613])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a warm, pixelated close-up shot reminiscent of Stardew Valley, a slightly shaky handheld camera closely follows the curious movements of a vibrantly colored red-eyed tree frog. With smooth, moist, bright green pixelated skin, a milky white belly, and striking blue and yellow stripes on its flanks, the frog cautiously emerges from behind a large, dark green taro leaf, dotted with glistening pixelated dewdrops. Its movements are slow and deliberate, with only its head and large, bulging scarlet eyes poking over the leaf's edge. It then secures a firm grip with its bright orange suction cups on its forelimbs and slowly pushes its body forward. Soft, golden sunlight filters through the pixelated jungle canopy, dappling the scene and illuminating the frog's contours and the rich textures of the leaf, giving its moist skin a subtle sheen. The entire scene is imbued with a tranquil and exploratory atmosphere. The saturated warm colors, captivating pixel art style, and the intimate camera angles that follow create a microscopic world brimming with life and wonder.", + "seed": 4576, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_2/index_9613_seed_4576_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.018680411390960217, + "vlm_logprob": -0.018680411390960217, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.018680411390960217, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style pixelated and reminiscent of Stardew Valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-eyed tree frog with bright green skin, a milky white belly, and blue and yellow stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the frog emerge from behind a large, dark green taro leaf dotted with pixelated dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the frog use its bright orange suction cups on its forelimbs to push its body forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up with a slightly shaky handheld movement following the frog?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00997227430343628 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.759972095489502 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00997227430343628, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00997227430343628, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11208073794841766, + 0.07327016443014145, + 0.040023185312747955, + 0.042472150176763535, + 0.08251794427633286, + 0.06109016761183739, + 0.02956804260611534, + 0.2727278470993042, + 0.22103093564510345, + 0.06521883606910706 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00997227430343628 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style pixelated and reminiscent of Stardew Valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-eyed tree frog with bright green skin, a milky white belly, and blue and yellow stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the frog emerge from behind a large, dark green taro leaf dotted with pixelated dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the frog use its bright orange suction cups on its forelimbs to push its body forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up with a slightly shaky handheld movement following the frog?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978943519294262 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63478946685791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978943519294262, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978943519294262, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11722627282142639, + 0.12048546224832535, + 0.03605395555496216, + 0.04337418079376221, + 0.10619376599788666, + 0.09414699673652649, + 0.12115124613046646, + 0.07871466875076294, + 0.2084847241640091, + 0.07416872680187225 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978943519294262 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style pixelated and reminiscent of Stardew Valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-eyed tree frog with bright green skin, a milky white belly, and blue and yellow stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the frog emerge from behind a large, dark green taro leaf dotted with pixelated dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the frog use its bright orange suction cups on its forelimbs to push its body forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up with a slightly shaky handheld movement following the frog?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011071440763771534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51107120513916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011071440763771534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011071440763771534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16440650820732117, + 0.11076189577579498, + 0.025902722030878067, + 0.01795082539319992, + 0.13563042879104614, + 0.16614992916584015, + 0.05448048561811447, + 0.1024613007903099, + 0.1785663366317749, + 0.04368960112333298 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011071440763771534 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style pixelated and reminiscent of Stardew Valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-eyed tree frog with bright green skin, a milky white belly, and blue and yellow stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the frog emerge from behind a large, dark green taro leaf dotted with pixelated dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the frog use its bright orange suction cups on its forelimbs to push its body forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up with a slightly shaky handheld movement following the frog?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054945044219493866 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299449920654297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054945044219493866, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054945044219493866, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1148582473397255, + 0.13799890875816345, + 0.036002762615680695, + 0.07827521115541458, + 0.18052862584590912, + 0.1570870280265808, + 0.07089072465896606, + 0.051923297345638275, + 0.13064196705818176, + 0.04179324209690094 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054945044219493866 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style pixelated and reminiscent of Stardew Valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-eyed tree frog with bright green skin, a milky white belly, and blue and yellow stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the frog emerge from behind a large, dark green taro leaf dotted with pixelated dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the frog use its bright orange suction cups on its forelimbs to push its body forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up with a slightly shaky handheld movement following the frog?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007623862475156784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882623672485352 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007623862475156784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007623862475156784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10190171748399734, + 0.09915201365947723, + 0.03066563419997692, + 0.03809038922190666, + 0.14654536545276642, + 0.16155961155891418, + 0.062360092997550964, + 0.09736696630716324, + 0.20330193638801575, + 0.059056274592876434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007623862475156784 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a warm, pixelated close-up shot reminiscent of Stardew Valley, a slightly shaky handheld camera closely follows the curious movements of a vibrantly colored red-eyed tree frog. With smooth, moist, bright green pixelated skin, a milky white belly, and striking blue and yellow stripes on its flanks, the frog cautiously emerges from behind a large, dark green taro leaf, dotted with glistening pixelated dewdrops. Its movements are slow and deliberate, with only its head and large, bulging scarlet eyes poking over the leaf's edge. It then secures a firm grip with its bright orange suction cups on its forelimbs and slowly pushes its body forward. Soft, golden sunlight filters through the pixelated jungle canopy, dappling the scene and illuminating the frog's contours and the rich textures of the leaf, giving its moist skin a subtle sheen. The entire scene is imbued with a tranquil and exploratory atmosphere. The saturated warm colors, captivating pixel art style, and the intimate camera angles that follow create a microscopic world brimming with life and wonder.", + "seed": 4577, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_2/index_9613_seed_4577_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.020398435276001693, + "vlm_logprob": -0.020398435276001693, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.020398435276001693, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style pixelated and reminiscent of Stardew Valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-eyed tree frog with bright green skin, a milky white belly, and blue and yellow stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the frog emerge from behind a large, dark green taro leaf dotted with pixelated dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the frog use its bright orange suction cups on its forelimbs to push its body forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up with a slightly shaky handheld movement following the frog?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007887882180511951 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.132887840270996 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007887882180511951, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007887882180511951, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17853966355323792, + 0.10704857110977173, + 0.05226263403892517, + 0.10282886028289795, + 0.05908028036355972, + 0.027749601751565933, + 0.24771340191364288, + 0.054738134145736694, + 0.084160715341568, + 0.08587814122438431 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007887882180511951 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style pixelated and reminiscent of Stardew Valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-eyed tree frog with bright green skin, a milky white belly, and blue and yellow stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the frog emerge from behind a large, dark green taro leaf dotted with pixelated dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the frog use its bright orange suction cups on its forelimbs to push its body forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up with a slightly shaky handheld movement following the frog?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005260791163891554 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255260944366455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005260791163891554, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005260791163891554, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05009569600224495, + 0.09025733917951584, + 0.04601438716053963, + 0.0792902484536171, + 0.11590075492858887, + 0.01140703447163105, + 0.3840155601501465, + 0.06321438401937485, + 0.1399390548467636, + 0.019865548238158226 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005260791163891554 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style pixelated and reminiscent of Stardew Valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-eyed tree frog with bright green skin, a milky white belly, and blue and yellow stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the frog emerge from behind a large, dark green taro leaf dotted with pixelated dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the frog use its bright orange suction cups on its forelimbs to push its body forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up with a slightly shaky handheld movement following the frog?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018179696053266525 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018179893493652 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018179696053266525, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018179696053266525, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2517992854118347, + 0.05259598791599274, + 0.07234591245651245, + 0.1854884922504425, + 0.16767391562461853, + 0.031024064868688583, + 0.07456297427415848, + 0.05035420507192612, + 0.07933595031499863, + 0.03481924533843994 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018179696053266525 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style pixelated and reminiscent of Stardew Valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-eyed tree frog with bright green skin, a milky white belly, and blue and yellow stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the frog emerge from behind a large, dark green taro leaf dotted with pixelated dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the frog use its bright orange suction cups on its forelimbs to push its body forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up with a slightly shaky handheld movement following the frog?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06203002110123634 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812030076980591 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06203002110123634, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06203002110123634, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11639855057001114, + 0.09130740910768509, + 0.10945651680231094, + 0.11593255400657654, + 0.18250751495361328, + 0.045084986835718155, + 0.08981728553771973, + 0.06773243844509125, + 0.12791790068149567, + 0.05384477227926254 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06203002110123634 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style pixelated and reminiscent of Stardew Valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-eyed tree frog with bright green skin, a milky white belly, and blue and yellow stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the frog emerge from behind a large, dark green taro leaf dotted with pixelated dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the frog use its bright orange suction cups on its forelimbs to push its body forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up with a slightly shaky handheld movement following the frog?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008633785881102085 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758633613586426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008633785881102085, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008633785881102085, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22547727823257446, + 0.06710205227136612, + 0.10031922906637192, + 0.07571317255496979, + 0.11110624670982361, + 0.0163558479398489, + 0.09734716266393661, + 0.0620996467769146, + 0.1297028660774231, + 0.114776611328125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008633785881102085 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a warm, pixelated close-up shot reminiscent of Stardew Valley, a slightly shaky handheld camera closely follows the curious movements of a vibrantly colored red-eyed tree frog. With smooth, moist, bright green pixelated skin, a milky white belly, and striking blue and yellow stripes on its flanks, the frog cautiously emerges from behind a large, dark green taro leaf, dotted with glistening pixelated dewdrops. Its movements are slow and deliberate, with only its head and large, bulging scarlet eyes poking over the leaf's edge. It then secures a firm grip with its bright orange suction cups on its forelimbs and slowly pushes its body forward. Soft, golden sunlight filters through the pixelated jungle canopy, dappling the scene and illuminating the frog's contours and the rich textures of the leaf, giving its moist skin a subtle sheen. The entire scene is imbued with a tranquil and exploratory atmosphere. The saturated warm colors, captivating pixel art style, and the intimate camera angles that follow create a microscopic world brimming with life and wonder.", + "seed": 4578, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_2/index_9613_seed_4578_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.01896028583869338, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01896028583869338, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01896028583869338, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style pixelated and reminiscent of Stardew Valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-eyed tree frog with bright green skin, a milky white belly, and blue and yellow stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the frog emerge from behind a large, dark green taro leaf dotted with pixelated dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the frog use its bright orange suction cups on its forelimbs to push its body forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up with a slightly shaky handheld movement following the frog?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03587159886956215 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4108715057373047 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03587159886956215, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03587159886956215, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1121000200510025, + 0.07373139262199402, + 0.08494649827480316, + 0.06642404198646545, + 0.0867084339261055, + 0.11414287239313126, + 0.20159386098384857, + 0.06791958212852478, + 0.044081684201955795, + 0.14835162460803986 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03587159886956215 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style pixelated and reminiscent of Stardew Valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-eyed tree frog with bright green skin, a milky white belly, and blue and yellow stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the frog emerge from behind a large, dark green taro leaf dotted with pixelated dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the frog use its bright orange suction cups on its forelimbs to push its body forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up with a slightly shaky handheld movement following the frog?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003201599232852459 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753201484680176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003201599232852459, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003201599232852459, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1302475929260254, + 0.12150569260120392, + 0.06923507899045944, + 0.06717722862958908, + 0.05714136362075806, + 0.010064730420708656, + 0.3034614026546478, + 0.021510042250156403, + 0.07531982660293579, + 0.14433707296848297 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003201599232852459 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style pixelated and reminiscent of Stardew Valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-eyed tree frog with bright green skin, a milky white belly, and blue and yellow stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the frog emerge from behind a large, dark green taro leaf dotted with pixelated dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the frog use its bright orange suction cups on its forelimbs to push its body forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up with a slightly shaky handheld movement following the frog?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005947037134319544 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130947113037109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005947037134319544, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005947037134319544, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34492307901382446, + 0.10698316246271133, + 0.12517043948173523, + 0.08728111535310745, + 0.07691944390535355, + 0.02628478594124317, + 0.08835703134536743, + 0.027654943987727165, + 0.03324605152010918, + 0.08317997306585312 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005947037134319544 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style pixelated and reminiscent of Stardew Valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-eyed tree frog with bright green skin, a milky white belly, and blue and yellow stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the frog emerge from behind a large, dark green taro leaf dotted with pixelated dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the frog use its bright orange suction cups on its forelimbs to push its body forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up with a slightly shaky handheld movement following the frog?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04304855689406395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168048620223999 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04304855689406395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04304855689406395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.109735868871212, + 0.13062818348407745, + 0.10126695781946182, + 0.07198474556207657, + 0.06415042281150818, + 0.04081902280449867, + 0.3025478422641754, + 0.025311961770057678, + 0.07827554643154144, + 0.07527948170900345 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04304855689406395 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style pixelated and reminiscent of Stardew Valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-eyed tree frog with bright green skin, a milky white belly, and blue and yellow stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the frog emerge from behind a large, dark green taro leaf dotted with pixelated dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the frog use its bright orange suction cups on its forelimbs to push its body forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up with a slightly shaky handheld movement following the frog?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067326370626688 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00673246383667 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067326370626688, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067326370626688, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16151532530784607, + 0.18579372763633728, + 0.07122441381216049, + 0.024832438677549362, + 0.03114107809960842, + 0.06775220483541489, + 0.09127608686685562, + 0.05292299762368202, + 0.07186715304851532, + 0.24167460203170776 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067326370626688 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a warm, pixelated close-up shot reminiscent of Stardew Valley, a slightly shaky handheld camera closely follows the curious movements of a vibrantly colored red-eyed tree frog. With smooth, moist, bright green pixelated skin, a milky white belly, and striking blue and yellow stripes on its flanks, the frog cautiously emerges from behind a large, dark green taro leaf, dotted with glistening pixelated dewdrops. Its movements are slow and deliberate, with only its head and large, bulging scarlet eyes poking over the leaf's edge. It then secures a firm grip with its bright orange suction cups on its forelimbs and slowly pushes its body forward. Soft, golden sunlight filters through the pixelated jungle canopy, dappling the scene and illuminating the frog's contours and the rich textures of the leaf, giving its moist skin a subtle sheen. The entire scene is imbued with a tranquil and exploratory atmosphere. The saturated warm colors, captivating pixel art style, and the intimate camera angles that follow create a microscopic world brimming with life and wonder.", + "seed": 4579, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_2/index_9613_seed_4579_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.02157567283138633, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02157567283138633, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02157567283138633, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style pixelated and reminiscent of Stardew Valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-eyed tree frog with bright green skin, a milky white belly, and blue and yellow stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the frog emerge from behind a large, dark green taro leaf dotted with pixelated dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the frog use its bright orange suction cups on its forelimbs to push its body forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up with a slightly shaky handheld movement following the frog?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.040018487721681595 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2900185585021973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.040018487721681595, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.040018487721681595, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20058158040046692, + 0.15709851682186127, + 0.12461868673563004, + 0.023973286151885986, + 0.040060754865407944, + 0.04613332450389862, + 0.11719159036874771, + 0.12747591733932495, + 0.08277305215597153, + 0.08009322732686996 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.040018487721681595 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style pixelated and reminiscent of Stardew Valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-eyed tree frog with bright green skin, a milky white belly, and blue and yellow stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the frog emerge from behind a large, dark green taro leaf dotted with pixelated dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the frog use its bright orange suction cups on its forelimbs to push its body forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up with a slightly shaky handheld movement following the frog?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004647050518542528 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379647254943848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004647050518542528, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004647050518542528, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10608882457017899, + 0.10514061897993088, + 0.12351290881633759, + 0.034965891391038895, + 0.056532103568315506, + 0.09444251656532288, + 0.14250122010707855, + 0.11777365952730179, + 0.09091361612081528, + 0.12812860310077667 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004647050518542528 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style pixelated and reminiscent of Stardew Valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-eyed tree frog with bright green skin, a milky white belly, and blue and yellow stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the frog emerge from behind a large, dark green taro leaf dotted with pixelated dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the frog use its bright orange suction cups on its forelimbs to push its body forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up with a slightly shaky handheld movement following the frog?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016068367287516594 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141068458557129 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016068367287516594, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016068367287516594, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15835478901863098, + 0.1417216658592224, + 0.13552288711071014, + 0.03289997950196266, + 0.10952001810073853, + 0.059089187532663345, + 0.090013787150383, + 0.14428646862506866, + 0.0787820890545845, + 0.0498090535402298 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016068367287516594 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style pixelated and reminiscent of Stardew Valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-eyed tree frog with bright green skin, a milky white belly, and blue and yellow stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the frog emerge from behind a large, dark green taro leaf dotted with pixelated dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the frog use its bright orange suction cups on its forelimbs to push its body forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up with a slightly shaky handheld movement following the frog?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043050382286310196 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680502891540527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043050382286310196, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043050382286310196, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10466776043176651, + 0.11472916603088379, + 0.10332977026700974, + 0.033915381878614426, + 0.2089843451976776, + 0.10695952922105789, + 0.08468866348266602, + 0.06816933304071426, + 0.11389288306236267, + 0.06066317856311798 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043050382286310196 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style pixelated and reminiscent of Stardew Valley?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a red-eyed tree frog with bright green skin, a milky white belly, and blue and yellow stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the frog emerge from behind a large, dark green taro leaf dotted with pixelated dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the frog use its bright orange suction cups on its forelimbs to push its body forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a close-up with a slightly shaky handheld movement following the frog?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004094076342880726 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504094123840332 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004094076342880726, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004094076342880726, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10942986607551575, + 0.14447754621505737, + 0.09559629112482071, + 0.029914850369095802, + 0.0577542819082737, + 0.02716074325144291, + 0.060804400593042374, + 0.3315678536891937, + 0.08497197180986404, + 0.058322157710790634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004094076342880726 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_3/index_tensor([5118, 5118])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_3/index_tensor([5118, 5118])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..763cda9fb67da0362c3c03fc2265377e25e90576 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_3/index_tensor([5118, 5118])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "Rendered with hyper-realistic cinematic CGI, the film begins with a medium close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, then the camera slowly pans right, focusing on a massive snakehead fish. It sits imperturbably at the entrance of a dim underwater cave, its massive body almost completely still, its gill covers opening and closing in a nearly imperceptible, slow, rhythmic pattern. The fish's body is covered in an intricate camouflage pattern of dark green, muddy brown, and black patches, blending seamlessly into the rugged, mossy rocky backdrop. Its cold, watchful yellow eyes, with pupils as sharp as needles, stare motionlessly ahead, radiating a fierce, focused murderous aura. The only light comes from above, a faint, gray-blue skylight penetrating the murky water, creating a visible path through the suspended sediment particles. As this light sweeps across the fish's body, each of its hard, tightly packed scales reflects a damp, dark metallic sheen. As the camera pans, it gradually reveals its slender and powerful body extending from head to tail. The whole scene, rendered in cold colors, is full of primitive and latent threat, creating a suffocating atmosphere of silence and tension.", + "seed": 6887, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_3/index_5118_seed_6887_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05432702312245965, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05432702312245965, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05432702312245965, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive snakehead fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's body covered in a camouflage pattern of dark green, muddy brown, and black patches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fish's eyes yellow with sharp, needle-like pupils staring motionlessly ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a faint gray-blue skylight from above illuminating suspended sediment particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up from a slightly upward angle and then slowly pan right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006963508669286966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.256963729858398 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006963508669286966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006963508669286966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09507577121257782, + 0.13726165890693665, + 0.04721035435795784, + 0.07980936020612717, + 0.28956127166748047, + 0.10894767940044403, + 0.041886020451784134, + 0.1190079003572464, + 0.05148620158433914, + 0.02975374646484852 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006963508669286966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive snakehead fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's body covered in a camouflage pattern of dark green, muddy brown, and black patches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fish's eyes yellow with sharp, needle-like pupils staring motionlessly ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a faint gray-blue skylight from above illuminating suspended sediment particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up from a slightly upward angle and then slowly pan right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008647022768855095 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586469650268555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008647022768855095, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008647022768855095, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10321612656116486, + 0.0818948894739151, + 0.02863227017223835, + 0.0388512946665287, + 0.2870030701160431, + 0.24305538833141327, + 0.08369285613298416, + 0.0677950456738472, + 0.03503793850541115, + 0.030821114778518677 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008647022768855095 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive snakehead fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's body covered in a camouflage pattern of dark green, muddy brown, and black patches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fish's eyes yellow with sharp, needle-like pupils staring motionlessly ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a faint gray-blue skylight from above illuminating suspended sediment particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up from a slightly upward angle and then slowly pan right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06202520430088043 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812025308609009 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06202520430088043, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06202520430088043, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10110882669687271, + 0.06491077691316605, + 0.049609340727329254, + 0.06647136807441711, + 0.48833081126213074, + 0.054343875497579575, + 0.08055178076028824, + 0.030302127823233604, + 0.035326868295669556, + 0.029044171795248985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06202520430088043 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive snakehead fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's body covered in a camouflage pattern of dark green, muddy brown, and black patches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fish's eyes yellow with sharp, needle-like pupils staring motionlessly ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a faint gray-blue skylight from above illuminating suspended sediment particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up from a slightly upward angle and then slowly pan right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368864953517914 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408688545227051 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368864953517914, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368864953517914, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2097473442554474, + 0.13439053297042847, + 0.05020216852426529, + 0.053898636251688004, + 0.2020769566297531, + 0.10056700557470322, + 0.12250951677560806, + 0.07245232164859772, + 0.019972344860434532, + 0.03418312594294548 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368864953517914 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive snakehead fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's body covered in a camouflage pattern of dark green, muddy brown, and black patches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fish's eyes yellow with sharp, needle-like pupils staring motionlessly ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a faint gray-blue skylight from above illuminating suspended sediment particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up from a slightly upward angle and then slowly pan right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16031073033809662 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103107452392578 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16031073033809662, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16031073033809662, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07517214119434357, + 0.06280355900526047, + 0.05264849588274956, + 0.11900666356086731, + 0.07330852001905441, + 0.11171615868806839, + 0.07454680651426315, + 0.04808635264635086, + 0.3275952935218811, + 0.055116016417741776 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16031073033809662 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Rendered with hyper-realistic cinematic CGI, the film begins with a medium close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, then the camera slowly pans right, focusing on a massive snakehead fish. It sits imperturbably at the entrance of a dim underwater cave, its massive body almost completely still, its gill covers opening and closing in a nearly imperceptible, slow, rhythmic pattern. The fish's body is covered in an intricate camouflage pattern of dark green, muddy brown, and black patches, blending seamlessly into the rugged, mossy rocky backdrop. Its cold, watchful yellow eyes, with pupils as sharp as needles, stare motionlessly ahead, radiating a fierce, focused murderous aura. The only light comes from above, a faint, gray-blue skylight penetrating the murky water, creating a visible path through the suspended sediment particles. As this light sweeps across the fish's body, each of its hard, tightly packed scales reflects a damp, dark metallic sheen. As the camera pans, it gradually reveals its slender and powerful body extending from head to tail. The whole scene, rendered in cold colors, is full of primitive and latent threat, creating a suffocating atmosphere of silence and tension.", + "seed": 6888, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_3/index_5118_seed_6888_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03286559460684657, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03286559460684657, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03286559460684657, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive snakehead fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's body covered in a camouflage pattern of dark green, muddy brown, and black patches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fish's eyes yellow with sharp, needle-like pupils staring motionlessly ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a faint gray-blue skylight from above illuminating suspended sediment particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up from a slightly upward angle and then slowly pan right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0125802056863904 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.512580394744873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0125802056863904, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0125802056863904, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1352333277463913, + 0.04463370516896248, + 0.03754099830985069, + 0.025156069546937943, + 0.036780569702386856, + 0.06920859962701797, + 0.16929885745048523, + 0.3156496584415436, + 0.07316620647907257, + 0.09333200007677078 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0125802056863904 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive snakehead fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's body covered in a camouflage pattern of dark green, muddy brown, and black patches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fish's eyes yellow with sharp, needle-like pupils staring motionlessly ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a faint gray-blue skylight from above illuminating suspended sediment particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up from a slightly upward angle and then slowly pan right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005264822859317064 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255264759063721 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005264822859317064, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005264822859317064, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1318390667438507, + 0.06462452560663223, + 0.036569613963365555, + 0.05393768474459648, + 0.0849796012043953, + 0.07042040675878525, + 0.12914933264255524, + 0.1435195803642273, + 0.12296857684850693, + 0.16199162602424622 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005264822859317064 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive snakehead fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's body covered in a camouflage pattern of dark green, muddy brown, and black patches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fish's eyes yellow with sharp, needle-like pupils staring motionlessly ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a faint gray-blue skylight from above illuminating suspended sediment particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up from a slightly upward angle and then slowly pan right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368357568979263 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086835384368896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368357568979263, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368357568979263, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16407522559165955, + 0.03616783395409584, + 0.052369698882102966, + 0.04654175415635109, + 0.07680659741163254, + 0.05123445764183998, + 0.19905367493629456, + 0.13006281852722168, + 0.13421380519866943, + 0.10947417467832565 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368357568979263 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive snakehead fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's body covered in a camouflage pattern of dark green, muddy brown, and black patches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fish's eyes yellow with sharp, needle-like pupils staring motionlessly ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a faint gray-blue skylight from above illuminating suspended sediment particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up from a slightly upward angle and then slowly pan right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012530997395515442 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38753080368042 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012530997395515442, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012530997395515442, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2178271859884262, + 0.3015851080417633, + 0.04587036743760109, + 0.042205266654491425, + 0.12503571808338165, + 0.028270386159420013, + 0.07260678708553314, + 0.05864560604095459, + 0.032119520008563995, + 0.07583397626876831 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012530997395515442 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive snakehead fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's body covered in a camouflage pattern of dark green, muddy brown, and black patches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fish's eyes yellow with sharp, needle-like pupils staring motionlessly ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a faint gray-blue skylight from above illuminating suspended sediment particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up from a slightly upward angle and then slowly pan right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10026837140321732 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3502683639526367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10026837140321732, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10026837140321732, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12595640122890472, + 0.0326278954744339, + 0.03678000345826149, + 0.036943063139915466, + 0.0522642582654953, + 0.06217443197965622, + 0.17864055931568146, + 0.34114235639572144, + 0.058254215866327286, + 0.0752168521285057 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10026837140321732 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Rendered with hyper-realistic cinematic CGI, the film begins with a medium close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, then the camera slowly pans right, focusing on a massive snakehead fish. It sits imperturbably at the entrance of a dim underwater cave, its massive body almost completely still, its gill covers opening and closing in a nearly imperceptible, slow, rhythmic pattern. The fish's body is covered in an intricate camouflage pattern of dark green, muddy brown, and black patches, blending seamlessly into the rugged, mossy rocky backdrop. Its cold, watchful yellow eyes, with pupils as sharp as needles, stare motionlessly ahead, radiating a fierce, focused murderous aura. The only light comes from above, a faint, gray-blue skylight penetrating the murky water, creating a visible path through the suspended sediment particles. As this light sweeps across the fish's body, each of its hard, tightly packed scales reflects a damp, dark metallic sheen. As the camera pans, it gradually reveals its slender and powerful body extending from head to tail. The whole scene, rendered in cold colors, is full of primitive and latent threat, creating a suffocating atmosphere of silence and tension.", + "seed": 6889, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_3/index_5118_seed_6889_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05330302473157644, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05330302473157644, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05330302473157644, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive snakehead fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's body covered in a camouflage pattern of dark green, muddy brown, and black patches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fish's eyes yellow with sharp, needle-like pupils staring motionlessly ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a faint gray-blue skylight from above illuminating suspended sediment particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up from a slightly upward angle and then slowly pan right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013342027552425861 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.388341903686523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013342027552425861, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013342027552425861, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1361379474401474, + 0.08585644513368607, + 0.18282337486743927, + 0.14250850677490234, + 0.15996143221855164, + 0.04058774560689926, + 0.057972341775894165, + 0.08071697503328323, + 0.041136447340250015, + 0.07229874283075333 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013342027552425861 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive snakehead fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's body covered in a camouflage pattern of dark green, muddy brown, and black patches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fish's eyes yellow with sharp, needle-like pupils staring motionlessly ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a faint gray-blue skylight from above illuminating suspended sediment particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up from a slightly upward angle and then slowly pan right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008646076545119286 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758646011352539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008646076545119286, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008646076545119286, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15774722397327423, + 0.18776915967464447, + 0.059478260576725006, + 0.05216258391737938, + 0.15994688868522644, + 0.12690469622612, + 0.04601261764764786, + 0.12688995897769928, + 0.02064327895641327, + 0.06244532763957977 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008646076545119286 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive snakehead fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's body covered in a camouflage pattern of dark green, muddy brown, and black patches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fish's eyes yellow with sharp, needle-like pupils staring motionlessly ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a faint gray-blue skylight from above illuminating suspended sediment particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up from a slightly upward angle and then slowly pan right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048634111881256104 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486340522766113 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048634111881256104, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048634111881256104, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07680908590555191, + 0.04696755111217499, + 0.18657894432544708, + 0.23181910812854767, + 0.11338796466588974, + 0.07325640320777893, + 0.11580869555473328, + 0.07597655802965164, + 0.042086098343133926, + 0.037309594452381134 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048634111881256104 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive snakehead fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's body covered in a camouflage pattern of dark green, muddy brown, and black patches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fish's eyes yellow with sharp, needle-like pupils staring motionlessly ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a faint gray-blue skylight from above illuminating suspended sediment particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up from a slightly upward angle and then slowly pan right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606050878763199 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410603523254395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606050878763199, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606050878763199, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11722610890865326, + 0.4118991494178772, + 0.03924436494708061, + 0.07599332183599472, + 0.04570851847529411, + 0.05032570660114288, + 0.04609991982579231, + 0.16468103229999542, + 0.02136220596730709, + 0.02745969407260418 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606050878763199 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive snakehead fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's body covered in a camouflage pattern of dark green, muddy brown, and black patches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fish's eyes yellow with sharp, needle-like pupils staring motionlessly ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a faint gray-blue skylight from above illuminating suspended sediment particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up from a slightly upward angle and then slowly pan right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17983239889144897 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048324584960938 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17983239889144897, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17983239889144897, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08534976840019226, + 0.1217469722032547, + 0.0590720996260643, + 0.04793863743543625, + 0.09758161008358002, + 0.06248481944203377, + 0.06401025503873825, + 0.17315462231636047, + 0.2100268304347992, + 0.07863442599773407 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17983239889144897 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Rendered with hyper-realistic cinematic CGI, the film begins with a medium close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, then the camera slowly pans right, focusing on a massive snakehead fish. It sits imperturbably at the entrance of a dim underwater cave, its massive body almost completely still, its gill covers opening and closing in a nearly imperceptible, slow, rhythmic pattern. The fish's body is covered in an intricate camouflage pattern of dark green, muddy brown, and black patches, blending seamlessly into the rugged, mossy rocky backdrop. Its cold, watchful yellow eyes, with pupils as sharp as needles, stare motionlessly ahead, radiating a fierce, focused murderous aura. The only light comes from above, a faint, gray-blue skylight penetrating the murky water, creating a visible path through the suspended sediment particles. As this light sweeps across the fish's body, each of its hard, tightly packed scales reflects a damp, dark metallic sheen. As the camera pans, it gradually reveals its slender and powerful body extending from head to tail. The whole scene, rendered in cold colors, is full of primitive and latent threat, creating a suffocating atmosphere of silence and tension.", + "seed": 6890, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_3/index_5118_seed_6890_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03379790261387825, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03379790261387825, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03379790261387825, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive snakehead fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's body covered in a camouflage pattern of dark green, muddy brown, and black patches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fish's eyes yellow with sharp, needle-like pupils staring motionlessly ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a faint gray-blue skylight from above illuminating suspended sediment particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up from a slightly upward angle and then slowly pan right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009552130475640297 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.759552001953125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009552130475640297, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009552130475640297, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12378828972578049, + 0.05878506228327751, + 0.07019814848899841, + 0.04609188809990883, + 0.24192401766777039, + 0.05877799540758133, + 0.1350315511226654, + 0.025514937937259674, + 0.07309114187955856, + 0.16679690778255463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009552130475640297 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive snakehead fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's body covered in a camouflage pattern of dark green, muddy brown, and black patches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fish's eyes yellow with sharp, needle-like pupils staring motionlessly ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a faint gray-blue skylight from above illuminating suspended sediment particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up from a slightly upward angle and then slowly pan right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607411541044712 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141074180603027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607411541044712, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607411541044712, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.060233715921640396, + 0.03847779706120491, + 0.15869580209255219, + 0.06264041364192963, + 0.2418052703142166, + 0.07452257722616196, + 0.028046291321516037, + 0.035479821264743805, + 0.08764991909265518, + 0.2124483287334442 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607411541044712 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive snakehead fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's body covered in a camouflage pattern of dark green, muddy brown, and black patches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fish's eyes yellow with sharp, needle-like pupils staring motionlessly ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a faint gray-blue skylight from above illuminating suspended sediment particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up from a slightly upward angle and then slowly pan right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038083530962467194 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288083553314209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038083530962467194, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038083530962467194, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.081489197909832, + 0.050508707761764526, + 0.055191341787576675, + 0.10660053789615631, + 0.2555454671382904, + 0.14718981087207794, + 0.0653204470872879, + 0.04631652310490608, + 0.0360979288816452, + 0.15574000775814056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038083530962467194 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive snakehead fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's body covered in a camouflage pattern of dark green, muddy brown, and black patches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fish's eyes yellow with sharp, needle-like pupils staring motionlessly ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a faint gray-blue skylight from above illuminating suspended sediment particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up from a slightly upward angle and then slowly pan right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026334352791309357 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651334285736084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026334352791309357, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026334352791309357, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07355217635631561, + 0.08826687186956406, + 0.21249473094940186, + 0.048972249031066895, + 0.12081270664930344, + 0.08024153858423233, + 0.06829773634672165, + 0.05548875033855438, + 0.06555436551570892, + 0.18631887435913086 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026334352791309357 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive snakehead fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fish's body covered in a camouflage pattern of dark green, muddy brown, and black patches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fish's eyes yellow with sharp, needle-like pupils staring motionlessly ahead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a faint gray-blue skylight from above illuminating suspended sediment particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium close-up from a slightly upward angle and then slowly pan right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07894538342952728 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789453983306885 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07894538342952728, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07894538342952728, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04052940011024475, + 0.039754241704940796, + 0.2053910493850708, + 0.02718016691505909, + 0.17218881845474243, + 0.18582041561603546, + 0.11596997082233429, + 0.04455952346324921, + 0.11584433913230896, + 0.05276209115982056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07894538342952728 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_4/index_tensor([8396, 8396])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_4/index_tensor([8396, 8396])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b67450031cf42d14a77bd9faae36c570f184c46a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_4/index_tensor([8396, 8396])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "fluid 360-degree panning shot closely follows a J-10C fighter jet as it performs a breathtaking tackling maneuver amidst the steel canyons of skyscrapers in the heart of a futuristic neon metropolis. The fighter jet, with its signature canard configuration and delta wings, its dark gray stealth-coated fuselage reflects the kaleidoscopic lights of the city below. With incredible speed and precision, it weaves through a narrow passageway formed by massive, translucent holographic billboards, its wings nearly brushing against the luminous surfaces, which flash with dynamic graphics and abstract data. As the fighter flies past, its powerful airflow disrupts the holographic projections, stirring up a dazzling stream of data composed of fragmented code and glowing particles, leaving behind a fleeting, dazzling digital trail. The scene is dominated by neon hues of cyan, magenta, and electric blue, which rapidly play across the fighter's sleek metal exterior, creating a visual atmosphere of intense tension, high-tech excitement, and adrenaline.", + "seed": 6664, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_4/index_8396_seed_6664_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08087297976016998, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08087297976016998, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08087297976016998, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a J-10C fighter jet with a canard configuration and delta wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fighter jet's fuselage dark gray and coated with a stealth material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jet perform a maneuver weaving through a narrow passageway formed by massive translucent holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jet's movement disrupt the holographic projections, creating a stream of fragmented code and glowing particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a fluid 360-degree panning shot that follows the jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11424820125102997 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.239248275756836 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11424820125102997, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11424820125102997, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.143244668841362, + 0.05862618610262871, + 0.04170094430446625, + 0.07044542580842972, + 0.04874907433986664, + 0.044307101517915726, + 0.052824828773736954, + 0.10100526362657547, + 0.06605558097362518, + 0.37304094433784485 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11424820125102997 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a J-10C fighter jet with a canard configuration and delta wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fighter jet's fuselage dark gray and coated with a stealth material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jet perform a maneuver weaving through a narrow passageway formed by massive translucent holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jet's movement disrupt the holographic projections, creating a stream of fragmented code and glowing particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a fluid 360-degree panning shot that follows the jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1799379587173462 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049379587173462 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1799379587173462, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1799379587173462, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02897273376584053, + 0.024020792916417122, + 0.013981571421027184, + 0.019754378125071526, + 0.017575586214661598, + 0.01305991131812334, + 0.017166895791888237, + 0.0239778570830822, + 0.02001763880252838, + 0.8214726448059082 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1799379587173462 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a J-10C fighter jet with a canard configuration and delta wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fighter jet's fuselage dark gray and coated with a stealth material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jet perform a maneuver weaving through a narrow passageway formed by massive translucent holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jet's movement disrupt the holographic projections, creating a stream of fragmented code and glowing particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a fluid 360-degree panning shot that follows the jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005251660011708736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255251884460449 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005251660011708736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005251660011708736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.033554691821336746, + 0.022005543112754822, + 0.020312445238232613, + 0.008364508859813213, + 0.03380373492836952, + 0.006596649531275034, + 0.024490687996149063, + 0.028273221105337143, + 0.011077518574893475, + 0.8115209341049194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005251660011708736 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a J-10C fighter jet with a canard configuration and delta wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fighter jet's fuselage dark gray and coated with a stealth material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jet perform a maneuver weaving through a narrow passageway formed by massive translucent holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jet's movement disrupt the holographic projections, creating a stream of fragmented code and glowing particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a fluid 360-degree panning shot that follows the jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004636489786207676 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379636287689209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004636489786207676, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004636489786207676, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.031203780323266983, + 0.17336399853229523, + 0.025908922776579857, + 0.012017722241580486, + 0.008015720173716545, + 0.021897386759519577, + 0.00913999229669571, + 0.010491927154362202, + 0.00935708824545145, + 0.6986035704612732 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004636489786207676 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a J-10C fighter jet with a canard configuration and delta wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fighter jet's fuselage dark gray and coated with a stealth material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jet perform a maneuver weaving through a narrow passageway formed by massive translucent holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jet's movement disrupt the holographic projections, creating a stream of fragmented code and glowing particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a fluid 360-degree panning shot that follows the jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10029058903455734 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350290536880493 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10029058903455734, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10029058903455734, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04647397622466087, + 0.2752732038497925, + 0.04376868158578873, + 0.03442990407347679, + 0.010617731139063835, + 0.039372872561216354, + 0.029237601906061172, + 0.008614989928901196, + 0.055681224912405014, + 0.4565298557281494 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10029058903455734 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "fluid 360-degree panning shot closely follows a J-10C fighter jet as it performs a breathtaking tackling maneuver amidst the steel canyons of skyscrapers in the heart of a futuristic neon metropolis. The fighter jet, with its signature canard configuration and delta wings, its dark gray stealth-coated fuselage reflects the kaleidoscopic lights of the city below. With incredible speed and precision, it weaves through a narrow passageway formed by massive, translucent holographic billboards, its wings nearly brushing against the luminous surfaces, which flash with dynamic graphics and abstract data. As the fighter flies past, its powerful airflow disrupts the holographic projections, stirring up a dazzling stream of data composed of fragmented code and glowing particles, leaving behind a fleeting, dazzling digital trail. The scene is dominated by neon hues of cyan, magenta, and electric blue, which rapidly play across the fighter's sleek metal exterior, creating a visual atmosphere of intense tension, high-tech excitement, and adrenaline.", + "seed": 6665, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_4/index_8396_seed_6665_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0909431954845786, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0909431954845786, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.174999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0909431954845786, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a J-10C fighter jet with a canard configuration and delta wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fighter jet's fuselage dark gray and coated with a stealth material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jet perform a maneuver weaving through a narrow passageway formed by massive translucent holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jet's movement disrupt the holographic projections, creating a stream of fragmented code and glowing particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a fluid 360-degree panning shot that follows the jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2027895301580429 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.702789545059204 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2027895301580429, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2027895301580429, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07510576397180557, + 0.07006273418664932, + 0.04455151781439781, + 0.1294204741716385, + 0.10089891403913498, + 0.0304701067507267, + 0.06021648272871971, + 0.2818462550640106, + 0.047517240047454834, + 0.15991045534610748 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2027895301580429 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a J-10C fighter jet with a canard configuration and delta wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fighter jet's fuselage dark gray and coated with a stealth material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jet perform a maneuver weaving through a narrow passageway formed by massive translucent holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jet's movement disrupt the holographic projections, creating a stream of fragmented code and glowing particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a fluid 360-degree panning shot that follows the jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12711460888385773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1271145343780518 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12711460888385773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12711460888385773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06206779181957245, + 0.043586984276771545, + 0.05795576423406601, + 0.11038266867399216, + 0.05227681249380112, + 0.024201691150665283, + 0.08748934417963028, + 0.24880582094192505, + 0.07119780778884888, + 0.24203531444072723 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12711460888385773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a J-10C fighter jet with a canard configuration and delta wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fighter jet's fuselage dark gray and coated with a stealth material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jet perform a maneuver weaving through a narrow passageway formed by massive translucent holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jet's movement disrupt the holographic projections, creating a stream of fragmented code and glowing particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a fluid 360-degree panning shot that follows the jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059498813934624195 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130949974060059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059498813934624195, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059498813934624195, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0504445806145668, + 0.05594117194414139, + 0.029923396185040474, + 0.1675734668970108, + 0.08041919022798538, + 0.015826940536499023, + 0.11255697160959244, + 0.03172300383448601, + 0.0599643811583519, + 0.3956269323825836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059498813934624195 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a J-10C fighter jet with a canard configuration and delta wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fighter jet's fuselage dark gray and coated with a stealth material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jet perform a maneuver weaving through a narrow passageway formed by massive translucent holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jet's movement disrupt the holographic projections, creating a stream of fragmented code and glowing particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a fluid 360-degree panning shot that follows the jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005949525628238916 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309494972229 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005949525628238916, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005949525628238916, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03890746459364891, + 0.03711317852139473, + 0.024131128564476967, + 0.0985066294670105, + 0.025310365483164787, + 0.017825130373239517, + 0.044578488916158676, + 0.017302168533205986, + 0.02294224314391613, + 0.6733831763267517 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005949525628238916 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a J-10C fighter jet with a canard configuration and delta wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fighter jet's fuselage dark gray and coated with a stealth material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jet perform a maneuver weaving through a narrow passageway formed by massive translucent holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jet's movement disrupt the holographic projections, creating a stream of fragmented code and glowing particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a fluid 360-degree panning shot that follows the jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11291243135929108 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.23791241645813 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11291243135929108, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11291243135929108, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07048078626394272, + 0.04971710219979286, + 0.09706590324640274, + 0.16404549777507782, + 0.051143717020750046, + 0.017834242433309555, + 0.037134382873773575, + 0.05385399982333183, + 0.058872804045677185, + 0.39985159039497375 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11291243135929108 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "fluid 360-degree panning shot closely follows a J-10C fighter jet as it performs a breathtaking tackling maneuver amidst the steel canyons of skyscrapers in the heart of a futuristic neon metropolis. The fighter jet, with its signature canard configuration and delta wings, its dark gray stealth-coated fuselage reflects the kaleidoscopic lights of the city below. With incredible speed and precision, it weaves through a narrow passageway formed by massive, translucent holographic billboards, its wings nearly brushing against the luminous surfaces, which flash with dynamic graphics and abstract data. As the fighter flies past, its powerful airflow disrupts the holographic projections, stirring up a dazzling stream of data composed of fragmented code and glowing particles, leaving behind a fleeting, dazzling digital trail. The scene is dominated by neon hues of cyan, magenta, and electric blue, which rapidly play across the fighter's sleek metal exterior, creating a visual atmosphere of intense tension, high-tech excitement, and adrenaline.", + "seed": 6666, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_4/index_8396_seed_6666_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1462933330796659, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1462933330796659, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1462933330796659, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a J-10C fighter jet with a canard configuration and delta wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fighter jet's fuselage dark gray and coated with a stealth material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jet perform a maneuver weaving through a narrow passageway formed by massive translucent holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jet's movement disrupt the holographic projections, creating a stream of fragmented code and glowing particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a fluid 360-degree panning shot that follows the jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2548612654209137 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5048612356185913 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2548612654209137, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2548612654209137, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1695023477077484, + 0.08014241605997086, + 0.09339231252670288, + 0.09194282442331314, + 0.08034825325012207, + 0.17160537838935852, + 0.21989575028419495, + 0.032025717198848724, + 0.03203170746564865, + 0.02911330759525299 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2548612654209137 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a J-10C fighter jet with a canard configuration and delta wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fighter jet's fuselage dark gray and coated with a stealth material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jet perform a maneuver weaving through a narrow passageway formed by massive translucent holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jet's movement disrupt the holographic projections, creating a stream of fragmented code and glowing particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a fluid 360-degree panning shot that follows the jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11297834664583206 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237978458404541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11297834664583206, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11297834664583206, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08904160559177399, + 0.09176511317491531, + 0.20686528086662292, + 0.07410359382629395, + 0.06705613434314728, + 0.1583288609981537, + 0.13796716928482056, + 0.05475257337093353, + 0.08018457144498825, + 0.03993508964776993 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11297834664583206 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a J-10C fighter jet with a canard configuration and delta wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fighter jet's fuselage dark gray and coated with a stealth material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jet perform a maneuver weaving through a narrow passageway formed by massive translucent holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jet's movement disrupt the holographic projections, creating a stream of fragmented code and glowing particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a fluid 360-degree panning shot that follows the jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005251778755337 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255251884460449 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005251778755337, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005251778755337, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12575304508209229, + 0.10844167321920395, + 0.14654730260372162, + 0.07596740871667862, + 0.053694017231464386, + 0.07331030815839767, + 0.2136809527873993, + 0.050224870443344116, + 0.07964809983968735, + 0.07273229211568832 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005251778755337 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a J-10C fighter jet with a canard configuration and delta wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fighter jet's fuselage dark gray and coated with a stealth material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jet perform a maneuver weaving through a narrow passageway formed by massive translucent holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jet's movement disrupt the holographic projections, creating a stream of fragmented code and glowing particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a fluid 360-degree panning shot that follows the jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00977774802595377 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634777545928955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00977774802595377, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00977774802595377, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10988836735486984, + 0.04852639511227608, + 0.07412107288837433, + 0.08640342205762863, + 0.10079286992549896, + 0.23140794038772583, + 0.1326160579919815, + 0.06102738901972771, + 0.0993209183216095, + 0.05589553341269493 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00977774802595377 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a J-10C fighter jet with a canard configuration and delta wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fighter jet's fuselage dark gray and coated with a stealth material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jet perform a maneuver weaving through a narrow passageway formed by massive translucent holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jet's movement disrupt the holographic projections, creating a stream of fragmented code and glowing particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a fluid 360-degree panning shot that follows the jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34859752655029297 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223597526550293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34859752655029297, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34859752655029297, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07449959218502045, + 0.037443604320287704, + 0.1562204211950302, + 0.0818474069237709, + 0.05833205580711365, + 0.07335767894983292, + 0.2509787380695343, + 0.05841103568673134, + 0.13724057376384735, + 0.07166890054941177 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34859752655029297 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "fluid 360-degree panning shot closely follows a J-10C fighter jet as it performs a breathtaking tackling maneuver amidst the steel canyons of skyscrapers in the heart of a futuristic neon metropolis. The fighter jet, with its signature canard configuration and delta wings, its dark gray stealth-coated fuselage reflects the kaleidoscopic lights of the city below. With incredible speed and precision, it weaves through a narrow passageway formed by massive, translucent holographic billboards, its wings nearly brushing against the luminous surfaces, which flash with dynamic graphics and abstract data. As the fighter flies past, its powerful airflow disrupts the holographic projections, stirring up a dazzling stream of data composed of fragmented code and glowing particles, leaving behind a fleeting, dazzling digital trail. The scene is dominated by neon hues of cyan, magenta, and electric blue, which rapidly play across the fighter's sleek metal exterior, creating a visual atmosphere of intense tension, high-tech excitement, and adrenaline.", + "seed": 6667, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_4/index_8396_seed_6667_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06467571230605244, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06467571230605244, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.674999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06467571230605244, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a J-10C fighter jet with a canard configuration and delta wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fighter jet's fuselage dark gray and coated with a stealth material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jet perform a maneuver weaving through a narrow passageway formed by massive translucent holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jet's movement disrupt the holographic projections, creating a stream of fragmented code and glowing particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a fluid 360-degree panning shot that follows the jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10096550732851028 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3509654998779297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10096550732851028, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10096550732851028, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13417430222034454, + 0.043477967381477356, + 0.0971728041768074, + 0.22348757088184357, + 0.1379491537809372, + 0.04757014662027359, + 0.06381414085626602, + 0.058326832950115204, + 0.12989571690559387, + 0.06413137167692184 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10096550732851028 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a J-10C fighter jet with a canard configuration and delta wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fighter jet's fuselage dark gray and coated with a stealth material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jet perform a maneuver weaving through a narrow passageway formed by massive translucent holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jet's movement disrupt the holographic projections, creating a stream of fragmented code and glowing particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a fluid 360-degree panning shot that follows the jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08905789256095886 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640579223632812 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08905789256095886, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08905789256095886, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11293741315603256, + 0.053195174783468246, + 0.08507242053747177, + 0.24194614589214325, + 0.19142839312553406, + 0.07765562832355499, + 0.058446254581213, + 0.02686198800802231, + 0.047866035252809525, + 0.10459061712026596 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08905789256095886 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a J-10C fighter jet with a canard configuration and delta wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fighter jet's fuselage dark gray and coated with a stealth material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jet perform a maneuver weaving through a narrow passageway formed by massive translucent holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jet's movement disrupt the holographic projections, creating a stream of fragmented code and glowing particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a fluid 360-degree panning shot that follows the jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004636134020984173 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379636287689209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004636134020984173, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004636134020984173, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07253263145685196, + 0.11204061657190323, + 0.07884050160646439, + 0.22871176898479462, + 0.11371181905269623, + 0.052470482885837555, + 0.0624200776219368, + 0.15000103414058685, + 0.05430722236633301, + 0.07496389746665955 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004636134020984173 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a J-10C fighter jet with a canard configuration and delta wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fighter jet's fuselage dark gray and coated with a stealth material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jet perform a maneuver weaving through a narrow passageway formed by massive translucent holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jet's movement disrupt the holographic projections, creating a stream of fragmented code and glowing particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a fluid 360-degree panning shot that follows the jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017109769396483898 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376710891723633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017109769396483898, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017109769396483898, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08156557381153107, + 0.10631762444972992, + 0.49118727445602417, + 0.09399339556694031, + 0.027709592133760452, + 0.05074721947312355, + 0.04918171837925911, + 0.030806444585323334, + 0.027263717725872993, + 0.041227515786886215 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017109769396483898 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a J-10C fighter jet with a canard configuration and delta wings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the fighter jet's fuselage dark gray and coated with a stealth material?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the jet perform a maneuver weaving through a narrow passageway formed by massive translucent holographic billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the jet's movement disrupt the holographic projections, creating a stream of fragmented code and glowing particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a fluid 360-degree panning shot that follows the jet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12700805068016052 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270079612731934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12700805068016052, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12700805068016052, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2526462972164154, + 0.1239214614033699, + 0.25128626823425293, + 0.054242271929979324, + 0.10941633582115173, + 0.06288530677556992, + 0.045531488955020905, + 0.03259352967143059, + 0.03380412980914116, + 0.03367290273308754 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12700805068016052 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_5/index_tensor([316, 316])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_5/index_tensor([316, 316])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f5ea9078610c3099b7c5414dc41a2e48429921a2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_5/index_tensor([316, 316])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "photorealistic, hyper-realistic macro shot, positioned at an extremely low angle, tracks a small, heavily rusted metal wheel in perfect sync as it moves backward, laboriously turning over a rough concrete floor. The high-definition lens, focused intensely on the wheel, clearly reveals every minute detail: the pitted texture of oxidized orange and dark brown rust coating the solid metal, the gleam of raw steel visible in countless tiny scratches, and the oily sheen of its precariously rotating fork. Under the immense pressure of an unseen, heavy, all-metal cart, the wheel slowly grinds, its movement displacing the fine gray dust and small pebbles scattered across the concrete. With each rotation, individual stones audibly crunch, turning to powder or being pushed aside, leaving clean, dark marks in the grime. A single, harsh, cold-toned industrial light casts sharp, dramatic shadows from above, highlighting the wheel's corroded surface and the gritty topography of the floor, creating a tense and visceral atmosphere of immense weight and grinding, protest movement.", + "seed": 24286, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_5/index_316_seed_24286_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.10156641295179725, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10156641295179725, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10156641295179725, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a small, heavily rusted metal wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle and tracking the wheel in sync as it moves backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wheel display pitted orange and dark brown rust with visible raw steel scratches and an oily sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rough concrete floor with fine gray dust and small pebbles being displaced by the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single harsh, cold-toned industrial light casting sharp shadows from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05054458975791931 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.050544500350952 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05054458975791931, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05054458975791931, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07853120565414429, + 0.03695613145828247, + 0.03576277568936348, + 0.08110986649990082, + 0.14512412250041962, + 0.1560555398464203, + 0.1463622897863388, + 0.13002240657806396, + 0.03314819931983948, + 0.1569274216890335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05054458975791931 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a small, heavily rusted metal wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle and tracking the wheel in sync as it moves backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wheel display pitted orange and dark brown rust with visible raw steel scratches and an oily sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rough concrete floor with fine gray dust and small pebbles being displaced by the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single harsh, cold-toned industrial light casting sharp shadows from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06207147613167763 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120715618133545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06207147613167763, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06207147613167763, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06226061284542084, + 0.030955413356423378, + 0.03575083240866661, + 0.05336267128586769, + 0.14412721991539001, + 0.1753188669681549, + 0.19897489249706268, + 0.09818703681230545, + 0.05844473838806152, + 0.14261774718761444 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06207147613167763 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a small, heavily rusted metal wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle and tracking the wheel in sync as it moves backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wheel display pitted orange and dark brown rust with visible raw steel scratches and an oily sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rough concrete floor with fine gray dust and small pebbles being displaced by the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single harsh, cold-toned industrial light casting sharp shadows from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022025867365300655 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.12720251083374 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022025867365300655, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022025867365300655, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06654542684555054, + 0.05016161873936653, + 0.04301195964217186, + 0.12204911559820175, + 0.09402294456958771, + 0.09892784804105759, + 0.1300334334373474, + 0.13833124935626984, + 0.08474038541316986, + 0.17217595875263214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022025867365300655 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a small, heavily rusted metal wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle and tracking the wheel in sync as it moves backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wheel display pitted orange and dark brown rust with visible raw steel scratches and an oily sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rough concrete floor with fine gray dust and small pebbles being displaced by the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single harsh, cold-toned industrial light casting sharp shadows from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00594525970518589 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130945205688477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00594525970518589, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00594525970518589, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09055130183696747, + 0.09919422119855881, + 0.08472580462694168, + 0.12711849808692932, + 0.09138954430818558, + 0.053586576133966446, + 0.09136859327554703, + 0.10763939470052719, + 0.06853082776069641, + 0.18589523434638977 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00594525970518589 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a small, heavily rusted metal wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle and tracking the wheel in sync as it moves backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wheel display pitted orange and dark brown rust with visible raw steel scratches and an oily sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rough concrete floor with fine gray dust and small pebbles being displaced by the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single harsh, cold-toned industrial light casting sharp shadows from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38706815242767334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370681524276733 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38706815242767334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38706815242767334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05772579088807106, + 0.03738229721784592, + 0.039162371307611465, + 0.04997538775205612, + 0.09928281605243683, + 0.10327388346195221, + 0.1648215651512146, + 0.1598130613565445, + 0.12016189843416214, + 0.16840095818042755 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38706815242767334 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "photorealistic, hyper-realistic macro shot, positioned at an extremely low angle, tracks a small, heavily rusted metal wheel in perfect sync as it moves backward, laboriously turning over a rough concrete floor. The high-definition lens, focused intensely on the wheel, clearly reveals every minute detail: the pitted texture of oxidized orange and dark brown rust coating the solid metal, the gleam of raw steel visible in countless tiny scratches, and the oily sheen of its precariously rotating fork. Under the immense pressure of an unseen, heavy, all-metal cart, the wheel slowly grinds, its movement displacing the fine gray dust and small pebbles scattered across the concrete. With each rotation, individual stones audibly crunch, turning to powder or being pushed aside, leaving clean, dark marks in the grime. A single, harsh, cold-toned industrial light casts sharp, dramatic shadows from above, highlighting the wheel's corroded surface and the gritty topography of the floor, creating a tense and visceral atmosphere of immense weight and grinding, protest movement.", + "seed": 24287, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_5/index_316_seed_24287_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.11594818267039955, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11594818267039955, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11594818267039955, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a small, heavily rusted metal wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle and tracking the wheel in sync as it moves backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wheel display pitted orange and dark brown rust with visible raw steel scratches and an oily sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rough concrete floor with fine gray dust and small pebbles being displaced by the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single harsh, cold-toned industrial light casting sharp shadows from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2551581561565399 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5051581859588623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2551581561565399, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2551581561565399, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10706913471221924, + 0.04358341172337532, + 0.09578361362218857, + 0.1141098290681839, + 0.030811378732323647, + 0.023451026529073715, + 0.03406718745827675, + 0.023721642792224884, + 0.007481919135898352, + 0.519920825958252 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2551581561565399 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a small, heavily rusted metal wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle and tracking the wheel in sync as it moves backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wheel display pitted orange and dark brown rust with visible raw steel scratches and an oily sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rough concrete floor with fine gray dust and small pebbles being displaced by the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single harsh, cold-toned industrial light casting sharp shadows from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603892296552658 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103891849517822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603892296552658, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603892296552658, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06647372990846634, + 0.01993483118712902, + 0.13888895511627197, + 0.09277364611625671, + 0.03893232345581055, + 0.04666246101260185, + 0.02500816434621811, + 0.008405477739870548, + 0.010926268063485622, + 0.5519941449165344 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603892296552658 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a small, heavily rusted metal wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle and tracking the wheel in sync as it moves backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wheel display pitted orange and dark brown rust with visible raw steel scratches and an oily sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rough concrete floor with fine gray dust and small pebbles being displaced by the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single harsh, cold-toned industrial light casting sharp shadows from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003197915619239211 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753198146820068 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003197915619239211, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003197915619239211, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10569880902767181, + 0.040468256920576096, + 0.0668240636587143, + 0.1995076686143875, + 0.026847006753087044, + 0.01664905995130539, + 0.025428345426917076, + 0.02477620542049408, + 0.01386336050927639, + 0.47993725538253784 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003197915619239211 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a small, heavily rusted metal wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle and tracking the wheel in sync as it moves backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wheel display pitted orange and dark brown rust with visible raw steel scratches and an oily sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rough concrete floor with fine gray dust and small pebbles being displaced by the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single harsh, cold-toned industrial light casting sharp shadows from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018184611573815346 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018184661865234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018184611573815346, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018184611573815346, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11699436604976654, + 0.06203746050596237, + 0.16155444085597992, + 0.24272486567497253, + 0.06242939084768295, + 0.048420097678899765, + 0.05768083035945892, + 0.04296837002038956, + 0.012895789928734303, + 0.19229434430599213 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018184611573815346 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a small, heavily rusted metal wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle and tracking the wheel in sync as it moves backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wheel display pitted orange and dark brown rust with visible raw steel scratches and an oily sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rough concrete floor with fine gray dust and small pebbles being displaced by the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single harsh, cold-toned industrial light casting sharp shadows from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14281100034713745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178110599517822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14281100034713745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14281100034713745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1870722621679306, + 0.06100115180015564, + 0.09078646451234818, + 0.19713959097862244, + 0.02844846434891224, + 0.042291563004255295, + 0.04695555195212364, + 0.027308857068419456, + 0.020256448537111282, + 0.2987397015094757 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14281100034713745 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "photorealistic, hyper-realistic macro shot, positioned at an extremely low angle, tracks a small, heavily rusted metal wheel in perfect sync as it moves backward, laboriously turning over a rough concrete floor. The high-definition lens, focused intensely on the wheel, clearly reveals every minute detail: the pitted texture of oxidized orange and dark brown rust coating the solid metal, the gleam of raw steel visible in countless tiny scratches, and the oily sheen of its precariously rotating fork. Under the immense pressure of an unseen, heavy, all-metal cart, the wheel slowly grinds, its movement displacing the fine gray dust and small pebbles scattered across the concrete. With each rotation, individual stones audibly crunch, turning to powder or being pushed aside, leaving clean, dark marks in the grime. A single, harsh, cold-toned industrial light casts sharp, dramatic shadows from above, highlighting the wheel's corroded surface and the gritty topography of the floor, creating a tense and visceral atmosphere of immense weight and grinding, protest movement.", + "seed": 24288, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_5/index_316_seed_24288_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1378297480987385, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1378297480987385, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1378297480987385, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a small, heavily rusted metal wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle and tracking the wheel in sync as it moves backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wheel display pitted orange and dark brown rust with visible raw steel scratches and an oily sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rough concrete floor with fine gray dust and small pebbles being displaced by the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single harsh, cold-toned industrial light casting sharp shadows from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.027678942307829857 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.652678966522217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.027678942307829857, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.027678942307829857, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05979813635349274, + 0.19295309484004974, + 0.052523184567689896, + 0.04283158853650093, + 0.16058023273944855, + 0.09240002185106277, + 0.10215490311384201, + 0.23552986979484558, + 0.0314750149846077, + 0.02975400537252426 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.027678942307829857 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a small, heavily rusted metal wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle and tracking the wheel in sync as it moves backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wheel display pitted orange and dark brown rust with visible raw steel scratches and an oily sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rough concrete floor with fine gray dust and small pebbles being displaced by the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single harsh, cold-toned industrial light casting sharp shadows from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520981431007385 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020980834960938 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520981431007385, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520981431007385, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1568109393119812, + 0.13062073290348053, + 0.03706321120262146, + 0.04553178697824478, + 0.14339257776737213, + 0.0592169314622879, + 0.08840702474117279, + 0.22228315472602844, + 0.0742175430059433, + 0.04245603457093239 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520981431007385 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a small, heavily rusted metal wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle and tracking the wheel in sync as it moves backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wheel display pitted orange and dark brown rust with visible raw steel scratches and an oily sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rough concrete floor with fine gray dust and small pebbles being displaced by the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single harsh, cold-toned industrial light casting sharp shadows from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017163321608677506 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376716136932373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017163321608677506, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017163321608677506, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19884037971496582, + 0.2802926003932953, + 0.043753281235694885, + 0.04968586564064026, + 0.029885878786444664, + 0.04795253276824951, + 0.060028430074453354, + 0.19332924485206604, + 0.03858484700322151, + 0.05764688551425934 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017163321608677506 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a small, heavily rusted metal wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle and tracking the wheel in sync as it moves backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wheel display pitted orange and dark brown rust with visible raw steel scratches and an oily sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rough concrete floor with fine gray dust and small pebbles being displaced by the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single harsh, cold-toned industrial light casting sharp shadows from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058207429945469 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955819606781006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058207429945469, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058207429945469, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10358595848083496, + 0.13852255046367645, + 0.0816996619105339, + 0.040769245475530624, + 0.26356467604637146, + 0.0246663186699152, + 0.04359087347984314, + 0.1680324822664261, + 0.02818736620247364, + 0.10738091915845871 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058207429945469 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a small, heavily rusted metal wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle and tracking the wheel in sync as it moves backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wheel display pitted orange and dark brown rust with visible raw steel scratches and an oily sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rough concrete floor with fine gray dust and small pebbles being displaced by the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single harsh, cold-toned industrial light casting sharp shadows from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38707324862480164 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137073278427124 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38707324862480164, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38707324862480164, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07664581388235092, + 0.12033103406429291, + 0.040261514484882355, + 0.04398377239704132, + 0.40091994404792786, + 0.031611617654561996, + 0.07363151013851166, + 0.15336497128009796, + 0.024006353691220284, + 0.03524352237582207 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38707324862480164 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "photorealistic, hyper-realistic macro shot, positioned at an extremely low angle, tracks a small, heavily rusted metal wheel in perfect sync as it moves backward, laboriously turning over a rough concrete floor. The high-definition lens, focused intensely on the wheel, clearly reveals every minute detail: the pitted texture of oxidized orange and dark brown rust coating the solid metal, the gleam of raw steel visible in countless tiny scratches, and the oily sheen of its precariously rotating fork. Under the immense pressure of an unseen, heavy, all-metal cart, the wheel slowly grinds, its movement displacing the fine gray dust and small pebbles scattered across the concrete. With each rotation, individual stones audibly crunch, turning to powder or being pushed aside, leaving clean, dark marks in the grime. A single, harsh, cold-toned industrial light casts sharp, dramatic shadows from above, highlighting the wheel's corroded surface and the gritty topography of the floor, creating a tense and visceral atmosphere of immense weight and grinding, protest movement.", + "seed": 24289, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_5/index_316_seed_24289_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.6397096067667007, + "vlm_logprob": -0.6397096067667007, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 0.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.6397096067667007, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a small, heavily rusted metal wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle and tracking the wheel in sync as it moves backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wheel display pitted orange and dark brown rust with visible raw steel scratches and an oily sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rough concrete floor with fine gray dust and small pebbles being displaced by the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single harsh, cold-toned industrial light casting sharp shadows from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.238201856613159 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11320191621780396 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.238201856613159, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -2.238201856613159, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17543670535087585, + 0.08245611190795898, + 0.3975452184677124, + 0.0963640958070755, + 0.057334620505571365, + 0.02921590395271778, + 0.03355969116091728, + 0.07872248440980911, + 0.030125482007861137, + 0.01923968456685543 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.238201856613159 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a small, heavily rusted metal wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle and tracking the wheel in sync as it moves backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wheel display pitted orange and dark brown rust with visible raw steel scratches and an oily sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rough concrete floor with fine gray dust and small pebbles being displaced by the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single harsh, cold-toned industrial light casting sharp shadows from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28152433037757874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4065243005752563 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28152433037757874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28152433037757874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16918407380580902, + 0.09834609180688858, + 0.35541266202926636, + 0.0934867411851883, + 0.05311582237482071, + 0.03826834633946419, + 0.04100862517952919, + 0.07599945366382599, + 0.05126055330038071, + 0.023917600512504578 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28152433037757874 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a small, heavily rusted metal wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle and tracking the wheel in sync as it moves backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wheel display pitted orange and dark brown rust with visible raw steel scratches and an oily sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rough concrete floor with fine gray dust and small pebbles being displaced by the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single harsh, cold-toned industrial light casting sharp shadows from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04872642457485199 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0487263202667236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04872642457485199, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04872642457485199, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16029447317123413, + 0.08320703357458115, + 0.40392419695854187, + 0.09149637818336487, + 0.06253911554813385, + 0.02793043851852417, + 0.04338556528091431, + 0.06810387223958969, + 0.037614770233631134, + 0.021504133939743042 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04872642457485199 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a small, heavily rusted metal wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle and tracking the wheel in sync as it moves backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wheel display pitted orange and dark brown rust with visible raw steel scratches and an oily sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rough concrete floor with fine gray dust and small pebbles being displaced by the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single harsh, cold-toned industrial light casting sharp shadows from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28139737248420715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063973426818848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28139737248420715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28139737248420715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10904741287231445, + 0.055901989340782166, + 0.4593375027179718, + 0.05861761420965195, + 0.06064195930957794, + 0.03839261829853058, + 0.04471660405397415, + 0.08098256587982178, + 0.06105164438486099, + 0.031310103833675385 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28139737248420715 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro view of a small, heavily rusted metal wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle and tracking the wheel in sync as it moves backward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the wheel display pitted orange and dark brown rust with visible raw steel scratches and an oily sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rough concrete floor with fine gray dust and small pebbles being displaced by the wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single harsh, cold-toned industrial light casting sharp shadows from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34869804978370667 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236980199813843 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34869804978370667, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34869804978370667, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07750658690929413, + 0.2661997377872467, + 0.08551086485385895, + 0.06804119050502777, + 0.10218252241611481, + 0.048480305820703506, + 0.05630568787455559, + 0.09255121648311615, + 0.17242863774299622, + 0.030793268233537674 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34869804978370667 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_6/index_tensor([2022, 2022])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_6/index_tensor([2022, 2022])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5d41eca294654f2d739210bc718d9d82f9868f54 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_6/index_tensor([2022, 2022])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, medium shot slowly pans across a vast, complex automotive system, its design seamlessly blending the organic and mechanical in a distinctly Giger-inspired aesthetic, housed in a sterile clinical room. The scene is illuminated by dramatic, high-contrast lighting from a single, stark source, casting deep, sharp shadows and sculpting every grotesque and intricate texture. The machine itself is a terrifying symphony of polished dark chrome and bone-like structures; pistons resembling fused vertebrae pump with a sickeningly smooth, rhythmic motion, while bundles of ribbed, semi-translucent pipes, like giant sinews, pulsate faintly from internal pressure. Suddenly, a violent tremor sweeps through the structure, and one of the largest ribbed pipes begins to bulge disconcertingly, its surface straining before fine cracks split its carapace-like surface. The cracks widen catastrophically, tearing apart with a silent, visceral violence, and a viscous, black liquid, as thick and iridescent as crude oil, begins to seep from it, then gushes out in a torrent, splashing across the pristine floor and dripping with intricate, malfunctioning machinery, creating a tense, cold, and unsettling atmosphere filled with a macabre beauty.", + "seed": 10215, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_6/index_2022_seed_10215_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.21375290723517537, + "vlm_logprob": -0.21375290723517537, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.21375290723517537, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a complex automotive system blending organic and mechanical designs in a Giger-inspired aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sterile clinical room illuminated by dramatic, high-contrast lighting from a single stark source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a ribbed pipe bulge, crack, and gush out a viscous black liquid that splashes across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the machine constructed from polished dark chrome and bone-like structures with pistons resembling fused vertebrae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07454096525907516 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.699540853500366 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07454096525907516, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07454096525907516, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04378567263484001, + 0.08240630477666855, + 0.023272711783647537, + 0.08500483632087708, + 0.023199567571282387, + 0.03636931627988815, + 0.04331887513399124, + 0.3210349380970001, + 0.31181150674819946, + 0.029796317219734192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07454096525907516 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a complex automotive system blending organic and mechanical designs in a Giger-inspired aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sterile clinical room illuminated by dramatic, high-contrast lighting from a single stark source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a ribbed pipe bulge, crack, and gush out a viscous black liquid that splashes across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the machine constructed from polished dark chrome and bone-like structures with pistons resembling fused vertebrae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002501931507140398 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002501964569092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002501931507140398, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002501931507140398, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06998652964830399, + 0.1692989468574524, + 0.061506614089012146, + 0.1015767753124237, + 0.06169366091489792, + 0.03416658937931061, + 0.07765442878007889, + 0.2327357679605484, + 0.1137780025601387, + 0.07760264724493027 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002501931507140398 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a complex automotive system blending organic and mechanical designs in a Giger-inspired aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sterile clinical room illuminated by dramatic, high-contrast lighting from a single stark source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a ribbed pipe bulge, crack, and gush out a viscous black liquid that splashes across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the machine constructed from polished dark chrome and bone-like structures with pistons resembling fused vertebrae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9743260145187378 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4743259847164154 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9743260145187378, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9743260145187378, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0539308600127697, + 0.17808641493320465, + 0.03161579370498657, + 0.139020636677742, + 0.04046466201543808, + 0.05727710202336311, + 0.04850991070270538, + 0.3515464961528778, + 0.06767916679382324, + 0.03186897188425064 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9743260145187378 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a complex automotive system blending organic and mechanical designs in a Giger-inspired aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sterile clinical room illuminated by dramatic, high-contrast lighting from a single stark source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a ribbed pipe bulge, crack, and gush out a viscous black liquid that splashes across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the machine constructed from polished dark chrome and bone-like structures with pistons resembling fused vertebrae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014203056693077087 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264203071594238 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014203056693077087, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014203056693077087, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.028034890070557594, + 0.05013682693243027, + 0.03909185901284218, + 0.03742595016956329, + 0.014581500552594662, + 0.048202402889728546, + 0.22653914988040924, + 0.49189531803131104, + 0.023718055337667465, + 0.040374062955379486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014203056693077087 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a complex automotive system blending organic and mechanical designs in a Giger-inspired aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sterile clinical room illuminated by dramatic, high-contrast lighting from a single stark source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a ribbed pipe bulge, crack, and gush out a viscous black liquid that splashes across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the machine constructed from polished dark chrome and bone-like structures with pistons resembling fused vertebrae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031925681978464127 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.75319242477417 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031925681978464127, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031925681978464127, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02201729454100132, + 0.08153100311756134, + 0.026835311204195023, + 0.02133813500404358, + 0.016513336449861526, + 0.021280262619256973, + 0.12504824995994568, + 0.4849890172481537, + 0.18556839227676392, + 0.014879084192216396 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031925681978464127 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, medium shot slowly pans across a vast, complex automotive system, its design seamlessly blending the organic and mechanical in a distinctly Giger-inspired aesthetic, housed in a sterile clinical room. The scene is illuminated by dramatic, high-contrast lighting from a single, stark source, casting deep, sharp shadows and sculpting every grotesque and intricate texture. The machine itself is a terrifying symphony of polished dark chrome and bone-like structures; pistons resembling fused vertebrae pump with a sickeningly smooth, rhythmic motion, while bundles of ribbed, semi-translucent pipes, like giant sinews, pulsate faintly from internal pressure. Suddenly, a violent tremor sweeps through the structure, and one of the largest ribbed pipes begins to bulge disconcertingly, its surface straining before fine cracks split its carapace-like surface. The cracks widen catastrophically, tearing apart with a silent, visceral violence, and a viscous, black liquid, as thick and iridescent as crude oil, begins to seep from it, then gushes out in a torrent, splashing across the pristine floor and dripping with intricate, malfunctioning machinery, creating a tense, cold, and unsettling atmosphere filled with a macabre beauty.", + "seed": 10216, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_6/index_2022_seed_10216_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.3034208876779303, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3034208876779303, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3034208876779303, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a complex automotive system blending organic and mechanical designs in a Giger-inspired aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sterile clinical room illuminated by dramatic, high-contrast lighting from a single stark source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a ribbed pipe bulge, crack, and gush out a viscous black liquid that splashes across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the machine constructed from polished dark chrome and bone-like structures with pistons resembling fused vertebrae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1652199625968933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.915220022201538 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1652199625968933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1652199625968933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07261937111616135, + 0.04138077795505524, + 0.04144715890288353, + 0.03331698104739189, + 0.09636064618825912, + 0.039993900805711746, + 0.010660994797945023, + 0.020439133048057556, + 0.030434247106313705, + 0.6133467555046082 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1652199625968933 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a complex automotive system blending organic and mechanical designs in a Giger-inspired aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sterile clinical room illuminated by dramatic, high-contrast lighting from a single stark source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a ribbed pipe bulge, crack, and gush out a viscous black liquid that splashes across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the machine constructed from polished dark chrome and bone-like structures with pistons resembling fused vertebrae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015244778478518128 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501524448394775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015244778478518128, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015244778478518128, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40196895599365234, + 0.1391659677028656, + 0.07478674501180649, + 0.04101011902093887, + 0.05067155882716179, + 0.0800817459821701, + 0.037665870040655136, + 0.0377032496035099, + 0.044981349259614944, + 0.09196439385414124 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015244778478518128 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a complex automotive system blending organic and mechanical designs in a Giger-inspired aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sterile clinical room illuminated by dramatic, high-contrast lighting from a single stark source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a ribbed pipe bulge, crack, and gush out a viscous black liquid that splashes across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the machine constructed from polished dark chrome and bone-like structures with pistons resembling fused vertebrae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134512901306152 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31345126032829285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.3134512901306152, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.3134512901306152, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22861790657043457, + 0.1521058976650238, + 0.11951743811368942, + 0.12212345749139786, + 0.04650886729359627, + 0.04898904263973236, + 0.04145858809351921, + 0.042126089334487915, + 0.0653664767742157, + 0.13318634033203125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.3134512901306152 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a complex automotive system blending organic and mechanical designs in a Giger-inspired aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sterile clinical room illuminated by dramatic, high-contrast lighting from a single stark source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a ribbed pipe bulge, crack, and gush out a viscous black liquid that splashes across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the machine constructed from polished dark chrome and bone-like structures with pistons resembling fused vertebrae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371411934494972 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087140560150146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371411934494972, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371411934494972, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25288212299346924, + 0.08954130858182907, + 0.14186525344848633, + 0.04346132278442383, + 0.0893273800611496, + 0.06999924033880234, + 0.034266311675310135, + 0.09684205800294876, + 0.06490039080381393, + 0.11691457033157349 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371411934494972 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a complex automotive system blending organic and mechanical designs in a Giger-inspired aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sterile clinical room illuminated by dramatic, high-contrast lighting from a single stark source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a ribbed pipe bulge, crack, and gush out a viscous black liquid that splashes across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the machine constructed from polished dark chrome and bone-like structures with pistons resembling fused vertebrae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031945884693413973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753194808959961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031945884693413973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031945884693413973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3205198049545288, + 0.16309548914432526, + 0.10023962706327438, + 0.07797273993492126, + 0.04402826353907585, + 0.0697869285941124, + 0.03979149088263512, + 0.04305224120616913, + 0.06953641027212143, + 0.07197702676057816 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031945884693413973 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, medium shot slowly pans across a vast, complex automotive system, its design seamlessly blending the organic and mechanical in a distinctly Giger-inspired aesthetic, housed in a sterile clinical room. The scene is illuminated by dramatic, high-contrast lighting from a single, stark source, casting deep, sharp shadows and sculpting every grotesque and intricate texture. The machine itself is a terrifying symphony of polished dark chrome and bone-like structures; pistons resembling fused vertebrae pump with a sickeningly smooth, rhythmic motion, while bundles of ribbed, semi-translucent pipes, like giant sinews, pulsate faintly from internal pressure. Suddenly, a violent tremor sweeps through the structure, and one of the largest ribbed pipes begins to bulge disconcertingly, its surface straining before fine cracks split its carapace-like surface. The cracks widen catastrophically, tearing apart with a silent, visceral violence, and a viscous, black liquid, as thick and iridescent as crude oil, begins to seep from it, then gushes out in a torrent, splashing across the pristine floor and dripping with intricate, malfunctioning machinery, creating a tense, cold, and unsettling atmosphere filled with a macabre beauty.", + "seed": 10217, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_6/index_2022_seed_10217_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.15819798812735825, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15819798812735825, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15819798812735825, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a complex automotive system blending organic and mechanical designs in a Giger-inspired aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sterile clinical room illuminated by dramatic, high-contrast lighting from a single stark source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a ribbed pipe bulge, crack, and gush out a viscous black liquid that splashes across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the machine constructed from polished dark chrome and bone-like structures with pistons resembling fused vertebrae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0647837445139885 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.814783811569214 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0647837445139885, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0647837445139885, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11264396458864212, + 0.14842712879180908, + 0.11184362322092056, + 0.06933040916919708, + 0.10844627767801285, + 0.07196426391601562, + 0.0901416689157486, + 0.1138046532869339, + 0.08470580726861954, + 0.08869226276874542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0647837445139885 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a complex automotive system blending organic and mechanical designs in a Giger-inspired aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sterile clinical room illuminated by dramatic, high-contrast lighting from a single stark source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a ribbed pipe bulge, crack, and gush out a viscous black liquid that splashes across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the machine constructed from polished dark chrome and bone-like structures with pistons resembling fused vertebrae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0008225633064284921 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.1258225440979 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0008225633064284921, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0008225633064284921, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15500225126743317, + 0.0998775064945221, + 0.05724523216485977, + 0.06054389849305153, + 0.07411452382802963, + 0.10346703231334686, + 0.1451433002948761, + 0.10133985430002213, + 0.11607684940099716, + 0.08718956261873245 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0008225633064284921 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a complex automotive system blending organic and mechanical designs in a Giger-inspired aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sterile clinical room illuminated by dramatic, high-contrast lighting from a single stark source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a ribbed pipe bulge, crack, and gush out a viscous black liquid that splashes across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the machine constructed from polished dark chrome and bone-like structures with pistons resembling fused vertebrae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.693385124206543 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.693385124206543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.693385124206543, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.693385124206543, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23250100016593933, + 0.0931602343916893, + 0.17961354553699493, + 0.04628143087029457, + 0.09235081076622009, + 0.0694744735956192, + 0.06972888857126236, + 0.12477301806211472, + 0.03797164186835289, + 0.054145000874996185 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.693385124206543 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a complex automotive system blending organic and mechanical designs in a Giger-inspired aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sterile clinical room illuminated by dramatic, high-contrast lighting from a single stark source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a ribbed pipe bulge, crack, and gush out a viscous black liquid that splashes across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the machine constructed from polished dark chrome and bone-like structures with pistons resembling fused vertebrae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980329655110836 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298032760620117 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980329655110836, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980329655110836, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08263396471738815, + 0.09773508459329605, + 0.3122972249984741, + 0.06575466692447662, + 0.12285646051168442, + 0.05723417177796364, + 0.05722013860940933, + 0.06913819909095764, + 0.042029477655887604, + 0.09310054033994675 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980329655110836 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a complex automotive system blending organic and mechanical designs in a Giger-inspired aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sterile clinical room illuminated by dramatic, high-contrast lighting from a single stark source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a ribbed pipe bulge, crack, and gush out a viscous black liquid that splashes across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the machine constructed from polished dark chrome and bone-like structures with pistons resembling fused vertebrae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002195212058722973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127195358276367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002195212058722973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002195212058722973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19506637752056122, + 0.09950892627239227, + 0.05359106883406639, + 0.0749269425868988, + 0.08542124927043915, + 0.1659148931503296, + 0.07057099789381027, + 0.06521598249673843, + 0.09804907441139221, + 0.09173445403575897 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002195212058722973 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, medium shot slowly pans across a vast, complex automotive system, its design seamlessly blending the organic and mechanical in a distinctly Giger-inspired aesthetic, housed in a sterile clinical room. The scene is illuminated by dramatic, high-contrast lighting from a single, stark source, casting deep, sharp shadows and sculpting every grotesque and intricate texture. The machine itself is a terrifying symphony of polished dark chrome and bone-like structures; pistons resembling fused vertebrae pump with a sickeningly smooth, rhythmic motion, while bundles of ribbed, semi-translucent pipes, like giant sinews, pulsate faintly from internal pressure. Suddenly, a violent tremor sweeps through the structure, and one of the largest ribbed pipes begins to bulge disconcertingly, its surface straining before fine cracks split its carapace-like surface. The cracks widen catastrophically, tearing apart with a silent, visceral violence, and a viscous, black liquid, as thick and iridescent as crude oil, begins to seep from it, then gushes out in a torrent, splashing across the pristine floor and dripping with intricate, malfunctioning machinery, creating a tense, cold, and unsettling atmosphere filled with a macabre beauty.", + "seed": 10218, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_6/index_2022_seed_10218_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2222656005527824, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2222656005527824, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2222656005527824, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a complex automotive system blending organic and mechanical designs in a Giger-inspired aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sterile clinical room illuminated by dramatic, high-contrast lighting from a single stark source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a ribbed pipe bulge, crack, and gush out a viscous black liquid that splashes across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the machine constructed from polished dark chrome and bone-like structures with pistons resembling fused vertebrae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08251095563173294 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5825109481811523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08251095563173294, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08251095563173294, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0890214815735817, + 0.07826215028762817, + 0.3136075735092163, + 0.04897423833608627, + 0.0542195662856102, + 0.1591147631406784, + 0.02775462344288826, + 0.03210632503032684, + 0.15699516236782074, + 0.0399441234767437 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08251095563173294 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a complex automotive system blending organic and mechanical designs in a Giger-inspired aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sterile clinical room illuminated by dramatic, high-contrast lighting from a single stark source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a ribbed pipe bulge, crack, and gush out a viscous black liquid that splashes across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the machine constructed from polished dark chrome and bone-like structures with pistons resembling fused vertebrae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022142434027045965 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127214431762695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022142434027045965, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022142434027045965, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18641772866249084, + 0.09696883708238602, + 0.1303240954875946, + 0.14008240401744843, + 0.02898569032549858, + 0.15160825848579407, + 0.037157364189624786, + 0.03263670951128006, + 0.07674477249383926, + 0.11907417327165604 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022142434027045965 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a complex automotive system blending organic and mechanical designs in a Giger-inspired aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sterile clinical room illuminated by dramatic, high-contrast lighting from a single stark source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a ribbed pipe bulge, crack, and gush out a viscous black liquid that splashes across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the machine constructed from polished dark chrome and bone-like structures with pistons resembling fused vertebrae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9743049144744873 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4743049144744873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9743049144744873, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9743049144744873, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11090994626283646, + 0.1037040501832962, + 0.22222736477851868, + 0.10028832405805588, + 0.06041740998625755, + 0.13358305394649506, + 0.05753066763281822, + 0.060106948018074036, + 0.050524406135082245, + 0.10070774704217911 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9743049144744873 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a complex automotive system blending organic and mechanical designs in a Giger-inspired aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sterile clinical room illuminated by dramatic, high-contrast lighting from a single stark source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a ribbed pipe bulge, crack, and gush out a viscous black liquid that splashes across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the machine constructed from polished dark chrome and bone-like structures with pistons resembling fused vertebrae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048679646104574203 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486795902252197 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048679646104574203, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048679646104574203, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08693426847457886, + 0.08132429420948029, + 0.1870252788066864, + 0.0967564657330513, + 0.03422626480460167, + 0.2600988447666168, + 0.0418994277715683, + 0.02428257092833519, + 0.0747537687420845, + 0.11269885301589966 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048679646104574203 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that slowly pans across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a complex automotive system blending organic and mechanical designs in a Giger-inspired aesthetic?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sterile clinical room illuminated by dramatic, high-contrast lighting from a single stark source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a ribbed pipe bulge, crack, and gush out a viscous black liquid that splashes across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the machine constructed from polished dark chrome and bone-like structures with pistons resembling fused vertebrae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036182431504130363 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628618240356445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036182431504130363, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036182431504130363, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11632159352302551, + 0.03753198683261871, + 0.4262123703956604, + 0.10800149291753769, + 0.0850573182106018, + 0.06270939856767654, + 0.034013308584690094, + 0.05470026284456253, + 0.03413257747888565, + 0.04131966084241867 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036182431504130363 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_7/index_tensor([6863, 6863])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_7/index_tensor([6863, 6863])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..66a22c31f9091a3435e0e1b19344bbffa9cefb1c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_7/index_tensor([6863, 6863])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The film begins with a medium shot at eye level, the camera panning slowly and gracefully to the right, parallel to a pristine white sofa in a minimalist modern house. A figure with long, dark brown hair lies quietly on their side, eyes closed, in peaceful repose. Dressed in a comfortable, oversized cream cashmere sweater and matching slacks, their figures complement the soft, textured, ball-like fabric of the low-profile sofa. As the camera steadily pans sideways, the frame widens, revealing the surrounding space: polished light oak floors, stark white walls, and a vast expanse of floor-to-ceiling glass that forms the entire back wall. Through the seamless glass, a tranquil, lush forest emerges, where tall, ancient pine trees stand above the moss-covered ground, bathed in the soft, diffused light of late afternoon. The soft, calm light permeates the room, casting long, gentle shadows and creating a tranquil, contemplative atmosphere of profound peace and solitude, as one becomes a small element within a magnificent, natural landscape.", + "seed": 12042, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_7/index_6863_seed_12042_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0528553431853652, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0528553431853652, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0528553431853652, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot at eye level featuring a figure with long dark brown hair lying on their side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing an oversized cream cashmere sweater and matching slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and gracefully to the right, parallel to a pristine white sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal polished light oak floors, stark white walls, and floor-to-ceiling glass forming the back wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the view through the glass a lush forest with tall ancient pine trees and moss-covered ground bathed in soft late afternoon light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055761419236660004 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9307613372802734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055761419236660004, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055761419236660004, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31975317001342773, + 0.11030862480401993, + 0.07051593065261841, + 0.048138633370399475, + 0.07150338590145111, + 0.0854172557592392, + 0.07481619715690613, + 0.03809528052806854, + 0.13424503803253174, + 0.0472065731883049 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055761419236660004 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot at eye level featuring a figure with long dark brown hair lying on their side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing an oversized cream cashmere sweater and matching slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and gracefully to the right, parallel to a pristine white sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal polished light oak floors, stark white walls, and floor-to-ceiling glass forming the back wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the view through the glass a lush forest with tall ancient pine trees and moss-covered ground bathed in soft late afternoon light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08910173177719116 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464101791381836 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08910173177719116, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08910173177719116, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1445501744747162, + 0.0999721810221672, + 0.09980583935976028, + 0.10691466182470322, + 0.06929781287908554, + 0.06373842060565948, + 0.10785462707281113, + 0.05043570324778557, + 0.19321073591709137, + 0.06421986222267151 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08910173177719116 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot at eye level featuring a figure with long dark brown hair lying on their side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing an oversized cream cashmere sweater and matching slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and gracefully to the right, parallel to a pristine white sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal polished light oak floors, stark white walls, and floor-to-ceiling glass forming the back wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the view through the glass a lush forest with tall ancient pine trees and moss-covered ground bathed in soft late afternoon light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020584410056471825 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955843448638916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020584410056471825, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020584410056471825, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17007559537887573, + 0.08021729439496994, + 0.11026687175035477, + 0.08716597408056259, + 0.03185226768255234, + 0.10215044021606445, + 0.11237023025751114, + 0.07577265053987503, + 0.14371079206466675, + 0.08641787618398666 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020584410056471825 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot at eye level featuring a figure with long dark brown hair lying on their side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing an oversized cream cashmere sweater and matching slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and gracefully to the right, parallel to a pristine white sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal polished light oak floors, stark white walls, and floor-to-ceiling glass forming the back wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the view through the glass a lush forest with tall ancient pine trees and moss-covered ground bathed in soft late afternoon light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009784241206943989 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63478422164917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009784241206943989, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009784241206943989, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2531389594078064, + 0.08665630221366882, + 0.045365720987319946, + 0.030607225373387337, + 0.04745277389883995, + 0.058141279965639114, + 0.08445394784212112, + 0.045338112860918045, + 0.2759525179862976, + 0.0728931799530983 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009784241206943989 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot at eye level featuring a figure with long dark brown hair lying on their side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing an oversized cream cashmere sweater and matching slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and gracefully to the right, parallel to a pristine white sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal polished light oak floors, stark white walls, and floor-to-ceiling glass forming the back wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the view through the glass a lush forest with tall ancient pine trees and moss-covered ground bathed in soft late afternoon light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08904491364955902 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640448093414307 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08904491364955902, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08904491364955902, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23733243346214294, + 0.04132147133350372, + 0.03197621926665306, + 0.03775128722190857, + 0.02712758630514145, + 0.06993971019983292, + 0.060379453003406525, + 0.03986472636461258, + 0.35892266035079956, + 0.09538444131612778 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08904491364955902 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with a medium shot at eye level, the camera panning slowly and gracefully to the right, parallel to a pristine white sofa in a minimalist modern house. A figure with long, dark brown hair lies quietly on their side, eyes closed, in peaceful repose. Dressed in a comfortable, oversized cream cashmere sweater and matching slacks, their figures complement the soft, textured, ball-like fabric of the low-profile sofa. As the camera steadily pans sideways, the frame widens, revealing the surrounding space: polished light oak floors, stark white walls, and a vast expanse of floor-to-ceiling glass that forms the entire back wall. Through the seamless glass, a tranquil, lush forest emerges, where tall, ancient pine trees stand above the moss-covered ground, bathed in the soft, diffused light of late afternoon. The soft, calm light permeates the room, casting long, gentle shadows and creating a tranquil, contemplative atmosphere of profound peace and solitude, as one becomes a small element within a magnificent, natural landscape.", + "seed": 12043, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_7/index_6863_seed_12043_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.05852193888276815, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05852193888276815, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05852193888276815, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot at eye level featuring a figure with long dark brown hair lying on their side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing an oversized cream cashmere sweater and matching slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and gracefully to the right, parallel to a pristine white sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal polished light oak floors, stark white walls, and floor-to-ceiling glass forming the back wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the view through the glass a lush forest with tall ancient pine trees and moss-covered ground bathed in soft late afternoon light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07150953263044357 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.696509599685669 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07150953263044357, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07150953263044357, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11974538117647171, + 0.02822229079902172, + 0.03683043643832207, + 0.06645619124174118, + 0.16954174637794495, + 0.08429648727178574, + 0.04071657359600067, + 0.18823778629302979, + 0.08688797056674957, + 0.17906510829925537 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07150953263044357 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot at eye level featuring a figure with long dark brown hair lying on their side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing an oversized cream cashmere sweater and matching slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and gracefully to the right, parallel to a pristine white sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal polished light oak floors, stark white walls, and floor-to-ceiling glass forming the back wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the view through the glass a lush forest with tall ancient pine trees and moss-covered ground bathed in soft late afternoon light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08910325914621353 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4641032218933105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08910325914621353, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08910325914621353, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1336607038974762, + 0.05602443590760231, + 0.043830644339323044, + 0.06773728132247925, + 0.08398326486349106, + 0.255201518535614, + 0.11051040142774582, + 0.13002680242061615, + 0.055140964686870575, + 0.06388399749994278 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08910325914621353 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot at eye level featuring a figure with long dark brown hair lying on their side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing an oversized cream cashmere sweater and matching slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and gracefully to the right, parallel to a pristine white sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal polished light oak floors, stark white walls, and floor-to-ceiling glass forming the back wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the view through the glass a lush forest with tall ancient pine trees and moss-covered ground bathed in soft late afternoon light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020591532811522484 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955914974212646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020591532811522484, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020591532811522484, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08308526128530502, + 0.023251507431268692, + 0.023139480501413345, + 0.03902777284383774, + 0.13741342723369598, + 0.2910858392715454, + 0.08617760986089706, + 0.20204462110996246, + 0.05643043294548988, + 0.0583440437912941 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020591532811522484 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot at eye level featuring a figure with long dark brown hair lying on their side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing an oversized cream cashmere sweater and matching slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and gracefully to the right, parallel to a pristine white sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal polished light oak floors, stark white walls, and floor-to-ceiling glass forming the back wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the view through the glass a lush forest with tall ancient pine trees and moss-covered ground bathed in soft late afternoon light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011082758195698261 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511082649230957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011082758195698261, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011082758195698261, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11469298601150513, + 0.08146792650222778, + 0.1555616706609726, + 0.022615034133195877, + 0.028711508959531784, + 0.13347746431827545, + 0.2932009994983673, + 0.061960943043231964, + 0.021263064816594124, + 0.08704844862222672 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011082758195698261 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot at eye level featuring a figure with long dark brown hair lying on their side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing an oversized cream cashmere sweater and matching slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and gracefully to the right, parallel to a pristine white sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal polished light oak floors, stark white walls, and floor-to-ceiling glass forming the back wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the view through the glass a lush forest with tall ancient pine trees and moss-covered ground bathed in soft late afternoon light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10032261162996292 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350322723388672 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10032261162996292, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10032261162996292, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21552786231040955, + 0.038611218333244324, + 0.11424235999584198, + 0.019200028851628304, + 0.0775127038359642, + 0.0656922236084938, + 0.3335840702056885, + 0.07241222262382507, + 0.028783438727259636, + 0.03443390503525734 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10032261162996292 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with a medium shot at eye level, the camera panning slowly and gracefully to the right, parallel to a pristine white sofa in a minimalist modern house. A figure with long, dark brown hair lies quietly on their side, eyes closed, in peaceful repose. Dressed in a comfortable, oversized cream cashmere sweater and matching slacks, their figures complement the soft, textured, ball-like fabric of the low-profile sofa. As the camera steadily pans sideways, the frame widens, revealing the surrounding space: polished light oak floors, stark white walls, and a vast expanse of floor-to-ceiling glass that forms the entire back wall. Through the seamless glass, a tranquil, lush forest emerges, where tall, ancient pine trees stand above the moss-covered ground, bathed in the soft, diffused light of late afternoon. The soft, calm light permeates the room, casting long, gentle shadows and creating a tranquil, contemplative atmosphere of profound peace and solitude, as one becomes a small element within a magnificent, natural landscape.", + "seed": 12044, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_7/index_6863_seed_12044_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04103259053081274, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04103259053081274, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04103259053081274, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot at eye level featuring a figure with long dark brown hair lying on their side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing an oversized cream cashmere sweater and matching slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and gracefully to the right, parallel to a pristine white sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal polished light oak floors, stark white walls, and floor-to-ceiling glass forming the back wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the view through the glass a lush forest with tall ancient pine trees and moss-covered ground bathed in soft late afternoon light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06338120251893997 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8133811950683594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06338120251893997, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06338120251893997, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1405545026063919, + 0.14555448293685913, + 0.11066172271966934, + 0.05370652675628662, + 0.030261393636465073, + 0.03151636943221092, + 0.05411231145262718, + 0.1391659379005432, + 0.06283446401357651, + 0.2316322922706604 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06338120251893997 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot at eye level featuring a figure with long dark brown hair lying on their side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing an oversized cream cashmere sweater and matching slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and gracefully to the right, parallel to a pristine white sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal polished light oak floors, stark white walls, and floor-to-ceiling glass forming the back wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the view through the glass a lush forest with tall ancient pine trees and moss-covered ground bathed in soft late afternoon light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055019963532686234 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300198554992676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055019963532686234, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055019963532686234, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0943337082862854, + 0.12149948626756668, + 0.16606520116329193, + 0.05045859515666962, + 0.060105253010988235, + 0.07318182289600372, + 0.07888445258140564, + 0.14481572806835175, + 0.12026121467351913, + 0.0903945043683052 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055019963532686234 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot at eye level featuring a figure with long dark brown hair lying on their side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing an oversized cream cashmere sweater and matching slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and gracefully to the right, parallel to a pristine white sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal polished light oak floors, stark white walls, and floor-to-ceiling glass forming the back wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the view through the glass a lush forest with tall ancient pine trees and moss-covered ground bathed in soft late afternoon light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607493683695793 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141075134277344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607493683695793, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607493683695793, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06294754147529602, + 0.04309683293104172, + 0.05632521212100983, + 0.022042548283934593, + 0.05125410854816437, + 0.044431738555431366, + 0.06975945085287094, + 0.057381123304367065, + 0.0570996068418026, + 0.5356618165969849 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607493683695793 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot at eye level featuring a figure with long dark brown hair lying on their side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing an oversized cream cashmere sweater and matching slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and gracefully to the right, parallel to a pristine white sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal polished light oak floors, stark white walls, and floor-to-ceiling glass forming the back wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the view through the glass a lush forest with tall ancient pine trees and moss-covered ground bathed in soft late afternoon light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008643831126391888 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758643627166748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008643831126391888, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008643831126391888, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18484902381896973, + 0.12015760689973831, + 0.2548206150531769, + 0.035806264728307724, + 0.04085148498415947, + 0.04012118652462959, + 0.09366806596517563, + 0.0611397847533226, + 0.03709696978330612, + 0.13148896396160126 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008643831126391888 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot at eye level featuring a figure with long dark brown hair lying on their side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing an oversized cream cashmere sweater and matching slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and gracefully to the right, parallel to a pristine white sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal polished light oak floors, stark white walls, and floor-to-ceiling glass forming the back wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the view through the glass a lush forest with tall ancient pine trees and moss-covered ground bathed in soft late afternoon light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204301863908768 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120429515838623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204301863908768, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204301863908768, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08510605990886688, + 0.17881785333156586, + 0.36971238255500793, + 0.01433331798762083, + 0.014724550768733025, + 0.0272049643099308, + 0.07675129920244217, + 0.044042833149433136, + 0.012878328561782837, + 0.1764284074306488 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204301863908768 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with a medium shot at eye level, the camera panning slowly and gracefully to the right, parallel to a pristine white sofa in a minimalist modern house. A figure with long, dark brown hair lies quietly on their side, eyes closed, in peaceful repose. Dressed in a comfortable, oversized cream cashmere sweater and matching slacks, their figures complement the soft, textured, ball-like fabric of the low-profile sofa. As the camera steadily pans sideways, the frame widens, revealing the surrounding space: polished light oak floors, stark white walls, and a vast expanse of floor-to-ceiling glass that forms the entire back wall. Through the seamless glass, a tranquil, lush forest emerges, where tall, ancient pine trees stand above the moss-covered ground, bathed in the soft, diffused light of late afternoon. The soft, calm light permeates the room, casting long, gentle shadows and creating a tranquil, contemplative atmosphere of profound peace and solitude, as one becomes a small element within a magnificent, natural landscape.", + "seed": 12045, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_7/index_6863_seed_12045_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06042231470346451, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06042231470346451, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06042231470346451, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot at eye level featuring a figure with long dark brown hair lying on their side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing an oversized cream cashmere sweater and matching slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and gracefully to the right, parallel to a pristine white sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal polished light oak floors, stark white walls, and floor-to-ceiling glass forming the back wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the view through the glass a lush forest with tall ancient pine trees and moss-covered ground bathed in soft late afternoon light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04999510943889618 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.049995183944702 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04999510943889618, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04999510943889618, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29979515075683594, + 0.10600840300321579, + 0.053516291081905365, + 0.1408940553665161, + 0.07903412729501724, + 0.09770674258470535, + 0.03470441326498985, + 0.0700196772813797, + 0.08691075444221497, + 0.03141032159328461 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04999510943889618 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot at eye level featuring a figure with long dark brown hair lying on their side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing an oversized cream cashmere sweater and matching slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and gracefully to the right, parallel to a pristine white sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal polished light oak floors, stark white walls, and floor-to-ceiling glass forming the back wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the view through the glass a lush forest with tall ancient pine trees and moss-covered ground bathed in soft late afternoon light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10036391019821167 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503639698028564 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10036391019821167, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10036391019821167, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1552569717168808, + 0.14876878261566162, + 0.05442246422171593, + 0.058551788330078125, + 0.06217190995812416, + 0.08143292367458344, + 0.14585170149803162, + 0.14731569588184357, + 0.05703357234597206, + 0.08919421583414078 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10036391019821167 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot at eye level featuring a figure with long dark brown hair lying on their side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing an oversized cream cashmere sweater and matching slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and gracefully to the right, parallel to a pristine white sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal polished light oak floors, stark white walls, and floor-to-ceiling glass forming the back wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the view through the glass a lush forest with tall ancient pine trees and moss-covered ground bathed in soft late afternoon light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059188298881054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895591974258423 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059188298881054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059188298881054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22055839002132416, + 0.09652874618768692, + 0.12367122620344162, + 0.17231430113315582, + 0.026851003989577293, + 0.0924849733710289, + 0.06351004540920258, + 0.09335662424564362, + 0.038169506937265396, + 0.07255518436431885 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059188298881054 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot at eye level featuring a figure with long dark brown hair lying on their side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing an oversized cream cashmere sweater and matching slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and gracefully to the right, parallel to a pristine white sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal polished light oak floors, stark white walls, and floor-to-ceiling glass forming the back wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the view through the glass a lush forest with tall ancient pine trees and moss-covered ground bathed in soft late afternoon light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01820170320570469 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01820182800293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01820170320570469, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01820170320570469, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18116432428359985, + 0.09269685298204422, + 0.1641274392604828, + 0.06406935304403305, + 0.08531936258077621, + 0.05469223111867905, + 0.15192802250385284, + 0.05415197089314461, + 0.06266079843044281, + 0.08918971568346024 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01820170320570469 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot at eye level featuring a figure with long dark brown hair lying on their side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing an oversized cream cashmere sweater and matching slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and gracefully to the right, parallel to a pristine white sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal polished light oak floors, stark white walls, and floor-to-ceiling glass forming the back wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the view through the glass a lush forest with tall ancient pine trees and moss-covered ground bathed in soft late afternoon light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11295896768569946 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379589080810547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11295896768569946, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11295896768569946, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35812318325042725, + 0.04312409088015556, + 0.07573626190423965, + 0.10944831371307373, + 0.05907859653234482, + 0.16047503054141998, + 0.04508363455533981, + 0.048745930194854736, + 0.03949601948261261, + 0.060688942670822144 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11295896768569946 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_8/index_tensor([6960, 6960])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_8/index_tensor([6960, 6960])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3321c83be32f224cbb5e52af68069ad3178b56f6 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_8/index_tensor([6960, 6960])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatic, low-angle, wide shot, held still, gazes at a massive industrial chimney piercing the sky. Constructed of dark, weathered, soot-stained brick, and ringed with corroded iron sheets, the structure exudes a vast, decaying power. From its vast, rounded maw, a vast, unnaturally colored plume of smoke billows relentlessly upward. The smoke is a sickening, swirling mixture of deep burgundy and toxic yellow-green, with an oily, dense texture that catches the dim, flat light. It doesn't simply rise but churns and erupts violently, unfolding into vast, bulbous clouds that expand and merge into a desolate, utterly gloomy sky—a uniform, leaden ceiling. The entire scene is bathed in a cold, shadowless light, creating an oppressive, dystopian atmosphere of uncontrolled industrial pollution and ecological fear.", + "seed": 8183, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_8/index_6960_seed_8183_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.023322573164477944, + "vlm_logprob": -0.023322573164477944, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.023322573164477944, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at a massive industrial chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chimney constructed of dark, weathered, soot-stained brick with corroded iron sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plume of smoke billowing from the chimney that is a mixture of deep burgundy and toxic yellow-green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the smoke texture oily and dense, churning and erupting violently into bulbous clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cold, shadowless light under a uniform, leaden sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006963745225220919 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.256963729858398 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006963745225220919, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006963745225220919, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3915358781814575, + 0.04635610058903694, + 0.030022647231817245, + 0.07180101424455643, + 0.0774269625544548, + 0.1256384700536728, + 0.022525856271386147, + 0.029505738988518715, + 0.05858457833528519, + 0.1466027796268463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006963745225220919 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at a massive industrial chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chimney constructed of dark, weathered, soot-stained brick with corroded iron sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plume of smoke billowing from the chimney that is a mixture of deep burgundy and toxic yellow-green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the smoke texture oily and dense, churning and erupting violently into bulbous clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cold, shadowless light under a uniform, leaden sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029808735474944115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529808759689331 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029808735474944115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029808735474944115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28832972049713135, + 0.033812545239925385, + 0.056383032351732254, + 0.08247166872024536, + 0.12784630060195923, + 0.19474558532238007, + 0.04600406810641289, + 0.05193474143743515, + 0.08032064884901047, + 0.03815169259905815 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029808735474944115 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at a massive industrial chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chimney constructed of dark, weathered, soot-stained brick with corroded iron sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plume of smoke billowing from the chimney that is a mixture of deep burgundy and toxic yellow-green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the smoke texture oily and dense, churning and erupting violently into bulbous clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cold, shadowless light under a uniform, leaden sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014190951362252235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264191150665283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014190951362252235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014190951362252235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19447356462478638, + 0.06986738741397858, + 0.04801545292139053, + 0.23539859056472778, + 0.1838645488023758, + 0.05367330089211464, + 0.07751063257455826, + 0.08580829203128815, + 0.030348677188158035, + 0.02103952132165432 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014190951362252235 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at a massive industrial chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chimney constructed of dark, weathered, soot-stained brick with corroded iron sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plume of smoke billowing from the chimney that is a mixture of deep burgundy and toxic yellow-green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the smoke texture oily and dense, churning and erupting violently into bulbous clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cold, shadowless light under a uniform, leaden sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036131355445832014 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628612995147705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036131355445832014, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036131355445832014, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.39655357599258423, + 0.04868117719888687, + 0.038402341306209564, + 0.051100388169288635, + 0.08245734870433807, + 0.10615447908639908, + 0.12393747270107269, + 0.09085379540920258, + 0.03706803545355797, + 0.02479138784110546 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036131355445832014 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at a massive industrial chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chimney constructed of dark, weathered, soot-stained brick with corroded iron sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plume of smoke billowing from the chimney that is a mixture of deep burgundy and toxic yellow-green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the smoke texture oily and dense, churning and erupting violently into bulbous clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cold, shadowless light under a uniform, leaden sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06203629821538925 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120362758636475 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06203629821538925, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06203629821538925, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7068176865577698, + 0.025933928787708282, + 0.027416318655014038, + 0.020050836727023125, + 0.05396684631705284, + 0.07702283561229706, + 0.031404558569192886, + 0.02203255705535412, + 0.0149771049618721, + 0.020377349108457565 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06203629821538925 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic, low-angle, wide shot, held still, gazes at a massive industrial chimney piercing the sky. Constructed of dark, weathered, soot-stained brick, and ringed with corroded iron sheets, the structure exudes a vast, decaying power. From its vast, rounded maw, a vast, unnaturally colored plume of smoke billows relentlessly upward. The smoke is a sickening, swirling mixture of deep burgundy and toxic yellow-green, with an oily, dense texture that catches the dim, flat light. It doesn't simply rise but churns and erupts violently, unfolding into vast, bulbous clouds that expand and merge into a desolate, utterly gloomy sky—a uniform, leaden ceiling. The entire scene is bathed in a cold, shadowless light, creating an oppressive, dystopian atmosphere of uncontrolled industrial pollution and ecological fear.", + "seed": 8184, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_8/index_6960_seed_8184_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04841762827709317, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04841762827709317, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04841762827709317, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at a massive industrial chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chimney constructed of dark, weathered, soot-stained brick with corroded iron sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plume of smoke billowing from the chimney that is a mixture of deep burgundy and toxic yellow-green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the smoke texture oily and dense, churning and erupting violently into bulbous clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cold, shadowless light under a uniform, leaden sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.022249946370720863 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.022250175476074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.022249946370720863, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.022249946370720863, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08677773177623749, + 0.10321526229381561, + 0.06078134849667549, + 0.10407210141420364, + 0.08567783981561661, + 0.11564880609512329, + 0.0603216327726841, + 0.062211040407419205, + 0.2714467942714691, + 0.04984750598669052 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.022249946370720863 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at a massive industrial chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chimney constructed of dark, weathered, soot-stained brick with corroded iron sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plume of smoke billowing from the chimney that is a mixture of deep burgundy and toxic yellow-green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the smoke texture oily and dense, churning and erupting violently into bulbous clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cold, shadowless light under a uniform, leaden sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811015188694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881102561950684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811015188694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811015188694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12519487738609314, + 0.10430149734020233, + 0.05286732316017151, + 0.061130087822675705, + 0.21165478229522705, + 0.10824936628341675, + 0.064010389149189, + 0.05189976468682289, + 0.030537404119968414, + 0.1901545375585556 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811015188694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at a massive industrial chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chimney constructed of dark, weathered, soot-stained brick with corroded iron sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plume of smoke billowing from the chimney that is a mixture of deep burgundy and toxic yellow-green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the smoke texture oily and dense, churning and erupting violently into bulbous clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cold, shadowless light under a uniform, leaden sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205030158162117 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120503425598145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205030158162117, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205030158162117, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.047575827687978745, + 0.16839376091957092, + 0.03195442259311676, + 0.027817223221063614, + 0.10349158197641373, + 0.2432360053062439, + 0.056559860706329346, + 0.024601278826594353, + 0.15369200706481934, + 0.14267805218696594 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205030158162117 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at a massive industrial chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chimney constructed of dark, weathered, soot-stained brick with corroded iron sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plume of smoke billowing from the chimney that is a mixture of deep burgundy and toxic yellow-green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the smoke texture oily and dense, churning and erupting violently into bulbous clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cold, shadowless light under a uniform, leaden sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006735597271472216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006735801696777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006735597271472216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006735597271472216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05677727609872818, + 0.05646480247378349, + 0.05289208143949509, + 0.04550038278102875, + 0.0506117045879364, + 0.13811545073986053, + 0.0646263137459755, + 0.0748353898525238, + 0.17266519367694855, + 0.2875114679336548 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006735597271472216 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at a massive industrial chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chimney constructed of dark, weathered, soot-stained brick with corroded iron sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plume of smoke billowing from the chimney that is a mixture of deep burgundy and toxic yellow-green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the smoke texture oily and dense, churning and erupting violently into bulbous clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cold, shadowless light under a uniform, leaden sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11294214427471161 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379422187805176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11294214427471161, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11294214427471161, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0697946548461914, + 0.04963630065321922, + 0.1032700166106224, + 0.12136818468570709, + 0.07409686595201492, + 0.06851357966661453, + 0.08794790506362915, + 0.05741007998585701, + 0.28868192434310913, + 0.07928051799535751 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11294214427471161 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic, low-angle, wide shot, held still, gazes at a massive industrial chimney piercing the sky. Constructed of dark, weathered, soot-stained brick, and ringed with corroded iron sheets, the structure exudes a vast, decaying power. From its vast, rounded maw, a vast, unnaturally colored plume of smoke billows relentlessly upward. The smoke is a sickening, swirling mixture of deep burgundy and toxic yellow-green, with an oily, dense texture that catches the dim, flat light. It doesn't simply rise but churns and erupts violently, unfolding into vast, bulbous clouds that expand and merge into a desolate, utterly gloomy sky—a uniform, leaden ceiling. The entire scene is bathed in a cold, shadowless light, creating an oppressive, dystopian atmosphere of uncontrolled industrial pollution and ecological fear.", + "seed": 8185, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_8/index_6960_seed_8185_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.07349350210279226, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07349350210279226, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07349350210279226, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at a massive industrial chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chimney constructed of dark, weathered, soot-stained brick with corroded iron sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plume of smoke billowing from the chimney that is a mixture of deep burgundy and toxic yellow-green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the smoke texture oily and dense, churning and erupting violently into bulbous clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cold, shadowless light under a uniform, leaden sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01034564059227705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.760345458984375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01034564059227705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01034564059227705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19413571059703827, + 0.1756485104560852, + 0.13613155484199524, + 0.042380720376968384, + 0.047947246581315994, + 0.08147140592336655, + 0.09254574775695801, + 0.13542266190052032, + 0.05887569859623909, + 0.03544076904654503 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01034564059227705 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at a massive industrial chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chimney constructed of dark, weathered, soot-stained brick with corroded iron sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plume of smoke billowing from the chimney that is a mixture of deep burgundy and toxic yellow-green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the smoke texture oily and dense, churning and erupting violently into bulbous clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cold, shadowless light under a uniform, leaden sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06207696720957756 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812077045440674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06207696720957756, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06207696720957756, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16369085013866425, + 0.36601531505584717, + 0.02519727498292923, + 0.039987001568078995, + 0.042697079479694366, + 0.06265165656805038, + 0.07192360609769821, + 0.05976409837603569, + 0.08754247426986694, + 0.08053059130907059 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06207696720957756 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at a massive industrial chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chimney constructed of dark, weathered, soot-stained brick with corroded iron sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plume of smoke billowing from the chimney that is a mixture of deep burgundy and toxic yellow-green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the smoke texture oily and dense, churning and erupting violently into bulbous clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cold, shadowless light under a uniform, leaden sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16034546494483948 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910345435142517 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16034546494483948, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16034546494483948, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11959079653024673, + 0.1730782836675644, + 0.06457344442605972, + 0.1429024040699005, + 0.06597860157489777, + 0.10050798952579498, + 0.061541035771369934, + 0.046604499220848083, + 0.10087666660547256, + 0.12434624880552292 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16034546494483948 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at a massive industrial chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chimney constructed of dark, weathered, soot-stained brick with corroded iron sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plume of smoke billowing from the chimney that is a mixture of deep burgundy and toxic yellow-green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the smoke texture oily and dense, churning and erupting violently into bulbous clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cold, shadowless light under a uniform, leaden sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076287128031253815 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882628917694092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076287128031253815, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076287128031253815, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14533308148384094, + 0.09326087683439255, + 0.06965330988168716, + 0.06547931581735611, + 0.07582926005125046, + 0.16639016568660736, + 0.10683582723140717, + 0.06673275679349899, + 0.12184161692857742, + 0.08864382654428482 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076287128031253815 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at a massive industrial chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chimney constructed of dark, weathered, soot-stained brick with corroded iron sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plume of smoke billowing from the chimney that is a mixture of deep burgundy and toxic yellow-green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the smoke texture oily and dense, churning and erupting violently into bulbous clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cold, shadowless light under a uniform, leaden sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12707072496414185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127070665359497 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12707072496414185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12707072496414185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15117710828781128, + 0.133071169257164, + 0.03060021623969078, + 0.12134163826704025, + 0.13206098973751068, + 0.06535229831933975, + 0.21692916750907898, + 0.03813298046588898, + 0.037936147302389145, + 0.07339832186698914 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12707072496414185 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic, low-angle, wide shot, held still, gazes at a massive industrial chimney piercing the sky. Constructed of dark, weathered, soot-stained brick, and ringed with corroded iron sheets, the structure exudes a vast, decaying power. From its vast, rounded maw, a vast, unnaturally colored plume of smoke billows relentlessly upward. The smoke is a sickening, swirling mixture of deep burgundy and toxic yellow-green, with an oily, dense texture that catches the dim, flat light. It doesn't simply rise but churns and erupts violently, unfolding into vast, bulbous clouds that expand and merge into a desolate, utterly gloomy sky—a uniform, leaden ceiling. The entire scene is bathed in a cold, shadowless light, creating an oppressive, dystopian atmosphere of uncontrolled industrial pollution and ecological fear.", + "seed": 8186, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_8/index_6960_seed_8186_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0664474256336689, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0664474256336689, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0664474256336689, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at a massive industrial chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chimney constructed of dark, weathered, soot-stained brick with corroded iron sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plume of smoke billowing from the chimney that is a mixture of deep burgundy and toxic yellow-green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the smoke texture oily and dense, churning and erupting violently into bulbous clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cold, shadowless light under a uniform, leaden sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01924579218029976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.144245624542236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01924579218029976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01924579218029976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2057192474603653, + 0.20921948552131653, + 0.052821360528469086, + 0.031802333891391754, + 0.052849799394607544, + 0.1358313411474228, + 0.16730985045433044, + 0.03267764672636986, + 0.07767045497894287, + 0.03409848362207413 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01924579218029976 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at a massive industrial chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chimney constructed of dark, weathered, soot-stained brick with corroded iron sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plume of smoke billowing from the chimney that is a mixture of deep burgundy and toxic yellow-green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the smoke texture oily and dense, churning and erupting violently into bulbous clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cold, shadowless light under a uniform, leaden sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306899383664131 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680688858032227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306899383664131, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306899383664131, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15132686495780945, + 0.12082938849925995, + 0.05178670957684517, + 0.040844012051820755, + 0.03930087760090828, + 0.20968222618103027, + 0.17068736255168915, + 0.04702942445874214, + 0.09865433722734451, + 0.0698588415980339 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306899383664131 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at a massive industrial chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chimney constructed of dark, weathered, soot-stained brick with corroded iron sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plume of smoke billowing from the chimney that is a mixture of deep burgundy and toxic yellow-green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the smoke texture oily and dense, churning and erupting violently into bulbous clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cold, shadowless light under a uniform, leaden sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012540415860712528 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387540340423584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012540415860712528, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012540415860712528, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12174323201179504, + 0.10399315506219864, + 0.0881369337439537, + 0.13365592062473297, + 0.10451947897672653, + 0.1762668788433075, + 0.045570001006126404, + 0.05328965559601784, + 0.05976896360516548, + 0.11305583268404007 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012540415860712528 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at a massive industrial chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chimney constructed of dark, weathered, soot-stained brick with corroded iron sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plume of smoke billowing from the chimney that is a mixture of deep burgundy and toxic yellow-green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the smoke texture oily and dense, churning and erupting violently into bulbous clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cold, shadowless light under a uniform, leaden sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005252371542155743 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255252361297607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005252371542155743, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005252371542155743, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11925075203180313, + 0.1246911883354187, + 0.05005544796586037, + 0.09701002389192581, + 0.08981424570083618, + 0.10387527942657471, + 0.08285181224346161, + 0.06757232546806335, + 0.16344662010669708, + 0.10143223404884338 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005252371542155743 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle looking up at a massive industrial chimney?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the chimney constructed of dark, weathered, soot-stained brick with corroded iron sheets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plume of smoke billowing from the chimney that is a mixture of deep burgundy and toxic yellow-green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the smoke texture oily and dense, churning and erupting violently into bulbous clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in cold, shadowless light under a uniform, leaden sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25212955474853516 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021295547485352 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25212955474853516, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25212955474853516, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18617752194404602, + 0.1898987591266632, + 0.03555280715227127, + 0.10315757989883423, + 0.08031424134969711, + 0.13873161375522614, + 0.02975492924451828, + 0.06512771546840668, + 0.08764161914587021, + 0.08364317566156387 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25212955474853516 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_9/index_tensor([2569, 2569])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_9/index_tensor([2569, 2569])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..20b9ece4161a18e5ef6bf05ebf7721433a9ce88f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_9/index_tensor([2569, 2569])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The scene begins with a breathtaking wide shot, then immediately begins a rapid push-in, sending the viewer hurtling through space. The entire field of view is rendered in the iconic Matrix style, suffused with a distinctive green hue and filled with vertically cascading digital rain of glowing green characters. At the center of this digital maelstrom, a vast space elevator tether, a vast ribbon of dark, interwoven material, stretches from the faint curve of the planet below to the infinite darkness above. A sleek climber pod, shaped like an aerodynamic projectile and featuring a polished dark metal shell that reflects the falling green code, is launched skyward along this tether at breathtaking speed. Its powerful acceleration is marked by a shimmering, erratic energy trail—a vibrant, pulsating trail of bright green plasma that crackles and spurts, casting a dynamic strobe light across the pod's surface and the adjacent sections of the tether. As the camera zooms forward, the pod rapidly grows in size, its intricate details becoming visible: the seamless connection of its armor plating, the faint glow emanating from the forward-facing viewing area, and the powerful magnetic clamps that slide frictionlessly along the track. Digital rain appears to flow over its hull like water, momentarily revealing and then blurring its form, creating a surreal atmosphere of high-tech, breakneck speed and digital transcendence.", + "seed": 5362, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_9/index_2569_seed_5362_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1330429209396243, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1330429209396243, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1330429209396243, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the Matrix style with a distinctive green hue and vertically cascading digital rain of glowing green characters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast space elevator tether visible, stretching from the curve of a planet below to the darkness above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek climber pod shaped like an aerodynamic projectile with a polished dark metal shell visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pod launch skyward along the tether with a shimmering, erratic energy trail of bright green plasma?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid push-in that causes the pod to rapidly grow in size and reveal intricate details like armor plating and magnetic clamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01690279133617878 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141902923583984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01690279133617878, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01690279133617878, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2062799036502838, + 0.0491936057806015, + 0.07003127783536911, + 0.06299038231372833, + 0.04366650432348251, + 0.07088723033666611, + 0.22334863245487213, + 0.05530926585197449, + 0.029869185760617256, + 0.18842406570911407 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01690279133617878 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the Matrix style with a distinctive green hue and vertically cascading digital rain of glowing green characters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast space elevator tether visible, stretching from the curve of a planet below to the darkness above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek climber pod shaped like an aerodynamic projectile with a polished dark metal shell visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pod launch skyward along the tether with a shimmering, erratic energy trail of bright green plasma?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid push-in that causes the pod to rapidly grow in size and reveal intricate details like armor plating and magnetic clamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062087271362543106 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812087297439575 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062087271362543106, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062087271362543106, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1729273945093155, + 0.03655978664755821, + 0.04013080894947052, + 0.09177998453378677, + 0.0177240539342165, + 0.10331955552101135, + 0.2027001976966858, + 0.049388229846954346, + 0.030493060126900673, + 0.25497695803642273 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062087271362543106 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the Matrix style with a distinctive green hue and vertically cascading digital rain of glowing green characters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast space elevator tether visible, stretching from the curve of a planet below to the darkness above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek climber pod shaped like an aerodynamic projectile with a polished dark metal shell visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pod launch skyward along the tether with a shimmering, erratic energy trail of bright green plasma?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid push-in that causes the pod to rapidly grow in size and reveal intricate details like armor plating and magnetic clamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04868168756365776 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486817359924316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04868168756365776, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04868168756365776, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17252510786056519, + 0.0533299520611763, + 0.059995707124471664, + 0.03324545919895172, + 0.01099523063749075, + 0.027079571038484573, + 0.24825115501880646, + 0.07300131022930145, + 0.027989691123366356, + 0.2935868501663208 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04868168756365776 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the Matrix style with a distinctive green hue and vertically cascading digital rain of glowing green characters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast space elevator tether visible, stretching from the curve of a planet below to the darkness above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek climber pod shaped like an aerodynamic projectile with a polished dark metal shell visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pod launch skyward along the tether with a shimmering, erratic energy trail of bright green plasma?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid push-in that causes the pod to rapidly grow in size and reveal intricate details like armor plating and magnetic clamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01419964898377657 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264199733734131 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01419964898377657, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01419964898377657, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16513147950172424, + 0.06260716915130615, + 0.07874337583780289, + 0.031350698322057724, + 0.04532425478100777, + 0.08161268383264542, + 0.08510571718215942, + 0.17140792310237885, + 0.05694800615310669, + 0.22176872193813324 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01419964898377657 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the Matrix style with a distinctive green hue and vertically cascading digital rain of glowing green characters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast space elevator tether visible, stretching from the curve of a planet below to the darkness above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek climber pod shaped like an aerodynamic projectile with a polished dark metal shell visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pod launch skyward along the tether with a shimmering, erratic energy trail of bright green plasma?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid push-in that causes the pod to rapidly grow in size and reveal intricate details like armor plating and magnetic clamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233432054519653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983432054519653 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233432054519653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233432054519653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3009912967681885, + 0.0994754433631897, + 0.09587298333644867, + 0.012378839775919914, + 0.0371452160179615, + 0.08050455152988434, + 0.03824305161833763, + 0.04936811700463295, + 0.07645847648382187, + 0.2095620334148407 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233432054519653 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene begins with a breathtaking wide shot, then immediately begins a rapid push-in, sending the viewer hurtling through space. The entire field of view is rendered in the iconic Matrix style, suffused with a distinctive green hue and filled with vertically cascading digital rain of glowing green characters. At the center of this digital maelstrom, a vast space elevator tether, a vast ribbon of dark, interwoven material, stretches from the faint curve of the planet below to the infinite darkness above. A sleek climber pod, shaped like an aerodynamic projectile and featuring a polished dark metal shell that reflects the falling green code, is launched skyward along this tether at breathtaking speed. Its powerful acceleration is marked by a shimmering, erratic energy trail—a vibrant, pulsating trail of bright green plasma that crackles and spurts, casting a dynamic strobe light across the pod's surface and the adjacent sections of the tether. As the camera zooms forward, the pod rapidly grows in size, its intricate details becoming visible: the seamless connection of its armor plating, the faint glow emanating from the forward-facing viewing area, and the powerful magnetic clamps that slide frictionlessly along the track. Digital rain appears to flow over its hull like water, momentarily revealing and then blurring its form, creating a surreal atmosphere of high-tech, breakneck speed and digital transcendence.", + "seed": 5363, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_9/index_2569_seed_5363_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02042417146731168, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02042417146731168, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02042417146731168, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the Matrix style with a distinctive green hue and vertically cascading digital rain of glowing green characters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast space elevator tether visible, stretching from the curve of a planet below to the darkness above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek climber pod shaped like an aerodynamic projectile with a polished dark metal shell visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pod launch skyward along the tether with a shimmering, erratic energy trail of bright green plasma?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid push-in that causes the pod to rapidly grow in size and reveal intricate details like armor plating and magnetic clamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016461040824651718 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14146089553833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016461040824651718, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016461040824651718, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24885721504688263, + 0.06215246394276619, + 0.11260280758142471, + 0.16041725873947144, + 0.09506160020828247, + 0.1417611837387085, + 0.056045323610305786, + 0.03082379885017872, + 0.060650814324617386, + 0.03162757307291031 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016461040824651718 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the Matrix style with a distinctive green hue and vertically cascading digital rain of glowing green characters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast space elevator tether visible, stretching from the curve of a planet below to the darkness above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek climber pod shaped like an aerodynamic projectile with a polished dark metal shell visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pod launch skyward along the tether with a shimmering, erratic energy trail of bright green plasma?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid push-in that causes the pod to rapidly grow in size and reveal intricate details like armor plating and magnetic clamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018200648948550224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018200874328613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018200648948550224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018200648948550224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07376432418823242, + 0.08646275848150253, + 0.031276583671569824, + 0.46552327275276184, + 0.0742359533905983, + 0.0726718083024025, + 0.09978607296943665, + 0.03564196079969406, + 0.01916186884045601, + 0.04147535189986229 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018200648948550224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the Matrix style with a distinctive green hue and vertically cascading digital rain of glowing green characters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast space elevator tether visible, stretching from the curve of a planet below to the darkness above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek climber pod shaped like an aerodynamic projectile with a polished dark metal shell visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pod launch skyward along the tether with a shimmering, erratic energy trail of bright green plasma?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid push-in that causes the pod to rapidly grow in size and reveal intricate details like armor plating and magnetic clamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013410394312813878 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626340866088867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013410394312813878, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013410394312813878, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03310320898890495, + 0.058073025196790695, + 0.03524293005466461, + 0.2542605698108673, + 0.06725223362445831, + 0.04035139083862305, + 0.25292593240737915, + 0.08122983574867249, + 0.06868292391300201, + 0.10887791216373444 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013410394312813878 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the Matrix style with a distinctive green hue and vertically cascading digital rain of glowing green characters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast space elevator tether visible, stretching from the curve of a planet below to the darkness above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek climber pod shaped like an aerodynamic projectile with a polished dark metal shell visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pod launch skyward along the tether with a shimmering, erratic energy trail of bright green plasma?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid push-in that causes the pod to rapidly grow in size and reveal intricate details like armor plating and magnetic clamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040934826247394085 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504093647003174 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040934826247394085, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040934826247394085, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.047747451812028885, + 0.060442544519901276, + 0.12547144293785095, + 0.37993767857551575, + 0.10885702818632126, + 0.051362764090299606, + 0.0742245465517044, + 0.05369025096297264, + 0.04234941676259041, + 0.05591687187552452 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040934826247394085 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the Matrix style with a distinctive green hue and vertically cascading digital rain of glowing green characters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast space elevator tether visible, stretching from the curve of a planet below to the darkness above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek climber pod shaped like an aerodynamic projectile with a polished dark metal shell visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pod launch skyward along the tether with a shimmering, erratic energy trail of bright green plasma?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid push-in that causes the pod to rapidly grow in size and reveal intricate details like armor plating and magnetic clamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06202464550733566 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120245933532715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06202464550733566, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06202464550733566, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06981822848320007, + 0.05351760610938072, + 0.05425592139363289, + 0.04667428135871887, + 0.1752624809741974, + 0.07759585976600647, + 0.17309033870697021, + 0.14877402782440186, + 0.044719669967889786, + 0.15629154443740845 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06202464550733566 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene begins with a breathtaking wide shot, then immediately begins a rapid push-in, sending the viewer hurtling through space. The entire field of view is rendered in the iconic Matrix style, suffused with a distinctive green hue and filled with vertically cascading digital rain of glowing green characters. At the center of this digital maelstrom, a vast space elevator tether, a vast ribbon of dark, interwoven material, stretches from the faint curve of the planet below to the infinite darkness above. A sleek climber pod, shaped like an aerodynamic projectile and featuring a polished dark metal shell that reflects the falling green code, is launched skyward along this tether at breathtaking speed. Its powerful acceleration is marked by a shimmering, erratic energy trail—a vibrant, pulsating trail of bright green plasma that crackles and spurts, casting a dynamic strobe light across the pod's surface and the adjacent sections of the tether. As the camera zooms forward, the pod rapidly grows in size, its intricate details becoming visible: the seamless connection of its armor plating, the faint glow emanating from the forward-facing viewing area, and the powerful magnetic clamps that slide frictionlessly along the track. Digital rain appears to flow over its hull like water, momentarily revealing and then blurring its form, creating a surreal atmosphere of high-tech, breakneck speed and digital transcendence.", + "seed": 5364, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_9/index_2569_seed_5364_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04010760709643364, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04010760709643364, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04010760709643364, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the Matrix style with a distinctive green hue and vertically cascading digital rain of glowing green characters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast space elevator tether visible, stretching from the curve of a planet below to the darkness above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek climber pod shaped like an aerodynamic projectile with a polished dark metal shell visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pod launch skyward along the tether with a shimmering, erratic energy trail of bright green plasma?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid push-in that causes the pod to rapidly grow in size and reveal intricate details like armor plating and magnetic clamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022832294926047325 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.252283096313477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022832294926047325, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022832294926047325, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22905665636062622, + 0.0749124065041542, + 0.06991147994995117, + 0.05573941394686699, + 0.03073693811893463, + 0.22254888713359833, + 0.054877471178770065, + 0.1326032429933548, + 0.04482238367199898, + 0.0847911387681961 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022832294926047325 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the Matrix style with a distinctive green hue and vertically cascading digital rain of glowing green characters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast space elevator tether visible, stretching from the curve of a planet below to the darkness above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek climber pod shaped like an aerodynamic projectile with a polished dark metal shell visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pod launch skyward along the tether with a shimmering, erratic energy trail of bright green plasma?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid push-in that causes the pod to rapidly grow in size and reveal intricate details like armor plating and magnetic clamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01108629535883665 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511086463928223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01108629535883665, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01108629535883665, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1601613610982895, + 0.13882389664649963, + 0.10241120308637619, + 0.17616505920886993, + 0.05825929343700409, + 0.19582456350326538, + 0.05624763295054436, + 0.029822606593370438, + 0.02229952998459339, + 0.05998494103550911 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01108629535883665 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the Matrix style with a distinctive green hue and vertically cascading digital rain of glowing green characters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast space elevator tether visible, stretching from the curve of a planet below to the darkness above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek climber pod shaped like an aerodynamic projectile with a polished dark metal shell visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pod launch skyward along the tether with a shimmering, erratic energy trail of bright green plasma?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid push-in that causes the pod to rapidly grow in size and reveal intricate details like armor plating and magnetic clamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018193509429693222 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01819372177124 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018193509429693222, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018193509429693222, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1957845240831375, + 0.10726499557495117, + 0.12534968554973602, + 0.08963615447282791, + 0.06574045866727829, + 0.12462157011032104, + 0.08154092729091644, + 0.07600440084934235, + 0.03500713035464287, + 0.09905019402503967 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018193509429693222 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the Matrix style with a distinctive green hue and vertically cascading digital rain of glowing green characters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast space elevator tether visible, stretching from the curve of a planet below to the darkness above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek climber pod shaped like an aerodynamic projectile with a polished dark metal shell visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pod launch skyward along the tether with a shimmering, erratic energy trail of bright green plasma?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid push-in that causes the pod to rapidly grow in size and reveal intricate details like armor plating and magnetic clamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008637567982077599 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758637428283691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008637567982077599, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008637567982077599, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07747602462768555, + 0.07997497171163559, + 0.08210095763206482, + 0.0816064402461052, + 0.187178373336792, + 0.1622234433889389, + 0.05538893863558769, + 0.08467105031013489, + 0.07157249748706818, + 0.11780732870101929 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008637567982077599 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the Matrix style with a distinctive green hue and vertically cascading digital rain of glowing green characters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast space elevator tether visible, stretching from the curve of a planet below to the darkness above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek climber pod shaped like an aerodynamic projectile with a polished dark metal shell visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pod launch skyward along the tether with a shimmering, erratic energy trail of bright green plasma?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid push-in that causes the pod to rapidly grow in size and reveal intricate details like armor plating and magnetic clamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.160337433218956 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103374481201172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.160337433218956, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.160337433218956, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23600046336650848, + 0.11366496235132217, + 0.1729116588830948, + 0.1473805159330368, + 0.0872698649764061, + 0.022756585851311684, + 0.05888338387012482, + 0.054868437349796295, + 0.015321850776672363, + 0.09094225615262985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.160337433218956 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene begins with a breathtaking wide shot, then immediately begins a rapid push-in, sending the viewer hurtling through space. The entire field of view is rendered in the iconic Matrix style, suffused with a distinctive green hue and filled with vertically cascading digital rain of glowing green characters. At the center of this digital maelstrom, a vast space elevator tether, a vast ribbon of dark, interwoven material, stretches from the faint curve of the planet below to the infinite darkness above. A sleek climber pod, shaped like an aerodynamic projectile and featuring a polished dark metal shell that reflects the falling green code, is launched skyward along this tether at breathtaking speed. Its powerful acceleration is marked by a shimmering, erratic energy trail—a vibrant, pulsating trail of bright green plasma that crackles and spurts, casting a dynamic strobe light across the pod's surface and the adjacent sections of the tether. As the camera zooms forward, the pod rapidly grows in size, its intricate details becoming visible: the seamless connection of its armor plating, the faint glow emanating from the forward-facing viewing area, and the powerful magnetic clamps that slide frictionlessly along the track. Digital rain appears to flow over its hull like water, momentarily revealing and then blurring its form, creating a surreal atmosphere of high-tech, breakneck speed and digital transcendence.", + "seed": 5365, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000075/group_9/index_2569_seed_5365_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.023414016561582686, + "vlm_logprob": -0.023414016561582686, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.023414016561582686, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the Matrix style with a distinctive green hue and vertically cascading digital rain of glowing green characters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast space elevator tether visible, stretching from the curve of a planet below to the darkness above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek climber pod shaped like an aerodynamic projectile with a polished dark metal shell visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pod launch skyward along the tether with a shimmering, erratic energy trail of bright green plasma?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid push-in that causes the pod to rapidly grow in size and reveal intricate details like armor plating and magnetic clamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036373662296682596 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753637313842773 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036373662296682596, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036373662296682596, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17798711359500885, + 0.125519260764122, + 0.10577210038900375, + 0.20897455513477325, + 0.09153133630752563, + 0.11549676954746246, + 0.02782953530550003, + 0.03424546495079994, + 0.06451229006052017, + 0.04813156649470329 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036373662296682596 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the Matrix style with a distinctive green hue and vertically cascading digital rain of glowing green characters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast space elevator tether visible, stretching from the curve of a planet below to the darkness above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek climber pod shaped like an aerodynamic projectile with a polished dark metal shell visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pod launch skyward along the tether with a shimmering, erratic energy trail of bright green plasma?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid push-in that causes the pod to rapidly grow in size and reveal intricate details like armor plating and magnetic clamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009797816164791584 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634798049926758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009797816164791584, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009797816164791584, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27950534224510193, + 0.10367096215486526, + 0.33409395813941956, + 0.07582167536020279, + 0.054790932685136795, + 0.054287176579236984, + 0.007810789160430431, + 0.025753498077392578, + 0.02224525436758995, + 0.04202038049697876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009797816164791584 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the Matrix style with a distinctive green hue and vertically cascading digital rain of glowing green characters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast space elevator tether visible, stretching from the curve of a planet below to the darkness above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek climber pod shaped like an aerodynamic projectile with a polished dark metal shell visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pod launch skyward along the tether with a shimmering, erratic energy trail of bright green plasma?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid push-in that causes the pod to rapidly grow in size and reveal intricate details like armor plating and magnetic clamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008649149909615517 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586493492126465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008649149909615517, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008649149909615517, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.042278897017240524, + 0.1240338385105133, + 0.060385026037693024, + 0.09748166054487228, + 0.3680286407470703, + 0.09086751192808151, + 0.0272532869130373, + 0.07176228612661362, + 0.0481577068567276, + 0.06975117325782776 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008649149909615517 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the Matrix style with a distinctive green hue and vertically cascading digital rain of glowing green characters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast space elevator tether visible, stretching from the curve of a planet below to the darkness above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek climber pod shaped like an aerodynamic projectile with a polished dark metal shell visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pod launch skyward along the tether with a shimmering, erratic energy trail of bright green plasma?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid push-in that causes the pod to rapidly grow in size and reveal intricate details like armor plating and magnetic clamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005948578007519245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130948543548584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005948578007519245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005948578007519245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10569433122873306, + 0.2534434199333191, + 0.08704013377428055, + 0.08534955978393555, + 0.10054825991392136, + 0.10595814138650894, + 0.03746946156024933, + 0.039580199867486954, + 0.10864368081092834, + 0.0762728750705719 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005948578007519245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in the Matrix style with a distinctive green hue and vertically cascading digital rain of glowing green characters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast space elevator tether visible, stretching from the curve of a planet below to the darkness above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sleek climber pod shaped like an aerodynamic projectile with a polished dark metal shell visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pod launch skyward along the tether with a shimmering, erratic energy trail of bright green plasma?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid push-in that causes the pod to rapidly grow in size and reveal intricate details like armor plating and magnetic clamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08903717249631882 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640371799468994 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08903717249631882, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08903717249631882, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11840072274208069, + 0.1620001196861267, + 0.055371034890413284, + 0.1199161559343338, + 0.10088605433702469, + 0.22299404442310333, + 0.03044244647026062, + 0.03710348531603813, + 0.03728621080517769, + 0.11559972167015076 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08903717249631882 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_0/index_tensor([2217, 2217])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_0/index_tensor([2217, 2217])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d8e08864a382cfdb692d7d65d924ad8d4b9bccde --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_0/index_tensor([2217, 2217])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot smoothly pans to the right, following a strange procession through a minimalist, cartoon-like world composed of crisp colors and flat blocks of color. The centerpiece of the scene is a large, furry, red, car-shaped pillow, covered in soft, fluffy down, boasting exaggerated round white headlights and a smiling black grille. It sits solemnly on a simple wooden trailer. A group of short, cartoon-like figures in uniform gray overalls carefully escort it. Divided into two groups, some in the front tug at the trailer's ropes, while others push cautiously from behind. Their steps are synchronized and cautious, their faces bearing a serious, focused expression that stands out from the scene. The background is a flat, blocky palette of soft mint green ground and azure sky, dotted in the distance by a few geometric, dark green trees. The entire scene is bathed in bright, even, shadowless light. However, this cartoon purity is broken by a strong cinematic texture: the entire picture is full of obvious film grain, and details are deliberately sharpened, which gives a childlike scene a surreal, documentary-like solemnity and creates a sense of absurd and realistic drama.", + "seed": 24417, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_0/index_2217_seed_24417_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.058267668820917606, + "vlm_logprob": -0.058267668820917606, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.058267668820917606, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle and panning smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a large, red, car-shaped pillow with fluffy down, white headlights, and a smiling black grille?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there cartoon-like figures in gray overalls pulling ropes in front and pushing from behind the trailer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a flat mint green ground, azure sky, and distant dark green geometric trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a strong film grain texture with deliberately sharpened details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08954523503780365 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.589545249938965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08954523503780365, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08954523503780365, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2188766896724701, + 0.06795629858970642, + 0.068366639316082, + 0.0494382381439209, + 0.07779441028833389, + 0.060841839760541916, + 0.13561765849590302, + 0.13917233049869537, + 0.06780828535556793, + 0.11412759125232697 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08954523503780365 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle and panning smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a large, red, car-shaped pillow with fluffy down, white headlights, and a smiling black grille?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there cartoon-like figures in gray overalls pulling ropes in front and pushing from behind the trailer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a flat mint green ground, azure sky, and distant dark green geometric trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a strong film grain texture with deliberately sharpened details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005263993050903082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255263805389404 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005263993050903082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005263993050903082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1596444845199585, + 0.07347694784402847, + 0.058923181146383286, + 0.10819216817617416, + 0.031794726848602295, + 0.07042288035154343, + 0.12210316210985184, + 0.10463938117027283, + 0.06353013962507248, + 0.20727285742759705 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005263993050903082 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle and panning smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a large, red, car-shaped pillow with fluffy down, white headlights, and a smiling black grille?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there cartoon-like figures in gray overalls pulling ropes in front and pushing from behind the trailer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a flat mint green ground, azure sky, and distant dark green geometric trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a strong film grain texture with deliberately sharpened details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898084819316864 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789809226989746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898084819316864, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898084819316864, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09449546039104462, + 0.04358822479844093, + 0.06247442960739136, + 0.042230743914842606, + 0.05161922425031662, + 0.05930010601878166, + 0.24784301221370697, + 0.1054919958114624, + 0.12343960255384445, + 0.16951720416545868 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898084819316864 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle and panning smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a large, red, car-shaped pillow with fluffy down, white headlights, and a smiling black grille?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there cartoon-like figures in gray overalls pulling ropes in front and pushing from behind the trailer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a flat mint green ground, azure sky, and distant dark green geometric trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a strong film grain texture with deliberately sharpened details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004631150048226118 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379631042480469 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004631150048226118, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004631150048226118, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18657882511615753, + 0.09554418921470642, + 0.09574130922555923, + 0.03753980994224548, + 0.04917360469698906, + 0.06398418545722961, + 0.07051605731248856, + 0.1121211051940918, + 0.06255383789539337, + 0.22624707221984863 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004631150048226118 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle and panning smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a large, red, car-shaped pillow with fluffy down, white headlights, and a smiling black grille?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there cartoon-like figures in gray overalls pulling ropes in front and pushing from behind the trailer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a flat mint green ground, azure sky, and distant dark green geometric trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a strong film grain texture with deliberately sharpened details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11291711777448654 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237917184829712 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11291711777448654, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11291711777448654, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19363103806972504, + 0.07198650389909744, + 0.06862075626850128, + 0.05278100073337555, + 0.03881506621837616, + 0.07427913695573807, + 0.13325682282447815, + 0.1556987464427948, + 0.05534522980451584, + 0.15558572113513947 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11291711777448654 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot smoothly pans to the right, following a strange procession through a minimalist, cartoon-like world composed of crisp colors and flat blocks of color. The centerpiece of the scene is a large, furry, red, car-shaped pillow, covered in soft, fluffy down, boasting exaggerated round white headlights and a smiling black grille. It sits solemnly on a simple wooden trailer. A group of short, cartoon-like figures in uniform gray overalls carefully escort it. Divided into two groups, some in the front tug at the trailer's ropes, while others push cautiously from behind. Their steps are synchronized and cautious, their faces bearing a serious, focused expression that stands out from the scene. The background is a flat, blocky palette of soft mint green ground and azure sky, dotted in the distance by a few geometric, dark green trees. The entire scene is bathed in bright, even, shadowless light. However, this cartoon purity is broken by a strong cinematic texture: the entire picture is full of obvious film grain, and details are deliberately sharpened, which gives a childlike scene a surreal, documentary-like solemnity and creates a sense of absurd and realistic drama.", + "seed": 24418, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_0/index_2217_seed_24418_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04039778234437108, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04039778234437108, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04039778234437108, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle and panning smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a large, red, car-shaped pillow with fluffy down, white headlights, and a smiling black grille?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there cartoon-like figures in gray overalls pulling ropes in front and pushing from behind the trailer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a flat mint green ground, azure sky, and distant dark green geometric trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a strong film grain texture with deliberately sharpened details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12202677130699158 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2470266819000244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12202677130699158, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12202677130699158, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10513931512832642, + 0.0358639620244503, + 0.1338968127965927, + 0.050327565521001816, + 0.07290014624595642, + 0.3215034604072571, + 0.2155272364616394, + 0.018355097621679306, + 0.017931565642356873, + 0.028554854914546013 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12202677130699158 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle and panning smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a large, red, car-shaped pillow with fluffy down, white headlights, and a smiling black grille?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there cartoon-like figures in gray overalls pulling ropes in front and pushing from behind the trailer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a flat mint green ground, azure sky, and distant dark green geometric trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a strong film grain texture with deliberately sharpened details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004646338522434235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379646301269531 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004646338522434235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004646338522434235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21730837225914001, + 0.07834433019161224, + 0.14748257398605347, + 0.029868002980947495, + 0.0619046576321125, + 0.18324127793312073, + 0.04627411067485809, + 0.04958828538656235, + 0.04340890422463417, + 0.14257946610450745 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004646338522434235 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle and panning smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a large, red, car-shaped pillow with fluffy down, white headlights, and a smiling black grille?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there cartoon-like figures in gray overalls pulling ropes in front and pushing from behind the trailer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a flat mint green ground, azure sky, and distant dark green geometric trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a strong film grain texture with deliberately sharpened details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05494820326566696 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929948091506958 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05494820326566696, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05494820326566696, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10561738908290863, + 0.034517932683229446, + 0.12186653912067413, + 0.02877861261367798, + 0.024471212178468704, + 0.5591513514518738, + 0.022517196834087372, + 0.016302520409226418, + 0.017281711101531982, + 0.0694955363869667 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05494820326566696 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle and panning smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a large, red, car-shaped pillow with fluffy down, white headlights, and a smiling black grille?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there cartoon-like figures in gray overalls pulling ropes in front and pushing from behind the trailer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a flat mint green ground, azure sky, and distant dark green geometric trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a strong film grain texture with deliberately sharpened details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021920003928244114 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.12719202041626 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021920003928244114, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021920003928244114, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11364974081516266, + 0.035768140107393265, + 0.07125231623649597, + 0.02607935108244419, + 0.09980262070894241, + 0.41437965631484985, + 0.04954521358013153, + 0.04832542687654495, + 0.06637808680534363, + 0.07481945306062698 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021920003928244114 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle and panning smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a large, red, car-shaped pillow with fluffy down, white headlights, and a smiling black grille?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there cartoon-like figures in gray overalls pulling ropes in front and pushing from behind the trailer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a flat mint green ground, azure sky, and distant dark green geometric trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a strong film grain texture with deliberately sharpened details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018175598233938217 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0181756019592285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018175598233938217, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018175598233938217, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20915354788303375, + 0.0330171100795269, + 0.036421362310647964, + 0.022703636437654495, + 0.03172394260764122, + 0.18764686584472656, + 0.06284478306770325, + 0.03052714467048645, + 0.054335419088602066, + 0.33162620663642883 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018175598233938217 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot smoothly pans to the right, following a strange procession through a minimalist, cartoon-like world composed of crisp colors and flat blocks of color. The centerpiece of the scene is a large, furry, red, car-shaped pillow, covered in soft, fluffy down, boasting exaggerated round white headlights and a smiling black grille. It sits solemnly on a simple wooden trailer. A group of short, cartoon-like figures in uniform gray overalls carefully escort it. Divided into two groups, some in the front tug at the trailer's ropes, while others push cautiously from behind. Their steps are synchronized and cautious, their faces bearing a serious, focused expression that stands out from the scene. The background is a flat, blocky palette of soft mint green ground and azure sky, dotted in the distance by a few geometric, dark green trees. The entire scene is bathed in bright, even, shadowless light. However, this cartoon purity is broken by a strong cinematic texture: the entire picture is full of obvious film grain, and details are deliberately sharpened, which gives a childlike scene a surreal, documentary-like solemnity and creates a sense of absurd and realistic drama.", + "seed": 24419, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_0/index_2217_seed_24419_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.18687932323664427, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18687932323664427, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18687932323664427, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle and panning smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a large, red, car-shaped pillow with fluffy down, white headlights, and a smiling black grille?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there cartoon-like figures in gray overalls pulling ropes in front and pushing from behind the trailer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a flat mint green ground, azure sky, and distant dark green geometric trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a strong film grain texture with deliberately sharpened details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6995930075645447 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6995930075645447 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6995930075645447, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6995930075645447, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10526757687330246, + 0.06592638790607452, + 0.09784921258687973, + 0.038976170122623444, + 0.0317835807800293, + 0.3976192772388458, + 0.03531387448310852, + 0.06542235612869263, + 0.12831075489521027, + 0.03353080898523331 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6995930075645447 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle and panning smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a large, red, car-shaped pillow with fluffy down, white headlights, and a smiling black grille?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there cartoon-like figures in gray overalls pulling ropes in front and pushing from behind the trailer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a flat mint green ground, azure sky, and distant dark green geometric trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a strong film grain texture with deliberately sharpened details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028305486775934696 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877830505371094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028305486775934696, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028305486775934696, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05299677327275276, + 0.04021388664841652, + 0.09756211191415787, + 0.07298726588487625, + 0.0133978221565485, + 0.6063410043716431, + 0.03361715376377106, + 0.040524981915950775, + 0.006064045242965221, + 0.03629496693611145 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028305486775934696 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle and panning smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a large, red, car-shaped pillow with fluffy down, white headlights, and a smiling black grille?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there cartoon-like figures in gray overalls pulling ropes in front and pushing from behind the trailer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a flat mint green ground, azure sky, and distant dark green geometric trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a strong film grain texture with deliberately sharpened details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10031194239854813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503119945526123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10031194239854813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10031194239854813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05806799605488777, + 0.029998792335391045, + 0.0343572273850441, + 0.016070084646344185, + 0.01287777442485094, + 0.7594056725502014, + 0.03565657511353493, + 0.03670812025666237, + 0.006681485567241907, + 0.010176233015954494 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10031194239854813 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle and panning smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a large, red, car-shaped pillow with fluffy down, white headlights, and a smiling black grille?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there cartoon-like figures in gray overalls pulling ropes in front and pushing from behind the trailer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a flat mint green ground, azure sky, and distant dark green geometric trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a strong film grain texture with deliberately sharpened details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004631743300706148 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379631519317627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004631743300706148, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004631743300706148, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09513276070356369, + 0.15823741257190704, + 0.17744150757789612, + 0.03529202193021774, + 0.11861088126897812, + 0.2067745178937912, + 0.07648608088493347, + 0.07645531743764877, + 0.024684783071279526, + 0.030884679406881332 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004631743300706148 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle and panning smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a large, red, car-shaped pillow with fluffy down, white headlights, and a smiling black grille?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there cartoon-like figures in gray overalls pulling ropes in front and pushing from behind the trailer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a flat mint green ground, azure sky, and distant dark green geometric trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a strong film grain texture with deliberately sharpened details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12702937424182892 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270294189453125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12702937424182892, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12702937424182892, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.050420913845300674, + 0.058102432638406754, + 0.0652993768453598, + 0.022229060530662537, + 0.017122238874435425, + 0.7032971978187561, + 0.024419840425252914, + 0.03392685204744339, + 0.014944680035114288, + 0.010237401351332664 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12702937424182892 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot smoothly pans to the right, following a strange procession through a minimalist, cartoon-like world composed of crisp colors and flat blocks of color. The centerpiece of the scene is a large, furry, red, car-shaped pillow, covered in soft, fluffy down, boasting exaggerated round white headlights and a smiling black grille. It sits solemnly on a simple wooden trailer. A group of short, cartoon-like figures in uniform gray overalls carefully escort it. Divided into two groups, some in the front tug at the trailer's ropes, while others push cautiously from behind. Their steps are synchronized and cautious, their faces bearing a serious, focused expression that stands out from the scene. The background is a flat, blocky palette of soft mint green ground and azure sky, dotted in the distance by a few geometric, dark green trees. The entire scene is bathed in bright, even, shadowless light. However, this cartoon purity is broken by a strong cinematic texture: the entire picture is full of obvious film grain, and details are deliberately sharpened, which gives a childlike scene a surreal, documentary-like solemnity and creates a sense of absurd and realistic drama.", + "seed": 24420, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_0/index_2217_seed_24420_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10442003612406552, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10442003612406552, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6999999403953554, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10442003612406552, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle and panning smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a large, red, car-shaped pillow with fluffy down, white headlights, and a smiling black grille?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there cartoon-like figures in gray overalls pulling ropes in front and pushing from behind the trailer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a flat mint green ground, azure sky, and distant dark green geometric trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a strong film grain texture with deliberately sharpened details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.40807777643203735 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1580777168273926 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.40807777643203735, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.40807777643203735, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09066704660654068, + 0.0646972581744194, + 0.06012262403964996, + 0.03699867054820061, + 0.6065627336502075, + 0.045341815799474716, + 0.0153633002191782, + 0.03312670812010765, + 0.017113110050559044, + 0.030006809160113335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.40807777643203735 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle and panning smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a large, red, car-shaped pillow with fluffy down, white headlights, and a smiling black grille?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there cartoon-like figures in gray overalls pulling ropes in front and pushing from behind the trailer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a flat mint green ground, azure sky, and distant dark green geometric trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a strong film grain texture with deliberately sharpened details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003210273804143071 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753210067749023 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003210273804143071, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003210273804143071, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08530677109956741, + 0.1797652691602707, + 0.056168533861637115, + 0.02915261685848236, + 0.09240458905696869, + 0.25683385133743286, + 0.08473336696624756, + 0.09649797528982162, + 0.03881990164518356, + 0.0803171917796135 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003210273804143071 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle and panning smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a large, red, car-shaped pillow with fluffy down, white headlights, and a smiling black grille?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there cartoon-like figures in gray overalls pulling ropes in front and pushing from behind the trailer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a flat mint green ground, azure sky, and distant dark green geometric trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a strong film grain texture with deliberately sharpened details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018182972446084023 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018182754516602 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018182972446084023, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018182972446084023, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1625804454088211, + 0.13619861006736755, + 0.17379118502140045, + 0.02603042870759964, + 0.07411455363035202, + 0.08586595952510834, + 0.0887654572725296, + 0.131923109292984, + 0.01678592525422573, + 0.10394428670406342 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018182972446084023 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle and panning smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a large, red, car-shaped pillow with fluffy down, white headlights, and a smiling black grille?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there cartoon-like figures in gray overalls pulling ropes in front and pushing from behind the trailer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a flat mint green ground, azure sky, and distant dark green geometric trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a strong film grain texture with deliberately sharpened details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003610522486269474 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628610610961914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003610522486269474, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003610522486269474, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15874552726745605, + 0.06862054765224457, + 0.06251847743988037, + 0.04294029623270035, + 0.29516664147377014, + 0.0650351345539093, + 0.0946795642375946, + 0.04357634112238884, + 0.0367167592048645, + 0.13200069963932037 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003610522486269474 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle and panning smoothly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a large, red, car-shaped pillow with fluffy down, white headlights, and a smiling black grille?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there cartoon-like figures in gray overalls pulling ropes in front and pushing from behind the trailer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a flat mint green ground, azure sky, and distant dark green geometric trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the image exhibit a strong film grain texture with deliberately sharpened details?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08901863545179367 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640185832977295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08901863545179367, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08901863545179367, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16147613525390625, + 0.08852626383304596, + 0.041726771742105484, + 0.025722458958625793, + 0.20905964076519012, + 0.1495101898908615, + 0.11065803468227386, + 0.1433035433292389, + 0.025635024532675743, + 0.044381946325302124 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08901863545179367 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_10/index_tensor([9373, 9373])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_10/index_tensor([9373, 9373])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..512aa0dd89a849dd3d0e964be6293bc24b4193dc --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_10/index_tensor([9373, 9373])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, tight medium shot depicts the massive trunk of a majestic nanmu tree, its growth captured in a slow, mesmerizing time-lapse. The camera remains perfectly still, allowing the eye to absorb the intricate golden bark—a complex tapestry of deep vertical cracks and a delicate network of fissures, with a subtle, waxy sheen. As time passes, the massive trunk thickens noticeably and almost imperceptibly, its surface expanding and reorganizing in a silent testament to the passing seasons. A vast, soft-edged shadow, cast from the dense canopy above, drifts steadily and deliberately through the woods, its slow flight highlighting and obscuring rich textures in a rhythmic, hypnotic dance. The scene is bathed in the warm, dappled light of the forest, creating a dominant hue of golden yellow and earthy brown, contrasting sharply with the cool, deep tones of the shifting shadows. The overall atmosphere is one of profound calm and contemplation, a contemplative and visually rich study of silent, powerful growth.", + "seed": 7345, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_10/index_9373_seed_7345_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.40575444520218296, + "vlm_logprob": -0.40575444520218296, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.40575444520218296, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive tree trunk with golden bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the tree trunk visibly thicken and expand over time?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large soft-edged shadow drifting steadily across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color palette composed of golden yellow and earthy brown tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain perfectly still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06351937353610992 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8135194778442383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06351937353610992, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06351937353610992, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10334774106740952, + 0.14474335312843323, + 0.022717611864209175, + 0.08158634603023529, + 0.03717920929193497, + 0.039227019995450974, + 0.024415167048573494, + 0.09521680325269699, + 0.04409125819802284, + 0.40747547149658203 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06351937353610992 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive tree trunk with golden bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the tree trunk visibly thicken and expand over time?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large soft-edged shadow drifting steadily across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color palette composed of golden yellow and earthy brown tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain perfectly still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289499521255493 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539499521255493 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4289499521255493, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4289499521255493, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05824284255504608, + 0.09099015593528748, + 0.03405669331550598, + 0.06398160755634308, + 0.038789860904216766, + 0.09030457586050034, + 0.047974321991205215, + 0.052059367299079895, + 0.08326361328363419, + 0.44033700227737427 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4289499521255493 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive tree trunk with golden bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the tree trunk visibly thicken and expand over time?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large soft-edged shadow drifting steadily across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color palette composed of golden yellow and earthy brown tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain perfectly still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371654078364372 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087164402008057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371654078364372, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371654078364372, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08055339008569717, + 0.10475414246320724, + 0.03707922622561455, + 0.3641390800476074, + 0.07116562128067017, + 0.1587134748697281, + 0.06482058018445969, + 0.03477344289422035, + 0.026496369391679764, + 0.057504698634147644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371654078364372 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive tree trunk with golden bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the tree trunk visibly thicken and expand over time?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large soft-edged shadow drifting steadily across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color palette composed of golden yellow and earthy brown tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain perfectly still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0004987664869986475 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.6254987716674805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0004987664869986475, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0004987664869986475, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19319100677967072, + 0.044238075613975525, + 0.049405619502067566, + 0.19623388350009918, + 0.08596204966306686, + 0.0857129767537117, + 0.05838895961642265, + 0.14884504675865173, + 0.04591759294271469, + 0.09210484474897385 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0004987664869986475 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive tree trunk with golden bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the tree trunk visibly thicken and expand over time?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large soft-edged shadow drifting steadily across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color palette composed of golden yellow and earthy brown tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain perfectly still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020875930786133 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520875632762909 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5020875930786133, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5020875930786133, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10392545908689499, + 0.06184650957584381, + 0.04934011027216911, + 0.06836670637130737, + 0.07481677085161209, + 0.14631882309913635, + 0.21632778644561768, + 0.11175982654094696, + 0.08033942431211472, + 0.08695864677429199 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5020875930786133 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, tight medium shot depicts the massive trunk of a majestic nanmu tree, its growth captured in a slow, mesmerizing time-lapse. The camera remains perfectly still, allowing the eye to absorb the intricate golden bark—a complex tapestry of deep vertical cracks and a delicate network of fissures, with a subtle, waxy sheen. As time passes, the massive trunk thickens noticeably and almost imperceptibly, its surface expanding and reorganizing in a silent testament to the passing seasons. A vast, soft-edged shadow, cast from the dense canopy above, drifts steadily and deliberately through the woods, its slow flight highlighting and obscuring rich textures in a rhythmic, hypnotic dance. The scene is bathed in the warm, dappled light of the forest, creating a dominant hue of golden yellow and earthy brown, contrasting sharply with the cool, deep tones of the shifting shadows. The overall atmosphere is one of profound calm and contemplation, a contemplative and visually rich study of silent, powerful growth.", + "seed": 7346, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_10/index_9373_seed_7346_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.33019769306411034, + "vlm_logprob": -0.33019769306411034, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1499999523162843, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.33019769306411034, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive tree trunk with golden bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the tree trunk visibly thicken and expand over time?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large soft-edged shadow drifting steadily across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color palette composed of golden yellow and earthy brown tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain perfectly still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018739912658929825 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018739700317383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018739912658929825, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018739912658929825, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3528643250465393, + 0.0455017164349556, + 0.06715048104524612, + 0.025715988129377365, + 0.01960301212966442, + 0.13768206536769867, + 0.10989995300769806, + 0.07521919906139374, + 0.038586750626564026, + 0.12777648866176605 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018739912658929825 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive tree trunk with golden bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the tree trunk visibly thicken and expand over time?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large soft-edged shadow drifting steadily across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color palette composed of golden yellow and earthy brown tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain perfectly still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47429829835891724 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742982983589172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47429829835891724, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47429829835891724, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16699904203414917, + 0.0742892324924469, + 0.021957863122224808, + 0.0752873495221138, + 0.027090469375252724, + 0.1630333960056305, + 0.14408448338508606, + 0.061617013067007065, + 0.0718223825097084, + 0.19381874799728394 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47429829835891724 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive tree trunk with golden bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the tree trunk visibly thicken and expand over time?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large soft-edged shadow drifting steadily across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color palette composed of golden yellow and earthy brown tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain perfectly still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020598072558641434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955981731414795 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020598072558641434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020598072558641434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22964408993721008, + 0.1196306049823761, + 0.2215871661901474, + 0.1786498874425888, + 0.008113105781376362, + 0.040073711425065994, + 0.11999023705720901, + 0.03739473968744278, + 0.020576316863298416, + 0.024340128526091576 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020598072558641434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive tree trunk with golden bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the tree trunk visibly thicken and expand over time?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large soft-edged shadow drifting steadily across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color palette composed of golden yellow and earthy brown tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain perfectly still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0003046525234822184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -8.125304222106934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0003046525234822184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 8.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0003046525234822184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34605497121810913, + 0.1276904046535492, + 0.12979060411453247, + 0.07010912150144577, + 0.028245672583580017, + 0.12301398068666458, + 0.04965430125594139, + 0.03969971090555191, + 0.04021478444337845, + 0.045526497066020966 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0003046525234822184 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive tree trunk with golden bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the tree trunk visibly thicken and expand over time?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large soft-edged shadow drifting steadily across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color palette composed of golden yellow and earthy brown tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain perfectly still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137047529220581 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38704749941825867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.137047529220581, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.137047529220581, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23476934432983398, + 0.05002511665225029, + 0.04896000772714615, + 0.016359295696020126, + 0.030045999214053154, + 0.09442675858736038, + 0.38381320238113403, + 0.11026593297719955, + 0.00821905117481947, + 0.023115308955311775 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.137047529220581 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, tight medium shot depicts the massive trunk of a majestic nanmu tree, its growth captured in a slow, mesmerizing time-lapse. The camera remains perfectly still, allowing the eye to absorb the intricate golden bark—a complex tapestry of deep vertical cracks and a delicate network of fissures, with a subtle, waxy sheen. As time passes, the massive trunk thickens noticeably and almost imperceptibly, its surface expanding and reorganizing in a silent testament to the passing seasons. A vast, soft-edged shadow, cast from the dense canopy above, drifts steadily and deliberately through the woods, its slow flight highlighting and obscuring rich textures in a rhythmic, hypnotic dance. The scene is bathed in the warm, dappled light of the forest, creating a dominant hue of golden yellow and earthy brown, contrasting sharply with the cool, deep tones of the shifting shadows. The overall atmosphere is one of profound calm and contemplation, a contemplative and visually rich study of silent, powerful growth.", + "seed": 7347, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_10/index_9373_seed_7347_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.310316234594211, + "vlm_logprob": -0.310316234594211, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.310316234594211, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive tree trunk with golden bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the tree trunk visibly thicken and expand over time?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large soft-edged shadow drifting steadily across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color palette composed of golden yellow and earthy brown tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain perfectly still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09111358225345612 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.466113567352295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09111358225345612, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09111358225345612, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09892391413450241, + 0.04398574307560921, + 0.026819175109267235, + 0.015174648724496365, + 0.01901254989206791, + 0.018971405923366547, + 0.04437093064188957, + 0.16078805923461914, + 0.5516862869262695, + 0.020267201587557793 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09111358225345612 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive tree trunk with golden bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the tree trunk visibly thicken and expand over time?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large soft-edged shadow drifting steadily across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color palette composed of golden yellow and earthy brown tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain perfectly still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578011155128479 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328011155128479 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7578011155128479, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7578011155128479, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17500531673431396, + 0.07286922633647919, + 0.02703600749373436, + 0.027799779549241066, + 0.04959029704332352, + 0.07152611762285233, + 0.11334278434515, + 0.0661114826798439, + 0.28815826773643494, + 0.1085607185959816 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7578011155128479 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive tree trunk with golden bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the tree trunk visibly thicken and expand over time?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large soft-edged shadow drifting steadily across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color palette composed of golden yellow and earthy brown tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain perfectly still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008649268187582493 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586493492126465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008649268187582493, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008649268187582493, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09823177009820938, + 0.05892513692378998, + 0.019521797075867653, + 0.05158289894461632, + 0.14975307881832123, + 0.045694928616285324, + 0.10040606558322906, + 0.2888995110988617, + 0.1364150047302246, + 0.05056978389620781 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008649268187582493 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive tree trunk with golden bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the tree trunk visibly thicken and expand over time?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large soft-edged shadow drifting steadily across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color palette composed of golden yellow and earthy brown tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain perfectly still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0006375664379447699 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.375637531280518 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0006375664379447699, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0006375664379447699, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.041490133851766586, + 0.018877804279327393, + 0.022262033075094223, + 0.02922152914106846, + 0.021557550877332687, + 0.04035458713769913, + 0.03655288740992546, + 0.20445485413074493, + 0.5699247717857361, + 0.015303822234272957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0006375664379447699 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive tree trunk with golden bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the tree trunk visibly thicken and expand over time?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large soft-edged shadow drifting steadily across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color palette composed of golden yellow and earthy brown tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain perfectly still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933796405792236 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933796405792236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6933796405792236, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6933796405792236, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04470992088317871, + 0.026874449104070663, + 0.021068206056952477, + 0.03117612563073635, + 0.01972290873527527, + 0.03076242469251156, + 0.052920613437891006, + 0.04491360858082771, + 0.6030400395393372, + 0.12481167167425156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6933796405792236 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, tight medium shot depicts the massive trunk of a majestic nanmu tree, its growth captured in a slow, mesmerizing time-lapse. The camera remains perfectly still, allowing the eye to absorb the intricate golden bark—a complex tapestry of deep vertical cracks and a delicate network of fissures, with a subtle, waxy sheen. As time passes, the massive trunk thickens noticeably and almost imperceptibly, its surface expanding and reorganizing in a silent testament to the passing seasons. A vast, soft-edged shadow, cast from the dense canopy above, drifts steadily and deliberately through the woods, its slow flight highlighting and obscuring rich textures in a rhythmic, hypnotic dance. The scene is bathed in the warm, dappled light of the forest, creating a dominant hue of golden yellow and earthy brown, contrasting sharply with the cool, deep tones of the shifting shadows. The overall atmosphere is one of profound calm and contemplation, a contemplative and visually rich study of silent, powerful growth.", + "seed": 7348, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_10/index_9373_seed_7348_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.34057800341397526, + "vlm_logprob": -0.34057800341397526, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.34057800341397526, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive tree trunk with golden bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the tree trunk visibly thicken and expand over time?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large soft-edged shadow drifting steadily across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color palette composed of golden yellow and earthy brown tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain perfectly still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0048114946112036705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5048112869262695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0048114946112036705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0048114946112036705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18461978435516357, + 0.06300967931747437, + 0.04751366004347801, + 0.031633514910936356, + 0.20652741193771362, + 0.07032578438520432, + 0.03361441567540169, + 0.05825229361653328, + 0.06884023547172546, + 0.23566320538520813 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0048114946112036705 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive tree trunk with golden bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the tree trunk visibly thicken and expand over time?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large soft-edged shadow drifting steadily across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color palette composed of golden yellow and earthy brown tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain perfectly still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.632813572883606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.757813572883606 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.632813572883606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.632813572883606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1135416179895401, + 0.04437967762351036, + 0.05042708292603493, + 0.09473803639411926, + 0.039718206971883774, + 0.1522192806005478, + 0.04783649742603302, + 0.05816487595438957, + 0.06437890231609344, + 0.33459579944610596 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.632813572883606 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive tree trunk with golden bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the tree trunk visibly thicken and expand over time?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large soft-edged shadow drifting steadily across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color palette composed of golden yellow and earthy brown tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain perfectly still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011088416911661625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110883712768555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011088416911661625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011088416911661625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06007809937000275, + 0.04152270033955574, + 0.02301311492919922, + 0.07391003519296646, + 0.14231105148792267, + 0.20908907055854797, + 0.01704784482717514, + 0.10361246764659882, + 0.05546072497963905, + 0.2739548683166504 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011088416911661625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive tree trunk with golden bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the tree trunk visibly thicken and expand over time?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large soft-edged shadow drifting steadily across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color palette composed of golden yellow and earthy brown tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain perfectly still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0002694958820939064 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -8.250269889831543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0002694958820939064, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 8.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0002694958820939064, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2406107485294342, + 0.06279720366001129, + 0.060094863176345825, + 0.04076062887907028, + 0.14814956486225128, + 0.05532033368945122, + 0.06333562731742859, + 0.0719664916396141, + 0.08806223422288895, + 0.16890229284763336 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0002694958820939064 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive tree trunk with golden bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the tree trunk visibly thicken and expand over time?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a large soft-edged shadow drifting steadily across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the dominant color palette composed of golden yellow and earthy brown tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera remain perfectly still throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.053907036781311 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42890700697898865 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.053907036781311, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.053907036781311, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09450269490480423, + 0.04314178600907326, + 0.053937774151563644, + 0.10835865885019302, + 0.23902946710586548, + 0.1111067682504654, + 0.08104747533798218, + 0.07402659952640533, + 0.05836788937449455, + 0.13648098707199097 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.053907036781311 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_11/index_tensor([2781, 2781])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_11/index_tensor([2781, 2781])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..48a469bed5fd24f42b14f3203ab7bb99b04a4a1b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_11/index_tensor([2781, 2781])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The camera sweeps across a vast, futuristic financial city skyline in a smooth, 360-degree panorama, adhering strictly to a high-contrast, monochrome, dark aesthetic. Against a pitch-black, starless backdrop, countless towering skyscrapers pierce the sky with twisted, asymmetrical geometric structures. Their crystalline facades, composed of polished obsidian and cool metal alloys, reflect a sharp, icy light from a single internal light source. Beneath these majestic structures, a symbolic data torrent of countless glowing binary codes and abstract data graphics surges and recedes like a vast digital tide. This dazzling, bright white torrent carves a dynamic path through the profound darkness, its rhythmic ebb casting ever-shifting, elongated shadows across the vast architectural surfaces, as if the lifeblood of the entire city is being slowly drained away. The resulting visual spectacle is cold, solemn, and imbued with an epic quality.", + "seed": 31923, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_11/index_2781_seed_31923_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.3390712022781372, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3390712022781372, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.625000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3390712022781372, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth 360-degree panorama sweeping across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers depicted as towering structures with twisted, asymmetrical geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the visual aesthetic high-contrast, monochrome, and dark with a pitch-black, starless backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a glowing torrent of binary codes and abstract data graphics surging beneath the skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crystalline facades of the buildings reflect a sharp, icy light from a single internal source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2248454093933105 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3498454689979553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2248454093933105, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.8749999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2248454093933105, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07861106097698212, + 0.05529783293604851, + 0.06863939762115479, + 0.07297221571207047, + 0.04467002674937248, + 0.02041657641530037, + 0.04391291365027428, + 0.037840574979782104, + 0.03826455399394035, + 0.5393748879432678 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2248454093933105 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth 360-degree panorama sweeping across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers depicted as towering structures with twisted, asymmetrical geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the visual aesthetic high-contrast, monochrome, and dark with a pitch-black, starless backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a glowing torrent of binary codes and abstract data graphics surging beneath the skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crystalline facades of the buildings reflect a sharp, icy light from a single internal source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17988955974578857 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048895597457886 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17988955974578857, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17988955974578857, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07751860469579697, + 0.08978644013404846, + 0.04211875796318054, + 0.09371822327375412, + 0.10511910915374756, + 0.02691682241857052, + 0.021475575864315033, + 0.026251688599586487, + 0.09275355190038681, + 0.42434120178222656 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17988955974578857 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth 360-degree panorama sweeping across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers depicted as towering structures with twisted, asymmetrical geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the visual aesthetic high-contrast, monochrome, and dark with a pitch-black, starless backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a glowing torrent of binary codes and abstract data graphics surging beneath the skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crystalline facades of the buildings reflect a sharp, icy light from a single internal source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205769628286362 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120577335357666 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205769628286362, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205769628286362, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05462147295475006, + 0.19632579386234283, + 0.02736087702214718, + 0.16949954628944397, + 0.0924108698964119, + 0.032845623791217804, + 0.020254069939255714, + 0.018223443999886513, + 0.037277016788721085, + 0.3511812090873718 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205769628286362 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth 360-degree panorama sweeping across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers depicted as towering structures with twisted, asymmetrical geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the visual aesthetic high-contrast, monochrome, and dark with a pitch-black, starless backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a glowing torrent of binary codes and abstract data graphics surging beneath the skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crystalline facades of the buildings reflect a sharp, icy light from a single internal source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866442829370499 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486643314361572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866442829370499, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866442829370499, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10470931977033615, + 0.19313758611679077, + 0.06465629488229752, + 0.10635222494602203, + 0.04903377592563629, + 0.014377054758369923, + 0.05037868395447731, + 0.029424447566270828, + 0.05751652643084526, + 0.3304140269756317 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866442829370499 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth 360-degree panorama sweeping across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers depicted as towering structures with twisted, asymmetrical geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the visual aesthetic high-contrast, monochrome, and dark with a pitch-black, starless backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a glowing torrent of binary codes and abstract data graphics surging beneath the skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crystalline facades of the buildings reflect a sharp, icy light from a single internal source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1798989176750183 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804898977279663 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1798989176750183, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1798989176750183, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10616350173950195, + 0.12469646334648132, + 0.04426619037985802, + 0.125656858086586, + 0.08616095036268234, + 0.031590983271598816, + 0.04907995089888573, + 0.05128496140241623, + 0.07485121488571167, + 0.3062489330768585 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1798989176750183 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The camera sweeps across a vast, futuristic financial city skyline in a smooth, 360-degree panorama, adhering strictly to a high-contrast, monochrome, dark aesthetic. Against a pitch-black, starless backdrop, countless towering skyscrapers pierce the sky with twisted, asymmetrical geometric structures. Their crystalline facades, composed of polished obsidian and cool metal alloys, reflect a sharp, icy light from a single internal light source. Beneath these majestic structures, a symbolic data torrent of countless glowing binary codes and abstract data graphics surges and recedes like a vast digital tide. This dazzling, bright white torrent carves a dynamic path through the profound darkness, its rhythmic ebb casting ever-shifting, elongated shadows across the vast architectural surfaces, as if the lifeblood of the entire city is being slowly drained away. The resulting visual spectacle is cold, solemn, and imbued with an epic quality.", + "seed": 31924, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_11/index_2781_seed_31924_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.1644423084333539, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1644423084333539, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1644423084333539, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth 360-degree panorama sweeping across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers depicted as towering structures with twisted, asymmetrical geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the visual aesthetic high-contrast, monochrome, and dark with a pitch-black, starless backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a glowing torrent of binary codes and abstract data graphics surging beneath the skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crystalline facades of the buildings reflect a sharp, icy light from a single internal source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47569596767425537 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9756959676742554 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47569596767425537, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47569596767425537, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20583155751228333, + 0.08137226849794388, + 0.06329932063817978, + 0.12272113561630249, + 0.1244119256734848, + 0.0636649951338768, + 0.13923372328281403, + 0.07875055819749832, + 0.04347635433077812, + 0.07723817974328995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47569596767425537 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth 360-degree panorama sweeping across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers depicted as towering structures with twisted, asymmetrical geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the visual aesthetic high-contrast, monochrome, and dark with a pitch-black, starless backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a glowing torrent of binary codes and abstract data graphics surging beneath the skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crystalline facades of the buildings reflect a sharp, icy light from a single internal source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002037018537521 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950204372406006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002037018537521, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002037018537521, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19379644095897675, + 0.07541214674711227, + 0.1192198395729065, + 0.08375296741724014, + 0.11611925810575485, + 0.17954890429973602, + 0.08584298193454742, + 0.025427499786019325, + 0.03832699730992317, + 0.0825529471039772 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002037018537521 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth 360-degree panorama sweeping across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers depicted as towering structures with twisted, asymmetrical geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the visual aesthetic high-contrast, monochrome, and dark with a pitch-black, starless backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a glowing torrent of binary codes and abstract data graphics surging beneath the skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crystalline facades of the buildings reflect a sharp, icy light from a single internal source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11294768005609512 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237947702407837 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11294768005609512, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11294768005609512, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10200793296098709, + 0.11592727154493332, + 0.2044573724269867, + 0.09961621463298798, + 0.05931169167160988, + 0.16037803888320923, + 0.11033257097005844, + 0.038236603140830994, + 0.03379014506936073, + 0.07594217360019684 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11294768005609512 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth 360-degree panorama sweeping across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers depicted as towering structures with twisted, asymmetrical geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the visual aesthetic high-contrast, monochrome, and dark with a pitch-black, starless backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a glowing torrent of binary codes and abstract data graphics surging beneath the skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crystalline facades of the buildings reflect a sharp, icy light from a single internal source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031929248943924904 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753192901611328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031929248943924904, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031929248943924904, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1733621209859848, + 0.09568627178668976, + 0.11474575102329254, + 0.07061215490102768, + 0.043821610510349274, + 0.11012513935565948, + 0.21970230340957642, + 0.035091008991003036, + 0.07581526786088943, + 0.06103844940662384 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031929248943924904 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth 360-degree panorama sweeping across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers depicted as towering structures with twisted, asymmetrical geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the visual aesthetic high-contrast, monochrome, and dark with a pitch-black, starless backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a glowing torrent of binary codes and abstract data graphics surging beneath the skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crystalline facades of the buildings reflect a sharp, icy light from a single internal source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603545993566513 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103546142578125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603545993566513, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603545993566513, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19453828036785126, + 0.05782611668109894, + 0.11104976385831833, + 0.19470354914665222, + 0.03367483615875244, + 0.09487026184797287, + 0.1116088479757309, + 0.07123995572328568, + 0.036543238908052444, + 0.09394516795873642 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603545993566513 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The camera sweeps across a vast, futuristic financial city skyline in a smooth, 360-degree panorama, adhering strictly to a high-contrast, monochrome, dark aesthetic. Against a pitch-black, starless backdrop, countless towering skyscrapers pierce the sky with twisted, asymmetrical geometric structures. Their crystalline facades, composed of polished obsidian and cool metal alloys, reflect a sharp, icy light from a single internal light source. Beneath these majestic structures, a symbolic data torrent of countless glowing binary codes and abstract data graphics surges and recedes like a vast digital tide. This dazzling, bright white torrent carves a dynamic path through the profound darkness, its rhythmic ebb casting ever-shifting, elongated shadows across the vast architectural surfaces, as if the lifeblood of the entire city is being slowly drained away. The resulting visual spectacle is cold, solemn, and imbued with an epic quality.", + "seed": 31925, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_11/index_2781_seed_31925_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1308673769235611, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1308673769235611, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1308673769235611, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth 360-degree panorama sweeping across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers depicted as towering structures with twisted, asymmetrical geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the visual aesthetic high-contrast, monochrome, and dark with a pitch-black, starless backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a glowing torrent of binary codes and abstract data graphics surging beneath the skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crystalline facades of the buildings reflect a sharp, icy light from a single internal source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2837938368320465 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4087938070297241 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2837938368320465, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2837938368320465, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15179455280303955, + 0.05418414622545242, + 0.08291974663734436, + 0.24867843091487885, + 0.15204499661922455, + 0.031325411051511765, + 0.08795309066772461, + 0.04794221371412277, + 0.033875707536935806, + 0.10928172618150711 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2837938368320465 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth 360-degree panorama sweeping across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers depicted as towering structures with twisted, asymmetrical geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the visual aesthetic high-contrast, monochrome, and dark with a pitch-black, starless backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a glowing torrent of binary codes and abstract data graphics surging beneath the skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crystalline facades of the buildings reflect a sharp, icy light from a single internal source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054957568645477295 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929957628250122 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054957568645477295, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054957568645477295, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10931351035833359, + 0.15970951318740845, + 0.08204521983861923, + 0.23628129065036774, + 0.0522964708507061, + 0.08167905360460281, + 0.14069096744060516, + 0.03726009279489517, + 0.051657188683748245, + 0.04906677454710007 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054957568645477295 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth 360-degree panorama sweeping across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers depicted as towering structures with twisted, asymmetrical geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the visual aesthetic high-contrast, monochrome, and dark with a pitch-black, starless backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a glowing torrent of binary codes and abstract data graphics surging beneath the skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crystalline facades of the buildings reflect a sharp, icy light from a single internal source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270628571510315 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270627975463867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270628571510315, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270628571510315, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10877164453268051, + 0.08205951005220413, + 0.04764469340443611, + 0.1891375035047531, + 0.018242737278342247, + 0.06530427932739258, + 0.4103540778160095, + 0.06008409336209297, + 0.007121505681425333, + 0.011280016973614693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270628571510315 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth 360-degree panorama sweeping across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers depicted as towering structures with twisted, asymmetrical geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the visual aesthetic high-contrast, monochrome, and dark with a pitch-black, starless backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a glowing torrent of binary codes and abstract data graphics surging beneath the skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crystalline facades of the buildings reflect a sharp, icy light from a single internal source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008639931678771973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758639812469482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008639931678771973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008639931678771973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06297363340854645, + 0.032214030623435974, + 0.09810364246368408, + 0.14036451280117035, + 0.04611888527870178, + 0.042976345866918564, + 0.4008696675300598, + 0.0234301146119833, + 0.121086485683918, + 0.03186267241835594 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008639931678771973 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth 360-degree panorama sweeping across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers depicted as towering structures with twisted, asymmetrical geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the visual aesthetic high-contrast, monochrome, and dark with a pitch-black, starless backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a glowing torrent of binary codes and abstract data graphics surging beneath the skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crystalline facades of the buildings reflect a sharp, icy light from a single internal source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1798826903104782 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048826456069946 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1798826903104782, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1798826903104782, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10204067826271057, + 0.052175071090459824, + 0.07835522294044495, + 0.2706335186958313, + 0.047911882400512695, + 0.18505555391311646, + 0.172836035490036, + 0.026862680912017822, + 0.025542661547660828, + 0.03858666494488716 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1798826903104782 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The camera sweeps across a vast, futuristic financial city skyline in a smooth, 360-degree panorama, adhering strictly to a high-contrast, monochrome, dark aesthetic. Against a pitch-black, starless backdrop, countless towering skyscrapers pierce the sky with twisted, asymmetrical geometric structures. Their crystalline facades, composed of polished obsidian and cool metal alloys, reflect a sharp, icy light from a single internal light source. Beneath these majestic structures, a symbolic data torrent of countless glowing binary codes and abstract data graphics surges and recedes like a vast digital tide. This dazzling, bright white torrent carves a dynamic path through the profound darkness, its rhythmic ebb casting ever-shifting, elongated shadows across the vast architectural surfaces, as if the lifeblood of the entire city is being slowly drained away. The resulting visual spectacle is cold, solemn, and imbued with an epic quality.", + "seed": 31926, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_11/index_2781_seed_31926_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.28386432901024816, + "vlm_logprob": -0.28386432901024816, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.28386432901024816, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth 360-degree panorama sweeping across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers depicted as towering structures with twisted, asymmetrical geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the visual aesthetic high-contrast, monochrome, and dark with a pitch-black, starless backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a glowing torrent of binary codes and abstract data graphics surging beneath the skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crystalline facades of the buildings reflect a sharp, icy light from a single internal source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4756361246109009 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9756361246109009 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4756361246109009, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4756361246109009, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16295526921749115, + 0.10311324149370193, + 0.09801433980464935, + 0.022087881341576576, + 0.059872835874557495, + 0.056523505598306656, + 0.26823773980140686, + 0.030606834217905998, + 0.18102574348449707, + 0.017562594264745712 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4756361246109009 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth 360-degree panorama sweeping across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers depicted as towering structures with twisted, asymmetrical geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the visual aesthetic high-contrast, monochrome, and dark with a pitch-black, starless backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a glowing torrent of binary codes and abstract data graphics surging beneath the skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crystalline facades of the buildings reflect a sharp, icy light from a single internal source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761536955833435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261536955833435 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761536955833435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761536955833435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10343962162733078, + 0.13379277288913727, + 0.1318558156490326, + 0.02478688769042492, + 0.022995706647634506, + 0.029252393171191216, + 0.0789078027009964, + 0.16313524544239044, + 0.2738696336746216, + 0.037964046001434326 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761536955833435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth 360-degree panorama sweeping across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers depicted as towering structures with twisted, asymmetrical geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the visual aesthetic high-contrast, monochrome, and dark with a pitch-black, starless backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a glowing torrent of binary codes and abstract data graphics surging beneath the skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crystalline facades of the buildings reflect a sharp, icy light from a single internal source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309320077300072 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168093204498291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309320077300072, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309320077300072, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21423208713531494, + 0.04684662073850632, + 0.03747957944869995, + 0.038600027561187744, + 0.05924446880817413, + 0.18104960024356842, + 0.2744452655315399, + 0.018405424430966377, + 0.10839419811964035, + 0.021302731707692146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309320077300072 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth 360-degree panorama sweeping across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers depicted as towering structures with twisted, asymmetrical geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the visual aesthetic high-contrast, monochrome, and dark with a pitch-black, starless backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a glowing torrent of binary codes and abstract data graphics surging beneath the skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crystalline facades of the buildings reflect a sharp, icy light from a single internal source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043081097304821014 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168081045150757 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043081097304821014, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043081097304821014, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09701322764158249, + 0.12570804357528687, + 0.12168648093938828, + 0.04562585800886154, + 0.02818792499601841, + 0.02262495644390583, + 0.13119082152843475, + 0.10837063938379288, + 0.2686462104320526, + 0.05094584822654724 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043081097304821014 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera movement a smooth 360-degree panorama sweeping across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the skyscrapers depicted as towering structures with twisted, asymmetrical geometric shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the visual aesthetic high-contrast, monochrome, and dark with a pitch-black, starless backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a glowing torrent of binary codes and abstract data graphics surging beneath the skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crystalline facades of the buildings reflect a sharp, icy light from a single internal source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813575267791748 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063575267791748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813575267791748, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813575267791748, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08545466512441635, + 0.07321995496749878, + 0.09595581889152527, + 0.09098488837480545, + 0.028394773602485657, + 0.03647588938474655, + 0.03209122270345688, + 0.09280514717102051, + 0.3805101215839386, + 0.08410754799842834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813575267791748 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_12/index_tensor([7386, 7386])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_12/index_tensor([7386, 7386])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b4d1a2c0d3e4cc836d85c04d6fda896d17008288 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_12/index_tensor([7386, 7386])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly overhead angle, the camera slowly pans to the right, following the movement. On the smooth lacquer surface of a dark, finely grained antique wooden table, scattered haphazardly are a string of pearls of varying sizes, the remains of a broken necklace, emitting a warm, milky white sheen. A warm yellow table lamp, shimmering obliquely from the side, casts a bright spot of light on the curved surface of each pearl. A slender, fair female hand, nails painted crimson, enters the frame with a decisive and fluid gesture. Without hesitation, it sweeps all the pearls towards the edge of the table, from left to right. Instantly, the pearls cascade down like a swarm of startled creatures, crashing onto the polished dark hardwood floor below with a crisp, dense sound. They then roll in all directions, eventually disappearing into the shadows of the frame. The entire scene, dimly lit, creates a dramatic atmosphere of elegance, decisiveness, and a touch of destructive beauty.", + "seed": 8836, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_12/index_7386_seed_8836_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.029965559393167494, + "vlm_logprob": -0.029965559393167494, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.029965559393167494, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a smooth, dark, finely grained antique wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are scattered pearls of varying sizes and a broken necklace visible on the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender fair female hand with crimson nail polish enter the frame and sweep the pearls from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the pearls cascade down from the table onto the dark hardwood floor and roll into the shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the movement of the hand and pearls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05319647490978241 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.053196430206299 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05319647490978241, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05319647490978241, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07693028450012207, + 0.05058405175805092, + 0.033176641911268234, + 0.18513233959674835, + 0.3085407614707947, + 0.055647678673267365, + 0.04345056787133217, + 0.04319410026073456, + 0.11108151078224182, + 0.0922621339559555 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05319647490978241 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a smooth, dark, finely grained antique wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are scattered pearls of varying sizes and a broken necklace visible on the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender fair female hand with crimson nail polish enter the frame and sweep the pearls from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the pearls cascade down from the table onto the dark hardwood floor and roll into the shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the movement of the hand and pearls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012560781091451645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387560844421387 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012560781091451645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012560781091451645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12952059507369995, + 0.12172746658325195, + 0.028940575197339058, + 0.3164826035499573, + 0.06112400442361832, + 0.06342561542987823, + 0.08097148686647415, + 0.02908652275800705, + 0.07604695856571198, + 0.0926741510629654 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012560781091451645 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a smooth, dark, finely grained antique wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are scattered pearls of varying sizes and a broken necklace visible on the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender fair female hand with crimson nail polish enter the frame and sweep the pearls from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the pearls cascade down from the table onto the dark hardwood floor and roll into the shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the movement of the hand and pearls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369637206196785 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408696413040161 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369637206196785, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369637206196785, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06255253404378891, + 0.03955461084842682, + 0.0533636137843132, + 0.14876864850521088, + 0.27928033471107483, + 0.1767551302909851, + 0.06240683048963547, + 0.051807619631290436, + 0.05623320862650871, + 0.06927750259637833 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369637206196785 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a smooth, dark, finely grained antique wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are scattered pearls of varying sizes and a broken necklace visible on the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender fair female hand with crimson nail polish enter the frame and sweep the pearls from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the pearls cascade down from the table onto the dark hardwood floor and roll into the shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the movement of the hand and pearls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020584525540471077 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955845832824707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020584525540471077, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020584525540471077, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.028596514835953712, + 0.025181187316775322, + 0.013662558048963547, + 0.05021220073103905, + 0.4997694790363312, + 0.07006385922431946, + 0.045488130301237106, + 0.02863374352455139, + 0.12815332412719727, + 0.11023902148008347 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020584525540471077 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a smooth, dark, finely grained antique wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are scattered pearls of varying sizes and a broken necklace visible on the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender fair female hand with crimson nail polish enter the frame and sweep the pearls from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the pearls cascade down from the table onto the dark hardwood floor and roll into the shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the movement of the hand and pearls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029789643362164497 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529789686203003 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029789643362164497, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029789643362164497, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04745112732052803, + 0.033556804060935974, + 0.03743477910757065, + 0.2752422094345093, + 0.14785043895244598, + 0.15754930675029755, + 0.04849807918071747, + 0.08199963718652725, + 0.11086434870958328, + 0.059553250670433044 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029789643362164497 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly overhead angle, the camera slowly pans to the right, following the movement. On the smooth lacquer surface of a dark, finely grained antique wooden table, scattered haphazardly are a string of pearls of varying sizes, the remains of a broken necklace, emitting a warm, milky white sheen. A warm yellow table lamp, shimmering obliquely from the side, casts a bright spot of light on the curved surface of each pearl. A slender, fair female hand, nails painted crimson, enters the frame with a decisive and fluid gesture. Without hesitation, it sweeps all the pearls towards the edge of the table, from left to right. Instantly, the pearls cascade down like a swarm of startled creatures, crashing onto the polished dark hardwood floor below with a crisp, dense sound. They then roll in all directions, eventually disappearing into the shadows of the frame. The entire scene, dimly lit, creates a dramatic atmosphere of elegance, decisiveness, and a touch of destructive beauty.", + "seed": 8837, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_12/index_7386_seed_8837_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.036538596451282504, + "vlm_logprob": -0.036538596451282504, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.036538596451282504, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a smooth, dark, finely grained antique wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are scattered pearls of varying sizes and a broken necklace visible on the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender fair female hand with crimson nail polish enter the frame and sweep the pearls from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the pearls cascade down from the table onto the dark hardwood floor and roll into the shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the movement of the hand and pearls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0489191971719265 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.298919200897217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0489191971719265, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0489191971719265, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11391695588827133, + 0.02833845652639866, + 0.04408853128552437, + 0.022746296599507332, + 0.028769057244062424, + 0.05338406562805176, + 0.09157399088144302, + 0.07141464203596115, + 0.05591696500778198, + 0.48985105752944946 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0489191971719265 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a smooth, dark, finely grained antique wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are scattered pearls of varying sizes and a broken necklace visible on the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender fair female hand with crimson nail polish enter the frame and sweep the pearls from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the pearls cascade down from the table onto the dark hardwood floor and roll into the shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the movement of the hand and pearls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059699080884456635 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130970001220703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059699080884456635, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059699080884456635, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.053998544812202454, + 0.06434131413698196, + 0.029838165268301964, + 0.02253931574523449, + 0.023842932656407356, + 0.052748799324035645, + 0.06622161716222763, + 0.07706446200609207, + 0.08957741409540176, + 0.5198274850845337 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059699080884456635 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a smooth, dark, finely grained antique wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are scattered pearls of varying sizes and a broken necklace visible on the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender fair female hand with crimson nail polish enter the frame and sweep the pearls from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the pearls cascade down from the table onto the dark hardwood floor and roll into the shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the movement of the hand and pearls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029799941927194595 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297999382019043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029799941927194595, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029799941927194595, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02396705374121666, + 0.03487323224544525, + 0.0164153054356575, + 0.02016785740852356, + 0.028449730947613716, + 0.06397723406553268, + 0.10752958059310913, + 0.0332501158118248, + 0.02592751570045948, + 0.6454423666000366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029799941927194595 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a smooth, dark, finely grained antique wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are scattered pearls of varying sizes and a broken necklace visible on the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender fair female hand with crimson nail polish enter the frame and sweep the pearls from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the pearls cascade down from the table onto the dark hardwood floor and roll into the shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the movement of the hand and pearls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306374117732048 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680636405944824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306374117732048, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306374117732048, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03639331832528114, + 0.052632272243499756, + 0.06251756101846695, + 0.09323937445878983, + 0.04183103144168854, + 0.1678178608417511, + 0.0965498611330986, + 0.0985834151506424, + 0.0445617139339447, + 0.3058736026287079 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306374117732048 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a smooth, dark, finely grained antique wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are scattered pearls of varying sizes and a broken necklace visible on the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender fair female hand with crimson nail polish enter the frame and sweep the pearls from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the pearls cascade down from the table onto the dark hardwood floor and roll into the shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the movement of the hand and pearls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05494019389152527 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299402236938477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05494019389152527, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05494019389152527, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0382637120783329, + 0.08827102184295654, + 0.017064489424228668, + 0.01803523488342762, + 0.023225685581564903, + 0.057005781680345535, + 0.18915627896785736, + 0.09954018890857697, + 0.038304999470710754, + 0.43113258481025696 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05494019389152527 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly overhead angle, the camera slowly pans to the right, following the movement. On the smooth lacquer surface of a dark, finely grained antique wooden table, scattered haphazardly are a string of pearls of varying sizes, the remains of a broken necklace, emitting a warm, milky white sheen. A warm yellow table lamp, shimmering obliquely from the side, casts a bright spot of light on the curved surface of each pearl. A slender, fair female hand, nails painted crimson, enters the frame with a decisive and fluid gesture. Without hesitation, it sweeps all the pearls towards the edge of the table, from left to right. Instantly, the pearls cascade down like a swarm of startled creatures, crashing onto the polished dark hardwood floor below with a crisp, dense sound. They then roll in all directions, eventually disappearing into the shadows of the frame. The entire scene, dimly lit, creates a dramatic atmosphere of elegance, decisiveness, and a touch of destructive beauty.", + "seed": 8838, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_12/index_7386_seed_8838_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04590383786708117, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04590383786708117, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04590383786708117, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a smooth, dark, finely grained antique wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are scattered pearls of varying sizes and a broken necklace visible on the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender fair female hand with crimson nail polish enter the frame and sweep the pearls from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the pearls cascade down from the table onto the dark hardwood floor and roll into the shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the movement of the hand and pearls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11918448656797409 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2441844940185547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11918448656797409, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11918448656797409, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05449299514293671, + 0.026311663910746574, + 0.049906034022569656, + 0.02928975783288479, + 0.04996233806014061, + 0.5725181698799133, + 0.049666449427604675, + 0.08651745319366455, + 0.03769562393426895, + 0.043639443814754486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11918448656797409 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a smooth, dark, finely grained antique wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are scattered pearls of varying sizes and a broken necklace visible on the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender fair female hand with crimson nail polish enter the frame and sweep the pearls from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the pearls cascade down from the table onto the dark hardwood floor and roll into the shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the movement of the hand and pearls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011108341626822948 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5111083984375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011108341626822948, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011108341626822948, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02915284037590027, + 0.015871431678533554, + 0.018036041408777237, + 0.023319896310567856, + 0.025664595887064934, + 0.684626042842865, + 0.06094365194439888, + 0.045510780066251755, + 0.047431085258722305, + 0.04944360628724098 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011108341626822948 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a smooth, dark, finely grained antique wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are scattered pearls of varying sizes and a broken necklace visible on the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender fair female hand with crimson nail polish enter the frame and sweep the pearls from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the pearls cascade down from the table onto the dark hardwood floor and roll into the shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the movement of the hand and pearls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307150840759277 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680715084075928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307150840759277, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307150840759277, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08986517786979675, + 0.040531501173973083, + 0.044577375054359436, + 0.015209118835628033, + 0.034705519676208496, + 0.6124938726425171, + 0.026887794956564903, + 0.04305172339081764, + 0.03226446360349655, + 0.0604134239256382 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307150840759277 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a smooth, dark, finely grained antique wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are scattered pearls of varying sizes and a broken necklace visible on the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender fair female hand with crimson nail polish enter the frame and sweep the pearls from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the pearls cascade down from the table onto the dark hardwood floor and roll into the shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the movement of the hand and pearls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02635699324309826 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513569355010986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02635699324309826, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02635699324309826, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04349932819604874, + 0.018291708081960678, + 0.025122590363025665, + 0.041868746280670166, + 0.02224346250295639, + 0.25722381472587585, + 0.028360025957226753, + 0.06652615964412689, + 0.05589153617620468, + 0.4409726560115814 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02635699324309826 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a smooth, dark, finely grained antique wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are scattered pearls of varying sizes and a broken necklace visible on the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender fair female hand with crimson nail polish enter the frame and sweep the pearls from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the pearls cascade down from the table onto the dark hardwood floor and roll into the shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the movement of the hand and pearls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029797859489917755 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297977924346924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029797859489917755, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029797859489917755, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.007884384132921696, + 0.005887621082365513, + 0.009601627476513386, + 0.006252928636968136, + 0.024470793083310127, + 0.8889544606208801, + 0.013736397959291935, + 0.014118604362010956, + 0.018252508714795113, + 0.010840783827006817 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029797859489917755 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly overhead angle, the camera slowly pans to the right, following the movement. On the smooth lacquer surface of a dark, finely grained antique wooden table, scattered haphazardly are a string of pearls of varying sizes, the remains of a broken necklace, emitting a warm, milky white sheen. A warm yellow table lamp, shimmering obliquely from the side, casts a bright spot of light on the curved surface of each pearl. A slender, fair female hand, nails painted crimson, enters the frame with a decisive and fluid gesture. Without hesitation, it sweeps all the pearls towards the edge of the table, from left to right. Instantly, the pearls cascade down like a swarm of startled creatures, crashing onto the polished dark hardwood floor below with a crisp, dense sound. They then roll in all directions, eventually disappearing into the shadows of the frame. The entire scene, dimly lit, creates a dramatic atmosphere of elegance, decisiveness, and a touch of destructive beauty.", + "seed": 8839, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_12/index_7386_seed_8839_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.023593970574438572, + "vlm_logprob": -0.023593970574438572, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.023593970574438572, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a smooth, dark, finely grained antique wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are scattered pearls of varying sizes and a broken necklace visible on the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender fair female hand with crimson nail polish enter the frame and sweep the pearls from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the pearls cascade down from the table onto the dark hardwood floor and roll into the shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the movement of the hand and pearls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026444070041179657 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7764439582824707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026444070041179657, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026444070041179657, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07808481156826019, + 0.04740525409579277, + 0.10416718572378159, + 0.042553260922431946, + 0.06967215985059738, + 0.2956421375274658, + 0.13096387684345245, + 0.11760224401950836, + 0.07663600891828537, + 0.037273064255714417 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026444070041179657 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a smooth, dark, finely grained antique wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are scattered pearls of varying sizes and a broken necklace visible on the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender fair female hand with crimson nail polish enter the frame and sweep the pearls from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the pearls cascade down from the table onto the dark hardwood floor and roll into the shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the movement of the hand and pearls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00865198578685522 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758652210235596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00865198578685522, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00865198578685522, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1743612438440323, + 0.11412642151117325, + 0.1855781525373459, + 0.06779523193836212, + 0.07955237478017807, + 0.047277264297008514, + 0.1548074185848236, + 0.056535959243774414, + 0.050183556973934174, + 0.06978236138820648 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00865198578685522 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a smooth, dark, finely grained antique wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are scattered pearls of varying sizes and a broken necklace visible on the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender fair female hand with crimson nail polish enter the frame and sweep the pearls from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the pearls cascade down from the table onto the dark hardwood floor and roll into the shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the movement of the hand and pearls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023281319066882133 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732813358306885 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023281319066882133, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023281319066882133, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3245609700679779, + 0.07479605078697205, + 0.09268297255039215, + 0.02888062782585621, + 0.05620119720697403, + 0.07398282736539841, + 0.189003124833107, + 0.05255976319313049, + 0.03582189977169037, + 0.07151056081056595 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023281319066882133 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a smooth, dark, finely grained antique wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are scattered pearls of varying sizes and a broken necklace visible on the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender fair female hand with crimson nail polish enter the frame and sweep the pearls from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the pearls cascade down from the table onto the dark hardwood floor and roll into the shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the movement of the hand and pearls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029801098629832268 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298011302948 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029801098629832268, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029801098629832268, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06282360106706619, + 0.027508297935128212, + 0.04993767663836479, + 0.0476205088198185, + 0.04173501953482628, + 0.12786395847797394, + 0.2927458882331848, + 0.06367619335651398, + 0.0815374031662941, + 0.20455145835876465 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029801098629832268 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a smooth, dark, finely grained antique wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are scattered pearls of varying sizes and a broken necklace visible on the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a slender fair female hand with crimson nail polish enter the frame and sweep the pearls from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the pearls cascade down from the table onto the dark hardwood floor and roll into the shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan to the right following the movement of the hand and pearls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02979137934744358 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297913551330566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02979137934744358, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02979137934744358, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08142607659101486, + 0.04114261269569397, + 0.06655516475439072, + 0.09071257710456848, + 0.1654253751039505, + 0.308616578578949, + 0.0880308672785759, + 0.07651585340499878, + 0.056301750242710114, + 0.025273097679018974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02979137934744358 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_15/index_tensor([4060, 4060])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_15/index_tensor([4060, 4060])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..dcb0f8096da3613f7848608fe29d92f0f2c86f55 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_15/index_tensor([4060, 4060])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focuses squarely on the awed face of a young woman dressed in traditional shrine maiden garb. She stands quietly at the wooden steps of an ancient shrine, her long, flowing, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband, strands brushing against her fair cheeks in the night breeze. The cool moonlight frames her delicate profile. Her head tilted slightly, her lips parted in wonder, her eyes, as clear as deep pools, gaze at the abyss of the night sky. Within these eyes, a magnificent meteor shower is perfectly reflected: countless fleeting, slender, brilliant arcs of silver light streak across her pupils, slightly dilated with concentration, as if the entire galaxy were ablaze in her gaze. Her pristine white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama take on a solemn yet soft quality in the dim light, while the shrine's architectural outlines and hanging stone lanterns behind her are completely blurred, transforming into a dreamy, softly shimmering backdrop composed of warm yellow dots. The entire image, shrouded in profound tranquility, exudes a sacred and ethereal beauty of classical Oriental beauty, capturing a poetic moment of dialogue between humanity and the universe.", + "seed": 5018, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_15/index_4060_seed_5018_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.011069241911172867, + "vlm_logprob": -0.011069241911172867, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.011069241911172867, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focusing on a young woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing traditional shrine maiden garb consisting of a white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have long, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the background elements, including the shrine steps and stone lanterns, completely blurred into a backdrop of warm yellow dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brilliant arcs of silver light reflecting as a meteor shower within the woman's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00419166125357151 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.629191875457764 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00419166125357151, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00419166125357151, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6330298185348511, + 0.07016819715499878, + 0.040092989802360535, + 0.024325761944055557, + 0.02647075243294239, + 0.04834788665175438, + 0.0155071672052145, + 0.023491958156228065, + 0.012974478304386139, + 0.1055910512804985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00419166125357151 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focusing on a young woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing traditional shrine maiden garb consisting of a white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have long, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the background elements, including the shrine steps and stone lanterns, completely blurred into a backdrop of warm yellow dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brilliant arcs of silver light reflecting as a meteor shower within the woman's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0337153896689415 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087154865264893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0337153896689415, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0337153896689415, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30277159810066223, + 0.09354420006275177, + 0.05661575868725777, + 0.09404421597719193, + 0.10822221636772156, + 0.033732715994119644, + 0.048063214868307114, + 0.02966254949569702, + 0.14980769157409668, + 0.08353579789400101 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0337153896689415 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focusing on a young woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing traditional shrine maiden garb consisting of a white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have long, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the background elements, including the shrine steps and stone lanterns, completely blurred into a backdrop of warm yellow dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brilliant arcs of silver light reflecting as a meteor shower within the woman's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004640880040824413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379641056060791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004640880040824413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004640880040824413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3039591610431671, + 0.10571873933076859, + 0.03720540180802345, + 0.051366474479436874, + 0.033671360462903976, + 0.033635400235652924, + 0.0246888417750597, + 0.021654946729540825, + 0.026461796835064888, + 0.3616379201412201 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004640880040824413 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focusing on a young woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing traditional shrine maiden garb consisting of a white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have long, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the background elements, including the shrine steps and stone lanterns, completely blurred into a backdrop of warm yellow dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brilliant arcs of silver light reflecting as a meteor shower within the woman's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017177602276206017 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376717567443848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017177602276206017, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017177602276206017, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35859188437461853, + 0.25694718956947327, + 0.024771062657237053, + 0.038670726120471954, + 0.03644006326794624, + 0.0386027917265892, + 0.02070329524576664, + 0.015296701341867447, + 0.028084931895136833, + 0.18189136683940887 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017177602276206017 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focusing on a young woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing traditional shrine maiden garb consisting of a white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have long, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the background elements, including the shrine steps and stone lanterns, completely blurred into a backdrop of warm yellow dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brilliant arcs of silver light reflecting as a meteor shower within the woman's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011080518364906311 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511080741882324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011080518364906311, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011080518364906311, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.47778311371803284, + 0.21525657176971436, + 0.03205738589167595, + 0.03183969110250473, + 0.0240476094186306, + 0.029672477394342422, + 0.02239391952753067, + 0.023726679384708405, + 0.032230980694293976, + 0.11099159717559814 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011080518364906311 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focuses squarely on the awed face of a young woman dressed in traditional shrine maiden garb. She stands quietly at the wooden steps of an ancient shrine, her long, flowing, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband, strands brushing against her fair cheeks in the night breeze. The cool moonlight frames her delicate profile. Her head tilted slightly, her lips parted in wonder, her eyes, as clear as deep pools, gaze at the abyss of the night sky. Within these eyes, a magnificent meteor shower is perfectly reflected: countless fleeting, slender, brilliant arcs of silver light streak across her pupils, slightly dilated with concentration, as if the entire galaxy were ablaze in her gaze. Her pristine white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama take on a solemn yet soft quality in the dim light, while the shrine's architectural outlines and hanging stone lanterns behind her are completely blurred, transforming into a dreamy, softly shimmering backdrop composed of warm yellow dots. The entire image, shrouded in profound tranquility, exudes a sacred and ethereal beauty of classical Oriental beauty, capturing a poetic moment of dialogue between humanity and the universe.", + "seed": 5019, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_15/index_4060_seed_5019_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.01141111133620143, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01141111133620143, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01141111133620143, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focusing on a young woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing traditional shrine maiden garb consisting of a white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have long, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the background elements, including the shrine steps and stone lanterns, completely blurred into a backdrop of warm yellow dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brilliant arcs of silver light reflecting as a meteor shower within the woman's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004717885982245207 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.754717826843262 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004717885982245207, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004717885982245207, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05842440575361252, + 0.1923496276140213, + 0.021493718028068542, + 0.11712467670440674, + 0.02650582417845726, + 0.03986320272088051, + 0.013105195946991444, + 0.020787935703992844, + 0.47768598794937134, + 0.03265939652919769 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004717885982245207 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focusing on a young woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing traditional shrine maiden garb consisting of a white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have long, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the background elements, including the shrine steps and stone lanterns, completely blurred into a backdrop of warm yellow dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brilliant arcs of silver light reflecting as a meteor shower within the woman's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020597955211997032 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955979347229004 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020597955211997032, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020597955211997032, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1119186133146286, + 0.3013651371002197, + 0.1192527785897255, + 0.04802002012729645, + 0.028682300820946693, + 0.02153775468468666, + 0.062092360109090805, + 0.01836475357413292, + 0.23921597003936768, + 0.049550265073776245 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020597955211997032 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focusing on a young woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing traditional shrine maiden garb consisting of a white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have long, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the background elements, including the shrine steps and stone lanterns, completely blurred into a backdrop of warm yellow dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brilliant arcs of silver light reflecting as a meteor shower within the woman's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00525260902941227 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255252838134766 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00525260902941227, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00525260902941227, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09470099210739136, + 0.4023112952709198, + 0.05552012473344803, + 0.2147981971502304, + 0.0163838192820549, + 0.024650054052472115, + 0.012773871421813965, + 0.02371850237250328, + 0.11831504106521606, + 0.03682812675833702 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00525260902941227 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focusing on a young woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing traditional shrine maiden garb consisting of a white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have long, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the background elements, including the shrine steps and stone lanterns, completely blurred into a backdrop of warm yellow dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brilliant arcs of silver light reflecting as a meteor shower within the woman's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003195539116859436 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753195762634277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003195539116859436, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003195539116859436, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11537230759859085, + 0.4406328499317169, + 0.027778005227446556, + 0.17934994399547577, + 0.024852143600583076, + 0.031981341540813446, + 0.014059234410524368, + 0.027131207287311554, + 0.055816397070884705, + 0.08302654325962067 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003195539116859436 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focusing on a young woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing traditional shrine maiden garb consisting of a white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have long, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the background elements, including the shrine steps and stone lanterns, completely blurred into a backdrop of warm yellow dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brilliant arcs of silver light reflecting as a meteor shower within the woman's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023291567340493202 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.77329158782959 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023291567340493202, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023291567340493202, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09242647886276245, + 0.17260335385799408, + 0.030723808333277702, + 0.28399187326431274, + 0.017325174063444138, + 0.021102601662278175, + 0.029536820948123932, + 0.04143683984875679, + 0.27051040530204773, + 0.040342606604099274 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023291567340493202 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focuses squarely on the awed face of a young woman dressed in traditional shrine maiden garb. She stands quietly at the wooden steps of an ancient shrine, her long, flowing, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband, strands brushing against her fair cheeks in the night breeze. The cool moonlight frames her delicate profile. Her head tilted slightly, her lips parted in wonder, her eyes, as clear as deep pools, gaze at the abyss of the night sky. Within these eyes, a magnificent meteor shower is perfectly reflected: countless fleeting, slender, brilliant arcs of silver light streak across her pupils, slightly dilated with concentration, as if the entire galaxy were ablaze in her gaze. Her pristine white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama take on a solemn yet soft quality in the dim light, while the shrine's architectural outlines and hanging stone lanterns behind her are completely blurred, transforming into a dreamy, softly shimmering backdrop composed of warm yellow dots. The entire image, shrouded in profound tranquility, exudes a sacred and ethereal beauty of classical Oriental beauty, capturing a poetic moment of dialogue between humanity and the universe.", + "seed": 5020, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_15/index_4060_seed_5020_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.02623121878132224, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02623121878132224, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02623121878132224, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focusing on a young woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing traditional shrine maiden garb consisting of a white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have long, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the background elements, including the shrine steps and stone lanterns, completely blurred into a backdrop of warm yellow dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brilliant arcs of silver light reflecting as a meteor shower within the woman's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0033844592981040478 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.128384590148926 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0033844592981040478, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0033844592981040478, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2512337565422058, + 0.12219937145709991, + 0.057680487632751465, + 0.06532419472932816, + 0.04228251427412033, + 0.1006111204624176, + 0.1933215707540512, + 0.06672268360853195, + 0.04379504919052124, + 0.05682923272252083 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0033844592981040478 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focusing on a young woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing traditional shrine maiden garb consisting of a white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have long, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the background elements, including the shrine steps and stone lanterns, completely blurred into a backdrop of warm yellow dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brilliant arcs of silver light reflecting as a meteor shower within the woman's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054972462356090546 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299724102020264 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054972462356090546, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054972462356090546, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28341153264045715, + 0.10157285630702972, + 0.03139099106192589, + 0.035815753042697906, + 0.04428833723068237, + 0.1368338018655777, + 0.1301075518131256, + 0.042779162526130676, + 0.05866307020187378, + 0.13513697683811188 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054972462356090546 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focusing on a young woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing traditional shrine maiden garb consisting of a white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have long, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the background elements, including the shrine steps and stone lanterns, completely blurred into a backdrop of warm yellow dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brilliant arcs of silver light reflecting as a meteor shower within the woman's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018185900524258614 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018186092376709 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018185900524258614, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018185900524258614, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3590390980243683, + 0.10269107669591904, + 0.0655173808336258, + 0.0502137765288353, + 0.05640504136681557, + 0.07502016425132751, + 0.09870851039886475, + 0.09593098610639572, + 0.0547894686460495, + 0.04168447479605675 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018185900524258614 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focusing on a young woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing traditional shrine maiden garb consisting of a white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have long, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the background elements, including the shrine steps and stone lanterns, completely blurred into a backdrop of warm yellow dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brilliant arcs of silver light reflecting as a meteor shower within the woman's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005952132865786552 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.13095235824585 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005952132865786552, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005952132865786552, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15124523639678955, + 0.0990954264998436, + 0.0718761757016182, + 0.09290248155593872, + 0.09050875157117844, + 0.1431952565908432, + 0.21201777458190918, + 0.06097361817955971, + 0.0337400883436203, + 0.04444519430398941 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005952132865786552 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focusing on a young woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing traditional shrine maiden garb consisting of a white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have long, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the background elements, including the shrine steps and stone lanterns, completely blurred into a backdrop of warm yellow dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brilliant arcs of silver light reflecting as a meteor shower within the woman's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048661138862371445 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048661231994629 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048661138862371445, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048661138862371445, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20856177806854248, + 0.11315948516130447, + 0.080695241689682, + 0.07352792471647263, + 0.05793860927224159, + 0.1388145536184311, + 0.15049104392528534, + 0.08191822469234467, + 0.0497577078640461, + 0.04513540118932724 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048661138862371445 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focuses squarely on the awed face of a young woman dressed in traditional shrine maiden garb. She stands quietly at the wooden steps of an ancient shrine, her long, flowing, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband, strands brushing against her fair cheeks in the night breeze. The cool moonlight frames her delicate profile. Her head tilted slightly, her lips parted in wonder, her eyes, as clear as deep pools, gaze at the abyss of the night sky. Within these eyes, a magnificent meteor shower is perfectly reflected: countless fleeting, slender, brilliant arcs of silver light streak across her pupils, slightly dilated with concentration, as if the entire galaxy were ablaze in her gaze. Her pristine white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama take on a solemn yet soft quality in the dim light, while the shrine's architectural outlines and hanging stone lanterns behind her are completely blurred, transforming into a dreamy, softly shimmering backdrop composed of warm yellow dots. The entire image, shrouded in profound tranquility, exudes a sacred and ethereal beauty of classical Oriental beauty, capturing a poetic moment of dialogue between humanity and the universe.", + "seed": 5021, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_15/index_4060_seed_5021_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.024759681057184936, + "vlm_logprob": -0.024759681057184936, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.024759681057184936, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focusing on a young woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing traditional shrine maiden garb consisting of a white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have long, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the background elements, including the shrine steps and stone lanterns, completely blurred into a backdrop of warm yellow dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brilliant arcs of silver light reflecting as a meteor shower within the woman's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005697202868759632 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.755697250366211 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005697202868759632, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005697202868759632, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15493479371070862, + 0.19589942693710327, + 0.2473352700471878, + 0.04682155326008797, + 0.05358083173632622, + 0.08606424182653427, + 0.06068696081638336, + 0.057366710156202316, + 0.030274726450443268, + 0.0670354887843132 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005697202868759632 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focusing on a young woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing traditional shrine maiden garb consisting of a white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have long, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the background elements, including the shrine steps and stone lanterns, completely blurred into a backdrop of warm yellow dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brilliant arcs of silver light reflecting as a meteor shower within the woman's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900883257389069 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790088176727295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900883257389069, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900883257389069, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0900498703122139, + 0.11314772069454193, + 0.20430640876293182, + 0.05019429326057434, + 0.05641651526093483, + 0.03718981519341469, + 0.12372901290655136, + 0.17282897233963013, + 0.040951892733573914, + 0.11118551343679428 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900883257389069 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focusing on a young woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing traditional shrine maiden garb consisting of a white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have long, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the background elements, including the shrine steps and stone lanterns, completely blurred into a backdrop of warm yellow dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brilliant arcs of silver light reflecting as a meteor shower within the woman's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008640640415251255 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758640766143799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008640640415251255, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008640640415251255, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0961870551109314, + 0.0780223160982132, + 0.12185601145029068, + 0.0671377182006836, + 0.09084540605545044, + 0.04894404485821724, + 0.08553474396467209, + 0.17272473871707916, + 0.10505660623311996, + 0.13369134068489075 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008640640415251255 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focusing on a young woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing traditional shrine maiden garb consisting of a white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have long, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the background elements, including the shrine steps and stone lanterns, completely blurred into a backdrop of warm yellow dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brilliant arcs of silver light reflecting as a meteor shower within the woman's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004097638186067343 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5040974617004395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004097638186067343, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004097638186067343, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14879633486270905, + 0.07448358833789825, + 0.08706335723400116, + 0.07526907324790955, + 0.10162289440631866, + 0.1562783122062683, + 0.10127522051334381, + 0.04839974641799927, + 0.08317763358354568, + 0.12363387644290924 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004097638186067343 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a sharp, shallow depth-of-field close-up focusing on a young woman's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing traditional shrine maiden garb consisting of a white Chihaya coat and crimson hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have long, raven-black hair held back by a simple white washi headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the background elements, including the shrine steps and stone lanterns, completely blurred into a backdrop of warm yellow dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brilliant arcs of silver light reflecting as a meteor shower within the woman's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026354091241955757 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513540744781494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026354091241955757, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026354091241955757, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13707199692726135, + 0.09198646992444992, + 0.10853221267461777, + 0.07180597633123398, + 0.0725981816649437, + 0.15103669464588165, + 0.06104526296257973, + 0.0691581442952156, + 0.07862479984760284, + 0.1581401526927948 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026354091241955757 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_2/index_tensor([5772, 5772])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_2/index_tensor([5772, 5772])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..919372194beafea4d0f8f93bc3b4ae5a26b68830 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_2/index_tensor([5772, 5772])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The scene unfolds in a medium close-up, with the camera beginning with a slow, deliberate push-in on a lone white candle, its candle showing delicate drips of cooling wax as it serves as the sole source of illumination in the pitch-black room. Its single flame trembles erratically, a teardrop of vibrant orange and yellow flame, its core a core of intense, incandescent light. This wild, unpredictable flickering casts vast, dancing shadows that wriggle and twist across the richly textured dark surfaces of the wooden table and the near background. As the camera inexorably approaches, focus settles on the flame itself, its ethereal, smoky tip licking at the oppressive darkness. The push-in continues, moving through the body of the flame, dissolving into an extreme close-up of the blackened fiber wick, its tip emitting a bright, incandescent red-orange flash that gently pulsates with heat, creating an atmosphere of profound solitude and concentration, where warm, dynamic light engages in a silent, brutal battle against a deep, enveloping darkness.", + "seed": 9759, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_2/index_5772_seed_9759_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07335866075009108, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07335866075009108, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07335866075009108, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up of a lone white candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, deliberate push-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the candle the sole source of illumination in a pitch-black room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame exhibit a vibrant orange and yellow color with a core of intense incandescent light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move through the flame to end in an extreme close-up of the blackened wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14373354613780975 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.018733501434326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14373354613780975, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14373354613780975, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06472047418355942, + 0.028784435242414474, + 0.043894391506910324, + 0.6047600507736206, + 0.06407070904970169, + 0.10937902331352234, + 0.02543536201119423, + 0.017168859019875526, + 0.02728118933737278, + 0.014505524188280106 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14373354613780975 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up of a lone white candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, deliberate push-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the candle the sole source of illumination in a pitch-black room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame exhibit a vibrant orange and yellow color with a core of intense incandescent light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move through the flame to end in an extreme close-up of the blackened wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371896222233772 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408719062805176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371896222233772, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371896222233772, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12825584411621094, + 0.07146137952804565, + 0.05478119105100632, + 0.18169426918029785, + 0.08132042735815048, + 0.12234365940093994, + 0.2666371464729309, + 0.04562157019972801, + 0.029416264966130257, + 0.018468303605914116 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371896222233772 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up of a lone white candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, deliberate push-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the candle the sole source of illumination in a pitch-black room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame exhibit a vibrant orange and yellow color with a core of intense incandescent light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move through the flame to end in an extreme close-up of the blackened wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16050010919570923 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9105000495910645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16050010919570923, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16050010919570923, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.038193609565496445, + 0.04101380333304405, + 0.044056236743927, + 0.03812868520617485, + 0.07425853610038757, + 0.7008057832717896, + 0.02026447467505932, + 0.015479872934520245, + 0.020763229578733444, + 0.007035721559077501 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16050010919570923 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up of a lone white candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, deliberate push-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the candle the sole source of illumination in a pitch-black room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame exhibit a vibrant orange and yellow color with a core of intense incandescent light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move through the flame to end in an extreme close-up of the blackened wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002496580593287945 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002496719360352 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002496580593287945, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002496580593287945, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07011618465185165, + 0.03049551323056221, + 0.037861548364162445, + 0.204420804977417, + 0.04972675070166588, + 0.5018861889839172, + 0.029069451615214348, + 0.027488434687256813, + 0.023535815998911858, + 0.025399252772331238 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002496580593287945 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up of a lone white candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, deliberate push-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the candle the sole source of illumination in a pitch-black room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame exhibit a vibrant orange and yellow color with a core of intense incandescent light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move through the flame to end in an extreme close-up of the blackened wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634410560131073 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651344060897827 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634410560131073, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634410560131073, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06859996914863586, + 0.06763210147619247, + 0.08376871794462204, + 0.25091591477394104, + 0.08854887634515762, + 0.08129981905221939, + 0.06745263189077377, + 0.20157717168331146, + 0.03726654127240181, + 0.05293826758861542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634410560131073 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene unfolds in a medium close-up, with the camera beginning with a slow, deliberate push-in on a lone white candle, its candle showing delicate drips of cooling wax as it serves as the sole source of illumination in the pitch-black room. Its single flame trembles erratically, a teardrop of vibrant orange and yellow flame, its core a core of intense, incandescent light. This wild, unpredictable flickering casts vast, dancing shadows that wriggle and twist across the richly textured dark surfaces of the wooden table and the near background. As the camera inexorably approaches, focus settles on the flame itself, its ethereal, smoky tip licking at the oppressive darkness. The push-in continues, moving through the body of the flame, dissolving into an extreme close-up of the blackened fiber wick, its tip emitting a bright, incandescent red-orange flash that gently pulsates with heat, creating an atmosphere of profound solitude and concentration, where warm, dynamic light engages in a silent, brutal battle against a deep, enveloping darkness.", + "seed": 9760, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_2/index_5772_seed_9760_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.11744533637538553, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11744533637538553, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11744533637538553, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up of a lone white candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, deliberate push-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the candle the sole source of illumination in a pitch-black room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame exhibit a vibrant orange and yellow color with a core of intense incandescent light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move through the flame to end in an extreme close-up of the blackened wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06305510550737381 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8130550384521484 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06305510550737381, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06305510550737381, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13901522755622864, + 0.0238986574113369, + 0.05198601633310318, + 0.06869938969612122, + 0.06729307770729065, + 0.07252904027700424, + 0.09116943180561066, + 0.12183228880167007, + 0.2759913504123688, + 0.08758552372455597 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06305510550737381 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up of a lone white candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, deliberate push-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the candle the sole source of illumination in a pitch-black room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame exhibit a vibrant orange and yellow color with a core of intense incandescent light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move through the flame to end in an extreme close-up of the blackened wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026363378390669823 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513633728027344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026363378390669823, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026363378390669823, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19604919850826263, + 0.04543397203087807, + 0.07714612782001495, + 0.2123117297887802, + 0.06522944569587708, + 0.058056436479091644, + 0.04092338681221008, + 0.09005063027143478, + 0.06710189580917358, + 0.14769712090492249 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026363378390669823 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up of a lone white candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, deliberate push-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the candle the sole source of illumination in a pitch-black room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame exhibit a vibrant orange and yellow color with a core of intense incandescent light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move through the flame to end in an extreme close-up of the blackened wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4744059443473816 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9744059443473816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4744059443473816, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4744059443473816, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1008867397904396, + 0.05960450321435928, + 0.08238188177347183, + 0.25666698813438416, + 0.14982758462429047, + 0.06189872696995735, + 0.035532187670469284, + 0.07046883553266525, + 0.04574732109904289, + 0.13698524236679077 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4744059443473816 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up of a lone white candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, deliberate push-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the candle the sole source of illumination in a pitch-black room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame exhibit a vibrant orange and yellow color with a core of intense incandescent light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move through the flame to end in an extreme close-up of the blackened wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002825318370014429 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778252601623535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002825318370014429, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002825318370014429, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1812915951013565, + 0.03671472892165184, + 0.04520043358206749, + 0.1278820037841797, + 0.04565251246094704, + 0.07586251944303513, + 0.10262452065944672, + 0.08505146205425262, + 0.09316771477460861, + 0.20655252039432526 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002825318370014429 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up of a lone white candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, deliberate push-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the candle the sole source of illumination in a pitch-black room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame exhibit a vibrant orange and yellow color with a core of intense incandescent light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move through the flame to end in an extreme close-up of the blackened wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057693526148796 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955769538879395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057693526148796, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057693526148796, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10081934183835983, + 0.02613876201212406, + 0.0664740800857544, + 0.15518714487552643, + 0.05755308270454407, + 0.04547268524765968, + 0.0773489698767662, + 0.06225375831127167, + 0.11955457925796509, + 0.2891975939273834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057693526148796 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene unfolds in a medium close-up, with the camera beginning with a slow, deliberate push-in on a lone white candle, its candle showing delicate drips of cooling wax as it serves as the sole source of illumination in the pitch-black room. Its single flame trembles erratically, a teardrop of vibrant orange and yellow flame, its core a core of intense, incandescent light. This wild, unpredictable flickering casts vast, dancing shadows that wriggle and twist across the richly textured dark surfaces of the wooden table and the near background. As the camera inexorably approaches, focus settles on the flame itself, its ethereal, smoky tip licking at the oppressive darkness. The push-in continues, moving through the body of the flame, dissolving into an extreme close-up of the blackened fiber wick, its tip emitting a bright, incandescent red-orange flash that gently pulsates with heat, creating an atmosphere of profound solitude and concentration, where warm, dynamic light engages in a silent, brutal battle against a deep, enveloping darkness.", + "seed": 9761, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_2/index_5772_seed_9761_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.058287132903933524, + "vlm_logprob": -0.058287132903933524, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.058287132903933524, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up of a lone white candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, deliberate push-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the candle the sole source of illumination in a pitch-black room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame exhibit a vibrant orange and yellow color with a core of intense incandescent light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move through the flame to end in an extreme close-up of the blackened wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019224626943469048 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.019224643707275 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019224626943469048, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019224626943469048, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09191308915615082, + 0.06080012395977974, + 0.15234951674938202, + 0.07611903548240662, + 0.11349361389875412, + 0.2318650335073471, + 0.12377732247114182, + 0.03581932559609413, + 0.023995038121938705, + 0.08986792713403702 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019224626943469048 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up of a lone white candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, deliberate push-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the candle the sole source of illumination in a pitch-black room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame exhibit a vibrant orange and yellow color with a core of intense incandescent light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move through the flame to end in an extreme close-up of the blackened wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029822619631886482 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529822587966919 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029822619631886482, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029822619631886482, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10444673895835876, + 0.061169255524873734, + 0.08355434238910675, + 0.13303028047084808, + 0.13300107419490814, + 0.1735900491476059, + 0.22507014870643616, + 0.01606249436736107, + 0.01335380133241415, + 0.05672188475728035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029822619631886482 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up of a lone white candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, deliberate push-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the candle the sole source of illumination in a pitch-black room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame exhibit a vibrant orange and yellow color with a core of intense incandescent light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move through the flame to end in an extreme close-up of the blackened wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2257431298494339 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6007431745529175 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2257431298494339, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2257431298494339, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10538530349731445, + 0.06462770700454712, + 0.21067731082439423, + 0.0512847974896431, + 0.02271975390613079, + 0.4312174320220947, + 0.0279606394469738, + 0.01052214577794075, + 0.006965804845094681, + 0.06863913685083389 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2257431298494339 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up of a lone white candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, deliberate push-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the candle the sole source of illumination in a pitch-black room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame exhibit a vibrant orange and yellow color with a core of intense incandescent light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move through the flame to end in an extreme close-up of the blackened wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004104048945009708 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504104137420654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004104048945009708, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004104048945009708, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11717946082353592, + 0.03657108545303345, + 0.17828762531280518, + 0.06738632917404175, + 0.05955769121646881, + 0.07835670560598373, + 0.08302131295204163, + 0.032024867832660675, + 0.03734118491411209, + 0.3102737367153168 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004104048945009708 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up of a lone white candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, deliberate push-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the candle the sole source of illumination in a pitch-black room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame exhibit a vibrant orange and yellow color with a core of intense incandescent light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move through the flame to end in an extreme close-up of the blackened wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012541239149868488 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875412940979 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012541239149868488, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012541239149868488, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06770479679107666, + 0.04961702227592468, + 0.13489378988742828, + 0.0491599477827549, + 0.0884253978729248, + 0.17050403356552124, + 0.10461434721946716, + 0.03406572714447975, + 0.04528101533651352, + 0.2557339072227478 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012541239149868488 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene unfolds in a medium close-up, with the camera beginning with a slow, deliberate push-in on a lone white candle, its candle showing delicate drips of cooling wax as it serves as the sole source of illumination in the pitch-black room. Its single flame trembles erratically, a teardrop of vibrant orange and yellow flame, its core a core of intense, incandescent light. This wild, unpredictable flickering casts vast, dancing shadows that wriggle and twist across the richly textured dark surfaces of the wooden table and the near background. As the camera inexorably approaches, focus settles on the flame itself, its ethereal, smoky tip licking at the oppressive darkness. The push-in continues, moving through the body of the flame, dissolving into an extreme close-up of the blackened fiber wick, its tip emitting a bright, incandescent red-orange flash that gently pulsates with heat, creating an atmosphere of profound solitude and concentration, where warm, dynamic light engages in a silent, brutal battle against a deep, enveloping darkness.", + "seed": 9762, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_2/index_5772_seed_9762_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.12273084330372512, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12273084330372512, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12273084330372512, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up of a lone white candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, deliberate push-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the candle the sole source of illumination in a pitch-black room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame exhibit a vibrant orange and yellow color with a core of intense incandescent light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move through the flame to end in an extreme close-up of the blackened wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.022505471482872963 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.897505521774292 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.022505471482872963, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.022505471482872963, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10013536363840103, + 0.12228073924779892, + 0.2256496399641037, + 0.04831656441092491, + 0.09330970793962479, + 0.16974109411239624, + 0.0635887086391449, + 0.09679461270570755, + 0.04304368421435356, + 0.0371399000287056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.022505471482872963 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up of a lone white candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, deliberate push-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the candle the sole source of illumination in a pitch-black room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame exhibit a vibrant orange and yellow color with a core of intense incandescent light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move through the flame to end in an extreme close-up of the blackened wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003937661647797 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950392723083496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003937661647797, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003937661647797, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.033974919468164444, + 0.05205538868904114, + 0.19417715072631836, + 0.15029902756214142, + 0.0766536220908165, + 0.09339053183794022, + 0.2073378711938858, + 0.11554905027151108, + 0.05442965775728226, + 0.022132737562060356 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003937661647797 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up of a lone white candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, deliberate push-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the candle the sole source of illumination in a pitch-black room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame exhibit a vibrant orange and yellow color with a core of intense incandescent light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move through the flame to end in an extreme close-up of the blackened wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4744259715080261 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9744259715080261 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4744259715080261, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4744259715080261, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08797653019428253, + 0.16849617660045624, + 0.1427149623632431, + 0.14533214271068573, + 0.19252322614192963, + 0.1574210822582245, + 0.028471868485212326, + 0.040618039667606354, + 0.022632500156760216, + 0.013813436962664127 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4744259715080261 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up of a lone white candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, deliberate push-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the candle the sole source of illumination in a pitch-black room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame exhibit a vibrant orange and yellow color with a core of intense incandescent light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move through the flame to end in an extreme close-up of the blackened wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003625251119956374 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628625392913818 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003625251119956374, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003625251119956374, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10496903210878372, + 0.08443871140480042, + 0.17626847326755524, + 0.20540717244148254, + 0.05968114361166954, + 0.09409767389297485, + 0.1871088743209839, + 0.027403244748711586, + 0.020184917375445366, + 0.04044070839881897 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003625251119956374 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium close-up of a lone white candle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, deliberate push-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the candle the sole source of illumination in a pitch-black room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame exhibit a vibrant orange and yellow color with a core of intense incandescent light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move through the flame to end in an extreme close-up of the blackened wick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305814579129219 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168058156967163 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305814579129219, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305814579129219, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.022624436765909195, + 0.10067103058099747, + 0.17778097093105316, + 0.07294891029596329, + 0.12376227974891663, + 0.046100910753011703, + 0.12633422017097473, + 0.10906721651554108, + 0.12032393366098404, + 0.10038601607084274 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305814579129219 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_3/index_tensor([4841, 4841])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_3/index_tensor([4841, 4841])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..312ad7d7302876e61cdbb638485c5a7485486ec3 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_3/index_tensor([4841, 4841])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slowly advancing wide shot, transitioning from a distant shot to a medium-long shot, reveals a magnificent mountaintop shimmering in the morning light. Within the frame, a rolling sea of clouds resembles a boundless white ocean, engulfing the mountainsides, with only a few dark blue peaks emerging like isolated islands. The sky shimmers delicately from deep indigo to pale white, with a warm orange-pink halo already permeating the horizon. On this secluded rocky platform, a Taoist priest, clad in a flowing off-white, wide-sleeved linen robe and a delicate bun held in place by an ancient wooden hairpin, stands with his back to the rising sun. He wields a peachwood sword, its blade a warm reddish-brown, engraved with faint, ancient runes. With his legs slightly bent and his center of gravity lowered, he dances with a steady, deliberate rhythm, the hem of his robe and its wide cuffs flowing gracefully with his movements. His movements were not swift but imbued with a restrained sense of power. Each turn, arm raise, and sword swing was precise and continuous. With a deft twist of his wrist, the tip of the peach wood sword traced clear, brilliant streaks of golden light through the cool air. These streaks seemed composed of countless luminous particles, lingering briefly in the air, forming graceful arcs and symbols before slowly dissipating like stardust. The soft morning light cast a faint golden rim around his silhouette, complementing the radiance of the sword tip. Against a cold background, the entire scene was punctuated by the warm glow of the rising sun and the golden radiance of the sword tip, creating an epic atmosphere of sacredness, tranquility, and the mystical power of the East.", + "seed": 21632, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_3/index_4841_seed_21632_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.029953948175534605, + "vlm_logprob": -0.029953948175534605, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.029953948175534605, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a secluded rocky mountaintop with a sea of clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Taoist priest visible wearing an off-white wide-sleeved linen robe and a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding a peachwood sword with a reddish-brown blade engraved with faint ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the priest perform slow, deliberate dance movements with his back to the rising sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the sword swings create visible streaks of golden light composed of luminous particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026978908106684685 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6519789695739746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026978908106684685, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026978908106684685, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13356347382068634, + 0.07372473925352097, + 0.06990038603544235, + 0.06712335348129272, + 0.08659318834543228, + 0.13535022735595703, + 0.10055854171514511, + 0.056774500757455826, + 0.19620643556118011, + 0.08020514994859695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026978908106684685 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a secluded rocky mountaintop with a sea of clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Taoist priest visible wearing an off-white wide-sleeved linen robe and a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding a peachwood sword with a reddish-brown blade engraved with faint ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the priest perform slow, deliberate dance movements with his back to the rising sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the sword swings create visible streaks of golden light composed of luminous particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014206935651600361 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264206886291504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014206935651600361, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014206935651600361, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10592102259397507, + 0.10635324567556381, + 0.07369858771562576, + 0.09134668111801147, + 0.1595110446214676, + 0.09495916217565536, + 0.07925427705049515, + 0.04961352422833443, + 0.19468218088150024, + 0.044660236686468124 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014206935651600361 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a secluded rocky mountaintop with a sea of clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Taoist priest visible wearing an off-white wide-sleeved linen robe and a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding a peachwood sword with a reddish-brown blade engraved with faint ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the priest perform slow, deliberate dance movements with his back to the rising sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the sword swings create visible streaks of golden light composed of luminous particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07904176414012909 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790417194366455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07904176414012909, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07904176414012909, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15088655054569244, + 0.05683300271630287, + 0.09733327478170395, + 0.05676169693470001, + 0.11890552192926407, + 0.07701987773180008, + 0.07604215294122696, + 0.04853987693786621, + 0.2633882164955139, + 0.054289866238832474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07904176414012909 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a secluded rocky mountaintop with a sea of clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Taoist priest visible wearing an off-white wide-sleeved linen robe and a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding a peachwood sword with a reddish-brown blade engraved with faint ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the priest perform slow, deliberate dance movements with his back to the rising sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the sword swings create visible streaks of golden light composed of luminous particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00319268717430532 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753192901611328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00319268717430532, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00319268717430532, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17673487961292267, + 0.08285557478666306, + 0.0418577715754509, + 0.05962230637669563, + 0.11979974806308746, + 0.09601888060569763, + 0.06393159180879593, + 0.07579910755157471, + 0.2556246817111969, + 0.027755415067076683 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00319268717430532 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a secluded rocky mountaintop with a sea of clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Taoist priest visible wearing an off-white wide-sleeved linen robe and a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding a peachwood sword with a reddish-brown blade engraved with faint ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the priest perform slow, deliberate dance movements with his back to the rising sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the sword swings create visible streaks of golden light composed of luminous particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026349445804953575 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513495445251465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026349445804953575, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026349445804953575, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14641818404197693, + 0.11406562477350235, + 0.07193593680858612, + 0.06085112318396568, + 0.11301937699317932, + 0.062090761959552765, + 0.06211541220545769, + 0.07412080466747284, + 0.22777831554412842, + 0.0676044151186943 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026349445804953575 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly advancing wide shot, transitioning from a distant shot to a medium-long shot, reveals a magnificent mountaintop shimmering in the morning light. Within the frame, a rolling sea of clouds resembles a boundless white ocean, engulfing the mountainsides, with only a few dark blue peaks emerging like isolated islands. The sky shimmers delicately from deep indigo to pale white, with a warm orange-pink halo already permeating the horizon. On this secluded rocky platform, a Taoist priest, clad in a flowing off-white, wide-sleeved linen robe and a delicate bun held in place by an ancient wooden hairpin, stands with his back to the rising sun. He wields a peachwood sword, its blade a warm reddish-brown, engraved with faint, ancient runes. With his legs slightly bent and his center of gravity lowered, he dances with a steady, deliberate rhythm, the hem of his robe and its wide cuffs flowing gracefully with his movements. His movements were not swift but imbued with a restrained sense of power. Each turn, arm raise, and sword swing was precise and continuous. With a deft twist of his wrist, the tip of the peach wood sword traced clear, brilliant streaks of golden light through the cool air. These streaks seemed composed of countless luminous particles, lingering briefly in the air, forming graceful arcs and symbols before slowly dissipating like stardust. The soft morning light cast a faint golden rim around his silhouette, complementing the radiance of the sword tip. Against a cold background, the entire scene was punctuated by the warm glow of the rising sun and the golden radiance of the sword tip, creating an epic atmosphere of sacredness, tranquility, and the mystical power of the East.", + "seed": 21633, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_3/index_4841_seed_21633_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03339523505419493, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03339523505419493, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03339523505419493, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a secluded rocky mountaintop with a sea of clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Taoist priest visible wearing an off-white wide-sleeved linen robe and a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding a peachwood sword with a reddish-brown blade engraved with faint ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the priest perform slow, deliberate dance movements with his back to the rising sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the sword swings create visible streaks of golden light composed of luminous particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06264795362949371 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812648057937622 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06264795362949371, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06264795362949371, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1912417858839035, + 0.06195392459630966, + 0.13365863263607025, + 0.09652843326330185, + 0.024715088307857513, + 0.05628148093819618, + 0.02382780984044075, + 0.22031891345977783, + 0.09640872478485107, + 0.0950651615858078 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06264795362949371 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a secluded rocky mountaintop with a sea of clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Taoist priest visible wearing an off-white wide-sleeved linen robe and a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding a peachwood sword with a reddish-brown blade engraved with faint ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the priest perform slow, deliberate dance movements with his back to the rising sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the sword swings create visible streaks of golden light composed of luminous particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018205096945166588 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018205165863037 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018205096945166588, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018205096945166588, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25338229537010193, + 0.17915505170822144, + 0.06585539132356644, + 0.09497909992933273, + 0.11677311360836029, + 0.11210959404706955, + 0.032676443457603455, + 0.04794923588633537, + 0.0667077973484993, + 0.03041195124387741 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018205096945166588 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a secluded rocky mountaintop with a sea of clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Taoist priest visible wearing an off-white wide-sleeved linen robe and a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding a peachwood sword with a reddish-brown blade engraved with faint ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the priest perform slow, deliberate dance movements with his back to the rising sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the sword swings create visible streaks of golden light composed of luminous particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0486922487616539 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048692226409912 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0486922487616539, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0486922487616539, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22971859574317932, + 0.1886306256055832, + 0.047769851982593536, + 0.060562994331121445, + 0.12052226066589355, + 0.2057235687971115, + 0.030925225466489792, + 0.040365070104599, + 0.04462229833006859, + 0.031159553676843643 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0486922487616539 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a secluded rocky mountaintop with a sea of clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Taoist priest visible wearing an off-white wide-sleeved linen robe and a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding a peachwood sword with a reddish-brown blade engraved with faint ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the priest perform slow, deliberate dance movements with his back to the rising sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the sword swings create visible streaks of golden light composed of luminous particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007629777304828167 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882629871368408 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007629777304828167, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007629777304828167, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0979851633310318, + 0.2325991988182068, + 0.10342356562614441, + 0.05567318946123123, + 0.033440787345170975, + 0.12213034927845001, + 0.03283967077732086, + 0.07121959328651428, + 0.06807857751846313, + 0.1826099455356598 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007629777304828167 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a secluded rocky mountaintop with a sea of clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Taoist priest visible wearing an off-white wide-sleeved linen robe and a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding a peachwood sword with a reddish-brown blade engraved with faint ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the priest perform slow, deliberate dance movements with his back to the rising sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the sword swings create visible streaks of golden light composed of luminous particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029801098629832268 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298011302948 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029801098629832268, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029801098629832268, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2034532129764557, + 0.44688689708709717, + 0.03814537823200226, + 0.04351811856031418, + 0.03058810904622078, + 0.06705071032047272, + 0.02078288234770298, + 0.05224733427166939, + 0.04036605358123779, + 0.05696127563714981 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029801098629832268 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly advancing wide shot, transitioning from a distant shot to a medium-long shot, reveals a magnificent mountaintop shimmering in the morning light. Within the frame, a rolling sea of clouds resembles a boundless white ocean, engulfing the mountainsides, with only a few dark blue peaks emerging like isolated islands. The sky shimmers delicately from deep indigo to pale white, with a warm orange-pink halo already permeating the horizon. On this secluded rocky platform, a Taoist priest, clad in a flowing off-white, wide-sleeved linen robe and a delicate bun held in place by an ancient wooden hairpin, stands with his back to the rising sun. He wields a peachwood sword, its blade a warm reddish-brown, engraved with faint, ancient runes. With his legs slightly bent and his center of gravity lowered, he dances with a steady, deliberate rhythm, the hem of his robe and its wide cuffs flowing gracefully with his movements. His movements were not swift but imbued with a restrained sense of power. Each turn, arm raise, and sword swing was precise and continuous. With a deft twist of his wrist, the tip of the peach wood sword traced clear, brilliant streaks of golden light through the cool air. These streaks seemed composed of countless luminous particles, lingering briefly in the air, forming graceful arcs and symbols before slowly dissipating like stardust. The soft morning light cast a faint golden rim around his silhouette, complementing the radiance of the sword tip. Against a cold background, the entire scene was punctuated by the warm glow of the rising sun and the golden radiance of the sword tip, creating an epic atmosphere of sacredness, tranquility, and the mystical power of the East.", + "seed": 21634, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_3/index_4841_seed_21634_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.01119531486183405, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01119531486183405, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01119531486183405, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a secluded rocky mountaintop with a sea of clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Taoist priest visible wearing an off-white wide-sleeved linen robe and a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding a peachwood sword with a reddish-brown blade engraved with faint ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the priest perform slow, deliberate dance movements with his back to the rising sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the sword swings create visible streaks of golden light composed of luminous particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010085809975862503 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.635085582733154 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010085809975862503, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010085809975862503, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23806606233119965, + 0.12025032937526703, + 0.09760824590921402, + 0.04701190069317818, + 0.07773534953594208, + 0.07281702756881714, + 0.11013337969779968, + 0.12880775332450867, + 0.041267938911914825, + 0.06630197912454605 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010085809975862503 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a secluded rocky mountaintop with a sea of clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Taoist priest visible wearing an off-white wide-sleeved linen robe and a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding a peachwood sword with a reddish-brown blade engraved with faint ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the priest perform slow, deliberate dance movements with his back to the rising sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the sword swings create visible streaks of golden light composed of luminous particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005955095402896404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130955219268799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005955095402896404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005955095402896404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22820334136486053, + 0.1059952974319458, + 0.05815631151199341, + 0.1360115259885788, + 0.09628108143806458, + 0.10690570622682571, + 0.06172546371817589, + 0.08499694615602493, + 0.038466088473796844, + 0.0832582488656044 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005955095402896404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a secluded rocky mountaintop with a sea of clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Taoist priest visible wearing an off-white wide-sleeved linen robe and a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding a peachwood sword with a reddish-brown blade engraved with faint ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the priest perform slow, deliberate dance movements with his back to the rising sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the sword swings create visible streaks of golden light composed of luminous particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023306243121623993 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773306131362915 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023306243121623993, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023306243121623993, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16591478884220123, + 0.07922769337892532, + 0.13256672024726868, + 0.10504864156246185, + 0.1542116105556488, + 0.1321447789669037, + 0.0705561414361, + 0.07943902164697647, + 0.030756302177906036, + 0.050134364515542984 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023306243121623993 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a secluded rocky mountaintop with a sea of clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Taoist priest visible wearing an off-white wide-sleeved linen robe and a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding a peachwood sword with a reddish-brown blade engraved with faint ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the priest perform slow, deliberate dance movements with his back to the rising sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the sword swings create visible streaks of golden light composed of luminous particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004093601368367672 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504093647003174 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004093601368367672, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004093601368367672, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11226224154233932, + 0.04864032194018364, + 0.059457384049892426, + 0.15244759619235992, + 0.2101384401321411, + 0.062349896878004074, + 0.09742604941129684, + 0.20409198105335236, + 0.022972531616687775, + 0.030213575810194016 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004093601368367672 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a secluded rocky mountaintop with a sea of clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Taoist priest visible wearing an off-white wide-sleeved linen robe and a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding a peachwood sword with a reddish-brown blade engraved with faint ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the priest perform slow, deliberate dance movements with his back to the rising sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the sword swings create visible streaks of golden light composed of luminous particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012535824440419674 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38753604888916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012535824440419674, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012535824440419674, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1369795799255371, + 0.07266471534967422, + 0.0314083993434906, + 0.052075471729040146, + 0.09086089581251144, + 0.10226933658123016, + 0.10476446896791458, + 0.32560980319976807, + 0.02557055652141571, + 0.05779673159122467 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012535824440419674 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly advancing wide shot, transitioning from a distant shot to a medium-long shot, reveals a magnificent mountaintop shimmering in the morning light. Within the frame, a rolling sea of clouds resembles a boundless white ocean, engulfing the mountainsides, with only a few dark blue peaks emerging like isolated islands. The sky shimmers delicately from deep indigo to pale white, with a warm orange-pink halo already permeating the horizon. On this secluded rocky platform, a Taoist priest, clad in a flowing off-white, wide-sleeved linen robe and a delicate bun held in place by an ancient wooden hairpin, stands with his back to the rising sun. He wields a peachwood sword, its blade a warm reddish-brown, engraved with faint, ancient runes. With his legs slightly bent and his center of gravity lowered, he dances with a steady, deliberate rhythm, the hem of his robe and its wide cuffs flowing gracefully with his movements. His movements were not swift but imbued with a restrained sense of power. Each turn, arm raise, and sword swing was precise and continuous. With a deft twist of his wrist, the tip of the peach wood sword traced clear, brilliant streaks of golden light through the cool air. These streaks seemed composed of countless luminous particles, lingering briefly in the air, forming graceful arcs and symbols before slowly dissipating like stardust. The soft morning light cast a faint golden rim around his silhouette, complementing the radiance of the sword tip. Against a cold background, the entire scene was punctuated by the warm glow of the rising sun and the golden radiance of the sword tip, creating an epic atmosphere of sacredness, tranquility, and the mystical power of the East.", + "seed": 21635, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_3/index_4841_seed_21635_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.018240096420049666, + "vlm_logprob": -0.018240096420049666, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.018240096420049666, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a secluded rocky mountaintop with a sea of clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Taoist priest visible wearing an off-white wide-sleeved linen robe and a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding a peachwood sword with a reddish-brown blade engraved with faint ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the priest perform slow, deliberate dance movements with his back to the rising sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the sword swings create visible streaks of golden light composed of luminous particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0186205692589283 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018620491027832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0186205692589283, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0186205692589283, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17414450645446777, + 0.053554560989141464, + 0.06062101945281029, + 0.1194474846124649, + 0.12253217399120331, + 0.0641988068819046, + 0.12328935414552689, + 0.11002267152070999, + 0.10430051386356354, + 0.06788893789052963 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0186205692589283 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a secluded rocky mountaintop with a sea of clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Taoist priest visible wearing an off-white wide-sleeved linen robe and a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding a peachwood sword with a reddish-brown blade engraved with faint ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the priest perform slow, deliberate dance movements with his back to the rising sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the sword swings create visible streaks of golden light composed of luminous particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014202586375176907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26420259475708 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014202586375176907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014202586375176907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08629052340984344, + 0.19258999824523926, + 0.13927549123764038, + 0.0844494178891182, + 0.06925339996814728, + 0.055393338203430176, + 0.07443179935216904, + 0.11346177011728287, + 0.05586748197674751, + 0.12898674607276917 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014202586375176907 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a secluded rocky mountaintop with a sea of clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Taoist priest visible wearing an off-white wide-sleeved linen robe and a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding a peachwood sword with a reddish-brown blade engraved with faint ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the priest perform slow, deliberate dance movements with his back to the rising sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the sword swings create visible streaks of golden light composed of luminous particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370939567685127 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087092876434326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370939567685127, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370939567685127, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11215312778949738, + 0.06369481980800629, + 0.048918530344963074, + 0.04235950484871864, + 0.05815516412258148, + 0.07508605718612671, + 0.3018557131290436, + 0.15782609581947327, + 0.06343679130077362, + 0.07651421427726746 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370939567685127 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a secluded rocky mountaintop with a sea of clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Taoist priest visible wearing an off-white wide-sleeved linen robe and a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding a peachwood sword with a reddish-brown blade engraved with faint ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the priest perform slow, deliberate dance movements with his back to the rising sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the sword swings create visible streaks of golden light composed of luminous particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004091345705091953 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504091262817383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004091345705091953, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004091345705091953, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11853459477424622, + 0.08976248651742935, + 0.10152670741081238, + 0.07155386358499527, + 0.08347727358341217, + 0.054787784814834595, + 0.1543254852294922, + 0.126275435090065, + 0.06137707829475403, + 0.1383792906999588 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004091345705091953 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a secluded rocky mountaintop with a sea of clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Taoist priest visible wearing an off-white wide-sleeved linen robe and a bun with a wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the priest holding a peachwood sword with a reddish-brown blade engraved with faint ancient runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the priest perform slow, deliberate dance movements with his back to the rising sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the sword swings create visible streaks of golden light composed of luminous particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020576585084199905 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955764770507812 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020576585084199905, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020576585084199905, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1344214528799057, + 0.0983247458934784, + 0.07971169054508209, + 0.0420721061527729, + 0.156835675239563, + 0.05488474294543266, + 0.281588077545166, + 0.09208240360021591, + 0.033344510942697525, + 0.026734644547104836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020576585084199905 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_4/index_tensor([6907, 6907])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_4/index_tensor([6907, 6907])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fba942766632dbf988286f91d1bd187923b71c34 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_4/index_tensor([6907, 6907])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle shot, hovering like a drone, focuses on a stretch of fine, freshly wet sand. In the bright, soft afternoon sunlight, the wet sand takes on a deep caramel hue, shimmering with shimmering waves. Several depressions hold crystal-clear water, reflecting the azure sky. At the center of the frame, two crabs of stark contrasting colors engage in a fierce duel: one, clad in a fiery scarlet carapace, its massive, disproportionate claws tipped with ivory white, appear exceptionally sharp; the other, with a sapphire blue shell speckled with yellow, gleams metallic in the sunlight. They lower their bodies, each holding its formidable claws high, cautiously circling each other, then suddenly lunge forward, their massive claws clashing in mid-air with a resounding snap. They kept pushing and shoving in the struggle, and every strong swing would throw tiny sand and water droplets into the air. The whole scene was full of primitive tension and tense natural drama, creating an atmosphere of vitality that was both cruel and magnificent.", + "seed": 24302, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_4/index_6907_seed_24302_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07206445969641209, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07206445969641209, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07206445969641209, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and high-angle, hovering like a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two crabs visible in the center of the frame engaging in a duel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one crab clad in a fiery scarlet carapace with massive claws tipped in ivory white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the other crab featuring a sapphire blue shell speckled with yellow that gleams metallically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs lunge forward and clash their claws in mid-air, throwing sand and water droplets into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1859390139579773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.810939073562622 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1859390139579773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1859390139579773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2827642858028412, + 0.12178613245487213, + 0.07062564045190811, + 0.22310319542884827, + 0.06499733775854111, + 0.05229603499174118, + 0.033347275108098984, + 0.05358802154660225, + 0.05638289079070091, + 0.041109196841716766 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1859390139579773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and high-angle, hovering like a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two crabs visible in the center of the frame engaging in a duel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one crab clad in a fiery scarlet carapace with massive claws tipped in ivory white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the other crab featuring a sapphire blue shell speckled with yellow that gleams metallically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs lunge forward and clash their claws in mid-air, throwing sand and water droplets into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02637499012053013 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513750553131104 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02637499012053013, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02637499012053013, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3005216717720032, + 0.11207830905914307, + 0.08835410326719284, + 0.04586755484342575, + 0.08035574108362198, + 0.07303734868764877, + 0.050041526556015015, + 0.09240518510341644, + 0.13875317573547363, + 0.01858532987535 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02637499012053013 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and high-angle, hovering like a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two crabs visible in the center of the frame engaging in a duel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one crab clad in a fiery scarlet carapace with massive claws tipped in ivory white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the other crab featuring a sapphire blue shell speckled with yellow that gleams metallically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs lunge forward and clash their claws in mid-air, throwing sand and water droplets into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810613602399826 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881062030792236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810613602399826, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810613602399826, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3073405921459198, + 0.17443184554576874, + 0.06904776394367218, + 0.19649481773376465, + 0.023630451411008835, + 0.047716282308101654, + 0.032910753041505814, + 0.08141527324914932, + 0.046038299798965454, + 0.02097390405833721 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810613602399826 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and high-angle, hovering like a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two crabs visible in the center of the frame engaging in a duel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one crab clad in a fiery scarlet carapace with massive claws tipped in ivory white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the other crab featuring a sapphire blue shell speckled with yellow that gleams metallically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs lunge forward and clash their claws in mid-air, throwing sand and water droplets into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495497211813927 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929955005645752 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495497211813927, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495497211813927, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20371554791927338, + 0.222759410738945, + 0.04038843885064125, + 0.07260534167289734, + 0.03935173526406288, + 0.0863325372338295, + 0.0470154695212841, + 0.11225263774394989, + 0.13515819609165192, + 0.04042070358991623 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495497211813927 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and high-angle, hovering like a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two crabs visible in the center of the frame engaging in a duel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one crab clad in a fiery scarlet carapace with massive claws tipped in ivory white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the other crab featuring a sapphire blue shell speckled with yellow that gleams metallically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs lunge forward and clash their claws in mid-air, throwing sand and water droplets into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05494718626141548 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299471378326416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05494718626141548, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05494718626141548, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14601443707942963, + 0.06014144793152809, + 0.07012531906366348, + 0.05892645940184593, + 0.03191473335027695, + 0.07456531375646591, + 0.039163824170827866, + 0.18009218573570251, + 0.31752920150756836, + 0.021527161821722984 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05494718626141548 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle shot, hovering like a drone, focuses on a stretch of fine, freshly wet sand. In the bright, soft afternoon sunlight, the wet sand takes on a deep caramel hue, shimmering with shimmering waves. Several depressions hold crystal-clear water, reflecting the azure sky. At the center of the frame, two crabs of stark contrasting colors engage in a fierce duel: one, clad in a fiery scarlet carapace, its massive, disproportionate claws tipped with ivory white, appear exceptionally sharp; the other, with a sapphire blue shell speckled with yellow, gleams metallic in the sunlight. They lower their bodies, each holding its formidable claws high, cautiously circling each other, then suddenly lunge forward, their massive claws clashing in mid-air with a resounding snap. They kept pushing and shoving in the struggle, and every strong swing would throw tiny sand and water droplets into the air. The whole scene was full of primitive tension and tense natural drama, creating an atmosphere of vitality that was both cruel and magnificent.", + "seed": 24303, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_4/index_6907_seed_24303_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08903594687581062, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08903594687581062, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08903594687581062, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and high-angle, hovering like a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two crabs visible in the center of the frame engaging in a duel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one crab clad in a fiery scarlet carapace with massive claws tipped in ivory white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the other crab featuring a sapphire blue shell speckled with yellow that gleams metallically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs lunge forward and clash their claws in mid-air, throwing sand and water droplets into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20930135250091553 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7093013525009155 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20930135250091553, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20930135250091553, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22932471334934235, + 0.13774801790714264, + 0.09804302453994751, + 0.06824035197496414, + 0.07408779859542847, + 0.06086428090929985, + 0.1995638906955719, + 0.05470341816544533, + 0.04545009881258011, + 0.031974416226148605 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20930135250091553 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and high-angle, hovering like a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two crabs visible in the center of the frame engaging in a duel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one crab clad in a fiery scarlet carapace with massive claws tipped in ivory white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the other crab featuring a sapphire blue shell speckled with yellow that gleams metallically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs lunge forward and clash their claws in mid-air, throwing sand and water droplets into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026385672390460968 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.65138578414917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026385672390460968, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026385672390460968, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18506254255771637, + 0.07333917170763016, + 0.07176775485277176, + 0.23464997112751007, + 0.07280945032835007, + 0.06461913883686066, + 0.09284211695194244, + 0.06778956204652786, + 0.09030688554048538, + 0.04681343585252762 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026385672390460968 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and high-angle, hovering like a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two crabs visible in the center of the frame engaging in a duel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one crab clad in a fiery scarlet carapace with massive claws tipped in ivory white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the other crab featuring a sapphire blue shell speckled with yellow that gleams metallically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs lunge forward and clash their claws in mid-air, throwing sand and water droplets into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04870064929127693 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0487005710601807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04870064929127693, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04870064929127693, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2052786648273468, + 0.06977375596761703, + 0.14741456508636475, + 0.2631000578403473, + 0.06952060014009476, + 0.025046715512871742, + 0.06683432310819626, + 0.04029524698853493, + 0.059500668197870255, + 0.05323542281985283 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04870064929127693 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and high-angle, hovering like a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two crabs visible in the center of the frame engaging in a duel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one crab clad in a fiery scarlet carapace with massive claws tipped in ivory white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the other crab featuring a sapphire blue shell speckled with yellow that gleams metallically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs lunge forward and clash their claws in mid-air, throwing sand and water droplets into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12709015607833862 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270902156829834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12709015607833862, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12709015607833862, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.207899808883667, + 0.06127563863992691, + 0.09016276895999908, + 0.27760177850723267, + 0.08242767304182053, + 0.021738361567258835, + 0.08285187929868698, + 0.052994366735219955, + 0.07209696620702744, + 0.050950787961483 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12709015607833862 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and high-angle, hovering like a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two crabs visible in the center of the frame engaging in a duel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one crab clad in a fiery scarlet carapace with massive claws tipped in ivory white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the other crab featuring a sapphire blue shell speckled with yellow that gleams metallically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs lunge forward and clash their claws in mid-air, throwing sand and water droplets into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033701904118061066 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087018966674805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033701904118061066, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033701904118061066, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2798598110675812, + 0.05306371673941612, + 0.10239845514297485, + 0.10808442533016205, + 0.11647779494524002, + 0.044424574822187424, + 0.11591178178787231, + 0.06701745092868805, + 0.07312636077404022, + 0.039635609835386276 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033701904118061066 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle shot, hovering like a drone, focuses on a stretch of fine, freshly wet sand. In the bright, soft afternoon sunlight, the wet sand takes on a deep caramel hue, shimmering with shimmering waves. Several depressions hold crystal-clear water, reflecting the azure sky. At the center of the frame, two crabs of stark contrasting colors engage in a fierce duel: one, clad in a fiery scarlet carapace, its massive, disproportionate claws tipped with ivory white, appear exceptionally sharp; the other, with a sapphire blue shell speckled with yellow, gleams metallic in the sunlight. They lower their bodies, each holding its formidable claws high, cautiously circling each other, then suddenly lunge forward, their massive claws clashing in mid-air with a resounding snap. They kept pushing and shoving in the struggle, and every strong swing would throw tiny sand and water droplets into the air. The whole scene was full of primitive tension and tense natural drama, creating an atmosphere of vitality that was both cruel and magnificent.", + "seed": 24304, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_4/index_6907_seed_24304_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05108591858297586, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05108591858297586, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05108591858297586, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and high-angle, hovering like a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two crabs visible in the center of the frame engaging in a duel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one crab clad in a fiery scarlet carapace with massive claws tipped in ivory white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the other crab featuring a sapphire blue shell speckled with yellow that gleams metallically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs lunge forward and clash their claws in mid-air, throwing sand and water droplets into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10673816502094269 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3567380905151367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10673816502094269, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10673816502094269, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02788529358804226, + 0.10419384390115738, + 0.7327615022659302, + 0.02486192248761654, + 0.015650523826479912, + 0.016147326678037643, + 0.013460692949593067, + 0.0186535082757473, + 0.02820628508925438, + 0.018179088830947876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10673816502094269 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and high-angle, hovering like a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two crabs visible in the center of the frame engaging in a duel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one crab clad in a fiery scarlet carapace with massive claws tipped in ivory white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the other crab featuring a sapphire blue shell speckled with yellow that gleams metallically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs lunge forward and clash their claws in mid-air, throwing sand and water droplets into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012559250928461552 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387559413909912 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012559250928461552, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012559250928461552, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15340116620063782, + 0.15953786671161652, + 0.0835520401597023, + 0.19195888936519623, + 0.09395013004541397, + 0.04754556342959404, + 0.0548759326338768, + 0.05583225190639496, + 0.13807855546474457, + 0.021267589181661606 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012559250928461552 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and high-angle, hovering like a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two crabs visible in the center of the frame engaging in a duel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one crab clad in a fiery scarlet carapace with massive claws tipped in ivory white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the other crab featuring a sapphire blue shell speckled with yellow that gleams metallically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs lunge forward and clash their claws in mid-air, throwing sand and water droplets into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05497302860021591 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299731254577637 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05497302860021591, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05497302860021591, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02028762176632881, + 0.45854511857032776, + 0.23953740298748016, + 0.023454448208212852, + 0.021888142451643944, + 0.11180698126554489, + 0.0674242451786995, + 0.019390471279621124, + 0.027977854013442993, + 0.009687683545053005 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05497302860021591 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and high-angle, hovering like a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two crabs visible in the center of the frame engaging in a duel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one crab clad in a fiery scarlet carapace with massive claws tipped in ivory white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the other crab featuring a sapphire blue shell speckled with yellow that gleams metallically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs lunge forward and clash their claws in mid-air, throwing sand and water droplets into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038107167929410934 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.28810715675354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038107167929410934, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038107167929410934, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04142322018742561, + 0.4881959855556488, + 0.09519369155168533, + 0.040180131793022156, + 0.027539782226085663, + 0.02414044179022312, + 0.027353864163160324, + 0.049323007464408875, + 0.17665834724903107, + 0.02999149076640606 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038107167929410934 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and high-angle, hovering like a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two crabs visible in the center of the frame engaging in a duel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one crab clad in a fiery scarlet carapace with massive claws tipped in ivory white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the other crab featuring a sapphire blue shell speckled with yellow that gleams metallically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs lunge forward and clash their claws in mid-air, throwing sand and water droplets into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043051980435848236 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680519580841064 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043051980435848236, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043051980435848236, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0590590164065361, + 0.2519576847553253, + 0.3081778287887573, + 0.149204820394516, + 0.026680128648877144, + 0.03201105818152428, + 0.047680940479040146, + 0.04593604803085327, + 0.05843106657266617, + 0.020861415192484856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043051980435848236 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle shot, hovering like a drone, focuses on a stretch of fine, freshly wet sand. In the bright, soft afternoon sunlight, the wet sand takes on a deep caramel hue, shimmering with shimmering waves. Several depressions hold crystal-clear water, reflecting the azure sky. At the center of the frame, two crabs of stark contrasting colors engage in a fierce duel: one, clad in a fiery scarlet carapace, its massive, disproportionate claws tipped with ivory white, appear exceptionally sharp; the other, with a sapphire blue shell speckled with yellow, gleams metallic in the sunlight. They lower their bodies, each holding its formidable claws high, cautiously circling each other, then suddenly lunge forward, their massive claws clashing in mid-air with a resounding snap. They kept pushing and shoving in the struggle, and every strong swing would throw tiny sand and water droplets into the air. The whole scene was full of primitive tension and tense natural drama, creating an atmosphere of vitality that was both cruel and magnificent.", + "seed": 24305, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_4/index_6907_seed_24305_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04450284633785486, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04450284633785486, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04450284633785486, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and high-angle, hovering like a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two crabs visible in the center of the frame engaging in a duel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one crab clad in a fiery scarlet carapace with massive claws tipped in ivory white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the other crab featuring a sapphire blue shell speckled with yellow that gleams metallically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs lunge forward and clash their claws in mid-air, throwing sand and water droplets into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14987029135227203 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0248703956604004 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14987029135227203, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14987029135227203, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.01617022417485714, + 0.019868528470396996, + 0.00906349066644907, + 0.0186227448284626, + 0.8555041551589966, + 0.008749430067837238, + 0.018132135272026062, + 0.01649749092757702, + 0.018925229087471962, + 0.018466651439666748 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14987029135227203 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and high-angle, hovering like a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two crabs visible in the center of the frame engaging in a duel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one crab clad in a fiery scarlet carapace with massive claws tipped in ivory white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the other crab featuring a sapphire blue shell speckled with yellow that gleams metallically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs lunge forward and clash their claws in mid-air, throwing sand and water droplets into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012559250928461552 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387559413909912 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012559250928461552, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012559250928461552, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.027161192148923874, + 0.08823341876268387, + 0.021745674312114716, + 0.05807289481163025, + 0.6318690180778503, + 0.060537610203027725, + 0.03960263729095459, + 0.024594396352767944, + 0.0259404219686985, + 0.02224268764257431 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012559250928461552 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and high-angle, hovering like a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two crabs visible in the center of the frame engaging in a duel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one crab clad in a fiery scarlet carapace with massive claws tipped in ivory white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the other crab featuring a sapphire blue shell speckled with yellow that gleams metallically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs lunge forward and clash their claws in mid-air, throwing sand and water droplets into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016089249402284622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14108943939209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016089249402284622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016089249402284622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.019109822809696198, + 0.0455758199095726, + 0.008720435202121735, + 0.029855970293283463, + 0.7529089450836182, + 0.08477434515953064, + 0.016833217814564705, + 0.01192910224199295, + 0.005973967723548412, + 0.024318398907780647 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016089249402284622 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and high-angle, hovering like a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two crabs visible in the center of the frame engaging in a duel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one crab clad in a fiery scarlet carapace with massive claws tipped in ivory white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the other crab featuring a sapphire blue shell speckled with yellow that gleams metallically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs lunge forward and clash their claws in mid-air, throwing sand and water droplets into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980225533246994 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298023223876953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980225533246994, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980225533246994, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.028806187212467194, + 0.02078952267765999, + 0.00860806368291378, + 0.02121606655418873, + 0.8244673013687134, + 0.030204549431800842, + 0.013112575747072697, + 0.016626745462417603, + 0.013110576197504997, + 0.02305838279426098 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980225533246994 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static and high-angle, hovering like a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two crabs visible in the center of the frame engaging in a duel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one crab clad in a fiery scarlet carapace with massive claws tipped in ivory white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the other crab featuring a sapphire blue shell speckled with yellow that gleams metallically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the crabs lunge forward and clash their claws in mid-air, throwing sand and water droplets into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014193184673786163 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264193058013916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014193184673786163, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014193184673786163, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03485514968633652, + 0.042665570974349976, + 0.054995618760585785, + 0.03619807958602905, + 0.2635740637779236, + 0.2545371353626251, + 0.1284349113702774, + 0.05787307396531105, + 0.05037165805697441, + 0.07649469375610352 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014193184673786163 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_5/index_tensor([1767, 1767])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_5/index_tensor([1767, 1767])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..491c62b882861a2304cfcb93b0a98c8bcb781d26 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_5/index_tensor([1767, 1767])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In one unbroken shot, the camera glides forward, slowly and ghostly, from a low angle, through the center aisle of the vast, smoke-filled Legislative Council chamber, a scene shrouded in a stark, dystopian sci-fi aesthetic. The imposing, brutalist concrete building, with its towering columns and vaulted ceilings, is almost entirely shrouded in deep shadows and a thick, synthetic haze that drifts lazily through the cavernous space. On either side of the camera's path, rows of spacious, empty, high-backed seats, constructed of cool, dark metal alloy and draped with worn black synthetic fabric, are arranged in quiet, orderly tiers. The only illumination comes from several monolithic screens embedded in the room's walls; they flicker unsteadily, silently displaying stark, graphic propaganda—bold, abstract symbols and faceless figures rendered in a harsh palette of scarlet and pristine white. This intermittent, cold digital light cast long, dancing shadows that crawled across the empty seats and polished stone floors, creating a scene of oppressive, silencing power and emphasizing the profound, tomblike silence of the abandoned halls of authority.", + "seed": 16653, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_5/index_1767_seed_16653_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.01594558535143733, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01594558535143733, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01594558535143733, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through the center aisle of a vast chamber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are rows of empty, high-backed seats made of dark metal alloy and draped with black fabric visible on either side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment filled with a thick, synthetic haze and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do monolithic screens on the walls display flickering propaganda with scarlet and white abstract symbols and faceless figures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brutalist concrete building with towering columns and vaulted ceilings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.028516480699181557 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6535165309906006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.028516480699181557, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.028516480699181557, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28966647386550903, + 0.1063399538397789, + 0.04555412009358406, + 0.03881998732686043, + 0.04837489873170853, + 0.025287922471761703, + 0.028225619345903397, + 0.03459174185991287, + 0.3161013424396515, + 0.06703796237707138 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.028516480699181557 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through the center aisle of a vast chamber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are rows of empty, high-backed seats made of dark metal alloy and draped with black fabric visible on either side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment filled with a thick, synthetic haze and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do monolithic screens on the walls display flickering propaganda with scarlet and white abstract symbols and faceless figures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brutalist concrete building with towering columns and vaulted ceilings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006742938421666622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00674295425415 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006742938421666622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006742938421666622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2687651813030243, + 0.049051810055971146, + 0.08682484924793243, + 0.09768523275852203, + 0.10209726542234421, + 0.055618397891521454, + 0.03382757678627968, + 0.07430965453386307, + 0.17736706137657166, + 0.05445303022861481 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006742938421666622 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through the center aisle of a vast chamber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are rows of empty, high-backed seats made of dark metal alloy and draped with black fabric visible on either side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment filled with a thick, synthetic haze and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do monolithic screens on the walls display flickering propaganda with scarlet and white abstract symbols and faceless figures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brutalist concrete building with towering columns and vaulted ceilings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029792074114084244 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529792070388794 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029792074114084244, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029792074114084244, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2987677752971649, + 0.132814422249794, + 0.23966942727565765, + 0.05767647549510002, + 0.02350752428174019, + 0.016694899648427963, + 0.031049154698848724, + 0.037594277411699295, + 0.1370968371629715, + 0.025129267945885658 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029792074114084244 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through the center aisle of a vast chamber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are rows of empty, high-backed seats made of dark metal alloy and draped with black fabric visible on either side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment filled with a thick, synthetic haze and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do monolithic screens on the walls display flickering propaganda with scarlet and white abstract symbols and faceless figures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brutalist concrete building with towering columns and vaulted ceilings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00361218536272645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628612041473389 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00361218536272645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00361218536272645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2181144505739212, + 0.10512486100196838, + 0.0900198221206665, + 0.08554740995168686, + 0.09975382685661316, + 0.029034029692411423, + 0.047497689723968506, + 0.0646452009677887, + 0.15915510058403015, + 0.10110756754875183 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00361218536272645 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through the center aisle of a vast chamber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are rows of empty, high-backed seats made of dark metal alloy and draped with black fabric visible on either side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment filled with a thick, synthetic haze and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do monolithic screens on the walls display flickering propaganda with scarlet and white abstract symbols and faceless figures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brutalist concrete building with towering columns and vaulted ceilings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011064248159527779 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511064052581787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011064248159527779, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011064248159527779, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3177805244922638, + 0.050858620554208755, + 0.07885770499706268, + 0.11587025970220566, + 0.04649379476904869, + 0.03664308786392212, + 0.024855954572558403, + 0.04317877069115639, + 0.22932158410549164, + 0.056139662861824036 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011064248159527779 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In one unbroken shot, the camera glides forward, slowly and ghostly, from a low angle, through the center aisle of the vast, smoke-filled Legislative Council chamber, a scene shrouded in a stark, dystopian sci-fi aesthetic. The imposing, brutalist concrete building, with its towering columns and vaulted ceilings, is almost entirely shrouded in deep shadows and a thick, synthetic haze that drifts lazily through the cavernous space. On either side of the camera's path, rows of spacious, empty, high-backed seats, constructed of cool, dark metal alloy and draped with worn black synthetic fabric, are arranged in quiet, orderly tiers. The only illumination comes from several monolithic screens embedded in the room's walls; they flicker unsteadily, silently displaying stark, graphic propaganda—bold, abstract symbols and faceless figures rendered in a harsh palette of scarlet and pristine white. This intermittent, cold digital light cast long, dancing shadows that crawled across the empty seats and polished stone floors, creating a scene of oppressive, silencing power and emphasizing the profound, tomblike silence of the abandoned halls of authority.", + "seed": 16654, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_5/index_1767_seed_16654_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.009716300759464502, + "vlm_logprob": -0.009716300759464502, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.009716300759464502, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through the center aisle of a vast chamber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are rows of empty, high-backed seats made of dark metal alloy and draped with black fabric visible on either side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment filled with a thick, synthetic haze and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do monolithic screens on the walls display flickering propaganda with scarlet and white abstract symbols and faceless figures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brutalist concrete building with towering columns and vaulted ceilings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005550686735659838 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.380550861358643 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005550686735659838, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005550686735659838, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23920679092407227, + 0.07528912276029587, + 0.05983971804380417, + 0.08494548499584198, + 0.08385919034481049, + 0.1671341359615326, + 0.09098000824451447, + 0.07602644711732864, + 0.08604038506746292, + 0.03667870908975601 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005550686735659838 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through the center aisle of a vast chamber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are rows of empty, high-backed seats made of dark metal alloy and draped with black fabric visible on either side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment filled with a thick, synthetic haze and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do monolithic screens on the walls display flickering propaganda with scarlet and white abstract symbols and faceless figures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brutalist concrete building with towering columns and vaulted ceilings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012539473362267017 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387539386749268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012539473362267017, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012539473362267017, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19498500227928162, + 0.03658744692802429, + 0.14035864174365997, + 0.045401543378829956, + 0.08643820881843567, + 0.062212929129600525, + 0.2971258759498596, + 0.07003502547740936, + 0.03385363891720772, + 0.03300175815820694 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012539473362267017 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through the center aisle of a vast chamber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are rows of empty, high-backed seats made of dark metal alloy and draped with black fabric visible on either side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment filled with a thick, synthetic haze and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do monolithic screens on the walls display flickering propaganda with scarlet and white abstract symbols and faceless figures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brutalist concrete building with towering columns and vaulted ceilings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006732044741511345 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006731986999512 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006732044741511345, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006732044741511345, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17687486112117767, + 0.05094773694872856, + 0.1462760716676712, + 0.056375741958618164, + 0.07346075773239136, + 0.05138121917843819, + 0.3194521367549896, + 0.06821754574775696, + 0.029459785670042038, + 0.027554092928767204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006732044741511345 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through the center aisle of a vast chamber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are rows of empty, high-backed seats made of dark metal alloy and draped with black fabric visible on either side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment filled with a thick, synthetic haze and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do monolithic screens on the walls display flickering propaganda with scarlet and white abstract symbols and faceless figures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brutalist concrete building with towering columns and vaulted ceilings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003189953975379467 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753190040588379 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003189953975379467, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003189953975379467, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08425790071487427, + 0.03070010058581829, + 0.06360889971256256, + 0.030519770458340645, + 0.0423627607524395, + 0.13608264923095703, + 0.3571542799472809, + 0.11622670292854309, + 0.055105507373809814, + 0.08398141711950302 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003189953975379467 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through the center aisle of a vast chamber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are rows of empty, high-backed seats made of dark metal alloy and draped with black fabric visible on either side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment filled with a thick, synthetic haze and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do monolithic screens on the walls display flickering propaganda with scarlet and white abstract symbols and faceless figures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brutalist concrete building with towering columns and vaulted ceilings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020569344982504845 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895569324493408 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020569344982504845, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020569344982504845, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2656790018081665, + 0.03319872170686722, + 0.02865760028362274, + 0.03986548259854317, + 0.06751798093318939, + 0.042841456830501556, + 0.3676448464393616, + 0.07421143352985382, + 0.05261464789509773, + 0.027768807485699654 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020569344982504845 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In one unbroken shot, the camera glides forward, slowly and ghostly, from a low angle, through the center aisle of the vast, smoke-filled Legislative Council chamber, a scene shrouded in a stark, dystopian sci-fi aesthetic. The imposing, brutalist concrete building, with its towering columns and vaulted ceilings, is almost entirely shrouded in deep shadows and a thick, synthetic haze that drifts lazily through the cavernous space. On either side of the camera's path, rows of spacious, empty, high-backed seats, constructed of cool, dark metal alloy and draped with worn black synthetic fabric, are arranged in quiet, orderly tiers. The only illumination comes from several monolithic screens embedded in the room's walls; they flicker unsteadily, silently displaying stark, graphic propaganda—bold, abstract symbols and faceless figures rendered in a harsh palette of scarlet and pristine white. This intermittent, cold digital light cast long, dancing shadows that crawled across the empty seats and polished stone floors, creating a scene of oppressive, silencing power and emphasizing the profound, tomblike silence of the abandoned halls of authority.", + "seed": 16655, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_5/index_1767_seed_16655_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.007618045480921864, + "vlm_logprob": -0.007618045480921864, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.007618045480921864, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through the center aisle of a vast chamber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are rows of empty, high-backed seats made of dark metal alloy and draped with black fabric visible on either side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment filled with a thick, synthetic haze and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do monolithic screens on the walls display flickering propaganda with scarlet and white abstract symbols and faceless figures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brutalist concrete building with towering columns and vaulted ceilings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010142690502107143 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.760142803192139 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010142690502107143, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010142690502107143, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13028718531131744, + 0.38027092814445496, + 0.041731465607881546, + 0.07186607271432877, + 0.05081816017627716, + 0.042794205248355865, + 0.04036635532975197, + 0.05746489390730858, + 0.10149556398391724, + 0.08290508389472961 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010142690502107143 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through the center aisle of a vast chamber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are rows of empty, high-backed seats made of dark metal alloy and draped with black fabric visible on either side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment filled with a thick, synthetic haze and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do monolithic screens on the walls display flickering propaganda with scarlet and white abstract symbols and faceless figures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brutalist concrete building with towering columns and vaulted ceilings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004098587669432163 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504098415374756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004098587669432163, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004098587669432163, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19308388233184814, + 0.1366681009531021, + 0.09482986479997635, + 0.08446138352155685, + 0.0571291409432888, + 0.136415496468544, + 0.11076042801141739, + 0.04358578100800514, + 0.0932866781949997, + 0.04977913573384285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004098587669432163 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through the center aisle of a vast chamber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are rows of empty, high-backed seats made of dark metal alloy and draped with black fabric visible on either side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment filled with a thick, synthetic haze and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do monolithic screens on the walls display flickering propaganda with scarlet and white abstract symbols and faceless figures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brutalist concrete building with towering columns and vaulted ceilings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031881716568022966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753188133239746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031881716568022966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031881716568022966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08958964794874191, + 0.08335157483816147, + 0.2143561691045761, + 0.045375943183898926, + 0.02269209362566471, + 0.3202151954174042, + 0.13408730924129486, + 0.017905917018651962, + 0.03863951563835144, + 0.03378661349415779 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031881716568022966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through the center aisle of a vast chamber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are rows of empty, high-backed seats made of dark metal alloy and draped with black fabric visible on either side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment filled with a thick, synthetic haze and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do monolithic screens on the walls display flickering propaganda with scarlet and white abstract symbols and faceless figures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brutalist concrete building with towering columns and vaulted ceilings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024861162528395653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002486228942871 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024861162528395653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024861162528395653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08108414709568024, + 0.40132254362106323, + 0.033673129975795746, + 0.019212210550904274, + 0.04304373264312744, + 0.1290508657693863, + 0.056139830499887466, + 0.08400031179189682, + 0.11443919688463211, + 0.038034021854400635 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024861162528395653 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through the center aisle of a vast chamber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are rows of empty, high-backed seats made of dark metal alloy and draped with black fabric visible on either side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment filled with a thick, synthetic haze and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do monolithic screens on the walls display flickering propaganda with scarlet and white abstract symbols and faceless figures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brutalist concrete building with towering columns and vaulted ceilings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018174661323428154 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018174648284912 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018174661323428154, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018174661323428154, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14735113084316254, + 0.32795408368110657, + 0.09541580080986023, + 0.029642337933182716, + 0.031218402087688446, + 0.07540585845708847, + 0.20326513051986694, + 0.02429688535630703, + 0.04296919330954552, + 0.02248121239244938 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018174661323428154 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In one unbroken shot, the camera glides forward, slowly and ghostly, from a low angle, through the center aisle of the vast, smoke-filled Legislative Council chamber, a scene shrouded in a stark, dystopian sci-fi aesthetic. The imposing, brutalist concrete building, with its towering columns and vaulted ceilings, is almost entirely shrouded in deep shadows and a thick, synthetic haze that drifts lazily through the cavernous space. On either side of the camera's path, rows of spacious, empty, high-backed seats, constructed of cool, dark metal alloy and draped with worn black synthetic fabric, are arranged in quiet, orderly tiers. The only illumination comes from several monolithic screens embedded in the room's walls; they flicker unsteadily, silently displaying stark, graphic propaganda—bold, abstract symbols and faceless figures rendered in a harsh palette of scarlet and pristine white. This intermittent, cold digital light cast long, dancing shadows that crawled across the empty seats and polished stone floors, creating a scene of oppressive, silencing power and emphasizing the profound, tomblike silence of the abandoned halls of authority.", + "seed": 16656, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_5/index_1767_seed_16656_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.023649721033871175, + "vlm_logprob": -0.023649721033871175, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.023649721033871175, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through the center aisle of a vast chamber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are rows of empty, high-backed seats made of dark metal alloy and draped with black fabric visible on either side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment filled with a thick, synthetic haze and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do monolithic screens on the walls display flickering propaganda with scarlet and white abstract symbols and faceless figures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brutalist concrete building with towering columns and vaulted ceilings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04891670122742653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.173916816711426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04891670122742653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04891670122742653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1413215547800064, + 0.12021192908287048, + 0.05758402869105339, + 0.25156959891319275, + 0.14618316292762756, + 0.06451095640659332, + 0.03631079941987991, + 0.031218722462654114, + 0.042707350105047226, + 0.10838192701339722 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04891670122742653 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through the center aisle of a vast chamber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are rows of empty, high-backed seats made of dark metal alloy and draped with black fabric visible on either side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment filled with a thick, synthetic haze and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do monolithic screens on the walls display flickering propaganda with scarlet and white abstract symbols and faceless figures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brutalist concrete building with towering columns and vaulted ceilings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01254983339458704 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387549877166748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01254983339458704, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01254983339458704, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23998044431209564, + 0.05524517595767975, + 0.135445699095726, + 0.100002720952034, + 0.14930199086666107, + 0.0500030554831028, + 0.03588534891605377, + 0.059826403856277466, + 0.09533035755157471, + 0.07897887378931046 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01254983339458704 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through the center aisle of a vast chamber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are rows of empty, high-backed seats made of dark metal alloy and draped with black fabric visible on either side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment filled with a thick, synthetic haze and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do monolithic screens on the walls display flickering propaganda with scarlet and white abstract symbols and faceless figures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brutalist concrete building with towering columns and vaulted ceilings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004094788804650307 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.50409460067749 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004094788804650307, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004094788804650307, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13694052398204803, + 0.07339147478342056, + 0.15881116688251495, + 0.0919608399271965, + 0.14158117771148682, + 0.09054509550333023, + 0.07998845726251602, + 0.08639184385538101, + 0.10169833898544312, + 0.038691118359565735 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004094788804650307 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through the center aisle of a vast chamber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are rows of empty, high-backed seats made of dark metal alloy and draped with black fabric visible on either side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment filled with a thick, synthetic haze and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do monolithic screens on the walls display flickering propaganda with scarlet and white abstract symbols and faceless figures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brutalist concrete building with towering columns and vaulted ceilings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634689211845398 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513469219207764 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634689211845398, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634689211845398, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2818232476711273, + 0.051470957696437836, + 0.19209235906600952, + 0.07427265495061874, + 0.09683851152658463, + 0.027824517339468002, + 0.04819478094577789, + 0.05247706174850464, + 0.04879116266965866, + 0.12621475756168365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634689211845398 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera moving forward through the center aisle of a vast chamber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are rows of empty, high-backed seats made of dark metal alloy and draped with black fabric visible on either side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment filled with a thick, synthetic haze and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do monolithic screens on the walls display flickering propaganda with scarlet and white abstract symbols and faceless figures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brutalist concrete building with towering columns and vaulted ceilings?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026340389624238014 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513404846191406 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026340389624238014, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026340389624238014, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20500339567661285, + 0.16835354268550873, + 0.19937381148338318, + 0.08318284898996353, + 0.12669551372528076, + 0.039012014865875244, + 0.03591149300336838, + 0.042110979557037354, + 0.028548672795295715, + 0.07180771231651306 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026340389624238014 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_7/index_tensor([9727, 9727])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_7/index_tensor([9727, 9727])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..cc221473ab59d1699ef2ca333ec70400642a47e5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_7/index_tensor([9727, 9727])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle, ultra-wide shot captures a sprawling futuristic metropolis at night, its rain-slicked streets like a dark mirror reflecting the spectacle unfolding below. A fleet of enormous, towering robots slowly and gracefully winds its way through a canyon-like avenue formed by massive black glass and steel skyscrapers. Their sleek, vaguely humanoid forms are constructed from matte black alloy that absorbs ambient light. Yet, their entire frames are traced by a complex network of vibrant blue and white lights that rhythmically pulsate, illuminating their path and casting long, shifting shadows. Each massive step descends with silent, ponderous weight, creating noticeable ripples in the puddles of water on the asphalt. The damp ground perfectly reflects the robots' lighting and the ever-changing colors of the city's towering holographic advertisements, which flicker silently in the background. The scene is immersed in a cool cyberpunk color palette of deep blue, electronic magentas, and pure white, creating an atmosphere of silent, awe-inspiring grandeur and technological mystery.", + "seed": 18006, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_7/index_9727_seed_18006_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04039746802300215, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04039746802300215, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.099999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04039746802300215, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, ultra-wide view of a futuristic metropolis at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are enormous, towering robots with sleek, vaguely humanoid forms moving through a canyon-like avenue of black glass and steel skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the robots constructed from matte black alloy with a complex network of vibrant blue and white lights tracing their frames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the robots move slowly and gracefully, creating ripples in puddles on the rain-slicked streets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a cool cyberpunk color palette of deep blue, electronic magentas, and pure white with holographic advertisements in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0212957002222538 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8962957859039307 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0212957002222538, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0212957002222538, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2855943739414215, + 0.07565228641033173, + 0.1756753921508789, + 0.11791075766086578, + 0.07331377267837524, + 0.04790927842259407, + 0.05505998060107231, + 0.03379985690116882, + 0.05006908252835274, + 0.08501526713371277 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0212957002222538 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, ultra-wide view of a futuristic metropolis at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are enormous, towering robots with sleek, vaguely humanoid forms moving through a canyon-like avenue of black glass and steel skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the robots constructed from matte black alloy with a complex network of vibrant blue and white lights tracing their frames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the robots move slowly and gracefully, creating ripples in puddles on the rain-slicked streets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a cool cyberpunk color palette of deep blue, electronic magentas, and pure white with holographic advertisements in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020600641146302223 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956005573272705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020600641146302223, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020600641146302223, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20437555015087128, + 0.08164031058549881, + 0.2613128423690796, + 0.05446549132466316, + 0.06075982004404068, + 0.1268082559108734, + 0.06277009099721909, + 0.07770587503910065, + 0.030660979449748993, + 0.03950079530477524 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020600641146302223 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, ultra-wide view of a futuristic metropolis at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are enormous, towering robots with sleek, vaguely humanoid forms moving through a canyon-like avenue of black glass and steel skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the robots constructed from matte black alloy with a complex network of vibrant blue and white lights tracing their frames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the robots move slowly and gracefully, creating ripples in puddles on the rain-slicked streets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a cool cyberpunk color palette of deep blue, electronic magentas, and pure white with holographic advertisements in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016073059290647507 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141073226928711 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016073059290647507, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016073059290647507, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19977067410945892, + 0.09157121926546097, + 0.1944945901632309, + 0.10487622022628784, + 0.05196710675954819, + 0.09991026669740677, + 0.057026058435440063, + 0.040393318980932236, + 0.11053552478551865, + 0.049454983323812485 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016073059290647507 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, ultra-wide view of a futuristic metropolis at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are enormous, towering robots with sleek, vaguely humanoid forms moving through a canyon-like avenue of black glass and steel skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the robots constructed from matte black alloy with a complex network of vibrant blue and white lights tracing their frames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the robots move slowly and gracefully, creating ripples in puddles on the rain-slicked streets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a cool cyberpunk color palette of deep blue, electronic magentas, and pure white with holographic advertisements in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14283858239650726 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017838478088379 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14283858239650726, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14283858239650726, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23721714317798615, + 0.06872294098138809, + 0.3468267023563385, + 0.04890633001923561, + 0.0700949877500534, + 0.0815085768699646, + 0.06070576608181, + 0.01798379234969616, + 0.02930222637951374, + 0.03873151168227196 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14283858239650726 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, ultra-wide view of a futuristic metropolis at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are enormous, towering robots with sleek, vaguely humanoid forms moving through a canyon-like avenue of black glass and steel skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the robots constructed from matte black alloy with a complex network of vibrant blue and white lights tracing their frames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the robots move slowly and gracefully, creating ripples in puddles on the rain-slicked streets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a cool cyberpunk color palette of deep blue, electronic magentas, and pure white with holographic advertisements in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011793570592999458 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751179218292236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011793570592999458, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011793570592999458, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23408891260623932, + 0.08845150470733643, + 0.2532927691936493, + 0.07551667094230652, + 0.05003542825579643, + 0.06713957339525223, + 0.06021621823310852, + 0.04247589781880379, + 0.05670657753944397, + 0.07207643985748291 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011793570592999458 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle, ultra-wide shot captures a sprawling futuristic metropolis at night, its rain-slicked streets like a dark mirror reflecting the spectacle unfolding below. A fleet of enormous, towering robots slowly and gracefully winds its way through a canyon-like avenue formed by massive black glass and steel skyscrapers. Their sleek, vaguely humanoid forms are constructed from matte black alloy that absorbs ambient light. Yet, their entire frames are traced by a complex network of vibrant blue and white lights that rhythmically pulsate, illuminating their path and casting long, shifting shadows. Each massive step descends with silent, ponderous weight, creating noticeable ripples in the puddles of water on the asphalt. The damp ground perfectly reflects the robots' lighting and the ever-changing colors of the city's towering holographic advertisements, which flicker silently in the background. The scene is immersed in a cool cyberpunk color palette of deep blue, electronic magentas, and pure white, creating an atmosphere of silent, awe-inspiring grandeur and technological mystery.", + "seed": 18007, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_7/index_9727_seed_18007_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0943137563765049, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0943137563765049, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0943137563765049, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, ultra-wide view of a futuristic metropolis at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are enormous, towering robots with sleek, vaguely humanoid forms moving through a canyon-like avenue of black glass and steel skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the robots constructed from matte black alloy with a complex network of vibrant blue and white lights tracing their frames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the robots move slowly and gracefully, creating ripples in puddles on the rain-slicked streets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a cool cyberpunk color palette of deep blue, electronic magentas, and pure white with holographic advertisements in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2025706171989441 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7025706768035889 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2025706171989441, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2025706171989441, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.43747156858444214, + 0.12585148215293884, + 0.05001077428460121, + 0.07067260146141052, + 0.07124301791191101, + 0.05390963703393936, + 0.05320551618933678, + 0.03790466859936714, + 0.038233060389757156, + 0.06149765104055405 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2025706171989441 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, ultra-wide view of a futuristic metropolis at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are enormous, towering robots with sleek, vaguely humanoid forms moving through a canyon-like avenue of black glass and steel skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the robots constructed from matte black alloy with a complex network of vibrant blue and white lights tracing their frames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the robots move slowly and gracefully, creating ripples in puddles on the rain-slicked streets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a cool cyberpunk color palette of deep blue, electronic magentas, and pure white with holographic advertisements in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020600641146302223 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956005573272705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020600641146302223, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020600641146302223, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12234337627887726, + 0.20998774468898773, + 0.05358770862221718, + 0.10597515851259232, + 0.09679924696683884, + 0.08212998509407043, + 0.059888873249292374, + 0.1231045201420784, + 0.06676927953958511, + 0.07941409945487976 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020600641146302223 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, ultra-wide view of a futuristic metropolis at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are enormous, towering robots with sleek, vaguely humanoid forms moving through a canyon-like avenue of black glass and steel skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the robots constructed from matte black alloy with a complex network of vibrant blue and white lights tracing their frames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the robots move slowly and gracefully, creating ripples in puddles on the rain-slicked streets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a cool cyberpunk color palette of deep blue, electronic magentas, and pure white with holographic advertisements in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020586978644132614 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955869674682617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020586978644132614, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020586978644132614, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17825321853160858, + 0.1157589852809906, + 0.06661193072795868, + 0.10908070206642151, + 0.1808292716741562, + 0.062114350497722626, + 0.0724688470363617, + 0.11659416556358337, + 0.016602102667093277, + 0.08168646693229675 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020586978644132614 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, ultra-wide view of a futuristic metropolis at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are enormous, towering robots with sleek, vaguely humanoid forms moving through a canyon-like avenue of black glass and steel skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the robots constructed from matte black alloy with a complex network of vibrant blue and white lights tracing their frames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the robots move slowly and gracefully, creating ripples in puddles on the rain-slicked streets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a cool cyberpunk color palette of deep blue, electronic magentas, and pure white with holographic advertisements in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22561319172382355 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006132364273071 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22561319172382355, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22561319172382355, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1452045887708664, + 0.31816548109054565, + 0.04797426238656044, + 0.08744751662015915, + 0.10306736081838608, + 0.0811290591955185, + 0.07963202893733978, + 0.0594099797308445, + 0.01982918567955494, + 0.05814054235816002 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22561319172382355 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, ultra-wide view of a futuristic metropolis at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are enormous, towering robots with sleek, vaguely humanoid forms moving through a canyon-like avenue of black glass and steel skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the robots constructed from matte black alloy with a complex network of vibrant blue and white lights tracing their frames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the robots move slowly and gracefully, creating ripples in puddles on the rain-slicked streets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a cool cyberpunk color palette of deep blue, electronic magentas, and pure white with holographic advertisements in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002197353169322014 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127197265625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002197353169322014, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002197353169322014, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17599564790725708, + 0.10565844923257828, + 0.050054263323545456, + 0.10167066752910614, + 0.0496344231069088, + 0.11946306377649307, + 0.056221552193164825, + 0.11412181705236435, + 0.06540451943874359, + 0.1617756187915802 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002197353169322014 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle, ultra-wide shot captures a sprawling futuristic metropolis at night, its rain-slicked streets like a dark mirror reflecting the spectacle unfolding below. A fleet of enormous, towering robots slowly and gracefully winds its way through a canyon-like avenue formed by massive black glass and steel skyscrapers. Their sleek, vaguely humanoid forms are constructed from matte black alloy that absorbs ambient light. Yet, their entire frames are traced by a complex network of vibrant blue and white lights that rhythmically pulsate, illuminating their path and casting long, shifting shadows. Each massive step descends with silent, ponderous weight, creating noticeable ripples in the puddles of water on the asphalt. The damp ground perfectly reflects the robots' lighting and the ever-changing colors of the city's towering holographic advertisements, which flicker silently in the background. The scene is immersed in a cool cyberpunk color palette of deep blue, electronic magentas, and pure white, creating an atmosphere of silent, awe-inspiring grandeur and technological mystery.", + "seed": 18008, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_7/index_9727_seed_18008_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.0183302458608523, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0183302458608523, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0183302458608523, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, ultra-wide view of a futuristic metropolis at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are enormous, towering robots with sleek, vaguely humanoid forms moving through a canyon-like avenue of black glass and steel skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the robots constructed from matte black alloy with a complex network of vibrant blue and white lights tracing their frames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the robots move slowly and gracefully, creating ripples in puddles on the rain-slicked streets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a cool cyberpunk color palette of deep blue, electronic magentas, and pure white with holographic advertisements in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018990136682987213 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0189900398254395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018990136682987213, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018990136682987213, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12126990407705307, + 0.03297742083668709, + 0.034374941140413284, + 0.09444916248321533, + 0.520581066608429, + 0.0312977135181427, + 0.05642069876194, + 0.024729913100600243, + 0.035965077579021454, + 0.047934144735336304 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018990136682987213 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, ultra-wide view of a futuristic metropolis at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are enormous, towering robots with sleek, vaguely humanoid forms moving through a canyon-like avenue of black glass and steel skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the robots constructed from matte black alloy with a complex network of vibrant blue and white lights tracing their frames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the robots move slowly and gracefully, creating ripples in puddles on the rain-slicked streets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a cool cyberpunk color palette of deep blue, electronic magentas, and pure white with holographic advertisements in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00979510135948658 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634795188903809 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00979510135948658, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00979510135948658, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18772132694721222, + 0.09809122234582901, + 0.037134721875190735, + 0.29830679297447205, + 0.09395583719015121, + 0.02330573834478855, + 0.11670529842376709, + 0.040514301508665085, + 0.024339156225323677, + 0.07992569357156754 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00979510135948658 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, ultra-wide view of a futuristic metropolis at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are enormous, towering robots with sleek, vaguely humanoid forms moving through a canyon-like avenue of black glass and steel skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the robots constructed from matte black alloy with a complex network of vibrant blue and white lights tracing their frames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the robots move slowly and gracefully, creating ripples in puddles on the rain-slicked streets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a cool cyberpunk color palette of deep blue, electronic magentas, and pure white with holographic advertisements in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006737728603184223 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00673770904541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006737728603184223, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006737728603184223, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12155008316040039, + 0.056499529629945755, + 0.07872295379638672, + 0.25784650444984436, + 0.15764805674552917, + 0.06758993864059448, + 0.1004466786980629, + 0.05636093392968178, + 0.031080644577741623, + 0.07225465774536133 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006737728603184223 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, ultra-wide view of a futuristic metropolis at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are enormous, towering robots with sleek, vaguely humanoid forms moving through a canyon-like avenue of black glass and steel skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the robots constructed from matte black alloy with a complex network of vibrant blue and white lights tracing their frames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the robots move slowly and gracefully, creating ripples in puddles on the rain-slicked streets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a cool cyberpunk color palette of deep blue, electronic magentas, and pure white with holographic advertisements in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495057255029678 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929950475692749 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495057255029678, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495057255029678, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06911221146583557, + 0.037186045199632645, + 0.020603086799383163, + 0.44538626074790955, + 0.2870986759662628, + 0.012311169877648354, + 0.021093444898724556, + 0.025924621149897575, + 0.016437754034996033, + 0.0648466944694519 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495057255029678 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, ultra-wide view of a futuristic metropolis at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are enormous, towering robots with sleek, vaguely humanoid forms moving through a canyon-like avenue of black glass and steel skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the robots constructed from matte black alloy with a complex network of vibrant blue and white lights tracing their frames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the robots move slowly and gracefully, creating ripples in puddles on the rain-slicked streets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a cool cyberpunk color palette of deep blue, electronic magentas, and pure white with holographic advertisements in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001177690108306706 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751177787780762 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001177690108306706, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001177690108306706, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2964369058609009, + 0.06119843199849129, + 0.02894853614270687, + 0.2392646074295044, + 0.10328162461519241, + 0.06716939806938171, + 0.08281270414590836, + 0.027651295065879822, + 0.05369594693183899, + 0.039540525525808334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001177690108306706 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle, ultra-wide shot captures a sprawling futuristic metropolis at night, its rain-slicked streets like a dark mirror reflecting the spectacle unfolding below. A fleet of enormous, towering robots slowly and gracefully winds its way through a canyon-like avenue formed by massive black glass and steel skyscrapers. Their sleek, vaguely humanoid forms are constructed from matte black alloy that absorbs ambient light. Yet, their entire frames are traced by a complex network of vibrant blue and white lights that rhythmically pulsate, illuminating their path and casting long, shifting shadows. Each massive step descends with silent, ponderous weight, creating noticeable ripples in the puddles of water on the asphalt. The damp ground perfectly reflects the robots' lighting and the ever-changing colors of the city's towering holographic advertisements, which flicker silently in the background. The scene is immersed in a cool cyberpunk color palette of deep blue, electronic magentas, and pure white, creating an atmosphere of silent, awe-inspiring grandeur and technological mystery.", + "seed": 18009, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_7/index_9727_seed_18009_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.18331003626808523, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18331003626808523, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.974999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18331003626808523, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, ultra-wide view of a futuristic metropolis at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are enormous, towering robots with sleek, vaguely humanoid forms moving through a canyon-like avenue of black glass and steel skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the robots constructed from matte black alloy with a complex network of vibrant blue and white lights tracing their frames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the robots move slowly and gracefully, creating ripples in puddles on the rain-slicked streets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a cool cyberpunk color palette of deep blue, electronic magentas, and pure white with holographic advertisements in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5258768200874329 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9008768200874329 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5258768200874329, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5258768200874329, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2467900514602661, + 0.0369844026863575, + 0.06281186640262604, + 0.04142407700419426, + 0.18087507784366608, + 0.06218450516462326, + 0.1160924881696701, + 0.10212761908769608, + 0.09257859736680984, + 0.05813129246234894 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5258768200874329 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, ultra-wide view of a futuristic metropolis at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are enormous, towering robots with sleek, vaguely humanoid forms moving through a canyon-like avenue of black glass and steel skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the robots constructed from matte black alloy with a complex network of vibrant blue and white lights tracing their frames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the robots move slowly and gracefully, creating ripples in puddles on the rain-slicked streets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a cool cyberpunk color palette of deep blue, electronic magentas, and pure white with holographic advertisements in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02060753107070923 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956074714660645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02060753107070923, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02060753107070923, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21546542644500732, + 0.04099682345986366, + 0.0555809885263443, + 0.047857318073511124, + 0.34570834040641785, + 0.04277517646551132, + 0.023379605263471603, + 0.08392886072397232, + 0.08120609074831009, + 0.06310135871171951 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02060753107070923 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, ultra-wide view of a futuristic metropolis at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are enormous, towering robots with sleek, vaguely humanoid forms moving through a canyon-like avenue of black glass and steel skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the robots constructed from matte black alloy with a complex network of vibrant blue and white lights tracing their frames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the robots move slowly and gracefully, creating ripples in puddles on the rain-slicked streets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a cool cyberpunk color palette of deep blue, electronic magentas, and pure white with holographic advertisements in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018188709393143654 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0181884765625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018188709393143654, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018188709393143654, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4716957211494446, + 0.068247489631176, + 0.02718324027955532, + 0.01923016645014286, + 0.18210847675800323, + 0.014416281133890152, + 0.06385690718889236, + 0.07172784954309464, + 0.03912115842103958, + 0.04241269826889038 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018188709393143654 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, ultra-wide view of a futuristic metropolis at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are enormous, towering robots with sleek, vaguely humanoid forms moving through a canyon-like avenue of black glass and steel skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the robots constructed from matte black alloy with a complex network of vibrant blue and white lights tracing their frames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the robots move slowly and gracefully, creating ripples in puddles on the rain-slicked streets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a cool cyberpunk color palette of deep blue, electronic magentas, and pure white with holographic advertisements in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34868550300598145 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236855030059814 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34868550300598145, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34868550300598145, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09672629833221436, + 0.04550774767994881, + 0.042341940104961395, + 0.035801369696855545, + 0.5163186192512512, + 0.033329691737890244, + 0.0531206838786602, + 0.09301573783159256, + 0.049052707850933075, + 0.03478521108627319 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34868550300598145 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle, ultra-wide view of a futuristic metropolis at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are enormous, towering robots with sleek, vaguely humanoid forms moving through a canyon-like avenue of black glass and steel skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the robots constructed from matte black alloy with a complex network of vibrant blue and white lights tracing their frames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the robots move slowly and gracefully, creating ripples in puddles on the rain-slicked streets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a cool cyberpunk color palette of deep blue, electronic magentas, and pure white with holographic advertisements in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031916177831590176 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531914710998535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031916177831590176, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031916177831590176, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2333301454782486, + 0.04177489131689072, + 0.05479634553194046, + 0.034109726548194885, + 0.3152923583984375, + 0.04053753986954689, + 0.09930645674467087, + 0.11288098245859146, + 0.04063002020120621, + 0.027341583743691444 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031916177831590176 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_8/index_tensor([5029, 5029])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_8/index_tensor([5029, 5029])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..16d0cb269469bcc774b70d1fa3cb9284a9be2b4a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_8/index_tensor([5029, 5029])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium-long shot, richly hand-painted in a watercolor style, captures a small, iron-hulled, rifle-powered boat sailing across the vast, tranquil Weishan Lake from a slightly sideways, horizontal angle. The boat's hull is a weathered, dark gray-green, speckled with rust along its edges and seams, reflecting a dull metallic sheen under the soft, diffuse light. With a long, slightly hoarse whistle, the boat begins to steadily decelerate. The V-shaped white waves previously stirred up by the bow gradually soften, transforming into delicate ripples that spread outward. At this point, the entire frame is accompanied by a slight flicker, like that of old film, as the camera begins a slow and precise shift in focus: in the foreground, the crystal-clear ripples on the water gradually lose focus, becoming blurred and dreamy, while the camera's focus steadily shifts backward, finally settling sharply on an old flag at the stern, gently fluttering in the breeze. The bright red color of the flag has faded, revealing a dull ochre color. The edges are worn and tattered, with fine tassel-like lines. Against the backdrop of the gray-blue lake and sky, it creates a tranquil, nostalgic and slightly melancholic poetic atmosphere, like a moving ink painting carrying the memories of the years.", + "seed": 1739, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_8/index_5029_seed_1739_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.22186046056449413, + "vlm_logprob": -0.22186046056449413, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.22186046056449413, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a small, iron-hulled, rifle-powered boat sailing on Weishan Lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's hull dark gray-green with visible rust speckles and a dull metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat steadily decelerate while the V-shaped waves soften into delicate ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus shift from blurred foreground ripples to a sharp focus on an old, faded red flag at the stern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video accompanied by a slight flicker resembling old film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9177172183990479 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5427172183990479 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9177172183990479, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9177172183990479, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5263134241104126, + 0.04145614430308342, + 0.053293514996767044, + 0.03700806945562363, + 0.06195105239748955, + 0.059324245899915695, + 0.036824747920036316, + 0.03397471457719803, + 0.1053970605134964, + 0.044456999748945236 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9177172183990479 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a small, iron-hulled, rifle-powered boat sailing on Weishan Lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's hull dark gray-green with visible rust speckles and a dull metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat steadily decelerate while the V-shaped waves soften into delicate ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus shift from blurred foreground ripples to a sharp focus on an old, faded red flag at the stern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video accompanied by a slight flicker resembling old film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020606597885489464 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895606517791748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020606597885489464, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020606597885489464, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3783217966556549, + 0.15754209458827972, + 0.07080508023500443, + 0.040683895349502563, + 0.056360773742198944, + 0.04602427780628204, + 0.08176777511835098, + 0.061219360679388046, + 0.0746210590004921, + 0.03265383094549179 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020606597885489464 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a small, iron-hulled, rifle-powered boat sailing on Weishan Lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's hull dark gray-green with visible rust speckles and a dull metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat steadily decelerate while the V-shaped waves soften into delicate ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus shift from blurred foreground ripples to a sharp focus on an old, faded red flag at the stern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video accompanied by a slight flicker resembling old film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204469874501228 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812044620513916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204469874501228, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204469874501228, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09873127937316895, + 0.12285848706960678, + 0.0575743205845356, + 0.12252074480056763, + 0.09335517883300781, + 0.04306995868682861, + 0.1149824857711792, + 0.12388486415147781, + 0.1543876826763153, + 0.06863497197628021 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204469874501228 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a small, iron-hulled, rifle-powered boat sailing on Weishan Lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's hull dark gray-green with visible rust speckles and a dull metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat steadily decelerate while the V-shaped waves soften into delicate ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus shift from blurred foreground ripples to a sharp focus on an old, faded red flag at the stern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video accompanied by a slight flicker resembling old film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008637804538011551 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75863790512085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008637804538011551, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008637804538011551, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10582628846168518, + 0.052451349794864655, + 0.025319430977106094, + 0.30741146206855774, + 0.0667676329612732, + 0.0269535630941391, + 0.1691056489944458, + 0.12314388155937195, + 0.03938596323132515, + 0.08363481611013412 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008637804538011551 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a small, iron-hulled, rifle-powered boat sailing on Weishan Lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's hull dark gray-green with visible rust speckles and a dull metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat steadily decelerate while the V-shaped waves soften into delicate ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus shift from blurred foreground ripples to a sharp focus on an old, faded red flag at the stern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video accompanied by a slight flicker resembling old film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10029598325490952 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3502960205078125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10029598325490952, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10029598325490952, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12771134078502655, + 0.24827629327774048, + 0.10763899236917496, + 0.13058313727378845, + 0.13723064959049225, + 0.06326854974031448, + 0.04698020592331886, + 0.039377883076667786, + 0.045188840478658676, + 0.05374413728713989 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10029598325490952 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium-long shot, richly hand-painted in a watercolor style, captures a small, iron-hulled, rifle-powered boat sailing across the vast, tranquil Weishan Lake from a slightly sideways, horizontal angle. The boat's hull is a weathered, dark gray-green, speckled with rust along its edges and seams, reflecting a dull metallic sheen under the soft, diffuse light. With a long, slightly hoarse whistle, the boat begins to steadily decelerate. The V-shaped white waves previously stirred up by the bow gradually soften, transforming into delicate ripples that spread outward. At this point, the entire frame is accompanied by a slight flicker, like that of old film, as the camera begins a slow and precise shift in focus: in the foreground, the crystal-clear ripples on the water gradually lose focus, becoming blurred and dreamy, while the camera's focus steadily shifts backward, finally settling sharply on an old flag at the stern, gently fluttering in the breeze. The bright red color of the flag has faded, revealing a dull ochre color. The edges are worn and tattered, with fine tassel-like lines. Against the backdrop of the gray-blue lake and sky, it creates a tranquil, nostalgic and slightly melancholic poetic atmosphere, like a moving ink painting carrying the memories of the years.", + "seed": 1740, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_8/index_5029_seed_1740_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.18551923837512732, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18551923837512732, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18551923837512732, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a small, iron-hulled, rifle-powered boat sailing on Weishan Lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's hull dark gray-green with visible rust speckles and a dull metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat steadily decelerate while the V-shaped waves soften into delicate ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus shift from blurred foreground ripples to a sharp focus on an old, faded red flag at the stern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video accompanied by a slight flicker resembling old film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.659398078918457 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.784398078918457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.659398078918457, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.659398078918457, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0651596263051033, + 0.20496276021003723, + 0.05282355472445488, + 0.04549189656972885, + 0.0452493354678154, + 0.17848140001296997, + 0.02700372412800789, + 0.2708596885204315, + 0.03550237417221069, + 0.07446566224098206 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.659398078918457 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a small, iron-hulled, rifle-powered boat sailing on Weishan Lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's hull dark gray-green with visible rust speckles and a dull metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat steadily decelerate while the V-shaped waves soften into delicate ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus shift from blurred foreground ripples to a sharp focus on an old, faded red flag at the stern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video accompanied by a slight flicker resembling old film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029846571385860443 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529846668243408 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029846571385860443, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029846571385860443, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12557260692119598, + 0.17144149541854858, + 0.04173771291971207, + 0.04670420661568642, + 0.08600209653377533, + 0.22485816478729248, + 0.1113499104976654, + 0.08506324142217636, + 0.06263219565153122, + 0.04463838413357735 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029846571385860443 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a small, iron-hulled, rifle-powered boat sailing on Weishan Lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's hull dark gray-green with visible rust speckles and a dull metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat steadily decelerate while the V-shaped waves soften into delicate ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus shift from blurred foreground ripples to a sharp focus on an old, faded red flag at the stern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video accompanied by a slight flicker resembling old film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867226630449295 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486721992492676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867226630449295, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867226630449295, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04624107852578163, + 0.048135265707969666, + 0.07613149285316467, + 0.06546492874622345, + 0.016678962856531143, + 0.2027566134929657, + 0.3498281240463257, + 0.05501965060830116, + 0.06170398369431496, + 0.07803986221551895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867226630449295 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a small, iron-hulled, rifle-powered boat sailing on Weishan Lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's hull dark gray-green with visible rust speckles and a dull metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat steadily decelerate while the V-shaped waves soften into delicate ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus shift from blurred foreground ripples to a sharp focus on an old, faded red flag at the stern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video accompanied by a slight flicker resembling old film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009783650748431683 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634783744812012 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009783650748431683, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009783650748431683, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09192254394292831, + 0.054932452738285065, + 0.04869816452264786, + 0.055060580372810364, + 0.044194143265485764, + 0.05005815252661705, + 0.13746806979179382, + 0.265456885099411, + 0.14783889055252075, + 0.10437007248401642 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009783650748431683 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a small, iron-hulled, rifle-powered boat sailing on Weishan Lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's hull dark gray-green with visible rust speckles and a dull metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat steadily decelerate while the V-shaped waves soften into delicate ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus shift from blurred foreground ripples to a sharp focus on an old, faded red flag at the stern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video accompanied by a slight flicker resembling old film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17989562451839447 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048956394195557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17989562451839447, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17989562451839447, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0393940694630146, + 0.5905711650848389, + 0.030187934637069702, + 0.01985727995634079, + 0.0160524919629097, + 0.018996374681591988, + 0.041429050266742706, + 0.12845219671726227, + 0.046284835785627365, + 0.06877455860376358 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17989562451839447 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium-long shot, richly hand-painted in a watercolor style, captures a small, iron-hulled, rifle-powered boat sailing across the vast, tranquil Weishan Lake from a slightly sideways, horizontal angle. The boat's hull is a weathered, dark gray-green, speckled with rust along its edges and seams, reflecting a dull metallic sheen under the soft, diffuse light. With a long, slightly hoarse whistle, the boat begins to steadily decelerate. The V-shaped white waves previously stirred up by the bow gradually soften, transforming into delicate ripples that spread outward. At this point, the entire frame is accompanied by a slight flicker, like that of old film, as the camera begins a slow and precise shift in focus: in the foreground, the crystal-clear ripples on the water gradually lose focus, becoming blurred and dreamy, while the camera's focus steadily shifts backward, finally settling sharply on an old flag at the stern, gently fluttering in the breeze. The bright red color of the flag has faded, revealing a dull ochre color. The edges are worn and tattered, with fine tassel-like lines. Against the backdrop of the gray-blue lake and sky, it creates a tranquil, nostalgic and slightly melancholic poetic atmosphere, like a moving ink painting carrying the memories of the years.", + "seed": 1741, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_8/index_5029_seed_1741_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.18615390183404087, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18615390183404087, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18615390183404087, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a small, iron-hulled, rifle-powered boat sailing on Weishan Lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's hull dark gray-green with visible rust speckles and a dull metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat steadily decelerate while the V-shaped waves soften into delicate ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus shift from blurred foreground ripples to a sharp focus on an old, faded red flag at the stern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video accompanied by a slight flicker resembling old film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.77858567237854 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.65358567237854 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.77858567237854, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.77858567237854, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1441309005022049, + 0.07858231663703918, + 0.04460940510034561, + 0.10546806454658508, + 0.22682146728038788, + 0.032753508538007736, + 0.021889785304665565, + 0.023337479680776596, + 0.0966121032834053, + 0.2257949709892273 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.77858567237854 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a small, iron-hulled, rifle-powered boat sailing on Weishan Lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's hull dark gray-green with visible rust speckles and a dull metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat steadily decelerate while the V-shaped waves soften into delicate ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus shift from blurred foreground ripples to a sharp focus on an old, faded red flag at the stern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video accompanied by a slight flicker resembling old film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0381363146007061 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881362438201904 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0381363146007061, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0381363146007061, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1736978441476822, + 0.15475793182849884, + 0.05080036446452141, + 0.1279650628566742, + 0.27037304639816284, + 0.021318519487977028, + 0.010502206161618233, + 0.02674461156129837, + 0.0862920805811882, + 0.07754838466644287 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0381363146007061 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a small, iron-hulled, rifle-powered boat sailing on Weishan Lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's hull dark gray-green with visible rust speckles and a dull metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat steadily decelerate while the V-shaped waves soften into delicate ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus shift from blurred foreground ripples to a sharp focus on an old, faded red flag at the stern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video accompanied by a slight flicker resembling old film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029813479632139206 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529813528060913 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029813479632139206, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029813479632139206, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2749338746070862, + 0.04334263503551483, + 0.14549700915813446, + 0.056835856288671494, + 0.20359773933887482, + 0.027066804468631744, + 0.041200459003448486, + 0.02445092797279358, + 0.08461952209472656, + 0.09845513105392456 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029813479632139206 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a small, iron-hulled, rifle-powered boat sailing on Weishan Lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's hull dark gray-green with visible rust speckles and a dull metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat steadily decelerate while the V-shaped waves soften into delicate ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus shift from blurred foreground ripples to a sharp focus on an old, faded red flag at the stern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video accompanied by a slight flicker resembling old film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005254624877125025 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255254745483398 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005254624877125025, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005254624877125025, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11141356080770493, + 0.0373121052980423, + 0.05683101341128349, + 0.06213241070508957, + 0.2740517854690552, + 0.04315561801195145, + 0.033512040972709656, + 0.08009304106235504, + 0.08655931800603867, + 0.21493905782699585 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005254624877125025 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a small, iron-hulled, rifle-powered boat sailing on Weishan Lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's hull dark gray-green with visible rust speckles and a dull metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat steadily decelerate while the V-shaped waves soften into delicate ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus shift from blurred foreground ripples to a sharp focus on an old, faded red flag at the stern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video accompanied by a slight flicker resembling old film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897941768169403 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789794921875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897941768169403, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897941768169403, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12027042359113693, + 0.025270506739616394, + 0.043902263045310974, + 0.02240707166492939, + 0.29946693778038025, + 0.12687595188617706, + 0.028077689930796623, + 0.02199113368988037, + 0.20080894231796265, + 0.11092911660671234 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897941768169403 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium-long shot, richly hand-painted in a watercolor style, captures a small, iron-hulled, rifle-powered boat sailing across the vast, tranquil Weishan Lake from a slightly sideways, horizontal angle. The boat's hull is a weathered, dark gray-green, speckled with rust along its edges and seams, reflecting a dull metallic sheen under the soft, diffuse light. With a long, slightly hoarse whistle, the boat begins to steadily decelerate. The V-shaped white waves previously stirred up by the bow gradually soften, transforming into delicate ripples that spread outward. At this point, the entire frame is accompanied by a slight flicker, like that of old film, as the camera begins a slow and precise shift in focus: in the foreground, the crystal-clear ripples on the water gradually lose focus, becoming blurred and dreamy, while the camera's focus steadily shifts backward, finally settling sharply on an old flag at the stern, gently fluttering in the breeze. The bright red color of the flag has faded, revealing a dull ochre color. The edges are worn and tattered, with fine tassel-like lines. Against the backdrop of the gray-blue lake and sky, it creates a tranquil, nostalgic and slightly melancholic poetic atmosphere, like a moving ink painting carrying the memories of the years.", + "seed": 1742, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_8/index_5029_seed_1742_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.18995456174015998, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18995456174015998, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.199999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18995456174015998, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a small, iron-hulled, rifle-powered boat sailing on Weishan Lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's hull dark gray-green with visible rust speckles and a dull metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat steadily decelerate while the V-shaped waves soften into delicate ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus shift from blurred foreground ripples to a sharp focus on an old, faded red flag at the stern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video accompanied by a slight flicker resembling old film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.656866729259491 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.781866729259491 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.656866729259491, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.656866729259491, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4401324689388275, + 0.04654166102409363, + 0.07616881281137466, + 0.04211064800620079, + 0.1490657776594162, + 0.023504363372921944, + 0.032856207340955734, + 0.05068933591246605, + 0.04659005627036095, + 0.09234064072370529 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.656866729259491 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a small, iron-hulled, rifle-powered boat sailing on Weishan Lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's hull dark gray-green with visible rust speckles and a dull metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat steadily decelerate while the V-shaped waves soften into delicate ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus shift from blurred foreground ripples to a sharp focus on an old, faded red flag at the stern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video accompanied by a slight flicker resembling old film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03374454751610756 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087445735931396 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03374454751610756, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03374454751610756, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25736159086227417, + 0.22353704273700714, + 0.0979275107383728, + 0.041992805898189545, + 0.19505825638771057, + 0.018724989145994186, + 0.0428537055850029, + 0.047643113881349564, + 0.026990439742803574, + 0.04791055619716644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03374454751610756 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a small, iron-hulled, rifle-powered boat sailing on Weishan Lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's hull dark gray-green with visible rust speckles and a dull metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat steadily decelerate while the V-shaped waves soften into delicate ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus shift from blurred foreground ripples to a sharp focus on an old, faded red flag at the stern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video accompanied by a slight flicker resembling old film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308098554611206 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168081045150757 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308098554611206, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308098554611206, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3259402811527252, + 0.04129711166024208, + 0.042659685015678406, + 0.1388474553823471, + 0.17014238238334656, + 0.09473711997270584, + 0.02031806856393814, + 0.0570087768137455, + 0.05889616534113884, + 0.05015287920832634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308098554611206 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a small, iron-hulled, rifle-powered boat sailing on Weishan Lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's hull dark gray-green with visible rust speckles and a dull metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat steadily decelerate while the V-shaped waves soften into delicate ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus shift from blurred foreground ripples to a sharp focus on an old, faded red flag at the stern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video accompanied by a slight flicker resembling old film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270335614681244 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270334720611572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270335614681244, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270335614681244, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5205778479576111, + 0.05625080317258835, + 0.06905950605869293, + 0.022431500256061554, + 0.1057901456952095, + 0.05979641154408455, + 0.044316209852695465, + 0.0323183499276638, + 0.025117024779319763, + 0.06434223055839539 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270335614681244 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a small, iron-hulled, rifle-powered boat sailing on Weishan Lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boat's hull dark gray-green with visible rust speckles and a dull metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the boat steadily decelerate while the V-shaped waves soften into delicate ripples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus shift from blurred foreground ripples to a sharp focus on an old, faded red flag at the stern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video accompanied by a slight flicker resembling old film?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08904698491096497 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640469551086426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08904698491096497, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08904698491096497, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5104307532310486, + 0.05501970648765564, + 0.06795840710401535, + 0.04182315990328789, + 0.15652212500572205, + 0.025254392996430397, + 0.034462034702301025, + 0.022987468168139458, + 0.0395231768488884, + 0.04601879045367241 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08904698491096497 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_9/index_tensor([3875, 3875])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_9/index_tensor([3875, 3875])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3f6b15c7c068b39a692aaaeee4e87c24ffa64f32 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_9/index_tensor([3875, 3875])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "seamless 360-degree tracking close-up unfolds smoothly around a curious sparrow perched on a weathered, ancient stone wall. The sparrow, small and plump, with feathers a complex interweaving of earthy browns, soft grays, and sharp black stripes, tilts its head from time to time, its dark, shiny eyes gleaming with inquiry. The wall it stands on is itself a tapestry of natural textures, composed of irregularly shaped stones. Vast swathes of vibrant green and deep emerald moss cling tenaciously to the rough surface, while clumps of delicate ferns sprout from the damp crevices. Steadying itself on its delicate legs and claws, the sparrow executes a series of quick, light hops along the wall's uneven top, pausing intermittently to delicately peck at a patch of moss with its tiny beak or peer curiously into a deep crevice between the stones, completely absorbed in its exploration. As the camera continues to rotate smoothly, soft, diffused sunlight is evenly distributed across the entire scene, constantly revealing new angles and microscopic details of the stones and moss, creating a dynamic yet tranquil background. The entire image is filled with a peaceful, natural atmosphere, capturing an intimate and fascinating moment of pure beauty and curiosity in nature.", + "seed": 11714, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_9/index_3875_seed_11714_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.12612534323707222, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12612534323707222, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12612534323707222, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a small, plump sparrow with earthy brown, soft gray, and black striped feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sparrow perched on and hopping along a weathered, ancient stone wall composed of irregularly shaped stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone wall and crevices covered with vibrant green and deep emerald moss and delicate ferns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sparrow perform actions such as tilting its head, hopping, pecking at moss, and peering into crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth 360-degree tracking rotation around the sparrow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.039255980402231216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2892560958862305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.039255980402231216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.039255980402231216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08148407191038132, + 0.20542708039283752, + 0.0240046214312315, + 0.07979846745729446, + 0.0369025394320488, + 0.02942291833460331, + 0.03741684928536415, + 0.03661392256617546, + 0.34700730443000793, + 0.12192220985889435 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.039255980402231216 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a small, plump sparrow with earthy brown, soft gray, and black striped feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sparrow perched on and hopping along a weathered, ancient stone wall composed of irregularly shaped stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone wall and crevices covered with vibrant green and deep emerald moss and delicate ferns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sparrow perform actions such as tilting its head, hopping, pecking at moss, and peering into crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth 360-degree tracking rotation around the sparrow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005953199230134487 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130953311920166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005953199230134487, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005953199230134487, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06321021914482117, + 0.06355391442775726, + 0.026649268344044685, + 0.040067728608846664, + 0.01635655388236046, + 0.02441531978547573, + 0.04169374331831932, + 0.03467591479420662, + 0.6404070854187012, + 0.04897022247314453 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005953199230134487 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a small, plump sparrow with earthy brown, soft gray, and black striped feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sparrow perched on and hopping along a weathered, ancient stone wall composed of irregularly shaped stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone wall and crevices covered with vibrant green and deep emerald moss and delicate ferns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sparrow perform actions such as tilting its head, hopping, pecking at moss, and peering into crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth 360-degree tracking rotation around the sparrow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004095975775271654 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504096031188965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004095975775271654, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004095975775271654, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09617920964956284, + 0.10238106548786163, + 0.12319611757993698, + 0.23183776438236237, + 0.06141108274459839, + 0.08427949249744415, + 0.03150662034749985, + 0.07424947619438171, + 0.14838680624961853, + 0.046572376042604446 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004095975775271654 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a small, plump sparrow with earthy brown, soft gray, and black striped feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sparrow perched on and hopping along a weathered, ancient stone wall composed of irregularly shaped stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone wall and crevices covered with vibrant green and deep emerald moss and delicate ferns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sparrow perform actions such as tilting its head, hopping, pecking at moss, and peering into crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth 360-degree tracking rotation around the sparrow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005249881185591221 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255249977111816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005249881185591221, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005249881185591221, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09088105708360672, + 0.13315433263778687, + 0.059873055666685104, + 0.08512596786022186, + 0.10598589479923248, + 0.03635531663894653, + 0.04878884553909302, + 0.06217518448829651, + 0.3212786912918091, + 0.0563817098736763 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005249881185591221 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a small, plump sparrow with earthy brown, soft gray, and black striped feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sparrow perched on and hopping along a weathered, ancient stone wall composed of irregularly shaped stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone wall and crevices covered with vibrant green and deep emerald moss and delicate ferns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sparrow perform actions such as tilting its head, hopping, pecking at moss, and peering into crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth 360-degree tracking rotation around the sparrow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5760716795921326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8260716795921326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5760716795921326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5760716795921326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17154325544834137, + 0.11650257557630539, + 0.07985735684633255, + 0.07116270810365677, + 0.08504407852888107, + 0.09790389984846115, + 0.029763812199234962, + 0.08822232484817505, + 0.21786409616470337, + 0.04213591292500496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5760716795921326 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "seamless 360-degree tracking close-up unfolds smoothly around a curious sparrow perched on a weathered, ancient stone wall. The sparrow, small and plump, with feathers a complex interweaving of earthy browns, soft grays, and sharp black stripes, tilts its head from time to time, its dark, shiny eyes gleaming with inquiry. The wall it stands on is itself a tapestry of natural textures, composed of irregularly shaped stones. Vast swathes of vibrant green and deep emerald moss cling tenaciously to the rough surface, while clumps of delicate ferns sprout from the damp crevices. Steadying itself on its delicate legs and claws, the sparrow executes a series of quick, light hops along the wall's uneven top, pausing intermittently to delicately peck at a patch of moss with its tiny beak or peer curiously into a deep crevice between the stones, completely absorbed in its exploration. As the camera continues to rotate smoothly, soft, diffused sunlight is evenly distributed across the entire scene, constantly revealing new angles and microscopic details of the stones and moss, creating a dynamic yet tranquil background. The entire image is filled with a peaceful, natural atmosphere, capturing an intimate and fascinating moment of pure beauty and curiosity in nature.", + "seed": 11715, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_9/index_3875_seed_11715_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.19214149322360755, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19214149322360755, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19214149322360755, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a small, plump sparrow with earthy brown, soft gray, and black striped feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sparrow perched on and hopping along a weathered, ancient stone wall composed of irregularly shaped stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone wall and crevices covered with vibrant green and deep emerald moss and delicate ferns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sparrow perform actions such as tilting its head, hopping, pecking at moss, and peering into crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth 360-degree tracking rotation around the sparrow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043760139495134354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168760061264038 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043760139495134354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043760139495134354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4241567850112915, + 0.2072950154542923, + 0.01600242406129837, + 0.10310530662536621, + 0.04542049393057823, + 0.11946212500333786, + 0.018445134162902832, + 0.017510829493403435, + 0.016773253679275513, + 0.03182860091328621 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043760139495134354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a small, plump sparrow with earthy brown, soft gray, and black striped feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sparrow perched on and hopping along a weathered, ancient stone wall composed of irregularly shaped stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone wall and crevices covered with vibrant green and deep emerald moss and delicate ferns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sparrow perform actions such as tilting its head, hopping, pecking at moss, and peering into crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth 360-degree tracking rotation around the sparrow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008644422516226768 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586445808410645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008644422516226768, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008644422516226768, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32470378279685974, + 0.11752655357122421, + 0.030895963311195374, + 0.14446112513542175, + 0.13455571234226227, + 0.05291054770350456, + 0.02750622108578682, + 0.052118971943855286, + 0.02726215496659279, + 0.08805891126394272 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008644422516226768 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a small, plump sparrow with earthy brown, soft gray, and black striped feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sparrow perched on and hopping along a weathered, ancient stone wall composed of irregularly shaped stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone wall and crevices covered with vibrant green and deep emerald moss and delicate ferns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sparrow perform actions such as tilting its head, hopping, pecking at moss, and peering into crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth 360-degree tracking rotation around the sparrow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004096094518899918 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504096031188965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004096094518899918, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004096094518899918, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21721838414669037, + 0.22550727427005768, + 0.1499282866716385, + 0.11035017669200897, + 0.05835110321640968, + 0.047388333827257156, + 0.01782367005944252, + 0.04105362296104431, + 0.070775605738163, + 0.06160353124141693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004096094518899918 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a small, plump sparrow with earthy brown, soft gray, and black striped feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sparrow perched on and hopping along a weathered, ancient stone wall composed of irregularly shaped stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone wall and crevices covered with vibrant green and deep emerald moss and delicate ferns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sparrow perform actions such as tilting its head, hopping, pecking at moss, and peering into crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth 360-degree tracking rotation around the sparrow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005944785661995411 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130944728851318 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005944785661995411, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005944785661995411, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23382927477359772, + 0.18508794903755188, + 0.038230761885643005, + 0.08321604877710342, + 0.1577516496181488, + 0.051758553832769394, + 0.03367382287979126, + 0.0712459459900856, + 0.09405278414487839, + 0.051153138279914856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005944785661995411 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a small, plump sparrow with earthy brown, soft gray, and black striped feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sparrow perched on and hopping along a weathered, ancient stone wall composed of irregularly shaped stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone wall and crevices covered with vibrant green and deep emerald moss and delicate ferns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sparrow perform actions such as tilting its head, hopping, pecking at moss, and peering into crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth 360-degree tracking rotation around the sparrow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8982620239257812 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5232620239257812 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8982620239257812, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8982620239257812, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07628224045038223, + 0.03995034098625183, + 0.041975636035203934, + 0.052990254014730453, + 0.21090799570083618, + 0.08262371271848679, + 0.07578285783529282, + 0.09153975546360016, + 0.21774514019489288, + 0.11020203679800034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8982620239257812 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "seamless 360-degree tracking close-up unfolds smoothly around a curious sparrow perched on a weathered, ancient stone wall. The sparrow, small and plump, with feathers a complex interweaving of earthy browns, soft grays, and sharp black stripes, tilts its head from time to time, its dark, shiny eyes gleaming with inquiry. The wall it stands on is itself a tapestry of natural textures, composed of irregularly shaped stones. Vast swathes of vibrant green and deep emerald moss cling tenaciously to the rough surface, while clumps of delicate ferns sprout from the damp crevices. Steadying itself on its delicate legs and claws, the sparrow executes a series of quick, light hops along the wall's uneven top, pausing intermittently to delicately peck at a patch of moss with its tiny beak or peer curiously into a deep crevice between the stones, completely absorbed in its exploration. As the camera continues to rotate smoothly, soft, diffused sunlight is evenly distributed across the entire scene, constantly revealing new angles and microscopic details of the stones and moss, creating a dynamic yet tranquil background. The entire image is filled with a peaceful, natural atmosphere, capturing an intimate and fascinating moment of pure beauty and curiosity in nature.", + "seed": 11716, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_9/index_3875_seed_11716_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.21788405608385802, + "vlm_logprob": -0.21788405608385802, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.21788405608385802, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a small, plump sparrow with earthy brown, soft gray, and black striped feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sparrow perched on and hopping along a weathered, ancient stone wall composed of irregularly shaped stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone wall and crevices covered with vibrant green and deep emerald moss and delicate ferns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sparrow perform actions such as tilting its head, hopping, pecking at moss, and peering into crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth 360-degree tracking rotation around the sparrow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013715313747525215 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3887152671813965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013715313747525215, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013715313747525215, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2992434501647949, + 0.08573009073734283, + 0.062598317861557, + 0.03545517101883888, + 0.01884574070572853, + 0.019849663600325584, + 0.08237668871879578, + 0.19622080028057098, + 0.03462371230125427, + 0.16505642235279083 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013715313747525215 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a small, plump sparrow with earthy brown, soft gray, and black striped feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sparrow perched on and hopping along a weathered, ancient stone wall composed of irregularly shaped stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone wall and crevices covered with vibrant green and deep emerald moss and delicate ferns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sparrow perform actions such as tilting its head, hopping, pecking at moss, and peering into crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth 360-degree tracking rotation around the sparrow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012541946023702621 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387541770935059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012541946023702621, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012541946023702621, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12086580693721771, + 0.07532725483179092, + 0.11871945858001709, + 0.12232540547847748, + 0.021110275760293007, + 0.01987813413143158, + 0.06436603516340256, + 0.15550266206264496, + 0.21654614806175232, + 0.08535882085561752 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012541946023702621 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a small, plump sparrow with earthy brown, soft gray, and black striped feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sparrow perched on and hopping along a weathered, ancient stone wall composed of irregularly shaped stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone wall and crevices covered with vibrant green and deep emerald moss and delicate ferns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sparrow perform actions such as tilting its head, hopping, pecking at moss, and peering into crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth 360-degree tracking rotation around the sparrow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040955008007586 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504095554351807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040955008007586, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040955008007586, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10727430880069733, + 0.03192155808210373, + 0.045500483363866806, + 0.05849196016788483, + 0.015470167621970177, + 0.017563391476869583, + 0.04830264300107956, + 0.5534879565238953, + 0.05598699674010277, + 0.06600049138069153 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040955008007586 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a small, plump sparrow with earthy brown, soft gray, and black striped feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sparrow perched on and hopping along a weathered, ancient stone wall composed of irregularly shaped stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone wall and crevices covered with vibrant green and deep emerald moss and delicate ferns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sparrow perform actions such as tilting its head, hopping, pecking at moss, and peering into crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth 360-degree tracking rotation around the sparrow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005248221103101969 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255248069763184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005248221103101969, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005248221103101969, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.056121934205293655, + 0.06021623685956001, + 0.05977870151400566, + 0.05810392275452614, + 0.03304111212491989, + 0.019352924078702927, + 0.06071288883686066, + 0.42296531796455383, + 0.054633449763059616, + 0.17507342994213104 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005248221103101969 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a small, plump sparrow with earthy brown, soft gray, and black striped feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sparrow perched on and hopping along a weathered, ancient stone wall composed of irregularly shaped stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone wall and crevices covered with vibrant green and deep emerald moss and delicate ferns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sparrow perform actions such as tilting its head, hopping, pecking at moss, and peering into crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth 360-degree tracking rotation around the sparrow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0538192987442017 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42881929874420166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0538192987442017, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0538192987442017, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04187029227614403, + 0.08956126123666763, + 0.06928814202547073, + 0.09909076243638992, + 0.031778484582901, + 0.03303098678588867, + 0.04290125519037247, + 0.502103865146637, + 0.06609109789133072, + 0.024283912032842636 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0538192987442017 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "seamless 360-degree tracking close-up unfolds smoothly around a curious sparrow perched on a weathered, ancient stone wall. The sparrow, small and plump, with feathers a complex interweaving of earthy browns, soft grays, and sharp black stripes, tilts its head from time to time, its dark, shiny eyes gleaming with inquiry. The wall it stands on is itself a tapestry of natural textures, composed of irregularly shaped stones. Vast swathes of vibrant green and deep emerald moss cling tenaciously to the rough surface, while clumps of delicate ferns sprout from the damp crevices. Steadying itself on its delicate legs and claws, the sparrow executes a series of quick, light hops along the wall's uneven top, pausing intermittently to delicately peck at a patch of moss with its tiny beak or peer curiously into a deep crevice between the stones, completely absorbed in its exploration. As the camera continues to rotate smoothly, soft, diffused sunlight is evenly distributed across the entire scene, constantly revealing new angles and microscopic details of the stones and moss, creating a dynamic yet tranquil background. The entire image is filled with a peaceful, natural atmosphere, capturing an intimate and fascinating moment of pure beauty and curiosity in nature.", + "seed": 11717, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000078/group_9/index_3875_seed_11717_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.20948238391429186, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20948238391429186, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.074999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20948238391429186, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a small, plump sparrow with earthy brown, soft gray, and black striped feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sparrow perched on and hopping along a weathered, ancient stone wall composed of irregularly shaped stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone wall and crevices covered with vibrant green and deep emerald moss and delicate ferns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sparrow perform actions such as tilting its head, hopping, pecking at moss, and peering into crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth 360-degree tracking rotation around the sparrow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6341994404792786 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7591994404792786 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6341994404792786, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6341994404792786, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15790516138076782, + 0.22609272599220276, + 0.048697520047426224, + 0.0480300597846508, + 0.08417157083749771, + 0.16880065202713013, + 0.08237357437610626, + 0.08612192422151566, + 0.051337409764528275, + 0.04646940529346466 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6341994404792786 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a small, plump sparrow with earthy brown, soft gray, and black striped feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sparrow perched on and hopping along a weathered, ancient stone wall composed of irregularly shaped stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone wall and crevices covered with vibrant green and deep emerald moss and delicate ferns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sparrow perform actions such as tilting its head, hopping, pecking at moss, and peering into crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth 360-degree tracking rotation around the sparrow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014203527010977268 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2642035484313965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014203527010977268, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014203527010977268, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09407724440097809, + 0.10326562076807022, + 0.027445131912827492, + 0.05516361445188522, + 0.09162505716085434, + 0.09428507834672928, + 0.1396178901195526, + 0.15192869305610657, + 0.10603944212198257, + 0.13655227422714233 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014203527010977268 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a small, plump sparrow with earthy brown, soft gray, and black striped feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sparrow perched on and hopping along a weathered, ancient stone wall composed of irregularly shaped stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone wall and crevices covered with vibrant green and deep emerald moss and delicate ferns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sparrow perform actions such as tilting its head, hopping, pecking at moss, and peering into crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth 360-degree tracking rotation around the sparrow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005255573429167271 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255255699157715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005255573429167271, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005255573429167271, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10073454678058624, + 0.11236709356307983, + 0.04067418724298477, + 0.05845772102475166, + 0.21278893947601318, + 0.1001831516623497, + 0.07840850949287415, + 0.086603082716465, + 0.13213913142681122, + 0.07764364033937454 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005255573429167271 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a small, plump sparrow with earthy brown, soft gray, and black striped feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sparrow perched on and hopping along a weathered, ancient stone wall composed of irregularly shaped stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone wall and crevices covered with vibrant green and deep emerald moss and delicate ferns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sparrow perform actions such as tilting its head, hopping, pecking at moss, and peering into crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth 360-degree tracking rotation around the sparrow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00673630740493536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067362785339355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00673630740493536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00673630740493536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11762519925832748, + 0.12284109741449356, + 0.052937719970941544, + 0.08992424607276917, + 0.07357364147901535, + 0.12005636841058731, + 0.06943938881158829, + 0.06387733668088913, + 0.22728665173053741, + 0.062438372522592545 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00673630740493536 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a small, plump sparrow with earthy brown, soft gray, and black striped feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sparrow perched on and hopping along a weathered, ancient stone wall composed of irregularly shaped stones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone wall and crevices covered with vibrant green and deep emerald moss and delicate ferns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sparrow perform actions such as tilting its head, hopping, pecking at moss, and peering into crevices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth 360-degree tracking rotation around the sparrow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38701707124710083 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137017011642456 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38701707124710083, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38701707124710083, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08786097168922424, + 0.072014719247818, + 0.040437012910842896, + 0.08096281439065933, + 0.08740424364805222, + 0.09964285790920258, + 0.04236612841486931, + 0.08389615267515182, + 0.2369948923587799, + 0.16842015087604523 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38701707124710083 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_0/index_tensor([827, 827])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_0/index_tensor([827, 827])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8d4f94478c1b52d4a1834212c67e9e1492dce7d2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_0/index_tensor([827, 827])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "fixed wide-angle shot, taken from a slightly upward angle, captures a vast, cathedral-like hall. The mirror-like, dark marble floor rises upward, illuminating the entire scene. In the center of the hall, a formidable, ancient globe, suspended in mid-air by an invisible force, its bronzed brass stand gleaming faintly in the gloom. Its surface, made of yellowed parchment, covered in tiny cracks and the marks of age, bears a faded ancient map of the world, its continental outlines blurred and place names barely discernible. With a solemn, almost imperceptible pace, it slowly rotates from west to east on its tilted axis. The only light comes from the hall's deep, domed ceiling, where a meticulously detailed galaxy is painted. A deep blue and indigo background is dotted with countless gold and silver stars, imbued with a soft, self-luminous effect. The light of this artificial starry sky flows across the curved surface of the globe and casts a dreamy reflection of it and the Milky Way on the marble floor, as if this ancient planet is slowly rotating, engaging in a silent gaze and dialogue across time and space with the eternal universe above. The entire picture is immersed in a tranquil, mysterious and eternal atmosphere of cold colors.", + "seed": 17315, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_0/index_827_seed_17315_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.12156369239091873, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12156369239091873, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.8999999880790712, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12156369239091873, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a vast, cathedral-like hall with a mirror-like dark marble floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient globe suspended in mid-air in the center of the hall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the globe have a surface made of yellowed parchment with a faded ancient map of the world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ceiling a deep dome painted with a galaxy featuring a blue and indigo background with gold and silver stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly from west to east on a tilted axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3492637276649475 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2242636680603027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3492637276649475, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8749999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3492637276649475, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32582175731658936, + 0.09707313030958176, + 0.0537618026137352, + 0.093525730073452, + 0.07127639651298523, + 0.07141987234354019, + 0.07251855731010437, + 0.056135356426239014, + 0.13639234006404877, + 0.022075027227401733 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3492637276649475 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a vast, cathedral-like hall with a mirror-like dark marble floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient globe suspended in mid-air in the center of the hall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the globe have a surface made of yellowed parchment with a faded ancient map of the world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ceiling a deep dome painted with a galaxy featuring a blue and indigo background with gold and silver stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly from west to east on a tilted axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011087002232670784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511086940765381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011087002232670784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011087002232670784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24426938593387604, + 0.08246428519487381, + 0.05907810106873512, + 0.1110791563987732, + 0.06939930468797684, + 0.14784231781959534, + 0.08474289625883102, + 0.05228037014603615, + 0.13125483691692352, + 0.017589353024959564 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011087002232670784 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a vast, cathedral-like hall with a mirror-like dark marble floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient globe suspended in mid-air in the center of the hall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the globe have a surface made of yellowed parchment with a faded ancient map of the world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ceiling a deep dome painted with a galaxy featuring a blue and indigo background with gold and silver stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly from west to east on a tilted axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607493683695793 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141075134277344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607493683695793, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607493683695793, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22695069015026093, + 0.06818655878305435, + 0.10601238161325455, + 0.0946568101644516, + 0.09331391006708145, + 0.054310284554958344, + 0.10771945863962173, + 0.10220799595117569, + 0.09381783753633499, + 0.05282409116625786 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607493683695793 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a vast, cathedral-like hall with a mirror-like dark marble floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient globe suspended in mid-air in the center of the hall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the globe have a surface made of yellowed parchment with a faded ancient map of the world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ceiling a deep dome painted with a galaxy featuring a blue and indigo background with gold and silver stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly from west to east on a tilted axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02982042171061039 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529820442199707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02982042171061039, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02982042171061039, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10934940725564957, + 0.09786936640739441, + 0.07200376689434052, + 0.08079616725444794, + 0.12953785061836243, + 0.06708390265703201, + 0.20594702661037445, + 0.1415213942527771, + 0.06975382566452026, + 0.02613731287419796 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02982042171061039 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a vast, cathedral-like hall with a mirror-like dark marble floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient globe suspended in mid-air in the center of the hall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the globe have a surface made of yellowed parchment with a faded ancient map of the world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ceiling a deep dome painted with a galaxy featuring a blue and indigo background with gold and silver stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly from west to east on a tilted axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20157237350940704 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015724182128906 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20157237350940704, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20157237350940704, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26484787464141846, + 0.06832706183195114, + 0.07234708219766617, + 0.07767050713300705, + 0.08189557492733002, + 0.05574185773730278, + 0.07385725528001785, + 0.13225369155406952, + 0.12077625095844269, + 0.05228284001350403 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20157237350940704 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "fixed wide-angle shot, taken from a slightly upward angle, captures a vast, cathedral-like hall. The mirror-like, dark marble floor rises upward, illuminating the entire scene. In the center of the hall, a formidable, ancient globe, suspended in mid-air by an invisible force, its bronzed brass stand gleaming faintly in the gloom. Its surface, made of yellowed parchment, covered in tiny cracks and the marks of age, bears a faded ancient map of the world, its continental outlines blurred and place names barely discernible. With a solemn, almost imperceptible pace, it slowly rotates from west to east on its tilted axis. The only light comes from the hall's deep, domed ceiling, where a meticulously detailed galaxy is painted. A deep blue and indigo background is dotted with countless gold and silver stars, imbued with a soft, self-luminous effect. The light of this artificial starry sky flows across the curved surface of the globe and casts a dreamy reflection of it and the Milky Way on the marble floor, as if this ancient planet is slowly rotating, engaging in a silent gaze and dialogue across time and space with the eternal universe above. The entire picture is immersed in a tranquil, mysterious and eternal atmosphere of cold colors.", + "seed": 17316, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_0/index_827_seed_17316_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.17590602627024055, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17590602627024055, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17590602627024055, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a vast, cathedral-like hall with a mirror-like dark marble floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient globe suspended in mid-air in the center of the hall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the globe have a surface made of yellowed parchment with a faded ancient map of the world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ceiling a deep dome painted with a galaxy featuring a blue and indigo background with gold and silver stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly from west to east on a tilted axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6943659782409668 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6943659782409668 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6943659782409668, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6943659782409668, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0783819928765297, + 0.06216530501842499, + 0.09693825244903564, + 0.10944613814353943, + 0.1036597490310669, + 0.11740577965974808, + 0.06747061759233475, + 0.24723494052886963, + 0.021782733500003815, + 0.09551450610160828 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6943659782409668 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a vast, cathedral-like hall with a mirror-like dark marble floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient globe suspended in mid-air in the center of the hall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the globe have a surface made of yellowed parchment with a faded ancient map of the world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ceiling a deep dome painted with a galaxy featuring a blue and indigo background with gold and silver stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly from west to east on a tilted axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005966826807707548 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130966663360596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005966826807707548, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005966826807707548, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09177974611520767, + 0.09412142634391785, + 0.14603549242019653, + 0.12922360002994537, + 0.10363742709159851, + 0.12226231396198273, + 0.08660303801298141, + 0.10371389985084534, + 0.030302751809358597, + 0.0923202633857727 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005966826807707548 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a vast, cathedral-like hall with a mirror-like dark marble floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient globe suspended in mid-air in the center of the hall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the globe have a surface made of yellowed parchment with a faded ancient map of the world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ceiling a deep dome painted with a galaxy featuring a blue and indigo background with gold and silver stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly from west to east on a tilted axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819467917084694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018194675445557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819467917084694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819467917084694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.040483493357896805, + 0.06397812068462372, + 0.04497243091464043, + 0.0396922267973423, + 0.03448242321610451, + 0.12156092375516891, + 0.037956979125738144, + 0.1618724763393402, + 0.15168459713459015, + 0.3033163547515869 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819467917084694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a vast, cathedral-like hall with a mirror-like dark marble floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient globe suspended in mid-air in the center of the hall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the globe have a surface made of yellowed parchment with a faded ancient map of the world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ceiling a deep dome painted with a galaxy featuring a blue and indigo background with gold and silver stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly from west to east on a tilted axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01820322498679161 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018203258514404 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01820322498679161, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01820322498679161, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14585328102111816, + 0.04510883241891861, + 0.06939908862113953, + 0.07653357088565826, + 0.08116239309310913, + 0.3747052848339081, + 0.03984206169843674, + 0.11114025115966797, + 0.02334793657064438, + 0.03290734812617302 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01820322498679161 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a vast, cathedral-like hall with a mirror-like dark marble floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient globe suspended in mid-air in the center of the hall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the globe have a surface made of yellowed parchment with a faded ancient map of the world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ceiling a deep dome painted with a galaxy featuring a blue and indigo background with gold and silver stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly from west to east on a tilted axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14279942214488983 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0177993774414062 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14279942214488983, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14279942214488983, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.058968182653188705, + 0.028506815433502197, + 0.09026919305324554, + 0.04098403453826904, + 0.049895938485860825, + 0.06670694798231125, + 0.02877536229789257, + 0.4582662284374237, + 0.049305543303489685, + 0.1283217817544937 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14279942214488983 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "fixed wide-angle shot, taken from a slightly upward angle, captures a vast, cathedral-like hall. The mirror-like, dark marble floor rises upward, illuminating the entire scene. In the center of the hall, a formidable, ancient globe, suspended in mid-air by an invisible force, its bronzed brass stand gleaming faintly in the gloom. Its surface, made of yellowed parchment, covered in tiny cracks and the marks of age, bears a faded ancient map of the world, its continental outlines blurred and place names barely discernible. With a solemn, almost imperceptible pace, it slowly rotates from west to east on its tilted axis. The only light comes from the hall's deep, domed ceiling, where a meticulously detailed galaxy is painted. A deep blue and indigo background is dotted with countless gold and silver stars, imbued with a soft, self-luminous effect. The light of this artificial starry sky flows across the curved surface of the globe and casts a dreamy reflection of it and the Milky Way on the marble floor, as if this ancient planet is slowly rotating, engaging in a silent gaze and dialogue across time and space with the eternal universe above. The entire picture is immersed in a tranquil, mysterious and eternal atmosphere of cold colors.", + "seed": 17317, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_0/index_827_seed_17317_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11324709136970341, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11324709136970341, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11324709136970341, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a vast, cathedral-like hall with a mirror-like dark marble floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient globe suspended in mid-air in the center of the hall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the globe have a surface made of yellowed parchment with a faded ancient map of the world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ceiling a deep dome painted with a galaxy featuring a blue and indigo background with gold and silver stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly from west to east on a tilted axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3494928777217865 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2244929075241089 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3494928777217865, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3494928777217865, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3923339545726776, + 0.08728916198015213, + 0.04072771593928337, + 0.019460365176200867, + 0.14135219156742096, + 0.0620729960501194, + 0.07661610096693039, + 0.05612601339817047, + 0.05553336441516876, + 0.06848815828561783 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3494928777217865 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a vast, cathedral-like hall with a mirror-like dark marble floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient globe suspended in mid-air in the center of the hall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the globe have a surface made of yellowed parchment with a faded ancient map of the world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ceiling a deep dome painted with a galaxy featuring a blue and indigo background with gold and silver stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly from west to east on a tilted axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024994343984872103 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002499580383301 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024994343984872103, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024994343984872103, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3841109275817871, + 0.10758350789546967, + 0.03721391037106514, + 0.021153436973690987, + 0.04726681113243103, + 0.06933502107858658, + 0.07267159968614578, + 0.0667148306965828, + 0.055738504976034164, + 0.1382114738225937 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024994343984872103 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a vast, cathedral-like hall with a mirror-like dark marble floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient globe suspended in mid-air in the center of the hall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the globe have a surface made of yellowed parchment with a faded ancient map of the world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ceiling a deep dome painted with a galaxy featuring a blue and indigo background with gold and silver stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly from west to east on a tilted axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006738557480275631 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006738662719727 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006738557480275631, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006738557480275631, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26531168818473816, + 0.10023658722639084, + 0.033145226538181305, + 0.04758746922016144, + 0.15546807646751404, + 0.07523524016141891, + 0.10166865587234497, + 0.044830307364463806, + 0.049737852066755295, + 0.12677887082099915 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006738557480275631 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a vast, cathedral-like hall with a mirror-like dark marble floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient globe suspended in mid-air in the center of the hall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the globe have a surface made of yellowed parchment with a faded ancient map of the world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ceiling a deep dome painted with a galaxy featuring a blue and indigo background with gold and silver stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly from west to east on a tilted axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059540290385484695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130954265594482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059540290385484695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059540290385484695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24700435996055603, + 0.08798247575759888, + 0.025903556495904922, + 0.03017481416463852, + 0.0715712383389473, + 0.11886167526245117, + 0.13700130581855774, + 0.09513559192419052, + 0.04327153414487839, + 0.14309348165988922 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059540290385484695 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a vast, cathedral-like hall with a mirror-like dark marble floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient globe suspended in mid-air in the center of the hall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the globe have a surface made of yellowed parchment with a faded ancient map of the world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ceiling a deep dome painted with a galaxy featuring a blue and indigo background with gold and silver stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly from west to east on a tilted axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20155055820941925 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015506029129028 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20155055820941925, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20155055820941925, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24966135621070862, + 0.09604369103908539, + 0.04487032815814018, + 0.055537447333335876, + 0.19254808127880096, + 0.08961521834135056, + 0.06231740862131119, + 0.04437375068664551, + 0.044937554746866226, + 0.12009519338607788 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20155055820941925 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "fixed wide-angle shot, taken from a slightly upward angle, captures a vast, cathedral-like hall. The mirror-like, dark marble floor rises upward, illuminating the entire scene. In the center of the hall, a formidable, ancient globe, suspended in mid-air by an invisible force, its bronzed brass stand gleaming faintly in the gloom. Its surface, made of yellowed parchment, covered in tiny cracks and the marks of age, bears a faded ancient map of the world, its continental outlines blurred and place names barely discernible. With a solemn, almost imperceptible pace, it slowly rotates from west to east on its tilted axis. The only light comes from the hall's deep, domed ceiling, where a meticulously detailed galaxy is painted. A deep blue and indigo background is dotted with countless gold and silver stars, imbued with a soft, self-luminous effect. The light of this artificial starry sky flows across the curved surface of the globe and casts a dreamy reflection of it and the Milky Way on the marble floor, as if this ancient planet is slowly rotating, engaging in a silent gaze and dialogue across time and space with the eternal universe above. The entire picture is immersed in a tranquil, mysterious and eternal atmosphere of cold colors.", + "seed": 17318, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_0/index_827_seed_17318_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.12674159943126143, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12674159943126143, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.300000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12674159943126143, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a vast, cathedral-like hall with a mirror-like dark marble floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient globe suspended in mid-air in the center of the hall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the globe have a surface made of yellowed parchment with a faded ancient map of the world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ceiling a deep dome painted with a galaxy featuring a blue and indigo background with gold and silver stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly from west to east on a tilted axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4300839304924011 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.055083990097046 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4300839304924011, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.6250000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4300839304924011, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1823648065328598, + 0.09924288839101791, + 0.04998677596449852, + 0.021037520840764046, + 0.11139918863773346, + 0.06300262361764908, + 0.03401026129722595, + 0.12194359302520752, + 0.2917109727859497, + 0.025301355868577957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4300839304924011 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a vast, cathedral-like hall with a mirror-like dark marble floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient globe suspended in mid-air in the center of the hall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the globe have a surface made of yellowed parchment with a faded ancient map of the world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ceiling a deep dome painted with a galaxy featuring a blue and indigo background with gold and silver stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly from west to east on a tilted axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036270327400416136 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628626823425293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036270327400416136, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036270327400416136, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12487427145242691, + 0.08053851127624512, + 0.1602257937192917, + 0.1338319033384323, + 0.08407146483659744, + 0.05734112113714218, + 0.0491860993206501, + 0.12378966063261032, + 0.15130077302455902, + 0.034840404987335205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036270327400416136 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a vast, cathedral-like hall with a mirror-like dark marble floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient globe suspended in mid-air in the center of the hall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the globe have a surface made of yellowed parchment with a faded ancient map of the world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ceiling a deep dome painted with a galaxy featuring a blue and indigo background with gold and silver stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly from west to east on a tilted axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033706627786159515 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087066650390625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033706627786159515, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033706627786159515, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14200879633426666, + 0.12261370569467545, + 0.20781154930591583, + 0.07845775783061981, + 0.1198602095246315, + 0.03943967819213867, + 0.06766465306282043, + 0.10133074969053268, + 0.09372639656066895, + 0.02708645537495613 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033706627786159515 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a vast, cathedral-like hall with a mirror-like dark marble floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient globe suspended in mid-air in the center of the hall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the globe have a surface made of yellowed parchment with a faded ancient map of the world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ceiling a deep dome painted with a galaxy featuring a blue and indigo background with gold and silver stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly from west to east on a tilted axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005953673273324966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130953788757324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005953673273324966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005953673273324966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15353834629058838, + 0.18341690301895142, + 0.04154251888394356, + 0.06243686005473137, + 0.25038567185401917, + 0.12046017497777939, + 0.04457894340157509, + 0.051639948040246964, + 0.07257115095853806, + 0.019429504871368408 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005953673273324966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a vast, cathedral-like hall with a mirror-like dark marble floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient globe suspended in mid-air in the center of the hall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the globe have a surface made of yellowed parchment with a faded ancient map of the world?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ceiling a deep dome painted with a galaxy featuring a blue and indigo background with gold and silver stars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly from west to east on a tilted axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16033673286437988 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103367328643799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16033673286437988, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16033673286437988, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08599543571472168, + 0.13735945522785187, + 0.08614350110292435, + 0.08858764171600342, + 0.1299620419740677, + 0.06269100308418274, + 0.03659629821777344, + 0.08067003637552261, + 0.27446335554122925, + 0.017531218007206917 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16033673286437988 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_1/index_tensor([8856, 8856])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_1/index_tensor([8856, 8856])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6ec8360de871efdbb842d0a6eaf8434362066dc7 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_1/index_tensor([8856, 8856])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An exquisite macro close-up, captured in a serene, observational documentary style, initially focuses precisely on a patch of lush, lush moss in the foreground, each delicate leaf and the shimmering water droplets dangling from it clearly visible. Then, in a steady and smooth motion, the camera pans back, the foreground moss fading into a soft green shadow, guiding the viewer's eye to the image's central subject: a cluster of translucent, amber-colored tricholoma fungi slowly emerging from the cracks of a dark brown, decaying log. Illuminated by the ever-shifting, dappled light filtering through the gaps in the forest canopy, the fungus takes on a wondrous jelly-like texture, its antler-like, branching structures translucent in the light, as if imbued with a warm, inner glow. Over time, we watch it steadily stretch upwards, branching out into new, tiny branches at a glacial pace that is both tangible and incredibly graceful. The entire process is silent and powerful, evoking a sense of awe and tranquility at the wonder of life in the microscopic world.", + "seed": 19015, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_1/index_8856_seed_19015_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.10606410233303905, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10606410233303905, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.400000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10606410233303905, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a macro close-up focusing on a patch of lush moss with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan back from the foreground moss to reveal a cluster of translucent, amber-colored tricholoma fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fungi shown emerging from the cracks of a dark brown, decaying log?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fungi exhibit a wondrous jelly-like texture with antler-like branching structures that appear translucent and glowing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the fungi steadily stretching upwards and branching out at a slow, glacial pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11322927474975586 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.238229274749756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11322927474975586, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11322927474975586, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7462663650512695, + 0.04241960495710373, + 0.04266086965799332, + 0.022483084350824356, + 0.027647189795970917, + 0.054941460490226746, + 0.026445167139172554, + 0.009503211826086044, + 0.012261049821972847, + 0.015372008085250854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11322927474975586 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a macro close-up focusing on a patch of lush moss with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan back from the foreground moss to reveal a cluster of translucent, amber-colored tricholoma fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fungi shown emerging from the cracks of a dark brown, decaying log?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fungi exhibit a wondrous jelly-like texture with antler-like branching structures that appear translucent and glowing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the fungi steadily stretching upwards and branching out at a slow, glacial pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008667586371302605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758667469024658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008667586371302605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008667586371302605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4041649401187897, + 0.11814026534557343, + 0.04855208843946457, + 0.041643448173999786, + 0.09105153381824493, + 0.13735516369342804, + 0.047458216547966, + 0.023190611973404884, + 0.028452856466174126, + 0.05999089404940605 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008667586371302605 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a macro close-up focusing on a patch of lush moss with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan back from the foreground moss to reveal a cluster of translucent, amber-colored tricholoma fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fungi shown emerging from the cracks of a dark brown, decaying log?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fungi exhibit a wondrous jelly-like texture with antler-like branching structures that appear translucent and glowing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the fungi steadily stretching upwards and branching out at a slow, glacial pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016078457236289978 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141078472137451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016078457236289978, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016078457236289978, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25538086891174316, + 0.04155602678656578, + 0.05644112080335617, + 0.08131890743970871, + 0.07601985335350037, + 0.32539528608322144, + 0.06605552136898041, + 0.020267022773623466, + 0.019720962271094322, + 0.057844460010528564 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016078457236289978 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a macro close-up focusing on a patch of lush moss with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan back from the foreground moss to reveal a cluster of translucent, amber-colored tricholoma fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fungi shown emerging from the cracks of a dark brown, decaying log?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fungi exhibit a wondrous jelly-like texture with antler-like branching structures that appear translucent and glowing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the fungi steadily stretching upwards and branching out at a slow, glacial pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005265060346573591 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255265235900879 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005265060346573591, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005265060346573591, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40971991419792175, + 0.0603102445602417, + 0.027206016704440117, + 0.08987949043512344, + 0.04739782214164734, + 0.1940615475177765, + 0.07375485450029373, + 0.031011590734124184, + 0.030422095209360123, + 0.036236442625522614 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005265060346573591 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a macro close-up focusing on a patch of lush moss with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan back from the foreground moss to reveal a cluster of translucent, amber-colored tricholoma fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fungi shown emerging from the cracks of a dark brown, decaying log?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fungi exhibit a wondrous jelly-like texture with antler-like branching structures that appear translucent and glowing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the fungi steadily stretching upwards and branching out at a slow, glacial pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870801329612732 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137080192565918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3870801329612732, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7500000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3870801329612732, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16814860701560974, + 0.031585194170475006, + 0.07246313244104385, + 0.03541274741292, + 0.056636545807123184, + 0.38144731521606445, + 0.14016510546207428, + 0.02416399121284485, + 0.04575132578611374, + 0.04422600567340851 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3870801329612732 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An exquisite macro close-up, captured in a serene, observational documentary style, initially focuses precisely on a patch of lush, lush moss in the foreground, each delicate leaf and the shimmering water droplets dangling from it clearly visible. Then, in a steady and smooth motion, the camera pans back, the foreground moss fading into a soft green shadow, guiding the viewer's eye to the image's central subject: a cluster of translucent, amber-colored tricholoma fungi slowly emerging from the cracks of a dark brown, decaying log. Illuminated by the ever-shifting, dappled light filtering through the gaps in the forest canopy, the fungus takes on a wondrous jelly-like texture, its antler-like, branching structures translucent in the light, as if imbued with a warm, inner glow. Over time, we watch it steadily stretch upwards, branching out into new, tiny branches at a glacial pace that is both tangible and incredibly graceful. The entire process is silent and powerful, evoking a sense of awe and tranquility at the wonder of life in the microscopic world.", + "seed": 19016, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_1/index_8856_seed_19016_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03154528765007854, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03154528765007854, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.4249999761581424, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03154528765007854, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a macro close-up focusing on a patch of lush moss with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan back from the foreground moss to reveal a cluster of translucent, amber-colored tricholoma fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fungi shown emerging from the cracks of a dark brown, decaying log?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fungi exhibit a wondrous jelly-like texture with antler-like branching structures that appear translucent and glowing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the fungi steadily stretching upwards and branching out at a slow, glacial pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0073158699087798595 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.007315635681152 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0073158699087798595, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0073158699087798595, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1541229486465454, + 0.04198593273758888, + 0.0292460098862648, + 0.07196912914514542, + 0.09847266972064972, + 0.06154824420809746, + 0.05546753481030464, + 0.02502642571926117, + 0.4061126708984375, + 0.05604846775531769 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0073158699087798595 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a macro close-up focusing on a patch of lush moss with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan back from the foreground moss to reveal a cluster of translucent, amber-colored tricholoma fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fungi shown emerging from the cracks of a dark brown, decaying log?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fungi exhibit a wondrous jelly-like texture with antler-like branching structures that appear translucent and glowing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the fungi steadily stretching upwards and branching out at a slow, glacial pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005976543761789799 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130976676940918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005976543761789799, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005976543761789799, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11848334223031998, + 0.06810222566127777, + 0.00997036974877119, + 0.07623129338026047, + 0.09701936691999435, + 0.01864529773592949, + 0.021252062171697617, + 0.1869346648454666, + 0.379477322101593, + 0.02388407476246357 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005976543761789799 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a macro close-up focusing on a patch of lush moss with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan back from the foreground moss to reveal a cluster of translucent, amber-colored tricholoma fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fungi shown emerging from the cracks of a dark brown, decaying log?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fungi exhibit a wondrous jelly-like texture with antler-like branching structures that appear translucent and glowing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the fungi steadily stretching upwards and branching out at a slow, glacial pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014203056693077087 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264203071594238 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014203056693077087, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014203056693077087, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14611458778381348, + 0.03438949957489967, + 0.01411084458231926, + 0.056237272918224335, + 0.12311000376939774, + 0.05627037584781647, + 0.03542963042855263, + 0.0999726802110672, + 0.4020628035068512, + 0.032302286475896835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014203056693077087 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a macro close-up focusing on a patch of lush moss with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan back from the foreground moss to reveal a cluster of translucent, amber-colored tricholoma fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fungi shown emerging from the cracks of a dark brown, decaying log?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fungi exhibit a wondrous jelly-like texture with antler-like branching structures that appear translucent and glowing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the fungi steadily stretching upwards and branching out at a slow, glacial pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003203381784260273 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753203392028809 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003203381784260273, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003203381784260273, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07482758909463882, + 0.08566509932279587, + 0.038227859884500504, + 0.08654443174600601, + 0.031957317143678665, + 0.0690431222319603, + 0.02256951481103897, + 0.1663617044687271, + 0.3953171372413635, + 0.029486287385225296 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003203381784260273 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a macro close-up focusing on a patch of lush moss with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan back from the foreground moss to reveal a cluster of translucent, amber-colored tricholoma fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fungi shown emerging from the cracks of a dark brown, decaying log?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fungi exhibit a wondrous jelly-like texture with antler-like branching structures that appear translucent and glowing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the fungi steadily stretching upwards and branching out at a slow, glacial pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12702758610248566 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270275115966797 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12702758610248566, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12702758610248566, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08000510931015015, + 0.1050616055727005, + 0.046986181288957596, + 0.07477773725986481, + 0.039390336722135544, + 0.0565396212041378, + 0.037407245486974716, + 0.043926771730184555, + 0.4861423373222351, + 0.029763102531433105 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12702758610248566 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An exquisite macro close-up, captured in a serene, observational documentary style, initially focuses precisely on a patch of lush, lush moss in the foreground, each delicate leaf and the shimmering water droplets dangling from it clearly visible. Then, in a steady and smooth motion, the camera pans back, the foreground moss fading into a soft green shadow, guiding the viewer's eye to the image's central subject: a cluster of translucent, amber-colored tricholoma fungi slowly emerging from the cracks of a dark brown, decaying log. Illuminated by the ever-shifting, dappled light filtering through the gaps in the forest canopy, the fungus takes on a wondrous jelly-like texture, its antler-like, branching structures translucent in the light, as if imbued with a warm, inner glow. Over time, we watch it steadily stretch upwards, branching out into new, tiny branches at a glacial pace that is both tangible and incredibly graceful. The entire process is silent and powerful, evoking a sense of awe and tranquility at the wonder of life in the microscopic world.", + "seed": 19017, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_1/index_8856_seed_19017_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11811141171492637, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11811141171492637, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11811141171492637, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a macro close-up focusing on a patch of lush moss with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan back from the foreground moss to reveal a cluster of translucent, amber-colored tricholoma fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fungi shown emerging from the cracks of a dark brown, decaying log?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fungi exhibit a wondrous jelly-like texture with antler-like branching structures that appear translucent and glowing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the fungi steadily stretching upwards and branching out at a slow, glacial pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0034724909346550703 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753472328186035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0034724909346550703, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0034724909346550703, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15689897537231445, + 0.46394601464271545, + 0.21250127255916595, + 0.029794352129101753, + 0.04139884561300278, + 0.015080696903169155, + 0.02150694839656353, + 0.010565879754722118, + 0.024267105385661125, + 0.02403990551829338 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0034724909346550703 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a macro close-up focusing on a patch of lush moss with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan back from the foreground moss to reveal a cluster of translucent, amber-colored tricholoma fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fungi shown emerging from the cracks of a dark brown, decaying log?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fungi exhibit a wondrous jelly-like texture with antler-like branching structures that appear translucent and glowing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the fungi steadily stretching upwards and branching out at a slow, glacial pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003210154827684164 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753210067749023 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003210154827684164, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003210154827684164, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14209969341754913, + 0.10645248740911484, + 0.19879911839962006, + 0.13936860859394073, + 0.09010320901870728, + 0.057429101318120956, + 0.07932684570550919, + 0.02667652815580368, + 0.09552190452814102, + 0.06422252207994461 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003210154827684164 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a macro close-up focusing on a patch of lush moss with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan back from the foreground moss to reveal a cluster of translucent, amber-colored tricholoma fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fungi shown emerging from the cracks of a dark brown, decaying log?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fungi exhibit a wondrous jelly-like texture with antler-like branching structures that appear translucent and glowing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the fungi steadily stretching upwards and branching out at a slow, glacial pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005260791163891554 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255260944366455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005260791163891554, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005260791163891554, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1380215883255005, + 0.16563306748867035, + 0.04654135927557945, + 0.0545596219599247, + 0.12795709073543549, + 0.04018668830394745, + 0.17831195890903473, + 0.05552389845252037, + 0.08487449586391449, + 0.10839017480611801 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005260791163891554 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a macro close-up focusing on a patch of lush moss with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan back from the foreground moss to reveal a cluster of translucent, amber-colored tricholoma fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fungi shown emerging from the cracks of a dark brown, decaying log?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fungi exhibit a wondrous jelly-like texture with antler-like branching structures that appear translucent and glowing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the fungi steadily stretching upwards and branching out at a slow, glacial pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002495629247277975 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002495765686035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002495629247277975, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002495629247277975, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13670025765895844, + 0.20018991827964783, + 0.06316931545734406, + 0.05727739259600639, + 0.09387119114398956, + 0.05123935267329216, + 0.06360828131437302, + 0.02777135744690895, + 0.14437371492385864, + 0.16179926693439484 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002495629247277975 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a macro close-up focusing on a patch of lush moss with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan back from the foreground moss to reveal a cluster of translucent, amber-colored tricholoma fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fungi shown emerging from the cracks of a dark brown, decaying log?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fungi exhibit a wondrous jelly-like texture with antler-like branching structures that appear translucent and glowing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the fungi steadily stretching upwards and branching out at a slow, glacial pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.576117992401123 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.826117992401123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.576117992401123, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.576117992401123, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13040879368782043, + 0.15152347087860107, + 0.07145717740058899, + 0.08349107950925827, + 0.10107068717479706, + 0.023727495223283768, + 0.14648182690143585, + 0.024512091651558876, + 0.1982811540365219, + 0.06904619932174683 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.576117992401123 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An exquisite macro close-up, captured in a serene, observational documentary style, initially focuses precisely on a patch of lush, lush moss in the foreground, each delicate leaf and the shimmering water droplets dangling from it clearly visible. Then, in a steady and smooth motion, the camera pans back, the foreground moss fading into a soft green shadow, guiding the viewer's eye to the image's central subject: a cluster of translucent, amber-colored tricholoma fungi slowly emerging from the cracks of a dark brown, decaying log. Illuminated by the ever-shifting, dappled light filtering through the gaps in the forest canopy, the fungus takes on a wondrous jelly-like texture, its antler-like, branching structures translucent in the light, as if imbued with a warm, inner glow. Over time, we watch it steadily stretch upwards, branching out into new, tiny branches at a glacial pace that is both tangible and incredibly graceful. The entire process is silent and powerful, evoking a sense of awe and tranquility at the wonder of life in the microscopic world.", + "seed": 19018, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_1/index_8856_seed_19018_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.08172526834532619, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08172526834532619, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08172526834532619, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a macro close-up focusing on a patch of lush moss with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan back from the foreground moss to reveal a cluster of translucent, amber-colored tricholoma fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fungi shown emerging from the cracks of a dark brown, decaying log?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fungi exhibit a wondrous jelly-like texture with antler-like branching structures that appear translucent and glowing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the fungi steadily stretching upwards and branching out at a slow, glacial pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009006942622363567 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.759006977081299 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009006942622363567, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009006942622363567, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5220036506652832, + 0.07008112221956253, + 0.11661124229431152, + 0.0825856477022171, + 0.057436857372522354, + 0.0850691944360733, + 0.02380581945180893, + 0.021304471418261528, + 0.013821450062096119, + 0.007280539721250534 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009006942622363567 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a macro close-up focusing on a patch of lush moss with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan back from the foreground moss to reveal a cluster of translucent, amber-colored tricholoma fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fungi shown emerging from the cracks of a dark brown, decaying log?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fungi exhibit a wondrous jelly-like texture with antler-like branching structures that appear translucent and glowing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the fungi steadily stretching upwards and branching out at a slow, glacial pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005274665541946888 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255274772644043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005274665541946888, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005274665541946888, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13705633580684662, + 0.14056192338466644, + 0.1590302735567093, + 0.08561888337135315, + 0.10637909919023514, + 0.11405783891677856, + 0.028939053416252136, + 0.08013759553432465, + 0.13228647410869598, + 0.015932461246848106 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005274665541946888 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a macro close-up focusing on a patch of lush moss with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan back from the foreground moss to reveal a cluster of translucent, amber-colored tricholoma fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fungi shown emerging from the cracks of a dark brown, decaying log?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fungi exhibit a wondrous jelly-like texture with antler-like branching structures that appear translucent and glowing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the fungi steadily stretching upwards and branching out at a slow, glacial pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040994188748300076 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504099369049072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040994188748300076, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040994188748300076, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10476087033748627, + 0.045875560492277145, + 0.2250002771615982, + 0.22020839154720306, + 0.13746057450771332, + 0.05349858105182648, + 0.03702222555875778, + 0.10318686813116074, + 0.0545949712395668, + 0.018391795456409454 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040994188748300076 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a macro close-up focusing on a patch of lush moss with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan back from the foreground moss to reveal a cluster of translucent, amber-colored tricholoma fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fungi shown emerging from the cracks of a dark brown, decaying log?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fungi exhibit a wondrous jelly-like texture with antler-like branching structures that appear translucent and glowing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the fungi steadily stretching upwards and branching out at a slow, glacial pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003201361745595932 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753201484680176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003201361745595932, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003201361745595932, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23022222518920898, + 0.12727899849414825, + 0.15885037183761597, + 0.0714266300201416, + 0.07913923263549805, + 0.08729729056358337, + 0.05113019049167633, + 0.11767050623893738, + 0.05557951331138611, + 0.02140498347580433 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003201361745595932 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a macro close-up focusing on a patch of lush moss with visible water droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan back from the foreground moss to reveal a cluster of translucent, amber-colored tricholoma fungi?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the fungi shown emerging from the cracks of a dark brown, decaying log?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the fungi exhibit a wondrous jelly-like texture with antler-like branching structures that appear translucent and glowing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the fungi steadily stretching upwards and branching out at a slow, glacial pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38704395294189453 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370439529418945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38704395294189453, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38704395294189453, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08300849050283432, + 0.015425329096615314, + 0.20647886395454407, + 0.11740018427371979, + 0.07176236808300018, + 0.09614641219377518, + 0.06553367525339127, + 0.2312457114458084, + 0.09538835287094116, + 0.017610596492886543 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38704395294189453 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_10/index_tensor([8991, 8991])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_10/index_tensor([8991, 8991])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4869046bf87f96d906771553fad885290d5c7a90 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_10/index_tensor([8991, 8991])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The shot begins with a slight upward angle, then slowly pulls back to reveal a magnificent scene: atop a cliff of rugged, dark gray rock, a woman in a classically elegant dress stands firm, braving the strong sea breeze. Her cascading, raven-black hair dances freely in the wind, occasionally brushing against her classically serene face. Her gaze, fixed on the distant, roiling sea, reveals an unwavering resolve. She wears a pale cyan silk gown, delicately embroidered with silver cloud patterns. The golden sunlight filtering through the gaps in the evening clouds reflects a soft, regal sheen. The strong wind whips at her, pushing her signature wide sleeves to their fullest, like two soft flags, gracefully and powerfully unfurling and fluttering in the air. The cascading, voluminous skirt ripples dramatically in the breeze, seemingly echoing the whitecaps of the deep blue sea below. The whole scene, with the cold cliffs, the ocean and the warm sunset glow interwoven, creates a sense of epic grandeur and a lonely and tenacious tranquil atmosphere.", + "seed": 25526, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_10/index_8991_seed_25526_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1168687512166798, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1168687512166798, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1168687512166798, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a cliff made of rugged, dark gray rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale cyan silk gown with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have cascading, raven-black hair that moves in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's wide sleeves and voluminous skirt shown fluttering and rippling in the strong sea breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slight upward angle and then slowly pull back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2825605571269989 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4075605869293213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2825605571269989, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2825605571269989, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2129637748003006, + 0.03992283344268799, + 0.0399174802005291, + 0.13920792937278748, + 0.07070345431566238, + 0.20175373554229736, + 0.049523983150720596, + 0.19329118728637695, + 0.01378883607685566, + 0.03892679885029793 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2825605571269989 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a cliff made of rugged, dark gray rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale cyan silk gown with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have cascading, raven-black hair that moves in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's wide sleeves and voluminous skirt shown fluttering and rippling in the strong sea breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slight upward angle and then slowly pull back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008665340952575207 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758665561676025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008665340952575207, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008665340952575207, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1625019758939743, + 0.09056513011455536, + 0.0339336022734642, + 0.25205227732658386, + 0.05980736017227173, + 0.1526123583316803, + 0.08446992188692093, + 0.09155745804309845, + 0.035517919808626175, + 0.03698199242353439 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008665340952575207 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a cliff made of rugged, dark gray rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale cyan silk gown with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have cascading, raven-black hair that moves in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's wide sleeves and voluminous skirt shown fluttering and rippling in the strong sea breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slight upward angle and then slowly pull back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008641703985631466 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758641719818115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008641703985631466, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008641703985631466, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5236780643463135, + 0.039726678282022476, + 0.021566715091466904, + 0.09831162542104721, + 0.03879754617810249, + 0.1161627322435379, + 0.021457858383655548, + 0.05508287996053696, + 0.05794597044587135, + 0.027270019054412842 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008641703985631466 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a cliff made of rugged, dark gray rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale cyan silk gown with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have cascading, raven-black hair that moves in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's wide sleeves and voluminous skirt shown fluttering and rippling in the strong sea breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slight upward angle and then slowly pull back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003193043638020754 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753192901611328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003193043638020754, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003193043638020754, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2369435876607895, + 0.06648798286914825, + 0.025670014321804047, + 0.09478844702243805, + 0.059062618762254715, + 0.1776473969221115, + 0.036254700273275375, + 0.10203024744987488, + 0.1556107997894287, + 0.045504145324230194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003193043638020754 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a cliff made of rugged, dark gray rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale cyan silk gown with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have cascading, raven-black hair that moves in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's wide sleeves and voluminous skirt shown fluttering and rippling in the strong sea breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slight upward angle and then slowly pull back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28128311038017273 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4062831401824951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28128311038017273, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28128311038017273, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4258166551589966, + 0.05122023820877075, + 0.04784633219242096, + 0.15763740241527557, + 0.028170574456453323, + 0.025034043937921524, + 0.01720297336578369, + 0.05064421519637108, + 0.16250565648078918, + 0.033921968191862106 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28128311038017273 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The shot begins with a slight upward angle, then slowly pulls back to reveal a magnificent scene: atop a cliff of rugged, dark gray rock, a woman in a classically elegant dress stands firm, braving the strong sea breeze. Her cascading, raven-black hair dances freely in the wind, occasionally brushing against her classically serene face. Her gaze, fixed on the distant, roiling sea, reveals an unwavering resolve. She wears a pale cyan silk gown, delicately embroidered with silver cloud patterns. The golden sunlight filtering through the gaps in the evening clouds reflects a soft, regal sheen. The strong wind whips at her, pushing her signature wide sleeves to their fullest, like two soft flags, gracefully and powerfully unfurling and fluttering in the air. The cascading, voluminous skirt ripples dramatically in the breeze, seemingly echoing the whitecaps of the deep blue sea below. The whole scene, with the cold cliffs, the ocean and the warm sunset glow interwoven, creates a sense of epic grandeur and a lonely and tenacious tranquil atmosphere.", + "seed": 25527, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_10/index_8991_seed_25527_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.09734510974958539, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09734510974958539, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09734510974958539, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a cliff made of rugged, dark gray rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale cyan silk gown with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have cascading, raven-black hair that moves in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's wide sleeves and voluminous skirt shown fluttering and rippling in the strong sea breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slight upward angle and then slowly pull back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10240652412176132 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3524065017700195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10240652412176132, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10240652412176132, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09850253164768219, + 0.1271640807390213, + 0.13356275856494904, + 0.28653833270072937, + 0.146834596991539, + 0.06797534227371216, + 0.01905517838895321, + 0.054560352116823196, + 0.020364627242088318, + 0.045442190021276474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10240652412176132 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a cliff made of rugged, dark gray rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale cyan silk gown with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have cascading, raven-black hair that moves in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's wide sleeves and voluminous skirt shown fluttering and rippling in the strong sea breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slight upward angle and then slowly pull back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02636999823153019 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651370048522949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02636999823153019, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02636999823153019, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.029544424265623093, + 0.02502460964024067, + 0.02736259438097477, + 0.0228568222373724, + 0.050259996205568314, + 0.02956356108188629, + 0.04058375582098961, + 0.6071016788482666, + 0.11347868293523788, + 0.05422389134764671 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02636999823153019 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a cliff made of rugged, dark gray rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale cyan silk gown with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have cascading, raven-black hair that moves in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's wide sleeves and voluminous skirt shown fluttering and rippling in the strong sea breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slight upward angle and then slowly pull back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005258894059807062 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255259037017822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005258894059807062, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005258894059807062, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03478776291012764, + 0.01863069273531437, + 0.017158344388008118, + 0.17682677507400513, + 0.04337228089570999, + 0.02181398682296276, + 0.03216840699315071, + 0.1509384661912918, + 0.12356457114219666, + 0.38073867559432983 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005258894059807062 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a cliff made of rugged, dark gray rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale cyan silk gown with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have cascading, raven-black hair that moves in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's wide sleeves and voluminous skirt shown fluttering and rippling in the strong sea breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slight upward angle and then slowly pull back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040965694934129715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504096508026123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040965694934129715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040965694934129715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04104935750365257, + 0.017337141558527946, + 0.026416389271616936, + 0.029915831983089447, + 0.01574646309018135, + 0.019472375512123108, + 0.09976079314947128, + 0.07424379140138626, + 0.19546042382717133, + 0.48059728741645813 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040965694934129715 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a cliff made of rugged, dark gray rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale cyan silk gown with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have cascading, raven-black hair that moves in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's wide sleeves and voluminous skirt shown fluttering and rippling in the strong sea breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slight upward angle and then slowly pull back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3485935628414154 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2235935926437378 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3485935628414154, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3485935628414154, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06955356150865555, + 0.05652604252099991, + 0.04038046672940254, + 0.16296027600765228, + 0.042568620294332504, + 0.035416170954704285, + 0.03360307216644287, + 0.1644139289855957, + 0.06982670724391937, + 0.324751079082489 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3485935628414154 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The shot begins with a slight upward angle, then slowly pulls back to reveal a magnificent scene: atop a cliff of rugged, dark gray rock, a woman in a classically elegant dress stands firm, braving the strong sea breeze. Her cascading, raven-black hair dances freely in the wind, occasionally brushing against her classically serene face. Her gaze, fixed on the distant, roiling sea, reveals an unwavering resolve. She wears a pale cyan silk gown, delicately embroidered with silver cloud patterns. The golden sunlight filtering through the gaps in the evening clouds reflects a soft, regal sheen. The strong wind whips at her, pushing her signature wide sleeves to their fullest, like two soft flags, gracefully and powerfully unfurling and fluttering in the air. The cascading, voluminous skirt ripples dramatically in the breeze, seemingly echoing the whitecaps of the deep blue sea below. The whole scene, with the cold cliffs, the ocean and the warm sunset glow interwoven, creates a sense of epic grandeur and a lonely and tenacious tranquil atmosphere.", + "seed": 25528, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_10/index_8991_seed_25528_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05730596981011331, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05730596981011331, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.099999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05730596981011331, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a cliff made of rugged, dark gray rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale cyan silk gown with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have cascading, raven-black hair that moves in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's wide sleeves and voluminous skirt shown fluttering and rippling in the strong sea breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slight upward angle and then slowly pull back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14438091218471527 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.019380807876587 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14438091218471527, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14438091218471527, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36179065704345703, + 0.05625409632921219, + 0.04430888965725899, + 0.04892546311020851, + 0.04897141456604004, + 0.06158050149679184, + 0.1344974935054779, + 0.10749787092208862, + 0.07297854125499725, + 0.06319507211446762 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14438091218471527 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a cliff made of rugged, dark gray rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale cyan silk gown with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have cascading, raven-black hair that moves in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's wide sleeves and voluminous skirt shown fluttering and rippling in the strong sea breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slight upward angle and then slowly pull back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00980312842875719 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634803295135498 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00980312842875719, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00980312842875719, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18022418022155762, + 0.16699768602848053, + 0.0592060461640358, + 0.04512576013803482, + 0.05598874017596245, + 0.08679194003343582, + 0.13521046936511993, + 0.09736571460962296, + 0.06098460406064987, + 0.1121048629283905 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00980312842875719 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a cliff made of rugged, dark gray rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale cyan silk gown with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have cascading, raven-black hair that moves in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's wide sleeves and voluminous skirt shown fluttering and rippling in the strong sea breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slight upward angle and then slowly pull back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003617530455812812 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628617763519287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003617530455812812, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003617530455812812, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29038476943969727, + 0.20839570462703705, + 0.05202178657054901, + 0.03196660056710243, + 0.05508166924118996, + 0.0462770015001297, + 0.05749955400824547, + 0.0584285594522953, + 0.10847771912813187, + 0.09146668761968613 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003617530455812812 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a cliff made of rugged, dark gray rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale cyan silk gown with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have cascading, raven-black hair that moves in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's wide sleeves and voluminous skirt shown fluttering and rippling in the strong sea breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slight upward angle and then slowly pull back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017128810286521912 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376712799072266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017128810286521912, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017128810286521912, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0904683843255043, + 0.10447610169649124, + 0.061799582093954086, + 0.03479586914181709, + 0.1457769125699997, + 0.050616152584552765, + 0.12362346053123474, + 0.10342606902122498, + 0.07505358755588531, + 0.20996388792991638 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017128810286521912 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a cliff made of rugged, dark gray rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale cyan silk gown with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have cascading, raven-black hair that moves in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's wide sleeves and voluminous skirt shown fluttering and rippling in the strong sea breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slight upward angle and then slowly pull back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270153969526291 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270153522491455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270153969526291, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270153969526291, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06280898302793503, + 0.08553576469421387, + 0.041169423609972, + 0.0420844592154026, + 0.07151147723197937, + 0.07346747070550919, + 0.18006452918052673, + 0.304935485124588, + 0.08897773921489716, + 0.049444667994976044 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270153969526291 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The shot begins with a slight upward angle, then slowly pulls back to reveal a magnificent scene: atop a cliff of rugged, dark gray rock, a woman in a classically elegant dress stands firm, braving the strong sea breeze. Her cascading, raven-black hair dances freely in the wind, occasionally brushing against her classically serene face. Her gaze, fixed on the distant, roiling sea, reveals an unwavering resolve. She wears a pale cyan silk gown, delicately embroidered with silver cloud patterns. The golden sunlight filtering through the gaps in the evening clouds reflects a soft, regal sheen. The strong wind whips at her, pushing her signature wide sleeves to their fullest, like two soft flags, gracefully and powerfully unfurling and fluttering in the air. The cascading, voluminous skirt ripples dramatically in the breeze, seemingly echoing the whitecaps of the deep blue sea below. The whole scene, with the cold cliffs, the ocean and the warm sunset glow interwoven, creates a sense of epic grandeur and a lonely and tenacious tranquil atmosphere.", + "seed": 25529, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_10/index_8991_seed_25529_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06063596219755709, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06063596219755709, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06063596219755709, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a cliff made of rugged, dark gray rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale cyan silk gown with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have cascading, raven-black hair that moves in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's wide sleeves and voluminous skirt shown fluttering and rippling in the strong sea breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slight upward angle and then slowly pull back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.056613512337207794 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9316134452819824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.056613512337207794, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.056613512337207794, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3652167022228241, + 0.04325389862060547, + 0.021510759368538857, + 0.11100095510482788, + 0.31225237250328064, + 0.045546866953372955, + 0.048170723021030426, + 0.017799612134695053, + 0.014758579432964325, + 0.020489461719989777 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.056613512337207794 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a cliff made of rugged, dark gray rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale cyan silk gown with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have cascading, raven-black hair that moves in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's wide sleeves and voluminous skirt shown fluttering and rippling in the strong sea breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slight upward angle and then slowly pull back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007646458223462105 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882646560668945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007646458223462105, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007646458223462105, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.874295175075531, + 0.010918740183115005, + 0.012379130348563194, + 0.012943144887685776, + 0.01090672891587019, + 0.01861516200006008, + 0.012306157499551773, + 0.024406906217336655, + 0.015960482880473137, + 0.007268412504345179 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007646458223462105 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a cliff made of rugged, dark gray rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale cyan silk gown with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have cascading, raven-black hair that moves in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's wide sleeves and voluminous skirt shown fluttering and rippling in the strong sea breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slight upward angle and then slowly pull back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009781171567738056 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634781360626221 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009781171567738056, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009781171567738056, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.8412997722625732, + 0.018467528745532036, + 0.020910724997520447, + 0.03825550153851509, + 0.016328930854797363, + 0.012238698080182076, + 0.018215160816907883, + 0.012126019224524498, + 0.009199216030538082, + 0.012958451174199581 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009781171567738056 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a cliff made of rugged, dark gray rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale cyan silk gown with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have cascading, raven-black hair that moves in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's wide sleeves and voluminous skirt shown fluttering and rippling in the strong sea breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slight upward angle and then slowly pull back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003615867579355836 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628615856170654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003615867579355836, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003615867579355836, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.9065406918525696, + 0.00415427889674902, + 0.005667355842888355, + 0.014966331422328949, + 0.00468044588342309, + 0.0022661779075860977, + 0.009309517219662666, + 0.003423581598326564, + 0.03773249313235283, + 0.011259149760007858 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003615867579355836 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a cliff made of rugged, dark gray rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale cyan silk gown with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman have cascading, raven-black hair that moves in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the woman's wide sleeves and voluminous skirt shown fluttering and rippling in the strong sea breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a slight upward angle and then slowly pull back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22552280128002167 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600522756576538 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22552280128002167, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22552280128002167, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36792099475860596, + 0.048910561949014664, + 0.03321164473891258, + 0.04145551845431328, + 0.0688885971903801, + 0.033705223351716995, + 0.025698939338326454, + 0.0373757965862751, + 0.30515724420547485, + 0.03767547011375427 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22552280128002167 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_11/index_tensor([8611, 8611])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_11/index_tensor([8611, 8611])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..98face9620fe46e698680efe6b45c5c800c716c6 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_11/index_tensor([8611, 8611])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle tracking shot follows a heavy main battle tank as it speeds across a vast, desolate, muddy plain. Painted in a dark olive green and earth-toned camouflage, the tank's armored hull is thickly coated with mud and grime. The diffuse light of a dull, overcast sky gives the metal a cold, faint sheen. Its massive, segmented metal tracks relentlessly crush the soft earth at high speed, each rotation violently sending chunks of dark, wet mud and slurry high into the air, forming a dense, arcing trail. Some of the mud even splashes back onto the tank's chassis. The tank's massive frame jolts slightly over the uneven terrain, its long gun barrel pointing steadily forward. The roar of its engine intertwines with the thump of its tracks, creating a chilling, monochromatic image that creates a powerful atmosphere of raw power, tension, and unstoppable mechanical kinetic energy.", + "seed": 7694, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_11/index_8611_seed_7694_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.19523071609437465, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19523071609437465, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19523071609437465, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy battle tank painted in dark olive green and earth-toned camouflage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armored hull thickly coated with mud and grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank move at high speed across a vast, desolate, muddy plain while crushing the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks send chunks of dark, wet mud and slurry high into the air forming a dense, arcing trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04001528024673462 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.29001522064209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04001528024673462, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04001528024673462, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3409018814563751, + 0.04761035740375519, + 0.028584809973835945, + 0.05755993723869324, + 0.02886985056102276, + 0.060857828706502914, + 0.12371593713760376, + 0.21456387639045715, + 0.0667860135436058, + 0.03054952435195446 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04001528024673462 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy battle tank painted in dark olive green and earth-toned camouflage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armored hull thickly coated with mud and grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank move at high speed across a vast, desolate, muddy plain while crushing the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks send chunks of dark, wet mud and slurry high into the air forming a dense, arcing trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03374074399471283 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408740758895874 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03374074399471283, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03374074399471283, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16187667846679688, + 0.1587761491537094, + 0.0551062636077404, + 0.09461082518100739, + 0.054416339844465256, + 0.037443146109580994, + 0.10744097083806992, + 0.25162214040756226, + 0.05234864354133606, + 0.026358788833022118 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03374074399471283 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy battle tank painted in dark olive green and earth-toned camouflage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armored hull thickly coated with mud and grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank move at high speed across a vast, desolate, muddy plain while crushing the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks send chunks of dark, wet mud and slurry high into the air forming a dense, arcing trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261326551437378 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761326551437378 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8261326551437378, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8261326551437378, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.200189471244812, + 0.0794852077960968, + 0.05749930068850517, + 0.05434168502688408, + 0.08865533769130707, + 0.05504610389471054, + 0.18342968821525574, + 0.0955551341176033, + 0.11989070475101471, + 0.06590738147497177 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8261326551437378 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy battle tank painted in dark olive green and earth-toned camouflage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armored hull thickly coated with mud and grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank move at high speed across a vast, desolate, muddy plain while crushing the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks send chunks of dark, wet mud and slurry high into the air forming a dense, arcing trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014217512682080269 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264217376708984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014217512682080269, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014217512682080269, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1312616467475891, + 0.1250234693288803, + 0.03654155135154724, + 0.0511176697909832, + 0.1009405255317688, + 0.05261346697807312, + 0.15880289673805237, + 0.12401243299245834, + 0.17903827130794525, + 0.04064810276031494 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014217512682080269 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy battle tank painted in dark olive green and earth-toned camouflage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armored hull thickly coated with mud and grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank move at high speed across a vast, desolate, muddy plain while crushing the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks send chunks of dark, wet mud and slurry high into the air forming a dense, arcing trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204738840460777 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120474815368652 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204738840460777, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204738840460777, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14163808524608612, + 0.024140749126672745, + 0.02791476994752884, + 0.04996420070528984, + 0.08899372071027756, + 0.12410322576761246, + 0.12669311463832855, + 0.2885887920856476, + 0.07428989559412003, + 0.05367337167263031 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204738840460777 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle tracking shot follows a heavy main battle tank as it speeds across a vast, desolate, muddy plain. Painted in a dark olive green and earth-toned camouflage, the tank's armored hull is thickly coated with mud and grime. The diffuse light of a dull, overcast sky gives the metal a cold, faint sheen. Its massive, segmented metal tracks relentlessly crush the soft earth at high speed, each rotation violently sending chunks of dark, wet mud and slurry high into the air, forming a dense, arcing trail. Some of the mud even splashes back onto the tank's chassis. The tank's massive frame jolts slightly over the uneven terrain, its long gun barrel pointing steadily forward. The roar of its engine intertwines with the thump of its tracks, creating a chilling, monochromatic image that creates a powerful atmosphere of raw power, tension, and unstoppable mechanical kinetic energy.", + "seed": 7695, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_11/index_8611_seed_7695_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.060854395106434825, + "vlm_logprob": -0.060854395106434825, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.060854395106434825, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy battle tank painted in dark olive green and earth-toned camouflage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armored hull thickly coated with mud and grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank move at high speed across a vast, desolate, muddy plain while crushing the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks send chunks of dark, wet mud and slurry high into the air forming a dense, arcing trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03259365260601044 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5325937271118164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03259365260601044, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03259365260601044, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2616415023803711, + 0.2348705232143402, + 0.07096140831708908, + 0.05257011950016022, + 0.06883244961500168, + 0.03212988004088402, + 0.0490088053047657, + 0.13799570500850677, + 0.044755853712558746, + 0.047233738005161285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03259365260601044 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy battle tank painted in dark olive green and earth-toned camouflage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armored hull thickly coated with mud and grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank move at high speed across a vast, desolate, muddy plain while crushing the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks send chunks of dark, wet mud and slurry high into the air forming a dense, arcing trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026382537558674812 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513824462890625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026382537558674812, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026382537558674812, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2870928943157196, + 0.05834538862109184, + 0.12734518945217133, + 0.29647496342658997, + 0.034999072551727295, + 0.016664627939462662, + 0.029486697167158127, + 0.043621402233839035, + 0.03944982588291168, + 0.06651993095874786 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026382537558674812 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy battle tank painted in dark olive green and earth-toned camouflage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armored hull thickly coated with mud and grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank move at high speed across a vast, desolate, muddy plain while crushing the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks send chunks of dark, wet mud and slurry high into the air forming a dense, arcing trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16037064790725708 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103705883026123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16037064790725708, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16037064790725708, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19701464474201202, + 0.12894265353679657, + 0.26108410954475403, + 0.06521962583065033, + 0.08512415736913681, + 0.02820991538465023, + 0.04041653499007225, + 0.05245545506477356, + 0.052307043224573135, + 0.08922585844993591 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16037064790725708 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy battle tank painted in dark olive green and earth-toned camouflage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armored hull thickly coated with mud and grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank move at high speed across a vast, desolate, muddy plain while crushing the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks send chunks of dark, wet mud and slurry high into the air forming a dense, arcing trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005958057940006256 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130958080291748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005958057940006256, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005958057940006256, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2509323060512543, + 0.08689121901988983, + 0.21294692158699036, + 0.09952203184366226, + 0.06361255049705505, + 0.02128087729215622, + 0.025730596855282784, + 0.0710105374455452, + 0.07957282662391663, + 0.08850018680095673 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005958057940006256 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy battle tank painted in dark olive green and earth-toned camouflage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armored hull thickly coated with mud and grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank move at high speed across a vast, desolate, muddy plain while crushing the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks send chunks of dark, wet mud and slurry high into the air forming a dense, arcing trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07896707952022552 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789670944213867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07896707952022552, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07896707952022552, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17078350484371185, + 0.21496005356311798, + 0.10082144290208817, + 0.10825525969266891, + 0.06260886043310165, + 0.03600148856639862, + 0.04942924156785011, + 0.15036623179912567, + 0.07103179395198822, + 0.03574215993285179 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07896707952022552 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle tracking shot follows a heavy main battle tank as it speeds across a vast, desolate, muddy plain. Painted in a dark olive green and earth-toned camouflage, the tank's armored hull is thickly coated with mud and grime. The diffuse light of a dull, overcast sky gives the metal a cold, faint sheen. Its massive, segmented metal tracks relentlessly crush the soft earth at high speed, each rotation violently sending chunks of dark, wet mud and slurry high into the air, forming a dense, arcing trail. Some of the mud even splashes back onto the tank's chassis. The tank's massive frame jolts slightly over the uneven terrain, its long gun barrel pointing steadily forward. The roar of its engine intertwines with the thump of its tracks, creating a chilling, monochromatic image that creates a powerful atmosphere of raw power, tension, and unstoppable mechanical kinetic energy.", + "seed": 7696, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_11/index_8611_seed_7696_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.12362863719463349, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12362863719463349, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12362863719463349, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy battle tank painted in dark olive green and earth-toned camouflage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armored hull thickly coated with mud and grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank move at high speed across a vast, desolate, muddy plain while crushing the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks send chunks of dark, wet mud and slurry high into the air forming a dense, arcing trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02914353832602501 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6541435718536377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02914353832602501, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02914353832602501, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14278432726860046, + 0.1027168408036232, + 0.13366790115833282, + 0.05143769085407257, + 0.11444118618965149, + 0.06763528287410736, + 0.07454746216535568, + 0.19688157737255096, + 0.03842621669173241, + 0.07746144384145737 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02914353832602501 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy battle tank painted in dark olive green and earth-toned camouflage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armored hull thickly coated with mud and grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank move at high speed across a vast, desolate, muddy plain while crushing the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks send chunks of dark, wet mud and slurry high into the air forming a dense, arcing trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05500100925564766 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300010204315186 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05500100925564766, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05500100925564766, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4485075771808624, + 0.046472758054733276, + 0.09872777760028839, + 0.043130893260240555, + 0.06973626464605331, + 0.03606296330690384, + 0.024212690070271492, + 0.1093437522649765, + 0.05382227152585983, + 0.06998299807310104 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05500100925564766 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy battle tank painted in dark olive green and earth-toned camouflage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armored hull thickly coated with mud and grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank move at high speed across a vast, desolate, muddy plain while crushing the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks send chunks of dark, wet mud and slurry high into the air forming a dense, arcing trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4288879334926605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.053887963294983 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4288879334926605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4288879334926605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22171232104301453, + 0.07237832248210907, + 0.05192131921648979, + 0.1349528282880783, + 0.20417262613773346, + 0.02130942977964878, + 0.025696080178022385, + 0.0491330623626709, + 0.08494095504283905, + 0.13378311693668365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4288879334926605 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy battle tank painted in dark olive green and earth-toned camouflage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armored hull thickly coated with mud and grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank move at high speed across a vast, desolate, muddy plain while crushing the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks send chunks of dark, wet mud and slurry high into the air forming a dense, arcing trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016079746186733246 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141079902648926 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016079746186733246, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016079746186733246, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.43316376209259033, + 0.07952727377414703, + 0.07299859076738358, + 0.06560379266738892, + 0.11249221116304398, + 0.021848786622285843, + 0.06848669797182083, + 0.03516107425093651, + 0.029683910310268402, + 0.08103390038013458 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016079746186733246 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy battle tank painted in dark olive green and earth-toned camouflage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armored hull thickly coated with mud and grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank move at high speed across a vast, desolate, muddy plain while crushing the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks send chunks of dark, wet mud and slurry high into the air forming a dense, arcing trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08903095871210098 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640309810638428 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08903095871210098, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08903095871210098, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18302582204341888, + 0.06287020444869995, + 0.20860587060451508, + 0.15233926475048065, + 0.14542323350906372, + 0.024392439052462578, + 0.07384361326694489, + 0.01662430539727211, + 0.047479961067438126, + 0.08539525419473648 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08903095871210098 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle tracking shot follows a heavy main battle tank as it speeds across a vast, desolate, muddy plain. Painted in a dark olive green and earth-toned camouflage, the tank's armored hull is thickly coated with mud and grime. The diffuse light of a dull, overcast sky gives the metal a cold, faint sheen. Its massive, segmented metal tracks relentlessly crush the soft earth at high speed, each rotation violently sending chunks of dark, wet mud and slurry high into the air, forming a dense, arcing trail. Some of the mud even splashes back onto the tank's chassis. The tank's massive frame jolts slightly over the uneven terrain, its long gun barrel pointing steadily forward. The roar of its engine intertwines with the thump of its tracks, creating a chilling, monochromatic image that creates a powerful atmosphere of raw power, tension, and unstoppable mechanical kinetic energy.", + "seed": 7697, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_11/index_8611_seed_7697_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.02911871988326311, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02911871988326311, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02911871988326311, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy battle tank painted in dark olive green and earth-toned camouflage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armored hull thickly coated with mud and grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank move at high speed across a vast, desolate, muddy plain while crushing the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks send chunks of dark, wet mud and slurry high into the air forming a dense, arcing trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.028818361461162567 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.653818368911743 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.028818361461162567, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.028818361461162567, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14050763845443726, + 0.11139961332082748, + 0.07339977473020554, + 0.059572733938694, + 0.08657106012105942, + 0.3004876375198364, + 0.04917163774371147, + 0.06844113022089005, + 0.05124848335981369, + 0.05920029431581497 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.028818361461162567 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy battle tank painted in dark olive green and earth-toned camouflage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armored hull thickly coated with mud and grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank move at high speed across a vast, desolate, muddy plain while crushing the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks send chunks of dark, wet mud and slurry high into the air forming a dense, arcing trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02982667088508606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298266410827637 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02982667088508606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02982667088508606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1992674022912979, + 0.0940227210521698, + 0.13087858259677887, + 0.15498089790344238, + 0.07931458204984665, + 0.1213957816362381, + 0.06350497901439667, + 0.06083337590098381, + 0.0460333488881588, + 0.04976840689778328 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02982667088508606 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy battle tank painted in dark olive green and earth-toned camouflage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armored hull thickly coated with mud and grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank move at high speed across a vast, desolate, muddy plain while crushing the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks send chunks of dark, wet mud and slurry high into the air forming a dense, arcing trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029807694256305695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298078060150146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029807694256305695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029807694256305695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11676830053329468, + 0.12018506228923798, + 0.17883102595806122, + 0.1330156922340393, + 0.19963683187961578, + 0.07365267723798752, + 0.04163162782788277, + 0.03988862410187721, + 0.05117236077785492, + 0.04521774873137474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029807694256305695 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy battle tank painted in dark olive green and earth-toned camouflage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armored hull thickly coated with mud and grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank move at high speed across a vast, desolate, muddy plain while crushing the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks send chunks of dark, wet mud and slurry high into the air forming a dense, arcing trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00220282468944788 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127202987670898 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00220282468944788, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00220282468944788, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10604801774024963, + 0.16285991668701172, + 0.23947195708751678, + 0.14356909692287445, + 0.06267999857664108, + 0.07814445346593857, + 0.046218231320381165, + 0.03120984137058258, + 0.08914156258106232, + 0.04065697640180588 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00220282468944788 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavy battle tank painted in dark olive green and earth-toned camouflage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tank's armored hull thickly coated with mud and grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tank move at high speed across a vast, desolate, muddy plain while crushing the earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the tank's tracks send chunks of dark, wet mud and slurry high into the air forming a dense, arcing trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot following the tank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054938048124313354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299380779266357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054938048124313354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054938048124313354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2297111302614212, + 0.10355383157730103, + 0.11453643441200256, + 0.09041903167963028, + 0.0777951255440712, + 0.04806671664118767, + 0.04338056594133377, + 0.13048003613948822, + 0.07785604149103165, + 0.08420110493898392 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054938048124313354 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_12/index_tensor([1126, 1126])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_12/index_tensor([1126, 1126])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..688ba1ff42b751780065db7781522d0e2dfdb0da --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_12/index_tensor([1126, 1126])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The close-up begins with a slow, gentle upward tilt, rendered in the captivating, detailed style of Pixar animation, with the foreground filled with the distinctive heart-shaped leaves of the machiya vine. Each leaf is a masterpiece of stylized realism, its vibrant green surface shimmering with soft, lifelike textures and subtle veins in the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun. The vine's tendrils methodically climb the sun-drenched wooden lattice, its honey-colored wood displaying a tactile, gently weathered grain. The camera's movement follows a single, bright green tendril, which extends with gentle, exploratory motion before making contact with the wood; it then begins to wrap steadily and purposefully around the lattice. As the tendril secures its new position, a tiny, new heart-shaped leaf at its base slowly unfolds, its surface smooth and flawless, capturing a moment of gentle, determined growth. The entire scene is bathed in a warm, saturated palette, with dappled sunlight creating a magical play of light and shadow, lending an atmosphere of peaceful optimism.", + "seed": 19511, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_12/index_1126_seed_19511_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.15006559547036885, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15006559547036885, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15006559547036885, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the foreground feature heart-shaped leaves of the machiya vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, gentle upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright green tendril climb the wooden lattice and wrap around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a tiny new heart-shaped leaf slowly unfold at the base of the tendril?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6461915969848633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7711915969848633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6461915969848633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6461915969848633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.39987650513648987, + 0.062528595328331, + 0.03902298957109451, + 0.05806791037321091, + 0.05130279064178467, + 0.032130446285009384, + 0.05227087438106537, + 0.16919812560081482, + 0.11326130479574203, + 0.022340377792716026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6461915969848633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the foreground feature heart-shaped leaves of the machiya vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, gentle upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright green tendril climb the wooden lattice and wrap around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a tiny new heart-shaped leaf slowly unfold at the base of the tendril?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016113296151161194 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14111328125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016113296151161194, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016113296151161194, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2411738634109497, + 0.054479051381349564, + 0.2581401467323303, + 0.04549553245306015, + 0.03102322481572628, + 0.01725516840815544, + 0.04255162179470062, + 0.04422258213162422, + 0.09197502583265305, + 0.1736837923526764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016113296151161194 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the foreground feature heart-shaped leaves of the machiya vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, gentle upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright green tendril climb the wooden lattice and wrap around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a tiny new heart-shaped leaf slowly unfold at the base of the tendril?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054943013936281204 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929943084716797 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054943013936281204, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054943013936281204, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05246438458561897, + 0.045554835349321365, + 0.10012346506118774, + 0.058914296329021454, + 0.07346548140048981, + 0.08912823349237442, + 0.0494244247674942, + 0.1533319354057312, + 0.3664226830005646, + 0.01117024663835764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054943013936281204 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the foreground feature heart-shaped leaves of the machiya vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, gentle upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright green tendril climb the wooden lattice and wrap around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a tiny new heart-shaped leaf slowly unfold at the base of the tendril?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009789316914975643 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63478946685791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009789316914975643, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009789316914975643, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19940246641635895, + 0.060473136603832245, + 0.14242926239967346, + 0.0924919992685318, + 0.07452964037656784, + 0.0642048642039299, + 0.05792781338095665, + 0.05502891167998314, + 0.19881296157836914, + 0.05469892919063568 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009789316914975643 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the foreground feature heart-shaped leaves of the machiya vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, gentle upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright green tendril climb the wooden lattice and wrap around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a tiny new heart-shaped leaf slowly unfold at the base of the tendril?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329075336456299 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732906341552734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329075336456299, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329075336456299, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1361784189939499, + 0.06370465457439423, + 0.17840398848056793, + 0.08385229855775833, + 0.12261268496513367, + 0.036445945501327515, + 0.06712884455919266, + 0.05133527144789696, + 0.18126411736011505, + 0.07907377183437347 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329075336456299 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The close-up begins with a slow, gentle upward tilt, rendered in the captivating, detailed style of Pixar animation, with the foreground filled with the distinctive heart-shaped leaves of the machiya vine. Each leaf is a masterpiece of stylized realism, its vibrant green surface shimmering with soft, lifelike textures and subtle veins in the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun. The vine's tendrils methodically climb the sun-drenched wooden lattice, its honey-colored wood displaying a tactile, gently weathered grain. The camera's movement follows a single, bright green tendril, which extends with gentle, exploratory motion before making contact with the wood; it then begins to wrap steadily and purposefully around the lattice. As the tendril secures its new position, a tiny, new heart-shaped leaf at its base slowly unfolds, its surface smooth and flawless, capturing a moment of gentle, determined growth. The entire scene is bathed in a warm, saturated palette, with dappled sunlight creating a magical play of light and shadow, lending an atmosphere of peaceful optimism.", + "seed": 19512, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_12/index_1126_seed_19512_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.27197746075689794, + "vlm_logprob": -0.27197746075689794, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.27197746075689794, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the foreground feature heart-shaped leaves of the machiya vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, gentle upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright green tendril climb the wooden lattice and wrap around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a tiny new heart-shaped leaf slowly unfold at the base of the tendril?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1458024978637695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3958025276660919 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1458024978637695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1458024978637695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1423521637916565, + 0.19185929000377655, + 0.09208893030881882, + 0.052221376448869705, + 0.08428379148244858, + 0.054629117250442505, + 0.0681963562965393, + 0.17016930878162384, + 0.08107856661081314, + 0.06312105804681778 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1458024978637695 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the foreground feature heart-shaped leaves of the machiya vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, gentle upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright green tendril climb the wooden lattice and wrap around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a tiny new heart-shaped leaf slowly unfold at the base of the tendril?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03818175569176674 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288181781768799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03818175569176674, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03818175569176674, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14963608980178833, + 0.06761982291936874, + 0.051216691732406616, + 0.03895192593336105, + 0.04077467322349548, + 0.07269700616598129, + 0.11805304884910583, + 0.2969028055667877, + 0.11131180077791214, + 0.05283616855740547 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03818175569176674 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the foreground feature heart-shaped leaves of the machiya vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, gentle upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright green tendril climb the wooden lattice and wrap around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a tiny new heart-shaped leaf slowly unfold at the base of the tendril?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428045928478241 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178046226501465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428045928478241, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428045928478241, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06662258505821228, + 0.07310622185468674, + 0.08921059221029282, + 0.08385464549064636, + 0.1859523504972458, + 0.1424626260995865, + 0.02428506501019001, + 0.0895276740193367, + 0.14048659801483154, + 0.10449162125587463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428045928478241 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the foreground feature heart-shaped leaves of the machiya vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, gentle upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright green tendril climb the wooden lattice and wrap around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a tiny new heart-shaped leaf slowly unfold at the base of the tendril?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0097969900816679 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634797096252441 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0097969900816679, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0097969900816679, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11199061572551727, + 0.0674016922712326, + 0.03328166902065277, + 0.16630543768405914, + 0.02923577092587948, + 0.048940509557724, + 0.0342104472219944, + 0.23853088915348053, + 0.21757903695106506, + 0.052523866295814514 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0097969900816679 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the foreground feature heart-shaped leaves of the machiya vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, gentle upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright green tendril climb the wooden lattice and wrap around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a tiny new heart-shaped leaf slowly unfold at the base of the tendril?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023301467299461365 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773301362991333 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023301467299461365, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023301467299461365, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10424277186393738, + 0.03852396830916405, + 0.026231881231069565, + 0.31939566135406494, + 0.06260219216346741, + 0.09345654398202896, + 0.0734502300620079, + 0.07779175788164139, + 0.17033790051937103, + 0.03396705165505409 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023301467299461365 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The close-up begins with a slow, gentle upward tilt, rendered in the captivating, detailed style of Pixar animation, with the foreground filled with the distinctive heart-shaped leaves of the machiya vine. Each leaf is a masterpiece of stylized realism, its vibrant green surface shimmering with soft, lifelike textures and subtle veins in the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun. The vine's tendrils methodically climb the sun-drenched wooden lattice, its honey-colored wood displaying a tactile, gently weathered grain. The camera's movement follows a single, bright green tendril, which extends with gentle, exploratory motion before making contact with the wood; it then begins to wrap steadily and purposefully around the lattice. As the tendril secures its new position, a tiny, new heart-shaped leaf at its base slowly unfolds, its surface smooth and flawless, capturing a moment of gentle, determined growth. The entire scene is bathed in a warm, saturated palette, with dappled sunlight creating a magical play of light and shadow, lending an atmosphere of peaceful optimism.", + "seed": 19513, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_12/index_1126_seed_19513_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.28295916486531497, + "vlm_logprob": -0.28295916486531497, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.28295916486531497, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the foreground feature heart-shaped leaves of the machiya vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, gentle upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright green tendril climb the wooden lattice and wrap around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a tiny new heart-shaped leaf slowly unfold at the base of the tendril?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.227939248085022 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.35293927788734436 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.227939248085022, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.227939248085022, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4689379036426544, + 0.016278410330414772, + 0.11155645549297333, + 0.03953917697072029, + 0.13634078204631805, + 0.08854363858699799, + 0.02865815907716751, + 0.012320460751652718, + 0.07122725993394852, + 0.02659769542515278 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.227939248085022 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the foreground feature heart-shaped leaves of the machiya vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, gentle upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright green tendril climb the wooden lattice and wrap around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a tiny new heart-shaped leaf slowly unfold at the base of the tendril?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029878389090299606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298783779144287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029878389090299606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029878389090299606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33667099475860596, + 0.07159020006656647, + 0.06345771253108978, + 0.0905827209353447, + 0.11085759103298187, + 0.07042433321475983, + 0.09628243744373322, + 0.10495561361312866, + 0.0349617525935173, + 0.020216641947627068 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029878389090299606 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the foreground feature heart-shaped leaves of the machiya vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, gentle upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright green tendril climb the wooden lattice and wrap around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a tiny new heart-shaped leaf slowly unfold at the base of the tendril?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11294405907392502 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379441261291504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11294405907392502, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11294405907392502, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17062637209892273, + 0.02138027921319008, + 0.17467200756072998, + 0.06141190975904465, + 0.07822296768426895, + 0.1610855907201767, + 0.026199936866760254, + 0.13176114857196808, + 0.15372757613658905, + 0.020912207663059235 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11294405907392502 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the foreground feature heart-shaped leaves of the machiya vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, gentle upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright green tendril climb the wooden lattice and wrap around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a tiny new heart-shaped leaf slowly unfold at the base of the tendril?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014218335039913654 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264218330383301 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014218335039913654, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014218335039913654, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5478283762931824, + 0.027390863746404648, + 0.10574551671743393, + 0.04821351170539856, + 0.08530310541391373, + 0.0728919580578804, + 0.01202179491519928, + 0.05763489380478859, + 0.02088024467229843, + 0.022089794278144836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014218335039913654 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the foreground feature heart-shaped leaves of the machiya vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, gentle upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright green tendril climb the wooden lattice and wrap around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a tiny new heart-shaped leaf slowly unfold at the base of the tendril?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02981579303741455 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529815673828125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02981579303741455, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02981579303741455, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2999761998653412, + 0.08087671548128128, + 0.21019607782363892, + 0.07912985235452652, + 0.06873160600662231, + 0.07022824883460999, + 0.05405231937766075, + 0.07676534354686737, + 0.03157010301947594, + 0.02847352810204029 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02981579303741455 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The close-up begins with a slow, gentle upward tilt, rendered in the captivating, detailed style of Pixar animation, with the foreground filled with the distinctive heart-shaped leaves of the machiya vine. Each leaf is a masterpiece of stylized realism, its vibrant green surface shimmering with soft, lifelike textures and subtle veins in the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun. The vine's tendrils methodically climb the sun-drenched wooden lattice, its honey-colored wood displaying a tactile, gently weathered grain. The camera's movement follows a single, bright green tendril, which extends with gentle, exploratory motion before making contact with the wood; it then begins to wrap steadily and purposefully around the lattice. As the tendril secures its new position, a tiny, new heart-shaped leaf at its base slowly unfolds, its surface smooth and flawless, capturing a moment of gentle, determined growth. The entire scene is bathed in a warm, saturated palette, with dappled sunlight creating a magical play of light and shadow, lending an atmosphere of peaceful optimism.", + "seed": 19514, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_12/index_1126_seed_19514_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2169390563853085, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2169390563853085, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2169390563853085, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the foreground feature heart-shaped leaves of the machiya vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, gentle upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright green tendril climb the wooden lattice and wrap around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a tiny new heart-shaped leaf slowly unfold at the base of the tendril?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9027078747749329 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5277078747749329 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9027078747749329, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9027078747749329, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26817193627357483, + 0.07663801312446594, + 0.08596578985452652, + 0.08645612001419067, + 0.09981882572174072, + 0.09776299446821213, + 0.08320944011211395, + 0.0838293507695198, + 0.06295151263475418, + 0.055196020752191544 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9027078747749329 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the foreground feature heart-shaped leaves of the machiya vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, gentle upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright green tendril climb the wooden lattice and wrap around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a tiny new heart-shaped leaf slowly unfold at the base of the tendril?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0264043640345335 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.65140438079834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0264043640345335, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0264043640345335, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2398274838924408, + 0.08738841861486435, + 0.025611940771341324, + 0.12504537403583527, + 0.08994380384683609, + 0.04382400959730148, + 0.1598532348871231, + 0.04782823473215103, + 0.05207422748208046, + 0.12860321998596191 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0264043640345335 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the foreground feature heart-shaped leaves of the machiya vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, gentle upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright green tendril climb the wooden lattice and wrap around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a tiny new heart-shaped leaf slowly unfold at the base of the tendril?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12702947854995728 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270294189453125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12702947854995728, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12702947854995728, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09692174196243286, + 0.10509449988603592, + 0.1137690544128418, + 0.18749064207077026, + 0.17968766391277313, + 0.07933147251605988, + 0.0552002377808094, + 0.07736454904079437, + 0.06305326521396637, + 0.04208690673112869 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12702947854995728 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the foreground feature heart-shaped leaves of the machiya vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, gentle upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright green tendril climb the wooden lattice and wrap around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a tiny new heart-shaped leaf slowly unfold at the base of the tendril?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005263044033199549 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255262851715088 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005263044033199549, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005263044033199549, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10633821785449982, + 0.1879328489303589, + 0.06437161564826965, + 0.073432557284832, + 0.09249624609947205, + 0.08344696462154388, + 0.09878074377775192, + 0.06460636854171753, + 0.08273027092218399, + 0.1458640843629837 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005263044033199549 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in the detailed style of Pixar animation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the foreground feature heart-shaped leaves of the machiya vine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a slow, gentle upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright green tendril climb the wooden lattice and wrap around it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a tiny new heart-shaped leaf slowly unfold at the base of the tendril?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023290520533919334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732906341552734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023290520533919334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023290520533919334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.095231793820858, + 0.1021660789847374, + 0.0943332239985466, + 0.047984667122364044, + 0.11410031467676163, + 0.0605861134827137, + 0.3063800036907196, + 0.07172564417123795, + 0.03074873797595501, + 0.0767434611916542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023290520533919334 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_13/index_tensor([5555, 5555])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_13/index_tensor([5555, 5555])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..55a21738c70f61512051f22074bab90a94cd16f1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_13/index_tensor([5555, 5555])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle close-up captures a well-seasoned black cast iron skillet resting on the black metal grate of a kitchen stove. The pan is filled with bacon grease, which slowly and relentlessly solidifies as it cools. Illuminated by the soft, diffuse light of a quiet morning, this transformation is revealed in minute detail: a waxy, opaque, milky solid has formed around the pan's cooler perimeter, its matte surface steadily creeping inward. This solidified fat contrasts sharply with the shrinking mass of still-warm, translucent amber liquid at the pan's center, which holds a last vestige of heat. Suspended and frozen within the solidified grease are tiny, deep reddish-brown, crispy remnants of cooked bacon. The entire process unfolds in a silent, deliberate sequence, as the final mass of liquid loses its luster and succumbs to the eroding solidification, creating a scene of quiet, still, ordinary domestic aftermath.", + "seed": 4520, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_13/index_5555_seed_4520_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.029246839764527976, + "vlm_logprob": -0.029246839764527976, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.029246839764527976, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a black cast iron skillet on a black metal grate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show bacon grease slowly solidifying from a translucent amber liquid into a waxy, opaque, milky solid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tiny, deep reddish-brown crispy bacon remnants visible suspended within the solidified grease?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the solidification shown creeping inward from the cooler perimeter while the center remains a shrinking mass of liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light consistent with a quiet morning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06079671531915665 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9357967376708984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06079671531915665, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06079671531915665, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13529427349567413, + 0.10508082062005997, + 0.23151883482933044, + 0.051987551152706146, + 0.03183869644999504, + 0.09686873853206635, + 0.014367842115461826, + 0.03433893993496895, + 0.28158971667289734, + 0.01711462251842022 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06079671531915665 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a black cast iron skillet on a black metal grate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show bacon grease slowly solidifying from a translucent amber liquid into a waxy, opaque, milky solid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tiny, deep reddish-brown crispy bacon remnants visible suspended within the solidified grease?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the solidification shown creeping inward from the cooler perimeter while the center remains a shrinking mass of liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light consistent with a quiet morning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026401925832033157 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651401996612549 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026401925832033157, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026401925832033157, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1073601022362709, + 0.08289003372192383, + 0.032003115862607956, + 0.1564909666776657, + 0.038803454488515854, + 0.17419523000717163, + 0.025408219546079636, + 0.011455981992185116, + 0.35699203610420227, + 0.014400813728570938 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026401925832033157 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a black cast iron skillet on a black metal grate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show bacon grease slowly solidifying from a translucent amber liquid into a waxy, opaque, milky solid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tiny, deep reddish-brown crispy bacon remnants visible suspended within the solidified grease?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the solidification shown creeping inward from the cooler perimeter while the center remains a shrinking mass of liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light consistent with a quiet morning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019518149783834815 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251951694488525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019518149783834815, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019518149783834815, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.029315439984202385, + 0.012711696326732635, + 0.03990978002548218, + 0.022994963452219963, + 0.01775042526423931, + 0.037414196878671646, + 0.004428687039762735, + 0.010664145462214947, + 0.8029288053512573, + 0.02188192494213581 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019518149783834815 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a black cast iron skillet on a black metal grate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show bacon grease slowly solidifying from a translucent amber liquid into a waxy, opaque, milky solid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tiny, deep reddish-brown crispy bacon remnants visible suspended within the solidified grease?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the solidification shown creeping inward from the cooler perimeter while the center remains a shrinking mass of liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light consistent with a quiet morning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023316258564591408 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733161449432373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023316258564591408, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023316258564591408, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11428244411945343, + 0.04650719836354256, + 0.08425680547952652, + 0.10376980155706406, + 0.05397626385092735, + 0.10536298155784607, + 0.029833128675818443, + 0.02109271101653576, + 0.42571815848350525, + 0.015200518071651459 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023316258564591408 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a black cast iron skillet on a black metal grate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show bacon grease slowly solidifying from a translucent amber liquid into a waxy, opaque, milky solid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tiny, deep reddish-brown crispy bacon remnants visible suspended within the solidified grease?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the solidification shown creeping inward from the cooler perimeter while the center remains a shrinking mass of liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light consistent with a quiet morning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03376748412847519 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087674617767334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03376748412847519, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03376748412847519, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17186324298381805, + 0.09399563819169998, + 0.13652093708515167, + 0.04478372633457184, + 0.022814691066741943, + 0.07011624425649643, + 0.05257955193519592, + 0.04119959473609924, + 0.34626927971839905, + 0.019857101142406464 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03376748412847519 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle close-up captures a well-seasoned black cast iron skillet resting on the black metal grate of a kitchen stove. The pan is filled with bacon grease, which slowly and relentlessly solidifies as it cools. Illuminated by the soft, diffuse light of a quiet morning, this transformation is revealed in minute detail: a waxy, opaque, milky solid has formed around the pan's cooler perimeter, its matte surface steadily creeping inward. This solidified fat contrasts sharply with the shrinking mass of still-warm, translucent amber liquid at the pan's center, which holds a last vestige of heat. Suspended and frozen within the solidified grease are tiny, deep reddish-brown, crispy remnants of cooked bacon. The entire process unfolds in a silent, deliberate sequence, as the final mass of liquid loses its luster and succumbs to the eroding solidification, creating a scene of quiet, still, ordinary domestic aftermath.", + "seed": 4521, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_13/index_5555_seed_4521_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.030600813194178046, + "vlm_logprob": -0.030600813194178046, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.030600813194178046, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a black cast iron skillet on a black metal grate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show bacon grease slowly solidifying from a translucent amber liquid into a waxy, opaque, milky solid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tiny, deep reddish-brown crispy bacon remnants visible suspended within the solidified grease?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the solidification shown creeping inward from the cooler perimeter while the center remains a shrinking mass of liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light consistent with a quiet morning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.035047564655542374 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5350475311279297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.035047564655542374, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.035047564655542374, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3435904085636139, + 0.07763122022151947, + 0.13182246685028076, + 0.11069631576538086, + 0.02916206419467926, + 0.07676944881677628, + 0.019345257431268692, + 0.046782732009887695, + 0.14288897812366486, + 0.021311087533831596 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.035047564655542374 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a black cast iron skillet on a black metal grate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show bacon grease slowly solidifying from a translucent amber liquid into a waxy, opaque, milky solid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tiny, deep reddish-brown crispy bacon remnants visible suspended within the solidified grease?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the solidification shown creeping inward from the cooler perimeter while the center remains a shrinking mass of liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light consistent with a quiet morning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03376494720578194 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087648391723633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03376494720578194, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03376494720578194, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.153865247964859, + 0.09695801138877869, + 0.1928541362285614, + 0.07061230391263962, + 0.08565202355384827, + 0.07412660866975784, + 0.07661247253417969, + 0.049627386033535004, + 0.14307835698127747, + 0.0566135011613369 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03376494720578194 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a black cast iron skillet on a black metal grate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show bacon grease slowly solidifying from a translucent amber liquid into a waxy, opaque, milky solid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tiny, deep reddish-brown crispy bacon remnants visible suspended within the solidified grease?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the solidification shown creeping inward from the cooler perimeter while the center remains a shrinking mass of liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light consistent with a quiet morning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017253764672204852 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376725196838379 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017253764672204852, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017253764672204852, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14356182515621185, + 0.09665941447019577, + 0.3192902207374573, + 0.06197812408208847, + 0.040953923016786575, + 0.08696299046278, + 0.07365640252828598, + 0.04561125859618187, + 0.07477651536464691, + 0.05654935911297798 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017253764672204852 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a black cast iron skillet on a black metal grate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show bacon grease slowly solidifying from a translucent amber liquid into a waxy, opaque, milky solid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tiny, deep reddish-brown crispy bacon remnants visible suspended within the solidified grease?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the solidification shown creeping inward from the cooler perimeter while the center remains a shrinking mass of liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light consistent with a quiet morning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033735211938619614 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087352752685547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033735211938619614, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033735211938619614, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1698468178510666, + 0.04176625236868858, + 0.30391618609428406, + 0.08927315473556519, + 0.028080178424715996, + 0.05448557063937187, + 0.06714928150177002, + 0.0894312933087349, + 0.12094470858573914, + 0.035106558352708817 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033735211938619614 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a black cast iron skillet on a black metal grate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show bacon grease slowly solidifying from a translucent amber liquid into a waxy, opaque, milky solid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tiny, deep reddish-brown crispy bacon remnants visible suspended within the solidified grease?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the solidification shown creeping inward from the cooler perimeter while the center remains a shrinking mass of liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light consistent with a quiet morning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048730965703725815 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0487308502197266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048730965703725815, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048730965703725815, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09975028783082962, + 0.06581845134496689, + 0.48787638545036316, + 0.06544531881809235, + 0.02985190413892269, + 0.05986719951033592, + 0.02338685281574726, + 0.05196961760520935, + 0.08756176382303238, + 0.02847227267920971 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048730965703725815 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle close-up captures a well-seasoned black cast iron skillet resting on the black metal grate of a kitchen stove. The pan is filled with bacon grease, which slowly and relentlessly solidifies as it cools. Illuminated by the soft, diffuse light of a quiet morning, this transformation is revealed in minute detail: a waxy, opaque, milky solid has formed around the pan's cooler perimeter, its matte surface steadily creeping inward. This solidified fat contrasts sharply with the shrinking mass of still-warm, translucent amber liquid at the pan's center, which holds a last vestige of heat. Suspended and frozen within the solidified grease are tiny, deep reddish-brown, crispy remnants of cooked bacon. The entire process unfolds in a silent, deliberate sequence, as the final mass of liquid loses its luster and succumbs to the eroding solidification, creating a scene of quiet, still, ordinary domestic aftermath.", + "seed": 4522, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_13/index_5555_seed_4522_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.025653344113379717, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025653344113379717, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025653344113379717, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a black cast iron skillet on a black metal grate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show bacon grease slowly solidifying from a translucent amber liquid into a waxy, opaque, milky solid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tiny, deep reddish-brown crispy bacon remnants visible suspended within the solidified grease?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the solidification shown creeping inward from the cooler perimeter while the center remains a shrinking mass of liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light consistent with a quiet morning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023441096767783165 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.023441314697266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023441096767783165, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023441096767783165, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11695162206888199, + 0.3007933795452118, + 0.10330269485712051, + 0.1341642588376999, + 0.06745518743991852, + 0.058726198971271515, + 0.06747258454561234, + 0.06362584978342056, + 0.05765141546726227, + 0.0298568457365036 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023441096767783165 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a black cast iron skillet on a black metal grate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show bacon grease slowly solidifying from a translucent amber liquid into a waxy, opaque, milky solid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tiny, deep reddish-brown crispy bacon remnants visible suspended within the solidified grease?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the solidification shown creeping inward from the cooler perimeter while the center remains a shrinking mass of liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light consistent with a quiet morning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02640540897846222 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6514053344726562 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02640540897846222, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02640540897846222, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.091629259288311, + 0.14137035608291626, + 0.08942209184169769, + 0.23244929313659668, + 0.14755535125732422, + 0.07083383947610855, + 0.06226231902837753, + 0.06933996081352234, + 0.03842734172940254, + 0.056710150092840195 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02640540897846222 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a black cast iron skillet on a black metal grate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show bacon grease slowly solidifying from a translucent amber liquid into a waxy, opaque, milky solid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tiny, deep reddish-brown crispy bacon remnants visible suspended within the solidified grease?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the solidification shown creeping inward from the cooler perimeter while the center remains a shrinking mass of liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light consistent with a quiet morning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015240018256008625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501523971557617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015240018256008625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015240018256008625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08821960538625717, + 0.08444241434335709, + 0.08599471300840378, + 0.14270398020744324, + 0.061992306262254715, + 0.05622828006744385, + 0.0786883607506752, + 0.05860530585050583, + 0.03475894033908844, + 0.3083661198616028 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015240018256008625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a black cast iron skillet on a black metal grate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show bacon grease slowly solidifying from a translucent amber liquid into a waxy, opaque, milky solid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tiny, deep reddish-brown crispy bacon remnants visible suspended within the solidified grease?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the solidification shown creeping inward from the cooler perimeter while the center remains a shrinking mass of liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light consistent with a quiet morning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0431024506688118 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168102502822876 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0431024506688118, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0431024506688118, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12974222004413605, + 0.1385287642478943, + 0.14426149427890778, + 0.15826697647571564, + 0.09850269556045532, + 0.04844484105706215, + 0.028332680463790894, + 0.10305231809616089, + 0.08022815734148026, + 0.07063978910446167 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0431024506688118 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a black cast iron skillet on a black metal grate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show bacon grease slowly solidifying from a translucent amber liquid into a waxy, opaque, milky solid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tiny, deep reddish-brown crispy bacon remnants visible suspended within the solidified grease?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the solidification shown creeping inward from the cooler perimeter while the center remains a shrinking mass of liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light consistent with a quiet morning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03379376232624054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087936878204346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03379376232624054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03379376232624054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13394685089588165, + 0.18941007554531097, + 0.1545872986316681, + 0.12541531026363373, + 0.05843024328351021, + 0.1449587345123291, + 0.05750897899270058, + 0.0344218872487545, + 0.04989265277981758, + 0.051427990198135376 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03379376232624054 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle close-up captures a well-seasoned black cast iron skillet resting on the black metal grate of a kitchen stove. The pan is filled with bacon grease, which slowly and relentlessly solidifies as it cools. Illuminated by the soft, diffuse light of a quiet morning, this transformation is revealed in minute detail: a waxy, opaque, milky solid has formed around the pan's cooler perimeter, its matte surface steadily creeping inward. This solidified fat contrasts sharply with the shrinking mass of still-warm, translucent amber liquid at the pan's center, which holds a last vestige of heat. Suspended and frozen within the solidified grease are tiny, deep reddish-brown, crispy remnants of cooked bacon. The entire process unfolds in a silent, deliberate sequence, as the final mass of liquid loses its luster and succumbs to the eroding solidification, creating a scene of quiet, still, ordinary domestic aftermath.", + "seed": 4523, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_13/index_5555_seed_4523_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.09779575015418232, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09779575015418232, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09779575015418232, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a black cast iron skillet on a black metal grate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show bacon grease slowly solidifying from a translucent amber liquid into a waxy, opaque, milky solid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tiny, deep reddish-brown crispy bacon remnants visible suspended within the solidified grease?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the solidification shown creeping inward from the cooler perimeter while the center remains a shrinking mass of liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light consistent with a quiet morning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18410952389240265 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8091095685958862 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18410952389240265, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18410952389240265, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26227790117263794, + 0.15721943974494934, + 0.07072000205516815, + 0.11154165863990784, + 0.15037907660007477, + 0.04615597799420357, + 0.05040695145726204, + 0.03215848281979561, + 0.05153220146894455, + 0.06760825961828232 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18410952389240265 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a black cast iron skillet on a black metal grate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show bacon grease slowly solidifying from a translucent amber liquid into a waxy, opaque, milky solid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tiny, deep reddish-brown crispy bacon remnants visible suspended within the solidified grease?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the solidification shown creeping inward from the cooler perimeter while the center remains a shrinking mass of liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light consistent with a quiet morning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16046872735023499 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104686975479126 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16046872735023499, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16046872735023499, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15529729425907135, + 0.2736753225326538, + 0.20882385969161987, + 0.03764580562710762, + 0.06999371945858002, + 0.04319579899311066, + 0.056321240961551666, + 0.08692755550146103, + 0.03354046121239662, + 0.03457895293831825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16046872735023499 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a black cast iron skillet on a black metal grate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show bacon grease slowly solidifying from a translucent amber liquid into a waxy, opaque, milky solid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tiny, deep reddish-brown crispy bacon remnants visible suspended within the solidified grease?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the solidification shown creeping inward from the cooler perimeter while the center remains a shrinking mass of liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light consistent with a quiet morning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015256681945174932 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.50152587890625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015256681945174932, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015256681945174932, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15718363225460052, + 0.15409265458583832, + 0.08016028255224228, + 0.1146753653883934, + 0.1263313591480255, + 0.07166940718889236, + 0.07675716280937195, + 0.08776775002479553, + 0.05897261202335358, + 0.07238975167274475 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015256681945174932 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a black cast iron skillet on a black metal grate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show bacon grease slowly solidifying from a translucent amber liquid into a waxy, opaque, milky solid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tiny, deep reddish-brown crispy bacon remnants visible suspended within the solidified grease?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the solidification shown creeping inward from the cooler perimeter while the center remains a shrinking mass of liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light consistent with a quiet morning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11301379650831223 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.238013744354248 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11301379650831223, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11301379650831223, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21033939719200134, + 0.1739458441734314, + 0.15017913281917572, + 0.13348239660263062, + 0.0320962592959404, + 0.06639450788497925, + 0.025304922834038734, + 0.07058440893888474, + 0.023643815889954567, + 0.11402937024831772 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11301379650831223 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle close-up of a black cast iron skillet on a black metal grate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show bacon grease slowly solidifying from a translucent amber liquid into a waxy, opaque, milky solid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are tiny, deep reddish-brown crispy bacon remnants visible suspended within the solidified grease?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the solidification shown creeping inward from the cooler perimeter while the center remains a shrinking mass of liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light consistent with a quiet morning?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02986103482544422 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298609733581543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02986103482544422, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02986103482544422, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24564404785633087, + 0.169832244515419, + 0.09599675238132477, + 0.11293800920248032, + 0.06992300599813461, + 0.07811451703310013, + 0.09124402701854706, + 0.023911044001579285, + 0.04209483414888382, + 0.07030145823955536 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02986103482544422 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_14/index_tensor([705, 705])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_14/index_tensor([705, 705])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..27585ca45306c377c1e25009b6b481107c91755b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_14/index_tensor([705, 705])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a breathtakingly high-speed sports documentary, a sweeping, low-angle tracking shot gracefully circles a basketball player resembling D'Angelo Russell, capturing his fall in stunning super-slow motion. The camera follows his desperate, acrobatic tumble after a mid-air collision. The player, with short, textured braids, is drenched in sweat, his face contorted in a mask of intense focus and controlled pain. His athletic frame is clad in a sweat-soaked basketball jersey and shorts, clinging to his strained muscles. As he descends, his body contorts in a display of raw athleticism, one arm reaching for the floor to break his fall. The scene is illuminated by bright, high-contrast overhead stadium lights, which cast sharp, mirrored highlights on the highly polished wooden court floor and gleam on the sweat that flies from his body. In the background, a beautifully rendered bokeh of the packed arena appears, with the crowd and distant scoreboard blurred into abstract shapes of light and color. He crashed to the polished floor, his shoulder taking the brunt of the blow, then deftly channeled the momentum into a chaotic yet controlled tumble, his limbs moving with a fluid desperation that underscored the sheer violence and grace of the moment.", + "seed": 28553, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_14/index_705_seed_28553_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.09757604785263538, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09757604785263538, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.9499999284744263, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09757604785263538, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a basketball player resembling D'Angelo Russell with short, textured braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the player wearing a sweat-soaked basketball jersey and shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the player falling after a mid-air collision with one arm reaching for the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, high-contrast overhead stadium lights casting sharp highlights on a polished wooden court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping, low-angle tracking shot that circles the player in super-slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2844487428665161 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4094487428665161 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2844487428665161, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2844487428665161, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.028021514415740967, + 0.010509133338928223, + 0.015774322673678398, + 0.011728737503290176, + 0.05817447975277901, + 0.022254500538110733, + 0.19651077687740326, + 0.020831968635320663, + 0.6128314733505249, + 0.023363100364804268 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2844487428665161 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a basketball player resembling D'Angelo Russell with short, textured braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the player wearing a sweat-soaked basketball jersey and shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the player falling after a mid-air collision with one arm reaching for the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, high-contrast overhead stadium lights casting sharp highlights on a polished wooden court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping, low-angle tracking shot that circles the player in super-slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018220549449324608 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0182204246521 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018220549449324608, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018220549449324608, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19727598130702972, + 0.027359412983059883, + 0.05390894412994385, + 0.015105275437235832, + 0.0679716244339943, + 0.08880504965782166, + 0.2638727128505707, + 0.15102790296077728, + 0.0856890082359314, + 0.04898407682776451 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018220549449324608 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a basketball player resembling D'Angelo Russell with short, textured braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the player wearing a sweat-soaked basketball jersey and shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the player falling after a mid-air collision with one arm reaching for the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, high-contrast overhead stadium lights casting sharp highlights on a polished wooden court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping, low-angle tracking shot that circles the player in super-slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607939414680004 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141079425811768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607939414680004, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607939414680004, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10128557682037354, + 0.022263022139668465, + 0.039933931082487106, + 0.02147078886628151, + 0.01940271072089672, + 0.08826985955238342, + 0.15955978631973267, + 0.07512830197811127, + 0.45479512214660645, + 0.017890892922878265 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607939414680004 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a basketball player resembling D'Angelo Russell with short, textured braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the player wearing a sweat-soaked basketball jersey and shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the player falling after a mid-air collision with one arm reaching for the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, high-contrast overhead stadium lights casting sharp highlights on a polished wooden court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping, low-angle tracking shot that circles the player in super-slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026361173018813133 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513612270355225 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026361173018813133, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026361173018813133, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17444583773612976, + 0.04065196216106415, + 0.06413617730140686, + 0.009615009650588036, + 0.025171874091029167, + 0.07840996235609055, + 0.3594260811805725, + 0.0438733734190464, + 0.18109117448329926, + 0.023178525269031525 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026361173018813133 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a basketball player resembling D'Angelo Russell with short, textured braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the player wearing a sweat-soaked basketball jersey and shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the player falling after a mid-air collision with one arm reaching for the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, high-contrast overhead stadium lights casting sharp highlights on a polished wooden court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping, low-angle tracking shot that circles the player in super-slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14277037978172302 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017770290374756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14277037978172302, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14277037978172302, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.073145292699337, + 0.027827201411128044, + 0.03046300634741783, + 0.022431746125221252, + 0.05000009015202522, + 0.05020928382873535, + 0.35315215587615967, + 0.04280885308980942, + 0.3066355586051941, + 0.04332675784826279 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14277037978172302 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a breathtakingly high-speed sports documentary, a sweeping, low-angle tracking shot gracefully circles a basketball player resembling D'Angelo Russell, capturing his fall in stunning super-slow motion. The camera follows his desperate, acrobatic tumble after a mid-air collision. The player, with short, textured braids, is drenched in sweat, his face contorted in a mask of intense focus and controlled pain. His athletic frame is clad in a sweat-soaked basketball jersey and shorts, clinging to his strained muscles. As he descends, his body contorts in a display of raw athleticism, one arm reaching for the floor to break his fall. The scene is illuminated by bright, high-contrast overhead stadium lights, which cast sharp, mirrored highlights on the highly polished wooden court floor and gleam on the sweat that flies from his body. In the background, a beautifully rendered bokeh of the packed arena appears, with the crowd and distant scoreboard blurred into abstract shapes of light and color. He crashed to the polished floor, his shoulder taking the brunt of the blow, then deftly channeled the momentum into a chaotic yet controlled tumble, his limbs moving with a fluid desperation that underscored the sheer violence and grace of the moment.", + "seed": 28554, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_14/index_705_seed_28554_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07459577843546868, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07459577843546868, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07459577843546868, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a basketball player resembling D'Angelo Russell with short, textured braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the player wearing a sweat-soaked basketball jersey and shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the player falling after a mid-air collision with one arm reaching for the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, high-contrast overhead stadium lights casting sharp highlights on a polished wooden court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping, low-angle tracking shot that circles the player in super-slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18279911577701569 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8077991008758545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18279911577701569, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18279911577701569, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09231927245855331, + 0.1219959706068039, + 0.13982228934764862, + 0.12540467083454132, + 0.04535891115665436, + 0.24383309483528137, + 0.0724542960524559, + 0.051384493708610535, + 0.037315260618925095, + 0.07011175155639648 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18279911577701569 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a basketball player resembling D'Angelo Russell with short, textured braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the player wearing a sweat-soaked basketball jersey and shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the player falling after a mid-air collision with one arm reaching for the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, high-contrast overhead stadium lights casting sharp highlights on a polished wooden court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping, low-angle tracking shot that circles the player in super-slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020609283819794655 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956093788146973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020609283819794655, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020609283819794655, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12056393921375275, + 0.154451385140419, + 0.16219963133335114, + 0.06252644211053848, + 0.04696272686123848, + 0.18777193129062653, + 0.12364577502012253, + 0.032398615032434464, + 0.037229154258966446, + 0.0722503513097763 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020609283819794655 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a basketball player resembling D'Angelo Russell with short, textured braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the player wearing a sweat-soaked basketball jersey and shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the player falling after a mid-air collision with one arm reaching for the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, high-contrast overhead stadium lights casting sharp highlights on a polished wooden court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping, low-angle tracking shot that circles the player in super-slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020591532811522484 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955914974212646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020591532811522484, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020591532811522484, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11225235462188721, + 0.07633113861083984, + 0.2427969127893448, + 0.09156828373670578, + 0.15189695358276367, + 0.05407825857400894, + 0.15661120414733887, + 0.03127744421362877, + 0.042012542486190796, + 0.041174884885549545 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020591532811522484 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a basketball player resembling D'Angelo Russell with short, textured braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the player wearing a sweat-soaked basketball jersey and shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the player falling after a mid-air collision with one arm reaching for the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, high-contrast overhead stadium lights casting sharp highlights on a polished wooden court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping, low-angle tracking shot that circles the player in super-slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10033383220434189 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503339290618896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10033383220434189, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10033383220434189, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10250838845968246, + 0.10115185379981995, + 0.18524539470672607, + 0.05230452120304108, + 0.036833908408880234, + 0.32466238737106323, + 0.050010018050670624, + 0.0704403817653656, + 0.0234508216381073, + 0.05339232459664345 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10033383220434189 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a basketball player resembling D'Angelo Russell with short, textured braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the player wearing a sweat-soaked basketball jersey and shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the player falling after a mid-air collision with one arm reaching for the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, high-contrast overhead stadium lights casting sharp highlights on a polished wooden court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping, low-angle tracking shot that circles the player in super-slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048645127564668655 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.04864501953125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048645127564668655, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048645127564668655, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23670761287212372, + 0.0872763991355896, + 0.05276135727763176, + 0.04541196674108505, + 0.06407322734594345, + 0.2682960629463196, + 0.07090084254741669, + 0.08357086777687073, + 0.04932428523898125, + 0.041677325963974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048645127564668655 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a breathtakingly high-speed sports documentary, a sweeping, low-angle tracking shot gracefully circles a basketball player resembling D'Angelo Russell, capturing his fall in stunning super-slow motion. The camera follows his desperate, acrobatic tumble after a mid-air collision. The player, with short, textured braids, is drenched in sweat, his face contorted in a mask of intense focus and controlled pain. His athletic frame is clad in a sweat-soaked basketball jersey and shorts, clinging to his strained muscles. As he descends, his body contorts in a display of raw athleticism, one arm reaching for the floor to break his fall. The scene is illuminated by bright, high-contrast overhead stadium lights, which cast sharp, mirrored highlights on the highly polished wooden court floor and gleam on the sweat that flies from his body. In the background, a beautifully rendered bokeh of the packed arena appears, with the crowd and distant scoreboard blurred into abstract shapes of light and color. He crashed to the polished floor, his shoulder taking the brunt of the blow, then deftly channeled the momentum into a chaotic yet controlled tumble, his limbs moving with a fluid desperation that underscored the sheer violence and grace of the moment.", + "seed": 28555, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_14/index_705_seed_28555_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.16838105022907257, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16838105022907257, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16838105022907257, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a basketball player resembling D'Angelo Russell with short, textured braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the player wearing a sweat-soaked basketball jersey and shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the player falling after a mid-air collision with one arm reaching for the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, high-contrast overhead stadium lights casting sharp highlights on a polished wooden court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping, low-angle tracking shot that circles the player in super-slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28299397230148315 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.407994031906128 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28299397230148315, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28299397230148315, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6037142872810364, + 0.06785621494054794, + 0.07745452225208282, + 0.046694159507751465, + 0.052779074758291245, + 0.03661977872252464, + 0.03520601615309715, + 0.039887357503175735, + 0.024118032306432724, + 0.015670524910092354 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28299397230148315 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a basketball player resembling D'Angelo Russell with short, textured braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the player wearing a sweat-soaked basketball jersey and shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the player falling after a mid-air collision with one arm reaching for the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, high-contrast overhead stadium lights casting sharp highlights on a polished wooden court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping, low-angle tracking shot that circles the player in super-slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03813929855823517 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881393432617188 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03813929855823517, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03813929855823517, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6327377557754517, + 0.07369287312030792, + 0.10092988610267639, + 0.04285162314772606, + 0.031363196671009064, + 0.02691172994673252, + 0.02670850045979023, + 0.03594113886356354, + 0.008546316996216774, + 0.0203169584274292 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03813929855823517 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a basketball player resembling D'Angelo Russell with short, textured braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the player wearing a sweat-soaked basketball jersey and shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the player falling after a mid-air collision with one arm reaching for the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, high-contrast overhead stadium lights casting sharp highlights on a polished wooden court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping, low-angle tracking shot that circles the player in super-slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307150840759277 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680715084075928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307150840759277, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307150840759277, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.608473002910614, + 0.07015275955200195, + 0.09468196332454681, + 0.029332170262932777, + 0.03796221315860748, + 0.0350179523229599, + 0.03291233628988266, + 0.046981081366539, + 0.014957437291741371, + 0.029529141262173653 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307150840759277 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a basketball player resembling D'Angelo Russell with short, textured braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the player wearing a sweat-soaked basketball jersey and shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the player falling after a mid-air collision with one arm reaching for the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, high-contrast overhead stadium lights casting sharp highlights on a polished wooden court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping, low-angle tracking shot that circles the player in super-slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25215864181518555 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021586418151855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25215864181518555, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25215864181518555, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16799136996269226, + 0.16044604778289795, + 0.28832322359085083, + 0.05903945490717888, + 0.05697411671280861, + 0.03475251421332359, + 0.03386573866009712, + 0.07245218008756638, + 0.05721341446042061, + 0.06894191354513168 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25215864181518555 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a basketball player resembling D'Angelo Russell with short, textured braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the player wearing a sweat-soaked basketball jersey and shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the player falling after a mid-air collision with one arm reaching for the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, high-contrast overhead stadium lights casting sharp highlights on a polished wooden court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping, low-angle tracking shot that circles the player in super-slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2255418300628662 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005418300628662 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2255418300628662, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2255418300628662, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15742965042591095, + 0.13956734538078308, + 0.06596861034631729, + 0.08988522738218307, + 0.1232568621635437, + 0.12035837769508362, + 0.08024448156356812, + 0.09947524219751358, + 0.04588068276643753, + 0.07793352752923965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2255418300628662 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a breathtakingly high-speed sports documentary, a sweeping, low-angle tracking shot gracefully circles a basketball player resembling D'Angelo Russell, capturing his fall in stunning super-slow motion. The camera follows his desperate, acrobatic tumble after a mid-air collision. The player, with short, textured braids, is drenched in sweat, his face contorted in a mask of intense focus and controlled pain. His athletic frame is clad in a sweat-soaked basketball jersey and shorts, clinging to his strained muscles. As he descends, his body contorts in a display of raw athleticism, one arm reaching for the floor to break his fall. The scene is illuminated by bright, high-contrast overhead stadium lights, which cast sharp, mirrored highlights on the highly polished wooden court floor and gleam on the sweat that flies from his body. In the background, a beautifully rendered bokeh of the packed arena appears, with the crowd and distant scoreboard blurred into abstract shapes of light and color. He crashed to the polished floor, his shoulder taking the brunt of the blow, then deftly channeled the momentum into a chaotic yet controlled tumble, his limbs moving with a fluid desperation that underscored the sheer violence and grace of the moment.", + "seed": 28556, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_14/index_705_seed_28556_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10118739269673824, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10118739269673824, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10118739269673824, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a basketball player resembling D'Angelo Russell with short, textured braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the player wearing a sweat-soaked basketball jersey and shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the player falling after a mid-air collision with one arm reaching for the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, high-contrast overhead stadium lights casting sharp highlights on a polished wooden court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping, low-angle tracking shot that circles the player in super-slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1626712530851364 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9126712083816528 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1626712530851364, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1626712530851364, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20554368197917938, + 0.06570915877819061, + 0.11939787864685059, + 0.08982968330383301, + 0.03861619159579277, + 0.08497673273086548, + 0.08331899344921112, + 0.04108750820159912, + 0.16588017344474792, + 0.10564002394676208 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1626712530851364 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a basketball player resembling D'Angelo Russell with short, textured braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the player wearing a sweat-soaked basketball jersey and shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the player falling after a mid-air collision with one arm reaching for the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, high-contrast overhead stadium lights casting sharp highlights on a polished wooden court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping, low-angle tracking shot that circles the player in super-slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01609581708908081 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410956382751465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01609581708908081, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01609581708908081, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15003840625286102, + 0.06441551446914673, + 0.10262651741504669, + 0.022862188518047333, + 0.028856532648205757, + 0.11555718630552292, + 0.059393126517534256, + 0.09321180731058121, + 0.04826442152261734, + 0.3147743344306946 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01609581708908081 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a basketball player resembling D'Angelo Russell with short, textured braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the player wearing a sweat-soaked basketball jersey and shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the player falling after a mid-air collision with one arm reaching for the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, high-contrast overhead stadium lights casting sharp highlights on a polished wooden court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping, low-angle tracking shot that circles the player in super-slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029804686084389687 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298047065734863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029804686084389687, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029804686084389687, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08420060575008392, + 0.04711306095123291, + 0.1417330652475357, + 0.058622539043426514, + 0.0466829352080822, + 0.03139990568161011, + 0.09237689524888992, + 0.24609683454036713, + 0.03709033876657486, + 0.21468381583690643 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029804686084389687 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a basketball player resembling D'Angelo Russell with short, textured braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the player wearing a sweat-soaked basketball jersey and shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the player falling after a mid-air collision with one arm reaching for the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, high-contrast overhead stadium lights casting sharp highlights on a polished wooden court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping, low-angle tracking shot that circles the player in super-slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607634499669075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141076564788818 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607634499669075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607634499669075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1743396371603012, + 0.056346334517002106, + 0.0611291341483593, + 0.043744973838329315, + 0.17663398385047913, + 0.09649518132209778, + 0.03917202726006508, + 0.02387199178338051, + 0.07093970477581024, + 0.25732704997062683 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607634499669075 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a basketball player resembling D'Angelo Russell with short, textured braids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the player wearing a sweat-soaked basketball jersey and shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the player falling after a mid-air collision with one arm reaching for the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, high-contrast overhead stadium lights casting sharp highlights on a polished wooden court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping, low-angle tracking shot that circles the player in super-slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28128886222839355 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4062888622283936 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28128886222839355, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28128886222839355, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20916935801506042, + 0.08907190710306168, + 0.08648741990327835, + 0.09709527343511581, + 0.05247638002038002, + 0.09515345841646194, + 0.09124293178319931, + 0.12630358338356018, + 0.0764327123761177, + 0.07656703889369965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28128886222839355 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_15/index_tensor([9034, 9034])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_15/index_tensor([9034, 9034])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a019ff05eecca9740812a06d4e73e7302ae52ae5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_15/index_tensor([9034, 9034])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle close-up, initially still on the cracked gray sidewalk, then tilts with breathtaking speed to follow the action. A plump rock pigeon, its neck feathers ablaze with a spectacular iridescence of metallic green, purple, and blue in the bright autumn sunlight, erupts vertically from the ground. With a powerful and decisive push from its pink feet, it soars into the air, its broad wings beating downward with immense force. This sudden, violent movement creates a miniature whirlwind, sending a chaotic spiral of brittle, dry leaves in shades of crimson and gold swirling across the sidewalk. As the pigeon ascends, each powerful wingbeat a deliberate muscle contraction, the low-hanging sunlight capturing the shifting colors of its feathers and revealing a softer gray pattern on the wings' underside, creating a vibrant atmosphere of raw, untamed nature bursting forth amidst the mundane urban environment.", + "seed": 6127, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_15/index_9034_seed_6127_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.039398204628378154, + "vlm_logprob": -0.039398204628378154, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.039398204628378154, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a low-angle close-up of a cracked gray sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt with speed to follow the action?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump rock pigeon visible with iridescent green, purple, and blue neck feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon erupt vertically from the ground and beat its wings downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brittle dry leaves in shades of crimson and gold swirling in a spiral on the sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008915025740861893 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758914947509766 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008915025740861893, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008915025740861893, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.50933837890625, + 0.03835552558302879, + 0.0369669608771801, + 0.17457853257656097, + 0.024312065914273262, + 0.02050372026860714, + 0.041881855577230453, + 0.03327015042304993, + 0.032497603446245193, + 0.08829521387815475 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008915025740861893 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a low-angle close-up of a cracked gray sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt with speed to follow the action?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump rock pigeon visible with iridescent green, purple, and blue neck feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon erupt vertically from the ground and beat its wings downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brittle dry leaves in shades of crimson and gold swirling in a spiral on the sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428792029619217 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178792476654053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428792029619217, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428792029619217, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18777500092983246, + 0.09713191539049149, + 0.14258235692977905, + 0.31759849190711975, + 0.032765183597803116, + 0.02724522165954113, + 0.01848059706389904, + 0.04839513823390007, + 0.028921635821461678, + 0.09910447895526886 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428792029619217 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a low-angle close-up of a cracked gray sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt with speed to follow the action?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump rock pigeon visible with iridescent green, purple, and blue neck feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon erupt vertically from the ground and beat its wings downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brittle dry leaves in shades of crimson and gold swirling in a spiral on the sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004647999536246061 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379648208618164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004647999536246061, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004647999536246061, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20077034831047058, + 0.07168397307395935, + 0.062017522752285004, + 0.11087673157453537, + 0.0862102285027504, + 0.2518986165523529, + 0.0718482956290245, + 0.08974466472864151, + 0.016433078795671463, + 0.03851652517914772 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004647999536246061 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a low-angle close-up of a cracked gray sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt with speed to follow the action?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump rock pigeon visible with iridescent green, purple, and blue neck feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon erupt vertically from the ground and beat its wings downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brittle dry leaves in shades of crimson and gold swirling in a spiral on the sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014203761704266071 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2642035484313965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014203761704266071, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014203761704266071, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09172432124614716, + 0.09985271096229553, + 0.1554577350616455, + 0.19123585522174835, + 0.09293349832296371, + 0.027470987290143967, + 0.07939166575670242, + 0.1259227693080902, + 0.026918010786175728, + 0.10909241437911987 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014203761704266071 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a low-angle close-up of a cracked gray sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt with speed to follow the action?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump rock pigeon visible with iridescent green, purple, and blue neck feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon erupt vertically from the ground and beat its wings downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brittle dry leaves in shades of crimson and gold swirling in a spiral on the sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026345033198595047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513450145721436 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026345033198595047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026345033198595047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1954219490289688, + 0.07984435558319092, + 0.10992389917373657, + 0.07901676744222641, + 0.11226041615009308, + 0.09195142239332199, + 0.1809391975402832, + 0.08282867819070816, + 0.016011402010917664, + 0.051801878958940506 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026345033198595047 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle close-up, initially still on the cracked gray sidewalk, then tilts with breathtaking speed to follow the action. A plump rock pigeon, its neck feathers ablaze with a spectacular iridescence of metallic green, purple, and blue in the bright autumn sunlight, erupts vertically from the ground. With a powerful and decisive push from its pink feet, it soars into the air, its broad wings beating downward with immense force. This sudden, violent movement creates a miniature whirlwind, sending a chaotic spiral of brittle, dry leaves in shades of crimson and gold swirling across the sidewalk. As the pigeon ascends, each powerful wingbeat a deliberate muscle contraction, the low-hanging sunlight capturing the shifting colors of its feathers and revealing a softer gray pattern on the wings' underside, creating a vibrant atmosphere of raw, untamed nature bursting forth amidst the mundane urban environment.", + "seed": 6128, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_15/index_9034_seed_6128_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06520796651020647, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06520796651020647, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06520796651020647, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a low-angle close-up of a cracked gray sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt with speed to follow the action?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump rock pigeon visible with iridescent green, purple, and blue neck feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon erupt vertically from the ground and beat its wings downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brittle dry leaves in shades of crimson and gold swirling in a spiral on the sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01645822636783123 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141458034515381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01645822636783123, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01645822636783123, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3092944622039795, + 0.03313840925693512, + 0.026956520974636078, + 0.03924339637160301, + 0.06311209499835968, + 0.33858489990234375, + 0.03167194500565529, + 0.07541600614786148, + 0.04538896679878235, + 0.03719324991106987 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01645822636783123 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a low-angle close-up of a cracked gray sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt with speed to follow the action?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump rock pigeon visible with iridescent green, purple, and blue neck feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon erupt vertically from the ground and beat its wings downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brittle dry leaves in shades of crimson and gold swirling in a spiral on the sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25216594338417053 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021659135818481 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25216594338417053, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25216594338417053, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1505843847990036, + 0.08271418511867523, + 0.0807725340127945, + 0.06944085657596588, + 0.08191260695457458, + 0.1275905966758728, + 0.03964255377650261, + 0.07174663990736008, + 0.06234205141663551, + 0.233253613114357 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25216594338417053 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a low-angle close-up of a cracked gray sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt with speed to follow the action?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump rock pigeon visible with iridescent green, purple, and blue neck feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon erupt vertically from the ground and beat its wings downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brittle dry leaves in shades of crimson and gold swirling in a spiral on the sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007635692600160837 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882635593414307 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007635692600160837, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007635692600160837, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18227197229862213, + 0.09665319323539734, + 0.1246619001030922, + 0.08914052695035934, + 0.09900315850973129, + 0.13049209117889404, + 0.054978396743535995, + 0.12667615711688995, + 0.02193908765912056, + 0.07418353855609894 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007635692600160837 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a low-angle close-up of a cracked gray sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt with speed to follow the action?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump rock pigeon visible with iridescent green, purple, and blue neck feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon erupt vertically from the ground and beat its wings downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brittle dry leaves in shades of crimson and gold swirling in a spiral on the sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016075875610113144 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14107608795166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016075875610113144, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016075875610113144, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10075777769088745, + 0.0936797633767128, + 0.12829916179180145, + 0.05864923819899559, + 0.11332608759403229, + 0.16341964900493622, + 0.06404582411050797, + 0.10618524998426437, + 0.045354943722486496, + 0.12628231942653656 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016075875610113144 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a low-angle close-up of a cracked gray sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt with speed to follow the action?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump rock pigeon visible with iridescent green, purple, and blue neck feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon erupt vertically from the ground and beat its wings downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brittle dry leaves in shades of crimson and gold swirling in a spiral on the sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370409458875656 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087040424346924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370409458875656, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370409458875656, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2590721845626831, + 0.04633564502000809, + 0.11136388778686523, + 0.09672696888446808, + 0.11391206830739975, + 0.2369670867919922, + 0.015868913382291794, + 0.04820750281214714, + 0.04367484524846077, + 0.02787092700600624 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370409458875656 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle close-up, initially still on the cracked gray sidewalk, then tilts with breathtaking speed to follow the action. A plump rock pigeon, its neck feathers ablaze with a spectacular iridescence of metallic green, purple, and blue in the bright autumn sunlight, erupts vertically from the ground. With a powerful and decisive push from its pink feet, it soars into the air, its broad wings beating downward with immense force. This sudden, violent movement creates a miniature whirlwind, sending a chaotic spiral of brittle, dry leaves in shades of crimson and gold swirling across the sidewalk. As the pigeon ascends, each powerful wingbeat a deliberate muscle contraction, the low-hanging sunlight capturing the shifting colors of its feathers and revealing a softer gray pattern on the wings' underside, creating a vibrant atmosphere of raw, untamed nature bursting forth amidst the mundane urban environment.", + "seed": 6129, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_15/index_9034_seed_6129_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04392230529338122, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04392230529338122, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04392230529338122, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a low-angle close-up of a cracked gray sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt with speed to follow the action?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump rock pigeon visible with iridescent green, purple, and blue neck feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon erupt vertically from the ground and beat its wings downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brittle dry leaves in shades of crimson and gold swirling in a spiral on the sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0215196181088686 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.896519660949707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0215196181088686, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0215196181088686, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.289788156747818, + 0.13221371173858643, + 0.09892051666975021, + 0.09451570361852646, + 0.04276488348841667, + 0.10894142836332321, + 0.062455371022224426, + 0.08225202560424805, + 0.03622519224882126, + 0.05192292854189873 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0215196181088686 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a low-angle close-up of a cracked gray sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt with speed to follow the action?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump rock pigeon visible with iridescent green, purple, and blue neck feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon erupt vertically from the ground and beat its wings downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brittle dry leaves in shades of crimson and gold swirling in a spiral on the sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10038989782333374 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503899574279785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10038989782333374, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10038989782333374, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13241563737392426, + 0.12293817102909088, + 0.06862962245941162, + 0.07679695636034012, + 0.15376518666744232, + 0.051869750022888184, + 0.21863354742527008, + 0.12078122794628143, + 0.027162447571754456, + 0.02700747363269329 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10038989782333374 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a low-angle close-up of a cracked gray sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt with speed to follow the action?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump rock pigeon visible with iridescent green, purple, and blue neck feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon erupt vertically from the ground and beat its wings downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brittle dry leaves in shades of crimson and gold swirling in a spiral on the sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005959480069577694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130959510803223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005959480069577694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005959480069577694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1616646945476532, + 0.0817926824092865, + 0.14296546578407288, + 0.1259043663740158, + 0.09935389459133148, + 0.10778038948774338, + 0.10693863034248352, + 0.06902109831571579, + 0.07402271777391434, + 0.030556008219718933 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005959480069577694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a low-angle close-up of a cracked gray sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt with speed to follow the action?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump rock pigeon visible with iridescent green, purple, and blue neck feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon erupt vertically from the ground and beat its wings downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brittle dry leaves in shades of crimson and gold swirling in a spiral on the sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043072763830423355 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680727005004883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043072763830423355, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043072763830423355, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1323266327381134, + 0.14187653362751007, + 0.1762007623910904, + 0.19276678562164307, + 0.08647307008504868, + 0.048941824585199356, + 0.05425029247999191, + 0.07764138281345367, + 0.05223076045513153, + 0.03729194402694702 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043072763830423355 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a low-angle close-up of a cracked gray sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt with speed to follow the action?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump rock pigeon visible with iridescent green, purple, and blue neck feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon erupt vertically from the ground and beat its wings downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brittle dry leaves in shades of crimson and gold swirling in a spiral on the sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866976663470268 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486698150634766 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866976663470268, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866976663470268, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22896654903888702, + 0.08271563798189163, + 0.04529566317796707, + 0.04251762107014656, + 0.042941171675920486, + 0.11143162101507187, + 0.18495388329029083, + 0.10134053975343704, + 0.07555403560400009, + 0.0842832550406456 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866976663470268 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle close-up, initially still on the cracked gray sidewalk, then tilts with breathtaking speed to follow the action. A plump rock pigeon, its neck feathers ablaze with a spectacular iridescence of metallic green, purple, and blue in the bright autumn sunlight, erupts vertically from the ground. With a powerful and decisive push from its pink feet, it soars into the air, its broad wings beating downward with immense force. This sudden, violent movement creates a miniature whirlwind, sending a chaotic spiral of brittle, dry leaves in shades of crimson and gold swirling across the sidewalk. As the pigeon ascends, each powerful wingbeat a deliberate muscle contraction, the low-hanging sunlight capturing the shifting colors of its feathers and revealing a softer gray pattern on the wings' underside, creating a vibrant atmosphere of raw, untamed nature bursting forth amidst the mundane urban environment.", + "seed": 6130, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_15/index_9034_seed_6130_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.045438445452600715, + "vlm_logprob": -0.045438445452600715, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.045438445452600715, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a low-angle close-up of a cracked gray sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt with speed to follow the action?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump rock pigeon visible with iridescent green, purple, and blue neck feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon erupt vertically from the ground and beat its wings downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brittle dry leaves in shades of crimson and gold swirling in a spiral on the sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018454985693097115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0184550285339355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018454985693097115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018454985693097115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19326260685920715, + 0.22652782499790192, + 0.011331969872117043, + 0.03600207343697548, + 0.028299087658524513, + 0.024763742461800575, + 0.029005682095885277, + 0.18930600583553314, + 0.09752719104290009, + 0.16397379338741302 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018454985693097115 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a low-angle close-up of a cracked gray sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt with speed to follow the action?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump rock pigeon visible with iridescent green, purple, and blue neck feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon erupt vertically from the ground and beat its wings downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brittle dry leaves in shades of crimson and gold swirling in a spiral on the sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14285346865653992 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178534984588623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14285346865653992, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14285346865653992, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0508507676422596, + 0.1683150678873062, + 0.03320101276040077, + 0.0393645204603672, + 0.04409016668796539, + 0.027964916080236435, + 0.03027433715760708, + 0.3923240602016449, + 0.03198111802339554, + 0.18163415789604187 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14285346865653992 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a low-angle close-up of a cracked gray sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt with speed to follow the action?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump rock pigeon visible with iridescent green, purple, and blue neck feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon erupt vertically from the ground and beat its wings downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brittle dry leaves in shades of crimson and gold swirling in a spiral on the sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006744122598320246 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006743907928467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006744122598320246, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006744122598320246, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11508798599243164, + 0.05633285269141197, + 0.14266081154346466, + 0.051515333354473114, + 0.04986698180437088, + 0.07094059139490128, + 0.012643475085496902, + 0.22432346642017365, + 0.04640386253595352, + 0.2302246391773224 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006744122598320246 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a low-angle close-up of a cracked gray sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt with speed to follow the action?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump rock pigeon visible with iridescent green, purple, and blue neck feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon erupt vertically from the ground and beat its wings downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brittle dry leaves in shades of crimson and gold swirling in a spiral on the sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607704907655716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141077041625977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607704907655716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607704907655716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1652681678533554, + 0.1575142741203308, + 0.04506329819560051, + 0.05997470021247864, + 0.05895066633820534, + 0.062386125326156616, + 0.01697278395295143, + 0.07331881672143936, + 0.058746904134750366, + 0.3018043339252472 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607704907655716 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a low-angle close-up of a cracked gray sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt with speed to follow the action?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump rock pigeon visible with iridescent green, purple, and blue neck feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pigeon erupt vertically from the ground and beat its wings downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are brittle dry leaves in shades of crimson and gold swirling in a spiral on the sidewalk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306260123848915 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168062686920166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306260123848915, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306260123848915, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1976494938135147, + 0.17886050045490265, + 0.09782403707504272, + 0.2718079090118408, + 0.012808766216039658, + 0.02789376489818096, + 0.009885087609291077, + 0.121019147336483, + 0.011543400585651398, + 0.07070788741111755 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306260123848915 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_2/index_tensor([2829, 2829])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_2/index_tensor([2829, 2829])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..95264c4d24e3c736db94ae1798c6abe6f748d261 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_2/index_tensor([2829, 2829])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, slightly elevated medium close-up peeks into the intimate confines of a simple wooden doghouse, its floor covered with a soft bed of thick, clean straw. The scene, rendered in rich, timeless black and white, emphasizes the delicate textures of the fur and the rough grain of the wooden walls. A mother dog, most likely a Golden Retriever, with long, shimmering fur, curls her body into a protective crescent, forming a warm, living barrier around her pups. In her arms, a wriggling mass of newborn puppies, their tiny, furry forms barely distinguishable from one another. Soft, diffused light streams in from the doghouse's entrance, casting gentle highlights on the mother's back and creating deep, comforting shadows that envelop the sleeping puppies. She gently and methodically grooms one of the dogs, her tongue slowly and deliberately rubbing against its head. This gentle movement draws the pup deeper into the warmth of its siblings, creating a powerful atmosphere of profound tranquility and primal, protective love.", + "seed": 22675, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_2/index_2829_seed_22675_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03797547444701195, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03797547444701195, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6249999523162844, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03797547444701195, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a simple wooden doghouse with a straw-covered floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a mother dog, appearing to be a Golden Retriever with long fur, curling her body around her puppies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mother dog gently grooming one of the puppies by rubbing its head with her tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly elevated medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0203858632594347 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0203857421875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0203858632594347, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0203858632594347, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06890399754047394, + 0.0577152743935585, + 0.07092303782701492, + 0.2710379958152771, + 0.058472443372011185, + 0.04590589180588722, + 0.3027218282222748, + 0.03988196328282356, + 0.05296754091978073, + 0.031470008194446564 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0203858632594347 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a simple wooden doghouse with a straw-covered floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a mother dog, appearing to be a Golden Retriever with long fur, curling her body around her puppies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mother dog gently grooming one of the puppies by rubbing its head with her tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly elevated medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11305670440196991 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2380566596984863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11305670440196991, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11305670440196991, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11706267297267914, + 0.10756055265665054, + 0.10443323850631714, + 0.1758631467819214, + 0.06442967057228088, + 0.09337484836578369, + 0.06774796545505524, + 0.08031846582889557, + 0.088889479637146, + 0.1003199964761734 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11305670440196991 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a simple wooden doghouse with a straw-covered floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a mother dog, appearing to be a Golden Retriever with long fur, curling her body around her puppies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mother dog gently grooming one of the puppies by rubbing its head with her tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly elevated medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023298438638448715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773298501968384 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023298438638448715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023298438638448715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18784460425376892, + 0.05760195478796959, + 0.08722550421953201, + 0.14935830235481262, + 0.02958620712161064, + 0.028654633089900017, + 0.33174780011177063, + 0.05675043538212776, + 0.03746222332119942, + 0.033768363296985626 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023298438638448715 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a simple wooden doghouse with a straw-covered floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a mother dog, appearing to be a Golden Retriever with long fur, curling her body around her puppies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mother dog gently grooming one of the puppies by rubbing its head with her tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly elevated medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059842273592949 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955984115600586 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059842273592949, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059842273592949, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1590142399072647, + 0.06613229960203171, + 0.037152670323848724, + 0.08719058334827423, + 0.06520399451255798, + 0.09208226948976517, + 0.19404183328151703, + 0.08909979462623596, + 0.16855169832706451, + 0.041530635207891464 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059842273592949 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a simple wooden doghouse with a straw-covered floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a mother dog, appearing to be a Golden Retriever with long fur, curling her body around her puppies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mother dog gently grooming one of the puppies by rubbing its head with her tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly elevated medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012537943199276924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387537956237793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012537943199276924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012537943199276924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13422232866287231, + 0.03451672941446304, + 0.02037334442138672, + 0.4427923262119293, + 0.029486076906323433, + 0.0749996080994606, + 0.10402669757604599, + 0.10616889595985413, + 0.02802760899066925, + 0.025386303663253784 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012537943199276924 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly elevated medium close-up peeks into the intimate confines of a simple wooden doghouse, its floor covered with a soft bed of thick, clean straw. The scene, rendered in rich, timeless black and white, emphasizes the delicate textures of the fur and the rough grain of the wooden walls. A mother dog, most likely a Golden Retriever, with long, shimmering fur, curls her body into a protective crescent, forming a warm, living barrier around her pups. In her arms, a wriggling mass of newborn puppies, their tiny, furry forms barely distinguishable from one another. Soft, diffused light streams in from the doghouse's entrance, casting gentle highlights on the mother's back and creating deep, comforting shadows that envelop the sleeping puppies. She gently and methodically grooms one of the dogs, her tongue slowly and deliberately rubbing against its head. This gentle movement draws the pup deeper into the warmth of its siblings, creating a powerful atmosphere of profound tranquility and primal, protective love.", + "seed": 22676, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_2/index_2829_seed_22676_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.09031909871846437, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09031909871846437, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09031909871846437, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a simple wooden doghouse with a straw-covered floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a mother dog, appearing to be a Golden Retriever with long fur, curling her body around her puppies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mother dog gently grooming one of the puppies by rubbing its head with her tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly elevated medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20485106110572815 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7048510313034058 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20485106110572815, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20485106110572815, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1418054699897766, + 0.1769677698612213, + 0.15284985303878784, + 0.07243894785642624, + 0.03706752881407738, + 0.0741051658987999, + 0.02812349982559681, + 0.04714487865567207, + 0.015287513844668865, + 0.25420933961868286 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20485106110572815 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a simple wooden doghouse with a straw-covered floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a mother dog, appearing to be a Golden Retriever with long fur, curling her body around her puppies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mother dog gently grooming one of the puppies by rubbing its head with her tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly elevated medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011162923648953438 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511162757873535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011162923648953438, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011162923648953438, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30997389554977417, + 0.15961766242980957, + 0.05164765194058418, + 0.02527606301009655, + 0.03203341364860535, + 0.03830963373184204, + 0.1795705109834671, + 0.03682389110326767, + 0.04095948860049248, + 0.12578772008419037 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011162923648953438 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a simple wooden doghouse with a straw-covered floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a mother dog, appearing to be a Golden Retriever with long fur, curling her body around her puppies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mother dog gently grooming one of the puppies by rubbing its head with her tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly elevated medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17994044721126556 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049404621124268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17994044721126556, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17994044721126556, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1151130422949791, + 0.09866227954626083, + 0.09475449472665787, + 0.02836930751800537, + 0.020006204023957253, + 0.16351646184921265, + 0.05012236163020134, + 0.08101438730955124, + 0.0877392366528511, + 0.2607021629810333 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17994044721126556 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a simple wooden doghouse with a straw-covered floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a mother dog, appearing to be a Golden Retriever with long fur, curling her body around her puppies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mother dog gently grooming one of the puppies by rubbing its head with her tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly elevated medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043099939823150635 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168099880218506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043099939823150635, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043099939823150635, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05159587040543556, + 0.4614616632461548, + 0.085478775203228, + 0.021349482238292694, + 0.023145657032728195, + 0.03666573390364647, + 0.03838768228888512, + 0.0511791855096817, + 0.0656401664018631, + 0.1650957316160202 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043099939823150635 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a simple wooden doghouse with a straw-covered floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a mother dog, appearing to be a Golden Retriever with long fur, curling her body around her puppies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mother dog gently grooming one of the puppies by rubbing its head with her tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly elevated medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012541121803224087 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875412940979 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012541121803224087, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012541121803224087, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08131388574838638, + 0.2511850595474243, + 0.05475695803761482, + 0.015511400997638702, + 0.017610227689146996, + 0.041357673704624176, + 0.03104850836098194, + 0.03206542134284973, + 0.02880939096212387, + 0.44634151458740234 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012541121803224087 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly elevated medium close-up peeks into the intimate confines of a simple wooden doghouse, its floor covered with a soft bed of thick, clean straw. The scene, rendered in rich, timeless black and white, emphasizes the delicate textures of the fur and the rough grain of the wooden walls. A mother dog, most likely a Golden Retriever, with long, shimmering fur, curls her body into a protective crescent, forming a warm, living barrier around her pups. In her arms, a wriggling mass of newborn puppies, their tiny, furry forms barely distinguishable from one another. Soft, diffused light streams in from the doghouse's entrance, casting gentle highlights on the mother's back and creating deep, comforting shadows that envelop the sleeping puppies. She gently and methodically grooms one of the dogs, her tongue slowly and deliberately rubbing against its head. This gentle movement draws the pup deeper into the warmth of its siblings, creating a powerful atmosphere of profound tranquility and primal, protective love.", + "seed": 22677, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_2/index_2829_seed_22677_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05732952021062374, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05732952021062374, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05732952021062374, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a simple wooden doghouse with a straw-covered floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a mother dog, appearing to be a Golden Retriever with long fur, curling her body around her puppies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mother dog gently grooming one of the puppies by rubbing its head with her tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly elevated medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18218648433685303 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.807186484336853 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18218648433685303, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18218648433685303, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.48628345131874084, + 0.051967035979032516, + 0.028028951957821846, + 0.026350365951657295, + 0.032446760684251785, + 0.05041384696960449, + 0.08052437752485275, + 0.10842553526163101, + 0.10274842381477356, + 0.032811179757118225 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18218648433685303 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a simple wooden doghouse with a straw-covered floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a mother dog, appearing to be a Golden Retriever with long fur, curling her body around her puppies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mother dog gently grooming one of the puppies by rubbing its head with her tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly elevated medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04881804808974266 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0488181114196777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04881804808974266, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04881804808974266, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04649665206670761, + 0.04586927220225334, + 0.014860683120787144, + 0.10337810218334198, + 0.13600479066371918, + 0.017962800338864326, + 0.05011908337473869, + 0.5596570372581482, + 0.008912568911910057, + 0.01673901081085205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04881804808974266 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a simple wooden doghouse with a straw-covered floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a mother dog, appearing to be a Golden Retriever with long fur, curling her body around her puppies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mother dog gently grooming one of the puppies by rubbing its head with her tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly elevated medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018202755600214005 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018202781677246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018202755600214005, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018202755600214005, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11012313514947891, + 0.04473743587732315, + 0.06137871742248535, + 0.09315019100904465, + 0.1790279597043991, + 0.1444605141878128, + 0.16455857455730438, + 0.09750549495220184, + 0.041311245411634445, + 0.06374680250883102 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018202755600214005 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a simple wooden doghouse with a straw-covered floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a mother dog, appearing to be a Golden Retriever with long fur, curling her body around her puppies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mother dog gently grooming one of the puppies by rubbing its head with her tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly elevated medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026366515085101128 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513664722442627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026366515085101128, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026366515085101128, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1692638397216797, + 0.040657173842191696, + 0.04404442012310028, + 0.03469141572713852, + 0.13287453353405, + 0.09587118774652481, + 0.04815494641661644, + 0.3134814202785492, + 0.07595868408679962, + 0.04500235989689827 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026366515085101128 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a simple wooden doghouse with a straw-covered floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a mother dog, appearing to be a Golden Retriever with long fur, curling her body around her puppies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mother dog gently grooming one of the puppies by rubbing its head with her tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly elevated medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011073797941207886 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511073589324951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011073797941207886, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011073797941207886, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15396222472190857, + 0.04386129230260849, + 0.028542090207338333, + 0.09526749700307846, + 0.11560662090778351, + 0.06994184851646423, + 0.1190033107995987, + 0.24360360205173492, + 0.06788978725671768, + 0.06232171878218651 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011073797941207886 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly elevated medium close-up peeks into the intimate confines of a simple wooden doghouse, its floor covered with a soft bed of thick, clean straw. The scene, rendered in rich, timeless black and white, emphasizes the delicate textures of the fur and the rough grain of the wooden walls. A mother dog, most likely a Golden Retriever, with long, shimmering fur, curls her body into a protective crescent, forming a warm, living barrier around her pups. In her arms, a wriggling mass of newborn puppies, their tiny, furry forms barely distinguishable from one another. Soft, diffused light streams in from the doghouse's entrance, casting gentle highlights on the mother's back and creating deep, comforting shadows that envelop the sleeping puppies. She gently and methodically grooms one of the dogs, her tongue slowly and deliberately rubbing against its head. This gentle movement draws the pup deeper into the warmth of its siblings, creating a powerful atmosphere of profound tranquility and primal, protective love.", + "seed": 22678, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_2/index_2829_seed_22678_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03241710658185184, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03241710658185184, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03241710658185184, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a simple wooden doghouse with a straw-covered floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a mother dog, appearing to be a Golden Retriever with long fur, curling her body around her puppies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mother dog gently grooming one of the puppies by rubbing its head with her tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly elevated medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11604806780815125 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2410480976104736 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11604806780815125, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11604806780815125, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11396440863609314, + 0.07861661165952682, + 0.0541236437857151, + 0.09940703958272934, + 0.10542310774326324, + 0.1756182610988617, + 0.030434390529990196, + 0.09102749079465866, + 0.08709023147821426, + 0.16429483890533447 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11604806780815125 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a simple wooden doghouse with a straw-covered floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a mother dog, appearing to be a Golden Retriever with long fur, curling her body around her puppies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mother dog gently grooming one of the puppies by rubbing its head with her tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly elevated medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032850131392478943 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753284931182861 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032850131392478943, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032850131392478943, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09550020098686218, + 0.0859534740447998, + 0.02612369880080223, + 0.04869001358747482, + 0.03337507322430611, + 0.07958263158798218, + 0.20570898056030273, + 0.31377333402633667, + 0.01885242387652397, + 0.09244012832641602 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032850131392478943 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a simple wooden doghouse with a straw-covered floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a mother dog, appearing to be a Golden Retriever with long fur, curling her body around her puppies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mother dog gently grooming one of the puppies by rubbing its head with her tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly elevated medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022033003624528646 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127203464508057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022033003624528646, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022033003624528646, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09142133593559265, + 0.062486682087183, + 0.09082664549350739, + 0.027079680934548378, + 0.07743566483259201, + 0.12122422456741333, + 0.3692300617694855, + 0.06755470484495163, + 0.047379374504089355, + 0.045361585915088654 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022033003624528646 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a simple wooden doghouse with a straw-covered floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a mother dog, appearing to be a Golden Retriever with long fur, curling her body around her puppies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mother dog gently grooming one of the puppies by rubbing its head with her tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly elevated medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014204349368810654 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264204502105713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014204349368810654, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014204349368810654, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07250862568616867, + 0.09766985476016998, + 0.02503708004951477, + 0.021836696192622185, + 0.04876331612467766, + 0.06439651548862457, + 0.44127827882766724, + 0.04048973694443703, + 0.14189711213111877, + 0.04612273350358009 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014204349368810654 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a simple wooden doghouse with a straw-covered floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a mother dog, appearing to be a Golden Retriever with long fur, curling her body around her puppies?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the mother dog gently grooming one of the puppies by rubbing its head with her tongue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, slightly elevated medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026344802230596542 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513447761535645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026344802230596542, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026344802230596542, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05945982411503792, + 0.05647890269756317, + 0.08144732564687729, + 0.035347387194633484, + 0.029296116903424263, + 0.36874404549598694, + 0.18076013028621674, + 0.07069309800863266, + 0.03755870833992958, + 0.08021453022956848 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026344802230596542 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_3/index_tensor([2187, 2187])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_3/index_tensor([2187, 2187])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d3dacbfd777f6cc715e1e22d2317580146d10e46 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_3/index_tensor([2187, 2187])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An epic drone shot, zooming out from a bird's-eye perspective, reveals a vast, turbulent ocean, shrouded by thick, gray-blue storm clouds. At the center of the frame, a truly mountainous wave surges forward with a slow, unstoppable momentum. Its massive base is a deep indigo, and as it rises, its crest shimmers like turquoise in the thinning light filtering through gaps in the clouds. As the behemoth surges forward, its razor-sharp crest curves gracefully and fatally inward, forming a bottomless tunnel of darkness. Then, a split second later, the entire structure collapses, its support unsupported. The collapse process is not completed in an instant. Instead, it is like a huge avalanche. The moment the waves hit the sea surface, it triggers a chaotic explosion, turning billions of tons of sea water into churning white foam and water mist that are thrown into the air, like boiling milk, forming a strong and dramatic visual contrast with the gloomy sky and dark sea water. The whole scene is full of primitive and awe-inspiring natural power, creating a grand atmosphere that is both magnificent and oppressive.", + "seed": 3442, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_3/index_2187_seed_3442_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.23484377805143594, + "vlm_logprob": -0.23484377805143594, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.23484377805143594, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a drone view that zooms out from a bird's-eye perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast ocean shrouded by thick gray-blue storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive wave surge forward with a deep indigo base and a turquoise crest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave form a bottomless tunnel of darkness before collapsing like an avalanche?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the collapse trigger a chaotic explosion of churning white foam and water mist resembling boiling milk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0571479797363281 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4321480095386505 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0571479797363281, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0571479797363281, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3060898184776306, + 0.14374896883964539, + 0.05836954340338707, + 0.11891397088766098, + 0.08291245251893997, + 0.04046136513352394, + 0.058181360363960266, + 0.03128664568066597, + 0.08119326829910278, + 0.0788426548242569 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0571479797363281 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a drone view that zooms out from a bird's-eye perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast ocean shrouded by thick gray-blue storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive wave surge forward with a deep indigo base and a turquoise crest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave form a bottomless tunnel of darkness before collapsing like an avalanche?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the collapse trigger a chaotic explosion of churning white foam and water mist resembling boiling milk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016079511493444443 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141079425811768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016079511493444443, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016079511493444443, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2819896936416626, + 0.0685461014509201, + 0.15355069935321808, + 0.041281938552856445, + 0.030870528891682625, + 0.06402283906936646, + 0.06578080356121063, + 0.15824420750141144, + 0.06690900772809982, + 0.06880418211221695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016079511493444443 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a drone view that zooms out from a bird's-eye perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast ocean shrouded by thick gray-blue storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive wave surge forward with a deep indigo base and a turquoise crest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave form a bottomless tunnel of darkness before collapsing like an avalanche?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the collapse trigger a chaotic explosion of churning white foam and water mist resembling boiling milk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005950118415057659 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130949974060059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005950118415057659, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005950118415057659, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14042067527770996, + 0.14064238965511322, + 0.08496718108654022, + 0.05858904495835304, + 0.05040004849433899, + 0.18173806369304657, + 0.12035328149795532, + 0.03892798349261284, + 0.09839966148138046, + 0.08556164801120758 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005950118415057659 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a drone view that zooms out from a bird's-eye perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast ocean shrouded by thick gray-blue storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive wave surge forward with a deep indigo base and a turquoise crest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave form a bottomless tunnel of darkness before collapsing like an avalanche?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the collapse trigger a chaotic explosion of churning white foam and water mist resembling boiling milk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897842675447464 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789785385131836 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897842675447464, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897842675447464, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11705365777015686, + 0.21197649836540222, + 0.04917518049478531, + 0.03669339790940285, + 0.11079199612140656, + 0.21189039945602417, + 0.055123794823884964, + 0.04616737365722656, + 0.054680436849594116, + 0.10644730180501938 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897842675447464 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a drone view that zooms out from a bird's-eye perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast ocean shrouded by thick gray-blue storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive wave surge forward with a deep indigo base and a turquoise crest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave form a bottomless tunnel of darkness before collapsing like an avalanche?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the collapse trigger a chaotic explosion of churning white foam and water mist resembling boiling milk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606285385787487 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410627365112305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606285385787487, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606285385787487, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1602310687303543, + 0.11738938838243484, + 0.11929097771644592, + 0.05006704106926918, + 0.061536166816949844, + 0.10460805147886276, + 0.047942548990249634, + 0.04600641503930092, + 0.08597896248102188, + 0.2069493532180786 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606285385787487 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic drone shot, zooming out from a bird's-eye perspective, reveals a vast, turbulent ocean, shrouded by thick, gray-blue storm clouds. At the center of the frame, a truly mountainous wave surges forward with a slow, unstoppable momentum. Its massive base is a deep indigo, and as it rises, its crest shimmers like turquoise in the thinning light filtering through gaps in the clouds. As the behemoth surges forward, its razor-sharp crest curves gracefully and fatally inward, forming a bottomless tunnel of darkness. Then, a split second later, the entire structure collapses, its support unsupported. The collapse process is not completed in an instant. Instead, it is like a huge avalanche. The moment the waves hit the sea surface, it triggers a chaotic explosion, turning billions of tons of sea water into churning white foam and water mist that are thrown into the air, like boiling milk, forming a strong and dramatic visual contrast with the gloomy sky and dark sea water. The whole scene is full of primitive and awe-inspiring natural power, creating a grand atmosphere that is both magnificent and oppressive.", + "seed": 3443, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_3/index_2187_seed_3443_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0882572771050036, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0882572771050036, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0882572771050036, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a drone view that zooms out from a bird's-eye perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast ocean shrouded by thick gray-blue storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive wave surge forward with a deep indigo base and a turquoise crest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave form a bottomless tunnel of darkness before collapsing like an avalanche?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the collapse trigger a chaotic explosion of churning white foam and water mist resembling boiling milk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3983632028102875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1483632326126099 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3983632028102875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3983632028102875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13479231297969818, + 0.08008648455142975, + 0.07008957862854004, + 0.14417634904384613, + 0.024244599044322968, + 0.03478788956999779, + 0.3046315014362335, + 0.13210712373256683, + 0.04232373088598251, + 0.03276040405035019 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3983632028102875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a drone view that zooms out from a bird's-eye perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast ocean shrouded by thick gray-blue storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive wave surge forward with a deep indigo base and a turquoise crest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave form a bottomless tunnel of darkness before collapsing like an avalanche?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the collapse trigger a chaotic explosion of churning white foam and water mist resembling boiling milk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007641253061592579 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882641315460205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007641253061592579, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007641253061592579, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14343246817588806, + 0.16045428812503815, + 0.1287849247455597, + 0.03234146162867546, + 0.0344039611518383, + 0.17523936927318573, + 0.2680199146270752, + 0.022487947717308998, + 0.00961464736610651, + 0.025221044197678566 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007641253061592579 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a drone view that zooms out from a bird's-eye perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast ocean shrouded by thick gray-blue storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive wave surge forward with a deep indigo base and a turquoise crest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave form a bottomless tunnel of darkness before collapsing like an avalanche?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the collapse trigger a chaotic explosion of churning white foam and water mist resembling boiling milk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052567594684660435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255256652832031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052567594684660435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052567594684660435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08742599934339523, + 0.03129211440682411, + 0.058904457837343216, + 0.04087899252772331, + 0.02873031608760357, + 0.017040574923157692, + 0.6684883236885071, + 0.03444448113441467, + 0.011386518366634846, + 0.02140815183520317 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052567594684660435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a drone view that zooms out from a bird's-eye perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast ocean shrouded by thick gray-blue storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive wave surge forward with a deep indigo base and a turquoise crest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave form a bottomless tunnel of darkness before collapsing like an avalanche?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the collapse trigger a chaotic explosion of churning white foam and water mist resembling boiling milk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023290520533919334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732906341552734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023290520533919334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023290520533919334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28041020035743713, + 0.09046661853790283, + 0.0983201190829277, + 0.16174626350402832, + 0.02793099731206894, + 0.04812048003077507, + 0.12663871049880981, + 0.07589530944824219, + 0.029024260118603706, + 0.06144705042243004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023290520533919334 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a drone view that zooms out from a bird's-eye perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast ocean shrouded by thick gray-blue storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive wave surge forward with a deep indigo base and a turquoise crest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave form a bottomless tunnel of darkness before collapsing like an avalanche?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the collapse trigger a chaotic explosion of churning white foam and water mist resembling boiling milk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006734649650752544 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006734848022461 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006734649650752544, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006734649650752544, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2426014244556427, + 0.06763935834169388, + 0.0822514146566391, + 0.040658704936504364, + 0.05186407268047333, + 0.03454989939928055, + 0.3500783145427704, + 0.05283685401082039, + 0.027926906943321228, + 0.04959309846162796 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006734649650752544 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic drone shot, zooming out from a bird's-eye perspective, reveals a vast, turbulent ocean, shrouded by thick, gray-blue storm clouds. At the center of the frame, a truly mountainous wave surges forward with a slow, unstoppable momentum. Its massive base is a deep indigo, and as it rises, its crest shimmers like turquoise in the thinning light filtering through gaps in the clouds. As the behemoth surges forward, its razor-sharp crest curves gracefully and fatally inward, forming a bottomless tunnel of darkness. Then, a split second later, the entire structure collapses, its support unsupported. The collapse process is not completed in an instant. Instead, it is like a huge avalanche. The moment the waves hit the sea surface, it triggers a chaotic explosion, turning billions of tons of sea water into churning white foam and water mist that are thrown into the air, like boiling milk, forming a strong and dramatic visual contrast with the gloomy sky and dark sea water. The whole scene is full of primitive and awe-inspiring natural power, creating a grand atmosphere that is both magnificent and oppressive.", + "seed": 3444, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_3/index_2187_seed_3444_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.24815072417259215, + "vlm_logprob": -0.24815072417259215, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.24815072417259215, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a drone view that zooms out from a bird's-eye perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast ocean shrouded by thick gray-blue storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive wave surge forward with a deep indigo base and a turquoise crest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave form a bottomless tunnel of darkness before collapsing like an avalanche?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the collapse trigger a chaotic explosion of churning white foam and water mist resembling boiling milk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.82989102602005 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.57989102602005 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.82989102602005, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.82989102602005, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11742814630270004, + 0.10600590705871582, + 0.13688300549983978, + 0.07301019877195358, + 0.2937985956668854, + 0.07127765566110611, + 0.04180365055799484, + 0.058929506689310074, + 0.014743968844413757, + 0.0861193984746933 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.82989102602005 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a drone view that zooms out from a bird's-eye perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast ocean shrouded by thick gray-blue storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive wave surge forward with a deep indigo base and a turquoise crest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave form a bottomless tunnel of darkness before collapsing like an avalanche?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the collapse trigger a chaotic explosion of churning white foam and water mist resembling boiling milk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31346067786216736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134607076644897 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31346067786216736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31346067786216736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24299338459968567, + 0.18240956962108612, + 0.048433683812618256, + 0.09758886694908142, + 0.042905475944280624, + 0.034323517233133316, + 0.13426868617534637, + 0.045777320861816406, + 0.06581517308950424, + 0.10548431426286697 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31346067786216736 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a drone view that zooms out from a bird's-eye perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast ocean shrouded by thick gray-blue storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive wave surge forward with a deep indigo base and a turquoise crest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave form a bottomless tunnel of darkness before collapsing like an avalanche?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the collapse trigger a chaotic explosion of churning white foam and water mist resembling boiling milk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00864548608660698 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758645534515381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00864548608660698, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00864548608660698, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20932357013225555, + 0.1622426062822342, + 0.08804372698068619, + 0.07710057497024536, + 0.09365133196115494, + 0.04223671555519104, + 0.07841404527425766, + 0.06734731793403625, + 0.05934753641486168, + 0.12229257822036743 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00864548608660698 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a drone view that zooms out from a bird's-eye perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast ocean shrouded by thick gray-blue storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive wave surge forward with a deep indigo base and a turquoise crest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave form a bottomless tunnel of darkness before collapsing like an avalanche?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the collapse trigger a chaotic explosion of churning white foam and water mist resembling boiling milk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897821068763733 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789783000946045 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897821068763733, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897821068763733, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13791227340698242, + 0.1322602778673172, + 0.05045202746987343, + 0.13168475031852722, + 0.06343080848455429, + 0.10468202084302902, + 0.0865558534860611, + 0.07239837944507599, + 0.04692709445953369, + 0.17369648814201355 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897821068763733 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a drone view that zooms out from a bird's-eye perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast ocean shrouded by thick gray-blue storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive wave surge forward with a deep indigo base and a turquoise crest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave form a bottomless tunnel of darkness before collapsing like an avalanche?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the collapse trigger a chaotic explosion of churning white foam and water mist resembling boiling milk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0097782202064991 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634778022766113 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0097782202064991, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0097782202064991, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1067676767706871, + 0.15606346726417542, + 0.06350734829902649, + 0.12149883061647415, + 0.06391880661249161, + 0.04295028746128082, + 0.11377494037151337, + 0.03545669838786125, + 0.058776192367076874, + 0.2372857928276062 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0097782202064991 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic drone shot, zooming out from a bird's-eye perspective, reveals a vast, turbulent ocean, shrouded by thick, gray-blue storm clouds. At the center of the frame, a truly mountainous wave surges forward with a slow, unstoppable momentum. Its massive base is a deep indigo, and as it rises, its crest shimmers like turquoise in the thinning light filtering through gaps in the clouds. As the behemoth surges forward, its razor-sharp crest curves gracefully and fatally inward, forming a bottomless tunnel of darkness. Then, a split second later, the entire structure collapses, its support unsupported. The collapse process is not completed in an instant. Instead, it is like a huge avalanche. The moment the waves hit the sea surface, it triggers a chaotic explosion, turning billions of tons of sea water into churning white foam and water mist that are thrown into the air, like boiling milk, forming a strong and dramatic visual contrast with the gloomy sky and dark sea water. The whole scene is full of primitive and awe-inspiring natural power, creating a grand atmosphere that is both magnificent and oppressive.", + "seed": 3445, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_3/index_2187_seed_3445_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2585438061505556, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2585438061505556, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2585438061505556, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a drone view that zooms out from a bird's-eye perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast ocean shrouded by thick gray-blue storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive wave surge forward with a deep indigo base and a turquoise crest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave form a bottomless tunnel of darkness before collapsing like an avalanche?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the collapse trigger a chaotic explosion of churning white foam and water mist resembling boiling milk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.22708261013031 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.35208263993263245 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.22708261013031, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.22708261013031, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08966673165559769, + 0.05038251727819443, + 0.09665469825267792, + 0.07809758931398392, + 0.06357824802398682, + 0.041669879108667374, + 0.08804517239332199, + 0.04847697541117668, + 0.030695335939526558, + 0.41273292899131775 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.22708261013031 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a drone view that zooms out from a bird's-eye perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast ocean shrouded by thick gray-blue storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive wave surge forward with a deep indigo base and a turquoise crest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave form a bottomless tunnel of darkness before collapsing like an avalanche?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the collapse trigger a chaotic explosion of churning white foam and water mist resembling boiling milk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009790024720132351 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634789943695068 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009790024720132351, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009790024720132351, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04889381304383278, + 0.21317793428897858, + 0.07646222412586212, + 0.040738217532634735, + 0.08448436856269836, + 0.040070392191410065, + 0.15250413119792938, + 0.04288940504193306, + 0.028674494475126266, + 0.27210503816604614 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009790024720132351 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a drone view that zooms out from a bird's-eye perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast ocean shrouded by thick gray-blue storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive wave surge forward with a deep indigo base and a turquoise crest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave form a bottomless tunnel of darkness before collapsing like an avalanche?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the collapse trigger a chaotic explosion of churning white foam and water mist resembling boiling milk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005254032090306282 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.25525426864624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005254032090306282, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005254032090306282, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10049376636743546, + 0.37703993916511536, + 0.12237725406885147, + 0.017207544296979904, + 0.02262490801513195, + 0.02263328805565834, + 0.03404217213392258, + 0.08905983716249466, + 0.029681038111448288, + 0.18484024703502655 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005254032090306282 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a drone view that zooms out from a bird's-eye perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast ocean shrouded by thick gray-blue storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive wave surge forward with a deep indigo base and a turquoise crest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave form a bottomless tunnel of darkness before collapsing like an avalanche?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the collapse trigger a chaotic explosion of churning white foam and water mist resembling boiling milk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865375533699989 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486538410186768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865375533699989, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865375533699989, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08899442851543427, + 0.2262905240058899, + 0.08013658970594406, + 0.04110220819711685, + 0.0743698999285698, + 0.05550355464220047, + 0.0417485237121582, + 0.14763601124286652, + 0.052341755479574203, + 0.1918766051530838 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865375533699989 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a drone view that zooms out from a bird's-eye perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a vast ocean shrouded by thick gray-blue storm clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive wave surge forward with a deep indigo base and a turquoise crest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave form a bottomless tunnel of darkness before collapsing like an avalanche?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the collapse trigger a chaotic explosion of churning white foam and water mist resembling boiling milk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019386084750294685 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251938819885254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019386084750294685, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019386084750294685, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0534057542681694, + 0.4401650130748749, + 0.05914627015590668, + 0.03454579412937164, + 0.03566361591219902, + 0.04441511631011963, + 0.03209112957119942, + 0.05504640191793442, + 0.06158747151494026, + 0.18393340706825256 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019386084750294685 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_4/index_tensor([2684, 2684])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_4/index_tensor([2684, 2684])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e0e6c40685a3314f7e956b7ba67e516d3ae380ac --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_4/index_tensor([2684, 2684])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, upward-focused shot reveals a massive bronze statue of Guan Yu, majestically standing on a vast, desolate plain, against a backdrop of swirling, dark clouds. The faint, cold light filtering through gaps in the clouds reveals the statue's weathered outline, its surface stained with a patina of weathered green. Suddenly, a dull, resonant sound echoes from within, and the statue begins to crumble from its core. Countless spiderweb-like cracks emerge with astonishing speed from its signature deep vermilion face, rapidly spreading downward, extending to its signature chest-length beard. As the cracks deepen, large fragments of bronze begin to peel and crumble like dead bark, sliding silently or snapping off under the weight of gravity. The cold light captures the sharp edges of the metal as they flare away. Deep within the cracks, the statue's hollow, dark interior is revealed, revealing its destruction stemming from its own inherent decay. The entire scene is permeated with an epic sense of tragedy of solemn destruction. Every cracked texture and every piece of rust on metal is presented with ultra-high clarity, perfectly embodying the ultimate realism and tragic aesthetics pursued by a high-detail digital artwork.", + "seed": 8650, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_4/index_2684_seed_8650_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.014078492950648069, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014078492950648069, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014078492950648069, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive bronze statue of Guan Yu with a deep vermilion face and chest-length beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the statue's surface covered in a weathered green patina and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do spiderweb-like cracks rapidly emerge from the statue's face and spread downward to the beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do large fragments of bronze peel and crumble from the statue's core like dead bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a slow, upward-focused view against a backdrop of swirling dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019380027428269386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01938009262085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019380027428269386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019380027428269386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.059469062834978104, + 0.06678120791912079, + 0.04758370295166969, + 0.031917352229356766, + 0.4510861039161682, + 0.060547731816768646, + 0.07244876772165298, + 0.07860912382602692, + 0.09779289364814758, + 0.03376409783959389 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019380027428269386 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive bronze statue of Guan Yu with a deep vermilion face and chest-length beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the statue's surface covered in a weathered green patina and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do spiderweb-like cracks rapidly emerge from the statue's face and spread downward to the beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do large fragments of bronze peel and crumble from the statue's core like dead bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a slow, upward-focused view against a backdrop of swirling dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076345098204910755 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88263463973999 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076345098204910755, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076345098204910755, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10485544800758362, + 0.044478047639131546, + 0.08976669609546661, + 0.06625984609127045, + 0.2791505455970764, + 0.09458378702402115, + 0.0739106610417366, + 0.15666402876377106, + 0.051162607967853546, + 0.0391683466732502 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076345098204910755 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive bronze statue of Guan Yu with a deep vermilion face and chest-length beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the statue's surface covered in a weathered green patina and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do spiderweb-like cracks rapidly emerge from the statue's face and spread downward to the beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do large fragments of bronze peel and crumble from the statue's core like dead bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a slow, upward-focused view against a backdrop of swirling dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020581606775522232 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955817222595215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020581606775522232, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020581606775522232, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1787685602903366, + 0.08042248338460922, + 0.019873550161719322, + 0.06545509397983551, + 0.15887489914894104, + 0.05460496246814728, + 0.10371852666139603, + 0.22494879364967346, + 0.0754871666431427, + 0.037846002727746964 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020581606775522232 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive bronze statue of Guan Yu with a deep vermilion face and chest-length beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the statue's surface covered in a weathered green patina and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do spiderweb-like cracks rapidly emerge from the statue's face and spread downward to the beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do large fragments of bronze peel and crumble from the statue's core like dead bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a slow, upward-focused view against a backdrop of swirling dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006733584217727184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006733417510986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006733584217727184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006733584217727184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15130001306533813, + 0.06398109346628189, + 0.04805346950888634, + 0.05273601412773132, + 0.1719759702682495, + 0.04509182274341583, + 0.0957241952419281, + 0.26827487349510193, + 0.04578263685107231, + 0.057079922407865524 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006733584217727184 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive bronze statue of Guan Yu with a deep vermilion face and chest-length beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the statue's surface covered in a weathered green patina and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do spiderweb-like cracks rapidly emerge from the statue's face and spread downward to the beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do large fragments of bronze peel and crumble from the statue's core like dead bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a slow, upward-focused view against a backdrop of swirling dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606273651123047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410627365112305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606273651123047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606273651123047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10171504318714142, + 0.0313439704477787, + 0.046025585383176804, + 0.03493683040142059, + 0.2870807349681854, + 0.047740545123815536, + 0.10643012076616287, + 0.20754404366016388, + 0.10067248344421387, + 0.036510542035102844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606273651123047 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, upward-focused shot reveals a massive bronze statue of Guan Yu, majestically standing on a vast, desolate plain, against a backdrop of swirling, dark clouds. The faint, cold light filtering through gaps in the clouds reveals the statue's weathered outline, its surface stained with a patina of weathered green. Suddenly, a dull, resonant sound echoes from within, and the statue begins to crumble from its core. Countless spiderweb-like cracks emerge with astonishing speed from its signature deep vermilion face, rapidly spreading downward, extending to its signature chest-length beard. As the cracks deepen, large fragments of bronze begin to peel and crumble like dead bark, sliding silently or snapping off under the weight of gravity. The cold light captures the sharp edges of the metal as they flare away. Deep within the cracks, the statue's hollow, dark interior is revealed, revealing its destruction stemming from its own inherent decay. The entire scene is permeated with an epic sense of tragedy of solemn destruction. Every cracked texture and every piece of rust on metal is presented with ultra-high clarity, perfectly embodying the ultimate realism and tragic aesthetics pursued by a high-detail digital artwork.", + "seed": 8651, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_4/index_2684_seed_8651_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0291658123023808, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0291658123023808, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0291658123023808, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive bronze statue of Guan Yu with a deep vermilion face and chest-length beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the statue's surface covered in a weathered green patina and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do spiderweb-like cracks rapidly emerge from the statue's face and spread downward to the beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do large fragments of bronze peel and crumble from the statue's core like dead bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a slow, upward-focused view against a backdrop of swirling dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07152362912893295 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.696523666381836 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07152362912893295, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07152362912893295, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13335713744163513, + 0.22180673480033875, + 0.04981250315904617, + 0.14652462303638458, + 0.18670904636383057, + 0.06575164198875427, + 0.06663406640291214, + 0.03151724115014076, + 0.06042010709643364, + 0.037466928362846375 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07152362912893295 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive bronze statue of Guan Yu with a deep vermilion face and chest-length beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the statue's surface covered in a weathered green patina and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do spiderweb-like cracks rapidly emerge from the statue's face and spread downward to the beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do large fragments of bronze peel and crumble from the statue's core like dead bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a slow, upward-focused view against a backdrop of swirling dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005961731541901827 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130961894989014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005961731541901827, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005961731541901827, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1276809424161911, + 0.17393215000629425, + 0.12225832045078278, + 0.12479383498430252, + 0.06572616100311279, + 0.07649350166320801, + 0.05885873734951019, + 0.06936574727296829, + 0.1202085018157959, + 0.060682110488414764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005961731541901827 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive bronze statue of Guan Yu with a deep vermilion face and chest-length beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the statue's surface covered in a weathered green patina and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do spiderweb-like cracks rapidly emerge from the statue's face and spread downward to the beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do large fragments of bronze peel and crumble from the statue's core like dead bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a slow, upward-focused view against a backdrop of swirling dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009788726456463337 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634788513183594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009788726456463337, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009788726456463337, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12429329752922058, + 0.15597456693649292, + 0.0520113967359066, + 0.10834752023220062, + 0.08455295860767365, + 0.1132827028632164, + 0.09349702298641205, + 0.10068636387586594, + 0.10063948482275009, + 0.06671474128961563 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009788726456463337 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive bronze statue of Guan Yu with a deep vermilion face and chest-length beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the statue's surface covered in a weathered green patina and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do spiderweb-like cracks rapidly emerge from the statue's face and spread downward to the beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do large fragments of bronze peel and crumble from the statue's core like dead bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a slow, upward-focused view against a backdrop of swirling dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003616699017584324 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628616809844971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003616699017584324, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003616699017584324, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13898663222789764, + 0.1890132576227188, + 0.036089494824409485, + 0.10430965572595596, + 0.06192692741751671, + 0.08820157498121262, + 0.06942842155694962, + 0.09258205443620682, + 0.13631807267665863, + 0.08314388245344162 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003616699017584324 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive bronze statue of Guan Yu with a deep vermilion face and chest-length beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the statue's surface covered in a weathered green patina and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do spiderweb-like cracks rapidly emerge from the statue's face and spread downward to the beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do large fragments of bronze peel and crumble from the statue's core like dead bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a slow, upward-focused view against a backdrop of swirling dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05493827536702156 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929938316345215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05493827536702156, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05493827536702156, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0936659649014473, + 0.16669683158397675, + 0.03732922673225403, + 0.08481300622224808, + 0.08435478061437607, + 0.13315001130104065, + 0.040926698595285416, + 0.10474099963903427, + 0.23300999402999878, + 0.021312475204467773 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05493827536702156 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, upward-focused shot reveals a massive bronze statue of Guan Yu, majestically standing on a vast, desolate plain, against a backdrop of swirling, dark clouds. The faint, cold light filtering through gaps in the clouds reveals the statue's weathered outline, its surface stained with a patina of weathered green. Suddenly, a dull, resonant sound echoes from within, and the statue begins to crumble from its core. Countless spiderweb-like cracks emerge with astonishing speed from its signature deep vermilion face, rapidly spreading downward, extending to its signature chest-length beard. As the cracks deepen, large fragments of bronze begin to peel and crumble like dead bark, sliding silently or snapping off under the weight of gravity. The cold light captures the sharp edges of the metal as they flare away. Deep within the cracks, the statue's hollow, dark interior is revealed, revealing its destruction stemming from its own inherent decay. The entire scene is permeated with an epic sense of tragedy of solemn destruction. Every cracked texture and every piece of rust on metal is presented with ultra-high clarity, perfectly embodying the ultimate realism and tragic aesthetics pursued by a high-detail digital artwork.", + "seed": 8652, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_4/index_2684_seed_8652_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.07008754471316933, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07008754471316933, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07008754471316933, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive bronze statue of Guan Yu with a deep vermilion face and chest-length beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the statue's surface covered in a weathered green patina and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do spiderweb-like cracks rapidly emerge from the statue's face and spread downward to the beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do large fragments of bronze peel and crumble from the statue's core like dead bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a slow, upward-focused view against a backdrop of swirling dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2832270562648773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4082270860671997 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2832270562648773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2832270562648773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13028475642204285, + 0.03662605211138725, + 0.039818886667490005, + 0.2136092633008957, + 0.4233756363391876, + 0.07678985595703125, + 0.011672710999846458, + 0.011655014008283615, + 0.035207536071538925, + 0.020960263907909393 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2832270562648773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive bronze statue of Guan Yu with a deep vermilion face and chest-length beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the statue's surface covered in a weathered green patina and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do spiderweb-like cracks rapidly emerge from the statue's face and spread downward to the beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do large fragments of bronze peel and crumble from the statue's core like dead bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a slow, upward-focused view against a backdrop of swirling dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007645629812031984 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882645606994629 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007645629812031984, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007645629812031984, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14977289736270905, + 0.04410902038216591, + 0.05166071653366089, + 0.27588385343551636, + 0.24975477159023285, + 0.05232159420847893, + 0.015364798717200756, + 0.025544214993715286, + 0.04064685478806496, + 0.09494126588106155 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007645629812031984 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive bronze statue of Guan Yu with a deep vermilion face and chest-length beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the statue's surface covered in a weathered green patina and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do spiderweb-like cracks rapidly emerge from the statue's face and spread downward to the beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do large fragments of bronze peel and crumble from the statue's core like dead bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a slow, upward-focused view against a backdrop of swirling dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370985761284828 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408709764480591 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370985761284828, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370985761284828, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08791641145944595, + 0.04769797623157501, + 0.03443266078829765, + 0.1036575511097908, + 0.4065929055213928, + 0.05226621776819229, + 0.027230801060795784, + 0.01580454595386982, + 0.062107525765895844, + 0.16229332983493805 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370985761284828 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive bronze statue of Guan Yu with a deep vermilion face and chest-length beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the statue's surface covered in a weathered green patina and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do spiderweb-like cracks rapidly emerge from the statue's face and spread downward to the beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do large fragments of bronze peel and crumble from the statue's core like dead bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a slow, upward-focused view against a backdrop of swirling dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009782588109374046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634782791137695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009782588109374046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009782588109374046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.045644793659448624, + 0.038350366055965424, + 0.03540768474340439, + 0.07552561908960342, + 0.37823089957237244, + 0.06720004230737686, + 0.02545822598040104, + 0.030818860977888107, + 0.06925676017999649, + 0.23410676419734955 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009782588109374046 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive bronze statue of Guan Yu with a deep vermilion face and chest-length beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the statue's surface covered in a weathered green patina and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do spiderweb-like cracks rapidly emerge from the statue's face and spread downward to the beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do large fragments of bronze peel and crumble from the statue's core like dead bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a slow, upward-focused view against a backdrop of swirling dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607259176671505 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141072750091553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607259176671505, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607259176671505, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10740098357200623, + 0.05552348867058754, + 0.06758096069097519, + 0.07933943718671799, + 0.2891102731227875, + 0.0830259621143341, + 0.049962881952524185, + 0.029156941920518875, + 0.12753503024578094, + 0.11136405169963837 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607259176671505 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, upward-focused shot reveals a massive bronze statue of Guan Yu, majestically standing on a vast, desolate plain, against a backdrop of swirling, dark clouds. The faint, cold light filtering through gaps in the clouds reveals the statue's weathered outline, its surface stained with a patina of weathered green. Suddenly, a dull, resonant sound echoes from within, and the statue begins to crumble from its core. Countless spiderweb-like cracks emerge with astonishing speed from its signature deep vermilion face, rapidly spreading downward, extending to its signature chest-length beard. As the cracks deepen, large fragments of bronze begin to peel and crumble like dead bark, sliding silently or snapping off under the weight of gravity. The cold light captures the sharp edges of the metal as they flare away. Deep within the cracks, the statue's hollow, dark interior is revealed, revealing its destruction stemming from its own inherent decay. The entire scene is permeated with an epic sense of tragedy of solemn destruction. Every cracked texture and every piece of rust on metal is presented with ultra-high clarity, perfectly embodying the ultimate realism and tragic aesthetics pursued by a high-detail digital artwork.", + "seed": 8653, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_4/index_2684_seed_8653_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.011531082354485989, + "vlm_logprob": -0.011531082354485989, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.011531082354485989, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive bronze statue of Guan Yu with a deep vermilion face and chest-length beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the statue's surface covered in a weathered green patina and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do spiderweb-like cracks rapidly emerge from the statue's face and spread downward to the beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do large fragments of bronze peel and crumble from the statue's core like dead bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a slow, upward-focused view against a backdrop of swirling dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019034231081604958 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.019034385681152 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019034231081604958, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019034231081604958, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1717994660139084, + 0.06837716698646545, + 0.1098005399107933, + 0.0850641205906868, + 0.12445133179426193, + 0.0800478607416153, + 0.13130350410938263, + 0.057311199605464935, + 0.07249758392572403, + 0.09934724867343903 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019034231081604958 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive bronze statue of Guan Yu with a deep vermilion face and chest-length beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the statue's surface covered in a weathered green patina and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do spiderweb-like cracks rapidly emerge from the statue's face and spread downward to the beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do large fragments of bronze peel and crumble from the statue's core like dead bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a slow, upward-focused view against a backdrop of swirling dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004106304608285427 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504106521606445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004106304608285427, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004106304608285427, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10200619697570801, + 0.06855926662683487, + 0.10459963232278824, + 0.12446720898151398, + 0.07872168719768524, + 0.059037331491708755, + 0.0761057585477829, + 0.04105691984295845, + 0.1939030885696411, + 0.15154290199279785 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004106304608285427 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive bronze statue of Guan Yu with a deep vermilion face and chest-length beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the statue's surface covered in a weathered green patina and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do spiderweb-like cracks rapidly emerge from the statue's face and spread downward to the beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do large fragments of bronze peel and crumble from the statue's core like dead bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a slow, upward-focused view against a backdrop of swirling dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018190348520874977 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018190383911133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018190348520874977, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018190348520874977, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07197895646095276, + 0.06622563302516937, + 0.05984565243124962, + 0.1051936224102974, + 0.04117174074053764, + 0.1331474483013153, + 0.057406116276979446, + 0.06631873548030853, + 0.24090014398097992, + 0.1578119695186615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018190348520874977 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive bronze statue of Guan Yu with a deep vermilion face and chest-length beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the statue's surface covered in a weathered green patina and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do spiderweb-like cracks rapidly emerge from the statue's face and spread downward to the beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do large fragments of bronze peel and crumble from the statue's core like dead bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a slow, upward-focused view against a backdrop of swirling dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005253676325082779 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255253791809082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005253676325082779, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005253676325082779, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0985674113035202, + 0.0781683549284935, + 0.05427438020706177, + 0.07370364665985107, + 0.05037583410739899, + 0.10599058866500854, + 0.06719158589839935, + 0.10229893773794174, + 0.19330383837223053, + 0.1761253923177719 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005253676325082779 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive bronze statue of Guan Yu with a deep vermilion face and chest-length beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the statue's surface covered in a weathered green patina and rust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do spiderweb-like cracks rapidly emerge from the statue's face and spread downward to the beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do large fragments of bronze peel and crumble from the statue's core like dead bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a slow, upward-focused view against a backdrop of swirling dark clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011070851236581802 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511070728302002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011070851236581802, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011070851236581802, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1643657386302948, + 0.0617210753262043, + 0.03926457092165947, + 0.04430723562836647, + 0.05973915383219719, + 0.07180114835500717, + 0.13634441792964935, + 0.07063669711351395, + 0.1849026083946228, + 0.16691730916500092 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011070851236581802 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_5/index_tensor([5199, 5199])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_5/index_tensor([5199, 5199])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ae9dc516c7c3315377cd469ca308456c0009f94e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_5/index_tensor([5199, 5199])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In the style of a neo-Chinese ink painting, the scene opens with a static, eye-level close-up of a gleaming white porcelain plate, artfully arranged upon a pile of vibrant red crayfish. Bold calligraphic brushstrokes define the sharp edges of the shells, while delicate grays and blacks create depth and shadows on the textured paper canvas. A wisp of steam, rendered like ethereal white ink, curls upward in a dance of anticipation. The entire composition is accented by a gorgeous, abstract splash of gold ink, shimmering with a life of its own. The camera then unfolds in a slow, graceful dollop, gradually revealing a diner, their face a study in minimalist lines, their mouth slightly open in delighted wonder. As the frame widens, the complete, elegant dining setting emerges, reminiscent of traditional East Asian masterpieces: a dark, polished wooden table, a pair of chopsticks resting on a jade-colored holder, and a softly focused, minimalist background. The slow unfolding, combined with the artistic medium, creates an atmosphere of refinement, culinary reverence, and quiet excitement.", + "seed": 7495, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_5/index_5199_seed_7495_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.020325399376451968, + "vlm_logprob": -0.020325399376451968, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.020325399376451968, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a neo-Chinese ink painting featuring bold brushstrokes and textured paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a gleaming white porcelain plate visible on a pile of vibrant red crayfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a wisp of steam rendered like ethereal white ink curl upward from the food?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a static, eye-level close-up and then slowly unfold to reveal a diner and the wider dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final scene a dark, polished wooden table with chopsticks on a jade-colored holder and a softly focused minimalist background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0023417449556291103 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.3773417472839355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0023417449556291103, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0023417449556291103, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04543931409716606, + 0.04103658348321915, + 0.043667107820510864, + 0.03320685401558876, + 0.10583455115556717, + 0.0867568626999855, + 0.15651080012321472, + 0.07029134780168533, + 0.11441489309072495, + 0.3028417229652405 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0023417449556291103 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a neo-Chinese ink painting featuring bold brushstrokes and textured paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a gleaming white porcelain plate visible on a pile of vibrant red crayfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a wisp of steam rendered like ethereal white ink curl upward from the food?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a static, eye-level close-up and then slowly unfold to reveal a diner and the wider dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final scene a dark, polished wooden table with chopsticks on a jade-colored holder and a softly focused minimalist background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004643134772777557 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379642963409424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004643134772777557, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004643134772777557, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13885746896266937, + 0.09947960078716278, + 0.07783430069684982, + 0.10794704407453537, + 0.061918746680021286, + 0.11549371480941772, + 0.03333451971411705, + 0.11713331192731857, + 0.06797843426465988, + 0.18002282083034515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004643134772777557 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a neo-Chinese ink painting featuring bold brushstrokes and textured paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a gleaming white porcelain plate visible on a pile of vibrant red crayfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a wisp of steam rendered like ethereal white ink curl upward from the food?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a static, eye-level close-up and then slowly unfold to reveal a diner and the wider dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final scene a dark, polished wooden table with chopsticks on a jade-colored holder and a softly focused minimalist background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0110683748498559 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511068344116211 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0110683748498559, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0110683748498559, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09901458770036697, + 0.0814816877245903, + 0.07137798517942429, + 0.04723064973950386, + 0.10525783896446228, + 0.07673314958810806, + 0.09569323807954788, + 0.15103913843631744, + 0.13766032457351685, + 0.13451141119003296 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0110683748498559 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a neo-Chinese ink painting featuring bold brushstrokes and textured paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a gleaming white porcelain plate visible on a pile of vibrant red crayfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a wisp of steam rendered like ethereal white ink curl upward from the food?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a static, eye-level close-up and then slowly unfold to reveal a diner and the wider dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final scene a dark, polished wooden table with chopsticks on a jade-colored holder and a softly focused minimalist background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004632218275219202 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379631996154785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004632218275219202, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004632218275219202, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0690082460641861, + 0.035541851073503494, + 0.0636378601193428, + 0.06122465431690216, + 0.07302765548229218, + 0.08422411978244781, + 0.10143230110406876, + 0.09240511059761047, + 0.31245866417884827, + 0.10703962296247482 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004632218275219202 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a neo-Chinese ink painting featuring bold brushstrokes and textured paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a gleaming white porcelain plate visible on a pile of vibrant red crayfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a wisp of steam rendered like ethereal white ink curl upward from the food?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a static, eye-level close-up and then slowly unfold to reveal a diner and the wider dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final scene a dark, polished wooden table with chopsticks on a jade-colored holder and a softly focused minimalist background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07894152402877808 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578941583633423 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07894152402877808, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07894152402877808, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02737322822213173, + 0.028618115931749344, + 0.059706397354602814, + 0.05259469896554947, + 0.05433015525341034, + 0.09676827490329742, + 0.13395924866199493, + 0.13778463006019592, + 0.3287193775177002, + 0.0801459476351738 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07894152402877808 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the style of a neo-Chinese ink painting, the scene opens with a static, eye-level close-up of a gleaming white porcelain plate, artfully arranged upon a pile of vibrant red crayfish. Bold calligraphic brushstrokes define the sharp edges of the shells, while delicate grays and blacks create depth and shadows on the textured paper canvas. A wisp of steam, rendered like ethereal white ink, curls upward in a dance of anticipation. The entire composition is accented by a gorgeous, abstract splash of gold ink, shimmering with a life of its own. The camera then unfolds in a slow, graceful dollop, gradually revealing a diner, their face a study in minimalist lines, their mouth slightly open in delighted wonder. As the frame widens, the complete, elegant dining setting emerges, reminiscent of traditional East Asian masterpieces: a dark, polished wooden table, a pair of chopsticks resting on a jade-colored holder, and a softly focused, minimalist background. The slow unfolding, combined with the artistic medium, creates an atmosphere of refinement, culinary reverence, and quiet excitement.", + "seed": 7496, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_5/index_5199_seed_7496_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.010668698698282242, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010668698698282242, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010668698698282242, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a neo-Chinese ink painting featuring bold brushstrokes and textured paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a gleaming white porcelain plate visible on a pile of vibrant red crayfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a wisp of steam rendered like ethereal white ink curl upward from the food?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a static, eye-level close-up and then slowly unfold to reveal a diner and the wider dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final scene a dark, polished wooden table with chopsticks on a jade-colored holder and a softly focused minimalist background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004149399232119322 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.879149436950684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004149399232119322, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004149399232119322, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08982577919960022, + 0.041965972632169724, + 0.063733771443367, + 0.1355389654636383, + 0.17574305832386017, + 0.10015285760164261, + 0.0445714108645916, + 0.21777088940143585, + 0.07865467667579651, + 0.05204266309738159 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004149399232119322 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a neo-Chinese ink painting featuring bold brushstrokes and textured paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a gleaming white porcelain plate visible on a pile of vibrant red crayfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a wisp of steam rendered like ethereal white ink curl upward from the food?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a static, eye-level close-up and then slowly unfold to reveal a diner and the wider dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final scene a dark, polished wooden table with chopsticks on a jade-colored holder and a softly focused minimalist background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005962205585092306 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130962371826172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005962205585092306, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005962205585092306, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1489229053258896, + 0.07527235150337219, + 0.21623866260051727, + 0.08718321472406387, + 0.11415955424308777, + 0.06260652840137482, + 0.04532048478722572, + 0.16717496514320374, + 0.04047849774360657, + 0.04264283552765846 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005962205585092306 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a neo-Chinese ink painting featuring bold brushstrokes and textured paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a gleaming white porcelain plate visible on a pile of vibrant red crayfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a wisp of steam rendered like ethereal white ink curl upward from the food?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a static, eye-level close-up and then slowly unfold to reveal a diner and the wider dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final scene a dark, polished wooden table with chopsticks on a jade-colored holder and a softly focused minimalist background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003611947875469923 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628612041473389 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003611947875469923, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003611947875469923, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25511807203292847, + 0.17653252184391022, + 0.13894103467464447, + 0.038481682538986206, + 0.1376529484987259, + 0.03545670583844185, + 0.035645514726638794, + 0.059193938970565796, + 0.07264650613069534, + 0.05033114179968834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003611947875469923 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a neo-Chinese ink painting featuring bold brushstrokes and textured paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a gleaming white porcelain plate visible on a pile of vibrant red crayfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a wisp of steam rendered like ethereal white ink curl upward from the food?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a static, eye-level close-up and then slowly unfold to reveal a diner and the wider dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final scene a dark, polished wooden table with chopsticks on a jade-colored holder and a softly focused minimalist background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005944430362433195 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.13094425201416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005944430362433195, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005944430362433195, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14296382665634155, + 0.05561235547065735, + 0.09900037944316864, + 0.07884041219949722, + 0.17263638973236084, + 0.12600108981132507, + 0.05321997404098511, + 0.08341815322637558, + 0.12315396964550018, + 0.06515339016914368 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005944430362433195 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a neo-Chinese ink painting featuring bold brushstrokes and textured paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a gleaming white porcelain plate visible on a pile of vibrant red crayfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a wisp of steam rendered like ethereal white ink curl upward from the food?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a static, eye-level close-up and then slowly unfold to reveal a diner and the wider dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final scene a dark, polished wooden table with chopsticks on a jade-colored holder and a softly focused minimalist background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03367551043629646 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086754322052 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03367551043629646, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03367551043629646, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06413668394088745, + 0.03782825171947479, + 0.05824586749076843, + 0.027679285034537315, + 0.054857268929481506, + 0.17712144553661346, + 0.0704803466796875, + 0.19909177720546722, + 0.1503901332616806, + 0.16016900539398193 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03367551043629646 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the style of a neo-Chinese ink painting, the scene opens with a static, eye-level close-up of a gleaming white porcelain plate, artfully arranged upon a pile of vibrant red crayfish. Bold calligraphic brushstrokes define the sharp edges of the shells, while delicate grays and blacks create depth and shadows on the textured paper canvas. A wisp of steam, rendered like ethereal white ink, curls upward in a dance of anticipation. The entire composition is accented by a gorgeous, abstract splash of gold ink, shimmering with a life of its own. The camera then unfolds in a slow, graceful dollop, gradually revealing a diner, their face a study in minimalist lines, their mouth slightly open in delighted wonder. As the frame widens, the complete, elegant dining setting emerges, reminiscent of traditional East Asian masterpieces: a dark, polished wooden table, a pair of chopsticks resting on a jade-colored holder, and a softly focused, minimalist background. The slow unfolding, combined with the artistic medium, creates an atmosphere of refinement, culinary reverence, and quiet excitement.", + "seed": 7497, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_5/index_5199_seed_7497_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04192234678193927, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04192234678193927, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04192234678193927, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a neo-Chinese ink painting featuring bold brushstrokes and textured paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a gleaming white porcelain plate visible on a pile of vibrant red crayfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a wisp of steam rendered like ethereal white ink curl upward from the food?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a static, eye-level close-up and then slowly unfold to reveal a diner and the wider dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final scene a dark, polished wooden table with chopsticks on a jade-colored holder and a softly focused minimalist background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.025476040318608284 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7754759788513184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.025476040318608284, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.025476040318608284, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20117273926734924, + 0.0808534026145935, + 0.053958289325237274, + 0.1346854567527771, + 0.20343290269374847, + 0.05483170971274376, + 0.08941438794136047, + 0.05272363871335983, + 0.06610359996557236, + 0.06282385438680649 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.025476040318608284 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a neo-Chinese ink painting featuring bold brushstrokes and textured paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a gleaming white porcelain plate visible on a pile of vibrant red crayfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a wisp of steam rendered like ethereal white ink curl upward from the food?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a static, eye-level close-up and then slowly unfold to reveal a diner and the wider dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final scene a dark, polished wooden table with chopsticks on a jade-colored holder and a softly focused minimalist background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011105158366262913 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511105060577393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011105158366262913, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011105158366262913, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13175635039806366, + 0.1435767114162445, + 0.057271022349596024, + 0.04617615044116974, + 0.2589349150657654, + 0.036424484103918076, + 0.2081928253173828, + 0.0667601004242897, + 0.026986798271536827, + 0.023920608684420586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011105158366262913 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a neo-Chinese ink painting featuring bold brushstrokes and textured paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a gleaming white porcelain plate visible on a pile of vibrant red crayfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a wisp of steam rendered like ethereal white ink curl upward from the food?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a static, eye-level close-up and then slowly unfold to reveal a diner and the wider dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final scene a dark, polished wooden table with chopsticks on a jade-colored holder and a softly focused minimalist background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005953317973762751 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130953311920166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005953317973762751, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005953317973762751, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5148475766181946, + 0.02973957546055317, + 0.06184197589755058, + 0.11439694464206696, + 0.11212879419326782, + 0.041564978659152985, + 0.012621116824448109, + 0.0240118857473135, + 0.057646509259939194, + 0.031200645491480827 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005953317973762751 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a neo-Chinese ink painting featuring bold brushstrokes and textured paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a gleaming white porcelain plate visible on a pile of vibrant red crayfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a wisp of steam rendered like ethereal white ink curl upward from the food?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a static, eye-level close-up and then slowly unfold to reveal a diner and the wider dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final scene a dark, polished wooden table with chopsticks on a jade-colored holder and a softly focused minimalist background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006737846881151199 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00673770904541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006737846881151199, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006737846881151199, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08568582683801651, + 0.06671154499053955, + 0.03989877924323082, + 0.08094283193349838, + 0.4903565049171448, + 0.055859435349702835, + 0.043146662414073944, + 0.022077538073062897, + 0.07037647068500519, + 0.04494447261095047 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006737846881151199 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a neo-Chinese ink painting featuring bold brushstrokes and textured paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a gleaming white porcelain plate visible on a pile of vibrant red crayfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a wisp of steam rendered like ethereal white ink curl upward from the food?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a static, eye-level close-up and then slowly unfold to reveal a diner and the wider dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final scene a dark, polished wooden table with chopsticks on a jade-colored holder and a softly focused minimalist background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603393703699112 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.91033935546875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603393703699112, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603393703699112, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11042027920484543, + 0.2051772177219391, + 0.056393831968307495, + 0.15911667048931122, + 0.1764039695262909, + 0.05997481197118759, + 0.0285127442330122, + 0.03852105140686035, + 0.0975751057267189, + 0.06790433079004288 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603393703699112 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the style of a neo-Chinese ink painting, the scene opens with a static, eye-level close-up of a gleaming white porcelain plate, artfully arranged upon a pile of vibrant red crayfish. Bold calligraphic brushstrokes define the sharp edges of the shells, while delicate grays and blacks create depth and shadows on the textured paper canvas. A wisp of steam, rendered like ethereal white ink, curls upward in a dance of anticipation. The entire composition is accented by a gorgeous, abstract splash of gold ink, shimmering with a life of its own. The camera then unfolds in a slow, graceful dollop, gradually revealing a diner, their face a study in minimalist lines, their mouth slightly open in delighted wonder. As the frame widens, the complete, elegant dining setting emerges, reminiscent of traditional East Asian masterpieces: a dark, polished wooden table, a pair of chopsticks resting on a jade-colored holder, and a softly focused, minimalist background. The slow unfolding, combined with the artistic medium, creates an atmosphere of refinement, culinary reverence, and quiet excitement.", + "seed": 7498, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_5/index_5199_seed_7498_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.00647858795709908, + "vlm_logprob": -0.00647858795709908, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.00647858795709908, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a neo-Chinese ink painting featuring bold brushstrokes and textured paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a gleaming white porcelain plate visible on a pile of vibrant red crayfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a wisp of steam rendered like ethereal white ink curl upward from the food?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a static, eye-level close-up and then slowly unfold to reveal a diner and the wider dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final scene a dark, polished wooden table with chopsticks on a jade-colored holder and a softly focused minimalist background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0034023988991975784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.003402233123779 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0034023988991975784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0034023988991975784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.051093507558107376, + 0.0149995107203722, + 0.04337041452527046, + 0.06907513737678528, + 0.13133418560028076, + 0.05486137419939041, + 0.13926559686660767, + 0.36423879861831665, + 0.07355892658233643, + 0.05820256471633911 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0034023988991975784 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a neo-Chinese ink painting featuring bold brushstrokes and textured paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a gleaming white porcelain plate visible on a pile of vibrant red crayfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a wisp of steam rendered like ethereal white ink curl upward from the food?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a static, eye-level close-up and then slowly unfold to reveal a diner and the wider dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final scene a dark, polished wooden table with chopsticks on a jade-colored holder and a softly focused minimalist background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024970562662929296 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.00249719619751 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024970562662929296, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024970562662929296, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09450662136077881, + 0.028924720361828804, + 0.07022861391305923, + 0.08702460676431656, + 0.13143596053123474, + 0.03235340490937233, + 0.042811885476112366, + 0.4081811010837555, + 0.04113902151584625, + 0.06339409202337265 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024970562662929296 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a neo-Chinese ink painting featuring bold brushstrokes and textured paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a gleaming white porcelain plate visible on a pile of vibrant red crayfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a wisp of steam rendered like ethereal white ink curl upward from the food?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a static, eye-level close-up and then slowly unfold to reveal a diner and the wider dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final scene a dark, polished wooden table with chopsticks on a jade-colored holder and a softly focused minimalist background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007622679229825735 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882622718811035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007622679229825735, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007622679229825735, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07718892395496368, + 0.029282541945576668, + 0.0524958036839962, + 0.14204253256320953, + 0.10684139281511307, + 0.06991995126008987, + 0.10899384319782257, + 0.1790522336959839, + 0.08621101081371307, + 0.14797170460224152 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007622679229825735 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a neo-Chinese ink painting featuring bold brushstrokes and textured paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a gleaming white porcelain plate visible on a pile of vibrant red crayfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a wisp of steam rendered like ethereal white ink curl upward from the food?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a static, eye-level close-up and then slowly unfold to reveal a diner and the wider dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final scene a dark, polished wooden table with chopsticks on a jade-colored holder and a softly focused minimalist background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002815927378833294 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778157234191895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002815927378833294, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002815927378833294, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.024857018142938614, + 0.009420737624168396, + 0.017444200813770294, + 0.0306123998016119, + 0.035246849060058594, + 0.03845115005970001, + 0.037984538823366165, + 0.6702079176902771, + 0.06408238410949707, + 0.07169277966022491 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002815927378833294 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a neo-Chinese ink painting featuring bold brushstrokes and textured paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a gleaming white porcelain plate visible on a pile of vibrant red crayfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a wisp of steam rendered like ethereal white ink curl upward from the food?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a static, eye-level close-up and then slowly unfold to reveal a diner and the wider dining setting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final scene a dark, polished wooden table with chopsticks on a jade-colored holder and a softly focused minimalist background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016054878011345863 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141055107116699 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016054878011345863, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016054878011345863, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0553903691470623, + 0.018533147871494293, + 0.07549363374710083, + 0.05471760779619217, + 0.035361398011446, + 0.0390157625079155, + 0.08398877829313278, + 0.29203662276268005, + 0.07980223000049591, + 0.26566043496131897 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016054878011345863 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_6/index_tensor([8210, 8210])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_6/index_tensor([8210, 8210])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a9c3d7d0e6655574e690ea21b6fca967116debc7 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_6/index_tensor([8210, 8210])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "cinematic, eye-level macro shot begins, the camera tracking smoothly to the right, following the action across the frame. A vibrant orange carrot, its skin displaying delicate earthy ridges and a fresh, dewy sheen, rolls steadily and deliberately across the surface of a dark, rustic wooden table. The table's deeply grained, matte-finish wood is illuminated by a single, warm, directional light source from the side, casting long, soft shadows and highlighting every subtle grain. The carrot gently bumps into a bumpy, light-brown ball of ginger, its papery, wrinkled skin catching the light. The gentle impact imparts momentum, and the ginger begins to roll alongside the carrot. Its irregular, bumpy shape causes it to sway slightly in an enchanting, uneven motion, contrasting with the carrot's smooth trajectory. The scene is bathed in warm tones, the bright orange contrasting with the dark, earthy tones of the wood and ginger, creating an atmosphere of concentration, tranquility, and painterly quality—like a still life come to life.", + "seed": 6560, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_6/index_8210_seed_6560_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05512661533430219, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05512661533430219, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05512661533430219, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level macro view of a vibrant orange carrot rolling across a dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot display delicate earthy ridges and a fresh, dewy sheen on its skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot gently bump into a bumpy, light-brown ball of ginger with papery, wrinkled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"After the impact, does the ginger begin to roll alongside the carrot while swaying slightly in an uneven motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly to the right, following the action across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05624869093298912 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.931248664855957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05624869093298912, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05624869093298912, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2257816046476364, + 0.09975781291723251, + 0.09591599553823471, + 0.10149098187685013, + 0.07143405824899673, + 0.10917282849550247, + 0.07466457039117813, + 0.10328518599271774, + 0.09098294377326965, + 0.02751397155225277 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05624869093298912 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level macro view of a vibrant orange carrot rolling across a dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot display delicate earthy ridges and a fresh, dewy sheen on its skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot gently bump into a bumpy, light-brown ball of ginger with papery, wrinkled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"After the impact, does the ginger begin to roll alongside the carrot while swaying slightly in an uneven motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly to the right, following the action across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023316839709877968 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733168601989746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023316839709877968, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023316839709877968, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.46932879090309143, + 0.08874966204166412, + 0.08100444078445435, + 0.050586212426424026, + 0.036780234426259995, + 0.04972980543971062, + 0.028793366625905037, + 0.0948447585105896, + 0.05391613021492958, + 0.046266648918390274 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023316839709877968 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level macro view of a vibrant orange carrot rolling across a dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot display delicate earthy ridges and a fresh, dewy sheen on its skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot gently bump into a bumpy, light-brown ball of ginger with papery, wrinkled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"After the impact, does the ginger begin to roll alongside the carrot while swaying slightly in an uneven motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly to the right, following the action across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005951777566224337 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130951881408691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005951777566224337, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005951777566224337, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14132480323314667, + 0.05455233156681061, + 0.16077382862567902, + 0.10675514489412308, + 0.12275805324316025, + 0.1322164386510849, + 0.0716509148478508, + 0.1023855060338974, + 0.055694419890642166, + 0.05188855901360512 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005951777566224337 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level macro view of a vibrant orange carrot rolling across a dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot display delicate earthy ridges and a fresh, dewy sheen on its skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot gently bump into a bumpy, light-brown ball of ginger with papery, wrinkled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"After the impact, does the ginger begin to roll alongside the carrot while swaying slightly in an uneven motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly to the right, following the action across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029790107160806656 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529790163040161 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029790107160806656, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029790107160806656, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3651762306690216, + 0.03840511664748192, + 0.07381735742092133, + 0.0501190610229969, + 0.05432114005088806, + 0.08604956418275833, + 0.06624126434326172, + 0.14427903294563293, + 0.06635287404060364, + 0.05523836612701416 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029790107160806656 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level macro view of a vibrant orange carrot rolling across a dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot display delicate earthy ridges and a fresh, dewy sheen on its skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot gently bump into a bumpy, light-brown ball of ginger with papery, wrinkled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"After the impact, does the ginger begin to roll alongside the carrot while swaying slightly in an uneven motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly to the right, following the action across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16032566130161285 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103256464004517 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16032566130161285, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16032566130161285, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20711514353752136, + 0.05694223940372467, + 0.11708135902881622, + 0.05338960140943527, + 0.1129067987203598, + 0.06009062007069588, + 0.18281704187393188, + 0.058810364454984665, + 0.06404746323823929, + 0.08679939806461334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16032566130161285 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematic, eye-level macro shot begins, the camera tracking smoothly to the right, following the action across the frame. A vibrant orange carrot, its skin displaying delicate earthy ridges and a fresh, dewy sheen, rolls steadily and deliberately across the surface of a dark, rustic wooden table. The table's deeply grained, matte-finish wood is illuminated by a single, warm, directional light source from the side, casting long, soft shadows and highlighting every subtle grain. The carrot gently bumps into a bumpy, light-brown ball of ginger, its papery, wrinkled skin catching the light. The gentle impact imparts momentum, and the ginger begins to roll alongside the carrot. Its irregular, bumpy shape causes it to sway slightly in an enchanting, uneven motion, contrasting with the carrot's smooth trajectory. The scene is bathed in warm tones, the bright orange contrasting with the dark, earthy tones of the wood and ginger, creating an atmosphere of concentration, tranquility, and painterly quality—like a still life come to life.", + "seed": 6561, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_6/index_8210_seed_6561_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.10819613030180335, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10819613030180335, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10819613030180335, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level macro view of a vibrant orange carrot rolling across a dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot display delicate earthy ridges and a fresh, dewy sheen on its skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot gently bump into a bumpy, light-brown ball of ginger with papery, wrinkled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"After the impact, does the ginger begin to roll alongside the carrot while swaying slightly in an uneven motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly to the right, following the action across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03912748396396637 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2891275882720947 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03912748396396637, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03912748396396637, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03943876549601555, + 0.02472859062254429, + 0.016995742917060852, + 0.04205423220992088, + 0.03263714164495468, + 0.6555460095405579, + 0.038807351142168045, + 0.04522717744112015, + 0.037356212735176086, + 0.06720873713493347 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03912748396396637 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level macro view of a vibrant orange carrot rolling across a dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot display delicate earthy ridges and a fresh, dewy sheen on its skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot gently bump into a bumpy, light-brown ball of ginger with papery, wrinkled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"After the impact, does the ginger begin to roll alongside the carrot while swaying slightly in an uneven motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly to the right, following the action across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07906247675418854 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790624618530273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07906247675418854, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07906247675418854, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09664762020111084, + 0.05460754409432411, + 0.01748824119567871, + 0.023459916934370995, + 0.026624584570527077, + 0.34729233384132385, + 0.028490455821156502, + 0.027267878875136375, + 0.03378752991557121, + 0.34433385729789734 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07906247675418854 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level macro view of a vibrant orange carrot rolling across a dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot display delicate earthy ridges and a fresh, dewy sheen on its skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot gently bump into a bumpy, light-brown ball of ginger with papery, wrinkled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"After the impact, does the ginger begin to roll alongside the carrot while swaying slightly in an uneven motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly to the right, following the action across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00595379201695323 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130953788757324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00595379201695323, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00595379201695323, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.040126945823431015, + 0.011266197077929974, + 0.0093349264934659, + 0.04353372007608414, + 0.07175128906965256, + 0.5383464694023132, + 0.033894337713718414, + 0.05402613803744316, + 0.04907199740409851, + 0.1486479490995407 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00595379201695323 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level macro view of a vibrant orange carrot rolling across a dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot display delicate earthy ridges and a fresh, dewy sheen on its skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot gently bump into a bumpy, light-brown ball of ginger with papery, wrinkled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"After the impact, does the ginger begin to roll alongside the carrot while swaying slightly in an uneven motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly to the right, following the action across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029794733971357346 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529794692993164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029794733971357346, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029794733971357346, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.027684038504958153, + 0.014825397171080112, + 0.02003689855337143, + 0.016556410118937492, + 0.042500726878643036, + 0.543298065662384, + 0.036935366690158844, + 0.04086379334330559, + 0.08729299157857895, + 0.17000630497932434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029794733971357346 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level macro view of a vibrant orange carrot rolling across a dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot display delicate earthy ridges and a fresh, dewy sheen on its skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot gently bump into a bumpy, light-brown ball of ginger with papery, wrinkled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"After the impact, does the ginger begin to roll alongside the carrot while swaying slightly in an uneven motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly to the right, following the action across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38704216480255127 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370421648025513 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38704216480255127, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38704216480255127, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.042698897421360016, + 0.015071682631969452, + 0.035434070974588394, + 0.04026234522461891, + 0.02664046362042427, + 0.5403555035591125, + 0.019615162163972855, + 0.03313392773270607, + 0.02154465578496456, + 0.22524327039718628 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38704216480255127 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematic, eye-level macro shot begins, the camera tracking smoothly to the right, following the action across the frame. A vibrant orange carrot, its skin displaying delicate earthy ridges and a fresh, dewy sheen, rolls steadily and deliberately across the surface of a dark, rustic wooden table. The table's deeply grained, matte-finish wood is illuminated by a single, warm, directional light source from the side, casting long, soft shadows and highlighting every subtle grain. The carrot gently bumps into a bumpy, light-brown ball of ginger, its papery, wrinkled skin catching the light. The gentle impact imparts momentum, and the ginger begins to roll alongside the carrot. Its irregular, bumpy shape causes it to sway slightly in an enchanting, uneven motion, contrasting with the carrot's smooth trajectory. The scene is bathed in warm tones, the bright orange contrasting with the dark, earthy tones of the wood and ginger, creating an atmosphere of concentration, tranquility, and painterly quality—like a still life come to life.", + "seed": 6562, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_6/index_8210_seed_6562_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.09738163203001023, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09738163203001023, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09738163203001023, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level macro view of a vibrant orange carrot rolling across a dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot display delicate earthy ridges and a fresh, dewy sheen on its skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot gently bump into a bumpy, light-brown ball of ginger with papery, wrinkled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"After the impact, does the ginger begin to roll alongside the carrot while swaying slightly in an uneven motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly to the right, following the action across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016986476257443428 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14198637008667 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016986476257443428, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016986476257443428, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08339840918779373, + 0.021445535123348236, + 0.060018233954906464, + 0.2925848960876465, + 0.11470356583595276, + 0.04447847977280617, + 0.056916575878858566, + 0.0410170778632164, + 0.12460386008024216, + 0.16083337366580963 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016986476257443428 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level macro view of a vibrant orange carrot rolling across a dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot display delicate earthy ridges and a fresh, dewy sheen on its skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot gently bump into a bumpy, light-brown ball of ginger with papery, wrinkled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"After the impact, does the ginger begin to roll alongside the carrot while swaying slightly in an uneven motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly to the right, following the action across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03372414782643318 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408724069595337 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03372414782643318, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03372414782643318, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20667558908462524, + 0.11014648526906967, + 0.11058586090803146, + 0.09917080402374268, + 0.1012016087770462, + 0.07615836709737778, + 0.04810358211398125, + 0.054156165570020676, + 0.04940969496965408, + 0.1443917602300644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03372414782643318 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level macro view of a vibrant orange carrot rolling across a dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot display delicate earthy ridges and a fresh, dewy sheen on its skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot gently bump into a bumpy, light-brown ball of ginger with papery, wrinkled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"After the impact, does the ginger begin to roll alongside the carrot while swaying slightly in an uneven motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly to the right, following the action across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011085351929068565 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511085510253906 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011085351929068565, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011085351929068565, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08027750253677368, + 0.029886096715927124, + 0.061394669115543365, + 0.4279577434062958, + 0.08474171906709671, + 0.07282660156488419, + 0.020857881754636765, + 0.028615444898605347, + 0.09567514061927795, + 0.09776714444160461 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011085351929068565 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level macro view of a vibrant orange carrot rolling across a dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot display delicate earthy ridges and a fresh, dewy sheen on its skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot gently bump into a bumpy, light-brown ball of ginger with papery, wrinkled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"After the impact, does the ginger begin to roll alongside the carrot while swaying slightly in an uneven motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly to the right, following the action across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03808766230940819 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880876064300537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03808766230940819, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03808766230940819, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.057288799434900284, + 0.02166845090687275, + 0.01528882049024105, + 0.45684877038002014, + 0.055761586874723434, + 0.035551924258470535, + 0.03935907781124115, + 0.020879626274108887, + 0.08510789275169373, + 0.21224501729011536 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03808766230940819 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level macro view of a vibrant orange carrot rolling across a dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot display delicate earthy ridges and a fresh, dewy sheen on its skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot gently bump into a bumpy, light-brown ball of ginger with papery, wrinkled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"After the impact, does the ginger begin to roll alongside the carrot while swaying slightly in an uneven motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly to the right, following the action across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38702452182769775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370245218276978 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38702452182769775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38702452182769775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04374539107084274, + 0.03477346524596214, + 0.07876430451869965, + 0.39528849720954895, + 0.08195904642343521, + 0.048837754875421524, + 0.04135093465447426, + 0.03612183406949043, + 0.11553552746772766, + 0.12362323701381683 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38702452182769775 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematic, eye-level macro shot begins, the camera tracking smoothly to the right, following the action across the frame. A vibrant orange carrot, its skin displaying delicate earthy ridges and a fresh, dewy sheen, rolls steadily and deliberately across the surface of a dark, rustic wooden table. The table's deeply grained, matte-finish wood is illuminated by a single, warm, directional light source from the side, casting long, soft shadows and highlighting every subtle grain. The carrot gently bumps into a bumpy, light-brown ball of ginger, its papery, wrinkled skin catching the light. The gentle impact imparts momentum, and the ginger begins to roll alongside the carrot. Its irregular, bumpy shape causes it to sway slightly in an enchanting, uneven motion, contrasting with the carrot's smooth trajectory. The scene is bathed in warm tones, the bright orange contrasting with the dark, earthy tones of the wood and ginger, creating an atmosphere of concentration, tranquility, and painterly quality—like a still life come to life.", + "seed": 6563, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_6/index_8210_seed_6563_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0625539387576282, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0625539387576282, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.574999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0625539387576282, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level macro view of a vibrant orange carrot rolling across a dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot display delicate earthy ridges and a fresh, dewy sheen on its skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot gently bump into a bumpy, light-brown ball of ginger with papery, wrinkled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"After the impact, does the ginger begin to roll alongside the carrot while swaying slightly in an uneven motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly to the right, following the action across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03172164410352707 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.531721591949463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03172164410352707, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03172164410352707, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18088820576667786, + 0.1281711310148239, + 0.08144107460975647, + 0.07154173403978348, + 0.060210470110177994, + 0.05608392506837845, + 0.08628645539283752, + 0.10289716720581055, + 0.06889606267213821, + 0.16358377039432526 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03172164410352707 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level macro view of a vibrant orange carrot rolling across a dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot display delicate earthy ridges and a fresh, dewy sheen on its skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot gently bump into a bumpy, light-brown ball of ginger with papery, wrinkled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"After the impact, does the ginger begin to roll alongside the carrot while swaying slightly in an uneven motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly to the right, following the action across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018219612538814545 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018219470977783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018219612538814545, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018219612538814545, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19452574849128723, + 0.08840309083461761, + 0.15848585963249207, + 0.1988663375377655, + 0.0643547922372818, + 0.022244062274694443, + 0.06271380186080933, + 0.06369648873806, + 0.08217500150203705, + 0.06453481316566467 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018219612538814545 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level macro view of a vibrant orange carrot rolling across a dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot display delicate earthy ridges and a fresh, dewy sheen on its skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot gently bump into a bumpy, light-brown ball of ginger with papery, wrinkled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"After the impact, does the ginger begin to roll alongside the carrot while swaying slightly in an uneven motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly to the right, following the action across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036196685396134853 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.62861967086792 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036196685396134853, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036196685396134853, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1530211865901947, + 0.08212490379810333, + 0.07282065600156784, + 0.04396304115653038, + 0.08163221925497055, + 0.04073945805430412, + 0.13056232035160065, + 0.18058045208454132, + 0.05730145424604416, + 0.15725433826446533 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036196685396134853 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level macro view of a vibrant orange carrot rolling across a dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot display delicate earthy ridges and a fresh, dewy sheen on its skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot gently bump into a bumpy, light-brown ball of ginger with papery, wrinkled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"After the impact, does the ginger begin to roll alongside the carrot while swaying slightly in an uneven motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly to the right, following the action across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368738293647766 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086873531341553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368738293647766, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368738293647766, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.151486337184906, + 0.06376167386770248, + 0.06310830265283585, + 0.06659027189016342, + 0.1012532040476799, + 0.06248542293906212, + 0.1092626228928566, + 0.09683031588792801, + 0.07789342850446701, + 0.2073284089565277 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368738293647766 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an eye-level macro view of a vibrant orange carrot rolling across a dark wooden table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot display delicate earthy ridges and a fresh, dewy sheen on its skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carrot gently bump into a bumpy, light-brown ball of ginger with papery, wrinkled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"After the impact, does the ginger begin to roll alongside the carrot while swaying slightly in an uneven motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera track smoothly to the right, following the action across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22552138566970825 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005213260650635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22552138566970825, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22552138566970825, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12863101065158844, + 0.08698096126317978, + 0.05163382366299629, + 0.08704584836959839, + 0.0916018858551979, + 0.033449914306402206, + 0.13109150528907776, + 0.0729944109916687, + 0.10354422777891159, + 0.21302640438079834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22552138566970825 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_7/index_tensor([6489, 6489])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_7/index_tensor([6489, 6489])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1cb21e8833e58cd0ce83a10fe8398b9953c5b9e3 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_7/index_tensor([6489, 6489])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, upward shot, from a low angle, envelopes the scene in the chilly, austere atmosphere of rain. A winding, ancient stone staircase, thoroughly soaked by the rain, each moss-covered step reflected the soft, diffuse light from the gloomy sky, making it incredibly slippery. A dense, deep bamboo forest flanked the steps. Drops of condensation dripped from the leaves, creating a faint sound in the still air. A thin mist swirled through the trees. A tall, upright knight stood steadily midway up the steps. He wore a wide, worn bamboo hat, its shadow obscuring most of his face, revealing only his sharply defined jaw and tightly pursed lips, a look of intense concentration. He wore a linen robe, stained a deep indigo by the moisture. A thick leather belt cinched his waist, and an ancient sword scabbard hung to his left. After a moment of stagnation, the knight's body suddenly exerted force. His right hand grasped the hilt of the sword with a lightning speed almost intangible to the naked eye. With a swift and decisive movement, and with a crisp sound of metal friction, a narrow and sharp straight-bladed longsword was drawn out boldly. The moment the sword was completely unsheathed and cut through the air, the mirror-like blade captured and reflected the only light source in the surrounding area, bursting out with a sharp, cold silver-white arc. This flash briefly illuminated his eyes under the bamboo hat and the splashing water droplets, then disappeared, leaving only the sword tip pointing steadily forward. The entire scene was filled with impending tension and the unique freehand beauty of martial arts.", + "seed": 33230, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_7/index_6489_seed_33230_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.15614977004006506, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15614977004006506, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15614977004006506, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot slow, upward, and from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, ancient stone staircase in a dense bamboo forest with rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tall knight wearing a worn bamboo hat and a deep indigo linen robe standing midway up the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the knight rapidly draw a straight-bladed longsword from its scabbard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light to create a sharp, cold silver-white arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6083179712295532 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8583179712295532 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6083179712295532, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6083179712295532, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2552820146083832, + 0.03906403109431267, + 0.08082915842533112, + 0.05189189687371254, + 0.417411208152771, + 0.031451206654310226, + 0.03730461001396179, + 0.04065626487135887, + 0.01712176576256752, + 0.028987808153033257 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6083179712295532 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot slow, upward, and from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, ancient stone staircase in a dense bamboo forest with rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tall knight wearing a worn bamboo hat and a deep indigo linen robe standing midway up the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the knight rapidly draw a straight-bladed longsword from its scabbard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light to create a sharp, cold silver-white arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008689094334840775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758688926696777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008689094334840775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008689094334840775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13085255026817322, + 0.11759310960769653, + 0.05883673205971718, + 0.05274811387062073, + 0.4568360149860382, + 0.020447008311748505, + 0.036953508853912354, + 0.037627026438713074, + 0.025815071538090706, + 0.062290895730257034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008689094334840775 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot slow, upward, and from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, ancient stone staircase in a dense bamboo forest with rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tall knight wearing a worn bamboo hat and a deep indigo linen robe standing midway up the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the knight rapidly draw a straight-bladed longsword from its scabbard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light to create a sharp, cold silver-white arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006750279571861029 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006750106811523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006750279571861029, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006750279571861029, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09161265939474106, + 0.023403555154800415, + 0.043620865792036057, + 0.0476401187479496, + 0.6951733231544495, + 0.01620182953774929, + 0.022610895335674286, + 0.03637881577014923, + 0.014327832497656345, + 0.00903006736189127 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006750279571861029 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot slow, upward, and from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, ancient stone staircase in a dense bamboo forest with rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tall knight wearing a worn bamboo hat and a deep indigo linen robe standing midway up the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the knight rapidly draw a straight-bladed longsword from its scabbard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light to create a sharp, cold silver-white arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1427963227033615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017796277999878 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1427963227033615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1427963227033615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0514298714697361, + 0.022474005818367004, + 0.013750610873103142, + 0.025267262011766434, + 0.8320273160934448, + 0.010682807303965092, + 0.0063926419243216515, + 0.01219012401998043, + 0.01645830273628235, + 0.00932709313929081 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1427963227033615 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot slow, upward, and from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, ancient stone staircase in a dense bamboo forest with rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tall knight wearing a worn bamboo hat and a deep indigo linen robe standing midway up the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the knight rapidly draw a straight-bladed longsword from its scabbard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light to create a sharp, cold silver-white arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014195182360708714 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264194965362549 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014195182360708714, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014195182360708714, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10171040147542953, + 0.011443745344877243, + 0.024161171168088913, + 0.025071533396840096, + 0.5851799249649048, + 0.013001730665564537, + 0.015142020769417286, + 0.16812150180339813, + 0.03673001378774643, + 0.019437944516539574 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014195182360708714 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, upward shot, from a low angle, envelopes the scene in the chilly, austere atmosphere of rain. A winding, ancient stone staircase, thoroughly soaked by the rain, each moss-covered step reflected the soft, diffuse light from the gloomy sky, making it incredibly slippery. A dense, deep bamboo forest flanked the steps. Drops of condensation dripped from the leaves, creating a faint sound in the still air. A thin mist swirled through the trees. A tall, upright knight stood steadily midway up the steps. He wore a wide, worn bamboo hat, its shadow obscuring most of his face, revealing only his sharply defined jaw and tightly pursed lips, a look of intense concentration. He wore a linen robe, stained a deep indigo by the moisture. A thick leather belt cinched his waist, and an ancient sword scabbard hung to his left. After a moment of stagnation, the knight's body suddenly exerted force. His right hand grasped the hilt of the sword with a lightning speed almost intangible to the naked eye. With a swift and decisive movement, and with a crisp sound of metal friction, a narrow and sharp straight-bladed longsword was drawn out boldly. The moment the sword was completely unsheathed and cut through the air, the mirror-like blade captured and reflected the only light source in the surrounding area, bursting out with a sharp, cold silver-white arc. This flash briefly illuminated his eyes under the bamboo hat and the splashing water droplets, then disappeared, leaving only the sword tip pointing steadily forward. The entire scene was filled with impending tension and the unique freehand beauty of martial arts.", + "seed": 33231, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_7/index_6489_seed_33231_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.20466415900737048, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20466415900737048, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20466415900737048, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot slow, upward, and from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, ancient stone staircase in a dense bamboo forest with rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tall knight wearing a worn bamboo hat and a deep indigo linen robe standing midway up the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the knight rapidly draw a straight-bladed longsword from its scabbard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light to create a sharp, cold silver-white arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07578606903553009 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8257861137390137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07578606903553009, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07578606903553009, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21167555451393127, + 0.2007044106721878, + 0.04798306152224541, + 0.08556254953145981, + 0.01443529687821865, + 0.32964470982551575, + 0.0074709695763885975, + 0.03485216945409775, + 0.030786916613578796, + 0.03688432648777962 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07578606903553009 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot slow, upward, and from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, ancient stone staircase in a dense bamboo forest with rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tall knight wearing a worn bamboo hat and a deep indigo linen robe standing midway up the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the knight rapidly draw a straight-bladed longsword from its scabbard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light to create a sharp, cold silver-white arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00677040871232748 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006770610809326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00677040871232748, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00677040871232748, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20484480261802673, + 0.19998116791248322, + 0.07784453779459, + 0.09432686120271683, + 0.03462139889597893, + 0.11890263855457306, + 0.02584127150475979, + 0.11618847399950027, + 0.043468743562698364, + 0.08398009836673737 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00677040871232748 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot slow, upward, and from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, ancient stone staircase in a dense bamboo forest with rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tall knight wearing a worn bamboo hat and a deep indigo linen robe standing midway up the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the knight rapidly draw a straight-bladed longsword from its scabbard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light to create a sharp, cold silver-white arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016076110303401947 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14107608795166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016076110303401947, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016076110303401947, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.054867736995220184, + 0.3241862654685974, + 0.06993666291236877, + 0.04175882413983345, + 0.04095170274376869, + 0.23962239921092987, + 0.039530493319034576, + 0.07355187833309174, + 0.023054979741573334, + 0.09253910928964615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016076110303401947 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot slow, upward, and from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, ancient stone staircase in a dense bamboo forest with rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tall knight wearing a worn bamboo hat and a deep indigo linen robe standing midway up the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the knight rapidly draw a straight-bladed longsword from its scabbard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light to create a sharp, cold silver-white arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983241319656372 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233241319656372 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8983241319656372, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8983241319656372, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1066230908036232, + 0.5844365358352661, + 0.0656692236661911, + 0.043687328696250916, + 0.051921915262937546, + 0.045233406126499176, + 0.017462966963648796, + 0.032064665108919144, + 0.018346788361668587, + 0.034554097801446915 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8983241319656372 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot slow, upward, and from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, ancient stone staircase in a dense bamboo forest with rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tall knight wearing a worn bamboo hat and a deep indigo linen robe standing midway up the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the knight rapidly draw a straight-bladed longsword from its scabbard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light to create a sharp, cold silver-white arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026364075019955635 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513640880584717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026364075019955635, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026364075019955635, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22194887697696686, + 0.24421177804470062, + 0.030015282332897186, + 0.07660824060440063, + 0.0858970656991005, + 0.20942115783691406, + 0.015568939037621021, + 0.03395870327949524, + 0.01937420479953289, + 0.06299582868814468 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026364075019955635 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, upward shot, from a low angle, envelopes the scene in the chilly, austere atmosphere of rain. A winding, ancient stone staircase, thoroughly soaked by the rain, each moss-covered step reflected the soft, diffuse light from the gloomy sky, making it incredibly slippery. A dense, deep bamboo forest flanked the steps. Drops of condensation dripped from the leaves, creating a faint sound in the still air. A thin mist swirled through the trees. A tall, upright knight stood steadily midway up the steps. He wore a wide, worn bamboo hat, its shadow obscuring most of his face, revealing only his sharply defined jaw and tightly pursed lips, a look of intense concentration. He wore a linen robe, stained a deep indigo by the moisture. A thick leather belt cinched his waist, and an ancient sword scabbard hung to his left. After a moment of stagnation, the knight's body suddenly exerted force. His right hand grasped the hilt of the sword with a lightning speed almost intangible to the naked eye. With a swift and decisive movement, and with a crisp sound of metal friction, a narrow and sharp straight-bladed longsword was drawn out boldly. The moment the sword was completely unsheathed and cut through the air, the mirror-like blade captured and reflected the only light source in the surrounding area, bursting out with a sharp, cold silver-white arc. This flash briefly illuminated his eyes under the bamboo hat and the splashing water droplets, then disappeared, leaving only the sword tip pointing steadily forward. The entire scene was filled with impending tension and the unique freehand beauty of martial arts.", + "seed": 33232, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_7/index_6489_seed_33232_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.07242323076352478, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07242323076352478, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07242323076352478, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot slow, upward, and from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, ancient stone staircase in a dense bamboo forest with rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tall knight wearing a worn bamboo hat and a deep indigo linen robe standing midway up the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the knight rapidly draw a straight-bladed longsword from its scabbard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light to create a sharp, cold silver-white arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2251095175743103 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.725109577178955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2251095175743103, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2251095175743103, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0934479758143425, + 0.04427144676446915, + 0.18755494058132172, + 0.12557023763656616, + 0.10845878720283508, + 0.2011893093585968, + 0.0466889962553978, + 0.0411795936524868, + 0.09144489467144012, + 0.060193825513124466 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2251095175743103 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot slow, upward, and from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, ancient stone staircase in a dense bamboo forest with rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tall knight wearing a worn bamboo hat and a deep indigo linen robe standing midway up the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the knight rapidly draw a straight-bladed longsword from its scabbard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light to create a sharp, cold silver-white arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006775973830372095 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006775856018066 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006775973830372095, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006775973830372095, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20800839364528656, + 0.19805128872394562, + 0.17734847962856293, + 0.03850423917174339, + 0.0764792412519455, + 0.07872699201107025, + 0.05382160842418671, + 0.026494624093174934, + 0.11053458601236343, + 0.0320306234061718 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006775973830372095 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot slow, upward, and from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, ancient stone staircase in a dense bamboo forest with rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tall knight wearing a worn bamboo hat and a deep indigo linen robe standing midway up the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the knight rapidly draw a straight-bladed longsword from its scabbard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light to create a sharp, cold silver-white arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008654113858938217 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586541175842285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008654113858938217, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008654113858938217, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14299550652503967, + 0.12533453106880188, + 0.1269957721233368, + 0.037729211151599884, + 0.09670049697160721, + 0.11163487285375595, + 0.10476589947938919, + 0.03970343619585037, + 0.1598707139492035, + 0.05426960065960884 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008654113858938217 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot slow, upward, and from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, ancient stone staircase in a dense bamboo forest with rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tall knight wearing a worn bamboo hat and a deep indigo linen robe standing midway up the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the knight rapidly draw a straight-bladed longsword from its scabbard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light to create a sharp, cold silver-white arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11293330788612366 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237933397293091 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11293330788612366, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11293330788612366, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04292721301317215, + 0.031876008957624435, + 0.08857008814811707, + 0.05877568945288658, + 0.16641385853290558, + 0.1645030677318573, + 0.037276413291692734, + 0.05520633980631828, + 0.2838589549064636, + 0.07059235125780106 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11293330788612366 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot slow, upward, and from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, ancient stone staircase in a dense bamboo forest with rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tall knight wearing a worn bamboo hat and a deep indigo linen robe standing midway up the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the knight rapidly draw a straight-bladed longsword from its scabbard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light to create a sharp, cold silver-white arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008643240667879581 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75864315032959 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008643240667879581, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008643240667879581, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04760710522532463, + 0.02103620395064354, + 0.02264796942472458, + 0.02875608205795288, + 0.0398460291326046, + 0.02960936538875103, + 0.027289722114801407, + 0.0295021403580904, + 0.7154273390769958, + 0.03827803581953049 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008643240667879581 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, upward shot, from a low angle, envelopes the scene in the chilly, austere atmosphere of rain. A winding, ancient stone staircase, thoroughly soaked by the rain, each moss-covered step reflected the soft, diffuse light from the gloomy sky, making it incredibly slippery. A dense, deep bamboo forest flanked the steps. Drops of condensation dripped from the leaves, creating a faint sound in the still air. A thin mist swirled through the trees. A tall, upright knight stood steadily midway up the steps. He wore a wide, worn bamboo hat, its shadow obscuring most of his face, revealing only his sharply defined jaw and tightly pursed lips, a look of intense concentration. He wore a linen robe, stained a deep indigo by the moisture. A thick leather belt cinched his waist, and an ancient sword scabbard hung to his left. After a moment of stagnation, the knight's body suddenly exerted force. His right hand grasped the hilt of the sword with a lightning speed almost intangible to the naked eye. With a swift and decisive movement, and with a crisp sound of metal friction, a narrow and sharp straight-bladed longsword was drawn out boldly. The moment the sword was completely unsheathed and cut through the air, the mirror-like blade captured and reflected the only light source in the surrounding area, bursting out with a sharp, cold silver-white arc. This flash briefly illuminated his eyes under the bamboo hat and the splashing water droplets, then disappeared, leaving only the sword tip pointing steadily forward. The entire scene was filled with impending tension and the unique freehand beauty of martial arts.", + "seed": 33233, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_7/index_6489_seed_33233_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07158580292016267, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07158580292016267, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07158580292016267, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot slow, upward, and from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, ancient stone staircase in a dense bamboo forest with rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tall knight wearing a worn bamboo hat and a deep indigo linen robe standing midway up the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the knight rapidly draw a straight-bladed longsword from its scabbard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light to create a sharp, cold silver-white arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18164923787117004 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9316492080688477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18164923787117004, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18164923787117004, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10426530987024307, + 0.0886845514178276, + 0.03228132054209709, + 0.03560095280408859, + 0.13806875050067902, + 0.09831314533948898, + 0.27519261837005615, + 0.1270979791879654, + 0.03778006508946419, + 0.0627153143286705 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18164923787117004 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot slow, upward, and from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, ancient stone staircase in a dense bamboo forest with rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tall knight wearing a worn bamboo hat and a deep indigo linen robe standing midway up the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the knight rapidly draw a straight-bladed longsword from its scabbard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light to create a sharp, cold silver-white arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012588916346430779 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387588977813721 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012588916346430779, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012588916346430779, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13030336797237396, + 0.08797790855169296, + 0.049749333411455154, + 0.037205860018730164, + 0.11187382787466049, + 0.095639169216156, + 0.20374202728271484, + 0.12473443150520325, + 0.08132895827293396, + 0.07744506746530533 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012588916346430779 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot slow, upward, and from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, ancient stone staircase in a dense bamboo forest with rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tall knight wearing a worn bamboo hat and a deep indigo linen robe standing midway up the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the knight rapidly draw a straight-bladed longsword from its scabbard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light to create a sharp, cold silver-white arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01108983252197504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51108980178833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01108983252197504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01108983252197504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10776598751544952, + 0.08839481323957443, + 0.037595294415950775, + 0.03566528856754303, + 0.2176847904920578, + 0.2421002984046936, + 0.11925362795591354, + 0.023950831964612007, + 0.016528191044926643, + 0.11106086522340775 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01108983252197504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot slow, upward, and from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, ancient stone staircase in a dense bamboo forest with rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tall knight wearing a worn bamboo hat and a deep indigo linen robe standing midway up the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the knight rapidly draw a straight-bladed longsword from its scabbard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light to create a sharp, cold silver-white arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14281430840492249 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178143978118896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14281430840492249, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14281430840492249, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11227443814277649, + 0.09491310268640518, + 0.03275357931852341, + 0.03162214532494545, + 0.13136254251003265, + 0.3058995008468628, + 0.20415586233139038, + 0.037360090762376785, + 0.02782304771244526, + 0.021835677325725555 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14281430840492249 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot slow, upward, and from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a winding, ancient stone staircase in a dense bamboo forest with rain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tall knight wearing a worn bamboo hat and a deep indigo linen robe standing midway up the steps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the knight rapidly draw a straight-bladed longsword from its scabbard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light to create a sharp, cold silver-white arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978671945631504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634786605834961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978671945631504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978671945631504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14542584121227264, + 0.05225403979420662, + 0.017990710213780403, + 0.03831079974770546, + 0.10222382098436356, + 0.3391461968421936, + 0.0810527428984642, + 0.020129958167672157, + 0.021469775587320328, + 0.18199609220027924 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978671945631504 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_8/index_tensor([163, 163])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_8/index_tensor([163, 163])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fc6cd93d28ff838f1a9fe3cee105143bf64d69a6 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_8/index_tensor([163, 163])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The shot begins in a medium shot, slightly overlooking, with a steady focus on an elderly angler. He wears a wide, frayed bamboo hat, casting a shadow over his weathered face, revealing only a long, graying beard that sways gently in the breeze. Dressed in a simple, dark gray linen jacket, the elderly man sits poised in the center of a rustic wooden boat, its hull a deep brown from years of waterlogging. Steady in his hands, he grips a slender bamboo fishing rod, his line plummeting into the calm, mirror-like surface of the lake, creating only barely perceptible ripples where it enters. The soft, diffuse morning light evenly bathes the water, reflecting the hazy outlines of the sky and distant mountains. The scene is shrouded in a tranquil slate-gray and ink-wash hue. As the camera begins to steadily and slowly pull back, the picture gradually widens, and the figures of the boat and the old man slowly shrink in his world. Finally, he turns into a lonely and harmonious ink dot on the vast lake, completely merging with the rolling indigo mountains shrouded in mist in the background, creating a sense of harmony between man and nature, tranquility and eternity full of oriental philosophical poetry.", + "seed": 16726, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_8/index_163_seed_16726_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.02927737107966095, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02927737107966095, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02927737107966095, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a wide, frayed bamboo hat and a dark gray linen jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in a rustic wooden boat with a deep brown hull on a calm lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with the line entering the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and steadily pull back to widen the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall visual style characterized by a slate-gray and ink-wash hue with hazy mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11391200870275497 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2389121055603027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11391200870275497, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11391200870275497, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1299978494644165, + 0.06181694567203522, + 0.13532675802707672, + 0.04431875795125961, + 0.09036879241466522, + 0.11300134658813477, + 0.06959114223718643, + 0.08517329394817352, + 0.1633823812007904, + 0.10702274739742279 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11391200870275497 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a wide, frayed bamboo hat and a dark gray linen jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in a rustic wooden boat with a deep brown hull on a calm lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with the line entering the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and steadily pull back to widen the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall visual style characterized by a slate-gray and ink-wash hue with hazy mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002824010793119669 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877823829650879 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002824010793119669, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002824010793119669, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2096491903066635, + 0.1169731467962265, + 0.1943504810333252, + 0.04931893199682236, + 0.049429696053266525, + 0.07830178737640381, + 0.07857098430395126, + 0.041628655046224594, + 0.05670328810811043, + 0.12507376074790955 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002824010793119669 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a wide, frayed bamboo hat and a dark gray linen jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in a rustic wooden boat with a deep brown hull on a calm lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with the line entering the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and steadily pull back to widen the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall visual style characterized by a slate-gray and ink-wash hue with hazy mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012545006349682808 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387545108795166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012545006349682808, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012545006349682808, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05768550932407379, + 0.08359286934137344, + 0.054357655346393585, + 0.08918271213769913, + 0.17973077297210693, + 0.22426313161849976, + 0.11496896296739578, + 0.09572222828865051, + 0.04879534989595413, + 0.05170085281133652 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012545006349682808 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a wide, frayed bamboo hat and a dark gray linen jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in a rustic wooden boat with a deep brown hull on a calm lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with the line entering the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and steadily pull back to widen the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall visual style characterized by a slate-gray and ink-wash hue with hazy mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016065435484051704 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14106559753418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016065435484051704, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016065435484051704, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06003127247095108, + 0.04263746738433838, + 0.2589678168296814, + 0.04416949301958084, + 0.0838591456413269, + 0.09493941813707352, + 0.08578624576330185, + 0.08640193939208984, + 0.0897144302725792, + 0.15349282324314117 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016065435484051704 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a wide, frayed bamboo hat and a dark gray linen jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in a rustic wooden boat with a deep brown hull on a calm lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with the line entering the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and steadily pull back to widen the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall visual style characterized by a slate-gray and ink-wash hue with hazy mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010403940686956048 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876040458679199 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010403940686956048, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010403940686956048, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13938552141189575, + 0.039434097707271576, + 0.4915611147880554, + 0.038278691470623016, + 0.05390924960374832, + 0.04489078000187874, + 0.06952051818370819, + 0.05420979857444763, + 0.03525494411587715, + 0.03355526551604271 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010403940686956048 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The shot begins in a medium shot, slightly overlooking, with a steady focus on an elderly angler. He wears a wide, frayed bamboo hat, casting a shadow over his weathered face, revealing only a long, graying beard that sways gently in the breeze. Dressed in a simple, dark gray linen jacket, the elderly man sits poised in the center of a rustic wooden boat, its hull a deep brown from years of waterlogging. Steady in his hands, he grips a slender bamboo fishing rod, his line plummeting into the calm, mirror-like surface of the lake, creating only barely perceptible ripples where it enters. The soft, diffuse morning light evenly bathes the water, reflecting the hazy outlines of the sky and distant mountains. The scene is shrouded in a tranquil slate-gray and ink-wash hue. As the camera begins to steadily and slowly pull back, the picture gradually widens, and the figures of the boat and the old man slowly shrink in his world. Finally, he turns into a lonely and harmonious ink dot on the vast lake, completely merging with the rolling indigo mountains shrouded in mist in the background, creating a sense of harmony between man and nature, tranquility and eternity full of oriental philosophical poetry.", + "seed": 16727, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_8/index_163_seed_16727_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.020786813693121076, + "vlm_logprob": -0.020786813693121076, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.020786813693121076, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a wide, frayed bamboo hat and a dark gray linen jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in a rustic wooden boat with a deep brown hull on a calm lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with the line entering the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and steadily pull back to widen the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall visual style characterized by a slate-gray and ink-wash hue with hazy mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01801673136651516 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.143016815185547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01801673136651516, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01801673136651516, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18158696591854095, + 0.03493485972285271, + 0.044963035732507706, + 0.12472259253263474, + 0.17310042679309845, + 0.08337962627410889, + 0.11359135806560516, + 0.1614287942647934, + 0.04381953179836273, + 0.038472797721624374 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01801673136651516 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a wide, frayed bamboo hat and a dark gray linen jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in a rustic wooden boat with a deep brown hull on a calm lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with the line entering the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and steadily pull back to widen the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall visual style characterized by a slate-gray and ink-wash hue with hazy mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004645270295441151 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379645347595215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004645270295441151, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004645270295441151, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1952660232782364, + 0.2072400450706482, + 0.24458664655685425, + 0.09564483165740967, + 0.10151024907827377, + 0.020940054208040237, + 0.0282150711864233, + 0.03687278926372528, + 0.047832172363996506, + 0.02189205028116703 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004645270295441151 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a wide, frayed bamboo hat and a dark gray linen jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in a rustic wooden boat with a deep brown hull on a calm lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with the line entering the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and steadily pull back to widen the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall visual style characterized by a slate-gray and ink-wash hue with hazy mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819608360528946 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018196105957031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819608360528946, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819608360528946, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19551634788513184, + 0.10351414233446121, + 0.1293695718050003, + 0.0855911374092102, + 0.0641387403011322, + 0.04221661761403084, + 0.10553127527236938, + 0.11243244260549545, + 0.03861492872238159, + 0.12307483702898026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819608360528946 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a wide, frayed bamboo hat and a dark gray linen jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in a rustic wooden boat with a deep brown hull on a calm lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with the line entering the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and steadily pull back to widen the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall visual style characterized by a slate-gray and ink-wash hue with hazy mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062034279108047485 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120343685150146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062034279108047485, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062034279108047485, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22408100962638855, + 0.05940290912985802, + 0.06219720095396042, + 0.10883134603500366, + 0.04177745059132576, + 0.06125824153423309, + 0.05201471224427223, + 0.07773425430059433, + 0.1356423795223236, + 0.1770605891942978 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062034279108047485 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a wide, frayed bamboo hat and a dark gray linen jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in a rustic wooden boat with a deep brown hull on a calm lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with the line entering the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and steadily pull back to widen the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall visual style characterized by a slate-gray and ink-wash hue with hazy mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010417040903121233 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876041889190674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010417040903121233, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010417040903121233, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29420754313468933, + 0.06475799530744553, + 0.027383841574192047, + 0.06252880394458771, + 0.06716838479042053, + 0.08703619241714478, + 0.0956706628203392, + 0.1353583186864853, + 0.08840375393629074, + 0.07748442888259888 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010417040903121233 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The shot begins in a medium shot, slightly overlooking, with a steady focus on an elderly angler. He wears a wide, frayed bamboo hat, casting a shadow over his weathered face, revealing only a long, graying beard that sways gently in the breeze. Dressed in a simple, dark gray linen jacket, the elderly man sits poised in the center of a rustic wooden boat, its hull a deep brown from years of waterlogging. Steady in his hands, he grips a slender bamboo fishing rod, his line plummeting into the calm, mirror-like surface of the lake, creating only barely perceptible ripples where it enters. The soft, diffuse morning light evenly bathes the water, reflecting the hazy outlines of the sky and distant mountains. The scene is shrouded in a tranquil slate-gray and ink-wash hue. As the camera begins to steadily and slowly pull back, the picture gradually widens, and the figures of the boat and the old man slowly shrink in his world. Finally, he turns into a lonely and harmonious ink dot on the vast lake, completely merging with the rolling indigo mountains shrouded in mist in the background, creating a sense of harmony between man and nature, tranquility and eternity full of oriental philosophical poetry.", + "seed": 16728, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_8/index_163_seed_16728_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.020364940050058067, + "vlm_logprob": -0.020364940050058067, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.020364940050058067, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a wide, frayed bamboo hat and a dark gray linen jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in a rustic wooden boat with a deep brown hull on a calm lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with the line entering the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and steadily pull back to widen the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall visual style characterized by a slate-gray and ink-wash hue with hazy mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.021064845845103264 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8960647583007812 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.021064845845103264, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.021064845845103264, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10669144988059998, + 0.16752585768699646, + 0.07744724303483963, + 0.050015490502119064, + 0.07585262507200241, + 0.08931536972522736, + 0.09735880047082901, + 0.057210952043533325, + 0.18183061480522156, + 0.09675157815217972 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.021064845845103264 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a wide, frayed bamboo hat and a dark gray linen jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in a rustic wooden boat with a deep brown hull on a calm lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with the line entering the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and steadily pull back to widen the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall visual style characterized by a slate-gray and ink-wash hue with hazy mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002820087829604745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877820014953613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002820087829604745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002820087829604745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06322100013494492, + 0.3459685146808624, + 0.18052446842193604, + 0.07221002876758575, + 0.045233651995658875, + 0.017384245991706848, + 0.022962015122175217, + 0.0322781465947628, + 0.12218991667032242, + 0.09802805632352829 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002820087829604745 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a wide, frayed bamboo hat and a dark gray linen jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in a rustic wooden boat with a deep brown hull on a calm lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with the line entering the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and steadily pull back to widen the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall visual style characterized by a slate-gray and ink-wash hue with hazy mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307573288679123 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680757999420166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307573288679123, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307573288679123, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1441037356853485, + 0.16481810808181763, + 0.11178866028785706, + 0.06385607272386551, + 0.0807129442691803, + 0.05212695151567459, + 0.03407344967126846, + 0.052257753908634186, + 0.12207190692424774, + 0.1741904467344284 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307573288679123 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a wide, frayed bamboo hat and a dark gray linen jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in a rustic wooden boat with a deep brown hull on a calm lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with the line entering the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and steadily pull back to widen the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall visual style characterized by a slate-gray and ink-wash hue with hazy mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368634358048439 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408686399459839 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368634358048439, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368634358048439, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16627222299575806, + 0.21869176626205444, + 0.0473393015563488, + 0.06977833807468414, + 0.1056157797574997, + 0.024297768250107765, + 0.07734180986881256, + 0.0360414944589138, + 0.19926121830940247, + 0.055360350757837296 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368634358048439 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a wide, frayed bamboo hat and a dark gray linen jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in a rustic wooden boat with a deep brown hull on a calm lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with the line entering the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and steadily pull back to widen the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall visual style characterized by a slate-gray and ink-wash hue with hazy mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001177690108306706 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751177787780762 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001177690108306706, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001177690108306706, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14313232898712158, + 0.12644502520561218, + 0.0766620859503746, + 0.06939535588026047, + 0.1133415475487709, + 0.036614369601011276, + 0.04092061519622803, + 0.035642366856336594, + 0.30245429277420044, + 0.055392052978277206 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001177690108306706 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The shot begins in a medium shot, slightly overlooking, with a steady focus on an elderly angler. He wears a wide, frayed bamboo hat, casting a shadow over his weathered face, revealing only a long, graying beard that sways gently in the breeze. Dressed in a simple, dark gray linen jacket, the elderly man sits poised in the center of a rustic wooden boat, its hull a deep brown from years of waterlogging. Steady in his hands, he grips a slender bamboo fishing rod, his line plummeting into the calm, mirror-like surface of the lake, creating only barely perceptible ripples where it enters. The soft, diffuse morning light evenly bathes the water, reflecting the hazy outlines of the sky and distant mountains. The scene is shrouded in a tranquil slate-gray and ink-wash hue. As the camera begins to steadily and slowly pull back, the picture gradually widens, and the figures of the boat and the old man slowly shrink in his world. Finally, he turns into a lonely and harmonious ink dot on the vast lake, completely merging with the rolling indigo mountains shrouded in mist in the background, creating a sense of harmony between man and nature, tranquility and eternity full of oriental philosophical poetry.", + "seed": 16729, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_8/index_163_seed_16729_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.01928986010607332, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01928986010607332, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01928986010607332, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a wide, frayed bamboo hat and a dark gray linen jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in a rustic wooden boat with a deep brown hull on a calm lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with the line entering the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and steadily pull back to widen the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall visual style characterized by a slate-gray and ink-wash hue with hazy mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06306573748588562 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.813065767288208 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06306573748588562, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06306573748588562, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19556523859500885, + 0.08332230150699615, + 0.1017635390162468, + 0.032597657293081284, + 0.060841307044029236, + 0.11858873069286346, + 0.08484125137329102, + 0.21112066507339478, + 0.04917873814702034, + 0.062180522829294205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06306573748588562 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a wide, frayed bamboo hat and a dark gray linen jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in a rustic wooden boat with a deep brown hull on a calm lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with the line entering the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and steadily pull back to widen the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall visual style characterized by a slate-gray and ink-wash hue with hazy mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0041035739704966545 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504103660583496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0041035739704966545, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0041035739704966545, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03545965999364853, + 0.04793443903326988, + 0.05007859319448471, + 0.025119764730334282, + 0.01800750382244587, + 0.10601460933685303, + 0.03589008003473282, + 0.1885477602481842, + 0.08176697790622711, + 0.41118061542510986 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0041035739704966545 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a wide, frayed bamboo hat and a dark gray linen jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in a rustic wooden boat with a deep brown hull on a calm lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with the line entering the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and steadily pull back to widen the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall visual style characterized by a slate-gray and ink-wash hue with hazy mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023304611444473267 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733047008514404 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023304611444473267, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023304611444473267, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10085592418909073, + 0.039518676698207855, + 0.3636813461780548, + 0.035817135125398636, + 0.044917430728673935, + 0.04758915677666664, + 0.08892260491847992, + 0.07219207286834717, + 0.058884333819150925, + 0.1476212441921234 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023304611444473267 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a wide, frayed bamboo hat and a dark gray linen jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in a rustic wooden boat with a deep brown hull on a calm lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with the line entering the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and steadily pull back to widen the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall visual style characterized by a slate-gray and ink-wash hue with hazy mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004639100283384323 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379639148712158 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004639100283384323, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004639100283384323, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.044789668172597885, + 0.024851229041814804, + 0.041855208575725555, + 0.033101752400398254, + 0.02150619402527809, + 0.2612490952014923, + 0.04557469114661217, + 0.18934695422649384, + 0.24110375344753265, + 0.09662146866321564 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004639100283384323 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man wearing a wide, frayed bamboo hat and a dark gray linen jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting in a rustic wooden boat with a deep brown hull on a calm lake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with the line entering the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start in a medium shot and steadily pull back to widen the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall visual style characterized by a slate-gray and ink-wash hue with hazy mountains in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013362773461267352 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626336097717285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013362773461267352, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013362773461267352, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09459199756383896, + 0.06966634094715118, + 0.10854456573724747, + 0.032808322459459305, + 0.09129117429256439, + 0.11051998287439346, + 0.044170212000608444, + 0.12501993775367737, + 0.0998682826757431, + 0.22351914644241333 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013362773461267352 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_9/index_tensor([8636, 8636])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_9/index_tensor([8636, 8636])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ded6260a902d7a98f641d63147e05a2af6811690 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_9/index_tensor([8636, 8636])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In the style of sports photography, a low-angle, static, full-body shot captures a lone female figure on a deserted, cracked asphalt village road as a sudden thunderstorm erupts with dramatic force. The camera's focus is sharply pulled to the immediate foreground, capturing heavy, crystal-like raindrops at hyperspeed as they explode onto the dark, damp ground. Each droplet forms a perfect, instantaneous crown-like splash, its surface reflecting the wounded, turbulent purple-gray storm clouds above. The runner's body is a tense sculpture of athletic power, her right leg extended forward, her calf muscles defined, her arms flexed in a powerful, driving motion. Her dark hair is plastered to her scalp and face by the floodwaters, and her simple, brightly colored athletic tank top and black running shorts, soaking wet, cling to her body. Her expression is one of fierce, unwavering determination, her gaze fixed forward, completely unfazed by the storm. The background shows the blurred outlines of simple village houses against an oppressively dark sky, while for a split second, off-camera lightning illuminates the scene, casting stark silver highlights on the runners’ skin and the millions of falling water droplets, creating a powerful, high-contrast atmosphere of raw energy and fierce human determination.", + "seed": 21264, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_9/index_8636_seed_21264_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03237831275910139, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03237831275910139, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03237831275910139, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, full-body view of a lone female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a deserted, cracked asphalt village road with blurred village houses in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the runner wearing a brightly colored athletic tank top and black running shorts that are soaking wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show heavy rain exploding into crown-like splashes on the ground with lightning illuminating the runner's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focus sharply pulled to the immediate foreground to capture the raindrops in hyperspeed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026478784158825874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7764787673950195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026478784158825874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026478784158825874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33277449011802673, + 0.0865110456943512, + 0.07645872980356216, + 0.06530465185642242, + 0.058469537645578384, + 0.19760748744010925, + 0.053100235760211945, + 0.03833860903978348, + 0.03091537021100521, + 0.06051988527178764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026478784158825874 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, full-body view of a lone female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a deserted, cracked asphalt village road with blurred village houses in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the runner wearing a brightly colored athletic tank top and black running shorts that are soaking wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show heavy rain exploding into crown-like splashes on the ground with lightning illuminating the runner's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focus sharply pulled to the immediate foreground to capture the raindrops in hyperspeed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866442829370499 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486643314361572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866442829370499, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866442829370499, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3295295536518097, + 0.09631950408220291, + 0.08046593517065048, + 0.04450707882642746, + 0.04759185016155243, + 0.24659539759159088, + 0.033298641443252563, + 0.05572797730565071, + 0.02924315258860588, + 0.03672090172767639 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866442829370499 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, full-body view of a lone female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a deserted, cracked asphalt village road with blurred village houses in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the runner wearing a brightly colored athletic tank top and black running shorts that are soaking wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show heavy rain exploding into crown-like splashes on the ground with lightning illuminating the runner's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focus sharply pulled to the immediate foreground to capture the raindrops in hyperspeed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016076814383268356 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141077041625977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016076814383268356, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016076814383268356, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16500455141067505, + 0.1678682118654251, + 0.05753191187977791, + 0.05647654086351395, + 0.057572271674871445, + 0.2551962435245514, + 0.057542502880096436, + 0.05731966719031334, + 0.024590548127889633, + 0.10089748352766037 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016076814383268356 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, full-body view of a lone female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a deserted, cracked asphalt village road with blurred village houses in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the runner wearing a brightly colored athletic tank top and black running shorts that are soaking wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show heavy rain exploding into crown-like splashes on the ground with lightning illuminating the runner's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focus sharply pulled to the immediate foreground to capture the raindrops in hyperspeed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008635913021862507 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758635997772217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008635913021862507, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008635913021862507, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2514369487762451, + 0.12135559320449829, + 0.10135293006896973, + 0.11633431911468506, + 0.08288935571908951, + 0.1417185515165329, + 0.04651159793138504, + 0.029114942997694016, + 0.04369610920548439, + 0.06558968126773834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008635913021862507 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, full-body view of a lone female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a deserted, cracked asphalt village road with blurred village houses in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the runner wearing a brightly colored athletic tank top and black running shorts that are soaking wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show heavy rain exploding into crown-like splashes on the ground with lightning illuminating the runner's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focus sharply pulled to the immediate foreground to capture the raindrops in hyperspeed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06203562393784523 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.81203556060791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06203562393784523, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06203562393784523, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23340938985347748, + 0.09426247328519821, + 0.09620876610279083, + 0.052317965775728226, + 0.07372921705245972, + 0.2205095738172531, + 0.06543197482824326, + 0.02609539031982422, + 0.057565148919820786, + 0.08047013729810715 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06203562393784523 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the style of sports photography, a low-angle, static, full-body shot captures a lone female figure on a deserted, cracked asphalt village road as a sudden thunderstorm erupts with dramatic force. The camera's focus is sharply pulled to the immediate foreground, capturing heavy, crystal-like raindrops at hyperspeed as they explode onto the dark, damp ground. Each droplet forms a perfect, instantaneous crown-like splash, its surface reflecting the wounded, turbulent purple-gray storm clouds above. The runner's body is a tense sculpture of athletic power, her right leg extended forward, her calf muscles defined, her arms flexed in a powerful, driving motion. Her dark hair is plastered to her scalp and face by the floodwaters, and her simple, brightly colored athletic tank top and black running shorts, soaking wet, cling to her body. Her expression is one of fierce, unwavering determination, her gaze fixed forward, completely unfazed by the storm. The background shows the blurred outlines of simple village houses against an oppressively dark sky, while for a split second, off-camera lightning illuminates the scene, casting stark silver highlights on the runners’ skin and the millions of falling water droplets, creating a powerful, high-contrast atmosphere of raw energy and fierce human determination.", + "seed": 21265, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_9/index_8636_seed_21265_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.052331849746406076, + "vlm_logprob": -0.052331849746406076, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.052331849746406076, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, full-body view of a lone female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a deserted, cracked asphalt village road with blurred village houses in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the runner wearing a brightly colored athletic tank top and black running shorts that are soaking wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show heavy rain exploding into crown-like splashes on the ground with lightning illuminating the runner's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focus sharply pulled to the immediate foreground to capture the raindrops in hyperspeed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.025221971794962883 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.900222063064575 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.025221971794962883, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.025221971794962883, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3653601109981537, + 0.18878284096717834, + 0.10393013805150986, + 0.04186053201556206, + 0.04629523307085037, + 0.043526653200387955, + 0.062214355915784836, + 0.05651426687836647, + 0.03540477156639099, + 0.0561111718416214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.025221971794962883 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, full-body view of a lone female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a deserted, cracked asphalt village road with blurred village houses in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the runner wearing a brightly colored athletic tank top and black running shorts that are soaking wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show heavy rain exploding into crown-like splashes on the ground with lightning illuminating the runner's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focus sharply pulled to the immediate foreground to capture the raindrops in hyperspeed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371204808354378 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408712148666382 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371204808354378, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371204808354378, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3563009798526764, + 0.19829876720905304, + 0.1220470443367958, + 0.05040125176310539, + 0.04830211028456688, + 0.05041682720184326, + 0.05365241691470146, + 0.051088862121105194, + 0.022570177912712097, + 0.04692157730460167 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371204808354378 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, full-body view of a lone female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a deserted, cracked asphalt village road with blurred village houses in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the runner wearing a brightly colored athletic tank top and black running shorts that are soaking wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show heavy rain exploding into crown-like splashes on the ground with lightning illuminating the runner's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focus sharply pulled to the immediate foreground to capture the raindrops in hyperspeed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02981463633477688 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298147201538086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02981463633477688, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02981463633477688, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17953608930110931, + 0.23828363418579102, + 0.08692510426044464, + 0.041260167956352234, + 0.06714067608118057, + 0.1038689836859703, + 0.08927007019519806, + 0.08514846116304398, + 0.055391743779182434, + 0.05317496508359909 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02981463633477688 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, full-body view of a lone female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a deserted, cracked asphalt village road with blurred village houses in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the runner wearing a brightly colored athletic tank top and black running shorts that are soaking wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show heavy rain exploding into crown-like splashes on the ground with lightning illuminating the runner's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focus sharply pulled to the immediate foreground to capture the raindrops in hyperspeed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012539944611489773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387539863586426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012539944611489773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012539944611489773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29582446813583374, + 0.14299030601978302, + 0.12460886687040329, + 0.05722658708691597, + 0.040214382112026215, + 0.03032042644917965, + 0.08186239749193192, + 0.09330879896879196, + 0.06922533363103867, + 0.06441842019557953 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012539944611489773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, full-body view of a lone female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a deserted, cracked asphalt village road with blurred village houses in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the runner wearing a brightly colored athletic tank top and black running shorts that are soaking wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show heavy rain exploding into crown-like splashes on the ground with lightning illuminating the runner's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focus sharply pulled to the immediate foreground to capture the raindrops in hyperspeed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16037064790725708 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103705883026123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16037064790725708, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16037064790725708, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21599921584129333, + 0.13938294351100922, + 0.10222399234771729, + 0.05308828875422478, + 0.0792490765452385, + 0.040645476430654526, + 0.09077168256044388, + 0.08820044249296188, + 0.15001274645328522, + 0.04042613506317139 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16037064790725708 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the style of sports photography, a low-angle, static, full-body shot captures a lone female figure on a deserted, cracked asphalt village road as a sudden thunderstorm erupts with dramatic force. The camera's focus is sharply pulled to the immediate foreground, capturing heavy, crystal-like raindrops at hyperspeed as they explode onto the dark, damp ground. Each droplet forms a perfect, instantaneous crown-like splash, its surface reflecting the wounded, turbulent purple-gray storm clouds above. The runner's body is a tense sculpture of athletic power, her right leg extended forward, her calf muscles defined, her arms flexed in a powerful, driving motion. Her dark hair is plastered to her scalp and face by the floodwaters, and her simple, brightly colored athletic tank top and black running shorts, soaking wet, cling to her body. Her expression is one of fierce, unwavering determination, her gaze fixed forward, completely unfazed by the storm. The background shows the blurred outlines of simple village houses against an oppressively dark sky, while for a split second, off-camera lightning illuminates the scene, casting stark silver highlights on the runners’ skin and the millions of falling water droplets, creating a powerful, high-contrast atmosphere of raw energy and fierce human determination.", + "seed": 21266, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_9/index_8636_seed_21266_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.08325674459338188, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08325674459338188, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08325674459338188, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, full-body view of a lone female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a deserted, cracked asphalt village road with blurred village houses in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the runner wearing a brightly colored athletic tank top and black running shorts that are soaking wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show heavy rain exploding into crown-like splashes on the ground with lightning illuminating the runner's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focus sharply pulled to the immediate foreground to capture the raindrops in hyperspeed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04329242929816246 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.29329252243042 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04329242929816246, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04329242929816246, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19427365064620972, + 0.10996157675981522, + 0.09227859228849411, + 0.07667972147464752, + 0.10141056776046753, + 0.13853515684604645, + 0.10977689176797867, + 0.08126500993967056, + 0.05622943863272667, + 0.03958943858742714 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04329242929816246 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, full-body view of a lone female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a deserted, cracked asphalt village road with blurred village houses in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the runner wearing a brightly colored athletic tank top and black running shorts that are soaking wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show heavy rain exploding into crown-like splashes on the ground with lightning illuminating the runner's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focus sharply pulled to the immediate foreground to capture the raindrops in hyperspeed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020591765642166138 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955917358398438 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020591765642166138, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020591765642166138, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21919295191764832, + 0.08308923989534378, + 0.12274517118930817, + 0.20253130793571472, + 0.07120604813098907, + 0.0891234427690506, + 0.07775277644395828, + 0.050616681575775146, + 0.06274735182523727, + 0.0209951251745224 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020591765642166138 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, full-body view of a lone female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a deserted, cracked asphalt village road with blurred village houses in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the runner wearing a brightly colored athletic tank top and black running shorts that are soaking wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show heavy rain exploding into crown-like splashes on the ground with lightning illuminating the runner's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focus sharply pulled to the immediate foreground to capture the raindrops in hyperspeed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05497697740793228 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299769401550293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05497697740793228, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05497697740793228, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.143329918384552, + 0.19497312605381012, + 0.05603789910674095, + 0.12146540731191635, + 0.09899844229221344, + 0.06446751207113266, + 0.15823981165885925, + 0.09130868315696716, + 0.025586865842342377, + 0.04559234902262688 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05497697740793228 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, full-body view of a lone female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a deserted, cracked asphalt village road with blurred village houses in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the runner wearing a brightly colored athletic tank top and black running shorts that are soaking wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show heavy rain exploding into crown-like splashes on the ground with lightning illuminating the runner's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focus sharply pulled to the immediate foreground to capture the raindrops in hyperspeed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0160687193274498 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141068935394287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0160687193274498, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0160687193274498, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22411443293094635, + 0.067880779504776, + 0.26697832345962524, + 0.0589364618062973, + 0.11989721655845642, + 0.13507409393787384, + 0.030644556507468224, + 0.03109261766076088, + 0.03953629732131958, + 0.025845184922218323 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0160687193274498 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, full-body view of a lone female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a deserted, cracked asphalt village road with blurred village houses in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the runner wearing a brightly colored athletic tank top and black running shorts that are soaking wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show heavy rain exploding into crown-like splashes on the ground with lightning illuminating the runner's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focus sharply pulled to the immediate foreground to capture the raindrops in hyperspeed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28135383129119873 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063538312911987 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28135383129119873, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28135383129119873, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1233334094285965, + 0.0884440615773201, + 0.0809999629855156, + 0.12876856327056885, + 0.14448684453964233, + 0.11652082204818726, + 0.14262202382087708, + 0.04649067297577858, + 0.0944516733288765, + 0.03388193994760513 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28135383129119873 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the style of sports photography, a low-angle, static, full-body shot captures a lone female figure on a deserted, cracked asphalt village road as a sudden thunderstorm erupts with dramatic force. The camera's focus is sharply pulled to the immediate foreground, capturing heavy, crystal-like raindrops at hyperspeed as they explode onto the dark, damp ground. Each droplet forms a perfect, instantaneous crown-like splash, its surface reflecting the wounded, turbulent purple-gray storm clouds above. The runner's body is a tense sculpture of athletic power, her right leg extended forward, her calf muscles defined, her arms flexed in a powerful, driving motion. Her dark hair is plastered to her scalp and face by the floodwaters, and her simple, brightly colored athletic tank top and black running shorts, soaking wet, cling to her body. Her expression is one of fierce, unwavering determination, her gaze fixed forward, completely unfazed by the storm. The background shows the blurred outlines of simple village houses against an oppressively dark sky, while for a split second, off-camera lightning illuminates the scene, casting stark silver highlights on the runners’ skin and the millions of falling water droplets, creating a powerful, high-contrast atmosphere of raw energy and fierce human determination.", + "seed": 21267, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000091/group_9/index_8636_seed_21267_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.11791986264288426, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11791986264288426, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11791986264288426, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, full-body view of a lone female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a deserted, cracked asphalt village road with blurred village houses in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the runner wearing a brightly colored athletic tank top and black running shorts that are soaking wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show heavy rain exploding into crown-like splashes on the ground with lightning illuminating the runner's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focus sharply pulled to the immediate foreground to capture the raindrops in hyperspeed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.032292913645505905 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6572928428649902 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.032292913645505905, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.032292913645505905, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37941402196884155, + 0.116402268409729, + 0.05284892022609711, + 0.11223220825195312, + 0.0552767775952816, + 0.053084563463926315, + 0.09333417564630508, + 0.04612278938293457, + 0.04331817105412483, + 0.047966182231903076 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.032292913645505905 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, full-body view of a lone female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a deserted, cracked asphalt village road with blurred village houses in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the runner wearing a brightly colored athletic tank top and black running shorts that are soaking wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show heavy rain exploding into crown-like splashes on the ground with lightning illuminating the runner's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focus sharply pulled to the immediate foreground to capture the raindrops in hyperspeed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307721555233002 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168077230453491 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307721555233002, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307721555233002, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2964088022708893, + 0.11259065568447113, + 0.08087765425443649, + 0.10872852057218552, + 0.07754885405302048, + 0.022288158535957336, + 0.0930112674832344, + 0.04084921255707741, + 0.10786929726600647, + 0.059827618300914764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307721555233002 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, full-body view of a lone female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a deserted, cracked asphalt village road with blurred village houses in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the runner wearing a brightly colored athletic tank top and black running shorts that are soaking wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show heavy rain exploding into crown-like splashes on the ground with lightning illuminating the runner's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focus sharply pulled to the immediate foreground to capture the raindrops in hyperspeed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11295502632856369 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237955093383789 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11295502632856369, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11295502632856369, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3194306492805481, + 0.1065734475851059, + 0.07033513486385345, + 0.05564098060131073, + 0.05677739158272743, + 0.038950417190790176, + 0.0866151675581932, + 0.09456058591604233, + 0.04562311992049217, + 0.1254930943250656 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11295502632856369 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, full-body view of a lone female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a deserted, cracked asphalt village road with blurred village houses in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the runner wearing a brightly colored athletic tank top and black running shorts that are soaking wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show heavy rain exploding into crown-like splashes on the ground with lightning illuminating the runner's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focus sharply pulled to the immediate foreground to capture the raindrops in hyperspeed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01419694535434246 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264196872711182 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01419694535434246, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01419694535434246, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21259623765945435, + 0.09612885117530823, + 0.0682029128074646, + 0.08798397332429886, + 0.16107718646526337, + 0.04695805534720421, + 0.10482090711593628, + 0.05424932762980461, + 0.08434993028640747, + 0.08363258093595505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01419694535434246 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static, full-body view of a lone female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a deserted, cracked asphalt village road with blurred village houses in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the runner wearing a brightly colored athletic tank top and black running shorts that are soaking wet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show heavy rain exploding into crown-like splashes on the ground with lightning illuminating the runner's skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focus sharply pulled to the immediate foreground to capture the raindrops in hyperspeed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870772123336792 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370772123336792 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3870772123336792, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3870772123336792, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31742343306541443, + 0.14161816239356995, + 0.05628287047147751, + 0.05559952184557915, + 0.06943278759717941, + 0.044607002288103104, + 0.11851366609334946, + 0.05698028951883316, + 0.07497256249189377, + 0.06456973403692245 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3870772123336792 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_0/index_tensor([8016, 8016])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_0/index_tensor([8016, 8016])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4546fe88dc0abeda5ae1b2c38a1c3cf4e4f1b13f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_0/index_tensor([8016, 8016])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "first-person perspective shot from inside a rocking carriage, moving forward at eye level, perfectly simulates the tangible sensation of a bumpy ride. The camera gently sways and pitches in time with the carriage's rhythm. Peering out through the rustic wooden window frames, one sees the narrow streets of an ancient village, paved entirely with weathered cobblestones of varying sizes. The streets are lined with a patchwork of wooden and stone houses, their walls covered in deep green moss. Ancient tiled roofs are stained by age, and occasionally wisps of smoke can be seen rising from stone chimneys. The warm, golden afternoon sun slants across the scene, casting a soft glow over the scene, lengthening the shadows of the buildings and making even tiny particles of dust in the air visible. The entire picture presents a remarkable retro film texture, with warm and saturated colors, obvious graininess and occasional slight lens flare caused by direct sunlight. As the carriage slowly moves forward, the scenery in front of you rhythmically rises and falls, creating a tranquil, nostalgic and immersive experience, as if a dusty memory is slowly being awakened.", + "seed": 1341, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_0/index_8016_seed_1341_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.11740563679486513, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11740563679486513, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11740563679486513, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a first-person perspective inside a rocking carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sway and pitch rhythmically to simulate a bumpy ride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the streets paved with weathered cobblestones of varying sizes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the house walls covered in deep green moss with ancient tiled roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with warm, saturated colors, obvious graininess, and lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04981082305312157 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0498108863830566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04981082305312157, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04981082305312157, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10911425948143005, + 0.07028540968894958, + 0.09129860252141953, + 0.07350174337625504, + 0.25132685899734497, + 0.11754250526428223, + 0.09756645560264587, + 0.08125685155391693, + 0.043042127043008804, + 0.06506521999835968 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04981082305312157 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a first-person perspective inside a rocking carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sway and pitch rhythmically to simulate a bumpy ride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the streets paved with weathered cobblestones of varying sizes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the house walls covered in deep green moss with ancient tiled roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with warm, saturated colors, obvious graininess, and lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007647995837032795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88264799118042 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007647995837032795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007647995837032795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10760295391082764, + 0.06948933750391006, + 0.1615421622991562, + 0.04703904688358307, + 0.08916640281677246, + 0.1940513551235199, + 0.09856857359409332, + 0.08004999160766602, + 0.08572526276111603, + 0.06676485389471054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007647995837032795 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a first-person perspective inside a rocking carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sway and pitch rhythmically to simulate a bumpy ride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the streets paved with weathered cobblestones of varying sizes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the house walls covered in deep green moss with ancient tiled roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with warm, saturated colors, obvious graininess, and lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12704889476299286 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127048969268799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12704889476299286, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12704889476299286, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12893088161945343, + 0.06332620233297348, + 0.15064117312431335, + 0.07935568690299988, + 0.0864366888999939, + 0.1016613319516182, + 0.21520723402500153, + 0.05820820853114128, + 0.049376118928194046, + 0.06685639917850494 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12704889476299286 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a first-person perspective inside a rocking carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sway and pitch rhythmically to simulate a bumpy ride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the streets paved with weathered cobblestones of varying sizes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the house walls covered in deep green moss with ancient tiled roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with warm, saturated colors, obvious graininess, and lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134925663471222 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134925365447998 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134925663471222, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134925663471222, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0945393368601799, + 0.0448685921728611, + 0.1527162790298462, + 0.05078119412064552, + 0.05919960141181946, + 0.29252859950065613, + 0.06889431923627853, + 0.029553396627306938, + 0.0205789003521204, + 0.1863398253917694 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134925663471222 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a first-person perspective inside a rocking carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sway and pitch rhythmically to simulate a bumpy ride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the streets paved with weathered cobblestones of varying sizes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the house walls covered in deep green moss with ancient tiled roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with warm, saturated colors, obvious graininess, and lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08902790397405624 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640278816223145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08902790397405624, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08902790397405624, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23149439692497253, + 0.06896568834781647, + 0.040847208350896835, + 0.05103417858481407, + 0.06331092119216919, + 0.07797528058290482, + 0.10674358159303665, + 0.07665267586708069, + 0.025906071066856384, + 0.25707000494003296 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08902790397405624 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "first-person perspective shot from inside a rocking carriage, moving forward at eye level, perfectly simulates the tangible sensation of a bumpy ride. The camera gently sways and pitches in time with the carriage's rhythm. Peering out through the rustic wooden window frames, one sees the narrow streets of an ancient village, paved entirely with weathered cobblestones of varying sizes. The streets are lined with a patchwork of wooden and stone houses, their walls covered in deep green moss. Ancient tiled roofs are stained by age, and occasionally wisps of smoke can be seen rising from stone chimneys. The warm, golden afternoon sun slants across the scene, casting a soft glow over the scene, lengthening the shadows of the buildings and making even tiny particles of dust in the air visible. The entire picture presents a remarkable retro film texture, with warm and saturated colors, obvious graininess and occasional slight lens flare caused by direct sunlight. As the carriage slowly moves forward, the scenery in front of you rhythmically rises and falls, creating a tranquil, nostalgic and immersive experience, as if a dusty memory is slowly being awakened.", + "seed": 1342, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_0/index_8016_seed_1342_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06829202715307474, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06829202715307474, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06829202715307474, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a first-person perspective inside a rocking carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sway and pitch rhythmically to simulate a bumpy ride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the streets paved with weathered cobblestones of varying sizes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the house walls covered in deep green moss with ancient tiled roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with warm, saturated colors, obvious graininess, and lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.044971659779548645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1699717044830322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.044971659779548645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.044971659779548645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10465662181377411, + 0.10867839306592941, + 0.05261971801519394, + 0.08274334669113159, + 0.3504679203033447, + 0.05482751876115799, + 0.04206693917512894, + 0.03520333394408226, + 0.0763484314084053, + 0.0923878476023674 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.044971659779548645 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a first-person perspective inside a rocking carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sway and pitch rhythmically to simulate a bumpy ride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the streets paved with weathered cobblestones of varying sizes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the house walls covered in deep green moss with ancient tiled roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with warm, saturated colors, obvious graininess, and lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032080160453915596 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753208160400391 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032080160453915596, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032080160453915596, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07188935577869415, + 0.09417054057121277, + 0.03262409567832947, + 0.0345333106815815, + 0.159597709774971, + 0.08992165327072144, + 0.09341006726026535, + 0.17237482964992523, + 0.12496316432952881, + 0.1265152543783188 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032080160453915596 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a first-person perspective inside a rocking carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sway and pitch rhythmically to simulate a bumpy ride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the streets paved with weathered cobblestones of varying sizes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the house walls covered in deep green moss with ancient tiled roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with warm, saturated colors, obvious graininess, and lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305575042963028 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168055772781372 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305575042963028, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305575042963028, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20781521499156952, + 0.058251455426216125, + 0.09814717620611191, + 0.07214865833520889, + 0.20288024842739105, + 0.14264783263206482, + 0.028658006340265274, + 0.052124086767435074, + 0.08745772391557693, + 0.049869604408741 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305575042963028 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a first-person perspective inside a rocking carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sway and pitch rhythmically to simulate a bumpy ride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the streets paved with weathered cobblestones of varying sizes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the house walls covered in deep green moss with ancient tiled roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with warm, saturated colors, obvious graininess, and lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015858292579651 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015857696533203 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2015858292579651, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2015858292579651, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06599164009094238, + 0.06003153324127197, + 0.05034807696938515, + 0.023159315809607506, + 0.2560166120529175, + 0.09557584673166275, + 0.04685695841908455, + 0.06396786868572235, + 0.20723426342010498, + 0.13081786036491394 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2015858292579651 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a first-person perspective inside a rocking carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sway and pitch rhythmically to simulate a bumpy ride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the streets paved with weathered cobblestones of varying sizes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the house walls covered in deep green moss with ancient tiled roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with warm, saturated colors, obvious graininess, and lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048638880252838135 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486388206481934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048638880252838135, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048638880252838135, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1876147985458374, + 0.23216012120246887, + 0.022367725148797035, + 0.04463978856801987, + 0.09385190159082413, + 0.07757212966680527, + 0.06718360632658005, + 0.08109438419342041, + 0.15435902774333954, + 0.039156485348939896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048638880252838135 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "first-person perspective shot from inside a rocking carriage, moving forward at eye level, perfectly simulates the tangible sensation of a bumpy ride. The camera gently sways and pitches in time with the carriage's rhythm. Peering out through the rustic wooden window frames, one sees the narrow streets of an ancient village, paved entirely with weathered cobblestones of varying sizes. The streets are lined with a patchwork of wooden and stone houses, their walls covered in deep green moss. Ancient tiled roofs are stained by age, and occasionally wisps of smoke can be seen rising from stone chimneys. The warm, golden afternoon sun slants across the scene, casting a soft glow over the scene, lengthening the shadows of the buildings and making even tiny particles of dust in the air visible. The entire picture presents a remarkable retro film texture, with warm and saturated colors, obvious graininess and occasional slight lens flare caused by direct sunlight. As the carriage slowly moves forward, the scenery in front of you rhythmically rises and falls, creating a tranquil, nostalgic and immersive experience, as if a dusty memory is slowly being awakened.", + "seed": 1343, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_0/index_8016_seed_1343_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11089052939787507, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11089052939787507, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11089052939787507, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a first-person perspective inside a rocking carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sway and pitch rhythmically to simulate a bumpy ride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the streets paved with weathered cobblestones of varying sizes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the house walls covered in deep green moss with ancient tiled roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with warm, saturated colors, obvious graininess, and lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0629352256655693 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8129351139068604 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0629352256655693, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0629352256655693, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11324302852153778, + 0.14069023728370667, + 0.02781040407717228, + 0.09267756342887878, + 0.06886523216962814, + 0.1492665559053421, + 0.14264453947544098, + 0.0927545428276062, + 0.026416894048452377, + 0.14563095569610596 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0629352256655693 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a first-person perspective inside a rocking carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sway and pitch rhythmically to simulate a bumpy ride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the streets paved with weathered cobblestones of varying sizes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the house walls covered in deep green moss with ancient tiled roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with warm, saturated colors, obvious graininess, and lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006749332416802645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006749153137207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006749332416802645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006749332416802645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10699930042028427, + 0.06425417959690094, + 0.0744566097855568, + 0.15895168483257294, + 0.12028692662715912, + 0.14913739264011383, + 0.08379475027322769, + 0.07950273156166077, + 0.08981155604124069, + 0.07280486822128296 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006749332416802645 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a first-person perspective inside a rocking carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sway and pitch rhythmically to simulate a bumpy ride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the streets paved with weathered cobblestones of varying sizes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the house walls covered in deep green moss with ancient tiled roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with warm, saturated colors, obvious graininess, and lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16037794947624207 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103779792785645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16037794947624207, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16037794947624207, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11871220916509628, + 0.10786448419094086, + 0.06222835183143616, + 0.19776643812656403, + 0.07622715085744858, + 0.08876629173755646, + 0.10755635052919388, + 0.07338188588619232, + 0.06155174598097801, + 0.10594508796930313 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16037794947624207 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a first-person perspective inside a rocking carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sway and pitch rhythmically to simulate a bumpy ride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the streets paved with weathered cobblestones of varying sizes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the house walls covered in deep green moss with ancient tiled roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with warm, saturated colors, obvious graininess, and lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813369035720825 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063369035720825 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813369035720825, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813369035720825, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11083576083183289, + 0.0568634532392025, + 0.04345901682972908, + 0.13012903928756714, + 0.2238846719264984, + 0.12094826251268387, + 0.12970682978630066, + 0.07249223440885544, + 0.03610002622008324, + 0.07558076083660126 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813369035720825 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a first-person perspective inside a rocking carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sway and pitch rhythmically to simulate a bumpy ride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the streets paved with weathered cobblestones of varying sizes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the house walls covered in deep green moss with ancient tiled roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with warm, saturated colors, obvious graininess, and lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305323585867882 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168053150177002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305323585867882, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305323585867882, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20556943118572235, + 0.04510143771767616, + 0.04818519204854965, + 0.12071043252944946, + 0.15358389914035797, + 0.10281781852245331, + 0.09572659432888031, + 0.05011908710002899, + 0.09998542815446854, + 0.07820063829421997 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305323585867882 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "first-person perspective shot from inside a rocking carriage, moving forward at eye level, perfectly simulates the tangible sensation of a bumpy ride. The camera gently sways and pitches in time with the carriage's rhythm. Peering out through the rustic wooden window frames, one sees the narrow streets of an ancient village, paved entirely with weathered cobblestones of varying sizes. The streets are lined with a patchwork of wooden and stone houses, their walls covered in deep green moss. Ancient tiled roofs are stained by age, and occasionally wisps of smoke can be seen rising from stone chimneys. The warm, golden afternoon sun slants across the scene, casting a soft glow over the scene, lengthening the shadows of the buildings and making even tiny particles of dust in the air visible. The entire picture presents a remarkable retro film texture, with warm and saturated colors, obvious graininess and occasional slight lens flare caused by direct sunlight. As the carriage slowly moves forward, the scenery in front of you rhythmically rises and falls, creating a tranquil, nostalgic and immersive experience, as if a dusty memory is slowly being awakened.", + "seed": 1344, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_0/index_8016_seed_1344_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.15128709226846696, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15128709226846696, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15128709226846696, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a first-person perspective inside a rocking carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sway and pitch rhythmically to simulate a bumpy ride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the streets paved with weathered cobblestones of varying sizes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the house walls covered in deep green moss with ancient tiled roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with warm, saturated colors, obvious graininess, and lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22878718376159668 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6037871837615967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22878718376159668, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22878718376159668, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21286308765411377, + 0.14601333439350128, + 0.07986028492450714, + 0.057004816830158234, + 0.017222179099917412, + 0.05588748678565025, + 0.2037481814622879, + 0.08482450991868973, + 0.08010078966617584, + 0.06247536092996597 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22878718376159668 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a first-person perspective inside a rocking carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sway and pitch rhythmically to simulate a bumpy ride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the streets paved with weathered cobblestones of varying sizes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the house walls covered in deep green moss with ancient tiled roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with warm, saturated colors, obvious graininess, and lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009815286844968796 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634815216064453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009815286844968796, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009815286844968796, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18313682079315186, + 0.15156112611293793, + 0.08858565986156464, + 0.060581106692552567, + 0.0700412318110466, + 0.0859631896018982, + 0.08225256204605103, + 0.11346729099750519, + 0.0950961709022522, + 0.0693148523569107 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009815286844968796 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a first-person perspective inside a rocking carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sway and pitch rhythmically to simulate a bumpy ride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the streets paved with weathered cobblestones of varying sizes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the house walls covered in deep green moss with ancient tiled roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with warm, saturated colors, obvious graininess, and lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14281585812568665 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178158283233643 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14281585812568665, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14281585812568665, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19445478916168213, + 0.14407920837402344, + 0.0564744807779789, + 0.10692933201789856, + 0.05331758037209511, + 0.06112399697303772, + 0.04761074483394623, + 0.11310110986232758, + 0.15244628489017487, + 0.0704624131321907 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14281585812568665 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a first-person perspective inside a rocking carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sway and pitch rhythmically to simulate a bumpy ride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the streets paved with weathered cobblestones of varying sizes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the house walls covered in deep green moss with ancient tiled roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with warm, saturated colors, obvious graininess, and lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486734926700592 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236734628677368 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486734926700592, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486734926700592, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11474922299385071, + 0.09988094121217728, + 0.09200185537338257, + 0.04712262004613876, + 0.28943896293640137, + 0.10621573030948639, + 0.07533826678991318, + 0.08131663501262665, + 0.04134416952729225, + 0.05259164422750473 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486734926700592 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a first-person perspective inside a rocking carriage?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sway and pitch rhythmically to simulate a bumpy ride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the streets paved with weathered cobblestones of varying sizes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the house walls covered in deep green moss with ancient tiled roofs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a retro film texture with warm, saturated colors, obvious graininess, and lens flare?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026343639940023422 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651343584060669 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026343639940023422, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026343639940023422, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08643174916505814, + 0.1511789709329605, + 0.10590500384569168, + 0.17201553285121918, + 0.08360133320093155, + 0.04964818060398102, + 0.02603786066174507, + 0.042503733187913895, + 0.11911466717720032, + 0.16356295347213745 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026343639940023422 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_1/index_tensor([8491, 8491])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_1/index_tensor([8491, 8491])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..364bab002ae8a8c53e75fd4ca1917d4794e67036 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_1/index_tensor([8491, 8491])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, initially static, focuses on a piece of yellow talisman paper suspended against a dark, blurred background. Its texture is rough, and upon it, intricate, twisting, and powerfully drawn mystical runes in vibrant vermilion red. Suddenly, without warning, a fiery red dot ignites at the center of the paper. Immediately, a brilliant orange-red flame bursts forth, ravenously devouring the paper. The edges of the paper rapidly curl and char under the licking of the flames, while the red runes glow with an extraordinary brilliance in the firelight, as if instantly animated. Then, as if lifted up by an invisible force, the entire burning talisman paper spins and struggles upward. The camera rapidly tilts upward, closely tracking its movement, capturing the dynamic moment as it leaves behind a trail of dancing, flickering black embers. The image is characterized by a stark contrast of light and shadow, with the flames acting as the sole, dynamic source of light, casting a violent, dancing shadow against the pitch-black background, creating a tense atmosphere imbued with a sense of mysterious ritual and the eruption of supernatural power.", + "seed": 15680, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_1/index_8491_seed_15680_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03224412114359439, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03224412114359439, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03224412114359439, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a piece of yellow talisman paper with rough texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are intricate twisting mystical runes drawn in vibrant vermilion red on the paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a fiery red dot ignite at the center of the paper followed by an orange-red flame that curls and chars the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the burning paper spin and struggle upward as if lifted by an invisible force while leaving a trail of black embers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward to track the paper's movement against a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019006745889782906 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.019006729125977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019006745889782906, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019006745889782906, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.013473156839609146, + 0.009292909875512123, + 0.02791946940124035, + 0.030402380973100662, + 0.01978328824043274, + 0.02756493352353573, + 0.0352039560675621, + 0.03817520663142204, + 0.7835943698883057, + 0.014590268023312092 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019006745889782906 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a piece of yellow talisman paper with rough texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are intricate twisting mystical runes drawn in vibrant vermilion red on the paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a fiery red dot ignite at the center of the paper followed by an orange-red flame that curls and chars the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the burning paper spin and struggle upward as if lifted by an invisible force while leaving a trail of black embers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward to track the paper's movement against a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0025001477915793657 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002500057220459 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0025001477915793657, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0025001477915793657, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.021954499185085297, + 0.019378848373889923, + 0.3370293378829956, + 0.09896913915872574, + 0.02862645871937275, + 0.029045751318335533, + 0.05607123300433159, + 0.01529098954051733, + 0.3769800066947937, + 0.016653742641210556 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0025001477915793657 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a piece of yellow talisman paper with rough texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are intricate twisting mystical runes drawn in vibrant vermilion red on the paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a fiery red dot ignite at the center of the paper followed by an orange-red flame that curls and chars the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the burning paper spin and struggle upward as if lifted by an invisible force while leaving a trail of black embers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward to track the paper's movement against a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007629659026861191 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882629871368408 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007629659026861191, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007629659026861191, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.01873667910695076, + 0.013503700494766235, + 0.10945754498243332, + 0.03557514026761055, + 0.08661537617444992, + 0.11339940875768661, + 0.19837072491645813, + 0.040788691490888596, + 0.31881749629974365, + 0.06473524123430252 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007629659026861191 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a piece of yellow talisman paper with rough texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are intricate twisting mystical runes drawn in vibrant vermilion red on the paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a fiery red dot ignite at the center of the paper followed by an orange-red flame that curls and chars the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the burning paper spin and struggle upward as if lifted by an invisible force while leaving a trail of black embers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward to track the paper's movement against a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305985942482948 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168059825897217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305985942482948, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305985942482948, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.015158375725150108, + 0.0070409816689789295, + 0.43796592950820923, + 0.010983957909047604, + 0.04635066166520119, + 0.08679194003343582, + 0.3062934875488281, + 0.012189486995339394, + 0.017087575048208237, + 0.06013766676187515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305985942482948 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a piece of yellow talisman paper with rough texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are intricate twisting mystical runes drawn in vibrant vermilion red on the paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a fiery red dot ignite at the center of the paper followed by an orange-red flame that curls and chars the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the burning paper spin and struggle upward as if lifted by an invisible force while leaving a trail of black embers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward to track the paper's movement against a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08902419358491898 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464024305343628 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08902419358491898, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08902419358491898, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.016567641869187355, + 0.009061940014362335, + 0.0870899111032486, + 0.024515246972441673, + 0.0234594214707613, + 0.08646935224533081, + 0.06811210513114929, + 0.03883026912808418, + 0.5723994374275208, + 0.07349463552236557 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08902419358491898 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, initially static, focuses on a piece of yellow talisman paper suspended against a dark, blurred background. Its texture is rough, and upon it, intricate, twisting, and powerfully drawn mystical runes in vibrant vermilion red. Suddenly, without warning, a fiery red dot ignites at the center of the paper. Immediately, a brilliant orange-red flame bursts forth, ravenously devouring the paper. The edges of the paper rapidly curl and char under the licking of the flames, while the red runes glow with an extraordinary brilliance in the firelight, as if instantly animated. Then, as if lifted up by an invisible force, the entire burning talisman paper spins and struggles upward. The camera rapidly tilts upward, closely tracking its movement, capturing the dynamic moment as it leaves behind a trail of dancing, flickering black embers. The image is characterized by a stark contrast of light and shadow, with the flames acting as the sole, dynamic source of light, casting a violent, dancing shadow against the pitch-black background, creating a tense atmosphere imbued with a sense of mysterious ritual and the eruption of supernatural power.", + "seed": 15681, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_1/index_8491_seed_15681_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.043883751076646146, + "vlm_logprob": -0.043883751076646146, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.043883751076646146, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a piece of yellow talisman paper with rough texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are intricate twisting mystical runes drawn in vibrant vermilion red on the paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a fiery red dot ignite at the center of the paper followed by an orange-red flame that curls and chars the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the burning paper spin and struggle upward as if lifted by an invisible force while leaving a trail of black embers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward to track the paper's movement against a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006767093203961849 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.131767272949219 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006767093203961849, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006767093203961849, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12562903761863708, + 0.058012548834085464, + 0.2924900949001312, + 0.01879393868148327, + 0.025254713371396065, + 0.07593142986297607, + 0.2346400022506714, + 0.061629291623830795, + 0.06713059544563293, + 0.040488358587026596 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006767093203961849 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a piece of yellow talisman paper with rough texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are intricate twisting mystical runes drawn in vibrant vermilion red on the paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a fiery red dot ignite at the center of the paper followed by an orange-red flame that curls and chars the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the burning paper spin and struggle upward as if lifted by an invisible force while leaving a trail of black embers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward to track the paper's movement against a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019488405669108033 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251948833465576 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019488405669108033, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019488405669108033, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07568527013063431, + 0.09242665022611618, + 0.1119639053940773, + 0.04969290643930435, + 0.03452179953455925, + 0.08132294565439224, + 0.1872946321964264, + 0.11829829216003418, + 0.1872217059135437, + 0.061571910977363586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019488405669108033 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a piece of yellow talisman paper with rough texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are intricate twisting mystical runes drawn in vibrant vermilion red on the paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a fiery red dot ignite at the center of the paper followed by an orange-red flame that curls and chars the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the burning paper spin and struggle upward as if lifted by an invisible force while leaving a trail of black embers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward to track the paper's movement against a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017128810286521912 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376712799072266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017128810286521912, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017128810286521912, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07791122049093246, + 0.06332690268754959, + 0.12026108056306839, + 0.014363467693328857, + 0.021551256999373436, + 0.07333241403102875, + 0.40929368138313293, + 0.08223868906497955, + 0.044842857867479324, + 0.09287844598293304 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017128810286521912 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a piece of yellow talisman paper with rough texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are intricate twisting mystical runes drawn in vibrant vermilion red on the paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a fiery red dot ignite at the center of the paper followed by an orange-red flame that curls and chars the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the burning paper spin and struggle upward as if lifted by an invisible force while leaving a trail of black embers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward to track the paper's movement against a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865432530641556 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048654317855835 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865432530641556, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865432530641556, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10635151714086533, + 0.09133842587471008, + 0.0686541497707367, + 0.022780442610383034, + 0.04880255460739136, + 0.07862106710672379, + 0.1057744100689888, + 0.08400977402925491, + 0.18877139687538147, + 0.20489630103111267 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865432530641556 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a piece of yellow talisman paper with rough texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are intricate twisting mystical runes drawn in vibrant vermilion red on the paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a fiery red dot ignite at the center of the paper followed by an orange-red flame that curls and chars the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the burning paper spin and struggle upward as if lifted by an invisible force while leaving a trail of black embers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward to track the paper's movement against a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16033561527729034 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910335659980774 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16033561527729034, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16033561527729034, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07315970957279205, + 0.05689224228262901, + 0.15763860940933228, + 0.013857214711606503, + 0.04366621375083923, + 0.052011795341968536, + 0.11740804463624954, + 0.0457846075296402, + 0.2934986352920532, + 0.14608290791511536 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16033561527729034 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, initially static, focuses on a piece of yellow talisman paper suspended against a dark, blurred background. Its texture is rough, and upon it, intricate, twisting, and powerfully drawn mystical runes in vibrant vermilion red. Suddenly, without warning, a fiery red dot ignites at the center of the paper. Immediately, a brilliant orange-red flame bursts forth, ravenously devouring the paper. The edges of the paper rapidly curl and char under the licking of the flames, while the red runes glow with an extraordinary brilliance in the firelight, as if instantly animated. Then, as if lifted up by an invisible force, the entire burning talisman paper spins and struggles upward. The camera rapidly tilts upward, closely tracking its movement, capturing the dynamic moment as it leaves behind a trail of dancing, flickering black embers. The image is characterized by a stark contrast of light and shadow, with the flames acting as the sole, dynamic source of light, casting a violent, dancing shadow against the pitch-black background, creating a tense atmosphere imbued with a sense of mysterious ritual and the eruption of supernatural power.", + "seed": 15682, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_1/index_8491_seed_15682_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.01556185942608863, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01556185942608863, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01556185942608863, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a piece of yellow talisman paper with rough texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are intricate twisting mystical runes drawn in vibrant vermilion red on the paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a fiery red dot ignite at the center of the paper followed by an orange-red flame that curls and chars the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the burning paper spin and struggle upward as if lifted by an invisible force while leaving a trail of black embers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward to track the paper's movement against a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01387839112430811 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.388878345489502 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01387839112430811, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01387839112430811, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09057553857564926, + 0.043631285429000854, + 0.04177754372358322, + 0.22792866826057434, + 0.02403402142226696, + 0.07397347688674927, + 0.048446256667375565, + 0.03067648410797119, + 0.37480059266090393, + 0.04415621981024742 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01387839112430811 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a piece of yellow talisman paper with rough texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are intricate twisting mystical runes drawn in vibrant vermilion red on the paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a fiery red dot ignite at the center of the paper followed by an orange-red flame that curls and chars the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the burning paper spin and struggle upward as if lifted by an invisible force while leaving a trail of black embers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward to track the paper's movement against a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0025013370905071497 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002501487731934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0025013370905071497, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0025013370905071497, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08211103081703186, + 0.037478748708963394, + 0.02301022596657276, + 0.5684947371482849, + 0.021677624434232712, + 0.02770153246819973, + 0.018962059170007706, + 0.022789739072322845, + 0.17928281426429749, + 0.018491456285119057 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0025013370905071497 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a piece of yellow talisman paper with rough texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are intricate twisting mystical runes drawn in vibrant vermilion red on the paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a fiery red dot ignite at the center of the paper followed by an orange-red flame that curls and chars the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the burning paper spin and struggle upward as if lifted by an invisible force while leaving a trail of black embers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward to track the paper's movement against a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017147850012406707 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376714706420898 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017147850012406707, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017147850012406707, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03308827802538872, + 0.028942570090293884, + 0.011057301424443722, + 0.6236726641654968, + 0.023630976676940918, + 0.07637271285057068, + 0.06638937443494797, + 0.062241677194833755, + 0.04805057868361473, + 0.026553822681307793 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017147850012406707 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a piece of yellow talisman paper with rough texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are intricate twisting mystical runes drawn in vibrant vermilion red on the paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a fiery red dot ignite at the center of the paper followed by an orange-red flame that curls and chars the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the burning paper spin and struggle upward as if lifted by an invisible force while leaving a trail of black embers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward to track the paper's movement against a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011075449176132679 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511075496673584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011075449176132679, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011075449176132679, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06301560252904892, + 0.025935683399438858, + 0.0189894437789917, + 0.4075217545032501, + 0.03852696716785431, + 0.05251222476363182, + 0.11847230792045593, + 0.08964413404464722, + 0.12126083672046661, + 0.06412104517221451 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011075449176132679 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a piece of yellow talisman paper with rough texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are intricate twisting mystical runes drawn in vibrant vermilion red on the paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a fiery red dot ignite at the center of the paper followed by an orange-red flame that curls and chars the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the burning paper spin and struggle upward as if lifted by an invisible force while leaving a trail of black embers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward to track the paper's movement against a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04863933473825455 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486392974853516 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04863933473825455, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04863933473825455, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04673371464014053, + 0.043735943734645844, + 0.02782178670167923, + 0.29564839601516724, + 0.07688901573419571, + 0.06377358734607697, + 0.03312796354293823, + 0.06123000755906105, + 0.29910558462142944, + 0.05193396285176277 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04863933473825455 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, initially static, focuses on a piece of yellow talisman paper suspended against a dark, blurred background. Its texture is rough, and upon it, intricate, twisting, and powerfully drawn mystical runes in vibrant vermilion red. Suddenly, without warning, a fiery red dot ignites at the center of the paper. Immediately, a brilliant orange-red flame bursts forth, ravenously devouring the paper. The edges of the paper rapidly curl and char under the licking of the flames, while the red runes glow with an extraordinary brilliance in the firelight, as if instantly animated. Then, as if lifted up by an invisible force, the entire burning talisman paper spins and struggles upward. The camera rapidly tilts upward, closely tracking its movement, capturing the dynamic moment as it leaves behind a trail of dancing, flickering black embers. The image is characterized by a stark contrast of light and shadow, with the flames acting as the sole, dynamic source of light, casting a violent, dancing shadow against the pitch-black background, creating a tense atmosphere imbued with a sense of mysterious ritual and the eruption of supernatural power.", + "seed": 15683, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_1/index_8491_seed_15683_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.01968590177129954, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01968590177129954, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01968590177129954, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a piece of yellow talisman paper with rough texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are intricate twisting mystical runes drawn in vibrant vermilion red on the paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a fiery red dot ignite at the center of the paper followed by an orange-red flame that curls and chars the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the burning paper spin and struggle upward as if lifted by an invisible force while leaving a trail of black embers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward to track the paper's movement against a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006771829444915056 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.256772041320801 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006771829444915056, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006771829444915056, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0745265781879425, + 0.27514269948005676, + 0.12017122656106949, + 0.04832186549901962, + 0.022807490080595016, + 0.046402327716350555, + 0.029853951185941696, + 0.024423666298389435, + 0.09537246078252792, + 0.262977659702301 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006771829444915056 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a piece of yellow talisman paper with rough texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are intricate twisting mystical runes drawn in vibrant vermilion red on the paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a fiery red dot ignite at the center of the paper followed by an orange-red flame that curls and chars the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the burning paper spin and struggle upward as if lifted by an invisible force while leaving a trail of black embers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward to track the paper's movement against a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001953242812305689 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251953125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001953242812305689, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001953242812305689, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16847792267799377, + 0.1638793796300888, + 0.17974212765693665, + 0.048181526362895966, + 0.04011986404657364, + 0.03928672522306442, + 0.03829323872923851, + 0.04191724583506584, + 0.190021350979805, + 0.09008060395717621 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001953242812305689 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a piece of yellow talisman paper with rough texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are intricate twisting mystical runes drawn in vibrant vermilion red on the paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a fiery red dot ignite at the center of the paper followed by an orange-red flame that curls and chars the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the burning paper spin and struggle upward as if lifted by an invisible force while leaving a trail of black embers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward to track the paper's movement against a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015136463334783912 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501513481140137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015136463334783912, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015136463334783912, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0485568530857563, + 0.16188101470470428, + 0.44961610436439514, + 0.03127506375312805, + 0.007599559146910906, + 0.014039299450814724, + 0.02242041751742363, + 0.023890120908617973, + 0.13508202135562897, + 0.10563962906599045 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015136463334783912 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a piece of yellow talisman paper with rough texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are intricate twisting mystical runes drawn in vibrant vermilion red on the paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a fiery red dot ignite at the center of the paper followed by an orange-red flame that curls and chars the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the burning paper spin and struggle upward as if lifted by an invisible force while leaving a trail of black embers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward to track the paper's movement against a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018187422305345535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187522888184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018187422305345535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018187422305345535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.060927052050828934, + 0.07036823034286499, + 0.07420416176319122, + 0.031776800751686096, + 0.009840860031545162, + 0.046390350908041, + 0.03339923545718193, + 0.03150421753525734, + 0.13170024752616882, + 0.5098888874053955 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018187422305345535 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a piece of yellow talisman paper with rough texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are intricate twisting mystical runes drawn in vibrant vermilion red on the paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a fiery red dot ignite at the center of the paper followed by an orange-red flame that curls and chars the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the burning paper spin and struggle upward as if lifted by an invisible force while leaving a trail of black embers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly tilt upward to track the paper's movement against a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000336796045303 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950032711029053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000336796045303, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000336796045303, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0432124137878418, + 0.05807219818234444, + 0.025984324514865875, + 0.024476639926433563, + 0.007739977911114693, + 0.034403085708618164, + 0.009032524190843105, + 0.014081036671996117, + 0.06310046464204788, + 0.7198973298072815 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000336796045303 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_10/index_tensor([7475, 7475])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_10/index_tensor([7475, 7475])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..33cdcb06b0dc1f8feb06c0c1d1293b9123468b85 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_10/index_tensor([7475, 7475])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "macro close-up shot from a level angle draws the viewer's gaze to a tranquil corner of the forest floor. A ray of warm afternoon sunlight penetrates the dense canopy, casting a soft beam that illuminates the center of the scene. The camera focuses on a young fawn, its light brown fur speckled with white appearing exceptionally soft and fluffy in the light. Its large, obsidian eyes gleam with innocence. Cautiously, it approaches a rotting log covered in emerald green moss. Atop this decaying log, a massive, fan-shaped, crimson Ganoderma lucidum thrives. Its surface is as smooth as lacquer, its edges gleaming with a golden sheen, revealing distinct rings of growth. The fawn's moist black nose gently touches the edge of the mushroom, and then, with its soft lips and tiny teeth, it delicately and tentatively nibbles at a corner of the cap, its movements filled with innocence and concentration. The entire background of the picture is blurred by the shallow depth of field into a dreamy green and brown halo. Rich details, saturated warm tones and soft light and shadow are intertwined, giving this quiet and vital moment a thick and delicate texture and atmosphere like a classical oil painting.", + "seed": 13411, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_10/index_7475_seed_13411_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.004240325442515314, + "vlm_logprob": -0.004240325442515314, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.004240325442515314, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a young fawn with light brown fur speckled with white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a rotting log covered in emerald green moss in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, fan-shaped, crimson Ganoderma lucidum mushroom growing on the log with a smooth lacquer-like surface and golden sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fawn gently touch the mushroom with its nose and then delicately nibble at the cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field into a green and brown halo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010100324638187885 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.635100364685059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010100324638187885, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010100324638187885, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08542071282863617, + 0.05897257849574089, + 0.13578583300113678, + 0.045924242585897446, + 0.27347856760025024, + 0.038809821009635925, + 0.16995015740394592, + 0.07116161286830902, + 0.09852202236652374, + 0.02197447046637535 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010100324638187885 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a young fawn with light brown fur speckled with white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a rotting log covered in emerald green moss in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, fan-shaped, crimson Ganoderma lucidum mushroom growing on the log with a smooth lacquer-like surface and golden sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fawn gently touch the mushroom with its nose and then delicately nibble at the cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field into a green and brown halo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004106542095541954 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504106521606445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004106542095541954, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004106542095541954, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09695833921432495, + 0.053720228374004364, + 0.06216917186975479, + 0.0628821924328804, + 0.040296558290719986, + 0.27458634972572327, + 0.22504310309886932, + 0.14583006501197815, + 0.01719975657761097, + 0.021314222365617752 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004106542095541954 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a young fawn with light brown fur speckled with white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a rotting log covered in emerald green moss in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, fan-shaped, crimson Ganoderma lucidum mushroom growing on the log with a smooth lacquer-like surface and golden sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fawn gently touch the mushroom with its nose and then delicately nibble at the cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field into a green and brown halo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017190692014992237 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376718997955322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017190692014992237, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017190692014992237, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14544276893138885, + 0.03786703944206238, + 0.048103202134370804, + 0.05350860208272934, + 0.12487122416496277, + 0.14773933589458466, + 0.2291850447654724, + 0.1296492964029312, + 0.03080081380903721, + 0.052832674235105515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017190692014992237 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a young fawn with light brown fur speckled with white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a rotting log covered in emerald green moss in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, fan-shaped, crimson Ganoderma lucidum mushroom growing on the log with a smooth lacquer-like surface and golden sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fawn gently touch the mushroom with its nose and then delicately nibble at the cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field into a green and brown halo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040955008007586 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504095554351807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040955008007586, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040955008007586, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12550745904445648, + 0.14266672730445862, + 0.1024489477276802, + 0.04539656639099121, + 0.06580463796854019, + 0.07032200694084167, + 0.1368836611509323, + 0.17507833242416382, + 0.10681800544261932, + 0.02907363697886467 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040955008007586 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a young fawn with light brown fur speckled with white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a rotting log covered in emerald green moss in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, fan-shaped, crimson Ganoderma lucidum mushroom growing on the log with a smooth lacquer-like surface and golden sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fawn gently touch the mushroom with its nose and then delicately nibble at the cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field into a green and brown halo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011801904765889049 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751180171966553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011801904765889049, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011801904765889049, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12168890982866287, + 0.05664721131324768, + 0.047380536794662476, + 0.08531657606363297, + 0.12284670025110245, + 0.06803309917449951, + 0.2570565938949585, + 0.1730862706899643, + 0.03362732753157616, + 0.034316763281822205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011801904765889049 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "macro close-up shot from a level angle draws the viewer's gaze to a tranquil corner of the forest floor. A ray of warm afternoon sunlight penetrates the dense canopy, casting a soft beam that illuminates the center of the scene. The camera focuses on a young fawn, its light brown fur speckled with white appearing exceptionally soft and fluffy in the light. Its large, obsidian eyes gleam with innocence. Cautiously, it approaches a rotting log covered in emerald green moss. Atop this decaying log, a massive, fan-shaped, crimson Ganoderma lucidum thrives. Its surface is as smooth as lacquer, its edges gleaming with a golden sheen, revealing distinct rings of growth. The fawn's moist black nose gently touches the edge of the mushroom, and then, with its soft lips and tiny teeth, it delicately and tentatively nibbles at a corner of the cap, its movements filled with innocence and concentration. The entire background of the picture is blurred by the shallow depth of field into a dreamy green and brown halo. Rich details, saturated warm tones and soft light and shadow are intertwined, giving this quiet and vital moment a thick and delicate texture and atmosphere like a classical oil painting.", + "seed": 13412, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_10/index_7475_seed_13412_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.008504400774836541, + "vlm_logprob": -0.008504400774836541, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.008504400774836541, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a young fawn with light brown fur speckled with white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a rotting log covered in emerald green moss in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, fan-shaped, crimson Ganoderma lucidum mushroom growing on the log with a smooth lacquer-like surface and golden sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fawn gently touch the mushroom with its nose and then delicately nibble at the cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field into a green and brown halo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02670595422387123 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6517059803009033 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02670595422387123, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02670595422387123, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3904021084308624, + 0.2621820271015167, + 0.02770419418811798, + 0.07885438203811646, + 0.015383311547338963, + 0.06614512205123901, + 0.03484615311026573, + 0.046971824020147324, + 0.03361448645591736, + 0.04389631748199463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02670595422387123 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a young fawn with light brown fur speckled with white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a rotting log covered in emerald green moss in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, fan-shaped, crimson Ganoderma lucidum mushroom growing on the log with a smooth lacquer-like surface and golden sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fawn gently touch the mushroom with its nose and then delicately nibble at the cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field into a green and brown halo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004647406283766031 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379647254943848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004647406283766031, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004647406283766031, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11582497507333755, + 0.034307654947042465, + 0.01980465091764927, + 0.04029429331421852, + 0.02758137136697769, + 0.17893289029598236, + 0.07679373770952225, + 0.0826617181301117, + 0.10959536582231522, + 0.31420329213142395 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004647406283766031 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a young fawn with light brown fur speckled with white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a rotting log covered in emerald green moss in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, fan-shaped, crimson Ganoderma lucidum mushroom growing on the log with a smooth lacquer-like surface and golden sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fawn gently touch the mushroom with its nose and then delicately nibble at the cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field into a green and brown halo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00249182409606874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.0024919509887695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00249182409606874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00249182409606874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16689032316207886, + 0.03401881828904152, + 0.02789079025387764, + 0.07539264857769012, + 0.027129603549838066, + 0.11564166843891144, + 0.05036285147070885, + 0.11562416702508926, + 0.06355589628219604, + 0.32349324226379395 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00249182409606874 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a young fawn with light brown fur speckled with white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a rotting log covered in emerald green moss in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, fan-shaped, crimson Ganoderma lucidum mushroom growing on the log with a smooth lacquer-like surface and golden sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fawn gently touch the mushroom with its nose and then delicately nibble at the cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field into a green and brown halo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006736426148563623 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067362785339355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006736426148563623, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006736426148563623, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22005927562713623, + 0.1252230405807495, + 0.1282743364572525, + 0.10989727079868317, + 0.10331796109676361, + 0.09465114027261734, + 0.04372381791472435, + 0.0679471418261528, + 0.0625368133187294, + 0.04436919465661049 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006736426148563623 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a young fawn with light brown fur speckled with white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a rotting log covered in emerald green moss in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, fan-shaped, crimson Ganoderma lucidum mushroom growing on the log with a smooth lacquer-like surface and golden sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fawn gently touch the mushroom with its nose and then delicately nibble at the cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field into a green and brown halo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019403931219130754 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.2519402503967285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019403931219130754, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019403931219130754, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.38156774640083313, + 0.09476099908351898, + 0.030994435772299767, + 0.11219058185815811, + 0.04676702246069908, + 0.14716964960098267, + 0.0212235264480114, + 0.04438750445842743, + 0.032763466238975525, + 0.08817508071660995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019403931219130754 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "macro close-up shot from a level angle draws the viewer's gaze to a tranquil corner of the forest floor. A ray of warm afternoon sunlight penetrates the dense canopy, casting a soft beam that illuminates the center of the scene. The camera focuses on a young fawn, its light brown fur speckled with white appearing exceptionally soft and fluffy in the light. Its large, obsidian eyes gleam with innocence. Cautiously, it approaches a rotting log covered in emerald green moss. Atop this decaying log, a massive, fan-shaped, crimson Ganoderma lucidum thrives. Its surface is as smooth as lacquer, its edges gleaming with a golden sheen, revealing distinct rings of growth. The fawn's moist black nose gently touches the edge of the mushroom, and then, with its soft lips and tiny teeth, it delicately and tentatively nibbles at a corner of the cap, its movements filled with innocence and concentration. The entire background of the picture is blurred by the shallow depth of field into a dreamy green and brown halo. Rich details, saturated warm tones and soft light and shadow are intertwined, giving this quiet and vital moment a thick and delicate texture and atmosphere like a classical oil painting.", + "seed": 13413, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_10/index_7475_seed_13413_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.004275530180893839, + "vlm_logprob": -0.004275530180893839, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.004275530180893839, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a young fawn with light brown fur speckled with white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a rotting log covered in emerald green moss in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, fan-shaped, crimson Ganoderma lucidum mushroom growing on the log with a smooth lacquer-like surface and golden sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fawn gently touch the mushroom with its nose and then delicately nibble at the cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field into a green and brown halo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007902784273028374 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8829026222229 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007902784273028374, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007902784273028374, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.44319048523902893, + 0.11904412508010864, + 0.07299881428480148, + 0.06014769896864891, + 0.06286236643791199, + 0.10563588887453079, + 0.04261070117354393, + 0.033392030745744705, + 0.026367483660578728, + 0.03375043720006943 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007902784273028374 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a young fawn with light brown fur speckled with white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a rotting log covered in emerald green moss in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, fan-shaped, crimson Ganoderma lucidum mushroom growing on the log with a smooth lacquer-like surface and golden sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fawn gently touch the mushroom with its nose and then delicately nibble at the cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field into a green and brown halo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007639478426426649 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882639408111572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007639478426426649, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007639478426426649, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11362502723932266, + 0.06255169957876205, + 0.09279335290193558, + 0.09442572295665741, + 0.10250649601221085, + 0.15248702466487885, + 0.059310607612133026, + 0.07513987272977829, + 0.1069764569401741, + 0.14018377661705017 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007639478426426649 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a young fawn with light brown fur speckled with white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a rotting log covered in emerald green moss in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, fan-shaped, crimson Ganoderma lucidum mushroom growing on the log with a smooth lacquer-like surface and golden sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fawn gently touch the mushroom with its nose and then delicately nibble at the cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field into a green and brown halo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011817384511232376 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751181602478027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011817384511232376, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011817384511232376, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10433351248502731, + 0.0953434407711029, + 0.053049057722091675, + 0.05084444582462311, + 0.056367360055446625, + 0.3110012412071228, + 0.20008298754692078, + 0.03116130828857422, + 0.032011352479457855, + 0.06580530107021332 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011817384511232376 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a young fawn with light brown fur speckled with white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a rotting log covered in emerald green moss in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, fan-shaped, crimson Ganoderma lucidum mushroom growing on the log with a smooth lacquer-like surface and golden sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fawn gently touch the mushroom with its nose and then delicately nibble at the cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field into a green and brown halo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003612779313698411 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628612995147705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003612779313698411, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003612779313698411, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.053752582520246506, + 0.22820833325386047, + 0.18263010680675507, + 0.06498406082391739, + 0.08351127803325653, + 0.1771611124277115, + 0.10921160876750946, + 0.029587190598249435, + 0.04219173640012741, + 0.028762035071849823 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003612779313698411 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a young fawn with light brown fur speckled with white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a rotting log covered in emerald green moss in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, fan-shaped, crimson Ganoderma lucidum mushroom growing on the log with a smooth lacquer-like surface and golden sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fawn gently touch the mushroom with its nose and then delicately nibble at the cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field into a green and brown halo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010408704401925206 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876040935516357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010408704401925206, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010408704401925206, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35455256700515747, + 0.11450603604316711, + 0.06507683545351028, + 0.10853834450244904, + 0.04133664816617966, + 0.07285584509372711, + 0.09145766496658325, + 0.06437604874372482, + 0.050833337008953094, + 0.03646662086248398 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010408704401925206 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "macro close-up shot from a level angle draws the viewer's gaze to a tranquil corner of the forest floor. A ray of warm afternoon sunlight penetrates the dense canopy, casting a soft beam that illuminates the center of the scene. The camera focuses on a young fawn, its light brown fur speckled with white appearing exceptionally soft and fluffy in the light. Its large, obsidian eyes gleam with innocence. Cautiously, it approaches a rotting log covered in emerald green moss. Atop this decaying log, a massive, fan-shaped, crimson Ganoderma lucidum thrives. Its surface is as smooth as lacquer, its edges gleaming with a golden sheen, revealing distinct rings of growth. The fawn's moist black nose gently touches the edge of the mushroom, and then, with its soft lips and tiny teeth, it delicately and tentatively nibbles at a corner of the cap, its movements filled with innocence and concentration. The entire background of the picture is blurred by the shallow depth of field into a dreamy green and brown halo. Rich details, saturated warm tones and soft light and shadow are intertwined, giving this quiet and vital moment a thick and delicate texture and atmosphere like a classical oil painting.", + "seed": 13414, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_10/index_7475_seed_13414_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.33085282230749724, + "vlm_logprob": -0.33085282230749724, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.33085282230749724, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a young fawn with light brown fur speckled with white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a rotting log covered in emerald green moss in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, fan-shaped, crimson Ganoderma lucidum mushroom growing on the log with a smooth lacquer-like surface and golden sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fawn gently touch the mushroom with its nose and then delicately nibble at the cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field into a green and brown halo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5023448467254639 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2523448169231415 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5023448467254639, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5023448467254639, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.709424614906311, + 0.09098687767982483, + 0.0643802061676979, + 0.023048656061291695, + 0.027217905968427658, + 0.02082778699696064, + 0.014333623461425304, + 0.01402215100824833, + 0.02659137360751629, + 0.009166845120489597 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5023448467254639 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a young fawn with light brown fur speckled with white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a rotting log covered in emerald green moss in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, fan-shaped, crimson Ganoderma lucidum mushroom growing on the log with a smooth lacquer-like surface and golden sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fawn gently touch the mushroom with its nose and then delicately nibble at the cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field into a green and brown halo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0487358495593071 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0487358570098877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0487358495593071, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0487358495593071, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5901739597320557, + 0.08805269747972488, + 0.06837707757949829, + 0.03653005510568619, + 0.04506911337375641, + 0.029511380940675735, + 0.017290867865085602, + 0.07313776761293411, + 0.03135421499609947, + 0.02050289325416088 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0487358495593071 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a young fawn with light brown fur speckled with white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a rotting log covered in emerald green moss in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, fan-shaped, crimson Ganoderma lucidum mushroom growing on the log with a smooth lacquer-like surface and golden sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fawn gently touch the mushroom with its nose and then delicately nibble at the cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field into a green and brown halo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018211768940091133 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018211841583252 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018211768940091133, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018211768940091133, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7121898531913757, + 0.07259146869182587, + 0.07188621908426285, + 0.026159703731536865, + 0.025589728727936745, + 0.01751975528895855, + 0.0109289875254035, + 0.02350425533950329, + 0.015276700258255005, + 0.02435329183936119 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018211768940091133 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a young fawn with light brown fur speckled with white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a rotting log covered in emerald green moss in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, fan-shaped, crimson Ganoderma lucidum mushroom growing on the log with a smooth lacquer-like surface and golden sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fawn gently touch the mushroom with its nose and then delicately nibble at the cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field into a green and brown halo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07901643216609955 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790164470672607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07901643216609955, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07901643216609955, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5437332391738892, + 0.169833704829216, + 0.11462405323982239, + 0.03272799775004387, + 0.03639219328761101, + 0.023464977741241455, + 0.015271748416125774, + 0.020732857286930084, + 0.02763940580189228, + 0.015579815953969955 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07901643216609955 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a young fawn with light brown fur speckled with white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a rotting log covered in emerald green moss in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, fan-shaped, crimson Ganoderma lucidum mushroom growing on the log with a smooth lacquer-like surface and golden sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the fawn gently touch the mushroom with its nose and then delicately nibble at the cap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field into a green and brown halo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005955214146524668 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130955219268799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005955214146524668, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005955214146524668, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7567188739776611, + 0.06320144981145859, + 0.055339012295007706, + 0.016131393611431122, + 0.02865070104598999, + 0.015224040485918522, + 0.01095557026565075, + 0.016925109550356865, + 0.023747149854898453, + 0.01310665812343359 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005955214146524668 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_11/index_tensor([6525, 6525])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_11/index_tensor([6525, 6525])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..80836a5a9fce1a3386fd330c58932d2990a6ae19 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_11/index_tensor([6525, 6525])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme cinematic macro shot, rendered in ultra-high definition, slowly zooms in on the interior of a gold-lipped pearl oyster, set against a deep, out-of-focus, abyssal black background. At the center of the frame, a lustrous pearl, its surface a creamy, milky white. Its nearly spherical shape catches soft, directed light, revealing a deep inner glow with subtle hints of rose and gold. The oyster's iridescent mantle gently nestles around the pearl, a delicate fleshy tissue that seems to breathe with slow, rhythmic pulsations, its folds delicately caressing the pearl's surface. The mantle's surface shimmers with a hypnotic, oily iridescence, its colors shifting and undulating delicately across a spectrum of malachite green, soft violet, and warm gold. The camera's deliberate movements capture the breathtaking play of light within the surrounding mother-of-pearl – a landscape of polished, undulating nacre, where every microscopic ridge and crystalline layer refracts light, creating a living universe teeming with color and texture. The focused, tranquil atmosphere is one of profound natural wonder, revealing the slow, beautiful creation of gemstones in stunning detail.", + "seed": 14261, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_11/index_6525_seed_14261_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07233602663036436, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07233602663036436, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07233602663036436, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view of the interior of a gold-lipped pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep, out-of-focus, and abyssal black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pearl creamy, milky white, nearly spherical, and showing a deep inner glow with hints of rose and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oyster's mantle shimmer with iridescence shifting between malachite green, soft violet, and warm gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013273565098643303 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5132737159729 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013273565098643303, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013273565098643303, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11492577940225601, + 0.05081436410546303, + 0.022514190524816513, + 0.21157807111740112, + 0.0555773489177227, + 0.07054315507411957, + 0.019463783130049706, + 0.06306418031454086, + 0.37446385622024536, + 0.01705523207783699 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013273565098643303 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view of the interior of a gold-lipped pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep, out-of-focus, and abyssal black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pearl creamy, milky white, nearly spherical, and showing a deep inner glow with hints of rose and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oyster's mantle shimmer with iridescence shifting between malachite green, soft violet, and warm gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22562336921691895 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600623369216919 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22562336921691895, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22562336921691895, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0784275159239769, + 0.059883151203393936, + 0.046018462628126144, + 0.3988521695137024, + 0.08213885873556137, + 0.11056619882583618, + 0.012913924641907215, + 0.04310506209731102, + 0.15793804824352264, + 0.010156652890145779 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22562336921691895 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view of the interior of a gold-lipped pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep, out-of-focus, and abyssal black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pearl creamy, milky white, nearly spherical, and showing a deep inner glow with hints of rose and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oyster's mantle shimmer with iridescence shifting between malachite green, soft violet, and warm gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011950739426538348 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751194953918457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011950739426538348, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011950739426538348, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1705661118030548, + 0.07927217334508896, + 0.051976561546325684, + 0.1690879464149475, + 0.1395283341407776, + 0.14854443073272705, + 0.07449665665626526, + 0.08204925060272217, + 0.04956809803843498, + 0.03491048142313957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011950739426538348 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view of the interior of a gold-lipped pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep, out-of-focus, and abyssal black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pearl creamy, milky white, nearly spherical, and showing a deep inner glow with hints of rose and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oyster's mantle shimmer with iridescence shifting between malachite green, soft violet, and warm gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008645131252706051 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758645057678223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008645131252706051, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008645131252706051, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06493902951478958, + 0.0746898427605629, + 0.03784586861729622, + 0.1700684130191803, + 0.03552224859595299, + 0.16746896505355835, + 0.03297823294997215, + 0.026954757049679756, + 0.37259945273399353, + 0.01693318411707878 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008645131252706051 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view of the interior of a gold-lipped pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep, out-of-focus, and abyssal black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pearl creamy, milky white, nearly spherical, and showing a deep inner glow with hints of rose and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oyster's mantle shimmer with iridescence shifting between malachite green, soft violet, and warm gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11294299364089966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237942934036255 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11294299364089966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11294299364089966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14785979688167572, + 0.04795560613274574, + 0.08376792818307877, + 0.3057728111743927, + 0.1157582551240921, + 0.04369845986366272, + 0.07468235492706299, + 0.02903643064200878, + 0.13236162066459656, + 0.019106736406683922 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11294299364089966 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme cinematic macro shot, rendered in ultra-high definition, slowly zooms in on the interior of a gold-lipped pearl oyster, set against a deep, out-of-focus, abyssal black background. At the center of the frame, a lustrous pearl, its surface a creamy, milky white. Its nearly spherical shape catches soft, directed light, revealing a deep inner glow with subtle hints of rose and gold. The oyster's iridescent mantle gently nestles around the pearl, a delicate fleshy tissue that seems to breathe with slow, rhythmic pulsations, its folds delicately caressing the pearl's surface. The mantle's surface shimmers with a hypnotic, oily iridescence, its colors shifting and undulating delicately across a spectrum of malachite green, soft violet, and warm gold. The camera's deliberate movements capture the breathtaking play of light within the surrounding mother-of-pearl – a landscape of polished, undulating nacre, where every microscopic ridge and crystalline layer refracts light, creating a living universe teeming with color and texture. The focused, tranquil atmosphere is one of profound natural wonder, revealing the slow, beautiful creation of gemstones in stunning detail.", + "seed": 14262, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_11/index_6525_seed_14262_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2629145696293563, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2629145696293563, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.275000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2629145696293563, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view of the interior of a gold-lipped pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep, out-of-focus, and abyssal black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pearl creamy, milky white, nearly spherical, and showing a deep inner glow with hints of rose and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oyster's mantle shimmer with iridescence shifting between malachite green, soft violet, and warm gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02852412685751915 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.653524160385132 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02852412685751915, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02852412685751915, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1400385946035385, + 0.13996867835521698, + 0.07338216155767441, + 0.14055509865283966, + 0.05355206876993179, + 0.1563991904258728, + 0.16373573243618011, + 0.06646313518285751, + 0.04149248078465462, + 0.024412861093878746 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02852412685751915 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view of the interior of a gold-lipped pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep, out-of-focus, and abyssal black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pearl creamy, milky white, nearly spherical, and showing a deep inner glow with hints of rose and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oyster's mantle shimmer with iridescence shifting between malachite green, soft violet, and warm gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370935440063477 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870934844017029 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1370935440063477, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.7500000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1370935440063477, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11157014966011047, + 0.3677736222743988, + 0.0656847208738327, + 0.19220797717571259, + 0.11141765862703323, + 0.04331548511981964, + 0.04153065010905266, + 0.028726447373628616, + 0.021655075252056122, + 0.016118187457323074 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1370935440063477 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view of the interior of a gold-lipped pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep, out-of-focus, and abyssal black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pearl creamy, milky white, nearly spherical, and showing a deep inner glow with hints of rose and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oyster's mantle shimmer with iridescence shifting between malachite green, soft violet, and warm gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002513584913685918 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002513408660889 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002513584913685918, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002513584913685918, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1816083788871765, + 0.14813204109668732, + 0.07041286677122116, + 0.14439985156059265, + 0.16032768785953522, + 0.08598055690526962, + 0.10093017667531967, + 0.03875322267413139, + 0.026671288534998894, + 0.04278397560119629 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002513584913685918 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view of the interior of a gold-lipped pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep, out-of-focus, and abyssal black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pearl creamy, milky white, nearly spherical, and showing a deep inner glow with hints of rose and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oyster's mantle shimmer with iridescence shifting between malachite green, soft violet, and warm gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003623469267040491 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.6286234855651855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003623469267040491, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003623469267040491, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12477929890155792, + 0.09558149427175522, + 0.047009434551000595, + 0.2878112196922302, + 0.16028964519500732, + 0.1296357363462448, + 0.06835319846868515, + 0.030443252995610237, + 0.024698950350284576, + 0.031397782266139984 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003623469267040491 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view of the interior of a gold-lipped pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep, out-of-focus, and abyssal black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pearl creamy, milky white, nearly spherical, and showing a deep inner glow with hints of rose and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oyster's mantle shimmer with iridescence shifting between malachite green, soft violet, and warm gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428181231021881 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178182125091553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428181231021881, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428181231021881, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18246249854564667, + 0.26496216654777527, + 0.11036310344934464, + 0.1525152176618576, + 0.055263400077819824, + 0.04668524116277695, + 0.09256048500537872, + 0.03932345658540726, + 0.0412871316075325, + 0.01457730121910572 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428181231021881 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme cinematic macro shot, rendered in ultra-high definition, slowly zooms in on the interior of a gold-lipped pearl oyster, set against a deep, out-of-focus, abyssal black background. At the center of the frame, a lustrous pearl, its surface a creamy, milky white. Its nearly spherical shape catches soft, directed light, revealing a deep inner glow with subtle hints of rose and gold. The oyster's iridescent mantle gently nestles around the pearl, a delicate fleshy tissue that seems to breathe with slow, rhythmic pulsations, its folds delicately caressing the pearl's surface. The mantle's surface shimmers with a hypnotic, oily iridescence, its colors shifting and undulating delicately across a spectrum of malachite green, soft violet, and warm gold. The camera's deliberate movements capture the breathtaking play of light within the surrounding mother-of-pearl – a landscape of polished, undulating nacre, where every microscopic ridge and crystalline layer refracts light, creating a living universe teeming with color and texture. The focused, tranquil atmosphere is one of profound natural wonder, revealing the slow, beautiful creation of gemstones in stunning detail.", + "seed": 14263, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_11/index_6525_seed_14263_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1276285189203918, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1276285189203918, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1276285189203918, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view of the interior of a gold-lipped pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep, out-of-focus, and abyssal black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pearl creamy, milky white, nearly spherical, and showing a deep inner glow with hints of rose and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oyster's mantle shimmer with iridescence shifting between malachite green, soft violet, and warm gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03927282989025116 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2892727851867676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03927282989025116, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03927282989025116, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.027517426759004593, + 0.02889799140393734, + 0.044486451894044876, + 0.01759696565568447, + 0.020675262436270714, + 0.13305027782917023, + 0.06229744479060173, + 0.03075450100004673, + 0.2715844511985779, + 0.36313924193382263 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03927282989025116 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view of the interior of a gold-lipped pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep, out-of-focus, and abyssal black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pearl creamy, milky white, nearly spherical, and showing a deep inner glow with hints of rose and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oyster's mantle shimmer with iridescence shifting between malachite green, soft violet, and warm gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233907699584961 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983907699584961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233907699584961, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233907699584961, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11356610059738159, + 0.07620353251695633, + 0.08679244667291641, + 0.035269130021333694, + 0.05241769179701805, + 0.05378219485282898, + 0.07667426764965057, + 0.17295926809310913, + 0.14244510233402252, + 0.18989022076129913 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233907699584961 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view of the interior of a gold-lipped pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep, out-of-focus, and abyssal black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pearl creamy, milky white, nearly spherical, and showing a deep inner glow with hints of rose and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oyster's mantle shimmer with iridescence shifting between malachite green, soft violet, and warm gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009803246706724167 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634803295135498 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009803246706724167, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009803246706724167, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17825600504875183, + 0.05084185674786568, + 0.07107352465391159, + 0.01777193322777748, + 0.10558806359767914, + 0.054813019931316376, + 0.117880679666996, + 0.13318146765232086, + 0.10644230991601944, + 0.16415110230445862 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009803246706724167 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view of the interior of a gold-lipped pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep, out-of-focus, and abyssal black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pearl creamy, milky white, nearly spherical, and showing a deep inner glow with hints of rose and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oyster's mantle shimmer with iridescence shifting between malachite green, soft violet, and warm gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036227568052709103 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628622531890869 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036227568052709103, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036227568052709103, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09722443670034409, + 0.03755616396665573, + 0.0504358671605587, + 0.020631464198231697, + 0.03336239978671074, + 0.07448326051235199, + 0.04970034956932068, + 0.09290293604135513, + 0.39288151264190674, + 0.15082162618637085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036227568052709103 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view of the interior of a gold-lipped pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep, out-of-focus, and abyssal black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pearl creamy, milky white, nearly spherical, and showing a deep inner glow with hints of rose and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oyster's mantle shimmer with iridescence shifting between malachite green, soft violet, and warm gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205299124121666 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120529651641846 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205299124121666, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205299124121666, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14136771857738495, + 0.06263990700244904, + 0.08868325501680374, + 0.06065145134925842, + 0.07382948696613312, + 0.3289835453033447, + 0.05114338919520378, + 0.035638678818941116, + 0.05570167675614357, + 0.10136086493730545 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205299124121666 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme cinematic macro shot, rendered in ultra-high definition, slowly zooms in on the interior of a gold-lipped pearl oyster, set against a deep, out-of-focus, abyssal black background. At the center of the frame, a lustrous pearl, its surface a creamy, milky white. Its nearly spherical shape catches soft, directed light, revealing a deep inner glow with subtle hints of rose and gold. The oyster's iridescent mantle gently nestles around the pearl, a delicate fleshy tissue that seems to breathe with slow, rhythmic pulsations, its folds delicately caressing the pearl's surface. The mantle's surface shimmers with a hypnotic, oily iridescence, its colors shifting and undulating delicately across a spectrum of malachite green, soft violet, and warm gold. The camera's deliberate movements capture the breathtaking play of light within the surrounding mother-of-pearl – a landscape of polished, undulating nacre, where every microscopic ridge and crystalline layer refracts light, creating a living universe teeming with color and texture. The focused, tranquil atmosphere is one of profound natural wonder, revealing the slow, beautiful creation of gemstones in stunning detail.", + "seed": 14264, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_11/index_6525_seed_14264_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.14099707836285233, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14099707836285233, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14099707836285233, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view of the interior of a gold-lipped pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep, out-of-focus, and abyssal black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pearl creamy, milky white, nearly spherical, and showing a deep inner glow with hints of rose and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oyster's mantle shimmer with iridescence shifting between malachite green, soft violet, and warm gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02461419813334942 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.774614095687866 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02461419813334942, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02461419813334942, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.052131932228803635, + 0.23685143887996674, + 0.045337967574596405, + 0.08734520524740219, + 0.0524764358997345, + 0.23432841897010803, + 0.02010211907327175, + 0.008517296984791756, + 0.017993401736021042, + 0.24491572380065918 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02461419813334942 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view of the interior of a gold-lipped pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep, out-of-focus, and abyssal black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pearl creamy, milky white, nearly spherical, and showing a deep inner glow with hints of rose and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oyster's mantle shimmer with iridescence shifting between malachite green, soft violet, and warm gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4743572175502777 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9743572473526001 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4743572175502777, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4743572175502777, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07420740276575089, + 0.30955126881599426, + 0.03532765433192253, + 0.07105021178722382, + 0.044257424771785736, + 0.09344809502363205, + 0.021689575165510178, + 0.047920435667037964, + 0.02243008464574814, + 0.28011783957481384 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4743572175502777 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view of the interior of a gold-lipped pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep, out-of-focus, and abyssal black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pearl creamy, milky white, nearly spherical, and showing a deep inner glow with hints of rose and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oyster's mantle shimmer with iridescence shifting between malachite green, soft violet, and warm gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00195609824731946 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251955986022949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00195609824731946, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00195609824731946, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07785549759864807, + 0.06823486089706421, + 0.5353590250015259, + 0.10160784423351288, + 0.01077816728502512, + 0.030596153810620308, + 0.021448396146297455, + 0.00970806647092104, + 0.013670017942786217, + 0.13074196875095367 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00195609824731946 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view of the interior of a gold-lipped pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep, out-of-focus, and abyssal black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pearl creamy, milky white, nearly spherical, and showing a deep inner glow with hints of rose and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oyster's mantle shimmer with iridescence shifting between malachite green, soft violet, and warm gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024924185127019882 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002492427825928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024924185127019882, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024924185127019882, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09070252627134323, + 0.07315497100353241, + 0.5515917539596558, + 0.009904113598167896, + 0.03586434945464134, + 0.03524640575051308, + 0.015816200524568558, + 0.014338569715619087, + 0.019757278263568878, + 0.15362383425235748 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024924185127019882 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro view of the interior of a gold-lipped pearl oyster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep, out-of-focus, and abyssal black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pearl creamy, milky white, nearly spherical, and showing a deep inner glow with hints of rose and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the oyster's mantle shimmer with iridescence shifting between malachite green, soft violet, and warm gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in on the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015654593706131 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015655040740967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2015654593706131, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2015654593706131, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03396417573094368, + 0.07545696198940277, + 0.08494409173727036, + 0.08359663933515549, + 0.06278964877128601, + 0.1019662469625473, + 0.025231579318642616, + 0.021897582337260246, + 0.05876268446445465, + 0.4513903260231018 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2015654593706131 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_12/index_tensor([5924, 5924])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_12/index_tensor([5924, 5924])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..59d946114eea1ccb8069d48bc1ccc8bdceb4a769 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_12/index_tensor([5924, 5924])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slowly descending, gently circling drone shot offers awe-inspiring views of a vast golden lotus throne floating in an abstract void. Constructed not of smooth gold, the throne reveals the texture of gilded metal weathered by time. Its surface is riddled with minute cracks and mottled colors. Simple, powerful lines outline each petal, imbued with the allure of Dunhuang murals. The throne's massive petals, layered one after another, steadily and gracefully unfold with a solemn and leisurely rhythm. As the innermost petals unfold, the compassionate figure of Guanyin, seated at the throne's center, is fully revealed. She clad in a pure, immaculate white silk robe, its folds flowing smoothly and simply. She sits in a serene lotus posture, her face serene and compassionate. Her eyes, slightly downcast, seem to survey the world, a faint, transcendent smile playing upon her lips. The entire scene is bathed in a soft, sacred golden light emanating from the lotus and Guanyin herself. This light casts gentle shadows across the mottled golden surface, highlighting its ancient texture. The backdrop, rather than the real world, features stylized auspicious cloud patterns composed of mineral pigments such as ochre, cinnabar, and malachite green. This perfectly replicates the weathered aesthetic of millennia-old murals, creating an atmosphere of solemnity, tranquility, and sacredness that transcends time and space.", + "seed": 18519, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_12/index_5924_seed_18519_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03845240445807576, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03845240445807576, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03845240445807576, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slowly descending, gently circling drone view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a vast golden lotus throne with a weathered, gilded metal texture featuring minute cracks and mottled colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the throne's massive petals unfold steadily and gracefully in a layered sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a figure of Guanyin seated in a serene lotus posture at the throne's center, wearing a pure white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft golden light with a backdrop of stylized auspicious cloud patterns in ochre, cinnabar, and malachite green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10475827753543854 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3547582626342773 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10475827753543854, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10475827753543854, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09331989288330078, + 0.09175752103328705, + 0.05361562222242355, + 0.032073743641376495, + 0.3853880763053894, + 0.08504745364189148, + 0.1380646973848343, + 0.033406924456357956, + 0.05601378530263901, + 0.031312283128499985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10475827753543854 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slowly descending, gently circling drone view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a vast golden lotus throne with a weathered, gilded metal texture featuring minute cracks and mottled colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the throne's massive petals unfold steadily and gracefully in a layered sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a figure of Guanyin seated in a serene lotus posture at the throne's center, wearing a pure white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft golden light with a backdrop of stylized auspicious cloud patterns in ochre, cinnabar, and malachite green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496208369731903 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929962158203125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496208369731903, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496208369731903, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07741100341081619, + 0.1527077555656433, + 0.27568790316581726, + 0.04193851351737976, + 0.1824486404657364, + 0.06370607763528824, + 0.04829166457056999, + 0.08357103914022446, + 0.030255461111664772, + 0.04398190602660179 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496208369731903 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slowly descending, gently circling drone view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a vast golden lotus throne with a weathered, gilded metal texture featuring minute cracks and mottled colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the throne's massive petals unfold steadily and gracefully in a layered sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a figure of Guanyin seated in a serene lotus posture at the throne's center, wearing a pure white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft golden light with a backdrop of stylized auspicious cloud patterns in ochre, cinnabar, and malachite green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006738320458680391 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006738185882568 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006738320458680391, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006738320458680391, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05278095230460167, + 0.15458516776561737, + 0.21308425068855286, + 0.03253767266869545, + 0.07704435288906097, + 0.18560916185379028, + 0.11434298753738403, + 0.05176903307437897, + 0.02824302390217781, + 0.09000348299741745 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006738320458680391 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slowly descending, gently circling drone view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a vast golden lotus throne with a weathered, gilded metal texture featuring minute cracks and mottled colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the throne's massive petals unfold steadily and gracefully in a layered sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a figure of Guanyin seated in a serene lotus posture at the throne's center, wearing a pure white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft golden light with a backdrop of stylized auspicious cloud patterns in ochre, cinnabar, and malachite green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00762551836669445 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882625579833984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00762551836669445, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00762551836669445, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07976216077804565, + 0.05308661237359047, + 0.14287777245044708, + 0.023320138454437256, + 0.16524015367031097, + 0.06536970287561417, + 0.14492909610271454, + 0.2417955845594406, + 0.048012200742959976, + 0.03560652211308479 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00762551836669445 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slowly descending, gently circling drone view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a vast golden lotus throne with a weathered, gilded metal texture featuring minute cracks and mottled colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the throne's massive petals unfold steadily and gracefully in a layered sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a figure of Guanyin seated in a serene lotus posture at the throne's center, wearing a pure white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft golden light with a backdrop of stylized auspicious cloud patterns in ochre, cinnabar, and malachite green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0181778222322464 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0181779861450195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0181778222322464, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0181778222322464, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09489660710096359, + 0.08337534219026566, + 0.2271631509065628, + 0.02648015320301056, + 0.1469225138425827, + 0.08149674534797668, + 0.14715038239955902, + 0.07382463663816452, + 0.04415192827582359, + 0.07453852891921997 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0181778222322464 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly descending, gently circling drone shot offers awe-inspiring views of a vast golden lotus throne floating in an abstract void. Constructed not of smooth gold, the throne reveals the texture of gilded metal weathered by time. Its surface is riddled with minute cracks and mottled colors. Simple, powerful lines outline each petal, imbued with the allure of Dunhuang murals. The throne's massive petals, layered one after another, steadily and gracefully unfold with a solemn and leisurely rhythm. As the innermost petals unfold, the compassionate figure of Guanyin, seated at the throne's center, is fully revealed. She clad in a pure, immaculate white silk robe, its folds flowing smoothly and simply. She sits in a serene lotus posture, her face serene and compassionate. Her eyes, slightly downcast, seem to survey the world, a faint, transcendent smile playing upon her lips. The entire scene is bathed in a soft, sacred golden light emanating from the lotus and Guanyin herself. This light casts gentle shadows across the mottled golden surface, highlighting its ancient texture. The backdrop, rather than the real world, features stylized auspicious cloud patterns composed of mineral pigments such as ochre, cinnabar, and malachite green. This perfectly replicates the weathered aesthetic of millennia-old murals, creating an atmosphere of solemnity, tranquility, and sacredness that transcends time and space.", + "seed": 18520, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_12/index_5924_seed_18520_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06724287420511246, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06724287420511246, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06724287420511246, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slowly descending, gently circling drone view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a vast golden lotus throne with a weathered, gilded metal texture featuring minute cracks and mottled colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the throne's massive petals unfold steadily and gracefully in a layered sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a figure of Guanyin seated in a serene lotus posture at the throne's center, wearing a pure white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft golden light with a backdrop of stylized auspicious cloud patterns in ochre, cinnabar, and malachite green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1508176326751709 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.025817632675171 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1508176326751709, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1508176326751709, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0855502337217331, + 0.025299303233623505, + 0.029543638229370117, + 0.38521814346313477, + 0.03835046663880348, + 0.04240996018052101, + 0.3122130036354065, + 0.035041842609643936, + 0.019704971462488174, + 0.026668453589081764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1508176326751709 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slowly descending, gently circling drone view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a vast golden lotus throne with a weathered, gilded metal texture featuring minute cracks and mottled colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the throne's massive petals unfold steadily and gracefully in a layered sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a figure of Guanyin seated in a serene lotus posture at the throne's center, wearing a pure white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft golden light with a backdrop of stylized auspicious cloud patterns in ochre, cinnabar, and malachite green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16036921739578247 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103691577911377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16036921739578247, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16036921739578247, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05518662557005882, + 0.04834024980664253, + 0.03885853290557861, + 0.567939281463623, + 0.04566574469208717, + 0.024276958778500557, + 0.07188235968351364, + 0.10607676208019257, + 0.016678297892212868, + 0.025095146149396896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16036921739578247 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slowly descending, gently circling drone view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a vast golden lotus throne with a weathered, gilded metal texture featuring minute cracks and mottled colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the throne's massive petals unfold steadily and gracefully in a layered sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a figure of Guanyin seated in a serene lotus posture at the throne's center, wearing a pure white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft golden light with a backdrop of stylized auspicious cloud patterns in ochre, cinnabar, and malachite green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00674246484413743 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006742477416992 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00674246484413743, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00674246484413743, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0499873049557209, + 0.013992521911859512, + 0.013097543269395828, + 0.0966368243098259, + 0.009024467319250107, + 0.013270612806081772, + 0.7492201924324036, + 0.026183223351836205, + 0.011717221699655056, + 0.016870081424713135 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00674246484413743 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slowly descending, gently circling drone view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a vast golden lotus throne with a weathered, gilded metal texture featuring minute cracks and mottled colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the throne's massive petals unfold steadily and gracefully in a layered sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a figure of Guanyin seated in a serene lotus posture at the throne's center, wearing a pure white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft golden light with a backdrop of stylized auspicious cloud patterns in ochre, cinnabar, and malachite green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004096925724297762 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504096984863281 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004096925724297762, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004096925724297762, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08082939684391022, + 0.03785574808716774, + 0.03224506974220276, + 0.29736053943634033, + 0.03148876130580902, + 0.026277760043740273, + 0.1434575468301773, + 0.2329360991716385, + 0.07568425685167313, + 0.041864823549985886 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004096925724297762 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slowly descending, gently circling drone view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a vast golden lotus throne with a weathered, gilded metal texture featuring minute cracks and mottled colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the throne's massive petals unfold steadily and gracefully in a layered sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a figure of Guanyin seated in a serene lotus posture at the throne's center, wearing a pure white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft golden light with a backdrop of stylized auspicious cloud patterns in ochre, cinnabar, and malachite green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014188130386173725 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264188289642334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014188130386173725, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014188130386173725, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05709472671151161, + 0.0370711013674736, + 0.0180516317486763, + 0.14892569184303284, + 0.02379506826400757, + 0.017044106498360634, + 0.35239896178245544, + 0.18235838413238525, + 0.13028495013713837, + 0.03297528624534607 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014188130386173725 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly descending, gently circling drone shot offers awe-inspiring views of a vast golden lotus throne floating in an abstract void. Constructed not of smooth gold, the throne reveals the texture of gilded metal weathered by time. Its surface is riddled with minute cracks and mottled colors. Simple, powerful lines outline each petal, imbued with the allure of Dunhuang murals. The throne's massive petals, layered one after another, steadily and gracefully unfold with a solemn and leisurely rhythm. As the innermost petals unfold, the compassionate figure of Guanyin, seated at the throne's center, is fully revealed. She clad in a pure, immaculate white silk robe, its folds flowing smoothly and simply. She sits in a serene lotus posture, her face serene and compassionate. Her eyes, slightly downcast, seem to survey the world, a faint, transcendent smile playing upon her lips. The entire scene is bathed in a soft, sacred golden light emanating from the lotus and Guanyin herself. This light casts gentle shadows across the mottled golden surface, highlighting its ancient texture. The backdrop, rather than the real world, features stylized auspicious cloud patterns composed of mineral pigments such as ochre, cinnabar, and malachite green. This perfectly replicates the weathered aesthetic of millennia-old murals, creating an atmosphere of solemnity, tranquility, and sacredness that transcends time and space.", + "seed": 18521, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_12/index_5924_seed_18521_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.0798454993404448, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0798454993404448, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.675000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0798454993404448, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slowly descending, gently circling drone view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a vast golden lotus throne with a weathered, gilded metal texture featuring minute cracks and mottled colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the throne's massive petals unfold steadily and gracefully in a layered sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a figure of Guanyin seated in a serene lotus posture at the throne's center, wearing a pure white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft golden light with a backdrop of stylized auspicious cloud patterns in ochre, cinnabar, and malachite green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1530701220035553 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0280702114105225 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1530701220035553, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1530701220035553, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09566918760538101, + 0.09484826773405075, + 0.07914206385612488, + 0.044705282896757126, + 0.04287223517894745, + 0.06770829856395721, + 0.35003384947776794, + 0.08220057189464569, + 0.11121568083763123, + 0.031604498624801636 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1530701220035553 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slowly descending, gently circling drone view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a vast golden lotus throne with a weathered, gilded metal texture featuring minute cracks and mottled colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the throne's massive petals unfold steadily and gracefully in a layered sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a figure of Guanyin seated in a serene lotus posture at the throne's center, wearing a pure white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft golden light with a backdrop of stylized auspicious cloud patterns in ochre, cinnabar, and malachite green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22554773092269897 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005477905273438 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22554773092269897, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22554773092269897, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06253986805677414, + 0.12190616130828857, + 0.14612625539302826, + 0.2166886180639267, + 0.027144579216837883, + 0.04097834974527359, + 0.04605858027935028, + 0.014583801850676537, + 0.19798608124256134, + 0.1259877234697342 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22554773092269897 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slowly descending, gently circling drone view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a vast golden lotus throne with a weathered, gilded metal texture featuring minute cracks and mottled colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the throne's massive petals unfold steadily and gracefully in a layered sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a figure of Guanyin seated in a serene lotus posture at the throne's center, wearing a pure white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft golden light with a backdrop of stylized auspicious cloud patterns in ochre, cinnabar, and malachite green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009784122928977013 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63478422164917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009784122928977013, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009784122928977013, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06179283186793327, + 0.05207506939768791, + 0.11482708901166916, + 0.11737734079360962, + 0.08274566382169724, + 0.08029455691576004, + 0.1551232635974884, + 0.040321577340364456, + 0.20638391375541687, + 0.08905865997076035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009784122928977013 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slowly descending, gently circling drone view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a vast golden lotus throne with a weathered, gilded metal texture featuring minute cracks and mottled colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the throne's massive petals unfold steadily and gracefully in a layered sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a figure of Guanyin seated in a serene lotus posture at the throne's center, wearing a pure white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft golden light with a backdrop of stylized auspicious cloud patterns in ochre, cinnabar, and malachite green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006734531372785568 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006734371185303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006734531372785568, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006734531372785568, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08572980761528015, + 0.04646644741296768, + 0.1226041167974472, + 0.161204531788826, + 0.10644099861383438, + 0.04845396801829338, + 0.09622655063867569, + 0.031611472368240356, + 0.08693581074476242, + 0.21432636678218842 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006734531372785568 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slowly descending, gently circling drone view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a vast golden lotus throne with a weathered, gilded metal texture featuring minute cracks and mottled colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the throne's massive petals unfold steadily and gracefully in a layered sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a figure of Guanyin seated in a serene lotus posture at the throne's center, wearing a pure white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft golden light with a backdrop of stylized auspicious cloud patterns in ochre, cinnabar, and malachite green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004090989474207163 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504090785980225 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004090989474207163, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004090989474207163, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1791558414697647, + 0.12591634690761566, + 0.16647709906101227, + 0.0657198429107666, + 0.04052191972732544, + 0.028325119987130165, + 0.038699086755514145, + 0.009032576344907284, + 0.1042628288269043, + 0.2418893426656723 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004090989474207163 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly descending, gently circling drone shot offers awe-inspiring views of a vast golden lotus throne floating in an abstract void. Constructed not of smooth gold, the throne reveals the texture of gilded metal weathered by time. Its surface is riddled with minute cracks and mottled colors. Simple, powerful lines outline each petal, imbued with the allure of Dunhuang murals. The throne's massive petals, layered one after another, steadily and gracefully unfold with a solemn and leisurely rhythm. As the innermost petals unfold, the compassionate figure of Guanyin, seated at the throne's center, is fully revealed. She clad in a pure, immaculate white silk robe, its folds flowing smoothly and simply. She sits in a serene lotus posture, her face serene and compassionate. Her eyes, slightly downcast, seem to survey the world, a faint, transcendent smile playing upon her lips. The entire scene is bathed in a soft, sacred golden light emanating from the lotus and Guanyin herself. This light casts gentle shadows across the mottled golden surface, highlighting its ancient texture. The backdrop, rather than the real world, features stylized auspicious cloud patterns composed of mineral pigments such as ochre, cinnabar, and malachite green. This perfectly replicates the weathered aesthetic of millennia-old murals, creating an atmosphere of solemnity, tranquility, and sacredness that transcends time and space.", + "seed": 18522, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_12/index_5924_seed_18522_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.05089347946923226, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05089347946923226, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.274999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05089347946923226, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slowly descending, gently circling drone view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a vast golden lotus throne with a weathered, gilded metal texture featuring minute cracks and mottled colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the throne's massive petals unfold steadily and gracefully in a layered sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a figure of Guanyin seated in a serene lotus posture at the throne's center, wearing a pure white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft golden light with a backdrop of stylized auspicious cloud patterns in ochre, cinnabar, and malachite green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18419311940670013 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8091931343078613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18419311940670013, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18419311940670013, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1436535269021988, + 0.02089112624526024, + 0.2895548641681671, + 0.11468286067247391, + 0.07098597288131714, + 0.022362595424056053, + 0.053195770829916, + 0.032282836735248566, + 0.060927651822566986, + 0.19146277010440826 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18419311940670013 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slowly descending, gently circling drone view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a vast golden lotus throne with a weathered, gilded metal texture featuring minute cracks and mottled colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the throne's massive petals unfold steadily and gracefully in a layered sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a figure of Guanyin seated in a serene lotus posture at the throne's center, wearing a pure white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft golden light with a backdrop of stylized auspicious cloud patterns in ochre, cinnabar, and malachite green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0486685186624527 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048668622970581 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0486685186624527, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0486685186624527, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16414189338684082, + 0.09251012653112411, + 0.07499722391366959, + 0.10417061299085617, + 0.07264736294746399, + 0.03578953444957733, + 0.05361117050051689, + 0.05226250737905502, + 0.08732012659311295, + 0.26254943013191223 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0486685186624527 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slowly descending, gently circling drone view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a vast golden lotus throne with a weathered, gilded metal texture featuring minute cracks and mottled colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the throne's massive petals unfold steadily and gracefully in a layered sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a figure of Guanyin seated in a serene lotus posture at the throne's center, wearing a pure white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft golden light with a backdrop of stylized auspicious cloud patterns in ochre, cinnabar, and malachite green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018182972446084023 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018182754516602 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018182972446084023, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018182972446084023, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15722091495990753, + 0.03654209524393082, + 0.18139789998531342, + 0.09892624616622925, + 0.048912614583969116, + 0.05887436121702194, + 0.15074396133422852, + 0.04988866671919823, + 0.05261916294693947, + 0.16487401723861694 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018182972446084023 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slowly descending, gently circling drone view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a vast golden lotus throne with a weathered, gilded metal texture featuring minute cracks and mottled colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the throne's massive petals unfold steadily and gracefully in a layered sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a figure of Guanyin seated in a serene lotus posture at the throne's center, wearing a pure white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft golden light with a backdrop of stylized auspicious cloud patterns in ochre, cinnabar, and malachite green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017120479606091976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376711845397949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017120479606091976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017120479606091976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1702602058649063, + 0.021646805107593536, + 0.1018953025341034, + 0.06998439133167267, + 0.03562584146857262, + 0.03723202273249626, + 0.028278565034270287, + 0.08844514191150665, + 0.22274444997310638, + 0.2238873392343521 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017120479606091976 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slowly descending, gently circling drone view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central object a vast golden lotus throne with a weathered, gilded metal texture featuring minute cracks and mottled colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the throne's massive petals unfold steadily and gracefully in a layered sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a figure of Guanyin seated in a serene lotus posture at the throne's center, wearing a pure white silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in soft golden light with a backdrop of stylized auspicious cloud patterns in ochre, cinnabar, and malachite green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017107388703152537 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376710891723633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017107388703152537, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017107388703152537, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32762792706489563, + 0.04226164147257805, + 0.2231513261795044, + 0.03711025044322014, + 0.06622745841741562, + 0.0391775444149971, + 0.08981892466545105, + 0.028103014454245567, + 0.05669951066374779, + 0.08982240408658981 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017107388703152537 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_13/index_tensor([1544, 1544])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_13/index_tensor([1544, 1544])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f4548eab361d97d516f00c9bb197bc55a3442fca --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_13/index_tensor([1544, 1544])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The film begins with a striking wide-angle shot, then the camera zooms in and out at breakneck speed, simulating the dynamic contraction of all visual elements toward the center of the frame. Within this fractured, surreal dimensional space, countless floating geometric fragments, twisted urban debris, and nebulous streaks of light, initially suspended in a pitch-black void, are now violently pulled and deformed by an invisible, immense gravitational force, transforming into dazzling streams of light that converge relentlessly toward the young man at the absolute center of the frame. The young man, clad in a tight, matte, dark blue combat suit with futuristic lines, leans back slightly, arms outstretched, his short, jet-black hair flowing in an invisible current. His eyes are closed, his pale face betraying the pain and fortitude of enduring the immense energy impact. Finally, all matter and energy collapsed violently within a ten-thousandth of a second, condensing into a hexagonal crystal embedded under the skin of his chest. The crystal was beating rhythmically, steadily and powerfully, and each beat emitted a soft and sacred blue glow. This light penetrated his combat uniform, not only illuminating his resolute face, but also providing the only source of light for this dark space that had just undergone a devastating reconstruction, creating an epic atmosphere of sacredness, rebirth and full of unknown power.", + "seed": 3862, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_13/index_1544_seed_3862_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0841176774352789, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0841176774352789, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.824999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0841176774352789, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pitch-black void containing floating geometric fragments and twisted urban debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young man visible at the absolute center of the frame wearing a tight, matte, dark blue combat suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the young man have short, jet-black hair, closed eyes, and an outstretched posture while leaning back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a hexagonal crystal visible embedded under the skin of the young man's chest emitting a soft blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid zooms in and out to simulate dynamic contraction of visual elements toward the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20252466201782227 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7025246620178223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20252466201782227, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20252466201782227, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5461525321006775, + 0.06074272096157074, + 0.046499207615852356, + 0.02804427221417427, + 0.022495515644550323, + 0.02606780454516411, + 0.10533557087182999, + 0.03006967343389988, + 0.04894019663333893, + 0.08565250784158707 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20252466201782227 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pitch-black void containing floating geometric fragments and twisted urban debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young man visible at the absolute center of the frame wearing a tight, matte, dark blue combat suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the young man have short, jet-black hair, closed eyes, and an outstretched posture while leaning back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a hexagonal crystal visible embedded under the skin of the young man's chest emitting a soft blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid zooms in and out to simulate dynamic contraction of visual elements toward the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270165592432022 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127016544342041 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270165592432022, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270165592432022, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22899819910526276, + 0.038669925183057785, + 0.05591105297207832, + 0.03067672997713089, + 0.02906424179673195, + 0.07545439153909683, + 0.10862180590629578, + 0.20874616503715515, + 0.07180077582597733, + 0.1520567089319229 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270165592432022 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pitch-black void containing floating geometric fragments and twisted urban debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young man visible at the absolute center of the frame wearing a tight, matte, dark blue combat suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the young man have short, jet-black hair, closed eyes, and an outstretched posture while leaning back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a hexagonal crystal visible embedded under the skin of the young man's chest emitting a soft blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid zooms in and out to simulate dynamic contraction of visual elements toward the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980121411383152 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298011302948 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980121411383152, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980121411383152, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.030238013714551926, + 0.022666770964860916, + 0.053996820002794266, + 0.02916914038360119, + 0.017658933997154236, + 0.02786841057240963, + 0.06767842173576355, + 0.14560338854789734, + 0.11816076189279556, + 0.4869593381881714 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980121411383152 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pitch-black void containing floating geometric fragments and twisted urban debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young man visible at the absolute center of the frame wearing a tight, matte, dark blue combat suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the young man have short, jet-black hair, closed eyes, and an outstretched posture while leaning back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a hexagonal crystal visible embedded under the skin of the young man's chest emitting a soft blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid zooms in and out to simulate dynamic contraction of visual elements toward the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043061573058366776 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680614948272705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043061573058366776, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043061573058366776, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1799943447113037, + 0.04338080808520317, + 0.0727444589138031, + 0.03350678086280823, + 0.0438583642244339, + 0.21187721192836761, + 0.08380231261253357, + 0.0760953277349472, + 0.07812467962503433, + 0.17661571502685547 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043061573058366776 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pitch-black void containing floating geometric fragments and twisted urban debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young man visible at the absolute center of the frame wearing a tight, matte, dark blue combat suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the young man have short, jet-black hair, closed eyes, and an outstretched posture while leaning back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a hexagonal crystal visible embedded under the skin of the young man's chest emitting a soft blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid zooms in and out to simulate dynamic contraction of visual elements toward the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018184378743171692 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018184185028076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018184378743171692, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018184378743171692, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18545173108577728, + 0.12334266304969788, + 0.0643729642033577, + 0.042340442538261414, + 0.06971116364002228, + 0.19469954073429108, + 0.07872495800256729, + 0.05355597287416458, + 0.05914607271552086, + 0.12865450978279114 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018184378743171692 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with a striking wide-angle shot, then the camera zooms in and out at breakneck speed, simulating the dynamic contraction of all visual elements toward the center of the frame. Within this fractured, surreal dimensional space, countless floating geometric fragments, twisted urban debris, and nebulous streaks of light, initially suspended in a pitch-black void, are now violently pulled and deformed by an invisible, immense gravitational force, transforming into dazzling streams of light that converge relentlessly toward the young man at the absolute center of the frame. The young man, clad in a tight, matte, dark blue combat suit with futuristic lines, leans back slightly, arms outstretched, his short, jet-black hair flowing in an invisible current. His eyes are closed, his pale face betraying the pain and fortitude of enduring the immense energy impact. Finally, all matter and energy collapsed violently within a ten-thousandth of a second, condensing into a hexagonal crystal embedded under the skin of his chest. The crystal was beating rhythmically, steadily and powerfully, and each beat emitted a soft and sacred blue glow. This light penetrated his combat uniform, not only illuminating his resolute face, but also providing the only source of light for this dark space that had just undergone a devastating reconstruction, creating an epic atmosphere of sacredness, rebirth and full of unknown power.", + "seed": 3863, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_13/index_1544_seed_3863_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.05160910040140152, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05160910040140152, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05160910040140152, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pitch-black void containing floating geometric fragments and twisted urban debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young man visible at the absolute center of the frame wearing a tight, matte, dark blue combat suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the young man have short, jet-black hair, closed eyes, and an outstretched posture while leaning back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a hexagonal crystal visible embedded under the skin of the young man's chest emitting a soft blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid zooms in and out to simulate dynamic contraction of visual elements toward the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1438896358013153 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0188896656036377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1438896358013153, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1438896358013153, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10010769963264465, + 0.13629060983657837, + 0.5528698563575745, + 0.03981512412428856, + 0.02040213719010353, + 0.03854535520076752, + 0.04301057010889053, + 0.025717761367559433, + 0.022216711193323135, + 0.021024189889431 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1438896358013153 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pitch-black void containing floating geometric fragments and twisted urban debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young man visible at the absolute center of the frame wearing a tight, matte, dark blue combat suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the young man have short, jet-black hair, closed eyes, and an outstretched posture while leaning back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a hexagonal crystal visible embedded under the skin of the young man's chest emitting a soft blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid zooms in and out to simulate dynamic contraction of visual elements toward the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033691875636577606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408691883087158 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033691875636577606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033691875636577606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08017810434103012, + 0.06216873228549957, + 0.12573154270648956, + 0.04303612932562828, + 0.11036420613527298, + 0.07515042275190353, + 0.11022572219371796, + 0.09066138416528702, + 0.11987116187810898, + 0.18261262774467468 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033691875636577606 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pitch-black void containing floating geometric fragments and twisted urban debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young man visible at the absolute center of the frame wearing a tight, matte, dark blue combat suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the young man have short, jet-black hair, closed eyes, and an outstretched posture while leaning back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a hexagonal crystal visible embedded under the skin of the young man's chest emitting a soft blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid zooms in and out to simulate dynamic contraction of visual elements toward the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00762551836669445 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882625579833984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00762551836669445, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00762551836669445, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11238950490951538, + 0.06545846164226532, + 0.24207188189029694, + 0.06662005186080933, + 0.061021335422992706, + 0.11898846179246902, + 0.049720510840415955, + 0.05464010685682297, + 0.09013088792562485, + 0.13895872235298157 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00762551836669445 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pitch-black void containing floating geometric fragments and twisted urban debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young man visible at the absolute center of the frame wearing a tight, matte, dark blue combat suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the young man have short, jet-black hair, closed eyes, and an outstretched posture while leaning back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a hexagonal crystal visible embedded under the skin of the young man's chest emitting a soft blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid zooms in and out to simulate dynamic contraction of visual elements toward the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02979299984872341 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297930240631104 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02979299984872341, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02979299984872341, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03646976500749588, + 0.0682026669383049, + 0.13059395551681519, + 0.029854582622647285, + 0.034915901720523834, + 0.05173024535179138, + 0.043771300464868546, + 0.056128475815057755, + 0.0785992294549942, + 0.469733864068985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02979299984872341 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pitch-black void containing floating geometric fragments and twisted urban debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young man visible at the absolute center of the frame wearing a tight, matte, dark blue combat suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the young man have short, jet-black hair, closed eyes, and an outstretched posture while leaning back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a hexagonal crystal visible embedded under the skin of the young man's chest emitting a soft blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid zooms in and out to simulate dynamic contraction of visual elements toward the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04304547235369682 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680455207824707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04304547235369682, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04304547235369682, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10144821554422379, + 0.4251840114593506, + 0.08209463953971863, + 0.03230316564440727, + 0.04428597539663315, + 0.08041922003030777, + 0.04542306810617447, + 0.055957429111003876, + 0.06188039854168892, + 0.07100393623113632 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04304547235369682 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with a striking wide-angle shot, then the camera zooms in and out at breakneck speed, simulating the dynamic contraction of all visual elements toward the center of the frame. Within this fractured, surreal dimensional space, countless floating geometric fragments, twisted urban debris, and nebulous streaks of light, initially suspended in a pitch-black void, are now violently pulled and deformed by an invisible, immense gravitational force, transforming into dazzling streams of light that converge relentlessly toward the young man at the absolute center of the frame. The young man, clad in a tight, matte, dark blue combat suit with futuristic lines, leans back slightly, arms outstretched, his short, jet-black hair flowing in an invisible current. His eyes are closed, his pale face betraying the pain and fortitude of enduring the immense energy impact. Finally, all matter and energy collapsed violently within a ten-thousandth of a second, condensing into a hexagonal crystal embedded under the skin of his chest. The crystal was beating rhythmically, steadily and powerfully, and each beat emitted a soft and sacred blue glow. This light penetrated his combat uniform, not only illuminating his resolute face, but also providing the only source of light for this dark space that had just undergone a devastating reconstruction, creating an epic atmosphere of sacredness, rebirth and full of unknown power.", + "seed": 3864, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_13/index_1544_seed_3864_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.3888005256652832, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3888005256652832, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3888005256652832, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pitch-black void containing floating geometric fragments and twisted urban debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young man visible at the absolute center of the frame wearing a tight, matte, dark blue combat suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the young man have short, jet-black hair, closed eyes, and an outstretched posture while leaning back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a hexagonal crystal visible embedded under the skin of the young man's chest emitting a soft blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid zooms in and out to simulate dynamic contraction of visual elements toward the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.805422067642212 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1804220825433731 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.805422067642212, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.805422067642212, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.293235182762146, + 0.14300651848316193, + 0.038623787462711334, + 0.08508908003568649, + 0.047326404601335526, + 0.08815877139568329, + 0.0368792898952961, + 0.04340642690658569, + 0.1409507840871811, + 0.08332380652427673 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.805422067642212 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pitch-black void containing floating geometric fragments and twisted urban debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young man visible at the absolute center of the frame wearing a tight, matte, dark blue combat suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the young man have short, jet-black hair, closed eyes, and an outstretched posture while leaning back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a hexagonal crystal visible embedded under the skin of the young man's chest emitting a soft blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid zooms in and out to simulate dynamic contraction of visual elements toward the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308144003152847 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168081521987915 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308144003152847, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308144003152847, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20868878066539764, + 0.1085616946220398, + 0.24817469716072083, + 0.04979070648550987, + 0.04001830890774727, + 0.08233970403671265, + 0.041602421551942825, + 0.09653561562299728, + 0.08623012900352478, + 0.03805793821811676 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308144003152847 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pitch-black void containing floating geometric fragments and twisted urban debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young man visible at the absolute center of the frame wearing a tight, matte, dark blue combat suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the young man have short, jet-black hair, closed eyes, and an outstretched posture while leaning back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a hexagonal crystal visible embedded under the skin of the young man's chest emitting a soft blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid zooms in and out to simulate dynamic contraction of visual elements toward the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014197180047631264 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26419734954834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014197180047631264, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014197180047631264, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23871873319149017, + 0.1364305168390274, + 0.10275772958993912, + 0.060633812099695206, + 0.044818464666604996, + 0.046009331941604614, + 0.04715647175908089, + 0.07722387462854385, + 0.1341067999601364, + 0.11214424669742584 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014197180047631264 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pitch-black void containing floating geometric fragments and twisted urban debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young man visible at the absolute center of the frame wearing a tight, matte, dark blue combat suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the young man have short, jet-black hair, closed eyes, and an outstretched posture while leaning back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a hexagonal crystal visible embedded under the skin of the young man's chest emitting a soft blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid zooms in and out to simulate dynamic contraction of visual elements toward the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026353510096669197 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651353597640991 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026353510096669197, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026353510096669197, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06785115599632263, + 0.026829171925783157, + 0.015220639295876026, + 0.020603202283382416, + 0.014962928369641304, + 0.017346002161502838, + 0.011575598269701004, + 0.01336218137294054, + 0.03142185136675835, + 0.7808272838592529 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026353510096669197 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pitch-black void containing floating geometric fragments and twisted urban debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young man visible at the absolute center of the frame wearing a tight, matte, dark blue combat suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the young man have short, jet-black hair, closed eyes, and an outstretched posture while leaning back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a hexagonal crystal visible embedded under the skin of the young man's chest emitting a soft blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid zooms in and out to simulate dynamic contraction of visual elements toward the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05494843050837517 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929948329925537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05494843050837517, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05494843050837517, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21517997980117798, + 0.11067994683980942, + 0.05029146000742912, + 0.09619970619678497, + 0.04838484525680542, + 0.06061145290732384, + 0.07252047210931778, + 0.06872371584177017, + 0.06803186237812042, + 0.20937657356262207 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05494843050837517 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with a striking wide-angle shot, then the camera zooms in and out at breakneck speed, simulating the dynamic contraction of all visual elements toward the center of the frame. Within this fractured, surreal dimensional space, countless floating geometric fragments, twisted urban debris, and nebulous streaks of light, initially suspended in a pitch-black void, are now violently pulled and deformed by an invisible, immense gravitational force, transforming into dazzling streams of light that converge relentlessly toward the young man at the absolute center of the frame. The young man, clad in a tight, matte, dark blue combat suit with futuristic lines, leans back slightly, arms outstretched, his short, jet-black hair flowing in an invisible current. His eyes are closed, his pale face betraying the pain and fortitude of enduring the immense energy impact. Finally, all matter and energy collapsed violently within a ten-thousandth of a second, condensing into a hexagonal crystal embedded under the skin of his chest. The crystal was beating rhythmically, steadily and powerfully, and each beat emitted a soft and sacred blue glow. This light penetrated his combat uniform, not only illuminating his resolute face, but also providing the only source of light for this dark space that had just undergone a devastating reconstruction, creating an epic atmosphere of sacredness, rebirth and full of unknown power.", + "seed": 3865, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_13/index_1544_seed_3865_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.08966370010748506, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08966370010748506, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08966370010748506, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pitch-black void containing floating geometric fragments and twisted urban debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young man visible at the absolute center of the frame wearing a tight, matte, dark blue combat suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the young man have short, jet-black hair, closed eyes, and an outstretched posture while leaning back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a hexagonal crystal visible embedded under the skin of the young man's chest emitting a soft blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid zooms in and out to simulate dynamic contraction of visual elements toward the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31441187858581543 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3144118785858154 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31441187858581543, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31441187858581543, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3075822591781616, + 0.1213613897562027, + 0.0528251938521862, + 0.03957111015915871, + 0.07776536047458649, + 0.05326715484261513, + 0.06295502185821533, + 0.2055846005678177, + 0.03897778317332268, + 0.040110085159540176 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31441187858581543 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pitch-black void containing floating geometric fragments and twisted urban debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young man visible at the absolute center of the frame wearing a tight, matte, dark blue combat suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the young man have short, jet-black hair, closed eyes, and an outstretched posture while leaning back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a hexagonal crystal visible embedded under the skin of the young man's chest emitting a soft blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid zooms in and out to simulate dynamic contraction of visual elements toward the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000669836997986 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950066089630127 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000669836997986, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000669836997986, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20604749023914337, + 0.1383412629365921, + 0.050327230244874954, + 0.028074339032173157, + 0.04978187382221222, + 0.04563093185424805, + 0.06701749563217163, + 0.11142579466104507, + 0.23664425313472748, + 0.0667092502117157 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000669836997986 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pitch-black void containing floating geometric fragments and twisted urban debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young man visible at the absolute center of the frame wearing a tight, matte, dark blue combat suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the young man have short, jet-black hair, closed eyes, and an outstretched posture while leaning back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a hexagonal crystal visible embedded under the skin of the young man's chest emitting a soft blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid zooms in and out to simulate dynamic contraction of visual elements toward the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007627174723893404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882627010345459 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007627174723893404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007627174723893404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05371308699250221, + 0.03738965466618538, + 0.0198072362691164, + 0.014906229451298714, + 0.014790819957852364, + 0.05311915650963783, + 0.04845409840345383, + 0.04493854194879532, + 0.6724842190742493, + 0.04039699584245682 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007627174723893404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pitch-black void containing floating geometric fragments and twisted urban debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young man visible at the absolute center of the frame wearing a tight, matte, dark blue combat suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the young man have short, jet-black hair, closed eyes, and an outstretched posture while leaning back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a hexagonal crystal visible embedded under the skin of the young man's chest emitting a soft blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid zooms in and out to simulate dynamic contraction of visual elements toward the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818554848432541 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018185615539551 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818554848432541, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818554848432541, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07623696327209473, + 0.07704541832208633, + 0.02196965366601944, + 0.02587882988154888, + 0.023864267393946648, + 0.04985261708498001, + 0.04407075047492981, + 0.04524030163884163, + 0.31774410605430603, + 0.31809717416763306 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818554848432541 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a pitch-black void containing floating geometric fragments and twisted urban debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young man visible at the absolute center of the frame wearing a tight, matte, dark blue combat suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the young man have short, jet-black hair, closed eyes, and an outstretched posture while leaning back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a hexagonal crystal visible embedded under the skin of the young man's chest emitting a soft blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid zooms in and out to simulate dynamic contraction of visual elements toward the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03808720037341118 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880871295928955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03808720037341118, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03808720037341118, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10370839387178421, + 0.34334951639175415, + 0.10084984451532364, + 0.026192359626293182, + 0.06522168964147568, + 0.052421413362026215, + 0.07415223121643066, + 0.057049352675676346, + 0.13965560495853424, + 0.03739960119128227 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03808720037341118 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_14/index_tensor([40, 40])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_14/index_tensor([40, 40])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b74777978a3e01e120e91a6c42daffb8259df376 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_14/index_tensor([40, 40])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, horizontal, medium shot, shot from behind, captures a man with slightly disheveled gray hair, wearing a dark brown tweed jacket and a beige wool sweater. He sits alone in a high-backed leather armchair, his back to the camera, facing a large arched window. Outside, dusk falls, and a gentle rain silently drizzles across the glass. His study is surrounded by towering, dark wooden bookshelves, crammed with ancient books of varying thickness, bound in leather or cloth. Some books are even haphazardly stacked on the floor and on the corners of the table. The man leans forward slightly, his elbows resting on his knees, his hands clasped before him, his head slightly lowered, his entire body almost motionless, completely absorbed in his thoughts. The cool twilight filtering in from the window serves as the primary light source, softly outlining his shoulders and head. Farther back, a small desk lamp casts a warm, orange glow, illuminating the gilded lettering on the book spines. The entire scene is dominated by deep wood tones and cool blue, dotted with warm lights, creating an academic atmosphere of extreme tranquility, concentration, contemplation, and a hint of melancholy.", + "seed": 28268, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_14/index_40_seed_28268_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04376290524378419, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04376290524378419, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04376290524378419, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, horizontal, medium shot taken from behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark brown tweed jacket and a beige wool sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting alone in a high-backed leather armchair with his back to the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool twilight from a large arched window and a warm orange desk lamp in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bookshelves filled with ancient books, some of which are stacked on the floor and table corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010830076411366463 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.010829925537109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010830076411366463, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010830076411366463, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19781015813350677, + 0.07913878560066223, + 0.10314518213272095, + 0.13242658972740173, + 0.09831803292036057, + 0.12868238985538483, + 0.04059925302863121, + 0.0662841722369194, + 0.03330262005329132, + 0.1202927902340889 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010830076411366463 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, horizontal, medium shot taken from behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark brown tweed jacket and a beige wool sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting alone in a high-backed leather armchair with his back to the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool twilight from a large arched window and a warm orange desk lamp in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bookshelves filled with ancient books, some of which are stacked on the floor and table corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06207125261425972 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120713233947754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06207125261425972, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06207125261425972, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11648492515087128, + 0.09021282941102982, + 0.07453511655330658, + 0.09277011454105377, + 0.06407439708709717, + 0.2025539129972458, + 0.14252667129039764, + 0.09075652807950974, + 0.030654728412628174, + 0.09543081372976303 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06207125261425972 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, horizontal, medium shot taken from behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark brown tweed jacket and a beige wool sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting alone in a high-backed leather armchair with his back to the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool twilight from a large arched window and a warm orange desk lamp in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bookshelves filled with ancient books, some of which are stacked on the floor and table corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031936378218233585 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531938552856445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031936378218233585, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031936378218233585, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16457760334014893, + 0.16170792281627655, + 0.07134067267179489, + 0.03723374009132385, + 0.051139071583747864, + 0.2503540515899658, + 0.07058193534612656, + 0.03209304437041283, + 0.041777513921260834, + 0.1191944032907486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031936378218233585 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, horizontal, medium shot taken from behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark brown tweed jacket and a beige wool sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting alone in a high-backed leather armchair with his back to the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool twilight from a large arched window and a warm orange desk lamp in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bookshelves filled with ancient books, some of which are stacked on the floor and table corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029800519347190857 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298004150390625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029800519347190857, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029800519347190857, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16544842720031738, + 0.05025356262922287, + 0.059973929077386856, + 0.2603268623352051, + 0.03182363882660866, + 0.10523372143507004, + 0.0893634557723999, + 0.03762900456786156, + 0.03386693447828293, + 0.16608040034770966 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029800519347190857 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, horizontal, medium shot taken from behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark brown tweed jacket and a beige wool sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting alone in a high-backed leather armchair with his back to the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool twilight from a large arched window and a warm orange desk lamp in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bookshelves filled with ancient books, some of which are stacked on the floor and table corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11291904002428055 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379190921783447 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11291904002428055, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11291904002428055, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3544751703739166, + 0.04005267843604088, + 0.021264294162392616, + 0.03519601747393608, + 0.05486137047410011, + 0.12443235516548157, + 0.25099629163742065, + 0.030353916808962822, + 0.033867284655570984, + 0.054500650614500046 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11291904002428055 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, horizontal, medium shot, shot from behind, captures a man with slightly disheveled gray hair, wearing a dark brown tweed jacket and a beige wool sweater. He sits alone in a high-backed leather armchair, his back to the camera, facing a large arched window. Outside, dusk falls, and a gentle rain silently drizzles across the glass. His study is surrounded by towering, dark wooden bookshelves, crammed with ancient books of varying thickness, bound in leather or cloth. Some books are even haphazardly stacked on the floor and on the corners of the table. The man leans forward slightly, his elbows resting on his knees, his hands clasped before him, his head slightly lowered, his entire body almost motionless, completely absorbed in his thoughts. The cool twilight filtering in from the window serves as the primary light source, softly outlining his shoulders and head. Farther back, a small desk lamp casts a warm, orange glow, illuminating the gilded lettering on the book spines. The entire scene is dominated by deep wood tones and cool blue, dotted with warm lights, creating an academic atmosphere of extreme tranquility, concentration, contemplation, and a hint of melancholy.", + "seed": 28269, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_14/index_40_seed_28269_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02024715831503272, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02024715831503272, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02024715831503272, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, horizontal, medium shot taken from behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark brown tweed jacket and a beige wool sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting alone in a high-backed leather armchair with his back to the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool twilight from a large arched window and a warm orange desk lamp in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bookshelves filled with ancient books, some of which are stacked on the floor and table corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012416680343449116 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.512416839599609 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012416680343449116, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012416680343449116, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10889867693185806, + 0.05884125083684921, + 0.03727981075644493, + 0.07627158612012863, + 0.05819747969508171, + 0.45223426818847656, + 0.01553349569439888, + 0.05418887734413147, + 0.049080535769462585, + 0.08947395533323288 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012416680343449116 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, horizontal, medium shot taken from behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark brown tweed jacket and a beige wool sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting alone in a high-backed leather armchair with his back to the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool twilight from a large arched window and a warm orange desk lamp in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bookshelves filled with ancient books, some of which are stacked on the floor and table corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496840178966522 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299683570861816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496840178966522, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496840178966522, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1644715815782547, + 0.08582856506109238, + 0.0646362155675888, + 0.07005363702774048, + 0.02452973835170269, + 0.07540353387594223, + 0.05576314032077789, + 0.06054742634296417, + 0.10666012018918991, + 0.2921060025691986 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496840178966522 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, horizontal, medium shot taken from behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark brown tweed jacket and a beige wool sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting alone in a high-backed leather armchair with his back to the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool twilight from a large arched window and a warm orange desk lamp in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bookshelves filled with ancient books, some of which are stacked on the floor and table corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005254743155092001 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255254745483398 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005254743155092001, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005254743155092001, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13513529300689697, + 0.061427194625139236, + 0.03555743023753166, + 0.049424123018980026, + 0.04019274562597275, + 0.3640449345111847, + 0.06975195556879044, + 0.027590731158852577, + 0.1515502780675888, + 0.0653252974152565 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005254743155092001 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, horizontal, medium shot taken from behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark brown tweed jacket and a beige wool sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting alone in a high-backed leather armchair with his back to the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool twilight from a large arched window and a warm orange desk lamp in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bookshelves filled with ancient books, some of which are stacked on the floor and table corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606426201760769 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141064167022705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606426201760769, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606426201760769, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13698866963386536, + 0.07766015827655792, + 0.048820123076438904, + 0.055351126939058304, + 0.03865211457014084, + 0.29141852259635925, + 0.05940178036689758, + 0.044834744185209274, + 0.09808670729398727, + 0.1487860232591629 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606426201760769 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, horizontal, medium shot taken from behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark brown tweed jacket and a beige wool sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting alone in a high-backed leather armchair with his back to the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool twilight from a large arched window and a warm orange desk lamp in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bookshelves filled with ancient books, some of which are stacked on the floor and table corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012531704269349575 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387531757354736 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012531704269349575, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012531704269349575, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29469361901283264, + 0.07061922550201416, + 0.07297657430171967, + 0.09300647675991058, + 0.06568384170532227, + 0.12752138078212738, + 0.035172928124666214, + 0.03347770497202873, + 0.07439795881509781, + 0.13245028257369995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012531704269349575 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, horizontal, medium shot, shot from behind, captures a man with slightly disheveled gray hair, wearing a dark brown tweed jacket and a beige wool sweater. He sits alone in a high-backed leather armchair, his back to the camera, facing a large arched window. Outside, dusk falls, and a gentle rain silently drizzles across the glass. His study is surrounded by towering, dark wooden bookshelves, crammed with ancient books of varying thickness, bound in leather or cloth. Some books are even haphazardly stacked on the floor and on the corners of the table. The man leans forward slightly, his elbows resting on his knees, his hands clasped before him, his head slightly lowered, his entire body almost motionless, completely absorbed in his thoughts. The cool twilight filtering in from the window serves as the primary light source, softly outlining his shoulders and head. Farther back, a small desk lamp casts a warm, orange glow, illuminating the gilded lettering on the book spines. The entire scene is dominated by deep wood tones and cool blue, dotted with warm lights, creating an academic atmosphere of extreme tranquility, concentration, contemplation, and a hint of melancholy.", + "seed": 28270, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_14/index_40_seed_28270_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03786156140267849, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03786156140267849, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03786156140267849, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, horizontal, medium shot taken from behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark brown tweed jacket and a beige wool sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting alone in a high-backed leather armchair with his back to the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool twilight from a large arched window and a warm orange desk lamp in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bookshelves filled with ancient books, some of which are stacked on the floor and table corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02039181999862194 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.020391941070557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02039181999862194, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02039181999862194, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15462560951709747, + 0.07565952092409134, + 0.08885040134191513, + 0.11417245864868164, + 0.1681966930627823, + 0.06881866604089737, + 0.07407800853252411, + 0.06894324719905853, + 0.15406475961208344, + 0.03259069845080376 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02039181999862194 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, horizontal, medium shot taken from behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark brown tweed jacket and a beige wool sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting alone in a high-backed leather armchair with his back to the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool twilight from a large arched window and a warm orange desk lamp in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bookshelves filled with ancient books, some of which are stacked on the floor and table corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062086936086416245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812086820602417 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062086936086416245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062086936086416245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22136515378952026, + 0.06861740350723267, + 0.07685746252536774, + 0.09081244468688965, + 0.039568934589624405, + 0.0488152913749218, + 0.15719713270664215, + 0.08857925981283188, + 0.12245140224695206, + 0.08573552966117859 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062086936086416245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, horizontal, medium shot taken from behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark brown tweed jacket and a beige wool sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting alone in a high-backed leather armchair with his back to the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool twilight from a large arched window and a warm orange desk lamp in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bookshelves filled with ancient books, some of which are stacked on the floor and table corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011086177080869675 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110859870910645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011086177080869675, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011086177080869675, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10321630537509918, + 0.03965321555733681, + 0.04411739856004715, + 0.09189191460609436, + 0.06325584650039673, + 0.2357679307460785, + 0.12596608698368073, + 0.09749922156333923, + 0.17312823235988617, + 0.025503847748041153 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011086177080869675 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, horizontal, medium shot taken from behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark brown tweed jacket and a beige wool sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting alone in a high-backed leather armchair with his back to the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool twilight from a large arched window and a warm orange desk lamp in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bookshelves filled with ancient books, some of which are stacked on the floor and table corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370881825685501 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087088108062744 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370881825685501, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370881825685501, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15015804767608643, + 0.09461754560470581, + 0.14516854286193848, + 0.046612221747636795, + 0.036112990230321884, + 0.06063707172870636, + 0.09840250015258789, + 0.31549057364463806, + 0.033116988837718964, + 0.019683532416820526 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370881825685501 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, horizontal, medium shot taken from behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark brown tweed jacket and a beige wool sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting alone in a high-backed leather armchair with his back to the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool twilight from a large arched window and a warm orange desk lamp in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bookshelves filled with ancient books, some of which are stacked on the floor and table corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06203405559062958 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120341300964355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06203405559062958, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06203405559062958, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09046541154384613, + 0.046661656349897385, + 0.0808015763759613, + 0.045920949429273605, + 0.02649223804473877, + 0.10276839137077332, + 0.12977047264575958, + 0.22996190190315247, + 0.08960508555173874, + 0.15755228698253632 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06203405559062958 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, horizontal, medium shot, shot from behind, captures a man with slightly disheveled gray hair, wearing a dark brown tweed jacket and a beige wool sweater. He sits alone in a high-backed leather armchair, his back to the camera, facing a large arched window. Outside, dusk falls, and a gentle rain silently drizzles across the glass. His study is surrounded by towering, dark wooden bookshelves, crammed with ancient books of varying thickness, bound in leather or cloth. Some books are even haphazardly stacked on the floor and on the corners of the table. The man leans forward slightly, his elbows resting on his knees, his hands clasped before him, his head slightly lowered, his entire body almost motionless, completely absorbed in his thoughts. The cool twilight filtering in from the window serves as the primary light source, softly outlining his shoulders and head. Farther back, a small desk lamp casts a warm, orange glow, illuminating the gilded lettering on the book spines. The entire scene is dominated by deep wood tones and cool blue, dotted with warm lights, creating an academic atmosphere of extreme tranquility, concentration, contemplation, and a hint of melancholy.", + "seed": 28271, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_14/index_40_seed_28271_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.030844656657427548, + "vlm_logprob": -0.030844656657427548, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.030844656657427548, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, horizontal, medium shot taken from behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark brown tweed jacket and a beige wool sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting alone in a high-backed leather armchair with his back to the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool twilight from a large arched window and a warm orange desk lamp in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bookshelves filled with ancient books, some of which are stacked on the floor and table corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004534794948995113 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.629534721374512 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004534794948995113, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004534794948995113, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1629987210035324, + 0.04628658667206764, + 0.029453657567501068, + 0.03426317870616913, + 0.45943760871887207, + 0.052290987223386765, + 0.08339037001132965, + 0.04367524012923241, + 0.018732409924268723, + 0.06947124004364014 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004534794948995113 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, horizontal, medium shot taken from behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark brown tweed jacket and a beige wool sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting alone in a high-backed leather armchair with his back to the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool twilight from a large arched window and a warm orange desk lamp in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bookshelves filled with ancient books, some of which are stacked on the floor and table corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038111988455057144 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288111925125122 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038111988455057144, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038111988455057144, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3549562990665436, + 0.03854719176888466, + 0.050234612077474594, + 0.05907013639807701, + 0.23878532648086548, + 0.058342911303043365, + 0.03069247491657734, + 0.05046769976615906, + 0.04978532716631889, + 0.06911807507276535 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038111988455057144 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, horizontal, medium shot taken from behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark brown tweed jacket and a beige wool sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting alone in a high-backed leather armchair with his back to the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool twilight from a large arched window and a warm orange desk lamp in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bookshelves filled with ancient books, some of which are stacked on the floor and table corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028173536993563175 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877817153930664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028173536993563175, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028173536993563175, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2218167632818222, + 0.05565235763788223, + 0.029156440868973732, + 0.03058190830051899, + 0.36958086490631104, + 0.029427191242575645, + 0.03509916737675667, + 0.018122512847185135, + 0.10330793261528015, + 0.10725487023591995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028173536993563175 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, horizontal, medium shot taken from behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark brown tweed jacket and a beige wool sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting alone in a high-backed leather armchair with his back to the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool twilight from a large arched window and a warm orange desk lamp in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bookshelves filled with ancient books, some of which are stacked on the floor and table corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02979646995663643 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297963619232178 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02979646995663643, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02979646995663643, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22971521317958832, + 0.14659535884857178, + 0.07214345037937164, + 0.03203805536031723, + 0.2204304039478302, + 0.0366331972181797, + 0.032465703785419464, + 0.06542424112558365, + 0.06451413780450821, + 0.10004020482301712 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02979646995663643 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, horizontal, medium shot taken from behind the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark brown tweed jacket and a beige wool sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man sitting alone in a high-backed leather armchair with his back to the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by cool twilight from a large arched window and a warm orange desk lamp in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the bookshelves filled with ancient books, some of which are stacked on the floor and table corners?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07896267622709274 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578962564468384 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07896267622709274, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07896267622709274, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15399248898029327, + 0.10586486756801605, + 0.082112155854702, + 0.043574292212724686, + 0.1984824687242508, + 0.0712215006351471, + 0.07509668916463852, + 0.08281262964010239, + 0.12217122316360474, + 0.06467165052890778 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07896267622709274 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_15/index_tensor([2536, 2536])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_15/index_tensor([2536, 2536])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..17bdce006477396e9fbe8634249c7ca5ed8f5588 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_15/index_tensor([2536, 2536])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, shot from a level angle, slowly pans forward, focusing on a wrinkled elderly man. Beneath his sparse silver-white hair lie gentle, deep eyes. The wrinkles on his forehead and around his eyes, as deep as the furrows of time, bear witness to the passage of time. He sits serenely in a room bathed in afternoon sunlight, wearing a worn, rough, dark gray sweater. Soft, warm light slants in from the side windows, illuminating the dust particles dancing in the air and casting long, blurred shadows on the wooden bookshelves behind him. Steadily and calmly, he slowly extends his hand, veined and covered in age spots and fine lines, toward the camera. His knuckles are slightly thickened from years of hard work, and the lines on his palm are clearly visible, as if reaching out to the audience on screen or offering a silent message. The entire picture presents a warm and faded retro film texture, with low color saturation and slight film grain. The main colors are amber and dark brown, creating a tranquil, nostalgic and story-filled emotional atmosphere.", + "seed": 13022, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_15/index_2536_seed_13022_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.010109503101557494, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010109503101557494, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010109503101557494, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a wrinkled elderly man with sparse silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn, rough, dark gray sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man slowly extend his hand toward the camera, showing age spots and fine lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with wooden bookshelves in the background, bathed in afternoon sunlight with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video have a warm, faded retro film texture with low color saturation and slight film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004005030728876591 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.629004955291748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004005030728876591, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004005030728876591, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4521893858909607, + 0.1671646535396576, + 0.029204418882727623, + 0.03056730143725872, + 0.08819784969091415, + 0.0676170065999031, + 0.018454767763614655, + 0.023539619520306587, + 0.035185955464839935, + 0.08787908405065536 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004005030728876591 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a wrinkled elderly man with sparse silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn, rough, dark gray sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man slowly extend his hand toward the camera, showing age spots and fine lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with wooden bookshelves in the background, bathed in afternoon sunlight with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video have a warm, faded retro film texture with low color saturation and slight film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01820041425526142 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018200397491455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01820041425526142, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01820041425526142, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37964823842048645, + 0.2535901665687561, + 0.0565609410405159, + 0.04599055275321007, + 0.04311363399028778, + 0.039484329521656036, + 0.015138828195631504, + 0.031178070232272148, + 0.04107275232672691, + 0.09422259032726288 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01820041425526142 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a wrinkled elderly man with sparse silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn, rough, dark gray sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man slowly extend his hand toward the camera, showing age spots and fine lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with wooden bookshelves in the background, bathed in afternoon sunlight with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video have a warm, faded retro film texture with low color saturation and slight film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024926564656198025 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002492427825928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024926564656198025, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024926564656198025, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1123676598072052, + 0.07752325385808945, + 0.04774395376443863, + 0.14093677699565887, + 0.16103029251098633, + 0.028281530365347862, + 0.03057374246418476, + 0.09572331607341766, + 0.07604730874300003, + 0.2297721654176712 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024926564656198025 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a wrinkled elderly man with sparse silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn, rough, dark gray sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man slowly extend his hand toward the camera, showing age spots and fine lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with wooden bookshelves in the background, bathed in afternoon sunlight with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video have a warm, faded retro film texture with low color saturation and slight film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606954075396061 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141069412231445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606954075396061, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606954075396061, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2462707906961441, + 0.28558316826820374, + 0.0611373633146286, + 0.11493918299674988, + 0.04217398911714554, + 0.02331572026014328, + 0.00709769781678915, + 0.03838871046900749, + 0.029015395790338516, + 0.15207797288894653 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606954075396061 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a wrinkled elderly man with sparse silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn, rough, dark gray sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man slowly extend his hand toward the camera, showing age spots and fine lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with wooden bookshelves in the background, bathed in afternoon sunlight with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video have a warm, faded retro film texture with low color saturation and slight film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009779873304069042 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634779930114746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009779873304069042, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009779873304069042, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14330627024173737, + 0.07990233600139618, + 0.040308281779289246, + 0.035854440182447433, + 0.0479421392083168, + 0.028613798320293427, + 0.031696487218141556, + 0.11258796602487564, + 0.08337656408548355, + 0.3964116871356964 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009779873304069042 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, shot from a level angle, slowly pans forward, focusing on a wrinkled elderly man. Beneath his sparse silver-white hair lie gentle, deep eyes. The wrinkles on his forehead and around his eyes, as deep as the furrows of time, bear witness to the passage of time. He sits serenely in a room bathed in afternoon sunlight, wearing a worn, rough, dark gray sweater. Soft, warm light slants in from the side windows, illuminating the dust particles dancing in the air and casting long, blurred shadows on the wooden bookshelves behind him. Steadily and calmly, he slowly extends his hand, veined and covered in age spots and fine lines, toward the camera. His knuckles are slightly thickened from years of hard work, and the lines on his palm are clearly visible, as if reaching out to the audience on screen or offering a silent message. The entire picture presents a warm and faded retro film texture, with low color saturation and slight film grain. The main colors are amber and dark brown, creating a tranquil, nostalgic and story-filled emotional atmosphere.", + "seed": 13023, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_15/index_2536_seed_13023_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02936728154309094, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02936728154309094, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02936728154309094, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a wrinkled elderly man with sparse silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn, rough, dark gray sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man slowly extend his hand toward the camera, showing age spots and fine lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with wooden bookshelves in the background, bathed in afternoon sunlight with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video have a warm, faded retro film texture with low color saturation and slight film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002875956939533353 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002875804901123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002875956939533353, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002875956939533353, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1403585821390152, + 0.03587138652801514, + 0.018773004412651062, + 0.04155741631984711, + 0.06451626121997833, + 0.1637723743915558, + 0.18227075040340424, + 0.1285877227783203, + 0.07659894227981567, + 0.14769358932971954 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002875956939533353 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a wrinkled elderly man with sparse silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn, rough, dark gray sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man slowly extend his hand toward the camera, showing age spots and fine lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with wooden bookshelves in the background, bathed in afternoon sunlight with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video have a warm, faded retro film texture with low color saturation and slight film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371654078364372 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087164402008057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371654078364372, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371654078364372, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1788705289363861, + 0.06013726443052292, + 0.06105821952223778, + 0.07283500581979752, + 0.17980891466140747, + 0.11828485131263733, + 0.040864307433366776, + 0.12122829258441925, + 0.06508766859769821, + 0.1018250435590744 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371654078364372 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a wrinkled elderly man with sparse silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn, rough, dark gray sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man slowly extend his hand toward the camera, showing age spots and fine lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with wooden bookshelves in the background, bathed in afternoon sunlight with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video have a warm, faded retro film texture with low color saturation and slight film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012545477598905563 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387545585632324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012545477598905563, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012545477598905563, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05726517736911774, + 0.0233480054885149, + 0.01708085648715496, + 0.024462388828396797, + 0.06757627427577972, + 0.4486614465713501, + 0.09821756184101105, + 0.06350455433130264, + 0.10028909146785736, + 0.09959456324577332 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012545477598905563 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a wrinkled elderly man with sparse silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn, rough, dark gray sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man slowly extend his hand toward the camera, showing age spots and fine lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with wooden bookshelves in the background, bathed in afternoon sunlight with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video have a warm, faded retro film texture with low color saturation and slight film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08905909210443497 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640591144561768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08905909210443497, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08905909210443497, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33602532744407654, + 0.03510177880525589, + 0.016493728384375572, + 0.017803313210606575, + 0.01606043428182602, + 0.07627634704113007, + 0.18427276611328125, + 0.10758917778730392, + 0.1215677335858345, + 0.08880934864282608 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08905909210443497 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a wrinkled elderly man with sparse silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn, rough, dark gray sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man slowly extend his hand toward the camera, showing age spots and fine lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with wooden bookshelves in the background, bathed in afternoon sunlight with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video have a warm, faded retro film texture with low color saturation and slight film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008639340288937092 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758639335632324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008639340288937092, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008639340288937092, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22502073645591736, + 0.05604250356554985, + 0.04798438400030136, + 0.02508663944900036, + 0.04245905205607414, + 0.1606237292289734, + 0.1162138506770134, + 0.09169873595237732, + 0.11481396853923798, + 0.1200563833117485 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008639340288937092 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, shot from a level angle, slowly pans forward, focusing on a wrinkled elderly man. Beneath his sparse silver-white hair lie gentle, deep eyes. The wrinkles on his forehead and around his eyes, as deep as the furrows of time, bear witness to the passage of time. He sits serenely in a room bathed in afternoon sunlight, wearing a worn, rough, dark gray sweater. Soft, warm light slants in from the side windows, illuminating the dust particles dancing in the air and casting long, blurred shadows on the wooden bookshelves behind him. Steadily and calmly, he slowly extends his hand, veined and covered in age spots and fine lines, toward the camera. His knuckles are slightly thickened from years of hard work, and the lines on his palm are clearly visible, as if reaching out to the audience on screen or offering a silent message. The entire picture presents a warm and faded retro film texture, with low color saturation and slight film grain. The main colors are amber and dark brown, creating a tranquil, nostalgic and story-filled emotional atmosphere.", + "seed": 13024, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_15/index_2536_seed_13024_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.009648974938318133, + "vlm_logprob": -0.009648974938318133, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.149999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.009648974938318133, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a wrinkled elderly man with sparse silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn, rough, dark gray sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man slowly extend his hand toward the camera, showing age spots and fine lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with wooden bookshelves in the background, bathed in afternoon sunlight with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video have a warm, faded retro film texture with low color saturation and slight film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013724679592996836 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.126372337341309 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013724679592996836, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013724679592996836, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0758281722664833, + 0.08170274645090103, + 0.0688743144273758, + 0.17378708720207214, + 0.10433341562747955, + 0.09774802625179291, + 0.10414395481348038, + 0.07560332119464874, + 0.08971815556287766, + 0.1282607764005661 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013724679592996836 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a wrinkled elderly man with sparse silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn, rough, dark gray sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man slowly extend his hand toward the camera, showing age spots and fine lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with wooden bookshelves in the background, bathed in afternoon sunlight with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video have a warm, faded retro film texture with low color saturation and slight film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018202053382992744 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01820182800293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018202053382992744, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018202053382992744, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14923030138015747, + 0.10752925276756287, + 0.07904092967510223, + 0.08172105252742767, + 0.06094188988208771, + 0.10036371648311615, + 0.13239458203315735, + 0.0711965560913086, + 0.024876898154616356, + 0.19270487129688263 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018202053382992744 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a wrinkled elderly man with sparse silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn, rough, dark gray sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man slowly extend his hand toward the camera, showing age spots and fine lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with wooden bookshelves in the background, bathed in afternoon sunlight with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video have a warm, faded retro film texture with low color saturation and slight film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002822346519678831 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877822399139404 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002822346519678831, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002822346519678831, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05177197605371475, + 0.12220646440982819, + 0.10003083199262619, + 0.10522778332233429, + 0.07508967816829681, + 0.34941616654396057, + 0.04303698614239693, + 0.07544881105422974, + 0.02383575588464737, + 0.05393558740615845 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002822346519678831 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a wrinkled elderly man with sparse silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn, rough, dark gray sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man slowly extend his hand toward the camera, showing age spots and fine lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with wooden bookshelves in the background, bathed in afternoon sunlight with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video have a warm, faded retro film texture with low color saturation and slight film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016067897900938988 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141067981719971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016067897900938988, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016067897900938988, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2158535271883011, + 0.05903376638889313, + 0.05601784214377403, + 0.1379885971546173, + 0.03700406849384308, + 0.11817477643489838, + 0.11100079119205475, + 0.09351018071174622, + 0.08191151916980743, + 0.0895048975944519 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016067897900938988 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a wrinkled elderly man with sparse silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn, rough, dark gray sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man slowly extend his hand toward the camera, showing age spots and fine lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with wooden bookshelves in the background, bathed in afternoon sunlight with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video have a warm, faded retro film texture with low color saturation and slight film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978010892868042 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634779930114746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978010892868042, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978010892868042, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09399624168872833, + 0.10870331525802612, + 0.041719067841768265, + 0.16861143708229065, + 0.04152185097336769, + 0.16536904871463776, + 0.12480009347200394, + 0.0345039889216423, + 0.062383558601140976, + 0.15839143097400665 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978010892868042 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, shot from a level angle, slowly pans forward, focusing on a wrinkled elderly man. Beneath his sparse silver-white hair lie gentle, deep eyes. The wrinkles on his forehead and around his eyes, as deep as the furrows of time, bear witness to the passage of time. He sits serenely in a room bathed in afternoon sunlight, wearing a worn, rough, dark gray sweater. Soft, warm light slants in from the side windows, illuminating the dust particles dancing in the air and casting long, blurred shadows on the wooden bookshelves behind him. Steadily and calmly, he slowly extends his hand, veined and covered in age spots and fine lines, toward the camera. His knuckles are slightly thickened from years of hard work, and the lines on his palm are clearly visible, as if reaching out to the audience on screen or offering a silent message. The entire picture presents a warm and faded retro film texture, with low color saturation and slight film grain. The main colors are amber and dark brown, creating a tranquil, nostalgic and story-filled emotional atmosphere.", + "seed": 13025, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_15/index_2536_seed_13025_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0072833933401852844, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0072833933401852844, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0072833933401852844, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a wrinkled elderly man with sparse silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn, rough, dark gray sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man slowly extend his hand toward the camera, showing age spots and fine lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with wooden bookshelves in the background, bathed in afternoon sunlight with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video have a warm, faded retro film texture with low color saturation and slight film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002076613949611783 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.502076625823975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002076613949611783, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002076613949611783, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16013891994953156, + 0.08287112414836884, + 0.04101482778787613, + 0.20417754352092743, + 0.048980459570884705, + 0.05422763153910637, + 0.14732009172439575, + 0.06700411438941956, + 0.06463543325662613, + 0.12962989509105682 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002076613949611783 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a wrinkled elderly man with sparse silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn, rough, dark gray sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man slowly extend his hand toward the camera, showing age spots and fine lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with wooden bookshelves in the background, bathed in afternoon sunlight with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video have a warm, faded retro film texture with low color saturation and slight film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012558662332594395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387558460235596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012558662332594395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012558662332594395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10879377275705338, + 0.03994514420628548, + 0.03363333269953728, + 0.15373267233371735, + 0.048932719975709915, + 0.14608627557754517, + 0.1383337825536728, + 0.1173282042145729, + 0.061108529567718506, + 0.15210558474063873 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012558662332594395 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a wrinkled elderly man with sparse silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn, rough, dark gray sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man slowly extend his hand toward the camera, showing age spots and fine lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with wooden bookshelves in the background, bathed in afternoon sunlight with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video have a warm, faded retro film texture with low color saturation and slight film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005259605124592781 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.2552595138549805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005259605124592781, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005259605124592781, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07762461155653, + 0.03980650380253792, + 0.05139784514904022, + 0.16439393162727356, + 0.09593430906534195, + 0.18061724305152893, + 0.11423967778682709, + 0.0655614510178566, + 0.06171620637178421, + 0.1487082988023758 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005259605124592781 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a wrinkled elderly man with sparse silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn, rough, dark gray sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man slowly extend his hand toward the camera, showing age spots and fine lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with wooden bookshelves in the background, bathed in afternoon sunlight with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video have a warm, faded retro film texture with low color saturation and slight film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006736899726092815 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006736755371094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006736899726092815, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006736899726092815, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09513512998819351, + 0.08015301078557968, + 0.041694775223731995, + 0.1068347916007042, + 0.04685363546013832, + 0.23558516800403595, + 0.1985711306333542, + 0.041858427226543427, + 0.06332772970199585, + 0.08998627960681915 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006736899726092815 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a wrinkled elderly man with sparse silver-white hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn, rough, dark gray sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man slowly extend his hand toward the camera, showing age spots and fine lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with wooden bookshelves in the background, bathed in afternoon sunlight with visible dust particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video have a warm, faded retro film texture with low color saturation and slight film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009785185568034649 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634785175323486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009785185568034649, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009785185568034649, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1414509266614914, + 0.06921987235546112, + 0.0341731421649456, + 0.10424507409334183, + 0.04504633694887161, + 0.25793224573135376, + 0.0798562616109848, + 0.06819634139537811, + 0.09923312813043594, + 0.10064669698476791 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009785185568034649 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_2/index_tensor([8559, 8559])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_2/index_tensor([8559, 8559])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..54830c1d61e56861e22a405635de887316aaf3bd --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_2/index_tensor([8559, 8559])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, extreme wide shot surveys a vast, sun-scorched desert plain under the harsh, white-out light of the midday sun. The parched, cracked earth stretches to distant, hazy mountains, and the air shimmers with a fiery glow. Suddenly, the ground begins to buckle and crack violently, a spiderweb of matter ripping outward from its center. With immense, relentless force, a massive, rectangular monolith rises from the earth, its craggy, weathered granite surface betraying immense age. Its catastrophic ascent shatters the surrounding terrain, hurling chunks of rock and soil into the pale blue sky. A dense, roiling maelstrom of pulverized rock and ochre dust rapidly expands, tumbling upward and outward, engulfing the base of the slab and unleashing a powerful, apocalyptic, unleashing of primordial earthly forces.", + "seed": 15971, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_2/index_8559_seed_15971_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08234385831747204, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08234385831747204, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08234385831747204, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, low-angle, extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sun-scorched desert plain with cracked earth and distant hazy mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive, rectangular monolith with a craggy, weathered granite surface rise from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the rising monolith cause the ground to buckle, crack, and hurl chunks of rock and soil into the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a dense, roiling maelstrom of pulverized rock and ochre dust expand and engulf the base of the monolith?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3936602771282196 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.143660306930542 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3936602771282196, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3936602771282196, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2315637171268463, + 0.30432412028312683, + 0.02833411656320095, + 0.11333498358726501, + 0.03183053433895111, + 0.05277217924594879, + 0.0699601098895073, + 0.03710174933075905, + 0.09509530663490295, + 0.035683147609233856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3936602771282196 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, low-angle, extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sun-scorched desert plain with cracked earth and distant hazy mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive, rectangular monolith with a craggy, weathered granite surface rise from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the rising monolith cause the ground to buckle, crack, and hurl chunks of rock and soil into the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a dense, roiling maelstrom of pulverized rock and ochre dust expand and engulf the base of the monolith?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007650480140000582 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882650375366211 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007650480140000582, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007650480140000582, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2499210238456726, + 0.3124389052391052, + 0.13042311370372772, + 0.0939989686012268, + 0.03323312848806381, + 0.05498051270842552, + 0.038443733006715775, + 0.02456105500459671, + 0.034668661653995514, + 0.02733093872666359 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007650480140000582 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, low-angle, extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sun-scorched desert plain with cracked earth and distant hazy mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive, rectangular monolith with a craggy, weathered granite surface rise from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the rising monolith cause the ground to buckle, crack, and hurl chunks of rock and soil into the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a dense, roiling maelstrom of pulverized rock and ochre dust expand and engulf the base of the monolith?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006742109544575214 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006742000579834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006742109544575214, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006742109544575214, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09715177863836288, + 0.27192890644073486, + 0.319074809551239, + 0.0896395817399025, + 0.038873400539159775, + 0.03184594213962555, + 0.045853391289711, + 0.027108192443847656, + 0.026674477383494377, + 0.05184952914714813 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006742109544575214 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, low-angle, extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sun-scorched desert plain with cracked earth and distant hazy mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive, rectangular monolith with a craggy, weathered granite surface rise from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the rising monolith cause the ground to buckle, crack, and hurl chunks of rock and soil into the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a dense, roiling maelstrom of pulverized rock and ochre dust expand and engulf the base of the monolith?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001179595128633082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.7511796951293945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001179595128633082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001179595128633082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15705803036689758, + 0.29618337750434875, + 0.13315753638744354, + 0.06707347184419632, + 0.053686946630477905, + 0.04341033846139908, + 0.049988698214292526, + 0.07498414814472198, + 0.047117408365011215, + 0.07733999937772751 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001179595128633082 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, low-angle, extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sun-scorched desert plain with cracked earth and distant hazy mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive, rectangular monolith with a craggy, weathered granite surface rise from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the rising monolith cause the ground to buckle, crack, and hurl chunks of rock and soil into the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a dense, roiling maelstrom of pulverized rock and ochre dust expand and engulf the base of the monolith?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024868296459317207 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002486705780029 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024868296459317207, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024868296459317207, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12340646237134933, + 0.21448972821235657, + 0.0724814385175705, + 0.10106458514928818, + 0.02992835082113743, + 0.01732380874454975, + 0.03604447469115257, + 0.039553944021463394, + 0.06606637686491013, + 0.29964083433151245 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024868296459317207 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, extreme wide shot surveys a vast, sun-scorched desert plain under the harsh, white-out light of the midday sun. The parched, cracked earth stretches to distant, hazy mountains, and the air shimmers with a fiery glow. Suddenly, the ground begins to buckle and crack violently, a spiderweb of matter ripping outward from its center. With immense, relentless force, a massive, rectangular monolith rises from the earth, its craggy, weathered granite surface betraying immense age. Its catastrophic ascent shatters the surrounding terrain, hurling chunks of rock and soil into the pale blue sky. A dense, roiling maelstrom of pulverized rock and ochre dust rapidly expands, tumbling upward and outward, engulfing the base of the slab and unleashing a powerful, apocalyptic, unleashing of primordial earthly forces.", + "seed": 15972, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_2/index_8559_seed_15972_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.05299463293049485, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05299463293049485, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05299463293049485, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, low-angle, extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sun-scorched desert plain with cracked earth and distant hazy mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive, rectangular monolith with a craggy, weathered granite surface rise from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the rising monolith cause the ground to buckle, crack, and hurl chunks of rock and soil into the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a dense, roiling maelstrom of pulverized rock and ochre dust expand and engulf the base of the monolith?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2576846778392792 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5076847076416016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2576846778392792, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2576846778392792, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2621709406375885, + 0.04865013062953949, + 0.1521936058998108, + 0.0704968199133873, + 0.13451257348060608, + 0.05405237525701523, + 0.053815629333257675, + 0.027510324493050575, + 0.15397228300571442, + 0.04262540116906166 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2576846778392792 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, low-angle, extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sun-scorched desert plain with cracked earth and distant hazy mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive, rectangular monolith with a craggy, weathered granite surface rise from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the rising monolith cause the ground to buckle, crack, and hurl chunks of rock and soil into the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a dense, roiling maelstrom of pulverized rock and ochre dust expand and engulf the base of the monolith?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022038952447474003 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127203941345215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022038952447474003, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022038952447474003, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3247780501842499, + 0.10887186974287033, + 0.07760483026504517, + 0.151566743850708, + 0.07241339236497879, + 0.06228148937225342, + 0.10150020569562912, + 0.01866082474589348, + 0.053961873054504395, + 0.02836064249277115 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022038952447474003 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, low-angle, extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sun-scorched desert plain with cracked earth and distant hazy mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive, rectangular monolith with a craggy, weathered granite surface rise from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the rising monolith cause the ground to buckle, crack, and hurl chunks of rock and soil into the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a dense, roiling maelstrom of pulverized rock and ochre dust expand and engulf the base of the monolith?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021975908894091845 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127197742462158 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021975908894091845, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021975908894091845, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1667744517326355, + 0.032720524817705154, + 0.08129878342151642, + 0.044509220868349075, + 0.1235477477312088, + 0.07553696632385254, + 0.17751453816890717, + 0.0536552257835865, + 0.15785746276378632, + 0.08658503741025925 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021975908894091845 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, low-angle, extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sun-scorched desert plain with cracked earth and distant hazy mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive, rectangular monolith with a craggy, weathered granite surface rise from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the rising monolith cause the ground to buckle, crack, and hurl chunks of rock and soil into the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a dense, roiling maelstrom of pulverized rock and ochre dust expand and engulf the base of the monolith?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001177332829684019 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.7511773109436035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001177332829684019, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001177332829684019, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15984351933002472, + 0.060599539428949356, + 0.0939951092004776, + 0.18242867290973663, + 0.17671321332454681, + 0.10455386340618134, + 0.0801914781332016, + 0.02787480503320694, + 0.08857688307762146, + 0.02522294409573078 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001177332829684019 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, low-angle, extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sun-scorched desert plain with cracked earth and distant hazy mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive, rectangular monolith with a craggy, weathered granite surface rise from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the rising monolith cause the ground to buckle, crack, and hurl chunks of rock and soil into the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a dense, roiling maelstrom of pulverized rock and ochre dust expand and engulf the base of the monolith?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001709667849354446 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376709461212158 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001709667849354446, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001709667849354446, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11294573545455933, + 0.02950836904346943, + 0.06251433491706848, + 0.03992858901619911, + 0.11858619004487991, + 0.06581506878137589, + 0.3638744056224823, + 0.036254484206438065, + 0.09593630582094193, + 0.07463657110929489 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001709667849354446 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, extreme wide shot surveys a vast, sun-scorched desert plain under the harsh, white-out light of the midday sun. The parched, cracked earth stretches to distant, hazy mountains, and the air shimmers with a fiery glow. Suddenly, the ground begins to buckle and crack violently, a spiderweb of matter ripping outward from its center. With immense, relentless force, a massive, rectangular monolith rises from the earth, its craggy, weathered granite surface betraying immense age. Its catastrophic ascent shatters the surrounding terrain, hurling chunks of rock and soil into the pale blue sky. A dense, roiling maelstrom of pulverized rock and ochre dust rapidly expands, tumbling upward and outward, engulfing the base of the slab and unleashing a powerful, apocalyptic, unleashing of primordial earthly forces.", + "seed": 15973, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_2/index_8559_seed_15973_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.023200267087668182, + "vlm_logprob": -0.023200267087668182, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.023200267087668182, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, low-angle, extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sun-scorched desert plain with cracked earth and distant hazy mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive, rectangular monolith with a craggy, weathered granite surface rise from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the rising monolith cause the ground to buckle, crack, and hurl chunks of rock and soil into the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a dense, roiling maelstrom of pulverized rock and ochre dust expand and engulf the base of the monolith?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10747426748275757 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3574743270874023 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10747426748275757, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10747426748275757, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05902829021215439, + 0.06357349455356598, + 0.04802625998854637, + 0.037071239203214645, + 0.1211085394024849, + 0.16395196318626404, + 0.1372734010219574, + 0.09123855084180832, + 0.0704069510102272, + 0.20832137763500214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10747426748275757 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, low-angle, extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sun-scorched desert plain with cracked earth and distant hazy mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive, rectangular monolith with a craggy, weathered granite surface rise from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the rising monolith cause the ground to buckle, crack, and hurl chunks of rock and soil into the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a dense, roiling maelstrom of pulverized rock and ochre dust expand and engulf the base of the monolith?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001053969725035131 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876053810119629 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001053969725035131, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001053969725035131, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15538343787193298, + 0.20587652921676636, + 0.08659050613641739, + 0.0377797968685627, + 0.09399812668561935, + 0.05671536922454834, + 0.14279405772686005, + 0.07663159817457199, + 0.05737674981355667, + 0.08685387670993805 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001053969725035131 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, low-angle, extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sun-scorched desert plain with cracked earth and distant hazy mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive, rectangular monolith with a craggy, weathered granite surface rise from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the rising monolith cause the ground to buckle, crack, and hurl chunks of rock and soil into the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a dense, roiling maelstrom of pulverized rock and ochre dust expand and engulf the base of the monolith?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001046586548909545 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876046657562256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001046586548909545, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001046586548909545, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06470860540866852, + 0.16155311465263367, + 0.11275990307331085, + 0.05572324991226196, + 0.18986718356609344, + 0.08177156746387482, + 0.08846641331911087, + 0.08717760443687439, + 0.09555019438266754, + 0.06242218613624573 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001046586548909545 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, low-angle, extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sun-scorched desert plain with cracked earth and distant hazy mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive, rectangular monolith with a craggy, weathered granite surface rise from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the rising monolith cause the ground to buckle, crack, and hurl chunks of rock and soil into the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a dense, roiling maelstrom of pulverized rock and ochre dust expand and engulf the base of the monolith?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011794761521741748 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.7511796951293945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011794761521741748, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011794761521741748, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.060789525508880615, + 0.13874226808547974, + 0.18883104622364044, + 0.03802887722849846, + 0.1251915544271469, + 0.04898008704185486, + 0.13771061599254608, + 0.12438303232192993, + 0.07609520107507706, + 0.06124778836965561 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011794761521741748 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, low-angle, extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sun-scorched desert plain with cracked earth and distant hazy mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive, rectangular monolith with a craggy, weathered granite surface rise from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the rising monolith cause the ground to buckle, crack, and hurl chunks of rock and soil into the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a dense, roiling maelstrom of pulverized rock and ochre dust expand and engulf the base of the monolith?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005247035529464483 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255247116088867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005247035529464483, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005247035529464483, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04012008383870125, + 0.0975591316819191, + 0.1291404515504837, + 0.05315496772527695, + 0.038386743515729904, + 0.10411608219146729, + 0.13411493599414825, + 0.16232842206954956, + 0.11493504792451859, + 0.12614412605762482 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005247035529464483 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, extreme wide shot surveys a vast, sun-scorched desert plain under the harsh, white-out light of the midday sun. The parched, cracked earth stretches to distant, hazy mountains, and the air shimmers with a fiery glow. Suddenly, the ground begins to buckle and crack violently, a spiderweb of matter ripping outward from its center. With immense, relentless force, a massive, rectangular monolith rises from the earth, its craggy, weathered granite surface betraying immense age. Its catastrophic ascent shatters the surrounding terrain, hurling chunks of rock and soil into the pale blue sky. A dense, roiling maelstrom of pulverized rock and ochre dust rapidly expands, tumbling upward and outward, engulfing the base of the slab and unleashing a powerful, apocalyptic, unleashing of primordial earthly forces.", + "seed": 15974, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_2/index_8559_seed_15974_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03142511514015496, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03142511514015496, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.2000000238418576, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03142511514015496, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, low-angle, extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sun-scorched desert plain with cracked earth and distant hazy mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive, rectangular monolith with a craggy, weathered granite surface rise from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the rising monolith cause the ground to buckle, crack, and hurl chunks of rock and soil into the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a dense, roiling maelstrom of pulverized rock and ochre dust expand and engulf the base of the monolith?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14697352051734924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0219736099243164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14697352051734924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14697352051734924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.48410624265670776, + 0.16095271706581116, + 0.034049272537231445, + 0.056650690734386444, + 0.0473201759159565, + 0.028928549960255623, + 0.030627993866801262, + 0.05053778365254402, + 0.0790538638830185, + 0.02777274139225483 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14697352051734924 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, low-angle, extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sun-scorched desert plain with cracked earth and distant hazy mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive, rectangular monolith with a craggy, weathered granite surface rise from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the rising monolith cause the ground to buckle, crack, and hurl chunks of rock and soil into the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a dense, roiling maelstrom of pulverized rock and ochre dust expand and engulf the base of the monolith?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036241819616407156 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628623962402344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036241819616407156, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036241819616407156, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4136301279067993, + 0.3084230124950409, + 0.04523215442895889, + 0.026177460327744484, + 0.04107701778411865, + 0.027235032990574837, + 0.02457858808338642, + 0.054133180528879166, + 0.027438949793577194, + 0.032074473798274994 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036241819616407156 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, low-angle, extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sun-scorched desert plain with cracked earth and distant hazy mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive, rectangular monolith with a craggy, weathered granite surface rise from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the rising monolith cause the ground to buckle, crack, and hurl chunks of rock and soil into the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a dense, roiling maelstrom of pulverized rock and ochre dust expand and engulf the base of the monolith?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002821395406499505 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877821445465088 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002821395406499505, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002821395406499505, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13376353681087494, + 0.1986464112997055, + 0.07462889701128006, + 0.07858724147081375, + 0.1809714138507843, + 0.14238473773002625, + 0.03438248857855797, + 0.04580744355916977, + 0.05690339207649231, + 0.05392447113990784 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002821395406499505 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, low-angle, extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sun-scorched desert plain with cracked earth and distant hazy mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive, rectangular monolith with a craggy, weathered granite surface rise from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the rising monolith cause the ground to buckle, crack, and hurl chunks of rock and soil into the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a dense, roiling maelstrom of pulverized rock and ochre dust expand and engulf the base of the monolith?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015112657565623522 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501511096954346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015112657565623522, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015112657565623522, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2291078418493271, + 0.1031227856874466, + 0.1191575676202774, + 0.05400681868195534, + 0.061461806297302246, + 0.0774419978260994, + 0.04251713678240776, + 0.12652698159217834, + 0.08479346334934235, + 0.10186360031366348 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015112657565623522 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, low-angle, extreme wide shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sun-scorched desert plain with cracked earth and distant hazy mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive, rectangular monolith with a craggy, weathered granite surface rise from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the rising monolith cause the ground to buckle, crack, and hurl chunks of rock and soil into the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a dense, roiling maelstrom of pulverized rock and ochre dust expand and engulf the base of the monolith?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002195212058722973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127195358276367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002195212058722973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002195212058722973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1746808886528015, + 0.1402403563261032, + 0.07150644809007645, + 0.05980214849114418, + 0.05399201810359955, + 0.10282762348651886, + 0.06409956514835358, + 0.09874244779348373, + 0.05203024297952652, + 0.1820782721042633 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002195212058722973 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_3/index_tensor([4199, 4199])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_3/index_tensor([4199, 4199])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ab540dc19eab39a89807cf38f46245b4874fc77a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_3/index_tensor([4199, 4199])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, slightly high-angled medium shot focuses on a pristine white ceramic mold with a classic grooved ring design, resting on a warm, rustic wooden kitchen countertop. The mold's rim is filled with a vibrant, translucent red gel. Its surface, initially smooth and mirror-like, casts soft shadows and creates a subtle glow on the ceramic in the bright, natural daylight streaming in from the off-camera window. Suddenly, an invisible vibration travels through the countertop, causing the mold to begin a rapid, subtle sway. This movement immediately sets the gel into a mesmerizing vibration; it sways violently, its smooth surface catching the light as it rocks back and forth within the confines of the ceramic. Then, the vibrant movement gradually and gracefully subsides, the waves becoming smaller and slower, until the gel settles with a final, subtle ripple, returning to a perfect, glass-like stillness, creating an atmosphere of focused, almost scientific, quiet observation.", + "seed": 1326, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_3/index_4199_seed_1326_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08824706652667373, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08824706652667373, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08824706652667373, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pristine white ceramic mold with a classic grooved ring design resting on a warm, rustic wooden kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mold's rim filled with a vibrant, translucent red gel that is initially smooth and mirror-like?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gel undergo a sequence of rapid violent swaying followed by a gradual subsidence into a final subtle ripple before returning to stillness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright natural daylight streaming in from an off-camera window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014576021581888199 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.764575958251953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014576021581888199, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014576021581888199, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13709187507629395, + 0.04784582927823067, + 0.1227136105298996, + 0.03218035772442818, + 0.02575351484119892, + 0.19328796863555908, + 0.06628168374300003, + 0.16702395677566528, + 0.13192519545555115, + 0.07589595764875412 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014576021581888199 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pristine white ceramic mold with a classic grooved ring design resting on a warm, rustic wooden kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mold's rim filled with a vibrant, translucent red gel that is initially smooth and mirror-like?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gel undergo a sequence of rapid violent swaying followed by a gradual subsidence into a final subtle ripple before returning to stillness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright natural daylight streaming in from an off-camera window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015310243470594287 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.50153112411499 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015310243470594287, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015310243470594287, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06817768514156342, + 0.021231215447187424, + 0.13255402445793152, + 0.008626902475953102, + 0.029800081625580788, + 0.05438162013888359, + 0.014676844701170921, + 0.6067892909049988, + 0.044910967350006104, + 0.01885139010846615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015310243470594287 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pristine white ceramic mold with a classic grooved ring design resting on a warm, rustic wooden kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mold's rim filled with a vibrant, translucent red gel that is initially smooth and mirror-like?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gel undergo a sequence of rapid violent swaying followed by a gradual subsidence into a final subtle ripple before returning to stillness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright natural daylight streaming in from an off-camera window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012547126039862633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387547016143799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012547126039862633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012547126039862633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11468596756458282, + 0.061888426542282104, + 0.1506430059671402, + 0.06226950138807297, + 0.09293849766254425, + 0.06918172538280487, + 0.16025249660015106, + 0.14292611181735992, + 0.0724124014377594, + 0.07280188053846359 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012547126039862633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pristine white ceramic mold with a classic grooved ring design resting on a warm, rustic wooden kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mold's rim filled with a vibrant, translucent red gel that is initially smooth and mirror-like?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gel undergo a sequence of rapid violent swaying followed by a gradual subsidence into a final subtle ripple before returning to stillness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright natural daylight streaming in from an off-camera window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520833909511566 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502083420753479 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520833909511566, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520833909511566, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09855477511882782, + 0.0314079187810421, + 0.13991115987300873, + 0.035562559962272644, + 0.14154887199401855, + 0.18803882598876953, + 0.0821600928902626, + 0.16257460415363312, + 0.0684230625629425, + 0.05181814357638359 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520833909511566 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pristine white ceramic mold with a classic grooved ring design resting on a warm, rustic wooden kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mold's rim filled with a vibrant, translucent red gel that is initially smooth and mirror-like?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gel undergo a sequence of rapid violent swaying followed by a gradual subsidence into a final subtle ripple before returning to stillness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright natural daylight streaming in from an off-camera window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1604977697134018 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910497784614563 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1604977697134018, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1604977697134018, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1826009750366211, + 0.03351239487528801, + 0.046742960810661316, + 0.02678021974861622, + 0.056872956454753876, + 0.04530525207519531, + 0.046640634536743164, + 0.47393983602523804, + 0.055664509534835815, + 0.03194022551178932 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1604977697134018 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly high-angled medium shot focuses on a pristine white ceramic mold with a classic grooved ring design, resting on a warm, rustic wooden kitchen countertop. The mold's rim is filled with a vibrant, translucent red gel. Its surface, initially smooth and mirror-like, casts soft shadows and creates a subtle glow on the ceramic in the bright, natural daylight streaming in from the off-camera window. Suddenly, an invisible vibration travels through the countertop, causing the mold to begin a rapid, subtle sway. This movement immediately sets the gel into a mesmerizing vibration; it sways violently, its smooth surface catching the light as it rocks back and forth within the confines of the ceramic. Then, the vibrant movement gradually and gracefully subsides, the waves becoming smaller and slower, until the gel settles with a final, subtle ripple, returning to a perfect, glass-like stillness, creating an atmosphere of focused, almost scientific, quiet observation.", + "seed": 1327, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_3/index_4199_seed_1327_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.12911412133835257, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12911412133835257, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.2499999940395354, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12911412133835257, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pristine white ceramic mold with a classic grooved ring design resting on a warm, rustic wooden kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mold's rim filled with a vibrant, translucent red gel that is initially smooth and mirror-like?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gel undergo a sequence of rapid violent swaying followed by a gradual subsidence into a final subtle ripple before returning to stillness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright natural daylight streaming in from an off-camera window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02788914553821087 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7778892517089844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02788914553821087, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02788914553821087, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16731230914592743, + 0.44560351967811584, + 0.06192299351096153, + 0.04189709946513176, + 0.03026686981320381, + 0.04802687466144562, + 0.09813179820775986, + 0.0676242858171463, + 0.015796352177858353, + 0.023417914286255836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02788914553821087 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pristine white ceramic mold with a classic grooved ring design resting on a warm, rustic wooden kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mold's rim filled with a vibrant, translucent red gel that is initially smooth and mirror-like?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gel undergo a sequence of rapid violent swaying followed by a gradual subsidence into a final subtle ripple before returning to stillness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright natural daylight streaming in from an off-camera window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036452056374400854 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628645420074463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036452056374400854, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036452056374400854, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0593549944460392, + 0.5371385812759399, + 0.09378664195537567, + 0.0555536150932312, + 0.0277168657630682, + 0.04424791783094406, + 0.08135358989238739, + 0.039803121238946915, + 0.02018902823328972, + 0.04085565358400345 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036452056374400854 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pristine white ceramic mold with a classic grooved ring design resting on a warm, rustic wooden kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mold's rim filled with a vibrant, translucent red gel that is initially smooth and mirror-like?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gel undergo a sequence of rapid violent swaying followed by a gradual subsidence into a final subtle ripple before returning to stillness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright natural daylight streaming in from an off-camera window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012546890415251255 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387547016143799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012546890415251255, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012546890415251255, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19985058903694153, + 0.4183824062347412, + 0.09627682715654373, + 0.062019120901823044, + 0.030802734196186066, + 0.04052363708615303, + 0.056314337998628616, + 0.03871185705065727, + 0.024660570546984673, + 0.032457899302244186 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012546890415251255 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pristine white ceramic mold with a classic grooved ring design resting on a warm, rustic wooden kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mold's rim filled with a vibrant, translucent red gel that is initially smooth and mirror-like?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gel undergo a sequence of rapid violent swaying followed by a gradual subsidence into a final subtle ripple before returning to stillness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright natural daylight streaming in from an off-camera window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47427502274513245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742749929428101 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47427502274513245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.4999999701976776, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47427502274513245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26202908158302307, + 0.4046862721443176, + 0.040596503764390945, + 0.035669874399900436, + 0.0315411239862442, + 0.04148154705762863, + 0.08670948445796967, + 0.05407499149441719, + 0.02634260430932045, + 0.016868500038981438 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47427502274513245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pristine white ceramic mold with a classic grooved ring design resting on a warm, rustic wooden kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mold's rim filled with a vibrant, translucent red gel that is initially smooth and mirror-like?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gel undergo a sequence of rapid violent swaying followed by a gradual subsidence into a final subtle ripple before returning to stillness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright natural daylight streaming in from an off-camera window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12721434235572815 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1272144317626953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12721434235572815, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12721434235572815, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13819243013858795, + 0.37137293815612793, + 0.14168961346149445, + 0.08050354570150375, + 0.038273051381111145, + 0.03738964721560478, + 0.026303768157958984, + 0.12196081876754761, + 0.015516478568315506, + 0.028797736391425133 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12721434235572815 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly high-angled medium shot focuses on a pristine white ceramic mold with a classic grooved ring design, resting on a warm, rustic wooden kitchen countertop. The mold's rim is filled with a vibrant, translucent red gel. Its surface, initially smooth and mirror-like, casts soft shadows and creates a subtle glow on the ceramic in the bright, natural daylight streaming in from the off-camera window. Suddenly, an invisible vibration travels through the countertop, causing the mold to begin a rapid, subtle sway. This movement immediately sets the gel into a mesmerizing vibration; it sways violently, its smooth surface catching the light as it rocks back and forth within the confines of the ceramic. Then, the vibrant movement gradually and gracefully subsides, the waves becoming smaller and slower, until the gel settles with a final, subtle ripple, returning to a perfect, glass-like stillness, creating an atmosphere of focused, almost scientific, quiet observation.", + "seed": 1328, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_3/index_4199_seed_1328_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10025826785713435, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10025826785713435, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.949999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10025826785713435, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pristine white ceramic mold with a classic grooved ring design resting on a warm, rustic wooden kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mold's rim filled with a vibrant, translucent red gel that is initially smooth and mirror-like?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gel undergo a sequence of rapid violent swaying followed by a gradual subsidence into a final subtle ripple before returning to stillness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright natural daylight streaming in from an off-camera window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038312096148729324 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5383121967315674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038312096148729324, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038312096148729324, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2572626769542694, + 0.10798124969005585, + 0.08546730875968933, + 0.06396898627281189, + 0.07220647484064102, + 0.09625344723463058, + 0.06511122733354568, + 0.11514898389577866, + 0.07447538524866104, + 0.06212424859404564 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038312096148729324 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pristine white ceramic mold with a classic grooved ring design resting on a warm, rustic wooden kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mold's rim filled with a vibrant, translucent red gel that is initially smooth and mirror-like?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gel undergo a sequence of rapid violent swaying followed by a gradual subsidence into a final subtle ripple before returning to stillness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright natural daylight streaming in from an off-camera window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012587503530085087 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387587547302246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012587503530085087, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012587503530085087, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24209743738174438, + 0.15645532310009003, + 0.0789540708065033, + 0.06636883318424225, + 0.05172622576355934, + 0.12839096784591675, + 0.056027866899967194, + 0.06539060175418854, + 0.03905678167939186, + 0.11553195863962173 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012587503530085087 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pristine white ceramic mold with a classic grooved ring design resting on a warm, rustic wooden kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mold's rim filled with a vibrant, translucent red gel that is initially smooth and mirror-like?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gel undergo a sequence of rapid violent swaying followed by a gradual subsidence into a final subtle ripple before returning to stillness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright natural daylight streaming in from an off-camera window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018200531601905823 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018200397491455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018200531601905823, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018200531601905823, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12841297686100006, + 0.11317738145589828, + 0.06896720081567764, + 0.13917529582977295, + 0.06771642714738846, + 0.20853005349636078, + 0.1298120617866516, + 0.047468848526477814, + 0.06804068386554718, + 0.028699027374386787 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018200531601905823 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pristine white ceramic mold with a classic grooved ring design resting on a warm, rustic wooden kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mold's rim filled with a vibrant, translucent red gel that is initially smooth and mirror-like?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gel undergo a sequence of rapid violent swaying followed by a gradual subsidence into a final subtle ripple before returning to stillness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright natural daylight streaming in from an off-camera window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17988158762454987 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048815727233887 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17988158762454987, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17988158762454987, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14886689186096191, + 0.11120329797267914, + 0.09687194973230362, + 0.10141032934188843, + 0.09517023712396622, + 0.15831947326660156, + 0.10478198528289795, + 0.0751749649643898, + 0.07637582719326019, + 0.03182506933808327 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17988158762454987 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pristine white ceramic mold with a classic grooved ring design resting on a warm, rustic wooden kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mold's rim filled with a vibrant, translucent red gel that is initially smooth and mirror-like?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gel undergo a sequence of rapid violent swaying followed by a gradual subsidence into a final subtle ripple before returning to stillness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright natural daylight streaming in from an off-camera window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2523096203804016 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5023095607757568 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2523096203804016, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2523096203804016, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2603791058063507, + 0.10781111568212509, + 0.04310065880417824, + 0.0577646903693676, + 0.07266644388437271, + 0.32188844680786133, + 0.051283806562423706, + 0.02382522076368332, + 0.03794976323843002, + 0.023330776020884514 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2523096203804016 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly high-angled medium shot focuses on a pristine white ceramic mold with a classic grooved ring design, resting on a warm, rustic wooden kitchen countertop. The mold's rim is filled with a vibrant, translucent red gel. Its surface, initially smooth and mirror-like, casts soft shadows and creates a subtle glow on the ceramic in the bright, natural daylight streaming in from the off-camera window. Suddenly, an invisible vibration travels through the countertop, causing the mold to begin a rapid, subtle sway. This movement immediately sets the gel into a mesmerizing vibration; it sways violently, its smooth surface catching the light as it rocks back and forth within the confines of the ceramic. Then, the vibrant movement gradually and gracefully subsides, the waves becoming smaller and slower, until the gel settles with a final, subtle ripple, returning to a perfect, glass-like stillness, creating an atmosphere of focused, almost scientific, quiet observation.", + "seed": 1329, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_3/index_4199_seed_1329_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.09085190994665027, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09085190994665027, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.225000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09085190994665027, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pristine white ceramic mold with a classic grooved ring design resting on a warm, rustic wooden kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mold's rim filled with a vibrant, translucent red gel that is initially smooth and mirror-like?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gel undergo a sequence of rapid violent swaying followed by a gradual subsidence into a final subtle ripple before returning to stillness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright natural daylight streaming in from an off-camera window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02013610489666462 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.395135879516602 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02013610489666462, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02013610489666462, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20178702473640442, + 0.34148871898651123, + 0.0641837790608406, + 0.08224373310804367, + 0.04014724865555763, + 0.034098394215106964, + 0.04935326427221298, + 0.05970480293035507, + 0.07809752970933914, + 0.048895545303821564 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02013610489666462 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pristine white ceramic mold with a classic grooved ring design resting on a warm, rustic wooden kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mold's rim filled with a vibrant, translucent red gel that is initially smooth and mirror-like?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gel undergo a sequence of rapid violent swaying followed by a gradual subsidence into a final subtle ripple before returning to stillness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright natural daylight streaming in from an off-camera window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005277037154883146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255277156829834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005277037154883146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005277037154883146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20060130953788757, + 0.3294965922832489, + 0.04909787327051163, + 0.07308570295572281, + 0.09185746312141418, + 0.11421658098697662, + 0.05071775242686272, + 0.03145372122526169, + 0.009778831154108047, + 0.04969412460923195 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005277037154883146 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pristine white ceramic mold with a classic grooved ring design resting on a warm, rustic wooden kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mold's rim filled with a vibrant, translucent red gel that is initially smooth and mirror-like?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gel undergo a sequence of rapid violent swaying followed by a gradual subsidence into a final subtle ripple before returning to stillness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright natural daylight streaming in from an off-camera window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033712852746248245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408712863922119 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033712852746248245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033712852746248245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24516496062278748, + 0.30435043573379517, + 0.11572962254285812, + 0.06926552206277847, + 0.052433885633945465, + 0.0661441832780838, + 0.07745920121669769, + 0.02995954267680645, + 0.017153870314359665, + 0.022338826209306717 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033712852746248245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pristine white ceramic mold with a classic grooved ring design resting on a warm, rustic wooden kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mold's rim filled with a vibrant, translucent red gel that is initially smooth and mirror-like?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gel undergo a sequence of rapid violent swaying followed by a gradual subsidence into a final subtle ripple before returning to stillness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright natural daylight streaming in from an off-camera window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25207775831222534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020778179168701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25207775831222534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25207775831222534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2785536050796509, + 0.404893159866333, + 0.06089503690600395, + 0.02298833802342415, + 0.044299378991127014, + 0.04461180046200752, + 0.043815433979034424, + 0.04742036387324333, + 0.01730707474052906, + 0.03521579131484032 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25207775831222534 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pristine white ceramic mold with a classic grooved ring design resting on a warm, rustic wooden kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the mold's rim filled with a vibrant, translucent red gel that is initially smooth and mirror-like?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gel undergo a sequence of rapid violent swaying followed by a gradual subsidence into a final subtle ripple before returning to stillness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by bright natural daylight streaming in from an off-camera window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14305579662322998 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0180559158325195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14305579662322998, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14305579662322998, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4397655427455902, + 0.11641880869865417, + 0.08057516813278198, + 0.05748223140835762, + 0.12130553275346756, + 0.05302911624312401, + 0.025659220293164253, + 0.03860490769147873, + 0.023520056158304214, + 0.0436394177377224 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14305579662322998 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_4/index_tensor([5350, 5350])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_4/index_tensor([5350, 5350])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9ace9be62fcf3f2434f061fd2ca8877717729e72 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_4/index_tensor([5350, 5350])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, slightly low-angle, extreme wide shot captures a breathtaking panorama rendered in a beautiful watercolor animation style. A lone high school girl, resembling Ichika Miyamizu with her short, dark brown bob hairstyle, stands in quiet contemplation on a windswept hilltop amidst the grass. Clad in her dark school uniform, she forms a delicate silhouette against the magnificent celestial backdrop. Above her, the aurora borealis dances across the vast, star-studded night sky, forming a vibrant, shimmering ribbon of green and purple. These celestial lights gracefully ripple and swirl, their brilliant colors softly seeping into the sky's deep indigo canvas, creating diffused painterly edges, as if wet paint were spreading across textured paper. The otherworldly glow of the aurora casts a cool, magical glow on the mountaintop and over the girl's shoulders, creating a profound atmosphere of quiet wonder and solitary awe. A gentle, cool breeze gently ruffles her hair and the hem of her skirt, the only subtle movement on the ground, contrasting sharply with the dynamic, silent scene unfolding in the sky.", + "seed": 1406, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_4/index_5350_seed_1406_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.25183105864562094, + "vlm_logprob": -0.25183105864562094, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.25183105864562094, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as an extreme wide shot capturing a panoramic view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a watercolor animation with diffused painterly edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a high school girl with short dark brown bob hair standing on a windswept hilltop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a night sky featuring the aurora borealis in green and purple colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of the girl's hair and skirt due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9020330905914307 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5270330905914307 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9020330905914307, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9020330905914307, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34664642810821533, + 0.04560232162475586, + 0.02244148775935173, + 0.04167567193508148, + 0.041196294128894806, + 0.027263442054390907, + 0.08246694505214691, + 0.040219902992248535, + 0.3329218924045563, + 0.019565530121326447 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9020330905914307 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as an extreme wide shot capturing a panoramic view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a watercolor animation with diffused painterly edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a high school girl with short dark brown bob hair standing on a windswept hilltop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a night sky featuring the aurora borealis in green and purple colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of the girl's hair and skirt due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17990568280220032 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804905652999878 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17990568280220032, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17990568280220032, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12840674817562103, + 0.09411612153053284, + 0.0878036692738533, + 0.06118689849972725, + 0.060805127024650574, + 0.22900372743606567, + 0.08171889185905457, + 0.04205213859677315, + 0.17596293985843658, + 0.03894371539354324 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17990568280220032 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as an extreme wide shot capturing a panoramic view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a watercolor animation with diffused painterly edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a high school girl with short dark brown bob hair standing on a windswept hilltop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a night sky featuring the aurora borealis in green and purple colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of the girl's hair and skirt due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11296705901622772 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237967014312744 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11296705901622772, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11296705901622772, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16400694847106934, + 0.04300934821367264, + 0.03199891746044159, + 0.06208757311105728, + 0.04185543209314346, + 0.04926149547100067, + 0.060054242610931396, + 0.028627581894397736, + 0.466562420129776, + 0.05253598466515541 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11296705901622772 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as an extreme wide shot capturing a panoramic view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a watercolor animation with diffused painterly edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a high school girl with short dark brown bob hair standing on a windswept hilltop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a night sky featuring the aurora borealis in green and purple colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of the girl's hair and skirt due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021975908894091845 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127197742462158 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021975908894091845, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021975908894091845, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16402386128902435, + 0.10278182476758957, + 0.12040509283542633, + 0.06187169626355171, + 0.1186881959438324, + 0.0759647935628891, + 0.026233866810798645, + 0.0436418280005455, + 0.1467123180627823, + 0.13967658579349518 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021975908894091845 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as an extreme wide shot capturing a panoramic view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a watercolor animation with diffused painterly edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a high school girl with short dark brown bob hair standing on a windswept hilltop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a night sky featuring the aurora borealis in green and purple colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of the girl's hair and skirt due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205186992883682 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812051773071289 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205186992883682, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205186992883682, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21831516921520233, + 0.0907210037112236, + 0.03422990068793297, + 0.07632621377706528, + 0.07358760386705399, + 0.08322104811668396, + 0.18422840535640717, + 0.07630857080221176, + 0.08773719519376755, + 0.0753248929977417 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205186992883682 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly low-angle, extreme wide shot captures a breathtaking panorama rendered in a beautiful watercolor animation style. A lone high school girl, resembling Ichika Miyamizu with her short, dark brown bob hairstyle, stands in quiet contemplation on a windswept hilltop amidst the grass. Clad in her dark school uniform, she forms a delicate silhouette against the magnificent celestial backdrop. Above her, the aurora borealis dances across the vast, star-studded night sky, forming a vibrant, shimmering ribbon of green and purple. These celestial lights gracefully ripple and swirl, their brilliant colors softly seeping into the sky's deep indigo canvas, creating diffused painterly edges, as if wet paint were spreading across textured paper. The otherworldly glow of the aurora casts a cool, magical glow on the mountaintop and over the girl's shoulders, creating a profound atmosphere of quiet wonder and solitary awe. A gentle, cool breeze gently ruffles her hair and the hem of her skirt, the only subtle movement on the ground, contrasting sharply with the dynamic, silent scene unfolding in the sky.", + "seed": 1407, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_4/index_5350_seed_1407_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.1080180914606899, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1080180914606899, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1080180914606899, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as an extreme wide shot capturing a panoramic view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a watercolor animation with diffused painterly edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a high school girl with short dark brown bob hair standing on a windswept hilltop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a night sky featuring the aurora borealis in green and purple colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of the girl's hair and skirt due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2594718933105469 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5094718933105469 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2594718933105469, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2594718933105469, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5221635103225708, + 0.11870788037776947, + 0.03909475356340408, + 0.036053840070962906, + 0.023042822256684303, + 0.056838832795619965, + 0.03713897243142128, + 0.08211909234523773, + 0.05189415067434311, + 0.03294612839818001 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2594718933105469 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as an extreme wide shot capturing a panoramic view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a watercolor animation with diffused painterly edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a high school girl with short dark brown bob hair standing on a windswept hilltop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a night sky featuring the aurora borealis in green and purple colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of the girl's hair and skirt due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054968852549791336 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.92996883392334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054968852549791336, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054968852549791336, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6347449421882629, + 0.05191507935523987, + 0.03452526032924652, + 0.040171217173337936, + 0.014782349579036236, + 0.04490906745195389, + 0.06931447237730026, + 0.05349103361368179, + 0.028007246553897858, + 0.028139272704720497 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054968852549791336 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as an extreme wide shot capturing a panoramic view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a watercolor animation with diffused painterly edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a high school girl with short dark brown bob hair standing on a windswept hilltop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a night sky featuring the aurora borealis in green and purple colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of the girl's hair and skirt due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16040070354938507 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104007482528687 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16040070354938507, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16040070354938507, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6402064561843872, + 0.05749532952904701, + 0.09114307910203934, + 0.025348002091050148, + 0.019173404201865196, + 0.06833868473768234, + 0.022956497967243195, + 0.03108890913426876, + 0.024049513041973114, + 0.02020009607076645 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16040070354938507 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as an extreme wide shot capturing a panoramic view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a watercolor animation with diffused painterly edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a high school girl with short dark brown bob hair standing on a windswept hilltop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a night sky featuring the aurora borealis in green and purple colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of the girl's hair and skirt due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003194113029167056 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753194332122803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003194113029167056, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003194113029167056, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.341797411441803, + 0.05812271311879158, + 0.04765743017196655, + 0.05862131714820862, + 0.0275082029402256, + 0.03186533600091934, + 0.058534372597932816, + 0.1440270096063614, + 0.07607437670230865, + 0.15579186379909515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003194113029167056 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as an extreme wide shot capturing a panoramic view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a watercolor animation with diffused painterly edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a high school girl with short dark brown bob hair standing on a windswept hilltop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a night sky featuring the aurora borealis in green and purple colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of the girl's hair and skirt due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062054894864559174 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120548725128174 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062054894864559174, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062054894864559174, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.53788161277771, + 0.06192618981003761, + 0.10056713968515396, + 0.03010137379169464, + 0.04698625206947327, + 0.027743631973862648, + 0.07769577205181122, + 0.051000505685806274, + 0.03368751332163811, + 0.03240996226668358 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062054894864559174 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly low-angle, extreme wide shot captures a breathtaking panorama rendered in a beautiful watercolor animation style. A lone high school girl, resembling Ichika Miyamizu with her short, dark brown bob hairstyle, stands in quiet contemplation on a windswept hilltop amidst the grass. Clad in her dark school uniform, she forms a delicate silhouette against the magnificent celestial backdrop. Above her, the aurora borealis dances across the vast, star-studded night sky, forming a vibrant, shimmering ribbon of green and purple. These celestial lights gracefully ripple and swirl, their brilliant colors softly seeping into the sky's deep indigo canvas, creating diffused painterly edges, as if wet paint were spreading across textured paper. The otherworldly glow of the aurora casts a cool, magical glow on the mountaintop and over the girl's shoulders, creating a profound atmosphere of quiet wonder and solitary awe. A gentle, cool breeze gently ruffles her hair and the hem of her skirt, the only subtle movement on the ground, contrasting sharply with the dynamic, silent scene unfolding in the sky.", + "seed": 1408, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_4/index_5350_seed_1408_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.45303024519234897, + "vlm_logprob": -0.45303024519234897, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.45303024519234897, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as an extreme wide shot capturing a panoramic view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a watercolor animation with diffused painterly edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a high school girl with short dark brown bob hair standing on a windswept hilltop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a night sky featuring the aurora borealis in green and purple colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of the girl's hair and skirt due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0199525356292725 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14495247602462769 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.0199525356292725, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -2.0199525356292725, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21642276644706726, + 0.11255586892366409, + 0.0872919112443924, + 0.06163056567311287, + 0.09772827476263046, + 0.02472456730902195, + 0.06071985512971878, + 0.2550201714038849, + 0.0394362211227417, + 0.044469863176345825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.0199525356292725 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as an extreme wide shot capturing a panoramic view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a watercolor animation with diffused painterly edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a high school girl with short dark brown bob hair standing on a windswept hilltop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a night sky featuring the aurora borealis in green and purple colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of the girl's hair and skirt due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0700593814253807 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695059299468994 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0700593814253807, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0700593814253807, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22872425615787506, + 0.2609621584415436, + 0.053284112364053726, + 0.044587843120098114, + 0.08759621530771255, + 0.06567893922328949, + 0.08830787241458893, + 0.0927952229976654, + 0.04027741774916649, + 0.03778592124581337 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0700593814253807 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as an extreme wide shot capturing a panoramic view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a watercolor animation with diffused painterly edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a high school girl with short dark brown bob hair standing on a windswept hilltop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a night sky featuring the aurora borealis in green and purple colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of the girl's hair and skirt due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14284923672676086 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178492069244385 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14284923672676086, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14284923672676086, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13685491681098938, + 0.15306878089904785, + 0.03777720034122467, + 0.04842749983072281, + 0.11812013387680054, + 0.13681504130363464, + 0.03531649336218834, + 0.24019719660282135, + 0.06096652150154114, + 0.03245621919631958 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14284923672676086 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as an extreme wide shot capturing a panoramic view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a watercolor animation with diffused painterly edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a high school girl with short dark brown bob hair standing on a windswept hilltop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a night sky featuring the aurora borealis in green and purple colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of the girl's hair and skirt due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002489089034497738 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.00248908996582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002489089034497738, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002489089034497738, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17884619534015656, + 0.2802024781703949, + 0.06331559270620346, + 0.0463847778737545, + 0.09393518418073654, + 0.03881000727415085, + 0.04763166978955269, + 0.2026558518409729, + 0.021343836560845375, + 0.026874395087361336 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002489089034497738 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as an extreme wide shot capturing a panoramic view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a watercolor animation with diffused painterly edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a high school girl with short dark brown bob hair standing on a windswept hilltop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a night sky featuring the aurora borealis in green and purple colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of the girl's hair and skirt due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029800983145833015 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298008918762207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029800983145833015, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029800983145833015, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1152648851275444, + 0.21334443986415863, + 0.0775277316570282, + 0.0481741800904274, + 0.05360561981797218, + 0.03411644697189331, + 0.08018821477890015, + 0.2781352400779724, + 0.05308453366160393, + 0.046558789908885956 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029800983145833015 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly low-angle, extreme wide shot captures a breathtaking panorama rendered in a beautiful watercolor animation style. A lone high school girl, resembling Ichika Miyamizu with her short, dark brown bob hairstyle, stands in quiet contemplation on a windswept hilltop amidst the grass. Clad in her dark school uniform, she forms a delicate silhouette against the magnificent celestial backdrop. Above her, the aurora borealis dances across the vast, star-studded night sky, forming a vibrant, shimmering ribbon of green and purple. These celestial lights gracefully ripple and swirl, their brilliant colors softly seeping into the sky's deep indigo canvas, creating diffused painterly edges, as if wet paint were spreading across textured paper. The otherworldly glow of the aurora casts a cool, magical glow on the mountaintop and over the girl's shoulders, creating a profound atmosphere of quiet wonder and solitary awe. A gentle, cool breeze gently ruffles her hair and the hem of her skirt, the only subtle movement on the ground, contrasting sharply with the dynamic, silent scene unfolding in the sky.", + "seed": 1409, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_4/index_5350_seed_1409_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.17627486097626388, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17627486097626388, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17627486097626388, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as an extreme wide shot capturing a panoramic view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a watercolor animation with diffused painterly edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a high school girl with short dark brown bob hair standing on a windswept hilltop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a night sky featuring the aurora borealis in green and purple colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of the girl's hair and skirt due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6435004472732544 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7685004472732544 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6435004472732544, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6435004472732544, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15973077714443207, + 0.32537373900413513, + 0.15009459853172302, + 0.0977902039885521, + 0.041613560169935226, + 0.010873954743146896, + 0.042400624603033066, + 0.07243070006370544, + 0.06198282167315483, + 0.037708960473537445 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6435004472732544 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as an extreme wide shot capturing a panoramic view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a watercolor animation with diffused painterly edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a high school girl with short dark brown bob hair standing on a windswept hilltop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a night sky featuring the aurora borealis in green and purple colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of the girl's hair and skirt due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059982344508171 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895599842071533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059982344508171, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059982344508171, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17188915610313416, + 0.28164252638816833, + 0.04614734649658203, + 0.042123716324567795, + 0.04237879440188408, + 0.06065730005502701, + 0.09472975879907608, + 0.07978744804859161, + 0.16468103229999542, + 0.015962978824973106 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059982344508171 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as an extreme wide shot capturing a panoramic view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a watercolor animation with diffused painterly edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a high school girl with short dark brown bob hair standing on a windswept hilltop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a night sky featuring the aurora borealis in green and purple colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of the girl's hair and skirt due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16038262844085693 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910382628440857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16038262844085693, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16038262844085693, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19246357679367065, + 0.15192900598049164, + 0.05159452557563782, + 0.06218016520142555, + 0.1355409473180771, + 0.03613744676113129, + 0.050696901977062225, + 0.14850538969039917, + 0.10359916090965271, + 0.06735288351774216 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16038262844085693 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as an extreme wide shot capturing a panoramic view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a watercolor animation with diffused painterly edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a high school girl with short dark brown bob hair standing on a windswept hilltop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a night sky featuring the aurora borealis in green and purple colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of the girl's hair and skirt due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019401551689952612 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.2519402503967285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019401551689952612, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019401551689952612, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13143126666545868, + 0.1790957748889923, + 0.09859338402748108, + 0.1821940541267395, + 0.03333081305027008, + 0.028074853122234344, + 0.08276975899934769, + 0.11412299424409866, + 0.08730891346931458, + 0.06307820230722427 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019401551689952612 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as an extreme wide shot capturing a panoramic view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a watercolor animation with diffused painterly edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a high school girl with short dark brown bob hair standing on a windswept hilltop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a night sky featuring the aurora borealis in green and purple colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there visible movement of the girl's hair and skirt due to a gentle breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054951250553131104 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299511909484863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054951250553131104, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054951250553131104, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1335134208202362, + 0.1550241857767105, + 0.08602972328662872, + 0.0403946153819561, + 0.08892638236284256, + 0.06359758228063583, + 0.07259323447942734, + 0.05653189867734909, + 0.1494128406047821, + 0.15397612750530243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054951250553131104 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_5/index_tensor([1245, 1245])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_5/index_tensor([1245, 1245])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f0c88c61e46acfb86aead6b08e9a64d9babdfdcf --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_5/index_tensor([1245, 1245])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "powerful, low-angle, sweeping shot plunges us into a world of powerful, hand-drawn sketches constructed entirely of charcoal and graphite. Amidst this abstract waterscape of wild brushstrokes and smudged ink, two butterfly carp, each with enormous, silky fins, engage in a fierce duel. One is pitch black, its scales outlined with fine crosshatching; the other is pure white, its bright areas highlighted by bold white space, creating a stark visual contrast. The camera follows them in a tense, rotating pattern, capturing every moment as they chase, spiral, and collide. Their vast, flowing fins trace graceful yet deadly arcs with each swing, and every violent collision stirs up splashes of ink and broken lines across the frame, as if their struggle is composing the surrounding environment in real time. The high-contrast light and shadow effects are extremely emphasized through heavy shadows and sharp white spaces. There is not a trace of superfluous color in the entire scene, only the pure confrontation of black, white and gray, creating a dynamic beauty that is both tense and magnificent as well as full of primitive explosive power.", + "seed": 5035, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_5/index_1245_seed_5035_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.037282897438853976, + "vlm_logprob": -0.037282897438853976, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.037282897438853976, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the two main subjects depicted as butterfly carp with enormous, silky fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one carp pitch black with fine crosshatching outlines and the other pure white with bold white space highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene constructed entirely of charcoal and graphite sketches with an abstract waterscape background of wild brushstrokes and smudged ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the carp engage in a fierce duel involving chasing, spiraling, and colliding while stirring up splashes of ink and broken lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the subjects in a tense, rotating pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11346523463726044 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2384653091430664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11346523463726044, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11346523463726044, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2254716008901596, + 0.05005905032157898, + 0.10959146916866302, + 0.029298989102244377, + 0.11446088552474976, + 0.06703851372003555, + 0.14982110261917114, + 0.027956262230873108, + 0.1951116919517517, + 0.03119034878909588 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11346523463726044 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the two main subjects depicted as butterfly carp with enormous, silky fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one carp pitch black with fine crosshatching outlines and the other pure white with bold white space highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene constructed entirely of charcoal and graphite sketches with an abstract waterscape background of wild brushstrokes and smudged ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the carp engage in a fierce duel involving chasing, spiraling, and colliding while stirring up splashes of ink and broken lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the subjects in a tense, rotating pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007639360148459673 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882639408111572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007639360148459673, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007639360148459673, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13422457873821259, + 0.06142628565430641, + 0.08592747151851654, + 0.07328367978334427, + 0.16418597102165222, + 0.04148171842098236, + 0.2522723376750946, + 0.031210241839289665, + 0.11092087626457214, + 0.045066919177770615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007639360148459673 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the two main subjects depicted as butterfly carp with enormous, silky fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one carp pitch black with fine crosshatching outlines and the other pure white with bold white space highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene constructed entirely of charcoal and graphite sketches with an abstract waterscape background of wild brushstrokes and smudged ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the carp engage in a fierce duel involving chasing, spiraling, and colliding while stirring up splashes of ink and broken lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the subjects in a tense, rotating pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018178289756178856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018178462982178 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018178289756178856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018178289756178856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1377951055765152, + 0.11456335335969925, + 0.08230450749397278, + 0.07152391970157623, + 0.057293906807899475, + 0.044641200453042984, + 0.35482028126716614, + 0.03374188393354416, + 0.07430047541856766, + 0.029015369713306427 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018178289756178856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the two main subjects depicted as butterfly carp with enormous, silky fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one carp pitch black with fine crosshatching outlines and the other pure white with bold white space highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene constructed entirely of charcoal and graphite sketches with an abstract waterscape background of wild brushstrokes and smudged ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the carp engage in a fierce duel involving chasing, spiraling, and colliding while stirring up splashes of ink and broken lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the subjects in a tense, rotating pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004092295654118061 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504092216491699 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004092295654118061, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004092295654118061, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18523655831813812, + 0.04372307285666466, + 0.11692360788583755, + 0.03526252135634422, + 0.16782380640506744, + 0.06250861287117004, + 0.16704340279102325, + 0.017864538356661797, + 0.17959554493427277, + 0.024018364027142525 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004092295654118061 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the two main subjects depicted as butterfly carp with enormous, silky fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one carp pitch black with fine crosshatching outlines and the other pure white with bold white space highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene constructed entirely of charcoal and graphite sketches with an abstract waterscape background of wild brushstrokes and smudged ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the carp engage in a fierce duel involving chasing, spiraling, and colliding while stirring up splashes of ink and broken lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the subjects in a tense, rotating pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04303930699825287 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168039321899414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04303930699825287, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04303930699825287, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12436669319868088, + 0.0695388987660408, + 0.1115955263376236, + 0.07992637157440186, + 0.06928803026676178, + 0.06747491657733917, + 0.1213880181312561, + 0.02937261387705803, + 0.29154306650161743, + 0.03550586476922035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04303930699825287 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful, low-angle, sweeping shot plunges us into a world of powerful, hand-drawn sketches constructed entirely of charcoal and graphite. Amidst this abstract waterscape of wild brushstrokes and smudged ink, two butterfly carp, each with enormous, silky fins, engage in a fierce duel. One is pitch black, its scales outlined with fine crosshatching; the other is pure white, its bright areas highlighted by bold white space, creating a stark visual contrast. The camera follows them in a tense, rotating pattern, capturing every moment as they chase, spiral, and collide. Their vast, flowing fins trace graceful yet deadly arcs with each swing, and every violent collision stirs up splashes of ink and broken lines across the frame, as if their struggle is composing the surrounding environment in real time. The high-contrast light and shadow effects are extremely emphasized through heavy shadows and sharp white spaces. There is not a trace of superfluous color in the entire scene, only the pure confrontation of black, white and gray, creating a dynamic beauty that is both tense and magnificent as well as full of primitive explosive power.", + "seed": 5036, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_5/index_1245_seed_5036_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0233582035638392, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0233582035638392, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0233582035638392, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the two main subjects depicted as butterfly carp with enormous, silky fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one carp pitch black with fine crosshatching outlines and the other pure white with bold white space highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene constructed entirely of charcoal and graphite sketches with an abstract waterscape background of wild brushstrokes and smudged ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the carp engage in a fierce duel involving chasing, spiraling, and colliding while stirring up splashes of ink and broken lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the subjects in a tense, rotating pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07047642022371292 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695476531982422 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07047642022371292, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07047642022371292, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14184466004371643, + 0.0940522626042366, + 0.21866923570632935, + 0.06736105680465698, + 0.026290427893400192, + 0.08455648273229599, + 0.1922481209039688, + 0.08710353821516037, + 0.04783079773187637, + 0.04004339873790741 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07047642022371292 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the two main subjects depicted as butterfly carp with enormous, silky fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one carp pitch black with fine crosshatching outlines and the other pure white with bold white space highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene constructed entirely of charcoal and graphite sketches with an abstract waterscape background of wild brushstrokes and smudged ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the carp engage in a fierce duel involving chasing, spiraling, and colliding while stirring up splashes of ink and broken lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the subjects in a tense, rotating pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005956161767244339 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130956172943115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005956161767244339, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005956161767244339, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24147899448871613, + 0.14936913549900055, + 0.1472155749797821, + 0.0752483531832695, + 0.01846458949148655, + 0.06760599464178085, + 0.16335821151733398, + 0.08222775161266327, + 0.03222094476222992, + 0.022810442373156548 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005956161767244339 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the two main subjects depicted as butterfly carp with enormous, silky fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one carp pitch black with fine crosshatching outlines and the other pure white with bold white space highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene constructed entirely of charcoal and graphite sketches with an abstract waterscape background of wild brushstrokes and smudged ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the carp engage in a fierce duel involving chasing, spiraling, and colliding while stirring up splashes of ink and broken lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the subjects in a tense, rotating pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005943363532423973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130943298339844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005943363532423973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005943363532423973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19427135586738586, + 0.09696519374847412, + 0.055476732552051544, + 0.11028029024600983, + 0.046561431139707565, + 0.28369441628456116, + 0.08031976968050003, + 0.05264193192124367, + 0.05170673504471779, + 0.028082191944122314 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005943363532423973 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the two main subjects depicted as butterfly carp with enormous, silky fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one carp pitch black with fine crosshatching outlines and the other pure white with bold white space highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene constructed entirely of charcoal and graphite sketches with an abstract waterscape background of wild brushstrokes and smudged ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the carp engage in a fierce duel involving chasing, spiraling, and colliding while stirring up splashes of ink and broken lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the subjects in a tense, rotating pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004633760545402765 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379633903503418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004633760545402765, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004633760545402765, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24309030175209045, + 0.05589224025607109, + 0.058270830661058426, + 0.09517090767621994, + 0.05833113193511963, + 0.13108259439468384, + 0.2065054178237915, + 0.05849715322256088, + 0.06577563285827637, + 0.027383776381611824 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004633760545402765 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the two main subjects depicted as butterfly carp with enormous, silky fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one carp pitch black with fine crosshatching outlines and the other pure white with bold white space highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene constructed entirely of charcoal and graphite sketches with an abstract waterscape background of wild brushstrokes and smudged ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the carp engage in a fierce duel involving chasing, spiraling, and colliding while stirring up splashes of ink and broken lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the subjects in a tense, rotating pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029781311750411987 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297813415527344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029781311750411987, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029781311750411987, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17556895315647125, + 0.0379723384976387, + 0.05645991489291191, + 0.059733159840106964, + 0.032996490597724915, + 0.29140686988830566, + 0.13765999674797058, + 0.11453083157539368, + 0.07412398606538773, + 0.01954742707312107 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029781311750411987 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful, low-angle, sweeping shot plunges us into a world of powerful, hand-drawn sketches constructed entirely of charcoal and graphite. Amidst this abstract waterscape of wild brushstrokes and smudged ink, two butterfly carp, each with enormous, silky fins, engage in a fierce duel. One is pitch black, its scales outlined with fine crosshatching; the other is pure white, its bright areas highlighted by bold white space, creating a stark visual contrast. The camera follows them in a tense, rotating pattern, capturing every moment as they chase, spiral, and collide. Their vast, flowing fins trace graceful yet deadly arcs with each swing, and every violent collision stirs up splashes of ink and broken lines across the frame, as if their struggle is composing the surrounding environment in real time. The high-contrast light and shadow effects are extremely emphasized through heavy shadows and sharp white spaces. There is not a trace of superfluous color in the entire scene, only the pure confrontation of black, white and gray, creating a dynamic beauty that is both tense and magnificent as well as full of primitive explosive power.", + "seed": 5037, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_5/index_1245_seed_5037_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.021106982557103037, + "vlm_logprob": -0.021106982557103037, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.021106982557103037, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the two main subjects depicted as butterfly carp with enormous, silky fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one carp pitch black with fine crosshatching outlines and the other pure white with bold white space highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene constructed entirely of charcoal and graphite sketches with an abstract waterscape background of wild brushstrokes and smudged ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the carp engage in a fierce duel involving chasing, spiraling, and colliding while stirring up splashes of ink and broken lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the subjects in a tense, rotating pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043687909841537476 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1686878204345703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043687909841537476, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043687909841537476, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20164574682712555, + 0.1505545675754547, + 0.018692007288336754, + 0.12804970145225525, + 0.07154831290245056, + 0.021023163571953773, + 0.04350845143198967, + 0.03691578656435013, + 0.07071975618600845, + 0.25734251737594604 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043687909841537476 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the two main subjects depicted as butterfly carp with enormous, silky fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one carp pitch black with fine crosshatching outlines and the other pure white with bold white space highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene constructed entirely of charcoal and graphite sketches with an abstract waterscape background of wild brushstrokes and smudged ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the carp engage in a fierce duel involving chasing, spiraling, and colliding while stirring up splashes of ink and broken lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the subjects in a tense, rotating pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005958531983196735 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130958557128906 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005958531983196735, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005958531983196735, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04499012604355812, + 0.07512371987104416, + 0.019920533522963524, + 0.4972178041934967, + 0.08579521626234055, + 0.020702330395579338, + 0.057096801698207855, + 0.022854678332805634, + 0.034943580627441406, + 0.1413552463054657 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005958531983196735 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the two main subjects depicted as butterfly carp with enormous, silky fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one carp pitch black with fine crosshatching outlines and the other pure white with bold white space highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene constructed entirely of charcoal and graphite sketches with an abstract waterscape background of wild brushstrokes and smudged ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the carp engage in a fierce duel involving chasing, spiraling, and colliding while stirring up splashes of ink and broken lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the subjects in a tense, rotating pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014193067327141762 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264193058013916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014193067327141762, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014193067327141762, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07215950638055801, + 0.09643933922052383, + 0.04435986652970314, + 0.2953599691390991, + 0.11491347849369049, + 0.0645330548286438, + 0.12573027610778809, + 0.022476719692349434, + 0.038278136402368546, + 0.12574972212314606 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014193067327141762 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the two main subjects depicted as butterfly carp with enormous, silky fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one carp pitch black with fine crosshatching outlines and the other pure white with bold white space highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene constructed entirely of charcoal and graphite sketches with an abstract waterscape background of wild brushstrokes and smudged ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the carp engage in a fierce duel involving chasing, spiraling, and colliding while stirring up splashes of ink and broken lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the subjects in a tense, rotating pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036131355445832014 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628612995147705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036131355445832014, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036131355445832014, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10102341324090958, + 0.1635001301765442, + 0.08947137743234634, + 0.13873344659805298, + 0.06582003831863403, + 0.058701515197753906, + 0.11878129094839096, + 0.05442133545875549, + 0.06892726570367813, + 0.1406201720237732 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036131355445832014 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the two main subjects depicted as butterfly carp with enormous, silky fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one carp pitch black with fine crosshatching outlines and the other pure white with bold white space highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene constructed entirely of charcoal and graphite sketches with an abstract waterscape background of wild brushstrokes and smudged ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the carp engage in a fierce duel involving chasing, spiraling, and colliding while stirring up splashes of ink and broken lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the subjects in a tense, rotating pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038082268089056015 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880823612213135 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038082268089056015, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038082268089056015, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08008023351430893, + 0.09405075758695602, + 0.07117703557014465, + 0.4553622007369995, + 0.062451161444187164, + 0.02763325907289982, + 0.056007955223321915, + 0.053829044103622437, + 0.041962239891290665, + 0.05744610354304314 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038082268089056015 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful, low-angle, sweeping shot plunges us into a world of powerful, hand-drawn sketches constructed entirely of charcoal and graphite. Amidst this abstract waterscape of wild brushstrokes and smudged ink, two butterfly carp, each with enormous, silky fins, engage in a fierce duel. One is pitch black, its scales outlined with fine crosshatching; the other is pure white, its bright areas highlighted by bold white space, creating a stark visual contrast. The camera follows them in a tense, rotating pattern, capturing every moment as they chase, spiral, and collide. Their vast, flowing fins trace graceful yet deadly arcs with each swing, and every violent collision stirs up splashes of ink and broken lines across the frame, as if their struggle is composing the surrounding environment in real time. The high-contrast light and shadow effects are extremely emphasized through heavy shadows and sharp white spaces. There is not a trace of superfluous color in the entire scene, only the pure confrontation of black, white and gray, creating a dynamic beauty that is both tense and magnificent as well as full of primitive explosive power.", + "seed": 5038, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_5/index_1245_seed_5038_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.02057081088423729, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02057081088423729, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02057081088423729, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the two main subjects depicted as butterfly carp with enormous, silky fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one carp pitch black with fine crosshatching outlines and the other pure white with bold white space highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene constructed entirely of charcoal and graphite sketches with an abstract waterscape background of wild brushstrokes and smudged ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the carp engage in a fierce duel involving chasing, spiraling, and colliding while stirring up splashes of ink and broken lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the subjects in a tense, rotating pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.049074478447437286 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.049074411392212 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.049074478447437286, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.049074478447437286, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3756086528301239, + 0.03956076130270958, + 0.09684271365404129, + 0.05788040533661842, + 0.03607561066746712, + 0.11247926205396652, + 0.0346515066921711, + 0.12365955114364624, + 0.05067409202456474, + 0.07256743311882019 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.049074478447437286 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the two main subjects depicted as butterfly carp with enormous, silky fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one carp pitch black with fine crosshatching outlines and the other pure white with bold white space highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene constructed entirely of charcoal and graphite sketches with an abstract waterscape background of wild brushstrokes and smudged ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the carp engage in a fierce duel involving chasing, spiraling, and colliding while stirring up splashes of ink and broken lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the subjects in a tense, rotating pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008649268187582493 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586493492126465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008649268187582493, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008649268187582493, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32018086314201355, + 0.08065921813249588, + 0.13554592430591583, + 0.07103868573904037, + 0.031590450555086136, + 0.042197082191705704, + 0.06580789387226105, + 0.11036870628595352, + 0.03875812888145447, + 0.10385306179523468 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008649268187582493 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the two main subjects depicted as butterfly carp with enormous, silky fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one carp pitch black with fine crosshatching outlines and the other pure white with bold white space highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene constructed entirely of charcoal and graphite sketches with an abstract waterscape background of wild brushstrokes and smudged ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the carp engage in a fierce duel involving chasing, spiraling, and colliding while stirring up splashes of ink and broken lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the subjects in a tense, rotating pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008634849451482296 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586350440979 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008634849451482296, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008634849451482296, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6345526576042175, + 0.05123154819011688, + 0.043652843683958054, + 0.022129183635115623, + 0.025968173518776894, + 0.04216272011399269, + 0.041583698242902756, + 0.06338507682085037, + 0.04206560552120209, + 0.033268555998802185 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008634849451482296 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the two main subjects depicted as butterfly carp with enormous, silky fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one carp pitch black with fine crosshatching outlines and the other pure white with bold white space highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene constructed entirely of charcoal and graphite sketches with an abstract waterscape background of wild brushstrokes and smudged ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the carp engage in a fierce duel involving chasing, spiraling, and colliding while stirring up splashes of ink and broken lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the subjects in a tense, rotating pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002815570682287216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778157234191895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002815570682287216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002815570682287216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7313553690910339, + 0.025227610021829605, + 0.036272965371608734, + 0.04903944954276085, + 0.011101935058832169, + 0.04155557230114937, + 0.02367580309510231, + 0.03366127982735634, + 0.026695946231484413, + 0.02141408622264862 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002815570682287216 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the two main subjects depicted as butterfly carp with enormous, silky fins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one carp pitch black with fine crosshatching outlines and the other pure white with bold white space highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene constructed entirely of charcoal and graphite sketches with an abstract waterscape background of wild brushstrokes and smudged ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the carp engage in a fierce duel involving chasing, spiraling, and colliding while stirring up splashes of ink and broken lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera follow the subjects in a tense, rotating pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033679887652397156 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408679962158203 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033679887652397156, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033679887652397156, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7495056390762329, + 0.020631851628422737, + 0.05911001190543175, + 0.02582736313343048, + 0.02368326671421528, + 0.023101048544049263, + 0.016750743612647057, + 0.03341323509812355, + 0.029033903032541275, + 0.01894293911755085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033679887652397156 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_6/index_tensor([9675, 9675])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_6/index_tensor([9675, 9675])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9a8f5d39654e8d7f64220e51204f67dbdbe0f083 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_6/index_tensor([9675, 9675])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "tight close-up initially depicts an antique hardcover book, impossibly suspended in mid-air. Bound in crimson leather with a worn texture and delicate gold-leaf filigree on its spine, the book performs a rhythmic, self-propelled acrobatic movement, tumbling back and forth and gracefully rotating on its vertical axis. With each rotation, its yellowed-edged pages open and close, emitting a soft, trembling whisper amidst the profound silence. The camera then executes a swift, smooth pullback, rapidly zooming out to reveal the book's true context. It is a solitary object, floating in the central aisle of a vast, empty, cathedral-like library. Towering dark mahogany bookshelves, filled with countless books, stretch into the shadows of the vaulted ceiling. Golden afternoon sunlight penetrates the tall, arched windows, illuminating dancing specks of dust and casting long, dramatic shadows across the polished wooden floor. The rapid exposition shifts the scene from one of magical curiosity to one of profound loneliness and quiet wonder, emphasizing a single point of movement within a vast, static, and silent world.", + "seed": 11505, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_6/index_9675_seed_11505_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.310138079803437, + "vlm_logprob": -0.310138079803437, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.310138079803437, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique hardcover book bound in crimson leather with gold-leaf filigree on its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the book perform a rhythmic acrobatic movement involving tumbling and rotating on its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the book's yellowed-edged pages open and close with each rotation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a swift, smooth pullback from a tight close-up to reveal a vast, empty cathedral-like library?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a library with towering dark mahogany bookshelves, arched windows, and golden afternoon sunlight illuminating dust specks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08934760093688965 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4643476009368896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08934760093688965, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08934760093688965, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1665157526731491, + 0.27849847078323364, + 0.11094757914543152, + 0.08963967114686966, + 0.05585107207298279, + 0.054963625967502594, + 0.08839061111211777, + 0.06432080268859863, + 0.03944988548755646, + 0.05142257735133171 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08934760093688965 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique hardcover book bound in crimson leather with gold-leaf filigree on its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the book perform a rhythmic acrobatic movement involving tumbling and rotating on its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the book's yellowed-edged pages open and close with each rotation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a swift, smooth pullback from a tight close-up to reveal a vast, empty cathedral-like library?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a library with towering dark mahogany bookshelves, arched windows, and golden afternoon sunlight illuminating dust specks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020600641146302223 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956005573272705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020600641146302223, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020600641146302223, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21568597853183746, + 0.14690111577510834, + 0.1468549519777298, + 0.10327329486608505, + 0.1879802793264389, + 0.02273978292942047, + 0.0768364816904068, + 0.05691118910908699, + 0.01643449440598488, + 0.026382461190223694 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020600641146302223 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique hardcover book bound in crimson leather with gold-leaf filigree on its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the book perform a rhythmic acrobatic movement involving tumbling and rotating on its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the book's yellowed-edged pages open and close with each rotation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a swift, smooth pullback from a tight close-up to reveal a vast, empty cathedral-like library?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a library with towering dark mahogany bookshelves, arched windows, and golden afternoon sunlight illuminating dust specks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029801908880472183 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529801845550537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029801908880472183, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029801908880472183, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1772015243768692, + 0.16400907933712006, + 0.13782863318920135, + 0.047545671463012695, + 0.05471254140138626, + 0.033558983355760574, + 0.15771788358688354, + 0.13816381990909576, + 0.05003902316093445, + 0.03922277316451073 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029801908880472183 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique hardcover book bound in crimson leather with gold-leaf filigree on its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the book perform a rhythmic acrobatic movement involving tumbling and rotating on its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the book's yellowed-edged pages open and close with each rotation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a swift, smooth pullback from a tight close-up to reveal a vast, empty cathedral-like library?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a library with towering dark mahogany bookshelves, arched windows, and golden afternoon sunlight illuminating dust specks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063026905059814 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28130272030830383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.4063026905059814, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -1.4063026905059814, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3395252525806427, + 0.16339075565338135, + 0.06550560146570206, + 0.03198728337883949, + 0.07637821137905121, + 0.055593010038137436, + 0.10291274636983871, + 0.04524614289402962, + 0.06984704732894897, + 0.049613889306783676 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.4063026905059814 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique hardcover book bound in crimson leather with gold-leaf filigree on its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the book perform a rhythmic acrobatic movement involving tumbling and rotating on its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the book's yellowed-edged pages open and close with each rotation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a swift, smooth pullback from a tight close-up to reveal a vast, empty cathedral-like library?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a library with towering dark mahogany bookshelves, arched windows, and golden afternoon sunlight illuminating dust specks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004637557547539473 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379637718200684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004637557547539473, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004637557547539473, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18303552269935608, + 0.36592239141464233, + 0.07789136469364166, + 0.046682246029376984, + 0.045500874519348145, + 0.020821159705519676, + 0.0651630237698555, + 0.050278570502996445, + 0.07424090802669525, + 0.07046398520469666 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004637557547539473 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "tight close-up initially depicts an antique hardcover book, impossibly suspended in mid-air. Bound in crimson leather with a worn texture and delicate gold-leaf filigree on its spine, the book performs a rhythmic, self-propelled acrobatic movement, tumbling back and forth and gracefully rotating on its vertical axis. With each rotation, its yellowed-edged pages open and close, emitting a soft, trembling whisper amidst the profound silence. The camera then executes a swift, smooth pullback, rapidly zooming out to reveal the book's true context. It is a solitary object, floating in the central aisle of a vast, empty, cathedral-like library. Towering dark mahogany bookshelves, filled with countless books, stretch into the shadows of the vaulted ceiling. Golden afternoon sunlight penetrates the tall, arched windows, illuminating dancing specks of dust and casting long, dramatic shadows across the polished wooden floor. The rapid exposition shifts the scene from one of magical curiosity to one of profound loneliness and quiet wonder, emphasizing a single point of movement within a vast, static, and silent world.", + "seed": 11506, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_6/index_9675_seed_11506_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08559656497091055, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08559656497091055, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08559656497091055, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique hardcover book bound in crimson leather with gold-leaf filigree on its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the book perform a rhythmic acrobatic movement involving tumbling and rotating on its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the book's yellowed-edged pages open and close with each rotation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a swift, smooth pullback from a tight close-up to reveal a vast, empty cathedral-like library?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a library with towering dark mahogany bookshelves, arched windows, and golden afternoon sunlight illuminating dust specks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026689471676945686 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6516895294189453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026689471676945686, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026689471676945686, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13363118469715118, + 0.15129145979881287, + 0.04848059266805649, + 0.04514661058783531, + 0.13172951340675354, + 0.1951826959848404, + 0.06808938086032867, + 0.03289153799414635, + 0.15397097170352936, + 0.03958607837557793 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026689471676945686 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique hardcover book bound in crimson leather with gold-leaf filigree on its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the book perform a rhythmic acrobatic movement involving tumbling and rotating on its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the book's yellowed-edged pages open and close with each rotation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a swift, smooth pullback from a tight close-up to reveal a vast, empty cathedral-like library?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a library with towering dark mahogany bookshelves, arched windows, and golden afternoon sunlight illuminating dust specks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018197840079665184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018198013305664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018197840079665184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018197840079665184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1179702877998352, + 0.054319966584444046, + 0.06389735639095306, + 0.053662221878767014, + 0.21712632477283478, + 0.06702577322721481, + 0.08337587863206863, + 0.09459751844406128, + 0.19329054653644562, + 0.05473417043685913 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018197840079665184 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique hardcover book bound in crimson leather with gold-leaf filigree on its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the book perform a rhythmic acrobatic movement involving tumbling and rotating on its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the book's yellowed-edged pages open and close with each rotation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a swift, smooth pullback from a tight close-up to reveal a vast, empty cathedral-like library?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a library with towering dark mahogany bookshelves, arched windows, and golden afternoon sunlight illuminating dust specks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620555654168129 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120555877685547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620555654168129, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620555654168129, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07263751327991486, + 0.02710825577378273, + 0.05355069413781166, + 0.033893655985593796, + 0.4093395471572876, + 0.11469906568527222, + 0.028340253978967667, + 0.036586008965969086, + 0.1738804280757904, + 0.04996461421251297 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620555654168129 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique hardcover book bound in crimson leather with gold-leaf filigree on its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the book perform a rhythmic acrobatic movement involving tumbling and rotating on its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the book's yellowed-edged pages open and close with each rotation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a swift, smooth pullback from a tight close-up to reveal a vast, empty cathedral-like library?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a library with towering dark mahogany bookshelves, arched windows, and golden afternoon sunlight illuminating dust specks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134150207042694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134150505065918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134150207042694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134150207042694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09709106385707855, + 0.0713881254196167, + 0.050058163702487946, + 0.05675884336233139, + 0.104186050593853, + 0.16099897027015686, + 0.041817571967840195, + 0.06250971555709839, + 0.27195000648498535, + 0.0832415297627449 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134150207042694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique hardcover book bound in crimson leather with gold-leaf filigree on its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the book perform a rhythmic acrobatic movement involving tumbling and rotating on its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the book's yellowed-edged pages open and close with each rotation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a swift, smooth pullback from a tight close-up to reveal a vast, empty cathedral-like library?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a library with towering dark mahogany bookshelves, arched windows, and golden afternoon sunlight illuminating dust specks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076249269768595695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882625102996826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076249269768595695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076249269768595695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1031598299741745, + 0.06730514764785767, + 0.047054022550582886, + 0.032902151346206665, + 0.18585751950740814, + 0.0829520970582962, + 0.06686463952064514, + 0.0576816126704216, + 0.28448358178138733, + 0.07173938304185867 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076249269768595695 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "tight close-up initially depicts an antique hardcover book, impossibly suspended in mid-air. Bound in crimson leather with a worn texture and delicate gold-leaf filigree on its spine, the book performs a rhythmic, self-propelled acrobatic movement, tumbling back and forth and gracefully rotating on its vertical axis. With each rotation, its yellowed-edged pages open and close, emitting a soft, trembling whisper amidst the profound silence. The camera then executes a swift, smooth pullback, rapidly zooming out to reveal the book's true context. It is a solitary object, floating in the central aisle of a vast, empty, cathedral-like library. Towering dark mahogany bookshelves, filled with countless books, stretch into the shadows of the vaulted ceiling. Golden afternoon sunlight penetrates the tall, arched windows, illuminating dancing specks of dust and casting long, dramatic shadows across the polished wooden floor. The rapid exposition shifts the scene from one of magical curiosity to one of profound loneliness and quiet wonder, emphasizing a single point of movement within a vast, static, and silent world.", + "seed": 11507, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_6/index_9675_seed_11507_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11763814566656947, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11763814566656947, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11763814566656947, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique hardcover book bound in crimson leather with gold-leaf filigree on its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the book perform a rhythmic acrobatic movement involving tumbling and rotating on its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the book's yellowed-edged pages open and close with each rotation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a swift, smooth pullback from a tight close-up to reveal a vast, empty cathedral-like library?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a library with towering dark mahogany bookshelves, arched windows, and golden afternoon sunlight illuminating dust specks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.523730456829071 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.898730456829071 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.523730456829071, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.523730456829071, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19845476746559143, + 0.09386234730482101, + 0.0822337195277214, + 0.07675907015800476, + 0.044632572680711746, + 0.05233726277947426, + 0.12367436289787292, + 0.08496686816215515, + 0.18666194379329681, + 0.05641704797744751 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.523730456829071 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique hardcover book bound in crimson leather with gold-leaf filigree on its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the book perform a rhythmic acrobatic movement involving tumbling and rotating on its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the book's yellowed-edged pages open and close with each rotation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a swift, smooth pullback from a tight close-up to reveal a vast, empty cathedral-like library?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a library with towering dark mahogany bookshelves, arched windows, and golden afternoon sunlight illuminating dust specks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016092298552393913 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141092300415039 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016092298552393913, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016092298552393913, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11459305137395859, + 0.07216910272836685, + 0.06548777967691422, + 0.09077228605747223, + 0.09658905863761902, + 0.05917889624834061, + 0.07550224661827087, + 0.21753551065921783, + 0.14216400682926178, + 0.06600803136825562 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016092298552393913 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique hardcover book bound in crimson leather with gold-leaf filigree on its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the book perform a rhythmic acrobatic movement involving tumbling and rotating on its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the book's yellowed-edged pages open and close with each rotation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a swift, smooth pullback from a tight close-up to reveal a vast, empty cathedral-like library?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a library with towering dark mahogany bookshelves, arched windows, and golden afternoon sunlight illuminating dust specks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026352349668741226 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513524055480957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026352349668741226, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026352349668741226, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10186134278774261, + 0.07368683815002441, + 0.05169261246919632, + 0.10194756090641022, + 0.0663515254855156, + 0.07362044602632523, + 0.19588202238082886, + 0.15395447611808777, + 0.0910658985376358, + 0.0899372473359108 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026352349668741226 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique hardcover book bound in crimson leather with gold-leaf filigree on its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the book perform a rhythmic acrobatic movement involving tumbling and rotating on its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the book's yellowed-edged pages open and close with each rotation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a swift, smooth pullback from a tight close-up to reveal a vast, empty cathedral-like library?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a library with towering dark mahogany bookshelves, arched windows, and golden afternoon sunlight illuminating dust specks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607024483382702 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141070365905762 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607024483382702, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607024483382702, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06480476260185242, + 0.07617004215717316, + 0.039235446602106094, + 0.06438905745744705, + 0.029444200918078423, + 0.04061305150389671, + 0.0654483214020729, + 0.1261945366859436, + 0.38754868507385254, + 0.10615193098783493 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607024483382702 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique hardcover book bound in crimson leather with gold-leaf filigree on its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the book perform a rhythmic acrobatic movement involving tumbling and rotating on its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the book's yellowed-edged pages open and close with each rotation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a swift, smooth pullback from a tight close-up to reveal a vast, empty cathedral-like library?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a library with towering dark mahogany bookshelves, arched windows, and golden afternoon sunlight illuminating dust specks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005945378448814154 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130945205688477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005945378448814154, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005945378448814154, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13717889785766602, + 0.06867582350969315, + 0.02868685871362686, + 0.041984573006629944, + 0.03730657696723938, + 0.09555978327989578, + 0.1553449183702469, + 0.08819044381380081, + 0.28292474150657654, + 0.06414741277694702 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005945378448814154 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "tight close-up initially depicts an antique hardcover book, impossibly suspended in mid-air. Bound in crimson leather with a worn texture and delicate gold-leaf filigree on its spine, the book performs a rhythmic, self-propelled acrobatic movement, tumbling back and forth and gracefully rotating on its vertical axis. With each rotation, its yellowed-edged pages open and close, emitting a soft, trembling whisper amidst the profound silence. The camera then executes a swift, smooth pullback, rapidly zooming out to reveal the book's true context. It is a solitary object, floating in the central aisle of a vast, empty, cathedral-like library. Towering dark mahogany bookshelves, filled with countless books, stretch into the shadows of the vaulted ceiling. Golden afternoon sunlight penetrates the tall, arched windows, illuminating dancing specks of dust and casting long, dramatic shadows across the polished wooden floor. The rapid exposition shifts the scene from one of magical curiosity to one of profound loneliness and quiet wonder, emphasizing a single point of movement within a vast, static, and silent world.", + "seed": 11508, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_6/index_9675_seed_11508_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.17634468637406825, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17634468637406825, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17634468637406825, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique hardcover book bound in crimson leather with gold-leaf filigree on its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the book perform a rhythmic acrobatic movement involving tumbling and rotating on its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the book's yellowed-edged pages open and close with each rotation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a swift, smooth pullback from a tight close-up to reveal a vast, empty cathedral-like library?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a library with towering dark mahogany bookshelves, arched windows, and golden afternoon sunlight illuminating dust specks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03018217161297798 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.530182123184204 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03018217161297798, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03018217161297798, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06563909351825714, + 0.02911471202969551, + 0.03942633047699928, + 0.13907064497470856, + 0.03589046001434326, + 0.03800537437200546, + 0.09087491035461426, + 0.1308600753545761, + 0.3523899018764496, + 0.07872854918241501 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03018217161297798 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique hardcover book bound in crimson leather with gold-leaf filigree on its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the book perform a rhythmic acrobatic movement involving tumbling and rotating on its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the book's yellowed-edged pages open and close with each rotation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a swift, smooth pullback from a tight close-up to reveal a vast, empty cathedral-like library?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a library with towering dark mahogany bookshelves, arched windows, and golden afternoon sunlight illuminating dust specks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020594336092472076 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895594358444214 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020594336092472076, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020594336092472076, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09737364202737808, + 0.09306540340185165, + 0.09550616145133972, + 0.11670525372028351, + 0.043815262615680695, + 0.11474905908107758, + 0.22004878520965576, + 0.06859730184078217, + 0.046183954924345016, + 0.1039552167057991 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020594336092472076 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique hardcover book bound in crimson leather with gold-leaf filigree on its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the book perform a rhythmic acrobatic movement involving tumbling and rotating on its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the book's yellowed-edged pages open and close with each rotation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a swift, smooth pullback from a tight close-up to reveal a vast, empty cathedral-like library?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a library with towering dark mahogany bookshelves, arched windows, and golden afternoon sunlight illuminating dust specks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496467649936676 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929964780807495 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496467649936676, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496467649936676, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06559251993894577, + 0.012513818219304085, + 0.02585919387638569, + 0.08516370505094528, + 0.0364106148481369, + 0.02298133075237274, + 0.09205994755029678, + 0.2315608114004135, + 0.3892931342124939, + 0.038564953953027725 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496467649936676 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique hardcover book bound in crimson leather with gold-leaf filigree on its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the book perform a rhythmic acrobatic movement involving tumbling and rotating on its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the book's yellowed-edged pages open and close with each rotation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a swift, smooth pullback from a tight close-up to reveal a vast, empty cathedral-like library?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a library with towering dark mahogany bookshelves, arched windows, and golden afternoon sunlight illuminating dust specks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7577996253967285 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6327996253967285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7577996253967285, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7577996253967285, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08003810793161392, + 0.014284542761743069, + 0.03107764758169651, + 0.03266721963882446, + 0.019082825630903244, + 0.019734546542167664, + 0.04088570177555084, + 0.0149617251008749, + 0.6705795526504517, + 0.07668823003768921 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7577996253967285 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an antique hardcover book bound in crimson leather with gold-leaf filigree on its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the book perform a rhythmic acrobatic movement involving tumbling and rotating on its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the book's yellowed-edged pages open and close with each rotation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a swift, smooth pullback from a tight close-up to reveal a vast, empty cathedral-like library?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a library with towering dark mahogany bookshelves, arched windows, and golden afternoon sunlight illuminating dust specks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018182622268795967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018182754516602 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018182622268795967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018182622268795967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13567839562892914, + 0.04059375450015068, + 0.052571844309568405, + 0.036476828157901764, + 0.015620967373251915, + 0.033137042075395584, + 0.11348852515220642, + 0.2527211606502533, + 0.10920962691307068, + 0.21050186455249786 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018182622268795967 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_7/index_tensor([8960, 8960])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_7/index_tensor([8960, 8960])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..495b0149cd1b92be4118837ac56af9c7872c2895 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_7/index_tensor([8960, 8960])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle shot rapidly tracks a massive black bull as it explosively charges forward across a sunny plain. Its dark hide gleams in the harsh, direct sunlight, its dense, powerful muscles ripple, its entire form rendered in a slight motion blur to emphasize the sheer speed of its charge. Thick, white steam erupts violently from its flared nostrils, a stark contrast to its black form. With its head lowered, its massive, sleek horns aimed forward, its hooves dig into the dry, ochre earth, kicking up a massive cloud of dust and small pebbles that tumble and swirl in its wake. The scene is filled with primal power, the bull's dark, muscular form contrasting sharply with the bright, chaotic explosions of dust, creating an intense and visceral atmosphere of untamed, explosive violence.", + "seed": 28160, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_7/index_8960_seed_28160_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.004024589993059635, + "vlm_logprob": -0.004024589993059635, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.004024589993059635, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive black bull with dense, powerful muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bull performing an explosive charge forward with its head lowered and horns aimed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sunny plain with dry, ochre earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible effects of thick white steam erupting from the bull's flared nostrils and a massive cloud of dust kicked up by its hooves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dramatic low-angle view with rapid camera tracking and slight motion blur on the bull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00225242436863482 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.002252578735352 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00225242436863482, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00225242436863482, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10171259939670563, + 0.1273888647556305, + 0.04669451341032982, + 0.12604598701000214, + 0.04816751182079315, + 0.12529775500297546, + 0.14518511295318604, + 0.042186133563518524, + 0.08863364905118942, + 0.14868785440921783 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00225242436863482 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive black bull with dense, powerful muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bull performing an explosive charge forward with its head lowered and horns aimed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sunny plain with dry, ochre earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible effects of thick white steam erupting from the bull's flared nostrils and a massive cloud of dust kicked up by its hooves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dramatic low-angle view with rapid camera tracking and slight motion blur on the bull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004643846768885851 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.37964391708374 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004643846768885851, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004643846768885851, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11991575360298157, + 0.06252758949995041, + 0.14287318289279938, + 0.18771705031394958, + 0.10436883568763733, + 0.08124037086963654, + 0.1533677726984024, + 0.046983297914266586, + 0.036117520183324814, + 0.06488866358995438 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004643846768885851 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive black bull with dense, powerful muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bull performing an explosive charge forward with its head lowered and horns aimed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sunny plain with dry, ochre earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible effects of thick white steam erupting from the bull's flared nostrils and a massive cloud of dust kicked up by its hooves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dramatic low-angle view with rapid camera tracking and slight motion blur on the bull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059450226835906506 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130945205688477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059450226835906506, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059450226835906506, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13972815871238708, + 0.03070521168410778, + 0.06019161641597748, + 0.04010571539402008, + 0.019261004403233528, + 0.029835131019353867, + 0.10365507751703262, + 0.3918113708496094, + 0.09570793807506561, + 0.08899877220392227 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059450226835906506 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive black bull with dense, powerful muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bull performing an explosive charge forward with its head lowered and horns aimed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sunny plain with dry, ochre earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible effects of thick white steam erupting from the bull's flared nostrils and a massive cloud of dust kicked up by its hooves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dramatic low-angle view with rapid camera tracking and slight motion blur on the bull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031901916954666376 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753190040588379 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031901916954666376, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031901916954666376, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16330483555793762, + 0.10083899646997452, + 0.09982050210237503, + 0.0801468938589096, + 0.03504146263003349, + 0.13255971670150757, + 0.23188278079032898, + 0.04676828160881996, + 0.06888625770807266, + 0.04075029864907265 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031901916954666376 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive black bull with dense, powerful muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bull performing an explosive charge forward with its head lowered and horns aimed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sunny plain with dry, ochre earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible effects of thick white steam erupting from the bull's flared nostrils and a massive cloud of dust kicked up by its hooves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dramatic low-angle view with rapid camera tracking and slight motion blur on the bull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004091464448720217 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504091262817383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004091464448720217, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004091464448720217, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1074909120798111, + 0.05494590476155281, + 0.1428614854812622, + 0.12649200856685638, + 0.09213259816169739, + 0.16214975714683533, + 0.15065428614616394, + 0.052557721734046936, + 0.03851370885968208, + 0.07220164686441422 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004091464448720217 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle shot rapidly tracks a massive black bull as it explosively charges forward across a sunny plain. Its dark hide gleams in the harsh, direct sunlight, its dense, powerful muscles ripple, its entire form rendered in a slight motion blur to emphasize the sheer speed of its charge. Thick, white steam erupts violently from its flared nostrils, a stark contrast to its black form. With its head lowered, its massive, sleek horns aimed forward, its hooves dig into the dry, ochre earth, kicking up a massive cloud of dust and small pebbles that tumble and swirl in its wake. The scene is filled with primal power, the bull's dark, muscular form contrasting sharply with the bright, chaotic explosions of dust, creating an intense and visceral atmosphere of untamed, explosive violence.", + "seed": 28161, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_7/index_8960_seed_28161_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.005508715799078345, + "vlm_logprob": -0.005508715799078345, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.005508715799078345, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive black bull with dense, powerful muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bull performing an explosive charge forward with its head lowered and horns aimed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sunny plain with dry, ochre earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible effects of thick white steam erupting from the bull's flared nostrils and a massive cloud of dust kicked up by its hooves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dramatic low-angle view with rapid camera tracking and slight motion blur on the bull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0025239300448447466 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.377523899078369 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0025239300448447466, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0025239300448447466, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14144347608089447, + 0.06671416759490967, + 0.14208869636058807, + 0.18532973527908325, + 0.0525854118168354, + 0.038271714001894, + 0.04469257965683937, + 0.11127733439207077, + 0.062139298766851425, + 0.15545757114887238 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0025239300448447466 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive black bull with dense, powerful muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bull performing an explosive charge forward with its head lowered and horns aimed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sunny plain with dry, ochre earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible effects of thick white steam erupting from the bull's flared nostrils and a massive cloud of dust kicked up by its hooves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dramatic low-angle view with rapid camera tracking and slight motion blur on the bull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008648558519780636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75864839553833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008648558519780636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008648558519780636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1055130884051323, + 0.11040081828832626, + 0.34971949458122253, + 0.12150973081588745, + 0.1165248304605484, + 0.03261886537075043, + 0.03864503279328346, + 0.06285697966814041, + 0.02871929109096527, + 0.033491868525743484 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008648558519780636 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive black bull with dense, powerful muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bull performing an explosive charge forward with its head lowered and horns aimed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sunny plain with dry, ochre earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible effects of thick white steam erupting from the bull's flared nostrils and a massive cloud of dust kicked up by its hooves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dramatic low-angle view with rapid camera tracking and slight motion blur on the bull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008634494617581367 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758634567260742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008634494617581367, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008634494617581367, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24274122714996338, + 0.07749539613723755, + 0.08671534806489944, + 0.16412241756916046, + 0.08126183599233627, + 0.08877679705619812, + 0.08432617038488388, + 0.0693812370300293, + 0.056610044091939926, + 0.04856962710618973 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008634494617581367 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive black bull with dense, powerful muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bull performing an explosive charge forward with its head lowered and horns aimed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sunny plain with dry, ochre earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible effects of thick white steam erupting from the bull's flared nostrils and a massive cloud of dust kicked up by its hooves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dramatic low-angle view with rapid camera tracking and slight motion blur on the bull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024880189448595047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002488136291504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024880189448595047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024880189448595047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14765483140945435, + 0.06875914335250854, + 0.23511245846748352, + 0.08050742745399475, + 0.06695400923490524, + 0.08217961341142654, + 0.05766165629029274, + 0.08381454646587372, + 0.041754238307476044, + 0.13560211658477783 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024880189448595047 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive black bull with dense, powerful muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bull performing an explosive charge forward with its head lowered and horns aimed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sunny plain with dry, ochre earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible effects of thick white steam erupting from the bull's flared nostrils and a massive cloud of dust kicked up by its hooves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dramatic low-angle view with rapid camera tracking and slight motion blur on the bull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005248576868325472 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255248546600342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005248576868325472, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005248576868325472, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1404769867658615, + 0.07593579590320587, + 0.0975135862827301, + 0.17432820796966553, + 0.11026045680046082, + 0.11858782917261124, + 0.06741663068532944, + 0.052565548568964005, + 0.08083797246217728, + 0.0820770263671875 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005248576868325472 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle shot rapidly tracks a massive black bull as it explosively charges forward across a sunny plain. Its dark hide gleams in the harsh, direct sunlight, its dense, powerful muscles ripple, its entire form rendered in a slight motion blur to emphasize the sheer speed of its charge. Thick, white steam erupts violently from its flared nostrils, a stark contrast to its black form. With its head lowered, its massive, sleek horns aimed forward, its hooves dig into the dry, ochre earth, kicking up a massive cloud of dust and small pebbles that tumble and swirl in its wake. The scene is filled with primal power, the bull's dark, muscular form contrasting sharply with the bright, chaotic explosions of dust, creating an intense and visceral atmosphere of untamed, explosive violence.", + "seed": 28162, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_7/index_8960_seed_28162_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.004385284380987287, + "vlm_logprob": -0.004385284380987287, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.004385284380987287, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive black bull with dense, powerful muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bull performing an explosive charge forward with its head lowered and horns aimed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sunny plain with dry, ochre earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible effects of thick white steam erupting from the bull's flared nostrils and a massive cloud of dust kicked up by its hooves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dramatic low-angle view with rapid camera tracking and slight motion blur on the bull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003628220409154892 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.878628253936768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003628220409154892, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003628220409154892, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08737257868051529, + 0.19287455081939697, + 0.07297511398792267, + 0.07755442708730698, + 0.043339647352695465, + 0.10479813069105148, + 0.2024119347333908, + 0.0696244090795517, + 0.03584950044751167, + 0.11319971084594727 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003628220409154892 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive black bull with dense, powerful muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bull performing an explosive charge forward with its head lowered and horns aimed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sunny plain with dry, ochre earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible effects of thick white steam erupting from the bull's flared nostrils and a massive cloud of dust kicked up by its hooves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dramatic low-angle view with rapid camera tracking and slight motion blur on the bull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005956991575658321 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130957126617432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005956991575658321, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005956991575658321, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11102413386106491, + 0.17841105163097382, + 0.1213185116648674, + 0.07715489715337753, + 0.044554200023412704, + 0.11260831356048584, + 0.11717498302459717, + 0.03214866667985916, + 0.0956922098994255, + 0.10991300642490387 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005956991575658321 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive black bull with dense, powerful muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bull performing an explosive charge forward with its head lowered and horns aimed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sunny plain with dry, ochre earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible effects of thick white steam erupting from the bull's flared nostrils and a massive cloud of dust kicked up by its hooves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dramatic low-angle view with rapid camera tracking and slight motion blur on the bull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003613016800954938 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628612995147705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003613016800954938, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003613016800954938, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15509887039661407, + 0.20626680552959442, + 0.09284543991088867, + 0.1918819546699524, + 0.01622455194592476, + 0.042871203273534775, + 0.10441333055496216, + 0.04743613302707672, + 0.033843994140625, + 0.10911771655082703 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003613016800954938 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive black bull with dense, powerful muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bull performing an explosive charge forward with its head lowered and horns aimed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sunny plain with dry, ochre earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible effects of thick white steam erupting from the bull's flared nostrils and a massive cloud of dust kicked up by its hooves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dramatic low-angle view with rapid camera tracking and slight motion blur on the bull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004094195086508989 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504094123840332 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004094195086508989, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004094195086508989, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19282062351703644, + 0.14307862520217896, + 0.20307673513889313, + 0.05040072277188301, + 0.04888976737856865, + 0.04438689351081848, + 0.0755162313580513, + 0.04810245335102081, + 0.1126880869269371, + 0.08103987574577332 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004094195086508989 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive black bull with dense, powerful muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bull performing an explosive charge forward with its head lowered and horns aimed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sunny plain with dry, ochre earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible effects of thick white steam erupting from the bull's flared nostrils and a massive cloud of dust kicked up by its hooves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dramatic low-angle view with rapid camera tracking and slight motion blur on the bull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004633998032659292 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379633903503418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004633998032659292, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004633998032659292, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15120361745357513, + 0.11027905344963074, + 0.07814446091651917, + 0.07441429048776627, + 0.0801251158118248, + 0.06542165577411652, + 0.08502211421728134, + 0.24623681604862213, + 0.0519343726336956, + 0.057218559086322784 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004633998032659292 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle shot rapidly tracks a massive black bull as it explosively charges forward across a sunny plain. Its dark hide gleams in the harsh, direct sunlight, its dense, powerful muscles ripple, its entire form rendered in a slight motion blur to emphasize the sheer speed of its charge. Thick, white steam erupts violently from its flared nostrils, a stark contrast to its black form. With its head lowered, its massive, sleek horns aimed forward, its hooves dig into the dry, ochre earth, kicking up a massive cloud of dust and small pebbles that tumble and swirl in its wake. The scene is filled with primal power, the bull's dark, muscular form contrasting sharply with the bright, chaotic explosions of dust, creating an intense and visceral atmosphere of untamed, explosive violence.", + "seed": 28163, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_7/index_8960_seed_28163_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0036552616860717536, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0036552616860717536, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0036552616860717536, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive black bull with dense, powerful muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bull performing an explosive charge forward with its head lowered and horns aimed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sunny plain with dry, ochre earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible effects of thick white steam erupting from the bull's flared nostrils and a massive cloud of dust kicked up by its hooves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dramatic low-angle view with rapid camera tracking and slight motion blur on the bull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002980435499921441 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.0029802322387695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002980435499921441, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002980435499921441, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.149715855717659, + 0.055309031158685684, + 0.11620303988456726, + 0.09533040225505829, + 0.12555783987045288, + 0.12577702105045319, + 0.1264609694480896, + 0.07802902907133102, + 0.05362911522388458, + 0.07398770749568939 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002980435499921441 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive black bull with dense, powerful muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bull performing an explosive charge forward with its head lowered and horns aimed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sunny plain with dry, ochre earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible effects of thick white steam erupting from the bull's flared nostrils and a massive cloud of dust kicked up by its hooves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dramatic low-angle view with rapid camera tracking and slight motion blur on the bull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052552176639437675 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255255222320557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052552176639437675, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052552176639437675, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1702926903963089, + 0.03612983226776123, + 0.0671403780579567, + 0.2840908169746399, + 0.044136691838502884, + 0.09699535369873047, + 0.06775715202093124, + 0.06498727202415466, + 0.042227696627378464, + 0.12624210119247437 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052552176639437675 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive black bull with dense, powerful muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bull performing an explosive charge forward with its head lowered and horns aimed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sunny plain with dry, ochre earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible effects of thick white steam erupting from the bull's flared nostrils and a massive cloud of dust kicked up by its hooves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dramatic low-angle view with rapid camera tracking and slight motion blur on the bull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036123041063547134 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628612518310547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036123041063547134, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036123041063547134, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18490472435951233, + 0.04057348519563675, + 0.09458351135253906, + 0.4515850841999054, + 0.03583621233701706, + 0.04840143769979477, + 0.0430862195789814, + 0.02991385944187641, + 0.01690000481903553, + 0.05421547591686249 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036123041063547134 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive black bull with dense, powerful muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bull performing an explosive charge forward with its head lowered and horns aimed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sunny plain with dry, ochre earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible effects of thick white steam erupting from the bull's flared nostrils and a massive cloud of dust kicked up by its hooves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dramatic low-angle view with rapid camera tracking and slight motion blur on the bull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028169972356408834 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877817153930664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028169972356408834, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028169972356408834, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3134709298610687, + 0.0641159862279892, + 0.04158222675323486, + 0.1449602246284485, + 0.052246950566768646, + 0.055966418236494064, + 0.061513662338256836, + 0.06360618770122528, + 0.07785184681415558, + 0.12468555569648743 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028169972356408834 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive black bull with dense, powerful muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bull performing an explosive charge forward with its head lowered and horns aimed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a sunny plain with dry, ochre earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there visible effects of thick white steam erupting from the bull's flared nostrils and a massive cloud of dust kicked up by its hooves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a dramatic low-angle view with rapid camera tracking and slight motion blur on the bull?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003611353924497962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.6286115646362305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003611353924497962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003611353924497962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09750916808843613, + 0.05135300010442734, + 0.0498511977493763, + 0.17744174599647522, + 0.08673719316720963, + 0.3140220046043396, + 0.04095391556620598, + 0.053022854030132294, + 0.03435104340314865, + 0.09475793689489365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003611353924497962 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_8/index_tensor([9815, 9815])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_8/index_tensor([9815, 9815])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a3fb3f1c7da49e8685953f4e62d13fbf7c27d8fc --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_8/index_tensor([9815, 9815])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "Viewed from a first-person perspective, the camera executes a slow, continuous, and tranquil forward drift beneath the crystal-clear surface of the Great Barrier Reef. Rendered in a vibrant, impressionistic style, the entire scene transforms the underwater world into a living, breathing painting. Gentle ripples on the water above act like a dynamic lens, fragmenting the brilliant sunlight into a constant dance of shimmering, corrosive patterns that punctuate the seascape below. Coral structures lose their clear biological definition, dissolving into a breathtaking mosaic of textured colors and shifting light; vast fields of staghorn and brain coral appear as thick, visible splotches and swirls of soft pinks, deep violets, and warm oranges. Schools of fish are depicted not as individual creatures but as fleeting blurs and swift, ephemeral streaks of pure pigment. Flashes of electric blue and canary yellow dart across the turquoise water like the quick, deliberate strokes of a painter's brush. The atmosphere is one of profound tranquility and dreamlike beauty, where the boundaries between light, water, and life blur into a beautiful, ever-shifting synthesis of movement and color.", + "seed": 28844, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_8/index_9815_seed_28844_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.10490746654104441, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10490746654104441, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10490746654104441, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, drifting forward beneath the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the Great Barrier Reef with visible coral structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the coral structures rendered as a mosaic of soft pinks, deep violets, and warm oranges rather than clear biological forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are schools of fish depicted as fleeting blurs and swift streaks of pigment rather than individual creatures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style impressionistic, featuring shimmering patterns of light and color that fragment the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0383065864443779 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.538306474685669 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0383065864443779, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0383065864443779, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2423074096441269, + 0.07765412330627441, + 0.09952791780233383, + 0.057261060923337936, + 0.045325469225645065, + 0.08528382331132889, + 0.05476350337266922, + 0.054315220564603806, + 0.1830810010433197, + 0.10048051178455353 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0383065864443779 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, drifting forward beneath the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the Great Barrier Reef with visible coral structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the coral structures rendered as a mosaic of soft pinks, deep violets, and warm oranges rather than clear biological forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are schools of fish depicted as fleeting blurs and swift streaks of pigment rather than individual creatures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style impressionistic, featuring shimmering patterns of light and color that fragment the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47419673204421997 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.97419673204422 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47419673204421997, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47419673204421997, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23789754509925842, + 0.0580899640917778, + 0.07317788898944855, + 0.1249920204281807, + 0.09237231314182281, + 0.04217197000980377, + 0.06134738028049469, + 0.043618232011795044, + 0.2321547418832779, + 0.03417801111936569 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47419673204421997 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, drifting forward beneath the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the Great Barrier Reef with visible coral structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the coral structures rendered as a mosaic of soft pinks, deep violets, and warm oranges rather than clear biological forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are schools of fish depicted as fleeting blurs and swift streaks of pigment rather than individual creatures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style impressionistic, featuring shimmering patterns of light and color that fragment the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013390155509114265 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626338958740234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013390155509114265, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013390155509114265, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3498431146144867, + 0.30089443922042847, + 0.04604431614279747, + 0.07722052931785583, + 0.024040553718805313, + 0.030857184901833534, + 0.0479658879339695, + 0.03094501420855522, + 0.05652473866939545, + 0.03566421568393707 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013390155509114265 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, drifting forward beneath the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the Great Barrier Reef with visible coral structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the coral structures rendered as a mosaic of soft pinks, deep violets, and warm oranges rather than clear biological forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are schools of fish depicted as fleeting blurs and swift streaks of pigment rather than individual creatures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style impressionistic, featuring shimmering patterns of light and color that fragment the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009777984581887722 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634778022766113 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009777984581887722, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009777984581887722, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24316725134849548, + 0.2509191036224365, + 0.11304693669080734, + 0.0356258787214756, + 0.06063930317759514, + 0.10589100420475006, + 0.0930350050330162, + 0.040747497230768204, + 0.039523735642433167, + 0.017404332756996155 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009777984581887722 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, drifting forward beneath the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the Great Barrier Reef with visible coral structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the coral structures rendered as a mosaic of soft pinks, deep violets, and warm oranges rather than clear biological forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are schools of fish depicted as fleeting blurs and swift streaks of pigment rather than individual creatures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style impressionistic, featuring shimmering patterns of light and color that fragment the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0009170140838250518 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.000916957855225 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0009170140838250518, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0009170140838250518, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12742909789085388, + 0.3228107690811157, + 0.02992941625416279, + 0.14366693794727325, + 0.04973810538649559, + 0.055487245321273804, + 0.06461066007614136, + 0.06817372888326645, + 0.06883654743432999, + 0.06931749731302261 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0009170140838250518 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Viewed from a first-person perspective, the camera executes a slow, continuous, and tranquil forward drift beneath the crystal-clear surface of the Great Barrier Reef. Rendered in a vibrant, impressionistic style, the entire scene transforms the underwater world into a living, breathing painting. Gentle ripples on the water above act like a dynamic lens, fragmenting the brilliant sunlight into a constant dance of shimmering, corrosive patterns that punctuate the seascape below. Coral structures lose their clear biological definition, dissolving into a breathtaking mosaic of textured colors and shifting light; vast fields of staghorn and brain coral appear as thick, visible splotches and swirls of soft pinks, deep violets, and warm oranges. Schools of fish are depicted not as individual creatures but as fleeting blurs and swift, ephemeral streaks of pure pigment. Flashes of electric blue and canary yellow dart across the turquoise water like the quick, deliberate strokes of a painter's brush. The atmosphere is one of profound tranquility and dreamlike beauty, where the boundaries between light, water, and life blur into a beautiful, ever-shifting synthesis of movement and color.", + "seed": 28845, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_8/index_9815_seed_28845_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08778171403100714, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08778171403100714, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08778171403100714, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, drifting forward beneath the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the Great Barrier Reef with visible coral structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the coral structures rendered as a mosaic of soft pinks, deep violets, and warm oranges rather than clear biological forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are schools of fish depicted as fleeting blurs and swift streaks of pigment rather than individual creatures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style impressionistic, featuring shimmering patterns of light and color that fragment the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04118741303682327 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4161875247955322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04118741303682327, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04118741303682327, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16518853604793549, + 0.2728945016860962, + 0.045315030962228775, + 0.12069378048181534, + 0.04502488300204277, + 0.17264872789382935, + 0.057003069669008255, + 0.016708293929696083, + 0.044547416269779205, + 0.059975773096084595 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04118741303682327 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, drifting forward beneath the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the Great Barrier Reef with visible coral structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the coral structures rendered as a mosaic of soft pinks, deep violets, and warm oranges rather than clear biological forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are schools of fish depicted as fleeting blurs and swift streaks of pigment rather than individual creatures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style impressionistic, featuring shimmering patterns of light and color that fragment the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870076835155487 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137007713317871 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3870076835155487, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3870076835155487, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13856923580169678, + 0.1460084468126297, + 0.09096528589725494, + 0.19557592272758484, + 0.09618391841650009, + 0.09401559829711914, + 0.023457543924450874, + 0.025750169530510902, + 0.11013790220022202, + 0.07933595031499863 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3870076835155487 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, drifting forward beneath the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the Great Barrier Reef with visible coral structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the coral structures rendered as a mosaic of soft pinks, deep violets, and warm oranges rather than clear biological forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are schools of fish depicted as fleeting blurs and swift streaks of pigment rather than individual creatures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style impressionistic, featuring shimmering patterns of light and color that fragment the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015170981641858816 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501517295837402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015170981641858816, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015170981641858816, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0815344825387001, + 0.0953705683350563, + 0.15071412920951843, + 0.06755607575178146, + 0.01946798339486122, + 0.09061244875192642, + 0.037739675492048264, + 0.030045295134186745, + 0.3819529712200165, + 0.04500632733106613 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015170981641858816 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, drifting forward beneath the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the Great Barrier Reef with visible coral structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the coral structures rendered as a mosaic of soft pinks, deep violets, and warm oranges rather than clear biological forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are schools of fish depicted as fleeting blurs and swift streaks of pigment rather than individual creatures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style impressionistic, featuring shimmering patterns of light and color that fragment the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00863863155245781 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758638858795166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00863863155245781, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00863863155245781, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15415401756763458, + 0.06166500225663185, + 0.043418291956186295, + 0.09448009729385376, + 0.0655270367860794, + 0.29141685366630554, + 0.03026222065091133, + 0.019601086154580116, + 0.1830051839351654, + 0.05647023394703865 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00863863155245781 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, drifting forward beneath the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the Great Barrier Reef with visible coral structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the coral structures rendered as a mosaic of soft pinks, deep violets, and warm oranges rather than clear biological forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are schools of fish depicted as fleeting blurs and swift streaks of pigment rather than individual creatures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style impressionistic, featuring shimmering patterns of light and color that fragment the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0005577438860200346 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.500557899475098 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0005577438860200346, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0005577438860200346, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25071221590042114, + 0.09859241545200348, + 0.06517263501882553, + 0.07112310081720352, + 0.030386051163077354, + 0.11601027846336365, + 0.030056672170758247, + 0.03723413869738579, + 0.2631463408470154, + 0.0375661700963974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0005577438860200346 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Viewed from a first-person perspective, the camera executes a slow, continuous, and tranquil forward drift beneath the crystal-clear surface of the Great Barrier Reef. Rendered in a vibrant, impressionistic style, the entire scene transforms the underwater world into a living, breathing painting. Gentle ripples on the water above act like a dynamic lens, fragmenting the brilliant sunlight into a constant dance of shimmering, corrosive patterns that punctuate the seascape below. Coral structures lose their clear biological definition, dissolving into a breathtaking mosaic of textured colors and shifting light; vast fields of staghorn and brain coral appear as thick, visible splotches and swirls of soft pinks, deep violets, and warm oranges. Schools of fish are depicted not as individual creatures but as fleeting blurs and swift, ephemeral streaks of pure pigment. Flashes of electric blue and canary yellow dart across the turquoise water like the quick, deliberate strokes of a painter's brush. The atmosphere is one of profound tranquility and dreamlike beauty, where the boundaries between light, water, and life blur into a beautiful, ever-shifting synthesis of movement and color.", + "seed": 28846, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_8/index_9815_seed_28846_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.3097013477701694, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3097013477701694, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3097013477701694, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, drifting forward beneath the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the Great Barrier Reef with visible coral structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the coral structures rendered as a mosaic of soft pinks, deep violets, and warm oranges rather than clear biological forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are schools of fish depicted as fleeting blurs and swift streaks of pigment rather than individual creatures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style impressionistic, featuring shimmering patterns of light and color that fragment the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12468327581882477 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.249683380126953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12468327581882477, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12468327581882477, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17669638991355896, + 0.030205262824892998, + 0.02536177448928356, + 0.015792686492204666, + 0.032995861023664474, + 0.008830099366605282, + 0.08113367110490799, + 0.011851171962916851, + 0.5324416756629944, + 0.08469142764806747 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12468327581882477 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, drifting forward beneath the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the Great Barrier Reef with visible coral structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the coral structures rendered as a mosaic of soft pinks, deep violets, and warm oranges rather than clear biological forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are schools of fish depicted as fleeting blurs and swift streaks of pigment rather than individual creatures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style impressionistic, featuring shimmering patterns of light and color that fragment the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4062451124191284 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2812451422214508 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.4062451124191284, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -1.4062451124191284, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12770147621631622, + 0.1080407127737999, + 0.1492825597524643, + 0.05517954006791115, + 0.03358776867389679, + 0.035062242299318314, + 0.19046784937381744, + 0.016454607248306274, + 0.1342533826828003, + 0.14996977150440216 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.4062451124191284 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, drifting forward beneath the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the Great Barrier Reef with visible coral structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the coral structures rendered as a mosaic of soft pinks, deep violets, and warm oranges rather than clear biological forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are schools of fish depicted as fleeting blurs and swift streaks of pigment rather than individual creatures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style impressionistic, featuring shimmering patterns of light and color that fragment the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028330450877547264 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877832889556885 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028330450877547264, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028330450877547264, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14470158517360687, + 0.1110750064253807, + 0.16904577612876892, + 0.05577228218317032, + 0.0683894157409668, + 0.029148327186703682, + 0.12185259163379669, + 0.02389596961438656, + 0.07840596139431, + 0.19771306216716766 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028330450877547264 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, drifting forward beneath the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the Great Barrier Reef with visible coral structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the coral structures rendered as a mosaic of soft pinks, deep violets, and warm oranges rather than clear biological forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are schools of fish depicted as fleeting blurs and swift streaks of pigment rather than individual creatures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style impressionistic, featuring shimmering patterns of light and color that fragment the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01254771463572979 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387547492980957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01254771463572979, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01254771463572979, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12981393933296204, + 0.1025034561753273, + 0.035599883645772934, + 0.026634028181433678, + 0.11631179600954056, + 0.045158661901950836, + 0.05119096860289574, + 0.03992843255400658, + 0.25960949063301086, + 0.1932494193315506 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01254771463572979 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, drifting forward beneath the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the Great Barrier Reef with visible coral structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the coral structures rendered as a mosaic of soft pinks, deep violets, and warm oranges rather than clear biological forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are schools of fish depicted as fleeting blurs and swift streaks of pigment rather than individual creatures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style impressionistic, featuring shimmering patterns of light and color that fragment the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021975908894091845 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127197742462158 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021975908894091845, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021975908894091845, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10492874681949615, + 0.0868028774857521, + 0.10406580567359924, + 0.043202899396419525, + 0.03485669568181038, + 0.012014970183372498, + 0.05323484167456627, + 0.020609769970178604, + 0.401828795671463, + 0.13845454156398773 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021975908894091845 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Viewed from a first-person perspective, the camera executes a slow, continuous, and tranquil forward drift beneath the crystal-clear surface of the Great Barrier Reef. Rendered in a vibrant, impressionistic style, the entire scene transforms the underwater world into a living, breathing painting. Gentle ripples on the water above act like a dynamic lens, fragmenting the brilliant sunlight into a constant dance of shimmering, corrosive patterns that punctuate the seascape below. Coral structures lose their clear biological definition, dissolving into a breathtaking mosaic of textured colors and shifting light; vast fields of staghorn and brain coral appear as thick, visible splotches and swirls of soft pinks, deep violets, and warm oranges. Schools of fish are depicted not as individual creatures but as fleeting blurs and swift, ephemeral streaks of pure pigment. Flashes of electric blue and canary yellow dart across the turquoise water like the quick, deliberate strokes of a painter's brush. The atmosphere is one of profound tranquility and dreamlike beauty, where the boundaries between light, water, and life blur into a beautiful, ever-shifting synthesis of movement and color.", + "seed": 28847, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_8/index_9815_seed_28847_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.08926403257064522, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08926403257064522, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08926403257064522, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, drifting forward beneath the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the Great Barrier Reef with visible coral structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the coral structures rendered as a mosaic of soft pinks, deep violets, and warm oranges rather than clear biological forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are schools of fish depicted as fleeting blurs and swift streaks of pigment rather than individual creatures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style impressionistic, featuring shimmering patterns of light and color that fragment the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0476723313331604 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4226722717285156 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0476723313331604, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0476723313331604, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12658818066120148, + 0.0345340371131897, + 0.022025903686881065, + 0.15142486989498138, + 0.07568958401679993, + 0.12477827072143555, + 0.05349966511130333, + 0.20816287398338318, + 0.08519263565540314, + 0.11810401827096939 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0476723313331604 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, drifting forward beneath the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the Great Barrier Reef with visible coral structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the coral structures rendered as a mosaic of soft pinks, deep violets, and warm oranges rather than clear biological forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are schools of fish depicted as fleeting blurs and swift streaks of pigment rather than individual creatures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style impressionistic, featuring shimmering patterns of light and color that fragment the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870002329349518 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370002031326294 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3870002329349518, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3870002329349518, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18237391114234924, + 0.04389497637748718, + 0.10702548176050186, + 0.15646876394748688, + 0.12311944365501404, + 0.09926820546388626, + 0.039398979395627975, + 0.19472721219062805, + 0.018331630155444145, + 0.03539135307073593 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3870002329349518 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, drifting forward beneath the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the Great Barrier Reef with visible coral structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the coral structures rendered as a mosaic of soft pinks, deep violets, and warm oranges rather than clear biological forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are schools of fish depicted as fleeting blurs and swift streaks of pigment rather than individual creatures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style impressionistic, featuring shimmering patterns of light and color that fragment the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022005646023899317 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127200603485107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022005646023899317, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022005646023899317, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08818680047988892, + 0.061583127826452255, + 0.0852227434515953, + 0.2795098125934601, + 0.07922625541687012, + 0.06656061112880707, + 0.049787577241659164, + 0.2079848349094391, + 0.0340302437543869, + 0.047908008098602295 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022005646023899317 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, drifting forward beneath the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the Great Barrier Reef with visible coral structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the coral structures rendered as a mosaic of soft pinks, deep violets, and warm oranges rather than clear biological forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are schools of fish depicted as fleeting blurs and swift streaks of pigment rather than individual creatures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style impressionistic, featuring shimmering patterns of light and color that fragment the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008636858314275742 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758636951446533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008636858314275742, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008636858314275742, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13954415917396545, + 0.02379053831100464, + 0.027348967269062996, + 0.19996821880340576, + 0.06047378480434418, + 0.06036949157714844, + 0.03243757411837578, + 0.3348251283168793, + 0.018428321927785873, + 0.10281386971473694 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008636858314275742 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, drifting forward beneath the water surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the Great Barrier Reef with visible coral structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the coral structures rendered as a mosaic of soft pinks, deep violets, and warm oranges rather than clear biological forms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are schools of fish depicted as fleeting blurs and swift streaks of pigment rather than individual creatures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style impressionistic, featuring shimmering patterns of light and color that fragment the sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0008101756684482098 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.125810146331787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0008101756684482098, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0008101756684482098, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10201416164636612, + 0.040286969393491745, + 0.046861276030540466, + 0.2940228283405304, + 0.07222439348697662, + 0.08961187303066254, + 0.04279090836644173, + 0.23579703271389008, + 0.024944880977272987, + 0.051445621997117996 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0008101756684482098 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_9/index_tensor([188, 188])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_9/index_tensor([188, 188])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c8b2a3dc59a924025e825512dc79d85ca9749c42 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_9/index_tensor([188, 188])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "stunning high-angle aerial photograph, as if taken from a drone, slowly tracks a lone mountain biker as he navigates a winding, narrow dirt path carved into the ridge of a vast, rugged mountain range. The low, late afternoon sun casts a warm golden hue over the epic landscape, casting long, dramatic shadows into the deep canyons below and illuminating the jagged, sun-scorched peaks in the distance. The riders, petite yet distinctive, clad in vibrant red windbreakers and black helmets, lean deliberately into the curves of the reddish-brown path, their bodies mere specks of determined movement. Their full-suspension mountain bikes, with their thick, knobby tires, steadily kick up a plume of light-colored ochre dust, capturing the whisper of golden light that follows them. The camera maintains its wide perspective, emphasizing the vastness of the wilderness and the solitary nature of the journey, creating a powerful atmosphere of awe, freedom, and the quiet endurance of humanity against the vastness of nature.", + "seed": 5572, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_9/index_188_seed_5572_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.12334454469382763, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12334454469382763, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12334454469382763, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a high-angle aerial perspective, as if taken from a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone mountain biker visible navigating a winding, narrow dirt path on a mountain ridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the rider and bike wearing vibrant red windbreakers and black helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a low, late afternoon sun casting a warm golden hue and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly track the biker while maintaining a wide perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007886581122875214 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1328864097595215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007886581122875214, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007886581122875214, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3330806493759155, + 0.039155103266239166, + 0.08203104138374329, + 0.06968555599451065, + 0.24666115641593933, + 0.018168332055211067, + 0.09660448879003525, + 0.06892430037260056, + 0.03009413555264473, + 0.015595260076224804 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007886581122875214 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a high-angle aerial perspective, as if taken from a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone mountain biker visible navigating a winding, narrow dirt path on a mountain ridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the rider and bike wearing vibrant red windbreakers and black helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a low, late afternoon sun casting a warm golden hue and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly track the biker while maintaining a wide perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308098554611206 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168081045150757 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308098554611206, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308098554611206, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6910528540611267, + 0.027433961629867554, + 0.05442877486348152, + 0.05472806096076965, + 0.022776247933506966, + 0.016363300383090973, + 0.014720759354531765, + 0.044514089822769165, + 0.027745582163333893, + 0.046236444264650345 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308098554611206 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a high-angle aerial perspective, as if taken from a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone mountain biker visible navigating a winding, narrow dirt path on a mountain ridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the rider and bike wearing vibrant red windbreakers and black helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a low, late afternoon sun casting a warm golden hue and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly track the biker while maintaining a wide perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5234071612358093 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8984071612358093 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5234071612358093, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5234071612358093, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7449498176574707, + 0.012184475548565388, + 0.03417953848838806, + 0.09557793289422989, + 0.013695912435650826, + 0.006304506212472916, + 0.019782477989792824, + 0.026101896539330482, + 0.02576473355293274, + 0.021458705887198448 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5234071612358093 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a high-angle aerial perspective, as if taken from a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone mountain biker visible navigating a winding, narrow dirt path on a mountain ridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the rider and bike wearing vibrant red windbreakers and black helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a low, late afternoon sun casting a warm golden hue and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly track the biker while maintaining a wide perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012547243386507034 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387547016143799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012547243386507034, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012547243386507034, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29685696959495544, + 0.1113283559679985, + 0.09767462313175201, + 0.06913775950670242, + 0.08545389771461487, + 0.018346304073929787, + 0.10490076243877411, + 0.02194470912218094, + 0.13506785035133362, + 0.059288736432790756 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012547243386507034 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a high-angle aerial perspective, as if taken from a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone mountain biker visible navigating a winding, narrow dirt path on a mountain ridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the rider and bike wearing vibrant red windbreakers and black helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a low, late afternoon sun casting a warm golden hue and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly track the biker while maintaining a wide perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980075217783451 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298006534576416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980075217783451, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980075217783451, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13871346414089203, + 0.0413525216281414, + 0.08395899832248688, + 0.15061260759830475, + 0.21429355442523956, + 0.07649620622396469, + 0.14386089146137238, + 0.05444622039794922, + 0.0653933733701706, + 0.030872205272316933 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980075217783451 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning high-angle aerial photograph, as if taken from a drone, slowly tracks a lone mountain biker as he navigates a winding, narrow dirt path carved into the ridge of a vast, rugged mountain range. The low, late afternoon sun casts a warm golden hue over the epic landscape, casting long, dramatic shadows into the deep canyons below and illuminating the jagged, sun-scorched peaks in the distance. The riders, petite yet distinctive, clad in vibrant red windbreakers and black helmets, lean deliberately into the curves of the reddish-brown path, their bodies mere specks of determined movement. Their full-suspension mountain bikes, with their thick, knobby tires, steadily kick up a plume of light-colored ochre dust, capturing the whisper of golden light that follows them. The camera maintains its wide perspective, emphasizing the vastness of the wilderness and the solitary nature of the journey, creating a powerful atmosphere of awe, freedom, and the quiet endurance of humanity against the vastness of nature.", + "seed": 5573, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_9/index_188_seed_5573_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08264557849615813, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08264557849615813, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08264557849615813, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a high-angle aerial perspective, as if taken from a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone mountain biker visible navigating a winding, narrow dirt path on a mountain ridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the rider and bike wearing vibrant red windbreakers and black helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a low, late afternoon sun casting a warm golden hue and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly track the biker while maintaining a wide perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012584914453327656 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.512584686279297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012584914453327656, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012584914453327656, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1603747010231018, + 0.043693941086530685, + 0.031001752242445946, + 0.046195901930332184, + 0.008095650933682919, + 0.031160691753029823, + 0.018019642680883408, + 0.010874416679143906, + 0.6195757389068604, + 0.03100760467350483 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012584914453327656 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a high-angle aerial perspective, as if taken from a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone mountain biker visible navigating a winding, narrow dirt path on a mountain ridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the rider and bike wearing vibrant red windbreakers and black helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a low, late afternoon sun casting a warm golden hue and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly track the biker while maintaining a wide perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308497905731201 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680850982666016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308497905731201, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308497905731201, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3518974184989929, + 0.08988022804260254, + 0.011871925555169582, + 0.01158024463802576, + 0.013540433719754219, + 0.020093150436878204, + 0.021558089181780815, + 0.020788878202438354, + 0.40302684903144836, + 0.055762678384780884 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308497905731201 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a high-angle aerial perspective, as if taken from a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone mountain biker visible navigating a winding, narrow dirt path on a mountain ridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the rider and bike wearing vibrant red windbreakers and black helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a low, late afternoon sun casting a warm golden hue and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly track the biker while maintaining a wide perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31350529193878174 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3135052919387817 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31350529193878174, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31350529193878174, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1906089335680008, + 0.23839960992336273, + 0.024340910837054253, + 0.033726464956998825, + 0.021052220836281776, + 0.03617861494421959, + 0.036182694137096405, + 0.02870650589466095, + 0.354457288980484, + 0.03634682297706604 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31350529193878174 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a high-angle aerial perspective, as if taken from a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone mountain biker visible navigating a winding, narrow dirt path on a mountain ridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the rider and bike wearing vibrant red windbreakers and black helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a low, late afternoon sun casting a warm golden hue and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly track the biker while maintaining a wide perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059540290385484695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130954265594482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059540290385484695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059540290385484695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07990852743387222, + 0.03662620857357979, + 0.0377533920109272, + 0.01921939104795456, + 0.018442142754793167, + 0.0437469445168972, + 0.21973657608032227, + 0.010474546812474728, + 0.4989452362060547, + 0.03514709696173668 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059540290385484695 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a high-angle aerial perspective, as if taken from a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone mountain biker visible navigating a winding, narrow dirt path on a mountain ridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the rider and bike wearing vibrant red windbreakers and black helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a low, late afternoon sun casting a warm golden hue and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly track the biker while maintaining a wide perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809867799282074 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880985736846924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809867799282074, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809867799282074, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11381147801876068, + 0.029310204088687897, + 0.022980932146310806, + 0.05488453060388565, + 0.01885572075843811, + 0.015953190624713898, + 0.014718017540872097, + 0.010821177624166012, + 0.6833679676055908, + 0.03529684245586395 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809867799282074 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning high-angle aerial photograph, as if taken from a drone, slowly tracks a lone mountain biker as he navigates a winding, narrow dirt path carved into the ridge of a vast, rugged mountain range. The low, late afternoon sun casts a warm golden hue over the epic landscape, casting long, dramatic shadows into the deep canyons below and illuminating the jagged, sun-scorched peaks in the distance. The riders, petite yet distinctive, clad in vibrant red windbreakers and black helmets, lean deliberately into the curves of the reddish-brown path, their bodies mere specks of determined movement. Their full-suspension mountain bikes, with their thick, knobby tires, steadily kick up a plume of light-colored ochre dust, capturing the whisper of golden light that follows them. The camera maintains its wide perspective, emphasizing the vastness of the wilderness and the solitary nature of the journey, creating a powerful atmosphere of awe, freedom, and the quiet endurance of humanity against the vastness of nature.", + "seed": 5574, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_9/index_188_seed_5574_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06507401708513498, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06507401708513498, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06507401708513498, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a high-angle aerial perspective, as if taken from a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone mountain biker visible navigating a winding, narrow dirt path on a mountain ridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the rider and bike wearing vibrant red windbreakers and black helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a low, late afternoon sun casting a warm golden hue and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly track the biker while maintaining a wide perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022512348368763924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.002251148223877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022512348368763924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022512348368763924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32310038805007935, + 0.04345855489373207, + 0.04134229198098183, + 0.1859901249408722, + 0.10754474997520447, + 0.050764359533786774, + 0.06408517807722092, + 0.0402374267578125, + 0.06635560095310211, + 0.07712134718894958 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022512348368763924 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a high-angle aerial perspective, as if taken from a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone mountain biker visible navigating a winding, narrow dirt path on a mountain ridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the rider and bike wearing vibrant red windbreakers and black helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a low, late afternoon sun casting a warm golden hue and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly track the biker while maintaining a wide perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029816025868058205 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529815912246704 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029816025868058205, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029816025868058205, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4351663291454315, + 0.03434784710407257, + 0.07940330356359482, + 0.08115901052951813, + 0.08366364240646362, + 0.0743560940027237, + 0.03461495414376259, + 0.06991665065288544, + 0.05132807046175003, + 0.05604413151741028 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029816025868058205 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a high-angle aerial perspective, as if taken from a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone mountain biker visible navigating a winding, narrow dirt path on a mountain ridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the rider and bike wearing vibrant red windbreakers and black helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a low, late afternoon sun casting a warm golden hue and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly track the biker while maintaining a wide perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521316707134247 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502131700515747 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521316707134247, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521316707134247, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3314693570137024, + 0.035496849566698074, + 0.055378250777721405, + 0.24543851613998413, + 0.07786958664655685, + 0.06254398822784424, + 0.046909820288419724, + 0.031002793461084366, + 0.054926589131355286, + 0.05896424502134323 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521316707134247 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a high-angle aerial perspective, as if taken from a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone mountain biker visible navigating a winding, narrow dirt path on a mountain ridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the rider and bike wearing vibrant red windbreakers and black helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a low, late afternoon sun casting a warm golden hue and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly track the biker while maintaining a wide perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020587796345353127 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895587682723999 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020587796345353127, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020587796345353127, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6003063917160034, + 0.039476148784160614, + 0.03239032253623009, + 0.07465705275535583, + 0.026018256321549416, + 0.03900820016860962, + 0.05065787583589554, + 0.030053433030843735, + 0.05447457730770111, + 0.05295778065919876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020587796345353127 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a high-angle aerial perspective, as if taken from a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone mountain biker visible navigating a winding, narrow dirt path on a mountain ridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the rider and bike wearing vibrant red windbreakers and black helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a low, late afternoon sun casting a warm golden hue and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly track the biker while maintaining a wide perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058335766196251 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895583391189575 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058335766196251, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058335766196251, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33069971203804016, + 0.05325255170464516, + 0.03175726160407066, + 0.09555959701538086, + 0.12662765383720398, + 0.06873534619808197, + 0.07435517758131027, + 0.05936180800199509, + 0.08390101045370102, + 0.07574988901615143 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058335766196251 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning high-angle aerial photograph, as if taken from a drone, slowly tracks a lone mountain biker as he navigates a winding, narrow dirt path carved into the ridge of a vast, rugged mountain range. The low, late afternoon sun casts a warm golden hue over the epic landscape, casting long, dramatic shadows into the deep canyons below and illuminating the jagged, sun-scorched peaks in the distance. The riders, petite yet distinctive, clad in vibrant red windbreakers and black helmets, lean deliberately into the curves of the reddish-brown path, their bodies mere specks of determined movement. Their full-suspension mountain bikes, with their thick, knobby tires, steadily kick up a plume of light-colored ochre dust, capturing the whisper of golden light that follows them. The camera maintains its wide perspective, emphasizing the vastness of the wilderness and the solitary nature of the journey, creating a powerful atmosphere of awe, freedom, and the quiet endurance of humanity against the vastness of nature.", + "seed": 5575, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000096/group_9/index_188_seed_5575_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10560987959615886, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10560987959615886, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9499999940395356, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10560987959615886, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a high-angle aerial perspective, as if taken from a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone mountain biker visible navigating a winding, narrow dirt path on a mountain ridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the rider and bike wearing vibrant red windbreakers and black helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a low, late afternoon sun casting a warm golden hue and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly track the biker while maintaining a wide perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003220373997464776 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.503220558166504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003220373997464776, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003220373997464776, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10287005454301834, + 0.05994855985045433, + 0.06111831218004227, + 0.15586122870445251, + 0.21645106375217438, + 0.08651084452867508, + 0.04512615129351616, + 0.024531662464141846, + 0.09457218647003174, + 0.15300996601581573 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003220373997464776 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a high-angle aerial perspective, as if taken from a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone mountain biker visible navigating a winding, narrow dirt path on a mountain ridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the rider and bike wearing vibrant red windbreakers and black helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a low, late afternoon sun casting a warm golden hue and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly track the biker while maintaining a wide perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026354322209954262 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513543128967285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026354322209954262, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026354322209954262, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0991574078798294, + 0.04325295612215996, + 0.09766929596662521, + 0.1551879644393921, + 0.0749717727303505, + 0.05582369491457939, + 0.07132319360971451, + 0.044611409306526184, + 0.10550994426012039, + 0.25249242782592773 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026354322209954262 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a high-angle aerial perspective, as if taken from a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone mountain biker visible navigating a winding, narrow dirt path on a mountain ridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the rider and bike wearing vibrant red windbreakers and black helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a low, late afternoon sun casting a warm golden hue and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly track the biker while maintaining a wide perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47433963418006897 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9743396043777466 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47433963418006897, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.4999999701976776, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47433963418006897, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13353978097438812, + 0.043723542243242264, + 0.040772609412670135, + 0.06581432372331619, + 0.06140940263867378, + 0.09240354597568512, + 0.059749536216259, + 0.03992503881454468, + 0.30716100335121155, + 0.15550123155117035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47433963418006897 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a high-angle aerial perspective, as if taken from a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone mountain biker visible navigating a winding, narrow dirt path on a mountain ridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the rider and bike wearing vibrant red windbreakers and black helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a low, late afternoon sun casting a warm golden hue and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly track the biker while maintaining a wide perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005949051585048437 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130949020385742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005949051585048437, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005949051585048437, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07771731913089752, + 0.0386669747531414, + 0.04583121836185455, + 0.08069422841072083, + 0.19489362835884094, + 0.328752726316452, + 0.04323189705610275, + 0.016692284494638443, + 0.08719261735677719, + 0.08632704615592957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005949051585048437 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a high-angle aerial perspective, as if taken from a drone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone mountain biker visible navigating a winding, narrow dirt path on a mountain ridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the rider and bike wearing vibrant red windbreakers and black helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a low, late afternoon sun casting a warm golden hue and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly track the biker while maintaining a wide perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018186016008257866 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018186092376709 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018186016008257866, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018186016008257866, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17449921369552612, + 0.074589803814888, + 0.09723573923110962, + 0.09805046021938324, + 0.14051397144794464, + 0.1442909687757492, + 0.05598455294966698, + 0.05158185958862305, + 0.049483221024274826, + 0.11377016454935074 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018186016008257866 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_0/index_tensor([6375, 6375])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_0/index_tensor([6375, 6375])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..834073f15972efd67cb24262e18353032758d843 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_0/index_tensor([6375, 6375])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "powerful shot begins with a close-up overhead shot of a distorted face. The Six-Fingered Qin Demon raises his head, roaring silently into the swirling blood-red clouds. His long, untidy black hair whips wildly in the unearthly wind, every muscle on his face tensed with utter fury, veins bulging from his forehead. The camera then smoothly pans upward and back, revealing his entire form—clothed in a tattered dark crimson robe, he stands alone atop the ruins of a vast ancient building. His gaze is frantic, as his right hand, rumored to have an extra finger, frantically strums the strings of an ancient black guqin before him at a speed barely tangible. Each plucking unleashes visible, blade-like, white sonic waves. These ripples of energy tear through the surrounding air, instantly severing the flying dust and debris, a perfect illustration of the aesthetics of destructive violence. As the camera continues to rise, a despairing panorama unfolds before his eyes: the entire mountaintop beneath his feet is collapsing, huge rocks and broken ground are constantly falling into the bottomless dark abyss below, and the whole world is heading towards destruction in his furious piano music, creating a grand and tragic atmosphere of the coming of doomsday.", + "seed": 22232, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_0/index_6375_seed_22232_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0465504439547658, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0465504439547658, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0465504439547658, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a Six-Fingered Qin Demon with long, untidy black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a tattered dark crimson robe and standing atop the ruins of an ancient building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character playing an ancient black guqin with his right hand, which has an extra finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible, blade-like white sonic waves generated by the guqin that sever flying dust and debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up overhead shot and then smoothly pan upward and back to reveal the collapsing mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08988481760025024 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4648847579956055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08988481760025024, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08988481760025024, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3736550807952881, + 0.11458858102560043, + 0.07033892720937729, + 0.07431937009096146, + 0.08233591914176941, + 0.08171741664409637, + 0.029806531965732574, + 0.04068003594875336, + 0.05247766152024269, + 0.08008045703172684 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08988481760025024 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a Six-Fingered Qin Demon with long, untidy black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a tattered dark crimson robe and standing atop the ruins of an ancient building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character playing an ancient black guqin with his right hand, which has an extra finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible, blade-like white sonic waves generated by the guqin that sever flying dust and debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up overhead shot and then smoothly pan upward and back to reveal the collapsing mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009798524901270866 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634798526763916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009798524901270866, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009798524901270866, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2641300559043884, + 0.14397312700748444, + 0.20182304084300995, + 0.04083599895238876, + 0.060828860849142075, + 0.038453102111816406, + 0.02419002540409565, + 0.04529538005590439, + 0.09168235212564468, + 0.08878810703754425 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009798524901270866 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a Six-Fingered Qin Demon with long, untidy black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a tattered dark crimson robe and standing atop the ruins of an ancient building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character playing an ancient black guqin with his right hand, which has an extra finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible, blade-like white sonic waves generated by the guqin that sever flying dust and debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up overhead shot and then smoothly pan upward and back to reveal the collapsing mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012543476186692715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387543678283691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012543476186692715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012543476186692715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2773193120956421, + 0.058081500232219696, + 0.06695858389139175, + 0.23974499106407166, + 0.10790365934371948, + 0.056142475455999374, + 0.04107354208827019, + 0.03581240773200989, + 0.04737337678670883, + 0.06959015130996704 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012543476186692715 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a Six-Fingered Qin Demon with long, untidy black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a tattered dark crimson robe and standing atop the ruins of an ancient building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character playing an ancient black guqin with his right hand, which has an extra finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible, blade-like white sonic waves generated by the guqin that sever flying dust and debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up overhead shot and then smoothly pan upward and back to reveal the collapsing mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007627766579389572 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882627964019775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007627766579389572, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007627766579389572, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28459760546684265, + 0.0550706647336483, + 0.02218276634812355, + 0.05121305212378502, + 0.0341288186609745, + 0.13004808127880096, + 0.04767066240310669, + 0.10158252716064453, + 0.1642579883337021, + 0.10924782603979111 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007627766579389572 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a Six-Fingered Qin Demon with long, untidy black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a tattered dark crimson robe and standing atop the ruins of an ancient building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character playing an ancient black guqin with his right hand, which has an extra finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible, blade-like white sonic waves generated by the guqin that sever flying dust and debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up overhead shot and then smoothly pan upward and back to reveal the collapsing mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11289763450622559 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2378976345062256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11289763450622559, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11289763450622559, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37815728783607483, + 0.09522368758916855, + 0.04259159415960312, + 0.05270155146718025, + 0.06553170830011368, + 0.05306949466466904, + 0.02227339707314968, + 0.031671710312366486, + 0.12897460162639618, + 0.1298050880432129 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11289763450622559 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful shot begins with a close-up overhead shot of a distorted face. The Six-Fingered Qin Demon raises his head, roaring silently into the swirling blood-red clouds. His long, untidy black hair whips wildly in the unearthly wind, every muscle on his face tensed with utter fury, veins bulging from his forehead. The camera then smoothly pans upward and back, revealing his entire form—clothed in a tattered dark crimson robe, he stands alone atop the ruins of a vast ancient building. His gaze is frantic, as his right hand, rumored to have an extra finger, frantically strums the strings of an ancient black guqin before him at a speed barely tangible. Each plucking unleashes visible, blade-like, white sonic waves. These ripples of energy tear through the surrounding air, instantly severing the flying dust and debris, a perfect illustration of the aesthetics of destructive violence. As the camera continues to rise, a despairing panorama unfolds before his eyes: the entire mountaintop beneath his feet is collapsing, huge rocks and broken ground are constantly falling into the bottomless dark abyss below, and the whole world is heading towards destruction in his furious piano music, creating a grand and tragic atmosphere of the coming of doomsday.", + "seed": 22233, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_0/index_6375_seed_22233_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.028251911606639625, + "vlm_logprob": -0.028251911606639625, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.028251911606639625, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a Six-Fingered Qin Demon with long, untidy black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a tattered dark crimson robe and standing atop the ruins of an ancient building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character playing an ancient black guqin with his right hand, which has an extra finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible, blade-like white sonic waves generated by the guqin that sever flying dust and debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up overhead shot and then smoothly pan upward and back to reveal the collapsing mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08996816724538803 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464968204498291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08996816724538803, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08996816724538803, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1360597312450409, + 0.04401612654328346, + 0.03019585832953453, + 0.07611596584320068, + 0.47628986835479736, + 0.0565154030919075, + 0.0212949700653553, + 0.04291009530425072, + 0.06127217039465904, + 0.0553298182785511 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08996816724538803 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a Six-Fingered Qin Demon with long, untidy black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a tattered dark crimson robe and standing atop the ruins of an ancient building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character playing an ancient black guqin with his right hand, which has an extra finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible, blade-like white sonic waves generated by the guqin that sever flying dust and debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up overhead shot and then smoothly pan upward and back to reveal the collapsing mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004103692714124918 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504103660583496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004103692714124918, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004103692714124918, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12748615443706512, + 0.04651800915598869, + 0.18644796311855316, + 0.1233690157532692, + 0.23340703547000885, + 0.04320957139134407, + 0.01597960665822029, + 0.07393456250429153, + 0.09543453902006149, + 0.05421357974410057 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004103692714124918 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a Six-Fingered Qin Demon with long, untidy black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a tattered dark crimson robe and standing atop the ruins of an ancient building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character playing an ancient black guqin with his right hand, which has an extra finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible, blade-like white sonic waves generated by the guqin that sever flying dust and debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up overhead shot and then smoothly pan upward and back to reveal the collapsing mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009781407192349434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634781360626221 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009781407192349434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009781407192349434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07384219765663147, + 0.06341833621263504, + 0.04885431006550789, + 0.1399139165878296, + 0.309733510017395, + 0.07282537966966629, + 0.07198049128055573, + 0.07370763272047043, + 0.09293531626462936, + 0.05278898403048515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009781407192349434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a Six-Fingered Qin Demon with long, untidy black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a tattered dark crimson robe and standing atop the ruins of an ancient building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character playing an ancient black guqin with his right hand, which has an extra finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible, blade-like white sonic waves generated by the guqin that sever flying dust and debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up overhead shot and then smoothly pan upward and back to reveal the collapsing mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026340274140238762 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513402462005615 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026340274140238762, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026340274140238762, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06399117410182953, + 0.12083376944065094, + 0.0842902809381485, + 0.05111069604754448, + 0.20356260240077972, + 0.07218505442142487, + 0.031021246686577797, + 0.050290949642658234, + 0.1440034657716751, + 0.17871081829071045 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026340274140238762 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a Six-Fingered Qin Demon with long, untidy black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a tattered dark crimson robe and standing atop the ruins of an ancient building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character playing an ancient black guqin with his right hand, which has an extra finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible, blade-like white sonic waves generated by the guqin that sever flying dust and debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up overhead shot and then smoothly pan upward and back to reveal the collapsing mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011066016741096973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51106595993042 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011066016741096973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011066016741096973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27686747908592224, + 0.07731392234563828, + 0.03481706976890564, + 0.08669746667146683, + 0.07413297146558762, + 0.06114755943417549, + 0.08127572387456894, + 0.06647071242332458, + 0.12148444354534149, + 0.1197926327586174 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011066016741096973 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful shot begins with a close-up overhead shot of a distorted face. The Six-Fingered Qin Demon raises his head, roaring silently into the swirling blood-red clouds. His long, untidy black hair whips wildly in the unearthly wind, every muscle on his face tensed with utter fury, veins bulging from his forehead. The camera then smoothly pans upward and back, revealing his entire form—clothed in a tattered dark crimson robe, he stands alone atop the ruins of a vast ancient building. His gaze is frantic, as his right hand, rumored to have an extra finger, frantically strums the strings of an ancient black guqin before him at a speed barely tangible. Each plucking unleashes visible, blade-like, white sonic waves. These ripples of energy tear through the surrounding air, instantly severing the flying dust and debris, a perfect illustration of the aesthetics of destructive violence. As the camera continues to rise, a despairing panorama unfolds before his eyes: the entire mountaintop beneath his feet is collapsing, huge rocks and broken ground are constantly falling into the bottomless dark abyss below, and the whole world is heading towards destruction in his furious piano music, creating a grand and tragic atmosphere of the coming of doomsday.", + "seed": 22234, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_0/index_6375_seed_22234_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.02691714009270072, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02691714009270072, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8999999523162843, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02691714009270072, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a Six-Fingered Qin Demon with long, untidy black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a tattered dark crimson robe and standing atop the ruins of an ancient building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character playing an ancient black guqin with his right hand, which has an extra finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible, blade-like white sonic waves generated by the guqin that sever flying dust and debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up overhead shot and then smoothly pan upward and back to reveal the collapsing mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06258491426706314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.81258487701416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06258491426706314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06258491426706314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3090377449989319, + 0.12663701176643372, + 0.1041472777724266, + 0.036827243864536285, + 0.2171507477760315, + 0.019364546984434128, + 0.03788762912154198, + 0.07569408416748047, + 0.048527225852012634, + 0.02472652494907379 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06258491426706314 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a Six-Fingered Qin Demon with long, untidy black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a tattered dark crimson robe and standing atop the ruins of an ancient building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character playing an ancient black guqin with his right hand, which has an extra finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible, blade-like white sonic waves generated by the guqin that sever flying dust and debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up overhead shot and then smoothly pan upward and back to reveal the collapsing mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005956872832030058 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130956649780273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005956872832030058, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005956872832030058, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30947139859199524, + 0.05645284801721573, + 0.07551772892475128, + 0.07608456164598465, + 0.16868248581886292, + 0.05337997153401375, + 0.04345826059579849, + 0.04356715828180313, + 0.08080198615789413, + 0.0925835520029068 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005956872832030058 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a Six-Fingered Qin Demon with long, untidy black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a tattered dark crimson robe and standing atop the ruins of an ancient building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character playing an ancient black guqin with his right hand, which has an extra finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible, blade-like white sonic waves generated by the guqin that sever flying dust and debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up overhead shot and then smoothly pan upward and back to reveal the collapsing mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818203739821911 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018181800842285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818203739821911, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818203739821911, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18363326787948608, + 0.06413375586271286, + 0.2663719058036804, + 0.035556674003601074, + 0.10206355899572372, + 0.05105658248066902, + 0.042386628687381744, + 0.10199291259050369, + 0.09490534663200378, + 0.057899363338947296 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818203739821911 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a Six-Fingered Qin Demon with long, untidy black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a tattered dark crimson robe and standing atop the ruins of an ancient building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character playing an ancient black guqin with his right hand, which has an extra finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible, blade-like white sonic waves generated by the guqin that sever flying dust and debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up overhead shot and then smoothly pan upward and back to reveal the collapsing mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014186250045895576 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264186382293701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014186250045895576, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014186250045895576, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1196741908788681, + 0.02973843179643154, + 0.13648083806037903, + 0.039500534534454346, + 0.24740959703922272, + 0.07195670157670975, + 0.06041252985596657, + 0.16484403610229492, + 0.06223434582352638, + 0.06774887442588806 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014186250045895576 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a Six-Fingered Qin Demon with long, untidy black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a tattered dark crimson robe and standing atop the ruins of an ancient building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character playing an ancient black guqin with his right hand, which has an extra finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible, blade-like white sonic waves generated by the guqin that sever flying dust and debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up overhead shot and then smoothly pan upward and back to reveal the collapsing mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033675625920295715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086756706237793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033675625920295715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033675625920295715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17061851918697357, + 0.03436542674899101, + 0.02523753046989441, + 0.05161317437887192, + 0.20644481480121613, + 0.09555923193693161, + 0.1211441233754158, + 0.10975776612758636, + 0.14195409417152405, + 0.04330529645085335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033675625920295715 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful shot begins with a close-up overhead shot of a distorted face. The Six-Fingered Qin Demon raises his head, roaring silently into the swirling blood-red clouds. His long, untidy black hair whips wildly in the unearthly wind, every muscle on his face tensed with utter fury, veins bulging from his forehead. The camera then smoothly pans upward and back, revealing his entire form—clothed in a tattered dark crimson robe, he stands alone atop the ruins of a vast ancient building. His gaze is frantic, as his right hand, rumored to have an extra finger, frantically strums the strings of an ancient black guqin before him at a speed barely tangible. Each plucking unleashes visible, blade-like, white sonic waves. These ripples of energy tear through the surrounding air, instantly severing the flying dust and debris, a perfect illustration of the aesthetics of destructive violence. As the camera continues to rise, a despairing panorama unfolds before his eyes: the entire mountaintop beneath his feet is collapsing, huge rocks and broken ground are constantly falling into the bottomless dark abyss below, and the whole world is heading towards destruction in his furious piano music, creating a grand and tragic atmosphere of the coming of doomsday.", + "seed": 22235, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_0/index_6375_seed_22235_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06467021852731705, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06467021852731705, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06467021852731705, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a Six-Fingered Qin Demon with long, untidy black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a tattered dark crimson robe and standing atop the ruins of an ancient building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character playing an ancient black guqin with his right hand, which has an extra finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible, blade-like white sonic waves generated by the guqin that sever flying dust and debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up overhead shot and then smoothly pan upward and back to reveal the collapsing mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22615529596805573 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6011552810668945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22615529596805573, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22615529596805573, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2952020764350891, + 0.23660074174404144, + 0.061107948422431946, + 0.10736977308988571, + 0.05548148602247238, + 0.03128416836261749, + 0.020781612023711205, + 0.08027015626430511, + 0.024552220478653908, + 0.08734986931085587 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22615529596805573 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a Six-Fingered Qin Demon with long, untidy black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a tattered dark crimson robe and standing atop the ruins of an ancient building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character playing an ancient black guqin with his right hand, which has an extra finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible, blade-like white sonic waves generated by the guqin that sever flying dust and debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up overhead shot and then smoothly pan upward and back to reveal the collapsing mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009795691817998886 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634795665740967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009795691817998886, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009795691817998886, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11278537660837173, + 0.04924760386347771, + 0.04921462759375572, + 0.05468960106372833, + 0.052021052688360214, + 0.028049664571881294, + 0.028387445956468582, + 0.0509931854903698, + 0.5215848684310913, + 0.05302654951810837 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009795691817998886 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a Six-Fingered Qin Demon with long, untidy black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a tattered dark crimson robe and standing atop the ruins of an ancient building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character playing an ancient black guqin with his right hand, which has an extra finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible, blade-like white sonic waves generated by the guqin that sever flying dust and debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up overhead shot and then smoothly pan upward and back to reveal the collapsing mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819257251918316 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018192768096924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819257251918316, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819257251918316, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18536430597305298, + 0.09312652051448822, + 0.046308498829603195, + 0.11316346377134323, + 0.0853053480386734, + 0.037967827171087265, + 0.0734868049621582, + 0.16550803184509277, + 0.09382947534322739, + 0.10593972355127335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819257251918316 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a Six-Fingered Qin Demon with long, untidy black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a tattered dark crimson robe and standing atop the ruins of an ancient building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character playing an ancient black guqin with his right hand, which has an extra finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible, blade-like white sonic waves generated by the guqin that sever flying dust and debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up overhead shot and then smoothly pan upward and back to reveal the collapsing mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020577168092131615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955771923065186 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020577168092131615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020577168092131615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10544495284557343, + 0.04407127574086189, + 0.06888438016176224, + 0.06399944424629211, + 0.06165993586182594, + 0.07173771411180496, + 0.19017431139945984, + 0.08236867189407349, + 0.1894632875919342, + 0.12219595164060593 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020577168092131615 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as a Six-Fingered Qin Demon with long, untidy black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a tattered dark crimson robe and standing atop the ruins of an ancient building?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character playing an ancient black guqin with his right hand, which has an extra finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are visible, blade-like white sonic waves generated by the guqin that sever flying dust and debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up overhead shot and then smoothly pan upward and back to reveal the collapsing mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04863036423921585 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048630475997925 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04863036423921585, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04863036423921585, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08537860959768295, + 0.03783359006047249, + 0.061017412692308426, + 0.05193261057138443, + 0.08940474689006805, + 0.026551365852355957, + 0.07982959598302841, + 0.07943403720855713, + 0.404093861579895, + 0.08452412486076355 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04863036423921585 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_1/index_tensor([996, 996])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_1/index_tensor([996, 996])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..574b1cd1aa9f761ff745e82cede05d60f1a8b8b0 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_1/index_tensor([996, 996])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, intimate close-up, angled slightly downward, captures a pair of slender hands methodically arranging a section of a towering, dark mahogany bookshelf. The skin of the hands is pale and smooth, the movements cautious and gentle. One hand carefully pushes a thick, crimson, leather-bound volume, its spine showing the slight cracks of age and embossed with unremarkable traces of faded gold leaf filigree, until its edge is perfectly flush with the adjacent one. Warm, soft light, as if from a nearby blackout lamp, casts a focused golden glow, highlighting the rich texture of the leather spines—from deep forest green to worn brown—and creating a soft sheen on the manicured fingernails. As the first hand holds the book in place, the fingers of the other delicately trace along the top edge of the aligned volume, ensuring a perfectly flat surface. The background is a soft-focus blur of more books and dark wood, enhancing the shallow depth of field and focusing the viewer's attention on the meticulous action, evoking an atmosphere of tranquility, concentration, and scholarship, imbued with the scent of old paper and leather.", + "seed": 23523, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_1/index_996_seed_23523_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.009665530361235141, + "vlm_logprob": -0.009665530361235141, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.009665530361235141, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands visible arranging books on a dark mahogany bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one hand pushing a thick, crimson, leather-bound volume with a spine showing cracks and faded gold leaf filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the other hand delicately trace along the top edge of the aligned volume to ensure a flat surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and soft, casting a focused golden glow that highlights the texture of the leather spines and manicured fingernails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, intimate close-up angled slightly downward with a soft-focus blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008268646895885468 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0082688331604 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008268646895885468, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008268646895885468, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04526692256331444, + 0.029542218893766403, + 0.02731744758784771, + 0.047122836112976074, + 0.05630144476890564, + 0.11714276671409607, + 0.11427595466375351, + 0.46201571822166443, + 0.0852261558175087, + 0.01578853838145733 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008268646895885468 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands visible arranging books on a dark mahogany bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one hand pushing a thick, crimson, leather-bound volume with a spine showing cracks and faded gold leaf filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the other hand delicately trace along the top edge of the aligned volume to ensure a flat surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and soft, casting a focused golden glow that highlights the texture of the leather spines and manicured fingernails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, intimate close-up angled slightly downward with a soft-focus blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014247128739953041 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264246940612793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014247128739953041, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014247128739953041, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03377639874815941, + 0.12380994856357574, + 0.11671178042888641, + 0.05639409273862839, + 0.07298047840595245, + 0.1981915682554245, + 0.12090343981981277, + 0.12601397931575775, + 0.09425142407417297, + 0.05696684867143631 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014247128739953041 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands visible arranging books on a dark mahogany bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one hand pushing a thick, crimson, leather-bound volume with a spine showing cracks and faded gold leaf filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the other hand delicately trace along the top edge of the aligned volume to ensure a flat surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and soft, casting a focused golden glow that highlights the texture of the leather spines and manicured fingernails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, intimate close-up angled slightly downward with a soft-focus blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012542416341602802 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387542247772217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012542416341602802, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012542416341602802, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.038623351603746414, + 0.07262083142995834, + 0.04860931634902954, + 0.05222586914896965, + 0.15869420766830444, + 0.040571317076683044, + 0.21297042071819305, + 0.25413429737091064, + 0.08329638838768005, + 0.038253992795944214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012542416341602802 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands visible arranging books on a dark mahogany bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one hand pushing a thick, crimson, leather-bound volume with a spine showing cracks and faded gold leaf filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the other hand delicately trace along the top edge of the aligned volume to ensure a flat surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and soft, casting a focused golden glow that highlights the texture of the leather spines and manicured fingernails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, intimate close-up angled slightly downward with a soft-focus blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00463933777064085 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379639148712158 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00463933777064085, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00463933777064085, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.053002554923295975, + 0.03867540508508682, + 0.054721035063266754, + 0.09364099055528641, + 0.03563383221626282, + 0.07211706787347794, + 0.10760951787233353, + 0.4243973195552826, + 0.09623609483242035, + 0.023966174572706223 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00463933777064085 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands visible arranging books on a dark mahogany bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one hand pushing a thick, crimson, leather-bound volume with a spine showing cracks and faded gold leaf filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the other hand delicately trace along the top edge of the aligned volume to ensure a flat surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and soft, casting a focused golden glow that highlights the texture of the leather spines and manicured fingernails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, intimate close-up angled slightly downward with a soft-focus blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008630122058093548 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758630275726318 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008630122058093548, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008630122058093548, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03587688133120537, + 0.06292257457971573, + 0.010238501243293285, + 0.029139798134565353, + 0.04118972271680832, + 0.1279110163450241, + 0.06781800091266632, + 0.3831019401550293, + 0.20734788477420807, + 0.03445364907383919 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008630122058093548 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, intimate close-up, angled slightly downward, captures a pair of slender hands methodically arranging a section of a towering, dark mahogany bookshelf. The skin of the hands is pale and smooth, the movements cautious and gentle. One hand carefully pushes a thick, crimson, leather-bound volume, its spine showing the slight cracks of age and embossed with unremarkable traces of faded gold leaf filigree, until its edge is perfectly flush with the adjacent one. Warm, soft light, as if from a nearby blackout lamp, casts a focused golden glow, highlighting the rich texture of the leather spines—from deep forest green to worn brown—and creating a soft sheen on the manicured fingernails. As the first hand holds the book in place, the fingers of the other delicately trace along the top edge of the aligned volume, ensuring a perfectly flat surface. The background is a soft-focus blur of more books and dark wood, enhancing the shallow depth of field and focusing the viewer's attention on the meticulous action, evoking an atmosphere of tranquility, concentration, and scholarship, imbued with the scent of old paper and leather.", + "seed": 23524, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_1/index_996_seed_23524_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.011915897484868765, + "vlm_logprob": -0.011915897484868765, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.011915897484868765, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands visible arranging books on a dark mahogany bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one hand pushing a thick, crimson, leather-bound volume with a spine showing cracks and faded gold leaf filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the other hand delicately trace along the top edge of the aligned volume to ensure a flat surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and soft, casting a focused golden glow that highlights the texture of the leather spines and manicured fingernails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, intimate close-up angled slightly downward with a soft-focus blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013281329534947872 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.388281345367432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013281329534947872, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013281329534947872, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1539236605167389, + 0.1059311255812645, + 0.07987474650144577, + 0.09685462713241577, + 0.057933785021305084, + 0.0464746430516243, + 0.3528189957141876, + 0.03216644749045372, + 0.03252934291958809, + 0.04149268567562103 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013281329534947872 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands visible arranging books on a dark mahogany bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one hand pushing a thick, crimson, leather-bound volume with a spine showing cracks and faded gold leaf filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the other hand delicately trace along the top edge of the aligned volume to ensure a flat surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and soft, casting a focused golden glow that highlights the texture of the leather spines and manicured fingernails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, intimate close-up angled slightly downward with a soft-focus blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01611974835395813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141119956970215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01611974835395813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01611974835395813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24021808803081512, + 0.04750382900238037, + 0.07712475210428238, + 0.06299689412117004, + 0.07175233215093613, + 0.053166333585977554, + 0.08949273824691772, + 0.26599767804145813, + 0.018284695222973824, + 0.07346265017986298 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01611974835395813 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands visible arranging books on a dark mahogany bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one hand pushing a thick, crimson, leather-bound volume with a spine showing cracks and faded gold leaf filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the other hand delicately trace along the top edge of the aligned volume to ensure a flat surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and soft, casting a focused golden glow that highlights the texture of the leather spines and manicured fingernails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, intimate close-up angled slightly downward with a soft-focus blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018193040043115616 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018193244934082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018193040043115616, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018193040043115616, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09625726193189621, + 0.06870138645172119, + 0.07377751171588898, + 0.07044153660535812, + 0.08392820507287979, + 0.04033474251627922, + 0.17744037508964539, + 0.27793246507644653, + 0.035744354128837585, + 0.07544213533401489 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018193040043115616 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands visible arranging books on a dark mahogany bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one hand pushing a thick, crimson, leather-bound volume with a spine showing cracks and faded gold leaf filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the other hand delicately trace along the top edge of the aligned volume to ensure a flat surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and soft, casting a focused golden glow that highlights the texture of the leather spines and manicured fingernails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, intimate close-up angled slightly downward with a soft-focus blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005256047938019037 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255256175994873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005256047938019037, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005256047938019037, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3060254752635956, + 0.08977160602807999, + 0.07563727349042892, + 0.09268923103809357, + 0.08555533736944199, + 0.04459863156080246, + 0.048377782106399536, + 0.14813339710235596, + 0.031161518767476082, + 0.07804980129003525 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005256047938019037 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands visible arranging books on a dark mahogany bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one hand pushing a thick, crimson, leather-bound volume with a spine showing cracks and faded gold leaf filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the other hand delicately trace along the top edge of the aligned volume to ensure a flat surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and soft, casting a focused golden glow that highlights the texture of the leather spines and manicured fingernails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, intimate close-up angled slightly downward with a soft-focus blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006729321554303169 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067291259765625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006729321554303169, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006729321554303169, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2201663702726364, + 0.066552072763443, + 0.055361974984407425, + 0.027835723012685776, + 0.04836234450340271, + 0.039464764297008514, + 0.044583920389413834, + 0.4311104416847229, + 0.034099508076906204, + 0.03246285021305084 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006729321554303169 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, intimate close-up, angled slightly downward, captures a pair of slender hands methodically arranging a section of a towering, dark mahogany bookshelf. The skin of the hands is pale and smooth, the movements cautious and gentle. One hand carefully pushes a thick, crimson, leather-bound volume, its spine showing the slight cracks of age and embossed with unremarkable traces of faded gold leaf filigree, until its edge is perfectly flush with the adjacent one. Warm, soft light, as if from a nearby blackout lamp, casts a focused golden glow, highlighting the rich texture of the leather spines—from deep forest green to worn brown—and creating a soft sheen on the manicured fingernails. As the first hand holds the book in place, the fingers of the other delicately trace along the top edge of the aligned volume, ensuring a perfectly flat surface. The background is a soft-focus blur of more books and dark wood, enhancing the shallow depth of field and focusing the viewer's attention on the meticulous action, evoking an atmosphere of tranquility, concentration, and scholarship, imbued with the scent of old paper and leather.", + "seed": 23525, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_1/index_996_seed_23525_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.011980820540338754, + "vlm_logprob": -0.011980820540338754, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.011980820540338754, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands visible arranging books on a dark mahogany bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one hand pushing a thick, crimson, leather-bound volume with a spine showing cracks and faded gold leaf filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the other hand delicately trace along the top edge of the aligned volume to ensure a flat surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and soft, casting a focused golden glow that highlights the texture of the leather spines and manicured fingernails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, intimate close-up angled slightly downward with a soft-focus blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008822272531688213 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.883822441101074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008822272531688213, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008822272531688213, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1964135766029358, + 0.07806891202926636, + 0.03941771015524864, + 0.07945968210697174, + 0.029246460646390915, + 0.06206827610731125, + 0.07281921803951263, + 0.019874028861522675, + 0.03380671143531799, + 0.388825386762619 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008822272531688213 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands visible arranging books on a dark mahogany bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one hand pushing a thick, crimson, leather-bound volume with a spine showing cracks and faded gold leaf filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the other hand delicately trace along the top edge of the aligned volume to ensure a flat surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and soft, casting a focused golden glow that highlights the texture of the leather spines and manicured fingernails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, intimate close-up angled slightly downward with a soft-focus blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02063111960887909 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956310749053955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02063111960887909, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02063111960887909, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32572829723358154, + 0.07380775362253189, + 0.08555211126804352, + 0.0565013512969017, + 0.05304184928536415, + 0.019661767408251762, + 0.07244694232940674, + 0.20320920646190643, + 0.060134224593639374, + 0.04991648718714714 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02063111960887909 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands visible arranging books on a dark mahogany bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one hand pushing a thick, crimson, leather-bound volume with a spine showing cracks and faded gold leaf filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the other hand delicately trace along the top edge of the aligned volume to ensure a flat surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and soft, casting a focused golden glow that highlights the texture of the leather spines and manicured fingernails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, intimate close-up angled slightly downward with a soft-focus blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018189294263720512 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018189430236816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018189294263720512, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018189294263720512, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14029815793037415, + 0.09562075138092041, + 0.11644221842288971, + 0.1981763243675232, + 0.04428800940513611, + 0.029894113540649414, + 0.15117590129375458, + 0.04836912453174591, + 0.03382306173443794, + 0.1419122964143753 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018189294263720512 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands visible arranging books on a dark mahogany bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one hand pushing a thick, crimson, leather-bound volume with a spine showing cracks and faded gold leaf filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the other hand delicately trace along the top edge of the aligned volume to ensure a flat surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and soft, casting a focused golden glow that highlights the texture of the leather spines and manicured fingernails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, intimate close-up angled slightly downward with a soft-focus blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024903970770537853 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002490520477295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024903970770537853, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024903970770537853, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1971246302127838, + 0.052551962435245514, + 0.09736853092908859, + 0.045797985047101974, + 0.022972112521529198, + 0.023221123963594437, + 0.09992664307355881, + 0.031997717916965485, + 0.04745352640748024, + 0.3815857470035553 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024903970770537853 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands visible arranging books on a dark mahogany bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one hand pushing a thick, crimson, leather-bound volume with a spine showing cracks and faded gold leaf filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the other hand delicately trace along the top edge of the aligned volume to ensure a flat surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and soft, casting a focused golden glow that highlights the texture of the leather spines and manicured fingernails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, intimate close-up angled slightly downward with a soft-focus blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009771019220352173 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63477087020874 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009771019220352173, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009771019220352173, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32490620017051697, + 0.07641538232564926, + 0.03646877408027649, + 0.034544751048088074, + 0.06369441747665405, + 0.06424016505479813, + 0.13357128202915192, + 0.06540336459875107, + 0.0467400848865509, + 0.15401561558246613 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009771019220352173 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, intimate close-up, angled slightly downward, captures a pair of slender hands methodically arranging a section of a towering, dark mahogany bookshelf. The skin of the hands is pale and smooth, the movements cautious and gentle. One hand carefully pushes a thick, crimson, leather-bound volume, its spine showing the slight cracks of age and embossed with unremarkable traces of faded gold leaf filigree, until its edge is perfectly flush with the adjacent one. Warm, soft light, as if from a nearby blackout lamp, casts a focused golden glow, highlighting the rich texture of the leather spines—from deep forest green to worn brown—and creating a soft sheen on the manicured fingernails. As the first hand holds the book in place, the fingers of the other delicately trace along the top edge of the aligned volume, ensuring a perfectly flat surface. The background is a soft-focus blur of more books and dark wood, enhancing the shallow depth of field and focusing the viewer's attention on the meticulous action, evoking an atmosphere of tranquility, concentration, and scholarship, imbued with the scent of old paper and leather.", + "seed": 23526, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_1/index_996_seed_23526_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.01365572209469974, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01365572209469974, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01365572209469974, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands visible arranging books on a dark mahogany bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one hand pushing a thick, crimson, leather-bound volume with a spine showing cracks and faded gold leaf filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the other hand delicately trace along the top edge of the aligned volume to ensure a flat surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and soft, casting a focused golden glow that highlights the texture of the leather spines and manicured fingernails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, intimate close-up angled slightly downward with a soft-focus blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009830750524997711 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.759830951690674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009830750524997711, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009830750524997711, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05456343665719032, + 0.6277986168861389, + 0.07095267623662949, + 0.03725026547908783, + 0.04270404204726219, + 0.01784423738718033, + 0.009697070345282555, + 0.026859628036618233, + 0.03782811760902405, + 0.07450192421674728 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009830750524997711 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands visible arranging books on a dark mahogany bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one hand pushing a thick, crimson, leather-bound volume with a spine showing cracks and faded gold leaf filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the other hand delicately trace along the top edge of the aligned volume to ensure a flat surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and soft, casting a focused golden glow that highlights the texture of the leather spines and manicured fingernails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, intimate close-up angled slightly downward with a soft-focus blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023343859240412712 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773343801498413 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023343859240412712, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023343859240412712, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08732327818870544, + 0.14339928328990936, + 0.13676689565181732, + 0.09775789082050323, + 0.12424294650554657, + 0.05563955754041672, + 0.03898333013057709, + 0.09208768606185913, + 0.08053169399499893, + 0.143267422914505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023343859240412712 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands visible arranging books on a dark mahogany bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one hand pushing a thick, crimson, leather-bound volume with a spine showing cracks and faded gold leaf filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the other hand delicately trace along the top edge of the aligned volume to ensure a flat surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and soft, casting a focused golden glow that highlights the texture of the leather spines and manicured fingernails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, intimate close-up angled slightly downward with a soft-focus blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634398825466633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651344060897827 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634398825466633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634398825466633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08377425372600555, + 0.3694172501564026, + 0.08255114406347275, + 0.07087408006191254, + 0.20770074427127838, + 0.12618388235569, + 0.010079434141516685, + 0.017683226615190506, + 0.013504990376532078, + 0.018230998888611794 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634398825466633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands visible arranging books on a dark mahogany bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one hand pushing a thick, crimson, leather-bound volume with a spine showing cracks and faded gold leaf filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the other hand delicately trace along the top edge of the aligned volume to ensure a flat surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and soft, casting a focused golden glow that highlights the texture of the leather spines and manicured fingernails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, intimate close-up angled slightly downward with a soft-focus blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002819255692884326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877819061279297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002819255692884326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002819255692884326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09279230982065201, + 0.6477694511413574, + 0.03649332746863365, + 0.05449135974049568, + 0.03809662535786629, + 0.010463885962963104, + 0.016215099021792412, + 0.011792520992457867, + 0.02290845289826393, + 0.06897702068090439 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002819255692884326 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of slender, pale hands visible arranging books on a dark mahogany bookshelf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is one hand pushing a thick, crimson, leather-bound volume with a spine showing cracks and faded gold leaf filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the other hand delicately trace along the top edge of the aligned volume to ensure a flat surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and soft, casting a focused golden glow that highlights the texture of the leather spines and manicured fingernails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, intimate close-up angled slightly downward with a soft-focus blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005940756760537624 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130940914154053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005940756760537624, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005940756760537624, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10490847378969193, + 0.5456708073616028, + 0.12782834470272064, + 0.031120238825678825, + 0.05350392311811447, + 0.015281323343515396, + 0.0285255815833807, + 0.009634817019104958, + 0.02481134794652462, + 0.058715175837278366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005940756760537624 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_10/index_tensor([3990, 3990])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_10/index_tensor([3990, 3990])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c08d9a5ee7c6cf940e7b1e3d4d56d0b45d2ad31d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_10/index_tensor([3990, 3990])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot captures a shrub rendered in a captivating sketch-style ink and watercolor, its forms swaying gently in the breeze. The shrub is covered in fluffy, pom-pom-like flowers, each a vibrant canary-yellow globe of delicate, silken petals. Delicate, expressive black ink lines loosely define the shapes of the graceful, vine-like branches and sparse green leaves, adding a graphic quality to the organic forms. The entire plant sways rhythmically back and forth, and this subtle movement causes each flower cluster to subtly tremble. The artistry is highlighted by the visible soft colors, where the translucent yellow watercolor meets the green of the leaves, creating a beautiful wet-on-wet effect. The background, an abstract palette of pale green and earthy brown, focuses entirely on the shrub's gentle movement. The scene is illuminated by a soft, diffuse light, enhancing the brightness of the colors and conveying an atmosphere of tranquility, peace, and artistic refinement.", + "seed": 581, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_10/index_3990_seed_581_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.022833060193806886, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022833060193806886, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022833060193806886, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a shrub covered in fluffy, pom-pom-like canary-yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sketch-style ink and watercolor with visible black ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shrub sway gently back and forth while the flowers tremble subtly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an abstract palette of pale green and earthy brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0049789962358772755 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379979133605957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0049789962358772755, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0049789962358772755, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3921770751476288, + 0.08807341009378433, + 0.0716901570558548, + 0.13583548367023468, + 0.05548771098256111, + 0.06769801676273346, + 0.024700302630662918, + 0.04660361260175705, + 0.05811296030879021, + 0.05962121859192848 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0049789962358772755 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a shrub covered in fluffy, pom-pom-like canary-yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sketch-style ink and watercolor with visible black ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shrub sway gently back and forth while the flowers tremble subtly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an abstract palette of pale green and earthy brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005959243047982454 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309590339660645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005959243047982454, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005959243047982454, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11636018753051758, + 0.1790926456451416, + 0.2733905613422394, + 0.11787786334753036, + 0.08143433928489685, + 0.05008694902062416, + 0.05113290250301361, + 0.039384275674819946, + 0.059091854840517044, + 0.03214848041534424 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005959243047982454 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a shrub covered in fluffy, pom-pom-like canary-yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sketch-style ink and watercolor with visible black ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shrub sway gently back and forth while the flowers tremble subtly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an abstract palette of pale green and earthy brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864751175045967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048647403717041 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864751175045967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864751175045967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09682691842317581, + 0.20587760210037231, + 0.20037324726581573, + 0.0778181403875351, + 0.13771086931228638, + 0.04015686735510826, + 0.0442671999335289, + 0.09887246787548065, + 0.06823896616697311, + 0.02985772304236889 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864751175045967 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a shrub covered in fluffy, pom-pom-like canary-yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sketch-style ink and watercolor with visible black ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shrub sway gently back and forth while the flowers tremble subtly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an abstract palette of pale green and earthy brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005944074597209692 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.13094425201416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005944074597209692, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005944074597209692, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1294061690568924, + 0.1060028225183487, + 0.3655160963535309, + 0.032250095158815384, + 0.07877705246210098, + 0.17379231750965118, + 0.0301414355635643, + 0.023581186309456825, + 0.03019668534398079, + 0.030336106196045876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005944074597209692 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a shrub covered in fluffy, pom-pom-like canary-yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sketch-style ink and watercolor with visible black ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shrub sway gently back and forth while the flowers tremble subtly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an abstract palette of pale green and earthy brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04863547533750534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048635482788086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04863547533750534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04863547533750534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24237604439258575, + 0.11738786101341248, + 0.09719009697437286, + 0.13830731809139252, + 0.05941826105117798, + 0.07090727239847183, + 0.035931020975112915, + 0.0997098982334137, + 0.050704337656497955, + 0.08806788176298141 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04863547533750534 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot captures a shrub rendered in a captivating sketch-style ink and watercolor, its forms swaying gently in the breeze. The shrub is covered in fluffy, pom-pom-like flowers, each a vibrant canary-yellow globe of delicate, silken petals. Delicate, expressive black ink lines loosely define the shapes of the graceful, vine-like branches and sparse green leaves, adding a graphic quality to the organic forms. The entire plant sways rhythmically back and forth, and this subtle movement causes each flower cluster to subtly tremble. The artistry is highlighted by the visible soft colors, where the translucent yellow watercolor meets the green of the leaves, creating a beautiful wet-on-wet effect. The background, an abstract palette of pale green and earthy brown, focuses entirely on the shrub's gentle movement. The scene is illuminated by a soft, diffuse light, enhancing the brightness of the colors and conveying an atmosphere of tranquility, peace, and artistic refinement.", + "seed": 582, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_10/index_3990_seed_582_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06319148391485215, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06319148391485215, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06319148391485215, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a shrub covered in fluffy, pom-pom-like canary-yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sketch-style ink and watercolor with visible black ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shrub sway gently back and forth while the flowers tremble subtly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an abstract palette of pale green and earthy brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01131321769207716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511313438415527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01131321769207716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01131321769207716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17167773842811584, + 0.18661046028137207, + 0.019199853762984276, + 0.0746494010090828, + 0.07913564890623093, + 0.02261311002075672, + 0.1443050652742386, + 0.02330661565065384, + 0.04763538017868996, + 0.2308667153120041 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01131321769207716 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a shrub covered in fluffy, pom-pom-like canary-yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sketch-style ink and watercolor with visible black ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shrub sway gently back and forth while the flowers tremble subtly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an abstract palette of pale green and earthy brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603720635175705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910372018814087 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603720635175705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603720635175705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1540738344192505, + 0.12412942945957184, + 0.02240520529448986, + 0.08794412761926651, + 0.08827031403779984, + 0.027329517528414726, + 0.30667147040367126, + 0.01884518191218376, + 0.08480541408061981, + 0.0855255201458931 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603720635175705 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a shrub covered in fluffy, pom-pom-like canary-yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sketch-style ink and watercolor with visible black ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shrub sway gently back and forth while the flowers tremble subtly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an abstract palette of pale green and earthy brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0298027191311121 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298027992248535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0298027191311121, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0298027191311121, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11195478588342667, + 0.07538993656635284, + 0.03369411826133728, + 0.05892146751284599, + 0.14433343708515167, + 0.0926007330417633, + 0.11040941625833511, + 0.07963186502456665, + 0.19955341517925262, + 0.09351084381341934 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0298027191311121 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a shrub covered in fluffy, pom-pom-like canary-yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sketch-style ink and watercolor with visible black ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shrub sway gently back and forth while the flowers tremble subtly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an abstract palette of pale green and earthy brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01418777834624052 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264187812805176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01418777834624052, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01418777834624052, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13466614484786987, + 0.0621858611702919, + 0.0595635324716568, + 0.1613890677690506, + 0.21676592528820038, + 0.0679582804441452, + 0.14639107882976532, + 0.04393119364976883, + 0.06788381189107895, + 0.039265044033527374 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01418777834624052 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a shrub covered in fluffy, pom-pom-like canary-yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sketch-style ink and watercolor with visible black ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shrub sway gently back and forth while the flowers tremble subtly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an abstract palette of pale green and earthy brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10028164088726044 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3502817153930664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10028164088726044, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10028164088726044, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10671073198318481, + 0.08805780857801437, + 0.052530281245708466, + 0.053045112639665604, + 0.21624593436717987, + 0.08119355887174606, + 0.13171926140785217, + 0.09514117985963821, + 0.13027116656303406, + 0.04508500546216965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10028164088726044 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot captures a shrub rendered in a captivating sketch-style ink and watercolor, its forms swaying gently in the breeze. The shrub is covered in fluffy, pom-pom-like flowers, each a vibrant canary-yellow globe of delicate, silken petals. Delicate, expressive black ink lines loosely define the shapes of the graceful, vine-like branches and sparse green leaves, adding a graphic quality to the organic forms. The entire plant sways rhythmically back and forth, and this subtle movement causes each flower cluster to subtly tremble. The artistry is highlighted by the visible soft colors, where the translucent yellow watercolor meets the green of the leaves, creating a beautiful wet-on-wet effect. The background, an abstract palette of pale green and earthy brown, focuses entirely on the shrub's gentle movement. The scene is illuminated by a soft, diffuse light, enhancing the brightness of the colors and conveying an atmosphere of tranquility, peace, and artistic refinement.", + "seed": 583, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_10/index_3990_seed_583_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04914678484201431, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04914678484201431, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.550000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04914678484201431, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a shrub covered in fluffy, pom-pom-like canary-yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sketch-style ink and watercolor with visible black ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shrub sway gently back and forth while the flowers tremble subtly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an abstract palette of pale green and earthy brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007077740505337715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.007077693939209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007077740505337715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007077740505337715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19444049894809723, + 0.1901635080575943, + 0.0707162395119667, + 0.03353571519255638, + 0.12888203561306, + 0.03198358789086342, + 0.1076161339879036, + 0.1262192279100418, + 0.0473259799182415, + 0.06911707669496536 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007077740505337715 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a shrub covered in fluffy, pom-pom-like canary-yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sketch-style ink and watercolor with visible black ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shrub sway gently back and forth while the flowers tremble subtly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an abstract palette of pale green and earthy brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043070822954177856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680707931518555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043070822954177856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043070822954177856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09369244426488876, + 0.1695890724658966, + 0.06047789752483368, + 0.04134639352560043, + 0.415018767118454, + 0.016137488186359406, + 0.03835057094693184, + 0.11025360226631165, + 0.018564380705356598, + 0.03656936436891556 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043070822954177856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a shrub covered in fluffy, pom-pom-like canary-yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sketch-style ink and watercolor with visible black ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shrub sway gently back and forth while the flowers tremble subtly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an abstract palette of pale green and earthy brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043053124099969864 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168053150177002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043053124099969864, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043053124099969864, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17371131479740143, + 0.09333548694849014, + 0.044674698263406754, + 0.06543903052806854, + 0.2971773147583008, + 0.035968516021966934, + 0.0671880766749382, + 0.05965699627995491, + 0.12154290080070496, + 0.04130566865205765 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043053124099969864 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a shrub covered in fluffy, pom-pom-like canary-yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sketch-style ink and watercolor with visible black ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shrub sway gently back and forth while the flowers tremble subtly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an abstract palette of pale green and earthy brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00977538712322712 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634775161743164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00977538712322712, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00977538712322712, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07719558477401733, + 0.217503160238266, + 0.1112428531050682, + 0.039012134075164795, + 0.28798627853393555, + 0.039170168340206146, + 0.11540204286575317, + 0.0746956467628479, + 0.01850300095975399, + 0.01928912103176117 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00977538712322712 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a shrub covered in fluffy, pom-pom-like canary-yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sketch-style ink and watercolor with visible black ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shrub sway gently back and forth while the flowers tremble subtly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an abstract palette of pale green and earthy brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.142756849527359 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017756938934326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.142756849527359, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.142756849527359, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07104373723268509, + 0.06054053083062172, + 0.11123067885637283, + 0.11489462107419968, + 0.2109120488166809, + 0.051942937076091766, + 0.04907462000846863, + 0.16589754819869995, + 0.08023271709680557, + 0.08423060178756714 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.142756849527359 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot captures a shrub rendered in a captivating sketch-style ink and watercolor, its forms swaying gently in the breeze. The shrub is covered in fluffy, pom-pom-like flowers, each a vibrant canary-yellow globe of delicate, silken petals. Delicate, expressive black ink lines loosely define the shapes of the graceful, vine-like branches and sparse green leaves, adding a graphic quality to the organic forms. The entire plant sways rhythmically back and forth, and this subtle movement causes each flower cluster to subtly tremble. The artistry is highlighted by the visible soft colors, where the translucent yellow watercolor meets the green of the leaves, creating a beautiful wet-on-wet effect. The background, an abstract palette of pale green and earthy brown, focuses entirely on the shrub's gentle movement. The scene is illuminated by a soft, diffuse light, enhancing the brightness of the colors and conveying an atmosphere of tranquility, peace, and artistic refinement.", + "seed": 584, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_10/index_3990_seed_584_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04686305485665798, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04686305485665798, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04686305485665798, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a shrub covered in fluffy, pom-pom-like canary-yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sketch-style ink and watercolor with visible black ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shrub sway gently back and forth while the flowers tremble subtly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an abstract palette of pale green and earthy brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004391431342810392 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504391193389893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004391431342810392, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004391431342810392, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19115082919597626, + 0.129917174577713, + 0.11159103363752365, + 0.03517808020114899, + 0.07098845392465591, + 0.11943697929382324, + 0.0625215470790863, + 0.12722907960414886, + 0.09665951877832413, + 0.055327314883470535 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004391431342810392 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a shrub covered in fluffy, pom-pom-like canary-yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sketch-style ink and watercolor with visible black ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shrub sway gently back and forth while the flowers tremble subtly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an abstract palette of pale green and earthy brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006741635967046022 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006741523742676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006741635967046022, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006741635967046022, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23872274160385132, + 0.17155101895332336, + 0.08675190806388855, + 0.09473353624343872, + 0.0631556510925293, + 0.08295746147632599, + 0.149178609251976, + 0.04679808020591736, + 0.03527892008423805, + 0.030872059985995293 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006741635967046022 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a shrub covered in fluffy, pom-pom-like canary-yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sketch-style ink and watercolor with visible black ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shrub sway gently back and forth while the flowers tremble subtly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an abstract palette of pale green and earthy brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1798652559518814 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048652410507202 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1798652559518814, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1798652559518814, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2733111083507538, + 0.08737097680568695, + 0.04528393596410751, + 0.07791867852210999, + 0.09622900933027267, + 0.06414365768432617, + 0.09109232574701309, + 0.10951773077249527, + 0.0657961517572403, + 0.08933643996715546 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1798652559518814 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a shrub covered in fluffy, pom-pom-like canary-yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sketch-style ink and watercolor with visible black ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shrub sway gently back and forth while the flowers tremble subtly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an abstract palette of pale green and earthy brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005244782194495201 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255244731903076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005244782194495201, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005244782194495201, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18102113902568817, + 0.08816191554069519, + 0.21336956322193146, + 0.06282880157232285, + 0.08794133365154266, + 0.06004004925489426, + 0.10381601750850677, + 0.1169208362698555, + 0.030842378735542297, + 0.05505800247192383 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005244782194495201 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a shrub covered in fluffy, pom-pom-like canary-yellow flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style a sketch-style ink and watercolor with visible black ink lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shrub sway gently back and forth while the flowers tremble subtly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an abstract palette of pale green and earthy brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038072168827056885 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288072109222412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038072168827056885, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038072168827056885, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1582932472229004, + 0.03785048425197601, + 0.08958384394645691, + 0.14160725474357605, + 0.10388101637363434, + 0.10051027685403824, + 0.21149004995822906, + 0.07948160171508789, + 0.04294836148619652, + 0.03435392677783966 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038072168827056885 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_11/index_tensor([6074, 6074])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_11/index_tensor([6074, 6074])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..47ba9fdf1b87001820b223d5122fb328b1866410 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_11/index_tensor([6074, 6074])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In the surreal and emotive style of Makoto Shinkai, a low-angle tracking shot follows Shun Kazama, a determined young man, as he strides unwaveringly forward. He wears a dark, high-collared school uniform, the fabric appearing damp and subtly shimmering under intricate lighting. The entire scene is bathed in the iconic golden hour light, casting long shadows and infusing the atmosphere with a warm, nostalgic glow. As the camera smoothly slides behind and to the side of him, dramatic anamorphic lens flares streak horizontally across the screen, created by the headlights of passing cars and glowing streetlights. The backdrop is a rain-slicked city street at dusk, every detail rendered with photorealistic precision; the wet asphalt perfectly reflects the vibrant neon signs of storefronts and the deep blue of the twilight sky, creating a world of idyllic beauty. Shun walks with a steady and purposeful pace, his foot occasionally splashing into a shallow puddle, sending a cloud of glowing droplets into the air. His expression is intensely focused, his gaze fixed on an unseen point ahead, embodying a powerful sense of forward momentum and a quiet, emotional gravity.", + "seed": 3268, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_11/index_6074_seed_3268_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07103287447243929, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07103287447243929, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07103287447243929, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a dark, high-collared school uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking forward with a steady pace while splashing into a shallow puddle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rain-slicked city street at dusk with neon signs and a twilight sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dramatic anamorphic lens flares streaking horizontally across the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth low-angle tracking shot that slides behind and to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08962708711624146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4646270275115967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08962708711624146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08962708711624146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2665940821170807, + 0.04626684635877609, + 0.11969804018735886, + 0.03961344435811043, + 0.07657484710216522, + 0.042282845824956894, + 0.023725764825940132, + 0.13785941898822784, + 0.06026243418455124, + 0.18712233006954193 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08962708711624146 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a dark, high-collared school uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking forward with a steady pace while splashing into a shallow puddle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rain-slicked city street at dusk with neon signs and a twilight sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dramatic anamorphic lens flares streaking horizontally across the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth low-angle tracking shot that slides behind and to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22558550536632538 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005854606628418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22558550536632538, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22558550536632538, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5224409103393555, + 0.03580004721879959, + 0.08769393712282181, + 0.07758589833974838, + 0.05124867334961891, + 0.03851908817887306, + 0.05249340459704399, + 0.01723085343837738, + 0.040436260402202606, + 0.0765509232878685 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22558550536632538 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a dark, high-collared school uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking forward with a steady pace while splashing into a shallow puddle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rain-slicked city street at dusk with neon signs and a twilight sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dramatic anamorphic lens flares streaking horizontally across the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth low-angle tracking shot that slides behind and to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024857595562934875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002485752105713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024857595562934875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024857595562934875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5066908001899719, + 0.08175698667764664, + 0.05041903257369995, + 0.0716247707605362, + 0.08446694165468216, + 0.07021205872297287, + 0.03642808273434639, + 0.028041742742061615, + 0.031461454927921295, + 0.03889809548854828 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024857595562934875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a dark, high-collared school uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking forward with a steady pace while splashing into a shallow puddle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rain-slicked city street at dusk with neon signs and a twilight sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dramatic anamorphic lens flares streaking horizontally across the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth low-angle tracking shot that slides behind and to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014195299707353115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264195442199707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014195299707353115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014195299707353115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7354652881622314, + 0.025991279631853104, + 0.01620495319366455, + 0.07226484268903732, + 0.030551103875041008, + 0.0193756353110075, + 0.046824004501104355, + 0.0163241196423769, + 0.01729700341820717, + 0.019701765850186348 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014195299707353115 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a dark, high-collared school uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking forward with a steady pace while splashing into a shallow puddle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rain-slicked city street at dusk with neon signs and a twilight sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dramatic anamorphic lens flares streaking horizontally across the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth low-angle tracking shot that slides behind and to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02327072061598301 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773270606994629 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02327072061598301, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02327072061598301, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21111291646957397, + 0.05700761079788208, + 0.0724535882472992, + 0.08023618161678314, + 0.056724172085523605, + 0.0915839821100235, + 0.04291621223092079, + 0.07915233075618744, + 0.24283798038959503, + 0.06597510725259781 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02327072061598301 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the surreal and emotive style of Makoto Shinkai, a low-angle tracking shot follows Shun Kazama, a determined young man, as he strides unwaveringly forward. He wears a dark, high-collared school uniform, the fabric appearing damp and subtly shimmering under intricate lighting. The entire scene is bathed in the iconic golden hour light, casting long shadows and infusing the atmosphere with a warm, nostalgic glow. As the camera smoothly slides behind and to the side of him, dramatic anamorphic lens flares streak horizontally across the screen, created by the headlights of passing cars and glowing streetlights. The backdrop is a rain-slicked city street at dusk, every detail rendered with photorealistic precision; the wet asphalt perfectly reflects the vibrant neon signs of storefronts and the deep blue of the twilight sky, creating a world of idyllic beauty. Shun walks with a steady and purposeful pace, his foot occasionally splashing into a shallow puddle, sending a cloud of glowing droplets into the air. His expression is intensely focused, his gaze fixed on an unseen point ahead, embodying a powerful sense of forward momentum and a quiet, emotional gravity.", + "seed": 3269, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_11/index_6074_seed_3269_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06724839042872191, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06724839042872191, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.474999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06724839042872191, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a dark, high-collared school uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking forward with a steady pace while splashing into a shallow puddle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rain-slicked city street at dusk with neon signs and a twilight sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dramatic anamorphic lens flares streaking horizontally across the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth low-angle tracking shot that slides behind and to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04361419007182121 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168614149093628 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04361419007182121, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04361419007182121, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2205105870962143, + 0.025285787880420685, + 0.042935170233249664, + 0.018959324806928635, + 0.12152721732854843, + 0.10655364394187927, + 0.24669350683689117, + 0.06579206138849258, + 0.11939214169979095, + 0.0323505699634552 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04361419007182121 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a dark, high-collared school uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking forward with a steady pace while splashing into a shallow puddle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rain-slicked city street at dusk with neon signs and a twilight sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dramatic anamorphic lens flares streaking horizontally across the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth low-angle tracking shot that slides behind and to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521260976791382 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021260976791382 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521260976791382, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521260976791382, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12385478615760803, + 0.1871979683637619, + 0.05360108241438866, + 0.1017773300409317, + 0.07503126561641693, + 0.05069800466299057, + 0.06481878459453583, + 0.13505573570728302, + 0.14129239320755005, + 0.06667263805866241 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521260976791382 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a dark, high-collared school uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking forward with a steady pace while splashing into a shallow puddle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rain-slicked city street at dusk with neon signs and a twilight sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dramatic anamorphic lens flares streaking horizontally across the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth low-angle tracking shot that slides behind and to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009781643748283386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634781837463379 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009781643748283386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009781643748283386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.160587340593338, + 0.08717957139015198, + 0.05219716578722, + 0.060723334550857544, + 0.22888299822807312, + 0.08925872296094894, + 0.05897079035639763, + 0.10477898269891739, + 0.09694653749465942, + 0.06047452241182327 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009781643748283386 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a dark, high-collared school uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking forward with a steady pace while splashing into a shallow puddle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rain-slicked city street at dusk with neon signs and a twilight sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dramatic anamorphic lens flares streaking horizontally across the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth low-angle tracking shot that slides behind and to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012545241974294186 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387545108795166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012545241974294186, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012545241974294186, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22084617614746094, + 0.23257248103618622, + 0.05011981725692749, + 0.07356549799442291, + 0.06284349411725998, + 0.04078908637166023, + 0.04207787662744522, + 0.11006300896406174, + 0.0665820837020874, + 0.10054044425487518 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012545241974294186 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a dark, high-collared school uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking forward with a steady pace while splashing into a shallow puddle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rain-slicked city street at dusk with neon signs and a twilight sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dramatic anamorphic lens flares streaking horizontally across the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth low-angle tracking shot that slides behind and to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018174778670072556 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018174648284912 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018174778670072556, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018174778670072556, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11429555714130402, + 0.055561479181051254, + 0.048751723021268845, + 0.09916267544031143, + 0.09773951768875122, + 0.09725695848464966, + 0.22242297232151031, + 0.11060609668493271, + 0.11193165928125381, + 0.04227132350206375 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018174778670072556 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the surreal and emotive style of Makoto Shinkai, a low-angle tracking shot follows Shun Kazama, a determined young man, as he strides unwaveringly forward. He wears a dark, high-collared school uniform, the fabric appearing damp and subtly shimmering under intricate lighting. The entire scene is bathed in the iconic golden hour light, casting long shadows and infusing the atmosphere with a warm, nostalgic glow. As the camera smoothly slides behind and to the side of him, dramatic anamorphic lens flares streak horizontally across the screen, created by the headlights of passing cars and glowing streetlights. The backdrop is a rain-slicked city street at dusk, every detail rendered with photorealistic precision; the wet asphalt perfectly reflects the vibrant neon signs of storefronts and the deep blue of the twilight sky, creating a world of idyllic beauty. Shun walks with a steady and purposeful pace, his foot occasionally splashing into a shallow puddle, sending a cloud of glowing droplets into the air. His expression is intensely focused, his gaze fixed on an unseen point ahead, embodying a powerful sense of forward momentum and a quiet, emotional gravity.", + "seed": 3270, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_11/index_6074_seed_3270_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.08752712924033404, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08752712924033404, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08752712924033404, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a dark, high-collared school uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking forward with a steady pace while splashing into a shallow puddle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rain-slicked city street at dusk with neon signs and a twilight sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dramatic anamorphic lens flares streaking horizontally across the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth low-angle tracking shot that slides behind and to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02209184318780899 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.897091865539551 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02209184318780899, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02209184318780899, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16800972819328308, + 0.16669760644435883, + 0.08686301112174988, + 0.09778392314910889, + 0.0827094092965126, + 0.04378907382488251, + 0.12149066478013992, + 0.06305745989084244, + 0.05671544745564461, + 0.11288367211818695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02209184318780899 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a dark, high-collared school uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking forward with a steady pace while splashing into a shallow puddle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rain-slicked city street at dusk with neon signs and a twilight sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dramatic anamorphic lens flares streaking horizontally across the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth low-angle tracking shot that slides behind and to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34866833686828613 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236683368682861 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34866833686828613, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34866833686828613, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1266067773103714, + 0.052727073431015015, + 0.09091280400753021, + 0.10029981285333633, + 0.23277167975902557, + 0.1687944084405899, + 0.06179971247911453, + 0.058536045253276825, + 0.042322102934122086, + 0.06522949039936066 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34866833686828613 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a dark, high-collared school uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking forward with a steady pace while splashing into a shallow puddle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rain-slicked city street at dusk with neon signs and a twilight sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dramatic anamorphic lens flares streaking horizontally across the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth low-angle tracking shot that slides behind and to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014192597009241581 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264192581176758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014192597009241581, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014192597009241581, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18718726933002472, + 0.07830386608839035, + 0.08047059923410416, + 0.05911364033818245, + 0.07103281468153, + 0.23562178015708923, + 0.07437508553266525, + 0.0354483500123024, + 0.02471551112830639, + 0.1537310928106308 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014192597009241581 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a dark, high-collared school uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking forward with a steady pace while splashing into a shallow puddle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rain-slicked city street at dusk with neon signs and a twilight sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dramatic anamorphic lens flares streaking horizontally across the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth low-angle tracking shot that slides behind and to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026351535692811012 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513514518737793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026351535692811012, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026351535692811012, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15371857583522797, + 0.061218418180942535, + 0.09760814160108566, + 0.057749345898628235, + 0.055567339062690735, + 0.39622172713279724, + 0.053241610527038574, + 0.05313877761363983, + 0.03462638333439827, + 0.036909665912389755 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026351535692811012 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a dark, high-collared school uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking forward with a steady pace while splashing into a shallow puddle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rain-slicked city street at dusk with neon signs and a twilight sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dramatic anamorphic lens flares streaking horizontally across the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth low-angle tracking shot that slides behind and to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026331333443522453 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513314247131348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026331333443522453, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026331333443522453, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26557374000549316, + 0.06018679589033127, + 0.10545315593481064, + 0.12135565280914307, + 0.0788288563489914, + 0.1238323301076889, + 0.04833114147186279, + 0.05873909965157509, + 0.06759671866893768, + 0.07010241597890854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026331333443522453 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the surreal and emotive style of Makoto Shinkai, a low-angle tracking shot follows Shun Kazama, a determined young man, as he strides unwaveringly forward. He wears a dark, high-collared school uniform, the fabric appearing damp and subtly shimmering under intricate lighting. The entire scene is bathed in the iconic golden hour light, casting long shadows and infusing the atmosphere with a warm, nostalgic glow. As the camera smoothly slides behind and to the side of him, dramatic anamorphic lens flares streak horizontally across the screen, created by the headlights of passing cars and glowing streetlights. The backdrop is a rain-slicked city street at dusk, every detail rendered with photorealistic precision; the wet asphalt perfectly reflects the vibrant neon signs of storefronts and the deep blue of the twilight sky, creating a world of idyllic beauty. Shun walks with a steady and purposeful pace, his foot occasionally splashing into a shallow puddle, sending a cloud of glowing droplets into the air. His expression is intensely focused, his gaze fixed on an unseen point ahead, embodying a powerful sense of forward momentum and a quiet, emotional gravity.", + "seed": 3271, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_11/index_6074_seed_3271_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07426941012963653, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07426941012963653, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07426941012963653, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a dark, high-collared school uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking forward with a steady pace while splashing into a shallow puddle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rain-slicked city street at dusk with neon signs and a twilight sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dramatic anamorphic lens flares streaking horizontally across the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth low-angle tracking shot that slides behind and to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02114129811525345 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.896141290664673 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02114129811525345, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02114129811525345, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18220408260822296, + 0.07366880029439926, + 0.09838540852069855, + 0.0793004259467125, + 0.21980337798595428, + 0.032643839716911316, + 0.1271757036447525, + 0.0844414234161377, + 0.05207692086696625, + 0.050300028175115585 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02114129811525345 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a dark, high-collared school uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking forward with a steady pace while splashing into a shallow puddle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rain-slicked city street at dusk with neon signs and a twilight sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dramatic anamorphic lens flares streaking horizontally across the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth low-angle tracking shot that slides behind and to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134453296661377 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134453296661377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134453296661377, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134453296661377, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12622271478176117, + 0.07061710208654404, + 0.07680041342973709, + 0.26453498005867004, + 0.058006200939416885, + 0.06251444667577744, + 0.11083998531103134, + 0.07622907310724258, + 0.12331411987543106, + 0.03092098794877529 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134453296661377 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a dark, high-collared school uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking forward with a steady pace while splashing into a shallow puddle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rain-slicked city street at dusk with neon signs and a twilight sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dramatic anamorphic lens flares streaking horizontally across the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth low-angle tracking shot that slides behind and to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004635184537619352 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379635334014893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004635184537619352, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004635184537619352, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06549396365880966, + 0.04100591316819191, + 0.017862454056739807, + 0.12144352495670319, + 0.12215773016214371, + 0.048957400023937225, + 0.48770394921302795, + 0.04314309358596802, + 0.022711006924510002, + 0.029520995914936066 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004635184537619352 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a dark, high-collared school uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking forward with a steady pace while splashing into a shallow puddle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rain-slicked city street at dusk with neon signs and a twilight sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dramatic anamorphic lens flares streaking horizontally across the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth low-angle tracking shot that slides behind and to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016069775447249413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410698890686035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016069775447249413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016069775447249413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16774709522724152, + 0.04432058334350586, + 0.11517978459596634, + 0.35789036750793457, + 0.09951426833868027, + 0.04580463096499443, + 0.03884988650679588, + 0.08645310997962952, + 0.018918737769126892, + 0.025321541354060173 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016069775447249413 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young man wearing a dark, high-collared school uniform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character walking forward with a steady pace while splashing into a shallow puddle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a rain-slicked city street at dusk with neon signs and a twilight sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dramatic anamorphic lens flares streaking horizontally across the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth low-angle tracking shot that slides behind and to the side of the character?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016055462881922722 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141055583953857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016055462881922722, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016055462881922722, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31789156794548035, + 0.04433222860097885, + 0.07940339297056198, + 0.09921745955944061, + 0.07333828508853912, + 0.04635825753211975, + 0.14214609563350677, + 0.13452887535095215, + 0.031141197308897972, + 0.03164258599281311 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016055462881922722 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_12/index_tensor([9232, 9232])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_12/index_tensor([9232, 9232])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0056c8022a7ea74318650b0c003d70cb5e536e96 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_12/index_tensor([9232, 9232])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a military archival-style shot with a signature vintage film texture, featuring slight color desaturation and noticeable grain, the camera pans in a fluid, unbroken 360-degree pan, closely following a missile hurtling through the sky at high speed. The missile's sleek gray-white metal hull and tail stabilizers reflect a cool, austere luster in the harsh sunlight. A dense, swirling column of white smoke erupts from its tail, leaving a striking, persistent trail across the vast pale blue sky. As the camera rotates at a constant speed, the viewer's perspective shifts around the missile, while the horizon and sparse clouds in the background rotate accordingly, creating a powerful sense of motion and an immersive sense of speed. In the final stage of the surround shooting, the camera angle is exactly aimed at the direction of the missile's advance, capturing it rushing towards a distant, vaguely outlined aerial target with unstoppable momentum and precision. Finally, at the decisive moment when the missile contacts the target, the picture is occupied by a violent and silent explosion. A dazzling orange-red fireball suddenly bursts out, and then turns into a black smoke mixed with metal fragments, slowly dissipating in the air. The whole process is full of calm and shocking destructive aesthetics.", + "seed": 25731, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_12/index_9232_seed_25731_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.12837522029876708, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12837522029876708, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.424999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12837522029876708, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a missile with a sleek gray-white metal hull and tail stabilizers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot with a vintage film texture, slight color desaturation, and noticeable grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a fluid, unbroken 360-degree pan around the missile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a violent explosion producing an orange-red fireball that turns into black smoke and metal fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast pale blue sky with sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14374716579914093 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.018747091293335 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14374716579914093, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14374716579914093, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09743517637252808, + 0.08602624386548996, + 0.029237058013677597, + 0.34374719858169556, + 0.06604260206222534, + 0.06593921035528183, + 0.07722819596529007, + 0.08398120105266571, + 0.08053766936063766, + 0.06982538849115372 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14374716579914093 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a missile with a sleek gray-white metal hull and tail stabilizers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot with a vintage film texture, slight color desaturation, and noticeable grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a fluid, unbroken 360-degree pan around the missile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a violent explosion producing an orange-red fireball that turns into black smoke and metal fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast pale blue sky with sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012553482316434383 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387553691864014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012553482316434383, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012553482316434383, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09383422136306763, + 0.09908270090818405, + 0.1590082198381424, + 0.10379094630479813, + 0.18485672771930695, + 0.1525208204984665, + 0.059914059937000275, + 0.05667902156710625, + 0.04952353239059448, + 0.040789756923913956 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012553482316434383 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a missile with a sleek gray-white metal hull and tail stabilizers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot with a vintage film texture, slight color desaturation, and noticeable grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a fluid, unbroken 360-degree pan around the missile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a violent explosion producing an orange-red fireball that turns into black smoke and metal fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast pale blue sky with sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4742072820663452 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742072820663452 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4742072820663452, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4742072820663452, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14058443903923035, + 0.08622747659683228, + 0.11460579186677933, + 0.12195762246847153, + 0.06725408136844635, + 0.15842774510383606, + 0.08212653547525406, + 0.12759417295455933, + 0.061382051557302475, + 0.039840105921030045 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4742072820663452 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a missile with a sleek gray-white metal hull and tail stabilizers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot with a vintage film texture, slight color desaturation, and noticeable grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a fluid, unbroken 360-degree pan around the missile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a violent explosion producing an orange-red fireball that turns into black smoke and metal fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast pale blue sky with sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006735597271472216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006735801696777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006735597271472216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006735597271472216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08607181161642075, + 0.04641632363200188, + 0.04194417595863342, + 0.20522713661193848, + 0.05007311329245567, + 0.035614948719739914, + 0.04454319179058075, + 0.06654895097017288, + 0.08592637628316879, + 0.33763399720191956 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006735597271472216 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a missile with a sleek gray-white metal hull and tail stabilizers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot with a vintage film texture, slight color desaturation, and noticeable grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a fluid, unbroken 360-degree pan around the missile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a violent explosion producing an orange-red fireball that turns into black smoke and metal fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast pale blue sky with sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004632574040442705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379632472991943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004632574040442705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004632574040442705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07064899802207947, + 0.03303125873208046, + 0.03262610360980034, + 0.09688917547464371, + 0.03366332873702049, + 0.4376586079597473, + 0.09353335201740265, + 0.13045655190944672, + 0.023392431437969208, + 0.04810017719864845 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004632574040442705 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a military archival-style shot with a signature vintage film texture, featuring slight color desaturation and noticeable grain, the camera pans in a fluid, unbroken 360-degree pan, closely following a missile hurtling through the sky at high speed. The missile's sleek gray-white metal hull and tail stabilizers reflect a cool, austere luster in the harsh sunlight. A dense, swirling column of white smoke erupts from its tail, leaving a striking, persistent trail across the vast pale blue sky. As the camera rotates at a constant speed, the viewer's perspective shifts around the missile, while the horizon and sparse clouds in the background rotate accordingly, creating a powerful sense of motion and an immersive sense of speed. In the final stage of the surround shooting, the camera angle is exactly aimed at the direction of the missile's advance, capturing it rushing towards a distant, vaguely outlined aerial target with unstoppable momentum and precision. Finally, at the decisive moment when the missile contacts the target, the picture is occupied by a violent and silent explosion. A dazzling orange-red fireball suddenly bursts out, and then turns into a black smoke mixed with metal fragments, slowly dissipating in the air. The whole process is full of calm and shocking destructive aesthetics.", + "seed": 25732, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_12/index_9232_seed_25732_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.4192708836868405, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4192708836868405, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1499999523162843, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4192708836868405, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a missile with a sleek gray-white metal hull and tail stabilizers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot with a vintage film texture, slight color desaturation, and noticeable grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a fluid, unbroken 360-degree pan around the missile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a violent explosion producing an orange-red fireball that turns into black smoke and metal fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast pale blue sky with sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019895751029253006 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.019895553588867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019895751029253006, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019895751029253006, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24260108172893524, + 0.0329013392329216, + 0.07957837730646133, + 0.09076724946498871, + 0.0527772456407547, + 0.0703006386756897, + 0.14483845233917236, + 0.12866927683353424, + 0.07673019915819168, + 0.08083612471818924 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019895751029253006 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a missile with a sleek gray-white metal hull and tail stabilizers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot with a vintage film texture, slight color desaturation, and noticeable grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a fluid, unbroken 360-degree pan around the missile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a violent explosion producing an orange-red fireball that turns into black smoke and metal fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast pale blue sky with sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866897314786911 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.04866886138916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866897314786911, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866897314786911, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2857222259044647, + 0.021591605618596077, + 0.09998084604740143, + 0.07941949367523193, + 0.09790412336587906, + 0.07289010286331177, + 0.1387486755847931, + 0.056917980313301086, + 0.06336142867803574, + 0.08346350491046906 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866897314786911 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a missile with a sleek gray-white metal hull and tail stabilizers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot with a vintage film texture, slight color desaturation, and noticeable grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a fluid, unbroken 360-degree pan around the missile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a violent explosion producing an orange-red fireball that turns into black smoke and metal fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast pale blue sky with sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017745018005371 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14274506270885468 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.017745018005371, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -2.017745018005371, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09231044352054596, + 0.05427606403827667, + 0.10139103978872299, + 0.25470593571662903, + 0.25506600737571716, + 0.04578128457069397, + 0.03125651180744171, + 0.06120520085096359, + 0.06852316111326218, + 0.03548433259129524 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.017745018005371 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a missile with a sleek gray-white metal hull and tail stabilizers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot with a vintage film texture, slight color desaturation, and noticeable grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a fluid, unbroken 360-degree pan around the missile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a violent explosion producing an orange-red fireball that turns into black smoke and metal fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast pale blue sky with sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004098350182175636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504098415374756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004098350182175636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004098350182175636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07594091445207596, + 0.04964151978492737, + 0.06278467178344727, + 0.1571180522441864, + 0.0996059775352478, + 0.07036873698234558, + 0.025019485503435135, + 0.06441137939691544, + 0.1383756548166275, + 0.25673359632492065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004098350182175636 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a missile with a sleek gray-white metal hull and tail stabilizers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot with a vintage film texture, slight color desaturation, and noticeable grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a fluid, unbroken 360-degree pan around the missile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a violent explosion producing an orange-red fireball that turns into black smoke and metal fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast pale blue sky with sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005946326069533825 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130946159362793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005946326069533825, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005946326069533825, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17878937721252441, + 0.0723302960395813, + 0.054470911622047424, + 0.24203188717365265, + 0.1533169150352478, + 0.03604837507009506, + 0.0634894147515297, + 0.04783805087208748, + 0.11434996873140335, + 0.037334732711315155 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005946326069533825 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a military archival-style shot with a signature vintage film texture, featuring slight color desaturation and noticeable grain, the camera pans in a fluid, unbroken 360-degree pan, closely following a missile hurtling through the sky at high speed. The missile's sleek gray-white metal hull and tail stabilizers reflect a cool, austere luster in the harsh sunlight. A dense, swirling column of white smoke erupts from its tail, leaving a striking, persistent trail across the vast pale blue sky. As the camera rotates at a constant speed, the viewer's perspective shifts around the missile, while the horizon and sparse clouds in the background rotate accordingly, creating a powerful sense of motion and an immersive sense of speed. In the final stage of the surround shooting, the camera angle is exactly aimed at the direction of the missile's advance, capturing it rushing towards a distant, vaguely outlined aerial target with unstoppable momentum and precision. Finally, at the decisive moment when the missile contacts the target, the picture is occupied by a violent and silent explosion. A dazzling orange-red fireball suddenly bursts out, and then turns into a black smoke mixed with metal fragments, slowly dissipating in the air. The whole process is full of calm and shocking destructive aesthetics.", + "seed": 25733, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_12/index_9232_seed_25733_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.21468340449500828, + "vlm_logprob": -0.21468340449500828, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.21468340449500828, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a missile with a sleek gray-white metal hull and tail stabilizers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot with a vintage film texture, slight color desaturation, and noticeable grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a fluid, unbroken 360-degree pan around the missile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a violent explosion producing an orange-red fireball that turns into black smoke and metal fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast pale blue sky with sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015111841261386871 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.265111923217773 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015111841261386871, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015111841261386871, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.053991444408893585, + 0.06715873628854752, + 0.09970264881849289, + 0.10041617602109909, + 0.177517369389534, + 0.029725484549999237, + 0.18242304027080536, + 0.15037523210048676, + 0.025287562981247902, + 0.11340226233005524 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015111841261386871 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a missile with a sleek gray-white metal hull and tail stabilizers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot with a vintage film texture, slight color desaturation, and noticeable grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a fluid, unbroken 360-degree pan around the missile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a violent explosion producing an orange-red fireball that turns into black smoke and metal fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast pale blue sky with sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898183912038803 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578981876373291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898183912038803, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898183912038803, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10924232006072998, + 0.06516867876052856, + 0.029244279488921165, + 0.020830567926168442, + 0.1248108521103859, + 0.05493714660406113, + 0.4893498420715332, + 0.04937281832098961, + 0.018097056075930595, + 0.03894643485546112 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898183912038803 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a missile with a sleek gray-white metal hull and tail stabilizers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot with a vintage film texture, slight color desaturation, and noticeable grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a fluid, unbroken 360-degree pan around the missile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a violent explosion producing an orange-red fireball that turns into black smoke and metal fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast pale blue sky with sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742012023925781 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4742012023925781 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9742012023925781, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9742012023925781, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0667029619216919, + 0.11355984956026077, + 0.07872125506401062, + 0.030694205313920975, + 0.08658836036920547, + 0.05419947952032089, + 0.31829634308815, + 0.08815661072731018, + 0.12159965932369232, + 0.041481275111436844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9742012023925781 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a missile with a sleek gray-white metal hull and tail stabilizers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot with a vintage film texture, slight color desaturation, and noticeable grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a fluid, unbroken 360-degree pan around the missile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a violent explosion producing an orange-red fireball that turns into black smoke and metal fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast pale blue sky with sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036131355445832014 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628612995147705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036131355445832014, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036131355445832014, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02959280088543892, + 0.019731970503926277, + 0.02390098385512829, + 0.03877171874046326, + 0.0769076868891716, + 0.02398497983813286, + 0.286735475063324, + 0.056173015385866165, + 0.028259649872779846, + 0.4159417450428009 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036131355445832014 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a missile with a sleek gray-white metal hull and tail stabilizers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot with a vintage film texture, slight color desaturation, and noticeable grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a fluid, unbroken 360-degree pan around the missile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a violent explosion producing an orange-red fireball that turns into black smoke and metal fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast pale blue sky with sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015090041561052203 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501509189605713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015090041561052203, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015090041561052203, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22037717700004578, + 0.08048990368843079, + 0.158547505736351, + 0.039993710815906525, + 0.0731998160481453, + 0.0527457669377327, + 0.16989624500274658, + 0.055798035115003586, + 0.07704821974039078, + 0.07190360128879547 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015090041561052203 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a military archival-style shot with a signature vintage film texture, featuring slight color desaturation and noticeable grain, the camera pans in a fluid, unbroken 360-degree pan, closely following a missile hurtling through the sky at high speed. The missile's sleek gray-white metal hull and tail stabilizers reflect a cool, austere luster in the harsh sunlight. A dense, swirling column of white smoke erupts from its tail, leaving a striking, persistent trail across the vast pale blue sky. As the camera rotates at a constant speed, the viewer's perspective shifts around the missile, while the horizon and sparse clouds in the background rotate accordingly, creating a powerful sense of motion and an immersive sense of speed. In the final stage of the surround shooting, the camera angle is exactly aimed at the direction of the missile's advance, capturing it rushing towards a distant, vaguely outlined aerial target with unstoppable momentum and precision. Finally, at the decisive moment when the missile contacts the target, the picture is occupied by a violent and silent explosion. A dazzling orange-red fireball suddenly bursts out, and then turns into a black smoke mixed with metal fragments, slowly dissipating in the air. The whole process is full of calm and shocking destructive aesthetics.", + "seed": 25734, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_12/index_9232_seed_25734_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.45236057313159106, + "vlm_logprob": -0.45236057313159106, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.45236057313159106, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a missile with a sleek gray-white metal hull and tail stabilizers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot with a vintage film texture, slight color desaturation, and noticeable grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a fluid, unbroken 360-degree pan around the missile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a violent explosion producing an orange-red fireball that turns into black smoke and metal fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast pale blue sky with sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02462141029536724 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7746214866638184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02462141029536724, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02462141029536724, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0496244840323925, + 0.16370542347431183, + 0.39013388752937317, + 0.06723131239414215, + 0.07542609423398972, + 0.030039241537451744, + 0.07168005406856537, + 0.034858398139476776, + 0.03035791777074337, + 0.08694320172071457 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02462141029536724 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a missile with a sleek gray-white metal hull and tail stabilizers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot with a vintage film texture, slight color desaturation, and noticeable grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a fluid, unbroken 360-degree pan around the missile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a violent explosion producing an orange-red fireball that turns into black smoke and metal fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast pale blue sky with sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28132152557373047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063215255737305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28132152557373047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28132152557373047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19422844052314758, + 0.10733435302972794, + 0.312926709651947, + 0.04318755492568016, + 0.021039651706814766, + 0.03277696669101715, + 0.03952108323574066, + 0.05872383713722229, + 0.051396872848272324, + 0.13886453211307526 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28132152557373047 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a missile with a sleek gray-white metal hull and tail stabilizers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot with a vintage film texture, slight color desaturation, and noticeable grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a fluid, unbroken 360-degree pan around the missile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a violent explosion producing an orange-red fireball that turns into black smoke and metal fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast pale blue sky with sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9102938175201416 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16029387712478638 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.9102938175201416, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.9102938175201416, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1269327998161316, + 0.04974307864904404, + 0.16522842645645142, + 0.0449567474424839, + 0.048526860773563385, + 0.08336437493562698, + 0.08277706801891327, + 0.08987267315387726, + 0.09588970243930817, + 0.21270832419395447 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.9102938175201416 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a missile with a sleek gray-white metal hull and tail stabilizers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot with a vintage film texture, slight color desaturation, and noticeable grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a fluid, unbroken 360-degree pan around the missile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a violent explosion producing an orange-red fireball that turns into black smoke and metal fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast pale blue sky with sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307904466986656 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168079137802124 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307904466986656, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307904466986656, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.050938814878463745, + 0.10327630490064621, + 0.06944363564252853, + 0.021221933886408806, + 0.03078732080757618, + 0.02695031464099884, + 0.01512366347014904, + 0.016198940575122833, + 0.05732965096831322, + 0.6087294220924377 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307904466986656 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a missile with a sleek gray-white metal hull and tail stabilizers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot with a vintage film texture, slight color desaturation, and noticeable grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a fluid, unbroken 360-degree pan around the missile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with a violent explosion producing an orange-red fireball that turns into black smoke and metal fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast pale blue sky with sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002487067598849535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.0024871826171875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002487067598849535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002487067598849535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13096734881401062, + 0.0957883968949318, + 0.42905211448669434, + 0.026267047971487045, + 0.024349186569452286, + 0.05496848747134209, + 0.052825696766376495, + 0.05406227335333824, + 0.04988105967640877, + 0.08183839917182922 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002487067598849535 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_13/index_tensor([3251, 3251])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_13/index_tensor([3251, 3251])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4fe9eece2d214033bc810c600a8d7747d5f3029b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_13/index_tensor([3251, 3251])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The film begins with an intimate close-up, rendered in the warm, faded sepia tones of a realistic old photograph. A small ginger cat, its fur a soft down, clings tenaciously to the thick, cream-colored knit of its owner's sweater. With its large, crystalline blue eyes, the kitten gazes forward with innocent trust, its miniature pink nose twitching slightly, its paws gently hooking into the wool. Then, the camera slowly and steadily pulls back, a deliberate and gentle movement that gradually expands the frame. The image shows the kitten resting securely on a person's chest, their hands tenderly cradling it. As the camera continues to retreat, the soft-focus scene resolutely unveils an old-fashioned photography studio, bathed in soft, diffuse light from a large, invisible window that casts long, gentle shadows. In the background, an old bellows camera, made of polished dark wood with brass fittings, stands on a tall wooden tripod, its lens trained directly on the couple, ready to capture this moment. The entire scene is imbued with a quiet, nostalgic atmosphere, evoking a sense of timeless tenderness and captured memories.", + "seed": 30212, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_13/index_3251_seed_30212_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0411682047881186, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0411682047881186, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0411682047881186, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in warm, faded sepia tones resembling an old photograph?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a small ginger cat with soft down fur clinging to a thick, cream-colored knit sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to expand the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an old-fashioned photography studio containing a dark wood bellows camera on a wooden tripod?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light casting long, gentle shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009268825873732567 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.759268760681152 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009268825873732567, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009268825873732567, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3401498794555664, + 0.11519350111484528, + 0.03648906201124191, + 0.05720391497015953, + 0.059324800968170166, + 0.03720225766301155, + 0.15054944157600403, + 0.10184475034475327, + 0.03783341869711876, + 0.0642089769244194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009268825873732567 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in warm, faded sepia tones resembling an old photograph?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a small ginger cat with soft down fur clinging to a thick, cream-colored knit sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to expand the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an old-fashioned photography studio containing a dark wood bellows camera on a wooden tripod?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light casting long, gentle shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005263993050903082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255263805389404 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005263993050903082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005263993050903082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32800689339637756, + 0.060820043087005615, + 0.09569530934095383, + 0.06351940333843231, + 0.12610000371932983, + 0.07437428086996078, + 0.11206182092428207, + 0.07219912111759186, + 0.03782077506184578, + 0.029402343556284904 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005263993050903082 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in warm, faded sepia tones resembling an old photograph?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a small ginger cat with soft down fur clinging to a thick, cream-colored knit sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to expand the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an old-fashioned photography studio containing a dark wood bellows camera on a wooden tripod?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light casting long, gentle shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16033652424812317 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103364944458008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16033652424812317, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16033652424812317, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12185212969779968, + 0.030222004279494286, + 0.033417608588933945, + 0.0346841961145401, + 0.06202232465147972, + 0.024906707927584648, + 0.5686408877372742, + 0.03285874053835869, + 0.04280020296573639, + 0.04859525337815285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16033652424812317 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in warm, faded sepia tones resembling an old photograph?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a small ginger cat with soft down fur clinging to a thick, cream-colored knit sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to expand the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an old-fashioned photography studio containing a dark wood bellows camera on a wooden tripod?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light casting long, gentle shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004637676291167736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379637718200684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004637676291167736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004637676291167736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09430412203073502, + 0.08897519111633301, + 0.0587051622569561, + 0.03874023258686066, + 0.04851295426487923, + 0.04477016255259514, + 0.43039727210998535, + 0.12717872858047485, + 0.04779089242219925, + 0.020625263452529907 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004637676291167736 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in warm, faded sepia tones resembling an old photograph?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a small ginger cat with soft down fur clinging to a thick, cream-colored knit sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to expand the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an old-fashioned photography studio containing a dark wood bellows camera on a wooden tripod?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light casting long, gentle shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02633400447666645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651334047317505 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02633400447666645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02633400447666645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21629886329174042, + 0.05858389288187027, + 0.061867039650678635, + 0.02930571138858795, + 0.058709874749183655, + 0.04646097123622894, + 0.2372124046087265, + 0.1944621354341507, + 0.029123669490218163, + 0.06797543913125992 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02633400447666645 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with an intimate close-up, rendered in the warm, faded sepia tones of a realistic old photograph. A small ginger cat, its fur a soft down, clings tenaciously to the thick, cream-colored knit of its owner's sweater. With its large, crystalline blue eyes, the kitten gazes forward with innocent trust, its miniature pink nose twitching slightly, its paws gently hooking into the wool. Then, the camera slowly and steadily pulls back, a deliberate and gentle movement that gradually expands the frame. The image shows the kitten resting securely on a person's chest, their hands tenderly cradling it. As the camera continues to retreat, the soft-focus scene resolutely unveils an old-fashioned photography studio, bathed in soft, diffuse light from a large, invisible window that casts long, gentle shadows. In the background, an old bellows camera, made of polished dark wood with brass fittings, stands on a tall wooden tripod, its lens trained directly on the couple, ready to capture this moment. The entire scene is imbued with a quiet, nostalgic atmosphere, evoking a sense of timeless tenderness and captured memories.", + "seed": 30213, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_13/index_3251_seed_30213_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.034380376385524866, + "vlm_logprob": -0.034380376385524866, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.034380376385524866, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in warm, faded sepia tones resembling an old photograph?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a small ginger cat with soft down fur clinging to a thick, cream-colored knit sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to expand the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an old-fashioned photography studio containing a dark wood bellows camera on a wooden tripod?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light casting long, gentle shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08963025361299515 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464630365371704 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08963025361299515, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08963025361299515, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31887179613113403, + 0.10805100947618484, + 0.029015375301241875, + 0.0846802294254303, + 0.016651298850774765, + 0.02564561367034912, + 0.2766846716403961, + 0.06430767476558685, + 0.026020856574177742, + 0.05007147789001465 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08963025361299515 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in warm, faded sepia tones resembling an old photograph?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a small ginger cat with soft down fur clinging to a thick, cream-colored knit sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to expand the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an old-fashioned photography studio containing a dark wood bellows camera on a wooden tripod?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light casting long, gentle shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004105354659259319 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504105567932129 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004105354659259319, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004105354659259319, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15792958438396454, + 0.26894015073776245, + 0.05419645830988884, + 0.11580917239189148, + 0.047399021685123444, + 0.03227962926030159, + 0.18303130567073822, + 0.06240097060799599, + 0.023418551310896873, + 0.054595112800598145 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004105354659259319 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in warm, faded sepia tones resembling an old photograph?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a small ginger cat with soft down fur clinging to a thick, cream-colored knit sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to expand the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an old-fashioned photography studio containing a dark wood bellows camera on a wooden tripod?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light casting long, gentle shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003613254288211465 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628613471984863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003613254288211465, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003613254288211465, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07493829727172852, + 0.029442574828863144, + 0.07441888749599457, + 0.19346347451210022, + 0.03416910022497177, + 0.06796454638242722, + 0.09199334681034088, + 0.30154359340667725, + 0.07196629792451859, + 0.06009988486766815 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003613254288211465 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in warm, faded sepia tones resembling an old photograph?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a small ginger cat with soft down fur clinging to a thick, cream-colored knit sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to expand the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an old-fashioned photography studio containing a dark wood bellows camera on a wooden tripod?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light casting long, gentle shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01253464724868536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875346183776855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01253464724868536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01253464724868536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.052694857120513916, + 0.052332162857055664, + 0.04079144448041916, + 0.13213489949703217, + 0.03034806065261364, + 0.03331533819437027, + 0.26715415716171265, + 0.09657037258148193, + 0.0823124498128891, + 0.21234619617462158 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01253464724868536 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in warm, faded sepia tones resembling an old photograph?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a small ginger cat with soft down fur clinging to a thick, cream-colored knit sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to expand the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an old-fashioned photography studio containing a dark wood bellows camera on a wooden tripod?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light casting long, gentle shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06201837211847305 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812018394470215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06201837211847305, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06201837211847305, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08185680210590363, + 0.13096201419830322, + 0.045340802520513535, + 0.06605834513902664, + 0.039397064596414566, + 0.03102528303861618, + 0.3443352282047272, + 0.10492664575576782, + 0.10587254166603088, + 0.05022526904940605 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06201837211847305 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with an intimate close-up, rendered in the warm, faded sepia tones of a realistic old photograph. A small ginger cat, its fur a soft down, clings tenaciously to the thick, cream-colored knit of its owner's sweater. With its large, crystalline blue eyes, the kitten gazes forward with innocent trust, its miniature pink nose twitching slightly, its paws gently hooking into the wool. Then, the camera slowly and steadily pulls back, a deliberate and gentle movement that gradually expands the frame. The image shows the kitten resting securely on a person's chest, their hands tenderly cradling it. As the camera continues to retreat, the soft-focus scene resolutely unveils an old-fashioned photography studio, bathed in soft, diffuse light from a large, invisible window that casts long, gentle shadows. In the background, an old bellows camera, made of polished dark wood with brass fittings, stands on a tall wooden tripod, its lens trained directly on the couple, ready to capture this moment. The entire scene is imbued with a quiet, nostalgic atmosphere, evoking a sense of timeless tenderness and captured memories.", + "seed": 30214, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_13/index_3251_seed_30214_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.02032540151849389, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02032540151849389, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02032540151849389, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in warm, faded sepia tones resembling an old photograph?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a small ginger cat with soft down fur clinging to a thick, cream-colored knit sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to expand the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an old-fashioned photography studio containing a dark wood bellows camera on a wooden tripod?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light casting long, gentle shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014900930225849152 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264901161193848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014900930225849152, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014900930225849152, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17832131683826447, + 0.10356404632329941, + 0.05367128551006317, + 0.03916403278708458, + 0.04598736763000488, + 0.1282341033220291, + 0.10285868495702744, + 0.07229751348495483, + 0.162478506565094, + 0.11342313885688782 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014900930225849152 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in warm, faded sepia tones resembling an old photograph?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a small ginger cat with soft down fur clinging to a thick, cream-colored knit sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to expand the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an old-fashioned photography studio containing a dark wood bellows camera on a wooden tripod?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light casting long, gentle shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002204370917752385 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127204418182373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002204370917752385, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002204370917752385, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1999724954366684, + 0.25229179859161377, + 0.0423847921192646, + 0.07454998046159744, + 0.06555669754743576, + 0.10233745723962784, + 0.04122721403837204, + 0.05100410059094429, + 0.10766401141881943, + 0.06301146745681763 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002204370917752385 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in warm, faded sepia tones resembling an old photograph?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a small ginger cat with soft down fur clinging to a thick, cream-colored knit sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to expand the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an old-fashioned photography studio containing a dark wood bellows camera on a wooden tripod?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light casting long, gentle shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048646148294210434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486462116241455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048646148294210434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048646148294210434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07218826562166214, + 0.11134219914674759, + 0.043111447244882584, + 0.02777802012860775, + 0.0658886656165123, + 0.07355732470750809, + 0.13942481577396393, + 0.06778375059366226, + 0.2925640046596527, + 0.10636147111654282 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048646148294210434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in warm, faded sepia tones resembling an old photograph?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a small ginger cat with soft down fur clinging to a thick, cream-colored knit sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to expand the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an old-fashioned photography studio containing a dark wood bellows camera on a wooden tripod?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light casting long, gentle shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021950930822640657 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127194881439209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021950930822640657, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021950930822640657, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2746689021587372, + 0.11657293885946274, + 0.048300113528966904, + 0.11191754788160324, + 0.04039885476231575, + 0.09423530846834183, + 0.13167186081409454, + 0.05354764685034752, + 0.03901233896613121, + 0.08967453241348267 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021950930822640657 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in warm, faded sepia tones resembling an old photograph?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a small ginger cat with soft down fur clinging to a thick, cream-colored knit sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to expand the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an old-fashioned photography studio containing a dark wood bellows camera on a wooden tripod?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light casting long, gentle shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368046507239342 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086804389953613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368046507239342, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368046507239342, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21600158512592316, + 0.18367667496204376, + 0.11592115461826324, + 0.037501487880945206, + 0.06679660081863403, + 0.04279147833585739, + 0.05856598913669586, + 0.0690455213189125, + 0.10916735976934433, + 0.10053213685750961 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368046507239342 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with an intimate close-up, rendered in the warm, faded sepia tones of a realistic old photograph. A small ginger cat, its fur a soft down, clings tenaciously to the thick, cream-colored knit of its owner's sweater. With its large, crystalline blue eyes, the kitten gazes forward with innocent trust, its miniature pink nose twitching slightly, its paws gently hooking into the wool. Then, the camera slowly and steadily pulls back, a deliberate and gentle movement that gradually expands the frame. The image shows the kitten resting securely on a person's chest, their hands tenderly cradling it. As the camera continues to retreat, the soft-focus scene resolutely unveils an old-fashioned photography studio, bathed in soft, diffuse light from a large, invisible window that casts long, gentle shadows. In the background, an old bellows camera, made of polished dark wood with brass fittings, stands on a tall wooden tripod, its lens trained directly on the couple, ready to capture this moment. The entire scene is imbued with a quiet, nostalgic atmosphere, evoking a sense of timeless tenderness and captured memories.", + "seed": 30215, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_13/index_3251_seed_30215_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.019476956129074095, + "vlm_logprob": -0.019476956129074095, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.019476956129074095, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in warm, faded sepia tones resembling an old photograph?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a small ginger cat with soft down fur clinging to a thick, cream-colored knit sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to expand the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an old-fashioned photography studio containing a dark wood bellows camera on a wooden tripod?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light casting long, gentle shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014902104623615742 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264902114868164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014902104623615742, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014902104623615742, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3481482267379761, + 0.129074364900589, + 0.05341838300228119, + 0.06811533123254776, + 0.0541115365922451, + 0.05914319306612015, + 0.04085481911897659, + 0.08236947655677795, + 0.04461084306240082, + 0.12015387415885925 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014902104623615742 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in warm, faded sepia tones resembling an old photograph?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a small ginger cat with soft down fur clinging to a thick, cream-colored knit sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to expand the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an old-fashioned photography studio containing a dark wood bellows camera on a wooden tripod?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light casting long, gentle shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032001733779907227 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753200054168701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032001733779907227, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032001733779907227, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1510639488697052, + 0.22359362244606018, + 0.1693071573972702, + 0.1377674788236618, + 0.07186069339513779, + 0.08160753548145294, + 0.03178480267524719, + 0.042319297790527344, + 0.0356101468205452, + 0.05508532375097275 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032001733779907227 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in warm, faded sepia tones resembling an old photograph?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a small ginger cat with soft down fur clinging to a thick, cream-colored knit sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to expand the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an old-fashioned photography studio containing a dark wood bellows camera on a wooden tripod?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light casting long, gentle shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008635676465928555 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758635520935059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008635676465928555, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008635676465928555, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08099652826786041, + 0.11119140684604645, + 0.19242288172245026, + 0.15946488082408905, + 0.16575753688812256, + 0.14357508718967438, + 0.08459411561489105, + 0.020929254591464996, + 0.014825521968305111, + 0.02624274604022503 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008635676465928555 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in warm, faded sepia tones resembling an old photograph?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a small ginger cat with soft down fur clinging to a thick, cream-colored knit sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to expand the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an old-fashioned photography studio containing a dark wood bellows camera on a wooden tripod?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light casting long, gentle shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00863473117351532 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758634567260742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00863473117351532, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00863473117351532, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3036213219165802, + 0.048450060188770294, + 0.13596558570861816, + 0.037213921546936035, + 0.03225349262356758, + 0.14575046300888062, + 0.10784832388162613, + 0.0887501910328865, + 0.03205658122897148, + 0.0680900365114212 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00863473117351532 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in warm, faded sepia tones resembling an old photograph?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a small ginger cat with soft down fur clinging to a thick, cream-colored knit sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to expand the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background an old-fashioned photography studio containing a dark wood bellows camera on a wooden tripod?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, diffuse light casting long, gentle shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062012095004320145 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812012195587158 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062012095004320145, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062012095004320145, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3006720542907715, + 0.1331065595149994, + 0.23938173055648804, + 0.10179002583026886, + 0.030181515961885452, + 0.05236978828907013, + 0.049521785229444504, + 0.01926574669778347, + 0.019000716507434845, + 0.0547100305557251 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062012095004320145 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_14/index_tensor([9256, 9256])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_14/index_tensor([9256, 9256])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3c2b8b6e4d9f2755971b4326b6122b7c0a647c68 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_14/index_tensor([9256, 9256])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In the style of a sports documentary, a low-angle, high-speed camera tracking shot, held close to the ground, captures in extreme slow motion the moment a professional motorcyclist conquers a precipitous mountain curve. Radiating the golden glow of the late afternoon sun, the athlete, clad in an aerodynamic black leather racing suit, its form-fitting leather embellished with striking red and white stripes, leans toward the apex at an improbable angle, his knees, covered in heavily worn sliders, almost parallel to the rough, dark gray asphalt. He controls a matte gray modern racing car, its lines sharp and its suspension compressed to the extreme by the immense centrifugal force. As the motorcycle leans to its limit, the motorcycle's metal footpegs and the athlete's knee sliders scrape against the road, instantly sending forth a shower of dazzling sparks. Under the extreme slow-motion particle effects, each spark is clearly visible. Like blazing miniature comets, they splash backwards with bright orange-yellow trails, briefly illuminating the sidewall of the rear tire that is spinning at high speed and slightly deformed by pressure, while stirring up a small amount of rubber and dust particles suspended in the warm air. The whole picture is full of the ultimate beauty of power, concentration and speed, creating a heart-pounding atmosphere of tension and awe.", + "seed": 19465, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_14/index_9256_seed_19465_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08280942705459893, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08280942705459893, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08280942705459893, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a professional motorcyclist wearing a black leather racing suit with red and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle matte gray with sharp lines and compressed suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show sparks flying from the footpegs and knee sliders scraping against dark gray asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks depicted as bright orange-yellow trails resembling blazing miniature comets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, high-speed camera tracking close to the ground in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16198959946632385 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9119895696640015 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16198959946632385, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16198959946632385, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19157154858112335, + 0.1558815836906433, + 0.12215539067983627, + 0.08236537128686905, + 0.046602945774793625, + 0.11124657094478607, + 0.04570216313004494, + 0.12359172850847244, + 0.041797589510679245, + 0.07908515632152557 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16198959946632385 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a professional motorcyclist wearing a black leather racing suit with red and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle matte gray with sharp lines and compressed suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show sparks flying from the footpegs and knee sliders scraping against dark gray asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks depicted as bright orange-yellow trails resembling blazing miniature comets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, high-speed camera tracking close to the ground in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2256091833114624 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006091833114624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2256091833114624, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2256091833114624, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14298611879348755, + 0.06447558104991913, + 0.08839400112628937, + 0.03365982323884964, + 0.03889026865363121, + 0.09100929647684097, + 0.022649524733424187, + 0.13923121988773346, + 0.08246305584907532, + 0.2962411344051361 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2256091833114624 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a professional motorcyclist wearing a black leather racing suit with red and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle matte gray with sharp lines and compressed suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show sparks flying from the footpegs and knee sliders scraping against dark gray asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks depicted as bright orange-yellow trails resembling blazing miniature comets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, high-speed camera tracking close to the ground in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014199178665876389 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264199256896973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014199178665876389, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014199178665876389, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04767937213182449, + 0.08881853520870209, + 0.020673301070928574, + 0.05729025974869728, + 0.013942240737378597, + 0.0827145054936409, + 0.013439415022730827, + 0.1724213808774948, + 0.06220725551247597, + 0.44081372022628784 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014199178665876389 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a professional motorcyclist wearing a black leather racing suit with red and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle matte gray with sharp lines and compressed suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show sparks flying from the footpegs and knee sliders scraping against dark gray asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks depicted as bright orange-yellow trails resembling blazing miniature comets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, high-speed camera tracking close to the ground in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036145609337836504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.62861442565918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036145609337836504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036145609337836504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07854507863521576, + 0.07108423113822937, + 0.038103796541690826, + 0.060275185853242874, + 0.052026957273483276, + 0.03424559161067009, + 0.024778742343187332, + 0.1623401939868927, + 0.04273185506463051, + 0.43586841225624084 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036145609337836504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a professional motorcyclist wearing a black leather racing suit with red and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle matte gray with sharp lines and compressed suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show sparks flying from the footpegs and knee sliders scraping against dark gray asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks depicted as bright orange-yellow trails resembling blazing miniature comets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, high-speed camera tracking close to the ground in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008634612895548344 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758634567260742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008634612895548344, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008634612895548344, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0900496244430542, + 0.062764011323452, + 0.08160834014415741, + 0.0670614019036293, + 0.10765612870454788, + 0.09510074555873871, + 0.0366714708507061, + 0.24114900827407837, + 0.037904415279626846, + 0.18003492057323456 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008634612895548344 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the style of a sports documentary, a low-angle, high-speed camera tracking shot, held close to the ground, captures in extreme slow motion the moment a professional motorcyclist conquers a precipitous mountain curve. Radiating the golden glow of the late afternoon sun, the athlete, clad in an aerodynamic black leather racing suit, its form-fitting leather embellished with striking red and white stripes, leans toward the apex at an improbable angle, his knees, covered in heavily worn sliders, almost parallel to the rough, dark gray asphalt. He controls a matte gray modern racing car, its lines sharp and its suspension compressed to the extreme by the immense centrifugal force. As the motorcycle leans to its limit, the motorcycle's metal footpegs and the athlete's knee sliders scrape against the road, instantly sending forth a shower of dazzling sparks. Under the extreme slow-motion particle effects, each spark is clearly visible. Like blazing miniature comets, they splash backwards with bright orange-yellow trails, briefly illuminating the sidewall of the rear tire that is spinning at high speed and slightly deformed by pressure, while stirring up a small amount of rubber and dust particles suspended in the warm air. The whole picture is full of the ultimate beauty of power, concentration and speed, creating a heart-pounding atmosphere of tension and awe.", + "seed": 19466, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_14/index_9256_seed_19466_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08767676991410553, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08767676991410553, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.724999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08767676991410553, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a professional motorcyclist wearing a black leather racing suit with red and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle matte gray with sharp lines and compressed suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show sparks flying from the footpegs and knee sliders scraping against dark gray asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks depicted as bright orange-yellow trails resembling blazing miniature comets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, high-speed camera tracking close to the ground in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31493908166885376 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.314939022064209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31493908166885376, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.9999999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31493908166885376, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3413354456424713, + 0.02851017378270626, + 0.050761617720127106, + 0.03692038357257843, + 0.03229312598705292, + 0.04219922423362732, + 0.09403225034475327, + 0.08265817165374756, + 0.1035759374499321, + 0.1877136379480362 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31493908166885376 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a professional motorcyclist wearing a black leather racing suit with red and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle matte gray with sharp lines and compressed suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show sparks flying from the footpegs and knee sliders scraping against dark gray asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks depicted as bright orange-yellow trails resembling blazing miniature comets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, high-speed camera tracking close to the ground in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1003231555223465 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.35032320022583 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1003231555223465, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1003231555223465, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14444220066070557, + 0.21603713929653168, + 0.11279353499412537, + 0.041697289794683456, + 0.07836756110191345, + 0.03945542871952057, + 0.10249079763889313, + 0.07578740268945694, + 0.047585245221853256, + 0.14134344458580017 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1003231555223465 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a professional motorcyclist wearing a black leather racing suit with red and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle matte gray with sharp lines and compressed suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show sparks flying from the footpegs and knee sliders scraping against dark gray asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks depicted as bright orange-yellow trails resembling blazing miniature comets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, high-speed camera tracking close to the ground in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014195417053997517 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264195442199707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014195417053997517, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014195417053997517, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11959367245435715, + 0.03767089545726776, + 0.03776056319475174, + 0.048316244035959244, + 0.208496555685997, + 0.06272031366825104, + 0.16841420531272888, + 0.07925159484148026, + 0.1135825365781784, + 0.12419341504573822 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014195417053997517 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a professional motorcyclist wearing a black leather racing suit with red and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle matte gray with sharp lines and compressed suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show sparks flying from the footpegs and knee sliders scraping against dark gray asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks depicted as bright orange-yellow trails resembling blazing miniature comets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, high-speed camera tracking close to the ground in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021961636375635862 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127196311950684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021961636375635862, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021961636375635862, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15274104475975037, + 0.07087799906730652, + 0.033039163798093796, + 0.1497093141078949, + 0.19005317986011505, + 0.11866825819015503, + 0.07217374444007874, + 0.03588784858584404, + 0.08668505400419235, + 0.0901644378900528 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021961636375635862 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a professional motorcyclist wearing a black leather racing suit with red and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle matte gray with sharp lines and compressed suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show sparks flying from the footpegs and knee sliders scraping against dark gray asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks depicted as bright orange-yellow trails resembling blazing miniature comets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, high-speed camera tracking close to the ground in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067300316877663136 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006730079650879 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067300316877663136, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067300316877663136, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07340849936008453, + 0.034364085644483566, + 0.051717907190322876, + 0.0441761277616024, + 0.09327876567840576, + 0.2407194823026657, + 0.23680531978607178, + 0.06789704412221909, + 0.07317837327718735, + 0.08445435017347336 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067300316877663136 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the style of a sports documentary, a low-angle, high-speed camera tracking shot, held close to the ground, captures in extreme slow motion the moment a professional motorcyclist conquers a precipitous mountain curve. Radiating the golden glow of the late afternoon sun, the athlete, clad in an aerodynamic black leather racing suit, its form-fitting leather embellished with striking red and white stripes, leans toward the apex at an improbable angle, his knees, covered in heavily worn sliders, almost parallel to the rough, dark gray asphalt. He controls a matte gray modern racing car, its lines sharp and its suspension compressed to the extreme by the immense centrifugal force. As the motorcycle leans to its limit, the motorcycle's metal footpegs and the athlete's knee sliders scrape against the road, instantly sending forth a shower of dazzling sparks. Under the extreme slow-motion particle effects, each spark is clearly visible. Like blazing miniature comets, they splash backwards with bright orange-yellow trails, briefly illuminating the sidewall of the rear tire that is spinning at high speed and slightly deformed by pressure, while stirring up a small amount of rubber and dust particles suspended in the warm air. The whole picture is full of the ultimate beauty of power, concentration and speed, creating a heart-pounding atmosphere of tension and awe.", + "seed": 19467, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_14/index_9256_seed_19467_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.07375781680457294, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07375781680457294, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07375781680457294, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a professional motorcyclist wearing a black leather racing suit with red and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle matte gray with sharp lines and compressed suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show sparks flying from the footpegs and knee sliders scraping against dark gray asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks depicted as bright orange-yellow trails resembling blazing miniature comets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, high-speed camera tracking close to the ground in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2530571222305298 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5030571222305298 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2530571222305298, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2530571222305298, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09928157180547714, + 0.09669499099254608, + 0.451382577419281, + 0.03810042515397072, + 0.04044588655233383, + 0.02766529656946659, + 0.02089991606771946, + 0.028195947408676147, + 0.14991529285907745, + 0.047418080270290375 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2530571222305298 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a professional motorcyclist wearing a black leather racing suit with red and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle matte gray with sharp lines and compressed suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show sparks flying from the footpegs and knee sliders scraping against dark gray asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks depicted as bright orange-yellow trails resembling blazing miniature comets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, high-speed camera tracking close to the ground in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10033005475997925 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350330114364624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10033005475997925, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10033005475997925, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18152418732643127, + 0.05758962407708168, + 0.4138544201850891, + 0.04971201717853546, + 0.12037685513496399, + 0.02466243878006935, + 0.028512146323919296, + 0.024711383506655693, + 0.06899916380643845, + 0.030057793483138084 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10033005475997925 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a professional motorcyclist wearing a black leather racing suit with red and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle matte gray with sharp lines and compressed suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show sparks flying from the footpegs and knee sliders scraping against dark gray asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks depicted as bright orange-yellow trails resembling blazing miniature comets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, high-speed camera tracking close to the ground in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008641703985631466 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758641719818115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008641703985631466, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008641703985631466, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14794199168682098, + 0.1704871505498886, + 0.07546517252922058, + 0.12003350257873535, + 0.10585950314998627, + 0.03755299746990204, + 0.15265020728111267, + 0.06968390941619873, + 0.06589138507843018, + 0.054434146732091904 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008641703985631466 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a professional motorcyclist wearing a black leather racing suit with red and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle matte gray with sharp lines and compressed suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show sparks flying from the footpegs and knee sliders scraping against dark gray asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks depicted as bright orange-yellow trails resembling blazing miniature comets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, high-speed camera tracking close to the ground in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015124559868127108 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.50151252746582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015124559868127108, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015124559868127108, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4115968346595764, + 0.04519971087574959, + 0.19982822239398956, + 0.03124917671084404, + 0.10775835067033768, + 0.009378919377923012, + 0.058540962636470795, + 0.029683470726013184, + 0.05565720051527023, + 0.051107171922922134 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015124559868127108 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a professional motorcyclist wearing a black leather racing suit with red and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle matte gray with sharp lines and compressed suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show sparks flying from the footpegs and knee sliders scraping against dark gray asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks depicted as bright orange-yellow trails resembling blazing miniature comets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, high-speed camera tracking close to the ground in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052477470599114895 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255247592926025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052477470599114895, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052477470599114895, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19256339967250824, + 0.08868024498224258, + 0.10101006925106049, + 0.1829962283372879, + 0.12382729351520538, + 0.06547749042510986, + 0.03700390085577965, + 0.02169216237962246, + 0.11587478965520859, + 0.07087443023920059 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052477470599114895 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the style of a sports documentary, a low-angle, high-speed camera tracking shot, held close to the ground, captures in extreme slow motion the moment a professional motorcyclist conquers a precipitous mountain curve. Radiating the golden glow of the late afternoon sun, the athlete, clad in an aerodynamic black leather racing suit, its form-fitting leather embellished with striking red and white stripes, leans toward the apex at an improbable angle, his knees, covered in heavily worn sliders, almost parallel to the rough, dark gray asphalt. He controls a matte gray modern racing car, its lines sharp and its suspension compressed to the extreme by the immense centrifugal force. As the motorcycle leans to its limit, the motorcycle's metal footpegs and the athlete's knee sliders scrape against the road, instantly sending forth a shower of dazzling sparks. Under the extreme slow-motion particle effects, each spark is clearly visible. Like blazing miniature comets, they splash backwards with bright orange-yellow trails, briefly illuminating the sidewall of the rear tire that is spinning at high speed and slightly deformed by pressure, while stirring up a small amount of rubber and dust particles suspended in the warm air. The whole picture is full of the ultimate beauty of power, concentration and speed, creating a heart-pounding atmosphere of tension and awe.", + "seed": 19468, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_14/index_9256_seed_19468_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.16613752543926238, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16613752543926238, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.924999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16613752543926238, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a professional motorcyclist wearing a black leather racing suit with red and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle matte gray with sharp lines and compressed suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show sparks flying from the footpegs and knee sliders scraping against dark gray asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks depicted as bright orange-yellow trails resembling blazing miniature comets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, high-speed camera tracking close to the ground in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14393123984336853 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0189311504364014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14393123984336853, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14393123984336853, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2618806064128876, + 0.035865165293216705, + 0.043304458260536194, + 0.03262416645884514, + 0.09797410666942596, + 0.09620372205972672, + 0.14642290771007538, + 0.16958965361118317, + 0.09482936561107635, + 0.021305866539478302 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14393123984336853 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a professional motorcyclist wearing a black leather racing suit with red and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle matte gray with sharp lines and compressed suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show sparks flying from the footpegs and knee sliders scraping against dark gray asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks depicted as bright orange-yellow trails resembling blazing miniature comets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, high-speed camera tracking close to the ground in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328198313713074 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578198313713074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6328198313713074, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6328198313713074, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19054009020328522, + 0.051939304918050766, + 0.11920899152755737, + 0.03755834326148033, + 0.06320260465145111, + 0.05622272193431854, + 0.060666896402835846, + 0.16933977603912354, + 0.22805894911289215, + 0.02326223812997341 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6328198313713074 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a professional motorcyclist wearing a black leather racing suit with red and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle matte gray with sharp lines and compressed suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show sparks flying from the footpegs and knee sliders scraping against dark gray asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks depicted as bright orange-yellow trails resembling blazing miniature comets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, high-speed camera tracking close to the ground in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980804070830345 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298080444335938 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980804070830345, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980804070830345, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10614535212516785, + 0.038847170770168304, + 0.05644841119647026, + 0.1065211296081543, + 0.11352076381444931, + 0.11524534970521927, + 0.1524391770362854, + 0.12950262427330017, + 0.1425883024930954, + 0.03874176740646362 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980804070830345 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a professional motorcyclist wearing a black leather racing suit with red and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle matte gray with sharp lines and compressed suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show sparks flying from the footpegs and knee sliders scraping against dark gray asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks depicted as bright orange-yellow trails resembling blazing miniature comets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, high-speed camera tracking close to the ground in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005949288606643677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309494972229 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005949288606643677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005949288606643677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2014794796705246, + 0.03939010202884674, + 0.15175120532512665, + 0.04730863496661186, + 0.06570455431938171, + 0.03539669141173363, + 0.06083013862371445, + 0.2569563388824463, + 0.10608160495758057, + 0.035101260989904404 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005949288606643677 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a professional motorcyclist wearing a black leather racing suit with red and white stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the motorcycle matte gray with sharp lines and compressed suspension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show sparks flying from the footpegs and knee sliders scraping against dark gray asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the sparks depicted as bright orange-yellow trails resembling blazing miniature comets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low-angle, high-speed camera tracking close to the ground in extreme slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01817922666668892 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018179416656494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01817922666668892, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01817922666668892, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07521824538707733, + 0.018292248249053955, + 0.018209140747785568, + 0.01602984592318535, + 0.028875384479761124, + 0.022643836215138435, + 0.020160021260380745, + 0.7228592038154602, + 0.054700370877981186, + 0.023011693730950356 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01817922666668892 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_15/index_tensor([2039, 2039])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_15/index_tensor([2039, 2039])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5ae543cfa9d24f1a02a8909f20c8de0986ef6590 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_15/index_tensor([2039, 2039])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle, rotating shot, captured in a powerful, candid style, closely follows a cherry-red, family-use tricycle. Under the glaring afternoon sun, the tricycle hurtles toward the corner of a makeshift track constructed on the park's asphalt path at a speed belying its design. The metallic paintwork gleams with dazzling light, and the handlebars reveal the whitening knuckles of clenched fists. As it fiercely carves into the turn, the vehicle tilts perilously outward, nearly tipping over. In that instant, the inside rear wheel is completely lifted off the ground, its black rubber tire spinning futilely and wildly in mid-air, a stark contrast to the rough gray track surface below. The other two tires, gripped by the immense centrifugal force, kick up a cloud of fine dust and grit. In the background, blurred spectators and fluttering colorful flags flash by, their intense motion blur accentuating the tricycle's breakneck speed. The entire picture is filled with highly saturated colors and strong contrast between light and dark, perfectly capturing this comical and exciting competitive moment that pushes household items to their limits, creating an intense atmosphere of adrenaline rush.", + "seed": 5399, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_15/index_2039_seed_5399_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05974648930132389, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05974648930132389, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05974648930132389, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cherry-red family-use tricycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tricycle moving at high speed toward a corner of a makeshift track on an asphalt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the inside rear wheel completely lifted off the ground while spinning in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a rotating camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by highly saturated colors and strong contrast between light and dark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05030089244246483 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0503008365631104 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05030089244246483, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05030089244246483, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.180633544921875, + 0.11393362283706665, + 0.0737428367137909, + 0.11342345178127289, + 0.13247734308242798, + 0.09564653038978577, + 0.04324594512581825, + 0.0330432653427124, + 0.047540925443172455, + 0.1663125455379486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05030089244246483 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cherry-red family-use tricycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tricycle moving at high speed toward a corner of a makeshift track on an asphalt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the inside rear wheel completely lifted off the ground while spinning in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a rotating camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by highly saturated colors and strong contrast between light and dark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17986585199832916 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804865837097168 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17986585199832916, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17986585199832916, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0837554782629013, + 0.21942606568336487, + 0.09764127433300018, + 0.10794156789779663, + 0.0595441535115242, + 0.09057407826185226, + 0.03577908128499985, + 0.10855086147785187, + 0.03656569495797157, + 0.16022172570228577 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17986585199832916 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cherry-red family-use tricycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tricycle moving at high speed toward a corner of a makeshift track on an asphalt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the inside rear wheel completely lifted off the ground while spinning in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a rotating camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by highly saturated colors and strong contrast between light and dark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020592350512742996 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895592451095581 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020592350512742996, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020592350512742996, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10171330720186234, + 0.10330428928136826, + 0.08077967911958694, + 0.07180313020944595, + 0.18819618225097656, + 0.052617669105529785, + 0.05109953507781029, + 0.11908920109272003, + 0.08540644496679306, + 0.1459905505180359 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020592350512742996 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cherry-red family-use tricycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tricycle moving at high speed toward a corner of a makeshift track on an asphalt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the inside rear wheel completely lifted off the ground while spinning in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a rotating camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by highly saturated colors and strong contrast between light and dark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029796933755278587 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529796838760376 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029796933755278587, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029796933755278587, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18059566617012024, + 0.06957248598337173, + 0.044763125479221344, + 0.05932094156742096, + 0.14007367193698883, + 0.14924751222133636, + 0.07160016149282455, + 0.13135063648223877, + 0.05219113081693649, + 0.10128459334373474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029796933755278587 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cherry-red family-use tricycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tricycle moving at high speed toward a corner of a makeshift track on an asphalt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the inside rear wheel completely lifted off the ground while spinning in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a rotating camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by highly saturated colors and strong contrast between light and dark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01817641779780388 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018176555633545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01817641779780388, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01817641779780388, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.382681280374527, + 0.04362113028764725, + 0.04303938150405884, + 0.03307823836803436, + 0.04982500895857811, + 0.03215315565466881, + 0.04343361780047417, + 0.03189040720462799, + 0.0630834698677063, + 0.27719423174858093 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01817641779780388 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle, rotating shot, captured in a powerful, candid style, closely follows a cherry-red, family-use tricycle. Under the glaring afternoon sun, the tricycle hurtles toward the corner of a makeshift track constructed on the park's asphalt path at a speed belying its design. The metallic paintwork gleams with dazzling light, and the handlebars reveal the whitening knuckles of clenched fists. As it fiercely carves into the turn, the vehicle tilts perilously outward, nearly tipping over. In that instant, the inside rear wheel is completely lifted off the ground, its black rubber tire spinning futilely and wildly in mid-air, a stark contrast to the rough gray track surface below. The other two tires, gripped by the immense centrifugal force, kick up a cloud of fine dust and grit. In the background, blurred spectators and fluttering colorful flags flash by, their intense motion blur accentuating the tricycle's breakneck speed. The entire picture is filled with highly saturated colors and strong contrast between light and dark, perfectly capturing this comical and exciting competitive moment that pushes household items to their limits, creating an intense atmosphere of adrenaline rush.", + "seed": 5400, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_15/index_2039_seed_5400_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04157730471342802, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04157730471342802, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04157730471342802, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cherry-red family-use tricycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tricycle moving at high speed toward a corner of a makeshift track on an asphalt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the inside rear wheel completely lifted off the ground while spinning in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a rotating camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by highly saturated colors and strong contrast between light and dark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05077734962105751 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0507774353027344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05077734962105751, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05077734962105751, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10973953455686569, + 0.08070757985115051, + 0.21116584539413452, + 0.07816504687070847, + 0.08575417846441269, + 0.031062429770827293, + 0.21546562016010284, + 0.04551698639988899, + 0.09685338288545609, + 0.045569345355033875 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05077734962105751 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cherry-red family-use tricycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tricycle moving at high speed toward a corner of a makeshift track on an asphalt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the inside rear wheel completely lifted off the ground while spinning in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a rotating camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by highly saturated colors and strong contrast between light and dark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11291424185037613 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379143238067627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11291424185037613, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11291424185037613, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11883822083473206, + 0.08508842438459396, + 0.10146331042051315, + 0.10146604478359222, + 0.05780794844031334, + 0.0936601459980011, + 0.17763836681842804, + 0.07669138163328171, + 0.055974967777729034, + 0.13137124478816986 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11291424185037613 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cherry-red family-use tricycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tricycle moving at high speed toward a corner of a makeshift track on an asphalt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the inside rear wheel completely lifted off the ground while spinning in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a rotating camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by highly saturated colors and strong contrast between light and dark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020589781925082207 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895589828491211 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020589781925082207, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020589781925082207, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13001203536987305, + 0.0938054695725441, + 0.08698925375938416, + 0.05272243171930313, + 0.0819949209690094, + 0.1007092222571373, + 0.33444106578826904, + 0.02449413388967514, + 0.0391511395573616, + 0.05568039044737816 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020589781925082207 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cherry-red family-use tricycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tricycle moving at high speed toward a corner of a makeshift track on an asphalt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the inside rear wheel completely lifted off the ground while spinning in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a rotating camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by highly saturated colors and strong contrast between light and dark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011075212620198727 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511075019836426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011075212620198727, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011075212620198727, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3213962912559509, + 0.0909193679690361, + 0.07418743520975113, + 0.08904294669628143, + 0.09206441044807434, + 0.16764825582504272, + 0.05578182637691498, + 0.038016580045223236, + 0.034136250615119934, + 0.03680666536092758 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011075212620198727 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cherry-red family-use tricycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tricycle moving at high speed toward a corner of a makeshift track on an asphalt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the inside rear wheel completely lifted off the ground while spinning in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a rotating camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by highly saturated colors and strong contrast between light and dark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01252993755042553 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875298500061035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01252993755042553, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01252993755042553, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3083527088165283, + 0.2698502540588379, + 0.03323066607117653, + 0.0659172460436821, + 0.03591356799006462, + 0.02783115580677986, + 0.034703850746154785, + 0.1526864767074585, + 0.021161938086152077, + 0.050352197140455246 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01252993755042553 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle, rotating shot, captured in a powerful, candid style, closely follows a cherry-red, family-use tricycle. Under the glaring afternoon sun, the tricycle hurtles toward the corner of a makeshift track constructed on the park's asphalt path at a speed belying its design. The metallic paintwork gleams with dazzling light, and the handlebars reveal the whitening knuckles of clenched fists. As it fiercely carves into the turn, the vehicle tilts perilously outward, nearly tipping over. In that instant, the inside rear wheel is completely lifted off the ground, its black rubber tire spinning futilely and wildly in mid-air, a stark contrast to the rough gray track surface below. The other two tires, gripped by the immense centrifugal force, kick up a cloud of fine dust and grit. In the background, blurred spectators and fluttering colorful flags flash by, their intense motion blur accentuating the tricycle's breakneck speed. The entire picture is filled with highly saturated colors and strong contrast between light and dark, perfectly capturing this comical and exciting competitive moment that pushes household items to their limits, creating an intense atmosphere of adrenaline rush.", + "seed": 5401, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_15/index_2039_seed_5401_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.048771897330880165, + "vlm_logprob": -0.048771897330880165, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.048771897330880165, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cherry-red family-use tricycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tricycle moving at high speed toward a corner of a makeshift track on an asphalt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the inside rear wheel completely lifted off the ground while spinning in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a rotating camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by highly saturated colors and strong contrast between light and dark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08057486265897751 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5805747509002686 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08057486265897751, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08057486265897751, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1812797486782074, + 0.07118713855743408, + 0.34618261456489563, + 0.023611348122358322, + 0.054820358753204346, + 0.06276077032089233, + 0.07983269542455673, + 0.09976887702941895, + 0.029376940801739693, + 0.05117948725819588 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08057486265897751 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cherry-red family-use tricycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tricycle moving at high speed toward a corner of a makeshift track on an asphalt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the inside rear wheel completely lifted off the ground while spinning in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a rotating camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by highly saturated colors and strong contrast between light and dark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10029543936252594 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3502955436706543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10029543936252594, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10029543936252594, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08228375762701035, + 0.060806214809417725, + 0.0344206728041172, + 0.03793667256832123, + 0.035711731761693954, + 0.051134929060935974, + 0.06995812803506851, + 0.09690579026937485, + 0.4122852087020874, + 0.11855689436197281 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10029543936252594 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cherry-red family-use tricycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tricycle moving at high speed toward a corner of a makeshift track on an asphalt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the inside rear wheel completely lifted off the ground while spinning in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a rotating camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by highly saturated colors and strong contrast between light and dark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026354322209954262 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513543128967285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026354322209954262, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026354322209954262, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1948297768831253, + 0.0727657750248909, + 0.05398968234658241, + 0.0454462394118309, + 0.06564109772443771, + 0.040875863283872604, + 0.149126335978508, + 0.06903376430273056, + 0.22876106202602386, + 0.07953030616044998 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026354322209954262 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cherry-red family-use tricycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tricycle moving at high speed toward a corner of a makeshift track on an asphalt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the inside rear wheel completely lifted off the ground while spinning in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a rotating camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by highly saturated colors and strong contrast between light and dark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057693526148796 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955769538879395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057693526148796, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057693526148796, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12028515338897705, + 0.17049919068813324, + 0.04067598655819893, + 0.06773335486650467, + 0.026525067165493965, + 0.028562843799591064, + 0.3212352395057678, + 0.16115307807922363, + 0.044648535549640656, + 0.018681593239307404 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057693526148796 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cherry-red family-use tricycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tricycle moving at high speed toward a corner of a makeshift track on an asphalt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the inside rear wheel completely lifted off the ground while spinning in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a rotating camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by highly saturated colors and strong contrast between light and dark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016057927161455154 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141057968139648 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016057927161455154, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016057927161455154, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29617196321487427, + 0.08411767333745956, + 0.11157911270856857, + 0.044376619160175323, + 0.02917766012251377, + 0.022990386933088303, + 0.06912077963352203, + 0.06853403896093369, + 0.142708882689476, + 0.1312229186296463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016057927161455154 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle, rotating shot, captured in a powerful, candid style, closely follows a cherry-red, family-use tricycle. Under the glaring afternoon sun, the tricycle hurtles toward the corner of a makeshift track constructed on the park's asphalt path at a speed belying its design. The metallic paintwork gleams with dazzling light, and the handlebars reveal the whitening knuckles of clenched fists. As it fiercely carves into the turn, the vehicle tilts perilously outward, nearly tipping over. In that instant, the inside rear wheel is completely lifted off the ground, its black rubber tire spinning futilely and wildly in mid-air, a stark contrast to the rough gray track surface below. The other two tires, gripped by the immense centrifugal force, kick up a cloud of fine dust and grit. In the background, blurred spectators and fluttering colorful flags flash by, their intense motion blur accentuating the tricycle's breakneck speed. The entire picture is filled with highly saturated colors and strong contrast between light and dark, perfectly capturing this comical and exciting competitive moment that pushes household items to their limits, creating an intense atmosphere of adrenaline rush.", + "seed": 5402, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_15/index_2039_seed_5402_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.041878684610128405, + "vlm_logprob": -0.041878684610128405, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.041878684610128405, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cherry-red family-use tricycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tricycle moving at high speed toward a corner of a makeshift track on an asphalt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the inside rear wheel completely lifted off the ground while spinning in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a rotating camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by highly saturated colors and strong contrast between light and dark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11492928117513657 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.23992919921875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11492928117513657, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11492928117513657, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10609448701143265, + 0.04739435389637947, + 0.03947067633271217, + 0.06486407667398453, + 0.24938835203647614, + 0.1505991369485855, + 0.21641142666339874, + 0.04558439925312996, + 0.031348034739494324, + 0.04884511977434158 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11492928117513657 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cherry-red family-use tricycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tricycle moving at high speed toward a corner of a makeshift track on an asphalt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the inside rear wheel completely lifted off the ground while spinning in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a rotating camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by highly saturated colors and strong contrast between light and dark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370225057005882 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087021350860596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370225057005882, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370225057005882, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15126250684261322, + 0.1834605634212494, + 0.17021524906158447, + 0.0442807637155056, + 0.08690137416124344, + 0.07830468565225601, + 0.14531977474689484, + 0.04819106310606003, + 0.026805002242326736, + 0.06525900214910507 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370225057005882 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cherry-red family-use tricycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tricycle moving at high speed toward a corner of a makeshift track on an asphalt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the inside rear wheel completely lifted off the ground while spinning in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a rotating camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by highly saturated colors and strong contrast between light and dark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329331450164318 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732932567596436 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329331450164318, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329331450164318, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2182956039905548, + 0.11442442238330841, + 0.13307490944862366, + 0.04282226786017418, + 0.19740143418312073, + 0.09800031781196594, + 0.029504945501685143, + 0.058422449976205826, + 0.06632079929113388, + 0.04173288121819496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329331450164318 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cherry-red family-use tricycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tricycle moving at high speed toward a corner of a makeshift track on an asphalt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the inside rear wheel completely lifted off the ground while spinning in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a rotating camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by highly saturated colors and strong contrast between light and dark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014194594696164131 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264194488525391 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014194594696164131, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014194594696164131, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1614190936088562, + 0.12635120749473572, + 0.06646488606929779, + 0.14570802450180054, + 0.11017276346683502, + 0.059331148862838745, + 0.07619579136371613, + 0.06452780961990356, + 0.09868305921554565, + 0.09114617109298706 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014194594696164131 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cherry-red family-use tricycle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the tricycle moving at high speed toward a corner of a makeshift track on an asphalt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the inside rear wheel completely lifted off the ground while spinning in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from a low angle with a rotating camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the image characterized by highly saturated colors and strong contrast between light and dark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023273982107639313 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732739448547363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023273982107639313, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023273982107639313, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25299322605133057, + 0.2020442634820938, + 0.026214223355054855, + 0.04848566651344299, + 0.15167663991451263, + 0.08010321110486984, + 0.08918111771345139, + 0.0319536030292511, + 0.03643283247947693, + 0.08091524243354797 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023273982107639313 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_2/index_tensor([5400, 5400])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_2/index_tensor([5400, 5400])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..80c89ba3c8cb0bf060adb776142802e561477a94 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_2/index_tensor([5400, 5400])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, still photograph taken from a slightly elevated angle captures a tiny, iridescent black beetle perched on the richly textured, dark gray plastic dashboard of a moving car. Intense, direct sunlight filtering through the windshield casts harsh, bright spots on the beetle's smooth carapace and creates sharp, elongated micro-shadows beneath its body. The entire surface vibrates with the vehicle's subtle, high-frequency vibrations, causing the beetle to desperately search for its place. Its six spindly legs frantically wriggle, sliding across the smooth, sun-warmed plastic, its antennae twitching nervously. It periodically grasps the raised veins of the dashboard's texture, only to be jolted again by the constant movement, sliding a few millimeters with each jolt. In the background, a bright, overexposed landscape of sun-bleached road and passing trees, completely blurred through the out-of-focus windshield, emphasizes the car's speed and creates a tense, slightly dramatic atmosphere focused entirely on this tiny creature's Herculean efforts to survive.", + "seed": 24428, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_2/index_5400_seed_24428_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.17277547288686038, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17277547288686038, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17277547288686038, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a tiny, iridescent black beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the beetle perched on a dark gray plastic dashboard with raised veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does intense direct sunlight create harsh bright spots and sharp elongated micro-shadows on the beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a bright, overexposed landscape of a sun-bleached road and passing trees that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the beetle exhibit frantic wriggling legs and antennae twitching while sliding across the vibrating surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04659494012594223 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1715948581695557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04659494012594223, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04659494012594223, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12362218648195267, + 0.041387587785720825, + 0.032675668597221375, + 0.08305680006742477, + 0.04315364360809326, + 0.06794438511133194, + 0.2208796888589859, + 0.05017875134944916, + 0.06843839585781097, + 0.26866284012794495 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04659494012594223 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a tiny, iridescent black beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the beetle perched on a dark gray plastic dashboard with raised veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does intense direct sunlight create harsh bright spots and sharp elongated micro-shadows on the beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a bright, overexposed landscape of a sun-bleached road and passing trees that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the beetle exhibit frantic wriggling legs and antennae twitching while sliding across the vibrating surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02330426312983036 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733042240142822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02330426312983036, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02330426312983036, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08836358040571213, + 0.07826158404350281, + 0.071579709649086, + 0.0783475935459137, + 0.02309366874396801, + 0.13891933858394623, + 0.07007522881031036, + 0.10260635614395142, + 0.07881191372871399, + 0.2699410021305084 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02330426312983036 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a tiny, iridescent black beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the beetle perched on a dark gray plastic dashboard with raised veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does intense direct sunlight create harsh bright spots and sharp elongated micro-shadows on the beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a bright, overexposed landscape of a sun-bleached road and passing trees that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the beetle exhibit frantic wriggling legs and antennae twitching while sliding across the vibrating surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026358967646956444 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513590812683105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026358967646956444, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026358967646956444, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10524771362543106, + 0.12462698668241501, + 0.03589067980647087, + 0.027722610160708427, + 0.04746139422059059, + 0.04582740738987923, + 0.19045913219451904, + 0.036654070019721985, + 0.05612095817923546, + 0.32998907566070557 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026358967646956444 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a tiny, iridescent black beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the beetle perched on a dark gray plastic dashboard with raised veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does intense direct sunlight create harsh bright spots and sharp elongated micro-shadows on the beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a bright, overexposed landscape of a sun-bleached road and passing trees that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the beetle exhibit frantic wriggling legs and antennae twitching while sliding across the vibrating surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009792149998247623 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634792327880859 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009792149998247623, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009792149998247623, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09432876855134964, + 0.11893217265605927, + 0.171103835105896, + 0.08501514047384262, + 0.027417581528425217, + 0.04576067626476288, + 0.03434762358665466, + 0.05899057537317276, + 0.027762599289417267, + 0.3363410234451294 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009792149998247623 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a tiny, iridescent black beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the beetle perched on a dark gray plastic dashboard with raised veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does intense direct sunlight create harsh bright spots and sharp elongated micro-shadows on the beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a bright, overexposed landscape of a sun-bleached road and passing trees that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the beetle exhibit frantic wriggling legs and antennae twitching while sliding across the vibrating surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578270435333252 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328270435333252 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7578270435333252, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7578270435333252, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09732598066329956, + 0.09191569685935974, + 0.02569783851504326, + 0.08623818308115005, + 0.07956034690141678, + 0.043526940047740936, + 0.1477850377559662, + 0.039451781660318375, + 0.16248996555805206, + 0.22600823640823364 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7578270435333252 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, still photograph taken from a slightly elevated angle captures a tiny, iridescent black beetle perched on the richly textured, dark gray plastic dashboard of a moving car. Intense, direct sunlight filtering through the windshield casts harsh, bright spots on the beetle's smooth carapace and creates sharp, elongated micro-shadows beneath its body. The entire surface vibrates with the vehicle's subtle, high-frequency vibrations, causing the beetle to desperately search for its place. Its six spindly legs frantically wriggle, sliding across the smooth, sun-warmed plastic, its antennae twitching nervously. It periodically grasps the raised veins of the dashboard's texture, only to be jolted again by the constant movement, sliding a few millimeters with each jolt. In the background, a bright, overexposed landscape of sun-bleached road and passing trees, completely blurred through the out-of-focus windshield, emphasizes the car's speed and creates a tense, slightly dramatic atmosphere focused entirely on this tiny creature's Herculean efforts to survive.", + "seed": 24429, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_2/index_5400_seed_24429_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.3587988378480077, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3587988378480077, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3587988378480077, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a tiny, iridescent black beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the beetle perched on a dark gray plastic dashboard with raised veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does intense direct sunlight create harsh bright spots and sharp elongated micro-shadows on the beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a bright, overexposed landscape of a sun-bleached road and passing trees that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the beetle exhibit frantic wriggling legs and antennae twitching while sliding across the vibrating surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4071769714355469 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2821769416332245 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.4071769714355469, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -1.4071769714355469, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11377441883087158, + 0.03289523720741272, + 0.03565329685807228, + 0.06692716479301453, + 0.1191168874502182, + 0.20379874110221863, + 0.19825144112110138, + 0.026197541505098343, + 0.07122809439897537, + 0.13215716183185577 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.4071769714355469 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a tiny, iridescent black beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the beetle perched on a dark gray plastic dashboard with raised veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does intense direct sunlight create harsh bright spots and sharp elongated micro-shadows on the beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a bright, overexposed landscape of a sun-bleached road and passing trees that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the beetle exhibit frantic wriggling legs and antennae twitching while sliding across the vibrating surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2016592025756836 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016592025756836 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2016592025756836, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2016592025756836, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07049351185560226, + 0.05091742426156998, + 0.024977128952741623, + 0.10770166665315628, + 0.37342438101768494, + 0.08477869629859924, + 0.1118156760931015, + 0.04835095629096031, + 0.08186320960521698, + 0.04567732661962509 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2016592025756836 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a tiny, iridescent black beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the beetle perched on a dark gray plastic dashboard with raised veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does intense direct sunlight create harsh bright spots and sharp elongated micro-shadows on the beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a bright, overexposed landscape of a sun-bleached road and passing trees that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the beetle exhibit frantic wriggling legs and antennae twitching while sliding across the vibrating surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016094762831926346 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14109468460083 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016094762831926346, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016094762831926346, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10080500692129135, + 0.019320059567689896, + 0.04217159375548363, + 0.05457787960767746, + 0.09924296289682388, + 0.14199258387088776, + 0.1766146421432495, + 0.024191631004214287, + 0.06922394037246704, + 0.27185961604118347 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016094762831926346 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a tiny, iridescent black beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the beetle perched on a dark gray plastic dashboard with raised veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does intense direct sunlight create harsh bright spots and sharp elongated micro-shadows on the beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a bright, overexposed landscape of a sun-bleached road and passing trees that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the beetle exhibit frantic wriggling legs and antennae twitching while sliding across the vibrating surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008655649609863758 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758655548095703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008655649609863758, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008655649609863758, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11466888338327408, + 0.03915423899888992, + 0.07892466336488724, + 0.06270496547222137, + 0.1399269700050354, + 0.14776453375816345, + 0.16603247821331024, + 0.05278148129582405, + 0.09987683594226837, + 0.09816496819257736 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008655649609863758 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a tiny, iridescent black beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the beetle perched on a dark gray plastic dashboard with raised veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does intense direct sunlight create harsh bright spots and sharp elongated micro-shadows on the beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a bright, overexposed landscape of a sun-bleached road and passing trees that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the beetle exhibit frantic wriggling legs and antennae twitching while sliding across the vibrating surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16040760278701782 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910407543182373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16040760278701782, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16040760278701782, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05294669419527054, + 0.019697101786732674, + 0.04992028698325157, + 0.05195557698607445, + 0.23895160853862762, + 0.1537700742483139, + 0.20462819933891296, + 0.040837544947862625, + 0.0540267638862133, + 0.13326609134674072 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16040760278701782 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, still photograph taken from a slightly elevated angle captures a tiny, iridescent black beetle perched on the richly textured, dark gray plastic dashboard of a moving car. Intense, direct sunlight filtering through the windshield casts harsh, bright spots on the beetle's smooth carapace and creates sharp, elongated micro-shadows beneath its body. The entire surface vibrates with the vehicle's subtle, high-frequency vibrations, causing the beetle to desperately search for its place. Its six spindly legs frantically wriggle, sliding across the smooth, sun-warmed plastic, its antennae twitching nervously. It periodically grasps the raised veins of the dashboard's texture, only to be jolted again by the constant movement, sliding a few millimeters with each jolt. In the background, a bright, overexposed landscape of sun-bleached road and passing trees, completely blurred through the out-of-focus windshield, emphasizes the car's speed and creates a tense, slightly dramatic atmosphere focused entirely on this tiny creature's Herculean efforts to survive.", + "seed": 24430, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_2/index_5400_seed_24430_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.022245751321315767, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022245751321315767, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022245751321315767, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a tiny, iridescent black beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the beetle perched on a dark gray plastic dashboard with raised veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does intense direct sunlight create harsh bright spots and sharp elongated micro-shadows on the beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a bright, overexposed landscape of a sun-bleached road and passing trees that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the beetle exhibit frantic wriggling legs and antennae twitching while sliding across the vibrating surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016145670786499977 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.391145706176758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016145670786499977, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016145670786499977, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11075844615697861, + 0.06059211120009422, + 0.17179979383945465, + 0.0787874311208725, + 0.2880053222179413, + 0.04407208785414696, + 0.08325047045946121, + 0.08382492512464523, + 0.04558449611067772, + 0.03332493081688881 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016145670786499977 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a tiny, iridescent black beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the beetle perched on a dark gray plastic dashboard with raised veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does intense direct sunlight create harsh bright spots and sharp elongated micro-shadows on the beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a bright, overexposed landscape of a sun-bleached road and passing trees that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the beetle exhibit frantic wriggling legs and antennae twitching while sliding across the vibrating surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014204937033355236 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264204978942871 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014204937033355236, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014204937033355236, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0682840645313263, + 0.14641821384429932, + 0.30388736724853516, + 0.08315892517566681, + 0.17902812361717224, + 0.04008723795413971, + 0.06153355911374092, + 0.04445153847336769, + 0.04887766391038895, + 0.02427322417497635 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014204937033355236 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a tiny, iridescent black beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the beetle perched on a dark gray plastic dashboard with raised veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does intense direct sunlight create harsh bright spots and sharp elongated micro-shadows on the beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a bright, overexposed landscape of a sun-bleached road and passing trees that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the beetle exhibit frantic wriggling legs and antennae twitching while sliding across the vibrating surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014201529324054718 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264201641082764 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014201529324054718, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014201529324054718, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17234665155410767, + 0.06522245705127716, + 0.31092751026153564, + 0.13030897080898285, + 0.07654524594545364, + 0.07119496911764145, + 0.030999034643173218, + 0.05195651575922966, + 0.04010651633143425, + 0.05039208382368088 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014201529324054718 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a tiny, iridescent black beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the beetle perched on a dark gray plastic dashboard with raised veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does intense direct sunlight create harsh bright spots and sharp elongated micro-shadows on the beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a bright, overexposed landscape of a sun-bleached road and passing trees that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the beetle exhibit frantic wriggling legs and antennae twitching while sliding across the vibrating surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046449145302176476 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379644870758057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046449145302176476, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046449145302176476, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13354426622390747, + 0.5135001540184021, + 0.07964623719453812, + 0.07179504632949829, + 0.05444701761007309, + 0.05794002115726471, + 0.014660526998341084, + 0.026223232969641685, + 0.017247769981622696, + 0.030995765700936317 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046449145302176476 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a tiny, iridescent black beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the beetle perched on a dark gray plastic dashboard with raised veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does intense direct sunlight create harsh bright spots and sharp elongated micro-shadows on the beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a bright, overexposed landscape of a sun-bleached road and passing trees that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the beetle exhibit frantic wriggling legs and antennae twitching while sliding across the vibrating surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06203170493245125 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120317459106445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06203170493245125, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06203170493245125, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08880031108856201, + 0.10056967288255692, + 0.11335515975952148, + 0.07032997906208038, + 0.057783327996730804, + 0.17679083347320557, + 0.068998321890831, + 0.16304989159107208, + 0.0919257178902626, + 0.06839676946401596 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06203170493245125 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, still photograph taken from a slightly elevated angle captures a tiny, iridescent black beetle perched on the richly textured, dark gray plastic dashboard of a moving car. Intense, direct sunlight filtering through the windshield casts harsh, bright spots on the beetle's smooth carapace and creates sharp, elongated micro-shadows beneath its body. The entire surface vibrates with the vehicle's subtle, high-frequency vibrations, causing the beetle to desperately search for its place. Its six spindly legs frantically wriggle, sliding across the smooth, sun-warmed plastic, its antennae twitching nervously. It periodically grasps the raised veins of the dashboard's texture, only to be jolted again by the constant movement, sliding a few millimeters with each jolt. In the background, a bright, overexposed landscape of sun-bleached road and passing trees, completely blurred through the out-of-focus windshield, emphasizes the car's speed and creates a tense, slightly dramatic atmosphere focused entirely on this tiny creature's Herculean efforts to survive.", + "seed": 24431, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_2/index_5400_seed_24431_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07664272338151931, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07664272338151931, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07664272338151931, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a tiny, iridescent black beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the beetle perched on a dark gray plastic dashboard with raised veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does intense direct sunlight create harsh bright spots and sharp elongated micro-shadows on the beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a bright, overexposed landscape of a sun-bleached road and passing trees that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the beetle exhibit frantic wriggling legs and antennae twitching while sliding across the vibrating surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20524249970912933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7052425146102905 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20524249970912933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20524249970912933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.028397854417562485, + 0.024701818823814392, + 0.08824887871742249, + 0.08784475177526474, + 0.1632843315601349, + 0.33610600233078003, + 0.010424652136862278, + 0.07195568829774857, + 0.16013430058956146, + 0.02890167012810707 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20524249970912933 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a tiny, iridescent black beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the beetle perched on a dark gray plastic dashboard with raised veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does intense direct sunlight create harsh bright spots and sharp elongated micro-shadows on the beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a bright, overexposed landscape of a sun-bleached road and passing trees that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the beetle exhibit frantic wriggling legs and antennae twitching while sliding across the vibrating surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004237920045853 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695042371749878 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004237920045853, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004237920045853, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.021131137385964394, + 0.05999703332781792, + 0.12722913920879364, + 0.0857468992471695, + 0.03217841312289238, + 0.400717556476593, + 0.01088906079530716, + 0.05405539646744728, + 0.20223769545555115, + 0.005817701108753681 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004237920045853 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a tiny, iridescent black beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the beetle perched on a dark gray plastic dashboard with raised veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does intense direct sunlight create harsh bright spots and sharp elongated micro-shadows on the beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a bright, overexposed landscape of a sun-bleached road and passing trees that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the beetle exhibit frantic wriggling legs and antennae twitching while sliding across the vibrating surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016078339889645576 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141078472137451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016078339889645576, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016078339889645576, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.021822931244969368, + 0.01949356682598591, + 0.018434712663292885, + 0.05697406455874443, + 0.009309994988143444, + 0.7485052347183228, + 0.004223767668008804, + 0.060070253908634186, + 0.03643355891108513, + 0.024731861427426338 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016078339889645576 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a tiny, iridescent black beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the beetle perched on a dark gray plastic dashboard with raised veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does intense direct sunlight create harsh bright spots and sharp elongated micro-shadows on the beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a bright, overexposed landscape of a sun-bleached road and passing trees that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the beetle exhibit frantic wriggling legs and antennae twitching while sliding across the vibrating surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028228219598531723 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778228759765625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028228219598531723, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028228219598531723, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.047921374440193176, + 0.023856086656451225, + 0.03523930162191391, + 0.049508463591337204, + 0.024361027404665947, + 0.7264782786369324, + 0.006127397064119577, + 0.022940224036574364, + 0.03383621200919151, + 0.02973160520195961 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028228219598531723 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a tiny, iridescent black beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the beetle perched on a dark gray plastic dashboard with raised veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does intense direct sunlight create harsh bright spots and sharp elongated micro-shadows on the beetle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a bright, overexposed landscape of a sun-bleached road and passing trees that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the beetle exhibit frantic wriggling legs and antennae twitching while sliding across the vibrating surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08902757614850998 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640276432037354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08902757614850998, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08902757614850998, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08717864751815796, + 0.04520638287067413, + 0.026835521683096886, + 0.2030452936887741, + 0.060738980770111084, + 0.28835102915763855, + 0.014989147894084454, + 0.11224021017551422, + 0.11245487630367279, + 0.048959918320178986 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08902757614850998 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_3/index_tensor([6737, 6737])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_3/index_tensor([6737, 6737])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e7bd973ff12f72523287e1181c338dff880b70e3 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_3/index_tensor([6737, 6737])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "Immersive, frontal underwater filming captures the scene as the camera pans backward at a slow, steady pace, maintaining a constant distance from the subject. The setting is the deep, silent depths of the ocean, a rich palette of deep sapphires and cobalt blues. From afar, above the shimmering, rippled surface, bright, sharply defined golden sunlight penetrates the abyss, creating ethereal pillars of light that illuminate countless tiny suspended particles, making light itself appear tangible. A toned, athletic female figure is perfectly centered in the frame, gracefully swimming directly toward the viewer. She wears a simple, dark navy one-piece swimsuit that contrasts sharply with her skin, which is intermittently speckled by passing sunlight. Her long, dark brown hair flows freely behind her, undulating with the current like dark ribbons. She moves with calm purpose, executing a slow, rhythmic breaststroke; her arms deliberately reach forward, then sweep back in a powerful, fluid motion, effortlessly propelling her through the water. With each gentle exhalation, she releases a small cloud of silver bubbles that absorb the light and shimmer as they rise. Her facial expression, calm and focused, her eyes fixed forward, creates an atmosphere of stunning, almost spiritual beauty, evoking a profound sense of tranquility and freedom in the vast, silent underwater world.", + "seed": 18478, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_3/index_6737_seed_18478_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.058224433287978175, + "vlm_logprob": -0.058224433287978175, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.058224433287978175, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in the deep ocean with a blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a toned, athletic female figure swimming directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swimmer wear a dark navy one-piece swimsuit and have long dark brown hair flowing behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning backward at a slow, steady pace while maintaining a constant distance from the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible pillars of golden sunlight penetrating the water and illuminating suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012409262359142303 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.512409210205078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012409262359142303, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012409262359142303, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09136233478784561, + 0.13834695518016815, + 0.1302490383386612, + 0.32968971133232117, + 0.0282591562718153, + 0.04836958274245262, + 0.035386741161346436, + 0.022417237982153893, + 0.1096741333603859, + 0.06624511629343033 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012409262359142303 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in the deep ocean with a blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a toned, athletic female figure swimming directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swimmer wear a dark navy one-piece swimsuit and have long dark brown hair flowing behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning backward at a slow, steady pace while maintaining a constant distance from the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible pillars of golden sunlight penetrating the water and illuminating suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0160838533192873 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141083717346191 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0160838533192873, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0160838533192873, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07041296362876892, + 0.15195906162261963, + 0.14632107317447662, + 0.04605671390891075, + 0.10040393471717834, + 0.06185198202729225, + 0.13673250377178192, + 0.07209937274456024, + 0.05719456076622009, + 0.15696778893470764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0160838533192873 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in the deep ocean with a blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a toned, athletic female figure swimming directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swimmer wear a dark navy one-piece swimsuit and have long dark brown hair flowing behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning backward at a slow, steady pace while maintaining a constant distance from the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible pillars of golden sunlight penetrating the water and illuminating suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898547500371933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789854526519775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898547500371933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898547500371933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06983113288879395, + 0.12696565687656403, + 0.10234944522380829, + 0.26403912901878357, + 0.07257416844367981, + 0.05207223445177078, + 0.04897342994809151, + 0.03350977972149849, + 0.08471627533435822, + 0.1449686586856842 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898547500371933 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in the deep ocean with a blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a toned, athletic female figure swimming directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swimmer wear a dark navy one-piece swimsuit and have long dark brown hair flowing behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning backward at a slow, steady pace while maintaining a constant distance from the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible pillars of golden sunlight penetrating the water and illuminating suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16035713255405426 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910357117652893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16035713255405426, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16035713255405426, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05143779516220093, + 0.16939325630664825, + 0.06953737884759903, + 0.302575945854187, + 0.042829640209674835, + 0.05445484444499016, + 0.1500108242034912, + 0.0548417791724205, + 0.01727546565234661, + 0.08764303475618362 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16035713255405426 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in the deep ocean with a blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a toned, athletic female figure swimming directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swimmer wear a dark navy one-piece swimsuit and have long dark brown hair flowing behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning backward at a slow, steady pace while maintaining a constant distance from the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible pillars of golden sunlight penetrating the water and illuminating suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023286443203687668 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732863426208496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023286443203687668, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023286443203687668, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.017699621617794037, + 0.11788982152938843, + 0.15967798233032227, + 0.5291799306869507, + 0.01445451658219099, + 0.09793559461832047, + 0.005582527723163366, + 0.022449849173426628, + 0.022242102771997452, + 0.012888006865978241 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023286443203687668 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Immersive, frontal underwater filming captures the scene as the camera pans backward at a slow, steady pace, maintaining a constant distance from the subject. The setting is the deep, silent depths of the ocean, a rich palette of deep sapphires and cobalt blues. From afar, above the shimmering, rippled surface, bright, sharply defined golden sunlight penetrates the abyss, creating ethereal pillars of light that illuminate countless tiny suspended particles, making light itself appear tangible. A toned, athletic female figure is perfectly centered in the frame, gracefully swimming directly toward the viewer. She wears a simple, dark navy one-piece swimsuit that contrasts sharply with her skin, which is intermittently speckled by passing sunlight. Her long, dark brown hair flows freely behind her, undulating with the current like dark ribbons. She moves with calm purpose, executing a slow, rhythmic breaststroke; her arms deliberately reach forward, then sweep back in a powerful, fluid motion, effortlessly propelling her through the water. With each gentle exhalation, she releases a small cloud of silver bubbles that absorb the light and shimmer as they rise. Her facial expression, calm and focused, her eyes fixed forward, creates an atmosphere of stunning, almost spiritual beauty, evoking a profound sense of tranquility and freedom in the vast, silent underwater world.", + "seed": 18479, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_3/index_6737_seed_18479_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0606866167858243, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0606866167858243, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0606866167858243, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in the deep ocean with a blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a toned, athletic female figure swimming directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swimmer wear a dark navy one-piece swimsuit and have long dark brown hair flowing behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning backward at a slow, steady pace while maintaining a constant distance from the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible pillars of golden sunlight penetrating the water and illuminating suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02805131860077381 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6530513763427734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02805131860077381, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02805131860077381, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.476290762424469, + 0.04224057495594025, + 0.1712428778409958, + 0.052167460322380066, + 0.04619418829679489, + 0.059396639466285706, + 0.04558205232024193, + 0.049130503088235855, + 0.04155035689473152, + 0.016204597428441048 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02805131860077381 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in the deep ocean with a blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a toned, athletic female figure swimming directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swimmer wear a dark navy one-piece swimsuit and have long dark brown hair flowing behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning backward at a slow, steady pace while maintaining a constant distance from the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible pillars of golden sunlight penetrating the water and illuminating suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014209521003067493 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264209747314453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014209521003067493, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014209521003067493, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3604884743690491, + 0.04932941868901253, + 0.06849415600299835, + 0.06222442537546158, + 0.1090146079659462, + 0.05321837216615677, + 0.04018671065568924, + 0.1377231776714325, + 0.07622062414884567, + 0.04310007020831108 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014209521003067493 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in the deep ocean with a blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a toned, athletic female figure swimming directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swimmer wear a dark navy one-piece swimsuit and have long dark brown hair flowing behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning backward at a slow, steady pace while maintaining a constant distance from the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible pillars of golden sunlight penetrating the water and illuminating suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495237931609154 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929952383041382 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495237931609154, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495237931609154, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4509378969669342, + 0.016526566818356514, + 0.045043352991342545, + 0.07286277413368225, + 0.05247870460152626, + 0.09333473443984985, + 0.01689968816936016, + 0.08063634485006332, + 0.08329997956752777, + 0.08797994256019592 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495237931609154 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in the deep ocean with a blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a toned, athletic female figure swimming directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swimmer wear a dark navy one-piece swimsuit and have long dark brown hair flowing behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning backward at a slow, steady pace while maintaining a constant distance from the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible pillars of golden sunlight penetrating the water and illuminating suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1798740178346634 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804874062538147 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1798740178346634, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1798740178346634, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.43265214562416077, + 0.0469401553273201, + 0.14449413120746613, + 0.04038216546177864, + 0.0412774421274662, + 0.0725363940000534, + 0.023569900542497635, + 0.10873319208621979, + 0.052414461970329285, + 0.037000011652708054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1798740178346634 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in the deep ocean with a blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a toned, athletic female figure swimming directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swimmer wear a dark navy one-piece swimsuit and have long dark brown hair flowing behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning backward at a slow, steady pace while maintaining a constant distance from the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible pillars of golden sunlight penetrating the water and illuminating suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634584717452526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651345729827881 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634584717452526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634584717452526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5493296980857849, + 0.1003008782863617, + 0.04387541487812996, + 0.026721589267253876, + 0.06075027585029602, + 0.0791533812880516, + 0.03735758364200592, + 0.04211871325969696, + 0.009541292674839497, + 0.05085118114948273 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634584717452526 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Immersive, frontal underwater filming captures the scene as the camera pans backward at a slow, steady pace, maintaining a constant distance from the subject. The setting is the deep, silent depths of the ocean, a rich palette of deep sapphires and cobalt blues. From afar, above the shimmering, rippled surface, bright, sharply defined golden sunlight penetrates the abyss, creating ethereal pillars of light that illuminate countless tiny suspended particles, making light itself appear tangible. A toned, athletic female figure is perfectly centered in the frame, gracefully swimming directly toward the viewer. She wears a simple, dark navy one-piece swimsuit that contrasts sharply with her skin, which is intermittently speckled by passing sunlight. Her long, dark brown hair flows freely behind her, undulating with the current like dark ribbons. She moves with calm purpose, executing a slow, rhythmic breaststroke; her arms deliberately reach forward, then sweep back in a powerful, fluid motion, effortlessly propelling her through the water. With each gentle exhalation, she releases a small cloud of silver bubbles that absorb the light and shimmer as they rise. Her facial expression, calm and focused, her eyes fixed forward, creates an atmosphere of stunning, almost spiritual beauty, evoking a profound sense of tranquility and freedom in the vast, silent underwater world.", + "seed": 18480, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_3/index_6737_seed_18480_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.09029070101678371, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09029070101678371, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09029070101678371, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in the deep ocean with a blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a toned, athletic female figure swimming directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swimmer wear a dark navy one-piece swimsuit and have long dark brown hair flowing behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning backward at a slow, steady pace while maintaining a constant distance from the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible pillars of golden sunlight penetrating the water and illuminating suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03112902119755745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5311291217803955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03112902119755745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03112902119755745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0952257513999939, + 0.0654776394367218, + 0.07491661608219147, + 0.11098024994134903, + 0.029252920299768448, + 0.22155126929283142, + 0.1324208378791809, + 0.05711420997977257, + 0.056381553411483765, + 0.1566789597272873 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03112902119755745 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in the deep ocean with a blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a toned, athletic female figure swimming directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swimmer wear a dark navy one-piece swimsuit and have long dark brown hair flowing behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning backward at a slow, steady pace while maintaining a constant distance from the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible pillars of golden sunlight penetrating the water and illuminating suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01820111833512783 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0182013511657715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01820111833512783, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01820111833512783, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10743097215890884, + 0.15678876638412476, + 0.13581185042858124, + 0.06767524033784866, + 0.0966557189822197, + 0.04656919091939926, + 0.17647291719913483, + 0.11483871191740036, + 0.0207042433321476, + 0.07705234736204147 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01820111833512783 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in the deep ocean with a blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a toned, athletic female figure swimming directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swimmer wear a dark navy one-piece swimsuit and have long dark brown hair flowing behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning backward at a slow, steady pace while maintaining a constant distance from the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible pillars of golden sunlight penetrating the water and illuminating suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370789811015129 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408707857131958 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370789811015129, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370789811015129, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07802673429250717, + 0.4208144545555115, + 0.09741096943616867, + 0.06888142228126526, + 0.03505263105034828, + 0.02261401154100895, + 0.21334180235862732, + 0.020251266658306122, + 0.015660084784030914, + 0.02794666215777397 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370789811015129 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in the deep ocean with a blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a toned, athletic female figure swimming directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swimmer wear a dark navy one-piece swimsuit and have long dark brown hair flowing behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning backward at a slow, steady pace while maintaining a constant distance from the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible pillars of golden sunlight penetrating the water and illuminating suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134540617465973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.313454031944275 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134540617465973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134540617465973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09296469390392303, + 0.05474046617746353, + 0.06060538440942764, + 0.06250131875276566, + 0.030407099053263664, + 0.03948989138007164, + 0.5121926069259644, + 0.043814584612846375, + 0.015958033502101898, + 0.08732593059539795 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134540617465973 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in the deep ocean with a blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a toned, athletic female figure swimming directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swimmer wear a dark navy one-piece swimsuit and have long dark brown hair flowing behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning backward at a slow, steady pace while maintaining a constant distance from the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible pillars of golden sunlight penetrating the water and illuminating suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496140569448471 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299614429473877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496140569448471, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496140569448471, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16395768523216248, + 0.07466603815555573, + 0.06859506666660309, + 0.1225210577249527, + 0.07945545017719269, + 0.04524507746100426, + 0.3098461627960205, + 0.03500587120652199, + 0.018683481961488724, + 0.08202414959669113 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496140569448471 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Immersive, frontal underwater filming captures the scene as the camera pans backward at a slow, steady pace, maintaining a constant distance from the subject. The setting is the deep, silent depths of the ocean, a rich palette of deep sapphires and cobalt blues. From afar, above the shimmering, rippled surface, bright, sharply defined golden sunlight penetrates the abyss, creating ethereal pillars of light that illuminate countless tiny suspended particles, making light itself appear tangible. A toned, athletic female figure is perfectly centered in the frame, gracefully swimming directly toward the viewer. She wears a simple, dark navy one-piece swimsuit that contrasts sharply with her skin, which is intermittently speckled by passing sunlight. Her long, dark brown hair flows freely behind her, undulating with the current like dark ribbons. She moves with calm purpose, executing a slow, rhythmic breaststroke; her arms deliberately reach forward, then sweep back in a powerful, fluid motion, effortlessly propelling her through the water. With each gentle exhalation, she releases a small cloud of silver bubbles that absorb the light and shimmer as they rise. Her facial expression, calm and focused, her eyes fixed forward, creates an atmosphere of stunning, almost spiritual beauty, evoking a profound sense of tranquility and freedom in the vast, silent underwater world.", + "seed": 18481, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_3/index_6737_seed_18481_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10020555611699819, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10020555611699819, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10020555611699819, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in the deep ocean with a blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a toned, athletic female figure swimming directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swimmer wear a dark navy one-piece swimsuit and have long dark brown hair flowing behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning backward at a slow, steady pace while maintaining a constant distance from the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible pillars of golden sunlight penetrating the water and illuminating suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.046613261103630066 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1716132164001465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.046613261103630066, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.046613261103630066, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09264607727527618, + 0.08456289023160934, + 0.05088610202074051, + 0.03705303743481636, + 0.06000513955950737, + 0.19574186205863953, + 0.05526250600814819, + 0.06305506080389023, + 0.29590412974357605, + 0.06488318741321564 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.046613261103630066 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in the deep ocean with a blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a toned, athletic female figure swimming directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swimmer wear a dark navy one-piece swimsuit and have long dark brown hair flowing behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning backward at a slow, steady pace while maintaining a constant distance from the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible pillars of golden sunlight penetrating the water and illuminating suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01609358936548233 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141093730926514 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01609358936548233, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01609358936548233, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10215607285499573, + 0.05518237501382828, + 0.023926466703414917, + 0.020246826112270355, + 0.026555044576525688, + 0.3771727979183197, + 0.04167075455188751, + 0.06546511501073837, + 0.06294083595275879, + 0.22468367218971252 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01609358936548233 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in the deep ocean with a blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a toned, athletic female figure swimming directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swimmer wear a dark navy one-piece swimsuit and have long dark brown hair flowing behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning backward at a slow, steady pace while maintaining a constant distance from the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible pillars of golden sunlight penetrating the water and illuminating suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14280086755752563 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017800807952881 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14280086755752563, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14280086755752563, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07378582656383514, + 0.05690060183405876, + 0.07823023945093155, + 0.06397728621959686, + 0.03894747793674469, + 0.36368802189826965, + 0.060984544456005096, + 0.05687734857201576, + 0.04369352012872696, + 0.16291514039039612 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14280086755752563 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in the deep ocean with a blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a toned, athletic female figure swimming directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swimmer wear a dark navy one-piece swimsuit and have long dark brown hair flowing behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning backward at a slow, steady pace while maintaining a constant distance from the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible pillars of golden sunlight penetrating the water and illuminating suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28131982684135437 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063198566436768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28131982684135437, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28131982684135437, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14041954278945923, + 0.061723679304122925, + 0.04330862686038017, + 0.047912225127220154, + 0.04707954823970795, + 0.1259215772151947, + 0.06895719468593597, + 0.12976370751857758, + 0.06599076837301254, + 0.2689231336116791 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28131982684135437 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater in the deep ocean with a blue color palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a toned, athletic female figure swimming directly toward the camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the swimmer wear a dark navy one-piece swimsuit and have long dark brown hair flowing behind her?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning backward at a slow, steady pace while maintaining a constant distance from the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible pillars of golden sunlight penetrating the water and illuminating suspended particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014200235716998577 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264200210571289 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014200235716998577, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014200235716998577, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.024864505976438522, + 0.0544920414686203, + 0.04885675758123398, + 0.086894191801548, + 0.06995721161365509, + 0.1877652257680893, + 0.0077979350462555885, + 0.011826306581497192, + 0.4818340837955475, + 0.02571173757314682 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014200235716998577 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_4/index_tensor([5388, 5388])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_4/index_tensor([5388, 5388])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..20e2a8efed0bd02f23054257874782ee869bf5de --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_4/index_tensor([5388, 5388])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot begins, following a dusty crimson off-road jeep as it slowly but steadily rolls across the vast, jagged crest of the ancient Great Wall. The massive off-road tires rumble over the weathered gray masonry, their bodywork reflecting a dull luster in the setting sun. Then, the camera slowly and smoothly zooms out, backward and upward, the jeep gradually shrinking in the frame, transforming from a powerful, concrete figure into a solitary, moving red dot. As the camera continues to retreat, the Great Wall's majestic fullness is revealed: like a giant stone dragon, it winds endlessly along the ridges of rolling green mountains, its towering beacon towers looming in the distance. Soft golden light gilds the entire scene with a warm and tranquil hue, casting long, gentle shadows across the valley, and mist quietly rising between the mountain cols. Ultimately, the entire picture presents a breathtaking sense of solemnity and loneliness that transcends time and space, highlighting the insignificance and tenacity of human creation in the face of the majestic nature.", + "seed": 6124, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_4/index_5388_seed_6124_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.020918401842936873, + "vlm_logprob": -0.020918401842936873, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.020918401842936873, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dusty crimson off-road jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jeep rolling across the jagged crest of the Great Wall made of weathered gray masonry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle tracking shot following the jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out, backward, and upward to reveal the Great Wall winding along green mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft golden light with mist rising between the mountain cols?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05640712007880211 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9314072132110596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05640712007880211, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05640712007880211, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2231641560792923, + 0.013361028395593166, + 0.0174222644418478, + 0.04877280443906784, + 0.028893187642097473, + 0.14541593194007874, + 0.04861719161272049, + 0.1060619056224823, + 0.309124618768692, + 0.05916694551706314 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05640712007880211 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dusty crimson off-road jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jeep rolling across the jagged crest of the Great Wall made of weathered gray masonry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle tracking shot following the jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out, backward, and upward to reveal the Great Wall winding along green mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft golden light with mist rising between the mountain cols?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012576202861964703 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387576103210449 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012576202861964703, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012576202861964703, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1079396978020668, + 0.06665416806936264, + 0.03280596435070038, + 0.22309701144695282, + 0.06891848146915436, + 0.0884041115641594, + 0.06381531059741974, + 0.046157460659742355, + 0.13830766081809998, + 0.1639002114534378 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012576202861964703 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dusty crimson off-road jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jeep rolling across the jagged crest of the Great Wall made of weathered gray masonry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle tracking shot following the jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out, backward, and upward to reveal the Great Wall winding along green mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft golden light with mist rising between the mountain cols?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026338066905736923 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513381004333496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026338066905736923, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026338066905736923, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13800586760044098, + 0.03886792063713074, + 0.017892220988869667, + 0.0547313392162323, + 0.04738260805606842, + 0.05491543561220169, + 0.05304056778550148, + 0.14655469357967377, + 0.37476369738578796, + 0.07384568452835083 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026338066905736923 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dusty crimson off-road jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jeep rolling across the jagged crest of the Great Wall made of weathered gray masonry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle tracking shot following the jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out, backward, and upward to reveal the Great Wall winding along green mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft golden light with mist rising between the mountain cols?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0006345880683511496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.375634670257568 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0006345880683511496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0006345880683511496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06499820947647095, + 0.02069052867591381, + 0.016310086473822594, + 0.04190206155180931, + 0.03871776536107063, + 0.04644453153014183, + 0.030691158026456833, + 0.08905580639839172, + 0.5683284997940063, + 0.08286140114068985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0006345880683511496 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dusty crimson off-road jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jeep rolling across the jagged crest of the Great Wall made of weathered gray masonry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle tracking shot following the jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out, backward, and upward to reveal the Great Wall winding along green mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft golden light with mist rising between the mountain cols?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008636031299829483 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758635997772217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008636031299829483, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008636031299829483, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06994127482175827, + 0.016299527138471603, + 0.015586026944220066, + 0.07781244069337845, + 0.05783583223819733, + 0.10635486245155334, + 0.02938353270292282, + 0.12631402909755707, + 0.37652531266212463, + 0.12394724041223526 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008636031299829483 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot begins, following a dusty crimson off-road jeep as it slowly but steadily rolls across the vast, jagged crest of the ancient Great Wall. The massive off-road tires rumble over the weathered gray masonry, their bodywork reflecting a dull luster in the setting sun. Then, the camera slowly and smoothly zooms out, backward and upward, the jeep gradually shrinking in the frame, transforming from a powerful, concrete figure into a solitary, moving red dot. As the camera continues to retreat, the Great Wall's majestic fullness is revealed: like a giant stone dragon, it winds endlessly along the ridges of rolling green mountains, its towering beacon towers looming in the distance. Soft golden light gilds the entire scene with a warm and tranquil hue, casting long, gentle shadows across the valley, and mist quietly rising between the mountain cols. Ultimately, the entire picture presents a breathtaking sense of solemnity and loneliness that transcends time and space, highlighting the insignificance and tenacity of human creation in the face of the majestic nature.", + "seed": 6125, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_4/index_5388_seed_6125_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.10433626305311919, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10433626305311919, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10433626305311919, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dusty crimson off-road jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jeep rolling across the jagged crest of the Great Wall made of weathered gray masonry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle tracking shot following the jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out, backward, and upward to reveal the Great Wall winding along green mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft golden light with mist rising between the mountain cols?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31876084208488464 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.318760871887207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31876084208488464, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31876084208488464, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.287294864654541, + 0.2820066809654236, + 0.029802661389112473, + 0.028946174308657646, + 0.052938591688871384, + 0.0431988425552845, + 0.07858811318874359, + 0.08561281859874725, + 0.04577810317277908, + 0.0658331960439682 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31876084208488464 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dusty crimson off-road jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jeep rolling across the jagged crest of the Great Wall made of weathered gray masonry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle tracking shot following the jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out, backward, and upward to reveal the Great Wall winding along green mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft golden light with mist rising between the mountain cols?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012580087408423424 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387579917907715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012580087408423424, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012580087408423424, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13088911771774292, + 0.09632984548807144, + 0.058465030044317245, + 0.03764323517680168, + 0.11043387651443481, + 0.11731034517288208, + 0.05571972206234932, + 0.1336486041545868, + 0.12114432454109192, + 0.1384158581495285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012580087408423424 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dusty crimson off-road jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jeep rolling across the jagged crest of the Great Wall made of weathered gray masonry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle tracking shot following the jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out, backward, and upward to reveal the Great Wall winding along green mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft golden light with mist rising between the mountain cols?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17984265089035034 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048427104949951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17984265089035034, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17984265089035034, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11585618555545807, + 0.24107833206653595, + 0.03496761992573738, + 0.05952468886971474, + 0.10338197648525238, + 0.1313416212797165, + 0.19035914540290833, + 0.01674610562622547, + 0.02480158396065235, + 0.08194272965192795 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17984265089035034 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dusty crimson off-road jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jeep rolling across the jagged crest of the Great Wall made of weathered gray masonry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle tracking shot following the jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out, backward, and upward to reveal the Great Wall winding along green mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft golden light with mist rising between the mountain cols?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0007182164117693901 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.250718116760254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0007182164117693901, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0007182164117693901, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10907988995313644, + 0.3525141477584839, + 0.037132371217012405, + 0.02786855958402157, + 0.06648453325033188, + 0.08192650228738785, + 0.13637475669384003, + 0.06458234041929245, + 0.04065798595547676, + 0.08337883651256561 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0007182164117693901 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dusty crimson off-road jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jeep rolling across the jagged crest of the Great Wall made of weathered gray masonry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle tracking shot following the jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out, backward, and upward to reveal the Great Wall winding along green mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft golden light with mist rising between the mountain cols?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009779518470168114 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634779453277588 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009779518470168114, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009779518470168114, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07219288498163223, + 0.5270476341247559, + 0.03137698024511337, + 0.02141687273979187, + 0.12229018658399582, + 0.029213935136795044, + 0.05493111163377762, + 0.04025585204362869, + 0.02775520831346512, + 0.07351932674646378 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009779518470168114 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot begins, following a dusty crimson off-road jeep as it slowly but steadily rolls across the vast, jagged crest of the ancient Great Wall. The massive off-road tires rumble over the weathered gray masonry, their bodywork reflecting a dull luster in the setting sun. Then, the camera slowly and smoothly zooms out, backward and upward, the jeep gradually shrinking in the frame, transforming from a powerful, concrete figure into a solitary, moving red dot. As the camera continues to retreat, the Great Wall's majestic fullness is revealed: like a giant stone dragon, it winds endlessly along the ridges of rolling green mountains, its towering beacon towers looming in the distance. Soft golden light gilds the entire scene with a warm and tranquil hue, casting long, gentle shadows across the valley, and mist quietly rising between the mountain cols. Ultimately, the entire picture presents a breathtaking sense of solemnity and loneliness that transcends time and space, highlighting the insignificance and tenacity of human creation in the face of the majestic nature.", + "seed": 6126, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_4/index_5388_seed_6126_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06243750189896673, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06243750189896673, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06243750189896673, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dusty crimson off-road jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jeep rolling across the jagged crest of the Great Wall made of weathered gray masonry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle tracking shot following the jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out, backward, and upward to reveal the Great Wall winding along green mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft golden light with mist rising between the mountain cols?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09110629558563232 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.466106414794922 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09110629558563232, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09110629558563232, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23067070543766022, + 0.09707806259393692, + 0.2265537679195404, + 0.028169257566332817, + 0.05861416459083557, + 0.13378024101257324, + 0.06661323457956314, + 0.06211377680301666, + 0.05101471766829491, + 0.04539208114147186 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09110629558563232 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dusty crimson off-road jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jeep rolling across the jagged crest of the Great Wall made of weathered gray masonry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle tracking shot following the jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out, backward, and upward to reveal the Great Wall winding along green mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft golden light with mist rising between the mountain cols?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012575025670230389 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387575149536133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012575025670230389, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012575025670230389, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18942175805568695, + 0.15653853118419647, + 0.09175950288772583, + 0.07468681037425995, + 0.05392337217926979, + 0.136188343167305, + 0.0338931567966938, + 0.05827505514025688, + 0.04869307950139046, + 0.15662036836147308 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012575025670230389 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dusty crimson off-road jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jeep rolling across the jagged crest of the Great Wall made of weathered gray masonry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle tracking shot following the jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out, backward, and upward to reveal the Great Wall winding along green mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft golden light with mist rising between the mountain cols?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20151673257350922 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015167474746704 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20151673257350922, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20151673257350922, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08787219226360321, + 0.0708112120628357, + 0.24014408886432648, + 0.05205618962645531, + 0.03510204702615738, + 0.37132635712623596, + 0.07349923253059387, + 0.031761012971401215, + 0.02505934052169323, + 0.012368381023406982 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20151673257350922 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dusty crimson off-road jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jeep rolling across the jagged crest of the Great Wall made of weathered gray masonry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle tracking shot following the jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out, backward, and upward to reveal the Great Wall winding along green mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft golden light with mist rising between the mountain cols?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010424185311421752 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876042366027832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010424185311421752, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010424185311421752, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1859063059091568, + 0.038965389132499695, + 0.11238507181406021, + 0.030294688418507576, + 0.02879820577800274, + 0.4234171211719513, + 0.04429326951503754, + 0.04636447876691818, + 0.0536850206553936, + 0.03589045628905296 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010424185311421752 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dusty crimson off-road jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jeep rolling across the jagged crest of the Great Wall made of weathered gray masonry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle tracking shot following the jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out, backward, and upward to reveal the Great Wall winding along green mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft golden light with mist rising between the mountain cols?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005947037134319544 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130947113037109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005947037134319544, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005947037134319544, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14807875454425812, + 0.036943964660167694, + 0.16918808221817017, + 0.0341026745736599, + 0.042059265077114105, + 0.42384493350982666, + 0.03258923441171646, + 0.03630596399307251, + 0.02562330663204193, + 0.051263824105262756 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005947037134319544 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot begins, following a dusty crimson off-road jeep as it slowly but steadily rolls across the vast, jagged crest of the ancient Great Wall. The massive off-road tires rumble over the weathered gray masonry, their bodywork reflecting a dull luster in the setting sun. Then, the camera slowly and smoothly zooms out, backward and upward, the jeep gradually shrinking in the frame, transforming from a powerful, concrete figure into a solitary, moving red dot. As the camera continues to retreat, the Great Wall's majestic fullness is revealed: like a giant stone dragon, it winds endlessly along the ridges of rolling green mountains, its towering beacon towers looming in the distance. Soft golden light gilds the entire scene with a warm and tranquil hue, casting long, gentle shadows across the valley, and mist quietly rising between the mountain cols. Ultimately, the entire picture presents a breathtaking sense of solemnity and loneliness that transcends time and space, highlighting the insignificance and tenacity of human creation in the face of the majestic nature.", + "seed": 6127, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_4/index_5388_seed_6127_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0560371246363502, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0560371246363502, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0560371246363502, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dusty crimson off-road jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jeep rolling across the jagged crest of the Great Wall made of weathered gray masonry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle tracking shot following the jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out, backward, and upward to reveal the Great Wall winding along green mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft golden light with mist rising between the mountain cols?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18234087526798248 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8073408603668213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18234087526798248, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18234087526798248, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10104571282863617, + 0.08421400934457779, + 0.021906791254878044, + 0.05131148546934128, + 0.265678733587265, + 0.10486642271280289, + 0.20268657803535461, + 0.1341712772846222, + 0.014447207562625408, + 0.019671855494379997 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18234087526798248 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dusty crimson off-road jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jeep rolling across the jagged crest of the Great Wall made of weathered gray masonry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle tracking shot following the jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out, backward, and upward to reveal the Great Wall winding along green mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft golden light with mist rising between the mountain cols?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009811627678573132 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6348114013671875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009811627678573132, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009811627678573132, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.048360683023929596, + 0.027203189209103584, + 0.018283618614077568, + 0.08002931624650955, + 0.2593371272087097, + 0.1551651656627655, + 0.3338104486465454, + 0.04262319579720497, + 0.006088238675147295, + 0.02909899689257145 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009811627678573132 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dusty crimson off-road jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jeep rolling across the jagged crest of the Great Wall made of weathered gray masonry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle tracking shot following the jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out, backward, and upward to reveal the Great Wall winding along green mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft golden light with mist rising between the mountain cols?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07895991951227188 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789599418640137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07895991951227188, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07895991951227188, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05517766997218132, + 0.02432270720601082, + 0.042538389563560486, + 0.09145744144916534, + 0.2505526542663574, + 0.16220109164714813, + 0.2815888822078705, + 0.045103177428245544, + 0.026352351531386375, + 0.02070562355220318 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07895991951227188 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dusty crimson off-road jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jeep rolling across the jagged crest of the Great Wall made of weathered gray masonry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle tracking shot following the jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out, backward, and upward to reveal the Great Wall winding along green mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft golden light with mist rising between the mountain cols?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0004377598816063255 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.7504377365112305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0004377598816063255, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0004377598816063255, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05028143897652626, + 0.03795298561453819, + 0.024570703506469727, + 0.07201019674539566, + 0.29069751501083374, + 0.16183574497699738, + 0.30707794427871704, + 0.021060699597001076, + 0.010759725235402584, + 0.023753000423312187 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0004377598816063255 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dusty crimson off-road jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the jeep rolling across the jagged crest of the Great Wall made of weathered gray masonry?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle tracking shot following the jeep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom out, backward, and upward to reveal the Great Wall winding along green mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft golden light with mist rising between the mountain cols?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008635440841317177 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758635520935059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008635440841317177, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008635440841317177, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06772501766681671, + 0.05681617185473442, + 0.036055486649274826, + 0.08566462248563766, + 0.06699243932962418, + 0.22164565324783325, + 0.3419218361377716, + 0.03689955174922943, + 0.04471249878406525, + 0.041566696017980576 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008635440841317177 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_5/index_tensor([6975, 6975])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_5/index_tensor([6975, 6975])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b04805c12373eab7e59c22eeb9be8291db87184c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_5/index_tensor([6975, 6975])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatically dynamic Snorri camera lens pinned a mysterious figure to the very center of the frame, creating a dizzying sensation of a stable subject amidst the world's turbulent motion. This figure, outlined in a form-fitting suit of dark armor gleaming with metallic and keratin, was enveloped in an ominous crimson glow of energy, like burning blood, a light that even stirred tiny arcs of electricity in the air around him. He tore through the air with thunderous force, slashing vertically from the sky. His body tensed under the immense acceleration of gravity, his grip on a massive blade composed of pure red light energy slicing a deadly arc through the air, poised to deliver a devastating blow. Around him, the world dissolved into a chaotic motion blur, gray clouds, sparse raindrops, and distant city lights stretched into countless vertical, rapidly streaking streaks of light and shadow, creating a stark visual contrast with the steady, incandescent glow of his body. This high-speed fall produces a strong cinematic light effect. The red halo creates glare and edge distortion on the lens, and the particles in the air are illuminated. The entire picture is filled with the destructive power of doomsday and a suffocating atmosphere of tension.", + "seed": 30329, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_5/index_6975_seed_30329_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.01798360354732722, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01798360354732722, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01798360354732722, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a mysterious figure wearing a form-fitting dark armor suit visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure enveloped in an ominous crimson glow with visible arcs of electricity in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a massive blade composed of pure red light energy and slashing vertically from the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a chaotic motion blur with gray clouds, sparse raindrops, and distant city lights stretched into vertical streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a stable subject while the world exhibits turbulent motion and vertical streaking effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07039076089859009 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6953907012939453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07039076089859009, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07039076089859009, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2661114037036896, + 0.0466855987906456, + 0.07538656145334244, + 0.33335310220718384, + 0.0424281470477581, + 0.11417557299137115, + 0.032288093119859695, + 0.03380098566412926, + 0.035354532301425934, + 0.020416008308529854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07039076089859009 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a mysterious figure wearing a form-fitting dark armor suit visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure enveloped in an ominous crimson glow with visible arcs of electricity in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a massive blade composed of pure red light energy and slashing vertically from the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a chaotic motion blur with gray clouds, sparse raindrops, and distant city lights stretched into vertical streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a stable subject while the world exhibits turbulent motion and vertical streaking effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011832863092422485 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.75118350982666 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011832863092422485, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011832863092422485, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7642918825149536, + 0.013721344992518425, + 0.01594027690589428, + 0.08388769626617432, + 0.02787228673696518, + 0.05277816951274872, + 0.009115968830883503, + 0.01225647609680891, + 0.011365985497832298, + 0.008769909851253033 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011832863092422485 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a mysterious figure wearing a form-fitting dark armor suit visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure enveloped in an ominous crimson glow with visible arcs of electricity in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a massive blade composed of pure red light energy and slashing vertically from the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a chaotic motion blur with gray clouds, sparse raindrops, and distant city lights stretched into vertical streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a stable subject while the world exhibits turbulent motion and vertical streaking effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005944785661995411 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130944728851318 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005944785661995411, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005944785661995411, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3700410723686218, + 0.03972930461168289, + 0.08673786371946335, + 0.13051415979862213, + 0.04927942156791687, + 0.12247107177972794, + 0.07549382746219635, + 0.06510733813047409, + 0.02179325558245182, + 0.038832712918519974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005944785661995411 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a mysterious figure wearing a form-fitting dark armor suit visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure enveloped in an ominous crimson glow with visible arcs of electricity in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a massive blade composed of pure red light energy and slashing vertically from the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a chaotic motion blur with gray clouds, sparse raindrops, and distant city lights stretched into vertical streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a stable subject while the world exhibits turbulent motion and vertical streaking effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013317534467205405 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626331806182861 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013317534467205405, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013317534467205405, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5941032767295837, + 0.02568499930202961, + 0.02498278208076954, + 0.09886855632066727, + 0.035065848380327225, + 0.06118718534708023, + 0.04517162963747978, + 0.0286746546626091, + 0.05820685625076294, + 0.02805420756340027 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013317534467205405 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a mysterious figure wearing a form-fitting dark armor suit visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure enveloped in an ominous crimson glow with visible arcs of electricity in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a massive blade composed of pure red light energy and slashing vertically from the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a chaotic motion blur with gray clouds, sparse raindrops, and distant city lights stretched into vertical streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a stable subject while the world exhibits turbulent motion and vertical streaking effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011067431420087814 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110673904418945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011067431420087814, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011067431420087814, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4517329931259155, + 0.08418679237365723, + 0.03884140029549599, + 0.13510282337665558, + 0.015553932636976242, + 0.04708011448383331, + 0.042307980358600616, + 0.0892949104309082, + 0.04020258039236069, + 0.055696554481983185 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011067431420087814 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatically dynamic Snorri camera lens pinned a mysterious figure to the very center of the frame, creating a dizzying sensation of a stable subject amidst the world's turbulent motion. This figure, outlined in a form-fitting suit of dark armor gleaming with metallic and keratin, was enveloped in an ominous crimson glow of energy, like burning blood, a light that even stirred tiny arcs of electricity in the air around him. He tore through the air with thunderous force, slashing vertically from the sky. His body tensed under the immense acceleration of gravity, his grip on a massive blade composed of pure red light energy slicing a deadly arc through the air, poised to deliver a devastating blow. Around him, the world dissolved into a chaotic motion blur, gray clouds, sparse raindrops, and distant city lights stretched into countless vertical, rapidly streaking streaks of light and shadow, creating a stark visual contrast with the steady, incandescent glow of his body. This high-speed fall produces a strong cinematic light effect. The red halo creates glare and edge distortion on the lens, and the particles in the air are illuminated. The entire picture is filled with the destructive power of doomsday and a suffocating atmosphere of tension.", + "seed": 30330, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_5/index_6975_seed_30330_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02030150555074215, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02030150555074215, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02030150555074215, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a mysterious figure wearing a form-fitting dark armor suit visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure enveloped in an ominous crimson glow with visible arcs of electricity in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a massive blade composed of pure red light energy and slashing vertically from the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a chaotic motion blur with gray clouds, sparse raindrops, and distant city lights stretched into vertical streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a stable subject while the world exhibits turbulent motion and vertical streaking effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07039798051118851 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6953980922698975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07039798051118851, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07039798051118851, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06694816797971725, + 0.12767741084098816, + 0.07145331799983978, + 0.23179565370082855, + 0.26617053151130676, + 0.07122260332107544, + 0.045441579073667526, + 0.06194206327199936, + 0.014842549338936806, + 0.04250610992312431 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07039798051118851 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a mysterious figure wearing a form-fitting dark armor suit visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure enveloped in an ominous crimson glow with visible arcs of electricity in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a massive blade composed of pure red light energy and slashing vertically from the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a chaotic motion blur with gray clouds, sparse raindrops, and distant city lights stretched into vertical streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a stable subject while the world exhibits turbulent motion and vertical streaking effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00282686366699636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877826690673828 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00282686366699636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00282686366699636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12318284064531326, + 0.06924288719892502, + 0.2540370225906372, + 0.10990029573440552, + 0.1715851128101349, + 0.04239450395107269, + 0.046999238431453705, + 0.06767124682664871, + 0.0719568207859993, + 0.043030064553022385 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00282686366699636 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a mysterious figure wearing a form-fitting dark armor suit visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure enveloped in an ominous crimson glow with visible arcs of electricity in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a massive blade composed of pure red light energy and slashing vertically from the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a chaotic motion blur with gray clouds, sparse raindrops, and distant city lights stretched into vertical streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a stable subject while the world exhibits turbulent motion and vertical streaking effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040937201119959354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504093647003174 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040937201119959354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040937201119959354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11931812018156052, + 0.07368636876344681, + 0.05267275869846344, + 0.2689460217952728, + 0.3023412525653839, + 0.0751737430691719, + 0.015604288317263126, + 0.04955758526921272, + 0.017573857679963112, + 0.025125985965132713 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040937201119959354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a mysterious figure wearing a form-fitting dark armor suit visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure enveloped in an ominous crimson glow with visible arcs of electricity in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a massive blade composed of pure red light energy and slashing vertically from the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a chaotic motion blur with gray clouds, sparse raindrops, and distant city lights stretched into vertical streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a stable subject while the world exhibits turbulent motion and vertical streaking effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036098097916692495 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628609657287598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036098097916692495, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036098097916692495, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12622717022895813, + 0.23431462049484253, + 0.20222726464271545, + 0.07721567898988724, + 0.10349240899085999, + 0.07902280986309052, + 0.0771348848938942, + 0.026407543569803238, + 0.029404213652014732, + 0.04455336555838585 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036098097916692495 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a mysterious figure wearing a form-fitting dark armor suit visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure enveloped in an ominous crimson glow with visible arcs of electricity in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a massive blade composed of pure red light energy and slashing vertically from the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a chaotic motion blur with gray clouds, sparse raindrops, and distant city lights stretched into vertical streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a stable subject while the world exhibits turbulent motion and vertical streaking effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020579153671860695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955790996551514 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020579153671860695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020579153671860695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21428360044956207, + 0.13621897995471954, + 0.04657277837395668, + 0.08959881216287613, + 0.14187268912792206, + 0.10225260257720947, + 0.08481482416391373, + 0.076134093105793, + 0.07416858524084091, + 0.03408306464552879 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020579153671860695 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatically dynamic Snorri camera lens pinned a mysterious figure to the very center of the frame, creating a dizzying sensation of a stable subject amidst the world's turbulent motion. This figure, outlined in a form-fitting suit of dark armor gleaming with metallic and keratin, was enveloped in an ominous crimson glow of energy, like burning blood, a light that even stirred tiny arcs of electricity in the air around him. He tore through the air with thunderous force, slashing vertically from the sky. His body tensed under the immense acceleration of gravity, his grip on a massive blade composed of pure red light energy slicing a deadly arc through the air, poised to deliver a devastating blow. Around him, the world dissolved into a chaotic motion blur, gray clouds, sparse raindrops, and distant city lights stretched into countless vertical, rapidly streaking streaks of light and shadow, creating a stark visual contrast with the steady, incandescent glow of his body. This high-speed fall produces a strong cinematic light effect. The red halo creates glare and edge distortion on the lens, and the particles in the air are illuminated. The entire picture is filled with the destructive power of doomsday and a suffocating atmosphere of tension.", + "seed": 30331, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_5/index_6975_seed_30331_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03783804595004767, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03783804595004767, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03783804595004767, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a mysterious figure wearing a form-fitting dark armor suit visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure enveloped in an ominous crimson glow with visible arcs of electricity in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a massive blade composed of pure red light energy and slashing vertically from the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a chaotic motion blur with gray clouds, sparse raindrops, and distant city lights stretched into vertical streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a stable subject while the world exhibits turbulent motion and vertical streaking effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16081075370311737 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9108107089996338 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16081075370311737, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16081075370311737, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13289523124694824, + 0.1122356578707695, + 0.1382898986339569, + 0.033459026366472244, + 0.1674509048461914, + 0.0640626922249794, + 0.0703795850276947, + 0.08626648783683777, + 0.14929552376270294, + 0.04566500708460808 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16081075370311737 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a mysterious figure wearing a form-fitting dark armor suit visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure enveloped in an ominous crimson glow with visible arcs of electricity in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a massive blade composed of pure red light energy and slashing vertically from the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a chaotic motion blur with gray clouds, sparse raindrops, and distant city lights stretched into vertical streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a stable subject while the world exhibits turbulent motion and vertical streaking effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019459851318970323 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251945972442627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019459851318970323, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019459851318970323, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11187154799699783, + 0.10874158143997192, + 0.11767314374446869, + 0.048766128718853, + 0.1048985943198204, + 0.040492381900548935, + 0.12316892296075821, + 0.12291940301656723, + 0.16629350185394287, + 0.05517483875155449 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019459851318970323 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a mysterious figure wearing a form-fitting dark armor suit visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure enveloped in an ominous crimson glow with visible arcs of electricity in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a massive blade composed of pure red light energy and slashing vertically from the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a chaotic motion blur with gray clouds, sparse raindrops, and distant city lights stretched into vertical streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a stable subject while the world exhibits turbulent motion and vertical streaking effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008634377270936966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758634567260742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008634377270936966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008634377270936966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21869449317455292, + 0.05799483507871628, + 0.12292420864105225, + 0.14000873267650604, + 0.1336192488670349, + 0.06896304339170456, + 0.04438198357820511, + 0.05155768245458603, + 0.09874403476715088, + 0.06311173737049103 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008634377270936966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a mysterious figure wearing a form-fitting dark armor suit visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure enveloped in an ominous crimson glow with visible arcs of electricity in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a massive blade composed of pure red light energy and slashing vertically from the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a chaotic motion blur with gray clouds, sparse raindrops, and distant city lights stretched into vertical streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a stable subject while the world exhibits turbulent motion and vertical streaking effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036095723044127226 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628609657287598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036095723044127226, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036095723044127226, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1752808541059494, + 0.09947048872709274, + 0.05402934551239014, + 0.11615736782550812, + 0.21259814500808716, + 0.11891987174749374, + 0.018010886386036873, + 0.06198958307504654, + 0.10827001184225082, + 0.03527340665459633 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036095723044127226 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a mysterious figure wearing a form-fitting dark armor suit visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure enveloped in an ominous crimson glow with visible arcs of electricity in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a massive blade composed of pure red light energy and slashing vertically from the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a chaotic motion blur with gray clouds, sparse raindrops, and distant city lights stretched into vertical streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a stable subject while the world exhibits turbulent motion and vertical streaking effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014189541339874268 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264189720153809 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014189541339874268, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014189541339874268, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09472262114286423, + 0.06254787743091583, + 0.12986822426319122, + 0.06538079679012299, + 0.17464514076709747, + 0.07385475933551788, + 0.05820256471633911, + 0.04052748531103134, + 0.23533159494400024, + 0.06491901725530624 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014189541339874268 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatically dynamic Snorri camera lens pinned a mysterious figure to the very center of the frame, creating a dizzying sensation of a stable subject amidst the world's turbulent motion. This figure, outlined in a form-fitting suit of dark armor gleaming with metallic and keratin, was enveloped in an ominous crimson glow of energy, like burning blood, a light that even stirred tiny arcs of electricity in the air around him. He tore through the air with thunderous force, slashing vertically from the sky. His body tensed under the immense acceleration of gravity, his grip on a massive blade composed of pure red light energy slicing a deadly arc through the air, poised to deliver a devastating blow. Around him, the world dissolved into a chaotic motion blur, gray clouds, sparse raindrops, and distant city lights stretched into countless vertical, rapidly streaking streaks of light and shadow, creating a stark visual contrast with the steady, incandescent glow of his body. This high-speed fall produces a strong cinematic light effect. The red halo creates glare and edge distortion on the lens, and the particles in the air are illuminated. The entire picture is filled with the destructive power of doomsday and a suffocating atmosphere of tension.", + "seed": 30332, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_5/index_6975_seed_30332_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.010879377694800496, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010879377694800496, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010879377694800496, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a mysterious figure wearing a form-fitting dark armor suit visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure enveloped in an ominous crimson glow with visible arcs of electricity in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a massive blade composed of pure red light energy and slashing vertically from the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a chaotic motion blur with gray clouds, sparse raindrops, and distant city lights stretched into vertical streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a stable subject while the world exhibits turbulent motion and vertical streaking effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03382176533341408 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4088218212127686 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03382176533341408, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03382176533341408, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05858205631375313, + 0.045301418751478195, + 0.03174889460206032, + 0.03931765258312225, + 0.08142466843128204, + 0.5229342579841614, + 0.11481285840272903, + 0.022925827652215958, + 0.03404650464653969, + 0.048905905336141586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03382176533341408 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a mysterious figure wearing a form-fitting dark armor suit visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure enveloped in an ominous crimson glow with visible arcs of electricity in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a massive blade composed of pure red light energy and slashing vertically from the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a chaotic motion blur with gray clouds, sparse raindrops, and distant city lights stretched into vertical streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a stable subject while the world exhibits turbulent motion and vertical streaking effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.000922969076782465 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.000923156738281 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.000922969076782465, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.000922969076782465, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08430401980876923, + 0.04437064751982689, + 0.046802058815956116, + 0.07038639485836029, + 0.1733660101890564, + 0.12173881381750107, + 0.20661292970180511, + 0.029947858303785324, + 0.1276138722896576, + 0.09485746175050735 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.000922969076782465 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a mysterious figure wearing a form-fitting dark armor suit visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure enveloped in an ominous crimson glow with visible arcs of electricity in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a massive blade composed of pure red light energy and slashing vertically from the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a chaotic motion blur with gray clouds, sparse raindrops, and distant city lights stretched into vertical streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a stable subject while the world exhibits turbulent motion and vertical streaking effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005944785661995411 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130944728851318 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005944785661995411, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005944785661995411, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20414412021636963, + 0.0514090396463871, + 0.033014748245477676, + 0.04486839845776558, + 0.09129805862903595, + 0.2000303566455841, + 0.035635143518447876, + 0.05234505981206894, + 0.19692346453666687, + 0.09033157676458359 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005944785661995411 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a mysterious figure wearing a form-fitting dark armor suit visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure enveloped in an ominous crimson glow with visible arcs of electricity in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a massive blade composed of pure red light energy and slashing vertically from the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a chaotic motion blur with gray clouds, sparse raindrops, and distant city lights stretched into vertical streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a stable subject while the world exhibits turbulent motion and vertical streaking effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011755467858165503 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751175403594971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011755467858165503, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011755467858165503, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08307264745235443, + 0.03469220921397209, + 0.025640692561864853, + 0.018441181629896164, + 0.03241242095828056, + 0.14965876936912537, + 0.03894965723156929, + 0.041148070245981216, + 0.4868309795856476, + 0.08915337175130844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011755467858165503 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a mysterious figure wearing a form-fitting dark armor suit visible in the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure enveloped in an ominous crimson glow with visible arcs of electricity in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a massive blade composed of pure red light energy and slashing vertically from the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background showing a chaotic motion blur with gray clouds, sparse raindrops, and distant city lights stretched into vertical streaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a stable subject while the world exhibits turbulent motion and vertical streaking effects?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012531821615993977 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387531757354736 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012531821615993977, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012531821615993977, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.46815016865730286, + 0.07123938202857971, + 0.029341334477066994, + 0.03578145429491997, + 0.031115615740418434, + 0.12934547662734985, + 0.04730919376015663, + 0.05401474982500076, + 0.07510438561439514, + 0.05859825015068054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012531821615993977 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_6/index_tensor([2376, 2376])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_6/index_tensor([2376, 2376])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9363247ec17af4b9fe0b8ece28e2b16fc325445a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_6/index_tensor([2376, 2376])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "high-angle macro shot, characterized by constant, subtle handheld shake, as if the camera were held by a trembling hand, focuses intensely on a classic, round, rainbow-swirled lollipop. The lollipop, with its vibrant, glossy swirls of cherry red, electric blue, and sunshine yellow, rests on a pristine, matte white surface under bright, clinical studio lighting. The action begins as the lollipop's crystal surface begins to sweat, forming tiny, shimmering beads of syrup that catch the overhead light. These beads quickly coalesce, and as the solid form dramatically liquefies, the disparate streams of color begin to chaotically interpenetrate. The lollipop collapses downward and outward, dissolving into a viscous, ever-expanding puddle. Once-separate colors now swirl together in a chaotic, hypnotic vortex, creating a miniature, turbulent galaxy of melted sugar. The relentless lens tremor, combined with the mesmerizing yet destructive shifts, creates a tense and slightly unsettling atmosphere, capturing the beautiful decay of a childhood icon.", + "seed": 23525, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_6/index_2376_seed_23525_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.26100721713155506, + "vlm_logprob": -0.26100721713155506, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.999999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.26100721713155506, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle macro view focusing on a classic round lollipop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop display vibrant glossy swirls of cherry red, electric blue, and sunshine yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lollipop resting on a pristine matte white surface under bright clinical studio lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop melt into a viscous puddle where the colors interpenetrate to form a chaotic vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a constant subtle handheld shake in the camera movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013563028536736965 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51356315612793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013563028536736965, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013563028536736965, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07443667948246002, + 0.10146744549274445, + 0.08153468370437622, + 0.205154150724411, + 0.11600537598133087, + 0.05769585445523262, + 0.09537888318300247, + 0.05556580796837807, + 0.05186527222394943, + 0.16089586913585663 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013563028536736965 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle macro view focusing on a classic round lollipop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop display vibrant glossy swirls of cherry red, electric blue, and sunshine yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lollipop resting on a pristine matte white surface under bright clinical studio lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop melt into a viscous puddle where the colors interpenetrate to form a chaotic vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a constant subtle handheld shake in the camera movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01820954494178295 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018209457397461 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01820954494178295, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01820954494178295, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09068836271762848, + 0.06009291484951973, + 0.08302966505289078, + 0.15556611120700836, + 0.12760692834854126, + 0.03919724002480507, + 0.15064693987369537, + 0.03503929451107979, + 0.08488445729017258, + 0.17324811220169067 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01820954494178295 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle macro view focusing on a classic round lollipop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop display vibrant glossy swirls of cherry red, electric blue, and sunshine yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lollipop resting on a pristine matte white surface under bright clinical studio lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop melt into a viscous puddle where the colors interpenetrate to form a chaotic vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a constant subtle handheld shake in the camera movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023296110332012177 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732961177825928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023296110332012177, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023296110332012177, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.051536038517951965, + 0.08605079352855682, + 0.17416521906852722, + 0.30567100644111633, + 0.02489704079926014, + 0.14007844030857086, + 0.012393218465149403, + 0.014558366499841213, + 0.021450892090797424, + 0.16919896006584167 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023296110332012177 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle macro view focusing on a classic round lollipop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop display vibrant glossy swirls of cherry red, electric blue, and sunshine yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lollipop resting on a pristine matte white surface under bright clinical studio lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop melt into a viscous puddle where the colors interpenetrate to form a chaotic vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a constant subtle handheld shake in the camera movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026352232322096825 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513521671295166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026352232322096825, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026352232322096825, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06938652694225311, + 0.07888932526111603, + 0.07595755159854889, + 0.11496347934007645, + 0.04964872822165489, + 0.08267276734113693, + 0.0631217211484909, + 0.06131068244576454, + 0.17941972613334656, + 0.2246294766664505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026352232322096825 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle macro view focusing on a classic round lollipop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop display vibrant glossy swirls of cherry red, electric blue, and sunshine yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lollipop resting on a pristine matte white surface under bright clinical studio lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop melt into a viscous puddle where the colors interpenetrate to form a chaotic vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a constant subtle handheld shake in the camera movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236151695251465 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486151099205017 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2236151695251465, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.8750000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2236151695251465, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21033795177936554, + 0.06367766857147217, + 0.08104601502418518, + 0.08344483375549316, + 0.08876045793294907, + 0.09849216043949127, + 0.06063995137810707, + 0.12173067778348923, + 0.0974748283624649, + 0.09439551830291748 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2236151695251465 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-angle macro shot, characterized by constant, subtle handheld shake, as if the camera were held by a trembling hand, focuses intensely on a classic, round, rainbow-swirled lollipop. The lollipop, with its vibrant, glossy swirls of cherry red, electric blue, and sunshine yellow, rests on a pristine, matte white surface under bright, clinical studio lighting. The action begins as the lollipop's crystal surface begins to sweat, forming tiny, shimmering beads of syrup that catch the overhead light. These beads quickly coalesce, and as the solid form dramatically liquefies, the disparate streams of color begin to chaotically interpenetrate. The lollipop collapses downward and outward, dissolving into a viscous, ever-expanding puddle. Once-separate colors now swirl together in a chaotic, hypnotic vortex, creating a miniature, turbulent galaxy of melted sugar. The relentless lens tremor, combined with the mesmerizing yet destructive shifts, creates a tense and slightly unsettling atmosphere, capturing the beautiful decay of a childhood icon.", + "seed": 23526, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_6/index_2376_seed_23526_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.40219299476593734, + "vlm_logprob": -0.40219299476593734, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.40219299476593734, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle macro view focusing on a classic round lollipop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop display vibrant glossy swirls of cherry red, electric blue, and sunshine yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lollipop resting on a pristine matte white surface under bright clinical studio lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop melt into a viscous puddle where the colors interpenetrate to form a chaotic vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a constant subtle handheld shake in the camera movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012272675521671772 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.637272834777832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012272675521671772, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012272675521671772, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06098131462931633, + 0.03362712264060974, + 0.030482659116387367, + 0.032566118985414505, + 0.32785022258758545, + 0.05314868688583374, + 0.2541200816631317, + 0.046494852751493454, + 0.10220474749803543, + 0.05852419510483742 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012272675521671772 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle macro view focusing on a classic round lollipop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop display vibrant glossy swirls of cherry red, electric blue, and sunshine yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lollipop resting on a pristine matte white surface under bright clinical studio lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop melt into a viscous puddle where the colors interpenetrate to form a chaotic vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a constant subtle handheld shake in the camera movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009806670248508453 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6348066329956055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009806670248508453, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009806670248508453, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05265865474939346, + 0.024158524349331856, + 0.04708081856369972, + 0.028806129470467567, + 0.5378322005271912, + 0.02788267470896244, + 0.1884748488664627, + 0.02990656904876232, + 0.04134514182806015, + 0.021854456514120102 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009806670248508453 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle macro view focusing on a classic round lollipop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop display vibrant glossy swirls of cherry red, electric blue, and sunshine yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lollipop resting on a pristine matte white surface under bright clinical studio lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop melt into a viscous puddle where the colors interpenetrate to form a chaotic vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a constant subtle handheld shake in the camera movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17992550134658813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049254417419434 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17992550134658813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17992550134658813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27402263879776, + 0.035481300204992294, + 0.02643595077097416, + 0.021000081673264503, + 0.1856692135334015, + 0.08386740833520889, + 0.15862369537353516, + 0.0551830492913723, + 0.10678505897521973, + 0.05293163284659386 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17992550134658813 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle macro view focusing on a classic round lollipop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop display vibrant glossy swirls of cherry red, electric blue, and sunshine yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lollipop resting on a pristine matte white surface under bright clinical studio lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop melt into a viscous puddle where the colors interpenetrate to form a chaotic vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a constant subtle handheld shake in the camera movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004100250080227852 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504100322723389 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004100250080227852, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004100250080227852, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1698516607284546, + 0.018961362540721893, + 0.03038453496992588, + 0.027645181864500046, + 0.13218748569488525, + 0.146479070186615, + 0.32204025983810425, + 0.037316009402275085, + 0.06863322854042053, + 0.046501170843839645 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004100250080227852 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle macro view focusing on a classic round lollipop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop display vibrant glossy swirls of cherry red, electric blue, and sunshine yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lollipop resting on a pristine matte white surface under bright clinical studio lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop melt into a viscous puddle where the colors interpenetrate to form a chaotic vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a constant subtle handheld shake in the camera movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048598766326904 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17985987663269043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.8048598766326904, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.8048598766326904, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10728652775287628, + 0.031065667048096657, + 0.020609576255083084, + 0.02319975569844246, + 0.4033787250518799, + 0.05866663530468941, + 0.1150999441742897, + 0.07569419592618942, + 0.06860662251710892, + 0.09639228880405426 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.8048598766326904 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-angle macro shot, characterized by constant, subtle handheld shake, as if the camera were held by a trembling hand, focuses intensely on a classic, round, rainbow-swirled lollipop. The lollipop, with its vibrant, glossy swirls of cherry red, electric blue, and sunshine yellow, rests on a pristine, matte white surface under bright, clinical studio lighting. The action begins as the lollipop's crystal surface begins to sweat, forming tiny, shimmering beads of syrup that catch the overhead light. These beads quickly coalesce, and as the solid form dramatically liquefies, the disparate streams of color begin to chaotically interpenetrate. The lollipop collapses downward and outward, dissolving into a viscous, ever-expanding puddle. Once-separate colors now swirl together in a chaotic, hypnotic vortex, creating a miniature, turbulent galaxy of melted sugar. The relentless lens tremor, combined with the mesmerizing yet destructive shifts, creates a tense and slightly unsettling atmosphere, capturing the beautiful decay of a childhood icon.", + "seed": 23527, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_6/index_2376_seed_23527_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.3186357539147139, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3186357539147139, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3186357539147139, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle macro view focusing on a classic round lollipop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop display vibrant glossy swirls of cherry red, electric blue, and sunshine yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lollipop resting on a pristine matte white surface under bright clinical studio lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop melt into a viscous puddle where the colors interpenetrate to form a chaotic vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a constant subtle handheld shake in the camera movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019260410219430923 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.144260406494141 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019260410219430923, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019260410219430923, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06859013438224792, + 0.093357615172863, + 0.03662761300802231, + 0.027467109262943268, + 0.038751889020204544, + 0.06089388579130173, + 0.10561049729585648, + 0.1757054328918457, + 0.2685805559158325, + 0.12441534548997879 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019260410219430923 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle macro view focusing on a classic round lollipop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop display vibrant glossy swirls of cherry red, electric blue, and sunshine yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lollipop resting on a pristine matte white surface under bright clinical studio lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop melt into a viscous puddle where the colors interpenetrate to form a chaotic vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a constant subtle handheld shake in the camera movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008665813133120537 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758666038513184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008665813133120537, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008665813133120537, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0853254646062851, + 0.14166536927223206, + 0.08193402737379074, + 0.06976576894521713, + 0.03413320332765579, + 0.09146474301815033, + 0.043661996722221375, + 0.21679078042507172, + 0.09797989577054977, + 0.1372787356376648 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008665813133120537 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle macro view focusing on a classic round lollipop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop display vibrant glossy swirls of cherry red, electric blue, and sunshine yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lollipop resting on a pristine matte white surface under bright clinical studio lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop melt into a viscous puddle where the colors interpenetrate to form a chaotic vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a constant subtle handheld shake in the camera movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14285966753959656 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017859697341919 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14285966753959656, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14285966753959656, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08540832251310349, + 0.12091384083032608, + 0.04313281178474426, + 0.01960560865700245, + 0.026640545576810837, + 0.03841700777411461, + 0.22315454483032227, + 0.22278393805027008, + 0.07888512313365936, + 0.14105820655822754 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14285966753959656 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle macro view focusing on a classic round lollipop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop display vibrant glossy swirls of cherry red, electric blue, and sunshine yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lollipop resting on a pristine matte white surface under bright clinical studio lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop melt into a viscous puddle where the colors interpenetrate to form a chaotic vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a constant subtle handheld shake in the camera movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016082797199487686 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141082763671875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016082797199487686, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016082797199487686, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06980739533901215, + 0.07384415715932846, + 0.07571492344141006, + 0.032942816615104675, + 0.02040701173245907, + 0.04112528637051582, + 0.04771638661623001, + 0.26804590225219727, + 0.09321876615285873, + 0.2771773338317871 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016082797199487686 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle macro view focusing on a classic round lollipop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop display vibrant glossy swirls of cherry red, electric blue, and sunshine yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lollipop resting on a pristine matte white surface under bright clinical studio lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop melt into a viscous puddle where the colors interpenetrate to form a chaotic vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a constant subtle handheld shake in the camera movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063100814819336 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.281310111284256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.4063100814819336, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -1.4063100814819336, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06873529404401779, + 0.05768434330821037, + 0.04612812027335167, + 0.043495215475559235, + 0.03851720690727234, + 0.06674803048372269, + 0.030409544706344604, + 0.44863027334213257, + 0.07932108640670776, + 0.12033093720674515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.4063100814819336 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-angle macro shot, characterized by constant, subtle handheld shake, as if the camera were held by a trembling hand, focuses intensely on a classic, round, rainbow-swirled lollipop. The lollipop, with its vibrant, glossy swirls of cherry red, electric blue, and sunshine yellow, rests on a pristine, matte white surface under bright, clinical studio lighting. The action begins as the lollipop's crystal surface begins to sweat, forming tiny, shimmering beads of syrup that catch the overhead light. These beads quickly coalesce, and as the solid form dramatically liquefies, the disparate streams of color begin to chaotically interpenetrate. The lollipop collapses downward and outward, dissolving into a viscous, ever-expanding puddle. Once-separate colors now swirl together in a chaotic, hypnotic vortex, creating a miniature, turbulent galaxy of melted sugar. The relentless lens tremor, combined with the mesmerizing yet destructive shifts, creates a tense and slightly unsettling atmosphere, capturing the beautiful decay of a childhood icon.", + "seed": 23528, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_6/index_2376_seed_23528_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.4421830203384161, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4421830203384161, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4421830203384161, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle macro view focusing on a classic round lollipop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop display vibrant glossy swirls of cherry red, electric blue, and sunshine yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lollipop resting on a pristine matte white surface under bright clinical studio lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop melt into a viscous puddle where the colors interpenetrate to form a chaotic vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a constant subtle handheld shake in the camera movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06304268538951874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.813042640686035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06304268538951874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06304268538951874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1266603171825409, + 0.15927639603614807, + 0.038737669587135315, + 0.08276558667421341, + 0.06695125997066498, + 0.12216593325138092, + 0.12184754014015198, + 0.20428167283535004, + 0.04555124044418335, + 0.03176240995526314 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06304268538951874 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle macro view focusing on a classic round lollipop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop display vibrant glossy swirls of cherry red, electric blue, and sunshine yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lollipop resting on a pristine matte white surface under bright clinical studio lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop melt into a viscous puddle where the colors interpenetrate to form a chaotic vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a constant subtle handheld shake in the camera movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014215279370546341 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264215469360352 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014215279370546341, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014215279370546341, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14327700436115265, + 0.20807774364948273, + 0.07532145828008652, + 0.058637894690036774, + 0.04600870609283447, + 0.09475468844175339, + 0.09013915807008743, + 0.04448580741882324, + 0.14793340861797333, + 0.09136416763067245 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014215279370546341 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle macro view focusing on a classic round lollipop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop display vibrant glossy swirls of cherry red, electric blue, and sunshine yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lollipop resting on a pristine matte white surface under bright clinical studio lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop melt into a viscous puddle where the colors interpenetrate to form a chaotic vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a constant subtle handheld shake in the camera movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233336091041565 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983336091041565 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233336091041565, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233336091041565, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2805618643760681, + 0.07671285420656204, + 0.09469014406204224, + 0.05473116412758827, + 0.028543634340167046, + 0.050590451806783676, + 0.04913982003927231, + 0.1902228146791458, + 0.026027737185359, + 0.14877949655056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233336091041565 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle macro view focusing on a classic round lollipop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop display vibrant glossy swirls of cherry red, electric blue, and sunshine yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lollipop resting on a pristine matte white surface under bright clinical studio lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop melt into a viscous puddle where the colors interpenetrate to form a chaotic vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a constant subtle handheld shake in the camera movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009788254275918007 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347880363464355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009788254275918007, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009788254275918007, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.047124940901994705, + 0.1727791428565979, + 0.05479242280125618, + 0.10239645838737488, + 0.018384594470262527, + 0.06938061863183975, + 0.13485416769981384, + 0.2550046741962433, + 0.03104761429131031, + 0.11423540115356445 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009788254275918007 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a high-angle macro view focusing on a classic round lollipop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop display vibrant glossy swirls of cherry red, electric blue, and sunshine yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lollipop resting on a pristine matte white surface under bright clinical studio lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lollipop melt into a viscous puddle where the colors interpenetrate to form a chaotic vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a constant subtle handheld shake in the camera movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600535273551941 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22553527355194092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.600535273551941, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.600535273551941, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09686332195997238, + 0.2110510766506195, + 0.08462224900722504, + 0.07707259804010391, + 0.06725899875164032, + 0.09113873541355133, + 0.06667818874120712, + 0.17336821556091309, + 0.024937361478805542, + 0.10700935125350952 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.600535273551941 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_7/index_tensor([5132, 5132])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_7/index_tensor([5132, 5132])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fd30d806add2459e8f8380505fe95661d624f615 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_7/index_tensor([5132, 5132])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly overhead angle, the camera slowly and steadily tilts downward, focusing on a warm, light-grained wood tabletop. A slender, manicured hand elegantly grips a classic black lacquer fountain pen. The silver tip glides across the delicate, off-white hardcover journal page, the wrist steady and deliberate, leaving lines of elegant cursive handwriting. Next to the journal, a latte steams in a white ceramic cup, its frothed milk featuring an intricate latte art pattern. Wisps of delicate white steam rise, visible in the light. A ray of fresh morning light slants in from the window, casting a soft, elongated spot on the wooden table, giving the rising steam a textured quality. In the background, the rest of the cafe is softly blurred, with the faint silhouettes of other patrons and the warm interior lighting barely visible. The main colors of the whole picture are warm beige, white and wood color, creating a peaceful, focused and poetic atmosphere, perfectly capturing a leisurely and beautiful morning time.", + "seed": 6375, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_7/index_5132_seed_6375_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.026810559444129467, + "vlm_logprob": -0.026810559444129467, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.026810559444129467, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a slender, manicured hand gripping a classic black lacquer fountain pen visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a latte with intricate latte art steaming in a white ceramic cup next to the journal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred showing faint silhouettes of other patrons and warm interior lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006860984489321709 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.006861209869385 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006860984489321709, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006860984489321709, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1657114177942276, + 0.07025787234306335, + 0.028896335512399673, + 0.096047043800354, + 0.09717439115047455, + 0.09254664182662964, + 0.037095967680215836, + 0.05656767636537552, + 0.2830330431461334, + 0.07266955822706223 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006860984489321709 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a slender, manicured hand gripping a classic black lacquer fountain pen visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a latte with intricate latte art steaming in a white ceramic cup next to the journal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred showing faint silhouettes of other patrons and warm interior lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897831499576569 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789783000946045 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897831499576569, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897831499576569, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2198483794927597, + 0.05332295224070549, + 0.06404225528240204, + 0.05292382836341858, + 0.07998118549585342, + 0.0645575001835823, + 0.10967141389846802, + 0.09072413295507431, + 0.1270168572664261, + 0.13791149854660034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897831499576569 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a slender, manicured hand gripping a classic black lacquer fountain pen visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a latte with intricate latte art steaming in a white ceramic cup next to the journal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred showing faint silhouettes of other patrons and warm interior lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008646313101053238 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758646488189697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008646313101053238, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008646313101053238, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10381128638982773, + 0.08174560219049454, + 0.029317550361156464, + 0.037050679326057434, + 0.09333369880914688, + 0.3129114508628845, + 0.05024371296167374, + 0.03913864493370056, + 0.1985805183649063, + 0.05386685952544212 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008646313101053238 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a slender, manicured hand gripping a classic black lacquer fountain pen visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a latte with intricate latte art steaming in a white ceramic cup next to the journal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred showing faint silhouettes of other patrons and warm interior lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009778928942978382 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63477897644043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009778928942978382, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009778928942978382, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2277212142944336, + 0.172464519739151, + 0.08360946178436279, + 0.0629776120185852, + 0.033926744014024734, + 0.1087161973118782, + 0.10596238821744919, + 0.05186069756746292, + 0.08520341664552689, + 0.06755772978067398 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009778928942978382 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a slender, manicured hand gripping a classic black lacquer fountain pen visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a latte with intricate latte art steaming in a white ceramic cup next to the journal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred showing faint silhouettes of other patrons and warm interior lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02978825569152832 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297882556915283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02978825569152832, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02978825569152832, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14681529998779297, + 0.07674524933099747, + 0.011649851687252522, + 0.022668050602078438, + 0.623367428779602, + 0.03693060949444771, + 0.0077858190052211285, + 0.012775647453963757, + 0.02576618455350399, + 0.03549586609005928 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02978825569152832 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly overhead angle, the camera slowly and steadily tilts downward, focusing on a warm, light-grained wood tabletop. A slender, manicured hand elegantly grips a classic black lacquer fountain pen. The silver tip glides across the delicate, off-white hardcover journal page, the wrist steady and deliberate, leaving lines of elegant cursive handwriting. Next to the journal, a latte steams in a white ceramic cup, its frothed milk featuring an intricate latte art pattern. Wisps of delicate white steam rise, visible in the light. A ray of fresh morning light slants in from the window, casting a soft, elongated spot on the wooden table, giving the rising steam a textured quality. In the background, the rest of the cafe is softly blurred, with the faint silhouettes of other patrons and the warm interior lighting barely visible. The main colors of the whole picture are warm beige, white and wood color, creating a peaceful, focused and poetic atmosphere, perfectly capturing a leisurely and beautiful morning time.", + "seed": 6376, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_7/index_5132_seed_6376_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.025824940763413906, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025824940763413906, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025824940763413906, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a slender, manicured hand gripping a classic black lacquer fountain pen visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a latte with intricate latte art steaming in a white ceramic cup next to the journal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred showing faint silhouettes of other patrons and warm interior lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010567422956228256 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.2605671882629395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010567422956228256, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010567422956228256, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07730234414339066, + 0.06518344581127167, + 0.14051036536693573, + 0.3141273856163025, + 0.08170152455568314, + 0.13742247223854065, + 0.04222450032830238, + 0.042179763317108154, + 0.04326295107603073, + 0.0560852512717247 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010567422956228256 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a slender, manicured hand gripping a classic black lacquer fountain pen visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a latte with intricate latte art steaming in a white ceramic cup next to the journal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred showing faint silhouettes of other patrons and warm interior lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204167380928993 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812041759490967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204167380928993, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204167380928993, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06656815856695175, + 0.037700410932302475, + 0.07063470035791397, + 0.5013284683227539, + 0.054762180894613266, + 0.06466344743967056, + 0.07892940193414688, + 0.02613399364054203, + 0.021914664655923843, + 0.07736454904079437 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204167380928993 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a slender, manicured hand gripping a classic black lacquer fountain pen visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a latte with intricate latte art steaming in a white ceramic cup next to the journal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred showing faint silhouettes of other patrons and warm interior lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008646313101053238 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758646488189697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008646313101053238, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008646313101053238, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16017411649227142, + 0.0353761687874794, + 0.06998325139284134, + 0.13846024870872498, + 0.12716151773929596, + 0.16172446310520172, + 0.0474456287920475, + 0.029932504519820213, + 0.15464158356189728, + 0.07510051876306534 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008646313101053238 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a slender, manicured hand gripping a classic black lacquer fountain pen visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a latte with intricate latte art steaming in a white ceramic cup next to the journal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred showing faint silhouettes of other patrons and warm interior lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038096267729997635 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880961894989014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038096267729997635, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038096267729997635, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13763552904129028, + 0.07474464178085327, + 0.06735994666814804, + 0.2180037498474121, + 0.05039186030626297, + 0.08229051530361176, + 0.04303942993283272, + 0.05530807375907898, + 0.1861390918493271, + 0.08508716523647308 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038096267729997635 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a slender, manicured hand gripping a classic black lacquer fountain pen visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a latte with intricate latte art steaming in a white ceramic cup next to the journal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred showing faint silhouettes of other patrons and warm interior lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00977302622050047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634773254394531 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00977302622050047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00977302622050047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04716724157333374, + 0.03757406398653984, + 0.11931219696998596, + 0.33678480982780457, + 0.16862621903419495, + 0.09896596521139145, + 0.05211859196424484, + 0.01077786274254322, + 0.09141425043344498, + 0.03725876659154892 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00977302622050047 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly overhead angle, the camera slowly and steadily tilts downward, focusing on a warm, light-grained wood tabletop. A slender, manicured hand elegantly grips a classic black lacquer fountain pen. The silver tip glides across the delicate, off-white hardcover journal page, the wrist steady and deliberate, leaving lines of elegant cursive handwriting. Next to the journal, a latte steams in a white ceramic cup, its frothed milk featuring an intricate latte art pattern. Wisps of delicate white steam rise, visible in the light. A ray of fresh morning light slants in from the window, casting a soft, elongated spot on the wooden table, giving the rising steam a textured quality. In the background, the rest of the cafe is softly blurred, with the faint silhouettes of other patrons and the warm interior lighting barely visible. The main colors of the whole picture are warm beige, white and wood color, creating a peaceful, focused and poetic atmosphere, perfectly capturing a leisurely and beautiful morning time.", + "seed": 6377, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_7/index_5132_seed_6377_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.015146632818505168, + "vlm_logprob": -0.015146632818505168, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.015146632818505168, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a slender, manicured hand gripping a classic black lacquer fountain pen visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a latte with intricate latte art steaming in a white ceramic cup next to the journal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred showing faint silhouettes of other patrons and warm interior lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008065866306424141 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.633065700531006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008065866306424141, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008065866306424141, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16247013211250305, + 0.2857718765735626, + 0.04362524673342705, + 0.05011667683720589, + 0.06623191386461258, + 0.04382166638970375, + 0.0476437546312809, + 0.11757739633321762, + 0.07488105446100235, + 0.10786029696464539 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008065866306424141 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a slender, manicured hand gripping a classic black lacquer fountain pen visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a latte with intricate latte art steaming in a white ceramic cup next to the journal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred showing faint silhouettes of other patrons and warm interior lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048663295805454254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048663377761841 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048663295805454254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048663295805454254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09402444213628769, + 0.05819498002529144, + 0.020348187536001205, + 0.040339644998311996, + 0.024106144905090332, + 0.06835966557264328, + 0.07861413806676865, + 0.5310909152030945, + 0.06882517784833908, + 0.01609664224088192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048663295805454254 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a slender, manicured hand gripping a classic black lacquer fountain pen visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a latte with intricate latte art steaming in a white ceramic cup next to the journal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred showing faint silhouettes of other patrons and warm interior lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024942022282630205 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.0024943351745605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024942022282630205, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024942022282630205, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13166628777980804, + 0.09666528552770615, + 0.03827837482094765, + 0.04447729513049126, + 0.017332103103399277, + 0.1251283437013626, + 0.08894823491573334, + 0.3251939117908478, + 0.08488494157791138, + 0.04742515832185745 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024942022282630205 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a slender, manicured hand gripping a classic black lacquer fountain pen visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a latte with intricate latte art steaming in a white ceramic cup next to the journal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred showing faint silhouettes of other patrons and warm interior lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006734176073223352 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006734371185303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006734176073223352, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006734176073223352, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2050395905971527, + 0.07609499990940094, + 0.035665713250637054, + 0.046895693987607956, + 0.08301036059856415, + 0.04012591764330864, + 0.07027864456176758, + 0.26932111382484436, + 0.06830905377864838, + 0.10525894910097122 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006734176073223352 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a slender, manicured hand gripping a classic black lacquer fountain pen visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a latte with intricate latte art steaming in a white ceramic cup next to the journal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred showing faint silhouettes of other patrons and warm interior lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009775623679161072 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634775638580322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009775623679161072, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009775623679161072, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25280898809432983, + 0.2008538395166397, + 0.04238726943731308, + 0.019932061433792114, + 0.0352574959397316, + 0.013593226671218872, + 0.038182757794857025, + 0.26924929022789, + 0.08215311914682388, + 0.04558192938566208 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009775623679161072 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly overhead angle, the camera slowly and steadily tilts downward, focusing on a warm, light-grained wood tabletop. A slender, manicured hand elegantly grips a classic black lacquer fountain pen. The silver tip glides across the delicate, off-white hardcover journal page, the wrist steady and deliberate, leaving lines of elegant cursive handwriting. Next to the journal, a latte steams in a white ceramic cup, its frothed milk featuring an intricate latte art pattern. Wisps of delicate white steam rise, visible in the light. A ray of fresh morning light slants in from the window, casting a soft, elongated spot on the wooden table, giving the rising steam a textured quality. In the background, the rest of the cafe is softly blurred, with the faint silhouettes of other patrons and the warm interior lighting barely visible. The main colors of the whole picture are warm beige, white and wood color, creating a peaceful, focused and poetic atmosphere, perfectly capturing a leisurely and beautiful morning time.", + "seed": 6378, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_7/index_5132_seed_6378_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04335676697082817, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04335676697082817, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04335676697082817, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a slender, manicured hand gripping a classic black lacquer fountain pen visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a latte with intricate latte art steaming in a white ceramic cup next to the journal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred showing faint silhouettes of other patrons and warm interior lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011369557119905949 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.011369705200195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011369557119905949, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011369557119905949, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20743517577648163, + 0.06927982717752457, + 0.07354482263326645, + 0.08011126518249512, + 0.07350880652666092, + 0.04400226101279259, + 0.0651661828160286, + 0.15547224879264832, + 0.17198793590068817, + 0.059491463005542755 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011369557119905949 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a slender, manicured hand gripping a classic black lacquer fountain pen visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a latte with intricate latte art steaming in a white ceramic cup next to the journal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred showing faint silhouettes of other patrons and warm interior lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12705372273921967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127053737640381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12705372273921967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12705372273921967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06382793188095093, + 0.10029078274965286, + 0.031769491732120514, + 0.061230260878801346, + 0.04009575769305229, + 0.08890170603990555, + 0.06175985559821129, + 0.14440132677555084, + 0.15499213337898254, + 0.25273069739341736 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12705372273921967 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a slender, manicured hand gripping a classic black lacquer fountain pen visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a latte with intricate latte art steaming in a white ceramic cup next to the journal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred showing faint silhouettes of other patrons and warm interior lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020592933520674706 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955929279327393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020592933520674706, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020592933520674706, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11060822010040283, + 0.25204408168792725, + 0.10236125439405441, + 0.0827019140124321, + 0.050512589514255524, + 0.060936588793992996, + 0.02906234934926033, + 0.05856728553771973, + 0.09781630337238312, + 0.1553894728422165 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020592933520674706 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a slender, manicured hand gripping a classic black lacquer fountain pen visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a latte with intricate latte art steaming in a white ceramic cup next to the journal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred showing faint silhouettes of other patrons and warm interior lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495181307196617 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299519062042236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495181307196617, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495181307196617, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.060260072350502014, + 0.053033746778964996, + 0.02254529856145382, + 0.0302827637642622, + 0.36893942952156067, + 0.04423678293824196, + 0.018614767119288445, + 0.1453494280576706, + 0.11458238214254379, + 0.14215542376041412 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495181307196617 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a slender, manicured hand gripping a classic black lacquer fountain pen visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a latte with intricate latte art steaming in a white ceramic cup next to the journal?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred showing faint silhouettes of other patrons and warm interior lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002815808402374387 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778157234191895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002815808402374387, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002815808402374387, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21412071585655212, + 0.15204092860221863, + 0.12256340682506561, + 0.09502997994422913, + 0.07822715491056442, + 0.06218250095844269, + 0.0275396928191185, + 0.015349425375461578, + 0.09387540817260742, + 0.1390707790851593 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002815808402374387 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_8/index_tensor([6819, 6819])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_8/index_tensor([6819, 6819])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4d55babb1beaa107a82bba728abf77b0e8427eec --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_8/index_tensor([6819, 6819])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle shot begins a slow, deliberate pan to the right, depicting the immense scale of a massive biomechanical tree against a surreal anime backdrop. The tree's trunk, a complex amalgam of gunmetal-gray metallic bark and interwoven fiber cables, dominates the frame, its surface etched with intricate patterns that emit a soft, internal cyan glow. At its base, vast, translucent root systems glow a vibrant emerald green, visibly channeling streams of light particles from the ground, creating a complex, mesmerizing representation of photosynthesis. As the camera glides, the background reveals a dense, neon-lit cityscape beneath a perpetual twilight, towering skyscrapers covered in holographic advertisements and flying vehicles leaving trails of light. Midway through the pan, a section of the trunk begins to bulge, its metal plates deforming before cracking and expanding outward with mechanical precision. From this newly formed hole, a thick, billowing cloud of golden, shimmering energy was forcefully expelled into the atmosphere, its countless glowing particles swirling and drifting upward, casting a warm, brilliant glow that momentarily overwhelmed the cool, electric tones of the surrounding metropolis, creating a breathtaking atmosphere of technological sublimity.", + "seed": 11933, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_8/index_6819_seed_11933_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05596931595355272, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05596931595355272, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7499999523162844, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05596931595355272, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive biomechanical tree with gunmetal-gray metallic bark and interwoven fiber cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the tree's roots glow a vibrant emerald green and emit streams of light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, neon-lit cityscape with holographic advertisements and flying vehicles under perpetual twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and perform a slow, deliberate pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a section of the trunk bulge, crack, and expel a thick cloud of golden, shimmering energy particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016463503241539 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141463279724121 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016463503241539, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016463503241539, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.052693601697683334, + 0.07018140703439713, + 0.02008962817490101, + 0.04556168243288994, + 0.049049630761146545, + 0.3845180869102478, + 0.19050396978855133, + 0.10920840501785278, + 0.0288863368332386, + 0.04930728301405907 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016463503241539 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive biomechanical tree with gunmetal-gray metallic bark and interwoven fiber cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the tree's roots glow a vibrant emerald green and emit streams of light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, neon-lit cityscape with holographic advertisements and flying vehicles under perpetual twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and perform a slow, deliberate pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a section of the trunk bulge, crack, and expel a thick cloud of golden, shimmering energy particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009791205637156963 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634791374206543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009791205637156963, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009791205637156963, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14312730729579926, + 0.08254241198301315, + 0.03805476427078247, + 0.03025813400745392, + 0.026110747829079628, + 0.14961081743240356, + 0.21730107069015503, + 0.16352839767932892, + 0.07712535560131073, + 0.07234100252389908 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009791205637156963 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive biomechanical tree with gunmetal-gray metallic bark and interwoven fiber cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the tree's roots glow a vibrant emerald green and emit streams of light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, neon-lit cityscape with holographic advertisements and flying vehicles under perpetual twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and perform a slow, deliberate pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a section of the trunk bulge, crack, and expel a thick cloud of golden, shimmering energy particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22562432289123535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006243228912354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22562432289123535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22562432289123535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05118155479431152, + 0.12741075456142426, + 0.011490733362734318, + 0.012331714853644371, + 0.04576285183429718, + 0.11158891022205353, + 0.38482967019081116, + 0.11924949288368225, + 0.06424765288829803, + 0.07190673798322678 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22562432289123535 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive biomechanical tree with gunmetal-gray metallic bark and interwoven fiber cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the tree's roots glow a vibrant emerald green and emit streams of light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, neon-lit cityscape with holographic advertisements and flying vehicles under perpetual twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and perform a slow, deliberate pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a section of the trunk bulge, crack, and expel a thick cloud of golden, shimmering energy particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018185313791036606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018185138702393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018185313791036606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018185313791036606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05392661690711975, + 0.04364258050918579, + 0.02862689644098282, + 0.029384233057498932, + 0.01659442111849785, + 0.2382538616657257, + 0.21796026825904846, + 0.3222005367279053, + 0.02975240722298622, + 0.019658192992210388 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018185313791036606 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive biomechanical tree with gunmetal-gray metallic bark and interwoven fiber cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the tree's roots glow a vibrant emerald green and emit streams of light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, neon-lit cityscape with holographic advertisements and flying vehicles under perpetual twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and perform a slow, deliberate pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a section of the trunk bulge, crack, and expel a thick cloud of golden, shimmering energy particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009782234206795692 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634782314300537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009782234206795692, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009782234206795692, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08646977692842484, + 0.06006735935807228, + 0.02390323393046856, + 0.02558879368007183, + 0.07220102101564407, + 0.18334278464317322, + 0.13199381530284882, + 0.313045471906662, + 0.02944241277873516, + 0.07394534349441528 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009782234206795692 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle shot begins a slow, deliberate pan to the right, depicting the immense scale of a massive biomechanical tree against a surreal anime backdrop. The tree's trunk, a complex amalgam of gunmetal-gray metallic bark and interwoven fiber cables, dominates the frame, its surface etched with intricate patterns that emit a soft, internal cyan glow. At its base, vast, translucent root systems glow a vibrant emerald green, visibly channeling streams of light particles from the ground, creating a complex, mesmerizing representation of photosynthesis. As the camera glides, the background reveals a dense, neon-lit cityscape beneath a perpetual twilight, towering skyscrapers covered in holographic advertisements and flying vehicles leaving trails of light. Midway through the pan, a section of the trunk begins to bulge, its metal plates deforming before cracking and expanding outward with mechanical precision. From this newly formed hole, a thick, billowing cloud of golden, shimmering energy was forcefully expelled into the atmosphere, its countless glowing particles swirling and drifting upward, casting a warm, brilliant glow that momentarily overwhelmed the cool, electric tones of the surrounding metropolis, creating a breathtaking atmosphere of technological sublimity.", + "seed": 11934, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_8/index_6819_seed_11934_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.026768918335437774, + "vlm_logprob": -0.026768918335437774, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.026768918335437774, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive biomechanical tree with gunmetal-gray metallic bark and interwoven fiber cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the tree's roots glow a vibrant emerald green and emit streams of light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, neon-lit cityscape with holographic advertisements and flying vehicles under perpetual twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and perform a slow, deliberate pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a section of the trunk bulge, crack, and expel a thick cloud of golden, shimmering energy particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05559533089399338 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9305953979492188 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05559533089399338, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05559533089399338, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23059943318367004, + 0.03633244335651398, + 0.3024302124977112, + 0.04598306119441986, + 0.05753375217318535, + 0.07899761199951172, + 0.03072153776884079, + 0.10435543209314346, + 0.06518316268920898, + 0.0478634238243103 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05559533089399338 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive biomechanical tree with gunmetal-gray metallic bark and interwoven fiber cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the tree's roots glow a vibrant emerald green and emit streams of light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, neon-lit cityscape with holographic advertisements and flying vehicles under perpetual twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and perform a slow, deliberate pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a section of the trunk bulge, crack, and expel a thick cloud of golden, shimmering energy particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016076814383268356 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141077041625977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016076814383268356, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016076814383268356, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16901682317256927, + 0.17503513395786285, + 0.203695148229599, + 0.1948816031217575, + 0.040592119097709656, + 0.047984395176172256, + 0.026305142790079117, + 0.03413361310958862, + 0.05733652040362358, + 0.05101947858929634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016076814383268356 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive biomechanical tree with gunmetal-gray metallic bark and interwoven fiber cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the tree's roots glow a vibrant emerald green and emit streams of light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, neon-lit cityscape with holographic advertisements and flying vehicles under perpetual twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and perform a slow, deliberate pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a section of the trunk bulge, crack, and expel a thick cloud of golden, shimmering energy particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818707026541233 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187046051025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818707026541233, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818707026541233, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2524556517601013, + 0.09356869012117386, + 0.16326959431171417, + 0.0865912064909935, + 0.030116064473986626, + 0.0636017918586731, + 0.02251986227929592, + 0.05510959029197693, + 0.1034541204571724, + 0.12931345403194427 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818707026541233 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive biomechanical tree with gunmetal-gray metallic bark and interwoven fiber cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the tree's roots glow a vibrant emerald green and emit streams of light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, neon-lit cityscape with holographic advertisements and flying vehicles under perpetual twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and perform a slow, deliberate pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a section of the trunk bulge, crack, and expel a thick cloud of golden, shimmering energy particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029792074114084244 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529792070388794 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029792074114084244, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029792074114084244, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14672550559043884, + 0.07317658513784409, + 0.3282369375228882, + 0.03959795460104942, + 0.043654896318912506, + 0.06867647916078568, + 0.09240403771400452, + 0.048915207386016846, + 0.08659876883029938, + 0.07201363891363144 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029792074114084244 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive biomechanical tree with gunmetal-gray metallic bark and interwoven fiber cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the tree's roots glow a vibrant emerald green and emit streams of light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, neon-lit cityscape with holographic advertisements and flying vehicles under perpetual twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and perform a slow, deliberate pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a section of the trunk bulge, crack, and expel a thick cloud of golden, shimmering energy particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014193302020430565 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264193534851074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014193302020430565, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014193302020430565, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11730566620826721, + 0.04386153817176819, + 0.17457197606563568, + 0.07253535836935043, + 0.04118020832538605, + 0.09190783649682999, + 0.1551336646080017, + 0.08262559771537781, + 0.10361974686384201, + 0.11725839972496033 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014193302020430565 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle shot begins a slow, deliberate pan to the right, depicting the immense scale of a massive biomechanical tree against a surreal anime backdrop. The tree's trunk, a complex amalgam of gunmetal-gray metallic bark and interwoven fiber cables, dominates the frame, its surface etched with intricate patterns that emit a soft, internal cyan glow. At its base, vast, translucent root systems glow a vibrant emerald green, visibly channeling streams of light particles from the ground, creating a complex, mesmerizing representation of photosynthesis. As the camera glides, the background reveals a dense, neon-lit cityscape beneath a perpetual twilight, towering skyscrapers covered in holographic advertisements and flying vehicles leaving trails of light. Midway through the pan, a section of the trunk begins to bulge, its metal plates deforming before cracking and expanding outward with mechanical precision. From this newly formed hole, a thick, billowing cloud of golden, shimmering energy was forcefully expelled into the atmosphere, its countless glowing particles swirling and drifting upward, casting a warm, brilliant glow that momentarily overwhelmed the cool, electric tones of the surrounding metropolis, creating a breathtaking atmosphere of technological sublimity.", + "seed": 11935, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_8/index_6819_seed_11935_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.020432255417108535, + "vlm_logprob": -0.020432255417108535, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.020432255417108535, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive biomechanical tree with gunmetal-gray metallic bark and interwoven fiber cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the tree's roots glow a vibrant emerald green and emit streams of light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, neon-lit cityscape with holographic advertisements and flying vehicles under perpetual twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and perform a slow, deliberate pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a section of the trunk bulge, crack, and expel a thick cloud of golden, shimmering energy particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02384823188185692 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773848295211792 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02384823188185692, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02384823188185692, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19368767738342285, + 0.07017415761947632, + 0.0737486332654953, + 0.0399218425154686, + 0.13847830891609192, + 0.03383418172597885, + 0.025046421214938164, + 0.07540252059698105, + 0.32381588220596313, + 0.02589038573205471 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02384823188185692 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive biomechanical tree with gunmetal-gray metallic bark and interwoven fiber cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the tree's roots glow a vibrant emerald green and emit streams of light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, neon-lit cityscape with holographic advertisements and flying vehicles under perpetual twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and perform a slow, deliberate pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a section of the trunk bulge, crack, and expel a thick cloud of golden, shimmering energy particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004647880792617798 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379647731781006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004647880792617798, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004647880792617798, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.49593889713287354, + 0.045538801699876785, + 0.02632572315633297, + 0.02402031049132347, + 0.08606559038162231, + 0.016246842220425606, + 0.04023051634430885, + 0.02876141667366028, + 0.15746945142745972, + 0.07940249145030975 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004647880792617798 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive biomechanical tree with gunmetal-gray metallic bark and interwoven fiber cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the tree's roots glow a vibrant emerald green and emit streams of light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, neon-lit cityscape with holographic advertisements and flying vehicles under perpetual twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and perform a slow, deliberate pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a section of the trunk bulge, crack, and expel a thick cloud of golden, shimmering energy particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980329655110836 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298032760620117 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980329655110836, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980329655110836, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1258699893951416, + 0.057697877287864685, + 0.1083369329571724, + 0.09032236784696579, + 0.07321195304393768, + 0.03717287257313728, + 0.050424154847860336, + 0.039430588483810425, + 0.37663644552230835, + 0.040896862745285034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980329655110836 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive biomechanical tree with gunmetal-gray metallic bark and interwoven fiber cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the tree's roots glow a vibrant emerald green and emit streams of light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, neon-lit cityscape with holographic advertisements and flying vehicles under perpetual twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and perform a slow, deliberate pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a section of the trunk bulge, crack, and expel a thick cloud of golden, shimmering energy particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023283647373318672 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732837200164795 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023283647373318672, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023283647373318672, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1363285332918167, + 0.1248333528637886, + 0.05631138011813164, + 0.06307170540094376, + 0.3175217807292938, + 0.02783951535820961, + 0.065181665122509, + 0.03263511881232262, + 0.08276720345020294, + 0.09350977838039398 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023283647373318672 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive biomechanical tree with gunmetal-gray metallic bark and interwoven fiber cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the tree's roots glow a vibrant emerald green and emit streams of light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, neon-lit cityscape with holographic advertisements and flying vehicles under perpetual twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and perform a slow, deliberate pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a section of the trunk bulge, crack, and expel a thick cloud of golden, shimmering energy particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057822048664093 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895578145980835 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057822048664093, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057822048664093, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12488088011741638, + 0.020367026329040527, + 0.03787420690059662, + 0.01335723977535963, + 0.0470825657248497, + 0.0180300734937191, + 0.017517991364002228, + 0.05977001413702965, + 0.3578784167766571, + 0.3032415807247162 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057822048664093 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle shot begins a slow, deliberate pan to the right, depicting the immense scale of a massive biomechanical tree against a surreal anime backdrop. The tree's trunk, a complex amalgam of gunmetal-gray metallic bark and interwoven fiber cables, dominates the frame, its surface etched with intricate patterns that emit a soft, internal cyan glow. At its base, vast, translucent root systems glow a vibrant emerald green, visibly channeling streams of light particles from the ground, creating a complex, mesmerizing representation of photosynthesis. As the camera glides, the background reveals a dense, neon-lit cityscape beneath a perpetual twilight, towering skyscrapers covered in holographic advertisements and flying vehicles leaving trails of light. Midway through the pan, a section of the trunk begins to bulge, its metal plates deforming before cracking and expanding outward with mechanical precision. From this newly formed hole, a thick, billowing cloud of golden, shimmering energy was forcefully expelled into the atmosphere, its countless glowing particles swirling and drifting upward, casting a warm, brilliant glow that momentarily overwhelmed the cool, electric tones of the surrounding metropolis, creating a breathtaking atmosphere of technological sublimity.", + "seed": 11936, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_8/index_6819_seed_11936_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.022830387577414513, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022830387577414513, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022830387577414513, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive biomechanical tree with gunmetal-gray metallic bark and interwoven fiber cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the tree's roots glow a vibrant emerald green and emit streams of light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, neon-lit cityscape with holographic advertisements and flying vehicles under perpetual twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and perform a slow, deliberate pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a section of the trunk bulge, crack, and expel a thick cloud of golden, shimmering energy particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026737408712506294 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6517374515533447 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026737408712506294, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026737408712506294, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21799159049987793, + 0.09960363805294037, + 0.10207375884056091, + 0.0819520354270935, + 0.10045956075191498, + 0.11062353104352951, + 0.038117654621601105, + 0.14188595116138458, + 0.034930258989334106, + 0.0723620131611824 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026737408712506294 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive biomechanical tree with gunmetal-gray metallic bark and interwoven fiber cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the tree's roots glow a vibrant emerald green and emit streams of light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, neon-lit cityscape with holographic advertisements and flying vehicles under perpetual twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and perform a slow, deliberate pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a section of the trunk bulge, crack, and expel a thick cloud of golden, shimmering energy particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032001733779907227 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753200054168701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032001733779907227, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032001733779907227, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15960125625133514, + 0.25671541690826416, + 0.04838630184531212, + 0.11500786244869232, + 0.0676545724272728, + 0.0289421658962965, + 0.025989636778831482, + 0.049270149320364, + 0.037731099873781204, + 0.21070151031017303 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032001733779907227 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive biomechanical tree with gunmetal-gray metallic bark and interwoven fiber cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the tree's roots glow a vibrant emerald green and emit streams of light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, neon-lit cityscape with holographic advertisements and flying vehicles under perpetual twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and perform a slow, deliberate pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a section of the trunk bulge, crack, and expel a thick cloud of golden, shimmering energy particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043063171207904816 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168063163757324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043063171207904816, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043063171207904816, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21909864246845245, + 0.2252744883298874, + 0.11624351888895035, + 0.05971342325210571, + 0.15349270403385162, + 0.028048092499375343, + 0.01846052147448063, + 0.044781845062971115, + 0.03186393529176712, + 0.10302276164293289 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043063171207904816 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive biomechanical tree with gunmetal-gray metallic bark and interwoven fiber cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the tree's roots glow a vibrant emerald green and emit streams of light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, neon-lit cityscape with holographic advertisements and flying vehicles under perpetual twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and perform a slow, deliberate pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a section of the trunk bulge, crack, and expel a thick cloud of golden, shimmering energy particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057494968175888 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955750465393066 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057494968175888, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057494968175888, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17524045705795288, + 0.07265377044677734, + 0.16351594030857086, + 0.09469188004732132, + 0.07185100764036179, + 0.09836021065711975, + 0.05641448497772217, + 0.07113736867904663, + 0.06510895490646362, + 0.13102596998214722 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057494968175888 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive biomechanical tree with gunmetal-gray metallic bark and interwoven fiber cables?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the tree's roots glow a vibrant emerald green and emit streams of light particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, neon-lit cityscape with holographic advertisements and flying vehicles under perpetual twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and perform a slow, deliberate pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a section of the trunk bulge, crack, and expel a thick cloud of golden, shimmering energy particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057623490691185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895576238632202 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057623490691185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057623490691185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06674704700708389, + 0.03267746418714523, + 0.027615603059530258, + 0.02058480493724346, + 0.027710655704140663, + 0.06575675308704376, + 0.015191122889518738, + 0.07165257632732391, + 0.07040626555681229, + 0.6016577482223511 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057623490691185 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_9/index_tensor([2530, 2530])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_9/index_tensor([2530, 2530])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bdfd80fd02b8c5af6e700f4dc4162a38b1852f6f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_9/index_tensor([2530, 2530])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static medium shot, at eye level, captures the exuberant energy of Wadadou, a cheerful, anthropomorphic taiko drummer rendered in a vibrant pop art style defined by bold, flat colors and thick, decisive black outlines. His body is a perfect bright red cylinder, his face nestled against the surface of the drum, his large, expressive eyes closed in musical ecstasy, his mouth wide open as he belts out the song. He passionately grasps a classic silver microphone in one hand, gripping it tightly, his entire body seemingly vibrating with the power of his voice. The scene is set in a karaoke room, its backdrop a flat, electric yellow wall covered in a repeating pattern of large cyan dots. Multi-colored strobe lights rhythmically flicker and flash, casting rapidly changing patterns of fuchsia and green onto the character and the room, creating sharp, black-outlined shadows that dance and pulsate to the beat, amplifying the vibrant, joyful atmosphere of the throat performance.", + "seed": 30766, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_9/index_2530_seed_30766_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.015376370470039546, + "vlm_logprob": -0.015376370470039546, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.015376370470039546, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character an anthropomorphic taiko drummer with a bright red cylindrical body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a classic silver microphone in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a flat electric yellow wall covered in a repeating pattern of large cyan dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multi-colored strobe lights casting rapidly changing patterns of fuchsia and green onto the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style defined by bold flat colors and thick decisive black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008760590106248856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758760452270508 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008760590106248856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008760590106248856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13017188012599945, + 0.07029753923416138, + 0.055131323635578156, + 0.04680643603205681, + 0.026521526277065277, + 0.058063920587301254, + 0.09287302196025848, + 0.06061260774731636, + 0.05294712632894516, + 0.40657466650009155 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008760590106248856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character an anthropomorphic taiko drummer with a bright red cylindrical body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a classic silver microphone in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a flat electric yellow wall covered in a repeating pattern of large cyan dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multi-colored strobe lights casting rapidly changing patterns of fuchsia and green onto the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style defined by bold flat colors and thick decisive black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05494098365306854 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929940938949585 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05494098365306854, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05494098365306854, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22723102569580078, + 0.09694056957960129, + 0.06221786513924599, + 0.06586188077926636, + 0.021141687408089638, + 0.03258724510669708, + 0.08862019330263138, + 0.048616837710142136, + 0.036175113171339035, + 0.32060757279396057 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05494098365306854 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character an anthropomorphic taiko drummer with a bright red cylindrical body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a classic silver microphone in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a flat electric yellow wall covered in a repeating pattern of large cyan dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multi-colored strobe lights casting rapidly changing patterns of fuchsia and green onto the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style defined by bold flat colors and thick decisive black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024850459303706884 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002485275268555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024850459303706884, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024850459303706884, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11628619581460953, + 0.11508433520793915, + 0.07676581293344498, + 0.05608062446117401, + 0.03785936161875725, + 0.017163077369332314, + 0.043068379163742065, + 0.028499465435743332, + 0.032265715301036835, + 0.4769270420074463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024850459303706884 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character an anthropomorphic taiko drummer with a bright red cylindrical body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a classic silver microphone in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a flat electric yellow wall covered in a repeating pattern of large cyan dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multi-colored strobe lights casting rapidly changing patterns of fuchsia and green onto the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style defined by bold flat colors and thick decisive black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009778456762433052 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347784996032715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009778456762433052, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009778456762433052, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18220701813697815, + 0.047617584466934204, + 0.0235934779047966, + 0.03031279146671295, + 0.03205170854926109, + 0.022420676425099373, + 0.03466513752937317, + 0.053778473287820816, + 0.11053087562322617, + 0.46282222867012024 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009778456762433052 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character an anthropomorphic taiko drummer with a bright red cylindrical body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a classic silver microphone in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a flat electric yellow wall covered in a repeating pattern of large cyan dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multi-colored strobe lights casting rapidly changing patterns of fuchsia and green onto the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style defined by bold flat colors and thick decisive black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0009167758980765939 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.000916957855225 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0009167758980765939, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0009167758980765939, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14017726480960846, + 0.11406248807907104, + 0.04008196294307709, + 0.06412632018327713, + 0.0412902906537056, + 0.024111006408929825, + 0.0644981786608696, + 0.07327686995267868, + 0.0732746496796608, + 0.3651009202003479 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0009167758980765939 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static medium shot, at eye level, captures the exuberant energy of Wadadou, a cheerful, anthropomorphic taiko drummer rendered in a vibrant pop art style defined by bold, flat colors and thick, decisive black outlines. His body is a perfect bright red cylinder, his face nestled against the surface of the drum, his large, expressive eyes closed in musical ecstasy, his mouth wide open as he belts out the song. He passionately grasps a classic silver microphone in one hand, gripping it tightly, his entire body seemingly vibrating with the power of his voice. The scene is set in a karaoke room, its backdrop a flat, electric yellow wall covered in a repeating pattern of large cyan dots. Multi-colored strobe lights rhythmically flicker and flash, casting rapidly changing patterns of fuchsia and green onto the character and the room, creating sharp, black-outlined shadows that dance and pulsate to the beat, amplifying the vibrant, joyful atmosphere of the throat performance.", + "seed": 30767, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_9/index_2530_seed_30767_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.009037514321971685, + "vlm_logprob": -0.009037514321971685, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.009037514321971685, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character an anthropomorphic taiko drummer with a bright red cylindrical body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a classic silver microphone in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a flat electric yellow wall covered in a repeating pattern of large cyan dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multi-colored strobe lights casting rapidly changing patterns of fuchsia and green onto the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style defined by bold flat colors and thick decisive black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004398433957248926 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504398345947266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004398433957248926, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004398433957248926, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18119433522224426, + 0.07903464138507843, + 0.09857920557260513, + 0.06991340219974518, + 0.10216216742992401, + 0.05011415481567383, + 0.1124846339225769, + 0.05852075666189194, + 0.21139413118362427, + 0.03660256788134575 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004398433957248926 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character an anthropomorphic taiko drummer with a bright red cylindrical body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a classic silver microphone in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a flat electric yellow wall covered in a repeating pattern of large cyan dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multi-colored strobe lights casting rapidly changing patterns of fuchsia and green onto the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style defined by bold flat colors and thick decisive black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369268402457237 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086925983428955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369268402457237, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369268402457237, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24780547618865967, + 0.12475206702947617, + 0.030769342556595802, + 0.04762222617864609, + 0.07564783096313477, + 0.024790698662400246, + 0.39236927032470703, + 0.020075062289834023, + 0.02162342146039009, + 0.014544570818543434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369268402457237 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character an anthropomorphic taiko drummer with a bright red cylindrical body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a classic silver microphone in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a flat electric yellow wall covered in a repeating pattern of large cyan dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multi-colored strobe lights casting rapidly changing patterns of fuchsia and green onto the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style defined by bold flat colors and thick decisive black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031894787680357695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753189563751221 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031894787680357695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031894787680357695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05469242483377457, + 0.13109229505062103, + 0.06829521059989929, + 0.03078576922416687, + 0.05562864989042282, + 0.4393330514431, + 0.08276250213384628, + 0.03210315853357315, + 0.09353043884038925, + 0.01177649199962616 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031894787680357695 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character an anthropomorphic taiko drummer with a bright red cylindrical body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a classic silver microphone in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a flat electric yellow wall covered in a repeating pattern of large cyan dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multi-colored strobe lights casting rapidly changing patterns of fuchsia and green onto the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style defined by bold flat colors and thick decisive black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003191736526787281 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753191947937012 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003191736526787281, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003191736526787281, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15512657165527344, + 0.2488245964050293, + 0.06229877099394798, + 0.07453638315200806, + 0.038943614810705185, + 0.1509673297405243, + 0.12897688150405884, + 0.04168825224041939, + 0.07695520669221878, + 0.02168242260813713 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003191736526787281 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character an anthropomorphic taiko drummer with a bright red cylindrical body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a classic silver microphone in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a flat electric yellow wall covered in a repeating pattern of large cyan dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multi-colored strobe lights casting rapidly changing patterns of fuchsia and green onto the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style defined by bold flat colors and thick decisive black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0007152383332140744 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.250715255737305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0007152383332140744, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0007152383332140744, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12369128316640854, + 0.10325515270233154, + 0.09475348144769669, + 0.08265691995620728, + 0.15890471637248993, + 0.07746510207653046, + 0.059670086950063705, + 0.06078685447573662, + 0.21345065534114838, + 0.025365684181451797 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0007152383332140744 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static medium shot, at eye level, captures the exuberant energy of Wadadou, a cheerful, anthropomorphic taiko drummer rendered in a vibrant pop art style defined by bold, flat colors and thick, decisive black outlines. His body is a perfect bright red cylinder, his face nestled against the surface of the drum, his large, expressive eyes closed in musical ecstasy, his mouth wide open as he belts out the song. He passionately grasps a classic silver microphone in one hand, gripping it tightly, his entire body seemingly vibrating with the power of his voice. The scene is set in a karaoke room, its backdrop a flat, electric yellow wall covered in a repeating pattern of large cyan dots. Multi-colored strobe lights rhythmically flicker and flash, casting rapidly changing patterns of fuchsia and green onto the character and the room, creating sharp, black-outlined shadows that dance and pulsate to the beat, amplifying the vibrant, joyful atmosphere of the throat performance.", + "seed": 30768, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_9/index_2530_seed_30768_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.008868048503063618, + "vlm_logprob": -0.008868048503063618, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.008868048503063618, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character an anthropomorphic taiko drummer with a bright red cylindrical body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a classic silver microphone in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a flat electric yellow wall covered in a repeating pattern of large cyan dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multi-colored strobe lights casting rapidly changing patterns of fuchsia and green onto the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style defined by bold flat colors and thick decisive black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003915858455002308 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628915786743164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003915858455002308, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003915858455002308, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20960663259029388, + 0.12529590725898743, + 0.05088215693831444, + 0.04880475625395775, + 0.06240532919764519, + 0.06913106143474579, + 0.06894276291131973, + 0.14532588422298431, + 0.09086158871650696, + 0.1287439614534378 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003915858455002308 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character an anthropomorphic taiko drummer with a bright red cylindrical body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a classic silver microphone in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a flat electric yellow wall covered in a repeating pattern of large cyan dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multi-colored strobe lights casting rapidly changing patterns of fuchsia and green onto the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style defined by bold flat colors and thick decisive black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369245305657387 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086923599243164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369245305657387, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369245305657387, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14232292771339417, + 0.19761021435260773, + 0.17729006707668304, + 0.03486992046236992, + 0.06057947129011154, + 0.043916504830121994, + 0.06781310588121414, + 0.04481475427746773, + 0.12670235335826874, + 0.10408064723014832 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369245305657387 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character an anthropomorphic taiko drummer with a bright red cylindrical body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a classic silver microphone in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a flat electric yellow wall covered in a repeating pattern of large cyan dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multi-colored strobe lights casting rapidly changing patterns of fuchsia and green onto the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style defined by bold flat colors and thick decisive black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024857595562934875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002485752105713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024857595562934875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024857595562934875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1091805025935173, + 0.2295157015323639, + 0.08608876913785934, + 0.051871638745069504, + 0.06382691860198975, + 0.13874591886997223, + 0.18636584281921387, + 0.01621602103114128, + 0.07321491092443466, + 0.04497379809617996 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024857595562934875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character an anthropomorphic taiko drummer with a bright red cylindrical body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a classic silver microphone in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a flat electric yellow wall covered in a repeating pattern of large cyan dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multi-colored strobe lights casting rapidly changing patterns of fuchsia and green onto the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style defined by bold flat colors and thick decisive black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036143234465271235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.62861442565918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036143234465271235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036143234465271235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05834653601050377, + 0.09145081043243408, + 0.10746026039123535, + 0.026233874261379242, + 0.021777084097266197, + 0.2422257363796234, + 0.2766062617301941, + 0.013900910504162312, + 0.09607857465744019, + 0.06591997295618057 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036143234465271235 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character an anthropomorphic taiko drummer with a bright red cylindrical body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a classic silver microphone in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a flat electric yellow wall covered in a repeating pattern of large cyan dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multi-colored strobe lights casting rapidly changing patterns of fuchsia and green onto the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style defined by bold flat colors and thick decisive black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.000631848000921309 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.375631809234619 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.000631848000921309, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.000631848000921309, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0816417932510376, + 0.06875602900981903, + 0.04134341701865196, + 0.022609548643231392, + 0.025129619985818863, + 0.04697422683238983, + 0.2921898066997528, + 0.043954189866781235, + 0.0685504749417305, + 0.3088509142398834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.000631848000921309 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static medium shot, at eye level, captures the exuberant energy of Wadadou, a cheerful, anthropomorphic taiko drummer rendered in a vibrant pop art style defined by bold, flat colors and thick, decisive black outlines. His body is a perfect bright red cylinder, his face nestled against the surface of the drum, his large, expressive eyes closed in musical ecstasy, his mouth wide open as he belts out the song. He passionately grasps a classic silver microphone in one hand, gripping it tightly, his entire body seemingly vibrating with the power of his voice. The scene is set in a karaoke room, its backdrop a flat, electric yellow wall covered in a repeating pattern of large cyan dots. Multi-colored strobe lights rhythmically flicker and flash, casting rapidly changing patterns of fuchsia and green onto the character and the room, creating sharp, black-outlined shadows that dance and pulsate to the beat, amplifying the vibrant, joyful atmosphere of the throat performance.", + "seed": 30769, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000102/group_9/index_2530_seed_30769_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.010090196947567165, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010090196947567165, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010090196947567165, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character an anthropomorphic taiko drummer with a bright red cylindrical body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a classic silver microphone in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a flat electric yellow wall covered in a repeating pattern of large cyan dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multi-colored strobe lights casting rapidly changing patterns of fuchsia and green onto the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style defined by bold flat colors and thick decisive black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010041317902505398 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.635041236877441 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010041317902505398, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010041317902505398, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04774942249059677, + 0.1557755172252655, + 0.056129734963178635, + 0.02847546897828579, + 0.021330859512090683, + 0.11604007333517075, + 0.4358556568622589, + 0.08880956470966339, + 0.020373983308672905, + 0.029459672048687935 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010041317902505398 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character an anthropomorphic taiko drummer with a bright red cylindrical body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a classic silver microphone in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a flat electric yellow wall covered in a repeating pattern of large cyan dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multi-colored strobe lights casting rapidly changing patterns of fuchsia and green onto the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style defined by bold flat colors and thick decisive black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818063110113144 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018180847167969 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818063110113144, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818063110113144, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.046122003346681595, + 0.2723536193370819, + 0.04279876872897148, + 0.11694839596748352, + 0.027579937130212784, + 0.06143002212047577, + 0.3546973168849945, + 0.016598906368017197, + 0.01836763694882393, + 0.043103404343128204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818063110113144 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character an anthropomorphic taiko drummer with a bright red cylindrical body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a classic silver microphone in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a flat electric yellow wall covered in a repeating pattern of large cyan dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multi-colored strobe lights casting rapidly changing patterns of fuchsia and green onto the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style defined by bold flat colors and thick decisive black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005249644163995981 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255249500274658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005249644163995981, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005249644163995981, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02390316314995289, + 0.06765097379684448, + 0.08338137716054916, + 0.1604684442281723, + 0.05151538923382759, + 0.1014946699142456, + 0.39680689573287964, + 0.05848256126046181, + 0.01640315353870392, + 0.039893362671136856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005249644163995981 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character an anthropomorphic taiko drummer with a bright red cylindrical body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a classic silver microphone in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a flat electric yellow wall covered in a repeating pattern of large cyan dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multi-colored strobe lights casting rapidly changing patterns of fuchsia and green onto the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style defined by bold flat colors and thick decisive black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606285385787487 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410627365112305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606285385787487, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606285385787487, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.039071522653102875, + 0.0705307275056839, + 0.04297548905014992, + 0.2876894474029541, + 0.06333661079406738, + 0.04480079188942909, + 0.36160197854042053, + 0.04094667732715607, + 0.02903973124921322, + 0.020007090643048286 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606285385787487 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main character an anthropomorphic taiko drummer with a bright red cylindrical body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a classic silver microphone in one hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a flat electric yellow wall covered in a repeating pattern of large cyan dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multi-colored strobe lights casting rapidly changing patterns of fuchsia and green onto the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style defined by bold flat colors and thick decisive black outlines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.000916537712328136 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.000916481018066 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.000916537712328136, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.000916537712328136, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07335875183343887, + 0.031181247904896736, + 0.07175367325544357, + 0.08984552323818207, + 0.043712254613637924, + 0.061243314296007156, + 0.45909446477890015, + 0.04502473771572113, + 0.030683347955346107, + 0.09410270303487778 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.000916537712328136 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_0/index_tensor([7083, 7083])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_0/index_tensor([7083, 7083])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0a6e7615c6aca26ae6ad0ccf88276c3f8f3a47ad --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_0/index_tensor([7083, 7083])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "majestic, sweeping panorama begins, the camera slowly panning across Jupiter's great curvature as a dramatic sunrise crosses its edge. The first bright rays from the distant, off-camera Sun strike the uppermost reaches of the gas giant's atmosphere with surgical precision, creating a striking contrast of movement between dazzling light and deep shadows, highlighting the planet's vast terrain. Captured with the razor-sharp clarity of high-speed sports photography and the aesthetic of a frozen moment, the atmosphere's turbulent, swirling motion is rendered in stunning detail. Bands of cream, ochre, and burnt Sienna churn in complex, chaotic patterns, while the Great Red Spot, a vast swirl of deep red and orange, dominates the frame. Its powerful anticyclonic rotation, captured in a single, hyper-detailed instant, reveals the raw, beautiful, and violent energy of a storm larger than life, contrasting starkly against the silent, star-studded darkness.", + "seed": 17328, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_0/index_7083_seed_17328_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.5131595157086849, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5131595157086849, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5131595157086849, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan across the curvature of Jupiter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sunrise visible with bright rays striking the upper edge of the planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the atmospheric bands colored cream, ochre, and burnt Sienna?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Red Spot visible as a vast swirl of deep red and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a silent, star-studded darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03228229284286499 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5322823524475098 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03228229284286499, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03228229284286499, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04403213411569595, + 0.019382363185286522, + 0.20628423988819122, + 0.037845999002456665, + 0.16843563318252563, + 0.04848198965191841, + 0.04541860520839691, + 0.25113412737846375, + 0.06244600936770439, + 0.116538867354393 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03228229284286499 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan across the curvature of Jupiter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sunrise visible with bright rays striking the upper edge of the planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the atmospheric bands colored cream, ochre, and burnt Sienna?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Red Spot visible as a vast swirl of deep red and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a silent, star-studded darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328309774398804 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578309774398804 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6328309774398804, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6328309774398804, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.052988793700933456, + 0.03272064030170441, + 0.13624383509159088, + 0.02183402143418789, + 0.3745570778846741, + 0.041639234870672226, + 0.02029535174369812, + 0.16293497383594513, + 0.11685241013765335, + 0.0399336963891983 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6328309774398804 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan across the curvature of Jupiter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sunrise visible with bright rays striking the upper edge of the planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the atmospheric bands colored cream, ochre, and burnt Sienna?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Red Spot visible as a vast swirl of deep red and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a silent, star-studded darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020609866827726364 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956098556518555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020609866827726364, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020609866827726364, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09199612587690353, + 0.06385941803455353, + 0.2707054018974304, + 0.06601571291685104, + 0.20996719598770142, + 0.09194446355104446, + 0.02547711879014969, + 0.0461287721991539, + 0.08718161284923553, + 0.04672418534755707 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020609866827726364 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan across the curvature of Jupiter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sunrise visible with bright rays striking the upper edge of the planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the atmospheric bands colored cream, ochre, and burnt Sienna?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Red Spot visible as a vast swirl of deep red and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a silent, star-studded darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261494040489197 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761494040489197 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8261494040489197, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8261494040489197, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.047386523336172104, + 0.037640102207660675, + 0.3184104263782501, + 0.030109599232673645, + 0.1335677057504654, + 0.08146867156028748, + 0.014963467605412006, + 0.15242889523506165, + 0.058367323130369186, + 0.1256573349237442 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8261494040489197 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan across the curvature of Jupiter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sunrise visible with bright rays striking the upper edge of the planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the atmospheric bands colored cream, ochre, and burnt Sienna?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Red Spot visible as a vast swirl of deep red and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a silent, star-studded darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539250373840332 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289250373840332 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0539250373840332, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0539250373840332, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08717668801546097, + 0.04207870736718178, + 0.3064868450164795, + 0.038003724068403244, + 0.08162862062454224, + 0.08215250074863434, + 0.03977544605731964, + 0.1270914226770401, + 0.08576489984989166, + 0.10984110832214355 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0539250373840332 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "majestic, sweeping panorama begins, the camera slowly panning across Jupiter's great curvature as a dramatic sunrise crosses its edge. The first bright rays from the distant, off-camera Sun strike the uppermost reaches of the gas giant's atmosphere with surgical precision, creating a striking contrast of movement between dazzling light and deep shadows, highlighting the planet's vast terrain. Captured with the razor-sharp clarity of high-speed sports photography and the aesthetic of a frozen moment, the atmosphere's turbulent, swirling motion is rendered in stunning detail. Bands of cream, ochre, and burnt Sienna churn in complex, chaotic patterns, while the Great Red Spot, a vast swirl of deep red and orange, dominates the frame. Its powerful anticyclonic rotation, captured in a single, hyper-detailed instant, reveals the raw, beautiful, and violent energy of a storm larger than life, contrasting starkly against the silent, star-studded darkness.", + "seed": 17329, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_0/index_7083_seed_17329_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.4130905982106924, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4130905982106924, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.4999999523162841, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4130905982106924, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan across the curvature of Jupiter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sunrise visible with bright rays striking the upper edge of the planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the atmospheric bands colored cream, ochre, and burnt Sienna?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Red Spot visible as a vast swirl of deep red and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a silent, star-studded darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04167955368757248 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.291679620742798 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04167955368757248, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04167955368757248, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14985445141792297, + 0.06755630671977997, + 0.1327168494462967, + 0.028282059356570244, + 0.10720182210206985, + 0.07399916648864746, + 0.107129767537117, + 0.033266909420490265, + 0.23340252041816711, + 0.06659016758203506 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04167955368757248 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan across the curvature of Jupiter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sunrise visible with bright rays striking the upper edge of the planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the atmospheric bands colored cream, ochre, and burnt Sienna?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Red Spot visible as a vast swirl of deep red and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a silent, star-studded darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4743340015411377 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9743340015411377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4743340015411377, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4743340015411377, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10032334923744202, + 0.02461245097219944, + 0.019761813804507256, + 0.023188522085547447, + 0.0887131541967392, + 0.03176730126142502, + 0.07588773220777512, + 0.12030011415481567, + 0.476818323135376, + 0.03862723708152771 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4743340015411377 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan across the curvature of Jupiter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sunrise visible with bright rays striking the upper edge of the planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the atmospheric bands colored cream, ochre, and burnt Sienna?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Red Spot visible as a vast swirl of deep red and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a silent, star-studded darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018220549449324608 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0182204246521 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018220549449324608, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018220549449324608, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09665414690971375, + 0.11485377699136734, + 0.060121454298496246, + 0.14158059656620026, + 0.09202852845191956, + 0.10710055381059647, + 0.058495063334703445, + 0.07630467414855957, + 0.22080467641353607, + 0.032056573778390884 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018220549449324608 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan across the curvature of Jupiter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sunrise visible with bright rays striking the upper edge of the planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the atmospheric bands colored cream, ochre, and burnt Sienna?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Red Spot visible as a vast swirl of deep red and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a silent, star-studded darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328341364860535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578341364860535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6328341364860535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6328341364860535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1383230984210968, + 0.0989648699760437, + 0.10336246341466904, + 0.12295255064964294, + 0.08069834858179092, + 0.119975745677948, + 0.028461530804634094, + 0.08930907398462296, + 0.11199857294559479, + 0.10595377534627914 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6328341364860535 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan across the curvature of Jupiter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sunrise visible with bright rays striking the upper edge of the planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the atmospheric bands colored cream, ochre, and burnt Sienna?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Red Spot visible as a vast swirl of deep red and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a silent, star-studded darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983847498893738 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233847498893738 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8983847498893738, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8983847498893738, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12582971155643463, + 0.26588475704193115, + 0.04203896224498749, + 0.1387159377336502, + 0.07406356930732727, + 0.07192498445510864, + 0.04266125708818436, + 0.05780348554253578, + 0.12326496094465256, + 0.05781232938170433 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8983847498893738 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "majestic, sweeping panorama begins, the camera slowly panning across Jupiter's great curvature as a dramatic sunrise crosses its edge. The first bright rays from the distant, off-camera Sun strike the uppermost reaches of the gas giant's atmosphere with surgical precision, creating a striking contrast of movement between dazzling light and deep shadows, highlighting the planet's vast terrain. Captured with the razor-sharp clarity of high-speed sports photography and the aesthetic of a frozen moment, the atmosphere's turbulent, swirling motion is rendered in stunning detail. Bands of cream, ochre, and burnt Sienna churn in complex, chaotic patterns, while the Great Red Spot, a vast swirl of deep red and orange, dominates the frame. Its powerful anticyclonic rotation, captured in a single, hyper-detailed instant, reveals the raw, beautiful, and violent energy of a storm larger than life, contrasting starkly against the silent, star-studded darkness.", + "seed": 17330, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_0/index_7083_seed_17330_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.3174212120473385, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3174212120473385, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.574999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3174212120473385, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan across the curvature of Jupiter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sunrise visible with bright rays striking the upper edge of the planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the atmospheric bands colored cream, ochre, and burnt Sienna?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Red Spot visible as a vast swirl of deep red and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a silent, star-studded darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07243746519088745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6974375247955322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07243746519088745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07243746519088745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04524275287985802, + 0.07815694808959961, + 0.02476745843887329, + 0.017587805166840553, + 0.4629378616809845, + 0.060262344777584076, + 0.1140892505645752, + 0.07625196874141693, + 0.10081741958856583, + 0.019886145368218422 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07243746519088745 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan across the curvature of Jupiter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sunrise visible with bright rays striking the upper edge of the planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the atmospheric bands colored cream, ochre, and burnt Sienna?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Red Spot visible as a vast swirl of deep red and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a silent, star-studded darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31348368525505066 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.313483715057373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31348368525505066, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31348368525505066, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.058067549020051956, + 0.09471747279167175, + 0.036458611488342285, + 0.01607462204992771, + 0.44452232122421265, + 0.11136043071746826, + 0.09961038827896118, + 0.08917418867349625, + 0.02464119717478752, + 0.025373268872499466 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31348368525505066 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan across the curvature of Jupiter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sunrise visible with bright rays striking the upper edge of the planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the atmospheric bands colored cream, ochre, and burnt Sienna?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Red Spot visible as a vast swirl of deep red and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a silent, star-studded darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026373248547315598 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513731479644775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026373248547315598, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026373248547315598, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0625288337469101, + 0.3239986300468445, + 0.041226815432310104, + 0.021008968353271484, + 0.17278115451335907, + 0.08868874609470367, + 0.08809470385313034, + 0.11779069155454636, + 0.04083959758281708, + 0.04304187372326851 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026373248547315598 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan across the curvature of Jupiter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sunrise visible with bright rays striking the upper edge of the planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the atmospheric bands colored cream, ochre, and burnt Sienna?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Red Spot visible as a vast swirl of deep red and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a silent, star-studded darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486390709877014 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236390113830566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486390709877014, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8749999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486390709877014, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05853970721364021, + 0.45469775795936584, + 0.03919200599193573, + 0.02591499499976635, + 0.0833551287651062, + 0.11421120911836624, + 0.07782935351133347, + 0.056595057249069214, + 0.048683591187000275, + 0.04098116606473923 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486390709877014 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan across the curvature of Jupiter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sunrise visible with bright rays striking the upper edge of the planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the atmospheric bands colored cream, ochre, and burnt Sienna?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Red Spot visible as a vast swirl of deep red and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a silent, star-studded darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261725902557373 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761725902557373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8261725902557373, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8261725902557373, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05130023509263992, + 0.07154616713523865, + 0.025870785117149353, + 0.052613962441682816, + 0.32138657569885254, + 0.11178351938724518, + 0.09941151738166809, + 0.1906595230102539, + 0.04217313230037689, + 0.033254582434892654 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8261725902557373 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "majestic, sweeping panorama begins, the camera slowly panning across Jupiter's great curvature as a dramatic sunrise crosses its edge. The first bright rays from the distant, off-camera Sun strike the uppermost reaches of the gas giant's atmosphere with surgical precision, creating a striking contrast of movement between dazzling light and deep shadows, highlighting the planet's vast terrain. Captured with the razor-sharp clarity of high-speed sports photography and the aesthetic of a frozen moment, the atmosphere's turbulent, swirling motion is rendered in stunning detail. Bands of cream, ochre, and burnt Sienna churn in complex, chaotic patterns, while the Great Red Spot, a vast swirl of deep red and orange, dominates the frame. Its powerful anticyclonic rotation, captured in a single, hyper-detailed instant, reveals the raw, beautiful, and violent energy of a storm larger than life, contrasting starkly against the silent, star-studded darkness.", + "seed": 17331, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_0/index_7083_seed_17331_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.25589246973395346, + "vlm_logprob": -0.25589246973395346, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.25589246973395346, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan across the curvature of Jupiter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sunrise visible with bright rays striking the upper edge of the planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the atmospheric bands colored cream, ochre, and burnt Sienna?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Red Spot visible as a vast swirl of deep red and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a silent, star-studded darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05849015340209007 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.933490037918091 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05849015340209007, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05849015340209007, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08283914625644684, + 0.14686867594718933, + 0.05469023808836937, + 0.035529665648937225, + 0.06468155980110168, + 0.044969674199819565, + 0.2061656266450882, + 0.17491714656352997, + 0.05192020907998085, + 0.1374179869890213 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05849015340209007 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan across the curvature of Jupiter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sunrise visible with bright rays striking the upper edge of the planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the atmospheric bands colored cream, ochre, and burnt Sienna?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Red Spot visible as a vast swirl of deep red and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a silent, star-studded darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2256341129541397 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006340980529785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2256341129541397, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2256341129541397, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0955749899148941, + 0.048866987228393555, + 0.07869231700897217, + 0.05762506276369095, + 0.07171382755041122, + 0.10095900297164917, + 0.09584064036607742, + 0.09220054745674133, + 0.2121250331401825, + 0.14640165865421295 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2256341129541397 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan across the curvature of Jupiter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sunrise visible with bright rays striking the upper edge of the planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the atmospheric bands colored cream, ochre, and burnt Sienna?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Red Spot visible as a vast swirl of deep red and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a silent, star-studded darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020613253116607666 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895613193511963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020613253116607666, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020613253116607666, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10827728360891342, + 0.14735721051692963, + 0.05111076682806015, + 0.038149505853652954, + 0.20140455663204193, + 0.10920365899801254, + 0.04287263751029968, + 0.06216029077768326, + 0.17775776982307434, + 0.0617063082754612 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020613253116607666 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan across the curvature of Jupiter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sunrise visible with bright rays striking the upper edge of the planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the atmospheric bands colored cream, ochre, and burnt Sienna?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Red Spot visible as a vast swirl of deep red and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a silent, star-studded darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813345789909363 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.406334638595581 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813345789909363, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813345789909363, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08079691231250763, + 0.1793997585773468, + 0.09249952435493469, + 0.07838577032089233, + 0.20627930760383606, + 0.06082607060670853, + 0.036653149873018265, + 0.06933952867984772, + 0.061342332512140274, + 0.1344776749610901 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813345789909363 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan across the curvature of Jupiter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sunrise visible with bright rays striking the upper edge of the planet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the atmospheric bands colored cream, ochre, and burnt Sienna?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Red Spot visible as a vast swirl of deep red and orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a silent, star-studded darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933902502059937 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933902502059937 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6933902502059937, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6933902502059937, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10015419125556946, + 0.06733833998441696, + 0.016244975849986076, + 0.037572864443063736, + 0.12072793394327164, + 0.07231804728507996, + 0.027355926111340523, + 0.08814017474651337, + 0.4094512164592743, + 0.060696348547935486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6933902502059937 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_1/index_tensor([7533, 7533])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_1/index_tensor([7533, 7533])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1de60736dae44b25d967bffaf52b28bf589aae01 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_1/index_tensor([7533, 7533])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, full-body shot, captured from a low angle, captures a gargoyle, composed entirely of rough, dark gray and lime-colored pixels, crouching in the dim interior of a Gothic cathedral, its towering stone pillars and vaulted ceiling looming in shadow. With demonic wings, sharp claws, and a hideous face, it faces away from the only source of light: a vast, ornate stained glass window depicting the stories of saints, its pixelated outline cast in an ominous silhouette. Suddenly, the gargoyle explodes from its crouch, unfurling in mid-air and delivering a devastating kick, its pixelated toe striking the center of the ornate stained glass window with pinpoint precision and force. At the moment of impact, the window did not shatter like ordinary glass, but exploded instantly. Countless bright red, blue and gold glass fragments decomposed and reorganized in the air into retro pixel art style geometric blocks of varying sizes and sharp edges. These blocks flew around in a slow-motion, explosive ballet posture. As the window shattered, a dazzling white light poured in, bringing this surreal scene that combined the aesthetics of Gothic destruction with the visual impact of 8-bit video games to a climax.", + "seed": 8340, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_1/index_7533_seed_8340_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.042763594351708886, + "vlm_logprob": -0.042763594351708886, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.675000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.042763594351708886, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gargoyle composed of rough, dark gray and lime-colored pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the dim interior of a Gothic cathedral with towering stone pillars and a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle start in a crouching position facing away from a vast, ornate stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle explode from its crouch to deliver a kick that strikes the center of the stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered glass fragments transform into retro pixel art style geometric blocks of varying sizes and sharp edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.146097332239151 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.021097421646118 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.146097332239151, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.146097332239151, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08496814221143723, + 0.09570744633674622, + 0.10822471231222153, + 0.30400294065475464, + 0.05286277085542679, + 0.04015159606933594, + 0.1860365867614746, + 0.04124976322054863, + 0.027717439457774162, + 0.0590786412358284 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.146097332239151 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gargoyle composed of rough, dark gray and lime-colored pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the dim interior of a Gothic cathedral with towering stone pillars and a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle start in a crouching position facing away from a vast, ornate stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle explode from its crouch to deliver a kick that strikes the center of the stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered glass fragments transform into retro pixel art style geometric blocks of varying sizes and sharp edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026374641805887222 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651374578475952 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026374641805887222, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026374641805887222, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22920382022857666, + 0.18183451890945435, + 0.05797525495290756, + 0.1648084670305252, + 0.1501014232635498, + 0.017231902107596397, + 0.0884503573179245, + 0.04874119535088539, + 0.029890308156609535, + 0.03176274523139 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026374641805887222 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gargoyle composed of rough, dark gray and lime-colored pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the dim interior of a Gothic cathedral with towering stone pillars and a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle start in a crouching position facing away from a vast, ornate stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle explode from its crouch to deliver a kick that strikes the center of the stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered glass fragments transform into retro pixel art style geometric blocks of varying sizes and sharp edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01608455553650856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141084671020508 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01608455553650856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01608455553650856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12173276394605637, + 0.13816918432712555, + 0.16772538423538208, + 0.07500692456960678, + 0.1748717874288559, + 0.0625770315527916, + 0.10556863248348236, + 0.07198692858219147, + 0.03185758739709854, + 0.05050378292798996 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01608455553650856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gargoyle composed of rough, dark gray and lime-colored pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the dim interior of a Gothic cathedral with towering stone pillars and a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle start in a crouching position facing away from a vast, ornate stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle explode from its crouch to deliver a kick that strikes the center of the stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered glass fragments transform into retro pixel art style geometric blocks of varying sizes and sharp edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014192949049174786 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264193058013916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014192949049174786, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014192949049174786, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09805938601493835, + 0.08365314453840256, + 0.11735125631093979, + 0.12365904450416565, + 0.26356446743011475, + 0.0435154065489769, + 0.1048477366566658, + 0.031995292752981186, + 0.0551045797765255, + 0.07824961096048355 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014192949049174786 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gargoyle composed of rough, dark gray and lime-colored pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the dim interior of a Gothic cathedral with towering stone pillars and a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle start in a crouching position facing away from a vast, ornate stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle explode from its crouch to deliver a kick that strikes the center of the stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered glass fragments transform into retro pixel art style geometric blocks of varying sizes and sharp edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011068493127822876 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511068344116211 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011068493127822876, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011068493127822876, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08990360051393509, + 0.06410010904073715, + 0.13013021647930145, + 0.23501227796077728, + 0.039723679423332214, + 0.04302575811743736, + 0.11824031919240952, + 0.08990459144115448, + 0.07030527293682098, + 0.11965418606996536 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011068493127822876 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, full-body shot, captured from a low angle, captures a gargoyle, composed entirely of rough, dark gray and lime-colored pixels, crouching in the dim interior of a Gothic cathedral, its towering stone pillars and vaulted ceiling looming in shadow. With demonic wings, sharp claws, and a hideous face, it faces away from the only source of light: a vast, ornate stained glass window depicting the stories of saints, its pixelated outline cast in an ominous silhouette. Suddenly, the gargoyle explodes from its crouch, unfurling in mid-air and delivering a devastating kick, its pixelated toe striking the center of the ornate stained glass window with pinpoint precision and force. At the moment of impact, the window did not shatter like ordinary glass, but exploded instantly. Countless bright red, blue and gold glass fragments decomposed and reorganized in the air into retro pixel art style geometric blocks of varying sizes and sharp edges. These blocks flew around in a slow-motion, explosive ballet posture. As the window shattered, a dazzling white light poured in, bringing this surreal scene that combined the aesthetics of Gothic destruction with the visual impact of 8-bit video games to a climax.", + "seed": 8341, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_1/index_7533_seed_8341_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.11168891079723835, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11168891079723835, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3249999940395356, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11168891079723835, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gargoyle composed of rough, dark gray and lime-colored pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the dim interior of a Gothic cathedral with towering stone pillars and a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle start in a crouching position facing away from a vast, ornate stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle explode from its crouch to deliver a kick that strikes the center of the stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered glass fragments transform into retro pixel art style geometric blocks of varying sizes and sharp edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47793248295783997 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9779324531555176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47793248295783997, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.4999999701976776, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47793248295783997, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.051853910088539124, + 0.014596604742109776, + 0.042087357491254807, + 0.054593756794929504, + 0.019885115325450897, + 0.03780490532517433, + 0.044589634984731674, + 0.7050986886024475, + 0.018063228577375412, + 0.011426907032728195 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47793248295783997 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gargoyle composed of rough, dark gray and lime-colored pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the dim interior of a Gothic cathedral with towering stone pillars and a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle start in a crouching position facing away from a vast, ornate stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle explode from its crouch to deliver a kick that strikes the center of the stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered glass fragments transform into retro pixel art style geometric blocks of varying sizes and sharp edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029838472604751587 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298385620117188 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029838472604751587, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029838472604751587, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08901344239711761, + 0.03424656391143799, + 0.023043373599648476, + 0.04388940706849098, + 0.02248518355190754, + 0.0145726278424263, + 0.02438025176525116, + 0.687184751033783, + 0.0502912811934948, + 0.010893143713474274 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029838472604751587 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gargoyle composed of rough, dark gray and lime-colored pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the dim interior of a Gothic cathedral with towering stone pillars and a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle start in a crouching position facing away from a vast, ornate stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle explode from its crouch to deliver a kick that strikes the center of the stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered glass fragments transform into retro pixel art style geometric blocks of varying sizes and sharp edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011094312183558941 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511094093322754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011094312183558941, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011094312183558941, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1010732352733612, + 0.0438736155629158, + 0.1283230185508728, + 0.23929676413536072, + 0.03696112707257271, + 0.10689640790224075, + 0.041161421686410904, + 0.26189419627189636, + 0.0286104679107666, + 0.011909730732440948 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011094312183558941 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gargoyle composed of rough, dark gray and lime-colored pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the dim interior of a Gothic cathedral with towering stone pillars and a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle start in a crouching position facing away from a vast, ornate stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle explode from its crouch to deliver a kick that strikes the center of the stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered glass fragments transform into retro pixel art style geometric blocks of varying sizes and sharp edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009782352484762669 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634782314300537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009782352484762669, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009782352484762669, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06424374133348465, + 0.02594107575714588, + 0.01729266718029976, + 0.05205054208636284, + 0.02031792141497135, + 0.07707086950540543, + 0.059025898575782776, + 0.6398779153823853, + 0.03499516099691391, + 0.009184302762150764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009782352484762669 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gargoyle composed of rough, dark gray and lime-colored pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the dim interior of a Gothic cathedral with towering stone pillars and a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle start in a crouching position facing away from a vast, ornate stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle explode from its crouch to deliver a kick that strikes the center of the stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered glass fragments transform into retro pixel art style geometric blocks of varying sizes and sharp edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029796933755278587 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529796838760376 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029796933755278587, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029796933755278587, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02049696072936058, + 0.010711039416491985, + 0.029386896640062332, + 0.030234728008508682, + 0.012414063327014446, + 0.029086844995617867, + 0.08186548203229904, + 0.7537413239479065, + 0.02004438079893589, + 0.012018311768770218 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029796933755278587 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, full-body shot, captured from a low angle, captures a gargoyle, composed entirely of rough, dark gray and lime-colored pixels, crouching in the dim interior of a Gothic cathedral, its towering stone pillars and vaulted ceiling looming in shadow. With demonic wings, sharp claws, and a hideous face, it faces away from the only source of light: a vast, ornate stained glass window depicting the stories of saints, its pixelated outline cast in an ominous silhouette. Suddenly, the gargoyle explodes from its crouch, unfurling in mid-air and delivering a devastating kick, its pixelated toe striking the center of the ornate stained glass window with pinpoint precision and force. At the moment of impact, the window did not shatter like ordinary glass, but exploded instantly. Countless bright red, blue and gold glass fragments decomposed and reorganized in the air into retro pixel art style geometric blocks of varying sizes and sharp edges. These blocks flew around in a slow-motion, explosive ballet posture. As the window shattered, a dazzling white light poured in, bringing this surreal scene that combined the aesthetics of Gothic destruction with the visual impact of 8-bit video games to a climax.", + "seed": 8342, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_1/index_7533_seed_8342_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.3006447460502386, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3006447460502386, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3006447460502386, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gargoyle composed of rough, dark gray and lime-colored pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the dim interior of a Gothic cathedral with towering stone pillars and a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle start in a crouching position facing away from a vast, ornate stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle explode from its crouch to deliver a kick that strikes the center of the stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered glass fragments transform into retro pixel art style geometric blocks of varying sizes and sharp edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.407094955444336 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28209495544433594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.407094955444336, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -1.407094955444336, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21328699588775635, + 0.11749552190303802, + 0.02134338766336441, + 0.22908397018909454, + 0.033357348293066025, + 0.024301301687955856, + 0.11247606575489044, + 0.11326070129871368, + 0.051455896347761154, + 0.0839388519525528 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.407094955444336 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gargoyle composed of rough, dark gray and lime-colored pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the dim interior of a Gothic cathedral with towering stone pillars and a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle start in a crouching position facing away from a vast, ornate stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle explode from its crouch to deliver a kick that strikes the center of the stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered glass fragments transform into retro pixel art style geometric blocks of varying sizes and sharp edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026369184255599976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651369094848633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026369184255599976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026369184255599976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2561664283275604, + 0.09433452039957047, + 0.1352176070213318, + 0.11759307980537415, + 0.07164883613586426, + 0.040701042860746384, + 0.12690898776054382, + 0.07215488702058792, + 0.04544447362422943, + 0.03983015567064285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026369184255599976 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gargoyle composed of rough, dark gray and lime-colored pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the dim interior of a Gothic cathedral with towering stone pillars and a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle start in a crouching position facing away from a vast, ornate stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle explode from its crouch to deliver a kick that strikes the center of the stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered glass fragments transform into retro pixel art style geometric blocks of varying sizes and sharp edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811543062329292 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881155014038086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811543062329292, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811543062329292, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3875866234302521, + 0.10013917088508606, + 0.03223760798573494, + 0.08686930686235428, + 0.0391472727060318, + 0.02438555285334587, + 0.07969724386930466, + 0.10169263184070587, + 0.055134836584329605, + 0.09310979396104813 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811543062329292 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gargoyle composed of rough, dark gray and lime-colored pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the dim interior of a Gothic cathedral with towering stone pillars and a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle start in a crouching position facing away from a vast, ornate stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle explode from its crouch to deliver a kick that strikes the center of the stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered glass fragments transform into retro pixel art style geometric blocks of varying sizes and sharp edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011070143431425095 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511070251464844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011070143431425095, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011070143431425095, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1736365258693695, + 0.15527144074440002, + 0.04531700164079666, + 0.18602360785007477, + 0.051624100655317307, + 0.03930428624153137, + 0.09393882751464844, + 0.10696685314178467, + 0.03155888244509697, + 0.11635851860046387 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011070143431425095 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gargoyle composed of rough, dark gray and lime-colored pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the dim interior of a Gothic cathedral with towering stone pillars and a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle start in a crouching position facing away from a vast, ornate stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle explode from its crouch to deliver a kick that strikes the center of the stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered glass fragments transform into retro pixel art style geometric blocks of varying sizes and sharp edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020574016496539116 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955740928649902 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020574016496539116, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020574016496539116, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25753241777420044, + 0.11581609398126602, + 0.027858639135956764, + 0.10745464265346527, + 0.03377409279346466, + 0.04995051026344299, + 0.07632876187562943, + 0.1766328364610672, + 0.046287283301353455, + 0.1083647683262825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020574016496539116 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, full-body shot, captured from a low angle, captures a gargoyle, composed entirely of rough, dark gray and lime-colored pixels, crouching in the dim interior of a Gothic cathedral, its towering stone pillars and vaulted ceiling looming in shadow. With demonic wings, sharp claws, and a hideous face, it faces away from the only source of light: a vast, ornate stained glass window depicting the stories of saints, its pixelated outline cast in an ominous silhouette. Suddenly, the gargoyle explodes from its crouch, unfurling in mid-air and delivering a devastating kick, its pixelated toe striking the center of the ornate stained glass window with pinpoint precision and force. At the moment of impact, the window did not shatter like ordinary glass, but exploded instantly. Countless bright red, blue and gold glass fragments decomposed and reorganized in the air into retro pixel art style geometric blocks of varying sizes and sharp edges. These blocks flew around in a slow-motion, explosive ballet posture. As the window shattered, a dazzling white light poured in, bringing this surreal scene that combined the aesthetics of Gothic destruction with the visual impact of 8-bit video games to a climax.", + "seed": 8343, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_1/index_7533_seed_8343_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.05874751359224319, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05874751359224319, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05874751359224319, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gargoyle composed of rough, dark gray and lime-colored pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the dim interior of a Gothic cathedral with towering stone pillars and a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle start in a crouching position facing away from a vast, ornate stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle explode from its crouch to deliver a kick that strikes the center of the stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered glass fragments transform into retro pixel art style geometric blocks of varying sizes and sharp edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22960124909877777 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.604601263999939 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22960124909877777, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22960124909877777, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24864791333675385, + 0.04382692277431488, + 0.034101251512765884, + 0.03487187623977661, + 0.037418216466903687, + 0.03903209790587425, + 0.0875905379652977, + 0.19397084414958954, + 0.07211068272590637, + 0.20842963457107544 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22960124909877777 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gargoyle composed of rough, dark gray and lime-colored pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the dim interior of a Gothic cathedral with towering stone pillars and a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle start in a crouching position facing away from a vast, ornate stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle explode from its crouch to deliver a kick that strikes the center of the stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered glass fragments transform into retro pixel art style geometric blocks of varying sizes and sharp edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04868066683411598 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486807823181152 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04868066683411598, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04868066683411598, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.45494547486305237, + 0.11876767128705978, + 0.047010891139507294, + 0.018723683431744576, + 0.01787634752690792, + 0.047481339424848557, + 0.042497944086790085, + 0.06958715617656708, + 0.03663980960845947, + 0.14646965265274048 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04868066683411598 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gargoyle composed of rough, dark gray and lime-colored pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the dim interior of a Gothic cathedral with towering stone pillars and a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle start in a crouching position facing away from a vast, ornate stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle explode from its crouch to deliver a kick that strikes the center of the stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered glass fragments transform into retro pixel art style geometric blocks of varying sizes and sharp edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004642185289412737 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379642009735107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004642185289412737, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004642185289412737, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29031091928482056, + 0.06421366333961487, + 0.0507689043879509, + 0.03448862582445145, + 0.040296200662851334, + 0.029112383723258972, + 0.03042099066078663, + 0.03806957229971886, + 0.029345272108912468, + 0.39297348260879517 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004642185289412737 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gargoyle composed of rough, dark gray and lime-colored pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the dim interior of a Gothic cathedral with towering stone pillars and a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle start in a crouching position facing away from a vast, ornate stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle explode from its crouch to deliver a kick that strikes the center of the stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered glass fragments transform into retro pixel art style geometric blocks of varying sizes and sharp edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031911423429846764 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753190994262695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031911423429846764, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031911423429846764, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1470712125301361, + 0.03873683139681816, + 0.026356149464845657, + 0.01877729780972004, + 0.027390792965888977, + 0.019169297069311142, + 0.04066159948706627, + 0.06017044559121132, + 0.045331817120313644, + 0.5763344764709473 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031911423429846764 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a gargoyle composed of rough, dark gray and lime-colored pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in the dim interior of a Gothic cathedral with towering stone pillars and a vaulted ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle start in a crouching position facing away from a vast, ornate stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the gargoyle explode from its crouch to deliver a kick that strikes the center of the stained glass window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shattered glass fragments transform into retro pixel art style geometric blocks of varying sizes and sharp edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007622324395924807 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882622241973877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007622324395924807, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007622324395924807, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16151757538318634, + 0.03898468613624573, + 0.02912110649049282, + 0.017255276441574097, + 0.01789393648505211, + 0.03000359609723091, + 0.07868723571300507, + 0.04480624198913574, + 0.06073480844497681, + 0.520995557308197 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007622324395924807 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_10/index_tensor([7285, 7285])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_10/index_tensor([7285, 7285])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b5bbbb62b4d15b9f19c8efcc11465939a1a43a05 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_10/index_tensor([7285, 7285])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium-long shot, shot from a level angle, slowly pans leftward across a patch of withered yellow reeds swaying gently in the morning mist. At the center of the frame, an ancient scholar sits alone on a moss-covered rock by the river. He wears a loose, blue-gray linen robe, its sleeves heavy with moisture. His long hair is pinned atop his head, a few strands falling around his thin face. His face is etched with melancholy, his brows slightly furrowed, his eyes staring deep and vacantly, as if his thoughts have drifted far away. Steady in his hands, he grips a slender, dimly shimmering bamboo fishing rod, the thin line silently lowering into the water. His posture is silent and enduring, as if he has become one with the surrounding landscape. A thick white mist lingered above the murky, dark green surface of the river. Only the delicate ripples where the fishing line entered the water, spreading outwards, broke the stillness of the surface. The entire scene was evenly illuminated by the soft, diffuse morning light, devoid of sharp shadows. The desaturated, cool tones resembled those of Chinese ink landscape paintings, creating an atmosphere of profound tranquility, solitude, and a poetic melancholy.", + "seed": 12403, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_10/index_7285_seed_12403_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.18933447189629077, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18933447189629077, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18933447189629077, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium-long shot featuring an ancient scholar sitting on a moss-covered rock by a river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar wearing a loose blue-gray linen robe and has long hair pinned atop his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with a line lowering into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a morning mist with withered yellow reeds swaying gently and a murky dark green river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan leftward across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012111220508813858 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.512111186981201 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012111220508813858, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012111220508813858, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3911682665348053, + 0.08138477802276611, + 0.05994797497987747, + 0.06143782287836075, + 0.03906024619936943, + 0.05951409786939621, + 0.07833290100097656, + 0.09074918925762177, + 0.0689929872751236, + 0.06941171735525131 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012111220508813858 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium-long shot featuring an ancient scholar sitting on a moss-covered rock by a river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar wearing a loose blue-gray linen robe and has long hair pinned atop his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with a line lowering into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a morning mist with withered yellow reeds swaying gently and a murky dark green river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan leftward across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007637467235326767 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826375007629395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007637467235326767, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007637467235326767, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2798617482185364, + 0.07677792012691498, + 0.06265313178300858, + 0.04125944525003433, + 0.06926623731851578, + 0.07095746695995331, + 0.08205569535493851, + 0.19119518995285034, + 0.05907965078949928, + 0.0668935626745224 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007637467235326767 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium-long shot featuring an ancient scholar sitting on a moss-covered rock by a river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar wearing a loose blue-gray linen robe and has long hair pinned atop his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with a line lowering into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a morning mist with withered yellow reeds swaying gently and a murky dark green river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan leftward across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016074232757091522 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141074180603027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016074232757091522, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016074232757091522, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2361229807138443, + 0.11650822311639786, + 0.1158691793680191, + 0.06148285046219826, + 0.06772259622812271, + 0.08692798763513565, + 0.08718538284301758, + 0.12828537821769714, + 0.043130286037921906, + 0.05676514282822609 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016074232757091522 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium-long shot featuring an ancient scholar sitting on a moss-covered rock by a river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar wearing a loose blue-gray linen robe and has long hair pinned atop his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with a line lowering into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a morning mist with withered yellow reeds swaying gently and a murky dark green river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan leftward across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01254265196621418 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387542724609375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01254265196621418, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01254265196621418, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21771886944770813, + 0.13106247782707214, + 0.14670521020889282, + 0.045576415956020355, + 0.0473715215921402, + 0.08229854702949524, + 0.10325627774000168, + 0.030988704413175583, + 0.06859822571277618, + 0.12642382085323334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01254265196621418 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium-long shot featuring an ancient scholar sitting on a moss-covered rock by a river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar wearing a loose blue-gray linen robe and has long hair pinned atop his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with a line lowering into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a morning mist with withered yellow reeds swaying gently and a murky dark green river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan leftward across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983067870140076 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233067870140076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8983067870140076, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8983067870140076, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13177219033241272, + 0.12790022790431976, + 0.07344452291727066, + 0.052314165979623795, + 0.054834555834531784, + 0.10578928887844086, + 0.042190179228782654, + 0.059872817248106, + 0.08374598622322083, + 0.26813605427742004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8983067870140076 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium-long shot, shot from a level angle, slowly pans leftward across a patch of withered yellow reeds swaying gently in the morning mist. At the center of the frame, an ancient scholar sits alone on a moss-covered rock by the river. He wears a loose, blue-gray linen robe, its sleeves heavy with moisture. His long hair is pinned atop his head, a few strands falling around his thin face. His face is etched with melancholy, his brows slightly furrowed, his eyes staring deep and vacantly, as if his thoughts have drifted far away. Steady in his hands, he grips a slender, dimly shimmering bamboo fishing rod, the thin line silently lowering into the water. His posture is silent and enduring, as if he has become one with the surrounding landscape. A thick white mist lingered above the murky, dark green surface of the river. Only the delicate ripples where the fishing line entered the water, spreading outwards, broke the stillness of the surface. The entire scene was evenly illuminated by the soft, diffuse morning light, devoid of sharp shadows. The desaturated, cool tones resembled those of Chinese ink landscape paintings, creating an atmosphere of profound tranquility, solitude, and a poetic melancholy.", + "seed": 12404, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_10/index_7285_seed_12404_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.12584596266970038, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12584596266970038, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12584596266970038, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium-long shot featuring an ancient scholar sitting on a moss-covered rock by a river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar wearing a loose blue-gray linen robe and has long hair pinned atop his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with a line lowering into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a morning mist with withered yellow reeds swaying gently and a murky dark green river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan leftward across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008802538737654686 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88380241394043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008802538737654686, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008802538737654686, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35112264752388, + 0.13077837228775024, + 0.03947130963206291, + 0.037470653653144836, + 0.10144645720720291, + 0.07649612426757812, + 0.07276558876037598, + 0.10780926793813705, + 0.03629985451698303, + 0.046339694410562515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008802538737654686 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium-long shot featuring an ancient scholar sitting on a moss-covered rock by a river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar wearing a loose blue-gray linen robe and has long hair pinned atop his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with a line lowering into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a morning mist with withered yellow reeds swaying gently and a murky dark green river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan leftward across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007640188094228506 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882640361785889 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007640188094228506, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007640188094228506, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25769197940826416, + 0.09175680577754974, + 0.07275126874446869, + 0.03589923307299614, + 0.0977129116654396, + 0.21948422491550446, + 0.08107447624206543, + 0.04281102865934372, + 0.03702002018690109, + 0.06379806995391846 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007640188094228506 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium-long shot featuring an ancient scholar sitting on a moss-covered rock by a river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar wearing a loose blue-gray linen robe and has long hair pinned atop his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with a line lowering into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a morning mist with withered yellow reeds swaying gently and a murky dark green river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan leftward across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016070479527115822 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141070365905762 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016070479527115822, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016070479527115822, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1939060240983963, + 0.11847587674856186, + 0.11771094799041748, + 0.11141718924045563, + 0.063398078083992, + 0.1158432811498642, + 0.07174775004386902, + 0.07752573490142822, + 0.04712110012769699, + 0.08285398781299591 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016070479527115822 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium-long shot featuring an ancient scholar sitting on a moss-covered rock by a river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar wearing a loose blue-gray linen robe and has long hair pinned atop his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with a line lowering into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a morning mist with withered yellow reeds swaying gently and a murky dark green river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan leftward across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058347500860691 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895583391189575 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058347500860691, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058347500860691, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30132558941841125, + 0.09349211305379868, + 0.06054067611694336, + 0.041993044316768646, + 0.059378039091825485, + 0.0787033885717392, + 0.10631643980741501, + 0.1630597859621048, + 0.03859252855181694, + 0.05659839138388634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058347500860691 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium-long shot featuring an ancient scholar sitting on a moss-covered rock by a river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar wearing a loose blue-gray linen robe and has long hair pinned atop his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with a line lowering into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a morning mist with withered yellow reeds swaying gently and a murky dark green river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan leftward across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.576133131980896 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.826133131980896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.576133131980896, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.576133131980896, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15245728194713593, + 0.06292429566383362, + 0.061748966574668884, + 0.05270460993051529, + 0.13724561035633087, + 0.07591231912374496, + 0.09502115845680237, + 0.166307732462883, + 0.08062040060758591, + 0.11505763232707977 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.576133131980896 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium-long shot, shot from a level angle, slowly pans leftward across a patch of withered yellow reeds swaying gently in the morning mist. At the center of the frame, an ancient scholar sits alone on a moss-covered rock by the river. He wears a loose, blue-gray linen robe, its sleeves heavy with moisture. His long hair is pinned atop his head, a few strands falling around his thin face. His face is etched with melancholy, his brows slightly furrowed, his eyes staring deep and vacantly, as if his thoughts have drifted far away. Steady in his hands, he grips a slender, dimly shimmering bamboo fishing rod, the thin line silently lowering into the water. His posture is silent and enduring, as if he has become one with the surrounding landscape. A thick white mist lingered above the murky, dark green surface of the river. Only the delicate ripples where the fishing line entered the water, spreading outwards, broke the stillness of the surface. The entire scene was evenly illuminated by the soft, diffuse morning light, devoid of sharp shadows. The desaturated, cool tones resembled those of Chinese ink landscape paintings, creating an atmosphere of profound tranquility, solitude, and a poetic melancholy.", + "seed": 12405, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_10/index_7285_seed_12405_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.16979698780924082, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16979698780924082, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16979698780924082, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium-long shot featuring an ancient scholar sitting on a moss-covered rock by a river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar wearing a loose blue-gray linen robe and has long hair pinned atop his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with a line lowering into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a morning mist with withered yellow reeds swaying gently and a murky dark green river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan leftward across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03170512989163399 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.531705141067505 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03170512989163399, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03170512989163399, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40835756063461304, + 0.06355291604995728, + 0.03940921649336815, + 0.03702361136674881, + 0.06423614919185638, + 0.04013100266456604, + 0.032204221934080124, + 0.10830379277467728, + 0.07978105545043945, + 0.12700051069259644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03170512989163399 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium-long shot featuring an ancient scholar sitting on a moss-covered rock by a river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar wearing a loose blue-gray linen robe and has long hair pinned atop his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with a line lowering into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a morning mist with withered yellow reeds swaying gently and a murky dark green river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan leftward across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012551010586321354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875508308410645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012551010586321354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012551010586321354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.314917653799057, + 0.09381002932786942, + 0.06783253699541092, + 0.05412037670612335, + 0.06959551572799683, + 0.05386001244187355, + 0.05469702184200287, + 0.12688954174518585, + 0.08151698857545853, + 0.08276034146547318 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012551010586321354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium-long shot featuring an ancient scholar sitting on a moss-covered rock by a river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar wearing a loose blue-gray linen robe and has long hair pinned atop his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with a line lowering into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a morning mist with withered yellow reeds swaying gently and a murky dark green river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan leftward across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0263564120978117 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513564586639404 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0263564120978117, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0263564120978117, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4282471537590027, + 0.0656324177980423, + 0.07738079875707626, + 0.041537489742040634, + 0.04042138159275055, + 0.0447625070810318, + 0.08433053642511368, + 0.06135651841759682, + 0.08269484341144562, + 0.07363630086183548 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0263564120978117 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium-long shot featuring an ancient scholar sitting on a moss-covered rock by a river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar wearing a loose blue-gray linen robe and has long hair pinned atop his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with a line lowering into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a morning mist with withered yellow reeds swaying gently and a murky dark green river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan leftward across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020588496699929237 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955883979797363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020588496699929237, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020588496699929237, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.46465054154396057, + 0.08655180782079697, + 0.060426995158195496, + 0.03974995017051697, + 0.03642832487821579, + 0.031081585213541985, + 0.03678199648857117, + 0.050564080476760864, + 0.09752608090639114, + 0.09623856842517853 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020588496699929237 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium-long shot featuring an ancient scholar sitting on a moss-covered rock by a river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar wearing a loose blue-gray linen robe and has long hair pinned atop his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with a line lowering into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a morning mist with withered yellow reeds swaying gently and a murky dark green river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan leftward across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7577838897705078 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6327838897705078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7577838897705078, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7577838897705078, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08892163634300232, + 0.04646216705441475, + 0.043667178601026535, + 0.06154868006706238, + 0.05083506926894188, + 0.05084909498691559, + 0.1016942486166954, + 0.2323666512966156, + 0.24108149111270905, + 0.08257383108139038 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7577838897705078 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium-long shot, shot from a level angle, slowly pans leftward across a patch of withered yellow reeds swaying gently in the morning mist. At the center of the frame, an ancient scholar sits alone on a moss-covered rock by the river. He wears a loose, blue-gray linen robe, its sleeves heavy with moisture. His long hair is pinned atop his head, a few strands falling around his thin face. His face is etched with melancholy, his brows slightly furrowed, his eyes staring deep and vacantly, as if his thoughts have drifted far away. Steady in his hands, he grips a slender, dimly shimmering bamboo fishing rod, the thin line silently lowering into the water. His posture is silent and enduring, as if he has become one with the surrounding landscape. A thick white mist lingered above the murky, dark green surface of the river. Only the delicate ripples where the fishing line entered the water, spreading outwards, broke the stillness of the surface. The entire scene was evenly illuminated by the soft, diffuse morning light, devoid of sharp shadows. The desaturated, cool tones resembled those of Chinese ink landscape paintings, creating an atmosphere of profound tranquility, solitude, and a poetic melancholy.", + "seed": 12406, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_10/index_7285_seed_12406_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.05733163235709071, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05733163235709071, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05733163235709071, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium-long shot featuring an ancient scholar sitting on a moss-covered rock by a river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar wearing a loose blue-gray linen robe and has long hair pinned atop his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with a line lowering into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a morning mist with withered yellow reeds swaying gently and a murky dark green river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan leftward across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005012089852243662 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.505012035369873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005012089852243662, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005012089852243662, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31832945346832275, + 0.048579391092061996, + 0.030810590833425522, + 0.04719660058617592, + 0.23318615555763245, + 0.09903950244188309, + 0.06770642846822739, + 0.05160485953092575, + 0.060502778738737106, + 0.04304425045847893 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005012089852243662 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium-long shot featuring an ancient scholar sitting on a moss-covered rock by a river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar wearing a loose blue-gray linen robe and has long hair pinned atop his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with a line lowering into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a morning mist with withered yellow reeds swaying gently and a murky dark green river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan leftward across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005957465618848801 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.13095760345459 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005957465618848801, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005957465618848801, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4081406891345978, + 0.07371366769075394, + 0.04570738598704338, + 0.05762317776679993, + 0.14659683406352997, + 0.07575484365224838, + 0.06318356841802597, + 0.05342224985361099, + 0.037284377962350845, + 0.03857317939400673 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005957465618848801 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium-long shot featuring an ancient scholar sitting on a moss-covered rock by a river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar wearing a loose blue-gray linen robe and has long hair pinned atop his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with a line lowering into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a morning mist with withered yellow reeds swaying gently and a murky dark green river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan leftward across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012540297582745552 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387540340423584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012540297582745552, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012540297582745552, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36938977241516113, + 0.04125156253576279, + 0.15588714182376862, + 0.01813654601573944, + 0.18167319893836975, + 0.06925211101770401, + 0.057787951081991196, + 0.03893846273422241, + 0.04815881699323654, + 0.01952449604868889 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012540297582745552 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium-long shot featuring an ancient scholar sitting on a moss-covered rock by a river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar wearing a loose blue-gray linen robe and has long hair pinned atop his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with a line lowering into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a morning mist with withered yellow reeds swaying gently and a murky dark green river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan leftward across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107639167457819 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110764503479 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107639167457819, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107639167457819, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32405325770378113, + 0.10770314186811447, + 0.0710049495100975, + 0.08114253729581833, + 0.056444860994815826, + 0.11494655907154083, + 0.07395397871732712, + 0.08090107887983322, + 0.039650529623031616, + 0.05019911378622055 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107639167457819 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium-long shot featuring an ancient scholar sitting on a moss-covered rock by a river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar wearing a loose blue-gray linen robe and has long hair pinned atop his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scholar holding a slender bamboo fishing rod with a line lowering into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a morning mist with withered yellow reeds swaying gently and a murky dark green river?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan leftward across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25207191705703735 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020718574523926 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25207191705703735, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25207191705703735, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1752779483795166, + 0.07660803943872452, + 0.03492753580212593, + 0.023072529584169388, + 0.2372303307056427, + 0.08825443685054779, + 0.12404361367225647, + 0.08245664089918137, + 0.14199557900428772, + 0.01613336242735386 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25207191705703735 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_11/index_tensor([4795, 4795])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_11/index_tensor([4795, 4795])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d5c2dd03ac6e0c78c4429c35c57f4d358b6b45f9 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_11/index_tensor([4795, 4795])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, handheld tracking shot, close to the ground, advances at a steady walking pace along a narrow dirt path through a Nordic pine forest, focusing squarely on a pair of weathered, dark brown leather hiking boots. As the camera pans, the boots rhythmically alternate their steps, each footfall firmly ground against the damp, golden and dark brown fallen leaves. The thick rubber tread of the soles is clearly visible, compacting the dead leaves and pine needles beneath their feet with a crisp, textured rustling sound. In a soft, shallow depth of field, the trunks of tall, upright Nordic pines slowly sweep backwards, their rough bark thickly coated with emerald green moss, a vibrant presence. Soft, golden morning sunlight penetrates the dense treetops, creating dappled shafts of light that illuminate the fine dust and mist hanging in the air, casting a warm, dreamy halo over the forest floor. There are no characters in the entire picture, only the continuous movement of footsteps, creating an extremely immersive hiking experience. The gradually increasing sound of the waterfall in the distance hints at the destination of the journey, giving this peaceful walk a clear sense of direction and an atmosphere full of anticipation.", + "seed": 27423, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_11/index_4795_seed_27423_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.01088323313742876, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01088323313742876, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01088323313742876, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pair of weathered, dark brown leather hiking boots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera advance steadily along a narrow dirt path through a Nordic pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the boots stepping on damp golden and dark brown fallen leaves with visible thick rubber treads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of tall Nordic pine trunks with rough bark coated in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.030287189409136772 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.530287265777588 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.030287189409136772, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.030287189409136772, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11260217428207397, + 0.03784665837883949, + 0.08553680032491684, + 0.04842343181371689, + 0.05491822585463524, + 0.043973904103040695, + 0.04558028280735016, + 0.3884890079498291, + 0.11673958599567413, + 0.06588993221521378 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.030287189409136772 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pair of weathered, dark brown leather hiking boots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera advance steadily along a narrow dirt path through a Nordic pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the boots stepping on damp golden and dark brown fallen leaves with visible thick rubber treads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of tall Nordic pine trunks with rough bark coated in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007641607895493507 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882641792297363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007641607895493507, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007641607895493507, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1833890676498413, + 0.05320056155323982, + 0.11154866963624954, + 0.03063889965415001, + 0.09161468595266342, + 0.15997521579265594, + 0.03747780993580818, + 0.2309158742427826, + 0.060135770589113235, + 0.041103508323431015 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007641607895493507 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pair of weathered, dark brown leather hiking boots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera advance steadily along a narrow dirt path through a Nordic pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the boots stepping on damp golden and dark brown fallen leaves with visible thick rubber treads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of tall Nordic pine trunks with rough bark coated in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005250118672847748 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255249977111816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005250118672847748, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005250118672847748, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21072667837142944, + 0.1388794183731079, + 0.1181640699505806, + 0.057252947241067886, + 0.12294192612171173, + 0.06533011049032211, + 0.04939844086766243, + 0.14069192111492157, + 0.05252077057957649, + 0.044093698263168335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005250118672847748 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pair of weathered, dark brown leather hiking boots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera advance steadily along a narrow dirt path through a Nordic pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the boots stepping on damp golden and dark brown fallen leaves with visible thick rubber treads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of tall Nordic pine trunks with rough bark coated in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003616936504840851 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628616809844971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003616936504840851, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003616936504840851, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1059512197971344, + 0.08500547707080841, + 0.09808715432882309, + 0.1423342078924179, + 0.09825757145881653, + 0.09565968066453934, + 0.03872618451714516, + 0.16609090566635132, + 0.0993385761976242, + 0.07054900377988815 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003616936504840851 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pair of weathered, dark brown leather hiking boots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera advance steadily along a narrow dirt path through a Nordic pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the boots stepping on damp golden and dark brown fallen leaves with visible thick rubber treads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of tall Nordic pine trunks with rough bark coated in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076203132048249245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882620334625244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076203132048249245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076203132048249245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16830740869045258, + 0.03958062827587128, + 0.0901763066649437, + 0.08301349729299545, + 0.17550058662891388, + 0.2485896348953247, + 0.0367305725812912, + 0.06791728734970093, + 0.05694691091775894, + 0.033237162977457047 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076203132048249245 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, handheld tracking shot, close to the ground, advances at a steady walking pace along a narrow dirt path through a Nordic pine forest, focusing squarely on a pair of weathered, dark brown leather hiking boots. As the camera pans, the boots rhythmically alternate their steps, each footfall firmly ground against the damp, golden and dark brown fallen leaves. The thick rubber tread of the soles is clearly visible, compacting the dead leaves and pine needles beneath their feet with a crisp, textured rustling sound. In a soft, shallow depth of field, the trunks of tall, upright Nordic pines slowly sweep backwards, their rough bark thickly coated with emerald green moss, a vibrant presence. Soft, golden morning sunlight penetrates the dense treetops, creating dappled shafts of light that illuminate the fine dust and mist hanging in the air, casting a warm, dreamy halo over the forest floor. There are no characters in the entire picture, only the continuous movement of footsteps, creating an extremely immersive hiking experience. The gradually increasing sound of the waterfall in the distance hints at the destination of the journey, giving this peaceful walk a clear sense of direction and an atmosphere full of anticipation.", + "seed": 27424, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_11/index_4795_seed_27424_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.005142359924502671, + "vlm_logprob": -0.005142359924502671, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.005142359924502671, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pair of weathered, dark brown leather hiking boots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera advance steadily along a narrow dirt path through a Nordic pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the boots stepping on damp golden and dark brown fallen leaves with visible thick rubber treads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of tall Nordic pine trunks with rough bark coated in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012928945943713188 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3879289627075195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012928945943713188, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012928945943713188, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08746447414159775, + 0.03301508352160454, + 0.03757285699248314, + 0.04262978211045265, + 0.21410810947418213, + 0.1642090231180191, + 0.28064414858818054, + 0.03117068111896515, + 0.03207578510046005, + 0.07711006700992584 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012928945943713188 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pair of weathered, dark brown leather hiking boots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera advance steadily along a narrow dirt path through a Nordic pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the boots stepping on damp golden and dark brown fallen leaves with visible thick rubber treads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of tall Nordic pine trunks with rough bark coated in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028318562544882298 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877831935882568 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028318562544882298, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028318562544882298, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1090666726231575, + 0.04892057925462723, + 0.0481945276260376, + 0.06747423857450485, + 0.26107385754585266, + 0.11318763345479965, + 0.22137784957885742, + 0.06249946728348732, + 0.022593824192881584, + 0.04561133310198784 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028318562544882298 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pair of weathered, dark brown leather hiking boots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera advance steadily along a narrow dirt path through a Nordic pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the boots stepping on damp golden and dark brown fallen leaves with visible thick rubber treads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of tall Nordic pine trunks with rough bark coated in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031916177831590176 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531914710998535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031916177831590176, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031916177831590176, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12906917929649353, + 0.10344593971967697, + 0.0786442905664444, + 0.06844981759786606, + 0.12803220748901367, + 0.18429848551750183, + 0.1860969513654709, + 0.058800093829631805, + 0.016209358349442482, + 0.04695367440581322 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031916177831590176 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pair of weathered, dark brown leather hiking boots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera advance steadily along a narrow dirt path through a Nordic pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the boots stepping on damp golden and dark brown fallen leaves with visible thick rubber treads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of tall Nordic pine trunks with rough bark coated in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015143604250624776 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501514434814453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015143604250624776, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015143604250624776, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05026813969016075, + 0.052263181656599045, + 0.04167470708489418, + 0.028019659221172333, + 0.21001197397708893, + 0.20590563118457794, + 0.28627124428749084, + 0.052699536085128784, + 0.01411730982363224, + 0.05876855552196503 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015143604250624776 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pair of weathered, dark brown leather hiking boots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera advance steadily along a narrow dirt path through a Nordic pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the boots stepping on damp golden and dark brown fallen leaves with visible thick rubber treads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of tall Nordic pine trunks with rough bark coated in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005245019216090441 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255245208740234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005245019216090441, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005245019216090441, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09775055199861526, + 0.06456227600574493, + 0.015773296356201172, + 0.016063062474131584, + 0.6269363164901733, + 0.05570393428206444, + 0.08756495267152786, + 0.01394561305642128, + 0.008627137169241905, + 0.013072894886136055 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005245019216090441 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, handheld tracking shot, close to the ground, advances at a steady walking pace along a narrow dirt path through a Nordic pine forest, focusing squarely on a pair of weathered, dark brown leather hiking boots. As the camera pans, the boots rhythmically alternate their steps, each footfall firmly ground against the damp, golden and dark brown fallen leaves. The thick rubber tread of the soles is clearly visible, compacting the dead leaves and pine needles beneath their feet with a crisp, textured rustling sound. In a soft, shallow depth of field, the trunks of tall, upright Nordic pines slowly sweep backwards, their rough bark thickly coated with emerald green moss, a vibrant presence. Soft, golden morning sunlight penetrates the dense treetops, creating dappled shafts of light that illuminate the fine dust and mist hanging in the air, casting a warm, dreamy halo over the forest floor. There are no characters in the entire picture, only the continuous movement of footsteps, creating an extremely immersive hiking experience. The gradually increasing sound of the waterfall in the distance hints at the destination of the journey, giving this peaceful walk a clear sense of direction and an atmosphere full of anticipation.", + "seed": 27425, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_11/index_4795_seed_27425_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.007158007123507559, + "vlm_logprob": -0.007158007123507559, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.007158007123507559, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pair of weathered, dark brown leather hiking boots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera advance steadily along a narrow dirt path through a Nordic pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the boots stepping on damp golden and dark brown fallen leaves with visible thick rubber treads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of tall Nordic pine trunks with rough bark coated in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018902640789747238 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018902778625488 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018902640789747238, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018902640789747238, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15241014957427979, + 0.047209084033966064, + 0.046634241938591, + 0.08158665895462036, + 0.1755034625530243, + 0.16734205186367035, + 0.06707392632961273, + 0.07224530726671219, + 0.03309175372123718, + 0.15690334141254425 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018902640789747238 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pair of weathered, dark brown leather hiking boots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera advance steadily along a narrow dirt path through a Nordic pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the boots stepping on damp golden and dark brown fallen leaves with visible thick rubber treads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of tall Nordic pine trunks with rough bark coated in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005267550237476826 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.25526762008667 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005267550237476826, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005267550237476826, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07166393101215363, + 0.2126685380935669, + 0.05957984924316406, + 0.08700431138277054, + 0.2796325385570526, + 0.054187238216400146, + 0.06416873633861542, + 0.01724439114332199, + 0.056586768478155136, + 0.09726365655660629 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005267550237476826 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pair of weathered, dark brown leather hiking boots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera advance steadily along a narrow dirt path through a Nordic pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the boots stepping on damp golden and dark brown fallen leaves with visible thick rubber treads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of tall Nordic pine trunks with rough bark coated in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002487067598849535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.0024871826171875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002487067598849535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002487067598849535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08345910906791687, + 0.09970474988222122, + 0.05557288974523544, + 0.07061013579368591, + 0.12344086170196533, + 0.0474407933652401, + 0.188431516289711, + 0.032590385526418686, + 0.08493674546480179, + 0.21381288766860962 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002487067598849535 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pair of weathered, dark brown leather hiking boots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera advance steadily along a narrow dirt path through a Nordic pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the boots stepping on damp golden and dark brown fallen leaves with visible thick rubber treads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of tall Nordic pine trunks with rough bark coated in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015137653099372983 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501513957977295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015137653099372983, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015137653099372983, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11992187798023224, + 0.041809286922216415, + 0.0792541429400444, + 0.1289306879043579, + 0.23734459280967712, + 0.047851867973804474, + 0.07799338549375534, + 0.037237271666526794, + 0.0837259516119957, + 0.14593102037906647 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015137653099372983 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pair of weathered, dark brown leather hiking boots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera advance steadily along a narrow dirt path through a Nordic pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the boots stepping on damp golden and dark brown fallen leaves with visible thick rubber treads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of tall Nordic pine trunks with rough bark coated in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007619011681526899 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826189041137695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007619011681526899, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007619011681526899, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0930674746632576, + 0.07686161994934082, + 0.049411334097385406, + 0.021534567698836327, + 0.06874210387468338, + 0.1201748177409172, + 0.1116403192281723, + 0.03355198726058006, + 0.08531445264816284, + 0.3397012948989868 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007619011681526899 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, handheld tracking shot, close to the ground, advances at a steady walking pace along a narrow dirt path through a Nordic pine forest, focusing squarely on a pair of weathered, dark brown leather hiking boots. As the camera pans, the boots rhythmically alternate their steps, each footfall firmly ground against the damp, golden and dark brown fallen leaves. The thick rubber tread of the soles is clearly visible, compacting the dead leaves and pine needles beneath their feet with a crisp, textured rustling sound. In a soft, shallow depth of field, the trunks of tall, upright Nordic pines slowly sweep backwards, their rough bark thickly coated with emerald green moss, a vibrant presence. Soft, golden morning sunlight penetrates the dense treetops, creating dappled shafts of light that illuminate the fine dust and mist hanging in the air, casting a warm, dreamy halo over the forest floor. There are no characters in the entire picture, only the continuous movement of footsteps, creating an extremely immersive hiking experience. The gradually increasing sound of the waterfall in the distance hints at the destination of the journey, giving this peaceful walk a clear sense of direction and an atmosphere full of anticipation.", + "seed": 27426, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_11/index_4795_seed_27426_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.004445424722507596, + "vlm_logprob": -0.004445424722507596, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.004445424722507596, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pair of weathered, dark brown leather hiking boots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera advance steadily along a narrow dirt path through a Nordic pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the boots stepping on damp golden and dark brown fallen leaves with visible thick rubber treads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of tall Nordic pine trunks with rough bark coated in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010276736691594124 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.635276794433594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010276736691594124, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010276736691594124, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07452353090047836, + 0.04915152117609978, + 0.07524238526821136, + 0.3025752305984497, + 0.03953336924314499, + 0.06141529604792595, + 0.07250455021858215, + 0.1686723530292511, + 0.07041167467832565, + 0.08597008138895035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010276736691594124 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pair of weathered, dark brown leather hiking boots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera advance steadily along a narrow dirt path through a Nordic pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the boots stepping on damp golden and dark brown fallen leaves with visible thick rubber treads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of tall Nordic pine trunks with rough bark coated in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004107847809791565 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.50410795211792 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004107847809791565, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004107847809791565, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13153155148029327, + 0.06455392390489578, + 0.07658398151397705, + 0.2797953486442566, + 0.09573111683130264, + 0.05453881248831749, + 0.055370211601257324, + 0.06921371817588806, + 0.07032670080661774, + 0.10235463082790375 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004107847809791565 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pair of weathered, dark brown leather hiking boots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera advance steadily along a narrow dirt path through a Nordic pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the boots stepping on damp golden and dark brown fallen leaves with visible thick rubber treads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of tall Nordic pine trunks with rough bark coated in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003190310439094901 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753190517425537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003190310439094901, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003190310439094901, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08597935736179352, + 0.15999506413936615, + 0.10341127961874008, + 0.1319618970155716, + 0.045992519706487656, + 0.04806981608271599, + 0.07672937959432602, + 0.19163668155670166, + 0.06576267629861832, + 0.09046133607625961 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003190310439094901 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pair of weathered, dark brown leather hiking boots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera advance steadily along a narrow dirt path through a Nordic pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the boots stepping on damp golden and dark brown fallen leaves with visible thick rubber treads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of tall Nordic pine trunks with rough bark coated in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010425376240164042 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876042366027832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010425376240164042, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010425376240164042, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09604116529226303, + 0.08974041044712067, + 0.08049984276294708, + 0.2166440188884735, + 0.05883338674902916, + 0.12606917321681976, + 0.0332317017018795, + 0.11338189244270325, + 0.08311893045902252, + 0.10243941843509674 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010425376240164042 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pair of weathered, dark brown leather hiking boots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle close to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera advance steadily along a narrow dirt path through a Nordic pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the boots stepping on damp golden and dark brown fallen leaves with visible thick rubber treads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of tall Nordic pine trunks with rough bark coated in emerald green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003609691048040986 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628609657287598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003609691048040986, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003609691048040986, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10801795870065689, + 0.08528786897659302, + 0.11335720866918564, + 0.0462789461016655, + 0.12671804428100586, + 0.04465878754854202, + 0.11011313647031784, + 0.2049814760684967, + 0.1010432168841362, + 0.059543389827013016 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003609691048040986 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_12/index_tensor([537, 537])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_12/index_tensor([537, 537])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3de9be5360ce30e4b888989b1bd73b1103bb79c1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_12/index_tensor([537, 537])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a scene crafted in a crisp, minimalist animation style, a steady, horizontal medium shot captures a vintage, beige cathode-ray tube television. It hovers in mid-air, set against a pure, soft, solid-color backdrop. Evenly lit, it eliminates all complex shadows, highlighting its contours. The television boasts the era's signature bulky form and slightly worn plastic casing, its iconic curved glass screen facing the viewer. It rotates steadily and deliberately around its vertical axis, its movements fluid and elegant. Meanwhile, the screen flashes with a frenzy of black and white, a staticky, noisy display. These bouncing dots contrast sharply with the steady rotation of the television, creating a surreal sense of nostalgia and a minimalist aesthetic.", + "seed": 12603, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_12/index_537_seed_12603_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06681945202872157, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06681945202872157, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06681945202872157, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage, beige cathode-ray tube television with a bulky form and slightly worn plastic casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the television hovering in mid-air against a pure, soft, solid-color backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a crisp, minimalist animation style with even lighting and no complex shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the television rotate steadily and deliberately around its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the television screen display a frenzy of black and white static with bouncing dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2529154121875763 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502915382385254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2529154121875763, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2529154121875763, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36858078837394714, + 0.035055410116910934, + 0.054532166570425034, + 0.07855524122714996, + 0.040594104677438736, + 0.09662159532308578, + 0.1336967647075653, + 0.10552337020635605, + 0.036675773561000824, + 0.05016479641199112 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2529154121875763 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage, beige cathode-ray tube television with a bulky form and slightly worn plastic casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the television hovering in mid-air against a pure, soft, solid-color backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a crisp, minimalist animation style with even lighting and no complex shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the television rotate steadily and deliberately around its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the television screen display a frenzy of black and white static with bouncing dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062056127935647964 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812056064605713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062056127935647964, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062056127935647964, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2292935699224472, + 0.07227105647325516, + 0.18236546218395233, + 0.11307527869939804, + 0.05851191654801369, + 0.11843358725309372, + 0.0577574223279953, + 0.07325690984725952, + 0.02516537345945835, + 0.06986946612596512 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062056127935647964 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage, beige cathode-ray tube television with a bulky form and slightly worn plastic casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the television hovering in mid-air against a pure, soft, solid-color backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a crisp, minimalist animation style with even lighting and no complex shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the television rotate steadily and deliberately around its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the television screen display a frenzy of black and white static with bouncing dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978152547031641 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634781360626221 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978152547031641, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978152547031641, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3491996228694916, + 0.039082061499357224, + 0.1550634205341339, + 0.08241447806358337, + 0.02904529869556427, + 0.09884852170944214, + 0.08418309688568115, + 0.09811920672655106, + 0.02232513576745987, + 0.0417192168533802 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978152547031641 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage, beige cathode-ray tube television with a bulky form and slightly worn plastic casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the television hovering in mid-air against a pure, soft, solid-color backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a crisp, minimalist animation style with even lighting and no complex shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the television rotate steadily and deliberately around its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the television screen display a frenzy of black and white static with bouncing dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040937201119959354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504093647003174 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040937201119959354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040937201119959354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28170788288116455, + 0.06052383407950401, + 0.07219477742910385, + 0.07107408344745636, + 0.08030147105455399, + 0.09263670444488525, + 0.13385508954524994, + 0.08707734942436218, + 0.05130600929260254, + 0.06932282447814941 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040937201119959354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage, beige cathode-ray tube television with a bulky form and slightly worn plastic casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the television hovering in mid-air against a pure, soft, solid-color backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a crisp, minimalist animation style with even lighting and no complex shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the television rotate steadily and deliberately around its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the television screen display a frenzy of black and white static with bouncing dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005250474438071251 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255250453948975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005250474438071251, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005250474438071251, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3059076964855194, + 0.03685040771961212, + 0.2014913707971573, + 0.07506707310676575, + 0.046363066881895065, + 0.05632263794541359, + 0.07878406345844269, + 0.1193736121058464, + 0.018833180889487267, + 0.06100691109895706 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005250474438071251 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a scene crafted in a crisp, minimalist animation style, a steady, horizontal medium shot captures a vintage, beige cathode-ray tube television. It hovers in mid-air, set against a pure, soft, solid-color backdrop. Evenly lit, it eliminates all complex shadows, highlighting its contours. The television boasts the era's signature bulky form and slightly worn plastic casing, its iconic curved glass screen facing the viewer. It rotates steadily and deliberately around its vertical axis, its movements fluid and elegant. Meanwhile, the screen flashes with a frenzy of black and white, a staticky, noisy display. These bouncing dots contrast sharply with the steady rotation of the television, creating a surreal sense of nostalgia and a minimalist aesthetic.", + "seed": 12604, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_12/index_537_seed_12604_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.01939235357567668, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01939235357567668, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01939235357567668, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage, beige cathode-ray tube television with a bulky form and slightly worn plastic casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the television hovering in mid-air against a pure, soft, solid-color backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a crisp, minimalist animation style with even lighting and no complex shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the television rotate steadily and deliberately around its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the television screen display a frenzy of black and white static with bouncing dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009263982996344566 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75926399230957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009263982996344566, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009263982996344566, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2103736847639084, + 0.2536904513835907, + 0.14370369911193848, + 0.06377092003822327, + 0.06966234743595123, + 0.06524908542633057, + 0.06422365456819534, + 0.03609492629766464, + 0.027181923389434814, + 0.06604929268360138 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009263982996344566 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage, beige cathode-ray tube television with a bulky form and slightly worn plastic casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the television hovering in mid-air against a pure, soft, solid-color backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a crisp, minimalist animation style with even lighting and no complex shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the television rotate steadily and deliberately around its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the television screen display a frenzy of black and white static with bouncing dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062044475227594376 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812044382095337 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062044475227594376, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062044475227594376, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1217508316040039, + 0.13775429129600525, + 0.08539049327373505, + 0.06827189773321152, + 0.21667063236236572, + 0.08711095154285431, + 0.05439181625843048, + 0.02325298823416233, + 0.09491182118654251, + 0.11049428582191467 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062044475227594376 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage, beige cathode-ray tube television with a bulky form and slightly worn plastic casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the television hovering in mid-air against a pure, soft, solid-color backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a crisp, minimalist animation style with even lighting and no complex shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the television rotate steadily and deliberately around its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the television screen display a frenzy of black and white static with bouncing dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107415184378624 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511074066162109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107415184378624, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107415184378624, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1231418251991272, + 0.2612628936767578, + 0.08422486484050751, + 0.10015750676393509, + 0.12084529548883438, + 0.058440037071704865, + 0.04760304465889931, + 0.03182420879602432, + 0.059636350721120834, + 0.11286399513483047 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107415184378624 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage, beige cathode-ray tube television with a bulky form and slightly worn plastic casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the television hovering in mid-air against a pure, soft, solid-color backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a crisp, minimalist animation style with even lighting and no complex shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the television rotate steadily and deliberately around its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the television screen display a frenzy of black and white static with bouncing dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059431265108287334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130943298339844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059431265108287334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059431265108287334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14059284329414368, + 0.08174029737710953, + 0.2217096984386444, + 0.062441520392894745, + 0.04591941088438034, + 0.19214482605457306, + 0.08753261715173721, + 0.03666578233242035, + 0.1020042821764946, + 0.029248744249343872 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059431265108287334 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage, beige cathode-ray tube television with a bulky form and slightly worn plastic casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the television hovering in mid-air against a pure, soft, solid-color backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a crisp, minimalist animation style with even lighting and no complex shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the television rotate steadily and deliberately around its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the television screen display a frenzy of black and white static with bouncing dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008636031299829483 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758635997772217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008636031299829483, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008636031299829483, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1406412571668625, + 0.0801924541592598, + 0.10278796404600143, + 0.08627264201641083, + 0.08511427044868469, + 0.1415332704782486, + 0.08923107385635376, + 0.1103595569729805, + 0.08529508113861084, + 0.07857238501310349 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008636031299829483 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a scene crafted in a crisp, minimalist animation style, a steady, horizontal medium shot captures a vintage, beige cathode-ray tube television. It hovers in mid-air, set against a pure, soft, solid-color backdrop. Evenly lit, it eliminates all complex shadows, highlighting its contours. The television boasts the era's signature bulky form and slightly worn plastic casing, its iconic curved glass screen facing the viewer. It rotates steadily and deliberately around its vertical axis, its movements fluid and elegant. Meanwhile, the screen flashes with a frenzy of black and white, a staticky, noisy display. These bouncing dots contrast sharply with the steady rotation of the television, creating a surreal sense of nostalgia and a minimalist aesthetic.", + "seed": 12605, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_12/index_537_seed_12605_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03286289654206485, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03286289654206485, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.849999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03286289654206485, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage, beige cathode-ray tube television with a bulky form and slightly worn plastic casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the television hovering in mid-air against a pure, soft, solid-color backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a crisp, minimalist animation style with even lighting and no complex shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the television rotate steadily and deliberately around its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the television screen display a frenzy of black and white static with bouncing dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0034474246203899384 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.878447532653809 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0034474246203899384, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0034474246203899384, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17248381674289703, + 0.06176040321588516, + 0.05661488324403763, + 0.06298227608203888, + 0.11744965612888336, + 0.21701331436634064, + 0.07787041366100311, + 0.041831936687231064, + 0.1473294347524643, + 0.044663820415735245 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0034474246203899384 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage, beige cathode-ray tube television with a bulky form and slightly worn plastic casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the television hovering in mid-air against a pure, soft, solid-color backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a crisp, minimalist animation style with even lighting and no complex shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the television rotate steadily and deliberately around its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the television screen display a frenzy of black and white static with bouncing dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14280830323696136 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017808198928833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14280830323696136, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14280830323696136, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14276953041553497, + 0.016396306455135345, + 0.07815961539745331, + 0.01765388622879982, + 0.045233890414237976, + 0.03182653710246086, + 0.041629113256931305, + 0.10050486028194427, + 0.23093757033348083, + 0.2948887348175049 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14280830323696136 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage, beige cathode-ray tube television with a bulky form and slightly worn plastic casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the television hovering in mid-air against a pure, soft, solid-color backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a crisp, minimalist animation style with even lighting and no complex shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the television rotate steadily and deliberately around its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the television screen display a frenzy of black and white static with bouncing dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005946681834757328 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130946636199951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005946681834757328, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005946681834757328, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1480201631784439, + 0.10959575325250626, + 0.0364869087934494, + 0.038280464708805084, + 0.04825923964381218, + 0.036971915513277054, + 0.09085986763238907, + 0.04484638571739197, + 0.38533511757850647, + 0.061344146728515625 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005946681834757328 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage, beige cathode-ray tube television with a bulky form and slightly worn plastic casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the television hovering in mid-air against a pure, soft, solid-color backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a crisp, minimalist animation style with even lighting and no complex shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the television rotate steadily and deliberately around its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the television screen display a frenzy of black and white static with bouncing dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011071440763771534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51107120513916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011071440763771534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011071440763771534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36285433173179626, + 0.06876149773597717, + 0.13596418499946594, + 0.03179376572370529, + 0.07278130203485489, + 0.08856641501188278, + 0.03621499612927437, + 0.10747110098600388, + 0.06260509788990021, + 0.03298727795481682 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011071440763771534 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage, beige cathode-ray tube television with a bulky form and slightly worn plastic casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the television hovering in mid-air against a pure, soft, solid-color backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a crisp, minimalist animation style with even lighting and no complex shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the television rotate steadily and deliberately around its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the television screen display a frenzy of black and white static with bouncing dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010406322544440627 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876040458679199 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010406322544440627, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010406322544440627, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07634095847606659, + 0.03487706929445267, + 0.05456282198429108, + 0.021075982600450516, + 0.07990799844264984, + 0.054667048156261444, + 0.04471677914261818, + 0.02056513912975788, + 0.5858785510063171, + 0.027407754212617874 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010406322544440627 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a scene crafted in a crisp, minimalist animation style, a steady, horizontal medium shot captures a vintage, beige cathode-ray tube television. It hovers in mid-air, set against a pure, soft, solid-color backdrop. Evenly lit, it eliminates all complex shadows, highlighting its contours. The television boasts the era's signature bulky form and slightly worn plastic casing, its iconic curved glass screen facing the viewer. It rotates steadily and deliberately around its vertical axis, its movements fluid and elegant. Meanwhile, the screen flashes with a frenzy of black and white, a staticky, noisy display. These bouncing dots contrast sharply with the steady rotation of the television, creating a surreal sense of nostalgia and a minimalist aesthetic.", + "seed": 12606, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_12/index_537_seed_12606_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.019068101327866314, + "vlm_logprob": -0.019068101327866314, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.019068101327866314, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage, beige cathode-ray tube television with a bulky form and slightly worn plastic casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the television hovering in mid-air against a pure, soft, solid-color backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a crisp, minimalist animation style with even lighting and no complex shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the television rotate steadily and deliberately around its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the television screen display a frenzy of black and white static with bouncing dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004904857836663723 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379904747009277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004904857836663723, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004904857836663723, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14110901951789856, + 0.1989288181066513, + 0.06420984119176865, + 0.06575100868940353, + 0.06779691576957703, + 0.14193570613861084, + 0.1758730411529541, + 0.045892052352428436, + 0.04756375402212143, + 0.050939783453941345 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004904857836663723 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage, beige cathode-ray tube television with a bulky form and slightly worn plastic casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the television hovering in mid-air against a pure, soft, solid-color backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a crisp, minimalist animation style with even lighting and no complex shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the television rotate steadily and deliberately around its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the television screen display a frenzy of black and white static with bouncing dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011078395880758762 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511078357696533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011078395880758762, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011078395880758762, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14239326119422913, + 0.13173870742321014, + 0.315589040517807, + 0.08983316272497177, + 0.027946652844548225, + 0.025060337036848068, + 0.1980430632829666, + 0.008982370607554913, + 0.03729681670665741, + 0.023116642609238625 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011078395880758762 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage, beige cathode-ray tube television with a bulky form and slightly worn plastic casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the television hovering in mid-air against a pure, soft, solid-color backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a crisp, minimalist animation style with even lighting and no complex shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the television rotate steadily and deliberately around its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the television screen display a frenzy of black and white static with bouncing dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00525154173374176 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255251407623291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00525154173374176, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00525154173374176, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1687166392803192, + 0.048344507813453674, + 0.19785618782043457, + 0.07137459516525269, + 0.0347755141556263, + 0.08469446748495102, + 0.24599303305149078, + 0.03872637078166008, + 0.061887022107839584, + 0.04763168841600418 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00525154173374176 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage, beige cathode-ray tube television with a bulky form and slightly worn plastic casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the television hovering in mid-air against a pure, soft, solid-color backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a crisp, minimalist animation style with even lighting and no complex shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the television rotate steadily and deliberately around its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the television screen display a frenzy of black and white static with bouncing dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004093007650226355 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504093170166016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004093007650226355, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004093007650226355, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12892650067806244, + 0.03998303413391113, + 0.14173026382923126, + 0.04186851531267166, + 0.0689416453242302, + 0.1724288910627365, + 0.14534075558185577, + 0.06385055929422379, + 0.1503385454416275, + 0.046591244637966156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004093007650226355 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage, beige cathode-ray tube television with a bulky form and slightly worn plastic casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the television hovering in mid-air against a pure, soft, solid-color backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a crisp, minimalist animation style with even lighting and no complex shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the television rotate steadily and deliberately around its vertical axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the television screen display a frenzy of black and white static with bouncing dots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07001270353794098 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950128078460693 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07001270353794098, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07001270353794098, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03741023316979408, + 0.24875670671463013, + 0.08787534385919571, + 0.03030690923333168, + 0.03937608748674393, + 0.16188880801200867, + 0.17270664870738983, + 0.021573398262262344, + 0.12560704350471497, + 0.07449887692928314 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07001270353794098 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_13/index_tensor([2006, 2006])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_13/index_tensor([2006, 2006])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ad3abd337418973f264acaf2d1ed53e889dffd37 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_13/index_tensor([2006, 2006])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slowly tilting downward shot begins with a close-up of the water's reflection. The surface, like a deep black jade, perfectly reflects a classical woman clad in pale pink silk Hanfu. Her hair, styled in an exquisitely ancient bun, is as black as ink, and her face, serene yet slightly melancholic, is so clear in the reflection that it seems almost tangible. Suddenly, her reflection begins to tremble slightly, then silently shatters like fine porcelain, the entire image disintegrating into thousands of fluttering peach petals, forming a dazzling yet sorrowful vortex within the water's reflection. At this moment, a real-life white jade hairpin, delicately carved with a lotus flower and tied with a red silk ribbon, slips silently from outside the frame, plunging into the water with a graceful arc and a soft, gentle plop, shattering the tranquility of the surface and sending ripples spreading outward. Then, from the depths of the pond, a massive koi, covered in metallic golden scales, calmly emerged, gleaming in the soft evening light. The koi gracefully swam toward the slowly sinking hairpin, carefully catching it in its mouth. With a single, swift turn, its magnificent tail fin swayed, and, carrying the hairpin, a symbol of womanhood's final remnant, it calmly and resolutely swam into the dark depths, leaving behind only the swirling reflections of petals, creating a scene of exquisite oriental classical aesthetics and a dreamlike, poetic atmosphere.", + "seed": 13143, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_13/index_2006_seed_13143_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.11274279598146678, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11274279598146678, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11274279598146678, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a water surface reflecting a classical woman in pale pink silk Hanfu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's reflection in the water tremble and shatter into thousands of fluttering peach petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white jade hairpin with a lotus carving and red silk ribbon slip into the water and sink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive koi with metallic golden scales emerge from the water, catch the hairpin in its mouth, and swim into the depths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video start with a camera shot that slowly tilts downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3495461642742157 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.224546194076538 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3495461642742157, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3495461642742157, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2412736564874649, + 0.18872147798538208, + 0.03636026382446289, + 0.05371659994125366, + 0.09512611478567123, + 0.033411428332328796, + 0.13484905660152435, + 0.12095002830028534, + 0.03797493875026703, + 0.05761643499135971 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3495461642742157 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a water surface reflecting a classical woman in pale pink silk Hanfu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's reflection in the water tremble and shatter into thousands of fluttering peach petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white jade hairpin with a lotus carving and red silk ribbon slip into the water and sink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive koi with metallic golden scales emerge from the water, catch the hairpin in its mouth, and swim into the depths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video start with a camera shot that slowly tilts downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10037167370319366 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503715991973877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10037167370319366, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10037167370319366, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10618678480386734, + 0.1785016804933548, + 0.0692681223154068, + 0.08347536623477936, + 0.0960698351264, + 0.03502853959798813, + 0.14553573727607727, + 0.07199525088071823, + 0.11999527364969254, + 0.09394343942403793 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10037167370319366 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a water surface reflecting a classical woman in pale pink silk Hanfu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's reflection in the water tremble and shatter into thousands of fluttering peach petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white jade hairpin with a lotus carving and red silk ribbon slip into the water and sink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive koi with metallic golden scales emerge from the water, catch the hairpin in its mouth, and swim into the depths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video start with a camera shot that slowly tilts downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309605807065964 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680960655212402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309605807065964, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309605807065964, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06154084578156471, + 0.06880345195531845, + 0.06180937588214874, + 0.08210879564285278, + 0.11285412311553955, + 0.05020750313997269, + 0.17333084344863892, + 0.1614512801170349, + 0.12146592885255814, + 0.10642780363559723 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309605807065964 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a water surface reflecting a classical woman in pale pink silk Hanfu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's reflection in the water tremble and shatter into thousands of fluttering peach petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white jade hairpin with a lotus carving and red silk ribbon slip into the water and sink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive koi with metallic golden scales emerge from the water, catch the hairpin in its mouth, and swim into the depths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video start with a camera shot that slowly tilts downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008650568313896656 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758650779724121 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008650568313896656, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008650568313896656, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05506231635808945, + 0.051307909190654755, + 0.03142791613936424, + 0.03206051141023636, + 0.050707001239061356, + 0.030022474005818367, + 0.16969037055969238, + 0.11211758106946945, + 0.34641069173812866, + 0.12119321525096893 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008650568313896656 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a water surface reflecting a classical woman in pale pink silk Hanfu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's reflection in the water tremble and shatter into thousands of fluttering peach petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white jade hairpin with a lotus carving and red silk ribbon slip into the water and sink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive koi with metallic golden scales emerge from the water, catch the hairpin in its mouth, and swim into the depths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video start with a camera shot that slowly tilts downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062049515545368195 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812049627304077 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062049515545368195, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062049515545368195, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08309265971183777, + 0.04678505286574364, + 0.0452004075050354, + 0.06280305981636047, + 0.07015529274940491, + 0.03919953480362892, + 0.29754430055618286, + 0.31825360655784607, + 0.022935936227440834, + 0.014030192978680134 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062049515545368195 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly tilting downward shot begins with a close-up of the water's reflection. The surface, like a deep black jade, perfectly reflects a classical woman clad in pale pink silk Hanfu. Her hair, styled in an exquisitely ancient bun, is as black as ink, and her face, serene yet slightly melancholic, is so clear in the reflection that it seems almost tangible. Suddenly, her reflection begins to tremble slightly, then silently shatters like fine porcelain, the entire image disintegrating into thousands of fluttering peach petals, forming a dazzling yet sorrowful vortex within the water's reflection. At this moment, a real-life white jade hairpin, delicately carved with a lotus flower and tied with a red silk ribbon, slips silently from outside the frame, plunging into the water with a graceful arc and a soft, gentle plop, shattering the tranquility of the surface and sending ripples spreading outward. Then, from the depths of the pond, a massive koi, covered in metallic golden scales, calmly emerged, gleaming in the soft evening light. The koi gracefully swam toward the slowly sinking hairpin, carefully catching it in its mouth. With a single, swift turn, its magnificent tail fin swayed, and, carrying the hairpin, a symbol of womanhood's final remnant, it calmly and resolutely swam into the dark depths, leaving behind only the swirling reflections of petals, creating a scene of exquisite oriental classical aesthetics and a dreamlike, poetic atmosphere.", + "seed": 13144, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_13/index_2006_seed_13144_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.032387422025203706, + "vlm_logprob": -0.032387422025203706, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.032387422025203706, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a water surface reflecting a classical woman in pale pink silk Hanfu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's reflection in the water tremble and shatter into thousands of fluttering peach petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white jade hairpin with a lotus carving and red silk ribbon slip into the water and sink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive koi with metallic golden scales emerge from the water, catch the hairpin in its mouth, and swim into the depths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video start with a camera shot that slowly tilts downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05711511895060539 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.932115077972412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05711511895060539, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05711511895060539, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.520844042301178, + 0.05223292112350464, + 0.04984811320900917, + 0.05322475731372833, + 0.018722249194979668, + 0.027194324880838394, + 0.20508316159248352, + 0.01473684050142765, + 0.04193266108632088, + 0.016180971637368202 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05711511895060539 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a water surface reflecting a classical woman in pale pink silk Hanfu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's reflection in the water tremble and shatter into thousands of fluttering peach petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white jade hairpin with a lotus carving and red silk ribbon slip into the water and sink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive koi with metallic golden scales emerge from the water, catch the hairpin in its mouth, and swim into the depths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video start with a camera shot that slowly tilts downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020608466118574142 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895608425140381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020608466118574142, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020608466118574142, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25671759247779846, + 0.062032848596572876, + 0.09320530295372009, + 0.2410765290260315, + 0.06541389226913452, + 0.03953663632273674, + 0.1405075639486313, + 0.029053039848804474, + 0.04130702093243599, + 0.03114958666265011 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020608466118574142 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a water surface reflecting a classical woman in pale pink silk Hanfu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's reflection in the water tremble and shatter into thousands of fluttering peach petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white jade hairpin with a lotus carving and red silk ribbon slip into the water and sink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive koi with metallic golden scales emerge from the water, catch the hairpin in its mouth, and swim into the depths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video start with a camera shot that slowly tilts downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023305892944335938 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773305892944336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023305892944335938, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023305892944335938, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10100212693214417, + 0.13527131080627441, + 0.10565799474716187, + 0.08884367346763611, + 0.29089802503585815, + 0.1014954149723053, + 0.05644545331597328, + 0.02308317832648754, + 0.07076127082109451, + 0.026541583240032196 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023305892944335938 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a water surface reflecting a classical woman in pale pink silk Hanfu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's reflection in the water tremble and shatter into thousands of fluttering peach petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white jade hairpin with a lotus carving and red silk ribbon slip into the water and sink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive koi with metallic golden scales emerge from the water, catch the hairpin in its mouth, and swim into the depths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video start with a camera shot that slowly tilts downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005953673273324966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130953788757324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005953673273324966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005953673273324966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1210506483912468, + 0.06552234292030334, + 0.03778591379523277, + 0.06921152770519257, + 0.10217615962028503, + 0.05964025855064392, + 0.19113922119140625, + 0.0864327996969223, + 0.20533284544944763, + 0.06170835345983505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005953673273324966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a water surface reflecting a classical woman in pale pink silk Hanfu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's reflection in the water tremble and shatter into thousands of fluttering peach petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white jade hairpin with a lotus carving and red silk ribbon slip into the water and sink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive koi with metallic golden scales emerge from the water, catch the hairpin in its mouth, and swim into the depths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video start with a camera shot that slowly tilts downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054953958839178085 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299540519714355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054953958839178085, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054953958839178085, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.131832093000412, + 0.09830071777105331, + 0.08499614894390106, + 0.13760891556739807, + 0.06400683522224426, + 0.07670609652996063, + 0.33426782488822937, + 0.02042573131620884, + 0.028665898367762566, + 0.023189682513475418 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054953958839178085 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly tilting downward shot begins with a close-up of the water's reflection. The surface, like a deep black jade, perfectly reflects a classical woman clad in pale pink silk Hanfu. Her hair, styled in an exquisitely ancient bun, is as black as ink, and her face, serene yet slightly melancholic, is so clear in the reflection that it seems almost tangible. Suddenly, her reflection begins to tremble slightly, then silently shatters like fine porcelain, the entire image disintegrating into thousands of fluttering peach petals, forming a dazzling yet sorrowful vortex within the water's reflection. At this moment, a real-life white jade hairpin, delicately carved with a lotus flower and tied with a red silk ribbon, slips silently from outside the frame, plunging into the water with a graceful arc and a soft, gentle plop, shattering the tranquility of the surface and sending ripples spreading outward. Then, from the depths of the pond, a massive koi, covered in metallic golden scales, calmly emerged, gleaming in the soft evening light. The koi gracefully swam toward the slowly sinking hairpin, carefully catching it in its mouth. With a single, swift turn, its magnificent tail fin swayed, and, carrying the hairpin, a symbol of womanhood's final remnant, it calmly and resolutely swam into the dark depths, leaving behind only the swirling reflections of petals, creating a scene of exquisite oriental classical aesthetics and a dreamlike, poetic atmosphere.", + "seed": 13145, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_13/index_2006_seed_13145_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.044179072696715595, + "vlm_logprob": -0.044179072696715595, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5249999523162843, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.044179072696715595, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a water surface reflecting a classical woman in pale pink silk Hanfu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's reflection in the water tremble and shatter into thousands of fluttering peach petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white jade hairpin with a lotus carving and red silk ribbon slip into the water and sink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive koi with metallic golden scales emerge from the water, catch the hairpin in its mouth, and swim into the depths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video start with a camera shot that slowly tilts downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.049562182277441025 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0495622158050537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.049562182277441025, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.049562182277441025, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19157899916172028, + 0.06868024915456772, + 0.15672744810581207, + 0.10123185813426971, + 0.10029049962759018, + 0.03691818192601204, + 0.05501123517751694, + 0.05146108567714691, + 0.10889103263616562, + 0.12920935451984406 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.049562182277441025 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a water surface reflecting a classical woman in pale pink silk Hanfu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's reflection in the water tremble and shatter into thousands of fluttering peach petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white jade hairpin with a lotus carving and red silk ribbon slip into the water and sink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive koi with metallic golden scales emerge from the water, catch the hairpin in its mouth, and swim into the depths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video start with a camera shot that slowly tilts downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018205799162387848 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018205642700195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018205799162387848, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018205799162387848, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25096815824508667, + 0.025917883962392807, + 0.06684199720621109, + 0.16533565521240234, + 0.1458863765001297, + 0.04174882173538208, + 0.11599774658679962, + 0.05222165957093239, + 0.09695422649383545, + 0.03812747821211815 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018205799162387848 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a water surface reflecting a classical woman in pale pink silk Hanfu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's reflection in the water tremble and shatter into thousands of fluttering peach petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white jade hairpin with a lotus carving and red silk ribbon slip into the water and sink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive koi with metallic golden scales emerge from the water, catch the hairpin in its mouth, and swim into the depths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video start with a camera shot that slowly tilts downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07005582749843597 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950557231903076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07005582749843597, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07005582749843597, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19650965929031372, + 0.044881295412778854, + 0.11503101885318756, + 0.15951010584831238, + 0.07342240959405899, + 0.04444368928670883, + 0.10332868993282318, + 0.06523898988962173, + 0.1120346263051033, + 0.08559951186180115 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07005582749843597 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a water surface reflecting a classical woman in pale pink silk Hanfu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's reflection in the water tremble and shatter into thousands of fluttering peach petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white jade hairpin with a lotus carving and red silk ribbon slip into the water and sink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive koi with metallic golden scales emerge from the water, catch the hairpin in its mouth, and swim into the depths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video start with a camera shot that slowly tilts downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004094670061022043 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.50409460067749 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004094670061022043, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004094670061022043, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12012694031000137, + 0.01950940676033497, + 0.034023016691207886, + 0.1276073008775711, + 0.030484184622764587, + 0.04410599544644356, + 0.052659738808870316, + 0.053999267518520355, + 0.07974198460578918, + 0.4377421736717224 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004094670061022043 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a water surface reflecting a classical woman in pale pink silk Hanfu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's reflection in the water tremble and shatter into thousands of fluttering peach petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white jade hairpin with a lotus carving and red silk ribbon slip into the water and sink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive koi with metallic golden scales emerge from the water, catch the hairpin in its mouth, and swim into the depths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video start with a camera shot that slowly tilts downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897688448429108 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.57897686958313 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897688448429108, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897688448429108, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18453018367290497, + 0.030510351061820984, + 0.11777272075414658, + 0.22640910744667053, + 0.1063212901353836, + 0.06704767793416977, + 0.07345590740442276, + 0.027948088943958282, + 0.05616787075996399, + 0.10983674228191376 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897688448429108 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly tilting downward shot begins with a close-up of the water's reflection. The surface, like a deep black jade, perfectly reflects a classical woman clad in pale pink silk Hanfu. Her hair, styled in an exquisitely ancient bun, is as black as ink, and her face, serene yet slightly melancholic, is so clear in the reflection that it seems almost tangible. Suddenly, her reflection begins to tremble slightly, then silently shatters like fine porcelain, the entire image disintegrating into thousands of fluttering peach petals, forming a dazzling yet sorrowful vortex within the water's reflection. At this moment, a real-life white jade hairpin, delicately carved with a lotus flower and tied with a red silk ribbon, slips silently from outside the frame, plunging into the water with a graceful arc and a soft, gentle plop, shattering the tranquility of the surface and sending ripples spreading outward. Then, from the depths of the pond, a massive koi, covered in metallic golden scales, calmly emerged, gleaming in the soft evening light. The koi gracefully swam toward the slowly sinking hairpin, carefully catching it in its mouth. With a single, swift turn, its magnificent tail fin swayed, and, carrying the hairpin, a symbol of womanhood's final remnant, it calmly and resolutely swam into the dark depths, leaving behind only the swirling reflections of petals, creating a scene of exquisite oriental classical aesthetics and a dreamlike, poetic atmosphere.", + "seed": 13146, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_13/index_2006_seed_13146_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.041080134361982344, + "vlm_logprob": -0.041080134361982344, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.041080134361982344, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a water surface reflecting a classical woman in pale pink silk Hanfu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's reflection in the water tremble and shatter into thousands of fluttering peach petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white jade hairpin with a lotus carving and red silk ribbon slip into the water and sink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive koi with metallic golden scales emerge from the water, catch the hairpin in its mouth, and swim into the depths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video start with a camera shot that slowly tilts downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03488951548933983 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4098894596099854 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03488951548933983, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03488951548933983, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14877714216709137, + 0.04668271914124489, + 0.22362521290779114, + 0.18476064503192902, + 0.07744646817445755, + 0.06341999769210815, + 0.1472771167755127, + 0.041054293513298035, + 0.02458803355693817, + 0.04236838221549988 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03488951548933983 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a water surface reflecting a classical woman in pale pink silk Hanfu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's reflection in the water tremble and shatter into thousands of fluttering peach petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white jade hairpin with a lotus carving and red silk ribbon slip into the water and sink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive koi with metallic golden scales emerge from the water, catch the hairpin in its mouth, and swim into the depths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video start with a camera shot that slowly tilts downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04870064929127693 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0487005710601807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04870064929127693, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04870064929127693, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08143457025289536, + 0.05750215798616409, + 0.03283717855811119, + 0.13076984882354736, + 0.27524274587631226, + 0.1598648577928543, + 0.1485859751701355, + 0.06212253123521805, + 0.017368491739034653, + 0.03427160158753395 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04870064929127693 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a water surface reflecting a classical woman in pale pink silk Hanfu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's reflection in the water tremble and shatter into thousands of fluttering peach petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white jade hairpin with a lotus carving and red silk ribbon slip into the water and sink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive koi with metallic golden scales emerge from the water, catch the hairpin in its mouth, and swim into the depths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video start with a camera shot that slowly tilts downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07008983939886093 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695089817047119 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07008983939886093, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07008983939886093, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05037406086921692, + 0.048695627599954605, + 0.2810010313987732, + 0.048658959567546844, + 0.17320510745048523, + 0.05483067035675049, + 0.22192434966564178, + 0.029762905091047287, + 0.03966398537158966, + 0.051883284002542496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07008983939886093 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a water surface reflecting a classical woman in pale pink silk Hanfu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's reflection in the water tremble and shatter into thousands of fluttering peach petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white jade hairpin with a lotus carving and red silk ribbon slip into the water and sink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive koi with metallic golden scales emerge from the water, catch the hairpin in its mouth, and swim into the depths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video start with a camera shot that slowly tilts downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008652813732624054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758652687072754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008652813732624054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008652813732624054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05147312209010124, + 0.03619011119008064, + 0.20038633048534393, + 0.055142421275377274, + 0.06630755960941315, + 0.03423226997256279, + 0.20770253241062164, + 0.14225691556930542, + 0.07807841897010803, + 0.12823031842708588 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008652813732624054 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a water surface reflecting a classical woman in pale pink silk Hanfu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the woman's reflection in the water tremble and shatter into thousands of fluttering peach petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white jade hairpin with a lotus carving and red silk ribbon slip into the water and sink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a massive koi with metallic golden scales emerge from the water, catch the hairpin in its mouth, and swim into the depths?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video start with a camera shot that slowly tilts downward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306785389780998 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680679321289062 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306785389780998, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306785389780998, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08833788335323334, + 0.06855063140392303, + 0.09332998096942902, + 0.07454325258731842, + 0.22525417804718018, + 0.12041892111301422, + 0.2058175653219223, + 0.05806910619139671, + 0.03232783079147339, + 0.03335065394639969 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306785389780998 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_14/index_tensor([8676, 8676])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_14/index_tensor([8676, 8676])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1b5c5da25805e2d5b42fd40289f56aa6faa2beef --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_14/index_tensor([8676, 8676])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot from a level angle, slightly handheld and imbued with a subtle sense of shakiness, instantly draws the viewer into the bustling and vibrant atmosphere of a wet market. At the center of the frame is an elderly woman with a wrinkled face and graying hair tied in a simple bun. Time has carved deep grooves into her tanned skin, but her eyes are remarkably sharp and focused. She wears a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock, the fabric defined by its distinct texture and soft creases from repeated washing. Standing before a vegetable stall piled high with vibrant greens, carrots dusted with fresh soil, and plump tomatoes, she leans forward slightly, extending her age-freckled right hand. With her index and middle fingers, she decisively indicates a price, her lips pursed as she speaks rapidly and forcefully to the vendor off-screen. In her left hand, she clutches a woven bamboo basket, its edges frayed. The tarpaulin overhead casts dappled shadows, while a few suspended incandescent bulbs emit a warm, dim glow, illuminating the dust and moisture floating in the air and creating a stark contrast between the vibrant colors of the vegetables and the dark clothing of the elderly woman. The entire scene, shrouded in warm tones, exudes an atmosphere both tense and full of life, perfectly capturing the uncompromising moments of everyday transactions.", + "seed": 3866, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_14/index_8676_seed_3866_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.013344312366098166, + "vlm_logprob": -0.013344312366098166, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.013344312366098166, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle with a slightly handheld, shaky camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly woman with a wrinkled face, graying hair in a bun, and deep grooves in her tanned skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock with visible texture and soft creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman standing before a vegetable stall containing vibrant greens, soil-dusted carrots, and plump tomatoes while holding a frayed woven bamboo basket in her left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dappled shadows from an overhead tarpaulin and warm, dim incandescent bulbs illuminating dust and moisture in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02161971665918827 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8966197967529297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02161971665918827, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02161971665918827, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08646037429571152, + 0.04345130920410156, + 0.04333998262882233, + 0.10671801120042801, + 0.11904790997505188, + 0.2880982458591461, + 0.13836315274238586, + 0.07314223796129227, + 0.06016695126891136, + 0.04121178761124611 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02161971665918827 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle with a slightly handheld, shaky camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly woman with a wrinkled face, graying hair in a bun, and deep grooves in her tanned skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock with visible texture and soft creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman standing before a vegetable stall containing vibrant greens, soil-dusted carrots, and plump tomatoes while holding a frayed woven bamboo basket in her left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dappled shadows from an overhead tarpaulin and warm, dim incandescent bulbs illuminating dust and moisture in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018201233819127083 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0182013511657715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018201233819127083, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018201233819127083, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.047747910022735596, + 0.06355719268321991, + 0.033425524830818176, + 0.02199837565422058, + 0.2612296938896179, + 0.31057748198509216, + 0.11120995879173279, + 0.05845106393098831, + 0.045676641166210175, + 0.04612613841891289 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018201233819127083 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle with a slightly handheld, shaky camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly woman with a wrinkled face, graying hair in a bun, and deep grooves in her tanned skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock with visible texture and soft creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman standing before a vegetable stall containing vibrant greens, soil-dusted carrots, and plump tomatoes while holding a frayed woven bamboo basket in her left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dappled shadows from an overhead tarpaulin and warm, dim incandescent bulbs illuminating dust and moisture in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067365444265306 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006736755371094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067365444265306, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067365444265306, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08003286272287369, + 0.03987345099449158, + 0.033604592084884644, + 0.05485694855451584, + 0.1543724685907364, + 0.2950522005558014, + 0.08856908977031708, + 0.12765620648860931, + 0.09877874702215195, + 0.02720339596271515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067365444265306 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle with a slightly handheld, shaky camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly woman with a wrinkled face, graying hair in a bun, and deep grooves in her tanned skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock with visible texture and soft creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman standing before a vegetable stall containing vibrant greens, soil-dusted carrots, and plump tomatoes while holding a frayed woven bamboo basket in her left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dappled shadows from an overhead tarpaulin and warm, dim incandescent bulbs illuminating dust and moisture in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007628831081092358 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882628917694092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007628831081092358, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007628831081092358, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16680440306663513, + 0.05618555098772049, + 0.02167421020567417, + 0.13878268003463745, + 0.1478385031223297, + 0.12312689423561096, + 0.07441378384828568, + 0.0628456398844719, + 0.1585504710674286, + 0.04977786913514137 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007628831081092358 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle with a slightly handheld, shaky camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly woman with a wrinkled face, graying hair in a bun, and deep grooves in her tanned skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock with visible texture and soft creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman standing before a vegetable stall containing vibrant greens, soil-dusted carrots, and plump tomatoes while holding a frayed woven bamboo basket in her left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dappled shadows from an overhead tarpaulin and warm, dim incandescent bulbs illuminating dust and moisture in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012535235844552517 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387535095214844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012535235844552517, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012535235844552517, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12210001796483994, + 0.056689340621232986, + 0.035311099141836166, + 0.24220743775367737, + 0.17801794409751892, + 0.10057801753282547, + 0.18514463305473328, + 0.018530631437897682, + 0.037309680134058, + 0.02411118894815445 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012535235844552517 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot from a level angle, slightly handheld and imbued with a subtle sense of shakiness, instantly draws the viewer into the bustling and vibrant atmosphere of a wet market. At the center of the frame is an elderly woman with a wrinkled face and graying hair tied in a simple bun. Time has carved deep grooves into her tanned skin, but her eyes are remarkably sharp and focused. She wears a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock, the fabric defined by its distinct texture and soft creases from repeated washing. Standing before a vegetable stall piled high with vibrant greens, carrots dusted with fresh soil, and plump tomatoes, she leans forward slightly, extending her age-freckled right hand. With her index and middle fingers, she decisively indicates a price, her lips pursed as she speaks rapidly and forcefully to the vendor off-screen. In her left hand, she clutches a woven bamboo basket, its edges frayed. The tarpaulin overhead casts dappled shadows, while a few suspended incandescent bulbs emit a warm, dim glow, illuminating the dust and moisture floating in the air and creating a stark contrast between the vibrant colors of the vegetables and the dark clothing of the elderly woman. The entire scene, shrouded in warm tones, exudes an atmosphere both tense and full of life, perfectly capturing the uncompromising moments of everyday transactions.", + "seed": 3867, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_14/index_8676_seed_3867_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.01814730018377304, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01814730018377304, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01814730018377304, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle with a slightly handheld, shaky camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly woman with a wrinkled face, graying hair in a bun, and deep grooves in her tanned skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock with visible texture and soft creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman standing before a vegetable stall containing vibrant greens, soil-dusted carrots, and plump tomatoes while holding a frayed woven bamboo basket in her left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dappled shadows from an overhead tarpaulin and warm, dim incandescent bulbs illuminating dust and moisture in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03942766785621643 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2894277572631836 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03942766785621643, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03942766785621643, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40417879819869995, + 0.09139341861009598, + 0.070285364985466, + 0.034155745059251785, + 0.0734189823269844, + 0.06920869648456573, + 0.07013625651597977, + 0.08558221906423569, + 0.06750565767288208, + 0.03413482755422592 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03942766785621643 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle with a slightly handheld, shaky camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly woman with a wrinkled face, graying hair in a bun, and deep grooves in her tanned skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock with visible texture and soft creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman standing before a vegetable stall containing vibrant greens, soil-dusted carrots, and plump tomatoes while holding a frayed woven bamboo basket in her left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dappled shadows from an overhead tarpaulin and warm, dim incandescent bulbs illuminating dust and moisture in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020600758492946625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956007957458496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020600758492946625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020600758492946625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21830876171588898, + 0.1466502696275711, + 0.04752654209733009, + 0.1137504056096077, + 0.07472209632396698, + 0.13036905229091644, + 0.038971517235040665, + 0.12243228405714035, + 0.0539269894361496, + 0.05334204435348511 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020600758492946625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle with a slightly handheld, shaky camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly woman with a wrinkled face, graying hair in a bun, and deep grooves in her tanned skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock with visible texture and soft creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman standing before a vegetable stall containing vibrant greens, soil-dusted carrots, and plump tomatoes while holding a frayed woven bamboo basket in her left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dappled shadows from an overhead tarpaulin and warm, dim incandescent bulbs illuminating dust and moisture in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00673524197191 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006735324859619 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00673524197191, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00673524197191, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21381328999996185, + 0.11593496799468994, + 0.07338917255401611, + 0.1795639544725418, + 0.05025339499115944, + 0.09323903918266296, + 0.04872525483369827, + 0.09688913077116013, + 0.09775140136480331, + 0.03044036030769348 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00673524197191 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle with a slightly handheld, shaky camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly woman with a wrinkled face, graying hair in a bun, and deep grooves in her tanned skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock with visible texture and soft creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman standing before a vegetable stall containing vibrant greens, soil-dusted carrots, and plump tomatoes while holding a frayed woven bamboo basket in her left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dappled shadows from an overhead tarpaulin and warm, dim incandescent bulbs illuminating dust and moisture in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009782115928828716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634782314300537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009782115928828716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009782115928828716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2684963643550873, + 0.07788708806037903, + 0.11547423899173737, + 0.0748337134718895, + 0.05389111116528511, + 0.1111360713839531, + 0.03014117106795311, + 0.06882801651954651, + 0.17209888994693756, + 0.02721334621310234 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009782115928828716 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle with a slightly handheld, shaky camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly woman with a wrinkled face, graying hair in a bun, and deep grooves in her tanned skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock with visible texture and soft creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman standing before a vegetable stall containing vibrant greens, soil-dusted carrots, and plump tomatoes while holding a frayed woven bamboo basket in her left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dappled shadows from an overhead tarpaulin and warm, dim incandescent bulbs illuminating dust and moisture in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014190716668963432 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264190673828125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014190716668963432, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014190716668963432, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2243255078792572, + 0.08441315591335297, + 0.05793776735663414, + 0.08648374676704407, + 0.0342145673930645, + 0.1770808845758438, + 0.033452678471803665, + 0.07993832975625992, + 0.11143696308135986, + 0.11071639508008957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014190716668963432 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot from a level angle, slightly handheld and imbued with a subtle sense of shakiness, instantly draws the viewer into the bustling and vibrant atmosphere of a wet market. At the center of the frame is an elderly woman with a wrinkled face and graying hair tied in a simple bun. Time has carved deep grooves into her tanned skin, but her eyes are remarkably sharp and focused. She wears a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock, the fabric defined by its distinct texture and soft creases from repeated washing. Standing before a vegetable stall piled high with vibrant greens, carrots dusted with fresh soil, and plump tomatoes, she leans forward slightly, extending her age-freckled right hand. With her index and middle fingers, she decisively indicates a price, her lips pursed as she speaks rapidly and forcefully to the vendor off-screen. In her left hand, she clutches a woven bamboo basket, its edges frayed. The tarpaulin overhead casts dappled shadows, while a few suspended incandescent bulbs emit a warm, dim glow, illuminating the dust and moisture floating in the air and creating a stark contrast between the vibrant colors of the vegetables and the dark clothing of the elderly woman. The entire scene, shrouded in warm tones, exudes an atmosphere both tense and full of life, perfectly capturing the uncompromising moments of everyday transactions.", + "seed": 3868, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_14/index_8676_seed_3868_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.01625964483246207, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01625964483246207, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01625964483246207, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle with a slightly handheld, shaky camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly woman with a wrinkled face, graying hair in a bun, and deep grooves in her tanned skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock with visible texture and soft creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman standing before a vegetable stall containing vibrant greens, soil-dusted carrots, and plump tomatoes while holding a frayed woven bamboo basket in her left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dappled shadows from an overhead tarpaulin and warm, dim incandescent bulbs illuminating dust and moisture in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.031117696315050125 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5311176776885986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.031117696315050125, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.031117696315050125, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3223024308681488, + 0.07172934710979462, + 0.0802430585026741, + 0.06794167309999466, + 0.08699213713407516, + 0.0465688519179821, + 0.049894869327545166, + 0.04452529177069664, + 0.12339188903570175, + 0.106410451233387 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.031117696315050125 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle with a slightly handheld, shaky camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly woman with a wrinkled face, graying hair in a bun, and deep grooves in her tanned skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock with visible texture and soft creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman standing before a vegetable stall containing vibrant greens, soil-dusted carrots, and plump tomatoes while holding a frayed woven bamboo basket in her left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dappled shadows from an overhead tarpaulin and warm, dim incandescent bulbs illuminating dust and moisture in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006738320458680391 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006738185882568 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006738320458680391, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006738320458680391, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2991243600845337, + 0.06854425370693207, + 0.09483747184276581, + 0.032427217811346054, + 0.06150510162115097, + 0.11608553677797318, + 0.0491790696978569, + 0.03998744860291481, + 0.07839469611644745, + 0.15991488099098206 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006738320458680391 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle with a slightly handheld, shaky camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly woman with a wrinkled face, graying hair in a bun, and deep grooves in her tanned skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock with visible texture and soft creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman standing before a vegetable stall containing vibrant greens, soil-dusted carrots, and plump tomatoes while holding a frayed woven bamboo basket in her left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dappled shadows from an overhead tarpaulin and warm, dim incandescent bulbs illuminating dust and moisture in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011069907806813717 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110697746276855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011069907806813717, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011069907806813717, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16820412874221802, + 0.0937838926911354, + 0.07151798158884048, + 0.09199808537960052, + 0.09344812482595444, + 0.1351781040430069, + 0.05638107284903526, + 0.09920737892389297, + 0.06418529897928238, + 0.12609587609767914 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011069907806813717 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle with a slightly handheld, shaky camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly woman with a wrinkled face, graying hair in a bun, and deep grooves in her tanned skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock with visible texture and soft creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman standing before a vegetable stall containing vibrant greens, soil-dusted carrots, and plump tomatoes while holding a frayed woven bamboo basket in her left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dappled shadows from an overhead tarpaulin and warm, dim incandescent bulbs illuminating dust and moisture in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01419447734951973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264194488525391 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01419447734951973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01419447734951973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21464315056800842, + 0.07257600873708725, + 0.07415665686130524, + 0.04269186779856682, + 0.11315666139125824, + 0.07700944691896439, + 0.06697437167167664, + 0.08870678395032883, + 0.1352306455373764, + 0.11485446989536285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01419447734951973 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle with a slightly handheld, shaky camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly woman with a wrinkled face, graying hair in a bun, and deep grooves in her tanned skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock with visible texture and soft creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman standing before a vegetable stall containing vibrant greens, soil-dusted carrots, and plump tomatoes while holding a frayed woven bamboo basket in her left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dappled shadows from an overhead tarpaulin and warm, dim incandescent bulbs illuminating dust and moisture in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0181778222322464 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0181779861450195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0181778222322464, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0181778222322464, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2455560564994812, + 0.09683509171009064, + 0.06265609711408615, + 0.04141724482178688, + 0.10924620181322098, + 0.0731748417019844, + 0.05895684286952019, + 0.05559622868895531, + 0.15522737801074982, + 0.10133396089076996 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0181778222322464 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot from a level angle, slightly handheld and imbued with a subtle sense of shakiness, instantly draws the viewer into the bustling and vibrant atmosphere of a wet market. At the center of the frame is an elderly woman with a wrinkled face and graying hair tied in a simple bun. Time has carved deep grooves into her tanned skin, but her eyes are remarkably sharp and focused. She wears a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock, the fabric defined by its distinct texture and soft creases from repeated washing. Standing before a vegetable stall piled high with vibrant greens, carrots dusted with fresh soil, and plump tomatoes, she leans forward slightly, extending her age-freckled right hand. With her index and middle fingers, she decisively indicates a price, her lips pursed as she speaks rapidly and forcefully to the vendor off-screen. In her left hand, she clutches a woven bamboo basket, its edges frayed. The tarpaulin overhead casts dappled shadows, while a few suspended incandescent bulbs emit a warm, dim glow, illuminating the dust and moisture floating in the air and creating a stark contrast between the vibrant colors of the vegetables and the dark clothing of the elderly woman. The entire scene, shrouded in warm tones, exudes an atmosphere both tense and full of life, perfectly capturing the uncompromising moments of everyday transactions.", + "seed": 3869, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_14/index_8676_seed_3869_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.015074878185987472, + "vlm_logprob": -0.015074878185987472, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.015074878185987472, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle with a slightly handheld, shaky camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly woman with a wrinkled face, graying hair in a bun, and deep grooves in her tanned skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock with visible texture and soft creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman standing before a vegetable stall containing vibrant greens, soil-dusted carrots, and plump tomatoes while holding a frayed woven bamboo basket in her left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dappled shadows from an overhead tarpaulin and warm, dim incandescent bulbs illuminating dust and moisture in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.030725186690688133 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5307252407073975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.030725186690688133, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.030725186690688133, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2033730447292328, + 0.1200367659330368, + 0.0769755095243454, + 0.04150458052754402, + 0.0439789816737175, + 0.15962155163288116, + 0.11179578304290771, + 0.07939866185188293, + 0.027970092371106148, + 0.13534501194953918 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.030725186690688133 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle with a slightly handheld, shaky camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly woman with a wrinkled face, graying hair in a bun, and deep grooves in her tanned skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock with visible texture and soft creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman standing before a vegetable stall containing vibrant greens, soil-dusted carrots, and plump tomatoes while holding a frayed woven bamboo basket in her left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dappled shadows from an overhead tarpaulin and warm, dim incandescent bulbs illuminating dust and moisture in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978990737348795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634789943695068 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978990737348795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978990737348795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22273556888103485, + 0.1564420908689499, + 0.07820768654346466, + 0.04320536553859711, + 0.07368724048137665, + 0.16262106597423553, + 0.0786062628030777, + 0.07632836699485779, + 0.050922323018312454, + 0.05724398419260979 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978990737348795 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle with a slightly handheld, shaky camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly woman with a wrinkled face, graying hair in a bun, and deep grooves in her tanned skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock with visible texture and soft creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman standing before a vegetable stall containing vibrant greens, soil-dusted carrots, and plump tomatoes while holding a frayed woven bamboo basket in her left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dappled shadows from an overhead tarpaulin and warm, dim incandescent bulbs illuminating dust and moisture in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009781643748283386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634781837463379 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009781643748283386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009781643748283386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16204823553562164, + 0.10370094329118729, + 0.09540285170078278, + 0.09927655756473541, + 0.13460735976696014, + 0.09056196361780167, + 0.03622860461473465, + 0.06670618802309036, + 0.04380771517753601, + 0.16765953600406647 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009781643748283386 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle with a slightly handheld, shaky camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly woman with a wrinkled face, graying hair in a bun, and deep grooves in her tanned skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock with visible texture and soft creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman standing before a vegetable stall containing vibrant greens, soil-dusted carrots, and plump tomatoes while holding a frayed woven bamboo basket in her left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dappled shadows from an overhead tarpaulin and warm, dim incandescent bulbs illuminating dust and moisture in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012542181648314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387542247772217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012542181648314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012542181648314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12054835259914398, + 0.12365327030420303, + 0.047416165471076965, + 0.07789632678031921, + 0.10337504744529724, + 0.27504003047943115, + 0.07054521143436432, + 0.057951897382736206, + 0.05476107448339462, + 0.06881263107061386 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012542181648314 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up from a level angle with a slightly handheld, shaky camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an elderly woman with a wrinkled face, graying hair in a bun, and deep grooves in her tanned skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a dark blue, slightly faded cotton smock with visible texture and soft creases?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman standing before a vegetable stall containing vibrant greens, soil-dusted carrots, and plump tomatoes while holding a frayed woven bamboo basket in her left hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature dappled shadows from an overhead tarpaulin and warm, dim incandescent bulbs illuminating dust and moisture in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012535471469163895 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387535572052002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012535471469163895, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012535471469163895, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14537931978702545, + 0.33120784163475037, + 0.08229406177997589, + 0.034349068999290466, + 0.03678079694509506, + 0.16494013369083405, + 0.02248396724462509, + 0.0752224251627922, + 0.026229633018374443, + 0.08111272752285004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012535471469163895 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_15/index_tensor([167, 167])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_15/index_tensor([167, 167])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..07372c0eb9235f08e1c6b7bfd0a0fe84800778e2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_15/index_tensor([167, 167])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, wide-angle shot captures the profound silence of a dense, ancient pine forest. Towering trees, with rough, dark brown bark and heavy, needle-laden branches, form an almost impenetrable canopy, allowing only a few faint, dusty, golden rays of sunlight to penetrate the cool, murky darkness that dotted the forest floor with thick, damp soil and fallen needles. The initially almost sacred silence was broken when a single pine needle began to tremble imperceptibly. This subtle movement spread like a contagion, first to a small branch, then to an entire limb, which trembled erratically. The vibration spread from one giant tree to another, rapidly escalating from weak, localized tremors to powerful, synchronized vibrations that engulfed the entire forest. The movement intensified dramatically until the entire forest shook violently; the massive trunks swayed back and forth in a discordant, unnatural rhythm, their branches clapping against each other, causing a cascade of needles to cascade down from the now wildly flickering and dancing light. The atmosphere shifts from quiet solemnity to palpable, growing dread as the violent, rhythmic tremors of the landscape suggest the awakening of a vast and unseen force.", + "seed": 31812, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_15/index_167_seed_31812_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.11441289857029915, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11441289857029915, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7750000238418577, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11441289857029915, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view of a dense pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the trees depicted as towering with rough, dark brown bark and needle-laden branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature faint, dusty, golden rays of sunlight penetrating a cool, murky darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the motion escalating from a single trembling needle to synchronized vibrations engulfing the entire forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the massive tree trunks sway back and forth in a discordant, unnatural rhythm with branches clapping against each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04003268852829933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2900326251983643 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04003268852829933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04003268852829933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20700864493846893, + 0.0775718167424202, + 0.08190669864416122, + 0.017643192782998085, + 0.020381247624754906, + 0.028861353173851967, + 0.05756450071930885, + 0.042585574090480804, + 0.12721411883831024, + 0.33926287293434143 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04003268852829933 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view of a dense pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the trees depicted as towering with rough, dark brown bark and needle-laden branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature faint, dusty, golden rays of sunlight penetrating a cool, murky darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the motion escalating from a single trembling needle to synchronized vibrations engulfing the entire forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the massive tree trunks sway back and forth in a discordant, unnatural rhythm with branches clapping against each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014212694019079208 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264212608337402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014212694019079208, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014212694019079208, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3011496663093567, + 0.1013638824224472, + 0.051921725273132324, + 0.05010073632001877, + 0.037496909499168396, + 0.015415247529745102, + 0.029910312965512276, + 0.04149942845106125, + 0.18764764070510864, + 0.1834944635629654 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014212694019079208 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view of a dense pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the trees depicted as towering with rough, dark brown bark and needle-laden branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature faint, dusty, golden rays of sunlight penetrating a cool, murky darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the motion escalating from a single trembling needle to synchronized vibrations engulfing the entire forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the massive tree trunks sway back and forth in a discordant, unnatural rhythm with branches clapping against each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026357341557741165 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651357412338257 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026357341557741165, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026357341557741165, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1349341869354248, + 0.4159839451313019, + 0.09052394330501556, + 0.02471446432173252, + 0.03348918259143829, + 0.023331545293331146, + 0.04098425805568695, + 0.10325238853693008, + 0.08416861295700073, + 0.04861752316355705 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026357341557741165 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view of a dense pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the trees depicted as towering with rough, dark brown bark and needle-laden branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature faint, dusty, golden rays of sunlight penetrating a cool, murky darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the motion escalating from a single trembling needle to synchronized vibrations engulfing the entire forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the massive tree trunks sway back and forth in a discordant, unnatural rhythm with branches clapping against each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428164690732956 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178165435791016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428164690732956, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428164690732956, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16380128264427185, + 0.18855823576450348, + 0.030089018866419792, + 0.02847098745405674, + 0.037040263414382935, + 0.038686543703079224, + 0.04242203012108803, + 0.0711318626999855, + 0.2893674075603485, + 0.11043237894773483 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428164690732956 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view of a dense pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the trees depicted as towering with rough, dark brown bark and needle-laden branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature faint, dusty, golden rays of sunlight penetrating a cool, murky darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the motion escalating from a single trembling needle to synchronized vibrations engulfing the entire forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the massive tree trunks sway back and forth in a discordant, unnatural rhythm with branches clapping against each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34864529967308044 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236453294754028 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34864529967308044, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34864529967308044, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.166371688246727, + 0.1670641303062439, + 0.032542768865823746, + 0.02289314568042755, + 0.03593368083238602, + 0.03693259507417679, + 0.04018973559141159, + 0.07509254664182663, + 0.23366965353488922, + 0.18931005895137787 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34864529967308044 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, wide-angle shot captures the profound silence of a dense, ancient pine forest. Towering trees, with rough, dark brown bark and heavy, needle-laden branches, form an almost impenetrable canopy, allowing only a few faint, dusty, golden rays of sunlight to penetrate the cool, murky darkness that dotted the forest floor with thick, damp soil and fallen needles. The initially almost sacred silence was broken when a single pine needle began to tremble imperceptibly. This subtle movement spread like a contagion, first to a small branch, then to an entire limb, which trembled erratically. The vibration spread from one giant tree to another, rapidly escalating from weak, localized tremors to powerful, synchronized vibrations that engulfed the entire forest. The movement intensified dramatically until the entire forest shook violently; the massive trunks swayed back and forth in a discordant, unnatural rhythm, their branches clapping against each other, causing a cascade of needles to cascade down from the now wildly flickering and dancing light. The atmosphere shifts from quiet solemnity to palpable, growing dread as the violent, rhythmic tremors of the landscape suggest the awakening of a vast and unseen force.", + "seed": 31813, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_15/index_167_seed_31813_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.17249944917857646, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17249944917857646, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17249944917857646, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view of a dense pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the trees depicted as towering with rough, dark brown bark and needle-laden branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature faint, dusty, golden rays of sunlight penetrating a cool, murky darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the motion escalating from a single trembling needle to synchronized vibrations engulfing the entire forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the massive tree trunks sway back and forth in a discordant, unnatural rhythm with branches clapping against each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05219857022166252 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.052198648452759 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05219857022166252, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05219857022166252, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09519051015377045, + 0.07991881668567657, + 0.04845923185348511, + 0.07185901701450348, + 0.06782563030719757, + 0.05308280140161514, + 0.4158734679222107, + 0.04303101822733879, + 0.09609494358301163, + 0.028664570301771164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05219857022166252 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view of a dense pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the trees depicted as towering with rough, dark brown bark and needle-laden branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature faint, dusty, golden rays of sunlight penetrating a cool, murky darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the motion escalating from a single trembling needle to synchronized vibrations engulfing the entire forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the massive tree trunks sway back and forth in a discordant, unnatural rhythm with branches clapping against each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01609945483505726 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141099452972412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01609945483505726, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01609945483505726, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18608933687210083, + 0.12404379993677139, + 0.1257706731557846, + 0.05749773606657982, + 0.031730759888887405, + 0.11003655195236206, + 0.044350799173116684, + 0.05169851332902908, + 0.14540761709213257, + 0.12337427586317062 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01609945483505726 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view of a dense pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the trees depicted as towering with rough, dark brown bark and needle-laden branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature faint, dusty, golden rays of sunlight penetrating a cool, murky darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the motion escalating from a single trembling needle to synchronized vibrations engulfing the entire forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the massive tree trunks sway back and forth in a discordant, unnatural rhythm with branches clapping against each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038117267191410065 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881171703338623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038117267191410065, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038117267191410065, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11468461900949478, + 0.13003484904766083, + 0.1431242674589157, + 0.07451114803552628, + 0.042016733437776566, + 0.023991784080863, + 0.08744630217552185, + 0.16494536399841309, + 0.1600944548845291, + 0.05915049463510513 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038117267191410065 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view of a dense pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the trees depicted as towering with rough, dark brown bark and needle-laden branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature faint, dusty, golden rays of sunlight penetrating a cool, murky darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the motion escalating from a single trembling needle to synchronized vibrations engulfing the entire forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the massive tree trunks sway back and forth in a discordant, unnatural rhythm with branches clapping against each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17990519106388092 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049051761627197 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17990519106388092, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17990519106388092, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09125415235757828, + 0.07428154349327087, + 0.08324553817510605, + 0.0763278678059578, + 0.060433607548475266, + 0.053487036377191544, + 0.1126442700624466, + 0.14987637102603912, + 0.13996046781539917, + 0.15848912298679352 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17990519106388092 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view of a dense pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the trees depicted as towering with rough, dark brown bark and needle-laden branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature faint, dusty, golden rays of sunlight penetrating a cool, murky darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the motion escalating from a single trembling needle to synchronized vibrations engulfing the entire forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the massive tree trunks sway back and forth in a discordant, unnatural rhythm with branches clapping against each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761767625808716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261767625808716 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761767625808716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761767625808716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1297210305929184, + 0.1556806117296219, + 0.10916980355978012, + 0.054558008909225464, + 0.04810209199786186, + 0.09033722430467606, + 0.06186452507972717, + 0.12016637623310089, + 0.14980992674827576, + 0.08059035986661911 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761767625808716 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, wide-angle shot captures the profound silence of a dense, ancient pine forest. Towering trees, with rough, dark brown bark and heavy, needle-laden branches, form an almost impenetrable canopy, allowing only a few faint, dusty, golden rays of sunlight to penetrate the cool, murky darkness that dotted the forest floor with thick, damp soil and fallen needles. The initially almost sacred silence was broken when a single pine needle began to tremble imperceptibly. This subtle movement spread like a contagion, first to a small branch, then to an entire limb, which trembled erratically. The vibration spread from one giant tree to another, rapidly escalating from weak, localized tremors to powerful, synchronized vibrations that engulfed the entire forest. The movement intensified dramatically until the entire forest shook violently; the massive trunks swayed back and forth in a discordant, unnatural rhythm, their branches clapping against each other, causing a cascade of needles to cascade down from the now wildly flickering and dancing light. The atmosphere shifts from quiet solemnity to palpable, growing dread as the violent, rhythmic tremors of the landscape suggest the awakening of a vast and unseen force.", + "seed": 31814, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_15/index_167_seed_31814_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10781398452818394, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10781398452818394, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10781398452818394, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view of a dense pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the trees depicted as towering with rough, dark brown bark and needle-laden branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature faint, dusty, golden rays of sunlight penetrating a cool, murky darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the motion escalating from a single trembling needle to synchronized vibrations engulfing the entire forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the massive tree trunks sway back and forth in a discordant, unnatural rhythm with branches clapping against each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.046202316880226135 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1712024211883545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.046202316880226135, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.046202316880226135, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11895541846752167, + 0.08716671913862228, + 0.08761603385210037, + 0.07804492115974426, + 0.09699974954128265, + 0.13062778115272522, + 0.19002346694469452, + 0.024137744680047035, + 0.14451001584529877, + 0.041918136179447174 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.046202316880226135 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view of a dense pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the trees depicted as towering with rough, dark brown bark and needle-laden branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature faint, dusty, golden rays of sunlight penetrating a cool, murky darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the motion escalating from a single trembling needle to synchronized vibrations engulfing the entire forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the massive tree trunks sway back and forth in a discordant, unnatural rhythm with branches clapping against each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02060379460453987 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895603895187378 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02060379460453987, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02060379460453987, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18896245956420898, + 0.1570919156074524, + 0.08585305511951447, + 0.15056002140045166, + 0.06563585996627808, + 0.0784124881029129, + 0.09459538012742996, + 0.056961894035339355, + 0.07641569525003433, + 0.04551119729876518 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02060379460453987 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view of a dense pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the trees depicted as towering with rough, dark brown bark and needle-laden branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature faint, dusty, golden rays of sunlight penetrating a cool, murky darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the motion escalating from a single trembling needle to synchronized vibrations engulfing the entire forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the massive tree trunks sway back and forth in a discordant, unnatural rhythm with branches clapping against each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329937182366848 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732994556427 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329937182366848, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329937182366848, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16374680399894714, + 0.040665153414011, + 0.06485198438167572, + 0.07989184558391571, + 0.316092848777771, + 0.04360375180840492, + 0.1411696821451187, + 0.015996620059013367, + 0.03242594376206398, + 0.10155532509088516 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329937182366848 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view of a dense pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the trees depicted as towering with rough, dark brown bark and needle-laden branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature faint, dusty, golden rays of sunlight penetrating a cool, murky darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the motion escalating from a single trembling needle to synchronized vibrations engulfing the entire forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the massive tree trunks sway back and forth in a discordant, unnatural rhythm with branches clapping against each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10031937807798386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503193855285645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10031937807798386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10031937807798386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06911113113164902, + 0.06643951684236526, + 0.1857433319091797, + 0.06683175265789032, + 0.08958323299884796, + 0.06386353075504303, + 0.21380114555358887, + 0.02168504148721695, + 0.16429586708545685, + 0.0586453378200531 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10031937807798386 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view of a dense pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the trees depicted as towering with rough, dark brown bark and needle-laden branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature faint, dusty, golden rays of sunlight penetrating a cool, murky darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the motion escalating from a single trembling needle to synchronized vibrations engulfing the entire forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the massive tree trunks sway back and forth in a discordant, unnatural rhythm with branches clapping against each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34864506125450134 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236450910568237 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34864506125450134, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34864506125450134, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15954631567001343, + 0.09914395213127136, + 0.11759883910417557, + 0.11768495291471481, + 0.12918512523174286, + 0.05165132135152817, + 0.10637110471725464, + 0.043348267674446106, + 0.11698901653289795, + 0.05848109722137451 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34864506125450134 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, wide-angle shot captures the profound silence of a dense, ancient pine forest. Towering trees, with rough, dark brown bark and heavy, needle-laden branches, form an almost impenetrable canopy, allowing only a few faint, dusty, golden rays of sunlight to penetrate the cool, murky darkness that dotted the forest floor with thick, damp soil and fallen needles. The initially almost sacred silence was broken when a single pine needle began to tremble imperceptibly. This subtle movement spread like a contagion, first to a small branch, then to an entire limb, which trembled erratically. The vibration spread from one giant tree to another, rapidly escalating from weak, localized tremors to powerful, synchronized vibrations that engulfed the entire forest. The movement intensified dramatically until the entire forest shook violently; the massive trunks swayed back and forth in a discordant, unnatural rhythm, their branches clapping against each other, causing a cascade of needles to cascade down from the now wildly flickering and dancing light. The atmosphere shifts from quiet solemnity to palpable, growing dread as the violent, rhythmic tremors of the landscape suggest the awakening of a vast and unseen force.", + "seed": 31815, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_15/index_167_seed_31815_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.15437317751348018, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15437317751348018, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.4749999940395355, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15437317751348018, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view of a dense pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the trees depicted as towering with rough, dark brown bark and needle-laden branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature faint, dusty, golden rays of sunlight penetrating a cool, murky darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the motion escalating from a single trembling needle to synchronized vibrations engulfing the entire forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the massive tree trunks sway back and forth in a discordant, unnatural rhythm with branches clapping against each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.035882867872714996 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4108829498291016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.035882867872714996, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.035882867872714996, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08963753283023834, + 0.06964217871427536, + 0.12336881458759308, + 0.3935795724391937, + 0.16121640801429749, + 0.04132305085659027, + 0.022238515317440033, + 0.0222222451120615, + 0.0626867264509201, + 0.014084948226809502 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.035882867872714996 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view of a dense pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the trees depicted as towering with rough, dark brown bark and needle-laden branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature faint, dusty, golden rays of sunlight penetrating a cool, murky darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the motion escalating from a single trembling needle to synchronized vibrations engulfing the entire forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the massive tree trunks sway back and forth in a discordant, unnatural rhythm with branches clapping against each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03372680023312569 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408726692199707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03372680023312569, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03372680023312569, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10949255526065826, + 0.09528107196092606, + 0.0697212740778923, + 0.28962576389312744, + 0.08559346199035645, + 0.07539195567369461, + 0.04242033511400223, + 0.03471808880567551, + 0.09266117960214615, + 0.10509433597326279 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03372680023312569 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view of a dense pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the trees depicted as towering with rough, dark brown bark and needle-laden branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature faint, dusty, golden rays of sunlight penetrating a cool, murky darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the motion escalating from a single trembling needle to synchronized vibrations engulfing the entire forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the massive tree trunks sway back and forth in a discordant, unnatural rhythm with branches clapping against each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026356877759099007 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513569355010986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026356877759099007, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026356877759099007, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07593967020511627, + 0.0738549679517746, + 0.49453553557395935, + 0.12545379996299744, + 0.07708677649497986, + 0.03712974861264229, + 0.016251377761363983, + 0.01907055638730526, + 0.020822318270802498, + 0.059855230152606964 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026356877759099007 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view of a dense pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the trees depicted as towering with rough, dark brown bark and needle-laden branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature faint, dusty, golden rays of sunlight penetrating a cool, murky darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the motion escalating from a single trembling needle to synchronized vibrations engulfing the entire forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the massive tree trunks sway back and forth in a discordant, unnatural rhythm with branches clapping against each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20158641040325165 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.701586365699768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20158641040325165, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20158641040325165, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17861805856227875, + 0.07802315056324005, + 0.13595369458198547, + 0.20590145885944366, + 0.13071168959140778, + 0.060505904257297516, + 0.028596872463822365, + 0.043175071477890015, + 0.07375096529722214, + 0.06476308405399323 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20158641040325165 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view of a dense pine forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the trees depicted as towering with rough, dark brown bark and needle-laden branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature faint, dusty, golden rays of sunlight penetrating a cool, murky darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the motion escalating from a single trembling needle to synchronized vibrations engulfing the entire forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the massive tree trunks sway back and forth in a discordant, unnatural rhythm with branches clapping against each other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4743129312992096 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9743129014968872 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4743129312992096, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.4999999701976776, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4743129312992096, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1247534453868866, + 0.10770966112613678, + 0.1352178156375885, + 0.09640519320964813, + 0.0893120989203453, + 0.1287490725517273, + 0.04783130809664726, + 0.12877798080444336, + 0.04482349753379822, + 0.09641989320516586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4743129312992096 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_2/index_tensor([9746, 9746])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_2/index_tensor([9746, 9746])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..221eada416cf70c278164768fc18978f812aa30f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_2/index_tensor([9746, 9746])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from a level angle, pans leftward at an incredibly slow pace, following an elderly man with silver hair and a face etched with deep, kindly wrinkles. He wears a traditional white silk training suit, the material gleaming subtly in the soft morning light, its loose fit gently undulating with his movements. In the high-contrast black and white image, every delicate fold of his suit and the intricate texture of his weathered skin are captured with clarity. He is in the quiet of a park in the early morning, his eyes slightly closed, his expression focused and serene. His center of gravity lowers, his arms slowly unfolding as if embracing a tree, shifting his weight steadily and deliberately. He lifts a foot gently, then drops it with the quietness of a feather. Each movement is imbued with sleek tension and fluid continuity. The soft side light casts long, gentle shadows on him and on the stone path under his feet. The branches of several ancient willow trees in the background sway gently in the breeze, and the morning mist in the distance has not yet completely dissipated, injecting the entire picture with a tranquil, focused and eternal Zen atmosphere.", + "seed": 21674, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_2/index_9746_seed_21674_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.031455252040177586, + "vlm_logprob": -0.031455252040177586, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.031455252040177586, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly man with silver hair and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional white silk training suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan leftward at a slow pace following the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform slow movements including lowering his center of gravity, unfolding his arms, and lifting/dropping a foot gently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005971330218017101 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255971431732178 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005971330218017101, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005971330218017101, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2596478760242462, + 0.15717442333698273, + 0.048513226211071014, + 0.03275024890899658, + 0.06221098452806473, + 0.051512036472558975, + 0.0730355903506279, + 0.04972917214035988, + 0.032478079199790955, + 0.23294837772846222 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005971330218017101 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly man with silver hair and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional white silk training suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan leftward at a slow pace following the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform slow movements including lowering his center of gravity, unfolding his arms, and lifting/dropping a foot gently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059398591518402 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955938816070557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059398591518402, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059398591518402, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19032049179077148, + 0.10205565392971039, + 0.06939463317394257, + 0.09085330367088318, + 0.08081457018852234, + 0.21298721432685852, + 0.05470100790262222, + 0.025966374203562737, + 0.06936854124069214, + 0.10353825241327286 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059398591518402 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly man with silver hair and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional white silk training suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan leftward at a slow pace following the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform slow movements including lowering his center of gravity, unfolding his arms, and lifting/dropping a foot gently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052565219812095165 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255256652832031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052565219812095165, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052565219812095165, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.036124955862760544, + 0.052394792437553406, + 0.020403467118740082, + 0.02717043273150921, + 0.645624041557312, + 0.03581399843096733, + 0.01862298510968685, + 0.03366650268435478, + 0.046547479927539825, + 0.08363139629364014 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052565219812095165 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly man with silver hair and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional white silk training suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan leftward at a slow pace following the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform slow movements including lowering his center of gravity, unfolding his arms, and lifting/dropping a foot gently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11291541904211044 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237915515899658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11291541904211044, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11291541904211044, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07713279128074646, + 0.23336482048034668, + 0.07305215299129486, + 0.18276193737983704, + 0.11995237320661545, + 0.045341670513153076, + 0.05863120034337044, + 0.05637847259640694, + 0.09725995361804962, + 0.056124694645404816 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11291541904211044 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly man with silver hair and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional white silk training suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan leftward at a slow pace following the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform slow movements including lowering his center of gravity, unfolding his arms, and lifting/dropping a foot gently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012539003044366837 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387538909912109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012539003044366837, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012539003044366837, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.042635537683963776, + 0.2628302276134491, + 0.02985246852040291, + 0.091370590031147, + 0.24683569371700287, + 0.0242355614900589, + 0.03143380954861641, + 0.043514102697372437, + 0.044580016285181046, + 0.18271198868751526 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012539003044366837 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from a level angle, pans leftward at an incredibly slow pace, following an elderly man with silver hair and a face etched with deep, kindly wrinkles. He wears a traditional white silk training suit, the material gleaming subtly in the soft morning light, its loose fit gently undulating with his movements. In the high-contrast black and white image, every delicate fold of his suit and the intricate texture of his weathered skin are captured with clarity. He is in the quiet of a park in the early morning, his eyes slightly closed, his expression focused and serene. His center of gravity lowers, his arms slowly unfolding as if embracing a tree, shifting his weight steadily and deliberately. He lifts a foot gently, then drops it with the quietness of a feather. Each movement is imbued with sleek tension and fluid continuity. The soft side light casts long, gentle shadows on him and on the stone path under his feet. The branches of several ancient willow trees in the background sway gently in the breeze, and the morning mist in the distance has not yet completely dissipated, injecting the entire picture with a tranquil, focused and eternal Zen atmosphere.", + "seed": 21675, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_2/index_9746_seed_21675_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04630009569227696, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04630009569227696, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.849999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04630009569227696, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly man with silver hair and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional white silk training suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan leftward at a slow pace following the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform slow movements including lowering his center of gravity, unfolding his arms, and lifting/dropping a foot gently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019364008679986 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.019363880157471 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019364008679986, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019364008679986, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22313056886196136, + 0.14049728214740753, + 0.14034061133861542, + 0.06978795677423477, + 0.08931346237659454, + 0.08569402992725372, + 0.09542983770370483, + 0.04280322790145874, + 0.04399007931351662, + 0.06901291757822037 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019364008679986 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly man with silver hair and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional white silk training suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan leftward at a slow pace following the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform slow movements including lowering his center of gravity, unfolding his arms, and lifting/dropping a foot gently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012553482316434383 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387553691864014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012553482316434383, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012553482316434383, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10372771322727203, + 0.07848208397626877, + 0.07863903790712357, + 0.061277080327272415, + 0.0519646555185318, + 0.07817060500383377, + 0.3640965521335602, + 0.09435566514730453, + 0.04552987217903137, + 0.043756768107414246 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012553482316434383 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly man with silver hair and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional white silk training suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan leftward at a slow pace following the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform slow movements including lowering his center of gravity, unfolding his arms, and lifting/dropping a foot gently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008647613227367401 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758647441864014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008647613227367401, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008647613227367401, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.39694124460220337, + 0.12395463138818741, + 0.027606027200818062, + 0.047394126653671265, + 0.2546083331108093, + 0.01648612692952156, + 0.04710054025053978, + 0.027295425534248352, + 0.03652377426624298, + 0.022089768201112747 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008647613227367401 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly man with silver hair and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional white silk training suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan leftward at a slow pace following the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform slow movements including lowering his center of gravity, unfolding his arms, and lifting/dropping a foot gently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17986027896404266 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804860234260559 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17986027896404266, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17986027896404266, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11965248733758926, + 0.09259038418531418, + 0.0640600174665451, + 0.06985926628112793, + 0.09290719777345657, + 0.1991390734910965, + 0.117634117603302, + 0.07429921627044678, + 0.08898317813873291, + 0.08087503165006638 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17986027896404266 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly man with silver hair and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional white silk training suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan leftward at a slow pace following the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform slow movements including lowering his center of gravity, unfolding his arms, and lifting/dropping a foot gently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011075095273554325 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511075019836426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011075095273554325, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011075095273554325, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19831188023090363, + 0.13872241973876953, + 0.06270767748355865, + 0.05113883316516876, + 0.08738625794649124, + 0.09231192618608475, + 0.17222318053245544, + 0.06684939563274384, + 0.051632463932037354, + 0.07871599495410919 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011075095273554325 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from a level angle, pans leftward at an incredibly slow pace, following an elderly man with silver hair and a face etched with deep, kindly wrinkles. He wears a traditional white silk training suit, the material gleaming subtly in the soft morning light, its loose fit gently undulating with his movements. In the high-contrast black and white image, every delicate fold of his suit and the intricate texture of his weathered skin are captured with clarity. He is in the quiet of a park in the early morning, his eyes slightly closed, his expression focused and serene. His center of gravity lowers, his arms slowly unfolding as if embracing a tree, shifting his weight steadily and deliberately. He lifts a foot gently, then drops it with the quietness of a feather. Each movement is imbued with sleek tension and fluid continuity. The soft side light casts long, gentle shadows on him and on the stone path under his feet. The branches of several ancient willow trees in the background sway gently in the breeze, and the morning mist in the distance has not yet completely dissipated, injecting the entire picture with a tranquil, focused and eternal Zen atmosphere.", + "seed": 21676, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_2/index_9746_seed_21676_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.027243535779416562, + "vlm_logprob": -0.027243535779416562, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.027243535779416562, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly man with silver hair and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional white silk training suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan leftward at a slow pace following the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform slow movements including lowering his center of gravity, unfolding his arms, and lifting/dropping a foot gently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013726954348385334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.388727188110352 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013726954348385334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013726954348385334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10662031173706055, + 0.028779176995158195, + 0.014010300859808922, + 0.027932874858379364, + 0.016546720638871193, + 0.08472803235054016, + 0.04970164597034454, + 0.014592079445719719, + 0.02399170957505703, + 0.6330971717834473 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013726954348385334 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly man with silver hair and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional white silk training suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan leftward at a slow pace following the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform slow movements including lowering his center of gravity, unfolding his arms, and lifting/dropping a foot gently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020600758492946625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956007957458496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020600758492946625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020600758492946625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10371816903352737, + 0.07958195358514786, + 0.10201074182987213, + 0.16260522603988647, + 0.037661343812942505, + 0.08989602327346802, + 0.06437301635742188, + 0.036412980407476425, + 0.049424316734075546, + 0.2743162214756012 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020600758492946625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly man with silver hair and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional white silk training suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan leftward at a slow pace following the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform slow movements including lowering his center of gravity, unfolding his arms, and lifting/dropping a foot gently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026355484500527382 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651355504989624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026355484500527382, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026355484500527382, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0063712103292346, + 0.003176335012540221, + 0.0017920946702361107, + 0.003090905724093318, + 0.0038917488418519497, + 0.03860418125987053, + 0.010200843214988708, + 0.011650407686829567, + 0.013895206153392792, + 0.9073270559310913 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026355484500527382 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly man with silver hair and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional white silk training suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan leftward at a slow pace following the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform slow movements including lowering his center of gravity, unfolding his arms, and lifting/dropping a foot gently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05494820326566696 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929948091506958 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05494820326566696, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05494820326566696, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.019767429679632187, + 0.006694017443805933, + 0.006935189012438059, + 0.01182926818728447, + 0.014643906615674496, + 0.03685213625431061, + 0.009286104701459408, + 0.015581345185637474, + 0.008673150092363358, + 0.8697373270988464 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05494820326566696 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly man with silver hair and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional white silk training suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan leftward at a slow pace following the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform slow movements including lowering his center of gravity, unfolding his arms, and lifting/dropping a foot gently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020586278289556503 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955862522125244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020586278289556503, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020586278289556503, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.027837948873639107, + 0.00938635878264904, + 0.007607451174408197, + 0.018167631700634956, + 0.02571878768503666, + 0.09270156174898148, + 0.0707622617483139, + 0.04884559288620949, + 0.018094705417752266, + 0.6808777451515198 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020586278289556503 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from a level angle, pans leftward at an incredibly slow pace, following an elderly man with silver hair and a face etched with deep, kindly wrinkles. He wears a traditional white silk training suit, the material gleaming subtly in the soft morning light, its loose fit gently undulating with his movements. In the high-contrast black and white image, every delicate fold of his suit and the intricate texture of his weathered skin are captured with clarity. He is in the quiet of a park in the early morning, his eyes slightly closed, his expression focused and serene. His center of gravity lowers, his arms slowly unfolding as if embracing a tree, shifting his weight steadily and deliberately. He lifts a foot gently, then drops it with the quietness of a feather. Each movement is imbued with sleek tension and fluid continuity. The soft side light casts long, gentle shadows on him and on the stone path under his feet. The branches of several ancient willow trees in the background sway gently in the breeze, and the morning mist in the distance has not yet completely dissipated, injecting the entire picture with a tranquil, focused and eternal Zen atmosphere.", + "seed": 21677, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_2/index_9746_seed_21677_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.09118123184889555, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09118123184889555, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09118123184889555, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly man with silver hair and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional white silk training suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan leftward at a slow pace following the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform slow movements including lowering his center of gravity, unfolding his arms, and lifting/dropping a foot gently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005974885076284409 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255974769592285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005974885076284409, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005974885076284409, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12136443704366684, + 0.12882426381111145, + 0.27484947443008423, + 0.08883070945739746, + 0.07254619896411896, + 0.04313239827752113, + 0.18458575010299683, + 0.024151034653186798, + 0.025050591677427292, + 0.036665115505456924 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005974885076284409 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly man with silver hair and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional white silk training suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan leftward at a slow pace following the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform slow movements including lowering his center of gravity, unfolding his arms, and lifting/dropping a foot gently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009792622178792953 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634792804718018 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009792622178792953, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009792622178792953, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1010582372546196, + 0.05923150107264519, + 0.038707129657268524, + 0.07882697880268097, + 0.07889113575220108, + 0.041090063750743866, + 0.25775834918022156, + 0.10562050342559814, + 0.03384656086564064, + 0.20496955513954163 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009792622178792953 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly man with silver hair and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional white silk training suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan leftward at a slow pace following the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform slow movements including lowering his center of gravity, unfolding his arms, and lifting/dropping a foot gently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0789957195520401 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578995704650879 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0789957195520401, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0789957195520401, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07074090093374252, + 0.027909018099308014, + 0.061320722103118896, + 0.020917171612381935, + 0.11273283511400223, + 0.028076017275452614, + 0.6127610206604004, + 0.016992777585983276, + 0.03693539276719093, + 0.011614137329161167 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0789957195520401 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly man with silver hair and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional white silk training suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan leftward at a slow pace following the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform slow movements including lowering his center of gravity, unfolding his arms, and lifting/dropping a foot gently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34860122203826904 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223601222038269 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34860122203826904, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34860122203826904, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05948202311992645, + 0.027750279754400253, + 0.16301237046718597, + 0.0826837420463562, + 0.08029817789793015, + 0.1328149437904358, + 0.06083545833826065, + 0.048728104680776596, + 0.046800870448350906, + 0.2975940704345703 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34860122203826904 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly man with silver hair and deep wrinkles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a traditional white silk training suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan leftward at a slow pace following the man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform slow movements including lowering his center of gravity, unfolding his arms, and lifting/dropping a foot gently?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012541710399091244 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387541770935059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012541710399091244, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012541710399091244, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10574493557214737, + 0.042647093534469604, + 0.17962972819805145, + 0.028056524693965912, + 0.10366728901863098, + 0.12414782494306564, + 0.10342799872159958, + 0.15115247666835785, + 0.05973352491855621, + 0.10179262608289719 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012541710399091244 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_3/index_tensor([9448, 9448])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_3/index_tensor([9448, 9448])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6fd72a82ec685a1fd6a3a34655eb25a53526efc7 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_3/index_tensor([9448, 9448])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle, extreme close-up captures the liquid-like reflection of an ornate silver hairpin in the mirror of a dark, black lacquered dressing table. A delicate, pale hand, its slender fingers gently grasping the hairpin between thumb and index finger; its intricately carved phoenix body, crafted from sterling silver with a subtle patina, gleams in the soft, warm light. A single, opaline, lustrous pearl dangles from its end. The hand moves with a slow, hypnotic rhythm, steadily and deliberately lifting the hairpin, elongating its reflection on the polished surface while the dangling pearl sways gracefully. Then, with the same smooth, continuous motion, the hairpin descends. The background is a beautiful soft-focus blur of thick, deep red silk fabric, its undulating folds appearing with a shallow depth of field. The warm light, coming from an unseen source off-camera, casts soft highlights on the silver carving and the hand, creating deep, gentle shadows across the vanity, evoking an atmosphere of elegance, tranquility, and profound personal connection.", + "seed": 15078, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_3/index_9448_seed_15078_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07810984449461103, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07810984449461103, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07810984449461103, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of an ornate silver hairpin reflected in a mirror?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a delicate, pale hand with slender fingers visible grasping the hairpin between the thumb and index finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hairpin feature an intricately carved phoenix body made of sterling silver with a subtle patina and a single opaline pearl dangling from its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand move with a slow, hypnotic rhythm to lift and then descend the hairpin, causing the reflection to elongate and the pearl to sway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of thick, deep red silk fabric with undulating folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18315501511096954 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8081550598144531 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18315501511096954, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18315501511096954, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07400886714458466, + 0.049441177397966385, + 0.03745758533477783, + 0.15364940464496613, + 0.2024785280227661, + 0.056429747492074966, + 0.2734885513782501, + 0.07684187591075897, + 0.03635889291763306, + 0.039845291525125504 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18315501511096954 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of an ornate silver hairpin reflected in a mirror?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a delicate, pale hand with slender fingers visible grasping the hairpin between the thumb and index finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hairpin feature an intricately carved phoenix body made of sterling silver with a subtle patina and a single opaline pearl dangling from its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand move with a slow, hypnotic rhythm to lift and then descend the hairpin, causing the reflection to elongate and the pearl to sway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of thick, deep red silk fabric with undulating folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01256290078163147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875627517700195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01256290078163147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01256290078163147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27716320753097534, + 0.1189098134636879, + 0.08669859915971756, + 0.11011366546154022, + 0.02849964238703251, + 0.02516675926744938, + 0.14839404821395874, + 0.09280013293027878, + 0.045962464064359665, + 0.0662916749715805 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01256290078163147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of an ornate silver hairpin reflected in a mirror?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a delicate, pale hand with slender fingers visible grasping the hairpin between the thumb and index finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hairpin feature an intricately carved phoenix body made of sterling silver with a subtle patina and a single opaline pearl dangling from its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand move with a slow, hypnotic rhythm to lift and then descend the hairpin, causing the reflection to elongate and the pearl to sway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of thick, deep red silk fabric with undulating folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10052790492773056 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3505280017852783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10052790492773056, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10052790492773056, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15736041963100433, + 0.13426627218723297, + 0.11904000490903854, + 0.07851449400186539, + 0.16336670517921448, + 0.03504391759634018, + 0.11764208227396011, + 0.05351244658231735, + 0.05529522895812988, + 0.08595843613147736 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10052790492773056 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of an ornate silver hairpin reflected in a mirror?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a delicate, pale hand with slender fingers visible grasping the hairpin between the thumb and index finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hairpin feature an intricately carved phoenix body made of sterling silver with a subtle patina and a single opaline pearl dangling from its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand move with a slow, hypnotic rhythm to lift and then descend the hairpin, causing the reflection to elongate and the pearl to sway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of thick, deep red silk fabric with undulating folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08905091136693954 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640510082244873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08905091136693954, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08905091136693954, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08500993996858597, + 0.06164466217160225, + 0.056507598608732224, + 0.1671026647090912, + 0.07849094271659851, + 0.029855815693736076, + 0.3980378210544586, + 0.062128063291311264, + 0.023580651730298996, + 0.03764178231358528 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08905091136693954 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of an ornate silver hairpin reflected in a mirror?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a delicate, pale hand with slender fingers visible grasping the hairpin between the thumb and index finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hairpin feature an intricately carved phoenix body made of sterling silver with a subtle patina and a single opaline pearl dangling from its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand move with a slow, hypnotic rhythm to lift and then descend the hairpin, causing the reflection to elongate and the pearl to sway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of thick, deep red silk fabric with undulating folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005252490285784006 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255252361297607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005252490285784006, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005252490285784006, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17352917790412903, + 0.0932481437921524, + 0.08124950528144836, + 0.32564863562583923, + 0.060932707041502, + 0.09728386998176575, + 0.0243143979460001, + 0.06750126928091049, + 0.03081112541258335, + 0.04548114165663719 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005252490285784006 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle, extreme close-up captures the liquid-like reflection of an ornate silver hairpin in the mirror of a dark, black lacquered dressing table. A delicate, pale hand, its slender fingers gently grasping the hairpin between thumb and index finger; its intricately carved phoenix body, crafted from sterling silver with a subtle patina, gleams in the soft, warm light. A single, opaline, lustrous pearl dangles from its end. The hand moves with a slow, hypnotic rhythm, steadily and deliberately lifting the hairpin, elongating its reflection on the polished surface while the dangling pearl sways gracefully. Then, with the same smooth, continuous motion, the hairpin descends. The background is a beautiful soft-focus blur of thick, deep red silk fabric, its undulating folds appearing with a shallow depth of field. The warm light, coming from an unseen source off-camera, casts soft highlights on the silver carving and the hand, creating deep, gentle shadows across the vanity, evoking an atmosphere of elegance, tranquility, and profound personal connection.", + "seed": 15079, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_3/index_9448_seed_15079_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.016309738461859524, + "vlm_logprob": -0.016309738461859524, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.016309738461859524, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of an ornate silver hairpin reflected in a mirror?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a delicate, pale hand with slender fingers visible grasping the hairpin between the thumb and index finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hairpin feature an intricately carved phoenix body made of sterling silver with a subtle patina and a single opaline pearl dangling from its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand move with a slow, hypnotic rhythm to lift and then descend the hairpin, causing the reflection to elongate and the pearl to sway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of thick, deep red silk fabric with undulating folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02392260730266571 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7739226818084717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02392260730266571, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02392260730266571, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05697116255760193, + 0.029357420280575752, + 0.061372220516204834, + 0.08525626361370087, + 0.08752921968698502, + 0.08429774641990662, + 0.05490991845726967, + 0.43380144238471985, + 0.03226563706994057, + 0.07423897832632065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02392260730266571 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of an ornate silver hairpin reflected in a mirror?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a delicate, pale hand with slender fingers visible grasping the hairpin between the thumb and index finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hairpin feature an intricately carved phoenix body made of sterling silver with a subtle patina and a single opaline pearl dangling from its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand move with a slow, hypnotic rhythm to lift and then descend the hairpin, causing the reflection to elongate and the pearl to sway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of thick, deep red silk fabric with undulating folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014201176352798939 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2642011642456055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014201176352798939, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014201176352798939, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07719714194536209, + 0.06476452201604843, + 0.03639165684580803, + 0.1508534699678421, + 0.35352635383605957, + 0.05674954131245613, + 0.020040247589349747, + 0.14295732975006104, + 0.04360302910208702, + 0.05391671508550644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014201176352798939 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of an ornate silver hairpin reflected in a mirror?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a delicate, pale hand with slender fingers visible grasping the hairpin between the thumb and index finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hairpin feature an intricately carved phoenix body made of sterling silver with a subtle patina and a single opaline pearl dangling from its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand move with a slow, hypnotic rhythm to lift and then descend the hairpin, causing the reflection to elongate and the pearl to sway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of thick, deep red silk fabric with undulating folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029846109449863434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.52984619140625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029846109449863434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029846109449863434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08164934068918228, + 0.04069524258375168, + 0.010615801438689232, + 0.0591634176671505, + 0.3844291865825653, + 0.1924629956483841, + 0.020128261297941208, + 0.030687494203448296, + 0.06533072888851166, + 0.11483750492334366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029846109449863434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of an ornate silver hairpin reflected in a mirror?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a delicate, pale hand with slender fingers visible grasping the hairpin between the thumb and index finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hairpin feature an intricately carved phoenix body made of sterling silver with a subtle patina and a single opaline pearl dangling from its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand move with a slow, hypnotic rhythm to lift and then descend the hairpin, causing the reflection to elongate and the pearl to sway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of thick, deep red silk fabric with undulating folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012539238668978214 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387539386749268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012539238668978214, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012539238668978214, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05469999089837074, + 0.022500883787870407, + 0.026196002960205078, + 0.0893959179520607, + 0.3796885013580322, + 0.17878547310829163, + 0.021954700350761414, + 0.1205933690071106, + 0.043974582105875015, + 0.062210556119680405 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012539238668978214 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of an ornate silver hairpin reflected in a mirror?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a delicate, pale hand with slender fingers visible grasping the hairpin between the thumb and index finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hairpin feature an intricately carved phoenix body made of sterling silver with a subtle patina and a single opaline pearl dangling from its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand move with a slow, hypnotic rhythm to lift and then descend the hairpin, causing the reflection to elongate and the pearl to sway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of thick, deep red silk fabric with undulating folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001039560534991324 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876039505004883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001039560534991324, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001039560534991324, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07880780845880508, + 0.013299661688506603, + 0.08782070875167847, + 0.039480216801166534, + 0.19168183207511902, + 0.11609899997711182, + 0.048614177852869034, + 0.27993154525756836, + 0.06792410463094711, + 0.07634095102548599 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001039560534991324 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle, extreme close-up captures the liquid-like reflection of an ornate silver hairpin in the mirror of a dark, black lacquered dressing table. A delicate, pale hand, its slender fingers gently grasping the hairpin between thumb and index finger; its intricately carved phoenix body, crafted from sterling silver with a subtle patina, gleams in the soft, warm light. A single, opaline, lustrous pearl dangles from its end. The hand moves with a slow, hypnotic rhythm, steadily and deliberately lifting the hairpin, elongating its reflection on the polished surface while the dangling pearl sways gracefully. Then, with the same smooth, continuous motion, the hairpin descends. The background is a beautiful soft-focus blur of thick, deep red silk fabric, its undulating folds appearing with a shallow depth of field. The warm light, coming from an unseen source off-camera, casts soft highlights on the silver carving and the hand, creating deep, gentle shadows across the vanity, evoking an atmosphere of elegance, tranquility, and profound personal connection.", + "seed": 15080, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_3/index_9448_seed_15080_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.017204549512825906, + "vlm_logprob": -0.017204549512825906, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.017204549512825906, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of an ornate silver hairpin reflected in a mirror?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a delicate, pale hand with slender fingers visible grasping the hairpin between the thumb and index finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hairpin feature an intricately carved phoenix body made of sterling silver with a subtle patina and a single opaline pearl dangling from its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand move with a slow, hypnotic rhythm to lift and then descend the hairpin, causing the reflection to elongate and the pearl to sway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of thick, deep red silk fabric with undulating folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019521258771419525 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.019521236419678 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019521258771419525, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019521258771419525, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11576490104198456, + 0.06369570642709732, + 0.08370140939950943, + 0.07460149377584457, + 0.10762502253055573, + 0.15815390646457672, + 0.07610272616147995, + 0.08462195098400116, + 0.1410183608531952, + 0.09471456706523895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019521258771419525 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of an ornate silver hairpin reflected in a mirror?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a delicate, pale hand with slender fingers visible grasping the hairpin between the thumb and index finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hairpin feature an intricately carved phoenix body made of sterling silver with a subtle patina and a single opaline pearl dangling from its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand move with a slow, hypnotic rhythm to lift and then descend the hairpin, causing the reflection to elongate and the pearl to sway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of thick, deep red silk fabric with undulating folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026358501985669136 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513586044311523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026358501985669136, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026358501985669136, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13944083452224731, + 0.22777728736400604, + 0.04944851994514465, + 0.09937799721956253, + 0.04550036042928696, + 0.06733912229537964, + 0.06477091461420059, + 0.13735947012901306, + 0.07232905924320221, + 0.0966564491391182 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026358501985669136 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of an ornate silver hairpin reflected in a mirror?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a delicate, pale hand with slender fingers visible grasping the hairpin between the thumb and index finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hairpin feature an intricately carved phoenix body made of sterling silver with a subtle patina and a single opaline pearl dangling from its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand move with a slow, hypnotic rhythm to lift and then descend the hairpin, causing the reflection to elongate and the pearl to sway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of thick, deep red silk fabric with undulating folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020620960742235184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956210613250732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020620960742235184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020620960742235184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1318667232990265, + 0.1169089525938034, + 0.06444312632083893, + 0.08948361128568649, + 0.05622962489724159, + 0.14974738657474518, + 0.10270360112190247, + 0.1052343025803566, + 0.04505333676934242, + 0.1383293867111206 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020620960742235184 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of an ornate silver hairpin reflected in a mirror?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a delicate, pale hand with slender fingers visible grasping the hairpin between the thumb and index finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hairpin feature an intricately carved phoenix body made of sterling silver with a subtle patina and a single opaline pearl dangling from its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand move with a slow, hypnotic rhythm to lift and then descend the hairpin, causing the reflection to elongate and the pearl to sway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of thick, deep red silk fabric with undulating folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818777248263359 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187999725342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818777248263359, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818777248263359, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04328073188662529, + 0.05920397490262985, + 0.050014428794384, + 0.05709174647927284, + 0.06635580956935883, + 0.2970202565193176, + 0.16326548159122467, + 0.14318591356277466, + 0.09113238751888275, + 0.029449235647916794 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818777248263359 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of an ornate silver hairpin reflected in a mirror?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a delicate, pale hand with slender fingers visible grasping the hairpin between the thumb and index finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hairpin feature an intricately carved phoenix body made of sterling silver with a subtle patina and a single opaline pearl dangling from its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand move with a slow, hypnotic rhythm to lift and then descend the hairpin, causing the reflection to elongate and the pearl to sway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of thick, deep red silk fabric with undulating folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013342535821720958 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626334190368652 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013342535821720958, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013342535821720958, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11653348058462143, + 0.036233238875865936, + 0.04954356327652931, + 0.03975234180688858, + 0.06330598890781403, + 0.27051883935928345, + 0.14233329892158508, + 0.05542833358049393, + 0.11013634502887726, + 0.1162145808339119 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013342535821720958 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle, extreme close-up captures the liquid-like reflection of an ornate silver hairpin in the mirror of a dark, black lacquered dressing table. A delicate, pale hand, its slender fingers gently grasping the hairpin between thumb and index finger; its intricately carved phoenix body, crafted from sterling silver with a subtle patina, gleams in the soft, warm light. A single, opaline, lustrous pearl dangles from its end. The hand moves with a slow, hypnotic rhythm, steadily and deliberately lifting the hairpin, elongating its reflection on the polished surface while the dangling pearl sways gracefully. Then, with the same smooth, continuous motion, the hairpin descends. The background is a beautiful soft-focus blur of thick, deep red silk fabric, its undulating folds appearing with a shallow depth of field. The warm light, coming from an unseen source off-camera, casts soft highlights on the silver carving and the hand, creating deep, gentle shadows across the vanity, evoking an atmosphere of elegance, tranquility, and profound personal connection.", + "seed": 15081, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_3/index_9448_seed_15081_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.021257579722441734, + "vlm_logprob": -0.021257579722441734, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.021257579722441734, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of an ornate silver hairpin reflected in a mirror?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a delicate, pale hand with slender fingers visible grasping the hairpin between the thumb and index finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hairpin feature an intricately carved phoenix body made of sterling silver with a subtle patina and a single opaline pearl dangling from its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand move with a slow, hypnotic rhythm to lift and then descend the hairpin, causing the reflection to elongate and the pearl to sway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of thick, deep red silk fabric with undulating folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019691573455929756 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.019691467285156 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019691573455929756, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019691573455929756, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09151823073625565, + 0.14555248618125916, + 0.03234454616904259, + 0.10960739105939865, + 0.0484282486140728, + 0.07300014793872833, + 0.09085389971733093, + 0.2492886334657669, + 0.06831666827201843, + 0.09108977764844894 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019691573455929756 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of an ornate silver hairpin reflected in a mirror?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a delicate, pale hand with slender fingers visible grasping the hairpin between the thumb and index finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hairpin feature an intricately carved phoenix body made of sterling silver with a subtle patina and a single opaline pearl dangling from its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand move with a slow, hypnotic rhythm to lift and then descend the hairpin, causing the reflection to elongate and the pearl to sway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of thick, deep red silk fabric with undulating folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02635374292731285 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513538360595703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02635374292731285, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02635374292731285, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12230445444583893, + 0.2570688724517822, + 0.0647382140159607, + 0.052888669073581696, + 0.047623161226511, + 0.06705481559038162, + 0.05512101948261261, + 0.09909652918577194, + 0.13115662336349487, + 0.10294771194458008 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02635374292731285 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of an ornate silver hairpin reflected in a mirror?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a delicate, pale hand with slender fingers visible grasping the hairpin between the thumb and index finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hairpin feature an intricately carved phoenix body made of sterling silver with a subtle patina and a single opaline pearl dangling from its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand move with a slow, hypnotic rhythm to lift and then descend the hairpin, causing the reflection to elongate and the pearl to sway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of thick, deep red silk fabric with undulating folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03815077245235443 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881507873535156 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03815077245235443, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03815077245235443, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2347203940153122, + 0.11734753102064133, + 0.054264556616544724, + 0.06064192205667496, + 0.04640207439661026, + 0.1431904435157776, + 0.041140083223581314, + 0.11536449939012527, + 0.09895370900630951, + 0.08797479420900345 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03815077245235443 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of an ornate silver hairpin reflected in a mirror?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a delicate, pale hand with slender fingers visible grasping the hairpin between the thumb and index finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hairpin feature an intricately carved phoenix body made of sterling silver with a subtle patina and a single opaline pearl dangling from its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand move with a slow, hypnotic rhythm to lift and then descend the hairpin, causing the reflection to elongate and the pearl to sway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of thick, deep red silk fabric with undulating folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020581139251589775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955812454223633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020581139251589775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020581139251589775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19680967926979065, + 0.06832754611968994, + 0.044635966420173645, + 0.10077463090419769, + 0.17690828442573547, + 0.12453608214855194, + 0.03934799134731293, + 0.11229342967271805, + 0.05482454225420952, + 0.08154178410768509 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020581139251589775 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of an ornate silver hairpin reflected in a mirror?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a delicate, pale hand with slender fingers visible grasping the hairpin between the thumb and index finger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hairpin feature an intricately carved phoenix body made of sterling silver with a subtle patina and a single opaline pearl dangling from its end?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand move with a slow, hypnotic rhythm to lift and then descend the hairpin, causing the reflection to elongate and the pearl to sway?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur of thick, deep red silk fabric with undulating folds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001510670525021851 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.5015106201171875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001510670525021851, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001510670525021851, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17470276355743408, + 0.14254127442836761, + 0.0335041843354702, + 0.03306286036968231, + 0.10903926938772202, + 0.05356365814805031, + 0.056622762233018875, + 0.2076576054096222, + 0.10964522510766983, + 0.07966042309999466 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001510670525021851 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_4/index_tensor([4114, 4114])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_4/index_tensor([4114, 4114])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6351ab531c5abfbcc7705bf4e07d6a322897c1e3 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_4/index_tensor([4114, 4114])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatic crane shot begins from a low, ground-hugging angle, capturing a close-up of the massive wooden wheels of a four-wheeled carriage spinning rapidly. Each rotation of the wheel's iron rims violently spurts dark brown mud and stagnant water from the road backward and to the sides, creating arcing trails of mud. As the camera smoothly and steadily ascends, a magnificent carriage, towed by four muscular, glossy black horses, emerges. The carriage, crafted from deep red wood polished to a mirror-like finish, features intricate gold carvings along the edges and adorned with elegant brass lanterns. The carriage races at full speed along a muddy dirt road at the edge of a forest, flanked by towering, ancient trees. The golden evening sunlight filters through the dense foliage, casting dappled, shifting shadows on the wet ground and the jolting carriage. As the camera passes over the driver's back as he drives intently, it finally gracefully passes over the curved leather roof and ends with a brief bird's-eye view, showing the spectacular sight of the carriage speeding away on the vast and tranquil forest path. The whole picture is full of power, speed and classical dramatic atmosphere.", + "seed": 13198, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_4/index_4114_seed_13198_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06169535703957081, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06169535703957081, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.999999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06169535703957081, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of massive wooden wheels spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the wheels spurts dark brown mud and stagnant water creating arcing trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage towed by four muscular, glossy black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage made of deep red wood with gold carvings and brass lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera ascend from a low angle to a bird's-eye view, passing over the driver and roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.031297024339437485 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.531296968460083 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.031297024339437485, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.031297024339437485, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25460320711135864, + 0.060048658400774, + 0.047829411923885345, + 0.09914949536323547, + 0.03400851786136627, + 0.03247848525643349, + 0.06443110853433609, + 0.08629851043224335, + 0.21485093235969543, + 0.1063016876578331 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.031297024339437485 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of massive wooden wheels spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the wheels spurts dark brown mud and stagnant water creating arcing trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage towed by four muscular, glossy black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage made of deep red wood with gold carvings and brass lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera ascend from a low angle to a bird's-eye view, passing over the driver and roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055031586438417435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300315380096436 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055031586438417435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055031586438417435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3513927757740021, + 0.10249616950750351, + 0.06046795845031738, + 0.053206104785203934, + 0.026481226086616516, + 0.028728701174259186, + 0.04568975418806076, + 0.04128140211105347, + 0.21075527369976044, + 0.07950060069561005 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055031586438417435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of massive wooden wheels spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the wheels spurts dark brown mud and stagnant water creating arcing trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage towed by four muscular, glossy black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage made of deep red wood with gold carvings and brass lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera ascend from a low angle to a bird's-eye view, passing over the driver and roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12707503139972687 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127074956893921 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12707503139972687, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12707503139972687, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09896032512187958, + 0.07081466168165207, + 0.05299840494990349, + 0.06872250139713287, + 0.05628567561507225, + 0.059671804308891296, + 0.2738173007965088, + 0.06662695109844208, + 0.15687452256679535, + 0.09522783756256104 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12707503139972687 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of massive wooden wheels spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the wheels spurts dark brown mud and stagnant water creating arcing trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage towed by four muscular, glossy black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage made of deep red wood with gold carvings and brass lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera ascend from a low angle to a bird's-eye view, passing over the driver and roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016097577288746834 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141097545623779 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016097577288746834, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016097577288746834, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11536242812871933, + 0.05234074965119362, + 0.11149685084819794, + 0.0709998607635498, + 0.06814664602279663, + 0.14289450645446777, + 0.15022413432598114, + 0.07493995130062103, + 0.14768444001674652, + 0.06591037660837173 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016097577288746834 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of massive wooden wheels spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the wheels spurts dark brown mud and stagnant water creating arcing trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage towed by four muscular, glossy black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage made of deep red wood with gold carvings and brass lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera ascend from a low angle to a bird's-eye view, passing over the driver and roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897556573152542 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789756774902344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897556573152542, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897556573152542, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26976072788238525, + 0.05201557278633118, + 0.047844644635915756, + 0.05248025804758072, + 0.06866361200809479, + 0.08058249950408936, + 0.06560124456882477, + 0.11006340384483337, + 0.14457660913467407, + 0.10841149091720581 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897556573152542 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic crane shot begins from a low, ground-hugging angle, capturing a close-up of the massive wooden wheels of a four-wheeled carriage spinning rapidly. Each rotation of the wheel's iron rims violently spurts dark brown mud and stagnant water from the road backward and to the sides, creating arcing trails of mud. As the camera smoothly and steadily ascends, a magnificent carriage, towed by four muscular, glossy black horses, emerges. The carriage, crafted from deep red wood polished to a mirror-like finish, features intricate gold carvings along the edges and adorned with elegant brass lanterns. The carriage races at full speed along a muddy dirt road at the edge of a forest, flanked by towering, ancient trees. The golden evening sunlight filters through the dense foliage, casting dappled, shifting shadows on the wet ground and the jolting carriage. As the camera passes over the driver's back as he drives intently, it finally gracefully passes over the curved leather roof and ends with a brief bird's-eye view, showing the spectacular sight of the carriage speeding away on the vast and tranquil forest path. The whole picture is full of power, speed and classical dramatic atmosphere.", + "seed": 13199, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_4/index_4114_seed_13199_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.05103878136724234, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05103878136724234, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05103878136724234, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of massive wooden wheels spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the wheels spurts dark brown mud and stagnant water creating arcing trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage towed by four muscular, glossy black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage made of deep red wood with gold carvings and brass lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera ascend from a low angle to a bird's-eye view, passing over the driver and roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08010711520910263 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5801072120666504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08010711520910263, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08010711520910263, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21704797446727753, + 0.13841453194618225, + 0.1052226573228836, + 0.05764961615204811, + 0.19274303317070007, + 0.02974015101790428, + 0.03932030126452446, + 0.06614871323108673, + 0.11978989094495773, + 0.033923108130693436 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08010711520910263 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of massive wooden wheels spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the wheels spurts dark brown mud and stagnant water creating arcing trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage towed by four muscular, glossy black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage made of deep red wood with gold carvings and brass lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera ascend from a low angle to a bird's-eye view, passing over the driver and roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07905741035938263 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579057455062866 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07905741035938263, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07905741035938263, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2599192261695862, + 0.23579716682434082, + 0.08557895570993423, + 0.027138780802488327, + 0.17277853190898895, + 0.017487110570073128, + 0.047353606671094894, + 0.0588405579328537, + 0.05557696521282196, + 0.039529118686914444 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07905741035938263 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of massive wooden wheels spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the wheels spurts dark brown mud and stagnant water creating arcing trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage towed by four muscular, glossy black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage made of deep red wood with gold carvings and brass lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera ascend from a low angle to a bird's-eye view, passing over the driver and roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062044475227594376 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812044382095337 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062044475227594376, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062044475227594376, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3063914477825165, + 0.10595124214887619, + 0.042576659470796585, + 0.03944147005677223, + 0.09495075047016144, + 0.05354519188404083, + 0.054752953350543976, + 0.20636612176895142, + 0.049604080617427826, + 0.04642007127404213 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062044475227594376 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of massive wooden wheels spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the wheels spurts dark brown mud and stagnant water creating arcing trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage towed by four muscular, glossy black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage made of deep red wood with gold carvings and brass lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera ascend from a low angle to a bird's-eye view, passing over the driver and roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007641962729394436 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882641792297363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007641962729394436, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007641962729394436, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16873130202293396, + 0.06888233125209808, + 0.05309070274233818, + 0.12639115750789642, + 0.3903159499168396, + 0.027844928205013275, + 0.03504128381609917, + 0.035301323980093, + 0.050344862043857574, + 0.04405616223812103 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007641962729394436 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of massive wooden wheels spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the wheels spurts dark brown mud and stagnant water creating arcing trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage towed by four muscular, glossy black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage made of deep red wood with gold carvings and brass lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera ascend from a low angle to a bird's-eye view, passing over the driver and roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634294331073761 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513428688049316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634294331073761, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634294331073761, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1616038829088211, + 0.07125575840473175, + 0.07559971511363983, + 0.2260926365852356, + 0.18375486135482788, + 0.028115497902035713, + 0.07056251168251038, + 0.09801967442035675, + 0.05379047989845276, + 0.031205005943775177 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634294331073761 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic crane shot begins from a low, ground-hugging angle, capturing a close-up of the massive wooden wheels of a four-wheeled carriage spinning rapidly. Each rotation of the wheel's iron rims violently spurts dark brown mud and stagnant water from the road backward and to the sides, creating arcing trails of mud. As the camera smoothly and steadily ascends, a magnificent carriage, towed by four muscular, glossy black horses, emerges. The carriage, crafted from deep red wood polished to a mirror-like finish, features intricate gold carvings along the edges and adorned with elegant brass lanterns. The carriage races at full speed along a muddy dirt road at the edge of a forest, flanked by towering, ancient trees. The golden evening sunlight filters through the dense foliage, casting dappled, shifting shadows on the wet ground and the jolting carriage. As the camera passes over the driver's back as he drives intently, it finally gracefully passes over the curved leather roof and ends with a brief bird's-eye view, showing the spectacular sight of the carriage speeding away on the vast and tranquil forest path. The whole picture is full of power, speed and classical dramatic atmosphere.", + "seed": 13200, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_4/index_4114_seed_13200_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.07494232468307019, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07494232468307019, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07494232468307019, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of massive wooden wheels spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the wheels spurts dark brown mud and stagnant water creating arcing trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage towed by four muscular, glossy black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage made of deep red wood with gold carvings and brass lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera ascend from a low angle to a bird's-eye view, passing over the driver and roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02209312655031681 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8970930576324463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02209312655031681, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02209312655031681, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19810113310813904, + 0.135682612657547, + 0.041968751698732376, + 0.16525709629058838, + 0.021435892209410667, + 0.055084895342588425, + 0.0474628321826458, + 0.24676723778247833, + 0.04486852139234543, + 0.043371088802814484 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02209312655031681 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of massive wooden wheels spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the wheels spurts dark brown mud and stagnant water creating arcing trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage towed by four muscular, glossy black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage made of deep red wood with gold carvings and brass lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera ascend from a low angle to a bird's-eye view, passing over the driver and roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04872426763176918 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0487241744995117 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04872426763176918, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04872426763176918, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17577558755874634, + 0.14230310916900635, + 0.03166591748595238, + 0.18913449347019196, + 0.055733416229486465, + 0.16395054757595062, + 0.05641688033938408, + 0.10262755304574966, + 0.029909564182162285, + 0.052483007311820984 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04872426763176918 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of massive wooden wheels spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the wheels spurts dark brown mud and stagnant water creating arcing trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage towed by four muscular, glossy black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage made of deep red wood with gold carvings and brass lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera ascend from a low angle to a bird's-eye view, passing over the driver and roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015863060951233 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015862464904785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2015863060951233, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2015863060951233, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.311471164226532, + 0.12016794085502625, + 0.03258344158530235, + 0.09937556833028793, + 0.13375505805015564, + 0.08705798536539078, + 0.07756314426660538, + 0.07778265327215195, + 0.03804093971848488, + 0.022202054038643837 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2015863060951233 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of massive wooden wheels spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the wheels spurts dark brown mud and stagnant water creating arcing trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage towed by four muscular, glossy black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage made of deep red wood with gold carvings and brass lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera ascend from a low angle to a bird's-eye view, passing over the driver and roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02332673966884613 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733266353607178 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02332673966884613, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02332673966884613, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08781913667917252, + 0.048313435167074203, + 0.025425657629966736, + 0.290009468793869, + 0.06675682216882706, + 0.07080003619194031, + 0.04591110348701477, + 0.27960172295570374, + 0.03468526899814606, + 0.050677426159381866 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02332673966884613 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of massive wooden wheels spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the wheels spurts dark brown mud and stagnant water creating arcing trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage towed by four muscular, glossy black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage made of deep red wood with gold carvings and brass lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera ascend from a low angle to a bird's-eye view, passing over the driver and roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0789811834692955 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789811611175537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0789811834692955, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0789811834692955, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.038031917065382004, + 0.03667164221405983, + 0.026783017441630363, + 0.049772199243307114, + 0.024082358926534653, + 0.13105517625808716, + 0.0929517075419426, + 0.4536662697792053, + 0.042980704456567764, + 0.10400497168302536 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0789811834692955 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic crane shot begins from a low, ground-hugging angle, capturing a close-up of the massive wooden wheels of a four-wheeled carriage spinning rapidly. Each rotation of the wheel's iron rims violently spurts dark brown mud and stagnant water from the road backward and to the sides, creating arcing trails of mud. As the camera smoothly and steadily ascends, a magnificent carriage, towed by four muscular, glossy black horses, emerges. The carriage, crafted from deep red wood polished to a mirror-like finish, features intricate gold carvings along the edges and adorned with elegant brass lanterns. The carriage races at full speed along a muddy dirt road at the edge of a forest, flanked by towering, ancient trees. The golden evening sunlight filters through the dense foliage, casting dappled, shifting shadows on the wet ground and the jolting carriage. As the camera passes over the driver's back as he drives intently, it finally gracefully passes over the curved leather roof and ends with a brief bird's-eye view, showing the spectacular sight of the carriage speeding away on the vast and tranquil forest path. The whole picture is full of power, speed and classical dramatic atmosphere.", + "seed": 13201, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_4/index_4114_seed_13201_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.058359472453594206, + "vlm_logprob": -0.058359472453594206, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.058359472453594206, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of massive wooden wheels spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the wheels spurts dark brown mud and stagnant water creating arcing trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage towed by four muscular, glossy black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage made of deep red wood with gold carvings and brass lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera ascend from a low angle to a bird's-eye view, passing over the driver and roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08045002818107605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5804500579833984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08045002818107605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08045002818107605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5703707933425903, + 0.02117435447871685, + 0.02169920690357685, + 0.05863211303949356, + 0.027712520211935043, + 0.05921522155404091, + 0.05118926987051964, + 0.09834964573383331, + 0.08452664315700531, + 0.0071302237920463085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08045002818107605 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of massive wooden wheels spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the wheels spurts dark brown mud and stagnant water creating arcing trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage towed by four muscular, glossy black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage made of deep red wood with gold carvings and brass lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera ascend from a low angle to a bird's-eye view, passing over the driver and roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04874254763126373 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0487425327301025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04874254763126373, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04874254763126373, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29085108637809753, + 0.10272369533777237, + 0.037489186972379684, + 0.051257070153951645, + 0.05179464444518089, + 0.1142265647649765, + 0.04570244997739792, + 0.1481161266565323, + 0.14025498926639557, + 0.017584150657057762 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04874254763126373 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of massive wooden wheels spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the wheels spurts dark brown mud and stagnant water creating arcing trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage towed by four muscular, glossy black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage made of deep red wood with gold carvings and brass lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera ascend from a low angle to a bird's-eye view, passing over the driver and roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026357341557741165 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651357412338257 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026357341557741165, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026357341557741165, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5891304016113281, + 0.04564174637198448, + 0.01998881623148918, + 0.07162094116210938, + 0.055129971355199814, + 0.06190712749958038, + 0.061247143894433975, + 0.0349508672952652, + 0.043976981192827225, + 0.016406027600169182 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026357341557741165 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of massive wooden wheels spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the wheels spurts dark brown mud and stagnant water creating arcing trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage towed by four muscular, glossy black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage made of deep red wood with gold carvings and brass lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera ascend from a low angle to a bird's-eye view, passing over the driver and roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023308921605348587 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733089923858643 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023308921605348587, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023308921605348587, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24116572737693787, + 0.08104255050420761, + 0.03656453639268875, + 0.045781392604112625, + 0.22351427376270294, + 0.11382024735212326, + 0.07594618201255798, + 0.050909802317619324, + 0.09156498312950134, + 0.039690300822257996 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023308921605348587 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of massive wooden wheels spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the wheels spurts dark brown mud and stagnant water creating arcing trails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage towed by four muscular, glossy black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the carriage made of deep red wood with gold carvings and brass lanterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera ascend from a low angle to a bird's-eye view, passing over the driver and roof?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1129385232925415 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237938404083252 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1129385232925415, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1129385232925415, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1017671674489975, + 0.07878948748111725, + 0.055893778800964355, + 0.13579699397087097, + 0.1195811927318573, + 0.09576279670000076, + 0.17099757492542267, + 0.07530607283115387, + 0.10602171719074249, + 0.06008320301771164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1129385232925415 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_5/index_tensor([7847, 7847])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_5/index_tensor([7847, 7847])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c8396a7ab0084eee9d91767cca503497eeffbdbe --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_5/index_tensor([7847, 7847])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "This extreme close-up, shot in dramatic slow motion with a static macro lens, focuses on a dog's damp, leathery black nose as it deliberately presses against the textured surface of a dark wooden floor. Warm, golden sunlight, shimmering at a low angle, frames the image, creating sharp highlights on the nose's glistening moisture and illuminating the deep grain of the wood. As the nose makes contact, its tip compresses slightly, leaving a faint damp imprint. Then, with forceful and focused flaring, the force of the inhalation creates a micro-vortex that lifts and swirls tiny, backlit dust particles from the floor's surface, sending them dancing through the air like glitter. Rendered in surreal detail, from the pebbled texture of the dog's nose to the individual specks of dust, the scene creates a focused and intense sensory atmosphere that amplifies the primal act of smell.", + "seed": 20030, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_5/index_7847_seed_20030_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.10858515216968953, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10858515216968953, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10858515216968953, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a dog's damp, black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nose pressing against a dark wooden floor with visible grain texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the nose tip compress slightly to leave a faint damp imprint upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the inhalation create a micro-vortex that lifts and swirls tiny dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden sunlight at a low angle creating sharp highlights on the nose and wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00354127143509686 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.628541469573975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00354127143509686, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00354127143509686, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15794584155082703, + 0.34482863545417786, + 0.03627854585647583, + 0.01846231147646904, + 0.03871172294020653, + 0.018831437453627586, + 0.20310348272323608, + 0.09196547418832779, + 0.05819711089134216, + 0.03167537972331047 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00354127143509686 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a dog's damp, black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nose pressing against a dark wooden floor with visible grain texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the nose tip compress slightly to leave a faint damp imprint upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the inhalation create a micro-vortex that lifts and swirls tiny dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden sunlight at a low angle creating sharp highlights on the nose and wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011101856827735901 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511101722717285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011101856827735901, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011101856827735901, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20670725405216217, + 0.4333307445049286, + 0.03605080023407936, + 0.012961708940565586, + 0.1985260397195816, + 0.03121783211827278, + 0.017425591126084328, + 0.02190319634974003, + 0.021551551297307014, + 0.02032528445124626 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011101856827735901 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a dog's damp, black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nose pressing against a dark wooden floor with visible grain texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the nose tip compress slightly to leave a faint damp imprint upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the inhalation create a micro-vortex that lifts and swirls tiny dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden sunlight at a low angle creating sharp highlights on the nose and wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04869145527482033 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048691511154175 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04869145527482033, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04869145527482033, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14301081001758575, + 0.5048056244850159, + 0.04113948717713356, + 0.019975291565060616, + 0.029893791303038597, + 0.02387498877942562, + 0.03837575763463974, + 0.0771765410900116, + 0.039923641830682755, + 0.08182407170534134 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04869145527482033 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a dog's damp, black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nose pressing against a dark wooden floor with visible grain texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the nose tip compress slightly to leave a faint damp imprint upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the inhalation create a micro-vortex that lifts and swirls tiny dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden sunlight at a low angle creating sharp highlights on the nose and wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4743342995643616 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9743342995643616 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4743342995643616, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4743342995643616, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10086359083652496, + 0.5322074890136719, + 0.03472653776407242, + 0.029047859832644463, + 0.04093019291758537, + 0.02035442180931568, + 0.018583979457616806, + 0.05937819182872772, + 0.08125520497560501, + 0.0826525017619133 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4743342995643616 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a dog's damp, black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nose pressing against a dark wooden floor with visible grain texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the nose tip compress slightly to leave a faint damp imprint upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the inhalation create a micro-vortex that lifts and swirls tiny dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden sunlight at a low angle creating sharp highlights on the nose and wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00525687774643302 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255256652832031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00525687774643302, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00525687774643302, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15630599856376648, + 0.5860300064086914, + 0.02046259678900242, + 0.012151041068136692, + 0.0510970763862133, + 0.014463469386100769, + 0.01833276078104973, + 0.026468243449926376, + 0.05475043132901192, + 0.059938449412584305 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00525687774643302 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This extreme close-up, shot in dramatic slow motion with a static macro lens, focuses on a dog's damp, leathery black nose as it deliberately presses against the textured surface of a dark wooden floor. Warm, golden sunlight, shimmering at a low angle, frames the image, creating sharp highlights on the nose's glistening moisture and illuminating the deep grain of the wood. As the nose makes contact, its tip compresses slightly, leaving a faint damp imprint. Then, with forceful and focused flaring, the force of the inhalation creates a micro-vortex that lifts and swirls tiny, backlit dust particles from the floor's surface, sending them dancing through the air like glitter. Rendered in surreal detail, from the pebbled texture of the dog's nose to the individual specks of dust, the scene creates a focused and intense sensory atmosphere that amplifies the primal act of smell.", + "seed": 20031, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_5/index_7847_seed_20031_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0807113703340292, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0807113703340292, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0807113703340292, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a dog's damp, black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nose pressing against a dark wooden floor with visible grain texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the nose tip compress slightly to leave a faint damp imprint upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the inhalation create a micro-vortex that lifts and swirls tiny dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden sunlight at a low angle creating sharp highlights on the nose and wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003919895738363266 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753920078277588 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003919895738363266, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003919895738363266, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16235964000225067, + 0.0637897253036499, + 0.10751569271087646, + 0.07718845456838608, + 0.11282182484865189, + 0.09755485504865646, + 0.1619640588760376, + 0.06166207417845726, + 0.03829875960946083, + 0.11684487015008926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003919895738363266 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a dog's damp, black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nose pressing against a dark wooden floor with visible grain texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the nose tip compress slightly to leave a faint damp imprint upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the inhalation create a micro-vortex that lifts and swirls tiny dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden sunlight at a low angle creating sharp highlights on the nose and wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029818570241332054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529818534851074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029818570241332054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029818570241332054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33560213446617126, + 0.08183632791042328, + 0.07433494180440903, + 0.06775910407304764, + 0.07316508144140244, + 0.03320169448852539, + 0.07518335431814194, + 0.09092454612255096, + 0.024051526561379433, + 0.14394129812717438 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029818570241332054 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a dog's damp, black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nose pressing against a dark wooden floor with visible grain texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the nose tip compress slightly to leave a faint damp imprint upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the inhalation create a micro-vortex that lifts and swirls tiny dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden sunlight at a low angle creating sharp highlights on the nose and wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812357783317566 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288123607635498 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812357783317566, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812357783317566, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10499194264411926, + 0.04132523760199547, + 0.07258683443069458, + 0.11319796741008759, + 0.17164283990859985, + 0.09467081725597382, + 0.15835919976234436, + 0.08271246403455734, + 0.05716843530535698, + 0.10334432870149612 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812357783317566 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a dog's damp, black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nose pressing against a dark wooden floor with visible grain texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the nose tip compress slightly to leave a faint damp imprint upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the inhalation create a micro-vortex that lifts and swirls tiny dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden sunlight at a low angle creating sharp highlights on the nose and wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3135029375553131 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3135029077529907 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3135029375553131, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3135029375553131, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18963623046875, + 0.046279408037662506, + 0.03689968213438988, + 0.16686657071113586, + 0.2862950265407562, + 0.05305344983935356, + 0.052320126444101334, + 0.04936431720852852, + 0.01958220638334751, + 0.09970298409461975 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3135029375553131 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a dog's damp, black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nose pressing against a dark wooden floor with visible grain texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the nose tip compress slightly to leave a faint damp imprint upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the inhalation create a micro-vortex that lifts and swirls tiny dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden sunlight at a low angle creating sharp highlights on the nose and wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0181918703019619 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018191814422607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0181918703019619, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0181918703019619, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23187604546546936, + 0.04441063106060028, + 0.056602559983730316, + 0.12760384380817413, + 0.10570365190505981, + 0.15182417631149292, + 0.055577363818883896, + 0.0686761662364006, + 0.04807814210653305, + 0.10964743047952652 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0181918703019619 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This extreme close-up, shot in dramatic slow motion with a static macro lens, focuses on a dog's damp, leathery black nose as it deliberately presses against the textured surface of a dark wooden floor. Warm, golden sunlight, shimmering at a low angle, frames the image, creating sharp highlights on the nose's glistening moisture and illuminating the deep grain of the wood. As the nose makes contact, its tip compresses slightly, leaving a faint damp imprint. Then, with forceful and focused flaring, the force of the inhalation creates a micro-vortex that lifts and swirls tiny, backlit dust particles from the floor's surface, sending them dancing through the air like glitter. Rendered in surreal detail, from the pebbled texture of the dog's nose to the individual specks of dust, the scene creates a focused and intense sensory atmosphere that amplifies the primal act of smell.", + "seed": 20032, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_5/index_7847_seed_20032_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03987868884578347, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03987868884578347, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.024999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03987868884578347, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a dog's damp, black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nose pressing against a dark wooden floor with visible grain texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the nose tip compress slightly to leave a faint damp imprint upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the inhalation create a micro-vortex that lifts and swirls tiny dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden sunlight at a low angle creating sharp highlights on the nose and wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004161152057349682 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.879161357879639 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004161152057349682, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004161152057349682, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21705283224582672, + 0.06401941180229187, + 0.045621249824762344, + 0.06353842467069626, + 0.05531034991145134, + 0.1193615049123764, + 0.07227127999067307, + 0.2583976089954376, + 0.05463588610291481, + 0.04979139566421509 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004161152057349682 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a dog's damp, black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nose pressing against a dark wooden floor with visible grain texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the nose tip compress slightly to leave a faint damp imprint upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the inhalation create a micro-vortex that lifts and swirls tiny dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden sunlight at a low angle creating sharp highlights on the nose and wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033714812248945236 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408714771270752 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033714812248945236, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033714812248945236, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11484833061695099, + 0.15178093314170837, + 0.05600576847791672, + 0.054062556475400925, + 0.08283799886703491, + 0.13978232443332672, + 0.056169647723436356, + 0.11821721494197845, + 0.12472476065158844, + 0.10157041996717453 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033714812248945236 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a dog's damp, black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nose pressing against a dark wooden floor with visible grain texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the nose tip compress slightly to leave a faint damp imprint upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the inhalation create a micro-vortex that lifts and swirls tiny dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden sunlight at a low angle creating sharp highlights on the nose and wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029817529022693634 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529817581176758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029817529022693634, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029817529022693634, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35470423102378845, + 0.035885121673345566, + 0.04148849844932556, + 0.030493957921862602, + 0.029704464599490166, + 0.09030910581350327, + 0.027720194309949875, + 0.2739483118057251, + 0.052288834005594254, + 0.06345735490322113 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029817529022693634 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a dog's damp, black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nose pressing against a dark wooden floor with visible grain texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the nose tip compress slightly to leave a faint damp imprint upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the inhalation create a micro-vortex that lifts and swirls tiny dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden sunlight at a low angle creating sharp highlights on the nose and wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12706191837787628 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270618438720703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12706191837787628, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12706191837787628, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25826314091682434, + 0.029024485498666763, + 0.0304532740265131, + 0.02445545606315136, + 0.034619856625795364, + 0.04502681642770767, + 0.03471098467707634, + 0.4810698628425598, + 0.030786970630288124, + 0.03158918023109436 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12706191837787628 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a dog's damp, black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nose pressing against a dark wooden floor with visible grain texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the nose tip compress slightly to leave a faint damp imprint upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the inhalation create a micro-vortex that lifts and swirls tiny dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden sunlight at a low angle creating sharp highlights on the nose and wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046380325220525265 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379638195037842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046380325220525265, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046380325220525265, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29571011662483215, + 0.12210488319396973, + 0.05441587418317795, + 0.04996984824538231, + 0.05675068497657776, + 0.2575409412384033, + 0.04796849191188812, + 0.04342102259397507, + 0.0322270393371582, + 0.0398910790681839 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046380325220525265 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This extreme close-up, shot in dramatic slow motion with a static macro lens, focuses on a dog's damp, leathery black nose as it deliberately presses against the textured surface of a dark wooden floor. Warm, golden sunlight, shimmering at a low angle, frames the image, creating sharp highlights on the nose's glistening moisture and illuminating the deep grain of the wood. As the nose makes contact, its tip compresses slightly, leaving a faint damp imprint. Then, with forceful and focused flaring, the force of the inhalation creates a micro-vortex that lifts and swirls tiny, backlit dust particles from the floor's surface, sending them dancing through the air like glitter. Rendered in surreal detail, from the pebbled texture of the dog's nose to the individual specks of dust, the scene creates a focused and intense sensory atmosphere that amplifies the primal act of smell.", + "seed": 20033, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_5/index_7847_seed_20033_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.056490621715784076, + "vlm_logprob": -0.056490621715784076, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.056490621715784076, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a dog's damp, black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nose pressing against a dark wooden floor with visible grain texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the nose tip compress slightly to leave a faint damp imprint upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the inhalation create a micro-vortex that lifts and swirls tiny dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden sunlight at a low angle creating sharp highlights on the nose and wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019391601905226707 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0193915367126465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019391601905226707, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019391601905226707, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5029907822608948, + 0.07089541107416153, + 0.03554477170109749, + 0.21220722794532776, + 0.03773833066225052, + 0.024320846423506737, + 0.03687321022152901, + 0.030268855392932892, + 0.026505649089813232, + 0.022654876112937927 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019391601905226707 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a dog's damp, black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nose pressing against a dark wooden floor with visible grain texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the nose tip compress slightly to leave a faint damp imprint upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the inhalation create a micro-vortex that lifts and swirls tiny dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden sunlight at a low angle creating sharp highlights on the nose and wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029825396835803986 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529825448989868 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029825396835803986, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029825396835803986, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5137666463851929, + 0.09930730611085892, + 0.05958377197384834, + 0.0681566596031189, + 0.017378514632582664, + 0.023696519434452057, + 0.05176793411374092, + 0.01921180449426174, + 0.11617524921894073, + 0.030955608934164047 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029825396835803986 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a dog's damp, black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nose pressing against a dark wooden floor with visible grain texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the nose tip compress slightly to leave a faint damp imprint upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the inhalation create a micro-vortex that lifts and swirls tiny dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden sunlight at a low angle creating sharp highlights on the nose and wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048674196004867554 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486741065979004 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048674196004867554, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048674196004867554, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30592983961105347, + 0.10595622658729553, + 0.0682826116681099, + 0.06621022522449493, + 0.042966149747371674, + 0.018797647207975388, + 0.17789043486118317, + 0.10224906355142593, + 0.07319346815347672, + 0.03852428123354912 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048674196004867554 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a dog's damp, black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nose pressing against a dark wooden floor with visible grain texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the nose tip compress slightly to leave a faint damp imprint upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the inhalation create a micro-vortex that lifts and swirls tiny dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden sunlight at a low angle creating sharp highlights on the nose and wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17992162704467773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049216270446777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17992162704467773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17992162704467773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2863521873950958, + 0.1547049731016159, + 0.061861779540777206, + 0.04676919803023338, + 0.09200945496559143, + 0.019412728026509285, + 0.19434338808059692, + 0.06395522505044937, + 0.05605565756559372, + 0.02453543059527874 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17992162704467773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up focusing on a dog's damp, black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the nose pressing against a dark wooden floor with visible grain texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the nose tip compress slightly to leave a faint damp imprint upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the inhalation create a micro-vortex that lifts and swirls tiny dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden sunlight at a low angle creating sharp highlights on the nose and wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004640286788344383 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379640102386475 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004640286788344383, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004640286788344383, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.45678478479385376, + 0.0891575738787651, + 0.05245900899171829, + 0.13998694717884064, + 0.05440806597471237, + 0.016112787649035454, + 0.042035821825265884, + 0.07320686429738998, + 0.042062271386384964, + 0.03378581255674362 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004640286788344383 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_6/index_tensor([7611, 7611])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_6/index_tensor([7611, 7611])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..24302190dd45b0dcab1f2dbe09a6f665909797fd --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_6/index_tensor([7611, 7611])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The medium shot, at eye level, initially static, then unfolds in a slow, almost imperceptible dolly motion, focusing on a sharp-featured, intelligent individual with slicked-back black hair, seated in a sleek, modern wheelchair. The wheelchair itself is a marvel of minimalist design, constructed from a matte black carbon fiber frame with large, thinly spoked wheels that gleam. They wear a professional yet stylish sapphire blue silk shirt. The scene unfolds in a vast, sunlit atrium. Bright natural sunlight pours through a high, geometric, glass-paneled ceiling, casting a dramatic light across the polished concrete floor and illuminating the dancing dust particles in the air. In the background, towering indoor palm trees and the clean lines of steel support beams in a large, minimalist planter hint at the vast scale of the space. The individual delivers an impassioned speech to an unseen companion off-camera, their body leaning forward with conviction. Their hands are in constant, articulate motion; one decisively slices the air to punctuate a point, while the other opens and closes, fingers spread and then forming a fist to convey the force of their argument. These sharp, expressive gestures are not random but executed with a deliberate rhythm that reflects the passion of their speech, creating an atmosphere of deep focus and stimulating intellectual enthusiasm.", + "seed": 32410, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_6/index_7611_seed_32410_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07962081842124462, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07962081842124462, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.849999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07962081842124462, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a person with sharp features, slicked-back black hair, wearing a sapphire blue silk shirt, seated in a matte black carbon fiber wheelchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin static and then move in a slow dolly motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sunlit atrium with a high geometric glass ceiling, polished concrete floor, and indoor palm trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the individual lean forward while making articulate hand gestures, including slicing the air and forming a fist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10694921016693115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.7319493293762207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10694921016693115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10694921016693115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4026547074317932, + 0.04076126962900162, + 0.021170683205127716, + 0.09200619161128998, + 0.05405689775943756, + 0.02053476870059967, + 0.1817958652973175, + 0.05378163233399391, + 0.049235280603170395, + 0.08400265872478485 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10694921016693115 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a person with sharp features, slicked-back black hair, wearing a sapphire blue silk shirt, seated in a matte black carbon fiber wheelchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin static and then move in a slow dolly motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sunlit atrium with a high geometric glass ceiling, polished concrete floor, and indoor palm trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the individual lean forward while making articulate hand gestures, including slicing the air and forming a fist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01821446232497692 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018214225769043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01821446232497692, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01821446232497692, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.551720142364502, + 0.036898255348205566, + 0.02255002036690712, + 0.02219674177467823, + 0.0312526598572731, + 0.03045107051730156, + 0.10740426182746887, + 0.055788442492485046, + 0.11508950591087341, + 0.026648931205272675 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01821446232497692 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a person with sharp features, slicked-back black hair, wearing a sapphire blue silk shirt, seated in a matte black carbon fiber wheelchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin static and then move in a slow dolly motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sunlit atrium with a high geometric glass ceiling, polished concrete floor, and indoor palm trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the individual lean forward while making articulate hand gestures, including slicing the air and forming a fist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428038626909256 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017803907394409 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428038626909256, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428038626909256, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06810294091701508, + 0.04683375358581543, + 0.05750524252653122, + 0.06809926778078079, + 0.09345648437738419, + 0.07026107609272003, + 0.061360109597444534, + 0.08866991847753525, + 0.08794792741537094, + 0.35776329040527344 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428038626909256 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a person with sharp features, slicked-back black hair, wearing a sapphire blue silk shirt, seated in a matte black carbon fiber wheelchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin static and then move in a slow dolly motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sunlit atrium with a high geometric glass ceiling, polished concrete floor, and indoor palm trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the individual lean forward while making articulate hand gestures, including slicing the air and forming a fist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10034633427858353 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350346326828003 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10034633427858353, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10034633427858353, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20768584311008453, + 0.038393739610910416, + 0.032153960317373276, + 0.04526480287313461, + 0.05276535823941231, + 0.0598173588514328, + 0.453855037689209, + 0.034157752990722656, + 0.04451414570212364, + 0.031392015516757965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10034633427858353 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a person with sharp features, slicked-back black hair, wearing a sapphire blue silk shirt, seated in a matte black carbon fiber wheelchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin static and then move in a slow dolly motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sunlit atrium with a high geometric glass ceiling, polished concrete floor, and indoor palm trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the individual lean forward while making articulate hand gestures, including slicing the air and forming a fist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029790222644805908 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529790163040161 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029790222644805908, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029790222644805908, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4926309287548065, + 0.03370089456439018, + 0.02864457108080387, + 0.05907125025987625, + 0.10014669597148895, + 0.03108994849026203, + 0.02726985700428486, + 0.021024860441684723, + 0.09486840665340424, + 0.11155257374048233 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029790222644805908 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The medium shot, at eye level, initially static, then unfolds in a slow, almost imperceptible dolly motion, focusing on a sharp-featured, intelligent individual with slicked-back black hair, seated in a sleek, modern wheelchair. The wheelchair itself is a marvel of minimalist design, constructed from a matte black carbon fiber frame with large, thinly spoked wheels that gleam. They wear a professional yet stylish sapphire blue silk shirt. The scene unfolds in a vast, sunlit atrium. Bright natural sunlight pours through a high, geometric, glass-paneled ceiling, casting a dramatic light across the polished concrete floor and illuminating the dancing dust particles in the air. In the background, towering indoor palm trees and the clean lines of steel support beams in a large, minimalist planter hint at the vast scale of the space. The individual delivers an impassioned speech to an unseen companion off-camera, their body leaning forward with conviction. Their hands are in constant, articulate motion; one decisively slices the air to punctuate a point, while the other opens and closes, fingers spread and then forming a fist to convey the force of their argument. These sharp, expressive gestures are not random but executed with a deliberate rhythm that reflects the passion of their speech, creating an atmosphere of deep focus and stimulating intellectual enthusiasm.", + "seed": 32411, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_6/index_7611_seed_32411_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04555255169980228, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04555255169980228, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04555255169980228, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a person with sharp features, slicked-back black hair, wearing a sapphire blue silk shirt, seated in a matte black carbon fiber wheelchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin static and then move in a slow dolly motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sunlit atrium with a high geometric glass ceiling, polished concrete floor, and indoor palm trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the individual lean forward while making articulate hand gestures, including slicing the air and forming a fist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0594882071018219 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.059488296508789 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0594882071018219, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0594882071018219, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09882748126983643, + 0.1468195766210556, + 0.05984782427549362, + 0.12527942657470703, + 0.10160495340824127, + 0.10155601054430008, + 0.13459011912345886, + 0.04939565435051918, + 0.12399174273014069, + 0.05808727443218231 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0594882071018219 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a person with sharp features, slicked-back black hair, wearing a sapphire blue silk shirt, seated in a matte black carbon fiber wheelchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin static and then move in a slow dolly motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sunlit atrium with a high geometric glass ceiling, polished concrete floor, and indoor palm trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the individual lean forward while making articulate hand gestures, including slicing the air and forming a fist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009794275276362896 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634794235229492 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009794275276362896, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009794275276362896, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15843097865581512, + 0.075279101729393, + 0.08290685713291168, + 0.20213373005390167, + 0.092826709151268, + 0.0584237277507782, + 0.2167503535747528, + 0.048416439443826675, + 0.0380297414958477, + 0.026802340522408485 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009794275276362896 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a person with sharp features, slicked-back black hair, wearing a sapphire blue silk shirt, seated in a matte black carbon fiber wheelchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin static and then move in a slow dolly motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sunlit atrium with a high geometric glass ceiling, polished concrete floor, and indoor palm trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the individual lean forward while making articulate hand gestures, including slicing the air and forming a fist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14278288185596466 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0177829265594482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14278288185596466, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14278288185596466, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07140670716762543, + 0.06551551818847656, + 0.21381418406963348, + 0.12011431157588959, + 0.1737491488456726, + 0.0549083910882473, + 0.03407144546508789, + 0.03295440599322319, + 0.1791619509458542, + 0.054304029792547226 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14278288185596466 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a person with sharp features, slicked-back black hair, wearing a sapphire blue silk shirt, seated in a matte black carbon fiber wheelchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin static and then move in a slow dolly motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sunlit atrium with a high geometric glass ceiling, polished concrete floor, and indoor palm trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the individual lean forward while making articulate hand gestures, including slicing the air and forming a fist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015109085943549871 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501511096954346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015109085943549871, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015109085943549871, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10012886673212051, + 0.05434645339846611, + 0.06689204275608063, + 0.11147487163543701, + 0.20038048923015594, + 0.10384184122085571, + 0.06266014277935028, + 0.05912235006690025, + 0.05812644958496094, + 0.18302640318870544 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015109085943549871 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a person with sharp features, slicked-back black hair, wearing a sapphire blue silk shirt, seated in a matte black carbon fiber wheelchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin static and then move in a slow dolly motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sunlit atrium with a high geometric glass ceiling, polished concrete floor, and indoor palm trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the individual lean forward while making articulate hand gestures, including slicing the air and forming a fist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014186485670506954 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264186382293701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014186485670506954, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014186485670506954, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06270870566368103, + 0.06321214884519577, + 0.06375755369663239, + 0.09198455512523651, + 0.1615828573703766, + 0.0677618458867073, + 0.1950615495443344, + 0.037793900817632675, + 0.2275121808052063, + 0.028624720871448517 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014186485670506954 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The medium shot, at eye level, initially static, then unfolds in a slow, almost imperceptible dolly motion, focusing on a sharp-featured, intelligent individual with slicked-back black hair, seated in a sleek, modern wheelchair. The wheelchair itself is a marvel of minimalist design, constructed from a matte black carbon fiber frame with large, thinly spoked wheels that gleam. They wear a professional yet stylish sapphire blue silk shirt. The scene unfolds in a vast, sunlit atrium. Bright natural sunlight pours through a high, geometric, glass-paneled ceiling, casting a dramatic light across the polished concrete floor and illuminating the dancing dust particles in the air. In the background, towering indoor palm trees and the clean lines of steel support beams in a large, minimalist planter hint at the vast scale of the space. The individual delivers an impassioned speech to an unseen companion off-camera, their body leaning forward with conviction. Their hands are in constant, articulate motion; one decisively slices the air to punctuate a point, while the other opens and closes, fingers spread and then forming a fist to convey the force of their argument. These sharp, expressive gestures are not random but executed with a deliberate rhythm that reflects the passion of their speech, creating an atmosphere of deep focus and stimulating intellectual enthusiasm.", + "seed": 32412, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_6/index_7611_seed_32412_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05496006333269179, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05496006333269179, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05496006333269179, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a person with sharp features, slicked-back black hair, wearing a sapphire blue silk shirt, seated in a matte black carbon fiber wheelchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin static and then move in a slow dolly motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sunlit atrium with a high geometric glass ceiling, polished concrete floor, and indoor palm trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the individual lean forward while making articulate hand gestures, including slicing the air and forming a fist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08757346868515015 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.837573528289795 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08757346868515015, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08757346868515015, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2573026716709137, + 0.05070255696773529, + 0.040792979300022125, + 0.029925860464572906, + 0.046488936990499496, + 0.057790592312812805, + 0.08879252523183823, + 0.19624236226081848, + 0.16726939380168915, + 0.06469216197729111 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08757346868515015 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a person with sharp features, slicked-back black hair, wearing a sapphire blue silk shirt, seated in a matte black carbon fiber wheelchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin static and then move in a slow dolly motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sunlit atrium with a high geometric glass ceiling, polished concrete floor, and indoor palm trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the individual lean forward while making articulate hand gestures, including slicing the air and forming a fist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371976688504219 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408719778060913 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371976688504219, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371976688504219, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30575019121170044, + 0.10909124463796616, + 0.05101951211690903, + 0.05109162628650665, + 0.026584919542074203, + 0.08437038958072662, + 0.059982746839523315, + 0.09090732783079147, + 0.07675289362668991, + 0.14444920420646667 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371976688504219 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a person with sharp features, slicked-back black hair, wearing a sapphire blue silk shirt, seated in a matte black carbon fiber wheelchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin static and then move in a slow dolly motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sunlit atrium with a high geometric glass ceiling, polished concrete floor, and indoor palm trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the individual lean forward while making articulate hand gestures, including slicing the air and forming a fist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12703703343868256 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270370483398438 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12703703343868256, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12703703343868256, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.050182994455099106, + 0.054472777992486954, + 0.04012785106897354, + 0.06889605522155762, + 0.04654628410935402, + 0.10692666471004486, + 0.16500423848628998, + 0.13461218774318695, + 0.06031564995646477, + 0.2729153335094452 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12703703343868256 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a person with sharp features, slicked-back black hair, wearing a sapphire blue silk shirt, seated in a matte black carbon fiber wheelchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin static and then move in a slow dolly motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sunlit atrium with a high geometric glass ceiling, polished concrete floor, and indoor palm trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the individual lean forward while making articulate hand gestures, including slicing the air and forming a fist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031928059179335833 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753192901611328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031928059179335833, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031928059179335833, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2221255749464035, + 0.039990127086639404, + 0.03141229972243309, + 0.017583515495061874, + 0.02627214789390564, + 0.03613802418112755, + 0.15374881029129028, + 0.36568111181259155, + 0.09160742908716202, + 0.0154409883543849 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031928059179335833 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a person with sharp features, slicked-back black hair, wearing a sapphire blue silk shirt, seated in a matte black carbon fiber wheelchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin static and then move in a slow dolly motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sunlit atrium with a high geometric glass ceiling, polished concrete floor, and indoor palm trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the individual lean forward while making articulate hand gestures, including slicing the air and forming a fist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023277241736650467 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732772827148438 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023277241736650467, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023277241736650467, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07493289560079575, + 0.06334273517131805, + 0.041006509214639664, + 0.04775179922580719, + 0.057429708540439606, + 0.08826199173927307, + 0.08980534225702286, + 0.176934152841568, + 0.029920119792222977, + 0.3306146562099457 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023277241736650467 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The medium shot, at eye level, initially static, then unfolds in a slow, almost imperceptible dolly motion, focusing on a sharp-featured, intelligent individual with slicked-back black hair, seated in a sleek, modern wheelchair. The wheelchair itself is a marvel of minimalist design, constructed from a matte black carbon fiber frame with large, thinly spoked wheels that gleam. They wear a professional yet stylish sapphire blue silk shirt. The scene unfolds in a vast, sunlit atrium. Bright natural sunlight pours through a high, geometric, glass-paneled ceiling, casting a dramatic light across the polished concrete floor and illuminating the dancing dust particles in the air. In the background, towering indoor palm trees and the clean lines of steel support beams in a large, minimalist planter hint at the vast scale of the space. The individual delivers an impassioned speech to an unseen companion off-camera, their body leaning forward with conviction. Their hands are in constant, articulate motion; one decisively slices the air to punctuate a point, while the other opens and closes, fingers spread and then forming a fist to convey the force of their argument. These sharp, expressive gestures are not random but executed with a deliberate rhythm that reflects the passion of their speech, creating an atmosphere of deep focus and stimulating intellectual enthusiasm.", + "seed": 32413, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_6/index_7611_seed_32413_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.053987582633271816, + "vlm_logprob": -0.053987582633271816, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.053987582633271816, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a person with sharp features, slicked-back black hair, wearing a sapphire blue silk shirt, seated in a matte black carbon fiber wheelchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin static and then move in a slow dolly motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sunlit atrium with a high geometric glass ceiling, polished concrete floor, and indoor palm trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the individual lean forward while making articulate hand gestures, including slicing the air and forming a fist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1300831288099289 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2550830841064453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1300831288099289, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1300831288099289, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5179371237754822, + 0.08338020741939545, + 0.029245318844914436, + 0.037018511444330215, + 0.045562807470560074, + 0.03700675070285797, + 0.03388024866580963, + 0.07490365952253342, + 0.05442403629422188, + 0.08664137870073318 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1300831288099289 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a person with sharp features, slicked-back black hair, wearing a sapphire blue silk shirt, seated in a matte black carbon fiber wheelchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin static and then move in a slow dolly motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sunlit atrium with a high geometric glass ceiling, polished concrete floor, and indoor palm trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the individual lean forward while making articulate hand gestures, including slicing the air and forming a fist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866965487599373 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486695766448975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866965487599373, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866965487599373, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4065615236759186, + 0.09934227913618088, + 0.07437785714864731, + 0.05178143084049225, + 0.07072877883911133, + 0.0352802537381649, + 0.04160432890057564, + 0.0660361722111702, + 0.03266754373908043, + 0.12161977589130402 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866965487599373 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a person with sharp features, slicked-back black hair, wearing a sapphire blue silk shirt, seated in a matte black carbon fiber wheelchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin static and then move in a slow dolly motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sunlit atrium with a high geometric glass ceiling, polished concrete floor, and indoor palm trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the individual lean forward while making articulate hand gestures, including slicing the air and forming a fist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06203259900212288 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812032699584961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06203259900212288, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06203259900212288, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3400862216949463, + 0.11724776774644852, + 0.08027039468288422, + 0.07666968554258347, + 0.10952356457710266, + 0.034817058593034744, + 0.0642874538898468, + 0.0520094595849514, + 0.03889769688248634, + 0.08619070798158646 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06203259900212288 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a person with sharp features, slicked-back black hair, wearing a sapphire blue silk shirt, seated in a matte black carbon fiber wheelchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin static and then move in a slow dolly motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sunlit atrium with a high geometric glass ceiling, polished concrete floor, and indoor palm trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the individual lean forward while making articulate hand gestures, including slicing the air and forming a fist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028178293723613024 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877817630767822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028178293723613024, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028178293723613024, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26223358511924744, + 0.04346032068133354, + 0.04619857296347618, + 0.03438825160264969, + 0.031101970002055168, + 0.024987857788801193, + 0.032710000872612, + 0.04296436160802841, + 0.044979676604270935, + 0.4369753897190094 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028178293723613024 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a person with sharp features, slicked-back black hair, wearing a sapphire blue silk shirt, seated in a matte black carbon fiber wheelchair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera begin static and then move in a slow dolly motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, sunlit atrium with a high geometric glass ceiling, polished concrete floor, and indoor palm trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the individual lean forward while making articulate hand gestures, including slicing the air and forming a fist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026334701105952263 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651334762573242 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026334701105952263, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026334701105952263, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15712545812129974, + 0.07035788893699646, + 0.08550676703453064, + 0.0671299546957016, + 0.2059212177991867, + 0.06212173029780388, + 0.06266234815120697, + 0.09201149642467499, + 0.07147479802370071, + 0.1256883144378662 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026334701105952263 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_7/index_tensor([7876, 7876])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_7/index_tensor([7876, 7876])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..046ac0841102d4b8e54f14b07f6e1b4fd07b89fb --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_7/index_tensor([7876, 7876])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, medium close-up shot from a level angle focuses on a majestic white tiger, set against a pure, endless, deep black void, placing all visual focus on the beast. The tiger's entire body adheres to a rigorously executed black-and-white dual-tonal scheme, its snow-white fur contrasting sharply and cleanly with deep, inky black stripes. At the apex of a silent roar, its massive mouth stretched to its limit, revealing sharp, white canines, its nose deeply wrinkled in fury. From its powerful neck to its broad shoulder blades, every muscle bulges with intense exertion, its chiseled features brimming with explosive power. Its eyes, wide open and fixed fixedly on the camera, convey an undeniable sense of menace. An intense, highly directional cold-toned light shines from the side and above, precisely carving out the three-dimensional contours and muscle texture of the tiger's body, casting sharp shadows on the pure white fur, further enhancing the high-contrast texture of the picture. The entire scene is filled with primitive, awe-inspiring wild power, creating a visually impactful and highly stylized atmosphere of tense confrontation.", + "seed": 4752, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_7/index_7876_seed_4752_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04036025460809469, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04036025460809469, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04036025460809469, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, endless, deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur snow-white with deep, inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth stretched wide open revealing sharp white canines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting highly directional, cold-toned, and coming from the side and above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054465148597955704 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0544650554656982 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054465148597955704, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054465148597955704, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07201965153217316, + 0.02621675841510296, + 0.07794856280088425, + 0.16965240240097046, + 0.02989766001701355, + 0.23044857382774353, + 0.07290474325418472, + 0.2887917459011078, + 0.012654334306716919, + 0.019465545192360878 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054465148597955704 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, endless, deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur snow-white with deep, inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth stretched wide open revealing sharp white canines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting highly directional, cold-toned, and coming from the side and above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1129843071103096 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379844188690186 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1129843071103096, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1129843071103096, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07339222729206085, + 0.04398961365222931, + 0.2280406355857849, + 0.1287606805562973, + 0.10859636962413788, + 0.21719752252101898, + 0.03217734396457672, + 0.026201196014881134, + 0.06887507438659668, + 0.07276925444602966 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1129843071103096 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, endless, deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur snow-white with deep, inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth stretched wide open revealing sharp white canines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting highly directional, cold-toned, and coming from the side and above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002206987701356411 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127206802368164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002206987701356411, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002206987701356411, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.058423519134521484, + 0.03740277886390686, + 0.04948800057172775, + 0.3807123899459839, + 0.018763957545161247, + 0.08261039108037949, + 0.032424446195364, + 0.060830164700746536, + 0.09606097638607025, + 0.18328341841697693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002206987701356411 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, endless, deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur snow-white with deep, inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth stretched wide open revealing sharp white canines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting highly directional, cold-toned, and coming from the side and above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016070714220404625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14107084274292 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016070714220404625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016070714220404625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06212138012051582, + 0.08925789594650269, + 0.04027669131755829, + 0.1048569604754448, + 0.03623519465327263, + 0.31794804334640503, + 0.04457565024495125, + 0.18236681818962097, + 0.0669422522187233, + 0.0554192028939724 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016070714220404625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, endless, deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur snow-white with deep, inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth stretched wide open revealing sharp white canines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting highly directional, cold-toned, and coming from the side and above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607411541044712 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141074180603027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607411541044712, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607411541044712, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11503074318170547, + 0.05490369349718094, + 0.12876899540424347, + 0.06921661645174026, + 0.048183225095272064, + 0.09799472987651825, + 0.03369039669632912, + 0.23317472636699677, + 0.12175832688808441, + 0.09727851301431656 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607411541044712 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, medium close-up shot from a level angle focuses on a majestic white tiger, set against a pure, endless, deep black void, placing all visual focus on the beast. The tiger's entire body adheres to a rigorously executed black-and-white dual-tonal scheme, its snow-white fur contrasting sharply and cleanly with deep, inky black stripes. At the apex of a silent roar, its massive mouth stretched to its limit, revealing sharp, white canines, its nose deeply wrinkled in fury. From its powerful neck to its broad shoulder blades, every muscle bulges with intense exertion, its chiseled features brimming with explosive power. Its eyes, wide open and fixed fixedly on the camera, convey an undeniable sense of menace. An intense, highly directional cold-toned light shines from the side and above, precisely carving out the three-dimensional contours and muscle texture of the tiger's body, casting sharp shadows on the pure white fur, further enhancing the high-contrast texture of the picture. The entire scene is filled with primitive, awe-inspiring wild power, creating a visually impactful and highly stylized atmosphere of tense confrontation.", + "seed": 4753, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_7/index_7876_seed_4753_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.018026511091738938, + "vlm_logprob": -0.018026511091738938, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.018026511091738938, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, endless, deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur snow-white with deep, inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth stretched wide open revealing sharp white canines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting highly directional, cold-toned, and coming from the side and above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03223370015621185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.657233715057373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03223370015621185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03223370015621185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12820179760456085, + 0.04718579351902008, + 0.03978937491774559, + 0.10193067789077759, + 0.10188540071249008, + 0.18701787292957306, + 0.07758327573537827, + 0.12232246994972229, + 0.08641115576028824, + 0.10767227411270142 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03223370015621185 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, endless, deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur snow-white with deep, inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth stretched wide open revealing sharp white canines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting highly directional, cold-toned, and coming from the side and above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016105905175209045 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141106128692627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016105905175209045, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016105905175209045, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22682347893714905, + 0.0757775753736496, + 0.11394233256578445, + 0.09696745872497559, + 0.2251008152961731, + 0.06497391313314438, + 0.03931569308042526, + 0.06381063908338547, + 0.03270743414759636, + 0.060580626130104065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016105905175209045 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, endless, deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur snow-white with deep, inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth stretched wide open revealing sharp white canines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting highly directional, cold-toned, and coming from the side and above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028254371136426926 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778252601623535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028254371136426926, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028254371136426926, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07257760316133499, + 0.06861235201358795, + 0.06010734289884567, + 0.09609051048755646, + 0.14137506484985352, + 0.028701815754175186, + 0.10092492401599884, + 0.055191464722156525, + 0.06316017359495163, + 0.3132587671279907 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028254371136426926 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, endless, deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur snow-white with deep, inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth stretched wide open revealing sharp white canines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting highly directional, cold-toned, and coming from the side and above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005264111328870058 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.2552642822265625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005264111328870058, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005264111328870058, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07116205990314484, + 0.05586690828204155, + 0.055014800280332565, + 0.10236955434083939, + 0.07565552741289139, + 0.06417112052440643, + 0.07054604589939117, + 0.2881406545639038, + 0.11480879783630371, + 0.10226460546255112 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005264111328870058 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, endless, deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur snow-white with deep, inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth stretched wide open revealing sharp white canines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting highly directional, cold-toned, and coming from the side and above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370340168476105 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408703327178955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370340168476105, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370340168476105, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09203259646892548, + 0.045276157557964325, + 0.19477371871471405, + 0.06800585240125656, + 0.08968700468540192, + 0.07707563787698746, + 0.12662523984909058, + 0.09277196228504181, + 0.03753192722797394, + 0.17621995508670807 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370340168476105 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, medium close-up shot from a level angle focuses on a majestic white tiger, set against a pure, endless, deep black void, placing all visual focus on the beast. The tiger's entire body adheres to a rigorously executed black-and-white dual-tonal scheme, its snow-white fur contrasting sharply and cleanly with deep, inky black stripes. At the apex of a silent roar, its massive mouth stretched to its limit, revealing sharp, white canines, its nose deeply wrinkled in fury. From its powerful neck to its broad shoulder blades, every muscle bulges with intense exertion, its chiseled features brimming with explosive power. Its eyes, wide open and fixed fixedly on the camera, convey an undeniable sense of menace. An intense, highly directional cold-toned light shines from the side and above, precisely carving out the three-dimensional contours and muscle texture of the tiger's body, casting sharp shadows on the pure white fur, further enhancing the high-contrast texture of the picture. The entire scene is filled with primitive, awe-inspiring wild power, creating a visually impactful and highly stylized atmosphere of tense confrontation.", + "seed": 4754, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_7/index_7876_seed_4754_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05338212712667882, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05338212712667882, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05338212712667882, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, endless, deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur snow-white with deep, inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth stretched wide open revealing sharp white canines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting highly directional, cold-toned, and coming from the side and above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055229123681783676 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0552291870117188 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055229123681783676, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055229123681783676, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08965779840946198, + 0.0652756541967392, + 0.044484417885541916, + 0.07753805816173553, + 0.30387380719184875, + 0.037322212010622025, + 0.048557259142398834, + 0.28196749091148376, + 0.014727931469678879, + 0.036595407873392105 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055229123681783676 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, endless, deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur snow-white with deep, inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth stretched wide open revealing sharp white canines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting highly directional, cold-toned, and coming from the side and above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16043582558631897 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104357957839966 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16043582558631897, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16043582558631897, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08259882032871246, + 0.09352339059114456, + 0.2827354073524475, + 0.14731740951538086, + 0.026762841269373894, + 0.037167299538850784, + 0.026512539014220238, + 0.2248685359954834, + 0.04344947263598442, + 0.03506430611014366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16043582558631897 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, endless, deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur snow-white with deep, inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth stretched wide open revealing sharp white canines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting highly directional, cold-toned, and coming from the side and above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022073446307331324 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127207279205322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022073446307331324, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022073446307331324, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11588598042726517, + 0.08630888164043427, + 0.23383109271526337, + 0.24858810007572174, + 0.032969534397125244, + 0.08178050816059113, + 0.03148677572607994, + 0.07294830679893494, + 0.05932694301009178, + 0.036873843520879745 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022073446307331324 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, endless, deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur snow-white with deep, inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth stretched wide open revealing sharp white canines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting highly directional, cold-toned, and coming from the side and above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005960783455520868 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130960941314697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005960783455520868, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005960783455520868, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10632207244634628, + 0.2266557663679123, + 0.10146012902259827, + 0.10555268824100494, + 0.14903806149959564, + 0.04583050310611725, + 0.12035557627677917, + 0.10668286681175232, + 0.02315201796591282, + 0.014950301498174667 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005960783455520868 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, endless, deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur snow-white with deep, inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth stretched wide open revealing sharp white canines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting highly directional, cold-toned, and coming from the side and above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043077558279037476 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680774688720703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043077558279037476, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043077558279037476, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15734806656837463, + 0.07130823284387589, + 0.2378627359867096, + 0.13059675693511963, + 0.12491296231746674, + 0.06114364042878151, + 0.05730457976460457, + 0.10892294347286224, + 0.032168712466955185, + 0.01843130961060524 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043077558279037476 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, medium close-up shot from a level angle focuses on a majestic white tiger, set against a pure, endless, deep black void, placing all visual focus on the beast. The tiger's entire body adheres to a rigorously executed black-and-white dual-tonal scheme, its snow-white fur contrasting sharply and cleanly with deep, inky black stripes. At the apex of a silent roar, its massive mouth stretched to its limit, revealing sharp, white canines, its nose deeply wrinkled in fury. From its powerful neck to its broad shoulder blades, every muscle bulges with intense exertion, its chiseled features brimming with explosive power. Its eyes, wide open and fixed fixedly on the camera, convey an undeniable sense of menace. An intense, highly directional cold-toned light shines from the side and above, precisely carving out the three-dimensional contours and muscle texture of the tiger's body, casting sharp shadows on the pure white fur, further enhancing the high-contrast texture of the picture. The entire scene is filled with primitive, awe-inspiring wild power, creating a visually impactful and highly stylized atmosphere of tense confrontation.", + "seed": 4755, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_7/index_7876_seed_4755_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.09306086304131896, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09306086304131896, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09306086304131896, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, endless, deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur snow-white with deep, inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth stretched wide open revealing sharp white canines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting highly directional, cold-toned, and coming from the side and above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.21132491528987885 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.71132493019104 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.21132491528987885, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.21132491528987885, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06335579603910446, + 0.03867679461836815, + 0.08391739428043365, + 0.03628912940621376, + 0.1394912451505661, + 0.3543153703212738, + 0.12419299781322479, + 0.04276704043149948, + 0.05036351457238197, + 0.06663072854280472 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.21132491528987885 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, endless, deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur snow-white with deep, inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth stretched wide open revealing sharp white canines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting highly directional, cold-toned, and coming from the side and above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20161721110343933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016172409057617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20161721110343933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20161721110343933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09941348433494568, + 0.2402709573507309, + 0.05227801203727722, + 0.03544319421052933, + 0.03542441874742508, + 0.054167360067367554, + 0.15693655610084534, + 0.03314313292503357, + 0.07293664664030075, + 0.21998625993728638 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20161721110343933 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, endless, deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur snow-white with deep, inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth stretched wide open revealing sharp white canines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting highly directional, cold-toned, and coming from the side and above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001949554425664246 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251949787139893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001949554425664246, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001949554425664246, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14006628096103668, + 0.10343269258737564, + 0.10495249927043915, + 0.04265483096241951, + 0.1158953309059143, + 0.21442104876041412, + 0.10084237158298492, + 0.06722865998744965, + 0.060204509645700455, + 0.05030179023742676 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001949554425664246 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, endless, deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur snow-white with deep, inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth stretched wide open revealing sharp white canines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting highly directional, cold-toned, and coming from the side and above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029822619631886482 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529822587966919 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029822619631886482, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029822619631886482, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.033150143921375275, + 0.049911633133888245, + 0.0807298943400383, + 0.030079439282417297, + 0.357342004776001, + 0.2494627833366394, + 0.11931374669075012, + 0.025515904650092125, + 0.022347260266542435, + 0.032147206366062164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029822619631886482 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium close-up from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure, endless, deep black void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's fur snow-white with deep, inky black stripes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the tiger's mouth stretched wide open revealing sharp white canines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting highly directional, cold-toned, and coming from the side and above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059001475572586 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.89559006690979 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059001475572586, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059001475572586, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2651851177215576, + 0.14382539689540863, + 0.13176029920578003, + 0.021273836493492126, + 0.047022175043821335, + 0.06878283619880676, + 0.11833679676055908, + 0.03891618177294731, + 0.06469462066888809, + 0.10020280629396439 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059001475572586 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_8/index_tensor([8648, 8648])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_8/index_tensor([8648, 8648])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1f902c24d0defa3ae1266faaa8416f0daa028020 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_8/index_tensor([8648, 8648])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, high-speed tracking shot follows a lithe, athletic man with short dark hair and sharp, focused features as he executes a perfect skateboard kickflip down a wide flight of concrete stairs. Caught in dramatic slow motion, he's dressed in a baggy black T-shirt and dark gray shorts, his body a study in controlled strength. The camera stays with him, tilting slightly upward, as he decisively springs onto the tail of his battered skateboard. At the peak of the jump, the board hangs suspended in mid-air, spinning perfectly on its axis beneath his feet, its underside gleaming with abstract blue and yellow graphics. The intense concentration on his face is palpable, and the gritty urban backdrop of brick buildings and metal railings melts into a painterly motion blur, with warm and cool colors isolating his sharp figure as the absolute center of attention. The entire scene is bathed in the golden glow of the afternoon sun, which gleams off the metal trucks of the board and creates a dramatic rim light around his silhouette, creating an atmosphere of pure, focused, and breathtaking athleticism.", + "seed": 11791, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_8/index_8648_seed_11791_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.018165767099708317, + "vlm_logprob": -0.018165767099708317, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.018165767099708317, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lithe, athletic man with short dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a baggy black T-shirt and dark gray shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man execute a skateboard kickflip down a wide flight of concrete stairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the skateboard's underside visible with abstract blue and yellow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle with a high-speed tracking shot that tilts slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03110729530453682 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.531107187271118 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03110729530453682, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03110729530453682, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17040294408798218, + 0.05984831228852272, + 0.11214319616556168, + 0.05262232571840286, + 0.1345899999141693, + 0.04611485078930855, + 0.034924738109111786, + 0.27351948618888855, + 0.033151499927043915, + 0.08268257230520248 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03110729530453682 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lithe, athletic man with short dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a baggy black T-shirt and dark gray shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man execute a skateboard kickflip down a wide flight of concrete stairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the skateboard's underside visible with abstract blue and yellow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle with a high-speed tracking shot that tilts slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00763652054592967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882636547088623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00763652054592967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00763652054592967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16079433262348175, + 0.10585503280162811, + 0.12355960160493851, + 0.13761764764785767, + 0.11196973919868469, + 0.03531016409397125, + 0.03576641157269478, + 0.11060258746147156, + 0.11219394207000732, + 0.06633056700229645 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00763652054592967 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lithe, athletic man with short dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a baggy black T-shirt and dark gray shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man execute a skateboard kickflip down a wide flight of concrete stairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the skateboard's underside visible with abstract blue and yellow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle with a high-speed tracking shot that tilts slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008632367476820946 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758632183074951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008632367476820946, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008632367476820946, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.193549245595932, + 0.1361895203590393, + 0.0693969577550888, + 0.1698256880044937, + 0.04165121167898178, + 0.06460241973400116, + 0.034594450145959854, + 0.22548902034759521, + 0.0297846719622612, + 0.034916821867227554 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008632367476820946 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lithe, athletic man with short dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a baggy black T-shirt and dark gray shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man execute a skateboard kickflip down a wide flight of concrete stairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the skateboard's underside visible with abstract blue and yellow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle with a high-speed tracking shot that tilts slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368104249238968 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086811542510986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368104249238968, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368104249238968, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1714646816253662, + 0.14505061507225037, + 0.05679890885949135, + 0.2096887081861496, + 0.04199843481183052, + 0.035507235676050186, + 0.06105906888842583, + 0.14888478815555573, + 0.06502857059240341, + 0.0645189881324768 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368104249238968 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lithe, athletic man with short dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a baggy black T-shirt and dark gray shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man execute a skateboard kickflip down a wide flight of concrete stairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the skateboard's underside visible with abstract blue and yellow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle with a high-speed tracking shot that tilts slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009771609678864479 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634771823883057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009771609678864479, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009771609678864479, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13803698122501373, + 0.06620877236127853, + 0.04438627511262894, + 0.09737007319927216, + 0.17726607620716095, + 0.05250879004597664, + 0.03939179703593254, + 0.15211254358291626, + 0.0761948972940445, + 0.15652373433113098 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009771609678864479 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, high-speed tracking shot follows a lithe, athletic man with short dark hair and sharp, focused features as he executes a perfect skateboard kickflip down a wide flight of concrete stairs. Caught in dramatic slow motion, he's dressed in a baggy black T-shirt and dark gray shorts, his body a study in controlled strength. The camera stays with him, tilting slightly upward, as he decisively springs onto the tail of his battered skateboard. At the peak of the jump, the board hangs suspended in mid-air, spinning perfectly on its axis beneath his feet, its underside gleaming with abstract blue and yellow graphics. The intense concentration on his face is palpable, and the gritty urban backdrop of brick buildings and metal railings melts into a painterly motion blur, with warm and cool colors isolating his sharp figure as the absolute center of attention. The entire scene is bathed in the golden glow of the afternoon sun, which gleams off the metal trucks of the board and creates a dramatic rim light around his silhouette, creating an atmosphere of pure, focused, and breathtaking athleticism.", + "seed": 11792, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_8/index_8648_seed_11792_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.01590959671884775, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01590959671884775, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01590959671884775, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lithe, athletic man with short dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a baggy black T-shirt and dark gray shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man execute a skateboard kickflip down a wide flight of concrete stairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the skateboard's underside visible with abstract blue and yellow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle with a high-speed tracking shot that tilts slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01669940911233425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141699314117432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01669940911233425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01669940911233425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18690353631973267, + 0.14527425169944763, + 0.06554711610078812, + 0.1639922708272934, + 0.051527831703424454, + 0.07942575961351395, + 0.1013723611831665, + 0.041178055107593536, + 0.08168686926364899, + 0.08309197425842285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01669940911233425 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lithe, athletic man with short dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a baggy black T-shirt and dark gray shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man execute a skateboard kickflip down a wide flight of concrete stairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the skateboard's underside visible with abstract blue and yellow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle with a high-speed tracking shot that tilts slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009794038720428944 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634794235229492 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009794038720428944, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009794038720428944, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19738195836544037, + 0.12553752958774567, + 0.1445697546005249, + 0.1278960108757019, + 0.0787222608923912, + 0.07305215299129486, + 0.06345555186271667, + 0.07729896157979965, + 0.040586553514003754, + 0.07149925827980042 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009794038720428944 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lithe, athletic man with short dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a baggy black T-shirt and dark gray shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man execute a skateboard kickflip down a wide flight of concrete stairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the skateboard's underside visible with abstract blue and yellow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle with a high-speed tracking shot that tilts slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014189423061907291 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26418924331665 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014189423061907291, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014189423061907291, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16436052322387695, + 0.17022079229354858, + 0.0994921550154686, + 0.23605215549468994, + 0.057415664196014404, + 0.13313445448875427, + 0.02590237930417061, + 0.030500927940011024, + 0.042755622416734695, + 0.040165334939956665 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014189423061907291 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lithe, athletic man with short dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a baggy black T-shirt and dark gray shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man execute a skateboard kickflip down a wide flight of concrete stairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the skateboard's underside visible with abstract blue and yellow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle with a high-speed tracking shot that tilts slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02633446827530861 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651334524154663 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02633446827530861, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02633446827530861, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18606409430503845, + 0.08828194439411163, + 0.03511893004179001, + 0.2351226955652237, + 0.05640539154410362, + 0.03802265599370003, + 0.0729474425315857, + 0.20620039105415344, + 0.053879328072071075, + 0.027957094833254814 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02633446827530861 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lithe, athletic man with short dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a baggy black T-shirt and dark gray shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man execute a skateboard kickflip down a wide flight of concrete stairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the skateboard's underside visible with abstract blue and yellow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle with a high-speed tracking shot that tilts slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012530644424259663 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38753080368042 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012530644424259663, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012530644424259663, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17531894147396088, + 0.13498294353485107, + 0.07164609432220459, + 0.1398649960756302, + 0.07661023736000061, + 0.12612979114055634, + 0.04376327991485596, + 0.05099013075232506, + 0.09880735725164413, + 0.08188622444868088 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012530644424259663 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, high-speed tracking shot follows a lithe, athletic man with short dark hair and sharp, focused features as he executes a perfect skateboard kickflip down a wide flight of concrete stairs. Caught in dramatic slow motion, he's dressed in a baggy black T-shirt and dark gray shorts, his body a study in controlled strength. The camera stays with him, tilting slightly upward, as he decisively springs onto the tail of his battered skateboard. At the peak of the jump, the board hangs suspended in mid-air, spinning perfectly on its axis beneath his feet, its underside gleaming with abstract blue and yellow graphics. The intense concentration on his face is palpable, and the gritty urban backdrop of brick buildings and metal railings melts into a painterly motion blur, with warm and cool colors isolating his sharp figure as the absolute center of attention. The entire scene is bathed in the golden glow of the afternoon sun, which gleams off the metal trucks of the board and creates a dramatic rim light around his silhouette, creating an atmosphere of pure, focused, and breathtaking athleticism.", + "seed": 11793, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_8/index_8648_seed_11793_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.016695650480687618, + "vlm_logprob": -0.016695650480687618, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.016695650480687618, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lithe, athletic man with short dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a baggy black T-shirt and dark gray shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man execute a skateboard kickflip down a wide flight of concrete stairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the skateboard's underside visible with abstract blue and yellow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle with a high-speed tracking shot that tilts slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.017105428501963615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.142105579376221 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.017105428501963615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.017105428501963615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09339960664510727, + 0.07071041315793991, + 0.041811753064394, + 0.04185975342988968, + 0.03675178810954094, + 0.040132127702236176, + 0.28685489296913147, + 0.2255828082561493, + 0.13280673325061798, + 0.030090058222413063 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.017105428501963615 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lithe, athletic man with short dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a baggy black T-shirt and dark gray shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man execute a skateboard kickflip down a wide flight of concrete stairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the skateboard's underside visible with abstract blue and yellow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle with a high-speed tracking shot that tilts slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009794510900974274 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63479471206665 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009794510900974274, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009794510900974274, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07268011569976807, + 0.07833365350961685, + 0.1396821290254593, + 0.043655864894390106, + 0.057197313755750656, + 0.04918846860527992, + 0.22925351560115814, + 0.22157897055149078, + 0.06642712652683258, + 0.04200281202793121 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009794510900974274 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lithe, athletic man with short dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a baggy black T-shirt and dark gray shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man execute a skateboard kickflip down a wide flight of concrete stairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the skateboard's underside visible with abstract blue and yellow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle with a high-speed tracking shot that tilts slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014188130386173725 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264188289642334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014188130386173725, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014188130386173725, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14161591231822968, + 0.2678080201148987, + 0.07267984747886658, + 0.1348031908273697, + 0.09615429490804672, + 0.056088387966156006, + 0.04453331232070923, + 0.06783489137887955, + 0.05705857276916504, + 0.061423540115356445 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014188130386173725 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lithe, athletic man with short dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a baggy black T-shirt and dark gray shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man execute a skateboard kickflip down a wide flight of concrete stairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the skateboard's underside visible with abstract blue and yellow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle with a high-speed tracking shot that tilts slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026332959532737732 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513328552246094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026332959532737732, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026332959532737732, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31406331062316895, + 0.06797654926776886, + 0.22634677588939667, + 0.05965336784720421, + 0.09469980746507645, + 0.06292156875133514, + 0.03763449564576149, + 0.06090686097741127, + 0.04720674082636833, + 0.028590593487024307 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026332959532737732 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lithe, athletic man with short dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a baggy black T-shirt and dark gray shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man execute a skateboard kickflip down a wide flight of concrete stairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the skateboard's underside visible with abstract blue and yellow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle with a high-speed tracking shot that tilts slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016057223081588745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141057014465332 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016057223081588745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016057223081588745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23801791667938232, + 0.07531829178333282, + 0.1942794919013977, + 0.06515247374773026, + 0.06656795740127563, + 0.09580419957637787, + 0.09312521666288376, + 0.0695153996348381, + 0.04980015009641647, + 0.05241894721984863 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016057223081588745 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, high-speed tracking shot follows a lithe, athletic man with short dark hair and sharp, focused features as he executes a perfect skateboard kickflip down a wide flight of concrete stairs. Caught in dramatic slow motion, he's dressed in a baggy black T-shirt and dark gray shorts, his body a study in controlled strength. The camera stays with him, tilting slightly upward, as he decisively springs onto the tail of his battered skateboard. At the peak of the jump, the board hangs suspended in mid-air, spinning perfectly on its axis beneath his feet, its underside gleaming with abstract blue and yellow graphics. The intense concentration on his face is palpable, and the gritty urban backdrop of brick buildings and metal railings melts into a painterly motion blur, with warm and cool colors isolating his sharp figure as the absolute center of attention. The entire scene is bathed in the golden glow of the afternoon sun, which gleams off the metal trucks of the board and creates a dramatic rim light around his silhouette, creating an atmosphere of pure, focused, and breathtaking athleticism.", + "seed": 11794, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_8/index_8648_seed_11794_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.016990565694868565, + "vlm_logprob": -0.016990565694868565, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.016990565694868565, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lithe, athletic man with short dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a baggy black T-shirt and dark gray shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man execute a skateboard kickflip down a wide flight of concrete stairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the skateboard's underside visible with abstract blue and yellow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle with a high-speed tracking shot that tilts slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011719544418156147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.636719703674316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011719544418156147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011719544418156147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07691915333271027, + 0.10914472490549088, + 0.03517090529203415, + 0.04960799589753151, + 0.04151931777596474, + 0.036356888711452484, + 0.4421464800834656, + 0.03588692098855972, + 0.03635767102241516, + 0.1368899941444397 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011719544418156147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lithe, athletic man with short dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a baggy black T-shirt and dark gray shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man execute a skateboard kickflip down a wide flight of concrete stairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the skateboard's underside visible with abstract blue and yellow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle with a high-speed tracking shot that tilts slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01109160017222166 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511091709136963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01109160017222166, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01109160017222166, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07841570675373077, + 0.08213331550359726, + 0.09734069555997849, + 0.07855552434921265, + 0.03490222617983818, + 0.05294841155409813, + 0.2594664394855499, + 0.08183004707098007, + 0.03734465688467026, + 0.19706298410892487 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01109160017222166 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lithe, athletic man with short dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a baggy black T-shirt and dark gray shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man execute a skateboard kickflip down a wide flight of concrete stairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the skateboard's underside visible with abstract blue and yellow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle with a high-speed tracking shot that tilts slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02327689342200756 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732768058776855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02327689342200756, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02327689342200756, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2971036434173584, + 0.14692555367946625, + 0.08463175594806671, + 0.05074504762887955, + 0.04338165745139122, + 0.029744617640972137, + 0.05564254894852638, + 0.04535213112831116, + 0.11701895296573639, + 0.1294541358947754 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02327689342200756 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lithe, athletic man with short dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a baggy black T-shirt and dark gray shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man execute a skateboard kickflip down a wide flight of concrete stairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the skateboard's underside visible with abstract blue and yellow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle with a high-speed tracking shot that tilts slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02633226290345192 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651332378387451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02633226290345192, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02633226290345192, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1404224932193756, + 0.09818185865879059, + 0.05480404570698738, + 0.31361499428749084, + 0.03232394903898239, + 0.1928434669971466, + 0.05127419903874397, + 0.024130171164870262, + 0.04009076580405235, + 0.052314046770334244 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02633226290345192 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a lithe, athletic man with short dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a baggy black T-shirt and dark gray shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man execute a skateboard kickflip down a wide flight of concrete stairs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the skateboard's underside visible with abstract blue and yellow graphics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from a low-angle with a high-speed tracking shot that tilts slightly upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012532527558505535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387532711029053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012532527558505535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012532527558505535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1594974845647812, + 0.13101011514663696, + 0.039590828120708466, + 0.12331201881170273, + 0.03196655586361885, + 0.039617959409952164, + 0.14535146951675415, + 0.03147782012820244, + 0.042362961918115616, + 0.2558128237724304 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012532527558505535 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_9/index_tensor([8784, 8784])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_9/index_tensor([8784, 8784])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7c3b3f917d95450fc59f14f3f1324ac8fa702aba --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_9/index_tensor([8784, 8784])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "high-angle wide shot, as if filmed from the highest tier of the stands, captures a vast, empty stadium under cover of darkness. The entire frame subtly vibrates with a low-frequency camera shake, suggesting a powerful tremor in the distance. The towering stadium lights pour down an intense, brilliant white light that cuts sharply through the cool, misty air, casting overlapping layers of harsh, clinical illumination onto the perfectly manicured lawn below. The lush green field is evenly covered with a fine layer of dew, making millions of blades of grass sparkle like tiny diamonds, creating a shimmering, damp sheen under the intense glare. The deep, inky darkness of the empty spectator stands, enveloping the brightly lit field, creates a stark, dramatic contrast and a profound sense of isolation. The visible mist catches the light, giving the beams volume and form as they pour downward. The camera's continuous, gentle panning, combined with the silent, static setting, creates a palpable atmosphere of tense anticipation and an unsettling sense of mystery, as if the world is holding its breath before a momentous, unseen event.", + "seed": 5012, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_9/index_8784_seed_5012_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.12691908422857523, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12691908422857523, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12691908422857523, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down from the stands onto a vast, empty stadium?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with intense, brilliant white stadium lights cutting through cool, misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the green field covered in dew, causing the grass to sparkle with a shimmering, damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the entire frame exhibit a subtle, low-frequency vibration simulating a camera shake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, gentle pan across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05057938024401665 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.050579309463501 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05057938024401665, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05057938024401665, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07560638338327408, + 0.12687672674655914, + 0.21783865988254547, + 0.04235672578215599, + 0.07160201668739319, + 0.11499136686325073, + 0.06537637859582901, + 0.1598254293203354, + 0.0808483213186264, + 0.04467800259590149 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05057938024401665 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down from the stands onto a vast, empty stadium?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with intense, brilliant white stadium lights cutting through cool, misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the green field covered in dew, causing the grass to sparkle with a shimmering, damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the entire frame exhibit a subtle, low-frequency vibration simulating a camera shake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, gentle pan across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009801947511732578 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634801864624023 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009801947511732578, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009801947511732578, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2065889835357666, + 0.41994068026542664, + 0.11470416188240051, + 0.06738246232271194, + 0.02118142880499363, + 0.013758976012468338, + 0.024783413857221603, + 0.05529473349452019, + 0.06153048202395439, + 0.014834698289632797 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009801947511732578 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down from the stands onto a vast, empty stadium?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with intense, brilliant white stadium lights cutting through cool, misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the green field covered in dew, causing the grass to sparkle with a shimmering, damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the entire frame exhibit a subtle, low-frequency vibration simulating a camera shake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, gentle pan across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10035722702741623 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503572940826416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10035722702741623, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10035722702741623, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08652864396572113, + 0.31706130504608154, + 0.0890042632818222, + 0.05590695142745972, + 0.042214810848236084, + 0.04756324365735054, + 0.039495062083005905, + 0.14499273896217346, + 0.05028896778821945, + 0.12694400548934937 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10035722702741623 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down from the stands onto a vast, empty stadium?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with intense, brilliant white stadium lights cutting through cool, misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the green field covered in dew, causing the grass to sparkle with a shimmering, damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the entire frame exhibit a subtle, low-frequency vibration simulating a camera shake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, gentle pan across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16038241982460022 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103823900222778 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16038241982460022, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16038241982460022, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09497731924057007, + 0.2183590531349182, + 0.2168504148721695, + 0.03866833075881004, + 0.0908268541097641, + 0.16777749359607697, + 0.024358363822102547, + 0.10508947819471359, + 0.031115204095840454, + 0.011977477930486202 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16038241982460022 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down from the stands onto a vast, empty stadium?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with intense, brilliant white stadium lights cutting through cool, misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the green field covered in dew, causing the grass to sparkle with a shimmering, damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the entire frame exhibit a subtle, low-frequency vibration simulating a camera shake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, gentle pan across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134744465351105 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.313474416732788 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134744465351105, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134744465351105, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15676498413085938, + 0.04957364872097969, + 0.07883557677268982, + 0.05572117120027542, + 0.1552315056324005, + 0.2080061435699463, + 0.026700789108872414, + 0.20923040807247162, + 0.033115729689598083, + 0.026820039376616478 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134744465351105 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-angle wide shot, as if filmed from the highest tier of the stands, captures a vast, empty stadium under cover of darkness. The entire frame subtly vibrates with a low-frequency camera shake, suggesting a powerful tremor in the distance. The towering stadium lights pour down an intense, brilliant white light that cuts sharply through the cool, misty air, casting overlapping layers of harsh, clinical illumination onto the perfectly manicured lawn below. The lush green field is evenly covered with a fine layer of dew, making millions of blades of grass sparkle like tiny diamonds, creating a shimmering, damp sheen under the intense glare. The deep, inky darkness of the empty spectator stands, enveloping the brightly lit field, creates a stark, dramatic contrast and a profound sense of isolation. The visible mist catches the light, giving the beams volume and form as they pour downward. The camera's continuous, gentle panning, combined with the silent, static setting, creates a palpable atmosphere of tense anticipation and an unsettling sense of mystery, as if the world is holding its breath before a momentous, unseen event.", + "seed": 5013, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_9/index_8784_seed_5013_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.1283052213024348, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1283052213024348, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.824999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1283052213024348, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down from the stands onto a vast, empty stadium?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with intense, brilliant white stadium lights cutting through cool, misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the green field covered in dew, causing the grass to sparkle with a shimmering, damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the entire frame exhibit a subtle, low-frequency vibration simulating a camera shake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, gentle pan across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.389958918094635 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1399588584899902 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.389958918094635, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.389958918094635, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15655727684497833, + 0.18065451085567474, + 0.09833730012178421, + 0.029357897117733955, + 0.05371231958270073, + 0.1345764845609665, + 0.1645016223192215, + 0.08340588212013245, + 0.06894111633300781, + 0.029955577105283737 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.389958918094635 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down from the stands onto a vast, empty stadium?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with intense, brilliant white stadium lights cutting through cool, misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the green field covered in dew, causing the grass to sparkle with a shimmering, damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the entire frame exhibit a subtle, low-frequency vibration simulating a camera shake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, gentle pan across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036334467586129904 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628633499145508 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036334467586129904, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036334467586129904, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18418459594249725, + 0.251878559589386, + 0.09737580269575119, + 0.07435628026723862, + 0.03115709125995636, + 0.09059827774763107, + 0.08551938831806183, + 0.11276464909315109, + 0.03491886705160141, + 0.03724648430943489 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036334467586129904 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down from the stands onto a vast, empty stadium?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with intense, brilliant white stadium lights cutting through cool, misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the green field covered in dew, causing the grass to sparkle with a shimmering, damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the entire frame exhibit a subtle, low-frequency vibration simulating a camera shake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, gentle pan across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043076418340206146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168076515197754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043076418340206146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043076418340206146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06646529585123062, + 0.5491886138916016, + 0.03378431499004364, + 0.043326590210199356, + 0.027683112770318985, + 0.17913711071014404, + 0.024133438244462013, + 0.030080797150731087, + 0.023664189502596855, + 0.022536620497703552 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043076418340206146 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down from the stands onto a vast, empty stadium?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with intense, brilliant white stadium lights cutting through cool, misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the green field covered in dew, causing the grass to sparkle with a shimmering, damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the entire frame exhibit a subtle, low-frequency vibration simulating a camera shake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, gentle pan across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204963102936745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812049627304077 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204963102936745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204963102936745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20196014642715454, + 0.16526800394058228, + 0.2515202760696411, + 0.09464896470308304, + 0.03523238003253937, + 0.04361820966005325, + 0.024770110845565796, + 0.03543873503804207, + 0.11209572851657867, + 0.03544751927256584 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204963102936745 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down from the stands onto a vast, empty stadium?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with intense, brilliant white stadium lights cutting through cool, misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the green field covered in dew, causing the grass to sparkle with a shimmering, damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the entire frame exhibit a subtle, low-frequency vibration simulating a camera shake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, gentle pan across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14280769228935242 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017807722091675 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14280769228935242, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14280769228935242, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16202692687511444, + 0.0531296469271183, + 0.1499500572681427, + 0.04758898541331291, + 0.07696862518787384, + 0.17845501005649567, + 0.06795376539230347, + 0.044586438685655594, + 0.11808792501688004, + 0.10125266015529633 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14280769228935242 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-angle wide shot, as if filmed from the highest tier of the stands, captures a vast, empty stadium under cover of darkness. The entire frame subtly vibrates with a low-frequency camera shake, suggesting a powerful tremor in the distance. The towering stadium lights pour down an intense, brilliant white light that cuts sharply through the cool, misty air, casting overlapping layers of harsh, clinical illumination onto the perfectly manicured lawn below. The lush green field is evenly covered with a fine layer of dew, making millions of blades of grass sparkle like tiny diamonds, creating a shimmering, damp sheen under the intense glare. The deep, inky darkness of the empty spectator stands, enveloping the brightly lit field, creates a stark, dramatic contrast and a profound sense of isolation. The visible mist catches the light, giving the beams volume and form as they pour downward. The camera's continuous, gentle panning, combined with the silent, static setting, creates a palpable atmosphere of tense anticipation and an unsettling sense of mystery, as if the world is holding its breath before a momentous, unseen event.", + "seed": 5014, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_9/index_8784_seed_5014_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.17686076927930117, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17686076927930117, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17686076927930117, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down from the stands onto a vast, empty stadium?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with intense, brilliant white stadium lights cutting through cool, misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the green field covered in dew, causing the grass to sparkle with a shimmering, damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the entire frame exhibit a subtle, low-frequency vibration simulating a camera shake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, gentle pan across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07509161531925201 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.700091600418091 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07509161531925201, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07509161531925201, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1262746900320053, + 0.026627982035279274, + 0.12831510603427887, + 0.24673862755298615, + 0.22591832280158997, + 0.08369125425815582, + 0.044135916978120804, + 0.03910013660788536, + 0.042204197496175766, + 0.03699376434087753 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07509161531925201 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down from the stands onto a vast, empty stadium?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with intense, brilliant white stadium lights cutting through cool, misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the green field covered in dew, causing the grass to sparkle with a shimmering, damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the entire frame exhibit a subtle, low-frequency vibration simulating a camera shake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, gentle pan across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005271107889711857 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255270957946777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005271107889711857, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005271107889711857, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1352071762084961, + 0.01866340823471546, + 0.10833321511745453, + 0.05114179849624634, + 0.04360367730259895, + 0.029647065326571465, + 0.01632598228752613, + 0.017473742365837097, + 0.419247031211853, + 0.16035690903663635 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005271107889711857 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down from the stands onto a vast, empty stadium?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with intense, brilliant white stadium lights cutting through cool, misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the green field covered in dew, causing the grass to sparkle with a shimmering, damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the entire frame exhibit a subtle, low-frequency vibration simulating a camera shake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, gentle pan across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07899913936853409 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789990425109863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07899913936853409, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07899913936853409, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14147193729877472, + 0.016160842031240463, + 0.10075395554304123, + 0.03292468935251236, + 0.4547782242298126, + 0.031118126586079597, + 0.0076784067787230015, + 0.018200885504484177, + 0.12581992149353027, + 0.07109302282333374 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07899913936853409 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down from the stands onto a vast, empty stadium?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with intense, brilliant white stadium lights cutting through cool, misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the green field covered in dew, causing the grass to sparkle with a shimmering, damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the entire frame exhibit a subtle, low-frequency vibration simulating a camera shake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, gentle pan across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20158065855503082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015806436538696 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20158065855503082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20158065855503082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05078309774398804, + 0.015043327584862709, + 0.06913680583238602, + 0.061057623475790024, + 0.48465049266815186, + 0.03963029757142067, + 0.014109963551163673, + 0.02646399289369583, + 0.1636296659708023, + 0.0754946917295456 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20158065855503082 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down from the stands onto a vast, empty stadium?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with intense, brilliant white stadium lights cutting through cool, misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the green field covered in dew, causing the grass to sparkle with a shimmering, damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the entire frame exhibit a subtle, low-frequency vibration simulating a camera shake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, gentle pan across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.523361325263977 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.898361325263977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.523361325263977, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.523361325263977, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07908066362142563, + 0.04793671518564224, + 0.13164152204990387, + 0.10788515210151672, + 0.15723441541194916, + 0.043808795511722565, + 0.03180741146206856, + 0.04391678050160408, + 0.16754181683063507, + 0.1891467571258545 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.523361325263977 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-angle wide shot, as if filmed from the highest tier of the stands, captures a vast, empty stadium under cover of darkness. The entire frame subtly vibrates with a low-frequency camera shake, suggesting a powerful tremor in the distance. The towering stadium lights pour down an intense, brilliant white light that cuts sharply through the cool, misty air, casting overlapping layers of harsh, clinical illumination onto the perfectly manicured lawn below. The lush green field is evenly covered with a fine layer of dew, making millions of blades of grass sparkle like tiny diamonds, creating a shimmering, damp sheen under the intense glare. The deep, inky darkness of the empty spectator stands, enveloping the brightly lit field, creates a stark, dramatic contrast and a profound sense of isolation. The visible mist catches the light, giving the beams volume and form as they pour downward. The camera's continuous, gentle panning, combined with the silent, static setting, creates a palpable atmosphere of tense anticipation and an unsettling sense of mystery, as if the world is holding its breath before a momentous, unseen event.", + "seed": 5015, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000105/group_9/index_8784_seed_5015_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.17555400906130672, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17555400906130672, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.299999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17555400906130672, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down from the stands onto a vast, empty stadium?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with intense, brilliant white stadium lights cutting through cool, misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the green field covered in dew, causing the grass to sparkle with a shimmering, damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the entire frame exhibit a subtle, low-frequency vibration simulating a camera shake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, gentle pan across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20480288565158844 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7048028707504272 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20480288565158844, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20480288565158844, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03876589238643646, + 0.030907653272151947, + 0.007725602015852928, + 0.006199479568749666, + 0.0272934939712286, + 0.03556458279490471, + 0.07164620608091354, + 0.17308063805103302, + 0.5835111141204834, + 0.025305351242423058 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20480288565158844 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down from the stands onto a vast, empty stadium?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with intense, brilliant white stadium lights cutting through cool, misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the green field covered in dew, causing the grass to sparkle with a shimmering, damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the entire frame exhibit a subtle, low-frequency vibration simulating a camera shake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, gentle pan across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005273835267871618 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255273818969727 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005273835267871618, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005273835267871618, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14343148469924927, + 0.07935433834791183, + 0.021323559805750847, + 0.02242358773946762, + 0.025719530880451202, + 0.027430659160017967, + 0.09672801941633224, + 0.07431404292583466, + 0.4645857512950897, + 0.04468904063105583 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005273835267871618 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down from the stands onto a vast, empty stadium?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with intense, brilliant white stadium lights cutting through cool, misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the green field covered in dew, causing the grass to sparkle with a shimmering, damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the entire frame exhibit a subtle, low-frequency vibration simulating a camera shake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, gentle pan across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900530844926834 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579005241394043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900530844926834, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900530844926834, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24492402374744415, + 0.16288037598133087, + 0.05046294257044792, + 0.04006560519337654, + 0.04406183212995529, + 0.0784384086728096, + 0.04536017030477524, + 0.09172772616147995, + 0.1157614067196846, + 0.12631751596927643 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900530844926834 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down from the stands onto a vast, empty stadium?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with intense, brilliant white stadium lights cutting through cool, misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the green field covered in dew, causing the grass to sparkle with a shimmering, damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the entire frame exhibit a subtle, low-frequency vibration simulating a camera shake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, gentle pan across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20158368349075317 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015836238861084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20158368349075317, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20158368349075317, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30235806107521057, + 0.10731787234544754, + 0.042058564722537994, + 0.0725020170211792, + 0.07279609143733978, + 0.03689955174922943, + 0.06917867809534073, + 0.09831991046667099, + 0.11944001913070679, + 0.07912923395633698 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20158368349075317 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down from the stands onto a vast, empty stadium?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night with intense, brilliant white stadium lights cutting through cool, misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the green field covered in dew, causing the grass to sparkle with a shimmering, damp sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the entire frame exhibit a subtle, low-frequency vibration simulating a camera shake?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, gentle pan across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.387104332447052 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1371042728424072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.387104332447052, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.387104332447052, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12319710850715637, + 0.0759393572807312, + 0.03257327526807785, + 0.038673754781484604, + 0.03927745297551155, + 0.03708096221089363, + 0.062227457761764526, + 0.10535814613103867, + 0.3302369713783264, + 0.1554354876279831 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.387104332447052 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_10/index_tensor([4372, 4372])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_10/index_tensor([4372, 4372])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..279479a1bc55ac767080cafd684fbbb7ab14804e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_10/index_tensor([4372, 4372])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "smooth, right-facing pan reveals a sharply angular M1216 shotgun constructed entirely of low-polygons. Its distinctive cylindrical magazine and barrel are coated in a captivating iridescent sheen, reflecting shifting cyan, magenta, and purple against the deep, dark background. The weapon jerks back, a massive, stylized, geometric white flash erupting from the muzzle. Immediately, a brass-colored shell, also constructed in a low-polygonal style, ejects cleanly, swirling away into the darkness. The muzzle faces a towering, imposing crystal structure, its interior seemingly imbued with a faint, cold white light, its translucent surface crisscrossed with natural geometric facets. At the moment the gunfire sounded, the entire crystalline structure exploded catastrophically outward without delay, instantly disintegrating into thousands of geometric fragments of varying sizes, flashing with sharp light. These fragments spread out in all directions in slow motion like a frozen cosmic explosion, each one capturing and refracting the light from the iridescent surface of the shotgun, creating a dazzling scene of destruction that was both violent and digitally beautiful. The overall atmosphere was filled with the coldness of futurism and the grandeur of surrealism.", + "seed": 8029, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_10/index_4372_seed_8029_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.12522724089212717, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12522724089212717, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12522724089212717, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth pan to the right at the beginning of the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shotgun depicted as sharply angular and constructed entirely of low-polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shotgun and ejected shell display an iridescent sheen with cyan, magenta, and purple reflections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crystal structure explode outward into thousands of geometric fragments in slow motion immediately after the gunfire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fragments refract light from the shotgun's iridescent surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5259743332862854 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9009743332862854 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5259743332862854, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5259743332862854, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04577048867940903, + 0.8414180278778076, + 0.019873982295393944, + 0.014114527963101864, + 0.013333288952708244, + 0.008142493665218353, + 0.01972888968884945, + 0.003769570030272007, + 0.021010002121329308, + 0.012838765978813171 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5259743332862854 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth pan to the right at the beginning of the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shotgun depicted as sharply angular and constructed entirely of low-polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shotgun and ejected shell display an iridescent sheen with cyan, magenta, and purple reflections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crystal structure explode outward into thousands of geometric fragments in slow motion immediately after the gunfire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fragments refract light from the shotgun's iridescent surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812484070658684 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881247997283936 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812484070658684, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812484070658684, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07930126786231995, + 0.21969003975391388, + 0.28274109959602356, + 0.11563771218061447, + 0.03842635825276375, + 0.024869345128536224, + 0.05099824443459511, + 0.027347784489393234, + 0.13035722076892853, + 0.030630990862846375 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812484070658684 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth pan to the right at the beginning of the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shotgun depicted as sharply angular and constructed entirely of low-polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shotgun and ejected shell display an iridescent sheen with cyan, magenta, and purple reflections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crystal structure explode outward into thousands of geometric fragments in slow motion immediately after the gunfire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fragments refract light from the shotgun's iridescent surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036194308195263147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628619194030762 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036194308195263147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036194308195263147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10969933867454529, + 0.6351819634437561, + 0.057792603969573975, + 0.04002862796187401, + 0.018044324591755867, + 0.02898295409977436, + 0.03146100789308548, + 0.028059041127562523, + 0.03087165765464306, + 0.01987859234213829 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036194308195263147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth pan to the right at the beginning of the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shotgun depicted as sharply angular and constructed entirely of low-polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shotgun and ejected shell display an iridescent sheen with cyan, magenta, and purple reflections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crystal structure explode outward into thousands of geometric fragments in slow motion immediately after the gunfire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fragments refract light from the shotgun's iridescent surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048638198524713516 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048638105392456 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048638198524713516, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048638198524713516, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07245323807001114, + 0.4765627980232239, + 0.05783548951148987, + 0.058979786932468414, + 0.02843621000647545, + 0.03796147555112839, + 0.099864162504673, + 0.04719648137688637, + 0.08051993697881699, + 0.04019049555063248 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048638198524713516 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth pan to the right at the beginning of the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shotgun depicted as sharply angular and constructed entirely of low-polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shotgun and ejected shell display an iridescent sheen with cyan, magenta, and purple reflections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crystal structure explode outward into thousands of geometric fragments in slow motion immediately after the gunfire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fragments refract light from the shotgun's iridescent surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009779401123523712 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634779453277588 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009779401123523712, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009779401123523712, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1310608834028244, + 0.08888609707355499, + 0.16978564858436584, + 0.11995147913694382, + 0.043715961277484894, + 0.058059390634298325, + 0.10607674717903137, + 0.05703803151845932, + 0.09894566237926483, + 0.1264800727367401 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009779401123523712 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "smooth, right-facing pan reveals a sharply angular M1216 shotgun constructed entirely of low-polygons. Its distinctive cylindrical magazine and barrel are coated in a captivating iridescent sheen, reflecting shifting cyan, magenta, and purple against the deep, dark background. The weapon jerks back, a massive, stylized, geometric white flash erupting from the muzzle. Immediately, a brass-colored shell, also constructed in a low-polygonal style, ejects cleanly, swirling away into the darkness. The muzzle faces a towering, imposing crystal structure, its interior seemingly imbued with a faint, cold white light, its translucent surface crisscrossed with natural geometric facets. At the moment the gunfire sounded, the entire crystalline structure exploded catastrophically outward without delay, instantly disintegrating into thousands of geometric fragments of varying sizes, flashing with sharp light. These fragments spread out in all directions in slow motion like a frozen cosmic explosion, each one capturing and refracting the light from the iridescent surface of the shotgun, creating a dazzling scene of destruction that was both violent and digitally beautiful. The overall atmosphere was filled with the coldness of futurism and the grandeur of surrealism.", + "seed": 8030, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_10/index_4372_seed_8030_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.28399033602327106, + "vlm_logprob": -0.28399033602327106, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.0749999940395356, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.28399033602327106, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth pan to the right at the beginning of the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shotgun depicted as sharply angular and constructed entirely of low-polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shotgun and ejected shell display an iridescent sheen with cyan, magenta, and purple reflections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crystal structure explode outward into thousands of geometric fragments in slow motion immediately after the gunfire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fragments refract light from the shotgun's iridescent surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2848648428916931 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.409864902496338 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2848648428916931, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2848648428916931, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08651719242334366, + 0.03351089730858803, + 0.19090910255908966, + 0.044289495795965195, + 0.2503995895385742, + 0.08471529930830002, + 0.17941251397132874, + 0.061244089156389236, + 0.037633102387189865, + 0.03136875107884407 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2848648428916931 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth pan to the right at the beginning of the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shotgun depicted as sharply angular and constructed entirely of low-polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shotgun and ejected shell display an iridescent sheen with cyan, magenta, and purple reflections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crystal structure explode outward into thousands of geometric fragments in slow motion immediately after the gunfire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fragments refract light from the shotgun's iridescent surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328208446502686 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578208446502686 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6328208446502686, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6328208446502686, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1382058560848236, + 0.055439069867134094, + 0.08783143013715744, + 0.04476304352283478, + 0.09067442268133163, + 0.2904990315437317, + 0.06734267622232437, + 0.04348887875676155, + 0.1052076444029808, + 0.07654789835214615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6328208446502686 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth pan to the right at the beginning of the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shotgun depicted as sharply angular and constructed entirely of low-polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shotgun and ejected shell display an iridescent sheen with cyan, magenta, and purple reflections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crystal structure explode outward into thousands of geometric fragments in slow motion immediately after the gunfire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fragments refract light from the shotgun's iridescent surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009791559539735317 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634791374206543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009791559539735317, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009791559539735317, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2851455509662628, + 0.04262617602944374, + 0.10841872543096542, + 0.06567124277353287, + 0.03750152885913849, + 0.1294453889131546, + 0.17944331467151642, + 0.01928878389298916, + 0.06285963952541351, + 0.0695996806025505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009791559539735317 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth pan to the right at the beginning of the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shotgun depicted as sharply angular and constructed entirely of low-polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shotgun and ejected shell display an iridescent sheen with cyan, magenta, and purple reflections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crystal structure explode outward into thousands of geometric fragments in slow motion immediately after the gunfire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fragments refract light from the shotgun's iridescent surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4742777645587921 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742777347564697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4742777645587921, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.4999999701976776, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4742777645587921, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1425277292728424, + 0.08135035634040833, + 0.11326730996370316, + 0.034437473863363266, + 0.03833385929465294, + 0.1718055158853531, + 0.19640767574310303, + 0.045844681560993195, + 0.09740319848060608, + 0.07862218469381332 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4742777645587921 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth pan to the right at the beginning of the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shotgun depicted as sharply angular and constructed entirely of low-polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shotgun and ejected shell display an iridescent sheen with cyan, magenta, and purple reflections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crystal structure explode outward into thousands of geometric fragments in slow motion immediately after the gunfire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fragments refract light from the shotgun's iridescent surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018196668475866318 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0181965827941895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018196668475866318, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018196668475866318, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1135156974196434, + 0.05374472960829735, + 0.13202105462551117, + 0.03361920639872551, + 0.06413964182138443, + 0.21605722606182098, + 0.20558734238147736, + 0.04209126532077789, + 0.09119731187820435, + 0.04802651330828667 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018196668475866318 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "smooth, right-facing pan reveals a sharply angular M1216 shotgun constructed entirely of low-polygons. Its distinctive cylindrical magazine and barrel are coated in a captivating iridescent sheen, reflecting shifting cyan, magenta, and purple against the deep, dark background. The weapon jerks back, a massive, stylized, geometric white flash erupting from the muzzle. Immediately, a brass-colored shell, also constructed in a low-polygonal style, ejects cleanly, swirling away into the darkness. The muzzle faces a towering, imposing crystal structure, its interior seemingly imbued with a faint, cold white light, its translucent surface crisscrossed with natural geometric facets. At the moment the gunfire sounded, the entire crystalline structure exploded catastrophically outward without delay, instantly disintegrating into thousands of geometric fragments of varying sizes, flashing with sharp light. These fragments spread out in all directions in slow motion like a frozen cosmic explosion, each one capturing and refracting the light from the iridescent surface of the shotgun, creating a dazzling scene of destruction that was both violent and digitally beautiful. The overall atmosphere was filled with the coldness of futurism and the grandeur of surrealism.", + "seed": 8031, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_10/index_4372_seed_8031_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.09238517237827182, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09238517237827182, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09238517237827182, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth pan to the right at the beginning of the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shotgun depicted as sharply angular and constructed entirely of low-polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shotgun and ejected shell display an iridescent sheen with cyan, magenta, and purple reflections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crystal structure explode outward into thousands of geometric fragments in slow motion immediately after the gunfire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fragments refract light from the shotgun's iridescent surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.23017367720603943 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6051737070083618 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.23017367720603943, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.23017367720603943, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11823738366365433, + 0.0571846142411232, + 0.11230333149433136, + 0.07827626913785934, + 0.06493181735277176, + 0.08175016194581985, + 0.15177133679389954, + 0.16692808270454407, + 0.09253646433353424, + 0.0760805606842041 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.23017367720603943 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth pan to the right at the beginning of the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shotgun depicted as sharply angular and constructed entirely of low-polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shotgun and ejected shell display an iridescent sheen with cyan, magenta, and purple reflections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crystal structure explode outward into thousands of geometric fragments in slow motion immediately after the gunfire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fragments refract light from the shotgun's iridescent surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11297685652971268 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379767894744873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11297685652971268, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11297685652971268, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13749510049819946, + 0.10742688179016113, + 0.2068387120962143, + 0.09261797368526459, + 0.07053279876708984, + 0.14177493751049042, + 0.11758696287870407, + 0.06300758570432663, + 0.02836618945002556, + 0.03435283899307251 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11297685652971268 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth pan to the right at the beginning of the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shotgun depicted as sharply angular and constructed entirely of low-polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shotgun and ejected shell display an iridescent sheen with cyan, magenta, and purple reflections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crystal structure explode outward into thousands of geometric fragments in slow motion immediately after the gunfire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fragments refract light from the shotgun's iridescent surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005954266060143709 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130954265594482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005954266060143709, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005954266060143709, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12955926358699799, + 0.06882382184267044, + 0.0662049651145935, + 0.1466187834739685, + 0.18943433463573456, + 0.10570589452981949, + 0.12755264341831207, + 0.06959020346403122, + 0.054527800530195236, + 0.04198228195309639 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005954266060143709 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth pan to the right at the beginning of the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shotgun depicted as sharply angular and constructed entirely of low-polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shotgun and ejected shell display an iridescent sheen with cyan, magenta, and purple reflections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crystal structure explode outward into thousands of geometric fragments in slow motion immediately after the gunfire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fragments refract light from the shotgun's iridescent surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10028217732906342 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3502821922302246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10028217732906342, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10028217732906342, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08158230781555176, + 0.09712094068527222, + 0.09274230152368546, + 0.08743846416473389, + 0.07995627820491791, + 0.25759708881378174, + 0.08192527294158936, + 0.09230475127696991, + 0.07087361812591553, + 0.058458954095840454 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10028217732906342 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth pan to the right at the beginning of the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shotgun depicted as sharply angular and constructed entirely of low-polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shotgun and ejected shell display an iridescent sheen with cyan, magenta, and purple reflections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crystal structure explode outward into thousands of geometric fragments in slow motion immediately after the gunfire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fragments refract light from the shotgun's iridescent surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01253888476639986 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387538909912109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01253888476639986, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01253888476639986, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12341548502445221, + 0.07171930372714996, + 0.09091212600469589, + 0.07850640267133713, + 0.09407901763916016, + 0.11407040059566498, + 0.14289602637290955, + 0.1238446906208992, + 0.06808442622423172, + 0.09247210621833801 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01253888476639986 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "smooth, right-facing pan reveals a sharply angular M1216 shotgun constructed entirely of low-polygons. Its distinctive cylindrical magazine and barrel are coated in a captivating iridescent sheen, reflecting shifting cyan, magenta, and purple against the deep, dark background. The weapon jerks back, a massive, stylized, geometric white flash erupting from the muzzle. Immediately, a brass-colored shell, also constructed in a low-polygonal style, ejects cleanly, swirling away into the darkness. The muzzle faces a towering, imposing crystal structure, its interior seemingly imbued with a faint, cold white light, its translucent surface crisscrossed with natural geometric facets. At the moment the gunfire sounded, the entire crystalline structure exploded catastrophically outward without delay, instantly disintegrating into thousands of geometric fragments of varying sizes, flashing with sharp light. These fragments spread out in all directions in slow motion like a frozen cosmic explosion, each one capturing and refracting the light from the iridescent surface of the shotgun, creating a dazzling scene of destruction that was both violent and digitally beautiful. The overall atmosphere was filled with the coldness of futurism and the grandeur of surrealism.", + "seed": 8032, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_10/index_4372_seed_8032_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10005322247743606, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10005322247743606, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10005322247743606, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth pan to the right at the beginning of the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shotgun depicted as sharply angular and constructed entirely of low-polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shotgun and ejected shell display an iridescent sheen with cyan, magenta, and purple reflections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crystal structure explode outward into thousands of geometric fragments in slow motion immediately after the gunfire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fragments refract light from the shotgun's iridescent surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31909483671188354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3190948963165283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31909483671188354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31909483671188354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1199251338839531, + 0.09044831991195679, + 0.23267140984535217, + 0.13505184650421143, + 0.16888432204723358, + 0.18488487601280212, + 0.013464923948049545, + 0.03010431118309498, + 0.01275502610951662, + 0.01180986501276493 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31909483671188354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth pan to the right at the beginning of the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shotgun depicted as sharply angular and constructed entirely of low-polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shotgun and ejected shell display an iridescent sheen with cyan, magenta, and purple reflections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crystal structure explode outward into thousands of geometric fragments in slow motion immediately after the gunfire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fragments refract light from the shotgun's iridescent surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11295768618583679 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237957715988159 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11295768618583679, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11295768618583679, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0714598000049591, + 0.1321752518415451, + 0.12592782080173492, + 0.04656556621193886, + 0.10686399042606354, + 0.23085962235927582, + 0.017464062198996544, + 0.02492567151784897, + 0.0203146580606699, + 0.22344352304935455 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11295768618583679 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth pan to the right at the beginning of the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shotgun depicted as sharply angular and constructed entirely of low-polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shotgun and ejected shell display an iridescent sheen with cyan, magenta, and purple reflections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crystal structure explode outward into thousands of geometric fragments in slow motion immediately after the gunfire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fragments refract light from the shotgun's iridescent surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004642541520297527 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379642486572266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004642541520297527, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004642541520297527, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1214628741145134, + 0.0632101520895958, + 0.025699041783809662, + 0.02019537054002285, + 0.042567651718854904, + 0.06501700729131699, + 0.02021068148314953, + 0.027412068098783493, + 0.020637407898902893, + 0.5935877561569214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004642541520297527 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth pan to the right at the beginning of the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shotgun depicted as sharply angular and constructed entirely of low-polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shotgun and ejected shell display an iridescent sheen with cyan, magenta, and purple reflections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crystal structure explode outward into thousands of geometric fragments in slow motion immediately after the gunfire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fragments refract light from the shotgun's iridescent surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05493466183543205 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299347400665283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05493466183543205, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05493466183543205, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.055699389427900314, + 0.05994730442762375, + 0.05189086124300957, + 0.07213996350765228, + 0.07602224498987198, + 0.2331908792257309, + 0.06091105565428734, + 0.0997990295290947, + 0.18207889795303345, + 0.1083204373717308 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05493466183543205 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth pan to the right at the beginning of the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shotgun depicted as sharply angular and constructed entirely of low-polygons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shotgun and ejected shell display an iridescent sheen with cyan, magenta, and purple reflections?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crystal structure explode outward into thousands of geometric fragments in slow motion immediately after the gunfire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the resulting fragments refract light from the shotgun's iridescent surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008636386133730412 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758636474609375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008636386133730412, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008636386133730412, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18166688084602356, + 0.041043005883693695, + 0.09202195703983307, + 0.061804596334695816, + 0.06034495308995247, + 0.09514763206243515, + 0.07673295587301254, + 0.04086494818329811, + 0.055338773876428604, + 0.29503434896469116 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008636386133730412 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_3/index_tensor([5122, 5122])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_3/index_tensor([5122, 5122])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..89f2fa5a2a23f24b68f1a48a6901eb7918e6e80b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_3/index_tensor([5122, 5122])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "Rendered in a stunningly realistic, hyper-realistic 3D animation, a tight, low-angle close-up locks on the bow of an ancient wooden ship, the camera rising and falling in sync with the vessel's dramatic rise and fall in the storm. Composed of thick, weathered, dark planks, their grain rough and streaked with rust from nails, the bow gleams with a damp sheen in the dimming light. With a fearless gesture, it slices through the turbid, surging gray-green waves before it, each downward cut splitting the swell in two. As the bow rises violently from the trough to crest a massive wave, a vast expanse of white foam and salty spray erupts in a spectacular curtain of water, blasting into the air. Countless shimmering droplets of water briefly catch the diffuse light filtering through the thick clouds before being blown away by the wind. The image is shrouded in a cool palette of slate gray, deep sea green, and the dark brown of damp wood, creating a tense, monumental, and charged atmosphere of a fierce struggle against the primal forces of nature.", + "seed": 19226, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_3/index_5122_seed_19226_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.020263939490541817, + "vlm_logprob": -0.020263939490541817, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.020263939490541817, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the bow of an ancient wooden ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the ship's planks thick, weathered, dark, and streaked with rust from nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship slice through turbid, surging gray-green waves, splitting the swells?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a cool palette of slate gray, deep sea green, and dark brown wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a tight, low-angle close-up that rises and falls in sync with the vessel's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06391017884016037 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8139102458953857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06391017884016037, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06391017884016037, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06574614346027374, + 0.024574892595410347, + 0.04587474837899208, + 0.09369220584630966, + 0.044011469930410385, + 0.056816037744283676, + 0.05288054421544075, + 0.02948772720992565, + 0.4667675793170929, + 0.12014865130186081 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06391017884016037 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the bow of an ancient wooden ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the ship's planks thick, weathered, dark, and streaked with rust from nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship slice through turbid, surging gray-green waves, splitting the swells?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a cool palette of slate gray, deep sea green, and dark brown wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a tight, low-angle close-up that rises and falls in sync with the vessel's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01421763002872467 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264217853546143 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01421763002872467, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01421763002872467, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08015809953212738, + 0.0487835556268692, + 0.0925086960196495, + 0.04554970934987068, + 0.048187509179115295, + 0.05794178321957588, + 0.07256931811571121, + 0.0365484282374382, + 0.10225474834442139, + 0.41549813747406006 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01421763002872467 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the bow of an ancient wooden ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the ship's planks thick, weathered, dark, and streaked with rust from nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship slice through turbid, surging gray-green waves, splitting the swells?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a cool palette of slate gray, deep sea green, and dark brown wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a tight, low-angle close-up that rises and falls in sync with the vessel's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028203255496919155 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778204917907715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028203255496919155, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028203255496919155, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19111739099025726, + 0.04206761345267296, + 0.05906242877244949, + 0.09779291599988937, + 0.05746111646294594, + 0.05182359740138054, + 0.10761377960443497, + 0.029032105579972267, + 0.09572301805019379, + 0.2683059573173523 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028203255496919155 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the bow of an ancient wooden ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the ship's planks thick, weathered, dark, and streaked with rust from nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship slice through turbid, surging gray-green waves, splitting the swells?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a cool palette of slate gray, deep sea green, and dark brown wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a tight, low-angle close-up that rises and falls in sync with the vessel's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021984234917908907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127198219299316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021984234917908907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021984234917908907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07246418297290802, + 0.04264446720480919, + 0.06197069585323334, + 0.03989105671644211, + 0.025160841643810272, + 0.041082385927438736, + 0.0336722694337368, + 0.05247558653354645, + 0.05273856222629547, + 0.5778999328613281 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021984234917908907 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the bow of an ancient wooden ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the ship's planks thick, weathered, dark, and streaked with rust from nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship slice through turbid, surging gray-green waves, splitting the swells?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a cool palette of slate gray, deep sea green, and dark brown wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a tight, low-angle close-up that rises and falls in sync with the vessel's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018173139542341232 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0181732177734375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018173139542341232, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018173139542341232, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1573060154914856, + 0.08080831170082092, + 0.058769553899765015, + 0.0490943007171154, + 0.03608742728829384, + 0.08143910020589828, + 0.06319975852966309, + 0.042124249041080475, + 0.1295737773180008, + 0.301597535610199 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018173139542341232 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Rendered in a stunningly realistic, hyper-realistic 3D animation, a tight, low-angle close-up locks on the bow of an ancient wooden ship, the camera rising and falling in sync with the vessel's dramatic rise and fall in the storm. Composed of thick, weathered, dark planks, their grain rough and streaked with rust from nails, the bow gleams with a damp sheen in the dimming light. With a fearless gesture, it slices through the turbid, surging gray-green waves before it, each downward cut splitting the swell in two. As the bow rises violently from the trough to crest a massive wave, a vast expanse of white foam and salty spray erupts in a spectacular curtain of water, blasting into the air. Countless shimmering droplets of water briefly catch the diffuse light filtering through the thick clouds before being blown away by the wind. The image is shrouded in a cool palette of slate gray, deep sea green, and the dark brown of damp wood, creating a tense, monumental, and charged atmosphere of a fierce struggle against the primal forces of nature.", + "seed": 19227, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_3/index_5122_seed_19227_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.007928231102414428, + "vlm_logprob": -0.007928231102414428, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.007928231102414428, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the bow of an ancient wooden ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the ship's planks thick, weathered, dark, and streaked with rust from nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship slice through turbid, surging gray-green waves, splitting the swells?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a cool palette of slate gray, deep sea green, and dark brown wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a tight, low-angle close-up that rises and falls in sync with the vessel's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008660731837153435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.883660793304443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008660731837153435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008660731837153435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11649464815855026, + 0.05907819792628288, + 0.12579238414764404, + 0.18569527566432953, + 0.08715704083442688, + 0.06985095143318176, + 0.091699980199337, + 0.06160656735301018, + 0.04220300540328026, + 0.1604219228029251 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008660731837153435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the bow of an ancient wooden ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the ship's planks thick, weathered, dark, and streaked with rust from nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship slice through turbid, surging gray-green waves, splitting the swells?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a cool palette of slate gray, deep sea green, and dark brown wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a tight, low-angle close-up that rises and falls in sync with the vessel's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009795927442610264 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634796142578125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009795927442610264, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009795927442610264, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1940051019191742, + 0.19752314686775208, + 0.0776788592338562, + 0.041996341198682785, + 0.20471760630607605, + 0.05129493027925491, + 0.06472967565059662, + 0.04292669519782066, + 0.03173983097076416, + 0.09338781237602234 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009795927442610264 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the bow of an ancient wooden ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the ship's planks thick, weathered, dark, and streaked with rust from nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship slice through turbid, surging gray-green waves, splitting the swells?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a cool palette of slate gray, deep sea green, and dark brown wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a tight, low-angle close-up that rises and falls in sync with the vessel's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003615511115640402 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628615379333496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003615511115640402, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003615511115640402, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0823308676481247, + 0.07460226863622665, + 0.0953177884221077, + 0.046281278133392334, + 0.21087095141410828, + 0.035134457051754, + 0.18491023778915405, + 0.07829489558935165, + 0.012686912901699543, + 0.17957034707069397 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003615511115640402 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the bow of an ancient wooden ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the ship's planks thick, weathered, dark, and streaked with rust from nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship slice through turbid, surging gray-green waves, splitting the swells?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a cool palette of slate gray, deep sea green, and dark brown wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a tight, low-angle close-up that rises and falls in sync with the vessel's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001513170194812119 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.5015130043029785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001513170194812119, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001513170194812119, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15303924679756165, + 0.06128845363855362, + 0.05439078062772751, + 0.07049763202667236, + 0.06140894070267677, + 0.03679044172167778, + 0.14411447942256927, + 0.02895181067287922, + 0.04979472607374191, + 0.33972346782684326 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001513170194812119 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the bow of an ancient wooden ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the ship's planks thick, weathered, dark, and streaked with rust from nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship slice through turbid, surging gray-green waves, splitting the swells?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a cool palette of slate gray, deep sea green, and dark brown wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a tight, low-angle close-up that rises and falls in sync with the vessel's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016055814921855927 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141055583953857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016055814921855927, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016055814921855927, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0720711424946785, + 0.08769939839839935, + 0.24686476588249207, + 0.053140122443437576, + 0.0491565577685833, + 0.053799599409103394, + 0.16305230557918549, + 0.062341492623090744, + 0.02296224609017372, + 0.18891240656375885 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016055814921855927 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Rendered in a stunningly realistic, hyper-realistic 3D animation, a tight, low-angle close-up locks on the bow of an ancient wooden ship, the camera rising and falling in sync with the vessel's dramatic rise and fall in the storm. Composed of thick, weathered, dark planks, their grain rough and streaked with rust from nails, the bow gleams with a damp sheen in the dimming light. With a fearless gesture, it slices through the turbid, surging gray-green waves before it, each downward cut splitting the swell in two. As the bow rises violently from the trough to crest a massive wave, a vast expanse of white foam and salty spray erupts in a spectacular curtain of water, blasting into the air. Countless shimmering droplets of water briefly catch the diffuse light filtering through the thick clouds before being blown away by the wind. The image is shrouded in a cool palette of slate gray, deep sea green, and the dark brown of damp wood, creating a tense, monumental, and charged atmosphere of a fierce struggle against the primal forces of nature.", + "seed": 19228, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_3/index_5122_seed_19228_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.009408726054243744, + "vlm_logprob": -0.009408726054243744, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.009408726054243744, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the bow of an ancient wooden ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the ship's planks thick, weathered, dark, and streaked with rust from nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship slice through turbid, surging gray-green waves, splitting the swells?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a cool palette of slate gray, deep sea green, and dark brown wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a tight, low-angle close-up that rises and falls in sync with the vessel's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006279973778873682 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.506279945373535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006279973778873682, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006279973778873682, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10113216936588287, + 0.043729133903980255, + 0.04523681849241257, + 0.22610929608345032, + 0.024663541465997696, + 0.05385398492217064, + 0.09530032426118851, + 0.26602691411972046, + 0.12311260402202606, + 0.020835163071751595 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006279973778873682 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the bow of an ancient wooden ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the ship's planks thick, weathered, dark, and streaked with rust from nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship slice through turbid, surging gray-green waves, splitting the swells?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a cool palette of slate gray, deep sea green, and dark brown wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a tight, low-angle close-up that rises and falls in sync with the vessel's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016082679852843285 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141082763671875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016082679852843285, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016082679852843285, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15980765223503113, + 0.0557960569858551, + 0.0492999330163002, + 0.1085905209183693, + 0.021681204438209534, + 0.05384540557861328, + 0.03927864879369736, + 0.10270816087722778, + 0.3503146767616272, + 0.05867776274681091 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016082679852843285 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the bow of an ancient wooden ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the ship's planks thick, weathered, dark, and streaked with rust from nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship slice through turbid, surging gray-green waves, splitting the swells?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a cool palette of slate gray, deep sea green, and dark brown wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a tight, low-angle close-up that rises and falls in sync with the vessel's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031919742468744516 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753191947937012 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031919742468744516, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031919742468744516, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10910765081644058, + 0.07347454130649567, + 0.26078179478645325, + 0.11409236490726471, + 0.014679079875349998, + 0.14282667636871338, + 0.027402283623814583, + 0.06629049777984619, + 0.1478404551744461, + 0.04350464791059494 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031919742468744516 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the bow of an ancient wooden ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the ship's planks thick, weathered, dark, and streaked with rust from nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship slice through turbid, surging gray-green waves, splitting the swells?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a cool palette of slate gray, deep sea green, and dark brown wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a tight, low-angle close-up that rises and falls in sync with the vessel's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.000920825288631022 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.00092077255249 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.000920825288631022, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.000920825288631022, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19949723780155182, + 0.06460051238536835, + 0.2441314160823822, + 0.03087797202169895, + 0.02511521428823471, + 0.08337214589118958, + 0.0432228147983551, + 0.11711414903402328, + 0.14089621603488922, + 0.05117237940430641 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.000920825288631022 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the bow of an ancient wooden ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the ship's planks thick, weathered, dark, and streaked with rust from nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship slice through turbid, surging gray-green waves, splitting the swells?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a cool palette of slate gray, deep sea green, and dark brown wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a tight, low-angle close-up that rises and falls in sync with the vessel's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020568177103996277 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955681324005127 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020568177103996277, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020568177103996277, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05374353379011154, + 0.045917823910713196, + 0.16022376716136932, + 0.1873743087053299, + 0.06081899255514145, + 0.20194309949874878, + 0.0577913261950016, + 0.14616331458091736, + 0.05451606959104538, + 0.03150781989097595 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020568177103996277 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Rendered in a stunningly realistic, hyper-realistic 3D animation, a tight, low-angle close-up locks on the bow of an ancient wooden ship, the camera rising and falling in sync with the vessel's dramatic rise and fall in the storm. Composed of thick, weathered, dark planks, their grain rough and streaked with rust from nails, the bow gleams with a damp sheen in the dimming light. With a fearless gesture, it slices through the turbid, surging gray-green waves before it, each downward cut splitting the swell in two. As the bow rises violently from the trough to crest a massive wave, a vast expanse of white foam and salty spray erupts in a spectacular curtain of water, blasting into the air. Countless shimmering droplets of water briefly catch the diffuse light filtering through the thick clouds before being blown away by the wind. The image is shrouded in a cool palette of slate gray, deep sea green, and the dark brown of damp wood, creating a tense, monumental, and charged atmosphere of a fierce struggle against the primal forces of nature.", + "seed": 19229, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_3/index_5122_seed_19229_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.011936083063483238, + "vlm_logprob": -0.011936083063483238, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.011936083063483238, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the bow of an ancient wooden ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the ship's planks thick, weathered, dark, and streaked with rust from nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship slice through turbid, surging gray-green waves, splitting the swells?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a cool palette of slate gray, deep sea green, and dark brown wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a tight, low-angle close-up that rises and falls in sync with the vessel's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0254538431763649 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.775453805923462 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0254538431763649, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0254538431763649, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24912092089653015, + 0.10606254637241364, + 0.10878247022628784, + 0.12958833575248718, + 0.10635749995708466, + 0.03397457301616669, + 0.03951994702219963, + 0.09078513085842133, + 0.07231415808200836, + 0.06349436938762665 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0254538431763649 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the bow of an ancient wooden ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the ship's planks thick, weathered, dark, and streaked with rust from nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship slice through turbid, surging gray-green waves, splitting the swells?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a cool palette of slate gray, deep sea green, and dark brown wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a tight, low-angle close-up that rises and falls in sync with the vessel's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014219510369002819 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264219284057617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014219510369002819, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014219510369002819, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14463891088962555, + 0.3306892216205597, + 0.10822421312332153, + 0.09104049205780029, + 0.04101737588644028, + 0.033823393285274506, + 0.041481710970401764, + 0.09182029217481613, + 0.054335735738277435, + 0.06292864680290222 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014219510369002819 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the bow of an ancient wooden ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the ship's planks thick, weathered, dark, and streaked with rust from nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship slice through turbid, surging gray-green waves, splitting the swells?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a cool palette of slate gray, deep sea green, and dark brown wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a tight, low-angle close-up that rises and falls in sync with the vessel's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036194308195263147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628619194030762 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036194308195263147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036194308195263147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14628839492797852, + 0.08002649992704391, + 0.07261592149734497, + 0.07530035078525543, + 0.05268661305308342, + 0.03536277264356613, + 0.11347796022891998, + 0.099969282746315, + 0.10230604559183121, + 0.2219661921262741 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036194308195263147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the bow of an ancient wooden ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the ship's planks thick, weathered, dark, and streaked with rust from nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship slice through turbid, surging gray-green waves, splitting the swells?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a cool palette of slate gray, deep sea green, and dark brown wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a tight, low-angle close-up that rises and falls in sync with the vessel's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021999699529260397 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127200126647949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021999699529260397, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021999699529260397, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13689707219600677, + 0.1875775307416916, + 0.07991983741521835, + 0.09052799642086029, + 0.10096557438373566, + 0.04746430739760399, + 0.06553560495376587, + 0.08190517872571945, + 0.12217295169830322, + 0.0870339423418045 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021999699529260397 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the bow of an ancient wooden ship?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the ship's planks thick, weathered, dark, and streaked with rust from nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the ship slice through turbid, surging gray-green waves, splitting the swells?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by a cool palette of slate gray, deep sea green, and dark brown wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a tight, low-angle close-up that rises and falls in sync with the vessel's motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014187660999596119 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264187812805176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014187660999596119, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014187660999596119, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11652198433876038, + 0.07750426232814789, + 0.022972075268626213, + 0.09336898475885391, + 0.2509630024433136, + 0.0583697147667408, + 0.06292416155338287, + 0.10220298171043396, + 0.13153120875358582, + 0.08364161849021912 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014187660999596119 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_4/index_tensor([4703, 4703])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_4/index_tensor([4703, 4703])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..72981ecd26c02ee0b6e18b84ab988fd67d824a35 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_4/index_tensor([4703, 4703])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot smoothly follows a handsome East Asian boy dressed in traditional Chinese clothing as he walks through a dense, tranquil, emerald green bamboo forest. Dappled sunlight filters through the gaps between the towering bamboo leaves, casting dancing specks of light on the moist dirt path. The boy's long, dark hair is tied back with a simple jade hairpin. His face is handsome, and a bright, free smile radiates. He wears a moon-white and indigo-colored, cross-collared Hanfu. The light silk fabric is embroidered with delicate silver cloud patterns. As he runs briskly and powerfully, his signature wide sleeves are lifted by the wind, like two outstretched wings, tracing graceful, continuous arcs in the air, occasionally dropping a few bamboo leaves. The entire scene, with its fluid light and shadow and refreshing green hues, creates an atmosphere of free and unrestrained, classical romance imbued with youthful spirit.", + "seed": 15605, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_4/index_4703_seed_15605_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.4208426222205162, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4208426222205162, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.7999999523162842, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4208426222205162, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a handsome East Asian boy wearing traditional Chinese clothing (Hanfu)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy running briskly with his wide sleeves lifted by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense emerald green bamboo forest with dappled sunlight on a moist dirt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7434885501861572 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7434885501861572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7434885501861572, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7434885501861572, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17924213409423828, + 0.1639804244041443, + 0.06438995152711868, + 0.13912266492843628, + 0.11610741168260574, + 0.13039308786392212, + 0.07305284589529037, + 0.043449319899082184, + 0.04629921913146973, + 0.0439630001783371 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7434885501861572 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a handsome East Asian boy wearing traditional Chinese clothing (Hanfu)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy running briskly with his wide sleeves lifted by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense emerald green bamboo forest with dappled sunlight on a moist dirt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236449718475342 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486449718475342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2236449718475342, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2236449718475342, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15168112516403198, + 0.060314904898405075, + 0.06575580686330795, + 0.2086612433195114, + 0.09566992521286011, + 0.04810309037566185, + 0.08994941413402557, + 0.18314993381500244, + 0.050304289907217026, + 0.046410251408815384 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2236449718475342 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a handsome East Asian boy wearing traditional Chinese clothing (Hanfu)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy running briskly with his wide sleeves lifted by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense emerald green bamboo forest with dappled sunlight on a moist dirt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029828868806362152 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298287868499756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029828868806362152, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029828868806362152, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23361898958683014, + 0.157037153840065, + 0.05352068319916725, + 0.07799405604600906, + 0.23010589182376862, + 0.0809738039970398, + 0.03194492682814598, + 0.04736080765724182, + 0.05009881407022476, + 0.03734489530324936 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029828868806362152 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a handsome East Asian boy wearing traditional Chinese clothing (Hanfu)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy running briskly with his wide sleeves lifted by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense emerald green bamboo forest with dappled sunlight on a moist dirt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08906400203704834 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464064121246338 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08906400203704834, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08906400203704834, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11498167365789413, + 0.15688452124595642, + 0.2853548228740692, + 0.19560082256793976, + 0.045457590371370316, + 0.03561791032552719, + 0.038829125463962555, + 0.043439317494630814, + 0.027584446594119072, + 0.05624972656369209 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08906400203704834 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a handsome East Asian boy wearing traditional Chinese clothing (Hanfu)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy running briskly with his wide sleeves lifted by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense emerald green bamboo forest with dappled sunlight on a moist dirt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018186718225479126 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018186569213867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018186718225479126, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018186718225479126, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1644633710384369, + 0.10889939963817596, + 0.07528707385063171, + 0.10656341910362244, + 0.21836893260478973, + 0.05384298786520958, + 0.045457787811756134, + 0.09739793092012405, + 0.05207931995391846, + 0.07763977348804474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018186718225479126 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot smoothly follows a handsome East Asian boy dressed in traditional Chinese clothing as he walks through a dense, tranquil, emerald green bamboo forest. Dappled sunlight filters through the gaps between the towering bamboo leaves, casting dancing specks of light on the moist dirt path. The boy's long, dark hair is tied back with a simple jade hairpin. His face is handsome, and a bright, free smile radiates. He wears a moon-white and indigo-colored, cross-collared Hanfu. The light silk fabric is embroidered with delicate silver cloud patterns. As he runs briskly and powerfully, his signature wide sleeves are lifted by the wind, like two outstretched wings, tracing graceful, continuous arcs in the air, occasionally dropping a few bamboo leaves. The entire scene, with its fluid light and shadow and refreshing green hues, creates an atmosphere of free and unrestrained, classical romance imbued with youthful spirit.", + "seed": 15606, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_4/index_4703_seed_15606_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.37582236658781765, + "vlm_logprob": -0.37582236658781765, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.37582236658781765, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a handsome East Asian boy wearing traditional Chinese clothing (Hanfu)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy running briskly with his wide sleeves lifted by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense emerald green bamboo forest with dappled sunlight on a moist dirt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.868584930896759 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.618584930896759 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.868584930896759, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.868584930896759, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33926790952682495, + 0.05402376502752304, + 0.09351983666419983, + 0.1346815824508667, + 0.18958213925361633, + 0.030103124678134918, + 0.021716900169849396, + 0.015781840309500694, + 0.09326883405447006, + 0.028054049238562584 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.868584930896759 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a handsome East Asian boy wearing traditional Chinese clothing (Hanfu)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy running briskly with his wide sleeves lifted by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense emerald green bamboo forest with dappled sunlight on a moist dirt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261563777923584 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761563777923584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8261563777923584, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8261563777923584, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3377348780632019, + 0.02910633198916912, + 0.03306618332862854, + 0.026698719710111618, + 0.12767170369625092, + 0.020176969468593597, + 0.009971682913601398, + 0.020308448001742363, + 0.38652974367141724, + 0.008735309354960918 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8261563777923584 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a handsome East Asian boy wearing traditional Chinese clothing (Hanfu)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy running briskly with his wide sleeves lifted by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense emerald green bamboo forest with dappled sunlight on a moist dirt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014221156015992165 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26422119140625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014221156015992165, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014221156015992165, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5364362597465515, + 0.1868196576833725, + 0.012931925244629383, + 0.02665742300450802, + 0.043797191232442856, + 0.00883375946432352, + 0.02948840521275997, + 0.019424064084887505, + 0.0616706907749176, + 0.07394050806760788 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014221156015992165 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a handsome East Asian boy wearing traditional Chinese clothing (Hanfu)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy running briskly with his wide sleeves lifted by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense emerald green bamboo forest with dappled sunlight on a moist dirt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16037043929100037 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103704690933228 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16037043929100037, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16037043929100037, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3102198541164398, + 0.10019063949584961, + 0.031682368367910385, + 0.052526071667671204, + 0.18813712894916534, + 0.03976865112781525, + 0.06429862976074219, + 0.06839323043823242, + 0.10988038033246994, + 0.03490293771028519 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16037043929100037 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a handsome East Asian boy wearing traditional Chinese clothing (Hanfu)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy running briskly with his wide sleeves lifted by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense emerald green bamboo forest with dappled sunlight on a moist dirt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009778928942978382 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63477897644043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009778928942978382, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009778928942978382, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6311777234077454, + 0.02813311107456684, + 0.01582326367497444, + 0.02467147447168827, + 0.04695846512913704, + 0.022816123440861702, + 0.018428537994623184, + 0.02087567187845707, + 0.12716850638389587, + 0.06394708901643753 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009778928942978382 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot smoothly follows a handsome East Asian boy dressed in traditional Chinese clothing as he walks through a dense, tranquil, emerald green bamboo forest. Dappled sunlight filters through the gaps between the towering bamboo leaves, casting dancing specks of light on the moist dirt path. The boy's long, dark hair is tied back with a simple jade hairpin. His face is handsome, and a bright, free smile radiates. He wears a moon-white and indigo-colored, cross-collared Hanfu. The light silk fabric is embroidered with delicate silver cloud patterns. As he runs briskly and powerfully, his signature wide sleeves are lifted by the wind, like two outstretched wings, tracing graceful, continuous arcs in the air, occasionally dropping a few bamboo leaves. The entire scene, with its fluid light and shadow and refreshing green hues, creates an atmosphere of free and unrestrained, classical romance imbued with youthful spirit.", + "seed": 15607, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_4/index_4703_seed_15607_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.35299698477610947, + "vlm_logprob": -0.35299698477610947, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.35299698477610947, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a handsome East Asian boy wearing traditional Chinese clothing (Hanfu)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy running briskly with his wide sleeves lifted by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense emerald green bamboo forest with dappled sunlight on a moist dirt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8854811191558838 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6354811191558838 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8854811191558838, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8854811191558838, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16594479978084564, + 0.07331541180610657, + 0.04174688085913658, + 0.05225123092532158, + 0.14648421108722687, + 0.042135417461395264, + 0.036989811807870865, + 0.20893138647079468, + 0.08840379118919373, + 0.14379702508449554 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8854811191558838 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a handsome East Asian boy wearing traditional Chinese clothing (Hanfu)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy running briskly with his wide sleeves lifted by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense emerald green bamboo forest with dappled sunlight on a moist dirt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933988928794861 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933988928794861 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6933988928794861, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6933988928794861, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10610093921422958, + 0.13678103685379028, + 0.03346196189522743, + 0.07577130943536758, + 0.06957590579986572, + 0.10220169275999069, + 0.03940518945455551, + 0.16096563637256622, + 0.061252202838659286, + 0.21448412537574768 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6933988928794861 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a handsome East Asian boy wearing traditional Chinese clothing (Hanfu)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy running briskly with his wide sleeves lifted by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense emerald green bamboo forest with dappled sunlight on a moist dirt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07902524620294571 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790252685546875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07902524620294571, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07902524620294571, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14404258131980896, + 0.21994540095329285, + 0.1954413503408432, + 0.040812525898218155, + 0.044383227825164795, + 0.042031217366456985, + 0.0337851420044899, + 0.12987209856510162, + 0.10500315576791763, + 0.044683340936899185 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07902524620294571 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a handsome East Asian boy wearing traditional Chinese clothing (Hanfu)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy running briskly with his wide sleeves lifted by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense emerald green bamboo forest with dappled sunlight on a moist dirt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10034288465976715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503429889678955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10034288465976715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10034288465976715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08473961800336838, + 0.18614044785499573, + 0.07151071727275848, + 0.2274719625711441, + 0.12661056220531464, + 0.052807681262493134, + 0.04423464462161064, + 0.08019369840621948, + 0.05837496370077133, + 0.06791570037603378 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10034288465976715 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a handsome East Asian boy wearing traditional Chinese clothing (Hanfu)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy running briskly with his wide sleeves lifted by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense emerald green bamboo forest with dappled sunlight on a moist dirt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006736780982464552 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006736755371094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006736780982464552, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006736780982464552, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11023057997226715, + 0.1207951009273529, + 0.045047011226415634, + 0.061569809913635254, + 0.14026804268360138, + 0.08393353223800659, + 0.0948445200920105, + 0.07985837757587433, + 0.11659751832485199, + 0.14685553312301636 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006736780982464552 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot smoothly follows a handsome East Asian boy dressed in traditional Chinese clothing as he walks through a dense, tranquil, emerald green bamboo forest. Dappled sunlight filters through the gaps between the towering bamboo leaves, casting dancing specks of light on the moist dirt path. The boy's long, dark hair is tied back with a simple jade hairpin. His face is handsome, and a bright, free smile radiates. He wears a moon-white and indigo-colored, cross-collared Hanfu. The light silk fabric is embroidered with delicate silver cloud patterns. As he runs briskly and powerfully, his signature wide sleeves are lifted by the wind, like two outstretched wings, tracing graceful, continuous arcs in the air, occasionally dropping a few bamboo leaves. The entire scene, with its fluid light and shadow and refreshing green hues, creates an atmosphere of free and unrestrained, classical romance imbued with youthful spirit.", + "seed": 15608, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_4/index_4703_seed_15608_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.3506663618609309, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3506663618609309, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3506663618609309, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a handsome East Asian boy wearing traditional Chinese clothing (Hanfu)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy running briskly with his wide sleeves lifted by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense emerald green bamboo forest with dappled sunlight on a moist dirt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.707554817199707 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.832554817199707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.707554817199707, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.707554817199707, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23183877766132355, + 0.11446725577116013, + 0.055393822491168976, + 0.1675085574388504, + 0.031912174075841904, + 0.1285453587770462, + 0.03876862674951553, + 0.029962414875626564, + 0.0427522175014019, + 0.15885083377361298 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.707554817199707 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a handsome East Asian boy wearing traditional Chinese clothing (Hanfu)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy running briskly with his wide sleeves lifted by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense emerald green bamboo forest with dappled sunlight on a moist dirt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578501105308533 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328501105308533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7578501105308533, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7578501105308533, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08865701407194138, + 0.15442407131195068, + 0.06980856508016586, + 0.1092977523803711, + 0.04050186648964882, + 0.10112801939249039, + 0.11468232423067093, + 0.06136454641819, + 0.09911884367465973, + 0.16101698577404022 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7578501105308533 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a handsome East Asian boy wearing traditional Chinese clothing (Hanfu)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy running briskly with his wide sleeves lifted by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense emerald green bamboo forest with dappled sunlight on a moist dirt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1799519956111908 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049520254135132 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1799519956111908, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1799519956111908, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22427645325660706, + 0.23089943826198578, + 0.08401508629322052, + 0.10600092262029648, + 0.030061423778533936, + 0.12706363201141357, + 0.03474938124418259, + 0.04495323821902275, + 0.04021963104605675, + 0.07776086032390594 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1799519956111908 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a handsome East Asian boy wearing traditional Chinese clothing (Hanfu)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy running briskly with his wide sleeves lifted by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense emerald green bamboo forest with dappled sunlight on a moist dirt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10034558176994324 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503456115722656 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10034558176994324, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10034558176994324, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15150508284568787, + 0.12009809166193008, + 0.06743981689214706, + 0.07264506071805954, + 0.07150430232286453, + 0.10253634303808212, + 0.17742829024791718, + 0.10969864577054977, + 0.05377946048974991, + 0.07336487621068954 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10034558176994324 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a smooth tracking shot following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a handsome East Asian boy wearing traditional Chinese clothing (Hanfu)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the boy running briskly with his wide sleeves lifted by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense emerald green bamboo forest with dappled sunlight on a moist dirt path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007629304192960262 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88262939453125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007629304192960262, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007629304192960262, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1942846029996872, + 0.10284962505102158, + 0.12281081080436707, + 0.07266755402088165, + 0.02600877545773983, + 0.10222657769918442, + 0.03465396165847778, + 0.05744505673646927, + 0.2071693390607834, + 0.07988366484642029 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007629304192960262 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_9/index_tensor([1348, 1348])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_9/index_tensor([1348, 1348])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0117b21acc0973af46d0a26aabb9fc0101f6a315 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_9/index_tensor([1348, 1348])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The scene opens in extreme close-up, directly behind a seated figure, as the camera begins a slow, deliberate 90-degree arc to the right. Initially, the frame fills with the textured, dark gray fabric of a worn, cotton hoodie, the hood pulled down, revealing the back of the neck. The man's shoulders are severely hunched forward, his petite body curled in a tense, defensive posture. As the camera steadily pans, the profile of an elderly, mixed-race man with light brown, weathered skin and neatly cut, salt-and-pepper curls gradually emerges. He sits in a simple, dark wooden chair, leaning against a plain, out-of-focus, neutral-toned wall, sharply illuminated by a single, harsh, artificial light overhead. As the camera settles on his profile, this cool light carves deep shadows into his features, capturing the raw intensity of his anger. His jaw is visibly clenched in tension, the muscles in his cheeks pulse rhythmically, and a frown forms above his downcast eyes. His arms remained stubbornly crossed across his chest, his lips pressed together in a firm, silent pout, creating a powerful, controlled atmosphere of simmering frustration and unspoken conflict.", + "seed": 28364, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_9/index_1348_seed_28364_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.2931188389658928, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2931188389658928, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2931188389658928, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up directly behind a seated figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate 90-degree arc to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly mixed-race man with light brown weathered skin and salt-and-pepper curls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh artificial light overhead creating deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the man's arms crossed across his chest with his jaw clenched and lips pressed together?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016635045409202576 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.391634941101074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016635045409202576, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016635045409202576, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05488469451665878, + 0.08176100254058838, + 0.22880882024765015, + 0.3560752868652344, + 0.030926967039704323, + 0.0317823626101017, + 0.038667649030685425, + 0.07227446883916855, + 0.07848162949085236, + 0.026337066665291786 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016635045409202576 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up directly behind a seated figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate 90-degree arc to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly mixed-race man with light brown weathered skin and salt-and-pepper curls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh artificial light overhead creating deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the man's arms crossed across his chest with his jaw clenched and lips pressed together?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03373117744922638 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.40873122215271 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03373117744922638, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03373117744922638, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09843970835208893, + 0.03223281726241112, + 0.3630644381046295, + 0.06494753062725067, + 0.0754241794347763, + 0.03723539039492607, + 0.0364748053252697, + 0.11514906585216522, + 0.13480643928050995, + 0.04222565516829491 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03373117744922638 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up directly behind a seated figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate 90-degree arc to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly mixed-race man with light brown weathered skin and salt-and-pepper curls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh artificial light overhead creating deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the man's arms crossed across his chest with his jaw clenched and lips pressed together?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04868713766336441 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048687219619751 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04868713766336441, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04868713766336441, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11697662621736526, + 0.06271525472402573, + 0.14347201585769653, + 0.05523451790213585, + 0.10753334313631058, + 0.02819407358765602, + 0.020941391587257385, + 0.10689228028059006, + 0.06947046518325806, + 0.2885700464248657 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04868713766336441 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up directly behind a seated figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate 90-degree arc to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly mixed-race man with light brown weathered skin and salt-and-pepper curls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh artificial light overhead creating deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the man's arms crossed across his chest with his jaw clenched and lips pressed together?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236684560775757 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486684262752533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2236684560775757, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2236684560775757, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1417728066444397, + 0.08940745145082474, + 0.10621770471334457, + 0.07257339358329773, + 0.03283907473087311, + 0.23961102962493896, + 0.025018392130732536, + 0.0784192904829979, + 0.09132244437932968, + 0.1228184700012207 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2236684560775757 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up directly behind a seated figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate 90-degree arc to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly mixed-race man with light brown weathered skin and salt-and-pepper curls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh artificial light overhead creating deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the man's arms crossed across his chest with his jaw clenched and lips pressed together?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428723782300949 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178723335266113 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428723782300949, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428723782300949, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0394415445625782, + 0.02113248035311699, + 0.42363375425338745, + 0.11793538182973862, + 0.023283038288354874, + 0.02654915489256382, + 0.025607207790017128, + 0.11029503494501114, + 0.10639685392379761, + 0.10572558641433716 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428723782300949 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene opens in extreme close-up, directly behind a seated figure, as the camera begins a slow, deliberate 90-degree arc to the right. Initially, the frame fills with the textured, dark gray fabric of a worn, cotton hoodie, the hood pulled down, revealing the back of the neck. The man's shoulders are severely hunched forward, his petite body curled in a tense, defensive posture. As the camera steadily pans, the profile of an elderly, mixed-race man with light brown, weathered skin and neatly cut, salt-and-pepper curls gradually emerges. He sits in a simple, dark wooden chair, leaning against a plain, out-of-focus, neutral-toned wall, sharply illuminated by a single, harsh, artificial light overhead. As the camera settles on his profile, this cool light carves deep shadows into his features, capturing the raw intensity of his anger. His jaw is visibly clenched in tension, the muscles in his cheeks pulse rhythmically, and a frown forms above his downcast eyes. His arms remained stubbornly crossed across his chest, his lips pressed together in a firm, silent pout, creating a powerful, controlled atmosphere of simmering frustration and unspoken conflict.", + "seed": 28365, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_9/index_1348_seed_28365_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.16978879868984223, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16978879868984223, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16978879868984223, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up directly behind a seated figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate 90-degree arc to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly mixed-race man with light brown weathered skin and salt-and-pepper curls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh artificial light overhead creating deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the man's arms crossed across his chest with his jaw clenched and lips pressed together?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.045544978231191635 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1705448627471924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.045544978231191635, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.045544978231191635, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10151712596416473, + 0.16542184352874756, + 0.08102210611104965, + 0.15868231654167175, + 0.044367097318172455, + 0.018386760726571083, + 0.21399913728237152, + 0.13961905241012573, + 0.05683759227395058, + 0.020146925002336502 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.045544978231191635 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up directly behind a seated figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate 90-degree arc to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly mixed-race man with light brown weathered skin and salt-and-pepper curls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh artificial light overhead creating deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the man's arms crossed across his chest with his jaw clenched and lips pressed together?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309011995792389 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680901050567627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309011995792389, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309011995792389, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0834713950753212, + 0.13790501654148102, + 0.11066760122776031, + 0.07135432213544846, + 0.05118705332279205, + 0.04434977471828461, + 0.23593324422836304, + 0.1499066948890686, + 0.07801596820354462, + 0.0372089147567749 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309011995792389 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up directly behind a seated figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate 90-degree arc to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly mixed-race man with light brown weathered skin and salt-and-pepper curls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh artificial light overhead creating deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the man's arms crossed across his chest with his jaw clenched and lips pressed together?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048684071749448776 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486841201782227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048684071749448776, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048684071749448776, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07847613841295242, + 0.027004454284906387, + 0.035848118364810944, + 0.10324615240097046, + 0.02442321553826332, + 0.04680553451180458, + 0.3341851830482483, + 0.2415793091058731, + 0.03759409487247467, + 0.07083771377801895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048684071749448776 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up directly behind a seated figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate 90-degree arc to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly mixed-race man with light brown weathered skin and salt-and-pepper curls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh artificial light overhead creating deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the man's arms crossed across his chest with his jaw clenched and lips pressed together?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.693424642086029 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.693424642086029 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.693424642086029, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.693424642086029, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06855051964521408, + 0.04228558391332626, + 0.09658343344926834, + 0.13674521446228027, + 0.010324951261281967, + 0.02934742532670498, + 0.15351296961307526, + 0.3895859122276306, + 0.02742682583630085, + 0.045637138187885284 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.693424642086029 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up directly behind a seated figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate 90-degree arc to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly mixed-race man with light brown weathered skin and salt-and-pepper curls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh artificial light overhead creating deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the man's arms crossed across his chest with his jaw clenched and lips pressed together?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018200181424617767 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018200397491455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018200181424617767, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018200181424617767, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.040617942810058594, + 0.052126433700323105, + 0.022983115166425705, + 0.20554228127002716, + 0.06183193624019623, + 0.08407441526651382, + 0.07599618285894394, + 0.3454059660434723, + 0.019279085099697113, + 0.09214261919260025 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018200181424617767 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene opens in extreme close-up, directly behind a seated figure, as the camera begins a slow, deliberate 90-degree arc to the right. Initially, the frame fills with the textured, dark gray fabric of a worn, cotton hoodie, the hood pulled down, revealing the back of the neck. The man's shoulders are severely hunched forward, his petite body curled in a tense, defensive posture. As the camera steadily pans, the profile of an elderly, mixed-race man with light brown, weathered skin and neatly cut, salt-and-pepper curls gradually emerges. He sits in a simple, dark wooden chair, leaning against a plain, out-of-focus, neutral-toned wall, sharply illuminated by a single, harsh, artificial light overhead. As the camera settles on his profile, this cool light carves deep shadows into his features, capturing the raw intensity of his anger. His jaw is visibly clenched in tension, the muscles in his cheeks pulse rhythmically, and a frown forms above his downcast eyes. His arms remained stubbornly crossed across his chest, his lips pressed together in a firm, silent pout, creating a powerful, controlled atmosphere of simmering frustration and unspoken conflict.", + "seed": 28366, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_9/index_1348_seed_28366_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.18356594294309617, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18356594294309617, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18356594294309617, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up directly behind a seated figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate 90-degree arc to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly mixed-race man with light brown weathered skin and salt-and-pepper curls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh artificial light overhead creating deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the man's arms crossed across his chest with his jaw clenched and lips pressed together?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03618529438972473 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4111852645874023 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03618529438972473, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03618529438972473, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2210082709789276, + 0.12915536761283875, + 0.06378086656332016, + 0.06356145441532135, + 0.05876070633530617, + 0.09237705171108246, + 0.1603279560804367, + 0.09768974035978317, + 0.06809738278388977, + 0.045241158455610275 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03618529438972473 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up directly behind a seated figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate 90-degree arc to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly mixed-race man with light brown weathered skin and salt-and-pepper curls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh artificial light overhead creating deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the man's arms crossed across his chest with his jaw clenched and lips pressed together?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033726222813129425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408726215362549 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033726222813129425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033726222813129425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.091731958091259, + 0.15596142411231995, + 0.06848285347223282, + 0.08734410256147385, + 0.08821897953748703, + 0.10186416655778885, + 0.0475110225379467, + 0.18281516432762146, + 0.13594257831573486, + 0.0401277169585228 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033726222813129425 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up directly behind a seated figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate 90-degree arc to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly mixed-race man with light brown weathered skin and salt-and-pepper curls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh artificial light overhead creating deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the man's arms crossed across his chest with his jaw clenched and lips pressed together?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07005360722541809 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950535774230957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07005360722541809, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07005360722541809, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08913237601518631, + 0.08408980071544647, + 0.03135038539767265, + 0.07245790958404541, + 0.038939233869314194, + 0.04736689478158951, + 0.07867946475744247, + 0.47455623745918274, + 0.06626015901565552, + 0.01716756261885166 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07005360722541809 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up directly behind a seated figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate 90-degree arc to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly mixed-race man with light brown weathered skin and salt-and-pepper curls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh artificial light overhead creating deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the man's arms crossed across his chest with his jaw clenched and lips pressed together?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5762091875076294 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8262091875076294 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5762091875076294, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5762091875076294, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20489689707756042, + 0.11042949557304382, + 0.03446632996201515, + 0.03951360657811165, + 0.08892542123794556, + 0.058423154056072235, + 0.15286751091480255, + 0.11642268300056458, + 0.08466573804616928, + 0.10938917100429535 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5762091875076294 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up directly behind a seated figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate 90-degree arc to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly mixed-race man with light brown weathered skin and salt-and-pepper curls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh artificial light overhead creating deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the man's arms crossed across his chest with his jaw clenched and lips pressed together?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20165540277957916 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.701655387878418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20165540277957916, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20165540277957916, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11408203840255737, + 0.03328931704163551, + 0.04392826557159424, + 0.048345278948545456, + 0.07694627344608307, + 0.08247960358858109, + 0.2879350781440735, + 0.13619336485862732, + 0.0725695863366127, + 0.10423117876052856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20165540277957916 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene opens in extreme close-up, directly behind a seated figure, as the camera begins a slow, deliberate 90-degree arc to the right. Initially, the frame fills with the textured, dark gray fabric of a worn, cotton hoodie, the hood pulled down, revealing the back of the neck. The man's shoulders are severely hunched forward, his petite body curled in a tense, defensive posture. As the camera steadily pans, the profile of an elderly, mixed-race man with light brown, weathered skin and neatly cut, salt-and-pepper curls gradually emerges. He sits in a simple, dark wooden chair, leaning against a plain, out-of-focus, neutral-toned wall, sharply illuminated by a single, harsh, artificial light overhead. As the camera settles on his profile, this cool light carves deep shadows into his features, capturing the raw intensity of his anger. His jaw is visibly clenched in tension, the muscles in his cheeks pulse rhythmically, and a frown forms above his downcast eyes. His arms remained stubbornly crossed across his chest, his lips pressed together in a firm, silent pout, creating a powerful, controlled atmosphere of simmering frustration and unspoken conflict.", + "seed": 28367, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000140/group_9/index_1348_seed_28367_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2886743899434805, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2886743899434805, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.0249999880790712, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2886743899434805, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up directly behind a seated figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate 90-degree arc to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly mixed-race man with light brown weathered skin and salt-and-pepper curls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh artificial light overhead creating deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the man's arms crossed across his chest with his jaw clenched and lips pressed together?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0820503756403923 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.582050323486328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0820503756403923, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0820503756403923, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16827163100242615, + 0.05772854760289192, + 0.14212870597839355, + 0.16286182403564453, + 0.06109212338924408, + 0.1354174017906189, + 0.11180012673139572, + 0.06504330784082413, + 0.07403440028429031, + 0.021621938794851303 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0820503756403923 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up directly behind a seated figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate 90-degree arc to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly mixed-race man with light brown weathered skin and salt-and-pepper curls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh artificial light overhead creating deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the man's arms crossed across his chest with his jaw clenched and lips pressed together?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02637162245810032 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651371717453003 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02637162245810032, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02637162245810032, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14562974870204926, + 0.09459273517131805, + 0.05661403387784958, + 0.07227549701929092, + 0.10838962346315384, + 0.15183918178081512, + 0.1502593457698822, + 0.10823964327573776, + 0.05454840138554573, + 0.05761177837848663 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02637162245810032 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up directly behind a seated figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate 90-degree arc to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly mixed-race man with light brown weathered skin and salt-and-pepper curls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh artificial light overhead creating deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the man's arms crossed across his chest with his jaw clenched and lips pressed together?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05497528240084648 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299752712249756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05497528240084648, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05497528240084648, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18699876964092255, + 0.06307576596736908, + 0.04740489274263382, + 0.10484220832586288, + 0.09383948892354965, + 0.06464418023824692, + 0.05207449197769165, + 0.14373433589935303, + 0.13307440280914307, + 0.11031146347522736 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05497528240084648 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up directly behind a seated figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate 90-degree arc to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly mixed-race man with light brown weathered skin and salt-and-pepper curls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh artificial light overhead creating deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the man's arms crossed across his chest with his jaw clenched and lips pressed together?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370940208435059 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870939612388611 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1370940208435059, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.7500000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1370940208435059, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16444703936576843, + 0.12471719086170197, + 0.23981069028377533, + 0.07575304061174393, + 0.17202000319957733, + 0.02721487171947956, + 0.05822470411658287, + 0.07065634429454803, + 0.024834491312503815, + 0.042321622371673584 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1370940208435059 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up directly behind a seated figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate 90-degree arc to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject an elderly mixed-race man with light brown weathered skin and salt-and-pepper curls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single harsh artificial light overhead creating deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the man's arms crossed across his chest with his jaw clenched and lips pressed together?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428806483745575 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.01788067817688 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428806483745575, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428806483745575, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13514778017997742, + 0.059982381761074066, + 0.16898636519908905, + 0.09793674200773239, + 0.08422598242759705, + 0.03943561390042305, + 0.09291122108697891, + 0.08113501220941544, + 0.10765545070171356, + 0.13258345425128937 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428806483745575 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_0/index_tensor([8254, 8254])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_0/index_tensor([8254, 8254])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7c587d13847acb4c53ea780c40a6f877fbb6dfea --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_0/index_tensor([8254, 8254])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic, long shot, beginning at eye level and then smoothly tilting downward to a seamless underwater perspective, captures a robust emperor penguin perched on the edge of a towering ice cliff. Its signature black and white feathers stand out against the chilling polar sun. Its belly is as white as snow, its back and head are a deep obsidian, and its neck is punctuated by a vibrant orange. Its body leans slightly forward, wings tucked close to its sides, its posture imbued with the tension of poised action. Below, the mirror-like calm of the Arctic Ocean reflects the pale blue sky and the ice cliff. Without hesitation, the penguin thrusts its feet, its body transforming into a streamlined arc of black and white. With a precise and powerful movement, it instantly pierces the tranquil waters, sending up a rapidly expanding ring of white spray and countless shimmering droplets that shimmer in the sunlight. The camera dives into the water right after it, and it immediately spreads its wings, as if flying in the deep blue liquid sky, paddling steadily and calmly, leaving a trail of silver bubbles around its body, and dives rapidly and firmly into the dark and deep sapphire waters. The beam of light formed by sunlight penetrating the water gradually weakens behind it, and the whole picture is filled with a dramatic atmosphere of majesty, power and natural beauty.", + "seed": 31702, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_0/index_8254_seed_31702_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.7077765291556716, + "vlm_logprob": -0.7077765291556716, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.7077765291556716, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust emperor penguin with black and white feathers and an orange neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin with the penguin perched on the edge of a towering ice cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the penguin perform a streamlined dive into the water, creating a ring of white spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward from eye level to an underwater perspective and then dive into the water after the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the underwater environment depicted as deep blue sapphire water with silver bubbles trailing the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168384552001953 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04338443651795387 + ], + "logprob_reward": -3.168384552001953, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -3.168384552001953, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6670364141464233, + 0.03559882938861847, + 0.07534350454807281, + 0.051810942590236664, + 0.03765186667442322, + 0.028554333373904228, + 0.03618736192584038, + 0.008673624135553837, + 0.025009362027049065, + 0.03413381800055504 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -3.168384552001953 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust emperor penguin with black and white feathers and an orange neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin with the penguin perched on the edge of a towering ice cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the penguin perform a streamlined dive into the water, creating a ring of white spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward from eye level to an underwater perspective and then dive into the water after the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the underwater environment depicted as deep blue sapphire water with silver bubbles trailing the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2524673640727997 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502467393875122 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2524673640727997, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2524673640727997, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6737015247344971, + 0.060303572565317154, + 0.03842700272798538, + 0.04206206277012825, + 0.032325729727745056, + 0.01969892531633377, + 0.04036172851920128, + 0.019800575450062752, + 0.0214396882802248, + 0.05187919735908508 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2524673640727997 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust emperor penguin with black and white feathers and an orange neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin with the penguin perched on the edge of a towering ice cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the penguin perform a streamlined dive into the water, creating a ring of white spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward from eye level to an underwater perspective and then dive into the water after the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the underwater environment depicted as deep blue sapphire water with silver bubbles trailing the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02643304131925106 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651432991027832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02643304131925106, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02643304131925106, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5633427500724792, + 0.045726798474788666, + 0.08052047342061996, + 0.04805766046047211, + 0.06682761013507843, + 0.041550517082214355, + 0.05111953243613243, + 0.01186315156519413, + 0.030029112473130226, + 0.06096246466040611 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02643304131925106 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust emperor penguin with black and white feathers and an orange neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin with the penguin perched on the edge of a towering ice cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the penguin perform a streamlined dive into the water, creating a ring of white spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward from eye level to an underwater perspective and then dive into the water after the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the underwater environment depicted as deep blue sapphire water with silver bubbles trailing the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01257431972771883 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387574195861816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01257431972771883, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01257431972771883, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6607576012611389, + 0.03524555265903473, + 0.06311023980379105, + 0.0453156903386116, + 0.04901820048689842, + 0.02493085339665413, + 0.03776267543435097, + 0.027462098747491837, + 0.023859675973653793, + 0.03253748267889023 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01257431972771883 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust emperor penguin with black and white feathers and an orange neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin with the penguin perched on the edge of a towering ice cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the penguin perform a streamlined dive into the water, creating a ring of white spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward from eye level to an underwater perspective and then dive into the water after the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the underwater environment depicted as deep blue sapphire water with silver bubbles trailing the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07902336865663528 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790233612060547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07902336865663528, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07902336865663528, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6219584345817566, + 0.04424941539764404, + 0.09092170745134354, + 0.04039546847343445, + 0.03457215428352356, + 0.023750411346554756, + 0.04191308096051216, + 0.04617911949753761, + 0.02037837915122509, + 0.03568180277943611 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07902336865663528 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, long shot, beginning at eye level and then smoothly tilting downward to a seamless underwater perspective, captures a robust emperor penguin perched on the edge of a towering ice cliff. Its signature black and white feathers stand out against the chilling polar sun. Its belly is as white as snow, its back and head are a deep obsidian, and its neck is punctuated by a vibrant orange. Its body leans slightly forward, wings tucked close to its sides, its posture imbued with the tension of poised action. Below, the mirror-like calm of the Arctic Ocean reflects the pale blue sky and the ice cliff. Without hesitation, the penguin thrusts its feet, its body transforming into a streamlined arc of black and white. With a precise and powerful movement, it instantly pierces the tranquil waters, sending up a rapidly expanding ring of white spray and countless shimmering droplets that shimmer in the sunlight. The camera dives into the water right after it, and it immediately spreads its wings, as if flying in the deep blue liquid sky, paddling steadily and calmly, leaving a trail of silver bubbles around its body, and dives rapidly and firmly into the dark and deep sapphire waters. The beam of light formed by sunlight penetrating the water gradually weakens behind it, and the whole picture is filled with a dramatic atmosphere of majesty, power and natural beauty.", + "seed": 31703, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_0/index_8254_seed_31703_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.016457753372378647, + "vlm_logprob": -0.016457753372378647, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.016457753372378647, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust emperor penguin with black and white feathers and an orange neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin with the penguin perched on the edge of a towering ice cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the penguin perform a streamlined dive into the water, creating a ring of white spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward from eye level to an underwater perspective and then dive into the water after the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the underwater environment depicted as deep blue sapphire water with silver bubbles trailing the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03413311019539833 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.409133195877075 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03413311019539833, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03413311019539833, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35587891936302185, + 0.07384500652551651, + 0.07205013930797577, + 0.07100673019886017, + 0.02005396969616413, + 0.15610037744045258, + 0.04328802600502968, + 0.08619861304759979, + 0.059852663427591324, + 0.061725616455078125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03413311019539833 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust emperor penguin with black and white feathers and an orange neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin with the penguin perched on the edge of a towering ice cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the penguin perform a streamlined dive into the water, creating a ring of white spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward from eye level to an underwater perspective and then dive into the water after the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the underwater environment depicted as deep blue sapphire water with silver bubbles trailing the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029805727303028107 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298056602478027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029805727303028107, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029805727303028107, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3134866952896118, + 0.046489838510751724, + 0.2451239377260208, + 0.06501906365156174, + 0.0530254952609539, + 0.10003107786178589, + 0.03658496215939522, + 0.08050084859132767, + 0.022245192900300026, + 0.03749288246035576 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029805727303028107 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust emperor penguin with black and white feathers and an orange neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin with the penguin perched on the edge of a towering ice cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the penguin perform a streamlined dive into the water, creating a ring of white spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward from eye level to an underwater perspective and then dive into the water after the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the underwater environment depicted as deep blue sapphire water with silver bubbles trailing the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017174031818285584 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376717567443848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017174031818285584, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017174031818285584, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1592501401901245, + 0.050231948494911194, + 0.13345664739608765, + 0.06384442746639252, + 0.05597687512636185, + 0.24621398746967316, + 0.06567249447107315, + 0.07446634769439697, + 0.1040075495839119, + 0.04687963426113129 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017174031818285584 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust emperor penguin with black and white feathers and an orange neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin with the penguin perched on the edge of a towering ice cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the penguin perform a streamlined dive into the water, creating a ring of white spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward from eye level to an underwater perspective and then dive into the water after the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the underwater environment depicted as deep blue sapphire water with silver bubbles trailing the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004098350182175636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504098415374756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004098350182175636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004098350182175636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11119518429040909, + 0.1437433958053589, + 0.061207957565784454, + 0.029342349618673325, + 0.060227006673812866, + 0.023598602041602135, + 0.10157035291194916, + 0.09297464042901993, + 0.20561452209949493, + 0.170525923371315 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004098350182175636 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust emperor penguin with black and white feathers and an orange neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin with the penguin perched on the edge of a towering ice cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the penguin perform a streamlined dive into the water, creating a ring of white spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward from eye level to an underwater perspective and then dive into the water after the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the underwater environment depicted as deep blue sapphire water with silver bubbles trailing the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012534175999462605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387534141540527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012534175999462605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012534175999462605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08931052684783936, + 0.08513664454221725, + 0.06265664100646973, + 0.04682714119553566, + 0.03239264711737633, + 0.12564291059970856, + 0.28440752625465393, + 0.081769198179245, + 0.0966898649930954, + 0.095166876912117 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012534175999462605 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, long shot, beginning at eye level and then smoothly tilting downward to a seamless underwater perspective, captures a robust emperor penguin perched on the edge of a towering ice cliff. Its signature black and white feathers stand out against the chilling polar sun. Its belly is as white as snow, its back and head are a deep obsidian, and its neck is punctuated by a vibrant orange. Its body leans slightly forward, wings tucked close to its sides, its posture imbued with the tension of poised action. Below, the mirror-like calm of the Arctic Ocean reflects the pale blue sky and the ice cliff. Without hesitation, the penguin thrusts its feet, its body transforming into a streamlined arc of black and white. With a precise and powerful movement, it instantly pierces the tranquil waters, sending up a rapidly expanding ring of white spray and countless shimmering droplets that shimmer in the sunlight. The camera dives into the water right after it, and it immediately spreads its wings, as if flying in the deep blue liquid sky, paddling steadily and calmly, leaving a trail of silver bubbles around its body, and dives rapidly and firmly into the dark and deep sapphire waters. The beam of light formed by sunlight penetrating the water gradually weakens behind it, and the whole picture is filled with a dramatic atmosphere of majesty, power and natural beauty.", + "seed": 31704, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_0/index_8254_seed_31704_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03509737008716911, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03509737008716911, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03509737008716911, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust emperor penguin with black and white feathers and an orange neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin with the penguin perched on the edge of a towering ice cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the penguin perform a streamlined dive into the water, creating a ring of white spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward from eye level to an underwater perspective and then dive into the water after the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the underwater environment depicted as deep blue sapphire water with silver bubbles trailing the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10117001831531525 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.351170063018799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10117001831531525, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10117001831531525, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2965717017650604, + 0.07540713250637054, + 0.08377939462661743, + 0.10345643758773804, + 0.1293124556541443, + 0.05750599503517151, + 0.07435640692710876, + 0.06587503850460052, + 0.05851420387625694, + 0.05522124469280243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10117001831531525 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust emperor penguin with black and white feathers and an orange neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin with the penguin perched on the edge of a towering ice cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the penguin perform a streamlined dive into the water, creating a ring of white spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward from eye level to an underwater perspective and then dive into the water after the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the underwater environment depicted as deep blue sapphire water with silver bubbles trailing the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496332421898842 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299633502960205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496332421898842, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496332421898842, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19181501865386963, + 0.11364041268825531, + 0.1696542352437973, + 0.10753122717142105, + 0.08484493941068649, + 0.12950986623764038, + 0.051802415400743484, + 0.03585775941610336, + 0.025783279910683632, + 0.0895608589053154 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496332421898842 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust emperor penguin with black and white feathers and an orange neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin with the penguin perched on the edge of a towering ice cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the penguin perform a streamlined dive into the water, creating a ring of white spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward from eye level to an underwater perspective and then dive into the water after the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the underwater environment depicted as deep blue sapphire water with silver bubbles trailing the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019451522966846824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.2519450187683105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019451522966846824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019451522966846824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11907167732715607, + 0.06145523115992546, + 0.13091139495372772, + 0.1060137152671814, + 0.1375144124031067, + 0.06072482466697693, + 0.18506862223148346, + 0.10608923435211182, + 0.025577601045370102, + 0.06757329404354095 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019451522966846824 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust emperor penguin with black and white feathers and an orange neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin with the penguin perched on the edge of a towering ice cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the penguin perform a streamlined dive into the water, creating a ring of white spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward from eye level to an underwater perspective and then dive into the water after the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the underwater environment depicted as deep blue sapphire water with silver bubbles trailing the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007631315384060144 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882631301879883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007631315384060144, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007631315384060144, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12051793932914734, + 0.059077825397253036, + 0.16601280868053436, + 0.1326807290315628, + 0.07197660207748413, + 0.06103551760315895, + 0.1287524551153183, + 0.1841566115617752, + 0.03043024055659771, + 0.04535924270749092 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007631315384060144 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust emperor penguin with black and white feathers and an orange neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin with the penguin perched on the edge of a towering ice cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the penguin perform a streamlined dive into the water, creating a ring of white spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward from eye level to an underwater perspective and then dive into the water after the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the underwater environment depicted as deep blue sapphire water with silver bubbles trailing the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009777040220797062 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634777069091797 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009777040220797062, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009777040220797062, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12128017097711563, + 0.0650128424167633, + 0.06499965488910675, + 0.11020132899284363, + 0.08732517808675766, + 0.11194717139005661, + 0.12139681726694107, + 0.14343583583831787, + 0.07239832729101181, + 0.10200264304876328 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009777040220797062 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, long shot, beginning at eye level and then smoothly tilting downward to a seamless underwater perspective, captures a robust emperor penguin perched on the edge of a towering ice cliff. Its signature black and white feathers stand out against the chilling polar sun. Its belly is as white as snow, its back and head are a deep obsidian, and its neck is punctuated by a vibrant orange. Its body leans slightly forward, wings tucked close to its sides, its posture imbued with the tension of poised action. Below, the mirror-like calm of the Arctic Ocean reflects the pale blue sky and the ice cliff. Without hesitation, the penguin thrusts its feet, its body transforming into a streamlined arc of black and white. With a precise and powerful movement, it instantly pierces the tranquil waters, sending up a rapidly expanding ring of white spray and countless shimmering droplets that shimmer in the sunlight. The camera dives into the water right after it, and it immediately spreads its wings, as if flying in the deep blue liquid sky, paddling steadily and calmly, leaving a trail of silver bubbles around its body, and dives rapidly and firmly into the dark and deep sapphire waters. The beam of light formed by sunlight penetrating the water gradually weakens behind it, and the whole picture is filled with a dramatic atmosphere of majesty, power and natural beauty.", + "seed": 31705, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_0/index_8254_seed_31705_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.013112353580072521, + "vlm_logprob": -0.013112353580072521, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.013112353580072521, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust emperor penguin with black and white feathers and an orange neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin with the penguin perched on the edge of a towering ice cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the penguin perform a streamlined dive into the water, creating a ring of white spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward from eye level to an underwater perspective and then dive into the water after the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the underwater environment depicted as deep blue sapphire water with silver bubbles trailing the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014761041849851608 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264760971069336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014761041849851608, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014761041849851608, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27451202273368835, + 0.16010837256908417, + 0.10710915923118591, + 0.04924938827753067, + 0.062414150685071945, + 0.03078448213636875, + 0.19429562985897064, + 0.035342518240213394, + 0.03327253833413124, + 0.05291174724698067 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014761041849851608 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust emperor penguin with black and white feathers and an orange neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin with the penguin perched on the edge of a towering ice cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the penguin perform a streamlined dive into the water, creating a ring of white spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward from eye level to an underwater perspective and then dive into the water after the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the underwater environment depicted as deep blue sapphire water with silver bubbles trailing the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370732069015503 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087073802948 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370732069015503, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370732069015503, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37442976236343384, + 0.10690386593341827, + 0.033399421721696854, + 0.1042541116476059, + 0.04105939716100693, + 0.11576956510543823, + 0.03798648715019226, + 0.025267567485570908, + 0.05133238062262535, + 0.10959745943546295 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370732069015503 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust emperor penguin with black and white feathers and an orange neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin with the penguin perched on the edge of a towering ice cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the penguin perform a streamlined dive into the water, creating a ring of white spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward from eye level to an underwater perspective and then dive into the water after the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the underwater environment depicted as deep blue sapphire water with silver bubbles trailing the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017178792040795088 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376718044281006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017178792040795088, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017178792040795088, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1301637887954712, + 0.10319561511278152, + 0.12979453802108765, + 0.07802527397871017, + 0.04475767910480499, + 0.06813110411167145, + 0.19449760019779205, + 0.11127562820911407, + 0.05576673895120621, + 0.08439207077026367 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017178792040795088 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust emperor penguin with black and white feathers and an orange neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin with the penguin perched on the edge of a towering ice cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the penguin perform a streamlined dive into the water, creating a ring of white spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward from eye level to an underwater perspective and then dive into the water after the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the underwater environment depicted as deep blue sapphire water with silver bubbles trailing the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008641350083053112 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758641242980957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008641350083053112, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008641350083053112, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10644055157899857, + 0.08511561155319214, + 0.04392816126346588, + 0.06451195478439331, + 0.04842629283666611, + 0.0751335471868515, + 0.08141755312681198, + 0.05634869262576103, + 0.07035543024539948, + 0.3683221638202667 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008641350083053112 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a robust emperor penguin with black and white feathers and an orange neck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the scene begin with the penguin perched on the edge of a towering ice cliff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the penguin perform a streamlined dive into the water, creating a ring of white spray?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt downward from eye level to an underwater perspective and then dive into the water after the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the underwater environment depicted as deep blue sapphire water with silver bubbles trailing the penguin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006734176073223352 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006734371185303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006734176073223352, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006734176073223352, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10643023997545242, + 0.1062769666314125, + 0.1103462502360344, + 0.03128951042890549, + 0.044657740741968155, + 0.19861675798892975, + 0.104570172727108, + 0.04625210911035538, + 0.11103315651416779, + 0.14052709937095642 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006734176073223352 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_1/index_tensor([8321, 8321])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_1/index_tensor([8321, 8321])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bb993b54bf1fa880ad817b90d26ea6bf9e5a2517 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_1/index_tensor([8321, 8321])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, extreme close-up time-lapse captures the captivating blossoming of a hibiscus flower against a completely black, featureless background. The sequence begins with the flower, a tightly curled, deep burgundy bud, its shape defined solely by an off-camera light source, casting a warm, buttery-yellow glow from the right. This light meticulously traces a bright halo along the bud's edges, creating soft, deep shadows within its crevices. As the timelapse progresses, the petals at the base of the bud gracefully peel away, and the petals begin to slowly and deliberately unfold. Each petal spirals outward, catching the warm light and highlighting its velvety texture and delicate, intricate network of veins within. The movement is fluid and continuous, culminating in the flower's full, glorious bloom. The broad, supple petals take on a perfect, delicate shape, fully embracing the light and revealing the vibrant yellow stem at its core, creating a tranquil, magical atmosphere of natural wonder.", + "seed": 15287, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_1/index_8321_seed_15287_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.17981246570125223, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17981246570125223, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17981246570125223, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a hibiscus flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely black and featureless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the flower blooming from a tightly curled deep burgundy bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, buttery-yellow light source coming from the right that creates a bright halo along the bud's edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals spiral outward to reveal a vibrant yellow stem at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02409578301012516 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0240960121154785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02409578301012516, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02409578301012516, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0374068021774292, + 0.022633535787463188, + 0.1151038408279419, + 0.03679016977548599, + 0.09599364548921585, + 0.4411320090293884, + 0.024103516712784767, + 0.01929812878370285, + 0.18579283356666565, + 0.02174554206430912 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02409578301012516 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a hibiscus flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely black and featureless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the flower blooming from a tightly curled deep burgundy bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, buttery-yellow light source coming from the right that creates a bright halo along the bud's edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals spiral outward to reveal a vibrant yellow stem at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261538743972778 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761538743972778 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8261538743972778, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8261538743972778, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08490698039531708, + 0.05265765264630318, + 0.051779188215732574, + 0.058204490691423416, + 0.3689877390861511, + 0.07846483588218689, + 0.0287314560264349, + 0.025516297668218613, + 0.06802961975336075, + 0.18272177875041962 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8261538743972778 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a hibiscus flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely black and featureless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the flower blooming from a tightly curled deep burgundy bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, buttery-yellow light source coming from the right that creates a bright halo along the bud's edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals spiral outward to reveal a vibrant yellow stem at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007643500808626413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882643699645996 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007643500808626413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007643500808626413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.051712654531002045, + 0.03889676183462143, + 0.24201685190200806, + 0.09787232428789139, + 0.143339604139328, + 0.24078167974948883, + 0.027008116245269775, + 0.039689186960458755, + 0.06464290618896484, + 0.05403994768857956 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007643500808626413 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a hibiscus flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely black and featureless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the flower blooming from a tightly curled deep burgundy bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, buttery-yellow light source coming from the right that creates a bright halo along the bud's edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals spiral outward to reveal a vibrant yellow stem at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020587796345353127 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895587682723999 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020587796345353127, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020587796345353127, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08487648516893387, + 0.1780581772327423, + 0.10067255049943924, + 0.09348584711551666, + 0.14227983355522156, + 0.15746429562568665, + 0.07185988873243332, + 0.027110856026411057, + 0.06010499224066734, + 0.0840870663523674 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020587796345353127 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a hibiscus flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely black and featureless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the flower blooming from a tightly curled deep burgundy bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, buttery-yellow light source coming from the right that creates a bright halo along the bud's edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals spiral outward to reveal a vibrant yellow stem at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020581373944878578 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955814838409424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020581373944878578, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020581373944878578, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11995110660791397, + 0.03667330741882324, + 0.04418852925300598, + 0.2024318426847458, + 0.25444358587265015, + 0.10412279516458511, + 0.04378257691860199, + 0.061806995421648026, + 0.07560405880212784, + 0.05699513107538223 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020581373944878578 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, extreme close-up time-lapse captures the captivating blossoming of a hibiscus flower against a completely black, featureless background. The sequence begins with the flower, a tightly curled, deep burgundy bud, its shape defined solely by an off-camera light source, casting a warm, buttery-yellow glow from the right. This light meticulously traces a bright halo along the bud's edges, creating soft, deep shadows within its crevices. As the timelapse progresses, the petals at the base of the bud gracefully peel away, and the petals begin to slowly and deliberately unfold. Each petal spirals outward, catching the warm light and highlighting its velvety texture and delicate, intricate network of veins within. The movement is fluid and continuous, culminating in the flower's full, glorious bloom. The broad, supple petals take on a perfect, delicate shape, fully embracing the light and revealing the vibrant yellow stem at its core, creating a tranquil, magical atmosphere of natural wonder.", + "seed": 15288, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_1/index_8321_seed_15288_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.3233034127391875, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3233034127391875, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3233034127391875, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a hibiscus flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely black and featureless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the flower blooming from a tightly curled deep burgundy bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, buttery-yellow light source coming from the right that creates a bright halo along the bud's edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals spiral outward to reveal a vibrant yellow stem at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05052180960774422 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1755218505859375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05052180960774422, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05052180960774422, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1581028252840042, + 0.04618247225880623, + 0.05113571882247925, + 0.14731188118457794, + 0.2507722079753876, + 0.048568226397037506, + 0.04624421149492264, + 0.144997239112854, + 0.03725026920437813, + 0.06943488121032715 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05052180960774422 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a hibiscus flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely black and featureless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the flower blooming from a tightly curled deep burgundy bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, buttery-yellow light source coming from the right that creates a bright halo along the bud's edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals spiral outward to reveal a vibrant yellow stem at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020544528961182 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25205448269844055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5020544528961182, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5020544528961182, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24527840316295624, + 0.048216745257377625, + 0.11658845841884613, + 0.14052583277225494, + 0.03995831683278084, + 0.028516124933958054, + 0.0799100324511528, + 0.057460058480501175, + 0.022744473069906235, + 0.22080163657665253 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5020544528961182 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a hibiscus flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely black and featureless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the flower blooming from a tightly curled deep burgundy bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, buttery-yellow light source coming from the right that creates a bright halo along the bud's edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals spiral outward to reveal a vibrant yellow stem at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00764515670016408 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882645130157471 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00764515670016408, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00764515670016408, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2496146857738495, + 0.07865455746650696, + 0.039174456149339676, + 0.13009734451770782, + 0.07623062282800674, + 0.06560231745243073, + 0.06795549392700195, + 0.04290270432829857, + 0.10390643030405045, + 0.14586138725280762 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00764515670016408 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a hibiscus flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely black and featureless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the flower blooming from a tightly curled deep burgundy bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, buttery-yellow light source coming from the right that creates a bright halo along the bud's edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals spiral outward to reveal a vibrant yellow stem at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018200181424617767 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018200397491455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018200181424617767, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018200181424617767, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17985592782497406, + 0.08296582847833633, + 0.06007770448923111, + 0.17225676774978638, + 0.07502097636461258, + 0.06212788447737694, + 0.13299325108528137, + 0.05911530554294586, + 0.05052647367119789, + 0.12505988776683807 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018200181424617767 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a hibiscus flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely black and featureless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the flower blooming from a tightly curled deep burgundy bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, buttery-yellow light source coming from the right that creates a bright halo along the bud's edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals spiral outward to reveal a vibrant yellow stem at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809546306729317 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288095474243164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809546306729317, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809546306729317, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06049081310629845, + 0.029412956908345222, + 0.031637951731681824, + 0.05693364143371582, + 0.05318983644247055, + 0.02146841026842594, + 0.07232782989740372, + 0.12622669339179993, + 0.41321516036987305, + 0.13509662449359894 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809546306729317 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, extreme close-up time-lapse captures the captivating blossoming of a hibiscus flower against a completely black, featureless background. The sequence begins with the flower, a tightly curled, deep burgundy bud, its shape defined solely by an off-camera light source, casting a warm, buttery-yellow glow from the right. This light meticulously traces a bright halo along the bud's edges, creating soft, deep shadows within its crevices. As the timelapse progresses, the petals at the base of the bud gracefully peel away, and the petals begin to slowly and deliberately unfold. Each petal spirals outward, catching the warm light and highlighting its velvety texture and delicate, intricate network of veins within. The movement is fluid and continuous, culminating in the flower's full, glorious bloom. The broad, supple petals take on a perfect, delicate shape, fully embracing the light and revealing the vibrant yellow stem at its core, creating a tranquil, magical atmosphere of natural wonder.", + "seed": 15289, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_1/index_8321_seed_15289_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10808451874181628, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10808451874181628, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10808451874181628, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a hibiscus flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely black and featureless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the flower blooming from a tightly curled deep burgundy bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, buttery-yellow light source coming from the right that creates a bright halo along the bud's edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals spiral outward to reveal a vibrant yellow stem at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02196531929075718 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.146965503692627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02196531929075718, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02196531929075718, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06832056492567062, + 0.07791868597269058, + 0.15982535481452942, + 0.04317802935838699, + 0.06727036833763123, + 0.18077750504016876, + 0.10273896157741547, + 0.1472826600074768, + 0.07267825305461884, + 0.08000961691141129 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02196531929075718 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a hibiscus flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely black and featureless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the flower blooming from a tightly curled deep burgundy bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, buttery-yellow light source coming from the right that creates a bright halo along the bud's edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals spiral outward to reveal a vibrant yellow stem at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47428080439567566 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.974280834197998 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47428080439567566, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47428080439567566, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19922465085983276, + 0.08172855526208878, + 0.054510604590177536, + 0.04888473078608513, + 0.054809074848890305, + 0.1351805031299591, + 0.09608583897352219, + 0.08870744705200195, + 0.046921081840991974, + 0.19394747912883759 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47428080439567566 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a hibiscus flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely black and featureless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the flower blooming from a tightly curled deep burgundy bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, buttery-yellow light source coming from the right that creates a bright halo along the bud's edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals spiral outward to reveal a vibrant yellow stem at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006745661608874798 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067458152771 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006745661608874798, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006745661608874798, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11550559103488922, + 0.11373025923967361, + 0.2105894833803177, + 0.042235877364873886, + 0.0964122787117958, + 0.0583014115691185, + 0.10106905549764633, + 0.127550408244133, + 0.08485288918018341, + 0.04975276440382004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006745661608874798 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a hibiscus flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely black and featureless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the flower blooming from a tightly curled deep burgundy bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, buttery-yellow light source coming from the right that creates a bright halo along the bud's edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals spiral outward to reveal a vibrant yellow stem at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029804106801748276 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529803991317749 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029804106801748276, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029804106801748276, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12010707706212997, + 0.1099458560347557, + 0.1656087189912796, + 0.13515539467334747, + 0.03687296062707901, + 0.06492443382740021, + 0.03372328728437424, + 0.024667106568813324, + 0.02785559371113777, + 0.2811395823955536 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029804106801748276 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a hibiscus flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely black and featureless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the flower blooming from a tightly curled deep burgundy bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, buttery-yellow light source coming from the right that creates a bright halo along the bud's edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals spiral outward to reveal a vibrant yellow stem at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007626701612025499 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882626533508301 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007626701612025499, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007626701612025499, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07685795426368713, + 0.08142279833555222, + 0.08417868614196777, + 0.23110993206501007, + 0.0641021877527237, + 0.07048982381820679, + 0.0771671012043953, + 0.09108403325080872, + 0.14670319855213165, + 0.07688429951667786 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007626701612025499 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, extreme close-up time-lapse captures the captivating blossoming of a hibiscus flower against a completely black, featureless background. The sequence begins with the flower, a tightly curled, deep burgundy bud, its shape defined solely by an off-camera light source, casting a warm, buttery-yellow glow from the right. This light meticulously traces a bright halo along the bud's edges, creating soft, deep shadows within its crevices. As the timelapse progresses, the petals at the base of the bud gracefully peel away, and the petals begin to slowly and deliberately unfold. Each petal spirals outward, catching the warm light and highlighting its velvety texture and delicate, intricate network of veins within. The movement is fluid and continuous, culminating in the flower's full, glorious bloom. The broad, supple petals take on a perfect, delicate shape, fully embracing the light and revealing the vibrant yellow stem at its core, creating a tranquil, magical atmosphere of natural wonder.", + "seed": 15290, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_1/index_8321_seed_15290_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.05443692193366587, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05443692193366587, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05443692193366587, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a hibiscus flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely black and featureless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the flower blooming from a tightly curled deep burgundy bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, buttery-yellow light source coming from the right that creates a bright halo along the bud's edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals spiral outward to reveal a vibrant yellow stem at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03183978050947189 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7818398475646973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03183978050947189, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03183978050947189, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2354062795639038, + 0.03776703402400017, + 0.06388432532548904, + 0.06326206773519516, + 0.09909921884536743, + 0.057208430022001266, + 0.14919033646583557, + 0.08378084748983383, + 0.16524077951908112, + 0.0451606884598732 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03183978050947189 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a hibiscus flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely black and featureless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the flower blooming from a tightly curled deep burgundy bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, buttery-yellow light source coming from the right that creates a bright halo along the bud's edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals spiral outward to reveal a vibrant yellow stem at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20161721110343933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016172409057617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20161721110343933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20161721110343933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2018638402223587, + 0.30731070041656494, + 0.0488414391875267, + 0.04145701602101326, + 0.016682419925928116, + 0.038735561072826385, + 0.07290664315223694, + 0.060301925987005234, + 0.16850072145462036, + 0.043399736285209656 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20161721110343933 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a hibiscus flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely black and featureless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the flower blooming from a tightly curled deep burgundy bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, buttery-yellow light source coming from the right that creates a bright halo along the bud's edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals spiral outward to reveal a vibrant yellow stem at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022072256542742252 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127207279205322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022072256542742252, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022072256542742252, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3404226005077362, + 0.055544257164001465, + 0.06014986336231232, + 0.060198329389095306, + 0.08510860055685043, + 0.07700176537036896, + 0.08750633150339127, + 0.052958305925130844, + 0.14424952864646912, + 0.036860428750514984 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022072256542742252 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a hibiscus flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely black and featureless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the flower blooming from a tightly curled deep burgundy bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, buttery-yellow light source coming from the right that creates a bright halo along the bud's edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals spiral outward to reveal a vibrant yellow stem at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369982913136482 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086997509002686 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369982913136482, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369982913136482, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18834319710731506, + 0.09865892678499222, + 0.1582356095314026, + 0.13225890696048737, + 0.10978225618600845, + 0.05072333663702011, + 0.054778896272182465, + 0.08783955127000809, + 0.10623446851968765, + 0.013144901022315025 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369982913136482 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a hibiscus flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background completely black and featureless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the flower blooming from a tightly curled deep burgundy bud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, buttery-yellow light source coming from the right that creates a bright halo along the bud's edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals spiral outward to reveal a vibrant yellow stem at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002820563269779086 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778204917907715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002820563269779086, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002820563269779086, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13663727045059204, + 0.06946370750665665, + 0.054752081632614136, + 0.08679766952991486, + 0.04441346973180771, + 0.067681223154068, + 0.1349455565214157, + 0.14127729833126068, + 0.17547446489334106, + 0.08855721354484558 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002820563269779086 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_10/index_tensor([5956, 5956])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_10/index_tensor([5956, 5956])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..827ec0b8285a717e3d962c8fe930d5382a68d320 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_10/index_tensor([5956, 5956])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, majestic, low-angle wide shot captures the full height of the Eiffel Tower, its summit reaching toward the upper edge of the frame. The scene is bathed in the ethereal glow of golden hour, with the setting sun, just outside the frame, casting a stream of brilliant, molten-gold light downward. This luminous light first kisses the top of the spire, then seems to flow like liquid honey along the intricate, crisscrossing ironwork, creating sharp, brilliant highlights on the sun-facing metal surfaces and casting long, deep, cool shadows that emphasize the tower's complex geometry. The sky in the background is a masterpiece of color, gradually fading from a fiery red-orange near the invisible horizon to a soft rose-pink, and finally to a deep, serene violet overhead. The atmosphere is filled with profound tranquility and awe. As the light continues to descend, the tower's warm bronze hue deepens into silhouette, and just as the last traces of sunlight fade from its zenith, the entire awe-inspiring vista begins to slowly, seamlessly, and deliberately fade to complete black, concluding the moment with a peaceful finale.", + "seed": 8420, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_10/index_5956_seed_8420_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.19990927991457283, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19990927991457283, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19990927991457283, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the Eiffel Tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing the full height of the tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden hour light with a stream of molten-gold light descending from the top of the spire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from fiery red-orange near the horizon to soft rose-pink and finally to deep violet overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire scene fading to complete black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0012518672738224268 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.126251697540283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0012518672738224268, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0012518672738224268, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.160931795835495, + 0.0380980484187603, + 0.06717793643474579, + 0.024874890223145485, + 0.022365476936101913, + 0.012442396022379398, + 0.0955028310418129, + 0.03255835548043251, + 0.4005235731601715, + 0.14552463591098785 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0012518672738224268 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the Eiffel Tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing the full height of the tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden hour light with a stream of molten-gold light descending from the top of the spire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from fiery red-orange near the horizon to soft rose-pink and finally to deep violet overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire scene fading to complete black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0700606107711792 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950607299804688 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0700606107711792, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0700606107711792, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15376809239387512, + 0.034681521356105804, + 0.06666658073663712, + 0.02853948250412941, + 0.06322397291660309, + 0.06002252921462059, + 0.4402328431606293, + 0.04090544581413269, + 0.04972758889198303, + 0.06223190575838089 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0700606107711792 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the Eiffel Tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing the full height of the tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden hour light with a stream of molten-gold light descending from the top of the spire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from fiery red-orange near the horizon to soft rose-pink and finally to deep violet overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire scene fading to complete black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054991304874420166 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299912452697754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054991304874420166, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054991304874420166, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0904311016201973, + 0.0547357052564621, + 0.03755006939172745, + 0.019815174862742424, + 0.021902799606323242, + 0.02718586102128029, + 0.2403300702571869, + 0.12429258972406387, + 0.17086929082870483, + 0.21288734674453735 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054991304874420166 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the Eiffel Tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing the full height of the tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden hour light with a stream of molten-gold light descending from the top of the spire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from fiery red-orange near the horizon to soft rose-pink and finally to deep violet overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire scene fading to complete black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17989802360534668 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048980236053467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17989802360534668, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17989802360534668, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08185473829507828, + 0.025848863646388054, + 0.02464289218187332, + 0.0110646216198802, + 0.021471384912729263, + 0.01852133497595787, + 0.49317309260368347, + 0.0213602427393198, + 0.28754159808158875, + 0.014521289616823196 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17989802360534668 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the Eiffel Tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing the full height of the tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden hour light with a stream of molten-gold light descending from the top of the spire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from fiery red-orange near the horizon to soft rose-pink and finally to deep violet overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire scene fading to complete black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933445930480957 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933445930480957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6933445930480957, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6933445930480957, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.012093983590602875, + 0.00839060079306364, + 0.011082116514444351, + 0.016521167010068893, + 0.023654138669371605, + 0.0174656230956316, + 0.6180316805839539, + 0.02780861221253872, + 0.12682656943798065, + 0.13812553882598877 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6933445930480957 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, majestic, low-angle wide shot captures the full height of the Eiffel Tower, its summit reaching toward the upper edge of the frame. The scene is bathed in the ethereal glow of golden hour, with the setting sun, just outside the frame, casting a stream of brilliant, molten-gold light downward. This luminous light first kisses the top of the spire, then seems to flow like liquid honey along the intricate, crisscrossing ironwork, creating sharp, brilliant highlights on the sun-facing metal surfaces and casting long, deep, cool shadows that emphasize the tower's complex geometry. The sky in the background is a masterpiece of color, gradually fading from a fiery red-orange near the invisible horizon to a soft rose-pink, and finally to a deep, serene violet overhead. The atmosphere is filled with profound tranquility and awe. As the light continues to descend, the tower's warm bronze hue deepens into silhouette, and just as the last traces of sunlight fade from its zenith, the entire awe-inspiring vista begins to slowly, seamlessly, and deliberately fade to complete black, concluding the moment with a peaceful finale.", + "seed": 8421, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_10/index_5956_seed_8421_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.34143662645947187, + "vlm_logprob": -0.34143662645947187, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.5749999642372132, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.34143662645947187, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the Eiffel Tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing the full height of the tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden hour light with a stream of molten-gold light descending from the top of the spire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from fiery red-orange near the horizon to soft rose-pink and finally to deep violet overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire scene fading to complete black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.000927137560211122 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.250926971435547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.000927137560211122, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.000927137560211122, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.014574048109352589, + 0.008742442354559898, + 0.0058626518584787846, + 0.021374061703681946, + 0.009825874119997025, + 0.14628612995147705, + 0.41503793001174927, + 0.018904168158769608, + 0.12115046381950378, + 0.2382422238588333 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.000927137560211122 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the Eiffel Tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing the full height of the tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden hour light with a stream of molten-gold light descending from the top of the spire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from fiery red-orange near the horizon to soft rose-pink and finally to deep violet overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire scene fading to complete black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31347566843032837 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134756088256836 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31347566843032837, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.9999999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31347566843032837, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03251037374138832, + 0.023178141564130783, + 0.046165917068719864, + 0.0725887343287468, + 0.022120842710137367, + 0.07665308564901352, + 0.01102312933653593, + 0.03433990105986595, + 0.6539576649665833, + 0.02746221423149109 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31347566843032837 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the Eiffel Tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing the full height of the tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden hour light with a stream of molten-gold light descending from the top of the spire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from fiery red-orange near the horizon to soft rose-pink and finally to deep violet overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire scene fading to complete black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14281617105007172 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178160667419434 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14281617105007172, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14281617105007172, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.028189633041620255, + 0.012363811954855919, + 0.010263645090162754, + 0.01629684865474701, + 0.013702473603188992, + 0.2519310712814331, + 0.301984578371048, + 0.011275006458163261, + 0.021220684051513672, + 0.33277225494384766 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14281617105007172 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the Eiffel Tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing the full height of the tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden hour light with a stream of molten-gold light descending from the top of the spire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from fiery red-orange near the horizon to soft rose-pink and finally to deep violet overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire scene fading to complete black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026353277266025543 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651353359222412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026353277266025543, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026353277266025543, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.005010706838220358, + 0.002904025837779045, + 0.00882063340395689, + 0.023378917947411537, + 0.005820889957249165, + 0.023009518161416054, + 0.5036747455596924, + 0.04602301865816116, + 0.012879619374871254, + 0.36847788095474243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026353277266025543 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the Eiffel Tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing the full height of the tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden hour light with a stream of molten-gold light descending from the top of the spire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from fiery red-orange near the horizon to soft rose-pink and finally to deep violet overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire scene fading to complete black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236108779907227 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34861090779304504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2236108779907227, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2236108779907227, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.002285670954734087, + 0.001971581717953086, + 0.0027419349644333124, + 0.012472569942474365, + 0.001668571843765676, + 0.01341167651116848, + 0.4314645528793335, + 0.012176108546555042, + 0.09947186708450317, + 0.42233550548553467 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2236108779907227 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, majestic, low-angle wide shot captures the full height of the Eiffel Tower, its summit reaching toward the upper edge of the frame. The scene is bathed in the ethereal glow of golden hour, with the setting sun, just outside the frame, casting a stream of brilliant, molten-gold light downward. This luminous light first kisses the top of the spire, then seems to flow like liquid honey along the intricate, crisscrossing ironwork, creating sharp, brilliant highlights on the sun-facing metal surfaces and casting long, deep, cool shadows that emphasize the tower's complex geometry. The sky in the background is a masterpiece of color, gradually fading from a fiery red-orange near the invisible horizon to a soft rose-pink, and finally to a deep, serene violet overhead. The atmosphere is filled with profound tranquility and awe. As the light continues to descend, the tower's warm bronze hue deepens into silhouette, and just as the last traces of sunlight fade from its zenith, the entire awe-inspiring vista begins to slowly, seamlessly, and deliberately fade to complete black, concluding the moment with a peaceful finale.", + "seed": 8422, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_10/index_5956_seed_8422_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.5781925933435559, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5781925933435559, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5781925933435559, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the Eiffel Tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing the full height of the tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden hour light with a stream of molten-gold light descending from the top of the spire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from fiery red-orange near the horizon to soft rose-pink and finally to deep violet overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire scene fading to complete black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007185094989836216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.007184982299805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007185094989836216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007185094989836216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1162840873003006, + 0.17014503479003906, + 0.04211464524269104, + 0.08270624279975891, + 0.07255314290523529, + 0.2798982262611389, + 0.06806845963001251, + 0.054167069494724274, + 0.03474540263414383, + 0.07931771129369736 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007185094989836216 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the Eiffel Tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing the full height of the tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden hour light with a stream of molten-gold light descending from the top of the spire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from fiery red-orange near the horizon to soft rose-pink and finally to deep violet overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire scene fading to complete black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021064281463623 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25210636854171753 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5021064281463623, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5021064281463623, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07025979459285736, + 0.179075688123703, + 0.05406424403190613, + 0.06382715702056885, + 0.23911386728286743, + 0.18041497468948364, + 0.08391202241182327, + 0.05114651843905449, + 0.055239610373973846, + 0.022946126759052277 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5021064281463623 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the Eiffel Tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing the full height of the tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden hour light with a stream of molten-gold light descending from the top of the spire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from fiery red-orange near the horizon to soft rose-pink and finally to deep violet overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire scene fading to complete black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07902909815311432 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579029083251953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07902909815311432, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07902909815311432, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1535409688949585, + 0.1310737282037735, + 0.1039384976029396, + 0.031463734805583954, + 0.13215385377407074, + 0.15518900752067566, + 0.09308843314647675, + 0.11961951106786728, + 0.04192541167140007, + 0.03800688311457634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07902909815311432 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the Eiffel Tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing the full height of the tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden hour light with a stream of molten-gold light descending from the top of the spire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from fiery red-orange near the horizon to soft rose-pink and finally to deep violet overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire scene fading to complete black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900464534759521 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790047645568848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900464534759521, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900464534759521, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17691023647785187, + 0.14243099093437195, + 0.048719365149736404, + 0.03765694424510002, + 0.15287084877490997, + 0.2213561236858368, + 0.0590008944272995, + 0.05310756713151932, + 0.06073400378227234, + 0.04721293970942497 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900464534759521 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the Eiffel Tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing the full height of the tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden hour light with a stream of molten-gold light descending from the top of the spire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from fiery red-orange near the horizon to soft rose-pink and finally to deep violet overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire scene fading to complete black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236377000808716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34863772988319397 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2236377000808716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2236377000808716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09261400997638702, + 0.16361434757709503, + 0.08831141889095306, + 0.0693691223859787, + 0.17733439803123474, + 0.12272633612155914, + 0.050246693193912506, + 0.06915566325187683, + 0.1159978061914444, + 0.05063014477491379 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2236377000808716 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, majestic, low-angle wide shot captures the full height of the Eiffel Tower, its summit reaching toward the upper edge of the frame. The scene is bathed in the ethereal glow of golden hour, with the setting sun, just outside the frame, casting a stream of brilliant, molten-gold light downward. This luminous light first kisses the top of the spire, then seems to flow like liquid honey along the intricate, crisscrossing ironwork, creating sharp, brilliant highlights on the sun-facing metal surfaces and casting long, deep, cool shadows that emphasize the tower's complex geometry. The sky in the background is a masterpiece of color, gradually fading from a fiery red-orange near the invisible horizon to a soft rose-pink, and finally to a deep, serene violet overhead. The atmosphere is filled with profound tranquility and awe. As the light continues to descend, the tower's warm bronze hue deepens into silhouette, and just as the last traces of sunlight fade from its zenith, the entire awe-inspiring vista begins to slowly, seamlessly, and deliberately fade to complete black, concluding the moment with a peaceful finale.", + "seed": 8423, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_10/index_5956_seed_8423_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.5564465157687664, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5564465157687664, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5564465157687664, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the Eiffel Tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing the full height of the tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden hour light with a stream of molten-gold light descending from the top of the spire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from fiery red-orange near the horizon to soft rose-pink and finally to deep violet overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire scene fading to complete black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.049418892711400986 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0494189262390137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.049418892711400986, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.049418892711400986, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21364589035511017, + 0.09489560127258301, + 0.026699217036366463, + 0.03015754744410515, + 0.04692690819501877, + 0.17124392092227936, + 0.18477709591388702, + 0.035181354731321335, + 0.03732645511627197, + 0.15914598107337952 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.049418892711400986 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the Eiffel Tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing the full height of the tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden hour light with a stream of molten-gold light descending from the top of the spire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from fiery red-orange near the horizon to soft rose-pink and finally to deep violet overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire scene fading to complete black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063355922698975 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813355624675751 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.4063355922698975, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -1.4063355922698975, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11875426769256592, + 0.09962410479784012, + 0.047515299171209335, + 0.039428725838661194, + 0.05040992423892021, + 0.07821682840585709, + 0.12160659581422806, + 0.04318571463227272, + 0.2583879828453064, + 0.14287054538726807 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.4063355922698975 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the Eiffel Tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing the full height of the tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden hour light with a stream of molten-gold light descending from the top of the spire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from fiery red-orange near the horizon to soft rose-pink and finally to deep violet overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire scene fading to complete black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08908035606145859 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464080333709717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08908035606145859, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08908035606145859, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10242156684398651, + 0.06339844316244125, + 0.07890012860298157, + 0.10262852162122726, + 0.06729742884635925, + 0.0952281653881073, + 0.06029503047466278, + 0.05940483510494232, + 0.20388571918010712, + 0.16654016077518463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08908035606145859 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the Eiffel Tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing the full height of the tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden hour light with a stream of molten-gold light descending from the top of the spire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from fiery red-orange near the horizon to soft rose-pink and finally to deep violet overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire scene fading to complete black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10034126788377762 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350341320037842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10034126788377762, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10034126788377762, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07450271397829056, + 0.11136066913604736, + 0.026263177394866943, + 0.04913295432925224, + 0.07600980252027512, + 0.06321757286787033, + 0.11240188032388687, + 0.06653114408254623, + 0.27682071924209595, + 0.1437593549489975 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10034126788377762 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the Eiffel Tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle wide shot capturing the full height of the tower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden hour light with a stream of molten-gold light descending from the top of the spire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky transition from fiery red-orange near the horizon to soft rose-pink and finally to deep violet overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the entire scene fading to complete black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370564699172974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38705649971961975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1370564699172974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1370564699172974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1104927808046341, + 0.049318209290504456, + 0.024116545915603638, + 0.02540801651775837, + 0.11029350757598877, + 0.12214665859937668, + 0.07772714644670486, + 0.03412787988781929, + 0.28060317039489746, + 0.16576606035232544 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1370564699172974 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_11/index_tensor([6964, 6964])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_11/index_tensor([6964, 6964])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..788b76bb9d9733c69dc40cbd29e6411f8e871456 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_11/index_tensor([6964, 6964])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, high-frame-rate medium close-up, rendered in hilarious slow motion, captures the awkward courtship rituals of a brightly lit professional photography studio. The scene is bathed in even, shadowless illumination from a large softbox light, set against a seamless, neutral gray paper backdrop. Two exceptionally furry cats are the focal points. One, a large, long-haired ginger tabby with vibrant green eyes, attempts to project suave confidence in front of the camera. The other, a pristine silver Persian with a flat, calm face, sits majestically beside it, observing with detached curiosity. The exact moment the ginger cat attempts to blink is deconstructed with comic precision; its facial muscles tense, and instead of a smooth, charming gesture, its face contorts into a goofy, cross-eyed grimace. One eyelid squeezes tightly shut, while the other eye drifts comically inward, its whiskers trembling. The sheer muscle movement sends visible slow-motion ripples through the dense fur on its cheeks and brows. The Persian cat remains expressionless, perhaps tilting its head an inch in silent confusion, amplifying the awkwardness of the failed romantic overture and creating an atmosphere of focused, intense humor.", + "seed": 14389, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_11/index_6964_seed_14389_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08456318816170097, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08456318816170097, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08456318816170097, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brightly lit professional photography studio with a seamless neutral gray paper backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two exceptionally furry cats visible: a large long-haired ginger tabby and a silver Persian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ginger tabby shown attempting to blink with one eyelid squeezing shut and the other eye drifting inward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ginger tabby's facial movement cause visible slow-motion ripples through its dense fur on the cheeks and brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static, high-frame-rate medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.35103747248649597 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2260375022888184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.35103747248649597, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.35103747248649597, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21735399961471558, + 0.21185268461704254, + 0.09602586179971695, + 0.06301221996545792, + 0.08193144202232361, + 0.11339399963617325, + 0.05825066193938255, + 0.09411118924617767, + 0.01461869664490223, + 0.049449268728494644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.35103747248649597 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brightly lit professional photography studio with a seamless neutral gray paper backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two exceptionally furry cats visible: a large long-haired ginger tabby and a silver Persian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ginger tabby shown attempting to blink with one eyelid squeezing shut and the other eye drifting inward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ginger tabby's facial movement cause visible slow-motion ripples through its dense fur on the cheeks and brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static, high-frame-rate medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00528118759393692 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.2552809715271 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00528118759393692, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00528118759393692, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1415266990661621, + 0.15563826262950897, + 0.1044289693236351, + 0.06827277690172195, + 0.14153361320495605, + 0.10637737065553665, + 0.040177781134843826, + 0.14090733230113983, + 0.049113739281892776, + 0.052023474127054214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00528118759393692 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brightly lit professional photography studio with a seamless neutral gray paper backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two exceptionally furry cats visible: a large long-haired ginger tabby and a silver Persian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ginger tabby shown attempting to blink with one eyelid squeezing shut and the other eye drifting inward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ginger tabby's facial movement cause visible slow-motion ripples through its dense fur on the cheeks and brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static, high-frame-rate medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048683393746614456 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486834049224854 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048683393746614456, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048683393746614456, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12571747601032257, + 0.09512628614902496, + 0.032351262867450714, + 0.03945377096533775, + 0.15625610947608948, + 0.25892800092697144, + 0.10218404978513718, + 0.05873163416981697, + 0.10044586658477783, + 0.03080546297132969 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048683393746614456 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brightly lit professional photography studio with a seamless neutral gray paper backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two exceptionally furry cats visible: a large long-haired ginger tabby and a silver Persian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ginger tabby shown attempting to blink with one eyelid squeezing shut and the other eye drifting inward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ginger tabby's facial movement cause visible slow-motion ripples through its dense fur on the cheeks and brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static, high-frame-rate medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107556652277708 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511075496673584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107556652277708, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107556652277708, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2919362187385559, + 0.17613182961940765, + 0.06000952795147896, + 0.05635605379939079, + 0.12101223319768906, + 0.09503167122602463, + 0.06606326252222061, + 0.039408519864082336, + 0.07180454581975937, + 0.022246068343520164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107556652277708 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brightly lit professional photography studio with a seamless neutral gray paper backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two exceptionally furry cats visible: a large long-haired ginger tabby and a silver Persian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ginger tabby shown attempting to blink with one eyelid squeezing shut and the other eye drifting inward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ginger tabby's facial movement cause visible slow-motion ripples through its dense fur on the cheeks and brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static, high-frame-rate medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006738320458680391 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006738185882568 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006738320458680391, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006738320458680391, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42760586738586426, + 0.12143417447805405, + 0.06771841645240784, + 0.08030254393815994, + 0.052621472626924515, + 0.06552200764417648, + 0.04364262893795967, + 0.050502434372901917, + 0.04611732065677643, + 0.04453310742974281 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006738320458680391 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-frame-rate medium close-up, rendered in hilarious slow motion, captures the awkward courtship rituals of a brightly lit professional photography studio. The scene is bathed in even, shadowless illumination from a large softbox light, set against a seamless, neutral gray paper backdrop. Two exceptionally furry cats are the focal points. One, a large, long-haired ginger tabby with vibrant green eyes, attempts to project suave confidence in front of the camera. The other, a pristine silver Persian with a flat, calm face, sits majestically beside it, observing with detached curiosity. The exact moment the ginger cat attempts to blink is deconstructed with comic precision; its facial muscles tense, and instead of a smooth, charming gesture, its face contorts into a goofy, cross-eyed grimace. One eyelid squeezes tightly shut, while the other eye drifts comically inward, its whiskers trembling. The sheer muscle movement sends visible slow-motion ripples through the dense fur on its cheeks and brows. The Persian cat remains expressionless, perhaps tilting its head an inch in silent confusion, amplifying the awkwardness of the failed romantic overture and creating an atmosphere of focused, intense humor.", + "seed": 14390, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_11/index_6964_seed_14390_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03837900748476386, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03837900748476386, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03837900748476386, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brightly lit professional photography studio with a seamless neutral gray paper backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two exceptionally furry cats visible: a large long-haired ginger tabby and a silver Persian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ginger tabby shown attempting to blink with one eyelid squeezing shut and the other eye drifting inward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ginger tabby's facial movement cause visible slow-motion ripples through its dense fur on the cheeks and brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static, high-frame-rate medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0717303603887558 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.696730375289917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0717303603887558, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0717303603887558, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37204810976982117, + 0.03777022287249565, + 0.07254163920879364, + 0.26245415210723877, + 0.08731666952371597, + 0.06589752435684204, + 0.048603251576423645, + 0.013252890668809414, + 0.017543019726872444, + 0.022572482004761696 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0717303603887558 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brightly lit professional photography studio with a seamless neutral gray paper backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two exceptionally furry cats visible: a large long-haired ginger tabby and a silver Persian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ginger tabby shown attempting to blink with one eyelid squeezing shut and the other eye drifting inward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ginger tabby's facial movement cause visible slow-motion ripples through its dense fur on the cheeks and brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static, high-frame-rate medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005277274176478386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255277156829834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005277274176478386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005277274176478386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08483845740556717, + 0.05059153214097023, + 0.04121055826544762, + 0.5583649277687073, + 0.08701413869857788, + 0.0554952546954155, + 0.043937504291534424, + 0.011908458545804024, + 0.022366052493453026, + 0.04427316039800644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005277274176478386 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brightly lit professional photography studio with a seamless neutral gray paper backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two exceptionally furry cats visible: a large long-haired ginger tabby and a silver Persian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ginger tabby shown attempting to blink with one eyelid squeezing shut and the other eye drifting inward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ginger tabby's facial movement cause visible slow-motion ripples through its dense fur on the cheeks and brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static, high-frame-rate medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08906727284193039 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464067220687866 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08906727284193039, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08906727284193039, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3566831946372986, + 0.04046174883842468, + 0.03476531431078911, + 0.3789824843406677, + 0.03377065435051918, + 0.024797853082418442, + 0.046548664569854736, + 0.031110616400837898, + 0.03740428015589714, + 0.015475171618163586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08906727284193039 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brightly lit professional photography studio with a seamless neutral gray paper backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two exceptionally furry cats visible: a large long-haired ginger tabby and a silver Persian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ginger tabby shown attempting to blink with one eyelid squeezing shut and the other eye drifting inward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ginger tabby's facial movement cause visible slow-motion ripples through its dense fur on the cheeks and brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static, high-frame-rate medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818987913429737 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018189907073975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818987913429737, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818987913429737, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3118346929550171, + 0.10612557828426361, + 0.054267872124910355, + 0.24307477474212646, + 0.06655245274305344, + 0.041004620492458344, + 0.057506006211042404, + 0.030034011229872704, + 0.05760950222611427, + 0.03199050948023796 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818987913429737 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brightly lit professional photography studio with a seamless neutral gray paper backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two exceptionally furry cats visible: a large long-haired ginger tabby and a silver Persian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ginger tabby shown attempting to blink with one eyelid squeezing shut and the other eye drifting inward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ginger tabby's facial movement cause visible slow-motion ripples through its dense fur on the cheeks and brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static, high-frame-rate medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007630250882357359 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882630348205566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007630250882357359, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007630250882357359, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12009631842374802, + 0.07020388543605804, + 0.03405613824725151, + 0.5223872661590576, + 0.04188428819179535, + 0.04941170662641525, + 0.04927876964211464, + 0.027534017339348793, + 0.05234363675117493, + 0.0328039713203907 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007630250882357359 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-frame-rate medium close-up, rendered in hilarious slow motion, captures the awkward courtship rituals of a brightly lit professional photography studio. The scene is bathed in even, shadowless illumination from a large softbox light, set against a seamless, neutral gray paper backdrop. Two exceptionally furry cats are the focal points. One, a large, long-haired ginger tabby with vibrant green eyes, attempts to project suave confidence in front of the camera. The other, a pristine silver Persian with a flat, calm face, sits majestically beside it, observing with detached curiosity. The exact moment the ginger cat attempts to blink is deconstructed with comic precision; its facial muscles tense, and instead of a smooth, charming gesture, its face contorts into a goofy, cross-eyed grimace. One eyelid squeezes tightly shut, while the other eye drifts comically inward, its whiskers trembling. The sheer muscle movement sends visible slow-motion ripples through the dense fur on its cheeks and brows. The Persian cat remains expressionless, perhaps tilting its head an inch in silent confusion, amplifying the awkwardness of the failed romantic overture and creating an atmosphere of focused, intense humor.", + "seed": 14391, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_11/index_6964_seed_14391_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04165095593780279, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04165095593780279, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04165095593780279, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brightly lit professional photography studio with a seamless neutral gray paper backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two exceptionally furry cats visible: a large long-haired ginger tabby and a silver Persian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ginger tabby shown attempting to blink with one eyelid squeezing shut and the other eye drifting inward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ginger tabby's facial movement cause visible slow-motion ripples through its dense fur on the cheeks and brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static, high-frame-rate medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10308249294757843 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3530824184417725 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10308249294757843, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10308249294757843, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.169026717543602, + 0.12210586667060852, + 0.0456000491976738, + 0.05426932871341705, + 0.12317968904972076, + 0.15151149034500122, + 0.07562275975942612, + 0.11676261574029922, + 0.055313777178525925, + 0.08660773187875748 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10308249294757843 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brightly lit professional photography studio with a seamless neutral gray paper backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two exceptionally furry cats visible: a large long-haired ginger tabby and a silver Persian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ginger tabby shown attempting to blink with one eyelid squeezing shut and the other eye drifting inward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ginger tabby's facial movement cause visible slow-motion ripples through its dense fur on the cheeks and brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static, high-frame-rate medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00766692403703928 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882667064666748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00766692403703928, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00766692403703928, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31479424238204956, + 0.1277777999639511, + 0.045817889273166656, + 0.06215819716453552, + 0.02993309125304222, + 0.23212435841560364, + 0.055076271295547485, + 0.029067957773804665, + 0.06359221041202545, + 0.03965799883008003 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00766692403703928 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brightly lit professional photography studio with a seamless neutral gray paper backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two exceptionally furry cats visible: a large long-haired ginger tabby and a silver Persian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ginger tabby shown attempting to blink with one eyelid squeezing shut and the other eye drifting inward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ginger tabby's facial movement cause visible slow-motion ripples through its dense fur on the cheeks and brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static, high-frame-rate medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07901401072740555 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790140628814697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07901401072740555, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07901401072740555, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12631765007972717, + 0.06125718727707863, + 0.035353291779756546, + 0.041829854249954224, + 0.099942646920681, + 0.03202689066529274, + 0.12481994926929474, + 0.2536761164665222, + 0.16056609153747559, + 0.06421032547950745 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07901401072740555 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brightly lit professional photography studio with a seamless neutral gray paper backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two exceptionally furry cats visible: a large long-haired ginger tabby and a silver Persian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ginger tabby shown attempting to blink with one eyelid squeezing shut and the other eye drifting inward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ginger tabby's facial movement cause visible slow-motion ripples through its dense fur on the cheeks and brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static, high-frame-rate medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012542063370347023 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387542247772217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012542063370347023, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012542063370347023, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17035320401191711, + 0.0808785930275917, + 0.04013926908373833, + 0.03906634449958801, + 0.048568353056907654, + 0.04578283056616783, + 0.24848797917366028, + 0.11546818912029266, + 0.1487361341714859, + 0.0625191405415535 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012542063370347023 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brightly lit professional photography studio with a seamless neutral gray paper backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two exceptionally furry cats visible: a large long-haired ginger tabby and a silver Persian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ginger tabby shown attempting to blink with one eyelid squeezing shut and the other eye drifting inward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ginger tabby's facial movement cause visible slow-motion ripples through its dense fur on the cheeks and brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static, high-frame-rate medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005949288606643677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309494972229 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005949288606643677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005949288606643677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.135360449552536, + 0.0702577754855156, + 0.029798896983265877, + 0.03585025295615196, + 0.08478976041078568, + 0.08973407000303268, + 0.1325910985469818, + 0.06199811026453972, + 0.2752354145050049, + 0.08438412845134735 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005949288606643677 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-frame-rate medium close-up, rendered in hilarious slow motion, captures the awkward courtship rituals of a brightly lit professional photography studio. The scene is bathed in even, shadowless illumination from a large softbox light, set against a seamless, neutral gray paper backdrop. Two exceptionally furry cats are the focal points. One, a large, long-haired ginger tabby with vibrant green eyes, attempts to project suave confidence in front of the camera. The other, a pristine silver Persian with a flat, calm face, sits majestically beside it, observing with detached curiosity. The exact moment the ginger cat attempts to blink is deconstructed with comic precision; its facial muscles tense, and instead of a smooth, charming gesture, its face contorts into a goofy, cross-eyed grimace. One eyelid squeezes tightly shut, while the other eye drifts comically inward, its whiskers trembling. The sheer muscle movement sends visible slow-motion ripples through the dense fur on its cheeks and brows. The Persian cat remains expressionless, perhaps tilting its head an inch in silent confusion, amplifying the awkwardness of the failed romantic overture and creating an atmosphere of focused, intense humor.", + "seed": 14392, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_11/index_6964_seed_14392_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04370713485404849, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04370713485404849, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04370713485404849, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brightly lit professional photography studio with a seamless neutral gray paper backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two exceptionally furry cats visible: a large long-haired ginger tabby and a silver Persian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ginger tabby shown attempting to blink with one eyelid squeezing shut and the other eye drifting inward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ginger tabby's facial movement cause visible slow-motion ripples through its dense fur on the cheeks and brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static, high-frame-rate medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11385839432477951 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.238858461380005 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11385839432477951, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11385839432477951, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1331174671649933, + 0.09768550843000412, + 0.05555609241127968, + 0.07577015459537506, + 0.13693958520889282, + 0.18288762867450714, + 0.17185339331626892, + 0.0958777368068695, + 0.0238045621663332, + 0.026507874950766563 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11385839432477951 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brightly lit professional photography studio with a seamless neutral gray paper backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two exceptionally furry cats visible: a large long-haired ginger tabby and a silver Persian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ginger tabby shown attempting to blink with one eyelid squeezing shut and the other eye drifting inward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ginger tabby's facial movement cause visible slow-motion ripples through its dense fur on the cheeks and brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static, high-frame-rate medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002837443258613348 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877837657928467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002837443258613348, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002837443258613348, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17820324003696442, + 0.09337816387414932, + 0.09265274554491043, + 0.10894014686346054, + 0.09399302303791046, + 0.15380971133708954, + 0.09234758466482162, + 0.08906884491443634, + 0.04535292461514473, + 0.05225367099046707 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002837443258613348 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brightly lit professional photography studio with a seamless neutral gray paper backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two exceptionally furry cats visible: a large long-haired ginger tabby and a silver Persian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ginger tabby shown attempting to blink with one eyelid squeezing shut and the other eye drifting inward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ginger tabby's facial movement cause visible slow-motion ripples through its dense fur on the cheeks and brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static, high-frame-rate medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0790102630853653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579010248184204 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0790102630853653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0790102630853653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10483884066343307, + 0.13408547639846802, + 0.08288609236478806, + 0.07236531376838684, + 0.10073453933000565, + 0.11809173226356506, + 0.14942044019699097, + 0.05044490098953247, + 0.15682312846183777, + 0.0303095281124115 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0790102630853653 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brightly lit professional photography studio with a seamless neutral gray paper backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two exceptionally furry cats visible: a large long-haired ginger tabby and a silver Persian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ginger tabby shown attempting to blink with one eyelid squeezing shut and the other eye drifting inward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ginger tabby's facial movement cause visible slow-motion ripples through its dense fur on the cheeks and brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static, high-frame-rate medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014192597009241581 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264192581176758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014192597009241581, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014192597009241581, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13918717205524445, + 0.1545800119638443, + 0.05751090496778488, + 0.12040535360574722, + 0.0816340371966362, + 0.1415453553199768, + 0.07779213786125183, + 0.08684533834457397, + 0.09233018755912781, + 0.04816952347755432 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014192597009241581 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a brightly lit professional photography studio with a seamless neutral gray paper backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are two exceptionally furry cats visible: a large long-haired ginger tabby and a silver Persian?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ginger tabby shown attempting to blink with one eyelid squeezing shut and the other eye drifting inward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ginger tabby's facial movement cause visible slow-motion ripples through its dense fur on the cheeks and brows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a static, high-frame-rate medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008636976592242718 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758636951446533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008636976592242718, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008636976592242718, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11095577478408813, + 0.07814013212919235, + 0.05074072256684303, + 0.09480980783700943, + 0.06768634915351868, + 0.27101925015449524, + 0.06887134909629822, + 0.1304452270269394, + 0.08504702150821686, + 0.042284343391656876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008636976592242718 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_12/index_tensor([9832, 9832])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_12/index_tensor([9832, 9832])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..af7210cccaa51746be8b066fd8e24d80216e6af3 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_12/index_tensor([9832, 9832])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "steady medium close-up shot from a subjective point of view (POV) places the viewer in direct confrontation with an Asian man who blocks the viewer's path. The man, approximately forty years old, has a sharp face and meticulously slicked-back black hair. He wears a well-tailored dark charcoal wool suit, a perfectly buttoned white shirt, and a dark blue silk tie. He stands motionless in the center of a narrow, dimly lit corridor, his body erect, shoulders tense, and his undeniable demeanor completely blocking the path ahead. The only light comes from a cold white downlight directly above him. This harsh light casts deep shadows on his face, making his eyes, fixed on the camera, appear even more profound and unpredictable, and his jawline, clenched in a firm, clenched motion, appear even more rigid. The background is a blurry, dark wall and a polished concrete floor with a faint sheen, creating a compressed, oppressive feeling. There is no unnecessary movement in the picture, only this solidified stillness. The air is filled with a silent, tense atmosphere that is about to explode. The main colors are cold gray and black, creating an extremely focused and confrontational mood.", + "seed": 30160, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_12/index_9832_seed_30160_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05220292198937386, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05220292198937386, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05220292198937386, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady medium close-up from a subjective point of view (POV)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an Asian man with slicked-back black hair wearing a dark charcoal wool suit, white shirt, and dark blue silk tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing motionless in the center of a narrow, dimly lit corridor with a polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold white downlight directly above the man, casting deep shadows on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurry dark wall with the main colors being cold gray and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07849229872226715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.7034924030303955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07849229872226715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07849229872226715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07962800562381744, + 0.07059252262115479, + 0.04975498467683792, + 0.11684323102235794, + 0.25318995118141174, + 0.13105754554271698, + 0.0858151763677597, + 0.064759761095047, + 0.08515506982803345, + 0.06320370733737946 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07849229872226715 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady medium close-up from a subjective point of view (POV)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an Asian man with slicked-back black hair wearing a dark charcoal wool suit, white shirt, and dark blue silk tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing motionless in the center of a narrow, dimly lit corridor with a polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold white downlight directly above the man, casting deep shadows on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurry dark wall with the main colors being cold gray and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018215984106063843 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018216133117676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018215984106063843, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018215984106063843, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14088770747184753, + 0.09177592396736145, + 0.14473892748355865, + 0.054563283920288086, + 0.3248387575149536, + 0.07067624479532242, + 0.04229435697197914, + 0.057439956814050674, + 0.025652889162302017, + 0.04713192582130432 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018215984106063843 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady medium close-up from a subjective point of view (POV)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an Asian man with slicked-back black hair wearing a dark charcoal wool suit, white shirt, and dark blue silk tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing motionless in the center of a narrow, dimly lit corridor with a polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold white downlight directly above the man, casting deep shadows on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurry dark wall with the main colors being cold gray and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10030773282051086 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503077030181885 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10030773282051086, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10030773282051086, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08425398170948029, + 0.04278333857655525, + 0.11837208271026611, + 0.0532904677093029, + 0.1557791531085968, + 0.2676162123680115, + 0.03249819949269295, + 0.038925204426050186, + 0.17777492105960846, + 0.028706416487693787 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10030773282051086 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady medium close-up from a subjective point of view (POV)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an Asian man with slicked-back black hair wearing a dark charcoal wool suit, white shirt, and dark blue silk tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing motionless in the center of a narrow, dimly lit corridor with a polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold white downlight directly above the man, casting deep shadows on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurry dark wall with the main colors being cold gray and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620572492480278 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120572566986084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620572492480278, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620572492480278, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08216071128845215, + 0.15429078042507172, + 0.10521520674228668, + 0.11334304511547089, + 0.21894313395023346, + 0.12326333671808243, + 0.037307217717170715, + 0.08239872753620148, + 0.03695113584399223, + 0.04612666741013527 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620572492480278 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady medium close-up from a subjective point of view (POV)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an Asian man with slicked-back black hair wearing a dark charcoal wool suit, white shirt, and dark blue silk tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing motionless in the center of a narrow, dimly lit corridor with a polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold white downlight directly above the man, casting deep shadows on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurry dark wall with the main colors being cold gray and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019413450499996543 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251941204071045 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019413450499996543, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019413450499996543, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09800734370946884, + 0.058079466223716736, + 0.0694502517580986, + 0.09334354847669601, + 0.31051915884017944, + 0.17914585769176483, + 0.0322890542447567, + 0.06166401132941246, + 0.04602598026394844, + 0.051475316286087036 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019413450499996543 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "steady medium close-up shot from a subjective point of view (POV) places the viewer in direct confrontation with an Asian man who blocks the viewer's path. The man, approximately forty years old, has a sharp face and meticulously slicked-back black hair. He wears a well-tailored dark charcoal wool suit, a perfectly buttoned white shirt, and a dark blue silk tie. He stands motionless in the center of a narrow, dimly lit corridor, his body erect, shoulders tense, and his undeniable demeanor completely blocking the path ahead. The only light comes from a cold white downlight directly above him. This harsh light casts deep shadows on his face, making his eyes, fixed on the camera, appear even more profound and unpredictable, and his jawline, clenched in a firm, clenched motion, appear even more rigid. The background is a blurry, dark wall and a polished concrete floor with a faint sheen, creating a compressed, oppressive feeling. There is no unnecessary movement in the picture, only this solidified stillness. The air is filled with a silent, tense atmosphere that is about to explode. The main colors are cold gray and black, creating an extremely focused and confrontational mood.", + "seed": 30161, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_12/index_9832_seed_30161_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07076225047931076, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07076225047931076, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07076225047931076, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady medium close-up from a subjective point of view (POV)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an Asian man with slicked-back black hair wearing a dark charcoal wool suit, white shirt, and dark blue silk tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing motionless in the center of a narrow, dimly lit corridor with a polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold white downlight directly above the man, casting deep shadows on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurry dark wall with the main colors being cold gray and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12025877833366394 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2452588081359863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12025877833366394, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12025877833366394, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07843173295259476, + 0.050377149134874344, + 0.14967718720436096, + 0.04953506216406822, + 0.05117924138903618, + 0.06032157689332962, + 0.02726469747722149, + 0.06426091492176056, + 0.02686319127678871, + 0.4420892298221588 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12025877833366394 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady medium close-up from a subjective point of view (POV)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an Asian man with slicked-back black hair wearing a dark charcoal wool suit, white shirt, and dark blue silk tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing motionless in the center of a narrow, dimly lit corridor with a polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold white downlight directly above the man, casting deep shadows on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurry dark wall with the main colors being cold gray and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05500540882349014 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300053119659424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05500540882349014, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05500540882349014, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21476507186889648, + 0.05692078173160553, + 0.03406187891960144, + 0.09679673612117767, + 0.028981508687138557, + 0.046099789440631866, + 0.033144306391477585, + 0.09048917889595032, + 0.11110309511423111, + 0.2876375913619995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05500540882349014 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady medium close-up from a subjective point of view (POV)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an Asian man with slicked-back black hair wearing a dark charcoal wool suit, white shirt, and dark blue silk tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing motionless in the center of a narrow, dimly lit corridor with a polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold white downlight directly above the man, casting deep shadows on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurry dark wall with the main colors being cold gray and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866647347807884 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048666477203369 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866647347807884, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866647347807884, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08184908330440521, + 0.028132367879152298, + 0.11257725208997726, + 0.15142826735973358, + 0.06388513743877411, + 0.02906409092247486, + 0.05808205157518387, + 0.13186560571193695, + 0.04121268913149834, + 0.3019033670425415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866647347807884 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady medium close-up from a subjective point of view (POV)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an Asian man with slicked-back black hair wearing a dark charcoal wool suit, white shirt, and dark blue silk tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing motionless in the center of a narrow, dimly lit corridor with a polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold white downlight directly above the man, casting deep shadows on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurry dark wall with the main colors being cold gray and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12706086039543152 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127060890197754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12706086039543152, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12706086039543152, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10269056260585785, + 0.045024190098047256, + 0.0325237438082695, + 0.02674023248255253, + 0.044555339962244034, + 0.027408653870224953, + 0.025992680341005325, + 0.0202106311917305, + 0.024146314710378647, + 0.6507076025009155 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12706086039543152 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady medium close-up from a subjective point of view (POV)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an Asian man with slicked-back black hair wearing a dark charcoal wool suit, white shirt, and dark blue silk tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing motionless in the center of a narrow, dimly lit corridor with a polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold white downlight directly above the man, casting deep shadows on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurry dark wall with the main colors being cold gray and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002819731365889311 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877819538116455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002819731365889311, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002819731365889311, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0538533516228199, + 0.026857051998376846, + 0.022917652502655983, + 0.06311281770467758, + 0.07376523315906525, + 0.027959054335951805, + 0.012211245484650135, + 0.027511190623044968, + 0.04433769732713699, + 0.6474747061729431 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002819731365889311 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "steady medium close-up shot from a subjective point of view (POV) places the viewer in direct confrontation with an Asian man who blocks the viewer's path. The man, approximately forty years old, has a sharp face and meticulously slicked-back black hair. He wears a well-tailored dark charcoal wool suit, a perfectly buttoned white shirt, and a dark blue silk tie. He stands motionless in the center of a narrow, dimly lit corridor, his body erect, shoulders tense, and his undeniable demeanor completely blocking the path ahead. The only light comes from a cold white downlight directly above him. This harsh light casts deep shadows on his face, making his eyes, fixed on the camera, appear even more profound and unpredictable, and his jawline, clenched in a firm, clenched motion, appear even more rigid. The background is a blurry, dark wall and a polished concrete floor with a faint sheen, creating a compressed, oppressive feeling. There is no unnecessary movement in the picture, only this solidified stillness. The air is filled with a silent, tense atmosphere that is about to explode. The main colors are cold gray and black, creating an extremely focused and confrontational mood.", + "seed": 30162, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_12/index_9832_seed_30162_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04133960586041212, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04133960586041212, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04133960586041212, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady medium close-up from a subjective point of view (POV)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an Asian man with slicked-back black hair wearing a dark charcoal wool suit, white shirt, and dark blue silk tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing motionless in the center of a narrow, dimly lit corridor with a polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold white downlight directly above the man, casting deep shadows on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurry dark wall with the main colors being cold gray and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06165282800793648 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.936652898788452 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06165282800793648, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06165282800793648, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0792103037238121, + 0.025713875889778137, + 0.047070711851119995, + 0.04008234664797783, + 0.042809903621673584, + 0.6735613942146301, + 0.02768777869641781, + 0.02714359574019909, + 0.015495581552386284, + 0.02122448943555355 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06165282800793648 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady medium close-up from a subjective point of view (POV)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an Asian man with slicked-back black hair wearing a dark charcoal wool suit, white shirt, and dark blue silk tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing motionless in the center of a narrow, dimly lit corridor with a polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold white downlight directly above the man, casting deep shadows on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurry dark wall with the main colors being cold gray and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029833264648914337 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298333168029785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029833264648914337, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029833264648914337, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09240803867578506, + 0.09405176341533661, + 0.042344458401203156, + 0.0844716802239418, + 0.022804129868745804, + 0.54051274061203, + 0.024157313629984856, + 0.02450171858072281, + 0.028656993061304092, + 0.04609116539359093 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029833264648914337 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady medium close-up from a subjective point of view (POV)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an Asian man with slicked-back black hair wearing a dark charcoal wool suit, white shirt, and dark blue silk tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing motionless in the center of a narrow, dimly lit corridor with a polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold white downlight directly above the man, casting deep shadows on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurry dark wall with the main colors being cold gray and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900464534759521 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790047645568848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900464534759521, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900464534759521, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07597650587558746, + 0.07228035479784012, + 0.05187731608748436, + 0.057530809193849564, + 0.07078024744987488, + 0.4899276793003082, + 0.04959597811102867, + 0.032903239130973816, + 0.014808714389801025, + 0.0843190848827362 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900464534759521 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady medium close-up from a subjective point of view (POV)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an Asian man with slicked-back black hair wearing a dark charcoal wool suit, white shirt, and dark blue silk tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing motionless in the center of a narrow, dimly lit corridor with a polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold white downlight directly above the man, casting deep shadows on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurry dark wall with the main colors being cold gray and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033716656267642975 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087166786193848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033716656267642975, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033716656267642975, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.028966013342142105, + 0.04260799288749695, + 0.07226899266242981, + 0.019568460062146187, + 0.02087935246527195, + 0.7772999405860901, + 0.010230538435280323, + 0.005239203572273254, + 0.008830918930470943, + 0.014108571223914623 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033716656267642975 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady medium close-up from a subjective point of view (POV)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an Asian man with slicked-back black hair wearing a dark charcoal wool suit, white shirt, and dark blue silk tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing motionless in the center of a narrow, dimly lit corridor with a polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold white downlight directly above the man, casting deep shadows on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurry dark wall with the main colors being cold gray and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024906350299715996 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002490520477295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024906350299715996, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024906350299715996, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09440816193819046, + 0.05035821720957756, + 0.032589156180620193, + 0.01922845095396042, + 0.05711227282881737, + 0.6629416942596436, + 0.012503364123404026, + 0.027174070477485657, + 0.016262874007225037, + 0.027421729639172554 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024906350299715996 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "steady medium close-up shot from a subjective point of view (POV) places the viewer in direct confrontation with an Asian man who blocks the viewer's path. The man, approximately forty years old, has a sharp face and meticulously slicked-back black hair. He wears a well-tailored dark charcoal wool suit, a perfectly buttoned white shirt, and a dark blue silk tie. He stands motionless in the center of a narrow, dimly lit corridor, his body erect, shoulders tense, and his undeniable demeanor completely blocking the path ahead. The only light comes from a cold white downlight directly above him. This harsh light casts deep shadows on his face, making his eyes, fixed on the camera, appear even more profound and unpredictable, and his jawline, clenched in a firm, clenched motion, appear even more rigid. The background is a blurry, dark wall and a polished concrete floor with a faint sheen, creating a compressed, oppressive feeling. There is no unnecessary movement in the picture, only this solidified stillness. The air is filled with a silent, tense atmosphere that is about to explode. The main colors are cold gray and black, creating an extremely focused and confrontational mood.", + "seed": 30163, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_12/index_9832_seed_30163_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.031832053372636435, + "vlm_logprob": -0.031832053372636435, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.031832053372636435, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady medium close-up from a subjective point of view (POV)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an Asian man with slicked-back black hair wearing a dark charcoal wool suit, white shirt, and dark blue silk tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing motionless in the center of a narrow, dimly lit corridor with a polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold white downlight directly above the man, casting deep shadows on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurry dark wall with the main colors being cold gray and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06086615100502968 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.935866117477417 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06086615100502968, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06086615100502968, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12411735951900482, + 0.08190172910690308, + 0.08964576572179794, + 0.06212145835161209, + 0.06010603532195091, + 0.34956997632980347, + 0.12708249688148499, + 0.04528729245066643, + 0.03196492791175842, + 0.028202958405017853 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06086615100502968 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady medium close-up from a subjective point of view (POV)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an Asian man with slicked-back black hair wearing a dark charcoal wool suit, white shirt, and dark blue silk tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing motionless in the center of a narrow, dimly lit corridor with a polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold white downlight directly above the man, casting deep shadows on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurry dark wall with the main colors being cold gray and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014214222319424152 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264214038848877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014214222319424152, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014214222319424152, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23148755729198456, + 0.09388349205255508, + 0.08493154495954514, + 0.0733003243803978, + 0.04909108951687813, + 0.16089174151420593, + 0.09673832356929779, + 0.0680437833070755, + 0.09218868613243103, + 0.049443431198596954 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014214222319424152 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady medium close-up from a subjective point of view (POV)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an Asian man with slicked-back black hair wearing a dark charcoal wool suit, white shirt, and dark blue silk tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing motionless in the center of a narrow, dimly lit corridor with a polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold white downlight directly above the man, casting deep shadows on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurry dark wall with the main colors being cold gray and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0336986780166626 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408698558807373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0336986780166626, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0336986780166626, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14990945160388947, + 0.17988887429237366, + 0.12946106493473053, + 0.061322495341300964, + 0.1339389830827713, + 0.04996388405561447, + 0.16817283630371094, + 0.04174236208200455, + 0.04630734771490097, + 0.039292700588703156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0336986780166626 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady medium close-up from a subjective point of view (POV)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an Asian man with slicked-back black hair wearing a dark charcoal wool suit, white shirt, and dark blue silk tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing motionless in the center of a narrow, dimly lit corridor with a polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold white downlight directly above the man, casting deep shadows on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurry dark wall with the main colors being cold gray and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866738244891167 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486674308776855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866738244891167, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866738244891167, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14050675928592682, + 0.12997373938560486, + 0.07259968668222427, + 0.12479133903980255, + 0.04870406538248062, + 0.29525479674339294, + 0.11980023980140686, + 0.02090410701930523, + 0.018750716000795364, + 0.028714602813124657 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866738244891167 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady medium close-up from a subjective point of view (POV)?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject an Asian man with slicked-back black hair wearing a dark charcoal wool suit, white shirt, and dark blue silk tie?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man standing motionless in the center of a narrow, dimly lit corridor with a polished concrete floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single cold white downlight directly above the man, casting deep shadows on his face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurry dark wall with the main colors being cold gray and black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017138330731540918 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376713752746582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017138330731540918, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017138330731540918, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10947819799184799, + 0.04709712788462639, + 0.12892557680606842, + 0.1157524511218071, + 0.05832614377140999, + 0.3316196799278259, + 0.058781400322914124, + 0.043397676199674606, + 0.0668991282582283, + 0.03972264379262924 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017138330731540918 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_13/index_tensor([7392, 7392])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_13/index_tensor([7392, 7392])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..474689f21f81772992712d3223bc8f927de74e92 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_13/index_tensor([7392, 7392])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatic close-up begins at the edge of a boiling hot pot. A deep red spicy broth swirls violently within the dark cast iron pot, its surface shimmering with an oily sheen as countless bubbles surge upward. Freshly sliced, tender beef slices, freshly simmered in the scalding broth, instantly curl and twist in the scalding broth, their color changing from bright red to an alluring, cooked brown. This contrasts sharply with the vibrant green vegetable leaves beside them, soaked in the red oil. Together, they rise and fall in the broth. The camera then slowly and steadily ascends, passing through the thick, swirling white steam rising from the pot. The steam momentarily obscures the frame, then gradually dissipates as the camera continues to rise. The soft, warm tones of the interior light permeate the steam, creating an alluring atmosphere of warmth, comfort, and a sense of everyday life.", + "seed": 32495, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_13/index_7392_seed_32495_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.01958790058270097, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01958790058270097, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01958790058270097, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a close-up view of a dark cast iron pot containing boiling broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are beef slices visible in the broth, changing color from bright red to cooked brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant green vegetable leaves visible in the broth alongside the beef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily ascend, passing through rising white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by soft, warm tones creating an atmosphere of warmth and comfort?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.039000000804662704 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2890000343322754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.039000000804662704, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.039000000804662704, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13575778901576996, + 0.02163640409708023, + 0.021243346855044365, + 0.0548282153904438, + 0.03981471806764603, + 0.2429506778717041, + 0.03877628967165947, + 0.08048060536384583, + 0.028005147352814674, + 0.33650675415992737 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.039000000804662704 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a close-up view of a dark cast iron pot containing boiling broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are beef slices visible in the broth, changing color from bright red to cooked brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant green vegetable leaves visible in the broth alongside the beef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily ascend, passing through rising white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by soft, warm tones creating an atmosphere of warmth and comfort?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012572788633406162 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387572765350342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012572788633406162, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012572788633406162, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07489915192127228, + 0.029726896435022354, + 0.025984587147831917, + 0.034668661653995514, + 0.04109757021069527, + 0.07330594211816788, + 0.11281755566596985, + 0.08171495050191879, + 0.059696491807699203, + 0.46608829498291016 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012572788633406162 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a close-up view of a dark cast iron pot containing boiling broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are beef slices visible in the broth, changing color from bright red to cooked brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant green vegetable leaves visible in the broth alongside the beef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily ascend, passing through rising white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by soft, warm tones creating an atmosphere of warmth and comfort?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003616699017584324 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628616809844971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003616699017584324, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003616699017584324, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17798081040382385, + 0.10246062278747559, + 0.022984106093645096, + 0.039193928241729736, + 0.041742075234651566, + 0.08691755682229996, + 0.055501632392406464, + 0.06421507149934769, + 0.034830618649721146, + 0.3741735517978668 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003616699017584324 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a close-up view of a dark cast iron pot containing boiling broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are beef slices visible in the broth, changing color from bright red to cooked brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant green vegetable leaves visible in the broth alongside the beef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily ascend, passing through rising white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by soft, warm tones creating an atmosphere of warmth and comfort?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811221942305565 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288112163543701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811221942305565, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811221942305565, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10079265385866165, + 0.0923997089266777, + 0.06900745630264282, + 0.04819498211145401, + 0.11246307939291, + 0.06909267604351044, + 0.0787709429860115, + 0.15317925810813904, + 0.12965108454227448, + 0.14644815027713776 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811221942305565 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a close-up view of a dark cast iron pot containing boiling broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are beef slices visible in the broth, changing color from bright red to cooked brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant green vegetable leaves visible in the broth alongside the beef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily ascend, passing through rising white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by soft, warm tones creating an atmosphere of warmth and comfort?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046377950347959995 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379637718200684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046377950347959995, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046377950347959995, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3150314390659332, + 0.06204596161842346, + 0.114702507853508, + 0.033724572509527206, + 0.06437032669782639, + 0.17574885487556458, + 0.038659900426864624, + 0.07729614526033401, + 0.05038559436798096, + 0.06803472340106964 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046377950347959995 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic close-up begins at the edge of a boiling hot pot. A deep red spicy broth swirls violently within the dark cast iron pot, its surface shimmering with an oily sheen as countless bubbles surge upward. Freshly sliced, tender beef slices, freshly simmered in the scalding broth, instantly curl and twist in the scalding broth, their color changing from bright red to an alluring, cooked brown. This contrasts sharply with the vibrant green vegetable leaves beside them, soaked in the red oil. Together, they rise and fall in the broth. The camera then slowly and steadily ascends, passing through the thick, swirling white steam rising from the pot. The steam momentarily obscures the frame, then gradually dissipates as the camera continues to rise. The soft, warm tones of the interior light permeate the steam, creating an alluring atmosphere of warmth, comfort, and a sense of everyday life.", + "seed": 32496, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_13/index_7392_seed_32496_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.012155886203981937, + "vlm_logprob": -0.012155886203981937, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.012155886203981937, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a close-up view of a dark cast iron pot containing boiling broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are beef slices visible in the broth, changing color from bright red to cooked brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant green vegetable leaves visible in the broth alongside the beef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily ascend, passing through rising white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by soft, warm tones creating an atmosphere of warmth and comfort?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03112243302166462 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5311224460601807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03112243302166462, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03112243302166462, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06694143265485764, + 0.07560385018587112, + 0.08113830536603928, + 0.27566567063331604, + 0.06804762780666351, + 0.08117861300706863, + 0.03762355446815491, + 0.05017802119255066, + 0.08770628273487091, + 0.17591670155525208 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03112243302166462 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a close-up view of a dark cast iron pot containing boiling broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are beef slices visible in the broth, changing color from bright red to cooked brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant green vegetable leaves visible in the broth alongside the beef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily ascend, passing through rising white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by soft, warm tones creating an atmosphere of warmth and comfort?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006765080615878105 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006764888763428 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006765080615878105, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006765080615878105, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08998464792966843, + 0.04622381180524826, + 0.1253020167350769, + 0.3085395097732544, + 0.02868122234940529, + 0.029640503227710724, + 0.0888623520731926, + 0.0673927590250969, + 0.07735632359981537, + 0.13801679015159607 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006765080615878105 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a close-up view of a dark cast iron pot containing boiling broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are beef slices visible in the broth, changing color from bright red to cooked brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant green vegetable leaves visible in the broth alongside the beef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily ascend, passing through rising white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by soft, warm tones creating an atmosphere of warmth and comfort?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019426537910476327 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.2519426345825195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019426537910476327, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019426537910476327, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07091308385133743, + 0.0821671262383461, + 0.06276869773864746, + 0.36057817935943604, + 0.04520561173558235, + 0.05024350807070732, + 0.07844990491867065, + 0.05286048725247383, + 0.09272696077823639, + 0.10408641397953033 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019426537910476327 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a close-up view of a dark cast iron pot containing boiling broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are beef slices visible in the broth, changing color from bright red to cooked brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant green vegetable leaves visible in the broth alongside the beef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily ascend, passing through rising white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by soft, warm tones creating an atmosphere of warmth and comfort?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014209403656423092 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264209270477295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014209403656423092, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014209403656423092, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.045001737773418427, + 0.03420759737491608, + 0.06527207791805267, + 0.0693284198641777, + 0.0998663529753685, + 0.08586491644382477, + 0.07132761180400848, + 0.12023446708917618, + 0.26407983899116516, + 0.1448170244693756 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014209403656423092 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a close-up view of a dark cast iron pot containing boiling broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are beef slices visible in the broth, changing color from bright red to cooked brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant green vegetable leaves visible in the broth alongside the beef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily ascend, passing through rising white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by soft, warm tones creating an atmosphere of warmth and comfort?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006739859934896231 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006740093231201 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006739859934896231, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006739859934896231, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11314983665943146, + 0.0783846527338028, + 0.0532459132373333, + 0.114351287484169, + 0.08345367759466171, + 0.07193266600370407, + 0.10866935551166534, + 0.0770573690533638, + 0.09498448669910431, + 0.20477071404457092 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006739859934896231 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic close-up begins at the edge of a boiling hot pot. A deep red spicy broth swirls violently within the dark cast iron pot, its surface shimmering with an oily sheen as countless bubbles surge upward. Freshly sliced, tender beef slices, freshly simmered in the scalding broth, instantly curl and twist in the scalding broth, their color changing from bright red to an alluring, cooked brown. This contrasts sharply with the vibrant green vegetable leaves beside them, soaked in the red oil. Together, they rise and fall in the broth. The camera then slowly and steadily ascends, passing through the thick, swirling white steam rising from the pot. The steam momentarily obscures the frame, then gradually dissipates as the camera continues to rise. The soft, warm tones of the interior light permeate the steam, creating an alluring atmosphere of warmth, comfort, and a sense of everyday life.", + "seed": 32497, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_13/index_7392_seed_32497_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04762355503626168, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04762355503626168, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04762355503626168, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a close-up view of a dark cast iron pot containing boiling broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are beef slices visible in the broth, changing color from bright red to cooked brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant green vegetable leaves visible in the broth alongside the beef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily ascend, passing through rising white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by soft, warm tones creating an atmosphere of warmth and comfort?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2040354311466217 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7040354013442993 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2040354311466217, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2040354311466217, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07056989520788193, + 0.03437809646129608, + 0.01920619048178196, + 0.04599712789058685, + 0.018773134797811508, + 0.032483603805303574, + 0.07630396634340286, + 0.4196491539478302, + 0.07919308543205261, + 0.20344577729701996 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2040354311466217 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a close-up view of a dark cast iron pot containing boiling broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are beef slices visible in the broth, changing color from bright red to cooked brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant green vegetable leaves visible in the broth alongside the beef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily ascend, passing through rising white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by soft, warm tones creating an atmosphere of warmth and comfort?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014229030348360538 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264228820800781 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014229030348360538, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014229030348360538, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1168019101023674, + 0.17961730062961578, + 0.030916109681129456, + 0.015772828832268715, + 0.03384063020348549, + 0.05127090588212013, + 0.05654026195406914, + 0.36015892028808594, + 0.09159847348928452, + 0.06348265707492828 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014229030348360538 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a close-up view of a dark cast iron pot containing boiling broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are beef slices visible in the broth, changing color from bright red to cooked brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant green vegetable leaves visible in the broth alongside the beef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily ascend, passing through rising white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by soft, warm tones creating an atmosphere of warmth and comfort?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002820563269779086 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778204917907715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002820563269779086, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002820563269779086, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11158958077430725, + 0.06457975506782532, + 0.03039662167429924, + 0.08977770805358887, + 0.035591449588537216, + 0.03326527401804924, + 0.06395044177770615, + 0.3687513470649719, + 0.10131923109292984, + 0.10077866911888123 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002820563269779086 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a close-up view of a dark cast iron pot containing boiling broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are beef slices visible in the broth, changing color from bright red to cooked brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant green vegetable leaves visible in the broth alongside the beef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily ascend, passing through rising white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by soft, warm tones creating an atmosphere of warmth and comfort?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011084291152656078 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511084079742432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011084291152656078, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011084291152656078, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06478562206029892, + 0.04201822727918625, + 0.03383931145071983, + 0.09646251052618027, + 0.058874499052762985, + 0.061193447560071945, + 0.08465614169836044, + 0.1301676481962204, + 0.3109290301799774, + 0.11707352101802826 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011084291152656078 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a close-up view of a dark cast iron pot containing boiling broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are beef slices visible in the broth, changing color from bright red to cooked brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant green vegetable leaves visible in the broth alongside the beef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily ascend, passing through rising white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by soft, warm tones creating an atmosphere of warmth and comfort?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005948459263890982 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130948543548584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005948459263890982, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005948459263890982, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1238497644662857, + 0.04423746466636658, + 0.03381611779332161, + 0.0690360739827156, + 0.13663209974765778, + 0.05328486114740372, + 0.07377955317497253, + 0.11139972507953644, + 0.23332516849040985, + 0.1206391379237175 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005948459263890982 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic close-up begins at the edge of a boiling hot pot. A deep red spicy broth swirls violently within the dark cast iron pot, its surface shimmering with an oily sheen as countless bubbles surge upward. Freshly sliced, tender beef slices, freshly simmered in the scalding broth, instantly curl and twist in the scalding broth, their color changing from bright red to an alluring, cooked brown. This contrasts sharply with the vibrant green vegetable leaves beside them, soaked in the red oil. Together, they rise and fall in the broth. The camera then slowly and steadily ascends, passing through the thick, swirling white steam rising from the pot. The steam momentarily obscures the frame, then gradually dissipates as the camera continues to rise. The soft, warm tones of the interior light permeate the steam, creating an alluring atmosphere of warmth, comfort, and a sense of everyday life.", + "seed": 32498, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_13/index_7392_seed_32498_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.01190488925203681, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01190488925203681, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01190488925203681, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a close-up view of a dark cast iron pot containing boiling broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are beef slices visible in the broth, changing color from bright red to cooked brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant green vegetable leaves visible in the broth alongside the beef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily ascend, passing through rising white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by soft, warm tones creating an atmosphere of warmth and comfort?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018268892541527748 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.143269062042236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018268892541527748, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018268892541527748, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2490997016429901, + 0.05534110590815544, + 0.05534122511744499, + 0.05788664147257805, + 0.05892856791615486, + 0.09336124360561371, + 0.06367553025484085, + 0.0586288757622242, + 0.16658882796764374, + 0.14114828407764435 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018268892541527748 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a close-up view of a dark cast iron pot containing boiling broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are beef slices visible in the broth, changing color from bright red to cooked brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant green vegetable leaves visible in the broth alongside the beef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily ascend, passing through rising white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by soft, warm tones creating an atmosphere of warmth and comfort?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007657578215003014 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882657527923584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007657578215003014, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007657578215003014, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21552418172359467, + 0.04760630428791046, + 0.05929972231388092, + 0.041846148669719696, + 0.03464418649673462, + 0.12117896974086761, + 0.11558912694454193, + 0.028099846094846725, + 0.07429283112287521, + 0.26191872358322144 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007657578215003014 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a close-up view of a dark cast iron pot containing boiling broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are beef slices visible in the broth, changing color from bright red to cooked brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant green vegetable leaves visible in the broth alongside the beef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily ascend, passing through rising white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by soft, warm tones creating an atmosphere of warmth and comfort?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036183618940413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628618240356445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036183618940413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036183618940413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11750980466604233, + 0.18901628255844116, + 0.057404231280088425, + 0.07173752039670944, + 0.0623861700296402, + 0.050037138164043427, + 0.11583056300878525, + 0.03466729819774628, + 0.04698307439684868, + 0.2544279396533966 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036183618940413 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a close-up view of a dark cast iron pot containing boiling broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are beef slices visible in the broth, changing color from bright red to cooked brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant green vegetable leaves visible in the broth alongside the beef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily ascend, passing through rising white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by soft, warm tones creating an atmosphere of warmth and comfort?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026362914592027664 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651362895965576 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026362914592027664, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026362914592027664, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09387680888175964, + 0.06580160558223724, + 0.022641828283667564, + 0.04687374457716942, + 0.1348240226507187, + 0.03943905979394913, + 0.03780419006943703, + 0.054196178913116455, + 0.08735489845275879, + 0.4171876609325409 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026362914592027664 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a close-up view of a dark cast iron pot containing boiling broth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are beef slices visible in the broth, changing color from bright red to cooked brown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant green vegetable leaves visible in the broth alongside the beef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily ascend, passing through rising white steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by soft, warm tones creating an atmosphere of warmth and comfort?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003616699017584324 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628616809844971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003616699017584324, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003616699017584324, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17608562111854553, + 0.03243749216198921, + 0.040640853345394135, + 0.11983374506235123, + 0.07745454460382462, + 0.04312079772353172, + 0.06776408106088638, + 0.04387452453374863, + 0.14672493934631348, + 0.2520633041858673 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003616699017584324 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_14/index_tensor([312, 312])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_14/index_tensor([312, 312])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a54716df7e5f484bf328e90d1de1a1324007b560 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_14/index_tensor([312, 312])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "wide, eye-level tracking shot pans smoothly to the right, following a cyclist leisurely along a sun-dappled country road. The cyclist, a woman with honey-blonde hair tied in a loose ponytail that sways gently in the breeze, wears a simple white linen shirt with rolled-up sleeves and light blue denim shorts, a serene, contented smile on her face. She rides a vintage, mint-green bicycle, complete with a wicker basket holding a few wildflowers, brown leather handlebars, and gleaming chrome fenders. Her pedaling rhythm is steady and unhurried, her body swaying gently as she passes a row of picturesque, quaint, storybook-like cottages, characterized by whitewashed stone walls, traditional straw roofs, and small, paneled windows overflowing with vibrant red and purple flowers. The golden afternoon sun filters through the dense canopy of trees, casting a shifting mosaic of bright light and soft shadows on the cyclists and the worn asphalt road, creating a warm, idyllic atmosphere that evokes a sense of tranquility and timeless peace.", + "seed": 10026, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_14/index_312_seed_10026_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.014726194739341735, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014726194739341735, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014726194739341735, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth tracking shot panning to the right following a cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist a woman with honey-blonde hair tied in a loose ponytail that sways in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist wearing a white linen shirt with rolled-up sleeves and light blue denim shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle vintage and mint-green with a wicker basket holding wildflowers and brown leather handlebars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a row of quaint cottages with whitewashed stone walls, straw roofs, and windows overflowing with red and purple flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014992651529610157 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264992713928223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014992651529610157, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014992651529610157, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07685156911611557, + 0.06234065443277359, + 0.16161185503005981, + 0.20320062339305878, + 0.056736819446086884, + 0.09447437524795532, + 0.07099387049674988, + 0.12246967107057571, + 0.10958239436149597, + 0.04173814505338669 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014992651529610157 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth tracking shot panning to the right following a cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist a woman with honey-blonde hair tied in a loose ponytail that sways in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist wearing a white linen shirt with rolled-up sleeves and light blue denim shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle vintage and mint-green with a wicker basket holding wildflowers and brown leather handlebars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a row of quaint cottages with whitewashed stone walls, straw roofs, and windows overflowing with red and purple flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023284463211894035 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773284435272217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023284463211894035, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023284463211894035, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34788888692855835, + 0.12181580066680908, + 0.037244200706481934, + 0.04881710559129715, + 0.04733508080244064, + 0.0583508275449276, + 0.14466339349746704, + 0.0753336101770401, + 0.06331288069486618, + 0.05523819848895073 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023284463211894035 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth tracking shot panning to the right following a cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist a woman with honey-blonde hair tied in a loose ponytail that sways in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist wearing a white linen shirt with rolled-up sleeves and light blue denim shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle vintage and mint-green with a wicker basket holding wildflowers and brown leather handlebars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a row of quaint cottages with whitewashed stone walls, straw roofs, and windows overflowing with red and purple flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008635913021862507 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758635997772217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008635913021862507, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008635913021862507, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18078838288784027, + 0.09414979815483093, + 0.10310108214616776, + 0.10522915422916412, + 0.028626039624214172, + 0.07772929966449738, + 0.11601630598306656, + 0.16078944504261017, + 0.0588223859667778, + 0.07474813610315323 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008635913021862507 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth tracking shot panning to the right following a cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist a woman with honey-blonde hair tied in a loose ponytail that sways in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist wearing a white linen shirt with rolled-up sleeves and light blue denim shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle vintage and mint-green with a wicker basket holding wildflowers and brown leather handlebars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a row of quaint cottages with whitewashed stone walls, straw roofs, and windows overflowing with red and purple flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014191068708896637 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264191150665283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014191068708896637, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014191068708896637, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27487653493881226, + 0.135189488530159, + 0.06323420256376266, + 0.0608355775475502, + 0.035648275166749954, + 0.0760045051574707, + 0.12494596838951111, + 0.07145894318819046, + 0.07039748132228851, + 0.08740905672311783 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014191068708896637 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth tracking shot panning to the right following a cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist a woman with honey-blonde hair tied in a loose ponytail that sways in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist wearing a white linen shirt with rolled-up sleeves and light blue denim shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle vintage and mint-green with a wicker basket holding wildflowers and brown leather handlebars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a row of quaint cottages with whitewashed stone walls, straw roofs, and windows overflowing with red and purple flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012526877224445343 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387526988983154 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012526877224445343, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012526877224445343, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07504557073116302, + 0.06069159880280495, + 0.08644265681505203, + 0.14265304803848267, + 0.12440958619117737, + 0.12924493849277496, + 0.09334053099155426, + 0.11584408581256866, + 0.07423946261405945, + 0.09808852523565292 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012526877224445343 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, eye-level tracking shot pans smoothly to the right, following a cyclist leisurely along a sun-dappled country road. The cyclist, a woman with honey-blonde hair tied in a loose ponytail that sways gently in the breeze, wears a simple white linen shirt with rolled-up sleeves and light blue denim shorts, a serene, contented smile on her face. She rides a vintage, mint-green bicycle, complete with a wicker basket holding a few wildflowers, brown leather handlebars, and gleaming chrome fenders. Her pedaling rhythm is steady and unhurried, her body swaying gently as she passes a row of picturesque, quaint, storybook-like cottages, characterized by whitewashed stone walls, traditional straw roofs, and small, paneled windows overflowing with vibrant red and purple flowers. The golden afternoon sun filters through the dense canopy of trees, casting a shifting mosaic of bright light and soft shadows on the cyclists and the worn asphalt road, creating a warm, idyllic atmosphere that evokes a sense of tranquility and timeless peace.", + "seed": 10027, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_14/index_312_seed_10027_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.017698142025619746, + "vlm_logprob": -0.017698142025619746, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.017698142025619746, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth tracking shot panning to the right following a cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist a woman with honey-blonde hair tied in a loose ponytail that sways in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist wearing a white linen shirt with rolled-up sleeves and light blue denim shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle vintage and mint-green with a wicker basket holding wildflowers and brown leather handlebars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a row of quaint cottages with whitewashed stone walls, straw roofs, and windows overflowing with red and purple flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03170778602361679 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.531707763671875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03170778602361679, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03170778602361679, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22013846039772034, + 0.14996477961540222, + 0.10152366012334824, + 0.07340524345636368, + 0.06271149218082428, + 0.043392907828092575, + 0.05938422679901123, + 0.06911838054656982, + 0.17630143463611603, + 0.04405941814184189 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03170778602361679 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth tracking shot panning to the right following a cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist a woman with honey-blonde hair tied in a loose ponytail that sways in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist wearing a white linen shirt with rolled-up sleeves and light blue denim shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle vintage and mint-green with a wicker basket holding wildflowers and brown leather handlebars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a row of quaint cottages with whitewashed stone walls, straw roofs, and windows overflowing with red and purple flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020583825185894966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955838680267334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020583825185894966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020583825185894966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37833812832832336, + 0.07890667021274567, + 0.055848121643066406, + 0.0593702606856823, + 0.0353756844997406, + 0.02591647394001484, + 0.0451226606965065, + 0.04420139640569687, + 0.2195749282836914, + 0.05734573304653168 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020583825185894966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth tracking shot panning to the right following a cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist a woman with honey-blonde hair tied in a loose ponytail that sways in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist wearing a white linen shirt with rolled-up sleeves and light blue denim shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle vintage and mint-green with a wicker basket holding wildflowers and brown leather handlebars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a row of quaint cottages with whitewashed stone walls, straw roofs, and windows overflowing with red and purple flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005947866942733526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130948066711426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005947866942733526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005947866942733526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17703565955162048, + 0.06942284852266312, + 0.12891779839992523, + 0.11278460174798965, + 0.1746681183576584, + 0.0665203109383583, + 0.10899771749973297, + 0.045295730233192444, + 0.0551254041492939, + 0.06123184785246849 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005947866942733526 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth tracking shot panning to the right following a cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist a woman with honey-blonde hair tied in a loose ponytail that sways in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist wearing a white linen shirt with rolled-up sleeves and light blue denim shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle vintage and mint-green with a wicker basket holding wildflowers and brown leather handlebars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a row of quaint cottages with whitewashed stone walls, straw roofs, and windows overflowing with red and purple flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014195065014064312 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264194965362549 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014195065014064312, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014195065014064312, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3190723657608032, + 0.04016146436333656, + 0.11656899005174637, + 0.09931665658950806, + 0.027465999126434326, + 0.03072284534573555, + 0.10181012004613876, + 0.06550396978855133, + 0.0888439193367958, + 0.1105336844921112 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014195065014064312 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth tracking shot panning to the right following a cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist a woman with honey-blonde hair tied in a loose ponytail that sways in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist wearing a white linen shirt with rolled-up sleeves and light blue denim shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle vintage and mint-green with a wicker basket holding wildflowers and brown leather handlebars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a row of quaint cottages with whitewashed stone walls, straw roofs, and windows overflowing with red and purple flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01605616696178913 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141056060791016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01605616696178913, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01605616696178913, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17673490941524506, + 0.06718487292528152, + 0.112554632127285, + 0.05742216110229492, + 0.02691558003425598, + 0.03617257624864578, + 0.1676541566848755, + 0.05234222114086151, + 0.13937845826148987, + 0.16364042460918427 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01605616696178913 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, eye-level tracking shot pans smoothly to the right, following a cyclist leisurely along a sun-dappled country road. The cyclist, a woman with honey-blonde hair tied in a loose ponytail that sways gently in the breeze, wears a simple white linen shirt with rolled-up sleeves and light blue denim shorts, a serene, contented smile on her face. She rides a vintage, mint-green bicycle, complete with a wicker basket holding a few wildflowers, brown leather handlebars, and gleaming chrome fenders. Her pedaling rhythm is steady and unhurried, her body swaying gently as she passes a row of picturesque, quaint, storybook-like cottages, characterized by whitewashed stone walls, traditional straw roofs, and small, paneled windows overflowing with vibrant red and purple flowers. The golden afternoon sun filters through the dense canopy of trees, casting a shifting mosaic of bright light and soft shadows on the cyclists and the worn asphalt road, creating a warm, idyllic atmosphere that evokes a sense of tranquility and timeless peace.", + "seed": 10028, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_14/index_312_seed_10028_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.020932532101869582, + "vlm_logprob": -0.020932532101869582, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.020932532101869582, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth tracking shot panning to the right following a cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist a woman with honey-blonde hair tied in a loose ponytail that sways in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist wearing a white linen shirt with rolled-up sleeves and light blue denim shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle vintage and mint-green with a wicker basket holding wildflowers and brown leather handlebars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a row of quaint cottages with whitewashed stone walls, straw roofs, and windows overflowing with red and purple flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03224201127886772 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5322420597076416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03224201127886772, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03224201127886772, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09280853718519211, + 0.05102939158678055, + 0.05020540952682495, + 0.0553077794611454, + 0.43566787242889404, + 0.05648861825466156, + 0.05585699528455734, + 0.1233002096414566, + 0.03528430685400963, + 0.04405082389712334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03224201127886772 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth tracking shot panning to the right following a cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist a woman with honey-blonde hair tied in a loose ponytail that sways in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist wearing a white linen shirt with rolled-up sleeves and light blue denim shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle vintage and mint-green with a wicker basket holding wildflowers and brown leather handlebars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a row of quaint cottages with whitewashed stone walls, straw roofs, and windows overflowing with red and purple flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016064144670963287 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141064167022705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016064144670963287, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016064144670963287, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16774161159992218, + 0.08387792110443115, + 0.04928331449627876, + 0.03333422914147377, + 0.3637597858905792, + 0.07369521260261536, + 0.024647250771522522, + 0.1147959977388382, + 0.040546923875808716, + 0.048317719250917435 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016064144670963287 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth tracking shot panning to the right following a cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist a woman with honey-blonde hair tied in a loose ponytail that sways in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist wearing a white linen shirt with rolled-up sleeves and light blue denim shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle vintage and mint-green with a wicker basket holding wildflowers and brown leather handlebars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a row of quaint cottages with whitewashed stone walls, straw roofs, and windows overflowing with red and purple flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004091820679605007 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504091739654541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004091820679605007, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004091820679605007, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12254688143730164, + 0.06410042196512222, + 0.04878872632980347, + 0.027605868875980377, + 0.45471617579460144, + 0.05504732206463814, + 0.017728809267282486, + 0.12383335828781128, + 0.04759097844362259, + 0.038041453808546066 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004091820679605007 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth tracking shot panning to the right following a cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist a woman with honey-blonde hair tied in a loose ponytail that sways in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist wearing a white linen shirt with rolled-up sleeves and light blue denim shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle vintage and mint-green with a wicker basket holding wildflowers and brown leather handlebars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a row of quaint cottages with whitewashed stone walls, straw roofs, and windows overflowing with red and purple flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014189188368618488 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26418924331665 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014189188368618488, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014189188368618488, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09306249767541885, + 0.04582248255610466, + 0.053411588072776794, + 0.050319038331508636, + 0.5074658393859863, + 0.037409208714962006, + 0.03821105137467384, + 0.10371195524930954, + 0.040988463908433914, + 0.029597889631986618 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014189188368618488 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth tracking shot panning to the right following a cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist a woman with honey-blonde hair tied in a loose ponytail that sways in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist wearing a white linen shirt with rolled-up sleeves and light blue denim shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle vintage and mint-green with a wicker basket holding wildflowers and brown leather handlebars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a row of quaint cottages with whitewashed stone walls, straw roofs, and windows overflowing with red and purple flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03807549551129341 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880754470825195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03807549551129341, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03807549551129341, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09559537470340729, + 0.04970868304371834, + 0.05935744568705559, + 0.08123115450143814, + 0.17054840922355652, + 0.12728236615657806, + 0.06660307198762894, + 0.21570424735546112, + 0.03754458576440811, + 0.09642460942268372 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03807549551129341 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, eye-level tracking shot pans smoothly to the right, following a cyclist leisurely along a sun-dappled country road. The cyclist, a woman with honey-blonde hair tied in a loose ponytail that sways gently in the breeze, wears a simple white linen shirt with rolled-up sleeves and light blue denim shorts, a serene, contented smile on her face. She rides a vintage, mint-green bicycle, complete with a wicker basket holding a few wildflowers, brown leather handlebars, and gleaming chrome fenders. Her pedaling rhythm is steady and unhurried, her body swaying gently as she passes a row of picturesque, quaint, storybook-like cottages, characterized by whitewashed stone walls, traditional straw roofs, and small, paneled windows overflowing with vibrant red and purple flowers. The golden afternoon sun filters through the dense canopy of trees, casting a shifting mosaic of bright light and soft shadows on the cyclists and the worn asphalt road, creating a warm, idyllic atmosphere that evokes a sense of tranquility and timeless peace.", + "seed": 10029, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_14/index_312_seed_10029_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.02434019260108471, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02434019260108471, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02434019260108471, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth tracking shot panning to the right following a cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist a woman with honey-blonde hair tied in a loose ponytail that sways in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist wearing a white linen shirt with rolled-up sleeves and light blue denim shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle vintage and mint-green with a wicker basket holding wildflowers and brown leather handlebars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a row of quaint cottages with whitewashed stone walls, straw roofs, and windows overflowing with red and purple flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06368370354175568 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8136837482452393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06368370354175568, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06368370354175568, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18771937489509583, + 0.10090479254722595, + 0.0563744455575943, + 0.2612535357475281, + 0.033251870423555374, + 0.03992905467748642, + 0.07095328718423843, + 0.05379142239689827, + 0.031510673463344574, + 0.16431155800819397 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06368370354175568 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth tracking shot panning to the right following a cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist a woman with honey-blonde hair tied in a loose ponytail that sways in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist wearing a white linen shirt with rolled-up sleeves and light blue denim shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle vintage and mint-green with a wicker basket holding wildflowers and brown leather handlebars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a row of quaint cottages with whitewashed stone walls, straw roofs, and windows overflowing with red and purple flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020577052608132362 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955769538879395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020577052608132362, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020577052608132362, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21088653802871704, + 0.2484663724899292, + 0.07384496927261353, + 0.033257659524679184, + 0.03831643983721733, + 0.035454507917165756, + 0.06623195856809616, + 0.05150614678859711, + 0.04131704568862915, + 0.20071831345558167 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020577052608132362 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth tracking shot panning to the right following a cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist a woman with honey-blonde hair tied in a loose ponytail that sways in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist wearing a white linen shirt with rolled-up sleeves and light blue denim shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle vintage and mint-green with a wicker basket holding wildflowers and brown leather handlebars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a row of quaint cottages with whitewashed stone walls, straw roofs, and windows overflowing with red and purple flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067337024956941605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067338943481445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067337024956941605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067337024956941605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2418973445892334, + 0.1104428842663765, + 0.055237457156181335, + 0.03841862455010414, + 0.04055684432387352, + 0.046951182186603546, + 0.06593137234449387, + 0.08781319856643677, + 0.08828134089708328, + 0.22446982562541962 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067337024956941605 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth tracking shot panning to the right following a cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist a woman with honey-blonde hair tied in a loose ponytail that sways in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist wearing a white linen shirt with rolled-up sleeves and light blue denim shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle vintage and mint-green with a wicker basket holding wildflowers and brown leather handlebars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a row of quaint cottages with whitewashed stone walls, straw roofs, and windows overflowing with red and purple flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012535588815808296 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387535572052002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012535588815808296, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012535588815808296, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.213191956281662, + 0.16965173184871674, + 0.09617780148983002, + 0.05118468403816223, + 0.03264207765460014, + 0.05939463898539543, + 0.06665648519992828, + 0.0522548072040081, + 0.039376866072416306, + 0.21946893632411957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012535588815808296 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a smooth tracking shot panning to the right following a cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist a woman with honey-blonde hair tied in a loose ponytail that sways in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cyclist wearing a white linen shirt with rolled-up sleeves and light blue denim shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the bicycle vintage and mint-green with a wicker basket holding wildflowers and brown leather handlebars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a row of quaint cottages with whitewashed stone walls, straw roofs, and windows overflowing with red and purple flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01817091554403305 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0181708335876465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01817091554403305, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01817091554403305, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1432008147239685, + 0.22715915739536285, + 0.02696068026125431, + 0.06036585941910744, + 0.04605169966816902, + 0.194366455078125, + 0.0340496264398098, + 0.06629322469234467, + 0.06565394252538681, + 0.13589850068092346 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01817091554403305 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_15/index_tensor([7440, 7440])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_15/index_tensor([7440, 7440])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..51aac6e40c9c0e0a1f73c25a6e6ce7852a7ef796 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_15/index_tensor([7440, 7440])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot captures a woman twirling gracefully across a vast, darkened ice rink, her movements deconstructed by a series of intense strobe flashes. She is a figure skater, her dark hair pulled back into a tight, elegant bun, revealing a face of serene concentration. Each powerful flash captures her unique, hyper-sharp pose during her leisurely spin: her body bends backward with athletic precision, one leg extended high, her arms flowing through a series of graceful gestures. She wears a sleeveless blue velvet skate dress embroidered with countless tiny, shimmering sequins, which bloom with brilliant starlight under the strobe lights. The backdrop, a pure black abyss, ensures the skater is the absolute focal point, while the polished black ice beneath her captures fragmented, momentary reflections. The lighting is central to the scene's drama: powerful, cool white strobes fired in rapid succession create a stark, high-contrast black-and-white effect, sculpting her form with sharp shadows before returning the scene to near-total darkness between each pulse. This staccato rhythm transforms graceful rotations into an artistic study of movement, creating a mesmerizing, dramatic, and intensely focused atmosphere that celebrates the sheer sculptural beauty of the athlete’s body.", + "seed": 30989, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_15/index_7440_seed_30989_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.14233436286449433, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14233436286449433, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14233436286449433, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman figure skater with dark hair pulled back into a tight bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a sleeveless blue velvet dress covered in tiny shimmering sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater perform a leisurely spin with her body bending backward and one leg extended high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense, rapid strobe flashes creating a high-contrast black-and-white effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure black abyss with a polished black ice surface reflecting the skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04330703988671303 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168307065963745 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04330703988671303, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04330703988671303, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10104940831661224, + 0.05551063269376755, + 0.020831363275647163, + 0.04355510324239731, + 0.4532870352268219, + 0.10678814351558685, + 0.08806174248456955, + 0.05146084725856781, + 0.03993687033653259, + 0.039518848061561584 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04330703988671303 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman figure skater with dark hair pulled back into a tight bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a sleeveless blue velvet dress covered in tiny shimmering sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater perform a leisurely spin with her body bending backward and one leg extended high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense, rapid strobe flashes creating a high-contrast black-and-white effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure black abyss with a polished black ice surface reflecting the skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038109004497528076 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288109064102173 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038109004497528076, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038109004497528076, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10348592698574066, + 0.05284847691655159, + 0.05607479065656662, + 0.07812931388616562, + 0.4128599464893341, + 0.12777768075466156, + 0.04726751893758774, + 0.03881916031241417, + 0.03360699862241745, + 0.04913020879030228 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038109004497528076 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman figure skater with dark hair pulled back into a tight bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a sleeveless blue velvet dress covered in tiny shimmering sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater perform a leisurely spin with her body bending backward and one leg extended high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense, rapid strobe flashes creating a high-contrast black-and-white effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure black abyss with a polished black ice surface reflecting the skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306088760495186 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168060779571533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306088760495186, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306088760495186, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13376188278198242, + 0.0775061845779419, + 0.08812974393367767, + 0.1118328720331192, + 0.19522732496261597, + 0.11205974966287613, + 0.10294697433710098, + 0.07583582401275635, + 0.05333530157804489, + 0.04936414957046509 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306088760495186 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman figure skater with dark hair pulled back into a tight bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a sleeveless blue velvet dress covered in tiny shimmering sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater perform a leisurely spin with her body bending backward and one leg extended high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense, rapid strobe flashes creating a high-contrast black-and-white effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure black abyss with a polished black ice surface reflecting the skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11291860789060593 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379186153411865 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11291860789060593, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11291860789060593, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.062301140278577805, + 0.02791789174079895, + 0.025210630148649216, + 0.05507202073931694, + 0.6754720211029053, + 0.04500040039420128, + 0.026374679058790207, + 0.01652618683874607, + 0.020449697971343994, + 0.04567529633641243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11291860789060593 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman figure skater with dark hair pulled back into a tight bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a sleeveless blue velvet dress covered in tiny shimmering sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater perform a leisurely spin with her body bending backward and one leg extended high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense, rapid strobe flashes creating a high-contrast black-and-white effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure black abyss with a polished black ice surface reflecting the skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47427627444267273 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742763042449951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47427627444267273, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47427627444267273, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0726105347275734, + 0.06937382370233536, + 0.03981734439730644, + 0.04315616190433502, + 0.12540826201438904, + 0.2724241018295288, + 0.027060162276029587, + 0.0866394191980362, + 0.04309941828250885, + 0.22041071951389313 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47427627444267273 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot captures a woman twirling gracefully across a vast, darkened ice rink, her movements deconstructed by a series of intense strobe flashes. She is a figure skater, her dark hair pulled back into a tight, elegant bun, revealing a face of serene concentration. Each powerful flash captures her unique, hyper-sharp pose during her leisurely spin: her body bends backward with athletic precision, one leg extended high, her arms flowing through a series of graceful gestures. She wears a sleeveless blue velvet skate dress embroidered with countless tiny, shimmering sequins, which bloom with brilliant starlight under the strobe lights. The backdrop, a pure black abyss, ensures the skater is the absolute focal point, while the polished black ice beneath her captures fragmented, momentary reflections. The lighting is central to the scene's drama: powerful, cool white strobes fired in rapid succession create a stark, high-contrast black-and-white effect, sculpting her form with sharp shadows before returning the scene to near-total darkness between each pulse. This staccato rhythm transforms graceful rotations into an artistic study of movement, creating a mesmerizing, dramatic, and intensely focused atmosphere that celebrates the sheer sculptural beauty of the athlete’s body.", + "seed": 30990, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_15/index_7440_seed_30990_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.1338764786720276, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1338764786720276, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1338764786720276, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman figure skater with dark hair pulled back into a tight bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a sleeveless blue velvet dress covered in tiny shimmering sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater perform a leisurely spin with her body bending backward and one leg extended high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense, rapid strobe flashes creating a high-contrast black-and-white effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure black abyss with a polished black ice surface reflecting the skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04344401881098747 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1684439182281494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04344401881098747, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04344401881098747, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1759747415781021, + 0.10775385797023773, + 0.08165322244167328, + 0.1097649559378624, + 0.058943428099155426, + 0.05686024948954582, + 0.13026559352874756, + 0.1060253158211708, + 0.04654524475336075, + 0.12621331214904785 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04344401881098747 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman figure skater with dark hair pulled back into a tight bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a sleeveless blue velvet dress covered in tiny shimmering sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater perform a leisurely spin with her body bending backward and one leg extended high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense, rapid strobe flashes creating a high-contrast black-and-white effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure black abyss with a polished black ice surface reflecting the skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029819611459970474 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298197269439697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029819611459970474, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029819611459970474, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24937357008457184, + 0.07561676949262619, + 0.04545718431472778, + 0.09644774347543716, + 0.05019209533929825, + 0.12032202631235123, + 0.06821582466363907, + 0.05307324230670929, + 0.04558929055929184, + 0.19571225345134735 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029819611459970474 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman figure skater with dark hair pulled back into a tight bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a sleeveless blue velvet dress covered in tiny shimmering sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater perform a leisurely spin with her body bending backward and one leg extended high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense, rapid strobe flashes creating a high-contrast black-and-white effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure black abyss with a polished black ice surface reflecting the skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048655346035957336 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486552715301514 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048655346035957336, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048655346035957336, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07231447100639343, + 0.11124391853809357, + 0.15909849107265472, + 0.1776530146598816, + 0.10158534348011017, + 0.09675667434930801, + 0.0340728722512722, + 0.11522836238145828, + 0.033927012234926224, + 0.09811976552009583 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048655346035957336 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman figure skater with dark hair pulled back into a tight bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a sleeveless blue velvet dress covered in tiny shimmering sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater perform a leisurely spin with her body bending backward and one leg extended high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense, rapid strobe flashes creating a high-contrast black-and-white effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure black abyss with a polished black ice surface reflecting the skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16036200523376465 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103620052337646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16036200523376465, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16036200523376465, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1536029726266861, + 0.05066290870308876, + 0.07509505748748779, + 0.13588538765907288, + 0.032160092145204544, + 0.11805255711078644, + 0.034401364624500275, + 0.10125745087862015, + 0.06617981940507889, + 0.23270240426063538 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16036200523376465 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman figure skater with dark hair pulled back into a tight bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a sleeveless blue velvet dress covered in tiny shimmering sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater perform a leisurely spin with her body bending backward and one leg extended high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense, rapid strobe flashes creating a high-contrast black-and-white effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure black abyss with a polished black ice surface reflecting the skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.387101411819458 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137101411819458 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.387101411819458, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.387101411819458, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09880430996417999, + 0.0683150663971901, + 0.042807191610336304, + 0.2809554636478424, + 0.0414767861366272, + 0.11682622134685516, + 0.07317579537630081, + 0.041085951030254364, + 0.16442979872226715, + 0.07212336361408234 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.387101411819458 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot captures a woman twirling gracefully across a vast, darkened ice rink, her movements deconstructed by a series of intense strobe flashes. She is a figure skater, her dark hair pulled back into a tight, elegant bun, revealing a face of serene concentration. Each powerful flash captures her unique, hyper-sharp pose during her leisurely spin: her body bends backward with athletic precision, one leg extended high, her arms flowing through a series of graceful gestures. She wears a sleeveless blue velvet skate dress embroidered with countless tiny, shimmering sequins, which bloom with brilliant starlight under the strobe lights. The backdrop, a pure black abyss, ensures the skater is the absolute focal point, while the polished black ice beneath her captures fragmented, momentary reflections. The lighting is central to the scene's drama: powerful, cool white strobes fired in rapid succession create a stark, high-contrast black-and-white effect, sculpting her form with sharp shadows before returning the scene to near-total darkness between each pulse. This staccato rhythm transforms graceful rotations into an artistic study of movement, creating a mesmerizing, dramatic, and intensely focused atmosphere that celebrates the sheer sculptural beauty of the athlete’s body.", + "seed": 30991, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_15/index_7440_seed_30991_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.019360233470797537, + "vlm_logprob": -0.019360233470797537, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.019360233470797537, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman figure skater with dark hair pulled back into a tight bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a sleeveless blue velvet dress covered in tiny shimmering sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater perform a leisurely spin with her body bending backward and one leg extended high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense, rapid strobe flashes creating a high-contrast black-and-white effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure black abyss with a polished black ice surface reflecting the skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011418350040912628 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511418342590332 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011418350040912628, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011418350040912628, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10858875513076782, + 0.2506597638130188, + 0.11315236240625381, + 0.08731646835803986, + 0.037347760051488876, + 0.0809907391667366, + 0.030321938917040825, + 0.08441898226737976, + 0.11733226478099823, + 0.089870885014534 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011418350040912628 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman figure skater with dark hair pulled back into a tight bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a sleeveless blue velvet dress covered in tiny shimmering sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater perform a leisurely spin with her body bending backward and one leg extended high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense, rapid strobe flashes creating a high-contrast black-and-white effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure black abyss with a polished black ice surface reflecting the skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014208580367267132 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264208793640137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014208580367267132, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014208580367267132, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11264989525079727, + 0.22646167874336243, + 0.07664050161838531, + 0.1344539225101471, + 0.04693234711885452, + 0.05947712063789368, + 0.019695186987519264, + 0.05275837704539299, + 0.09556926041841507, + 0.17536167800426483 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014208580367267132 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman figure skater with dark hair pulled back into a tight bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a sleeveless blue velvet dress covered in tiny shimmering sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater perform a leisurely spin with her body bending backward and one leg extended high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense, rapid strobe flashes creating a high-contrast black-and-white effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure black abyss with a polished black ice surface reflecting the skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026347937062382698 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513478755950928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026347937062382698, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026347937062382698, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1671498864889145, + 0.06791609525680542, + 0.05911437049508095, + 0.15851597487926483, + 0.09178230911493301, + 0.15886282920837402, + 0.051329631358385086, + 0.06526432186365128, + 0.09007792919874191, + 0.08998662978410721 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026347937062382698 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman figure skater with dark hair pulled back into a tight bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a sleeveless blue velvet dress covered in tiny shimmering sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater perform a leisurely spin with her body bending backward and one leg extended high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense, rapid strobe flashes creating a high-contrast black-and-white effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure black abyss with a polished black ice surface reflecting the skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0380924791097641 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880923748016357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0380924791097641, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0380924791097641, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1397986114025116, + 0.2485320270061493, + 0.10638981312513351, + 0.1858895719051361, + 0.024701785296201706, + 0.10979987680912018, + 0.05065491423010826, + 0.04891446232795715, + 0.03339285030961037, + 0.05192611739039421 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0380924791097641 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman figure skater with dark hair pulled back into a tight bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a sleeveless blue velvet dress covered in tiny shimmering sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater perform a leisurely spin with her body bending backward and one leg extended high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense, rapid strobe flashes creating a high-contrast black-and-white effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure black abyss with a polished black ice surface reflecting the skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006733820773661137 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067338943481445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006733820773661137, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006733820773661137, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09209776669740677, + 0.24238185584545135, + 0.21083612740039825, + 0.08970954269170761, + 0.04497155547142029, + 0.10070879012346268, + 0.08337613940238953, + 0.02232377417385578, + 0.0950731560587883, + 0.01852128654718399 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006733820773661137 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot captures a woman twirling gracefully across a vast, darkened ice rink, her movements deconstructed by a series of intense strobe flashes. She is a figure skater, her dark hair pulled back into a tight, elegant bun, revealing a face of serene concentration. Each powerful flash captures her unique, hyper-sharp pose during her leisurely spin: her body bends backward with athletic precision, one leg extended high, her arms flowing through a series of graceful gestures. She wears a sleeveless blue velvet skate dress embroidered with countless tiny, shimmering sequins, which bloom with brilliant starlight under the strobe lights. The backdrop, a pure black abyss, ensures the skater is the absolute focal point, while the polished black ice beneath her captures fragmented, momentary reflections. The lighting is central to the scene's drama: powerful, cool white strobes fired in rapid succession create a stark, high-contrast black-and-white effect, sculpting her form with sharp shadows before returning the scene to near-total darkness between each pulse. This staccato rhythm transforms graceful rotations into an artistic study of movement, creating a mesmerizing, dramatic, and intensely focused atmosphere that celebrates the sheer sculptural beauty of the athlete’s body.", + "seed": 30992, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_15/index_7440_seed_30992_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04115467518568039, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04115467518568039, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04115467518568039, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman figure skater with dark hair pulled back into a tight bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a sleeveless blue velvet dress covered in tiny shimmering sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater perform a leisurely spin with her body bending backward and one leg extended high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense, rapid strobe flashes creating a high-contrast black-and-white effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure black abyss with a polished black ice surface reflecting the skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03009495697915554 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.530094861984253 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03009495697915554, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03009495697915554, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17868845164775848, + 0.07115837931632996, + 0.023224201053380966, + 0.11208125948905945, + 0.11991782486438751, + 0.06748092919588089, + 0.06702617555856705, + 0.08590690791606903, + 0.17453540861606598, + 0.09998046606779099 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03009495697915554 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman figure skater with dark hair pulled back into a tight bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a sleeveless blue velvet dress covered in tiny shimmering sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater perform a leisurely spin with her body bending backward and one leg extended high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense, rapid strobe flashes creating a high-contrast black-and-white effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure black abyss with a polished black ice surface reflecting the skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023304728791117668 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733047008514404 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023304728791117668, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023304728791117668, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07283783704042435, + 0.05777948349714279, + 0.024540357291698456, + 0.1076439768075943, + 0.10908269137144089, + 0.045573554933071136, + 0.07773441821336746, + 0.07111024856567383, + 0.3793826103210449, + 0.05431482195854187 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023304728791117668 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman figure skater with dark hair pulled back into a tight bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a sleeveless blue velvet dress covered in tiny shimmering sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater perform a leisurely spin with her body bending backward and one leg extended high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense, rapid strobe flashes creating a high-contrast black-and-white effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure black abyss with a polished black ice surface reflecting the skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369821608066559 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408698320388794 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369821608066559, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369821608066559, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05372832715511322, + 0.031114259734749794, + 0.016459451988339424, + 0.0581478625535965, + 0.08554472029209137, + 0.10505326092243195, + 0.12887217104434967, + 0.040625978261232376, + 0.45735183358192444, + 0.023102188482880592 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369821608066559 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman figure skater with dark hair pulled back into a tight bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a sleeveless blue velvet dress covered in tiny shimmering sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater perform a leisurely spin with her body bending backward and one leg extended high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense, rapid strobe flashes creating a high-contrast black-and-white effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure black abyss with a polished black ice surface reflecting the skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864898696541786 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486490726470947 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864898696541786, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864898696541786, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1141737550497055, + 0.06369047611951828, + 0.035779714584350586, + 0.028593219816684723, + 0.05071001499891281, + 0.06522917002439499, + 0.15481191873550415, + 0.20681999623775482, + 0.23495855927467346, + 0.04523307830095291 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864898696541786 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman figure skater with dark hair pulled back into a tight bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skater wearing a sleeveless blue velvet dress covered in tiny shimmering sequins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the skater perform a leisurely spin with her body bending backward and one leg extended high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by intense, rapid strobe flashes creating a high-contrast black-and-white effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure black abyss with a polished black ice surface reflecting the skater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002648711204529 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695026397705078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002648711204529, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002648711204529, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09162451326847076, + 0.024601737037301064, + 0.042387720197439194, + 0.02136947214603424, + 0.0920519307255745, + 0.13023193180561066, + 0.17160680890083313, + 0.05728355050086975, + 0.2624465823173523, + 0.10639577358961105 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002648711204529 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_2/index_tensor([9557, 9557])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_2/index_tensor([9557, 9557])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..606b9703e67667b68262669ad26d4ef84ffbe3aa --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_2/index_tensor([9557, 9557])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up, static shot, shot slightly up from eye level with the character, evokes the innocent style of a child's sketch. The background is a textured off-white drawing paper, illuminated by a bright, even, soft light. In the center, a toy soldier, embodied by a G36K rifle, is outlined with rough, twisted black crayon lines. The rifle's barrel forms its torso, while the buttstock and barrel serve as legs. It bends forward in a concerned gesture. Before it, a chubby bear toy lies on the ground, unevenly filled in with the same childish brown crayon. One of its eyes is drawn as a button, the other a simple 'X', giving it a lovable, worn-out look. The G36K soldier carefully extends an arm, embodied by a magazine, and steadily and gently grasps one of the bear's paws, attempting to lift it from the ground. A few simple green vertical lines represent grass at the bottom of the drawing paper. Through such naive lines and simple colors, the entire scene creates a pure and warm atmosphere of friendship that transcends species and images, and is full of touching childlike fun.", + "seed": 29456, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_2/index_9557_seed_29456_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.027613453194499017, + "vlm_logprob": -0.027613453194499017, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.027613453194499017, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a child's sketch using rough, twisted black crayon lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured off-white drawing paper illuminated by bright, even, soft light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a toy soldier figure outlined with a G36K rifle, where the barrel forms the torso and the buttstock/barrel serve as legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a chubby bear toy lying on the ground with one eye drawn as a button and the other as a simple 'X'?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the soldier extend an arm embodied by a magazine to gently grasp one of the bear's paws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010346820577979088 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.01034688949585 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010346820577979088, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010346820577979088, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22525721788406372, + 0.13681252300739288, + 0.07346008718013763, + 0.06009051948785782, + 0.0561106912791729, + 0.04080864414572716, + 0.190097376704216, + 0.0931258499622345, + 0.06306732445955276, + 0.06116976588964462 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010346820577979088 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a child's sketch using rough, twisted black crayon lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured off-white drawing paper illuminated by bright, even, soft light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a toy soldier figure outlined with a G36K rifle, where the barrel forms the torso and the buttstock/barrel serve as legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a chubby bear toy lying on the ground with one eye drawn as a button and the other as a simple 'X'?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the soldier extend an arm embodied by a magazine to gently grasp one of the bear's paws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865296185016632 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486528873443604 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865296185016632, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865296185016632, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19871054589748383, + 0.11854518949985504, + 0.20061896741390228, + 0.031771499663591385, + 0.050391923636198044, + 0.04530205950140953, + 0.194835364818573, + 0.06762959063053131, + 0.03783838450908661, + 0.054356496781110764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865296185016632 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a child's sketch using rough, twisted black crayon lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured off-white drawing paper illuminated by bright, even, soft light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a toy soldier figure outlined with a G36K rifle, where the barrel forms the torso and the buttstock/barrel serve as legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a chubby bear toy lying on the ground with one eye drawn as a button and the other as a simple 'X'?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the soldier extend an arm embodied by a magazine to gently grasp one of the bear's paws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818426139652729 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018184185028076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818426139652729, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818426139652729, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1595257818698883, + 0.1271853893995285, + 0.2306322306394577, + 0.04401258006691933, + 0.06701267510652542, + 0.05986981466412544, + 0.09079089760780334, + 0.09535705298185349, + 0.08205068111419678, + 0.0435628779232502 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818426139652729 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a child's sketch using rough, twisted black crayon lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured off-white drawing paper illuminated by bright, even, soft light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a toy soldier figure outlined with a G36K rifle, where the barrel forms the torso and the buttstock/barrel serve as legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a chubby bear toy lying on the ground with one eye drawn as a button and the other as a simple 'X'?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the soldier extend an arm embodied by a magazine to gently grasp one of the bear's paws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005945852026343346 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130945682525635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005945852026343346, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005945852026343346, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13620257377624512, + 0.09090821444988251, + 0.22373291850090027, + 0.07753351330757141, + 0.054087117314338684, + 0.1056251972913742, + 0.13719959557056427, + 0.07079585641622543, + 0.0499386340379715, + 0.05397629737854004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005945852026343346 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a child's sketch using rough, twisted black crayon lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured off-white drawing paper illuminated by bright, even, soft light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a toy soldier figure outlined with a G36K rifle, where the barrel forms the torso and the buttstock/barrel serve as legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a chubby bear toy lying on the ground with one eye drawn as a button and the other as a simple 'X'?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the soldier extend an arm embodied by a magazine to gently grasp one of the bear's paws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054937370121479034 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299373626708984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054937370121479034, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054937370121479034, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21835371851921082, + 0.17540961503982544, + 0.16402661800384521, + 0.053012214601039886, + 0.08976054191589355, + 0.06269419938325882, + 0.08858504891395569, + 0.02972918003797531, + 0.0724676176905632, + 0.04596123471856117 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054937370121479034 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, static shot, shot slightly up from eye level with the character, evokes the innocent style of a child's sketch. The background is a textured off-white drawing paper, illuminated by a bright, even, soft light. In the center, a toy soldier, embodied by a G36K rifle, is outlined with rough, twisted black crayon lines. The rifle's barrel forms its torso, while the buttstock and barrel serve as legs. It bends forward in a concerned gesture. Before it, a chubby bear toy lies on the ground, unevenly filled in with the same childish brown crayon. One of its eyes is drawn as a button, the other a simple 'X', giving it a lovable, worn-out look. The G36K soldier carefully extends an arm, embodied by a magazine, and steadily and gently grasps one of the bear's paws, attempting to lift it from the ground. A few simple green vertical lines represent grass at the bottom of the drawing paper. Through such naive lines and simple colors, the entire scene creates a pure and warm atmosphere of friendship that transcends species and images, and is full of touching childlike fun.", + "seed": 29457, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_2/index_9557_seed_29457_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07766358451917768, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07766358451917768, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07766358451917768, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a child's sketch using rough, twisted black crayon lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured off-white drawing paper illuminated by bright, even, soft light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a toy soldier figure outlined with a G36K rifle, where the barrel forms the torso and the buttstock/barrel serve as legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a chubby bear toy lying on the ground with one eye drawn as a button and the other as a simple 'X'?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the soldier extend an arm embodied by a magazine to gently grasp one of the bear's paws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16127419471740723 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9112741947174072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16127419471740723, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16127419471740723, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2503652572631836, + 0.0759182944893837, + 0.06661880761384964, + 0.08753737807273865, + 0.03935316205024719, + 0.06917070597410202, + 0.08978651463985443, + 0.04710179939866066, + 0.19746710360050201, + 0.0766809955239296 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16127419471740723 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a child's sketch using rough, twisted black crayon lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured off-white drawing paper illuminated by bright, even, soft light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a toy soldier figure outlined with a G36K rifle, where the barrel forms the torso and the buttstock/barrel serve as legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a chubby bear toy lying on the ground with one eye drawn as a button and the other as a simple 'X'?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the soldier extend an arm embodied by a magazine to gently grasp one of the bear's paws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003548741340637 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695035457611084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003548741340637, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003548741340637, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22028912603855133, + 0.11742422729730606, + 0.09415140748023987, + 0.06499747186899185, + 0.06092021241784096, + 0.08775455504655838, + 0.09597312659025192, + 0.040125925093889236, + 0.11972362548112869, + 0.0986403375864029 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003548741340637 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a child's sketch using rough, twisted black crayon lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured off-white drawing paper illuminated by bright, even, soft light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a toy soldier figure outlined with a G36K rifle, where the barrel forms the torso and the buttstock/barrel serve as legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a chubby bear toy lying on the ground with one eye drawn as a button and the other as a simple 'X'?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the soldier extend an arm embodied by a magazine to gently grasp one of the bear's paws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06203136593103409 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120312690734863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06203136593103409, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06203136593103409, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25032028555870056, + 0.13539786636829376, + 0.09336493909358978, + 0.08170999586582184, + 0.04472017660737038, + 0.03881080821156502, + 0.06266264617443085, + 0.07028823345899582, + 0.15196041762828827, + 0.07076466828584671 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06203136593103409 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a child's sketch using rough, twisted black crayon lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured off-white drawing paper illuminated by bright, even, soft light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a toy soldier figure outlined with a G36K rifle, where the barrel forms the torso and the buttstock/barrel serve as legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a chubby bear toy lying on the ground with one eye drawn as a button and the other as a simple 'X'?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the soldier extend an arm embodied by a magazine to gently grasp one of the bear's paws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005943956319242716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130943775177002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005943956319242716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005943956319242716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21054142713546753, + 0.12029211968183517, + 0.06877042353153229, + 0.12107200175523758, + 0.08530034869909286, + 0.09542234241962433, + 0.059270862489938736, + 0.055954426527023315, + 0.10762423276901245, + 0.07575184851884842 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005943956319242716 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a child's sketch using rough, twisted black crayon lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured off-white drawing paper illuminated by bright, even, soft light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a toy soldier figure outlined with a G36K rifle, where the barrel forms the torso and the buttstock/barrel serve as legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a chubby bear toy lying on the ground with one eye drawn as a button and the other as a simple 'X'?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the soldier extend an arm embodied by a magazine to gently grasp one of the bear's paws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08903291821479797 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640328884124756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08903291821479797, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08903291821479797, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17409662902355194, + 0.30580440163612366, + 0.06861509382724762, + 0.148512601852417, + 0.06545896083116531, + 0.046390801668167114, + 0.037259601056575775, + 0.034241970628499985, + 0.08271647244691849, + 0.03690347075462341 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08903291821479797 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, static shot, shot slightly up from eye level with the character, evokes the innocent style of a child's sketch. The background is a textured off-white drawing paper, illuminated by a bright, even, soft light. In the center, a toy soldier, embodied by a G36K rifle, is outlined with rough, twisted black crayon lines. The rifle's barrel forms its torso, while the buttstock and barrel serve as legs. It bends forward in a concerned gesture. Before it, a chubby bear toy lies on the ground, unevenly filled in with the same childish brown crayon. One of its eyes is drawn as a button, the other a simple 'X', giving it a lovable, worn-out look. The G36K soldier carefully extends an arm, embodied by a magazine, and steadily and gently grasps one of the bear's paws, attempting to lift it from the ground. A few simple green vertical lines represent grass at the bottom of the drawing paper. Through such naive lines and simple colors, the entire scene creates a pure and warm atmosphere of friendship that transcends species and images, and is full of touching childlike fun.", + "seed": 29458, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_2/index_9557_seed_29458_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.030976862460374833, + "vlm_logprob": -0.030976862460374833, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.030976862460374833, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a child's sketch using rough, twisted black crayon lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured off-white drawing paper illuminated by bright, even, soft light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a toy soldier figure outlined with a G36K rifle, where the barrel forms the torso and the buttstock/barrel serve as legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a chubby bear toy lying on the ground with one eye drawn as a button and the other as a simple 'X'?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the soldier extend an arm embodied by a magazine to gently grasp one of the bear's paws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012965896166861057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.637965679168701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012965896166861057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012965896166861057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1996590495109558, + 0.13327346742153168, + 0.03331654146313667, + 0.0422939658164978, + 0.025375472381711006, + 0.08796986192464828, + 0.18717025220394135, + 0.11230865120887756, + 0.10326576977968216, + 0.0753670483827591 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012965896166861057 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a child's sketch using rough, twisted black crayon lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured off-white drawing paper illuminated by bright, even, soft light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a toy soldier figure outlined with a G36K rifle, where the barrel forms the torso and the buttstock/barrel serve as legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a chubby bear toy lying on the ground with one eye drawn as a button and the other as a simple 'X'?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the soldier extend an arm embodied by a magazine to gently grasp one of the bear's paws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370628505945206 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087061882019043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370628505945206, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370628505945206, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19603228569030762, + 0.08151456713676453, + 0.06069757416844368, + 0.0441800057888031, + 0.05229983106255531, + 0.13403405249118805, + 0.19423078000545502, + 0.1151375100016594, + 0.07370062917470932, + 0.048172760754823685 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370628505945206 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a child's sketch using rough, twisted black crayon lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured off-white drawing paper illuminated by bright, even, soft light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a toy soldier figure outlined with a G36K rifle, where the barrel forms the torso and the buttstock/barrel serve as legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a chubby bear toy lying on the ground with one eye drawn as a button and the other as a simple 'X'?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the soldier extend an arm embodied by a magazine to gently grasp one of the bear's paws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023289471864700317 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773289442062378 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023289471864700317, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023289471864700317, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2107771933078766, + 0.15848608314990997, + 0.05687538534402847, + 0.04015630856156349, + 0.033924032002687454, + 0.09724505245685577, + 0.18795791268348694, + 0.05672837048768997, + 0.05514725297689438, + 0.10270243138074875 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023289471864700317 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a child's sketch using rough, twisted black crayon lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured off-white drawing paper illuminated by bright, even, soft light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a toy soldier figure outlined with a G36K rifle, where the barrel forms the torso and the buttstock/barrel serve as legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a chubby bear toy lying on the ground with one eye drawn as a button and the other as a simple 'X'?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the soldier extend an arm embodied by a magazine to gently grasp one of the bear's paws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005946326069533825 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130946159362793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005946326069533825, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005946326069533825, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13706712424755096, + 0.11391782015562057, + 0.08678430318832397, + 0.048948757350444794, + 0.05814133211970329, + 0.16169410943984985, + 0.1784566044807434, + 0.0788482055068016, + 0.05137365683913231, + 0.08476805686950684 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005946326069533825 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a child's sketch using rough, twisted black crayon lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured off-white drawing paper illuminated by bright, even, soft light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a toy soldier figure outlined with a G36K rifle, where the barrel forms the torso and the buttstock/barrel serve as legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a chubby bear toy lying on the ground with one eye drawn as a button and the other as a simple 'X'?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the soldier extend an arm embodied by a magazine to gently grasp one of the bear's paws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0789763331413269 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789763927459717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0789763331413269, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0789763331413269, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16839957237243652, + 0.10753490030765533, + 0.058634236454963684, + 0.051221393048763275, + 0.052322614938020706, + 0.11722467839717865, + 0.14772626757621765, + 0.20424160361289978, + 0.05898661911487579, + 0.03370813652873039 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0789763331413269 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, static shot, shot slightly up from eye level with the character, evokes the innocent style of a child's sketch. The background is a textured off-white drawing paper, illuminated by a bright, even, soft light. In the center, a toy soldier, embodied by a G36K rifle, is outlined with rough, twisted black crayon lines. The rifle's barrel forms its torso, while the buttstock and barrel serve as legs. It bends forward in a concerned gesture. Before it, a chubby bear toy lies on the ground, unevenly filled in with the same childish brown crayon. One of its eyes is drawn as a button, the other a simple 'X', giving it a lovable, worn-out look. The G36K soldier carefully extends an arm, embodied by a magazine, and steadily and gently grasps one of the bear's paws, attempting to lift it from the ground. A few simple green vertical lines represent grass at the bottom of the drawing paper. Through such naive lines and simple colors, the entire scene creates a pure and warm atmosphere of friendship that transcends species and images, and is full of touching childlike fun.", + "seed": 29459, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_2/index_9557_seed_29459_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03655597735196352, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03655597735196352, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03655597735196352, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a child's sketch using rough, twisted black crayon lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured off-white drawing paper illuminated by bright, even, soft light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a toy soldier figure outlined with a G36K rifle, where the barrel forms the torso and the buttstock/barrel serve as legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a chubby bear toy lying on the ground with one eye drawn as a button and the other as a simple 'X'?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the soldier extend an arm embodied by a magazine to gently grasp one of the bear's paws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023372741416096687 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8983726501464844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023372741416096687, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023372741416096687, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28205248713493347, + 0.06936375796794891, + 0.12401339411735535, + 0.02378736063838005, + 0.0879441499710083, + 0.046598199754953384, + 0.07884582132101059, + 0.12195644527673721, + 0.02972438745200634, + 0.13571402430534363 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023372741416096687 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a child's sketch using rough, twisted black crayon lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured off-white drawing paper illuminated by bright, even, soft light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a toy soldier figure outlined with a G36K rifle, where the barrel forms the torso and the buttstock/barrel serve as legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a chubby bear toy lying on the ground with one eye drawn as a button and the other as a simple 'X'?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the soldier extend an arm embodied by a magazine to gently grasp one of the bear's paws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043071165680885315 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680712699890137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043071165680885315, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043071165680885315, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18680864572525024, + 0.1554311364889145, + 0.07973272353410721, + 0.04296974465250969, + 0.054186321794986725, + 0.05309322476387024, + 0.13388916850090027, + 0.06642100214958191, + 0.13405047357082367, + 0.09341754764318466 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043071165680885315 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a child's sketch using rough, twisted black crayon lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured off-white drawing paper illuminated by bright, even, soft light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a toy soldier figure outlined with a G36K rifle, where the barrel forms the torso and the buttstock/barrel serve as legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a chubby bear toy lying on the ground with one eye drawn as a button and the other as a simple 'X'?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the soldier extend an arm embodied by a magazine to gently grasp one of the bear's paws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057635225355625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895576238632202 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057635225355625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057635225355625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10620080679655075, + 0.12293462455272675, + 0.08492664247751236, + 0.0792766883969307, + 0.05310572683811188, + 0.2503352463245392, + 0.10269292443990707, + 0.07594259828329086, + 0.04651407152414322, + 0.07807066291570663 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057635225355625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a child's sketch using rough, twisted black crayon lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured off-white drawing paper illuminated by bright, even, soft light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a toy soldier figure outlined with a G36K rifle, where the barrel forms the torso and the buttstock/barrel serve as legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a chubby bear toy lying on the ground with one eye drawn as a button and the other as a simple 'X'?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the soldier extend an arm embodied by a magazine to gently grasp one of the bear's paws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006732163019478321 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006731986999512 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006732163019478321, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006732163019478321, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10510876029729843, + 0.10904018580913544, + 0.20914921164512634, + 0.09015396982431412, + 0.1153964102268219, + 0.04435800388455391, + 0.06941834837198257, + 0.04108574613928795, + 0.11697107553482056, + 0.09931826591491699 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006732163019478321 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with a child's sketch using rough, twisted black crayon lines?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a textured off-white drawing paper illuminated by bright, even, soft light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a toy soldier figure outlined with a G36K rifle, where the barrel forms the torso and the buttstock/barrel serve as legs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a chubby bear toy lying on the ground with one eye drawn as a button and the other as a simple 'X'?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the soldier extend an arm embodied by a magazine to gently grasp one of the bear's paws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08902746438980103 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640274047851562 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08902746438980103, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08902746438980103, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1773819476366043, + 0.12360750883817673, + 0.10642237961292267, + 0.09798324853181839, + 0.05418815836310387, + 0.05350271984934807, + 0.0606091283261776, + 0.08055347949266434, + 0.11736063659191132, + 0.12839077413082123 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08902746438980103 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_3/index_tensor([7478, 7478])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_3/index_tensor([7478, 7478])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b05f31a36f0846c99c2c45b10cbe3d0d9c35aef4 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_3/index_tensor([7478, 7478])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow-motion camera, shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly zooms into a vast, heavy industrial factory floor. Beneath the soaring ceiling, thick steel beams and pipes crisscross. Several high-hanging industrial lights cast cold, intense beams, forming distinct paths through the air thick with a faint wisp of dust. At the center of the frame, an unfinished tank turret dominates with its imposing mass. Composed of thick, angular, dark gray metal armor, each massive hexagonal bolt and neat rows of round rivets are clearly visible under the cold light, embodying an unparalleled sense of industrial might. Several workers, dressed in heavy, oily dark blue overalls and wearing yellow hard hats, work collaboratively around the turret. One of them crouches, steadily and precisely manipulating a welding torch along a seam in the armor. In an instant, a dazzling cascade of white and orange sparks erupts, briefly illuminating his focused face and the surrounding metal before scattering like meteors onto the concrete floor below. Next to him, another worker leaned forward, decisively and forcefully tightening a bolt on the side with a large pneumatic wrench, emitting a high-pitched mechanical sound. Amidst the constant industrial noise and flying sparks, the entire scene exuded an atmosphere of tension, focus, and creativity, replete with the stark contrast between the cold texture of metal and the fiery energy of welding.", + "seed": 10415, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_3/index_7478_seed_10415_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.027861604187637567, + "vlm_logprob": -0.027861604187637567, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.027861604187637567, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an unfinished tank turret composed of dark gray metal armor with visible hexagonal bolts and round rivets at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are workers wearing heavy dark blue overalls and yellow hard hats visible working around the turret?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one worker crouching and manipulating a welding torch that erupts with a cascade of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is another worker leaning forward and tightening a bolt on the turret with a large pneumatic wrench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.041244152933359146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2912442684173584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.041244152933359146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.041244152933359146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07488711923360825, + 0.0983523577451706, + 0.042688947170972824, + 0.044115956872701645, + 0.09042053669691086, + 0.10754366219043732, + 0.07910259068012238, + 0.11279262602329254, + 0.05158935859799385, + 0.2985069155693054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.041244152933359146 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an unfinished tank turret composed of dark gray metal armor with visible hexagonal bolts and round rivets at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are workers wearing heavy dark blue overalls and yellow hard hats visible working around the turret?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one worker crouching and manipulating a welding torch that erupts with a cascade of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is another worker leaning forward and tightening a bolt on the turret with a large pneumatic wrench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01821797341108322 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018218040466309 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01821797341108322, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01821797341108322, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10027964413166046, + 0.2854120135307312, + 0.069043830037117, + 0.05343765765428543, + 0.055727798491716385, + 0.13571728765964508, + 0.053427793085575104, + 0.05863691493868828, + 0.11388148367404938, + 0.07443559169769287 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01821797341108322 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an unfinished tank turret composed of dark gray metal armor with visible hexagonal bolts and round rivets at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are workers wearing heavy dark blue overalls and yellow hard hats visible working around the turret?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one worker crouching and manipulating a welding torch that erupts with a cascade of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is another worker leaning forward and tightening a bolt on the turret with a large pneumatic wrench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011077924631536007 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511077880859375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011077924631536007, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011077924631536007, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05974486842751503, + 0.10194207727909088, + 0.38830217719078064, + 0.21377690136432648, + 0.02421301230788231, + 0.035490211099386215, + 0.08522150665521622, + 0.01923411525785923, + 0.02766885608434677, + 0.044406309723854065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011077924631536007 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an unfinished tank turret composed of dark gray metal armor with visible hexagonal bolts and round rivets at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are workers wearing heavy dark blue overalls and yellow hard hats visible working around the turret?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one worker crouching and manipulating a welding torch that erupts with a cascade of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is another worker leaning forward and tightening a bolt on the turret with a large pneumatic wrench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00673760985955596 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00673770904541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00673760985955596, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00673760985955596, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08418016135692596, + 0.053634993731975555, + 0.03521137312054634, + 0.036611784249544144, + 0.3514961004257202, + 0.10699055343866348, + 0.11096835881471634, + 0.07716920971870422, + 0.04621337726712227, + 0.0975240170955658 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00673760985955596 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an unfinished tank turret composed of dark gray metal armor with visible hexagonal bolts and round rivets at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are workers wearing heavy dark blue overalls and yellow hard hats visible working around the turret?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one worker crouching and manipulating a welding torch that erupts with a cascade of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is another worker leaning forward and tightening a bolt on the turret with a large pneumatic wrench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620303601026535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.81203031539917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620303601026535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620303601026535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12907278537750244, + 0.06628832966089249, + 0.14586812257766724, + 0.03979559615254402, + 0.11141931265592575, + 0.0877845287322998, + 0.1068536639213562, + 0.0352105051279068, + 0.08639800548553467, + 0.1913091540336609 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620303601026535 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion camera, shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly zooms into a vast, heavy industrial factory floor. Beneath the soaring ceiling, thick steel beams and pipes crisscross. Several high-hanging industrial lights cast cold, intense beams, forming distinct paths through the air thick with a faint wisp of dust. At the center of the frame, an unfinished tank turret dominates with its imposing mass. Composed of thick, angular, dark gray metal armor, each massive hexagonal bolt and neat rows of round rivets are clearly visible under the cold light, embodying an unparalleled sense of industrial might. Several workers, dressed in heavy, oily dark blue overalls and wearing yellow hard hats, work collaboratively around the turret. One of them crouches, steadily and precisely manipulating a welding torch along a seam in the armor. In an instant, a dazzling cascade of white and orange sparks erupts, briefly illuminating his focused face and the surrounding metal before scattering like meteors onto the concrete floor below. Next to him, another worker leaned forward, decisively and forcefully tightening a bolt on the side with a large pneumatic wrench, emitting a high-pitched mechanical sound. Amidst the constant industrial noise and flying sparks, the entire scene exuded an atmosphere of tension, focus, and creativity, replete with the stark contrast between the cold texture of metal and the fiery energy of welding.", + "seed": 10416, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_3/index_7478_seed_10416_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.019604146759957076, + "vlm_logprob": -0.019604146759957076, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.019604146759957076, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an unfinished tank turret composed of dark gray metal armor with visible hexagonal bolts and round rivets at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are workers wearing heavy dark blue overalls and yellow hard hats visible working around the turret?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one worker crouching and manipulating a welding torch that erupts with a cascade of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is another worker leaning forward and tightening a bolt on the turret with a large pneumatic wrench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.021782677620649338 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.271782875061035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.021782677620649338, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.021782677620649338, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21324916183948517, + 0.08651328831911087, + 0.06293433904647827, + 0.05258161574602127, + 0.0675332322716713, + 0.10663646459579468, + 0.03942501172423363, + 0.12984499335289001, + 0.04402124509215355, + 0.19726061820983887 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.021782677620649338 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an unfinished tank turret composed of dark gray metal armor with visible hexagonal bolts and round rivets at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are workers wearing heavy dark blue overalls and yellow hard hats visible working around the turret?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one worker crouching and manipulating a welding torch that erupts with a cascade of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is another worker leaning forward and tightening a bolt on the turret with a large pneumatic wrench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012564195320010185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387564182281494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012564195320010185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012564195320010185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.142120361328125, + 0.1208629235625267, + 0.03843042626976967, + 0.06480762362480164, + 0.09728238731622696, + 0.03408773988485336, + 0.03698689118027687, + 0.03951660543680191, + 0.11282337456941605, + 0.3130817711353302 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012564195320010185 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an unfinished tank turret composed of dark gray metal armor with visible hexagonal bolts and round rivets at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are workers wearing heavy dark blue overalls and yellow hard hats visible working around the turret?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one worker crouching and manipulating a welding torch that erupts with a cascade of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is another worker leaning forward and tightening a bolt on the turret with a large pneumatic wrench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005252490285784006 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255252361297607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005252490285784006, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005252490285784006, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12307363003492355, + 0.08136025816202164, + 0.15401004254817963, + 0.07980307936668396, + 0.11308369040489197, + 0.10460822284221649, + 0.06653320789337158, + 0.06334242224693298, + 0.09006533026695251, + 0.1241200864315033 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005252490285784006 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an unfinished tank turret composed of dark gray metal armor with visible hexagonal bolts and round rivets at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are workers wearing heavy dark blue overalls and yellow hard hats visible working around the turret?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one worker crouching and manipulating a welding torch that erupts with a cascade of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is another worker leaning forward and tightening a bolt on the turret with a large pneumatic wrench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009779990650713444 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634779930114746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009779990650713444, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009779990650713444, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15326769649982452, + 0.11552966386079788, + 0.06986752152442932, + 0.08495879918336868, + 0.14003489911556244, + 0.06527906656265259, + 0.05908220633864403, + 0.032764315605163574, + 0.09373107552528381, + 0.18548478186130524 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009779990650713444 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an unfinished tank turret composed of dark gray metal armor with visible hexagonal bolts and round rivets at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are workers wearing heavy dark blue overalls and yellow hard hats visible working around the turret?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one worker crouching and manipulating a welding torch that erupts with a cascade of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is another worker leaning forward and tightening a bolt on the turret with a large pneumatic wrench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0486413799226284 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486414432525635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0486413799226284, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0486413799226284, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11845235526561737, + 0.12692010402679443, + 0.08637643605470657, + 0.08226566761732101, + 0.04830361157655716, + 0.0436469167470932, + 0.05581217631697655, + 0.07090052217245102, + 0.11999625712633133, + 0.24732595682144165 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0486413799226284 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion camera, shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly zooms into a vast, heavy industrial factory floor. Beneath the soaring ceiling, thick steel beams and pipes crisscross. Several high-hanging industrial lights cast cold, intense beams, forming distinct paths through the air thick with a faint wisp of dust. At the center of the frame, an unfinished tank turret dominates with its imposing mass. Composed of thick, angular, dark gray metal armor, each massive hexagonal bolt and neat rows of round rivets are clearly visible under the cold light, embodying an unparalleled sense of industrial might. Several workers, dressed in heavy, oily dark blue overalls and wearing yellow hard hats, work collaboratively around the turret. One of them crouches, steadily and precisely manipulating a welding torch along a seam in the armor. In an instant, a dazzling cascade of white and orange sparks erupts, briefly illuminating his focused face and the surrounding metal before scattering like meteors onto the concrete floor below. Next to him, another worker leaned forward, decisively and forcefully tightening a bolt on the side with a large pneumatic wrench, emitting a high-pitched mechanical sound. Amidst the constant industrial noise and flying sparks, the entire scene exuded an atmosphere of tension, focus, and creativity, replete with the stark contrast between the cold texture of metal and the fiery energy of welding.", + "seed": 10417, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_3/index_7478_seed_10417_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03831586521118879, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03831586521118879, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03831586521118879, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an unfinished tank turret composed of dark gray metal armor with visible hexagonal bolts and round rivets at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are workers wearing heavy dark blue overalls and yellow hard hats visible working around the turret?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one worker crouching and manipulating a welding torch that erupts with a cascade of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is another worker leaning forward and tightening a bolt on the turret with a large pneumatic wrench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03296997398138046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5329699516296387 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03296997398138046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03296997398138046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10674117505550385, + 0.05779323726892471, + 0.17855672538280487, + 0.1617983728647232, + 0.018268456682562828, + 0.07705006748437881, + 0.115318164229393, + 0.10812980681657791, + 0.12063916027545929, + 0.05570484697818756 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03296997398138046 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an unfinished tank turret composed of dark gray metal armor with visible hexagonal bolts and round rivets at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are workers wearing heavy dark blue overalls and yellow hard hats visible working around the turret?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one worker crouching and manipulating a welding torch that erupts with a cascade of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is another worker leaning forward and tightening a bolt on the turret with a large pneumatic wrench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026376035064458847 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513760089874268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026376035064458847, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026376035064458847, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2683448791503906, + 0.11150052398443222, + 0.06982535868883133, + 0.03982255607843399, + 0.02449251338839531, + 0.04305235296487808, + 0.1734745055437088, + 0.06830929964780807, + 0.08775897324085236, + 0.1134190708398819 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026376035064458847 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an unfinished tank turret composed of dark gray metal armor with visible hexagonal bolts and round rivets at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are workers wearing heavy dark blue overalls and yellow hard hats visible working around the turret?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one worker crouching and manipulating a welding torch that erupts with a cascade of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is another worker leaning forward and tightening a bolt on the turret with a large pneumatic wrench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02328656055033207 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732865810394287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02328656055033207, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02328656055033207, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42007872462272644, + 0.11359957605600357, + 0.09331093728542328, + 0.08548527956008911, + 0.016159839928150177, + 0.062458336353302, + 0.02343599870800972, + 0.08130887895822525, + 0.07033973932266235, + 0.033822737634181976 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02328656055033207 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an unfinished tank turret composed of dark gray metal armor with visible hexagonal bolts and round rivets at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are workers wearing heavy dark blue overalls and yellow hard hats visible working around the turret?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one worker crouching and manipulating a welding torch that erupts with a cascade of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is another worker leaning forward and tightening a bolt on the turret with a large pneumatic wrench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008640640415251255 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758640766143799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008640640415251255, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008640640415251255, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1556374728679657, + 0.0388333722949028, + 0.17023779451847076, + 0.07996857911348343, + 0.029671693220734596, + 0.07187134027481079, + 0.16709570586681366, + 0.1515604853630066, + 0.053844429552555084, + 0.08127923309803009 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008640640415251255 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an unfinished tank turret composed of dark gray metal armor with visible hexagonal bolts and round rivets at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are workers wearing heavy dark blue overalls and yellow hard hats visible working around the turret?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one worker crouching and manipulating a welding torch that erupts with a cascade of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is another worker leaning forward and tightening a bolt on the turret with a large pneumatic wrench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10030611604452133 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503060340881348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10030611604452133, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10030611604452133, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2754179835319519, + 0.04713713377714157, + 0.23544490337371826, + 0.051402248442173004, + 0.015439937822520733, + 0.06636055558919907, + 0.10878003388643265, + 0.10618633031845093, + 0.054053496569395065, + 0.03977734595537186 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10030611604452133 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion camera, shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly zooms into a vast, heavy industrial factory floor. Beneath the soaring ceiling, thick steel beams and pipes crisscross. Several high-hanging industrial lights cast cold, intense beams, forming distinct paths through the air thick with a faint wisp of dust. At the center of the frame, an unfinished tank turret dominates with its imposing mass. Composed of thick, angular, dark gray metal armor, each massive hexagonal bolt and neat rows of round rivets are clearly visible under the cold light, embodying an unparalleled sense of industrial might. Several workers, dressed in heavy, oily dark blue overalls and wearing yellow hard hats, work collaboratively around the turret. One of them crouches, steadily and precisely manipulating a welding torch along a seam in the armor. In an instant, a dazzling cascade of white and orange sparks erupts, briefly illuminating his focused face and the surrounding metal before scattering like meteors onto the concrete floor below. Next to him, another worker leaned forward, decisively and forcefully tightening a bolt on the side with a large pneumatic wrench, emitting a high-pitched mechanical sound. Amidst the constant industrial noise and flying sparks, the entire scene exuded an atmosphere of tension, focus, and creativity, replete with the stark contrast between the cold texture of metal and the fiery energy of welding.", + "seed": 10418, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_3/index_7478_seed_10418_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04048395231366157, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04048395231366157, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04048395231366157, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an unfinished tank turret composed of dark gray metal armor with visible hexagonal bolts and round rivets at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are workers wearing heavy dark blue overalls and yellow hard hats visible working around the turret?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one worker crouching and manipulating a welding torch that erupts with a cascade of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is another worker leaning forward and tightening a bolt on the turret with a large pneumatic wrench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03338662162423134 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.533386707305908 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03338662162423134, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03338662162423134, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06899651139974594, + 0.31833338737487793, + 0.07021878659725189, + 0.06809478998184204, + 0.09188804775476456, + 0.051184363663196564, + 0.01797281950712204, + 0.09218540787696838, + 0.1885984092950821, + 0.032527439296245575 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03338662162423134 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an unfinished tank turret composed of dark gray metal armor with visible hexagonal bolts and round rivets at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are workers wearing heavy dark blue overalls and yellow hard hats visible working around the turret?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one worker crouching and manipulating a welding torch that erupts with a cascade of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is another worker leaning forward and tightening a bolt on the turret with a large pneumatic wrench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02983870357275009 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529838800430298 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02983870357275009, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02983870357275009, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.046561744064092636, + 0.03703220561146736, + 0.24613365530967712, + 0.07048573344945908, + 0.07790695130825043, + 0.10437066107988358, + 0.05037691444158554, + 0.08426201343536377, + 0.11388909816741943, + 0.16898107528686523 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02983870357275009 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an unfinished tank turret composed of dark gray metal armor with visible hexagonal bolts and round rivets at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are workers wearing heavy dark blue overalls and yellow hard hats visible working around the turret?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one worker crouching and manipulating a welding torch that erupts with a cascade of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is another worker leaning forward and tightening a bolt on the turret with a large pneumatic wrench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026345033198595047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513450145721436 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026345033198595047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026345033198595047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05367358401417732, + 0.3404815196990967, + 0.0532863475382328, + 0.15036852657794952, + 0.04362014681100845, + 0.052489858120679855, + 0.01693621836602688, + 0.07572253048419952, + 0.1357710361480713, + 0.07765019685029984 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026345033198595047 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an unfinished tank turret composed of dark gray metal armor with visible hexagonal bolts and round rivets at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are workers wearing heavy dark blue overalls and yellow hard hats visible working around the turret?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one worker crouching and manipulating a welding torch that erupts with a cascade of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is another worker leaning forward and tightening a bolt on the turret with a large pneumatic wrench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012542534619569778 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387542724609375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012542534619569778, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012542534619569778, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.048238854855298996, + 0.41117754578590393, + 0.07237806916236877, + 0.045913953334093094, + 0.015874871984124184, + 0.01615242473781109, + 0.01870504580438137, + 0.18172971904277802, + 0.09749609977006912, + 0.09233346581459045 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012542534619569778 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an unfinished tank turret composed of dark gray metal armor with visible hexagonal bolts and round rivets at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are workers wearing heavy dark blue overalls and yellow hard hats visible working around the turret?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one worker crouching and manipulating a welding torch that erupts with a cascade of white and orange sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is another worker leaning forward and tightening a bolt on the turret with a large pneumatic wrench?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10030686855316162 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350306987762451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10030686855316162, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10030686855316162, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05232951417565346, + 0.26999059319496155, + 0.044799018651247025, + 0.0948948934674263, + 0.031392890959978104, + 0.033318907022476196, + 0.0147649385035038, + 0.343509316444397, + 0.05567418411374092, + 0.05932570993900299 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10030686855316162 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_4/index_tensor([6016, 6016])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_4/index_tensor([6016, 6016])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0da102202b490d30ad1e7efa9bbb626dd203dcda --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_4/index_tensor([6016, 6016])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a tight, cinematic composition, captured from a slight overhead angle, the camera focuses on a figure clad in a thick, deep indigo canvas apron, their steady, deft hands executing a precise culinary gesture. One hand carefully pushes a sharp, golden block of butter from a half-open wax paper and, with a deliberate, precise motion, slides it into a sizzling black cast iron pan below. Powered by the next-generation gaming textures of Unreal Engine, every detail is rendered with photorealistic precision: the moment the butter touches the pan, it melts with a distinct sizzle, countless fine bubbles boiling around the edges, forming a shimmering, transparent, and rich, milky savory rim. A warm, directional light cast from above and to the side creates dynamic flares of light on the melting butter's surface and softly outlines the figure's forearm and apron, rendering the lighting and shadow details with unparalleled authenticity. The professional kitchen environment in the background is softly blurred by the depth of field effect, with only the blurred halo of stainless steel appliances as embellishment. The entire picture presents a highly focused, almost sacred cooking ritual in the extremely realistic light and shadow details. The atmosphere is tranquil and powerful.", + "seed": 20670, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_4/index_6016_seed_20670_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.20958379162475466, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20958379162475466, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20958379162475466, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a figure wearing a thick, deep indigo canvas apron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure slide a sharp, golden block of butter from wax paper into a sizzling black cast iron pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the butter melt with visible fine bubbles and form a shimmering, transparent, milky rim upon touching the pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle with a tight composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a professional kitchen with stainless steel appliances that are softly blurred by depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.83147132396698 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.58147132396698 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.83147132396698, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.83147132396698, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12419717758893967, + 0.33328601717948914, + 0.07717331498861313, + 0.0701170563697815, + 0.060242362320423126, + 0.045535262674093246, + 0.03689073771238327, + 0.16570492088794708, + 0.06699761003255844, + 0.019855471327900887 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.83147132396698 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a figure wearing a thick, deep indigo canvas apron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure slide a sharp, golden block of butter from wax paper into a sizzling black cast iron pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the butter melt with visible fine bubbles and form a shimmering, transparent, milky rim upon touching the pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle with a tight composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a professional kitchen with stainless steel appliances that are softly blurred by depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0381997711956501 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881996631622314 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0381997711956501, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0381997711956501, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02690213732421398, + 0.039609141647815704, + 0.07941477000713348, + 0.40876272320747375, + 0.08582273125648499, + 0.0467180572450161, + 0.046386756002902985, + 0.12437855452299118, + 0.11717405915260315, + 0.02483110874891281 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0381997711956501 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a figure wearing a thick, deep indigo canvas apron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure slide a sharp, golden block of butter from wax paper into a sizzling black cast iron pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the butter melt with visible fine bubbles and form a shimmering, transparent, milky rim upon touching the pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle with a tight composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a professional kitchen with stainless steel appliances that are softly blurred by depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011090303771197796 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511090278625488 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011090303771197796, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011090303771197796, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03142394497990608, + 0.045076701790094376, + 0.04395108297467232, + 0.39782100915908813, + 0.12426534295082092, + 0.022909434512257576, + 0.03668070212006569, + 0.06327091157436371, + 0.15888135135173798, + 0.07571946829557419 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011090303771197796 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a figure wearing a thick, deep indigo canvas apron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure slide a sharp, golden block of butter from wax paper into a sizzling black cast iron pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the butter melt with visible fine bubbles and form a shimmering, transparent, milky rim upon touching the pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle with a tight composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a professional kitchen with stainless steel appliances that are softly blurred by depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006745188031345606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006745338439941 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006745188031345606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006745188031345606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03924600034952164, + 0.05803442746400833, + 0.039383240044116974, + 0.40612688660621643, + 0.10410801321268082, + 0.06145136058330536, + 0.13541774451732635, + 0.12210459262132645, + 0.020331189036369324, + 0.01379652414470911 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006745188031345606 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a figure wearing a thick, deep indigo canvas apron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure slide a sharp, golden block of butter from wax paper into a sizzling black cast iron pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the butter melt with visible fine bubbles and form a shimmering, transparent, milky rim upon touching the pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle with a tight composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a professional kitchen with stainless steel appliances that are softly blurred by depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16041237115859985 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910412311553955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16041237115859985, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16041237115859985, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0955839455127716, + 0.11732187122106552, + 0.0695790946483612, + 0.44359177350997925, + 0.05073754861950874, + 0.04597114771604538, + 0.04134845361113548, + 0.083059161901474, + 0.03185882791876793, + 0.020948268473148346 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16041237115859985 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a tight, cinematic composition, captured from a slight overhead angle, the camera focuses on a figure clad in a thick, deep indigo canvas apron, their steady, deft hands executing a precise culinary gesture. One hand carefully pushes a sharp, golden block of butter from a half-open wax paper and, with a deliberate, precise motion, slides it into a sizzling black cast iron pan below. Powered by the next-generation gaming textures of Unreal Engine, every detail is rendered with photorealistic precision: the moment the butter touches the pan, it melts with a distinct sizzle, countless fine bubbles boiling around the edges, forming a shimmering, transparent, and rich, milky savory rim. A warm, directional light cast from above and to the side creates dynamic flares of light on the melting butter's surface and softly outlines the figure's forearm and apron, rendering the lighting and shadow details with unparalleled authenticity. The professional kitchen environment in the background is softly blurred by the depth of field effect, with only the blurred halo of stainless steel appliances as embellishment. The entire picture presents a highly focused, almost sacred cooking ritual in the extremely realistic light and shadow details. The atmosphere is tranquil and powerful.", + "seed": 20671, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_4/index_6016_seed_20671_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06934219636023045, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06934219636023045, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06934219636023045, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a figure wearing a thick, deep indigo canvas apron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure slide a sharp, golden block of butter from wax paper into a sizzling black cast iron pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the butter melt with visible fine bubbles and form a shimmering, transparent, milky rim upon touching the pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle with a tight composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a professional kitchen with stainless steel appliances that are softly blurred by depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.13082462549209595 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.130824565887451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.13082462549209595, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.13082462549209595, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19733041524887085, + 0.08075655251741409, + 0.08023732155561447, + 0.30179402232170105, + 0.06528901308774948, + 0.023861292749643326, + 0.01495113130658865, + 0.07911521196365356, + 0.11726143211126328, + 0.039403680711984634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.13082462549209595 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a figure wearing a thick, deep indigo canvas apron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure slide a sharp, golden block of butter from wax paper into a sizzling black cast iron pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the butter melt with visible fine bubbles and form a shimmering, transparent, milky rim upon touching the pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle with a tight composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a professional kitchen with stainless steel appliances that are softly blurred by depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05502583086490631 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.930025815963745 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05502583086490631, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05502583086490631, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23210982978343964, + 0.045897334814071655, + 0.09916644543409348, + 0.03654896840453148, + 0.10856162011623383, + 0.046497512608766556, + 0.019877227023243904, + 0.20168587565422058, + 0.1564454436302185, + 0.05320972949266434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05502583086490631 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a figure wearing a thick, deep indigo canvas apron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure slide a sharp, golden block of butter from wax paper into a sizzling black cast iron pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the butter melt with visible fine bubbles and form a shimmering, transparent, milky rim upon touching the pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle with a tight composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a professional kitchen with stainless steel appliances that are softly blurred by depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811635076999664 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288116455078125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811635076999664, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811635076999664, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16512566804885864, + 0.036235980689525604, + 0.07101621478796005, + 0.043597180396318436, + 0.131618469953537, + 0.04918377846479416, + 0.30282074213027954, + 0.09303959459066391, + 0.052126847207546234, + 0.05523547902703285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811635076999664 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a figure wearing a thick, deep indigo canvas apron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure slide a sharp, golden block of butter from wax paper into a sizzling black cast iron pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the butter melt with visible fine bubbles and form a shimmering, transparent, milky rim upon touching the pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle with a tight composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a professional kitchen with stainless steel appliances that are softly blurred by depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009789789095520973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634789943695068 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009789789095520973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009789789095520973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20967300236225128, + 0.04738672450184822, + 0.12371764332056046, + 0.05661257728934288, + 0.18989188969135284, + 0.10003794729709625, + 0.04096782207489014, + 0.07606551051139832, + 0.05828196182847023, + 0.0973648726940155 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009789789095520973 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a figure wearing a thick, deep indigo canvas apron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure slide a sharp, golden block of butter from wax paper into a sizzling black cast iron pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the butter melt with visible fine bubbles and form a shimmering, transparent, milky rim upon touching the pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle with a tight composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a professional kitchen with stainless steel appliances that are softly blurred by depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11295438557863235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379543781280518 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11295438557863235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11295438557863235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25047066807746887, + 0.042098965495824814, + 0.06337938457727432, + 0.09790326654911041, + 0.3698384165763855, + 0.020015697926282883, + 0.02955860085785389, + 0.029065124690532684, + 0.041651710867881775, + 0.0560181625187397 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11295438557863235 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a tight, cinematic composition, captured from a slight overhead angle, the camera focuses on a figure clad in a thick, deep indigo canvas apron, their steady, deft hands executing a precise culinary gesture. One hand carefully pushes a sharp, golden block of butter from a half-open wax paper and, with a deliberate, precise motion, slides it into a sizzling black cast iron pan below. Powered by the next-generation gaming textures of Unreal Engine, every detail is rendered with photorealistic precision: the moment the butter touches the pan, it melts with a distinct sizzle, countless fine bubbles boiling around the edges, forming a shimmering, transparent, and rich, milky savory rim. A warm, directional light cast from above and to the side creates dynamic flares of light on the melting butter's surface and softly outlines the figure's forearm and apron, rendering the lighting and shadow details with unparalleled authenticity. The professional kitchen environment in the background is softly blurred by the depth of field effect, with only the blurred halo of stainless steel appliances as embellishment. The entire picture presents a highly focused, almost sacred cooking ritual in the extremely realistic light and shadow details. The atmosphere is tranquil and powerful.", + "seed": 20672, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_4/index_6016_seed_20672_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11545657366514206, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11545657366514206, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11545657366514206, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a figure wearing a thick, deep indigo canvas apron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure slide a sharp, golden block of butter from wax paper into a sizzling black cast iron pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the butter melt with visible fine bubbles and form a shimmering, transparent, milky rim upon touching the pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle with a tight composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a professional kitchen with stainless steel appliances that are softly blurred by depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18222671747207642 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8072266578674316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18222671747207642, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18222671747207642, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1779245287179947, + 0.05091242864727974, + 0.059131111949682236, + 0.08320486545562744, + 0.10811562091112137, + 0.12432917207479477, + 0.03512512519955635, + 0.12495249509811401, + 0.15221302211284637, + 0.08409158885478973 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18222671747207642 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a figure wearing a thick, deep indigo canvas apron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure slide a sharp, golden block of butter from wax paper into a sizzling black cast iron pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the butter melt with visible fine bubbles and form a shimmering, transparent, milky rim upon touching the pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle with a tight composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a professional kitchen with stainless steel appliances that are softly blurred by depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.100425586104393 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3504254817962646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.100425586104393, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.100425586104393, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1651967614889145, + 0.06058051437139511, + 0.033207397907972336, + 0.07257960736751556, + 0.13850228488445282, + 0.24967123568058014, + 0.06377742439508438, + 0.1114276647567749, + 0.039149850606918335, + 0.06590732932090759 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.100425586104393 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a figure wearing a thick, deep indigo canvas apron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure slide a sharp, golden block of butter from wax paper into a sizzling black cast iron pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the butter melt with visible fine bubbles and form a shimmering, transparent, milky rim upon touching the pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle with a tight composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a professional kitchen with stainless steel appliances that are softly blurred by depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033726684749126434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408726692199707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033726684749126434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033726684749126434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11906885355710983, + 0.06060164049267769, + 0.02077414281666279, + 0.09899819642305374, + 0.22164621949195862, + 0.10076870024204254, + 0.075088731944561, + 0.19032998383045197, + 0.03634319081902504, + 0.07638037949800491 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033726684749126434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a figure wearing a thick, deep indigo canvas apron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure slide a sharp, golden block of butter from wax paper into a sizzling black cast iron pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the butter melt with visible fine bubbles and form a shimmering, transparent, milky rim upon touching the pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle with a tight composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a professional kitchen with stainless steel appliances that are softly blurred by depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008645012974739075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758645057678223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008645012974739075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008645012974739075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27552250027656555, + 0.036132294684648514, + 0.03290729969739914, + 0.05040191859006882, + 0.03792746365070343, + 0.3040231764316559, + 0.035808224231004715, + 0.10444511473178864, + 0.08785708248615265, + 0.03497493267059326 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008645012974739075 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a figure wearing a thick, deep indigo canvas apron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure slide a sharp, golden block of butter from wax paper into a sizzling black cast iron pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the butter melt with visible fine bubbles and form a shimmering, transparent, milky rim upon touching the pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle with a tight composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a professional kitchen with stainless steel appliances that are softly blurred by depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25225886702537537 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5022588968276978 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25225886702537537, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25225886702537537, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24697349965572357, + 0.05608070269227028, + 0.03034675121307373, + 0.0678897351026535, + 0.061096448451280594, + 0.18265320360660553, + 0.05168106034398079, + 0.08916697651147842, + 0.14123079180717468, + 0.0728808268904686 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25225886702537537 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a tight, cinematic composition, captured from a slight overhead angle, the camera focuses on a figure clad in a thick, deep indigo canvas apron, their steady, deft hands executing a precise culinary gesture. One hand carefully pushes a sharp, golden block of butter from a half-open wax paper and, with a deliberate, precise motion, slides it into a sizzling black cast iron pan below. Powered by the next-generation gaming textures of Unreal Engine, every detail is rendered with photorealistic precision: the moment the butter touches the pan, it melts with a distinct sizzle, countless fine bubbles boiling around the edges, forming a shimmering, transparent, and rich, milky savory rim. A warm, directional light cast from above and to the side creates dynamic flares of light on the melting butter's surface and softly outlines the figure's forearm and apron, rendering the lighting and shadow details with unparalleled authenticity. The professional kitchen environment in the background is softly blurred by the depth of field effect, with only the blurred halo of stainless steel appliances as embellishment. The entire picture presents a highly focused, almost sacred cooking ritual in the extremely realistic light and shadow details. The atmosphere is tranquil and powerful.", + "seed": 20673, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_4/index_6016_seed_20673_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07242539171129465, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07242539171129465, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07242539171129465, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a figure wearing a thick, deep indigo canvas apron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure slide a sharp, golden block of butter from wax paper into a sizzling black cast iron pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the butter melt with visible fine bubbles and form a shimmering, transparent, milky rim upon touching the pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle with a tight composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a professional kitchen with stainless steel appliances that are softly blurred by depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1664901226758957 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.916490077972412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1664901226758957, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1664901226758957, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6490389704704285, + 0.03627597913146019, + 0.06894045323133469, + 0.015744492411613464, + 0.018300343304872513, + 0.04533764347434044, + 0.02103821001946926, + 0.027693407610058784, + 0.05217680335044861, + 0.06545370817184448 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1664901226758957 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a figure wearing a thick, deep indigo canvas apron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure slide a sharp, golden block of butter from wax paper into a sizzling black cast iron pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the butter melt with visible fine bubbles and form a shimmering, transparent, milky rim upon touching the pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle with a tight composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a professional kitchen with stainless steel appliances that are softly blurred by depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03816615045070648 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288166046142578 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03816615045070648, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03816615045070648, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35121482610702515, + 0.11727353930473328, + 0.09894037246704102, + 0.035054005682468414, + 0.04503423348069191, + 0.03251110762357712, + 0.017726371064782143, + 0.026231396943330765, + 0.05701577663421631, + 0.21899837255477905 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03816615045070648 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a figure wearing a thick, deep indigo canvas apron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure slide a sharp, golden block of butter from wax paper into a sizzling black cast iron pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the butter melt with visible fine bubbles and form a shimmering, transparent, milky rim upon touching the pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle with a tight composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a professional kitchen with stainless steel appliances that are softly blurred by depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059854008257389 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955986499786377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059854008257389, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059854008257389, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5575432777404785, + 0.06713202595710754, + 0.05757710337638855, + 0.030529281124472618, + 0.03816604241728783, + 0.03410666808485985, + 0.06878767162561417, + 0.020606566220521927, + 0.07519183307886124, + 0.0503595769405365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059854008257389 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a figure wearing a thick, deep indigo canvas apron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure slide a sharp, golden block of butter from wax paper into a sizzling black cast iron pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the butter melt with visible fine bubbles and form a shimmering, transparent, milky rim upon touching the pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle with a tight composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a professional kitchen with stainless steel appliances that are softly blurred by depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009790497832000256 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634790420532227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009790497832000256, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009790497832000256, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.46768826246261597, + 0.02765895240008831, + 0.055834610015153885, + 0.062408316880464554, + 0.03673248738050461, + 0.05366532504558563, + 0.12292475998401642, + 0.033675383776426315, + 0.06209111586213112, + 0.07732084393501282 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009790497832000256 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a figure wearing a thick, deep indigo canvas apron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure slide a sharp, golden block of butter from wax paper into a sizzling black cast iron pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the butter melt with visible fine bubbles and form a shimmering, transparent, milky rim upon touching the pan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera captured from a slight overhead angle with a tight composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a professional kitchen with stainless steel appliances that are softly blurred by depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12708164751529694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270816326141357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12708164751529694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12708164751529694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6522054076194763, + 0.010735083371400833, + 0.09462277591228485, + 0.03601361811161041, + 0.03019547276198864, + 0.009159661829471588, + 0.0669010654091835, + 0.04506440833210945, + 0.02034297212958336, + 0.034759532660245895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12708164751529694 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_5/index_tensor([5434, 5434])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_5/index_tensor([5434, 5434])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..087646086eefc113c5e7ea37e350a06b02b037a1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_5/index_tensor([5434, 5434])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "frantic, erratic point-of-view shot plunges the viewer headfirst into a desperate, full-throttle run through a dense, claustrophobic forest of towering evergreens. The camera, representing the runner's eyes, swings violently up and down with each heavy footstep, which treads across a treacherous carpet of dark soil, gnarled roots, and damp pine needles, swerving erratically to narrowly avoid the thick, moss-covered trunks that crowd the frame. Low-hanging branches, laden with sharp green needles, lash violently at the camera, some striking with jarring force, momentarily obscuring vision and filling the periphery with chaotic motion blur. In the twilight hours, the low-hanging sun pierces the thick canopy, casting sharp golden rays that create disorienting flickers between blinding brightness and deep, oppressive shadows. This high-contrast world of deep forest greens and earthy browns, punctuated by fleeting bursts of brilliant golden sunlight, creates a palpable sense of panic and suffocating urgency, driven by relentless forward motion and a constant chaotic assault on the senses.", + "seed": 31495, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_5/index_5434_seed_31495_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.35897733122110365, + "vlm_logprob": -0.35897733122110365, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.35897733122110365, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person point-of-view perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera swing violently up and down with each footstep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered with dark soil, gnarled roots, and damp pine needles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do low-hanging branches with sharp green needles strike the camera and create motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by sharp golden rays piercing the canopy to create high contrast between bright light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11210178583860397 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3621017932891846 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11210178583860397, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11210178583860397, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08760432153940201, + 0.07279859483242035, + 0.15721194446086884, + 0.14412368834018707, + 0.08661765605211258, + 0.09238938242197037, + 0.03332319110631943, + 0.06517577171325684, + 0.20903155207633972, + 0.05172399431467056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11210178583860397 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person point-of-view perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera swing violently up and down with each footstep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered with dark soil, gnarled roots, and damp pine needles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do low-hanging branches with sharp green needles strike the camera and create motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by sharp golden rays piercing the canopy to create high contrast between bright light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370694637298584 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.387069433927536 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1370694637298584, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1370694637298584, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12901856005191803, + 0.08843179047107697, + 0.12752583622932434, + 0.11056947708129883, + 0.03781323879957199, + 0.029300814494490623, + 0.04840284213423729, + 0.05677582696080208, + 0.07626919448375702, + 0.2958923876285553 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1370694637298584 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person point-of-view perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera swing violently up and down with each footstep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered with dark soil, gnarled roots, and damp pine needles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do low-hanging branches with sharp green needles strike the camera and create motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by sharp golden rays piercing the canopy to create high contrast between bright light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009792149998247623 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634792327880859 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009792149998247623, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009792149998247623, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07024821639060974, + 0.07461187243461609, + 0.08446259051561356, + 0.076422318816185, + 0.05419861525297165, + 0.037298109382390976, + 0.04718875139951706, + 0.36580953001976013, + 0.06847918778657913, + 0.12128080427646637 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009792149998247623 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person point-of-view perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera swing violently up and down with each footstep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered with dark soil, gnarled roots, and damp pine needles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do low-hanging branches with sharp green needles strike the camera and create motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by sharp golden rays piercing the canopy to create high contrast between bright light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012554659508168697 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38755464553833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012554659508168697, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012554659508168697, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09018062055110931, + 0.0778726190328598, + 0.23162271082401276, + 0.12921491265296936, + 0.030790895223617554, + 0.018641211092472076, + 0.0419805683195591, + 0.1053185909986496, + 0.07820574939250946, + 0.19617217779159546 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012554659508168697 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person point-of-view perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera swing violently up and down with each footstep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered with dark soil, gnarled roots, and damp pine needles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do low-hanging branches with sharp green needles strike the camera and create motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by sharp golden rays piercing the canopy to create high contrast between bright light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233685970306396 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983685970306396 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233685970306396, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233685970306396, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09390256553888321, + 0.07744569331407547, + 0.16778148710727692, + 0.15559075772762299, + 0.11429433524608612, + 0.16421256959438324, + 0.058067139238119125, + 0.06898826360702515, + 0.046187303960323334, + 0.05352987349033356 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233685970306396 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "frantic, erratic point-of-view shot plunges the viewer headfirst into a desperate, full-throttle run through a dense, claustrophobic forest of towering evergreens. The camera, representing the runner's eyes, swings violently up and down with each heavy footstep, which treads across a treacherous carpet of dark soil, gnarled roots, and damp pine needles, swerving erratically to narrowly avoid the thick, moss-covered trunks that crowd the frame. Low-hanging branches, laden with sharp green needles, lash violently at the camera, some striking with jarring force, momentarily obscuring vision and filling the periphery with chaotic motion blur. In the twilight hours, the low-hanging sun pierces the thick canopy, casting sharp golden rays that create disorienting flickers between blinding brightness and deep, oppressive shadows. This high-contrast world of deep forest greens and earthy browns, punctuated by fleeting bursts of brilliant golden sunlight, creates a palpable sense of panic and suffocating urgency, driven by relentless forward motion and a constant chaotic assault on the senses.", + "seed": 31496, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_5/index_5434_seed_31496_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.23014748711138963, + "vlm_logprob": -0.23014748711138963, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.23014748711138963, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person point-of-view perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera swing violently up and down with each footstep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered with dark soil, gnarled roots, and damp pine needles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do low-hanging branches with sharp green needles strike the camera and create motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by sharp golden rays piercing the canopy to create high contrast between bright light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06152571737766266 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.936525821685791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06152571737766266, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06152571737766266, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09555648267269135, + 0.21319249272346497, + 0.07521593570709229, + 0.09349316358566284, + 0.07236378639936447, + 0.10585565119981766, + 0.1444183737039566, + 0.04702569916844368, + 0.09743582457304001, + 0.055442553013563156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06152571737766266 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person point-of-view perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera swing violently up and down with each footstep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered with dark soil, gnarled roots, and damp pine needles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do low-hanging branches with sharp green needles strike the camera and create motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by sharp golden rays piercing the canopy to create high contrast between bright light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742794632911682 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4742794632911682 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9742794632911682, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9742794632911682, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10625174641609192, + 0.3152340054512024, + 0.020300518721342087, + 0.02939840964972973, + 0.07575741410255432, + 0.03806580230593681, + 0.04366843402385712, + 0.02999088168144226, + 0.04371756687760353, + 0.2976152300834656 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9742794632911682 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person point-of-view perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera swing violently up and down with each footstep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered with dark soil, gnarled roots, and damp pine needles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do low-hanging branches with sharp green needles strike the camera and create motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by sharp golden rays piercing the canopy to create high contrast between bright light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005955095402896404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130955219268799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005955095402896404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005955095402896404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1562240570783615, + 0.06266745179891586, + 0.0678635761141777, + 0.06969594955444336, + 0.06263583898544312, + 0.09192439168691635, + 0.08793751895427704, + 0.12961463630199432, + 0.10331086069345474, + 0.168125718832016 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005955095402896404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person point-of-view perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera swing violently up and down with each footstep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered with dark soil, gnarled roots, and damp pine needles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do low-hanging branches with sharp green needles strike the camera and create motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by sharp golden rays piercing the canopy to create high contrast between bright light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00865045003592968 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758650302886963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00865045003592968, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00865045003592968, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07517170906066895, + 0.11101216822862625, + 0.08508719503879547, + 0.039647217839956284, + 0.06345897912979126, + 0.07171569019556046, + 0.126085564494133, + 0.05413052812218666, + 0.06797704845666885, + 0.3057138919830322 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00865045003592968 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person point-of-view perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera swing violently up and down with each footstep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered with dark soil, gnarled roots, and damp pine needles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do low-hanging branches with sharp green needles strike the camera and create motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by sharp golden rays piercing the canopy to create high contrast between bright light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10032670944929123 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503267765045166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10032670944929123, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10032670944929123, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16248688101768494, + 0.015073871240019798, + 0.014845225028693676, + 0.07447011768817902, + 0.0415794774889946, + 0.04270834103226662, + 0.13459990918636322, + 0.16160942614078522, + 0.07205768674612045, + 0.28056907653808594 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10032670944929123 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "frantic, erratic point-of-view shot plunges the viewer headfirst into a desperate, full-throttle run through a dense, claustrophobic forest of towering evergreens. The camera, representing the runner's eyes, swings violently up and down with each heavy footstep, which treads across a treacherous carpet of dark soil, gnarled roots, and damp pine needles, swerving erratically to narrowly avoid the thick, moss-covered trunks that crowd the frame. Low-hanging branches, laden with sharp green needles, lash violently at the camera, some striking with jarring force, momentarily obscuring vision and filling the periphery with chaotic motion blur. In the twilight hours, the low-hanging sun pierces the thick canopy, casting sharp golden rays that create disorienting flickers between blinding brightness and deep, oppressive shadows. This high-contrast world of deep forest greens and earthy browns, punctuated by fleeting bursts of brilliant golden sunlight, creates a palpable sense of panic and suffocating urgency, driven by relentless forward motion and a constant chaotic assault on the senses.", + "seed": 31497, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_5/index_5434_seed_31497_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.43339095143601297, + "vlm_logprob": -0.43339095143601297, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.43339095143601297, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person point-of-view perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera swing violently up and down with each footstep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered with dark soil, gnarled roots, and damp pine needles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do low-hanging branches with sharp green needles strike the camera and create motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by sharp golden rays piercing the canopy to create high contrast between bright light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07149221748113632 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8214921951293945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07149221748113632, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07149221748113632, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16702012717723846, + 0.18641987442970276, + 0.1892811506986618, + 0.07439941167831421, + 0.024646738544106483, + 0.08757752180099487, + 0.05144224315881729, + 0.03776552900671959, + 0.08555078506469727, + 0.0958966389298439 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07149221748113632 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person point-of-view perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera swing violently up and down with each footstep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered with dark soil, gnarled roots, and damp pine needles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do low-hanging branches with sharp green needles strike the camera and create motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by sharp golden rays piercing the canopy to create high contrast between bright light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020666122436523 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25206655263900757 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5020666122436523, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5020666122436523, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14490117132663727, + 0.22043459117412567, + 0.1588020920753479, + 0.036400314420461655, + 0.045729245990514755, + 0.13693110644817352, + 0.03719024732708931, + 0.023327330127358437, + 0.12287501990795135, + 0.07340889424085617 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5020666122436523 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person point-of-view perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera swing violently up and down with each footstep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered with dark soil, gnarled roots, and damp pine needles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do low-hanging branches with sharp green needles strike the camera and create motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by sharp golden rays piercing the canopy to create high contrast between bright light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004647762048989534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379647731781006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004647762048989534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004647762048989534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14789506793022156, + 0.2318427413702011, + 0.16828857362270355, + 0.0476459339261055, + 0.05062262341380119, + 0.033452410250902176, + 0.09046698361635208, + 0.08361396938562393, + 0.032794635742902756, + 0.11337703466415405 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004647762048989534 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person point-of-view perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera swing violently up and down with each footstep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered with dark soil, gnarled roots, and damp pine needles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do low-hanging branches with sharp green needles strike the camera and create motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by sharp golden rays piercing the canopy to create high contrast between bright light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012555130757391453 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387555122375488 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012555130757391453, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012555130757391453, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06519765406847, + 0.31500503420829773, + 0.12553653120994568, + 0.052390389144420624, + 0.05387406796216965, + 0.10815542936325073, + 0.07727093994617462, + 0.021881315857172012, + 0.04744258150458336, + 0.1332460641860962 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012555130757391453 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person point-of-view perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera swing violently up and down with each footstep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered with dark soil, gnarled roots, and damp pine needles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do low-hanging branches with sharp green needles strike the camera and create motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by sharp golden rays piercing the canopy to create high contrast between bright light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761930346488953 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261930346488953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761930346488953, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761930346488953, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23913288116455078, + 0.12251365184783936, + 0.12177099287509918, + 0.1040576919913292, + 0.03167400881648064, + 0.0506204254925251, + 0.032009951770305634, + 0.06529974937438965, + 0.16125598549842834, + 0.07166466861963272 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761930346488953 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "frantic, erratic point-of-view shot plunges the viewer headfirst into a desperate, full-throttle run through a dense, claustrophobic forest of towering evergreens. The camera, representing the runner's eyes, swings violently up and down with each heavy footstep, which treads across a treacherous carpet of dark soil, gnarled roots, and damp pine needles, swerving erratically to narrowly avoid the thick, moss-covered trunks that crowd the frame. Low-hanging branches, laden with sharp green needles, lash violently at the camera, some striking with jarring force, momentarily obscuring vision and filling the periphery with chaotic motion blur. In the twilight hours, the low-hanging sun pierces the thick canopy, casting sharp golden rays that create disorienting flickers between blinding brightness and deep, oppressive shadows. This high-contrast world of deep forest greens and earthy browns, punctuated by fleeting bursts of brilliant golden sunlight, creates a palpable sense of panic and suffocating urgency, driven by relentless forward motion and a constant chaotic assault on the senses.", + "seed": 31498, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_5/index_5434_seed_31498_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.32469588574022057, + "vlm_logprob": -0.32469588574022057, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.32469588574022057, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person point-of-view perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera swing violently up and down with each footstep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered with dark soil, gnarled roots, and damp pine needles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do low-hanging branches with sharp green needles strike the camera and create motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by sharp golden rays piercing the canopy to create high contrast between bright light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07278279960155487 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8227827548980713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07278279960155487, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07278279960155487, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10053913295269012, + 0.06307722628116608, + 0.11614334583282471, + 0.03947434574365616, + 0.20034483075141907, + 0.05175919085741043, + 0.0964631587266922, + 0.16795693337917328, + 0.13100051879882812, + 0.03324135020375252 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07278279960155487 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person point-of-view perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera swing violently up and down with each footstep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered with dark soil, gnarled roots, and damp pine needles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do low-hanging branches with sharp green needles strike the camera and create motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by sharp golden rays piercing the canopy to create high contrast between bright light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4062979221343994 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2812979519367218 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.4062979221343994, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -1.4062979221343994, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06923413276672363, + 0.056906718760728836, + 0.07057972252368927, + 0.06994412839412689, + 0.18397314846515656, + 0.036876507103443146, + 0.09063185006380081, + 0.09355323761701584, + 0.296182245016098, + 0.032118283212184906 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.4062979221343994 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person point-of-view perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera swing violently up and down with each footstep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered with dark soil, gnarled roots, and damp pine needles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do low-hanging branches with sharp green needles strike the camera and create motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by sharp golden rays piercing the canopy to create high contrast between bright light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008653759025037289 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75865364074707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008653759025037289, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008653759025037289, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09754776209592819, + 0.10302291810512543, + 0.04734009504318237, + 0.067892886698246, + 0.0369475893676281, + 0.07353799045085907, + 0.3649982810020447, + 0.09869381785392761, + 0.09178363531827927, + 0.018235070630908012 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008653759025037289 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person point-of-view perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera swing violently up and down with each footstep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered with dark soil, gnarled roots, and damp pine needles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do low-hanging branches with sharp green needles strike the camera and create motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by sharp golden rays piercing the canopy to create high contrast between bright light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00865836814045906 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758658409118652 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00865836814045906, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00865836814045906, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09049221128225327, + 0.06427324563264847, + 0.14693623781204224, + 0.11325059831142426, + 0.11914636194705963, + 0.060249920934438705, + 0.0667237788438797, + 0.061898671090602875, + 0.18080005049705505, + 0.09622892737388611 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00865836814045906 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person point-of-view perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera swing violently up and down with each footstep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground covered with dark soil, gnarled roots, and damp pine needles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do low-hanging branches with sharp green needles strike the camera and create motion blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by sharp golden rays piercing the canopy to create high contrast between bright light and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270865797996521 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127086639404297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270865797996521, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270865797996521, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08948364108800888, + 0.4309275448322296, + 0.0340319462120533, + 0.026201149448752403, + 0.02278902195394039, + 0.07675784081220627, + 0.042729754000902176, + 0.0561867281794548, + 0.20678772032260895, + 0.01410460565239191 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270865797996521 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_6/index_tensor([672, 672])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_6/index_tensor([672, 672])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..54e8f3a39bc9c02298e39794f84ed3f0740d36f7 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_6/index_tensor([672, 672])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from an upward angle, the camera steady, captures a boy, perhaps five or six, with short, shaggy brown hair, a few strands clinging to his forehead with excitement, his cheeks flushed with exertion. He wears a slightly baggy striped T-shirt and dark blue gym shorts, barefoot, and straddles a sturdy wooden dining chair, imagining it as a majestic warhorse. This takes place in a cozy family living room, against a backdrop of softly carpeted wood floors and a distant corner of a sofa. The boy grips the top of the chair's backrest tightly, as if it were the reins of a warhorse. He throws his entire weight forward, lifting the chair's front legs heavily off the ground. Then, with all his might, he throws his weight backward, leaving the back legs practically suspended in the air, achieving a precarious yet exhilarating balance. Soft afternoon sunlight slants through the window, illuminating the chair's smooth surface, reflecting a warm patina and casting rapidly shifting shadows on the floor with each violent sway. His eyes were wide open, flashing with concentration and wildness, his mouth was tightly closed, but the corners of his mouth could not help but rise slightly, revealing a pure, immersive joy. The whole scene was full of pure childhood imagination, fearless energy and an ambition to conquer the world. The atmosphere was both dynamic and warm.", + "seed": 32287, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_6/index_672_seed_32287_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04348583957180381, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04348583957180381, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04348583957180381, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a cozy family living room with wood floors and a sofa visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a slightly baggy striped T-shirt and dark blue gym shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the boy straddling a sturdy wooden dining chair and gripping the backrest tightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy lift the chair's front legs off the ground and then throw his weight backward to suspend the back legs in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot from an upward angle with the camera remaining steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03928566724061966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.289285659790039 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03928566724061966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03928566724061966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4398074448108673, + 0.039011355489492416, + 0.12126597762107849, + 0.12390065938234329, + 0.02594713121652603, + 0.028870372101664543, + 0.09128530323505402, + 0.02805873192846775, + 0.04578161612153053, + 0.05607135221362114 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03928566724061966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a cozy family living room with wood floors and a sofa visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a slightly baggy striped T-shirt and dark blue gym shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the boy straddling a sturdy wooden dining chair and gripping the backrest tightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy lift the chair's front legs off the ground and then throw his weight backward to suspend the back legs in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot from an upward angle with the camera remaining steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006761173252016306 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006761074066162 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006761173252016306, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006761173252016306, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10438474267721176, + 0.030161894857883453, + 0.15092511475086212, + 0.0479973666369915, + 0.12264692038297653, + 0.07914548367261887, + 0.05310662090778351, + 0.175114706158638, + 0.08273961395025253, + 0.15377748012542725 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006761173252016306 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a cozy family living room with wood floors and a sofa visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a slightly baggy striped T-shirt and dark blue gym shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the boy straddling a sturdy wooden dining chair and gripping the backrest tightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy lift the chair's front legs off the ground and then throw his weight backward to suspend the back legs in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot from an upward angle with the camera remaining steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607775315642357 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141077518463135 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607775315642357, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607775315642357, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21485015749931335, + 0.0666646733880043, + 0.1612285077571869, + 0.06209878250956535, + 0.07113417237997055, + 0.05864139646291733, + 0.10461551696062088, + 0.09153041988611221, + 0.10694095492362976, + 0.06229538470506668 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607775315642357 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a cozy family living room with wood floors and a sofa visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a slightly baggy striped T-shirt and dark blue gym shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the boy straddling a sturdy wooden dining chair and gripping the backrest tightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy lift the chair's front legs off the ground and then throw his weight backward to suspend the back legs in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot from an upward angle with the camera remaining steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012542181648314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387542247772217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012542181648314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012542181648314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1645752489566803, + 0.23890161514282227, + 0.10868137329816818, + 0.12177225202322006, + 0.09930509328842163, + 0.04686858505010605, + 0.046284664422273636, + 0.051945433020591736, + 0.06810888648033142, + 0.05355685576796532 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012542181648314 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a cozy family living room with wood floors and a sofa visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a slightly baggy striped T-shirt and dark blue gym shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the boy straddling a sturdy wooden dining chair and gripping the backrest tightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy lift the chair's front legs off the ground and then throw his weight backward to suspend the back legs in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot from an upward angle with the camera remaining steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1427624225616455 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0177624225616455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1427624225616455, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1427624225616455, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23792581260204315, + 0.06980918347835541, + 0.09184196591377258, + 0.2151120901107788, + 0.05976760387420654, + 0.0809505432844162, + 0.05417488142848015, + 0.054614655673503876, + 0.07768218219280243, + 0.058121103793382645 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1427624225616455 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from an upward angle, the camera steady, captures a boy, perhaps five or six, with short, shaggy brown hair, a few strands clinging to his forehead with excitement, his cheeks flushed with exertion. He wears a slightly baggy striped T-shirt and dark blue gym shorts, barefoot, and straddles a sturdy wooden dining chair, imagining it as a majestic warhorse. This takes place in a cozy family living room, against a backdrop of softly carpeted wood floors and a distant corner of a sofa. The boy grips the top of the chair's backrest tightly, as if it were the reins of a warhorse. He throws his entire weight forward, lifting the chair's front legs heavily off the ground. Then, with all his might, he throws his weight backward, leaving the back legs practically suspended in the air, achieving a precarious yet exhilarating balance. Soft afternoon sunlight slants through the window, illuminating the chair's smooth surface, reflecting a warm patina and casting rapidly shifting shadows on the floor with each violent sway. His eyes were wide open, flashing with concentration and wildness, his mouth was tightly closed, but the corners of his mouth could not help but rise slightly, revealing a pure, immersive joy. The whole scene was full of pure childhood imagination, fearless energy and an ambition to conquer the world. The atmosphere was both dynamic and warm.", + "seed": 32288, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_6/index_672_seed_32288_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0844664577394724, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0844664577394724, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0844664577394724, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a cozy family living room with wood floors and a sofa visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a slightly baggy striped T-shirt and dark blue gym shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the boy straddling a sturdy wooden dining chair and gripping the backrest tightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy lift the chair's front legs off the ground and then throw his weight backward to suspend the back legs in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot from an upward angle with the camera remaining steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03883305564522743 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2888331413269043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03883305564522743, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03883305564522743, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14970582723617554, + 0.09697340428829193, + 0.10618031769990921, + 0.12540778517723083, + 0.07359827309846878, + 0.03820504620671272, + 0.04407048597931862, + 0.11425869166851044, + 0.08579885214567184, + 0.1658012866973877 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03883305564522743 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a cozy family living room with wood floors and a sofa visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a slightly baggy striped T-shirt and dark blue gym shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the boy straddling a sturdy wooden dining chair and gripping the backrest tightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy lift the chair's front legs off the ground and then throw his weight backward to suspend the back legs in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot from an upward angle with the camera remaining steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01255913358181715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387558937072754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01255913358181715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01255913358181715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06480172276496887, + 0.05704156309366226, + 0.1919059455394745, + 0.16122189164161682, + 0.04776967689394951, + 0.0514356903731823, + 0.022034713998436928, + 0.10314542800188065, + 0.21252913773059845, + 0.08811426162719727 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01255913358181715 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a cozy family living room with wood floors and a sofa visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a slightly baggy striped T-shirt and dark blue gym shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the boy straddling a sturdy wooden dining chair and gripping the backrest tightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy lift the chair's front legs off the ground and then throw his weight backward to suspend the back legs in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot from an upward angle with the camera remaining steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009792503900825977 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634792327880859 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009792503900825977, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009792503900825977, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07083461433649063, + 0.0640028566122055, + 0.1332947313785553, + 0.20381686091423035, + 0.05409371480345726, + 0.03196907043457031, + 0.047200482338666916, + 0.09913507103919983, + 0.13027456402778625, + 0.16537804901599884 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009792503900825977 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a cozy family living room with wood floors and a sofa visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a slightly baggy striped T-shirt and dark blue gym shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the boy straddling a sturdy wooden dining chair and gripping the backrest tightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy lift the chair's front legs off the ground and then throw his weight backward to suspend the back legs in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot from an upward angle with the camera remaining steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01254771463572979 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387547492980957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01254771463572979, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01254771463572979, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09325262904167175, + 0.04375673085451126, + 0.293168842792511, + 0.1727018505334854, + 0.05722954496741295, + 0.021566318348050117, + 0.06773436814546585, + 0.0575665719807148, + 0.07627923786640167, + 0.11674396693706512 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01254771463572979 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a cozy family living room with wood floors and a sofa visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a slightly baggy striped T-shirt and dark blue gym shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the boy straddling a sturdy wooden dining chair and gripping the backrest tightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy lift the chair's front legs off the ground and then throw his weight backward to suspend the back legs in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot from an upward angle with the camera remaining steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3485998809337616 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223599910736084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3485998809337616, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3485998809337616, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07789316773414612, + 0.09520772844552994, + 0.4231813848018646, + 0.22366510331630707, + 0.02337578311562538, + 0.017954546958208084, + 0.032532189041376114, + 0.036433786153793335, + 0.028777725994586945, + 0.0409785732626915 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3485998809337616 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from an upward angle, the camera steady, captures a boy, perhaps five or six, with short, shaggy brown hair, a few strands clinging to his forehead with excitement, his cheeks flushed with exertion. He wears a slightly baggy striped T-shirt and dark blue gym shorts, barefoot, and straddles a sturdy wooden dining chair, imagining it as a majestic warhorse. This takes place in a cozy family living room, against a backdrop of softly carpeted wood floors and a distant corner of a sofa. The boy grips the top of the chair's backrest tightly, as if it were the reins of a warhorse. He throws his entire weight forward, lifting the chair's front legs heavily off the ground. Then, with all his might, he throws his weight backward, leaving the back legs practically suspended in the air, achieving a precarious yet exhilarating balance. Soft afternoon sunlight slants through the window, illuminating the chair's smooth surface, reflecting a warm patina and casting rapidly shifting shadows on the floor with each violent sway. His eyes were wide open, flashing with concentration and wildness, his mouth was tightly closed, but the corners of his mouth could not help but rise slightly, revealing a pure, immersive joy. The whole scene was full of pure childhood imagination, fearless energy and an ambition to conquer the world. The atmosphere was both dynamic and warm.", + "seed": 32289, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_6/index_672_seed_32289_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04685361422598362, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04685361422598362, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04685361422598362, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a cozy family living room with wood floors and a sofa visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a slightly baggy striped T-shirt and dark blue gym shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the boy straddling a sturdy wooden dining chair and gripping the backrest tightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy lift the chair's front legs off the ground and then throw his weight backward to suspend the back legs in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot from an upward angle with the camera remaining steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03463805839419365 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4096381664276123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03463805839419365, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03463805839419365, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3161064386367798, + 0.05788443982601166, + 0.049587883055210114, + 0.21429923176765442, + 0.052471183240413666, + 0.023535268381237984, + 0.010168629698455334, + 0.026385359466075897, + 0.21566325426101685, + 0.03389836475253105 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03463805839419365 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a cozy family living room with wood floors and a sofa visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a slightly baggy striped T-shirt and dark blue gym shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the boy straddling a sturdy wooden dining chair and gripping the backrest tightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy lift the chair's front legs off the ground and then throw his weight backward to suspend the back legs in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot from an upward angle with the camera remaining steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012558309361338615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387558460235596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012558309361338615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012558309361338615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7097371816635132, + 0.04121088236570358, + 0.028621627017855644, + 0.03886847570538521, + 0.02775443159043789, + 0.01921447180211544, + 0.004973325878381729, + 0.022039474919438362, + 0.08273027837276459, + 0.02484983205795288 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012558309361338615 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a cozy family living room with wood floors and a sofa visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a slightly baggy striped T-shirt and dark blue gym shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the boy straddling a sturdy wooden dining chair and gripping the backrest tightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy lift the chair's front legs off the ground and then throw his weight backward to suspend the back legs in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot from an upward angle with the camera remaining steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012546183541417122 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387546062469482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012546183541417122, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012546183541417122, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5945271253585815, + 0.061849236488342285, + 0.08666179329156876, + 0.03550739213824272, + 0.09553943574428558, + 0.020803125575184822, + 0.016699256375432014, + 0.020252808928489685, + 0.050994761288166046, + 0.01716507598757744 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012546183541417122 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a cozy family living room with wood floors and a sofa visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a slightly baggy striped T-shirt and dark blue gym shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the boy straddling a sturdy wooden dining chair and gripping the backrest tightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy lift the chair's front legs off the ground and then throw his weight backward to suspend the back legs in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot from an upward angle with the camera remaining steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014202704653143883 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26420259475708 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014202704653143883, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014202704653143883, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36609718203544617, + 0.104134701192379, + 0.12537500262260437, + 0.13705262541770935, + 0.04287154972553253, + 0.0631018728017807, + 0.04304393753409386, + 0.02406524494290352, + 0.05210522562265396, + 0.042152684181928635 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014202704653143883 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a cozy family living room with wood floors and a sofa visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a slightly baggy striped T-shirt and dark blue gym shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the boy straddling a sturdy wooden dining chair and gripping the backrest tightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy lift the chair's front legs off the ground and then throw his weight backward to suspend the back legs in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot from an upward angle with the camera remaining steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16032281517982483 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103227853775024 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16032281517982483, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16032281517982483, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.734592616558075, + 0.045469872653484344, + 0.04548563435673714, + 0.025512175634503365, + 0.041578423231840134, + 0.02935563586652279, + 0.02454644814133644, + 0.019412213936448097, + 0.020127780735492706, + 0.013919170014560223 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16032281517982483 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from an upward angle, the camera steady, captures a boy, perhaps five or six, with short, shaggy brown hair, a few strands clinging to his forehead with excitement, his cheeks flushed with exertion. He wears a slightly baggy striped T-shirt and dark blue gym shorts, barefoot, and straddles a sturdy wooden dining chair, imagining it as a majestic warhorse. This takes place in a cozy family living room, against a backdrop of softly carpeted wood floors and a distant corner of a sofa. The boy grips the top of the chair's backrest tightly, as if it were the reins of a warhorse. He throws his entire weight forward, lifting the chair's front legs heavily off the ground. Then, with all his might, he throws his weight backward, leaving the back legs practically suspended in the air, achieving a precarious yet exhilarating balance. Soft afternoon sunlight slants through the window, illuminating the chair's smooth surface, reflecting a warm patina and casting rapidly shifting shadows on the floor with each violent sway. His eyes were wide open, flashing with concentration and wildness, his mouth was tightly closed, but the corners of his mouth could not help but rise slightly, revealing a pure, immersive joy. The whole scene was full of pure childhood imagination, fearless energy and an ambition to conquer the world. The atmosphere was both dynamic and warm.", + "seed": 32290, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_6/index_672_seed_32290_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.030875799618661402, + "vlm_logprob": -0.030875799618661402, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.030875799618661402, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a cozy family living room with wood floors and a sofa visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a slightly baggy striped T-shirt and dark blue gym shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the boy straddling a sturdy wooden dining chair and gripping the backrest tightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy lift the chair's front legs off the ground and then throw his weight backward to suspend the back legs in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot from an upward angle with the camera remaining steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.024245774373412132 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7742457389831543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.024245774373412132, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.024245774373412132, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18863174319267273, + 0.1448885053396225, + 0.15410000085830688, + 0.08297712355852127, + 0.0909426286816597, + 0.03142212703824043, + 0.04768383502960205, + 0.13985513150691986, + 0.047249697148799896, + 0.07224919646978378 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.024245774373412132 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a cozy family living room with wood floors and a sofa visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a slightly baggy striped T-shirt and dark blue gym shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the boy straddling a sturdy wooden dining chair and gripping the backrest tightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy lift the chair's front legs off the ground and then throw his weight backward to suspend the back legs in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot from an upward angle with the camera remaining steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008661322295665741 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758661270141602 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008661322295665741, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008661322295665741, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06805174052715302, + 0.08339137583971024, + 0.06994075328111649, + 0.056829389184713364, + 0.33647310733795166, + 0.03982869163155556, + 0.030538281425833702, + 0.20542113482952118, + 0.04691974073648453, + 0.06260571628808975 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008661322295665741 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a cozy family living room with wood floors and a sofa visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a slightly baggy striped T-shirt and dark blue gym shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the boy straddling a sturdy wooden dining chair and gripping the backrest tightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy lift the chair's front legs off the ground and then throw his weight backward to suspend the back legs in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot from an upward angle with the camera remaining steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008646667934954166 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758646488189697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008646667934954166, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008646667934954166, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11450662463903427, + 0.09431146085262299, + 0.06916804611682892, + 0.2530834674835205, + 0.11495186388492584, + 0.07440787553787231, + 0.07064379006624222, + 0.03529663756489754, + 0.1132572814822197, + 0.06037292256951332 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008646667934954166 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a cozy family living room with wood floors and a sofa visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a slightly baggy striped T-shirt and dark blue gym shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the boy straddling a sturdy wooden dining chair and gripping the backrest tightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy lift the chair's front legs off the ground and then throw his weight backward to suspend the back legs in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot from an upward angle with the camera remaining steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012544889003038406 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387545108795166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012544889003038406, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012544889003038406, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1323290467262268, + 0.06924266368150711, + 0.16244114935398102, + 0.14235025644302368, + 0.1415393352508545, + 0.058553408831357956, + 0.05892636626958847, + 0.037159912288188934, + 0.13434650003910065, + 0.06311142444610596 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012544889003038406 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a cozy family living room with wood floors and a sofa visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the boy wearing a slightly baggy striped T-shirt and dark blue gym shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the boy straddling a sturdy wooden dining chair and gripping the backrest tightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the boy lift the chair's front legs off the ground and then throw his weight backward to suspend the back legs in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot from an upward angle with the camera remaining steady?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10028034448623657 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350280284881592 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10028034448623657, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10028034448623657, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13487793505191803, + 0.18884631991386414, + 0.18122699856758118, + 0.06351423263549805, + 0.07782038301229477, + 0.07040160149335861, + 0.08147723972797394, + 0.05684715509414673, + 0.08915784955024719, + 0.05583030357956886 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10028034448623657 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_7/index_tensor([9598, 9598])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_7/index_tensor([9598, 9598])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b590ed4ce88de75e5a36a0302ccbe5732bbc3378 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_7/index_tensor([9598, 9598])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, wide-angle shot captures the dramatic and chaotic scene of a stream of weathered, rough-hewn wooden crates relentlessly cascading down a steep, sun-drenched grassy slope. The crates, varying in size and crafted from pale, unfinished pine trees, tumble and bounce uncontrollably along the vibrant green slope, dotted with small rocks and exposed dirt. Bathed in the golden, low-angle light of the late afternoon sun, each crate casts a long, fast-moving shadow. As they descend, they violently collide with each other and the uneven ground, disintegrating spectacularly upon impact. They burst apart in deafening explosions, sending sharp, pale wooden splinters and clouds of fine dust into the air, creating a visually stunning yet destructive scene filled with raw kinetic energy and a palpable sense of unstoppable momentum.", + "seed": 3326, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_7/index_9598_seed_3326_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.3196254374459386, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3196254374459386, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3196254374459386, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are weathered, rough-hewn wooden crates visible cascading down a steep grassy slope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the crates made of pale, unfinished pine wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the crates violently collide, disintegrate, and explode into splinters and dust upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in golden, low-angle light casting long, fast-moving shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05703078582882881 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.05703067779541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05703078582882881, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05703078582882881, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12108422815799713, + 0.05640596151351929, + 0.08854430168867111, + 0.19990649819374084, + 0.05929800122976303, + 0.14588607847690582, + 0.08614958822727203, + 0.04462582617998123, + 0.16033180058002472, + 0.037767697125673294 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05703078582882881 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are weathered, rough-hewn wooden crates visible cascading down a steep grassy slope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the crates made of pale, unfinished pine wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the crates violently collide, disintegrate, and explode into splinters and dust upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in golden, low-angle light casting long, fast-moving shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008660731837153435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758660793304443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008660731837153435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008660731837153435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11737614870071411, + 0.04525581747293472, + 0.12124153971672058, + 0.13262797892093658, + 0.05021028220653534, + 0.060161102563142776, + 0.06382785737514496, + 0.0275028795003891, + 0.3564373254776001, + 0.02535908855497837 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008660731837153435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are weathered, rough-hewn wooden crates visible cascading down a steep grassy slope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the crates made of pale, unfinished pine wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the crates violently collide, disintegrate, and explode into splinters and dust upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in golden, low-angle light casting long, fast-moving shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059386856853962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955938816070557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059386856853962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059386856853962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05906011164188385, + 0.09653060138225555, + 0.1449875831604004, + 0.2197001874446869, + 0.19314290583133698, + 0.04136262461543083, + 0.02717951126396656, + 0.026571471244096756, + 0.1601577252149582, + 0.03130735829472542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059386856853962 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are weathered, rough-hewn wooden crates visible cascading down a steep grassy slope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the crates made of pale, unfinished pine wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the crates violently collide, disintegrate, and explode into splinters and dust upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in golden, low-angle light casting long, fast-moving shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020462274551392 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25204625725746155 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5020462274551392, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5020462274551392, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0691305622458458, + 0.07392118871212006, + 0.18478114902973175, + 0.24578990042209625, + 0.07961703091859818, + 0.06888679414987564, + 0.04153338074684143, + 0.08051888644695282, + 0.1117669865489006, + 0.044054120779037476 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5020462274551392 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are weathered, rough-hewn wooden crates visible cascading down a steep grassy slope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the crates made of pale, unfinished pine wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the crates violently collide, disintegrate, and explode into splinters and dust upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in golden, low-angle light casting long, fast-moving shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00979557354003191 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634795665740967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00979557354003191, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00979557354003191, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08200972527265549, + 0.0413801372051239, + 0.20887398719787598, + 0.18947359919548035, + 0.04284258559346199, + 0.0960002914071083, + 0.13038985431194305, + 0.08620133996009827, + 0.07095839083194733, + 0.05187010392546654 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00979557354003191 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, wide-angle shot captures the dramatic and chaotic scene of a stream of weathered, rough-hewn wooden crates relentlessly cascading down a steep, sun-drenched grassy slope. The crates, varying in size and crafted from pale, unfinished pine trees, tumble and bounce uncontrollably along the vibrant green slope, dotted with small rocks and exposed dirt. Bathed in the golden, low-angle light of the late afternoon sun, each crate casts a long, fast-moving shadow. As they descend, they violently collide with each other and the uneven ground, disintegrating spectacularly upon impact. They burst apart in deafening explosions, sending sharp, pale wooden splinters and clouds of fine dust into the air, creating a visually stunning yet destructive scene filled with raw kinetic energy and a palpable sense of unstoppable momentum.", + "seed": 3327, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_7/index_9598_seed_3327_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.40363132655620576, + "vlm_logprob": -0.40363132655620576, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.40363132655620576, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are weathered, rough-hewn wooden crates visible cascading down a steep grassy slope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the crates made of pale, unfinished pine wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the crates violently collide, disintegrate, and explode into splinters and dust upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in golden, low-angle light casting long, fast-moving shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.035631775856018066 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5356316566467285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.035631775856018066, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.035631775856018066, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13209420442581177, + 0.07012494653463364, + 0.04855581000447273, + 0.09136710315942764, + 0.05310387536883354, + 0.07642315328121185, + 0.21331451833248138, + 0.0486128069460392, + 0.11989414691925049, + 0.14650945365428925 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.035631775856018066 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are weathered, rough-hewn wooden crates visible cascading down a steep grassy slope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the crates made of pale, unfinished pine wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the crates violently collide, disintegrate, and explode into splinters and dust upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in golden, low-angle light casting long, fast-moving shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012564901262521744 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875651359558105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012564901262521744, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012564901262521744, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11384212970733643, + 0.050871532410383224, + 0.1010817438364029, + 0.08265703171491623, + 0.05227681249380112, + 0.07361460477113724, + 0.3482617139816284, + 0.0687997043132782, + 0.03511025384068489, + 0.07348444312810898 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012564901262521744 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are weathered, rough-hewn wooden crates visible cascading down a steep grassy slope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the crates made of pale, unfinished pine wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the crates violently collide, disintegrate, and explode into splinters and dust upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in golden, low-angle light casting long, fast-moving shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029809314757585526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298092365264893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029809314757585526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029809314757585526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0916784256696701, + 0.09118659049272537, + 0.11250488460063934, + 0.09672840684652328, + 0.10960577428340912, + 0.056036703288555145, + 0.23241128027439117, + 0.09868952631950378, + 0.03051457740366459, + 0.08064379543066025 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029809314757585526 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are weathered, rough-hewn wooden crates visible cascading down a steep grassy slope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the crates made of pale, unfinished pine wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the crates violently collide, disintegrate, and explode into splinters and dust upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in golden, low-angle light casting long, fast-moving shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103198051452637 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16031977534294128 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.9103198051452637, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.9103198051452637, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.039366815239191055, + 0.040885258466005325, + 0.03758638724684715, + 0.04353468492627144, + 0.03907151520252228, + 0.023711200803518295, + 0.6114906072616577, + 0.04303136095404625, + 0.030469072982668877, + 0.09085311740636826 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.9103198051452637 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are weathered, rough-hewn wooden crates visible cascading down a steep grassy slope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the crates made of pale, unfinished pine wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the crates violently collide, disintegrate, and explode into splinters and dust upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in golden, low-angle light casting long, fast-moving shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02983083575963974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298309326171875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02983083575963974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02983083575963974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08950314670801163, + 0.03742928057909012, + 0.027271002531051636, + 0.03764811158180237, + 0.03062451258301735, + 0.01848578080534935, + 0.536700963973999, + 0.040279339998960495, + 0.04945788159966469, + 0.13259997963905334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02983083575963974 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, wide-angle shot captures the dramatic and chaotic scene of a stream of weathered, rough-hewn wooden crates relentlessly cascading down a steep, sun-drenched grassy slope. The crates, varying in size and crafted from pale, unfinished pine trees, tumble and bounce uncontrollably along the vibrant green slope, dotted with small rocks and exposed dirt. Bathed in the golden, low-angle light of the late afternoon sun, each crate casts a long, fast-moving shadow. As they descend, they violently collide with each other and the uneven ground, disintegrating spectacularly upon impact. They burst apart in deafening explosions, sending sharp, pale wooden splinters and clouds of fine dust into the air, creating a visually stunning yet destructive scene filled with raw kinetic energy and a palpable sense of unstoppable momentum.", + "seed": 3328, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_7/index_9598_seed_3328_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.3427826926112175, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3427826926112175, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3427826926112175, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are weathered, rough-hewn wooden crates visible cascading down a steep grassy slope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the crates made of pale, unfinished pine wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the crates violently collide, disintegrate, and explode into splinters and dust upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in golden, low-angle light casting long, fast-moving shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.044663332402706146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.294663429260254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.044663332402706146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.044663332402706146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12268040329217911, + 0.060645464807748795, + 0.1116659939289093, + 0.05928729847073555, + 0.03638185188174248, + 0.05500272288918495, + 0.07798674702644348, + 0.35867732763290405, + 0.07355284690856934, + 0.044119320809841156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.044663332402706146 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are weathered, rough-hewn wooden crates visible cascading down a steep grassy slope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the crates made of pale, unfinished pine wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the crates violently collide, disintegrate, and explode into splinters and dust upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in golden, low-angle light casting long, fast-moving shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029821693897247314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298216342926025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029821693897247314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029821693897247314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0881614238023758, + 0.057571109384298325, + 0.1087828129529953, + 0.05694764479994774, + 0.04238259047269821, + 0.11327937990427017, + 0.02739284746348858, + 0.44953295588493347, + 0.02093658037483692, + 0.035012729465961456 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029821693897247314 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are weathered, rough-hewn wooden crates visible cascading down a steep grassy slope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the crates made of pale, unfinished pine wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the crates violently collide, disintegrate, and explode into splinters and dust upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in golden, low-angle light casting long, fast-moving shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026352928951382637 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651352882385254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026352928951382637, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026352928951382637, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08932732790708542, + 0.13252006471157074, + 0.10020888596773148, + 0.06465350836515427, + 0.11177346110343933, + 0.07692626118659973, + 0.03866509348154068, + 0.3013868033885956, + 0.03535879775881767, + 0.04917970299720764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026352928951382637 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are weathered, rough-hewn wooden crates visible cascading down a steep grassy slope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the crates made of pale, unfinished pine wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the crates violently collide, disintegrate, and explode into splinters and dust upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in golden, low-angle light casting long, fast-moving shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005207300186157 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22552071511745453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.6005207300186157, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.6005207300186157, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06094195693731308, + 0.05426374450325966, + 0.09160422533750534, + 0.06281117349863052, + 0.027253136038780212, + 0.11152637004852295, + 0.16937676072120667, + 0.36656081676483154, + 0.02961079031229019, + 0.026051005348563194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.6005207300186157 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are weathered, rough-hewn wooden crates visible cascading down a steep grassy slope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the crates made of pale, unfinished pine wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the crates violently collide, disintegrate, and explode into splinters and dust upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in golden, low-angle light casting long, fast-moving shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012554777786135674 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38755464553833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012554777786135674, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012554777786135674, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09936321526765823, + 0.06216839328408241, + 0.1284588873386383, + 0.03550756350159645, + 0.034072645008563995, + 0.09253271669149399, + 0.0781543031334877, + 0.213004469871521, + 0.13268214464187622, + 0.12405567616224289 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012554777786135674 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, wide-angle shot captures the dramatic and chaotic scene of a stream of weathered, rough-hewn wooden crates relentlessly cascading down a steep, sun-drenched grassy slope. The crates, varying in size and crafted from pale, unfinished pine trees, tumble and bounce uncontrollably along the vibrant green slope, dotted with small rocks and exposed dirt. Bathed in the golden, low-angle light of the late afternoon sun, each crate casts a long, fast-moving shadow. As they descend, they violently collide with each other and the uneven ground, disintegrating spectacularly upon impact. They burst apart in deafening explosions, sending sharp, pale wooden splinters and clouds of fine dust into the air, creating a visually stunning yet destructive scene filled with raw kinetic energy and a palpable sense of unstoppable momentum.", + "seed": 3329, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_7/index_9598_seed_3329_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.41027323752641676, + "vlm_logprob": -0.41027323752641676, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.349999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.41027323752641676, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are weathered, rough-hewn wooden crates visible cascading down a steep grassy slope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the crates made of pale, unfinished pine wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the crates violently collide, disintegrate, and explode into splinters and dust upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in golden, low-angle light casting long, fast-moving shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.13599975407123566 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1359996795654297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.13599975407123566, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.13599975407123566, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15210287272930145, + 0.07601708173751831, + 0.09034133702516556, + 0.06207415089011192, + 0.18126633763313293, + 0.0291119571775198, + 0.043693527579307556, + 0.11029070615768433, + 0.04548193886876106, + 0.20962005853652954 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.13599975407123566 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are weathered, rough-hewn wooden crates visible cascading down a steep grassy slope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the crates made of pale, unfinished pine wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the crates violently collide, disintegrate, and explode into splinters and dust upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in golden, low-angle light casting long, fast-moving shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38707518577575684 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370751857757568 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38707518577575684, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38707518577575684, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3214253783226013, + 0.16532550752162933, + 0.09455642104148865, + 0.029887249693274498, + 0.057950615882873535, + 0.06391981989145279, + 0.06581664830446243, + 0.035381097346544266, + 0.04748648777604103, + 0.11825080215930939 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38707518577575684 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are weathered, rough-hewn wooden crates visible cascading down a steep grassy slope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the crates made of pale, unfinished pine wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the crates violently collide, disintegrate, and explode into splinters and dust upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in golden, low-angle light casting long, fast-moving shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813604772090912 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063605070114136 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813604772090912, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813604772090912, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24768052995204926, + 0.11406732350587845, + 0.09650072455406189, + 0.044899243861436844, + 0.1378290057182312, + 0.08061663061380386, + 0.07695569843053818, + 0.06478645652532578, + 0.07576059550046921, + 0.060903776437044144 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813604772090912 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are weathered, rough-hewn wooden crates visible cascading down a steep grassy slope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the crates made of pale, unfinished pine wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the crates violently collide, disintegrate, and explode into splinters and dust upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in golden, low-angle light casting long, fast-moving shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236119508743286 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486119210720062 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2236119508743286, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2236119508743286, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07218882441520691, + 0.056898221373558044, + 0.04228243604302406, + 0.04322722181677818, + 0.043572746217250824, + 0.07360617071390152, + 0.14497455954551697, + 0.06454133987426758, + 0.1583053171634674, + 0.3004031479358673 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2236119508743286 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are weathered, rough-hewn wooden crates visible cascading down a steep grassy slope?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the crates made of pale, unfinished pine wood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the crates violently collide, disintegrate, and explode into splinters and dust upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in golden, low-angle light casting long, fast-moving shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0233188197016716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733187675476074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0233188197016716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0233188197016716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12058447301387787, + 0.1030782163143158, + 0.04440419003367424, + 0.05054536089301109, + 0.1485116183757782, + 0.0275617316365242, + 0.08052579313516617, + 0.03613758832216263, + 0.09260234236717224, + 0.29604870080947876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0233188197016716 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_8/index_tensor([1349, 1349])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_8/index_tensor([1349, 1349])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3e5778288cdc7a358fe535f3cc64ddc3bdc30a9a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_8/index_tensor([1349, 1349])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, upward-tilting close-up shot from a low angle captures a solemn and vivid moment in a corner of the Forbidden City. The scene unfolds under the bright afternoon sun, whose intense, directional light vividly depicts the texture of the deep vermilion palace walls, revealing the subtle mottled marks left by time. The camera pans upward, passing over rows of glazed golden tiles that gleam with an almost liquid sheen in the sunlight, their iconic eaves tracing graceful curves against the azure sky. The visual centerpiece is a massive, bright yellow flag woven from heavy silk, affixed to a tall pole. It unfurls and billows powerfully and gracefully against the strong wind. The wind creates slow, deep undulations on its surface, and the intricate dragon motifs meticulously embroidered with gold and red silk thread seem to come alive as the flag flutters, shimmering and fading in the light. The color saturation of the entire scene is extremely high. The vermilion of the wall, the bright yellow of the tiles and flags, and the deep blue of the sky create a strong visual impact. The light casts sharp and deep shadows on the edges of objects, enhancing the three-dimensional sense and texture of the picture, perfectly reproducing the iconic capture of vivid colors, strong light and shadow contrasts, and instantaneous dynamics in Steve McCurry's works, creating a historical atmosphere that is both magnificent and full of vitality.", + "seed": 2783, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_8/index_1349_seed_2783_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.022072499524801968, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022072499524801968, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022072499524801968, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a corner of the Forbidden City featuring deep vermilion palace walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slow, upward-tilting close-up from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bright yellow flag made of heavy silk visible, billowing in the wind with intricate gold and red dragon motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight casting sharp, deep shadows and revealing mottled marks on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color saturation extremely high with strong visual impact from the vermilion, yellow, and azure blue colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05110849067568779 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0511085987091064 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05110849067568779, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05110849067568779, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0628027617931366, + 0.03726883605122566, + 0.03802480176091194, + 0.09265324473381042, + 0.0228629931807518, + 0.043985914438962936, + 0.01837371475994587, + 0.027775079011917114, + 0.6210612654685974, + 0.035191405564546585 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05110849067568779 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a corner of the Forbidden City featuring deep vermilion palace walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slow, upward-tilting close-up from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bright yellow flag made of heavy silk visible, billowing in the wind with intricate gold and red dragon motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight casting sharp, deep shadows and revealing mottled marks on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color saturation extremely high with strong visual impact from the vermilion, yellow, and azure blue colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812460973858833 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881245613098145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812460973858833, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812460973858833, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03466420620679855, + 0.032475102692842484, + 0.06986922770738602, + 0.06972775608301163, + 0.030468005686998367, + 0.03720109164714813, + 0.04535454139113426, + 0.07816532999277115, + 0.5543383955955505, + 0.04773638769984245 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812460973858833 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a corner of the Forbidden City featuring deep vermilion palace walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slow, upward-tilting close-up from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bright yellow flag made of heavy silk visible, billowing in the wind with intricate gold and red dragon motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight casting sharp, deep shadows and revealing mottled marks on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color saturation extremely high with strong visual impact from the vermilion, yellow, and azure blue colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004105829633772373 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504106044769287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004105829633772373, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004105829633772373, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06535230576992035, + 0.025398405268788338, + 0.05034477636218071, + 0.04404711350798607, + 0.018346522003412247, + 0.04800727218389511, + 0.047939978539943695, + 0.042941201478242874, + 0.563724160194397, + 0.09389813989400864 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004105829633772373 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a corner of the Forbidden City featuring deep vermilion palace walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slow, upward-tilting close-up from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bright yellow flag made of heavy silk visible, billowing in the wind with intricate gold and red dragon motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight casting sharp, deep shadows and revealing mottled marks on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color saturation extremely high with strong visual impact from the vermilion, yellow, and azure blue colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01419729832559824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26419734954834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01419729832559824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01419729832559824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02175109088420868, + 0.025370335206389427, + 0.028023207560181618, + 0.04881122335791588, + 0.014507336542010307, + 0.018154408782720566, + 0.013913455419242382, + 0.03127453476190567, + 0.7739454507827759, + 0.02424902282655239 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01419729832559824 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a corner of the Forbidden City featuring deep vermilion palace walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slow, upward-tilting close-up from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bright yellow flag made of heavy silk visible, billowing in the wind with intricate gold and red dragon motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight casting sharp, deep shadows and revealing mottled marks on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color saturation extremely high with strong visual impact from the vermilion, yellow, and azure blue colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028262692503631115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.87782621383667 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028262692503631115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028262692503631115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.045204102993011475, + 0.05582213029265404, + 0.04308615252375603, + 0.06107880175113678, + 0.025095181539654732, + 0.023354753851890564, + 0.030270641669631004, + 0.041862595826387405, + 0.6360742449760437, + 0.038151320070028305 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028262692503631115 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, upward-tilting close-up shot from a low angle captures a solemn and vivid moment in a corner of the Forbidden City. The scene unfolds under the bright afternoon sun, whose intense, directional light vividly depicts the texture of the deep vermilion palace walls, revealing the subtle mottled marks left by time. The camera pans upward, passing over rows of glazed golden tiles that gleam with an almost liquid sheen in the sunlight, their iconic eaves tracing graceful curves against the azure sky. The visual centerpiece is a massive, bright yellow flag woven from heavy silk, affixed to a tall pole. It unfurls and billows powerfully and gracefully against the strong wind. The wind creates slow, deep undulations on its surface, and the intricate dragon motifs meticulously embroidered with gold and red silk thread seem to come alive as the flag flutters, shimmering and fading in the light. The color saturation of the entire scene is extremely high. The vermilion of the wall, the bright yellow of the tiles and flags, and the deep blue of the sky create a strong visual impact. The light casts sharp and deep shadows on the edges of objects, enhancing the three-dimensional sense and texture of the picture, perfectly reproducing the iconic capture of vivid colors, strong light and shadow contrasts, and instantaneous dynamics in Steve McCurry's works, creating a historical atmosphere that is both magnificent and full of vitality.", + "seed": 2784, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_8/index_1349_seed_2784_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.022345395665615796, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022345395665615796, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022345395665615796, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a corner of the Forbidden City featuring deep vermilion palace walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slow, upward-tilting close-up from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bright yellow flag made of heavy silk visible, billowing in the wind with intricate gold and red dragon motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight casting sharp, deep shadows and revealing mottled marks on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color saturation extremely high with strong visual impact from the vermilion, yellow, and azure blue colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0716998502612114 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.696699857711792 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0716998502612114, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0716998502612114, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29149726033210754, + 0.027347208932042122, + 0.0675525888800621, + 0.03260927274823189, + 0.050119850784540176, + 0.04729078710079193, + 0.08715397864580154, + 0.030017852783203125, + 0.31150466203689575, + 0.05490657314658165 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0716998502612114 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a corner of the Forbidden City featuring deep vermilion palace walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slow, upward-tilting close-up from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bright yellow flag made of heavy silk visible, billowing in the wind with intricate gold and red dragon motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight casting sharp, deep shadows and revealing mottled marks on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color saturation extremely high with strong visual impact from the vermilion, yellow, and azure blue colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026371274143457413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513712406158447 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026371274143457413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026371274143457413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3515814542770386, + 0.07540915161371231, + 0.05693652853369713, + 0.06170108541846275, + 0.06451676040887833, + 0.10380362719297409, + 0.043032482266426086, + 0.032296258956193924, + 0.18244051933288574, + 0.028282195329666138 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026371274143457413 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a corner of the Forbidden City featuring deep vermilion palace walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slow, upward-tilting close-up from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bright yellow flag made of heavy silk visible, billowing in the wind with intricate gold and red dragon motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight casting sharp, deep shadows and revealing mottled marks on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color saturation extremely high with strong visual impact from the vermilion, yellow, and azure blue colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002201278228312731 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127201080322266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002201278228312731, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002201278228312731, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24309994280338287, + 0.09620212763547897, + 0.042213547974824905, + 0.0341375395655632, + 0.07633289694786072, + 0.06586901843547821, + 0.056095462292432785, + 0.0568111278116703, + 0.24486245214939117, + 0.08437588810920715 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002201278228312731 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a corner of the Forbidden City featuring deep vermilion palace walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slow, upward-tilting close-up from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bright yellow flag made of heavy silk visible, billowing in the wind with intricate gold and red dragon motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight casting sharp, deep shadows and revealing mottled marks on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color saturation extremely high with strong visual impact from the vermilion, yellow, and azure blue colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008635676465928555 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758635520935059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008635676465928555, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008635676465928555, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16213233768939972, + 0.05024578049778938, + 0.03762093558907509, + 0.11622467637062073, + 0.2577710747718811, + 0.04597187787294388, + 0.04520227760076523, + 0.023538999259471893, + 0.21272657811641693, + 0.04856543615460396 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008635676465928555 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a corner of the Forbidden City featuring deep vermilion palace walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slow, upward-tilting close-up from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bright yellow flag made of heavy silk visible, billowing in the wind with intricate gold and red dragon motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight casting sharp, deep shadows and revealing mottled marks on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color saturation extremely high with strong visual impact from the vermilion, yellow, and azure blue colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002818899229168892 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877819061279297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002818899229168892, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002818899229168892, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37899529933929443, + 0.12053971737623215, + 0.03494929522275925, + 0.06043713539838791, + 0.07470360398292542, + 0.048145730048418045, + 0.07882046699523926, + 0.045677509158849716, + 0.06719717383384705, + 0.0905340239405632 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002818899229168892 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, upward-tilting close-up shot from a low angle captures a solemn and vivid moment in a corner of the Forbidden City. The scene unfolds under the bright afternoon sun, whose intense, directional light vividly depicts the texture of the deep vermilion palace walls, revealing the subtle mottled marks left by time. The camera pans upward, passing over rows of glazed golden tiles that gleam with an almost liquid sheen in the sunlight, their iconic eaves tracing graceful curves against the azure sky. The visual centerpiece is a massive, bright yellow flag woven from heavy silk, affixed to a tall pole. It unfurls and billows powerfully and gracefully against the strong wind. The wind creates slow, deep undulations on its surface, and the intricate dragon motifs meticulously embroidered with gold and red silk thread seem to come alive as the flag flutters, shimmering and fading in the light. The color saturation of the entire scene is extremely high. The vermilion of the wall, the bright yellow of the tiles and flags, and the deep blue of the sky create a strong visual impact. The light casts sharp and deep shadows on the edges of objects, enhancing the three-dimensional sense and texture of the picture, perfectly reproducing the iconic capture of vivid colors, strong light and shadow contrasts, and instantaneous dynamics in Steve McCurry's works, creating a historical atmosphere that is both magnificent and full of vitality.", + "seed": 2785, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_8/index_1349_seed_2785_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.010553427459672093, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010553427459672093, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010553427459672093, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a corner of the Forbidden City featuring deep vermilion palace walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slow, upward-tilting close-up from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bright yellow flag made of heavy silk visible, billowing in the wind with intricate gold and red dragon motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight casting sharp, deep shadows and revealing mottled marks on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color saturation extremely high with strong visual impact from the vermilion, yellow, and azure blue colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019893648102879524 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.019893646240234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019893648102879524, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019893648102879524, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08408079296350479, + 0.058554574847221375, + 0.19322386384010315, + 0.051472585648298264, + 0.11446263641119003, + 0.08810602873563766, + 0.08567529916763306, + 0.18403087556362152, + 0.036002933979034424, + 0.10439042001962662 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019893648102879524 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a corner of the Forbidden City featuring deep vermilion palace walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slow, upward-tilting close-up from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bright yellow flag made of heavy silk visible, billowing in the wind with intricate gold and red dragon motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight casting sharp, deep shadows and revealing mottled marks on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color saturation extremely high with strong visual impact from the vermilion, yellow, and azure blue colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01609734259545803 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141097545623779 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01609734259545803, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01609734259545803, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.044766198843717575, + 0.02322949469089508, + 0.07104365527629852, + 0.07146316021680832, + 0.07292980700731277, + 0.030608685687184334, + 0.05504598468542099, + 0.07797501236200333, + 0.10543374717235565, + 0.4475042223930359 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01609734259545803 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a corner of the Forbidden City featuring deep vermilion palace walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slow, upward-tilting close-up from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bright yellow flag made of heavy silk visible, billowing in the wind with intricate gold and red dragon motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight casting sharp, deep shadows and revealing mottled marks on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color saturation extremely high with strong visual impact from the vermilion, yellow, and azure blue colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00595355499535799 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130953788757324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00595355499535799, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00595355499535799, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09325840324163437, + 0.06849434226751328, + 0.042877521365880966, + 0.04594302922487259, + 0.05443334951996803, + 0.047323163598775864, + 0.03978085145354271, + 0.19672490656375885, + 0.06500787287950516, + 0.34615659713745117 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00595355499535799 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a corner of the Forbidden City featuring deep vermilion palace walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slow, upward-tilting close-up from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bright yellow flag made of heavy silk visible, billowing in the wind with intricate gold and red dragon motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight casting sharp, deep shadows and revealing mottled marks on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color saturation extremely high with strong visual impact from the vermilion, yellow, and azure blue colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076280031353235245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882627964019775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076280031353235245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076280031353235245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15459594130516052, + 0.04968505725264549, + 0.1075432300567627, + 0.03274191915988922, + 0.06434323638677597, + 0.11323219537734985, + 0.09089995920658112, + 0.18357492983341217, + 0.0658358782529831, + 0.1375475972890854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076280031353235245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a corner of the Forbidden City featuring deep vermilion palace walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slow, upward-tilting close-up from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bright yellow flag made of heavy silk visible, billowing in the wind with intricate gold and red dragon motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight casting sharp, deep shadows and revealing mottled marks on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color saturation extremely high with strong visual impact from the vermilion, yellow, and azure blue colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031945884693413973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753194808959961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031945884693413973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031945884693413973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0931776612997055, + 0.0528070405125618, + 0.09532478451728821, + 0.03127976506948471, + 0.06338348239660263, + 0.059199344366788864, + 0.029417846351861954, + 0.16216899454593658, + 0.06262168288230896, + 0.35061943531036377 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031945884693413973 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, upward-tilting close-up shot from a low angle captures a solemn and vivid moment in a corner of the Forbidden City. The scene unfolds under the bright afternoon sun, whose intense, directional light vividly depicts the texture of the deep vermilion palace walls, revealing the subtle mottled marks left by time. The camera pans upward, passing over rows of glazed golden tiles that gleam with an almost liquid sheen in the sunlight, their iconic eaves tracing graceful curves against the azure sky. The visual centerpiece is a massive, bright yellow flag woven from heavy silk, affixed to a tall pole. It unfurls and billows powerfully and gracefully against the strong wind. The wind creates slow, deep undulations on its surface, and the intricate dragon motifs meticulously embroidered with gold and red silk thread seem to come alive as the flag flutters, shimmering and fading in the light. The color saturation of the entire scene is extremely high. The vermilion of the wall, the bright yellow of the tiles and flags, and the deep blue of the sky create a strong visual impact. The light casts sharp and deep shadows on the edges of objects, enhancing the three-dimensional sense and texture of the picture, perfectly reproducing the iconic capture of vivid colors, strong light and shadow contrasts, and instantaneous dynamics in Steve McCurry's works, creating a historical atmosphere that is both magnificent and full of vitality.", + "seed": 2786, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_8/index_1349_seed_2786_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.017547966819256543, + "vlm_logprob": -0.017547966819256543, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.017547966819256543, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a corner of the Forbidden City featuring deep vermilion palace walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slow, upward-tilting close-up from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bright yellow flag made of heavy silk visible, billowing in the wind with intricate gold and red dragon motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight casting sharp, deep shadows and revealing mottled marks on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color saturation extremely high with strong visual impact from the vermilion, yellow, and azure blue colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.027158981189131737 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6521589756011963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.027158981189131737, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.027158981189131737, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.452839195728302, + 0.2913433313369751, + 0.02060551568865776, + 0.045858535915613174, + 0.021412888541817665, + 0.022148538380861282, + 0.016033334657549858, + 0.019981706514954567, + 0.048923760652542114, + 0.060853227972984314 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.027158981189131737 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a corner of the Forbidden City featuring deep vermilion palace walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slow, upward-tilting close-up from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bright yellow flag made of heavy silk visible, billowing in the wind with intricate gold and red dragon motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight casting sharp, deep shadows and revealing mottled marks on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color saturation extremely high with strong visual impact from the vermilion, yellow, and azure blue colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011100324802100658 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5111002922058105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011100324802100658, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011100324802100658, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3211950361728668, + 0.1636054664850235, + 0.025561869144439697, + 0.058613669127225876, + 0.0881122276186943, + 0.03797914460301399, + 0.0500682033598423, + 0.026060717180371284, + 0.19850994646549225, + 0.030293762683868408 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011100324802100658 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a corner of the Forbidden City featuring deep vermilion palace walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slow, upward-tilting close-up from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bright yellow flag made of heavy silk visible, billowing in the wind with intricate gold and red dragon motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight casting sharp, deep shadows and revealing mottled marks on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color saturation extremely high with strong visual impact from the vermilion, yellow, and azure blue colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004644440021365881 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379644393920898 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004644440021365881, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004644440021365881, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5023190975189209, + 0.06662102788686752, + 0.024379277601838112, + 0.04795604571700096, + 0.0745411068201065, + 0.03635881468653679, + 0.1060330867767334, + 0.024722913280129433, + 0.0704340860247612, + 0.046634525060653687 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004644440021365881 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a corner of the Forbidden City featuring deep vermilion palace walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slow, upward-tilting close-up from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bright yellow flag made of heavy silk visible, billowing in the wind with intricate gold and red dragon motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight casting sharp, deep shadows and revealing mottled marks on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color saturation extremely high with strong visual impact from the vermilion, yellow, and azure blue colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038097530603408813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288097620010376 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038097530603408813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038097530603408813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27339571714401245, + 0.37458229064941406, + 0.02500498853623867, + 0.06352401524782181, + 0.0321030355989933, + 0.02894495241343975, + 0.0313829630613327, + 0.013144131749868393, + 0.059240829199552536, + 0.09867704659700394 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038097530603408813 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a corner of the Forbidden City featuring deep vermilion palace walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a slow, upward-tilting close-up from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive bright yellow flag made of heavy silk visible, billowing in the wind with intricate gold and red dragon motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight casting sharp, deep shadows and revealing mottled marks on the walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color saturation extremely high with strong visual impact from the vermilion, yellow, and azure blue colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006738557480275631 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006738662719727 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006738557480275631, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006738557480275631, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6586434841156006, + 0.04394928738474846, + 0.019543545320630074, + 0.0349043644964695, + 0.03439641743898392, + 0.028849316760897636, + 0.0494152270257473, + 0.019308844581246376, + 0.030463624745607376, + 0.08052587509155273 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006738557480275631 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_9/index_tensor([9287, 9287])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_9/index_tensor([9287, 9287])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0975887c73e9cfecc45948e4793f4c69111a305c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_9/index_tensor([9287, 9287])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme macro lens pans slowly and steadily to the right, penetrating the interior of a precision-cast brass and steel gear system. Against a deep, almost black background, a precise and dramatic sidelight cast from the upper left sculpts the entire mechanical structure into sharp relief. At the center of the frame, a large brass main gear rotates clockwise with a steady and deliberate rhythm. Its warm gold surface reflects the light with a soft, rich luster, and the edges of its teeth are outlined with dazzling brilliance. It drives several smaller, meshing steel gears in a rapid counterclockwise rotation. The cool, silver-gray metal surface, with its industrial brushed texture, contrasts sharply with the warm tones of the brass. Within the complex multi-axis mechanism, different levels of gears rotate synchronously at varying speeds, creating a silent and harmonious mechanical ballet. The high-resolution texture reveals every tiny scratch on the metal surface, left by long-term operation, and the translucent dark lubricant stuck between the teeth. The oil reflects a faint, viscous sheen under the light. The entire scene is free of superfluous elements. The interweaving of light and shadow and the collision of materials create an atmosphere of focus, rigor, and power, perfectly showcasing the pure beauty of industrial aesthetics and mechanical transmission.", + "seed": 10430, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_9/index_9287_seed_10430_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.037834116257727146, + "vlm_logprob": -0.037834116257727146, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.037834116257727146, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning slowly and steadily to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main gear large, made of brass, and rotating clockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are smaller steel gears meshing with the main gear and rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a precise sidelight from the upper left creating sharp relief against a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details including tiny scratches on the metal and translucent dark lubricant between the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12007664144039154 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2450766563415527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12007664144039154, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12007664144039154, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.059909235686063766, + 0.1309385448694229, + 0.10503697395324707, + 0.04509441554546356, + 0.21310406923294067, + 0.06615383923053741, + 0.08943315595388412, + 0.10392158478498459, + 0.13656815886497498, + 0.0498400516808033 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12007664144039154 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning slowly and steadily to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main gear large, made of brass, and rotating clockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are smaller steel gears meshing with the main gear and rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a precise sidelight from the upper left creating sharp relief against a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details including tiny scratches on the metal and translucent dark lubricant between the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014216807670891285 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264216899871826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014216807670891285, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014216807670891285, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10420745611190796, + 0.07759349793195724, + 0.1522405594587326, + 0.061372123658657074, + 0.22961150109767914, + 0.053292322903871536, + 0.05539432168006897, + 0.051597412675619125, + 0.11439541727304459, + 0.10029542446136475 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014216807670891285 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning slowly and steadily to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main gear large, made of brass, and rotating clockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are smaller steel gears meshing with the main gear and rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a precise sidelight from the upper left creating sharp relief against a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details including tiny scratches on the metal and translucent dark lubricant between the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012547479011118412 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387547492980957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012547479011118412, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012547479011118412, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11303193867206573, + 0.1424691528081894, + 0.1317765712738037, + 0.05640376731753349, + 0.1284855753183365, + 0.038141533732414246, + 0.04334220662713051, + 0.07861953973770142, + 0.18463227152824402, + 0.08309748023748398 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012547479011118412 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning slowly and steadily to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main gear large, made of brass, and rotating clockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are smaller steel gears meshing with the main gear and rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a precise sidelight from the upper left creating sharp relief against a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details including tiny scratches on the metal and translucent dark lubricant between the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369303047657013 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086930751800537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369303047657013, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369303047657013, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3192935883998871, + 0.11756805330514908, + 0.19606459140777588, + 0.13698013126850128, + 0.03164390102028847, + 0.03046981431543827, + 0.08032047003507614, + 0.026496004313230515, + 0.030065637081861496, + 0.031097786501049995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369303047657013 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning slowly and steadily to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main gear large, made of brass, and rotating clockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are smaller steel gears meshing with the main gear and rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a precise sidelight from the upper left creating sharp relief against a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details including tiny scratches on the metal and translucent dark lubricant between the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008636622689664364 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758636474609375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008636622689664364, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008636622689664364, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25925764441490173, + 0.08009129762649536, + 0.17512179911136627, + 0.0581333301961422, + 0.08580367267131805, + 0.03871828690171242, + 0.042663510888814926, + 0.09541148692369461, + 0.08206203579902649, + 0.08273691684007645 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008636622689664364 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme macro lens pans slowly and steadily to the right, penetrating the interior of a precision-cast brass and steel gear system. Against a deep, almost black background, a precise and dramatic sidelight cast from the upper left sculpts the entire mechanical structure into sharp relief. At the center of the frame, a large brass main gear rotates clockwise with a steady and deliberate rhythm. Its warm gold surface reflects the light with a soft, rich luster, and the edges of its teeth are outlined with dazzling brilliance. It drives several smaller, meshing steel gears in a rapid counterclockwise rotation. The cool, silver-gray metal surface, with its industrial brushed texture, contrasts sharply with the warm tones of the brass. Within the complex multi-axis mechanism, different levels of gears rotate synchronously at varying speeds, creating a silent and harmonious mechanical ballet. The high-resolution texture reveals every tiny scratch on the metal surface, left by long-term operation, and the translucent dark lubricant stuck between the teeth. The oil reflects a faint, viscous sheen under the light. The entire scene is free of superfluous elements. The interweaving of light and shadow and the collision of materials create an atmosphere of focus, rigor, and power, perfectly showcasing the pure beauty of industrial aesthetics and mechanical transmission.", + "seed": 10431, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_9/index_9287_seed_10431_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0631464034318924, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0631464034318924, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0631464034318924, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning slowly and steadily to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main gear large, made of brass, and rotating clockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are smaller steel gears meshing with the main gear and rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a precise sidelight from the upper left creating sharp relief against a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details including tiny scratches on the metal and translucent dark lubricant between the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.23220273852348328 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6072027683258057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.23220273852348328, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.23220273852348328, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7378820776939392, + 0.016931934282183647, + 0.020023982971906662, + 0.029540900141000748, + 0.035145603120326996, + 0.024107234552502632, + 0.07185345143079758, + 0.027848027646541595, + 0.017251307144761086, + 0.019415507093071938 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.23220273852348328 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning slowly and steadily to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main gear large, made of brass, and rotating clockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are smaller steel gears meshing with the main gear and rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a precise sidelight from the upper left creating sharp relief against a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details including tiny scratches on the metal and translucent dark lubricant between the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02060099132359028 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956010341644287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02060099132359028, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02060099132359028, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.352049857378006, + 0.032565534114837646, + 0.041891589760780334, + 0.07524771988391876, + 0.18785199522972107, + 0.031749654561281204, + 0.06931400299072266, + 0.09828539937734604, + 0.05194902420043945, + 0.059095270931720734 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02060099132359028 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning slowly and steadily to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main gear large, made of brass, and rotating clockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are smaller steel gears meshing with the main gear and rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a precise sidelight from the upper left creating sharp relief against a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details including tiny scratches on the metal and translucent dark lubricant between the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020594686269760132 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895594596862793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020594686269760132, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020594686269760132, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6339441537857056, + 0.03706776350736618, + 0.045828986912965775, + 0.04501562565565109, + 0.03159986436367035, + 0.04407540336251259, + 0.03765426576137543, + 0.08041837066411972, + 0.014510171487927437, + 0.02988535910844803 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020594686269760132 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning slowly and steadily to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main gear large, made of brass, and rotating clockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are smaller steel gears meshing with the main gear and rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a precise sidelight from the upper left creating sharp relief against a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details including tiny scratches on the metal and translucent dark lubricant between the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033695679157972336 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408695697784424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033695679157972336, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033695679157972336, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6791982054710388, + 0.03204330429434776, + 0.023109035566449165, + 0.01915338635444641, + 0.08244571834802628, + 0.04369737580418587, + 0.01692437008023262, + 0.04862730950117111, + 0.015444966964423656, + 0.0393562987446785 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033695679157972336 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning slowly and steadily to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main gear large, made of brass, and rotating clockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are smaller steel gears meshing with the main gear and rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a precise sidelight from the upper left creating sharp relief against a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details including tiny scratches on the metal and translucent dark lubricant between the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008637921884655952 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75863790512085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008637921884655952, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008637921884655952, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4099108576774597, + 0.07065135985612869, + 0.04865839332342148, + 0.033908113837242126, + 0.058456916362047195, + 0.06080857664346695, + 0.1331327110528946, + 0.06470370292663574, + 0.02455754205584526, + 0.09521176666021347 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008637921884655952 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme macro lens pans slowly and steadily to the right, penetrating the interior of a precision-cast brass and steel gear system. Against a deep, almost black background, a precise and dramatic sidelight cast from the upper left sculpts the entire mechanical structure into sharp relief. At the center of the frame, a large brass main gear rotates clockwise with a steady and deliberate rhythm. Its warm gold surface reflects the light with a soft, rich luster, and the edges of its teeth are outlined with dazzling brilliance. It drives several smaller, meshing steel gears in a rapid counterclockwise rotation. The cool, silver-gray metal surface, with its industrial brushed texture, contrasts sharply with the warm tones of the brass. Within the complex multi-axis mechanism, different levels of gears rotate synchronously at varying speeds, creating a silent and harmonious mechanical ballet. The high-resolution texture reveals every tiny scratch on the metal surface, left by long-term operation, and the translucent dark lubricant stuck between the teeth. The oil reflects a faint, viscous sheen under the light. The entire scene is free of superfluous elements. The interweaving of light and shadow and the collision of materials create an atmosphere of focus, rigor, and power, perfectly showcasing the pure beauty of industrial aesthetics and mechanical transmission.", + "seed": 10432, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_9/index_9287_seed_10432_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03762332703918218, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03762332703918218, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.574999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03762332703918218, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning slowly and steadily to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main gear large, made of brass, and rotating clockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are smaller steel gears meshing with the main gear and rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a precise sidelight from the upper left creating sharp relief against a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details including tiny scratches on the metal and translucent dark lubricant between the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08957597613334656 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.589576005935669 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08957597613334656, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08957597613334656, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05619746819138527, + 0.08631227165460587, + 0.04930604249238968, + 0.08082213997840881, + 0.1891852766275406, + 0.3343750834465027, + 0.028063975274562836, + 0.06745172291994095, + 0.037205204367637634, + 0.07108085602521896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08957597613334656 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning slowly and steadily to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main gear large, made of brass, and rotating clockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are smaller steel gears meshing with the main gear and rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a precise sidelight from the upper left creating sharp relief against a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details including tiny scratches on the metal and translucent dark lubricant between the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020602509379386902 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956024646759033 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020602509379386902, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020602509379386902, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3154066801071167, + 0.11295202374458313, + 0.049515388906002045, + 0.1326756626367569, + 0.04484659805893898, + 0.043177198618650436, + 0.025551578029990196, + 0.0644339993596077, + 0.06534124910831451, + 0.14609967172145844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020602509379386902 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning slowly and steadily to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main gear large, made of brass, and rotating clockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are smaller steel gears meshing with the main gear and rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a precise sidelight from the upper left creating sharp relief against a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details including tiny scratches on the metal and translucent dark lubricant between the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018206268548965454 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0182061195373535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018206268548965454, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018206268548965454, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.135227233171463, + 0.20563164353370667, + 0.05405496805906296, + 0.10478627681732178, + 0.05637732148170471, + 0.06111067533493042, + 0.03794405236840248, + 0.11441529542207718, + 0.07517903298139572, + 0.1552734375 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018206268548965454 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning slowly and steadily to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main gear large, made of brass, and rotating clockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are smaller steel gears meshing with the main gear and rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a precise sidelight from the upper left creating sharp relief against a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details including tiny scratches on the metal and translucent dark lubricant between the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865466430783272 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048654556274414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865466430783272, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865466430783272, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13790756464004517, + 0.18983794748783112, + 0.09549020975828171, + 0.1798037439584732, + 0.08354431390762329, + 0.03252921625971794, + 0.029078559949994087, + 0.03577827662229538, + 0.04122437164187431, + 0.17480571568012238 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865466430783272 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning slowly and steadily to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main gear large, made of brass, and rotating clockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are smaller steel gears meshing with the main gear and rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a precise sidelight from the upper left creating sharp relief against a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details including tiny scratches on the metal and translucent dark lubricant between the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0110772168263793 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511077404022217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0110772168263793, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0110772168263793, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10502821952104568, + 0.152246356010437, + 0.04356449842453003, + 0.19183304905891418, + 0.07740018516778946, + 0.07122233510017395, + 0.03405153006315231, + 0.04594665765762329, + 0.08186618238687515, + 0.19684092700481415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0110772168263793 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme macro lens pans slowly and steadily to the right, penetrating the interior of a precision-cast brass and steel gear system. Against a deep, almost black background, a precise and dramatic sidelight cast from the upper left sculpts the entire mechanical structure into sharp relief. At the center of the frame, a large brass main gear rotates clockwise with a steady and deliberate rhythm. Its warm gold surface reflects the light with a soft, rich luster, and the edges of its teeth are outlined with dazzling brilliance. It drives several smaller, meshing steel gears in a rapid counterclockwise rotation. The cool, silver-gray metal surface, with its industrial brushed texture, contrasts sharply with the warm tones of the brass. Within the complex multi-axis mechanism, different levels of gears rotate synchronously at varying speeds, creating a silent and harmonious mechanical ballet. The high-resolution texture reveals every tiny scratch on the metal surface, left by long-term operation, and the translucent dark lubricant stuck between the teeth. The oil reflects a faint, viscous sheen under the light. The entire scene is free of superfluous elements. The interweaving of light and shadow and the collision of materials create an atmosphere of focus, rigor, and power, perfectly showcasing the pure beauty of industrial aesthetics and mechanical transmission.", + "seed": 10433, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000172/group_9/index_9287_seed_10433_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.041414016112685206, + "vlm_logprob": -0.041414016112685206, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.041414016112685206, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning slowly and steadily to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main gear large, made of brass, and rotating clockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are smaller steel gears meshing with the main gear and rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a precise sidelight from the upper left creating sharp relief against a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details including tiny scratches on the metal and translucent dark lubricant between the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12013742327690125 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2451374530792236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12013742327690125, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12013742327690125, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14838922023773193, + 0.029007211327552795, + 0.02917262725532055, + 0.014522704295814037, + 0.3135280907154083, + 0.07397843152284622, + 0.11214505136013031, + 0.16344797611236572, + 0.09301658719778061, + 0.022792117670178413 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12013742327690125 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning slowly and steadily to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main gear large, made of brass, and rotating clockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are smaller steel gears meshing with the main gear and rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a precise sidelight from the upper left creating sharp relief against a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details including tiny scratches on the metal and translucent dark lubricant between the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018215281888842583 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018215179443359 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018215281888842583, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018215281888842583, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1111685261130333, + 0.05235173925757408, + 0.04264381527900696, + 0.01931827701628208, + 0.47604861855506897, + 0.0727165937423706, + 0.03409790247678757, + 0.09241797029972076, + 0.06507103145122528, + 0.03416554257273674 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018215281888842583 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning slowly and steadily to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main gear large, made of brass, and rotating clockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are smaller steel gears meshing with the main gear and rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a precise sidelight from the upper left creating sharp relief against a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details including tiny scratches on the metal and translucent dark lubricant between the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026373596861958504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513736248016357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026373596861958504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026373596861958504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1033000499010086, + 0.03548431396484375, + 0.04064346104860306, + 0.019268708303570747, + 0.33297815918922424, + 0.07308315485715866, + 0.08161594718694687, + 0.09531669318675995, + 0.07864993065595627, + 0.13965952396392822 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026373596861958504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning slowly and steadily to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main gear large, made of brass, and rotating clockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are smaller steel gears meshing with the main gear and rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a precise sidelight from the upper left creating sharp relief against a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details including tiny scratches on the metal and translucent dark lubricant between the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370455652475357 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087045192718506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370455652475357, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370455652475357, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1781662255525589, + 0.14064566791057587, + 0.04484238848090172, + 0.03498438000679016, + 0.13461318612098694, + 0.2496783584356308, + 0.01881295070052147, + 0.0835457369685173, + 0.05557456612586975, + 0.059136491268873215 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370455652475357 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera panning slowly and steadily to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main gear large, made of brass, and rotating clockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are smaller steel gears meshing with the main gear and rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting a precise sidelight from the upper left creating sharp relief against a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are visible details including tiny scratches on the metal and translucent dark lubricant between the gear teeth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008639222010970116 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758639335632324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008639222010970116, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008639222010970116, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2668873369693756, + 0.13949550688266754, + 0.05786966159939766, + 0.018441008403897285, + 0.07491189241409302, + 0.10348924994468689, + 0.04039446637034416, + 0.145668625831604, + 0.10747133940458298, + 0.045370906591415405 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008639222010970116 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_0/index_tensor([5551, 5551])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_0/index_tensor([5551, 5551])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c05d1016cbaf6bf6e837ee36c46d7d9479d85399 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_0/index_tensor([5551, 5551])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "shot begins at extreme distance, panning to the left at an incredibly slow speed, capturing a majestic mountaintop scene. The mountain wind whips across the scene with an invisible yet powerful force, stirring the thick, swirling clouds above. At the visual center, a weathered, gnarled pine tree stands tenaciously on a rocky outcrop. Its trunk, twisted like a dragon, tilts dramatically to one side, as if in an eternal struggle against the relentless wind. Its dark gray bark is covered in deep cracks and moss-covered patches, while its bare branches stretch into the air, a sinister yet powerful presence. As the sun sets behind the distant mountains, golden, almost physical Crepuscular rays, with a cinematic quality, dramatically penetrate the gaps in the thick clouds, illuminating the dead pine tree with pinpoint precision, illuminating the edges of its rough bark with a brilliant golden rim. This strong light cast an extremely long, sharply outlined black shadow on the dead pine on the rugged ground. As the clouds moved and the light changed, the shadow slowly squirmed and deformed on the ground. The whole scene, with its warm gold contrasting with the deep blue-gray tones of the background, created an epic atmosphere of desolation, loneliness, and yet full of indomitable vitality.", + "seed": 26851, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_0/index_5551_seed_26851_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.24418527409434318, + "vlm_logprob": -0.24418527409434318, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.324999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.24418527409434318, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extreme distance and pan slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a weathered, gnarled pine tree visible at the visual center on a rocky outcrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk twisted and tilted dramatically to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden crepuscular rays visible penetrating the clouds and illuminating the tree with a brilliant golden rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a long, sharply outlined black shadow visible on the ground that slowly squirms and deforms as the light changes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0591058731079102 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4341058135032654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0591058731079102, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.6250000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0591058731079102, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06568582355976105, + 0.04070216789841652, + 0.6480932235717773, + 0.025611452758312225, + 0.022899549454450607, + 0.040279850363731384, + 0.10185602307319641, + 0.006497548893094063, + 0.031394392251968384, + 0.016979986801743507 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0591058731079102 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extreme distance and pan slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a weathered, gnarled pine tree visible at the visual center on a rocky outcrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk twisted and tilted dramatically to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden crepuscular rays visible penetrating the clouds and illuminating the tree with a brilliant golden rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a long, sharply outlined black shadow visible on the ground that slowly squirms and deforms as the light changes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008666286244988441 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758666515350342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008666286244988441, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008666286244988441, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15049900114536285, + 0.162245512008667, + 0.04012530297040939, + 0.02466433122754097, + 0.10498084872961044, + 0.18036700785160065, + 0.07075753808021545, + 0.04539747163653374, + 0.06069044768810272, + 0.1602725237607956 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008666286244988441 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extreme distance and pan slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a weathered, gnarled pine tree visible at the visual center on a rocky outcrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk twisted and tilted dramatically to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden crepuscular rays visible penetrating the clouds and illuminating the tree with a brilliant golden rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a long, sharply outlined black shadow visible on the ground that slowly squirms and deforms as the light changes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036216876469552517 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628621578216553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036216876469552517, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036216876469552517, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25625932216644287, + 0.09679968655109406, + 0.20049074292182922, + 0.04880519211292267, + 0.04656926542520523, + 0.06646621227264404, + 0.1137942299246788, + 0.031345438212156296, + 0.03215832635760307, + 0.10731157660484314 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036216876469552517 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extreme distance and pan slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a weathered, gnarled pine tree visible at the visual center on a rocky outcrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk twisted and tilted dramatically to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden crepuscular rays visible penetrating the clouds and illuminating the tree with a brilliant golden rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a long, sharply outlined black shadow visible on the ground that slowly squirms and deforms as the light changes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006747674662619829 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006747722625732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006747674662619829, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006747674662619829, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14769214391708374, + 0.11196733266115189, + 0.24130074679851532, + 0.07009115815162659, + 0.06305646151304245, + 0.05924191698431969, + 0.06491264700889587, + 0.07061109691858292, + 0.049736425280570984, + 0.12139011919498444 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006747674662619829 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extreme distance and pan slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a weathered, gnarled pine tree visible at the visual center on a rocky outcrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk twisted and tilted dramatically to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden crepuscular rays visible penetrating the clouds and illuminating the tree with a brilliant golden rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a long, sharply outlined black shadow visible on the ground that slowly squirms and deforms as the light changes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14278484880924225 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017784833908081 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14278484880924225, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14278484880924225, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05206875503063202, + 0.13162563741207123, + 0.5214039087295532, + 0.02298193983733654, + 0.0475151501595974, + 0.05321536213159561, + 0.08710584044456482, + 0.02214675396680832, + 0.014885992743074894, + 0.04705071449279785 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14278484880924225 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shot begins at extreme distance, panning to the left at an incredibly slow speed, capturing a majestic mountaintop scene. The mountain wind whips across the scene with an invisible yet powerful force, stirring the thick, swirling clouds above. At the visual center, a weathered, gnarled pine tree stands tenaciously on a rocky outcrop. Its trunk, twisted like a dragon, tilts dramatically to one side, as if in an eternal struggle against the relentless wind. Its dark gray bark is covered in deep cracks and moss-covered patches, while its bare branches stretch into the air, a sinister yet powerful presence. As the sun sets behind the distant mountains, golden, almost physical Crepuscular rays, with a cinematic quality, dramatically penetrate the gaps in the thick clouds, illuminating the dead pine tree with pinpoint precision, illuminating the edges of its rough bark with a brilliant golden rim. This strong light cast an extremely long, sharply outlined black shadow on the dead pine on the rugged ground. As the clouds moved and the light changed, the shadow slowly squirmed and deformed on the ground. The whole scene, with its warm gold contrasting with the deep blue-gray tones of the background, created an epic atmosphere of desolation, loneliness, and yet full of indomitable vitality.", + "seed": 26852, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_0/index_5551_seed_26852_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2823862233897671, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2823862233897671, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2823862233897671, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extreme distance and pan slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a weathered, gnarled pine tree visible at the visual center on a rocky outcrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk twisted and tilted dramatically to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden crepuscular rays visible penetrating the clouds and illuminating the tree with a brilliant golden rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a long, sharply outlined black shadow visible on the ground that slowly squirms and deforms as the light changes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3180965185165405 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3180965483188629 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.3180965185165405, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.3180965185165405, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20594841241836548, + 0.04643068090081215, + 0.041499581187963486, + 0.057877860963344574, + 0.05773858726024628, + 0.08184140175580978, + 0.04588911682367325, + 0.14729201793670654, + 0.20788772404193878, + 0.10759463161230087 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.3180965185165405 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extreme distance and pan slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a weathered, gnarled pine tree visible at the visual center on a rocky outcrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk twisted and tilted dramatically to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden crepuscular rays visible penetrating the clouds and illuminating the tree with a brilliant golden rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a long, sharply outlined black shadow visible on the ground that slowly squirms and deforms as the light changes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007657578215003014 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882657527923584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007657578215003014, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007657578215003014, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13840852677822113, + 0.14167779684066772, + 0.12213253229856491, + 0.17761175334453583, + 0.033567484468221664, + 0.048248641192913055, + 0.03846844658255577, + 0.05735456198453903, + 0.09732292592525482, + 0.14520737528800964 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007657578215003014 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extreme distance and pan slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a weathered, gnarled pine tree visible at the visual center on a rocky outcrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk twisted and tilted dramatically to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden crepuscular rays visible penetrating the clouds and illuminating the tree with a brilliant golden rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a long, sharply outlined black shadow visible on the ground that slowly squirms and deforms as the light changes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019468179671093822 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251946926116943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019468179671093822, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019468179671093822, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17540377378463745, + 0.09804252535104752, + 0.22122600674629211, + 0.12420859187841415, + 0.0541430339217186, + 0.04579319804906845, + 0.028693147003650665, + 0.03766917064785957, + 0.0706438273191452, + 0.14417670667171478 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019468179671093822 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extreme distance and pan slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a weathered, gnarled pine tree visible at the visual center on a rocky outcrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk twisted and tilted dramatically to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden crepuscular rays visible penetrating the clouds and illuminating the tree with a brilliant golden rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a long, sharply outlined black shadow visible on the ground that slowly squirms and deforms as the light changes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005259486846625805 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.2552595138549805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005259486846625805, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005259486846625805, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26910361647605896, + 0.07865060120820999, + 0.07485584914684296, + 0.08346883952617645, + 0.10653884708881378, + 0.09761026501655579, + 0.09725452214479446, + 0.047073833644390106, + 0.05379738658666611, + 0.091646209359169 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005259486846625805 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extreme distance and pan slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a weathered, gnarled pine tree visible at the visual center on a rocky outcrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk twisted and tilted dramatically to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden crepuscular rays visible penetrating the clouds and illuminating the tree with a brilliant golden rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a long, sharply outlined black shadow visible on the ground that slowly squirms and deforms as the light changes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897071540355682 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789706707000732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897071540355682, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897071540355682, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09333635121583939, + 0.0626673698425293, + 0.06241806223988533, + 0.06805849075317383, + 0.08075397461652756, + 0.10493594408035278, + 0.03652578592300415, + 0.14996285736560822, + 0.10453654080629349, + 0.23680463433265686 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897071540355682 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shot begins at extreme distance, panning to the left at an incredibly slow speed, capturing a majestic mountaintop scene. The mountain wind whips across the scene with an invisible yet powerful force, stirring the thick, swirling clouds above. At the visual center, a weathered, gnarled pine tree stands tenaciously on a rocky outcrop. Its trunk, twisted like a dragon, tilts dramatically to one side, as if in an eternal struggle against the relentless wind. Its dark gray bark is covered in deep cracks and moss-covered patches, while its bare branches stretch into the air, a sinister yet powerful presence. As the sun sets behind the distant mountains, golden, almost physical Crepuscular rays, with a cinematic quality, dramatically penetrate the gaps in the thick clouds, illuminating the dead pine tree with pinpoint precision, illuminating the edges of its rough bark with a brilliant golden rim. This strong light cast an extremely long, sharply outlined black shadow on the dead pine on the rugged ground. As the clouds moved and the light changed, the shadow slowly squirmed and deformed on the ground. The whole scene, with its warm gold contrasting with the deep blue-gray tones of the background, created an epic atmosphere of desolation, loneliness, and yet full of indomitable vitality.", + "seed": 26853, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_0/index_5551_seed_26853_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.4656699816696346, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4656699816696346, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.950000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4656699816696346, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extreme distance and pan slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a weathered, gnarled pine tree visible at the visual center on a rocky outcrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk twisted and tilted dramatically to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden crepuscular rays visible penetrating the clouds and illuminating the tree with a brilliant golden rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a long, sharply outlined black shadow visible on the ground that slowly squirms and deforms as the light changes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1284892559051514 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12848933041095734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.1284892559051514, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -2.1284892559051514, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2942526936531067, + 0.08621719479560852, + 0.1625298261642456, + 0.06642648577690125, + 0.12066863477230072, + 0.04587330296635628, + 0.047374751418828964, + 0.03575237840414047, + 0.09152471274137497, + 0.04938003793358803 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.1284892559051514 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extreme distance and pan slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a weathered, gnarled pine tree visible at the visual center on a rocky outcrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk twisted and tilted dramatically to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden crepuscular rays visible penetrating the clouds and illuminating the tree with a brilliant golden rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a long, sharply outlined black shadow visible on the ground that slowly squirms and deforms as the light changes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007674022112041712 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882674217224121 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007674022112041712, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007674022112041712, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2053738236427307, + 0.06270409375429153, + 0.20032331347465515, + 0.06375674903392792, + 0.2542058527469635, + 0.057819582521915436, + 0.05825228989124298, + 0.029124431312084198, + 0.02795035019516945, + 0.04048950597643852 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007674022112041712 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extreme distance and pan slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a weathered, gnarled pine tree visible at the visual center on a rocky outcrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk twisted and tilted dramatically to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden crepuscular rays visible penetrating the clouds and illuminating the tree with a brilliant golden rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a long, sharply outlined black shadow visible on the ground that slowly squirms and deforms as the light changes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004647406283766031 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379647254943848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004647406283766031, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004647406283766031, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25680336356163025, + 0.0560351125895977, + 0.1806981861591339, + 0.05694231018424034, + 0.1675114780664444, + 0.05988538637757301, + 0.08865423500537872, + 0.018796933814883232, + 0.052455488592386246, + 0.06221751496195793 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004647406283766031 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extreme distance and pan slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a weathered, gnarled pine tree visible at the visual center on a rocky outcrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk twisted and tilted dramatically to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden crepuscular rays visible penetrating the clouds and illuminating the tree with a brilliant golden rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a long, sharply outlined black shadow visible on the ground that slowly squirms and deforms as the light changes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007640306372195482 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882640361785889 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007640306372195482, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007640306372195482, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2854863405227661, + 0.05164513364434242, + 0.1530771404504776, + 0.060881052166223526, + 0.11330273747444153, + 0.08740954846143723, + 0.05414862185716629, + 0.026135971769690514, + 0.10469245165586472, + 0.0632210299372673 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007640306372195482 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extreme distance and pan slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a weathered, gnarled pine tree visible at the visual center on a rocky outcrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk twisted and tilted dramatically to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden crepuscular rays visible penetrating the clouds and illuminating the tree with a brilliant golden rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a long, sharply outlined black shadow visible on the ground that slowly squirms and deforms as the light changes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1798989176750183 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804898977279663 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1798989176750183, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1798989176750183, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10059601068496704, + 0.03149767592549324, + 0.11155910789966583, + 0.1009514257311821, + 0.06929301470518112, + 0.17934074997901917, + 0.06211971119046211, + 0.0932845026254654, + 0.18684597313404083, + 0.06451181322336197 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1798989176750183 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shot begins at extreme distance, panning to the left at an incredibly slow speed, capturing a majestic mountaintop scene. The mountain wind whips across the scene with an invisible yet powerful force, stirring the thick, swirling clouds above. At the visual center, a weathered, gnarled pine tree stands tenaciously on a rocky outcrop. Its trunk, twisted like a dragon, tilts dramatically to one side, as if in an eternal struggle against the relentless wind. Its dark gray bark is covered in deep cracks and moss-covered patches, while its bare branches stretch into the air, a sinister yet powerful presence. As the sun sets behind the distant mountains, golden, almost physical Crepuscular rays, with a cinematic quality, dramatically penetrate the gaps in the thick clouds, illuminating the dead pine tree with pinpoint precision, illuminating the edges of its rough bark with a brilliant golden rim. This strong light cast an extremely long, sharply outlined black shadow on the dead pine on the rugged ground. As the clouds moved and the light changed, the shadow slowly squirmed and deformed on the ground. The whole scene, with its warm gold contrasting with the deep blue-gray tones of the background, created an epic atmosphere of desolation, loneliness, and yet full of indomitable vitality.", + "seed": 26854, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_0/index_5551_seed_26854_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.16365694075357168, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16365694075357168, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16365694075357168, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extreme distance and pan slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a weathered, gnarled pine tree visible at the visual center on a rocky outcrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk twisted and tilted dramatically to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden crepuscular rays visible penetrating the clouds and illuminating the tree with a brilliant golden rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a long, sharply outlined black shadow visible on the ground that slowly squirms and deforms as the light changes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7615912556648254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6365912556648254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7615912556648254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7615912556648254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18491706252098083, + 0.055464573204517365, + 0.21895074844360352, + 0.09572017937898636, + 0.15628761053085327, + 0.05424594134092331, + 0.0634370669722557, + 0.029786845669150352, + 0.09351499378681183, + 0.04767502471804619 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7615912556648254 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extreme distance and pan slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a weathered, gnarled pine tree visible at the visual center on a rocky outcrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk twisted and tilted dramatically to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden crepuscular rays visible penetrating the clouds and illuminating the tree with a brilliant golden rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a long, sharply outlined black shadow visible on the ground that slowly squirms and deforms as the light changes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005971330218017101 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130971431732178 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005971330218017101, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005971330218017101, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15013569593429565, + 0.16282306611537933, + 0.06762310862541199, + 0.08286873251199722, + 0.0634601041674614, + 0.0583607479929924, + 0.1377844661474228, + 0.06094498559832573, + 0.11193500459194183, + 0.10406409949064255 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005971330218017101 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extreme distance and pan slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a weathered, gnarled pine tree visible at the visual center on a rocky outcrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk twisted and tilted dramatically to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden crepuscular rays visible penetrating the clouds and illuminating the tree with a brilliant golden rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a long, sharply outlined black shadow visible on the ground that slowly squirms and deforms as the light changes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001719426247291267 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.3767194747924805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001719426247291267, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001719426247291267, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2657877206802368, + 0.1284586787223816, + 0.09990282356739044, + 0.07095270603895187, + 0.05967717990279198, + 0.06127065047621727, + 0.12273998558521271, + 0.040325384587049484, + 0.07322149723768234, + 0.0776633769273758 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001719426247291267 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extreme distance and pan slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a weathered, gnarled pine tree visible at the visual center on a rocky outcrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk twisted and tilted dramatically to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden crepuscular rays visible penetrating the clouds and illuminating the tree with a brilliant golden rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a long, sharply outlined black shadow visible on the ground that slowly squirms and deforms as the light changes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00595379201695323 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130953788757324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00595379201695323, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00595379201695323, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3158581852912903, + 0.12345347553491592, + 0.0344804972410202, + 0.08821939677000046, + 0.07893829047679901, + 0.05113472044467926, + 0.09375565499067307, + 0.04497487097978592, + 0.03430149331688881, + 0.13488346338272095 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00595379201695323 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extreme distance and pan slowly to the left?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a weathered, gnarled pine tree visible at the visual center on a rocky outcrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk twisted and tilted dramatically to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are golden crepuscular rays visible penetrating the clouds and illuminating the tree with a brilliant golden rim?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a long, sharply outlined black shadow visible on the ground that slowly squirms and deforms as the light changes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04304889962077141 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168048858642578 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04304889962077141, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04304889962077141, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1940757930278778, + 0.16942688822746277, + 0.11113537102937698, + 0.06991522759199142, + 0.047937456518411636, + 0.10265235602855682, + 0.07752011716365814, + 0.0628279447555542, + 0.053694527596235275, + 0.11081437021493912 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04304889962077141 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_1/index_tensor([4161, 4161])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_1/index_tensor([4161, 4161])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..717d72189a550c3c2b3ab1df53f05ea9c9d882e0 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_1/index_tensor([4161, 4161])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "wide shot, captured from a distant hillside, steadily pans from left to right, tracking a bizarre train constructed entirely of giant brass gears and steam pistons. The train's body is a chaotic, exposed mass of machinery, its countless large and small, gleaming bronze gears meshing frantically, while bright copper steam pistons pump violently up and down on either side. Rather than a smooth ride, it jolted and lurched forward with a comical jerkiness over the uneven track, the entire structure swaying and bouncing violently as if on the verge of falling apart. Each exaggerated jolt caused its metal parts to collide, creating a visually dynamic sense of clashing parts. Meanwhile, thick white steam billowed from several rudimentary chimneys, billowing and dissipating in the warm, golden afternoon sunlight. The entire scene is bathed in a soft, slanting sun, which creates dazzling highlights on the brass surfaces and casts long shadows, creating an atmosphere both chaotic and spectacular, imbued with the allure of steampunk fantasy.", + "seed": 5610, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_1/index_4161_seed_5610_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.16414692997932434, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16414692997932434, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.349999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16414692997932434, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the train constructed entirely of giant brass gears and steam pistons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train's body a chaotic, exposed mass of machinery with gleaming bronze gears meshing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do bright copper steam pistons pump violently up and down on either side of the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train move with a comical jerkiness, jolting and lurching forward while swaying and bouncing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured in a wide shot from a distant hillside with the camera panning steadily from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.35291457176208496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.227914571762085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.35291457176208496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.35291457176208496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14901696145534515, + 0.07829733937978745, + 0.05694153532385826, + 0.06980462372303009, + 0.12159593403339386, + 0.18900586664676666, + 0.14940603077411652, + 0.058537885546684265, + 0.06847114115953445, + 0.058922603726387024 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.35291457176208496 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the train constructed entirely of giant brass gears and steam pistons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train's body a chaotic, exposed mass of machinery with gleaming bronze gears meshing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do bright copper steam pistons pump violently up and down on either side of the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train move with a comical jerkiness, jolting and lurching forward while swaying and bouncing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured in a wide shot from a distant hillside with the camera panning steadily from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01820533163845539 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018205165863037 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01820533163845539, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01820533163845539, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09645640850067139, + 0.17009304463863373, + 0.09442360699176788, + 0.055638108402490616, + 0.0796782597899437, + 0.07798758149147034, + 0.08877536654472351, + 0.0950646623969078, + 0.10451772809028625, + 0.13736529648303986 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01820533163845539 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the train constructed entirely of giant brass gears and steam pistons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train's body a chaotic, exposed mass of machinery with gleaming bronze gears meshing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do bright copper steam pistons pump violently up and down on either side of the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train move with a comical jerkiness, jolting and lurching forward while swaying and bouncing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured in a wide shot from a distant hillside with the camera panning steadily from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11294256895780563 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379424571990967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11294256895780563, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11294256895780563, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.054754048585891724, + 0.04357273131608963, + 0.029507379978895187, + 0.10441510379314423, + 0.273095965385437, + 0.024818889796733856, + 0.03916960954666138, + 0.22251121699810028, + 0.020426876842975616, + 0.18772810697555542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11294256895780563 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the train constructed entirely of giant brass gears and steam pistons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train's body a chaotic, exposed mass of machinery with gleaming bronze gears meshing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do bright copper steam pistons pump violently up and down on either side of the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train move with a comical jerkiness, jolting and lurching forward while swaying and bouncing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured in a wide shot from a distant hillside with the camera panning steadily from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02328225038945675 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773282289505005 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02328225038945675, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02328225038945675, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11287791281938553, + 0.06069270521402359, + 0.05843980237841606, + 0.11652200669050217, + 0.14034700393676758, + 0.10136581212282181, + 0.22241707146167755, + 0.07507270574569702, + 0.04606982693076134, + 0.0661950632929802 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02328225038945675 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the train constructed entirely of giant brass gears and steam pistons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train's body a chaotic, exposed mass of machinery with gleaming bronze gears meshing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do bright copper steam pistons pump violently up and down on either side of the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train move with a comical jerkiness, jolting and lurching forward while swaying and bouncing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured in a wide shot from a distant hillside with the camera panning steadily from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31338992714881897 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3133898973464966 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31338992714881897, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31338992714881897, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4677373766899109, + 0.02018272876739502, + 0.01501999981701374, + 0.0329732708632946, + 0.15341410040855408, + 0.03197585046291351, + 0.026569562032818794, + 0.16812296211719513, + 0.02716839127242565, + 0.05683578550815582 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31338992714881897 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide shot, captured from a distant hillside, steadily pans from left to right, tracking a bizarre train constructed entirely of giant brass gears and steam pistons. The train's body is a chaotic, exposed mass of machinery, its countless large and small, gleaming bronze gears meshing frantically, while bright copper steam pistons pump violently up and down on either side. Rather than a smooth ride, it jolted and lurched forward with a comical jerkiness over the uneven track, the entire structure swaying and bouncing violently as if on the verge of falling apart. Each exaggerated jolt caused its metal parts to collide, creating a visually dynamic sense of clashing parts. Meanwhile, thick white steam billowed from several rudimentary chimneys, billowing and dissipating in the warm, golden afternoon sunlight. The entire scene is bathed in a soft, slanting sun, which creates dazzling highlights on the brass surfaces and casts long shadows, creating an atmosphere both chaotic and spectacular, imbued with the allure of steampunk fantasy.", + "seed": 5611, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_1/index_4161_seed_5611_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2867593357339501, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2867593357339501, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2867593357339501, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the train constructed entirely of giant brass gears and steam pistons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train's body a chaotic, exposed mass of machinery with gleaming bronze gears meshing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do bright copper steam pistons pump violently up and down on either side of the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train move with a comical jerkiness, jolting and lurching forward while swaying and bouncing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured in a wide shot from a distant hillside with the camera panning steadily from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1384730339050293 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3884730041027069 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1384730339050293, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1384730339050293, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18223878741264343, + 0.049462661147117615, + 0.1507287472486496, + 0.07425335794687271, + 0.06909282505512238, + 0.09787414968013763, + 0.02906888723373413, + 0.16627012193202972, + 0.07332037389278412, + 0.10769007354974747 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1384730339050293 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the train constructed entirely of giant brass gears and steam pistons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train's body a chaotic, exposed mass of machinery with gleaming bronze gears meshing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do bright copper steam pistons pump violently up and down on either side of the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train move with a comical jerkiness, jolting and lurching forward while swaying and bouncing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured in a wide shot from a distant hillside with the camera panning steadily from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011096787638962269 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511096954345703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011096787638962269, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011096787638962269, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11947304755449295, + 0.05553575977683067, + 0.0918748527765274, + 0.08628065139055252, + 0.03432302922010422, + 0.07865335792303085, + 0.0664067268371582, + 0.16894499957561493, + 0.07063105702400208, + 0.22787655889987946 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011096787638962269 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the train constructed entirely of giant brass gears and steam pistons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train's body a chaotic, exposed mass of machinery with gleaming bronze gears meshing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do bright copper steam pistons pump violently up and down on either side of the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train move with a comical jerkiness, jolting and lurching forward while swaying and bouncing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured in a wide shot from a distant hillside with the camera panning steadily from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811084106564522 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881107330322266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811084106564522, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811084106564522, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0762149915099144, + 0.00890996865928173, + 0.03256148472428322, + 0.012986612506210804, + 0.012263096868991852, + 0.0572538822889328, + 0.029959235340356827, + 0.5092710256576538, + 0.022278910502791405, + 0.23830080032348633 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811084106564522 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the train constructed entirely of giant brass gears and steam pistons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train's body a chaotic, exposed mass of machinery with gleaming bronze gears meshing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do bright copper steam pistons pump violently up and down on either side of the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train move with a comical jerkiness, jolting and lurching forward while swaying and bouncing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured in a wide shot from a distant hillside with the camera panning steadily from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020577985793352127 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895577907562256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020577985793352127, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020577985793352127, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1649436503648758, + 0.03521725535392761, + 0.06256557255983353, + 0.05014725401997566, + 0.02411610819399357, + 0.08051911741495132, + 0.10566160082817078, + 0.15187139809131622, + 0.07995735108852386, + 0.2450007051229477 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020577985793352127 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the train constructed entirely of giant brass gears and steam pistons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train's body a chaotic, exposed mass of machinery with gleaming bronze gears meshing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do bright copper steam pistons pump violently up and down on either side of the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train move with a comical jerkiness, jolting and lurching forward while swaying and bouncing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured in a wide shot from a distant hillside with the camera panning steadily from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22553803026676178 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005380153656006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22553803026676178, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22553803026676178, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0956144779920578, + 0.007324536796659231, + 0.017145929858088493, + 0.012560919858515263, + 0.025879863649606705, + 0.0848117545247078, + 0.0398988351225853, + 0.6415314078330994, + 0.022381605580449104, + 0.05285067483782768 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22553803026676178 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide shot, captured from a distant hillside, steadily pans from left to right, tracking a bizarre train constructed entirely of giant brass gears and steam pistons. The train's body is a chaotic, exposed mass of machinery, its countless large and small, gleaming bronze gears meshing frantically, while bright copper steam pistons pump violently up and down on either side. Rather than a smooth ride, it jolted and lurched forward with a comical jerkiness over the uneven track, the entire structure swaying and bouncing violently as if on the verge of falling apart. Each exaggerated jolt caused its metal parts to collide, creating a visually dynamic sense of clashing parts. Meanwhile, thick white steam billowed from several rudimentary chimneys, billowing and dissipating in the warm, golden afternoon sunlight. The entire scene is bathed in a soft, slanting sun, which creates dazzling highlights on the brass surfaces and casts long shadows, creating an atmosphere both chaotic and spectacular, imbued with the allure of steampunk fantasy.", + "seed": 5612, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_1/index_4161_seed_5612_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.256237168982625, + "vlm_logprob": -0.256237168982625, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.256237168982625, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the train constructed entirely of giant brass gears and steam pistons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train's body a chaotic, exposed mass of machinery with gleaming bronze gears meshing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do bright copper steam pistons pump violently up and down on either side of the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train move with a comical jerkiness, jolting and lurching forward while swaying and bouncing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured in a wide shot from a distant hillside with the camera panning steadily from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1374907493591309 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38749077916145325 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1374907493591309, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1374907493591309, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1986563801765442, + 0.09320636838674545, + 0.09029653668403625, + 0.1411500722169876, + 0.050466664135456085, + 0.17016935348510742, + 0.04528292641043663, + 0.10308392345905304, + 0.04861845821142197, + 0.05906934663653374 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1374907493591309 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the train constructed entirely of giant brass gears and steam pistons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train's body a chaotic, exposed mass of machinery with gleaming bronze gears meshing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do bright copper steam pistons pump violently up and down on either side of the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train move with a comical jerkiness, jolting and lurching forward while swaying and bouncing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured in a wide shot from a distant hillside with the camera panning steadily from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02331334725022316 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773313283920288 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02331334725022316, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02331334725022316, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22870740294456482, + 0.12385043501853943, + 0.12758015096187592, + 0.0772179588675499, + 0.0806851014494896, + 0.10516156256198883, + 0.05696028843522072, + 0.0937652438879013, + 0.0251754317432642, + 0.08089642971754074 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02331334725022316 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the train constructed entirely of giant brass gears and steam pistons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train's body a chaotic, exposed mass of machinery with gleaming bronze gears meshing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do bright copper steam pistons pump violently up and down on either side of the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train move with a comical jerkiness, jolting and lurching forward while swaying and bouncing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured in a wide shot from a distant hillside with the camera panning steadily from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029808273538947105 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529808282852173 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029808273538947105, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029808273538947105, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2460751086473465, + 0.2011318951845169, + 0.07512989640235901, + 0.07334782928228378, + 0.05599261075258255, + 0.17842009663581848, + 0.032660920172929764, + 0.03615511208772659, + 0.027353502810001373, + 0.07373296469449997 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029808273538947105 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the train constructed entirely of giant brass gears and steam pistons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train's body a chaotic, exposed mass of machinery with gleaming bronze gears meshing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do bright copper steam pistons pump violently up and down on either side of the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train move with a comical jerkiness, jolting and lurching forward while swaying and bouncing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured in a wide shot from a distant hillside with the camera panning steadily from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020576000213623047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895576000213623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020576000213623047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020576000213623047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2128741592168808, + 0.21351143717765808, + 0.05966293439269066, + 0.03794804960489273, + 0.08399710059165955, + 0.22852927446365356, + 0.022991416975855827, + 0.02502819523215294, + 0.031044943258166313, + 0.08441247791051865 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020576000213623047 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the train constructed entirely of giant brass gears and steam pistons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train's body a chaotic, exposed mass of machinery with gleaming bronze gears meshing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do bright copper steam pistons pump violently up and down on either side of the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train move with a comical jerkiness, jolting and lurching forward while swaying and bouncing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured in a wide shot from a distant hillside with the camera panning steadily from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06999747455120087 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.694997549057007 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06999747455120087, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06999747455120087, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3459765911102295, + 0.15281109511852264, + 0.03820859268307686, + 0.11711237579584122, + 0.03489517420530319, + 0.16161586344242096, + 0.06639612466096878, + 0.03247203677892685, + 0.017877968028187752, + 0.0326341837644577 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06999747455120087 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide shot, captured from a distant hillside, steadily pans from left to right, tracking a bizarre train constructed entirely of giant brass gears and steam pistons. The train's body is a chaotic, exposed mass of machinery, its countless large and small, gleaming bronze gears meshing frantically, while bright copper steam pistons pump violently up and down on either side. Rather than a smooth ride, it jolted and lurched forward with a comical jerkiness over the uneven track, the entire structure swaying and bouncing violently as if on the verge of falling apart. Each exaggerated jolt caused its metal parts to collide, creating a visually dynamic sense of clashing parts. Meanwhile, thick white steam billowed from several rudimentary chimneys, billowing and dissipating in the warm, golden afternoon sunlight. The entire scene is bathed in a soft, slanting sun, which creates dazzling highlights on the brass surfaces and casts long shadows, creating an atmosphere both chaotic and spectacular, imbued with the allure of steampunk fantasy.", + "seed": 5613, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_1/index_4161_seed_5613_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1433506863191724, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1433506863191724, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1433506863191724, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the train constructed entirely of giant brass gears and steam pistons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train's body a chaotic, exposed mass of machinery with gleaming bronze gears meshing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do bright copper steam pistons pump violently up and down on either side of the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train move with a comical jerkiness, jolting and lurching forward while swaying and bouncing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured in a wide shot from a distant hillside with the camera panning steadily from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5249669551849365 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8999669551849365 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5249669551849365, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5249669551849365, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18783409893512726, + 0.13034968078136444, + 0.062400370836257935, + 0.027732394635677338, + 0.12724275887012482, + 0.07393348217010498, + 0.19590359926223755, + 0.06163615733385086, + 0.05000651255249977, + 0.08296094834804535 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5249669551849365 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the train constructed entirely of giant brass gears and steam pistons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train's body a chaotic, exposed mass of machinery with gleaming bronze gears meshing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do bright copper steam pistons pump violently up and down on either side of the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train move with a comical jerkiness, jolting and lurching forward while swaying and bouncing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured in a wide shot from a distant hillside with the camera panning steadily from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012551716528832912 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387551784515381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012551716528832912, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012551716528832912, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13461409509181976, + 0.09259609133005142, + 0.06804275512695312, + 0.061182837933301926, + 0.11354999244213104, + 0.06472901999950409, + 0.06599170714616776, + 0.22598589956760406, + 0.04764619097113609, + 0.12566137313842773 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012551716528832912 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the train constructed entirely of giant brass gears and steam pistons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train's body a chaotic, exposed mass of machinery with gleaming bronze gears meshing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do bright copper steam pistons pump violently up and down on either side of the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train move with a comical jerkiness, jolting and lurching forward while swaying and bouncing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured in a wide shot from a distant hillside with the camera panning steadily from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043062712997198105 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168062686920166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043062712997198105, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043062712997198105, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19950997829437256, + 0.17956985533237457, + 0.036657899618148804, + 0.04781389608979225, + 0.07793112099170685, + 0.07069231569766998, + 0.07571688294410706, + 0.03483318164944649, + 0.06060020253062248, + 0.2166745960712433 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043062712997198105 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the train constructed entirely of giant brass gears and steam pistons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train's body a chaotic, exposed mass of machinery with gleaming bronze gears meshing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do bright copper steam pistons pump violently up and down on either side of the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train move with a comical jerkiness, jolting and lurching forward while swaying and bouncing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured in a wide shot from a distant hillside with the camera panning steadily from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023276543244719505 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732765674591064 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023276543244719505, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023276543244719505, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20958298444747925, + 0.08778245002031326, + 0.06719481945037842, + 0.03654208406805992, + 0.09146596491336823, + 0.08422138541936874, + 0.04218543320894241, + 0.13827946782112122, + 0.09667231142520905, + 0.146073117852211 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023276543244719505 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the train constructed entirely of giant brass gears and steam pistons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the train's body a chaotic, exposed mass of machinery with gleaming bronze gears meshing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do bright copper steam pistons pump violently up and down on either side of the train?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the train move with a comical jerkiness, jolting and lurching forward while swaying and bouncing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene captured in a wide shot from a distant hillside with the camera panning steadily from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11289550364017487 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2378954887390137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11289550364017487, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11289550364017487, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4516817331314087, + 0.09549076855182648, + 0.041339386254549026, + 0.031099433079361916, + 0.04377920925617218, + 0.08819203823804855, + 0.09949170053005219, + 0.08388479799032211, + 0.0400858037173748, + 0.024955151602625847 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11289550364017487 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_10/index_tensor([2, 2])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_10/index_tensor([2, 2])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2c14c1a9a993c6f758d179443d09c60512773ac1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_10/index_tensor([2, 2])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from a slightly overhead, horizontal angle, features a concentrated, warm yellow spotlight shining diagonally from above, precisely illuminating the center of the scene. An antique copper coin spins steadily and rapidly in the air. Its deep reddish-brown metal surface, stained with age and featuring a faint classical portrait, merges into a hazy, shimmering ring in its rapid motion. Beneath the coin lies a mirror-smooth, pure black obsidian, its cold surface clearly reflecting the coin's dynamic reflection and the warm light. Reaching its apex, the coin begins to oscillate erratically, its trajectory becoming unpredictable before slamming into the obsidian with a crisp, powerful impact. After a brief bounce, it quickly settles, landing face-up. The intense contrast of light and shadow against the dark background creates an atmosphere of suspense, focus, and a sense of fateful drama.", + "seed": 12690, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_10/index_2_seed_12690_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.21075741723179817, + "vlm_logprob": -0.21075741723179817, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.21075741723179817, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly overhead horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a concentrated warm yellow spotlight shining diagonally from above illuminating the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an antique copper coin with a deep reddish-brown surface and faint classical portrait visible spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a mirror-smooth pure black obsidian surface visible beneath the coin reflecting the light and coin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the coin oscillate erratically before slamming into the obsidian and settling face-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1851462423801422 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8101462125778198 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1851462423801422, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1851462423801422, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09246968477964401, + 0.11924394965171814, + 0.11698850244283676, + 0.11243265867233276, + 0.08550171554088593, + 0.08596104383468628, + 0.16825129091739655, + 0.14941473305225372, + 0.04328366369009018, + 0.026452749967575073 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1851462423801422 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly overhead horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a concentrated warm yellow spotlight shining diagonally from above illuminating the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an antique copper coin with a deep reddish-brown surface and faint classical portrait visible spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a mirror-smooth pure black obsidian surface visible beneath the coin reflecting the light and coin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the coin oscillate erratically before slamming into the obsidian and settling face-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029830720275640488 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298306941986084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029830720275640488, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029830720275640488, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06533577293157578, + 0.05802623927593231, + 0.06008639931678772, + 0.10489538311958313, + 0.055050354450941086, + 0.07092760503292084, + 0.4177030920982361, + 0.1093766987323761, + 0.023198720067739487, + 0.035399727523326874 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029830720275640488 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly overhead horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a concentrated warm yellow spotlight shining diagonally from above illuminating the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an antique copper coin with a deep reddish-brown surface and faint classical portrait visible spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a mirror-smooth pure black obsidian surface visible beneath the coin reflecting the light and coin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the coin oscillate erratically before slamming into the obsidian and settling face-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898514717817307 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789852142333984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898514717817307, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898514717817307, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05849810689687729, + 0.03367188572883606, + 0.06802479177713394, + 0.22296202182769775, + 0.03772536292672157, + 0.07377603650093079, + 0.3551550507545471, + 0.10649417340755463, + 0.02415739744901657, + 0.019535208120942116 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898514717817307 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly overhead horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a concentrated warm yellow spotlight shining diagonally from above illuminating the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an antique copper coin with a deep reddish-brown surface and faint classical portrait visible spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a mirror-smooth pure black obsidian surface visible beneath the coin reflecting the light and coin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the coin oscillate erratically before slamming into the obsidian and settling face-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270400732755661 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127040147781372 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270400732755661, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270400732755661, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05922820419073105, + 0.04076894000172615, + 0.0757775828242302, + 0.13989724218845367, + 0.05191660672426224, + 0.05139845237135887, + 0.3342897295951843, + 0.16159777343273163, + 0.029558802023530006, + 0.05556667223572731 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270400732755661 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly overhead horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a concentrated warm yellow spotlight shining diagonally from above illuminating the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an antique copper coin with a deep reddish-brown surface and faint classical portrait visible spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a mirror-smooth pure black obsidian surface visible beneath the coin reflecting the light and coin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the coin oscillate erratically before slamming into the obsidian and settling face-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.632784903049469 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.757784903049469 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.632784903049469, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.632784903049469, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0277362372726202, + 0.0335722379386425, + 0.032362837344408035, + 0.2441878318786621, + 0.015356645919382572, + 0.11083906143903732, + 0.44475796818733215, + 0.0511559434235096, + 0.014424911700189114, + 0.02560633048415184 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.632784903049469 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from a slightly overhead, horizontal angle, features a concentrated, warm yellow spotlight shining diagonally from above, precisely illuminating the center of the scene. An antique copper coin spins steadily and rapidly in the air. Its deep reddish-brown metal surface, stained with age and featuring a faint classical portrait, merges into a hazy, shimmering ring in its rapid motion. Beneath the coin lies a mirror-smooth, pure black obsidian, its cold surface clearly reflecting the coin's dynamic reflection and the warm light. Reaching its apex, the coin begins to oscillate erratically, its trajectory becoming unpredictable before slamming into the obsidian with a crisp, powerful impact. After a brief bounce, it quickly settles, landing face-up. The intense contrast of light and shadow against the dark background creates an atmosphere of suspense, focus, and a sense of fateful drama.", + "seed": 12691, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_10/index_2_seed_12691_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.5686549298465252, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5686549298465252, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 0.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5686549298465252, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly overhead horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a concentrated warm yellow spotlight shining diagonally from above illuminating the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an antique copper coin with a deep reddish-brown surface and faint classical portrait visible spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a mirror-smooth pure black obsidian surface visible beneath the coin reflecting the light and coin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the coin oscillate erratically before slamming into the obsidian and settling face-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18515753746032715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8101575374603271 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18515753746032715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18515753746032715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08030141890048981, + 0.1516755372285843, + 0.11479256302118301, + 0.21246008574962616, + 0.06948868185281754, + 0.02389545924961567, + 0.2512562572956085, + 0.06909871846437454, + 0.01627528667449951, + 0.010755949653685093 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18515753746032715 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly overhead horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a concentrated warm yellow spotlight shining diagonally from above illuminating the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an antique copper coin with a deep reddish-brown surface and faint classical portrait visible spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a mirror-smooth pure black obsidian surface visible beneath the coin reflecting the light and coin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the coin oscillate erratically before slamming into the obsidian and settling face-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03813597187399864 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881360054016113 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03813597187399864, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03813597187399864, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04824762046337128, + 0.21645095944404602, + 0.1270446479320526, + 0.13550293445587158, + 0.046062104403972626, + 0.0313025638461113, + 0.2368815690279007, + 0.12068285048007965, + 0.027720795944333076, + 0.010103984735906124 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03813597187399864 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly overhead horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a concentrated warm yellow spotlight shining diagonally from above illuminating the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an antique copper coin with a deep reddish-brown surface and faint classical portrait visible spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a mirror-smooth pure black obsidian surface visible beneath the coin reflecting the light and coin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the coin oscillate erratically before slamming into the obsidian and settling face-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289388358592987 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.053938865661621 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4289388358592987, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4289388358592987, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06734555214643478, + 0.2335476577281952, + 0.08624598383903503, + 0.30328646302223206, + 0.1398812085390091, + 0.03558573126792908, + 0.020838527008891106, + 0.07337341457605362, + 0.024900440126657486, + 0.014995023608207703 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4289388358592987 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly overhead horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a concentrated warm yellow spotlight shining diagonally from above illuminating the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an antique copper coin with a deep reddish-brown surface and faint classical portrait visible spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a mirror-smooth pure black obsidian surface visible beneath the coin reflecting the light and coin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the coin oscillate erratically before slamming into the obsidian and settling face-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137125849723816 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3871258497238159 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.137125849723816, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.137125849723816, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0907193124294281, + 0.2518947720527649, + 0.0968252494931221, + 0.13929849863052368, + 0.10471955686807632, + 0.08687977492809296, + 0.031780365854501724, + 0.1087460145354271, + 0.07824140042066574, + 0.010895061306655407 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.137125849723816 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly overhead horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a concentrated warm yellow spotlight shining diagonally from above illuminating the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an antique copper coin with a deep reddish-brown surface and faint classical portrait visible spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a mirror-smooth pure black obsidian surface visible beneath the coin reflecting the light and coin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the coin oscillate erratically before slamming into the obsidian and settling face-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539164543151855 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42891648411750793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0539164543151855, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0539164543151855, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0872589573264122, + 0.30052462220191956, + 0.060739174485206604, + 0.12784351408481598, + 0.06632227450609207, + 0.020375363528728485, + 0.21728233993053436, + 0.08325199782848358, + 0.01942632906138897, + 0.016975386068224907 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0539164543151855 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from a slightly overhead, horizontal angle, features a concentrated, warm yellow spotlight shining diagonally from above, precisely illuminating the center of the scene. An antique copper coin spins steadily and rapidly in the air. Its deep reddish-brown metal surface, stained with age and featuring a faint classical portrait, merges into a hazy, shimmering ring in its rapid motion. Beneath the coin lies a mirror-smooth, pure black obsidian, its cold surface clearly reflecting the coin's dynamic reflection and the warm light. Reaching its apex, the coin begins to oscillate erratically, its trajectory becoming unpredictable before slamming into the obsidian with a crisp, powerful impact. After a brief bounce, it quickly settles, landing face-up. The intense contrast of light and shadow against the dark background creates an atmosphere of suspense, focus, and a sense of fateful drama.", + "seed": 12692, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_10/index_2_seed_12692_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.061431142315268514, + "vlm_logprob": -0.061431142315268514, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.061431142315268514, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly overhead horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a concentrated warm yellow spotlight shining diagonally from above illuminating the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an antique copper coin with a deep reddish-brown surface and faint classical portrait visible spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a mirror-smooth pure black obsidian surface visible beneath the coin reflecting the light and coin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the coin oscillate erratically before slamming into the obsidian and settling face-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06712523102760315 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9421253204345703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06712523102760315, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06712523102760315, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08102837204933167, + 0.4400985836982727, + 0.028101621195673943, + 0.09337769448757172, + 0.02687861956655979, + 0.023199090734124184, + 0.057926956564188004, + 0.118690624833107, + 0.04554228112101555, + 0.08515613526105881 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06712523102760315 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly overhead horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a concentrated warm yellow spotlight shining diagonally from above illuminating the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an antique copper coin with a deep reddish-brown surface and faint classical portrait visible spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a mirror-smooth pure black obsidian surface visible beneath the coin reflecting the light and coin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the coin oscillate erratically before slamming into the obsidian and settling face-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011101856827735901 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511101722717285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011101856827735901, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011101856827735901, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03806636482477188, + 0.7645177841186523, + 0.04230211675167084, + 0.04171845689415932, + 0.01482655294239521, + 0.010380666702985764, + 0.014173377305269241, + 0.012041195295751095, + 0.012717431411147118, + 0.0492560975253582 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011101856827735901 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly overhead horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a concentrated warm yellow spotlight shining diagonally from above illuminating the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an antique copper coin with a deep reddish-brown surface and faint classical portrait visible spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a mirror-smooth pure black obsidian surface visible beneath the coin reflecting the light and coin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the coin oscillate erratically before slamming into the obsidian and settling face-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0232975073158741 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732975482940674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0232975073158741, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0232975073158741, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10803394764661789, + 0.36296021938323975, + 0.08194786310195923, + 0.11752742528915405, + 0.027213089168071747, + 0.03701527416706085, + 0.029416780918836594, + 0.12963254749774933, + 0.03150953724980354, + 0.07474333792924881 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0232975073158741 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly overhead horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a concentrated warm yellow spotlight shining diagonally from above illuminating the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an antique copper coin with a deep reddish-brown surface and faint classical portrait visible spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a mirror-smooth pure black obsidian surface visible beneath the coin reflecting the light and coin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the coin oscillate erratically before slamming into the obsidian and settling face-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004094788804650307 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.50409460067749 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004094788804650307, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004094788804650307, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04368063807487488, + 0.7223604321479797, + 0.01846451498568058, + 0.049676161259412766, + 0.0201755128800869, + 0.0534529834985733, + 0.014244121499359608, + 0.048073895275592804, + 0.016649501398205757, + 0.013222221285104752 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004094788804650307 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly overhead horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a concentrated warm yellow spotlight shining diagonally from above illuminating the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an antique copper coin with a deep reddish-brown surface and faint classical portrait visible spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a mirror-smooth pure black obsidian surface visible beneath the coin reflecting the light and coin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the coin oscillate erratically before slamming into the obsidian and settling face-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20153632760047913 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015362977981567 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20153632760047913, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20153632760047913, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.007233952637761831, + 0.881421685218811, + 0.00769741041585803, + 0.03362385556101799, + 0.012659897096455097, + 0.008248499594628811, + 0.007969332858920097, + 0.019448833540081978, + 0.015664253383874893, + 0.006032325327396393 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20153632760047913 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from a slightly overhead, horizontal angle, features a concentrated, warm yellow spotlight shining diagonally from above, precisely illuminating the center of the scene. An antique copper coin spins steadily and rapidly in the air. Its deep reddish-brown metal surface, stained with age and featuring a faint classical portrait, merges into a hazy, shimmering ring in its rapid motion. Beneath the coin lies a mirror-smooth, pure black obsidian, its cold surface clearly reflecting the coin's dynamic reflection and the warm light. Reaching its apex, the coin begins to oscillate erratically, its trajectory becoming unpredictable before slamming into the obsidian with a crisp, powerful impact. After a brief bounce, it quickly settles, landing face-up. The intense contrast of light and shadow against the dark background creates an atmosphere of suspense, focus, and a sense of fateful drama.", + "seed": 12693, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_10/index_2_seed_12693_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.11804906632751226, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11804906632751226, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11804906632751226, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly overhead horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a concentrated warm yellow spotlight shining diagonally from above illuminating the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an antique copper coin with a deep reddish-brown surface and faint classical portrait visible spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a mirror-smooth pure black obsidian surface visible beneath the coin reflecting the light and coin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the coin oscillate erratically before slamming into the obsidian and settling face-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12093514949083328 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2459352016448975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12093514949083328, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12093514949083328, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15057814121246338, + 0.09285107254981995, + 0.04652275890111923, + 0.2320035696029663, + 0.13679122924804688, + 0.07413119822740555, + 0.17582891881465912, + 0.050037652254104614, + 0.01886563003063202, + 0.022389821708202362 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12093514949083328 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly overhead horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a concentrated warm yellow spotlight shining diagonally from above illuminating the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an antique copper coin with a deep reddish-brown surface and faint classical portrait visible spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a mirror-smooth pure black obsidian surface visible beneath the coin reflecting the light and coin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the coin oscillate erratically before slamming into the obsidian and settling face-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07005883008241653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695058822631836 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07005883008241653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07005883008241653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.219612717628479, + 0.09249939024448395, + 0.12257983535528183, + 0.17499680817127228, + 0.12500832974910736, + 0.07542262226343155, + 0.10437134653329849, + 0.0499834269285202, + 0.01209314540028572, + 0.023432372137904167 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07005883008241653 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly overhead horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a concentrated warm yellow spotlight shining diagonally from above illuminating the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an antique copper coin with a deep reddish-brown surface and faint classical portrait visible spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a mirror-smooth pure black obsidian surface visible beneath the coin reflecting the light and coin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the coin oscillate erratically before slamming into the obsidian and settling face-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810521960258484 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881052494049072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810521960258484, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810521960258484, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12848982214927673, + 0.06507409363985062, + 0.11596925556659698, + 0.39978593587875366, + 0.05213075131177902, + 0.07564892619848251, + 0.07344762980937958, + 0.03277947008609772, + 0.0331098772585392, + 0.02356421761214733 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810521960258484 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly overhead horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a concentrated warm yellow spotlight shining diagonally from above illuminating the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an antique copper coin with a deep reddish-brown surface and faint classical portrait visible spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a mirror-smooth pure black obsidian surface visible beneath the coin reflecting the light and coin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the coin oscillate erratically before slamming into the obsidian and settling face-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012533704750239849 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387533664703369 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012533704750239849, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012533704750239849, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11363905668258667, + 0.09538068622350693, + 0.032576754689216614, + 0.297828733921051, + 0.15833359956741333, + 0.05504760146141052, + 0.14682969450950623, + 0.06075720861554146, + 0.011261713691055775, + 0.028344951570034027 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012533704750239849 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly overhead horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a concentrated warm yellow spotlight shining diagonally from above illuminating the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an antique copper coin with a deep reddish-brown surface and faint classical portrait visible spinning rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a mirror-smooth pure black obsidian surface visible beneath the coin reflecting the light and coin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the coin oscillate erratically before slamming into the obsidian and settling face-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486124277114868 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236124277114868 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486124277114868, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486124277114868, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08376608788967133, + 0.0828171819448471, + 0.12081684917211533, + 0.12379128485918045, + 0.106302410364151, + 0.10480446368455887, + 0.2336088865995407, + 0.06236128509044647, + 0.057190749794244766, + 0.024540795013308525 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486124277114868 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_11/index_tensor([1557, 1557])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_11/index_tensor([1557, 1557])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..942ddf3c7e5e53d36c1ca3f51e6afa638130958b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_11/index_tensor([1557, 1557])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle shot unfolds across a massive American flag, its silhouette silhouetted against a warm sunset sky. As the camera begins a slow, deliberate push-in, the flag begins to flutter majestically in a steady breeze. The movement isn't frantic, but rather a series of powerful, graceful undulations that weave through the heavy fabric. Surreal details become increasingly apparent; crimson stripes appear to glow from within, pristine white stripes capture golden hues, and the rich navy blue possesses a cosmic texture. The camera's slow advance reveals the intricate weave of the material, the tight stitching separating the stripes, and the raised, tactile quality of the fifty embroidered stars. The setting sun, low on the horizon, backlights the flag, making the fabric appear slightly translucent and highlighting every subtle fold and ripple with a glowing edge, while casting deep, soft shadows within its valleys. The entire scene is imbued with a tranquil, solemn, and awe-inspiring atmosphere as the frame gradually fills with the texture of the flag, transforming the patriotic symbol into a breathtaking abstract landscape of color, light, and movement.", + "seed": 8345, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_11/index_1557_seed_8345_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04954755073413253, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04954755073413253, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04954755073413253, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive American flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the flag flutter with powerful, graceful undulations rather than frantic movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flag's stripes exhibit glowing crimson and golden hues while the blue field has a cosmic texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate push-in that gradually fills the frame with the flag's texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the flag backlit by a low setting sun, creating translucent fabric with glowing edges and deep soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004480086732655764 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504479885101318 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004480086732655764, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004480086732655764, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16423769295215607, + 0.10166727751493454, + 0.18428045511245728, + 0.06825205683708191, + 0.10391425341367722, + 0.10883388668298721, + 0.05066119506955147, + 0.14211373031139374, + 0.042131178081035614, + 0.03390830010175705 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004480086732655764 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive American flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the flag flutter with powerful, graceful undulations rather than frantic movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flag's stripes exhibit glowing crimson and golden hues while the blue field has a cosmic texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate push-in that gradually fills the frame with the flag's texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the flag backlit by a low setting sun, creating translucent fabric with glowing edges and deep soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01421328168362379 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2642130851745605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01421328168362379, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01421328168362379, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10367447137832642, + 0.0663408488035202, + 0.17288053035736084, + 0.05018619820475578, + 0.13226191699504852, + 0.18931281566619873, + 0.02890585921704769, + 0.19747143983840942, + 0.035614077001810074, + 0.023351818323135376 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01421328168362379 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive American flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the flag flutter with powerful, graceful undulations rather than frantic movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flag's stripes exhibit glowing crimson and golden hues while the blue field has a cosmic texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate push-in that gradually fills the frame with the flag's texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the flag backlit by a low setting sun, creating translucent fabric with glowing edges and deep soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002092897891998 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695020914077759 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002092897891998, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002092897891998, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07778818905353546, + 0.07120880484580994, + 0.10131901502609253, + 0.06874057650566101, + 0.05556377023458481, + 0.15885263681411743, + 0.02092909812927246, + 0.34063291549682617, + 0.07009439915418625, + 0.034870583564043045 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002092897891998 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive American flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the flag flutter with powerful, graceful undulations rather than frantic movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flag's stripes exhibit glowing crimson and golden hues while the blue field has a cosmic texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate push-in that gradually fills the frame with the flag's texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the flag backlit by a low setting sun, creating translucent fabric with glowing edges and deep soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07001136988401413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950113773345947 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07001136988401413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07001136988401413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05101597681641579, + 0.10487820953130722, + 0.17899760603904724, + 0.04483393207192421, + 0.10386639088392258, + 0.12830132246017456, + 0.025278227403759956, + 0.29421964287757874, + 0.01638898067176342, + 0.05221971496939659 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07001136988401413 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive American flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the flag flutter with powerful, graceful undulations rather than frantic movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flag's stripes exhibit glowing crimson and golden hues while the blue field has a cosmic texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate push-in that gradually fills the frame with the flag's texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the flag backlit by a low setting sun, creating translucent fabric with glowing edges and deep soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08901208639144897 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640121459960938 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08901208639144897, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08901208639144897, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1501997709274292, + 0.12487635016441345, + 0.1285146027803421, + 0.10684429854154587, + 0.09289325773715973, + 0.08578755706548691, + 0.07048914581537247, + 0.15548540651798248, + 0.028400065377354622, + 0.0565095990896225 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08901208639144897 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle shot unfolds across a massive American flag, its silhouette silhouetted against a warm sunset sky. As the camera begins a slow, deliberate push-in, the flag begins to flutter majestically in a steady breeze. The movement isn't frantic, but rather a series of powerful, graceful undulations that weave through the heavy fabric. Surreal details become increasingly apparent; crimson stripes appear to glow from within, pristine white stripes capture golden hues, and the rich navy blue possesses a cosmic texture. The camera's slow advance reveals the intricate weave of the material, the tight stitching separating the stripes, and the raised, tactile quality of the fifty embroidered stars. The setting sun, low on the horizon, backlights the flag, making the fabric appear slightly translucent and highlighting every subtle fold and ripple with a glowing edge, while casting deep, soft shadows within its valleys. The entire scene is imbued with a tranquil, solemn, and awe-inspiring atmosphere as the frame gradually fills with the texture of the flag, transforming the patriotic symbol into a breathtaking abstract landscape of color, light, and movement.", + "seed": 8346, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_11/index_1557_seed_8346_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07689115940593183, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07689115940593183, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.424999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07689115940593183, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive American flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the flag flutter with powerful, graceful undulations rather than frantic movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flag's stripes exhibit glowing crimson and golden hues while the blue field has a cosmic texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate push-in that gradually fills the frame with the flag's texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the flag backlit by a low setting sun, creating translucent fabric with glowing edges and deep soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0038503098767250776 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.62885046005249 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0038503098767250776, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0038503098767250776, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11208148300647736, + 0.06459515541791916, + 0.24993066489696503, + 0.038020696491003036, + 0.14338834583759308, + 0.04541327804327011, + 0.013302153907716274, + 0.04836258664727211, + 0.23182708024978638, + 0.053078558295965195 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0038503098767250776 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive American flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the flag flutter with powerful, graceful undulations rather than frantic movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flag's stripes exhibit glowing crimson and golden hues while the blue field has a cosmic texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate push-in that gradually fills the frame with the flag's texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the flag backlit by a low setting sun, creating translucent fabric with glowing edges and deep soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819479651749134 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018194675445557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819479651749134, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819479651749134, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08899819850921631, + 0.1302313208580017, + 0.11050709336996078, + 0.05461030453443527, + 0.21297533810138702, + 0.033401619642972946, + 0.032243382185697556, + 0.042660970240831375, + 0.22677239775657654, + 0.06759931892156601 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819479651749134 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive American flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the flag flutter with powerful, graceful undulations rather than frantic movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flag's stripes exhibit glowing crimson and golden hues while the blue field has a cosmic texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate push-in that gradually fills the frame with the flag's texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the flag backlit by a low setting sun, creating translucent fabric with glowing edges and deep soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043057575821876526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168057680130005 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043057575821876526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043057575821876526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1450875699520111, + 0.05705150589346886, + 0.12124290317296982, + 0.032207198441028595, + 0.10258744657039642, + 0.025480249896645546, + 0.031265582889318466, + 0.03687603771686554, + 0.3386804461479187, + 0.1095210462808609 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043057575821876526 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive American flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the flag flutter with powerful, graceful undulations rather than frantic movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flag's stripes exhibit glowing crimson and golden hues while the blue field has a cosmic texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate push-in that gradually fills the frame with the flag's texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the flag backlit by a low setting sun, creating translucent fabric with glowing edges and deep soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03808422014117241 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880842685699463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03808422014117241, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03808422014117241, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10782527923583984, + 0.0685160905122757, + 0.13647812604904175, + 0.1333412081003189, + 0.13227449357509613, + 0.039517614990472794, + 0.04025179147720337, + 0.018890047445893288, + 0.15653669834136963, + 0.16636870801448822 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03808422014117241 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive American flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the flag flutter with powerful, graceful undulations rather than frantic movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flag's stripes exhibit glowing crimson and golden hues while the blue field has a cosmic texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate push-in that gradually fills the frame with the flag's texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the flag backlit by a low setting sun, creating translucent fabric with glowing edges and deep soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2812688946723938 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.406268835067749 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2812688946723938, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2812688946723938, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20541229844093323, + 0.10954677313566208, + 0.06399153918027878, + 0.03686150535941124, + 0.06749121099710464, + 0.03241853415966034, + 0.059512753039598465, + 0.06894031912088394, + 0.24735239148139954, + 0.10847260802984238 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2812688946723938 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle shot unfolds across a massive American flag, its silhouette silhouetted against a warm sunset sky. As the camera begins a slow, deliberate push-in, the flag begins to flutter majestically in a steady breeze. The movement isn't frantic, but rather a series of powerful, graceful undulations that weave through the heavy fabric. Surreal details become increasingly apparent; crimson stripes appear to glow from within, pristine white stripes capture golden hues, and the rich navy blue possesses a cosmic texture. The camera's slow advance reveals the intricate weave of the material, the tight stitching separating the stripes, and the raised, tactile quality of the fifty embroidered stars. The setting sun, low on the horizon, backlights the flag, making the fabric appear slightly translucent and highlighting every subtle fold and ripple with a glowing edge, while casting deep, soft shadows within its valleys. The entire scene is imbued with a tranquil, solemn, and awe-inspiring atmosphere as the frame gradually fills with the texture of the flag, transforming the patriotic symbol into a breathtaking abstract landscape of color, light, and movement.", + "seed": 8347, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_11/index_1557_seed_8347_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.08936774274334311, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08936774274334311, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08936774274334311, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive American flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the flag flutter with powerful, graceful undulations rather than frantic movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flag's stripes exhibit glowing crimson and golden hues while the blue field has a cosmic texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate push-in that gradually fills the frame with the flag's texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the flag backlit by a low setting sun, creating translucent fabric with glowing edges and deep soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003957774024456739 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628957748413086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003957774024456739, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003957774024456739, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07375970482826233, + 0.08177579194307327, + 0.21503852307796478, + 0.09630497545003891, + 0.05526534467935562, + 0.0966501384973526, + 0.13908492028713226, + 0.11073650419712067, + 0.03202567994594574, + 0.09935843199491501 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003957774024456739 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive American flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the flag flutter with powerful, graceful undulations rather than frantic movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flag's stripes exhibit glowing crimson and golden hues while the blue field has a cosmic texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate push-in that gradually fills the frame with the flag's texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the flag backlit by a low setting sun, creating translucent fabric with glowing edges and deep soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020593751221895218 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955936431884766 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020593751221895218, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020593751221895218, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0815494954586029, + 0.1340588480234146, + 0.09021200984716415, + 0.07468487322330475, + 0.08881629258394241, + 0.22099582850933075, + 0.05525366589426994, + 0.11464109271764755, + 0.03251791000366211, + 0.10726992040872574 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020593751221895218 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive American flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the flag flutter with powerful, graceful undulations rather than frantic movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flag's stripes exhibit glowing crimson and golden hues while the blue field has a cosmic texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate push-in that gradually fills the frame with the flag's texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the flag backlit by a low setting sun, creating translucent fabric with glowing edges and deep soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0789787545800209 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789787769317627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0789787545800209, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0789787545800209, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07789409905672073, + 0.10200799256563187, + 0.2220562845468521, + 0.04022211953997612, + 0.06441032886505127, + 0.10941867530345917, + 0.09903648495674133, + 0.10045479983091354, + 0.030012037605047226, + 0.15448714792728424 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0789787545800209 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive American flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the flag flutter with powerful, graceful undulations rather than frantic movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flag's stripes exhibit glowing crimson and golden hues while the blue field has a cosmic texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate push-in that gradually fills the frame with the flag's texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the flag backlit by a low setting sun, creating translucent fabric with glowing edges and deep soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620303601026535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.81203031539917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620303601026535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620303601026535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06532961875200272, + 0.15568415820598602, + 0.2599720358848572, + 0.059058450162410736, + 0.03681182488799095, + 0.20674045383930206, + 0.0749308317899704, + 0.03492426499724388, + 0.031009143218398094, + 0.07553911954164505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620303601026535 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive American flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the flag flutter with powerful, graceful undulations rather than frantic movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flag's stripes exhibit glowing crimson and golden hues while the blue field has a cosmic texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate push-in that gradually fills the frame with the flag's texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the flag backlit by a low setting sun, creating translucent fabric with glowing edges and deep soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2812780737876892 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.406278133392334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2812780737876892, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2812780737876892, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08101902157068253, + 0.1549922376871109, + 0.14098431169986725, + 0.031151123344898224, + 0.10070636868476868, + 0.20899741351604462, + 0.06261978298425674, + 0.04989258944988251, + 0.040480054914951324, + 0.12915702164173126 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2812780737876892 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle shot unfolds across a massive American flag, its silhouette silhouetted against a warm sunset sky. As the camera begins a slow, deliberate push-in, the flag begins to flutter majestically in a steady breeze. The movement isn't frantic, but rather a series of powerful, graceful undulations that weave through the heavy fabric. Surreal details become increasingly apparent; crimson stripes appear to glow from within, pristine white stripes capture golden hues, and the rich navy blue possesses a cosmic texture. The camera's slow advance reveals the intricate weave of the material, the tight stitching separating the stripes, and the raised, tactile quality of the fifty embroidered stars. The setting sun, low on the horizon, backlights the flag, making the fabric appear slightly translucent and highlighting every subtle fold and ripple with a glowing edge, while casting deep, soft shadows within its valleys. The entire scene is imbued with a tranquil, solemn, and awe-inspiring atmosphere as the frame gradually fills with the texture of the flag, transforming the patriotic symbol into a breathtaking abstract landscape of color, light, and movement.", + "seed": 8348, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_11/index_1557_seed_8348_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.16839308068156242, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16839308068156242, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16839308068156242, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive American flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the flag flutter with powerful, graceful undulations rather than frantic movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flag's stripes exhibit glowing crimson and golden hues while the blue field has a cosmic texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate push-in that gradually fills the frame with the flag's texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the flag backlit by a low setting sun, creating translucent fabric with glowing edges and deep soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00827183946967125 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88327169418335 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00827183946967125, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00827183946967125, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10294546186923981, + 0.044827595353126526, + 0.05091274157166481, + 0.10001388937234879, + 0.14040808379650116, + 0.19847679138183594, + 0.061557091772556305, + 0.11666328459978104, + 0.06316709518432617, + 0.12102792412042618 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00827183946967125 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive American flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the flag flutter with powerful, graceful undulations rather than frantic movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flag's stripes exhibit glowing crimson and golden hues while the blue field has a cosmic texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate push-in that gradually fills the frame with the flag's texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the flag backlit by a low setting sun, creating translucent fabric with glowing edges and deep soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308486729860306 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680848598480225 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308486729860306, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308486729860306, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1332053542137146, + 0.06629183143377304, + 0.11615440994501114, + 0.05813088268041611, + 0.09325921535491943, + 0.08531241118907928, + 0.0691419318318367, + 0.1489853411912918, + 0.1395917534828186, + 0.0899268314242363 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308486729860306 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive American flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the flag flutter with powerful, graceful undulations rather than frantic movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flag's stripes exhibit glowing crimson and golden hues while the blue field has a cosmic texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate push-in that gradually fills the frame with the flag's texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the flag backlit by a low setting sun, creating translucent fabric with glowing edges and deep soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34863412380218506 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223634123802185 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34863412380218506, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34863412380218506, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10502162575721741, + 0.04393647983670235, + 0.16037653386592865, + 0.0869501531124115, + 0.06412242352962494, + 0.11038214713335037, + 0.04853087663650513, + 0.04768962413072586, + 0.24504567682743073, + 0.08794447034597397 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34863412380218506 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive American flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the flag flutter with powerful, graceful undulations rather than frantic movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flag's stripes exhibit glowing crimson and golden hues while the blue field has a cosmic texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate push-in that gradually fills the frame with the flag's texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the flag backlit by a low setting sun, creating translucent fabric with glowing edges and deep soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495768040418625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929957628250122 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495768040418625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495768040418625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0638510137796402, + 0.024206332862377167, + 0.03941207751631737, + 0.025634540244936943, + 0.12405243515968323, + 0.5691620707511902, + 0.015640554949641228, + 0.0724431723356247, + 0.014571073465049267, + 0.051026709377765656 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495768040418625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive American flag?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the flag flutter with powerful, graceful undulations rather than frantic movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flag's stripes exhibit glowing crimson and golden hues while the blue field has a cosmic texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate push-in that gradually fills the frame with the flag's texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the flag backlit by a low setting sun, creating translucent fabric with glowing edges and deep soft shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870168924331665 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370168924331665 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3870168924331665, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3870168924331665, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10060982406139374, + 0.02563396282494068, + 0.05420638993382454, + 0.03078162670135498, + 0.08968791365623474, + 0.27541154623031616, + 0.05228491500020027, + 0.02504023164510727, + 0.1724158525466919, + 0.17392772436141968 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3870168924331665 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_12/index_tensor([1379, 1379])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_12/index_tensor([1379, 1379])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..747a3bb174edb56ca661204275b38135b632b4e0 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_12/index_tensor([1379, 1379])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, steady underwater camera zooms in, guiding the viewer through the deep, murky depths of the ocean, where tiny particles, suspended in the dim light, drift like dust. As the camera deepens, the wreck of a massive, ancient wooden sailing ship gradually emerges, its broken masts and hull thickly encrusted with barnacles and seaweed, silently telling of its history. A giant octopus of awe-inspiring size perches atop the wreck. Its thick tentacles, covered in a color-shifting, leathery skin mottled with crimson and ochre, carefully wrap around the ship's structure, its massive suction cups clearly visible. One of its tentacles calmly reaches into a darkened gun port, as if searching for a lost secret. Faint blue-green light filtering down from the surface casts a dreamy beam through the water, illuminating the octopus's enormous, intelligent golden eye, which appears to calmly observe the camera's approach. The entire picture, in cool tones of deep blue and dark green, presents a magnificent, tranquil yet oppressive mysterious atmosphere, as if entering an eternally unchanging deep-sea kingdom.", + "seed": 7595, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_12/index_1379_seed_7595_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.014523761416785418, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014523761416785418, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014523761416785418, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, steady zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive ancient wooden sailing ship wreck visible with broken masts and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a giant octopus perched on the wreck with thick tentacles covered in crimson and ochre mottled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one of the octopus's tentacles reaching into a darkened gun port?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by faint blue-green light filtering down from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0288041140884161 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.653804063796997 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0288041140884161, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0288041140884161, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24773100018501282, + 0.1432221531867981, + 0.11189053952693939, + 0.11469284445047379, + 0.06798148900270462, + 0.053868308663368225, + 0.05879075452685356, + 0.08373815566301346, + 0.03181968629360199, + 0.08626503497362137 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0288041140884161 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, steady zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive ancient wooden sailing ship wreck visible with broken masts and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a giant octopus perched on the wreck with thick tentacles covered in crimson and ochre mottled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one of the octopus's tentacles reaching into a darkened gun port?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by faint blue-green light filtering down from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017207353375852108 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376720905303955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017207353375852108, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017207353375852108, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24817979335784912, + 0.10709037631750107, + 0.07364299148321152, + 0.0663369745016098, + 0.09375147521495819, + 0.040300242602825165, + 0.08082740753889084, + 0.05688425526022911, + 0.14564397931098938, + 0.08734245598316193 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017207353375852108 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, steady zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive ancient wooden sailing ship wreck visible with broken masts and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a giant octopus perched on the wreck with thick tentacles covered in crimson and ochre mottled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one of the octopus's tentacles reaching into a darkened gun port?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by faint blue-green light filtering down from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015111466636881232 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501511096954346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015111466636881232, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015111466636881232, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23072171211242676, + 0.052327949553728104, + 0.05812769755721092, + 0.02262883074581623, + 0.09101029485464096, + 0.047769539058208466, + 0.08931894600391388, + 0.08087670058012009, + 0.24408143758773804, + 0.08313686400651932 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015111466636881232 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, steady zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive ancient wooden sailing ship wreck visible with broken masts and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a giant octopus perched on the wreck with thick tentacles covered in crimson and ochre mottled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one of the octopus's tentacles reaching into a darkened gun port?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by faint blue-green light filtering down from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038097646087408066 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288097620010376 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038097646087408066, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038097646087408066, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.316692054271698, + 0.08366204053163528, + 0.05524620786309242, + 0.0377875380218029, + 0.07408010959625244, + 0.03950940817594528, + 0.09546855092048645, + 0.06107451394200325, + 0.15093842148780823, + 0.08554113656282425 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038097646087408066 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, steady zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive ancient wooden sailing ship wreck visible with broken masts and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a giant octopus perched on the wreck with thick tentacles covered in crimson and ochre mottled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one of the octopus's tentacles reaching into a darkened gun port?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by faint blue-green light filtering down from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024851649068295956 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002485275268555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024851649068295956, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024851649068295956, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14202868938446045, + 0.17631050944328308, + 0.11270026862621307, + 0.04131072387099266, + 0.1008419319987297, + 0.08495111763477325, + 0.20308002829551697, + 0.052117884159088135, + 0.03211703896522522, + 0.05454178526997566 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024851649068295956 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, steady underwater camera zooms in, guiding the viewer through the deep, murky depths of the ocean, where tiny particles, suspended in the dim light, drift like dust. As the camera deepens, the wreck of a massive, ancient wooden sailing ship gradually emerges, its broken masts and hull thickly encrusted with barnacles and seaweed, silently telling of its history. A giant octopus of awe-inspiring size perches atop the wreck. Its thick tentacles, covered in a color-shifting, leathery skin mottled with crimson and ochre, carefully wrap around the ship's structure, its massive suction cups clearly visible. One of its tentacles calmly reaches into a darkened gun port, as if searching for a lost secret. Faint blue-green light filtering down from the surface casts a dreamy beam through the water, illuminating the octopus's enormous, intelligent golden eye, which appears to calmly observe the camera's approach. The entire picture, in cool tones of deep blue and dark green, presents a magnificent, tranquil yet oppressive mysterious atmosphere, as if entering an eternally unchanging deep-sea kingdom.", + "seed": 7596, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_12/index_1379_seed_7596_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02202351893647574, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02202351893647574, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02202351893647574, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, steady zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive ancient wooden sailing ship wreck visible with broken masts and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a giant octopus perched on the wreck with thick tentacles covered in crimson and ochre mottled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one of the octopus's tentacles reaching into a darkened gun port?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by faint blue-green light filtering down from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08340846002101898 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5834083557128906 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08340846002101898, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08340846002101898, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13082319498062134, + 0.190015971660614, + 0.03228919580578804, + 0.13715681433677673, + 0.042406000196933746, + 0.11356659233570099, + 0.052676405757665634, + 0.03980492055416107, + 0.07704152166843414, + 0.1842193305492401 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08340846002101898 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, steady zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive ancient wooden sailing ship wreck visible with broken masts and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a giant octopus perched on the wreck with thick tentacles covered in crimson and ochre mottled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one of the octopus's tentacles reaching into a darkened gun port?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by faint blue-green light filtering down from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019478887552395463 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.25194787979126 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019478887552395463, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019478887552395463, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08404621481895447, + 0.05920116603374481, + 0.2518640458583832, + 0.10439928621053696, + 0.032937951385974884, + 0.022261228412389755, + 0.023874854668974876, + 0.143289253115654, + 0.15627403557300568, + 0.12185203284025192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019478887552395463 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, steady zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive ancient wooden sailing ship wreck visible with broken masts and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a giant octopus perched on the wreck with thick tentacles covered in crimson and ochre mottled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one of the octopus's tentacles reaching into a darkened gun port?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by faint blue-green light filtering down from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00030179237364791334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -8.125301361083984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00030179237364791334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 8.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00030179237364791334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11340488493442535, + 0.11468937247991562, + 0.11046935617923737, + 0.06149251013994217, + 0.028516536578536034, + 0.07702765613794327, + 0.07854477316141129, + 0.21860986948013306, + 0.11125630885362625, + 0.08598875254392624 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00030179237364791334 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, steady zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive ancient wooden sailing ship wreck visible with broken masts and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a giant octopus perched on the wreck with thick tentacles covered in crimson and ochre mottled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one of the octopus's tentacles reaching into a darkened gun port?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by faint blue-green light filtering down from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023282716050744057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773282766342163 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023282716050744057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023282716050744057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05864596366882324, + 0.0280993040651083, + 0.032311730086803436, + 0.03800668567419052, + 0.025799522176384926, + 0.027582598850131035, + 0.053493890911340714, + 0.12173610180616379, + 0.25733619928359985, + 0.3569880425930023 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023282716050744057 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, steady zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive ancient wooden sailing ship wreck visible with broken masts and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a giant octopus perched on the wreck with thick tentacles covered in crimson and ochre mottled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one of the octopus's tentacles reaching into a darkened gun port?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by faint blue-green light filtering down from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011767374817281961 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751176834106445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011767374817281961, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011767374817281961, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15690068900585175, + 0.13206978142261505, + 0.08439471572637558, + 0.05868794769048691, + 0.08517744392156601, + 0.07973597943782806, + 0.0665709376335144, + 0.07668284326791763, + 0.16963300108909607, + 0.09014660865068436 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011767374817281961 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, steady underwater camera zooms in, guiding the viewer through the deep, murky depths of the ocean, where tiny particles, suspended in the dim light, drift like dust. As the camera deepens, the wreck of a massive, ancient wooden sailing ship gradually emerges, its broken masts and hull thickly encrusted with barnacles and seaweed, silently telling of its history. A giant octopus of awe-inspiring size perches atop the wreck. Its thick tentacles, covered in a color-shifting, leathery skin mottled with crimson and ochre, carefully wrap around the ship's structure, its massive suction cups clearly visible. One of its tentacles calmly reaches into a darkened gun port, as if searching for a lost secret. Faint blue-green light filtering down from the surface casts a dreamy beam through the water, illuminating the octopus's enormous, intelligent golden eye, which appears to calmly observe the camera's approach. The entire picture, in cool tones of deep blue and dark green, presents a magnificent, tranquil yet oppressive mysterious atmosphere, as if entering an eternally unchanging deep-sea kingdom.", + "seed": 7597, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_12/index_1379_seed_7597_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.015245968801900744, + "vlm_logprob": -0.015245968801900744, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.015245968801900744, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, steady zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive ancient wooden sailing ship wreck visible with broken masts and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a giant octopus perched on the wreck with thick tentacles covered in crimson and ochre mottled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one of the octopus's tentacles reaching into a darkened gun port?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by faint blue-green light filtering down from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04661382734775543 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.171613931655884 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04661382734775543, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04661382734775543, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10159508883953094, + 0.08093955367803574, + 0.14091654121875763, + 0.04445140063762665, + 0.17101304233074188, + 0.11919824033975601, + 0.1474016308784485, + 0.0585036426782608, + 0.04681682586669922, + 0.08916414529085159 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04661382734775543 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, steady zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive ancient wooden sailing ship wreck visible with broken masts and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a giant octopus perched on the wreck with thick tentacles covered in crimson and ochre mottled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one of the octopus's tentacles reaching into a darkened gun port?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by faint blue-green light filtering down from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003203381784260273 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753203392028809 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003203381784260273, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003203381784260273, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34282398223876953, + 0.0986846312880516, + 0.07964058220386505, + 0.04844839498400688, + 0.08407425135374069, + 0.09688762575387955, + 0.06962288171052933, + 0.05131235346198082, + 0.05669979378581047, + 0.0718054547905922 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003203381784260273 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, steady zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive ancient wooden sailing ship wreck visible with broken masts and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a giant octopus perched on the wreck with thick tentacles covered in crimson and ochre mottled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one of the octopus's tentacles reaching into a darkened gun port?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by faint blue-green light filtering down from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036143234465271235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.62861442565918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036143234465271235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036143234465271235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08145958185195923, + 0.050648417323827744, + 0.04381585121154785, + 0.08913585543632507, + 0.2454717457294464, + 0.15843330323696136, + 0.12374105304479599, + 0.06537877023220062, + 0.05149461328983307, + 0.09042079746723175 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036143234465271235 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, steady zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive ancient wooden sailing ship wreck visible with broken masts and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a giant octopus perched on the wreck with thick tentacles covered in crimson and ochre mottled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one of the octopus's tentacles reaching into a darkened gun port?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by faint blue-green light filtering down from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0160652007907629 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410651206970215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0160652007907629, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0160652007907629, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14192207157611847, + 0.07976436614990234, + 0.09895019978284836, + 0.04921026527881622, + 0.07407960295677185, + 0.06185752898454666, + 0.08985405415296555, + 0.049212586134672165, + 0.2196539342403412, + 0.13549542427062988 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0160652007907629 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, steady zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive ancient wooden sailing ship wreck visible with broken masts and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a giant octopus perched on the wreck with thick tentacles covered in crimson and ochre mottled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one of the octopus's tentacles reaching into a darkened gun port?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by faint blue-green light filtering down from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006733110640197992 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006732940673828 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006733110640197992, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006733110640197992, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13090138137340546, + 0.10972490161657333, + 0.11143452674150467, + 0.05984431877732277, + 0.054582592099905014, + 0.04882749542593956, + 0.1806957870721817, + 0.05044881999492645, + 0.1566402167081833, + 0.09689997881650925 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006733110640197992 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, steady underwater camera zooms in, guiding the viewer through the deep, murky depths of the ocean, where tiny particles, suspended in the dim light, drift like dust. As the camera deepens, the wreck of a massive, ancient wooden sailing ship gradually emerges, its broken masts and hull thickly encrusted with barnacles and seaweed, silently telling of its history. A giant octopus of awe-inspiring size perches atop the wreck. Its thick tentacles, covered in a color-shifting, leathery skin mottled with crimson and ochre, carefully wrap around the ship's structure, its massive suction cups clearly visible. One of its tentacles calmly reaches into a darkened gun port, as if searching for a lost secret. Faint blue-green light filtering down from the surface casts a dreamy beam through the water, illuminating the octopus's enormous, intelligent golden eye, which appears to calmly observe the camera's approach. The entire picture, in cool tones of deep blue and dark green, presents a magnificent, tranquil yet oppressive mysterious atmosphere, as if entering an eternally unchanging deep-sea kingdom.", + "seed": 7598, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_12/index_1379_seed_7598_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.014351510733831674, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014351510733831674, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014351510733831674, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, steady zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive ancient wooden sailing ship wreck visible with broken masts and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a giant octopus perched on the wreck with thick tentacles covered in crimson and ochre mottled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one of the octopus's tentacles reaching into a darkened gun port?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by faint blue-green light filtering down from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04266378656029701 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.292663812637329 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04266378656029701, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04266378656029701, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09495753794908524, + 0.43389153480529785, + 0.029910458251833916, + 0.018995270133018494, + 0.04627950116991997, + 0.03868141025304794, + 0.033860910683870316, + 0.06061739847064018, + 0.08130735158920288, + 0.16149863600730896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04266378656029701 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, steady zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive ancient wooden sailing ship wreck visible with broken masts and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a giant octopus perched on the wreck with thick tentacles covered in crimson and ochre mottled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one of the octopus's tentacles reaching into a darkened gun port?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by faint blue-green light filtering down from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006746135652065277 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006746292114258 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006746135652065277, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006746135652065277, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22358380258083344, + 0.10325822234153748, + 0.11871445178985596, + 0.11462235450744629, + 0.0327288843691349, + 0.06867936998605728, + 0.041593167930841446, + 0.04610089957714081, + 0.03508505970239639, + 0.215633824467659 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006746135652065277 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, steady zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive ancient wooden sailing ship wreck visible with broken masts and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a giant octopus perched on the wreck with thick tentacles covered in crimson and ochre mottled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one of the octopus's tentacles reaching into a darkened gun port?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by faint blue-green light filtering down from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00043704494601115584 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.750437259674072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00043704494601115584, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00043704494601115584, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10145464539527893, + 0.30756986141204834, + 0.034179531037807465, + 0.020722072571516037, + 0.05599784851074219, + 0.03798406943678856, + 0.048958487808704376, + 0.09194387495517731, + 0.17906098067760468, + 0.12212856858968735 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00043704494601115584 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, steady zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive ancient wooden sailing ship wreck visible with broken masts and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a giant octopus perched on the wreck with thick tentacles covered in crimson and ochre mottled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one of the octopus's tentacles reaching into a darkened gun port?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by faint blue-green light filtering down from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020577285438776016 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955771923065186 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020577285438776016, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020577285438776016, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05121361464262009, + 0.32738247513771057, + 0.0328451506793499, + 0.040015313774347305, + 0.08403192460536957, + 0.05399369075894356, + 0.08394886553287506, + 0.04536785930395126, + 0.07668491452932358, + 0.2045162320137024 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020577285438776016 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow, steady zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive ancient wooden sailing ship wreck visible with broken masts and barnacles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a giant octopus perched on the wreck with thick tentacles covered in crimson and ochre mottled skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is one of the octopus's tentacles reaching into a darkened gun port?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by faint blue-green light filtering down from the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013333010720089078 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626333236694336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013333010720089078, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013333010720089078, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1372775286436081, + 0.4725179076194763, + 0.06705642491579056, + 0.0628179982304573, + 0.07146579772233963, + 0.021177928894758224, + 0.04072334244847298, + 0.02902868576347828, + 0.0345713272690773, + 0.06336301565170288 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013333010720089078 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_13/index_tensor([303, 303])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_13/index_tensor([303, 303])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1f3157d20087917cc69a82834a05b71ee2a2c74b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_13/index_tensor([303, 303])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatic 360-degree rotating camera smoothly circles a lone figure in the center of a grand and majestic throne room, rendered in the sharp, dramatic style of Japanese anime. The protagonist, a former Ming Dynasty official, his long black hair meticulously tied into a traditional headdress, is in the final, solemn moment of a deep kowtow. His face, etched with deep exhaustion and weary resignation, leans toward the floor. He wears a dark blue silk robe, the delicate fabric delicately catching the light, and his brow is now furrowed by his prostration. As the camera swirls around him, it captures his labored, deliberate movements as he places his palms flat on the cold, polished black stone floor and lowers his forehead until firm, resonant contact is made. The vast hall is adorned with towering yellow Qing Dynasty flags crafted from heavy silk, suspended from the high, shadowed ceiling and adorned with fierce, stylized dragons. The environment is defined by a dramatic contrast of black and white, with sharp, cold rays of light piercing the vast darkness, illuminating the dust and casting long, stark shadows from the massive vermilion pillars. The invisible emperor's throne lies somewhere out of frame, its unseen presence creating an oppressive atmosphere of absolute power. The camera's swiveling movement isolates the bowing official, emphasizing the immense solemnity of his submission and visually heralding the arrival of a new, powerful era, all captured with the bold silhouettes and high-contrast lighting characteristic of a mature anime aesthetic.", + "seed": 20883, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_13/index_303_seed_20883_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.12658955743536354, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12658955743536354, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.999999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12658955743536354, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with sharp, dramatic Japanese anime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the protagonist wearing a dark blue silk robe with long black hair tied in a traditional headdress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing a deep kowtow with palms flat on a cold, polished black stone floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are towering yellow Qing Dynasty flags with stylized dragons visible hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth 360-degree rotation circling the central figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.15057861804962158 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.025578498840332 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.15057861804962158, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.15057861804962158, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20844005048274994, + 0.042963411659002304, + 0.07828889787197113, + 0.16461868584156036, + 0.0653388574719429, + 0.06367423385381699, + 0.17630472779273987, + 0.06613758951425552, + 0.07996159791946411, + 0.05427199974656105 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.15057861804962158 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with sharp, dramatic Japanese anime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the protagonist wearing a dark blue silk robe with long black hair tied in a traditional headdress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing a deep kowtow with palms flat on a cold, polished black stone floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are towering yellow Qing Dynasty flags with stylized dragons visible hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth 360-degree rotation circling the central figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007649888750165701 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882649898529053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007649888750165701, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007649888750165701, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22094325721263885, + 0.04303795099258423, + 0.04403942450881004, + 0.14230193197727203, + 0.028949782252311707, + 0.08705216646194458, + 0.1786983162164688, + 0.07626818865537643, + 0.11411883682012558, + 0.06459013372659683 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007649888750165701 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with sharp, dramatic Japanese anime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the protagonist wearing a dark blue silk robe with long black hair tied in a traditional headdress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing a deep kowtow with palms flat on a cold, polished black stone floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are towering yellow Qing Dynasty flags with stylized dragons visible hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth 360-degree rotation circling the central figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016071418300271034 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141071319580078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016071418300271034, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016071418300271034, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2554474174976349, + 0.03911813721060753, + 0.035699766129255295, + 0.22741419076919556, + 0.056217264384031296, + 0.06552884727716446, + 0.09318462014198303, + 0.09956211596727371, + 0.06579935550689697, + 0.062028344720602036 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016071418300271034 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with sharp, dramatic Japanese anime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the protagonist wearing a dark blue silk robe with long black hair tied in a traditional headdress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing a deep kowtow with palms flat on a cold, polished black stone floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are towering yellow Qing Dynasty flags with stylized dragons visible hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth 360-degree rotation circling the central figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029790684580802917 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297906398773193 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029790684580802917, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029790684580802917, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34622129797935486, + 0.09093805402517319, + 0.07247156649827957, + 0.1810513436794281, + 0.05823855474591255, + 0.04929102957248688, + 0.06539835780858994, + 0.058624111115932465, + 0.04413948580622673, + 0.0336262471973896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029790684580802917 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with sharp, dramatic Japanese anime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the protagonist wearing a dark blue silk robe with long black hair tied in a traditional headdress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing a deep kowtow with palms flat on a cold, polished black stone floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are towering yellow Qing Dynasty flags with stylized dragons visible hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth 360-degree rotation circling the central figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4288571774959564 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0538572072982788 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4288571774959564, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4288571774959564, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08669485151767731, + 0.05514825880527496, + 0.04280441626906395, + 0.051660846918821335, + 0.10168787837028503, + 0.433406263589859, + 0.06940548121929169, + 0.047116268426179886, + 0.07737837731838226, + 0.034697290509939194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4288571774959564 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic 360-degree rotating camera smoothly circles a lone figure in the center of a grand and majestic throne room, rendered in the sharp, dramatic style of Japanese anime. The protagonist, a former Ming Dynasty official, his long black hair meticulously tied into a traditional headdress, is in the final, solemn moment of a deep kowtow. His face, etched with deep exhaustion and weary resignation, leans toward the floor. He wears a dark blue silk robe, the delicate fabric delicately catching the light, and his brow is now furrowed by his prostration. As the camera swirls around him, it captures his labored, deliberate movements as he places his palms flat on the cold, polished black stone floor and lowers his forehead until firm, resonant contact is made. The vast hall is adorned with towering yellow Qing Dynasty flags crafted from heavy silk, suspended from the high, shadowed ceiling and adorned with fierce, stylized dragons. The environment is defined by a dramatic contrast of black and white, with sharp, cold rays of light piercing the vast darkness, illuminating the dust and casting long, stark shadows from the massive vermilion pillars. The invisible emperor's throne lies somewhere out of frame, its unseen presence creating an oppressive atmosphere of absolute power. The camera's swiveling movement isolates the bowing official, emphasizing the immense solemnity of his submission and visually heralding the arrival of a new, powerful era, all captured with the bold silhouettes and high-contrast lighting characteristic of a mature anime aesthetic.", + "seed": 20884, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_13/index_303_seed_20884_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.19011069796979427, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19011069796979427, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.6499999523162843, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19011069796979427, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with sharp, dramatic Japanese anime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the protagonist wearing a dark blue silk robe with long black hair tied in a traditional headdress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing a deep kowtow with palms flat on a cold, polished black stone floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are towering yellow Qing Dynasty flags with stylized dragons visible hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth 360-degree rotation circling the central figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.260202556848526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5102025270462036 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.260202556848526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.260202556848526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13131095468997955, + 0.08135392516851425, + 0.4433991312980652, + 0.06558215618133545, + 0.04269951954483986, + 0.04654572904109955, + 0.028117118403315544, + 0.05403127521276474, + 0.07389902323484421, + 0.033061202615499496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.260202556848526 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with sharp, dramatic Japanese anime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the protagonist wearing a dark blue silk robe with long black hair tied in a traditional headdress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing a deep kowtow with palms flat on a cold, polished black stone floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are towering yellow Qing Dynasty flags with stylized dragons visible hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth 360-degree rotation circling the central figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01609441079199314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141094207763672 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01609441079199314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01609441079199314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24732384085655212, + 0.057074371725320816, + 0.3666273057460785, + 0.0619690828025341, + 0.03121938556432724, + 0.06552832573652267, + 0.04132328927516937, + 0.04383409395813942, + 0.046502359211444855, + 0.03859793767333031 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01609441079199314 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with sharp, dramatic Japanese anime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the protagonist wearing a dark blue silk robe with long black hair tied in a traditional headdress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing a deep kowtow with palms flat on a cold, polished black stone floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are towering yellow Qing Dynasty flags with stylized dragons visible hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth 360-degree rotation circling the central figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023289471864700317 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773289442062378 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023289471864700317, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023289471864700317, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07542141526937485, + 0.019371354952454567, + 0.7673695683479309, + 0.026699084788560867, + 0.021616173908114433, + 0.04113687947392464, + 0.011805984191596508, + 0.01205956470221281, + 0.012194965034723282, + 0.012325024232268333 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023289471864700317 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with sharp, dramatic Japanese anime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the protagonist wearing a dark blue silk robe with long black hair tied in a traditional headdress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing a deep kowtow with palms flat on a cold, polished black stone floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are towering yellow Qing Dynasty flags with stylized dragons visible hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth 360-degree rotation circling the central figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018182504922151566 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018182277679443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018182504922151566, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018182504922151566, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0837613046169281, + 0.06608261913061142, + 0.15569768846035004, + 0.04609416425228119, + 0.058510713279247284, + 0.075434111058712, + 0.02167482115328312, + 0.03604176640510559, + 0.08675637096166611, + 0.3699463903903961 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018182504922151566 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with sharp, dramatic Japanese anime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the protagonist wearing a dark blue silk robe with long black hair tied in a traditional headdress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing a deep kowtow with palms flat on a cold, polished black stone floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are towering yellow Qing Dynasty flags with stylized dragons visible hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth 360-degree rotation circling the central figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6327845454216003 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7577845454216003 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6327845454216003, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6327845454216003, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07269994914531708, + 0.07519763708114624, + 0.35157066583633423, + 0.05090802162885666, + 0.05198802798986435, + 0.03540327399969101, + 0.1129019483923912, + 0.1459292769432068, + 0.036367613822221756, + 0.06703360378742218 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6327845454216003 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic 360-degree rotating camera smoothly circles a lone figure in the center of a grand and majestic throne room, rendered in the sharp, dramatic style of Japanese anime. The protagonist, a former Ming Dynasty official, his long black hair meticulously tied into a traditional headdress, is in the final, solemn moment of a deep kowtow. His face, etched with deep exhaustion and weary resignation, leans toward the floor. He wears a dark blue silk robe, the delicate fabric delicately catching the light, and his brow is now furrowed by his prostration. As the camera swirls around him, it captures his labored, deliberate movements as he places his palms flat on the cold, polished black stone floor and lowers his forehead until firm, resonant contact is made. The vast hall is adorned with towering yellow Qing Dynasty flags crafted from heavy silk, suspended from the high, shadowed ceiling and adorned with fierce, stylized dragons. The environment is defined by a dramatic contrast of black and white, with sharp, cold rays of light piercing the vast darkness, illuminating the dust and casting long, stark shadows from the massive vermilion pillars. The invisible emperor's throne lies somewhere out of frame, its unseen presence creating an oppressive atmosphere of absolute power. The camera's swiveling movement isolates the bowing official, emphasizing the immense solemnity of his submission and visually heralding the arrival of a new, powerful era, all captured with the bold silhouettes and high-contrast lighting characteristic of a mature anime aesthetic.", + "seed": 20885, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_13/index_303_seed_20885_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.15974218528717757, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15974218528717757, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15974218528717757, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with sharp, dramatic Japanese anime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the protagonist wearing a dark blue silk robe with long black hair tied in a traditional headdress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing a deep kowtow with palms flat on a cold, polished black stone floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are towering yellow Qing Dynasty flags with stylized dragons visible hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth 360-degree rotation circling the central figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4407738745212555 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.065773844718933 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4407738745212555, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4407738745212555, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06484689563512802, + 0.06456514447927475, + 0.24264998733997345, + 0.10937049239873886, + 0.1385609358549118, + 0.03760765120387077, + 0.025291183963418007, + 0.016449466347694397, + 0.09223861247301102, + 0.20841971039772034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4407738745212555 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with sharp, dramatic Japanese anime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the protagonist wearing a dark blue silk robe with long black hair tied in a traditional headdress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing a deep kowtow with palms flat on a cold, polished black stone floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are towering yellow Qing Dynasty flags with stylized dragons visible hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth 360-degree rotation circling the central figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014234318397939205 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26423454284668 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014234318397939205, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014234318397939205, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28250619769096375, + 0.1265653818845749, + 0.232658252120018, + 0.0768977478146553, + 0.03918174281716347, + 0.02102229930460453, + 0.0284093227237463, + 0.01788409985601902, + 0.05287555977702141, + 0.1219993606209755 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014234318397939205 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with sharp, dramatic Japanese anime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the protagonist wearing a dark blue silk robe with long black hair tied in a traditional headdress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing a deep kowtow with palms flat on a cold, polished black stone floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are towering yellow Qing Dynasty flags with stylized dragons visible hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth 360-degree rotation circling the central figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014206582680344582 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264206409454346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014206582680344582, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014206582680344582, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0857335701584816, + 0.09678542613983154, + 0.511195719242096, + 0.11661790311336517, + 0.025290964171290398, + 0.06425289064645767, + 0.028228649869561195, + 0.012785379774868488, + 0.03189241141080856, + 0.027217067778110504 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014206582680344582 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with sharp, dramatic Japanese anime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the protagonist wearing a dark blue silk robe with long black hair tied in a traditional headdress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing a deep kowtow with palms flat on a cold, polished black stone floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are towering yellow Qing Dynasty flags with stylized dragons visible hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth 360-degree rotation circling the central figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016067897900938988 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141067981719971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016067897900938988, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016067897900938988, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16089549660682678, + 0.06259691715240479, + 0.3972795307636261, + 0.03319786861538887, + 0.02253538928925991, + 0.09302748739719391, + 0.0932447612285614, + 0.06556233018636703, + 0.03457508608698845, + 0.03708508238196373 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016067897900938988 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with sharp, dramatic Japanese anime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the protagonist wearing a dark blue silk robe with long black hair tied in a traditional headdress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing a deep kowtow with palms flat on a cold, polished black stone floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are towering yellow Qing Dynasty flags with stylized dragons visible hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth 360-degree rotation circling the central figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31342825293540955 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.313428282737732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31342825293540955, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31342825293540955, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07537660002708435, + 0.06211632862687111, + 0.36040177941322327, + 0.1574370563030243, + 0.05547776818275452, + 0.054601337760686874, + 0.04205606132745743, + 0.02524404600262642, + 0.11852410435676575, + 0.048764944076538086 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31342825293540955 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic 360-degree rotating camera smoothly circles a lone figure in the center of a grand and majestic throne room, rendered in the sharp, dramatic style of Japanese anime. The protagonist, a former Ming Dynasty official, his long black hair meticulously tied into a traditional headdress, is in the final, solemn moment of a deep kowtow. His face, etched with deep exhaustion and weary resignation, leans toward the floor. He wears a dark blue silk robe, the delicate fabric delicately catching the light, and his brow is now furrowed by his prostration. As the camera swirls around him, it captures his labored, deliberate movements as he places his palms flat on the cold, polished black stone floor and lowers his forehead until firm, resonant contact is made. The vast hall is adorned with towering yellow Qing Dynasty flags crafted from heavy silk, suspended from the high, shadowed ceiling and adorned with fierce, stylized dragons. The environment is defined by a dramatic contrast of black and white, with sharp, cold rays of light piercing the vast darkness, illuminating the dust and casting long, stark shadows from the massive vermilion pillars. The invisible emperor's throne lies somewhere out of frame, its unseen presence creating an oppressive atmosphere of absolute power. The camera's swiveling movement isolates the bowing official, emphasizing the immense solemnity of his submission and visually heralding the arrival of a new, powerful era, all captured with the bold silhouettes and high-contrast lighting characteristic of a mature anime aesthetic.", + "seed": 20886, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_13/index_303_seed_20886_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.062473292276263234, + "vlm_logprob": -0.062473292276263234, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.174999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.062473292276263234, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with sharp, dramatic Japanese anime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the protagonist wearing a dark blue silk robe with long black hair tied in a traditional headdress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing a deep kowtow with palms flat on a cold, polished black stone floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are towering yellow Qing Dynasty flags with stylized dragons visible hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth 360-degree rotation circling the central figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10739150643348694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.357391595840454 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10739150643348694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10739150643348694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.054405659437179565, + 0.15593591332435608, + 0.034028321504592896, + 0.023411184549331665, + 0.03572891280055046, + 0.027461403980851173, + 0.03213527798652649, + 0.30295923352241516, + 0.06578566879034042, + 0.2681484520435333 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10739150643348694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with sharp, dramatic Japanese anime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the protagonist wearing a dark blue silk robe with long black hair tied in a traditional headdress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing a deep kowtow with palms flat on a cold, polished black stone floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are towering yellow Qing Dynasty flags with stylized dragons visible hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth 360-degree rotation circling the central figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014215044677257538 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264214992523193 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014215044677257538, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014215044677257538, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08346990495920181, + 0.12082894891500473, + 0.060431107878685, + 0.03680381923913956, + 0.021959759294986725, + 0.031603533774614334, + 0.053322721272706985, + 0.15895602107048035, + 0.18515229225158691, + 0.247471883893013 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014215044677257538 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with sharp, dramatic Japanese anime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the protagonist wearing a dark blue silk robe with long black hair tied in a traditional headdress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing a deep kowtow with palms flat on a cold, polished black stone floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are towering yellow Qing Dynasty flags with stylized dragons visible hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth 360-degree rotation circling the central figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980491705238819 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298049449920654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980491705238819, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980491705238819, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10400450974702835, + 0.176920086145401, + 0.05343470349907875, + 0.034254346042871475, + 0.021350163966417313, + 0.04947229474782944, + 0.030421553179621696, + 0.14702346920967102, + 0.13917399942874908, + 0.2439449429512024 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980491705238819 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with sharp, dramatic Japanese anime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the protagonist wearing a dark blue silk robe with long black hair tied in a traditional headdress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing a deep kowtow with palms flat on a cold, polished black stone floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are towering yellow Qing Dynasty flags with stylized dragons visible hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth 360-degree rotation circling the central figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018183674663305283 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018183708190918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018183674663305283, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018183674663305283, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18742342293262482, + 0.17203165590763092, + 0.05729490891098976, + 0.021834705024957657, + 0.01923810876905918, + 0.024988241493701935, + 0.014210009947419167, + 0.020898735150694847, + 0.02059757523238659, + 0.4614826738834381 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018183674663305283 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with sharp, dramatic Japanese anime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the protagonist wearing a dark blue silk robe with long black hair tied in a traditional headdress?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing a deep kowtow with palms flat on a cold, polished black stone floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are towering yellow Qing Dynasty flags with stylized dragons visible hanging from the ceiling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth 360-degree rotation circling the central figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14277131855487823 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0177712440490723 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14277131855487823, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14277131855487823, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04146985709667206, + 0.06877543032169342, + 0.02524864673614502, + 0.0626445859670639, + 0.012451465241611004, + 0.039082784205675125, + 0.0469924695789814, + 0.08254846930503845, + 0.0409221276640892, + 0.5798640847206116 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14277131855487823 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_14/index_tensor([4887, 4887])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_14/index_tensor([4887, 4887])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..13710b41cbfa5e6d3004763b51b4596b0503660d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_14/index_tensor([4887, 4887])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The scene begins with a medium shot from a slightly high angle, the camera beginning a slow, mesmerizing advance, capturing a tightly closed crimson hibiscus bud nestled in a lush, verdant garden. Warm, syrupy golden sunlight pours down with visible, ethereal light, illuminating the bud and casting soft, dappled light on the waxy green leaves in the out-of-focus background. A single, perfect dewdrop glitters on the bud's emerald green petals. As the light intensifies, the flower begins to bloom in a rapid, elegant time-lapse; the petals peel back, their velvety petals unfurling in a steady, spiraling motion. The camera's deliberate advance reveals the petals' intricate textures and rich color gradations, from a deep, passionate crimson at the base to a delicate, soft pink rim. This movement, a silent, hypnotic dance of life, culminates in an extreme close-up, as the flower fully opens, revealing its vibrant yellow, pollen-dusted center. The entire scene is bathed in a warm golden palette, creating an atmosphere of wondrous and deeply tranquility, capturing a moment of natural magic.", + "seed": 3187, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_14/index_4887_seed_3187_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.051993381883949044, + "vlm_logprob": -0.051993381883949044, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.051993381883949044, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot from a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow advance throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a crimson hibiscus bud blooming in a rapid time-lapse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final shot an extreme close-up revealing a yellow pollen-dusted center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden sunlight with visible ethereal light rays?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04164879396557808 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2916488647460938 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04164879396557808, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04164879396557808, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17558732628822327, + 0.042458634823560715, + 0.08209015429019928, + 0.04701605811715126, + 0.11392124742269516, + 0.06833074986934662, + 0.0681452825665474, + 0.10780861228704453, + 0.2304796427488327, + 0.06416230648756027 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04164879396557808 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot from a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow advance throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a crimson hibiscus bud blooming in a rapid time-lapse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final shot an extreme close-up revealing a yellow pollen-dusted center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden sunlight with visible ethereal light rays?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11292915046215057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237929105758667 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11292915046215057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11292915046215057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04685445874929428, + 0.022362232208251953, + 0.03768414258956909, + 0.014815699309110641, + 0.08435656875371933, + 0.13910402357578278, + 0.10145045816898346, + 0.09054231643676758, + 0.41137567162513733, + 0.051454365253448486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11292915046215057 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot from a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow advance throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a crimson hibiscus bud blooming in a rapid time-lapse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final shot an extreme close-up revealing a yellow pollen-dusted center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden sunlight with visible ethereal light rays?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005257233511656523 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.2552571296691895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005257233511656523, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005257233511656523, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03538528457283974, + 0.025365401059389114, + 0.03539763763546944, + 0.035517919808626175, + 0.050362732261419296, + 0.03587985783815384, + 0.05859026685357094, + 0.10431958734989166, + 0.5623722076416016, + 0.05680910870432854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005257233511656523 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot from a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow advance throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a crimson hibiscus bud blooming in a rapid time-lapse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final shot an extreme close-up revealing a yellow pollen-dusted center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden sunlight with visible ethereal light rays?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062037643045186996 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812037706375122 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062037643045186996, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062037643045186996, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.022059381008148193, + 0.015871170908212662, + 0.021821336820721626, + 0.023216966539621353, + 0.05055227130651474, + 0.01857125200331211, + 0.024925392121076584, + 0.06076086312532425, + 0.6575269103050232, + 0.10469438135623932 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062037643045186996 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot from a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow advance throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a crimson hibiscus bud blooming in a rapid time-lapse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final shot an extreme close-up revealing a yellow pollen-dusted center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden sunlight with visible ethereal light rays?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038094088435173035 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880940437316895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038094088435173035, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038094088435173035, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15800251066684723, + 0.04808570072054863, + 0.0232681967318058, + 0.07410500943660736, + 0.05143534019589424, + 0.05027464032173157, + 0.03429730609059334, + 0.06175098940730095, + 0.44312483072280884, + 0.05565544590353966 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038094088435173035 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene begins with a medium shot from a slightly high angle, the camera beginning a slow, mesmerizing advance, capturing a tightly closed crimson hibiscus bud nestled in a lush, verdant garden. Warm, syrupy golden sunlight pours down with visible, ethereal light, illuminating the bud and casting soft, dappled light on the waxy green leaves in the out-of-focus background. A single, perfect dewdrop glitters on the bud's emerald green petals. As the light intensifies, the flower begins to bloom in a rapid, elegant time-lapse; the petals peel back, their velvety petals unfurling in a steady, spiraling motion. The camera's deliberate advance reveals the petals' intricate textures and rich color gradations, from a deep, passionate crimson at the base to a delicate, soft pink rim. This movement, a silent, hypnotic dance of life, culminates in an extreme close-up, as the flower fully opens, revealing its vibrant yellow, pollen-dusted center. The entire scene is bathed in a warm golden palette, creating an atmosphere of wondrous and deeply tranquility, capturing a moment of natural magic.", + "seed": 3188, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_14/index_4887_seed_3188_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.013019875809550285, + "vlm_logprob": -0.013019875809550285, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.924999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.013019875809550285, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot from a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow advance throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a crimson hibiscus bud blooming in a rapid time-lapse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final shot an extreme close-up revealing a yellow pollen-dusted center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden sunlight with visible ethereal light rays?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03646935150027275 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4114694595336914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03646935150027275, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03646935150027275, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02162483148276806, + 0.023911794647574425, + 0.01443772204220295, + 0.021974410861730576, + 0.5913299322128296, + 0.06326091289520264, + 0.11988228559494019, + 0.014342635869979858, + 0.0727633684873581, + 0.05647213011980057 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03646935150027275 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot from a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow advance throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a crimson hibiscus bud blooming in a rapid time-lapse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final shot an extreme close-up revealing a yellow pollen-dusted center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden sunlight with visible ethereal light rays?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018188124522566795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187999725342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018188124522566795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018188124522566795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.01977565512061119, + 0.014363023452460766, + 0.009271465241909027, + 0.041589099913835526, + 0.4585428833961487, + 0.06374908983707428, + 0.1856241375207901, + 0.04295680671930313, + 0.060376234352588654, + 0.10375165194272995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018188124522566795 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot from a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow advance throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a crimson hibiscus bud blooming in a rapid time-lapse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final shot an extreme close-up revealing a yellow pollen-dusted center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden sunlight with visible ethereal light rays?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004095619544386864 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504095554351807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004095619544386864, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004095619544386864, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03226623684167862, + 0.01599045842885971, + 0.01361751090735197, + 0.044272635132074356, + 0.1708211898803711, + 0.18490420281887054, + 0.17909567058086395, + 0.029799658805131912, + 0.09250152111053467, + 0.23673087358474731 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004095619544386864 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot from a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow advance throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a crimson hibiscus bud blooming in a rapid time-lapse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final shot an extreme close-up revealing a yellow pollen-dusted center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden sunlight with visible ethereal light rays?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017120479606091976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376711845397949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017120479606091976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017120479606091976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.019036313518881798, + 0.012568484991788864, + 0.011606966145336628, + 0.02205711416900158, + 0.48928919434547424, + 0.10822983831167221, + 0.07459075003862381, + 0.047124214470386505, + 0.07343427836894989, + 0.14206284284591675 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017120479606091976 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot from a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow advance throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a crimson hibiscus bud blooming in a rapid time-lapse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final shot an extreme close-up revealing a yellow pollen-dusted center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden sunlight with visible ethereal light rays?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004634235519915819 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379634380340576 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004634235519915819, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004634235519915819, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13243286311626434, + 0.02787182293832302, + 0.17642337083816528, + 0.04634992405772209, + 0.01565197855234146, + 0.10400759428739548, + 0.1314062476158142, + 0.01733522117137909, + 0.19528406858444214, + 0.15323691070079803 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004634235519915819 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene begins with a medium shot from a slightly high angle, the camera beginning a slow, mesmerizing advance, capturing a tightly closed crimson hibiscus bud nestled in a lush, verdant garden. Warm, syrupy golden sunlight pours down with visible, ethereal light, illuminating the bud and casting soft, dappled light on the waxy green leaves in the out-of-focus background. A single, perfect dewdrop glitters on the bud's emerald green petals. As the light intensifies, the flower begins to bloom in a rapid, elegant time-lapse; the petals peel back, their velvety petals unfurling in a steady, spiraling motion. The camera's deliberate advance reveals the petals' intricate textures and rich color gradations, from a deep, passionate crimson at the base to a delicate, soft pink rim. This movement, a silent, hypnotic dance of life, culminates in an extreme close-up, as the flower fully opens, revealing its vibrant yellow, pollen-dusted center. The entire scene is bathed in a warm golden palette, creating an atmosphere of wondrous and deeply tranquility, capturing a moment of natural magic.", + "seed": 3189, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_14/index_4887_seed_3189_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.019041105546057223, + "vlm_logprob": -0.019041105546057223, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.019041105546057223, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot from a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow advance throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a crimson hibiscus bud blooming in a rapid time-lapse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final shot an extreme close-up revealing a yellow pollen-dusted center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden sunlight with visible ethereal light rays?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.028809906914830208 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6538100242614746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.028809906914830208, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.028809906914830208, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.032833777368068695, + 0.015849901363253593, + 0.037656836211681366, + 0.02379552833735943, + 0.03496036306023598, + 0.06500697880983353, + 0.1597234010696411, + 0.04026450216770172, + 0.05045295134186745, + 0.5394558310508728 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.028809906914830208 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot from a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow advance throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a crimson hibiscus bud blooming in a rapid time-lapse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final shot an extreme close-up revealing a yellow pollen-dusted center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden sunlight with visible ethereal light rays?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0336962565779686 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408696174621582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0336962565779686, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0336962565779686, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.042515672743320465, + 0.021054599434137344, + 0.09000024944543839, + 0.038378290832042694, + 0.054308317601680756, + 0.178644597530365, + 0.1148996651172638, + 0.08716651797294617, + 0.045209869742393494, + 0.327822208404541 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0336962565779686 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot from a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow advance throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a crimson hibiscus bud blooming in a rapid time-lapse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final shot an extreme close-up revealing a yellow pollen-dusted center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden sunlight with visible ethereal light rays?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040968069806694984 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504096984863281 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040968069806694984, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040968069806694984, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08741742372512817, + 0.042378559708595276, + 0.10926266759634018, + 0.041819918900728226, + 0.07508215308189392, + 0.21585364639759064, + 0.10230221599340439, + 0.13010193407535553, + 0.11288589984178543, + 0.08289556205272675 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040968069806694984 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot from a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow advance throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a crimson hibiscus bud blooming in a rapid time-lapse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final shot an extreme close-up revealing a yellow pollen-dusted center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden sunlight with visible ethereal light rays?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012538060545921326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387537956237793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012538060545921326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012538060545921326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04904266819357872, + 0.01580650731921196, + 0.04535861313343048, + 0.024075206369161606, + 0.04111555963754654, + 0.04115168750286102, + 0.07052915543317795, + 0.017423246055841446, + 0.04483528062701225, + 0.6506620645523071 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012538060545921326 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot from a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow advance throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a crimson hibiscus bud blooming in a rapid time-lapse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final shot an extreme close-up revealing a yellow pollen-dusted center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden sunlight with visible ethereal light rays?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016064496710896492 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141064643859863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016064496710896492, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016064496710896492, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2289809286594391, + 0.14913330972194672, + 0.027356164529919624, + 0.04559074342250824, + 0.01915140263736248, + 0.05040157586336136, + 0.12345350533723831, + 0.033982083201408386, + 0.02996307983994484, + 0.29198727011680603 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016064496710896492 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene begins with a medium shot from a slightly high angle, the camera beginning a slow, mesmerizing advance, capturing a tightly closed crimson hibiscus bud nestled in a lush, verdant garden. Warm, syrupy golden sunlight pours down with visible, ethereal light, illuminating the bud and casting soft, dappled light on the waxy green leaves in the out-of-focus background. A single, perfect dewdrop glitters on the bud's emerald green petals. As the light intensifies, the flower begins to bloom in a rapid, elegant time-lapse; the petals peel back, their velvety petals unfurling in a steady, spiraling motion. The camera's deliberate advance reveals the petals' intricate textures and rich color gradations, from a deep, passionate crimson at the base to a delicate, soft pink rim. This movement, a silent, hypnotic dance of life, culminates in an extreme close-up, as the flower fully opens, revealing its vibrant yellow, pollen-dusted center. The entire scene is bathed in a warm golden palette, creating an atmosphere of wondrous and deeply tranquility, capturing a moment of natural magic.", + "seed": 3190, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_14/index_4887_seed_3190_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.033877532742917535, + "vlm_logprob": -0.033877532742917535, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.033877532742917535, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot from a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow advance throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a crimson hibiscus bud blooming in a rapid time-lapse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final shot an extreme close-up revealing a yellow pollen-dusted center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden sunlight with visible ethereal light rays?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05265308916568756 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0526530742645264 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05265308916568756, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05265308916568756, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27104565501213074, + 0.050596825778484344, + 0.047742508351802826, + 0.041235461831092834, + 0.11034715920686722, + 0.12893365323543549, + 0.08991515636444092, + 0.13654564321041107, + 0.06959321349859238, + 0.05404471606016159 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05265308916568756 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot from a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow advance throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a crimson hibiscus bud blooming in a rapid time-lapse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final shot an extreme close-up revealing a yellow pollen-dusted center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden sunlight with visible ethereal light rays?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0789761170744896 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789761543273926 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0789761170744896, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0789761170744896, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22603684663772583, + 0.07276248186826706, + 0.06358624994754791, + 0.03487234562635422, + 0.08017286658287048, + 0.07714962959289551, + 0.31716111302375793, + 0.02529098652303219, + 0.071442149579525, + 0.03152528405189514 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0789761170744896 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot from a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow advance throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a crimson hibiscus bud blooming in a rapid time-lapse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final shot an extreme close-up revealing a yellow pollen-dusted center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden sunlight with visible ethereal light rays?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004641473293304443 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379641532897949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004641473293304443, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004641473293304443, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5003527998924255, + 0.03854050487279892, + 0.05454118549823761, + 0.03252953290939331, + 0.027873454615473747, + 0.035626817494630814, + 0.1151839941740036, + 0.06146027147769928, + 0.08613035082817078, + 0.047761108726263046 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004641473293304443 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot from a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow advance throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a crimson hibiscus bud blooming in a rapid time-lapse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final shot an extreme close-up revealing a yellow pollen-dusted center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden sunlight with visible ethereal light rays?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012538296170532703 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387538433074951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012538296170532703, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012538296170532703, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28269121050834656, + 0.04812701791524887, + 0.033950429409742355, + 0.03100409172475338, + 0.034478746354579926, + 0.1506306231021881, + 0.050838619470596313, + 0.035237982869148254, + 0.22424715757369995, + 0.10879409313201904 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012538296170532703 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a medium shot from a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow advance throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a crimson hibiscus bud blooming in a rapid time-lapse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the final shot an extreme close-up revealing a yellow pollen-dusted center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden sunlight with visible ethereal light rays?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020578688010573387 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895578622817993 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020578688010573387, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020578688010573387, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28938406705856323, + 0.1344430297613144, + 0.1775725781917572, + 0.19377844035625458, + 0.018763810396194458, + 0.027224184945225716, + 0.03416300192475319, + 0.07738852500915527, + 0.030462920665740967, + 0.01681937836110592 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020578688010573387 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_15/index_tensor([248, 248])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_15/index_tensor([248, 248])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b3e95153d6152ced4f43c23dc0505a65c4d082c7 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_15/index_tensor([248, 248])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slowly zooming, wide-angle aerial shot, beginning with a close-up of the young man, gradually reveals a magnificent, epic scene: Under the golden sunlight of dawn, the mythical youth Nezha stands atop a lone, steep mountaintop, piercing a sea of clouds. He wears his signature double-braided bun, tied with a red string. His face is delicate, his gaze focused, exuding a calmness and strength belying his age. He wears a simple white silk training suit, the collar and cuffs embroidered with subtle auspicious cloud patterns in silver thread. A multi-meter-long red Hun Tian Ling, a translucent, fiery cinnabar-colored satin with a faint golden glow at the edges, wraps around him as if alive. Driven by the mountaintop morning breeze and his movements, it carves graceful and powerful arcs through the air. He is absorbed in practicing Tai Chi, his movements slow and fluid, his arms tracing smooth, continuous paths like flowing clouds and water. Each gesture is imbued with an inner strength that blends strength and flexibility, as if engaging in a silent dialogue with the very essence of heaven and earth. Beneath him lay a vast, swirling sea of clouds. Thick, cotton-like, the clouds stretched across the sky, rimmed with a dazzling golden rim by the rising sun. The rays of light penetrated the clouds, casting streaks of light. Distant mountains loomed in the mist. The entire scene, interwoven with the cool blue sky and the warm morning light, created an atmosphere of sacred, tranquil, yet powerful Eastern fantasy.", + "seed": 11294, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_15/index_248_seed_11294_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06044483240693808, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06044483240693808, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06044483240693808, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of a young man and then zoom out to reveal a wide scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as Nezha wearing a white silk training suit with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a translucent, fiery red Hun Tian Ling weapon wrapping around the character and moving through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing slow, fluid Tai Chi movements against a background of a sea of clouds and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden dawn sunlight with a cool blue sky and warm morning light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.030695708468556404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.530695676803589 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.030695708468556404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.030695708468556404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08508733659982681, + 0.09687764197587967, + 0.04147399961948395, + 0.07821889966726303, + 0.07813747227191925, + 0.06260265409946442, + 0.03153907135128975, + 0.09624160826206207, + 0.05348096042871475, + 0.3763403296470642 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.030695708468556404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of a young man and then zoom out to reveal a wide scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as Nezha wearing a white silk training suit with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a translucent, fiery red Hun Tian Ling weapon wrapping around the character and moving through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing slow, fluid Tai Chi movements against a background of a sea of clouds and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden dawn sunlight with a cool blue sky and warm morning light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603979617357254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910398006439209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603979617357254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603979617357254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07718288898468018, + 0.08536107838153839, + 0.024903548881411552, + 0.035688549280166626, + 0.030690113082528114, + 0.02994942106306553, + 0.021003227680921555, + 0.05337607488036156, + 0.04731328412890434, + 0.5945318341255188 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603979617357254 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of a young man and then zoom out to reveal a wide scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as Nezha wearing a white silk training suit with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a translucent, fiery red Hun Tian Ling weapon wrapping around the character and moving through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing slow, fluid Tai Chi movements against a background of a sea of clouds and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden dawn sunlight with a cool blue sky and warm morning light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004099775105714798 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5040998458862305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004099775105714798, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004099775105714798, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.027602648362517357, + 0.0899362564086914, + 0.0984158143401146, + 0.021719546988606453, + 0.009553177282214165, + 0.009364820085465908, + 0.03396217152476311, + 0.015091664157807827, + 0.018430911004543304, + 0.6759229898452759 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004099775105714798 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of a young man and then zoom out to reveal a wide scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as Nezha wearing a white silk training suit with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a translucent, fiery red Hun Tian Ling weapon wrapping around the character and moving through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing slow, fluid Tai Chi movements against a background of a sea of clouds and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden dawn sunlight with a cool blue sky and warm morning light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10029630362987518 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3502962589263916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10029630362987518, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10029630362987518, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02147042751312256, + 0.024672893807291985, + 0.017804019153118134, + 0.02162983827292919, + 0.01291836891323328, + 0.010995685122907162, + 0.025155166164040565, + 0.00966524425894022, + 0.022743042558431625, + 0.8329452872276306 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10029630362987518 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of a young man and then zoom out to reveal a wide scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as Nezha wearing a white silk training suit with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a translucent, fiery red Hun Tian Ling weapon wrapping around the character and moving through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing slow, fluid Tai Chi movements against a background of a sea of clouds and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden dawn sunlight with a cool blue sky and warm morning light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006734413094818592 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006734371185303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006734413094818592, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006734413094818592, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13221421837806702, + 0.05169600620865822, + 0.02676243521273136, + 0.04693508520722389, + 0.0166791845113039, + 0.024750445038080215, + 0.03256365656852722, + 0.045163195580244064, + 0.04161779582500458, + 0.5816180109977722 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006734413094818592 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly zooming, wide-angle aerial shot, beginning with a close-up of the young man, gradually reveals a magnificent, epic scene: Under the golden sunlight of dawn, the mythical youth Nezha stands atop a lone, steep mountaintop, piercing a sea of clouds. He wears his signature double-braided bun, tied with a red string. His face is delicate, his gaze focused, exuding a calmness and strength belying his age. He wears a simple white silk training suit, the collar and cuffs embroidered with subtle auspicious cloud patterns in silver thread. A multi-meter-long red Hun Tian Ling, a translucent, fiery cinnabar-colored satin with a faint golden glow at the edges, wraps around him as if alive. Driven by the mountaintop morning breeze and his movements, it carves graceful and powerful arcs through the air. He is absorbed in practicing Tai Chi, his movements slow and fluid, his arms tracing smooth, continuous paths like flowing clouds and water. Each gesture is imbued with an inner strength that blends strength and flexibility, as if engaging in a silent dialogue with the very essence of heaven and earth. Beneath him lay a vast, swirling sea of clouds. Thick, cotton-like, the clouds stretched across the sky, rimmed with a dazzling golden rim by the rising sun. The rays of light penetrated the clouds, casting streaks of light. Distant mountains loomed in the mist. The entire scene, interwoven with the cool blue sky and the warm morning light, created an atmosphere of sacred, tranquil, yet powerful Eastern fantasy.", + "seed": 11295, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_15/index_248_seed_11295_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.1722933399491012, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1722933399491012, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.699999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1722933399491012, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of a young man and then zoom out to reveal a wide scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as Nezha wearing a white silk training suit with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a translucent, fiery red Hun Tian Ling weapon wrapping around the character and moving through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing slow, fluid Tai Chi movements against a background of a sea of clouds and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden dawn sunlight with a cool blue sky and warm morning light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.43236929178237915 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0573692321777344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.43236929178237915, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.6249999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.43236929178237915, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14600449800491333, + 0.07067392021417618, + 0.04212546721100807, + 0.09216047823429108, + 0.05183970928192139, + 0.10029834508895874, + 0.11147516220808029, + 0.2472279965877533, + 0.022934120148420334, + 0.11526035517454147 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.43236929178237915 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of a young man and then zoom out to reveal a wide scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as Nezha wearing a white silk training suit with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a translucent, fiery red Hun Tian Ling weapon wrapping around the character and moving through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing slow, fluid Tai Chi movements against a background of a sea of clouds and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden dawn sunlight with a cool blue sky and warm morning light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16037927567958832 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103792905807495 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16037927567958832, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16037927567958832, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.335014671087265, + 0.037708353251218796, + 0.020708946511149406, + 0.1658606380224228, + 0.05277492105960846, + 0.03612813353538513, + 0.04419521987438202, + 0.2508440315723419, + 0.011990295723080635, + 0.044774748384952545 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16037927567958832 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of a young man and then zoom out to reveal a wide scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as Nezha wearing a white silk training suit with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a translucent, fiery red Hun Tian Ling weapon wrapping around the character and moving through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing slow, fluid Tai Chi movements against a background of a sea of clouds and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden dawn sunlight with a cool blue sky and warm morning light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004101199563592672 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504101276397705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004101199563592672, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004101199563592672, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15677329897880554, + 0.13266772031784058, + 0.06374626606702805, + 0.12485746294260025, + 0.03359135240316391, + 0.055910494178533554, + 0.07262472808361053, + 0.062374699860811234, + 0.1790141612291336, + 0.11843983083963394 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004101199563592672 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of a young man and then zoom out to reveal a wide scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as Nezha wearing a white silk training suit with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a translucent, fiery red Hun Tian Ling weapon wrapping around the character and moving through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing slow, fluid Tai Chi movements against a background of a sea of clouds and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden dawn sunlight with a cool blue sky and warm morning light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25207969546318054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502079725265503 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25207969546318054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25207969546318054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12967729568481445, + 0.18717603385448456, + 0.02529628947377205, + 0.2056635022163391, + 0.044661059975624084, + 0.08285310864448547, + 0.05831286683678627, + 0.06327122449874878, + 0.06103219464421272, + 0.1420563906431198 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25207969546318054 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of a young man and then zoom out to reveal a wide scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as Nezha wearing a white silk training suit with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a translucent, fiery red Hun Tian Ling weapon wrapping around the character and moving through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing slow, fluid Tai Chi movements against a background of a sea of clouds and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden dawn sunlight with a cool blue sky and warm morning light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012537237256765366 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387537002563477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012537237256765366, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012537237256765366, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23140951991081238, + 0.06829764693975449, + 0.022119799628853798, + 0.08587461709976196, + 0.02327810786664486, + 0.06379379332065582, + 0.06423687189817429, + 0.2297201007604599, + 0.033224109560251236, + 0.17804542183876038 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012537237256765366 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly zooming, wide-angle aerial shot, beginning with a close-up of the young man, gradually reveals a magnificent, epic scene: Under the golden sunlight of dawn, the mythical youth Nezha stands atop a lone, steep mountaintop, piercing a sea of clouds. He wears his signature double-braided bun, tied with a red string. His face is delicate, his gaze focused, exuding a calmness and strength belying his age. He wears a simple white silk training suit, the collar and cuffs embroidered with subtle auspicious cloud patterns in silver thread. A multi-meter-long red Hun Tian Ling, a translucent, fiery cinnabar-colored satin with a faint golden glow at the edges, wraps around him as if alive. Driven by the mountaintop morning breeze and his movements, it carves graceful and powerful arcs through the air. He is absorbed in practicing Tai Chi, his movements slow and fluid, his arms tracing smooth, continuous paths like flowing clouds and water. Each gesture is imbued with an inner strength that blends strength and flexibility, as if engaging in a silent dialogue with the very essence of heaven and earth. Beneath him lay a vast, swirling sea of clouds. Thick, cotton-like, the clouds stretched across the sky, rimmed with a dazzling golden rim by the rising sun. The rays of light penetrated the clouds, casting streaks of light. Distant mountains loomed in the mist. The entire scene, interwoven with the cool blue sky and the warm morning light, created an atmosphere of sacred, tranquil, yet powerful Eastern fantasy.", + "seed": 11296, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_15/index_248_seed_11296_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10228768233209848, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10228768233209848, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10228768233209848, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of a young man and then zoom out to reveal a wide scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as Nezha wearing a white silk training suit with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a translucent, fiery red Hun Tian Ling weapon wrapping around the character and moving through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing slow, fluid Tai Chi movements against a background of a sea of clouds and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden dawn sunlight with a cool blue sky and warm morning light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22744081914424896 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6024408340454102 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22744081914424896, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22744081914424896, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10797128081321716, + 0.11590056866407394, + 0.06143732741475105, + 0.057627830654382706, + 0.1520581990480423, + 0.0776854008436203, + 0.3617480397224426, + 0.04199424386024475, + 0.012423926033079624, + 0.011153190396726131 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22744081914424896 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of a young man and then zoom out to reveal a wide scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as Nezha wearing a white silk training suit with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a translucent, fiery red Hun Tian Ling weapon wrapping around the character and moving through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing slow, fluid Tai Chi movements against a background of a sea of clouds and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden dawn sunlight with a cool blue sky and warm morning light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08906640112400055 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464066505432129 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08906640112400055, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08906640112400055, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1420355588197708, + 0.10106246173381805, + 0.02949359267950058, + 0.027085844427347183, + 0.15334506332874298, + 0.0640670657157898, + 0.3434886038303375, + 0.06498583406209946, + 0.043809812515974045, + 0.030626190826296806 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08906640112400055 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of a young man and then zoom out to reveal a wide scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as Nezha wearing a white silk training suit with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a translucent, fiery red Hun Tian Ling weapon wrapping around the character and moving through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing slow, fluid Tai Chi movements against a background of a sea of clouds and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden dawn sunlight with a cool blue sky and warm morning light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005259842611849308 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255259990692139 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005259842611849308, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005259842611849308, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15254360437393188, + 0.0657423734664917, + 0.06488512456417084, + 0.04513334110379219, + 0.13061678409576416, + 0.07192761451005936, + 0.14389148354530334, + 0.07335314154624939, + 0.1338602751493454, + 0.11804623901844025 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005259842611849308 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of a young man and then zoom out to reveal a wide scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as Nezha wearing a white silk training suit with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a translucent, fiery red Hun Tian Ling weapon wrapping around the character and moving through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing slow, fluid Tai Chi movements against a background of a sea of clouds and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden dawn sunlight with a cool blue sky and warm morning light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17988935112953186 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048893213272095 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17988935112953186, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17988935112953186, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09045248478651047, + 0.06777646392583847, + 0.046189021319150925, + 0.044776469469070435, + 0.44001391530036926, + 0.05003440007567406, + 0.10831346362829208, + 0.05010422691702843, + 0.05472719669342041, + 0.04761234670877457 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17988935112953186 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of a young man and then zoom out to reveal a wide scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as Nezha wearing a white silk training suit with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a translucent, fiery red Hun Tian Ling weapon wrapping around the character and moving through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing slow, fluid Tai Chi movements against a background of a sea of clouds and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden dawn sunlight with a cool blue sky and warm morning light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978199765086174 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634781837463379 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978199765086174, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978199765086174, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11022370308637619, + 0.03972391411662102, + 0.022058948874473572, + 0.03943576291203499, + 0.19300778210163116, + 0.05308322235941887, + 0.28839847445487976, + 0.141418918967247, + 0.06821635365486145, + 0.0444328710436821 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978199765086174 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly zooming, wide-angle aerial shot, beginning with a close-up of the young man, gradually reveals a magnificent, epic scene: Under the golden sunlight of dawn, the mythical youth Nezha stands atop a lone, steep mountaintop, piercing a sea of clouds. He wears his signature double-braided bun, tied with a red string. His face is delicate, his gaze focused, exuding a calmness and strength belying his age. He wears a simple white silk training suit, the collar and cuffs embroidered with subtle auspicious cloud patterns in silver thread. A multi-meter-long red Hun Tian Ling, a translucent, fiery cinnabar-colored satin with a faint golden glow at the edges, wraps around him as if alive. Driven by the mountaintop morning breeze and his movements, it carves graceful and powerful arcs through the air. He is absorbed in practicing Tai Chi, his movements slow and fluid, his arms tracing smooth, continuous paths like flowing clouds and water. Each gesture is imbued with an inner strength that blends strength and flexibility, as if engaging in a silent dialogue with the very essence of heaven and earth. Beneath him lay a vast, swirling sea of clouds. Thick, cotton-like, the clouds stretched across the sky, rimmed with a dazzling golden rim by the rising sun. The rays of light penetrated the clouds, casting streaks of light. Distant mountains loomed in the mist. The entire scene, interwoven with the cool blue sky and the warm morning light, created an atmosphere of sacred, tranquil, yet powerful Eastern fantasy.", + "seed": 11297, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_15/index_248_seed_11297_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.13589925933629274, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13589925933629274, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.825000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13589925933629274, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of a young man and then zoom out to reveal a wide scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as Nezha wearing a white silk training suit with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a translucent, fiery red Hun Tian Ling weapon wrapping around the character and moving through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing slow, fluid Tai Chi movements against a background of a sea of clouds and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden dawn sunlight with a cool blue sky and warm morning light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3502766489982605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2252767086029053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3502766489982605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8750000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3502766489982605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0258614681661129, + 0.015767870470881462, + 0.022670593112707138, + 0.030050279572606087, + 0.03561985120177269, + 0.5597680807113647, + 0.0257884431630373, + 0.02252342738211155, + 0.23687255382537842, + 0.025077423080801964 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3502766489982605 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of a young man and then zoom out to reveal a wide scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as Nezha wearing a white silk training suit with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a translucent, fiery red Hun Tian Ling weapon wrapping around the character and moving through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing slow, fluid Tai Chi movements against a background of a sea of clouds and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden dawn sunlight with a cool blue sky and warm morning light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07899550348520279 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789954662323 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07899550348520279, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07899550348520279, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.027834076434373856, + 0.018732046708464622, + 0.019228752702474594, + 0.0948646068572998, + 0.03473711386322975, + 0.4781716763973236, + 0.03282618522644043, + 0.019558247178792953, + 0.24699971079826355, + 0.027047570794820786 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07899550348520279 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of a young man and then zoom out to reveal a wide scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as Nezha wearing a white silk training suit with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a translucent, fiery red Hun Tian Ling weapon wrapping around the character and moving through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing slow, fluid Tai Chi movements against a background of a sea of clouds and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden dawn sunlight with a cool blue sky and warm morning light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004100012592971325 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5040998458862305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004100012592971325, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004100012592971325, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.057481274008750916, + 0.0464942567050457, + 0.020449085161089897, + 0.05652337521314621, + 0.10886504501104355, + 0.25836047530174255, + 0.03982812166213989, + 0.022779107093811035, + 0.20596431195735931, + 0.1832548975944519 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004100012592971325 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of a young man and then zoom out to reveal a wide scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as Nezha wearing a white silk training suit with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a translucent, fiery red Hun Tian Ling weapon wrapping around the character and moving through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing slow, fluid Tai Chi movements against a background of a sea of clouds and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden dawn sunlight with a cool blue sky and warm morning light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22555011510849 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005501747131348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22555011510849, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22555011510849, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.045918937772512436, + 0.009130149148404598, + 0.0237435232847929, + 0.07224521040916443, + 0.04454946145415306, + 0.30955439805984497, + 0.035905007272958755, + 0.01051313430070877, + 0.40536201000213623, + 0.04307820647954941 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22555011510849 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up of a young man and then zoom out to reveal a wide scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character depicted as Nezha wearing a white silk training suit with silver cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a translucent, fiery red Hun Tian Ling weapon wrapping around the character and moving through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the character performing slow, fluid Tai Chi movements against a background of a sea of clouds and distant mountains?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by golden dawn sunlight with a cool blue sky and warm morning light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020574016496539116 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955740928649902 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020574016496539116, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020574016496539116, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05857381597161293, + 0.04885571822524071, + 0.026545356959104538, + 0.06980548053979874, + 0.04589434713125229, + 0.23354536294937134, + 0.0643310695886612, + 0.01684270240366459, + 0.4065026640892029, + 0.029103513807058334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020574016496539116 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_2/index_tensor([6693, 6693])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_2/index_tensor([6693, 6693])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ff1aeea8471d5ad6e00fb78611bb201c2813ec1e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_2/index_tensor([6693, 6693])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The cinematic close-up unfolds with an exquisitely detailed traditional phoenix pendant, crafted from lustrous, polished 24-karat gold and delicately suspended against a deep, non-reflective black velvet backdrop. The camera immediately begins a slow, steady push-in, inexorably approaching the jewel. A warm keylight, positioned slightly off-camera, illuminates the pendant, causing its polished surface to shimmer and create a dynamic play of mirrored highlights and soft shadows, depicting every curve and line of the exquisite craftsmanship. The phoenix is depicted in mid-flight, its wings adorned with individually articulated feathers, its long, graceful tail composed of intricate, swirling filigree, a display of incredible precision. As it dangles, the pendant executes a subtle, shimmering movement, rotating almost imperceptibly, causing light to dance and shimmer on the intricate filigree, highlighting the depth and artistry of the piece. The atmosphere is one of quiet reverence and luxury, focusing the viewer's full attention on the timeless beauty and profound skill embodied in this traditional jewelry.", + "seed": 16844, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_2/index_6693_seed_16844_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06306351386010647, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06306351386010647, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06306351386010647, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a traditional phoenix pendant crafted from polished 24-karat gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, non-reflective black velvet backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant illuminated by a warm keylight positioned slightly off-camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady push-in approaching the pendant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant shown rotating subtly while dangling, causing light to shimmer on the filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0562870055437088 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9312870502471924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0562870055437088, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0562870055437088, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06337425857782364, + 0.03911617770791054, + 0.02798471227288246, + 0.2540103793144226, + 0.018913302570581436, + 0.01838560402393341, + 0.04404820129275322, + 0.08975831419229507, + 0.14479294419288635, + 0.29961615800857544 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0562870055437088 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a traditional phoenix pendant crafted from polished 24-karat gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, non-reflective black velvet backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant illuminated by a warm keylight positioned slightly off-camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady push-in approaching the pendant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant shown rotating subtly while dangling, causing light to shimmer on the filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11297014355659485 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379701137542725 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11297014355659485, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11297014355659485, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0387427918612957, + 0.054306671023368835, + 0.08543788641691208, + 0.08582858741283417, + 0.028995178639888763, + 0.08159372955560684, + 0.06603784114122391, + 0.0700080618262291, + 0.38401558995246887, + 0.10503368079662323 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11297014355659485 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a traditional phoenix pendant crafted from polished 24-karat gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, non-reflective black velvet backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant illuminated by a warm keylight positioned slightly off-camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady push-in approaching the pendant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant shown rotating subtly while dangling, causing light to shimmer on the filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02332301251590252 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733230590820312 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02332301251590252, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02332301251590252, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06706766039133072, + 0.08077696710824966, + 0.10512374341487885, + 0.06398572772741318, + 0.03412001207470894, + 0.11245916783809662, + 0.12673935294151306, + 0.11819396913051605, + 0.21649900078773499, + 0.07503438740968704 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02332301251590252 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a traditional phoenix pendant crafted from polished 24-karat gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, non-reflective black velvet backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant illuminated by a warm keylight positioned slightly off-camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady push-in approaching the pendant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant shown rotating subtly while dangling, causing light to shimmer on the filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11294065415859222 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237940549850464 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11294065415859222, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11294065415859222, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.054874785244464874, + 0.02905327081680298, + 0.05541754513978958, + 0.05666394159197807, + 0.047717880457639694, + 0.30529481172561646, + 0.14906756579875946, + 0.02869352512061596, + 0.1109890267252922, + 0.16222769021987915 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11294065415859222 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a traditional phoenix pendant crafted from polished 24-karat gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, non-reflective black velvet backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant illuminated by a warm keylight positioned slightly off-camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady push-in approaching the pendant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant shown rotating subtly while dangling, causing light to shimmer on the filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009796753525733948 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634796619415283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009796753525733948, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009796753525733948, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0246559027582407, + 0.024969974532723427, + 0.030755601823329926, + 0.25348883867263794, + 0.05644482374191284, + 0.18446511030197144, + 0.0952562689781189, + 0.014864226803183556, + 0.2620947062969208, + 0.053004536777734756 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009796753525733948 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The cinematic close-up unfolds with an exquisitely detailed traditional phoenix pendant, crafted from lustrous, polished 24-karat gold and delicately suspended against a deep, non-reflective black velvet backdrop. The camera immediately begins a slow, steady push-in, inexorably approaching the jewel. A warm keylight, positioned slightly off-camera, illuminates the pendant, causing its polished surface to shimmer and create a dynamic play of mirrored highlights and soft shadows, depicting every curve and line of the exquisite craftsmanship. The phoenix is depicted in mid-flight, its wings adorned with individually articulated feathers, its long, graceful tail composed of intricate, swirling filigree, a display of incredible precision. As it dangles, the pendant executes a subtle, shimmering movement, rotating almost imperceptibly, causing light to dance and shimmer on the intricate filigree, highlighting the depth and artistry of the piece. The atmosphere is one of quiet reverence and luxury, focusing the viewer's full attention on the timeless beauty and profound skill embodied in this traditional jewelry.", + "seed": 16845, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_2/index_6693_seed_16845_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08505271915346384, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08505271915346384, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08505271915346384, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a traditional phoenix pendant crafted from polished 24-karat gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, non-reflective black velvet backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant illuminated by a warm keylight positioned slightly off-camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady push-in approaching the pendant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant shown rotating subtly while dangling, causing light to shimmer on the filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08210890740156174 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.582108974456787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08210890740156174, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08210890740156174, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1959453523159027, + 0.146614208817482, + 0.03277091681957245, + 0.10002865642309189, + 0.11024211347103119, + 0.08241308480501175, + 0.07932456582784653, + 0.03986240178346634, + 0.07679816335439682, + 0.13600052893161774 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08210890740156174 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a traditional phoenix pendant crafted from polished 24-karat gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, non-reflective black velvet backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant illuminated by a warm keylight positioned slightly off-camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady push-in approaching the pendant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant shown rotating subtly while dangling, causing light to shimmer on the filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521171271800995 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021171569824219 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521171271800995, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521171271800995, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09839186817407608, + 0.05348210781812668, + 0.06239395588636398, + 0.0972699373960495, + 0.11497844010591507, + 0.28648290038108826, + 0.0230743158608675, + 0.11695555597543716, + 0.04927593097090721, + 0.0976950004696846 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521171271800995 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a traditional phoenix pendant crafted from polished 24-karat gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, non-reflective black velvet backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant illuminated by a warm keylight positioned slightly off-camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady push-in approaching the pendant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant shown rotating subtly while dangling, causing light to shimmer on the filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012556425295770168 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387556552886963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012556425295770168, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012556425295770168, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2461959570646286, + 0.06838709115982056, + 0.0842730924487114, + 0.0967092514038086, + 0.04991514980792999, + 0.09308453649282455, + 0.04275013878941536, + 0.04058203101158142, + 0.07884280383586884, + 0.19926002621650696 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012556425295770168 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a traditional phoenix pendant crafted from polished 24-karat gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, non-reflective black velvet backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant illuminated by a warm keylight positioned slightly off-camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady push-in approaching the pendant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant shown rotating subtly while dangling, causing light to shimmer on the filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048665110021829605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486650466918945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048665110021829605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048665110021829605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23146361112594604, + 0.22276514768600464, + 0.0902915969491005, + 0.1593257337808609, + 0.08481957763433456, + 0.035617951303720474, + 0.06606549024581909, + 0.02212543413043022, + 0.04027459770441055, + 0.047250814735889435 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048665110021829605 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a traditional phoenix pendant crafted from polished 24-karat gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, non-reflective black velvet backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant illuminated by a warm keylight positioned slightly off-camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady push-in approaching the pendant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant shown rotating subtly while dangling, causing light to shimmer on the filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029816025868058205 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529815912246704 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029816025868058205, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029816025868058205, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.146675705909729, + 0.10457617044448853, + 0.2476050704717636, + 0.08601447939872742, + 0.0774245411157608, + 0.07898098975419998, + 0.08064316213130951, + 0.049639955163002014, + 0.04409651830792427, + 0.08434336632490158 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029816025868058205 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The cinematic close-up unfolds with an exquisitely detailed traditional phoenix pendant, crafted from lustrous, polished 24-karat gold and delicately suspended against a deep, non-reflective black velvet backdrop. The camera immediately begins a slow, steady push-in, inexorably approaching the jewel. A warm keylight, positioned slightly off-camera, illuminates the pendant, causing its polished surface to shimmer and create a dynamic play of mirrored highlights and soft shadows, depicting every curve and line of the exquisite craftsmanship. The phoenix is depicted in mid-flight, its wings adorned with individually articulated feathers, its long, graceful tail composed of intricate, swirling filigree, a display of incredible precision. As it dangles, the pendant executes a subtle, shimmering movement, rotating almost imperceptibly, causing light to dance and shimmer on the intricate filigree, highlighting the depth and artistry of the piece. The atmosphere is one of quiet reverence and luxury, focusing the viewer's full attention on the timeless beauty and profound skill embodied in this traditional jewelry.", + "seed": 16846, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_2/index_6693_seed_16846_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03544861674308777, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03544861674308777, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03544861674308777, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a traditional phoenix pendant crafted from polished 24-karat gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, non-reflective black velvet backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant illuminated by a warm keylight positioned slightly off-camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady push-in approaching the pendant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant shown rotating subtly while dangling, causing light to shimmer on the filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.030988262966275215 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5309882164001465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.030988262966275215, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.030988262966275215, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07303410768508911, + 0.04284707084298134, + 0.015016768127679825, + 0.02027554251253605, + 0.41758620738983154, + 0.09337905794382095, + 0.1410275548696518, + 0.11020039767026901, + 0.05536327511072159, + 0.031270045787096024 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.030988262966275215 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a traditional phoenix pendant crafted from polished 24-karat gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, non-reflective black velvet backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant illuminated by a warm keylight positioned slightly off-camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady push-in approaching the pendant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant shown rotating subtly while dangling, causing light to shimmer on the filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004282623529434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695042848587036 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004282623529434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004282623529434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.062481362372636795, + 0.07282235473394394, + 0.02119147963821888, + 0.029439283534884453, + 0.497439980506897, + 0.19134147465229034, + 0.05449850484728813, + 0.03572291135787964, + 0.015296857804059982, + 0.019765835255384445 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004282623529434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a traditional phoenix pendant crafted from polished 24-karat gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, non-reflective black velvet backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant illuminated by a warm keylight positioned slightly off-camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady push-in approaching the pendant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant shown rotating subtly while dangling, causing light to shimmer on the filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012556543573737144 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387556552886963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012556543573737144, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012556543573737144, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09292887151241302, + 0.23107361793518066, + 0.06128612905740738, + 0.027135588228702545, + 0.16781289875507355, + 0.0816420242190361, + 0.2028011977672577, + 0.06619726866483688, + 0.03098553605377674, + 0.03813677281141281 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012556543573737144 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a traditional phoenix pendant crafted from polished 24-karat gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, non-reflective black velvet backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant illuminated by a warm keylight positioned slightly off-camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady push-in approaching the pendant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant shown rotating subtly while dangling, causing light to shimmer on the filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043061114847660065 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680610179901123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043061114847660065, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043061114847660065, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06469959765672684, + 0.0743161290884018, + 0.035265445709228516, + 0.03575161471962929, + 0.2210802137851715, + 0.30856624245643616, + 0.19500327110290527, + 0.02320438250899315, + 0.01640496775507927, + 0.025708172470331192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043061114847660065 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a traditional phoenix pendant crafted from polished 24-karat gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, non-reflective black velvet backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant illuminated by a warm keylight positioned slightly off-camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady push-in approaching the pendant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant shown rotating subtly while dangling, causing light to shimmer on the filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020594336092472076 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895594358444214 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020594336092472076, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020594336092472076, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03050611913204193, + 0.02771439030766487, + 0.013382974080741405, + 0.008252122439444065, + 0.6838446855545044, + 0.02877073362469673, + 0.0972326248884201, + 0.02652241848409176, + 0.022928567603230476, + 0.060845375061035156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020594336092472076 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The cinematic close-up unfolds with an exquisitely detailed traditional phoenix pendant, crafted from lustrous, polished 24-karat gold and delicately suspended against a deep, non-reflective black velvet backdrop. The camera immediately begins a slow, steady push-in, inexorably approaching the jewel. A warm keylight, positioned slightly off-camera, illuminates the pendant, causing its polished surface to shimmer and create a dynamic play of mirrored highlights and soft shadows, depicting every curve and line of the exquisite craftsmanship. The phoenix is depicted in mid-flight, its wings adorned with individually articulated feathers, its long, graceful tail composed of intricate, swirling filigree, a display of incredible precision. As it dangles, the pendant executes a subtle, shimmering movement, rotating almost imperceptibly, causing light to dance and shimmer on the intricate filigree, highlighting the depth and artistry of the piece. The atmosphere is one of quiet reverence and luxury, focusing the viewer's full attention on the timeless beauty and profound skill embodied in this traditional jewelry.", + "seed": 16847, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_2/index_6693_seed_16847_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04882554691284895, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04882554691284895, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.349999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04882554691284895, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a traditional phoenix pendant crafted from polished 24-karat gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, non-reflective black velvet backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant illuminated by a warm keylight positioned slightly off-camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady push-in approaching the pendant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant shown rotating subtly while dangling, causing light to shimmer on the filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10341707617044449 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.353417158126831 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10341707617044449, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10341707617044449, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10640454292297363, + 0.08235017210245132, + 0.1637503057718277, + 0.03677840158343315, + 0.12121769785881042, + 0.11912359297275543, + 0.07543794810771942, + 0.10379552841186523, + 0.09028837084770203, + 0.10085339844226837 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10341707617044449 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a traditional phoenix pendant crafted from polished 24-karat gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, non-reflective black velvet backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant illuminated by a warm keylight positioned slightly off-camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady push-in approaching the pendant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant shown rotating subtly while dangling, causing light to shimmer on the filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900816947221756 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579008102416992 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900816947221756, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900816947221756, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31780415773391724, + 0.15532182157039642, + 0.17518925666809082, + 0.041846707463264465, + 0.08213717490434647, + 0.06039762869477272, + 0.058628376573324203, + 0.045165762305259705, + 0.03647177666425705, + 0.027037352323532104 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900816947221756 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a traditional phoenix pendant crafted from polished 24-karat gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, non-reflective black velvet backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant illuminated by a warm keylight positioned slightly off-camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady push-in approaching the pendant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant shown rotating subtly while dangling, causing light to shimmer on the filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009800058789551258 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634799957275391 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009800058789551258, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009800058789551258, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10274871438741684, + 0.13746720552444458, + 0.43372952938079834, + 0.04497367888689041, + 0.04917430132627487, + 0.06298083066940308, + 0.05036688968539238, + 0.03331093490123749, + 0.026355044916272163, + 0.058892872184515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009800058789551258 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a traditional phoenix pendant crafted from polished 24-karat gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, non-reflective black velvet backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant illuminated by a warm keylight positioned slightly off-camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady push-in approaching the pendant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant shown rotating subtly while dangling, causing light to shimmer on the filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033702366054058075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087023735046387 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033702366054058075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033702366054058075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05592396855354309, + 0.10380984842777252, + 0.039438094943761826, + 0.06593400239944458, + 0.13153262436389923, + 0.20906135439872742, + 0.07075705379247665, + 0.0630083978176117, + 0.11563979089260101, + 0.1448947936296463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033702366054058075 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a traditional phoenix pendant crafted from polished 24-karat gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, non-reflective black velvet backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant illuminated by a warm keylight positioned slightly off-camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady push-in approaching the pendant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the pendant shown rotating subtly while dangling, causing light to shimmer on the filigree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018200064077973366 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018199920654297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018200064077973366, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018200064077973366, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06349703669548035, + 0.1690984070301056, + 0.04443838447332382, + 0.14946812391281128, + 0.07615777105093002, + 0.13243035972118378, + 0.0383751355111599, + 0.05304770544171333, + 0.041875485330820084, + 0.23161165416240692 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018200064077973366 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_3/index_tensor([6736, 6736])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_3/index_tensor([6736, 6736])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..35ae8d4e6ed1392e76dff6ce04a82c5442266e56 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_3/index_tensor([6736, 6736])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "This extreme macro, high-angle shot, filmed at a high frame rate, captures extremely slow motion, held statically to capture the incredibly complex inner workings of a clock's escapement. At the center of the frame, a polished, golden brass disc pendulum performs a slow, mesmerizing torsional oscillation, twisting steadily and deliberately on a nearly invisible suspension wire. Its mirror-like surface catches the bright, directional studio light, reflecting the surrounding intricate machinery in twisting, flowing patterns. The mechanism itself is a dense, multi-layered world of interlocking gears crafted from brass and steel, their perfectly machined teeth meshing with perfect precision, while vibrant rubies set into the plates glitter like tiny embers. As the pendulum rhythmically twists, its motion drives the escapement; a pair of delicate pallets can be seen engaging and disengaging with the teeth of the escape wheel in a precise, hypnotic dance. With each release, the gear train advances, each minute's rotation and interaction captured with surreal clarity, showcasing the pure mechanical beauty grounded in physics and creating an atmosphere of focused, mechanical perfection.", + "seed": 13113, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_3/index_6736_seed_13113_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.042928971163928506, + "vlm_logprob": -0.042928971163928506, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.042928971163928506, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro, high-angle view of a clock's escapement mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a polished golden brass disc pendulum visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendulum performing a slow torsional oscillation on a nearly invisible suspension wire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are interlocking gears made of brass and steel with vibrant ruby jewels visible in the mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Can a pair of delicate pallets be seen engaging and disengaging with the teeth of the escape wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015040799044072628 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.640040874481201 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015040799044072628, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015040799044072628, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1515578031539917, + 0.12923462688922882, + 0.11884155124425888, + 0.02812756784260273, + 0.023651134222745895, + 0.21391227841377258, + 0.16176185011863708, + 0.11029360443353653, + 0.027380961924791336, + 0.035238537937402725 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015040799044072628 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro, high-angle view of a clock's escapement mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a polished golden brass disc pendulum visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendulum performing a slow torsional oscillation on a nearly invisible suspension wire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are interlocking gears made of brass and steel with vibrant ruby jewels visible in the mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Can a pair of delicate pallets be seen engaging and disengaging with the teeth of the escape wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018220899626612663 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018220901489258 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018220899626612663, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018220899626612663, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07105737924575806, + 0.11868005245923996, + 0.14352405071258545, + 0.03256410360336304, + 0.02161148004233837, + 0.10868079215288162, + 0.0822271853685379, + 0.389950156211853, + 0.014107363298535347, + 0.017597420141100883 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018220899626612663 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro, high-angle view of a clock's escapement mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a polished golden brass disc pendulum visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendulum performing a slow torsional oscillation on a nearly invisible suspension wire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are interlocking gears made of brass and steel with vibrant ruby jewels visible in the mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Can a pair of delicate pallets be seen engaging and disengaging with the teeth of the escape wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023324409499764442 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773324489593506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023324409499764442, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023324409499764442, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09804816544055939, + 0.21106936037540436, + 0.06130475923418999, + 0.02562136761844158, + 0.022320901975035667, + 0.15604616701602936, + 0.04245288297533989, + 0.23278827965259552, + 0.12789985537528992, + 0.022448228672146797 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023324409499764442 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro, high-angle view of a clock's escapement mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a polished golden brass disc pendulum visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendulum performing a slow torsional oscillation on a nearly invisible suspension wire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are interlocking gears made of brass and steel with vibrant ruby jewels visible in the mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Can a pair of delicate pallets be seen engaging and disengaging with the teeth of the escape wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0790274441242218 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790274143218994 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0790274441242218, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0790274441242218, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1705022156238556, + 0.13189886510372162, + 0.07655057311058044, + 0.03243502974510193, + 0.03394149988889694, + 0.05949972942471504, + 0.11014572530984879, + 0.29035019874572754, + 0.03034057654440403, + 0.06433559954166412 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0790274441242218 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro, high-angle view of a clock's escapement mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a polished golden brass disc pendulum visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendulum performing a slow torsional oscillation on a nearly invisible suspension wire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are interlocking gears made of brass and steel with vibrant ruby jewels visible in the mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Can a pair of delicate pallets be seen engaging and disengaging with the teeth of the escape wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07903130352497101 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579031229019165 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07903130352497101, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07903130352497101, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2453310340642929, + 0.14892703294754028, + 0.15041595697402954, + 0.03127990663051605, + 0.050108399242162704, + 0.0764392539858818, + 0.03938298672437668, + 0.10500781983137131, + 0.10313677042722702, + 0.04997079819440842 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07903130352497101 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This extreme macro, high-angle shot, filmed at a high frame rate, captures extremely slow motion, held statically to capture the incredibly complex inner workings of a clock's escapement. At the center of the frame, a polished, golden brass disc pendulum performs a slow, mesmerizing torsional oscillation, twisting steadily and deliberately on a nearly invisible suspension wire. Its mirror-like surface catches the bright, directional studio light, reflecting the surrounding intricate machinery in twisting, flowing patterns. The mechanism itself is a dense, multi-layered world of interlocking gears crafted from brass and steel, their perfectly machined teeth meshing with perfect precision, while vibrant rubies set into the plates glitter like tiny embers. As the pendulum rhythmically twists, its motion drives the escapement; a pair of delicate pallets can be seen engaging and disengaging with the teeth of the escape wheel in a precise, hypnotic dance. With each release, the gear train advances, each minute's rotation and interaction captured with surreal clarity, showcasing the pure mechanical beauty grounded in physics and creating an atmosphere of focused, mechanical perfection.", + "seed": 13114, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_3/index_6736_seed_13114_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.042099594883620736, + "vlm_logprob": -0.042099594883620736, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.042099594883620736, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro, high-angle view of a clock's escapement mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a polished golden brass disc pendulum visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendulum performing a slow torsional oscillation on a nearly invisible suspension wire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are interlocking gears made of brass and steel with vibrant ruby jewels visible in the mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Can a pair of delicate pallets be seen engaging and disengaging with the teeth of the escape wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06660096347332001 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.816601037979126 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06660096347332001, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06660096347332001, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16147002577781677, + 0.13116611540317535, + 0.043739594519138336, + 0.26252299547195435, + 0.0740404799580574, + 0.04086190462112427, + 0.04977092146873474, + 0.039356034249067307, + 0.11062359809875488, + 0.08644837141036987 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06660096347332001 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro, high-angle view of a clock's escapement mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a polished golden brass disc pendulum visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendulum performing a slow torsional oscillation on a nearly invisible suspension wire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are interlocking gears made of brass and steel with vibrant ruby jewels visible in the mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Can a pair of delicate pallets be seen engaging and disengaging with the teeth of the escape wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008667821995913982 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758667945861816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008667821995913982, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008667821995913982, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09870225936174393, + 0.18508626520633698, + 0.06183542311191559, + 0.3141145408153534, + 0.03807422146201134, + 0.024492256343364716, + 0.05250793322920799, + 0.08264899998903275, + 0.11209724098443985, + 0.0304409172385931 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008667821995913982 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro, high-angle view of a clock's escapement mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a polished golden brass disc pendulum visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendulum performing a slow torsional oscillation on a nearly invisible suspension wire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are interlocking gears made of brass and steel with vibrant ruby jewels visible in the mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Can a pair of delicate pallets be seen engaging and disengaging with the teeth of the escape wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026379751041531563 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513798236846924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026379751041531563, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026379751041531563, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07068194448947906, + 0.1781911551952362, + 0.06658057123422623, + 0.137098029255867, + 0.0667208880186081, + 0.3325622081756592, + 0.0415811650454998, + 0.026407567784190178, + 0.05099710822105408, + 0.029179340228438377 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026379751041531563 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro, high-angle view of a clock's escapement mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a polished golden brass disc pendulum visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendulum performing a slow torsional oscillation on a nearly invisible suspension wire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are interlocking gears made of brass and steel with vibrant ruby jewels visible in the mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Can a pair of delicate pallets be seen engaging and disengaging with the teeth of the escape wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02982562966644764 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298256874084473 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02982562966644764, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02982562966644764, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08468198776245117, + 0.09292851388454437, + 0.030849747359752655, + 0.3874177932739258, + 0.024923987686634064, + 0.08822696655988693, + 0.040328606963157654, + 0.09242431074380875, + 0.08677904307842255, + 0.07143905758857727 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02982562966644764 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro, high-angle view of a clock's escapement mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a polished golden brass disc pendulum visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendulum performing a slow torsional oscillation on a nearly invisible suspension wire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are interlocking gears made of brass and steel with vibrant ruby jewels visible in the mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Can a pair of delicate pallets be seen engaging and disengaging with the teeth of the escape wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0790238082408905 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579023838043213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0790238082408905, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0790238082408905, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19427531957626343, + 0.1074647605419159, + 0.04200256988406181, + 0.24004331231117249, + 0.044232700020074844, + 0.11686618626117706, + 0.05442053824663162, + 0.08140568435192108, + 0.0859527587890625, + 0.03333613649010658 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0790238082408905 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This extreme macro, high-angle shot, filmed at a high frame rate, captures extremely slow motion, held statically to capture the incredibly complex inner workings of a clock's escapement. At the center of the frame, a polished, golden brass disc pendulum performs a slow, mesmerizing torsional oscillation, twisting steadily and deliberately on a nearly invisible suspension wire. Its mirror-like surface catches the bright, directional studio light, reflecting the surrounding intricate machinery in twisting, flowing patterns. The mechanism itself is a dense, multi-layered world of interlocking gears crafted from brass and steel, their perfectly machined teeth meshing with perfect precision, while vibrant rubies set into the plates glitter like tiny embers. As the pendulum rhythmically twists, its motion drives the escapement; a pair of delicate pallets can be seen engaging and disengaging with the teeth of the escape wheel in a precise, hypnotic dance. With each release, the gear train advances, each minute's rotation and interaction captured with surreal clarity, showcasing the pure mechanical beauty grounded in physics and creating an atmosphere of focused, mechanical perfection.", + "seed": 13115, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_3/index_6736_seed_13115_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.0351360023021698, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0351360023021698, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0351360023021698, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro, high-angle view of a clock's escapement mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a polished golden brass disc pendulum visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendulum performing a slow torsional oscillation on a nearly invisible suspension wire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are interlocking gears made of brass and steel with vibrant ruby jewels visible in the mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Can a pair of delicate pallets be seen engaging and disengaging with the teeth of the escape wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.017391325905919075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.642391204833984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.017391325905919075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.017391325905919075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26768121123313904, + 0.0582919679582119, + 0.046827420592308044, + 0.045571114867925644, + 0.11704834550619125, + 0.048264507204294205, + 0.04463322088122368, + 0.06718102842569351, + 0.04427908733487129, + 0.26022207736968994 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.017391325905919075 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro, high-angle view of a clock's escapement mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a polished golden brass disc pendulum visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendulum performing a slow torsional oscillation on a nearly invisible suspension wire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are interlocking gears made of brass and steel with vibrant ruby jewels visible in the mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Can a pair of delicate pallets be seen engaging and disengaging with the teeth of the escape wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309320077300072 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168093204498291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309320077300072, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309320077300072, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11334261298179626, + 0.07551532983779907, + 0.06701163947582245, + 0.03166528046131134, + 0.06514067202806473, + 0.04191705211997032, + 0.03270890563726425, + 0.07968749105930328, + 0.036062609404325485, + 0.4569483995437622 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309320077300072 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro, high-angle view of a clock's escapement mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a polished golden brass disc pendulum visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendulum performing a slow torsional oscillation on a nearly invisible suspension wire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are interlocking gears made of brass and steel with vibrant ruby jewels visible in the mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Can a pair of delicate pallets be seen engaging and disengaging with the teeth of the escape wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026378124952316284 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513781547546387 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026378124952316284, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026378124952316284, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2321033775806427, + 0.06840486079454422, + 0.06886552274227142, + 0.042013831436634064, + 0.15136592090129852, + 0.08932619541883469, + 0.0694834366440773, + 0.04608152434229851, + 0.07876379042863846, + 0.15359145402908325 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026378124952316284 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro, high-angle view of a clock's escapement mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a polished golden brass disc pendulum visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendulum performing a slow torsional oscillation on a nearly invisible suspension wire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are interlocking gears made of brass and steel with vibrant ruby jewels visible in the mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Can a pair of delicate pallets be seen engaging and disengaging with the teeth of the escape wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009796636179089546 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634796619415283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009796636179089546, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009796636179089546, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15102285146713257, + 0.07917485386133194, + 0.053750179708004, + 0.051637765020132065, + 0.10055253654718399, + 0.09409128874540329, + 0.10708877444267273, + 0.039341915398836136, + 0.06051226705312729, + 0.262827605009079 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009796636179089546 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro, high-angle view of a clock's escapement mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a polished golden brass disc pendulum visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendulum performing a slow torsional oscillation on a nearly invisible suspension wire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are interlocking gears made of brass and steel with vibrant ruby jewels visible in the mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Can a pair of delicate pallets be seen engaging and disengaging with the teeth of the escape wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07902072370052338 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790207386016846 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07902072370052338, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07902072370052338, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1968550682067871, + 0.08758308738470078, + 0.043698500841856, + 0.031734827905893326, + 0.10848996043205261, + 0.07081007957458496, + 0.07066651433706284, + 0.02811669558286667, + 0.07034071534872055, + 0.2917045056819916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07902072370052338 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This extreme macro, high-angle shot, filmed at a high frame rate, captures extremely slow motion, held statically to capture the incredibly complex inner workings of a clock's escapement. At the center of the frame, a polished, golden brass disc pendulum performs a slow, mesmerizing torsional oscillation, twisting steadily and deliberately on a nearly invisible suspension wire. Its mirror-like surface catches the bright, directional studio light, reflecting the surrounding intricate machinery in twisting, flowing patterns. The mechanism itself is a dense, multi-layered world of interlocking gears crafted from brass and steel, their perfectly machined teeth meshing with perfect precision, while vibrant rubies set into the plates glitter like tiny embers. As the pendulum rhythmically twists, its motion drives the escapement; a pair of delicate pallets can be seen engaging and disengaging with the teeth of the escape wheel in a precise, hypnotic dance. With each release, the gear train advances, each minute's rotation and interaction captured with surreal clarity, showcasing the pure mechanical beauty grounded in physics and creating an atmosphere of focused, mechanical perfection.", + "seed": 13116, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_3/index_6736_seed_13116_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.026719409972429276, + "vlm_logprob": -0.026719409972429276, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.026719409972429276, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro, high-angle view of a clock's escapement mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a polished golden brass disc pendulum visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendulum performing a slow torsional oscillation on a nearly invisible suspension wire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are interlocking gears made of brass and steel with vibrant ruby jewels visible in the mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Can a pair of delicate pallets be seen engaging and disengaging with the teeth of the escape wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00936354510486126 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.509363651275635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00936354510486126, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00936354510486126, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.273941308259964, + 0.055431339889764786, + 0.08477000892162323, + 0.10000951588153839, + 0.03299097716808319, + 0.07765933871269226, + 0.16063980758190155, + 0.04218113422393799, + 0.05830281600356102, + 0.11407370865345001 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00936354510486126 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro, high-angle view of a clock's escapement mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a polished golden brass disc pendulum visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendulum performing a slow torsional oscillation on a nearly invisible suspension wire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are interlocking gears made of brass and steel with vibrant ruby jewels visible in the mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Can a pair of delicate pallets be seen engaging and disengaging with the teeth of the escape wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014217747375369072 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264217853546143 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014217747375369072, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014217747375369072, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15822337567806244, + 0.14216069877147675, + 0.15199503302574158, + 0.04044061899185181, + 0.09770771861076355, + 0.07361311465501785, + 0.10080786049365997, + 0.15336044132709503, + 0.03214084729552269, + 0.049550335854291916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014217747375369072 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro, high-angle view of a clock's escapement mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a polished golden brass disc pendulum visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendulum performing a slow torsional oscillation on a nearly invisible suspension wire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are interlocking gears made of brass and steel with vibrant ruby jewels visible in the mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Can a pair of delicate pallets be seen engaging and disengaging with the teeth of the escape wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03373221680521965 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087321758270264 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03373221680521965, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03373221680521965, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17201413214206696, + 0.07227903604507446, + 0.05828690156340599, + 0.048428744077682495, + 0.09070483595132828, + 0.10592087358236313, + 0.0790521502494812, + 0.100558802485466, + 0.16034917533397675, + 0.11240538209676743 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03373221680521965 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro, high-angle view of a clock's escapement mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a polished golden brass disc pendulum visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendulum performing a slow torsional oscillation on a nearly invisible suspension wire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are interlocking gears made of brass and steel with vibrant ruby jewels visible in the mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Can a pair of delicate pallets be seen engaging and disengaging with the teeth of the escape wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01420881599187851 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264208793640137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01420881599187851, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01420881599187851, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17257928848266602, + 0.087828129529953, + 0.15937568247318268, + 0.16010782122612, + 0.044204484671354294, + 0.05412980541586876, + 0.13142001628875732, + 0.06540162861347198, + 0.07596077024936676, + 0.04899236932396889 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01420881599187851 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme macro, high-angle view of a clock's escapement mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a polished golden brass disc pendulum visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the pendulum performing a slow torsional oscillation on a nearly invisible suspension wire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are interlocking gears made of brass and steel with vibrant ruby jewels visible in the mechanism?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Can a pair of delicate pallets be seen engaging and disengaging with the teeth of the escape wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062074724584817886 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812074661254883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062074724584817886, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062074724584817886, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15861988067626953, + 0.04766858369112015, + 0.15865296125411987, + 0.05590340122580528, + 0.049047768115997314, + 0.04012935608625412, + 0.11972428113222122, + 0.17983627319335938, + 0.1610732227563858, + 0.02934427559375763 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062074724584817886 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_4/index_tensor([6536, 6536])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_4/index_tensor([6536, 6536])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6dda04d2bb04737e3444eaccc0b3d304379aa710 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_4/index_tensor([6536, 6536])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, low-angle, medium shot panning to the right captures the stunning scene of two massive white tigers locked in a mortal combat on a barren snowy landscape. Their thick, pristine white fur is splattered with a striking crimson of blood, clotted on their shoulders, flanks, and cheeks, creating a brutal, stark contrast to the pristine whiteness of their coats. One tiger has its blood-stained jaws firmly fixed on the other's neck. The tiger throbs in agony, its powerful body thrashing, muscles rippling beneath its fur as it struggles to break free from the deadly grip, its snarling mouth gaping, revealing sharp, blood-stained canines. Their hot breath condenses into a white mist in the icy air, and their massive claws gouge the smooth, powdery snow around them, leaving a chaotic mess of footprints and drag marks. Under the gloomy grey sky, the diffuse cold light evenly illuminates the entire scene without a trace of shadow, only highlighting the savagery and cruelty of this primitive power showdown, creating a tense and suffocating primitive atmosphere.", + "seed": 3546, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_4/index_6536_seed_3546_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0834196962416172, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0834196962416172, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0834196962416172, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive white tigers visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a barren snowy landscape under a gloomy grey sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one tiger biting the neck of the other while the second tiger thrashes and struggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snow around the tigers gouged with chaotic footprints and drag marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle medium shot that pans to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05576412379741669 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9307641983032227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05576412379741669, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05576412379741669, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.021029941737651825, + 0.29365062713623047, + 0.026691848412156105, + 0.017597166821360588, + 0.11183510720729828, + 0.03985293582081795, + 0.019543467089533806, + 0.03326069563627243, + 0.05072956532239914, + 0.38580864667892456 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05576412379741669 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive white tigers visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a barren snowy landscape under a gloomy grey sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one tiger biting the neck of the other while the second tiger thrashes and struggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snow around the tigers gouged with chaotic footprints and drag marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle medium shot that pans to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07901202142238617 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579011917114258 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07901202142238617, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07901202142238617, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05289158597588539, + 0.1500040739774704, + 0.24423378705978394, + 0.12852627038955688, + 0.059460677206516266, + 0.06913480162620544, + 0.010951222851872444, + 0.03864802420139313, + 0.023235520347952843, + 0.2229139804840088 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07901202142238617 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive white tigers visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a barren snowy landscape under a gloomy grey sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one tiger biting the neck of the other while the second tiger thrashes and struggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snow around the tigers gouged with chaotic footprints and drag marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle medium shot that pans to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014201881363987923 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264202117919922 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014201881363987923, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014201881363987923, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08051951229572296, + 0.46495264768600464, + 0.025964034721255302, + 0.014748060144484043, + 0.08801289647817612, + 0.03276831656694412, + 0.02017606794834137, + 0.0174343753606081, + 0.01398407481610775, + 0.2414400577545166 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014201881363987923 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive white tigers visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a barren snowy landscape under a gloomy grey sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one tiger biting the neck of the other while the second tiger thrashes and struggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snow around the tigers gouged with chaotic footprints and drag marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle medium shot that pans to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016074584797024727 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410746574401855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016074584797024727, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016074584797024727, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08882579952478409, + 0.29754748940467834, + 0.13090582191944122, + 0.04758637398481369, + 0.06666339933872223, + 0.0862545520067215, + 0.008861024864017963, + 0.029381215572357178, + 0.01956305280327797, + 0.22441133856773376 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016074584797024727 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive white tigers visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a barren snowy landscape under a gloomy grey sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one tiger biting the neck of the other while the second tiger thrashes and struggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snow around the tigers gouged with chaotic footprints and drag marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle medium shot that pans to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520458698272705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020458698272705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520458698272705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520458698272705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03589092940092087, + 0.30705222487449646, + 0.019346218556165695, + 0.023660318925976753, + 0.04718102887272835, + 0.04667581990361214, + 0.008053534664213657, + 0.02351316623389721, + 0.02957148663699627, + 0.4590553045272827 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520458698272705 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, low-angle, medium shot panning to the right captures the stunning scene of two massive white tigers locked in a mortal combat on a barren snowy landscape. Their thick, pristine white fur is splattered with a striking crimson of blood, clotted on their shoulders, flanks, and cheeks, creating a brutal, stark contrast to the pristine whiteness of their coats. One tiger has its blood-stained jaws firmly fixed on the other's neck. The tiger throbs in agony, its powerful body thrashing, muscles rippling beneath its fur as it struggles to break free from the deadly grip, its snarling mouth gaping, revealing sharp, blood-stained canines. Their hot breath condenses into a white mist in the icy air, and their massive claws gouge the smooth, powdery snow around them, leaving a chaotic mess of footprints and drag marks. Under the gloomy grey sky, the diffuse cold light evenly illuminates the entire scene without a trace of shadow, only highlighting the savagery and cruelty of this primitive power showdown, creating a tense and suffocating primitive atmosphere.", + "seed": 3547, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_4/index_6536_seed_3547_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.239301123842597, + "vlm_logprob": -0.239301123842597, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.239301123842597, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive white tigers visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a barren snowy landscape under a gloomy grey sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one tiger biting the neck of the other while the second tiger thrashes and struggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snow around the tigers gouged with chaotic footprints and drag marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle medium shot that pans to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3881490230560303 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1381490230560303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3881490230560303, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3881490230560303, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19404713809490204, + 0.1631503701210022, + 0.03218999132514, + 0.2433411031961441, + 0.13738028705120087, + 0.0374971441924572, + 0.06763841211795807, + 0.03341114893555641, + 0.0418068952858448, + 0.04953745752573013 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3881490230560303 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive white tigers visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a barren snowy landscape under a gloomy grey sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one tiger biting the neck of the other while the second tiger thrashes and struggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snow around the tigers gouged with chaotic footprints and drag marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle medium shot that pans to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04868180304765701 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486817359924316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04868180304765701, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04868180304765701, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17270055413246155, + 0.1310083270072937, + 0.03920245170593262, + 0.09259914606809616, + 0.0653047263622284, + 0.05083733797073364, + 0.04735090583562851, + 0.03820955380797386, + 0.05080707371234894, + 0.3119799792766571 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04868180304765701 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive white tigers visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a barren snowy landscape under a gloomy grey sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one tiger biting the neck of the other while the second tiger thrashes and struggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snow around the tigers gouged with chaotic footprints and drag marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle medium shot that pans to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329506166279316 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732951641082764 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329506166279316, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329506166279316, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21265918016433716, + 0.09817236661911011, + 0.025713840499520302, + 0.25431376695632935, + 0.08817679435014725, + 0.04542876407504082, + 0.08510725200176239, + 0.05396437644958496, + 0.05617650970816612, + 0.08028718084096909 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329506166279316 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive white tigers visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a barren snowy landscape under a gloomy grey sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one tiger biting the neck of the other while the second tiger thrashes and struggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snow around the tigers gouged with chaotic footprints and drag marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle medium shot that pans to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307173565030098 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168071746826172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307173565030098, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307173565030098, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14980410039424896, + 0.20350733399391174, + 0.043723732233047485, + 0.08748915791511536, + 0.0680629163980484, + 0.04847235232591629, + 0.09378684312105179, + 0.042776551097631454, + 0.0664878860116005, + 0.19588911533355713 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307173565030098 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive white tigers visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a barren snowy landscape under a gloomy grey sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one tiger biting the neck of the other while the second tiger thrashes and struggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snow around the tigers gouged with chaotic footprints and drag marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle medium shot that pans to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933079957962036 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933079957962036 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6933079957962036, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6933079957962036, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20695652067661285, + 0.1514834314584732, + 0.062057074159383774, + 0.17880907654762268, + 0.06331335753202438, + 0.02237246185541153, + 0.04441147297620773, + 0.06540815532207489, + 0.0698823407292366, + 0.13530610501766205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6933079957962036 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, low-angle, medium shot panning to the right captures the stunning scene of two massive white tigers locked in a mortal combat on a barren snowy landscape. Their thick, pristine white fur is splattered with a striking crimson of blood, clotted on their shoulders, flanks, and cheeks, creating a brutal, stark contrast to the pristine whiteness of their coats. One tiger has its blood-stained jaws firmly fixed on the other's neck. The tiger throbs in agony, its powerful body thrashing, muscles rippling beneath its fur as it struggles to break free from the deadly grip, its snarling mouth gaping, revealing sharp, blood-stained canines. Their hot breath condenses into a white mist in the icy air, and their massive claws gouge the smooth, powdery snow around them, leaving a chaotic mess of footprints and drag marks. Under the gloomy grey sky, the diffuse cold light evenly illuminates the entire scene without a trace of shadow, only highlighting the savagery and cruelty of this primitive power showdown, creating a tense and suffocating primitive atmosphere.", + "seed": 3548, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_4/index_6536_seed_3548_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.14711530469357967, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14711530469357967, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14711530469357967, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive white tigers visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a barren snowy landscape under a gloomy grey sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one tiger biting the neck of the other while the second tiger thrashes and struggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snow around the tigers gouged with chaotic footprints and drag marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle medium shot that pans to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06266430020332336 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812664270401001 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06266430020332336, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06266430020332336, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.043173275887966156, + 0.13244234025478363, + 0.03893759101629257, + 0.03526317700743675, + 0.03327678516507149, + 0.523149847984314, + 0.022703668102622032, + 0.08113665878772736, + 0.05014849826693535, + 0.03976820409297943 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06266430020332336 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive white tigers visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a barren snowy landscape under a gloomy grey sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one tiger biting the neck of the other while the second tiger thrashes and struggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snow around the tigers gouged with chaotic footprints and drag marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle medium shot that pans to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059526927769184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955953121185303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059526927769184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059526927769184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17328694462776184, + 0.12061262875795364, + 0.044981908053159714, + 0.033885810524225235, + 0.05010903626680374, + 0.35106879472732544, + 0.03601246699690819, + 0.07351776957511902, + 0.071476049721241, + 0.04504859447479248 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059526927769184 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive white tigers visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a barren snowy landscape under a gloomy grey sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one tiger biting the neck of the other while the second tiger thrashes and struggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snow around the tigers gouged with chaotic footprints and drag marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle medium shot that pans to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978671945631504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634786605834961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978671945631504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978671945631504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14006774127483368, + 0.03684268519282341, + 0.03728890419006348, + 0.018228942528367043, + 0.06654980778694153, + 0.5134392380714417, + 0.07307237386703491, + 0.06840133666992188, + 0.019386762753129005, + 0.02672213315963745 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978671945631504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive white tigers visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a barren snowy landscape under a gloomy grey sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one tiger biting the neck of the other while the second tiger thrashes and struggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snow around the tigers gouged with chaotic footprints and drag marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle medium shot that pans to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0097829420119524 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634782791137695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0097829420119524, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0097829420119524, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.041785016655921936, + 0.2573225200176239, + 0.025861874222755432, + 0.03585616871714592, + 0.09069585055112839, + 0.4019356369972229, + 0.02178412489593029, + 0.05597297102212906, + 0.03978222236037254, + 0.029003646224737167 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0097829420119524 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive white tigers visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a barren snowy landscape under a gloomy grey sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one tiger biting the neck of the other while the second tiger thrashes and struggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snow around the tigers gouged with chaotic footprints and drag marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle medium shot that pans to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6327472925186157 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7577472925186157 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6327472925186157, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6327472925186157, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08548857271671295, + 0.43659818172454834, + 0.07724449783563614, + 0.043520521372556686, + 0.03917304798960686, + 0.0868738442659378, + 0.022029414772987366, + 0.05203424021601677, + 0.13904322683811188, + 0.017994485795497894 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6327472925186157 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, low-angle, medium shot panning to the right captures the stunning scene of two massive white tigers locked in a mortal combat on a barren snowy landscape. Their thick, pristine white fur is splattered with a striking crimson of blood, clotted on their shoulders, flanks, and cheeks, creating a brutal, stark contrast to the pristine whiteness of their coats. One tiger has its blood-stained jaws firmly fixed on the other's neck. The tiger throbs in agony, its powerful body thrashing, muscles rippling beneath its fur as it struggles to break free from the deadly grip, its snarling mouth gaping, revealing sharp, blood-stained canines. Their hot breath condenses into a white mist in the icy air, and their massive claws gouge the smooth, powdery snow around them, leaving a chaotic mess of footprints and drag marks. Under the gloomy grey sky, the diffuse cold light evenly illuminates the entire scene without a trace of shadow, only highlighting the savagery and cruelty of this primitive power showdown, creating a tense and suffocating primitive atmosphere.", + "seed": 3549, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_4/index_6536_seed_3549_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.3064245134592056, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3064245134592056, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3064245134592056, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive white tigers visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a barren snowy landscape under a gloomy grey sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one tiger biting the neck of the other while the second tiger thrashes and struggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snow around the tigers gouged with chaotic footprints and drag marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle medium shot that pans to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5772455930709839 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8272455930709839 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5772455930709839, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5772455930709839, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2206137478351593, + 0.050344180315732956, + 0.18640410900115967, + 0.08707523345947266, + 0.0736018717288971, + 0.0705629214644432, + 0.11793506145477295, + 0.04516635835170746, + 0.05014393851161003, + 0.09815260767936707 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5772455930709839 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive white tigers visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a barren snowy landscape under a gloomy grey sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one tiger biting the neck of the other while the second tiger thrashes and struggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snow around the tigers gouged with chaotic footprints and drag marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle medium shot that pans to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07006338238716125 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695063352584839 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07006338238716125, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07006338238716125, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10165730863809586, + 0.5219277739524841, + 0.08547602593898773, + 0.052816443145275116, + 0.020135998725891113, + 0.019108956679701805, + 0.07135126739740372, + 0.067335344851017, + 0.039508163928985596, + 0.020682740956544876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07006338238716125 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive white tigers visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a barren snowy landscape under a gloomy grey sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one tiger biting the neck of the other while the second tiger thrashes and struggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snow around the tigers gouged with chaotic footprints and drag marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle medium shot that pans to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020594686269760132 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895594596862793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020594686269760132, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020594686269760132, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23027819395065308, + 0.1306697279214859, + 0.14934979379177094, + 0.03245849162340164, + 0.055700886994600296, + 0.08941950649023056, + 0.1342281997203827, + 0.08071712404489517, + 0.03772931173443794, + 0.059448737651109695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020594686269760132 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive white tigers visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a barren snowy landscape under a gloomy grey sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one tiger biting the neck of the other while the second tiger thrashes and struggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snow around the tigers gouged with chaotic footprints and drag marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle medium shot that pans to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811325132846832 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881133556365967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811325132846832, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811325132846832, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.194443017244339, + 0.22645637392997742, + 0.15023639798164368, + 0.13949309289455414, + 0.04094376787543297, + 0.03542093560099602, + 0.05702168121933937, + 0.06405496597290039, + 0.03738914430141449, + 0.05454067885875702 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811325132846832 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two massive white tigers visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a barren snowy landscape under a gloomy grey sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is one tiger biting the neck of the other while the second tiger thrashes and struggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the snow around the tigers gouged with chaotic footprints and drag marks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle medium shot that pans to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261056542396545 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761056542396545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8261056542396545, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8261056542396545, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1261274665594101, + 0.1491701900959015, + 0.14207017421722412, + 0.08561110496520996, + 0.054898664355278015, + 0.061425451189279556, + 0.07318153977394104, + 0.19080202281475067, + 0.0878492072224617, + 0.02886423096060753 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8261056542396545 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_5/index_tensor([1107, 1107])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_5/index_tensor([1107, 1107])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..62849fcc8e5af0fbcf16a91ef51dc6f3341939b5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_5/index_tensor([1107, 1107])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up macro lens, panning slowly to the right, closely tracks the tip of a single leaf on a citron. Covered in a velvety, silvery-white down, the leaf is outlined with a soft golden hue in the soft, diffuse first rays of dawn light filtering through the mist. Countless shimmering dewdrops cling to the leaf's furry surface like tiny diamonds, each reflecting the surrounding deep green background, blurred into soft focus. As a gentle, invisible force sweeps over the leaf, a subtle, rhythmic tremor begins. Then, the plump dewdrops lose their grip and gracefully tumble in slow motion, sliding from the tip, tracing tiny, shimmering arcs through the air before tumbling out of the frame. The image's dominant hue is a cool blue-gray, punctuated by the warm golden glow of dawn, creating an atmosphere of utterly dreamy, hushed stillness, imbued with the subtle rhythms of life.", + "seed": 23305, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_5/index_1107_seed_23305_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0908393731340766, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0908393731340766, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0908393731340766, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a single leaf on a citron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf covered in velvety, silvery-white down with a soft golden outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are countless shimmering dewdrops visible on the leaf's surface reflecting the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right while tracking the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dewdrops detach from the leaf and tumble in slow motion through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019367516040802002 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.019367694854736 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019367516040802002, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019367516040802002, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06448182463645935, + 0.0482347346842289, + 0.0956324115395546, + 0.048746250569820404, + 0.10727571696043015, + 0.15836882591247559, + 0.029393818229436874, + 0.03377440199255943, + 0.38979005813598633, + 0.02430199272930622 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019367516040802002 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a single leaf on a citron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf covered in velvety, silvery-white down with a soft golden outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are countless shimmering dewdrops visible on the leaf's surface reflecting the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right while tracking the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dewdrops detach from the leaf and tumble in slow motion through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01255324762314558 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875532150268555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01255324762314558, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01255324762314558, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11120595037937164, + 0.040855854749679565, + 0.18118049204349518, + 0.026887327432632446, + 0.40580928325653076, + 0.0547553151845932, + 0.039039451628923416, + 0.015685413032770157, + 0.07134321331977844, + 0.05323769152164459 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01255324762314558 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a single leaf on a citron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf covered in velvety, silvery-white down with a soft golden outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are countless shimmering dewdrops visible on the leaf's surface reflecting the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right while tracking the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dewdrops detach from the leaf and tumble in slow motion through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029813364148139954 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529813289642334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029813364148139954, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029813364148139954, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15815742313861847, + 0.03448701277375221, + 0.24280594289302826, + 0.019010627642273903, + 0.14031173288822174, + 0.0737309455871582, + 0.07740914076566696, + 0.04462422803044319, + 0.08210507780313492, + 0.1273578405380249 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029813364148139954 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a single leaf on a citron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf covered in velvety, silvery-white down with a soft golden outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are countless shimmering dewdrops visible on the leaf's surface reflecting the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right while tracking the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dewdrops detach from the leaf and tumble in slow motion through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897556573152542 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789756774902344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897556573152542, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897556573152542, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0365094393491745, + 0.04341735690832138, + 0.030491815879940987, + 0.02224636636674404, + 0.05738123878836632, + 0.01848093420267105, + 0.022613612934947014, + 0.0238946620374918, + 0.7030616402626038, + 0.041902944445610046 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897556573152542 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a single leaf on a citron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf covered in velvety, silvery-white down with a soft golden outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are countless shimmering dewdrops visible on the leaf's surface reflecting the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right while tracking the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dewdrops detach from the leaf and tumble in slow motion through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31348717212677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.31348717212677 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31348717212677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31348717212677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05397332087159157, + 0.0363427959382534, + 0.11637960374355316, + 0.03336144611239433, + 0.12868084013462067, + 0.03577958419919014, + 0.026726216077804565, + 0.015195013955235481, + 0.3086589276790619, + 0.24490231275558472 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31348717212677 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up macro lens, panning slowly to the right, closely tracks the tip of a single leaf on a citron. Covered in a velvety, silvery-white down, the leaf is outlined with a soft golden hue in the soft, diffuse first rays of dawn light filtering through the mist. Countless shimmering dewdrops cling to the leaf's furry surface like tiny diamonds, each reflecting the surrounding deep green background, blurred into soft focus. As a gentle, invisible force sweeps over the leaf, a subtle, rhythmic tremor begins. Then, the plump dewdrops lose their grip and gracefully tumble in slow motion, sliding from the tip, tracing tiny, shimmering arcs through the air before tumbling out of the frame. The image's dominant hue is a cool blue-gray, punctuated by the warm golden glow of dawn, creating an atmosphere of utterly dreamy, hushed stillness, imbued with the subtle rhythms of life.", + "seed": 23306, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_5/index_1107_seed_23306_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.16134753599762916, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16134753599762916, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16134753599762916, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a single leaf on a citron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf covered in velvety, silvery-white down with a soft golden outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are countless shimmering dewdrops visible on the leaf's surface reflecting the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right while tracking the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dewdrops detach from the leaf and tumble in slow motion through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02463083155453205 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7746307849884033 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02463083155453205, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02463083155453205, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4645501673221588, + 0.0835711807012558, + 0.08442770689725876, + 0.0614289753139019, + 0.03413356468081474, + 0.05399172753095627, + 0.01781615801155567, + 0.048513226211071014, + 0.0943407416343689, + 0.057226527482271194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02463083155453205 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a single leaf on a citron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf covered in velvety, silvery-white down with a soft golden outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are countless shimmering dewdrops visible on the leaf's surface reflecting the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right while tracking the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dewdrops detach from the leaf and tumble in slow motion through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01256290078163147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875627517700195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01256290078163147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01256290078163147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5501795411109924, + 0.09711962193250656, + 0.016978280618786812, + 0.12114198505878448, + 0.041994720697402954, + 0.02276802994310856, + 0.017949873581528664, + 0.030287273228168488, + 0.04629385843873024, + 0.055286847054958344 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01256290078163147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a single leaf on a citron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf covered in velvety, silvery-white down with a soft golden outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are countless shimmering dewdrops visible on the leaf's surface reflecting the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right while tracking the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dewdrops detach from the leaf and tumble in slow motion through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059456892311573 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895594596862793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059456892311573, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059456892311573, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.43534529209136963, + 0.09992003440856934, + 0.017956530675292015, + 0.11937335878610611, + 0.025209940969944, + 0.027490241453051567, + 0.028310630470514297, + 0.05250992253422737, + 0.10363869369029999, + 0.0902453139424324 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059456892311573 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a single leaf on a citron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf covered in velvety, silvery-white down with a soft golden outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are countless shimmering dewdrops visible on the leaf's surface reflecting the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right while tracking the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dewdrops detach from the leaf and tumble in slow motion through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2255634367465973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600563406944275 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2255634367465973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2255634367465973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.523993730545044, + 0.13653436303138733, + 0.02646685764193535, + 0.07791560143232346, + 0.04321675002574921, + 0.0498371496796608, + 0.03237548843026161, + 0.024361934512853622, + 0.053339455276727676, + 0.03195866569876671 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2255634367465973 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a single leaf on a citron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf covered in velvety, silvery-white down with a soft golden outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are countless shimmering dewdrops visible on the leaf's surface reflecting the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right while tracking the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dewdrops detach from the leaf and tumble in slow motion through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233859419822693 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983859419822693 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233859419822693, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233859419822693, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3029162585735321, + 0.07749408483505249, + 0.034879136830568314, + 0.3140820860862732, + 0.023549994453787804, + 0.03967776894569397, + 0.022586639970541, + 0.03384103626012802, + 0.10143183916807175, + 0.04954114928841591 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233859419822693 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up macro lens, panning slowly to the right, closely tracks the tip of a single leaf on a citron. Covered in a velvety, silvery-white down, the leaf is outlined with a soft golden hue in the soft, diffuse first rays of dawn light filtering through the mist. Countless shimmering dewdrops cling to the leaf's furry surface like tiny diamonds, each reflecting the surrounding deep green background, blurred into soft focus. As a gentle, invisible force sweeps over the leaf, a subtle, rhythmic tremor begins. Then, the plump dewdrops lose their grip and gracefully tumble in slow motion, sliding from the tip, tracing tiny, shimmering arcs through the air before tumbling out of the frame. The image's dominant hue is a cool blue-gray, punctuated by the warm golden glow of dawn, creating an atmosphere of utterly dreamy, hushed stillness, imbued with the subtle rhythms of life.", + "seed": 23307, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_5/index_1107_seed_23307_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11254656352102757, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11254656352102757, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.6499999880790712, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11254656352102757, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a single leaf on a citron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf covered in velvety, silvery-white down with a soft golden outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are countless shimmering dewdrops visible on the leaf's surface reflecting the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right while tracking the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dewdrops detach from the leaf and tumble in slow motion through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.056130360811948776 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9311304092407227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.056130360811948776, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.056130360811948776, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1934734284877777, + 0.06796726584434509, + 0.04429230839014053, + 0.14609035849571228, + 0.06668819487094879, + 0.17911890149116516, + 0.03497812896966934, + 0.0846099928021431, + 0.14979524910449982, + 0.032986175268888474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.056130360811948776 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a single leaf on a citron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf covered in velvety, silvery-white down with a soft golden outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are countless shimmering dewdrops visible on the leaf's surface reflecting the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right while tracking the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dewdrops detach from the leaf and tumble in slow motion through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054985664784908295 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929985761642456 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054985664784908295, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054985664784908295, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13379313051700592, + 0.06613368541002274, + 0.07644635438919067, + 0.2958783507347107, + 0.17316149175167084, + 0.02576223574578762, + 0.07748530805110931, + 0.03930108621716499, + 0.039146505296230316, + 0.07289183139801025 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054985664784908295 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a single leaf on a citron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf covered in velvety, silvery-white down with a soft golden outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are countless shimmering dewdrops visible on the leaf's surface reflecting the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right while tracking the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dewdrops detach from the leaf and tumble in slow motion through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011087356135249138 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511087417602539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011087356135249138, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011087356135249138, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16196125745773315, + 0.055484626442193985, + 0.09393222630023956, + 0.06386316567659378, + 0.25907132029533386, + 0.1612442433834076, + 0.02857137657701969, + 0.039886631071567535, + 0.04153221473097801, + 0.09445291757583618 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011087356135249138 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a single leaf on a citron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf covered in velvety, silvery-white down with a soft golden outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are countless shimmering dewdrops visible on the leaf's surface reflecting the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right while tracking the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dewdrops detach from the leaf and tumble in slow motion through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12704280018806458 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127042770385742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12704280018806458, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12704280018806458, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40892624855041504, + 0.04772272706031799, + 0.03914327919483185, + 0.09647242724895477, + 0.0693129152059555, + 0.0392872653901577, + 0.029243694618344307, + 0.09848301112651825, + 0.046379752457141876, + 0.12502866983413696 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12704280018806458 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a single leaf on a citron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf covered in velvety, silvery-white down with a soft golden outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are countless shimmering dewdrops visible on the leaf's surface reflecting the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right while tracking the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dewdrops detach from the leaf and tumble in slow motion through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31348663568496704 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134865760803223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31348663568496704, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.9999999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31348663568496704, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3217715620994568, + 0.0592239648103714, + 0.07933121919631958, + 0.08242110908031464, + 0.1409386396408081, + 0.11940732598304749, + 0.05024712160229683, + 0.018382512032985687, + 0.08418864011764526, + 0.04408789798617363 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31348663568496704 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up macro lens, panning slowly to the right, closely tracks the tip of a single leaf on a citron. Covered in a velvety, silvery-white down, the leaf is outlined with a soft golden hue in the soft, diffuse first rays of dawn light filtering through the mist. Countless shimmering dewdrops cling to the leaf's furry surface like tiny diamonds, each reflecting the surrounding deep green background, blurred into soft focus. As a gentle, invisible force sweeps over the leaf, a subtle, rhythmic tremor begins. Then, the plump dewdrops lose their grip and gracefully tumble in slow motion, sliding from the tip, tracing tiny, shimmering arcs through the air before tumbling out of the frame. The image's dominant hue is a cool blue-gray, punctuated by the warm golden glow of dawn, creating an atmosphere of utterly dreamy, hushed stillness, imbued with the subtle rhythms of life.", + "seed": 23308, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_5/index_1107_seed_23308_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.02020754376426339, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02020754376426339, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02020754376426339, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a single leaf on a citron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf covered in velvety, silvery-white down with a soft golden outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are countless shimmering dewdrops visible on the leaf's surface reflecting the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right while tracking the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dewdrops detach from the leaf and tumble in slow motion through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02306198887526989 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.898061990737915 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02306198887526989, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02306198887526989, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1438269019126892, + 0.13275876641273499, + 0.11252200603485107, + 0.03527659550309181, + 0.04672722890973091, + 0.04237129166722298, + 0.29189470410346985, + 0.06730540841817856, + 0.059340350329875946, + 0.06797663867473602 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02306198887526989 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a single leaf on a citron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf covered in velvety, silvery-white down with a soft golden outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are countless shimmering dewdrops visible on the leaf's surface reflecting the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right while tracking the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dewdrops detach from the leaf and tumble in slow motion through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012553482316434383 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387553691864014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012553482316434383, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012553482316434383, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.187399223446846, + 0.24600327014923096, + 0.16553916037082672, + 0.050961047410964966, + 0.07757136970758438, + 0.05713149532675743, + 0.03788114711642265, + 0.04106762260198593, + 0.023026540875434875, + 0.11341916769742966 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012553482316434383 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a single leaf on a citron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf covered in velvety, silvery-white down with a soft golden outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are countless shimmering dewdrops visible on the leaf's surface reflecting the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right while tracking the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dewdrops detach from the leaf and tumble in slow motion through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006743175443261862 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00674295425415 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006743175443261862, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006743175443261862, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.040643446147441864, + 0.13905780017375946, + 0.05712438374757767, + 0.046976570039987564, + 0.019272517412900925, + 0.06384886056184769, + 0.06201042979955673, + 0.02875763364136219, + 0.06279697269201279, + 0.47951140999794006 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006743175443261862 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a single leaf on a citron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf covered in velvety, silvery-white down with a soft golden outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are countless shimmering dewdrops visible on the leaf's surface reflecting the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right while tracking the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dewdrops detach from the leaf and tumble in slow motion through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038094546645879745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880945205688477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038094546645879745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038094546645879745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06792966276407242, + 0.2860429286956787, + 0.03496147692203522, + 0.04444273188710213, + 0.03131559118628502, + 0.0399523563683033, + 0.06722282618284225, + 0.0330401211977005, + 0.07035773992538452, + 0.32473450899124146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038094546645879745 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view of a single leaf on a citron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf covered in velvety, silvery-white down with a soft golden outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are countless shimmering dewdrops visible on the leaf's surface reflecting the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly to the right while tracking the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do dewdrops detach from the leaf and tumble in slow motion through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020584525540471077 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955845832824707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020584525540471077, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020584525540471077, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02762909047305584, + 0.0640382468700409, + 0.019368654116988182, + 0.013692257925868034, + 0.015184595249593258, + 0.026716023683547974, + 0.054661255329847336, + 0.026598043739795685, + 0.04987780749797821, + 0.7022339701652527 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020584525540471077 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_6/index_tensor([4852, 4852])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_6/index_tensor([4852, 4852])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0de46328e6d8e8e836a483a45e53a0637304456e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_6/index_tensor([4852, 4852])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, slightly high-angle extreme close-up captures a photorealistic animation of a standard silver metal paperclip resting on a dark, polished oak surface. The wood's intricate grain is visible in macroscopic detail, and its smooth finish reflects a warm, directional light source from the side, casting a soft, elongated shadow from the paperclip. Nearby, a simple, powerful bar magnet, its surface a dark, matte gray. As the motion begins, the paperclip trembles slightly, almost imperceptibly, under the influence of an invisible magnetic field. Then it begins to slide, initially slowly and deliberately, through the wood. Gradually and smoothly, the movement accelerates, and the paperclip glides swiftly and decisively across the remaining distance until it secures itself firmly on one of the magnet's poles with a final, satisfying click, creating a focused and clean atmosphere that vividly illustrates the power of an unseen force.", + "seed": 15130, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_6/index_4852_seed_15130_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04148304210975766, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04148304210975766, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8499999761581423, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04148304210975766, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a standard silver metal paperclip resting on a dark, polished oak surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a simple, powerful bar magnet with a dark, matte gray surface visible nearby?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paperclip slide across the wood, accelerating from slow to swift before clicking onto the magnet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and directional from the side, casting a soft, elongated shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.017003118991851807 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.267003059387207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.017003118991851807, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.017003118991851807, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07945892214775085, + 0.07291940599679947, + 0.022364163771271706, + 0.3701413869857788, + 0.029567886143922806, + 0.020626334473490715, + 0.2588111460208893, + 0.06929802894592285, + 0.015018300153315067, + 0.06179441884160042 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.017003118991851807 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a standard silver metal paperclip resting on a dark, polished oak surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a simple, powerful bar magnet with a dark, matte gray surface visible nearby?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paperclip slide across the wood, accelerating from slow to swift before clicking onto the magnet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and directional from the side, casting a soft, elongated shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14281854033470154 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178184509277344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14281854033470154, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14281854033470154, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04475489631295204, + 0.020538605749607086, + 0.03453904762864113, + 0.6180443167686462, + 0.048544853925704956, + 0.06370992213487625, + 0.05946870520710945, + 0.07726386189460754, + 0.007419540546834469, + 0.025716183707118034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14281854033470154 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a standard silver metal paperclip resting on a dark, polished oak surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a simple, powerful bar magnet with a dark, matte gray surface visible nearby?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paperclip slide across the wood, accelerating from slow to swift before clicking onto the magnet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and directional from the side, casting a soft, elongated shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052567594684660435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255256652832031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052567594684660435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052567594684660435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04143277183175087, + 0.08915390074253082, + 0.012969913892447948, + 0.3913175165653229, + 0.018513640388846397, + 0.11865852773189545, + 0.040349625051021576, + 0.13995228707790375, + 0.00800966564565897, + 0.13964208960533142 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052567594684660435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a standard silver metal paperclip resting on a dark, polished oak surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a simple, powerful bar magnet with a dark, matte gray surface visible nearby?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paperclip slide across the wood, accelerating from slow to swift before clicking onto the magnet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and directional from the side, casting a soft, elongated shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029801908880472183 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529801845550537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029801908880472183, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029801908880472183, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07324591279029846, + 0.04421801120042801, + 0.037943463772535324, + 0.5061497688293457, + 0.024098586291074753, + 0.06136355176568031, + 0.09574592858552933, + 0.06967060267925262, + 0.026812221854925156, + 0.06075190007686615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029801908880472183 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a standard silver metal paperclip resting on a dark, polished oak surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a simple, powerful bar magnet with a dark, matte gray surface visible nearby?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paperclip slide across the wood, accelerating from slow to swift before clicking onto the magnet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and directional from the side, casting a soft, elongated shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012534882873296738 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387535095214844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012534882873296738, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012534882873296738, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06870190054178238, + 0.04904526472091675, + 0.026120847091078758, + 0.32893091440200806, + 0.07266955077648163, + 0.026765838265419006, + 0.07416681200265884, + 0.2807433009147644, + 0.012925335206091404, + 0.05993019789457321 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012534882873296738 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly high-angle extreme close-up captures a photorealistic animation of a standard silver metal paperclip resting on a dark, polished oak surface. The wood's intricate grain is visible in macroscopic detail, and its smooth finish reflects a warm, directional light source from the side, casting a soft, elongated shadow from the paperclip. Nearby, a simple, powerful bar magnet, its surface a dark, matte gray. As the motion begins, the paperclip trembles slightly, almost imperceptibly, under the influence of an invisible magnetic field. Then it begins to slide, initially slowly and deliberately, through the wood. Gradually and smoothly, the movement accelerates, and the paperclip glides swiftly and decisively across the remaining distance until it secures itself firmly on one of the magnet's poles with a final, satisfying click, creating a focused and clean atmosphere that vividly illustrates the power of an unseen force.", + "seed": 15131, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_6/index_4852_seed_15131_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02671460574492812, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02671460574492812, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02671460574492812, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a standard silver metal paperclip resting on a dark, polished oak surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a simple, powerful bar magnet with a dark, matte gray surface visible nearby?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paperclip slide across the wood, accelerating from slow to swift before clicking onto the magnet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and directional from the side, casting a soft, elongated shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.017017299309372902 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.517017364501953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.017017299309372902, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.017017299309372902, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18933309614658356, + 0.14107905328273773, + 0.09758665412664413, + 0.17206861078739166, + 0.09513798356056213, + 0.05271606519818306, + 0.03538099303841591, + 0.06281374394893646, + 0.06599778681993484, + 0.08788605779409409 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.017017299309372902 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a standard silver metal paperclip resting on a dark, polished oak surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a simple, powerful bar magnet with a dark, matte gray surface visible nearby?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paperclip slide across the wood, accelerating from slow to swift before clicking onto the magnet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and directional from the side, casting a soft, elongated shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004404813051224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950440406799316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004404813051224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004404813051224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14142294228076935, + 0.03723858669400215, + 0.18659096956253052, + 0.10874471068382263, + 0.159443199634552, + 0.05413719639182091, + 0.05281746760010719, + 0.0708056166768074, + 0.1326759159564972, + 0.05612342059612274 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004404813051224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a standard silver metal paperclip resting on a dark, polished oak surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a simple, powerful bar magnet with a dark, matte gray surface visible nearby?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paperclip slide across the wood, accelerating from slow to swift before clicking onto the magnet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and directional from the side, casting a soft, elongated shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007631551939994097 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882631778717041 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007631551939994097, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007631551939994097, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11900091171264648, + 0.039632126688957214, + 0.16088508069515228, + 0.08357170969247818, + 0.15402059257030487, + 0.09920889139175415, + 0.03586903586983681, + 0.06145506724715233, + 0.07890994846820831, + 0.16744662821292877 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007631551939994097 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a standard silver metal paperclip resting on a dark, polished oak surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a simple, powerful bar magnet with a dark, matte gray surface visible nearby?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paperclip slide across the wood, accelerating from slow to swift before clicking onto the magnet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and directional from the side, casting a soft, elongated shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026346659287810326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513466835021973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026346659287810326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026346659287810326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08477767556905746, + 0.07038123905658722, + 0.061913829296827316, + 0.14076903462409973, + 0.07783358544111252, + 0.12063021957874298, + 0.18224968016147614, + 0.05526619777083397, + 0.0814049020409584, + 0.12477367371320724 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026346659287810326 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a standard silver metal paperclip resting on a dark, polished oak surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a simple, powerful bar magnet with a dark, matte gray surface visible nearby?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paperclip slide across the wood, accelerating from slow to swift before clicking onto the magnet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and directional from the side, casting a soft, elongated shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012533470056951046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387533664703369 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012533470056951046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012533470056951046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21486561000347137, + 0.05699083209037781, + 0.16629736125469208, + 0.11260242760181427, + 0.08281030505895615, + 0.08057179301977158, + 0.08386626839637756, + 0.07317397743463516, + 0.0673346072435379, + 0.06148672103881836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012533470056951046 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly high-angle extreme close-up captures a photorealistic animation of a standard silver metal paperclip resting on a dark, polished oak surface. The wood's intricate grain is visible in macroscopic detail, and its smooth finish reflects a warm, directional light source from the side, casting a soft, elongated shadow from the paperclip. Nearby, a simple, powerful bar magnet, its surface a dark, matte gray. As the motion begins, the paperclip trembles slightly, almost imperceptibly, under the influence of an invisible magnetic field. Then it begins to slide, initially slowly and deliberately, through the wood. Gradually and smoothly, the movement accelerates, and the paperclip glides swiftly and decisively across the remaining distance until it secures itself firmly on one of the magnet's poles with a final, satisfying click, creating a focused and clean atmosphere that vividly illustrates the power of an unseen force.", + "seed": 15132, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_6/index_4852_seed_15132_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.02732659885659814, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02732659885659814, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02732659885659814, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a standard silver metal paperclip resting on a dark, polished oak surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a simple, powerful bar magnet with a dark, matte gray surface visible nearby?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paperclip slide across the wood, accelerating from slow to swift before clicking onto the magnet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and directional from the side, casting a soft, elongated shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02648644521832466 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.901486396789551 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02648644521832466, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02648644521832466, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11003302037715912, + 0.06679610162973404, + 0.041766420006752014, + 0.05596365034580231, + 0.5315771698951721, + 0.08415323495864868, + 0.05491109937429428, + 0.019283359870314598, + 0.021111799404025078, + 0.01440416369587183 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02648644521832466 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a standard silver metal paperclip resting on a dark, polished oak surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a simple, powerful bar magnet with a dark, matte gray surface visible nearby?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paperclip slide across the wood, accelerating from slow to swift before clicking onto the magnet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and directional from the side, casting a soft, elongated shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033733367919921875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408733367919922 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033733367919921875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033733367919921875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19336442649364471, + 0.054851602762937546, + 0.24147069454193115, + 0.03346327319741249, + 0.09553813934326172, + 0.08558637648820877, + 0.05164392665028572, + 0.08075137436389923, + 0.12614144384860992, + 0.03718872368335724 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033733367919921875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a standard silver metal paperclip resting on a dark, polished oak surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a simple, powerful bar magnet with a dark, matte gray surface visible nearby?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paperclip slide across the wood, accelerating from slow to swift before clicking onto the magnet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and directional from the side, casting a soft, elongated shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006741872988641262 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006742000579834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006741872988641262, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006741872988641262, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08621776103973389, + 0.07270508259534836, + 0.03553163260221481, + 0.020022347569465637, + 0.5611037015914917, + 0.08938369154930115, + 0.056776706129312515, + 0.019799498841166496, + 0.015551473945379257, + 0.04290810599923134 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006741872988641262 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a standard silver metal paperclip resting on a dark, polished oak surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a simple, powerful bar magnet with a dark, matte gray surface visible nearby?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paperclip slide across the wood, accelerating from slow to swift before clicking onto the magnet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and directional from the side, casting a soft, elongated shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204425171017647 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812044143676758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204425171017647, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204425171017647, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04259048402309418, + 0.045503679662942886, + 0.049925487488508224, + 0.014038355089724064, + 0.761552631855011, + 0.03350455313920975, + 0.01097528263926506, + 0.013344923965632915, + 0.016931261867284775, + 0.01163328718394041 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204425171017647 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a standard silver metal paperclip resting on a dark, polished oak surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a simple, powerful bar magnet with a dark, matte gray surface visible nearby?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paperclip slide across the wood, accelerating from slow to swift before clicking onto the magnet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and directional from the side, casting a soft, elongated shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007627056445926428 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882627010345459 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007627056445926428, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007627056445926428, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17375962436199188, + 0.06625969707965851, + 0.06315627694129944, + 0.08005455881357193, + 0.3114978075027466, + 0.07241890579462051, + 0.04013804346323013, + 0.03397009149193764, + 0.04070798307657242, + 0.11803694814443588 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007627056445926428 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly high-angle extreme close-up captures a photorealistic animation of a standard silver metal paperclip resting on a dark, polished oak surface. The wood's intricate grain is visible in macroscopic detail, and its smooth finish reflects a warm, directional light source from the side, casting a soft, elongated shadow from the paperclip. Nearby, a simple, powerful bar magnet, its surface a dark, matte gray. As the motion begins, the paperclip trembles slightly, almost imperceptibly, under the influence of an invisible magnetic field. Then it begins to slide, initially slowly and deliberately, through the wood. Gradually and smoothly, the movement accelerates, and the paperclip glides swiftly and decisively across the remaining distance until it secures itself firmly on one of the magnet's poles with a final, satisfying click, creating a focused and clean atmosphere that vividly illustrates the power of an unseen force.", + "seed": 15133, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_6/index_4852_seed_15133_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04407733138650656, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04407733138650656, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3999999523162843, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04407733138650656, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a standard silver metal paperclip resting on a dark, polished oak surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a simple, powerful bar magnet with a dark, matte gray surface visible nearby?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paperclip slide across the wood, accelerating from slow to swift before clicking onto the magnet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and directional from the side, casting a soft, elongated shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06942811608314514 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8194282054901123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06942811608314514, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06942811608314514, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13217726349830627, + 0.04866037145256996, + 0.10354690998792648, + 0.09128178656101227, + 0.23893378674983978, + 0.04588569328188896, + 0.22477807104587555, + 0.039246365427970886, + 0.04893266037106514, + 0.02655703015625477 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06942811608314514 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a standard silver metal paperclip resting on a dark, polished oak surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a simple, powerful bar magnet with a dark, matte gray surface visible nearby?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paperclip slide across the wood, accelerating from slow to swift before clicking onto the magnet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and directional from the side, casting a soft, elongated shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620722621679306 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812072277069092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620722621679306, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620722621679306, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20231904089450836, + 0.04129457846283913, + 0.12592466175556183, + 0.0651806965470314, + 0.05400623753666878, + 0.15826910734176636, + 0.0715206190943718, + 0.11196231096982956, + 0.07632651925086975, + 0.09319620579481125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620722621679306 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a standard silver metal paperclip resting on a dark, polished oak surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a simple, powerful bar magnet with a dark, matte gray surface visible nearby?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paperclip slide across the wood, accelerating from slow to swift before clicking onto the magnet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and directional from the side, casting a soft, elongated shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018200064077973366 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018199920654297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018200064077973366, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018200064077973366, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16208334267139435, + 0.04782666265964508, + 0.1348608285188675, + 0.11212822049856186, + 0.05583960562944412, + 0.05915510281920433, + 0.08488436043262482, + 0.1426708847284317, + 0.16537654399871826, + 0.03517444431781769 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018200064077973366 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a standard silver metal paperclip resting on a dark, polished oak surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a simple, powerful bar magnet with a dark, matte gray surface visible nearby?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paperclip slide across the wood, accelerating from slow to swift before clicking onto the magnet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and directional from the side, casting a soft, elongated shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204817444086075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120481967926025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204817444086075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204817444086075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11476939171552658, + 0.040854357182979584, + 0.036523301154375076, + 0.11484582722187042, + 0.06305121630430222, + 0.06817304342985153, + 0.07497628778219223, + 0.185903862118721, + 0.21824458241462708, + 0.08265820890665054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204817444086075 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up with a slightly high angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a standard silver metal paperclip resting on a dark, polished oak surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a simple, powerful bar magnet with a dark, matte gray surface visible nearby?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paperclip slide across the wood, accelerating from slow to swift before clicking onto the magnet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting warm and directional from the side, casting a soft, elongated shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008638040162622929 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75863790512085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008638040162622929, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008638040162622929, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20205369591712952, + 0.06903228908777237, + 0.10186009109020233, + 0.0722280815243721, + 0.05194101855158806, + 0.07995620369911194, + 0.18782790005207062, + 0.0658753365278244, + 0.06856755167245865, + 0.10065782070159912 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008638040162622929 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_7/index_tensor([3143, 3143])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_7/index_tensor([3143, 3143])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7f6f4931bc6e0bd9a540ff57c285f59b7aafb409 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_7/index_tensor([3143, 3143])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle shot captures a pair of clean, capable hands performing a methodical task on a warm-toned wooden kitchen countertop, illuminated by bright, even overhead lighting. The recorder's right hand firmly grasps the black plastic handle of a polished stainless steel kettle, tilting it to release a stream of clear steam directly into a translucent bucket containing a mound of fine flour. After adding water, the right hand deliberately moves the kettle and returns it to its round, black power base on the counter. The left hand immediately picks up a matching translucent lid and snaps it onto the flour bucket with a swift and decisive movement, sealing it. The right hand then retrieves a standard metal fork from the countertop and gently places it flat on the center of the lid. Finally, two hands enter the frame, one on each side of the bucket, firmly grasping it before lifting it straight out of sight, completing the preparation process in an atmosphere of focused concentration and tranquility.", + "seed": 28931, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_7/index_3143_seed_28931_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.02951849342789501, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02951849342789501, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02951849342789501, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle view of a kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are clean, capable hands visible performing a methodical task on a warm-toned wooden countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand grasp a black plastic handle of a polished stainless steel kettle and tilt it to release steam into a translucent bucket of flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands subsequently place a metal fork on the lid, lift the bucket out of sight, and is the lighting bright and even?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, even overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.041231684386730194 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.291231632232666 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.041231684386730194, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.041231684386730194, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40332233905792236, + 0.08228364586830139, + 0.09288887679576874, + 0.052925288677215576, + 0.06723764538764954, + 0.08300042152404785, + 0.07712636142969131, + 0.039029933512210846, + 0.041975200176239014, + 0.06021026521921158 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.041231684386730194 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle view of a kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are clean, capable hands visible performing a methodical task on a warm-toned wooden countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand grasp a black plastic handle of a polished stainless steel kettle and tilt it to release steam into a translucent bucket of flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands subsequently place a metal fork on the lid, lift the bucket out of sight, and is the lighting bright and even?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, even overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019530047429725528 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251953125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019530047429725528, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019530047429725528, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11336375772953033, + 0.11207371205091476, + 0.09252209216356277, + 0.09604816138744354, + 0.05033054202795029, + 0.12049631029367447, + 0.14567700028419495, + 0.06499579548835754, + 0.12924693524837494, + 0.0752456933259964 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019530047429725528 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle view of a kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are clean, capable hands visible performing a methodical task on a warm-toned wooden countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand grasp a black plastic handle of a polished stainless steel kettle and tilt it to release steam into a translucent bucket of flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands subsequently place a metal fork on the lid, lift the bucket out of sight, and is the lighting bright and even?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, even overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02979866974055767 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529798746109009 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02979866974055767, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02979866974055767, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09115945547819138, + 0.13936588168144226, + 0.06845633685588837, + 0.09398360550403595, + 0.042681943625211716, + 0.12873458862304688, + 0.17571070790290833, + 0.16698533296585083, + 0.04833342507481575, + 0.04458882659673691 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02979866974055767 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle view of a kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are clean, capable hands visible performing a methodical task on a warm-toned wooden countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand grasp a black plastic handle of a polished stainless steel kettle and tilt it to release steam into a translucent bucket of flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands subsequently place a metal fork on the lid, lift the bucket out of sight, and is the lighting bright and even?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, even overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06206833943724632 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812068223953247 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06206833943724632, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06206833943724632, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28959497809410095, + 0.06892742216587067, + 0.08964025974273682, + 0.03246261924505234, + 0.038870230317115784, + 0.0745897963643074, + 0.0632454976439476, + 0.2174491435289383, + 0.06560108810663223, + 0.05961901694536209 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06206833943724632 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle view of a kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are clean, capable hands visible performing a methodical task on a warm-toned wooden countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand grasp a black plastic handle of a polished stainless steel kettle and tilt it to release steam into a translucent bucket of flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands subsequently place a metal fork on the lid, lift the bucket out of sight, and is the lighting bright and even?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, even overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012540768831968307 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387540817260742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012540768831968307, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012540768831968307, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30404460430145264, + 0.08666222542524338, + 0.11392509192228317, + 0.05190304294228554, + 0.07886054366827011, + 0.09588342905044556, + 0.09707586467266083, + 0.03758515045046806, + 0.0631282776594162, + 0.07093171775341034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012540768831968307 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle shot captures a pair of clean, capable hands performing a methodical task on a warm-toned wooden kitchen countertop, illuminated by bright, even overhead lighting. The recorder's right hand firmly grasps the black plastic handle of a polished stainless steel kettle, tilting it to release a stream of clear steam directly into a translucent bucket containing a mound of fine flour. After adding water, the right hand deliberately moves the kettle and returns it to its round, black power base on the counter. The left hand immediately picks up a matching translucent lid and snaps it onto the flour bucket with a swift and decisive movement, sealing it. The right hand then retrieves a standard metal fork from the countertop and gently places it flat on the center of the lid. Finally, two hands enter the frame, one on each side of the bucket, firmly grasping it before lifting it straight out of sight, completing the preparation process in an atmosphere of focused concentration and tranquility.", + "seed": 28932, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_7/index_3143_seed_28932_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.020519188372418284, + "vlm_logprob": -0.020519188372418284, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.020519188372418284, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle view of a kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are clean, capable hands visible performing a methodical task on a warm-toned wooden countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand grasp a black plastic handle of a polished stainless steel kettle and tilt it to release steam into a translucent bucket of flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands subsequently place a metal fork on the lid, lift the bucket out of sight, and is the lighting bright and even?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, even overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029909396544098854 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.654909372329712 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029909396544098854, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029909396544098854, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08179086446762085, + 0.3421041965484619, + 0.04049248248338699, + 0.09754632413387299, + 0.13608483970165253, + 0.07558789849281311, + 0.03944467380642891, + 0.04706871509552002, + 0.11204320192337036, + 0.02783682942390442 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029909396544098854 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle view of a kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are clean, capable hands visible performing a methodical task on a warm-toned wooden countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand grasp a black plastic handle of a polished stainless steel kettle and tilt it to release steam into a translucent bucket of flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands subsequently place a metal fork on the lid, lift the bucket out of sight, and is the lighting bright and even?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, even overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003212888026610017 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753212928771973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003212888026610017, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003212888026610017, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11395642161369324, + 0.12081672251224518, + 0.08544106781482697, + 0.05059947818517685, + 0.04904617369174957, + 0.11079619079828262, + 0.04767150059342384, + 0.039730966091156006, + 0.28909990191459656, + 0.09284162521362305 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003212888026610017 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle view of a kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are clean, capable hands visible performing a methodical task on a warm-toned wooden countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand grasp a black plastic handle of a polished stainless steel kettle and tilt it to release steam into a translucent bucket of flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands subsequently place a metal fork on the lid, lift the bucket out of sight, and is the lighting bright and even?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, even overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370167315006256 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087016582489014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370167315006256, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370167315006256, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30331310629844666, + 0.19735559821128845, + 0.07500342279672623, + 0.050477318465709686, + 0.10976991057395935, + 0.029358329251408577, + 0.10478553920984268, + 0.03274812176823616, + 0.042439233511686325, + 0.054749470204114914 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370167315006256 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle view of a kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are clean, capable hands visible performing a methodical task on a warm-toned wooden countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand grasp a black plastic handle of a polished stainless steel kettle and tilt it to release steam into a translucent bucket of flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands subsequently place a metal fork on the lid, lift the bucket out of sight, and is the lighting bright and even?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, even overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029819495975971222 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298194885253906 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029819495975971222, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029819495975971222, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1317041963338852, + 0.23807722330093384, + 0.06843746453523636, + 0.08713904023170471, + 0.04987373575568199, + 0.07666375488042831, + 0.06594356149435043, + 0.05857403203845024, + 0.10089150816202164, + 0.12269554287195206 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029819495975971222 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle view of a kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are clean, capable hands visible performing a methodical task on a warm-toned wooden countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand grasp a black plastic handle of a polished stainless steel kettle and tilt it to release steam into a translucent bucket of flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands subsequently place a metal fork on the lid, lift the bucket out of sight, and is the lighting bright and even?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, even overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005952488165348768 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.13095235824585 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005952488165348768, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005952488165348768, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11661965399980545, + 0.44438719749450684, + 0.031676873564720154, + 0.08332308381795883, + 0.0830417275428772, + 0.04563724994659424, + 0.06273450702428818, + 0.034836545586586, + 0.061641495674848557, + 0.036101602017879486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005952488165348768 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle shot captures a pair of clean, capable hands performing a methodical task on a warm-toned wooden kitchen countertop, illuminated by bright, even overhead lighting. The recorder's right hand firmly grasps the black plastic handle of a polished stainless steel kettle, tilting it to release a stream of clear steam directly into a translucent bucket containing a mound of fine flour. After adding water, the right hand deliberately moves the kettle and returns it to its round, black power base on the counter. The left hand immediately picks up a matching translucent lid and snaps it onto the flour bucket with a swift and decisive movement, sealing it. The right hand then retrieves a standard metal fork from the countertop and gently places it flat on the center of the lid. Finally, two hands enter the frame, one on each side of the bucket, firmly grasping it before lifting it straight out of sight, completing the preparation process in an atmosphere of focused concentration and tranquility.", + "seed": 28933, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_7/index_3143_seed_28933_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.0418731099460274, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0418731099460274, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0418731099460274, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle view of a kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are clean, capable hands visible performing a methodical task on a warm-toned wooden countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand grasp a black plastic handle of a polished stainless steel kettle and tilt it to release steam into a translucent bucket of flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands subsequently place a metal fork on the lid, lift the bucket out of sight, and is the lighting bright and even?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, even overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.022768737748265266 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.89776873588562 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.022768737748265266, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.022768737748265266, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16257202625274658, + 0.0903606042265892, + 0.11702999472618103, + 0.049455951899290085, + 0.09119278192520142, + 0.07317470759153366, + 0.043200068175792694, + 0.11189574748277664, + 0.13459983468055725, + 0.1265183836221695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.022768737748265266 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle view of a kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are clean, capable hands visible performing a methodical task on a warm-toned wooden countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand grasp a black plastic handle of a polished stainless steel kettle and tilt it to release steam into a translucent bucket of flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands subsequently place a metal fork on the lid, lift the bucket out of sight, and is the lighting bright and even?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, even overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003214313881471753 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753214359283447 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003214313881471753, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003214313881471753, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13750289380550385, + 0.05591109022498131, + 0.10820203274488449, + 0.06359141319990158, + 0.05578097701072693, + 0.0703950822353363, + 0.041037026792764664, + 0.11341633647680283, + 0.2084900587797165, + 0.14567306637763977 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003214313881471753 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle view of a kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are clean, capable hands visible performing a methodical task on a warm-toned wooden countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand grasp a black plastic handle of a polished stainless steel kettle and tilt it to release steam into a translucent bucket of flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands subsequently place a metal fork on the lid, lift the bucket out of sight, and is the lighting bright and even?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, even overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866647347807884 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048666477203369 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866647347807884, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866647347807884, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08591243624687195, + 0.172687828540802, + 0.08963684737682343, + 0.08968497812747955, + 0.07526618987321854, + 0.05731072276830673, + 0.02945927530527115, + 0.12296576797962189, + 0.127793550491333, + 0.14928236603736877 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866647347807884 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle view of a kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are clean, capable hands visible performing a methodical task on a warm-toned wooden countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand grasp a black plastic handle of a polished stainless steel kettle and tilt it to release steam into a translucent bucket of flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands subsequently place a metal fork on the lid, lift the bucket out of sight, and is the lighting bright and even?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, even overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270817518234253 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127081871032715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270817518234253, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270817518234253, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15945325791835785, + 0.12734289467334747, + 0.09092102199792862, + 0.06556001305580139, + 0.05478360131382942, + 0.05339102819561958, + 0.06941336393356323, + 0.08521398901939392, + 0.1417718231678009, + 0.1521490514278412 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270817518234253 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle view of a kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are clean, capable hands visible performing a methodical task on a warm-toned wooden countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand grasp a black plastic handle of a polished stainless steel kettle and tilt it to release steam into a translucent bucket of flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands subsequently place a metal fork on the lid, lift the bucket out of sight, and is the lighting bright and even?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, even overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007634272798895836 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882634162902832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007634272798895836, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007634272798895836, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26630789041519165, + 0.12380924075841904, + 0.07884036004543304, + 0.0565606914460659, + 0.06879275292158127, + 0.038880910724401474, + 0.04596387594938278, + 0.05441195145249367, + 0.10146704316139221, + 0.16496524214744568 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007634272798895836 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, high-angle shot captures a pair of clean, capable hands performing a methodical task on a warm-toned wooden kitchen countertop, illuminated by bright, even overhead lighting. The recorder's right hand firmly grasps the black plastic handle of a polished stainless steel kettle, tilting it to release a stream of clear steam directly into a translucent bucket containing a mound of fine flour. After adding water, the right hand deliberately moves the kettle and returns it to its round, black power base on the counter. The left hand immediately picks up a matching translucent lid and snaps it onto the flour bucket with a swift and decisive movement, sealing it. The right hand then retrieves a standard metal fork from the countertop and gently places it flat on the center of the lid. Finally, two hands enter the frame, one on each side of the bucket, firmly grasping it before lifting it straight out of sight, completing the preparation process in an atmosphere of focused concentration and tranquility.", + "seed": 28934, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_7/index_3143_seed_28934_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.02274122373200953, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02274122373200953, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02274122373200953, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle view of a kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are clean, capable hands visible performing a methodical task on a warm-toned wooden countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand grasp a black plastic handle of a polished stainless steel kettle and tilt it to release steam into a translucent bucket of flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands subsequently place a metal fork on the lid, lift the bucket out of sight, and is the lighting bright and even?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, even overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04212493076920509 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2921249866485596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04212493076920509, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04212493076920509, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14099960029125214, + 0.07863178849220276, + 0.08396715670824051, + 0.2028646618127823, + 0.04937652125954628, + 0.17729979753494263, + 0.044714972376823425, + 0.03922403231263161, + 0.1551324725151062, + 0.027788903564214706 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04212493076920509 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle view of a kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are clean, capable hands visible performing a methodical task on a warm-toned wooden countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand grasp a black plastic handle of a polished stainless steel kettle and tilt it to release steam into a translucent bucket of flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands subsequently place a metal fork on the lid, lift the bucket out of sight, and is the lighting bright and even?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, even overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032130067702382803 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753212928771973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032130067702382803, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032130067702382803, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.036467451602220535, + 0.06875379383563995, + 0.1324944645166397, + 0.34329673647880554, + 0.049073610454797745, + 0.0819704458117485, + 0.026045536622405052, + 0.027180630713701248, + 0.04499838128685951, + 0.18971885740756989 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032130067702382803 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle view of a kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are clean, capable hands visible performing a methodical task on a warm-toned wooden countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand grasp a black plastic handle of a polished stainless steel kettle and tilt it to release steam into a translucent bucket of flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands subsequently place a metal fork on the lid, lift the bucket out of sight, and is the lighting bright and even?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, even overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016070479527115822 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141070365905762 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016070479527115822, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016070479527115822, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07210918515920639, + 0.10153046995401382, + 0.11773953586816788, + 0.5006140470504761, + 0.04683241248130798, + 0.04204517602920532, + 0.036204125732183456, + 0.020231226459145546, + 0.02678634785115719, + 0.03590746968984604 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016070479527115822 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle view of a kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are clean, capable hands visible performing a methodical task on a warm-toned wooden countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand grasp a black plastic handle of a polished stainless steel kettle and tilt it to release steam into a translucent bucket of flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands subsequently place a metal fork on the lid, lift the bucket out of sight, and is the lighting bright and even?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, even overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048681121319532394 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486810207366943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048681121319532394, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048681121319532394, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2005891650915146, + 0.12790845334529877, + 0.19724015891551971, + 0.04537546634674072, + 0.06127408891916275, + 0.062377892434597015, + 0.07853203266859055, + 0.05179092660546303, + 0.10363110154867172, + 0.07128073275089264 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048681121319532394 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, high-angle view of a kitchen countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are clean, capable hands visible performing a methodical task on a warm-toned wooden countertop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the right hand grasp a black plastic handle of a polished stainless steel kettle and tilt it to release steam into a translucent bucket of flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the hands subsequently place a metal fork on the lid, lift the bucket out of sight, and is the lighting bright and even?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, even overhead lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036165802739560604 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628616809844971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036165802739560604, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036165802739560604, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1060764417052269, + 0.030429238453507423, + 0.11266294866800308, + 0.4523690938949585, + 0.030787521973252296, + 0.0491095595061779, + 0.04729645699262619, + 0.051392219960689545, + 0.06778208166360855, + 0.05209444463253021 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036165802739560604 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_8/index_tensor([663, 663])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_8/index_tensor([663, 663])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..50518af3ecfc8c722e15b9fa82c5d04fd23d6452 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_8/index_tensor([663, 663])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "smooth, right-facing medium shot follows a woman dressed in ornate, classical Chinese clothing. Her hair is styled in an intricate, ancient bun, and a white jade hairpin carved with a phoenix pattern is placed diagonally in her hair. Its delicate pearl tassels dangle gently with her movements. She wears a chest-length ruqun (a skirt) in pale pink and moon-white. The wide silk cuffs are delicately embroidered with pale gold peach blossoms, and the fabric shimmers softly in the breeze. With a light, almost dance-like movement, she moves slowly around an ancient, blossoming peach tree, her bare feet treading the lush grass, each step effortless and graceful. The tree's sturdy, twisted branches are adorned with layers of pink petals. The warm, golden afternoon sunlight filters through the blossoms, casting soft, dappled shadows on her fair face and flowing skirt. There is a peaceful and contented smile on her face, her eyes sometimes gazing at the delicate flowers, sometimes lowering their eyes in thought. The whole scene is shrouded in a tranquil, poetic and dreamy atmosphere. The picture is painted in warm tones, full of classical oriental beauty.", + "seed": 25957, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_8/index_663_seed_25957_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.01485974844545126, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01485974844545126, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01485974844545126, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing ornate, classical Chinese clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white jade hairpin with a phoenix pattern and pearl tassels visible in her hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale pink and moon-white chest-length ruqun with wide silk cuffs embroidered with pale gold peach blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman moving slowly around an ancient, blossoming peach tree with bare feet on lush grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight filtering through blossoms to create dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008188367821276188 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.883188247680664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008188367821276188, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008188367821276188, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22938096523284912, + 0.09561456739902496, + 0.08787568658590317, + 0.03238081559538841, + 0.14323586225509644, + 0.092272087931633, + 0.08873241394758224, + 0.050283800810575485, + 0.05670328438282013, + 0.12352053076028824 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008188367821276188 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing ornate, classical Chinese clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white jade hairpin with a phoenix pattern and pearl tassels visible in her hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale pink and moon-white chest-length ruqun with wide silk cuffs embroidered with pale gold peach blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman moving slowly around an ancient, blossoming peach tree with bare feet on lush grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight filtering through blossoms to create dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0160874892026186 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141087532043457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0160874892026186, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0160874892026186, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19054347276687622, + 0.09780319780111313, + 0.10373856127262115, + 0.05497780814766884, + 0.053965840488672256, + 0.07507195323705673, + 0.2374361753463745, + 0.04323998838663101, + 0.08495373278856277, + 0.05826926603913307 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0160874892026186 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing ornate, classical Chinese clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white jade hairpin with a phoenix pattern and pearl tassels visible in her hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale pink and moon-white chest-length ruqun with wide silk cuffs embroidered with pale gold peach blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman moving slowly around an ancient, blossoming peach tree with bare feet on lush grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight filtering through blossoms to create dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014203761704266071 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2642035484313965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014203761704266071, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014203761704266071, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2502870261669159, + 0.17032764852046967, + 0.051786039024591446, + 0.06043493375182152, + 0.10251782089471817, + 0.10503418743610382, + 0.09774097800254822, + 0.042790211737155914, + 0.07390651851892471, + 0.04517465457320213 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014203761704266071 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing ornate, classical Chinese clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white jade hairpin with a phoenix pattern and pearl tassels visible in her hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale pink and moon-white chest-length ruqun with wide silk cuffs embroidered with pale gold peach blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman moving slowly around an ancient, blossoming peach tree with bare feet on lush grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight filtering through blossoms to create dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012535941787064075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38753604888916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012535941787064075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012535941787064075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09992718696594238, + 0.15461233258247375, + 0.11743233352899551, + 0.024004705250263214, + 0.06260322034358978, + 0.35972943902015686, + 0.10706078261137009, + 0.019914478063583374, + 0.018037419766187668, + 0.036678068339824677 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012535941787064075 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing ornate, classical Chinese clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white jade hairpin with a phoenix pattern and pearl tassels visible in her hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale pink and moon-white chest-length ruqun with wide silk cuffs embroidered with pale gold peach blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman moving slowly around an ancient, blossoming peach tree with bare feet on lush grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight filtering through blossoms to create dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023283181712031364 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732832431793213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023283181712031364, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023283181712031364, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2955304980278015, + 0.10879302769899368, + 0.20884402096271515, + 0.027233751490712166, + 0.060207296162843704, + 0.11331619322299957, + 0.09544189274311066, + 0.041585229337215424, + 0.0235951766371727, + 0.025452902540564537 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023283181712031364 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "smooth, right-facing medium shot follows a woman dressed in ornate, classical Chinese clothing. Her hair is styled in an intricate, ancient bun, and a white jade hairpin carved with a phoenix pattern is placed diagonally in her hair. Its delicate pearl tassels dangle gently with her movements. She wears a chest-length ruqun (a skirt) in pale pink and moon-white. The wide silk cuffs are delicately embroidered with pale gold peach blossoms, and the fabric shimmers softly in the breeze. With a light, almost dance-like movement, she moves slowly around an ancient, blossoming peach tree, her bare feet treading the lush grass, each step effortless and graceful. The tree's sturdy, twisted branches are adorned with layers of pink petals. The warm, golden afternoon sunlight filters through the blossoms, casting soft, dappled shadows on her fair face and flowing skirt. There is a peaceful and contented smile on her face, her eyes sometimes gazing at the delicate flowers, sometimes lowering their eyes in thought. The whole scene is shrouded in a tranquil, poetic and dreamy atmosphere. The picture is painted in warm tones, full of classical oriental beauty.", + "seed": 25958, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_8/index_663_seed_25958_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.008812261465936898, + "vlm_logprob": -0.008812261465936898, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.008812261465936898, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing ornate, classical Chinese clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white jade hairpin with a phoenix pattern and pearl tassels visible in her hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale pink and moon-white chest-length ruqun with wide silk cuffs embroidered with pale gold peach blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman moving slowly around an ancient, blossoming peach tree with bare feet on lush grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight filtering through blossoms to create dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004434632603079081 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504434585571289 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004434632603079081, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004434632603079081, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22377128899097443, + 0.07170591503381729, + 0.05916731059551239, + 0.03780893236398697, + 0.08281949907541275, + 0.12977860867977142, + 0.10788829624652863, + 0.05252547189593315, + 0.05512034520506859, + 0.179414302110672 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004434632603079081 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing ornate, classical Chinese clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white jade hairpin with a phoenix pattern and pearl tassels visible in her hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale pink and moon-white chest-length ruqun with wide silk cuffs embroidered with pale gold peach blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman moving slowly around an ancient, blossoming peach tree with bare feet on lush grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight filtering through blossoms to create dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012557956390082836 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875579833984375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012557956390082836, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012557956390082836, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3138149380683899, + 0.1015913113951683, + 0.03982012718915939, + 0.028988130390644073, + 0.04745993763208389, + 0.08308840543031693, + 0.057897381484508514, + 0.04020054638385773, + 0.02876916341483593, + 0.2583700120449066 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012557956390082836 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing ornate, classical Chinese clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white jade hairpin with a phoenix pattern and pearl tassels visible in her hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale pink and moon-white chest-length ruqun with wide silk cuffs embroidered with pale gold peach blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman moving slowly around an ancient, blossoming peach tree with bare feet on lush grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight filtering through blossoms to create dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008651750162243843 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586517333984375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008651750162243843, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008651750162243843, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19558463990688324, + 0.05964948982000351, + 0.06413590162992477, + 0.04791732504963875, + 0.10377396643161774, + 0.10593198239803314, + 0.06213318556547165, + 0.03922557085752487, + 0.06260780245065689, + 0.25904014706611633 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008651750162243843 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing ornate, classical Chinese clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white jade hairpin with a phoenix pattern and pearl tassels visible in her hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale pink and moon-white chest-length ruqun with wide silk cuffs embroidered with pale gold peach blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman moving slowly around an ancient, blossoming peach tree with bare feet on lush grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight filtering through blossoms to create dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008637921884655952 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75863790512085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008637921884655952, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008637921884655952, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1779707968235016, + 0.16579900681972504, + 0.04287685081362724, + 0.04358680546283722, + 0.1535276621580124, + 0.07177924364805222, + 0.06692563742399216, + 0.09315159171819687, + 0.056007448583841324, + 0.12837496399879456 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008637921884655952 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing ornate, classical Chinese clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white jade hairpin with a phoenix pattern and pearl tassels visible in her hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale pink and moon-white chest-length ruqun with wide silk cuffs embroidered with pale gold peach blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman moving slowly around an ancient, blossoming peach tree with bare feet on lush grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight filtering through blossoms to create dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009779046289622784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63477897644043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009779046289622784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009779046289622784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13233673572540283, + 0.13172227144241333, + 0.03925735503435135, + 0.03384082764387131, + 0.06408706307411194, + 0.14976151287555695, + 0.1200578585267067, + 0.09617779403924942, + 0.06749840825796127, + 0.1652601808309555 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009779046289622784 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "smooth, right-facing medium shot follows a woman dressed in ornate, classical Chinese clothing. Her hair is styled in an intricate, ancient bun, and a white jade hairpin carved with a phoenix pattern is placed diagonally in her hair. Its delicate pearl tassels dangle gently with her movements. She wears a chest-length ruqun (a skirt) in pale pink and moon-white. The wide silk cuffs are delicately embroidered with pale gold peach blossoms, and the fabric shimmers softly in the breeze. With a light, almost dance-like movement, she moves slowly around an ancient, blossoming peach tree, her bare feet treading the lush grass, each step effortless and graceful. The tree's sturdy, twisted branches are adorned with layers of pink petals. The warm, golden afternoon sunlight filters through the blossoms, casting soft, dappled shadows on her fair face and flowing skirt. There is a peaceful and contented smile on her face, her eyes sometimes gazing at the delicate flowers, sometimes lowering their eyes in thought. The whole scene is shrouded in a tranquil, poetic and dreamy atmosphere. The picture is painted in warm tones, full of classical oriental beauty.", + "seed": 25959, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_8/index_663_seed_25959_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.010698482394218445, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010698482394218445, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010698482394218445, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing ornate, classical Chinese clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white jade hairpin with a phoenix pattern and pearl tassels visible in her hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale pink and moon-white chest-length ruqun with wide silk cuffs embroidered with pale gold peach blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman moving slowly around an ancient, blossoming peach tree with bare feet on lush grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight filtering through blossoms to create dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004398315213620663 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504398345947266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004398315213620663, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004398315213620663, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16410106420516968, + 0.05909885838627815, + 0.028616540133953094, + 0.016018813475966454, + 0.0715147852897644, + 0.0453072264790535, + 0.041161198168992996, + 0.0443129800260067, + 0.11606981605291367, + 0.4137987196445465 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004398315213620663 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing ornate, classical Chinese clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white jade hairpin with a phoenix pattern and pearl tassels visible in her hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale pink and moon-white chest-length ruqun with wide silk cuffs embroidered with pale gold peach blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman moving slowly around an ancient, blossoming peach tree with bare feet on lush grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight filtering through blossoms to create dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020604845136404037 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956048488616943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020604845136404037, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020604845136404037, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12238616496324539, + 0.08481281250715256, + 0.014263603836297989, + 0.026703419163823128, + 0.02608617953956127, + 0.014396973885595798, + 0.018283212557435036, + 0.1172088086605072, + 0.16310782730579376, + 0.41275104880332947 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020604845136404037 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing ornate, classical Chinese clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white jade hairpin with a phoenix pattern and pearl tassels visible in her hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale pink and moon-white chest-length ruqun with wide silk cuffs embroidered with pale gold peach blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman moving slowly around an ancient, blossoming peach tree with bare feet on lush grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight filtering through blossoms to create dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007637940347194672 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882637977600098 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007637940347194672, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007637940347194672, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11767694354057312, + 0.09851375222206116, + 0.026079289615154266, + 0.03848665580153465, + 0.1355888545513153, + 0.02758498676121235, + 0.02541806362569332, + 0.061460088938474655, + 0.13289277255535126, + 0.33629855513572693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007637940347194672 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing ornate, classical Chinese clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white jade hairpin with a phoenix pattern and pearl tassels visible in her hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale pink and moon-white chest-length ruqun with wide silk cuffs embroidered with pale gold peach blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman moving slowly around an ancient, blossoming peach tree with bare feet on lush grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight filtering through blossoms to create dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107332669198513 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511073112487793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107332669198513, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107332669198513, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08588039129972458, + 0.09201247245073318, + 0.046962711960077286, + 0.029174963012337685, + 0.042369987815618515, + 0.04534952715039253, + 0.03835223242640495, + 0.054559770971536636, + 0.11497202515602112, + 0.45036596059799194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107332669198513 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing ornate, classical Chinese clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white jade hairpin with a phoenix pattern and pearl tassels visible in her hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale pink and moon-white chest-length ruqun with wide silk cuffs embroidered with pale gold peach blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman moving slowly around an ancient, blossoming peach tree with bare feet on lush grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight filtering through blossoms to create dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009777984581887722 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634778022766113 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009777984581887722, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009777984581887722, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10437952727079391, + 0.12483344972133636, + 0.03617745637893677, + 0.07968177646398544, + 0.024438854306936264, + 0.024792831391096115, + 0.03729652613401413, + 0.05036703124642372, + 0.17649349570274353, + 0.34153908491134644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009777984581887722 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "smooth, right-facing medium shot follows a woman dressed in ornate, classical Chinese clothing. Her hair is styled in an intricate, ancient bun, and a white jade hairpin carved with a phoenix pattern is placed diagonally in her hair. Its delicate pearl tassels dangle gently with her movements. She wears a chest-length ruqun (a skirt) in pale pink and moon-white. The wide silk cuffs are delicately embroidered with pale gold peach blossoms, and the fabric shimmers softly in the breeze. With a light, almost dance-like movement, she moves slowly around an ancient, blossoming peach tree, her bare feet treading the lush grass, each step effortless and graceful. The tree's sturdy, twisted branches are adorned with layers of pink petals. The warm, golden afternoon sunlight filters through the blossoms, casting soft, dappled shadows on her fair face and flowing skirt. There is a peaceful and contented smile on her face, her eyes sometimes gazing at the delicate flowers, sometimes lowering their eyes in thought. The whole scene is shrouded in a tranquil, poetic and dreamy atmosphere. The picture is painted in warm tones, full of classical oriental beauty.", + "seed": 25960, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_8/index_663_seed_25960_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.006101108528673649, + "vlm_logprob": -0.006101108528673649, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.006101108528673649, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing ornate, classical Chinese clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white jade hairpin with a phoenix pattern and pearl tassels visible in her hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale pink and moon-white chest-length ruqun with wide silk cuffs embroidered with pale gold peach blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman moving slowly around an ancient, blossoming peach tree with bare feet on lush grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight filtering through blossoms to create dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0056017800234258175 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.25560188293457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0056017800234258175, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0056017800234258175, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11841589957475662, + 0.05976858362555504, + 0.09233209490776062, + 0.047468896955251694, + 0.10036645084619522, + 0.057960763573646545, + 0.05736127495765686, + 0.09116871654987335, + 0.29792073369026184, + 0.0772365927696228 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0056017800234258175 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing ornate, classical Chinese clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white jade hairpin with a phoenix pattern and pearl tassels visible in her hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale pink and moon-white chest-length ruqun with wide silk cuffs embroidered with pale gold peach blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman moving slowly around an ancient, blossoming peach tree with bare feet on lush grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight filtering through blossoms to create dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006755726411938667 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006755828857422 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006755726411938667, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006755726411938667, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13305410742759705, + 0.06604481488466263, + 0.13898037374019623, + 0.06145867705345154, + 0.21266792714595795, + 0.06075017899274826, + 0.033163994550704956, + 0.050610702484846115, + 0.16237513720989227, + 0.08089408278465271 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006755726411938667 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing ornate, classical Chinese clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white jade hairpin with a phoenix pattern and pearl tassels visible in her hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale pink and moon-white chest-length ruqun with wide silk cuffs embroidered with pale gold peach blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman moving slowly around an ancient, blossoming peach tree with bare feet on lush grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight filtering through blossoms to create dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005263637285679579 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255263805389404 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005263637285679579, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005263637285679579, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1176050677895546, + 0.0837133526802063, + 0.14582878351211548, + 0.07647141814231873, + 0.07394479215145111, + 0.030457384884357452, + 0.062213458120822906, + 0.051265981048345566, + 0.2614399492740631, + 0.09705978631973267 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005263637285679579 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing ornate, classical Chinese clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white jade hairpin with a phoenix pattern and pearl tassels visible in her hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale pink and moon-white chest-length ruqun with wide silk cuffs embroidered with pale gold peach blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman moving slowly around an ancient, blossoming peach tree with bare feet on lush grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight filtering through blossoms to create dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007631197106093168 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882631301879883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007631197106093168, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007631197106093168, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06690656393766403, + 0.05140331760048866, + 0.1437390148639679, + 0.055083464831113815, + 0.41668501496315, + 0.027695421129465103, + 0.028779227286577225, + 0.03549697995185852, + 0.08003290742635727, + 0.09417811036109924 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007631197106093168 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a woman wearing ornate, classical Chinese clothing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white jade hairpin with a phoenix pattern and pearl tassels visible in her hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a pale pink and moon-white chest-length ruqun with wide silk cuffs embroidered with pale gold peach blossoms?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman moving slowly around an ancient, blossoming peach tree with bare feet on lush grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by warm, golden afternoon sunlight filtering through blossoms to create dappled shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005253201816231012 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255253314971924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005253201816231012, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005253201816231012, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09514228999614716, + 0.03467360883951187, + 0.036160025745630264, + 0.07388428598642349, + 0.12441039085388184, + 0.08642219007015228, + 0.02529411017894745, + 0.05233244225382805, + 0.2062251716852188, + 0.26545554399490356 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005253201816231012 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_9/index_tensor([2584, 2584])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_9/index_tensor([2584, 2584])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bad448c7c2f212c2757349164cdd6a11db11677b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_9/index_tensor([2584, 2584])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "wide, panoramic shot, the camera slowly tilting downward and zooming out, reveals a diver sinking gently into a deep, almost inky blue ocean. Clad in a sleek black diving suit and strapped to a silver oxygen tank, the diver's exhaled bubbles rise in a steady, rhythmic stream as his body unfurls, descending with a near-weightless grace. He is gently enveloped by a vast swarm of thousands of nearly transparent, bioluminescent jellyfish. Like floating ghostly lanterns, these jellyfish pulse rhythmically with the ocean currents, their translucent, bell-shaped bodies emitting a soft, biological, cool blue-green glow. This shifting light illuminates the diver's mask and body, casting a constantly shifting, dynamic play of light and shadow across the murky water. The swarm drifts gently past him, creating an immersive, enveloping feeling. The faint light from the sky filtering through the sea creates a hazy halo above, interwoven with the cold light of the jellyfish, creating an otherworldly atmosphere of tranquility and fantasy, filled with awe for the wonders of the deep sea.", + "seed": 6272, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_9/index_2584_seed_6272_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.13676156774163245, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13676156774163245, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13676156774163245, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep, inky blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a diver wearing a sleek black diving suit and strapped to a silver oxygen tank visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of nearly transparent, bioluminescent jellyfish surrounding the diver?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and zoom out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the diver sinking gently while bubbles rise in a steady, rhythmic stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.036485325545072556 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.411485433578491 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.036485325545072556, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.036485325545072556, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15309420228004456, + 0.07216806709766388, + 0.0978519394993782, + 0.052050404250621796, + 0.2938811182975769, + 0.10038039088249207, + 0.02281293086707592, + 0.05618507042527199, + 0.040228985249996185, + 0.11134686321020126 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.036485325545072556 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep, inky blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a diver wearing a sleek black diving suit and strapped to a silver oxygen tank visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of nearly transparent, bioluminescent jellyfish surrounding the diver?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and zoom out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the diver sinking gently while bubbles rise in a steady, rhythmic stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033717233687639236 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408717155456543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033717233687639236, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033717233687639236, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11534330248832703, + 0.09062393754720688, + 0.08239101618528366, + 0.039565250277519226, + 0.03246302530169487, + 0.08850658684968948, + 0.08411639928817749, + 0.1692061424255371, + 0.1292337328195572, + 0.16855059564113617 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033717233687639236 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep, inky blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a diver wearing a sleek black diving suit and strapped to a silver oxygen tank visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of nearly transparent, bioluminescent jellyfish surrounding the diver?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and zoom out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the diver sinking gently while bubbles rise in a steady, rhythmic stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023292383179068565 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773292303085327 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023292383179068565, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023292383179068565, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08838682621717453, + 0.02583891898393631, + 0.08917198330163956, + 0.1523677408695221, + 0.1642409861087799, + 0.30346012115478516, + 0.023267848417162895, + 0.04513588920235634, + 0.048959147185087204, + 0.05917053669691086 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023292383179068565 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep, inky blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a diver wearing a sleek black diving suit and strapped to a silver oxygen tank visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of nearly transparent, bioluminescent jellyfish surrounding the diver?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and zoom out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the diver sinking gently while bubbles rise in a steady, rhythmic stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761148929595947 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261148929595947 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761148929595947, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761148929595947, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12386354804039001, + 0.047553665935993195, + 0.14724422991275787, + 0.16403897106647491, + 0.31559163331985474, + 0.055583517998456955, + 0.05892159789800644, + 0.026197701692581177, + 0.03437439352273941, + 0.026630623266100883 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761148929595947 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep, inky blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a diver wearing a sleek black diving suit and strapped to a silver oxygen tank visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of nearly transparent, bioluminescent jellyfish surrounding the diver?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and zoom out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the diver sinking gently while bubbles rise in a steady, rhythmic stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014198003336787224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264197826385498 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014198003336787224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014198003336787224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06774480640888214, + 0.06256375461816788, + 0.06960418820381165, + 0.14603087306022644, + 0.1284836083650589, + 0.220063716173172, + 0.042607687413692474, + 0.15191751718521118, + 0.06753762811422348, + 0.04344620555639267 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014198003336787224 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, panoramic shot, the camera slowly tilting downward and zooming out, reveals a diver sinking gently into a deep, almost inky blue ocean. Clad in a sleek black diving suit and strapped to a silver oxygen tank, the diver's exhaled bubbles rise in a steady, rhythmic stream as his body unfurls, descending with a near-weightless grace. He is gently enveloped by a vast swarm of thousands of nearly transparent, bioluminescent jellyfish. Like floating ghostly lanterns, these jellyfish pulse rhythmically with the ocean currents, their translucent, bell-shaped bodies emitting a soft, biological, cool blue-green glow. This shifting light illuminates the diver's mask and body, casting a constantly shifting, dynamic play of light and shadow across the murky water. The swarm drifts gently past him, creating an immersive, enveloping feeling. The faint light from the sky filtering through the sea creates a hazy halo above, interwoven with the cold light of the jellyfish, creating an otherworldly atmosphere of tranquility and fantasy, filled with awe for the wonders of the deep sea.", + "seed": 6273, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_9/index_2584_seed_6273_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.15252767521888017, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15252767521888017, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.2749999523162843, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15252767521888017, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep, inky blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a diver wearing a sleek black diving suit and strapped to a silver oxygen tank visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of nearly transparent, bioluminescent jellyfish surrounding the diver?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and zoom out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the diver sinking gently while bubbles rise in a steady, rhythmic stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020377103239297867 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.020377159118652 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020377103239297867, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020377103239297867, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1370978057384491, + 0.02060878835618496, + 0.04340935871005058, + 0.044183388352394104, + 0.08390215784311295, + 0.039331741631031036, + 0.018860621377825737, + 0.11044372618198395, + 0.3655323088169098, + 0.13663019239902496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020377103239297867 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep, inky blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a diver wearing a sleek black diving suit and strapped to a silver oxygen tank visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of nearly transparent, bioluminescent jellyfish surrounding the diver?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and zoom out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the diver sinking gently while bubbles rise in a steady, rhythmic stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018207672983407974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018207550048828 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018207672983407974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018207672983407974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12225242704153061, + 0.02250080183148384, + 0.020698627457022667, + 0.013016490265727043, + 0.056657250970602036, + 0.05593143031001091, + 0.030965765938162804, + 0.10437136888504028, + 0.5632151365280151, + 0.01039066631346941 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018207672983407974 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep, inky blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a diver wearing a sleek black diving suit and strapped to a silver oxygen tank visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of nearly transparent, bioluminescent jellyfish surrounding the diver?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and zoom out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the diver sinking gently while bubbles rise in a steady, rhythmic stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012543593533337116 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387543678283691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012543593533337116, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012543593533337116, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12845230102539062, + 0.04981023818254471, + 0.06927473843097687, + 0.04692354425787926, + 0.3038861155509949, + 0.02563278190791607, + 0.10252829641103745, + 0.12985706329345703, + 0.07726200670003891, + 0.06637292355298996 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012543593533337116 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep, inky blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a diver wearing a sleek black diving suit and strapped to a silver oxygen tank visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of nearly transparent, bioluminescent jellyfish surrounding the diver?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and zoom out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the diver sinking gently while bubbles rise in a steady, rhythmic stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933186054229736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933186054229736 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6933186054229736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6933186054229736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21330761909484863, + 0.10368865728378296, + 0.04202332720160484, + 0.08807659149169922, + 0.07544566690921783, + 0.06145579740405083, + 0.06545472890138626, + 0.08872611075639725, + 0.15542809665203094, + 0.10639342665672302 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6933186054229736 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep, inky blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a diver wearing a sleek black diving suit and strapped to a silver oxygen tank visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of nearly transparent, bioluminescent jellyfish surrounding the diver?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and zoom out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the diver sinking gently while bubbles rise in a steady, rhythmic stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018191400915384293 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018191337585449 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018191400915384293, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018191400915384293, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1365664303302765, + 0.0931578055024147, + 0.06178360804915428, + 0.049425575882196426, + 0.05253807455301285, + 0.05351927503943443, + 0.040390096604824066, + 0.05695212259888649, + 0.4305489957332611, + 0.025117985904216766 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018191400915384293 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, panoramic shot, the camera slowly tilting downward and zooming out, reveals a diver sinking gently into a deep, almost inky blue ocean. Clad in a sleek black diving suit and strapped to a silver oxygen tank, the diver's exhaled bubbles rise in a steady, rhythmic stream as his body unfurls, descending with a near-weightless grace. He is gently enveloped by a vast swarm of thousands of nearly transparent, bioluminescent jellyfish. Like floating ghostly lanterns, these jellyfish pulse rhythmically with the ocean currents, their translucent, bell-shaped bodies emitting a soft, biological, cool blue-green glow. This shifting light illuminates the diver's mask and body, casting a constantly shifting, dynamic play of light and shadow across the murky water. The swarm drifts gently past him, creating an immersive, enveloping feeling. The faint light from the sky filtering through the sea creates a hazy halo above, interwoven with the cold light of the jellyfish, creating an otherworldly atmosphere of tranquility and fantasy, filled with awe for the wonders of the deep sea.", + "seed": 6274, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_9/index_2584_seed_6274_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.07284709811210632, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07284709811210632, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07284709811210632, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep, inky blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a diver wearing a sleek black diving suit and strapped to a silver oxygen tank visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of nearly transparent, bioluminescent jellyfish surrounding the diver?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and zoom out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the diver sinking gently while bubbles rise in a steady, rhythmic stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.017799992114305496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2677998542785645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.017799992114305496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.017799992114305496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17655767500400543, + 0.14695297181606293, + 0.09180382639169693, + 0.09043585509061813, + 0.02807638794183731, + 0.022295933216810226, + 0.04873405024409294, + 0.033570192754268646, + 0.11197490990161896, + 0.24959821999073029 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.017799992114305496 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep, inky blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a diver wearing a sleek black diving suit and strapped to a silver oxygen tank visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of nearly transparent, bioluminescent jellyfish surrounding the diver?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and zoom out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the diver sinking gently while bubbles rise in a steady, rhythmic stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02637173980474472 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651371717453003 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02637173980474472, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02637173980474472, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07333490252494812, + 0.06169230490922928, + 0.08074136823415756, + 0.09836145490407944, + 0.009753778576850891, + 0.02799239568412304, + 0.07560598850250244, + 0.11416526138782501, + 0.3966757655143738, + 0.06167677789926529 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02637173980474472 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep, inky blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a diver wearing a sleek black diving suit and strapped to a silver oxygen tank visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of nearly transparent, bioluminescent jellyfish surrounding the diver?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and zoom out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the diver sinking gently while bubbles rise in a steady, rhythmic stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018193624913692474 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01819372177124 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018193624913692474, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018193624913692474, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08207310736179352, + 0.12530146539211273, + 0.022645315155386925, + 0.053069911897182465, + 0.04169072210788727, + 0.039636120200157166, + 0.1614600569009781, + 0.06724531203508377, + 0.1307644098997116, + 0.2761135697364807 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018193624913692474 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep, inky blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a diver wearing a sleek black diving suit and strapped to a silver oxygen tank visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of nearly transparent, bioluminescent jellyfish surrounding the diver?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and zoom out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the diver sinking gently while bubbles rise in a steady, rhythmic stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28128957748413086 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4062895774841309 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28128957748413086, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28128957748413086, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17395898699760437, + 0.08629581332206726, + 0.093549445271492, + 0.10530873388051987, + 0.0641583502292633, + 0.03404812142252922, + 0.044029347598552704, + 0.03828248009085655, + 0.09051066637039185, + 0.26985806226730347 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28128957748413086 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep, inky blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a diver wearing a sleek black diving suit and strapped to a silver oxygen tank visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of nearly transparent, bioluminescent jellyfish surrounding the diver?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and zoom out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the diver sinking gently while bubbles rise in a steady, rhythmic stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020580556243658066 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895580530166626 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020580556243658066, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020580556243658066, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16220159828662872, + 0.10535679757595062, + 0.1062474325299263, + 0.03696127608418465, + 0.03848925977945328, + 0.02356846071779728, + 0.04833874851465225, + 0.021547473967075348, + 0.07826308161020279, + 0.37902578711509705 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020580556243658066 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, panoramic shot, the camera slowly tilting downward and zooming out, reveals a diver sinking gently into a deep, almost inky blue ocean. Clad in a sleek black diving suit and strapped to a silver oxygen tank, the diver's exhaled bubbles rise in a steady, rhythmic stream as his body unfurls, descending with a near-weightless grace. He is gently enveloped by a vast swarm of thousands of nearly transparent, bioluminescent jellyfish. Like floating ghostly lanterns, these jellyfish pulse rhythmically with the ocean currents, their translucent, bell-shaped bodies emitting a soft, biological, cool blue-green glow. This shifting light illuminates the diver's mask and body, casting a constantly shifting, dynamic play of light and shadow across the murky water. The swarm drifts gently past him, creating an immersive, enveloping feeling. The faint light from the sky filtering through the sea creates a hazy halo above, interwoven with the cold light of the jellyfish, creating an otherworldly atmosphere of tranquility and fantasy, filled with awe for the wonders of the deep sea.", + "seed": 6275, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000175/group_9/index_2584_seed_6275_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2318621478974819, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2318621478974819, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.950000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2318621478974819, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep, inky blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a diver wearing a sleek black diving suit and strapped to a silver oxygen tank visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of nearly transparent, bioluminescent jellyfish surrounding the diver?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and zoom out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the diver sinking gently while bubbles rise in a steady, rhythmic stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05809812247753143 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.933098077774048 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05809812247753143, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05809812247753143, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20019666850566864, + 0.16202235221862793, + 0.20713414251804352, + 0.08178496360778809, + 0.09851424396038055, + 0.0376407690346241, + 0.042730893939733505, + 0.02814454212784767, + 0.11118112504482269, + 0.030650300905108452 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05809812247753143 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep, inky blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a diver wearing a sleek black diving suit and strapped to a silver oxygen tank visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of nearly transparent, bioluminescent jellyfish surrounding the diver?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and zoom out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the diver sinking gently while bubbles rise in a steady, rhythmic stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014218335039913654 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264218330383301 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014218335039913654, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014218335039913654, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1085374653339386, + 0.050244759768247604, + 0.09776023030281067, + 0.07029582560062408, + 0.19477660953998566, + 0.06407902389764786, + 0.1129363551735878, + 0.09183007478713989, + 0.056966062635183334, + 0.1525735855102539 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014218335039913654 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep, inky blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a diver wearing a sleek black diving suit and strapped to a silver oxygen tank visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of nearly transparent, bioluminescent jellyfish surrounding the diver?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and zoom out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the diver sinking gently while bubbles rise in a steady, rhythmic stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0125422989949584 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387542247772217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0125422989949584, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0125422989949584, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.118413046002388, + 0.11721835285425186, + 0.11185841262340546, + 0.17016427218914032, + 0.17423580586910248, + 0.20861265063285828, + 0.02418007142841816, + 0.025948582217097282, + 0.02762649394571781, + 0.021742314100265503 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0125422989949584 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep, inky blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a diver wearing a sleek black diving suit and strapped to a silver oxygen tank visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of nearly transparent, bioluminescent jellyfish surrounding the diver?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and zoom out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the diver sinking gently while bubbles rise in a steady, rhythmic stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0538616180419922 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42886167764663696 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0538616180419922, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.6249999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0538616180419922, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08430290967226028, + 0.06079449877142906, + 0.1921856850385666, + 0.07468856126070023, + 0.12214946001768112, + 0.17305006086826324, + 0.030905647203326225, + 0.04041595011949539, + 0.03382130712270737, + 0.18768595159053802 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0538616180419922 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep, inky blue ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a diver wearing a sleek black diving suit and strapped to a silver oxygen tank visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of nearly transparent, bioluminescent jellyfish surrounding the diver?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and zoom out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the diver sinking gently while bubbles rise in a steady, rhythmic stream?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020590364933013916 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895590305328369 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020590364933013916, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020590364933013916, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09295292943716049, + 0.042858392000198364, + 0.2119830846786499, + 0.05889621376991272, + 0.2260557860136032, + 0.10758790373802185, + 0.1001506894826889, + 0.03977072238922119, + 0.08006024360656738, + 0.03968406468629837 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020590364933013916 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_0/index_tensor([8420, 8420])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_0/index_tensor([8420, 8420])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f03e3ebb59295b0b650923941566c5890a32ac30 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_0/index_tensor([8420, 8420])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slowly advancing shot, shot from a level angle, begins as a medium shot and eventually settles into a close-up. The entire image, rendered in the texture of a high-contrast black-and-white film, depicts a young woman in a simple white dress standing alone in a vast, snow-covered wilderness on a dark, snow-covered night. The cold moonlight, the sole source of light, penetrates the sparse clouds, gilding the dense, heavy snowfall with a silvery edge and casting soft, three-dimensional shadows on her fair skin and the plain hem of her dress. Initially, she lowers her head, her long, black hair, a few strands wet with tears, clinging to her cheeks. Her shoulders tremble slightly from suppressed sobs, tears silently streaming down her cold face, creating an atmosphere of profound loneliness and sorrow. As the camera approached her very slowly, she slowly raised her head and closed her eyes, as if taking a deep breath of cold air. When she opened her eyes again, all the sadness had dissipated, replaced by a frank and relieved smile quietly blooming on her lips. This smile carried a hint of indifference that came from seeing through the world, and together with the snowflakes flying in the sky, it formed a quiet, poetic and beautiful picture.", + "seed": 11922, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_0/index_8420_seed_11922_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.020387079939246176, + "vlm_logprob": -0.020387079939246176, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.020387079939246176, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast black-and-white film texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, snow-covered wilderness at night with snow falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as a medium shot and slowly transition to a close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower her head with wet tears on her face, then raise her head and close her eyes before opening them with a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cold moonlight penetrating sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011249448172748089 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.886249542236328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011249448172748089, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011249448172748089, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25924956798553467, + 0.043397001922130585, + 0.06542595475912094, + 0.0847901701927185, + 0.1724870204925537, + 0.08376146107912064, + 0.0533793568611145, + 0.051517970860004425, + 0.12059718370437622, + 0.06539423018693924 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011249448172748089 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast black-and-white film texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, snow-covered wilderness at night with snow falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as a medium shot and slowly transition to a close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower her head with wet tears on her face, then raise her head and close her eyes before opening them with a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cold moonlight penetrating sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004648949019610882 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.3796491622924805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004648949019610882, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004648949019610882, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.126632958650589, + 0.06965992599725723, + 0.1370207667350769, + 0.05952855199575424, + 0.2089938074350357, + 0.13748933374881744, + 0.07133202999830246, + 0.04631105065345764, + 0.10273933410644531, + 0.04029223695397377 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004648949019610882 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast black-and-white film texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, snow-covered wilderness at night with snow falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as a medium shot and slowly transition to a close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower her head with wet tears on her face, then raise her head and close her eyes before opening them with a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cold moonlight penetrating sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014202586375176907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26420259475708 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014202586375176907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014202586375176907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09211874008178711, + 0.060425691306591034, + 0.17835983633995056, + 0.08751098811626434, + 0.17208172380924225, + 0.13198773562908173, + 0.13091285526752472, + 0.07303915917873383, + 0.057452477514743805, + 0.016110802069306374 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014202586375176907 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast black-and-white film texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, snow-covered wilderness at night with snow falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as a medium shot and slowly transition to a close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower her head with wet tears on her face, then raise her head and close her eyes before opening them with a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cold moonlight penetrating sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204604357481003 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120460510253906 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204604357481003, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204604357481003, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11299149692058563, + 0.05193537101149559, + 0.07781801372766495, + 0.05062687024474144, + 0.18457135558128357, + 0.055955857038497925, + 0.08199028670787811, + 0.27360859513282776, + 0.06737899780273438, + 0.04312308877706528 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204604357481003 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast black-and-white film texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, snow-covered wilderness at night with snow falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as a medium shot and slowly transition to a close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower her head with wet tears on her face, then raise her head and close her eyes before opening them with a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cold moonlight penetrating sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009788372553884983 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634788513183594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009788372553884983, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009788372553884983, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07312069833278656, + 0.06739544868469238, + 0.07625461369752884, + 0.05060464143753052, + 0.30746474862098694, + 0.11929537355899811, + 0.0858258605003357, + 0.06719997525215149, + 0.08299434185028076, + 0.0698443278670311 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009788372553884983 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly advancing shot, shot from a level angle, begins as a medium shot and eventually settles into a close-up. The entire image, rendered in the texture of a high-contrast black-and-white film, depicts a young woman in a simple white dress standing alone in a vast, snow-covered wilderness on a dark, snow-covered night. The cold moonlight, the sole source of light, penetrates the sparse clouds, gilding the dense, heavy snowfall with a silvery edge and casting soft, three-dimensional shadows on her fair skin and the plain hem of her dress. Initially, she lowers her head, her long, black hair, a few strands wet with tears, clinging to her cheeks. Her shoulders tremble slightly from suppressed sobs, tears silently streaming down her cold face, creating an atmosphere of profound loneliness and sorrow. As the camera approached her very slowly, she slowly raised her head and closed her eyes, as if taking a deep breath of cold air. When she opened her eyes again, all the sadness had dissipated, replaced by a frank and relieved smile quietly blooming on her lips. This smile carried a hint of indifference that came from seeing through the world, and together with the snowflakes flying in the sky, it formed a quiet, poetic and beautiful picture.", + "seed": 11923, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_0/index_8420_seed_11923_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02707248171791434, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02707248171791434, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02707248171791434, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast black-and-white film texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, snow-covered wilderness at night with snow falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as a medium shot and slowly transition to a close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower her head with wet tears on her face, then raise her head and close her eyes before opening them with a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cold moonlight penetrating sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0061081876046955585 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.631108283996582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0061081876046955585, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0061081876046955585, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2526521682739258, + 0.08093973249197006, + 0.08122644573450089, + 0.09357482194900513, + 0.08484449982643127, + 0.06332755833864212, + 0.0323791541159153, + 0.10076431185007095, + 0.11331654340028763, + 0.09697477519512177 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0061081876046955585 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast black-and-white film texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, snow-covered wilderness at night with snow falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as a medium shot and slowly transition to a close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower her head with wet tears on her face, then raise her head and close her eyes before opening them with a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cold moonlight penetrating sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02636430785059929 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651364326477051 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02636430785059929, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02636430785059929, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2506360411643982, + 0.1770276129245758, + 0.045711908489465714, + 0.12203266471624374, + 0.08731763809919357, + 0.09883767366409302, + 0.03483828902244568, + 0.06545110791921616, + 0.07065688073635101, + 0.0474901981651783 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02636430785059929 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast black-and-white film texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, snow-covered wilderness at night with snow falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as a medium shot and slowly transition to a close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower her head with wet tears on her face, then raise her head and close her eyes before opening them with a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cold moonlight penetrating sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01420129369944334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2642011642456055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01420129369944334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01420129369944334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0779537782073021, + 0.044585131108760834, + 0.0660758838057518, + 0.11349355429410934, + 0.06825637072324753, + 0.03595902398228645, + 0.05659317970275879, + 0.3145573139190674, + 0.20271587371826172, + 0.019809851422905922 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01420129369944334 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast black-and-white film texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, snow-covered wilderness at night with snow falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as a medium shot and slowly transition to a close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower her head with wet tears on her face, then raise her head and close her eyes before opening them with a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cold moonlight penetrating sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054958246648311615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299583435058594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054958246648311615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054958246648311615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.044414643198251724, + 0.054002441465854645, + 0.03854820132255554, + 0.04809174686670303, + 0.035232484340667725, + 0.04106738045811653, + 0.026293592527508736, + 0.07730216532945633, + 0.2704838216304779, + 0.3645634949207306 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054958246648311615 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast black-and-white film texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, snow-covered wilderness at night with snow falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as a medium shot and slowly transition to a close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower her head with wet tears on her face, then raise her head and close her eyes before opening them with a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cold moonlight penetrating sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03373037278652191 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087302684783936 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03373037278652191, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03373037278652191, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22720149159431458, + 0.06395432353019714, + 0.07673908025026321, + 0.11781132221221924, + 0.07358717173337936, + 0.1591634899377823, + 0.0393994115293026, + 0.11625068634748459, + 0.0531095527112484, + 0.07278354465961456 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03373037278652191 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly advancing shot, shot from a level angle, begins as a medium shot and eventually settles into a close-up. The entire image, rendered in the texture of a high-contrast black-and-white film, depicts a young woman in a simple white dress standing alone in a vast, snow-covered wilderness on a dark, snow-covered night. The cold moonlight, the sole source of light, penetrates the sparse clouds, gilding the dense, heavy snowfall with a silvery edge and casting soft, three-dimensional shadows on her fair skin and the plain hem of her dress. Initially, she lowers her head, her long, black hair, a few strands wet with tears, clinging to her cheeks. Her shoulders tremble slightly from suppressed sobs, tears silently streaming down her cold face, creating an atmosphere of profound loneliness and sorrow. As the camera approached her very slowly, she slowly raised her head and closed her eyes, as if taking a deep breath of cold air. When she opened her eyes again, all the sadness had dissipated, replaced by a frank and relieved smile quietly blooming on her lips. This smile carried a hint of indifference that came from seeing through the world, and together with the snowflakes flying in the sky, it formed a quiet, poetic and beautiful picture.", + "seed": 11924, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_0/index_8420_seed_11924_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.022451523505151273, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022451523505151273, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022451523505151273, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast black-and-white film texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, snow-covered wilderness at night with snow falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as a medium shot and slowly transition to a close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower her head with wet tears on her face, then raise her head and close her eyes before opening them with a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cold moonlight penetrating sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014580133371055126 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.764580249786377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014580133371055126, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014580133371055126, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09048584848642349, + 0.01677127741277218, + 0.019521301612257957, + 0.03454764187335968, + 0.045402370393276215, + 0.15751245617866516, + 0.12672743201255798, + 0.14955446124076843, + 0.15039533376693726, + 0.20908190310001373 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014580133371055126 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast black-and-white film texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, snow-covered wilderness at night with snow falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as a medium shot and slowly transition to a close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower her head with wet tears on her face, then raise her head and close her eyes before opening them with a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cold moonlight penetrating sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007642790675163269 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88264274597168 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007642790675163269, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007642790675163269, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10228341072797775, + 0.031014425680041313, + 0.062360286712646484, + 0.02198139950633049, + 0.04893302172422409, + 0.544561505317688, + 0.04492944851517677, + 0.07407680153846741, + 0.03471897915005684, + 0.035140715539455414 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007642790675163269 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast black-and-white film texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, snow-covered wilderness at night with snow falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as a medium shot and slowly transition to a close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower her head with wet tears on her face, then raise her head and close her eyes before opening them with a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cold moonlight penetrating sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020589547231793404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895589590072632 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020589547231793404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020589547231793404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.056073788553476334, + 0.03373578190803528, + 0.044179774820804596, + 0.054174985736608505, + 0.2645106613636017, + 0.10096417367458344, + 0.20134030282497406, + 0.12024397403001785, + 0.05140560492873192, + 0.07337094843387604 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020589547231793404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast black-and-white film texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, snow-covered wilderness at night with snow falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as a medium shot and slowly transition to a close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower her head with wet tears on her face, then raise her head and close her eyes before opening them with a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cold moonlight penetrating sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026348518207669258 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.65134859085083 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026348518207669258, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026348518207669258, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.038898538798093796, + 0.03125860542058945, + 0.030569136142730713, + 0.03462081030011177, + 0.10650886595249176, + 0.23109033703804016, + 0.09342808276414871, + 0.06052187830209732, + 0.2745142877101898, + 0.0985894575715065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026348518207669258 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast black-and-white film texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, snow-covered wilderness at night with snow falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as a medium shot and slowly transition to a close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower her head with wet tears on her face, then raise her head and close her eyes before opening them with a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cold moonlight penetrating sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0430966280400753 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680965423583984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0430966280400753, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0430966280400753, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12359141558408737, + 0.042813364416360855, + 0.050722524523735046, + 0.01596095599234104, + 0.10289468616247177, + 0.40430593490600586, + 0.046953681856393814, + 0.10217421501874924, + 0.053505733609199524, + 0.057077556848526 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0430966280400753 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly advancing shot, shot from a level angle, begins as a medium shot and eventually settles into a close-up. The entire image, rendered in the texture of a high-contrast black-and-white film, depicts a young woman in a simple white dress standing alone in a vast, snow-covered wilderness on a dark, snow-covered night. The cold moonlight, the sole source of light, penetrates the sparse clouds, gilding the dense, heavy snowfall with a silvery edge and casting soft, three-dimensional shadows on her fair skin and the plain hem of her dress. Initially, she lowers her head, her long, black hair, a few strands wet with tears, clinging to her cheeks. Her shoulders tremble slightly from suppressed sobs, tears silently streaming down her cold face, creating an atmosphere of profound loneliness and sorrow. As the camera approached her very slowly, she slowly raised her head and closed her eyes, as if taking a deep breath of cold air. When she opened her eyes again, all the sadness had dissipated, replaced by a frank and relieved smile quietly blooming on her lips. This smile carried a hint of indifference that came from seeing through the world, and together with the snowflakes flying in the sky, it formed a quiet, poetic and beautiful picture.", + "seed": 11925, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_0/index_8420_seed_11925_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.030941683892160655, + "vlm_logprob": -0.030941683892160655, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.030941683892160655, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast black-and-white film texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, snow-covered wilderness at night with snow falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as a medium shot and slowly transition to a close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower her head with wet tears on her face, then raise her head and close her eyes before opening them with a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cold moonlight penetrating sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007891902700066566 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.13289213180542 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007891902700066566, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007891902700066566, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.533380389213562, + 0.021634824573993683, + 0.017789416015148163, + 0.0233081616461277, + 0.013891843147575855, + 0.024723846465349197, + 0.1488884836435318, + 0.13943779468536377, + 0.013768834993243217, + 0.06317642331123352 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007891902700066566 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast black-and-white film texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, snow-covered wilderness at night with snow falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as a medium shot and slowly transition to a close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower her head with wet tears on her face, then raise her head and close her eyes before opening them with a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cold moonlight penetrating sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008648322895169258 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75864839553833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008648322895169258, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008648322895169258, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3028186857700348, + 0.0582604855298996, + 0.0618428997695446, + 0.04382551088929176, + 0.026570558547973633, + 0.023020286113023758, + 0.23303890228271484, + 0.12912996113300323, + 0.0443962998688221, + 0.07709633558988571 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008648322895169258 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast black-and-white film texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, snow-covered wilderness at night with snow falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as a medium shot and slowly transition to a close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower her head with wet tears on her face, then raise her head and close her eyes before opening them with a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cold moonlight penetrating sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004643846768885851 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.37964391708374 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004643846768885851, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004643846768885851, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0473102405667305, + 0.023763446137309074, + 0.018585724756121635, + 0.019902966916561127, + 0.014933742582798004, + 0.013546578586101532, + 0.7240336537361145, + 0.10226708650588989, + 0.029054701328277588, + 0.006601824890822172 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004643846768885851 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast black-and-white film texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, snow-covered wilderness at night with snow falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as a medium shot and slowly transition to a close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower her head with wet tears on her face, then raise her head and close her eyes before opening them with a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cold moonlight penetrating sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11292989552021027 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379298210144043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11292989552021027, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11292989552021027, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18813011050224304, + 0.005441900342702866, + 0.009455950930714607, + 0.005177145823836327, + 0.008374379016458988, + 0.011443707160651684, + 0.07389678806066513, + 0.6575082540512085, + 0.02967633120715618, + 0.010895461775362492 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11292989552021027 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast black-and-white film texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, snow-covered wilderness at night with snow falling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start as a medium shot and slowly transition to a close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the woman lower her head with wet tears on her face, then raise her head and close her eyes before opening them with a smile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cold moonlight penetrating sparse clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059445157647133 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895594358444214 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059445157647133, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059445157647133, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14738324284553528, + 0.022848378866910934, + 0.009705745615065098, + 0.021321654319763184, + 0.011623263359069824, + 0.022069051861763, + 0.39945313334465027, + 0.25047096610069275, + 0.046228814870119095, + 0.06889577209949493 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059445157647133 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_1/index_tensor([5225, 5225])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_1/index_tensor([5225, 5225])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ef5b42ba6e20ce137de5a33c6af749a6fbe182ae --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_1/index_tensor([5225, 5225])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "cinematic, high-angle, wide shot slowly sweeps across a vast landscape radically transformed by the flood, the entire scene rendered in the swirling, emotive style of a Van Gogh painting. Powerful waves of muddy water sweep across the fields, their turbulent motion captured in thick, visible brushstrokes of ochre, sienna, and deep blue. The water's surface is a chaotic tapestry, vibrant, directional brushstrokes conveying immense power, swirling and eddying around the underwater obstruction. Amidst this deluge stands a lone farmhouse, its weathered white walls and dark roof seeming a lone point of resilience. The water relentlessly pounding against its stone foundation, unleashing explosive sprays of foam painted in frenzied white and pale blue. Above, the sky is a swirling cloud of rich gray, cobalt blue, and a bright, unsettling yellow, reflecting the chaos below. A dramatic break in the cloud layer allows a shaft of light to penetrate the darkness, illuminating the churning waters and highlighting the thick, tactile texture of the paint, creating an atmosphere of overwhelming natural power, awe, and profound, melancholic beauty.", + "seed": 23956, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_1/index_5225_seed_23956_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03213567798957229, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03213567798957229, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03213567798957229, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle wide shot of a vast landscape transformed by a flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in the swirling, emotive style of a Van Gogh painting with thick, visible brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone farmhouse with weathered white walls and a dark roof visible amidst the flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky display a swirling cloud layer of rich gray, cobalt blue, and bright yellow with a shaft of light penetrating it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.025198373943567276 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.775198459625244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.025198373943567276, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.025198373943567276, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28974422812461853, + 0.0752059817314148, + 0.09195126593112946, + 0.05785870924592018, + 0.17960844933986664, + 0.059264156967401505, + 0.023809662088751793, + 0.05000355467200279, + 0.05368020385503769, + 0.11887373775243759 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.025198373943567276 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle wide shot of a vast landscape transformed by a flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in the swirling, emotive style of a Van Gogh painting with thick, visible brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone farmhouse with weathered white walls and a dark roof visible amidst the flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky display a swirling cloud layer of rich gray, cobalt blue, and bright yellow with a shaft of light penetrating it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012544653378427029 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387544631958008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012544653378427029, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012544653378427029, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2152722179889679, + 0.09230928868055344, + 0.0576937273144722, + 0.10259557515382767, + 0.08196733146905899, + 0.05306070297956467, + 0.04565197601914406, + 0.0724206268787384, + 0.11404338479042053, + 0.16498520970344543 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012544653378427029 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle wide shot of a vast landscape transformed by a flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in the swirling, emotive style of a Van Gogh painting with thick, visible brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone farmhouse with weathered white walls and a dark roof visible amidst the flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky display a swirling cloud layer of rich gray, cobalt blue, and bright yellow with a shaft of light penetrating it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496027693152428 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929960250854492 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496027693152428, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496027693152428, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11401166766881943, + 0.03748626634478569, + 0.09605225175619125, + 0.047956619411706924, + 0.048946086317300797, + 0.03864426538348198, + 0.01789519563317299, + 0.06084587052464485, + 0.12925031781196594, + 0.40891149640083313 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496027693152428 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle wide shot of a vast landscape transformed by a flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in the swirling, emotive style of a Van Gogh painting with thick, visible brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone farmhouse with weathered white walls and a dark roof visible amidst the flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky display a swirling cloud layer of rich gray, cobalt blue, and bright yellow with a shaft of light penetrating it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059498813934624195 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130949974060059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059498813934624195, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059498813934624195, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4519784450531006, + 0.04017579182982445, + 0.031331345438957214, + 0.13925708830356598, + 0.06980908662080765, + 0.05899547040462494, + 0.015864867717027664, + 0.052783429622650146, + 0.03271649777889252, + 0.10708802193403244 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059498813934624195 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle wide shot of a vast landscape transformed by a flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in the swirling, emotive style of a Van Gogh painting with thick, visible brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone farmhouse with weathered white walls and a dark roof visible amidst the flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky display a swirling cloud layer of rich gray, cobalt blue, and bright yellow with a shaft of light penetrating it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06202520430088043 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812025308609009 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06202520430088043, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06202520430088043, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1049288809299469, + 0.03780069574713707, + 0.0666368156671524, + 0.030106784775853157, + 0.19700664281845093, + 0.39263275265693665, + 0.021706143394112587, + 0.03675175458192825, + 0.04519186168909073, + 0.06723767518997192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06202520430088043 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematic, high-angle, wide shot slowly sweeps across a vast landscape radically transformed by the flood, the entire scene rendered in the swirling, emotive style of a Van Gogh painting. Powerful waves of muddy water sweep across the fields, their turbulent motion captured in thick, visible brushstrokes of ochre, sienna, and deep blue. The water's surface is a chaotic tapestry, vibrant, directional brushstrokes conveying immense power, swirling and eddying around the underwater obstruction. Amidst this deluge stands a lone farmhouse, its weathered white walls and dark roof seeming a lone point of resilience. The water relentlessly pounding against its stone foundation, unleashing explosive sprays of foam painted in frenzied white and pale blue. Above, the sky is a swirling cloud of rich gray, cobalt blue, and a bright, unsettling yellow, reflecting the chaos below. A dramatic break in the cloud layer allows a shaft of light to penetrate the darkness, illuminating the churning waters and highlighting the thick, tactile texture of the paint, creating an atmosphere of overwhelming natural power, awe, and profound, melancholic beauty.", + "seed": 23957, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_1/index_5225_seed_23957_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.01699469778686762, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01699469778686762, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01699469778686762, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle wide shot of a vast landscape transformed by a flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in the swirling, emotive style of a Van Gogh painting with thick, visible brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone farmhouse with weathered white walls and a dark roof visible amidst the flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky display a swirling cloud layer of rich gray, cobalt blue, and bright yellow with a shaft of light penetrating it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002976156771183014 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002975940704346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002976156771183014, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002976156771183014, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11389368772506714, + 0.07469815760850906, + 0.15639887750148773, + 0.14255744218826294, + 0.09230049699544907, + 0.11826113611459732, + 0.09318551421165466, + 0.04885933920741081, + 0.04431730508804321, + 0.11552805453538895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002976156771183014 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle wide shot of a vast landscape transformed by a flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in the swirling, emotive style of a Van Gogh painting with thick, visible brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone farmhouse with weathered white walls and a dark roof visible amidst the flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky display a swirling cloud layer of rich gray, cobalt blue, and bright yellow with a shaft of light penetrating it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00762906763702631 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882628917694092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00762906763702631, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00762906763702631, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1555846631526947, + 0.24201415479183197, + 0.18488618731498718, + 0.05761263519525528, + 0.05181732401251793, + 0.049899641424417496, + 0.04738570749759674, + 0.04806895926594734, + 0.028633907437324524, + 0.13409678637981415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00762906763702631 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle wide shot of a vast landscape transformed by a flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in the swirling, emotive style of a Van Gogh painting with thick, visible brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone farmhouse with weathered white walls and a dark roof visible amidst the flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky display a swirling cloud layer of rich gray, cobalt blue, and bright yellow with a shaft of light penetrating it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014192361384630203 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264192581176758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014192361384630203, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014192361384630203, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1237240806221962, + 0.44602105021476746, + 0.29241690039634705, + 0.04785585403442383, + 0.010480867698788643, + 0.01380949281156063, + 0.01269895862787962, + 0.024107161909341812, + 0.014291398227214813, + 0.014594233594834805 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014192361384630203 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle wide shot of a vast landscape transformed by a flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in the swirling, emotive style of a Van Gogh painting with thick, visible brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone farmhouse with weathered white walls and a dark roof visible amidst the flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky display a swirling cloud layer of rich gray, cobalt blue, and bright yellow with a shaft of light penetrating it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005250830203294754 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255250930786133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005250830203294754, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005250830203294754, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1301792711019516, + 0.2862829864025116, + 0.1100216880440712, + 0.2202616184949875, + 0.026523983106017113, + 0.05744417756795883, + 0.0323147289454937, + 0.028806252405047417, + 0.06937843561172485, + 0.03878684714436531 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005250830203294754 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle wide shot of a vast landscape transformed by a flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in the swirling, emotive style of a Van Gogh painting with thick, visible brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone farmhouse with weathered white walls and a dark roof visible amidst the flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky display a swirling cloud layer of rich gray, cobalt blue, and bright yellow with a shaft of light penetrating it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05492507293820381 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929924964904785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05492507293820381, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05492507293820381, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2241971492767334, + 0.1903872936964035, + 0.13671085238456726, + 0.06935041397809982, + 0.06183593347668648, + 0.09305687248706818, + 0.06442490220069885, + 0.05562732368707657, + 0.07021632790565491, + 0.034192901104688644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05492507293820381 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematic, high-angle, wide shot slowly sweeps across a vast landscape radically transformed by the flood, the entire scene rendered in the swirling, emotive style of a Van Gogh painting. Powerful waves of muddy water sweep across the fields, their turbulent motion captured in thick, visible brushstrokes of ochre, sienna, and deep blue. The water's surface is a chaotic tapestry, vibrant, directional brushstrokes conveying immense power, swirling and eddying around the underwater obstruction. Amidst this deluge stands a lone farmhouse, its weathered white walls and dark roof seeming a lone point of resilience. The water relentlessly pounding against its stone foundation, unleashing explosive sprays of foam painted in frenzied white and pale blue. Above, the sky is a swirling cloud of rich gray, cobalt blue, and a bright, unsettling yellow, reflecting the chaos below. A dramatic break in the cloud layer allows a shaft of light to penetrate the darkness, illuminating the churning waters and highlighting the thick, tactile texture of the paint, creating an atmosphere of overwhelming natural power, awe, and profound, melancholic beauty.", + "seed": 23958, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_1/index_5225_seed_23958_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.02270198268815875, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02270198268815875, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02270198268815875, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle wide shot of a vast landscape transformed by a flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in the swirling, emotive style of a Van Gogh painting with thick, visible brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone farmhouse with weathered white walls and a dark roof visible amidst the flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky display a swirling cloud layer of rich gray, cobalt blue, and bright yellow with a shaft of light penetrating it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010267415083944798 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63526725769043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010267415083944798, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010267415083944798, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05487236753106117, + 0.0819430947303772, + 0.48606207966804504, + 0.22037926316261292, + 0.026279034093022346, + 0.010719639249145985, + 0.015268154442310333, + 0.04556666314601898, + 0.039096809923648834, + 0.01981285959482193 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010267415083944798 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle wide shot of a vast landscape transformed by a flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in the swirling, emotive style of a Van Gogh painting with thick, visible brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone farmhouse with weathered white walls and a dark roof visible amidst the flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky display a swirling cloud layer of rich gray, cobalt blue, and bright yellow with a shaft of light penetrating it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019468179671093822 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251946926116943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019468179671093822, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019468179671093822, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07988619059324265, + 0.0942932516336441, + 0.15473228693008423, + 0.4311319887638092, + 0.06376040726900101, + 0.021222613751888275, + 0.00873596128076315, + 0.043480128049850464, + 0.07242288440465927, + 0.030334264039993286 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019468179671093822 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle wide shot of a vast landscape transformed by a flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in the swirling, emotive style of a Van Gogh painting with thick, visible brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone farmhouse with weathered white walls and a dark roof visible amidst the flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky display a swirling cloud layer of rich gray, cobalt blue, and bright yellow with a shaft of light penetrating it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029792420566082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529792308807373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029792420566082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029792420566082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06525296717882156, + 0.05658714473247528, + 0.25058597326278687, + 0.4666583836078644, + 0.02263975888490677, + 0.009478745050728321, + 0.01472644042223692, + 0.019670609384775162, + 0.06693146377801895, + 0.027468450367450714 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029792420566082 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle wide shot of a vast landscape transformed by a flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in the swirling, emotive style of a Van Gogh painting with thick, visible brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone farmhouse with weathered white walls and a dark roof visible amidst the flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky display a swirling cloud layer of rich gray, cobalt blue, and bright yellow with a shaft of light penetrating it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015141224721446633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501513957977295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015141224721446633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015141224721446633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05982727184891701, + 0.1068810373544693, + 0.5255635380744934, + 0.16677504777908325, + 0.046231240034103394, + 0.014864380471408367, + 0.012325482442975044, + 0.02725096419453621, + 0.008442693389952183, + 0.031838420778512955 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015141224721446633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle wide shot of a vast landscape transformed by a flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in the swirling, emotive style of a Van Gogh painting with thick, visible brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone farmhouse with weathered white walls and a dark roof visible amidst the flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky display a swirling cloud layer of rich gray, cobalt blue, and bright yellow with a shaft of light penetrating it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06998913735151291 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6949892044067383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06998913735151291, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06998913735151291, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04973660036921501, + 0.10886041074991226, + 0.4854981005191803, + 0.19937090575695038, + 0.03656286001205444, + 0.007965263910591602, + 0.013653869740664959, + 0.039692871272563934, + 0.048665788024663925, + 0.009993284940719604 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06998913735151291 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematic, high-angle, wide shot slowly sweeps across a vast landscape radically transformed by the flood, the entire scene rendered in the swirling, emotive style of a Van Gogh painting. Powerful waves of muddy water sweep across the fields, their turbulent motion captured in thick, visible brushstrokes of ochre, sienna, and deep blue. The water's surface is a chaotic tapestry, vibrant, directional brushstrokes conveying immense power, swirling and eddying around the underwater obstruction. Amidst this deluge stands a lone farmhouse, its weathered white walls and dark roof seeming a lone point of resilience. The water relentlessly pounding against its stone foundation, unleashing explosive sprays of foam painted in frenzied white and pale blue. Above, the sky is a swirling cloud of rich gray, cobalt blue, and a bright, unsettling yellow, reflecting the chaos below. A dramatic break in the cloud layer allows a shaft of light to penetrate the darkness, illuminating the churning waters and highlighting the thick, tactile texture of the paint, creating an atmosphere of overwhelming natural power, awe, and profound, melancholic beauty.", + "seed": 23959, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_1/index_5225_seed_23959_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04751703185029328, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04751703185029328, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04751703185029328, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle wide shot of a vast landscape transformed by a flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in the swirling, emotive style of a Van Gogh painting with thick, visible brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone farmhouse with weathered white walls and a dark roof visible amidst the flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky display a swirling cloud layer of rich gray, cobalt blue, and bright yellow with a shaft of light penetrating it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004524707794189453 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8795247077941895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004524707794189453, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004524707794189453, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22104227542877197, + 0.10865052044391632, + 0.21045073866844177, + 0.06760063022375107, + 0.05485519394278526, + 0.03906543552875519, + 0.13582484424114227, + 0.06042811647057533, + 0.03438885137438774, + 0.06769339740276337 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004524707794189453 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle wide shot of a vast landscape transformed by a flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in the swirling, emotive style of a Van Gogh painting with thick, visible brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone farmhouse with weathered white walls and a dark roof visible amidst the flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky display a swirling cloud layer of rich gray, cobalt blue, and bright yellow with a shaft of light penetrating it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00362038123421371 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628620147705078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00362038123421371, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00362038123421371, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04442933201789856, + 0.09847112745046616, + 0.7234374284744263, + 0.01585237681865692, + 0.019587771967053413, + 0.008915185928344727, + 0.019754990935325623, + 0.014377927407622337, + 0.021052269265055656, + 0.034121591597795486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00362038123421371 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle wide shot of a vast landscape transformed by a flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in the swirling, emotive style of a Van Gogh painting with thick, visible brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone farmhouse with weathered white walls and a dark roof visible amidst the flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky display a swirling cloud layer of rich gray, cobalt blue, and bright yellow with a shaft of light penetrating it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023283181712031364 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732832431793213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023283181712031364, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023283181712031364, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13825863599777222, + 0.1836421638727188, + 0.18566644191741943, + 0.1045750081539154, + 0.04582511633634567, + 0.04732378199696541, + 0.10636282712221146, + 0.1089242696762085, + 0.050586313009262085, + 0.028835441917181015 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023283181712031364 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle wide shot of a vast landscape transformed by a flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in the swirling, emotive style of a Van Gogh painting with thick, visible brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone farmhouse with weathered white walls and a dark roof visible amidst the flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky display a swirling cloud layer of rich gray, cobalt blue, and bright yellow with a shaft of light penetrating it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00463957479223609 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379639625549316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00463957479223609, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00463957479223609, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10118629038333893, + 0.19437989592552185, + 0.39112457633018494, + 0.07180759310722351, + 0.053864192217588425, + 0.021322114393115044, + 0.0391768254339695, + 0.03908585384488106, + 0.040202416479587555, + 0.04785019904375076 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00463957479223609 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle wide shot of a vast landscape transformed by a flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in the swirling, emotive style of a Van Gogh painting with thick, visible brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a lone farmhouse with weathered white walls and a dark roof visible amidst the flood?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sky display a swirling cloud layer of rich gray, cobalt blue, and bright yellow with a shaft of light penetrating it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly sweep across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20151731371879578 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015173435211182 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20151731371879578, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20151731371879578, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16122202575206757, + 0.25022459030151367, + 0.12417469918727875, + 0.05456966906785965, + 0.04344869405031204, + 0.06811778992414474, + 0.1518716961145401, + 0.034740202128887177, + 0.043600086122751236, + 0.06803055852651596 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20151731371879578 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_10/index_tensor([9500, 9500])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_10/index_tensor([9500, 9500])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..095ab986db9e5811e1ea55cb50a8c1fb91d7055e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_10/index_tensor([9500, 9500])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "After midnight, a wide shot at eye level begins a slow, deliberate advance along rain-slicked, deserted city streets, their black asphalt gleaming like polished obsidian in the sparse, cold glow of distant streetlights. The camera slides past the facades of darkened storefronts, their windows empty and black, surfaces revealing worn, peeling paint that curls from the brick walls in muted earthy tones. A lone, stationary municipal maintenance truck sits in the middle of the street, its faded orange paint smeared with grime; its amber warning lights flicker slowly, casting a rhythmic, hypnotic pulse that washes over the damp ground and reflects in shallow puddles. An unseen, humming wind blows by, pushing scraps of paper and discarded wrappers in a ghostly dance along the empty, cracked concrete sidewalk. The camera's focus continues to narrow, past the truck and onto the old neon sign of a closed restaurant. The logo, a relic of a bygone era, flickered erratically, its red pipes sputtering with inconsistent life and humming until a letter suddenly dimmed and part of the logo fell into permanent shadow, perfectly conveying a profound sense of slow decay and forgotten purpose.", + "seed": 30460, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_10/index_9500_seed_30460_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.02152649611234665, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02152649611234665, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.049999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02152649611234665, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on deserted city streets with black asphalt that appears rain-slicked and gleaming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, stationary municipal maintenance truck visible in the middle of the street with faded orange paint and smeared grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do amber warning lights on the truck flicker slowly, casting a rhythmic pulse that reflects in shallow puddles on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate advance (dolly in) that starts wide at eye level and narrows focus past the truck to an old neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old neon sign of a closed restaurant visible, showing red pipes that flicker erratically with one letter dimming and part of the logo falling into shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019106511026620865 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.019106388092041 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019106511026620865, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019106511026620865, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.187582328915596, + 0.3647574186325073, + 0.08971188962459564, + 0.03616428002715111, + 0.09179949760437012, + 0.02464388683438301, + 0.06983374804258347, + 0.04477376118302345, + 0.038939736783504486, + 0.051793500781059265 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019106511026620865 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on deserted city streets with black asphalt that appears rain-slicked and gleaming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, stationary municipal maintenance truck visible in the middle of the street with faded orange paint and smeared grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do amber warning lights on the truck flicker slowly, casting a rhythmic pulse that reflects in shallow puddles on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate advance (dolly in) that starts wide at eye level and narrows focus past the truck to an old neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old neon sign of a closed restaurant visible, showing red pipes that flicker erratically with one letter dimming and part of the logo falling into shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01254394743591547 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38754415512085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01254394743591547, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01254394743591547, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16800706088542938, + 0.3079392611980438, + 0.07257198542356491, + 0.05130898207426071, + 0.06019056960940361, + 0.04009942710399628, + 0.13366152346134186, + 0.040859609842300415, + 0.08491169661283493, + 0.04044994339346886 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01254394743591547 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on deserted city streets with black asphalt that appears rain-slicked and gleaming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, stationary municipal maintenance truck visible in the middle of the street with faded orange paint and smeared grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do amber warning lights on the truck flicker slowly, casting a rhythmic pulse that reflects in shallow puddles on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate advance (dolly in) that starts wide at eye level and narrows focus past the truck to an old neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old neon sign of a closed restaurant visible, showing red pipes that flicker erratically with one letter dimming and part of the logo falling into shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020601576194167137 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895601511001587 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020601576194167137, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020601576194167137, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12569864094257355, + 0.09337614476680756, + 0.05784272775053978, + 0.05100689455866814, + 0.12976683676242828, + 0.08810394257307053, + 0.1299094259738922, + 0.12579885125160217, + 0.06157649680972099, + 0.1369199901819229 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020601576194167137 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on deserted city streets with black asphalt that appears rain-slicked and gleaming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, stationary municipal maintenance truck visible in the middle of the street with faded orange paint and smeared grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do amber warning lights on the truck flicker slowly, casting a rhythmic pulse that reflects in shallow puddles on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate advance (dolly in) that starts wide at eye level and narrows focus past the truck to an old neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old neon sign of a closed restaurant visible, showing red pipes that flicker erratically with one letter dimming and part of the logo falling into shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006737136282026768 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006737232208252 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006737136282026768, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006737136282026768, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061344798654317856, + 0.07938768714666367, + 0.03553948551416397, + 0.08199895918369293, + 0.08335252851247787, + 0.07305712252855301, + 0.2942778766155243, + 0.06695467978715897, + 0.1936383694410324, + 0.030448494479060173 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006737136282026768 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on deserted city streets with black asphalt that appears rain-slicked and gleaming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, stationary municipal maintenance truck visible in the middle of the street with faded orange paint and smeared grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do amber warning lights on the truck flicker slowly, casting a rhythmic pulse that reflects in shallow puddles on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate advance (dolly in) that starts wide at eye level and narrows focus past the truck to an old neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old neon sign of a closed restaurant visible, showing red pipes that flicker erratically with one letter dimming and part of the logo falling into shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048643309623003006 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486433506011963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048643309623003006, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048643309623003006, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04809454455971718, + 0.08910258114337921, + 0.02679242379963398, + 0.02829454094171524, + 0.03250579908490181, + 0.03762597590684891, + 0.385463148355484, + 0.10960476845502853, + 0.1769285649061203, + 0.06558756530284882 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048643309623003006 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "After midnight, a wide shot at eye level begins a slow, deliberate advance along rain-slicked, deserted city streets, their black asphalt gleaming like polished obsidian in the sparse, cold glow of distant streetlights. The camera slides past the facades of darkened storefronts, their windows empty and black, surfaces revealing worn, peeling paint that curls from the brick walls in muted earthy tones. A lone, stationary municipal maintenance truck sits in the middle of the street, its faded orange paint smeared with grime; its amber warning lights flicker slowly, casting a rhythmic, hypnotic pulse that washes over the damp ground and reflects in shallow puddles. An unseen, humming wind blows by, pushing scraps of paper and discarded wrappers in a ghostly dance along the empty, cracked concrete sidewalk. The camera's focus continues to narrow, past the truck and onto the old neon sign of a closed restaurant. The logo, a relic of a bygone era, flickered erratically, its red pipes sputtering with inconsistent life and humming until a letter suddenly dimmed and part of the logo fell into permanent shadow, perfectly conveying a profound sense of slow decay and forgotten purpose.", + "seed": 30461, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_10/index_9500_seed_30461_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.040518900472670795, + "vlm_logprob": -0.040518900472670795, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.040518900472670795, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on deserted city streets with black asphalt that appears rain-slicked and gleaming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, stationary municipal maintenance truck visible in the middle of the street with faded orange paint and smeared grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do amber warning lights on the truck flicker slowly, casting a rhythmic pulse that reflects in shallow puddles on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate advance (dolly in) that starts wide at eye level and narrows focus past the truck to an old neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old neon sign of a closed restaurant visible, showing red pipes that flicker erratically with one letter dimming and part of the logo falling into shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08345572650432587 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.583455801010132 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08345572650432587, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08345572650432587, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29437634348869324, + 0.13611458241939545, + 0.19130505621433258, + 0.1086680144071579, + 0.08478980511426926, + 0.0463523231446743, + 0.02845957688987255, + 0.024605240672826767, + 0.0626986101269722, + 0.022630421444773674 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08345572650432587 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on deserted city streets with black asphalt that appears rain-slicked and gleaming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, stationary municipal maintenance truck visible in the middle of the street with faded orange paint and smeared grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do amber warning lights on the truck flicker slowly, casting a rhythmic pulse that reflects in shallow puddles on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate advance (dolly in) that starts wide at eye level and narrows focus past the truck to an old neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old neon sign of a closed restaurant visible, showing red pipes that flicker erratically with one letter dimming and part of the logo falling into shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026360243558883667 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651360273361206 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026360243558883667, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026360243558883667, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26610249280929565, + 0.10840734839439392, + 0.12359131127595901, + 0.053126171231269836, + 0.03711695596575737, + 0.037891168147325516, + 0.10034644603729248, + 0.06860575824975967, + 0.13851973414421082, + 0.06629268079996109 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026360243558883667 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on deserted city streets with black asphalt that appears rain-slicked and gleaming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, stationary municipal maintenance truck visible in the middle of the street with faded orange paint and smeared grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do amber warning lights on the truck flicker slowly, casting a rhythmic pulse that reflects in shallow puddles on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate advance (dolly in) that starts wide at eye level and narrows focus past the truck to an old neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old neon sign of a closed restaurant visible, showing red pipes that flicker erratically with one letter dimming and part of the logo falling into shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038134824484586716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288134813308716 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038134824484586716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038134824484586716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16575828194618225, + 0.05197712033987045, + 0.20375113189220428, + 0.11652426421642303, + 0.06829152256250381, + 0.038109246641397476, + 0.16905461251735687, + 0.023079251870512962, + 0.06511908769607544, + 0.09833551943302155 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038134824484586716 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on deserted city streets with black asphalt that appears rain-slicked and gleaming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, stationary municipal maintenance truck visible in the middle of the street with faded orange paint and smeared grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do amber warning lights on the truck flicker slowly, casting a rhythmic pulse that reflects in shallow puddles on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate advance (dolly in) that starts wide at eye level and narrows focus past the truck to an old neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old neon sign of a closed restaurant visible, showing red pipes that flicker erratically with one letter dimming and part of the logo falling into shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00595770264044404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.13095760345459 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00595770264044404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00595770264044404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09107308834791183, + 0.036689817905426025, + 0.082044318318367, + 0.03572804853320122, + 0.03129562363028526, + 0.11349230259656906, + 0.16088902950286865, + 0.04244696721434593, + 0.03727180138230324, + 0.36906898021698 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00595770264044404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on deserted city streets with black asphalt that appears rain-slicked and gleaming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, stationary municipal maintenance truck visible in the middle of the street with faded orange paint and smeared grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do amber warning lights on the truck flicker slowly, casting a rhythmic pulse that reflects in shallow puddles on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate advance (dolly in) that starts wide at eye level and narrows focus past the truck to an old neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old neon sign of a closed restaurant visible, showing red pipes that flicker erratically with one letter dimming and part of the logo falling into shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04868600517511368 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486860275268555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04868600517511368, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04868600517511368, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08009959012269974, + 0.03266919404268265, + 0.03227066621184349, + 0.04549853503704071, + 0.04416569322347641, + 0.03638901561498642, + 0.09206511080265045, + 0.03571499139070511, + 0.06678871810436249, + 0.5343385338783264 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04868600517511368 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "After midnight, a wide shot at eye level begins a slow, deliberate advance along rain-slicked, deserted city streets, their black asphalt gleaming like polished obsidian in the sparse, cold glow of distant streetlights. The camera slides past the facades of darkened storefronts, their windows empty and black, surfaces revealing worn, peeling paint that curls from the brick walls in muted earthy tones. A lone, stationary municipal maintenance truck sits in the middle of the street, its faded orange paint smeared with grime; its amber warning lights flicker slowly, casting a rhythmic, hypnotic pulse that washes over the damp ground and reflects in shallow puddles. An unseen, humming wind blows by, pushing scraps of paper and discarded wrappers in a ghostly dance along the empty, cracked concrete sidewalk. The camera's focus continues to narrow, past the truck and onto the old neon sign of a closed restaurant. The logo, a relic of a bygone era, flickered erratically, its red pipes sputtering with inconsistent life and humming until a letter suddenly dimmed and part of the logo fell into permanent shadow, perfectly conveying a profound sense of slow decay and forgotten purpose.", + "seed": 30462, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_10/index_9500_seed_30462_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.13342072404921054, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13342072404921054, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13342072404921054, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on deserted city streets with black asphalt that appears rain-slicked and gleaming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, stationary municipal maintenance truck visible in the middle of the street with faded orange paint and smeared grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do amber warning lights on the truck flicker slowly, casting a rhythmic pulse that reflects in shallow puddles on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate advance (dolly in) that starts wide at eye level and narrows focus past the truck to an old neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old neon sign of a closed restaurant visible, showing red pipes that flicker erratically with one letter dimming and part of the logo falling into shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5270323753356934 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9020323753356934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5270323753356934, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5270323753356934, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23957961797714233, + 0.16201584041118622, + 0.2000627964735031, + 0.16241499781608582, + 0.08200515806674957, + 0.028830507770180702, + 0.027266765013337135, + 0.04811849817633629, + 0.02376358024775982, + 0.02594223991036415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5270323753356934 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on deserted city streets with black asphalt that appears rain-slicked and gleaming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, stationary municipal maintenance truck visible in the middle of the street with faded orange paint and smeared grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do amber warning lights on the truck flicker slowly, casting a rhythmic pulse that reflects in shallow puddles on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate advance (dolly in) that starts wide at eye level and narrows focus past the truck to an old neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old neon sign of a closed restaurant visible, showing red pipes that flicker erratically with one letter dimming and part of the logo falling into shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054981715977191925 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299817085266113 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054981715977191925, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054981715977191925, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27884024381637573, + 0.15821658074855804, + 0.18822059035301208, + 0.08620729297399521, + 0.03773336112499237, + 0.03559908643364906, + 0.028793644160032272, + 0.06839233636856079, + 0.034757666289806366, + 0.08323919773101807 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054981715977191925 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on deserted city streets with black asphalt that appears rain-slicked and gleaming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, stationary municipal maintenance truck visible in the middle of the street with faded orange paint and smeared grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do amber warning lights on the truck flicker slowly, casting a rhythmic pulse that reflects in shallow puddles on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate advance (dolly in) that starts wide at eye level and narrows focus past the truck to an old neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old neon sign of a closed restaurant visible, showing red pipes that flicker erratically with one letter dimming and part of the logo falling into shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020615823566913605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895615816116333 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020615823566913605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020615823566913605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12070264667272568, + 0.2129574716091156, + 0.19263868033885956, + 0.10785907506942749, + 0.1088360995054245, + 0.0536012202501297, + 0.02699384093284607, + 0.05884229764342308, + 0.056852832436561584, + 0.060715802013874054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020615823566913605 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on deserted city streets with black asphalt that appears rain-slicked and gleaming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, stationary municipal maintenance truck visible in the middle of the street with faded orange paint and smeared grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do amber warning lights on the truck flicker slowly, casting a rhythmic pulse that reflects in shallow puddles on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate advance (dolly in) that starts wide at eye level and narrows focus past the truck to an old neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old neon sign of a closed restaurant visible, showing red pipes that flicker erratically with one letter dimming and part of the logo falling into shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026358501985669136 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513586044311523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026358501985669136, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026358501985669136, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42880040407180786, + 0.07034281641244888, + 0.06068471819162369, + 0.07699955254793167, + 0.04750838875770569, + 0.07048497349023819, + 0.09374090284109116, + 0.040534891188144684, + 0.08320029079914093, + 0.02770308218896389 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026358501985669136 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on deserted city streets with black asphalt that appears rain-slicked and gleaming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, stationary municipal maintenance truck visible in the middle of the street with faded orange paint and smeared grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do amber warning lights on the truck flicker slowly, casting a rhythmic pulse that reflects in shallow puddles on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate advance (dolly in) that starts wide at eye level and narrows focus past the truck to an old neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old neon sign of a closed restaurant visible, showing red pipes that flicker erratically with one letter dimming and part of the logo falling into shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811520338058472 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881152629852295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811520338058472, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811520338058472, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2580791115760803, + 0.10167357325553894, + 0.02628650702536106, + 0.05522739887237549, + 0.04901060089468956, + 0.07050381600856781, + 0.05831923335790634, + 0.0642770305275917, + 0.18198858201503754, + 0.1346341371536255 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811520338058472 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "After midnight, a wide shot at eye level begins a slow, deliberate advance along rain-slicked, deserted city streets, their black asphalt gleaming like polished obsidian in the sparse, cold glow of distant streetlights. The camera slides past the facades of darkened storefronts, their windows empty and black, surfaces revealing worn, peeling paint that curls from the brick walls in muted earthy tones. A lone, stationary municipal maintenance truck sits in the middle of the street, its faded orange paint smeared with grime; its amber warning lights flicker slowly, casting a rhythmic, hypnotic pulse that washes over the damp ground and reflects in shallow puddles. An unseen, humming wind blows by, pushing scraps of paper and discarded wrappers in a ghostly dance along the empty, cracked concrete sidewalk. The camera's focus continues to narrow, past the truck and onto the old neon sign of a closed restaurant. The logo, a relic of a bygone era, flickered erratically, its red pipes sputtering with inconsistent life and humming until a letter suddenly dimmed and part of the logo fell into permanent shadow, perfectly conveying a profound sense of slow decay and forgotten purpose.", + "seed": 30463, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_10/index_9500_seed_30463_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03485758248716593, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03485758248716593, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03485758248716593, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on deserted city streets with black asphalt that appears rain-slicked and gleaming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, stationary municipal maintenance truck visible in the middle of the street with faded orange paint and smeared grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do amber warning lights on the truck flicker slowly, casting a rhythmic pulse that reflects in shallow puddles on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate advance (dolly in) that starts wide at eye level and narrows focus past the truck to an old neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old neon sign of a closed restaurant visible, showing red pipes that flicker erratically with one letter dimming and part of the logo falling into shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07455369085073471 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6995537281036377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07455369085073471, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07455369085073471, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12904268503189087, + 0.18836182355880737, + 0.037228476256132126, + 0.4019739329814911, + 0.050326887518167496, + 0.07495254278182983, + 0.014712709933519363, + 0.033011797815561295, + 0.04094523936510086, + 0.029443910345435143 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07455369085073471 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on deserted city streets with black asphalt that appears rain-slicked and gleaming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, stationary municipal maintenance truck visible in the middle of the street with faded orange paint and smeared grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do amber warning lights on the truck flicker slowly, casting a rhythmic pulse that reflects in shallow puddles on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate advance (dolly in) that starts wide at eye level and narrows focus past the truck to an old neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old neon sign of a closed restaurant visible, showing red pipes that flicker erratically with one letter dimming and part of the logo falling into shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005967537872493267 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130967617034912 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005967537872493267, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005967537872493267, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07086211442947388, + 0.07149702310562134, + 0.01623518578708172, + 0.5236837267875671, + 0.0168121550232172, + 0.049124620854854584, + 0.021050941199064255, + 0.12367524206638336, + 0.07025636732578278, + 0.03680257871747017 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005967537872493267 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on deserted city streets with black asphalt that appears rain-slicked and gleaming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, stationary municipal maintenance truck visible in the middle of the street with faded orange paint and smeared grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do amber warning lights on the truck flicker slowly, casting a rhythmic pulse that reflects in shallow puddles on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate advance (dolly in) that starts wide at eye level and narrows focus past the truck to an old neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old neon sign of a closed restaurant visible, showing red pipes that flicker erratically with one letter dimming and part of the logo falling into shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018209779635071754 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018209934234619 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018209779635071754, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018209779635071754, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0859871357679367, + 0.02626321278512478, + 0.015194420702755451, + 0.723867654800415, + 0.01667282171547413, + 0.02099875546991825, + 0.023706434294581413, + 0.02300126850605011, + 0.03666875511407852, + 0.027639517560601234 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018209779635071754 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on deserted city streets with black asphalt that appears rain-slicked and gleaming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, stationary municipal maintenance truck visible in the middle of the street with faded orange paint and smeared grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do amber warning lights on the truck flicker slowly, casting a rhythmic pulse that reflects in shallow puddles on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate advance (dolly in) that starts wide at eye level and narrows focus past the truck to an old neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old neon sign of a closed restaurant visible, showing red pipes that flicker erratically with one letter dimming and part of the logo falling into shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059200033545494 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895591974258423 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059200033545494, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059200033545494, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0788969025015831, + 0.05573461949825287, + 0.04150108993053436, + 0.4497343897819519, + 0.08992298692464828, + 0.040963273495435715, + 0.03873474895954132, + 0.08568808436393738, + 0.0903337299823761, + 0.028490189462900162 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059200033545494 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on deserted city streets with black asphalt that appears rain-slicked and gleaming?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone, stationary municipal maintenance truck visible in the middle of the street with faded orange paint and smeared grime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do amber warning lights on the truck flicker slowly, casting a rhythmic pulse that reflects in shallow puddles on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate advance (dolly in) that starts wide at eye level and narrows focus past the truck to an old neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the old neon sign of a closed restaurant visible, showing red pipes that flicker erratically with one letter dimming and part of the logo falling into shadow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054964903742074966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929965019226074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054964903742074966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054964903742074966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17123572528362274, + 0.059171468019485474, + 0.05107569694519043, + 0.23656713962554932, + 0.049268145114183426, + 0.059198956936597824, + 0.09755447506904602, + 0.10623597353696823, + 0.1052006334066391, + 0.06449177861213684 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054964903742074966 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_11/index_tensor([2803, 2803])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_11/index_tensor([2803, 2803])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..24b2412a788895f83fcce7f2e50453dfebeb4a1c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_11/index_tensor([2803, 2803])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An epic wide-angle shot, captured from behind and sideways in a fluid drone-like perspective, follows a young man with delicate features and a spirit, capturing his entire body. He wears a flowing white silk Hanfu suit, its wide cuffs and hem embroidered with pale cyan cloud patterns. His long black hair is tied back with a simple jade hairpin, strands dancing freely in the wind. His feet rest firmly on a vast, shimmering ribbon of silk, seemingly woven from liquid light and silk. The silk, with its iridescent sheen, leaves a fleeting, dazzling trail in the air. With a carefree and effortless grace, the young man glides through this wondrous landscape, composed entirely of the lush green of classical Chinese landscape painting. His body tilts gracefully with the undulations of the silk, his arms slightly outstretched for balance, his face radiating pure joy and confidence. He journeys among precipitous, pen-shaped peaks, rendered in vast expanses of azurite and ochre, their contours outlined in pale gold, plunging into the thick, swirling sea of mist below. Soft, diffused sunlight pierces the mist, casting a tranquil, dreamy halo over the cool-toned scene. This highlights the dynamic beauty of the young man's white robe fluttering in the wind, creating a majestic atmosphere of otherworldliness and free flight.", + "seed": 15595, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_11/index_2803_seed_15595_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.01161327906884253, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01161327906884253, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01161327906884253, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned behind and to the side of the subject in a wide-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young man wearing a flowing white silk Hanfu suit with pale cyan cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject gliding on a vast, shimmering ribbon of silk that leaves a trailing effect in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of lush green classical Chinese landscape painting elements with pen-shaped peaks in azurite and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with thick swirling mist and soft diffused sunlight creating a cool-toned atmosphere?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029914487153291702 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.654914379119873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029914487153291702, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029914487153291702, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05151038616895676, + 0.07815256714820862, + 0.04209597036242485, + 0.043557893484830856, + 0.03090379573404789, + 0.0318804495036602, + 0.6518164277076721, + 0.018335601314902306, + 0.021505247801542282, + 0.03024166077375412 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029914487153291702 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned behind and to the side of the subject in a wide-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young man wearing a flowing white silk Hanfu suit with pale cyan cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject gliding on a vast, shimmering ribbon of silk that leaves a trailing effect in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of lush green classical Chinese landscape painting elements with pen-shaped peaks in azurite and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with thick swirling mist and soft diffused sunlight creating a cool-toned atmosphere?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016070714220404625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14107084274292 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016070714220404625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016070714220404625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08015663921833038, + 0.05761180818080902, + 0.07796287536621094, + 0.18128299713134766, + 0.019739016890525818, + 0.1223883181810379, + 0.21330177783966064, + 0.07955879718065262, + 0.07128088176250458, + 0.09671688079833984 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016070714220404625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned behind and to the side of the subject in a wide-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young man wearing a flowing white silk Hanfu suit with pale cyan cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject gliding on a vast, shimmering ribbon of silk that leaves a trailing effect in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of lush green classical Chinese landscape painting elements with pen-shaped peaks in azurite and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with thick swirling mist and soft diffused sunlight creating a cool-toned atmosphere?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002815808402374387 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778157234191895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002815808402374387, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002815808402374387, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13002315163612366, + 0.061850570142269135, + 0.09839948266744614, + 0.07739103585481644, + 0.032783739268779755, + 0.08025261759757996, + 0.2592989504337311, + 0.0605592280626297, + 0.1259307712316513, + 0.07351041585206985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002815808402374387 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned behind and to the side of the subject in a wide-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young man wearing a flowing white silk Hanfu suit with pale cyan cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject gliding on a vast, shimmering ribbon of silk that leaves a trailing effect in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of lush green classical Chinese landscape painting elements with pen-shaped peaks in azurite and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with thick swirling mist and soft diffused sunlight creating a cool-toned atmosphere?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004631980787962675 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379631996154785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004631980787962675, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004631980787962675, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21390041708946228, + 0.0772792398929596, + 0.026900550350546837, + 0.10958902537822723, + 0.07620830833911896, + 0.1035887748003006, + 0.25738033652305603, + 0.02693047933280468, + 0.052230603992938995, + 0.055992238223552704 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004631980787962675 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned behind and to the side of the subject in a wide-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young man wearing a flowing white silk Hanfu suit with pale cyan cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject gliding on a vast, shimmering ribbon of silk that leaves a trailing effect in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of lush green classical Chinese landscape painting elements with pen-shaped peaks in azurite and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with thick swirling mist and soft diffused sunlight creating a cool-toned atmosphere?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004633404780179262 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.37963342666626 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004633404780179262, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004633404780179262, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05135698616504669, + 0.04532682150602341, + 0.03642897680401802, + 0.05047321692109108, + 0.05377071350812912, + 0.09620178490877151, + 0.46596503257751465, + 0.06359643489122391, + 0.0995265319943428, + 0.03735344856977463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004633404780179262 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic wide-angle shot, captured from behind and sideways in a fluid drone-like perspective, follows a young man with delicate features and a spirit, capturing his entire body. He wears a flowing white silk Hanfu suit, its wide cuffs and hem embroidered with pale cyan cloud patterns. His long black hair is tied back with a simple jade hairpin, strands dancing freely in the wind. His feet rest firmly on a vast, shimmering ribbon of silk, seemingly woven from liquid light and silk. The silk, with its iridescent sheen, leaves a fleeting, dazzling trail in the air. With a carefree and effortless grace, the young man glides through this wondrous landscape, composed entirely of the lush green of classical Chinese landscape painting. His body tilts gracefully with the undulations of the silk, his arms slightly outstretched for balance, his face radiating pure joy and confidence. He journeys among precipitous, pen-shaped peaks, rendered in vast expanses of azurite and ochre, their contours outlined in pale gold, plunging into the thick, swirling sea of mist below. Soft, diffused sunlight pierces the mist, casting a tranquil, dreamy halo over the cool-toned scene. This highlights the dynamic beauty of the young man's white robe fluttering in the wind, creating a majestic atmosphere of otherworldliness and free flight.", + "seed": 15596, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_11/index_2803_seed_15596_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.017308212956413625, + "vlm_logprob": -0.017308212956413625, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.017308212956413625, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned behind and to the side of the subject in a wide-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young man wearing a flowing white silk Hanfu suit with pale cyan cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject gliding on a vast, shimmering ribbon of silk that leaves a trailing effect in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of lush green classical Chinese landscape painting elements with pen-shaped peaks in azurite and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with thick swirling mist and soft diffused sunlight creating a cool-toned atmosphere?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05522077903151512 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.05522084236145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05522077903151512, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05522077903151512, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1513674408197403, + 0.07550433278083801, + 0.38790780305862427, + 0.04486897960305214, + 0.04016274958848953, + 0.046230215579271317, + 0.05728313326835632, + 0.03779052942991257, + 0.059904783964157104, + 0.09898006170988083 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05522077903151512 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned behind and to the side of the subject in a wide-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young man wearing a flowing white silk Hanfu suit with pale cyan cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject gliding on a vast, shimmering ribbon of silk that leaves a trailing effect in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of lush green classical Chinese landscape painting elements with pen-shaped peaks in azurite and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with thick swirling mist and soft diffused sunlight creating a cool-toned atmosphere?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819128356873989 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018191337585449 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819128356873989, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819128356873989, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07751498371362686, + 0.20749598741531372, + 0.30782344937324524, + 0.038496021181344986, + 0.05797913670539856, + 0.08417423814535141, + 0.13785402476787567, + 0.02302667126059532, + 0.033407654613256454, + 0.03222792595624924 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819128356873989 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned behind and to the side of the subject in a wide-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young man wearing a flowing white silk Hanfu suit with pale cyan cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject gliding on a vast, shimmering ribbon of silk that leaves a trailing effect in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of lush green classical Chinese landscape painting elements with pen-shaped peaks in azurite and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with thick swirling mist and soft diffused sunlight creating a cool-toned atmosphere?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005943363532423973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130943298339844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005943363532423973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005943363532423973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17810901999473572, + 0.07040343433618546, + 0.08395036309957504, + 0.06561002135276794, + 0.02435542829334736, + 0.04131365567445755, + 0.3625602722167969, + 0.037588734179735184, + 0.07165973633527756, + 0.06444933265447617 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005943363532423973 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned behind and to the side of the subject in a wide-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young man wearing a flowing white silk Hanfu suit with pale cyan cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject gliding on a vast, shimmering ribbon of silk that leaves a trailing effect in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of lush green classical Chinese landscape painting elements with pen-shaped peaks in azurite and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with thick swirling mist and soft diffused sunlight creating a cool-toned atmosphere?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019370617810636759 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251936912536621 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019370617810636759, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019370617810636759, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08443435281515121, + 0.08423051238059998, + 0.3470264971256256, + 0.041263800114393234, + 0.021507663652300835, + 0.09068325161933899, + 0.1197308748960495, + 0.07036925107240677, + 0.05808509513735771, + 0.08266869187355042 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019370617810636759 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned behind and to the side of the subject in a wide-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young man wearing a flowing white silk Hanfu suit with pale cyan cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject gliding on a vast, shimmering ribbon of silk that leaves a trailing effect in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of lush green classical Chinese landscape painting elements with pen-shaped peaks in azurite and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with thick swirling mist and soft diffused sunlight creating a cool-toned atmosphere?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005248576868325472 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255248546600342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005248576868325472, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005248576868325472, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21505343914031982, + 0.120489202439785, + 0.13697148859500885, + 0.05534551292657852, + 0.019582321867346764, + 0.05003378167748451, + 0.1494694948196411, + 0.07085903733968735, + 0.05186586454510689, + 0.13032987713813782 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005248576868325472 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic wide-angle shot, captured from behind and sideways in a fluid drone-like perspective, follows a young man with delicate features and a spirit, capturing his entire body. He wears a flowing white silk Hanfu suit, its wide cuffs and hem embroidered with pale cyan cloud patterns. His long black hair is tied back with a simple jade hairpin, strands dancing freely in the wind. His feet rest firmly on a vast, shimmering ribbon of silk, seemingly woven from liquid light and silk. The silk, with its iridescent sheen, leaves a fleeting, dazzling trail in the air. With a carefree and effortless grace, the young man glides through this wondrous landscape, composed entirely of the lush green of classical Chinese landscape painting. His body tilts gracefully with the undulations of the silk, his arms slightly outstretched for balance, his face radiating pure joy and confidence. He journeys among precipitous, pen-shaped peaks, rendered in vast expanses of azurite and ochre, their contours outlined in pale gold, plunging into the thick, swirling sea of mist below. Soft, diffused sunlight pierces the mist, casting a tranquil, dreamy halo over the cool-toned scene. This highlights the dynamic beauty of the young man's white robe fluttering in the wind, creating a majestic atmosphere of otherworldliness and free flight.", + "seed": 15597, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_11/index_2803_seed_15597_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.012203662609681486, + "vlm_logprob": -0.012203662609681486, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.012203662609681486, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned behind and to the side of the subject in a wide-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young man wearing a flowing white silk Hanfu suit with pale cyan cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject gliding on a vast, shimmering ribbon of silk that leaves a trailing effect in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of lush green classical Chinese landscape painting elements with pen-shaped peaks in azurite and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with thick swirling mist and soft diffused sunlight creating a cool-toned atmosphere?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03385772183537483 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.533857822418213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03385772183537483, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03385772183537483, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34432879090309143, + 0.11326766014099121, + 0.04900359734892845, + 0.05472232773900032, + 0.09231773018836975, + 0.10613928735256195, + 0.06444575637578964, + 0.06743813306093216, + 0.061276938766241074, + 0.047059740871191025 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03385772183537483 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned behind and to the side of the subject in a wide-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young man wearing a flowing white silk Hanfu suit with pale cyan cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject gliding on a vast, shimmering ribbon of silk that leaves a trailing effect in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of lush green classical Chinese landscape painting elements with pen-shaped peaks in azurite and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with thick swirling mist and soft diffused sunlight creating a cool-toned atmosphere?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014206229709088802 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264206409454346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014206229709088802, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014206229709088802, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1918065994977951, + 0.12008745968341827, + 0.08386008441448212, + 0.09095485508441925, + 0.08022160828113556, + 0.04227420315146446, + 0.12706831097602844, + 0.06708545982837677, + 0.09679418802261353, + 0.09984728693962097 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014206229709088802 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned behind and to the side of the subject in a wide-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young man wearing a flowing white silk Hanfu suit with pale cyan cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject gliding on a vast, shimmering ribbon of silk that leaves a trailing effect in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of lush green classical Chinese landscape painting elements with pen-shaped peaks in azurite and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with thick swirling mist and soft diffused sunlight creating a cool-toned atmosphere?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005250474438071251 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255250453948975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005250474438071251, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005250474438071251, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.385598748922348, + 0.049715425819158554, + 0.027962252497673035, + 0.07917682826519012, + 0.14431877434253693, + 0.17582593858242035, + 0.05115353688597679, + 0.03661416843533516, + 0.02737892046570778, + 0.02225535549223423 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005250474438071251 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned behind and to the side of the subject in a wide-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young man wearing a flowing white silk Hanfu suit with pale cyan cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject gliding on a vast, shimmering ribbon of silk that leaves a trailing effect in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of lush green classical Chinese landscape painting elements with pen-shaped peaks in azurite and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with thick swirling mist and soft diffused sunlight creating a cool-toned atmosphere?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036114726681262255 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.6286115646362305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036114726681262255, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036114726681262255, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20857614278793335, + 0.2523796558380127, + 0.05171772837638855, + 0.09985852241516113, + 0.10973000526428223, + 0.06337849795818329, + 0.04827916994690895, + 0.062316276133060455, + 0.06317819654941559, + 0.04058580473065376 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036114726681262255 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned behind and to the side of the subject in a wide-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young man wearing a flowing white silk Hanfu suit with pale cyan cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject gliding on a vast, shimmering ribbon of silk that leaves a trailing effect in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of lush green classical Chinese landscape painting elements with pen-shaped peaks in azurite and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with thick swirling mist and soft diffused sunlight creating a cool-toned atmosphere?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040924143977463245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504092216491699 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040924143977463245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040924143977463245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36812546849250793, + 0.09452100843191147, + 0.07694011926651001, + 0.054872818291187286, + 0.02896048128604889, + 0.061654139310121536, + 0.0526239387691021, + 0.16336974501609802, + 0.031169166788458824, + 0.06776309013366699 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040924143977463245 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic wide-angle shot, captured from behind and sideways in a fluid drone-like perspective, follows a young man with delicate features and a spirit, capturing his entire body. He wears a flowing white silk Hanfu suit, its wide cuffs and hem embroidered with pale cyan cloud patterns. His long black hair is tied back with a simple jade hairpin, strands dancing freely in the wind. His feet rest firmly on a vast, shimmering ribbon of silk, seemingly woven from liquid light and silk. The silk, with its iridescent sheen, leaves a fleeting, dazzling trail in the air. With a carefree and effortless grace, the young man glides through this wondrous landscape, composed entirely of the lush green of classical Chinese landscape painting. His body tilts gracefully with the undulations of the silk, his arms slightly outstretched for balance, his face radiating pure joy and confidence. He journeys among precipitous, pen-shaped peaks, rendered in vast expanses of azurite and ochre, their contours outlined in pale gold, plunging into the thick, swirling sea of mist below. Soft, diffused sunlight pierces the mist, casting a tranquil, dreamy halo over the cool-toned scene. This highlights the dynamic beauty of the young man's white robe fluttering in the wind, creating a majestic atmosphere of otherworldliness and free flight.", + "seed": 15598, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_11/index_2803_seed_15598_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.015238838829100132, + "vlm_logprob": -0.015238838829100132, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.015238838829100132, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned behind and to the side of the subject in a wide-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young man wearing a flowing white silk Hanfu suit with pale cyan cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject gliding on a vast, shimmering ribbon of silk that leaves a trailing effect in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of lush green classical Chinese landscape painting elements with pen-shaped peaks in azurite and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with thick swirling mist and soft diffused sunlight creating a cool-toned atmosphere?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03830360621213913 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5383036136627197 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03830360621213913, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03830360621213913, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19570066034793854, + 0.07331190258264542, + 0.05192619562149048, + 0.1889839768409729, + 0.09558103233575821, + 0.07836825400590897, + 0.09815841913223267, + 0.03782831132411957, + 0.12069995701313019, + 0.05944129079580307 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03830360621213913 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned behind and to the side of the subject in a wide-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young man wearing a flowing white silk Hanfu suit with pale cyan cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject gliding on a vast, shimmering ribbon of silk that leaves a trailing effect in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of lush green classical Chinese landscape painting elements with pen-shaped peaks in azurite and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with thick swirling mist and soft diffused sunlight creating a cool-toned atmosphere?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329995296895504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732999324798584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329995296895504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329995296895504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26333925127983093, + 0.06678823381662369, + 0.08173052966594696, + 0.07862337678670883, + 0.03581053763628006, + 0.11240905523300171, + 0.028022101148962975, + 0.04105978086590767, + 0.19186654686927795, + 0.10035063326358795 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329995296895504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned behind and to the side of the subject in a wide-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young man wearing a flowing white silk Hanfu suit with pale cyan cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject gliding on a vast, shimmering ribbon of silk that leaves a trailing effect in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of lush green classical Chinese landscape painting elements with pen-shaped peaks in azurite and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with thick swirling mist and soft diffused sunlight creating a cool-toned atmosphere?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052503556944429874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255250453948975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052503556944429874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052503556944429874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26717978715896606, + 0.08477810025215149, + 0.09784719347953796, + 0.04854849725961685, + 0.07958290725946426, + 0.14482587575912476, + 0.11069672554731369, + 0.043658800423145294, + 0.0861530527472496, + 0.036729056388139725 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052503556944429874 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned behind and to the side of the subject in a wide-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young man wearing a flowing white silk Hanfu suit with pale cyan cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject gliding on a vast, shimmering ribbon of silk that leaves a trailing effect in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of lush green classical Chinese landscape painting elements with pen-shaped peaks in azurite and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with thick swirling mist and soft diffused sunlight creating a cool-toned atmosphere?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005248458590358496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255248546600342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005248458590358496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005248458590358496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11024756729602814, + 0.061528295278549194, + 0.10139789432287216, + 0.09346333891153336, + 0.14939817786216736, + 0.04255300387740135, + 0.12473279982805252, + 0.06706783175468445, + 0.07874143868684769, + 0.17086966335773468 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005248458590358496 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned behind and to the side of the subject in a wide-angle shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young man wearing a flowing white silk Hanfu suit with pale cyan cloud embroidery?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the subject gliding on a vast, shimmering ribbon of silk that leaves a trailing effect in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of lush green classical Chinese landscape painting elements with pen-shaped peaks in azurite and ochre?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filled with thick swirling mist and soft diffused sunlight creating a cool-toned atmosphere?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004091820679605007 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504091739654541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004091820679605007, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004091820679605007, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20735667645931244, + 0.059869349002838135, + 0.05168236047029495, + 0.1218634769320488, + 0.1741478592157364, + 0.058927930891513824, + 0.15038952231407166, + 0.020525500178337097, + 0.10240951180458069, + 0.05282771959900856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004091820679605007 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_12/index_tensor([5810, 5810])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_12/index_tensor([5810, 5810])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..09207128b01999601ceb491ab117a1f1fc329ff1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_12/index_tensor([5810, 5810])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up shot from a level angle features a mechanical tentacle constructed of matte black composite material and a human finger. The tentacle, covered in delicate wiring, is etched with a dense network of microcircuits, almost resembling biological neurons. Under the even, soft overhead lighting, these circuits reflect a faint blue-green glow. At the tip of the tentacle is a precision probe crafted from highly polished chrome alloy, gleaming with a cold metallic sheen. Its sharp, mirrored highlights contrast starkly with the matte texture of the tentacle itself. With steady, almost silent movements, it cautiously and tentatively approaches the tip of a human index finger on the other side of the frame. The skin on this fingertip exhibits a healthy, warm hue, the fine texture of the fingerprint clearly visible in the soft light, revealing the softness and warmth of life. When the cold metal tip finally touches the warm skin, it indents the soft pad of the finger, a moment of contact captured with pinpoint precision. The background of the entire scene is blurred into a soft, technologically-sounding cool grey tone. The main tones are composed of the cool black of machinery, the silver-white of metal, and the warm pink of skin, creating a focused, tranquil, yet futuristic tension, profoundly exploring the delicate first contact between man-made objects and natural life.", + "seed": 20410, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_12/index_5810_seed_20410_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0898166973143816, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0898166973143816, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.174999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0898166973143816, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical tentacle made of matte black composite material with visible wiring and microcircuits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle tip feature a highly polished chrome alloy probe that reflects a cold metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the human index finger show warm skin tones with clearly visible fingerprint texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the chrome probe touching the finger pad and indenting the soft skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04945996403694153 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.174459934234619 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04945996403694153, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04945996403694153, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32448819279670715, + 0.09090791642665863, + 0.057248469442129135, + 0.054435111582279205, + 0.06529322266578674, + 0.0462363101541996, + 0.07564572989940643, + 0.08516351878643036, + 0.12164197117090225, + 0.07893948256969452 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04945996403694153 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical tentacle made of matte black composite material with visible wiring and microcircuits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle tip feature a highly polished chrome alloy probe that reflects a cold metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the human index finger show warm skin tones with clearly visible fingerprint texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the chrome probe touching the finger pad and indenting the soft skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31351250410079956 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3135125637054443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31351250410079956, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31351250410079956, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3404751718044281, + 0.14935220777988434, + 0.16343151032924652, + 0.12726958096027374, + 0.052376244217157364, + 0.07640114426612854, + 0.02066253498196602, + 0.01929699443280697, + 0.037353117018938065, + 0.013381497003138065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31351250410079956 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical tentacle made of matte black composite material with visible wiring and microcircuits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle tip feature a highly polished chrome alloy probe that reflects a cold metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the human index finger show warm skin tones with clearly visible fingerprint texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the chrome probe touching the finger pad and indenting the soft skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0298132486641407 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529813289642334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0298132486641407, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0298132486641407, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7736114859580994, + 0.042415160685777664, + 0.05799335241317749, + 0.039281461387872696, + 0.018387384712696075, + 0.013334764167666435, + 0.008821919560432434, + 0.019230835139751434, + 0.01585899293422699, + 0.01106457319110632 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0298132486641407 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical tentacle made of matte black composite material with visible wiring and microcircuits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle tip feature a highly polished chrome alloy probe that reflects a cold metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the human index finger show warm skin tones with clearly visible fingerprint texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the chrome probe touching the finger pad and indenting the soft skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018197255209088326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018197059631348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018197255209088326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018197255209088326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10595695674419403, + 0.05753587186336517, + 0.03469057008624077, + 0.06143117696046829, + 0.2938796579837799, + 0.16436144709587097, + 0.08585034310817719, + 0.12504842877388, + 0.04405924305319786, + 0.027186313644051552 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018197255209088326 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical tentacle made of matte black composite material with visible wiring and microcircuits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle tip feature a highly polished chrome alloy probe that reflects a cold metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the human index finger show warm skin tones with clearly visible fingerprint texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the chrome probe touching the finger pad and indenting the soft skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810051456093788 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288100481033325 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810051456093788, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810051456093788, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24228346347808838, + 0.08869760483503342, + 0.03365189582109451, + 0.04653514549136162, + 0.19512106478214264, + 0.04217519983649254, + 0.07471276074647903, + 0.03159031271934509, + 0.20300281047821045, + 0.042229749262332916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810051456093788 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up shot from a level angle features a mechanical tentacle constructed of matte black composite material and a human finger. The tentacle, covered in delicate wiring, is etched with a dense network of microcircuits, almost resembling biological neurons. Under the even, soft overhead lighting, these circuits reflect a faint blue-green glow. At the tip of the tentacle is a precision probe crafted from highly polished chrome alloy, gleaming with a cold metallic sheen. Its sharp, mirrored highlights contrast starkly with the matte texture of the tentacle itself. With steady, almost silent movements, it cautiously and tentatively approaches the tip of a human index finger on the other side of the frame. The skin on this fingertip exhibits a healthy, warm hue, the fine texture of the fingerprint clearly visible in the soft light, revealing the softness and warmth of life. When the cold metal tip finally touches the warm skin, it indents the soft pad of the finger, a moment of contact captured with pinpoint precision. The background of the entire scene is blurred into a soft, technologically-sounding cool grey tone. The main tones are composed of the cool black of machinery, the silver-white of metal, and the warm pink of skin, creating a focused, tranquil, yet futuristic tension, profoundly exploring the delicate first contact between man-made objects and natural life.", + "seed": 20411, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_12/index_5810_seed_20411_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.09171476624906064, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09171476624906064, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09171476624906064, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical tentacle made of matte black composite material with visible wiring and microcircuits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle tip feature a highly polished chrome alloy probe that reflects a cold metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the human index finger show warm skin tones with clearly visible fingerprint texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the chrome probe touching the finger pad and indenting the soft skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1311926245689392 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.631192684173584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1311926245689392, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1311926245689392, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14892753958702087, + 0.049733225256204605, + 0.056585948914289474, + 0.027042213827371597, + 0.319074809551239, + 0.1617172360420227, + 0.12304114550352097, + 0.045479174703359604, + 0.034315358847379684, + 0.03408340737223625 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1311926245689392 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical tentacle made of matte black composite material with visible wiring and microcircuits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle tip feature a highly polished chrome alloy probe that reflects a cold metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the human index finger show warm skin tones with clearly visible fingerprint texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the chrome probe touching the finger pad and indenting the soft skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17996205389499664 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049620389938354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17996205389499664, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17996205389499664, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0341128446161747, + 0.06643354147672653, + 0.02880426123738289, + 0.04316766932606697, + 0.6408158540725708, + 0.06878422945737839, + 0.07959219068288803, + 0.016514580696821213, + 0.004434332717210054, + 0.017340460792183876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17996205389499664 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical tentacle made of matte black composite material with visible wiring and microcircuits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle tip feature a highly polished chrome alloy probe that reflects a cold metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the human index finger show warm skin tones with clearly visible fingerprint texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the chrome probe touching the finger pad and indenting the soft skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062060944736003876 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812060832977295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062060944736003876, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062060944736003876, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3252048194408417, + 0.14104890823364258, + 0.05518969148397446, + 0.03224266320466995, + 0.28208982944488525, + 0.05000000447034836, + 0.05328510329127312, + 0.021969377994537354, + 0.01007501594722271, + 0.028894606977701187 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062060944736003876 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical tentacle made of matte black composite material with visible wiring and microcircuits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle tip feature a highly polished chrome alloy probe that reflects a cold metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the human index finger show warm skin tones with clearly visible fingerprint texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the chrome probe touching the finger pad and indenting the soft skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329995296895504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732999324798584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329995296895504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329995296895504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14512062072753906, + 0.23689870536327362, + 0.082978256046772, + 0.12189729511737823, + 0.13064061105251312, + 0.06308712810277939, + 0.07273396104574203, + 0.04996085911989212, + 0.05348554998636246, + 0.04319698363542557 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329995296895504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical tentacle made of matte black composite material with visible wiring and microcircuits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle tip feature a highly polished chrome alloy probe that reflects a cold metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the human index finger show warm skin tones with clearly visible fingerprint texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the chrome probe touching the finger pad and indenting the soft skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062058255076408386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812058210372925 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062058255076408386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062058255076408386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12867645919322968, + 0.07767055183649063, + 0.03317634388804436, + 0.01731538027524948, + 0.5041695833206177, + 0.06998766958713531, + 0.09519952535629272, + 0.02441217191517353, + 0.0275235828012228, + 0.02186877653002739 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062058255076408386 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up shot from a level angle features a mechanical tentacle constructed of matte black composite material and a human finger. The tentacle, covered in delicate wiring, is etched with a dense network of microcircuits, almost resembling biological neurons. Under the even, soft overhead lighting, these circuits reflect a faint blue-green glow. At the tip of the tentacle is a precision probe crafted from highly polished chrome alloy, gleaming with a cold metallic sheen. Its sharp, mirrored highlights contrast starkly with the matte texture of the tentacle itself. With steady, almost silent movements, it cautiously and tentatively approaches the tip of a human index finger on the other side of the frame. The skin on this fingertip exhibits a healthy, warm hue, the fine texture of the fingerprint clearly visible in the soft light, revealing the softness and warmth of life. When the cold metal tip finally touches the warm skin, it indents the soft pad of the finger, a moment of contact captured with pinpoint precision. The background of the entire scene is blurred into a soft, technologically-sounding cool grey tone. The main tones are composed of the cool black of machinery, the silver-white of metal, and the warm pink of skin, creating a focused, tranquil, yet futuristic tension, profoundly exploring the delicate first contact between man-made objects and natural life.", + "seed": 20412, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_12/index_5810_seed_20412_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.2709835052490234, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2709835052490234, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.074999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2709835052490234, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical tentacle made of matte black composite material with visible wiring and microcircuits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle tip feature a highly polished chrome alloy probe that reflects a cold metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the human index finger show warm skin tones with clearly visible fingerprint texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the chrome probe touching the finger pad and indenting the soft skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05235503986477852 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6773550510406494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05235503986477852, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05235503986477852, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23954744637012482, + 0.0901857241988182, + 0.16286517679691315, + 0.0636792853474617, + 0.0742918848991394, + 0.05524681136012077, + 0.1506340205669403, + 0.03747313842177391, + 0.0282098688185215, + 0.09786669164896011 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05235503986477852 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical tentacle made of matte black composite material with visible wiring and microcircuits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle tip feature a highly polished chrome alloy probe that reflects a cold metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the human index finger show warm skin tones with clearly visible fingerprint texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the chrome probe touching the finger pad and indenting the soft skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983616828918457 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233616828918457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8983616828918457, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8983616828918457, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20018261671066284, + 0.12570494413375854, + 0.09478319436311722, + 0.16995880007743835, + 0.10439000278711319, + 0.05044789984822273, + 0.09568530321121216, + 0.05978892371058464, + 0.05709194764494896, + 0.04196629300713539 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8983616828918457 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical tentacle made of matte black composite material with visible wiring and microcircuits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle tip feature a highly polished chrome alloy probe that reflects a cold metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the human index finger show warm skin tones with clearly visible fingerprint texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the chrome probe touching the finger pad and indenting the soft skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16039887070655823 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103988409042358 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16039887070655823, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16039887070655823, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11553968489170074, + 0.10606840252876282, + 0.04085862636566162, + 0.12917733192443848, + 0.3949563503265381, + 0.03770698979496956, + 0.06642085313796997, + 0.035531532019376755, + 0.03152903541922569, + 0.04221120476722717 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16039887070655823 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical tentacle made of matte black composite material with visible wiring and microcircuits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle tip feature a highly polished chrome alloy probe that reflects a cold metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the human index finger show warm skin tones with clearly visible fingerprint texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the chrome probe touching the finger pad and indenting the soft skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018207203596830368 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01820707321167 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018207203596830368, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018207203596830368, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06409220397472382, + 0.19281843304634094, + 0.145701065659523, + 0.041472677141427994, + 0.3809354305267334, + 0.019497176632285118, + 0.11349958181381226, + 0.015186337754130363, + 0.009329036809504032, + 0.017468078061938286 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018207203596830368 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical tentacle made of matte black composite material with visible wiring and microcircuits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle tip feature a highly polished chrome alloy probe that reflects a cold metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the human index finger show warm skin tones with clearly visible fingerprint texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the chrome probe touching the finger pad and indenting the soft skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22559472918510437 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005947589874268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22559472918510437, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22559472918510437, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08708079159259796, + 0.07953212410211563, + 0.060291893780231476, + 0.073765829205513, + 0.5064932107925415, + 0.05108177289366722, + 0.022138403728604317, + 0.03241432085633278, + 0.028494272381067276, + 0.05870732665061951 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22559472918510437 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up shot from a level angle features a mechanical tentacle constructed of matte black composite material and a human finger. The tentacle, covered in delicate wiring, is etched with a dense network of microcircuits, almost resembling biological neurons. Under the even, soft overhead lighting, these circuits reflect a faint blue-green glow. At the tip of the tentacle is a precision probe crafted from highly polished chrome alloy, gleaming with a cold metallic sheen. Its sharp, mirrored highlights contrast starkly with the matte texture of the tentacle itself. With steady, almost silent movements, it cautiously and tentatively approaches the tip of a human index finger on the other side of the frame. The skin on this fingertip exhibits a healthy, warm hue, the fine texture of the fingerprint clearly visible in the soft light, revealing the softness and warmth of life. When the cold metal tip finally touches the warm skin, it indents the soft pad of the finger, a moment of contact captured with pinpoint precision. The background of the entire scene is blurred into a soft, technologically-sounding cool grey tone. The main tones are composed of the cool black of machinery, the silver-white of metal, and the warm pink of skin, creating a focused, tranquil, yet futuristic tension, profoundly exploring the delicate first contact between man-made objects and natural life.", + "seed": 20413, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_12/index_5810_seed_20413_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.11534689851105213, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11534689851105213, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11534689851105213, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical tentacle made of matte black composite material with visible wiring and microcircuits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle tip feature a highly polished chrome alloy probe that reflects a cold metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the human index finger show warm skin tones with clearly visible fingerprint texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the chrome probe touching the finger pad and indenting the soft skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07539445906877518 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.32539439201355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07539445906877518, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07539445906877518, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16163910925388336, + 0.10302282869815826, + 0.08664751052856445, + 0.09013370424509048, + 0.14740081131458282, + 0.16429370641708374, + 0.08551868051290512, + 0.048681873828172684, + 0.03922562301158905, + 0.07343614846467972 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07539445906877518 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical tentacle made of matte black composite material with visible wiring and microcircuits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle tip feature a highly polished chrome alloy probe that reflects a cold metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the human index finger show warm skin tones with clearly visible fingerprint texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the chrome probe touching the finger pad and indenting the soft skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34865590929985046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236559391021729 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34865590929985046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34865590929985046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.49174147844314575, + 0.09935417771339417, + 0.12058531492948532, + 0.03914952278137207, + 0.05301308631896973, + 0.04676759988069534, + 0.03342379257082939, + 0.04154091700911522, + 0.02697475627064705, + 0.04744940623641014 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34865590929985046 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical tentacle made of matte black composite material with visible wiring and microcircuits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle tip feature a highly polished chrome alloy probe that reflects a cold metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the human index finger show warm skin tones with clearly visible fingerprint texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the chrome probe touching the finger pad and indenting the soft skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004104554653168 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950409412384033 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004104554653168, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004104554653168, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4581296741962433, + 0.09344077110290527, + 0.15315376222133636, + 0.04704270139336586, + 0.047524672001600266, + 0.01600736193358898, + 0.035927481949329376, + 0.03575065732002258, + 0.020473066717386246, + 0.09254986047744751 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004104554653168 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical tentacle made of matte black composite material with visible wiring and microcircuits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle tip feature a highly polished chrome alloy probe that reflects a cold metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the human index finger show warm skin tones with clearly visible fingerprint texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the chrome probe touching the finger pad and indenting the soft skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059456892311573 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895594596862793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059456892311573, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059456892311573, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1834000051021576, + 0.13209283351898193, + 0.12397709488868713, + 0.07092592120170593, + 0.15841780602931976, + 0.06912574172019958, + 0.06160383298993111, + 0.04712650179862976, + 0.0365898571908474, + 0.1167404055595398 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059456892311573 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from a level angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mechanical tentacle made of matte black composite material with visible wiring and microcircuits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the tentacle tip feature a highly polished chrome alloy probe that reflects a cold metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the human index finger show warm skin tones with clearly visible fingerprint texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the chrome probe touching the finger pad and indenting the soft skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204850971698761 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120484352111816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204850971698761, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204850971698761, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22908474504947662, + 0.13429364562034607, + 0.15869945287704468, + 0.07368723303079605, + 0.07541927695274353, + 0.037595976144075394, + 0.06780538707971573, + 0.03176821395754814, + 0.021946949884295464, + 0.16969908773899078 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204850971698761 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_13/index_tensor([7630, 7630])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_13/index_tensor([7630, 7630])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3a05b377730567935ad6dfc440a29cd42cb84d04 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_13/index_tensor([7630, 7630])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly and steadily zooms in on a bride nestled within the grand interior of a Gothic cathedral. Her dark brown hair is meticulously tied in a chignon, a few strands carelessly falling around her cheeks. Her features are chiseled, her lips pursed, and her clear eyes are filled with steely determination and unquestionable fortitude, not the shyness of a newlywed. She wears a magnificent white lace wedding gown, its train composed of cascading tulle trailing across the vibrant red velvet carpet. The bodice and long sleeves are embellished with delicate pearls and crystals. The towering stained-glass windows filter the afternoon sunlight into iridescent beams, casting a dazzling radiance on the dust particles floating in the air and the hem of her pristine white dress. In a solemn yet eerie silence, one of her hands steadily and calmly grasped the hilt of the ancient sword hidden at her waist. With a slow, powerful movement, the longsword, gleaming with an icy light, was drawn from its scabbard inch by inch. The slender blade reflected a sharp light, and the sound of metal rubbing was unusually clear and piercing in the empty church. Finally, she pulled the sword completely out, the tip of the sword slightly tilted downwards towards the red carpet. The whole scene was filled with the contradictory tension of holiness and rebellion, and the tranquility contained tremendous power.", + "seed": 10475, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_13/index_7630_seed_10475_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.056680533569306135, + "vlm_logprob": -0.056680533569306135, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.056680533569306135, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the bride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bride wearing a white lace wedding gown with a train of cascading tulle on a red velvet carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bride draw a longsword from its scabbard with a slow, powerful movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering stained-glass windows visible filtering afternoon sunlight into iridescent beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12962697446346283 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.254626989364624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12962697446346283, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12962697446346283, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07895265519618988, + 0.7183675169944763, + 0.014775224961340427, + 0.016159607097506523, + 0.013608574867248535, + 0.05787343531847, + 0.037032175809144974, + 0.02115963213145733, + 0.023247353732585907, + 0.018823806196451187 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12962697446346283 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the bride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bride wearing a white lace wedding gown with a train of cascading tulle on a red velvet carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bride draw a longsword from its scabbard with a slow, powerful movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering stained-glass windows visible filtering afternoon sunlight into iridescent beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205635145306587 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812056303024292 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205635145306587, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205635145306587, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.023128680884838104, + 0.6881214380264282, + 0.011637113057076931, + 0.00894529465585947, + 0.010158948600292206, + 0.07115060836076736, + 0.11325911432504654, + 0.013688959181308746, + 0.04611625894904137, + 0.0137935820966959 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205635145306587 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the bride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bride wearing a white lace wedding gown with a train of cascading tulle on a red velvet carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bride draw a longsword from its scabbard with a slow, powerful movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering stained-glass windows visible filtering afternoon sunlight into iridescent beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0041004871018230915 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504100322723389 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0041004871018230915, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0041004871018230915, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05311683937907219, + 0.5967876315116882, + 0.013002080842852592, + 0.011592622846364975, + 0.01264380756765604, + 0.11789814382791519, + 0.08239028602838516, + 0.01918228343129158, + 0.06761326640844345, + 0.02577301114797592 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0041004871018230915 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the bride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bride wearing a white lace wedding gown with a train of cascading tulle on a red velvet carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bride draw a longsword from its scabbard with a slow, powerful movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering stained-glass windows visible filtering afternoon sunlight into iridescent beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898459583520889 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578984498977661 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898459583520889, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898459583520889, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11208027601242065, + 0.1597261130809784, + 0.030119577422738075, + 0.015080799348652363, + 0.015444830991327763, + 0.1393493413925171, + 0.27809515595436096, + 0.03145342692732811, + 0.14479324221611023, + 0.07385725528001785 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898459583520889 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the bride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bride wearing a white lace wedding gown with a train of cascading tulle on a red velvet carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bride draw a longsword from its scabbard with a slow, powerful movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering stained-glass windows visible filtering afternoon sunlight into iridescent beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00863425899296999 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758634090423584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00863425899296999, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00863425899296999, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05243854224681854, + 0.5854068994522095, + 0.03654157370328903, + 0.010378149338066578, + 0.017416760325431824, + 0.05487224459648132, + 0.1246751919388771, + 0.021804213523864746, + 0.03622134029865265, + 0.060245081782341 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00863425899296999 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly and steadily zooms in on a bride nestled within the grand interior of a Gothic cathedral. Her dark brown hair is meticulously tied in a chignon, a few strands carelessly falling around her cheeks. Her features are chiseled, her lips pursed, and her clear eyes are filled with steely determination and unquestionable fortitude, not the shyness of a newlywed. She wears a magnificent white lace wedding gown, its train composed of cascading tulle trailing across the vibrant red velvet carpet. The bodice and long sleeves are embellished with delicate pearls and crystals. The towering stained-glass windows filter the afternoon sunlight into iridescent beams, casting a dazzling radiance on the dust particles floating in the air and the hem of her pristine white dress. In a solemn yet eerie silence, one of her hands steadily and calmly grasped the hilt of the ancient sword hidden at her waist. With a slow, powerful movement, the longsword, gleaming with an icy light, was drawn from its scabbard inch by inch. The slender blade reflected a sharp light, and the sound of metal rubbing was unusually clear and piercing in the empty church. Finally, she pulled the sword completely out, the tip of the sword slightly tilted downwards towards the red carpet. The whole scene was filled with the contradictory tension of holiness and rebellion, and the tranquility contained tremendous power.", + "seed": 10476, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_13/index_7630_seed_10476_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.20583120519295334, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20583120519295334, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20583120519295334, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the bride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bride wearing a white lace wedding gown with a train of cascading tulle on a red velvet carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bride draw a longsword from its scabbard with a slow, powerful movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering stained-glass windows visible filtering afternoon sunlight into iridescent beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1958056390285492 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8208056688308716 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1958056390285492, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1958056390285492, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05618530139327049, + 0.033947721123695374, + 0.07447677105665207, + 0.03326728567481041, + 0.04379533231258392, + 0.03287491947412491, + 0.0969153642654419, + 0.3112877905368805, + 0.22348268330097198, + 0.09376683831214905 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1958056390285492 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the bride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bride wearing a white lace wedding gown with a train of cascading tulle on a red velvet carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bride draw a longsword from its scabbard with a slow, powerful movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering stained-glass windows visible filtering afternoon sunlight into iridescent beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10033027082681656 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350330352783203 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10033027082681656, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10033027082681656, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05321730300784111, + 0.040026336908340454, + 0.1445290595293045, + 0.058257922530174255, + 0.049505919218063354, + 0.03807250037789345, + 0.29383257031440735, + 0.06294697523117065, + 0.20375308394432068, + 0.055858343839645386 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10033027082681656 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the bride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bride wearing a white lace wedding gown with a train of cascading tulle on a red velvet carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bride draw a longsword from its scabbard with a slow, powerful movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering stained-glass windows visible filtering afternoon sunlight into iridescent beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059529622085392475 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130952835083008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059529622085392475, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059529622085392475, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0947352722287178, + 0.05148177966475487, + 0.18457724153995514, + 0.07687512785196304, + 0.05466476082801819, + 0.042397238314151764, + 0.13300366699695587, + 0.20996779203414917, + 0.08425624668598175, + 0.0680408924818039 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059529622085392475 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the bride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bride wearing a white lace wedding gown with a train of cascading tulle on a red velvet carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bride draw a longsword from its scabbard with a slow, powerful movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering stained-glass windows visible filtering afternoon sunlight into iridescent beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933732032775879 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6933732032775879 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6933732032775879, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6933732032775879, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11193640530109406, + 0.03997980058193207, + 0.08116209506988525, + 0.06670230627059937, + 0.04772462695837021, + 0.04380743205547333, + 0.2713245451450348, + 0.11074553430080414, + 0.1072220578789711, + 0.1193951740860939 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6933732032775879 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the bride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bride wearing a white lace wedding gown with a train of cascading tulle on a red velvet carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bride draw a longsword from its scabbard with a slow, powerful movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering stained-glass windows visible filtering afternoon sunlight into iridescent beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369395062327385 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.40869402885437 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369395062327385, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369395062327385, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.01838771440088749, + 0.018858207389712334, + 0.039950061589479446, + 0.05929875746369362, + 0.013942359015345573, + 0.10119073837995529, + 0.16617846488952637, + 0.29978126287460327, + 0.2216438204050064, + 0.06076868250966072 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369395062327385 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly and steadily zooms in on a bride nestled within the grand interior of a Gothic cathedral. Her dark brown hair is meticulously tied in a chignon, a few strands carelessly falling around her cheeks. Her features are chiseled, her lips pursed, and her clear eyes are filled with steely determination and unquestionable fortitude, not the shyness of a newlywed. She wears a magnificent white lace wedding gown, its train composed of cascading tulle trailing across the vibrant red velvet carpet. The bodice and long sleeves are embellished with delicate pearls and crystals. The towering stained-glass windows filter the afternoon sunlight into iridescent beams, casting a dazzling radiance on the dust particles floating in the air and the hem of her pristine white dress. In a solemn yet eerie silence, one of her hands steadily and calmly grasped the hilt of the ancient sword hidden at her waist. With a slow, powerful movement, the longsword, gleaming with an icy light, was drawn from its scabbard inch by inch. The slender blade reflected a sharp light, and the sound of metal rubbing was unusually clear and piercing in the empty church. Finally, she pulled the sword completely out, the tip of the sword slightly tilted downwards towards the red carpet. The whole scene was filled with the contradictory tension of holiness and rebellion, and the tranquility contained tremendous power.", + "seed": 10477, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_13/index_7630_seed_10477_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06386892199516296, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06386892199516296, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06386892199516296, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the bride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bride wearing a white lace wedding gown with a train of cascading tulle on a red velvet carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bride draw a longsword from its scabbard with a slow, powerful movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering stained-glass windows visible filtering afternoon sunlight into iridescent beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09422481060028076 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5942249298095703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09422481060028076, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09422481060028076, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13431762158870697, + 0.09769357740879059, + 0.053933627903461456, + 0.0466480627655983, + 0.05764760449528694, + 0.11674881726503372, + 0.1043623685836792, + 0.10493101924657822, + 0.1895069032907486, + 0.0942104160785675 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09422481060028076 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the bride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bride wearing a white lace wedding gown with a train of cascading tulle on a red velvet carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bride draw a longsword from its scabbard with a slow, powerful movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering stained-glass windows visible filtering afternoon sunlight into iridescent beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0700429379940033 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695042848587036 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0700429379940033, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0700429379940033, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08021235466003418, + 0.058265358209609985, + 0.03521876037120819, + 0.03263682872056961, + 0.07148465514183044, + 0.1724490225315094, + 0.06989914178848267, + 0.24901555478572845, + 0.1082661896944046, + 0.12255214899778366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0700429379940033 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the bride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bride wearing a white lace wedding gown with a train of cascading tulle on a red velvet carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bride draw a longsword from its scabbard with a slow, powerful movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering stained-glass windows visible filtering afternoon sunlight into iridescent beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011083818972110748 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511083602905273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011083818972110748, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011083818972110748, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1162254586815834, + 0.11682268977165222, + 0.04914317652583122, + 0.04256186634302139, + 0.06130080297589302, + 0.23746056854724884, + 0.07958757877349854, + 0.0792093500494957, + 0.14344897866249084, + 0.0742395669221878 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011083818972110748 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the bride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bride wearing a white lace wedding gown with a train of cascading tulle on a red velvet carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bride draw a longsword from its scabbard with a slow, powerful movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering stained-glass windows visible filtering afternoon sunlight into iridescent beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054965466260910034 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299654960632324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054965466260910034, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054965466260910034, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.060255445539951324, + 0.06837639957666397, + 0.04853728413581848, + 0.04287577420473099, + 0.03828999027609825, + 0.4728347957134247, + 0.05921735242009163, + 0.050290439277887344, + 0.10871992260217667, + 0.05060261860489845 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054965466260910034 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the bride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bride wearing a white lace wedding gown with a train of cascading tulle on a red velvet carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bride draw a longsword from its scabbard with a slow, powerful movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering stained-glass windows visible filtering afternoon sunlight into iridescent beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08902757614850998 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640276432037354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08902757614850998, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08902757614850998, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13762891292572021, + 0.027083905413746834, + 0.33625346422195435, + 0.02807912789285183, + 0.02655964158475399, + 0.07609264552593231, + 0.029467493295669556, + 0.1171305701136589, + 0.15434743463993073, + 0.06735675036907196 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08902757614850998 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly and steadily zooms in on a bride nestled within the grand interior of a Gothic cathedral. Her dark brown hair is meticulously tied in a chignon, a few strands carelessly falling around her cheeks. Her features are chiseled, her lips pursed, and her clear eyes are filled with steely determination and unquestionable fortitude, not the shyness of a newlywed. She wears a magnificent white lace wedding gown, its train composed of cascading tulle trailing across the vibrant red velvet carpet. The bodice and long sleeves are embellished with delicate pearls and crystals. The towering stained-glass windows filter the afternoon sunlight into iridescent beams, casting a dazzling radiance on the dust particles floating in the air and the hem of her pristine white dress. In a solemn yet eerie silence, one of her hands steadily and calmly grasped the hilt of the ancient sword hidden at her waist. With a slow, powerful movement, the longsword, gleaming with an icy light, was drawn from its scabbard inch by inch. The slender blade reflected a sharp light, and the sound of metal rubbing was unusually clear and piercing in the empty church. Finally, she pulled the sword completely out, the tip of the sword slightly tilted downwards towards the red carpet. The whole scene was filled with the contradictory tension of holiness and rebellion, and the tranquility contained tremendous power.", + "seed": 10478, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_13/index_7630_seed_10478_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.12818943038582803, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12818943038582803, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12818943038582803, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the bride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bride wearing a white lace wedding gown with a train of cascading tulle on a red velvet carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bride draw a longsword from its scabbard with a slow, powerful movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering stained-glass windows visible filtering afternoon sunlight into iridescent beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09844373911619186 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5984437465667725 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09844373911619186, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09844373911619186, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11167243123054504, + 0.06541626155376434, + 0.07745843380689621, + 0.19361330568790436, + 0.0623507983982563, + 0.03478183597326279, + 0.06830542534589767, + 0.18221591413021088, + 0.08909908682107925, + 0.11508642882108688 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09844373911619186 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the bride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bride wearing a white lace wedding gown with a train of cascading tulle on a red velvet carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bride draw a longsword from its scabbard with a slow, powerful movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering stained-glass windows visible filtering afternoon sunlight into iridescent beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900398224592209 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790040493011475 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900398224592209, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900398224592209, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.035574235022068024, + 0.03433777019381523, + 0.053332265466451645, + 0.10809449851512909, + 0.12377601861953735, + 0.02994708903133869, + 0.17135515809059143, + 0.19898158311843872, + 0.19342869520187378, + 0.05117269605398178 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900398224592209 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the bride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bride wearing a white lace wedding gown with a train of cascading tulle on a red velvet carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bride draw a longsword from its scabbard with a slow, powerful movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering stained-glass windows visible filtering afternoon sunlight into iridescent beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00979037955403328 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634790420532227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00979037955403328, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00979037955403328, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07395020872354507, + 0.036743130534887314, + 0.11789358407258987, + 0.12264908850193024, + 0.22226916253566742, + 0.044416338205337524, + 0.10997790843248367, + 0.08061487972736359, + 0.12134072184562683, + 0.07014500349760056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00979037955403328 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the bride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bride wearing a white lace wedding gown with a train of cascading tulle on a red velvet carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bride draw a longsword from its scabbard with a slow, powerful movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering stained-glass windows visible filtering afternoon sunlight into iridescent beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521314024925232 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502131462097168 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521314024925232, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521314024925232, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.058820851147174835, + 0.042897626757621765, + 0.08477900177240372, + 0.07032442837953568, + 0.20699883997440338, + 0.054992131888866425, + 0.24187016487121582, + 0.09893188625574112, + 0.08067042380571365, + 0.059714678674936295 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521314024925232 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily zoom in on the bride?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the bride wearing a white lace wedding gown with a train of cascading tulle on a red velvet carpet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bride draw a longsword from its scabbard with a slow, powerful movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are towering stained-glass windows visible filtering afternoon sunlight into iridescent beams?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20157764852046967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015776634216309 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20157764852046967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20157764852046967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19124415516853333, + 0.15105676651000977, + 0.026428237557411194, + 0.07334399968385696, + 0.06432008743286133, + 0.02794971689581871, + 0.15302202105522156, + 0.10508441925048828, + 0.15543659031391144, + 0.05211407691240311 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20157764852046967 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_14/index_tensor([6372, 6372])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_14/index_tensor([6372, 6372])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b14fd76df4f882912edfb80f5d7911e2c6c2ec25 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_14/index_tensor([6372, 6372])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic low-angle shot begins at the base of a massive jungle tree. The camera tilts upward in a smooth, continuous motion, perfectly tracking the rapid ascent of a small, vibrantly colored lizard. The creature's skin is a captivating mosaic of iridescent scales, shimmering from electric blue to emerald green, with a streak of fiery orange running along its spine. Large golden eyes with piercing vertical pupils dart around vigilantly as the creature climbs decisively and swiftly. Its slender body moves with fluid, sinuous grace, its four-toed feet and tiny, sharp claws securely digging into the gnarled, moss-covered bark of the towering trunk. The surrounding environment is a dense, humid jungle; thick, twisting vines hang down, and exotic plants with dark green, waxy leaves create a layered, out-of-focus background. Dappled sunlight filters through the thick canopy far above, casting shifting patterns of light and shadow throughout the scene, creating a vibrant and immersive atmosphere of wild, untamed nature.", + "seed": 1894, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_14/index_6372_seed_1894_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.020241672266274692, + "vlm_logprob": -0.020241672266274692, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.020241672266274692, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle at the base of a massive jungle tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward in a smooth, continuous motion while tracking a small lizard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard's skin a mosaic of iridescent scales shimmering from electric blue to emerald green with a streak of fiery orange along its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard climbing decisively and swiftly up the gnarled, moss-covered bark of the tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, humid jungle with thick twisting vines and exotic plants featuring dark green, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019259708002209663 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.394259929656982 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019259708002209663, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019259708002209663, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1644797921180725, + 0.054724741727113724, + 0.05197061598300934, + 0.10833828151226044, + 0.07382519543170929, + 0.10808861255645752, + 0.0830441564321518, + 0.08123727887868881, + 0.17653176188468933, + 0.09775951504707336 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019259708002209663 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle at the base of a massive jungle tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward in a smooth, continuous motion while tracking a small lizard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard's skin a mosaic of iridescent scales shimmering from electric blue to emerald green with a streak of fiery orange along its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard climbing decisively and swiftly up the gnarled, moss-covered bark of the tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, humid jungle with thick twisting vines and exotic plants featuring dark green, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026376383379101753 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651376485824585 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026376383379101753, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026376383379101753, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11385441571474075, + 0.10201045125722885, + 0.05983085185289383, + 0.09299849718809128, + 0.11544212698936462, + 0.07306553423404694, + 0.1034715473651886, + 0.16112583875656128, + 0.08805646002292633, + 0.0901443213224411 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026376383379101753 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle at the base of a massive jungle tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward in a smooth, continuous motion while tracking a small lizard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard's skin a mosaic of iridescent scales shimmering from electric blue to emerald green with a streak of fiery orange along its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard climbing decisively and swiftly up the gnarled, moss-covered bark of the tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, humid jungle with thick twisting vines and exotic plants featuring dark green, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026349563151597977 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513495445251465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026349563151597977, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026349563151597977, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07699457556009293, + 0.026138685643672943, + 0.0672900602221489, + 0.15604108572006226, + 0.1792963594198227, + 0.07356822490692139, + 0.052027251571416855, + 0.07058491557836533, + 0.2174711525440216, + 0.08058763295412064 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026349563151597977 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle at the base of a massive jungle tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward in a smooth, continuous motion while tracking a small lizard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard's skin a mosaic of iridescent scales shimmering from electric blue to emerald green with a streak of fiery orange along its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard climbing decisively and swiftly up the gnarled, moss-covered bark of the tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, humid jungle with thick twisting vines and exotic plants featuring dark green, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023279106244444847 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732791900634766 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023279106244444847, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023279106244444847, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0542343370616436, + 0.04586295410990715, + 0.04663870483636856, + 0.06285041570663452, + 0.11328273266553879, + 0.14158067107200623, + 0.09768032282590866, + 0.1272677481174469, + 0.20027002692222595, + 0.11033210903406143 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023279106244444847 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle at the base of a massive jungle tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward in a smooth, continuous motion while tracking a small lizard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard's skin a mosaic of iridescent scales shimmering from electric blue to emerald green with a streak of fiery orange along its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard climbing decisively and swiftly up the gnarled, moss-covered bark of the tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, humid jungle with thick twisting vines and exotic plants featuring dark green, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005943600554019213 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130943775177002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005943600554019213, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005943600554019213, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11617074906826019, + 0.0631333515048027, + 0.0668846145272255, + 0.05535297095775604, + 0.14795497059822083, + 0.08518093824386597, + 0.17195375263690948, + 0.07713431119918823, + 0.07227515429258347, + 0.1439591497182846 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005943600554019213 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic low-angle shot begins at the base of a massive jungle tree. The camera tilts upward in a smooth, continuous motion, perfectly tracking the rapid ascent of a small, vibrantly colored lizard. The creature's skin is a captivating mosaic of iridescent scales, shimmering from electric blue to emerald green, with a streak of fiery orange running along its spine. Large golden eyes with piercing vertical pupils dart around vigilantly as the creature climbs decisively and swiftly. Its slender body moves with fluid, sinuous grace, its four-toed feet and tiny, sharp claws securely digging into the gnarled, moss-covered bark of the towering trunk. The surrounding environment is a dense, humid jungle; thick, twisting vines hang down, and exotic plants with dark green, waxy leaves create a layered, out-of-focus background. Dappled sunlight filters through the thick canopy far above, casting shifting patterns of light and shadow throughout the scene, creating a vibrant and immersive atmosphere of wild, untamed nature.", + "seed": 1895, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_14/index_6372_seed_1895_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03867431422695518, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03867431422695518, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03867431422695518, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle at the base of a massive jungle tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward in a smooth, continuous motion while tracking a small lizard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard's skin a mosaic of iridescent scales shimmering from electric blue to emerald green with a streak of fiery orange along its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard climbing decisively and swiftly up the gnarled, moss-covered bark of the tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, humid jungle with thick twisting vines and exotic plants featuring dark green, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01739249750971794 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.642392635345459 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01739249750971794, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01739249750971794, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2214183658361435, + 0.09185481816530228, + 0.13575945794582367, + 0.14998413622379303, + 0.0388803593814373, + 0.04360612854361534, + 0.042257171124219894, + 0.0649905726313591, + 0.05443247780203819, + 0.15681661665439606 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01739249750971794 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle at the base of a massive jungle tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward in a smooth, continuous motion while tracking a small lizard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard's skin a mosaic of iridescent scales shimmering from electric blue to emerald green with a streak of fiery orange along its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard climbing decisively and swiftly up the gnarled, moss-covered bark of the tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, humid jungle with thick twisting vines and exotic plants featuring dark green, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04310279339551926 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168102741241455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04310279339551926, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04310279339551926, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25841018557548523, + 0.18794381618499756, + 0.1185997724533081, + 0.12474886327981949, + 0.05296644568443298, + 0.03546601161360741, + 0.053521014750003815, + 0.035297997295856476, + 0.08152677118778229, + 0.05151912569999695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04310279339551926 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle at the base of a massive jungle tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward in a smooth, continuous motion while tracking a small lizard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard's skin a mosaic of iridescent scales shimmering from electric blue to emerald green with a streak of fiery orange along its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard climbing decisively and swiftly up the gnarled, moss-covered bark of the tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, humid jungle with thick twisting vines and exotic plants featuring dark green, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898756861686707 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789875984191895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898756861686707, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898756861686707, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12562580406665802, + 0.22231385111808777, + 0.1980995386838913, + 0.24615757167339325, + 0.046567969024181366, + 0.020933957770466805, + 0.03730956092476845, + 0.02480356954038143, + 0.030143978074193, + 0.048044122755527496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898756861686707 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle at the base of a massive jungle tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward in a smooth, continuous motion while tracking a small lizard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard's skin a mosaic of iridescent scales shimmering from electric blue to emerald green with a streak of fiery orange along its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard climbing decisively and swiftly up the gnarled, moss-covered bark of the tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, humid jungle with thick twisting vines and exotic plants featuring dark green, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864274337887764 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048642635345459 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864274337887764, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864274337887764, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29853591322898865, + 0.09405764937400818, + 0.05299946293234825, + 0.086182601749897, + 0.11940810829401016, + 0.04222385585308075, + 0.06347686052322388, + 0.05161052197217941, + 0.09413260966539383, + 0.09737235307693481 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864274337887764 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle at the base of a massive jungle tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward in a smooth, continuous motion while tracking a small lizard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard's skin a mosaic of iridescent scales shimmering from electric blue to emerald green with a streak of fiery orange along its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard climbing decisively and swiftly up the gnarled, moss-covered bark of the tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, humid jungle with thick twisting vines and exotic plants featuring dark green, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005245968233793974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255246162414551 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005245968233793974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005245968233793974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21080216765403748, + 0.12893237173557281, + 0.12726084887981415, + 0.11806536465883255, + 0.03389008343219757, + 0.0900280773639679, + 0.07276545464992523, + 0.05134831741452217, + 0.06387297064065933, + 0.1030343696475029 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005245968233793974 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic low-angle shot begins at the base of a massive jungle tree. The camera tilts upward in a smooth, continuous motion, perfectly tracking the rapid ascent of a small, vibrantly colored lizard. The creature's skin is a captivating mosaic of iridescent scales, shimmering from electric blue to emerald green, with a streak of fiery orange running along its spine. Large golden eyes with piercing vertical pupils dart around vigilantly as the creature climbs decisively and swiftly. Its slender body moves with fluid, sinuous grace, its four-toed feet and tiny, sharp claws securely digging into the gnarled, moss-covered bark of the towering trunk. The surrounding environment is a dense, humid jungle; thick, twisting vines hang down, and exotic plants with dark green, waxy leaves create a layered, out-of-focus background. Dappled sunlight filters through the thick canopy far above, casting shifting patterns of light and shadow throughout the scene, creating a vibrant and immersive atmosphere of wild, untamed nature.", + "seed": 1896, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_14/index_6372_seed_1896_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.047839711606502536, + "vlm_logprob": -0.047839711606502536, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5999999761581423, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.047839711606502536, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle at the base of a massive jungle tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward in a smooth, continuous motion while tracking a small lizard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard's skin a mosaic of iridescent scales shimmering from electric blue to emerald green with a streak of fiery orange along its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard climbing decisively and swiftly up the gnarled, moss-covered bark of the tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, humid jungle with thick twisting vines and exotic plants featuring dark green, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01571849174797535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.515718460083008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01571849174797535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01571849174797535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12275548279285431, + 0.05523979291319847, + 0.03653661906719208, + 0.15573693811893463, + 0.03892496973276138, + 0.01596928760409355, + 0.1467713713645935, + 0.24408429861068726, + 0.09042578935623169, + 0.09355545789003372 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01571849174797535 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle at the base of a massive jungle tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward in a smooth, continuous motion while tracking a small lizard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard's skin a mosaic of iridescent scales shimmering from electric blue to emerald green with a streak of fiery orange along its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard climbing decisively and swiftly up the gnarled, moss-covered bark of the tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, humid jungle with thick twisting vines and exotic plants featuring dark green, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04311421141028404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168114185333252 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04311421141028404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04311421141028404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04018097743391991, + 0.030321938917040825, + 0.05744904652237892, + 0.09535932540893555, + 0.025338739156723022, + 0.01745973899960518, + 0.13168717920780182, + 0.4144318401813507, + 0.12706631422042847, + 0.06070481613278389 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04311421141028404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle at the base of a massive jungle tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward in a smooth, continuous motion while tracking a small lizard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard's skin a mosaic of iridescent scales shimmering from electric blue to emerald green with a streak of fiery orange along its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard climbing decisively and swiftly up the gnarled, moss-covered bark of the tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, humid jungle with thick twisting vines and exotic plants featuring dark green, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12708480656147003 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127084732055664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12708480656147003, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12708480656147003, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14065168797969818, + 0.05634431168437004, + 0.03867074102163315, + 0.12050778418779373, + 0.03696192428469658, + 0.019814424216747284, + 0.12995845079421997, + 0.28816184401512146, + 0.050001297146081924, + 0.11892757564783096 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12708480656147003 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle at the base of a massive jungle tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward in a smooth, continuous motion while tracking a small lizard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard's skin a mosaic of iridescent scales shimmering from electric blue to emerald green with a streak of fiery orange along its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard climbing decisively and swiftly up the gnarled, moss-covered bark of the tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, humid jungle with thick twisting vines and exotic plants featuring dark green, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864716902375221 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048647165298462 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864716902375221, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864716902375221, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.097309410572052, + 0.07521641254425049, + 0.1212511882185936, + 0.06461178511381149, + 0.04920582473278046, + 0.03746875748038292, + 0.13433976471424103, + 0.1420542150735855, + 0.1623513400554657, + 0.11619129776954651 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864716902375221 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle at the base of a massive jungle tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward in a smooth, continuous motion while tracking a small lizard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard's skin a mosaic of iridescent scales shimmering from electric blue to emerald green with a streak of fiery orange along its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard climbing decisively and swiftly up the gnarled, moss-covered bark of the tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, humid jungle with thick twisting vines and exotic plants featuring dark green, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004633879289031029 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379633903503418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004633879289031029, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004633879289031029, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12811897695064545, + 0.1510569453239441, + 0.048957906663417816, + 0.1171082854270935, + 0.07733991742134094, + 0.029503485187888145, + 0.14303067326545715, + 0.15102729201316833, + 0.06530120223760605, + 0.08855529129505157 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004633879289031029 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic low-angle shot begins at the base of a massive jungle tree. The camera tilts upward in a smooth, continuous motion, perfectly tracking the rapid ascent of a small, vibrantly colored lizard. The creature's skin is a captivating mosaic of iridescent scales, shimmering from electric blue to emerald green, with a streak of fiery orange running along its spine. Large golden eyes with piercing vertical pupils dart around vigilantly as the creature climbs decisively and swiftly. Its slender body moves with fluid, sinuous grace, its four-toed feet and tiny, sharp claws securely digging into the gnarled, moss-covered bark of the towering trunk. The surrounding environment is a dense, humid jungle; thick, twisting vines hang down, and exotic plants with dark green, waxy leaves create a layered, out-of-focus background. Dappled sunlight filters through the thick canopy far above, casting shifting patterns of light and shadow throughout the scene, creating a vibrant and immersive atmosphere of wild, untamed nature.", + "seed": 1897, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_14/index_6372_seed_1897_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.05515276398509741, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05515276398509741, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05515276398509741, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle at the base of a massive jungle tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward in a smooth, continuous motion while tracking a small lizard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard's skin a mosaic of iridescent scales shimmering from electric blue to emerald green with a streak of fiery orange along its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard climbing decisively and swiftly up the gnarled, moss-covered bark of the tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, humid jungle with thick twisting vines and exotic plants featuring dark green, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.028519030660390854 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7785189151763916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.028519030660390854, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.028519030660390854, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16412866115570068, + 0.10541561990976334, + 0.06446206569671631, + 0.23970924317836761, + 0.07905585318803787, + 0.1126580536365509, + 0.05950845777988434, + 0.048709895461797714, + 0.06174010783433914, + 0.06461207568645477 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.028519030660390854 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle at the base of a massive jungle tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward in a smooth, continuous motion while tracking a small lizard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard's skin a mosaic of iridescent scales shimmering from electric blue to emerald green with a streak of fiery orange along its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard climbing decisively and swiftly up the gnarled, moss-covered bark of the tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, humid jungle with thick twisting vines and exotic plants featuring dark green, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03813425078988075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881343364715576 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03813425078988075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03813425078988075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21121078729629517, + 0.0964055210351944, + 0.05779356136918068, + 0.09810104966163635, + 0.0802803784608841, + 0.18763548135757446, + 0.06112459674477577, + 0.04485377296805382, + 0.06650559604167938, + 0.09608923643827438 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03813425078988075 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle at the base of a massive jungle tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward in a smooth, continuous motion while tracking a small lizard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard's skin a mosaic of iridescent scales shimmering from electric blue to emerald green with a streak of fiery orange along its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard climbing decisively and swiftly up the gnarled, moss-covered bark of the tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, humid jungle with thick twisting vines and exotic plants featuring dark green, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17988835275173187 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804888367652893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17988835275173187, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17988835275173187, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25498732924461365, + 0.17297811806201935, + 0.06541647762060165, + 0.0998985692858696, + 0.04240183159708977, + 0.10634128749370575, + 0.04846448078751564, + 0.06850636005401611, + 0.0635727196931839, + 0.07743291556835175 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17988835275173187 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle at the base of a massive jungle tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward in a smooth, continuous motion while tracking a small lizard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard's skin a mosaic of iridescent scales shimmering from electric blue to emerald green with a streak of fiery orange along its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard climbing decisively and swiftly up the gnarled, moss-covered bark of the tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, humid jungle with thick twisting vines and exotic plants featuring dark green, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02328178472816944 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732818126678467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02328178472816944, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02328178472816944, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12189429253339767, + 0.05919786915183067, + 0.17090262472629547, + 0.2110331803560257, + 0.041737474501132965, + 0.07902655005455017, + 0.05775522440671921, + 0.1360703557729721, + 0.07290555536746979, + 0.049476880580186844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02328178472816944 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle at the base of a massive jungle tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward in a smooth, continuous motion while tracking a small lizard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard's skin a mosaic of iridescent scales shimmering from electric blue to emerald green with a streak of fiery orange along its spine?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lizard climbing decisively and swiftly up the gnarled, moss-covered bark of the tree trunk?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dense, humid jungle with thick twisting vines and exotic plants featuring dark green, waxy leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005940400995314121 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309404373168945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005940400995314121, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005940400995314121, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1353573054075241, + 0.10578160732984543, + 0.08827236294746399, + 0.18740959465503693, + 0.1037074625492096, + 0.12894771993160248, + 0.07725153863430023, + 0.08719795197248459, + 0.03538105636835098, + 0.050693415105342865 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005940400995314121 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_15/index_tensor([5318, 5318])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_15/index_tensor([5318, 5318])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..cbc9868625e0e706cb08266e7b9a1b7ed0cb1a7a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_15/index_tensor([5318, 5318])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, places the viewer in a deserted underground parking garage late at night. The sole source of light comes from an old overhead fluorescent tube, flickering erratically. Each flicker casts long, twisting, dancing shadows across the rough concrete and grease-stained stanchions. Beneath the light, an unidentified figure leans over a lone metal shopping cart. Wearing a baggy, dark gray hoodie, the hood pulled down far enough to almost completely obscure their face, revealing only a taut jawline. Their hands, with a frantic, almost desperate intensity, quickly and frantically rummage through the cart's piled-up debris—tattered newspapers, empty plastic bottles, and a soiled blanket are pushed aside without hesitation, rustling and clattering. Each time the light flickers, the scene is plunged into near-total darkness, save for the faint green glow of the distant fire exit. The cold tones and harsh changes in light and shadow, combined with the urgent and silent search action, create a heart-pounding sense of suspense and claustrophobia.", + "seed": 30709, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_15/index_5318_seed_30709_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.11027919724583626, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11027919724583626, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11027919724583626, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deserted underground parking garage at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the primary light source a single old overhead fluorescent tube that flickers erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an unidentified figure wearing a baggy dark gray hoodie with the hood pulled down visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure frantically rummaging through a lone metal shopping cart containing debris like newspapers and plastic bottles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16099120676517487 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9109911918640137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16099120676517487, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16099120676517487, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17903505265712738, + 0.057458363473415375, + 0.04554995894432068, + 0.04167228937149048, + 0.31036174297332764, + 0.0364350825548172, + 0.06539210677146912, + 0.1315826028585434, + 0.07681898027658463, + 0.05569382384419441 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16099120676517487 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deserted underground parking garage at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the primary light source a single old overhead fluorescent tube that flickers erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an unidentified figure wearing a baggy dark gray hoodie with the hood pulled down visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure frantically rummaging through a lone metal shopping cart containing debris like newspapers and plastic bottles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2016427367925644 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016427516937256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2016427367925644, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2016427367925644, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2528316080570221, + 0.10290224850177765, + 0.07114547491073608, + 0.03038117103278637, + 0.12527810037136078, + 0.048853371292352676, + 0.058935895562171936, + 0.06751848757266998, + 0.09641304612159729, + 0.14574050903320312 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2016427367925644 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deserted underground parking garage at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the primary light source a single old overhead fluorescent tube that flickers erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an unidentified figure wearing a baggy dark gray hoodie with the hood pulled down visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure frantically rummaging through a lone metal shopping cart containing debris like newspapers and plastic bottles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062068674713373184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120687007904053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062068674713373184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062068674713373184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19239945709705353, + 0.13172213733196259, + 0.05462934076786041, + 0.13553966581821442, + 0.08105535060167313, + 0.09241408854722977, + 0.04729029908776283, + 0.04021861031651497, + 0.10565163195133209, + 0.11907941102981567 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062068674713373184 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deserted underground parking garage at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the primary light source a single old overhead fluorescent tube that flickers erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an unidentified figure wearing a baggy dark gray hoodie with the hood pulled down visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure frantically rummaging through a lone metal shopping cart containing debris like newspapers and plastic bottles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02637452632188797 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651374578475952 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02637452632188797, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02637452632188797, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17827889323234558, + 0.11714702844619751, + 0.10181434452533722, + 0.06046202778816223, + 0.0760050117969513, + 0.09237324446439743, + 0.05540774017572403, + 0.09259740263223648, + 0.08923672884702682, + 0.13667753338813782 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02637452632188797 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deserted underground parking garage at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the primary light source a single old overhead fluorescent tube that flickers erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an unidentified figure wearing a baggy dark gray hoodie with the hood pulled down visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure frantically rummaging through a lone metal shopping cart containing debris like newspapers and plastic bottles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10031884163618088 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503189086914062 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10031884163618088, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10031884163618088, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1417846530675888, + 0.1017756462097168, + 0.10178911685943604, + 0.1235552653670311, + 0.08982913941144943, + 0.05598517507314682, + 0.05845741555094719, + 0.1186525821685791, + 0.0610090009868145, + 0.1471620351076126 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10031884163618088 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, places the viewer in a deserted underground parking garage late at night. The sole source of light comes from an old overhead fluorescent tube, flickering erratically. Each flicker casts long, twisting, dancing shadows across the rough concrete and grease-stained stanchions. Beneath the light, an unidentified figure leans over a lone metal shopping cart. Wearing a baggy, dark gray hoodie, the hood pulled down far enough to almost completely obscure their face, revealing only a taut jawline. Their hands, with a frantic, almost desperate intensity, quickly and frantically rummage through the cart's piled-up debris—tattered newspapers, empty plastic bottles, and a soiled blanket are pushed aside without hesitation, rustling and clattering. Each time the light flickers, the scene is plunged into near-total darkness, save for the faint green glow of the distant fire exit. The cold tones and harsh changes in light and shadow, combined with the urgent and silent search action, create a heart-pounding sense of suspense and claustrophobia.", + "seed": 30710, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_15/index_5318_seed_30710_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.13726670667529106, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13726670667529106, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13726670667529106, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deserted underground parking garage at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the primary light source a single old overhead fluorescent tube that flickers erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an unidentified figure wearing a baggy dark gray hoodie with the hood pulled down visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure frantically rummaging through a lone metal shopping cart containing debris like newspapers and plastic bottles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18059056997299194 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8055906295776367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18059056997299194, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18059056997299194, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21916908025741577, + 0.02592885121703148, + 0.04964860528707504, + 0.0896381288766861, + 0.04322294890880585, + 0.05356471985578537, + 0.10230857133865356, + 0.3282104730606079, + 0.014484630897641182, + 0.0738239660859108 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18059056997299194 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deserted underground parking garage at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the primary light source a single old overhead fluorescent tube that flickers erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an unidentified figure wearing a baggy dark gray hoodie with the hood pulled down visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure frantically rummaging through a lone metal shopping cart containing debris like newspapers and plastic bottles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22563886642456055 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006388664245605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22563886642456055, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22563886642456055, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2867526412010193, + 0.07649951428174973, + 0.061729371547698975, + 0.05143774673342705, + 0.061542313545942307, + 0.03393840044736862, + 0.053063228726387024, + 0.20398199558258057, + 0.02348770573735237, + 0.14756716787815094 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22563886642456055 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deserted underground parking garage at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the primary light source a single old overhead fluorescent tube that flickers erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an unidentified figure wearing a baggy dark gray hoodie with the hood pulled down visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure frantically rummaging through a lone metal shopping cart containing debris like newspapers and plastic bottles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866420477628708 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048664093017578 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866420477628708, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866420477628708, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06522763520479202, + 0.21160197257995605, + 0.1402442455291748, + 0.08315816521644592, + 0.06383819878101349, + 0.029057204723358154, + 0.05208199471235275, + 0.19081370532512665, + 0.025299599394202232, + 0.13867731392383575 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866420477628708 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deserted underground parking garage at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the primary light source a single old overhead fluorescent tube that flickers erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an unidentified figure wearing a baggy dark gray hoodie with the hood pulled down visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure frantically rummaging through a lone metal shopping cart containing debris like newspapers and plastic bottles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029830489307641983 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298304557800293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029830489307641983, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029830489307641983, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24275611340999603, + 0.0492800809442997, + 0.08329353481531143, + 0.0716666579246521, + 0.10752611607313156, + 0.11068481206893921, + 0.04949268326163292, + 0.18799754977226257, + 0.015972839668393135, + 0.0813295915722847 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029830489307641983 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deserted underground parking garage at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the primary light source a single old overhead fluorescent tube that flickers erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an unidentified figure wearing a baggy dark gray hoodie with the hood pulled down visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure frantically rummaging through a lone metal shopping cart containing debris like newspapers and plastic bottles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20160940289497375 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016093730926514 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20160940289497375, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20160940289497375, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3372332751750946, + 0.04546187445521355, + 0.05473247915506363, + 0.024420348927378654, + 0.05589743331074715, + 0.030625661835074425, + 0.04812871292233467, + 0.2570574879646301, + 0.018027575686573982, + 0.1284150779247284 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20160940289497375 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, places the viewer in a deserted underground parking garage late at night. The sole source of light comes from an old overhead fluorescent tube, flickering erratically. Each flicker casts long, twisting, dancing shadows across the rough concrete and grease-stained stanchions. Beneath the light, an unidentified figure leans over a lone metal shopping cart. Wearing a baggy, dark gray hoodie, the hood pulled down far enough to almost completely obscure their face, revealing only a taut jawline. Their hands, with a frantic, almost desperate intensity, quickly and frantically rummage through the cart's piled-up debris—tattered newspapers, empty plastic bottles, and a soiled blanket are pushed aside without hesitation, rustling and clattering. Each time the light flickers, the scene is plunged into near-total darkness, save for the faint green glow of the distant fire exit. The cold tones and harsh changes in light and shadow, combined with the urgent and silent search action, create a heart-pounding sense of suspense and claustrophobia.", + "seed": 30711, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_15/index_5318_seed_30711_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.22585502713918687, + "vlm_logprob": -0.22585502713918687, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.22585502713918687, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deserted underground parking garage at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the primary light source a single old overhead fluorescent tube that flickers erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an unidentified figure wearing a baggy dark gray hoodie with the hood pulled down visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure frantically rummaging through a lone metal shopping cart containing debris like newspapers and plastic bottles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6348072290420532 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7598072290420532 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6348072290420532, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6348072290420532, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09063684940338135, + 0.09913286566734314, + 0.4005049169063568, + 0.07487227767705917, + 0.04192793369293213, + 0.015092254616320133, + 0.023497449234128, + 0.03609605133533478, + 0.19704872369766235, + 0.0211907047778368 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6348072290420532 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deserted underground parking garage at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the primary light source a single old overhead fluorescent tube that flickers erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an unidentified figure wearing a baggy dark gray hoodie with the hood pulled down visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure frantically rummaging through a lone metal shopping cart containing debris like newspapers and plastic bottles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31352853775024414 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3135285377502441 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31352853775024414, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31352853775024414, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09489671885967255, + 0.11875320225954056, + 0.4548744857311249, + 0.03209121897816658, + 0.04142278432846069, + 0.024574974551796913, + 0.036725301295518875, + 0.06981591880321503, + 0.08803456276655197, + 0.03881082311272621 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31352853775024414 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deserted underground parking garage at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the primary light source a single old overhead fluorescent tube that flickers erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an unidentified figure wearing a baggy dark gray hoodie with the hood pulled down visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure frantically rummaging through a lone metal shopping cart containing debris like newspapers and plastic bottles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062070466578006744 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812070369720459 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062070466578006744, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062070466578006744, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.047549135982990265, + 0.034082163125276566, + 0.8480167388916016, + 0.01023299340158701, + 0.008468320593237877, + 0.006370647810399532, + 0.01680796593427658, + 0.013035460375249386, + 0.005778662394732237, + 0.00965793989598751 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062070466578006744 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deserted underground parking garage at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the primary light source a single old overhead fluorescent tube that flickers erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an unidentified figure wearing a baggy dark gray hoodie with the hood pulled down visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure frantically rummaging through a lone metal shopping cart containing debris like newspapers and plastic bottles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02982933074235916 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529829263687134 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02982933074235916, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02982933074235916, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06780772656202316, + 0.0595080628991127, + 0.650290310382843, + 0.027192430570721626, + 0.032316047698259354, + 0.01799996756017208, + 0.02498392015695572, + 0.0446472205221653, + 0.052889954298734665, + 0.02236441895365715 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02982933074235916 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deserted underground parking garage at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the primary light source a single old overhead fluorescent tube that flickers erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an unidentified figure wearing a baggy dark gray hoodie with the hood pulled down visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure frantically rummaging through a lone metal shopping cart containing debris like newspapers and plastic bottles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08903957158327103 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640395641326904 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08903957158327103, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08903957158327103, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09658917039632797, + 0.1515541672706604, + 0.2144722193479538, + 0.03744405135512352, + 0.09075555950403214, + 0.0276207085698843, + 0.20017020404338837, + 0.051579322665929794, + 0.05224216729402542, + 0.07757249474525452 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08903957158327103 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, places the viewer in a deserted underground parking garage late at night. The sole source of light comes from an old overhead fluorescent tube, flickering erratically. Each flicker casts long, twisting, dancing shadows across the rough concrete and grease-stained stanchions. Beneath the light, an unidentified figure leans over a lone metal shopping cart. Wearing a baggy, dark gray hoodie, the hood pulled down far enough to almost completely obscure their face, revealing only a taut jawline. Their hands, with a frantic, almost desperate intensity, quickly and frantically rummage through the cart's piled-up debris—tattered newspapers, empty plastic bottles, and a soiled blanket are pushed aside without hesitation, rustling and clattering. Each time the light flickers, the scene is plunged into near-total darkness, save for the faint green glow of the distant fire exit. The cold tones and harsh changes in light and shadow, combined with the urgent and silent search action, create a heart-pounding sense of suspense and claustrophobia.", + "seed": 30712, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_15/index_5318_seed_30712_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1349297970533371, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1349297970533371, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1349297970533371, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deserted underground parking garage at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the primary light source a single old overhead fluorescent tube that flickers erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an unidentified figure wearing a baggy dark gray hoodie with the hood pulled down visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure frantically rummaging through a lone metal shopping cart containing debris like newspapers and plastic bottles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22687308490276337 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6018730401992798 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22687308490276337, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22687308490276337, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18069641292095184, + 0.057681649923324585, + 0.040178678929805756, + 0.16361254453659058, + 0.2672097682952881, + 0.027145568281412125, + 0.10457754880189896, + 0.054600782692432404, + 0.050752975046634674, + 0.05354408919811249 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22687308490276337 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deserted underground parking garage at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the primary light source a single old overhead fluorescent tube that flickers erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an unidentified figure wearing a baggy dark gray hoodie with the hood pulled down visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure frantically rummaging through a lone metal shopping cart containing debris like newspapers and plastic bottles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521754801273346 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021754503250122 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521754801273346, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521754801273346, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16374510526657104, + 0.08733883500099182, + 0.06907860189676285, + 0.12227611988782883, + 0.07465260475873947, + 0.13893938064575195, + 0.10169919580221176, + 0.15265558660030365, + 0.03681939095258713, + 0.05279522016644478 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521754801273346 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deserted underground parking garage at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the primary light source a single old overhead fluorescent tube that flickers erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an unidentified figure wearing a baggy dark gray hoodie with the hood pulled down visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure frantically rummaging through a lone metal shopping cart containing debris like newspapers and plastic bottles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11295247077941895 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237952470779419 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11295247077941895, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11295247077941895, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14158308506011963, + 0.2125791311264038, + 0.02861052379012108, + 0.09098125994205475, + 0.1187007799744606, + 0.04125373438000679, + 0.1389365941286087, + 0.14592736959457397, + 0.06000349298119545, + 0.021423952654004097 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11295247077941895 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deserted underground parking garage at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the primary light source a single old overhead fluorescent tube that flickers erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an unidentified figure wearing a baggy dark gray hoodie with the hood pulled down visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure frantically rummaging through a lone metal shopping cart containing debris like newspapers and plastic bottles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020604144781827927 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895604133605957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020604144781827927, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020604144781827927, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21987897157669067, + 0.08409682661294937, + 0.08772999793291092, + 0.1269168257713318, + 0.17805010080337524, + 0.03072456084191799, + 0.041553154587745667, + 0.17500020563602448, + 0.033517222851514816, + 0.022532165050506592 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020604144781827927 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deserted underground parking garage at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the primary light source a single old overhead fluorescent tube that flickers erratically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an unidentified figure wearing a baggy dark gray hoodie with the hood pulled down visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the figure frantically rummaging through a lone metal shopping cart containing debris like newspapers and plastic bottles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera maintain a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204380467534065 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120439052581787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204380467534065, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204380467534065, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08829532563686371, + 0.08962935954332352, + 0.05960579216480255, + 0.08615821599960327, + 0.3367093801498413, + 0.05595063045620918, + 0.050253208726644516, + 0.1083272397518158, + 0.06234434247016907, + 0.06272655725479126 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204380467534065 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_2/index_tensor([7939, 7939])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_2/index_tensor([7939, 7939])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..56d5795c16ee9648cf0574c91e84a26850936782 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_2/index_tensor([7939, 7939])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "super-slow-motion, low-angle tracking shot gracefully circles a majestic Andalusian stallion as it explosively launches from the ground. The entire sequence, captured in a series of incredibly detailed, frozen moments, conveys immense power. With a gleaming dark bay coat and a wild, flowing black mane and tail, the stallion is a study in kinetic energy. In this bullet-like effect, every muscle fiber is visibly tensed and defined, from the way its powerful hips curl and then release power to the taut, rising arc of its body against the sky. As its hooves leave the earth, the camera captures the initial impact, kicking up a cloud of fine golden dust that hangs suspended and illuminated. The scene is set across a vast, arid plain at golden hour; the low-hanging sun casts a brilliant rim light on the horse's body, sculpting its powerful physique and highlighting every whipping of its mane. The background is a soft-focus landscape of distant, hazy mountains against a sky painted in deep oranges and purples, creating a serene yet epic atmosphere of raw, untamed beauty and arrested movement.", + "seed": 5146, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_2/index_7939_seed_5146_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.02083728164434433, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02083728164434433, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02083728164434433, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Andalusian stallion with a dark bay coat and a wild, flowing black mane and tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stallion performing an explosive launch from the ground with visibly tensed muscle fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a cloud of fine golden dust kicked up by the hooves that hangs suspended in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, arid plain at golden hour with distant, hazy mountains and a sky painted in deep oranges and purples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that gracefully circles the horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03486994281411171 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.409869909286499 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03486994281411171, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03486994281411171, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15375429391860962, + 0.11640433967113495, + 0.05642780661582947, + 0.055594608187675476, + 0.07130686938762665, + 0.050886474549770355, + 0.21446435153484344, + 0.18699035048484802, + 0.06667108833789825, + 0.027499856427311897 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03486994281411171 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Andalusian stallion with a dark bay coat and a wild, flowing black mane and tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stallion performing an explosive launch from the ground with visibly tensed muscle fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a cloud of fine golden dust kicked up by the hooves that hangs suspended in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, arid plain at golden hour with distant, hazy mountains and a sky painted in deep oranges and purples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that gracefully circles the horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01820884272456169 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018208980560303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01820884272456169, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01820884272456169, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15402258932590485, + 0.2217685431241989, + 0.10793205350637436, + 0.0795280858874321, + 0.02000795677304268, + 0.04007105901837349, + 0.08916018158197403, + 0.16209718585014343, + 0.021747518330812454, + 0.1036648079752922 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01820884272456169 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Andalusian stallion with a dark bay coat and a wild, flowing black mane and tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stallion performing an explosive launch from the ground with visibly tensed muscle fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a cloud of fine golden dust kicked up by the hooves that hangs suspended in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, arid plain at golden hour with distant, hazy mountains and a sky painted in deep oranges and purples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that gracefully circles the horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005250118672847748 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255249977111816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005250118672847748, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005250118672847748, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26317691802978516, + 0.15561877191066742, + 0.16197212040424347, + 0.04152930527925491, + 0.026856139302253723, + 0.06997022777795792, + 0.05897393450140953, + 0.10464096069335938, + 0.06563776731491089, + 0.051623810082674026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005250118672847748 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Andalusian stallion with a dark bay coat and a wild, flowing black mane and tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stallion performing an explosive launch from the ground with visibly tensed muscle fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a cloud of fine golden dust kicked up by the hooves that hangs suspended in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, arid plain at golden hour with distant, hazy mountains and a sky painted in deep oranges and purples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that gracefully circles the horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002815570682287216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778157234191895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002815570682287216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002815570682287216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18468241393566132, + 0.12391560524702072, + 0.057088643312454224, + 0.09253445267677307, + 0.09371047466993332, + 0.08871126919984818, + 0.06136344000697136, + 0.2113349735736847, + 0.03157424181699753, + 0.055084533989429474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002815570682287216 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Andalusian stallion with a dark bay coat and a wild, flowing black mane and tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stallion performing an explosive launch from the ground with visibly tensed muscle fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a cloud of fine golden dust kicked up by the hooves that hangs suspended in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, arid plain at golden hour with distant, hazy mountains and a sky painted in deep oranges and purples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that gracefully circles the horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043041933327913284 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168041944503784 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043041933327913284, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043041933327913284, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17552314698696136, + 0.2979516386985779, + 0.06698159128427505, + 0.08003171533346176, + 0.02373371087014675, + 0.0342828594148159, + 0.061046551913022995, + 0.16464807093143463, + 0.05550680682063103, + 0.04029395431280136 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043041933327913284 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "super-slow-motion, low-angle tracking shot gracefully circles a majestic Andalusian stallion as it explosively launches from the ground. The entire sequence, captured in a series of incredibly detailed, frozen moments, conveys immense power. With a gleaming dark bay coat and a wild, flowing black mane and tail, the stallion is a study in kinetic energy. In this bullet-like effect, every muscle fiber is visibly tensed and defined, from the way its powerful hips curl and then release power to the taut, rising arc of its body against the sky. As its hooves leave the earth, the camera captures the initial impact, kicking up a cloud of fine golden dust that hangs suspended and illuminated. The scene is set across a vast, arid plain at golden hour; the low-hanging sun casts a brilliant rim light on the horse's body, sculpting its powerful physique and highlighting every whipping of its mane. The background is a soft-focus landscape of distant, hazy mountains against a sky painted in deep oranges and purples, creating a serene yet epic atmosphere of raw, untamed beauty and arrested movement.", + "seed": 5147, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_2/index_7939_seed_5147_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.020445415563881398, + "vlm_logprob": -0.020445415563881398, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.020445415563881398, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Andalusian stallion with a dark bay coat and a wild, flowing black mane and tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stallion performing an explosive launch from the ground with visibly tensed muscle fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a cloud of fine golden dust kicked up by the hooves that hangs suspended in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, arid plain at golden hour with distant, hazy mountains and a sky painted in deep oranges and purples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that gracefully circles the horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03071478381752968 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.530714750289917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03071478381752968, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03071478381752968, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05300861969590187, + 0.057793471962213516, + 0.0642358809709549, + 0.1730431318283081, + 0.3382202386856079, + 0.15204967558383942, + 0.09707045555114746, + 0.013122371397912502, + 0.02517787739634514, + 0.0262782983481884 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03071478381752968 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Andalusian stallion with a dark bay coat and a wild, flowing black mane and tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stallion performing an explosive launch from the ground with visibly tensed muscle fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a cloud of fine golden dust kicked up by the hooves that hangs suspended in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, arid plain at golden hour with distant, hazy mountains and a sky painted in deep oranges and purples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that gracefully circles the horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014212928712368011 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2642130851745605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014212928712368011, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014212928712368011, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06180296465754509, + 0.06081462651491165, + 0.060829050838947296, + 0.15698495507240295, + 0.06647886335849762, + 0.09808631241321564, + 0.27231982350349426, + 0.041835855692625046, + 0.05145382136106491, + 0.12939371168613434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014212928712368011 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Andalusian stallion with a dark bay coat and a wild, flowing black mane and tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stallion performing an explosive launch from the ground with visibly tensed muscle fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a cloud of fine golden dust kicked up by the hooves that hangs suspended in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, arid plain at golden hour with distant, hazy mountains and a sky painted in deep oranges and purples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that gracefully circles the horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011070732958614826 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511070728302002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011070732958614826, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011070732958614826, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05385012552142143, + 0.17106491327285767, + 0.019665956497192383, + 0.12196024507284164, + 0.36087262630462646, + 0.08605233579874039, + 0.041507285088300705, + 0.08324813842773438, + 0.02888030745089054, + 0.03289806470274925 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011070732958614826 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Andalusian stallion with a dark bay coat and a wild, flowing black mane and tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stallion performing an explosive launch from the ground with visibly tensed muscle fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a cloud of fine golden dust kicked up by the hooves that hangs suspended in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, arid plain at golden hour with distant, hazy mountains and a sky painted in deep oranges and purples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that gracefully circles the horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031885281205177307 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753188610076904 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031885281205177307, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031885281205177307, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12980931997299194, + 0.057232603430747986, + 0.0503363162279129, + 0.18970048427581787, + 0.29313790798187256, + 0.12983256578445435, + 0.03731376677751541, + 0.022206248715519905, + 0.0472317710518837, + 0.04319901764392853 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031885281205177307 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Andalusian stallion with a dark bay coat and a wild, flowing black mane and tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stallion performing an explosive launch from the ground with visibly tensed muscle fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a cloud of fine golden dust kicked up by the hooves that hangs suspended in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, arid plain at golden hour with distant, hazy mountains and a sky painted in deep oranges and purples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that gracefully circles the horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04304010421037674 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680400371551514 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04304010421037674, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04304010421037674, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07987944781780243, + 0.04510359838604927, + 0.059753067791461945, + 0.11705320328474045, + 0.30816420912742615, + 0.14198273420333862, + 0.08208250999450684, + 0.08092193305492401, + 0.05624283477663994, + 0.028816459700465202 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04304010421037674 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "super-slow-motion, low-angle tracking shot gracefully circles a majestic Andalusian stallion as it explosively launches from the ground. The entire sequence, captured in a series of incredibly detailed, frozen moments, conveys immense power. With a gleaming dark bay coat and a wild, flowing black mane and tail, the stallion is a study in kinetic energy. In this bullet-like effect, every muscle fiber is visibly tensed and defined, from the way its powerful hips curl and then release power to the taut, rising arc of its body against the sky. As its hooves leave the earth, the camera captures the initial impact, kicking up a cloud of fine golden dust that hangs suspended and illuminated. The scene is set across a vast, arid plain at golden hour; the low-hanging sun casts a brilliant rim light on the horse's body, sculpting its powerful physique and highlighting every whipping of its mane. The background is a soft-focus landscape of distant, hazy mountains against a sky painted in deep oranges and purples, creating a serene yet epic atmosphere of raw, untamed beauty and arrested movement.", + "seed": 5148, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_2/index_7939_seed_5148_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.07369334511458873, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07369334511458873, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07369334511458873, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Andalusian stallion with a dark bay coat and a wild, flowing black mane and tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stallion performing an explosive launch from the ground with visibly tensed muscle fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a cloud of fine golden dust kicked up by the hooves that hangs suspended in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, arid plain at golden hour with distant, hazy mountains and a sky painted in deep oranges and purples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that gracefully circles the horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0804680660367012 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.58046817779541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0804680660367012, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0804680660367012, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12142320722341537, + 0.10345572978258133, + 0.06381365656852722, + 0.04138089343905449, + 0.13845019042491913, + 0.18383637070655823, + 0.10381904989480972, + 0.07330978661775589, + 0.1067255437374115, + 0.06378550827503204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0804680660367012 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Andalusian stallion with a dark bay coat and a wild, flowing black mane and tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stallion performing an explosive launch from the ground with visibly tensed muscle fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a cloud of fine golden dust kicked up by the hooves that hangs suspended in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, arid plain at golden hour with distant, hazy mountains and a sky painted in deep oranges and purples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that gracefully circles the horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1003536656498909 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350353717803955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1003536656498909, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1003536656498909, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07041707634925842, + 0.09070626646280289, + 0.02970004826784134, + 0.3304688334465027, + 0.09302075207233429, + 0.0415814071893692, + 0.036297161132097244, + 0.11678191274404526, + 0.17743663489818573, + 0.013589895330369473 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1003536656498909 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Andalusian stallion with a dark bay coat and a wild, flowing black mane and tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stallion performing an explosive launch from the ground with visibly tensed muscle fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a cloud of fine golden dust kicked up by the hooves that hangs suspended in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, arid plain at golden hour with distant, hazy mountains and a sky painted in deep oranges and purples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that gracefully circles the horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020579388365149498 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955793380737305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020579388365149498, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020579388365149498, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12939301133155823, + 0.08689671009778976, + 0.05532292649149895, + 0.3511529564857483, + 0.13759280741214752, + 0.03092588111758232, + 0.024534355849027634, + 0.10976744443178177, + 0.03435105085372925, + 0.04006289318203926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020579388365149498 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Andalusian stallion with a dark bay coat and a wild, flowing black mane and tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stallion performing an explosive launch from the ground with visibly tensed muscle fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a cloud of fine golden dust kicked up by the hooves that hangs suspended in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, arid plain at golden hour with distant, hazy mountains and a sky painted in deep oranges and purples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that gracefully circles the horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006736189126968384 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067362785339355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006736189126968384, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006736189126968384, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18764778971672058, + 0.06395389139652252, + 0.1282917559146881, + 0.1763448566198349, + 0.14039380848407745, + 0.017540214583277702, + 0.02505105920135975, + 0.09009909629821777, + 0.054551973938941956, + 0.11612546443939209 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006736189126968384 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Andalusian stallion with a dark bay coat and a wild, flowing black mane and tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stallion performing an explosive launch from the ground with visibly tensed muscle fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a cloud of fine golden dust kicked up by the hooves that hangs suspended in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, arid plain at golden hour with distant, hazy mountains and a sky painted in deep oranges and purples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that gracefully circles the horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603294163942337 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103294610977173 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603294163942337, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603294163942337, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1168268695473671, + 0.08730189502239227, + 0.022363970056176186, + 0.2597106099128723, + 0.016593702137470245, + 0.043674685060977936, + 0.04366937279701233, + 0.24007663130760193, + 0.14475518465042114, + 0.025027116760611534 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603294163942337 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "super-slow-motion, low-angle tracking shot gracefully circles a majestic Andalusian stallion as it explosively launches from the ground. The entire sequence, captured in a series of incredibly detailed, frozen moments, conveys immense power. With a gleaming dark bay coat and a wild, flowing black mane and tail, the stallion is a study in kinetic energy. In this bullet-like effect, every muscle fiber is visibly tensed and defined, from the way its powerful hips curl and then release power to the taut, rising arc of its body against the sky. As its hooves leave the earth, the camera captures the initial impact, kicking up a cloud of fine golden dust that hangs suspended and illuminated. The scene is set across a vast, arid plain at golden hour; the low-hanging sun casts a brilliant rim light on the horse's body, sculpting its powerful physique and highlighting every whipping of its mane. The background is a soft-focus landscape of distant, hazy mountains against a sky painted in deep oranges and purples, creating a serene yet epic atmosphere of raw, untamed beauty and arrested movement.", + "seed": 5149, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_2/index_7939_seed_5149_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.030871925549581646, + "vlm_logprob": -0.030871925549581646, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.030871925549581646, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Andalusian stallion with a dark bay coat and a wild, flowing black mane and tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stallion performing an explosive launch from the ground with visibly tensed muscle fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a cloud of fine golden dust kicked up by the hooves that hangs suspended in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, arid plain at golden hour with distant, hazy mountains and a sky painted in deep oranges and purples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that gracefully circles the horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05585837364196777 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9308583736419678 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05585837364196777, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05585837364196777, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5397987961769104, + 0.1220603659749031, + 0.0697946771979332, + 0.03806743025779724, + 0.0952383428812027, + 0.04082118719816208, + 0.04019245132803917, + 0.013091976754367352, + 0.01531469076871872, + 0.025619976222515106 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05585837364196777 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Andalusian stallion with a dark bay coat and a wild, flowing black mane and tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stallion performing an explosive launch from the ground with visibly tensed muscle fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a cloud of fine golden dust kicked up by the hooves that hangs suspended in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, arid plain at golden hour with distant, hazy mountains and a sky painted in deep oranges and purples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that gracefully circles the horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03373117744922638 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.40873122215271 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03373117744922638, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03373117744922638, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4604995548725128, + 0.07135855406522751, + 0.06398488581180573, + 0.06565247476100922, + 0.04363479092717171, + 0.04359763115644455, + 0.06835465133190155, + 0.07536252588033676, + 0.06713883578777313, + 0.040416065603494644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03373117744922638 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Andalusian stallion with a dark bay coat and a wild, flowing black mane and tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stallion performing an explosive launch from the ground with visibly tensed muscle fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a cloud of fine golden dust kicked up by the hooves that hangs suspended in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, arid plain at golden hour with distant, hazy mountains and a sky painted in deep oranges and purples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that gracefully circles the horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01419247966259718 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264192581176758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01419247966259718, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01419247966259718, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.44521915912628174, + 0.08458241075277328, + 0.04374944418668747, + 0.05460980907082558, + 0.04853648692369461, + 0.09829621762037277, + 0.08818697184324265, + 0.07339853793382645, + 0.03619324415922165, + 0.027227677404880524 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01419247966259718 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Andalusian stallion with a dark bay coat and a wild, flowing black mane and tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stallion performing an explosive launch from the ground with visibly tensed muscle fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a cloud of fine golden dust kicked up by the hooves that hangs suspended in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, arid plain at golden hour with distant, hazy mountains and a sky painted in deep oranges and purples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that gracefully circles the horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019384894985705614 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251938343048096 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019384894985705614, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019384894985705614, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35222601890563965, + 0.09670556336641312, + 0.03174636512994766, + 0.04872512072324753, + 0.1254335641860962, + 0.09811706840991974, + 0.11052961647510529, + 0.03324946388602257, + 0.06823040544986725, + 0.0350368432700634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019384894985705614 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an Andalusian stallion with a dark bay coat and a wild, flowing black mane and tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stallion performing an explosive launch from the ground with visibly tensed muscle fibers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a cloud of fine golden dust kicked up by the hooves that hangs suspended in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, arid plain at golden hour with distant, hazy mountains and a sky painted in deep oranges and purples?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle tracking shot that gracefully circles the horse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04863910749554634 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486390590667725 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04863910749554634, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04863910749554634, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42157313227653503, + 0.1657831072807312, + 0.055988505482673645, + 0.05325591564178467, + 0.07723933458328247, + 0.04246344417333603, + 0.055014718323946, + 0.06349215656518936, + 0.03770586475729942, + 0.027483804151415825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04863910749554634 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_3/index_tensor([8883, 8883])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_3/index_tensor([8883, 8883])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..135cd4e7348c68448cf6e5b3e8d9409f983c8a66 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_3/index_tensor([8883, 8883])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow-motion, circling shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, captures a swordsman's fluid, flowing swordplay. The swordsman, with long, black hair tied high, a few strands falling around his resolute face as he moves, wears a slightly rough white cotton top and dark blue samurai hakama. Barefoot, he stands firmly on the moss-covered, ancient stone slabs. He is at the apex of a fluid spin, his body sinking slightly. The katana in his hand gleams with a cool metallic sheen, tracing an elegant yet deadly silver arc through the air, its sharp wind stirring the surrounding air. Around him, countless pale pink cherry blossom petals fall like dense raindrops, some gently clinging to his shoulders, others swept up by the sword's energy, forming a fleeting, dazzling vortex. The golden sunlight of the evening shines through the lush branches of the cherry trees, casting mottled and elongated shadows on the ground. The light accurately illuminates the sharp edge of the blade, outlining his focused profile and giving the flying petals a dreamy translucent texture. The whole picture achieves a perfect balance between tranquil beauty and imminent dramatic tension, creating a visual atmosphere that is both poetic and powerful.", + "seed": 23245, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_3/index_8883_seed_23245_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.016084503661841155, + "vlm_logprob": -0.016084503661841155, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.016084503661841155, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a barefoot swordsman with long black hair tied high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman wearing a white cotton top and dark blue samurai hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting ancient stone slabs covered in moss with falling pale pink cherry blossom petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a fluid spin where his body sinks slightly while holding a gleaming katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a circling view taken from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04324333742260933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168243408203125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04324333742260933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04324333742260933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16625452041625977, + 0.07559370249509811, + 0.08105774968862534, + 0.13913753628730774, + 0.055526867508888245, + 0.04130687564611435, + 0.0402437224984169, + 0.07148951292037964, + 0.04448288306593895, + 0.2849065959453583 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04324333742260933 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a barefoot swordsman with long black hair tied high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman wearing a white cotton top and dark blue samurai hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting ancient stone slabs covered in moss with falling pale pink cherry blossom petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a fluid spin where his body sinks slightly while holding a gleaming katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a circling view taken from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819128356873989 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018191337585449 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819128356873989, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819128356873989, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12070073932409286, + 0.2674914598464966, + 0.04472164437174797, + 0.11301223188638687, + 0.04875165596604347, + 0.053940847516059875, + 0.04178469255566597, + 0.04406249150633812, + 0.04213894158601761, + 0.22339536249637604 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819128356873989 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a barefoot swordsman with long black hair tied high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman wearing a white cotton top and dark blue samurai hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting ancient stone slabs covered in moss with falling pale pink cherry blossom petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a fluid spin where his body sinks slightly while holding a gleaming katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a circling view taken from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004635303281247616 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379635334014893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004635303281247616, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004635303281247616, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25149065256118774, + 0.08155425637960434, + 0.08217564225196838, + 0.04949963465332985, + 0.034027695655822754, + 0.04203861951828003, + 0.023563433438539505, + 0.11979716271162033, + 0.037751633673906326, + 0.2781013250350952 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004635303281247616 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a barefoot swordsman with long black hair tied high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman wearing a white cotton top and dark blue samurai hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting ancient stone slabs covered in moss with falling pale pink cherry blossom petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a fluid spin where his body sinks slightly while holding a gleaming katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a circling view taken from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006731215864419937 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006731033325195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006731215864419937, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006731215864419937, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17494773864746094, + 0.03822663053870201, + 0.11004174500703812, + 0.10452710092067719, + 0.03135725483298302, + 0.05938473343849182, + 0.04470130056142807, + 0.1585259884595871, + 0.050053536891937256, + 0.22823400795459747 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006731215864419937 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a barefoot swordsman with long black hair tied high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman wearing a white cotton top and dark blue samurai hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting ancient stone slabs covered in moss with falling pale pink cherry blossom petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a fluid spin where his body sinks slightly while holding a gleaming katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a circling view taken from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007621378172188997 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826212882995605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007621378172188997, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007621378172188997, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35894379019737244, + 0.08432532101869583, + 0.050760410726070404, + 0.04811727628111839, + 0.0697442963719368, + 0.14728932082653046, + 0.03503049537539482, + 0.059763748198747635, + 0.04686921462416649, + 0.09915619343519211 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007621378172188997 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion, circling shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, captures a swordsman's fluid, flowing swordplay. The swordsman, with long, black hair tied high, a few strands falling around his resolute face as he moves, wears a slightly rough white cotton top and dark blue samurai hakama. Barefoot, he stands firmly on the moss-covered, ancient stone slabs. He is at the apex of a fluid spin, his body sinking slightly. The katana in his hand gleams with a cool metallic sheen, tracing an elegant yet deadly silver arc through the air, its sharp wind stirring the surrounding air. Around him, countless pale pink cherry blossom petals fall like dense raindrops, some gently clinging to his shoulders, others swept up by the sword's energy, forming a fleeting, dazzling vortex. The golden sunlight of the evening shines through the lush branches of the cherry trees, casting mottled and elongated shadows on the ground. The light accurately illuminates the sharp edge of the blade, outlining his focused profile and giving the flying petals a dreamy translucent texture. The whole picture achieves a perfect balance between tranquil beauty and imminent dramatic tension, creating a visual atmosphere that is both poetic and powerful.", + "seed": 23246, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_3/index_8883_seed_23246_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.013514709193259478, + "vlm_logprob": -0.013514709193259478, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.013514709193259478, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a barefoot swordsman with long black hair tied high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman wearing a white cotton top and dark blue samurai hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting ancient stone slabs covered in moss with falling pale pink cherry blossom petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a fluid spin where his body sinks slightly while holding a gleaming katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a circling view taken from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033917300403118134 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408917188644409 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033917300403118134, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033917300403118134, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11695848405361176, + 0.08579370379447937, + 0.07513932883739471, + 0.13946998119354248, + 0.04000244289636612, + 0.06946060061454773, + 0.18716007471084595, + 0.050563473254442215, + 0.10585135221481323, + 0.12960052490234375 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033917300403118134 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a barefoot swordsman with long black hair tied high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman wearing a white cotton top and dark blue samurai hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting ancient stone slabs covered in moss with falling pale pink cherry blossom petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a fluid spin where his body sinks slightly while holding a gleaming katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a circling view taken from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014198591001331806 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2641987800598145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014198591001331806, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014198591001331806, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10439004004001617, + 0.06628347188234329, + 0.03490461781620979, + 0.06349746882915497, + 0.058243487030267715, + 0.06265896558761597, + 0.32328495383262634, + 0.15862292051315308, + 0.03166180104017258, + 0.09645230323076248 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014198591001331806 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a barefoot swordsman with long black hair tied high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman wearing a white cotton top and dark blue samurai hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting ancient stone slabs covered in moss with falling pale pink cherry blossom petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a fluid spin where his body sinks slightly while holding a gleaming katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a circling view taken from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004093838855624199 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504093647003174 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004093838855624199, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004093838855624199, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16742923855781555, + 0.07643482834100723, + 0.08002670854330063, + 0.2986389696598053, + 0.03453707695007324, + 0.033623404800891876, + 0.06899553537368774, + 0.023411739617586136, + 0.1546679586172104, + 0.06223459914326668 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004093838855624199 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a barefoot swordsman with long black hair tied high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman wearing a white cotton top and dark blue samurai hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting ancient stone slabs covered in moss with falling pale pink cherry blossom petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a fluid spin where his body sinks slightly while holding a gleaming katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a circling view taken from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008634849451482296 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586350440979 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008634849451482296, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008634849451482296, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13330647349357605, + 0.043010734021663666, + 0.05790126696228981, + 0.09009137749671936, + 0.06840558350086212, + 0.09147106856107712, + 0.12561792135238647, + 0.11802349239587784, + 0.15566930174827576, + 0.11650274693965912 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008634849451482296 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a barefoot swordsman with long black hair tied high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman wearing a white cotton top and dark blue samurai hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting ancient stone slabs covered in moss with falling pale pink cherry blossom petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a fluid spin where his body sinks slightly while holding a gleaming katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a circling view taken from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067289662547409534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067291259765625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067289662547409534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067289662547409534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11344394832849503, + 0.05249694362282753, + 0.09447087347507477, + 0.23114164173603058, + 0.05599329620599747, + 0.1452963799238205, + 0.08962683379650116, + 0.04002876579761505, + 0.11682658642530441, + 0.060674604028463364 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067289662547409534 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion, circling shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, captures a swordsman's fluid, flowing swordplay. The swordsman, with long, black hair tied high, a few strands falling around his resolute face as he moves, wears a slightly rough white cotton top and dark blue samurai hakama. Barefoot, he stands firmly on the moss-covered, ancient stone slabs. He is at the apex of a fluid spin, his body sinking slightly. The katana in his hand gleams with a cool metallic sheen, tracing an elegant yet deadly silver arc through the air, its sharp wind stirring the surrounding air. Around him, countless pale pink cherry blossom petals fall like dense raindrops, some gently clinging to his shoulders, others swept up by the sword's energy, forming a fleeting, dazzling vortex. The golden sunlight of the evening shines through the lush branches of the cherry trees, casting mottled and elongated shadows on the ground. The light accurately illuminates the sharp edge of the blade, outlining his focused profile and giving the flying petals a dreamy translucent texture. The whole picture achieves a perfect balance between tranquil beauty and imminent dramatic tension, creating a visual atmosphere that is both poetic and powerful.", + "seed": 23247, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_3/index_8883_seed_23247_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.01335499957203865, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01335499957203865, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01335499957203865, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a barefoot swordsman with long black hair tied high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman wearing a white cotton top and dark blue samurai hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting ancient stone slabs covered in moss with falling pale pink cherry blossom petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a fluid spin where his body sinks slightly while holding a gleaming katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a circling view taken from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023772334679961205 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7737722396850586 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023772334679961205, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023772334679961205, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13609187304973602, + 0.13829179108142853, + 0.04755866900086403, + 0.11784101277589798, + 0.0646846666932106, + 0.08424895256757736, + 0.05906492844223976, + 0.09642276167869568, + 0.1281156837940216, + 0.12767960131168365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023772334679961205 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a barefoot swordsman with long black hair tied high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman wearing a white cotton top and dark blue samurai hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting ancient stone slabs covered in moss with falling pale pink cherry blossom petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a fluid spin where his body sinks slightly while holding a gleaming katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a circling view taken from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018195966258645058 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018196105957031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018195966258645058, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018195966258645058, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16340063512325287, + 0.09183824807405472, + 0.06250564008951187, + 0.11329073458909988, + 0.052807439118623734, + 0.10705247521400452, + 0.09134792536497116, + 0.06262359023094177, + 0.11520703881978989, + 0.13992628455162048 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018195966258645058 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a barefoot swordsman with long black hair tied high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman wearing a white cotton top and dark blue samurai hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting ancient stone slabs covered in moss with falling pale pink cherry blossom petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a fluid spin where his body sinks slightly while holding a gleaming katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a circling view taken from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005254387855529785 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.25525426864624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005254387855529785, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005254387855529785, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20364218950271606, + 0.12170585244894028, + 0.23278765380382538, + 0.05588150769472122, + 0.016947107389569283, + 0.038597967475652695, + 0.05619778856635094, + 0.07839096337556839, + 0.13816818594932556, + 0.05768075957894325 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005254387855529785 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a barefoot swordsman with long black hair tied high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman wearing a white cotton top and dark blue samurai hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting ancient stone slabs covered in moss with falling pale pink cherry blossom petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a fluid spin where his body sinks slightly while holding a gleaming katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a circling view taken from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009777394123375416 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634777545928955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009777394123375416, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009777394123375416, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18926753103733063, + 0.07553736120462418, + 0.04949285089969635, + 0.06893845647573471, + 0.06622875481843948, + 0.14799384772777557, + 0.02047254703938961, + 0.05978243425488472, + 0.14688284695148468, + 0.1754034012556076 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009777394123375416 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a barefoot swordsman with long black hair tied high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman wearing a white cotton top and dark blue samurai hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting ancient stone slabs covered in moss with falling pale pink cherry blossom petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a fluid spin where his body sinks slightly while holding a gleaming katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a circling view taken from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00977491494268179 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634774684906006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00977491494268179, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00977491494268179, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11509738117456436, + 0.08131295442581177, + 0.07157435268163681, + 0.08162336051464081, + 0.1017325222492218, + 0.15065205097198486, + 0.03160103037953377, + 0.05011511594057083, + 0.11561525613069534, + 0.20067597925662994 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00977491494268179 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion, circling shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, captures a swordsman's fluid, flowing swordplay. The swordsman, with long, black hair tied high, a few strands falling around his resolute face as he moves, wears a slightly rough white cotton top and dark blue samurai hakama. Barefoot, he stands firmly on the moss-covered, ancient stone slabs. He is at the apex of a fluid spin, his body sinking slightly. The katana in his hand gleams with a cool metallic sheen, tracing an elegant yet deadly silver arc through the air, its sharp wind stirring the surrounding air. Around him, countless pale pink cherry blossom petals fall like dense raindrops, some gently clinging to his shoulders, others swept up by the sword's energy, forming a fleeting, dazzling vortex. The golden sunlight of the evening shines through the lush branches of the cherry trees, casting mottled and elongated shadows on the ground. The light accurately illuminates the sharp edge of the blade, outlining his focused profile and giving the flying petals a dreamy translucent texture. The whole picture achieves a perfect balance between tranquil beauty and imminent dramatic tension, creating a visual atmosphere that is both poetic and powerful.", + "seed": 23248, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_3/index_8883_seed_23248_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.014562979899346828, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014562979899346828, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014562979899346828, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a barefoot swordsman with long black hair tied high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman wearing a white cotton top and dark blue samurai hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting ancient stone slabs covered in moss with falling pale pink cherry blossom petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a fluid spin where his body sinks slightly while holding a gleaming katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a circling view taken from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023545196279883385 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773545265197754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023545196279883385, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023545196279883385, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1506091207265854, + 0.042636770755052567, + 0.04278542846441269, + 0.06580542027950287, + 0.04683179035782814, + 0.09139421582221985, + 0.06865692138671875, + 0.12022335827350616, + 0.06801938265562057, + 0.3030375838279724 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023545196279883385 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a barefoot swordsman with long black hair tied high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman wearing a white cotton top and dark blue samurai hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting ancient stone slabs covered in moss with falling pale pink cherry blossom petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a fluid spin where his body sinks slightly while holding a gleaming katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a circling view taken from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029809197410941124 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298092365264893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029809197410941124, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029809197410941124, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13071613013744354, + 0.04837446287274361, + 0.11799637228250504, + 0.08042274415493011, + 0.05803948640823364, + 0.06152486428618431, + 0.04466211050748825, + 0.11721855401992798, + 0.10947424918413162, + 0.2315710484981537 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029809197410941124 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a barefoot swordsman with long black hair tied high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman wearing a white cotton top and dark blue samurai hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting ancient stone slabs covered in moss with falling pale pink cherry blossom petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a fluid spin where his body sinks slightly while holding a gleaming katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a circling view taken from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004095026291906834 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504095077514648 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004095026291906834, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004095026291906834, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12745413184165955, + 0.0287009347230196, + 0.08595706522464752, + 0.09825267642736435, + 0.06780215352773666, + 0.13979731500148773, + 0.030231591314077377, + 0.09948532283306122, + 0.05304480344057083, + 0.2692740261554718 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004095026291906834 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a barefoot swordsman with long black hair tied high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman wearing a white cotton top and dark blue samurai hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting ancient stone slabs covered in moss with falling pale pink cherry blossom petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a fluid spin where his body sinks slightly while holding a gleaming katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a circling view taken from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067337024956941605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067338943481445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067337024956941605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067337024956941605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11510295420885086, + 0.053177837282419205, + 0.027792977169156075, + 0.12042221426963806, + 0.13233566284179688, + 0.06807248294353485, + 0.06770459562540054, + 0.0683303251862526, + 0.06376368552446365, + 0.28329727053642273 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067337024956941605 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a barefoot swordsman with long black hair tied high?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman wearing a white cotton top and dark blue samurai hakama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting ancient stone slabs covered in moss with falling pale pink cherry blossom petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a fluid spin where his body sinks slightly while holding a gleaming katana?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a circling view taken from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00863177701830864 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758631706237793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00863177701830864, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00863177701830864, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10553682595491409, + 0.030505426228046417, + 0.0844811275601387, + 0.13287700712680817, + 0.17115162312984467, + 0.03883097320795059, + 0.041543226689100266, + 0.02244342304766178, + 0.05927642434835434, + 0.31335389614105225 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00863177701830864 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_4/index_tensor([4654, 4654])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_4/index_tensor([4654, 4654])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e61b2a5efaf7ecb6b9e06f2b80b21bbd01af9c8a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_4/index_tensor([4654, 4654])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera held still, focusing on a plump, 3D, cartoon-like bullfrog. Its smooth, elastic skin is a vibrant emerald green, speckled with pale yellow, and its large, bulging, cartoon-like eyes sparkle with mischief. It sits sturdily on a broad, rounded lotus leaf, coated in a waxy sheen. The backdrop is a tranquil summer night pond, its deep blue water reflecting the hazy moonlight. As a firefly, trailing a faint yellow-green glow, leisurely flies past the camera, the bullfrog suddenly, with lightning speed, extends its long, flexible pink tongue. Drawing a precise arc through the air, it quickly captures the firefly and retracts it into its mouth. When it swallowed the firefly, a smug and comical expression of satisfaction immediately appeared on its face, and a big smile appeared at the corner of its mouth. At this moment, its round white belly began to flash a soft and rhythmic yellow-green light from the inside out, as if imprisoning the firefly's light within its body. At the same time, the focus of the camera switched instantly from its smug and comical facial expression at an extremely fast speed, and clearly focused on its magically glowing belly. The whole picture was full of the exaggerated fun and dreamy visual effects of 3D cartoon animation.", + "seed": 7957, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_4/index_4654_seed_7957_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.3129718753974885, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3129718753974885, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3129718753974885, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, 3D, cartoon-like bullfrog with vibrant emerald green skin speckled with pale yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bullfrog sitting on a broad, rounded lotus leaf coated in a waxy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog extend its long, flexible pink tongue to capture a firefly trailing a faint yellow-green glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog's round white belly flash a soft, rhythmic yellow-green light from the inside out after swallowing the firefly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus switch instantly from the bullfrog's facial expression to its glowing belly at an extremely fast speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002469111466780305 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127469062805176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002469111466780305, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002469111466780305, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07646790146827698, + 0.07096613198518753, + 0.0536905899643898, + 0.022876717150211334, + 0.3403032124042511, + 0.09802420437335968, + 0.11104127764701843, + 0.028626104816794395, + 0.02717828005552292, + 0.17082558572292328 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002469111466780305 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, 3D, cartoon-like bullfrog with vibrant emerald green skin speckled with pale yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bullfrog sitting on a broad, rounded lotus leaf coated in a waxy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog extend its long, flexible pink tongue to capture a firefly trailing a faint yellow-green glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog's round white belly flash a soft, rhythmic yellow-green light from the inside out after swallowing the firefly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus switch instantly from the bullfrog's facial expression to its glowing belly at an extremely fast speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005956872832030058 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130956649780273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005956872832030058, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005956872832030058, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.037129271775484085, + 0.08915960043668747, + 0.6643920540809631, + 0.011111227795481682, + 0.09254246205091476, + 0.025822509080171585, + 0.020339015871286392, + 0.013278119266033173, + 0.010770373046398163, + 0.035455331206321716 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005956872832030058 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, 3D, cartoon-like bullfrog with vibrant emerald green skin speckled with pale yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bullfrog sitting on a broad, rounded lotus leaf coated in a waxy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog extend its long, flexible pink tongue to capture a firefly trailing a faint yellow-green glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog's round white belly flash a soft, rhythmic yellow-green light from the inside out after swallowing the firefly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus switch instantly from the bullfrog's facial expression to its glowing belly at an extremely fast speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020612435415387154 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956124782562256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020612435415387154, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020612435415387154, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.019601408392190933, + 0.03222795948386192, + 0.390190988779068, + 0.013653632253408432, + 0.3876194655895233, + 0.050160907208919525, + 0.03499498590826988, + 0.012618180364370346, + 0.020814457908272743, + 0.03811797499656677 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020612435415387154 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, 3D, cartoon-like bullfrog with vibrant emerald green skin speckled with pale yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bullfrog sitting on a broad, rounded lotus leaf coated in a waxy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog extend its long, flexible pink tongue to capture a firefly trailing a faint yellow-green glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog's round white belly flash a soft, rhythmic yellow-green light from the inside out after swallowing the firefly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus switch instantly from the bullfrog's facial expression to its glowing belly at an extremely fast speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03372311219573021 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087231159210205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03372311219573021, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03372311219573021, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.034226737916469574, + 0.0474713034927845, + 0.10217754542827606, + 0.03780263662338257, + 0.22824206948280334, + 0.07424217462539673, + 0.16722393035888672, + 0.02424166165292263, + 0.06311341375112534, + 0.2212585210800171 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03372311219573021 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, 3D, cartoon-like bullfrog with vibrant emerald green skin speckled with pale yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bullfrog sitting on a broad, rounded lotus leaf coated in a waxy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog extend its long, flexible pink tongue to capture a firefly trailing a faint yellow-green glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog's round white belly flash a soft, rhythmic yellow-green light from the inside out after swallowing the firefly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus switch instantly from the bullfrog's facial expression to its glowing belly at an extremely fast speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020978450775146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25209784507751465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5020978450775146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5020978450775146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.01573840156197548, + 0.02915261499583721, + 0.5478925108909607, + 0.015327543020248413, + 0.17105582356452942, + 0.045405227690935135, + 0.036467112600803375, + 0.006932864431291819, + 0.010310248471796513, + 0.12171774357557297 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5020978450775146 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera held still, focusing on a plump, 3D, cartoon-like bullfrog. Its smooth, elastic skin is a vibrant emerald green, speckled with pale yellow, and its large, bulging, cartoon-like eyes sparkle with mischief. It sits sturdily on a broad, rounded lotus leaf, coated in a waxy sheen. The backdrop is a tranquil summer night pond, its deep blue water reflecting the hazy moonlight. As a firefly, trailing a faint yellow-green glow, leisurely flies past the camera, the bullfrog suddenly, with lightning speed, extends its long, flexible pink tongue. Drawing a precise arc through the air, it quickly captures the firefly and retracts it into its mouth. When it swallowed the firefly, a smug and comical expression of satisfaction immediately appeared on its face, and a big smile appeared at the corner of its mouth. At this moment, its round white belly began to flash a soft and rhythmic yellow-green light from the inside out, as if imprisoning the firefly's light within its body. At the same time, the focus of the camera switched instantly from its smug and comical facial expression at an extremely fast speed, and clearly focused on its magically glowing belly. The whole picture was full of the exaggerated fun and dreamy visual effects of 3D cartoon animation.", + "seed": 7958, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_4/index_4654_seed_7958_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.10097215622663498, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10097215622663498, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10097215622663498, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, 3D, cartoon-like bullfrog with vibrant emerald green skin speckled with pale yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bullfrog sitting on a broad, rounded lotus leaf coated in a waxy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog extend its long, flexible pink tongue to capture a firefly trailing a faint yellow-green glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog's round white belly flash a soft, rhythmic yellow-green light from the inside out after swallowing the firefly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus switch instantly from the bullfrog's facial expression to its glowing belly at an extremely fast speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004661882296204567 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504662036895752 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004661882296204567, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004661882296204567, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09357824921607971, + 0.0617733895778656, + 0.0647767186164856, + 0.15306644141674042, + 0.21293611824512482, + 0.08656291663646698, + 0.0478714220225811, + 0.026968762278556824, + 0.13654373586177826, + 0.11592228710651398 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004661882296204567 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, 3D, cartoon-like bullfrog with vibrant emerald green skin speckled with pale yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bullfrog sitting on a broad, rounded lotus leaf coated in a waxy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog extend its long, flexible pink tongue to capture a firefly trailing a faint yellow-green glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog's round white belly flash a soft, rhythmic yellow-green light from the inside out after swallowing the firefly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus switch instantly from the bullfrog's facial expression to its glowing belly at an extremely fast speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812874108552933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881288528442383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812874108552933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812874108552933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11420127004384995, + 0.10783050954341888, + 0.12221313267946243, + 0.1605091243982315, + 0.054449308663606644, + 0.034855447709560394, + 0.054155297577381134, + 0.04918641969561577, + 0.16999110579490662, + 0.13260836899280548 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812874108552933 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, 3D, cartoon-like bullfrog with vibrant emerald green skin speckled with pale yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bullfrog sitting on a broad, rounded lotus leaf coated in a waxy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog extend its long, flexible pink tongue to capture a firefly trailing a faint yellow-green glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog's round white belly flash a soft, rhythmic yellow-green light from the inside out after swallowing the firefly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus switch instantly from the bullfrog's facial expression to its glowing belly at an extremely fast speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020611269399523735 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.89561128616333 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020611269399523735, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020611269399523735, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04296721890568733, + 0.0326334573328495, + 0.07345166057348251, + 0.16836172342300415, + 0.27339816093444824, + 0.07970147579908371, + 0.029684873297810555, + 0.04275990650057793, + 0.02662251517176628, + 0.23041898012161255 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020611269399523735 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, 3D, cartoon-like bullfrog with vibrant emerald green skin speckled with pale yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bullfrog sitting on a broad, rounded lotus leaf coated in a waxy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog extend its long, flexible pink tongue to capture a firefly trailing a faint yellow-green glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog's round white belly flash a soft, rhythmic yellow-green light from the inside out after swallowing the firefly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus switch instantly from the bullfrog's facial expression to its glowing belly at an extremely fast speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012567020952701569 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387567043304443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012567020952701569, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012567020952701569, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.033521294593811035, + 0.014698860235512257, + 0.05087534338235855, + 0.09960293769836426, + 0.10436952114105225, + 0.06993070989847183, + 0.02423454076051712, + 0.022687571123242378, + 0.08789090067148209, + 0.49218830466270447 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012567020952701569 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, 3D, cartoon-like bullfrog with vibrant emerald green skin speckled with pale yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bullfrog sitting on a broad, rounded lotus leaf coated in a waxy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog extend its long, flexible pink tongue to capture a firefly trailing a faint yellow-green glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog's round white belly flash a soft, rhythmic yellow-green light from the inside out after swallowing the firefly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus switch instantly from the bullfrog's facial expression to its glowing belly at an extremely fast speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4288918673992157 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.053891897201538 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4288918673992157, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4288918673992157, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03996739163994789, + 0.048169296234846115, + 0.09161856025457382, + 0.11912284046411514, + 0.04286310449242592, + 0.014929767698049545, + 0.02044462412595749, + 0.04249199479818344, + 0.15659648180007935, + 0.42379599809646606 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4288918673992157 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera held still, focusing on a plump, 3D, cartoon-like bullfrog. Its smooth, elastic skin is a vibrant emerald green, speckled with pale yellow, and its large, bulging, cartoon-like eyes sparkle with mischief. It sits sturdily on a broad, rounded lotus leaf, coated in a waxy sheen. The backdrop is a tranquil summer night pond, its deep blue water reflecting the hazy moonlight. As a firefly, trailing a faint yellow-green glow, leisurely flies past the camera, the bullfrog suddenly, with lightning speed, extends its long, flexible pink tongue. Drawing a precise arc through the air, it quickly captures the firefly and retracts it into its mouth. When it swallowed the firefly, a smug and comical expression of satisfaction immediately appeared on its face, and a big smile appeared at the corner of its mouth. At this moment, its round white belly began to flash a soft and rhythmic yellow-green light from the inside out, as if imprisoning the firefly's light within its body. At the same time, the focus of the camera switched instantly from its smug and comical facial expression at an extremely fast speed, and clearly focused on its magically glowing belly. The whole picture was full of the exaggerated fun and dreamy visual effects of 3D cartoon animation.", + "seed": 7959, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_4/index_4654_seed_7959_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.2871816038154066, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2871816038154066, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2871816038154066, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, 3D, cartoon-like bullfrog with vibrant emerald green skin speckled with pale yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bullfrog sitting on a broad, rounded lotus leaf coated in a waxy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog extend its long, flexible pink tongue to capture a firefly trailing a faint yellow-green glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog's round white belly flash a soft, rhythmic yellow-green light from the inside out after swallowing the firefly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus switch instantly from the bullfrog's facial expression to its glowing belly at an extremely fast speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0025903978385031223 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127590179443359 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0025903978385031223, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0025903978385031223, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.035615578293800354, + 0.022905778139829636, + 0.014596838504076004, + 0.027808181941509247, + 0.012980658560991287, + 0.18284547328948975, + 0.19179382920265198, + 0.21966338157653809, + 0.21317841112613678, + 0.07861190289258957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0025903978385031223 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, 3D, cartoon-like bullfrog with vibrant emerald green skin speckled with pale yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bullfrog sitting on a broad, rounded lotus leaf coated in a waxy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog extend its long, flexible pink tongue to capture a firefly trailing a faint yellow-green glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog's round white belly flash a soft, rhythmic yellow-green light from the inside out after swallowing the firefly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus switch instantly from the bullfrog's facial expression to its glowing belly at an extremely fast speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00979462917894125 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63479471206665 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00979462917894125, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00979462917894125, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06764978170394897, + 0.02968139946460724, + 0.057623788714408875, + 0.03943251073360443, + 0.03768347203731537, + 0.04691358655691147, + 0.10190775245428085, + 0.19070744514465332, + 0.1641729474067688, + 0.2642273008823395 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00979462917894125 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, 3D, cartoon-like bullfrog with vibrant emerald green skin speckled with pale yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bullfrog sitting on a broad, rounded lotus leaf coated in a waxy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog extend its long, flexible pink tongue to capture a firefly trailing a faint yellow-green glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog's round white belly flash a soft, rhythmic yellow-green light from the inside out after swallowing the firefly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus switch instantly from the bullfrog's facial expression to its glowing belly at an extremely fast speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01256501954048872 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875651359558105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01256501954048872, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01256501954048872, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07639653235673904, + 0.06074612960219383, + 0.11570881307125092, + 0.10638811439275742, + 0.04275885596871376, + 0.17927198112010956, + 0.08651982247829437, + 0.19162407517433167, + 0.06719975173473358, + 0.07338593155145645 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01256501954048872 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, 3D, cartoon-like bullfrog with vibrant emerald green skin speckled with pale yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bullfrog sitting on a broad, rounded lotus leaf coated in a waxy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog extend its long, flexible pink tongue to capture a firefly trailing a faint yellow-green glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog's round white belly flash a soft, rhythmic yellow-green light from the inside out after swallowing the firefly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus switch instantly from the bullfrog's facial expression to its glowing belly at an extremely fast speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046457452699542046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379645824432373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046457452699542046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046457452699542046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.011931019835174084, + 0.02281385287642479, + 0.012498891912400723, + 0.02328568883240223, + 0.010879898443818092, + 0.18468979001045227, + 0.049052875488996506, + 0.19798699021339417, + 0.24412211775779724, + 0.24273890256881714 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046457452699542046 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, 3D, cartoon-like bullfrog with vibrant emerald green skin speckled with pale yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bullfrog sitting on a broad, rounded lotus leaf coated in a waxy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog extend its long, flexible pink tongue to capture a firefly trailing a faint yellow-green glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog's round white belly flash a soft, rhythmic yellow-green light from the inside out after swallowing the firefly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus switch instantly from the bullfrog's facial expression to its glowing belly at an extremely fast speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063122272491455 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813122570514679 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.4063122272491455, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -1.4063122272491455, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.015186413191258907, + 0.015001350082457066, + 0.01863930933177471, + 0.02013654261827469, + 0.028894992545247078, + 0.3430408239364624, + 0.26874101161956787, + 0.06847013533115387, + 0.06079447269439697, + 0.16109494864940643 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.4063122272491455 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera held still, focusing on a plump, 3D, cartoon-like bullfrog. Its smooth, elastic skin is a vibrant emerald green, speckled with pale yellow, and its large, bulging, cartoon-like eyes sparkle with mischief. It sits sturdily on a broad, rounded lotus leaf, coated in a waxy sheen. The backdrop is a tranquil summer night pond, its deep blue water reflecting the hazy moonlight. As a firefly, trailing a faint yellow-green glow, leisurely flies past the camera, the bullfrog suddenly, with lightning speed, extends its long, flexible pink tongue. Drawing a precise arc through the air, it quickly captures the firefly and retracts it into its mouth. When it swallowed the firefly, a smug and comical expression of satisfaction immediately appeared on its face, and a big smile appeared at the corner of its mouth. At this moment, its round white belly began to flash a soft and rhythmic yellow-green light from the inside out, as if imprisoning the firefly's light within its body. At the same time, the focus of the camera switched instantly from its smug and comical facial expression at an extremely fast speed, and clearly focused on its magically glowing belly. The whole picture was full of the exaggerated fun and dreamy visual effects of 3D cartoon animation.", + "seed": 7960, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_4/index_4654_seed_7960_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.4280162926763296, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4280162926763296, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4280162926763296, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, 3D, cartoon-like bullfrog with vibrant emerald green skin speckled with pale yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bullfrog sitting on a broad, rounded lotus leaf coated in a waxy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog extend its long, flexible pink tongue to capture a firefly trailing a faint yellow-green glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog's round white belly flash a soft, rhythmic yellow-green light from the inside out after swallowing the firefly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus switch instantly from the bullfrog's facial expression to its glowing belly at an extremely fast speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005829831585288048 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255829811096191 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005829831585288048, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005829831585288048, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1267206072807312, + 0.07295002788305283, + 0.04758569225668907, + 0.03558260202407837, + 0.23259444534778595, + 0.05901744216680527, + 0.06612398475408554, + 0.1500745713710785, + 0.09152106940746307, + 0.11782955378293991 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005829831585288048 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, 3D, cartoon-like bullfrog with vibrant emerald green skin speckled with pale yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bullfrog sitting on a broad, rounded lotus leaf coated in a waxy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog extend its long, flexible pink tongue to capture a firefly trailing a faint yellow-green glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog's round white belly flash a soft, rhythmic yellow-green light from the inside out after swallowing the firefly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus switch instantly from the bullfrog's facial expression to its glowing belly at an extremely fast speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08912015706300735 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4641201496124268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08912015706300735, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08912015706300735, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17542120814323425, + 0.12717223167419434, + 0.057787828147411346, + 0.04402404651045799, + 0.12641695141792297, + 0.0820019319653511, + 0.20601502060890198, + 0.0890091210603714, + 0.03292230889201164, + 0.05922933667898178 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08912015706300735 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, 3D, cartoon-like bullfrog with vibrant emerald green skin speckled with pale yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bullfrog sitting on a broad, rounded lotus leaf coated in a waxy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog extend its long, flexible pink tongue to capture a firefly trailing a faint yellow-green glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog's round white belly flash a soft, rhythmic yellow-green light from the inside out after swallowing the firefly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus switch instantly from the bullfrog's facial expression to its glowing belly at an extremely fast speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06211617588996887 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8121161460876465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06211617588996887, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06211617588996887, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07043621689081192, + 0.031437329947948456, + 0.08340957760810852, + 0.04429714381694794, + 0.2168007791042328, + 0.03048493154346943, + 0.08966760337352753, + 0.1310831755399704, + 0.09159000962972641, + 0.21079322695732117 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06211617588996887 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, 3D, cartoon-like bullfrog with vibrant emerald green skin speckled with pale yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bullfrog sitting on a broad, rounded lotus leaf coated in a waxy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog extend its long, flexible pink tongue to capture a firefly trailing a faint yellow-green glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog's round white belly flash a soft, rhythmic yellow-green light from the inside out after swallowing the firefly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus switch instantly from the bullfrog's facial expression to its glowing belly at an extremely fast speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2814375162124634 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4064375162124634 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2814375162124634, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2814375162124634, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09850545972585678, + 0.10853336751461029, + 0.10132128745317459, + 0.07596780359745026, + 0.11307741701602936, + 0.04448995366692543, + 0.13053202629089355, + 0.13830582797527313, + 0.05212938040494919, + 0.13713745772838593 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2814375162124634 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a plump, 3D, cartoon-like bullfrog with vibrant emerald green skin speckled with pale yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bullfrog sitting on a broad, rounded lotus leaf coated in a waxy sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog extend its long, flexible pink tongue to capture a firefly trailing a faint yellow-green glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bullfrog's round white belly flash a soft, rhythmic yellow-green light from the inside out after swallowing the firefly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera focus switch instantly from the bullfrog's facial expression to its glowing belly at an extremely fast speed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015777826309204 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20157773792743683 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.7015777826309204, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -1.7015777826309204, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14978934824466705, + 0.11747131496667862, + 0.049697231501340866, + 0.0294179767370224, + 0.16416315734386444, + 0.05218319222331047, + 0.05964447557926178, + 0.21314136683940887, + 0.10568723827600479, + 0.05880468711256981 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.7015777826309204 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_5/index_tensor([5214, 5214])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_5/index_tensor([5214, 5214])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0974777f6697b2f4fb8357b0daed07e4983a781f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_5/index_tensor([5214, 5214])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, upward tilt begins with a close-up of a glistening pool of warm amber syrup, collected on a pristine white ceramic plate, set against the soft-focus backdrop of a sunny kitchen. As the camera steadily moves upward, it reveals a towering stack of five fluffy, golden-brown pancakes, their delicately crisp edges and porous surfaces. Thick, viscous maple syrup deliberately oozes along the sides, catching the soft morning light and forming smooth, slow-moving streams that weave through the uneven contours of the stack before dripping seductively onto the plate below. The entire scene is bathed in the warm, soft glow of the early morning sun, casting gentle shadows and highlighting textures, creating a tranquil yet intensely appetizing atmosphere that celebrates a moment of quiet, delicious indulgence.", + "seed": 13868, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_5/index_5214_seed_13868_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1439581662416458, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1439581662416458, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1439581662416458, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pool of warm amber syrup on a white ceramic plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady upward tilt movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a towering stack of five fluffy, golden-brown pancakes revealed as the camera moves upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does thick, viscous maple syrup ooze down the sides of the pancake stack and drip onto the plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sunny kitchen with a soft-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08994005620479584 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464940071105957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08994005620479584, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08994005620479584, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37661048769950867, + 0.15845566987991333, + 0.05524677038192749, + 0.018125932663679123, + 0.2328065186738968, + 0.04594501480460167, + 0.017278289422392845, + 0.029020097106695175, + 0.04361559823155403, + 0.02289559692144394 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08994005620479584 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pool of warm amber syrup on a white ceramic plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady upward tilt movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a towering stack of five fluffy, golden-brown pancakes revealed as the camera moves upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does thick, viscous maple syrup ooze down the sides of the pancake stack and drip onto the plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sunny kitchen with a soft-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014229852706193924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264229774475098 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014229852706193924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014229852706193924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09689341485500336, + 0.07667773216962814, + 0.19318610429763794, + 0.03898555785417557, + 0.42111101746559143, + 0.03643392026424408, + 0.025865307077765465, + 0.050726886838674545, + 0.0322403609752655, + 0.02787974290549755 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014229852706193924 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pool of warm amber syrup on a white ceramic plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady upward tilt movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a towering stack of five fluffy, golden-brown pancakes revealed as the camera moves upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does thick, viscous maple syrup ooze down the sides of the pancake stack and drip onto the plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sunny kitchen with a soft-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020594101399183273 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955941200256348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020594101399183273, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020594101399183273, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23799017071723938, + 0.2402055263519287, + 0.13352973759174347, + 0.028813090175390244, + 0.1300121694803238, + 0.06926827132701874, + 0.046587906777858734, + 0.052543431520462036, + 0.013625780120491982, + 0.047423940151929855 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020594101399183273 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pool of warm amber syrup on a white ceramic plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady upward tilt movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a towering stack of five fluffy, golden-brown pancakes revealed as the camera moves upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does thick, viscous maple syrup ooze down the sides of the pancake stack and drip onto the plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sunny kitchen with a soft-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134857714176178 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134857416152954 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134857714176178, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134857714176178, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1350468099117279, + 0.03435715287923813, + 0.19050168991088867, + 0.08293331414461136, + 0.2992163300514221, + 0.08285129815340042, + 0.030015816912055016, + 0.04430023953318596, + 0.03943563252687454, + 0.06134174391627312 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134857714176178 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pool of warm amber syrup on a white ceramic plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady upward tilt movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a towering stack of five fluffy, golden-brown pancakes revealed as the camera moves upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does thick, viscous maple syrup ooze down the sides of the pancake stack and drip onto the plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sunny kitchen with a soft-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28154104948043823 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.406541109085083 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28154104948043823, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28154104948043823, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10424083471298218, + 0.058972157537937164, + 0.27066707611083984, + 0.0353592112660408, + 0.09269201755523682, + 0.1354595124721527, + 0.0962725430727005, + 0.18303890526294708, + 0.009896082803606987, + 0.013401681557297707 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28154104948043823 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, upward tilt begins with a close-up of a glistening pool of warm amber syrup, collected on a pristine white ceramic plate, set against the soft-focus backdrop of a sunny kitchen. As the camera steadily moves upward, it reveals a towering stack of five fluffy, golden-brown pancakes, their delicately crisp edges and porous surfaces. Thick, viscous maple syrup deliberately oozes along the sides, catching the soft morning light and forming smooth, slow-moving streams that weave through the uneven contours of the stack before dripping seductively onto the plate below. The entire scene is bathed in the warm, soft glow of the early morning sun, casting gentle shadows and highlighting textures, creating a tranquil yet intensely appetizing atmosphere that celebrates a moment of quiet, delicious indulgence.", + "seed": 13869, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_5/index_5214_seed_13869_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.13362035900354385, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13362035900354385, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13362035900354385, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pool of warm amber syrup on a white ceramic plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady upward tilt movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a towering stack of five fluffy, golden-brown pancakes revealed as the camera moves upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does thick, viscous maple syrup ooze down the sides of the pancake stack and drip onto the plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sunny kitchen with a soft-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12815861403942108 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1281585693359375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12815861403942108, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12815861403942108, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5118537545204163, + 0.03393265977501869, + 0.13669535517692566, + 0.013414406217634678, + 0.10589536279439926, + 0.0791965052485466, + 0.044784579426050186, + 0.04078017920255661, + 0.015981437638401985, + 0.017465725541114807 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12815861403942108 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pool of warm amber syrup on a white ceramic plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady upward tilt movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a towering stack of five fluffy, golden-brown pancakes revealed as the camera moves upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does thick, viscous maple syrup ooze down the sides of the pancake stack and drip onto the plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sunny kitchen with a soft-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029830025508999825 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529829978942871 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029830025508999825, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029830025508999825, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5301987528800964, + 0.019407903775572777, + 0.023109138011932373, + 0.011250953190028667, + 0.037538401782512665, + 0.33626118302345276, + 0.004843152593821287, + 0.011593678966164589, + 0.016528284177184105, + 0.009268537163734436 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029830025508999825 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pool of warm amber syrup on a white ceramic plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady upward tilt movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a towering stack of five fluffy, golden-brown pancakes revealed as the camera moves upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does thick, viscous maple syrup ooze down the sides of the pancake stack and drip onto the plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sunny kitchen with a soft-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0110840555280447 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511084079742432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0110840555280447, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0110840555280447, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5565717220306396, + 0.08400305360555649, + 0.05204248055815697, + 0.021020004525780678, + 0.115555040538311, + 0.03673378750681877, + 0.01895037107169628, + 0.030445965006947517, + 0.028623323887586594, + 0.056054260581731796 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0110840555280447 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pool of warm amber syrup on a white ceramic plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady upward tilt movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a towering stack of five fluffy, golden-brown pancakes revealed as the camera moves upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does thick, viscous maple syrup ooze down the sides of the pancake stack and drip onto the plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sunny kitchen with a soft-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003793120384216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695037841796875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003793120384216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003793120384216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14014741778373718, + 0.04260513186454773, + 0.1129305511713028, + 0.021215349435806274, + 0.14474976062774658, + 0.42652809619903564, + 0.03826022148132324, + 0.011937721632421017, + 0.01767788641154766, + 0.04394792020320892 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003793120384216 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pool of warm amber syrup on a white ceramic plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady upward tilt movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a towering stack of five fluffy, golden-brown pancakes revealed as the camera moves upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does thick, viscous maple syrup ooze down the sides of the pancake stack and drip onto the plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sunny kitchen with a soft-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289911687374115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539911985397339 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4289911687374115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4289911687374115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.730239748954773, + 0.026167547330260277, + 0.027971815317869186, + 0.013388791121542454, + 0.04500783979892731, + 0.06337796896696091, + 0.030327335000038147, + 0.031128276139497757, + 0.006307394243776798, + 0.026083266362547874 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4289911687374115 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, upward tilt begins with a close-up of a glistening pool of warm amber syrup, collected on a pristine white ceramic plate, set against the soft-focus backdrop of a sunny kitchen. As the camera steadily moves upward, it reveals a towering stack of five fluffy, golden-brown pancakes, their delicately crisp edges and porous surfaces. Thick, viscous maple syrup deliberately oozes along the sides, catching the soft morning light and forming smooth, slow-moving streams that weave through the uneven contours of the stack before dripping seductively onto the plate below. The entire scene is bathed in the warm, soft glow of the early morning sun, casting gentle shadows and highlighting textures, creating a tranquil yet intensely appetizing atmosphere that celebrates a moment of quiet, delicious indulgence.", + "seed": 13870, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_5/index_5214_seed_13870_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11500403098762035, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11500403098762035, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.799999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11500403098762035, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pool of warm amber syrup on a white ceramic plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady upward tilt movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a towering stack of five fluffy, golden-brown pancakes revealed as the camera moves upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does thick, viscous maple syrup ooze down the sides of the pancake stack and drip onto the plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sunny kitchen with a soft-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0705660730600357 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695566177368164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0705660730600357, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0705660730600357, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15792502462863922, + 0.10672765970230103, + 0.11017309129238129, + 0.07118340581655502, + 0.182778462767601, + 0.07154814898967743, + 0.0749279335141182, + 0.13163761794567108, + 0.025407884269952774, + 0.06769081205129623 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0705660730600357 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pool of warm amber syrup on a white ceramic plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady upward tilt movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a towering stack of five fluffy, golden-brown pancakes revealed as the camera moves upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does thick, viscous maple syrup ooze down the sides of the pancake stack and drip onto the plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sunny kitchen with a soft-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012563489377498627 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387563705444336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012563489377498627, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012563489377498627, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03762431442737579, + 0.028500637039542198, + 0.02441183663904667, + 0.05345531180500984, + 0.4996235966682434, + 0.06612220406532288, + 0.04996899887919426, + 0.11625823378562927, + 0.04657132178544998, + 0.07746346294879913 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012563489377498627 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pool of warm amber syrup on a white ceramic plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady upward tilt movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a towering stack of five fluffy, golden-brown pancakes revealed as the camera moves upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does thick, viscous maple syrup ooze down the sides of the pancake stack and drip onto the plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sunny kitchen with a soft-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607481949031353 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410746574401855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607481949031353, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607481949031353, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07910563051700592, + 0.03806561976671219, + 0.0593058243393898, + 0.11068059504032135, + 0.11593444645404816, + 0.10585899651050568, + 0.06358443200588226, + 0.28050684928894043, + 0.033588606864213943, + 0.11336900293827057 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607481949031353 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pool of warm amber syrup on a white ceramic plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady upward tilt movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a towering stack of five fluffy, golden-brown pancakes revealed as the camera moves upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does thick, viscous maple syrup ooze down the sides of the pancake stack and drip onto the plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sunny kitchen with a soft-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12706884741783142 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270687580108643 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12706884741783142, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12706884741783142, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12783780694007874, + 0.09254947304725647, + 0.052729230374097824, + 0.09977678954601288, + 0.06574427336454391, + 0.03572796285152435, + 0.05792481452226639, + 0.2725672125816345, + 0.05519863963127136, + 0.13994385302066803 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12706884741783142 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pool of warm amber syrup on a white ceramic plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady upward tilt movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a towering stack of five fluffy, golden-brown pancakes revealed as the camera moves upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does thick, viscous maple syrup ooze down the sides of the pancake stack and drip onto the plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sunny kitchen with a soft-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3487469255924225 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2237468957901 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3487469255924225, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3487469255924225, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.018626343458890915, + 0.029846908524632454, + 0.019984062761068344, + 0.107838936150074, + 0.0862279087305069, + 0.051967646926641464, + 0.0353887602686882, + 0.40708261728286743, + 0.05659983679652214, + 0.1864369511604309 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3487469255924225 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, upward tilt begins with a close-up of a glistening pool of warm amber syrup, collected on a pristine white ceramic plate, set against the soft-focus backdrop of a sunny kitchen. As the camera steadily moves upward, it reveals a towering stack of five fluffy, golden-brown pancakes, their delicately crisp edges and porous surfaces. Thick, viscous maple syrup deliberately oozes along the sides, catching the soft morning light and forming smooth, slow-moving streams that weave through the uneven contours of the stack before dripping seductively onto the plate below. The entire scene is bathed in the warm, soft glow of the early morning sun, casting gentle shadows and highlighting textures, creating a tranquil yet intensely appetizing atmosphere that celebrates a moment of quiet, delicious indulgence.", + "seed": 13871, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_5/index_5214_seed_13871_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.3220838002860546, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3220838002860546, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.899999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3220838002860546, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pool of warm amber syrup on a white ceramic plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady upward tilt movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a towering stack of five fluffy, golden-brown pancakes revealed as the camera moves upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does thick, viscous maple syrup ooze down the sides of the pancake stack and drip onto the plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sunny kitchen with a soft-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3493555188179016 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2243554592132568 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3493555188179016, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8749999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3493555188179016, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.46576976776123047, + 0.055906958878040314, + 0.04974997416138649, + 0.024458590894937515, + 0.16081851720809937, + 0.05352092161774635, + 0.018660930916666985, + 0.08062780648469925, + 0.07129549235105515, + 0.019190996885299683 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3493555188179016 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pool of warm amber syrup on a white ceramic plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady upward tilt movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a towering stack of five fluffy, golden-brown pancakes revealed as the camera moves upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does thick, viscous maple syrup ooze down the sides of the pancake stack and drip onto the plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sunny kitchen with a soft-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023326389491558075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733263969421387 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023326389491558075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023326389491558075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11841690540313721, + 0.06961230933666229, + 0.03204300254583359, + 0.2556411027908325, + 0.0301771629601717, + 0.02309386432170868, + 0.06759370118379593, + 0.11633481830358505, + 0.22755374014377594, + 0.05953340232372284 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023326389491558075 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pool of warm amber syrup on a white ceramic plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady upward tilt movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a towering stack of five fluffy, golden-brown pancakes revealed as the camera moves upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does thick, viscous maple syrup ooze down the sides of the pancake stack and drip onto the plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sunny kitchen with a soft-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023300651460886 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733006477355957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023300651460886, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023300651460886, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6257660984992981, + 0.036786749958992004, + 0.03233824297785759, + 0.03041427955031395, + 0.08243132382631302, + 0.04540376737713814, + 0.050941962748765945, + 0.03786112740635872, + 0.0180014930665493, + 0.04005492851138115 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023300651460886 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pool of warm amber syrup on a white ceramic plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady upward tilt movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a towering stack of five fluffy, golden-brown pancakes revealed as the camera moves upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does thick, viscous maple syrup ooze down the sides of the pancake stack and drip onto the plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sunny kitchen with a soft-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16039887070655823 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103988409042358 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16039887070655823, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16039887070655823, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09255657345056534, + 0.045331571251153946, + 0.05639319494366646, + 0.05702068656682968, + 0.47804439067840576, + 0.05812067911028862, + 0.041758209466934204, + 0.07760115712881088, + 0.047280050814151764, + 0.04589342325925827 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16039887070655823 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pool of warm amber syrup on a white ceramic plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady upward tilt movement throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a towering stack of five fluffy, golden-brown pancakes revealed as the camera moves upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does thick, viscous maple syrup ooze down the sides of the pancake stack and drip onto the plate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a sunny kitchen with a soft-focus background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0540375709533691 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42903751134872437 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0540375709533691, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.6250000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0540375709533691, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37133315205574036, + 0.032860610634088516, + 0.07338449358940125, + 0.047261498868465424, + 0.20395421981811523, + 0.025086157023906708, + 0.0564638189971447, + 0.10816938430070877, + 0.03533222898840904, + 0.04615440592169762 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0540375709533691 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_6/index_tensor([5407, 5407])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_6/index_tensor([5407, 5407])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..01dc9dc8bfd71e9076db31e14dc655ec3daceb24 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_6/index_tensor([5407, 5407])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, medium shot captures a massive fighter in the vast emptiness of a brutal concrete hangar. His bare torso reveals chiseled, taut muscles, interwoven with ancient, jagged battle scars and intricate cybernetic augmentations. One arm is a fully mechanical prosthesis constructed of matte black carbon fiber and polished steel, its complex servos humming faintly as metal plates seamlessly graft onto his jaw and neck, a single, cool blue LED pulsing steadily. Clad in dark, heavy tactical pants tucked into worn combat boots, his posture a coiled spring of latent violence. He stands motionless, facing an unseen opponent off-screen, his cold, piercing gray eyes unwavering, unblinking and radiating pure focus. The entire scene is sculpted from above and to the side by a single, harsh spotlight, creating a dramatic black-and-white contrast effect, with deep, elongated shadows stretching across the dusty concrete floor. The stark, high-contrast lighting gleamed off his metal reinforcements, defining every sinew while plunging the hangar's vast, unadorned walls into near-total darkness. A palpable, unspoken tension hung in the air, creating a grim, suspenseful atmosphere of an impending, brutal confrontation.", + "seed": 10304, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_6/index_5407_seed_10304_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.27586277285590766, + "vlm_logprob": -0.27586277285590766, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.27586277285590766, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive fighter with a bare torso revealing chiseled muscles and battle scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fighter have a mechanical prosthesis on one arm made of matte black carbon fiber and polished steel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, empty concrete hangar with dusty floors and unadorned walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a single harsh spotlight creating high-contrast black-and-white tones with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, low-angle medium shot with the fighter standing motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14364980161190033 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0186498165130615 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14364980161190033, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14364980161190033, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04385785013437271, + 0.04659932479262352, + 0.025209689512848854, + 0.04332297295331955, + 0.017933160066604614, + 0.0645531490445137, + 0.0899939015507698, + 0.13019558787345886, + 0.27492931485176086, + 0.2634049952030182 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14364980161190033 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive fighter with a bare torso revealing chiseled muscles and battle scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fighter have a mechanical prosthesis on one arm made of matte black carbon fiber and polished steel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, empty concrete hangar with dusty floors and unadorned walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a single harsh spotlight creating high-contrast black-and-white tones with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, low-angle medium shot with the fighter standing motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07005494087934494 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950550079345703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07005494087934494, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07005494087934494, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1481945812702179, + 0.25399520993232727, + 0.04075422137975693, + 0.1402176022529602, + 0.04072423651814461, + 0.05794572830200195, + 0.03793604299426079, + 0.05763423442840576, + 0.1603960394859314, + 0.06220213696360588 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07005494087934494 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive fighter with a bare torso revealing chiseled muscles and battle scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fighter have a mechanical prosthesis on one arm made of matte black carbon fiber and polished steel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, empty concrete hangar with dusty floors and unadorned walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a single harsh spotlight creating high-contrast black-and-white tones with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, low-angle medium shot with the fighter standing motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023290403187274933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732903957366943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023290403187274933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023290403187274933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0825020894408226, + 0.33156317472457886, + 0.07099655270576477, + 0.12472295016050339, + 0.1109287366271019, + 0.08145643025636673, + 0.056063637137413025, + 0.03898593783378601, + 0.059622276574373245, + 0.04315818473696709 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023290403187274933 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive fighter with a bare torso revealing chiseled muscles and battle scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fighter have a mechanical prosthesis on one arm made of matte black carbon fiber and polished steel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, empty concrete hangar with dusty floors and unadorned walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a single harsh spotlight creating high-contrast black-and-white tones with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, low-angle medium shot with the fighter standing motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005255692172795534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255255699157715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005255692172795534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005255692172795534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15895186364650726, + 0.19406642019748688, + 0.09071190655231476, + 0.0846332237124443, + 0.05828925967216492, + 0.28796321153640747, + 0.02222873456776142, + 0.04052332788705826, + 0.03787859529256821, + 0.024753442034125328 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005255692172795534 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive fighter with a bare torso revealing chiseled muscles and battle scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fighter have a mechanical prosthesis on one arm made of matte black carbon fiber and polished steel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, empty concrete hangar with dusty floors and unadorned walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a single harsh spotlight creating high-contrast black-and-white tones with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, low-angle medium shot with the fighter standing motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370630264282227 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38706305623054504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1370630264282227, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1370630264282227, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09135513007640839, + 0.0666385143995285, + 0.11300348490476608, + 0.09606139361858368, + 0.05527450144290924, + 0.3000347316265106, + 0.04590648412704468, + 0.02230721339583397, + 0.18588249385356903, + 0.02353597991168499 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1370630264282227 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, medium shot captures a massive fighter in the vast emptiness of a brutal concrete hangar. His bare torso reveals chiseled, taut muscles, interwoven with ancient, jagged battle scars and intricate cybernetic augmentations. One arm is a fully mechanical prosthesis constructed of matte black carbon fiber and polished steel, its complex servos humming faintly as metal plates seamlessly graft onto his jaw and neck, a single, cool blue LED pulsing steadily. Clad in dark, heavy tactical pants tucked into worn combat boots, his posture a coiled spring of latent violence. He stands motionless, facing an unseen opponent off-screen, his cold, piercing gray eyes unwavering, unblinking and radiating pure focus. The entire scene is sculpted from above and to the side by a single, harsh spotlight, creating a dramatic black-and-white contrast effect, with deep, elongated shadows stretching across the dusty concrete floor. The stark, high-contrast lighting gleamed off his metal reinforcements, defining every sinew while plunging the hangar's vast, unadorned walls into near-total darkness. A palpable, unspoken tension hung in the air, creating a grim, suspenseful atmosphere of an impending, brutal confrontation.", + "seed": 10305, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_6/index_5407_seed_10305_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.17389229265972972, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17389229265972972, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17389229265972972, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive fighter with a bare torso revealing chiseled muscles and battle scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fighter have a mechanical prosthesis on one arm made of matte black carbon fiber and polished steel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, empty concrete hangar with dusty floors and unadorned walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a single harsh spotlight creating high-contrast black-and-white tones with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, low-angle medium shot with the fighter standing motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22610945999622345 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.601109504699707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22610945999622345, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22610945999622345, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.011060211807489395, + 0.007030635606497526, + 0.008219887502491474, + 0.007968222722411156, + 0.018752384930849075, + 0.008045458234846592, + 0.007050754502415657, + 0.010774841532111168, + 0.14582712948322296, + 0.7752705216407776 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22610945999622345 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive fighter with a bare torso revealing chiseled muscles and battle scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fighter have a mechanical prosthesis on one arm made of matte black carbon fiber and polished steel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, empty concrete hangar with dusty floors and unadorned walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a single harsh spotlight creating high-contrast black-and-white tones with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, low-angle medium shot with the fighter standing motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048701103776693344 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048701047897339 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048701103776693344, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048701103776693344, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.055255740880966187, + 0.02147684432566166, + 0.03731372952461243, + 0.08784262835979462, + 0.6195167303085327, + 0.014164765365421772, + 0.008257757872343063, + 0.014117566868662834, + 0.11295615136623383, + 0.029098080471158028 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048701103776693344 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive fighter with a bare torso revealing chiseled muscles and battle scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fighter have a mechanical prosthesis on one arm made of matte black carbon fiber and polished steel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, empty concrete hangar with dusty floors and unadorned walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a single harsh spotlight creating high-contrast black-and-white tones with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, low-angle medium shot with the fighter standing motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012540061958134174 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387539863586426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012540061958134174, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012540061958134174, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1903507560491562, + 0.053281866014003754, + 0.31407952308654785, + 0.025772470980882645, + 0.03569968789815903, + 0.034577127546072006, + 0.01989113911986351, + 0.029019901528954506, + 0.03800636902451515, + 0.2593211233615875 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012540061958134174 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive fighter with a bare torso revealing chiseled muscles and battle scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fighter have a mechanical prosthesis on one arm made of matte black carbon fiber and polished steel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, empty concrete hangar with dusty floors and unadorned walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a single harsh spotlight creating high-contrast black-and-white tones with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, low-angle medium shot with the fighter standing motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005951777566224337 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130951881408691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005951777566224337, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005951777566224337, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.017251627519726753, + 0.022167488932609558, + 0.061500582844018936, + 0.020559828728437424, + 0.3542710840702057, + 0.02448270097374916, + 0.03926382213830948, + 0.013066122308373451, + 0.0666837990283966, + 0.3807528614997864 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005951777566224337 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive fighter with a bare torso revealing chiseled muscles and battle scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fighter have a mechanical prosthesis on one arm made of matte black carbon fiber and polished steel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, empty concrete hangar with dusty floors and unadorned walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a single harsh spotlight creating high-contrast black-and-white tones with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, low-angle medium shot with the fighter standing motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761590600013733 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261590600013733 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761590600013733, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761590600013733, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.025452706962823868, + 0.03408662974834442, + 0.05304012447595596, + 0.0733281746506691, + 0.38905641436576843, + 0.03253637254238129, + 0.013093147426843643, + 0.03931567072868347, + 0.1094331368803978, + 0.2306576818227768 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761590600013733 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, medium shot captures a massive fighter in the vast emptiness of a brutal concrete hangar. His bare torso reveals chiseled, taut muscles, interwoven with ancient, jagged battle scars and intricate cybernetic augmentations. One arm is a fully mechanical prosthesis constructed of matte black carbon fiber and polished steel, its complex servos humming faintly as metal plates seamlessly graft onto his jaw and neck, a single, cool blue LED pulsing steadily. Clad in dark, heavy tactical pants tucked into worn combat boots, his posture a coiled spring of latent violence. He stands motionless, facing an unseen opponent off-screen, his cold, piercing gray eyes unwavering, unblinking and radiating pure focus. The entire scene is sculpted from above and to the side by a single, harsh spotlight, creating a dramatic black-and-white contrast effect, with deep, elongated shadows stretching across the dusty concrete floor. The stark, high-contrast lighting gleamed off his metal reinforcements, defining every sinew while plunging the hangar's vast, unadorned walls into near-total darkness. A palpable, unspoken tension hung in the air, creating a grim, suspenseful atmosphere of an impending, brutal confrontation.", + "seed": 10306, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_6/index_5407_seed_10306_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.3353645741939545, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3353645741939545, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3353645741939545, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive fighter with a bare torso revealing chiseled muscles and battle scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fighter have a mechanical prosthesis on one arm made of matte black carbon fiber and polished steel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, empty concrete hangar with dusty floors and unadorned walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a single harsh spotlight creating high-contrast black-and-white tones with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, low-angle medium shot with the fighter standing motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07064805179834366 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695647954940796 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07064805179834366, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07064805179834366, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14723937213420868, + 0.14340925216674805, + 0.028510181233286858, + 0.09748426824808121, + 0.03288905695080757, + 0.05785219743847847, + 0.05826262757182121, + 0.2860710322856903, + 0.06719847768545151, + 0.08108348399400711 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07064805179834366 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive fighter with a bare torso revealing chiseled muscles and battle scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fighter have a mechanical prosthesis on one arm made of matte black carbon fiber and polished steel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, empty concrete hangar with dusty floors and unadorned walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a single harsh spotlight creating high-contrast black-and-white tones with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, low-angle medium shot with the fighter standing motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048688389360904694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486884117126465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048688389360904694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048688389360904694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16172292828559875, + 0.1813165843486786, + 0.06893699616193771, + 0.18159228563308716, + 0.050396088510751724, + 0.03095817007124424, + 0.046564389020204544, + 0.088414266705513, + 0.13415704667568207, + 0.05594118312001228 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048688389360904694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive fighter with a bare torso revealing chiseled muscles and battle scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fighter have a mechanical prosthesis on one arm made of matte black carbon fiber and polished steel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, empty concrete hangar with dusty floors and unadorned walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a single harsh spotlight creating high-contrast black-and-white tones with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, low-angle medium shot with the fighter standing motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048666246235370636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.04866623878479 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048666246235370636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048666246235370636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3409809470176697, + 0.10673894733190536, + 0.02577146887779236, + 0.16212783753871918, + 0.055805984884500504, + 0.1492149531841278, + 0.05537540093064308, + 0.034628789871931076, + 0.030832290649414062, + 0.03852340579032898 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048666246235370636 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive fighter with a bare torso revealing chiseled muscles and battle scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fighter have a mechanical prosthesis on one arm made of matte black carbon fiber and polished steel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, empty concrete hangar with dusty floors and unadorned walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a single harsh spotlight creating high-contrast black-and-white tones with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, low-angle medium shot with the fighter standing motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006739504635334015 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006739616394043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006739504635334015, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006739504635334015, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25325289368629456, + 0.07840756326913834, + 0.07348912209272385, + 0.18198274075984955, + 0.061538659036159515, + 0.0484081506729126, + 0.09913747757673264, + 0.0325990729033947, + 0.09941448271274567, + 0.07176988571882248 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006739504635334015 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive fighter with a bare torso revealing chiseled muscles and battle scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fighter have a mechanical prosthesis on one arm made of matte black carbon fiber and polished steel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, empty concrete hangar with dusty floors and unadorned walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a single harsh spotlight creating high-contrast black-and-white tones with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, low-angle medium shot with the fighter standing motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020806789398193 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520807087421417 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5020806789398193, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5020806789398193, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14329442381858826, + 0.12140451371669769, + 0.2501840591430664, + 0.1477859765291214, + 0.0541251040995121, + 0.042232707142829895, + 0.03115086816251278, + 0.04799150303006172, + 0.05525454506278038, + 0.10657623410224915 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5020806789398193 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, medium shot captures a massive fighter in the vast emptiness of a brutal concrete hangar. His bare torso reveals chiseled, taut muscles, interwoven with ancient, jagged battle scars and intricate cybernetic augmentations. One arm is a fully mechanical prosthesis constructed of matte black carbon fiber and polished steel, its complex servos humming faintly as metal plates seamlessly graft onto his jaw and neck, a single, cool blue LED pulsing steadily. Clad in dark, heavy tactical pants tucked into worn combat boots, his posture a coiled spring of latent violence. He stands motionless, facing an unseen opponent off-screen, his cold, piercing gray eyes unwavering, unblinking and radiating pure focus. The entire scene is sculpted from above and to the side by a single, harsh spotlight, creating a dramatic black-and-white contrast effect, with deep, elongated shadows stretching across the dusty concrete floor. The stark, high-contrast lighting gleamed off his metal reinforcements, defining every sinew while plunging the hangar's vast, unadorned walls into near-total darkness. A palpable, unspoken tension hung in the air, creating a grim, suspenseful atmosphere of an impending, brutal confrontation.", + "seed": 10307, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_6/index_5407_seed_10307_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04785256613977253, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04785256613977253, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04785256613977253, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive fighter with a bare torso revealing chiseled muscles and battle scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fighter have a mechanical prosthesis on one arm made of matte black carbon fiber and polished steel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, empty concrete hangar with dusty floors and unadorned walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a single harsh spotlight creating high-contrast black-and-white tones with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, low-angle medium shot with the fighter standing motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06285865604877472 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8128585815429688 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06285865604877472, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06285865604877472, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1636747270822525, + 0.03280354291200638, + 0.017616724595427513, + 0.03620823472738266, + 0.05769629776477814, + 0.0839858427643776, + 0.22130833566188812, + 0.2526445686817169, + 0.07806050777435303, + 0.056001245975494385 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06285865604877472 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive fighter with a bare torso revealing chiseled muscles and battle scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fighter have a mechanical prosthesis on one arm made of matte black carbon fiber and polished steel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, empty concrete hangar with dusty floors and unadorned walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a single harsh spotlight creating high-contrast black-and-white tones with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, low-angle medium shot with the fighter standing motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0430925153195858 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680924892425537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0430925153195858, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0430925153195858, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1930062174797058, + 0.056702788919210434, + 0.05864289030432701, + 0.053383711725473404, + 0.04903663694858551, + 0.11540648341178894, + 0.10019777715206146, + 0.1886005401611328, + 0.09887081384658813, + 0.08615218102931976 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0430925153195858 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive fighter with a bare torso revealing chiseled muscles and battle scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fighter have a mechanical prosthesis on one arm made of matte black carbon fiber and polished steel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, empty concrete hangar with dusty floors and unadorned walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a single harsh spotlight creating high-contrast black-and-white tones with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, low-angle medium shot with the fighter standing motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018187422305345535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187522888184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018187422305345535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018187422305345535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.41725149750709534, + 0.06838884204626083, + 0.06381106376647949, + 0.14020869135856628, + 0.05824820697307587, + 0.1205921322107315, + 0.03761358931660652, + 0.03975784033536911, + 0.01833653450012207, + 0.03579159080982208 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018187422305345535 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive fighter with a bare torso revealing chiseled muscles and battle scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fighter have a mechanical prosthesis on one arm made of matte black carbon fiber and polished steel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, empty concrete hangar with dusty floors and unadorned walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a single harsh spotlight creating high-contrast black-and-white tones with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, low-angle medium shot with the fighter standing motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002198066795244813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127198219299316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002198066795244813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002198066795244813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26994675397872925, + 0.07269086688756943, + 0.04591665044426918, + 0.060282573103904724, + 0.03351163491606712, + 0.07461749762296677, + 0.1200539618730545, + 0.07943447679281235, + 0.05229168385267258, + 0.1912538707256317 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002198066795244813 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive fighter with a bare torso revealing chiseled muscles and battle scars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the fighter have a mechanical prosthesis on one arm made of matte black carbon fiber and polished steel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast, empty concrete hangar with dusty floors and unadorned walls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting dominated by a single harsh spotlight creating high-contrast black-and-white tones with deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static, low-angle medium shot with the fighter standing motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1129261702299118 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379262447357178 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1129261702299118, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1129261702299118, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08894342929124832, + 0.0566122867166996, + 0.04004859924316406, + 0.05459747090935707, + 0.036850180476903915, + 0.12665589153766632, + 0.1387382596731186, + 0.07665744423866272, + 0.1253366768360138, + 0.2555597126483917 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1129261702299118 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_7/index_tensor([7953, 7953])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_7/index_tensor([7953, 7953])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..84fe186c430059161e73cc522842790f9428f2a5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_7/index_tensor([7953, 7953])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In the style of a sports documentary, a fluid and dynamic side-angle tracking shot follows, transporting us into the clear blue depths of the ocean. Sunlight filtering through the surface creates dancing beams of light, illuminating a magnificent spectacle: thousands of shimmering silver bonito, each with a sleek, spindle-shaped body, moving in coordinated, fluid motion at breathtaking speed. Their tail fins sway in unison, their mirror-like silver flanks refracting in the light, creating countless, ever-changing flashes that stand in stark contrast to the deep blue, almost black, of their backs. With uncanny precision, these independent organisms form a vast, three-dimensional vortex, constantly rotating counterclockwise at high speed, resembling a living, silver tornado roaring in the depths of the ocean. The camera pans along the edge of the vortex, capturing dazzling details inside the school of fish - each fish maintains a perfect distance from its neighbors, together creating a dynamic balance that is both chaotic and orderly. The entire picture is full of primitive vitality and an awe-inspiring sense of collective power, perfectly showcasing the ultimate beauty of teamwork in nature.", + "seed": 26272, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_7/index_7953_seed_26272_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06151335046160966, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06151335046160966, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06151335046160966, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of shimmering silver bonito fish visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the fish form a vast, three-dimensional vortex rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the clear blue depths of the ocean with sunlight filtering through the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a side-angle tracking shot panning along the edge of the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the fish display mirror-like silver flanks that refract light to create flashes contrasting with their dark backs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008265336975455284 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.008265495300293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008265336975455284, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008265336975455284, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35977455973625183, + 0.07833154499530792, + 0.0918562188744545, + 0.11601961404085159, + 0.0738254189491272, + 0.05851680412888527, + 0.052122894674539566, + 0.06821177899837494, + 0.04082377627491951, + 0.06051739677786827 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008265336975455284 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of shimmering silver bonito fish visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the fish form a vast, three-dimensional vortex rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the clear blue depths of the ocean with sunlight filtering through the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a side-angle tracking shot panning along the edge of the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the fish display mirror-like silver flanks that refract light to create flashes contrasting with their dark backs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043083954602479935 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168083906173706 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043083954602479935, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043083954602479935, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1894712597131729, + 0.07314468920230865, + 0.101964071393013, + 0.0958496704697609, + 0.041965585201978683, + 0.054084669798612595, + 0.30485230684280396, + 0.03250874951481819, + 0.06232032552361488, + 0.04383863881230354 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043083954602479935 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of shimmering silver bonito fish visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the fish form a vast, three-dimensional vortex rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the clear blue depths of the ocean with sunlight filtering through the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a side-angle tracking shot panning along the edge of the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the fish display mirror-like silver flanks that refract light to create flashes contrasting with their dark backs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002197947818785906 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127197742462158 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002197947818785906, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002197947818785906, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19841061532497406, + 0.11757473647594452, + 0.0853358581662178, + 0.18636147677898407, + 0.05428443104028702, + 0.043072935193777084, + 0.18611283600330353, + 0.03748752921819687, + 0.03572562336921692, + 0.0556340366601944 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002197947818785906 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of shimmering silver bonito fish visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the fish form a vast, three-dimensional vortex rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the clear blue depths of the ocean with sunlight filtering through the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a side-angle tracking shot panning along the edge of the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the fish display mirror-like silver flanks that refract light to create flashes contrasting with their dark backs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520742416381836 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020742416381836 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520742416381836, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520742416381836, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07252272218465805, + 0.060514532029628754, + 0.050913967192173004, + 0.1455390900373459, + 0.05553737282752991, + 0.05332253873348236, + 0.4364371597766876, + 0.030031738802790642, + 0.04767044261097908, + 0.047510456293821335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520742416381836 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of shimmering silver bonito fish visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the fish form a vast, three-dimensional vortex rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the clear blue depths of the ocean with sunlight filtering through the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a side-angle tracking shot panning along the edge of the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the fish display mirror-like silver flanks that refract light to create flashes contrasting with their dark backs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019452712731435895 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251945495605469 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019452712731435895, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019452712731435895, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20124167203903198, + 0.10418041795492172, + 0.09082711488008499, + 0.1006707102060318, + 0.1110856905579567, + 0.06357786059379578, + 0.15396980941295624, + 0.10269566625356674, + 0.03040670044720173, + 0.04134431853890419 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019452712731435895 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the style of a sports documentary, a fluid and dynamic side-angle tracking shot follows, transporting us into the clear blue depths of the ocean. Sunlight filtering through the surface creates dancing beams of light, illuminating a magnificent spectacle: thousands of shimmering silver bonito, each with a sleek, spindle-shaped body, moving in coordinated, fluid motion at breathtaking speed. Their tail fins sway in unison, their mirror-like silver flanks refracting in the light, creating countless, ever-changing flashes that stand in stark contrast to the deep blue, almost black, of their backs. With uncanny precision, these independent organisms form a vast, three-dimensional vortex, constantly rotating counterclockwise at high speed, resembling a living, silver tornado roaring in the depths of the ocean. The camera pans along the edge of the vortex, capturing dazzling details inside the school of fish - each fish maintains a perfect distance from its neighbors, together creating a dynamic balance that is both chaotic and orderly. The entire picture is full of primitive vitality and an awe-inspiring sense of collective power, perfectly showcasing the ultimate beauty of teamwork in nature.", + "seed": 26273, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_7/index_7953_seed_26273_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06472779529867694, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06472779529867694, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06472779529867694, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of shimmering silver bonito fish visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the fish form a vast, three-dimensional vortex rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the clear blue depths of the ocean with sunlight filtering through the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a side-angle tracking shot panning along the edge of the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the fish display mirror-like silver flanks that refract light to create flashes contrasting with their dark backs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013730364851653576 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.388730525970459 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013730364851653576, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013730364851653576, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1695082187652588, + 0.06742536276578903, + 0.10141054540872574, + 0.07315059006214142, + 0.08531948179006577, + 0.07966781407594681, + 0.12084893137216568, + 0.022135775536298752, + 0.16154853999614716, + 0.11898471415042877 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013730364851653576 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of shimmering silver bonito fish visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the fish form a vast, three-dimensional vortex rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the clear blue depths of the ocean with sunlight filtering through the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a side-angle tracking shot panning along the edge of the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the fish display mirror-like silver flanks that refract light to create flashes contrasting with their dark backs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054970771074295044 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299707412719727 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054970771074295044, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054970771074295044, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10102306306362152, + 0.04792066290974617, + 0.07133256644010544, + 0.06311070173978806, + 0.05791892111301422, + 0.09647027403116226, + 0.15329502522945404, + 0.028531396761536598, + 0.1083226203918457, + 0.27207475900650024 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054970771074295044 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of shimmering silver bonito fish visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the fish form a vast, three-dimensional vortex rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the clear blue depths of the ocean with sunlight filtering through the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a side-angle tracking shot panning along the edge of the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the fish display mirror-like silver flanks that refract light to create flashes contrasting with their dark backs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0009201106731779873 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.000920295715332 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0009201106731779873, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0009201106731779873, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09945236146450043, + 0.1149815246462822, + 0.048061124980449677, + 0.12452150136232376, + 0.10032103955745697, + 0.09212100505828857, + 0.060849107801914215, + 0.04537133872509003, + 0.07572389394044876, + 0.2385970801115036 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0009201106731779873 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of shimmering silver bonito fish visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the fish form a vast, three-dimensional vortex rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the clear blue depths of the ocean with sunlight filtering through the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a side-angle tracking shot panning along the edge of the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the fish display mirror-like silver flanks that refract light to create flashes contrasting with their dark backs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25207507610321045 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020750761032104 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25207507610321045, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25207507610321045, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04271237552165985, + 0.09664922207593918, + 0.08388382941484451, + 0.061741095036268234, + 0.027326827868819237, + 0.05681444704532623, + 0.18546590209007263, + 0.05756710097193718, + 0.13489839434623718, + 0.252940833568573 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25207507610321045 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of shimmering silver bonito fish visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the fish form a vast, three-dimensional vortex rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the clear blue depths of the ocean with sunlight filtering through the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a side-angle tracking shot panning along the edge of the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the fish display mirror-like silver flanks that refract light to create flashes contrasting with their dark backs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019426537910476327 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.2519426345825195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019426537910476327, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019426537910476327, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22171667218208313, + 0.10530409216880798, + 0.07173998653888702, + 0.035982467234134674, + 0.050135061144828796, + 0.10886510461568832, + 0.10504753142595291, + 0.03325483947992325, + 0.08493657410144806, + 0.18301762640476227 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019426537910476327 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the style of a sports documentary, a fluid and dynamic side-angle tracking shot follows, transporting us into the clear blue depths of the ocean. Sunlight filtering through the surface creates dancing beams of light, illuminating a magnificent spectacle: thousands of shimmering silver bonito, each with a sleek, spindle-shaped body, moving in coordinated, fluid motion at breathtaking speed. Their tail fins sway in unison, their mirror-like silver flanks refracting in the light, creating countless, ever-changing flashes that stand in stark contrast to the deep blue, almost black, of their backs. With uncanny precision, these independent organisms form a vast, three-dimensional vortex, constantly rotating counterclockwise at high speed, resembling a living, silver tornado roaring in the depths of the ocean. The camera pans along the edge of the vortex, capturing dazzling details inside the school of fish - each fish maintains a perfect distance from its neighbors, together creating a dynamic balance that is both chaotic and orderly. The entire picture is full of primitive vitality and an awe-inspiring sense of collective power, perfectly showcasing the ultimate beauty of teamwork in nature.", + "seed": 26274, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_7/index_7953_seed_26274_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06124725395347923, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06124725395347923, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06124725395347923, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of shimmering silver bonito fish visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the fish form a vast, three-dimensional vortex rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the clear blue depths of the ocean with sunlight filtering through the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a side-angle tracking shot panning along the edge of the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the fish display mirror-like silver flanks that refract light to create flashes contrasting with their dark backs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006302718538790941 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.256302833557129 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006302718538790941, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006302718538790941, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3823595345020294, + 0.14121580123901367, + 0.07254082709550858, + 0.046196259558200836, + 0.04588735103607178, + 0.03580044209957123, + 0.08554243296384811, + 0.03255505859851837, + 0.04894816502928734, + 0.10895408689975739 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006302718538790941 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of shimmering silver bonito fish visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the fish form a vast, three-dimensional vortex rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the clear blue depths of the ocean with sunlight filtering through the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a side-angle tracking shot panning along the edge of the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the fish display mirror-like silver flanks that refract light to create flashes contrasting with their dark backs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308303818106651 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680829524993896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308303818106651, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308303818106651, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4386371672153473, + 0.03765757381916046, + 0.1308733969926834, + 0.1069955974817276, + 0.04039210453629494, + 0.027065221220254898, + 0.0529274046421051, + 0.025062033906579018, + 0.12240491807460785, + 0.01798456348478794 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308303818106651 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of shimmering silver bonito fish visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the fish form a vast, three-dimensional vortex rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the clear blue depths of the ocean with sunlight filtering through the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a side-angle tracking shot panning along the edge of the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the fish display mirror-like silver flanks that refract light to create flashes contrasting with their dark backs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002819731365889311 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877819538116455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002819731365889311, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002819731365889311, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11348969489336014, + 0.0917821004986763, + 0.09015467017889023, + 0.040854617953300476, + 0.10256055742502213, + 0.026648160070180893, + 0.21481819450855255, + 0.01764579489827156, + 0.28053802251815796, + 0.021508172154426575 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002819731365889311 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of shimmering silver bonito fish visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the fish form a vast, three-dimensional vortex rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the clear blue depths of the ocean with sunlight filtering through the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a side-angle tracking shot panning along the edge of the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the fish display mirror-like silver flanks that refract light to create flashes contrasting with their dark backs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520872950553894 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020873546600342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520872950553894, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520872950553894, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09478287398815155, + 0.05386043339967728, + 0.07981091737747192, + 0.10721408575773239, + 0.11232377588748932, + 0.08880845457315445, + 0.22034184634685516, + 0.036819569766521454, + 0.18639139831066132, + 0.019646678119897842 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520872950553894 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of shimmering silver bonito fish visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the fish form a vast, three-dimensional vortex rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the clear blue depths of the ocean with sunlight filtering through the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a side-angle tracking shot panning along the edge of the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the fish display mirror-like silver flanks that refract light to create flashes contrasting with their dark backs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019434866262599826 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251943588256836 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019434866262599826, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019434866262599826, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16898226737976074, + 0.08628198504447937, + 0.04635658860206604, + 0.035459864884614944, + 0.029125234112143517, + 0.04169998690485954, + 0.08965500444173813, + 0.041973214596509933, + 0.40866389870643616, + 0.0518018938601017 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019434866262599826 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the style of a sports documentary, a fluid and dynamic side-angle tracking shot follows, transporting us into the clear blue depths of the ocean. Sunlight filtering through the surface creates dancing beams of light, illuminating a magnificent spectacle: thousands of shimmering silver bonito, each with a sleek, spindle-shaped body, moving in coordinated, fluid motion at breathtaking speed. Their tail fins sway in unison, their mirror-like silver flanks refracting in the light, creating countless, ever-changing flashes that stand in stark contrast to the deep blue, almost black, of their backs. With uncanny precision, these independent organisms form a vast, three-dimensional vortex, constantly rotating counterclockwise at high speed, resembling a living, silver tornado roaring in the depths of the ocean. The camera pans along the edge of the vortex, capturing dazzling details inside the school of fish - each fish maintains a perfect distance from its neighbors, together creating a dynamic balance that is both chaotic and orderly. The entire picture is full of primitive vitality and an awe-inspiring sense of collective power, perfectly showcasing the ultimate beauty of teamwork in nature.", + "seed": 26275, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_7/index_7953_seed_26275_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10692258510971442, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10692258510971442, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10692258510971442, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of shimmering silver bonito fish visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the fish form a vast, three-dimensional vortex rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the clear blue depths of the ocean with sunlight filtering through the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a side-angle tracking shot panning along the edge of the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the fish display mirror-like silver flanks that refract light to create flashes contrasting with their dark backs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009153308346867561 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.884153366088867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009153308346867561, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009153308346867561, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07208113372325897, + 0.06220586970448494, + 0.13050876557826996, + 0.06768504530191422, + 0.2266790270805359, + 0.06095528230071068, + 0.12265154719352722, + 0.0175822414457798, + 0.19291894137859344, + 0.04673212021589279 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009153308346867561 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of shimmering silver bonito fish visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the fish form a vast, three-dimensional vortex rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the clear blue depths of the ocean with sunlight filtering through the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a side-angle tracking shot panning along the edge of the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the fish display mirror-like silver flanks that refract light to create flashes contrasting with their dark backs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867078736424446 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048670768737793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867078736424446, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867078736424446, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0981861874461174, + 0.053612761199474335, + 0.07572336494922638, + 0.07857047021389008, + 0.21661193668842316, + 0.05144256725907326, + 0.10133564472198486, + 0.046108342707157135, + 0.2455613911151886, + 0.032847389578819275 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867078736424446 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of shimmering silver bonito fish visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the fish form a vast, three-dimensional vortex rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the clear blue depths of the ocean with sunlight filtering through the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a side-angle tracking shot panning along the edge of the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the fish display mirror-like silver flanks that refract light to create flashes contrasting with their dark backs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0008139872807078063 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.125813961029053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0008139872807078063, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0008139872807078063, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09235222637653351, + 0.09111221879720688, + 0.09653123468160629, + 0.19620934128761292, + 0.22700539231300354, + 0.03937280923128128, + 0.10672664642333984, + 0.03342467173933983, + 0.07716380804777145, + 0.04010159894824028 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0008139872807078063 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of shimmering silver bonito fish visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the fish form a vast, three-dimensional vortex rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the clear blue depths of the ocean with sunlight filtering through the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a side-angle tracking shot panning along the edge of the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the fish display mirror-like silver flanks that refract light to create flashes contrasting with their dark backs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4742574393749237 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742574691772461 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4742574393749237, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4742574393749237, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03813181817531586, + 0.034939613193273544, + 0.29354533553123474, + 0.13077601790428162, + 0.24747490882873535, + 0.025488903746008873, + 0.036509547382593155, + 0.07533179223537445, + 0.07094706594944, + 0.046855002641677856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4742574393749237 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of shimmering silver bonito fish visible in the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the fish form a vast, three-dimensional vortex rotating counterclockwise?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment the clear blue depths of the ocean with sunlight filtering through the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a side-angle tracking shot panning along the edge of the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the fish display mirror-like silver flanks that refract light to create flashes contrasting with their dark backs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017174031818285584 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376717567443848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017174031818285584, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017174031818285584, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15018035471439362, + 0.04496075212955475, + 0.294093519449234, + 0.060097310692071915, + 0.05547034367918968, + 0.0577487014234066, + 0.06572779268026352, + 0.0385037325322628, + 0.15562087297439575, + 0.07759658247232437 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017174031818285584 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_8/index_tensor([5801, 5801])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_8/index_tensor([5801, 5801])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2459e145dc7688beef213383e51082a37eec48e4 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_8/index_tensor([5801, 5801])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "This surreal CGI rendering, captured in an intimate macro close-up, focuses on a cluster of slender stems of weaver bamboo. The camera exhibits a subtle, organic tremor, as if guided by the observer's steady breath in the cool, tranquil morning air. Each vibrant green stalk and delicate, lance-shaped leaf is rendered with photorealistic precision, their surfaces shimmering with a blanket of countless droplets of crystalline morning dew. Soft, diffuse light filtering through the invisible treetops captures these spherical beads of moisture and refracts them into a dynamic array of tiny, luminous sparks that dance and shimmer through the woods. The shallow depth of field blurs the background into a soft, painterly bokeh of greens and muted earth tones, enhancing the sense of tranquil isolation. The overall cool color palette and the gentle, almost imperceptible movement of the frame work together to create an atmosphere of profound tranquility and contemplation, immersing the viewer in the scene's serene beauty.", + "seed": 23627, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_8/index_5801_seed_23627_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.010484510194510221, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010484510194510221, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010484510194510221, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cluster of slender weaver bamboo stems with lance-shaped leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks and leaves vibrant green and covered in countless droplets of dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle, organic tremor resembling a steady breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into a soft, painterly bokeh of greens and muted earth tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a cool color palette and diffuse lighting that refracts dew into luminous sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01372060552239418 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.388720512390137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01372060552239418, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01372060552239418, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11281009763479233, + 0.041317496448755264, + 0.03523583337664604, + 0.03688949719071388, + 0.05178079381585121, + 0.037873342633247375, + 0.3206629753112793, + 0.06731543689966202, + 0.13485434651374817, + 0.1612602174282074 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01372060552239418 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cluster of slender weaver bamboo stems with lance-shaped leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks and leaves vibrant green and covered in countless droplets of dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle, organic tremor resembling a steady breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into a soft, painterly bokeh of greens and muted earth tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a cool color palette and diffuse lighting that refracts dew into luminous sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006744240876287222 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006744384765625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006744240876287222, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006744240876287222, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10046619176864624, + 0.06205470860004425, + 0.03273157402873039, + 0.029242563992738724, + 0.07737856358289719, + 0.07420192658901215, + 0.18814338743686676, + 0.06361980736255646, + 0.09028360992670059, + 0.28187766671180725 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006744240876287222 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cluster of slender weaver bamboo stems with lance-shaped leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks and leaves vibrant green and covered in countless droplets of dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle, organic tremor resembling a steady breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into a soft, painterly bokeh of greens and muted earth tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a cool color palette and diffuse lighting that refracts dew into luminous sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023285046219825745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773285150527954 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023285046219825745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023285046219825745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11244726181030273, + 0.05253181606531143, + 0.08689284324645996, + 0.07338099926710129, + 0.050495050847530365, + 0.05457029864192009, + 0.3815006911754608, + 0.05689803510904312, + 0.06899465620517731, + 0.0622883066534996 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023285046219825745 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cluster of slender weaver bamboo stems with lance-shaped leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks and leaves vibrant green and covered in countless droplets of dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle, organic tremor resembling a steady breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into a soft, painterly bokeh of greens and muted earth tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a cool color palette and diffuse lighting that refracts dew into luminous sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019369428046047688 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251936912536621 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019369428046047688, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019369428046047688, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14531277120113373, + 0.062142953276634216, + 0.0706682875752449, + 0.07254882156848907, + 0.06272225081920624, + 0.038956381380558014, + 0.2030794620513916, + 0.10352915525436401, + 0.038578350096940994, + 0.20246148109436035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019369428046047688 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cluster of slender weaver bamboo stems with lance-shaped leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks and leaves vibrant green and covered in countless droplets of dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle, organic tremor resembling a steady breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into a soft, painterly bokeh of greens and muted earth tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a cool color palette and diffuse lighting that refracts dew into luminous sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006735715549439192 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006735801696777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006735715549439192, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006735715549439192, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11814724653959274, + 0.09892656654119492, + 0.03397104889154434, + 0.030855000019073486, + 0.052926063537597656, + 0.09415498375892639, + 0.2485596239566803, + 0.11217062920331955, + 0.06049157679080963, + 0.1497972458600998 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006735715549439192 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This surreal CGI rendering, captured in an intimate macro close-up, focuses on a cluster of slender stems of weaver bamboo. The camera exhibits a subtle, organic tremor, as if guided by the observer's steady breath in the cool, tranquil morning air. Each vibrant green stalk and delicate, lance-shaped leaf is rendered with photorealistic precision, their surfaces shimmering with a blanket of countless droplets of crystalline morning dew. Soft, diffuse light filtering through the invisible treetops captures these spherical beads of moisture and refracts them into a dynamic array of tiny, luminous sparks that dance and shimmer through the woods. The shallow depth of field blurs the background into a soft, painterly bokeh of greens and muted earth tones, enhancing the sense of tranquil isolation. The overall cool color palette and the gentle, almost imperceptible movement of the frame work together to create an atmosphere of profound tranquility and contemplation, immersing the viewer in the scene's serene beauty.", + "seed": 23628, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_8/index_5801_seed_23628_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.008581522852182388, + "vlm_logprob": -0.008581522852182388, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.008581522852182388, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cluster of slender weaver bamboo stems with lance-shaped leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks and leaves vibrant green and covered in countless droplets of dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle, organic tremor resembling a steady breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into a soft, painterly bokeh of greens and muted earth tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a cool color palette and diffuse lighting that refracts dew into luminous sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010601039975881577 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.635601043701172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010601039975881577, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010601039975881577, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14155125617980957, + 0.08460856974124908, + 0.13738210499286652, + 0.037968527525663376, + 0.10299529135227203, + 0.04126554727554321, + 0.2708728611469269, + 0.061128027737140656, + 0.06983357667922974, + 0.052394215017557144 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010601039975881577 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cluster of slender weaver bamboo stems with lance-shaped leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks and leaves vibrant green and covered in countless droplets of dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle, organic tremor resembling a steady breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into a soft, painterly bokeh of greens and muted earth tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a cool color palette and diffuse lighting that refracts dew into luminous sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067449514754116535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006744861602783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067449514754116535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067449514754116535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07870464026927948, + 0.15438389778137207, + 0.10287401080131531, + 0.07821712642908096, + 0.03196096047759056, + 0.08115582913160324, + 0.19177450239658356, + 0.14507624506950378, + 0.0776379331946373, + 0.05821486935019493 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067449514754116535 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cluster of slender weaver bamboo stems with lance-shaped leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks and leaves vibrant green and covered in countless droplets of dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle, organic tremor resembling a steady breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into a soft, painterly bokeh of greens and muted earth tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a cool color palette and diffuse lighting that refracts dew into luminous sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014190481044352055 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264190673828125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014190481044352055, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014190481044352055, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12085042893886566, + 0.12549549341201782, + 0.050329357385635376, + 0.08969347178936005, + 0.06314468383789062, + 0.0681171864271164, + 0.15726850926876068, + 0.10021034628152847, + 0.119920514523983, + 0.10496997833251953 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014190481044352055 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cluster of slender weaver bamboo stems with lance-shaped leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks and leaves vibrant green and covered in countless droplets of dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle, organic tremor resembling a steady breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into a soft, painterly bokeh of greens and muted earth tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a cool color palette and diffuse lighting that refracts dew into luminous sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006733584217727184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006733417510986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006733584217727184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006733584217727184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13679789006710052, + 0.08591568470001221, + 0.11705968528985977, + 0.10064388811588287, + 0.0720321387052536, + 0.10511060804128647, + 0.1927238404750824, + 0.11258995532989502, + 0.04327390715479851, + 0.03385242074728012 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006733584217727184 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cluster of slender weaver bamboo stems with lance-shaped leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks and leaves vibrant green and covered in countless droplets of dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle, organic tremor resembling a steady breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into a soft, painterly bokeh of greens and muted earth tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a cool color palette and diffuse lighting that refracts dew into luminous sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004637557547539473 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379637718200684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004637557547539473, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004637557547539473, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12007515877485275, + 0.09637896716594696, + 0.053989801555871964, + 0.0616854764521122, + 0.03862524777650833, + 0.03940068557858467, + 0.14918814599514008, + 0.2863006591796875, + 0.07332911342382431, + 0.08102678507566452 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004637557547539473 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This surreal CGI rendering, captured in an intimate macro close-up, focuses on a cluster of slender stems of weaver bamboo. The camera exhibits a subtle, organic tremor, as if guided by the observer's steady breath in the cool, tranquil morning air. Each vibrant green stalk and delicate, lance-shaped leaf is rendered with photorealistic precision, their surfaces shimmering with a blanket of countless droplets of crystalline morning dew. Soft, diffuse light filtering through the invisible treetops captures these spherical beads of moisture and refracts them into a dynamic array of tiny, luminous sparks that dance and shimmer through the woods. The shallow depth of field blurs the background into a soft, painterly bokeh of greens and muted earth tones, enhancing the sense of tranquil isolation. The overall cool color palette and the gentle, almost imperceptible movement of the frame work together to create an atmosphere of profound tranquility and contemplation, immersing the viewer in the scene's serene beauty.", + "seed": 23629, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_8/index_5801_seed_23629_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.016263084043748675, + "vlm_logprob": -0.016263084043748675, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.524999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.016263084043748675, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cluster of slender weaver bamboo stems with lance-shaped leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks and leaves vibrant green and covered in countless droplets of dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle, organic tremor resembling a steady breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into a soft, painterly bokeh of greens and muted earth tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a cool color palette and diffuse lighting that refracts dew into luminous sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01554679311811924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.265546798706055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01554679311811924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01554679311811924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1203354001045227, + 0.06033388152718544, + 0.19019630551338196, + 0.07336068898439407, + 0.08906851708889008, + 0.1245492473244667, + 0.04709329456090927, + 0.06451599299907684, + 0.15164218842983246, + 0.07890445739030838 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01554679311811924 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cluster of slender weaver bamboo stems with lance-shaped leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks and leaves vibrant green and covered in countless droplets of dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle, organic tremor resembling a steady breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into a soft, painterly bokeh of greens and muted earth tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a cool color palette and diffuse lighting that refracts dew into luminous sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371158614754677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087116718292236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371158614754677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371158614754677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0784563273191452, + 0.08410988748073578, + 0.1760750412940979, + 0.11285368353128433, + 0.060654886066913605, + 0.09699123352766037, + 0.02407914027571678, + 0.13344240188598633, + 0.08423838764429092, + 0.14909903705120087 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371158614754677 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cluster of slender weaver bamboo stems with lance-shaped leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks and leaves vibrant green and covered in countless droplets of dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle, organic tremor resembling a steady breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into a soft, painterly bokeh of greens and muted earth tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a cool color palette and diffuse lighting that refracts dew into luminous sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018183909356594086 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018183708190918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018183909356594086, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018183909356594086, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1064542680978775, + 0.04646729677915573, + 0.07496660947799683, + 0.06023823097348213, + 0.04396314546465874, + 0.42442038655281067, + 0.04244434833526611, + 0.06723672151565552, + 0.027679268270730972, + 0.10612977296113968 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018183909356594086 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cluster of slender weaver bamboo stems with lance-shaped leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks and leaves vibrant green and covered in countless droplets of dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle, organic tremor resembling a steady breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into a soft, painterly bokeh of greens and muted earth tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a cool color palette and diffuse lighting that refracts dew into luminous sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013336582342162728 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626333713531494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013336582342162728, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013336582342162728, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03912712261080742, + 0.022992732003331184, + 0.3860674500465393, + 0.12274923920631409, + 0.07441762089729309, + 0.15723727643489838, + 0.013606960885226727, + 0.05055393651127815, + 0.045190270990133286, + 0.08805739134550095 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013336582342162728 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cluster of slender weaver bamboo stems with lance-shaped leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks and leaves vibrant green and covered in countless droplets of dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle, organic tremor resembling a steady breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into a soft, painterly bokeh of greens and muted earth tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a cool color palette and diffuse lighting that refracts dew into luminous sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012539473362267017 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387539386749268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012539473362267017, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012539473362267017, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05309755727648735, + 0.046328723430633545, + 0.0934392660856247, + 0.0692933201789856, + 0.044874876737594604, + 0.3287642002105713, + 0.028571104630827904, + 0.05463167279958725, + 0.1509033739566803, + 0.13009589910507202 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012539473362267017 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This surreal CGI rendering, captured in an intimate macro close-up, focuses on a cluster of slender stems of weaver bamboo. The camera exhibits a subtle, organic tremor, as if guided by the observer's steady breath in the cool, tranquil morning air. Each vibrant green stalk and delicate, lance-shaped leaf is rendered with photorealistic precision, their surfaces shimmering with a blanket of countless droplets of crystalline morning dew. Soft, diffuse light filtering through the invisible treetops captures these spherical beads of moisture and refracts them into a dynamic array of tiny, luminous sparks that dance and shimmer through the woods. The shallow depth of field blurs the background into a soft, painterly bokeh of greens and muted earth tones, enhancing the sense of tranquil isolation. The overall cool color palette and the gentle, almost imperceptible movement of the frame work together to create an atmosphere of profound tranquility and contemplation, immersing the viewer in the scene's serene beauty.", + "seed": 23630, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_8/index_5801_seed_23630_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.011834612023085356, + "vlm_logprob": -0.011834612023085356, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.011834612023085356, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cluster of slender weaver bamboo stems with lance-shaped leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks and leaves vibrant green and covered in countless droplets of dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle, organic tremor resembling a steady breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into a soft, painterly bokeh of greens and muted earth tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a cool color palette and diffuse lighting that refracts dew into luminous sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013594310730695724 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.388594150543213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013594310730695724, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013594310730695724, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.39072322845458984, + 0.13545745611190796, + 0.02168234810233116, + 0.04617021977901459, + 0.058681946247816086, + 0.1016865223646164, + 0.1240963339805603, + 0.014374501071870327, + 0.01571374386548996, + 0.091413713991642 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013594310730695724 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cluster of slender weaver bamboo stems with lance-shaped leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks and leaves vibrant green and covered in countless droplets of dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle, organic tremor resembling a steady breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into a soft, painterly bokeh of greens and muted earth tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a cool color palette and diffuse lighting that refracts dew into luminous sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011090068146586418 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511090278625488 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011090068146586418, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011090068146586418, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20032808184623718, + 0.11258269101381302, + 0.013673321343958378, + 0.01909666135907173, + 0.17718525230884552, + 0.03819260746240616, + 0.36973580718040466, + 0.02181152068078518, + 0.013878691010177135, + 0.03351530432701111 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011090068146586418 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cluster of slender weaver bamboo stems with lance-shaped leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks and leaves vibrant green and covered in countless droplets of dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle, organic tremor resembling a steady breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into a soft, painterly bokeh of greens and muted earth tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a cool color palette and diffuse lighting that refracts dew into luminous sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02328725904226303 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773287296295166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02328725904226303, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02328725904226303, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1282324641942978, + 0.20824682712554932, + 0.01607324182987213, + 0.03386777639389038, + 0.035545412451028824, + 0.31258171796798706, + 0.1096101775765419, + 0.04462633654475212, + 0.012337608262896538, + 0.09887838363647461 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02328725904226303 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cluster of slender weaver bamboo stems with lance-shaped leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks and leaves vibrant green and covered in countless droplets of dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle, organic tremor resembling a steady breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into a soft, painterly bokeh of greens and muted earth tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a cool color palette and diffuse lighting that refracts dew into luminous sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005250118672847748 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255249977111816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005250118672847748, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005250118672847748, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29086220264434814, + 0.1985495537519455, + 0.01333076786249876, + 0.013739465735852718, + 0.03008650615811348, + 0.07709617912769318, + 0.10853274911642075, + 0.05261596664786339, + 0.02871580980718136, + 0.18647077679634094 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005250118672847748 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a cluster of slender weaver bamboo stems with lance-shaped leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the bamboo stalks and leaves vibrant green and covered in countless droplets of dew?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a subtle, organic tremor resembling a steady breath?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred into a soft, painterly bokeh of greens and muted earth tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered with a cool color palette and diffuse lighting that refracts dew into luminous sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005951303523033857 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130951404571533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005951303523033857, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005951303523033857, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10054533928632736, + 0.12272901087999344, + 0.009738320484757423, + 0.011119638569653034, + 0.1449575424194336, + 0.06879062205553055, + 0.4044716954231262, + 0.07876075059175491, + 0.023067617788910866, + 0.03581942245364189 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005951303523033857 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_9/index_tensor([913, 913])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_9/index_tensor([913, 913])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bfcb031fa5d2146fa07361efe5dd0ddf94eaee69 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_9/index_tensor([913, 913])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a surreal animated sequence in the unmistakable style of Satoshi Kon, a stunning close-up, shot with head-tracking stabilization, maintains a firm focus on a single, bizarre, curled bamboo leaf. Twisting in a spiraling pattern that defies natural growth, the leaf displays a saturated, almost artificial emerald green. Its fine veins resemble the veins of a miniature map, and its waxy surface reflects an indescribable, soft, and constant light source from its surroundings. Stirred by an invisible breeze, the leaf sways in an incredibly slow, almost hypnotic manner. Each minute tremor acts as an invisible editing point, triggering a dramatic shift in the background: the tranquil, blurred, and out-of-focus depths of the bamboo forest seamlessly and illogically transforms into the silhouettes of a crowded city intersection with the leaf's first tremor; then, with the next twitch, the crowd dissolves into a shimmering, red and blue pixelated digital noise. The surreal stability of the foreground objects and the fluid transformation of the background world form a strong and eerie visual contrast, accurately creating a dreamlike, unsettling atmosphere with a strong sense of psychological suspense.", + "seed": 32345, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_9/index_913_seed_32345_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.015061128209345043, + "vlm_logprob": -0.015061128209345043, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.015061128209345043, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single, curled bamboo leaf with a spiraling, unnatural twist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf colored with a saturated, artificial emerald green and does it show fine veins resembling a miniature map?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sway in an incredibly slow, hypnotic manner due to an invisible breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background transform from a blurred bamboo forest to a crowded city intersection, and then to red and blue pixelated digital noise upon the leaf's tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a stunning close-up utilizing head-tracking stabilization that maintains firm focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007134555839002132 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.132134437561035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007134555839002132, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007134555839002132, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.060920942574739456, + 0.07305408269166946, + 0.35011085867881775, + 0.041321419179439545, + 0.06229091435670853, + 0.09857423603534698, + 0.12602786719799042, + 0.09670200943946838, + 0.01249854825437069, + 0.0784991905093193 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007134555839002132 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single, curled bamboo leaf with a spiraling, unnatural twist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf colored with a saturated, artificial emerald green and does it show fine veins resembling a miniature map?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sway in an incredibly slow, hypnotic manner due to an invisible breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background transform from a blurred bamboo forest to a crowded city intersection, and then to red and blue pixelated digital noise upon the leaf's tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a stunning close-up utilizing head-tracking stabilization that maintains firm focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015216212486848235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501521587371826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015216212486848235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015216212486848235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1576397567987442, + 0.09307719022035599, + 0.3195848762989044, + 0.09382741153240204, + 0.06713101267814636, + 0.03570101782679558, + 0.0646490678191185, + 0.056882377713918686, + 0.03360126540064812, + 0.0779060423374176 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015216212486848235 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single, curled bamboo leaf with a spiraling, unnatural twist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf colored with a saturated, artificial emerald green and does it show fine veins resembling a miniature map?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sway in an incredibly slow, hypnotic manner due to an invisible breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background transform from a blurred bamboo forest to a crowded city intersection, and then to red and blue pixelated digital noise upon the leaf's tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a stunning close-up utilizing head-tracking stabilization that maintains firm focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023288888856768608 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732889652252197 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023288888856768608, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023288888856768608, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10897158831357956, + 0.07007215172052383, + 0.32148051261901855, + 0.07941443473100662, + 0.04991713538765907, + 0.0237372238188982, + 0.0689530149102211, + 0.13451538980007172, + 0.08550466597080231, + 0.05743386968970299 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023288888856768608 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single, curled bamboo leaf with a spiraling, unnatural twist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf colored with a saturated, artificial emerald green and does it show fine veins resembling a miniature map?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sway in an incredibly slow, hypnotic manner due to an invisible breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background transform from a blurred bamboo forest to a crowded city intersection, and then to red and blue pixelated digital noise upon the leaf's tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a stunning close-up utilizing head-tracking stabilization that maintains firm focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005259486846625805 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.2552595138549805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005259486846625805, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005259486846625805, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08364976942539215, + 0.05719471350312233, + 0.18318811058998108, + 0.10287682712078094, + 0.06956245750188828, + 0.07099903374910355, + 0.06634465605020523, + 0.11559519171714783, + 0.032203029841184616, + 0.2183862179517746 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005259486846625805 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single, curled bamboo leaf with a spiraling, unnatural twist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf colored with a saturated, artificial emerald green and does it show fine veins resembling a miniature map?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sway in an incredibly slow, hypnotic manner due to an invisible breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background transform from a blurred bamboo forest to a crowded city intersection, and then to red and blue pixelated digital noise upon the leaf's tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a stunning close-up utilizing head-tracking stabilization that maintains firm focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038101088255643845 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881011962890625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038101088255643845, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038101088255643845, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07183138281106949, + 0.06545368582010269, + 0.2682987451553345, + 0.10418014973402023, + 0.037906963378190994, + 0.03125370666384697, + 0.09169872850179672, + 0.17882725596427917, + 0.1003102958202362, + 0.05023903772234917 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038101088255643845 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a surreal animated sequence in the unmistakable style of Satoshi Kon, a stunning close-up, shot with head-tracking stabilization, maintains a firm focus on a single, bizarre, curled bamboo leaf. Twisting in a spiraling pattern that defies natural growth, the leaf displays a saturated, almost artificial emerald green. Its fine veins resemble the veins of a miniature map, and its waxy surface reflects an indescribable, soft, and constant light source from its surroundings. Stirred by an invisible breeze, the leaf sways in an incredibly slow, almost hypnotic manner. Each minute tremor acts as an invisible editing point, triggering a dramatic shift in the background: the tranquil, blurred, and out-of-focus depths of the bamboo forest seamlessly and illogically transforms into the silhouettes of a crowded city intersection with the leaf's first tremor; then, with the next twitch, the crowd dissolves into a shimmering, red and blue pixelated digital noise. The surreal stability of the foreground objects and the fluid transformation of the background world form a strong and eerie visual contrast, accurately creating a dreamlike, unsettling atmosphere with a strong sense of psychological suspense.", + "seed": 32346, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_9/index_913_seed_32346_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.017546537891030313, + "vlm_logprob": -0.017546537891030313, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.017546537891030313, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single, curled bamboo leaf with a spiraling, unnatural twist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf colored with a saturated, artificial emerald green and does it show fine veins resembling a miniature map?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sway in an incredibly slow, hypnotic manner due to an invisible breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background transform from a blurred bamboo forest to a crowded city intersection, and then to red and blue pixelated digital noise upon the leaf's tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a stunning close-up utilizing head-tracking stabilization that maintains firm focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007909643463790417 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.132909774780273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007909643463790417, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007909643463790417, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18545091152191162, + 0.0680047795176506, + 0.17964233458042145, + 0.07697819173336029, + 0.0969671681523323, + 0.0469023771584034, + 0.058196716010570526, + 0.0787537470459938, + 0.053798165172338486, + 0.1553056240081787 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007909643463790417 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single, curled bamboo leaf with a spiraling, unnatural twist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf colored with a saturated, artificial emerald green and does it show fine veins resembling a miniature map?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sway in an incredibly slow, hypnotic manner due to an invisible breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background transform from a blurred bamboo forest to a crowded city intersection, and then to red and blue pixelated digital noise upon the leaf's tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a stunning close-up utilizing head-tracking stabilization that maintains firm focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032062334939837456 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753206253051758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032062334939837456, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032062334939837456, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1423804759979248, + 0.07896213233470917, + 0.15888622403144836, + 0.062050361186265945, + 0.08334378898143768, + 0.04758142679929733, + 0.09695535153150558, + 0.05151344835758209, + 0.08604757487773895, + 0.1922791600227356 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032062334939837456 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single, curled bamboo leaf with a spiraling, unnatural twist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf colored with a saturated, artificial emerald green and does it show fine veins resembling a miniature map?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sway in an incredibly slow, hypnotic manner due to an invisible breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background transform from a blurred bamboo forest to a crowded city intersection, and then to red and blue pixelated digital noise upon the leaf's tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a stunning close-up utilizing head-tracking stabilization that maintains firm focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0232976246625185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732975482940674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0232976246625185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0232976246625185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08450700342655182, + 0.07778520882129669, + 0.1483502984046936, + 0.0931655615568161, + 0.05908925086259842, + 0.026919782161712646, + 0.05024460330605507, + 0.13555362820625305, + 0.12417721003293991, + 0.2002074122428894 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0232976246625185 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single, curled bamboo leaf with a spiraling, unnatural twist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf colored with a saturated, artificial emerald green and does it show fine veins resembling a miniature map?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sway in an incredibly slow, hypnotic manner due to an invisible breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background transform from a blurred bamboo forest to a crowded city intersection, and then to red and blue pixelated digital noise upon the leaf's tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a stunning close-up utilizing head-tracking stabilization that maintains firm focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004646694287657738 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.3796467781066895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004646694287657738, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004646694287657738, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08014019578695297, + 0.0388440266251564, + 0.06261596083641052, + 0.08889676630496979, + 0.03834884986281395, + 0.01655423827469349, + 0.028125498443841934, + 0.11414877325296402, + 0.03853379935026169, + 0.4937918782234192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004646694287657738 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single, curled bamboo leaf with a spiraling, unnatural twist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf colored with a saturated, artificial emerald green and does it show fine veins resembling a miniature map?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sway in an incredibly slow, hypnotic manner due to an invisible breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background transform from a blurred bamboo forest to a crowded city intersection, and then to red and blue pixelated digital noise upon the leaf's tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a stunning close-up utilizing head-tracking stabilization that maintains firm focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867249354720116 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486724376678467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867249354720116, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867249354720116, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05217207595705986, + 0.037004608660936356, + 0.1089356392621994, + 0.059281524270772934, + 0.08755354583263397, + 0.07631421834230423, + 0.2306036353111267, + 0.05192836746573448, + 0.034197743982076645, + 0.2620086073875427 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867249354720116 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a surreal animated sequence in the unmistakable style of Satoshi Kon, a stunning close-up, shot with head-tracking stabilization, maintains a firm focus on a single, bizarre, curled bamboo leaf. Twisting in a spiraling pattern that defies natural growth, the leaf displays a saturated, almost artificial emerald green. Its fine veins resemble the veins of a miniature map, and its waxy surface reflects an indescribable, soft, and constant light source from its surroundings. Stirred by an invisible breeze, the leaf sways in an incredibly slow, almost hypnotic manner. Each minute tremor acts as an invisible editing point, triggering a dramatic shift in the background: the tranquil, blurred, and out-of-focus depths of the bamboo forest seamlessly and illogically transforms into the silhouettes of a crowded city intersection with the leaf's first tremor; then, with the next twitch, the crowd dissolves into a shimmering, red and blue pixelated digital noise. The surreal stability of the foreground objects and the fluid transformation of the background world form a strong and eerie visual contrast, accurately creating a dreamlike, unsettling atmosphere with a strong sense of psychological suspense.", + "seed": 32347, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_9/index_913_seed_32347_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.017158046504482626, + "vlm_logprob": -0.017158046504482626, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.017158046504482626, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single, curled bamboo leaf with a spiraling, unnatural twist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf colored with a saturated, artificial emerald green and does it show fine veins resembling a miniature map?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sway in an incredibly slow, hypnotic manner due to an invisible breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background transform from a blurred bamboo forest to a crowded city intersection, and then to red and blue pixelated digital noise upon the leaf's tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a stunning close-up utilizing head-tracking stabilization that maintains firm focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018035465851426125 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.143035411834717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018035465851426125, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018035465851426125, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18309776484966278, + 0.06485188007354736, + 0.159070685505867, + 0.09383255988359451, + 0.08130580186843872, + 0.145546555519104, + 0.04331975057721138, + 0.06394486129283905, + 0.07334543019533157, + 0.0916847363114357 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018035465851426125 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single, curled bamboo leaf with a spiraling, unnatural twist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf colored with a saturated, artificial emerald green and does it show fine veins resembling a miniature map?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sway in an incredibly slow, hypnotic manner due to an invisible breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background transform from a blurred bamboo forest to a crowded city intersection, and then to red and blue pixelated digital noise upon the leaf's tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a stunning close-up utilizing head-tracking stabilization that maintains firm focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028400584124028683 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877840042114258 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028400584124028683, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028400584124028683, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16005337238311768, + 0.04036305099725723, + 0.14063741266727448, + 0.20592913031578064, + 0.06188966706395149, + 0.09817914664745331, + 0.03844701871275902, + 0.07203250378370285, + 0.07215799391269684, + 0.11031067371368408 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028400584124028683 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single, curled bamboo leaf with a spiraling, unnatural twist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf colored with a saturated, artificial emerald green and does it show fine veins resembling a miniature map?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sway in an incredibly slow, hypnotic manner due to an invisible breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background transform from a blurred bamboo forest to a crowded city intersection, and then to red and blue pixelated digital noise upon the leaf's tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a stunning close-up utilizing head-tracking stabilization that maintains firm focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018201936036348343 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01820182800293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018201936036348343, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018201936036348343, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14408303797245026, + 0.06917806714773178, + 0.21939592063426971, + 0.09674666821956635, + 0.06021607294678688, + 0.2030603438615799, + 0.06459584087133408, + 0.026183761656284332, + 0.04653866961598396, + 0.07000162452459335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018201936036348343 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single, curled bamboo leaf with a spiraling, unnatural twist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf colored with a saturated, artificial emerald green and does it show fine veins resembling a miniature map?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sway in an incredibly slow, hypnotic manner due to an invisible breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background transform from a blurred bamboo forest to a crowded city intersection, and then to red and blue pixelated digital noise upon the leaf's tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a stunning close-up utilizing head-tracking stabilization that maintains firm focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036289331037551165 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628628730773926 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036289331037551165, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036289331037551165, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12854838371276855, + 0.06048278883099556, + 0.2988748252391815, + 0.13860231637954712, + 0.058232471346855164, + 0.07121847569942474, + 0.029879655689001083, + 0.03985441476106644, + 0.09930960834026337, + 0.07499707490205765 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036289331037551165 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single, curled bamboo leaf with a spiraling, unnatural twist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf colored with a saturated, artificial emerald green and does it show fine veins resembling a miniature map?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sway in an incredibly slow, hypnotic manner due to an invisible breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background transform from a blurred bamboo forest to a crowded city intersection, and then to red and blue pixelated digital noise upon the leaf's tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a stunning close-up utilizing head-tracking stabilization that maintains firm focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308383911848068 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168083906173706 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308383911848068, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308383911848068, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2370402216911316, + 0.062264181673526764, + 0.09501174092292786, + 0.0727725625038147, + 0.07875824719667435, + 0.07405533641576767, + 0.07579023391008377, + 0.07458168268203735, + 0.10411599278450012, + 0.12560983002185822 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308383911848068 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a surreal animated sequence in the unmistakable style of Satoshi Kon, a stunning close-up, shot with head-tracking stabilization, maintains a firm focus on a single, bizarre, curled bamboo leaf. Twisting in a spiraling pattern that defies natural growth, the leaf displays a saturated, almost artificial emerald green. Its fine veins resemble the veins of a miniature map, and its waxy surface reflects an indescribable, soft, and constant light source from its surroundings. Stirred by an invisible breeze, the leaf sways in an incredibly slow, almost hypnotic manner. Each minute tremor acts as an invisible editing point, triggering a dramatic shift in the background: the tranquil, blurred, and out-of-focus depths of the bamboo forest seamlessly and illogically transforms into the silhouettes of a crowded city intersection with the leaf's first tremor; then, with the next twitch, the crowd dissolves into a shimmering, red and blue pixelated digital noise. The surreal stability of the foreground objects and the fluid transformation of the background world form a strong and eerie visual contrast, accurately creating a dreamlike, unsettling atmosphere with a strong sense of psychological suspense.", + "seed": 32348, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000178/group_9/index_913_seed_32348_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.022437429893761872, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022437429893761872, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022437429893761872, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single, curled bamboo leaf with a spiraling, unnatural twist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf colored with a saturated, artificial emerald green and does it show fine veins resembling a miniature map?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sway in an incredibly slow, hypnotic manner due to an invisible breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background transform from a blurred bamboo forest to a crowded city intersection, and then to red and blue pixelated digital noise upon the leaf's tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a stunning close-up utilizing head-tracking stabilization that maintains firm focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009844915941357613 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.884844779968262 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009844915941357613, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009844915941357613, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11640481650829315, + 0.07367277145385742, + 0.08242686837911606, + 0.15022073686122894, + 0.03285021334886551, + 0.02747996151447296, + 0.1055041253566742, + 0.052519313991069794, + 0.24112366139888763, + 0.11779754608869553 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009844915941357613 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single, curled bamboo leaf with a spiraling, unnatural twist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf colored with a saturated, artificial emerald green and does it show fine veins resembling a miniature map?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sway in an incredibly slow, hypnotic manner due to an invisible breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background transform from a blurred bamboo forest to a crowded city intersection, and then to red and blue pixelated digital noise upon the leaf's tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a stunning close-up utilizing head-tracking stabilization that maintains firm focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0025052609853446484 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002505302429199 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0025052609853446484, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0025052609853446484, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04599931463599205, + 0.018348224461078644, + 0.10760538280010223, + 0.24671582877635956, + 0.029680263251066208, + 0.013897477649152279, + 0.041424460709095, + 0.02170330099761486, + 0.29259175062179565, + 0.1820339858531952 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0025052609853446484 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single, curled bamboo leaf with a spiraling, unnatural twist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf colored with a saturated, artificial emerald green and does it show fine veins resembling a miniature map?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sway in an incredibly slow, hypnotic manner due to an invisible breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background transform from a blurred bamboo forest to a crowded city intersection, and then to red and blue pixelated digital noise upon the leaf's tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a stunning close-up utilizing head-tracking stabilization that maintains firm focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038110267370939255 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881102561950684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038110267370939255, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038110267370939255, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.034868113696575165, + 0.02923772670328617, + 0.026655716821551323, + 0.05341538041830063, + 0.013713682070374489, + 0.005567221902310848, + 0.08042047172784805, + 0.008327345363795757, + 0.6247279047966003, + 0.12306643277406693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038110267370939255 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single, curled bamboo leaf with a spiraling, unnatural twist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf colored with a saturated, artificial emerald green and does it show fine veins resembling a miniature map?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sway in an incredibly slow, hypnotic manner due to an invisible breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background transform from a blurred bamboo forest to a crowded city intersection, and then to red and blue pixelated digital noise upon the leaf's tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a stunning close-up utilizing head-tracking stabilization that maintains firm focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006748148240149021 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006748199462891 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006748148240149021, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006748148240149021, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02260572463274002, + 0.02231726422905922, + 0.07988888025283813, + 0.024373408406972885, + 0.034008461982011795, + 0.00920787826180458, + 0.09773450344800949, + 0.011698434129357338, + 0.3300941288471222, + 0.36807122826576233 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006748148240149021 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a single, curled bamboo leaf with a spiraling, unnatural twist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the leaf colored with a saturated, artificial emerald green and does it show fine veins resembling a miniature map?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the leaf sway in an incredibly slow, hypnotic manner due to an invisible breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background transform from a blurred bamboo forest to a crowded city intersection, and then to red and blue pixelated digital noise upon the leaf's tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a stunning close-up utilizing head-tracking stabilization that maintains firm focus on the leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05497855693101883 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929978609085083 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05497855693101883, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05497855693101883, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.023976271972060204, + 0.05553106218576431, + 0.057153377681970596, + 0.03427441790699959, + 0.04238279163837433, + 0.011205967515707016, + 0.05987648665904999, + 0.018667351454496384, + 0.6306883096694946, + 0.06624393165111542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05497855693101883 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_0/index_tensor([6899, 6899])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_0/index_tensor([6899, 6899])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b35c07e1a65cf0c7a11f32bbea70e399a8768fdd --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_0/index_tensor([6899, 6899])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot, shot from a level angle and slowly moving forward, focuses on the empress, clad in a gorgeous crimson silk palace gown. She sits upright on a carved rosewood chair. The lapels and wide sleeves of her gown are intricately embroidered with phoenix motifs in gold thread. Her long, jet-black hair is meticulously styled into a towering, classical bun, adorned with swaying golden hairpins and a pearl hairpin. A soft ray of afternoon sunlight filters through the quaint carved window panes in the background, glazing her profile and the silk fabric with a warm golden halo. A plump, snow-white, fluffy Persian cat curls lazily in her lap, eyes closed and purring with barely audible contentment. The queen had a gentle and peaceful smile on her face, her eyes lowered. She slowly raised her fair and slender right hand, and the emerald green and warm jade ring on her ring finger shone with a soft luster in the light. Her fingertips carefully and extremely gently touched the top of the cat's head, and then stroked its smooth back with a steady and leisurely rhythm. The whole picture was rich and noble in color, creating an extremely peaceful, private and warm atmosphere full of royal nobility in the quiet light and shadow.", + "seed": 22925, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_0/index_6899_seed_22925_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.027030135225504636, + "vlm_logprob": -0.027030135225504636, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9999999523162844, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.027030135225504636, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an empress sitting upright on a carved rosewood chair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the empress wearing a crimson silk palace gown with gold phoenix embroidery on the lapels and sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a plump, snow-white, fluffy Persian cat curled in the empress's lap with its eyes closed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the empress raise her right hand to gently stroke the cat's head and back while wearing an emerald green jade ring?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a level angle and slowly moving forward, with afternoon sunlight filtering through a carved window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020137740299105644 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.020137786865234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020137740299105644, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020137740299105644, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.045318327844142914, + 0.028002671897411346, + 0.026686863973736763, + 0.0332912914454937, + 0.19894693791866302, + 0.03776280954480171, + 0.02258395217359066, + 0.06249995902180672, + 0.33158284425735474, + 0.21332436800003052 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020137740299105644 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an empress sitting upright on a carved rosewood chair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the empress wearing a crimson silk palace gown with gold phoenix embroidery on the lapels and sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a plump, snow-white, fluffy Persian cat curled in the empress's lap with its eyes closed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the empress raise her right hand to gently stroke the cat's head and back while wearing an emerald green jade ring?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a level angle and slowly moving forward, with afternoon sunlight filtering through a carved window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011090775020420551 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110907554626465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011090775020420551, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011090775020420551, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06091000512242317, + 0.035495635122060776, + 0.07658661156892776, + 0.03529501333832741, + 0.20371240377426147, + 0.07421250641345978, + 0.012416995130479336, + 0.03600967302918434, + 0.40419965982437134, + 0.06116153672337532 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011090775020420551 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an empress sitting upright on a carved rosewood chair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the empress wearing a crimson silk palace gown with gold phoenix embroidery on the lapels and sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a plump, snow-white, fluffy Persian cat curled in the empress's lap with its eyes closed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the empress raise her right hand to gently stroke the cat's head and back while wearing an emerald green jade ring?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a level angle and slowly moving forward, with afternoon sunlight filtering through a carved window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006739978212863207 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006740093231201 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006739978212863207, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006739978212863207, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.025119557976722717, + 0.02513435110449791, + 0.014657430350780487, + 0.028002366423606873, + 0.09230702370405197, + 0.07407862693071365, + 0.018535301089286804, + 0.09253840893507004, + 0.4885675013065338, + 0.14105942845344543 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006739978212863207 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an empress sitting upright on a carved rosewood chair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the empress wearing a crimson silk palace gown with gold phoenix embroidery on the lapels and sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a plump, snow-white, fluffy Persian cat curled in the empress's lap with its eyes closed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the empress raise her right hand to gently stroke the cat's head and back while wearing an emerald green jade ring?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a level angle and slowly moving forward, with afternoon sunlight filtering through a carved window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0181953813880682 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018195152282715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0181953813880682, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0181953813880682, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.025259800255298615, + 0.026426516473293304, + 0.021198846399784088, + 0.0204512570053339, + 0.23106279969215393, + 0.08974464237689972, + 0.05229794606566429, + 0.06128465756773949, + 0.4137175381183624, + 0.058556001633405685 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0181953813880682 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an empress sitting upright on a carved rosewood chair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the empress wearing a crimson silk palace gown with gold phoenix embroidery on the lapels and sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a plump, snow-white, fluffy Persian cat curled in the empress's lap with its eyes closed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the empress raise her right hand to gently stroke the cat's head and back while wearing an emerald green jade ring?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a level angle and slowly moving forward, with afternoon sunlight filtering through a carved window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898680120706558 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578986883163452 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898680120706558, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898680120706558, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02915053628385067, + 0.007572582457214594, + 0.021491773426532745, + 0.009112547151744366, + 0.16024766862392426, + 0.05251246690750122, + 0.01864130236208439, + 0.03177064284682274, + 0.5344426035881042, + 0.1350579857826233 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898680120706558 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot, shot from a level angle and slowly moving forward, focuses on the empress, clad in a gorgeous crimson silk palace gown. She sits upright on a carved rosewood chair. The lapels and wide sleeves of her gown are intricately embroidered with phoenix motifs in gold thread. Her long, jet-black hair is meticulously styled into a towering, classical bun, adorned with swaying golden hairpins and a pearl hairpin. A soft ray of afternoon sunlight filters through the quaint carved window panes in the background, glazing her profile and the silk fabric with a warm golden halo. A plump, snow-white, fluffy Persian cat curls lazily in her lap, eyes closed and purring with barely audible contentment. The queen had a gentle and peaceful smile on her face, her eyes lowered. She slowly raised her fair and slender right hand, and the emerald green and warm jade ring on her ring finger shone with a soft luster in the light. Her fingertips carefully and extremely gently touched the top of the cat's head, and then stroked its smooth back with a steady and leisurely rhythm. The whole picture was rich and noble in color, creating an extremely peaceful, private and warm atmosphere full of royal nobility in the quiet light and shadow.", + "seed": 22926, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_0/index_6899_seed_22926_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.011171965952962637, + "vlm_logprob": -0.011171965952962637, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.011171965952962637, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an empress sitting upright on a carved rosewood chair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the empress wearing a crimson silk palace gown with gold phoenix embroidery on the lapels and sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a plump, snow-white, fluffy Persian cat curled in the empress's lap with its eyes closed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the empress raise her right hand to gently stroke the cat's head and back while wearing an emerald green jade ring?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a level angle and slowly moving forward, with afternoon sunlight filtering through a carved window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009839840233325958 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88484001159668 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009839840233325958, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009839840233325958, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.046431977301836014, + 0.01692228391766548, + 0.015359428711235523, + 0.023527467623353004, + 0.013392738066613674, + 0.011299524456262589, + 0.13965554535388947, + 0.03946402296423912, + 0.03155392035841942, + 0.6623930931091309 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009839840233325958 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an empress sitting upright on a carved rosewood chair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the empress wearing a crimson silk palace gown with gold phoenix embroidery on the lapels and sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a plump, snow-white, fluffy Persian cat curled in the empress's lap with its eyes closed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the empress raise her right hand to gently stroke the cat's head and back while wearing an emerald green jade ring?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a level angle and slowly moving forward, with afternoon sunlight filtering through a carved window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009803010150790215 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63480281829834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009803010150790215, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009803010150790215, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11420334875583649, + 0.03637867048382759, + 0.012773647904396057, + 0.015335352160036564, + 0.06266738474369049, + 0.05282789468765259, + 0.07070815563201904, + 0.05448660999536514, + 0.021815109997987747, + 0.5588037967681885 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009803010150790215 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an empress sitting upright on a carved rosewood chair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the empress wearing a crimson silk palace gown with gold phoenix embroidery on the lapels and sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a plump, snow-white, fluffy Persian cat curled in the empress's lap with its eyes closed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the empress raise her right hand to gently stroke the cat's head and back while wearing an emerald green jade ring?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a level angle and slowly moving forward, with afternoon sunlight filtering through a carved window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005951777566224337 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130951881408691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005951777566224337, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005951777566224337, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.029443912208080292, + 0.006078626960515976, + 0.003633133601397276, + 0.004440859891474247, + 0.008926223032176495, + 0.029366744682192802, + 0.015350831672549248, + 0.024366077035665512, + 0.02970779500901699, + 0.8486858010292053 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005951777566224337 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an empress sitting upright on a carved rosewood chair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the empress wearing a crimson silk palace gown with gold phoenix embroidery on the lapels and sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a plump, snow-white, fluffy Persian cat curled in the empress's lap with its eyes closed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the empress raise her right hand to gently stroke the cat's head and back while wearing an emerald green jade ring?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a level angle and slowly moving forward, with afternoon sunlight filtering through a carved window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014199883677065372 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264199733734131 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014199883677065372, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014199883677065372, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07505820691585541, + 0.011905914172530174, + 0.014968570321798325, + 0.017619499936699867, + 0.05302894115447998, + 0.06986277550458908, + 0.04146384075284004, + 0.05250411853194237, + 0.02731235884130001, + 0.6362757682800293 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014199883677065372 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an empress sitting upright on a carved rosewood chair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the empress wearing a crimson silk palace gown with gold phoenix embroidery on the lapels and sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a plump, snow-white, fluffy Persian cat curled in the empress's lap with its eyes closed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the empress raise her right hand to gently stroke the cat's head and back while wearing an emerald green jade ring?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a level angle and slowly moving forward, with afternoon sunlight filtering through a carved window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016065318137407303 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410651206970215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016065318137407303, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016065318137407303, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04690137878060341, + 0.023920457810163498, + 0.020369485020637512, + 0.012535001151263714, + 0.017504172399640083, + 0.025337805971503258, + 0.04006599634885788, + 0.029851771891117096, + 0.03277156874537468, + 0.7507423758506775 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016065318137407303 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot, shot from a level angle and slowly moving forward, focuses on the empress, clad in a gorgeous crimson silk palace gown. She sits upright on a carved rosewood chair. The lapels and wide sleeves of her gown are intricately embroidered with phoenix motifs in gold thread. Her long, jet-black hair is meticulously styled into a towering, classical bun, adorned with swaying golden hairpins and a pearl hairpin. A soft ray of afternoon sunlight filters through the quaint carved window panes in the background, glazing her profile and the silk fabric with a warm golden halo. A plump, snow-white, fluffy Persian cat curls lazily in her lap, eyes closed and purring with barely audible contentment. The queen had a gentle and peaceful smile on her face, her eyes lowered. She slowly raised her fair and slender right hand, and the emerald green and warm jade ring on her ring finger shone with a soft luster in the light. Her fingertips carefully and extremely gently touched the top of the cat's head, and then stroked its smooth back with a steady and leisurely rhythm. The whole picture was rich and noble in color, creating an extremely peaceful, private and warm atmosphere full of royal nobility in the quiet light and shadow.", + "seed": 22927, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_0/index_6899_seed_22927_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.012109632045030594, + "vlm_logprob": -0.012109632045030594, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.012109632045030594, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an empress sitting upright on a carved rosewood chair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the empress wearing a crimson silk palace gown with gold phoenix embroidery on the lapels and sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a plump, snow-white, fluffy Persian cat curled in the empress's lap with its eyes closed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the empress raise her right hand to gently stroke the cat's head and back while wearing an emerald green jade ring?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a level angle and slowly moving forward, with afternoon sunlight filtering through a carved window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013474587351083755 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.388474464416504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013474587351083755, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013474587351083755, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13806189596652985, + 0.06756848096847534, + 0.04695035517215729, + 0.09286191314458847, + 0.06773597002029419, + 0.10966700315475464, + 0.12823259830474854, + 0.13048692047595978, + 0.09186530858278275, + 0.126569464802742 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013474587351083755 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an empress sitting upright on a carved rosewood chair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the empress wearing a crimson silk palace gown with gold phoenix embroidery on the lapels and sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a plump, snow-white, fluffy Persian cat curled in the empress's lap with its eyes closed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the empress raise her right hand to gently stroke the cat's head and back while wearing an emerald green jade ring?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a level angle and slowly moving forward, with afternoon sunlight filtering through a carved window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011091482825577259 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511091709136963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011091482825577259, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011091482825577259, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10478518158197403, + 0.061248525977134705, + 0.07146962732076645, + 0.06183002144098282, + 0.08392859995365143, + 0.11661752313375473, + 0.2436830997467041, + 0.11472876369953156, + 0.04555421695113182, + 0.09615446627140045 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011091482825577259 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an empress sitting upright on a carved rosewood chair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the empress wearing a crimson silk palace gown with gold phoenix embroidery on the lapels and sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a plump, snow-white, fluffy Persian cat curled in the empress's lap with its eyes closed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the empress raise her right hand to gently stroke the cat's head and back while wearing an emerald green jade ring?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a level angle and slowly moving forward, with afternoon sunlight filtering through a carved window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005254032090306282 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.25525426864624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005254032090306282, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005254032090306282, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06401646137237549, + 0.0470266193151474, + 0.04950470104813576, + 0.06245151534676552, + 0.036571014672517776, + 0.11773582547903061, + 0.12995557487010956, + 0.12652507424354553, + 0.2446921318769455, + 0.12152104824781418 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005254032090306282 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an empress sitting upright on a carved rosewood chair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the empress wearing a crimson silk palace gown with gold phoenix embroidery on the lapels and sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a plump, snow-white, fluffy Persian cat curled in the empress's lap with its eyes closed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the empress raise her right hand to gently stroke the cat's head and back while wearing an emerald green jade ring?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a level angle and slowly moving forward, with afternoon sunlight filtering through a carved window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818987913429737 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018189907073975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818987913429737, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818987913429737, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1324344277381897, + 0.06499291956424713, + 0.04639377072453499, + 0.10742636024951935, + 0.11527141183614731, + 0.04841560497879982, + 0.19101177155971527, + 0.10392188280820847, + 0.13815920054912567, + 0.05197266861796379 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818987913429737 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an empress sitting upright on a carved rosewood chair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the empress wearing a crimson silk palace gown with gold phoenix embroidery on the lapels and sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a plump, snow-white, fluffy Persian cat curled in the empress's lap with its eyes closed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the empress raise her right hand to gently stroke the cat's head and back while wearing an emerald green jade ring?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a level angle and slowly moving forward, with afternoon sunlight filtering through a carved window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012538178823888302 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387537956237793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012538178823888302, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012538178823888302, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08911198377609253, + 0.19669103622436523, + 0.03708244115114212, + 0.1141279861330986, + 0.06431228667497635, + 0.13353823125362396, + 0.18901167809963226, + 0.04179782792925835, + 0.0902273952960968, + 0.04409917816519737 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012538178823888302 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium close-up shot, shot from a level angle and slowly moving forward, focuses on the empress, clad in a gorgeous crimson silk palace gown. She sits upright on a carved rosewood chair. The lapels and wide sleeves of her gown are intricately embroidered with phoenix motifs in gold thread. Her long, jet-black hair is meticulously styled into a towering, classical bun, adorned with swaying golden hairpins and a pearl hairpin. A soft ray of afternoon sunlight filters through the quaint carved window panes in the background, glazing her profile and the silk fabric with a warm golden halo. A plump, snow-white, fluffy Persian cat curls lazily in her lap, eyes closed and purring with barely audible contentment. The queen had a gentle and peaceful smile on her face, her eyes lowered. She slowly raised her fair and slender right hand, and the emerald green and warm jade ring on her ring finger shone with a soft luster in the light. Her fingertips carefully and extremely gently touched the top of the cat's head, and then stroked its smooth back with a steady and leisurely rhythm. The whole picture was rich and noble in color, creating an extremely peaceful, private and warm atmosphere full of royal nobility in the quiet light and shadow.", + "seed": 22928, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_0/index_6899_seed_22928_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.022419830691069363, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022419830691069363, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022419830691069363, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an empress sitting upright on a carved rosewood chair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the empress wearing a crimson silk palace gown with gold phoenix embroidery on the lapels and sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a plump, snow-white, fluffy Persian cat curled in the empress's lap with its eyes closed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the empress raise her right hand to gently stroke the cat's head and back while wearing an emerald green jade ring?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a level angle and slowly moving forward, with afternoon sunlight filtering through a carved window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02178407646715641 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8967840671539307 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02178407646715641, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02178407646715641, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2727651596069336, + 0.08720646053552628, + 0.032055068761110306, + 0.08061812072992325, + 0.07280734181404114, + 0.20108038187026978, + 0.07990330457687378, + 0.04868069663643837, + 0.04950081557035446, + 0.07538266479969025 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02178407646715641 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an empress sitting upright on a carved rosewood chair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the empress wearing a crimson silk palace gown with gold phoenix embroidery on the lapels and sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a plump, snow-white, fluffy Persian cat curled in the empress's lap with its eyes closed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the empress raise her right hand to gently stroke the cat's head and back while wearing an emerald green jade ring?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a level angle and slowly moving forward, with afternoon sunlight filtering through a carved window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01821516454219818 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018215179443359 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01821516454219818, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01821516454219818, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27856504917144775, + 0.08517797291278839, + 0.08053065836429596, + 0.14945626258850098, + 0.05022444203495979, + 0.09207353740930557, + 0.0977611318230629, + 0.044328149408102036, + 0.04029984772205353, + 0.08158288151025772 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01821516454219818 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an empress sitting upright on a carved rosewood chair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the empress wearing a crimson silk palace gown with gold phoenix embroidery on the lapels and sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a plump, snow-white, fluffy Persian cat curled in the empress's lap with its eyes closed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the empress raise her right hand to gently stroke the cat's head and back while wearing an emerald green jade ring?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a level angle and slowly moving forward, with afternoon sunlight filtering through a carved window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007631906773895025 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882631778717041 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007631906773895025, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007631906773895025, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10248181223869324, + 0.05192739889025688, + 0.028085367754101753, + 0.06170165538787842, + 0.06708360463380814, + 0.20213869214057922, + 0.22566883265972137, + 0.08104556053876877, + 0.055332157760858536, + 0.1245349571108818 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007631906773895025 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an empress sitting upright on a carved rosewood chair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the empress wearing a crimson silk palace gown with gold phoenix embroidery on the lapels and sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a plump, snow-white, fluffy Persian cat curled in the empress's lap with its eyes closed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the empress raise her right hand to gently stroke the cat's head and back while wearing an emerald green jade ring?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a level angle and slowly moving forward, with afternoon sunlight filtering through a carved window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026361754164099693 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513617038726807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026361754164099693, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026361754164099693, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13265246152877808, + 0.06550600379705429, + 0.06174025684595108, + 0.04914719983935356, + 0.09775593876838684, + 0.1549074649810791, + 0.0871434435248375, + 0.07347891479730606, + 0.11606533080339432, + 0.16160298883914948 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026361754164099693 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium close-up of an empress sitting upright on a carved rosewood chair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the empress wearing a crimson silk palace gown with gold phoenix embroidery on the lapels and sleeves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a plump, snow-white, fluffy Persian cat curled in the empress's lap with its eyes closed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the empress raise her right hand to gently stroke the cat's head and back while wearing an emerald green jade ring?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a level angle and slowly moving forward, with afternoon sunlight filtering through a carved window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810625150799751 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881062030792236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810625150799751, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810625150799751, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10918573290109634, + 0.3906598389148712, + 0.03558065742254257, + 0.09395855665206909, + 0.047932013869285583, + 0.049174826592206955, + 0.0533960796892643, + 0.09143582731485367, + 0.06336686760187149, + 0.06530959159135818 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810625150799751 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_1/index_tensor([2812, 2812])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_1/index_tensor([2812, 2812])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..590e2daa9ddb9ba5256397b99847b309b68c7e30 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_1/index_tensor([2812, 2812])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, low-angle tracking shot follows a massive giant panda as it journeys through the depths of a lush bamboo forest shrouded in thick morning mist. The panda's thick, distinct black and white fur appears incredibly realistic in the soft, diffused light, each strand of black and creamy white hair clearly visible, even the tiny droplets of water clinging to its damp fur. With a leisurely, yet clumsy gait, it steadily explores, its sturdy body slightly hunched, its massive paws carefully treading the damp, fallen leaves. Occasionally, it pauses, raising its classic round face, its damp black nose twitching slightly as it seems to sniff the fresh bamboo air. A thin mist slowly drifts between the bamboo stalks, obscuring the distant landscape and creating a tranquil and mysterious atmosphere. Light penetrates the mist, casting a soft, subtle sheen on its glossy black fur and the surrounding lush bamboo leaves, creating an almost documentary-like sense of reality and an enchanting natural beauty.", + "seed": 17521, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_1/index_2812_seed_17521_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.23951080590486526, + "vlm_logprob": -0.23951080590486526, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.550000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.23951080590486526, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive giant panda with thick black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush bamboo forest shrouded in thick morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the panda moving with a leisurely, clumsy gait while treading on damp fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the panda pause occasionally to raise its face and twitch its damp black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, low-angle tracking shot following the panda?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.034886982291936874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4098870754241943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.034886982291936874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.034886982291936874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1089625135064125, + 0.022189104929566383, + 0.040558502078056335, + 0.03235667571425438, + 0.1134767159819603, + 0.016174791380763054, + 0.35198774933815, + 0.037631772458553314, + 0.020836060866713524, + 0.25582611560821533 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.034886982291936874 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive giant panda with thick black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush bamboo forest shrouded in thick morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the panda moving with a leisurely, clumsy gait while treading on damp fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the panda pause occasionally to raise its face and twitch its damp black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, low-angle tracking shot following the panda?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539219379425049 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42892199754714966 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0539219379425049, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.6249999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0539219379425049, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1366008073091507, + 0.13603119552135468, + 0.13470889627933502, + 0.02287270314991474, + 0.06531473994255066, + 0.013824342750012875, + 0.06436493992805481, + 0.20148977637290955, + 0.07794072479009628, + 0.14685188233852386 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0539219379425049 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive giant panda with thick black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush bamboo forest shrouded in thick morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the panda moving with a leisurely, clumsy gait while treading on damp fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the panda pause occasionally to raise its face and twitch its damp black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, low-angle tracking shot following the panda?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033728644251823425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.40872859954834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033728644251823425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033728644251823425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05197041854262352, + 0.0799252837896347, + 0.2036590874195099, + 0.02822697162628174, + 0.2683812379837036, + 0.013171536847949028, + 0.07324367761611938, + 0.09643691033124924, + 0.018453361466526985, + 0.16653147339820862 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033728644251823425 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive giant panda with thick black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush bamboo forest shrouded in thick morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the panda moving with a leisurely, clumsy gait while treading on damp fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the panda pause occasionally to raise its face and twitch its damp black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, low-angle tracking shot following the panda?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02635873481631279 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513588428497314 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02635873481631279, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02635873481631279, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08002127707004547, + 0.15620577335357666, + 0.08938319236040115, + 0.031416136771440506, + 0.15894711017608643, + 0.041489385068416595, + 0.1436370611190796, + 0.10139087587594986, + 0.04265930503606796, + 0.1548498570919037 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02635873481631279 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive giant panda with thick black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush bamboo forest shrouded in thick morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the panda moving with a leisurely, clumsy gait while treading on damp fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the panda pause occasionally to raise its face and twitch its damp black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, low-angle tracking shot following the panda?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865773022174835 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486576557159424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865773022174835, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865773022174835, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14780819416046143, + 0.15676020085811615, + 0.04680246114730835, + 0.014965164475142956, + 0.1258125901222229, + 0.027071494609117508, + 0.18440766632556915, + 0.12101496756076813, + 0.03579983860254288, + 0.1395573914051056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865773022174835 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, low-angle tracking shot follows a massive giant panda as it journeys through the depths of a lush bamboo forest shrouded in thick morning mist. The panda's thick, distinct black and white fur appears incredibly realistic in the soft, diffused light, each strand of black and creamy white hair clearly visible, even the tiny droplets of water clinging to its damp fur. With a leisurely, yet clumsy gait, it steadily explores, its sturdy body slightly hunched, its massive paws carefully treading the damp, fallen leaves. Occasionally, it pauses, raising its classic round face, its damp black nose twitching slightly as it seems to sniff the fresh bamboo air. A thin mist slowly drifts between the bamboo stalks, obscuring the distant landscape and creating a tranquil and mysterious atmosphere. Light penetrates the mist, casting a soft, subtle sheen on its glossy black fur and the surrounding lush bamboo leaves, creating an almost documentary-like sense of reality and an enchanting natural beauty.", + "seed": 17522, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_1/index_2812_seed_17522_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.055473748967051505, + "vlm_logprob": -0.055473748967051505, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.199999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.055473748967051505, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive giant panda with thick black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush bamboo forest shrouded in thick morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the panda moving with a leisurely, clumsy gait while treading on damp fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the panda pause occasionally to raise its face and twitch its damp black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, low-angle tracking shot following the panda?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03873913735151291 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2887392044067383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03873913735151291, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03873913735151291, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12972837686538696, + 0.1258569210767746, + 0.06539225578308105, + 0.0819932222366333, + 0.0565897561609745, + 0.13966837525367737, + 0.06849659234285355, + 0.04504513368010521, + 0.24953292310237885, + 0.037696465849876404 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03873913735151291 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive giant panda with thick black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush bamboo forest shrouded in thick morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the panda moving with a leisurely, clumsy gait while treading on damp fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the panda pause occasionally to raise its face and twitch its damp black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, low-angle tracking shot following the panda?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16039897501468658 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103989601135254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16039897501468658, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16039897501468658, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20650550723075867, + 0.046306170523166656, + 0.034668829292058945, + 0.07188288867473602, + 0.10793451964855194, + 0.03977178409695625, + 0.027916520833969116, + 0.029164649546146393, + 0.4074612557888031, + 0.028387831524014473 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16039897501468658 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive giant panda with thick black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush bamboo forest shrouded in thick morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the panda moving with a leisurely, clumsy gait while treading on damp fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the panda pause occasionally to raise its face and twitch its damp black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, low-angle tracking shot following the panda?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02635374292731285 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513538360595703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02635374292731285, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02635374292731285, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10273231565952301, + 0.12360432744026184, + 0.061040010303258896, + 0.08101433515548706, + 0.04161132127046585, + 0.12592941522598267, + 0.06363231688737869, + 0.030392106622457504, + 0.3270566761493683, + 0.04298718646168709 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02635374292731285 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive giant panda with thick black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush bamboo forest shrouded in thick morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the panda moving with a leisurely, clumsy gait while treading on damp fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the panda pause occasionally to raise its face and twitch its damp black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, low-angle tracking shot following the panda?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018188124522566795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187999725342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018188124522566795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018188124522566795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.058054473251104355, + 0.1362086534500122, + 0.07430682331323624, + 0.04277106374502182, + 0.06088397279381752, + 0.2402184158563614, + 0.07826676964759827, + 0.017729198560118675, + 0.2589035928249359, + 0.032656989991664886 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018188124522566795 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive giant panda with thick black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush bamboo forest shrouded in thick morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the panda moving with a leisurely, clumsy gait while treading on damp fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the panda pause occasionally to raise its face and twitch its damp black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, low-angle tracking shot following the panda?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368876501917839 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.40868878364563 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368876501917839, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368876501917839, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0993119403719902, + 0.07033871114253998, + 0.08383860439062119, + 0.07527313381433487, + 0.084015391767025, + 0.14865276217460632, + 0.06388578563928604, + 0.029209600761532784, + 0.32473787665367126, + 0.020736150443553925 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368876501917839 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, low-angle tracking shot follows a massive giant panda as it journeys through the depths of a lush bamboo forest shrouded in thick morning mist. The panda's thick, distinct black and white fur appears incredibly realistic in the soft, diffused light, each strand of black and creamy white hair clearly visible, even the tiny droplets of water clinging to its damp fur. With a leisurely, yet clumsy gait, it steadily explores, its sturdy body slightly hunched, its massive paws carefully treading the damp, fallen leaves. Occasionally, it pauses, raising its classic round face, its damp black nose twitching slightly as it seems to sniff the fresh bamboo air. A thin mist slowly drifts between the bamboo stalks, obscuring the distant landscape and creating a tranquil and mysterious atmosphere. Light penetrates the mist, casting a soft, subtle sheen on its glossy black fur and the surrounding lush bamboo leaves, creating an almost documentary-like sense of reality and an enchanting natural beauty.", + "seed": 17523, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_1/index_2812_seed_17523_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.4488504782319069, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4488504782319069, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.7499999761581422, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4488504782319069, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive giant panda with thick black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush bamboo forest shrouded in thick morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the panda moving with a leisurely, clumsy gait while treading on damp fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the panda pause occasionally to raise its face and twitch its damp black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, low-angle tracking shot following the panda?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.034881342202425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.409881353378296 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.034881342202425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.034881342202425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6513555645942688, + 0.03753863647580147, + 0.040192969143390656, + 0.035102277994155884, + 0.02894914709031582, + 0.07094224542379379, + 0.047163303941488266, + 0.022467510774731636, + 0.019664878025650978, + 0.04662347212433815 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.034881342202425 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive giant panda with thick black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush bamboo forest shrouded in thick morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the panda moving with a leisurely, clumsy gait while treading on damp fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the panda pause occasionally to raise its face and twitch its damp black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, low-angle tracking shot following the panda?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103506803512573 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16035063564777374 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.9103506803512573, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.9103506803512573, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4821721315383911, + 0.025442667305469513, + 0.04210810735821724, + 0.07515937089920044, + 0.05211687088012695, + 0.038837138563394547, + 0.02961013652384281, + 0.09256545454263687, + 0.12623456120491028, + 0.03575350344181061 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.9103506803512573 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive giant panda with thick black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush bamboo forest shrouded in thick morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the panda moving with a leisurely, clumsy gait while treading on damp fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the panda pause occasionally to raise its face and twitch its damp black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, low-angle tracking shot following the panda?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1429506093263626 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0179505348205566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1429506093263626, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1429506093263626, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.178540900349617, + 0.052615486085414886, + 0.0672461986541748, + 0.12502029538154602, + 0.05702754482626915, + 0.057491328567266464, + 0.06620878726243973, + 0.2038869708776474, + 0.14100879430770874, + 0.05095368251204491 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1429506093263626 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive giant panda with thick black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush bamboo forest shrouded in thick morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the panda moving with a leisurely, clumsy gait while treading on damp fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the panda pause occasionally to raise its face and twitch its damp black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, low-angle tracking shot following the panda?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309982433915138 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168099880218506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309982433915138, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309982433915138, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20608548820018768, + 0.06588578224182129, + 0.17007800936698914, + 0.11196506768465042, + 0.0673472061753273, + 0.054339274764060974, + 0.038687873631715775, + 0.09286946803331375, + 0.13003963232040405, + 0.0627022385597229 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309982433915138 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive giant panda with thick black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush bamboo forest shrouded in thick morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the panda moving with a leisurely, clumsy gait while treading on damp fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the panda pause occasionally to raise its face and twitch its damp black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, low-angle tracking shot following the panda?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11296993494033813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379698753356934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11296993494033813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11296993494033813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.508809506893158, + 0.022228656336665154, + 0.060639042407274246, + 0.07522401958703995, + 0.07627604156732559, + 0.03460489585995674, + 0.027171947062015533, + 0.07012715935707092, + 0.0774020180106163, + 0.047516774386167526 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11296993494033813 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, low-angle tracking shot follows a massive giant panda as it journeys through the depths of a lush bamboo forest shrouded in thick morning mist. The panda's thick, distinct black and white fur appears incredibly realistic in the soft, diffused light, each strand of black and creamy white hair clearly visible, even the tiny droplets of water clinging to its damp fur. With a leisurely, yet clumsy gait, it steadily explores, its sturdy body slightly hunched, its massive paws carefully treading the damp, fallen leaves. Occasionally, it pauses, raising its classic round face, its damp black nose twitching slightly as it seems to sniff the fresh bamboo air. A thin mist slowly drifts between the bamboo stalks, obscuring the distant landscape and creating a tranquil and mysterious atmosphere. Light penetrates the mist, casting a soft, subtle sheen on its glossy black fur and the surrounding lush bamboo leaves, creating an almost documentary-like sense of reality and an enchanting natural beauty.", + "seed": 17524, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_1/index_2812_seed_17524_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2101683236658573, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2101683236658573, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.149999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2101683236658573, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive giant panda with thick black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush bamboo forest shrouded in thick morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the panda moving with a leisurely, clumsy gait while treading on damp fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the panda pause occasionally to raise its face and twitch its damp black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, low-angle tracking shot following the panda?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038746364414691925 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2887463569641113 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038746364414691925, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038746364414691925, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1631198227405548, + 0.09081331640481949, + 0.06044064462184906, + 0.06975560635328293, + 0.09596258401870728, + 0.1696052849292755, + 0.056635335087776184, + 0.08801505714654922, + 0.05749606713652611, + 0.14815635979175568 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038746364414691925 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive giant panda with thick black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush bamboo forest shrouded in thick morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the panda moving with a leisurely, clumsy gait while treading on damp fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the panda pause occasionally to raise its face and twitch its damp black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, low-angle tracking shot following the panda?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578496932983398 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328496932983398 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7578496932983398, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7578496932983398, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18052789568901062, + 0.15994153916835785, + 0.07564189285039902, + 0.055427517741918564, + 0.052706897258758545, + 0.1962670534849167, + 0.02762247435748577, + 0.09561663866043091, + 0.0353199802339077, + 0.12092819064855576 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7578496932983398 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive giant panda with thick black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush bamboo forest shrouded in thick morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the panda moving with a leisurely, clumsy gait while treading on damp fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the panda pause occasionally to raise its face and twitch its damp black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, low-angle tracking shot following the panda?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12708553671836853 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270854473114014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12708553671836853, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12708553671836853, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13981829583644867, + 0.140548974275589, + 0.10127931833267212, + 0.12092052400112152, + 0.08268588036298752, + 0.08638805896043777, + 0.05843392759561539, + 0.07604876160621643, + 0.03356090188026428, + 0.1603153496980667 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12708553671836853 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive giant panda with thick black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush bamboo forest shrouded in thick morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the panda moving with a leisurely, clumsy gait while treading on damp fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the panda pause occasionally to raise its face and twitch its damp black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, low-angle tracking shot following the panda?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038113366812467575 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881133556365967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038113366812467575, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038113366812467575, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0737210065126419, + 0.08433545380830765, + 0.10530261695384979, + 0.07893332839012146, + 0.07443859428167343, + 0.12846826016902924, + 0.021153226494789124, + 0.07076149433851242, + 0.058275461196899414, + 0.3046104311943054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038113366812467575 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive giant panda with thick black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush bamboo forest shrouded in thick morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the panda moving with a leisurely, clumsy gait while treading on damp fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the panda pause occasionally to raise its face and twitch its damp black nose?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, low-angle tracking shot following the panda?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890466570854187 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640467166900635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0890466570854187, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0890466570854187, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08613187819719315, + 0.08025199174880981, + 0.053139783442020416, + 0.03361287713050842, + 0.05978773161768913, + 0.07347825169563293, + 0.01517134066671133, + 0.36822688579559326, + 0.04901007562875748, + 0.18118919432163239 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0890466570854187 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_10/index_tensor([2624, 2624])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_10/index_tensor([2624, 2624])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1594508ad687891b8c1e05f0499919b39ec419e5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_10/index_tensor([2624, 2624])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "This dynamic slow-motion extreme close-up, filmed at eye level with a static camera, meticulously captures the powerful moment of celebratory high-fives. Two hands, one slightly larger and more substantial, the other more slender, move swiftly and decisively toward the center of the frame. The scene is bathed in the warm golden glow of a setting sun, which glints off the skin and creates a soft, atmospheric lens flare against the severely out-of-focus backdrop of lush greenery. As the open palms connect with the resounding clap, the ultra-detailed slow motion reveals the physics of the impact; visible shockwaves surge through the muscles and skin of their hands, the connected force causing the skin to compress and then vibrate. The sheer energy of this moment is palpable, transforming a simple gesture into an epic triumphant event, conveying a powerful sense of shared triumph and excitement.", + "seed": 3795, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_10/index_2624_seed_3795_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.5971448045223952, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5971448045223952, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.225000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5971448045223952, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two hands performing a high-five?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the two hands visibly different in size, with one being larger and the other more slender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video filmed in slow motion showing visible shockwaves and skin compression upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a warm golden glow with a soft lens flare against a severely out-of-focus green background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye level and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0542149543762207 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4292150139808655 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0542149543762207, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.6249999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0542149543762207, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17607881128787994, + 0.14705993235111237, + 0.08700379729270935, + 0.026734143495559692, + 0.04743430018424988, + 0.0921398252248764, + 0.037759292870759964, + 0.019371753558516502, + 0.04764759913086891, + 0.3187706470489502 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0542149543762207 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two hands performing a high-five?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the two hands visibly different in size, with one being larger and the other more slender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video filmed in slow motion showing visible shockwaves and skin compression upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a warm golden glow with a soft lens flare against a severely out-of-focus green background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye level and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12710349261760712 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127103567123413 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12710349261760712, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12710349261760712, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28530237078666687, + 0.10670999437570572, + 0.18916283547878265, + 0.04666295275092125, + 0.061627261340618134, + 0.04985693469643593, + 0.09918639808893204, + 0.026826567947864532, + 0.05274370312690735, + 0.0819210335612297 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12710349261760712 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two hands performing a high-five?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the two hands visibly different in size, with one being larger and the other more slender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video filmed in slow motion showing visible shockwaves and skin compression upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a warm golden glow with a soft lens flare against a severely out-of-focus green background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye level and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761287808418274 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261287808418274 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761287808418274, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761287808418274, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27434584498405457, + 0.09807043522596359, + 0.1418362855911255, + 0.0329110324382782, + 0.09307264536619186, + 0.04668160527944565, + 0.040646109730005264, + 0.06691256165504456, + 0.06949952244758606, + 0.13602393865585327 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761287808418274 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two hands performing a high-five?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the two hands visibly different in size, with one being larger and the other more slender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video filmed in slow motion showing visible shockwaves and skin compression upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a warm golden glow with a soft lens flare against a severely out-of-focus green background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye level and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004640286788344383 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379640102386475 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004640286788344383, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004640286788344383, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24119627475738525, + 0.20303118228912354, + 0.07384748756885529, + 0.03639669716358185, + 0.0651775598526001, + 0.09482359141111374, + 0.05141837149858475, + 0.03158716484904289, + 0.06650923937559128, + 0.136012464761734 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004640286788344383 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two hands performing a high-five?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the two hands visibly different in size, with one being larger and the other more slender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video filmed in slow motion showing visible shockwaves and skin compression upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a warm golden glow with a soft lens flare against a severely out-of-focus green background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye level and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223636507987976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486364781856537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.223636507987976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.223636507987976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17519038915634155, + 0.10718151181936264, + 0.06616504490375519, + 0.07612289488315582, + 0.1123095378279686, + 0.11876683682203293, + 0.12210109084844589, + 0.056407779455184937, + 0.05299966409802437, + 0.11275523155927658 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.223636507987976 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This dynamic slow-motion extreme close-up, filmed at eye level with a static camera, meticulously captures the powerful moment of celebratory high-fives. Two hands, one slightly larger and more substantial, the other more slender, move swiftly and decisively toward the center of the frame. The scene is bathed in the warm golden glow of a setting sun, which glints off the skin and creates a soft, atmospheric lens flare against the severely out-of-focus backdrop of lush greenery. As the open palms connect with the resounding clap, the ultra-detailed slow motion reveals the physics of the impact; visible shockwaves surge through the muscles and skin of their hands, the connected force causing the skin to compress and then vibrate. The sheer energy of this moment is palpable, transforming a simple gesture into an epic triumphant event, conveying a powerful sense of shared triumph and excitement.", + "seed": 3796, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_10/index_2624_seed_3796_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.330992000317201, + "vlm_logprob": -0.330992000317201, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.330992000317201, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two hands performing a high-five?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the two hands visibly different in size, with one being larger and the other more slender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video filmed in slow motion showing visible shockwaves and skin compression upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a warm golden glow with a soft lens flare against a severely out-of-focus green background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye level and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22622394561767578 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6012239456176758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22622394561767578, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22622394561767578, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03879028186202049, + 0.07825876027345657, + 0.0650947242975235, + 0.21066203713417053, + 0.11874011904001236, + 0.08623363822698593, + 0.10248564928770065, + 0.048025425523519516, + 0.07415129244327545, + 0.17755809426307678 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22622394561767578 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two hands performing a high-five?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the two hands visibly different in size, with one being larger and the other more slender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video filmed in slow motion showing visible shockwaves and skin compression upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a warm golden glow with a soft lens flare against a severely out-of-focus green background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye level and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05498272925615311 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299826622009277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05498272925615311, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05498272925615311, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08372555673122406, + 0.05439763516187668, + 0.032952047884464264, + 0.40841421484947205, + 0.08571118116378784, + 0.03745204955339432, + 0.06642820686101913, + 0.08538419753313065, + 0.09493831545114517, + 0.050596654415130615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05498272925615311 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two hands performing a high-five?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the two hands visibly different in size, with one being larger and the other more slender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video filmed in slow motion showing visible shockwaves and skin compression upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a warm golden glow with a soft lens flare against a severely out-of-focus green background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye level and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4742436408996582 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742436408996582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4742436408996582, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4742436408996582, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.057737648487091064, + 0.07316774874925613, + 0.043674126267433167, + 0.42237845063209534, + 0.1130908876657486, + 0.0815543457865715, + 0.0523831732571125, + 0.046033825725317, + 0.07782697677612305, + 0.032152872532606125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4742436408996582 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two hands performing a high-five?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the two hands visibly different in size, with one being larger and the other more slender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video filmed in slow motion showing visible shockwaves and skin compression upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a warm golden glow with a soft lens flare against a severely out-of-focus green background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye level and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011811431031674147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751181125640869 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011811431031674147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011811431031674147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03646474331617355, + 0.023391257971525192, + 0.07103109359741211, + 0.44385555386543274, + 0.024051696062088013, + 0.048849478363990784, + 0.03175630792975426, + 0.011670856736600399, + 0.29197531938552856, + 0.016953738406300545 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011811431031674147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two hands performing a high-five?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the two hands visibly different in size, with one being larger and the other more slender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video filmed in slow motion showing visible shockwaves and skin compression upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a warm golden glow with a soft lens flare against a severely out-of-focus green background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye level and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983285427093506 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233285427093506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8983285427093506, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8983285427093506, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03700077906250954, + 0.06003120541572571, + 0.055773958563804626, + 0.47729238867759705, + 0.04242090508341789, + 0.04522470012307167, + 0.05110223963856697, + 0.015126235783100128, + 0.16529105603694916, + 0.05073651298880577 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8983285427093506 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This dynamic slow-motion extreme close-up, filmed at eye level with a static camera, meticulously captures the powerful moment of celebratory high-fives. Two hands, one slightly larger and more substantial, the other more slender, move swiftly and decisively toward the center of the frame. The scene is bathed in the warm golden glow of a setting sun, which glints off the skin and creates a soft, atmospheric lens flare against the severely out-of-focus backdrop of lush greenery. As the open palms connect with the resounding clap, the ultra-detailed slow motion reveals the physics of the impact; visible shockwaves surge through the muscles and skin of their hands, the connected force causing the skin to compress and then vibrate. The sheer energy of this moment is palpable, transforming a simple gesture into an epic triumphant event, conveying a powerful sense of shared triumph and excitement.", + "seed": 3797, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_10/index_2624_seed_3797_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.2623008104739711, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2623008104739711, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2623008104739711, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two hands performing a high-five?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the two hands visibly different in size, with one being larger and the other more slender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video filmed in slow motion showing visible shockwaves and skin compression upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a warm golden glow with a soft lens flare against a severely out-of-focus green background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye level and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10081721842288971 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3508172035217285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10081721842288971, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10081721842288971, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30291083455085754, + 0.022264832630753517, + 0.24979983270168304, + 0.06151074543595314, + 0.049921829253435135, + 0.027886318042874336, + 0.14481857419013977, + 0.08909935504198074, + 0.03697318956255913, + 0.014814486727118492 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10081721842288971 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two hands performing a high-five?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the two hands visibly different in size, with one being larger and the other more slender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video filmed in slow motion showing visible shockwaves and skin compression upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a warm golden glow with a soft lens flare against a severely out-of-focus green background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye level and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371308371424675 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087131023406982 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371308371424675, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371308371424675, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18193431198596954, + 0.07484343647956848, + 0.27608320116996765, + 0.11049260944128036, + 0.06750888377428055, + 0.026418019086122513, + 0.10188364237546921, + 0.05964844301342964, + 0.04722147434949875, + 0.05396590381860733 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371308371424675 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two hands performing a high-five?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the two hands visibly different in size, with one being larger and the other more slender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video filmed in slow motion showing visible shockwaves and skin compression upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a warm golden glow with a soft lens flare against a severely out-of-focus green background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye level and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20153525471687317 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015352249145508 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20153525471687317, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20153525471687317, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1937190145254135, + 0.09056145697832108, + 0.06484001874923706, + 0.2113736867904663, + 0.11410153657197952, + 0.07259703427553177, + 0.09747233986854553, + 0.05854775384068489, + 0.058317508548498154, + 0.03846960514783859 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20153525471687317 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two hands performing a high-five?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the two hands visibly different in size, with one being larger and the other more slender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video filmed in slow motion showing visible shockwaves and skin compression upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a warm golden glow with a soft lens flare against a severely out-of-focus green background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye level and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001178999780677259 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751179218292236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001178999780677259, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001178999780677259, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4099785387516022, + 0.042578451335430145, + 0.06090636923909187, + 0.025132203474640846, + 0.08194251358509064, + 0.07364540547132492, + 0.10928303003311157, + 0.08587701618671417, + 0.06447678804397583, + 0.046179670840501785 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001178999780677259 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two hands performing a high-five?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the two hands visibly different in size, with one being larger and the other more slender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video filmed in slow motion showing visible shockwaves and skin compression upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a warm golden glow with a soft lens flare against a severely out-of-focus green background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye level and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742594957351685 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47425949573516846 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9742594957351685, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9742594957351685, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.221955344080925, + 0.03258481249213219, + 0.05994825437664986, + 0.034120701253414154, + 0.08720150589942932, + 0.04433866962790489, + 0.07895372062921524, + 0.2515109181404114, + 0.16171813011169434, + 0.027667880058288574 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9742594957351685 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This dynamic slow-motion extreme close-up, filmed at eye level with a static camera, meticulously captures the powerful moment of celebratory high-fives. Two hands, one slightly larger and more substantial, the other more slender, move swiftly and decisively toward the center of the frame. The scene is bathed in the warm golden glow of a setting sun, which glints off the skin and creates a soft, atmospheric lens flare against the severely out-of-focus backdrop of lush greenery. As the open palms connect with the resounding clap, the ultra-detailed slow motion reveals the physics of the impact; visible shockwaves surge through the muscles and skin of their hands, the connected force causing the skin to compress and then vibrate. The sheer energy of this moment is palpable, transforming a simple gesture into an epic triumphant event, conveying a powerful sense of shared triumph and excitement.", + "seed": 3798, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_10/index_2624_seed_3798_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.6305579737992957, + "vlm_logprob": -0.6305579737992957, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.6305579737992957, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two hands performing a high-five?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the two hands visibly different in size, with one being larger and the other more slender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video filmed in slow motion showing visible shockwaves and skin compression upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a warm golden glow with a soft lens flare against a severely out-of-focus green background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye level and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9745964407920837 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47459644079208374 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9745964407920837, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9745964407920837, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07752601057291031, + 0.03033381514251232, + 0.08176307380199432, + 0.07380764931440353, + 0.4775049686431885, + 0.17935135960578918, + 0.015700843185186386, + 0.029560668393969536, + 0.025919565930962563, + 0.008532047271728516 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9745964407920837 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two hands performing a high-five?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the two hands visibly different in size, with one being larger and the other more slender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video filmed in slow motion showing visible shockwaves and skin compression upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a warm golden glow with a soft lens flare against a severely out-of-focus green background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye level and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12710894644260406 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1271090507507324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12710894644260406, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12710894644260406, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30790475010871887, + 0.026535246521234512, + 0.06888972222805023, + 0.08106543868780136, + 0.25460177659988403, + 0.12154275178909302, + 0.019671780988574028, + 0.042346760630607605, + 0.060563236474990845, + 0.016878556460142136 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12710894644260406 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two hands performing a high-five?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the two hands visibly different in size, with one being larger and the other more slender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video filmed in slow motion showing visible shockwaves and skin compression upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a warm golden glow with a soft lens flare against a severely out-of-focus green background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye level and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34859374165534973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2235937118530273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34859374165534973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34859374165534973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3083661198616028, + 0.2855803370475769, + 0.08006903529167175, + 0.040379345417022705, + 0.11967948079109192, + 0.06905478239059448, + 0.021548081189393997, + 0.028002727776765823, + 0.030522961169481277, + 0.016797106713056564 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34859374165534973 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two hands performing a high-five?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the two hands visibly different in size, with one being larger and the other more slender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video filmed in slow motion showing visible shockwaves and skin compression upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a warm golden glow with a soft lens flare against a severely out-of-focus green background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye level and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.000920825288631022 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.00092077255249 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.000920825288631022, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.000920825288631022, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21152225136756897, + 0.038459960371255875, + 0.16646239161491394, + 0.05501256883144379, + 0.3080339729785919, + 0.14421936869621277, + 0.015418045222759247, + 0.022749315947294235, + 0.019950607791543007, + 0.018171509727835655 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.000920825288631022 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of two hands performing a high-five?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the two hands visibly different in size, with one being larger and the other more slender?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video filmed in slow motion showing visible shockwaves and skin compression upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene bathed in a warm golden glow with a soft lens flare against a severely out-of-focus green background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at eye level and remains static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.70156991481781 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20156994462013245 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.70156991481781, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -1.70156991481781, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3282690942287445, + 0.09125269949436188, + 0.08980534225702286, + 0.03628053143620491, + 0.06997374445199966, + 0.0506371334195137, + 0.038715168833732605, + 0.02999105304479599, + 0.24134162068367004, + 0.023733578622341156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.70156991481781 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_11/index_tensor([108, 108])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_11/index_tensor([108, 108])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9513f4d7436573149f39db4af60cadc80c174f51 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_11/index_tensor([108, 108])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium, close-up, static shot, shot from a horizontal angle, focuses on a white-haired elderly man lying on his side on an old wooden bed. His sparse, graying hair is matted against the pillow, and he wears a light gray cotton nightgown, slightly worn from numerous washes. The background is a dimly lit bedroom, with only a soft ray of morning light slanting in from the nearby window, illuminating his pale profile, etched with illness, and the fine dust particles floating in the air. Suddenly, a violent, deep cough shatters the stillness of the room. Seized by the sudden onset, the elderly man instinctively curls up. His eyes are tightly closed, his deeply wrinkled face contorted in agony from the violent movements and lack of oxygen. Each deep, chest-deep cough, threatening to rupture his lungs, sends his thin shoulders, visible through the thin nightgown, trembling uncontrollably. His entire body twitches against the slightly wrinkled white sheets, creating a heartbreaking atmosphere of vulnerability, a silent struggle against illness in this quiet environment.", + "seed": 32985, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_11/index_108_seed_32985_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0863448322750628, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0863448322750628, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0863448322750628, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with white or graying hair lying on his side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a light gray, slightly worn cotton nightgown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit bedroom with a soft ray of morning light coming from a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform a violent coughing action that causes his shoulders to tremble and his body to twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, close-up view from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011978951282799244 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.636979103088379 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011978951282799244, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011978951282799244, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23134663701057434, + 0.18058116734027863, + 0.06525425612926483, + 0.12468639761209488, + 0.15701250731945038, + 0.040151454508304596, + 0.06895282864570618, + 0.043370090425014496, + 0.029257558286190033, + 0.059387147426605225 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011978951282799244 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with white or graying hair lying on his side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a light gray, slightly worn cotton nightgown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit bedroom with a soft ray of morning light coming from a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform a violent coughing action that causes his shoulders to tremble and his body to twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, close-up view from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02981428988277912 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298142433166504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02981428988277912, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02981428988277912, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1410539746284485, + 0.08594227582216263, + 0.07976662367582321, + 0.21350707113742828, + 0.10397685319185257, + 0.11603251844644547, + 0.05357856675982475, + 0.08842464536428452, + 0.0396350622177124, + 0.07808240503072739 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02981428988277912 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with white or graying hair lying on his side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a light gray, slightly worn cotton nightgown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit bedroom with a soft ray of morning light coming from a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform a violent coughing action that causes his shoulders to tremble and his body to twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, close-up view from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007631433662027121 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882631301879883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007631433662027121, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007631433662027121, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10910337418317795, + 0.04017285257577896, + 0.2537181079387665, + 0.015545673668384552, + 0.03294021636247635, + 0.48332077264785767, + 0.008481806144118309, + 0.012543361634016037, + 0.009704207070171833, + 0.034469686448574066 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007631433662027121 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with white or graying hair lying on his side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a light gray, slightly worn cotton nightgown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit bedroom with a soft ray of morning light coming from a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform a violent coughing action that causes his shoulders to tremble and his body to twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, close-up view from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34860703349113464 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223607063293457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34860703349113464, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34860703349113464, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.058526281267404556, + 0.05908426269888878, + 0.08832457661628723, + 0.05240248143672943, + 0.26307743787765503, + 0.08047164231538773, + 0.16005367040634155, + 0.12794269621372223, + 0.04595116525888443, + 0.06416580080986023 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34860703349113464 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with white or graying hair lying on his side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a light gray, slightly worn cotton nightgown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit bedroom with a soft ray of morning light coming from a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform a violent coughing action that causes his shoulders to tremble and his body to twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, close-up view from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369245305657387 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086923599243164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369245305657387, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369245305657387, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14190080761909485, + 0.08212557435035706, + 0.11673486232757568, + 0.054624222218990326, + 0.1302509307861328, + 0.1524072289466858, + 0.05017619580030441, + 0.04985286667943001, + 0.05697287246584892, + 0.16495443880558014 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369245305657387 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium, close-up, static shot, shot from a horizontal angle, focuses on a white-haired elderly man lying on his side on an old wooden bed. His sparse, graying hair is matted against the pillow, and he wears a light gray cotton nightgown, slightly worn from numerous washes. The background is a dimly lit bedroom, with only a soft ray of morning light slanting in from the nearby window, illuminating his pale profile, etched with illness, and the fine dust particles floating in the air. Suddenly, a violent, deep cough shatters the stillness of the room. Seized by the sudden onset, the elderly man instinctively curls up. His eyes are tightly closed, his deeply wrinkled face contorted in agony from the violent movements and lack of oxygen. Each deep, chest-deep cough, threatening to rupture his lungs, sends his thin shoulders, visible through the thin nightgown, trembling uncontrollably. His entire body twitches against the slightly wrinkled white sheets, creating a heartbreaking atmosphere of vulnerability, a silent struggle against illness in this quiet environment.", + "seed": 32986, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_11/index_108_seed_32986_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.14524666564539074, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14524666564539074, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14524666564539074, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with white or graying hair lying on his side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a light gray, slightly worn cotton nightgown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit bedroom with a soft ray of morning light coming from a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform a violent coughing action that causes his shoulders to tremble and his body to twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, close-up view from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03900676593184471 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2890067100524902 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03900676593184471, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03900676593184471, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08877862989902496, + 0.6815208196640015, + 0.031377118080854416, + 0.02367505244910717, + 0.032526783645153046, + 0.06529044359922409, + 0.021460093557834625, + 0.010549873113632202, + 0.01892324537038803, + 0.025897972285747528 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03900676593184471 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with white or graying hair lying on his side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a light gray, slightly worn cotton nightgown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit bedroom with a soft ray of morning light coming from a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform a violent coughing action that causes his shoulders to tremble and his body to twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, close-up view from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371815383434296 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087181091308594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371815383434296, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371815383434296, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18669147789478302, + 0.3047514259815216, + 0.05886108800768852, + 0.04453415796160698, + 0.07876931875944138, + 0.05604361742734909, + 0.11631958186626434, + 0.03575052320957184, + 0.03588631749153137, + 0.08239253610372543 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371815383434296 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with white or graying hair lying on his side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a light gray, slightly worn cotton nightgown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit bedroom with a soft ray of morning light coming from a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform a violent coughing action that causes his shoulders to tremble and his body to twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, close-up view from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004640998784452677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379641056060791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004640998784452677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004640998784452677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1024826318025589, + 0.20128700137138367, + 0.06160201504826546, + 0.34155943989753723, + 0.037190038710832596, + 0.05157395452260971, + 0.05204455554485321, + 0.05289116129279137, + 0.04133882373571396, + 0.05803041160106659 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004640998784452677 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with white or graying hair lying on his side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a light gray, slightly worn cotton nightgown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit bedroom with a soft ray of morning light coming from a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform a violent coughing action that causes his shoulders to tremble and his body to twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, close-up view from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328034996986389 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578034996986389 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6328034996986389, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6328034996986389, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06551393121480942, + 0.5488032698631287, + 0.02572542242705822, + 0.03750527277588844, + 0.02901076339185238, + 0.023754479363560677, + 0.1138971820473671, + 0.06998095661401749, + 0.024867208674550056, + 0.060941457748413086 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6328034996986389 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with white or graying hair lying on his side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a light gray, slightly worn cotton nightgown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit bedroom with a soft ray of morning light coming from a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform a violent coughing action that causes his shoulders to tremble and his body to twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, close-up view from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016063909977674484 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141063690185547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016063909977674484, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016063909977674484, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05758163705468178, + 0.4678318500518799, + 0.04277516528964043, + 0.04685857892036438, + 0.034121960401535034, + 0.04374362528324127, + 0.0850365161895752, + 0.08185920119285583, + 0.039183031767606735, + 0.10100843012332916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016063909977674484 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium, close-up, static shot, shot from a horizontal angle, focuses on a white-haired elderly man lying on his side on an old wooden bed. His sparse, graying hair is matted against the pillow, and he wears a light gray cotton nightgown, slightly worn from numerous washes. The background is a dimly lit bedroom, with only a soft ray of morning light slanting in from the nearby window, illuminating his pale profile, etched with illness, and the fine dust particles floating in the air. Suddenly, a violent, deep cough shatters the stillness of the room. Seized by the sudden onset, the elderly man instinctively curls up. His eyes are tightly closed, his deeply wrinkled face contorted in agony from the violent movements and lack of oxygen. Each deep, chest-deep cough, threatening to rupture his lungs, sends his thin shoulders, visible through the thin nightgown, trembling uncontrollably. His entire body twitches against the slightly wrinkled white sheets, creating a heartbreaking atmosphere of vulnerability, a silent struggle against illness in this quiet environment.", + "seed": 32987, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_11/index_108_seed_32987_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.09493911024183035, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09493911024183035, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09493911024183035, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with white or graying hair lying on his side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a light gray, slightly worn cotton nightgown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit bedroom with a soft ray of morning light coming from a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform a violent coughing action that causes his shoulders to tremble and his body to twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, close-up view from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.030980288982391357 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.530980348587036 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.030980288982391357, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.030980288982391357, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05948357284069061, + 0.4324142038822174, + 0.042544346302747726, + 0.27304503321647644, + 0.02057538740336895, + 0.03779507428407669, + 0.050861913710832596, + 0.02205405943095684, + 0.02782379649579525, + 0.03340265899896622 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.030980288982391357 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with white or graying hair lying on his side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a light gray, slightly worn cotton nightgown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit bedroom with a soft ray of morning light coming from a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform a violent coughing action that causes his shoulders to tremble and his body to twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, close-up view from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016085494309663773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141085624694824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016085494309663773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016085494309663773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13475830852985382, + 0.45173799991607666, + 0.054200656712055206, + 0.0816003829240799, + 0.012579874135553837, + 0.15222688019275665, + 0.04315107315778732, + 0.024562282487750053, + 0.019498594105243683, + 0.025683945044875145 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016085494309663773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with white or graying hair lying on his side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a light gray, slightly worn cotton nightgown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit bedroom with a soft ray of morning light coming from a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform a violent coughing action that causes his shoulders to tremble and his body to twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, close-up view from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026373712345957756 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513736248016357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026373712345957756, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026373712345957756, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1780485063791275, + 0.23893366754055023, + 0.1001969575881958, + 0.07559292018413544, + 0.10630808025598526, + 0.04586341604590416, + 0.03934295102953911, + 0.04377841576933861, + 0.14561980962753296, + 0.026315296068787575 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026373712345957756 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with white or graying hair lying on his side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a light gray, slightly worn cotton nightgown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit bedroom with a soft ray of morning light coming from a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform a violent coughing action that causes his shoulders to tremble and his body to twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, close-up view from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870624005794525 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137062430381775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3870624005794525, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3870624005794525, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08666770905256271, + 0.38856253027915955, + 0.07743626832962036, + 0.04844404384493828, + 0.07266417890787125, + 0.0339055135846138, + 0.037945933640003204, + 0.09569867700338364, + 0.11029001325368881, + 0.048385076224803925 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3870624005794525 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with white or graying hair lying on his side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a light gray, slightly worn cotton nightgown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit bedroom with a soft ray of morning light coming from a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform a violent coughing action that causes his shoulders to tremble and his body to twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, close-up view from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014193654991686344 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264193534851074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014193654991686344, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014193654991686344, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1250232458114624, + 0.3565014898777008, + 0.04844248294830322, + 0.060647595673799515, + 0.09751845896244049, + 0.04912159964442253, + 0.09107266366481781, + 0.08767354488372803, + 0.03024505451321602, + 0.053753867745399475 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014193654991686344 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium, close-up, static shot, shot from a horizontal angle, focuses on a white-haired elderly man lying on his side on an old wooden bed. His sparse, graying hair is matted against the pillow, and he wears a light gray cotton nightgown, slightly worn from numerous washes. The background is a dimly lit bedroom, with only a soft ray of morning light slanting in from the nearby window, illuminating his pale profile, etched with illness, and the fine dust particles floating in the air. Suddenly, a violent, deep cough shatters the stillness of the room. Seized by the sudden onset, the elderly man instinctively curls up. His eyes are tightly closed, his deeply wrinkled face contorted in agony from the violent movements and lack of oxygen. Each deep, chest-deep cough, threatening to rupture his lungs, sends his thin shoulders, visible through the thin nightgown, trembling uncontrollably. His entire body twitches against the slightly wrinkled white sheets, creating a heartbreaking atmosphere of vulnerability, a silent struggle against illness in this quiet environment.", + "seed": 32988, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_11/index_108_seed_32988_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10141895115375518, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10141895115375518, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.300000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10141895115375518, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with white or graying hair lying on his side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a light gray, slightly worn cotton nightgown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit bedroom with a soft ray of morning light coming from a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform a violent coughing action that causes his shoulders to tremble and his body to twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, close-up view from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01741674728691578 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.142416954040527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01741674728691578, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01741674728691578, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12521059811115265, + 0.038762565702199936, + 0.07055773586034775, + 0.3830438256263733, + 0.09889544546604156, + 0.03092074580490589, + 0.05069555714726448, + 0.053409356623888016, + 0.05846824124455452, + 0.09003587812185287 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01741674728691578 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with white or graying hair lying on his side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a light gray, slightly worn cotton nightgown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit bedroom with a soft ray of morning light coming from a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform a violent coughing action that causes his shoulders to tremble and his body to twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, close-up view from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023297972977161407 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732980251312256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023297972977161407, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023297972977161407, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10700951516628265, + 0.03441079333424568, + 0.08698128908872604, + 0.3408322036266327, + 0.07235545665025711, + 0.021181125193834305, + 0.04181753098964691, + 0.05080621689558029, + 0.04878133907914162, + 0.19582447409629822 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023297972977161407 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with white or graying hair lying on his side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a light gray, slightly worn cotton nightgown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit bedroom with a soft ray of morning light coming from a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform a violent coughing action that causes his shoulders to tremble and his body to twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, close-up view from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014204349368810654 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264204502105713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014204349368810654, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014204349368810654, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23280514776706696, + 0.0561525896191597, + 0.05729253962635994, + 0.23475828766822815, + 0.029792504385113716, + 0.03582657128572464, + 0.11224808543920517, + 0.03598679602146149, + 0.11271949857473373, + 0.09241801500320435 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014204349368810654 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with white or graying hair lying on his side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a light gray, slightly worn cotton nightgown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit bedroom with a soft ray of morning light coming from a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform a violent coughing action that causes his shoulders to tremble and his body to twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, close-up view from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4288904070854187 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0538904666900635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4288904070854187, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.6250000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4288904070854187, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15433676540851593, + 0.03427906706929207, + 0.04839947074651718, + 0.3091900944709778, + 0.1034465953707695, + 0.08164229989051819, + 0.10045681893825531, + 0.0364462211728096, + 0.11200008541345596, + 0.01980256289243698 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4288904070854187 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly man with white or graying hair lying on his side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a light gray, slightly worn cotton nightgown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dimly lit bedroom with a soft ray of morning light coming from a window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform a violent coughing action that causes his shoulders to tremble and his body to twitch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static, close-up view from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0232852790504694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773285388946533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0232852790504694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0232852790504694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2277466356754303, + 0.041832972317934036, + 0.047283466905355453, + 0.18581247329711914, + 0.09026984125375748, + 0.058495521545410156, + 0.19821467995643616, + 0.03238939121365547, + 0.07501509040594101, + 0.042939916253089905 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0232852790504694 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_12/index_tensor([1796, 1796])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_12/index_tensor([1796, 1796])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..305832b7cd11e827827eb4d498951c2b55183477 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_12/index_tensor([1796, 1796])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow-motion overhead shot, the camera tilting slowly upward, follows a fluffy orange tabby kitten as it struggles to scale a towering, vintage-style bookshelf crafted from dark walnut, its surface minutely scratched and patinated by age. The shelves are cluttered and tightly packed with heavy hardcover books, their gilded titles on the leather covers glimmering in the light. In the extreme slow-motion, the kitten's every movement is magnified: its front paws dig deep into the wood, its hind legs clumsily kicking in the air, searching for new footholds. Its tiny body trembles slightly with the effort, its face a look of focused yet clumsy determination. A ray of warm afternoon sunlight slants in through a side window, skewing dust particles in the air and softly illuminating the kitten's fluffy fur and blue eyes. Even a tiny scrap of sawdust, loosened by its claws, drifts gracefully down. The whole picture is painted in warm tones, full of a tranquil and cozy atmosphere, while at the same time carrying a hint of dramatic tension due to the kitten's efforts, creating a poetic moment about the unremitting efforts of tiny lives.", + "seed": 4887, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_12/index_1796_seed_4887_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1300034761428833, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1300034761428833, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1300034761428833, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an overhead view of a fluffy orange tabby kitten?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the kitten attempting to climb a tall, vintage-style bookshelf made of dark walnut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly upward while following the kitten's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight entering through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in slow motion showing the kitten's paws digging into the wood and its body trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16455581784248352 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9145557880401611 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16455581784248352, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16455581784248352, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05115598812699318, + 0.03741391375660896, + 0.21874190866947174, + 0.08808053284883499, + 0.17671003937721252, + 0.12808097898960114, + 0.03869268670678139, + 0.03739093616604805, + 0.16798198223114014, + 0.055750977247953415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16455581784248352 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an overhead view of a fluffy orange tabby kitten?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the kitten attempting to climb a tall, vintage-style bookshelf made of dark walnut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly upward while following the kitten's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight entering through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in slow motion showing the kitten's paws digging into the wood and its body trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22557322680950165 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600573182106018 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22557322680950165, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22557322680950165, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13998201489448547, + 0.08808837085962296, + 0.033269431442022324, + 0.11445946246385574, + 0.03743068501353264, + 0.1251232922077179, + 0.1009974479675293, + 0.15225236117839813, + 0.04070247709751129, + 0.16769443452358246 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22557322680950165 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an overhead view of a fluffy orange tabby kitten?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the kitten attempting to climb a tall, vintage-style bookshelf made of dark walnut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly upward while following the kitten's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight entering through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in slow motion showing the kitten's paws digging into the wood and its body trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14278392493724823 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0177838802337646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14278392493724823, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14278392493724823, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14477699995040894, + 0.07167011499404907, + 0.17060551047325134, + 0.046855684369802475, + 0.11087730526924133, + 0.29609042406082153, + 0.036638181656599045, + 0.037677157670259476, + 0.04395044595003128, + 0.0408581979572773 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14278392493724823 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an overhead view of a fluffy orange tabby kitten?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the kitten attempting to climb a tall, vintage-style bookshelf made of dark walnut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly upward while following the kitten's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight entering through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in slow motion showing the kitten's paws digging into the wood and its body trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07899770140647888 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789976119995117 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07899770140647888, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07899770140647888, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20982053875923157, + 0.05066373199224472, + 0.05380796641111374, + 0.23754803836345673, + 0.027800019830465317, + 0.18993383646011353, + 0.04673825204372406, + 0.053189728409051895, + 0.05338294804096222, + 0.07711494714021683 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07899770140647888 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an overhead view of a fluffy orange tabby kitten?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the kitten attempting to climb a tall, vintage-style bookshelf made of dark walnut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly upward while following the kitten's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight entering through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in slow motion showing the kitten's paws digging into the wood and its body trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038106709718704224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288106679916382 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038106709718704224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038106709718704224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13009092211723328, + 0.0944649800658226, + 0.06348516047000885, + 0.16143879294395447, + 0.21635107696056366, + 0.07436142861843109, + 0.05893280357122421, + 0.07628317922353745, + 0.05726122856140137, + 0.06733042746782303 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038106709718704224 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion overhead shot, the camera tilting slowly upward, follows a fluffy orange tabby kitten as it struggles to scale a towering, vintage-style bookshelf crafted from dark walnut, its surface minutely scratched and patinated by age. The shelves are cluttered and tightly packed with heavy hardcover books, their gilded titles on the leather covers glimmering in the light. In the extreme slow-motion, the kitten's every movement is magnified: its front paws dig deep into the wood, its hind legs clumsily kicking in the air, searching for new footholds. Its tiny body trembles slightly with the effort, its face a look of focused yet clumsy determination. A ray of warm afternoon sunlight slants in through a side window, skewing dust particles in the air and softly illuminating the kitten's fluffy fur and blue eyes. Even a tiny scrap of sawdust, loosened by its claws, drifts gracefully down. The whole picture is painted in warm tones, full of a tranquil and cozy atmosphere, while at the same time carrying a hint of dramatic tension due to the kitten's efforts, creating a poetic moment about the unremitting efforts of tiny lives.", + "seed": 4888, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_12/index_1796_seed_4888_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.12929039150476457, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12929039150476457, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12929039150476457, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an overhead view of a fluffy orange tabby kitten?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the kitten attempting to climb a tall, vintage-style bookshelf made of dark walnut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly upward while following the kitten's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight entering through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in slow motion showing the kitten's paws digging into the wood and its body trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3922900855541229 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1422901153564453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3922900855541229, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3922900855541229, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1752156764268875, + 0.08538930118083954, + 0.05637180805206299, + 0.13332518935203552, + 0.08404800295829773, + 0.0482591912150383, + 0.203889861702919, + 0.0743684470653534, + 0.03706159442663193, + 0.1020708754658699 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3922900855541229 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an overhead view of a fluffy orange tabby kitten?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the kitten attempting to climb a tall, vintage-style bookshelf made of dark walnut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly upward while following the kitten's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight entering through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in slow motion showing the kitten's paws digging into the wood and its body trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043081555515527725 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168081521987915 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043081555515527725, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043081555515527725, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18569184839725494, + 0.06424625217914581, + 0.12462235242128372, + 0.04512154310941696, + 0.1809951215982437, + 0.03071604296565056, + 0.06997159868478775, + 0.1718975156545639, + 0.038149476051330566, + 0.08858829736709595 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043081555515527725 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an overhead view of a fluffy orange tabby kitten?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the kitten attempting to climb a tall, vintage-style bookshelf made of dark walnut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly upward while following the kitten's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight entering through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in slow motion showing the kitten's paws digging into the wood and its body trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08902539312839508 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640254974365234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08902539312839508, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08902539312839508, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1446034461259842, + 0.13792560994625092, + 0.05784313753247261, + 0.06374037265777588, + 0.16352960467338562, + 0.026401162147521973, + 0.07578957825899124, + 0.10102188587188721, + 0.06323504447937012, + 0.16591015458106995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08902539312839508 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an overhead view of a fluffy orange tabby kitten?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the kitten attempting to climb a tall, vintage-style bookshelf made of dark walnut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly upward while following the kitten's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight entering through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in slow motion showing the kitten's paws digging into the wood and its body trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898878306150436 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578988790512085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898878306150436, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898878306150436, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05364537984132767, + 0.05778336897492409, + 0.04678529500961304, + 0.02962377667427063, + 0.1746988743543625, + 0.020873641595244408, + 0.11063650250434875, + 0.08151289820671082, + 0.053223852068185806, + 0.37121641635894775 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898878306150436 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an overhead view of a fluffy orange tabby kitten?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the kitten attempting to climb a tall, vintage-style bookshelf made of dark walnut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly upward while following the kitten's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight entering through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in slow motion showing the kitten's paws digging into the wood and its body trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306614026427269 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680660247802734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306614026427269, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306614026427269, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17395317554473877, + 0.045833881944417953, + 0.024539751932024956, + 0.044323623180389404, + 0.2275083363056183, + 0.02567283809185028, + 0.0711623802781105, + 0.04000185430049896, + 0.028214475139975548, + 0.31878963112831116 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306614026427269 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion overhead shot, the camera tilting slowly upward, follows a fluffy orange tabby kitten as it struggles to scale a towering, vintage-style bookshelf crafted from dark walnut, its surface minutely scratched and patinated by age. The shelves are cluttered and tightly packed with heavy hardcover books, their gilded titles on the leather covers glimmering in the light. In the extreme slow-motion, the kitten's every movement is magnified: its front paws dig deep into the wood, its hind legs clumsily kicking in the air, searching for new footholds. Its tiny body trembles slightly with the effort, its face a look of focused yet clumsy determination. A ray of warm afternoon sunlight slants in through a side window, skewing dust particles in the air and softly illuminating the kitten's fluffy fur and blue eyes. Even a tiny scrap of sawdust, loosened by its claws, drifts gracefully down. The whole picture is painted in warm tones, full of a tranquil and cozy atmosphere, while at the same time carrying a hint of dramatic tension due to the kitten's efforts, creating a poetic moment about the unremitting efforts of tiny lives.", + "seed": 4889, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_12/index_1796_seed_4889_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06052474603056908, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06052474603056908, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06052474603056908, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an overhead view of a fluffy orange tabby kitten?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the kitten attempting to climb a tall, vintage-style bookshelf made of dark walnut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly upward while following the kitten's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight entering through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in slow motion showing the kitten's paws digging into the wood and its body trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05851702764630318 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9335169792175293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05851702764630318, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05851702764630318, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16101710498332977, + 0.1512102335691452, + 0.14026305079460144, + 0.059930771589279175, + 0.14670631289482117, + 0.09381520003080368, + 0.09411938488483429, + 0.020655658096075058, + 0.07002957910299301, + 0.06225268915295601 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05851702764630318 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an overhead view of a fluffy orange tabby kitten?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the kitten attempting to climb a tall, vintage-style bookshelf made of dark walnut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly upward while following the kitten's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight entering through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in slow motion showing the kitten's paws digging into the wood and its body trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07899583131074905 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578995943069458 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07899583131074905, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07899583131074905, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15623435378074646, + 0.26317036151885986, + 0.08161472529172897, + 0.05839701369404793, + 0.053477298468351364, + 0.05103781446814537, + 0.17109207808971405, + 0.037386272102594376, + 0.042858660221099854, + 0.08473142236471176 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07899583131074905 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an overhead view of a fluffy orange tabby kitten?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the kitten attempting to climb a tall, vintage-style bookshelf made of dark walnut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly upward while following the kitten's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight entering through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in slow motion showing the kitten's paws digging into the wood and its body trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0430564358830452 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680564880371094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0430564358830452, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0430564358830452, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12145973742008209, + 0.35463833808898926, + 0.10189555585384369, + 0.06800822913646698, + 0.12521520256996155, + 0.08795652538537979, + 0.025925448164343834, + 0.015069562941789627, + 0.02731800638139248, + 0.07251345366239548 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0430564358830452 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an overhead view of a fluffy orange tabby kitten?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the kitten attempting to climb a tall, vintage-style bookshelf made of dark walnut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly upward while following the kitten's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight entering through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in slow motion showing the kitten's paws digging into the wood and its body trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898955047130585 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789895057678223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898955047130585, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898955047130585, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13999807834625244, + 0.10752759873867035, + 0.07258925586938858, + 0.2797964811325073, + 0.06161980703473091, + 0.16460609436035156, + 0.047704100608825684, + 0.013586070388555527, + 0.042868636548519135, + 0.06970395147800446 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898955047130585 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an overhead view of a fluffy orange tabby kitten?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the kitten attempting to climb a tall, vintage-style bookshelf made of dark walnut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly upward while following the kitten's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight entering through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in slow motion showing the kitten's paws digging into the wood and its body trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306488484144211 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168064832687378 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306488484144211, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306488484144211, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14445029199123383, + 0.16786128282546997, + 0.09268875420093536, + 0.0661562979221344, + 0.05081925168633461, + 0.04353868588805199, + 0.15517644584178925, + 0.03808177262544632, + 0.08198671042919159, + 0.15924055874347687 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306488484144211 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion overhead shot, the camera tilting slowly upward, follows a fluffy orange tabby kitten as it struggles to scale a towering, vintage-style bookshelf crafted from dark walnut, its surface minutely scratched and patinated by age. The shelves are cluttered and tightly packed with heavy hardcover books, their gilded titles on the leather covers glimmering in the light. In the extreme slow-motion, the kitten's every movement is magnified: its front paws dig deep into the wood, its hind legs clumsily kicking in the air, searching for new footholds. Its tiny body trembles slightly with the effort, its face a look of focused yet clumsy determination. A ray of warm afternoon sunlight slants in through a side window, skewing dust particles in the air and softly illuminating the kitten's fluffy fur and blue eyes. Even a tiny scrap of sawdust, loosened by its claws, drifts gracefully down. The whole picture is painted in warm tones, full of a tranquil and cozy atmosphere, while at the same time carrying a hint of dramatic tension due to the kitten's efforts, creating a poetic moment about the unremitting efforts of tiny lives.", + "seed": 4890, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_12/index_1796_seed_4890_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.08751369044184684, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08751369044184684, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08751369044184684, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an overhead view of a fluffy orange tabby kitten?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the kitten attempting to climb a tall, vintage-style bookshelf made of dark walnut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly upward while following the kitten's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight entering through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in slow motion showing the kitten's paws digging into the wood and its body trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22873549163341522 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6037354469299316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22873549163341522, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22873549163341522, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04451935738325119, + 0.04169022664427757, + 0.03773975744843483, + 0.03330544754862785, + 0.09255968779325485, + 0.021908102557063103, + 0.04870740696787834, + 0.5981312990188599, + 0.04969301074743271, + 0.031745705753564835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22873549163341522 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an overhead view of a fluffy orange tabby kitten?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the kitten attempting to climb a tall, vintage-style bookshelf made of dark walnut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly upward while following the kitten's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight entering through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in slow motion showing the kitten's paws digging into the wood and its body trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812552988529205 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288125514984131 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812552988529205, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812552988529205, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11900338530540466, + 0.1430237740278244, + 0.11027766019105911, + 0.040010713040828705, + 0.018469884991645813, + 0.011739344336092472, + 0.030691606923937798, + 0.4443013072013855, + 0.04607069119811058, + 0.03641163185238838 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812552988529205 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an overhead view of a fluffy orange tabby kitten?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the kitten attempting to climb a tall, vintage-style bookshelf made of dark walnut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly upward while following the kitten's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight entering through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in slow motion showing the kitten's paws digging into the wood and its body trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897016406059265 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578970193862915 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897016406059265, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897016406059265, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.39699387550354004, + 0.061819419264793396, + 0.044629622250795364, + 0.0111588966101408, + 0.05637121573090553, + 0.012954228557646275, + 0.031091392040252686, + 0.3447372317314148, + 0.025721019133925438, + 0.014523048885166645 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897016406059265 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an overhead view of a fluffy orange tabby kitten?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the kitten attempting to climb a tall, vintage-style bookshelf made of dark walnut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly upward while following the kitten's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight entering through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in slow motion showing the kitten's paws digging into the wood and its body trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867124184966087 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048671245574951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867124184966087, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867124184966087, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11831071227788925, + 0.08859742432832718, + 0.46190786361694336, + 0.011824801564216614, + 0.02155456505715847, + 0.004688667599111795, + 0.013762024231255054, + 0.2580893933773041, + 0.00940929725766182, + 0.011855286546051502 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867124184966087 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an overhead view of a fluffy orange tabby kitten?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the kitten attempting to climb a tall, vintage-style bookshelf made of dark walnut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly upward while following the kitten's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a ray of warm afternoon sunlight entering through a side window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in slow motion showing the kitten's paws digging into the wood and its body trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306602478027344 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680660247802734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306602478027344, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306602478027344, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15228146314620972, + 0.16131658852100372, + 0.15552836656570435, + 0.05254533141851425, + 0.09890664368867874, + 0.05180184915661812, + 0.0721130445599556, + 0.14284676313400269, + 0.07724671810865402, + 0.03541325777769089 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306602478027344 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_13/index_tensor([9234, 9234])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_13/index_tensor([9234, 9234])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ac95b4053115ab4380d72709e501e1b6e8dc60f2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_13/index_tensor([9234, 9234])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium shot from a horizontal angle, the camera pans slowly and steadily to the right, following a slender figure. She wears a dark blue cotton and linen robe, her long hair tied back in a simple bun, creating a classical and elegant silhouette. Her body rests against a high, weathered, slightly mottled white wall, atop which rises neatly arranged dark blue eaves and tiles, creating a classic architectural aesthetic. She walks lightly and leisurely, her wide robe sleeves fluttering as she moves, her fingertips occasionally brushing the rough plaster surface. Under her feet lies a slightly damp bluestone pavement, and the surroundings are starkly empty. Apart from her and the seemingly endless wall, nothing else exists, creating a minimalist composition. Under the soft, diffuse light of an overcast sky, the entire scene is bathed in a cool, desaturated palette. The white walls, dark tiles, and dark blue robe create an atmosphere of profound tranquility, a solitude imbued with contemplation and poetry.", + "seed": 8147, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_13/index_9234_seed_8147_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.052987547125667334, + "vlm_logprob": -0.052987547125667334, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.052987547125667334, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot featuring a slender figure wearing a dark blue cotton and linen robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure have long hair tied back in a simple bun and walk lightly against a high, weathered white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue eaves and tiles visible atop the wall, with the figure's sleeves fluttering and fingertips brushing the rough plaster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a slightly damp bluestone pavement in a starkly empty, minimalist environment under soft, diffuse overcast light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and steadily to the right, following the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07216810435056686 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6971681118011475 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07216810435056686, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07216810435056686, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11832699179649353, + 0.18146032094955444, + 0.051131632179021835, + 0.07319306582212448, + 0.08765427768230438, + 0.05774899572134018, + 0.08143103122711182, + 0.14650586247444153, + 0.17979484796524048, + 0.02275291457772255 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07216810435056686 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot featuring a slender figure wearing a dark blue cotton and linen robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure have long hair tied back in a simple bun and walk lightly against a high, weathered white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue eaves and tiles visible atop the wall, with the figure's sleeves fluttering and fingertips brushing the rough plaster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a slightly damp bluestone pavement in a starkly empty, minimalist environment under soft, diffuse overcast light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and steadily to the right, following the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011101268231868744 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511101245880127 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011101268231868744, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011101268231868744, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08755774050951004, + 0.23378832638263702, + 0.06403720378875732, + 0.055715397000312805, + 0.06013072654604912, + 0.049800269305706024, + 0.045580826699733734, + 0.06069980189204216, + 0.2951292395591736, + 0.047560449689626694 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011101268231868744 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot featuring a slender figure wearing a dark blue cotton and linen robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure have long hair tied back in a simple bun and walk lightly against a high, weathered white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue eaves and tiles visible atop the wall, with the figure's sleeves fluttering and fingertips brushing the rough plaster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a slightly damp bluestone pavement in a starkly empty, minimalist environment under soft, diffuse overcast light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and steadily to the right, following the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052597238682210445 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.2552595138549805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052597238682210445, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052597238682210445, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17734339833259583, + 0.27692529559135437, + 0.0772947296500206, + 0.053591806441545486, + 0.057322416454553604, + 0.06917364150285721, + 0.026317747309803963, + 0.05840182304382324, + 0.15222860872745514, + 0.051400553435087204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052597238682210445 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot featuring a slender figure wearing a dark blue cotton and linen robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure have long hair tied back in a simple bun and walk lightly against a high, weathered white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue eaves and tiles visible atop the wall, with the figure's sleeves fluttering and fingertips brushing the rough plaster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a slightly damp bluestone pavement in a starkly empty, minimalist environment under soft, diffuse overcast light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and steadily to the right, following the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016069775447249413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410698890686035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016069775447249413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016069775447249413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10460773855447769, + 0.1792016476392746, + 0.0353720597922802, + 0.0380227155983448, + 0.08834666758775711, + 0.10589856654405594, + 0.09239883720874786, + 0.039879217743873596, + 0.06684084236621857, + 0.24943171441555023 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016069775447249413 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot featuring a slender figure wearing a dark blue cotton and linen robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure have long hair tied back in a simple bun and walk lightly against a high, weathered white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue eaves and tiles visible atop the wall, with the figure's sleeves fluttering and fingertips brushing the rough plaster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a slightly damp bluestone pavement in a starkly empty, minimalist environment under soft, diffuse overcast light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and steadily to the right, following the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603388637304306 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103388786315918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603388637304306, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603388637304306, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10253752022981644, + 0.21312686800956726, + 0.05896614491939545, + 0.04083964601159096, + 0.1345095932483673, + 0.08395632356405258, + 0.018773982301354408, + 0.03689521551132202, + 0.253506600856781, + 0.05688812956213951 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603388637304306 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot from a horizontal angle, the camera pans slowly and steadily to the right, following a slender figure. She wears a dark blue cotton and linen robe, her long hair tied back in a simple bun, creating a classical and elegant silhouette. Her body rests against a high, weathered, slightly mottled white wall, atop which rises neatly arranged dark blue eaves and tiles, creating a classic architectural aesthetic. She walks lightly and leisurely, her wide robe sleeves fluttering as she moves, her fingertips occasionally brushing the rough plaster surface. Under her feet lies a slightly damp bluestone pavement, and the surroundings are starkly empty. Apart from her and the seemingly endless wall, nothing else exists, creating a minimalist composition. Under the soft, diffuse light of an overcast sky, the entire scene is bathed in a cool, desaturated palette. The white walls, dark tiles, and dark blue robe create an atmosphere of profound tranquility, a solitude imbued with contemplation and poetry.", + "seed": 8148, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_13/index_9234_seed_8148_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06389392474666238, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06389392474666238, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06389392474666238, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot featuring a slender figure wearing a dark blue cotton and linen robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure have long hair tied back in a simple bun and walk lightly against a high, weathered white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue eaves and tiles visible atop the wall, with the figure's sleeves fluttering and fingertips brushing the rough plaster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a slightly damp bluestone pavement in a starkly empty, minimalist environment under soft, diffuse overcast light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and steadily to the right, following the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04438820481300354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1693882942199707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04438820481300354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04438820481300354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2855479419231415, + 0.10817471146583557, + 0.10009059309959412, + 0.03837452828884125, + 0.05647541582584381, + 0.025711631402373314, + 0.028986534103751183, + 0.030094590038061142, + 0.23765186965465546, + 0.08889219909906387 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04438820481300354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot featuring a slender figure wearing a dark blue cotton and linen robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure have long hair tied back in a simple bun and walk lightly against a high, weathered white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue eaves and tiles visible atop the wall, with the figure's sleeves fluttering and fingertips brushing the rough plaster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a slightly damp bluestone pavement in a starkly empty, minimalist environment under soft, diffuse overcast light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and steadily to the right, following the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007639241870492697 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882639408111572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007639241870492697, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007639241870492697, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17884773015975952, + 0.1449858695268631, + 0.16659043729305267, + 0.06802785396575928, + 0.07412388920783997, + 0.026858361437916756, + 0.024653224274516106, + 0.03552167862653732, + 0.185881569981575, + 0.09450940787792206 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007639241870492697 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot featuring a slender figure wearing a dark blue cotton and linen robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure have long hair tied back in a simple bun and walk lightly against a high, weathered white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue eaves and tiles visible atop the wall, with the figure's sleeves fluttering and fingertips brushing the rough plaster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a slightly damp bluestone pavement in a starkly empty, minimalist environment under soft, diffuse overcast light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and steadily to the right, following the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006741398945450783 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006741523742676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006741398945450783, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006741398945450783, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.252559632062912, + 0.10863354057073593, + 0.05246327072381973, + 0.04702762886881828, + 0.06773176789283752, + 0.023769279941916466, + 0.050243932753801346, + 0.034756921231746674, + 0.2496122270822525, + 0.11320175975561142 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006741398945450783 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot featuring a slender figure wearing a dark blue cotton and linen robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure have long hair tied back in a simple bun and walk lightly against a high, weathered white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue eaves and tiles visible atop the wall, with the figure's sleeves fluttering and fingertips brushing the rough plaster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a slightly damp bluestone pavement in a starkly empty, minimalist environment under soft, diffuse overcast light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and steadily to the right, following the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008634612895548344 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758634567260742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008634612895548344, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008634612895548344, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20285454392433167, + 0.294167697429657, + 0.07777850329875946, + 0.042673077434301376, + 0.03394613042473793, + 0.028421692550182343, + 0.022512301802635193, + 0.01751890778541565, + 0.19407960772514343, + 0.08604751527309418 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008634612895548344 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot featuring a slender figure wearing a dark blue cotton and linen robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure have long hair tied back in a simple bun and walk lightly against a high, weathered white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue eaves and tiles visible atop the wall, with the figure's sleeves fluttering and fingertips brushing the rough plaster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a slightly damp bluestone pavement in a starkly empty, minimalist environment under soft, diffuse overcast light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and steadily to the right, following the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25206616520881653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020661354064941 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25206616520881653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25206616520881653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08766546100378036, + 0.07253499329090118, + 0.06986179202795029, + 0.11969617009162903, + 0.05920311063528061, + 0.08236376196146011, + 0.03427600860595703, + 0.03768510743975639, + 0.2936829626560211, + 0.14303068816661835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25206616520881653 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot from a horizontal angle, the camera pans slowly and steadily to the right, following a slender figure. She wears a dark blue cotton and linen robe, her long hair tied back in a simple bun, creating a classical and elegant silhouette. Her body rests against a high, weathered, slightly mottled white wall, atop which rises neatly arranged dark blue eaves and tiles, creating a classic architectural aesthetic. She walks lightly and leisurely, her wide robe sleeves fluttering as she moves, her fingertips occasionally brushing the rough plaster surface. Under her feet lies a slightly damp bluestone pavement, and the surroundings are starkly empty. Apart from her and the seemingly endless wall, nothing else exists, creating a minimalist composition. Under the soft, diffuse light of an overcast sky, the entire scene is bathed in a cool, desaturated palette. The white walls, dark tiles, and dark blue robe create an atmosphere of profound tranquility, a solitude imbued with contemplation and poetry.", + "seed": 8149, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_13/index_9234_seed_8149_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.025132915191352367, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025132915191352367, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025132915191352367, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot featuring a slender figure wearing a dark blue cotton and linen robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure have long hair tied back in a simple bun and walk lightly against a high, weathered white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue eaves and tiles visible atop the wall, with the figure's sleeves fluttering and fingertips brushing the rough plaster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a slightly damp bluestone pavement in a starkly empty, minimalist environment under soft, diffuse overcast light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and steadily to the right, following the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04981592670083046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0498158931732178 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04981592670083046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04981592670083046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09921564906835556, + 0.06333562731742859, + 0.08649741113185883, + 0.08625709265470505, + 0.04740547761321068, + 0.07112622261047363, + 0.09473839402198792, + 0.35672658681869507, + 0.0738920122385025, + 0.020805520936846733 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04981592670083046 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot featuring a slender figure wearing a dark blue cotton and linen robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure have long hair tied back in a simple bun and walk lightly against a high, weathered white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue eaves and tiles visible atop the wall, with the figure's sleeves fluttering and fingertips brushing the rough plaster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a slightly damp bluestone pavement in a starkly empty, minimalist environment under soft, diffuse overcast light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and steadily to the right, following the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008649386465549469 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586493492126465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008649386465549469, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008649386465549469, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13815873861312866, + 0.09338796138763428, + 0.13627643883228302, + 0.12745244801044464, + 0.07473371922969818, + 0.0692756325006485, + 0.11291313916444778, + 0.0766696035861969, + 0.13499540090560913, + 0.0361369326710701 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008649386465549469 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot featuring a slender figure wearing a dark blue cotton and linen robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure have long hair tied back in a simple bun and walk lightly against a high, weathered white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue eaves and tiles visible atop the wall, with the figure's sleeves fluttering and fingertips brushing the rough plaster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a slightly damp bluestone pavement in a starkly empty, minimalist environment under soft, diffuse overcast light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and steadily to the right, following the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002489089034497738 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.00248908996582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002489089034497738, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002489089034497738, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07477609813213348, + 0.0518391951918602, + 0.12189215421676636, + 0.05998446047306061, + 0.07179317623376846, + 0.025776930153369904, + 0.09335669875144958, + 0.3285054862499237, + 0.09568757563829422, + 0.07638822495937347 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002489089034497738 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot featuring a slender figure wearing a dark blue cotton and linen robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure have long hair tied back in a simple bun and walk lightly against a high, weathered white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue eaves and tiles visible atop the wall, with the figure's sleeves fluttering and fingertips brushing the rough plaster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a slightly damp bluestone pavement in a starkly empty, minimalist environment under soft, diffuse overcast light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and steadily to the right, following the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009775623679161072 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634775638580322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009775623679161072, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009775623679161072, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07545116543769836, + 0.035473693162202835, + 0.03121468983590603, + 0.09688257426023483, + 0.0871143788099289, + 0.04093249514698982, + 0.10354623943567276, + 0.34260293841362, + 0.09833080321550369, + 0.08845103532075882 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009775623679161072 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot featuring a slender figure wearing a dark blue cotton and linen robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure have long hair tied back in a simple bun and walk lightly against a high, weathered white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue eaves and tiles visible atop the wall, with the figure's sleeves fluttering and fingertips brushing the rough plaster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a slightly damp bluestone pavement in a starkly empty, minimalist environment under soft, diffuse overcast light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and steadily to the right, following the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0549345500767231 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929934501647949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0549345500767231, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0549345500767231, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06094830110669136, + 0.024686235934495926, + 0.03491976857185364, + 0.03241967409849167, + 0.024740036576986313, + 0.03283302113413811, + 0.03881153464317322, + 0.6134238243103027, + 0.028898335993289948, + 0.10831921547651291 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0549345500767231 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot from a horizontal angle, the camera pans slowly and steadily to the right, following a slender figure. She wears a dark blue cotton and linen robe, her long hair tied back in a simple bun, creating a classical and elegant silhouette. Her body rests against a high, weathered, slightly mottled white wall, atop which rises neatly arranged dark blue eaves and tiles, creating a classic architectural aesthetic. She walks lightly and leisurely, her wide robe sleeves fluttering as she moves, her fingertips occasionally brushing the rough plaster surface. Under her feet lies a slightly damp bluestone pavement, and the surroundings are starkly empty. Apart from her and the seemingly endless wall, nothing else exists, creating a minimalist composition. Under the soft, diffuse light of an overcast sky, the entire scene is bathed in a cool, desaturated palette. The white walls, dark tiles, and dark blue robe create an atmosphere of profound tranquility, a solitude imbued with contemplation and poetry.", + "seed": 8150, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_13/index_9234_seed_8150_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04614581633359194, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04614581633359194, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04614581633359194, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot featuring a slender figure wearing a dark blue cotton and linen robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure have long hair tied back in a simple bun and walk lightly against a high, weathered white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue eaves and tiles visible atop the wall, with the figure's sleeves fluttering and fingertips brushing the rough plaster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a slightly damp bluestone pavement in a starkly empty, minimalist environment under soft, diffuse overcast light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and steadily to the right, following the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10241664201021194 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.352416753768921 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10241664201021194, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10241664201021194, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25316017866134644, + 0.1445562094449997, + 0.08697424829006195, + 0.08373390883207321, + 0.052766889333724976, + 0.07727513462305069, + 0.0315677635371685, + 0.05744600296020508, + 0.13214640319347382, + 0.08037328720092773 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10241664201021194 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot featuring a slender figure wearing a dark blue cotton and linen robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure have long hair tied back in a simple bun and walk lightly against a high, weathered white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue eaves and tiles visible atop the wall, with the figure's sleeves fluttering and fingertips brushing the rough plaster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a slightly damp bluestone pavement in a starkly empty, minimalist environment under soft, diffuse overcast light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and steadily to the right, following the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011093840934336185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511093616485596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011093840934336185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011093840934336185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15398366749286652, + 0.0957898274064064, + 0.0801968201994896, + 0.07358144223690033, + 0.047733064740896225, + 0.06728121638298035, + 0.05399750545620918, + 0.11947664618492126, + 0.20730827748775482, + 0.10065155476331711 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011093840934336185 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot featuring a slender figure wearing a dark blue cotton and linen robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure have long hair tied back in a simple bun and walk lightly against a high, weathered white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue eaves and tiles visible atop the wall, with the figure's sleeves fluttering and fingertips brushing the rough plaster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a slightly damp bluestone pavement in a starkly empty, minimalist environment under soft, diffuse overcast light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and steadily to the right, following the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007632853463292122 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882632732391357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007632853463292122, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007632853463292122, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18704448640346527, + 0.12080198526382446, + 0.07535304874181747, + 0.06676945090293884, + 0.12557052075862885, + 0.0879368931055069, + 0.09888896346092224, + 0.06750982254743576, + 0.0920676663517952, + 0.0780571848154068 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007632853463292122 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot featuring a slender figure wearing a dark blue cotton and linen robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure have long hair tied back in a simple bun and walk lightly against a high, weathered white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue eaves and tiles visible atop the wall, with the figure's sleeves fluttering and fingertips brushing the rough plaster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a slightly damp bluestone pavement in a starkly empty, minimalist environment under soft, diffuse overcast light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and steadily to the right, following the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057681791484356 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955767154693604 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057681791484356, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057681791484356, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20292416214942932, + 0.12206671386957169, + 0.09136686474084854, + 0.05942694842815399, + 0.07303843647241592, + 0.06558559834957123, + 0.07860477268695831, + 0.19678649306297302, + 0.0502648763358593, + 0.05993518605828285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057681791484356 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a medium shot featuring a slender figure wearing a dark blue cotton and linen robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the figure have long hair tied back in a simple bun and walk lightly against a high, weathered white wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are dark blue eaves and tiles visible atop the wall, with the figure's sleeves fluttering and fingertips brushing the rough plaster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a slightly damp bluestone pavement in a starkly empty, minimalist environment under soft, diffuse overcast light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan slowly and steadily to the right, following the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08900892734527588 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640088081359863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08900892734527588, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08900892734527588, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07477965950965881, + 0.035200219601392746, + 0.04263387620449066, + 0.07043633610010147, + 0.07446997612714767, + 0.04082079231739044, + 0.08337822556495667, + 0.2791585624217987, + 0.2053341269493103, + 0.09378822892904282 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08900892734527588 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_14/index_tensor([4996, 4996])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_14/index_tensor([4996, 4996])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..18753fa7740a4f9b61ec45f97ec81edb2f106f93 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_14/index_tensor([4996, 4996])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "Shot using high-speed macro photography using stark, focused lighting, the camera slowly and deliberately tilts downward to capture the dramatic final moments of a candle flame against a deep black background. Initially vibrant and dancing, the flame—a teardrop of brilliant yellow and orange with a blue base—suddenly begins to dramatically shrink. It flickers erratically, its light collapsing inward in rapid, spasmodic sequences until it is extinguished, leaving only a bright orange flicker emitting intense heat at the tip of a blackened spiral. As the last of the light source dwindles, a delicate, almost ethereal wisp of white smoke unravels from the wick, curling gracefully upward in a slow, hypnotic spiral into the darkness. Below, the circular pool of transparent liquid wax, shimmering in the flame's reflection, loses its luster and begins to cool noticeably. Its surface tension tightens as the last traces of warmth dissipate, creating a profound atmosphere of tranquil finality and ephemeral beauty.", + "seed": 27696, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_14/index_4996_seed_27696_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.16320901541039348, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16320901541039348, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16320901541039348, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a high-speed macro shot focused on a candle flame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep black with stark, focused lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame shrink, flicker erratically, and extinguish leaving a bright orange flicker at the tip of a blackened spiral?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a circular pool of transparent liquid wax visible below the flame that cools and loses its luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10592538118362427 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3559253215789795 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10592538118362427, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10592538118362427, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0784115195274353, + 0.05871453881263733, + 0.025151662528514862, + 0.039486248046159744, + 0.11593601852655411, + 0.21705220639705658, + 0.0616733580827713, + 0.04364432394504547, + 0.23765364289283752, + 0.12227646261453629 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10592538118362427 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a high-speed macro shot focused on a candle flame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep black with stark, focused lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame shrink, flicker erratically, and extinguish leaving a bright orange flicker at the tip of a blackened spiral?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a circular pool of transparent liquid wax visible below the flame that cools and loses its luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08905713260173798 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464057207107544 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08905713260173798, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08905713260173798, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.010515117086470127, + 0.013820636086165905, + 0.01792057417333126, + 0.02112666331231594, + 0.3750077188014984, + 0.1621498316526413, + 0.1222711130976677, + 0.038422856479883194, + 0.13829806447029114, + 0.10046742111444473 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08905713260173798 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a high-speed macro shot focused on a candle flame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep black with stark, focused lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame shrink, flicker erratically, and extinguish leaving a bright orange flicker at the tip of a blackened spiral?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a circular pool of transparent liquid wax visible below the flame that cools and loses its luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761995315551758 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261995315551758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761995315551758, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761995315551758, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.034672241657972336, + 0.06071086227893829, + 0.05466083064675331, + 0.046265553683042526, + 0.3003886640071869, + 0.14503180980682373, + 0.05523962900042534, + 0.021865613758563995, + 0.18641293048858643, + 0.09475187957286835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761995315551758 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a high-speed macro shot focused on a candle flame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep black with stark, focused lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame shrink, flicker erratically, and extinguish leaving a bright orange flicker at the tip of a blackened spiral?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a circular pool of transparent liquid wax visible below the flame that cools and loses its luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812151402235031 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288121461868286 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812151402235031, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812151402235031, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02619384601712227, + 0.012245689518749714, + 0.01703527383506298, + 0.04383520036935806, + 0.318387895822525, + 0.0917292907834053, + 0.10770909488201141, + 0.04093782976269722, + 0.2649255394935608, + 0.07700028270483017 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812151402235031 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a high-speed macro shot focused on a candle flame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep black with stark, focused lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame shrink, flicker erratically, and extinguish leaving a bright orange flicker at the tip of a blackened spiral?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a circular pool of transparent liquid wax visible below the flame that cools and loses its luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006741517689079046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006741523742676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006741517689079046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006741517689079046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04192215949296951, + 0.02617531828582287, + 0.03239917755126953, + 0.057977281510829926, + 0.07194750010967255, + 0.15425844490528107, + 0.1981295347213745, + 0.04732873663306236, + 0.20347023010253906, + 0.16639156639575958 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006741517689079046 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Shot using high-speed macro photography using stark, focused lighting, the camera slowly and deliberately tilts downward to capture the dramatic final moments of a candle flame against a deep black background. Initially vibrant and dancing, the flame—a teardrop of brilliant yellow and orange with a blue base—suddenly begins to dramatically shrink. It flickers erratically, its light collapsing inward in rapid, spasmodic sequences until it is extinguished, leaving only a bright orange flicker emitting intense heat at the tip of a blackened spiral. As the last of the light source dwindles, a delicate, almost ethereal wisp of white smoke unravels from the wick, curling gracefully upward in a slow, hypnotic spiral into the darkness. Below, the circular pool of transparent liquid wax, shimmering in the flame's reflection, loses its luster and begins to cool noticeably. Its surface tension tightens as the last traces of warmth dissipate, creating a profound atmosphere of tranquil finality and ephemeral beauty.", + "seed": 27697, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_14/index_4996_seed_27697_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0323135057464242, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0323135057464242, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0323135057464242, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a high-speed macro shot focused on a candle flame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep black with stark, focused lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame shrink, flicker erratically, and extinguish leaving a bright orange flicker at the tip of a blackened spiral?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a circular pool of transparent liquid wax visible below the flame that cools and loses its luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.050558414310216904 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.17555832862854 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.050558414310216904, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.050558414310216904, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06985962390899658, + 0.039510954171419144, + 0.03621240705251694, + 0.02029428631067276, + 0.08360171318054199, + 0.05890364944934845, + 0.47944366931915283, + 0.10242513567209244, + 0.05117516592144966, + 0.058573368936777115 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.050558414310216904 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a high-speed macro shot focused on a candle flame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep black with stark, focused lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame shrink, flicker erratically, and extinguish leaving a bright orange flicker at the tip of a blackened spiral?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a circular pool of transparent liquid wax visible below the flame that cools and loses its luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018208960071206093 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018208980560303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018208960071206093, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018208960071206093, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.042547378689050674, + 0.06437493115663528, + 0.034204091876745224, + 0.033750928938388824, + 0.07673870027065277, + 0.10526277124881744, + 0.3070395588874817, + 0.15727508068084717, + 0.10094887763261795, + 0.0778576135635376 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018208960071206093 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a high-speed macro shot focused on a candle flame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep black with stark, focused lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame shrink, flicker erratically, and extinguish leaving a bright orange flicker at the tip of a blackened spiral?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a circular pool of transparent liquid wax visible below the flame that cools and loses its luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018202872946858406 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018202781677246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018202872946858406, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018202872946858406, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13601647317409515, + 0.04425238445401192, + 0.03696996346116066, + 0.06309714168310165, + 0.089629627764225, + 0.17877787351608276, + 0.29465344548225403, + 0.08166824281215668, + 0.02857561968266964, + 0.04635922238230705 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018202872946858406 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a high-speed macro shot focused on a candle flame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep black with stark, focused lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame shrink, flicker erratically, and extinguish leaving a bright orange flicker at the tip of a blackened spiral?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a circular pool of transparent liquid wax visible below the flame that cools and loses its luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205545365810394 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120553493499756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205545365810394, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205545365810394, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.045220308005809784, + 0.028501838445663452, + 0.07800449430942535, + 0.05844982713460922, + 0.060691654682159424, + 0.09893306344747543, + 0.2140570729970932, + 0.2139691412448883, + 0.09063009172677994, + 0.11154250055551529 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205545365810394 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a high-speed macro shot focused on a candle flame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep black with stark, focused lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame shrink, flicker erratically, and extinguish leaving a bright orange flicker at the tip of a blackened spiral?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a circular pool of transparent liquid wax visible below the flame that cools and loses its luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012541827745735645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387541770935059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012541827745735645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012541827745735645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05901171639561653, + 0.020387159660458565, + 0.06248091906309128, + 0.02878158912062645, + 0.10527883470058441, + 0.07816445827484131, + 0.21019604802131653, + 0.10555241256952286, + 0.14102999866008759, + 0.18911688029766083 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012541827745735645 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Shot using high-speed macro photography using stark, focused lighting, the camera slowly and deliberately tilts downward to capture the dramatic final moments of a candle flame against a deep black background. Initially vibrant and dancing, the flame—a teardrop of brilliant yellow and orange with a blue base—suddenly begins to dramatically shrink. It flickers erratically, its light collapsing inward in rapid, spasmodic sequences until it is extinguished, leaving only a bright orange flicker emitting intense heat at the tip of a blackened spiral. As the last of the light source dwindles, a delicate, almost ethereal wisp of white smoke unravels from the wick, curling gracefully upward in a slow, hypnotic spiral into the darkness. Below, the circular pool of transparent liquid wax, shimmering in the flame's reflection, loses its luster and begins to cool noticeably. Its surface tension tightens as the last traces of warmth dissipate, creating a profound atmosphere of tranquil finality and ephemeral beauty.", + "seed": 27698, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_14/index_4996_seed_27698_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04225843558087945, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04225843558087945, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04225843558087945, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a high-speed macro shot focused on a candle flame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep black with stark, focused lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame shrink, flicker erratically, and extinguish leaving a bright orange flicker at the tip of a blackened spiral?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a circular pool of transparent liquid wax visible below the flame that cools and loses its luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06321413815021515 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.188214063644409 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06321413815021515, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06321413815021515, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20363321900367737, + 0.04809674620628357, + 0.03539705276489258, + 0.10368065536022186, + 0.125631183385849, + 0.0704452395439148, + 0.1377514898777008, + 0.06556389480829239, + 0.15859025716781616, + 0.05121030658483505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06321413815021515 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a high-speed macro shot focused on a candle flame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep black with stark, focused lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame shrink, flicker erratically, and extinguish leaving a bright orange flicker at the tip of a blackened spiral?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a circular pool of transparent liquid wax visible below the flame that cools and loses its luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309285804629326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168092966079712 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309285804629326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309285804629326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03908800333738327, + 0.06877247989177704, + 0.04114095866680145, + 0.0922517478466034, + 0.08088871836662292, + 0.12588723003864288, + 0.054477840662002563, + 0.14036612212657928, + 0.28190547227859497, + 0.0752214640378952 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309285804629326 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a high-speed macro shot focused on a candle flame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep black with stark, focused lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame shrink, flicker erratically, and extinguish leaving a bright orange flicker at the tip of a blackened spiral?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a circular pool of transparent liquid wax visible below the flame that cools and loses its luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048683051019907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486831665039062 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048683051019907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048683051019907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12027626484632492, + 0.163235604763031, + 0.06048827990889549, + 0.12978431582450867, + 0.11290161311626434, + 0.1251707524061203, + 0.06085578352212906, + 0.07654546201229095, + 0.13104617595672607, + 0.01969575509428978 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048683051019907 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a high-speed macro shot focused on a candle flame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep black with stark, focused lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame shrink, flicker erratically, and extinguish leaving a bright orange flicker at the tip of a blackened spiral?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a circular pool of transparent liquid wax visible below the flame that cools and loses its luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867010563611984 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486700534820557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867010563611984, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867010563611984, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07332289963960648, + 0.06859998404979706, + 0.07623284310102463, + 0.11853819340467453, + 0.12355945259332657, + 0.04589199274778366, + 0.047320399433374405, + 0.12798422574996948, + 0.1893385350704193, + 0.1292114555835724 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867010563611984 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a high-speed macro shot focused on a candle flame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep black with stark, focused lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame shrink, flicker erratically, and extinguish leaving a bright orange flicker at the tip of a blackened spiral?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a circular pool of transparent liquid wax visible below the flame that cools and loses its luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007632025051862001 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882632255554199 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007632025051862001, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007632025051862001, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05012797936797142, + 0.07377923280000687, + 0.07742805033922195, + 0.13634610176086426, + 0.09977353364229202, + 0.04433082044124603, + 0.12731966376304626, + 0.13787424564361572, + 0.15418115258216858, + 0.09883923828601837 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007632025051862001 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Shot using high-speed macro photography using stark, focused lighting, the camera slowly and deliberately tilts downward to capture the dramatic final moments of a candle flame against a deep black background. Initially vibrant and dancing, the flame—a teardrop of brilliant yellow and orange with a blue base—suddenly begins to dramatically shrink. It flickers erratically, its light collapsing inward in rapid, spasmodic sequences until it is extinguished, leaving only a bright orange flicker emitting intense heat at the tip of a blackened spiral. As the last of the light source dwindles, a delicate, almost ethereal wisp of white smoke unravels from the wick, curling gracefully upward in a slow, hypnotic spiral into the darkness. Below, the circular pool of transparent liquid wax, shimmering in the flame's reflection, loses its luster and begins to cool noticeably. Its surface tension tightens as the last traces of warmth dissipate, creating a profound atmosphere of tranquil finality and ephemeral beauty.", + "seed": 27699, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_14/index_4996_seed_27699_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.20389706045389175, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20389706045389175, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20389706045389175, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a high-speed macro shot focused on a candle flame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep black with stark, focused lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame shrink, flicker erratically, and extinguish leaving a bright orange flicker at the tip of a blackened spiral?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a circular pool of transparent liquid wax visible below the flame that cools and loses its luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06870462745428085 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.068704605102539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06870462745428085, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06870462745428085, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08420022577047348, + 0.061480291187763214, + 0.0696602314710617, + 0.24906428158283234, + 0.0792446956038475, + 0.257306843996048, + 0.04040300473570824, + 0.061325553804636, + 0.050446704030036926, + 0.046868253499269485 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06870462745428085 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a high-speed macro shot focused on a candle flame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep black with stark, focused lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame shrink, flicker erratically, and extinguish leaving a bright orange flicker at the tip of a blackened spiral?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a circular pool of transparent liquid wax visible below the flame that cools and loses its luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813924252986908 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063924551010132 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813924252986908, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813924252986908, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05254942178726196, + 0.10614733397960663, + 0.13032639026641846, + 0.5270102024078369, + 0.06354741007089615, + 0.032093096524477005, + 0.016650782898068428, + 0.04877123236656189, + 0.014685671776533127, + 0.008218386210501194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813924252986908 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a high-speed macro shot focused on a candle flame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep black with stark, focused lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame shrink, flicker erratically, and extinguish leaving a bright orange flicker at the tip of a blackened spiral?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a circular pool of transparent liquid wax visible below the flame that cools and loses its luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006750753149390221 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006750583648682 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006750753149390221, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006750753149390221, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03340999782085419, + 0.1156257763504982, + 0.6177750825881958, + 0.022926125675439835, + 0.05155888944864273, + 0.052755337208509445, + 0.02377885952591896, + 0.03046031855046749, + 0.021492375060915947, + 0.03021720051765442 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006750753149390221 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a high-speed macro shot focused on a candle flame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep black with stark, focused lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame shrink, flicker erratically, and extinguish leaving a bright orange flicker at the tip of a blackened spiral?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a circular pool of transparent liquid wax visible below the flame that cools and loses its luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328303813934326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578303813934326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6328303813934326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6328303813934326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03880300000309944, + 0.08512900769710541, + 0.07251663506031036, + 0.43856191635131836, + 0.024209430441260338, + 0.07888945192098618, + 0.05083470046520233, + 0.13910196721553802, + 0.034148920327425, + 0.03780500218272209 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6328303813934326 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a high-speed macro shot focused on a candle flame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately tilt downward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background deep black with stark, focused lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flame shrink, flicker erratically, and extinguish leaving a bright orange flicker at the tip of a blackened spiral?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a circular pool of transparent liquid wax visible below the flame that cools and loses its luster?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029807114973664284 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298070907592773 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029807114973664284, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029807114973664284, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09930317103862762, + 0.052532751113176346, + 0.06754764169454575, + 0.15157075226306915, + 0.05191618576645851, + 0.05087040364742279, + 0.032344747334718704, + 0.10301855951547623, + 0.19917626678943634, + 0.19171950221061707 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029807114973664284 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_15/index_tensor([1729, 1729])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_15/index_tensor([1729, 1729])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b6663a76bdae40f02200844b7c038590ad3ec7b6 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_15/index_tensor([1729, 1729])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "wide-angle lens at eye level captures the dynamic scene, as the camera executes a series of rapid, repetitive side-to-side pans to track the frenetic action across the vast, sun-drenched park lawn. A diverse group of five young people, their faces flushed with exertion and beaming with joyful, competitive smiles, are energetically immersed in a game. Their casual, colorful athletic attire—a young woman with a high ponytail in a bright yellow T-shirt and black running shorts, a man in a blue sleeveless top and gray sweatpants, another in a simple white T-shirt—creates a vibrant pop of color against the lush green grass. The camera's movement is driven by their play; as one player sprints decisively across the court, it quickly tracks them, then suddenly moves back to follow another player as they dodge and weave with agility and grace. The bright afternoon sun casts long, dancing shadows that expand and contract with their rapid movements. The entire scene is filled with a warm golden light, creating a carefree, exuberant atmosphere imbued with the pure energy of friendly competition and outdoor fun.", + "seed": 16817, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_15/index_1729_seed_16817_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.10183866233564913, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10183866233564913, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.249999994039536, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10183866233564913, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched park lawn with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are five young people visible playing a game in casual, colorful athletic attire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with a high ponytail wearing a bright yellow T-shirt and black running shorts visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid, repetitive side-to-side pans to track the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long, dancing shadows visible on the grass that expand and contract with the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022521864157170057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.002252101898193 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022521864157170057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022521864157170057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3624914884567261, + 0.060151636600494385, + 0.03383001312613487, + 0.05605819821357727, + 0.09614431858062744, + 0.0661294087767601, + 0.0548618920147419, + 0.047186266630887985, + 0.0926617980003357, + 0.13048501312732697 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022521864157170057 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched park lawn with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are five young people visible playing a game in casual, colorful athletic attire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with a high ponytail wearing a bright yellow T-shirt and black running shorts visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid, repetitive side-to-side pans to track the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long, dancing shadows visible on the grass that expand and contract with the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014218335039913654 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264218330383301 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014218335039913654, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014218335039913654, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3911154568195343, + 0.038963817059993744, + 0.052612464874982834, + 0.15154077112674713, + 0.13335967063903809, + 0.08165812492370605, + 0.037509385496377945, + 0.0256352536380291, + 0.019641168415546417, + 0.06796396523714066 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014218335039913654 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched park lawn with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are five young people visible playing a game in casual, colorful athletic attire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with a high ponytail wearing a bright yellow T-shirt and black running shorts visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid, repetitive side-to-side pans to track the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long, dancing shadows visible on the grass that expand and contract with the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059498813934624195 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130949974060059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059498813934624195, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059498813934624195, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2189868986606598, + 0.02608220838010311, + 0.07911930978298187, + 0.05647066608071327, + 0.18600086867809296, + 0.1661030799150467, + 0.10619033128023148, + 0.06904949992895126, + 0.053460653871297836, + 0.03853645920753479 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059498813934624195 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched park lawn with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are five young people visible playing a game in casual, colorful athletic attire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with a high ponytail wearing a bright yellow T-shirt and black running shorts visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid, repetitive side-to-side pans to track the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long, dancing shadows visible on the grass that expand and contract with the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4742347300052643 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742347002029419 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4742347300052643, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.4999999701976776, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4742347300052643, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31502649188041687, + 0.14925554394721985, + 0.10993675887584686, + 0.06838735938072205, + 0.15963104367256165, + 0.038131751120090485, + 0.02205774001777172, + 0.03912505879998207, + 0.032732222229242325, + 0.06571599841117859 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4742347300052643 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched park lawn with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are five young people visible playing a game in casual, colorful athletic attire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with a high ponytail wearing a bright yellow T-shirt and black running shorts visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid, repetitive side-to-side pans to track the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long, dancing shadows visible on the grass that expand and contract with the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012538178823888302 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387537956237793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012538178823888302, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012538178823888302, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3381939232349396, + 0.1091633141040802, + 0.051712099462747574, + 0.04552779346704483, + 0.1853971779346466, + 0.03895324096083641, + 0.039398930966854095, + 0.04349024221301079, + 0.06880830973386765, + 0.07935496419668198 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012538178823888302 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle lens at eye level captures the dynamic scene, as the camera executes a series of rapid, repetitive side-to-side pans to track the frenetic action across the vast, sun-drenched park lawn. A diverse group of five young people, their faces flushed with exertion and beaming with joyful, competitive smiles, are energetically immersed in a game. Their casual, colorful athletic attire—a young woman with a high ponytail in a bright yellow T-shirt and black running shorts, a man in a blue sleeveless top and gray sweatpants, another in a simple white T-shirt—creates a vibrant pop of color against the lush green grass. The camera's movement is driven by their play; as one player sprints decisively across the court, it quickly tracks them, then suddenly moves back to follow another player as they dodge and weave with agility and grace. The bright afternoon sun casts long, dancing shadows that expand and contract with their rapid movements. The entire scene is filled with a warm golden light, creating a carefree, exuberant atmosphere imbued with the pure energy of friendly competition and outdoor fun.", + "seed": 16818, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_15/index_1729_seed_16818_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08300301195122302, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08300301195122302, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.300000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08300301195122302, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched park lawn with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are five young people visible playing a game in casual, colorful athletic attire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with a high ponytail wearing a bright yellow T-shirt and black running shorts visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid, repetitive side-to-side pans to track the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long, dancing shadows visible on the grass that expand and contract with the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0030083658639341593 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.1280083656311035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0030083658639341593, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0030083658639341593, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2190922498703003, + 0.08114509284496307, + 0.25243401527404785, + 0.054395902901887894, + 0.08406689763069153, + 0.11525858938694, + 0.054960187524557114, + 0.03664461150765419, + 0.03496430441737175, + 0.06703812628984451 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0030083658639341593 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched park lawn with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are five young people visible playing a game in casual, colorful athletic attire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with a high ponytail wearing a bright yellow T-shirt and black running shorts visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid, repetitive side-to-side pans to track the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long, dancing shadows visible on the grass that expand and contract with the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011097731068730354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110979080200195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011097731068730354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011097731068730354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1947035938501358, + 0.08241715282201767, + 0.13280437886714935, + 0.2341206967830658, + 0.0666033998131752, + 0.07446178793907166, + 0.043885473161935806, + 0.03473066911101341, + 0.04560321941971779, + 0.0906696543097496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011097731068730354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched park lawn with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are five young people visible playing a game in casual, colorful athletic attire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with a high ponytail wearing a bright yellow T-shirt and black running shorts visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid, repetitive side-to-side pans to track the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long, dancing shadows visible on the grass that expand and contract with the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040968069806694984 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504096984863281 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040968069806694984, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040968069806694984, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2923683524131775, + 0.2668720781803131, + 0.03402724489569664, + 0.17460337281227112, + 0.06917356699705124, + 0.04223044589161873, + 0.030119555070996284, + 0.02533937245607376, + 0.027391783893108368, + 0.03787430375814438 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040968069806694984 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched park lawn with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are five young people visible playing a game in casual, colorful athletic attire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with a high ponytail wearing a bright yellow T-shirt and black running shorts visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid, repetitive side-to-side pans to track the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long, dancing shadows visible on the grass that expand and contract with the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38702744245529175 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370275020599365 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38702744245529175, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7500000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38702744245529175, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17439225316047668, + 0.11537515372037888, + 0.1618812531232834, + 0.09301038086414337, + 0.055223800241947174, + 0.13275478780269623, + 0.07331037521362305, + 0.08158513903617859, + 0.031184988096356392, + 0.0812818706035614 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38702744245529175 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched park lawn with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are five young people visible playing a game in casual, colorful athletic attire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with a high ponytail wearing a bright yellow T-shirt and black running shorts visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid, repetitive side-to-side pans to track the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long, dancing shadows visible on the grass that expand and contract with the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009784713387489319 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634784698486328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009784713387489319, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009784713387489319, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2355692982673645, + 0.04186131805181503, + 0.2746945917606354, + 0.13164164125919342, + 0.06796251982450485, + 0.07366754114627838, + 0.04586780071258545, + 0.03255072236061096, + 0.03768889605998993, + 0.058495666831731796 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009784713387489319 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle lens at eye level captures the dynamic scene, as the camera executes a series of rapid, repetitive side-to-side pans to track the frenetic action across the vast, sun-drenched park lawn. A diverse group of five young people, their faces flushed with exertion and beaming with joyful, competitive smiles, are energetically immersed in a game. Their casual, colorful athletic attire—a young woman with a high ponytail in a bright yellow T-shirt and black running shorts, a man in a blue sleeveless top and gray sweatpants, another in a simple white T-shirt—creates a vibrant pop of color against the lush green grass. The camera's movement is driven by their play; as one player sprints decisively across the court, it quickly tracks them, then suddenly moves back to follow another player as they dodge and weave with agility and grace. The bright afternoon sun casts long, dancing shadows that expand and contract with their rapid movements. The entire scene is filled with a warm golden light, creating a carefree, exuberant atmosphere imbued with the pure energy of friendly competition and outdoor fun.", + "seed": 16819, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_15/index_1729_seed_16819_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04377869265154004, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04377869265154004, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04377869265154004, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched park lawn with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are five young people visible playing a game in casual, colorful athletic attire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with a high ponytail wearing a bright yellow T-shirt and black running shorts visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid, repetitive side-to-side pans to track the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long, dancing shadows visible on the grass that expand and contract with the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002148345345631242 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.502148151397705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002148345345631242, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002148345345631242, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27428945899009705, + 0.033713892102241516, + 0.033412907272577286, + 0.02709754928946495, + 0.4209950864315033, + 0.023607945069670677, + 0.05597143992781639, + 0.07583814859390259, + 0.025944873690605164, + 0.029128586873412132 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002148345345631242 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched park lawn with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are five young people visible playing a game in casual, colorful athletic attire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with a high ponytail wearing a bright yellow T-shirt and black running shorts visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid, repetitive side-to-side pans to track the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long, dancing shadows visible on the grass that expand and contract with the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02332662232220173 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733266353607178 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02332662232220173, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02332662232220173, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16898617148399353, + 0.13716310262680054, + 0.10474834591150284, + 0.04834430664777756, + 0.25647857785224915, + 0.051907941699028015, + 0.06124993413686752, + 0.08349258452653885, + 0.05105215311050415, + 0.03657684475183487 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02332662232220173 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched park lawn with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are five young people visible playing a game in casual, colorful athletic attire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with a high ponytail wearing a bright yellow T-shirt and black running shorts visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid, repetitive side-to-side pans to track the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long, dancing shadows visible on the grass that expand and contract with the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024915861431509256 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002491474151611 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024915861431509256, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024915861431509256, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13228611648082733, + 0.20654405653476715, + 0.12152612209320068, + 0.08376678824424744, + 0.22881557047367096, + 0.05208136886358261, + 0.04030483216047287, + 0.037637319415807724, + 0.0504581592977047, + 0.046579670161008835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024915861431509256 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched park lawn with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are five young people visible playing a game in casual, colorful athletic attire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with a high ponytail wearing a bright yellow T-shirt and black running shorts visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid, repetitive side-to-side pans to track the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long, dancing shadows visible on the grass that expand and contract with the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17985311150550842 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804853081703186 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17985311150550842, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17985311150550842, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06190193071961403, + 0.06603516638278961, + 0.13216394186019897, + 0.11880476772785187, + 0.15206442773342133, + 0.05722503736615181, + 0.16273044049739838, + 0.14362835884094238, + 0.03325800225138664, + 0.0721878930926323 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17985311150550842 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched park lawn with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are five young people visible playing a game in casual, colorful athletic attire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with a high ponytail wearing a bright yellow T-shirt and black running shorts visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid, repetitive side-to-side pans to track the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long, dancing shadows visible on the grass that expand and contract with the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011073797941207886 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511073589324951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011073797941207886, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011073797941207886, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23366165161132812, + 0.04906810075044632, + 0.07423756271600723, + 0.046773187816143036, + 0.22189205884933472, + 0.035754717886447906, + 0.10653380304574966, + 0.12459716945886612, + 0.07929903268814087, + 0.028182629495859146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011073797941207886 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle lens at eye level captures the dynamic scene, as the camera executes a series of rapid, repetitive side-to-side pans to track the frenetic action across the vast, sun-drenched park lawn. A diverse group of five young people, their faces flushed with exertion and beaming with joyful, competitive smiles, are energetically immersed in a game. Their casual, colorful athletic attire—a young woman with a high ponytail in a bright yellow T-shirt and black running shorts, a man in a blue sleeveless top and gray sweatpants, another in a simple white T-shirt—creates a vibrant pop of color against the lush green grass. The camera's movement is driven by their play; as one player sprints decisively across the court, it quickly tracks them, then suddenly moves back to follow another player as they dodge and weave with agility and grace. The bright afternoon sun casts long, dancing shadows that expand and contract with their rapid movements. The entire scene is filled with a warm golden light, creating a carefree, exuberant atmosphere imbued with the pure energy of friendly competition and outdoor fun.", + "seed": 16820, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_15/index_1729_seed_16820_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.023182246927171947, + "vlm_logprob": -0.023182246927171947, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.023182246927171947, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched park lawn with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are five young people visible playing a game in casual, colorful athletic attire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with a high ponytail wearing a bright yellow T-shirt and black running shorts visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid, repetitive side-to-side pans to track the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long, dancing shadows visible on the grass that expand and contract with the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004804851021617651 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.629805088043213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004804851021617651, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004804851021617651, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19912980496883392, + 0.1887824833393097, + 0.1404331773519516, + 0.06836752593517303, + 0.04429321363568306, + 0.10760059207677841, + 0.07078936696052551, + 0.05908893048763275, + 0.06474055349826813, + 0.05677429586648941 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004804851021617651 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched park lawn with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are five young people visible playing a game in casual, colorful athletic attire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with a high ponytail wearing a bright yellow T-shirt and black running shorts visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid, repetitive side-to-side pans to track the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long, dancing shadows visible on the grass that expand and contract with the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01257337722927332 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875732421875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01257337722927332, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01257337722927332, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3186805248260498, + 0.1418885886669159, + 0.11870604008436203, + 0.10137939453125, + 0.057667460292577744, + 0.047907523810863495, + 0.03496444597840309, + 0.06156477332115173, + 0.024201463907957077, + 0.09303983300924301 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01257337722927332 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched park lawn with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are five young people visible playing a game in casual, colorful athletic attire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with a high ponytail wearing a bright yellow T-shirt and black running shorts visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid, repetitive side-to-side pans to track the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long, dancing shadows visible on the grass that expand and contract with the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009786837734282017 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634786605834961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009786837734282017, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009786837734282017, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18426987528800964, + 0.23474006354808807, + 0.05876297131180763, + 0.0787394791841507, + 0.05541861429810524, + 0.04053970053792, + 0.06495901197195053, + 0.1082618311047554, + 0.037427835166454315, + 0.13688060641288757 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009786837734282017 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched park lawn with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are five young people visible playing a game in casual, colorful athletic attire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with a high ponytail wearing a bright yellow T-shirt and black running shorts visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid, repetitive side-to-side pans to track the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long, dancing shadows visible on the grass that expand and contract with the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0789615735411644 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789616107940674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0789615735411644, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0789615735411644, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11216940730810165, + 0.12345371395349503, + 0.07820634543895721, + 0.09870748966932297, + 0.21865111589431763, + 0.05054926127195358, + 0.0402410551905632, + 0.18494845926761627, + 0.050344593822956085, + 0.04272858053445816 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0789615735411644 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched park lawn with lush green grass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are five young people visible playing a game in casual, colorful athletic attire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with a high ponytail wearing a bright yellow T-shirt and black running shorts visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute rapid, repetitive side-to-side pans to track the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are long, dancing shadows visible on the grass that expand and contract with the players' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009784595109522343 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634784698486328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009784595109522343, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009784595109522343, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1772996187210083, + 0.24076831340789795, + 0.07819690555334091, + 0.029819495975971222, + 0.07381909340620041, + 0.046146512031555176, + 0.04342314973473549, + 0.16039399802684784, + 0.06263449043035507, + 0.08749847114086151 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009784595109522343 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_2/index_tensor([3962, 3962])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_2/index_tensor([3962, 3962])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4234f289bea4791f01fe341e8588eeddb2b1ff4d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_2/index_tensor([3962, 3962])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a stunning macro close-up, the camera tilts upward at an incredibly slow speed, closely tracking a new potato sprout as it indomitably rises from the moist, dark brown soil rich in organic matter. This delicate, almost translucent white stalk, with a tender green tip and a slight curl, steadily and slowly pushes upward, pushing away the earth beneath it with a resilient force imbued with life. As it continues to push, tiny cracks appear in the surrounding soil, and small clumps of earth loosen and tumble away, revealing the dark, moist interior. A faint but hopeful ray of overhead light penetrates directly from above, precisely illuminating the tip of the new sprout, giving it an almost luminous quality and causing tiny water droplets clinging to the soil and the sprout to shimmer with a shimmering light. The dominant tones of deep brown and black contrast sharply with the vibrant green of the new sprout, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, concentration, and vibrant tension, celebrating the tenacious will of a tiny life to break through the earth.", + "seed": 7385, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_2/index_3962_seed_7385_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07733732433989644, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07733732433989644, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07733732433989644, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up focusing on a new potato sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward at a very slow speed while tracking the sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sprout depicted as a delicate, translucent white stalk with a tender green tip and a slight curl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout push upward, causing tiny cracks to appear in the surrounding dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint ray of overhead light illuminating the sprout tip and causing water droplets to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006432542577385902 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.63143253326416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006432542577385902, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006432542577385902, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11066842824220657, + 0.1018856018781662, + 0.08138162642717361, + 0.0925559476017952, + 0.3469899892807007, + 0.02414909563958645, + 0.02534002624452114, + 0.019614731892943382, + 0.17198148369789124, + 0.025433098897337914 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006432542577385902 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up focusing on a new potato sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward at a very slow speed while tracking the sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sprout depicted as a delicate, translucent white stalk with a tender green tip and a slight curl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout push upward, causing tiny cracks to appear in the surrounding dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint ray of overhead light illuminating the sprout tip and causing water droplets to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31347164511680603 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134716749191284 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31347164511680603, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31347164511680603, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19785571098327637, + 0.0888947993516922, + 0.12609584629535675, + 0.05969502776861191, + 0.1003384068608284, + 0.08335142582654953, + 0.07238078862428665, + 0.1029377207159996, + 0.06719747185707092, + 0.10125284641981125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31347164511680603 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up focusing on a new potato sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward at a very slow speed while tracking the sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sprout depicted as a delicate, translucent white stalk with a tender green tip and a slight curl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout push upward, causing tiny cracks to appear in the surrounding dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint ray of overhead light illuminating the sprout tip and causing water droplets to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006740807089954615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006740570068359 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006740807089954615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006740807089954615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14097990095615387, + 0.07281672209501266, + 0.05071946978569031, + 0.054652947932481766, + 0.23882579803466797, + 0.06682316958904266, + 0.02731293998658657, + 0.09138736128807068, + 0.2160685956478119, + 0.040413059294223785 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006740807089954615 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up focusing on a new potato sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward at a very slow speed while tracking the sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sprout depicted as a delicate, translucent white stalk with a tender green tip and a slight curl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout push upward, causing tiny cracks to appear in the surrounding dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint ray of overhead light illuminating the sprout tip and causing water droplets to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369763866066933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086976051330566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369763866066933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369763866066933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1256464421749115, + 0.08324770629405975, + 0.09126189351081848, + 0.08249858766794205, + 0.13911788165569305, + 0.07960201054811478, + 0.13538731634616852, + 0.11987816542387009, + 0.09504655003547668, + 0.048313457518815994 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369763866066933 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up focusing on a new potato sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward at a very slow speed while tracking the sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sprout depicted as a delicate, translucent white stalk with a tender green tip and a slight curl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout push upward, causing tiny cracks to appear in the surrounding dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint ray of overhead light illuminating the sprout tip and causing water droplets to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634398825466633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651344060897827 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634398825466633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634398825466633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22338220477104187, + 0.08666219562292099, + 0.03474360704421997, + 0.08341766148805618, + 0.166482612490654, + 0.03163199871778488, + 0.04587293788790703, + 0.06293358653783798, + 0.16471517086029053, + 0.10015801340341568 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634398825466633 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a stunning macro close-up, the camera tilts upward at an incredibly slow speed, closely tracking a new potato sprout as it indomitably rises from the moist, dark brown soil rich in organic matter. This delicate, almost translucent white stalk, with a tender green tip and a slight curl, steadily and slowly pushes upward, pushing away the earth beneath it with a resilient force imbued with life. As it continues to push, tiny cracks appear in the surrounding soil, and small clumps of earth loosen and tumble away, revealing the dark, moist interior. A faint but hopeful ray of overhead light penetrates directly from above, precisely illuminating the tip of the new sprout, giving it an almost luminous quality and causing tiny water droplets clinging to the soil and the sprout to shimmer with a shimmering light. The dominant tones of deep brown and black contrast sharply with the vibrant green of the new sprout, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, concentration, and vibrant tension, celebrating the tenacious will of a tiny life to break through the earth.", + "seed": 7386, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_2/index_3962_seed_7386_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.055125311762094495, + "vlm_logprob": -0.055125311762094495, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.649999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.055125311762094495, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up focusing on a new potato sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward at a very slow speed while tracking the sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sprout depicted as a delicate, translucent white stalk with a tender green tip and a slight curl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout push upward, causing tiny cracks to appear in the surrounding dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint ray of overhead light illuminating the sprout tip and causing water droplets to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0092815812677145 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.384281635284424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0092815812677145, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0092815812677145, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15510469675064087, + 0.029897794127464294, + 0.227094829082489, + 0.051195837557315826, + 0.06746021658182144, + 0.07788694649934769, + 0.1794314831495285, + 0.0382564477622509, + 0.10296419262886047, + 0.07070747017860413 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0092815812677145 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up focusing on a new potato sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward at a very slow speed while tracking the sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sprout depicted as a delicate, translucent white stalk with a tender green tip and a slight curl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout push upward, causing tiny cracks to appear in the surrounding dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint ray of overhead light illuminating the sprout tip and causing water droplets to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12707598507404327 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270759105682373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12707598507404327, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12707598507404327, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15461012721061707, + 0.04053516685962677, + 0.25427040457725525, + 0.05434368923306465, + 0.10961970686912537, + 0.1569015085697174, + 0.14632445573806763, + 0.022495342418551445, + 0.019127218052744865, + 0.04177246242761612 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12707598507404327 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up focusing on a new potato sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward at a very slow speed while tracking the sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sprout depicted as a delicate, translucent white stalk with a tender green tip and a slight curl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout push upward, causing tiny cracks to appear in the surrounding dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint ray of overhead light illuminating the sprout tip and causing water droplets to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005260316655039787 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255260467529297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005260316655039787, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005260316655039787, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11281386762857437, + 0.04643930494785309, + 0.18730081617832184, + 0.07940128445625305, + 0.17269998788833618, + 0.07172386348247528, + 0.14551964402198792, + 0.05062604695558548, + 0.06232241541147232, + 0.07115272432565689 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005260316655039787 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up focusing on a new potato sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward at a very slow speed while tracking the sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sprout depicted as a delicate, translucent white stalk with a tender green tip and a slight curl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout push upward, causing tiny cracks to appear in the surrounding dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint ray of overhead light illuminating the sprout tip and causing water droplets to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033697061240673065 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086971282958984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033697061240673065, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033697061240673065, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05976893752813339, + 0.05860617384314537, + 0.47393831610679626, + 0.0525473989546299, + 0.06771430373191833, + 0.05270509049296379, + 0.09808911383152008, + 0.03804668039083481, + 0.017902294173836708, + 0.080681711435318 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033697061240673065 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up focusing on a new potato sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward at a very slow speed while tracking the sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sprout depicted as a delicate, translucent white stalk with a tender green tip and a slight curl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout push upward, causing tiny cracks to appear in the surrounding dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint ray of overhead light illuminating the sprout tip and causing water droplets to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10031161457300186 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350311517715454 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10031161457300186, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10031161457300186, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0723198801279068, + 0.038154490292072296, + 0.2539289891719818, + 0.07845765352249146, + 0.13525477051734924, + 0.028697427362203598, + 0.1942955106496811, + 0.03651382401585579, + 0.020705463364720345, + 0.1416720747947693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10031161457300186 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a stunning macro close-up, the camera tilts upward at an incredibly slow speed, closely tracking a new potato sprout as it indomitably rises from the moist, dark brown soil rich in organic matter. This delicate, almost translucent white stalk, with a tender green tip and a slight curl, steadily and slowly pushes upward, pushing away the earth beneath it with a resilient force imbued with life. As it continues to push, tiny cracks appear in the surrounding soil, and small clumps of earth loosen and tumble away, revealing the dark, moist interior. A faint but hopeful ray of overhead light penetrates directly from above, precisely illuminating the tip of the new sprout, giving it an almost luminous quality and causing tiny water droplets clinging to the soil and the sprout to shimmer with a shimmering light. The dominant tones of deep brown and black contrast sharply with the vibrant green of the new sprout, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, concentration, and vibrant tension, celebrating the tenacious will of a tiny life to break through the earth.", + "seed": 7387, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_2/index_3962_seed_7387_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.018583321943879128, + "vlm_logprob": -0.018583321943879128, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.018583321943879128, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up focusing on a new potato sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward at a very slow speed while tracking the sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sprout depicted as a delicate, translucent white stalk with a tender green tip and a slight curl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout push upward, causing tiny cracks to appear in the surrounding dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint ray of overhead light illuminating the sprout tip and causing water droplets to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.025459537282586098 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7754595279693604 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.025459537282586098, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.025459537282586098, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18152756989002228, + 0.1065598800778389, + 0.02661905810236931, + 0.1619160920381546, + 0.17385445535182953, + 0.11514237523078918, + 0.11370321363210678, + 0.03785518929362297, + 0.061437901109457016, + 0.02138427086174488 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.025459537282586098 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up focusing on a new potato sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward at a very slow speed while tracking the sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sprout depicted as a delicate, translucent white stalk with a tender green tip and a slight curl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout push upward, causing tiny cracks to appear in the surrounding dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint ray of overhead light illuminating the sprout tip and causing water droplets to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023318704217672348 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733187675476074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023318704217672348, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023318704217672348, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12056239694356918, + 0.05543787404894829, + 0.05628359317779541, + 0.07389466464519501, + 0.2494506984949112, + 0.11964564770460129, + 0.032118186354637146, + 0.05633256584405899, + 0.07078872621059418, + 0.165485680103302 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023318704217672348 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up focusing on a new potato sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward at a very slow speed while tracking the sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sprout depicted as a delicate, translucent white stalk with a tender green tip and a slight curl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout push upward, causing tiny cracks to appear in the surrounding dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint ray of overhead light illuminating the sprout tip and causing water droplets to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011077570728957653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511077404022217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011077570728957653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011077570728957653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21025912463665009, + 0.05166713520884514, + 0.03211824223399162, + 0.050063006579875946, + 0.2253022938966751, + 0.10920203477144241, + 0.1161702424287796, + 0.08224846422672272, + 0.07355999201536179, + 0.049409423023462296 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011077570728957653 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up focusing on a new potato sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward at a very slow speed while tracking the sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sprout depicted as a delicate, translucent white stalk with a tender green tip and a slight curl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout push upward, causing tiny cracks to appear in the surrounding dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint ray of overhead light illuminating the sprout tip and causing water droplets to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009776449762284756 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634776592254639 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009776449762284756, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009776449762284756, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12384837120771408, + 0.034677654504776, + 0.03436820209026337, + 0.1552971601486206, + 0.20335738360881805, + 0.173531174659729, + 0.09446055442094803, + 0.04392847791314125, + 0.07098834216594696, + 0.06554270535707474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009776449762284756 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up focusing on a new potato sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward at a very slow speed while tracking the sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sprout depicted as a delicate, translucent white stalk with a tender green tip and a slight curl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout push upward, causing tiny cracks to appear in the surrounding dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint ray of overhead light illuminating the sprout tip and causing water droplets to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023284347727894783 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773284435272217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023284347727894783, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023284347727894783, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.39881032705307007, + 0.04298724606633186, + 0.02874884009361267, + 0.03445695713162422, + 0.1545470505952835, + 0.05485488101840019, + 0.0984056144952774, + 0.07091695070266724, + 0.08878277242183685, + 0.027489392086863518 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023284347727894783 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a stunning macro close-up, the camera tilts upward at an incredibly slow speed, closely tracking a new potato sprout as it indomitably rises from the moist, dark brown soil rich in organic matter. This delicate, almost translucent white stalk, with a tender green tip and a slight curl, steadily and slowly pushes upward, pushing away the earth beneath it with a resilient force imbued with life. As it continues to push, tiny cracks appear in the surrounding soil, and small clumps of earth loosen and tumble away, revealing the dark, moist interior. A faint but hopeful ray of overhead light penetrates directly from above, precisely illuminating the tip of the new sprout, giving it an almost luminous quality and causing tiny water droplets clinging to the soil and the sprout to shimmer with a shimmering light. The dominant tones of deep brown and black contrast sharply with the vibrant green of the new sprout, creating an atmosphere of tranquility, concentration, and vibrant tension, celebrating the tenacious will of a tiny life to break through the earth.", + "seed": 7388, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_2/index_3962_seed_7388_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.11568972021341324, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11568972021341324, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11568972021341324, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up focusing on a new potato sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward at a very slow speed while tracking the sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sprout depicted as a delicate, translucent white stalk with a tender green tip and a slight curl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout push upward, causing tiny cracks to appear in the surrounding dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint ray of overhead light illuminating the sprout tip and causing water droplets to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009242014959454536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.009242057800293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009242014959454536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009242014959454536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19774721562862396, + 0.04365498945116997, + 0.10231032222509384, + 0.07320036739110947, + 0.0837131068110466, + 0.06757830828428268, + 0.09294891357421875, + 0.10914430022239685, + 0.10004083067178726, + 0.1296616643667221 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009242014959454536 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up focusing on a new potato sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward at a very slow speed while tracking the sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sprout depicted as a delicate, translucent white stalk with a tender green tip and a slight curl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout push upward, causing tiny cracks to appear in the surrounding dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint ray of overhead light illuminating the sprout tip and causing water droplets to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134894371032715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134894371032715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134894371032715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134894371032715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0788365826010704, + 0.03489663451910019, + 0.02304510958492756, + 0.048240646719932556, + 0.04774213582277298, + 0.0910629853606224, + 0.03654784336686134, + 0.22791625559329987, + 0.05055400729179382, + 0.36115777492523193 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134894371032715 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up focusing on a new potato sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward at a very slow speed while tracking the sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sprout depicted as a delicate, translucent white stalk with a tender green tip and a slight curl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout push upward, causing tiny cracks to appear in the surrounding dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint ray of overhead light illuminating the sprout tip and causing water droplets to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011089006438851357 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511088848114014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011089006438851357, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011089006438851357, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.098720021545887, + 0.03995216637849808, + 0.025342391803860664, + 0.055071111768484116, + 0.04873088002204895, + 0.06870087236166, + 0.061218131333589554, + 0.4138224422931671, + 0.04981273040175438, + 0.1386292576789856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011089006438851357 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up focusing on a new potato sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward at a very slow speed while tracking the sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sprout depicted as a delicate, translucent white stalk with a tender green tip and a slight curl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout push upward, causing tiny cracks to appear in the surrounding dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint ray of overhead light illuminating the sprout tip and causing water droplets to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306579753756523 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680657863616943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306579753756523, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306579753756523, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1281251162290573, + 0.06675270199775696, + 0.06948985159397125, + 0.06758127361536026, + 0.062164273113012314, + 0.04323285445570946, + 0.06536583602428436, + 0.1917095184326172, + 0.05443822592496872, + 0.2511403262615204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306579753756523 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up focusing on a new potato sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward at a very slow speed while tracking the sprout?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sprout depicted as a delicate, translucent white stalk with a tender green tip and a slight curl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the sprout push upward, causing tiny cracks to appear in the surrounding dark brown soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a faint ray of overhead light illuminating the sprout tip and causing water droplets to shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20156234502792358 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015624046325684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20156234502792358, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20156234502792358, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14589737355709076, + 0.044731587171554565, + 0.059585969895124435, + 0.04755504056811333, + 0.1407759189605713, + 0.0620308555662632, + 0.034964822232723236, + 0.2753133773803711, + 0.04347093030810356, + 0.14567410945892334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20156234502792358 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_3/index_tensor([5181, 5181])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_3/index_tensor([5181, 5181])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d14e3d0c2439de71c1aaf2d112b7682d0d514f1b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_3/index_tensor([5181, 5181])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "stunning close-up begins from a low angle, the camera slowly and steadily tilting upward. The image first captures a pair of aged hands, deeply wrinkled and tinged with age spots. They tremble slightly as they carefully close and hold a small, slender incense stick. Scarlet sparks burn at the tip, sending wisps of winding, swirling smoke rising. As these hands rise with an extremely slow and solemn rhythm, the camera follows, and the smoke permeates the frame, gradually revealing the face of an elderly man. His eyes are closed, his brow furrowed, and deep wrinkles, like knife-cut lines, crisscross his forehead and around his eyes. His lips are pressed into a sad, resolute line. Every detail betrays unspoken regret. A beam of warm yellow candlelight from the side and front, serving as the sole light source, gently outlines the contours of his face, the trembling back of his hand, and the edge of the curling smoke. Against the deep, blurred dark background (the outline of the mahogany altar of the ancient ancestral hall is faintly visible), a strong contrast of light and dark is formed, sculpting the texture of the skin and every bit of repressed emotion vividly. The entire scene is shrouded in a solemn and dignified atmosphere of classical Chinese aesthetics, full of introspection and painful repentance.", + "seed": 23720, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_3/index_5181_seed_23720_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.02691662311553955, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02691662311553955, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02691662311553955, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pair of aged, wrinkled hands with age spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown trembling slightly while holding a small, slender incense stick with burning scarlet sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt upward from a low angle to reveal the face of an elderly man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single warm yellow candlelight source from the side and front, creating strong light and dark contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, blurred dark setting with a faintly visible outline of a mahogany altar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007372671738266945 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.007372856140137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007372671738266945, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007372671738266945, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2288176417350769, + 0.12295554578304291, + 0.1678585261106491, + 0.16941721737384796, + 0.04610157385468483, + 0.033112868666648865, + 0.04664246365427971, + 0.034314341843128204, + 0.09565486013889313, + 0.055124975740909576 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007372671738266945 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pair of aged, wrinkled hands with age spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown trembling slightly while holding a small, slender incense stick with burning scarlet sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt upward from a low angle to reveal the face of an elderly man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single warm yellow candlelight source from the side and front, creating strong light and dark contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, blurred dark setting with a faintly visible outline of a mahogany altar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029819265007972717 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298192501068115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029819265007972717, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029819265007972717, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.131644144654274, + 0.32615041732788086, + 0.09270195662975311, + 0.07099390774965286, + 0.0631428062915802, + 0.06355228275060654, + 0.04139994829893112, + 0.07695133984088898, + 0.08458811789751053, + 0.048875097185373306 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029819265007972717 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pair of aged, wrinkled hands with age spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown trembling slightly while holding a small, slender incense stick with burning scarlet sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt upward from a low angle to reveal the face of an elderly man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single warm yellow candlelight source from the side and front, creating strong light and dark contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, blurred dark setting with a faintly visible outline of a mahogany altar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004094788804650307 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.50409460067749 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004094788804650307, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004094788804650307, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11240279674530029, + 0.09185890108346939, + 0.09343425184488297, + 0.06787236779928207, + 0.044210076332092285, + 0.07792583853006363, + 0.06585077196359634, + 0.04102860763669014, + 0.20468980073928833, + 0.20072658360004425 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004094788804650307 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pair of aged, wrinkled hands with age spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown trembling slightly while holding a small, slender incense stick with burning scarlet sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt upward from a low angle to reveal the face of an elderly man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single warm yellow candlelight source from the side and front, creating strong light and dark contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, blurred dark setting with a faintly visible outline of a mahogany altar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023291800171136856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773291826248169 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023291800171136856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023291800171136856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09168952703475952, + 0.09080114960670471, + 0.07865632325410843, + 0.05735791474580765, + 0.0399598628282547, + 0.04551300033926964, + 0.07735294848680496, + 0.1880669742822647, + 0.24223561584949493, + 0.08836664259433746 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023291800171136856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pair of aged, wrinkled hands with age spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown trembling slightly while holding a small, slender incense stick with burning scarlet sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt upward from a low angle to reveal the face of an elderly man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single warm yellow candlelight source from the side and front, creating strong light and dark contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, blurred dark setting with a faintly visible outline of a mahogany altar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000458985567093 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.69500470161438 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000458985567093, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000458985567093, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19046805799007416, + 0.07562147080898285, + 0.05879339948296547, + 0.05351700261235237, + 0.03121684491634369, + 0.08431931585073471, + 0.060214199125766754, + 0.07365349680185318, + 0.07637599855661392, + 0.2958202362060547 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000458985567093 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning close-up begins from a low angle, the camera slowly and steadily tilting upward. The image first captures a pair of aged hands, deeply wrinkled and tinged with age spots. They tremble slightly as they carefully close and hold a small, slender incense stick. Scarlet sparks burn at the tip, sending wisps of winding, swirling smoke rising. As these hands rise with an extremely slow and solemn rhythm, the camera follows, and the smoke permeates the frame, gradually revealing the face of an elderly man. His eyes are closed, his brow furrowed, and deep wrinkles, like knife-cut lines, crisscross his forehead and around his eyes. His lips are pressed into a sad, resolute line. Every detail betrays unspoken regret. A beam of warm yellow candlelight from the side and front, serving as the sole light source, gently outlines the contours of his face, the trembling back of his hand, and the edge of the curling smoke. Against the deep, blurred dark background (the outline of the mahogany altar of the ancient ancestral hall is faintly visible), a strong contrast of light and dark is formed, sculpting the texture of the skin and every bit of repressed emotion vividly. The entire scene is shrouded in a solemn and dignified atmosphere of classical Chinese aesthetics, full of introspection and painful repentance.", + "seed": 23721, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_3/index_5181_seed_23721_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.024290565587580203, + "vlm_logprob": -0.024290565587580203, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.824999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.024290565587580203, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pair of aged, wrinkled hands with age spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown trembling slightly while holding a small, slender incense stick with burning scarlet sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt upward from a low angle to reveal the face of an elderly man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single warm yellow candlelight source from the side and front, creating strong light and dark contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, blurred dark setting with a faintly visible outline of a mahogany altar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008988040499389172 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758987903594971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008988040499389172, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008988040499389172, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33979925513267517, + 0.03527211770415306, + 0.13699385523796082, + 0.06503833085298538, + 0.04595642909407616, + 0.046160660684108734, + 0.05210593342781067, + 0.08640027046203613, + 0.04990219697356224, + 0.14237098395824432 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008988040499389172 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pair of aged, wrinkled hands with age spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown trembling slightly while holding a small, slender incense stick with burning scarlet sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt upward from a low angle to reveal the face of an elderly man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single warm yellow candlelight source from the side and front, creating strong light and dark contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, blurred dark setting with a faintly visible outline of a mahogany altar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02982204221189022 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298221111297607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02982204221189022, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02982204221189022, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20881430804729462, + 0.0345158651471138, + 0.10399560630321503, + 0.06466886401176453, + 0.1392471045255661, + 0.08442511409521103, + 0.06201997399330139, + 0.12033192068338394, + 0.07773344218730927, + 0.10424786806106567 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02982204221189022 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pair of aged, wrinkled hands with age spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown trembling slightly while holding a small, slender incense stick with burning scarlet sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt upward from a low angle to reveal the face of an elderly man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single warm yellow candlelight source from the side and front, creating strong light and dark contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, blurred dark setting with a faintly visible outline of a mahogany altar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818625070154667 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018186092376709 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818625070154667, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818625070154667, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08089374750852585, + 0.049233078956604004, + 0.09983287006616592, + 0.10080555826425552, + 0.05086173117160797, + 0.06347784399986267, + 0.04254143312573433, + 0.06801669299602509, + 0.07245264202356339, + 0.37188443541526794 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818625070154667 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pair of aged, wrinkled hands with age spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown trembling slightly while holding a small, slender incense stick with burning scarlet sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt upward from a low angle to reveal the face of an elderly man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single warm yellow candlelight source from the side and front, creating strong light and dark contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, blurred dark setting with a faintly visible outline of a mahogany altar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811738267540932 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881174087524414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811738267540932, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811738267540932, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17522065341472626, + 0.047257233411073685, + 0.2282204031944275, + 0.06641806662082672, + 0.06256504356861115, + 0.05264197662472725, + 0.07737583667039871, + 0.11218972504138947, + 0.04282701760530472, + 0.135283961892128 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811738267540932 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pair of aged, wrinkled hands with age spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown trembling slightly while holding a small, slender incense stick with burning scarlet sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt upward from a low angle to reveal the face of an elderly man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single warm yellow candlelight source from the side and front, creating strong light and dark contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, blurred dark setting with a faintly visible outline of a mahogany altar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026339111849665642 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651339054107666 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026339111849665642, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026339111849665642, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11198549717664719, + 0.1299716830253601, + 0.19145821034908295, + 0.08933043479919434, + 0.056890819221735, + 0.048962727189064026, + 0.05904293432831764, + 0.1106269508600235, + 0.05789858102798462, + 0.14383213222026825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026339111849665642 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning close-up begins from a low angle, the camera slowly and steadily tilting upward. The image first captures a pair of aged hands, deeply wrinkled and tinged with age spots. They tremble slightly as they carefully close and hold a small, slender incense stick. Scarlet sparks burn at the tip, sending wisps of winding, swirling smoke rising. As these hands rise with an extremely slow and solemn rhythm, the camera follows, and the smoke permeates the frame, gradually revealing the face of an elderly man. His eyes are closed, his brow furrowed, and deep wrinkles, like knife-cut lines, crisscross his forehead and around his eyes. His lips are pressed into a sad, resolute line. Every detail betrays unspoken regret. A beam of warm yellow candlelight from the side and front, serving as the sole light source, gently outlines the contours of his face, the trembling back of his hand, and the edge of the curling smoke. Against the deep, blurred dark background (the outline of the mahogany altar of the ancient ancestral hall is faintly visible), a strong contrast of light and dark is formed, sculpting the texture of the skin and every bit of repressed emotion vividly. The entire scene is shrouded in a solemn and dignified atmosphere of classical Chinese aesthetics, full of introspection and painful repentance.", + "seed": 23722, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_3/index_5181_seed_23722_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06939832181669772, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06939832181669772, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06939832181669772, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pair of aged, wrinkled hands with age spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown trembling slightly while holding a small, slender incense stick with burning scarlet sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt upward from a low angle to reveal the face of an elderly man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single warm yellow candlelight source from the side and front, creating strong light and dark contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, blurred dark setting with a faintly visible outline of a mahogany altar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010126405395567417 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63512659072876 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010126405395567417, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010126405395567417, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13354122638702393, + 0.1190490871667862, + 0.10470633208751678, + 0.03477134183049202, + 0.07390978932380676, + 0.31851840019226074, + 0.024767708033323288, + 0.05199284106492996, + 0.03964611142873764, + 0.09909714758396149 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010126405395567417 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pair of aged, wrinkled hands with age spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown trembling slightly while holding a small, slender incense stick with burning scarlet sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt upward from a low angle to reveal the face of an elderly man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single warm yellow candlelight source from the side and front, creating strong light and dark contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, blurred dark setting with a faintly visible outline of a mahogany altar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307207837700844 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168071985244751 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307207837700844, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307207837700844, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09275759756565094, + 0.09407173842191696, + 0.37422072887420654, + 0.04468890652060509, + 0.03645193949341774, + 0.14817866683006287, + 0.03077654168009758, + 0.04667797312140465, + 0.0521496906876564, + 0.08002619445323944 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307207837700844 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pair of aged, wrinkled hands with age spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown trembling slightly while holding a small, slender incense stick with burning scarlet sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt upward from a low angle to reveal the face of an elderly man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single warm yellow candlelight source from the side and front, creating strong light and dark contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, blurred dark setting with a faintly visible outline of a mahogany altar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003191380063071847 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531914710998535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003191380063071847, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003191380063071847, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.216351717710495, + 0.1266709417104721, + 0.05933946371078491, + 0.04180997982621193, + 0.0693637952208519, + 0.20282255113124847, + 0.08742795884609222, + 0.06586714833974838, + 0.044320642948150635, + 0.08602581173181534 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003191380063071847 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pair of aged, wrinkled hands with age spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown trembling slightly while holding a small, slender incense stick with burning scarlet sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt upward from a low angle to reveal the face of an elderly man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single warm yellow candlelight source from the side and front, creating strong light and dark contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, blurred dark setting with a faintly visible outline of a mahogany altar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20158125460147858 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015812397003174 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20158125460147858, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20158125460147858, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1869274079799652, + 0.2311636358499527, + 0.08901170641183853, + 0.032652731984853745, + 0.04791906848549843, + 0.12048687785863876, + 0.03825269266963005, + 0.046420417726039886, + 0.055831748992204666, + 0.15133367478847504 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20158125460147858 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pair of aged, wrinkled hands with age spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown trembling slightly while holding a small, slender incense stick with burning scarlet sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt upward from a low angle to reveal the face of an elderly man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single warm yellow candlelight source from the side and front, creating strong light and dark contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, blurred dark setting with a faintly visible outline of a mahogany altar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890204906463623 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640204906463623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0890204906463623, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0890204906463623, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11938399076461792, + 0.27781781554222107, + 0.06827326118946075, + 0.11678238958120346, + 0.06089901179075241, + 0.11879465728998184, + 0.02423062175512314, + 0.04133734479546547, + 0.04692224785685539, + 0.12555865943431854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0890204906463623 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning close-up begins from a low angle, the camera slowly and steadily tilting upward. The image first captures a pair of aged hands, deeply wrinkled and tinged with age spots. They tremble slightly as they carefully close and hold a small, slender incense stick. Scarlet sparks burn at the tip, sending wisps of winding, swirling smoke rising. As these hands rise with an extremely slow and solemn rhythm, the camera follows, and the smoke permeates the frame, gradually revealing the face of an elderly man. His eyes are closed, his brow furrowed, and deep wrinkles, like knife-cut lines, crisscross his forehead and around his eyes. His lips are pressed into a sad, resolute line. Every detail betrays unspoken regret. A beam of warm yellow candlelight from the side and front, serving as the sole light source, gently outlines the contours of his face, the trembling back of his hand, and the edge of the curling smoke. Against the deep, blurred dark background (the outline of the mahogany altar of the ancient ancestral hall is faintly visible), a strong contrast of light and dark is formed, sculpting the texture of the skin and every bit of repressed emotion vividly. The entire scene is shrouded in a solemn and dignified atmosphere of classical Chinese aesthetics, full of introspection and painful repentance.", + "seed": 23723, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_3/index_5181_seed_23723_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.030885889288038017, + "vlm_logprob": -0.030885889288038017, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.030885889288038017, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pair of aged, wrinkled hands with age spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown trembling slightly while holding a small, slender incense stick with burning scarlet sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt upward from a low angle to reveal the face of an elderly man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single warm yellow candlelight source from the side and front, creating strong light and dark contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, blurred dark setting with a faintly visible outline of a mahogany altar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013042028062045574 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.388041973114014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013042028062045574, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013042028062045574, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20412911474704742, + 0.07568259537220001, + 0.3488093912601471, + 0.048314161598682404, + 0.02755248360335827, + 0.034110989421606064, + 0.07129226624965668, + 0.037562526762485504, + 0.09072336554527283, + 0.06182308495044708 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013042028062045574 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pair of aged, wrinkled hands with age spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown trembling slightly while holding a small, slender incense stick with burning scarlet sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt upward from a low angle to reveal the face of an elderly man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single warm yellow candlelight source from the side and front, creating strong light and dark contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, blurred dark setting with a faintly visible outline of a mahogany altar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812220320105553 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881221771240234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812220320105553, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812220320105553, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1258712112903595, + 0.08532005548477173, + 0.2012939155101776, + 0.08226931095123291, + 0.04216054454445839, + 0.0447397343814373, + 0.21915939450263977, + 0.040618229657411575, + 0.05725625529885292, + 0.1013113483786583 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812220320105553 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pair of aged, wrinkled hands with age spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown trembling slightly while holding a small, slender incense stick with burning scarlet sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt upward from a low angle to reveal the face of an elderly man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single warm yellow candlelight source from the side and front, creating strong light and dark contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, blurred dark setting with a faintly visible outline of a mahogany altar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005254269111901522 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.25525426864624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005254269111901522, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005254269111901522, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21342001855373383, + 0.07935193926095963, + 0.14909884333610535, + 0.046759650111198425, + 0.0487750843167305, + 0.05727238953113556, + 0.1603933572769165, + 0.07108715176582336, + 0.10121404379606247, + 0.0726274624466896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005254269111901522 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pair of aged, wrinkled hands with age spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown trembling slightly while holding a small, slender incense stick with burning scarlet sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt upward from a low angle to reveal the face of an elderly man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single warm yellow candlelight source from the side and front, creating strong light and dark contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, blurred dark setting with a faintly visible outline of a mahogany altar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043074704706668854 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168074607849121 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043074704706668854, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043074704706668854, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1784628927707672, + 0.0685281753540039, + 0.17352205514907837, + 0.03545912727713585, + 0.027111509814858437, + 0.054464057087898254, + 0.26182764768600464, + 0.07976491004228592, + 0.05832373723387718, + 0.06253587454557419 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043074704706668854 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot of a pair of aged, wrinkled hands with age spots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown trembling slightly while holding a small, slender incense stick with burning scarlet sparks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt upward from a low angle to reveal the face of an elderly man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single warm yellow candlelight source from the side and front, creating strong light and dark contrast?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep, blurred dark setting with a faintly visible outline of a mahogany altar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0549362413585186 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929936170578003 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0549362413585186, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0549362413585186, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17045500874519348, + 0.15593492984771729, + 0.17666718363761902, + 0.019307713955640793, + 0.03572671860456467, + 0.08046692609786987, + 0.10353531688451767, + 0.0406363345682621, + 0.10982382297515869, + 0.10744599252939224 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0549362413585186 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_4/index_tensor([73, 73])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_4/index_tensor([73, 73])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..efbcc17f854ccc173193121d3eba9d67ff9a37b2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_4/index_tensor([73, 73])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "steady, documentary-style shot, initially captured in medium shot, shows a massive humpback whale suddenly breaching the cold, deep blue surface of the ocean. Its dark gray skin, scarred by barnacles and the scars of time, gleams wetly in the clear polar air. With unstoppable, raw force, it crashes into the ledge of a towering glacier, its veins of varying shades of blue trembling violently at the impact. Instantly, tons of ice shatter from the main glacier, sending countless glittering shards mingling with churning white water and flung into the air by the immense force. Under the low polar sunlight, the splashing water droplets and ice crystals create fleeting rainbows. As the camera steadily and smoothly pulls back, the frame gradually expands into a magnificent panorama, capturing the entire scene: the massive whale slowly sinking through the churning waters, while the massive glacier, its broken wounds clearly visible, is surrounded by newly formed ice floes. The entire picture is dominated by cold blue and white tones, full of primitive and majestic power, conveying a deep awe of the magnificent power of nature.", + "seed": 27566, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_4/index_73_seed_27566_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0442593976855278, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0442593976855278, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0442593976855278, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale shown breaching the surface of the ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the whale crash into the ledge of a towering glacier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do tons of ice shatter and fling into the air upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily and smoothly pull back to reveal a panorama of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by cold blue and white tones under low polar sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010360860265791416 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7603607177734375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010360860265791416, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010360860265791416, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1633210927248001, + 0.1512167900800705, + 0.1560116410255432, + 0.040851615369319916, + 0.11521992832422256, + 0.08047877997159958, + 0.08500094711780548, + 0.05567887797951698, + 0.050775960087776184, + 0.10144435614347458 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010360860265791416 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale shown breaching the surface of the ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the whale crash into the ledge of a towering glacier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do tons of ice shatter and fling into the air upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily and smoothly pull back to reveal a panorama of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by cold blue and white tones under low polar sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026364773511886597 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651364803314209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026364773511886597, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026364773511886597, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09534085541963577, + 0.07961483299732208, + 0.04688306152820587, + 0.11663810908794403, + 0.05307208001613617, + 0.0866425484418869, + 0.3053387403488159, + 0.044441577047109604, + 0.07077944278717041, + 0.10124872624874115 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026364773511886597 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale shown breaching the surface of the ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the whale crash into the ledge of a towering glacier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do tons of ice shatter and fling into the air upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily and smoothly pull back to reveal a panorama of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by cold blue and white tones under low polar sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002202229807153344 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127202033996582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002202229807153344, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002202229807153344, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17883522808551788, + 0.042255498468875885, + 0.03978756442666054, + 0.1179552897810936, + 0.10040505975484848, + 0.1341681182384491, + 0.21753311157226562, + 0.03303911164402962, + 0.07237102836370468, + 0.0636499896645546 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002202229807153344 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale shown breaching the surface of the ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the whale crash into the ledge of a towering glacier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do tons of ice shatter and fling into the air upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily and smoothly pull back to reveal a panorama of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by cold blue and white tones under low polar sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17987920343875885 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048791885375977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17987920343875885, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17987920343875885, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18714015185832977, + 0.047593262046575546, + 0.04532131925225258, + 0.19383865594863892, + 0.22797514498233795, + 0.08131099492311478, + 0.029765784740447998, + 0.03432989865541458, + 0.035223327577114105, + 0.11750154197216034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17987920343875885 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale shown breaching the surface of the ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the whale crash into the ledge of a towering glacier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do tons of ice shatter and fling into the air upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily and smoothly pull back to reveal a panorama of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by cold blue and white tones under low polar sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024899214040488005 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002490043640137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024899214040488005, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024899214040488005, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1695881485939026, + 0.049207769334316254, + 0.035863444209098816, + 0.05635030195116997, + 0.08884185552597046, + 0.14042110741138458, + 0.07171916961669922, + 0.13296979665756226, + 0.1042928546667099, + 0.1507454514503479 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024899214040488005 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "steady, documentary-style shot, initially captured in medium shot, shows a massive humpback whale suddenly breaching the cold, deep blue surface of the ocean. Its dark gray skin, scarred by barnacles and the scars of time, gleams wetly in the clear polar air. With unstoppable, raw force, it crashes into the ledge of a towering glacier, its veins of varying shades of blue trembling violently at the impact. Instantly, tons of ice shatter from the main glacier, sending countless glittering shards mingling with churning white water and flung into the air by the immense force. Under the low polar sunlight, the splashing water droplets and ice crystals create fleeting rainbows. As the camera steadily and smoothly pulls back, the frame gradually expands into a magnificent panorama, capturing the entire scene: the massive whale slowly sinking through the churning waters, while the massive glacier, its broken wounds clearly visible, is surrounded by newly formed ice floes. The entire picture is dominated by cold blue and white tones, full of primitive and majestic power, conveying a deep awe of the magnificent power of nature.", + "seed": 27567, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_4/index_73_seed_27567_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.19837767435237766, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19837767435237766, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19837767435237766, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale shown breaching the surface of the ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the whale crash into the ledge of a towering glacier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do tons of ice shatter and fling into the air upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily and smoothly pull back to reveal a panorama of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by cold blue and white tones under low polar sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015922073274850845 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2659220695495605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015922073274850845, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015922073274850845, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05643128603696823, + 0.18347010016441345, + 0.08420984447002411, + 0.06508881598711014, + 0.10861694067716599, + 0.03233005851507187, + 0.08787070959806442, + 0.08490767329931259, + 0.14597643911838531, + 0.1510981321334839 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015922073274850845 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale shown breaching the surface of the ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the whale crash into the ledge of a towering glacier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do tons of ice shatter and fling into the air upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily and smoothly pull back to reveal a panorama of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by cold blue and white tones under low polar sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761615037918091 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261615037918091 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761615037918091, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761615037918091, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09993921220302582, + 0.11093919724225998, + 0.0881807804107666, + 0.06456389278173447, + 0.12607039511203766, + 0.046133097261190414, + 0.05061515048146248, + 0.26124146580696106, + 0.1073087751865387, + 0.045008059591054916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761615037918091 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale shown breaching the surface of the ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the whale crash into the ledge of a towering glacier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do tons of ice shatter and fling into the air upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily and smoothly pull back to reveal a panorama of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by cold blue and white tones under low polar sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008648204617202282 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75864839553833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008648204617202282, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008648204617202282, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13763640820980072, + 0.11691688001155853, + 0.06312365084886551, + 0.07055087387561798, + 0.16884922981262207, + 0.039868950843811035, + 0.032299306243658066, + 0.27566298842430115, + 0.07245709002017975, + 0.022634627297520638 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008648204617202282 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale shown breaching the surface of the ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the whale crash into the ledge of a towering glacier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do tons of ice shatter and fling into the air upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily and smoothly pull back to reveal a panorama of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by cold blue and white tones under low polar sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38706108927726746 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370611190795898 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38706108927726746, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38706108927726746, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12411725521087646, + 0.07438170909881592, + 0.04612911492586136, + 0.03668283671140671, + 0.07323704659938812, + 0.07721997797489166, + 0.03788869082927704, + 0.2549291253089905, + 0.20797967910766602, + 0.06743457913398743 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38706108927726746 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale shown breaching the surface of the ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the whale crash into the ledge of a towering glacier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do tons of ice shatter and fling into the air upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily and smoothly pull back to reveal a panorama of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by cold blue and white tones under low polar sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040955008007586 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504095554351807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040955008007586, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040955008007586, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0981200784444809, + 0.0673666000366211, + 0.09434062987565994, + 0.0490538626909256, + 0.1550714075565338, + 0.03478014096617699, + 0.11491774767637253, + 0.27360570430755615, + 0.08606084436178207, + 0.026683015748858452 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040955008007586 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "steady, documentary-style shot, initially captured in medium shot, shows a massive humpback whale suddenly breaching the cold, deep blue surface of the ocean. Its dark gray skin, scarred by barnacles and the scars of time, gleams wetly in the clear polar air. With unstoppable, raw force, it crashes into the ledge of a towering glacier, its veins of varying shades of blue trembling violently at the impact. Instantly, tons of ice shatter from the main glacier, sending countless glittering shards mingling with churning white water and flung into the air by the immense force. Under the low polar sunlight, the splashing water droplets and ice crystals create fleeting rainbows. As the camera steadily and smoothly pulls back, the frame gradually expands into a magnificent panorama, capturing the entire scene: the massive whale slowly sinking through the churning waters, while the massive glacier, its broken wounds clearly visible, is surrounded by newly formed ice floes. The entire picture is dominated by cold blue and white tones, full of primitive and majestic power, conveying a deep awe of the magnificent power of nature.", + "seed": 27568, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_4/index_73_seed_27568_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10083883497864007, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10083883497864007, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10083883497864007, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale shown breaching the surface of the ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the whale crash into the ledge of a towering glacier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do tons of ice shatter and fling into the air upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily and smoothly pull back to reveal a panorama of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by cold blue and white tones under low polar sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018889306113123894 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.143889427185059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018889306113123894, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018889306113123894, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12180294841527939, + 0.12319646775722504, + 0.06693428754806519, + 0.33886897563934326, + 0.050451524555683136, + 0.06529073417186737, + 0.0861096903681755, + 0.02630281262099743, + 0.07600473612546921, + 0.045037832111120224 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018889306113123894 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale shown breaching the surface of the ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the whale crash into the ledge of a towering glacier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do tons of ice shatter and fling into the air upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily and smoothly pull back to reveal a panorama of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by cold blue and white tones under low polar sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04868214204907417 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.04868221282959 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04868214204907417, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04868214204907417, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10949603468179703, + 0.29383647441864014, + 0.10095884650945663, + 0.07077492773532867, + 0.10850391536951065, + 0.07556118816137314, + 0.020590765401721, + 0.07639072835445404, + 0.07497749477624893, + 0.06890971958637238 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04868214204907417 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale shown breaching the surface of the ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the whale crash into the ledge of a towering glacier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do tons of ice shatter and fling into the air upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily and smoothly pull back to reveal a panorama of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by cold blue and white tones under low polar sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00525664072483778 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255256652832031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00525664072483778, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00525664072483778, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07166603207588196, + 0.07141733169555664, + 0.09752079099416733, + 0.5554243922233582, + 0.03602713719010353, + 0.02982749603688717, + 0.020009592175483704, + 0.015077807009220123, + 0.035049840807914734, + 0.06797956675291061 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00525664072483778 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale shown breaching the surface of the ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the whale crash into the ledge of a towering glacier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do tons of ice shatter and fling into the air upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily and smoothly pull back to reveal a panorama of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by cold blue and white tones under low polar sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4288773536682129 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.053877353668213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4288773536682129, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4288773536682129, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07455897331237793, + 0.07495555281639099, + 0.05766396224498749, + 0.2822118103504181, + 0.09459082782268524, + 0.07829907536506653, + 0.09585775434970856, + 0.05312951281666756, + 0.10481228679418564, + 0.08392024785280228 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4288773536682129 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale shown breaching the surface of the ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the whale crash into the ledge of a towering glacier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do tons of ice shatter and fling into the air upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily and smoothly pull back to reveal a panorama of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by cold blue and white tones under low polar sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00248873233795166 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002488613128662 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00248873233795166, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00248873233795166, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20121493935585022, + 0.11225104331970215, + 0.058061812072992325, + 0.0778982862830162, + 0.13299159705638885, + 0.14614596962928772, + 0.0441618449985981, + 0.07296492159366608, + 0.05622154474258423, + 0.09808801114559174 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00248873233795166 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "steady, documentary-style shot, initially captured in medium shot, shows a massive humpback whale suddenly breaching the cold, deep blue surface of the ocean. Its dark gray skin, scarred by barnacles and the scars of time, gleams wetly in the clear polar air. With unstoppable, raw force, it crashes into the ledge of a towering glacier, its veins of varying shades of blue trembling violently at the impact. Instantly, tons of ice shatter from the main glacier, sending countless glittering shards mingling with churning white water and flung into the air by the immense force. Under the low polar sunlight, the splashing water droplets and ice crystals create fleeting rainbows. As the camera steadily and smoothly pulls back, the frame gradually expands into a magnificent panorama, capturing the entire scene: the massive whale slowly sinking through the churning waters, while the massive glacier, its broken wounds clearly visible, is surrounded by newly formed ice floes. The entire picture is dominated by cold blue and white tones, full of primitive and majestic power, conveying a deep awe of the magnificent power of nature.", + "seed": 27569, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_4/index_73_seed_27569_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03177285552956164, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03177285552956164, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03177285552956164, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale shown breaching the surface of the ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the whale crash into the ledge of a towering glacier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do tons of ice shatter and fling into the air upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily and smoothly pull back to reveal a panorama of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by cold blue and white tones under low polar sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009822960011661053 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.759822845458984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009822960011661053, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009822960011661053, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09814143180847168, + 0.04149629548192024, + 0.09457945078611374, + 0.20669588446617126, + 0.16961710155010223, + 0.03088432550430298, + 0.13311882317066193, + 0.061162132769823074, + 0.0355505496263504, + 0.12875396013259888 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009822960011661053 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale shown breaching the surface of the ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the whale crash into the ledge of a towering glacier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do tons of ice shatter and fling into the air upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily and smoothly pull back to reveal a panorama of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by cold blue and white tones under low polar sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029826901853084564 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298268795013428 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029826901853084564, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029826901853084564, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0877504050731659, + 0.07927868515253067, + 0.1598651260137558, + 0.1561519056558609, + 0.05990224704146385, + 0.08217339962720871, + 0.09768570214509964, + 0.061614155769348145, + 0.09119834005832672, + 0.12437998503446579 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029826901853084564 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale shown breaching the surface of the ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the whale crash into the ledge of a towering glacier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do tons of ice shatter and fling into the air upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily and smoothly pull back to reveal a panorama of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by cold blue and white tones under low polar sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002200802555307746 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127200603485107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002200802555307746, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002200802555307746, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06418097019195557, + 0.0182794276624918, + 0.033029112964868546, + 0.36065876483917236, + 0.2521516680717468, + 0.04355624318122864, + 0.04302685335278511, + 0.038069531321525574, + 0.03436923027038574, + 0.11267821490764618 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002200802555307746 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale shown breaching the surface of the ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the whale crash into the ledge of a towering glacier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do tons of ice shatter and fling into the air upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily and smoothly pull back to reveal a panorama of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by cold blue and white tones under low polar sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.112920843064785 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379207611083984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.112920843064785, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.112920843064785, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10342666506767273, + 0.013114400207996368, + 0.021846842020750046, + 0.40175172686576843, + 0.04060307517647743, + 0.02684110216796398, + 0.07282261550426483, + 0.04145168513059616, + 0.15268570184707642, + 0.12545621395111084 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.112920843064785 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a massive humpback whale shown breaching the surface of the ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the whale crash into the ledge of a towering glacier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do tons of ice shatter and fling into the air upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily and smoothly pull back to reveal a panorama of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene dominated by cold blue and white tones under low polar sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004092770162969828 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504092693328857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004092770162969828, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004092770162969828, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14792893826961517, + 0.03762071579694748, + 0.06495075672864914, + 0.0737355500459671, + 0.06960706412792206, + 0.04485690966248512, + 0.05880095437169075, + 0.10463810712099075, + 0.08661732077598572, + 0.3112437129020691 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004092770162969828 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_5/index_tensor([1571, 1571])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_5/index_tensor([1571, 1571])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a11436034942578d270a11621ba112176a94cfb5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_5/index_tensor([1571, 1571])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot glides slowly and deliberately across the deeply shadowed ancient forest floor, exploring the complex world of velvety emerald green moss clinging to gnarled dark roots and decaying chestnut leaves. Faint, dappled dusk light penetrates the dense canopy above, creating a carefully orchestrated black-and-white effect that feels both naturalistic and divine. The camera's steady movement gradually reveals the subject: a massive centipede, its segmented body a stunning blend of polished blood-red chitin and gleaming obsidian black, each plate reflecting the dim light with a glassy sheen. Its countless slender legs hold an unsettling stillness against the damp earth. The creature's head stands on high alert, its powerful blades sharp as surgical steel, glistening as they part slightly, shimmering with a hint of toxic moisture, ready to strike with terrifying imminence. The entire scene is rendered with the hyper-detailed, painterly realism and mythic grandeur of the masterpieces of John William Waterhouse and Wadim Kashin, evoking an atmosphere of primal fear and breathtaking, terrifying beauty.", + "seed": 10550, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_5/index_1571_seed_10550_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.020138086075894533, + "vlm_logprob": -0.020138086075894533, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.020138086075894533, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, positioned near the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate tracking movement across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive centipede with a segmented body visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the centipede's body display a mix of polished blood-red and obsidian black colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's head raised with its mandibles slightly parted and glistening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011813207529485226 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.761813163757324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011813207529485226, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011813207529485226, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05867994576692581, + 0.14771941304206848, + 0.0590316504240036, + 0.27421578764915466, + 0.18198160827159882, + 0.02041856199502945, + 0.011566001921892166, + 0.11126342415809631, + 0.09799820929765701, + 0.03712539002299309 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011813207529485226 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, positioned near the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate tracking movement across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive centipede with a segmented body visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the centipede's body display a mix of polished blood-red and obsidian black colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's head raised with its mandibles slightly parted and glistening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020583592355251312 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955836296081543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020583592355251312, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020583592355251312, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07458402216434479, + 0.05659555271267891, + 0.04363367706537247, + 0.3990113139152527, + 0.14083537459373474, + 0.031124098226428032, + 0.04292647913098335, + 0.06731416285037994, + 0.06940176337957382, + 0.07457353174686432 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020583592355251312 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, positioned near the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate tracking movement across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive centipede with a segmented body visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the centipede's body display a mix of polished blood-red and obsidian black colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's head raised with its mandibles slightly parted and glistening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0008137490367516875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.125813961029053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0008137490367516875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0008137490367516875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03178258240222931, + 0.12029506266117096, + 0.0246351920068264, + 0.2564542889595032, + 0.03249124437570572, + 0.018247665837407112, + 0.013947608880698681, + 0.2450626939535141, + 0.17192795872688293, + 0.08515570312738419 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0008137490367516875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, positioned near the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate tracking movement across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive centipede with a segmented body visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the centipede's body display a mix of polished blood-red and obsidian black colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's head raised with its mandibles slightly parted and glistening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012544653378427029 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387544631958008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012544653378427029, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012544653378427029, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03517412766814232, + 0.15639273822307587, + 0.08088300377130508, + 0.05221574753522873, + 0.16575372219085693, + 0.037593621760606766, + 0.023940468207001686, + 0.10353568941354752, + 0.2469162940979004, + 0.09759453684091568 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012544653378427029 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, positioned near the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate tracking movement across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive centipede with a segmented body visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the centipede's body display a mix of polished blood-red and obsidian black colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's head raised with its mandibles slightly parted and glistening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05493522807955742 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299352169036865 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05493522807955742, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05493522807955742, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05368399992585182, + 0.06368102133274078, + 0.03643958270549774, + 0.05346168577671051, + 0.2212924361228943, + 0.05249617621302605, + 0.02712574601173401, + 0.1578649878501892, + 0.07411348074674606, + 0.2598409056663513 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05493522807955742 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot glides slowly and deliberately across the deeply shadowed ancient forest floor, exploring the complex world of velvety emerald green moss clinging to gnarled dark roots and decaying chestnut leaves. Faint, dappled dusk light penetrates the dense canopy above, creating a carefully orchestrated black-and-white effect that feels both naturalistic and divine. The camera's steady movement gradually reveals the subject: a massive centipede, its segmented body a stunning blend of polished blood-red chitin and gleaming obsidian black, each plate reflecting the dim light with a glassy sheen. Its countless slender legs hold an unsettling stillness against the damp earth. The creature's head stands on high alert, its powerful blades sharp as surgical steel, glistening as they part slightly, shimmering with a hint of toxic moisture, ready to strike with terrifying imminence. The entire scene is rendered with the hyper-detailed, painterly realism and mythic grandeur of the masterpieces of John William Waterhouse and Wadim Kashin, evoking an atmosphere of primal fear and breathtaking, terrifying beauty.", + "seed": 10551, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_5/index_1571_seed_10551_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.051217953965533525, + "vlm_logprob": -0.051217953965533525, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.051217953965533525, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, positioned near the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate tracking movement across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive centipede with a segmented body visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the centipede's body display a mix of polished blood-red and obsidian black colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's head raised with its mandibles slightly parted and glistening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12097983062267303 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2459797859191895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12097983062267303, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12097983062267303, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4499426782131195, + 0.1365051567554474, + 0.04203693941235542, + 0.04570675268769264, + 0.039298295974731445, + 0.08265769481658936, + 0.022663939744234085, + 0.03379043564200401, + 0.11590417474508286, + 0.0314939059317112 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12097983062267303 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, positioned near the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate tracking movement across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive centipede with a segmented body visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the centipede's body display a mix of polished blood-red and obsidian black colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's head raised with its mandibles slightly parted and glistening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10032110661268234 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350321054458618 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10032110661268234, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10032110661268234, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24849306046962738, + 0.11412129551172256, + 0.09567494690418243, + 0.10931108891963959, + 0.0350455604493618, + 0.09130258113145828, + 0.0386325977742672, + 0.0875990018248558, + 0.1084112599492073, + 0.07140861451625824 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10032110661268234 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, positioned near the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate tracking movement across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive centipede with a segmented body visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the centipede's body display a mix of polished blood-red and obsidian black colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's head raised with its mandibles slightly parted and glistening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0008147019543685019 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.125814914703369 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0008147019543685019, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0008147019543685019, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25166064500808716, + 0.11782456189393997, + 0.0447724387049675, + 0.056691769510507584, + 0.04595508053898811, + 0.20906086266040802, + 0.05211354047060013, + 0.12265556305646896, + 0.05762756988406181, + 0.041638001799583435 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0008147019543685019 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, positioned near the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate tracking movement across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive centipede with a segmented body visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the centipede's body display a mix of polished blood-red and obsidian black colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's head raised with its mandibles slightly parted and glistening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007636875845491886 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882637023925781 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007636875845491886, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007636875845491886, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1782749891281128, + 0.15936008095741272, + 0.06330538541078568, + 0.08747749775648117, + 0.06603183597326279, + 0.12291234731674194, + 0.07082660496234894, + 0.12490321695804596, + 0.02948608435690403, + 0.09742198139429092 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007636875845491886 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, positioned near the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate tracking movement across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive centipede with a segmented body visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the centipede's body display a mix of polished blood-red and obsidian black colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's head raised with its mandibles slightly parted and glistening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02633725479245186 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651337146759033 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02633725479245186, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02633725479245186, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25263309478759766, + 0.052950937300920486, + 0.028933169320225716, + 0.03241902217268944, + 0.10107996314764023, + 0.3382132351398468, + 0.032610002905130386, + 0.08471984416246414, + 0.019289959222078323, + 0.057150792330503464 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02633725479245186 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot glides slowly and deliberately across the deeply shadowed ancient forest floor, exploring the complex world of velvety emerald green moss clinging to gnarled dark roots and decaying chestnut leaves. Faint, dappled dusk light penetrates the dense canopy above, creating a carefully orchestrated black-and-white effect that feels both naturalistic and divine. The camera's steady movement gradually reveals the subject: a massive centipede, its segmented body a stunning blend of polished blood-red chitin and gleaming obsidian black, each plate reflecting the dim light with a glassy sheen. Its countless slender legs hold an unsettling stillness against the damp earth. The creature's head stands on high alert, its powerful blades sharp as surgical steel, glistening as they part slightly, shimmering with a hint of toxic moisture, ready to strike with terrifying imminence. The entire scene is rendered with the hyper-detailed, painterly realism and mythic grandeur of the masterpieces of John William Waterhouse and Wadim Kashin, evoking an atmosphere of primal fear and breathtaking, terrifying beauty.", + "seed": 10552, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_5/index_1571_seed_10552_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.029455558443441988, + "vlm_logprob": -0.029455558443441988, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.029455558443441988, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, positioned near the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate tracking movement across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive centipede with a segmented body visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the centipede's body display a mix of polished blood-red and obsidian black colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's head raised with its mandibles slightly parted and glistening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.027861205860972404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7778611183166504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.027861205860972404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.027861205860972404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2464950531721115, + 0.09372454881668091, + 0.10853260010480881, + 0.09075237810611725, + 0.028835393488407135, + 0.20016732811927795, + 0.045016609132289886, + 0.10112513601779938, + 0.04335968941450119, + 0.041991304606199265 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.027861205860972404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, positioned near the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate tracking movement across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive centipede with a segmented body visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the centipede's body display a mix of polished blood-red and obsidian black colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's head raised with its mandibles slightly parted and glistening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038109924644231796 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881100177764893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038109924644231796, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038109924644231796, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.343550443649292, + 0.07853693515062332, + 0.12778206169605255, + 0.048188671469688416, + 0.021604470908641815, + 0.09039793908596039, + 0.06759293377399445, + 0.06246653571724892, + 0.07457571476697922, + 0.08530435711145401 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038109924644231796 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, positioned near the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate tracking movement across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive centipede with a segmented body visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the centipede's body display a mix of polished blood-red and obsidian black colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's head raised with its mandibles slightly parted and glistening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00151305110193789 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.5015130043029785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00151305110193789, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00151305110193789, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08536963909864426, + 0.04967891052365303, + 0.6303057074546814, + 0.06578271090984344, + 0.02546524442732334, + 0.01496035885065794, + 0.03902730718255043, + 0.024614937603473663, + 0.02110418491065502, + 0.04369093105196953 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00151305110193789 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, positioned near the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate tracking movement across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive centipede with a segmented body visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the centipede's body display a mix of polished blood-red and obsidian black colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's head raised with its mandibles slightly parted and glistening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009786129929125309 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634786128997803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009786129929125309, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009786129929125309, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11961311101913452, + 0.07579096406698227, + 0.11107666790485382, + 0.04400499910116196, + 0.08909021317958832, + 0.07506713271141052, + 0.21107032895088196, + 0.055998872965574265, + 0.10981622338294983, + 0.10847153514623642 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009786129929125309 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, positioned near the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate tracking movement across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive centipede with a segmented body visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the centipede's body display a mix of polished blood-red and obsidian black colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's head raised with its mandibles slightly parted and glistening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000748068094254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695007562637329 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000748068094254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000748068094254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0995754525065422, + 0.0759701132774353, + 0.3722997009754181, + 0.12057026475667953, + 0.10684329271316528, + 0.027449199929833412, + 0.0393775999546051, + 0.025944827124476433, + 0.047636728733778, + 0.08433277904987335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000748068094254 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot glides slowly and deliberately across the deeply shadowed ancient forest floor, exploring the complex world of velvety emerald green moss clinging to gnarled dark roots and decaying chestnut leaves. Faint, dappled dusk light penetrates the dense canopy above, creating a carefully orchestrated black-and-white effect that feels both naturalistic and divine. The camera's steady movement gradually reveals the subject: a massive centipede, its segmented body a stunning blend of polished blood-red chitin and gleaming obsidian black, each plate reflecting the dim light with a glassy sheen. Its countless slender legs hold an unsettling stillness against the damp earth. The creature's head stands on high alert, its powerful blades sharp as surgical steel, glistening as they part slightly, shimmering with a hint of toxic moisture, ready to strike with terrifying imminence. The entire scene is rendered with the hyper-detailed, painterly realism and mythic grandeur of the masterpieces of John William Waterhouse and Wadim Kashin, evoking an atmosphere of primal fear and breathtaking, terrifying beauty.", + "seed": 10553, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_5/index_1571_seed_10553_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03101585959084332, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03101585959084332, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03101585959084332, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, positioned near the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate tracking movement across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive centipede with a segmented body visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the centipede's body display a mix of polished blood-red and obsidian black colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's head raised with its mandibles slightly parted and glistening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029117833822965622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.9041178226470947 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029117833822965622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029117833822965622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35721006989479065, + 0.1271929293870926, + 0.09788761287927628, + 0.16624322533607483, + 0.0355568490922451, + 0.04101816937327385, + 0.04944746196269989, + 0.04383007436990738, + 0.0252266563475132, + 0.056386977434158325 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029117833822965622 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, positioned near the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate tracking movement across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive centipede with a segmented body visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the centipede's body display a mix of polished blood-red and obsidian black colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's head raised with its mandibles slightly parted and glistening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496569350361824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299657344818115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496569350361824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496569350361824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19562122225761414, + 0.09381581842899323, + 0.13675229251384735, + 0.11880023777484894, + 0.11447982490062714, + 0.07452388107776642, + 0.09684392809867859, + 0.05450362339615822, + 0.06577049940824509, + 0.048888739198446274 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496569350361824 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, positioned near the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate tracking movement across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive centipede with a segmented body visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the centipede's body display a mix of polished blood-red and obsidian black colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's head raised with its mandibles slightly parted and glistening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013367536012083292 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626336574554443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013367536012083292, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013367536012083292, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13274841010570526, + 0.0679648369550705, + 0.2455928921699524, + 0.05866793915629387, + 0.03110041655600071, + 0.0915960818529129, + 0.05528835579752922, + 0.197734996676445, + 0.05844947323203087, + 0.06085660681128502 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013367536012083292 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, positioned near the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate tracking movement across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive centipede with a segmented body visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the centipede's body display a mix of polished blood-red and obsidian black colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's head raised with its mandibles slightly parted and glistening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076340362429618835 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882634162902832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076340362429618835, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076340362429618835, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21496258676052094, + 0.10350634157657623, + 0.06375772505998611, + 0.15129975974559784, + 0.04926791042089462, + 0.11741131544113159, + 0.04436422884464264, + 0.12470339238643646, + 0.062391284853219986, + 0.06833551824092865 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076340362429618835 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low, positioned near the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate tracking movement across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive centipede with a segmented body visible as the main subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the centipede's body display a mix of polished blood-red and obsidian black colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the centipede's head raised with its mandibles slightly parted and glistening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062024980783462524 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120250701904297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062024980783462524, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062024980783462524, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11553306877613068, + 0.07457397133111954, + 0.08991768211126328, + 0.03745400533080101, + 0.025432854890823364, + 0.04995154216885567, + 0.04403724521398544, + 0.27062010765075684, + 0.20602074265480042, + 0.08645878732204437 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062024980783462524 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_6/index_tensor([1351, 1351])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_6/index_tensor([1351, 1351])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d635b20d27b34df44107ddec121c9c80dad02417 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_6/index_tensor([1351, 1351])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, filmed from a very low angle, focuses on a patch of damp, black earth covered in rotting leaves. The ground suddenly arches upward and cracks violently. Then, with unstoppable force, a human skull, smeared with moist black mud and entangled with tiny plant roots, bursts forth, sending clods of mud and dead leaves scattering in all directions. As the mud-covered skull fully emerges and remains still, its sunken eye sockets empty, only a few yellowed teeth exposed amidst the chaos, the camera begins a steady and smooth pull-back. As the camera pulls back, a wider scene is gradually revealed: a gloomy forest shrouded in hazy moonlight. Tall, twisted trees cast long, dancing shadows, and the ground is littered with more bones and dilapidated tombstones. The cold moonlight is the only light source, which sharply outlines the slippery contours of the skull and forms high-contrast light and shadow on the soil. The main colors of the entire picture are gloomy blue-black and dark brown, creating an extremely tense, thrilling and mysterious atmosphere.", + "seed": 13211, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_6/index_1351_seed_13211_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.01721294680610299, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01721294680610299, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01721294680610299, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up filmed from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a human skull covered in moist black mud and entangled with tiny plant roots burst upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skull shown with empty sunken eye sockets and only a few yellowed teeth exposed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady and smooth pull-back to reveal a wider scene of a gloomy forest with tall twisted trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated primarily by cold moonlight creating high-contrast light and shadow with gloomy blue-black and dark brown colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04480833187699318 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2948083877563477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04480833187699318, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04480833187699318, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.268627405166626, + 0.0788133442401886, + 0.13686802983283997, + 0.14223285019397736, + 0.06855268776416779, + 0.03979719057679176, + 0.02757481299340725, + 0.04499727115035057, + 0.11937054246664047, + 0.0731659084558487 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04480833187699318 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up filmed from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a human skull covered in moist black mud and entangled with tiny plant roots burst upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skull shown with empty sunken eye sockets and only a few yellowed teeth exposed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady and smooth pull-back to reveal a wider scene of a gloomy forest with tall twisted trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated primarily by cold moonlight creating high-contrast light and shadow with gloomy blue-black and dark brown colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020608583465218544 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.89560866355896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020608583465218544, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020608583465218544, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.251547247171402, + 0.11101676523685455, + 0.10262473672628403, + 0.060706522315740585, + 0.09564203768968582, + 0.08238404244184494, + 0.0964709222316742, + 0.05832413211464882, + 0.07636483758687973, + 0.06491874158382416 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020608583465218544 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up filmed from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a human skull covered in moist black mud and entangled with tiny plant roots burst upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skull shown with empty sunken eye sockets and only a few yellowed teeth exposed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady and smooth pull-back to reveal a wider scene of a gloomy forest with tall twisted trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated primarily by cold moonlight creating high-contrast light and shadow with gloomy blue-black and dark brown colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011082993820309639 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511083126068115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011082993820309639, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011082993820309639, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3013860583305359, + 0.08756760507822037, + 0.08237642049789429, + 0.06821392476558685, + 0.11749555170536041, + 0.0725415050983429, + 0.05181625857949257, + 0.06289654970169067, + 0.10381714999675751, + 0.05188894271850586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011082993820309639 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up filmed from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a human skull covered in moist black mud and entangled with tiny plant roots burst upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skull shown with empty sunken eye sockets and only a few yellowed teeth exposed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady and smooth pull-back to reveal a wider scene of a gloomy forest with tall twisted trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated primarily by cold moonlight creating high-contrast light and shadow with gloomy blue-black and dark brown colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007628357969224453 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882628440856934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007628357969224453, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007628357969224453, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25312748551368713, + 0.06773646175861359, + 0.1351265013217926, + 0.09364859759807587, + 0.04655490070581436, + 0.03817661479115486, + 0.05336097255349159, + 0.04500660300254822, + 0.10840432345867157, + 0.158857524394989 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007628357969224453 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up filmed from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a human skull covered in moist black mud and entangled with tiny plant roots burst upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skull shown with empty sunken eye sockets and only a few yellowed teeth exposed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady and smooth pull-back to reveal a wider scene of a gloomy forest with tall twisted trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated primarily by cold moonlight creating high-contrast light and shadow with gloomy blue-black and dark brown colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019364668987691402 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251936435699463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019364668987691402, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019364668987691402, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1427910476922989, + 0.03266642615199089, + 0.06131478399038315, + 0.16808785498142242, + 0.08503946661949158, + 0.06793422251939774, + 0.039409004151821136, + 0.0336359478533268, + 0.29116296768188477, + 0.07795817404985428 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019364668987691402 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, filmed from a very low angle, focuses on a patch of damp, black earth covered in rotting leaves. The ground suddenly arches upward and cracks violently. Then, with unstoppable force, a human skull, smeared with moist black mud and entangled with tiny plant roots, bursts forth, sending clods of mud and dead leaves scattering in all directions. As the mud-covered skull fully emerges and remains still, its sunken eye sockets empty, only a few yellowed teeth exposed amidst the chaos, the camera begins a steady and smooth pull-back. As the camera pulls back, a wider scene is gradually revealed: a gloomy forest shrouded in hazy moonlight. Tall, twisted trees cast long, dancing shadows, and the ground is littered with more bones and dilapidated tombstones. The cold moonlight is the only light source, which sharply outlines the slippery contours of the skull and forms high-contrast light and shadow on the soil. The main colors of the entire picture are gloomy blue-black and dark brown, creating an extremely tense, thrilling and mysterious atmosphere.", + "seed": 13212, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_6/index_1351_seed_13212_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.012248004274442791, + "vlm_logprob": -0.012248004274442791, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.012248004274442791, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up filmed from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a human skull covered in moist black mud and entangled with tiny plant roots burst upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skull shown with empty sunken eye sockets and only a few yellowed teeth exposed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady and smooth pull-back to reveal a wider scene of a gloomy forest with tall twisted trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated primarily by cold moonlight creating high-contrast light and shadow with gloomy blue-black and dark brown colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.027930764481425285 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.777930736541748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.027930764481425285, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.027930764481425285, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14830641448497772, + 0.2449418008327484, + 0.04852171614766121, + 0.08889556676149368, + 0.0476425401866436, + 0.1005871444940567, + 0.03214802220463753, + 0.07538845390081406, + 0.08817547559738159, + 0.12539280951023102 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.027930764481425285 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up filmed from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a human skull covered in moist black mud and entangled with tiny plant roots burst upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skull shown with empty sunken eye sockets and only a few yellowed teeth exposed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady and smooth pull-back to reveal a wider scene of a gloomy forest with tall twisted trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated primarily by cold moonlight creating high-contrast light and shadow with gloomy blue-black and dark brown colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01110397931188345 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511104106903076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01110397931188345, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01110397931188345, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13265912234783173, + 0.5388373732566833, + 0.04202655330300331, + 0.04354095831513405, + 0.03204616159200668, + 0.05492628365755081, + 0.028893033042550087, + 0.018476035445928574, + 0.03140604868531227, + 0.07718852907419205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01110397931188345 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up filmed from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a human skull covered in moist black mud and entangled with tiny plant roots burst upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skull shown with empty sunken eye sockets and only a few yellowed teeth exposed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady and smooth pull-back to reveal a wider scene of a gloomy forest with tall twisted trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated primarily by cold moonlight creating high-contrast light and shadow with gloomy blue-black and dark brown colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008646313101053238 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758646488189697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008646313101053238, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008646313101053238, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14579784870147705, + 0.2884054481983185, + 0.0626458153128624, + 0.09101861715316772, + 0.09260812401771545, + 0.10633134841918945, + 0.053134068846702576, + 0.03316236659884453, + 0.07304294407367706, + 0.05385345220565796 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008646313101053238 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up filmed from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a human skull covered in moist black mud and entangled with tiny plant roots burst upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skull shown with empty sunken eye sockets and only a few yellowed teeth exposed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady and smooth pull-back to reveal a wider scene of a gloomy forest with tall twisted trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated primarily by cold moonlight creating high-contrast light and shadow with gloomy blue-black and dark brown colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011073680594563484 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511073589324951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011073680594563484, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011073680594563484, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03928806260228157, + 0.2230198085308075, + 0.11635706573724747, + 0.0917031317949295, + 0.04874946549534798, + 0.14825387299060822, + 0.04211672022938728, + 0.07615427672863007, + 0.08242534846067429, + 0.13193224370479584 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011073680594563484 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up filmed from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a human skull covered in moist black mud and entangled with tiny plant roots burst upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skull shown with empty sunken eye sockets and only a few yellowed teeth exposed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady and smooth pull-back to reveal a wider scene of a gloomy forest with tall twisted trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated primarily by cold moonlight creating high-contrast light and shadow with gloomy blue-black and dark brown colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024852838832885027 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002485275268555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024852838832885027, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024852838832885027, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1767663061618805, + 0.07477381080389023, + 0.05563727766275406, + 0.06138823553919792, + 0.06003894284367561, + 0.0770503506064415, + 0.061910971999168396, + 0.2252327799797058, + 0.049915384501218796, + 0.1572858989238739 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024852838832885027 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, filmed from a very low angle, focuses on a patch of damp, black earth covered in rotting leaves. The ground suddenly arches upward and cracks violently. Then, with unstoppable force, a human skull, smeared with moist black mud and entangled with tiny plant roots, bursts forth, sending clods of mud and dead leaves scattering in all directions. As the mud-covered skull fully emerges and remains still, its sunken eye sockets empty, only a few yellowed teeth exposed amidst the chaos, the camera begins a steady and smooth pull-back. As the camera pulls back, a wider scene is gradually revealed: a gloomy forest shrouded in hazy moonlight. Tall, twisted trees cast long, dancing shadows, and the ground is littered with more bones and dilapidated tombstones. The cold moonlight is the only light source, which sharply outlines the slippery contours of the skull and forms high-contrast light and shadow on the soil. The main colors of the entire picture are gloomy blue-black and dark brown, creating an extremely tense, thrilling and mysterious atmosphere.", + "seed": 13213, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_6/index_1351_seed_13213_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.02730615548789501, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02730615548789501, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02730615548789501, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up filmed from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a human skull covered in moist black mud and entangled with tiny plant roots burst upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skull shown with empty sunken eye sockets and only a few yellowed teeth exposed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady and smooth pull-back to reveal a wider scene of a gloomy forest with tall twisted trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated primarily by cold moonlight creating high-contrast light and shadow with gloomy blue-black and dark brown colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09350721538066864 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4685072898864746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09350721538066864, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09350721538066864, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3397812247276306, + 0.38296836614608765, + 0.03173523768782616, + 0.05674608796834946, + 0.05064583197236061, + 0.030925534665584564, + 0.06060682237148285, + 0.02344316616654396, + 0.01186166238039732, + 0.01128602959215641 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09350721538066864 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up filmed from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a human skull covered in moist black mud and entangled with tiny plant roots burst upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skull shown with empty sunken eye sockets and only a few yellowed teeth exposed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady and smooth pull-back to reveal a wider scene of a gloomy forest with tall twisted trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated primarily by cold moonlight creating high-contrast light and shadow with gloomy blue-black and dark brown colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0182130578905344 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018213272094727 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0182130578905344, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0182130578905344, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2773091197013855, + 0.2834495007991791, + 0.046277496963739395, + 0.05651877075433731, + 0.09674184024333954, + 0.0712304413318634, + 0.0681961253285408, + 0.020715264603495598, + 0.04495026543736458, + 0.034611210227012634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0182130578905344 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up filmed from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a human skull covered in moist black mud and entangled with tiny plant roots burst upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skull shown with empty sunken eye sockets and only a few yellowed teeth exposed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady and smooth pull-back to reveal a wider scene of a gloomy forest with tall twisted trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated primarily by cold moonlight creating high-contrast light and shadow with gloomy blue-black and dark brown colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012545006349682808 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387545108795166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012545006349682808, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012545006349682808, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1450411081314087, + 0.4028608798980713, + 0.05994535982608795, + 0.057764001190662384, + 0.03643972426652908, + 0.06343921273946762, + 0.0774088129401207, + 0.05643855780363083, + 0.06758039444684982, + 0.03308183327317238 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012545006349682808 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up filmed from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a human skull covered in moist black mud and entangled with tiny plant roots burst upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skull shown with empty sunken eye sockets and only a few yellowed teeth exposed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady and smooth pull-back to reveal a wider scene of a gloomy forest with tall twisted trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated primarily by cold moonlight creating high-contrast light and shadow with gloomy blue-black and dark brown colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978199765086174 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634781837463379 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978199765086174, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978199765086174, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22272150218486786, + 0.29962676763534546, + 0.05933603271842003, + 0.03281005471944809, + 0.040392667055130005, + 0.10586126148700714, + 0.09547057747840881, + 0.07100512832403183, + 0.03372529521584511, + 0.039050739258527756 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978199765086174 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up filmed from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a human skull covered in moist black mud and entangled with tiny plant roots burst upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skull shown with empty sunken eye sockets and only a few yellowed teeth exposed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady and smooth pull-back to reveal a wider scene of a gloomy forest with tall twisted trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated primarily by cold moonlight creating high-contrast light and shadow with gloomy blue-black and dark brown colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024835001677274704 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002483367919922 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024835001677274704, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024835001677274704, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.254031777381897, + 0.1509302705526352, + 0.15292902290821075, + 0.056276578456163406, + 0.11231401562690735, + 0.0529051199555397, + 0.055976029485464096, + 0.04126951843500137, + 0.0597708635032177, + 0.06359684467315674 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024835001677274704 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, filmed from a very low angle, focuses on a patch of damp, black earth covered in rotting leaves. The ground suddenly arches upward and cracks violently. Then, with unstoppable force, a human skull, smeared with moist black mud and entangled with tiny plant roots, bursts forth, sending clods of mud and dead leaves scattering in all directions. As the mud-covered skull fully emerges and remains still, its sunken eye sockets empty, only a few yellowed teeth exposed amidst the chaos, the camera begins a steady and smooth pull-back. As the camera pulls back, a wider scene is gradually revealed: a gloomy forest shrouded in hazy moonlight. Tall, twisted trees cast long, dancing shadows, and the ground is littered with more bones and dilapidated tombstones. The cold moonlight is the only light source, which sharply outlines the slippery contours of the skull and forms high-contrast light and shadow on the soil. The main colors of the entire picture are gloomy blue-black and dark brown, creating an extremely tense, thrilling and mysterious atmosphere.", + "seed": 13214, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_6/index_1351_seed_13214_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.010617645317688584, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010617645317688584, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010617645317688584, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up filmed from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a human skull covered in moist black mud and entangled with tiny plant roots burst upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skull shown with empty sunken eye sockets and only a few yellowed teeth exposed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady and smooth pull-back to reveal a wider scene of a gloomy forest with tall twisted trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated primarily by cold moonlight creating high-contrast light and shadow with gloomy blue-black and dark brown colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.017379140481352806 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.267379283905029 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.017379140481352806, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.017379140481352806, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.49734753370285034, + 0.05013366416096687, + 0.04860097914934158, + 0.06253395229578018, + 0.04528528451919556, + 0.0550357848405838, + 0.11266002058982849, + 0.032835833728313446, + 0.03382772579789162, + 0.06173925846815109 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.017379140481352806 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up filmed from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a human skull covered in moist black mud and entangled with tiny plant roots burst upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skull shown with empty sunken eye sockets and only a few yellowed teeth exposed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady and smooth pull-back to reveal a wider scene of a gloomy forest with tall twisted trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated primarily by cold moonlight creating high-contrast light and shadow with gloomy blue-black and dark brown colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007642199285328388 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826422691345215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007642199285328388, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007642199285328388, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09851648658514023, + 0.12363194674253464, + 0.04026883468031883, + 0.1453087329864502, + 0.046909768134355545, + 0.060283441096544266, + 0.18100015819072723, + 0.07076043635606766, + 0.08054469525814056, + 0.15277545154094696 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007642199285328388 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up filmed from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a human skull covered in moist black mud and entangled with tiny plant roots burst upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skull shown with empty sunken eye sockets and only a few yellowed teeth exposed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady and smooth pull-back to reveal a wider scene of a gloomy forest with tall twisted trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated primarily by cold moonlight creating high-contrast light and shadow with gloomy blue-black and dark brown colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01419729832559824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26419734954834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01419729832559824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01419729832559824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20910502970218658, + 0.07653313130140305, + 0.02001669444143772, + 0.049154169857501984, + 0.023275287821888924, + 0.10496026277542114, + 0.2313537448644638, + 0.07301715016365051, + 0.04874052479863167, + 0.1638440042734146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01419729832559824 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up filmed from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a human skull covered in moist black mud and entangled with tiny plant roots burst upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skull shown with empty sunken eye sockets and only a few yellowed teeth exposed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady and smooth pull-back to reveal a wider scene of a gloomy forest with tall twisted trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated primarily by cold moonlight creating high-contrast light and shadow with gloomy blue-black and dark brown colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012537001632153988 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387537002563477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012537001632153988, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012537001632153988, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.234318345785141, + 0.05239706486463547, + 0.0351884700357914, + 0.1675041913986206, + 0.030810682103037834, + 0.0713457390666008, + 0.2472212165594101, + 0.055216122418642044, + 0.039058901369571686, + 0.06693927198648453 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012537001632153988 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot an extreme close-up filmed from a very low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a human skull covered in moist black mud and entangled with tiny plant roots burst upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the skull shown with empty sunken eye sockets and only a few yellowed teeth exposed?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a steady and smooth pull-back to reveal a wider scene of a gloomy forest with tall twisted trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated primarily by cold moonlight creating high-contrast light and shadow with gloomy blue-black and dark brown colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013325868640094995 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626332759857178 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013325868640094995, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013325868640094995, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18474707007408142, + 0.04735502973198891, + 0.1352703869342804, + 0.1748301237821579, + 0.05009477585554123, + 0.04909633845090866, + 0.07114702463150024, + 0.08361438661813736, + 0.05467143654823303, + 0.14917346835136414 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013325868640094995 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_7/index_tensor([2830, 2830])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_7/index_tensor([2830, 2830])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ffecd8ad2399f873df7a1d7377ec285adc7ea9bc --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_7/index_tensor([2830, 2830])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly and steadily pulls back to reveal a dreamlike scene: Deep within a misty bamboo forest, a woman with nine enormous, fluffy, snow-white fox tails dances gracefully. Her long, raven-black hair, pinned with a simple wooden hairpin, adorns a flowing white silk dress, its hem and wide cuffs swaying like water with her movements. Cool moonlight filters through the gaps in the towering bamboo, casting dappled shadows on her delicate, serene features, illuminating her focused, yet slightly melancholic gaze. Her bare feet, lightly treading the soft moss and fallen leaves, each spin and lift of her arms is fluid and rhythmic, causing the nine fox tails behind her to sway gracefully like clouds of mist. Thousands of fireflies emitting soft green light were attracted by her dance, forming a constantly swirling and flickering halo around her. These flowing light spots were intertwined with the white mist slowly spreading on the ground and the silvery moonlight scattered among the bamboo leaves, creating an extremely tranquil, mysterious and poetic atmosphere full of oriental classical charm.", + "seed": 20826, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_7/index_2830_seed_20826_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06272817179560661, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06272817179560661, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06272817179560661, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily pulling back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a misty bamboo forest with towering bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a flowing white silk dress with nine enormous, fluffy, snow-white fox tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of fireflies emitting soft green light forming a swirling halo around the woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05947450175881386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.059474468231201 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05947450175881386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05947450175881386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08072332292795181, + 0.09001623094081879, + 0.06672757863998413, + 0.06483800709247589, + 0.16353051364421844, + 0.25661396980285645, + 0.035946980118751526, + 0.05904800072312355, + 0.06537465751171112, + 0.11718078702688217 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05947450175881386 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily pulling back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a misty bamboo forest with towering bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a flowing white silk dress with nine enormous, fluffy, snow-white fox tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of fireflies emitting soft green light forming a swirling halo around the woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14280344545841217 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017803430557251 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14280344545841217, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14280344545841217, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07610820233821869, + 0.10577844828367233, + 0.05388261377811432, + 0.07608727365732193, + 0.07765626162290573, + 0.12746994197368622, + 0.0910678580403328, + 0.09358008205890656, + 0.04678747057914734, + 0.2515818774700165 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14280344545841217 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily pulling back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a misty bamboo forest with towering bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a flowing white silk dress with nine enormous, fluffy, snow-white fox tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of fireflies emitting soft green light forming a swirling halo around the woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009784476831555367 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634784698486328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009784476831555367, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009784476831555367, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1899973750114441, + 0.03240269795060158, + 0.04720407351851463, + 0.1320572942495346, + 0.15152733027935028, + 0.18189263343811035, + 0.03016865812242031, + 0.035259027034044266, + 0.08838486671447754, + 0.11110606044530869 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009784476831555367 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily pulling back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a misty bamboo forest with towering bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a flowing white silk dress with nine enormous, fluffy, snow-white fox tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of fireflies emitting soft green light forming a swirling halo around the woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012545948848128319 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387546062469482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012545948848128319, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012545948848128319, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04660719260573387, + 0.39396390318870544, + 0.10205701738595963, + 0.05039678514003754, + 0.042834147810935974, + 0.058550506830215454, + 0.020714791491627693, + 0.17873677611351013, + 0.0592530220746994, + 0.04688583314418793 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012545948848128319 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily pulling back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a misty bamboo forest with towering bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a flowing white silk dress with nine enormous, fluffy, snow-white fox tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of fireflies emitting soft green light forming a swirling halo around the woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08903248608112335 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640324115753174 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08903248608112335, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08903248608112335, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25646695494651794, + 0.12047046422958374, + 0.06730452924966812, + 0.0676053911447525, + 0.03626687824726105, + 0.07095341384410858, + 0.03280278295278549, + 0.06921636313199997, + 0.031850360333919525, + 0.24706284701824188 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08903248608112335 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly and steadily pulls back to reveal a dreamlike scene: Deep within a misty bamboo forest, a woman with nine enormous, fluffy, snow-white fox tails dances gracefully. Her long, raven-black hair, pinned with a simple wooden hairpin, adorns a flowing white silk dress, its hem and wide cuffs swaying like water with her movements. Cool moonlight filters through the gaps in the towering bamboo, casting dappled shadows on her delicate, serene features, illuminating her focused, yet slightly melancholic gaze. Her bare feet, lightly treading the soft moss and fallen leaves, each spin and lift of her arms is fluid and rhythmic, causing the nine fox tails behind her to sway gracefully like clouds of mist. Thousands of fireflies emitting soft green light were attracted by her dance, forming a constantly swirling and flickering halo around her. These flowing light spots were intertwined with the white mist slowly spreading on the ground and the silvery moonlight scattered among the bamboo leaves, creating an extremely tranquil, mysterious and poetic atmosphere full of oriental classical charm.", + "seed": 20827, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_7/index_2830_seed_20827_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.12339040227234363, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12339040227234363, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12339040227234363, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily pulling back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a misty bamboo forest with towering bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a flowing white silk dress with nine enormous, fluffy, snow-white fox tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of fireflies emitting soft green light forming a swirling halo around the woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.13205334544181824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2570533752441406 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.13205334544181824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.13205334544181824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12878020107746124, + 0.08833994716405869, + 0.057058434933423996, + 0.07418760657310486, + 0.054528288543224335, + 0.06698604673147202, + 0.08006331324577332, + 0.20123952627182007, + 0.20334400236606598, + 0.045472651720047 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.13205334544181824 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily pulling back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a misty bamboo forest with towering bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a flowing white silk dress with nine enormous, fluffy, snow-white fox tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of fireflies emitting soft green light forming a swirling halo around the woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31346625089645386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134663105010986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31346625089645386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31346625089645386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12335275113582611, + 0.10820886492729187, + 0.058593302965164185, + 0.07428272813558578, + 0.05150223523378372, + 0.044261228293180466, + 0.16376319527626038, + 0.13700440526008606, + 0.10857103019952774, + 0.1304602473974228 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31346625089645386 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily pulling back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a misty bamboo forest with towering bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a flowing white silk dress with nine enormous, fluffy, snow-white fox tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of fireflies emitting soft green light forming a swirling halo around the woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607024483382702 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141070365905762 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607024483382702, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607024483382702, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11555520445108414, + 0.0353434793651104, + 0.0692286565899849, + 0.033016759902238846, + 0.06540177762508392, + 0.012409168295562267, + 0.10302337259054184, + 0.1610451489686966, + 0.35082900524139404, + 0.05414741486310959 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607024483382702 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily pulling back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a misty bamboo forest with towering bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a flowing white silk dress with nine enormous, fluffy, snow-white fox tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of fireflies emitting soft green light forming a swirling halo around the woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012549009174108505 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387548923492432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012549009174108505, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012549009174108505, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20317445695400238, + 0.11850440502166748, + 0.051657404750585556, + 0.08710388094186783, + 0.0483863539993763, + 0.05598513036966324, + 0.09574908018112183, + 0.2165299952030182, + 0.07721180468797684, + 0.04569748044013977 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012549009174108505 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily pulling back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a misty bamboo forest with towering bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a flowing white silk dress with nine enormous, fluffy, snow-white fox tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of fireflies emitting soft green light forming a swirling halo around the woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14281316101551056 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017813205718994 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14281316101551056, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14281316101551056, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08043680340051651, + 0.05048827454447746, + 0.05382878705859184, + 0.16411270201206207, + 0.06923423707485199, + 0.02688673883676529, + 0.16594818234443665, + 0.21903038024902344, + 0.08563017845153809, + 0.08440370112657547 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14281316101551056 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly and steadily pulls back to reveal a dreamlike scene: Deep within a misty bamboo forest, a woman with nine enormous, fluffy, snow-white fox tails dances gracefully. Her long, raven-black hair, pinned with a simple wooden hairpin, adorns a flowing white silk dress, its hem and wide cuffs swaying like water with her movements. Cool moonlight filters through the gaps in the towering bamboo, casting dappled shadows on her delicate, serene features, illuminating her focused, yet slightly melancholic gaze. Her bare feet, lightly treading the soft moss and fallen leaves, each spin and lift of her arms is fluid and rhythmic, causing the nine fox tails behind her to sway gracefully like clouds of mist. Thousands of fireflies emitting soft green light were attracted by her dance, forming a constantly swirling and flickering halo around her. These flowing light spots were intertwined with the white mist slowly spreading on the ground and the silvery moonlight scattered among the bamboo leaves, creating an extremely tranquil, mysterious and poetic atmosphere full of oriental classical charm.", + "seed": 20828, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_7/index_2830_seed_20828_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.07747422643005848, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07747422643005848, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.874999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07747422643005848, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily pulling back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a misty bamboo forest with towering bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a flowing white silk dress with nine enormous, fluffy, snow-white fox tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of fireflies emitting soft green light forming a swirling halo around the woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12332313507795334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2483232021331787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12332313507795334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12332313507795334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.322689950466156, + 0.09218676388263702, + 0.11596821993589401, + 0.12397550046443939, + 0.05959031730890274, + 0.058944351971149445, + 0.06421814858913422, + 0.030413953587412834, + 0.0596357136964798, + 0.072377048432827 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12332313507795334 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily pulling back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a misty bamboo forest with towering bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a flowing white silk dress with nine enormous, fluffy, snow-white fox tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of fireflies emitting soft green light forming a swirling halo around the woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10034137964248657 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350341320037842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10034137964248657, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10034137964248657, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03759235888719559, + 0.021557435393333435, + 0.03691547363996506, + 0.699414849281311, + 0.06277693808078766, + 0.07082843780517578, + 0.022589655593037605, + 0.021991748362779617, + 0.007189805619418621, + 0.01914330944418907 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10034137964248657 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily pulling back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a misty bamboo forest with towering bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a flowing white silk dress with nine enormous, fluffy, snow-white fox tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of fireflies emitting soft green light forming a swirling halo around the woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016071300953626633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141071319580078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016071300953626633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016071300953626633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08882118761539459, + 0.050376441329717636, + 0.019376572221517563, + 0.5787356495857239, + 0.07406436651945114, + 0.06692050397396088, + 0.07026983052492142, + 0.015413239598274231, + 0.014323236420750618, + 0.021698933094739914 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016071300953626633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily pulling back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a misty bamboo forest with towering bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a flowing white silk dress with nine enormous, fluffy, snow-white fox tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of fireflies emitting soft green light forming a swirling halo around the woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020592933520674706 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955929279327393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020592933520674706, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020592933520674706, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10702796280384064, + 0.08375310152769089, + 0.11140912026166916, + 0.1102447658777237, + 0.11068572103977203, + 0.1227002665400505, + 0.1584801822900772, + 0.046168889850378036, + 0.07679522782564163, + 0.07273479551076889 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020592933520674706 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily pulling back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a misty bamboo forest with towering bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a flowing white silk dress with nine enormous, fluffy, snow-white fox tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of fireflies emitting soft green light forming a swirling halo around the woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12704238295555115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127042293548584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12704238295555115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12704238295555115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0895695686340332, + 0.11619508266448975, + 0.044894296675920486, + 0.15089936554431915, + 0.0544220432639122, + 0.03675059601664543, + 0.2554612457752228, + 0.10142548382282257, + 0.08486780524253845, + 0.065514475107193 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12704238295555115 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly and steadily pulls back to reveal a dreamlike scene: Deep within a misty bamboo forest, a woman with nine enormous, fluffy, snow-white fox tails dances gracefully. Her long, raven-black hair, pinned with a simple wooden hairpin, adorns a flowing white silk dress, its hem and wide cuffs swaying like water with her movements. Cool moonlight filters through the gaps in the towering bamboo, casting dappled shadows on her delicate, serene features, illuminating her focused, yet slightly melancholic gaze. Her bare feet, lightly treading the soft moss and fallen leaves, each spin and lift of her arms is fluid and rhythmic, causing the nine fox tails behind her to sway gracefully like clouds of mist. Thousands of fireflies emitting soft green light were attracted by her dance, forming a constantly swirling and flickering halo around her. These flowing light spots were intertwined with the white mist slowly spreading on the ground and the silvery moonlight scattered among the bamboo leaves, creating an extremely tranquil, mysterious and poetic atmosphere full of oriental classical charm.", + "seed": 20829, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_7/index_2830_seed_20829_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.053641291055828336, + "vlm_logprob": -0.053641291055828336, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.053641291055828336, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily pulling back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a misty bamboo forest with towering bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a flowing white silk dress with nine enormous, fluffy, snow-white fox tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of fireflies emitting soft green light forming a swirling halo around the woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.040361568331718445 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4153616428375244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.040361568331718445, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.040361568331718445, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11017949134111404, + 0.028218571096658707, + 0.015630029141902924, + 0.5941768288612366, + 0.07420510053634644, + 0.02945011667907238, + 0.05860861390829086, + 0.010466938838362694, + 0.06228341534733772, + 0.016780884936451912 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.040361568331718445 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily pulling back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a misty bamboo forest with towering bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a flowing white silk dress with nine enormous, fluffy, snow-white fox tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of fireflies emitting soft green light forming a swirling halo around the woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11294352263212204 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237943410873413 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11294352263212204, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11294352263212204, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13909052312374115, + 0.05223866552114487, + 0.06411323696374893, + 0.34753191471099854, + 0.07387794554233551, + 0.12585030496120453, + 0.044729046523571014, + 0.026778453961014748, + 0.07639139890670776, + 0.0493985079228878 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11294352263212204 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily pulling back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a misty bamboo forest with towering bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a flowing white silk dress with nine enormous, fluffy, snow-white fox tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of fireflies emitting soft green light forming a swirling halo around the woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005951895844191313 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130951881408691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005951895844191313, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005951895844191313, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19110456109046936, + 0.09150273352861404, + 0.0388946533203125, + 0.25449785590171814, + 0.043907180428504944, + 0.1160329133272171, + 0.12351523339748383, + 0.03461171314120293, + 0.06594077497720718, + 0.03999243304133415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005951895844191313 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily pulling back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a misty bamboo forest with towering bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a flowing white silk dress with nine enormous, fluffy, snow-white fox tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of fireflies emitting soft green light forming a swirling halo around the woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008643240667879581 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75864315032959 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008643240667879581, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008643240667879581, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05608152598142624, + 0.08538122475147247, + 0.0376756377518177, + 0.1935926079750061, + 0.07348281145095825, + 0.2707153558731079, + 0.16828297078609467, + 0.016941139474511147, + 0.0666833221912384, + 0.03116350993514061 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008643240667879581 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera slowly and steadily pulling back to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a misty bamboo forest with towering bamboo?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a flowing white silk dress with nine enormous, fluffy, snow-white fox tails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are thousands of fireflies emitting soft green light forming a swirling halo around the woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10030622780323029 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350306272506714 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10030622780323029, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10030622780323029, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10877855122089386, + 0.029164303094148636, + 0.04061480239033699, + 0.41428422927856445, + 0.10692380368709564, + 0.1786724328994751, + 0.05254402011632919, + 0.01699475757777691, + 0.03290383145213127, + 0.019119273871183395 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10030622780323029 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_8/index_tensor([5602, 5602])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_8/index_tensor([5602, 5602])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8120e1c70ec6638378be4f1320ac0c713601523e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_8/index_tensor([5602, 5602])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "fluid, low-angle, tracking shot captures a young woman leisurely cycling along a dirt path winding through a dense, lush bamboo forest. Her long, dark hair is tied into a ponytail, swaying gently in the breeze, and a relaxed smile graces her face. Dressed in a simple white cotton T-shirt and light khaki slacks, she rides a vintage mint-green bicycle, pedaling rhythmically as the bike glides smoothly forward. Bright afternoon sunlight filters through the dense foliage between the towering bamboo poles, casting a shifting, dappled, and dancing light on the ground and her body. As she pedals, the swaying shadows of the bamboo, like flowing ink marks, quickly pass over, interweave, and separate across her pristine white T-shirt, her bare arms, and the leaf-covered path beneath her feet, creating a visual effect rich in rhythm and vitality. The tones of the entire scene are warm and vibrant. The dynamic changes of light and shadow combined with the steady riding rhythm create an extremely peaceful, healing and poetic summer afternoon atmosphere.", + "seed": 18217, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_8/index_5602_seed_18217_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.008088258234784007, + "vlm_logprob": -0.008088258234784007, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.008088258234784007, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with long dark hair tied in a ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white cotton T-shirt and light khaki slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding a vintage mint-green bicycle along a dirt path in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle and executing a tracking shot that moves with the cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight filtering through the bamboo to create shifting, dappled light and shadows on the subject and ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008443135768175125 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.883443355560303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008443135768175125, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008443135768175125, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16476142406463623, + 0.10370789468288422, + 0.1537407487630844, + 0.061307165771722794, + 0.10507208853960037, + 0.1362767517566681, + 0.06973917782306671, + 0.03197663649916649, + 0.13583098351955414, + 0.037587158381938934 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008443135768175125 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with long dark hair tied in a ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white cotton T-shirt and light khaki slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding a vintage mint-green bicycle along a dirt path in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle and executing a tracking shot that moves with the cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight filtering through the bamboo to create shifting, dappled light and shadows on the subject and ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016079042106866837 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141078948974609 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016079042106866837, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016079042106866837, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1420152336359024, + 0.06758737564086914, + 0.10979795455932617, + 0.037860121577978134, + 0.12336087226867676, + 0.2597251534461975, + 0.060582634061574936, + 0.05712471529841423, + 0.10882283002138138, + 0.03312305733561516 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016079042106866837 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with long dark hair tied in a ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white cotton T-shirt and light khaki slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding a vintage mint-green bicycle along a dirt path in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle and executing a tracking shot that moves with the cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight filtering through the bamboo to create shifting, dappled light and shadows on the subject and ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031914988067001104 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531914710998535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031914988067001104, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031914988067001104, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09941509366035461, + 0.06796009838581085, + 0.06395004689693451, + 0.03303292766213417, + 0.022640811279416084, + 0.6083534359931946, + 0.02668551355600357, + 0.023493757471442223, + 0.03690561652183533, + 0.017562737688422203 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031914988067001104 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with long dark hair tied in a ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white cotton T-shirt and light khaki slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding a vintage mint-green bicycle along a dirt path in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle and executing a tracking shot that moves with the cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight filtering through the bamboo to create shifting, dappled light and shadows on the subject and ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008636031299829483 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758635997772217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008636031299829483, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008636031299829483, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04494971036911011, + 0.046406131237745285, + 0.08569502830505371, + 0.023158961907029152, + 0.01609214022755623, + 0.6532796621322632, + 0.012554188258945942, + 0.026223229244351387, + 0.06765281409025192, + 0.02398807182908058 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008636031299829483 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with long dark hair tied in a ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white cotton T-shirt and light khaki slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding a vintage mint-green bicycle along a dirt path in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle and executing a tracking shot that moves with the cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight filtering through the bamboo to create shifting, dappled light and shadows on the subject and ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00409158319234848 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504091739654541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00409158319234848, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00409158319234848, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04351770877838135, + 0.031036071479320526, + 0.7828441858291626, + 0.01205881591886282, + 0.009285914711654186, + 0.025190262123942375, + 0.015508527867496014, + 0.008012956008315086, + 0.05286482349038124, + 0.019680719822645187 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00409158319234848 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "fluid, low-angle, tracking shot captures a young woman leisurely cycling along a dirt path winding through a dense, lush bamboo forest. Her long, dark hair is tied into a ponytail, swaying gently in the breeze, and a relaxed smile graces her face. Dressed in a simple white cotton T-shirt and light khaki slacks, she rides a vintage mint-green bicycle, pedaling rhythmically as the bike glides smoothly forward. Bright afternoon sunlight filters through the dense foliage between the towering bamboo poles, casting a shifting, dappled, and dancing light on the ground and her body. As she pedals, the swaying shadows of the bamboo, like flowing ink marks, quickly pass over, interweave, and separate across her pristine white T-shirt, her bare arms, and the leaf-covered path beneath her feet, creating a visual effect rich in rhythm and vitality. The tones of the entire scene are warm and vibrant. The dynamic changes of light and shadow combined with the steady riding rhythm create an extremely peaceful, healing and poetic summer afternoon atmosphere.", + "seed": 18218, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_8/index_5602_seed_18218_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.007455583196133375, + "vlm_logprob": -0.007455583196133375, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.007455583196133375, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with long dark hair tied in a ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white cotton T-shirt and light khaki slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding a vintage mint-green bicycle along a dirt path in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle and executing a tracking shot that moves with the cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight filtering through the bamboo to create shifting, dappled light and shadows on the subject and ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009276502765715122 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.759276390075684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009276502765715122, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009276502765715122, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16574737429618835, + 0.060227178037166595, + 0.15627354383468628, + 0.1973404735326767, + 0.05462472140789032, + 0.05313216149806976, + 0.08460889011621475, + 0.05423196405172348, + 0.1016436293721199, + 0.07217008620500565 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009276502765715122 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with long dark hair tied in a ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white cotton T-shirt and light khaki slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding a vintage mint-green bicycle along a dirt path in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle and executing a tracking shot that moves with the cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight filtering through the bamboo to create shifting, dappled light and shadows on the subject and ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01254818495362997 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387547969818115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01254818495362997, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01254818495362997, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23612472414970398, + 0.06542816758155823, + 0.09414918720722198, + 0.049853142350912094, + 0.16492891311645508, + 0.11486773192882538, + 0.07757474482059479, + 0.046569135040044785, + 0.07337340712547302, + 0.07713086158037186 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01254818495362997 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with long dark hair tied in a ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white cotton T-shirt and light khaki slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding a vintage mint-green bicycle along a dirt path in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle and executing a tracking shot that moves with the cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight filtering through the bamboo to create shifting, dappled light and shadows on the subject and ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00248659192584455 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002486705780029 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00248659192584455, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00248659192584455, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28227636218070984, + 0.06021236628293991, + 0.08114685863256454, + 0.033556561917066574, + 0.03641090169548988, + 0.08277706056833267, + 0.08561208099126816, + 0.05936849117279053, + 0.20564237236976624, + 0.07299690693616867 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00248659192584455 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with long dark hair tied in a ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white cotton T-shirt and light khaki slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding a vintage mint-green bicycle along a dirt path in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle and executing a tracking shot that moves with the cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight filtering through the bamboo to create shifting, dappled light and shadows on the subject and ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009777157567441463 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634777069091797 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009777157567441463, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009777157567441463, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2812125086784363, + 0.0635952278971672, + 0.09571946412324905, + 0.06639781594276428, + 0.05222252011299133, + 0.12106587737798691, + 0.043042946606874466, + 0.06493960320949554, + 0.16813220083713531, + 0.043671898543834686 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009777157567441463 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with long dark hair tied in a ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white cotton T-shirt and light khaki slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding a vintage mint-green bicycle along a dirt path in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle and executing a tracking shot that moves with the cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight filtering through the bamboo to create shifting, dappled light and shadows on the subject and ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031894787680357695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753189563751221 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031894787680357695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031894787680357695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1739986538887024, + 0.05203402414917946, + 0.08861743658781052, + 0.0324581079185009, + 0.04075882211327553, + 0.05476496368646622, + 0.038858458399772644, + 0.08067511767148972, + 0.3752668499946594, + 0.0625675618648529 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031894787680357695 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "fluid, low-angle, tracking shot captures a young woman leisurely cycling along a dirt path winding through a dense, lush bamboo forest. Her long, dark hair is tied into a ponytail, swaying gently in the breeze, and a relaxed smile graces her face. Dressed in a simple white cotton T-shirt and light khaki slacks, she rides a vintage mint-green bicycle, pedaling rhythmically as the bike glides smoothly forward. Bright afternoon sunlight filters through the dense foliage between the towering bamboo poles, casting a shifting, dappled, and dancing light on the ground and her body. As she pedals, the swaying shadows of the bamboo, like flowing ink marks, quickly pass over, interweave, and separate across her pristine white T-shirt, her bare arms, and the leaf-covered path beneath her feet, creating a visual effect rich in rhythm and vitality. The tones of the entire scene are warm and vibrant. The dynamic changes of light and shadow combined with the steady riding rhythm create an extremely peaceful, healing and poetic summer afternoon atmosphere.", + "seed": 18219, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_8/index_5602_seed_18219_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.009840391157194973, + "vlm_logprob": -0.009840391157194973, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.009840391157194973, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with long dark hair tied in a ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white cotton T-shirt and light khaki slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding a vintage mint-green bicycle along a dirt path in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle and executing a tracking shot that moves with the cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight filtering through the bamboo to create shifting, dappled light and shadows on the subject and ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01882707141339779 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018826961517334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01882707141339779, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01882707141339779, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1991938054561615, + 0.040634240955114365, + 0.06158037483692169, + 0.05781729891896248, + 0.07067367434501648, + 0.07735352218151093, + 0.026395998895168304, + 0.18006275594234467, + 0.21902704238891602, + 0.06726126372814178 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01882707141339779 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with long dark hair tied in a ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white cotton T-shirt and light khaki slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding a vintage mint-green bicycle along a dirt path in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle and executing a tracking shot that moves with the cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight filtering through the bamboo to create shifting, dappled light and shadows on the subject and ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014209521003067493 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264209747314453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014209521003067493, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014209521003067493, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10587774962186813, + 0.326040118932724, + 0.07225663214921951, + 0.04426686465740204, + 0.051644839346408844, + 0.09495905041694641, + 0.037016838788986206, + 0.13406431674957275, + 0.08796976506710052, + 0.04590391740202904 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014209521003067493 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with long dark hair tied in a ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white cotton T-shirt and light khaki slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding a vintage mint-green bicycle along a dirt path in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle and executing a tracking shot that moves with the cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight filtering through the bamboo to create shifting, dappled light and shadows on the subject and ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031929248943924904 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753192901611328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031929248943924904, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031929248943924904, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0747634544968605, + 0.6269209384918213, + 0.06713243573904037, + 0.018288504332304, + 0.039292462170124054, + 0.021825486794114113, + 0.011237440630793571, + 0.03520781919360161, + 0.08561211079359055, + 0.01971925050020218 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031929248943924904 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with long dark hair tied in a ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white cotton T-shirt and light khaki slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding a vintage mint-green bicycle along a dirt path in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle and executing a tracking shot that moves with the cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight filtering through the bamboo to create shifting, dappled light and shadows on the subject and ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009780345484614372 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634780406951904 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009780345484614372, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009780345484614372, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10759548097848892, + 0.38159817457199097, + 0.09435497969388962, + 0.053263962268829346, + 0.03634610399603844, + 0.03414295241236687, + 0.020607566460967064, + 0.10713290423154831, + 0.10341834276914597, + 0.061539530754089355 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009780345484614372 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with long dark hair tied in a ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white cotton T-shirt and light khaki slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding a vintage mint-green bicycle along a dirt path in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle and executing a tracking shot that moves with the cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight filtering through the bamboo to create shifting, dappled light and shadows on the subject and ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003192092990502715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753191947937012 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003192092990502715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003192092990502715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06568068265914917, + 0.06763765215873718, + 0.032742537558078766, + 0.03409717604517937, + 0.022142881527543068, + 0.01886831410229206, + 0.02777898870408535, + 0.11105068773031235, + 0.5500290989875793, + 0.06997189670801163 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003192092990502715 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "fluid, low-angle, tracking shot captures a young woman leisurely cycling along a dirt path winding through a dense, lush bamboo forest. Her long, dark hair is tied into a ponytail, swaying gently in the breeze, and a relaxed smile graces her face. Dressed in a simple white cotton T-shirt and light khaki slacks, she rides a vintage mint-green bicycle, pedaling rhythmically as the bike glides smoothly forward. Bright afternoon sunlight filters through the dense foliage between the towering bamboo poles, casting a shifting, dappled, and dancing light on the ground and her body. As she pedals, the swaying shadows of the bamboo, like flowing ink marks, quickly pass over, interweave, and separate across her pristine white T-shirt, her bare arms, and the leaf-covered path beneath her feet, creating a visual effect rich in rhythm and vitality. The tones of the entire scene are warm and vibrant. The dynamic changes of light and shadow combined with the steady riding rhythm create an extremely peaceful, healing and poetic summer afternoon atmosphere.", + "seed": 18220, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_8/index_5602_seed_18220_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.010201290436089038, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010201290436089038, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010201290436089038, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with long dark hair tied in a ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white cotton T-shirt and light khaki slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding a vintage mint-green bicycle along a dirt path in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle and executing a tracking shot that moves with the cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight filtering through the bamboo to create shifting, dappled light and shadows on the subject and ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018694985657930374 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018694877624512 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018694985657930374, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018694985657930374, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5394772887229919, + 0.026697682216763496, + 0.06431596726179123, + 0.04703746363520622, + 0.029247866943478584, + 0.02623610757291317, + 0.1665562242269516, + 0.04682091251015663, + 0.027591003105044365, + 0.026019567623734474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018694985657930374 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with long dark hair tied in a ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white cotton T-shirt and light khaki slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding a vintage mint-green bicycle along a dirt path in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle and executing a tracking shot that moves with the cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight filtering through the bamboo to create shifting, dappled light and shadows on the subject and ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012548891827464104 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387548923492432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012548891827464104, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012548891827464104, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6069801449775696, + 0.03454969450831413, + 0.07235219329595566, + 0.029568081721663475, + 0.02272108569741249, + 0.055313825607299805, + 0.04848988354206085, + 0.06164390593767166, + 0.023341374471783638, + 0.04503984376788139 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012548891827464104 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with long dark hair tied in a ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white cotton T-shirt and light khaki slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding a vintage mint-green bicycle along a dirt path in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle and executing a tracking shot that moves with the cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight filtering through the bamboo to create shifting, dappled light and shadows on the subject and ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003614442190155387 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.62861442565918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003614442190155387, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003614442190155387, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6017420887947083, + 0.05770277976989746, + 0.07667972147464752, + 0.016555817797780037, + 0.05079123377799988, + 0.04293515905737877, + 0.060726117342710495, + 0.03164606913924217, + 0.03811201453208923, + 0.02310897409915924 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003614442190155387 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with long dark hair tied in a ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white cotton T-shirt and light khaki slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding a vintage mint-green bicycle along a dirt path in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle and executing a tracking shot that moves with the cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight filtering through the bamboo to create shifting, dappled light and shadows on the subject and ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012535353191196918 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387535572052002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012535353191196918, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012535353191196918, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3057440221309662, + 0.02971029467880726, + 0.027869610115885735, + 0.08803018927574158, + 0.01659504510462284, + 0.022030318155884743, + 0.46596235036849976, + 0.013223384507000446, + 0.013683624565601349, + 0.017151150852441788 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012535353191196918 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young woman with long dark hair tied in a ponytail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white cotton T-shirt and light khaki slacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman riding a vintage mint-green bicycle along a dirt path in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low angle and executing a tracking shot that moves with the cyclist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature bright afternoon sunlight filtering through the bamboo to create shifting, dappled light and shadows on the subject and ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003612779313698411 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628612995147705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003612779313698411, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003612779313698411, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42427191138267517, + 0.03291532024741173, + 0.02978336438536644, + 0.1360914260149002, + 0.013220788910984993, + 0.030679844319820404, + 0.21399015188217163, + 0.018855467438697815, + 0.035969339311122894, + 0.06422241777181625 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003612779313698411 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_9/index_tensor([6138, 6138])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_9/index_tensor([6138, 6138])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..77242de55fbdeb7343bd4aaac91e5bc9b7e6fccd --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_9/index_tensor([6138, 6138])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a retro cyberpunk city, a low-angle tracking shot glides steadily along the base of a massive, weathered bronze statue. The entire scene is drenched in a perpetual, shimmering neon rain. Sparkling pink and cyan droplets pierce the dark air and splash onto the damp, black streets, creating a million tiny, fleeting reflections. Suddenly, the camera's steady movement contrasts with a violent event: the pavement at the edge of the statue's base snaps. Cobwebs rip outward with terrifying speed, tearing the ground apart. From these newly formed cracks, a powerful, pulsating blue burst of electrical energy erupts, casting a harsh, cold light that overwhelms the surrounding neon. This powerful blue light pulses with a rhythmic, almost living rhythm, illuminating the grimy, textured surface of the statue's bronze base and the gleaming, rain-slicked streets, creating a dramatic and ominous atmosphere of primal power unleashed at the heart of this decaying metropolis.", + "seed": 11409, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_9/index_6138_seed_11409_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.014599908143281937, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014599908143281937, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014599908143281937, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a retro cyberpunk city with a massive, weathered bronze statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene drenched in shimmering neon rain with pink and cyan droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot gliding along the base of the statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pavement at the statue's base snap and tear apart with cobwebs rippling outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful, pulsating blue burst of electrical energy erupt from the cracks and illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016871025785803795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141870975494385 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016871025785803795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016871025785803795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15413251519203186, + 0.1683279275894165, + 0.13866959512233734, + 0.060982294380664825, + 0.2151414304971695, + 0.06266050040721893, + 0.04051518812775612, + 0.04973499849438667, + 0.06935267895460129, + 0.040482908487319946 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016871025785803795 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a retro cyberpunk city with a massive, weathered bronze statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene drenched in shimmering neon rain with pink and cyan droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot gliding along the base of the statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pavement at the statue's base snap and tear apart with cobwebs rippling outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful, pulsating blue burst of electrical energy erupt from the cracks and illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029823778197169304 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298237800598145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029823778197169304, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029823778197169304, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16891740262508392, + 0.10389620810747147, + 0.24157503247261047, + 0.09201163053512573, + 0.13233233988285065, + 0.052148185670375824, + 0.048983313143253326, + 0.07945720106363297, + 0.03950127586722374, + 0.04117736592888832 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029823778197169304 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a retro cyberpunk city with a massive, weathered bronze statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene drenched in shimmering neon rain with pink and cyan droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot gliding along the base of the statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pavement at the statue's base snap and tear apart with cobwebs rippling outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful, pulsating blue burst of electrical energy erupt from the cracks and illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076261102221906185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882626056671143 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076261102221906185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076261102221906185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1370362639427185, + 0.16840431094169617, + 0.14122821390628815, + 0.1376851350069046, + 0.19305260479450226, + 0.03148156404495239, + 0.051928285509347916, + 0.047898851335048676, + 0.06057315692305565, + 0.030711615458130836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076261102221906185 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a retro cyberpunk city with a massive, weathered bronze statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene drenched in shimmering neon rain with pink and cyan droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot gliding along the base of the statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pavement at the statue's base snap and tear apart with cobwebs rippling outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful, pulsating blue burst of electrical energy erupt from the cracks and illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018183792009949684 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018183708190918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018183792009949684, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018183792009949684, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.053464215248823166, + 0.07532074302434921, + 0.055610354989767075, + 0.07815218716859818, + 0.40239715576171875, + 0.1142682433128357, + 0.1011631116271019, + 0.06605379283428192, + 0.02889130264520645, + 0.024678876623511314 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018183792009949684 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a retro cyberpunk city with a massive, weathered bronze statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene drenched in shimmering neon rain with pink and cyan droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot gliding along the base of the statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pavement at the statue's base snap and tear apart with cobwebs rippling outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful, pulsating blue burst of electrical energy erupt from the cracks and illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0004948345012962818 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.625494956970215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0004948345012962818, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0004948345012962818, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07200872898101807, + 0.11305779218673706, + 0.048761721700429916, + 0.05104091390967369, + 0.28985753655433655, + 0.14321225881576538, + 0.08765954524278641, + 0.03725430741906166, + 0.05100790411233902, + 0.10613930970430374 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0004948345012962818 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a retro cyberpunk city, a low-angle tracking shot glides steadily along the base of a massive, weathered bronze statue. The entire scene is drenched in a perpetual, shimmering neon rain. Sparkling pink and cyan droplets pierce the dark air and splash onto the damp, black streets, creating a million tiny, fleeting reflections. Suddenly, the camera's steady movement contrasts with a violent event: the pavement at the edge of the statue's base snaps. Cobwebs rip outward with terrifying speed, tearing the ground apart. From these newly formed cracks, a powerful, pulsating blue burst of electrical energy erupts, casting a harsh, cold light that overwhelms the surrounding neon. This powerful blue light pulses with a rhythmic, almost living rhythm, illuminating the grimy, textured surface of the statue's bronze base and the gleaming, rain-slicked streets, creating a dramatic and ominous atmosphere of primal power unleashed at the heart of this decaying metropolis.", + "seed": 11410, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_9/index_6138_seed_11410_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.008885713433846832, + "vlm_logprob": -0.008885713433846832, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.008885713433846832, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a retro cyberpunk city with a massive, weathered bronze statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene drenched in shimmering neon rain with pink and cyan droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot gliding along the base of the statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pavement at the statue's base snap and tear apart with cobwebs rippling outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful, pulsating blue burst of electrical energy erupt from the cracks and illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.021125424653291702 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.896125316619873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.021125424653291702, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.021125424653291702, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4287623167037964, + 0.04588184878230095, + 0.06864874809980392, + 0.05782186612486839, + 0.07624351233243942, + 0.06512726843357086, + 0.08685136586427689, + 0.09374126046895981, + 0.021149832755327225, + 0.05577191337943077 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.021125424653291702 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a retro cyberpunk city with a massive, weathered bronze statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene drenched in shimmering neon rain with pink and cyan droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot gliding along the base of the statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pavement at the statue's base snap and tear apart with cobwebs rippling outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful, pulsating blue burst of electrical energy erupt from the cracks and illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004102861508727074 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.50410270690918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004102861508727074, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004102861508727074, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22025364637374878, + 0.07272547483444214, + 0.03652619943022728, + 0.03836097568273544, + 0.0864550992846489, + 0.1646527200937271, + 0.21383315324783325, + 0.06191040575504303, + 0.02953684702515602, + 0.07574549317359924 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004102861508727074 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a retro cyberpunk city with a massive, weathered bronze statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene drenched in shimmering neon rain with pink and cyan droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot gliding along the base of the statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pavement at the statue's base snap and tear apart with cobwebs rippling outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful, pulsating blue burst of electrical energy erupt from the cracks and illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004092058166861534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504092216491699 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004092058166861534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004092058166861534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17784248292446136, + 0.05938710272312164, + 0.07105638086795807, + 0.07695171236991882, + 0.10981155931949615, + 0.09822318702936172, + 0.058426134288311005, + 0.1428527683019638, + 0.11625544726848602, + 0.08919326215982437 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004092058166861534 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a retro cyberpunk city with a massive, weathered bronze statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene drenched in shimmering neon rain with pink and cyan droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot gliding along the base of the statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pavement at the statue's base snap and tear apart with cobwebs rippling outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful, pulsating blue burst of electrical energy erupt from the cracks and illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014189541339874268 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264189720153809 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014189541339874268, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014189541339874268, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08702315390110016, + 0.039059922099113464, + 0.03503275662660599, + 0.04608966037631035, + 0.08635538816452026, + 0.28316494822502136, + 0.1191117912530899, + 0.08107481151819229, + 0.10364707559347153, + 0.11944044381380081 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014189541339874268 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a retro cyberpunk city with a massive, weathered bronze statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene drenched in shimmering neon rain with pink and cyan droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot gliding along the base of the statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pavement at the statue's base snap and tear apart with cobwebs rippling outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful, pulsating blue burst of electrical energy erupt from the cracks and illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.000918681500479579 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.000918865203857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.000918681500479579, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.000918681500479579, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10627003759145737, + 0.05139201879501343, + 0.04313049465417862, + 0.043176885694265366, + 0.1855688989162445, + 0.06532088667154312, + 0.07663886994123459, + 0.0854148119688034, + 0.2514641284942627, + 0.0916229784488678 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.000918681500479579 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a retro cyberpunk city, a low-angle tracking shot glides steadily along the base of a massive, weathered bronze statue. The entire scene is drenched in a perpetual, shimmering neon rain. Sparkling pink and cyan droplets pierce the dark air and splash onto the damp, black streets, creating a million tiny, fleeting reflections. Suddenly, the camera's steady movement contrasts with a violent event: the pavement at the edge of the statue's base snaps. Cobwebs rip outward with terrifying speed, tearing the ground apart. From these newly formed cracks, a powerful, pulsating blue burst of electrical energy erupts, casting a harsh, cold light that overwhelms the surrounding neon. This powerful blue light pulses with a rhythmic, almost living rhythm, illuminating the grimy, textured surface of the statue's bronze base and the gleaming, rain-slicked streets, creating a dramatic and ominous atmosphere of primal power unleashed at the heart of this decaying metropolis.", + "seed": 11411, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_9/index_6138_seed_11411_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.025528286956250666, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025528286956250666, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025528286956250666, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a retro cyberpunk city with a massive, weathered bronze statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene drenched in shimmering neon rain with pink and cyan droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot gliding along the base of the statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pavement at the statue's base snap and tear apart with cobwebs rippling outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful, pulsating blue burst of electrical energy erupt from the cracks and illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05768928304314613 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9326891899108887 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05768928304314613, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05768928304314613, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03771142661571503, + 0.06199628859758377, + 0.11334912478923798, + 0.11437710374593735, + 0.42010897397994995, + 0.05327311530709267, + 0.04552125558257103, + 0.07912091165781021, + 0.016931943595409393, + 0.05760989338159561 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05768928304314613 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a retro cyberpunk city with a massive, weathered bronze statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene drenched in shimmering neon rain with pink and cyan droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot gliding along the base of the statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pavement at the statue's base snap and tear apart with cobwebs rippling outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful, pulsating blue burst of electrical energy erupt from the cracks and illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020602043718099594 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895601987838745 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020602043718099594, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020602043718099594, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08045640587806702, + 0.14806966483592987, + 0.04844396188855171, + 0.0964503288269043, + 0.3395872712135315, + 0.04962197318673134, + 0.03801353648304939, + 0.1029152125120163, + 0.021633954718708992, + 0.07480765879154205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020602043718099594 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a retro cyberpunk city with a massive, weathered bronze statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene drenched in shimmering neon rain with pink and cyan droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot gliding along the base of the statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pavement at the statue's base snap and tear apart with cobwebs rippling outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful, pulsating blue burst of electrical energy erupt from the cracks and illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005253201816231012 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255253314971924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005253201816231012, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005253201816231012, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07021983712911606, + 0.08804241567850113, + 0.05008674040436745, + 0.1123778447508812, + 0.3016582429409027, + 0.07107676565647125, + 0.05426463484764099, + 0.13999620079994202, + 0.026451461017131805, + 0.08582586795091629 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005253201816231012 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a retro cyberpunk city with a massive, weathered bronze statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene drenched in shimmering neon rain with pink and cyan droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot gliding along the base of the statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pavement at the statue's base snap and tear apart with cobwebs rippling outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful, pulsating blue burst of electrical energy erupt from the cracks and illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305460676550865 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680545806884766 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305460676550865, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305460676550865, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0871012881398201, + 0.14399535953998566, + 0.11282292008399963, + 0.05176187679171562, + 0.27266448736190796, + 0.05074752867221832, + 0.05405201017856598, + 0.12243342399597168, + 0.04250609502196312, + 0.061915017664432526 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305460676550865 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a retro cyberpunk city with a massive, weathered bronze statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene drenched in shimmering neon rain with pink and cyan droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot gliding along the base of the statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pavement at the statue's base snap and tear apart with cobwebs rippling outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful, pulsating blue burst of electrical energy erupt from the cracks and illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010422994382679462 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876042366027832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010422994382679462, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010422994382679462, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08484439551830292, + 0.07131906598806381, + 0.06350907683372498, + 0.08080343902111053, + 0.16390205919742584, + 0.06462379544973373, + 0.04406549036502838, + 0.08708599209785461, + 0.03608864173293114, + 0.30375808477401733 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010422994382679462 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a retro cyberpunk city, a low-angle tracking shot glides steadily along the base of a massive, weathered bronze statue. The entire scene is drenched in a perpetual, shimmering neon rain. Sparkling pink and cyan droplets pierce the dark air and splash onto the damp, black streets, creating a million tiny, fleeting reflections. Suddenly, the camera's steady movement contrasts with a violent event: the pavement at the edge of the statue's base snaps. Cobwebs rip outward with terrifying speed, tearing the ground apart. From these newly formed cracks, a powerful, pulsating blue burst of electrical energy erupts, casting a harsh, cold light that overwhelms the surrounding neon. This powerful blue light pulses with a rhythmic, almost living rhythm, illuminating the grimy, textured surface of the statue's bronze base and the gleaming, rain-slicked streets, creating a dramatic and ominous atmosphere of primal power unleashed at the heart of this decaying metropolis.", + "seed": 11412, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000196/group_9/index_6138_seed_11412_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.009067832812434062, + "vlm_logprob": -0.009067832812434062, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.009067832812434062, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a retro cyberpunk city with a massive, weathered bronze statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene drenched in shimmering neon rain with pink and cyan droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot gliding along the base of the statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pavement at the statue's base snap and tear apart with cobwebs rippling outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful, pulsating blue burst of electrical energy erupt from the cracks and illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01861518621444702 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018615245819092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01861518621444702, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01861518621444702, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07791287451982498, + 0.04292525351047516, + 0.11303538084030151, + 0.05171448737382889, + 0.15751676261425018, + 0.08988387137651443, + 0.19485890865325928, + 0.08252914994955063, + 0.0813026949763298, + 0.10832057893276215 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01861518621444702 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a retro cyberpunk city with a massive, weathered bronze statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene drenched in shimmering neon rain with pink and cyan droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot gliding along the base of the statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pavement at the statue's base snap and tear apart with cobwebs rippling outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful, pulsating blue burst of electrical energy erupt from the cracks and illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004104880150407553 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504105091094971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004104880150407553, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004104880150407553, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10932377725839615, + 0.07090088725090027, + 0.13362807035446167, + 0.18700365722179413, + 0.05569937825202942, + 0.061923738569021225, + 0.0849149227142334, + 0.13118630647659302, + 0.04009468853473663, + 0.12532460689544678 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004104880150407553 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a retro cyberpunk city with a massive, weathered bronze statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene drenched in shimmering neon rain with pink and cyan droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot gliding along the base of the statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pavement at the statue's base snap and tear apart with cobwebs rippling outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful, pulsating blue burst of electrical energy erupt from the cracks and illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004092533141374588 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504092693328857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004092533141374588, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004092533141374588, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06404445320367813, + 0.04061161354184151, + 0.254751056432724, + 0.06137845665216446, + 0.13794851303100586, + 0.06664285063743591, + 0.10495408624410629, + 0.04209503158926964, + 0.07143313437700272, + 0.15614081919193268 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004092533141374588 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a retro cyberpunk city with a massive, weathered bronze statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene drenched in shimmering neon rain with pink and cyan droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot gliding along the base of the statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pavement at the statue's base snap and tear apart with cobwebs rippling outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful, pulsating blue burst of electrical energy erupt from the cracks and illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018184611573815346 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018184661865234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018184611573815346, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018184611573815346, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09541308879852295, + 0.05689607188105583, + 0.08290393650531769, + 0.08620189130306244, + 0.1030510812997818, + 0.05519576743245125, + 0.13569772243499756, + 0.16195040941238403, + 0.07797067612409592, + 0.14471937716007233 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018184611573815346 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a retro cyberpunk city with a massive, weathered bronze statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene drenched in shimmering neon rain with pink and cyan droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a low-angle tracking shot gliding along the base of the statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the pavement at the statue's base snap and tear apart with cobwebs rippling outward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a powerful, pulsating blue burst of electrical energy erupt from the cracks and illuminate the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00034195298212580383 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -8.00034236907959 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00034195298212580383, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 8.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00034195298212580383, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06428100168704987, + 0.04043647274374962, + 0.10295314341783524, + 0.06134912744164467, + 0.07105258852243423, + 0.05813745781779289, + 0.1361943483352661, + 0.17673322558403015, + 0.08282583206892014, + 0.2060367614030838 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00034195298212580383 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_0/index_tensor([2555, 2555])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_0/index_tensor([2555, 2555])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0cc14cb91342a8c84f651bf7c40573b71a0304a4 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_0/index_tensor([2555, 2555])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "smooth, low-angle tracking shot gently follows an unexpected moment within a vintage train carriage bathed in the golden afternoon sun. An open, silvery metal precision repair tool box, gently slid from the edge of a dark green velvet seat by the train's gentle jolt. It toppled to the floor with a soft, muffled thud, and the various small tools lining the box—tiny screwdrivers with colorful plastic handles, gleaming tweezers, and a few knurled nuts—clinked and scattered across the dusty, beam-lit wooden floor. The camera panned out to capture a curled-up orange tabby kitten nearby. Startled by the sudden noise, it lifted its furry head, its large, emerald eyes filled with pure curiosity. One of the shiniest chrome screwdrivers rolled directly to the kitten's feet, almost touching its soft, white paw. The kitten cautiously extended one paw, its pad slightly spread, and tentatively, hesitantly reached for the shiny new toy. The entire scene is bathed in a warm, soft glow, with tiny particles floating in the air shimmering in the sunlight, creating a cinematic atmosphere that is tranquil, healing, and filled with accidental warmth.", + "seed": 28027, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_0/index_2555_seed_28027_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04121162099763751, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04121162099763751, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04121162099763751, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vintage train carriage with a dark green velvet seat and a wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a silvery metal precision repair tool box visible, having slid off the seat and toppled to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are small tools including screwdrivers with colorful plastic handles, tweezers, and knurled nuts scattered on the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an orange tabby kitten visible that lifts its head and cautiously reaches for a chrome screwdriver with its paw?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a smooth low-angle tracking shot that pans out to capture the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08928807079792023 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4642879962921143 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08928807079792023, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08928807079792023, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10866566002368927, + 0.05756775662302971, + 0.269706130027771, + 0.35859984159469604, + 0.029657991603016853, + 0.059180326759815216, + 0.02037489041686058, + 0.014313675463199615, + 0.033896554261446, + 0.04803713038563728 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08928807079792023 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vintage train carriage with a dark green velvet seat and a wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a silvery metal precision repair tool box visible, having slid off the seat and toppled to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are small tools including screwdrivers with colorful plastic handles, tweezers, and knurled nuts scattered on the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an orange tabby kitten visible that lifts its head and cautiously reaches for a chrome screwdriver with its paw?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a smooth low-angle tracking shot that pans out to capture the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014199061319231987 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264199256896973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014199061319231987, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014199061319231987, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11163340508937836, + 0.09891868382692337, + 0.1475268453359604, + 0.41768038272857666, + 0.053971175104379654, + 0.04606206342577934, + 0.025279710069298744, + 0.032589156180620193, + 0.02834516204893589, + 0.03799344599246979 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014199061319231987 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vintage train carriage with a dark green velvet seat and a wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a silvery metal precision repair tool box visible, having slid off the seat and toppled to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are small tools including screwdrivers with colorful plastic handles, tweezers, and knurled nuts scattered on the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an orange tabby kitten visible that lifts its head and cautiously reaches for a chrome screwdriver with its paw?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a smooth low-angle tracking shot that pans out to capture the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007629540748894215 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88262939453125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007629540748894215, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007629540748894215, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09731443226337433, + 0.07603801041841507, + 0.05390848219394684, + 0.4640744626522064, + 0.05321277678012848, + 0.07151012122631073, + 0.04579121246933937, + 0.036467380821704865, + 0.03665534034371376, + 0.06502784043550491 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007629540748894215 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vintage train carriage with a dark green velvet seat and a wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a silvery metal precision repair tool box visible, having slid off the seat and toppled to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are small tools including screwdrivers with colorful plastic handles, tweezers, and knurled nuts scattered on the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an orange tabby kitten visible that lifts its head and cautiously reaches for a chrome screwdriver with its paw?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a smooth low-angle tracking shot that pans out to capture the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005943956319242716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130943775177002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005943956319242716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005943956319242716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04291469603776932, + 0.0513896644115448, + 0.14781998097896576, + 0.11494429409503937, + 0.04733597859740257, + 0.23043492436408997, + 0.09130381792783737, + 0.1160186156630516, + 0.05977891385555267, + 0.09805901348590851 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005943956319242716 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vintage train carriage with a dark green velvet seat and a wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a silvery metal precision repair tool box visible, having slid off the seat and toppled to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are small tools including screwdrivers with colorful plastic handles, tweezers, and knurled nuts scattered on the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an orange tabby kitten visible that lifts its head and cautiously reaches for a chrome screwdriver with its paw?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a smooth low-angle tracking shot that pans out to capture the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08899747580289841 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4639973640441895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08899747580289841, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08899747580289841, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09265118837356567, + 0.03184930235147476, + 0.15768542885780334, + 0.37436380982398987, + 0.10240790992975235, + 0.06737542897462845, + 0.051205966621637344, + 0.04646781459450722, + 0.044419411569833755, + 0.03157370910048485 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08899747580289841 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "smooth, low-angle tracking shot gently follows an unexpected moment within a vintage train carriage bathed in the golden afternoon sun. An open, silvery metal precision repair tool box, gently slid from the edge of a dark green velvet seat by the train's gentle jolt. It toppled to the floor with a soft, muffled thud, and the various small tools lining the box—tiny screwdrivers with colorful plastic handles, gleaming tweezers, and a few knurled nuts—clinked and scattered across the dusty, beam-lit wooden floor. The camera panned out to capture a curled-up orange tabby kitten nearby. Startled by the sudden noise, it lifted its furry head, its large, emerald eyes filled with pure curiosity. One of the shiniest chrome screwdrivers rolled directly to the kitten's feet, almost touching its soft, white paw. The kitten cautiously extended one paw, its pad slightly spread, and tentatively, hesitantly reached for the shiny new toy. The entire scene is bathed in a warm, soft glow, with tiny particles floating in the air shimmering in the sunlight, creating a cinematic atmosphere that is tranquil, healing, and filled with accidental warmth.", + "seed": 28028, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_0/index_2555_seed_28028_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0309714381583035, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0309714381583035, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0309714381583035, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vintage train carriage with a dark green velvet seat and a wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a silvery metal precision repair tool box visible, having slid off the seat and toppled to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are small tools including screwdrivers with colorful plastic handles, tweezers, and knurled nuts scattered on the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an orange tabby kitten visible that lifts its head and cautiously reaches for a chrome screwdriver with its paw?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a smooth low-angle tracking shot that pans out to capture the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06253306567668915 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812533140182495 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06253306567668915, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06253306567668915, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20369064807891846, + 0.24019069969654083, + 0.026213547214865685, + 0.11703182011842728, + 0.15725216269493103, + 0.03392746299505234, + 0.025072118267416954, + 0.135387122631073, + 0.028372805565595627, + 0.03286154940724373 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06253306567668915 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vintage train carriage with a dark green velvet seat and a wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a silvery metal precision repair tool box visible, having slid off the seat and toppled to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are small tools including screwdrivers with colorful plastic handles, tweezers, and knurled nuts scattered on the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an orange tabby kitten visible that lifts its head and cautiously reaches for a chrome screwdriver with its paw?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a smooth low-angle tracking shot that pans out to capture the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026355136185884476 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651355028152466 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026355136185884476, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026355136185884476, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16790033876895905, + 0.11875437200069427, + 0.08850135654211044, + 0.11599566042423248, + 0.07576911151409149, + 0.07625892758369446, + 0.045563772320747375, + 0.17713913321495056, + 0.028042061254382133, + 0.10607525706291199 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026355136185884476 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vintage train carriage with a dark green velvet seat and a wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a silvery metal precision repair tool box visible, having slid off the seat and toppled to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are small tools including screwdrivers with colorful plastic handles, tweezers, and knurled nuts scattered on the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an orange tabby kitten visible that lifts its head and cautiously reaches for a chrome screwdriver with its paw?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a smooth low-angle tracking shot that pans out to capture the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005949525628238916 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309494972229 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005949525628238916, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005949525628238916, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04044923931360245, + 0.12179376184940338, + 0.04165668413043022, + 0.10899633169174194, + 0.1043948158621788, + 0.07910587638616562, + 0.04790831729769707, + 0.31478795409202576, + 0.03995179757475853, + 0.1009552925825119 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005949525628238916 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vintage train carriage with a dark green velvet seat and a wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a silvery metal precision repair tool box visible, having slid off the seat and toppled to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are small tools including screwdrivers with colorful plastic handles, tweezers, and knurled nuts scattered on the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an orange tabby kitten visible that lifts its head and cautiously reaches for a chrome screwdriver with its paw?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a smooth low-angle tracking shot that pans out to capture the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026339229196310043 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651339292526245 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026339229196310043, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026339229196310043, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05399920791387558, + 0.06380436569452286, + 0.029542891308665276, + 0.10684957355260849, + 0.15020711719989777, + 0.060116320848464966, + 0.069193996489048, + 0.2214183658361435, + 0.07227829843759537, + 0.17258985340595245 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026339229196310043 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vintage train carriage with a dark green velvet seat and a wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a silvery metal precision repair tool box visible, having slid off the seat and toppled to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are small tools including screwdrivers with colorful plastic handles, tweezers, and knurled nuts scattered on the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an orange tabby kitten visible that lifts its head and cautiously reaches for a chrome screwdriver with its paw?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a smooth low-angle tracking shot that pans out to capture the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368023410439491 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086802005767822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368023410439491, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368023410439491, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28178778290748596, + 0.08523581176996231, + 0.04851943999528885, + 0.08622680604457855, + 0.11559057980775833, + 0.15405914187431335, + 0.05311913043260574, + 0.07771356403827667, + 0.03594732657074928, + 0.06180043891072273 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368023410439491 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "smooth, low-angle tracking shot gently follows an unexpected moment within a vintage train carriage bathed in the golden afternoon sun. An open, silvery metal precision repair tool box, gently slid from the edge of a dark green velvet seat by the train's gentle jolt. It toppled to the floor with a soft, muffled thud, and the various small tools lining the box—tiny screwdrivers with colorful plastic handles, gleaming tweezers, and a few knurled nuts—clinked and scattered across the dusty, beam-lit wooden floor. The camera panned out to capture a curled-up orange tabby kitten nearby. Startled by the sudden noise, it lifted its furry head, its large, emerald eyes filled with pure curiosity. One of the shiniest chrome screwdrivers rolled directly to the kitten's feet, almost touching its soft, white paw. The kitten cautiously extended one paw, its pad slightly spread, and tentatively, hesitantly reached for the shiny new toy. The entire scene is bathed in a warm, soft glow, with tiny particles floating in the air shimmering in the sunlight, creating a cinematic atmosphere that is tranquil, healing, and filled with accidental warmth.", + "seed": 28029, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_0/index_2555_seed_28029_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.022485946863889696, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022485946863889696, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022485946863889696, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vintage train carriage with a dark green velvet seat and a wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a silvery metal precision repair tool box visible, having slid off the seat and toppled to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are small tools including screwdrivers with colorful plastic handles, tweezers, and knurled nuts scattered on the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an orange tabby kitten visible that lifts its head and cautiously reaches for a chrome screwdriver with its paw?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a smooth low-angle tracking shot that pans out to capture the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02359991893172264 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773599863052368 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02359991893172264, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02359991893172264, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2236601710319519, + 0.3067299425601959, + 0.06662076711654663, + 0.0451664999127388, + 0.2048787772655487, + 0.02039816975593567, + 0.036218442022800446, + 0.0254504457116127, + 0.023457808420062065, + 0.0474189929664135 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02359991893172264 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vintage train carriage with a dark green velvet seat and a wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a silvery metal precision repair tool box visible, having slid off the seat and toppled to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are small tools including screwdrivers with colorful plastic handles, tweezers, and knurled nuts scattered on the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an orange tabby kitten visible that lifts its head and cautiously reaches for a chrome screwdriver with its paw?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a smooth low-angle tracking shot that pans out to capture the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978671945631504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634786605834961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978671945631504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978671945631504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17260079085826874, + 0.5353904962539673, + 0.024479759857058525, + 0.06402383744716644, + 0.06277405470609665, + 0.01274503767490387, + 0.01921757124364376, + 0.03658026456832886, + 0.04085518792271614, + 0.03133295103907585 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978671945631504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vintage train carriage with a dark green velvet seat and a wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a silvery metal precision repair tool box visible, having slid off the seat and toppled to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are small tools including screwdrivers with colorful plastic handles, tweezers, and knurled nuts scattered on the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an orange tabby kitten visible that lifts its head and cautiously reaches for a chrome screwdriver with its paw?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a smooth low-angle tracking shot that pans out to capture the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005951540544629097 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130951404571533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005951540544629097, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005951540544629097, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0669846385717392, + 0.3048592805862427, + 0.030333302915096283, + 0.054746437817811966, + 0.08124243468046188, + 0.06444910913705826, + 0.020868666470050812, + 0.018748756498098373, + 0.2892549932003021, + 0.0685124322772026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005951540544629097 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vintage train carriage with a dark green velvet seat and a wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a silvery metal precision repair tool box visible, having slid off the seat and toppled to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are small tools including screwdrivers with colorful plastic handles, tweezers, and knurled nuts scattered on the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an orange tabby kitten visible that lifts its head and cautiously reaches for a chrome screwdriver with its paw?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a smooth low-angle tracking shot that pans out to capture the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011070497334003448 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511070728302002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011070497334003448, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011070497334003448, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10317771881818771, + 0.03960179165005684, + 0.034681085497140884, + 0.030440233647823334, + 0.1245858445763588, + 0.039724308997392654, + 0.021557779982686043, + 0.048130497336387634, + 0.3707624673843384, + 0.1873382329940796 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011070497334003448 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vintage train carriage with a dark green velvet seat and a wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a silvery metal precision repair tool box visible, having slid off the seat and toppled to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are small tools including screwdrivers with colorful plastic handles, tweezers, and knurled nuts scattered on the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an orange tabby kitten visible that lifts its head and cautiously reaches for a chrome screwdriver with its paw?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a smooth low-angle tracking shot that pans out to capture the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062021058052778244 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812021017074585 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062021058052778244, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062021058052778244, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09827938675880432, + 0.11696795374155045, + 0.061775028705596924, + 0.07255397737026215, + 0.1517029106616974, + 0.06154756620526314, + 0.052478987723588943, + 0.07067994773387909, + 0.21152129769325256, + 0.10249291360378265 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062021058052778244 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "smooth, low-angle tracking shot gently follows an unexpected moment within a vintage train carriage bathed in the golden afternoon sun. An open, silvery metal precision repair tool box, gently slid from the edge of a dark green velvet seat by the train's gentle jolt. It toppled to the floor with a soft, muffled thud, and the various small tools lining the box—tiny screwdrivers with colorful plastic handles, gleaming tweezers, and a few knurled nuts—clinked and scattered across the dusty, beam-lit wooden floor. The camera panned out to capture a curled-up orange tabby kitten nearby. Startled by the sudden noise, it lifted its furry head, its large, emerald eyes filled with pure curiosity. One of the shiniest chrome screwdrivers rolled directly to the kitten's feet, almost touching its soft, white paw. The kitten cautiously extended one paw, its pad slightly spread, and tentatively, hesitantly reached for the shiny new toy. The entire scene is bathed in a warm, soft glow, with tiny particles floating in the air shimmering in the sunlight, creating a cinematic atmosphere that is tranquil, healing, and filled with accidental warmth.", + "seed": 28030, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_0/index_2555_seed_28030_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.012559177912771701, + "vlm_logprob": -0.012559177912771701, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.012559177912771701, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vintage train carriage with a dark green velvet seat and a wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a silvery metal precision repair tool box visible, having slid off the seat and toppled to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are small tools including screwdrivers with colorful plastic handles, tweezers, and knurled nuts scattered on the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an orange tabby kitten visible that lifts its head and cautiously reaches for a chrome screwdriver with its paw?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a smooth low-angle tracking shot that pans out to capture the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016459399834275246 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1414594650268555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016459399834275246, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016459399834275246, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14109593629837036, + 0.08525820076465607, + 0.4081695079803467, + 0.06710830330848694, + 0.03321090713143349, + 0.10381513088941574, + 0.03208627551794052, + 0.0614311620593071, + 0.030108369886875153, + 0.03771626204252243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016459399834275246 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vintage train carriage with a dark green velvet seat and a wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a silvery metal precision repair tool box visible, having slid off the seat and toppled to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are small tools including screwdrivers with colorful plastic handles, tweezers, and knurled nuts scattered on the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an orange tabby kitten visible that lifts its head and cautiously reaches for a chrome screwdriver with its paw?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a smooth low-angle tracking shot that pans out to capture the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006739386357367039 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006739616394043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006739386357367039, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006739386357367039, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06161800026893616, + 0.026821348816156387, + 0.24792852997779846, + 0.03883684054017067, + 0.04559516906738281, + 0.0651945024728775, + 0.11544996500015259, + 0.16233190894126892, + 0.057405900210142136, + 0.17881786823272705 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006739386357367039 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vintage train carriage with a dark green velvet seat and a wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a silvery metal precision repair tool box visible, having slid off the seat and toppled to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are small tools including screwdrivers with colorful plastic handles, tweezers, and knurled nuts scattered on the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an orange tabby kitten visible that lifts its head and cautiously reaches for a chrome screwdriver with its paw?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a smooth low-angle tracking shot that pans out to capture the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005253083072602749 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255253314971924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005253083072602749, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005253083072602749, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12444382160902023, + 0.043261609971523285, + 0.16882970929145813, + 0.062376439571380615, + 0.09616433829069138, + 0.1001444086432457, + 0.06852754950523376, + 0.18947553634643555, + 0.058599598705768585, + 0.08817699551582336 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005253083072602749 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vintage train carriage with a dark green velvet seat and a wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a silvery metal precision repair tool box visible, having slid off the seat and toppled to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are small tools including screwdrivers with colorful plastic handles, tweezers, and knurled nuts scattered on the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an orange tabby kitten visible that lifts its head and cautiously reaches for a chrome screwdriver with its paw?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a smooth low-angle tracking shot that pans out to capture the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107108686119318 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51107120513916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107108686119318, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107108686119318, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04882758855819702, + 0.0266824159771204, + 0.1829966902732849, + 0.04364648088812828, + 0.0796888917684555, + 0.07665684074163437, + 0.053966838866472244, + 0.18329466879367828, + 0.2330140769481659, + 0.07122554630041122 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107108686119318 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vintage train carriage with a dark green velvet seat and a wooden floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a silvery metal precision repair tool box visible, having slid off the seat and toppled to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are small tools including screwdrivers with colorful plastic handles, tweezers, and knurled nuts scattered on the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an orange tabby kitten visible that lifts its head and cautiously reaches for a chrome screwdriver with its paw?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a smooth low-angle tracking shot that pans out to capture the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023272933438420296 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.77327299118042 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023272933438420296, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023272933438420296, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11576372385025024, + 0.031880103051662445, + 0.30008625984191895, + 0.09087839722633362, + 0.04983972758054733, + 0.10711327195167542, + 0.12845110893249512, + 0.07971004396677017, + 0.07194351404905319, + 0.024333782494068146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023272933438420296 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_1/index_tensor([8983, 8983])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_1/index_tensor([8983, 8983])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8c3359522a136d69ab32350855e64bbe8a239d7c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_1/index_tensor([8983, 8983])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium shot, initially at eye level, transitions into a steady, ascending crane shot, capturing a young, bespectacled engineer standing in a vast meadow. His dark, slightly tousled hair and thin, black frames are defined by soft, textured brushstrokes. He wears a practical, faded olive-green canvas jacket over a simple gray T-shirt, his posture tense, leaning forward as he watches intently. His eyes, wide behind his lenses, a furrowed brow, are filled with concentration and deep hope. The central subject of his gaze is a prototype aircraft, rendered in dynamic splotches of unpainted aluminum and composite gray; it speeds across the uneven field, its spinning propeller a circular blur of vibrant brushstrokes. The entire scene is visualized in a gentle splatter art style, with soft colors and textured, dynamic brushstrokes capturing movement. As the aircraft's wheels decisively leave the ground, kicking up impressionistic bursts of green and brown soil, the camera lifts and tilts, powerfully following the aircraft's ascent. The frame widens to show the aircraft steadily climbing toward a hopeful, open sky—a vast canvas of soft blues and pale morning yellows—creating an atmosphere of triumph and emotional resonance as the engineer's creation soars into the serene air, leaving a subtle, painterly trail behind it.", + "seed": 16784, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_1/index_8983_seed_16784_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.023256487399339675, + "vlm_logprob": -0.023256487399339675, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.023256487399339675, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a young engineer wearing glasses and an olive-green canvas jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast meadow with a prototype aircraft speeding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft take off, leaving the ground and kicking up soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a gentle splatter art style with textured brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition from an initial eye-level medium shot to a steady, ascending crane shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02785506099462509 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.652855157852173 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02785506099462509, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02785506099462509, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14155977964401245, + 0.05318941920995712, + 0.09414756298065186, + 0.15307389199733734, + 0.1263209581375122, + 0.05992953106760979, + 0.08316440135240555, + 0.11483997851610184, + 0.08394785225391388, + 0.08982662856578827 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02785506099462509 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a young engineer wearing glasses and an olive-green canvas jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast meadow with a prototype aircraft speeding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft take off, leaving the ground and kicking up soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a gentle splatter art style with textured brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition from an initial eye-level medium shot to a steady, ascending crane shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0097922682762146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634792327880859 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0097922682762146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0097922682762146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10812342911958694, + 0.0653841644525528, + 0.17284360527992249, + 0.10070378333330154, + 0.11045151203870773, + 0.053868502378463745, + 0.06948874890804291, + 0.07092933356761932, + 0.16294847428798676, + 0.08525844663381577 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0097922682762146 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a young engineer wearing glasses and an olive-green canvas jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast meadow with a prototype aircraft speeding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft take off, leaving the ground and kicking up soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a gentle splatter art style with textured brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition from an initial eye-level medium shot to a steady, ascending crane shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014194712042808533 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264194488525391 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014194712042808533, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014194712042808533, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08396501839160919, + 0.04758599027991295, + 0.20533612370491028, + 0.09820134192705154, + 0.06611400097608566, + 0.030249139294028282, + 0.039278700947761536, + 0.09028681367635727, + 0.2131539136171341, + 0.12582899630069733 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014194712042808533 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a young engineer wearing glasses and an olive-green canvas jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast meadow with a prototype aircraft speeding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft take off, leaving the ground and kicking up soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a gentle splatter art style with textured brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition from an initial eye-level medium shot to a steady, ascending crane shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026356063783168793 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513559818267822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026356063783168793, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026356063783168793, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14670443534851074, + 0.02957979403436184, + 0.06959187984466553, + 0.12766622006893158, + 0.1414719820022583, + 0.05970163270831108, + 0.06001098453998566, + 0.08287910372018814, + 0.16526885330677032, + 0.11712509393692017 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026356063783168793 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a young engineer wearing glasses and an olive-green canvas jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast meadow with a prototype aircraft speeding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft take off, leaving the ground and kicking up soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a gentle splatter art style with textured brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition from an initial eye-level medium shot to a steady, ascending crane shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03808433189988136 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880842685699463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03808433189988136, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03808433189988136, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11161670088768005, + 0.03233591094613075, + 0.05688542127609253, + 0.05516239255666733, + 0.0828719437122345, + 0.15954190492630005, + 0.058396946638822556, + 0.08325912058353424, + 0.2927022874355316, + 0.06722735613584518 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03808433189988136 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, initially at eye level, transitions into a steady, ascending crane shot, capturing a young, bespectacled engineer standing in a vast meadow. His dark, slightly tousled hair and thin, black frames are defined by soft, textured brushstrokes. He wears a practical, faded olive-green canvas jacket over a simple gray T-shirt, his posture tense, leaning forward as he watches intently. His eyes, wide behind his lenses, a furrowed brow, are filled with concentration and deep hope. The central subject of his gaze is a prototype aircraft, rendered in dynamic splotches of unpainted aluminum and composite gray; it speeds across the uneven field, its spinning propeller a circular blur of vibrant brushstrokes. The entire scene is visualized in a gentle splatter art style, with soft colors and textured, dynamic brushstrokes capturing movement. As the aircraft's wheels decisively leave the ground, kicking up impressionistic bursts of green and brown soil, the camera lifts and tilts, powerfully following the aircraft's ascent. The frame widens to show the aircraft steadily climbing toward a hopeful, open sky—a vast canvas of soft blues and pale morning yellows—creating an atmosphere of triumph and emotional resonance as the engineer's creation soars into the serene air, leaving a subtle, painterly trail behind it.", + "seed": 16785, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_1/index_8983_seed_16785_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0539242135360837, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0539242135360837, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0539242135360837, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a young engineer wearing glasses and an olive-green canvas jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast meadow with a prototype aircraft speeding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft take off, leaving the ground and kicking up soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a gentle splatter art style with textured brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition from an initial eye-level medium shot to a steady, ascending crane shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12862685322761536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.128626823425293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12862685322761536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12862685322761536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1610470414161682, + 0.06808120012283325, + 0.10836799442768097, + 0.0684090331196785, + 0.18839916586875916, + 0.12512421607971191, + 0.06579089164733887, + 0.0538037084043026, + 0.09759931266307831, + 0.06337742507457733 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12862685322761536 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a young engineer wearing glasses and an olive-green canvas jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast meadow with a prototype aircraft speeding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft take off, leaving the ground and kicking up soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a gentle splatter art style with textured brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition from an initial eye-level medium shot to a steady, ascending crane shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029817992821335793 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529818058013916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029817992821335793, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029817992821335793, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05643206462264061, + 0.06116432324051857, + 0.19644515216350555, + 0.04418366402387619, + 0.08079042285680771, + 0.06896056234836578, + 0.13659721612930298, + 0.16470815241336823, + 0.06616619974374771, + 0.12455231696367264 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029817992821335793 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a young engineer wearing glasses and an olive-green canvas jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast meadow with a prototype aircraft speeding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft take off, leaving the ground and kicking up soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a gentle splatter art style with textured brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition from an initial eye-level medium shot to a steady, ascending crane shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011080400086939335 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511080265045166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011080400086939335, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011080400086939335, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03749705106019974, + 0.02405618317425251, + 0.1688135713338852, + 0.03128191456198692, + 0.05014405772089958, + 0.10044560581445694, + 0.15618735551834106, + 0.2318457067012787, + 0.07267540693283081, + 0.12705311179161072 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011080400086939335 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a young engineer wearing glasses and an olive-green canvas jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast meadow with a prototype aircraft speeding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft take off, leaving the ground and kicking up soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a gentle splatter art style with textured brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition from an initial eye-level medium shot to a steady, ascending crane shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0110840555280447 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511084079742432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0110840555280447, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0110840555280447, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.051184557378292084, + 0.05335904285311699, + 0.3677624464035034, + 0.05486219748854637, + 0.044632598757743835, + 0.09242270886898041, + 0.10701465606689453, + 0.0590088851749897, + 0.087803915143013, + 0.08194902539253235 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0110840555280447 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a young engineer wearing glasses and an olive-green canvas jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast meadow with a prototype aircraft speeding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft take off, leaving the ground and kicking up soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a gentle splatter art style with textured brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition from an initial eye-level medium shot to a steady, ascending crane shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890117660164833 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640116691589355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0890117660164833, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0890117660164833, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.043464191257953644, + 0.04988479986786842, + 0.08474783599376678, + 0.027628008276224136, + 0.035523585975170135, + 0.11464448273181915, + 0.1650235801935196, + 0.12312520295381546, + 0.27124857902526855, + 0.08470971137285233 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0890117660164833 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, initially at eye level, transitions into a steady, ascending crane shot, capturing a young, bespectacled engineer standing in a vast meadow. His dark, slightly tousled hair and thin, black frames are defined by soft, textured brushstrokes. He wears a practical, faded olive-green canvas jacket over a simple gray T-shirt, his posture tense, leaning forward as he watches intently. His eyes, wide behind his lenses, a furrowed brow, are filled with concentration and deep hope. The central subject of his gaze is a prototype aircraft, rendered in dynamic splotches of unpainted aluminum and composite gray; it speeds across the uneven field, its spinning propeller a circular blur of vibrant brushstrokes. The entire scene is visualized in a gentle splatter art style, with soft colors and textured, dynamic brushstrokes capturing movement. As the aircraft's wheels decisively leave the ground, kicking up impressionistic bursts of green and brown soil, the camera lifts and tilts, powerfully following the aircraft's ascent. The frame widens to show the aircraft steadily climbing toward a hopeful, open sky—a vast canvas of soft blues and pale morning yellows—creating an atmosphere of triumph and emotional resonance as the engineer's creation soars into the serene air, leaving a subtle, painterly trail behind it.", + "seed": 16786, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_1/index_8983_seed_16786_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05075104851275682, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05075104851275682, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05075104851275682, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a young engineer wearing glasses and an olive-green canvas jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast meadow with a prototype aircraft speeding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft take off, leaving the ground and kicking up soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a gentle splatter art style with textured brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition from an initial eye-level medium shot to a steady, ascending crane shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11527086794376373 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2402708530426025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11527086794376373, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11527086794376373, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24581633508205414, + 0.035402845591306686, + 0.04819033294916153, + 0.15334127843379974, + 0.0896654948592186, + 0.05700651556253433, + 0.08117745816707611, + 0.061077285557985306, + 0.12317760288715363, + 0.10514488816261292 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11527086794376373 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a young engineer wearing glasses and an olive-green canvas jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast meadow with a prototype aircraft speeding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft take off, leaving the ground and kicking up soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a gentle splatter art style with textured brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition from an initial eye-level medium shot to a steady, ascending crane shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0205958541482687 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955957889556885 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0205958541482687, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0205958541482687, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3772331476211548, + 0.053976550698280334, + 0.047027651220560074, + 0.1078285276889801, + 0.02975349687039852, + 0.07509153336286545, + 0.05261240899562836, + 0.046749044209718704, + 0.14284181594848633, + 0.06688569486141205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0205958541482687 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a young engineer wearing glasses and an olive-green canvas jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast meadow with a prototype aircraft speeding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft take off, leaving the ground and kicking up soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a gentle splatter art style with textured brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition from an initial eye-level medium shot to a steady, ascending crane shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009783296845853329 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347832679748535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009783296845853329, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009783296845853329, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16476769745349884, + 0.043953146785497665, + 0.021228989586234093, + 0.017907878383994102, + 0.022517893463373184, + 0.0635257288813591, + 0.20845244824886322, + 0.1152745932340622, + 0.21502070128917694, + 0.12735095620155334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009783296845853329 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a young engineer wearing glasses and an olive-green canvas jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast meadow with a prototype aircraft speeding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft take off, leaving the ground and kicking up soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a gentle splatter art style with textured brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition from an initial eye-level medium shot to a steady, ascending crane shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810429945588112 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288104295730591 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810429945588112, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810429945588112, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23009617626667023, + 0.061108093708753586, + 0.05608177185058594, + 0.08513876050710678, + 0.038016509264707565, + 0.06495896726846695, + 0.10887594521045685, + 0.11333213001489639, + 0.13382740318775177, + 0.10856426507234573 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810429945588112 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a young engineer wearing glasses and an olive-green canvas jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast meadow with a prototype aircraft speeding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft take off, leaving the ground and kicking up soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a gentle splatter art style with textured brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition from an initial eye-level medium shot to a steady, ascending crane shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000092417001724 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950008869171143 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000092417001724, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000092417001724, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05335848405957222, + 0.029859671369194984, + 0.055691350251436234, + 0.03076441027224064, + 0.029782060533761978, + 0.05271195247769356, + 0.07145527005195618, + 0.10153328627347946, + 0.4759545922279358, + 0.09888899326324463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000092417001724 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, initially at eye level, transitions into a steady, ascending crane shot, capturing a young, bespectacled engineer standing in a vast meadow. His dark, slightly tousled hair and thin, black frames are defined by soft, textured brushstrokes. He wears a practical, faded olive-green canvas jacket over a simple gray T-shirt, his posture tense, leaning forward as he watches intently. His eyes, wide behind his lenses, a furrowed brow, are filled with concentration and deep hope. The central subject of his gaze is a prototype aircraft, rendered in dynamic splotches of unpainted aluminum and composite gray; it speeds across the uneven field, its spinning propeller a circular blur of vibrant brushstrokes. The entire scene is visualized in a gentle splatter art style, with soft colors and textured, dynamic brushstrokes capturing movement. As the aircraft's wheels decisively leave the ground, kicking up impressionistic bursts of green and brown soil, the camera lifts and tilts, powerfully following the aircraft's ascent. The frame widens to show the aircraft steadily climbing toward a hopeful, open sky—a vast canvas of soft blues and pale morning yellows—creating an atmosphere of triumph and emotional resonance as the engineer's creation soars into the serene air, leaving a subtle, painterly trail behind it.", + "seed": 16787, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_1/index_8983_seed_16787_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.01599422013387084, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01599422013387084, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01599422013387084, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a young engineer wearing glasses and an olive-green canvas jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast meadow with a prototype aircraft speeding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft take off, leaving the ground and kicking up soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a gentle splatter art style with textured brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition from an initial eye-level medium shot to a steady, ascending crane shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.027687057852745056 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6526870727539062 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.027687057852745056, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.027687057852745056, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34244251251220703, + 0.0604892261326313, + 0.05660650506615639, + 0.04374469444155693, + 0.06406817585229874, + 0.08573228120803833, + 0.06223640218377113, + 0.11988233029842377, + 0.05876433849334717, + 0.10603354126214981 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.027687057852745056 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a young engineer wearing glasses and an olive-green canvas jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast meadow with a prototype aircraft speeding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft take off, leaving the ground and kicking up soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a gentle splatter art style with textured brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition from an initial eye-level medium shot to a steady, ascending crane shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02981891855597496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298190116882324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02981891855597496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02981891855597496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1114695742726326, + 0.07821503281593323, + 0.06211860850453377, + 0.04606480523943901, + 0.11726061999797821, + 0.05531654879450798, + 0.1238723173737526, + 0.11102111637592316, + 0.14870573580265045, + 0.14595559239387512 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02981891855597496 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a young engineer wearing glasses and an olive-green canvas jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast meadow with a prototype aircraft speeding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft take off, leaving the ground and kicking up soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a gentle splatter art style with textured brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition from an initial eye-level medium shot to a steady, ascending crane shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005950355436652899 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130950450897217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005950355436652899, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005950355436652899, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1561904102563858, + 0.07594864070415497, + 0.05496088042855263, + 0.03221626952290535, + 0.023899368941783905, + 0.03817656636238098, + 0.10075807571411133, + 0.1501101404428482, + 0.15538720786571503, + 0.2123524397611618 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005950355436652899 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a young engineer wearing glasses and an olive-green canvas jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast meadow with a prototype aircraft speeding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft take off, leaving the ground and kicking up soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a gentle splatter art style with textured brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition from an initial eye-level medium shot to a steady, ascending crane shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067379651591181755 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006738185882568 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067379651591181755, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067379651591181755, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22321763634681702, + 0.0546514131128788, + 0.10891906172037125, + 0.02974764071404934, + 0.05229094251990318, + 0.09688025712966919, + 0.062483929097652435, + 0.06526348739862442, + 0.1441550850868225, + 0.1623905599117279 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067379651591181755 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a young engineer wearing glasses and an olive-green canvas jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a vast meadow with a prototype aircraft speeding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the aircraft take off, leaving the ground and kicking up soil?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a gentle splatter art style with textured brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera transition from an initial eye-level medium shot to a steady, ascending crane shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00977680366486311 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634776592254639 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00977680366486311, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00977680366486311, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09967546910047531, + 0.0859784483909607, + 0.09481308609247208, + 0.0359782800078392, + 0.08770131319761276, + 0.06418756395578384, + 0.049680210649967194, + 0.09836072474718094, + 0.20945413410663605, + 0.17417074739933014 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00977680366486311 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_10/index_tensor([723, 723])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_10/index_tensor([723, 723])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6cb2eb0f31a090a8014ec013ae076d94c2520cf3 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_10/index_tensor([723, 723])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly and steadily pans forward as a fantastical city constructed entirely of crispy dough rises from a smooth, dark surface. The city's primary structures—its towering skyscrapers, its crisscrossing towers, and its delicate bridges—are each constructed from stacked and stitched together slices of dough baked to perfection. Illuminated by a soft, focused warm light, each \"wall\" takes on an alluring caramel hue, its surface dotted with natural bubbles of varying sizes and tiny, crispy cracks, the result of baking. As the city's structure rises and expands, tiny crumbs of dough gently flake off from the structure's connections, drifting slowly through the air like dust. The camera continuously and steadily moves forward, gradually transitioning from a panoramic view showing the magnificent outline of the entire city to close-ups focusing on several core buildings in the city center, allowing the audience to clearly see the tightly fitted stacking of the dough and the layered soft shadows cast by light on its uneven surface. The whole picture creates a coveted architectural aesthetic in a surreal, tranquil and solemn atmosphere.", + "seed": 22400, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_10/index_723_seed_22400_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.14061196926049888, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14061196926049888, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.724999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14061196926049888, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a fantastical city constructed entirely of crispy dough slices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the city rise from a smooth, dark surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the structures illuminated by a soft, focused warm light with a caramel hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a wide-angle upward shot and pan forward while transitioning to close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crumbs of dough visible flaking off the structure and drifting through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18065983057022095 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8056597709655762 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18065983057022095, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18065983057022095, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.052701763808727264, + 0.04556549713015556, + 0.04527164250612259, + 0.09734918177127838, + 0.035639986395835876, + 0.07622335851192474, + 0.23793424665927887, + 0.0928393229842186, + 0.16580629348754883, + 0.1506686955690384 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18065983057022095 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a fantastical city constructed entirely of crispy dough slices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the city rise from a smooth, dark surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the structures illuminated by a soft, focused warm light with a caramel hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a wide-angle upward shot and pan forward while transitioning to close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crumbs of dough visible flaking off the structure and drifting through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870874047279358 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137087345123291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3870874047279358, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3870874047279358, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10523930937051773, + 0.13907288014888763, + 0.04528391361236572, + 0.14447881281375885, + 0.01874845288693905, + 0.02008560672402382, + 0.06199030950665474, + 0.08175309747457504, + 0.22940459847450256, + 0.1539430022239685 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3870874047279358 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a fantastical city constructed entirely of crispy dough slices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the city rise from a smooth, dark surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the structures illuminated by a soft, focused warm light with a caramel hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a wide-angle upward shot and pan forward while transitioning to close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crumbs of dough visible flaking off the structure and drifting through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003201955696567893 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753201961517334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003201955696567893, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003201955696567893, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09262188524007797, + 0.07380283623933792, + 0.033002376556396484, + 0.15592850744724274, + 0.039671819657087326, + 0.16351419687271118, + 0.07836008071899414, + 0.06924764811992645, + 0.18940959870815277, + 0.10444105416536331 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003201955696567893 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a fantastical city constructed entirely of crispy dough slices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the city rise from a smooth, dark surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the structures illuminated by a soft, focused warm light with a caramel hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a wide-angle upward shot and pan forward while transitioning to close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crumbs of dough visible flaking off the structure and drifting through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306214302778244 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168062210083008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306214302778244, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306214302778244, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08696077018976212, + 0.03763088211417198, + 0.04733331874012947, + 0.051635585725307465, + 0.10155404359102249, + 0.22261010110378265, + 0.0694727823138237, + 0.06009086221456528, + 0.2073860615491867, + 0.11532554775476456 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306214302778244 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a fantastical city constructed entirely of crispy dough slices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the city rise from a smooth, dark surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the structures illuminated by a soft, focused warm light with a caramel hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a wide-angle upward shot and pan forward while transitioning to close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crumbs of dough visible flaking off the structure and drifting through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08904851227998734 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640486240386963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08904851227998734, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08904851227998734, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08525140583515167, + 0.037269242107868195, + 0.056146904826164246, + 0.03711820766329765, + 0.07581708580255508, + 0.1163051649928093, + 0.06940694898366928, + 0.13846635818481445, + 0.21239425241947174, + 0.17182444036006927 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08904851227998734 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly and steadily pans forward as a fantastical city constructed entirely of crispy dough rises from a smooth, dark surface. The city's primary structures—its towering skyscrapers, its crisscrossing towers, and its delicate bridges—are each constructed from stacked and stitched together slices of dough baked to perfection. Illuminated by a soft, focused warm light, each \"wall\" takes on an alluring caramel hue, its surface dotted with natural bubbles of varying sizes and tiny, crispy cracks, the result of baking. As the city's structure rises and expands, tiny crumbs of dough gently flake off from the structure's connections, drifting slowly through the air like dust. The camera continuously and steadily moves forward, gradually transitioning from a panoramic view showing the magnificent outline of the entire city to close-ups focusing on several core buildings in the city center, allowing the audience to clearly see the tightly fitted stacking of the dough and the layered soft shadows cast by light on its uneven surface. The whole picture creates a coveted architectural aesthetic in a surreal, tranquil and solemn atmosphere.", + "seed": 22401, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_10/index_723_seed_22401_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.37869604453444483, + "vlm_logprob": -0.37869604453444483, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.37869604453444483, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a fantastical city constructed entirely of crispy dough slices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the city rise from a smooth, dark surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the structures illuminated by a soft, focused warm light with a caramel hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a wide-angle upward shot and pan forward while transitioning to close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crumbs of dough visible flaking off the structure and drifting through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6334242820739746 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7584242820739746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6334242820739746, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6334242820739746, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08259623497724533, + 0.05991155281662941, + 0.036195382475852966, + 0.09727742522954941, + 0.17815014719963074, + 0.09664851427078247, + 0.1452774703502655, + 0.0848751813173294, + 0.18754877150058746, + 0.031519316136837006 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6334242820739746 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a fantastical city constructed entirely of crispy dough slices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the city rise from a smooth, dark surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the structures illuminated by a soft, focused warm light with a caramel hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a wide-angle upward shot and pan forward while transitioning to close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crumbs of dough visible flaking off the structure and drifting through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137052059173584 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870520293712616 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.137052059173584, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.137052059173584, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.027448199689388275, + 0.021493786945939064, + 0.025536246597766876, + 0.07723947614431381, + 0.08047522604465485, + 0.5752172470092773, + 0.03310205414891243, + 0.05134791508316994, + 0.08936917036771774, + 0.018770765513181686 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.137052059173584 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a fantastical city constructed entirely of crispy dough slices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the city rise from a smooth, dark surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the structures illuminated by a soft, focused warm light with a caramel hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a wide-angle upward shot and pan forward while transitioning to close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crumbs of dough visible flaking off the structure and drifting through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005970500409603119 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130970478057861 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005970500409603119, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005970500409603119, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06893789023160934, + 0.0595608688890934, + 0.031343914568424225, + 0.048069633543491364, + 0.039354536682367325, + 0.3469846248626709, + 0.1179802268743515, + 0.03931921347975731, + 0.21570229530334473, + 0.03274673596024513 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005970500409603119 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a fantastical city constructed entirely of crispy dough slices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the city rise from a smooth, dark surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the structures illuminated by a soft, focused warm light with a caramel hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a wide-angle upward shot and pan forward while transitioning to close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crumbs of dough visible flaking off the structure and drifting through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496829003095627 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299683570861816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496829003095627, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496829003095627, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.037179410457611084, + 0.021769508719444275, + 0.022782666608691216, + 0.02617582120001316, + 0.020177222788333893, + 0.8304769396781921, + 0.007589961402118206, + 0.010523244738578796, + 0.014313844032585621, + 0.009011350572109222 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496829003095627 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a fantastical city constructed entirely of crispy dough slices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the city rise from a smooth, dark surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the structures illuminated by a soft, focused warm light with a caramel hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a wide-angle upward shot and pan forward while transitioning to close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crumbs of dough visible flaking off the structure and drifting through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062065090984106064 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120651245117188 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062065090984106064, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062065090984106064, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.060164760798215866, + 0.04194983094930649, + 0.0401000902056694, + 0.061536818742752075, + 0.03158549219369888, + 0.3704584240913391, + 0.054010022431612015, + 0.07077912986278534, + 0.2179679572582245, + 0.051447439938783646 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062065090984106064 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly and steadily pans forward as a fantastical city constructed entirely of crispy dough rises from a smooth, dark surface. The city's primary structures—its towering skyscrapers, its crisscrossing towers, and its delicate bridges—are each constructed from stacked and stitched together slices of dough baked to perfection. Illuminated by a soft, focused warm light, each \"wall\" takes on an alluring caramel hue, its surface dotted with natural bubbles of varying sizes and tiny, crispy cracks, the result of baking. As the city's structure rises and expands, tiny crumbs of dough gently flake off from the structure's connections, drifting slowly through the air like dust. The camera continuously and steadily moves forward, gradually transitioning from a panoramic view showing the magnificent outline of the entire city to close-ups focusing on several core buildings in the city center, allowing the audience to clearly see the tightly fitted stacking of the dough and the layered soft shadows cast by light on its uneven surface. The whole picture creates a coveted architectural aesthetic in a surreal, tranquil and solemn atmosphere.", + "seed": 22402, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_10/index_723_seed_22402_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.17851435653865338, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17851435653865338, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17851435653865338, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a fantastical city constructed entirely of crispy dough slices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the city rise from a smooth, dark surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the structures illuminated by a soft, focused warm light with a caramel hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a wide-angle upward shot and pan forward while transitioning to close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crumbs of dough visible flaking off the structure and drifting through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00796653050929308 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8829665184021 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00796653050929308, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00796653050929308, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17013011872768402, + 0.03257954120635986, + 0.030816679820418358, + 0.037703245878219604, + 0.09125164151191711, + 0.17545872926712036, + 0.03570723161101341, + 0.07566940784454346, + 0.29508888721466064, + 0.05559451878070831 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00796653050929308 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a fantastical city constructed entirely of crispy dough slices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the city rise from a smooth, dark surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the structures illuminated by a soft, focused warm light with a caramel hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a wide-angle upward shot and pan forward while transitioning to close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crumbs of dough visible flaking off the structure and drifting through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261101245880127 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761101245880127 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8261101245880127, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8261101245880127, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15841077268123627, + 0.24350208044052124, + 0.03654450923204422, + 0.07636266946792603, + 0.07316653430461884, + 0.04909035563468933, + 0.03705017268657684, + 0.18922486901283264, + 0.10155358910560608, + 0.03509444370865822 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8261101245880127 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a fantastical city constructed entirely of crispy dough slices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the city rise from a smooth, dark surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the structures illuminated by a soft, focused warm light with a caramel hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a wide-angle upward shot and pan forward while transitioning to close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crumbs of dough visible flaking off the structure and drifting through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002203657291829586 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127203464508057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002203657291829586, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002203657291829586, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16205526888370514, + 0.17899999022483826, + 0.0734206959605217, + 0.13231134414672852, + 0.1402820348739624, + 0.04487771540880203, + 0.03629455715417862, + 0.11073321104049683, + 0.06982144713401794, + 0.051203660666942596 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002203657291829586 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a fantastical city constructed entirely of crispy dough slices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the city rise from a smooth, dark surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the structures illuminated by a soft, focused warm light with a caramel hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a wide-angle upward shot and pan forward while transitioning to close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crumbs of dough visible flaking off the structure and drifting through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038099367171525955 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880992889404297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038099367171525955, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038099367171525955, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3227265477180481, + 0.1800955832004547, + 0.041800953447818756, + 0.05701538547873497, + 0.08958718180656433, + 0.06927401572465897, + 0.04753793776035309, + 0.0888979434967041, + 0.06430789083242416, + 0.03875651955604553 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038099367171525955 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a fantastical city constructed entirely of crispy dough slices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the city rise from a smooth, dark surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the structures illuminated by a soft, focused warm light with a caramel hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a wide-angle upward shot and pan forward while transitioning to close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crumbs of dough visible flaking off the structure and drifting through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018192103132605553 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018192291259766 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018192103132605553, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018192103132605553, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19987031817436218, + 0.08274197578430176, + 0.022022562101483345, + 0.0860351100564003, + 0.0671367198228836, + 0.030863845720887184, + 0.23250892758369446, + 0.12967514991760254, + 0.11493712663650513, + 0.03420822694897652 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018192103132605553 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly and steadily pans forward as a fantastical city constructed entirely of crispy dough rises from a smooth, dark surface. The city's primary structures—its towering skyscrapers, its crisscrossing towers, and its delicate bridges—are each constructed from stacked and stitched together slices of dough baked to perfection. Illuminated by a soft, focused warm light, each \"wall\" takes on an alluring caramel hue, its surface dotted with natural bubbles of varying sizes and tiny, crispy cracks, the result of baking. As the city's structure rises and expands, tiny crumbs of dough gently flake off from the structure's connections, drifting slowly through the air like dust. The camera continuously and steadily moves forward, gradually transitioning from a panoramic view showing the magnificent outline of the entire city to close-ups focusing on several core buildings in the city center, allowing the audience to clearly see the tightly fitted stacking of the dough and the layered soft shadows cast by light on its uneven surface. The whole picture creates a coveted architectural aesthetic in a surreal, tranquil and solemn atmosphere.", + "seed": 22403, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_10/index_723_seed_22403_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.11406201785430312, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11406201785430312, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11406201785430312, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a fantastical city constructed entirely of crispy dough slices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the city rise from a smooth, dark surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the structures illuminated by a soft, focused warm light with a caramel hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a wide-angle upward shot and pan forward while transitioning to close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crumbs of dough visible flaking off the structure and drifting through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005269566550850868 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.380269527435303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005269566550850868, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005269566550850868, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08913957327604294, + 0.09571579098701477, + 0.03713594377040863, + 0.1261148303747177, + 0.20303358137607574, + 0.11766333878040314, + 0.036493610590696335, + 0.12764275074005127, + 0.06610449403524399, + 0.10095608979463577 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005269566550850868 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a fantastical city constructed entirely of crispy dough slices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the city rise from a smooth, dark surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the structures illuminated by a soft, focused warm light with a caramel hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a wide-angle upward shot and pan forward while transitioning to close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crumbs of dough visible flaking off the structure and drifting through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233231782913208 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983231782913208 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233231782913208, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233231782913208, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09501956403255463, + 0.20005503296852112, + 0.03251422196626663, + 0.06505946815013885, + 0.036531392484903336, + 0.08376511186361313, + 0.01766626536846161, + 0.08020541816949844, + 0.023757796734571457, + 0.3654257655143738 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233231782913208 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a fantastical city constructed entirely of crispy dough slices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the city rise from a smooth, dark surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the structures illuminated by a soft, focused warm light with a caramel hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a wide-angle upward shot and pan forward while transitioning to close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crumbs of dough visible flaking off the structure and drifting through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028275768272578716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778276443481445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028275768272578716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028275768272578716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09035276621580124, + 0.08456482738256454, + 0.049570899456739426, + 0.04651563614606857, + 0.2740657925605774, + 0.03763944283127785, + 0.034451473504304886, + 0.271291047334671, + 0.06124104931950569, + 0.05030708387494087 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028275768272578716 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a fantastical city constructed entirely of crispy dough slices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the city rise from a smooth, dark surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the structures illuminated by a soft, focused warm light with a caramel hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a wide-angle upward shot and pan forward while transitioning to close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crumbs of dough visible flaking off the structure and drifting through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012542063370347023 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387542247772217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012542063370347023, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012542063370347023, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06896857172250748, + 0.03516015410423279, + 0.027424674481153488, + 0.08145851641893387, + 0.12255610525608063, + 0.10390818864107132, + 0.027802301570773125, + 0.1267622858285904, + 0.2205791026353836, + 0.18538005650043488 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012542063370347023 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a fantastical city constructed entirely of crispy dough slices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the city rise from a smooth, dark surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the structures illuminated by a soft, focused warm light with a caramel hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a wide-angle upward shot and pan forward while transitioning to close-ups?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are tiny crumbs of dough visible flaking off the structure and drifting through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026347704231739044 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513476371765137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026347704231739044, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026347704231739044, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05043540894985199, + 0.030896110460162163, + 0.02278931438922882, + 0.10126307606697083, + 0.3977832794189453, + 0.08109735697507858, + 0.030135203152894974, + 0.029033280909061432, + 0.0781952515244484, + 0.17837172746658325 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026347704231739044 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_11/index_tensor([3896, 3896])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_11/index_tensor([3896, 3896])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fc2dafc6c5dcfdf0238b8072666c51849cd06047 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_11/index_tensor([3896, 3896])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from an overhead angle, the camera slowly pans rightward, focusing on a pink lotus in full bloom. The petals unfold in layers, a delicate deep pink at the edges, fading to a soft milky white towards the center. A vibrant yellow pod, dotted with tiny pores, nestles in the center. Crystal-clear water droplets gently roll across the broad, silky petals, reflecting the soft morning light. The lotus floats gracefully on the mirror-like, deep green lake. With its almost imperceptible movements, delicate, concentric ripples steadily and leisurely spread outward from the base of the flower, breaking the water's absolute calm. Dotted around are several large, emerald green, rounded lotus leaves, creating a tranquil scene. The entire scene is bathed in soft natural light filtered through the mist, creating a refreshing and tranquil atmosphere in cool tones, imbued with the ultimate Zen spirit and the beauty of life.", + "seed": 14577, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_11/index_3896_seed_14577_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.2782989914063364, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2782989914063364, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2782989914063364, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from an overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan rightward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a pink lotus in full bloom visible with petals unfolding in layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vibrant yellow pod dotted with tiny pores visible in the center of the lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear water droplets rolling across the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1471298336982727 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.022129774093628 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1471298336982727, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1471298336982727, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09524000436067581, + 0.14768901467323303, + 0.09761391580104828, + 0.03515525907278061, + 0.04657191038131714, + 0.0778718888759613, + 0.09070535749197006, + 0.13257504999637604, + 0.13102056086063385, + 0.14555707573890686 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1471298336982727 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from an overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan rightward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a pink lotus in full bloom visible with petals unfolding in layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vibrant yellow pod dotted with tiny pores visible in the center of the lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear water droplets rolling across the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578203678131104 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328203678131104 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7578203678131104, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7578203678131104, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05771597847342491, + 0.28234532475471497, + 0.09252526611089706, + 0.01580124720931053, + 0.019930558279156685, + 0.11299923807382584, + 0.06482285261154175, + 0.1789979785680771, + 0.12928685545921326, + 0.04557466134428978 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7578203678131104 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from an overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan rightward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a pink lotus in full bloom visible with petals unfolding in layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vibrant yellow pod dotted with tiny pores visible in the center of the lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear water droplets rolling across the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036258448380976915 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628625869750977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036258448380976915, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036258448380976915, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07109742611646652, + 0.1684993952512741, + 0.08536382764577866, + 0.01507550198584795, + 0.0624815970659256, + 0.0639876127243042, + 0.0394277423620224, + 0.157585009932518, + 0.05333336442708969, + 0.28314852714538574 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036258448380976915 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from an overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan rightward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a pink lotus in full bloom visible with petals unfolding in layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vibrant yellow pod dotted with tiny pores visible in the center of the lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear water droplets rolling across the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008640758693218231 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758640766143799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008640758693218231, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008640758693218231, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08568289130926132, + 0.13559779524803162, + 0.05867088958621025, + 0.10196179151535034, + 0.025194231420755386, + 0.05346640944480896, + 0.0962691381573677, + 0.1513766050338745, + 0.09678387641906738, + 0.19499635696411133 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008640758693218231 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from an overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan rightward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a pink lotus in full bloom visible with petals unfolding in layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vibrant yellow pod dotted with tiny pores visible in the center of the lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear water droplets rolling across the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47427815198898315 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742781519889832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47427815198898315, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47427815198898315, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09799045324325562, + 0.03719279542565346, + 0.03168502822518349, + 0.02908630110323429, + 0.013959149830043316, + 0.017111772671341896, + 0.021000776439905167, + 0.06904491037130356, + 0.07735753059387207, + 0.6055712699890137 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47427815198898315 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from an overhead angle, the camera slowly pans rightward, focusing on a pink lotus in full bloom. The petals unfold in layers, a delicate deep pink at the edges, fading to a soft milky white towards the center. A vibrant yellow pod, dotted with tiny pores, nestles in the center. Crystal-clear water droplets gently roll across the broad, silky petals, reflecting the soft morning light. The lotus floats gracefully on the mirror-like, deep green lake. With its almost imperceptible movements, delicate, concentric ripples steadily and leisurely spread outward from the base of the flower, breaking the water's absolute calm. Dotted around are several large, emerald green, rounded lotus leaves, creating a tranquil scene. The entire scene is bathed in soft natural light filtered through the mist, creating a refreshing and tranquil atmosphere in cool tones, imbued with the ultimate Zen spirit and the beauty of life.", + "seed": 14578, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_11/index_3896_seed_14578_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2311643541790545, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2311643541790545, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2311643541790545, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from an overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan rightward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a pink lotus in full bloom visible with petals unfolding in layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vibrant yellow pod dotted with tiny pores visible in the center of the lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear water droplets rolling across the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10330000519752502 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.353300094604492 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10330000519752502, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10330000519752502, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23341307044029236, + 0.04448891431093216, + 0.0838947594165802, + 0.031334225088357925, + 0.052256226539611816, + 0.10488568991422653, + 0.299847275018692, + 0.027696341276168823, + 0.09219387173652649, + 0.029989631846547127 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10330000519752502 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from an overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan rightward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a pink lotus in full bloom visible with petals unfolding in layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vibrant yellow pod dotted with tiny pores visible in the center of the lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear water droplets rolling across the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983187079429626 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233187079429626 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8983187079429626, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8983187079429626, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12038658559322357, + 0.046521659940481186, + 0.07295320928096771, + 0.1204042062163353, + 0.06475777924060822, + 0.12925350666046143, + 0.2114301472902298, + 0.15050901472568512, + 0.04035099595785141, + 0.04343293234705925 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8983187079429626 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from an overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan rightward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a pink lotus in full bloom visible with petals unfolding in layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vibrant yellow pod dotted with tiny pores visible in the center of the lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear water droplets rolling across the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046497792936861515 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379649639129639 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046497792936861515, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046497792936861515, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09629394859075546, + 0.07927937060594559, + 0.05326223373413086, + 0.1422348916530609, + 0.07264254987239838, + 0.1526123434305191, + 0.1692032366991043, + 0.04088825732469559, + 0.11612240970134735, + 0.07746076583862305 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046497792936861515 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from an overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan rightward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a pink lotus in full bloom visible with petals unfolding in layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vibrant yellow pod dotted with tiny pores visible in the center of the lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear water droplets rolling across the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067370180040597916 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006737232208252 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067370180040597916, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067370180040597916, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.43182867765426636, + 0.04708683118224144, + 0.03968587890267372, + 0.09504713118076324, + 0.028101922944188118, + 0.06266169995069504, + 0.18562771379947662, + 0.02814481034874916, + 0.037112340331077576, + 0.04470297694206238 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067370180040597916 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from an overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan rightward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a pink lotus in full bloom visible with petals unfolding in layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vibrant yellow pod dotted with tiny pores visible in the center of the lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear water droplets rolling across the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14281626045703888 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178163051605225 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14281626045703888, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14281626045703888, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19660116732120514, + 0.04076838493347168, + 0.10631722211837769, + 0.0770992636680603, + 0.11181531101465225, + 0.14755770564079285, + 0.14528387784957886, + 0.09504061937332153, + 0.02861654758453369, + 0.050899896770715714 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14281626045703888 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from an overhead angle, the camera slowly pans rightward, focusing on a pink lotus in full bloom. The petals unfold in layers, a delicate deep pink at the edges, fading to a soft milky white towards the center. A vibrant yellow pod, dotted with tiny pores, nestles in the center. Crystal-clear water droplets gently roll across the broad, silky petals, reflecting the soft morning light. The lotus floats gracefully on the mirror-like, deep green lake. With its almost imperceptible movements, delicate, concentric ripples steadily and leisurely spread outward from the base of the flower, breaking the water's absolute calm. Dotted around are several large, emerald green, rounded lotus leaves, creating a tranquil scene. The entire scene is bathed in soft natural light filtered through the mist, creating a refreshing and tranquil atmosphere in cool tones, imbued with the ultimate Zen spirit and the beauty of life.", + "seed": 14579, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_11/index_3896_seed_14579_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.3611275427043438, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3611275427043438, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3611275427043438, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from an overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan rightward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a pink lotus in full bloom visible with petals unfolding in layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vibrant yellow pod dotted with tiny pores visible in the center of the lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear water droplets rolling across the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06655935943126678 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.816559314727783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06655935943126678, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06655935943126678, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04013591632246971, + 0.016788600012660027, + 0.010787740349769592, + 0.2967225909233093, + 0.023475682362914085, + 0.2262088656425476, + 0.2962077558040619, + 0.031005946919322014, + 0.019069729372859, + 0.03959717974066734 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06655935943126678 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from an overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan rightward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a pink lotus in full bloom visible with petals unfolding in layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vibrant yellow pod dotted with tiny pores visible in the center of the lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear water droplets rolling across the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020925998687744 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520926594734192 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5020925998687744, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5020925998687744, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03608269616961479, + 0.022609839215874672, + 0.009333630092442036, + 0.03820296749472618, + 0.03294551372528076, + 0.17380940914154053, + 0.6273588538169861, + 0.015827983617782593, + 0.027955103665590286, + 0.015874052420258522 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5020925998687744 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from an overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan rightward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a pink lotus in full bloom visible with petals unfolding in layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vibrant yellow pod dotted with tiny pores visible in the center of the lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear water droplets rolling across the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006750279571861029 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006750106811523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006750279571861029, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006750279571861029, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07238244265317917, + 0.05182827264070511, + 0.03131527081131935, + 0.1492977738380432, + 0.03496001288294792, + 0.0822516530752182, + 0.44733133912086487, + 0.04515011981129646, + 0.06109063699841499, + 0.024392468854784966 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006750279571861029 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from an overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan rightward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a pink lotus in full bloom visible with petals unfolding in layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vibrant yellow pod dotted with tiny pores visible in the center of the lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear water droplets rolling across the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046377950347959995 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379637718200684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046377950347959995, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046377950347959995, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03956810384988785, + 0.01814444363117218, + 0.028197934851050377, + 0.07090390473604202, + 0.029461968690156937, + 0.05373932421207428, + 0.6214048862457275, + 0.0451972633600235, + 0.06265751272439957, + 0.030724620446562767 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046377950347959995 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from an overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan rightward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a pink lotus in full bloom visible with petals unfolding in layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vibrant yellow pod dotted with tiny pores visible in the center of the lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear water droplets rolling across the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22559767961502075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600597620010376 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22559767961502075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22559767961502075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08672311156988144, + 0.07042260468006134, + 0.04586651548743248, + 0.13027380406856537, + 0.07674794644117355, + 0.11198392510414124, + 0.15301179885864258, + 0.09529680758714676, + 0.13827890157699585, + 0.09139460325241089 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22559767961502075 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from an overhead angle, the camera slowly pans rightward, focusing on a pink lotus in full bloom. The petals unfold in layers, a delicate deep pink at the edges, fading to a soft milky white towards the center. A vibrant yellow pod, dotted with tiny pores, nestles in the center. Crystal-clear water droplets gently roll across the broad, silky petals, reflecting the soft morning light. The lotus floats gracefully on the mirror-like, deep green lake. With its almost imperceptible movements, delicate, concentric ripples steadily and leisurely spread outward from the base of the flower, breaking the water's absolute calm. Dotted around are several large, emerald green, rounded lotus leaves, creating a tranquil scene. The entire scene is bathed in soft natural light filtered through the mist, creating a refreshing and tranquil atmosphere in cool tones, imbued with the ultimate Zen spirit and the beauty of life.", + "seed": 14580, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_11/index_3896_seed_14580_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2491919520776719, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2491919520776719, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2491919520776719, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from an overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan rightward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a pink lotus in full bloom visible with petals unfolding in layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vibrant yellow pod dotted with tiny pores visible in the center of the lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear water droplets rolling across the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0651354119181633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8151354789733887 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0651354119181633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0651354119181633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24128377437591553, + 0.048722218722105026, + 0.23055849969387054, + 0.24389728903770447, + 0.07380791008472443, + 0.03924022242426872, + 0.02128731459379196, + 0.027845673263072968, + 0.06711214780807495, + 0.006244977004826069 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0651354119181633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from an overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan rightward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a pink lotus in full bloom visible with petals unfolding in layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vibrant yellow pod dotted with tiny pores visible in the center of the lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear water droplets rolling across the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742647409439087 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4742647111415863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9742647409439087, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9742647409439087, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13213637471199036, + 0.017662685364484787, + 0.30207741260528564, + 0.0742625743150711, + 0.019925082102417946, + 0.037609223276376724, + 0.031216392293572426, + 0.3086303174495697, + 0.06447348743677139, + 0.012006382457911968 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9742647409439087 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from an overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan rightward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a pink lotus in full bloom visible with petals unfolding in layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vibrant yellow pod dotted with tiny pores visible in the center of the lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear water droplets rolling across the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024980073794722557 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002498149871826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024980073794722557, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024980073794722557, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09444935619831085, + 0.02457096427679062, + 0.16278955340385437, + 0.2575606405735016, + 0.029463933780789375, + 0.027475133538246155, + 0.01646360009908676, + 0.35571083426475525, + 0.013805115595459938, + 0.017710858955979347 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024980073794722557 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from an overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan rightward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a pink lotus in full bloom visible with petals unfolding in layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vibrant yellow pod dotted with tiny pores visible in the center of the lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear water droplets rolling across the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024876620154827833 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002487659454346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024876620154827833, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024876620154827833, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06531234085559845, + 0.018994487822055817, + 0.058168064802885056, + 0.7167733311653137, + 0.05994317680597305, + 0.01656627468764782, + 0.011638322845101357, + 0.02488797903060913, + 0.019643260166049004, + 0.008072755299508572 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024876620154827833 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from an overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan rightward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a pink lotus in full bloom visible with petals unfolding in layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vibrant yellow pod dotted with tiny pores visible in the center of the lotus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear water droplets rolling across the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015739381313324 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015739679336548 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2015739381313324, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2015739381313324, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3055279552936554, + 0.06264208257198334, + 0.1603662073612213, + 0.16475635766983032, + 0.019988782703876495, + 0.02254100702702999, + 0.02980358526110649, + 0.19019818305969238, + 0.027049465104937553, + 0.017126355320215225 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2015739381313324 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_12/index_tensor([9466, 9466])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_12/index_tensor([9466, 9466])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..795d20a000c71e89b39da8620bef0f550ea44bac --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_12/index_tensor([9466, 9466])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static medium shot, shot from a sideways angle, captures a tranquil moment imbued with classical oriental aesthetics. A beam of warm afternoon sunlight penetrates a dark wooden window lattice carved with intricate geometric patterns, casting a clear path through the air, and countless tiny dust particles drift slowly within the beam. A woman of ancient times, her hair tied high in a bun, sits quietly at the intersection of light and shadow. Her long, lustrous black hair is neatly tied up with an elegant jade hairpin, revealing her smooth forehead and graceful neck. The light precisely outlines her delicate profile, her high nose bridge, her thin, tightly pursed lips, and her long, slightly fluttering eyelashes casting a subtle shadow on her cheeks. Her expression is focused and peaceful. She wears an elegant moon-white silk gown, layered over a light gray cotton and linen double-breasted top. The sunlight illuminates the garment, revealing the delicate texture of the fabric. Her hands rest gracefully on her knees, her posture dignified and relaxed. The background is a simple traditional study, with mottled light and shadows from the window panes on the dark wooden floor. A table with writing brushes, ink, paper and inkstone on it can be vaguely seen in the corner of the far wall. The whole picture has soft and warm tones, creating a secluded, quiet and introverted poetic atmosphere.", + "seed": 8661, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_12/index_9466_seed_8661_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.02910051355138421, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02910051355138421, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02910051355138421, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static medium shot from a sideways angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with ancient-style hair tied in a bun and adorned with a jade hairpin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a moon-white silk gown layered over a light gray cotton and linen double-breasted top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a traditional study with a dark wooden window lattice and a table containing writing brushes, ink, paper, and an inkstone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight visible penetrating the window and illuminating dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019232695922255516 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.394232749938965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019232695922255516, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019232695922255516, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14493417739868164, + 0.04909534007310867, + 0.035392019897699356, + 0.37438538670539856, + 0.016591787338256836, + 0.09544304013252258, + 0.13171251118183136, + 0.02770092338323593, + 0.03909913823008537, + 0.08564570546150208 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019232695922255516 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static medium shot from a sideways angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with ancient-style hair tied in a bun and adorned with a jade hairpin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a moon-white silk gown layered over a light gray cotton and linen double-breasted top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a traditional study with a dark wooden window lattice and a table containing writing brushes, ink, paper, and an inkstone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight visible penetrating the window and illuminating dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004654762800782919 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379654884338379 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004654762800782919, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004654762800782919, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07463523000478745, + 0.02543817274272442, + 0.02076292224228382, + 0.05149821192026138, + 0.033989716321229935, + 0.16737744212150574, + 0.4973444640636444, + 0.04027262702584267, + 0.021807415410876274, + 0.06687382608652115 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004654762800782919 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static medium shot from a sideways angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with ancient-style hair tied in a bun and adorned with a jade hairpin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a moon-white silk gown layered over a light gray cotton and linen double-breasted top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a traditional study with a dark wooden window lattice and a table containing writing brushes, ink, paper, and an inkstone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight visible penetrating the window and illuminating dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062042124569416046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812042236328125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062042124569416046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062042124569416046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.047922685742378235, + 0.029429923743009567, + 0.019285913556814194, + 0.397842675447464, + 0.21901516616344452, + 0.10482471436262131, + 0.0867093950510025, + 0.05559205636382103, + 0.01745302975177765, + 0.021924417465925217 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062042124569416046 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static medium shot from a sideways angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with ancient-style hair tied in a bun and adorned with a jade hairpin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a moon-white silk gown layered over a light gray cotton and linen double-breasted top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a traditional study with a dark wooden window lattice and a table containing writing brushes, ink, paper, and an inkstone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight visible penetrating the window and illuminating dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004632455296814442 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379632472991943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004632455296814442, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004632455296814442, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08952083438634872, + 0.03700105845928192, + 0.015727989375591278, + 0.2548058032989502, + 0.02724568545818329, + 0.15185421705245972, + 0.31016457080841064, + 0.06802687048912048, + 0.02069350704550743, + 0.024959402158856392 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004632455296814442 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static medium shot from a sideways angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with ancient-style hair tied in a bun and adorned with a jade hairpin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a moon-white silk gown layered over a light gray cotton and linen double-breasted top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a traditional study with a dark wooden window lattice and a table containing writing brushes, ink, paper, and an inkstone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight visible penetrating the window and illuminating dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05494052916765213 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299404621124268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05494052916765213, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05494052916765213, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18160250782966614, + 0.05228472501039505, + 0.027147382497787476, + 0.2778010666370392, + 0.031009458005428314, + 0.05532419681549072, + 0.2691512107849121, + 0.03184490650892258, + 0.04276052862405777, + 0.03107396513223648 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05494052916765213 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static medium shot, shot from a sideways angle, captures a tranquil moment imbued with classical oriental aesthetics. A beam of warm afternoon sunlight penetrates a dark wooden window lattice carved with intricate geometric patterns, casting a clear path through the air, and countless tiny dust particles drift slowly within the beam. A woman of ancient times, her hair tied high in a bun, sits quietly at the intersection of light and shadow. Her long, lustrous black hair is neatly tied up with an elegant jade hairpin, revealing her smooth forehead and graceful neck. The light precisely outlines her delicate profile, her high nose bridge, her thin, tightly pursed lips, and her long, slightly fluttering eyelashes casting a subtle shadow on her cheeks. Her expression is focused and peaceful. She wears an elegant moon-white silk gown, layered over a light gray cotton and linen double-breasted top. The sunlight illuminates the garment, revealing the delicate texture of the fabric. Her hands rest gracefully on her knees, her posture dignified and relaxed. The background is a simple traditional study, with mottled light and shadows from the window panes on the dark wooden floor. A table with writing brushes, ink, paper and inkstone on it can be vaguely seen in the corner of the far wall. The whole picture has soft and warm tones, creating a secluded, quiet and introverted poetic atmosphere.", + "seed": 8662, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_12/index_9466_seed_8662_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0304743567481637, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0304743567481637, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0304743567481637, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static medium shot from a sideways angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with ancient-style hair tied in a bun and adorned with a jade hairpin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a moon-white silk gown layered over a light gray cotton and linen double-breasted top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a traditional study with a dark wooden window lattice and a table containing writing brushes, ink, paper, and an inkstone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight visible penetrating the window and illuminating dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02465537190437317 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.899655342102051 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02465537190437317, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02465537190437317, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09654463827610016, + 0.043612927198410034, + 0.05946630984544754, + 0.02311396598815918, + 0.034719206392765045, + 0.03218493238091469, + 0.0829009860754013, + 0.05826996639370918, + 0.1724209189414978, + 0.39676612615585327 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02465537190437317 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static medium shot from a sideways angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with ancient-style hair tied in a bun and adorned with a jade hairpin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a moon-white silk gown layered over a light gray cotton and linen double-breasted top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a traditional study with a dark wooden window lattice and a table containing writing brushes, ink, paper, and an inkstone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight visible penetrating the window and illuminating dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01256290078163147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875627517700195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01256290078163147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01256290078163147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11714883148670197, + 0.04880725219845772, + 0.04326019063591957, + 0.01280883327126503, + 0.052811093628406525, + 0.05482977256178856, + 0.07976137101650238, + 0.028289351612329483, + 0.019028328359127045, + 0.5432549715042114 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01256290078163147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static medium shot from a sideways angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with ancient-style hair tied in a bun and adorned with a jade hairpin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a moon-white silk gown layered over a light gray cotton and linen double-breasted top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a traditional study with a dark wooden window lattice and a table containing writing brushes, ink, paper, and an inkstone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight visible penetrating the window and illuminating dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054958585649728775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299585819244385 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054958585649728775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054958585649728775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1638771891593933, + 0.0641358494758606, + 0.04216615855693817, + 0.02956342324614525, + 0.2453344613313675, + 0.05553353577852249, + 0.12996770441532135, + 0.06062117964029312, + 0.09792784601449966, + 0.11087263375520706 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054958585649728775 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static medium shot from a sideways angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with ancient-style hair tied in a bun and adorned with a jade hairpin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a moon-white silk gown layered over a light gray cotton and linen double-breasted top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a traditional study with a dark wooden window lattice and a table containing writing brushes, ink, paper, and an inkstone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight visible penetrating the window and illuminating dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005249881185591221 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255249977111816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005249881185591221, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005249881185591221, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12260731309652328, + 0.06766321510076523, + 0.05588255077600479, + 0.02363104745745659, + 0.03972669318318367, + 0.03900265321135521, + 0.06245826184749603, + 0.06597900390625, + 0.054125215858221054, + 0.46892404556274414 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005249881185591221 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static medium shot from a sideways angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with ancient-style hair tied in a bun and adorned with a jade hairpin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a moon-white silk gown layered over a light gray cotton and linen double-breasted top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a traditional study with a dark wooden window lattice and a table containing writing brushes, ink, paper, and an inkstone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight visible penetrating the window and illuminating dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054945044219493866 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299449920654297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054945044219493866, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054945044219493866, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21405841410160065, + 0.18142050504684448, + 0.023798363283276558, + 0.015502219088375568, + 0.024512091651558876, + 0.048233915120363235, + 0.10023798048496246, + 0.06769353151321411, + 0.08212140947580338, + 0.2424214780330658 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054945044219493866 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static medium shot, shot from a sideways angle, captures a tranquil moment imbued with classical oriental aesthetics. A beam of warm afternoon sunlight penetrates a dark wooden window lattice carved with intricate geometric patterns, casting a clear path through the air, and countless tiny dust particles drift slowly within the beam. A woman of ancient times, her hair tied high in a bun, sits quietly at the intersection of light and shadow. Her long, lustrous black hair is neatly tied up with an elegant jade hairpin, revealing her smooth forehead and graceful neck. The light precisely outlines her delicate profile, her high nose bridge, her thin, tightly pursed lips, and her long, slightly fluttering eyelashes casting a subtle shadow on her cheeks. Her expression is focused and peaceful. She wears an elegant moon-white silk gown, layered over a light gray cotton and linen double-breasted top. The sunlight illuminates the garment, revealing the delicate texture of the fabric. Her hands rest gracefully on her knees, her posture dignified and relaxed. The background is a simple traditional study, with mottled light and shadows from the window panes on the dark wooden floor. A table with writing brushes, ink, paper and inkstone on it can be vaguely seen in the corner of the far wall. The whole picture has soft and warm tones, creating a secluded, quiet and introverted poetic atmosphere.", + "seed": 8663, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_12/index_9466_seed_8663_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04521662564948201, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04521662564948201, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04521662564948201, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static medium shot from a sideways angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with ancient-style hair tied in a bun and adorned with a jade hairpin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a moon-white silk gown layered over a light gray cotton and linen double-breasted top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a traditional study with a dark wooden window lattice and a table containing writing brushes, ink, paper, and an inkstone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight visible penetrating the window and illuminating dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029945608228445053 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7799456119537354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029945608228445053, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029945608228445053, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06815019249916077, + 0.17158463597297668, + 0.04830193519592285, + 0.03499727323651314, + 0.07739971578121185, + 0.068893201649189, + 0.0810508280992508, + 0.03313281759619713, + 0.2919522821903229, + 0.1245371401309967 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029945608228445053 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static medium shot from a sideways angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with ancient-style hair tied in a bun and adorned with a jade hairpin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a moon-white silk gown layered over a light gray cotton and linen double-breasted top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a traditional study with a dark wooden window lattice and a table containing writing brushes, ink, paper, and an inkstone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight visible penetrating the window and illuminating dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004656542558223009 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.3796563148498535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004656542558223009, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004656542558223009, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10335391759872437, + 0.07798410952091217, + 0.053725361824035645, + 0.034198831766843796, + 0.11656418442726135, + 0.04735509306192398, + 0.023447467014193535, + 0.03487895056605339, + 0.07506350427865982, + 0.433428555727005 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004656542558223009 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static medium shot from a sideways angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with ancient-style hair tied in a bun and adorned with a jade hairpin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a moon-white silk gown layered over a light gray cotton and linen double-breasted top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a traditional study with a dark wooden window lattice and a table containing writing brushes, ink, paper, and an inkstone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight visible penetrating the window and illuminating dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12705445289611816 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127054452896118 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12705445289611816, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12705445289611816, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06907375901937485, + 0.05968421697616577, + 0.059141822159290314, + 0.055309150367975235, + 0.15453319251537323, + 0.05472612753510475, + 0.028659624978899956, + 0.023060929030179977, + 0.044610314071178436, + 0.45120084285736084 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12705445289611816 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static medium shot from a sideways angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with ancient-style hair tied in a bun and adorned with a jade hairpin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a moon-white silk gown layered over a light gray cotton and linen double-breasted top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a traditional study with a dark wooden window lattice and a table containing writing brushes, ink, paper, and an inkstone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight visible penetrating the window and illuminating dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026337487623095512 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513373851776123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026337487623095512, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026337487623095512, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05544723570346832, + 0.023212675005197525, + 0.03813423216342926, + 0.021428285166621208, + 0.1706325262784958, + 0.12304145842790604, + 0.08780275285243988, + 0.038883235305547714, + 0.11175864934921265, + 0.32965901494026184 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026337487623095512 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static medium shot from a sideways angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with ancient-style hair tied in a bun and adorned with a jade hairpin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a moon-white silk gown layered over a light gray cotton and linen double-breasted top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a traditional study with a dark wooden window lattice and a table containing writing brushes, ink, paper, and an inkstone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight visible penetrating the window and illuminating dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03808903694152832 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880890369415283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03808903694152832, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03808903694152832, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12150301039218903, + 0.14877213537693024, + 0.04327353462576866, + 0.02336518093943596, + 0.057842060923576355, + 0.047793515026569366, + 0.05320734158158302, + 0.09033523499965668, + 0.09451941400766373, + 0.3193885385990143 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03808903694152832 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static medium shot, shot from a sideways angle, captures a tranquil moment imbued with classical oriental aesthetics. A beam of warm afternoon sunlight penetrates a dark wooden window lattice carved with intricate geometric patterns, casting a clear path through the air, and countless tiny dust particles drift slowly within the beam. A woman of ancient times, her hair tied high in a bun, sits quietly at the intersection of light and shadow. Her long, lustrous black hair is neatly tied up with an elegant jade hairpin, revealing her smooth forehead and graceful neck. The light precisely outlines her delicate profile, her high nose bridge, her thin, tightly pursed lips, and her long, slightly fluttering eyelashes casting a subtle shadow on her cheeks. Her expression is focused and peaceful. She wears an elegant moon-white silk gown, layered over a light gray cotton and linen double-breasted top. The sunlight illuminates the garment, revealing the delicate texture of the fabric. Her hands rest gracefully on her knees, her posture dignified and relaxed. The background is a simple traditional study, with mottled light and shadows from the window panes on the dark wooden floor. A table with writing brushes, ink, paper and inkstone on it can be vaguely seen in the corner of the far wall. The whole picture has soft and warm tones, creating a secluded, quiet and introverted poetic atmosphere.", + "seed": 8664, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_12/index_9466_seed_8664_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.05741786696016789, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05741786696016789, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05741786696016789, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static medium shot from a sideways angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with ancient-style hair tied in a bun and adorned with a jade hairpin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a moon-white silk gown layered over a light gray cotton and linen double-breasted top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a traditional study with a dark wooden window lattice and a table containing writing brushes, ink, paper, and an inkstone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight visible penetrating the window and illuminating dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038844410330057144 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.413844347000122 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038844410330057144, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038844410330057144, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6988744139671326, + 0.07399578392505646, + 0.04151728376746178, + 0.0392487533390522, + 0.05223347619175911, + 0.016421891748905182, + 0.02038486674427986, + 0.012350640259683132, + 0.021178318187594414, + 0.023794492706656456 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038844410330057144 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static medium shot from a sideways angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with ancient-style hair tied in a bun and adorned with a jade hairpin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a moon-white silk gown layered over a light gray cotton and linen double-breasted top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a traditional study with a dark wooden window lattice and a table containing writing brushes, ink, paper, and an inkstone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight visible penetrating the window and illuminating dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016087723895907402 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141087532043457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016087723895907402, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016087723895907402, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7686933875083923, + 0.13080964982509613, + 0.029039939865469933, + 0.011572017334401608, + 0.011498607695102692, + 0.008434327319264412, + 0.010695850476622581, + 0.007005831226706505, + 0.010572127066552639, + 0.011678187176585197 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016087723895907402 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static medium shot from a sideways angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with ancient-style hair tied in a bun and adorned with a jade hairpin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a moon-white silk gown layered over a light gray cotton and linen double-breasted top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a traditional study with a dark wooden window lattice and a table containing writing brushes, ink, paper, and an inkstone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight visible penetrating the window and illuminating dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17988188564777374 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048819303512573 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17988188564777374, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17988188564777374, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5707266330718994, + 0.24683944880962372, + 0.04147099331021309, + 0.01855093240737915, + 0.02349272184073925, + 0.014077442698180676, + 0.017590278759598732, + 0.016729041934013367, + 0.023922327905893326, + 0.0266001895070076 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17988188564777374 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static medium shot from a sideways angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with ancient-style hair tied in a bun and adorned with a jade hairpin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a moon-white silk gown layered over a light gray cotton and linen double-breasted top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a traditional study with a dark wooden window lattice and a table containing writing brushes, ink, paper, and an inkstone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight visible penetrating the window and illuminating dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014187425374984741 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264187335968018 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014187425374984741, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014187425374984741, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7662133574485779, + 0.08508831262588501, + 0.028637481853365898, + 0.011466309428215027, + 0.02723577618598938, + 0.015227193012833595, + 0.016288721933960915, + 0.011327391490340233, + 0.01837894134223461, + 0.020136520266532898 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014187425374984741 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a static medium shot from a sideways angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a woman with ancient-style hair tied in a bun and adorned with a jade hairpin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a moon-white silk gown layered over a light gray cotton and linen double-breasted top?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a traditional study with a dark wooden window lattice and a table containing writing brushes, ink, paper, and an inkstone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a beam of warm afternoon sunlight visible penetrating the window and illuminating dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038087889552116394 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288087844848633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038087889552116394, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038087889552116394, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.8615717887878418, + 0.0512567013502121, + 0.010873306542634964, + 0.009272992610931396, + 0.011763004586100578, + 0.006504217628389597, + 0.013397899456322193, + 0.009634369984269142, + 0.013685185462236404, + 0.012040538713335991 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038087889552116394 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_13/index_tensor([1014, 1014])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_13/index_tensor([1014, 1014])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b3f57f41af4802cbcb4ee31ef105cb111b49acb1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_13/index_tensor([1014, 1014])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The image begins from a low-angle perspective, deep within the turbulent, spray-soaked basin at the foot of the massive waterfall. The water violently churns into a chaotic vortex of white foam and powerful current, spewing a thick, roiling cloud of mist that saturates the air. The camera then begins a slow, majestic upward tilt, a seamless crane shot ascending through the luminous fog. As it rises, the lens glides over sheer, damp rock faces, their dark gray surfaces covered in green algae, shimmering under the constant spray. This vast expanse of water is not a single curtain but a complex, braided torrent, thousands of tons of water cascading relentlessly in a shimmering, translucent stream that captures the soft, diffused morning light. The camera movement culminates on the cliffs, a broad, jagged rim of ancient rock over which the river flows with immense and fluid force, before plunging into the abyss below, ultimately revealing the vast scale of this natural wonder against the backdrop of a dense, untouched forest canopy, creating a profound and overwhelming atmosphere of raw, natural grandeur beneath a pale, brooding sky.", + "seed": 30390, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_13/index_1014_seed_30390_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.18591382522135974, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18591382522135974, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18591382522135974, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin from a low-angle perspective at the foot of a massive waterfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water depicted as a chaotic vortex of white foam and a braided torrent rather than a single curtain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow upward tilt in a seamless crane shot ascending through mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark gray rock faces covered in green algae visible as the camera rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video reveal a broad, jagged cliff rim and a dense forest canopy against a pale, brooding sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5819849967956543 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8319849967956543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5819849967956543, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5819849967956543, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19153089821338654, + 0.11508939415216446, + 0.14827130734920502, + 0.047863759100437164, + 0.06189229339361191, + 0.08906100690364838, + 0.09752999991178513, + 0.07423200458288193, + 0.1146540492773056, + 0.05987531319260597 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5819849967956543 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin from a low-angle perspective at the foot of a massive waterfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water depicted as a chaotic vortex of white foam and a braided torrent rather than a single curtain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow upward tilt in a seamless crane shot ascending through mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark gray rock faces covered in green algae visible as the camera rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video reveal a broad, jagged cliff rim and a dense forest canopy against a pale, brooding sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023316839709877968 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733168601989746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023316839709877968, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023316839709877968, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17570465803146362, + 0.12953504920005798, + 0.13304929435253143, + 0.053397126495838165, + 0.045998234301805496, + 0.07534338533878326, + 0.05698825791478157, + 0.05270282179117203, + 0.23658572137355804, + 0.04069540277123451 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023316839709877968 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin from a low-angle perspective at the foot of a massive waterfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water depicted as a chaotic vortex of white foam and a braided torrent rather than a single curtain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow upward tilt in a seamless crane shot ascending through mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark gray rock faces covered in green algae visible as the camera rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video reveal a broad, jagged cliff rim and a dense forest canopy against a pale, brooding sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20155152678489685 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015515565872192 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20155152678489685, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20155152678489685, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17696991562843323, + 0.04918403550982475, + 0.12072531133890152, + 0.045374561101198196, + 0.05119602009654045, + 0.06485379487276077, + 0.05792821943759918, + 0.04594700410962105, + 0.3519035577774048, + 0.03591756150126457 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20155152678489685 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin from a low-angle perspective at the foot of a massive waterfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water depicted as a chaotic vortex of white foam and a braided torrent rather than a single curtain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow upward tilt in a seamless crane shot ascending through mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark gray rock faces covered in green algae visible as the camera rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video reveal a broad, jagged cliff rim and a dense forest canopy against a pale, brooding sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009787782095372677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634787559509277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009787782095372677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009787782095372677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1901397854089737, + 0.06957963109016418, + 0.06541454792022705, + 0.0659680888056755, + 0.06093339994549751, + 0.08266153186559677, + 0.051053736358881, + 0.14078277349472046, + 0.2208944708108902, + 0.05257202312350273 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009787782095372677 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin from a low-angle perspective at the foot of a massive waterfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water depicted as a chaotic vortex of white foam and a braided torrent rather than a single curtain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow upward tilt in a seamless crane shot ascending through mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark gray rock faces covered in green algae visible as the camera rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video reveal a broad, jagged cliff rim and a dense forest canopy against a pale, brooding sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11292798072099686 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379279136657715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11292798072099686, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11292798072099686, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2144162952899933, + 0.07100314646959305, + 0.06343672424554825, + 0.042028144001960754, + 0.0510384701192379, + 0.036472924053668976, + 0.022136850282549858, + 0.08591806888580322, + 0.3721781075000763, + 0.041371215134859085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11292798072099686 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The image begins from a low-angle perspective, deep within the turbulent, spray-soaked basin at the foot of the massive waterfall. The water violently churns into a chaotic vortex of white foam and powerful current, spewing a thick, roiling cloud of mist that saturates the air. The camera then begins a slow, majestic upward tilt, a seamless crane shot ascending through the luminous fog. As it rises, the lens glides over sheer, damp rock faces, their dark gray surfaces covered in green algae, shimmering under the constant spray. This vast expanse of water is not a single curtain but a complex, braided torrent, thousands of tons of water cascading relentlessly in a shimmering, translucent stream that captures the soft, diffused morning light. The camera movement culminates on the cliffs, a broad, jagged rim of ancient rock over which the river flows with immense and fluid force, before plunging into the abyss below, ultimately revealing the vast scale of this natural wonder against the backdrop of a dense, untouched forest canopy, creating a profound and overwhelming atmosphere of raw, natural grandeur beneath a pale, brooding sky.", + "seed": 30391, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_13/index_1014_seed_30391_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04327280670404434, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04327280670404434, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04327280670404434, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin from a low-angle perspective at the foot of a massive waterfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water depicted as a chaotic vortex of white foam and a braided torrent rather than a single curtain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow upward tilt in a seamless crane shot ascending through mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark gray rock faces covered in green algae visible as the camera rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video reveal a broad, jagged cliff rim and a dense forest canopy against a pale, brooding sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.111075758934021 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3610758781433105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.111075758934021, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.111075758934021, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20705942809581757, + 0.1106734424829483, + 0.054305147379636765, + 0.11282169818878174, + 0.06627830117940903, + 0.15986892580986023, + 0.08934676647186279, + 0.08885297179222107, + 0.06985411047935486, + 0.04093918949365616 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.111075758934021 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin from a low-angle perspective at the foot of a massive waterfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water depicted as a chaotic vortex of white foam and a braided torrent rather than a single curtain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow upward tilt in a seamless crane shot ascending through mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark gray rock faces covered in green algae visible as the camera rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video reveal a broad, jagged cliff rim and a dense forest canopy against a pale, brooding sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0430886335670948 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168088674545288 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0430886335670948, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0430886335670948, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11248474568128586, + 0.13032864034175873, + 0.1326560527086258, + 0.28847020864486694, + 0.09157615154981613, + 0.07006513327360153, + 0.041950199753046036, + 0.057541824877262115, + 0.042979538440704346, + 0.031947504729032516 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0430886335670948 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin from a low-angle perspective at the foot of a massive waterfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water depicted as a chaotic vortex of white foam and a braided torrent rather than a single curtain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow upward tilt in a seamless crane shot ascending through mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark gray rock faces covered in green algae visible as the camera rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video reveal a broad, jagged cliff rim and a dense forest canopy against a pale, brooding sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023301467299461365 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773301362991333 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023301467299461365, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023301467299461365, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17262721061706543, + 0.22429323196411133, + 0.14081303775310516, + 0.03604378178715706, + 0.04455291107296944, + 0.12069500982761383, + 0.11597677320241928, + 0.04444160684943199, + 0.05220010131597519, + 0.0483563132584095 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023301467299461365 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin from a low-angle perspective at the foot of a massive waterfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water depicted as a chaotic vortex of white foam and a braided torrent rather than a single curtain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow upward tilt in a seamless crane shot ascending through mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark gray rock faces covered in green algae visible as the camera rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video reveal a broad, jagged cliff rim and a dense forest canopy against a pale, brooding sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012545360252261162 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387545585632324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012545360252261162, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012545360252261162, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22692719101905823, + 0.30844274163246155, + 0.06633889675140381, + 0.03043665550649166, + 0.08583179861307144, + 0.04599592834711075, + 0.039910174906253815, + 0.04441550374031067, + 0.12679603695869446, + 0.02490507811307907 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012545360252261162 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin from a low-angle perspective at the foot of a massive waterfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water depicted as a chaotic vortex of white foam and a braided torrent rather than a single curtain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow upward tilt in a seamless crane shot ascending through mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark gray rock faces covered in green algae visible as the camera rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video reveal a broad, jagged cliff rim and a dense forest canopy against a pale, brooding sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026352813467383385 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651352882385254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026352813467383385, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026352813467383385, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2008628249168396, + 0.05045022442936897, + 0.14885149896144867, + 0.08639121800661087, + 0.06573322415351868, + 0.18939357995986938, + 0.07615382224321365, + 0.08296189457178116, + 0.047330185770988464, + 0.05187152698636055 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026352813467383385 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The image begins from a low-angle perspective, deep within the turbulent, spray-soaked basin at the foot of the massive waterfall. The water violently churns into a chaotic vortex of white foam and powerful current, spewing a thick, roiling cloud of mist that saturates the air. The camera then begins a slow, majestic upward tilt, a seamless crane shot ascending through the luminous fog. As it rises, the lens glides over sheer, damp rock faces, their dark gray surfaces covered in green algae, shimmering under the constant spray. This vast expanse of water is not a single curtain but a complex, braided torrent, thousands of tons of water cascading relentlessly in a shimmering, translucent stream that captures the soft, diffused morning light. The camera movement culminates on the cliffs, a broad, jagged rim of ancient rock over which the river flows with immense and fluid force, before plunging into the abyss below, ultimately revealing the vast scale of this natural wonder against the backdrop of a dense, untouched forest canopy, creating a profound and overwhelming atmosphere of raw, natural grandeur beneath a pale, brooding sky.", + "seed": 30392, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_13/index_1014_seed_30392_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11119015030562877, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11119015030562877, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11119015030562877, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin from a low-angle perspective at the foot of a massive waterfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water depicted as a chaotic vortex of white foam and a braided torrent rather than a single curtain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow upward tilt in a seamless crane shot ascending through mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark gray rock faces covered in green algae visible as the camera rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video reveal a broad, jagged cliff rim and a dense forest canopy against a pale, brooding sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.481370747089386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.981370747089386 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.481370747089386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.481370747089386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20676347613334656, + 0.08912219852209091, + 0.06188349425792694, + 0.1685144007205963, + 0.1565125584602356, + 0.01964476890861988, + 0.058348480612039566, + 0.05101421847939491, + 0.060331158339977264, + 0.1278652399778366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.481370747089386 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin from a low-angle perspective at the foot of a massive waterfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water depicted as a chaotic vortex of white foam and a braided torrent rather than a single curtain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow upward tilt in a seamless crane shot ascending through mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark gray rock faces covered in green algae visible as the camera rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video reveal a broad, jagged cliff rim and a dense forest canopy against a pale, brooding sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02331812120974064 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.77331805229187 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02331812120974064, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02331812120974064, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1370554119348526, + 0.16376106441020966, + 0.11435192823410034, + 0.13458256423473358, + 0.10450245440006256, + 0.041099417954683304, + 0.04261678457260132, + 0.05802347511053085, + 0.11609002947807312, + 0.08791691809892654 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02331812120974064 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin from a low-angle perspective at the foot of a massive waterfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water depicted as a chaotic vortex of white foam and a braided torrent rather than a single curtain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow upward tilt in a seamless crane shot ascending through mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark gray rock faces covered in green algae visible as the camera rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video reveal a broad, jagged cliff rim and a dense forest canopy against a pale, brooding sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329820580780506 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732982635498047 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329820580780506, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329820580780506, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08444972336292267, + 0.0675942599773407, + 0.1354408711194992, + 0.16421250998973846, + 0.09158740937709808, + 0.030547786504030228, + 0.10556987673044205, + 0.08467571437358856, + 0.10955678671598434, + 0.12636509537696838 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329820580780506 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin from a low-angle perspective at the foot of a massive waterfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water depicted as a chaotic vortex of white foam and a braided torrent rather than a single curtain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow upward tilt in a seamless crane shot ascending through mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark gray rock faces covered in green algae visible as the camera rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video reveal a broad, jagged cliff rim and a dense forest canopy against a pale, brooding sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009781407192349434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634781360626221 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009781407192349434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009781407192349434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1723800003528595, + 0.04880258068442345, + 0.11376166343688965, + 0.08648650348186493, + 0.10445670783519745, + 0.10479854047298431, + 0.054094426333904266, + 0.10708155483007431, + 0.08428341895341873, + 0.12385464459657669 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009781407192349434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin from a low-angle perspective at the foot of a massive waterfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water depicted as a chaotic vortex of white foam and a braided torrent rather than a single curtain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow upward tilt in a seamless crane shot ascending through mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark gray rock faces covered in green algae visible as the camera rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video reveal a broad, jagged cliff rim and a dense forest canopy against a pale, brooding sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018182270228862762 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018182277679443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018182270228862762, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018182270228862762, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0729404166340828, + 0.05649446323513985, + 0.06046216934919357, + 0.16866685450077057, + 0.05422477051615715, + 0.02613595500588417, + 0.07789500802755356, + 0.20612859725952148, + 0.0713357925415039, + 0.20571595430374146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018182270228862762 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The image begins from a low-angle perspective, deep within the turbulent, spray-soaked basin at the foot of the massive waterfall. The water violently churns into a chaotic vortex of white foam and powerful current, spewing a thick, roiling cloud of mist that saturates the air. The camera then begins a slow, majestic upward tilt, a seamless crane shot ascending through the luminous fog. As it rises, the lens glides over sheer, damp rock faces, their dark gray surfaces covered in green algae, shimmering under the constant spray. This vast expanse of water is not a single curtain but a complex, braided torrent, thousands of tons of water cascading relentlessly in a shimmering, translucent stream that captures the soft, diffused morning light. The camera movement culminates on the cliffs, a broad, jagged rim of ancient rock over which the river flows with immense and fluid force, before plunging into the abyss below, ultimately revealing the vast scale of this natural wonder against the backdrop of a dense, untouched forest canopy, creating a profound and overwhelming atmosphere of raw, natural grandeur beneath a pale, brooding sky.", + "seed": 30393, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_13/index_1014_seed_30393_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.05138782896101475, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05138782896101475, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05138782896101475, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin from a low-angle perspective at the foot of a massive waterfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water depicted as a chaotic vortex of white foam and a braided torrent rather than a single curtain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow upward tilt in a seamless crane shot ascending through mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark gray rock faces covered in green algae visible as the camera rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video reveal a broad, jagged cliff rim and a dense forest canopy against a pale, brooding sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1637493520975113 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.91374933719635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1637493520975113, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1637493520975113, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.026849443092942238, + 0.18861889839172363, + 0.02189859002828598, + 0.4571883976459503, + 0.05172036960721016, + 0.062176015228033066, + 0.026295607909560204, + 0.05948192998766899, + 0.04899342358112335, + 0.056777290999889374 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1637493520975113 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin from a low-angle perspective at the foot of a massive waterfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water depicted as a chaotic vortex of white foam and a braided torrent rather than a single curtain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow upward tilt in a seamless crane shot ascending through mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark gray rock faces covered in green algae visible as the camera rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video reveal a broad, jagged cliff rim and a dense forest canopy against a pale, brooding sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012567255645990372 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387567043304443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012567255645990372, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012567255645990372, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06631510704755783, + 0.046413056552410126, + 0.027532430365681648, + 0.4081069529056549, + 0.03402484208345413, + 0.03138964623212814, + 0.0384274423122406, + 0.06547974050045013, + 0.23647475242614746, + 0.0458359457552433 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012567255645990372 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin from a low-angle perspective at the foot of a massive waterfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water depicted as a chaotic vortex of white foam and a braided torrent rather than a single curtain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow upward tilt in a seamless crane shot ascending through mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark gray rock faces covered in green algae visible as the camera rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video reveal a broad, jagged cliff rim and a dense forest canopy against a pale, brooding sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634573169052601 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651345729827881 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634573169052601, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634573169052601, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.037288106977939606, + 0.48282769322395325, + 0.034986112266778946, + 0.05561075359582901, + 0.039171990007162094, + 0.02383933961391449, + 0.04420910030603409, + 0.17897538840770721, + 0.08071441203355789, + 0.02237716130912304 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634573169052601 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin from a low-angle perspective at the foot of a massive waterfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water depicted as a chaotic vortex of white foam and a braided torrent rather than a single curtain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow upward tilt in a seamless crane shot ascending through mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark gray rock faces covered in green algae visible as the camera rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video reveal a broad, jagged cliff rim and a dense forest canopy against a pale, brooding sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369683399796486 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086968898773193 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369683399796486, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369683399796486, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10186023265123367, + 0.2214222550392151, + 0.040063921362161636, + 0.3083544075489044, + 0.062468841671943665, + 0.027596721425652504, + 0.05477096512913704, + 0.0462789386510849, + 0.08289643377065659, + 0.054287251085042953 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369683399796486 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin from a low-angle perspective at the foot of a massive waterfall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the water depicted as a chaotic vortex of white foam and a braided torrent rather than a single curtain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow upward tilt in a seamless crane shot ascending through mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark gray rock faces covered in green algae visible as the camera rises?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video reveal a broad, jagged cliff rim and a dense forest canopy against a pale, brooding sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020579971373081207 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955800533294678 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020579971373081207, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020579971373081207, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06144452840089798, + 0.33882617950439453, + 0.04902230203151703, + 0.13292667269706726, + 0.07352175563573837, + 0.022404763847589493, + 0.07710421830415726, + 0.05052756890654564, + 0.11363738775253296, + 0.08058451861143112 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020579971373081207 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_14/index_tensor([1401, 1401])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_14/index_tensor([1401, 1401])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1c8284bde64f4c3074dbe2ae3e0523c465558947 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_14/index_tensor([1401, 1401])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures the profound tranquility of a traditional Chinese garden, the camera held perfectly still, documenting a breathtaking passage of time. At the center of the frame stands a majestic ancient tree, its dark, gnarled trunk deeply cracked by age, its bare branches unfurling in intricate, sculptural patterns. In the soft background, a classic wooden cottage, with an elegantly curved, dark gray tiled roof and delicate latticed windows, sits beside a tranquil, reflective pond. As the time-lapse sequence begins, the sun's path is rapidly traced across the sky, causing shadows to dance across meticulously raked gravel and moss-covered stones. On the branches, thousands of tightly packed deep pink buds begin to swell, then unfold in a swift, silent, and graceful ballet. Each flower deliberately opens, its delicate, paper-thin petals expanding from closed spirals to full, soft-pink blossoms, creating a visual transformation from stark, wintry silhouettes to vibrant, cloud-like blooms. The light shifts dynamically from the cool, crisp light of early morning to the warm, golden tones of late afternoon, illuminating the translucence of the petals and deepening the serene, contemplative, and breathtaking atmosphere of the scene.", + "seed": 16693, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_14/index_1401_seed_16693_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07027611373923719, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07027611373923719, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07027611373923719, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a majestic ancient tree with a dark, gnarled, deeply cracked trunk visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a classic wooden cottage with a dark gray tiled roof and latticed windows visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do deep pink buds on the tree branches rapidly swell and unfold into full blossoms during the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting shift dynamically from cool early morning tones to warm late afternoon golden tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11783643811941147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2428364753723145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11783643811941147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11783643811941147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17230890691280365, + 0.04453020542860031, + 0.03644609451293945, + 0.039275508373975754, + 0.03212597221136093, + 0.031124288216233253, + 0.18628345429897308, + 0.20554302632808685, + 0.10723378509283066, + 0.1451287865638733 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11783643811941147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a majestic ancient tree with a dark, gnarled, deeply cracked trunk visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a classic wooden cottage with a dark gray tiled roof and latticed windows visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do deep pink buds on the tree branches rapidly swell and unfold into full blossoms during the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting shift dynamically from cool early morning tones to warm late afternoon golden tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001729184528812766 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.3767290115356445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001729184528812766, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001729184528812766, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13951505720615387, + 0.061367981135845184, + 0.045014217495918274, + 0.07522012293338776, + 0.032686829566955566, + 0.047920744866132736, + 0.13376574218273163, + 0.18755964934825897, + 0.1506480723619461, + 0.12630151212215424 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001729184528812766 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a majestic ancient tree with a dark, gnarled, deeply cracked trunk visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a classic wooden cottage with a dark gray tiled roof and latticed windows visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do deep pink buds on the tree branches rapidly swell and unfold into full blossoms during the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting shift dynamically from cool early morning tones to warm late afternoon golden tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014190598390996456 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264190673828125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014190598390996456, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014190598390996456, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11718274652957916, + 0.17357668280601501, + 0.07912235707044601, + 0.06965730339288712, + 0.07674875110387802, + 0.034725964069366455, + 0.0866372212767601, + 0.1633228361606598, + 0.07406951487064362, + 0.1249566376209259 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014190598390996456 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a majestic ancient tree with a dark, gnarled, deeply cracked trunk visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a classic wooden cottage with a dark gray tiled roof and latticed windows visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do deep pink buds on the tree branches rapidly swell and unfold into full blossoms during the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting shift dynamically from cool early morning tones to warm late afternoon golden tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016062971204519272 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410627365112305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016062971204519272, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016062971204519272, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0800422877073288, + 0.04275289922952652, + 0.01829810068011284, + 0.05013953149318695, + 0.044373057782649994, + 0.042355556041002274, + 0.1888524889945984, + 0.21027366816997528, + 0.1004667654633522, + 0.22244565188884735 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016062971204519272 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a majestic ancient tree with a dark, gnarled, deeply cracked trunk visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a classic wooden cottage with a dark gray tiled roof and latticed windows visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do deep pink buds on the tree branches rapidly swell and unfold into full blossoms during the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting shift dynamically from cool early morning tones to warm late afternoon golden tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20156137645244598 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015613317489624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20156137645244598, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20156137645244598, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08086119592189789, + 0.03202500194311142, + 0.02620070055127144, + 0.0388907715678215, + 0.029202211648225784, + 0.02655322663486004, + 0.17426294088363647, + 0.2045399248600006, + 0.12675528228282928, + 0.260708749294281 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20156137645244598 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures the profound tranquility of a traditional Chinese garden, the camera held perfectly still, documenting a breathtaking passage of time. At the center of the frame stands a majestic ancient tree, its dark, gnarled trunk deeply cracked by age, its bare branches unfurling in intricate, sculptural patterns. In the soft background, a classic wooden cottage, with an elegantly curved, dark gray tiled roof and delicate latticed windows, sits beside a tranquil, reflective pond. As the time-lapse sequence begins, the sun's path is rapidly traced across the sky, causing shadows to dance across meticulously raked gravel and moss-covered stones. On the branches, thousands of tightly packed deep pink buds begin to swell, then unfold in a swift, silent, and graceful ballet. Each flower deliberately opens, its delicate, paper-thin petals expanding from closed spirals to full, soft-pink blossoms, creating a visual transformation from stark, wintry silhouettes to vibrant, cloud-like blooms. The light shifts dynamically from the cool, crisp light of early morning to the warm, golden tones of late afternoon, illuminating the translucence of the petals and deepening the serene, contemplative, and breathtaking atmosphere of the scene.", + "seed": 16694, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_14/index_1401_seed_16694_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.14027751013636588, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14027751013636588, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14027751013636588, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a majestic ancient tree with a dark, gnarled, deeply cracked trunk visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a classic wooden cottage with a dark gray tiled roof and latticed windows visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do deep pink buds on the tree branches rapidly swell and unfold into full blossoms during the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting shift dynamically from cool early morning tones to warm late afternoon golden tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28612440824508667 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4111244678497314 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28612440824508667, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28612440824508667, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24368484318256378, + 0.08202867209911346, + 0.08006148040294647, + 0.10463881492614746, + 0.08345185965299606, + 0.047363851219415665, + 0.04176441580057144, + 0.06466397643089294, + 0.12977415323257446, + 0.12256798148155212 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28612440824508667 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a majestic ancient tree with a dark, gnarled, deeply cracked trunk visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a classic wooden cottage with a dark gray tiled roof and latticed windows visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do deep pink buds on the tree branches rapidly swell and unfold into full blossoms during the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting shift dynamically from cool early morning tones to warm late afternoon golden tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002213291823863983 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127213478088379 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002213291823863983, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002213291823863983, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19655103981494904, + 0.15868708491325378, + 0.05576564371585846, + 0.052029527723789215, + 0.03519923612475395, + 0.03948889672756195, + 0.12482587993144989, + 0.1217455267906189, + 0.1287505179643631, + 0.08695666491985321 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002213291823863983 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a majestic ancient tree with a dark, gnarled, deeply cracked trunk visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a classic wooden cottage with a dark gray tiled roof and latticed windows visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do deep pink buds on the tree branches rapidly swell and unfold into full blossoms during the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting shift dynamically from cool early morning tones to warm late afternoon golden tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0380881205201149 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288088083267212 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0380881205201149, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0380881205201149, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24209368228912354, + 0.2014605551958084, + 0.08351241797208786, + 0.053288135677576065, + 0.06667310744524002, + 0.03889133408665657, + 0.04246440529823303, + 0.04646381363272667, + 0.1571064293384552, + 0.06804608553647995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0380881205201149 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a majestic ancient tree with a dark, gnarled, deeply cracked trunk visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a classic wooden cottage with a dark gray tiled roof and latticed windows visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do deep pink buds on the tree branches rapidly swell and unfold into full blossoms during the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting shift dynamically from cool early morning tones to warm late afternoon golden tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026335861533880234 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513359546661377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026335861533880234, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026335861533880234, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08357878029346466, + 0.05489807203412056, + 0.05850039795041084, + 0.07374367862939835, + 0.05816671997308731, + 0.06258659809827805, + 0.15454262495040894, + 0.2090921700000763, + 0.16732090711593628, + 0.07757002115249634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026335861533880234 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a majestic ancient tree with a dark, gnarled, deeply cracked trunk visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a classic wooden cottage with a dark gray tiled roof and latticed windows visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do deep pink buds on the tree branches rapidly swell and unfold into full blossoms during the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting shift dynamically from cool early morning tones to warm late afternoon golden tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34862586855888367 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223625898361206 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34862586855888367, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34862586855888367, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2193135768175125, + 0.061292681843042374, + 0.04654094949364662, + 0.05870857834815979, + 0.07564237713813782, + 0.06296782940626144, + 0.05623283237218857, + 0.11693369597196579, + 0.15117771923542023, + 0.15118972957134247 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34862586855888367 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures the profound tranquility of a traditional Chinese garden, the camera held perfectly still, documenting a breathtaking passage of time. At the center of the frame stands a majestic ancient tree, its dark, gnarled trunk deeply cracked by age, its bare branches unfurling in intricate, sculptural patterns. In the soft background, a classic wooden cottage, with an elegantly curved, dark gray tiled roof and delicate latticed windows, sits beside a tranquil, reflective pond. As the time-lapse sequence begins, the sun's path is rapidly traced across the sky, causing shadows to dance across meticulously raked gravel and moss-covered stones. On the branches, thousands of tightly packed deep pink buds begin to swell, then unfold in a swift, silent, and graceful ballet. Each flower deliberately opens, its delicate, paper-thin petals expanding from closed spirals to full, soft-pink blossoms, creating a visual transformation from stark, wintry silhouettes to vibrant, cloud-like blooms. The light shifts dynamically from the cool, crisp light of early morning to the warm, golden tones of late afternoon, illuminating the translucence of the petals and deepening the serene, contemplative, and breathtaking atmosphere of the scene.", + "seed": 16695, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_14/index_1401_seed_16695_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11234281635843217, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11234281635843217, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11234281635843217, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a majestic ancient tree with a dark, gnarled, deeply cracked trunk visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a classic wooden cottage with a dark gray tiled roof and latticed windows visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do deep pink buds on the tree branches rapidly swell and unfold into full blossoms during the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting shift dynamically from cool early morning tones to warm late afternoon golden tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28510332107543945 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4101033210754395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28510332107543945, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28510332107543945, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1851963847875595, + 0.07668597251176834, + 0.1737215518951416, + 0.04619603604078293, + 0.06448324024677277, + 0.03393394127488136, + 0.16161929070949554, + 0.1627247929573059, + 0.03400669991970062, + 0.06143205612897873 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28510332107543945 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a majestic ancient tree with a dark, gnarled, deeply cracked trunk visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a classic wooden cottage with a dark gray tiled roof and latticed windows visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do deep pink buds on the tree branches rapidly swell and unfold into full blossoms during the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting shift dynamically from cool early morning tones to warm late afternoon golden tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022107940167188644 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.12721061706543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022107940167188644, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022107940167188644, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21907265484333038, + 0.12748898565769196, + 0.08213184028863907, + 0.08690732717514038, + 0.06050993129611015, + 0.047649186104536057, + 0.1134122908115387, + 0.10516023635864258, + 0.08509834110736847, + 0.07256919890642166 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022107940167188644 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a majestic ancient tree with a dark, gnarled, deeply cracked trunk visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a classic wooden cottage with a dark gray tiled roof and latticed windows visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do deep pink buds on the tree branches rapidly swell and unfold into full blossoms during the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting shift dynamically from cool early morning tones to warm late afternoon golden tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07001747936010361 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950175762176514 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07001747936010361, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07001747936010361, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20507484674453735, + 0.19470208883285522, + 0.06181009113788605, + 0.07448737323284149, + 0.1632101982831955, + 0.07000581175088882, + 0.026866037398576736, + 0.07169939577579498, + 0.07067026942968369, + 0.06147391349077225 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07001747936010361 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a majestic ancient tree with a dark, gnarled, deeply cracked trunk visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a classic wooden cottage with a dark gray tiled roof and latticed windows visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do deep pink buds on the tree branches rapidly swell and unfold into full blossoms during the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting shift dynamically from cool early morning tones to warm late afternoon golden tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028166405390948057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877816677093506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028166405390948057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028166405390948057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17326468229293823, + 0.14197753369808197, + 0.19077616930007935, + 0.03042224422097206, + 0.03676098212599754, + 0.030241474509239197, + 0.06871016323566437, + 0.15243956446647644, + 0.08951839059591293, + 0.08588885515928268 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028166405390948057 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a majestic ancient tree with a dark, gnarled, deeply cracked trunk visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a classic wooden cottage with a dark gray tiled roof and latticed windows visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do deep pink buds on the tree branches rapidly swell and unfold into full blossoms during the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting shift dynamically from cool early morning tones to warm late afternoon golden tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20156584680080414 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015658617019653 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20156584680080414, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20156584680080414, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3201741576194763, + 0.11698323488235474, + 0.048638880252838135, + 0.022190958261489868, + 0.08069200068712234, + 0.11422896385192871, + 0.1266605705022812, + 0.06859450042247772, + 0.0279233381152153, + 0.0739133358001709 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20156584680080414 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level wide-angle shot captures the profound tranquility of a traditional Chinese garden, the camera held perfectly still, documenting a breathtaking passage of time. At the center of the frame stands a majestic ancient tree, its dark, gnarled trunk deeply cracked by age, its bare branches unfurling in intricate, sculptural patterns. In the soft background, a classic wooden cottage, with an elegantly curved, dark gray tiled roof and delicate latticed windows, sits beside a tranquil, reflective pond. As the time-lapse sequence begins, the sun's path is rapidly traced across the sky, causing shadows to dance across meticulously raked gravel and moss-covered stones. On the branches, thousands of tightly packed deep pink buds begin to swell, then unfold in a swift, silent, and graceful ballet. Each flower deliberately opens, its delicate, paper-thin petals expanding from closed spirals to full, soft-pink blossoms, creating a visual transformation from stark, wintry silhouettes to vibrant, cloud-like blooms. The light shifts dynamically from the cool, crisp light of early morning to the warm, golden tones of late afternoon, illuminating the translucence of the petals and deepening the serene, contemplative, and breathtaking atmosphere of the scene.", + "seed": 16696, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_14/index_1401_seed_16696_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.095659133605659, + "vlm_logprob": -0.095659133605659, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.095659133605659, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a majestic ancient tree with a dark, gnarled, deeply cracked trunk visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a classic wooden cottage with a dark gray tiled roof and latticed windows visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do deep pink buds on the tree branches rapidly swell and unfold into full blossoms during the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting shift dynamically from cool early morning tones to warm late afternoon golden tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.23147882521152496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6064788103103638 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.23147882521152496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.23147882521152496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11188678443431854, + 0.09408090263605118, + 0.02741416171193123, + 0.10502476990222931, + 0.05049481242895126, + 0.17580436170101166, + 0.08524883538484573, + 0.1480550765991211, + 0.06823515146970749, + 0.1337551772594452 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.23147882521152496 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a majestic ancient tree with a dark, gnarled, deeply cracked trunk visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a classic wooden cottage with a dark gray tiled roof and latticed windows visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do deep pink buds on the tree branches rapidly swell and unfold into full blossoms during the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting shift dynamically from cool early morning tones to warm late afternoon golden tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0025054989382624626 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002505302429199 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0025054989382624626, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0025054989382624626, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21984167397022247, + 0.06823589652776718, + 0.029665948823094368, + 0.031633663922548294, + 0.09731651097536087, + 0.2045729160308838, + 0.06139974296092987, + 0.08040156960487366, + 0.04504656046628952, + 0.16188552975654602 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0025054989382624626 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a majestic ancient tree with a dark, gnarled, deeply cracked trunk visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a classic wooden cottage with a dark gray tiled roof and latticed windows visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do deep pink buds on the tree branches rapidly swell and unfold into full blossoms during the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting shift dynamically from cool early morning tones to warm late afternoon golden tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026342712342739105 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513426303863525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026342712342739105, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026342712342739105, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13823769986629486, + 0.04516398534178734, + 0.07198752462863922, + 0.03725804388523102, + 0.0418279767036438, + 0.12659823894500732, + 0.15200628340244293, + 0.29120272397994995, + 0.04989950731396675, + 0.04581804946064949 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026342712342739105 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a majestic ancient tree with a dark, gnarled, deeply cracked trunk visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a classic wooden cottage with a dark gray tiled roof and latticed windows visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do deep pink buds on the tree branches rapidly swell and unfold into full blossoms during the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting shift dynamically from cool early morning tones to warm late afternoon golden tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038092825561761856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288092851638794 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038092825561761856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038092825561761856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05331456661224365, + 0.027467016130685806, + 0.023315437138080597, + 0.03611006960272789, + 0.03591819480061531, + 0.09389589726924896, + 0.054506801068782806, + 0.32955098152160645, + 0.061317212879657745, + 0.2846037745475769 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038092825561761856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level wide-angle view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a majestic ancient tree with a dark, gnarled, deeply cracked trunk visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a classic wooden cottage with a dark gray tiled roof and latticed windows visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do deep pink buds on the tree branches rapidly swell and unfold into full blossoms during the sequence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting shift dynamically from cool early morning tones to warm late afternoon golden tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17987580597400665 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048758506774902 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17987580597400665, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17987580597400665, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18710023164749146, + 0.047592513263225555, + 0.026866503059864044, + 0.04830573871731758, + 0.043566759675741196, + 0.11716540902853012, + 0.08525128662586212, + 0.06591706722974777, + 0.1437292993068695, + 0.23450513184070587 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17987580597400665 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_15/index_tensor([5239, 5239])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_15/index_tensor([5239, 5239])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3015725256c2a5b4e445955242e885f7ee3b6c29 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_15/index_tensor([5239, 5239])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static shot, shot vertically from high above, captures a meteorite, its surface rugged and deep, charred texture, streaking through the inky blackness of space, hurtling towards a vast, dead lunar landscape. This surface, a patchwork of gray, is dotted with sharp-edged craters of varying sizes, casting deep, elongated shadows against the cold light of a distant sun. In the silent vacuum, the meteorite instantly impacts the lunar surface, unleashing a brief, blinding, incandescent flash. Immediately thereafter, a massive shock wave, centered at the impact point, violently hurls a vast cloud of lunar dust and rock fragments in a spectacular, radial pattern, forming an expanding, swirling gray cloud that rapidly engulfs the surrounding crater landscape. The entire process, silent yet imbued with a sense of destructive power, creates an atmosphere of vast, cold, and magnificent cosmic collision.", + "seed": 13142, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_15/index_5239_seed_13142_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08790598749183118, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08790598749183118, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08790598749183118, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot vertically from high above looking down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a meteorite with a rugged, charred texture visible streaking through space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast lunar landscape with gray surfaces and sharp-edged craters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the meteorite impacting the surface and creating a blinding incandescent flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a massive shock wave hurl a radial, expanding cloud of dust and rock fragments after the impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4165668785572052 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1665668487548828 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4165668785572052, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4165668785572052, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14073622226715088, + 0.1669960916042328, + 0.10583804547786713, + 0.08616778254508972, + 0.07596562057733536, + 0.032445259392261505, + 0.06405059248209, + 0.07579036802053452, + 0.19350014626979828, + 0.058509811758995056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4165668785572052 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot vertically from high above looking down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a meteorite with a rugged, charred texture visible streaking through space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast lunar landscape with gray surfaces and sharp-edged craters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the meteorite impacting the surface and creating a blinding incandescent flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a massive shock wave hurl a radial, expanding cloud of dust and rock fragments after the impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011111760511994362 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511111736297607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011111760511994362, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011111760511994362, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25714635848999023, + 0.09342115372419357, + 0.15153768658638, + 0.10533104836940765, + 0.04021325334906578, + 0.027938665822148323, + 0.03928089886903763, + 0.06503012776374817, + 0.1464076042175293, + 0.07369319349527359 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011111760511994362 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot vertically from high above looking down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a meteorite with a rugged, charred texture visible streaking through space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast lunar landscape with gray surfaces and sharp-edged craters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the meteorite impacting the surface and creating a blinding incandescent flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a massive shock wave hurl a radial, expanding cloud of dust and rock fragments after the impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007643500808626413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882643699645996 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007643500808626413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007643500808626413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18416433036327362, + 0.0683315098285675, + 0.1390451341867447, + 0.10205750167369843, + 0.06256943196058273, + 0.05203643813729286, + 0.0763821005821228, + 0.0765177384018898, + 0.15858617424964905, + 0.08030962944030762 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007643500808626413 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot vertically from high above looking down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a meteorite with a rugged, charred texture visible streaking through space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast lunar landscape with gray surfaces and sharp-edged craters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the meteorite impacting the surface and creating a blinding incandescent flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a massive shock wave hurl a radial, expanding cloud of dust and rock fragments after the impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024937265552580357 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002493858337402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024937265552580357, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024937265552580357, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13298507034778595, + 0.08920459449291229, + 0.09937969595193863, + 0.08606244623661041, + 0.04121694341301918, + 0.029221748933196068, + 0.0731239765882492, + 0.05570129677653313, + 0.09205886721611023, + 0.30104535818099976 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024937265552580357 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot vertically from high above looking down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a meteorite with a rugged, charred texture visible streaking through space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast lunar landscape with gray surfaces and sharp-edged craters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the meteorite impacting the surface and creating a blinding incandescent flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a massive shock wave hurl a radial, expanding cloud of dust and rock fragments after the impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001714071026071906 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.37671422958374 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001714071026071906, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001714071026071906, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11490602791309357, + 0.0917651504278183, + 0.0671762153506279, + 0.06942863762378693, + 0.038337767124176025, + 0.036721404641866684, + 0.1116827130317688, + 0.0766642689704895, + 0.07693242281675339, + 0.3163853585720062 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001714071026071906 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static shot, shot vertically from high above, captures a meteorite, its surface rugged and deep, charred texture, streaking through the inky blackness of space, hurtling towards a vast, dead lunar landscape. This surface, a patchwork of gray, is dotted with sharp-edged craters of varying sizes, casting deep, elongated shadows against the cold light of a distant sun. In the silent vacuum, the meteorite instantly impacts the lunar surface, unleashing a brief, blinding, incandescent flash. Immediately thereafter, a massive shock wave, centered at the impact point, violently hurls a vast cloud of lunar dust and rock fragments in a spectacular, radial pattern, forming an expanding, swirling gray cloud that rapidly engulfs the surrounding crater landscape. The entire process, silent yet imbued with a sense of destructive power, creates an atmosphere of vast, cold, and magnificent cosmic collision.", + "seed": 13143, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_15/index_5239_seed_13143_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.17870013660285622, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17870013660285622, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17870013660285622, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot vertically from high above looking down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a meteorite with a rugged, charred texture visible streaking through space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast lunar landscape with gray surfaces and sharp-edged craters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the meteorite impacting the surface and creating a blinding incandescent flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a massive shock wave hurl a radial, expanding cloud of dust and rock fragments after the impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8384923934936523 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5884923934936523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8384923934936523, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8384923934936523, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14835600554943085, + 0.32518285512924194, + 0.039674535393714905, + 0.07154083997011185, + 0.1011214330792427, + 0.021566743031144142, + 0.055739626288414, + 0.028143981471657753, + 0.03848985210061073, + 0.17018410563468933 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8384923934936523 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot vertically from high above looking down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a meteorite with a rugged, charred texture visible streaking through space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast lunar landscape with gray surfaces and sharp-edged craters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the meteorite impacting the surface and creating a blinding incandescent flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a massive shock wave hurl a radial, expanding cloud of dust and rock fragments after the impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018219027668237686 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018218994140625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018219027668237686, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018219027668237686, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1725338250398636, + 0.12778054177761078, + 0.09111540019512177, + 0.16213658452033997, + 0.09886541217565536, + 0.06503278017044067, + 0.07390450686216354, + 0.04152178764343262, + 0.0526241660118103, + 0.11448502540588379 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018219027668237686 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot vertically from high above looking down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a meteorite with a rugged, charred texture visible streaking through space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast lunar landscape with gray surfaces and sharp-edged craters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the meteorite impacting the surface and creating a blinding incandescent flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a massive shock wave hurl a radial, expanding cloud of dust and rock fragments after the impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029819726943969727 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298197269439697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029819726943969727, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029819726943969727, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11734899133443832, + 0.05162859335541725, + 0.08599952608346939, + 0.47677353024482727, + 0.026441536843776703, + 0.02982516586780548, + 0.031996846199035645, + 0.012682625092566013, + 0.0356891006231308, + 0.13161411881446838 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029819726943969727 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot vertically from high above looking down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a meteorite with a rugged, charred texture visible streaking through space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast lunar landscape with gray surfaces and sharp-edged craters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the meteorite impacting the surface and creating a blinding incandescent flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a massive shock wave hurl a radial, expanding cloud of dust and rock fragments after the impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001716570113785565 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376716613769531 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001716570113785565, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001716570113785565, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11796891689300537, + 0.1509876698255539, + 0.06278789788484573, + 0.021394697949290276, + 0.21932290494441986, + 0.1836237907409668, + 0.021148571744561195, + 0.017007067799568176, + 0.01970154233276844, + 0.1860569268465042 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001716570113785565 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot vertically from high above looking down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a meteorite with a rugged, charred texture visible streaking through space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast lunar landscape with gray surfaces and sharp-edged craters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the meteorite impacting the surface and creating a blinding incandescent flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a massive shock wave hurl a radial, expanding cloud of dust and rock fragments after the impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005252964794635773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255252838134766 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005252964794635773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005252964794635773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08535467088222504, + 0.1708349585533142, + 0.06708431243896484, + 0.0575178861618042, + 0.18372872471809387, + 0.08331497013568878, + 0.03135323524475098, + 0.016534846276044846, + 0.04377153515815735, + 0.2605048418045044 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005252964794635773 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static shot, shot vertically from high above, captures a meteorite, its surface rugged and deep, charred texture, streaking through the inky blackness of space, hurtling towards a vast, dead lunar landscape. This surface, a patchwork of gray, is dotted with sharp-edged craters of varying sizes, casting deep, elongated shadows against the cold light of a distant sun. In the silent vacuum, the meteorite instantly impacts the lunar surface, unleashing a brief, blinding, incandescent flash. Immediately thereafter, a massive shock wave, centered at the impact point, violently hurls a vast cloud of lunar dust and rock fragments in a spectacular, radial pattern, forming an expanding, swirling gray cloud that rapidly engulfs the surrounding crater landscape. The entire process, silent yet imbued with a sense of destructive power, creates an atmosphere of vast, cold, and magnificent cosmic collision.", + "seed": 13144, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_15/index_5239_seed_13144_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.14196092868223786, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14196092868223786, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14196092868223786, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot vertically from high above looking down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a meteorite with a rugged, charred texture visible streaking through space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast lunar landscape with gray surfaces and sharp-edged craters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the meteorite impacting the surface and creating a blinding incandescent flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a massive shock wave hurl a radial, expanding cloud of dust and rock fragments after the impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6142726540565491 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8642726540565491 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6142726540565491, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6142726540565491, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0330740362405777, + 0.053634002804756165, + 0.42581620812416077, + 0.023088961839675903, + 0.07687686383724213, + 0.02475030906498432, + 0.05787578970193863, + 0.044538963586091995, + 0.23807764053344727, + 0.022267194464802742 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6142726540565491 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot vertically from high above looking down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a meteorite with a rugged, charred texture visible streaking through space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast lunar landscape with gray surfaces and sharp-edged craters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the meteorite impacting the surface and creating a blinding incandescent flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a massive shock wave hurl a radial, expanding cloud of dust and rock fragments after the impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055015113204717636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300150871276855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055015113204717636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055015113204717636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.031202565878629684, + 0.05626768246293068, + 0.22108851373195648, + 0.0297935139387846, + 0.013000085949897766, + 0.00909192394465208, + 0.020293457433581352, + 0.09251432120800018, + 0.4924345314502716, + 0.034313417971134186 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055015113204717636 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot vertically from high above looking down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a meteorite with a rugged, charred texture visible streaking through space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast lunar landscape with gray surfaces and sharp-edged craters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the meteorite impacting the surface and creating a blinding incandescent flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a massive shock wave hurl a radial, expanding cloud of dust and rock fragments after the impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02332557551562786 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733256816864014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02332557551562786, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02332557551562786, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05899090692400932, + 0.5826600193977356, + 0.10954734683036804, + 0.05842731520533562, + 0.016485245898365974, + 0.027284828945994377, + 0.023929357528686523, + 0.04767001047730446, + 0.04304644092917442, + 0.03195852413773537 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02332557551562786 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot vertically from high above looking down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a meteorite with a rugged, charred texture visible streaking through space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast lunar landscape with gray surfaces and sharp-edged craters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the meteorite impacting the surface and creating a blinding incandescent flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a massive shock wave hurl a radial, expanding cloud of dust and rock fragments after the impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012550657615065575 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875508308410645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012550657615065575, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012550657615065575, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.021671846508979797, + 0.06272400170564651, + 0.017387934029102325, + 0.010096079669892788, + 0.01575312577188015, + 0.009508064016699791, + 0.022926200181245804, + 0.1598493754863739, + 0.532971978187561, + 0.14711138606071472 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012550657615065575 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot vertically from high above looking down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a meteorite with a rugged, charred texture visible streaking through space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast lunar landscape with gray surfaces and sharp-edged craters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the meteorite impacting the surface and creating a blinding incandescent flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a massive shock wave hurl a radial, expanding cloud of dust and rock fragments after the impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004640643019229174 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379640579223633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004640643019229174, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004640643019229174, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03705548867583275, + 0.06586559861898422, + 0.06233471259474754, + 0.025054408237338066, + 0.014635810628533363, + 0.010946447029709816, + 0.02738792821764946, + 0.06947103142738342, + 0.5441868901252747, + 0.14306165277957916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004640643019229174 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static shot, shot vertically from high above, captures a meteorite, its surface rugged and deep, charred texture, streaking through the inky blackness of space, hurtling towards a vast, dead lunar landscape. This surface, a patchwork of gray, is dotted with sharp-edged craters of varying sizes, casting deep, elongated shadows against the cold light of a distant sun. In the silent vacuum, the meteorite instantly impacts the lunar surface, unleashing a brief, blinding, incandescent flash. Immediately thereafter, a massive shock wave, centered at the impact point, violently hurls a vast cloud of lunar dust and rock fragments in a spectacular, radial pattern, forming an expanding, swirling gray cloud that rapidly engulfs the surrounding crater landscape. The entire process, silent yet imbued with a sense of destructive power, creates an atmosphere of vast, cold, and magnificent cosmic collision.", + "seed": 13145, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_15/index_5239_seed_13145_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.12669404838234186, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12669404838234186, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12669404838234186, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot vertically from high above looking down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a meteorite with a rugged, charred texture visible streaking through space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast lunar landscape with gray surfaces and sharp-edged craters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the meteorite impacting the surface and creating a blinding incandescent flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a massive shock wave hurl a radial, expanding cloud of dust and rock fragments after the impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.45721307396888733 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.082213044166565 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.45721307396888733, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.45721307396888733, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2254762053489685, + 0.11550667881965637, + 0.04857856407761574, + 0.1945124715566635, + 0.1253848820924759, + 0.02591117098927498, + 0.04794043302536011, + 0.054884620010852814, + 0.053313519805669785, + 0.10849149525165558 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.45721307396888733 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot vertically from high above looking down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a meteorite with a rugged, charred texture visible streaking through space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast lunar landscape with gray surfaces and sharp-edged craters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the meteorite impacting the surface and creating a blinding incandescent flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a massive shock wave hurl a radial, expanding cloud of dust and rock fragments after the impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029852010309696198 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298519134521484 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029852010309696198, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029852010309696198, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.45980799198150635, + 0.05922588333487511, + 0.2030155509710312, + 0.06572279334068298, + 0.02750379405915737, + 0.03300715982913971, + 0.034614160656929016, + 0.05353901535272598, + 0.022535735741257668, + 0.041027896106243134 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029852010309696198 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot vertically from high above looking down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a meteorite with a rugged, charred texture visible streaking through space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast lunar landscape with gray surfaces and sharp-edged craters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the meteorite impacting the surface and creating a blinding incandescent flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a massive shock wave hurl a radial, expanding cloud of dust and rock fragments after the impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.127108633518219 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127108573913574 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.127108633518219, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.127108633518219, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6212832927703857, + 0.03788617253303528, + 0.0523640476167202, + 0.14350184798240662, + 0.02244160696864128, + 0.023531541228294373, + 0.028210492804646492, + 0.011156097985804081, + 0.020097188651561737, + 0.03952771797776222 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.127108633518219 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot vertically from high above looking down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a meteorite with a rugged, charred texture visible streaking through space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast lunar landscape with gray surfaces and sharp-edged craters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the meteorite impacting the surface and creating a blinding incandescent flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a massive shock wave hurl a radial, expanding cloud of dust and rock fragments after the impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012556072324514389 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387556076049805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012556072324514389, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012556072324514389, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10138685256242752, + 0.07939567416906357, + 0.12770132720470428, + 0.2665015459060669, + 0.06196463108062744, + 0.03721645101904869, + 0.07963453233242035, + 0.09069053083658218, + 0.07333927601575851, + 0.08216915279626846 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012556072324514389 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot vertically from high above looking down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a meteorite with a rugged, charred texture visible streaking through space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast lunar landscape with gray surfaces and sharp-edged craters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the meteorite impacting the surface and creating a blinding incandescent flash?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a massive shock wave hurl a radial, expanding cloud of dust and rock fragments after the impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006740451790392399 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006740570068359 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006740451790392399, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006740451790392399, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23070360720157623, + 0.05307130515575409, + 0.06728101521730423, + 0.31346237659454346, + 0.040531668812036514, + 0.010817773640155792, + 0.07988835871219635, + 0.05392514914274216, + 0.04970674589276314, + 0.10061201453208923 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006740451790392399 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_2/index_tensor([2323, 2323])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_2/index_tensor([2323, 2323])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..361922b9497280096367be7ecba52c25fd1196d3 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_2/index_tensor([2323, 2323])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, handheld tracking shot, brimming with raw energy, the camera trembles violently as it closely follows a matte black fixed-grip bicycle with fluorescent green rims. A young man, wearing a loose, dark gray hoodie and a backward-facing baseball cap, rides across a cracked concrete pavement amidst the ruins of an urban area. As he barrels into the center of the frame, the rider abruptly shifts his weight backward, locking his legs with the rear wheel and launching the rear end of the bike in a swift, fluid arc. This \"spin and spin\" is precise and violent, the rear tire screeching against the rough ground, kicking up a cloud of dust and gravel. In the cold, diffuse light of the overcast sky, the scratches and wear on the bicycle frame from constant use are clearly visible, as is the focused, determined expression on the rider's face. The background is dilapidated industrial buildings, broken brick walls covered with graffiti and weeds growing tenaciously from the cracks in the ground. The overall color tone tends to be a cold gray-blue, and only the fluorescent green wheels are the only bright embellishment in the picture, creating an atmosphere full of street rebellion, tension and primitive dynamic aesthetics.", + "seed": 22152, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_2/index_2323_seed_22152_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.037535641342401505, + "vlm_logprob": -0.037535641342401505, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.037535641342401505, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a handheld, trembling motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a matte black bicycle with fluorescent green rims being ridden by a young man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider perform a specific stunt where he locks his legs with the rear wheel to launch the bike's rear end in a swift arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of dilapidated industrial buildings, broken brick walls with graffiti, and weeds growing from cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color tone a cold gray-blue with the fluorescent green wheels as the only bright embellishment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07948864996433258 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.704488754272461 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07948864996433258, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07948864996433258, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1841585338115692, + 0.08677824586629868, + 0.20702522993087769, + 0.059317998588085175, + 0.060184210538864136, + 0.14956921339035034, + 0.06770289689302444, + 0.03708209842443466, + 0.049865394830703735, + 0.09831622987985611 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07948864996433258 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a handheld, trembling motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a matte black bicycle with fluorescent green rims being ridden by a young man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider perform a specific stunt where he locks his legs with the rear wheel to launch the bike's rear end in a swift arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of dilapidated industrial buildings, broken brick walls with graffiti, and weeds growing from cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color tone a cold gray-blue with the fluorescent green wheels as the only bright embellishment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308212548494339 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680822372436523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308212548494339, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308212548494339, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1592535823583603, + 0.16509908437728882, + 0.25203296542167664, + 0.03520094230771065, + 0.039083197712898254, + 0.11399369686841965, + 0.07180161774158478, + 0.04791569337248802, + 0.05149554833769798, + 0.06412364542484283 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308212548494339 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a handheld, trembling motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a matte black bicycle with fluorescent green rims being ridden by a young man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider perform a specific stunt where he locks his legs with the rear wheel to launch the bike's rear end in a swift arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of dilapidated industrial buildings, broken brick walls with graffiti, and weeds growing from cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color tone a cold gray-blue with the fluorescent green wheels as the only bright embellishment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026340389624238014 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513404846191406 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026340389624238014, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026340389624238014, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1360834687948227, + 0.11921625584363937, + 0.09946954995393753, + 0.04523690417408943, + 0.19366554915905, + 0.11619099229574203, + 0.04632342606782913, + 0.06646910309791565, + 0.03755674511194229, + 0.13978798687458038 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026340389624238014 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a handheld, trembling motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a matte black bicycle with fluorescent green rims being ridden by a young man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider perform a specific stunt where he locks his legs with the rear wheel to launch the bike's rear end in a swift arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of dilapidated industrial buildings, broken brick walls with graffiti, and weeds growing from cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color tone a cold gray-blue with the fluorescent green wheels as the only bright embellishment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818707026541233 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187046051025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818707026541233, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818707026541233, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.138800248503685, + 0.07370813935995102, + 0.049685120582580566, + 0.036230042576789856, + 0.05401839315891266, + 0.07198435813188553, + 0.05702146887779236, + 0.16359509527683258, + 0.06911414116621017, + 0.28584298491477966 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818707026541233 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a handheld, trembling motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a matte black bicycle with fluorescent green rims being ridden by a young man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider perform a specific stunt where he locks his legs with the rear wheel to launch the bike's rear end in a swift arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of dilapidated industrial buildings, broken brick walls with graffiti, and weeds growing from cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color tone a cold gray-blue with the fluorescent green wheels as the only bright embellishment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020579971373081207 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955800533294678 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020579971373081207, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020579971373081207, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21708177030086517, + 0.0616091713309288, + 0.12064863741397858, + 0.03304023668169975, + 0.06062038615345955, + 0.06386546045541763, + 0.05016881227493286, + 0.12432733178138733, + 0.08533576130867004, + 0.18330241739749908 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020579971373081207 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, handheld tracking shot, brimming with raw energy, the camera trembles violently as it closely follows a matte black fixed-grip bicycle with fluorescent green rims. A young man, wearing a loose, dark gray hoodie and a backward-facing baseball cap, rides across a cracked concrete pavement amidst the ruins of an urban area. As he barrels into the center of the frame, the rider abruptly shifts his weight backward, locking his legs with the rear wheel and launching the rear end of the bike in a swift, fluid arc. This \"spin and spin\" is precise and violent, the rear tire screeching against the rough ground, kicking up a cloud of dust and gravel. In the cold, diffuse light of the overcast sky, the scratches and wear on the bicycle frame from constant use are clearly visible, as is the focused, determined expression on the rider's face. The background is dilapidated industrial buildings, broken brick walls covered with graffiti and weeds growing tenaciously from the cracks in the ground. The overall color tone tends to be a cold gray-blue, and only the fluorescent green wheels are the only bright embellishment in the picture, creating an atmosphere full of street rebellion, tension and primitive dynamic aesthetics.", + "seed": 22153, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_2/index_2323_seed_22153_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.026836091466248036, + "vlm_logprob": -0.026836091466248036, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.026836091466248036, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a handheld, trembling motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a matte black bicycle with fluorescent green rims being ridden by a young man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider perform a specific stunt where he locks his legs with the rear wheel to launch the bike's rear end in a swift arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of dilapidated industrial buildings, broken brick walls with graffiti, and weeds growing from cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color tone a cold gray-blue with the fluorescent green wheels as the only bright embellishment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07964542508125305 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8296453952789307 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07964542508125305, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07964542508125305, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1408548802137375, + 0.17167995870113373, + 0.06789877265691757, + 0.08900238573551178, + 0.13415001332759857, + 0.08834710717201233, + 0.034803424030542374, + 0.1571621149778366, + 0.04368982091546059, + 0.07241152971982956 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07964542508125305 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a handheld, trembling motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a matte black bicycle with fluorescent green rims being ridden by a young man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider perform a specific stunt where he locks his legs with the rear wheel to launch the bike's rear end in a swift arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of dilapidated industrial buildings, broken brick walls with graffiti, and weeds growing from cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color tone a cold gray-blue with the fluorescent green wheels as the only bright embellishment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012553717941045761 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387553691864014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012553717941045761, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012553717941045761, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08956632018089294, + 0.13542403280735016, + 0.13261063396930695, + 0.06967785954475403, + 0.07357896864414215, + 0.1652173548936844, + 0.1223510354757309, + 0.11223277449607849, + 0.06658408790826797, + 0.032756950706243515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012553717941045761 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a handheld, trembling motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a matte black bicycle with fluorescent green rims being ridden by a young man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider perform a specific stunt where he locks his legs with the rear wheel to launch the bike's rear end in a swift arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of dilapidated industrial buildings, broken brick walls with graffiti, and weeds growing from cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color tone a cold gray-blue with the fluorescent green wheels as the only bright embellishment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02328353188931942 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732834815979004 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02328353188931942, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02328353188931942, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0606677271425724, + 0.24679121375083923, + 0.12422028928995132, + 0.11443891376256943, + 0.07659397274255753, + 0.035569023340940475, + 0.023493219166994095, + 0.15213093161582947, + 0.14045469462871552, + 0.02564001828432083 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02328353188931942 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a handheld, trembling motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a matte black bicycle with fluorescent green rims being ridden by a young man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider perform a specific stunt where he locks his legs with the rear wheel to launch the bike's rear end in a swift arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of dilapidated industrial buildings, broken brick walls with graffiti, and weeds growing from cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color tone a cold gray-blue with the fluorescent green wheels as the only bright embellishment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011072737164795399 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511072635650635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011072737164795399, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011072737164795399, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08429348468780518, + 0.22050604224205017, + 0.2106291949748993, + 0.1886942982673645, + 0.05317148566246033, + 0.017196577042341232, + 0.010927838273346424, + 0.07381001859903336, + 0.0428498312830925, + 0.09792119264602661 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011072737164795399 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a handheld, trembling motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a matte black bicycle with fluorescent green rims being ridden by a young man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider perform a specific stunt where he locks his legs with the rear wheel to launch the bike's rear end in a swift arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of dilapidated industrial buildings, broken brick walls with graffiti, and weeds growing from cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color tone a cold gray-blue with the fluorescent green wheels as the only bright embellishment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007625045254826546 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882625102996826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007625045254826546, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007625045254826546, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14253661036491394, + 0.19163833558559418, + 0.13224057853221893, + 0.10133273154497147, + 0.05306923761963844, + 0.03533150255680084, + 0.03845739737153053, + 0.18301895260810852, + 0.034571245312690735, + 0.08780339360237122 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007625045254826546 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, handheld tracking shot, brimming with raw energy, the camera trembles violently as it closely follows a matte black fixed-grip bicycle with fluorescent green rims. A young man, wearing a loose, dark gray hoodie and a backward-facing baseball cap, rides across a cracked concrete pavement amidst the ruins of an urban area. As he barrels into the center of the frame, the rider abruptly shifts his weight backward, locking his legs with the rear wheel and launching the rear end of the bike in a swift, fluid arc. This \"spin and spin\" is precise and violent, the rear tire screeching against the rough ground, kicking up a cloud of dust and gravel. In the cold, diffuse light of the overcast sky, the scratches and wear on the bicycle frame from constant use are clearly visible, as is the focused, determined expression on the rider's face. The background is dilapidated industrial buildings, broken brick walls covered with graffiti and weeds growing tenaciously from the cracks in the ground. The overall color tone tends to be a cold gray-blue, and only the fluorescent green wheels are the only bright embellishment in the picture, creating an atmosphere full of street rebellion, tension and primitive dynamic aesthetics.", + "seed": 22154, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_2/index_2323_seed_22154_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.030163035728037357, + "vlm_logprob": -0.030163035728037357, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.030163035728037357, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a handheld, trembling motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a matte black bicycle with fluorescent green rims being ridden by a young man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider perform a specific stunt where he locks his legs with the rear wheel to launch the bike's rear end in a swift arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of dilapidated industrial buildings, broken brick walls with graffiti, and weeds growing from cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color tone a cold gray-blue with the fluorescent green wheels as the only bright embellishment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07958278059959412 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.829582691192627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07958278059959412, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07958278059959412, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15309786796569824, + 0.08180128037929535, + 0.2140628546476364, + 0.14130830764770508, + 0.12286626547574997, + 0.06346408277750015, + 0.06687679141759872, + 0.02655462548136711, + 0.1015223041176796, + 0.028445549309253693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07958278059959412 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a handheld, trembling motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a matte black bicycle with fluorescent green rims being ridden by a young man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider perform a specific stunt where he locks his legs with the rear wheel to launch the bike's rear end in a swift arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of dilapidated industrial buildings, broken brick walls with graffiti, and weeds growing from cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color tone a cold gray-blue with the fluorescent green wheels as the only bright embellishment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029809430241584778 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298094749450684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029809430241584778, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029809430241584778, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0890197828412056, + 0.07959192246198654, + 0.4151385724544525, + 0.09814450144767761, + 0.048787761479616165, + 0.024086246266961098, + 0.06125304847955704, + 0.04299148917198181, + 0.11566146463155746, + 0.025325236842036247 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029809430241584778 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a handheld, trembling motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a matte black bicycle with fluorescent green rims being ridden by a young man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider perform a specific stunt where he locks his legs with the rear wheel to launch the bike's rear end in a swift arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of dilapidated industrial buildings, broken brick walls with graffiti, and weeds growing from cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color tone a cold gray-blue with the fluorescent green wheels as the only bright embellishment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020574131980538368 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955740928649902 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020574131980538368, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020574131980538368, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09691176563501358, + 0.027865977957844734, + 0.4677080512046814, + 0.05140449106693268, + 0.08330492675304413, + 0.07759928703308105, + 0.04801958054304123, + 0.018133962526917458, + 0.111329086124897, + 0.01772296614944935 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020574131980538368 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a handheld, trembling motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a matte black bicycle with fluorescent green rims being ridden by a young man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider perform a specific stunt where he locks his legs with the rear wheel to launch the bike's rear end in a swift arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of dilapidated industrial buildings, broken brick walls with graffiti, and weeds growing from cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color tone a cold gray-blue with the fluorescent green wheels as the only bright embellishment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009778456762433052 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347784996032715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009778456762433052, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009778456762433052, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34359925985336304, + 0.04796465113759041, + 0.15414085984230042, + 0.02594081126153469, + 0.05272982642054558, + 0.05898476764559746, + 0.026236146688461304, + 0.009697984904050827, + 0.24684926867485046, + 0.03385644778609276 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009778456762433052 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a handheld, trembling motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a matte black bicycle with fluorescent green rims being ridden by a young man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider perform a specific stunt where he locks his legs with the rear wheel to launch the bike's rear end in a swift arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of dilapidated industrial buildings, broken brick walls with graffiti, and weeds growing from cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color tone a cold gray-blue with the fluorescent green wheels as the only bright embellishment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011070379056036472 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511070251464844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011070379056036472, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011070379056036472, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19010570645332336, + 0.10309204459190369, + 0.16900378465652466, + 0.06136371195316315, + 0.06914865225553513, + 0.038926657289266586, + 0.13761068880558014, + 0.07289287447929382, + 0.11003091931343079, + 0.0478249192237854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011070379056036472 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, handheld tracking shot, brimming with raw energy, the camera trembles violently as it closely follows a matte black fixed-grip bicycle with fluorescent green rims. A young man, wearing a loose, dark gray hoodie and a backward-facing baseball cap, rides across a cracked concrete pavement amidst the ruins of an urban area. As he barrels into the center of the frame, the rider abruptly shifts his weight backward, locking his legs with the rear wheel and launching the rear end of the bike in a swift, fluid arc. This \"spin and spin\" is precise and violent, the rear tire screeching against the rough ground, kicking up a cloud of dust and gravel. In the cold, diffuse light of the overcast sky, the scratches and wear on the bicycle frame from constant use are clearly visible, as is the focused, determined expression on the rider's face. The background is dilapidated industrial buildings, broken brick walls covered with graffiti and weeds growing tenaciously from the cracks in the ground. The overall color tone tends to be a cold gray-blue, and only the fluorescent green wheels are the only bright embellishment in the picture, creating an atmosphere full of street rebellion, tension and primitive dynamic aesthetics.", + "seed": 22155, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_2/index_2323_seed_22155_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04441385511308908, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04441385511308908, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.675000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04441385511308908, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a handheld, trembling motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a matte black bicycle with fluorescent green rims being ridden by a young man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider perform a specific stunt where he locks his legs with the rear wheel to launch the bike's rear end in a swift arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of dilapidated industrial buildings, broken brick walls with graffiti, and weeds growing from cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color tone a cold gray-blue with the fluorescent green wheels as the only bright embellishment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.15437091886997223 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0293710231781006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.15437091886997223, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.15437091886997223, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26630836725234985, + 0.07076175510883331, + 0.07951865345239639, + 0.1457551121711731, + 0.19914712011814117, + 0.026988934725522995, + 0.05692458897829056, + 0.05705701559782028, + 0.03409959003329277, + 0.06343882530927658 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.15437091886997223 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a handheld, trembling motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a matte black bicycle with fluorescent green rims being ridden by a young man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider perform a specific stunt where he locks his legs with the rear wheel to launch the bike's rear end in a swift arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of dilapidated industrial buildings, broken brick walls with graffiti, and weeds growing from cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color tone a cold gray-blue with the fluorescent green wheels as the only bright embellishment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016087371855974197 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141087532043457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016087371855974197, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016087371855974197, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09890465438365936, + 0.12381862848997116, + 0.1171337366104126, + 0.19233272969722748, + 0.18498820066452026, + 0.05419483780860901, + 0.04371023178100586, + 0.059792060405015945, + 0.05054312199354172, + 0.07458179444074631 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016087371855974197 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a handheld, trembling motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a matte black bicycle with fluorescent green rims being ridden by a young man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider perform a specific stunt where he locks his legs with the rear wheel to launch the bike's rear end in a swift arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of dilapidated industrial buildings, broken brick walls with graffiti, and weeds growing from cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color tone a cold gray-blue with the fluorescent green wheels as the only bright embellishment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634306065738201 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513431072235107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634306065738201, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634306065738201, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17535674571990967, + 0.08953158557415009, + 0.1771831065416336, + 0.1597338318824768, + 0.06703630089759827, + 0.022931186482310295, + 0.06247228384017944, + 0.037134069949388504, + 0.05299752950668335, + 0.15562336146831512 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634306065738201 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a handheld, trembling motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a matte black bicycle with fluorescent green rims being ridden by a young man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider perform a specific stunt where he locks his legs with the rear wheel to launch the bike's rear end in a swift arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of dilapidated industrial buildings, broken brick walls with graffiti, and weeds growing from cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color tone a cold gray-blue with the fluorescent green wheels as the only bright embellishment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011074034497141838 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511074066162109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011074034497141838, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011074034497141838, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5164100527763367, + 0.06450901925563812, + 0.08475843816995621, + 0.024651022627949715, + 0.03615405410528183, + 0.018605593591928482, + 0.12979578971862793, + 0.05853627249598503, + 0.025449179112911224, + 0.041130535304546356 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011074034497141838 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle with a handheld, trembling motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a matte black bicycle with fluorescent green rims being ridden by a young man?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the rider perform a specific stunt where he locks his legs with the rear wheel to launch the bike's rear end in a swift arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of dilapidated industrial buildings, broken brick walls with graffiti, and weeds growing from cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color tone a cold gray-blue with the fluorescent green wheels as the only bright embellishment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014193889684975147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264194011688232 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014193889684975147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014193889684975147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6820313930511475, + 0.054765619337558746, + 0.0238141231238842, + 0.03424861654639244, + 0.022108852863311768, + 0.01593366079032421, + 0.06711896508932114, + 0.049745507538318634, + 0.016828320920467377, + 0.033404868096113205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014193889684975147 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_3/index_tensor([3630, 3630])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_3/index_tensor([3630, 3630])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f5d2d4b79356bb06043c6bca6526db83e4ee5ecf --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_3/index_tensor([3630, 3630])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, medium shot captures a chaotic flock of mallards, fiercely jockeying for position at the edge of a muddy, reed-covered pond. The camera's steadiness contrasts starkly with the frenzy of the subjects. The dense flock, drakes with iridescent green heads and hens with speckled brown feathers, shoves and jostles, their bodies in a flurry of motion. Wings flap frantically, not for flight but for leverage, sending shimmering droplets arcing through the air. Bright orange beaks snap open and close at breakneck speed, creating ever-expanding ripples as torn pieces of white bread are dropped into the murky, green-brown water. With their agitated orange webbed feet, the ducks half-crawl together in a desperate pursuit of their wet meal. The entire scene is illuminated by the soft, even light of an overcast sky, capturing the shimmer of moisture on feathers and the explosive splashes on the water's surface, creating a vivid and palpable atmosphere of pure, instinctive madness.", + "seed": 24380, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_3/index_3630_seed_24380_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08946632277220487, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08946632277220487, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08946632277220487, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle, medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are mallards visible jockeying for position at the edge of a muddy, reed-covered pond?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ducks include drakes with iridescent green heads and hens with speckled brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are bright orange beaks snapping open and close while pieces of white bread are dropped into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the soft, even light of an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28452903032302856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5345289707183838 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28452903032302856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28452903032302856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15329046547412872, + 0.20281700789928436, + 0.1042482927441597, + 0.06605523079633713, + 0.07448910176753998, + 0.06775031983852386, + 0.11446095257997513, + 0.04966777563095093, + 0.09441205114126205, + 0.07280881702899933 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28452903032302856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle, medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are mallards visible jockeying for position at the edge of a muddy, reed-covered pond?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ducks include drakes with iridescent green heads and hens with speckled brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are bright orange beaks snapping open and close while pieces of white bread are dropped into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the soft, even light of an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012567726895213127 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387567520141602 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012567726895213127, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012567726895213127, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16079112887382507, + 0.11281326413154602, + 0.060380928218364716, + 0.07465536892414093, + 0.0661872997879982, + 0.09018663316965103, + 0.03682743385434151, + 0.10891846567392349, + 0.1802103966474533, + 0.10902904719114304 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012567726895213127 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle, medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are mallards visible jockeying for position at the edge of a muddy, reed-covered pond?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ducks include drakes with iridescent green heads and hens with speckled brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are bright orange beaks snapping open and close while pieces of white bread are dropped into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the soft, even light of an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012550421990454197 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387550354003906 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012550421990454197, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012550421990454197, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.49700015783309937, + 0.09286034107208252, + 0.04747096076607704, + 0.03626672923564911, + 0.05143359676003456, + 0.08555739372968674, + 0.02469615265727043, + 0.05346813425421715, + 0.060611020773649216, + 0.050635576248168945 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012550421990454197 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle, medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are mallards visible jockeying for position at the edge of a muddy, reed-covered pond?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ducks include drakes with iridescent green heads and hens with speckled brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are bright orange beaks snapping open and close while pieces of white bread are dropped into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the soft, even light of an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048663295805454254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048663377761841 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048663295805454254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048663295805454254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1370115876197815, + 0.08631948381662369, + 0.07985718548297882, + 0.08558514714241028, + 0.11848794668912888, + 0.17904192209243774, + 0.041270799934864044, + 0.054462503641843796, + 0.11949285864830017, + 0.0984705239534378 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048663295805454254 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle, medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are mallards visible jockeying for position at the edge of a muddy, reed-covered pond?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ducks include drakes with iridescent green heads and hens with speckled brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are bright orange beaks snapping open and close while pieces of white bread are dropped into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the soft, even light of an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08902113884687424 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640212059020996 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08902113884687424, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08902113884687424, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2831432819366455, + 0.1337457150220871, + 0.03510676696896553, + 0.05901957303285599, + 0.06130944937467575, + 0.08555708825588226, + 0.10052642971277237, + 0.06419917941093445, + 0.10893124341964722, + 0.06846129149198532 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08902113884687424 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, medium shot captures a chaotic flock of mallards, fiercely jockeying for position at the edge of a muddy, reed-covered pond. The camera's steadiness contrasts starkly with the frenzy of the subjects. The dense flock, drakes with iridescent green heads and hens with speckled brown feathers, shoves and jostles, their bodies in a flurry of motion. Wings flap frantically, not for flight but for leverage, sending shimmering droplets arcing through the air. Bright orange beaks snap open and close at breakneck speed, creating ever-expanding ripples as torn pieces of white bread are dropped into the murky, green-brown water. With their agitated orange webbed feet, the ducks half-crawl together in a desperate pursuit of their wet meal. The entire scene is illuminated by the soft, even light of an overcast sky, capturing the shimmer of moisture on feathers and the explosive splashes on the water's surface, creating a vivid and palpable atmosphere of pure, instinctive madness.", + "seed": 24381, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_3/index_3630_seed_24381_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.15643479377031327, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15643479377031327, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15643479377031327, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle, medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are mallards visible jockeying for position at the edge of a muddy, reed-covered pond?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ducks include drakes with iridescent green heads and hens with speckled brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are bright orange beaks snapping open and close while pieces of white bread are dropped into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the soft, even light of an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5540215969085693 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9290215969085693 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5540215969085693, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5540215969085693, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18303260207176208, + 0.06614752858877182, + 0.057394128292798996, + 0.12653765082359314, + 0.07193463295698166, + 0.11907567828893661, + 0.06486062705516815, + 0.04635767638683319, + 0.09435955435037613, + 0.1702999472618103 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5540215969085693 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle, medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are mallards visible jockeying for position at the edge of a muddy, reed-covered pond?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ducks include drakes with iridescent green heads and hens with speckled brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are bright orange beaks snapping open and close while pieces of white bread are dropped into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the soft, even light of an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01610414683818817 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141104221343994 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01610414683818817, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01610414683818817, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18696095049381256, + 0.2203534096479416, + 0.03290911018848419, + 0.09398853033781052, + 0.04671338573098183, + 0.045388299971818924, + 0.028456810861825943, + 0.07562179118394852, + 0.07033184170722961, + 0.19927585124969482 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01610414683818817 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle, medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are mallards visible jockeying for position at the edge of a muddy, reed-covered pond?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ducks include drakes with iridescent green heads and hens with speckled brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are bright orange beaks snapping open and close while pieces of white bread are dropped into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the soft, even light of an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020598072558641434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955981731414795 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020598072558641434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020598072558641434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2508384883403778, + 0.09309341013431549, + 0.0619087815284729, + 0.10642094165086746, + 0.05699373409152031, + 0.06251834332942963, + 0.04287242889404297, + 0.032701678574085236, + 0.04457163065671921, + 0.24808058142662048 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020598072558641434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle, medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are mallards visible jockeying for position at the edge of a muddy, reed-covered pond?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ducks include drakes with iridescent green heads and hens with speckled brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are bright orange beaks snapping open and close while pieces of white bread are dropped into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the soft, even light of an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048660341650247574 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486602783203125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048660341650247574, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048660341650247574, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18798062205314636, + 0.0988461896777153, + 0.06920138001441956, + 0.08228236436843872, + 0.04703712835907936, + 0.13511814177036285, + 0.048043567687273026, + 0.03402744606137276, + 0.051812976598739624, + 0.24565014243125916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048660341650247574 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle, medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are mallards visible jockeying for position at the edge of a muddy, reed-covered pond?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ducks include drakes with iridescent green heads and hens with speckled brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are bright orange beaks snapping open and close while pieces of white bread are dropped into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the soft, even light of an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1427898108959198 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017789840698242 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1427898108959198, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1427898108959198, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0713687613606453, + 0.17653372883796692, + 0.04942236468195915, + 0.2759774625301361, + 0.027725517749786377, + 0.06327205151319504, + 0.013197234831750393, + 0.02785247005522251, + 0.020611295476555824, + 0.274039089679718 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1427898108959198 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, medium shot captures a chaotic flock of mallards, fiercely jockeying for position at the edge of a muddy, reed-covered pond. The camera's steadiness contrasts starkly with the frenzy of the subjects. The dense flock, drakes with iridescent green heads and hens with speckled brown feathers, shoves and jostles, their bodies in a flurry of motion. Wings flap frantically, not for flight but for leverage, sending shimmering droplets arcing through the air. Bright orange beaks snap open and close at breakneck speed, creating ever-expanding ripples as torn pieces of white bread are dropped into the murky, green-brown water. With their agitated orange webbed feet, the ducks half-crawl together in a desperate pursuit of their wet meal. The entire scene is illuminated by the soft, even light of an overcast sky, capturing the shimmer of moisture on feathers and the explosive splashes on the water's surface, creating a vivid and palpable atmosphere of pure, instinctive madness.", + "seed": 24382, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_3/index_3630_seed_24382_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.16945044323801994, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16945044323801994, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.574999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16945044323801994, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle, medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are mallards visible jockeying for position at the edge of a muddy, reed-covered pond?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ducks include drakes with iridescent green heads and hens with speckled brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are bright orange beaks snapping open and close while pieces of white bread are dropped into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the soft, even light of an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6042305827140808 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8542305827140808 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6042305827140808, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6042305827140808, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.049362171441316605, + 0.08577512949705124, + 0.04874889552593231, + 0.023743677884340286, + 0.09944653511047363, + 0.42498233914375305, + 0.07892373949289322, + 0.043553657829761505, + 0.06151000037789345, + 0.08395388722419739 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6042305827140808 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle, medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are mallards visible jockeying for position at the edge of a muddy, reed-covered pond?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ducks include drakes with iridescent green heads and hens with speckled brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are bright orange beaks snapping open and close while pieces of white bread are dropped into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the soft, even light of an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018214929848909378 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018214702606201 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018214929848909378, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018214929848909378, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03722189739346504, + 0.03905804455280304, + 0.057493969798088074, + 0.034844499081373215, + 0.07007326185703278, + 0.6072160005569458, + 0.08108946681022644, + 0.014795695431530476, + 0.024975882843136787, + 0.03323129937052727 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018214929848909378 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle, medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are mallards visible jockeying for position at the edge of a muddy, reed-covered pond?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ducks include drakes with iridescent green heads and hens with speckled brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are bright orange beaks snapping open and close while pieces of white bread are dropped into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the soft, even light of an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811325132846832 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881133556365967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811325132846832, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811325132846832, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03636786714196205, + 0.016506852582097054, + 0.03141706436872482, + 0.03261036425828934, + 0.047891177237033844, + 0.7527183890342712, + 0.030875880271196365, + 0.020203446969389915, + 0.015714522451162338, + 0.015694452449679375 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811325132846832 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle, medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are mallards visible jockeying for position at the edge of a muddy, reed-covered pond?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ducks include drakes with iridescent green heads and hens with speckled brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are bright orange beaks snapping open and close while pieces of white bread are dropped into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the soft, even light of an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026353277266025543 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651353359222412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026353277266025543, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026353277266025543, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06762481480836868, + 0.011112403124570847, + 0.038611188530921936, + 0.022151218727231026, + 0.14248551428318024, + 0.481405109167099, + 0.05789472535252571, + 0.04685208946466446, + 0.0306535791605711, + 0.10120939463376999 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026353277266025543 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle, medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are mallards visible jockeying for position at the edge of a muddy, reed-covered pond?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ducks include drakes with iridescent green heads and hens with speckled brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are bright orange beaks snapping open and close while pieces of white bread are dropped into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the soft, even light of an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16034017503261566 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103401899337769 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16034017503261566, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16034017503261566, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04402640089392662, + 0.10310841351747513, + 0.05606319382786751, + 0.046262647956609726, + 0.04729977250099182, + 0.3115316927433014, + 0.07220275700092316, + 0.11590760946273804, + 0.07421158999204636, + 0.12938588857650757 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16034017503261566 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, medium shot captures a chaotic flock of mallards, fiercely jockeying for position at the edge of a muddy, reed-covered pond. The camera's steadiness contrasts starkly with the frenzy of the subjects. The dense flock, drakes with iridescent green heads and hens with speckled brown feathers, shoves and jostles, their bodies in a flurry of motion. Wings flap frantically, not for flight but for leverage, sending shimmering droplets arcing through the air. Bright orange beaks snap open and close at breakneck speed, creating ever-expanding ripples as torn pieces of white bread are dropped into the murky, green-brown water. With their agitated orange webbed feet, the ducks half-crawl together in a desperate pursuit of their wet meal. The entire scene is illuminated by the soft, even light of an overcast sky, capturing the shimmer of moisture on feathers and the explosive splashes on the water's surface, creating a vivid and palpable atmosphere of pure, instinctive madness.", + "seed": 24383, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_3/index_3630_seed_24383_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.11007780488580465, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11007780488580465, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.050000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11007780488580465, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle, medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are mallards visible jockeying for position at the edge of a muddy, reed-covered pond?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ducks include drakes with iridescent green heads and hens with speckled brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are bright orange beaks snapping open and close while pieces of white bread are dropped into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the soft, even light of an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3823656439781189 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2573657035827637 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3823656439781189, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8750000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3823656439781189, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.255270779132843, + 0.053494375199079514, + 0.10474571585655212, + 0.1002233475446701, + 0.23454789817333221, + 0.06062890589237213, + 0.033998675644397736, + 0.056733328849077225, + 0.026122376322746277, + 0.07423458993434906 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3823656439781189 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle, medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are mallards visible jockeying for position at the edge of a muddy, reed-covered pond?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ducks include drakes with iridescent green heads and hens with speckled brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are bright orange beaks snapping open and close while pieces of white bread are dropped into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the soft, even light of an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011105275712907314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511105060577393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011105275712907314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011105275712907314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19779431819915771, + 0.09413207322359085, + 0.02011915296316147, + 0.127015620470047, + 0.0356346070766449, + 0.10853222757577896, + 0.02012546919286251, + 0.05321259796619415, + 0.013326355256140232, + 0.3301076889038086 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011105275712907314 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle, medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are mallards visible jockeying for position at the edge of a muddy, reed-covered pond?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ducks include drakes with iridescent green heads and hens with speckled brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are bright orange beaks snapping open and close while pieces of white bread are dropped into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the soft, even light of an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014201998710632324 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264202117919922 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014201998710632324, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014201998710632324, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25995907187461853, + 0.1598399430513382, + 0.06393218785524368, + 0.06079023703932762, + 0.033575136214494705, + 0.13316380977630615, + 0.07027220726013184, + 0.042910221964120865, + 0.03629213199019432, + 0.13926507532596588 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014201998710632324 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle, medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are mallards visible jockeying for position at the edge of a muddy, reed-covered pond?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ducks include drakes with iridescent green heads and hens with speckled brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are bright orange beaks snapping open and close while pieces of white bread are dropped into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the soft, even light of an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029799941927194595 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297999382019043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029799941927194595, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029799941927194595, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16013994812965393, + 0.06523803621530533, + 0.04676775261759758, + 0.14135035872459412, + 0.06615381687879562, + 0.14366891980171204, + 0.0345071405172348, + 0.04330259934067726, + 0.02025415748357773, + 0.2786172330379486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029799941927194595 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, low-angle, medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are mallards visible jockeying for position at the edge of a muddy, reed-covered pond?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the ducks include drakes with iridescent green heads and hens with speckled brown feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are bright orange beaks snapping open and close while pieces of white bread are dropped into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by the soft, even light of an overcast sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11291616410017014 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379162311553955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11291616410017014, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11291616410017014, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2374241203069687, + 0.1059097871184349, + 0.055139292031526566, + 0.038309384137392044, + 0.0634523555636406, + 0.18297597765922546, + 0.05230553075671196, + 0.02446984127163887, + 0.03977656364440918, + 0.20023715496063232 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11291616410017014 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_4/index_tensor([9865, 9865])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_4/index_tensor([9865, 9865])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..117a3d4b63c208d6f8c9585ea0fe6dba5a3b85a6 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_4/index_tensor([9865, 9865])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "smooth, perfectly stabilized sideways tracking shot moves parallel to the ornate, sprawling mansion, swiftly traversing a surreal, dreamlike landscape. The mansion, a majestic structure of dark, weathered stone and intricate Gothic spires, glides across the terrain with effortless yet breathtaking speed. From its numerous large, mullioned windows, a warm, vibrant golden light glows intensely, spilling over and casting a fleeting warmth onto the ground below. The camera perfectly centers the mansion, capturing the surreal textures of its stonework and the detailed tracery of its windows against the rapidly blurring surroundings. The landscape is a vast, polished obsidian plain, perfectly mirroring the surreal sky above. Two slender crescent moons hang suspended amidst swirling clouds of deep purple and bright cyan. Strange crystal plants dot the plain, shimmering with a soft, cool bioluminescence that contrasts starkly with the warm glow of the mansion. The overall atmosphere is one of majestic, silent power and profound mystery, a visually stunning and emotionally resonant scene that feels both epic and deeply dreamlike.", + "seed": 28854, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_4/index_9865_seed_28854_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1588313676416874, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1588313676416874, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1588313676416874, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large mansion made of dark, weathered stone with intricate Gothic spires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the mansion move across the terrain with swift speed while the camera tracks parallel to it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a vast, polished obsidian plain that mirrors the sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two slender crescent moons visible in a sky with swirling clouds of deep purple and bright cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do strange crystal plants with soft, cool bioluminescence appear on the plain contrasting with the mansion's warm light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07932800054550171 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5793280601501465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07932800054550171, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07932800054550171, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06449078768491745, + 0.07139833271503448, + 0.08789236098527908, + 0.06641759723424911, + 0.07263976335525513, + 0.09960809350013733, + 0.313701331615448, + 0.049688179045915604, + 0.12859484553337097, + 0.04556870087981224 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07932800054550171 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large mansion made of dark, weathered stone with intricate Gothic spires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the mansion move across the terrain with swift speed while the camera tracks parallel to it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a vast, polished obsidian plain that mirrors the sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two slender crescent moons visible in a sky with swirling clouds of deep purple and bright cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do strange crystal plants with soft, cool bioluminescence appear on the plain contrasting with the mansion's warm light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1129852682352066 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237985372543335 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1129852682352066, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1129852682352066, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09086287021636963, + 0.0649833083152771, + 0.12024900317192078, + 0.04761899635195732, + 0.09728681296110153, + 0.07839322835206985, + 0.07748173177242279, + 0.3699705898761749, + 0.021899065002799034, + 0.03125433251261711 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1129852682352066 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large mansion made of dark, weathered stone with intricate Gothic spires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the mansion move across the terrain with swift speed while the camera tracks parallel to it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a vast, polished obsidian plain that mirrors the sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two slender crescent moons visible in a sky with swirling clouds of deep purple and bright cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do strange crystal plants with soft, cool bioluminescence appear on the plain contrasting with the mansion's warm light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.523348867893219 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.898348867893219 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.523348867893219, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.523348867893219, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15572990477085114, + 0.13617807626724243, + 0.08093131333589554, + 0.0452774241566658, + 0.12018716335296631, + 0.07574690133333206, + 0.11228015273809433, + 0.1281699538230896, + 0.055693428963422775, + 0.08980569988489151 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.523348867893219 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large mansion made of dark, weathered stone with intricate Gothic spires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the mansion move across the terrain with swift speed while the camera tracks parallel to it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a vast, polished obsidian plain that mirrors the sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two slender crescent moons visible in a sky with swirling clouds of deep purple and bright cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do strange crystal plants with soft, cool bioluminescence appear on the plain contrasting with the mansion's warm light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048700083047151566 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0487000942230225 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048700083047151566, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048700083047151566, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1744672805070877, + 0.056863635778427124, + 0.15034140646457672, + 0.03817272558808327, + 0.1572616994380951, + 0.0967850461602211, + 0.14489446580410004, + 0.07035218179225922, + 0.04941046983003616, + 0.06145106628537178 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048700083047151566 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large mansion made of dark, weathered stone with intricate Gothic spires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the mansion move across the terrain with swift speed while the camera tracks parallel to it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a vast, polished obsidian plain that mirrors the sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two slender crescent moons visible in a sky with swirling clouds of deep purple and bright cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do strange crystal plants with soft, cool bioluminescence appear on the plain contrasting with the mansion's warm light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029794618487358093 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529794692993164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029794618487358093, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029794618487358093, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09306007623672485, + 0.05721168592572212, + 0.08409034460783005, + 0.0748998373746872, + 0.1186894103884697, + 0.06149580702185631, + 0.07009640336036682, + 0.19342657923698425, + 0.13653580844402313, + 0.11049406230449677 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029794618487358093 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "smooth, perfectly stabilized sideways tracking shot moves parallel to the ornate, sprawling mansion, swiftly traversing a surreal, dreamlike landscape. The mansion, a majestic structure of dark, weathered stone and intricate Gothic spires, glides across the terrain with effortless yet breathtaking speed. From its numerous large, mullioned windows, a warm, vibrant golden light glows intensely, spilling over and casting a fleeting warmth onto the ground below. The camera perfectly centers the mansion, capturing the surreal textures of its stonework and the detailed tracery of its windows against the rapidly blurring surroundings. The landscape is a vast, polished obsidian plain, perfectly mirroring the surreal sky above. Two slender crescent moons hang suspended amidst swirling clouds of deep purple and bright cyan. Strange crystal plants dot the plain, shimmering with a soft, cool bioluminescence that contrasts starkly with the warm glow of the mansion. The overall atmosphere is one of majestic, silent power and profound mystery, a visually stunning and emotionally resonant scene that feels both epic and deeply dreamlike.", + "seed": 28855, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_4/index_9865_seed_28855_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.97650426030159, + "vlm_logprob": -0.97650426030159, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 0.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.97650426030159, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large mansion made of dark, weathered stone with intricate Gothic spires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the mansion move across the terrain with swift speed while the camera tracks parallel to it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a vast, polished obsidian plain that mirrors the sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two slender crescent moons visible in a sky with swirling clouds of deep purple and bright cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do strange crystal plants with soft, cool bioluminescence appear on the plain contrasting with the mansion's warm light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529951572418213 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029951509088277817 + ], + "logprob_reward": -3.529951572418213, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -3.529951572418213, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10636259615421295, + 0.055349718779325485, + 0.0845092386007309, + 0.018593281507492065, + 0.11721183359622955, + 0.10833084583282471, + 0.036440227180719376, + 0.3322163224220276, + 0.10787186026573181, + 0.03311404585838318 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -3.529951572418213 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large mansion made of dark, weathered stone with intricate Gothic spires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the mansion move across the terrain with swift speed while the camera tracks parallel to it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a vast, polished obsidian plain that mirrors the sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two slender crescent moons visible in a sky with swirling clouds of deep purple and bright cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do strange crystal plants with soft, cool bioluminescence appear on the plain contrasting with the mansion's warm light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8987855911254883 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5237855911254883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8987855911254883, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8987855911254883, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1335640251636505, + 0.09966277331113815, + 0.04125422611832619, + 0.02633112110197544, + 0.052460744976997375, + 0.159014493227005, + 0.08751697838306427, + 0.329116553068161, + 0.01617501862347126, + 0.054904066026210785 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8987855911254883 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large mansion made of dark, weathered stone with intricate Gothic spires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the mansion move across the terrain with swift speed while the camera tracks parallel to it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a vast, polished obsidian plain that mirrors the sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two slender crescent moons visible in a sky with swirling clouds of deep purple and bright cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do strange crystal plants with soft, cool bioluminescence appear on the plain contrasting with the mansion's warm light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16060376167297363 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9106037616729736 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16060376167297363, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16060376167297363, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1454213708639145, + 0.06232156604528427, + 0.0456482395529747, + 0.07772363722324371, + 0.28116342425346375, + 0.03809180483222008, + 0.04783130809664726, + 0.17651090025901794, + 0.07770084589719772, + 0.047586895525455475 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16060376167297363 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large mansion made of dark, weathered stone with intricate Gothic spires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the mansion move across the terrain with swift speed while the camera tracks parallel to it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a vast, polished obsidian plain that mirrors the sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two slender crescent moons visible in a sky with swirling clouds of deep purple and bright cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do strange crystal plants with soft, cool bioluminescence appear on the plain contrasting with the mansion's warm light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1801479458808899 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8051478862762451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1801479458808899, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1801479458808899, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24610145390033722, + 0.11975087225437164, + 0.039060454815626144, + 0.020136971026659012, + 0.06988342106342316, + 0.10832985490560532, + 0.04155579209327698, + 0.21268898248672485, + 0.06265025585889816, + 0.07984194904565811 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1801479458808899 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large mansion made of dark, weathered stone with intricate Gothic spires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the mansion move across the terrain with swift speed while the camera tracks parallel to it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a vast, polished obsidian plain that mirrors the sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two slender crescent moons visible in a sky with swirling clouds of deep purple and bright cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do strange crystal plants with soft, cool bioluminescence appear on the plain contrasting with the mansion's warm light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11303243041038513 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.238032341003418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11303243041038513, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11303243041038513, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27142447233200073, + 0.06830848753452301, + 0.07281456142663956, + 0.03857005760073662, + 0.09883881360292435, + 0.08695932477712631, + 0.04329035058617592, + 0.058441925793886185, + 0.1749182641506195, + 0.08643366396427155 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11303243041038513 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "smooth, perfectly stabilized sideways tracking shot moves parallel to the ornate, sprawling mansion, swiftly traversing a surreal, dreamlike landscape. The mansion, a majestic structure of dark, weathered stone and intricate Gothic spires, glides across the terrain with effortless yet breathtaking speed. From its numerous large, mullioned windows, a warm, vibrant golden light glows intensely, spilling over and casting a fleeting warmth onto the ground below. The camera perfectly centers the mansion, capturing the surreal textures of its stonework and the detailed tracery of its windows against the rapidly blurring surroundings. The landscape is a vast, polished obsidian plain, perfectly mirroring the surreal sky above. Two slender crescent moons hang suspended amidst swirling clouds of deep purple and bright cyan. Strange crystal plants dot the plain, shimmering with a soft, cool bioluminescence that contrasts starkly with the warm glow of the mansion. The overall atmosphere is one of majestic, silent power and profound mystery, a visually stunning and emotionally resonant scene that feels both epic and deeply dreamlike.", + "seed": 28856, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_4/index_9865_seed_28856_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.25355265140533445, + "vlm_logprob": -0.25355265140533445, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.25355265140533445, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large mansion made of dark, weathered stone with intricate Gothic spires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the mansion move across the terrain with swift speed while the camera tracks parallel to it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a vast, polished obsidian plain that mirrors the sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two slender crescent moons visible in a sky with swirling clouds of deep purple and bright cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do strange crystal plants with soft, cool bioluminescence appear on the plain contrasting with the mansion's warm light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8262248635292053 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5762248635292053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8262248635292053, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8262248635292053, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11394236981868744, + 0.11217107623815536, + 0.07414745539426804, + 0.05963432043790817, + 0.0822344571352005, + 0.10484367609024048, + 0.08371320366859436, + 0.10208622366189957, + 0.02980613522231579, + 0.23742106556892395 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8262248635292053 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large mansion made of dark, weathered stone with intricate Gothic spires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the mansion move across the terrain with swift speed while the camera tracks parallel to it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a vast, polished obsidian plain that mirrors the sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two slender crescent moons visible in a sky with swirling clouds of deep purple and bright cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do strange crystal plants with soft, cool bioluminescence appear on the plain contrasting with the mansion's warm light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620885044336319 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120884895324707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620885044336319, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620885044336319, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1717899590730667, + 0.10895919799804688, + 0.26455676555633545, + 0.06469672918319702, + 0.07714831829071045, + 0.11133063584566116, + 0.05766141042113304, + 0.04033280536532402, + 0.020742278546094894, + 0.08278196305036545 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620885044336319 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large mansion made of dark, weathered stone with intricate Gothic spires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the mansion move across the terrain with swift speed while the camera tracks parallel to it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a vast, polished obsidian plain that mirrors the sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two slender crescent moons visible in a sky with swirling clouds of deep purple and bright cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do strange crystal plants with soft, cool bioluminescence appear on the plain contrasting with the mansion's warm light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28140413761138916 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4064041376113892 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28140413761138916, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28140413761138916, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19115883111953735, + 0.1154436469078064, + 0.06518395245075226, + 0.16777414083480835, + 0.07389651238918304, + 0.08906476944684982, + 0.12731115520000458, + 0.03957439959049225, + 0.019414497539401054, + 0.11117810010910034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28140413761138916 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large mansion made of dark, weathered stone with intricate Gothic spires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the mansion move across the terrain with swift speed while the camera tracks parallel to it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a vast, polished obsidian plain that mirrors the sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two slender crescent moons visible in a sky with swirling clouds of deep purple and bright cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do strange crystal plants with soft, cool bioluminescence appear on the plain contrasting with the mansion's warm light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05499514192342758 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929995059967041 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05499514192342758, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05499514192342758, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24561740458011627, + 0.1316843330860138, + 0.07658680528402328, + 0.0649857372045517, + 0.0984363779425621, + 0.08395418524742126, + 0.05510464310646057, + 0.10841003805398941, + 0.0710655152797699, + 0.06415493041276932 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05499514192342758 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large mansion made of dark, weathered stone with intricate Gothic spires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the mansion move across the terrain with swift speed while the camera tracks parallel to it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a vast, polished obsidian plain that mirrors the sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two slender crescent moons visible in a sky with swirling clouds of deep purple and bright cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do strange crystal plants with soft, cool bioluminescence appear on the plain contrasting with the mansion's warm light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0430506095290184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168050527572632 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0430506095290184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0430506095290184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21349503099918365, + 0.11062958836555481, + 0.06043818220496178, + 0.12043160945177078, + 0.174909308552742, + 0.046677034348249435, + 0.07502923160791397, + 0.09644925594329834, + 0.04524258151650429, + 0.05669810250401497 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0430506095290184 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "smooth, perfectly stabilized sideways tracking shot moves parallel to the ornate, sprawling mansion, swiftly traversing a surreal, dreamlike landscape. The mansion, a majestic structure of dark, weathered stone and intricate Gothic spires, glides across the terrain with effortless yet breathtaking speed. From its numerous large, mullioned windows, a warm, vibrant golden light glows intensely, spilling over and casting a fleeting warmth onto the ground below. The camera perfectly centers the mansion, capturing the surreal textures of its stonework and the detailed tracery of its windows against the rapidly blurring surroundings. The landscape is a vast, polished obsidian plain, perfectly mirroring the surreal sky above. Two slender crescent moons hang suspended amidst swirling clouds of deep purple and bright cyan. Strange crystal plants dot the plain, shimmering with a soft, cool bioluminescence that contrasts starkly with the warm glow of the mansion. The overall atmosphere is one of majestic, silent power and profound mystery, a visually stunning and emotionally resonant scene that feels both epic and deeply dreamlike.", + "seed": 28857, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_4/index_9865_seed_28857_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.22089234013110398, + "vlm_logprob": -0.22089234013110398, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.22089234013110398, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large mansion made of dark, weathered stone with intricate Gothic spires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the mansion move across the terrain with swift speed while the camera tracks parallel to it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a vast, polished obsidian plain that mirrors the sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two slender crescent moons visible in a sky with swirling clouds of deep purple and bright cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do strange crystal plants with soft, cool bioluminescence appear on the plain contrasting with the mansion's warm light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5235328674316406 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8985328674316406 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5235328674316406, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5235328674316406, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.246763214468956, + 0.058024052530527115, + 0.22061777114868164, + 0.04725257679820061, + 0.037829991430044174, + 0.1143743023276329, + 0.04918913543224335, + 0.08040684461593628, + 0.08645658940076828, + 0.05908547714352608 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5235328674316406 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large mansion made of dark, weathered stone with intricate Gothic spires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the mansion move across the terrain with swift speed while the camera tracks parallel to it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a vast, polished obsidian plain that mirrors the sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two slender crescent moons visible in a sky with swirling clouds of deep purple and bright cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do strange crystal plants with soft, cool bioluminescence appear on the plain contrasting with the mansion's warm light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1799369603395462 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049370050430298 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1799369603395462, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1799369603395462, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12596367299556732, + 0.21391518414020538, + 0.19082482159137726, + 0.027308866381645203, + 0.046252381056547165, + 0.11109375208616257, + 0.05933118239045143, + 0.09433680027723312, + 0.05386301502585411, + 0.07711037248373032 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1799369603395462 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large mansion made of dark, weathered stone with intricate Gothic spires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the mansion move across the terrain with swift speed while the camera tracks parallel to it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a vast, polished obsidian plain that mirrors the sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two slender crescent moons visible in a sky with swirling clouds of deep purple and bright cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do strange crystal plants with soft, cool bioluminescence appear on the plain contrasting with the mansion's warm light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486589193344116 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236589193344116 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486589193344116, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486589193344116, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19339096546173096, + 0.05430918186903, + 0.062056977301836014, + 0.07063497602939606, + 0.03164120391011238, + 0.08574846386909485, + 0.027226760983467102, + 0.09854015707969666, + 0.2586597204208374, + 0.11779151856899261 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486589193344116 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large mansion made of dark, weathered stone with intricate Gothic spires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the mansion move across the terrain with swift speed while the camera tracks parallel to it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a vast, polished obsidian plain that mirrors the sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two slender crescent moons visible in a sky with swirling clouds of deep purple and bright cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do strange crystal plants with soft, cool bioluminescence appear on the plain contrasting with the mansion's warm light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03813929855823517 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881393432617188 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03813929855823517, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03813929855823517, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18258948624134064, + 0.0740191712975502, + 0.0804496631026268, + 0.062197957187891006, + 0.03672729432582855, + 0.1312132477760315, + 0.03458384424448013, + 0.042229872196912766, + 0.08610276877880096, + 0.26988670229911804 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03813929855823517 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large mansion made of dark, weathered stone with intricate Gothic spires?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the mansion move across the terrain with swift speed while the camera tracks parallel to it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground a vast, polished obsidian plain that mirrors the sky above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are two slender crescent moons visible in a sky with swirling clouds of deep purple and bright cyan?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do strange crystal plants with soft, cool bioluminescence appear on the plain contrasting with the mansion's warm light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014193654991686344 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264193534851074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014193654991686344, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014193654991686344, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20502857863903046, + 0.08093654364347458, + 0.10371595621109009, + 0.06265219300985336, + 0.053276751190423965, + 0.13318400084972382, + 0.0768977478146553, + 0.05338970199227333, + 0.09497586637735367, + 0.13594262301921844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014193654991686344 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_5/index_tensor([7051, 7051])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_5/index_tensor([7051, 7051])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..28a872bb222b1f1de06db095b0d34add7ff1dfe4 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_5/index_tensor([7051, 7051])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, centrally composed medium shot captures a vigorous elderly man seated at a large, dark, solid wood desk, the surface of which gleams with a warm sheen. He wears a dark gray, double-breasted, buttoned-up Chinese-style jacket, his silvery hair meticulously combed. Deep wrinkles on his forehead and around his eyes bear the wisdom of age, yet his eyes pierce with a sharp, focused gaze. He leans forward slightly, breath held, his right hand firmly grasping a soft, smooth wolf-hair brush. With a delicate, flowing motion, the tip of the brush, saturated with thick ink, writes a vigorous, powerful stroke on the white rice paper spread before him. The ink instantly smears across the delicate fibers, while his left hand gently presses against the edge to maintain evenness. A soft beam of natural light shines in obliquely from the window on one side of the painting, not only carving out the contours of his focused face, but also allowing the moist ink to reflect highlights on the delicate paper. The entire scene is filled with a solemn and tranquil sense of ritual under the warm light, and is imbued with the tranquility and power of classical Eastern aesthetics.", + "seed": 16088, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_5/index_7051_seed_16088_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04817045545205474, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04817045545205474, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04817045545205474, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, centrally composed medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark gray, double-breasted, buttoned-up Chinese-style jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a soft, smooth wolf-hair brush in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip, saturated with thick ink, write a vigorous stroke on white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a soft beam of natural light shining obliquely from a window on one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12198424339294434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3719842433929443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12198424339294434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12198424339294434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7463129758834839, + 0.02642405591905117, + 0.019364183768630028, + 0.023759670555591583, + 0.054231494665145874, + 0.02474055625498295, + 0.021840166300535202, + 0.02158639207482338, + 0.015142797492444515, + 0.046597711741924286 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12198424339294434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, centrally composed medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark gray, double-breasted, buttoned-up Chinese-style jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a soft, smooth wolf-hair brush in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip, saturated with thick ink, write a vigorous stroke on white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a soft beam of natural light shining obliquely from a window on one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07902425527572632 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579024314880371 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07902425527572632, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07902425527572632, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16173478960990906, + 0.059399232268333435, + 0.07438161969184875, + 0.016436196863651276, + 0.3463258743286133, + 0.1906779557466507, + 0.026853282004594803, + 0.04598454385995865, + 0.027895689010620117, + 0.05031084641814232 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07902425527572632 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, centrally composed medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark gray, double-breasted, buttoned-up Chinese-style jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a soft, smooth wolf-hair brush in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip, saturated with thick ink, write a vigorous stroke on white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a soft beam of natural light shining obliquely from a window on one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058931440114975 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955893516540527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058931440114975, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058931440114975, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23496302962303162, + 0.05734085664153099, + 0.057327866554260254, + 0.02725362963974476, + 0.2850763499736786, + 0.26806512475013733, + 0.018112393096089363, + 0.0255275946110487, + 0.010172126814723015, + 0.016161000356078148 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058931440114975 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, centrally composed medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark gray, double-breasted, buttoned-up Chinese-style jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a soft, smooth wolf-hair brush in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip, saturated with thick ink, write a vigorous stroke on white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a soft beam of natural light shining obliquely from a window on one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016063440591096878 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141063213348389 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016063440591096878, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016063440591096878, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1016206294298172, + 0.0891113132238388, + 0.05895700305700302, + 0.030473673716187477, + 0.0573447085916996, + 0.5006681680679321, + 0.03266988694667816, + 0.05679107829928398, + 0.013387287966907024, + 0.05897625535726547 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016063440591096878 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, centrally composed medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark gray, double-breasted, buttoned-up Chinese-style jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a soft, smooth wolf-hair brush in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip, saturated with thick ink, write a vigorous stroke on white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a soft beam of natural light shining obliquely from a window on one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003191023599356413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753190994262695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003191023599356413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003191023599356413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12175386399030685, + 0.019960010424256325, + 0.017414093017578125, + 0.009865107014775276, + 0.5195611119270325, + 0.25904789566993713, + 0.01742597110569477, + 0.010834243148565292, + 0.005034100729972124, + 0.01910362020134926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003191023599356413 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, centrally composed medium shot captures a vigorous elderly man seated at a large, dark, solid wood desk, the surface of which gleams with a warm sheen. He wears a dark gray, double-breasted, buttoned-up Chinese-style jacket, his silvery hair meticulously combed. Deep wrinkles on his forehead and around his eyes bear the wisdom of age, yet his eyes pierce with a sharp, focused gaze. He leans forward slightly, breath held, his right hand firmly grasping a soft, smooth wolf-hair brush. With a delicate, flowing motion, the tip of the brush, saturated with thick ink, writes a vigorous, powerful stroke on the white rice paper spread before him. The ink instantly smears across the delicate fibers, while his left hand gently presses against the edge to maintain evenness. A soft beam of natural light shines in obliquely from the window on one side of the painting, not only carving out the contours of his focused face, but also allowing the moist ink to reflect highlights on the delicate paper. The entire scene is filled with a solemn and tranquil sense of ritual under the warm light, and is imbued with the tranquility and power of classical Eastern aesthetics.", + "seed": 16089, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_5/index_7051_seed_16089_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.10502589214593172, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10502589214593172, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10502589214593172, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, centrally composed medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark gray, double-breasted, buttoned-up Chinese-style jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a soft, smooth wolf-hair brush in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip, saturated with thick ink, write a vigorous stroke on white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a soft beam of natural light shining obliquely from a window on one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3643024265766144 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.239302396774292 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3643024265766144, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3643024265766144, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2510840892791748, + 0.06787098199129105, + 0.08306131511926651, + 0.0966477021574974, + 0.060405123978853226, + 0.024760426953434944, + 0.10027602314949036, + 0.08879871666431427, + 0.09426520764827728, + 0.13283047080039978 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3643024265766144 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, centrally composed medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark gray, double-breasted, buttoned-up Chinese-style jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a soft, smooth wolf-hair brush in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip, saturated with thick ink, write a vigorous stroke on white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a soft beam of natural light shining obliquely from a window on one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07903901487588882 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790390968322754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07903901487588882, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07903901487588882, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13918910920619965, + 0.12147077172994614, + 0.07459120452404022, + 0.0555959977209568, + 0.04955730214715004, + 0.027506165206432343, + 0.03413720801472664, + 0.1166585385799408, + 0.18660731613636017, + 0.19468645751476288 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07903901487588882 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, centrally composed medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark gray, double-breasted, buttoned-up Chinese-style jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a soft, smooth wolf-hair brush in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip, saturated with thick ink, write a vigorous stroke on white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a soft beam of natural light shining obliquely from a window on one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0486704483628273 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048670530319214 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0486704483628273, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0486704483628273, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33996933698654175, + 0.14069227874279022, + 0.04015953838825226, + 0.051472779363393784, + 0.05700137838721275, + 0.03616009280085564, + 0.09878978133201599, + 0.04300341010093689, + 0.11054641753435135, + 0.08220499753952026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0486704483628273 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, centrally composed medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark gray, double-breasted, buttoned-up Chinese-style jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a soft, smooth wolf-hair brush in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip, saturated with thick ink, write a vigorous stroke on white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a soft beam of natural light shining obliquely from a window on one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057880349457264 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955788612365723 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057880349457264, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057880349457264, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36887794733047485, + 0.13260382413864136, + 0.05020201578736305, + 0.06271586567163467, + 0.033133555203676224, + 0.04385814443230629, + 0.09850143641233444, + 0.04395429044961929, + 0.09209741652011871, + 0.0740554928779602 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057880349457264 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, centrally composed medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark gray, double-breasted, buttoned-up Chinese-style jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a soft, smooth wolf-hair brush in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip, saturated with thick ink, write a vigorous stroke on white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a soft beam of natural light shining obliquely from a window on one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012538767419755459 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387538909912109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012538767419755459, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012538767419755459, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15659783780574799, + 0.03979473188519478, + 0.020986735820770264, + 0.03204500302672386, + 0.015982486307621002, + 0.02655017003417015, + 0.13129547238349915, + 0.10770583152770996, + 0.2098476141691208, + 0.2591940760612488 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012538767419755459 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, centrally composed medium shot captures a vigorous elderly man seated at a large, dark, solid wood desk, the surface of which gleams with a warm sheen. He wears a dark gray, double-breasted, buttoned-up Chinese-style jacket, his silvery hair meticulously combed. Deep wrinkles on his forehead and around his eyes bear the wisdom of age, yet his eyes pierce with a sharp, focused gaze. He leans forward slightly, breath held, his right hand firmly grasping a soft, smooth wolf-hair brush. With a delicate, flowing motion, the tip of the brush, saturated with thick ink, writes a vigorous, powerful stroke on the white rice paper spread before him. The ink instantly smears across the delicate fibers, while his left hand gently presses against the edge to maintain evenness. A soft beam of natural light shines in obliquely from the window on one side of the painting, not only carving out the contours of his focused face, but also allowing the moist ink to reflect highlights on the delicate paper. The entire scene is filled with a solemn and tranquil sense of ritual under the warm light, and is imbued with the tranquility and power of classical Eastern aesthetics.", + "seed": 16090, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_5/index_7051_seed_16090_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.08203117717057466, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08203117717057466, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08203117717057466, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, centrally composed medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark gray, double-breasted, buttoned-up Chinese-style jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a soft, smooth wolf-hair brush in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip, saturated with thick ink, write a vigorous stroke on white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a soft beam of natural light shining obliquely from a window on one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2581798732280731 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6331799030303955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2581798732280731, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2581798732280731, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2774573266506195, + 0.22016647458076477, + 0.05322137475013733, + 0.07510723173618317, + 0.09891695529222488, + 0.060122620314359665, + 0.06269099563360214, + 0.035986755043268204, + 0.09081611037254333, + 0.025514157488942146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2581798732280731 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, centrally composed medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark gray, double-breasted, buttoned-up Chinese-style jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a soft, smooth wolf-hair brush in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip, saturated with thick ink, write a vigorous stroke on white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a soft beam of natural light shining obliquely from a window on one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10035895556211472 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503589630126953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10035895556211472, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10035895556211472, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19544704258441925, + 0.11347401142120361, + 0.06431153416633606, + 0.2532999813556671, + 0.11405476182699203, + 0.04872481897473335, + 0.04228179529309273, + 0.04269178584218025, + 0.08206097036600113, + 0.04365324229001999 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10035895556211472 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, centrally composed medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark gray, double-breasted, buttoned-up Chinese-style jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a soft, smooth wolf-hair brush in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip, saturated with thick ink, write a vigorous stroke on white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a soft beam of natural light shining obliquely from a window on one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02635478787124157 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513547897338867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02635478787124157, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02635478787124157, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15764348208904266, + 0.07372380793094635, + 0.039669811725616455, + 0.09386007487773895, + 0.1601904034614563, + 0.04871296510100365, + 0.02961817942559719, + 0.027432376518845558, + 0.3403504192829132, + 0.02879847027361393 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02635478787124157 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, centrally composed medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark gray, double-breasted, buttoned-up Chinese-style jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a soft, smooth wolf-hair brush in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip, saturated with thick ink, write a vigorous stroke on white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a soft beam of natural light shining obliquely from a window on one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011070025153458118 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511070251464844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011070025153458118, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011070025153458118, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17321106791496277, + 0.2157541811466217, + 0.09837360680103302, + 0.08944864571094513, + 0.07220403105020523, + 0.037682753056287766, + 0.041497793048620224, + 0.02685757726430893, + 0.19318194687366486, + 0.0517883226275444 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011070025153458118 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, centrally composed medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark gray, double-breasted, buttoned-up Chinese-style jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a soft, smooth wolf-hair brush in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip, saturated with thick ink, write a vigorous stroke on white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a soft beam of natural light shining obliquely from a window on one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014192244037985802 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2641921043396 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014192244037985802, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014192244037985802, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18042197823524475, + 0.4732879102230072, + 0.09754130244255066, + 0.017264951020479202, + 0.039715927094221115, + 0.03692525625228882, + 0.08359532803297043, + 0.014204149134457111, + 0.037082329392433167, + 0.019960938021540642 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014192244037985802 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, centrally composed medium shot captures a vigorous elderly man seated at a large, dark, solid wood desk, the surface of which gleams with a warm sheen. He wears a dark gray, double-breasted, buttoned-up Chinese-style jacket, his silvery hair meticulously combed. Deep wrinkles on his forehead and around his eyes bear the wisdom of age, yet his eyes pierce with a sharp, focused gaze. He leans forward slightly, breath held, his right hand firmly grasping a soft, smooth wolf-hair brush. With a delicate, flowing motion, the tip of the brush, saturated with thick ink, writes a vigorous, powerful stroke on the white rice paper spread before him. The ink instantly smears across the delicate fibers, while his left hand gently presses against the edge to maintain evenness. A soft beam of natural light shines in obliquely from the window on one side of the painting, not only carving out the contours of his focused face, but also allowing the moist ink to reflect highlights on the delicate paper. The entire scene is filled with a solemn and tranquil sense of ritual under the warm light, and is imbued with the tranquility and power of classical Eastern aesthetics.", + "seed": 16091, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_5/index_7051_seed_16091_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06899182349443436, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06899182349443436, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06899182349443436, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, centrally composed medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark gray, double-breasted, buttoned-up Chinese-style jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a soft, smooth wolf-hair brush in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip, saturated with thick ink, write a vigorous stroke on white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a soft beam of natural light shining obliquely from a window on one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16397520899772644 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.038975238800049 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16397520899772644, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16397520899772644, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33600836992263794, + 0.16963382065296173, + 0.12057874351739883, + 0.05776029825210571, + 0.04998524859547615, + 0.051136475056409836, + 0.026663413271307945, + 0.03572436794638634, + 0.04358204826712608, + 0.1089271828532219 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16397520899772644 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, centrally composed medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark gray, double-breasted, buttoned-up Chinese-style jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a soft, smooth wolf-hair brush in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip, saturated with thick ink, write a vigorous stroke on white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a soft beam of natural light shining obliquely from a window on one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07006660848855972 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950666904449463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07006660848855972, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07006660848855972, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1396770030260086, + 0.15347543358802795, + 0.15017421543598175, + 0.13233457505702972, + 0.06470577418804169, + 0.056228090077638626, + 0.132218599319458, + 0.060390062630176544, + 0.051718488335609436, + 0.05907776206731796 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07006660848855972 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, centrally composed medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark gray, double-breasted, buttoned-up Chinese-style jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a soft, smooth wolf-hair brush in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip, saturated with thick ink, write a vigorous stroke on white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a soft beam of natural light shining obliquely from a window on one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023294946178793907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732949256896973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023294946178793907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023294946178793907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12440775334835052, + 0.10482817888259888, + 0.12209254503250122, + 0.1380353718996048, + 0.1617545485496521, + 0.05985111743211746, + 0.04122691974043846, + 0.09329848736524582, + 0.05741714686155319, + 0.09708794206380844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023294946178793907 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, centrally composed medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark gray, double-breasted, buttoned-up Chinese-style jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a soft, smooth wolf-hair brush in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip, saturated with thick ink, write a vigorous stroke on white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a soft beam of natural light shining obliquely from a window on one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008637094870209694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758636951446533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008637094870209694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008637094870209694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10148593038320541, + 0.217190220952034, + 0.0575622133910656, + 0.079914391040802, + 0.07405135780572891, + 0.12192151695489883, + 0.10879296064376831, + 0.08706507831811905, + 0.05557785928249359, + 0.09643851965665817 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008637094870209694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, centrally composed medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a dark gray, double-breasted, buttoned-up Chinese-style jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding a soft, smooth wolf-hair brush in his right hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the brush tip, saturated with thick ink, write a vigorous stroke on white rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a soft beam of natural light shining obliquely from a window on one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898525893688202 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789852142333984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898525893688202, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898525893688202, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26343345642089844, + 0.15460695326328278, + 0.20557795464992523, + 0.05866605415940285, + 0.1250423938035965, + 0.05509912595152855, + 0.03643474727869034, + 0.025838809087872505, + 0.01993274874985218, + 0.055367715656757355 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898525893688202 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_6/index_tensor([2606, 2606])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_6/index_tensor([2606, 2606])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d7880e81381237c1695a8567ae26c83cefdf3d1b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_6/index_tensor([2606, 2606])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, extreme-wide shot captures the apocalyptic grandeur of a menacing, swirling supercell thunderstorm, completely dominating the sky, its dark, turbulent core perfectly positioned at the center of the frame. In a breathtakingly realistic CGI display, the massive storm structure—a churning vortex of bruised purple, deep indigo, and sickly green-yellow hues—spins with slow, relentless terror against a backdrop of open, desolate grassland. The ambient light is an eerie twilight, intermittently punctuated by bright flashes of cold-blue internal lightning that outline the cloud's seething textures. Suddenly, the action begins, as massive, irregularly shaped hailstones the size of grapefruits begin to plummet from the storm's churning base, not falling in sheets but as individual, ponderous projectiles that whiz through the air. They slam into the dry, cracked earth below with a ferocious force, each impact meticulously rendered to show the ice exploding into a cascade of crystalline shards and kicking up plumes of dust. The ground quickly transforms into a chaotic tapestry of fresh craters and shattered ice, creating a scene of visceral horror that conveys the raw, untamable power of nature in awe-inspiring, surreal detail.", + "seed": 31746, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_6/index_2606_seed_31746_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.02251445911824703, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02251445911824703, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02251445911824703, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme-wide shot capturing a massive supercell thunderstorm dominating the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the storm's dark, turbulent core positioned at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the storm display hues of bruised purple, deep indigo, and sickly green-yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive hailstones the size of grapefruits shown plummeting from the storm base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the hailstone impacts create fresh craters and plumes of dust on the dry, cracked earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006592667195945978 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.256592750549316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006592667195945978, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006592667195945978, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13438767194747925, + 0.08556468784809113, + 0.06378711760044098, + 0.0880231186747551, + 0.11387013643980026, + 0.20287755131721497, + 0.04705974832177162, + 0.04250386729836464, + 0.05533049628138542, + 0.16659556329250336 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006592667195945978 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme-wide shot capturing a massive supercell thunderstorm dominating the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the storm's dark, turbulent core positioned at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the storm display hues of bruised purple, deep indigo, and sickly green-yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive hailstones the size of grapefruits shown plummeting from the storm base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the hailstone impacts create fresh craters and plumes of dust on the dry, cracked earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059258334338665 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.89559268951416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059258334338665, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059258334338665, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25156059861183167, + 0.11714137345552444, + 0.12507638335227966, + 0.08493500202894211, + 0.09538394212722778, + 0.18132764101028442, + 0.022490767762064934, + 0.01917252503335476, + 0.02643592469394207, + 0.07647585868835449 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059258334338665 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme-wide shot capturing a massive supercell thunderstorm dominating the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the storm's dark, turbulent core positioned at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the storm display hues of bruised purple, deep indigo, and sickly green-yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive hailstones the size of grapefruits shown plummeting from the storm base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the hailstone impacts create fresh craters and plumes of dust on the dry, cracked earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028266259469091892 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877826690673828 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028266259469091892, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028266259469091892, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19082984328269958, + 0.12465343624353409, + 0.19720222055912018, + 0.10772718489170074, + 0.044099122285842896, + 0.04037183150649071, + 0.05684077367186546, + 0.06562625616788864, + 0.03651666268706322, + 0.13613265752792358 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028266259469091892 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme-wide shot capturing a massive supercell thunderstorm dominating the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the storm's dark, turbulent core positioned at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the storm display hues of bruised purple, deep indigo, and sickly green-yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive hailstones the size of grapefruits shown plummeting from the storm base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the hailstone impacts create fresh craters and plumes of dust on the dry, cracked earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0700187087059021 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695018768310547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0700187087059021, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0700187087059021, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08124225586652756, + 0.0712020993232727, + 0.10851464420557022, + 0.03153727203607559, + 0.027714833617210388, + 0.10760033130645752, + 0.13210579752922058, + 0.11187534034252167, + 0.0803576111793518, + 0.24784979224205017 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0700187087059021 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme-wide shot capturing a massive supercell thunderstorm dominating the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the storm's dark, turbulent core positioned at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the storm display hues of bruised purple, deep indigo, and sickly green-yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive hailstones the size of grapefruits shown plummeting from the storm base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the hailstone impacts create fresh craters and plumes of dust on the dry, cracked earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012541710399091244 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387541770935059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012541710399091244, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012541710399091244, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10980655997991562, + 0.06556505709886551, + 0.09271777421236038, + 0.058210715651512146, + 0.06317847222089767, + 0.036751631647348404, + 0.08229116350412369, + 0.09571412205696106, + 0.09190567582845688, + 0.30385881662368774 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012541710399091244 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, extreme-wide shot captures the apocalyptic grandeur of a menacing, swirling supercell thunderstorm, completely dominating the sky, its dark, turbulent core perfectly positioned at the center of the frame. In a breathtakingly realistic CGI display, the massive storm structure—a churning vortex of bruised purple, deep indigo, and sickly green-yellow hues—spins with slow, relentless terror against a backdrop of open, desolate grassland. The ambient light is an eerie twilight, intermittently punctuated by bright flashes of cold-blue internal lightning that outline the cloud's seething textures. Suddenly, the action begins, as massive, irregularly shaped hailstones the size of grapefruits begin to plummet from the storm's churning base, not falling in sheets but as individual, ponderous projectiles that whiz through the air. They slam into the dry, cracked earth below with a ferocious force, each impact meticulously rendered to show the ice exploding into a cascade of crystalline shards and kicking up plumes of dust. The ground quickly transforms into a chaotic tapestry of fresh craters and shattered ice, creating a scene of visceral horror that conveys the raw, untamable power of nature in awe-inspiring, surreal detail.", + "seed": 31747, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_6/index_2606_seed_31747_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.012231656024232507, + "vlm_logprob": -0.012231656024232507, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.012231656024232507, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme-wide shot capturing a massive supercell thunderstorm dominating the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the storm's dark, turbulent core positioned at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the storm display hues of bruised purple, deep indigo, and sickly green-yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive hailstones the size of grapefruits shown plummeting from the storm base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the hailstone impacts create fresh craters and plumes of dust on the dry, cracked earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010420202277600765 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.635420322418213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010420202277600765, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010420202277600765, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2952861189842224, + 0.08898613601922989, + 0.08929768204689026, + 0.05928212031722069, + 0.10950645804405212, + 0.05538041889667511, + 0.03408422693610191, + 0.14131411910057068, + 0.08487871289253235, + 0.04198397323489189 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010420202277600765 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme-wide shot capturing a massive supercell thunderstorm dominating the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the storm's dark, turbulent core positioned at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the storm display hues of bruised purple, deep indigo, and sickly green-yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive hailstones the size of grapefruits shown plummeting from the storm base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the hailstone impacts create fresh craters and plumes of dust on the dry, cracked earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012551363557577133 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387551307678223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012551363557577133, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012551363557577133, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2900351285934448, + 0.1527748703956604, + 0.18617749214172363, + 0.0704626515507698, + 0.07432980835437775, + 0.027859967201948166, + 0.02875436283648014, + 0.08879812806844711, + 0.04314359277486801, + 0.03766404464840889 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012551363557577133 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme-wide shot capturing a massive supercell thunderstorm dominating the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the storm's dark, turbulent core positioned at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the storm display hues of bruised purple, deep indigo, and sickly green-yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive hailstones the size of grapefruits shown plummeting from the storm base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the hailstone impacts create fresh craters and plumes of dust on the dry, cracked earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031986285466700792 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753198623657227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031986285466700792, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031986285466700792, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1363551765680313, + 0.08947169035673141, + 0.06778552383184433, + 0.0688692033290863, + 0.038742393255233765, + 0.018310949206352234, + 0.036498770117759705, + 0.400617390871048, + 0.09063287079334259, + 0.05271604284644127 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031986285466700792 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme-wide shot capturing a massive supercell thunderstorm dominating the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the storm's dark, turbulent core positioned at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the storm display hues of bruised purple, deep indigo, and sickly green-yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive hailstones the size of grapefruits shown plummeting from the storm base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the hailstone impacts create fresh craters and plumes of dust on the dry, cracked earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026348982006311417 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513490676879883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026348982006311417, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026348982006311417, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.144930899143219, + 0.09513117372989655, + 0.03842616453766823, + 0.04000742733478546, + 0.04131537675857544, + 0.08943253755569458, + 0.04139578714966774, + 0.3588884472846985, + 0.05345345661044121, + 0.09701873362064362 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026348982006311417 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme-wide shot capturing a massive supercell thunderstorm dominating the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the storm's dark, turbulent core positioned at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the storm display hues of bruised purple, deep indigo, and sickly green-yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive hailstones the size of grapefruits shown plummeting from the storm base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the hailstone impacts create fresh craters and plumes of dust on the dry, cracked earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00863910373300314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758639335632324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00863910373300314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00863910373300314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05707705393433571, + 0.052282530814409256, + 0.018203306943178177, + 0.012538623996078968, + 0.015486253425478935, + 0.03932151198387146, + 0.03481400012969971, + 0.5854290127754211, + 0.06289052218198776, + 0.12195712327957153 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00863910373300314 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, extreme-wide shot captures the apocalyptic grandeur of a menacing, swirling supercell thunderstorm, completely dominating the sky, its dark, turbulent core perfectly positioned at the center of the frame. In a breathtakingly realistic CGI display, the massive storm structure—a churning vortex of bruised purple, deep indigo, and sickly green-yellow hues—spins with slow, relentless terror against a backdrop of open, desolate grassland. The ambient light is an eerie twilight, intermittently punctuated by bright flashes of cold-blue internal lightning that outline the cloud's seething textures. Suddenly, the action begins, as massive, irregularly shaped hailstones the size of grapefruits begin to plummet from the storm's churning base, not falling in sheets but as individual, ponderous projectiles that whiz through the air. They slam into the dry, cracked earth below with a ferocious force, each impact meticulously rendered to show the ice exploding into a cascade of crystalline shards and kicking up plumes of dust. The ground quickly transforms into a chaotic tapestry of fresh craters and shattered ice, creating a scene of visceral horror that conveys the raw, untamable power of nature in awe-inspiring, surreal detail.", + "seed": 31748, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_6/index_2606_seed_31748_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.01210951921530068, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01210951921530068, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01210951921530068, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme-wide shot capturing a massive supercell thunderstorm dominating the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the storm's dark, turbulent core positioned at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the storm display hues of bruised purple, deep indigo, and sickly green-yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive hailstones the size of grapefruits shown plummeting from the storm base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the hailstone impacts create fresh craters and plumes of dust on the dry, cracked earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0074556199833750725 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.007455825805664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0074556199833750725, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0074556199833750725, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3178600072860718, + 0.35061100125312805, + 0.012341267429292202, + 0.04448530077934265, + 0.05869673937559128, + 0.012545649893581867, + 0.0440359003841877, + 0.06196621060371399, + 0.08407846093177795, + 0.013379526324570179 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0074556199833750725 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme-wide shot capturing a massive supercell thunderstorm dominating the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the storm's dark, turbulent core positioned at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the storm display hues of bruised purple, deep indigo, and sickly green-yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive hailstones the size of grapefruits shown plummeting from the storm base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the hailstone impacts create fresh craters and plumes of dust on the dry, cracked earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012547949329018593 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387547969818115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012547949329018593, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012547949329018593, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6695616245269775, + 0.03879338502883911, + 0.014648395590484142, + 0.03169627487659454, + 0.03472357243299484, + 0.03495177626609802, + 0.02984706126153469, + 0.051430825144052505, + 0.06514198333024979, + 0.02920512855052948 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012547949329018593 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme-wide shot capturing a massive supercell thunderstorm dominating the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the storm's dark, turbulent core positioned at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the storm display hues of bruised purple, deep indigo, and sickly green-yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive hailstones the size of grapefruits shown plummeting from the storm base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the hailstone impacts create fresh craters and plumes of dust on the dry, cracked earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022024677600711584 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.12720251083374 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022024677600711584, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022024677600711584, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5109038352966309, + 0.26706191897392273, + 0.012236184440553188, + 0.030875297263264656, + 0.07025697827339172, + 0.014454706571996212, + 0.014085678383708, + 0.013630879111588001, + 0.05929895490407944, + 0.007195552811026573 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022024677600711584 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme-wide shot capturing a massive supercell thunderstorm dominating the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the storm's dark, turbulent core positioned at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the storm display hues of bruised purple, deep indigo, and sickly green-yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive hailstones the size of grapefruits shown plummeting from the storm base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the hailstone impacts create fresh craters and plumes of dust on the dry, cracked earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370317071676254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408703088760376 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370317071676254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370317071676254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08201649785041809, + 0.34786683320999146, + 0.015255235135555267, + 0.06729909032583237, + 0.0609297938644886, + 0.012429003603756428, + 0.01686801016330719, + 0.10487482696771622, + 0.25435468554496765, + 0.03810598701238632 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370317071676254 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme-wide shot capturing a massive supercell thunderstorm dominating the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the storm's dark, turbulent core positioned at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the storm display hues of bruised purple, deep indigo, and sickly green-yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive hailstones the size of grapefruits shown plummeting from the storm base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the hailstone impacts create fresh craters and plumes of dust on the dry, cracked earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00463838828727603 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379638195037842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00463838828727603, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00463838828727603, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1871843785047531, + 0.12459985166788101, + 0.00979100726544857, + 0.02118801698088646, + 0.04457689821720123, + 0.017914094030857086, + 0.010990628972649574, + 0.04715292900800705, + 0.5032334327697754, + 0.03336869180202484 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00463838828727603 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, extreme-wide shot captures the apocalyptic grandeur of a menacing, swirling supercell thunderstorm, completely dominating the sky, its dark, turbulent core perfectly positioned at the center of the frame. In a breathtakingly realistic CGI display, the massive storm structure—a churning vortex of bruised purple, deep indigo, and sickly green-yellow hues—spins with slow, relentless terror against a backdrop of open, desolate grassland. The ambient light is an eerie twilight, intermittently punctuated by bright flashes of cold-blue internal lightning that outline the cloud's seething textures. Suddenly, the action begins, as massive, irregularly shaped hailstones the size of grapefruits begin to plummet from the storm's churning base, not falling in sheets but as individual, ponderous projectiles that whiz through the air. They slam into the dry, cracked earth below with a ferocious force, each impact meticulously rendered to show the ice exploding into a cascade of crystalline shards and kicking up plumes of dust. The ground quickly transforms into a chaotic tapestry of fresh craters and shattered ice, creating a scene of visceral horror that conveys the raw, untamable power of nature in awe-inspiring, surreal detail.", + "seed": 31749, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_6/index_2606_seed_31749_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.013029013108462096, + "vlm_logprob": -0.013029013108462096, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.013029013108462096, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme-wide shot capturing a massive supercell thunderstorm dominating the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the storm's dark, turbulent core positioned at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the storm display hues of bruised purple, deep indigo, and sickly green-yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive hailstones the size of grapefruits shown plummeting from the storm base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the hailstone impacts create fresh craters and plumes of dust on the dry, cracked earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007665031123906374 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.132665157318115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007665031123906374, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007665031123906374, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11880506575107574, + 0.08551289141178131, + 0.05810408666729927, + 0.12632958590984344, + 0.10290204733610153, + 0.048806220293045044, + 0.065689817070961, + 0.2604062557220459, + 0.08226359635591507, + 0.05118047073483467 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007665031123906374 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme-wide shot capturing a massive supercell thunderstorm dominating the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the storm's dark, turbulent core positioned at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the storm display hues of bruised purple, deep indigo, and sickly green-yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive hailstones the size of grapefruits shown plummeting from the storm base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the hailstone impacts create fresh craters and plumes of dust on the dry, cracked earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01108488067984581 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511085033416748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01108488067984581, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01108488067984581, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14119432866573334, + 0.09747347980737686, + 0.06385615468025208, + 0.18737445771694183, + 0.08472362160682678, + 0.0550445057451725, + 0.0246445182710886, + 0.2297339290380478, + 0.05227666348218918, + 0.0636783242225647 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01108488067984581 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme-wide shot capturing a massive supercell thunderstorm dominating the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the storm's dark, turbulent core positioned at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the storm display hues of bruised purple, deep indigo, and sickly green-yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive hailstones the size of grapefruits shown plummeting from the storm base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the hailstone impacts create fresh craters and plumes of dust on the dry, cracked earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059547401033341885 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130954742431641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059547401033341885, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059547401033341885, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10336074233055115, + 0.05971970781683922, + 0.047784473747015, + 0.10185331851243973, + 0.05256498605012894, + 0.0406220406293869, + 0.09536706656217575, + 0.320977121591568, + 0.11998115479946136, + 0.057769402861595154 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059547401033341885 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme-wide shot capturing a massive supercell thunderstorm dominating the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the storm's dark, turbulent core positioned at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the storm display hues of bruised purple, deep indigo, and sickly green-yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive hailstones the size of grapefruits shown plummeting from the storm base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the hailstone impacts create fresh craters and plumes of dust on the dry, cracked earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370363265275955 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408703565597534 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370363265275955, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370363265275955, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07270157337188721, + 0.05314720794558525, + 0.07341476529836655, + 0.26732295751571655, + 0.08419059962034225, + 0.0988067239522934, + 0.12290949374437332, + 0.09044410288333893, + 0.08545184880495071, + 0.05161067098379135 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370363265275955 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme-wide shot capturing a massive supercell thunderstorm dominating the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the storm's dark, turbulent core positioned at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the storm display hues of bruised purple, deep indigo, and sickly green-yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive hailstones the size of grapefruits shown plummeting from the storm base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the hailstone impacts create fresh craters and plumes of dust on the dry, cracked earth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006736780982464552 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006736755371094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006736780982464552, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006736780982464552, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0570438914000988, + 0.03893044963479042, + 0.046113356947898865, + 0.1717415601015091, + 0.12385249137878418, + 0.08740203827619553, + 0.1664310097694397, + 0.14590950310230255, + 0.09171278029680252, + 0.07086300849914551 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006736780982464552 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_7/index_tensor([9860, 9860])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_7/index_tensor([9860, 9860])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1e110d960cf4630e0f87280f66850aafbae7dbae --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_7/index_tensor([9860, 9860])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, beginning at a slight upward angle, then smoothly pulls back, culminating in a magnificent, one-shot, unbroken focus on a flaming phoenix awakening from its crouching state. Initially, the frame captures only the pulsating glow at the phoenix's core, like a pulsating heart. As the camera slowly retreats, its massive wings spread out to its sides with a majestic and deliberate rhythm. This phoenix is not composed of flesh and blood; its entire body and every feather are composed of incandescent, viscous lava. The edges of its feathers shimmer with golden-red sparks, while deep, almost black lava veins flow within, as if liquid gold is being slowly poured into the darkness. It raises its head majestically, its beak gleaming with incandescent light, its eyes two blazing stars, imbued with an ancient and powerful power. The background is the vast, boundless void of space, dotted with distant, faint stardust, making the phoenix the sole source of light in the entire scene. Its blazing light casts an intense glow in the darkness, illuminating every flowing detail. When the wings are finally fully spread out, forming a magnificent posture that covers the sky, the sparks at the tips of the wings float away like dandelions, drawing a short and bright trajectory in the void before going out. The whole picture is full of a sacred and magnificent epic feeling, conveying a kind of nirvana and rebirth, unparalleled life force and cosmic magnificent aesthetics.", + "seed": 24701, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_7/index_9860_seed_24701_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.14800415206700562, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14800415206700562, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.800000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14800415206700562, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a phoenix composed entirely of incandescent, viscous lava?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot at a slight upward angle showing only a pulsating glow at the phoenix's core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull back from the close-up to reveal the phoenix's massive wings spreading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background the vast void of space dotted with distant, faint stardust where the phoenix is the sole source of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do golden-red sparks float away from the wing tips like dandelions, leaving short bright trajectories before fading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.352000892162323 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2270009517669678 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.352000892162323, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8750000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.352000892162323, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21247777342796326, + 0.20341412723064423, + 0.034561216831207275, + 0.08554248511791229, + 0.059635620564222336, + 0.01215152908116579, + 0.3483518660068512, + 0.007319767028093338, + 0.017513101920485497, + 0.019032498821616173 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.352000892162323 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a phoenix composed entirely of incandescent, viscous lava?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot at a slight upward angle showing only a pulsating glow at the phoenix's core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull back from the close-up to reveal the phoenix's massive wings spreading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background the vast void of space dotted with distant, faint stardust where the phoenix is the sole source of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do golden-red sparks float away from the wing tips like dandelions, leaving short bright trajectories before fading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020600290969014168 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956003189086914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020600290969014168, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020600290969014168, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1833707094192505, + 0.4283292293548584, + 0.02516515552997589, + 0.20704874396324158, + 0.026960810646414757, + 0.0062638744711875916, + 0.03304541856050491, + 0.028661580756306648, + 0.03258555755019188, + 0.028568897396326065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020600290969014168 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a phoenix composed entirely of incandescent, viscous lava?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot at a slight upward angle showing only a pulsating glow at the phoenix's core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull back from the close-up to reveal the phoenix's massive wings spreading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background the vast void of space dotted with distant, faint stardust where the phoenix is the sole source of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do golden-red sparks float away from the wing tips like dandelions, leaving short bright trajectories before fading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005260198377072811 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255259990692139 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005260198377072811, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005260198377072811, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15116292238235474, + 0.22325007617473602, + 0.02272271178662777, + 0.17591185867786407, + 0.018766002729535103, + 0.05766966938972473, + 0.23543499410152435, + 0.02156040444970131, + 0.031705714762210846, + 0.06181565299630165 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005260198377072811 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a phoenix composed entirely of incandescent, viscous lava?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot at a slight upward angle showing only a pulsating glow at the phoenix's core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull back from the close-up to reveal the phoenix's massive wings spreading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background the vast void of space dotted with distant, faint stardust where the phoenix is the sole source of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do golden-red sparks float away from the wing tips like dandelions, leaving short bright trajectories before fading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134936988353729 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134937286376953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134936988353729, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134936988353729, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36724942922592163, + 0.29677051305770874, + 0.02099509723484516, + 0.11955255270004272, + 0.03859750181436539, + 0.022815674543380737, + 0.034219276160001755, + 0.006063986569643021, + 0.03540839999914169, + 0.05832755193114281 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134936988353729 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a phoenix composed entirely of incandescent, viscous lava?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot at a slight upward angle showing only a pulsating glow at the phoenix's core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull back from the close-up to reveal the phoenix's massive wings spreading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background the vast void of space dotted with distant, faint stardust where the phoenix is the sole source of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do golden-red sparks float away from the wing tips like dandelions, leaving short bright trajectories before fading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866567999124527 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048665761947632 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866567999124527, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866567999124527, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11092989891767502, + 0.11274316161870956, + 0.028659874573349953, + 0.08432811498641968, + 0.12816044688224792, + 0.05727764591574669, + 0.20829322934150696, + 0.039464134722948074, + 0.056150440126657486, + 0.1739930659532547 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866567999124527 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, beginning at a slight upward angle, then smoothly pulls back, culminating in a magnificent, one-shot, unbroken focus on a flaming phoenix awakening from its crouching state. Initially, the frame captures only the pulsating glow at the phoenix's core, like a pulsating heart. As the camera slowly retreats, its massive wings spread out to its sides with a majestic and deliberate rhythm. This phoenix is not composed of flesh and blood; its entire body and every feather are composed of incandescent, viscous lava. The edges of its feathers shimmer with golden-red sparks, while deep, almost black lava veins flow within, as if liquid gold is being slowly poured into the darkness. It raises its head majestically, its beak gleaming with incandescent light, its eyes two blazing stars, imbued with an ancient and powerful power. The background is the vast, boundless void of space, dotted with distant, faint stardust, making the phoenix the sole source of light in the entire scene. Its blazing light casts an intense glow in the darkness, illuminating every flowing detail. When the wings are finally fully spread out, forming a magnificent posture that covers the sky, the sparks at the tips of the wings float away like dandelions, drawing a short and bright trajectory in the void before going out. The whole picture is full of a sacred and magnificent epic feeling, conveying a kind of nirvana and rebirth, unparalleled life force and cosmic magnificent aesthetics.", + "seed": 24702, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_7/index_9860_seed_24702_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.11438095988705754, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11438095988705754, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11438095988705754, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a phoenix composed entirely of incandescent, viscous lava?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot at a slight upward angle showing only a pulsating glow at the phoenix's core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull back from the close-up to reveal the phoenix's massive wings spreading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background the vast void of space dotted with distant, faint stardust where the phoenix is the sole source of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do golden-red sparks float away from the wing tips like dandelions, leaving short bright trajectories before fading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14374850690364838 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0187485218048096 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14374850690364838, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14374850690364838, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04039189592003822, + 0.021368997171521187, + 0.01934037171304226, + 0.09823161363601685, + 0.05378180369734764, + 0.015249076299369335, + 0.020443322136998177, + 0.013402209617197514, + 0.7100186944007874, + 0.007772036362439394 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14374850690364838 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a phoenix composed entirely of incandescent, viscous lava?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot at a slight upward angle showing only a pulsating glow at the phoenix's core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull back from the close-up to reveal the phoenix's massive wings spreading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background the vast void of space dotted with distant, faint stardust where the phoenix is the sole source of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do golden-red sparks float away from the wing tips like dandelions, leaving short bright trajectories before fading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03372172638773918 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408721685409546 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03372172638773918, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03372172638773918, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06149451807141304, + 0.05133989453315735, + 0.02166997827589512, + 0.13514816761016846, + 0.4611043334007263, + 0.08186499029397964, + 0.018827905878424644, + 0.04788985103368759, + 0.08493851870298386, + 0.035721827298402786 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03372172638773918 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a phoenix composed entirely of incandescent, viscous lava?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot at a slight upward angle showing only a pulsating glow at the phoenix's core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull back from the close-up to reveal the phoenix's massive wings spreading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background the vast void of space dotted with distant, faint stardust where the phoenix is the sole source of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do golden-red sparks float away from the wing tips like dandelions, leaving short bright trajectories before fading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007634746376425028 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88263463973999 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007634746376425028, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007634746376425028, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09247364103794098, + 0.045274052768945694, + 0.0438389889895916, + 0.0579100102186203, + 0.34061524271965027, + 0.0828484445810318, + 0.02986128069460392, + 0.06795494258403778, + 0.16667282581329346, + 0.07255058735609055 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007634746376425028 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a phoenix composed entirely of incandescent, viscous lava?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot at a slight upward angle showing only a pulsating glow at the phoenix's core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull back from the close-up to reveal the phoenix's massive wings spreading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background the vast void of space dotted with distant, faint stardust where the phoenix is the sole source of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do golden-red sparks float away from the wing tips like dandelions, leaving short bright trajectories before fading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486810624599457 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223681092262268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486810624599457, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486810624599457, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1378750056028366, + 0.07450451701879501, + 0.0580274872481823, + 0.11697106063365936, + 0.23599843680858612, + 0.047124557197093964, + 0.0336039774119854, + 0.11969465762376785, + 0.13759289681911469, + 0.03860735148191452 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486810624599457 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a phoenix composed entirely of incandescent, viscous lava?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot at a slight upward angle showing only a pulsating glow at the phoenix's core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull back from the close-up to reveal the phoenix's massive wings spreading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background the vast void of space dotted with distant, faint stardust where the phoenix is the sole source of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do golden-red sparks float away from the wing tips like dandelions, leaving short bright trajectories before fading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811875730752945 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288118839263916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811875730752945, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811875730752945, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07271217554807663, + 0.02029164507985115, + 0.04681676626205444, + 0.09035491943359375, + 0.3663458824157715, + 0.08997348695993423, + 0.044306788593530655, + 0.08672728389501572, + 0.13531938195228577, + 0.04715169221162796 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811875730752945 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, beginning at a slight upward angle, then smoothly pulls back, culminating in a magnificent, one-shot, unbroken focus on a flaming phoenix awakening from its crouching state. Initially, the frame captures only the pulsating glow at the phoenix's core, like a pulsating heart. As the camera slowly retreats, its massive wings spread out to its sides with a majestic and deliberate rhythm. This phoenix is not composed of flesh and blood; its entire body and every feather are composed of incandescent, viscous lava. The edges of its feathers shimmer with golden-red sparks, while deep, almost black lava veins flow within, as if liquid gold is being slowly poured into the darkness. It raises its head majestically, its beak gleaming with incandescent light, its eyes two blazing stars, imbued with an ancient and powerful power. The background is the vast, boundless void of space, dotted with distant, faint stardust, making the phoenix the sole source of light in the entire scene. Its blazing light casts an intense glow in the darkness, illuminating every flowing detail. When the wings are finally fully spread out, forming a magnificent posture that covers the sky, the sparks at the tips of the wings float away like dandelions, drawing a short and bright trajectory in the void before going out. The whole picture is full of a sacred and magnificent epic feeling, conveying a kind of nirvana and rebirth, unparalleled life force and cosmic magnificent aesthetics.", + "seed": 24703, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_7/index_9860_seed_24703_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10139303505420685, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10139303505420685, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10139303505420685, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a phoenix composed entirely of incandescent, viscous lava?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot at a slight upward angle showing only a pulsating glow at the phoenix's core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull back from the close-up to reveal the phoenix's massive wings spreading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background the vast void of space dotted with distant, faint stardust where the phoenix is the sole source of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do golden-red sparks float away from the wing tips like dandelions, leaving short bright trajectories before fading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07090849429368973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695908546447754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07090849429368973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07090849429368973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07666735351085663, + 0.07261335104703903, + 0.08586451411247253, + 0.044904157519340515, + 0.13922357559204102, + 0.27113890647888184, + 0.08375950902700424, + 0.06676321476697922, + 0.0940510630607605, + 0.0650143250823021 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07090849429368973 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a phoenix composed entirely of incandescent, viscous lava?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot at a slight upward angle showing only a pulsating glow at the phoenix's core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull back from the close-up to reveal the phoenix's massive wings spreading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background the vast void of space dotted with distant, faint stardust where the phoenix is the sole source of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do golden-red sparks float away from the wing tips like dandelions, leaving short bright trajectories before fading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008647613227367401 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758647441864014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008647613227367401, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008647613227367401, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14856122434139252, + 0.053461894392967224, + 0.022911876440048218, + 0.04127483814954758, + 0.0381498783826828, + 0.06511274725198746, + 0.08262290805578232, + 0.09425408393144608, + 0.43217912316322327, + 0.021471433341503143 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008647613227367401 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a phoenix composed entirely of incandescent, viscous lava?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot at a slight upward angle showing only a pulsating glow at the phoenix's core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull back from the close-up to reveal the phoenix's massive wings spreading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background the vast void of space dotted with distant, faint stardust where the phoenix is the sole source of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do golden-red sparks float away from the wing tips like dandelions, leaving short bright trajectories before fading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002201516181230545 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127201557159424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002201516181230545, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002201516181230545, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14067408442497253, + 0.07582062482833862, + 0.051197946071624756, + 0.1217116042971611, + 0.06423947215080261, + 0.07491663843393326, + 0.06322930753231049, + 0.10078815370798111, + 0.2426459938287735, + 0.06477619707584381 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002201516181230545 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a phoenix composed entirely of incandescent, viscous lava?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot at a slight upward angle showing only a pulsating glow at the phoenix's core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull back from the close-up to reveal the phoenix's massive wings spreading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background the vast void of space dotted with distant, faint stardust where the phoenix is the sole source of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do golden-red sparks float away from the wing tips like dandelions, leaving short bright trajectories before fading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3871053159236908 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1371053457260132 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3871053159236908, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3871053159236908, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2895040214061737, + 0.08381368219852448, + 0.0568038672208786, + 0.1428891271352768, + 0.09613150358200073, + 0.09042096138000488, + 0.05808563157916069, + 0.08677605539560318, + 0.060158006846904755, + 0.0354170985519886 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3871053159236908 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a phoenix composed entirely of incandescent, viscous lava?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot at a slight upward angle showing only a pulsating glow at the phoenix's core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull back from the close-up to reveal the phoenix's massive wings spreading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background the vast void of space dotted with distant, faint stardust where the phoenix is the sole source of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do golden-red sparks float away from the wing tips like dandelions, leaving short bright trajectories before fading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810223564505577 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288102149963379 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810223564505577, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810223564505577, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18703150749206543, + 0.0492953285574913, + 0.044055357575416565, + 0.02889333851635456, + 0.1458519548177719, + 0.03957429528236389, + 0.066777803003788, + 0.14868566393852234, + 0.17978441715240479, + 0.11005031317472458 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810223564505577 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, beginning at a slight upward angle, then smoothly pulls back, culminating in a magnificent, one-shot, unbroken focus on a flaming phoenix awakening from its crouching state. Initially, the frame captures only the pulsating glow at the phoenix's core, like a pulsating heart. As the camera slowly retreats, its massive wings spread out to its sides with a majestic and deliberate rhythm. This phoenix is not composed of flesh and blood; its entire body and every feather are composed of incandescent, viscous lava. The edges of its feathers shimmer with golden-red sparks, while deep, almost black lava veins flow within, as if liquid gold is being slowly poured into the darkness. It raises its head majestically, its beak gleaming with incandescent light, its eyes two blazing stars, imbued with an ancient and powerful power. The background is the vast, boundless void of space, dotted with distant, faint stardust, making the phoenix the sole source of light in the entire scene. Its blazing light casts an intense glow in the darkness, illuminating every flowing detail. When the wings are finally fully spread out, forming a magnificent posture that covers the sky, the sparks at the tips of the wings float away like dandelions, drawing a short and bright trajectory in the void before going out. The whole picture is full of a sacred and magnificent epic feeling, conveying a kind of nirvana and rebirth, unparalleled life force and cosmic magnificent aesthetics.", + "seed": 24704, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_7/index_9860_seed_24704_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.15050105126574637, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15050105126574637, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15050105126574637, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a phoenix composed entirely of incandescent, viscous lava?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot at a slight upward angle showing only a pulsating glow at the phoenix's core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull back from the close-up to reveal the phoenix's massive wings spreading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background the vast void of space dotted with distant, faint stardust where the phoenix is the sole source of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do golden-red sparks float away from the wing tips like dandelions, leaving short bright trajectories before fading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16156603395938873 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9115660190582275 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16156603395938873, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16156603395938873, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.054827287793159485, + 0.0569152869284153, + 0.0689259022474289, + 0.07512832432985306, + 0.09290634095668793, + 0.022811999544501305, + 0.04674834758043289, + 0.10341064631938934, + 0.02083689160645008, + 0.4574889838695526 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16156603395938873 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a phoenix composed entirely of incandescent, viscous lava?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot at a slight upward angle showing only a pulsating glow at the phoenix's core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull back from the close-up to reveal the phoenix's massive wings spreading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background the vast void of space dotted with distant, faint stardust where the phoenix is the sole source of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do golden-red sparks float away from the wing tips like dandelions, leaving short bright trajectories before fading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014212694019079208 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264212608337402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014212694019079208, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014212694019079208, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10104043036699295, + 0.04914628341794014, + 0.029368208721280098, + 0.046786438673734665, + 0.049175143241882324, + 0.07677879929542542, + 0.1107073649764061, + 0.071379154920578, + 0.0387362465262413, + 0.42688193917274475 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014212694019079208 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a phoenix composed entirely of incandescent, viscous lava?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot at a slight upward angle showing only a pulsating glow at the phoenix's core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull back from the close-up to reveal the phoenix's massive wings spreading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background the vast void of space dotted with distant, faint stardust where the phoenix is the sole source of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do golden-red sparks float away from the wing tips like dandelions, leaving short bright trajectories before fading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004647406283766031 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379647254943848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004647406283766031, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004647406283766031, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.056043658405542374, + 0.06241092458367348, + 0.028652191162109375, + 0.034826889634132385, + 0.12765589356422424, + 0.07746981084346771, + 0.09274161607027054, + 0.0705103948712349, + 0.04757632315158844, + 0.40211233496665955 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004647406283766031 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a phoenix composed entirely of incandescent, viscous lava?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot at a slight upward angle showing only a pulsating glow at the phoenix's core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull back from the close-up to reveal the phoenix's massive wings spreading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background the vast void of space dotted with distant, faint stardust where the phoenix is the sole source of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do golden-red sparks float away from the wing tips like dandelions, leaving short bright trajectories before fading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5234043598175049 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8984043598175049 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5234043598175049, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5234043598175049, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10971192270517349, + 0.059215985238552094, + 0.029098406434059143, + 0.06709697097539902, + 0.12168802320957184, + 0.051420554518699646, + 0.03590384125709534, + 0.0403529591858387, + 0.03514174744486809, + 0.45036959648132324 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5234043598175049 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a phoenix composed entirely of incandescent, viscous lava?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot at a slight upward angle showing only a pulsating glow at the phoenix's core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pull back from the close-up to reveal the phoenix's massive wings spreading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background the vast void of space dotted with distant, faint stardust where the phoenix is the sole source of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do golden-red sparks float away from the wing tips like dandelions, leaving short bright trajectories before fading out?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867476224899292 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486748218536377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867476224899292, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867476224899292, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12152142822742462, + 0.08116079866886139, + 0.037427548319101334, + 0.06020760163664818, + 0.09721305221319199, + 0.07120081782341003, + 0.05713612958788872, + 0.15334650874137878, + 0.19328297674655914, + 0.12750309705734253 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867476224899292 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_8/index_tensor([5061, 5061])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_8/index_tensor([5061, 5061])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4a63619e856b46cc29dffa785e2be3f0c29c86d5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_8/index_tensor([5061, 5061])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up shot from a static camera, captured at a high frame rate, captures the interior of a running dishwasher in a strikingly sculptural, high-contrast monochrome style. A powerful jet of water erupts from the frame, lashing the walls of an inverted glass like a liquid whip, instantly exploding into countless crystalline droplets of diverse shapes. In slow motion, each droplet resembles a tiny diamond suspended in mid-air, its surface reflecting a dazzling, single-source light. The impact creates a complex and graceful turbulence, with vortices of varying sizes rapidly forming, swirling, deforming, and then disappearing on the glass's smooth surface. The edges of the water appear razor-sharp in the sharp light. The deep black background contrasts sharply with the illuminated, liquid metallic sheen of the water. The interplay of light and shadow vividly captures the dynamic energy and pure form of water, elevating the everyday washing process into a visual ballet of power and abstract beauty.", + "seed": 28906, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_8/index_5061_seed_28906_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.35291066877543925, + "vlm_logprob": -0.35291066877543925, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.35291066877543925, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an extreme close-up of the interior of a running dishwasher?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of water erupt and strike an inverted glass, creating crystalline droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion presented in slow motion with razor-sharp edges and a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14546796679496765 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.02046799659729 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14546796679496765, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14546796679496765, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11294376850128174, + 0.12399734556674957, + 0.16437368094921112, + 0.04850456863641739, + 0.03181830793619156, + 0.173603817820549, + 0.03655160963535309, + 0.05844796448945999, + 0.18748874962329865, + 0.06227012351155281 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14546796679496765 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an extreme close-up of the interior of a running dishwasher?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of water erupt and strike an inverted glass, creating crystalline droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion presented in slow motion with razor-sharp edges and a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005737781524658 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22557379305362701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.6005737781524658, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.6005737781524658, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10997556149959564, + 0.16487455368041992, + 0.04981483519077301, + 0.04372496157884598, + 0.09632764011621475, + 0.2540460526943207, + 0.08107999712228775, + 0.044437944889068604, + 0.1056118831038475, + 0.050106581300497055 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.6005737781524658 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an extreme close-up of the interior of a running dishwasher?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of water erupt and strike an inverted glass, creating crystalline droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion presented in slow motion with razor-sharp edges and a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004118651617318392 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5041184425354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004118651617318392, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004118651617318392, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26931512355804443, + 0.20510724186897278, + 0.048410315066576004, + 0.0268511101603508, + 0.03829246386885643, + 0.08277510106563568, + 0.030311627313494682, + 0.021058226004242897, + 0.06501065939664841, + 0.2128681242465973 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004118651617318392 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an extreme close-up of the interior of a running dishwasher?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of water erupt and strike an inverted glass, creating crystalline droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion presented in slow motion with razor-sharp edges and a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007647759281098843 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88264799118042 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007647759281098843, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007647759281098843, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12125495821237564, + 0.08450301736593246, + 0.11153458058834076, + 0.1141788437962532, + 0.034950803965330124, + 0.35252928733825684, + 0.016092848032712936, + 0.02630145102739334, + 0.08240213990211487, + 0.05625198036432266 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007647759281098843 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an extreme close-up of the interior of a running dishwasher?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of water erupt and strike an inverted glass, creating crystalline droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion presented in slow motion with razor-sharp edges and a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006745188031345606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006745338439941 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006745188031345606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006745188031345606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10180774331092834, + 0.1103782206773758, + 0.064821258187294, + 0.030103560537099838, + 0.07799949496984482, + 0.393837034702301, + 0.04515595734119415, + 0.043787866830825806, + 0.09909897297620773, + 0.03300992399454117 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006745188031345606 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up shot from a static camera, captured at a high frame rate, captures the interior of a running dishwasher in a strikingly sculptural, high-contrast monochrome style. A powerful jet of water erupts from the frame, lashing the walls of an inverted glass like a liquid whip, instantly exploding into countless crystalline droplets of diverse shapes. In slow motion, each droplet resembles a tiny diamond suspended in mid-air, its surface reflecting a dazzling, single-source light. The impact creates a complex and graceful turbulence, with vortices of varying sizes rapidly forming, swirling, deforming, and then disappearing on the glass's smooth surface. The edges of the water appear razor-sharp in the sharp light. The deep black background contrasts sharply with the illuminated, liquid metallic sheen of the water. The interplay of light and shadow vividly captures the dynamic energy and pure form of water, elevating the everyday washing process into a visual ballet of power and abstract beauty.", + "seed": 28907, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_8/index_5061_seed_28907_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.3715842511388473, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3715842511388473, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3715842511388473, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an extreme close-up of the interior of a running dishwasher?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of water erupt and strike an inverted glass, creating crystalline droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion presented in slow motion with razor-sharp edges and a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5246980786323547 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8996980786323547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5246980786323547, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5246980786323547, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2987658679485321, + 0.04864748939871788, + 0.11088202893733978, + 0.03497825935482979, + 0.08571859449148178, + 0.0180230550467968, + 0.05252335965633392, + 0.09396715462207794, + 0.182243213057518, + 0.07425106316804886 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5246980786323547 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an extreme close-up of the interior of a running dishwasher?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of water erupt and strike an inverted glass, creating crystalline droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion presented in slow motion with razor-sharp edges and a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.313422679901123 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31342267990112305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.313422679901123, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.313422679901123, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11739282310009003, + 0.035771697759628296, + 0.05255165323615074, + 0.03075632080435753, + 0.045366071164608, + 0.028194790706038475, + 0.042997971177101135, + 0.04984043538570404, + 0.5562430620193481, + 0.04088514670729637 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.313422679901123 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an extreme close-up of the interior of a running dishwasher?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of water erupt and strike an inverted glass, creating crystalline droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion presented in slow motion with razor-sharp edges and a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0005015069036744535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.62550163269043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0005015069036744535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0005015069036744535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16541385650634766, + 0.06913347542285919, + 0.057445574551820755, + 0.04337642341852188, + 0.08397754281759262, + 0.032860953360795975, + 0.2012442648410797, + 0.0453571081161499, + 0.24331924319267273, + 0.057871438562870026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0005015069036744535 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an extreme close-up of the interior of a running dishwasher?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of water erupt and strike an inverted glass, creating crystalline droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion presented in slow motion with razor-sharp edges and a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012559603899717331 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387559413909912 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012559603899717331, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012559603899717331, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19516803324222565, + 0.10845538973808289, + 0.10185054689645767, + 0.042760252952575684, + 0.06655509024858475, + 0.03810177743434906, + 0.060914576053619385, + 0.06014568731188774, + 0.23836982250213623, + 0.08767879754304886 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012559603899717331 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an extreme close-up of the interior of a running dishwasher?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of water erupt and strike an inverted glass, creating crystalline droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion presented in slow motion with razor-sharp edges and a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006739386357367039 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006739616394043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006739386357367039, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006739386357367039, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1485823541879654, + 0.08747764676809311, + 0.07397778332233429, + 0.046758271753787994, + 0.06868904083967209, + 0.0437338650226593, + 0.03983538597822189, + 0.028520779684185982, + 0.4094529449939728, + 0.05297192186117172 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006739386357367039 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up shot from a static camera, captured at a high frame rate, captures the interior of a running dishwasher in a strikingly sculptural, high-contrast monochrome style. A powerful jet of water erupts from the frame, lashing the walls of an inverted glass like a liquid whip, instantly exploding into countless crystalline droplets of diverse shapes. In slow motion, each droplet resembles a tiny diamond suspended in mid-air, its surface reflecting a dazzling, single-source light. The impact creates a complex and graceful turbulence, with vortices of varying sizes rapidly forming, swirling, deforming, and then disappearing on the glass's smooth surface. The edges of the water appear razor-sharp in the sharp light. The deep black background contrasts sharply with the illuminated, liquid metallic sheen of the water. The interplay of light and shadow vividly captures the dynamic energy and pure form of water, elevating the everyday washing process into a visual ballet of power and abstract beauty.", + "seed": 28908, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_8/index_5061_seed_28908_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.4189960787538439, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4189960787538439, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4189960787538439, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an extreme close-up of the interior of a running dishwasher?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of water erupt and strike an inverted glass, creating crystalline droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion presented in slow motion with razor-sharp edges and a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5786385536193848 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8286385536193848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5786385536193848, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5786385536193848, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6133699417114258, + 0.030956463888287544, + 0.03560090437531471, + 0.025443870574235916, + 0.057334158569574356, + 0.019376829266548157, + 0.06592385470867157, + 0.030964113771915436, + 0.05269739404320717, + 0.0683325007557869 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5786385536193848 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an extreme close-up of the interior of a running dishwasher?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of water erupt and strike an inverted glass, creating crystalline droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion presented in slow motion with razor-sharp edges and a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021002292633057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521001696586609 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5021002292633057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5021002292633057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17151811718940735, + 0.057989321649074554, + 0.07698909938335419, + 0.03797762095928192, + 0.1786920577287674, + 0.06560353934764862, + 0.16098807752132416, + 0.04757188633084297, + 0.06206771358847618, + 0.14060257375240326 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5021002292633057 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an extreme close-up of the interior of a running dishwasher?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of water erupt and strike an inverted glass, creating crystalline droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion presented in slow motion with razor-sharp edges and a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015311434399336576 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.50153112411499 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015311434399336576, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015311434399336576, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16069921851158142, + 0.059480249881744385, + 0.1926925778388977, + 0.018023762851953506, + 0.10638789087533951, + 0.025739237666130066, + 0.046643227338790894, + 0.036168649792671204, + 0.035925332456827164, + 0.31823989748954773 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015311434399336576 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an extreme close-up of the interior of a running dishwasher?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of water erupt and strike an inverted glass, creating crystalline droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion presented in slow motion with razor-sharp edges and a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006754068657755852 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006753921508789 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006754068657755852, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006754068657755852, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.48310035467147827, + 0.05806434154510498, + 0.041100263595581055, + 0.02442663162946701, + 0.08623870462179184, + 0.04978570342063904, + 0.08740618079900742, + 0.04791144281625748, + 0.04261469468474388, + 0.07935167849063873 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006754068657755852 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an extreme close-up of the interior of a running dishwasher?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of water erupt and strike an inverted glass, creating crystalline droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion presented in slow motion with razor-sharp edges and a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005956398788839579 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130956172943115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005956398788839579, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005956398788839579, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1921287328004837, + 0.03669122979044914, + 0.15431347489356995, + 0.024117486551404, + 0.14833508431911469, + 0.033034615218639374, + 0.09829667210578918, + 0.037762779742479324, + 0.03305317461490631, + 0.24226675927639008 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005956398788839579 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up shot from a static camera, captured at a high frame rate, captures the interior of a running dishwasher in a strikingly sculptural, high-contrast monochrome style. A powerful jet of water erupts from the frame, lashing the walls of an inverted glass like a liquid whip, instantly exploding into countless crystalline droplets of diverse shapes. In slow motion, each droplet resembles a tiny diamond suspended in mid-air, its surface reflecting a dazzling, single-source light. The impact creates a complex and graceful turbulence, with vortices of varying sizes rapidly forming, swirling, deforming, and then disappearing on the glass's smooth surface. The edges of the water appear razor-sharp in the sharp light. The deep black background contrasts sharply with the illuminated, liquid metallic sheen of the water. The interplay of light and shadow vividly captures the dynamic energy and pure form of water, elevating the everyday washing process into a visual ballet of power and abstract beauty.", + "seed": 28909, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_8/index_5061_seed_28909_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.48326388804707676, + "vlm_logprob": -0.48326388804707676, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.48326388804707676, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an extreme close-up of the interior of a running dishwasher?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of water erupt and strike an inverted glass, creating crystalline droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion presented in slow motion with razor-sharp edges and a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.694541335105896 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.694541335105896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.694541335105896, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.694541335105896, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1689113974571228, + 0.03338439017534256, + 0.06803079694509506, + 0.14676973223686218, + 0.27100670337677, + 0.04874800518155098, + 0.05843262001872063, + 0.10091809183359146, + 0.07528986036777496, + 0.028508448973298073 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.694541335105896 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an extreme close-up of the interior of a running dishwasher?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of water erupt and strike an inverted glass, creating crystalline droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion presented in slow motion with razor-sharp edges and a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015687227249146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20156867802143097 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.7015687227249146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -1.7015687227249146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07193151116371155, + 0.03191181272268295, + 0.31561216711997986, + 0.020449316129088402, + 0.17897531390190125, + 0.03346015140414238, + 0.2679433524608612, + 0.03200376033782959, + 0.006611379329115152, + 0.04110124334692955 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.7015687227249146 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an extreme close-up of the interior of a running dishwasher?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of water erupt and strike an inverted glass, creating crystalline droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion presented in slow motion with razor-sharp edges and a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013468727702274919 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626347064971924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013468727702274919, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013468727702274919, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07968547195196152, + 0.15908867120742798, + 0.2720631957054138, + 0.05624682828783989, + 0.1257980316877365, + 0.03386404365301132, + 0.1210518330335617, + 0.08367697149515152, + 0.011238866485655308, + 0.05728612467646599 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013468727702274919 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an extreme close-up of the interior of a running dishwasher?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of water erupt and strike an inverted glass, creating crystalline droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion presented in slow motion with razor-sharp edges and a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014221273362636566 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26422119140625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014221273362636566, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014221273362636566, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08414886891841888, + 0.05506826564669609, + 0.1876468062400818, + 0.0962095558643341, + 0.027716392651200294, + 0.09051142632961273, + 0.20884430408477783, + 0.1501995474100113, + 0.034296706318855286, + 0.06535811722278595 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014221273362636566 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene an extreme close-up of the interior of a running dishwasher?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static throughout the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast monochrome style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of water erupt and strike an inverted glass, creating crystalline droplets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the motion presented in slow motion with razor-sharp edges and a deep black background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004641236271709204 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379641056060791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004641236271709204, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004641236271709204, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07303392142057419, + 0.023192713037133217, + 0.26417458057403564, + 0.03093436360359192, + 0.196732297539711, + 0.03246619179844856, + 0.2638627588748932, + 0.07025841623544693, + 0.01291462779045105, + 0.032430123537778854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004641236271709204 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_9/index_tensor([7744, 7744])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_9/index_tensor([7744, 7744])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3d6f4a2a855f3e08c547b7536cae6258f0241aef --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_9/index_tensor([7744, 7744])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static wide-angle shot establishes a tranquil forest floor, focusing on the base of a large, gnarled tree, its bark dotted with green moss. Spreading from the roots is a magnificent mass of gray-brown, fan-shaped fungal caps, their overlapping, feathery texture strongly reminiscent of hen's feathers, all bathed in soft, diffuse light filtering through the dense canopy above. The scene then dramatically shifts to a stunning macro shot, projecting the viewer's perspective down to the ground beneath the fungus, witnessing a mesmerizing time-lapse sequence. In this incredibly detailed view, a delicate, brilliant white network of hyphae begins to rapidly expand, its intricate web-like tendrils visibly spreading and branching across the frame. These filaments intricately weave through the damp, dark soil, relentlessly grasping at decaying, rust-colored leaves. Their deliberate, pulsating growth creates a hypnotic and beautiful spectacle, showcasing the unseen, foundational processes of nature.", + "seed": 6469, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_9/index_7744_seed_6469_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.00534819234162569, + "vlm_logprob": -0.00534819234162569, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.00534819234162569, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static wide-angle view of a forest floor featuring the base of a large, gnarled tree with green moss on its bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a mass of gray-brown, fan-shaped fungal caps with an overlapping, feathery texture spreading from the tree roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition from the wide shot to a stunning macro shot projecting the perspective down to the ground beneath the fungus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"In the macro shot, does a delicate, brilliant white network of hyphae rapidly expand and branch across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the white hyphae filaments visibly weave through damp, dark soil and grasp at decaying, rust-colored leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024678034242242575 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127467632293701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024678034242242575, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024678034242242575, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25531452894210815, + 0.10387647151947021, + 0.05275324359536171, + 0.023097330704331398, + 0.08144436776638031, + 0.0699084997177124, + 0.17545659840106964, + 0.027604680508375168, + 0.14544972777366638, + 0.0650944635272026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024678034242242575 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static wide-angle view of a forest floor featuring the base of a large, gnarled tree with green moss on its bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a mass of gray-brown, fan-shaped fungal caps with an overlapping, feathery texture spreading from the tree roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition from the wide shot to a stunning macro shot projecting the perspective down to the ground beneath the fungus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"In the macro shot, does a delicate, brilliant white network of hyphae rapidly expand and branch across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the white hyphae filaments visibly weave through damp, dark soil and grasp at decaying, rust-colored leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00105015910230577 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876049995422363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00105015910230577, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00105015910230577, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0671408399939537, + 0.0869116485118866, + 0.1497027575969696, + 0.039283543825149536, + 0.09820181131362915, + 0.17516262829303741, + 0.1587515026330948, + 0.02452908642590046, + 0.1644243448972702, + 0.03589189425110817 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00105015910230577 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static wide-angle view of a forest floor featuring the base of a large, gnarled tree with green moss on its bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a mass of gray-brown, fan-shaped fungal caps with an overlapping, feathery texture spreading from the tree roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition from the wide shot to a stunning macro shot projecting the perspective down to the ground beneath the fungus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"In the macro shot, does a delicate, brilliant white network of hyphae rapidly expand and branch across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the white hyphae filaments visibly weave through damp, dark soil and grasp at decaying, rust-colored leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008640168234705925 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758640289306641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008640168234705925, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008640168234705925, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06256049871444702, + 0.08247300982475281, + 0.08505420386791229, + 0.03462850674986839, + 0.09043947607278824, + 0.09354152530431747, + 0.24258792400360107, + 0.06172191724181175, + 0.17828594148159027, + 0.06870703399181366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008640168234705925 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static wide-angle view of a forest floor featuring the base of a large, gnarled tree with green moss on its bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a mass of gray-brown, fan-shaped fungal caps with an overlapping, feathery texture spreading from the tree roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition from the wide shot to a stunning macro shot projecting the perspective down to the ground beneath the fungus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"In the macro shot, does a delicate, brilliant white network of hyphae rapidly expand and branch across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the white hyphae filaments visibly weave through damp, dark soil and grasp at decaying, rust-colored leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059465630911290646 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130946636199951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059465630911290646, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059465630911290646, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06082826480269432, + 0.03152789920568466, + 0.023437120020389557, + 0.02082647942006588, + 0.06457816809415817, + 0.03253598511219025, + 0.32070353627204895, + 0.04155031219124794, + 0.3800608813762665, + 0.023951346054673195 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059465630911290646 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static wide-angle view of a forest floor featuring the base of a large, gnarled tree with green moss on its bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a mass of gray-brown, fan-shaped fungal caps with an overlapping, feathery texture spreading from the tree roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition from the wide shot to a stunning macro shot projecting the perspective down to the ground beneath the fungus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"In the macro shot, does a delicate, brilliant white network of hyphae rapidly expand and branch across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the white hyphae filaments visibly weave through damp, dark soil and grasp at decaying, rust-colored leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008636267855763435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758636474609375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008636267855763435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008636267855763435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17303800582885742, + 0.060515813529491425, + 0.023799173533916473, + 0.0284369345754385, + 0.1672835648059845, + 0.14688193798065186, + 0.1386198252439499, + 0.08710993826389313, + 0.12004503607749939, + 0.054269809275865555 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008636267855763435 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static wide-angle shot establishes a tranquil forest floor, focusing on the base of a large, gnarled tree, its bark dotted with green moss. Spreading from the roots is a magnificent mass of gray-brown, fan-shaped fungal caps, their overlapping, feathery texture strongly reminiscent of hen's feathers, all bathed in soft, diffuse light filtering through the dense canopy above. The scene then dramatically shifts to a stunning macro shot, projecting the viewer's perspective down to the ground beneath the fungus, witnessing a mesmerizing time-lapse sequence. In this incredibly detailed view, a delicate, brilliant white network of hyphae begins to rapidly expand, its intricate web-like tendrils visibly spreading and branching across the frame. These filaments intricately weave through the damp, dark soil, relentlessly grasping at decaying, rust-colored leaves. Their deliberate, pulsating growth creates a hypnotic and beautiful spectacle, showcasing the unseen, foundational processes of nature.", + "seed": 6470, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_9/index_7744_seed_6470_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.010930041689425707, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010930041689425707, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010930041689425707, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static wide-angle view of a forest floor featuring the base of a large, gnarled tree with green moss on its bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a mass of gray-brown, fan-shaped fungal caps with an overlapping, feathery texture spreading from the tree roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition from the wide shot to a stunning macro shot projecting the perspective down to the ground beneath the fungus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"In the macro shot, does a delicate, brilliant white network of hyphae rapidly expand and branch across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the white hyphae filaments visibly weave through damp, dark soil and grasp at decaying, rust-colored leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013118154369294643 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.388118267059326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013118154369294643, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013118154369294643, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19361001253128052, + 0.10425900667905807, + 0.045670557767152786, + 0.11638247221708298, + 0.05733881890773773, + 0.26554790139198303, + 0.030147086828947067, + 0.06841953098773956, + 0.07537174224853516, + 0.04325279965996742 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013118154369294643 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static wide-angle view of a forest floor featuring the base of a large, gnarled tree with green moss on its bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a mass of gray-brown, fan-shaped fungal caps with an overlapping, feathery texture spreading from the tree roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition from the wide shot to a stunning macro shot projecting the perspective down to the ground beneath the fungus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"In the macro shot, does a delicate, brilliant white network of hyphae rapidly expand and branch across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the white hyphae filaments visibly weave through damp, dark soil and grasp at decaying, rust-colored leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019564551766961813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251956462860107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019564551766961813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019564551766961813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11823796480894089, + 0.10301901400089264, + 0.0884002223610878, + 0.1124986857175827, + 0.04759330302476883, + 0.19687014818191528, + 0.024115389212965965, + 0.1393696814775467, + 0.10335005819797516, + 0.06654554605484009 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019564551766961813 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static wide-angle view of a forest floor featuring the base of a large, gnarled tree with green moss on its bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a mass of gray-brown, fan-shaped fungal caps with an overlapping, feathery texture spreading from the tree roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition from the wide shot to a stunning macro shot projecting the perspective down to the ground beneath the fungus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"In the macro shot, does a delicate, brilliant white network of hyphae rapidly expand and branch across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the white hyphae filaments visibly weave through damp, dark soil and grasp at decaying, rust-colored leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819409430027008 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018194198608398 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819409430027008, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819409430027008, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.056397758424282074, + 0.08962084352970123, + 0.028905197978019714, + 0.10501594096422195, + 0.07060515135526657, + 0.21399730443954468, + 0.029857955873012543, + 0.13151657581329346, + 0.22765448689460754, + 0.04642879217863083 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819409430027008 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static wide-angle view of a forest floor featuring the base of a large, gnarled tree with green moss on its bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a mass of gray-brown, fan-shaped fungal caps with an overlapping, feathery texture spreading from the tree roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition from the wide shot to a stunning macro shot projecting the perspective down to the ground beneath the fungus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"In the macro shot, does a delicate, brilliant white network of hyphae rapidly expand and branch across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the white hyphae filaments visibly weave through damp, dark soil and grasp at decaying, rust-colored leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003192092990502715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753191947937012 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003192092990502715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003192092990502715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06735164672136307, + 0.06255471706390381, + 0.04505942016839981, + 0.04008709266781807, + 0.04529145359992981, + 0.25214335322380066, + 0.026624178513884544, + 0.10535717755556107, + 0.2074889838695526, + 0.14804191887378693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003192092990502715 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static wide-angle view of a forest floor featuring the base of a large, gnarled tree with green moss on its bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a mass of gray-brown, fan-shaped fungal caps with an overlapping, feathery texture spreading from the tree roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition from the wide shot to a stunning macro shot projecting the perspective down to the ground beneath the fungus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"In the macro shot, does a delicate, brilliant white network of hyphae rapidly expand and branch across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the white hyphae filaments visibly weave through damp, dark soil and grasp at decaying, rust-colored leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018189411610364914 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018189430236816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018189411610364914, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018189411610364914, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07957006990909576, + 0.060301076620817184, + 0.050028447061777115, + 0.04817671328783035, + 0.1354047805070877, + 0.3418949842453003, + 0.02301190048456192, + 0.1409464180469513, + 0.06972596049308777, + 0.050939567387104034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018189411610364914 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static wide-angle shot establishes a tranquil forest floor, focusing on the base of a large, gnarled tree, its bark dotted with green moss. Spreading from the roots is a magnificent mass of gray-brown, fan-shaped fungal caps, their overlapping, feathery texture strongly reminiscent of hen's feathers, all bathed in soft, diffuse light filtering through the dense canopy above. The scene then dramatically shifts to a stunning macro shot, projecting the viewer's perspective down to the ground beneath the fungus, witnessing a mesmerizing time-lapse sequence. In this incredibly detailed view, a delicate, brilliant white network of hyphae begins to rapidly expand, its intricate web-like tendrils visibly spreading and branching across the frame. These filaments intricately weave through the damp, dark soil, relentlessly grasping at decaying, rust-colored leaves. Their deliberate, pulsating growth creates a hypnotic and beautiful spectacle, showcasing the unseen, foundational processes of nature.", + "seed": 6471, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_9/index_7744_seed_6471_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.02487481660209596, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02487481660209596, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02487481660209596, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static wide-angle view of a forest floor featuring the base of a large, gnarled tree with green moss on its bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a mass of gray-brown, fan-shaped fungal caps with an overlapping, feathery texture spreading from the tree roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition from the wide shot to a stunning macro shot projecting the perspective down to the ground beneath the fungus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"In the macro shot, does a delicate, brilliant white network of hyphae rapidly expand and branch across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the white hyphae filaments visibly weave through damp, dark soil and grasp at decaying, rust-colored leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009999892674386501 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634999752044678 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009999892674386501, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009999892674386501, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16715215146541595, + 0.1232912465929985, + 0.0585998110473156, + 0.05813628062605858, + 0.02618187479674816, + 0.058321572840213776, + 0.220936581492424, + 0.17865058779716492, + 0.06368570774793625, + 0.045044176280498505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009999892674386501 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static wide-angle view of a forest floor featuring the base of a large, gnarled tree with green moss on its bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a mass of gray-brown, fan-shaped fungal caps with an overlapping, feathery texture spreading from the tree roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition from the wide shot to a stunning macro shot projecting the perspective down to the ground beneath the fungus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"In the macro shot, does a delicate, brilliant white network of hyphae rapidly expand and branch across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the white hyphae filaments visibly weave through damp, dark soil and grasp at decaying, rust-colored leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002208415186032653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127208232879639 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002208415186032653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002208415186032653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10062437504529953, + 0.05085914582014084, + 0.07168139517307281, + 0.05321640148758888, + 0.05797047168016434, + 0.13247916102409363, + 0.10195368528366089, + 0.2387361079454422, + 0.09293410181999207, + 0.09954516589641571 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002208415186032653 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static wide-angle view of a forest floor featuring the base of a large, gnarled tree with green moss on its bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a mass of gray-brown, fan-shaped fungal caps with an overlapping, feathery texture spreading from the tree roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition from the wide shot to a stunning macro shot projecting the perspective down to the ground beneath the fungus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"In the macro shot, does a delicate, brilliant white network of hyphae rapidly expand and branch across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the white hyphae filaments visibly weave through damp, dark soil and grasp at decaying, rust-colored leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029802024364471436 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529802083969116 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029802024364471436, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029802024364471436, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08605460822582245, + 0.030609939247369766, + 0.05395301431417465, + 0.08061812818050385, + 0.02073795534670353, + 0.2021043449640274, + 0.025412579998373985, + 0.40338370203971863, + 0.06277894973754883, + 0.03434675186872482 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029802024364471436 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static wide-angle view of a forest floor featuring the base of a large, gnarled tree with green moss on its bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a mass of gray-brown, fan-shaped fungal caps with an overlapping, feathery texture spreading from the tree roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition from the wide shot to a stunning macro shot projecting the perspective down to the ground beneath the fungus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"In the macro shot, does a delicate, brilliant white network of hyphae rapidly expand and branch across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the white hyphae filaments visibly weave through damp, dark soil and grasp at decaying, rust-colored leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033696141093969345 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408696174621582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033696141093969345, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033696141093969345, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06884173303842545, + 0.03329714015126228, + 0.05257244035601616, + 0.09349116683006287, + 0.015500408597290516, + 0.09457386285066605, + 0.056583140045404434, + 0.3940834105014801, + 0.09621953219175339, + 0.09483715146780014 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033696141093969345 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static wide-angle view of a forest floor featuring the base of a large, gnarled tree with green moss on its bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a mass of gray-brown, fan-shaped fungal caps with an overlapping, feathery texture spreading from the tree roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition from the wide shot to a stunning macro shot projecting the perspective down to the ground beneath the fungus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"In the macro shot, does a delicate, brilliant white network of hyphae rapidly expand and branch across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the white hyphae filaments visibly weave through damp, dark soil and grasp at decaying, rust-colored leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866760969161987 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486676692962646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866760969161987, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866760969161987, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.053985271602869034, + 0.030378147959709167, + 0.07161588966846466, + 0.07212217152118683, + 0.02074280194938183, + 0.20810464024543762, + 0.14387208223342896, + 0.25143566727638245, + 0.09023866802453995, + 0.057504668831825256 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866760969161987 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static wide-angle shot establishes a tranquil forest floor, focusing on the base of a large, gnarled tree, its bark dotted with green moss. Spreading from the roots is a magnificent mass of gray-brown, fan-shaped fungal caps, their overlapping, feathery texture strongly reminiscent of hen's feathers, all bathed in soft, diffuse light filtering through the dense canopy above. The scene then dramatically shifts to a stunning macro shot, projecting the viewer's perspective down to the ground beneath the fungus, witnessing a mesmerizing time-lapse sequence. In this incredibly detailed view, a delicate, brilliant white network of hyphae begins to rapidly expand, its intricate web-like tendrils visibly spreading and branching across the frame. These filaments intricately weave through the damp, dark soil, relentlessly grasping at decaying, rust-colored leaves. Their deliberate, pulsating growth creates a hypnotic and beautiful spectacle, showcasing the unseen, foundational processes of nature.", + "seed": 6472, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000201/group_9/index_7744_seed_6472_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.006557777523994446, + "vlm_logprob": -0.006557777523994446, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.006557777523994446, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static wide-angle view of a forest floor featuring the base of a large, gnarled tree with green moss on its bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a mass of gray-brown, fan-shaped fungal caps with an overlapping, feathery texture spreading from the tree roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition from the wide shot to a stunning macro shot projecting the perspective down to the ground beneath the fungus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"In the macro shot, does a delicate, brilliant white network of hyphae rapidly expand and branch across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the white hyphae filaments visibly weave through damp, dark soil and grasp at decaying, rust-colored leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009211541153490543 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.759211540222168 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009211541153490543, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009211541153490543, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27743181586265564, + 0.16406697034835815, + 0.12123384326696396, + 0.054617177695035934, + 0.05120208486914635, + 0.03441008925437927, + 0.07486629486083984, + 0.037164218723773956, + 0.043075013905763626, + 0.14193247258663177 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009211541153490543 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static wide-angle view of a forest floor featuring the base of a large, gnarled tree with green moss on its bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a mass of gray-brown, fan-shaped fungal caps with an overlapping, feathery texture spreading from the tree roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition from the wide shot to a stunning macro shot projecting the perspective down to the ground beneath the fungus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"In the macro shot, does a delicate, brilliant white network of hyphae rapidly expand and branch across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the white hyphae filaments visibly weave through damp, dark soil and grasp at decaying, rust-colored leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00283316383138299 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877833366394043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00283316383138299, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00283316383138299, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11300750076770782, + 0.07276646047830582, + 0.02599245123565197, + 0.04188491404056549, + 0.06456198543310165, + 0.033242687582969666, + 0.0690479725599289, + 0.20046795904636383, + 0.0571279376745224, + 0.3219001889228821 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00283316383138299 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static wide-angle view of a forest floor featuring the base of a large, gnarled tree with green moss on its bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a mass of gray-brown, fan-shaped fungal caps with an overlapping, feathery texture spreading from the tree roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition from the wide shot to a stunning macro shot projecting the perspective down to the ground beneath the fungus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"In the macro shot, does a delicate, brilliant white network of hyphae rapidly expand and branch across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the white hyphae filaments visibly weave through damp, dark soil and grasp at decaying, rust-colored leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009785657748579979 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347856521606445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009785657748579979, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009785657748579979, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2013787031173706, + 0.049654632806777954, + 0.04594713822007179, + 0.058690983802080154, + 0.07697797566652298, + 0.09071440994739532, + 0.07771692425012589, + 0.10354781895875931, + 0.08126873522996902, + 0.2141026109457016 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009785657748579979 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static wide-angle view of a forest floor featuring the base of a large, gnarled tree with green moss on its bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a mass of gray-brown, fan-shaped fungal caps with an overlapping, feathery texture spreading from the tree roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition from the wide shot to a stunning macro shot projecting the perspective down to the ground beneath the fungus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"In the macro shot, does a delicate, brilliant white network of hyphae rapidly expand and branch across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the white hyphae filaments visibly weave through damp, dark soil and grasp at decaying, rust-colored leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011797142215073109 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.7511796951293945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011797142215073109, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011797142215073109, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08884364366531372, + 0.06579290330410004, + 0.05444832518696785, + 0.04808414354920387, + 0.03604850918054581, + 0.09945076704025269, + 0.12890760600566864, + 0.060821283608675, + 0.0749550610780716, + 0.34264782071113586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011797142215073109 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static wide-angle view of a forest floor featuring the base of a large, gnarled tree with green moss on its bark?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a mass of gray-brown, fan-shaped fungal caps with an overlapping, feathery texture spreading from the tree roots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition from the wide shot to a stunning macro shot projecting the perspective down to the ground beneath the fungus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"In the macro shot, does a delicate, brilliant white network of hyphae rapidly expand and branch across the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the white hyphae filaments visibly weave through damp, dark soil and grasp at decaying, rust-colored leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009778810665011406 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63477897644043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009778810665011406, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009778810665011406, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09350427240133286, + 0.04780322313308716, + 0.04484809935092926, + 0.060309942811727524, + 0.08698204159736633, + 0.04627335071563721, + 0.11576958000659943, + 0.1283782571554184, + 0.06890902668237686, + 0.30722227692604065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009778810665011406 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_0/index_tensor([3909, 3909])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_0/index_tensor([3909, 3909])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bd5d308ddaed3302c2c50b0b607e461bbd5efcf4 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_0/index_tensor([3909, 3909])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly overhead angle, the camera held still, focuses on a pink lotus blossoming in a morning pond. The lotus is in full bloom, its delicate petals a deeper pink at the edges, fading to a softer pale pink towards the center, its cascading structure gracefully unfurling. Crystal-clear dewdrops, like tiny diamonds, scatter across the broad, silky surface of the petals, each one clearly reflecting its surroundings. The calm, mirror-like surface of the pond reflects the pale blue and orange of the dawn sky. A few broad, dark green lotus leaves blur the subject, and a thin layer of morning mist gently shrouds the water. A barely perceptible breeze rustles the petals, causing them to tremble ever so slightly, rhythmically, and the clinging dewdrops roll in response, reflecting tiny shimmers of light. At dawn, the soft golden sunlight shines from the side at a low angle, penetrating the thin edges of the petals, giving them a translucent texture. The whole picture has fresh and soft tones, creating an extremely peaceful, pure and vital Zen atmosphere.", + "seed": 11218, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_0/index_3909_seed_11218_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.16903173178434372, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16903173178434372, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16903173178434372, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pink lotus in full bloom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear dewdrops visible on the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a calm pond reflecting a pale blue and orange dawn sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals tremble slightly and do dewdrops roll in response to a breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00957739818841219 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88457727432251 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00957739818841219, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00957739818841219, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15274380147457123, + 0.28342127799987793, + 0.11508811265230179, + 0.08523347973823547, + 0.04794574901461601, + 0.05129142105579376, + 0.07794785499572754, + 0.06861758232116699, + 0.0755997970700264, + 0.04211090877652168 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00957739818841219 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pink lotus in full bloom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear dewdrops visible on the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a calm pond reflecting a pale blue and orange dawn sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals tremble slightly and do dewdrops roll in response to a breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4743416905403137 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9743416905403137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4743416905403137, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4743416905403137, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23110125958919525, + 0.165835440158844, + 0.06873989850282669, + 0.044420648366212845, + 0.10819016396999359, + 0.03274163603782654, + 0.09561972320079803, + 0.023256074637174606, + 0.061419982463121414, + 0.16867518424987793 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4743416905403137 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pink lotus in full bloom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear dewdrops visible on the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a calm pond reflecting a pale blue and orange dawn sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals tremble slightly and do dewdrops roll in response to a breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28141069412231445 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4064106941223145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28141069412231445, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28141069412231445, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19052356481552124, + 0.08457087725400925, + 0.1502595990896225, + 0.13434834778308868, + 0.16495099663734436, + 0.02563200145959854, + 0.09235923737287521, + 0.028116373345255852, + 0.043411996215581894, + 0.08582696318626404 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28141069412231445 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pink lotus in full bloom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear dewdrops visible on the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a calm pond reflecting a pale blue and orange dawn sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals tremble slightly and do dewdrops roll in response to a breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009794275276362896 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634794235229492 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009794275276362896, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009794275276362896, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26271188259124756, + 0.13656319677829742, + 0.05108995363116264, + 0.028445584699511528, + 0.06827113032341003, + 0.12518498301506042, + 0.14938054978847504, + 0.08961513638496399, + 0.019514476880431175, + 0.06922309100627899 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009794275276362896 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pink lotus in full bloom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear dewdrops visible on the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a calm pond reflecting a pale blue and orange dawn sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals tremble slightly and do dewdrops roll in response to a breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003460079431534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950345039367676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003460079431534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003460079431534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15895208716392517, + 0.14622685313224792, + 0.04823239892721176, + 0.03623974695801735, + 0.20422646403312683, + 0.08456864953041077, + 0.05027337372303009, + 0.029085544869303703, + 0.04956832528114319, + 0.19262655079364777 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003460079431534 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly overhead angle, the camera held still, focuses on a pink lotus blossoming in a morning pond. The lotus is in full bloom, its delicate petals a deeper pink at the edges, fading to a softer pale pink towards the center, its cascading structure gracefully unfurling. Crystal-clear dewdrops, like tiny diamonds, scatter across the broad, silky surface of the petals, each one clearly reflecting its surroundings. The calm, mirror-like surface of the pond reflects the pale blue and orange of the dawn sky. A few broad, dark green lotus leaves blur the subject, and a thin layer of morning mist gently shrouds the water. A barely perceptible breeze rustles the petals, causing them to tremble ever so slightly, rhythmically, and the clinging dewdrops roll in response, reflecting tiny shimmers of light. At dawn, the soft golden sunlight shines from the side at a low angle, penetrating the thin edges of the petals, giving them a translucent texture. The whole picture has fresh and soft tones, creating an extremely peaceful, pure and vital Zen atmosphere.", + "seed": 11219, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_0/index_3909_seed_11219_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.13782336805015802, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13782336805015802, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13782336805015802, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pink lotus in full bloom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear dewdrops visible on the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a calm pond reflecting a pale blue and orange dawn sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals tremble slightly and do dewdrops roll in response to a breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005981994792819023 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.380981922149658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005981994792819023, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005981994792819023, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15031492710113525, + 0.0955703854560852, + 0.06203664466738701, + 0.06291182339191437, + 0.05701616778969765, + 0.2889236509799957, + 0.07899075746536255, + 0.06686355918645859, + 0.07125486433506012, + 0.06611721217632294 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005981994792819023 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pink lotus in full bloom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear dewdrops visible on the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a calm pond reflecting a pale blue and orange dawn sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals tremble slightly and do dewdrops roll in response to a breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233727693557739 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983727693557739 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233727693557739, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233727693557739, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21487991511821747, + 0.09788531064987183, + 0.08403987437486649, + 0.08332114666700363, + 0.12697865068912506, + 0.13905109465122223, + 0.04462708160281181, + 0.08734185993671417, + 0.03904026374220848, + 0.08283472806215286 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233727693557739 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pink lotus in full bloom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear dewdrops visible on the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a calm pond reflecting a pale blue and orange dawn sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals tremble slightly and do dewdrops roll in response to a breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06206217780709267 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120622634887695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06206217780709267, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06206217780709267, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16650724411010742, + 0.17135894298553467, + 0.074249267578125, + 0.040539275854825974, + 0.10342346131801605, + 0.09057223796844482, + 0.09329140931367874, + 0.18612807989120483, + 0.03367408737540245, + 0.04025597870349884 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06206217780709267 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pink lotus in full bloom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear dewdrops visible on the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a calm pond reflecting a pale blue and orange dawn sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals tremble slightly and do dewdrops roll in response to a breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008649858646094799 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758649826049805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008649858646094799, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008649858646094799, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12077336013317108, + 0.08671001344919205, + 0.07424510270357132, + 0.0977998897433281, + 0.11727980524301529, + 0.2734638750553131, + 0.03014482744038105, + 0.10036429762840271, + 0.057933688163757324, + 0.0412851981818676 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008649858646094799 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pink lotus in full bloom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear dewdrops visible on the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a calm pond reflecting a pale blue and orange dawn sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals tremble slightly and do dewdrops roll in response to a breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890500396490097 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464050054550171 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0890500396490097, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0890500396490097, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1353636234998703, + 0.08409306406974792, + 0.10817450284957886, + 0.10879887640476227, + 0.03980069234967232, + 0.3017011284828186, + 0.03185977041721344, + 0.0404539629817009, + 0.05395157262682915, + 0.09580273926258087 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0890500396490097 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly overhead angle, the camera held still, focuses on a pink lotus blossoming in a morning pond. The lotus is in full bloom, its delicate petals a deeper pink at the edges, fading to a softer pale pink towards the center, its cascading structure gracefully unfurling. Crystal-clear dewdrops, like tiny diamonds, scatter across the broad, silky surface of the petals, each one clearly reflecting its surroundings. The calm, mirror-like surface of the pond reflects the pale blue and orange of the dawn sky. A few broad, dark green lotus leaves blur the subject, and a thin layer of morning mist gently shrouds the water. A barely perceptible breeze rustles the petals, causing them to tremble ever so slightly, rhythmically, and the clinging dewdrops roll in response, reflecting tiny shimmers of light. At dawn, the soft golden sunlight shines from the side at a low angle, penetrating the thin edges of the petals, giving them a translucent texture. The whole picture has fresh and soft tones, creating an extremely peaceful, pure and vital Zen atmosphere.", + "seed": 11220, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_0/index_3909_seed_11220_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1102709679864347, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1102709679864347, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1102709679864347, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pink lotus in full bloom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear dewdrops visible on the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a calm pond reflecting a pale blue and orange dawn sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals tremble slightly and do dewdrops roll in response to a breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006767448503524065 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.131767272949219 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006767448503524065, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006767448503524065, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12700890004634857, + 0.0776732787489891, + 0.10089477151632309, + 0.08535467833280563, + 0.07561320066452026, + 0.04218008741736412, + 0.07169687002897263, + 0.10400840640068054, + 0.08880624920129776, + 0.22676357626914978 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006767448503524065 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pink lotus in full bloom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear dewdrops visible on the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a calm pond reflecting a pale blue and orange dawn sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals tremble slightly and do dewdrops roll in response to a breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31348228454589844 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134822845458984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31348228454589844, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31348228454589844, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10574053227901459, + 0.06015247106552124, + 0.19914859533309937, + 0.1250651627779007, + 0.05409551039338112, + 0.02037721872329712, + 0.04420415684580803, + 0.19563280045986176, + 0.021444056183099747, + 0.17413954436779022 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31348228454589844 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pink lotus in full bloom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear dewdrops visible on the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a calm pond reflecting a pale blue and orange dawn sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals tremble slightly and do dewdrops roll in response to a breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16040994226932526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910409927368164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16040994226932526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16040994226932526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13242773711681366, + 0.09220074862241745, + 0.23826411366462708, + 0.07470881938934326, + 0.11030884832143784, + 0.01993546262383461, + 0.01888880878686905, + 0.1260880082845688, + 0.013928355649113655, + 0.17324911057949066 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16040994226932526 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pink lotus in full bloom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear dewdrops visible on the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a calm pond reflecting a pale blue and orange dawn sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals tremble slightly and do dewdrops roll in response to a breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008648558519780636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75864839553833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008648558519780636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008648558519780636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10586895048618317, + 0.06175859272480011, + 0.043717946857213974, + 0.13472986221313477, + 0.17924758791923523, + 0.09552285075187683, + 0.03605147823691368, + 0.18286989629268646, + 0.10202349722385406, + 0.05820939317345619 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008648558519780636 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pink lotus in full bloom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear dewdrops visible on the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a calm pond reflecting a pale blue and orange dawn sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals tremble slightly and do dewdrops roll in response to a breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062046606093645096 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812046527862549 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062046606093645096, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062046606093645096, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17928458750247955, + 0.04639659449458122, + 0.0501706562936306, + 0.16818314790725708, + 0.10876654833555222, + 0.035018566995859146, + 0.05084569379687309, + 0.055916160345077515, + 0.08711053431034088, + 0.2183074802160263 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062046606093645096 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly overhead angle, the camera held still, focuses on a pink lotus blossoming in a morning pond. The lotus is in full bloom, its delicate petals a deeper pink at the edges, fading to a softer pale pink towards the center, its cascading structure gracefully unfurling. Crystal-clear dewdrops, like tiny diamonds, scatter across the broad, silky surface of the petals, each one clearly reflecting its surroundings. The calm, mirror-like surface of the pond reflects the pale blue and orange of the dawn sky. A few broad, dark green lotus leaves blur the subject, and a thin layer of morning mist gently shrouds the water. A barely perceptible breeze rustles the petals, causing them to tremble ever so slightly, rhythmically, and the clinging dewdrops roll in response, reflecting tiny shimmers of light. At dawn, the soft golden sunlight shines from the side at a low angle, penetrating the thin edges of the petals, giving them a translucent texture. The whole picture has fresh and soft tones, creating an extremely peaceful, pure and vital Zen atmosphere.", + "seed": 11221, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_0/index_3909_seed_11221_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.08541465504094958, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08541465504094958, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08541465504094958, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pink lotus in full bloom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear dewdrops visible on the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a calm pond reflecting a pale blue and orange dawn sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals tremble slightly and do dewdrops roll in response to a breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008772997185587883 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.133772850036621 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008772997185587883, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008772997185587883, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1331927627325058, + 0.18392114341259003, + 0.05870314687490463, + 0.13290858268737793, + 0.05243814364075661, + 0.056193865835666656, + 0.06794761121273041, + 0.12036730349063873, + 0.08360234647989273, + 0.11072507500648499 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008772997185587883 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pink lotus in full bloom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear dewdrops visible on the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a calm pond reflecting a pale blue and orange dawn sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals tremble slightly and do dewdrops roll in response to a breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1604047566652298 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104048013687134 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1604047566652298, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1604047566652298, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26297563314437866, + 0.14366036653518677, + 0.06744502484798431, + 0.1800941526889801, + 0.04173416271805763, + 0.03167780488729477, + 0.03535393625497818, + 0.062224455177783966, + 0.046595651656389236, + 0.12823884189128876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1604047566652298 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pink lotus in full bloom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear dewdrops visible on the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a calm pond reflecting a pale blue and orange dawn sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals tremble slightly and do dewdrops roll in response to a breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20160190761089325 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016018629074097 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20160190761089325, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20160190761089325, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1426180601119995, + 0.19884367287158966, + 0.0921531543135643, + 0.07211344689130783, + 0.05816745385527611, + 0.05387474596500397, + 0.15373365581035614, + 0.15679597854614258, + 0.018096134066581726, + 0.053603727370500565 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20160190761089325 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pink lotus in full bloom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear dewdrops visible on the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a calm pond reflecting a pale blue and orange dawn sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals tremble slightly and do dewdrops roll in response to a breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007640424650162458 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882640361785889 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007640424650162458, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007640424650162458, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22459819912910461, + 0.10908486694097519, + 0.06854142248630524, + 0.10364743322134018, + 0.1512264907360077, + 0.043335702270269394, + 0.03997636213898659, + 0.04986974969506264, + 0.08526785671710968, + 0.12445191293954849 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007640424650162458 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pink lotus in full bloom?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are crystal-clear dewdrops visible on the lotus petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background a calm pond reflecting a pale blue and orange dawn sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still from a slightly overhead angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the petals tremble slightly and do dewdrops roll in response to a breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865318909287453 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486531257629395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865318909287453, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865318909287453, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1807246208190918, + 0.08820292353630066, + 0.08453845232725143, + 0.10664482414722443, + 0.13710251450538635, + 0.051001351326704025, + 0.032214704900979996, + 0.07453345507383347, + 0.07790298014879227, + 0.1671341359615326 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865318909287453 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_1/index_tensor([6830, 6830])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_1/index_tensor([6830, 6830])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..54dd519459354d75afa8a885dcb2f78ed7f5e66a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_1/index_tensor([6830, 6830])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up, captured from a precarious handheld perspective, captures a stack of thick, drawing technique books, their covers adorned with vibrant abstract art. Rendered in a dramatic, Jojo-esque style, the scene is defined by supersaturated, bizarre colors, where vibrant fuchsias, electric cyans, and acidic yellows clash violently, with each object sharply delineated by thick black outlines. The books rest on a dark wooden surface, stained with old paint splatters. Suddenly, the stack erupts in intense, underdamped vibrations, the camera swaying in sync with the initial tremors. The books rattle violently against one another, their covers transforming into a chaotic, colorful blur as the handheld view struggles to keep them in frame, intensifying the overwhelming, chaotic energy. As the intense vibrations continue, the air around the books seems to crackle with stylized lines of energy. Then, as suddenly as it had begun, the oscillations began to slowly and deliberately subside; the violent rattling faded into a steady vibration, then into a faint residual tremor, and then the stack returned to a tense stillness, now tilted slightly, casting deep, graphic shadows against the oddly colored surroundings in the harsh single-source light.", + "seed": 17031, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_1/index_6830_seed_17031_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.036803655722178516, + "vlm_logprob": -0.036803655722178516, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.036803655722178516, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a stack of thick books with covers featuring vibrant abstract art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by thick black outlines and supersaturated colors like fuchsia, cyan, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a dark wooden surface with old paint splatters beneath the books?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the book stack erupting in intense vibrations that cause the camera to sway and the covers to blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the stack returning to a tense stillness while tilted slightly and casting deep graphic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018819350749254227 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018819332122803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018819350749254227, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018819350749254227, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13717445731163025, + 0.07675804197788239, + 0.03606262430548668, + 0.06104325130581856, + 0.07847389578819275, + 0.020982686430215836, + 0.22518238425254822, + 0.03625768795609474, + 0.06314928084611893, + 0.2649157643318176 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018819350749254227 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a stack of thick books with covers featuring vibrant abstract art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by thick black outlines and supersaturated colors like fuchsia, cyan, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a dark wooden surface with old paint splatters beneath the books?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the book stack erupting in intense vibrations that cause the camera to sway and the covers to blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the stack returning to a tense stillness while tilted slightly and casting deep graphic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015168600948527455 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501516819000244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015168600948527455, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015168600948527455, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1049460917711258, + 0.10572973638772964, + 0.04000360891222954, + 0.033912837505340576, + 0.21366342902183533, + 0.04399394989013672, + 0.13819724321365356, + 0.014997873455286026, + 0.10716966539621353, + 0.19738559424877167 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015168600948527455 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a stack of thick books with covers featuring vibrant abstract art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by thick black outlines and supersaturated colors like fuchsia, cyan, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a dark wooden surface with old paint splatters beneath the books?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the book stack erupting in intense vibrations that cause the camera to sway and the covers to blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the stack returning to a tense stillness while tilted slightly and casting deep graphic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897159457206726 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789716243743896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897159457206726, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897159457206726, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14479181170463562, + 0.08212153613567352, + 0.04845522344112396, + 0.021923311054706573, + 0.059945136308670044, + 0.02304549142718315, + 0.19281867146492004, + 0.037324290722608566, + 0.058797407895326614, + 0.3307770788669586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897159457206726 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a stack of thick books with covers featuring vibrant abstract art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by thick black outlines and supersaturated colors like fuchsia, cyan, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a dark wooden surface with old paint splatters beneath the books?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the book stack erupting in intense vibrations that cause the camera to sway and the covers to blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the stack returning to a tense stillness while tilted slightly and casting deep graphic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05493263155221939 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299325942993164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05493263155221939, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05493263155221939, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07588968425989151, + 0.0854465514421463, + 0.030610471963882446, + 0.029711971059441566, + 0.1772521287202835, + 0.15279275178909302, + 0.1108972355723381, + 0.020706256851553917, + 0.027676261961460114, + 0.2890166640281677 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05493263155221939 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a stack of thick books with covers featuring vibrant abstract art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by thick black outlines and supersaturated colors like fuchsia, cyan, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a dark wooden surface with old paint splatters beneath the books?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the book stack erupting in intense vibrations that cause the camera to sway and the covers to blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the stack returning to a tense stillness while tilted slightly and casting deep graphic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02977784164249897 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529777765274048 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02977784164249897, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02977784164249897, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07762710750102997, + 0.07069629430770874, + 0.023115891963243484, + 0.037797536700963974, + 0.11258669197559357, + 0.030246416106820107, + 0.14474666118621826, + 0.034515172243118286, + 0.1030569076538086, + 0.36561134457588196 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02977784164249897 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, captured from a precarious handheld perspective, captures a stack of thick, drawing technique books, their covers adorned with vibrant abstract art. Rendered in a dramatic, Jojo-esque style, the scene is defined by supersaturated, bizarre colors, where vibrant fuchsias, electric cyans, and acidic yellows clash violently, with each object sharply delineated by thick black outlines. The books rest on a dark wooden surface, stained with old paint splatters. Suddenly, the stack erupts in intense, underdamped vibrations, the camera swaying in sync with the initial tremors. The books rattle violently against one another, their covers transforming into a chaotic, colorful blur as the handheld view struggles to keep them in frame, intensifying the overwhelming, chaotic energy. As the intense vibrations continue, the air around the books seems to crackle with stylized lines of energy. Then, as suddenly as it had begun, the oscillations began to slowly and deliberately subside; the violent rattling faded into a steady vibration, then into a faint residual tremor, and then the stack returned to a tense stillness, now tilted slightly, casting deep, graphic shadows against the oddly colored surroundings in the harsh single-source light.", + "seed": 17032, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_1/index_6830_seed_17032_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04156764494255185, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04156764494255185, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04156764494255185, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a stack of thick books with covers featuring vibrant abstract art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by thick black outlines and supersaturated colors like fuchsia, cyan, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a dark wooden surface with old paint splatters beneath the books?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the book stack erupting in intense vibrations that cause the camera to sway and the covers to blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the stack returning to a tense stillness while tilted slightly and casting deep graphic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0490424707531929 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0490424633026123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0490424707531929, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0490424707531929, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12647242844104767, + 0.2308146059513092, + 0.05939101427793503, + 0.10980530083179474, + 0.06392982602119446, + 0.11513923108577728, + 0.18024136126041412, + 0.03870267793536186, + 0.02517751231789589, + 0.05032600834965706 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0490424707531929 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a stack of thick books with covers featuring vibrant abstract art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by thick black outlines and supersaturated colors like fuchsia, cyan, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a dark wooden surface with old paint splatters beneath the books?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the book stack erupting in intense vibrations that cause the camera to sway and the covers to blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the stack returning to a tense stillness while tilted slightly and casting deep graphic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005259012337774038 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255259037017822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005259012337774038, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005259012337774038, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1809689849615097, + 0.1041426733136177, + 0.08965197950601578, + 0.08929198235273361, + 0.10366139560937881, + 0.05805567651987076, + 0.18221968412399292, + 0.08082956075668335, + 0.052421629428863525, + 0.05875649303197861 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005259012337774038 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a stack of thick books with covers featuring vibrant abstract art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by thick black outlines and supersaturated colors like fuchsia, cyan, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a dark wooden surface with old paint splatters beneath the books?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the book stack erupting in intense vibrations that cause the camera to sway and the covers to blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the stack returning to a tense stillness while tilted slightly and casting deep graphic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897710800170898 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578977108001709 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897710800170898, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897710800170898, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23687128722667694, + 0.12741726636886597, + 0.07805235683917999, + 0.01834169588983059, + 0.039135660976171494, + 0.09259418398141861, + 0.16412511467933655, + 0.10721102356910706, + 0.01725192181766033, + 0.11899953335523605 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897710800170898 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a stack of thick books with covers featuring vibrant abstract art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by thick black outlines and supersaturated colors like fuchsia, cyan, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a dark wooden surface with old paint splatters beneath the books?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the book stack erupting in intense vibrations that cause the camera to sway and the covers to blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the stack returning to a tense stillness while tilted slightly and casting deep graphic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012534764595329762 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875346183776855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012534764595329762, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012534764595329762, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1677820086479187, + 0.1393170952796936, + 0.06851860880851746, + 0.0840318351984024, + 0.18274140357971191, + 0.08439105749130249, + 0.1218285858631134, + 0.027882125228643417, + 0.03210541233420372, + 0.0914018526673317 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012534764595329762 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a stack of thick books with covers featuring vibrant abstract art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by thick black outlines and supersaturated colors like fuchsia, cyan, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a dark wooden surface with old paint splatters beneath the books?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the book stack erupting in intense vibrations that cause the camera to sway and the covers to blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the stack returning to a tense stillness while tilted slightly and casting deep graphic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06202486902475357 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120248317718506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06202486902475357, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06202486902475357, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061117984354496, + 0.054996710270643234, + 0.029718920588493347, + 0.048476554453372955, + 0.08042487502098083, + 0.06327975541353226, + 0.19356279075145721, + 0.06189405918121338, + 0.13886995613574982, + 0.2676584720611572 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06202486902475357 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, captured from a precarious handheld perspective, captures a stack of thick, drawing technique books, their covers adorned with vibrant abstract art. Rendered in a dramatic, Jojo-esque style, the scene is defined by supersaturated, bizarre colors, where vibrant fuchsias, electric cyans, and acidic yellows clash violently, with each object sharply delineated by thick black outlines. The books rest on a dark wooden surface, stained with old paint splatters. Suddenly, the stack erupts in intense, underdamped vibrations, the camera swaying in sync with the initial tremors. The books rattle violently against one another, their covers transforming into a chaotic, colorful blur as the handheld view struggles to keep them in frame, intensifying the overwhelming, chaotic energy. As the intense vibrations continue, the air around the books seems to crackle with stylized lines of energy. Then, as suddenly as it had begun, the oscillations began to slowly and deliberately subside; the violent rattling faded into a steady vibration, then into a faint residual tremor, and then the stack returned to a tense stillness, now tilted slightly, casting deep, graphic shadows against the oddly colored surroundings in the harsh single-source light.", + "seed": 17033, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_1/index_6830_seed_17033_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03204783465480432, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03204783465480432, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03204783465480432, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a stack of thick books with covers featuring vibrant abstract art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by thick black outlines and supersaturated colors like fuchsia, cyan, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a dark wooden surface with old paint splatters beneath the books?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the book stack erupting in intense vibrations that cause the camera to sway and the covers to blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the stack returning to a tense stillness while tilted slightly and casting deep graphic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038911715149879456 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288911819458008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038911715149879456, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038911715149879456, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1690339744091034, + 0.051480330526828766, + 0.061847034841775894, + 0.05530063807964325, + 0.08391501009464264, + 0.06299635767936707, + 0.13030532002449036, + 0.10751113295555115, + 0.03091331571340561, + 0.24669691920280457 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038911715149879456 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a stack of thick books with covers featuring vibrant abstract art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by thick black outlines and supersaturated colors like fuchsia, cyan, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a dark wooden surface with old paint splatters beneath the books?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the book stack erupting in intense vibrations that cause the camera to sway and the covers to blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the stack returning to a tense stillness while tilted slightly and casting deep graphic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0009233264136128128 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.000923156738281 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0009233264136128128, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0009233264136128128, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21709060668945312, + 0.10233515501022339, + 0.16949479281902313, + 0.10246648639440536, + 0.044261280447244644, + 0.09885628521442413, + 0.08595168590545654, + 0.0437515452504158, + 0.056168440729379654, + 0.07962371408939362 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0009233264136128128 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a stack of thick books with covers featuring vibrant abstract art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by thick black outlines and supersaturated colors like fuchsia, cyan, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a dark wooden surface with old paint splatters beneath the books?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the book stack erupting in intense vibrations that cause the camera to sway and the covers to blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the stack returning to a tense stillness while tilted slightly and casting deep graphic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038087889552116394 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288087844848633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038087889552116394, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038087889552116394, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15221989154815674, + 0.04559040814638138, + 0.09075894951820374, + 0.03605639562010765, + 0.05888325721025467, + 0.07656095921993256, + 0.2350626140832901, + 0.024167263880372047, + 0.12031358480453491, + 0.16038668155670166 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038087889552116394 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a stack of thick books with covers featuring vibrant abstract art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by thick black outlines and supersaturated colors like fuchsia, cyan, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a dark wooden surface with old paint splatters beneath the books?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the book stack erupting in intense vibrations that cause the camera to sway and the covers to blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the stack returning to a tense stillness while tilted slightly and casting deep graphic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04863831400871277 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048638343811035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04863831400871277, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04863831400871277, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16826045513153076, + 0.09389864653348923, + 0.14386104047298431, + 0.09237420558929443, + 0.06745738536119461, + 0.19342581927776337, + 0.04549778997898102, + 0.0688362792134285, + 0.020309414714574814, + 0.10607899725437164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04863831400871277 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a stack of thick books with covers featuring vibrant abstract art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by thick black outlines and supersaturated colors like fuchsia, cyan, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a dark wooden surface with old paint splatters beneath the books?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the book stack erupting in intense vibrations that cause the camera to sway and the covers to blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the stack returning to a tense stillness while tilted slightly and casting deep graphic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033677928149700165 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408677816390991 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033677928149700165, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033677928149700165, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09209677577018738, + 0.05773203447461128, + 0.08658996969461441, + 0.06577588617801666, + 0.03579332306981087, + 0.19766409695148468, + 0.1214122548699379, + 0.12641923129558563, + 0.05986347794532776, + 0.15665294229984283 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033677928149700165 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, captured from a precarious handheld perspective, captures a stack of thick, drawing technique books, their covers adorned with vibrant abstract art. Rendered in a dramatic, Jojo-esque style, the scene is defined by supersaturated, bizarre colors, where vibrant fuchsias, electric cyans, and acidic yellows clash violently, with each object sharply delineated by thick black outlines. The books rest on a dark wooden surface, stained with old paint splatters. Suddenly, the stack erupts in intense, underdamped vibrations, the camera swaying in sync with the initial tremors. The books rattle violently against one another, their covers transforming into a chaotic, colorful blur as the handheld view struggles to keep them in frame, intensifying the overwhelming, chaotic energy. As the intense vibrations continue, the air around the books seems to crackle with stylized lines of energy. Then, as suddenly as it had begun, the oscillations began to slowly and deliberately subside; the violent rattling faded into a steady vibration, then into a faint residual tremor, and then the stack returned to a tense stillness, now tilted slightly, casting deep, graphic shadows against the oddly colored surroundings in the harsh single-source light.", + "seed": 17034, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_1/index_6830_seed_17034_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0341675371164456, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0341675371164456, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.249999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0341675371164456, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a stack of thick books with covers featuring vibrant abstract art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by thick black outlines and supersaturated colors like fuchsia, cyan, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a dark wooden surface with old paint splatters beneath the books?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the book stack erupting in intense vibrations that cause the camera to sway and the covers to blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the stack returning to a tense stillness while tilted slightly and casting deep graphic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010229893028736115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63523006439209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010229893028736115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010229893028736115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14356034994125366, + 0.0667804405093193, + 0.15048375725746155, + 0.21532711386680603, + 0.1348555088043213, + 0.07455004751682281, + 0.04709215089678764, + 0.07082497328519821, + 0.044782985001802444, + 0.05174269899725914 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010229893028736115 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a stack of thick books with covers featuring vibrant abstract art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by thick black outlines and supersaturated colors like fuchsia, cyan, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a dark wooden surface with old paint splatters beneath the books?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the book stack erupting in intense vibrations that cause the camera to sway and the covers to blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the stack returning to a tense stillness while tilted slightly and casting deep graphic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019462230848148465 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251946449279785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019462230848148465, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019462230848148465, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.085784412920475, + 0.04438302293419838, + 0.11407407373189926, + 0.10488373786211014, + 0.10024761408567429, + 0.09697744995355606, + 0.07593399286270142, + 0.21131448447704315, + 0.04872646927833557, + 0.11767477542161942 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019462230848148465 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a stack of thick books with covers featuring vibrant abstract art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by thick black outlines and supersaturated colors like fuchsia, cyan, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a dark wooden surface with old paint splatters beneath the books?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the book stack erupting in intense vibrations that cause the camera to sway and the covers to blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the stack returning to a tense stillness while tilted slightly and casting deep graphic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058207429945469 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955819606781006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058207429945469, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058207429945469, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09010021388530731, + 0.04132838919758797, + 0.12815415859222412, + 0.09381209313869476, + 0.39891722798347473, + 0.05591456964612007, + 0.025766106322407722, + 0.09221367537975311, + 0.030270343646407127, + 0.04352324455976486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058207429945469 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a stack of thick books with covers featuring vibrant abstract art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by thick black outlines and supersaturated colors like fuchsia, cyan, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a dark wooden surface with old paint splatters beneath the books?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the book stack erupting in intense vibrations that cause the camera to sway and the covers to blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the stack returning to a tense stillness while tilted slightly and casting deep graphic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011072383262217045 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511072158813477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011072383262217045, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011072383262217045, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07319717854261398, + 0.041856251657009125, + 0.16323602199554443, + 0.0868234857916832, + 0.09034610539674759, + 0.08107909560203552, + 0.05806896090507507, + 0.3003058433532715, + 0.06236783042550087, + 0.042719196528196335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011072383262217045 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a stack of thick books with covers featuring vibrant abstract art?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by thick black outlines and supersaturated colors like fuchsia, cyan, and yellow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a dark wooden surface with old paint splatters beneath the books?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the book stack erupting in intense vibrations that cause the camera to sway and the covers to blur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with the stack returning to a tense stillness while tilted slightly and casting deep graphic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270071119070053 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127007007598877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270071119070053, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270071119070053, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.055732838809490204, + 0.058849483728408813, + 0.04657984524965286, + 0.08611703664064407, + 0.07465416938066483, + 0.08580275624990463, + 0.11623289436101913, + 0.15993885695934296, + 0.08250217139720917, + 0.23358993232250214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270071119070053 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_10/index_tensor([8195, 8195])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_10/index_tensor([8195, 8195])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7227cad29a6d8258f1fa3f9bfdb66e643f9d63cb --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_10/index_tensor([8195, 8195])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "macro, slightly high-angled, static shot captures a lone, enormous horned helmet snail, its form dominating the frame amidst a bed of fine, golden sand on the seafloor. Bright, shimmering patterns of corrosive light, filtering down through the clear turquoise water, dance across the snail's pale, bone-white shell, adorned with thick, sturdy knobs like the towers of a miniature fortress, showing subtle signs of age, with faint green algae growing in the crevices. Suddenly, a massive, dark shadow glides swiftly and silently across the scene from an unseen source, plunging the snail into cool, ominous darkness. The snail reacts instantly, slowly and deliberately beginning to retract into its protective home; its delicate eyestalks disappear first, retracting into its body, followed by the methodical contraction of its soft, mottled brown, muscular feet. The creature pulls itself inward relentlessly until its hard, dark brown gill cover closes, sealing the shell's opening with a flawless defensive finale. As bright, dappled sunlight returns to the scene, the shell acts like an inert, impenetrable fortress, creating an intense yet ultimately serene atmosphere of natural drama and survival.", + "seed": 32542, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_10/index_8195_seed_32542_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08323229849338531, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08323229849338531, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08323229849338531, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro, slightly high-angled, static view of a horned helmet snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail situated on a bed of fine golden sand on the seafloor with bright shimmering patterns of light filtering down through clear turquoise water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive dark shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene, plunging the snail into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the snail react by slowly retracting its eyestalks and feet before its hard dark brown gill cover closes to seal the shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with bright dappled sunlight returning to the sealed shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019246377050876617 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.144246578216553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019246377050876617, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019246377050876617, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16747571527957916, + 0.14761383831501007, + 0.21798349916934967, + 0.06636727601289749, + 0.04864605888724327, + 0.08532856404781342, + 0.10180914402008057, + 0.025383910164237022, + 0.08312810957431793, + 0.05626387894153595 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019246377050876617 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro, slightly high-angled, static view of a horned helmet snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail situated on a bed of fine golden sand on the seafloor with bright shimmering patterns of light filtering down through clear turquoise water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive dark shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene, plunging the snail into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the snail react by slowly retracting its eyestalks and feet before its hard dark brown gill cover closes to seal the shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with bright dappled sunlight returning to the sealed shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008651158772408962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758651256561279 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008651158772408962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008651158772408962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06572097539901733, + 0.11554425209760666, + 0.1665005087852478, + 0.06516727805137634, + 0.047845106571912766, + 0.138376384973526, + 0.0531497485935688, + 0.053641002625226974, + 0.0736919492483139, + 0.2203627973794937 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008651158772408962 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro, slightly high-angled, static view of a horned helmet snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail situated on a bed of fine golden sand on the seafloor with bright shimmering patterns of light filtering down through clear turquoise water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive dark shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene, plunging the snail into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the snail react by slowly retracting its eyestalks and feet before its hard dark brown gill cover closes to seal the shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with bright dappled sunlight returning to the sealed shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980538085103035 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298054218292236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980538085103035, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980538085103035, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06052391603589058, + 0.0643405169248581, + 0.4082053601741791, + 0.05369877442717552, + 0.05090723931789398, + 0.04188767448067665, + 0.0889115110039711, + 0.031242867931723595, + 0.06476407498121262, + 0.13551807403564453 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980538085103035 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro, slightly high-angled, static view of a horned helmet snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail situated on a bed of fine golden sand on the seafloor with bright shimmering patterns of light filtering down through clear turquoise water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive dark shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene, plunging the snail into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the snail react by slowly retracting its eyestalks and feet before its hard dark brown gill cover closes to seal the shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with bright dappled sunlight returning to the sealed shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978341419249773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347832679748535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978341419249773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978341419249773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05893968790769577, + 0.07041629403829575, + 0.12475726008415222, + 0.09260673820972443, + 0.0903862714767456, + 0.12389139831066132, + 0.1478869765996933, + 0.03715815767645836, + 0.12766145169734955, + 0.1262957900762558 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978341419249773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro, slightly high-angled, static view of a horned helmet snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail situated on a bed of fine golden sand on the seafloor with bright shimmering patterns of light filtering down through clear turquoise water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive dark shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene, plunging the snail into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the snail react by slowly retracting its eyestalks and feet before its hard dark brown gill cover closes to seal the shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with bright dappled sunlight returning to the sealed shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486751616001129 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236751317977905 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486751616001129, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486751616001129, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05594444274902344, + 0.05417269095778465, + 0.3354780375957489, + 0.044201385229825974, + 0.06564994156360626, + 0.05906488746404648, + 0.03928309306502342, + 0.05825524032115936, + 0.10120107978582382, + 0.1867491602897644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486751616001129 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "macro, slightly high-angled, static shot captures a lone, enormous horned helmet snail, its form dominating the frame amidst a bed of fine, golden sand on the seafloor. Bright, shimmering patterns of corrosive light, filtering down through the clear turquoise water, dance across the snail's pale, bone-white shell, adorned with thick, sturdy knobs like the towers of a miniature fortress, showing subtle signs of age, with faint green algae growing in the crevices. Suddenly, a massive, dark shadow glides swiftly and silently across the scene from an unseen source, plunging the snail into cool, ominous darkness. The snail reacts instantly, slowly and deliberately beginning to retract into its protective home; its delicate eyestalks disappear first, retracting into its body, followed by the methodical contraction of its soft, mottled brown, muscular feet. The creature pulls itself inward relentlessly until its hard, dark brown gill cover closes, sealing the shell's opening with a flawless defensive finale. As bright, dappled sunlight returns to the scene, the shell acts like an inert, impenetrable fortress, creating an intense yet ultimately serene atmosphere of natural drama and survival.", + "seed": 32543, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_10/index_8195_seed_32543_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08682251619175077, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08682251619175077, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08682251619175077, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro, slightly high-angled, static view of a horned helmet snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail situated on a bed of fine golden sand on the seafloor with bright shimmering patterns of light filtering down through clear turquoise water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive dark shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene, plunging the snail into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the snail react by slowly retracting its eyestalks and feet before its hard dark brown gill cover closes to seal the shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with bright dappled sunlight returning to the sealed shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03774253651499748 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4127426147460938 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03774253651499748, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03774253651499748, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08681956678628922, + 0.066094771027565, + 0.03914085403084755, + 0.01632550172507763, + 0.10772474110126495, + 0.03428364172577858, + 0.06830847263336182, + 0.5340359807014465, + 0.026825303211808205, + 0.020441103726625443 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03774253651499748 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro, slightly high-angled, static view of a horned helmet snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail situated on a bed of fine golden sand on the seafloor with bright shimmering patterns of light filtering down through clear turquoise water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive dark shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene, plunging the snail into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the snail react by slowly retracting its eyestalks and feet before its hard dark brown gill cover closes to seal the shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with bright dappled sunlight returning to the sealed shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016090890392661095 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410908699035645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016090890392661095, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016090890392661095, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.054070472717285156, + 0.06862062960863113, + 0.1312657743692398, + 0.016362199559807777, + 0.2274823933839798, + 0.02756056748330593, + 0.03263555467128754, + 0.3963988125324249, + 0.019986821338534355, + 0.025616824626922607 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016090890392661095 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro, slightly high-angled, static view of a horned helmet snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail situated on a bed of fine golden sand on the seafloor with bright shimmering patterns of light filtering down through clear turquoise water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive dark shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene, plunging the snail into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the snail react by slowly retracting its eyestalks and feet before its hard dark brown gill cover closes to seal the shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with bright dappled sunlight returning to the sealed shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026351535692811012 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513514518737793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026351535692811012, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026351535692811012, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15174829959869385, + 0.15193374454975128, + 0.07458559423685074, + 0.03873074799776077, + 0.20887324213981628, + 0.035437483340501785, + 0.041575755923986435, + 0.1384529173374176, + 0.09537336230278015, + 0.0632888600230217 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026351535692811012 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro, slightly high-angled, static view of a horned helmet snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail situated on a bed of fine golden sand on the seafloor with bright shimmering patterns of light filtering down through clear turquoise water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive dark shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene, plunging the snail into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the snail react by slowly retracting its eyestalks and feet before its hard dark brown gill cover closes to seal the shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with bright dappled sunlight returning to the sealed shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005253201816231012 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255253314971924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005253201816231012, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005253201816231012, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06151081994175911, + 0.06877291947603226, + 0.04511163383722305, + 0.02831321582198143, + 0.027110517024993896, + 0.06575056910514832, + 0.039344288408756256, + 0.5714333653450012, + 0.0477081760764122, + 0.044944483786821365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005253201816231012 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro, slightly high-angled, static view of a horned helmet snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail situated on a bed of fine golden sand on the seafloor with bright shimmering patterns of light filtering down through clear turquoise water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive dark shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene, plunging the snail into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the snail react by slowly retracting its eyestalks and feet before its hard dark brown gill cover closes to seal the shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with bright dappled sunlight returning to the sealed shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486744165420532 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236744165420532 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486744165420532, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486744165420532, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08273495733737946, + 0.07416185736656189, + 0.06576413661241531, + 0.04421745240688324, + 0.09331358969211578, + 0.06432921439409256, + 0.08073923736810684, + 0.2837033271789551, + 0.0693894475698471, + 0.14164669811725616 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486744165420532 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "macro, slightly high-angled, static shot captures a lone, enormous horned helmet snail, its form dominating the frame amidst a bed of fine, golden sand on the seafloor. Bright, shimmering patterns of corrosive light, filtering down through the clear turquoise water, dance across the snail's pale, bone-white shell, adorned with thick, sturdy knobs like the towers of a miniature fortress, showing subtle signs of age, with faint green algae growing in the crevices. Suddenly, a massive, dark shadow glides swiftly and silently across the scene from an unseen source, plunging the snail into cool, ominous darkness. The snail reacts instantly, slowly and deliberately beginning to retract into its protective home; its delicate eyestalks disappear first, retracting into its body, followed by the methodical contraction of its soft, mottled brown, muscular feet. The creature pulls itself inward relentlessly until its hard, dark brown gill cover closes, sealing the shell's opening with a flawless defensive finale. As bright, dappled sunlight returns to the scene, the shell acts like an inert, impenetrable fortress, creating an intense yet ultimately serene atmosphere of natural drama and survival.", + "seed": 32544, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_10/index_8195_seed_32544_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.36686163349077106, + "vlm_logprob": -0.36686163349077106, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.36686163349077106, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro, slightly high-angled, static view of a horned helmet snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail situated on a bed of fine golden sand on the seafloor with bright shimmering patterns of light filtering down through clear turquoise water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive dark shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene, plunging the snail into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the snail react by slowly retracting its eyestalks and feet before its hard dark brown gill cover closes to seal the shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with bright dappled sunlight returning to the sealed shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011839007027447224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.761838912963867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011839007027447224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011839007027447224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0455952063202858, + 0.02527218498289585, + 0.02721366472542286, + 0.6741065979003906, + 0.03485051169991493, + 0.033132657408714294, + 0.04576773941516876, + 0.0388018861413002, + 0.04056259244680405, + 0.03469698876142502 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011839007027447224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro, slightly high-angled, static view of a horned helmet snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail situated on a bed of fine golden sand on the seafloor with bright shimmering patterns of light filtering down through clear turquoise water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive dark shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene, plunging the snail into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the snail react by slowly retracting its eyestalks and feet before its hard dark brown gill cover closes to seal the shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with bright dappled sunlight returning to the sealed shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006755134556442499 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006755352020264 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006755134556442499, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006755134556442499, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05557088553905487, + 0.04322327300906181, + 0.10897313058376312, + 0.5024665594100952, + 0.04013674706220627, + 0.031802576035261154, + 0.04208692908287048, + 0.05450664460659027, + 0.045395754277706146, + 0.07583751529455185 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006755134556442499 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro, slightly high-angled, static view of a horned helmet snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail situated on a bed of fine golden sand on the seafloor with bright shimmering patterns of light filtering down through clear turquoise water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive dark shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene, plunging the snail into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the snail react by slowly retracting its eyestalks and feet before its hard dark brown gill cover closes to seal the shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with bright dappled sunlight returning to the sealed shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031976778991520405 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.75319766998291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031976778991520405, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031976778991520405, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05049656331539154, + 0.017889630049467087, + 0.0889953076839447, + 0.4703088402748108, + 0.017518289387226105, + 0.018909718841314316, + 0.039088521152734756, + 0.05011709779500961, + 0.07231959700584412, + 0.17435643076896667 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031976778991520405 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro, slightly high-angled, static view of a horned helmet snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail situated on a bed of fine golden sand on the seafloor with bright shimmering patterns of light filtering down through clear turquoise water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive dark shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene, plunging the snail into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the snail react by slowly retracting its eyestalks and feet before its hard dark brown gill cover closes to seal the shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with bright dappled sunlight returning to the sealed shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007630960550159216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882630825042725 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007630960550159216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007630960550159216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.042959392070770264, + 0.026484141126275063, + 0.1084972470998764, + 0.35090309381484985, + 0.031230947002768517, + 0.027061594650149345, + 0.15480011701583862, + 0.05373164638876915, + 0.03435216471552849, + 0.16997969150543213 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007630960550159216 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro, slightly high-angled, static view of a horned helmet snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail situated on a bed of fine golden sand on the seafloor with bright shimmering patterns of light filtering down through clear turquoise water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive dark shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene, plunging the snail into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the snail react by slowly retracting its eyestalks and feet before its hard dark brown gill cover closes to seal the shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with bright dappled sunlight returning to the sealed shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048853874206543 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1798853725194931 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.8048853874206543, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.8048853874206543, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02733391709625721, + 0.016897479072213173, + 0.06228505074977875, + 0.4794066250324249, + 0.00959419272840023, + 0.026227707043290138, + 0.0982271358370781, + 0.05123245343565941, + 0.1148165687918663, + 0.11397889256477356 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.8048853874206543 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "macro, slightly high-angled, static shot captures a lone, enormous horned helmet snail, its form dominating the frame amidst a bed of fine, golden sand on the seafloor. Bright, shimmering patterns of corrosive light, filtering down through the clear turquoise water, dance across the snail's pale, bone-white shell, adorned with thick, sturdy knobs like the towers of a miniature fortress, showing subtle signs of age, with faint green algae growing in the crevices. Suddenly, a massive, dark shadow glides swiftly and silently across the scene from an unseen source, plunging the snail into cool, ominous darkness. The snail reacts instantly, slowly and deliberately beginning to retract into its protective home; its delicate eyestalks disappear first, retracting into its body, followed by the methodical contraction of its soft, mottled brown, muscular feet. The creature pulls itself inward relentlessly until its hard, dark brown gill cover closes, sealing the shell's opening with a flawless defensive finale. As bright, dappled sunlight returns to the scene, the shell acts like an inert, impenetrable fortress, creating an intense yet ultimately serene atmosphere of natural drama and survival.", + "seed": 32545, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_10/index_8195_seed_32545_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.037132996367290616, + "vlm_logprob": -0.037132996367290616, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.037132996367290616, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro, slightly high-angled, static view of a horned helmet snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail situated on a bed of fine golden sand on the seafloor with bright shimmering patterns of light filtering down through clear turquoise water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive dark shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene, plunging the snail into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the snail react by slowly retracting its eyestalks and feet before its hard dark brown gill cover closes to seal the shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with bright dappled sunlight returning to the sealed shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012605632655322552 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.637605667114258 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012605632655322552, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012605632655322552, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14321774244308472, + 0.04946592077612877, + 0.039064448326826096, + 0.16255901753902435, + 0.138642817735672, + 0.07904889434576035, + 0.08400551974773407, + 0.08258159458637238, + 0.11535803973674774, + 0.10605604946613312 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012605632655322552 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro, slightly high-angled, static view of a horned helmet snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail situated on a bed of fine golden sand on the seafloor with bright shimmering patterns of light filtering down through clear turquoise water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive dark shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene, plunging the snail into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the snail react by slowly retracting its eyestalks and feet before its hard dark brown gill cover closes to seal the shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with bright dappled sunlight returning to the sealed shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024990777019411325 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002499103546143 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024990777019411325, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024990777019411325, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13407137989997864, + 0.038832180202007294, + 0.047053106129169464, + 0.0934133380651474, + 0.19152024388313293, + 0.12173859775066376, + 0.11524298042058945, + 0.061252690851688385, + 0.08525565266609192, + 0.11161977797746658 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024990777019411325 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro, slightly high-angled, static view of a horned helmet snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail situated on a bed of fine golden sand on the seafloor with bright shimmering patterns of light filtering down through clear turquoise water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive dark shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene, plunging the snail into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the snail react by slowly retracting its eyestalks and feet before its hard dark brown gill cover closes to seal the shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with bright dappled sunlight returning to the sealed shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370685875415802 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087069034576416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370685875415802, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370685875415802, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08725093305110931, + 0.038976382464170456, + 0.05384239926934242, + 0.14624150097370148, + 0.03986180201172829, + 0.2554120421409607, + 0.09701163321733475, + 0.1273254156112671, + 0.07057928293943405, + 0.08349860459566116 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370685875415802 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro, slightly high-angled, static view of a horned helmet snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail situated on a bed of fine golden sand on the seafloor with bright shimmering patterns of light filtering down through clear turquoise water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive dark shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene, plunging the snail into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the snail react by slowly retracting its eyestalks and feet before its hard dark brown gill cover closes to seal the shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with bright dappled sunlight returning to the sealed shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978152547031641 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634781360626221 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978152547031641, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978152547031641, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10129987448453903, + 0.06196197494864464, + 0.06922495365142822, + 0.10685524344444275, + 0.0577596053481102, + 0.08190295845270157, + 0.14543010294437408, + 0.1450246125459671, + 0.1672365963459015, + 0.0633041113615036 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978152547031641 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro, slightly high-angled, static view of a horned helmet snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the snail situated on a bed of fine golden sand on the seafloor with bright shimmering patterns of light filtering down through clear turquoise water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a massive dark shadow glide swiftly and silently across the scene, plunging the snail into darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the snail react by slowly retracting its eyestalks and feet before its hard dark brown gill cover closes to seal the shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video end with bright dappled sunlight returning to the sealed shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12707188725471497 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270718574523926 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12707188725471497, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12707188725471497, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07391718029975891, + 0.04784552380442619, + 0.02728760801255703, + 0.1637123078107834, + 0.04627150669693947, + 0.07001810520887375, + 0.05218648537993431, + 0.12964020669460297, + 0.2397734373807907, + 0.1493477076292038 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12707188725471497 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_11/index_tensor([7198, 7198])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_11/index_tensor([7198, 7198])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..24579d28e5b00d056f223ca92fded409cb687906 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_11/index_tensor([7198, 7198])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a wide, low-angle, still shot, a white-haired Qin Mo (a musical instrument) stands in a tranquil bamboo forest. Clad in a wide-sleeved, dark-colored silk robe, his snow-white hair gently swaying in the breeze and steam, he stands with grace and poise before an ancient clay medicine cauldron. The cauldron is dark brown, its surface mottled with age. Thick white steam rises from its mouth, obscuring his features in a hazy, mysterious silhouette. Steady in one hand, he gently stirs a long-handled wooden spoon within the cauldron, his movements measured and ritualistic. In the background, cascading, verdant bamboo leaves rise. Soft rays of sunlight penetrate the gaps in the forest, casting dappled beams of light through the lingering steam, adding depth and layering to the scene. The entire painting presents the delicate texture and elegant tones of antique silk painting, with ink-like black, white and blue as the main colors, creating a quiet, focused and mysterious atmosphere full of oriental classical aesthetics.", + "seed": 23852, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_11/index_7198_seed_23852_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.031880173832178116, + "vlm_logprob": -0.031880173832178116, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.031880173832178116, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-haired character named Qin Mo wearing a dark-colored wide-sleeved silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing in front of an ancient dark brown clay medicine cauldron with thick white steam rising from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a long-handled wooden spoon and stirring the contents of the cauldron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a verdant bamboo forest with dappled sunlight beams penetrating through the steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of an antique silk painting featuring ink-like black, white, and blue tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06319142132997513 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8131914138793945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06319142132997513, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06319142132997513, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3762870132923126, + 0.057168953120708466, + 0.07259637862443924, + 0.10186377912759781, + 0.1269407868385315, + 0.028181610628962517, + 0.022999804466962814, + 0.048938676714897156, + 0.041621990501880646, + 0.12340106070041656 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06319142132997513 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-haired character named Qin Mo wearing a dark-colored wide-sleeved silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing in front of an ancient dark brown clay medicine cauldron with thick white steam rising from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a long-handled wooden spoon and stirring the contents of the cauldron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a verdant bamboo forest with dappled sunlight beams penetrating through the steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of an antique silk painting featuring ink-like black, white, and blue tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006741872988641262 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006742000579834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006741872988641262, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006741872988641262, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07719459384679794, + 0.05008595436811447, + 0.046144284307956696, + 0.3333366811275482, + 0.19393040239810944, + 0.04870406165719032, + 0.011112086474895477, + 0.042357780039310455, + 0.04040171951055527, + 0.156732439994812 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006741872988641262 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-haired character named Qin Mo wearing a dark-colored wide-sleeved silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing in front of an ancient dark brown clay medicine cauldron with thick white steam rising from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a long-handled wooden spoon and stirring the contents of the cauldron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a verdant bamboo forest with dappled sunlight beams penetrating through the steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of an antique silk painting featuring ink-like black, white, and blue tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002604007720947 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.69502592086792 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002604007720947, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002604007720947, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13382339477539062, + 0.07934819906949997, + 0.060930684208869934, + 0.07531656324863434, + 0.15910419821739197, + 0.14329811930656433, + 0.06149209663271904, + 0.06907062977552414, + 0.08559639006853104, + 0.13201969861984253 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002604007720947 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-haired character named Qin Mo wearing a dark-colored wide-sleeved silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing in front of an ancient dark brown clay medicine cauldron with thick white steam rising from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a long-handled wooden spoon and stirring the contents of the cauldron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a verdant bamboo forest with dappled sunlight beams penetrating through the steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of an antique silk painting featuring ink-like black, white, and blue tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005249525420367718 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255249500274658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005249525420367718, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005249525420367718, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2472202628850937, + 0.036620158702135086, + 0.03254633769392967, + 0.08892275393009186, + 0.14270418882369995, + 0.04425952211022377, + 0.10197915136814117, + 0.2165607213973999, + 0.03952271491289139, + 0.04966411367058754 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005249525420367718 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-haired character named Qin Mo wearing a dark-colored wide-sleeved silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing in front of an ancient dark brown clay medicine cauldron with thick white steam rising from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a long-handled wooden spoon and stirring the contents of the cauldron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a verdant bamboo forest with dappled sunlight beams penetrating through the steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of an antique silk painting featuring ink-like black, white, and blue tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014192009344696999 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2641921043396 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014192009344696999, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014192009344696999, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3303832411766052, + 0.07139616459608078, + 0.08441362529993057, + 0.05834878981113434, + 0.10996712744235992, + 0.12049306184053421, + 0.036921508610248566, + 0.05099508911371231, + 0.04168456420302391, + 0.09539678692817688 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014192009344696999 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a wide, low-angle, still shot, a white-haired Qin Mo (a musical instrument) stands in a tranquil bamboo forest. Clad in a wide-sleeved, dark-colored silk robe, his snow-white hair gently swaying in the breeze and steam, he stands with grace and poise before an ancient clay medicine cauldron. The cauldron is dark brown, its surface mottled with age. Thick white steam rises from its mouth, obscuring his features in a hazy, mysterious silhouette. Steady in one hand, he gently stirs a long-handled wooden spoon within the cauldron, his movements measured and ritualistic. In the background, cascading, verdant bamboo leaves rise. Soft rays of sunlight penetrate the gaps in the forest, casting dappled beams of light through the lingering steam, adding depth and layering to the scene. The entire painting presents the delicate texture and elegant tones of antique silk painting, with ink-like black, white and blue as the main colors, creating a quiet, focused and mysterious atmosphere full of oriental classical aesthetics.", + "seed": 23853, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_11/index_7198_seed_23853_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02343723983503878, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02343723983503878, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02343723983503878, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-haired character named Qin Mo wearing a dark-colored wide-sleeved silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing in front of an ancient dark brown clay medicine cauldron with thick white steam rising from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a long-handled wooden spoon and stirring the contents of the cauldron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a verdant bamboo forest with dappled sunlight beams penetrating through the steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of an antique silk painting featuring ink-like black, white, and blue tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05682887136936188 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9318289756774902 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05682887136936188, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05682887136936188, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19901292026042938, + 0.03919726237654686, + 0.03736298158764839, + 0.026943178847432137, + 0.031523652374744415, + 0.04118789732456207, + 0.280402809381485, + 0.2632334530353546, + 0.033056747168302536, + 0.048079028725624084 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05682887136936188 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-haired character named Qin Mo wearing a dark-colored wide-sleeved silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing in front of an ancient dark brown clay medicine cauldron with thick white steam rising from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a long-handled wooden spoon and stirring the contents of the cauldron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a verdant bamboo forest with dappled sunlight beams penetrating through the steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of an antique silk painting featuring ink-like black, white, and blue tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028208012226969004 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.87782096862793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028208012226969004, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028208012226969004, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06110425665974617, + 0.03968222066760063, + 0.02778083272278309, + 0.025425495579838753, + 0.05159822106361389, + 0.022058535367250443, + 0.07449425756931305, + 0.6283270716667175, + 0.0300260242074728, + 0.03950303792953491 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028208012226969004 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-haired character named Qin Mo wearing a dark-colored wide-sleeved silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing in front of an ancient dark brown clay medicine cauldron with thick white steam rising from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a long-handled wooden spoon and stirring the contents of the cauldron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a verdant bamboo forest with dappled sunlight beams penetrating through the steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of an antique silk painting featuring ink-like black, white, and blue tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306705296039581 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.16806697845459 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306705296039581, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306705296039581, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1706780046224594, + 0.1415398269891739, + 0.09432142972946167, + 0.08746325969696045, + 0.0652608796954155, + 0.04371034353971481, + 0.12595099210739136, + 0.12998755276203156, + 0.08104464411735535, + 0.06004306301474571 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306705296039581 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-haired character named Qin Mo wearing a dark-colored wide-sleeved silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing in front of an ancient dark brown clay medicine cauldron with thick white steam rising from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a long-handled wooden spoon and stirring the contents of the cauldron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a verdant bamboo forest with dappled sunlight beams penetrating through the steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of an antique silk painting featuring ink-like black, white, and blue tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001937180757522583 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251937389373779 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001937180757522583, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001937180757522583, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12481465190649033, + 0.030930345878005028, + 0.01704385317862034, + 0.033112671226263046, + 0.033383093774318695, + 0.041675809770822525, + 0.32440146803855896, + 0.2758484482765198, + 0.08318499475717545, + 0.035604629665613174 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001937180757522583 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-haired character named Qin Mo wearing a dark-colored wide-sleeved silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing in front of an ancient dark brown clay medicine cauldron with thick white steam rising from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a long-handled wooden spoon and stirring the contents of the cauldron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a verdant bamboo forest with dappled sunlight beams penetrating through the steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of an antique silk painting featuring ink-like black, white, and blue tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012532292865216732 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875322341918945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012532292865216732, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012532292865216732, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16729754209518433, + 0.029251327738165855, + 0.028538698330521584, + 0.03692110627889633, + 0.01399223878979683, + 0.03750630468130112, + 0.16748738288879395, + 0.44057902693748474, + 0.04618625342845917, + 0.0322401188313961 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012532292865216732 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a wide, low-angle, still shot, a white-haired Qin Mo (a musical instrument) stands in a tranquil bamboo forest. Clad in a wide-sleeved, dark-colored silk robe, his snow-white hair gently swaying in the breeze and steam, he stands with grace and poise before an ancient clay medicine cauldron. The cauldron is dark brown, its surface mottled with age. Thick white steam rises from its mouth, obscuring his features in a hazy, mysterious silhouette. Steady in one hand, he gently stirs a long-handled wooden spoon within the cauldron, his movements measured and ritualistic. In the background, cascading, verdant bamboo leaves rise. Soft rays of sunlight penetrate the gaps in the forest, casting dappled beams of light through the lingering steam, adding depth and layering to the scene. The entire painting presents the delicate texture and elegant tones of antique silk painting, with ink-like black, white and blue as the main colors, creating a quiet, focused and mysterious atmosphere full of oriental classical aesthetics.", + "seed": 23854, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_11/index_7198_seed_23854_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03979761591181159, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03979761591181159, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.824999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03979761591181159, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-haired character named Qin Mo wearing a dark-colored wide-sleeved silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing in front of an ancient dark brown clay medicine cauldron with thick white steam rising from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a long-handled wooden spoon and stirring the contents of the cauldron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a verdant bamboo forest with dappled sunlight beams penetrating through the steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of an antique silk painting featuring ink-like black, white, and blue tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12846311926841736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.12846302986145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12846311926841736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12846311926841736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17411932349205017, + 0.10517428815364838, + 0.10610557347536087, + 0.0899532362818718, + 0.08953473716974258, + 0.08935546875, + 0.06120464950799942, + 0.12883515655994415, + 0.07441508769989014, + 0.08130252361297607 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12846311926841736 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-haired character named Qin Mo wearing a dark-colored wide-sleeved silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing in front of an ancient dark brown clay medicine cauldron with thick white steam rising from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a long-handled wooden spoon and stirring the contents of the cauldron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a verdant bamboo forest with dappled sunlight beams penetrating through the steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of an antique silk painting featuring ink-like black, white, and blue tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016078339889645576 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141078472137451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016078339889645576, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016078339889645576, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1288873702287674, + 0.15682277083396912, + 0.12163010239601135, + 0.054578933864831924, + 0.1291445940732956, + 0.13729144632816315, + 0.04424205794930458, + 0.0810588002204895, + 0.08048145473003387, + 0.06586247682571411 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016078339889645576 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-haired character named Qin Mo wearing a dark-colored wide-sleeved silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing in front of an ancient dark brown clay medicine cauldron with thick white steam rising from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a long-handled wooden spoon and stirring the contents of the cauldron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a verdant bamboo forest with dappled sunlight beams penetrating through the steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of an antique silk painting featuring ink-like black, white, and blue tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811760991811752 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881176471710205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811760991811752, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811760991811752, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08210042119026184, + 0.10371511429548264, + 0.12116745859384537, + 0.0798908919095993, + 0.08946111053228378, + 0.09902264922857285, + 0.05144137516617775, + 0.21410851180553436, + 0.09568896144628525, + 0.06340346485376358 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811760991811752 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-haired character named Qin Mo wearing a dark-colored wide-sleeved silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing in front of an ancient dark brown clay medicine cauldron with thick white steam rising from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a long-handled wooden spoon and stirring the contents of the cauldron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a verdant bamboo forest with dappled sunlight beams penetrating through the steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of an antique silk painting featuring ink-like black, white, and blue tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005254269111901522 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.25525426864624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005254269111901522, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005254269111901522, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1906776875257492, + 0.14269869029521942, + 0.06313540041446686, + 0.03635187819600105, + 0.14905114471912384, + 0.08415093272924423, + 0.04889337345957756, + 0.09242034703493118, + 0.07229763269424438, + 0.12032295763492584 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005254269111901522 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-haired character named Qin Mo wearing a dark-colored wide-sleeved silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing in front of an ancient dark brown clay medicine cauldron with thick white steam rising from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a long-handled wooden spoon and stirring the contents of the cauldron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a verdant bamboo forest with dappled sunlight beams penetrating through the steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of an antique silk painting featuring ink-like black, white, and blue tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011074741370975971 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511074542999268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011074741370975971, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011074741370975971, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22920168936252594, + 0.14535604417324066, + 0.05298609659075737, + 0.0691014751791954, + 0.06475825607776642, + 0.05347954109311104, + 0.03285108134150505, + 0.1140170618891716, + 0.15316788852214813, + 0.08508087694644928 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011074741370975971 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a wide, low-angle, still shot, a white-haired Qin Mo (a musical instrument) stands in a tranquil bamboo forest. Clad in a wide-sleeved, dark-colored silk robe, his snow-white hair gently swaying in the breeze and steam, he stands with grace and poise before an ancient clay medicine cauldron. The cauldron is dark brown, its surface mottled with age. Thick white steam rises from its mouth, obscuring his features in a hazy, mysterious silhouette. Steady in one hand, he gently stirs a long-handled wooden spoon within the cauldron, his movements measured and ritualistic. In the background, cascading, verdant bamboo leaves rise. Soft rays of sunlight penetrate the gaps in the forest, casting dappled beams of light through the lingering steam, adding depth and layering to the scene. The entire painting presents the delicate texture and elegant tones of antique silk painting, with ink-like black, white and blue as the main colors, creating a quiet, focused and mysterious atmosphere full of oriental classical aesthetics.", + "seed": 23855, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_11/index_7198_seed_23855_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03672737069427967, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03672737069427967, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03672737069427967, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-haired character named Qin Mo wearing a dark-colored wide-sleeved silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing in front of an ancient dark brown clay medicine cauldron with thick white steam rising from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a long-handled wooden spoon and stirring the contents of the cauldron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a verdant bamboo forest with dappled sunlight beams penetrating through the steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of an antique silk painting featuring ink-like black, white, and blue tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10268852114677429 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3526885509490967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10268852114677429, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10268852114677429, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27532774209976196, + 0.05699116736650467, + 0.075193390250206, + 0.06007611006498337, + 0.043446194380521774, + 0.0900835320353508, + 0.12570767104625702, + 0.089340940117836, + 0.09939248859882355, + 0.08444075286388397 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10268852114677429 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-haired character named Qin Mo wearing a dark-colored wide-sleeved silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing in front of an ancient dark brown clay medicine cauldron with thick white steam rising from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a long-handled wooden spoon and stirring the contents of the cauldron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a verdant bamboo forest with dappled sunlight beams penetrating through the steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of an antique silk painting featuring ink-like black, white, and blue tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005956043489277363 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130956172943115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005956043489277363, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005956043489277363, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3320567011833191, + 0.038547616451978683, + 0.05767418444156647, + 0.02716677635908127, + 0.01819762960076332, + 0.1014300212264061, + 0.023510552942752838, + 0.02204977162182331, + 0.19202099740505219, + 0.1873456984758377 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005956043489277363 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-haired character named Qin Mo wearing a dark-colored wide-sleeved silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing in front of an ancient dark brown clay medicine cauldron with thick white steam rising from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a long-handled wooden spoon and stirring the contents of the cauldron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a verdant bamboo forest with dappled sunlight beams penetrating through the steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of an antique silk painting featuring ink-like black, white, and blue tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810510411858559 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288105010986328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810510411858559, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810510411858559, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3080366551876068, + 0.038256384432315826, + 0.034656912088394165, + 0.041645124554634094, + 0.020616440102458, + 0.09990710765123367, + 0.08022529631853104, + 0.06462384015321732, + 0.23394350707530975, + 0.07808869332075119 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810510411858559 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-haired character named Qin Mo wearing a dark-colored wide-sleeved silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing in front of an ancient dark brown clay medicine cauldron with thick white steam rising from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a long-handled wooden spoon and stirring the contents of the cauldron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a verdant bamboo forest with dappled sunlight beams penetrating through the steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of an antique silk painting featuring ink-like black, white, and blue tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003191736526787281 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753191947937012 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003191736526787281, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003191736526787281, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11679248511791229, + 0.04830404743552208, + 0.059569794684648514, + 0.028556494042277336, + 0.018450619652867317, + 0.11083196848630905, + 0.04464714601635933, + 0.04384087026119232, + 0.4404606223106384, + 0.08854586631059647 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003191736526787281 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a white-haired character named Qin Mo wearing a dark-colored wide-sleeved silk robe?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character standing in front of an ancient dark brown clay medicine cauldron with thick white steam rising from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character holding a long-handled wooden spoon and stirring the contents of the cauldron?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background composed of a verdant bamboo forest with dappled sunlight beams penetrating through the steam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of an antique silk painting featuring ink-like black, white, and blue tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369544818997383 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086954593658447 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369544818997383, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369544818997383, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23270347714424133, + 0.05085102841258049, + 0.08460017293691635, + 0.0652153491973877, + 0.050801586359739304, + 0.08945212513208389, + 0.055483557283878326, + 0.07966084778308868, + 0.14276747405529022, + 0.1484643816947937 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369544818997383 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_12/index_tensor([7740, 7740])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_12/index_tensor([7740, 7740])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6b3f2b51f6daab1418256a345d02b73fdc518c71 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_12/index_tensor([7740, 7740])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow-motion tracking shot, filmed from an extremely low angle, follows a snow-white Arctic fox as it lowers itself completely to the ground, stalking ankle-deep in deep snow. The fox's shaggy, flawless white fur, each hair distinct and detailed in the soft, diffuse light of an overcast winter sky, its watchful amber eyes fixed intently on a target off-screen, a gaze of calm and deadly concentration. It moves forward with a near-immobile pace, carefully lifting each limb and then silently treading through the soft, powdery snow, making almost no sound save for the brush of its bushy, black-tipped tail. The surrounding birch forest background is transformed into a hazy, creamy bokeh composed of vertical lines and soft light spots due to the extremely shallow depth of field effect. The outlines of the tree trunks are blurred, and only the sharp form of the fox in the foreground and the shimmering light on the snow are clearly visible. The entire picture is shrouded in an extreme tranquility and a tense atmosphere that is ready to explode, creating an atmosphere that is both beautiful and full of primitive vitality.", + "seed": 4042, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_12/index_7740_seed_4042_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.2577735947445035, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2577735947445035, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.449999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2577735947445035, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a snow-white Arctic fox with shaggy white fur and black-tipped tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox moving slowly with a near-immobile pace, carefully lifting each limb?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a hazy birch forest with vertical lines and soft light spots due to shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's gaze fixed intently forward with watchful amber eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0744009017944336 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4494008421897888 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0744009017944336, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.6250000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0744009017944336, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1907871514558792, + 0.11487408727407455, + 0.08455836027860641, + 0.07927168905735016, + 0.1128590926527977, + 0.09158845245838165, + 0.10738357901573181, + 0.08338082581758499, + 0.06585662811994553, + 0.06944019347429276 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0744009017944336 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a snow-white Arctic fox with shaggy white fur and black-tipped tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox moving slowly with a near-immobile pace, carefully lifting each limb?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a hazy birch forest with vertical lines and soft light spots due to shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's gaze fixed intently forward with watchful amber eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307710379362106 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168076992034912 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307710379362106, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307710379362106, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0730271190404892, + 0.05345332995057106, + 0.1389128565788269, + 0.22354476153850555, + 0.12584640085697174, + 0.04704326391220093, + 0.13730022311210632, + 0.06707458943128586, + 0.06942884624004364, + 0.0643685832619667 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307710379362106 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a snow-white Arctic fox with shaggy white fur and black-tipped tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox moving slowly with a near-immobile pace, carefully lifting each limb?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a hazy birch forest with vertical lines and soft light spots due to shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's gaze fixed intently forward with watchful amber eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865852743387222 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048658609390259 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865852743387222, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865852743387222, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05961758270859718, + 0.03893928602337837, + 0.05861871317028999, + 0.09502784162759781, + 0.07656016200780869, + 0.10046281665563583, + 0.2795500159263611, + 0.14255785942077637, + 0.07804008573293686, + 0.0706256777048111 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865852743387222 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a snow-white Arctic fox with shaggy white fur and black-tipped tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox moving slowly with a near-immobile pace, carefully lifting each limb?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a hazy birch forest with vertical lines and soft light spots due to shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's gaze fixed intently forward with watchful amber eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978152547031641 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634781360626221 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978152547031641, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978152547031641, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2661966383457184, + 0.12867675721645355, + 0.06180239096283913, + 0.04069242253899574, + 0.0813840925693512, + 0.10372504591941833, + 0.21422554552555084, + 0.028507372364401817, + 0.03488270193338394, + 0.03990699723362923 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978152547031641 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a snow-white Arctic fox with shaggy white fur and black-tipped tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox moving slowly with a near-immobile pace, carefully lifting each limb?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a hazy birch forest with vertical lines and soft light spots due to shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's gaze fixed intently forward with watchful amber eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1129499152302742 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237949848175049 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1129499152302742, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1129499152302742, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11029665917158127, + 0.0694994330406189, + 0.08570729196071625, + 0.1905340999364853, + 0.15780892968177795, + 0.13535411655902863, + 0.08576836436986923, + 0.059700820595026016, + 0.0418265238404274, + 0.0635037049651146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1129499152302742 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion tracking shot, filmed from an extremely low angle, follows a snow-white Arctic fox as it lowers itself completely to the ground, stalking ankle-deep in deep snow. The fox's shaggy, flawless white fur, each hair distinct and detailed in the soft, diffuse light of an overcast winter sky, its watchful amber eyes fixed intently on a target off-screen, a gaze of calm and deadly concentration. It moves forward with a near-immobile pace, carefully lifting each limb and then silently treading through the soft, powdery snow, making almost no sound save for the brush of its bushy, black-tipped tail. The surrounding birch forest background is transformed into a hazy, creamy bokeh composed of vertical lines and soft light spots due to the extremely shallow depth of field effect. The outlines of the tree trunks are blurred, and only the sharp form of the fox in the foreground and the shimmering light on the snow are clearly visible. The entire picture is shrouded in an extreme tranquility and a tense atmosphere that is ready to explode, creating an atmosphere that is both beautiful and full of primitive vitality.", + "seed": 4043, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_12/index_7740_seed_4043_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.39786798786371946, + "vlm_logprob": -0.39786798786371946, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.924999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.39786798786371946, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a snow-white Arctic fox with shaggy white fur and black-tipped tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox moving slowly with a near-immobile pace, carefully lifting each limb?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a hazy birch forest with vertical lines and soft light spots due to shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's gaze fixed intently forward with watchful amber eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6142535209655762 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.23925349116325378 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.6142535209655762, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.6142535209655762, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.043345220386981964, + 0.20077811181545258, + 0.09248099476099014, + 0.2515375018119812, + 0.027221795171499252, + 0.06555848568677902, + 0.21515408158302307, + 0.03675954416394234, + 0.026147088035941124, + 0.041017208248376846 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.6142535209655762 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a snow-white Arctic fox with shaggy white fur and black-tipped tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox moving slowly with a near-immobile pace, carefully lifting each limb?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a hazy birch forest with vertical lines and soft light spots due to shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's gaze fixed intently forward with watchful amber eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062072597444057465 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812072515487671 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062072597444057465, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062072597444057465, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.021323312073946, + 0.34339603781700134, + 0.32871708273887634, + 0.03347842022776604, + 0.04129968211054802, + 0.09035792201757431, + 0.08156538009643555, + 0.018396073952317238, + 0.009182222187519073, + 0.03228382021188736 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062072597444057465 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a snow-white Arctic fox with shaggy white fur and black-tipped tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox moving slowly with a near-immobile pace, carefully lifting each limb?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a hazy birch forest with vertical lines and soft light spots due to shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's gaze fixed intently forward with watchful amber eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14283621311187744 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017836093902588 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14283621311187744, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14283621311187744, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.029045552015304565, + 0.18558940291404724, + 0.20106402039527893, + 0.04774206504225731, + 0.05535264313220978, + 0.028481189161539078, + 0.252017080783844, + 0.041924431920051575, + 0.07111480832099915, + 0.08766880631446838 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14283621311187744 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a snow-white Arctic fox with shaggy white fur and black-tipped tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox moving slowly with a near-immobile pace, carefully lifting each limb?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a hazy birch forest with vertical lines and soft light spots due to shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's gaze fixed intently forward with watchful amber eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009783296845853329 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347832679748535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009783296845853329, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009783296845853329, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09169160574674606, + 0.30554237961769104, + 0.21378880739212036, + 0.16397427022457123, + 0.031359631568193436, + 0.037882354110479355, + 0.09049158543348312, + 0.025545869022607803, + 0.011648574844002724, + 0.028074968606233597 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009783296845853329 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a snow-white Arctic fox with shaggy white fur and black-tipped tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox moving slowly with a near-immobile pace, carefully lifting each limb?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a hazy birch forest with vertical lines and soft light spots due to shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's gaze fixed intently forward with watchful amber eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603943109512329 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910394310951233 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603943109512329, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603943109512329, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.025772003456950188, + 0.06718025356531143, + 0.1433316469192505, + 0.10797112435102463, + 0.15374085307121277, + 0.1072627529501915, + 0.295729398727417, + 0.02364419400691986, + 0.04800598323345184, + 0.027361853048205376 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603943109512329 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion tracking shot, filmed from an extremely low angle, follows a snow-white Arctic fox as it lowers itself completely to the ground, stalking ankle-deep in deep snow. The fox's shaggy, flawless white fur, each hair distinct and detailed in the soft, diffuse light of an overcast winter sky, its watchful amber eyes fixed intently on a target off-screen, a gaze of calm and deadly concentration. It moves forward with a near-immobile pace, carefully lifting each limb and then silently treading through the soft, powdery snow, making almost no sound save for the brush of its bushy, black-tipped tail. The surrounding birch forest background is transformed into a hazy, creamy bokeh composed of vertical lines and soft light spots due to the extremely shallow depth of field effect. The outlines of the tree trunks are blurred, and only the sharp form of the fox in the foreground and the shimmering light on the snow are clearly visible. The entire picture is shrouded in an extreme tranquility and a tense atmosphere that is ready to explode, creating an atmosphere that is both beautiful and full of primitive vitality.", + "seed": 4044, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_12/index_7740_seed_4044_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.22175033949315548, + "vlm_logprob": -0.22175033949315548, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.22175033949315548, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a snow-white Arctic fox with shaggy white fur and black-tipped tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox moving slowly with a near-immobile pace, carefully lifting each limb?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a hazy birch forest with vertical lines and soft light spots due to shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's gaze fixed intently forward with watchful amber eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8565236330032349 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6065236330032349 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8565236330032349, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8565236330032349, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20630837976932526, + 0.055814921855926514, + 0.06839532405138016, + 0.08685068786144257, + 0.06006000190973282, + 0.02506265416741371, + 0.09375333786010742, + 0.044485773891210556, + 0.018496446311473846, + 0.34077244997024536 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8565236330032349 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a snow-white Arctic fox with shaggy white fur and black-tipped tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox moving slowly with a near-immobile pace, carefully lifting each limb?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a hazy birch forest with vertical lines and soft light spots due to shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's gaze fixed intently forward with watchful amber eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004082202911377 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695040702819824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004082202911377, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004082202911377, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15509474277496338, + 0.07667365670204163, + 0.1635473519563675, + 0.1352146863937378, + 0.12887385487556458, + 0.04053806513547897, + 0.08795379847288132, + 0.0806267037987709, + 0.03773760050535202, + 0.09373953938484192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004082202911377 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a snow-white Arctic fox with shaggy white fur and black-tipped tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox moving slowly with a near-immobile pace, carefully lifting each limb?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a hazy birch forest with vertical lines and soft light spots due to shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's gaze fixed intently forward with watchful amber eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08904502540826797 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640450477600098 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08904502540826797, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08904502540826797, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17256900668144226, + 0.06619841605424881, + 0.08658944815397263, + 0.19522283971309662, + 0.04804091900587082, + 0.06465151160955429, + 0.0434042327105999, + 0.04085225239396095, + 0.03136467561125755, + 0.2511068284511566 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08904502540826797 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a snow-white Arctic fox with shaggy white fur and black-tipped tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox moving slowly with a near-immobile pace, carefully lifting each limb?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a hazy birch forest with vertical lines and soft light spots due to shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's gaze fixed intently forward with watchful amber eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004097519442439079 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5040974617004395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004097519442439079, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004097519442439079, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22254306077957153, + 0.06936878710985184, + 0.060308802872896194, + 0.04550845921039581, + 0.13164088129997253, + 0.0557992085814476, + 0.05337344855070114, + 0.03161880373954773, + 0.017584839835762978, + 0.3122537136077881 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004097519442439079 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a snow-white Arctic fox with shaggy white fur and black-tipped tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox moving slowly with a near-immobile pace, carefully lifting each limb?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a hazy birch forest with vertical lines and soft light spots due to shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's gaze fixed intently forward with watchful amber eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08904469758272171 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640448093414307 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08904469758272171, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08904469758272171, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25271913409233093, + 0.10355433821678162, + 0.06799586862325668, + 0.03742722049355507, + 0.05945403873920441, + 0.032289355993270874, + 0.09044576436281204, + 0.05411972105503082, + 0.04076749086380005, + 0.26122695207595825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08904469758272171 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow-motion tracking shot, filmed from an extremely low angle, follows a snow-white Arctic fox as it lowers itself completely to the ground, stalking ankle-deep in deep snow. The fox's shaggy, flawless white fur, each hair distinct and detailed in the soft, diffuse light of an overcast winter sky, its watchful amber eyes fixed intently on a target off-screen, a gaze of calm and deadly concentration. It moves forward with a near-immobile pace, carefully lifting each limb and then silently treading through the soft, powdery snow, making almost no sound save for the brush of its bushy, black-tipped tail. The surrounding birch forest background is transformed into a hazy, creamy bokeh composed of vertical lines and soft light spots due to the extremely shallow depth of field effect. The outlines of the tree trunks are blurred, and only the sharp form of the fox in the foreground and the shimmering light on the snow are clearly visible. The entire picture is shrouded in an extreme tranquility and a tense atmosphere that is ready to explode, creating an atmosphere that is both beautiful and full of primitive vitality.", + "seed": 4045, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_12/index_7740_seed_4045_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2248139380477369, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2248139380477369, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2248139380477369, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a snow-white Arctic fox with shaggy white fur and black-tipped tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox moving slowly with a near-immobile pace, carefully lifting each limb?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a hazy birch forest with vertical lines and soft light spots due to shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's gaze fixed intently forward with watchful amber eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9204095602035522 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5454095602035522 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9204095602035522, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9204095602035522, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23930689692497253, + 0.08067459613084793, + 0.13378596305847168, + 0.10335388779640198, + 0.15280471742153168, + 0.0817510262131691, + 0.038412515074014664, + 0.05056946352124214, + 0.038582462817430496, + 0.08075840771198273 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9204095602035522 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a snow-white Arctic fox with shaggy white fur and black-tipped tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox moving slowly with a near-immobile pace, carefully lifting each limb?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a hazy birch forest with vertical lines and soft light spots due to shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's gaze fixed intently forward with watchful amber eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811566159129143 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881157398223877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811566159129143, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811566159129143, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17535120248794556, + 0.07232339680194855, + 0.23442742228507996, + 0.04778295010328293, + 0.030731843784451485, + 0.07315155118703842, + 0.051561929285526276, + 0.12875917553901672, + 0.031544677913188934, + 0.15436585247516632 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811566159129143 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a snow-white Arctic fox with shaggy white fur and black-tipped tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox moving slowly with a near-immobile pace, carefully lifting each limb?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a hazy birch forest with vertical lines and soft light spots due to shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's gaze fixed intently forward with watchful amber eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062051646411418915 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.81205153465271 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062051646411418915, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062051646411418915, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0958869531750679, + 0.10238572210073471, + 0.08782835304737091, + 0.11182696372270584, + 0.2096123993396759, + 0.06649955362081528, + 0.06946689635515213, + 0.12702301144599915, + 0.06473851203918457, + 0.06473158299922943 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062051646411418915 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a snow-white Arctic fox with shaggy white fur and black-tipped tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox moving slowly with a near-immobile pace, carefully lifting each limb?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a hazy birch forest with vertical lines and soft light spots due to shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's gaze fixed intently forward with watchful amber eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031898352317512035 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753190040588379 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031898352317512035, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031898352317512035, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09503135830163956, + 0.17438705265522003, + 0.2751467823982239, + 0.04579218849539757, + 0.06583376228809357, + 0.167207732796669, + 0.03549686074256897, + 0.04653966426849365, + 0.038086723536252975, + 0.05647791549563408 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031898352317512035 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot filmed from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a snow-white Arctic fox with shaggy white fur and black-tipped tail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the fox moving slowly with a near-immobile pace, carefully lifting each limb?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a hazy birch forest with vertical lines and soft light spots due to shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the fox's gaze fixed intently forward with watchful amber eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10030298680067062 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503029346466064 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10030298680067062, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10030298680067062, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0992342159152031, + 0.0720585510134697, + 0.2583602964878082, + 0.1504228264093399, + 0.021494386717677116, + 0.08187966048717499, + 0.09044115245342255, + 0.08441910147666931, + 0.03640009090304375, + 0.1052897572517395 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10030298680067062 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_13/index_tensor([330, 330])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_13/index_tensor([330, 330])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a1660e0d1b64d93596a9232a75a571e6a09855bc --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_13/index_tensor([330, 330])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot follows a young swordsman as he strides forth from the depths of a bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist. His features are delicate and resolute, his long, dark hair held back by a simple white headband. His gaze is piercing and focused. He wears a lightweight, well-tailored white Hanfu robe, and at his waist hangs a longsword in a pristine dark wooden sheath, a striking contrast to the white of his garments. As he advances with steady, powerful force, his wide cuffs and hem rustle in the breeze, rhythmically fluttering and radiating an unstoppable aura. Surrounding him is a towering sea of emerald green bamboo, shrouded in a veil of morning mist, its leaves shimmering with glistening dewdrops. The rising sun's rays filter through the thin mist and through the gaps between the bamboo leaves, casting dappled, soft beams of light, creating ever-shifting shadows on his pristine white robe and the damp, leaf-studded path beneath his feet. The entire picture is dominated by cool emerald green and pure white, creating a cinematic atmosphere that is both tranquil and mysterious, yet contains a powerful inner strength.", + "seed": 8234, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_13/index_330_seed_8234_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05819181576371193, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05819181576371193, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05819181576371193, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young swordsman wearing a white Hanfu robe with a white headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a longsword in a dark wooden sheath visible hanging at the swordsman's waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist with dappled sunlight filtering through?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman advance forward with steady, powerful strides while his robe cuffs and hem flutter in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2034887820482254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.828488826751709 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2034887820482254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2034887820482254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.007582498248666525, + 0.9572076797485352, + 0.003812988754361868, + 0.002067806664854288, + 0.006636671256273985, + 0.005953914951533079, + 0.003887146944180131, + 0.0016771993832662702, + 0.009198742918670177, + 0.001975328428670764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2034887820482254 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young swordsman wearing a white Hanfu robe with a white headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a longsword in a dark wooden sheath visible hanging at the swordsman's waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist with dappled sunlight filtering through?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman advance forward with steady, powerful strides while his robe cuffs and hem flutter in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02331509441137314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773315191268921 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02331509441137314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02331509441137314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.015851248055696487, + 0.8487600088119507, + 0.008306239731609821, + 0.006414326839148998, + 0.027251729741692543, + 0.01584010198712349, + 0.028667211532592773, + 0.007630217354744673, + 0.011969906277954578, + 0.02930907905101776 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02331509441137314 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young swordsman wearing a white Hanfu robe with a white headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a longsword in a dark wooden sheath visible hanging at the swordsman's waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist with dappled sunlight filtering through?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman advance forward with steady, powerful strides while his robe cuffs and hem flutter in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029800057411193848 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297999382019043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029800057411193848, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029800057411193848, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07498270273208618, + 0.4997049570083618, + 0.025541020557284355, + 0.018361616879701614, + 0.04766649752855301, + 0.14737330377101898, + 0.06067444756627083, + 0.04016154259443283, + 0.06033087149262428, + 0.025203043594956398 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029800057411193848 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young swordsman wearing a white Hanfu robe with a white headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a longsword in a dark wooden sheath visible hanging at the swordsman's waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist with dappled sunlight filtering through?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman advance forward with steady, powerful strides while his robe cuffs and hem flutter in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107603870332241 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511075973510742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107603870332241, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107603870332241, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04658397287130356, + 0.8297607898712158, + 0.019447388127446175, + 0.009896432049572468, + 0.011716876178979874, + 0.02259734645485878, + 0.02119281142950058, + 0.01602962240576744, + 0.015213625505566597, + 0.007561080623418093 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107603870332241 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young swordsman wearing a white Hanfu robe with a white headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a longsword in a dark wooden sheath visible hanging at the swordsman's waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist with dappled sunlight filtering through?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman advance forward with steady, powerful strides while his robe cuffs and hem flutter in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023279106244444847 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732791900634766 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023279106244444847, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023279106244444847, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04612515866756439, + 0.2925381064414978, + 0.029066046699881554, + 0.021720482036471367, + 0.3287365734577179, + 0.047158993780612946, + 0.037633851170539856, + 0.04991726577281952, + 0.1293511539697647, + 0.0177523922175169 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023279106244444847 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot follows a young swordsman as he strides forth from the depths of a bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist. His features are delicate and resolute, his long, dark hair held back by a simple white headband. His gaze is piercing and focused. He wears a lightweight, well-tailored white Hanfu robe, and at his waist hangs a longsword in a pristine dark wooden sheath, a striking contrast to the white of his garments. As he advances with steady, powerful force, his wide cuffs and hem rustle in the breeze, rhythmically fluttering and radiating an unstoppable aura. Surrounding him is a towering sea of emerald green bamboo, shrouded in a veil of morning mist, its leaves shimmering with glistening dewdrops. The rising sun's rays filter through the thin mist and through the gaps between the bamboo leaves, casting dappled, soft beams of light, creating ever-shifting shadows on his pristine white robe and the damp, leaf-studded path beneath his feet. The entire picture is dominated by cool emerald green and pure white, creating a cinematic atmosphere that is both tranquil and mysterious, yet contains a powerful inner strength.", + "seed": 8235, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_13/index_330_seed_8235_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.043845375254750255, + "vlm_logprob": -0.043845375254750255, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.043845375254750255, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young swordsman wearing a white Hanfu robe with a white headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a longsword in a dark wooden sheath visible hanging at the swordsman's waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist with dappled sunlight filtering through?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman advance forward with steady, powerful strides while his robe cuffs and hem flutter in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14072518050670624 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2657251358032227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14072518050670624, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14072518050670624, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.135498046875, + 0.048184286803007126, + 0.25463250279426575, + 0.15291611850261688, + 0.02213408425450325, + 0.10747963935136795, + 0.1618582308292389, + 0.03739631175994873, + 0.039596185088157654, + 0.04030461609363556 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14072518050670624 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young swordsman wearing a white Hanfu robe with a white headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a longsword in a dark wooden sheath visible hanging at the swordsman's waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist with dappled sunlight filtering through?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman advance forward with steady, powerful strides while his robe cuffs and hem flutter in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026376616209745407 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651376724243164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026376616209745407, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026376616209745407, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3307097852230072, + 0.054400552064180374, + 0.1599850207567215, + 0.05736634507775307, + 0.015953687950968742, + 0.10655118525028229, + 0.037242211401462555, + 0.03785804286599159, + 0.15483056008815765, + 0.04510252922773361 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026376616209745407 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young swordsman wearing a white Hanfu robe with a white headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a longsword in a dark wooden sheath visible hanging at the swordsman's waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist with dappled sunlight filtering through?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman advance forward with steady, powerful strides while his robe cuffs and hem flutter in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980630472302437 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.52980637550354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980630472302437, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980630472302437, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2799575924873352, + 0.060278210788965225, + 0.29268890619277954, + 0.06155453994870186, + 0.028446389362215996, + 0.06518334150314331, + 0.04057806730270386, + 0.03381834924221039, + 0.08870980143547058, + 0.048784736543893814 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980630472302437 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young swordsman wearing a white Hanfu robe with a white headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a longsword in a dark wooden sheath visible hanging at the swordsman's waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist with dappled sunlight filtering through?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman advance forward with steady, powerful strides while his robe cuffs and hem flutter in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978624727576971 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634786128997803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978624727576971, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978624727576971, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25081348419189453, + 0.0326271653175354, + 0.32110515236854553, + 0.07975494116544724, + 0.010159376077353954, + 0.09186005592346191, + 0.10165764391422272, + 0.0248243510723114, + 0.06251196563243866, + 0.024685844779014587 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978624727576971 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young swordsman wearing a white Hanfu robe with a white headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a longsword in a dark wooden sheath visible hanging at the swordsman's waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist with dappled sunlight filtering through?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman advance forward with steady, powerful strides while his robe cuffs and hem flutter in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012532527558505535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387532711029053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012532527558505535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012532527558505535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09501662850379944, + 0.12265666574239731, + 0.09425460547208786, + 0.2832971513271332, + 0.017941899597644806, + 0.08474025130271912, + 0.08703034371137619, + 0.058809857815504074, + 0.06702464073896408, + 0.08922795206308365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012532527558505535 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot follows a young swordsman as he strides forth from the depths of a bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist. His features are delicate and resolute, his long, dark hair held back by a simple white headband. His gaze is piercing and focused. He wears a lightweight, well-tailored white Hanfu robe, and at his waist hangs a longsword in a pristine dark wooden sheath, a striking contrast to the white of his garments. As he advances with steady, powerful force, his wide cuffs and hem rustle in the breeze, rhythmically fluttering and radiating an unstoppable aura. Surrounding him is a towering sea of emerald green bamboo, shrouded in a veil of morning mist, its leaves shimmering with glistening dewdrops. The rising sun's rays filter through the thin mist and through the gaps between the bamboo leaves, casting dappled, soft beams of light, creating ever-shifting shadows on his pristine white robe and the damp, leaf-studded path beneath his feet. The entire picture is dominated by cool emerald green and pure white, creating a cinematic atmosphere that is both tranquil and mysterious, yet contains a powerful inner strength.", + "seed": 8236, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_13/index_330_seed_8236_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.059445909410715106, + "vlm_logprob": -0.059445909410715106, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.059445909410715106, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young swordsman wearing a white Hanfu robe with a white headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a longsword in a dark wooden sheath visible hanging at the swordsman's waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist with dappled sunlight filtering through?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman advance forward with steady, powerful strides while his robe cuffs and hem flutter in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2483198642730713 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6233198642730713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2483198642730713, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2483198642730713, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15693019330501556, + 0.08278246223926544, + 0.08395501971244812, + 0.20807719230651855, + 0.08373332768678665, + 0.046648044139146805, + 0.09199031442403793, + 0.032835476100444794, + 0.17174512147903442, + 0.041302844882011414 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2483198642730713 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young swordsman wearing a white Hanfu robe with a white headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a longsword in a dark wooden sheath visible hanging at the swordsman's waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist with dappled sunlight filtering through?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman advance forward with steady, powerful strides while his robe cuffs and hem flutter in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012567726895213127 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387567520141602 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012567726895213127, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012567726895213127, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12442635744810104, + 0.07903410494327545, + 0.20963744819164276, + 0.04541794955730438, + 0.0879630520939827, + 0.13604305684566498, + 0.04092828184366226, + 0.023215878754854202, + 0.08567100763320923, + 0.1676628589630127 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012567726895213127 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young swordsman wearing a white Hanfu robe with a white headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a longsword in a dark wooden sheath visible hanging at the swordsman's waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist with dappled sunlight filtering through?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman advance forward with steady, powerful strides while his robe cuffs and hem flutter in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01419447734951973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264194488525391 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01419447734951973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01419447734951973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20050083100795746, + 0.09262269735336304, + 0.07849996536970139, + 0.1615738868713379, + 0.06790375709533691, + 0.05904373899102211, + 0.07332291454076767, + 0.0356866717338562, + 0.15495100617408752, + 0.0758945494890213 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01419447734951973 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young swordsman wearing a white Hanfu robe with a white headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a longsword in a dark wooden sheath visible hanging at the swordsman's waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist with dappled sunlight filtering through?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman advance forward with steady, powerful strides while his robe cuffs and hem flutter in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107768900692463 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511077880859375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107768900692463, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107768900692463, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14357803761959076, + 0.3792991638183594, + 0.07299470156431198, + 0.03817513957619667, + 0.051643647253513336, + 0.0523596815764904, + 0.031469397246837616, + 0.05496061593294144, + 0.12430630624294281, + 0.05121340602636337 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107768900692463 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young swordsman wearing a white Hanfu robe with a white headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a longsword in a dark wooden sheath visible hanging at the swordsman's waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist with dappled sunlight filtering through?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman advance forward with steady, powerful strides while his robe cuffs and hem flutter in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01106978952884674 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110697746276855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01106978952884674, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01106978952884674, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09906958043575287, + 0.16020984947681427, + 0.10863902419805527, + 0.0833418220281601, + 0.15861572325229645, + 0.10876806825399399, + 0.034734245389699936, + 0.013610538095235825, + 0.10394328087568283, + 0.12906786799430847 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01106978952884674 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle tracking shot follows a young swordsman as he strides forth from the depths of a bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist. His features are delicate and resolute, his long, dark hair held back by a simple white headband. His gaze is piercing and focused. He wears a lightweight, well-tailored white Hanfu robe, and at his waist hangs a longsword in a pristine dark wooden sheath, a striking contrast to the white of his garments. As he advances with steady, powerful force, his wide cuffs and hem rustle in the breeze, rhythmically fluttering and radiating an unstoppable aura. Surrounding him is a towering sea of emerald green bamboo, shrouded in a veil of morning mist, its leaves shimmering with glistening dewdrops. The rising sun's rays filter through the thin mist and through the gaps between the bamboo leaves, casting dappled, soft beams of light, creating ever-shifting shadows on his pristine white robe and the damp, leaf-studded path beneath his feet. The entire picture is dominated by cool emerald green and pure white, creating a cinematic atmosphere that is both tranquil and mysterious, yet contains a powerful inner strength.", + "seed": 8237, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_13/index_330_seed_8237_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.038274528458714485, + "vlm_logprob": -0.038274528458714485, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.038274528458714485, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young swordsman wearing a white Hanfu robe with a white headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a longsword in a dark wooden sheath visible hanging at the swordsman's waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist with dappled sunlight filtering through?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman advance forward with steady, powerful strides while his robe cuffs and hem flutter in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12621642649173737 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.251216411590576 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12621642649173737, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12621642649173737, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1332603096961975, + 0.017000362277030945, + 0.007634774316102266, + 0.02053207904100418, + 0.018089061602950096, + 0.012454534880816936, + 0.010651537217199802, + 0.007220950908958912, + 0.6382332444190979, + 0.13492310047149658 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12621642649173737 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young swordsman wearing a white Hanfu robe with a white headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a longsword in a dark wooden sheath visible hanging at the swordsman's waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist with dappled sunlight filtering through?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman advance forward with steady, powerful strides while his robe cuffs and hem flutter in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02060297690331936 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956029415130615 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02060297690331936, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02060297690331936, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06726370751857758, + 0.029795216396450996, + 0.01565442979335785, + 0.029441356658935547, + 0.037871137261390686, + 0.023946505039930344, + 0.038479022681713104, + 0.03572496026754379, + 0.40821099281311035, + 0.3136126697063446 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02060297690331936 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young swordsman wearing a white Hanfu robe with a white headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a longsword in a dark wooden sheath visible hanging at the swordsman's waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist with dappled sunlight filtering through?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman advance forward with steady, powerful strides while his robe cuffs and hem flutter in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020581139251589775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955812454223633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020581139251589775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020581139251589775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06322814524173737, + 0.03950329124927521, + 0.021288737654685974, + 0.020644761621952057, + 0.10359997302293777, + 0.15511538088321686, + 0.04883473366498947, + 0.03292939439415932, + 0.46995508670806885, + 0.04490046203136444 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020581139251589775 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young swordsman wearing a white Hanfu robe with a white headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a longsword in a dark wooden sheath visible hanging at the swordsman's waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist with dappled sunlight filtering through?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman advance forward with steady, powerful strides while his robe cuffs and hem flutter in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014196240343153477 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264196395874023 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014196240343153477, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014196240343153477, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04711107909679413, + 0.021590160205960274, + 0.018551137298345566, + 0.04803181439638138, + 0.07956734299659729, + 0.07246347516775131, + 0.026812519878149033, + 0.03703587129712105, + 0.5713244080543518, + 0.07751225680112839 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014196240343153477 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle following the subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young swordsman wearing a white Hanfu robe with a white headband?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a longsword in a dark wooden sheath visible hanging at the swordsman's waist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a bamboo forest shrouded in morning mist with dappled sunlight filtering through?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the swordsman advance forward with steady, powerful strides while his robe cuffs and hem flutter in the breeze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00977585930377245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634775638580322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00977585930377245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00977585930377245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05332731083035469, + 0.01398150809109211, + 0.01724221371114254, + 0.015258763916790485, + 0.03133097663521767, + 0.09452900290489197, + 0.031056948006153107, + 0.017207397148013115, + 0.44332611560821533, + 0.2827397882938385 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00977585930377245 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_14/index_tensor([4286, 4286])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_14/index_tensor([4286, 4286])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2da75c355d0b6d8218e0e5a693a0b3c7a7c16058 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_14/index_tensor([4286, 4286])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "Shot in a raw, documentary style, this low-angle, wide-angle shot follows a massive mining haul truck, slowly moving backward to maintain a perfectly centered composition as it deliberately reverses out of the deep shadows of a cavernous tunnel entrance. The vehicle is an industrial behemoth, its standard yellow paint almost completely obscured by a thick, matte, caked-on dirt and fine ochre dust, deep scratches revealing the gleam of raw metal beneath. Its massive tires, each taller than a man, churn up the loose gravel ground, kicking up thick, billowing clouds of dust that catch the harsh, direct sunlight. The tunnel's mouth is a rough arch blasted into a massive wall of rugged gray and brown rock. Within lies a pitch-black void from which the machinery emerges. The relentless midday sun illuminates the scene, casting deep, sharp shadows and illuminating the swirling dust particles, creating a tangible, gritty texture in the air. The steady, observational nature of the image and the sheer scale of the subject against the pristine rocky landscape evoke a powerful atmosphere of industrial power and objective reality.", + "seed": 25435, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_14/index_4286_seed_25435_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05888177286833525, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05888177286833525, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7499999523162844, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05888177286833525, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive mining haul truck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the truck moving backward while maintaining a centered composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the truck's yellow paint obscured by thick, matte, caked-on dirt and ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the truck emerging from a pitch-black void at the mouth of a cavernous tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02279728651046753 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.022797107696533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02279728651046753, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02279728651046753, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17670872807502747, + 0.03964269161224365, + 0.1940777599811554, + 0.15517587959766388, + 0.05886165052652359, + 0.06831958144903183, + 0.10649242997169495, + 0.09008122235536575, + 0.05754316970705986, + 0.05309688672423363 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02279728651046753 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive mining haul truck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the truck moving backward while maintaining a centered composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the truck's yellow paint obscured by thick, matte, caked-on dirt and ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the truck emerging from a pitch-black void at the mouth of a cavernous tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015954703092575 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.701595425605774 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2015954703092575, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2015954703092575, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12873144447803497, + 0.03285130113363266, + 0.07854698598384857, + 0.1001499816775322, + 0.06492794305086136, + 0.17060965299606323, + 0.26617521047592163, + 0.0399184413254261, + 0.06704138219356537, + 0.051047638058662415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2015954703092575 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive mining haul truck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the truck moving backward while maintaining a centered composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the truck's yellow paint obscured by thick, matte, caked-on dirt and ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the truck emerging from a pitch-black void at the mouth of a cavernous tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012576555833220482 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387576580047607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012576555833220482, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012576555833220482, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0897076353430748, + 0.0746362954378128, + 0.5015983581542969, + 0.038796816021203995, + 0.03861270472407341, + 0.018262140452861786, + 0.038407959043979645, + 0.0857439786195755, + 0.04379210248589516, + 0.07044194638729095 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012576555833220482 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive mining haul truck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the truck moving backward while maintaining a centered composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the truck's yellow paint obscured by thick, matte, caked-on dirt and ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the truck emerging from a pitch-black void at the mouth of a cavernous tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05494820326566696 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929948091506958 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05494820326566696, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05494820326566696, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16968166828155518, + 0.12106288224458694, + 0.31119269132614136, + 0.17278513312339783, + 0.04658453166484833, + 0.028052793815732002, + 0.060075800865888596, + 0.042877424508333206, + 0.01810448057949543, + 0.0295825507491827 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05494820326566696 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive mining haul truck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the truck moving backward while maintaining a centered composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the truck's yellow paint obscured by thick, matte, caked-on dirt and ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the truck emerging from a pitch-black void at the mouth of a cavernous tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002491348423063755 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002491474151611 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002491348423063755, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002491348423063755, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21184934675693512, + 0.08811354637145996, + 0.12121305614709854, + 0.03159535676240921, + 0.06758883595466614, + 0.05610349029302597, + 0.10061065107584, + 0.08610103279352188, + 0.06859497725963593, + 0.16822975873947144 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002491348423063755 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Shot in a raw, documentary style, this low-angle, wide-angle shot follows a massive mining haul truck, slowly moving backward to maintain a perfectly centered composition as it deliberately reverses out of the deep shadows of a cavernous tunnel entrance. The vehicle is an industrial behemoth, its standard yellow paint almost completely obscured by a thick, matte, caked-on dirt and fine ochre dust, deep scratches revealing the gleam of raw metal beneath. Its massive tires, each taller than a man, churn up the loose gravel ground, kicking up thick, billowing clouds of dust that catch the harsh, direct sunlight. The tunnel's mouth is a rough arch blasted into a massive wall of rugged gray and brown rock. Within lies a pitch-black void from which the machinery emerges. The relentless midday sun illuminates the scene, casting deep, sharp shadows and illuminating the swirling dust particles, creating a tangible, gritty texture in the air. The steady, observational nature of the image and the sheer scale of the subject against the pristine rocky landscape evoke a powerful atmosphere of industrial power and objective reality.", + "seed": 25436, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_14/index_4286_seed_25436_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08299105442129076, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08299105442129076, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08299105442129076, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive mining haul truck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the truck moving backward while maintaining a centered composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the truck's yellow paint obscured by thick, matte, caked-on dirt and ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the truck emerging from a pitch-black void at the mouth of a cavernous tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026892108842730522 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7768921852111816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026892108842730522, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026892108842730522, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11491891741752625, + 0.12731213867664337, + 0.048230644315481186, + 0.04223964735865593, + 0.3175036907196045, + 0.06723464280366898, + 0.04135916754603386, + 0.05666452273726463, + 0.047854743897914886, + 0.13668183982372284 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026892108842730522 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive mining haul truck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the truck moving backward while maintaining a centered composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the truck's yellow paint obscured by thick, matte, caked-on dirt and ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the truck emerging from a pitch-black void at the mouth of a cavernous tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20158202946186066 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015820741653442 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20158202946186066, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20158202946186066, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.042702581733465195, + 0.08408910781145096, + 0.05180121213197708, + 0.11972536146640778, + 0.0435100719332695, + 0.13196001946926117, + 0.19324515759944916, + 0.09187615662813187, + 0.16568103432655334, + 0.07540927827358246 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20158202946186066 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive mining haul truck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the truck moving backward while maintaining a centered composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the truck's yellow paint obscured by thick, matte, caked-on dirt and ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the truck emerging from a pitch-black void at the mouth of a cavernous tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02332545816898346 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733254432678223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02332545816898346, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02332545816898346, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07895621657371521, + 0.07495928555727005, + 0.20722587406635284, + 0.03093043714761734, + 0.3061569929122925, + 0.07015585899353027, + 0.02592495270073414, + 0.0408676378428936, + 0.05909958854317665, + 0.1057230681180954 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02332545816898346 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive mining haul truck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the truck moving backward while maintaining a centered composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the truck's yellow paint obscured by thick, matte, caked-on dirt and ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the truck emerging from a pitch-black void at the mouth of a cavernous tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603364199399948 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103363752365112 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603364199399948, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603364199399948, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11236170679330826, + 0.0708850622177124, + 0.05792859569191933, + 0.1463293433189392, + 0.2094144970178604, + 0.04312573000788689, + 0.05131884291768074, + 0.0748538076877594, + 0.14763984084129333, + 0.0861426368355751 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603364199399948 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive mining haul truck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the truck moving backward while maintaining a centered composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the truck's yellow paint obscured by thick, matte, caked-on dirt and ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the truck emerging from a pitch-black void at the mouth of a cavernous tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002819255692884326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877819061279297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002819255692884326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002819255692884326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.054678384214639664, + 0.059051018208265305, + 0.05151021108031273, + 0.019037142395973206, + 0.20994022488594055, + 0.34858623147010803, + 0.06310620158910751, + 0.04917177930474281, + 0.048641376197338104, + 0.0962773859500885 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002819255692884326 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Shot in a raw, documentary style, this low-angle, wide-angle shot follows a massive mining haul truck, slowly moving backward to maintain a perfectly centered composition as it deliberately reverses out of the deep shadows of a cavernous tunnel entrance. The vehicle is an industrial behemoth, its standard yellow paint almost completely obscured by a thick, matte, caked-on dirt and fine ochre dust, deep scratches revealing the gleam of raw metal beneath. Its massive tires, each taller than a man, churn up the loose gravel ground, kicking up thick, billowing clouds of dust that catch the harsh, direct sunlight. The tunnel's mouth is a rough arch blasted into a massive wall of rugged gray and brown rock. Within lies a pitch-black void from which the machinery emerges. The relentless midday sun illuminates the scene, casting deep, sharp shadows and illuminating the swirling dust particles, creating a tangible, gritty texture in the air. The steady, observational nature of the image and the sheer scale of the subject against the pristine rocky landscape evoke a powerful atmosphere of industrial power and objective reality.", + "seed": 25437, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_14/index_4286_seed_25437_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04672514609992504, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04672514609992504, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04672514609992504, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive mining haul truck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the truck moving backward while maintaining a centered composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the truck's yellow paint obscured by thick, matte, caked-on dirt and ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the truck emerging from a pitch-black void at the mouth of a cavernous tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00983157753944397 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.884831428527832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00983157753944397, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00983157753944397, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21220043301582336, + 0.10743753612041473, + 0.06533988565206528, + 0.12593913078308105, + 0.07106653600931168, + 0.04440721496939659, + 0.09981673955917358, + 0.09093701839447021, + 0.12358605116605759, + 0.05926945433020592 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00983157753944397 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive mining haul truck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the truck moving backward while maintaining a centered composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the truck's yellow paint obscured by thick, matte, caked-on dirt and ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the truck emerging from a pitch-black void at the mouth of a cavernous tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16039003431797028 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910390019416809 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16039003431797028, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16039003431797028, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08611686527729034, + 0.040230926126241684, + 0.015806272625923157, + 0.030002925544977188, + 0.07633805274963379, + 0.03310498222708702, + 0.04342713579535484, + 0.07556167989969254, + 0.02474702149629593, + 0.5746641755104065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16039003431797028 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive mining haul truck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the truck moving backward while maintaining a centered composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the truck's yellow paint obscured by thick, matte, caked-on dirt and ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the truck emerging from a pitch-black void at the mouth of a cavernous tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005975833162665367 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130975723266602 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005975833162665367, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005975833162665367, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12594129145145416, + 0.057375628501176834, + 0.09845097362995148, + 0.04770278185606003, + 0.06960497051477432, + 0.09465233236551285, + 0.18524162471294403, + 0.06100967526435852, + 0.05245170369744301, + 0.20756900310516357 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005975833162665367 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive mining haul truck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the truck moving backward while maintaining a centered composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the truck's yellow paint obscured by thick, matte, caked-on dirt and ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the truck emerging from a pitch-black void at the mouth of a cavernous tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05493658035993576 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929936647415161 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05493658035993576, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05493658035993576, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1638001799583435, + 0.05723203346133232, + 0.15302571654319763, + 0.07113020122051239, + 0.04819974675774574, + 0.043356191366910934, + 0.0969422310590744, + 0.035333920270204544, + 0.04802044853568077, + 0.28295934200286865 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05493658035993576 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive mining haul truck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the truck moving backward while maintaining a centered composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the truck's yellow paint obscured by thick, matte, caked-on dirt and ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the truck emerging from a pitch-black void at the mouth of a cavernous tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024917051196098328 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002491474151611 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024917051196098328, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024917051196098328, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18629582226276398, + 0.06238672137260437, + 0.056467488408088684, + 0.09135168045759201, + 0.030148599296808243, + 0.04013882577419281, + 0.09815455973148346, + 0.09408491849899292, + 0.050644341856241226, + 0.2903269827365875 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024917051196098328 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Shot in a raw, documentary style, this low-angle, wide-angle shot follows a massive mining haul truck, slowly moving backward to maintain a perfectly centered composition as it deliberately reverses out of the deep shadows of a cavernous tunnel entrance. The vehicle is an industrial behemoth, its standard yellow paint almost completely obscured by a thick, matte, caked-on dirt and fine ochre dust, deep scratches revealing the gleam of raw metal beneath. Its massive tires, each taller than a man, churn up the loose gravel ground, kicking up thick, billowing clouds of dust that catch the harsh, direct sunlight. The tunnel's mouth is a rough arch blasted into a massive wall of rugged gray and brown rock. Within lies a pitch-black void from which the machinery emerges. The relentless midday sun illuminates the scene, casting deep, sharp shadows and illuminating the swirling dust particles, creating a tangible, gritty texture in the air. The steady, observational nature of the image and the sheer scale of the subject against the pristine rocky landscape evoke a powerful atmosphere of industrial power and objective reality.", + "seed": 25438, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_14/index_4286_seed_25438_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06590259303338826, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06590259303338826, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06590259303338826, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive mining haul truck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the truck moving backward while maintaining a centered composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the truck's yellow paint obscured by thick, matte, caked-on dirt and ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the truck emerging from a pitch-black void at the mouth of a cavernous tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06717293709516525 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8171730041503906 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06717293709516525, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06717293709516525, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06831233948469162, + 0.023693369701504707, + 0.07489266246557236, + 0.3972397744655609, + 0.08507950603961945, + 0.0283601563423872, + 0.0464828722178936, + 0.10652322322130203, + 0.0976463183760643, + 0.07176976650953293 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06717293709516525 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive mining haul truck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the truck moving backward while maintaining a centered composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the truck's yellow paint obscured by thick, matte, caked-on dirt and ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the truck emerging from a pitch-black void at the mouth of a cavernous tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22561271488666534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600612759590149 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22561271488666534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22561271488666534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08987310528755188, + 0.06407466530799866, + 0.10851182788610458, + 0.10883098095655441, + 0.08190944790840149, + 0.09661661088466644, + 0.058220602571964264, + 0.21447612345218658, + 0.11078312247991562, + 0.06670345366001129 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22561271488666534 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive mining haul truck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the truck moving backward while maintaining a centered composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the truck's yellow paint obscured by thick, matte, caked-on dirt and ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the truck emerging from a pitch-black void at the mouth of a cavernous tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009823078289628029 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634822845458984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009823078289628029, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009823078289628029, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19519111514091492, + 0.0714465007185936, + 0.038515765219926834, + 0.17337393760681152, + 0.1122790053486824, + 0.03533216565847397, + 0.0596449039876461, + 0.10908448696136475, + 0.13121967017650604, + 0.07391244918107986 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009823078289628029 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive mining haul truck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the truck moving backward while maintaining a centered composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the truck's yellow paint obscured by thick, matte, caked-on dirt and ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the truck emerging from a pitch-black void at the mouth of a cavernous tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0232852790504694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773285388946533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0232852790504694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0232852790504694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3966417610645294, + 0.0356915257871151, + 0.12676803767681122, + 0.04378306493163109, + 0.08998369425535202, + 0.035884834825992584, + 0.03637099638581276, + 0.12254154682159424, + 0.09389594197273254, + 0.01843857765197754 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0232852790504694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive mining haul truck?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the truck moving backward while maintaining a centered composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the truck's yellow paint obscured by thick, matte, caked-on dirt and ochre dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the truck emerging from a pitch-black void at the mouth of a cavernous tunnel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low-angle, wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003618955845013261 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628619194030762 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003618955845013261, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003618955845013261, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12365749478340149, + 0.04999520629644394, + 0.03573289141058922, + 0.17412671446800232, + 0.08715138584375381, + 0.038589756935834885, + 0.040001288056373596, + 0.25920239090919495, + 0.12566909193992615, + 0.06587378680706024 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003618955845013261 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_15/index_tensor([3407, 3407])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_15/index_tensor([3407, 3407])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fa8d9eb709f8bf2510117105d3191fd4893fa8d9 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_15/index_tensor([3407, 3407])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "macro close-up shot from a low side angle, the camera remains still, focusing completely on a budding Epiphyllum in the quiet, dark garden. The cool, silvery moonlight provides the sole source of light, shrouding the scene in a mysterious and tranquil atmosphere, against a backdrop of blurred, out-of-focus dark foliage. Initially, the bud is tightly closed, its deep green outer bracts enveloping the faintly glimpsed snow-white interior. As time passes, the outermost bracts begin to tremble slightly, then peel back with exquisite slowness and grace. Immediately, the snow-white inner petals begin a silent dance, carefully unfurling from the center outward, layer by layer, unhurriedly opening. Each petal is as thin as a cicada's wing, translucent in the moonlight, its soft, waxy sheen gleaming. Light filters through the petals' edges, outlining their sharp, chaste contours while casting deep, soft shadows within their folds. Finally, the entire flower blooms fully, forming a huge and perfect white chalice, revealing a cluster of delicate pale yellow stamens in the center. The whole process is filled with the miracle of life awakening and the ultimate beauty of fleetingness. The color tone of the picture forms a sharp contrast with the cold blue-black and pure bright white, creating a sacred and sad poetry.", + "seed": 7241, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_15/index_3407_seed_7241_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07294392983894796, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07294392983894796, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.050000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07294392983894796, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a budding Epiphyllum flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low side angle and remains still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a dark garden with blurred, out-of-focus dark foliage in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower bloom sequentially from a tightly closed deep green bud to a fully open white chalice with pale yellow stamens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cool, silvery moonlight, creating a high contrast between cold blue-black shadows and pure bright white highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01287657767534256 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.262876510620117 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01287657767534256, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01287657767534256, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07030484825372696, + 0.07088275253772736, + 0.042748771607875824, + 0.1267765462398529, + 0.046373337507247925, + 0.10430332273244858, + 0.1038382351398468, + 0.05077914893627167, + 0.09673977643251419, + 0.2872532308101654 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01287657767534256 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a budding Epiphyllum flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low side angle and remains still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a dark garden with blurred, out-of-focus dark foliage in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower bloom sequentially from a tightly closed deep green bud to a fully open white chalice with pale yellow stamens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cool, silvery moonlight, creating a high contrast between cold blue-black shadows and pure bright white highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20158563554286957 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015856504440308 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20158563554286957, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20158563554286957, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1056600958108902, + 0.06965840607881546, + 0.06692316383123398, + 0.2734661400318146, + 0.031169265508651733, + 0.2875383794307709, + 0.07651933282613754, + 0.030966954305768013, + 0.020304350182414055, + 0.037793952971696854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20158563554286957 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a budding Epiphyllum flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low side angle and remains still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a dark garden with blurred, out-of-focus dark foliage in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower bloom sequentially from a tightly closed deep green bud to a fully open white chalice with pale yellow stamens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cool, silvery moonlight, creating a high contrast between cold blue-black shadows and pure bright white highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005952251143753529 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.13095235824585 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005952251143753529, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005952251143753529, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1656251847743988, + 0.16421477496623993, + 0.03956932947039604, + 0.192563995718956, + 0.022260446101427078, + 0.07299454510211945, + 0.11361415684223175, + 0.042412757873535156, + 0.01830768585205078, + 0.1684371531009674 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005952251143753529 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a budding Epiphyllum flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low side angle and remains still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a dark garden with blurred, out-of-focus dark foliage in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower bloom sequentially from a tightly closed deep green bud to a fully open white chalice with pale yellow stamens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cool, silvery moonlight, creating a high contrast between cold blue-black shadows and pure bright white highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015142414486035705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501514434814453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015142414486035705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015142414486035705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06453988701105118, + 0.08553257584571838, + 0.04661364480853081, + 0.2555656433105469, + 0.02757423184812069, + 0.09179803729057312, + 0.06692958623170853, + 0.02264457941055298, + 0.07306136935949326, + 0.26574045419692993 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015142414486035705 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a budding Epiphyllum flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low side angle and remains still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a dark garden with blurred, out-of-focus dark foliage in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower bloom sequentially from a tightly closed deep green bud to a fully open white chalice with pale yellow stamens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cool, silvery moonlight, creating a high contrast between cold blue-black shadows and pure bright white highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14279094338417053 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0177910327911377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14279094338417053, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14279094338417053, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13603892922401428, + 0.11678244173526764, + 0.0964348167181015, + 0.21886254847049713, + 0.036949776113033295, + 0.12352701276540756, + 0.019172579050064087, + 0.022238442674279213, + 0.07357335835695267, + 0.15642014145851135 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14279094338417053 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "macro close-up shot from a low side angle, the camera remains still, focusing completely on a budding Epiphyllum in the quiet, dark garden. The cool, silvery moonlight provides the sole source of light, shrouding the scene in a mysterious and tranquil atmosphere, against a backdrop of blurred, out-of-focus dark foliage. Initially, the bud is tightly closed, its deep green outer bracts enveloping the faintly glimpsed snow-white interior. As time passes, the outermost bracts begin to tremble slightly, then peel back with exquisite slowness and grace. Immediately, the snow-white inner petals begin a silent dance, carefully unfurling from the center outward, layer by layer, unhurriedly opening. Each petal is as thin as a cicada's wing, translucent in the moonlight, its soft, waxy sheen gleaming. Light filters through the petals' edges, outlining their sharp, chaste contours while casting deep, soft shadows within their folds. Finally, the entire flower blooms fully, forming a huge and perfect white chalice, revealing a cluster of delicate pale yellow stamens in the center. The whole process is filled with the miracle of life awakening and the ultimate beauty of fleetingness. The color tone of the picture forms a sharp contrast with the cold blue-black and pure bright white, creating a sacred and sad poetry.", + "seed": 7242, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_15/index_3407_seed_7242_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04504453744739294, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04504453744739294, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04504453744739294, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a budding Epiphyllum flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low side angle and remains still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a dark garden with blurred, out-of-focus dark foliage in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower bloom sequentially from a tightly closed deep green bud to a fully open white chalice with pale yellow stamens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cool, silvery moonlight, creating a high contrast between cold blue-black shadows and pure bright white highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00957692600786686 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.134576797485352 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00957692600786686, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00957692600786686, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15038752555847168, + 0.1043422594666481, + 0.29080942273139954, + 0.11448346078395844, + 0.10748430341482162, + 0.08793383836746216, + 0.04637504369020462, + 0.025065569207072258, + 0.03536698967218399, + 0.03775158151984215 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00957692600786686 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a budding Epiphyllum flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low side angle and remains still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a dark garden with blurred, out-of-focus dark foliage in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower bloom sequentially from a tightly closed deep green bud to a fully open white chalice with pale yellow stamens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cool, silvery moonlight, creating a high contrast between cold blue-black shadows and pure bright white highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12708616256713867 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270861625671387 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12708616256713867, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12708616256713867, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02972560189664364, + 0.0245345588773489, + 0.27213287353515625, + 0.2048601657152176, + 0.21130982041358948, + 0.08055760711431503, + 0.018233926966786385, + 0.14622339606285095, + 0.006654579192399979, + 0.005767475813627243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12708616256713867 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a budding Epiphyllum flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low side angle and remains still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a dark garden with blurred, out-of-focus dark foliage in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower bloom sequentially from a tightly closed deep green bud to a fully open white chalice with pale yellow stamens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cool, silvery moonlight, creating a high contrast between cold blue-black shadows and pure bright white highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005958294961601496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130958080291748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005958294961601496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005958294961601496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08703061193227768, + 0.12363285571336746, + 0.3146026134490967, + 0.15504272282123566, + 0.2081492841243744, + 0.03929714486002922, + 0.026393944397568703, + 0.010222407057881355, + 0.016623811796307564, + 0.01900460757315159 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005958294961601496 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a budding Epiphyllum flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low side angle and remains still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a dark garden with blurred, out-of-focus dark foliage in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower bloom sequentially from a tightly closed deep green bud to a fully open white chalice with pale yellow stamens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cool, silvery moonlight, creating a high contrast between cold blue-black shadows and pure bright white highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036183618940413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628618240356445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036183618940413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036183618940413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09031254798173904, + 0.0827418640255928, + 0.17637284100055695, + 0.1841089427471161, + 0.09666711837053299, + 0.17105935513973236, + 0.03318749740719795, + 0.07064832001924515, + 0.0490800179541111, + 0.045821551233530045 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036183618940413 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a budding Epiphyllum flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low side angle and remains still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a dark garden with blurred, out-of-focus dark foliage in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower bloom sequentially from a tightly closed deep green bud to a fully open white chalice with pale yellow stamens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cool, silvery moonlight, creating a high contrast between cold blue-black shadows and pure bright white highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898294180631638 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789828300476074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898294180631638, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898294180631638, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10091385245323181, + 0.13409121334552765, + 0.15409712493419647, + 0.22118692100048065, + 0.12853002548217773, + 0.04373941570520401, + 0.052648864686489105, + 0.07872504740953445, + 0.05531652644276619, + 0.03075104020535946 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898294180631638 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "macro close-up shot from a low side angle, the camera remains still, focusing completely on a budding Epiphyllum in the quiet, dark garden. The cool, silvery moonlight provides the sole source of light, shrouding the scene in a mysterious and tranquil atmosphere, against a backdrop of blurred, out-of-focus dark foliage. Initially, the bud is tightly closed, its deep green outer bracts enveloping the faintly glimpsed snow-white interior. As time passes, the outermost bracts begin to tremble slightly, then peel back with exquisite slowness and grace. Immediately, the snow-white inner petals begin a silent dance, carefully unfurling from the center outward, layer by layer, unhurriedly opening. Each petal is as thin as a cicada's wing, translucent in the moonlight, its soft, waxy sheen gleaming. Light filters through the petals' edges, outlining their sharp, chaste contours while casting deep, soft shadows within their folds. Finally, the entire flower blooms fully, forming a huge and perfect white chalice, revealing a cluster of delicate pale yellow stamens in the center. The whole process is filled with the miracle of life awakening and the ultimate beauty of fleetingness. The color tone of the picture forms a sharp contrast with the cold blue-black and pure bright white, creating a sacred and sad poetry.", + "seed": 7243, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_15/index_3407_seed_7243_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06272278716787696, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06272278716787696, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06272278716787696, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a budding Epiphyllum flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low side angle and remains still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a dark garden with blurred, out-of-focus dark foliage in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower bloom sequentially from a tightly closed deep green bud to a fully open white chalice with pale yellow stamens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cool, silvery moonlight, creating a high contrast between cold blue-black shadows and pure bright white highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012692738324403763 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.012692928314209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012692738324403763, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012692738324403763, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08262255787849426, + 0.06077177822589874, + 0.08011013269424438, + 0.10561320185661316, + 0.04772907868027687, + 0.03276156634092331, + 0.10291001945734024, + 0.275422066450119, + 0.17417913675308228, + 0.037880439311265945 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012692738324403763 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a budding Epiphyllum flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low side angle and remains still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a dark garden with blurred, out-of-focus dark foliage in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower bloom sequentially from a tightly closed deep green bud to a fully open white chalice with pale yellow stamens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cool, silvery moonlight, creating a high contrast between cold blue-black shadows and pure bright white highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17991963028907776 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049196004867554 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17991963028907776, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17991963028907776, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15004687011241913, + 0.05429408699274063, + 0.4087982475757599, + 0.0451497919857502, + 0.07345952838659286, + 0.05126449838280678, + 0.12354259192943573, + 0.025014352053403854, + 0.05162401497364044, + 0.01680597849190235 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17991963028907776 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a budding Epiphyllum flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low side angle and remains still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a dark garden with blurred, out-of-focus dark foliage in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower bloom sequentially from a tightly closed deep green bud to a fully open white chalice with pale yellow stamens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cool, silvery moonlight, creating a high contrast between cold blue-black shadows and pure bright white highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018199946731328964 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018199920654297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018199946731328964, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018199946731328964, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16891606152057648, + 0.06727435439825058, + 0.2026544064283371, + 0.08589054644107819, + 0.11235648393630981, + 0.1265101283788681, + 0.037746816873550415, + 0.12462632358074188, + 0.058268435299396515, + 0.015756502747535706 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018199946731328964 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a budding Epiphyllum flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low side angle and remains still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a dark garden with blurred, out-of-focus dark foliage in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower bloom sequentially from a tightly closed deep green bud to a fully open white chalice with pale yellow stamens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cool, silvery moonlight, creating a high contrast between cold blue-black shadows and pure bright white highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002491943072527647 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.0024919509887695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002491943072527647, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002491943072527647, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1050582230091095, + 0.04374975711107254, + 0.40914976596832275, + 0.06087597832083702, + 0.04138118028640747, + 0.05183080583810806, + 0.07339468598365784, + 0.14003115892410278, + 0.05863175168633461, + 0.015896709635853767 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002491943072527647 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a budding Epiphyllum flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low side angle and remains still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a dark garden with blurred, out-of-focus dark foliage in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower bloom sequentially from a tightly closed deep green bud to a fully open white chalice with pale yellow stamens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cool, silvery moonlight, creating a high contrast between cold blue-black shadows and pure bright white highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10030967742204666 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503096103668213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10030967742204666, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10030967742204666, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10621636360883713, + 0.09329576045274734, + 0.13519668579101562, + 0.1707797348499298, + 0.10648932307958603, + 0.10115033388137817, + 0.13353487849235535, + 0.0838446319103241, + 0.05612115189433098, + 0.013371078297495842 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10030967742204666 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "macro close-up shot from a low side angle, the camera remains still, focusing completely on a budding Epiphyllum in the quiet, dark garden. The cool, silvery moonlight provides the sole source of light, shrouding the scene in a mysterious and tranquil atmosphere, against a backdrop of blurred, out-of-focus dark foliage. Initially, the bud is tightly closed, its deep green outer bracts enveloping the faintly glimpsed snow-white interior. As time passes, the outermost bracts begin to tremble slightly, then peel back with exquisite slowness and grace. Immediately, the snow-white inner petals begin a silent dance, carefully unfurling from the center outward, layer by layer, unhurriedly opening. Each petal is as thin as a cicada's wing, translucent in the moonlight, its soft, waxy sheen gleaming. Light filters through the petals' edges, outlining their sharp, chaste contours while casting deep, soft shadows within their folds. Finally, the entire flower blooms fully, forming a huge and perfect white chalice, revealing a cluster of delicate pale yellow stamens in the center. The whole process is filled with the miracle of life awakening and the ultimate beauty of fleetingness. The color tone of the picture forms a sharp contrast with the cold blue-black and pure bright white, creating a sacred and sad poetry.", + "seed": 7244, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_15/index_3407_seed_7244_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07066516373306513, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07066516373306513, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07066516373306513, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a budding Epiphyllum flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low side angle and remains still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a dark garden with blurred, out-of-focus dark foliage in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower bloom sequentially from a tightly closed deep green bud to a fully open white chalice with pale yellow stamens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cool, silvery moonlight, creating a high contrast between cold blue-black shadows and pure bright white highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013897554948925972 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.76389741897583 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013897554948925972, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013897554948925972, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09254606068134308, + 0.1105504184961319, + 0.16341395676136017, + 0.06998423486948013, + 0.043878402560949326, + 0.1304837018251419, + 0.106283038854599, + 0.1177494004368782, + 0.10214932262897491, + 0.06296146661043167 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013897554948925972 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a budding Epiphyllum flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low side angle and remains still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a dark garden with blurred, out-of-focus dark foliage in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower bloom sequentially from a tightly closed deep green bud to a fully open white chalice with pale yellow stamens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cool, silvery moonlight, creating a high contrast between cold blue-black shadows and pure bright white highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521485388278961 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021485090255737 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521485388278961, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521485388278961, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20403385162353516, + 0.06122814863920212, + 0.23239627480506897, + 0.1565553992986679, + 0.07162071019411087, + 0.10224061459302902, + 0.0891689881682396, + 0.01968998648226261, + 0.03299465775489807, + 0.030071325600147247 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521485388278961 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a budding Epiphyllum flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low side angle and remains still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a dark garden with blurred, out-of-focus dark foliage in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower bloom sequentially from a tightly closed deep green bud to a fully open white chalice with pale yellow stamens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cool, silvery moonlight, creating a high contrast between cold blue-black shadows and pure bright white highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016080567613244057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141080379486084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016080567613244057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016080567613244057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06099718436598778, + 0.5286655426025391, + 0.12234960496425629, + 0.08619679510593414, + 0.03976869955658913, + 0.04171355441212654, + 0.023843685165047646, + 0.032706182450056076, + 0.03797591105103493, + 0.025782866403460503 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016080567613244057 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a budding Epiphyllum flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low side angle and remains still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a dark garden with blurred, out-of-focus dark foliage in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower bloom sequentially from a tightly closed deep green bud to a fully open white chalice with pale yellow stamens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cool, silvery moonlight, creating a high contrast between cold blue-black shadows and pure bright white highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011824527755379677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751182556152344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011824527755379677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011824527755379677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12053951621055603, + 0.06774704903364182, + 0.25354182720184326, + 0.08470729738473892, + 0.07238063961267471, + 0.10854331403970718, + 0.07408521324396133, + 0.08066340535879135, + 0.08450876176357269, + 0.05328303202986717 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011824527755379677 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a macro close-up of a budding Epiphyllum flower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a low side angle and remains still throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a dark garden with blurred, out-of-focus dark foliage in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the flower bloom sequentially from a tightly closed deep green bud to a fully open white chalice with pale yellow stamens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting provided solely by cool, silvery moonlight, creating a high contrast between cold blue-black shadows and pure bright white highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07001670449972153 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695016622543335 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07001670449972153, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07001670449972153, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16170009970664978, + 0.08576872944831848, + 0.2615046501159668, + 0.10188266634941101, + 0.04058975726366043, + 0.12460561841726303, + 0.06945526599884033, + 0.060707055032253265, + 0.052986569702625275, + 0.04079955071210861 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07001670449972153 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_2/index_tensor([1396, 1396])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_2/index_tensor([1396, 1396])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..85f6f1fd9284d7bac86b70c65d02adf9ce221634 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_2/index_tensor([1396, 1396])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, extreme close-up depicts a highly detailed luxury watch, rendered in a flawless, high-fidelity digital aesthetic. The entire scene, captured in stark, elegant black and white, creates a world of pure form and texture. The watch features a polished and brushed metal case, delicately balanced by a perfectly smooth, non-reflective black surface on the crown. A single, crisp key light shone from the side, sculpting its form, casting brilliant white highlights on the beveled edges of the lugs and the intricate knurling of the crown, while immersing the opposite side in deep, velvety shadows. The watch never remains still; it undergoes a slow, mesmerizing nutation, gently and deliberately rocking on its axis with the hypnotic grace of a spinning top losing energy. This slow, circular oscillation causes light to play dynamically across its surface, causing the metal facets to shimmer with ever-changing angles of reflection. This emphasizes the dramatic interplay of light and shadow on the intricate, non-branded mechanical parts visible through the sapphire crystal, creating an atmosphere of sophisticated, highly focused mechanical precision and quiet elegance.", + "seed": 12916, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_2/index_1396_seed_12916_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.14712856491096318, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14712856491096318, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.550000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14712856491096318, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a luxury watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in stark black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the watch exhibit a slow nutation motion, rocking gently on its axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a single side key light creating high contrast with brilliant highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are intricate mechanical parts visible through the sapphire crystal of the watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029930105432868004 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6549301147460938 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029930105432868004, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029930105432868004, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22030270099639893, + 0.033574290573596954, + 0.16198351979255676, + 0.29773032665252686, + 0.11390015482902527, + 0.02355182357132435, + 0.027767328545451164, + 0.02614058181643486, + 0.03843779116868973, + 0.05661151185631752 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029930105432868004 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a luxury watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in stark black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the watch exhibit a slow nutation motion, rocking gently on its axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a single side key light creating high contrast with brilliant highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are intricate mechanical parts visible through the sapphire crystal of the watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010699268896132708 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876070022583008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010699268896132708, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010699268896132708, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12252533435821533, + 0.031235208734869957, + 0.10960924625396729, + 0.4520168900489807, + 0.0677025094628334, + 0.07778618484735489, + 0.01981019228696823, + 0.038872119039297104, + 0.03981590270996094, + 0.040626391768455505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010699268896132708 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a luxury watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in stark black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the watch exhibit a slow nutation motion, rocking gently on its axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a single side key light creating high contrast with brilliant highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are intricate mechanical parts visible through the sapphire crystal of the watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31344953179359436 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.313449501991272 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31344953179359436, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31344953179359436, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14403894543647766, + 0.07473750412464142, + 0.32363831996917725, + 0.1601003259420395, + 0.08258458226919174, + 0.03160226345062256, + 0.05011037364602089, + 0.034010838717222214, + 0.07058887928724289, + 0.028588000684976578 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31344953179359436 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a luxury watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in stark black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the watch exhibit a slow nutation motion, rocking gently on its axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a single side key light creating high contrast with brilliant highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are intricate mechanical parts visible through the sapphire crystal of the watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004099537618458271 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504099369049072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004099537618458271, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004099537618458271, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4480607509613037, + 0.04279767721891403, + 0.16131985187530518, + 0.16558311879634857, + 0.040588367730379105, + 0.012054533697664738, + 0.013721928000450134, + 0.025723448023200035, + 0.03313926234841347, + 0.057011090219020844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004099537618458271 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a luxury watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in stark black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the watch exhibit a slow nutation motion, rocking gently on its axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a single side key light creating high contrast with brilliant highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are intricate mechanical parts visible through the sapphire crystal of the watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.387093722820282 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370937824249268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.387093722820282, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7500000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.387093722820282, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1313301920890808, + 0.03209437429904938, + 0.2441791296005249, + 0.11870348453521729, + 0.07033970206975937, + 0.04493645206093788, + 0.045922987163066864, + 0.07915573567152023, + 0.11604735255241394, + 0.11729053407907486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.387093722820282 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, extreme close-up depicts a highly detailed luxury watch, rendered in a flawless, high-fidelity digital aesthetic. The entire scene, captured in stark, elegant black and white, creates a world of pure form and texture. The watch features a polished and brushed metal case, delicately balanced by a perfectly smooth, non-reflective black surface on the crown. A single, crisp key light shone from the side, sculpting its form, casting brilliant white highlights on the beveled edges of the lugs and the intricate knurling of the crown, while immersing the opposite side in deep, velvety shadows. The watch never remains still; it undergoes a slow, mesmerizing nutation, gently and deliberately rocking on its axis with the hypnotic grace of a spinning top losing energy. This slow, circular oscillation causes light to play dynamically across its surface, causing the metal facets to shimmer with ever-changing angles of reflection. This emphasizes the dramatic interplay of light and shadow on the intricate, non-branded mechanical parts visible through the sapphire crystal, creating an atmosphere of sophisticated, highly focused mechanical precision and quiet elegance.", + "seed": 12917, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_2/index_1396_seed_12917_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.12816772554069758, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12816772554069758, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1499999940395353, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12816772554069758, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a luxury watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in stark black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the watch exhibit a slow nutation motion, rocking gently on its axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a single side key light creating high contrast with brilliant highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are intricate mechanical parts visible through the sapphire crystal of the watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014736962504684925 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.389737129211426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014736962504684925, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014736962504684925, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12833169102668762, + 0.06323415786027908, + 0.07222514599561691, + 0.13194745779037476, + 0.14110052585601807, + 0.06725054234266281, + 0.09634357690811157, + 0.10617753863334656, + 0.10153358429670334, + 0.09185578674077988 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014736962504684925 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a luxury watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in stark black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the watch exhibit a slow nutation motion, rocking gently on its axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a single side key light creating high contrast with brilliant highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are intricate mechanical parts visible through the sapphire crystal of the watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01612584851682186 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141125679016113 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01612584851682186, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01612584851682186, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16677634418010712, + 0.0817222148180008, + 0.05255039781332016, + 0.22632890939712524, + 0.04870690032839775, + 0.0352490097284317, + 0.12750671803951263, + 0.0750453993678093, + 0.14599297940731049, + 0.040121134370565414 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01612584851682186 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a luxury watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in stark black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the watch exhibit a slow nutation motion, rocking gently on its axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a single side key light creating high contrast with brilliant highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are intricate mechanical parts visible through the sapphire crystal of the watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4742732346057892 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742732048034668 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4742732346057892, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.4999999701976776, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4742732346057892, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11858285963535309, + 0.0666232705116272, + 0.0765046551823616, + 0.11784013360738754, + 0.08348109573125839, + 0.10574926435947418, + 0.06446021050214767, + 0.06731355935335159, + 0.15187199413776398, + 0.14757293462753296 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4742732346057892 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a luxury watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in stark black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the watch exhibit a slow nutation motion, rocking gently on its axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a single side key light creating high contrast with brilliant highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are intricate mechanical parts visible through the sapphire crystal of the watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00864654965698719 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758646488189697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00864654965698719, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00864654965698719, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10584545880556107, + 0.05089215189218521, + 0.10610680282115936, + 0.3125379979610443, + 0.037187110632658005, + 0.03791326284408569, + 0.05317612737417221, + 0.18382896482944489, + 0.06839000433683395, + 0.044122129678726196 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00864654965698719 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a luxury watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in stark black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the watch exhibit a slow nutation motion, rocking gently on its axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a single side key light creating high contrast with brilliant highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are intricate mechanical parts visible through the sapphire crystal of the watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270560324192047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127056121826172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270560324192047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270560324192047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21249912679195404, + 0.08378972113132477, + 0.03809989243745804, + 0.05928407981991768, + 0.19077084958553314, + 0.05277036875486374, + 0.07416670024394989, + 0.046979181468486786, + 0.1469966173171997, + 0.09464356303215027 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270560324192047 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, extreme close-up depicts a highly detailed luxury watch, rendered in a flawless, high-fidelity digital aesthetic. The entire scene, captured in stark, elegant black and white, creates a world of pure form and texture. The watch features a polished and brushed metal case, delicately balanced by a perfectly smooth, non-reflective black surface on the crown. A single, crisp key light shone from the side, sculpting its form, casting brilliant white highlights on the beveled edges of the lugs and the intricate knurling of the crown, while immersing the opposite side in deep, velvety shadows. The watch never remains still; it undergoes a slow, mesmerizing nutation, gently and deliberately rocking on its axis with the hypnotic grace of a spinning top losing energy. This slow, circular oscillation causes light to play dynamically across its surface, causing the metal facets to shimmer with ever-changing angles of reflection. This emphasizes the dramatic interplay of light and shadow on the intricate, non-branded mechanical parts visible through the sapphire crystal, creating an atmosphere of sophisticated, highly focused mechanical precision and quiet elegance.", + "seed": 12918, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_2/index_1396_seed_12918_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10156975169666112, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10156975169666112, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10156975169666112, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a luxury watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in stark black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the watch exhibit a slow nutation motion, rocking gently on its axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a single side key light creating high contrast with brilliant highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are intricate mechanical parts visible through the sapphire crystal of the watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.26198846101760864 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5119884014129639 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.26198846101760864, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.26198846101760864, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.043870218098163605, + 0.02022401988506317, + 0.02471035160124302, + 0.03205087408423424, + 0.031225785613059998, + 0.22848419845104218, + 0.01760728843510151, + 0.04049282893538475, + 0.05231627821922302, + 0.5090181231498718 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.26198846101760864 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a luxury watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in stark black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the watch exhibit a slow nutation motion, rocking gently on its axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a single side key light creating high contrast with brilliant highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are intricate mechanical parts visible through the sapphire crystal of the watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028827323112636805 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877882957458496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028827323112636805, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028827323112636805, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0986059382557869, + 0.06306056678295135, + 0.036060791462659836, + 0.015426903031766415, + 0.020359309390187263, + 0.06851235777139664, + 0.028973041102290154, + 0.07811610400676727, + 0.09933269768953323, + 0.49155235290527344 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028827323112636805 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a luxury watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in stark black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the watch exhibit a slow nutation motion, rocking gently on its axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a single side key light creating high contrast with brilliant highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are intricate mechanical parts visible through the sapphire crystal of the watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603682041168213 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103682041168213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603682041168213, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603682041168213, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.033999715000391006, + 0.013265052810311317, + 0.024019679054617882, + 0.021640848368406296, + 0.01566803641617298, + 0.008674362674355507, + 0.015740374103188515, + 0.014105916023254395, + 0.019039928913116455, + 0.8338460922241211 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603682041168213 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a luxury watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in stark black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the watch exhibit a slow nutation motion, rocking gently on its axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a single side key light creating high contrast with brilliant highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are intricate mechanical parts visible through the sapphire crystal of the watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036215689033269882 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628621578216553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036215689033269882, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036215689033269882, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06344332545995712, + 0.05352500081062317, + 0.06185056269168854, + 0.06779027730226517, + 0.0888366848230362, + 0.06686116755008698, + 0.04233545437455177, + 0.06073799356818199, + 0.05919511243700981, + 0.43542441725730896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036215689033269882 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a luxury watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in stark black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the watch exhibit a slow nutation motion, rocking gently on its axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a single side key light creating high contrast with brilliant highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are intricate mechanical parts visible through the sapphire crystal of the watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898779213428497 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789878368377686 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898779213428497, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898779213428497, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09506607055664062, + 0.03252808004617691, + 0.043325603008270264, + 0.029334528371691704, + 0.05841317027807236, + 0.16899296641349792, + 0.010419833473861217, + 0.02201342023909092, + 0.09087766706943512, + 0.4490286111831665 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898779213428497 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, extreme close-up depicts a highly detailed luxury watch, rendered in a flawless, high-fidelity digital aesthetic. The entire scene, captured in stark, elegant black and white, creates a world of pure form and texture. The watch features a polished and brushed metal case, delicately balanced by a perfectly smooth, non-reflective black surface on the crown. A single, crisp key light shone from the side, sculpting its form, casting brilliant white highlights on the beveled edges of the lugs and the intricate knurling of the crown, while immersing the opposite side in deep, velvety shadows. The watch never remains still; it undergoes a slow, mesmerizing nutation, gently and deliberately rocking on its axis with the hypnotic grace of a spinning top losing energy. This slow, circular oscillation causes light to play dynamically across its surface, causing the metal facets to shimmer with ever-changing angles of reflection. This emphasizes the dramatic interplay of light and shadow on the intricate, non-branded mechanical parts visible through the sapphire crystal, creating an atmosphere of sophisticated, highly focused mechanical precision and quiet elegance.", + "seed": 12919, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_2/index_1396_seed_12919_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.09199792491272092, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09199792491272092, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09199792491272092, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a luxury watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in stark black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the watch exhibit a slow nutation motion, rocking gently on its axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a single side key light creating high contrast with brilliant highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are intricate mechanical parts visible through the sapphire crystal of the watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015705464407801628 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.265705585479736 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015705464407801628, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015705464407801628, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0849420353770256, + 0.04581596329808235, + 0.08797240257263184, + 0.3319600820541382, + 0.10017634183168411, + 0.07884038984775543, + 0.09903940558433533, + 0.10935461521148682, + 0.029533371329307556, + 0.03236537054181099 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015705464407801628 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a luxury watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in stark black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the watch exhibit a slow nutation motion, rocking gently on its axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a single side key light creating high contrast with brilliant highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are intricate mechanical parts visible through the sapphire crystal of the watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002513109240680933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.0025129318237305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002513109240680933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002513109240680933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07252504676580429, + 0.08237776160240173, + 0.07151542603969574, + 0.2212524712085724, + 0.15051838755607605, + 0.03772138059139252, + 0.06261825561523438, + 0.12702976167201996, + 0.09232084453105927, + 0.08212070167064667 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002513109240680933 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a luxury watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in stark black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the watch exhibit a slow nutation motion, rocking gently on its axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a single side key light creating high contrast with brilliant highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are intricate mechanical parts visible through the sapphire crystal of the watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520976662635803 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020976066589355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520976662635803, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520976662635803, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08784766495227814, + 0.05295147746801376, + 0.09219984710216522, + 0.09117107093334198, + 0.0644267275929451, + 0.07296042889356613, + 0.27042531967163086, + 0.1546441912651062, + 0.07494645565748215, + 0.038426801562309265 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520976662635803 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a luxury watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in stark black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the watch exhibit a slow nutation motion, rocking gently on its axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a single side key light creating high contrast with brilliant highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are intricate mechanical parts visible through the sapphire crystal of the watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978860817849636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634788513183594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978860817849636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978860817849636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09494756162166595, + 0.08179564774036407, + 0.08457663655281067, + 0.20448599755764008, + 0.08627936989068985, + 0.17348028719425201, + 0.1039867177605629, + 0.06539171189069748, + 0.04862947016954422, + 0.05642661452293396 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978860817849636 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a luxury watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in stark black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the watch exhibit a slow nutation motion, rocking gently on its axis?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a single side key light creating high contrast with brilliant highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are intricate mechanical parts visible through the sapphire crystal of the watch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17988477647304535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048847913742065 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17988477647304535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17988477647304535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10427124798297882, + 0.06066533178091049, + 0.11161267757415771, + 0.020905254408717155, + 0.11927271634340286, + 0.06220206245779991, + 0.13768966495990753, + 0.08417998999357224, + 0.21708442270755768, + 0.08211666345596313 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17988477647304535 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_3/index_tensor([2860, 2860])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_3/index_tensor([2860, 2860])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2e9b3001dbb54e4a417fe7d0a5d7b19378a1cc4e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_3/index_tensor([2860, 2860])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "From a first-person perspective, the camera glides forward steadily and deliberately, hovering above the damp, textured surface of a decaying log, covered in a vibrant, velvety carpet of green moss. Soft, diffused morning light filters through the unseen treetops with a dreamy, ethereal quality, capturing countless tiny dewdrops scattered across the moss like jewels. The camera focuses on a tiny, translucent snail, its pale, almost ghostly body delicately perched atop a perfectly spherical droplet of water, which magnifies the intricate fibers of the moss beneath. The camera continues its slow, extreme macro shot, revealing the snail's glassy, amber shell, shimmering as light refracts through its delicate, spiraling architecture. As the camera briefly passes over the creature, it captures the shimmering, iridescent trail it leaves behind: a smooth ribbon of rainbow hues (pink, blue, and green) shimmering against a lush, out-of-focus background, creating a tranquil and magical atmosphere focused on this miniature, wondrous world.", + "seed": 11260, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_3/index_2860_seed_11260_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06271061135921627, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06271061135921627, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06271061135921627, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, gliding forward steadily above a decaying log covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny, translucent snail with a glassy amber shell visible perched on a perfectly spherical water droplet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature soft, diffused morning light filtering through unseen treetops with a dreamy quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a shimmering, iridescent trail of rainbow hues (pink, blue, and green) visible behind the snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background lush and out-of-focus, creating a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07277725636959076 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.697777271270752 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07277725636959076, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07277725636959076, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08459006994962692, + 0.058008480817079544, + 0.07828332483768463, + 0.050701480358839035, + 0.04308640584349632, + 0.07480549812316895, + 0.07612156122922897, + 0.029674824327230453, + 0.1035659909248352, + 0.4011622965335846 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07277725636959076 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, gliding forward steadily above a decaying log covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny, translucent snail with a glassy amber shell visible perched on a perfectly spherical water droplet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature soft, diffused morning light filtering through unseen treetops with a dreamy quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a shimmering, iridescent trail of rainbow hues (pink, blue, and green) visible behind the snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background lush and out-of-focus, creating a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029834885150194168 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298349857330322 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029834885150194168, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029834885150194168, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02280314452946186, + 0.019621314480900764, + 0.03172774985432625, + 0.02996070310473442, + 0.02232903242111206, + 0.09314548969268799, + 0.07053866982460022, + 0.05105222761631012, + 0.2671263813972473, + 0.3916953206062317 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029834885150194168 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, gliding forward steadily above a decaying log covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny, translucent snail with a glassy amber shell visible perched on a perfectly spherical water droplet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature soft, diffused morning light filtering through unseen treetops with a dreamy quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a shimmering, iridescent trail of rainbow hues (pink, blue, and green) visible behind the snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background lush and out-of-focus, creating a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008651158772408962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758651256561279 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008651158772408962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008651158772408962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18348756432533264, + 0.11096639186143875, + 0.29264035820961, + 0.1038651168346405, + 0.042792074382305145, + 0.02995796501636505, + 0.04726092144846916, + 0.05623350292444229, + 0.06483069062232971, + 0.06796543300151825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008651158772408962 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, gliding forward steadily above a decaying log covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny, translucent snail with a glassy amber shell visible perched on a perfectly spherical water droplet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature soft, diffused morning light filtering through unseen treetops with a dreamy quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a shimmering, iridescent trail of rainbow hues (pink, blue, and green) visible behind the snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background lush and out-of-focus, creating a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015729695558548 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015730142593384 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2015729695558548, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2015729695558548, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04801003262400627, + 0.04813423007726669, + 0.08018478751182556, + 0.16122615337371826, + 0.10062204301357269, + 0.050476495176553726, + 0.040684279054403305, + 0.06096137315034866, + 0.30962973833084106, + 0.10007080435752869 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2015729695558548 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, gliding forward steadily above a decaying log covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny, translucent snail with a glassy amber shell visible perched on a perfectly spherical water droplet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature soft, diffused morning light filtering through unseen treetops with a dreamy quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a shimmering, iridescent trail of rainbow hues (pink, blue, and green) visible behind the snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background lush and out-of-focus, creating a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0007167869480326772 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.250716686248779 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0007167869480326772, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0007167869480326772, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12052551656961441, + 0.03320230916142464, + 0.23395083844661713, + 0.05189044401049614, + 0.03450360894203186, + 0.05996004492044449, + 0.030499199405312538, + 0.04890531301498413, + 0.1679742932319641, + 0.21858839690685272 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0007167869480326772 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "From a first-person perspective, the camera glides forward steadily and deliberately, hovering above the damp, textured surface of a decaying log, covered in a vibrant, velvety carpet of green moss. Soft, diffused morning light filters through the unseen treetops with a dreamy, ethereal quality, capturing countless tiny dewdrops scattered across the moss like jewels. The camera focuses on a tiny, translucent snail, its pale, almost ghostly body delicately perched atop a perfectly spherical droplet of water, which magnifies the intricate fibers of the moss beneath. The camera continues its slow, extreme macro shot, revealing the snail's glassy, amber shell, shimmering as light refracts through its delicate, spiraling architecture. As the camera briefly passes over the creature, it captures the shimmering, iridescent trail it leaves behind: a smooth ribbon of rainbow hues (pink, blue, and green) shimmering against a lush, out-of-focus background, creating a tranquil and magical atmosphere focused on this miniature, wondrous world.", + "seed": 11261, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_3/index_2860_seed_11261_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0188096423400566, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0188096423400566, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0188096423400566, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, gliding forward steadily above a decaying log covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny, translucent snail with a glassy amber shell visible perched on a perfectly spherical water droplet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature soft, diffused morning light filtering through unseen treetops with a dreamy quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a shimmering, iridescent trail of rainbow hues (pink, blue, and green) visible behind the snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background lush and out-of-focus, creating a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.035395924001932144 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.410395860671997 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.035395924001932144, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.035395924001932144, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10059212148189545, + 0.05978931114077568, + 0.049748267978429794, + 0.1493494212627411, + 0.0552014596760273, + 0.3081759214401245, + 0.07022075355052948, + 0.13066385686397552, + 0.023072995245456696, + 0.053185876458883286 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.035395924001932144 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, gliding forward steadily above a decaying log covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny, translucent snail with a glassy amber shell visible perched on a perfectly spherical water droplet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature soft, diffused morning light filtering through unseen treetops with a dreamy quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a shimmering, iridescent trail of rainbow hues (pink, blue, and green) visible behind the snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background lush and out-of-focus, creating a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023309387266635895 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733094692230225 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023309387266635895, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023309387266635895, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09349732100963593, + 0.05884755775332451, + 0.02533724159002304, + 0.20961278676986694, + 0.07929500937461853, + 0.17378714680671692, + 0.15458035469055176, + 0.04014791175723076, + 0.07401622086763382, + 0.0908784344792366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023309387266635895 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, gliding forward steadily above a decaying log covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny, translucent snail with a glassy amber shell visible perched on a perfectly spherical water droplet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature soft, diffused morning light filtering through unseen treetops with a dreamy quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a shimmering, iridescent trail of rainbow hues (pink, blue, and green) visible behind the snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background lush and out-of-focus, creating a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01420411467552185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264204025268555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01420411467552185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01420411467552185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14973151683807373, + 0.13507553935050964, + 0.09991560876369476, + 0.09489263594150543, + 0.067127525806427, + 0.10679568350315094, + 0.06313170492649078, + 0.12340546399354935, + 0.028348376974463463, + 0.13157595694065094 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01420411467552185 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, gliding forward steadily above a decaying log covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny, translucent snail with a glassy amber shell visible perched on a perfectly spherical water droplet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature soft, diffused morning light filtering through unseen treetops with a dreamy quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a shimmering, iridescent trail of rainbow hues (pink, blue, and green) visible behind the snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background lush and out-of-focus, creating a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058008871972561 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955800533294678 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058008871972561, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058008871972561, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05406159162521362, + 0.6523424983024597, + 0.05414358153939247, + 0.06309469044208527, + 0.02307167649269104, + 0.057729050517082214, + 0.02821960113942623, + 0.026784932240843773, + 0.015458726324141026, + 0.02509361132979393 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058008871972561 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, gliding forward steadily above a decaying log covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny, translucent snail with a glassy amber shell visible perched on a perfectly spherical water droplet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature soft, diffused morning light filtering through unseen treetops with a dreamy quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a shimmering, iridescent trail of rainbow hues (pink, blue, and green) visible behind the snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background lush and out-of-focus, creating a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0005586970364674926 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.500558853149414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0005586970364674926, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0005586970364674926, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19153530895709991, + 0.1880767047405243, + 0.06577924638986588, + 0.26202133297920227, + 0.03355161100625992, + 0.10995141416788101, + 0.03270081430673599, + 0.06929056346416473, + 0.016084235161542892, + 0.031008683145046234 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0005586970364674926 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "From a first-person perspective, the camera glides forward steadily and deliberately, hovering above the damp, textured surface of a decaying log, covered in a vibrant, velvety carpet of green moss. Soft, diffused morning light filters through the unseen treetops with a dreamy, ethereal quality, capturing countless tiny dewdrops scattered across the moss like jewels. The camera focuses on a tiny, translucent snail, its pale, almost ghostly body delicately perched atop a perfectly spherical droplet of water, which magnifies the intricate fibers of the moss beneath. The camera continues its slow, extreme macro shot, revealing the snail's glassy, amber shell, shimmering as light refracts through its delicate, spiraling architecture. As the camera briefly passes over the creature, it captures the shimmering, iridescent trail it leaves behind: a smooth ribbon of rainbow hues (pink, blue, and green) shimmering against a lush, out-of-focus background, creating a tranquil and magical atmosphere focused on this miniature, wondrous world.", + "seed": 11262, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_3/index_2860_seed_11262_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.0637000288697891, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0637000288697891, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.224999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0637000288697891, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, gliding forward steadily above a decaying log covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny, translucent snail with a glassy amber shell visible perched on a perfectly spherical water droplet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature soft, diffused morning light filtering through unseen treetops with a dreamy quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a shimmering, iridescent trail of rainbow hues (pink, blue, and green) visible behind the snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background lush and out-of-focus, creating a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.044092245399951935 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1690921783447266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.044092245399951935, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.044092245399951935, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09010031819343567, + 0.04756586253643036, + 0.057563815265893936, + 0.13751785457134247, + 0.28330501914024353, + 0.08942167460918427, + 0.04214927554130554, + 0.042012039572000504, + 0.07716266810894012, + 0.1332014948129654 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.044092245399951935 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, gliding forward steadily above a decaying log covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny, translucent snail with a glassy amber shell visible perched on a perfectly spherical water droplet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature soft, diffused morning light filtering through unseen treetops with a dreamy quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a shimmering, iridescent trail of rainbow hues (pink, blue, and green) visible behind the snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background lush and out-of-focus, creating a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01820673607289791 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018206596374512 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01820673607289791, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01820673607289791, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08031015843153, + 0.07133984565734863, + 0.045374978333711624, + 0.09797362983226776, + 0.38611745834350586, + 0.08807460218667984, + 0.04243592917919159, + 0.04908345267176628, + 0.030225997790694237, + 0.10906392335891724 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01820673607289791 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, gliding forward steadily above a decaying log covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny, translucent snail with a glassy amber shell visible perched on a perfectly spherical water droplet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature soft, diffused morning light filtering through unseen treetops with a dreamy quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a shimmering, iridescent trail of rainbow hues (pink, blue, and green) visible behind the snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background lush and out-of-focus, creating a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031943507492542267 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753194332122803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031943507492542267, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031943507492542267, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09201116859912872, + 0.4932883083820343, + 0.028649399057030678, + 0.11314723640680313, + 0.05536503717303276, + 0.08460138738155365, + 0.03505581617355347, + 0.028761036694049835, + 0.013161088339984417, + 0.05595948174595833 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031943507492542267 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, gliding forward steadily above a decaying log covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny, translucent snail with a glassy amber shell visible perched on a perfectly spherical water droplet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature soft, diffused morning light filtering through unseen treetops with a dreamy quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a shimmering, iridescent trail of rainbow hues (pink, blue, and green) visible behind the snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background lush and out-of-focus, creating a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25208932161331177 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502089262008667 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25208932161331177, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25208932161331177, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06538838893175125, + 0.07604527473449707, + 0.042099468410015106, + 0.10685074329376221, + 0.3741445541381836, + 0.07547731697559357, + 0.04844873771071434, + 0.07953757047653198, + 0.026684075593948364, + 0.1053238958120346 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25208932161331177 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, gliding forward steadily above a decaying log covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny, translucent snail with a glassy amber shell visible perched on a perfectly spherical water droplet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature soft, diffused morning light filtering through unseen treetops with a dreamy quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a shimmering, iridescent trail of rainbow hues (pink, blue, and green) visible behind the snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background lush and out-of-focus, creating a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0009174905135296285 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.000917434692383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0009174905135296285, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0009174905135296285, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09037825465202332, + 0.13894538581371307, + 0.029445480555295944, + 0.06460918486118317, + 0.36069732904434204, + 0.07352019846439362, + 0.054556433111429214, + 0.048861291259527206, + 0.03710491582751274, + 0.10188156366348267 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0009174905135296285 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "From a first-person perspective, the camera glides forward steadily and deliberately, hovering above the damp, textured surface of a decaying log, covered in a vibrant, velvety carpet of green moss. Soft, diffused morning light filters through the unseen treetops with a dreamy, ethereal quality, capturing countless tiny dewdrops scattered across the moss like jewels. The camera focuses on a tiny, translucent snail, its pale, almost ghostly body delicately perched atop a perfectly spherical droplet of water, which magnifies the intricate fibers of the moss beneath. The camera continues its slow, extreme macro shot, revealing the snail's glassy, amber shell, shimmering as light refracts through its delicate, spiraling architecture. As the camera briefly passes over the creature, it captures the shimmering, iridescent trail it leaves behind: a smooth ribbon of rainbow hues (pink, blue, and green) shimmering against a lush, out-of-focus background, creating a tranquil and magical atmosphere focused on this miniature, wondrous world.", + "seed": 11263, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_3/index_2860_seed_11263_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03525412022136152, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03525412022136152, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03525412022136152, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, gliding forward steadily above a decaying log covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny, translucent snail with a glassy amber shell visible perched on a perfectly spherical water droplet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature soft, diffused morning light filtering through unseen treetops with a dreamy quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a shimmering, iridescent trail of rainbow hues (pink, blue, and green) visible behind the snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background lush and out-of-focus, creating a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.046603359282016754 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1716034412384033 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.046603359282016754, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.046603359282016754, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12494819611310959, + 0.056822746992111206, + 0.09191182255744934, + 0.0452546663582325, + 0.20391105115413666, + 0.04674646258354187, + 0.07343749701976776, + 0.17812097072601318, + 0.1256367564201355, + 0.05320991575717926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.046603359282016754 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, gliding forward steadily above a decaying log covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny, translucent snail with a glassy amber shell visible perched on a perfectly spherical water droplet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature soft, diffused morning light filtering through unseen treetops with a dreamy quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a shimmering, iridescent trail of rainbow hues (pink, blue, and green) visible behind the snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background lush and out-of-focus, creating a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023313695564866066 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733137607574463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023313695564866066, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023313695564866066, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06541237235069275, + 0.2167602777481079, + 0.07673811912536621, + 0.07108566164970398, + 0.09342645108699799, + 0.06289365142583847, + 0.08483554422855377, + 0.13991716504096985, + 0.12602078914642334, + 0.06290995329618454 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023313695564866066 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, gliding forward steadily above a decaying log covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny, translucent snail with a glassy amber shell visible perched on a perfectly spherical water droplet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature soft, diffused morning light filtering through unseen treetops with a dreamy quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a shimmering, iridescent trail of rainbow hues (pink, blue, and green) visible behind the snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background lush and out-of-focus, creating a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004101437050849199 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504101276397705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004101437050849199, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004101437050849199, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061345819383859634, + 0.6292203068733215, + 0.09601876884698868, + 0.03915233165025711, + 0.017596494406461716, + 0.011906668543815613, + 0.03490748256444931, + 0.021819327026605606, + 0.05850934237241745, + 0.029523463919758797 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004101437050849199 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, gliding forward steadily above a decaying log covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny, translucent snail with a glassy amber shell visible perched on a perfectly spherical water droplet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature soft, diffused morning light filtering through unseen treetops with a dreamy quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a shimmering, iridescent trail of rainbow hues (pink, blue, and green) visible behind the snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background lush and out-of-focus, creating a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10031409561634064 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350314140319824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10031409561634064, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10031409561634064, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04917287081480026, + 0.353068470954895, + 0.1814051866531372, + 0.1077040582895279, + 0.056748706847429276, + 0.016198109835386276, + 0.11063092201948166, + 0.04180005565285683, + 0.04451197385787964, + 0.038759611546993256 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10031409561634064 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perspective first-person, gliding forward steadily above a decaying log covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny, translucent snail with a glassy amber shell visible perched on a perfectly spherical water droplet?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature soft, diffused morning light filtering through unseen treetops with a dreamy quality?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a shimmering, iridescent trail of rainbow hues (pink, blue, and green) visible behind the snail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background lush and out-of-focus, creating a shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001938013592734933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.2519378662109375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001938013592734933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001938013592734933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05246139317750931, + 0.4651980996131897, + 0.11408428102731705, + 0.03582973778247833, + 0.06536691635847092, + 0.02506539225578308, + 0.1387465000152588, + 0.016721656545996666, + 0.030429955571889877, + 0.05609601363539696 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001938013592734933 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_4/index_tensor([4961, 4961])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_4/index_tensor([4961, 4961])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ff8694202509b45e0685bd32c038f6b098068130 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_4/index_tensor([4961, 4961])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle shot slowly pans to the right, following a ghostly entity through the desolate cobblestone streets of a perpetually dark town. Gothic, dilapidated buildings with crumbling, blackened windows lean precariously over the narrow streets, their jagged outlines struggling against the starless, inky sky. This entity is a ghostly double-decker bus, its form shimmering and translucent, emitting a cold, sickly green phosphorescence that fails to truly illuminate its surroundings. Its edges blur into a thick, rolling fog covering the ground, and through its hollow, empty windows, no passengers or driver can be seen. The bus does not roll on wheels, but rather glides silently and unsettlingly over the damp, gleaming cobblestones, its movement a slow, deliberate crawl that feels sentient and predatory. The bus's ethereal light serves as the primary illumination, casting long, twisted shadows that dance and writhe across the decaying facade, creating an eerie, silent atmosphere imbued with profound dread and supernatural terror.", + "seed": 29363, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_4/index_4961_seed_29363_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03187478103209287, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03187478103209287, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03187478103209287, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ghostly double-decker bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bus translucent and emitting a cold, sickly green phosphorescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bus glide silently over damp cobblestones without visible wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a desolate town with Gothic, dilapidated buildings and a starless, inky sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and slowly pan to the right following the bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.030829109251499176 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5308291912078857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.030829109251499176, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.030829109251499176, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13066843152046204, + 0.039261069148778915, + 0.06752080470323563, + 0.03550436720252037, + 0.041472047567367554, + 0.08224963396787643, + 0.20135724544525146, + 0.04818449169397354, + 0.06097116693854332, + 0.2928108274936676 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.030829109251499176 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ghostly double-decker bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bus translucent and emitting a cold, sickly green phosphorescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bus glide silently over damp cobblestones without visible wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a desolate town with Gothic, dilapidated buildings and a starless, inky sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and slowly pan to the right following the bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017254954436793923 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376725673675537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017254954436793923, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017254954436793923, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18578648567199707, + 0.057528603821992874, + 0.06542135775089264, + 0.04907025396823883, + 0.07228381186723709, + 0.061774469912052155, + 0.1880446970462799, + 0.04256592318415642, + 0.11835180222988129, + 0.15917260944843292 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017254954436793923 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ghostly double-decker bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bus translucent and emitting a cold, sickly green phosphorescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bus glide silently over damp cobblestones without visible wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a desolate town with Gothic, dilapidated buildings and a starless, inky sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and slowly pan to the right following the bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055010825395584106 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300107955932617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055010825395584106, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055010825395584106, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22464676201343536, + 0.09526138752698898, + 0.08670438081026077, + 0.07004209607839584, + 0.1820315420627594, + 0.050467412918806076, + 0.08739351481199265, + 0.02892479859292507, + 0.08177187293767929, + 0.0927562490105629 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055010825395584106 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ghostly double-decker bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bus translucent and emitting a cold, sickly green phosphorescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bus glide silently over damp cobblestones without visible wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a desolate town with Gothic, dilapidated buildings and a starless, inky sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and slowly pan to the right following the bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978058110922575 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634780406951904 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978058110922575, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978058110922575, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16531313955783844, + 0.09876756370067596, + 0.19624385237693787, + 0.027708036825060844, + 0.06430277228355408, + 0.06587337702512741, + 0.13296718895435333, + 0.03989137336611748, + 0.1022629514336586, + 0.10666970163583755 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978058110922575 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ghostly double-decker bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bus translucent and emitting a cold, sickly green phosphorescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bus glide silently over damp cobblestones without visible wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a desolate town with Gothic, dilapidated buildings and a starless, inky sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and slowly pan to the right following the bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06202789396047592 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812027931213379 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06202789396047592, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06202789396047592, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08691658079624176, + 0.0494837686419487, + 0.08509588241577148, + 0.0245698019862175, + 0.056217897683382034, + 0.06853505969047546, + 0.0634523406624794, + 0.043884750455617905, + 0.07291270792484283, + 0.4489312767982483 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06202789396047592 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle shot slowly pans to the right, following a ghostly entity through the desolate cobblestone streets of a perpetually dark town. Gothic, dilapidated buildings with crumbling, blackened windows lean precariously over the narrow streets, their jagged outlines struggling against the starless, inky sky. This entity is a ghostly double-decker bus, its form shimmering and translucent, emitting a cold, sickly green phosphorescence that fails to truly illuminate its surroundings. Its edges blur into a thick, rolling fog covering the ground, and through its hollow, empty windows, no passengers or driver can be seen. The bus does not roll on wheels, but rather glides silently and unsettlingly over the damp, gleaming cobblestones, its movement a slow, deliberate crawl that feels sentient and predatory. The bus's ethereal light serves as the primary illumination, casting long, twisted shadows that dance and writhe across the decaying facade, creating an eerie, silent atmosphere imbued with profound dread and supernatural terror.", + "seed": 29364, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_4/index_4961_seed_29364_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.025187994306907057, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025187994306907057, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025187994306907057, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ghostly double-decker bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bus translucent and emitting a cold, sickly green phosphorescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bus glide silently over damp cobblestones without visible wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a desolate town with Gothic, dilapidated buildings and a starless, inky sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and slowly pan to the right following the bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04454385116696358 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.169543743133545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04454385116696358, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04454385116696358, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06846585869789124, + 0.031927287578582764, + 0.04923246428370476, + 0.17545200884342194, + 0.0486018992960453, + 0.04067666083574295, + 0.07545411586761475, + 0.2389703243970871, + 0.11215829104185104, + 0.1590610146522522 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04454385116696358 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ghostly double-decker bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bus translucent and emitting a cold, sickly green phosphorescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bus glide silently over damp cobblestones without visible wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a desolate town with Gothic, dilapidated buildings and a starless, inky sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and slowly pan to the right following the bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019595485646277666 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251959323883057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019595485646277666, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019595485646277666, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1120513528585434, + 0.11656807363033295, + 0.03948921710252762, + 0.08378525823354721, + 0.07959901541471481, + 0.05873376503586769, + 0.03018597885966301, + 0.14251907169818878, + 0.16820451617240906, + 0.16886374354362488 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019595485646277666 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ghostly double-decker bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bus translucent and emitting a cold, sickly green phosphorescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bus glide silently over damp cobblestones without visible wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a desolate town with Gothic, dilapidated buildings and a starless, inky sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and slowly pan to the right following the bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03372080624103546 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087207317352295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03372080624103546, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03372080624103546, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13565777242183685, + 0.08217805624008179, + 0.05483486130833626, + 0.11853399872779846, + 0.18358321487903595, + 0.08630160242319107, + 0.07059969007968903, + 0.12918174266815186, + 0.044657714664936066, + 0.09447134286165237 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03372080624103546 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ghostly double-decker bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bus translucent and emitting a cold, sickly green phosphorescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bus glide silently over damp cobblestones without visible wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a desolate town with Gothic, dilapidated buildings and a starless, inky sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and slowly pan to the right following the bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076275295577943325 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882627487182617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076275295577943325, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076275295577943325, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25093069672584534, + 0.13711881637573242, + 0.04556244984269142, + 0.07305935025215149, + 0.08340013027191162, + 0.0613558404147625, + 0.041669346392154694, + 0.1805577427148819, + 0.050732072442770004, + 0.0756135880947113 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076275295577943325 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ghostly double-decker bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bus translucent and emitting a cold, sickly green phosphorescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bus glide silently over damp cobblestones without visible wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a desolate town with Gothic, dilapidated buildings and a starless, inky sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and slowly pan to the right following the bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03808823600411415 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288088321685791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03808823600411415, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03808823600411415, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22117012739181519, + 0.03909042850136757, + 0.06492537260055542, + 0.07613194733858109, + 0.09416846930980682, + 0.03663935884833336, + 0.05962762609124184, + 0.17540398240089417, + 0.1727372705936432, + 0.060105469077825546 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03808823600411415 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle shot slowly pans to the right, following a ghostly entity through the desolate cobblestone streets of a perpetually dark town. Gothic, dilapidated buildings with crumbling, blackened windows lean precariously over the narrow streets, their jagged outlines struggling against the starless, inky sky. This entity is a ghostly double-decker bus, its form shimmering and translucent, emitting a cold, sickly green phosphorescence that fails to truly illuminate its surroundings. Its edges blur into a thick, rolling fog covering the ground, and through its hollow, empty windows, no passengers or driver can be seen. The bus does not roll on wheels, but rather glides silently and unsettlingly over the damp, gleaming cobblestones, its movement a slow, deliberate crawl that feels sentient and predatory. The bus's ethereal light serves as the primary illumination, casting long, twisted shadows that dance and writhe across the decaying facade, creating an eerie, silent atmosphere imbued with profound dread and supernatural terror.", + "seed": 29365, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_4/index_4961_seed_29365_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03230749845970422, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03230749845970422, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03230749845970422, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ghostly double-decker bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bus translucent and emitting a cold, sickly green phosphorescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bus glide silently over damp cobblestones without visible wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a desolate town with Gothic, dilapidated buildings and a starless, inky sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and slowly pan to the right following the bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.024098576977849007 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7740986347198486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.024098576977849007, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.024098576977849007, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2887919545173645, + 0.13123443722724915, + 0.05026201903820038, + 0.024069003760814667, + 0.03793029114603996, + 0.023146137595176697, + 0.05702884495258331, + 0.10709300637245178, + 0.0820184126496315, + 0.19842596352100372 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.024098576977849007 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ghostly double-decker bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bus translucent and emitting a cold, sickly green phosphorescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bus glide silently over damp cobblestones without visible wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a desolate town with Gothic, dilapidated buildings and a starless, inky sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and slowly pan to the right following the bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013496108585968614 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626349449157715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013496108585968614, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013496108585968614, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2769818603992462, + 0.07465982437133789, + 0.06575845181941986, + 0.06690772622823715, + 0.03475431352853775, + 0.05321454629302025, + 0.07574424892663956, + 0.11659468710422516, + 0.1259211003780365, + 0.1094631627202034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013496108585968614 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ghostly double-decker bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bus translucent and emitting a cold, sickly green phosphorescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bus glide silently over damp cobblestones without visible wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a desolate town with Gothic, dilapidated buildings and a starless, inky sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and slowly pan to the right following the bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055008117109537125 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300081729888916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055008117109537125, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055008117109537125, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19813720881938934, + 0.1726236790418625, + 0.10603795945644379, + 0.10569803416728973, + 0.02801106683909893, + 0.03876997530460358, + 0.026341401040554047, + 0.04934599623084068, + 0.06605567783117294, + 0.20897898077964783 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055008117109537125 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ghostly double-decker bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bus translucent and emitting a cold, sickly green phosphorescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bus glide silently over damp cobblestones without visible wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a desolate town with Gothic, dilapidated buildings and a starless, inky sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and slowly pan to the right following the bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011078042909502983 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511077880859375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011078042909502983, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011078042909502983, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.267721951007843, + 0.03129195049405098, + 0.22013595700263977, + 0.08869334310293198, + 0.025222325697541237, + 0.055757075548172, + 0.033050067722797394, + 0.07574969530105591, + 0.08221349120140076, + 0.12016420066356659 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011078042909502983 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ghostly double-decker bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bus translucent and emitting a cold, sickly green phosphorescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bus glide silently over damp cobblestones without visible wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a desolate town with Gothic, dilapidated buildings and a starless, inky sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and slowly pan to the right following the bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000314444303513 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695003032684326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000314444303513, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000314444303513, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16635161638259888, + 0.06725627183914185, + 0.062492795288562775, + 0.04313467815518379, + 0.07202251255512238, + 0.14468038082122803, + 0.06366394460201263, + 0.06363116949796677, + 0.18416281044483185, + 0.13260389864444733 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000314444303513 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle shot slowly pans to the right, following a ghostly entity through the desolate cobblestone streets of a perpetually dark town. Gothic, dilapidated buildings with crumbling, blackened windows lean precariously over the narrow streets, their jagged outlines struggling against the starless, inky sky. This entity is a ghostly double-decker bus, its form shimmering and translucent, emitting a cold, sickly green phosphorescence that fails to truly illuminate its surroundings. Its edges blur into a thick, rolling fog covering the ground, and through its hollow, empty windows, no passengers or driver can be seen. The bus does not roll on wheels, but rather glides silently and unsettlingly over the damp, gleaming cobblestones, its movement a slow, deliberate crawl that feels sentient and predatory. The bus's ethereal light serves as the primary illumination, casting long, twisted shadows that dance and writhe across the decaying facade, creating an eerie, silent atmosphere imbued with profound dread and supernatural terror.", + "seed": 29366, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_4/index_4961_seed_29366_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.09847989529371262, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09847989529371262, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.449999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09847989529371262, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ghostly double-decker bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bus translucent and emitting a cold, sickly green phosphorescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bus glide silently over damp cobblestones without visible wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a desolate town with Gothic, dilapidated buildings and a starless, inky sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and slowly pan to the right following the bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3929784893989563 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1429784297943115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3929784893989563, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3929784893989563, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06083318218588829, + 0.030488405376672745, + 0.029542580246925354, + 0.04704135283827782, + 0.1078966036438942, + 0.15668678283691406, + 0.03863777220249176, + 0.4232543110847473, + 0.06150183081626892, + 0.04411712661385536 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3929784893989563 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ghostly double-decker bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bus translucent and emitting a cold, sickly green phosphorescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bus glide silently over damp cobblestones without visible wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a desolate town with Gothic, dilapidated buildings and a starless, inky sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and slowly pan to the right following the bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028435057029128075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877843379974365 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028435057029128075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028435057029128075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10092389583587646, + 0.06975483894348145, + 0.02935042604804039, + 0.13269056379795074, + 0.11795471608638763, + 0.10583209991455078, + 0.0460592582821846, + 0.24046553671360016, + 0.10253242403268814, + 0.054436299949884415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028435057029128075 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ghostly double-decker bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bus translucent and emitting a cold, sickly green phosphorescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bus glide silently over damp cobblestones without visible wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a desolate town with Gothic, dilapidated buildings and a starless, inky sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and slowly pan to the right following the bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048691000789403915 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486910343170166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048691000789403915, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048691000789403915, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17161515355110168, + 0.04570598527789116, + 0.04606570675969124, + 0.22736412286758423, + 0.09187866747379303, + 0.1010567918419838, + 0.0946822538971901, + 0.09597629308700562, + 0.05286037549376488, + 0.07279461622238159 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048691000789403915 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ghostly double-decker bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bus translucent and emitting a cold, sickly green phosphorescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bus glide silently over damp cobblestones without visible wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a desolate town with Gothic, dilapidated buildings and a starless, inky sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and slowly pan to the right following the bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014195182360708714 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264194965362549 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014195182360708714, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014195182360708714, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1548897624015808, + 0.05873449146747589, + 0.07101970165967941, + 0.25198477506637573, + 0.09225646406412125, + 0.08582904934883118, + 0.06994333118200302, + 0.11115259677171707, + 0.02145344577729702, + 0.08273638784885406 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014195182360708714 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ghostly double-decker bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the bus translucent and emitting a cold, sickly green phosphorescence?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bus glide silently over damp cobblestones without visible wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a desolate town with Gothic, dilapidated buildings and a starless, inky sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle, wide-angle shot and slowly pan to the right following the bus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033691298216581345 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.40869140625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033691298216581345, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033691298216581345, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13064876198768616, + 0.06814464181661606, + 0.11497517675161362, + 0.06228404492139816, + 0.15352986752986908, + 0.12182456254959106, + 0.05368760973215103, + 0.10199156403541565, + 0.04919442906975746, + 0.1437193602323532 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033691298216581345 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_5/index_tensor([9852, 9852])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_5/index_tensor([9852, 9852])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b2d80800b888307f6174e54d28e7bf8c1a6112cc --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_5/index_tensor([9852, 9852])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In the style of a live-action film, the camera sweeps in slow, dramatic 180-degree arcs from a low angle, circling two elite athletes locked in a fierce, physical confrontation in the low post. The offensive player, a powerful forward with muscular build and features reminiscent of Harrison Barnes, wears a crimson jersey and matching shorts, his short black hair matted with sweat. He methodically backs down his opponent, hunched over, creating space with his shoulders and back. His opponent, an equally formidable defender in a contrasting white uniform, stands firm, legs wide at the ready, forearms pressing firmly into the forward's lower back. The entire scene unfolds in dramatic slow motion under the intense, high-key glare of the stadium lights, sculpting every tense muscle and casting sharp shadows on the polished hardwood court. As they jockey for position under the basket, glistening beads of sweat spray from their foreheads, arcing through the air like tiny crystals catching bright light. The camera's tight, circling movements capture the raw strength and sheer determination etched on their faces—the clenched jaws, narrowed eyes, and flared nostrils—transforming the athletic match into a tense, pivotal cinematic scene focused entirely on a primal contest of will and strength, with the blurred crowd in the background adding to the epic scale of the moment.", + "seed": 16594, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_5/index_9852_seed_16594_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.014392032846808433, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014392032846808433, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014392032846808433, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two basketball players engaged in a physical confrontation in the low post?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the offensive player wearing a crimson jersey and matching shorts with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the defensive player wearing a white uniform with legs wide and forearms pressing into the opponent's back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in dramatic slow motion under high-key stadium lights on a polished hardwood court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep in slow 180-degree arcs from a low angle while circling the players?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01033785380423069 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.635337829589844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01033785380423069, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01033785380423069, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05458049103617668, + 0.0854915902018547, + 0.02634492702782154, + 0.034712087363004684, + 0.042483024299144745, + 0.20228330790996552, + 0.16336645185947418, + 0.27094757556915283, + 0.058964189141988754, + 0.060826290398836136 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01033785380423069 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two basketball players engaged in a physical confrontation in the low post?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the offensive player wearing a crimson jersey and matching shorts with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the defensive player wearing a white uniform with legs wide and forearms pressing into the opponent's back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in dramatic slow motion under high-key stadium lights on a polished hardwood court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep in slow 180-degree arcs from a low angle while circling the players?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005959006026387215 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309590339660645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005959006026387215, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005959006026387215, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11620720475912094, + 0.07826604694128036, + 0.040012478828430176, + 0.04477699473500252, + 0.053108956664800644, + 0.13664552569389343, + 0.15570266544818878, + 0.16781437397003174, + 0.15243947505950928, + 0.05502624437212944 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005959006026387215 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two basketball players engaged in a physical confrontation in the low post?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the offensive player wearing a crimson jersey and matching shorts with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the defensive player wearing a white uniform with legs wide and forearms pressing into the opponent's back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in dramatic slow motion under high-key stadium lights on a polished hardwood court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep in slow 180-degree arcs from a low angle while circling the players?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014195770025253296 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264195919036865 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014195770025253296, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014195770025253296, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07071494311094284, + 0.08830847591161728, + 0.04103350639343262, + 0.050115909427404404, + 0.029964609071612358, + 0.21586476266384125, + 0.1645096242427826, + 0.25519871711730957, + 0.024684110656380653, + 0.059605374932289124 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014195770025253296 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two basketball players engaged in a physical confrontation in the low post?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the offensive player wearing a crimson jersey and matching shorts with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the defensive player wearing a white uniform with legs wide and forearms pressing into the opponent's back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in dramatic slow motion under high-key stadium lights on a polished hardwood court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep in slow 180-degree arcs from a low angle while circling the players?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023288540542125702 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732884883880615 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023288540542125702, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023288540542125702, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09572584182024002, + 0.0693412721157074, + 0.037199124693870544, + 0.10894381254911423, + 0.05005805939435959, + 0.1441490203142166, + 0.12281747162342072, + 0.21583883464336395, + 0.08153814822435379, + 0.07438840717077255 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023288540542125702 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two basketball players engaged in a physical confrontation in the low post?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the offensive player wearing a crimson jersey and matching shorts with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the defensive player wearing a white uniform with legs wide and forearms pressing into the opponent's back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in dramatic slow motion under high-key stadium lights on a polished hardwood court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep in slow 180-degree arcs from a low angle while circling the players?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018178993836045265 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018178939819336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018178993836045265, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018178993836045265, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10883543640375137, + 0.10512147843837738, + 0.05215902253985405, + 0.06811296194791794, + 0.31297916173934937, + 0.1427033543586731, + 0.04088953509926796, + 0.08389893919229507, + 0.05552045255899429, + 0.02977965585887432 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018178993836045265 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the style of a live-action film, the camera sweeps in slow, dramatic 180-degree arcs from a low angle, circling two elite athletes locked in a fierce, physical confrontation in the low post. The offensive player, a powerful forward with muscular build and features reminiscent of Harrison Barnes, wears a crimson jersey and matching shorts, his short black hair matted with sweat. He methodically backs down his opponent, hunched over, creating space with his shoulders and back. His opponent, an equally formidable defender in a contrasting white uniform, stands firm, legs wide at the ready, forearms pressing firmly into the forward's lower back. The entire scene unfolds in dramatic slow motion under the intense, high-key glare of the stadium lights, sculpting every tense muscle and casting sharp shadows on the polished hardwood court. As they jockey for position under the basket, glistening beads of sweat spray from their foreheads, arcing through the air like tiny crystals catching bright light. The camera's tight, circling movements capture the raw strength and sheer determination etched on their faces—the clenched jaws, narrowed eyes, and flared nostrils—transforming the athletic match into a tense, pivotal cinematic scene focused entirely on a primal contest of will and strength, with the blurred crowd in the background adding to the epic scale of the moment.", + "seed": 16595, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_5/index_9852_seed_16595_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02920004613697529, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02920004613697529, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02920004613697529, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two basketball players engaged in a physical confrontation in the low post?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the offensive player wearing a crimson jersey and matching shorts with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the defensive player wearing a white uniform with legs wide and forearms pressing into the opponent's back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in dramatic slow motion under high-key stadium lights on a polished hardwood court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep in slow 180-degree arcs from a low angle while circling the players?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04967233166098595 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0496723651885986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04967233166098595, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04967233166098595, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.029124483466148376, + 0.035914599895477295, + 0.38581234216690063, + 0.021884875372052193, + 0.03305724263191223, + 0.05843281373381615, + 0.10968783497810364, + 0.11671142280101776, + 0.190996915102005, + 0.018377505242824554 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04967233166098595 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two basketball players engaged in a physical confrontation in the low post?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the offensive player wearing a crimson jersey and matching shorts with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the defensive player wearing a white uniform with legs wide and forearms pressing into the opponent's back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in dramatic slow motion under high-key stadium lights on a polished hardwood court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep in slow 180-degree arcs from a low angle while circling the players?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01422515232115984 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264225006103516 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01422515232115984, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01422515232115984, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12772135436534882, + 0.10022161155939102, + 0.4324650168418884, + 0.11931797116994858, + 0.027558911591768265, + 0.04636002331972122, + 0.045605577528476715, + 0.044233474880456924, + 0.04304899647831917, + 0.013466957025229931 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01422515232115984 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two basketball players engaged in a physical confrontation in the low post?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the offensive player wearing a crimson jersey and matching shorts with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the defensive player wearing a white uniform with legs wide and forearms pressing into the opponent's back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in dramatic slow motion under high-key stadium lights on a polished hardwood court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep in slow 180-degree arcs from a low angle while circling the players?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01420129369944334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2642011642456055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01420129369944334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01420129369944334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03188898414373398, + 0.023304779082536697, + 0.1782478392124176, + 0.02378997765481472, + 0.10483051091432571, + 0.08184979856014252, + 0.09420100599527359, + 0.13755078613758087, + 0.2953428030014038, + 0.02899356186389923 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01420129369944334 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two basketball players engaged in a physical confrontation in the low post?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the offensive player wearing a crimson jersey and matching shorts with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the defensive player wearing a white uniform with legs wide and forearms pressing into the opponent's back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in dramatic slow motion under high-key stadium lights on a polished hardwood court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep in slow 180-degree arcs from a low angle while circling the players?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810567781329155 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881057262420654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810567781329155, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810567781329155, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15400364995002747, + 0.0912044569849968, + 0.1981230080127716, + 0.0390457920730114, + 0.030772529542446136, + 0.05237255617976189, + 0.06032964214682579, + 0.09083543717861176, + 0.24499566853046417, + 0.038317274302244186 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810567781329155 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two basketball players engaged in a physical confrontation in the low post?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the offensive player wearing a crimson jersey and matching shorts with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the defensive player wearing a white uniform with legs wide and forearms pressing into the opponent's back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in dramatic slow motion under high-key stadium lights on a polished hardwood court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep in slow 180-degree arcs from a low angle while circling the players?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029795775189995766 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297958850860596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029795775189995766, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029795775189995766, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0585305392742157, + 0.14841920137405396, + 0.28948190808296204, + 0.02443484216928482, + 0.04544191434979439, + 0.03850023075938225, + 0.05642865598201752, + 0.060408324003219604, + 0.24457986652851105, + 0.03377455472946167 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029795775189995766 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the style of a live-action film, the camera sweeps in slow, dramatic 180-degree arcs from a low angle, circling two elite athletes locked in a fierce, physical confrontation in the low post. The offensive player, a powerful forward with muscular build and features reminiscent of Harrison Barnes, wears a crimson jersey and matching shorts, his short black hair matted with sweat. He methodically backs down his opponent, hunched over, creating space with his shoulders and back. His opponent, an equally formidable defender in a contrasting white uniform, stands firm, legs wide at the ready, forearms pressing firmly into the forward's lower back. The entire scene unfolds in dramatic slow motion under the intense, high-key glare of the stadium lights, sculpting every tense muscle and casting sharp shadows on the polished hardwood court. As they jockey for position under the basket, glistening beads of sweat spray from their foreheads, arcing through the air like tiny crystals catching bright light. The camera's tight, circling movements capture the raw strength and sheer determination etched on their faces—the clenched jaws, narrowed eyes, and flared nostrils—transforming the athletic match into a tense, pivotal cinematic scene focused entirely on a primal contest of will and strength, with the blurred crowd in the background adding to the epic scale of the moment.", + "seed": 16596, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_5/index_9852_seed_16596_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.02937681945040822, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02937681945040822, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02937681945040822, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two basketball players engaged in a physical confrontation in the low post?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the offensive player wearing a crimson jersey and matching shorts with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the defensive player wearing a white uniform with legs wide and forearms pressing into the opponent's back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in dramatic slow motion under high-key stadium lights on a polished hardwood court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep in slow 180-degree arcs from a low angle while circling the players?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0420987606048584 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2920987606048584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0420987606048584, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0420987606048584, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03280322626233101, + 0.017291134223341942, + 0.12520717084407806, + 0.023814085870981216, + 0.020911630243062973, + 0.029381681233644485, + 0.2986074686050415, + 0.2215796262025833, + 0.13455425202846527, + 0.09584974497556686 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0420987606048584 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two basketball players engaged in a physical confrontation in the low post?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the offensive player wearing a crimson jersey and matching shorts with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the defensive player wearing a white uniform with legs wide and forearms pressing into the opponent's back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in dramatic slow motion under high-key stadium lights on a polished hardwood court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep in slow 180-degree arcs from a low angle while circling the players?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007645511534065008 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882645606994629 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007645511534065008, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007645511534065008, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08214132487773895, + 0.018569139763712883, + 0.08770889043807983, + 0.06260930746793747, + 0.038982972502708435, + 0.029645325616002083, + 0.43800774216651917, + 0.06866689026355743, + 0.07624734193086624, + 0.09742104262113571 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007645511534065008 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two basketball players engaged in a physical confrontation in the low post?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the offensive player wearing a crimson jersey and matching shorts with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the defensive player wearing a white uniform with legs wide and forearms pressing into the opponent's back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in dramatic slow motion under high-key stadium lights on a polished hardwood court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep in slow 180-degree arcs from a low angle while circling the players?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011076274327933788 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110764503479 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011076274327933788, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011076274327933788, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07352177053689957, + 0.02759520709514618, + 0.1539561152458191, + 0.015578683465719223, + 0.01596357487142086, + 0.17358100414276123, + 0.18850499391555786, + 0.03628033027052879, + 0.1535354107618332, + 0.16148298978805542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011076274327933788 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two basketball players engaged in a physical confrontation in the low post?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the offensive player wearing a crimson jersey and matching shorts with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the defensive player wearing a white uniform with legs wide and forearms pressing into the opponent's back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in dramatic slow motion under high-key stadium lights on a polished hardwood court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep in slow 180-degree arcs from a low angle while circling the players?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016064966097474098 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410651206970215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016064966097474098, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016064966097474098, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12210804224014282, + 0.014839468523859978, + 0.2179267257452011, + 0.019819006323814392, + 0.017621954903006554, + 0.1483382284641266, + 0.11166690289974213, + 0.18585318326950073, + 0.11578814685344696, + 0.046038344502449036 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016064966097474098 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two basketball players engaged in a physical confrontation in the low post?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the offensive player wearing a crimson jersey and matching shorts with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the defensive player wearing a white uniform with legs wide and forearms pressing into the opponent's back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in dramatic slow motion under high-key stadium lights on a polished hardwood court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep in slow 180-degree arcs from a low angle while circling the players?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06999858468770981 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6949985027313232 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06999858468770981, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06999858468770981, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04981548711657524, + 0.024976542219519615, + 0.17396320402622223, + 0.038939591497182846, + 0.01913216896355152, + 0.07943323999643326, + 0.06505687534809113, + 0.4056275486946106, + 0.10073771327733994, + 0.04231763258576393 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06999858468770981 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the style of a live-action film, the camera sweeps in slow, dramatic 180-degree arcs from a low angle, circling two elite athletes locked in a fierce, physical confrontation in the low post. The offensive player, a powerful forward with muscular build and features reminiscent of Harrison Barnes, wears a crimson jersey and matching shorts, his short black hair matted with sweat. He methodically backs down his opponent, hunched over, creating space with his shoulders and back. His opponent, an equally formidable defender in a contrasting white uniform, stands firm, legs wide at the ready, forearms pressing firmly into the forward's lower back. The entire scene unfolds in dramatic slow motion under the intense, high-key glare of the stadium lights, sculpting every tense muscle and casting sharp shadows on the polished hardwood court. As they jockey for position under the basket, glistening beads of sweat spray from their foreheads, arcing through the air like tiny crystals catching bright light. The camera's tight, circling movements capture the raw strength and sheer determination etched on their faces—the clenched jaws, narrowed eyes, and flared nostrils—transforming the athletic match into a tense, pivotal cinematic scene focused entirely on a primal contest of will and strength, with the blurred crowd in the background adding to the epic scale of the moment.", + "seed": 16597, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_5/index_9852_seed_16597_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.022685535438358783, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022685535438358783, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022685535438358783, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two basketball players engaged in a physical confrontation in the low post?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the offensive player wearing a crimson jersey and matching shorts with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the defensive player wearing a white uniform with legs wide and forearms pressing into the opponent's back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in dramatic slow motion under high-key stadium lights on a polished hardwood court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep in slow 180-degree arcs from a low angle while circling the players?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02851288951933384 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.653512954711914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02851288951933384, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02851288951933384, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09100373089313507, + 0.10675595700740814, + 0.14820553362369537, + 0.11894059926271439, + 0.06039813160896301, + 0.09211207181215286, + 0.1347315013408661, + 0.13127125799655914, + 0.038040027022361755, + 0.07854119688272476 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02851288951933384 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two basketball players engaged in a physical confrontation in the low post?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the offensive player wearing a crimson jersey and matching shorts with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the defensive player wearing a white uniform with legs wide and forearms pressing into the opponent's back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in dramatic slow motion under high-key stadium lights on a polished hardwood court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep in slow 180-degree arcs from a low angle while circling the players?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005268855020403862 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.2552690505981445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005268855020403862, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005268855020403862, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06525835394859314, + 0.1619921326637268, + 0.424190878868103, + 0.050444815307855606, + 0.04038260877132416, + 0.06075654178857803, + 0.043100349605083466, + 0.037673406302928925, + 0.048642970621585846, + 0.0675579160451889 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005268855020403862 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two basketball players engaged in a physical confrontation in the low post?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the offensive player wearing a crimson jersey and matching shorts with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the defensive player wearing a white uniform with legs wide and forearms pressing into the opponent's back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in dramatic slow motion under high-key stadium lights on a polished hardwood court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep in slow 180-degree arcs from a low angle while circling the players?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008639576844871044 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758639812469482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008639576844871044, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008639576844871044, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1256905496120453, + 0.15108950436115265, + 0.17087247967720032, + 0.08366881310939789, + 0.06332428008317947, + 0.0926738828420639, + 0.09088169038295746, + 0.09993162006139755, + 0.04731035232543945, + 0.07455676048994064 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008639576844871044 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two basketball players engaged in a physical confrontation in the low post?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the offensive player wearing a crimson jersey and matching shorts with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the defensive player wearing a white uniform with legs wide and forearms pressing into the opponent's back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in dramatic slow motion under high-key stadium lights on a polished hardwood court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep in slow 180-degree arcs from a low angle while circling the players?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016069775447249413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410698890686035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016069775447249413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016069775447249413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1786983758211136, + 0.07277540862560272, + 0.1970437914133072, + 0.05104970186948776, + 0.166513130068779, + 0.04488780349493027, + 0.05013921856880188, + 0.0996679812669754, + 0.06912286579608917, + 0.07010169327259064 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016069775447249413 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two basketball players engaged in a physical confrontation in the low post?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the offensive player wearing a crimson jersey and matching shorts with short black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the defensive player wearing a white uniform with legs wide and forearms pressing into the opponent's back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene filmed in dramatic slow motion under high-key stadium lights on a polished hardwood court?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep in slow 180-degree arcs from a low angle while circling the players?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05493658035993576 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929936647415161 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05493658035993576, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05493658035993576, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18974849581718445, + 0.04819370061159134, + 0.17973552644252777, + 0.0546235553920269, + 0.046229660511016846, + 0.06991330534219742, + 0.12524178624153137, + 0.13087406754493713, + 0.08221719413995743, + 0.07322276383638382 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05493658035993576 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_6/index_tensor([2700, 2700])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_6/index_tensor([2700, 2700])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..087c92730e453ed6b230f1af53cab82ce394b7e5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_6/index_tensor([2700, 2700])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static macro close-up captures a captivating time-lapse of a camellia blossom, rendered in a clean, artistic style. The sequence begins with a tightly curled bud, its outer petals sealed in a perfect, compact formation. The petals slowly unfurl in a seamless, graceful, accelerated motion, carefully peeling back layer by layer to reveal the intricate structure within. The entire visual effect is defined by the gentle color gradations and crisp outlines across the petals' surfaces, imbuing the flower with a clear, almost illustrative elegance. As bloom reaches its peak, the final petals open, fully revealing the vibrant, pollen-drenched yellow stamens at their core. A soft, diffuse morning light illuminates the scene, casting soft highlights on the waxy, dark green leaves surrounding the flower and capturing a single, perfectly formed dewdrop glittering on the edge of a petal. The atmosphere is serene and focused in its beauty, with the stunning 4K resolution rendering every delicate texture and subtle color shift with surreal clarity.", + "seed": 18175, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_6/index_2700_seed_18175_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0076408189255744215, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0076408189255744215, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.524999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0076408189255744215, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video a time-lapse sequence of a camellia blossom opening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled bud with sealed outer petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the petals unfurl in a seamless, accelerated motion to reveal yellow pollen-drenched stamens at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark green leaves and a single dewdrop on a petal visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style clean, artistic, and illustrative with crisp outlines and clear color gradations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008055814541876316 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.883055686950684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008055814541876316, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008055814541876316, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09408742934465408, + 0.029646379873156548, + 0.0521385483443737, + 0.00984160415828228, + 0.018777767196297646, + 0.030887866392731667, + 0.035598818212747574, + 0.019009530544281006, + 0.02833397313952446, + 0.6816781163215637 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008055814541876316 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video a time-lapse sequence of a camellia blossom opening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled bud with sealed outer petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the petals unfurl in a seamless, accelerated motion to reveal yellow pollen-drenched stamens at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark green leaves and a single dewdrop on a petal visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style clean, artistic, and illustrative with crisp outlines and clear color gradations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036204999778419733 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628620624542236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036204999778419733, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036204999778419733, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16786415874958038, + 0.06293181329965591, + 0.08532799035310745, + 0.0683458149433136, + 0.054976776242256165, + 0.1455683410167694, + 0.026095019653439522, + 0.016496676951646805, + 0.017734790220856667, + 0.3546586036682129 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036204999778419733 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video a time-lapse sequence of a camellia blossom opening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled bud with sealed outer petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the petals unfurl in a seamless, accelerated motion to reveal yellow pollen-drenched stamens at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark green leaves and a single dewdrop on a petal visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style clean, artistic, and illustrative with crisp outlines and clear color gradations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0007246490567922592 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.250724792480469 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0007246490567922592, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0007246490567922592, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15403833985328674, + 0.015660516917705536, + 0.030119657516479492, + 0.01158533338457346, + 0.025745278224349022, + 0.03449677303433418, + 0.006381362676620483, + 0.01948598027229309, + 0.020697707310318947, + 0.681788980960846 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0007246490567922592 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video a time-lapse sequence of a camellia blossom opening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled bud with sealed outer petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the petals unfurl in a seamless, accelerated motion to reveal yellow pollen-drenched stamens at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark green leaves and a single dewdrop on a petal visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style clean, artistic, and illustrative with crisp outlines and clear color gradations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007627884857356548 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882627964019775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007627884857356548, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007627884857356548, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1674080491065979, + 0.037498749792575836, + 0.039811599999666214, + 0.03006543591618538, + 0.14244675636291504, + 0.03328052535653114, + 0.008367030881345272, + 0.015358288772404194, + 0.024919120594859123, + 0.500844419002533 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007627884857356548 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video a time-lapse sequence of a camellia blossom opening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled bud with sealed outer petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the petals unfurl in a seamless, accelerated motion to reveal yellow pollen-drenched stamens at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark green leaves and a single dewdrop on a petal visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style clean, artistic, and illustrative with crisp outlines and clear color gradations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018175246194005013 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01817512512207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018175246194005013, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018175246194005013, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21655943989753723, + 0.013885973952710629, + 0.017351144924759865, + 0.023700466379523277, + 0.03305245190858841, + 0.12488653510808945, + 0.017049342393875122, + 0.046377502381801605, + 0.034119974821805954, + 0.47301721572875977 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018175246194005013 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static macro close-up captures a captivating time-lapse of a camellia blossom, rendered in a clean, artistic style. The sequence begins with a tightly curled bud, its outer petals sealed in a perfect, compact formation. The petals slowly unfurl in a seamless, graceful, accelerated motion, carefully peeling back layer by layer to reveal the intricate structure within. The entire visual effect is defined by the gentle color gradations and crisp outlines across the petals' surfaces, imbuing the flower with a clear, almost illustrative elegance. As bloom reaches its peak, the final petals open, fully revealing the vibrant, pollen-drenched yellow stamens at their core. A soft, diffuse morning light illuminates the scene, casting soft highlights on the waxy, dark green leaves surrounding the flower and capturing a single, perfectly formed dewdrop glittering on the edge of a petal. The atmosphere is serene and focused in its beauty, with the stunning 4K resolution rendering every delicate texture and subtle color shift with surreal clarity.", + "seed": 18176, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_6/index_2700_seed_18176_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.01097324611619115, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01097324611619115, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01097324611619115, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video a time-lapse sequence of a camellia blossom opening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled bud with sealed outer petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the petals unfurl in a seamless, accelerated motion to reveal yellow pollen-drenched stamens at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark green leaves and a single dewdrop on a petal visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style clean, artistic, and illustrative with crisp outlines and clear color gradations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006425554398447275 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.631425380706787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006425554398447275, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006425554398447275, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08368466794490814, + 0.04077351465821266, + 0.12929275631904602, + 0.11869154125452042, + 0.07776834070682526, + 0.06481508165597916, + 0.05210556089878082, + 0.14763692021369934, + 0.07440942525863647, + 0.21082215011119843 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006425554398447275 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video a time-lapse sequence of a camellia blossom opening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled bud with sealed outer petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the petals unfurl in a seamless, accelerated motion to reveal yellow pollen-drenched stamens at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark green leaves and a single dewdrop on a petal visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style clean, artistic, and illustrative with crisp outlines and clear color gradations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019471748964861035 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251947402954102 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019471748964861035, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019471748964861035, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18111982941627502, + 0.19076836109161377, + 0.10006837546825409, + 0.08371898531913757, + 0.11061422526836395, + 0.12000105530023575, + 0.05369875207543373, + 0.08120289444923401, + 0.028069453313946724, + 0.0507381297647953 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019471748964861035 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video a time-lapse sequence of a camellia blossom opening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled bud with sealed outer petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the petals unfurl in a seamless, accelerated motion to reveal yellow pollen-drenched stamens at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark green leaves and a single dewdrop on a petal visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style clean, artistic, and illustrative with crisp outlines and clear color gradations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0006387577159330249 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.375638961791992 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0006387577159330249, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0006387577159330249, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2810375988483429, + 0.0861225575208664, + 0.15299564599990845, + 0.1050214171409607, + 0.05984495207667351, + 0.05926933512091637, + 0.05334651097655296, + 0.09101469814777374, + 0.07572304457426071, + 0.035624269396066666 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0006387577159330249 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video a time-lapse sequence of a camellia blossom opening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled bud with sealed outer petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the petals unfurl in a seamless, accelerated motion to reveal yellow pollen-drenched stamens at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark green leaves and a single dewdrop on a petal visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style clean, artistic, and illustrative with crisp outlines and clear color gradations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016066256910562515 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141066074371338 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016066256910562515, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016066256910562515, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20826178789138794, + 0.03838794678449631, + 0.0562325194478035, + 0.13530333340168, + 0.1847865879535675, + 0.03937947005033493, + 0.06402023136615753, + 0.0861976221203804, + 0.03389034420251846, + 0.15354014933109283 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016066256910562515 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video a time-lapse sequence of a camellia blossom opening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled bud with sealed outer petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the petals unfurl in a seamless, accelerated motion to reveal yellow pollen-drenched stamens at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark green leaves and a single dewdrop on a petal visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style clean, artistic, and illustrative with crisp outlines and clear color gradations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029788486659526825 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297884941101074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029788486659526825, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029788486659526825, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2127780169248581, + 0.10663250833749771, + 0.08387189358472824, + 0.07575094699859619, + 0.04306572675704956, + 0.03311486914753914, + 0.08843189477920532, + 0.13744980096817017, + 0.05838846042752266, + 0.1605159342288971 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029788486659526825 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static macro close-up captures a captivating time-lapse of a camellia blossom, rendered in a clean, artistic style. The sequence begins with a tightly curled bud, its outer petals sealed in a perfect, compact formation. The petals slowly unfurl in a seamless, graceful, accelerated motion, carefully peeling back layer by layer to reveal the intricate structure within. The entire visual effect is defined by the gentle color gradations and crisp outlines across the petals' surfaces, imbuing the flower with a clear, almost illustrative elegance. As bloom reaches its peak, the final petals open, fully revealing the vibrant, pollen-drenched yellow stamens at their core. A soft, diffuse morning light illuminates the scene, casting soft highlights on the waxy, dark green leaves surrounding the flower and capturing a single, perfectly formed dewdrop glittering on the edge of a petal. The atmosphere is serene and focused in its beauty, with the stunning 4K resolution rendering every delicate texture and subtle color shift with surreal clarity.", + "seed": 18177, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_6/index_2700_seed_18177_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.01017352424096316, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01017352424096316, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01017352424096316, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video a time-lapse sequence of a camellia blossom opening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled bud with sealed outer petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the petals unfurl in a seamless, accelerated motion to reveal yellow pollen-drenched stamens at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark green leaves and a single dewdrop on a petal visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style clean, artistic, and illustrative with crisp outlines and clear color gradations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008430015295743942 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.758430004119873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008430015295743942, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008430015295743942, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08680489659309387, + 0.07086987793445587, + 0.12307844310998917, + 0.15468159317970276, + 0.058571308851242065, + 0.20004670321941376, + 0.149071604013443, + 0.0413602739572525, + 0.0608464777469635, + 0.05466879904270172 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008430015295743942 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video a time-lapse sequence of a camellia blossom opening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled bud with sealed outer petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the petals unfurl in a seamless, accelerated motion to reveal yellow pollen-drenched stamens at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark green leaves and a single dewdrop on a petal visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style clean, artistic, and illustrative with crisp outlines and clear color gradations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011857867939397693 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751185894012451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011857867939397693, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011857867939397693, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3703685700893402, + 0.08077654987573624, + 0.05067411810159683, + 0.06532591581344604, + 0.03059574030339718, + 0.12890635430812836, + 0.1130790263414383, + 0.07098596543073654, + 0.060318075120449066, + 0.02896975167095661 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011857867939397693 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video a time-lapse sequence of a camellia blossom opening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled bud with sealed outer petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the petals unfurl in a seamless, accelerated motion to reveal yellow pollen-drenched stamens at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark green leaves and a single dewdrop on a petal visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style clean, artistic, and illustrative with crisp outlines and clear color gradations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0007227431051433086 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.250722885131836 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0007227431051433086, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0007227431051433086, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14486737549304962, + 0.10091157257556915, + 0.11456134170293808, + 0.11075356602668762, + 0.10500302165746689, + 0.15507173538208008, + 0.09069669991731644, + 0.03765426203608513, + 0.05353545397520065, + 0.08694493770599365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0007227431051433086 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video a time-lapse sequence of a camellia blossom opening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled bud with sealed outer petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the petals unfurl in a seamless, accelerated motion to reveal yellow pollen-drenched stamens at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark green leaves and a single dewdrop on a petal visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style clean, artistic, and illustrative with crisp outlines and clear color gradations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634294331073761 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513428688049316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634294331073761, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634294331073761, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12157372385263443, + 0.03957255929708481, + 0.06475413590669632, + 0.1108163520693779, + 0.1368909329175949, + 0.19036343693733215, + 0.2449009269475937, + 0.023008937016129494, + 0.04397101327776909, + 0.024148033931851387 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634294331073761 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video a time-lapse sequence of a camellia blossom opening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled bud with sealed outer petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the petals unfurl in a seamless, accelerated motion to reveal yellow pollen-drenched stamens at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark green leaves and a single dewdrop on a petal visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style clean, artistic, and illustrative with crisp outlines and clear color gradations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014186132699251175 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264185905456543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014186132699251175, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014186132699251175, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28266310691833496, + 0.09917985647916794, + 0.0975978747010231, + 0.03751886263489723, + 0.1269407719373703, + 0.11155013740062714, + 0.0669914186000824, + 0.05359065532684326, + 0.03726533427834511, + 0.08670200407505035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014186132699251175 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static macro close-up captures a captivating time-lapse of a camellia blossom, rendered in a clean, artistic style. The sequence begins with a tightly curled bud, its outer petals sealed in a perfect, compact formation. The petals slowly unfurl in a seamless, graceful, accelerated motion, carefully peeling back layer by layer to reveal the intricate structure within. The entire visual effect is defined by the gentle color gradations and crisp outlines across the petals' surfaces, imbuing the flower with a clear, almost illustrative elegance. As bloom reaches its peak, the final petals open, fully revealing the vibrant, pollen-drenched yellow stamens at their core. A soft, diffuse morning light illuminates the scene, casting soft highlights on the waxy, dark green leaves surrounding the flower and capturing a single, perfectly formed dewdrop glittering on the edge of a petal. The atmosphere is serene and focused in its beauty, with the stunning 4K resolution rendering every delicate texture and subtle color shift with surreal clarity.", + "seed": 18178, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_6/index_2700_seed_18178_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.007279980729799717, + "vlm_logprob": -0.007279980729799717, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.007279980729799717, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video a time-lapse sequence of a camellia blossom opening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled bud with sealed outer petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the petals unfurl in a seamless, accelerated motion to reveal yellow pollen-drenched stamens at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark green leaves and a single dewdrop on a petal visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style clean, artistic, and illustrative with crisp outlines and clear color gradations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00438727717846632 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.129387378692627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00438727717846632, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00438727717846632, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19516849517822266, + 0.09909577667713165, + 0.1088123694062233, + 0.07688247412443161, + 0.10782582312822342, + 0.1499544084072113, + 0.08002671599388123, + 0.041467443108558655, + 0.07259025424718857, + 0.0681762620806694 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00438727717846632 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video a time-lapse sequence of a camellia blossom opening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled bud with sealed outer petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the petals unfurl in a seamless, accelerated motion to reveal yellow pollen-drenched stamens at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark green leaves and a single dewdrop on a petal visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style clean, artistic, and illustrative with crisp outlines and clear color gradations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002201516181230545 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127201557159424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002201516181230545, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002201516181230545, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23207437992095947, + 0.18906977772712708, + 0.11318082362413406, + 0.0543016716837883, + 0.14738593995571136, + 0.07743055373430252, + 0.04425898939371109, + 0.05475204437971115, + 0.04408198222517967, + 0.043463852256536484 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002201516181230545 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video a time-lapse sequence of a camellia blossom opening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled bud with sealed outer petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the petals unfurl in a seamless, accelerated motion to reveal yellow pollen-drenched stamens at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark green leaves and a single dewdrop on a petal visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style clean, artistic, and illustrative with crisp outlines and clear color gradations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0005644158809445798 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.5005645751953125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0005644158809445798, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0005644158809445798, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1198347806930542, + 0.08091419190168381, + 0.05900181457400322, + 0.09878631681203842, + 0.14317895472049713, + 0.11923035979270935, + 0.08342529833316803, + 0.12776081264019012, + 0.045439135283231735, + 0.12242836505174637 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0005644158809445798 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video a time-lapse sequence of a camellia blossom opening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled bud with sealed outer petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the petals unfurl in a seamless, accelerated motion to reveal yellow pollen-drenched stamens at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark green leaves and a single dewdrop on a petal visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style clean, artistic, and illustrative with crisp outlines and clear color gradations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011072265915572643 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511072158813477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011072265915572643, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011072265915572643, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19922234117984772, + 0.19394758343696594, + 0.06884777545928955, + 0.08632717281579971, + 0.04774633049964905, + 0.05500912666320801, + 0.11886952817440033, + 0.12155411392450333, + 0.03296034410595894, + 0.07551561295986176 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011072265915572643 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video a time-lapse sequence of a camellia blossom opening?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the sequence begin with a tightly curled bud with sealed outer petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the petals unfurl in a seamless, accelerated motion to reveal yellow pollen-drenched stamens at the core?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are dark green leaves and a single dewdrop on a petal visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style clean, artistic, and illustrative with crisp outlines and clear color gradations?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0181744284927845 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018174648284912 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0181744284927845, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0181744284927845, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2103801965713501, + 0.09194505959749222, + 0.038052529096603394, + 0.05554226413369179, + 0.19616924226284027, + 0.06588060408830643, + 0.11981650441884995, + 0.09770562499761581, + 0.07157480716705322, + 0.0529332235455513 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0181744284927845 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_7/index_tensor([1498, 1498])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_7/index_tensor([1498, 1498])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1ee1825b0472b155904a97fe35f718b044564837 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_7/index_tensor([1498, 1498])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The first-person shot begins with a hand appearing in the frame, its skin weathered, its knuckles slightly reddened by the cold. The sleeve of a dark green waxed canvas jacket is visible at the wrist. The hand grips the cool, heavy black cast iron handle of a massive, dark oak door, its surface showing deep veins and years of weathering. Steady and deliberate, the hand pulls the door shut; as the heavy boards swing shut with a low groan, the warm golden light from within gradually fades, finally fading as the door closes with a solid, unmistakable thud, plunging the scene into the cool, aimless light of the outdoors. The camera, mimicking a human gaze, pauses for a moment before turning to face a narrow, winding dirt path that disappears into a dense, old-growth forest. Tall pines and birches, their trunks saturated with moisture and partially encrusted with green moss, form a thick canopy overhead. A thick, rolling fog blankets the forest floor, enveloping the gnarled roots and damp fallen leaves in a soft, ethereal grey, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and profound isolation as the camera begins to move forward at a steady walking pace, into the heart of the misty forest.", + "seed": 24468, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_7/index_1498_seed_24468_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.041092911968007684, + "vlm_logprob": -0.041092911968007684, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.041092911968007684, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective showing a weathered hand gripping a black cast iron door handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the door made of dark oak with visible deep veins and weathering, and does it close to block warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene after the door closes set in a dense old-growth forest with tall pines and birches covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the forest floor covered in a thick rolling fog and damp fallen leaves under a canopy of tall trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward at a steady walking pace along a narrow winding dirt path into the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01310591772198677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.388105869293213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01310591772198677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01310591772198677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05317530781030655, + 0.045137256383895874, + 0.06345445662736893, + 0.018366914242506027, + 0.11148214340209961, + 0.020102770999073982, + 0.1520235240459442, + 0.4632812738418579, + 0.04504167661070824, + 0.027934661135077477 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01310591772198677 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective showing a weathered hand gripping a black cast iron door handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the door made of dark oak with visible deep veins and weathering, and does it close to block warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene after the door closes set in a dense old-growth forest with tall pines and birches covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the forest floor covered in a thick rolling fog and damp fallen leaves under a canopy of tall trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward at a steady walking pace along a narrow winding dirt path into the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17988866567611694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048887252807617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17988866567611694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17988866567611694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.039545346051454544, + 0.07722893357276917, + 0.04778914153575897, + 0.02466680109500885, + 0.16499678790569305, + 0.039285916835069656, + 0.2103506326675415, + 0.3407694399356842, + 0.04046466946601868, + 0.014902358874678612 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17988866567611694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective showing a weathered hand gripping a black cast iron door handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the door made of dark oak with visible deep veins and weathering, and does it close to block warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene after the door closes set in a dense old-growth forest with tall pines and birches covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the forest floor covered in a thick rolling fog and damp fallen leaves under a canopy of tall trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward at a steady walking pace along a narrow winding dirt path into the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036106412298977375 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628610610961914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036106412298977375, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036106412298977375, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03385050967335701, + 0.05014808848500252, + 0.0405222587287426, + 0.02594580315053463, + 0.13804656267166138, + 0.08227291703224182, + 0.10813816636800766, + 0.18215115368366241, + 0.17743107676506042, + 0.1614934355020523 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036106412298977375 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective showing a weathered hand gripping a black cast iron door handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the door made of dark oak with visible deep veins and weathering, and does it close to block warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene after the door closes set in a dense old-growth forest with tall pines and birches covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the forest floor covered in a thick rolling fog and damp fallen leaves under a canopy of tall trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward at a steady walking pace along a narrow winding dirt path into the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005249762907624245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255249977111816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005249762907624245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005249762907624245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04398437216877937, + 0.028240861371159554, + 0.046946942806243896, + 0.04323428124189377, + 0.07454264909029007, + 0.06646714359521866, + 0.18060337007045746, + 0.32014554738998413, + 0.07103262841701508, + 0.12480214983224869 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005249762907624245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective showing a weathered hand gripping a black cast iron door handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the door made of dark oak with visible deep veins and weathering, and does it close to block warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene after the door closes set in a dense old-growth forest with tall pines and birches covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the forest floor covered in a thick rolling fog and damp fallen leaves under a canopy of tall trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward at a steady walking pace along a narrow winding dirt path into the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036095723044127226 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628609657287598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036095723044127226, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036095723044127226, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.051886577159166336, + 0.04988361522555351, + 0.04428381472826004, + 0.04829224571585655, + 0.04772739112377167, + 0.04522102698683739, + 0.1803625524044037, + 0.20082733035087585, + 0.20682835578918457, + 0.12468710541725159 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036095723044127226 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The first-person shot begins with a hand appearing in the frame, its skin weathered, its knuckles slightly reddened by the cold. The sleeve of a dark green waxed canvas jacket is visible at the wrist. The hand grips the cool, heavy black cast iron handle of a massive, dark oak door, its surface showing deep veins and years of weathering. Steady and deliberate, the hand pulls the door shut; as the heavy boards swing shut with a low groan, the warm golden light from within gradually fades, finally fading as the door closes with a solid, unmistakable thud, plunging the scene into the cool, aimless light of the outdoors. The camera, mimicking a human gaze, pauses for a moment before turning to face a narrow, winding dirt path that disappears into a dense, old-growth forest. Tall pines and birches, their trunks saturated with moisture and partially encrusted with green moss, form a thick canopy overhead. A thick, rolling fog blankets the forest floor, enveloping the gnarled roots and damp fallen leaves in a soft, ethereal grey, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and profound isolation as the camera begins to move forward at a steady walking pace, into the heart of the misty forest.", + "seed": 24469, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_7/index_1498_seed_24469_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02586567047983408, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02586567047983408, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02586567047983408, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective showing a weathered hand gripping a black cast iron door handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the door made of dark oak with visible deep veins and weathering, and does it close to block warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene after the door closes set in a dense old-growth forest with tall pines and birches covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the forest floor covered in a thick rolling fog and damp fallen leaves under a canopy of tall trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward at a steady walking pace along a narrow winding dirt path into the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02664954401552677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6516494750976562 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02664954401552677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02664954401552677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20249103009700775, + 0.048425182700157166, + 0.0939568504691124, + 0.062084563076496124, + 0.08579230308532715, + 0.04750719293951988, + 0.08750396966934204, + 0.21836020052433014, + 0.13425809144973755, + 0.019620582461357117 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02664954401552677 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective showing a weathered hand gripping a black cast iron door handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the door made of dark oak with visible deep veins and weathering, and does it close to block warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene after the door closes set in a dense old-growth forest with tall pines and birches covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the forest floor covered in a thick rolling fog and damp fallen leaves under a canopy of tall trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward at a steady walking pace along a narrow winding dirt path into the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08904175460338593 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640417098999023 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08904175460338593, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08904175460338593, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08400988578796387, + 0.157533660531044, + 0.032538264989852905, + 0.09766885638237, + 0.4252850115299225, + 0.07666076719760895, + 0.03986130654811859, + 0.044289421290159225, + 0.022283587604761124, + 0.019869232550263405 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08904175460338593 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective showing a weathered hand gripping a black cast iron door handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the door made of dark oak with visible deep veins and weathering, and does it close to block warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene after the door closes set in a dense old-growth forest with tall pines and birches covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the forest floor covered in a thick rolling fog and damp fallen leaves under a canopy of tall trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward at a steady walking pace along a narrow winding dirt path into the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028139064088463783 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877813816070557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028139064088463783, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028139064088463783, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15060940384864807, + 0.05372694507241249, + 0.05768958479166031, + 0.13084210455417633, + 0.17514283955097198, + 0.10954845696687698, + 0.07149031013250351, + 0.07556725293397903, + 0.09323646873235703, + 0.08214667439460754 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028139064088463783 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective showing a weathered hand gripping a black cast iron door handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the door made of dark oak with visible deep veins and weathering, and does it close to block warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene after the door closes set in a dense old-growth forest with tall pines and birches covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the forest floor covered in a thick rolling fog and damp fallen leaves under a canopy of tall trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward at a steady walking pace along a narrow winding dirt path into the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006734294816851616 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006734371185303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006734294816851616, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006734294816851616, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0642625167965889, + 0.06882134824991226, + 0.027438605204224586, + 0.07632904499769211, + 0.1705426275730133, + 0.05947508662939072, + 0.0588177852332592, + 0.15240304172039032, + 0.2894860804080963, + 0.03242386877536774 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006734294816851616 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective showing a weathered hand gripping a black cast iron door handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the door made of dark oak with visible deep veins and weathering, and does it close to block warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene after the door closes set in a dense old-growth forest with tall pines and birches covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the forest floor covered in a thick rolling fog and damp fallen leaves under a canopy of tall trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward at a steady walking pace along a narrow winding dirt path into the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004088852554559708 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504088878631592 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004088852554559708, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004088852554559708, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18079568445682526, + 0.07516983151435852, + 0.051865968853235245, + 0.1284419596195221, + 0.1167650893330574, + 0.0786631777882576, + 0.06875789910554886, + 0.10162353515625, + 0.12094078212976456, + 0.07697615027427673 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004088852554559708 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The first-person shot begins with a hand appearing in the frame, its skin weathered, its knuckles slightly reddened by the cold. The sleeve of a dark green waxed canvas jacket is visible at the wrist. The hand grips the cool, heavy black cast iron handle of a massive, dark oak door, its surface showing deep veins and years of weathering. Steady and deliberate, the hand pulls the door shut; as the heavy boards swing shut with a low groan, the warm golden light from within gradually fades, finally fading as the door closes with a solid, unmistakable thud, plunging the scene into the cool, aimless light of the outdoors. The camera, mimicking a human gaze, pauses for a moment before turning to face a narrow, winding dirt path that disappears into a dense, old-growth forest. Tall pines and birches, their trunks saturated with moisture and partially encrusted with green moss, form a thick canopy overhead. A thick, rolling fog blankets the forest floor, enveloping the gnarled roots and damp fallen leaves in a soft, ethereal grey, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and profound isolation as the camera begins to move forward at a steady walking pace, into the heart of the misty forest.", + "seed": 24470, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_7/index_1498_seed_24470_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.030524415103718637, + "vlm_logprob": -0.030524415103718637, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.030524415103718637, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective showing a weathered hand gripping a black cast iron door handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the door made of dark oak with visible deep veins and weathering, and does it close to block warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene after the door closes set in a dense old-growth forest with tall pines and birches covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the forest floor covered in a thick rolling fog and damp fallen leaves under a canopy of tall trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward at a steady walking pace along a narrow winding dirt path into the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02673334628343582 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6517333984375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02673334628343582, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02673334628343582, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14704322814941406, + 0.2861933708190918, + 0.04049133136868477, + 0.07826104015111923, + 0.10224296152591705, + 0.09291668981313705, + 0.03950610011816025, + 0.06956189125776291, + 0.11663185805082321, + 0.02715158462524414 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02673334628343582 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective showing a weathered hand gripping a black cast iron door handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the door made of dark oak with visible deep veins and weathering, and does it close to block warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene after the door closes set in a dense old-growth forest with tall pines and birches covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the forest floor covered in a thick rolling fog and damp fallen leaves under a canopy of tall trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward at a steady walking pace along a narrow winding dirt path into the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11294267326593399 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237942695617676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11294267326593399, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11294267326593399, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09757005423307419, + 0.276721715927124, + 0.03671032935380936, + 0.07505817711353302, + 0.0933673307299614, + 0.06602771580219269, + 0.09395679086446762, + 0.06647972017526627, + 0.07635264843702316, + 0.1177554652094841 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11294267326593399 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective showing a weathered hand gripping a black cast iron door handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the door made of dark oak with visible deep veins and weathering, and does it close to block warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene after the door closes set in a dense old-growth forest with tall pines and birches covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the forest floor covered in a thick rolling fog and damp fallen leaves under a canopy of tall trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward at a steady walking pace along a narrow winding dirt path into the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003609928535297513 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628610134124756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003609928535297513, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003609928535297513, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07393904030323029, + 0.11805572360754013, + 0.050705686211586, + 0.07981245219707489, + 0.0843556746840477, + 0.07638150453567505, + 0.1176106333732605, + 0.16842666268348694, + 0.1513938456773758, + 0.07931872457265854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003609928535297513 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective showing a weathered hand gripping a black cast iron door handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the door made of dark oak with visible deep veins and weathering, and does it close to block warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene after the door closes set in a dense old-growth forest with tall pines and birches covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the forest floor covered in a thick rolling fog and damp fallen leaves under a canopy of tall trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward at a steady walking pace along a narrow winding dirt path into the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004091108217835426 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504091262817383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004091108217835426, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004091108217835426, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.054230473935604095, + 0.08117835223674774, + 0.01890505850315094, + 0.0311456136405468, + 0.02708989381790161, + 0.02729097753763199, + 0.07386291027069092, + 0.13402026891708374, + 0.10127104818820953, + 0.4510054588317871 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004091108217835426 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective showing a weathered hand gripping a black cast iron door handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the door made of dark oak with visible deep veins and weathering, and does it close to block warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene after the door closes set in a dense old-growth forest with tall pines and birches covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the forest floor covered in a thick rolling fog and damp fallen leaves under a canopy of tall trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward at a steady walking pace along a narrow winding dirt path into the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005245019216090441 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255245208740234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005245019216090441, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005245019216090441, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06909353286027908, + 0.13640211522579193, + 0.03460768610239029, + 0.06450936943292618, + 0.034498147666454315, + 0.027117013931274414, + 0.1787700653076172, + 0.11270978301763535, + 0.24300123751163483, + 0.09929107129573822 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005245019216090441 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The first-person shot begins with a hand appearing in the frame, its skin weathered, its knuckles slightly reddened by the cold. The sleeve of a dark green waxed canvas jacket is visible at the wrist. The hand grips the cool, heavy black cast iron handle of a massive, dark oak door, its surface showing deep veins and years of weathering. Steady and deliberate, the hand pulls the door shut; as the heavy boards swing shut with a low groan, the warm golden light from within gradually fades, finally fading as the door closes with a solid, unmistakable thud, plunging the scene into the cool, aimless light of the outdoors. The camera, mimicking a human gaze, pauses for a moment before turning to face a narrow, winding dirt path that disappears into a dense, old-growth forest. Tall pines and birches, their trunks saturated with moisture and partially encrusted with green moss, form a thick canopy overhead. A thick, rolling fog blankets the forest floor, enveloping the gnarled roots and damp fallen leaves in a soft, ethereal grey, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and profound isolation as the camera begins to move forward at a steady walking pace, into the heart of the misty forest.", + "seed": 24471, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_7/index_1498_seed_24471_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.014939799788407981, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014939799788407981, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014939799788407981, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective showing a weathered hand gripping a black cast iron door handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the door made of dark oak with visible deep veins and weathering, and does it close to block warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene after the door closes set in a dense old-growth forest with tall pines and birches covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the forest floor covered in a thick rolling fog and damp fallen leaves under a canopy of tall trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward at a steady walking pace along a narrow winding dirt path into the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013269800692796707 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.388269901275635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013269800692796707, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013269800692796707, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6607244610786438, + 0.06616921722888947, + 0.022385001182556152, + 0.07276377826929092, + 0.02669360488653183, + 0.023944435641169548, + 0.04255257546901703, + 0.03585914522409439, + 0.01855659671127796, + 0.030351273715496063 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013269800692796707 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective showing a weathered hand gripping a black cast iron door handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the door made of dark oak with visible deep veins and weathering, and does it close to block warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene after the door closes set in a dense old-growth forest with tall pines and birches covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the forest floor covered in a thick rolling fog and damp fallen leaves under a canopy of tall trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward at a steady walking pace along a narrow winding dirt path into the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05497054383158684 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299705028533936 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05497054383158684, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05497054383158684, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14359226822853088, + 0.322118878364563, + 0.026551326736807823, + 0.15025243163108826, + 0.060943759977817535, + 0.05899658799171448, + 0.06410010159015656, + 0.03355072811245918, + 0.030592340975999832, + 0.10930157452821732 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05497054383158684 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective showing a weathered hand gripping a black cast iron door handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the door made of dark oak with visible deep veins and weathering, and does it close to block warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene after the door closes set in a dense old-growth forest with tall pines and birches covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the forest floor covered in a thick rolling fog and damp fallen leaves under a canopy of tall trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward at a steady walking pace along a narrow winding dirt path into the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013335392577573657 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626333713531494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013335392577573657, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013335392577573657, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19626986980438232, + 0.06325015425682068, + 0.06861123442649841, + 0.06632989645004272, + 0.049973923712968826, + 0.07629915326833725, + 0.128381609916687, + 0.16733257472515106, + 0.0725783258676529, + 0.11097333580255508 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013335392577573657 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective showing a weathered hand gripping a black cast iron door handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the door made of dark oak with visible deep veins and weathering, and does it close to block warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene after the door closes set in a dense old-growth forest with tall pines and birches covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the forest floor covered in a thick rolling fog and damp fallen leaves under a canopy of tall trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward at a steady walking pace along a narrow winding dirt path into the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019375376868993044 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251937389373779 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019375376868993044, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019375376868993044, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1689341515302658, + 0.0400208979845047, + 0.026578927412629128, + 0.02686171606183052, + 0.018748663365840912, + 0.047039955854415894, + 0.10786375403404236, + 0.09985840320587158, + 0.05042592063546181, + 0.41366761922836304 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019375376868993044 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective showing a weathered hand gripping a black cast iron door handle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the door made of dark oak with visible deep veins and weathering, and does it close to block warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene after the door closes set in a dense old-growth forest with tall pines and birches covered in green moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the forest floor covered in a thick rolling fog and damp fallen leaves under a canopy of tall trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move forward at a steady walking pace along a narrow winding dirt path into the forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003187577472999692 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753187656402588 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003187577472999692, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003187577472999692, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3500308096408844, + 0.04962519556283951, + 0.03667805343866348, + 0.04952317476272583, + 0.0315626822412014, + 0.03639448061585426, + 0.12956662476062775, + 0.07801207900047302, + 0.06880106031894684, + 0.16980578005313873 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003187577472999692 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_8/index_tensor([6057, 6057])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_8/index_tensor([6057, 6057])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b9c255e88e8956f96d54de64a3d9477ac930af71 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_8/index_tensor([6057, 6057])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, slow, sideways tracking shot glides silently across the crystal-clear deep blue waters. Sunlight filters down from the surface, casting a mesmerizing, ever-shifting network of caustic patterns across the seafloor. A massive great white shark lies motionless on the pristine, white, sandy seafloor, its massive body casting a long, soft shadow. As the camera drifts over its head, surreal details are breathtaking: its unblinking black eyes bereft of ancient wisdom, its mouth slightly open, revealing the edges of jagged teeth. The camera's steady movement captures the rough, sandpaper-like texture of its gray dorsal skin, faintly scarred and subtly freckled, telling the story of a life of predation, contrasting starkly with its pristine white underbelly. The only movement is the slow, rhythmic, and powerful pulsation of its five enormous gill slits, which open and close in a deliberate, life-sustaining rhythm. The camera continues its slow progress along the creature's flank, past its massive pectoral fins and towering dorsal fin, emphasizing its immense scale and creating an atmosphere of quiet majesty and immense, dormant power.", + "seed": 28532, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_8/index_6057_seed_28532_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.015707221534103154, + "vlm_logprob": -0.015707221534103154, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.015707221534103154, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep blue, crystal-clear water with sunlight filtering down to create caustic patterns on the seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive great white shark lying motionless on a pristine white sandy seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shark have unblinking black eyes, a slightly open mouth with jagged teeth, and gray dorsal skin with faint scars and freckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the only visible movement the slow, rhythmic pulsation of the shark's five enormous gill slits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sideways tracking shot that glides over the shark's head and along its flank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015150941908359528 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.265151023864746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015150941908359528, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015150941908359528, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1801653653383255, + 0.1295415312051773, + 0.11149004101753235, + 0.12966497242450714, + 0.05726685747504234, + 0.037045445293188095, + 0.024880744516849518, + 0.20984452962875366, + 0.050214577466249466, + 0.0698859766125679 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015150941908359528 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep blue, crystal-clear water with sunlight filtering down to create caustic patterns on the seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive great white shark lying motionless on a pristine white sandy seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shark have unblinking black eyes, a slightly open mouth with jagged teeth, and gray dorsal skin with faint scars and freckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the only visible movement the slow, rhythmic pulsation of the shark's five enormous gill slits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sideways tracking shot that glides over the shark's head and along its flank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014221508987247944 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264221668243408 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014221508987247944, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014221508987247944, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09746314585208893, + 0.11442074179649353, + 0.11749251186847687, + 0.10900448262691498, + 0.16984307765960693, + 0.10056065768003464, + 0.05740858614444733, + 0.10256905108690262, + 0.0660155639052391, + 0.06522221863269806 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014221508987247944 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep blue, crystal-clear water with sunlight filtering down to create caustic patterns on the seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive great white shark lying motionless on a pristine white sandy seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shark have unblinking black eyes, a slightly open mouth with jagged teeth, and gray dorsal skin with faint scars and freckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the only visible movement the slow, rhythmic pulsation of the shark's five enormous gill slits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sideways tracking shot that glides over the shark's head and along its flank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00674353027716279 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006743431091309 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00674353027716279, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00674353027716279, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15814712643623352, + 0.05399107187986374, + 0.04903382062911987, + 0.02561364136636257, + 0.05711128190159798, + 0.02153599262237549, + 0.03537668660283089, + 0.509280800819397, + 0.03486669063568115, + 0.05504290387034416 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00674353027716279 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep blue, crystal-clear water with sunlight filtering down to create caustic patterns on the seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive great white shark lying motionless on a pristine white sandy seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shark have unblinking black eyes, a slightly open mouth with jagged teeth, and gray dorsal skin with faint scars and freckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the only visible movement the slow, rhythmic pulsation of the shark's five enormous gill slits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sideways tracking shot that glides over the shark's head and along its flank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02635258063673973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651352643966675 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02635258063673973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02635258063673973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11771570891141891, + 0.12565714120864868, + 0.07656027376651764, + 0.03148603439331055, + 0.0902036502957344, + 0.02252783253788948, + 0.036893997341394424, + 0.3865465819835663, + 0.05431172996759415, + 0.05809707194566727 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02635258063673973 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep blue, crystal-clear water with sunlight filtering down to create caustic patterns on the seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive great white shark lying motionless on a pristine white sandy seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shark have unblinking black eyes, a slightly open mouth with jagged teeth, and gray dorsal skin with faint scars and freckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the only visible movement the slow, rhythmic pulsation of the shark's five enormous gill slits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sideways tracking shot that glides over the shark's head and along its flank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016067545861005783 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410675048828125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016067545861005783, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016067545861005783, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.059699635952711105, + 0.0683804452419281, + 0.08812739700078964, + 0.07154334336519241, + 0.1880023032426834, + 0.03247004747390747, + 0.034578315913677216, + 0.40196436643600464, + 0.031256671994924545, + 0.023977484554052353 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016067545861005783 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, slow, sideways tracking shot glides silently across the crystal-clear deep blue waters. Sunlight filters down from the surface, casting a mesmerizing, ever-shifting network of caustic patterns across the seafloor. A massive great white shark lies motionless on the pristine, white, sandy seafloor, its massive body casting a long, soft shadow. As the camera drifts over its head, surreal details are breathtaking: its unblinking black eyes bereft of ancient wisdom, its mouth slightly open, revealing the edges of jagged teeth. The camera's steady movement captures the rough, sandpaper-like texture of its gray dorsal skin, faintly scarred and subtly freckled, telling the story of a life of predation, contrasting starkly with its pristine white underbelly. The only movement is the slow, rhythmic, and powerful pulsation of its five enormous gill slits, which open and close in a deliberate, life-sustaining rhythm. The camera continues its slow progress along the creature's flank, past its massive pectoral fins and towering dorsal fin, emphasizing its immense scale and creating an atmosphere of quiet majesty and immense, dormant power.", + "seed": 28533, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_8/index_6057_seed_28533_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.31433967798948287, + "vlm_logprob": -0.31433967798948287, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.31433967798948287, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep blue, crystal-clear water with sunlight filtering down to create caustic patterns on the seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive great white shark lying motionless on a pristine white sandy seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shark have unblinking black eyes, a slightly open mouth with jagged teeth, and gray dorsal skin with faint scars and freckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the only visible movement the slow, rhythmic pulsation of the shark's five enormous gill slits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sideways tracking shot that glides over the shark's head and along its flank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1282701939344406 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.128270149230957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1282701939344406, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1282701939344406, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12687519192695618, + 0.08460964262485504, + 0.0563068650662899, + 0.25754934549331665, + 0.07412655651569366, + 0.06650485098361969, + 0.04655402898788452, + 0.04980114847421646, + 0.1811128854751587, + 0.05655955523252487 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1282701939344406 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep blue, crystal-clear water with sunlight filtering down to create caustic patterns on the seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive great white shark lying motionless on a pristine white sandy seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shark have unblinking black eyes, a slightly open mouth with jagged teeth, and gray dorsal skin with faint scars and freckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the only visible movement the slow, rhythmic pulsation of the shark's five enormous gill slits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sideways tracking shot that glides over the shark's head and along its flank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134430646896362 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31344306468963623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.3134430646896362, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.3134430646896362, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.050718240439891815, + 0.05474543571472168, + 0.07470785826444626, + 0.05181949585676193, + 0.030560040846467018, + 0.05231665074825287, + 0.03048350289463997, + 0.03753509745001793, + 0.5834126472473145, + 0.03370103985071182 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.3134430646896362 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep blue, crystal-clear water with sunlight filtering down to create caustic patterns on the seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive great white shark lying motionless on a pristine white sandy seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shark have unblinking black eyes, a slightly open mouth with jagged teeth, and gray dorsal skin with faint scars and freckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the only visible movement the slow, rhythmic pulsation of the shark's five enormous gill slits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sideways tracking shot that glides over the shark's head and along its flank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04875707998871803 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0487570762634277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04875707998871803, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04875707998871803, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06308063864707947, + 0.05513780936598778, + 0.04463587701320648, + 0.08655688166618347, + 0.0303946565836668, + 0.030737247318029404, + 0.022631922736763954, + 0.03869842737913132, + 0.5894953608512878, + 0.038631148636341095 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04875707998871803 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep blue, crystal-clear water with sunlight filtering down to create caustic patterns on the seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive great white shark lying motionless on a pristine white sandy seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shark have unblinking black eyes, a slightly open mouth with jagged teeth, and gray dorsal skin with faint scars and freckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the only visible movement the slow, rhythmic pulsation of the shark's five enormous gill slits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sideways tracking shot that glides over the shark's head and along its flank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04311101511120796 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1681110858917236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04311101511120796, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04311101511120796, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07886748760938644, + 0.0803728923201561, + 0.09978140890598297, + 0.07368535548448563, + 0.04079875349998474, + 0.08297344297170639, + 0.056957487016916275, + 0.05726015195250511, + 0.36144134402275085, + 0.06786169111728668 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04311101511120796 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep blue, crystal-clear water with sunlight filtering down to create caustic patterns on the seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive great white shark lying motionless on a pristine white sandy seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shark have unblinking black eyes, a slightly open mouth with jagged teeth, and gray dorsal skin with faint scars and freckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the only visible movement the slow, rhythmic pulsation of the shark's five enormous gill slits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sideways tracking shot that glides over the shark's head and along its flank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811703622341156 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288116931915283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811703622341156, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811703622341156, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10021774470806122, + 0.06334319710731506, + 0.11898989975452423, + 0.14932073652744293, + 0.06243224814534187, + 0.08398306369781494, + 0.08843019604682922, + 0.0803796648979187, + 0.1834404170513153, + 0.06946281343698502 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811703622341156 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, slow, sideways tracking shot glides silently across the crystal-clear deep blue waters. Sunlight filters down from the surface, casting a mesmerizing, ever-shifting network of caustic patterns across the seafloor. A massive great white shark lies motionless on the pristine, white, sandy seafloor, its massive body casting a long, soft shadow. As the camera drifts over its head, surreal details are breathtaking: its unblinking black eyes bereft of ancient wisdom, its mouth slightly open, revealing the edges of jagged teeth. The camera's steady movement captures the rough, sandpaper-like texture of its gray dorsal skin, faintly scarred and subtly freckled, telling the story of a life of predation, contrasting starkly with its pristine white underbelly. The only movement is the slow, rhythmic, and powerful pulsation of its five enormous gill slits, which open and close in a deliberate, life-sustaining rhythm. The camera continues its slow progress along the creature's flank, past its massive pectoral fins and towering dorsal fin, emphasizing its immense scale and creating an atmosphere of quiet majesty and immense, dormant power.", + "seed": 28534, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_8/index_6057_seed_28534_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.020951183699071407, + "vlm_logprob": -0.020951183699071407, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.020951183699071407, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep blue, crystal-clear water with sunlight filtering down to create caustic patterns on the seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive great white shark lying motionless on a pristine white sandy seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shark have unblinking black eyes, a slightly open mouth with jagged teeth, and gray dorsal skin with faint scars and freckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the only visible movement the slow, rhythmic pulsation of the shark's five enormous gill slits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sideways tracking shot that glides over the shark's head and along its flank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016813941299915314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1418137550354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016813941299915314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016813941299915314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3011334240436554, + 0.10075782984495163, + 0.10465322434902191, + 0.0326160229742527, + 0.05398775264620781, + 0.037961382418870926, + 0.07614966481924057, + 0.08097590506076813, + 0.0812113881111145, + 0.13055340945720673 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016813941299915314 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep blue, crystal-clear water with sunlight filtering down to create caustic patterns on the seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive great white shark lying motionless on a pristine white sandy seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shark have unblinking black eyes, a slightly open mouth with jagged teeth, and gray dorsal skin with faint scars and freckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the only visible movement the slow, rhythmic pulsation of the shark's five enormous gill slits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sideways tracking shot that glides over the shark's head and along its flank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038130808621644974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288130760192871 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038130808621644974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038130808621644974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18103544414043427, + 0.12003486603498459, + 0.07828930765390396, + 0.025967830792069435, + 0.048048436641693115, + 0.04221154749393463, + 0.10899356007575989, + 0.09575632959604263, + 0.0889495462179184, + 0.2107132077217102 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038130808621644974 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep blue, crystal-clear water with sunlight filtering down to create caustic patterns on the seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive great white shark lying motionless on a pristine white sandy seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shark have unblinking black eyes, a slightly open mouth with jagged teeth, and gray dorsal skin with faint scars and freckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the only visible movement the slow, rhythmic pulsation of the shark's five enormous gill slits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sideways tracking shot that glides over the shark's head and along its flank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008646904490888119 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586469650268555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008646904490888119, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008646904490888119, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18647880852222443, + 0.10830874741077423, + 0.06609585881233215, + 0.04106287285685539, + 0.05976304039359093, + 0.05481729283928871, + 0.1278591752052307, + 0.08221189677715302, + 0.12069479376077652, + 0.1527075171470642 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008646904490888119 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep blue, crystal-clear water with sunlight filtering down to create caustic patterns on the seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive great white shark lying motionless on a pristine white sandy seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shark have unblinking black eyes, a slightly open mouth with jagged teeth, and gray dorsal skin with faint scars and freckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the only visible movement the slow, rhythmic pulsation of the shark's five enormous gill slits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sideways tracking shot that glides over the shark's head and along its flank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020588964223861694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955888748168945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020588964223861694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020588964223861694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16648365557193756, + 0.11342865973711014, + 0.0684715211391449, + 0.041068412363529205, + 0.05365707352757454, + 0.057742729783058167, + 0.15666235983371735, + 0.10580310225486755, + 0.1348758488893509, + 0.1018066331744194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020588964223861694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep blue, crystal-clear water with sunlight filtering down to create caustic patterns on the seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive great white shark lying motionless on a pristine white sandy seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shark have unblinking black eyes, a slightly open mouth with jagged teeth, and gray dorsal skin with faint scars and freckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the only visible movement the slow, rhythmic pulsation of the shark's five enormous gill slits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sideways tracking shot that glides over the shark's head and along its flank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020575299859046936 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955752849578857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020575299859046936, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020575299859046936, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16124270856380463, + 0.050195515155792236, + 0.046533338725566864, + 0.03780446574091911, + 0.05845801159739494, + 0.05768069997429848, + 0.10377504676580429, + 0.16397716104984283, + 0.14792224764823914, + 0.17241086065769196 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020575299859046936 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, slow, sideways tracking shot glides silently across the crystal-clear deep blue waters. Sunlight filters down from the surface, casting a mesmerizing, ever-shifting network of caustic patterns across the seafloor. A massive great white shark lies motionless on the pristine, white, sandy seafloor, its massive body casting a long, soft shadow. As the camera drifts over its head, surreal details are breathtaking: its unblinking black eyes bereft of ancient wisdom, its mouth slightly open, revealing the edges of jagged teeth. The camera's steady movement captures the rough, sandpaper-like texture of its gray dorsal skin, faintly scarred and subtly freckled, telling the story of a life of predation, contrasting starkly with its pristine white underbelly. The only movement is the slow, rhythmic, and powerful pulsation of its five enormous gill slits, which open and close in a deliberate, life-sustaining rhythm. The camera continues its slow progress along the creature's flank, past its massive pectoral fins and towering dorsal fin, emphasizing its immense scale and creating an atmosphere of quiet majesty and immense, dormant power.", + "seed": 28535, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_8/index_6057_seed_28535_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.02018676996231079, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02018676996231079, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02018676996231079, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep blue, crystal-clear water with sunlight filtering down to create caustic patterns on the seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive great white shark lying motionless on a pristine white sandy seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shark have unblinking black eyes, a slightly open mouth with jagged teeth, and gray dorsal skin with faint scars and freckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the only visible movement the slow, rhythmic pulsation of the shark's five enormous gill slits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sideways tracking shot that glides over the shark's head and along its flank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023818664252758026 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7738187313079834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023818664252758026, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023818664252758026, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06914403289556503, + 0.058544889092445374, + 0.15127284824848175, + 0.11218012869358063, + 0.037678062915802, + 0.3635653555393219, + 0.06879094988107681, + 0.042867109179496765, + 0.034001778811216354, + 0.06195490062236786 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023818664252758026 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep blue, crystal-clear water with sunlight filtering down to create caustic patterns on the seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive great white shark lying motionless on a pristine white sandy seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shark have unblinking black eyes, a slightly open mouth with jagged teeth, and gray dorsal skin with faint scars and freckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the only visible movement the slow, rhythmic pulsation of the shark's five enormous gill slits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sideways tracking shot that glides over the shark's head and along its flank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02982921525835991 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529829263687134 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02982921525835991, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02982921525835991, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05203365162014961, + 0.07661166787147522, + 0.17855091392993927, + 0.1171669289469719, + 0.050290707498788834, + 0.2612641155719757, + 0.05540180206298828, + 0.05153164267539978, + 0.08237365633249283, + 0.0747748613357544 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02982921525835991 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep blue, crystal-clear water with sunlight filtering down to create caustic patterns on the seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive great white shark lying motionless on a pristine white sandy seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shark have unblinking black eyes, a slightly open mouth with jagged teeth, and gray dorsal skin with faint scars and freckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the only visible movement the slow, rhythmic pulsation of the shark's five enormous gill slits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sideways tracking shot that glides over the shark's head and along its flank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01420881599187851 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264208793640137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01420881599187851, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01420881599187851, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05758098512887955, + 0.03783637657761574, + 0.12298569828271866, + 0.0872439444065094, + 0.03574083745479584, + 0.3669518232345581, + 0.07751479744911194, + 0.031173383817076683, + 0.08602273464202881, + 0.09694942831993103 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01420881599187851 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep blue, crystal-clear water with sunlight filtering down to create caustic patterns on the seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive great white shark lying motionless on a pristine white sandy seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shark have unblinking black eyes, a slightly open mouth with jagged teeth, and gray dorsal skin with faint scars and freckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the only visible movement the slow, rhythmic pulsation of the shark's five enormous gill slits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sideways tracking shot that glides over the shark's head and along its flank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023296808823943138 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.77329683303833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023296808823943138, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023296808823943138, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04618187993764877, + 0.04760701209306717, + 0.12287432700395584, + 0.04014572128653526, + 0.03512924164533615, + 0.5230677723884583, + 0.031297631561756134, + 0.026114951819181442, + 0.07130815088748932, + 0.05627334862947464 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023296808823943138 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in deep blue, crystal-clear water with sunlight filtering down to create caustic patterns on the seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive great white shark lying motionless on a pristine white sandy seafloor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the shark have unblinking black eyes, a slightly open mouth with jagged teeth, and gray dorsal skin with faint scars and freckles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the only visible movement the slow, rhythmic pulsation of the shark's five enormous gill slits?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sideways tracking shot that glides over the shark's head and along its flank?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009780345484614372 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634780406951904 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009780345484614372, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009780345484614372, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04247888922691345, + 0.06399520486593246, + 0.09656185656785965, + 0.030792972072958946, + 0.016659589484333992, + 0.42131590843200684, + 0.11721890419721603, + 0.0252962838858366, + 0.13139821588993073, + 0.054282210767269135 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009780345484614372 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_9/index_tensor([7067, 7067])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_9/index_tensor([7067, 7067])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9ee304874dbbfba295dfb9f3c3a67fd401a9aa6e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_9/index_tensor([7067, 7067])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "This stunning, surreal extreme wide shot, rendered in the stunning Unreal Engine style, captures the vast Arctic landscape, the camera held nearly still yet trembling in sync with the violent tremors sweeping across the Earth. A low, golden sun hangs near the horizon, casting long, dramatic shadows and bathing the scene in a warm, ethereal glow that contrasts sharply with the frigid surroundings. In the distant background, massive, jagged mountains capped by thick, ancient ice begin to experience massive avalanches, their slopes collapsing in thunderous plumes of shifting snow and ice debris. In the foreground, the catastrophe is imminent and visceral: a vast glacial ice cap cracks under the pressure, deep blue spiderwebs of cracks rapidly tearing through its pristine white surface. The entire event unfolds at a fluid high frame rate, capturing in pristine, fluid clarity how each fissure throws a column of exploding ice into the air, sparkling like diamonds in the low light, while vast expanses of ice tumble and grind, revealing the glacier's sapphire depths. The atmosphere is one of terrifying, sublime beauty, an earth-shattering event rendered in stunning, lifelike detail.", + "seed": 117, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_9/index_7067_seed_117_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.29091693349182607, + "vlm_logprob": -0.29091693349182607, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.29091693349182607, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot that is held nearly still yet trembling in sync with violent tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a low golden sun visible near the horizon casting long shadows and a warm ethereal glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive jagged mountains capped with thick ancient ice visible in the distant background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vast glacial ice cap in the foreground cracking with deep blue spiderweb fissures and throwing columns of exploding ice into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video depict avalanches occurring on the mountain slopes with thunderous plumes of shifting snow and ice debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1626291126012802 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9126291275024414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1626291126012802, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1626291126012802, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3558635711669922, + 0.03954499587416649, + 0.03546777740120888, + 0.03786148503422737, + 0.07120367139577866, + 0.07562550902366638, + 0.026933491230010986, + 0.23006094992160797, + 0.0672457292675972, + 0.060192834585905075 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1626291126012802 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot that is held nearly still yet trembling in sync with violent tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a low golden sun visible near the horizon casting long shadows and a warm ethereal glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive jagged mountains capped with thick ancient ice visible in the distant background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vast glacial ice cap in the foreground cracking with deep blue spiderweb fissures and throwing columns of exploding ice into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video depict avalanches occurring on the mountain slopes with thunderous plumes of shifting snow and ice debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011095372959971428 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110955238342285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011095372959971428, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011095372959971428, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13503997027873993, + 0.047401074320077896, + 0.08924925327301025, + 0.05757724866271019, + 0.08365980535745621, + 0.21602745354175568, + 0.04609566926956177, + 0.1092250645160675, + 0.06931502372026443, + 0.14640939235687256 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011095372959971428 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot that is held nearly still yet trembling in sync with violent tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a low golden sun visible near the horizon casting long shadows and a warm ethereal glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive jagged mountains capped with thick ancient ice visible in the distant background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vast glacial ice cap in the foreground cracking with deep blue spiderweb fissures and throwing columns of exploding ice into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video depict avalanches occurring on the mountain slopes with thunderous plumes of shifting snow and ice debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306808114051819 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680681705474854 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306808114051819, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306808114051819, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3285914361476898, + 0.06276600062847137, + 0.03634832426905632, + 0.039805322885513306, + 0.060512296855449677, + 0.40042850375175476, + 0.009942411445081234, + 0.03700603172183037, + 0.014560085721313953, + 0.010039580054581165 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306808114051819 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot that is held nearly still yet trembling in sync with violent tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a low golden sun visible near the horizon casting long shadows and a warm ethereal glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive jagged mountains capped with thick ancient ice visible in the distant background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vast glacial ice cap in the foreground cracking with deep blue spiderweb fissures and throwing columns of exploding ice into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video depict avalanches occurring on the mountain slopes with thunderous plumes of shifting snow and ice debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014204349368810654 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264204502105713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014204349368810654, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014204349368810654, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1417296975851059, + 0.0612313449382782, + 0.12041693925857544, + 0.04071294143795967, + 0.10709729045629501, + 0.09324309974908829, + 0.034571416676044464, + 0.18172712624073029, + 0.1665724813938141, + 0.05269765108823776 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014204349368810654 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot that is held nearly still yet trembling in sync with violent tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a low golden sun visible near the horizon casting long shadows and a warm ethereal glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive jagged mountains capped with thick ancient ice visible in the distant background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vast glacial ice cap in the foreground cracking with deep blue spiderweb fissures and throwing columns of exploding ice into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video depict avalanches occurring on the mountain slopes with thunderous plumes of shifting snow and ice debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2235877513885498 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3485877513885498 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2235877513885498, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2235877513885498, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06032317504286766, + 0.03068045899271965, + 0.054586417973041534, + 0.03639232739806175, + 0.072614386677742, + 0.41473275423049927, + 0.029377903789281845, + 0.1255568563938141, + 0.06325804442167282, + 0.11247766762971878 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2235877513885498 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This stunning, surreal extreme wide shot, rendered in the stunning Unreal Engine style, captures the vast Arctic landscape, the camera held nearly still yet trembling in sync with the violent tremors sweeping across the Earth. A low, golden sun hangs near the horizon, casting long, dramatic shadows and bathing the scene in a warm, ethereal glow that contrasts sharply with the frigid surroundings. In the distant background, massive, jagged mountains capped by thick, ancient ice begin to experience massive avalanches, their slopes collapsing in thunderous plumes of shifting snow and ice debris. In the foreground, the catastrophe is imminent and visceral: a vast glacial ice cap cracks under the pressure, deep blue spiderwebs of cracks rapidly tearing through its pristine white surface. The entire event unfolds at a fluid high frame rate, capturing in pristine, fluid clarity how each fissure throws a column of exploding ice into the air, sparkling like diamonds in the low light, while vast expanses of ice tumble and grind, revealing the glacier's sapphire depths. The atmosphere is one of terrifying, sublime beauty, an earth-shattering event rendered in stunning, lifelike detail.", + "seed": 118, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_9/index_7067_seed_118_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2613799382001162, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2613799382001162, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2613799382001162, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot that is held nearly still yet trembling in sync with violent tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a low golden sun visible near the horizon casting long shadows and a warm ethereal glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive jagged mountains capped with thick ancient ice visible in the distant background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vast glacial ice cap in the foreground cracking with deep blue spiderweb fissures and throwing columns of exploding ice into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video depict avalanches occurring on the mountain slopes with thunderous plumes of shifting snow and ice debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1827826350927353 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8077826499938965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1827826350927353, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1827826350927353, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23422344028949738, + 0.043768756091594696, + 0.028040291741490364, + 0.06401170790195465, + 0.03777661547064781, + 0.03537258133292198, + 0.15025214850902557, + 0.06389674544334412, + 0.16463471949100494, + 0.17802299559116364 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1827826350927353 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot that is held nearly still yet trembling in sync with violent tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a low golden sun visible near the horizon casting long shadows and a warm ethereal glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive jagged mountains capped with thick ancient ice visible in the distant background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vast glacial ice cap in the foreground cracking with deep blue spiderweb fissures and throwing columns of exploding ice into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video depict avalanches occurring on the mountain slopes with thunderous plumes of shifting snow and ice debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011093251407146454 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110931396484375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011093251407146454, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011093251407146454, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2202364206314087, + 0.08095286041498184, + 0.03830808028578758, + 0.0989040806889534, + 0.03037392906844616, + 0.028775470331311226, + 0.08923608809709549, + 0.05329582840204239, + 0.25177082419395447, + 0.10814640671014786 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011093251407146454 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot that is held nearly still yet trembling in sync with violent tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a low golden sun visible near the horizon casting long shadows and a warm ethereal glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive jagged mountains capped with thick ancient ice visible in the distant background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vast glacial ice cap in the foreground cracking with deep blue spiderweb fissures and throwing columns of exploding ice into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video depict avalanches occurring on the mountain slopes with thunderous plumes of shifting snow and ice debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306625574827194 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680662631988525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306625574827194, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306625574827194, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09679242968559265, + 0.026452835649251938, + 0.02417735755443573, + 0.31642571091651917, + 0.012902896851301193, + 0.012483314611017704, + 0.03737978637218475, + 0.010673100128769875, + 0.12117327749729156, + 0.34153932332992554 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306625574827194 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot that is held nearly still yet trembling in sync with violent tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a low golden sun visible near the horizon casting long shadows and a warm ethereal glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive jagged mountains capped with thick ancient ice visible in the distant background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vast glacial ice cap in the foreground cracking with deep blue spiderweb fissures and throwing columns of exploding ice into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video depict avalanches occurring on the mountain slopes with thunderous plumes of shifting snow and ice debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607411541044712 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141074180603027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607411541044712, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607411541044712, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14838333427906036, + 0.02034577541053295, + 0.029929334297776222, + 0.044725026935338974, + 0.06108869984745979, + 0.029467185959219933, + 0.13604603707790375, + 0.11989033967256546, + 0.31927409768104553, + 0.09085018932819366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607411541044712 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot that is held nearly still yet trembling in sync with violent tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a low golden sun visible near the horizon casting long shadows and a warm ethereal glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive jagged mountains capped with thick ancient ice visible in the distant background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vast glacial ice cap in the foreground cracking with deep blue spiderweb fissures and throwing columns of exploding ice into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video depict avalanches occurring on the mountain slopes with thunderous plumes of shifting snow and ice debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.05388343334198 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42888343334198 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.05388343334198, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.05388343334198, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18489857017993927, + 0.04729731008410454, + 0.02279634401202202, + 0.1414206624031067, + 0.030442791059613228, + 0.021668193861842155, + 0.0754401907324791, + 0.05477270856499672, + 0.10594415664672852, + 0.31531912088394165 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.05388343334198 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This stunning, surreal extreme wide shot, rendered in the stunning Unreal Engine style, captures the vast Arctic landscape, the camera held nearly still yet trembling in sync with the violent tremors sweeping across the Earth. A low, golden sun hangs near the horizon, casting long, dramatic shadows and bathing the scene in a warm, ethereal glow that contrasts sharply with the frigid surroundings. In the distant background, massive, jagged mountains capped by thick, ancient ice begin to experience massive avalanches, their slopes collapsing in thunderous plumes of shifting snow and ice debris. In the foreground, the catastrophe is imminent and visceral: a vast glacial ice cap cracks under the pressure, deep blue spiderwebs of cracks rapidly tearing through its pristine white surface. The entire event unfolds at a fluid high frame rate, capturing in pristine, fluid clarity how each fissure throws a column of exploding ice into the air, sparkling like diamonds in the low light, while vast expanses of ice tumble and grind, revealing the glacier's sapphire depths. The atmosphere is one of terrifying, sublime beauty, an earth-shattering event rendered in stunning, lifelike detail.", + "seed": 119, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_9/index_7067_seed_119_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.2771659584250301, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2771659584250301, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2771659584250301, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot that is held nearly still yet trembling in sync with violent tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a low golden sun visible near the horizon casting long shadows and a warm ethereal glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive jagged mountains capped with thick ancient ice visible in the distant background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vast glacial ice cap in the foreground cracking with deep blue spiderweb fissures and throwing columns of exploding ice into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video depict avalanches occurring on the mountain slopes with thunderous plumes of shifting snow and ice debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.031298525631427765 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5312986373901367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.031298525631427765, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.031298525631427765, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11000131815671921, + 0.04326244071125984, + 0.5027151107788086, + 0.05296029895544052, + 0.04492242634296417, + 0.051848459988832474, + 0.036656975746154785, + 0.02398833818733692, + 0.08675911277532578, + 0.04688550904393196 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.031298525631427765 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot that is held nearly still yet trembling in sync with violent tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a low golden sun visible near the horizon casting long shadows and a warm ethereal glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive jagged mountains capped with thick ancient ice visible in the distant background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vast glacial ice cap in the foreground cracking with deep blue spiderweb fissures and throwing columns of exploding ice into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video depict avalanches occurring on the mountain slopes with thunderous plumes of shifting snow and ice debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014211871661245823 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264211654663086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014211871661245823, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014211871661245823, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.279847651720047, + 0.18727095425128937, + 0.04189084842801094, + 0.053597960621118546, + 0.04104224964976311, + 0.07991819083690643, + 0.04408833011984825, + 0.14295446872711182, + 0.06468047201633453, + 0.06470879167318344 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014211871661245823 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot that is held nearly still yet trembling in sync with violent tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a low golden sun visible near the horizon casting long shadows and a warm ethereal glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive jagged mountains capped with thick ancient ice visible in the distant background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vast glacial ice cap in the foreground cracking with deep blue spiderweb fissures and throwing columns of exploding ice into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video depict avalanches occurring on the mountain slopes with thunderous plumes of shifting snow and ice debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023290986195206642 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732908725738525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023290986195206642, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023290986195206642, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2541029155254364, + 0.067405566573143, + 0.287207692861557, + 0.09489627927541733, + 0.043485481292009354, + 0.03895654156804085, + 0.03422880917787552, + 0.07734064757823944, + 0.06520040333271027, + 0.037175629287958145 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023290986195206642 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot that is held nearly still yet trembling in sync with violent tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a low golden sun visible near the horizon casting long shadows and a warm ethereal glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive jagged mountains capped with thick ancient ice visible in the distant background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vast glacial ice cap in the foreground cracking with deep blue spiderweb fissures and throwing columns of exploding ice into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video depict avalanches occurring on the mountain slopes with thunderous plumes of shifting snow and ice debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003617530455812812 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628617763519287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003617530455812812, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003617530455812812, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15387596189975739, + 0.05433318763971329, + 0.22275705635547638, + 0.04937834292650223, + 0.029304582625627518, + 0.043137118220329285, + 0.15929259359836578, + 0.07745834439992905, + 0.09393925219774246, + 0.11652351915836334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003617530455812812 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot that is held nearly still yet trembling in sync with violent tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a low golden sun visible near the horizon casting long shadows and a warm ethereal glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive jagged mountains capped with thick ancient ice visible in the distant background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vast glacial ice cap in the foreground cracking with deep blue spiderweb fissures and throwing columns of exploding ice into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video depict avalanches occurring on the mountain slopes with thunderous plumes of shifting snow and ice debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134108781814575 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31341084837913513 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.3134108781814575, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.3134108781814575, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22606050968170166, + 0.09367715567350388, + 0.07010708004236221, + 0.043934211134910583, + 0.1026335284113884, + 0.11647597700357437, + 0.15181048214435577, + 0.0533565953373909, + 0.08499230444431305, + 0.056952137500047684 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.3134108781814575 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This stunning, surreal extreme wide shot, rendered in the stunning Unreal Engine style, captures the vast Arctic landscape, the camera held nearly still yet trembling in sync with the violent tremors sweeping across the Earth. A low, golden sun hangs near the horizon, casting long, dramatic shadows and bathing the scene in a warm, ethereal glow that contrasts sharply with the frigid surroundings. In the distant background, massive, jagged mountains capped by thick, ancient ice begin to experience massive avalanches, their slopes collapsing in thunderous plumes of shifting snow and ice debris. In the foreground, the catastrophe is imminent and visceral: a vast glacial ice cap cracks under the pressure, deep blue spiderwebs of cracks rapidly tearing through its pristine white surface. The entire event unfolds at a fluid high frame rate, capturing in pristine, fluid clarity how each fissure throws a column of exploding ice into the air, sparkling like diamonds in the low light, while vast expanses of ice tumble and grind, revealing the glacier's sapphire depths. The atmosphere is one of terrifying, sublime beauty, an earth-shattering event rendered in stunning, lifelike detail.", + "seed": 120, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000206/group_9/index_7067_seed_120_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.19382243864238263, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19382243864238263, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19382243864238263, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot that is held nearly still yet trembling in sync with violent tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a low golden sun visible near the horizon casting long shadows and a warm ethereal glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive jagged mountains capped with thick ancient ice visible in the distant background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vast glacial ice cap in the foreground cracking with deep blue spiderweb fissures and throwing columns of exploding ice into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video depict avalanches occurring on the mountain slopes with thunderous plumes of shifting snow and ice debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06393656879663467 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.813936471939087 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06393656879663467, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06393656879663467, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15225110948085785, + 0.03269137442111969, + 0.10659847408533096, + 0.17881201207637787, + 0.06406271457672119, + 0.053037021309137344, + 0.06712688505649567, + 0.12080688029527664, + 0.11381638795137405, + 0.11079715937376022 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06393656879663467 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot that is held nearly still yet trembling in sync with violent tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a low golden sun visible near the horizon casting long shadows and a warm ethereal glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive jagged mountains capped with thick ancient ice visible in the distant background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vast glacial ice cap in the foreground cracking with deep blue spiderweb fissures and throwing columns of exploding ice into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video depict avalanches occurring on the mountain slopes with thunderous plumes of shifting snow and ice debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048671696335077286 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486717224121094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048671696335077286, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048671696335077286, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27992862462997437, + 0.21982909739017487, + 0.08455213904380798, + 0.041223134845495224, + 0.07184374332427979, + 0.08512519299983978, + 0.09288331866264343, + 0.022461334243416786, + 0.07399529963731766, + 0.028158167377114296 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048671696335077286 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot that is held nearly still yet trembling in sync with violent tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a low golden sun visible near the horizon casting long shadows and a warm ethereal glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive jagged mountains capped with thick ancient ice visible in the distant background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vast glacial ice cap in the foreground cracking with deep blue spiderweb fissures and throwing columns of exploding ice into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video depict avalanches occurring on the mountain slopes with thunderous plumes of shifting snow and ice debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0205827746540308 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895582675933838 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0205827746540308, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0205827746540308, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09788434952497482, + 0.05032172054052353, + 0.14230339229106903, + 0.07235205173492432, + 0.0784074068069458, + 0.3123999536037445, + 0.05201451852917671, + 0.08332282304763794, + 0.05689762905240059, + 0.05409615486860275 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0205827746540308 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot that is held nearly still yet trembling in sync with violent tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a low golden sun visible near the horizon casting long shadows and a warm ethereal glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive jagged mountains capped with thick ancient ice visible in the distant background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vast glacial ice cap in the foreground cracking with deep blue spiderweb fissures and throwing columns of exploding ice into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video depict avalanches occurring on the mountain slopes with thunderous plumes of shifting snow and ice debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0097876638174057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634787559509277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0097876638174057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0097876638174057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11018364876508713, + 0.055568236857652664, + 0.12914857268333435, + 0.06832239031791687, + 0.08940139412879944, + 0.12681394815444946, + 0.0880618616938591, + 0.20212596654891968, + 0.03259679675102234, + 0.09777718037366867 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0097876638174057 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an extreme wide shot that is held nearly still yet trembling in sync with violent tremors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a low golden sun visible near the horizon casting long shadows and a warm ethereal glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are massive jagged mountains capped with thick ancient ice visible in the distant background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a vast glacial ice cap in the foreground cracking with deep blue spiderweb fissures and throwing columns of exploding ice into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video depict avalanches occurring on the mountain slopes with thunderous plumes of shifting snow and ice debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261334896087646 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761334896087646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8261334896087646, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8261334896087646, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10012524574995041, + 0.045351434499025345, + 0.1742750108242035, + 0.05662799999117851, + 0.06705928593873978, + 0.09199520945549011, + 0.05072029307484627, + 0.10913567990064621, + 0.10421749949455261, + 0.20049232244491577 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8261334896087646 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_0/index_tensor([9570, 9570])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_0/index_tensor([9570, 9570])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..033a63f67c7a9d5201708fbf9bd0d2def32c4fe6 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_0/index_tensor([9570, 9570])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot captures an intimate and dynamic scene surrounding a dark wooden dining table in a warmly lit room. The primary focus is on two men seated among several other softly focused individuals. The first man, wearing a simple white T-shirt that accentuates his animated movements and with tousled light brown hair, enthusiastically participates in the conversation. He gestures energetically, waving his arms in expressive arcs and swaying his upper body in rhythm with his unspoken words. Opposite him, a man in a heather-gray crewneck sweater listens intently, his posture more reserved. He nods slowly and deliberately in response, his mouth slightly open, as if in awe or about to speak. The man in white suddenly and gently turns, picks up a piece of food from a nearby plate, leans forward, and steadily and deliberately feeds it to the man in gray, who accepts without hesitation. Then, the man in white smoothly rises from his chair and stands behind his friend, gently but firmly holding the seated man's head with both hands, looking down with a focused and affectionate expression, creating a quiet, emotional scene under the soft and strange overhead lighting, bathing the scene in a warm and intimate glow.", + "seed": 2622, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_0/index_9570_seed_2622_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.3354087799787521, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3354087799787521, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3354087799787521, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a dark wooden dining table visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man wearing a white T-shirt and light brown hair visible gesturing energetically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt feed food to a man in a heather-gray crewneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt stand behind the seated man and hold his head with both hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1767170429229736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42671704292297363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1767170429229736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1767170429229736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05458928644657135, + 0.07527797669172287, + 0.20658139884471893, + 0.14218750596046448, + 0.07155867666006088, + 0.03301490098237991, + 0.05448654666543007, + 0.10383564978837967, + 0.11190792918205261, + 0.1465601623058319 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1767170429229736 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a dark wooden dining table visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man wearing a white T-shirt and light brown hair visible gesturing energetically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt feed food to a man in a heather-gray crewneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt stand behind the seated man and hold his head with both hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20163922011852264 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.701639175415039 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20163922011852264, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20163922011852264, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12213624268770218, + 0.03883843123912811, + 0.3542448878288269, + 0.1266046166419983, + 0.13169333338737488, + 0.017341909930109978, + 0.030493654310703278, + 0.029864279553294182, + 0.02665063552558422, + 0.12213200330734253 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20163922011852264 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a dark wooden dining table visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man wearing a white T-shirt and light brown hair visible gesturing energetically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt feed food to a man in a heather-gray crewneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt stand behind the seated man and hold his head with both hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04868929833173752 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048689365386963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04868929833173752, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04868929833173752, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04768126830458641, + 0.02484709583222866, + 0.15222378075122833, + 0.12135499715805054, + 0.04854441061615944, + 0.026649218052625656, + 0.046858835965394974, + 0.07699842751026154, + 0.040148112922906876, + 0.41469380259513855 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04868929833173752 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a dark wooden dining table visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man wearing a white T-shirt and light brown hair visible gesturing energetically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt feed food to a man in a heather-gray crewneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt stand behind the seated man and hold his head with both hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17993606626987457 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049360513687134 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17993606626987457, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17993606626987457, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06964442133903503, + 0.043801549822092056, + 0.1301403045654297, + 0.22676245868206024, + 0.06384406983852386, + 0.04562627524137497, + 0.03815785050392151, + 0.04605839401483536, + 0.09824018180370331, + 0.23772455751895905 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17993606626987457 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a dark wooden dining table visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man wearing a white T-shirt and light brown hair visible gesturing energetically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt feed food to a man in a heather-gray crewneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt stand behind the seated man and hold his head with both hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07006227225065231 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950621604919434 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07006227225065231, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07006227225065231, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09045709669589996, + 0.0630023255944252, + 0.17419938743114471, + 0.07783965766429901, + 0.05074109882116318, + 0.09175566583871841, + 0.064596027135849, + 0.08720346540212631, + 0.20723681151866913, + 0.09296848624944687 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07006227225065231 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot captures an intimate and dynamic scene surrounding a dark wooden dining table in a warmly lit room. The primary focus is on two men seated among several other softly focused individuals. The first man, wearing a simple white T-shirt that accentuates his animated movements and with tousled light brown hair, enthusiastically participates in the conversation. He gestures energetically, waving his arms in expressive arcs and swaying his upper body in rhythm with his unspoken words. Opposite him, a man in a heather-gray crewneck sweater listens intently, his posture more reserved. He nods slowly and deliberately in response, his mouth slightly open, as if in awe or about to speak. The man in white suddenly and gently turns, picks up a piece of food from a nearby plate, leans forward, and steadily and deliberately feeds it to the man in gray, who accepts without hesitation. Then, the man in white smoothly rises from his chair and stands behind his friend, gently but firmly holding the seated man's head with both hands, looking down with a focused and affectionate expression, creating a quiet, emotional scene under the soft and strange overhead lighting, bathing the scene in a warm and intimate glow.", + "seed": 2623, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_0/index_9570_seed_2623_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.206704805791378, + "vlm_logprob": -0.206704805791378, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.206704805791378, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a dark wooden dining table visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man wearing a white T-shirt and light brown hair visible gesturing energetically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt feed food to a man in a heather-gray crewneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt stand behind the seated man and hold his head with both hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.48875734210014343 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1137573719024658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.48875734210014343, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.48875734210014343, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12313389778137207, + 0.16861169040203094, + 0.07967360317707062, + 0.05103779211640358, + 0.053173523396253586, + 0.07119522988796234, + 0.04122304543852806, + 0.09924785047769547, + 0.17181627452373505, + 0.14088717103004456 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.48875734210014343 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a dark wooden dining table visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man wearing a white T-shirt and light brown hair visible gesturing energetically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt feed food to a man in a heather-gray crewneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt stand behind the seated man and hold his head with both hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309936612844467 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680994033813477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309936612844467, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309936612844467, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17199169099330902, + 0.07375802844762802, + 0.2631914019584656, + 0.03206123039126396, + 0.03653084859251976, + 0.05402340367436409, + 0.22494739294052124, + 0.04986490681767464, + 0.043069835752248764, + 0.050561267882585526 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309936612844467 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a dark wooden dining table visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man wearing a white T-shirt and light brown hair visible gesturing energetically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt feed food to a man in a heather-gray crewneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt stand behind the seated man and hold his head with both hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1604018211364746 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104018211364746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1604018211364746, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1604018211364746, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1576494723558426, + 0.09724056720733643, + 0.07093439996242523, + 0.101619653403759, + 0.07516586035490036, + 0.06664255261421204, + 0.1044565737247467, + 0.07456722855567932, + 0.11266405880451202, + 0.13905973732471466 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1604018211364746 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a dark wooden dining table visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man wearing a white T-shirt and light brown hair visible gesturing energetically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt feed food to a man in a heather-gray crewneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt stand behind the seated man and hold his head with both hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25217336416244507 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021734237670898 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25217336416244507, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25217336416244507, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11338136345148087, + 0.0704188272356987, + 0.11854150891304016, + 0.12744009494781494, + 0.11993306130170822, + 0.04459315165877342, + 0.09521409869194031, + 0.05220705643296242, + 0.125654935836792, + 0.13261590898036957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25217336416244507 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a dark wooden dining table visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man wearing a white T-shirt and light brown hair visible gesturing energetically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt feed food to a man in a heather-gray crewneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt stand behind the seated man and hold his head with both hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08909213542938232 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464092254638672 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08909213542938232, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08909213542938232, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08351348340511322, + 0.03197678178548813, + 0.027871379628777504, + 0.035026028752326965, + 0.06878240406513214, + 0.05100153014063835, + 0.05461433529853821, + 0.12095808237791061, + 0.37941813468933105, + 0.14683784544467926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08909213542938232 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot captures an intimate and dynamic scene surrounding a dark wooden dining table in a warmly lit room. The primary focus is on two men seated among several other softly focused individuals. The first man, wearing a simple white T-shirt that accentuates his animated movements and with tousled light brown hair, enthusiastically participates in the conversation. He gestures energetically, waving his arms in expressive arcs and swaying his upper body in rhythm with his unspoken words. Opposite him, a man in a heather-gray crewneck sweater listens intently, his posture more reserved. He nods slowly and deliberately in response, his mouth slightly open, as if in awe or about to speak. The man in white suddenly and gently turns, picks up a piece of food from a nearby plate, leans forward, and steadily and deliberately feeds it to the man in gray, who accepts without hesitation. Then, the man in white smoothly rises from his chair and stands behind his friend, gently but firmly holding the seated man's head with both hands, looking down with a focused and affectionate expression, creating a quiet, emotional scene under the soft and strange overhead lighting, bathing the scene in a warm and intimate glow.", + "seed": 2624, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_0/index_9570_seed_2624_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.25890788435935974, + "vlm_logprob": -0.25890788435935974, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.25890788435935974, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a dark wooden dining table visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man wearing a white T-shirt and light brown hair visible gesturing energetically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt feed food to a man in a heather-gray crewneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt stand behind the seated man and hold his head with both hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9292862415313721 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5542862415313721 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9292862415313721, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9292862415313721, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09954959899187088, + 0.3105432093143463, + 0.06446807086467743, + 0.05814355984330177, + 0.03314660117030144, + 0.06413951516151428, + 0.08658339828252792, + 0.09890035539865494, + 0.06741030514240265, + 0.11711535602807999 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9292862415313721 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a dark wooden dining table visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man wearing a white T-shirt and light brown hair visible gesturing energetically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt feed food to a man in a heather-gray crewneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt stand behind the seated man and hold his head with both hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07903020083904266 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790302753448486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07903020083904266, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07903020083904266, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13801507651805878, + 0.10684943199157715, + 0.051869481801986694, + 0.05367463082075119, + 0.06396694481372833, + 0.08046038448810577, + 0.1823708862066269, + 0.08166228979825974, + 0.13880521059036255, + 0.10232557356357574 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07903020083904266 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a dark wooden dining table visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man wearing a white T-shirt and light brown hair visible gesturing energetically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt feed food to a man in a heather-gray crewneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt stand behind the seated man and hold his head with both hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08907021582126617 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640703201293945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08907021582126617, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08907021582126617, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23133431375026703, + 0.11562047153711319, + 0.030527785420417786, + 0.1484549343585968, + 0.09933565557003021, + 0.12806548178195953, + 0.09026185423135757, + 0.03934526816010475, + 0.03988217934966087, + 0.07717207819223404 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08907021582126617 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a dark wooden dining table visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man wearing a white T-shirt and light brown hair visible gesturing energetically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt feed food to a man in a heather-gray crewneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt stand behind the seated man and hold his head with both hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12708260118961334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127082586288452 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12708260118961334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12708260118961334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09935112297534943, + 0.18123668432235718, + 0.04512028396129608, + 0.05852240324020386, + 0.22671565413475037, + 0.11100094020366669, + 0.09793974459171295, + 0.08513908833265305, + 0.04959884285926819, + 0.045375291258096695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12708260118961334 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a dark wooden dining table visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man wearing a white T-shirt and light brown hair visible gesturing energetically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt feed food to a man in a heather-gray crewneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt stand behind the seated man and hold his head with both hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07007016241550446 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695070266723633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07007016241550446, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07007016241550446, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06171882525086403, + 0.19531168043613434, + 0.035333991050720215, + 0.05935398489236832, + 0.09794282913208008, + 0.10051105916500092, + 0.028811706230044365, + 0.1174178496003151, + 0.0848049595952034, + 0.2187931388616562 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07007016241550446 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot captures an intimate and dynamic scene surrounding a dark wooden dining table in a warmly lit room. The primary focus is on two men seated among several other softly focused individuals. The first man, wearing a simple white T-shirt that accentuates his animated movements and with tousled light brown hair, enthusiastically participates in the conversation. He gestures energetically, waving his arms in expressive arcs and swaying his upper body in rhythm with his unspoken words. Opposite him, a man in a heather-gray crewneck sweater listens intently, his posture more reserved. He nods slowly and deliberately in response, his mouth slightly open, as if in awe or about to speak. The man in white suddenly and gently turns, picks up a piece of food from a nearby plate, leans forward, and steadily and deliberately feeds it to the man in gray, who accepts without hesitation. Then, the man in white smoothly rises from his chair and stands behind his friend, gently but firmly holding the seated man's head with both hands, looking down with a focused and affectionate expression, creating a quiet, emotional scene under the soft and strange overhead lighting, bathing the scene in a warm and intimate glow.", + "seed": 2625, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_0/index_9570_seed_2625_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.15515529960393906, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15515529960393906, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15515529960393906, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a dark wooden dining table visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man wearing a white T-shirt and light brown hair visible gesturing energetically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt feed food to a man in a heather-gray crewneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt stand behind the seated man and hold his head with both hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5634244680404663 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9384244680404663 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5634244680404663, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5634244680404663, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13490787148475647, + 0.0576217919588089, + 0.05413535237312317, + 0.044057633727788925, + 0.05170745030045509, + 0.06193369999527931, + 0.19313383102416992, + 0.11679168045520782, + 0.1381986141204834, + 0.1475120484828949 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5634244680404663 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a dark wooden dining table visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man wearing a white T-shirt and light brown hair visible gesturing energetically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt feed food to a man in a heather-gray crewneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt stand behind the seated man and hold his head with both hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033734407275915146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087343215942383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033734407275915146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033734407275915146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30757835507392883, + 0.12153595685958862, + 0.08355025202035904, + 0.03250562772154808, + 0.05268094688653946, + 0.06624952703714371, + 0.16138197481632233, + 0.073257215321064, + 0.055454839020967484, + 0.045805349946022034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033734407275915146 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a dark wooden dining table visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man wearing a white T-shirt and light brown hair visible gesturing energetically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt feed food to a man in a heather-gray crewneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt stand behind the seated man and hold his head with both hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05497223883867264 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299721717834473 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05497223883867264, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05497223883867264, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11286185681819916, + 0.0710301622748375, + 0.03875232860445976, + 0.13189566135406494, + 0.023231804370880127, + 0.26346561312675476, + 0.08351655304431915, + 0.14920087158679962, + 0.06232721731066704, + 0.06371798366308212 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05497223883867264 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a dark wooden dining table visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man wearing a white T-shirt and light brown hair visible gesturing energetically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt feed food to a man in a heather-gray crewneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt stand behind the seated man and hold his head with both hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10034310072660446 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503429889678955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10034310072660446, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10034310072660446, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10020503401756287, + 0.02985958568751812, + 0.04681383818387985, + 0.03279414772987366, + 0.046240802854299545, + 0.0886358693242073, + 0.1364130824804306, + 0.2654231786727905, + 0.17654713988304138, + 0.07706737518310547 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10034310072660446 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, eye-level medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a dark wooden dining table visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a man wearing a white T-shirt and light brown hair visible gesturing energetically?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt feed food to a man in a heather-gray crewneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the man in the white T-shirt stand behind the seated man and hold his head with both hands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023302283138036728 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733023166656494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023302283138036728, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023302283138036728, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06072671338915825, + 0.03182879090309143, + 0.042050834745168686, + 0.026893658563494682, + 0.045038823038339615, + 0.07531238347291946, + 0.10710311681032181, + 0.13059408962726593, + 0.3847556412220001, + 0.09569593518972397 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023302283138036728 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_1/index_tensor([4140, 4140])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_1/index_tensor([4140, 4140])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..caf8f121467419d69c01ce875c53708d3e677736 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_1/index_tensor([4140, 4140])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, wide-angle shot captures a perfectly shaped lemon tree, the centerpiece of a sun-drenched grove, embodying the clean, bright aesthetic of a high-end product advertisement. A lush canopy of glossy, dark green leaves rests atop a sturdy, richly textured brown trunk, against a softly blurred backdrop of identical trees and a clear, azure sky. The scene then shifts into a seamless time-lapse, showing the tree through its entire fruiting cycle under perfect, high-key lighting that eliminates harsh shadows. Tiny white flowers first bloom on the branches, then gracefully give way to tiny green buds. These buds steadily and deliberately expand, growing from small, firm spheres into full-sized, unripe green lemons. As the fruit ripens, a magical, accelerating transformation of color sweeps across the tree, from deep emerald to a brilliant, sunny yellow. In its final moments, the tree is laden with plump, vibrant yellow lemons, their waxy rinds gleaming as if freshly polished, embodying a pure, natural freshness and vitality.", + "seed": 17444, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_1/index_4140_seed_17444_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.09000055768992751, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09000055768992751, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09000055768992751, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly shaped lemon tree with a sturdy brown trunk and dark green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the tree's fruiting cycle starting with tiny white flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flowers transform into green buds that expand into unripe green lemons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lemons' color change from deep emerald to a brilliant sunny yellow as they ripen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view with a softly blurred background of identical trees and a clear azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3157989978790283 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3157989978790283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3157989978790283, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3157989978790283, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2153865098953247, + 0.09624867886304855, + 0.09355323016643524, + 0.11157840490341187, + 0.15737731754779816, + 0.05249401554465294, + 0.027208874002099037, + 0.10496384650468826, + 0.04794200882315636, + 0.09324716031551361 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3157989978790283 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly shaped lemon tree with a sturdy brown trunk and dark green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the tree's fruiting cycle starting with tiny white flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flowers transform into green buds that expand into unripe green lemons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lemons' color change from deep emerald to a brilliant sunny yellow as they ripen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view with a softly blurred background of identical trees and a clear azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10032843798398972 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503284454345703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10032843798398972, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10032843798398972, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11768734455108643, + 0.19009986519813538, + 0.30269894003868103, + 0.09394898265600204, + 0.07433021068572998, + 0.0519922710955143, + 0.04184485971927643, + 0.05994377285242081, + 0.021710708737373352, + 0.04574303701519966 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10032843798398972 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly shaped lemon tree with a sturdy brown trunk and dark green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the tree's fruiting cycle starting with tiny white flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flowers transform into green buds that expand into unripe green lemons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lemons' color change from deep emerald to a brilliant sunny yellow as they ripen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view with a softly blurred background of identical trees and a clear azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019463420612737536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251946449279785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019463420612737536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019463420612737536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14349426329135895, + 0.14490044116973877, + 0.12042772769927979, + 0.09200313687324524, + 0.11299582570791245, + 0.05372846499085426, + 0.040088750422000885, + 0.13901610672473907, + 0.054240237921476364, + 0.09910507500171661 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019463420612737536 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly shaped lemon tree with a sturdy brown trunk and dark green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the tree's fruiting cycle starting with tiny white flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flowers transform into green buds that expand into unripe green lemons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lemons' color change from deep emerald to a brilliant sunny yellow as they ripen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view with a softly blurred background of identical trees and a clear azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008645012974739075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758645057678223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008645012974739075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008645012974739075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14924636483192444, + 0.06603041291236877, + 0.12752874195575714, + 0.06695032119750977, + 0.07342473417520523, + 0.06688281148672104, + 0.05987551808357239, + 0.11431199312210083, + 0.09118267148733139, + 0.18456631898880005 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008645012974739075 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly shaped lemon tree with a sturdy brown trunk and dark green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the tree's fruiting cycle starting with tiny white flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flowers transform into green buds that expand into unripe green lemons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lemons' color change from deep emerald to a brilliant sunny yellow as they ripen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view with a softly blurred background of identical trees and a clear azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023283997550606728 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732839584350586 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023283997550606728, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023283997550606728, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1032981351017952, + 0.08564672619104385, + 0.1728707253932953, + 0.16877931356430054, + 0.06793839484453201, + 0.08462091535329819, + 0.08403820544481277, + 0.11917054653167725, + 0.06784217059612274, + 0.04579487815499306 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023283997550606728 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, wide-angle shot captures a perfectly shaped lemon tree, the centerpiece of a sun-drenched grove, embodying the clean, bright aesthetic of a high-end product advertisement. A lush canopy of glossy, dark green leaves rests atop a sturdy, richly textured brown trunk, against a softly blurred backdrop of identical trees and a clear, azure sky. The scene then shifts into a seamless time-lapse, showing the tree through its entire fruiting cycle under perfect, high-key lighting that eliminates harsh shadows. Tiny white flowers first bloom on the branches, then gracefully give way to tiny green buds. These buds steadily and deliberately expand, growing from small, firm spheres into full-sized, unripe green lemons. As the fruit ripens, a magical, accelerating transformation of color sweeps across the tree, from deep emerald to a brilliant, sunny yellow. In its final moments, the tree is laden with plump, vibrant yellow lemons, their waxy rinds gleaming as if freshly polished, embodying a pure, natural freshness and vitality.", + "seed": 17445, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_1/index_4140_seed_17445_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06710825194604694, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06710825194604694, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06710825194604694, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly shaped lemon tree with a sturdy brown trunk and dark green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the tree's fruiting cycle starting with tiny white flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flowers transform into green buds that expand into unripe green lemons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lemons' color change from deep emerald to a brilliant sunny yellow as they ripen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view with a softly blurred background of identical trees and a clear azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1438174843788147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.01881742477417 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1438174843788147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1438174843788147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09938263148069382, + 0.06799181550741196, + 0.03296457231044769, + 0.02236858755350113, + 0.020073145627975464, + 0.01893502101302147, + 0.14004993438720703, + 0.08982503414154053, + 0.07827194035053253, + 0.4301372766494751 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1438174843788147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly shaped lemon tree with a sturdy brown trunk and dark green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the tree's fruiting cycle starting with tiny white flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flowers transform into green buds that expand into unripe green lemons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lemons' color change from deep emerald to a brilliant sunny yellow as they ripen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view with a softly blurred background of identical trees and a clear azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11293213069438934 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379322052001953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11293213069438934, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11293213069438934, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.050490252673625946, + 0.022576836869120598, + 0.03713835030794144, + 0.022997332736849785, + 0.046507708728313446, + 0.05748089402914047, + 0.15411929786205292, + 0.20664836466312408, + 0.19024471938610077, + 0.21179626882076263 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11293213069438934 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly shaped lemon tree with a sturdy brown trunk and dark green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the tree's fruiting cycle starting with tiny white flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flowers transform into green buds that expand into unripe green lemons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lemons' color change from deep emerald to a brilliant sunny yellow as they ripen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view with a softly blurred background of identical trees and a clear azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002823535120114684 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877823352813721 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002823535120114684, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002823535120114684, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1078856959939003, + 0.04478500783443451, + 0.03368049114942551, + 0.023537760600447655, + 0.0337878055870533, + 0.02872244082391262, + 0.17668962478637695, + 0.17098592221736908, + 0.10631770640611649, + 0.2736075222492218 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002823535120114684 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly shaped lemon tree with a sturdy brown trunk and dark green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the tree's fruiting cycle starting with tiny white flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flowers transform into green buds that expand into unripe green lemons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lemons' color change from deep emerald to a brilliant sunny yellow as they ripen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view with a softly blurred background of identical trees and a clear azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059529622085392475 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130952835083008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059529622085392475, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059529622085392475, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10197591036558151, + 0.041070710867643356, + 0.06480199843645096, + 0.03010290302336216, + 0.023062923923134804, + 0.02344663441181183, + 0.22554196417331696, + 0.12515558302402496, + 0.06433304399251938, + 0.3005083203315735 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059529622085392475 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly shaped lemon tree with a sturdy brown trunk and dark green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the tree's fruiting cycle starting with tiny white flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flowers transform into green buds that expand into unripe green lemons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lemons' color change from deep emerald to a brilliant sunny yellow as they ripen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view with a softly blurred background of identical trees and a clear azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07001514732837677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950151920318604 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07001514732837677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07001514732837677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09979482740163803, + 0.058817308396101, + 0.039268601685762405, + 0.028842316940426826, + 0.05739082396030426, + 0.036063048988580704, + 0.06773083657026291, + 0.20932233333587646, + 0.27234864234924316, + 0.13042129576206207 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07001514732837677 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, wide-angle shot captures a perfectly shaped lemon tree, the centerpiece of a sun-drenched grove, embodying the clean, bright aesthetic of a high-end product advertisement. A lush canopy of glossy, dark green leaves rests atop a sturdy, richly textured brown trunk, against a softly blurred backdrop of identical trees and a clear, azure sky. The scene then shifts into a seamless time-lapse, showing the tree through its entire fruiting cycle under perfect, high-key lighting that eliminates harsh shadows. Tiny white flowers first bloom on the branches, then gracefully give way to tiny green buds. These buds steadily and deliberately expand, growing from small, firm spheres into full-sized, unripe green lemons. As the fruit ripens, a magical, accelerating transformation of color sweeps across the tree, from deep emerald to a brilliant, sunny yellow. In its final moments, the tree is laden with plump, vibrant yellow lemons, their waxy rinds gleaming as if freshly polished, embodying a pure, natural freshness and vitality.", + "seed": 17446, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_1/index_4140_seed_17446_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.012918294756673276, + "vlm_logprob": -0.012918294756673276, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.012918294756673276, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly shaped lemon tree with a sturdy brown trunk and dark green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the tree's fruiting cycle starting with tiny white flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flowers transform into green buds that expand into unripe green lemons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lemons' color change from deep emerald to a brilliant sunny yellow as they ripen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view with a softly blurred background of identical trees and a clear azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.028855886310338974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.653855800628662 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.028855886310338974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.028855886310338974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06222720071673393, + 0.023661693558096886, + 0.3806561529636383, + 0.19238275289535522, + 0.0679764598608017, + 0.03151393309235573, + 0.03542094677686691, + 0.040488578379154205, + 0.024728095158934593, + 0.140944242477417 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.028855886310338974 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly shaped lemon tree with a sturdy brown trunk and dark green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the tree's fruiting cycle starting with tiny white flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flowers transform into green buds that expand into unripe green lemons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lemons' color change from deep emerald to a brilliant sunny yellow as they ripen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view with a softly blurred background of identical trees and a clear azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02330368012189865 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773303747177124 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02330368012189865, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02330368012189865, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07362056523561478, + 0.03750177472829819, + 0.09546203911304474, + 0.05515776202082634, + 0.2979995310306549, + 0.08833546936511993, + 0.044669151306152344, + 0.16743901371955872, + 0.033689286559820175, + 0.1061253771185875 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02330368012189865 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly shaped lemon tree with a sturdy brown trunk and dark green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the tree's fruiting cycle starting with tiny white flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flowers transform into green buds that expand into unripe green lemons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lemons' color change from deep emerald to a brilliant sunny yellow as they ripen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view with a softly blurred background of identical trees and a clear azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011837625643238425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751183986663818 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011837625643238425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011837625643238425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0907280370593071, + 0.04098169133067131, + 0.20692439377307892, + 0.1438981294631958, + 0.09648244082927704, + 0.10097399353981018, + 0.11300338059663773, + 0.0640411451458931, + 0.031183797866106033, + 0.11178302019834518 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011837625643238425 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly shaped lemon tree with a sturdy brown trunk and dark green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the tree's fruiting cycle starting with tiny white flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flowers transform into green buds that expand into unripe green lemons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lemons' color change from deep emerald to a brilliant sunny yellow as they ripen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view with a softly blurred background of identical trees and a clear azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036196685396134853 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.62861967086792 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036196685396134853, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036196685396134853, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1345110684633255, + 0.03122207336127758, + 0.05820435285568237, + 0.16417722404003143, + 0.0957740917801857, + 0.0384848527610302, + 0.05202493071556091, + 0.044701073318719864, + 0.043118275701999664, + 0.337782084941864 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036196685396134853 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly shaped lemon tree with a sturdy brown trunk and dark green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the tree's fruiting cycle starting with tiny white flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flowers transform into green buds that expand into unripe green lemons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lemons' color change from deep emerald to a brilliant sunny yellow as they ripen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view with a softly blurred background of identical trees and a clear azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007628476247191429 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882628440856934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007628476247191429, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007628476247191429, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0538240484893322, + 0.026694240048527718, + 0.09599409997463226, + 0.09529343247413635, + 0.023428279906511307, + 0.014192037284374237, + 0.040260717272758484, + 0.027421705424785614, + 0.021571042016148567, + 0.6013203263282776 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007628476247191429 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, wide-angle shot captures a perfectly shaped lemon tree, the centerpiece of a sun-drenched grove, embodying the clean, bright aesthetic of a high-end product advertisement. A lush canopy of glossy, dark green leaves rests atop a sturdy, richly textured brown trunk, against a softly blurred backdrop of identical trees and a clear, azure sky. The scene then shifts into a seamless time-lapse, showing the tree through its entire fruiting cycle under perfect, high-key lighting that eliminates harsh shadows. Tiny white flowers first bloom on the branches, then gracefully give way to tiny green buds. These buds steadily and deliberately expand, growing from small, firm spheres into full-sized, unripe green lemons. As the fruit ripens, a magical, accelerating transformation of color sweeps across the tree, from deep emerald to a brilliant, sunny yellow. In its final moments, the tree is laden with plump, vibrant yellow lemons, their waxy rinds gleaming as if freshly polished, embodying a pure, natural freshness and vitality.", + "seed": 17447, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_1/index_4140_seed_17447_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.012701321649365127, + "vlm_logprob": -0.012701321649365127, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.012701321649365127, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly shaped lemon tree with a sturdy brown trunk and dark green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the tree's fruiting cycle starting with tiny white flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flowers transform into green buds that expand into unripe green lemons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lemons' color change from deep emerald to a brilliant sunny yellow as they ripen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view with a softly blurred background of identical trees and a clear azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018030548468232155 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.143030643463135 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018030548468232155, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018030548468232155, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06475451588630676, + 0.032773420214653015, + 0.030438877642154694, + 0.05839288607239723, + 0.03647491708397865, + 0.37552353739738464, + 0.06569445133209229, + 0.10025753080844879, + 0.07460061460733414, + 0.16108927130699158 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018030548468232155 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly shaped lemon tree with a sturdy brown trunk and dark green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the tree's fruiting cycle starting with tiny white flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flowers transform into green buds that expand into unripe green lemons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lemons' color change from deep emerald to a brilliant sunny yellow as they ripen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view with a softly blurred background of identical trees and a clear azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033710893243551254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087109565734863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033710893243551254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033710893243551254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.017094498500227928, + 0.012330610305070877, + 0.0372377373278141, + 0.0706171914935112, + 0.09234432876110077, + 0.46644699573516846, + 0.0599982813000679, + 0.034278251230716705, + 0.1441328078508377, + 0.06551926583051682 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033710893243551254 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly shaped lemon tree with a sturdy brown trunk and dark green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the tree's fruiting cycle starting with tiny white flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flowers transform into green buds that expand into unripe green lemons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lemons' color change from deep emerald to a brilliant sunny yellow as they ripen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view with a softly blurred background of identical trees and a clear azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017183552263304591 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376718521118164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017183552263304591, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017183552263304591, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.031972602009773254, + 0.017737966030836105, + 0.0373399518430233, + 0.08627832680940628, + 0.05909857153892517, + 0.25342854857444763, + 0.08932813256978989, + 0.049800433218479156, + 0.2682264447212219, + 0.10678896307945251 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017183552263304591 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly shaped lemon tree with a sturdy brown trunk and dark green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the tree's fruiting cycle starting with tiny white flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flowers transform into green buds that expand into unripe green lemons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lemons' color change from deep emerald to a brilliant sunny yellow as they ripen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view with a softly blurred background of identical trees and a clear azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004099300131201744 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504099369049072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004099300131201744, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004099300131201744, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0852150022983551, + 0.028640087693929672, + 0.042358215898275375, + 0.06053992733359337, + 0.07855579257011414, + 0.1223895400762558, + 0.27211153507232666, + 0.09652931988239288, + 0.06825528293848038, + 0.14540524780750275 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004099300131201744 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a perfectly shaped lemon tree with a sturdy brown trunk and dark green leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the video show a time-lapse of the tree's fruiting cycle starting with tiny white flowers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the flowers transform into green buds that expand into unripe green lemons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lemons' color change from deep emerald to a brilliant sunny yellow as they ripen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, wide-angle view with a softly blurred background of identical trees and a clear azure sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005947511177510023 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130947589874268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005947511177510023, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005947511177510023, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.038595572113990784, + 0.04404531419277191, + 0.04828229546546936, + 0.05346890538930893, + 0.04281248524785042, + 0.27781903743743896, + 0.07755787670612335, + 0.02786736935377121, + 0.34231802821159363, + 0.04723317176103592 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005947511177510023 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_10/index_tensor([3031, 3031])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_10/index_tensor([3031, 3031])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d3b17b1d0488915f583b37b65d15321e55c98e9e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_10/index_tensor([3031, 3031])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In surreal digital cinematography, a static, extreme close-up captures the face of a teenage Pacific Islander girl awakening from a deep slumber. Her head rests on a soft, defocused pillow, its fabric texture subtly suggesting a shallow depth of field. The camera's close proximity reveals the intricate texture of her warm olive skin and the delicate, individual lashes of her long, black eyelashes, gently clumped together with sleep. The movement unfolds deliberately slowly: her eyelids tremble at first, with a faint, subconscious flutter, before gradually parting, revealing a sliver of deep brown iris beneath. As her eyes fully open, her gaze is momentarily unfocused, holding a deep, unguarded emotion, before slowly coming into focus. The entire scene is defined by heavily desaturated tones, washing the palette to a range of stark, almost monochromatic soft grays and muted, hazy hues. This stylistic choice amplifies the raw, meditative atmosphere and draws all attention to the quiet, powerful intimacy of her awakening gaze.", + "seed": 19694, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_10/index_3031_seed_19694_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.10466101402416825, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10466101402416825, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10466101402416825, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl's skin tone warm olive with visible intricate texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are her eyelashes long, black, and gently clumped together with sleep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the girl's action involve her eyelids trembling and then gradually opening to reveal a deep brown iris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette heavily desaturated, consisting of soft grays and muted, hazy hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28619155287742615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4111915826797485 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28619155287742615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28619155287742615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3483389914035797, + 0.055853016674518585, + 0.04348207637667656, + 0.043819963932037354, + 0.04914874956011772, + 0.09952076524496078, + 0.15092472732067108, + 0.10959114134311676, + 0.06683599948883057, + 0.032484620809555054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28619155287742615 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl's skin tone warm olive with visible intricate texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are her eyelashes long, black, and gently clumped together with sleep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the girl's action involve her eyelids trembling and then gradually opening to reveal a deep brown iris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette heavily desaturated, consisting of soft grays and muted, hazy hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014220098033547401 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264220237731934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014220098033547401, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014220098033547401, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42981165647506714, + 0.07504348456859589, + 0.11206399649381638, + 0.036140114068984985, + 0.03698069974780083, + 0.045653313398361206, + 0.10201086103916168, + 0.08454462885856628, + 0.05680838227272034, + 0.020942892879247665 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014220098033547401 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl's skin tone warm olive with visible intricate texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are her eyelashes long, black, and gently clumped together with sleep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the girl's action involve her eyelids trembling and then gradually opening to reveal a deep brown iris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette heavily desaturated, consisting of soft grays and muted, hazy hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052567594684660435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255256652832031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052567594684660435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052567594684660435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3302869498729706, + 0.05745610222220421, + 0.07793638855218887, + 0.08128227293491364, + 0.059454210102558136, + 0.09307001531124115, + 0.056808825582265854, + 0.07211432605981827, + 0.11983416974544525, + 0.05175669118762016 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052567594684660435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl's skin tone warm olive with visible intricate texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are her eyelashes long, black, and gently clumped together with sleep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the girl's action involve her eyelids trembling and then gradually opening to reveal a deep brown iris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette heavily desaturated, consisting of soft grays and muted, hazy hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016070127487182617 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141070365905762 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016070127487182617, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016070127487182617, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2394697070121765, + 0.06580697745084763, + 0.05398649722337723, + 0.08039190620183945, + 0.0929507240653038, + 0.05940103530883789, + 0.17124320566654205, + 0.05466613918542862, + 0.15417346358299255, + 0.02791031263768673 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016070127487182617 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl's skin tone warm olive with visible intricate texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are her eyelashes long, black, and gently clumped together with sleep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the girl's action involve her eyelids trembling and then gradually opening to reveal a deep brown iris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette heavily desaturated, consisting of soft grays and muted, hazy hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20156653225421906 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015665769577026 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20156653225421906, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20156653225421906, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3561933636665344, + 0.14363963901996613, + 0.03433581814169884, + 0.04979780316352844, + 0.08876029402017593, + 0.020896654576063156, + 0.14931097626686096, + 0.027570949867367744, + 0.08071122318506241, + 0.04878333583474159 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20156653225421906 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In surreal digital cinematography, a static, extreme close-up captures the face of a teenage Pacific Islander girl awakening from a deep slumber. Her head rests on a soft, defocused pillow, its fabric texture subtly suggesting a shallow depth of field. The camera's close proximity reveals the intricate texture of her warm olive skin and the delicate, individual lashes of her long, black eyelashes, gently clumped together with sleep. The movement unfolds deliberately slowly: her eyelids tremble at first, with a faint, subconscious flutter, before gradually parting, revealing a sliver of deep brown iris beneath. As her eyes fully open, her gaze is momentarily unfocused, holding a deep, unguarded emotion, before slowly coming into focus. The entire scene is defined by heavily desaturated tones, washing the palette to a range of stark, almost monochromatic soft grays and muted, hazy hues. This stylistic choice amplifies the raw, meditative atmosphere and draws all attention to the quiet, powerful intimacy of her awakening gaze.", + "seed": 19695, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_10/index_3031_seed_19695_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.13018570719286798, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13018570719286798, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7000000357627867, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13018570719286798, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl's skin tone warm olive with visible intricate texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are her eyelashes long, black, and gently clumped together with sleep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the girl's action involve her eyelids trembling and then gradually opening to reveal a deep brown iris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette heavily desaturated, consisting of soft grays and muted, hazy hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3916592001914978 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1416592597961426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3916592001914978, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7500000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3916592001914978, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11866632848978043, + 0.023483389988541603, + 0.10167770087718964, + 0.02943497523665428, + 0.0834643617272377, + 0.07258845120668411, + 0.09037189930677414, + 0.07825247198343277, + 0.288848340511322, + 0.11321217566728592 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3916592001914978 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl's skin tone warm olive with visible intricate texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are her eyelashes long, black, and gently clumped together with sleep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the girl's action involve her eyelids trembling and then gradually opening to reveal a deep brown iris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette heavily desaturated, consisting of soft grays and muted, hazy hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02983291819691658 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298328399658203 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02983291819691658, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02983291819691658, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11162760853767395, + 0.08985168486833572, + 0.04887033998966217, + 0.0467727966606617, + 0.05372786149382591, + 0.03091796487569809, + 0.06352648884057999, + 0.20791170001029968, + 0.12013190984725952, + 0.22666165232658386 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02983291819691658 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl's skin tone warm olive with visible intricate texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are her eyelashes long, black, and gently clumped together with sleep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the girl's action involve her eyelids trembling and then gradually opening to reveal a deep brown iris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette heavily desaturated, consisting of soft grays and muted, hazy hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007639241870492697 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882639408111572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007639241870492697, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007639241870492697, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08646374195814133, + 0.06447027623653412, + 0.12248888611793518, + 0.0529787614941597, + 0.07683272659778595, + 0.08604369312524796, + 0.05559913069009781, + 0.23238912224769592, + 0.05489610135555267, + 0.16783757507801056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007639241870492697 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl's skin tone warm olive with visible intricate texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are her eyelashes long, black, and gently clumped together with sleep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the girl's action involve her eyelids trembling and then gradually opening to reveal a deep brown iris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette heavily desaturated, consisting of soft grays and muted, hazy hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.142801895737648 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178020000457764 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.142801895737648, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.142801895737648, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06344366818666458, + 0.04043175280094147, + 0.04438724368810654, + 0.0770837664604187, + 0.1574973315000534, + 0.20642468333244324, + 0.0572986826300621, + 0.20753315091133118, + 0.05992882698774338, + 0.08597086369991302 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.142801895737648 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl's skin tone warm olive with visible intricate texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are her eyelashes long, black, and gently clumped together with sleep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the girl's action involve her eyelids trembling and then gradually opening to reveal a deep brown iris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette heavily desaturated, consisting of soft grays and muted, hazy hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07899527996778488 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789952278137207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07899527996778488, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07899527996778488, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18549183011054993, + 0.048408955335617065, + 0.1489173173904419, + 0.09146751463413239, + 0.06841186434030533, + 0.15196576714515686, + 0.06671195477247238, + 0.0667145624756813, + 0.08281495422124863, + 0.08909525722265244 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07899527996778488 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In surreal digital cinematography, a static, extreme close-up captures the face of a teenage Pacific Islander girl awakening from a deep slumber. Her head rests on a soft, defocused pillow, its fabric texture subtly suggesting a shallow depth of field. The camera's close proximity reveals the intricate texture of her warm olive skin and the delicate, individual lashes of her long, black eyelashes, gently clumped together with sleep. The movement unfolds deliberately slowly: her eyelids tremble at first, with a faint, subconscious flutter, before gradually parting, revealing a sliver of deep brown iris beneath. As her eyes fully open, her gaze is momentarily unfocused, holding a deep, unguarded emotion, before slowly coming into focus. The entire scene is defined by heavily desaturated tones, washing the palette to a range of stark, almost monochromatic soft grays and muted, hazy hues. This stylistic choice amplifies the raw, meditative atmosphere and draws all attention to the quiet, powerful intimacy of her awakening gaze.", + "seed": 19696, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_10/index_3031_seed_19696_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11738782990723848, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11738782990723848, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11738782990723848, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl's skin tone warm olive with visible intricate texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are her eyelashes long, black, and gently clumped together with sleep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the girl's action involve her eyelids trembling and then gradually opening to reveal a deep brown iris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette heavily desaturated, consisting of soft grays and muted, hazy hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3915736973285675 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1415736675262451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3915736973285675, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3915736973285675, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11296990513801575, + 0.06142856925725937, + 0.04358383268117905, + 0.06366792321205139, + 0.036441680043935776, + 0.061797987669706345, + 0.0964866578578949, + 0.2897629737854004, + 0.14293497800827026, + 0.09092552214860916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3915736973285675 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl's skin tone warm olive with visible intricate texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are her eyelashes long, black, and gently clumped together with sleep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the girl's action involve her eyelids trembling and then gradually opening to reveal a deep brown iris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette heavily desaturated, consisting of soft grays and muted, hazy hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0430925153195858 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680924892425537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0430925153195858, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0430925153195858, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21542762219905853, + 0.1654154509305954, + 0.043846745043992996, + 0.05420032888650894, + 0.11973673105239868, + 0.07515513896942139, + 0.03946893662214279, + 0.12303586304187775, + 0.10668004304170609, + 0.057033102959394455 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0430925153195858 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl's skin tone warm olive with visible intricate texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are her eyelashes long, black, and gently clumped together with sleep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the girl's action involve her eyelids trembling and then gradually opening to reveal a deep brown iris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette heavily desaturated, consisting of soft grays and muted, hazy hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004640880040824413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379641056060791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004640880040824413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004640880040824413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1433788686990738, + 0.14097991585731506, + 0.049266185611486435, + 0.056400638073682785, + 0.02980920486152172, + 0.13988825678825378, + 0.0777178406715393, + 0.09106335788965225, + 0.17599667608737946, + 0.09549909085035324 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004640880040824413 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl's skin tone warm olive with visible intricate texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are her eyelashes long, black, and gently clumped together with sleep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the girl's action involve her eyelids trembling and then gradually opening to reveal a deep brown iris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette heavily desaturated, consisting of soft grays and muted, hazy hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020581373944878578 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955814838409424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020581373944878578, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020581373944878578, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1213182657957077, + 0.045488063246011734, + 0.033548809587955475, + 0.03893022984266281, + 0.04142177104949951, + 0.10071472078561783, + 0.04096630588173866, + 0.19408008456230164, + 0.2719995379447937, + 0.11153227090835571 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020581373944878578 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl's skin tone warm olive with visible intricate texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are her eyelashes long, black, and gently clumped together with sleep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the girl's action involve her eyelids trembling and then gradually opening to reveal a deep brown iris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette heavily desaturated, consisting of soft grays and muted, hazy hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12705068290233612 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270506381988525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12705068290233612, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12705068290233612, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14108097553253174, + 0.12275087088346481, + 0.04169129580259323, + 0.05080995708703995, + 0.0817045122385025, + 0.05345296487212181, + 0.04689381271600723, + 0.21642231941223145, + 0.11604416370391846, + 0.12914906442165375 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12705068290233612 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In surreal digital cinematography, a static, extreme close-up captures the face of a teenage Pacific Islander girl awakening from a deep slumber. Her head rests on a soft, defocused pillow, its fabric texture subtly suggesting a shallow depth of field. The camera's close proximity reveals the intricate texture of her warm olive skin and the delicate, individual lashes of her long, black eyelashes, gently clumped together with sleep. The movement unfolds deliberately slowly: her eyelids tremble at first, with a faint, subconscious flutter, before gradually parting, revealing a sliver of deep brown iris beneath. As her eyes fully open, her gaze is momentarily unfocused, holding a deep, unguarded emotion, before slowly coming into focus. The entire scene is defined by heavily desaturated tones, washing the palette to a range of stark, almost monochromatic soft grays and muted, hazy hues. This stylistic choice amplifies the raw, meditative atmosphere and draws all attention to the quiet, powerful intimacy of her awakening gaze.", + "seed": 19697, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_10/index_3031_seed_19697_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1682160312309861, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1682160312309861, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1682160312309861, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl's skin tone warm olive with visible intricate texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are her eyelashes long, black, and gently clumped together with sleep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the girl's action involve her eyelids trembling and then gradually opening to reveal a deep brown iris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette heavily desaturated, consisting of soft grays and muted, hazy hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22798611223697662 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6029860973358154 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22798611223697662, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22798611223697662, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08970188349485397, + 0.3345876634120941, + 0.23782172799110413, + 0.047343168407678604, + 0.09143061935901642, + 0.03099047765135765, + 0.05665701627731323, + 0.07483897358179092, + 0.02013331465423107, + 0.016495108604431152 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22798611223697662 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl's skin tone warm olive with visible intricate texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are her eyelashes long, black, and gently clumped together with sleep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the girl's action involve her eyelids trembling and then gradually opening to reveal a deep brown iris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette heavily desaturated, consisting of soft grays and muted, hazy hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02332056686282158 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733206748962402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02332056686282158, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02332056686282158, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13357260823249817, + 0.412130743265152, + 0.13884347677230835, + 0.10149702429771423, + 0.08649569749832153, + 0.04216088354587555, + 0.022343356162309647, + 0.03178158029913902, + 0.019442971795797348, + 0.01173165813088417 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02332056686282158 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl's skin tone warm olive with visible intricate texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are her eyelashes long, black, and gently clumped together with sleep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the girl's action involve her eyelids trembling and then gradually opening to reveal a deep brown iris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette heavily desaturated, consisting of soft grays and muted, hazy hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007636047434061766 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882636070251465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007636047434061766, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007636047434061766, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18359485268592834, + 0.38863813877105713, + 0.10271313041448593, + 0.08367819339036942, + 0.06726978719234467, + 0.04655035212635994, + 0.03045116923749447, + 0.04858767241239548, + 0.01793055050075054, + 0.030586138367652893 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007636047434061766 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl's skin tone warm olive with visible intricate texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are her eyelashes long, black, and gently clumped together with sleep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the girl's action involve her eyelids trembling and then gradually opening to reveal a deep brown iris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette heavily desaturated, consisting of soft grays and muted, hazy hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005950355436652899 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130950450897217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005950355436652899, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005950355436652899, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14342737197875977, + 0.1087629646062851, + 0.400710791349411, + 0.048372525721788406, + 0.08419845998287201, + 0.06294361501932144, + 0.05556367337703705, + 0.0384996235370636, + 0.020503317937254906, + 0.03701769560575485 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005950355436652899 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a teenage Pacific Islander girl?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the girl's skin tone warm olive with visible intricate texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are her eyelashes long, black, and gently clumped together with sleep?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the girl's action involve her eyelids trembling and then gradually opening to reveal a deep brown iris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the overall color palette heavily desaturated, consisting of soft grays and muted, hazy hues?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761870741844177 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261870741844177 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761870741844177, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761870741844177, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05498906224966049, + 0.708195149898529, + 0.07935107499361038, + 0.06046191602945328, + 0.052904292941093445, + 0.011356099508702755, + 0.007339425850659609, + 0.010170221328735352, + 0.005729340948164463, + 0.009503397159278393 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761870741844177 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_11/index_tensor([9995, 9995])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_11/index_tensor([9995, 9995])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..527e5ace445b231e684523090c69e9886ceb4bf2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_11/index_tensor([9995, 9995])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a dramatic close-up, the camera slowly tilts downward from a level angle, capturing the fair, smooth cheek of a young woman. Illuminated by a faint, soft overhead light in the dim room, the texture of her skin is clearly visible. A plump, crystalline tear silently spills from her reddened eye, sliding slowly down the curve of her cheek, leaving a wet streak that shimmers in the dim light. As the tear reaches her jawline, it lingers briefly, gathering weight before silently dripping. The camera follows the tear, focusing on the blade of a meticulously polished steel longsword, resting horizontally below. Its blade reflects the cold, sharp luster of metal in the gloom. The teardrop instantly bursts open upon contact with the mirror-smooth blade, forming a tiny, fleeting ripple. In that moment, the cold, hard surface of the blade clearly yet slightly distortedly reflects her deep eyes, filled with endless sorrow and despair, with long eyelashes trembling slightly. The entire painting is characterized by strong contrasts of light and shadow, and a cold color palette, creating an atmosphere of heartbreak, tranquility, and a profound sense of fate.", + "seed": 21403, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_11/index_9995_seed_21403_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1577587530016899, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1577587530016899, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1577587530016899, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up shot of a young woman's fair, smooth cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward from a level angle to follow a tear sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump, crystalline tear visible spilling from a reddened eye and sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear burst upon contact with a horizontally resting, polished steel longsword blade below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the blade reflect the woman's deep eyes with long eyelashes trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12878228724002838 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.128782272338867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12878228724002838, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12878228724002838, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05300743877887726, + 0.061085689812898636, + 0.05923745036125183, + 0.642307460308075, + 0.11106481403112411, + 0.011756602674722672, + 0.021762512624263763, + 0.009983736090362072, + 0.021367011591792107, + 0.008427239023149014 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12878228724002838 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up shot of a young woman's fair, smooth cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward from a level angle to follow a tear sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump, crystalline tear visible spilling from a reddened eye and sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear burst upon contact with a horizontally resting, polished steel longsword blade below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the blade reflect the woman's deep eyes with long eyelashes trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02639751508831978 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651397466659546 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02639751508831978, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02639751508831978, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05199494585394859, + 0.06386713683605194, + 0.09195458889007568, + 0.11646600812673569, + 0.4876876175403595, + 0.08260104805231094, + 0.017886783927679062, + 0.033731602132320404, + 0.030072808265686035, + 0.02373744361102581 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02639751508831978 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up shot of a young woman's fair, smooth cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward from a level angle to follow a tear sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump, crystalline tear visible spilling from a reddened eye and sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear burst upon contact with a horizontally resting, polished steel longsword blade below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the blade reflect the woman's deep eyes with long eyelashes trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05503079667687416 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300308227539062 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05503079667687416, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05503079667687416, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05087919905781746, + 0.029857000336050987, + 0.09975194931030273, + 0.13722580671310425, + 0.452587366104126, + 0.1358838975429535, + 0.024132050573825836, + 0.03513414040207863, + 0.014127102680504322, + 0.02042149379849434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05503079667687416 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up shot of a young woman's fair, smooth cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward from a level angle to follow a tear sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump, crystalline tear visible spilling from a reddened eye and sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear burst upon contact with a horizontally resting, polished steel longsword blade below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the blade reflect the woman's deep eyes with long eyelashes trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05500213801860809 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.930002212524414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05500213801860809, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05500213801860809, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04517363756895065, + 0.06694594025611877, + 0.048438142985105515, + 0.4169599115848541, + 0.16478779911994934, + 0.0903920978307724, + 0.027536960318684578, + 0.028738215565681458, + 0.04732218384742737, + 0.06370511651039124 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05500213801860809 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up shot of a young woman's fair, smooth cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward from a level angle to follow a tear sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump, crystalline tear visible spilling from a reddened eye and sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear burst upon contact with a horizontally resting, polished steel longsword blade below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the blade reflect the woman's deep eyes with long eyelashes trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5235810279846191 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8985810279846191 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5235810279846191, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5235810279846191, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06757132709026337, + 0.10268543660640717, + 0.05530276894569397, + 0.1165875717997551, + 0.1131911650300026, + 0.16219063103199005, + 0.07973111420869827, + 0.07923697680234909, + 0.06848393380641937, + 0.15501907467842102 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5235810279846191 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a dramatic close-up, the camera slowly tilts downward from a level angle, capturing the fair, smooth cheek of a young woman. Illuminated by a faint, soft overhead light in the dim room, the texture of her skin is clearly visible. A plump, crystalline tear silently spills from her reddened eye, sliding slowly down the curve of her cheek, leaving a wet streak that shimmers in the dim light. As the tear reaches her jawline, it lingers briefly, gathering weight before silently dripping. The camera follows the tear, focusing on the blade of a meticulously polished steel longsword, resting horizontally below. Its blade reflects the cold, sharp luster of metal in the gloom. The teardrop instantly bursts open upon contact with the mirror-smooth blade, forming a tiny, fleeting ripple. In that moment, the cold, hard surface of the blade clearly yet slightly distortedly reflects her deep eyes, filled with endless sorrow and despair, with long eyelashes trembling slightly. The entire painting is characterized by strong contrasts of light and shadow, and a cold color palette, creating an atmosphere of heartbreak, tranquility, and a profound sense of fate.", + "seed": 21404, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_11/index_9995_seed_21404_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04501252695918083, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04501252695918083, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04501252695918083, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up shot of a young woman's fair, smooth cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward from a level angle to follow a tear sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump, crystalline tear visible spilling from a reddened eye and sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear burst upon contact with a horizontally resting, polished steel longsword blade below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the blade reflect the woman's deep eyes with long eyelashes trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05620034784078598 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9312002658843994 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05620034784078598, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05620034784078598, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5025865435600281, + 0.11621078103780746, + 0.12353946268558502, + 0.06217150762677193, + 0.03323850780725479, + 0.06728214770555496, + 0.0412660576403141, + 0.018522804602980614, + 0.016328519210219383, + 0.018853584304451942 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05620034784078598 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up shot of a young woman's fair, smooth cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward from a level angle to follow a tear sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump, crystalline tear visible spilling from a reddened eye and sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear burst upon contact with a horizontally resting, polished steel longsword blade below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the blade reflect the woman's deep eyes with long eyelashes trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02333454228937626 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773334503173828 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02333454228937626, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02333454228937626, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0789351537823677, + 0.25985971093177795, + 0.049130383878946304, + 0.04820622131228447, + 0.04828016832470894, + 0.4354654848575592, + 0.031615883111953735, + 0.013220719061791897, + 0.014019737020134926, + 0.021266551688313484 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02333454228937626 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up shot of a young woman's fair, smooth cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward from a level angle to follow a tear sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump, crystalline tear visible spilling from a reddened eye and sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear burst upon contact with a horizontally resting, polished steel longsword blade below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the blade reflect the woman's deep eyes with long eyelashes trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023337220773100853 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733371257781982 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023337220773100853, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023337220773100853, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3714078962802887, + 0.07141199707984924, + 0.03519337624311447, + 0.0315905399620533, + 0.05797760561108589, + 0.3613153398036957, + 0.013886146247386932, + 0.025275738909840584, + 0.013296850025653839, + 0.01864451728761196 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023337220773100853 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up shot of a young woman's fair, smooth cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward from a level angle to follow a tear sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump, crystalline tear visible spilling from a reddened eye and sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear burst upon contact with a horizontally resting, polished steel longsword blade below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the blade reflect the woman's deep eyes with long eyelashes trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04310370609164238 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1681036949157715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04310370609164238, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04310370609164238, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3655143082141876, + 0.05405086651444435, + 0.03840787336230278, + 0.03515705093741417, + 0.044050976634025574, + 0.275390625, + 0.04330549016594887, + 0.09119484573602676, + 0.028754886239767075, + 0.02417311817407608 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04310370609164238 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up shot of a young woman's fair, smooth cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward from a level angle to follow a tear sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump, crystalline tear visible spilling from a reddened eye and sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear burst upon contact with a horizontally resting, polished steel longsword blade below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the blade reflect the woman's deep eyes with long eyelashes trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07908681780099869 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790867805480957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07908681780099869, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07908681780099869, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.49219828844070435, + 0.11080910265445709, + 0.030103176832199097, + 0.026791157200932503, + 0.02213977836072445, + 0.13568226993083954, + 0.05022384598851204, + 0.07943834364414215, + 0.03598659113049507, + 0.01662737876176834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07908681780099869 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a dramatic close-up, the camera slowly tilts downward from a level angle, capturing the fair, smooth cheek of a young woman. Illuminated by a faint, soft overhead light in the dim room, the texture of her skin is clearly visible. A plump, crystalline tear silently spills from her reddened eye, sliding slowly down the curve of her cheek, leaving a wet streak that shimmers in the dim light. As the tear reaches her jawline, it lingers briefly, gathering weight before silently dripping. The camera follows the tear, focusing on the blade of a meticulously polished steel longsword, resting horizontally below. Its blade reflects the cold, sharp luster of metal in the gloom. The teardrop instantly bursts open upon contact with the mirror-smooth blade, forming a tiny, fleeting ripple. In that moment, the cold, hard surface of the blade clearly yet slightly distortedly reflects her deep eyes, filled with endless sorrow and despair, with long eyelashes trembling slightly. The entire painting is characterized by strong contrasts of light and shadow, and a cold color palette, creating an atmosphere of heartbreak, tranquility, and a profound sense of fate.", + "seed": 21405, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_11/index_9995_seed_21405_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04918730752542615, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04918730752542615, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04918730752542615, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up shot of a young woman's fair, smooth cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward from a level angle to follow a tear sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump, crystalline tear visible spilling from a reddened eye and sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear burst upon contact with a horizontally resting, polished steel longsword blade below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the blade reflect the woman's deep eyes with long eyelashes trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06406773626804352 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.814067840576172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06406773626804352, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06406773626804352, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21282054483890533, + 0.10701299458742142, + 0.3847305476665497, + 0.07600009441375732, + 0.06828147917985916, + 0.05567535012960434, + 0.052638035267591476, + 0.01390230655670166, + 0.013391776941716671, + 0.015546835027635098 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06406773626804352 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up shot of a young woman's fair, smooth cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward from a level angle to follow a tear sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump, crystalline tear visible spilling from a reddened eye and sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear burst upon contact with a horizontally resting, polished steel longsword blade below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the blade reflect the woman's deep eyes with long eyelashes trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01423866767436266 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2642388343811035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01423866767436266, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01423866767436266, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1313263326883316, + 0.13372938334941864, + 0.09170741587877274, + 0.33100539445877075, + 0.1355695128440857, + 0.036673653870821, + 0.038896944373846054, + 0.027345871552824974, + 0.04142632707953453, + 0.03231916204094887 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01423866767436266 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up shot of a young woman's fair, smooth cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward from a level angle to follow a tear sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump, crystalline tear visible spilling from a reddened eye and sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear burst upon contact with a horizontally resting, polished steel longsword blade below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the blade reflect the woman's deep eyes with long eyelashes trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006765672471374273 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006765842437744 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006765672471374273, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006765672471374273, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09667667746543884, + 0.15476644039154053, + 0.2417607307434082, + 0.1917044222354889, + 0.11605504900217056, + 0.045263029634952545, + 0.07568210363388062, + 0.023276466876268387, + 0.030685488134622574, + 0.02412959188222885 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006765672471374273 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up shot of a young woman's fair, smooth cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward from a level angle to follow a tear sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump, crystalline tear visible spilling from a reddened eye and sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear burst upon contact with a horizontally resting, polished steel longsword blade below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the blade reflect the woman's deep eyes with long eyelashes trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0337250716984272 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087250232696533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0337250716984272, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0337250716984272, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061986472457647324, + 0.11976594477891922, + 0.032322563230991364, + 0.2471926212310791, + 0.07572098821401596, + 0.058058205991983414, + 0.09819771349430084, + 0.06256594508886337, + 0.1325049102306366, + 0.11168457567691803 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0337250716984272 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up shot of a young woman's fair, smooth cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward from a level angle to follow a tear sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump, crystalline tear visible spilling from a reddened eye and sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear burst upon contact with a horizontally resting, polished steel longsword blade below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the blade reflect the woman's deep eyes with long eyelashes trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1271393895149231 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1271393299102783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1271393895149231, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1271393895149231, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20099139213562012, + 0.15803198516368866, + 0.07780993729829788, + 0.07948191463947296, + 0.05552466958761215, + 0.15584099292755127, + 0.14179587364196777, + 0.030962301418185234, + 0.026050452142953873, + 0.07351043820381165 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1271393895149231 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a dramatic close-up, the camera slowly tilts downward from a level angle, capturing the fair, smooth cheek of a young woman. Illuminated by a faint, soft overhead light in the dim room, the texture of her skin is clearly visible. A plump, crystalline tear silently spills from her reddened eye, sliding slowly down the curve of her cheek, leaving a wet streak that shimmers in the dim light. As the tear reaches her jawline, it lingers briefly, gathering weight before silently dripping. The camera follows the tear, focusing on the blade of a meticulously polished steel longsword, resting horizontally below. Its blade reflects the cold, sharp luster of metal in the gloom. The teardrop instantly bursts open upon contact with the mirror-smooth blade, forming a tiny, fleeting ripple. In that moment, the cold, hard surface of the blade clearly yet slightly distortedly reflects her deep eyes, filled with endless sorrow and despair, with long eyelashes trembling slightly. The entire painting is characterized by strong contrasts of light and shadow, and a cold color palette, creating an atmosphere of heartbreak, tranquility, and a profound sense of fate.", + "seed": 21406, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_11/index_9995_seed_21406_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0708356775343418, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0708356775343418, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0708356775343418, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up shot of a young woman's fair, smooth cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward from a level angle to follow a tear sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump, crystalline tear visible spilling from a reddened eye and sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear burst upon contact with a horizontally resting, polished steel longsword blade below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the blade reflect the woman's deep eyes with long eyelashes trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0219540074467659 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.89695405960083 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0219540074467659, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0219540074467659, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2416178584098816, + 0.1991109848022461, + 0.14551280438899994, + 0.13465596735477448, + 0.13376495242118835, + 0.05550718307495117, + 0.01625593565404415, + 0.020606612786650658, + 0.01639898121356964, + 0.036568742245435715 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0219540074467659 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up shot of a young woman's fair, smooth cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward from a level angle to follow a tear sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump, crystalline tear visible spilling from a reddened eye and sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear burst upon contact with a horizontally resting, polished steel longsword blade below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the blade reflect the woman's deep eyes with long eyelashes trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0381472185254097 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288147211074829 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0381472185254097, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0381472185254097, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12793336808681488, + 0.22522948682308197, + 0.14198052883148193, + 0.14077559113502502, + 0.07883375138044357, + 0.12091981619596481, + 0.06871864199638367, + 0.018049350008368492, + 0.035271674394607544, + 0.042287811636924744 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0381472185254097 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up shot of a young woman's fair, smooth cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward from a level angle to follow a tear sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump, crystalline tear visible spilling from a reddened eye and sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear burst upon contact with a horizontally resting, polished steel longsword blade below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the blade reflect the woman's deep eyes with long eyelashes trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06209556385874748 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120956420898438 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06209556385874748, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06209556385874748, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.438289612531662, + 0.12887927889823914, + 0.08880171179771423, + 0.06673268973827362, + 0.0291945468634367, + 0.07613769918680191, + 0.05762076377868652, + 0.05565181374549866, + 0.03502411022782326, + 0.02366776578128338 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06209556385874748 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up shot of a young woman's fair, smooth cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward from a level angle to follow a tear sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump, crystalline tear visible spilling from a reddened eye and sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear burst upon contact with a horizontally resting, polished steel longsword blade below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the blade reflect the woman's deep eyes with long eyelashes trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08907894045114517 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464078903198242 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08907894045114517, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08907894045114517, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09429605305194855, + 0.04406118765473366, + 0.03499487787485123, + 0.05507051944732666, + 0.04082190617918968, + 0.16959933936595917, + 0.15317769348621368, + 0.12366379052400589, + 0.055130090564489365, + 0.22918449342250824 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08907894045114517 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a close-up shot of a young woman's fair, smooth cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward from a level angle to follow a tear sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a plump, crystalline tear visible spilling from a reddened eye and sliding down the cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear burst upon contact with a horizontally resting, polished steel longsword blade below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the blade reflect the woman's deep eyes with long eyelashes trembling slightly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1429026573896408 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0179026126861572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1429026573896408, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1429026573896408, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1959553360939026, + 0.2362748086452484, + 0.061009909957647324, + 0.05063994973897934, + 0.053609445691108704, + 0.16909943521022797, + 0.03469831496477127, + 0.098078154027462, + 0.04476863890886307, + 0.05586601421236992 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1429026573896408 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_12/index_tensor([5170, 5170])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_12/index_tensor([5170, 5170])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0bc41e4af1765d40ac2c9ed73a85a21b900701e4 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_12/index_tensor([5170, 5170])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The film begins with an extreme close-up, the frame completely dominated by a single crimson maple leaf. Its veins are clearly visible, like a miniature, branching river system, each tiny vein brimming with the texture of life. A layer of translucent morning dew coats the leaf's surface, shimmering in the soft, diffuse light, making the red appear particularly vibrant. As the camera slowly and steadily pulls back, the leaf begins an elegant aerial ballet, gently swaying and circling in the air, then descending in a slow, rhythmic manner. The pull-out gradually reveals the vast, ethereal background behind it: the sky is not blue, but a vast, unfolding ink painting. Light gray clouds, like moist ink spreading naturally across rice paper, create a layered effect of varying shades and blurred edges. In this minimalist, almost monochrome world of cold colors, the falling red leaf is the only bright color. Every flip and drift of it draws the eye. In the end, it becomes a lonely and eye-catching red dot, falling into the boundless gray and white. The whole picture is filled with a quiet, lonely and poetic oriental aesthetic atmosphere.", + "seed": 8513, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_12/index_5170_seed_8513_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.39471468292176726, + "vlm_logprob": -0.39471468292176726, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.39471468292176726, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of a single crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the maple leaf covered in a layer of translucent morning dew that shimmers in the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to reveal the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast sky with light gray clouds resembling ink spreading on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the maple leaf perform an aerial motion of swaying, circling, and descending slowly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04898514971137047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048985242843628 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04898514971137047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04898514971137047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21589571237564087, + 0.38165831565856934, + 0.04730856418609619, + 0.056654784828424454, + 0.08196882158517838, + 0.058007460087537766, + 0.07287733256816864, + 0.0583062618970871, + 0.009962880052626133, + 0.017359793186187744 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04898514971137047 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of a single crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the maple leaf covered in a layer of translucent morning dew that shimmers in the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to reveal the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast sky with light gray clouds resembling ink spreading on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the maple leaf perform an aerial motion of swaying, circling, and descending slowly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048641681671143 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17986416816711426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.8048641681671143, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.8048641681671143, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15000727772712708, + 0.6320302486419678, + 0.026025716215372086, + 0.03781122714281082, + 0.02163008786737919, + 0.008898301981389523, + 0.02269788458943367, + 0.04020863398909569, + 0.032490603625774384, + 0.0281999371945858 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.8048641681671143 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of a single crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the maple leaf covered in a layer of translucent morning dew that shimmers in the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to reveal the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast sky with light gray clouds resembling ink spreading on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the maple leaf perform an aerial motion of swaying, circling, and descending slowly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02636384405195713 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513638496398926 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02636384405195713, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02636384405195713, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1504695862531662, + 0.5447389483451843, + 0.03880031779408455, + 0.041742999106645584, + 0.03817607834935188, + 0.011747908778488636, + 0.06633467972278595, + 0.05718480795621872, + 0.03155922144651413, + 0.019245482981204987 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02636384405195713 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of a single crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the maple leaf covered in a layer of translucent morning dew that shimmers in the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to reveal the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast sky with light gray clouds resembling ink spreading on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the maple leaf perform an aerial motion of swaying, circling, and descending slowly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02331031858921051 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773310422897339 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02331031858921051, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02331031858921051, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13720422983169556, + 0.41402581334114075, + 0.07945048809051514, + 0.06032583490014076, + 0.09893961995840073, + 0.04677151143550873, + 0.04783120006322861, + 0.03513309732079506, + 0.04231582209467888, + 0.03800242766737938 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02331031858921051 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of a single crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the maple leaf covered in a layer of translucent morning dew that shimmers in the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to reveal the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast sky with light gray clouds resembling ink spreading on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the maple leaf perform an aerial motion of swaying, circling, and descending slowly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004993408918381 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695050001144409 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004993408918381, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004993408918381, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13062690198421478, + 0.39453351497650146, + 0.07649575918912888, + 0.2046641707420349, + 0.04400824382901192, + 0.05388748645782471, + 0.04363192990422249, + 0.0132065424695611, + 0.010567482560873032, + 0.02837793156504631 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004993408918381 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with an extreme close-up, the frame completely dominated by a single crimson maple leaf. Its veins are clearly visible, like a miniature, branching river system, each tiny vein brimming with the texture of life. A layer of translucent morning dew coats the leaf's surface, shimmering in the soft, diffuse light, making the red appear particularly vibrant. As the camera slowly and steadily pulls back, the leaf begins an elegant aerial ballet, gently swaying and circling in the air, then descending in a slow, rhythmic manner. The pull-out gradually reveals the vast, ethereal background behind it: the sky is not blue, but a vast, unfolding ink painting. Light gray clouds, like moist ink spreading naturally across rice paper, create a layered effect of varying shades and blurred edges. In this minimalist, almost monochrome world of cold colors, the falling red leaf is the only bright color. Every flip and drift of it draws the eye. In the end, it becomes a lonely and eye-catching red dot, falling into the boundless gray and white. The whole picture is filled with a quiet, lonely and poetic oriental aesthetic atmosphere.", + "seed": 8514, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_12/index_5170_seed_8514_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.3357154347002506, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3357154347002506, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3357154347002506, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of a single crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the maple leaf covered in a layer of translucent morning dew that shimmers in the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to reveal the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast sky with light gray clouds resembling ink spreading on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the maple leaf perform an aerial motion of swaying, circling, and descending slowly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020897915586829185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.89589786529541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020897915586829185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020897915586829185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.009732167236506939, + 0.036152396351099014, + 0.012868099845945835, + 0.032354824244976044, + 0.8395100831985474, + 0.03893248736858368, + 0.008353742770850658, + 0.008038380183279514, + 0.009350859560072422, + 0.004706951789557934 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020897915586829185 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of a single crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the maple leaf covered in a layer of translucent morning dew that shimmers in the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to reveal the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast sky with light gray clouds resembling ink spreading on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the maple leaf perform an aerial motion of swaying, circling, and descending slowly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005475521087646 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22554753720760345 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.6005475521087646, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.6005475521087646, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10980786383152008, + 0.11320000886917114, + 0.03375083580613136, + 0.02756090834736824, + 0.6446391344070435, + 0.0187752153724432, + 0.013687191531062126, + 0.016799727454781532, + 0.01214491855353117, + 0.009634247981011868 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.6005475521087646 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of a single crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the maple leaf covered in a layer of translucent morning dew that shimmers in the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to reveal the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast sky with light gray clouds resembling ink spreading on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the maple leaf perform an aerial motion of swaying, circling, and descending slowly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012554895132780075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387555122375488 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012554895132780075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012554895132780075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.060666587203741074, + 0.159682035446167, + 0.06239064037799835, + 0.027170754969120026, + 0.5674074292182922, + 0.020821038633584976, + 0.049712397158145905, + 0.020226536318659782, + 0.02017008513212204, + 0.011752407997846603 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012554895132780075 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of a single crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the maple leaf covered in a layer of translucent morning dew that shimmers in the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to reveal the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast sky with light gray clouds resembling ink spreading on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the maple leaf perform an aerial motion of swaying, circling, and descending slowly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026374874636530876 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513748168945312 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026374874636530876, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026374874636530876, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09417330473661423, + 0.0644814744591713, + 0.0453958734869957, + 0.012325877323746681, + 0.6017695665359497, + 0.05224284902215004, + 0.02714187651872635, + 0.0477871373295784, + 0.0340738445520401, + 0.020608216524124146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026374874636530876 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of a single crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the maple leaf covered in a layer of translucent morning dew that shimmers in the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to reveal the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast sky with light gray clouds resembling ink spreading on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the maple leaf perform an aerial motion of swaying, circling, and descending slowly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018201936036348343 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01820182800293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018201936036348343, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018201936036348343, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04410060495138168, + 0.021179083734750748, + 0.03322683647274971, + 0.04320796579122543, + 0.769199013710022, + 0.019776880741119385, + 0.017630556598305702, + 0.014552491717040539, + 0.009957616217434406, + 0.027168909087777138 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018201936036348343 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with an extreme close-up, the frame completely dominated by a single crimson maple leaf. Its veins are clearly visible, like a miniature, branching river system, each tiny vein brimming with the texture of life. A layer of translucent morning dew coats the leaf's surface, shimmering in the soft, diffuse light, making the red appear particularly vibrant. As the camera slowly and steadily pulls back, the leaf begins an elegant aerial ballet, gently swaying and circling in the air, then descending in a slow, rhythmic manner. The pull-out gradually reveals the vast, ethereal background behind it: the sky is not blue, but a vast, unfolding ink painting. Light gray clouds, like moist ink spreading naturally across rice paper, create a layered effect of varying shades and blurred edges. In this minimalist, almost monochrome world of cold colors, the falling red leaf is the only bright color. Every flip and drift of it draws the eye. In the end, it becomes a lonely and eye-catching red dot, falling into the boundless gray and white. The whole picture is filled with a quiet, lonely and poetic oriental aesthetic atmosphere.", + "seed": 8515, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_12/index_5170_seed_8515_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.2491599652916193, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2491599652916193, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2491599652916193, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of a single crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the maple leaf covered in a layer of translucent morning dew that shimmers in the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to reveal the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast sky with light gray clouds resembling ink spreading on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the maple leaf perform an aerial motion of swaying, circling, and descending slowly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016262495890259743 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141262531280518 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016262495890259743, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016262495890259743, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27626365423202515, + 0.09408321231603622, + 0.18926553428173065, + 0.13780121505260468, + 0.038796763867139816, + 0.09342532604932785, + 0.07943852990865707, + 0.027080658823251724, + 0.028925130143761635, + 0.03491995111107826 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016262495890259743 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of a single crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the maple leaf covered in a layer of translucent morning dew that shimmers in the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to reveal the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast sky with light gray clouds resembling ink spreading on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the maple leaf perform an aerial motion of swaying, circling, and descending slowly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370724439620972 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38707244396209717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1370724439620972, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1370724439620972, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5191523432731628, + 0.047748811542987823, + 0.19513851404190063, + 0.04814726859331131, + 0.039219897240400314, + 0.015880810096859932, + 0.04943990707397461, + 0.02534347213804722, + 0.032829251140356064, + 0.02709963545203209 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1370724439620972 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of a single crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the maple leaf covered in a layer of translucent morning dew that shimmers in the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to reveal the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast sky with light gray clouds resembling ink spreading on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the maple leaf perform an aerial motion of swaying, circling, and descending slowly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009793803095817566 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634793758392334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009793803095817566, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009793803095817566, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.189737930893898, + 0.15412890911102295, + 0.16985324025154114, + 0.08635442703962326, + 0.04938163608312607, + 0.05068590119481087, + 0.15888845920562744, + 0.024948736652731895, + 0.0802254006266594, + 0.035795390605926514 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009793803095817566 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of a single crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the maple leaf covered in a layer of translucent morning dew that shimmers in the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to reveal the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast sky with light gray clouds resembling ink spreading on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the maple leaf perform an aerial motion of swaying, circling, and descending slowly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020602744072675705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956027030944824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020602744072675705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020602744072675705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2499363124370575, + 0.09268048405647278, + 0.10906777530908585, + 0.06930915266275406, + 0.0426328219473362, + 0.05556396394968033, + 0.2016671895980835, + 0.06106403097510338, + 0.07890132069587708, + 0.03917694464325905 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020602744072675705 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of a single crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the maple leaf covered in a layer of translucent morning dew that shimmers in the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to reveal the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast sky with light gray clouds resembling ink spreading on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the maple leaf perform an aerial motion of swaying, circling, and descending slowly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06206833943724632 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812068223953247 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06206833943724632, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06206833943724632, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21617570519447327, + 0.2291737198829651, + 0.21090975403785706, + 0.04164411500096321, + 0.03449436277151108, + 0.07591540366411209, + 0.06338657438755035, + 0.027872078120708466, + 0.07267079502344131, + 0.027757471427321434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06206833943724632 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with an extreme close-up, the frame completely dominated by a single crimson maple leaf. Its veins are clearly visible, like a miniature, branching river system, each tiny vein brimming with the texture of life. A layer of translucent morning dew coats the leaf's surface, shimmering in the soft, diffuse light, making the red appear particularly vibrant. As the camera slowly and steadily pulls back, the leaf begins an elegant aerial ballet, gently swaying and circling in the air, then descending in a slow, rhythmic manner. The pull-out gradually reveals the vast, ethereal background behind it: the sky is not blue, but a vast, unfolding ink painting. Light gray clouds, like moist ink spreading naturally across rice paper, create a layered effect of varying shades and blurred edges. In this minimalist, almost monochrome world of cold colors, the falling red leaf is the only bright color. Every flip and drift of it draws the eye. In the end, it becomes a lonely and eye-catching red dot, falling into the boundless gray and white. The whole picture is filled with a quiet, lonely and poetic oriental aesthetic atmosphere.", + "seed": 8516, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_12/index_5170_seed_8516_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.37242642752826216, + "vlm_logprob": -0.37242642752826216, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.37242642752826216, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of a single crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the maple leaf covered in a layer of translucent morning dew that shimmers in the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to reveal the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast sky with light gray clouds resembling ink spreading on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the maple leaf perform an aerial motion of swaying, circling, and descending slowly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04921180382370949 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0492117404937744 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04921180382370949, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04921180382370949, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05782250687479973, + 0.02975202165544033, + 0.022130211815238, + 0.06642431020736694, + 0.07651367038488388, + 0.14812840521335602, + 0.42252030968666077, + 0.13491900265216827, + 0.02635849453508854, + 0.015431053936481476 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04921180382370949 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of a single crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the maple leaf covered in a layer of translucent morning dew that shimmers in the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to reveal the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast sky with light gray clouds resembling ink spreading on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the maple leaf perform an aerial motion of swaying, circling, and descending slowly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005795001983643 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22557951509952545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.6005795001983643, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.6005795001983643, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26080095767974854, + 0.04688991606235504, + 0.06822330504655838, + 0.14205443859100342, + 0.0658903643488884, + 0.04726967588067055, + 0.2481841892004013, + 0.07257524132728577, + 0.02419193461537361, + 0.02391994558274746 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.6005795001983643 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of a single crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the maple leaf covered in a layer of translucent morning dew that shimmers in the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to reveal the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast sky with light gray clouds resembling ink spreading on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the maple leaf perform an aerial motion of swaying, circling, and descending slowly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01820182055234909 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01820182800293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01820182055234909, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01820182055234909, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10643388330936432, + 0.040954187512397766, + 0.03122565522789955, + 0.06653852760791779, + 0.06981372088193893, + 0.2176813930273056, + 0.3256800174713135, + 0.08615568280220032, + 0.026730576530098915, + 0.028786400333046913 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01820182055234909 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of a single crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the maple leaf covered in a layer of translucent morning dew that shimmers in the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to reveal the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast sky with light gray clouds resembling ink spreading on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the maple leaf perform an aerial motion of swaying, circling, and descending slowly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01421281136572361 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264212608337402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01421281136572361, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01421281136572361, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11415070295333862, + 0.045270886272192, + 0.06358934193849564, + 0.0997377261519432, + 0.13675419986248016, + 0.04422172158956528, + 0.13937968015670776, + 0.06391609460115433, + 0.06127222999930382, + 0.23170743882656097 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01421281136572361 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of a single crimson maple leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the maple leaf covered in a layer of translucent morning dew that shimmers in the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily pull back to reveal the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast sky with light gray clouds resembling ink spreading on rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the maple leaf perform an aerial motion of swaying, circling, and descending slowly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17992620170116425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049261569976807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17992620170116425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17992620170116425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12177835404872894, + 0.028997361660003662, + 0.01654084399342537, + 0.06336119771003723, + 0.2504860460758209, + 0.11314544081687927, + 0.3041321039199829, + 0.04587305337190628, + 0.010927485302090645, + 0.044758088886737823 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17992620170116425 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_13/index_tensor([7838, 7838])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_13/index_tensor([7838, 7838])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..537e9b7a6a60c05cd6a0449f9d2aaf9f0a5f238e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_13/index_tensor([7838, 7838])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, taken from a slightly overhead perspective, the camera remains still, focusing on a pair of clean, knuckled hands meticulously carving food on a dark wooden cutting board with intense concentration. One hand steadily and gently grasps a bright orange carrot, one end expertly shaved into the shape of a petal, poised to bloom. The other deftly manipulates a small, sharp carving knife, its tip carefully slicing, cutting, and picking at the carrot. With each stroke of the knife, a thin, cicada-wing piece of carrot curls and peels away, gradually revealing the outline of the next petal. The fresh texture and moist cut surface of the carrot are clearly visible. A warm overhead light, diagonally shining from above, precisely illuminates the hands and the orange \"flower,\" casting soft yet sharp shadows on the cutting board. The blade occasionally gleams with a cool, metallic sheen. The background is softly blurred, and the warm hues of the entire scene create a tranquil, focused, and artistic atmosphere, imbued with the charm of craftsmanship and the beauty of creation.", + "seed": 9147, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_13/index_7838_seed_9147_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.026786430925130843, + "vlm_logprob": -0.026786430925130843, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.026786430925130843, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of clean, knuckled hands visible carving food on a dark wooden cutting board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright orange carrot being carved into a petal shape with thin, curling pieces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a small, sharp carving knife visible with a cool, metallic sheen on its blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot from a slightly overhead perspective and remains still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred with warm overhead lighting casting soft yet sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06336240470409393 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8133623600006104 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06336240470409393, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06336240470409393, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1983676254749298, + 0.042720869183540344, + 0.03862809017300606, + 0.0361827090382576, + 0.05584188178181648, + 0.09523177891969681, + 0.09575477242469788, + 0.2240620106458664, + 0.0839398130774498, + 0.12927046418190002 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06336240470409393 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of clean, knuckled hands visible carving food on a dark wooden cutting board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright orange carrot being carved into a petal shape with thin, curling pieces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a small, sharp carving knife visible with a cool, metallic sheen on its blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot from a slightly overhead perspective and remains still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred with warm overhead lighting casting soft yet sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007647995837032795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88264799118042 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007647995837032795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007647995837032795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40309780836105347, + 0.10711521655321121, + 0.04397263005375862, + 0.014522096142172813, + 0.05209420993924141, + 0.048090361058712006, + 0.07189830392599106, + 0.12146550416946411, + 0.06815709918737411, + 0.06958668678998947 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007647995837032795 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of clean, knuckled hands visible carving food on a dark wooden cutting board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright orange carrot being carved into a petal shape with thin, curling pieces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a small, sharp carving knife visible with a cool, metallic sheen on its blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot from a slightly overhead perspective and remains still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred with warm overhead lighting casting soft yet sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369763866066933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086976051330566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369763866066933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369763866066933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09484340995550156, + 0.06808280199766159, + 0.029232874512672424, + 0.018734535202383995, + 0.03611554950475693, + 0.043921492993831635, + 0.048408981412649155, + 0.29988983273506165, + 0.2243591994047165, + 0.13641132414340973 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369763866066933 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of clean, knuckled hands visible carving food on a dark wooden cutting board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright orange carrot being carved into a petal shape with thin, curling pieces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a small, sharp carving knife visible with a cool, metallic sheen on its blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot from a slightly overhead perspective and remains still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred with warm overhead lighting casting soft yet sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02327992208302021 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773279905319214 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02327992208302021, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02327992208302021, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09011555463075638, + 0.05322101712226868, + 0.03366608917713165, + 0.020277466624975204, + 0.09177479892969131, + 0.07446347177028656, + 0.07478122413158417, + 0.42343321442604065, + 0.04160405695438385, + 0.09666311740875244 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02327992208302021 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of clean, knuckled hands visible carving food on a dark wooden cutting board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright orange carrot being carved into a petal shape with thin, curling pieces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a small, sharp carving knife visible with a cool, metallic sheen on its blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot from a slightly overhead perspective and remains still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred with warm overhead lighting casting soft yet sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059441933408379555 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.13094425201416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059441933408379555, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059441933408379555, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12123242020606995, + 0.06631375104188919, + 0.024189824238419533, + 0.011236324906349182, + 0.12318632751703262, + 0.059230905026197433, + 0.06956937164068222, + 0.19011461734771729, + 0.23633521795272827, + 0.09859123080968857 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059441933408379555 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, taken from a slightly overhead perspective, the camera remains still, focusing on a pair of clean, knuckled hands meticulously carving food on a dark wooden cutting board with intense concentration. One hand steadily and gently grasps a bright orange carrot, one end expertly shaved into the shape of a petal, poised to bloom. The other deftly manipulates a small, sharp carving knife, its tip carefully slicing, cutting, and picking at the carrot. With each stroke of the knife, a thin, cicada-wing piece of carrot curls and peels away, gradually revealing the outline of the next petal. The fresh texture and moist cut surface of the carrot are clearly visible. A warm overhead light, diagonally shining from above, precisely illuminates the hands and the orange \"flower,\" casting soft yet sharp shadows on the cutting board. The blade occasionally gleams with a cool, metallic sheen. The background is softly blurred, and the warm hues of the entire scene create a tranquil, focused, and artistic atmosphere, imbued with the charm of craftsmanship and the beauty of creation.", + "seed": 9148, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_13/index_7838_seed_9148_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03606934389099479, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03606934389099479, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03606934389099479, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of clean, knuckled hands visible carving food on a dark wooden cutting board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright orange carrot being carved into a petal shape with thin, curling pieces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a small, sharp carving knife visible with a cool, metallic sheen on its blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot from a slightly overhead perspective and remains still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred with warm overhead lighting casting soft yet sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11406783014535904 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.239067792892456 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11406783014535904, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11406783014535904, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3173379600048065, + 0.06403039395809174, + 0.049400631338357925, + 0.24162277579307556, + 0.035641446709632874, + 0.02232186309993267, + 0.08212582767009735, + 0.07779949903488159, + 0.025517316535115242, + 0.08420231938362122 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11406783014535904 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of clean, knuckled hands visible carving food on a dark wooden cutting board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright orange carrot being carved into a petal shape with thin, curling pieces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a small, sharp carving knife visible with a cool, metallic sheen on its blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot from a slightly overhead perspective and remains still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred with warm overhead lighting casting soft yet sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007645629812031984 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882645606994629 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007645629812031984, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007645629812031984, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11084204912185669, + 0.10229639708995819, + 0.14104902744293213, + 0.12572240829467773, + 0.0387534461915493, + 0.07987227290868759, + 0.07134071737527847, + 0.19954483211040497, + 0.022092461585998535, + 0.10848645120859146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007645629812031984 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of clean, knuckled hands visible carving food on a dark wooden cutting board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright orange carrot being carved into a petal shape with thin, curling pieces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a small, sharp carving knife visible with a cool, metallic sheen on its blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot from a slightly overhead perspective and remains still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred with warm overhead lighting casting soft yet sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634863369166851 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.65134859085083 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634863369166851, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634863369166851, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07868103682994843, + 0.10875767469406128, + 0.017052631825208664, + 0.3431793451309204, + 0.1495831459760666, + 0.02122301235795021, + 0.1282682865858078, + 0.03201236203312874, + 0.019003968685865402, + 0.10223858803510666 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634863369166851 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of clean, knuckled hands visible carving food on a dark wooden cutting board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright orange carrot being carved into a petal shape with thin, curling pieces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a small, sharp carving knife visible with a cool, metallic sheen on its blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot from a slightly overhead perspective and remains still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred with warm overhead lighting casting soft yet sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026338299736380577 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513383388519287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026338299736380577, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026338299736380577, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08047118782997131, + 0.08607391268014908, + 0.04471638798713684, + 0.251190721988678, + 0.06984110921621323, + 0.041338883340358734, + 0.07263151556253433, + 0.3326570391654968, + 0.0097119752317667, + 0.01136727537959814 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026338299736380577 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of clean, knuckled hands visible carving food on a dark wooden cutting board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright orange carrot being carved into a petal shape with thin, curling pieces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a small, sharp carving knife visible with a cool, metallic sheen on its blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot from a slightly overhead perspective and remains still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred with warm overhead lighting casting soft yet sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005946326069533825 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130946159362793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005946326069533825, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005946326069533825, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0492042638361454, + 0.05282885953783989, + 0.012834189459681511, + 0.45860958099365234, + 0.13707277178764343, + 0.042744435369968414, + 0.05053326487541199, + 0.1662852168083191, + 0.01404622197151184, + 0.01584123633801937 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005946326069533825 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, taken from a slightly overhead perspective, the camera remains still, focusing on a pair of clean, knuckled hands meticulously carving food on a dark wooden cutting board with intense concentration. One hand steadily and gently grasps a bright orange carrot, one end expertly shaved into the shape of a petal, poised to bloom. The other deftly manipulates a small, sharp carving knife, its tip carefully slicing, cutting, and picking at the carrot. With each stroke of the knife, a thin, cicada-wing piece of carrot curls and peels away, gradually revealing the outline of the next petal. The fresh texture and moist cut surface of the carrot are clearly visible. A warm overhead light, diagonally shining from above, precisely illuminates the hands and the orange \"flower,\" casting soft yet sharp shadows on the cutting board. The blade occasionally gleams with a cool, metallic sheen. The background is softly blurred, and the warm hues of the entire scene create a tranquil, focused, and artistic atmosphere, imbued with the charm of craftsmanship and the beauty of creation.", + "seed": 9149, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_13/index_7838_seed_9149_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05759231736883521, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05759231736883521, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05759231736883521, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of clean, knuckled hands visible carving food on a dark wooden cutting board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright orange carrot being carved into a petal shape with thin, curling pieces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a small, sharp carving knife visible with a cool, metallic sheen on its blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot from a slightly overhead perspective and remains still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred with warm overhead lighting casting soft yet sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12804147601127625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1280415058135986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12804147601127625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12804147601127625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.211525097489357, + 0.06182964891195297, + 0.05611824244260788, + 0.1188986673951149, + 0.13780704140663147, + 0.04434603452682495, + 0.25146016478538513, + 0.04064073786139488, + 0.03798066824674606, + 0.03939375281333923 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12804147601127625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of clean, knuckled hands visible carving food on a dark wooden cutting board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright orange carrot being carved into a petal shape with thin, curling pieces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a small, sharp carving knife visible with a cool, metallic sheen on its blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot from a slightly overhead perspective and remains still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred with warm overhead lighting casting soft yet sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008658604696393013 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758658409118652 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008658604696393013, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008658604696393013, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13706214725971222, + 0.1364571452140808, + 0.1758066564798355, + 0.10365891456604004, + 0.1538410186767578, + 0.047988954931497574, + 0.06504696607589722, + 0.034391071647405624, + 0.11219381541013718, + 0.03355330228805542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008658604696393013 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of clean, knuckled hands visible carving food on a dark wooden cutting board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright orange carrot being carved into a petal shape with thin, curling pieces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a small, sharp carving knife visible with a cool, metallic sheen on its blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot from a slightly overhead perspective and remains still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred with warm overhead lighting casting soft yet sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11293000727891922 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379300594329834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11293000727891922, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11293000727891922, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1633397489786148, + 0.13341231644153595, + 0.1869044452905655, + 0.09571118652820587, + 0.1605226695537567, + 0.12927095592021942, + 0.06020120531320572, + 0.019295545294880867, + 0.03781925514340401, + 0.013522638939321041 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11293000727891922 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of clean, knuckled hands visible carving food on a dark wooden cutting board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright orange carrot being carved into a petal shape with thin, curling pieces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a small, sharp carving knife visible with a cool, metallic sheen on its blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot from a slightly overhead perspective and remains still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred with warm overhead lighting casting soft yet sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033694297075271606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408694267272949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033694297075271606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033694297075271606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06608814746141434, + 0.055441051721572876, + 0.0694214254617691, + 0.09576888382434845, + 0.07490812987089157, + 0.04002957046031952, + 0.08679062873125076, + 0.1760595440864563, + 0.2820090055465698, + 0.05348362773656845 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033694297075271606 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of clean, knuckled hands visible carving food on a dark wooden cutting board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright orange carrot being carved into a petal shape with thin, curling pieces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a small, sharp carving knife visible with a cool, metallic sheen on its blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot from a slightly overhead perspective and remains still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred with warm overhead lighting casting soft yet sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046372017823159695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379637241363525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046372017823159695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046372017823159695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2658015191555023, + 0.1265709400177002, + 0.03624642267823219, + 0.1521816849708557, + 0.059839315712451935, + 0.06920208781957626, + 0.057296451181173325, + 0.08376926928758621, + 0.11466321349143982, + 0.03442902863025665 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046372017823159695 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot, taken from a slightly overhead perspective, the camera remains still, focusing on a pair of clean, knuckled hands meticulously carving food on a dark wooden cutting board with intense concentration. One hand steadily and gently grasps a bright orange carrot, one end expertly shaved into the shape of a petal, poised to bloom. The other deftly manipulates a small, sharp carving knife, its tip carefully slicing, cutting, and picking at the carrot. With each stroke of the knife, a thin, cicada-wing piece of carrot curls and peels away, gradually revealing the outline of the next petal. The fresh texture and moist cut surface of the carrot are clearly visible. A warm overhead light, diagonally shining from above, precisely illuminates the hands and the orange \"flower,\" casting soft yet sharp shadows on the cutting board. The blade occasionally gleams with a cool, metallic sheen. The background is softly blurred, and the warm hues of the entire scene create a tranquil, focused, and artistic atmosphere, imbued with the charm of craftsmanship and the beauty of creation.", + "seed": 9150, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_13/index_7838_seed_9150_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0191677994094789, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0191677994094789, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0191677994094789, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of clean, knuckled hands visible carving food on a dark wooden cutting board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright orange carrot being carved into a petal shape with thin, curling pieces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a small, sharp carving knife visible with a cool, metallic sheen on its blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot from a slightly overhead perspective and remains still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred with warm overhead lighting casting soft yet sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04378969222307205 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1687896251678467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04378969222307205, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04378969222307205, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6599295139312744, + 0.058122243732213974, + 0.021633094176650047, + 0.03826206550002098, + 0.034687817096710205, + 0.06269343197345734, + 0.05194346606731415, + 0.007949167862534523, + 0.047879546880722046, + 0.016899684444069862 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04378969222307205 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of clean, knuckled hands visible carving food on a dark wooden cutting board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright orange carrot being carved into a petal shape with thin, curling pieces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a small, sharp carving knife visible with a cool, metallic sheen on its blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot from a slightly overhead perspective and remains still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred with warm overhead lighting casting soft yet sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006753121502697468 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006752967834473 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006753121502697468, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006753121502697468, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5792264938354492, + 0.06584937870502472, + 0.025890009477734566, + 0.028222745284438133, + 0.08604434877634048, + 0.05908825248479843, + 0.051415134221315384, + 0.016948943957686424, + 0.01931076869368553, + 0.06800399720668793 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006753121502697468 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of clean, knuckled hands visible carving food on a dark wooden cutting board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright orange carrot being carved into a petal shape with thin, curling pieces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a small, sharp carving knife visible with a cool, metallic sheen on its blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot from a slightly overhead perspective and remains still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred with warm overhead lighting casting soft yet sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02328772470355034 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773287773132324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02328772470355034, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02328772470355034, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7068184018135071, + 0.05182095989584923, + 0.017176300287246704, + 0.03695092350244522, + 0.06017357483506203, + 0.053208451718091965, + 0.027452826499938965, + 0.013020198792219162, + 0.014288229867815971, + 0.019090179353952408 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02328772470355034 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of clean, knuckled hands visible carving food on a dark wooden cutting board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright orange carrot being carved into a petal shape with thin, curling pieces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a small, sharp carving knife visible with a cool, metallic sheen on its blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot from a slightly overhead perspective and remains still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred with warm overhead lighting casting soft yet sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016063909977674484 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141063690185547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016063909977674484, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016063909977674484, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16531184315681458, + 0.1007661297917366, + 0.04380105808377266, + 0.03984171524643898, + 0.13274826109409332, + 0.08277345448732376, + 0.11105142533779144, + 0.11240877956151962, + 0.09523744881153107, + 0.11605989187955856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016063909977674484 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are a pair of clean, knuckled hands visible carving food on a dark wooden cutting board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a bright orange carrot being carved into a petal shape with thin, curling pieces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a small, sharp carving knife visible with a cool, metallic sheen on its blade?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned in a close-up shot from a slightly overhead perspective and remains still?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background softly blurred with warm overhead lighting casting soft yet sharp shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005944548640400171 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130944728851318 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005944548640400171, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005944548640400171, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.47863954305648804, + 0.0540800467133522, + 0.041105251759290695, + 0.06704845279455185, + 0.06932259351015091, + 0.08101099729537964, + 0.08696532249450684, + 0.02536999061703682, + 0.0470769889652729, + 0.049380749464035034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005944548640400171 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_14/index_tensor([8718, 8718])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_14/index_tensor([8718, 8718])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d83651b167b476ccb589bc70b1aee18532dcd431 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_14/index_tensor([8718, 8718])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, beginning at eye level and then slowly rising to a slight overhead perspective, captures a sun-drenched, bustling European square. The ancient cobblestones gleam in the warm golden afternoon sun, and in the center, an ornate stone fountain joyfully sprays water. Initially, the image unfolds in real time: a flock of pigeons, their feathers a riot of gray, white, and iridescent colors, leisurely peck at the ground, surrounded by tourists in a variety of casual attire and expressions. Suddenly, as the flock, startled, suddenly soars into the air, the rhythm of the world is instantly stretched, seamlessly transitioning into extreme slow motion. As the pigeons flap their wings vigorously, every muscle contraction and feather spread is visible, and the dust particles stirred up are frozen in the light. The water droplets from the fountain are no longer a dynamic mist, but suspended in mid-air like countless shimmering crystal beads, each reflecting a dazzling light. On the ground, the expressions of the tourists slowly shifted at a near-still frame rate: a child's mouth gaped in a moment of surprise; a woman, holding her phone, moved her arm imperceptibly, her face shifting from indifference to wonder. When the torrent of birds finally rose and dispersed, transforming into a vast vortex soaring into the azure sky, the camera smoothly returned to real time, and the gurgling of the fountain and the clamor of the crowds instantly returned, creating a shocking return from surreal tranquility to vivid reality.", + "seed": 10627, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_14/index_8718_seed_10627_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.17385193658992648, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17385193658992648, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17385193658992648, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a sun-drenched European square with ancient cobblestones and an ornate stone fountain in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly rise to a slight overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do pigeons with gray, white, and iridescent feathers initially peck at the ground before suddenly soaring into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition to extreme slow motion when the pigeons take flight, freezing water droplets and dust particles in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video return to real time after the pigeons disperse, restoring the sound of the fountain and the clamor of the crowds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015379408374428749 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.390379428863525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015379408374428749, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015379408374428749, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12167850136756897, + 0.07064136117696762, + 0.3975842595100403, + 0.0841277688741684, + 0.04637251794338226, + 0.07188861817121506, + 0.020624050870537758, + 0.030879339203238487, + 0.0256514735519886, + 0.13055214285850525 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015379408374428749 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a sun-drenched European square with ancient cobblestones and an ornate stone fountain in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly rise to a slight overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do pigeons with gray, white, and iridescent feathers initially peck at the ground before suddenly soaring into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition to extreme slow motion when the pigeons take flight, freezing water droplets and dust particles in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video return to real time after the pigeons disperse, restoring the sound of the fountain and the clamor of the crowds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11296577751636505 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379658222198486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11296577751636505, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11296577751636505, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10711631923913956, + 0.06529812514781952, + 0.15673445165157318, + 0.0409172922372818, + 0.03238587826490402, + 0.08802913874387741, + 0.1239718496799469, + 0.16061647236347198, + 0.15683968365192413, + 0.06809081137180328 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11296577751636505 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a sun-drenched European square with ancient cobblestones and an ornate stone fountain in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly rise to a slight overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do pigeons with gray, white, and iridescent feathers initially peck at the ground before suddenly soaring into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition to extreme slow motion when the pigeons take flight, freezing water droplets and dust particles in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video return to real time after the pigeons disperse, restoring the sound of the fountain and the clamor of the crowds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007640424650162458 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882640361785889 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007640424650162458, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007640424650162458, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05725998058915138, + 0.027003120630979538, + 0.6688137054443359, + 0.02496497891843319, + 0.025244902819395065, + 0.029243187978863716, + 0.07647829502820969, + 0.022753113880753517, + 0.03498689830303192, + 0.0332518145442009 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007640424650162458 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a sun-drenched European square with ancient cobblestones and an ornate stone fountain in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly rise to a slight overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do pigeons with gray, white, and iridescent feathers initially peck at the ground before suddenly soaring into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition to extreme slow motion when the pigeons take flight, freezing water droplets and dust particles in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video return to real time after the pigeons disperse, restoring the sound of the fountain and the clamor of the crowds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10033544898033142 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503353595733643 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10033544898033142, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10033544898033142, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.026960888877511024, + 0.02328013814985752, + 0.8315681219100952, + 0.011160900816321373, + 0.010303412564098835, + 0.013014253228902817, + 0.018292296677827835, + 0.014731953851878643, + 0.014758933335542679, + 0.035929083824157715 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10033544898033142 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a sun-drenched European square with ancient cobblestones and an ornate stone fountain in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly rise to a slight overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do pigeons with gray, white, and iridescent feathers initially peck at the ground before suddenly soaring into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition to extreme slow motion when the pigeons take flight, freezing water droplets and dust particles in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video return to real time after the pigeons disperse, restoring the sound of the fountain and the clamor of the crowds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6329386234283447 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7579386234283447 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6329386234283447, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6329386234283447, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.047699976712465286, + 0.04364240542054176, + 0.6852535009384155, + 0.03684355691075325, + 0.024759169667959213, + 0.023290278390049934, + 0.016346771270036697, + 0.021597012877464294, + 0.04717914015054703, + 0.05338812991976738 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6329386234283447 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, beginning at eye level and then slowly rising to a slight overhead perspective, captures a sun-drenched, bustling European square. The ancient cobblestones gleam in the warm golden afternoon sun, and in the center, an ornate stone fountain joyfully sprays water. Initially, the image unfolds in real time: a flock of pigeons, their feathers a riot of gray, white, and iridescent colors, leisurely peck at the ground, surrounded by tourists in a variety of casual attire and expressions. Suddenly, as the flock, startled, suddenly soars into the air, the rhythm of the world is instantly stretched, seamlessly transitioning into extreme slow motion. As the pigeons flap their wings vigorously, every muscle contraction and feather spread is visible, and the dust particles stirred up are frozen in the light. The water droplets from the fountain are no longer a dynamic mist, but suspended in mid-air like countless shimmering crystal beads, each reflecting a dazzling light. On the ground, the expressions of the tourists slowly shifted at a near-still frame rate: a child's mouth gaped in a moment of surprise; a woman, holding her phone, moved her arm imperceptibly, her face shifting from indifference to wonder. When the torrent of birds finally rose and dispersed, transforming into a vast vortex soaring into the azure sky, the camera smoothly returned to real time, and the gurgling of the fountain and the clamor of the crowds instantly returned, creating a shocking return from surreal tranquility to vivid reality.", + "seed": 10628, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_14/index_8718_seed_10628_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2257775455713272, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2257775455713272, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.8500000059604647, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2257775455713272, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a sun-drenched European square with ancient cobblestones and an ornate stone fountain in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly rise to a slight overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do pigeons with gray, white, and iridescent feathers initially peck at the ground before suddenly soaring into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition to extreme slow motion when the pigeons take flight, freezing water droplets and dust particles in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video return to real time after the pigeons disperse, restoring the sound of the fountain and the clamor of the crowds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016413666307926178 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.266413688659668 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016413666307926178, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016413666307926178, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1972358226776123, + 0.10094656050205231, + 0.12353549897670746, + 0.1267845183610916, + 0.08675198256969452, + 0.2173159420490265, + 0.04045996814966202, + 0.03439674526453018, + 0.03551663085818291, + 0.0370563305914402 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016413666307926178 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a sun-drenched European square with ancient cobblestones and an ornate stone fountain in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly rise to a slight overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do pigeons with gray, white, and iridescent feathers initially peck at the ground before suddenly soaring into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition to extreme slow motion when the pigeons take flight, freezing water droplets and dust particles in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video return to real time after the pigeons disperse, restoring the sound of the fountain and the clamor of the crowds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06208200752735138 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812082052230835 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06208200752735138, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06208200752735138, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10359340161085129, + 0.05132784694433212, + 0.0345437116920948, + 0.0412689670920372, + 0.04275905340909958, + 0.3856354057788849, + 0.05102233588695526, + 0.13029424846172333, + 0.08603313565254211, + 0.07352188229560852 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06208200752735138 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a sun-drenched European square with ancient cobblestones and an ornate stone fountain in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly rise to a slight overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do pigeons with gray, white, and iridescent feathers initially peck at the ground before suddenly soaring into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition to extreme slow motion when the pigeons take flight, freezing water droplets and dust particles in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video return to real time after the pigeons disperse, restoring the sound of the fountain and the clamor of the crowds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005958057940006256 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130958080291748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005958057940006256, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005958057940006256, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08923688530921936, + 0.06103809177875519, + 0.06011069566011429, + 0.07258483022451401, + 0.07569386065006256, + 0.3026033043861389, + 0.08082602173089981, + 0.1363757699728012, + 0.04980820417404175, + 0.07172232866287231 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005958057940006256 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a sun-drenched European square with ancient cobblestones and an ornate stone fountain in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly rise to a slight overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do pigeons with gray, white, and iridescent feathers initially peck at the ground before suddenly soaring into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition to extreme slow motion when the pigeons take flight, freezing water droplets and dust particles in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video return to real time after the pigeons disperse, restoring the sound of the fountain and the clamor of the crowds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003860175609589 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950385570526123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003860175609589, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003860175609589, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07372681051492691, + 0.07434680312871933, + 0.04694839194417, + 0.11319798231124878, + 0.04716441407799721, + 0.2777095437049866, + 0.07522204518318176, + 0.1614934206008911, + 0.07312004268169403, + 0.057070549577474594 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003860175609589 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a sun-drenched European square with ancient cobblestones and an ornate stone fountain in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly rise to a slight overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do pigeons with gray, white, and iridescent feathers initially peck at the ground before suddenly soaring into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition to extreme slow motion when the pigeons take flight, freezing water droplets and dust particles in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video return to real time after the pigeons disperse, restoring the sound of the fountain and the clamor of the crowds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9743953943252563 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47439542412757874 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9743953943252563, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.4999999701976776, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9743953943252563, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1256711483001709, + 0.06683859974145889, + 0.05340404435992241, + 0.05621135234832764, + 0.048068817704916, + 0.059820860624313354, + 0.14346718788146973, + 0.07411841303110123, + 0.12765708565711975, + 0.2447424978017807 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9743953943252563 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, beginning at eye level and then slowly rising to a slight overhead perspective, captures a sun-drenched, bustling European square. The ancient cobblestones gleam in the warm golden afternoon sun, and in the center, an ornate stone fountain joyfully sprays water. Initially, the image unfolds in real time: a flock of pigeons, their feathers a riot of gray, white, and iridescent colors, leisurely peck at the ground, surrounded by tourists in a variety of casual attire and expressions. Suddenly, as the flock, startled, suddenly soars into the air, the rhythm of the world is instantly stretched, seamlessly transitioning into extreme slow motion. As the pigeons flap their wings vigorously, every muscle contraction and feather spread is visible, and the dust particles stirred up are frozen in the light. The water droplets from the fountain are no longer a dynamic mist, but suspended in mid-air like countless shimmering crystal beads, each reflecting a dazzling light. On the ground, the expressions of the tourists slowly shifted at a near-still frame rate: a child's mouth gaped in a moment of surprise; a woman, holding her phone, moved her arm imperceptibly, her face shifting from indifference to wonder. When the torrent of birds finally rose and dispersed, transforming into a vast vortex soaring into the azure sky, the camera smoothly returned to real time, and the gurgling of the fountain and the clamor of the crowds instantly returned, creating a shocking return from surreal tranquility to vivid reality.", + "seed": 10629, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_14/index_8718_seed_10629_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.20302610509097577, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20302610509097577, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20302610509097577, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a sun-drenched European square with ancient cobblestones and an ornate stone fountain in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly rise to a slight overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do pigeons with gray, white, and iridescent feathers initially peck at the ground before suddenly soaring into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition to extreme slow motion when the pigeons take flight, freezing water droplets and dust particles in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video return to real time after the pigeons disperse, restoring the sound of the fountain and the clamor of the crowds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015586228109896183 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2655863761901855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015586228109896183, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015586228109896183, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17422936856746674, + 0.0439322255551815, + 0.03442831709980965, + 0.2648085653781891, + 0.054577674716711044, + 0.10852827876806259, + 0.06674805283546448, + 0.03212328627705574, + 0.1707693189382553, + 0.04985485598444939 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015586228109896183 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a sun-drenched European square with ancient cobblestones and an ornate stone fountain in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly rise to a slight overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do pigeons with gray, white, and iridescent feathers initially peck at the ground before suddenly soaring into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition to extreme slow motion when the pigeons take flight, freezing water droplets and dust particles in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video return to real time after the pigeons disperse, restoring the sound of the fountain and the clamor of the crowds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16039735078811646 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103972911834717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16039735078811646, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16039735078811646, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1636982262134552, + 0.15200483798980713, + 0.04510827362537384, + 0.13909439742565155, + 0.14807964861392975, + 0.06084618717432022, + 0.05326073244214058, + 0.027838071808218956, + 0.13321056962013245, + 0.07685904204845428 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16039735078811646 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a sun-drenched European square with ancient cobblestones and an ornate stone fountain in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly rise to a slight overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do pigeons with gray, white, and iridescent feathers initially peck at the ground before suddenly soaring into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition to extreme slow motion when the pigeons take flight, freezing water droplets and dust particles in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video return to real time after the pigeons disperse, restoring the sound of the fountain and the clamor of the crowds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011094783432781696 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511094570159912 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011094783432781696, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011094783432781696, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10873854905366898, + 0.06731342524290085, + 0.061240702867507935, + 0.10454047471284866, + 0.22322630882263184, + 0.09347190707921982, + 0.11136036366224289, + 0.05599172040820122, + 0.1353146731853485, + 0.038801923394203186 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011094783432781696 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a sun-drenched European square with ancient cobblestones and an ornate stone fountain in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly rise to a slight overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do pigeons with gray, white, and iridescent feathers initially peck at the ground before suddenly soaring into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition to extreme slow motion when the pigeons take flight, freezing water droplets and dust particles in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video return to real time after the pigeons disperse, restoring the sound of the fountain and the clamor of the crowds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004326581954956 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950433254241943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004326581954956, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004326581954956, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2647016644477844, + 0.04833715036511421, + 0.042999401688575745, + 0.0949881300330162, + 0.1790013164281845, + 0.059354860335588455, + 0.11148674786090851, + 0.023319628089666367, + 0.13102969527244568, + 0.044781457632780075 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004326581954956 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a sun-drenched European square with ancient cobblestones and an ornate stone fountain in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly rise to a slight overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do pigeons with gray, white, and iridescent feathers initially peck at the ground before suddenly soaring into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition to extreme slow motion when the pigeons take flight, freezing water droplets and dust particles in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video return to real time after the pigeons disperse, restoring the sound of the fountain and the clamor of the crowds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7580088973045349 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6330088973045349 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7580088973045349, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7580088973045349, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06771861761808395, + 0.051618244498968124, + 0.03106672130525112, + 0.5114314556121826, + 0.04798870533704758, + 0.01885676383972168, + 0.022620297968387604, + 0.023698458448052406, + 0.15387016534805298, + 0.07113060355186462 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7580088973045349 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, beginning at eye level and then slowly rising to a slight overhead perspective, captures a sun-drenched, bustling European square. The ancient cobblestones gleam in the warm golden afternoon sun, and in the center, an ornate stone fountain joyfully sprays water. Initially, the image unfolds in real time: a flock of pigeons, their feathers a riot of gray, white, and iridescent colors, leisurely peck at the ground, surrounded by tourists in a variety of casual attire and expressions. Suddenly, as the flock, startled, suddenly soars into the air, the rhythm of the world is instantly stretched, seamlessly transitioning into extreme slow motion. As the pigeons flap their wings vigorously, every muscle contraction and feather spread is visible, and the dust particles stirred up are frozen in the light. The water droplets from the fountain are no longer a dynamic mist, but suspended in mid-air like countless shimmering crystal beads, each reflecting a dazzling light. On the ground, the expressions of the tourists slowly shifted at a near-still frame rate: a child's mouth gaped in a moment of surprise; a woman, holding her phone, moved her arm imperceptibly, her face shifting from indifference to wonder. When the torrent of birds finally rose and dispersed, transforming into a vast vortex soaring into the azure sky, the camera smoothly returned to real time, and the gurgling of the fountain and the clamor of the crowds instantly returned, creating a shocking return from surreal tranquility to vivid reality.", + "seed": 10630, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_14/index_8718_seed_10630_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1651916889473796, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1651916889473796, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1651916889473796, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a sun-drenched European square with ancient cobblestones and an ornate stone fountain in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly rise to a slight overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do pigeons with gray, white, and iridescent feathers initially peck at the ground before suddenly soaring into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition to extreme slow motion when the pigeons take flight, freezing water droplets and dust particles in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video return to real time after the pigeons disperse, restoring the sound of the fountain and the clamor of the crowds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03042307309806347 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.655423164367676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03042307309806347, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03042307309806347, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23963476717472076, + 0.10300218313932419, + 0.07751870900392532, + 0.08756090700626373, + 0.1299530416727066, + 0.15466053783893585, + 0.03869323059916496, + 0.05960523337125778, + 0.062387336045503616, + 0.04698402062058449 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03042307309806347 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a sun-drenched European square with ancient cobblestones and an ornate stone fountain in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly rise to a slight overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do pigeons with gray, white, and iridescent feathers initially peck at the ground before suddenly soaring into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition to extreme slow motion when the pigeons take flight, freezing water droplets and dust particles in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video return to real time after the pigeons disperse, restoring the sound of the fountain and the clamor of the crowds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1003437489271164 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350343704223633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1003437489271164, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1003437489271164, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06725987046957016, + 0.047572337090969086, + 0.03904728963971138, + 0.13184042274951935, + 0.07350334525108337, + 0.37002477049827576, + 0.1633877456188202, + 0.028998378664255142, + 0.04767859727144241, + 0.03068728931248188 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1003437489271164 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a sun-drenched European square with ancient cobblestones and an ornate stone fountain in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly rise to a slight overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do pigeons with gray, white, and iridescent feathers initially peck at the ground before suddenly soaring into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition to extreme slow motion when the pigeons take flight, freezing water droplets and dust particles in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video return to real time after the pigeons disperse, restoring the sound of the fountain and the clamor of the crowds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005956635810434818 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130956649780273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005956635810434818, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005956635810434818, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1467224806547165, + 0.06243415176868439, + 0.08968920260667801, + 0.23826466500759125, + 0.04428322613239288, + 0.23764173686504364, + 0.07286984473466873, + 0.05997581034898758, + 0.02679947204887867, + 0.021319333463907242 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005956635810434818 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a sun-drenched European square with ancient cobblestones and an ornate stone fountain in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly rise to a slight overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do pigeons with gray, white, and iridescent feathers initially peck at the ground before suddenly soaring into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition to extreme slow motion when the pigeons take flight, freezing water droplets and dust particles in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video return to real time after the pigeons disperse, restoring the sound of the fountain and the clamor of the crowds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11296333372592926 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379634380340576 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11296333372592926, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11296333372592926, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14577409625053406, + 0.07363186031579971, + 0.10908488929271698, + 0.26932522654533386, + 0.03967165946960449, + 0.18973730504512787, + 0.06068079173564911, + 0.03996022790670395, + 0.04848279803991318, + 0.02365112118422985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11296333372592926 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a sun-drenched European square with ancient cobblestones and an ornate stone fountain in the center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly rise to a slight overhead perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do pigeons with gray, white, and iridescent feathers initially peck at the ground before suddenly soaring into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video transition to extreme slow motion when the pigeons take flight, freezing water droplets and dust particles in mid-air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video return to real time after the pigeons disperse, restoring the sound of the fountain and the clamor of the crowds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.576271653175354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.826271653175354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.576271653175354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.576271653175354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1929430067539215, + 0.10135754942893982, + 0.09707295894622803, + 0.11937438696622849, + 0.04540812596678734, + 0.10359429568052292, + 0.10721884667873383, + 0.07931375503540039, + 0.11733943969011307, + 0.036377642303705215 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.576271653175354 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_15/index_tensor([9266, 9266])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_15/index_tensor([9266, 9266])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..21acfa356b3a090df30518d6e15cc36b6bf7b09e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_15/index_tensor([9266, 9266])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle tracking shot moves smoothly, following a skier as they carve powerful, deep turns through the untouched powder snow of a remote, nighttime mountainside. Clad in sleek, dark technical skiwear and a matte black helmet with reflective goggles, the skier slung low and aggressively entered turns, the sharp edge of their skis decisively cutting through the snow, kicking up a magnificent, shimmering plume in their wake. The entire scene was dramatically illuminated by the intense, flickering glow of a massive bonfire blazing in their path. This single, powerful light source cast warm, vibrant orange and yellow light that danced across the skier's body and the flying snow, creating a stark, high-contrast black and white effect against the deep, cold night. As the skier passed, the bonfire crackled and the volcano erupted, sending fiery sparks and embers shooting up into the inky, starless sky, creating an exhilarating atmosphere of speed and raw, elemental power.", + "seed": 8390, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_15/index_9266_seed_8390_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.033740833852789365, + "vlm_logprob": -0.033740833852789365, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.033740833852789365, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a skier carving turns through powder snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing dark technical skiwear and a matte black helmet with reflective goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a remote mountainside with a massive bonfire providing the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting create a high-contrast effect with warm orange and yellow light against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a smooth, low-angle tracking shot following the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06513340026140213 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8151333332061768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06513340026140213, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06513340026140213, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10307227075099945, + 0.06394143402576447, + 0.13003209233283997, + 0.14502625167369843, + 0.13591668009757996, + 0.05299857631325722, + 0.0644519180059433, + 0.03087027557194233, + 0.11404014378786087, + 0.1596502810716629 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06513340026140213 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a skier carving turns through powder snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing dark technical skiwear and a matte black helmet with reflective goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a remote mountainside with a massive bonfire providing the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting create a high-contrast effect with warm orange and yellow light against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a smooth, low-angle tracking shot following the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033711932599544525 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087119102478027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033711932599544525, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033711932599544525, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09783431887626648, + 0.07940949499607086, + 0.15587218105793, + 0.11051198840141296, + 0.1292913854122162, + 0.09269481152296066, + 0.046797025948762894, + 0.06668522208929062, + 0.03216506168246269, + 0.18873845040798187 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033711932599544525 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a skier carving turns through powder snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing dark technical skiwear and a matte black helmet with reflective goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a remote mountainside with a massive bonfire providing the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting create a high-contrast effect with warm orange and yellow light against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a smooth, low-angle tracking shot following the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076280031353235245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882627964019775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076280031353235245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076280031353235245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13923539221286774, + 0.08897938579320908, + 0.03865022584795952, + 0.16757069528102875, + 0.16975335776805878, + 0.18393869698047638, + 0.027584971860051155, + 0.01407431811094284, + 0.03280208259820938, + 0.13741089403629303 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076280031353235245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a skier carving turns through powder snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing dark technical skiwear and a matte black helmet with reflective goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a remote mountainside with a massive bonfire providing the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting create a high-contrast effect with warm orange and yellow light against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a smooth, low-angle tracking shot following the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00020954797219019383 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -8.50020980834961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00020954797219019383, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 8.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00020954797219019383, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1571759581565857, + 0.07469112426042557, + 0.07192671298980713, + 0.12507472932338715, + 0.09904519468545914, + 0.21587690711021423, + 0.029568105936050415, + 0.038422174751758575, + 0.09616216272115707, + 0.09205693006515503 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00020954797219019383 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a skier carving turns through powder snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing dark technical skiwear and a matte black helmet with reflective goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a remote mountainside with a massive bonfire providing the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting create a high-contrast effect with warm orange and yellow light against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a smooth, low-angle tracking shot following the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06202128529548645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812021255493164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06202128529548645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06202128529548645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09390817582607269, + 0.05919880419969559, + 0.09703221917152405, + 0.14694012701511383, + 0.3092386722564697, + 0.1264198273420334, + 0.03703876584768295, + 0.02505810186266899, + 0.05081934109330177, + 0.05434601753950119 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06202128529548645 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle tracking shot moves smoothly, following a skier as they carve powerful, deep turns through the untouched powder snow of a remote, nighttime mountainside. Clad in sleek, dark technical skiwear and a matte black helmet with reflective goggles, the skier slung low and aggressively entered turns, the sharp edge of their skis decisively cutting through the snow, kicking up a magnificent, shimmering plume in their wake. The entire scene was dramatically illuminated by the intense, flickering glow of a massive bonfire blazing in their path. This single, powerful light source cast warm, vibrant orange and yellow light that danced across the skier's body and the flying snow, creating a stark, high-contrast black and white effect against the deep, cold night. As the skier passed, the bonfire crackled and the volcano erupted, sending fiery sparks and embers shooting up into the inky, starless sky, creating an exhilarating atmosphere of speed and raw, elemental power.", + "seed": 8391, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_15/index_9266_seed_8391_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.09330641498672776, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09330641498672776, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09330641498672776, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a skier carving turns through powder snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing dark technical skiwear and a matte black helmet with reflective goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a remote mountainside with a massive bonfire providing the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting create a high-contrast effect with warm orange and yellow light against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a smooth, low-angle tracking shot following the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.35277843475341797 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.227778434753418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.35277843475341797, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.35277843475341797, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31067878007888794, + 0.10081913322210312, + 0.05884935334324837, + 0.059701450169086456, + 0.16129224002361298, + 0.11713889986276627, + 0.03595877066254616, + 0.059543222188949585, + 0.0726172924041748, + 0.023400910198688507 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.35277843475341797 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a skier carving turns through powder snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing dark technical skiwear and a matte black helmet with reflective goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a remote mountainside with a massive bonfire providing the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting create a high-contrast effect with warm orange and yellow light against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a smooth, low-angle tracking shot following the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0549858883023262 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929986000061035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0549858883023262, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0549858883023262, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0995333194732666, + 0.04876229912042618, + 0.0672072321176529, + 0.1332143098115921, + 0.08684402704238892, + 0.10198327898979187, + 0.20382729172706604, + 0.03785572201013565, + 0.11622954159975052, + 0.10454297065734863 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0549858883023262 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a skier carving turns through powder snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing dark technical skiwear and a matte black helmet with reflective goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a remote mountainside with a massive bonfire providing the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting create a high-contrast effect with warm orange and yellow light against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a smooth, low-angle tracking shot following the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003617767943069339 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628617763519287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003617767943069339, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003617767943069339, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29489925503730774, + 0.1719125509262085, + 0.09499803930521011, + 0.02750946767628193, + 0.044373296201229095, + 0.06986888498067856, + 0.08702186495065689, + 0.045577287673950195, + 0.03770916908979416, + 0.12613023817539215 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003617767943069339 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a skier carving turns through powder snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing dark technical skiwear and a matte black helmet with reflective goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a remote mountainside with a massive bonfire providing the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting create a high-contrast effect with warm orange and yellow light against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a smooth, low-angle tracking shot following the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00020990552729927003 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -8.50020980834961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00020990552729927003, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 8.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00020990552729927003, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4384355843067169, + 0.057181134819984436, + 0.04264279454946518, + 0.017616424709558487, + 0.053234610706567764, + 0.05369563773274422, + 0.12248969823122025, + 0.053957607597112656, + 0.07127692550420761, + 0.0894695520401001 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00020990552729927003 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a skier carving turns through powder snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing dark technical skiwear and a matte black helmet with reflective goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a remote mountainside with a massive bonfire providing the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting create a high-contrast effect with warm orange and yellow light against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a smooth, low-angle tracking shot following the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054940078407526016 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299399852752686 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054940078407526016, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054940078407526016, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15689507126808167, + 0.10256901383399963, + 0.14000412821769714, + 0.09347750246524811, + 0.17841175198554993, + 0.0561278760433197, + 0.06413565576076508, + 0.058047790080308914, + 0.03967302292585373, + 0.1106582060456276 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054940078407526016 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle tracking shot moves smoothly, following a skier as they carve powerful, deep turns through the untouched powder snow of a remote, nighttime mountainside. Clad in sleek, dark technical skiwear and a matte black helmet with reflective goggles, the skier slung low and aggressively entered turns, the sharp edge of their skis decisively cutting through the snow, kicking up a magnificent, shimmering plume in their wake. The entire scene was dramatically illuminated by the intense, flickering glow of a massive bonfire blazing in their path. This single, powerful light source cast warm, vibrant orange and yellow light that danced across the skier's body and the flying snow, creating a stark, high-contrast black and white effect against the deep, cold night. As the skier passed, the bonfire crackled and the volcano erupted, sending fiery sparks and embers shooting up into the inky, starless sky, creating an exhilarating atmosphere of speed and raw, elemental power.", + "seed": 8392, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_15/index_9266_seed_8392_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.017820213291270193, + "vlm_logprob": -0.017820213291270193, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.017820213291270193, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a skier carving turns through powder snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing dark technical skiwear and a matte black helmet with reflective goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a remote mountainside with a massive bonfire providing the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting create a high-contrast effect with warm orange and yellow light against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a smooth, low-angle tracking shot following the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03615482524037361 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4111547470092773 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03615482524037361, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03615482524037361, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.029510032385587692, + 0.12008585780858994, + 0.044289618730545044, + 0.03985489159822464, + 0.0789298340678215, + 0.014700844883918762, + 0.05190581455826759, + 0.018487023189663887, + 0.5135112404823303, + 0.0887247622013092 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03615482524037361 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a skier carving turns through powder snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing dark technical skiwear and a matte black helmet with reflective goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a remote mountainside with a massive bonfire providing the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting create a high-contrast effect with warm orange and yellow light against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a smooth, low-angle tracking shot following the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023303797468543053 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773303747177124 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023303797468543053, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023303797468543053, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03488540276885033, + 0.059115227311849594, + 0.03270125389099121, + 0.03359082341194153, + 0.028573356568813324, + 0.04646766558289528, + 0.026714039966464043, + 0.015180393122136593, + 0.7022682428359985, + 0.020503608509898186 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023303797468543053 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a skier carving turns through powder snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing dark technical skiwear and a matte black helmet with reflective goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a remote mountainside with a massive bonfire providing the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting create a high-contrast effect with warm orange and yellow light against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a smooth, low-angle tracking shot following the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031935188453644514 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753193378448486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031935188453644514, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031935188453644514, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13702253997325897, + 0.17681635916233063, + 0.1140068918466568, + 0.061699505895376205, + 0.05444229766726494, + 0.026569580659270287, + 0.08076614141464233, + 0.01887385919690132, + 0.25034284591674805, + 0.0794600248336792 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031935188453644514 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a skier carving turns through powder snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing dark technical skiwear and a matte black helmet with reflective goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a remote mountainside with a massive bonfire providing the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting create a high-contrast effect with warm orange and yellow light against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a smooth, low-angle tracking shot following the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00011526874004630372 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -9.125115394592285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00011526874004630372, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 9.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00011526874004630372, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2488505244255066, + 0.06126835569739342, + 0.07261165231466293, + 0.06487176567316055, + 0.03979617357254028, + 0.10048698633909225, + 0.047784920781850815, + 0.03942793607711792, + 0.21138019859790802, + 0.113521508872509 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00011526874004630372 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a skier carving turns through powder snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing dark technical skiwear and a matte black helmet with reflective goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a remote mountainside with a massive bonfire providing the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting create a high-contrast effect with warm orange and yellow light against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a smooth, low-angle tracking shot following the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026333656162023544 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513335704803467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026333656162023544, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026333656162023544, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05606013908982277, + 0.06330942362546921, + 0.042181167751550674, + 0.015966832637786865, + 0.04139268770813942, + 0.028073551133275032, + 0.04407056048512459, + 0.015400107018649578, + 0.6124975681304932, + 0.08104801177978516 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026333656162023544 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle tracking shot moves smoothly, following a skier as they carve powerful, deep turns through the untouched powder snow of a remote, nighttime mountainside. Clad in sleek, dark technical skiwear and a matte black helmet with reflective goggles, the skier slung low and aggressively entered turns, the sharp edge of their skis decisively cutting through the snow, kicking up a magnificent, shimmering plume in their wake. The entire scene was dramatically illuminated by the intense, flickering glow of a massive bonfire blazing in their path. This single, powerful light source cast warm, vibrant orange and yellow light that danced across the skier's body and the flying snow, creating a stark, high-contrast black and white effect against the deep, cold night. As the skier passed, the bonfire crackled and the volcano erupted, sending fiery sparks and embers shooting up into the inky, starless sky, creating an exhilarating atmosphere of speed and raw, elemental power.", + "seed": 8393, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_15/index_9266_seed_8393_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1622299920360092, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1622299920360092, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1622299920360092, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a skier carving turns through powder snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing dark technical skiwear and a matte black helmet with reflective goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a remote mountainside with a massive bonfire providing the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting create a high-contrast effect with warm orange and yellow light against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a smooth, low-angle tracking shot following the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6962911486625671 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6962911486625671 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6962911486625671, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6962911486625671, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14369072020053864, + 0.41982948780059814, + 0.03156541287899017, + 0.05869845673441887, + 0.04356798902153969, + 0.05458470433950424, + 0.016803674399852753, + 0.12998446822166443, + 0.07351625710725784, + 0.027758793905377388 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6962911486625671 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a skier carving turns through powder snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing dark technical skiwear and a matte black helmet with reflective goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a remote mountainside with a massive bonfire providing the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting create a high-contrast effect with warm orange and yellow light against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a smooth, low-angle tracking shot following the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05500506982207298 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300050735473633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05500506982207298, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05500506982207298, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21042604744434357, + 0.5181929469108582, + 0.07024125009775162, + 0.036340221762657166, + 0.023162085562944412, + 0.015001431107521057, + 0.03595470264554024, + 0.05061313882470131, + 0.02275572158396244, + 0.017312418669462204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05500506982207298 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a skier carving turns through powder snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing dark technical skiwear and a matte black helmet with reflective goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a remote mountainside with a massive bonfire providing the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting create a high-contrast effect with warm orange and yellow light against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a smooth, low-angle tracking shot following the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004642185289412737 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379642009735107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004642185289412737, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004642185289412737, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30172860622406006, + 0.14458997547626495, + 0.0728393942117691, + 0.0854569748044014, + 0.1171407476067543, + 0.035408541560173035, + 0.06535016745328903, + 0.09852433204650879, + 0.03872940316796303, + 0.040231816470623016 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004642185289412737 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a skier carving turns through powder snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing dark technical skiwear and a matte black helmet with reflective goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a remote mountainside with a massive bonfire providing the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting create a high-contrast effect with warm orange and yellow light against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a smooth, low-angle tracking shot following the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00026854246971197426 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -8.250268936157227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00026854246971197426, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 8.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00026854246971197426, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2710248529911041, + 0.09108174592256546, + 0.08584285527467728, + 0.06276372075080872, + 0.04925371706485748, + 0.04137773439288139, + 0.1097770407795906, + 0.16937562823295593, + 0.06044180318713188, + 0.059060897678136826 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00026854246971197426 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a skier carving turns through powder snow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the skier wearing dark technical skiwear and a matte black helmet with reflective goggles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at night on a remote mountainside with a massive bonfire providing the primary light source?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the lighting create a high-contrast effect with warm orange and yellow light against a dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a smooth, low-angle tracking shot following the skier?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054943013936281204 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929943084716797 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054943013936281204, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054943013936281204, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21162615716457367, + 0.10966084152460098, + 0.07920539379119873, + 0.08629059046506882, + 0.04483507201075554, + 0.06646884232759476, + 0.06572236865758896, + 0.23392286896705627, + 0.03803294897079468, + 0.06423496454954147 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054943013936281204 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_2/index_tensor([5091, 5091])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_2/index_tensor([5091, 5091])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..784af60b3011bff162c1889bcaf5ab15a00f416d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_2/index_tensor([5091, 5091])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, upward-tilting close-up focuses on two bronzed, vein-filled arms clinging to the rough edges of a massive, ancient gray granite door. Biceps and forearms bulge, every muscle trembling under the strain. Callused and dust-covered hands, knuckles white from the exertion. A single, warm, torch-like light from above and side casts deep, dramatic shadows on the bulging muscles and the weathered, cracked stone surface, highlighting the fine beads of sweat on the skin and the rough texture of the stone. As the arms exert slow, yet determined force, the heavy stone door is irresistibly pushed sideways from its original position, creaking dully and harshly as it rubs against the ground. Ancient dust stirred in the air dances in the light. The entire scene is imbued with a sense of primal power and epic majesty, creating an atmosphere of intense focus and suspense.", + "seed": 9340, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_2/index_5091_seed_9340_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.37925135511904956, + "vlm_logprob": -0.37925135511904956, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.374999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.37925135511904956, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two bronzed, vein-filled arms visible in the close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, ancient gray granite door visible with rough edges and weathered cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone door being pushed sideways, creaking and rubbing against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a single warm light source from above and side casting deep shadows and illuminating sweat beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.024230647832155228 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.774230718612671 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.024230647832155228, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.024230647832155228, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2148100733757019, + 0.0690605640411377, + 0.059221964329481125, + 0.1683606654405594, + 0.09488580375909805, + 0.07610490918159485, + 0.1178436279296875, + 0.038754165172576904, + 0.07505791634321213, + 0.08590029180049896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.024230647832155228 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two bronzed, vein-filled arms visible in the close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, ancient gray granite door visible with rough edges and weathered cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone door being pushed sideways, creaking and rubbing against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a single warm light source from above and side casting deep shadows and illuminating sweat beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761359333992004 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261359333992004 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761359333992004, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761359333992004, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09357748925685883, + 0.04767588526010513, + 0.046683985739946365, + 0.124052494764328, + 0.17145851254463196, + 0.1035783588886261, + 0.1412639021873474, + 0.08123648166656494, + 0.11050201207399368, + 0.0799708217382431 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761359333992004 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two bronzed, vein-filled arms visible in the close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, ancient gray granite door visible with rough edges and weathered cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone door being pushed sideways, creaking and rubbing against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a single warm light source from above and side casting deep shadows and illuminating sweat beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.070045605301857 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950457096099854 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.070045605301857, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.070045605301857, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24354346096515656, + 0.09000828117132187, + 0.05432647094130516, + 0.31079360842704773, + 0.07857973128557205, + 0.06727378070354462, + 0.08319906890392303, + 0.015937021002173424, + 0.029650932177901268, + 0.026687681674957275 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.070045605301857 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two bronzed, vein-filled arms visible in the close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, ancient gray granite door visible with rough edges and weathered cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone door being pushed sideways, creaking and rubbing against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a single warm light source from above and side casting deep shadows and illuminating sweat beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223646879196167 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486468195915222 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.223646879196167, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.8750000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -1.223646879196167, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2369304895401001, + 0.09763744473457336, + 0.05380518361926079, + 0.14149922132492065, + 0.12547016143798828, + 0.06955840438604355, + 0.10450366139411926, + 0.03860286995768547, + 0.07874266058206558, + 0.053249891847372055 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.223646879196167 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two bronzed, vein-filled arms visible in the close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, ancient gray granite door visible with rough edges and weathered cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone door being pushed sideways, creaking and rubbing against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a single warm light source from above and side casting deep shadows and illuminating sweat beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021977098658680916 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127197742462158 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021977098658680916, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021977098658680916, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17890332639217377, + 0.059236638247966766, + 0.06343012303113937, + 0.07210037857294083, + 0.12582768499851227, + 0.10146721452474594, + 0.18292178213596344, + 0.06245714798569679, + 0.09542921185493469, + 0.05822651460766792 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021977098658680916 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, upward-tilting close-up focuses on two bronzed, vein-filled arms clinging to the rough edges of a massive, ancient gray granite door. Biceps and forearms bulge, every muscle trembling under the strain. Callused and dust-covered hands, knuckles white from the exertion. A single, warm, torch-like light from above and side casts deep, dramatic shadows on the bulging muscles and the weathered, cracked stone surface, highlighting the fine beads of sweat on the skin and the rough texture of the stone. As the arms exert slow, yet determined force, the heavy stone door is irresistibly pushed sideways from its original position, creaking dully and harshly as it rubs against the ground. Ancient dust stirred in the air dances in the light. The entire scene is imbued with a sense of primal power and epic majesty, creating an atmosphere of intense focus and suspense.", + "seed": 9341, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_2/index_5091_seed_9341_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2940462986007333, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2940462986007333, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.3750000059604646, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2940462986007333, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two bronzed, vein-filled arms visible in the close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, ancient gray granite door visible with rough edges and weathered cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone door being pushed sideways, creaking and rubbing against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a single warm light source from above and side casting deep shadows and illuminating sweat beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07155847549438477 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6965584754943848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07155847549438477, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07155847549438477, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2629787027835846, + 0.07185527682304382, + 0.10495360195636749, + 0.05763665586709976, + 0.047635264694690704, + 0.05860221013426781, + 0.0829329863190651, + 0.10622479766607285, + 0.09810705482959747, + 0.1090734675526619 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07155847549438477 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two bronzed, vein-filled arms visible in the close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, ancient gray granite door visible with rough edges and weathered cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone door being pushed sideways, creaking and rubbing against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a single warm light source from above and side casting deep shadows and illuminating sweat beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38704800605773926 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370480060577393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38704800605773926, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38704800605773926, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0921487957239151, + 0.051493752747774124, + 0.0471956841647625, + 0.05356227979063988, + 0.427831768989563, + 0.08280289173126221, + 0.13137181103229523, + 0.03073766827583313, + 0.036566972732543945, + 0.0462883822619915 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38704800605773926 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two bronzed, vein-filled arms visible in the close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, ancient gray granite door visible with rough edges and weathered cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone door being pushed sideways, creaking and rubbing against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a single warm light source from above and side casting deep shadows and illuminating sweat beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371020406484604 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408710241317749 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371020406484604, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371020406484604, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0675327256321907, + 0.023047782480716705, + 0.03496089205145836, + 0.06377336382865906, + 0.24752123653888702, + 0.1355682611465454, + 0.11062738299369812, + 0.10909277200698853, + 0.02222200483083725, + 0.18565355241298676 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371020406484604 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two bronzed, vein-filled arms visible in the close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, ancient gray granite door visible with rough edges and weathered cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone door being pushed sideways, creaking and rubbing against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a single warm light source from above and side casting deep shadows and illuminating sweat beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742950201034546 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.474295049905777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9742950201034546, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.4999999701976776, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9742950201034546, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08562778681516647, + 0.04983160272240639, + 0.027746742591261864, + 0.06321404874324799, + 0.4246708154678345, + 0.052549365907907486, + 0.08799272030591965, + 0.06837756931781769, + 0.04364190995693207, + 0.09634750336408615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9742950201034546 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two bronzed, vein-filled arms visible in the close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, ancient gray granite door visible with rough edges and weathered cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone door being pushed sideways, creaking and rubbing against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a single warm light source from above and side casting deep shadows and illuminating sweat beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003619787283241749 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.62861967086792 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003619787283241749, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003619787283241749, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1632242500782013, + 0.05435476079583168, + 0.07686837017536163, + 0.07867558300495148, + 0.08138061314821243, + 0.23771452903747559, + 0.054420795291662216, + 0.05377419665455818, + 0.06594216078519821, + 0.13364478945732117 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003619787283241749 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, upward-tilting close-up focuses on two bronzed, vein-filled arms clinging to the rough edges of a massive, ancient gray granite door. Biceps and forearms bulge, every muscle trembling under the strain. Callused and dust-covered hands, knuckles white from the exertion. A single, warm, torch-like light from above and side casts deep, dramatic shadows on the bulging muscles and the weathered, cracked stone surface, highlighting the fine beads of sweat on the skin and the rough texture of the stone. As the arms exert slow, yet determined force, the heavy stone door is irresistibly pushed sideways from its original position, creaking dully and harshly as it rubs against the ground. Ancient dust stirred in the air dances in the light. The entire scene is imbued with a sense of primal power and epic majesty, creating an atmosphere of intense focus and suspense.", + "seed": 9342, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_2/index_5091_seed_9342_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.29835437387228014, + "vlm_logprob": -0.29835437387228014, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.29835437387228014, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two bronzed, vein-filled arms visible in the close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, ancient gray granite door visible with rough edges and weathered cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone door being pushed sideways, creaking and rubbing against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a single warm light source from above and side casting deep shadows and illuminating sweat beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05589703842997551 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9308969974517822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05589703842997551, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05589703842997551, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10707313567399979, + 0.12874974310398102, + 0.15589557588100433, + 0.10461118817329407, + 0.050803933292627335, + 0.13703399896621704, + 0.05370235815644264, + 0.07872872054576874, + 0.06914551556110382, + 0.11425583809614182 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05589703842997551 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two bronzed, vein-filled arms visible in the close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, ancient gray granite door visible with rough edges and weathered cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone door being pushed sideways, creaking and rubbing against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a single warm light source from above and side casting deep shadows and illuminating sweat beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47425371408462524 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742537140846252 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47425371408462524, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47425371408462524, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15817540884017944, + 0.10117961466312408, + 0.0743674710392952, + 0.06595675647258759, + 0.08459661900997162, + 0.10095403343439102, + 0.1484825313091278, + 0.09092095494270325, + 0.07761749625205994, + 0.09774912148714066 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47425371408462524 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two bronzed, vein-filled arms visible in the close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, ancient gray granite door visible with rough edges and weathered cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone door being pushed sideways, creaking and rubbing against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a single warm light source from above and side casting deep shadows and illuminating sweat beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015853375196457 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.701585292816162 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2015853375196457, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2015853375196457, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19502270221710205, + 0.0847146213054657, + 0.05389493703842163, + 0.061988893896341324, + 0.0789087563753128, + 0.15694817900657654, + 0.085599385201931, + 0.041331563144922256, + 0.06746329367160797, + 0.17412765324115753 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2015853375196457 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two bronzed, vein-filled arms visible in the close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, ancient gray granite door visible with rough edges and weathered cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone door being pushed sideways, creaking and rubbing against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a single warm light source from above and side casting deep shadows and illuminating sweat beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578375935554504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328375935554504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7578375935554504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7578375935554504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17703677713871002, + 0.06982574611902237, + 0.07039766758680344, + 0.11549501121044159, + 0.11656545847654343, + 0.18599267303943634, + 0.033668387681245804, + 0.09814220666885376, + 0.07620856910943985, + 0.05666755512356758 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7578375935554504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two bronzed, vein-filled arms visible in the close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, ancient gray granite door visible with rough edges and weathered cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone door being pushed sideways, creaking and rubbing against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a single warm light source from above and side casting deep shadows and illuminating sweat beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00219818577170372 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127198219299316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00219818577170372, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00219818577170372, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20432184636592865, + 0.10340610891580582, + 0.0932963564991951, + 0.07768028974533081, + 0.07324440777301788, + 0.10706552863121033, + 0.03987603262066841, + 0.0473068542778492, + 0.15274301171302795, + 0.10105957090854645 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00219818577170372 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, upward-tilting close-up focuses on two bronzed, vein-filled arms clinging to the rough edges of a massive, ancient gray granite door. Biceps and forearms bulge, every muscle trembling under the strain. Callused and dust-covered hands, knuckles white from the exertion. A single, warm, torch-like light from above and side casts deep, dramatic shadows on the bulging muscles and the weathered, cracked stone surface, highlighting the fine beads of sweat on the skin and the rough texture of the stone. As the arms exert slow, yet determined force, the heavy stone door is irresistibly pushed sideways from its original position, creaking dully and harshly as it rubs against the ground. Ancient dust stirred in the air dances in the light. The entire scene is imbued with a sense of primal power and epic majesty, creating an atmosphere of intense focus and suspense.", + "seed": 9343, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_2/index_5091_seed_9343_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.5377372623421252, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5377372623421252, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5377372623421252, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two bronzed, vein-filled arms visible in the close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, ancient gray granite door visible with rough edges and weathered cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone door being pushed sideways, creaking and rubbing against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a single warm light source from above and side casting deep shadows and illuminating sweat beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07077344506978989 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6957733631134033 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07077344506978989, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07077344506978989, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2390047013759613, + 0.06316646188497543, + 0.08171059936285019, + 0.12823981046676636, + 0.07509148120880127, + 0.035827621817588806, + 0.09199357777833939, + 0.10137519985437393, + 0.14611536264419556, + 0.03747519105672836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07077344506978989 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two bronzed, vein-filled arms visible in the close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, ancient gray granite door visible with rough edges and weathered cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone door being pushed sideways, creaking and rubbing against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a single warm light source from above and side casting deep shadows and illuminating sweat beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17989403009414673 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804893970489502 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17989403009414673, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17989403009414673, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.032193705439567566, + 0.026901869103312492, + 0.02990764193236828, + 0.0721072182059288, + 0.04994465410709381, + 0.04008060321211815, + 0.16029804944992065, + 0.24948014318943024, + 0.2785263657569885, + 0.06055974215269089 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17989403009414673 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two bronzed, vein-filled arms visible in the close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, ancient gray granite door visible with rough edges and weathered cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone door being pushed sideways, creaking and rubbing against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a single warm light source from above and side casting deep shadows and illuminating sweat beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103983640670776 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16039836406707764 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.9103983640670776, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.9103983640670776, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13116192817687988, + 0.11790192127227783, + 0.103522390127182, + 0.06956124305725098, + 0.05595573037862778, + 0.04250214248895645, + 0.05341853201389313, + 0.033059097826480865, + 0.1763429492712021, + 0.21657401323318481 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.9103983640670776 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two bronzed, vein-filled arms visible in the close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, ancient gray granite door visible with rough edges and weathered cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone door being pushed sideways, creaking and rubbing against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a single warm light source from above and side casting deep shadows and illuminating sweat beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5235180854797363 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8985180854797363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5235180854797363, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5235180854797363, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13065940141677856, + 0.14425013959407806, + 0.12318727374076843, + 0.05504591763019562, + 0.03874696418642998, + 0.04825540632009506, + 0.09869837760925293, + 0.06201945245265961, + 0.20820806920528412, + 0.09092898666858673 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5235180854797363 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two bronzed, vein-filled arms visible in the close-up shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow upward tilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive, ancient gray granite door visible with rough edges and weathered cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the stone door being pushed sideways, creaking and rubbing against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a single warm light source from above and side casting deep shadows and illuminating sweat beads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004102386999875307 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5041022300720215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004102386999875307, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004102386999875307, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13402286171913147, + 0.11545967310667038, + 0.1134423017501831, + 0.07635663449764252, + 0.05950610339641571, + 0.04065939038991928, + 0.04787746071815491, + 0.03793608024716377, + 0.1662398874759674, + 0.20849964022636414 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004102386999875307 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_3/index_tensor([5991, 5991])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_3/index_tensor([5991, 5991])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..34ebce1e9b66589972f5b8e9a556fb325054807e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_3/index_tensor([5991, 5991])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatic and violent low-angle shot, shaky with turbulent underwater motion, captures the explosive moment a giant, blood-red crayfish erupts from a dark cavern in the riverbed. Its vibrant, pyrotechnically armored carapace gleams in the dim green light filtering from above, its massive, serrated pincers held high in a menacing threat. Its tail whips with powerful, spasmodic thrashings, propelling it forward as its multiple legs frantically crawl across the soft mud in a chaotic pursuit of its fleeing rival. The sudden movement unleashes a dizzying swirling vortex of silt and decaying organic debris, muddying the water's surface. The camera shakes and flickers violently, struggling to hold the frantic action in frame as the light is erratically broken by suspended sediment, amplifying the raw aggression of the territorial dispute into a visceral, intense visual chaos.", + "seed": 21454, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_3/index_5991_seed_21454_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0887229785323143, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0887229785323143, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.724999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0887229785323143, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant crayfish with a blood-red carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crayfish erupt from a dark cavern in a riverbed environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crayfish's tail whiplashing and its legs crawling frantically across soft mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by dim green light filtering from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a low-angle, shaky, and turbulent motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38773590326309204 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1377358436584473 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38773590326309204, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38773590326309204, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09219104796648026, + 0.1025591641664505, + 0.0786941647529602, + 0.14406080543994904, + 0.036925721913576126, + 0.027730047702789307, + 0.08442389219999313, + 0.07026872783899307, + 0.13989917933940887, + 0.22324727475643158 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38773590326309204 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant crayfish with a blood-red carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crayfish erupt from a dark cavern in a riverbed environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crayfish's tail whiplashing and its legs crawling frantically across soft mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by dim green light filtering from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a low-angle, shaky, and turbulent motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020601926371455193 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895601987838745 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020601926371455193, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020601926371455193, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3085854947566986, + 0.1319873034954071, + 0.07021503150463104, + 0.1870124489068985, + 0.060992226004600525, + 0.0599030964076519, + 0.04587722569704056, + 0.022249111905694008, + 0.05430886149406433, + 0.05886919051408768 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020601926371455193 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant crayfish with a blood-red carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crayfish erupt from a dark cavern in a riverbed environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crayfish's tail whiplashing and its legs crawling frantically across soft mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by dim green light filtering from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a low-angle, shaky, and turbulent motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059188298881054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895591974258423 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059188298881054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059188298881054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31917044520378113, + 0.06125315651297569, + 0.06360942125320435, + 0.240060955286026, + 0.11093373596668243, + 0.0332014299929142, + 0.018914978951215744, + 0.046835288405418396, + 0.05456780642271042, + 0.051452748477458954 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059188298881054 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant crayfish with a blood-red carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crayfish erupt from a dark cavern in a riverbed environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crayfish's tail whiplashing and its legs crawling frantically across soft mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by dim green light filtering from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a low-angle, shaky, and turbulent motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036151548847556114 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628615379333496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036151548847556114, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036151548847556114, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4405549466609955, + 0.0422915481030941, + 0.027970222756266594, + 0.07672538608312607, + 0.03943534940481186, + 0.03951290249824524, + 0.026783304288983345, + 0.031855273991823196, + 0.22762449085712433, + 0.04724660888314247 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036151548847556114 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant crayfish with a blood-red carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crayfish erupt from a dark cavern in a riverbed environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crayfish's tail whiplashing and its legs crawling frantically across soft mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by dim green light filtering from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a low-angle, shaky, and turbulent motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011070025153458118 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511070251464844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011070025153458118, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011070025153458118, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14838755130767822, + 0.0864672064781189, + 0.0944289118051529, + 0.26293784379959106, + 0.11983438581228256, + 0.10901960730552673, + 0.021645860746502876, + 0.05811090022325516, + 0.03660494089126587, + 0.06256282329559326 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011070025153458118 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic and violent low-angle shot, shaky with turbulent underwater motion, captures the explosive moment a giant, blood-red crayfish erupts from a dark cavern in the riverbed. Its vibrant, pyrotechnically armored carapace gleams in the dim green light filtering from above, its massive, serrated pincers held high in a menacing threat. Its tail whips with powerful, spasmodic thrashings, propelling it forward as its multiple legs frantically crawl across the soft mud in a chaotic pursuit of its fleeing rival. The sudden movement unleashes a dizzying swirling vortex of silt and decaying organic debris, muddying the water's surface. The camera shakes and flickers violently, struggling to hold the frantic action in frame as the light is erratically broken by suspended sediment, amplifying the raw aggression of the territorial dispute into a visceral, intense visual chaos.", + "seed": 21455, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_3/index_5991_seed_21455_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.027128005167469382, + "vlm_logprob": -0.027128005167469382, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.027128005167469382, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant crayfish with a blood-red carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crayfish erupt from a dark cavern in a riverbed environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crayfish's tail whiplashing and its legs crawling frantically across soft mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by dim green light filtering from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a low-angle, shaky, and turbulent motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10064529627561569 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3506453037261963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10064529627561569, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10064529627561569, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26446279883384705, + 0.0655834823846817, + 0.05344047024846077, + 0.27020585536956787, + 0.06800124049186707, + 0.04865378886461258, + 0.061663538217544556, + 0.04129192605614662, + 0.07844037562608719, + 0.04825655370950699 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10064529627561569 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant crayfish with a blood-red carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crayfish erupt from a dark cavern in a riverbed environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crayfish's tail whiplashing and its legs crawling frantically across soft mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by dim green light filtering from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a low-angle, shaky, and turbulent motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012549362145364285 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38754940032959 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012549362145364285, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012549362145364285, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2326456904411316, + 0.1089315190911293, + 0.057044267654418945, + 0.07575412094593048, + 0.10143374651670456, + 0.05881970003247261, + 0.0988607406616211, + 0.05102245882153511, + 0.11923191696405411, + 0.09625580906867981 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012549362145364285 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant crayfish with a blood-red carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crayfish erupt from a dark cavern in a riverbed environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crayfish's tail whiplashing and its legs crawling frantically across soft mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by dim green light filtering from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a low-angle, shaky, and turbulent motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01419882569462061 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2641987800598145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01419882569462061, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01419882569462061, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36574190855026245, + 0.07669436186552048, + 0.06889592856168747, + 0.08969651907682419, + 0.0643584206700325, + 0.05787699297070503, + 0.10086365789175034, + 0.061529964208602905, + 0.045749519020318985, + 0.06859278678894043 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01419882569462061 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant crayfish with a blood-red carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crayfish erupt from a dark cavern in a riverbed environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crayfish's tail whiplashing and its legs crawling frantically across soft mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by dim green light filtering from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a low-angle, shaky, and turbulent motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036145609337836504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.62861442565918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036145609337836504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036145609337836504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15031476318836212, + 0.053359512239694595, + 0.053052835166454315, + 0.06675413995981216, + 0.08131033927202225, + 0.10843461751937866, + 0.0806390643119812, + 0.059536952525377274, + 0.14150001108646393, + 0.20509777963161469 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036145609337836504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant crayfish with a blood-red carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crayfish erupt from a dark cavern in a riverbed environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crayfish's tail whiplashing and its legs crawling frantically across soft mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by dim green light filtering from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a low-angle, shaky, and turbulent motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004631980787962675 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379631996154785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004631980787962675, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004631980787962675, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16591642796993256, + 0.09835804998874664, + 0.060536231845617294, + 0.05878784507513046, + 0.06087081879377365, + 0.07674271613359451, + 0.0834861695766449, + 0.12580060958862305, + 0.07498185336589813, + 0.19451922178268433 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004631980787962675 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic and violent low-angle shot, shaky with turbulent underwater motion, captures the explosive moment a giant, blood-red crayfish erupts from a dark cavern in the riverbed. Its vibrant, pyrotechnically armored carapace gleams in the dim green light filtering from above, its massive, serrated pincers held high in a menacing threat. Its tail whips with powerful, spasmodic thrashings, propelling it forward as its multiple legs frantically crawl across the soft mud in a chaotic pursuit of its fleeing rival. The sudden movement unleashes a dizzying swirling vortex of silt and decaying organic debris, muddying the water's surface. The camera shakes and flickers violently, struggling to hold the frantic action in frame as the light is erratically broken by suspended sediment, amplifying the raw aggression of the territorial dispute into a visceral, intense visual chaos.", + "seed": 21456, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_3/index_5991_seed_21456_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.08980083933565766, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08980083933565766, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08980083933565766, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant crayfish with a blood-red carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crayfish erupt from a dark cavern in a riverbed environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crayfish's tail whiplashing and its legs crawling frantically across soft mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by dim green light filtering from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a low-angle, shaky, and turbulent motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38775935769081116 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1377593278884888 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38775935769081116, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38775935769081116, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09432554990053177, + 0.1412501484155655, + 0.09789308160543442, + 0.28849926590919495, + 0.12160060554742813, + 0.0882716253399849, + 0.020606065168976784, + 0.026509976014494896, + 0.02686229534447193, + 0.0941813662648201 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38775935769081116 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant crayfish with a blood-red carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crayfish erupt from a dark cavern in a riverbed environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crayfish's tail whiplashing and its legs crawling frantically across soft mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by dim green light filtering from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a low-angle, shaky, and turbulent motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018199946731328964 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018199920654297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018199946731328964, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018199946731328964, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12196420878171921, + 0.15895748138427734, + 0.12523050606250763, + 0.12262164056301117, + 0.06067058444023132, + 0.05246607959270477, + 0.07814286649227142, + 0.040664590895175934, + 0.09042361378669739, + 0.14885850250720978 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018199946731328964 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant crayfish with a blood-red carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crayfish erupt from a dark cavern in a riverbed environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crayfish's tail whiplashing and its legs crawling frantically across soft mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by dim green light filtering from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a low-angle, shaky, and turbulent motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370743617415428 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087073802948 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370743617415428, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370743617415428, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0959990993142128, + 0.09418105334043503, + 0.26239392161369324, + 0.20520131289958954, + 0.057721611112356186, + 0.026129890233278275, + 0.08109462261199951, + 0.015457318164408207, + 0.062037479132413864, + 0.09978362917900085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370743617415428 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant crayfish with a blood-red carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crayfish erupt from a dark cavern in a riverbed environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crayfish's tail whiplashing and its legs crawling frantically across soft mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by dim green light filtering from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a low-angle, shaky, and turbulent motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017133570509031415 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376713275909424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017133570509031415, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017133570509031415, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07412148267030716, + 0.3334486484527588, + 0.049272459000349045, + 0.05806237831711769, + 0.04812878370285034, + 0.07373085618019104, + 0.10975200682878494, + 0.03341268375515938, + 0.061495304107666016, + 0.15857546031475067 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017133570509031415 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant crayfish with a blood-red carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crayfish erupt from a dark cavern in a riverbed environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crayfish's tail whiplashing and its legs crawling frantically across soft mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by dim green light filtering from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a low-angle, shaky, and turbulent motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007624099031090736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88262414932251 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007624099031090736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007624099031090736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11973195523023605, + 0.16729086637496948, + 0.046917371451854706, + 0.12918373942375183, + 0.08288717269897461, + 0.03252732381224632, + 0.07625840604305267, + 0.02722027897834778, + 0.09485378116369247, + 0.22312913835048676 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007624099031090736 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic and violent low-angle shot, shaky with turbulent underwater motion, captures the explosive moment a giant, blood-red crayfish erupts from a dark cavern in the riverbed. Its vibrant, pyrotechnically armored carapace gleams in the dim green light filtering from above, its massive, serrated pincers held high in a menacing threat. Its tail whips with powerful, spasmodic thrashings, propelling it forward as its multiple legs frantically crawl across the soft mud in a chaotic pursuit of its fleeing rival. The sudden movement unleashes a dizzying swirling vortex of silt and decaying organic debris, muddying the water's surface. The camera shakes and flickers violently, struggling to hold the frantic action in frame as the light is erratically broken by suspended sediment, amplifying the raw aggression of the territorial dispute into a visceral, intense visual chaos.", + "seed": 21457, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_3/index_5991_seed_21457_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04385702135041356, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04385702135041356, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04385702135041356, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant crayfish with a blood-red carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crayfish erupt from a dark cavern in a riverbed environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crayfish's tail whiplashing and its legs crawling frantically across soft mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by dim green light filtering from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a low-angle, shaky, and turbulent motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16072791814804077 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9107279777526855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16072791814804077, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16072791814804077, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36827588081359863, + 0.11001795530319214, + 0.061208128929138184, + 0.06718546897172928, + 0.041621267795562744, + 0.0363931804895401, + 0.09171827882528305, + 0.04743770509958267, + 0.1260017603635788, + 0.05014027655124664 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16072791814804077 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant crayfish with a blood-red carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crayfish erupt from a dark cavern in a riverbed environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crayfish's tail whiplashing and its legs crawling frantically across soft mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by dim green light filtering from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a low-angle, shaky, and turbulent motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059188298881054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895591974258423 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059188298881054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059188298881054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08404283225536346, + 0.015862494707107544, + 0.05321625620126724, + 0.05770847946405411, + 0.040554456412792206, + 0.020766133442521095, + 0.09294619411230087, + 0.013221691362559795, + 0.5882083177566528, + 0.03347308933734894 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059188298881054 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant crayfish with a blood-red carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crayfish erupt from a dark cavern in a riverbed environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crayfish's tail whiplashing and its legs crawling frantically across soft mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by dim green light filtering from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a low-angle, shaky, and turbulent motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058802917599678 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895587921142578 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058802917599678, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058802917599678, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11329849809408188, + 0.048353202641010284, + 0.05546066164970398, + 0.08751571923494339, + 0.048491738736629486, + 0.031299471855163574, + 0.11857780069112778, + 0.01902552880346775, + 0.3665849566459656, + 0.11139235645532608 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058802917599678 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant crayfish with a blood-red carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crayfish erupt from a dark cavern in a riverbed environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crayfish's tail whiplashing and its legs crawling frantically across soft mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by dim green light filtering from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a low-angle, shaky, and turbulent motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00319126108661294 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531914710998535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00319126108661294, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00319126108661294, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.062430642545223236, + 0.04994727671146393, + 0.0412282794713974, + 0.0387139692902565, + 0.26163250207901, + 0.03864755854010582, + 0.10671854019165039, + 0.015003833919763565, + 0.261454313993454, + 0.12422307580709457 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00319126108661294 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a giant crayfish with a blood-red carapace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the crayfish erupt from a dark cavern in a riverbed environment?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crayfish's tail whiplashing and its legs crawling frantically across soft mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by dim green light filtering from above?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a low-angle, shaky, and turbulent motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014186015352606773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264185905456543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014186015352606773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014186015352606773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14741921424865723, + 0.02926039882004261, + 0.07332193851470947, + 0.06151527911424637, + 0.0537206195294857, + 0.04321875795722008, + 0.1724245548248291, + 0.10036298632621765, + 0.15759049355983734, + 0.1611657291650772 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014186015352606773 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_4/index_tensor([5584, 5584])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_4/index_tensor([5584, 5584])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..debd7eb0a8cc05bbbf99c18a71c8323d6674ef17 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_4/index_tensor([5584, 5584])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, intimate close-up captures a scene in a meticulously crafted frozen world, rendered entirely in dramatic, high-contrast black and white. The central subject is a textured puppet of a dwarf caiman, its head and powerful jaws filling the frame. A harsh, key light from the side carves its form against the deep black background, casting sharp highlights on the ridges of its individually sculpted armored scales and creating deep shadows in the crevices of its rough, clay-like skin. Within its powerful jaws, held with incredible tenderness, rests one of its tiny young. The baby caiman is itself a delicate puppet, nestled securely, its own newly formed scales softly illuminated within the vast darkness of its parent's mouth. The parent's pose is one of immense, focused stillness, a thoughtful and cautious gesture that conveys a profound sense of parental care. The background, a soft-focus blur of its handcrafted surroundings, suggests a nest of textured earth and miniature reeds, further emphasizing the tenderness, protection, and profound quiet of the moment.", + "seed": 30044, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_4/index_5584_seed_30044_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.009934509359300136, + "vlm_logprob": -0.009934509359300136, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.009934509359300136, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a textured puppet of a dwarf caiman with its head and jaws filling the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered entirely in dramatic, high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny young caiman puppet visible resting inside the parent's jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur suggesting a nest of textured earth and miniature reeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a harsh key light from the side creating sharp highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012994137592613697 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.637994289398193 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012994137592613697, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012994137592613697, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12694098055362701, + 0.20725947618484497, + 0.165792316198349, + 0.06420335918664932, + 0.03244106099009514, + 0.04663379490375519, + 0.10079016536474228, + 0.16006767749786377, + 0.04752345383167267, + 0.04834775999188423 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012994137592613697 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a textured puppet of a dwarf caiman with its head and jaws filling the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered entirely in dramatic, high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny young caiman puppet visible resting inside the parent's jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur suggesting a nest of textured earth and miniature reeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a harsh key light from the side creating sharp highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00675229262560606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067524909973145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00675229262560606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00675229262560606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12091454863548279, + 0.3204721212387085, + 0.028702212497591972, + 0.0754188746213913, + 0.15005357563495636, + 0.09295586496591568, + 0.006830611731857061, + 0.023599784821271896, + 0.02332502044737339, + 0.15772736072540283 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00675229262560606 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a textured puppet of a dwarf caiman with its head and jaws filling the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered entirely in dramatic, high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny young caiman puppet visible resting inside the parent's jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur suggesting a nest of textured earth and miniature reeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a harsh key light from the side creating sharp highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014195887371897697 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264195919036865 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014195887371897697, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014195887371897697, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1140652671456337, + 0.23717986047267914, + 0.1991327702999115, + 0.0986468493938446, + 0.0430353507399559, + 0.07969838380813599, + 0.05233130231499672, + 0.08210562914609909, + 0.04314619302749634, + 0.0506584569811821 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014195887371897697 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a textured puppet of a dwarf caiman with its head and jaws filling the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered entirely in dramatic, high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny young caiman puppet visible resting inside the parent's jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur suggesting a nest of textured earth and miniature reeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a harsh key light from the side creating sharp highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005950710736215115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130950927734375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005950710736215115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005950710736215115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1373942792415619, + 0.0837034285068512, + 0.07904864102602005, + 0.058062244206666946, + 0.09419824928045273, + 0.08850700408220291, + 0.04913795366883278, + 0.08329097926616669, + 0.1766979694366455, + 0.14995929598808289 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005950710736215115 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a textured puppet of a dwarf caiman with its head and jaws filling the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered entirely in dramatic, high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny young caiman puppet visible resting inside the parent's jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur suggesting a nest of textured earth and miniature reeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a harsh key light from the side creating sharp highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009779518470168114 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634779453277588 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009779518470168114, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009779518470168114, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.126998633146286, + 0.22397662699222565, + 0.04948216676712036, + 0.10120158642530441, + 0.04721393436193466, + 0.04586799815297127, + 0.03491517901420593, + 0.03835068643093109, + 0.027131924405694008, + 0.30486124753952026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009779518470168114 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, intimate close-up captures a scene in a meticulously crafted frozen world, rendered entirely in dramatic, high-contrast black and white. The central subject is a textured puppet of a dwarf caiman, its head and powerful jaws filling the frame. A harsh, key light from the side carves its form against the deep black background, casting sharp highlights on the ridges of its individually sculpted armored scales and creating deep shadows in the crevices of its rough, clay-like skin. Within its powerful jaws, held with incredible tenderness, rests one of its tiny young. The baby caiman is itself a delicate puppet, nestled securely, its own newly formed scales softly illuminated within the vast darkness of its parent's mouth. The parent's pose is one of immense, focused stillness, a thoughtful and cautious gesture that conveys a profound sense of parental care. The background, a soft-focus blur of its handcrafted surroundings, suggests a nest of textured earth and miniature reeds, further emphasizing the tenderness, protection, and profound quiet of the moment.", + "seed": 30045, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_4/index_5584_seed_30045_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.01614923495799303, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01614923495799303, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01614923495799303, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a textured puppet of a dwarf caiman with its head and jaws filling the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered entirely in dramatic, high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny young caiman puppet visible resting inside the parent's jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur suggesting a nest of textured earth and miniature reeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a harsh key light from the side creating sharp highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014432210475206375 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.639432430267334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014432210475206375, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014432210475206375, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13958682119846344, + 0.02819625847041607, + 0.023986779153347015, + 0.01749761775135994, + 0.015441598370671272, + 0.019124936312437057, + 0.22331899404525757, + 0.37710079550743103, + 0.09985343366861343, + 0.05589277297258377 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014432210475206375 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a textured puppet of a dwarf caiman with its head and jaws filling the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered entirely in dramatic, high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny young caiman puppet visible resting inside the parent's jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur suggesting a nest of textured earth and miniature reeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a harsh key light from the side creating sharp highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371262177824974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.40871262550354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371262177824974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371262177824974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3179236948490143, + 0.07744873315095901, + 0.10789640992879868, + 0.0346536822617054, + 0.04104417935013771, + 0.020519781857728958, + 0.09877091646194458, + 0.1097072884440422, + 0.1213977038860321, + 0.07063761353492737 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371262177824974 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a textured puppet of a dwarf caiman with its head and jaws filling the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered entirely in dramatic, high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny young caiman puppet visible resting inside the parent's jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur suggesting a nest of textured earth and miniature reeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a harsh key light from the side creating sharp highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818414404988289 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018184185028076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818414404988289, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818414404988289, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16598188877105713, + 0.048507850617170334, + 0.04538027197122574, + 0.027044668793678284, + 0.056326933205127716, + 0.08243473619222641, + 0.19444650411605835, + 0.17015440762043, + 0.06876768916845322, + 0.14095503091812134 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818414404988289 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a textured puppet of a dwarf caiman with its head and jaws filling the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered entirely in dramatic, high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny young caiman puppet visible resting inside the parent's jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur suggesting a nest of textured earth and miniature reeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a harsh key light from the side creating sharp highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004638269543647766 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379638195037842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004638269543647766, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004638269543647766, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19472016394138336, + 0.09753517806529999, + 0.06191007047891617, + 0.056664932519197464, + 0.08692387491464615, + 0.06810397654771805, + 0.09795860201120377, + 0.24036839604377747, + 0.04515200853347778, + 0.05066278576850891 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004638269543647766 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a textured puppet of a dwarf caiman with its head and jaws filling the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered entirely in dramatic, high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny young caiman puppet visible resting inside the parent's jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur suggesting a nest of textured earth and miniature reeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a harsh key light from the side creating sharp highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009778928942978382 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63477897644043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009778928942978382, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009778928942978382, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20969422161579132, + 0.05672181025147438, + 0.034189410507678986, + 0.02006823755800724, + 0.08272893726825714, + 0.03999673202633858, + 0.1621561348438263, + 0.134439617395401, + 0.11297980695962906, + 0.14702510833740234 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009778928942978382 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, intimate close-up captures a scene in a meticulously crafted frozen world, rendered entirely in dramatic, high-contrast black and white. The central subject is a textured puppet of a dwarf caiman, its head and powerful jaws filling the frame. A harsh, key light from the side carves its form against the deep black background, casting sharp highlights on the ridges of its individually sculpted armored scales and creating deep shadows in the crevices of its rough, clay-like skin. Within its powerful jaws, held with incredible tenderness, rests one of its tiny young. The baby caiman is itself a delicate puppet, nestled securely, its own newly formed scales softly illuminated within the vast darkness of its parent's mouth. The parent's pose is one of immense, focused stillness, a thoughtful and cautious gesture that conveys a profound sense of parental care. The background, a soft-focus blur of its handcrafted surroundings, suggests a nest of textured earth and miniature reeds, further emphasizing the tenderness, protection, and profound quiet of the moment.", + "seed": 30046, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_4/index_5584_seed_30046_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.013109338749200106, + "vlm_logprob": -0.013109338749200106, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.013109338749200106, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a textured puppet of a dwarf caiman with its head and jaws filling the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered entirely in dramatic, high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny young caiman puppet visible resting inside the parent's jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur suggesting a nest of textured earth and miniature reeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a harsh key light from the side creating sharp highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012276443652808666 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.637276649475098 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012276443652808666, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012276443652808666, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13009797036647797, + 0.050087083131074905, + 0.054788388311862946, + 0.02824273891746998, + 0.21350836753845215, + 0.13314050436019897, + 0.17501559853553772, + 0.10088438540697098, + 0.0503128245472908, + 0.06392207741737366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012276443652808666 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a textured puppet of a dwarf caiman with its head and jaws filling the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered entirely in dramatic, high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny young caiman puppet visible resting inside the parent's jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur suggesting a nest of textured earth and miniature reeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a harsh key light from the side creating sharp highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02635025978088379 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651350259780884 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02635025978088379, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02635025978088379, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1094890832901001, + 0.3262973725795746, + 0.2626761198043823, + 0.04901786893606186, + 0.044325847178697586, + 0.07156495749950409, + 0.03300749510526657, + 0.030468665063381195, + 0.035422660410404205, + 0.037729937583208084 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02635025978088379 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a textured puppet of a dwarf caiman with its head and jaws filling the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered entirely in dramatic, high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny young caiman puppet visible resting inside the parent's jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur suggesting a nest of textured earth and miniature reeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a harsh key light from the side creating sharp highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014191421680152416 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264191627502441 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014191421680152416, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014191421680152416, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05902528762817383, + 0.06322912871837616, + 0.12564246356487274, + 0.09951861202716827, + 0.1508866399526596, + 0.11416276544332504, + 0.18547871708869934, + 0.12068255990743637, + 0.037838879972696304, + 0.04353494197130203 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014191421680152416 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a textured puppet of a dwarf caiman with its head and jaws filling the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered entirely in dramatic, high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny young caiman puppet visible resting inside the parent's jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur suggesting a nest of textured earth and miniature reeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a harsh key light from the side creating sharp highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040934826247394085 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504093647003174 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040934826247394085, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040934826247394085, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07818252593278885, + 0.07145289331674576, + 0.07065162807703018, + 0.06025518476963043, + 0.22654308378696442, + 0.19073665142059326, + 0.14156921207904816, + 0.038050536066293716, + 0.05193239450454712, + 0.07062589377164841 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040934826247394085 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a textured puppet of a dwarf caiman with its head and jaws filling the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered entirely in dramatic, high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny young caiman puppet visible resting inside the parent's jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur suggesting a nest of textured earth and miniature reeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a harsh key light from the side creating sharp highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008635086007416248 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586350440979 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008635086007416248, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008635086007416248, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17082318663597107, + 0.1424802839756012, + 0.13810427486896515, + 0.04033670946955681, + 0.14561186730861664, + 0.1399979591369629, + 0.040002115070819855, + 0.09428932517766953, + 0.03719591349363327, + 0.05115829408168793 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008635086007416248 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, intimate close-up captures a scene in a meticulously crafted frozen world, rendered entirely in dramatic, high-contrast black and white. The central subject is a textured puppet of a dwarf caiman, its head and powerful jaws filling the frame. A harsh, key light from the side carves its form against the deep black background, casting sharp highlights on the ridges of its individually sculpted armored scales and creating deep shadows in the crevices of its rough, clay-like skin. Within its powerful jaws, held with incredible tenderness, rests one of its tiny young. The baby caiman is itself a delicate puppet, nestled securely, its own newly formed scales softly illuminated within the vast darkness of its parent's mouth. The parent's pose is one of immense, focused stillness, a thoughtful and cautious gesture that conveys a profound sense of parental care. The background, a soft-focus blur of its handcrafted surroundings, suggests a nest of textured earth and miniature reeds, further emphasizing the tenderness, protection, and profound quiet of the moment.", + "seed": 30047, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_4/index_5584_seed_30047_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.061015131790190934, + "vlm_logprob": -0.061015131790190934, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.061015131790190934, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a textured puppet of a dwarf caiman with its head and jaws filling the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered entirely in dramatic, high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny young caiman puppet visible resting inside the parent's jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur suggesting a nest of textured earth and miniature reeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a harsh key light from the side creating sharp highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012611517682671547 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.637611389160156 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012611517682671547, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012611517682671547, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14481152594089508, + 0.1058347076177597, + 0.07615374773740768, + 0.0976032018661499, + 0.06633400171995163, + 0.11897789686918259, + 0.08463138341903687, + 0.09718847274780273, + 0.09639173001050949, + 0.11207341402769089 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012611517682671547 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a textured puppet of a dwarf caiman with its head and jaws filling the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered entirely in dramatic, high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny young caiman puppet visible resting inside the parent's jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur suggesting a nest of textured earth and miniature reeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a harsh key light from the side creating sharp highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2256305068731308 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600630521774292 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2256305068731308, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2256305068731308, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26173070073127747, + 0.16430504620075226, + 0.10311979800462723, + 0.047088686376810074, + 0.06833180785179138, + 0.15156838297843933, + 0.036097101867198944, + 0.06598623096942902, + 0.032992612570524216, + 0.06877967715263367 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2256305068731308 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a textured puppet of a dwarf caiman with its head and jaws filling the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered entirely in dramatic, high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny young caiman puppet visible resting inside the parent's jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur suggesting a nest of textured earth and miniature reeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a harsh key light from the side creating sharp highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306282848119736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168062925338745 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306282848119736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306282848119736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10445272922515869, + 0.1208416149020195, + 0.06014819070696831, + 0.051652684807777405, + 0.0873056948184967, + 0.14767345786094666, + 0.0580131821334362, + 0.10627938061952591, + 0.07472774386405945, + 0.188905268907547 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306282848119736 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a textured puppet of a dwarf caiman with its head and jaws filling the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered entirely in dramatic, high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny young caiman puppet visible resting inside the parent's jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur suggesting a nest of textured earth and miniature reeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a harsh key light from the side creating sharp highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031936378218233585 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531938552856445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031936378218233585, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031936378218233585, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2484150379896164, + 0.10338816046714783, + 0.06699079275131226, + 0.06599016487598419, + 0.08899769186973572, + 0.13451169431209564, + 0.043366797268390656, + 0.11721748113632202, + 0.026236403733491898, + 0.1048857569694519 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031936378218233585 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the central subject a textured puppet of a dwarf caiman with its head and jaws filling the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered entirely in dramatic, high-contrast black and white?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a tiny young caiman puppet visible resting inside the parent's jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a soft-focus blur suggesting a nest of textured earth and miniature reeds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a harsh key light from the side creating sharp highlights and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020577168092131615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955771923065186 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020577168092131615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020577168092131615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21634110808372498, + 0.1298046112060547, + 0.06297427415847778, + 0.08440342545509338, + 0.16011036932468414, + 0.06787173449993134, + 0.05418609455227852, + 0.07720432430505753, + 0.056492939591407776, + 0.09061115980148315 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020577168092131615 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_5/index_tensor([1023, 1023])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_5/index_tensor([1023, 1023])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a4cfc937848c7eb77e6e66bded4af32a47c66107 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_5/index_tensor([1023, 1023])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic, close-fitting, low-angle tracking shot follows a heavily modified Dodge Challenger SRT Demon in a fluid, S-curved path. This beast of muscle is clad in a light-absorbing satin matte black paint and fitted with an aggressive widebody kit, accentuating its wide, low-slung profile. Custom, deep-concave, deep-bronze wheels wrapped in low-profile, high-performance tires spin rapidly along its sides as it demonstrates its autonomy. The camera follows closely, capturing the vehicle's front wheels swerving with inhuman precision, even without a driver, as it glides through the first neon orange obstacle cone with minimal roll, steady and composed. The scene is set in a spacious, converted industrial warehouse, its polished concrete floor reflecting the cool, industrial lighting overhead and the variegated glow of the pink and blue neon signs adorning the walls. At the edge of the warehouse, a group of friends dressed in fashionable streetwear watch excitedly, their faces a mixture of awe and excitement, some holding up their phones to record the technologically advanced spectacle. A fierce red \"devil's eye\" halo continuously lights up in the vehicle's customized LED headlights. As it effortlessly weaves between obstacles, the sequential LED taillights at the rear of the vehicle draw elegant light trails. The entire picture is full of high technology, street culture and convincing realism, creating a futuristic party atmosphere that is both tense and cool.", + "seed": 9550, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_5/index_1023_seed_9550_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1781653368845582, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1781653368845582, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.624999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1781653368845582, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily modified Dodge Challenger SRT Demon with a widebody kit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle painted in a light-absorbing satin matte black finish with deep-bronze wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving autonomously without a visible driver inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a spacious converted industrial warehouse with polished concrete floors and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a group of friends in streetwear watching the car from the edge of the warehouse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14761139452457428 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.022611379623413 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14761139452457428, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14761139452457428, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1026124432682991, + 0.05974462255835533, + 0.1481579840183258, + 0.09335871040821075, + 0.07359959930181503, + 0.1226712241768837, + 0.13041387498378754, + 0.07614906877279282, + 0.0682920441031456, + 0.12500041723251343 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14761139452457428 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily modified Dodge Challenger SRT Demon with a widebody kit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle painted in a light-absorbing satin matte black finish with deep-bronze wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving autonomously without a visible driver inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a spacious converted industrial warehouse with polished concrete floors and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a group of friends in streetwear watching the car from the edge of the warehouse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018215514719486237 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018215656280518 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018215514719486237, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018215514719486237, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06780792027711868, + 0.102242611348629, + 0.17162646353244781, + 0.04171448200941086, + 0.11538656800985336, + 0.18125523626804352, + 0.07770290225744247, + 0.06260741502046585, + 0.11311125010251999, + 0.06654514372348785 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018215514719486237 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily modified Dodge Challenger SRT Demon with a widebody kit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle painted in a light-absorbing satin matte black finish with deep-bronze wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving autonomously without a visible driver inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a spacious converted industrial warehouse with polished concrete floors and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a group of friends in streetwear watching the car from the edge of the warehouse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5762418508529663 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8262418508529663 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5762418508529663, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5762418508529663, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15142415463924408, + 0.05672590062022209, + 0.07914521545171738, + 0.060900114476680756, + 0.1821223348379135, + 0.07870803773403168, + 0.18093334138393402, + 0.060641344636678696, + 0.06981799751520157, + 0.07958155125379562 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5762418508529663 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily modified Dodge Challenger SRT Demon with a widebody kit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle painted in a light-absorbing satin matte black finish with deep-bronze wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving autonomously without a visible driver inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a spacious converted industrial warehouse with polished concrete floors and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a group of friends in streetwear watching the car from the edge of the warehouse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005951066501438618 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130950927734375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005951066501438618, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005951066501438618, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2041427493095398, + 0.21385307610034943, + 0.0971030592918396, + 0.06823895126581192, + 0.10098916292190552, + 0.04697231948375702, + 0.07903626561164856, + 0.03390054777264595, + 0.04603562876582146, + 0.10972827672958374 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005951066501438618 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily modified Dodge Challenger SRT Demon with a widebody kit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle painted in a light-absorbing satin matte black finish with deep-bronze wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving autonomously without a visible driver inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a spacious converted industrial warehouse with polished concrete floors and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a group of friends in streetwear watching the car from the edge of the warehouse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14280685782432556 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178067684173584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14280685782432556, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14280685782432556, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03793174773454666, + 0.06495817005634308, + 0.07507969439029694, + 0.1105315238237381, + 0.17559710144996643, + 0.08218719810247421, + 0.23804381489753723, + 0.14597082138061523, + 0.042655061930418015, + 0.027044862508773804 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14280685782432556 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, close-fitting, low-angle tracking shot follows a heavily modified Dodge Challenger SRT Demon in a fluid, S-curved path. This beast of muscle is clad in a light-absorbing satin matte black paint and fitted with an aggressive widebody kit, accentuating its wide, low-slung profile. Custom, deep-concave, deep-bronze wheels wrapped in low-profile, high-performance tires spin rapidly along its sides as it demonstrates its autonomy. The camera follows closely, capturing the vehicle's front wheels swerving with inhuman precision, even without a driver, as it glides through the first neon orange obstacle cone with minimal roll, steady and composed. The scene is set in a spacious, converted industrial warehouse, its polished concrete floor reflecting the cool, industrial lighting overhead and the variegated glow of the pink and blue neon signs adorning the walls. At the edge of the warehouse, a group of friends dressed in fashionable streetwear watch excitedly, their faces a mixture of awe and excitement, some holding up their phones to record the technologically advanced spectacle. A fierce red \"devil's eye\" halo continuously lights up in the vehicle's customized LED headlights. As it effortlessly weaves between obstacles, the sequential LED taillights at the rear of the vehicle draw elegant light trails. The entire picture is full of high technology, street culture and convincing realism, creating a futuristic party atmosphere that is both tense and cool.", + "seed": 9551, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_5/index_1023_seed_9551_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.20230380073189735, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20230380073189735, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20230380073189735, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily modified Dodge Challenger SRT Demon with a widebody kit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle painted in a light-absorbing satin matte black finish with deep-bronze wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving autonomously without a visible driver inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a spacious converted industrial warehouse with polished concrete floors and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a group of friends in streetwear watching the car from the edge of the warehouse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2274675965309143 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6024675369262695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2274675965309143, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2274675965309143, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10557851940393448, + 0.06682675331830978, + 0.07192105799913406, + 0.08426860719919205, + 0.09274397790431976, + 0.0667162537574768, + 0.04907386749982834, + 0.09911204129457474, + 0.06316937506198883, + 0.30058956146240234 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2274675965309143 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily modified Dodge Challenger SRT Demon with a widebody kit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle painted in a light-absorbing satin matte black finish with deep-bronze wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving autonomously without a visible driver inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a spacious converted industrial warehouse with polished concrete floors and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a group of friends in streetwear watching the car from the edge of the warehouse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06208884343504906 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.81208872795105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06208884343504906, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06208884343504906, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.054970014840364456, + 0.11139675974845886, + 0.058406051248311996, + 0.12461397796869278, + 0.09150031954050064, + 0.04364430531859398, + 0.03861502557992935, + 0.1337059885263443, + 0.05743679404258728, + 0.28571078181266785 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06208884343504906 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily modified Dodge Challenger SRT Demon with a widebody kit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle painted in a light-absorbing satin matte black finish with deep-bronze wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving autonomously without a visible driver inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a spacious converted industrial warehouse with polished concrete floors and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a group of friends in streetwear watching the car from the edge of the warehouse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5234699249267578 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8984699249267578 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5234699249267578, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5234699249267578, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1613927185535431, + 0.05250629782676697, + 0.05329413712024689, + 0.09583554416894913, + 0.11235829442739487, + 0.07881247997283936, + 0.18371646106243134, + 0.1438010036945343, + 0.06113537773489952, + 0.05714770406484604 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5234699249267578 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily modified Dodge Challenger SRT Demon with a widebody kit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle painted in a light-absorbing satin matte black finish with deep-bronze wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving autonomously without a visible driver inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a spacious converted industrial warehouse with polished concrete floors and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a group of friends in streetwear watching the car from the edge of the warehouse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038116924464702606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288116931915283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038116924464702606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038116924464702606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1128041222691536, + 0.11721335351467133, + 0.08851057291030884, + 0.18488124012947083, + 0.17306901514530182, + 0.10923842340707779, + 0.043346382677555084, + 0.0528813898563385, + 0.05491630733013153, + 0.06313914805650711 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038116924464702606 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily modified Dodge Challenger SRT Demon with a widebody kit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle painted in a light-absorbing satin matte black finish with deep-bronze wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving autonomously without a visible driver inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a spacious converted industrial warehouse with polished concrete floors and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a group of friends in streetwear watching the car from the edge of the warehouse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.160375714302063 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910375714302063 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.160375714302063, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.160375714302063, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15281543135643005, + 0.11649677157402039, + 0.05413011834025383, + 0.21654607355594635, + 0.04926789924502373, + 0.044035617262125015, + 0.07561328262090683, + 0.10000697523355484, + 0.09796217828989029, + 0.09312567859888077 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.160375714302063 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, close-fitting, low-angle tracking shot follows a heavily modified Dodge Challenger SRT Demon in a fluid, S-curved path. This beast of muscle is clad in a light-absorbing satin matte black paint and fitted with an aggressive widebody kit, accentuating its wide, low-slung profile. Custom, deep-concave, deep-bronze wheels wrapped in low-profile, high-performance tires spin rapidly along its sides as it demonstrates its autonomy. The camera follows closely, capturing the vehicle's front wheels swerving with inhuman precision, even without a driver, as it glides through the first neon orange obstacle cone with minimal roll, steady and composed. The scene is set in a spacious, converted industrial warehouse, its polished concrete floor reflecting the cool, industrial lighting overhead and the variegated glow of the pink and blue neon signs adorning the walls. At the edge of the warehouse, a group of friends dressed in fashionable streetwear watch excitedly, their faces a mixture of awe and excitement, some holding up their phones to record the technologically advanced spectacle. A fierce red \"devil's eye\" halo continuously lights up in the vehicle's customized LED headlights. As it effortlessly weaves between obstacles, the sequential LED taillights at the rear of the vehicle draw elegant light trails. The entire picture is full of high technology, street culture and convincing realism, creating a futuristic party atmosphere that is both tense and cool.", + "seed": 9552, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_5/index_1023_seed_9552_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.12919187997467815, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12919187997467815, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12919187997467815, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily modified Dodge Challenger SRT Demon with a widebody kit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle painted in a light-absorbing satin matte black finish with deep-bronze wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving autonomously without a visible driver inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a spacious converted industrial warehouse with polished concrete floors and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a group of friends in streetwear watching the car from the edge of the warehouse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10263925045728683 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3526391983032227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10263925045728683, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10263925045728683, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1513867974281311, + 0.07673060148954391, + 0.03628445044159889, + 0.04964044317603111, + 0.028665637597441673, + 0.16546525061130524, + 0.10750380903482437, + 0.1329851746559143, + 0.09078741818666458, + 0.16055043041706085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10263925045728683 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily modified Dodge Challenger SRT Demon with a widebody kit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle painted in a light-absorbing satin matte black finish with deep-bronze wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving autonomously without a visible driver inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a spacious converted industrial warehouse with polished concrete floors and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a group of friends in streetwear watching the car from the edge of the warehouse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048675671219825745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048675775527954 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048675671219825745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048675671219825745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12151484936475754, + 0.29148420691490173, + 0.057094380259513855, + 0.02891789935529232, + 0.056917719542980194, + 0.08866217732429504, + 0.0955401137471199, + 0.08869104832410812, + 0.06932418048381805, + 0.1018534004688263 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048675671219825745 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily modified Dodge Challenger SRT Demon with a widebody kit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle painted in a light-absorbing satin matte black finish with deep-bronze wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving autonomously without a visible driver inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a spacious converted industrial warehouse with polished concrete floors and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a group of friends in streetwear watching the car from the edge of the warehouse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42899349331855774 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539934635162354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42899349331855774, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42899349331855774, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15397407114505768, + 0.08648446202278137, + 0.05852092057466507, + 0.04208313673734665, + 0.03019094653427601, + 0.06511247903108597, + 0.07633835822343826, + 0.25406786799430847, + 0.11702610552310944, + 0.11620166152715683 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42899349331855774 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily modified Dodge Challenger SRT Demon with a widebody kit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle painted in a light-absorbing satin matte black finish with deep-bronze wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving autonomously without a visible driver inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a spacious converted industrial warehouse with polished concrete floors and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a group of friends in streetwear watching the car from the edge of the warehouse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036147984210401773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628614902496338 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036147984210401773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036147984210401773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2349262535572052, + 0.10858757048845291, + 0.07887281477451324, + 0.15822845697402954, + 0.07245982438325882, + 0.06034526601433754, + 0.03827119991183281, + 0.07538943737745285, + 0.03566315397620201, + 0.13725607097148895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036147984210401773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily modified Dodge Challenger SRT Demon with a widebody kit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle painted in a light-absorbing satin matte black finish with deep-bronze wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving autonomously without a visible driver inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a spacious converted industrial warehouse with polished concrete floors and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a group of friends in streetwear watching the car from the edge of the warehouse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620361864566803 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120362758636475 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620361864566803, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620361864566803, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24957367777824402, + 0.11742953956127167, + 0.07532556354999542, + 0.31181368231773376, + 0.03090849332511425, + 0.03495168313384056, + 0.035182416439056396, + 0.08307300508022308, + 0.02911853790283203, + 0.03262339159846306 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620361864566803 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, close-fitting, low-angle tracking shot follows a heavily modified Dodge Challenger SRT Demon in a fluid, S-curved path. This beast of muscle is clad in a light-absorbing satin matte black paint and fitted with an aggressive widebody kit, accentuating its wide, low-slung profile. Custom, deep-concave, deep-bronze wheels wrapped in low-profile, high-performance tires spin rapidly along its sides as it demonstrates its autonomy. The camera follows closely, capturing the vehicle's front wheels swerving with inhuman precision, even without a driver, as it glides through the first neon orange obstacle cone with minimal roll, steady and composed. The scene is set in a spacious, converted industrial warehouse, its polished concrete floor reflecting the cool, industrial lighting overhead and the variegated glow of the pink and blue neon signs adorning the walls. At the edge of the warehouse, a group of friends dressed in fashionable streetwear watch excitedly, their faces a mixture of awe and excitement, some holding up their phones to record the technologically advanced spectacle. A fierce red \"devil's eye\" halo continuously lights up in the vehicle's customized LED headlights. As it effortlessly weaves between obstacles, the sequential LED taillights at the rear of the vehicle draw elegant light trails. The entire picture is full of high technology, street culture and convincing realism, creating a futuristic party atmosphere that is both tense and cool.", + "seed": 9553, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_5/index_1023_seed_9553_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.12082429369911551, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12082429369911551, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12082429369911551, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily modified Dodge Challenger SRT Demon with a widebody kit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle painted in a light-absorbing satin matte black finish with deep-bronze wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving autonomously without a visible driver inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a spacious converted industrial warehouse with polished concrete floors and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a group of friends in streetwear watching the car from the edge of the warehouse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06480653584003448 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8148064613342285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06480653584003448, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06480653584003448, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05664193257689476, + 0.04475517198443413, + 0.022991087287664413, + 0.021665439009666443, + 0.49448657035827637, + 0.12097838521003723, + 0.02284884825348854, + 0.05115143582224846, + 0.04428664222359657, + 0.12019453197717667 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06480653584003448 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily modified Dodge Challenger SRT Demon with a widebody kit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle painted in a light-absorbing satin matte black finish with deep-bronze wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving autonomously without a visible driver inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a spacious converted industrial warehouse with polished concrete floors and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a group of friends in streetwear watching the car from the edge of the warehouse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01821024715900421 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018210411071777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01821024715900421, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01821024715900421, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07082974165678024, + 0.053025200963020325, + 0.0492742694914341, + 0.03372656926512718, + 0.44637250900268555, + 0.05058581754565239, + 0.04050469398498535, + 0.12471356987953186, + 0.06787597388029099, + 0.06309162080287933 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01821024715900421 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily modified Dodge Challenger SRT Demon with a widebody kit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle painted in a light-absorbing satin matte black finish with deep-bronze wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving autonomously without a visible driver inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a spacious converted industrial warehouse with polished concrete floors and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a group of friends in streetwear watching the car from the edge of the warehouse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47443073987960815 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9744307398796082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47443073987960815, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47443073987960815, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13847896456718445, + 0.048112902790308, + 0.0507858581840992, + 0.04105060175061226, + 0.19548484683036804, + 0.05433358624577522, + 0.05964961647987366, + 0.11818592995405197, + 0.06611936539411545, + 0.22779829800128937 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47443073987960815 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily modified Dodge Challenger SRT Demon with a widebody kit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle painted in a light-absorbing satin matte black finish with deep-bronze wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving autonomously without a visible driver inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a spacious converted industrial warehouse with polished concrete floors and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a group of friends in streetwear watching the car from the edge of the warehouse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036170552484691143 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628617286682129 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036170552484691143, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036170552484691143, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2792249917984009, + 0.15850843489170074, + 0.09524813294410706, + 0.1145733967423439, + 0.0677051693201065, + 0.033017490059137344, + 0.020596632733941078, + 0.08658383041620255, + 0.051162492483854294, + 0.0933794304728508 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036170552484691143 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a heavily modified Dodge Challenger SRT Demon with a widebody kit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the vehicle painted in a light-absorbing satin matte black finish with deep-bronze wheels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car driving autonomously without a visible driver inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a spacious converted industrial warehouse with polished concrete floors and neon signs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a group of friends in streetwear watching the car from the edge of the warehouse?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305689036846161 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680569648742676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305689036846161, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305689036846161, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.051209188997745514, + 0.027786850929260254, + 0.02210451103746891, + 0.027499893680214882, + 0.1005762591958046, + 0.04068818315863609, + 0.03897571191191673, + 0.048400066792964935, + 0.1974799484014511, + 0.44527941942214966 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305689036846161 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_6/index_tensor([2025, 2025])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_6/index_tensor([2025, 2025])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..cdcea754689f0fa3398e03e5efe8c3c685a85e2f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_6/index_tensor([2025, 2025])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, focuses on an elderly farmer wearing a wide-brimmed straw hat, bent deeply over, intently planting rice in a vast paddy field. The hat, bleached and frayed at the edges by years of sun, frames his weathered, deeply wrinkled face, an expression of serene concentration. He wears a plain, light-colored shirt, soaked with sweat and mud, his trouser legs rolled up to his knees, his bare feet firmly planted in the muddy field. In his left hand, he holds a small bundle of fresh, emerald green seedlings, while his right hand expertly separates a few from among them. Carefully and rhythmically, he inserts them, row by row, ankle-deep into the murky water, reflecting the grayish-white sunlight. Each insertion creates a subtle ripple on the calm surface. In the distance, endless rice paddies stretch to a hazy horizon where they meet the sky. The entire picture presents a distinct faded retro film style, with low color saturation and an overall tone tending towards warm yellow-brown. The obvious film grain and soft diffuse light together create a visual atmosphere that is nostalgic, tranquil and full of respect for labor.", + "seed": 33185, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_6/index_2025_seed_33185_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07853526342660189, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07853526342660189, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.499999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07853526342660189, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer wearing a wide-brimmed straw hat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer bent deeply over while planting rice seedlings in a paddy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a faded retro film style with low color saturation and a warm yellow-brown tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by obvious film grain and soft diffuse light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3154981732368469 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3154981136322021 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3154981732368469, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.9999999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3154981732368469, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4083118438720703, + 0.1157146468758583, + 0.12755614519119263, + 0.09048831462860107, + 0.03434443473815918, + 0.07021992653608322, + 0.04519004747271538, + 0.023874321952462196, + 0.03461657837033272, + 0.04968377947807312 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3154981732368469 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer wearing a wide-brimmed straw hat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer bent deeply over while planting rice seedlings in a paddy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a faded retro film style with low color saturation and a warm yellow-brown tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by obvious film grain and soft diffuse light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014225621707737446 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264225482940674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014225621707737446, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014225621707737446, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.38972213864326477, + 0.18958748877048492, + 0.08656197786331177, + 0.08555625379085541, + 0.05028068646788597, + 0.040183402597904205, + 0.044514890760183334, + 0.030462313443422318, + 0.048291392624378204, + 0.034839533269405365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014225621707737446 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer wearing a wide-brimmed straw hat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer bent deeply over while planting rice seedlings in a paddy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a faded retro film style with low color saturation and a warm yellow-brown tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by obvious film grain and soft diffuse light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370409458875656 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087040424346924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370409458875656, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370409458875656, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23513111472129822, + 0.1406998336315155, + 0.14458657801151276, + 0.17496763169765472, + 0.06290921568870544, + 0.0393805056810379, + 0.07060353457927704, + 0.04362817108631134, + 0.042585670948028564, + 0.04550765082240105 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370409458875656 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer wearing a wide-brimmed straw hat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer bent deeply over while planting rice seedlings in a paddy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a faded retro film style with low color saturation and a warm yellow-brown tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by obvious film grain and soft diffuse light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023299138993024826 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773299217224121 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023299138993024826, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023299138993024826, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.39903634786605835, + 0.21181485056877136, + 0.09084702283143997, + 0.045206163078546524, + 0.04738400876522064, + 0.07736552506685257, + 0.053819749504327774, + 0.021144451573491096, + 0.027986645698547363, + 0.0253952294588089 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023299138993024826 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer wearing a wide-brimmed straw hat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer bent deeply over while planting rice seedlings in a paddy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a faded retro film style with low color saturation and a warm yellow-brown tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by obvious film grain and soft diffuse light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005949288606643677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309494972229 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005949288606643677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005949288606643677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.45959118008613586, + 0.15033549070358276, + 0.08826497942209244, + 0.060084205120801926, + 0.044279586523771286, + 0.03955526649951935, + 0.03808613866567612, + 0.04078904166817665, + 0.029948240146040916, + 0.049065884202718735 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005949288606643677 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, focuses on an elderly farmer wearing a wide-brimmed straw hat, bent deeply over, intently planting rice in a vast paddy field. The hat, bleached and frayed at the edges by years of sun, frames his weathered, deeply wrinkled face, an expression of serene concentration. He wears a plain, light-colored shirt, soaked with sweat and mud, his trouser legs rolled up to his knees, his bare feet firmly planted in the muddy field. In his left hand, he holds a small bundle of fresh, emerald green seedlings, while his right hand expertly separates a few from among them. Carefully and rhythmically, he inserts them, row by row, ankle-deep into the murky water, reflecting the grayish-white sunlight. Each insertion creates a subtle ripple on the calm surface. In the distance, endless rice paddies stretch to a hazy horizon where they meet the sky. The entire picture presents a distinct faded retro film style, with low color saturation and an overall tone tending towards warm yellow-brown. The obvious film grain and soft diffuse light together create a visual atmosphere that is nostalgic, tranquil and full of respect for labor.", + "seed": 33186, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_6/index_2025_seed_33186_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08041848735883832, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08041848735883832, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08041848735883832, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer wearing a wide-brimmed straw hat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer bent deeply over while planting rice seedlings in a paddy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a faded retro film style with low color saturation and a warm yellow-brown tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by obvious film grain and soft diffuse light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3150373697280884 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3150373697280884 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3150373697280884, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3150373697280884, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20347492396831512, + 0.12125512957572937, + 0.0985993891954422, + 0.1259465217590332, + 0.0534328855574131, + 0.030526041984558105, + 0.039230987429618835, + 0.037848033010959625, + 0.20694169402122498, + 0.08274438977241516 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3150373697280884 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer wearing a wide-brimmed straw hat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer bent deeply over while planting rice seedlings in a paddy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a faded retro film style with low color saturation and a warm yellow-brown tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by obvious film grain and soft diffuse light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008660968393087387 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758660793304443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008660968393087387, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008660968393087387, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20541003346443176, + 0.11664101481437683, + 0.08204226195812225, + 0.1609940379858017, + 0.0434068962931633, + 0.0258636474609375, + 0.09639061987400055, + 0.055795393884181976, + 0.09461762011051178, + 0.11883846670389175 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008660968393087387 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer wearing a wide-brimmed straw hat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer bent deeply over while planting rice seedlings in a paddy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a faded retro film style with low color saturation and a warm yellow-brown tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by obvious film grain and soft diffuse light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495023354887962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.92995023727417 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495023354887962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495023354887962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3267534077167511, + 0.12403217703104019, + 0.07351123541593552, + 0.11113105714321136, + 0.06398194283246994, + 0.06572675704956055, + 0.031128674745559692, + 0.021194277331233025, + 0.09743992984294891, + 0.08510053902864456 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495023354887962 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer wearing a wide-brimmed straw hat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer bent deeply over while planting rice seedlings in a paddy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a faded retro film style with low color saturation and a warm yellow-brown tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by obvious film grain and soft diffuse light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018193509429693222 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01819372177124 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018193509429693222, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018193509429693222, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4555406868457794, + 0.06747999042272568, + 0.06720606982707977, + 0.08114011585712433, + 0.11085781455039978, + 0.04602257162332535, + 0.048026587814092636, + 0.023443598300218582, + 0.033669330179691315, + 0.06661318242549896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018193509429693222 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer wearing a wide-brimmed straw hat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer bent deeply over while planting rice seedlings in a paddy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a faded retro film style with low color saturation and a warm yellow-brown tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by obvious film grain and soft diffuse light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052503556944429874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255250453948975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052503556944429874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052503556944429874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36076194047927856, + 0.06532123684883118, + 0.04721061885356903, + 0.118686243891716, + 0.06430310010910034, + 0.03678072243928909, + 0.04221208766102791, + 0.03247210755944252, + 0.13514505326747894, + 0.09710684418678284 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052503556944429874 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, focuses on an elderly farmer wearing a wide-brimmed straw hat, bent deeply over, intently planting rice in a vast paddy field. The hat, bleached and frayed at the edges by years of sun, frames his weathered, deeply wrinkled face, an expression of serene concentration. He wears a plain, light-colored shirt, soaked with sweat and mud, his trouser legs rolled up to his knees, his bare feet firmly planted in the muddy field. In his left hand, he holds a small bundle of fresh, emerald green seedlings, while his right hand expertly separates a few from among them. Carefully and rhythmically, he inserts them, row by row, ankle-deep into the murky water, reflecting the grayish-white sunlight. Each insertion creates a subtle ripple on the calm surface. In the distance, endless rice paddies stretch to a hazy horizon where they meet the sky. The entire picture presents a distinct faded retro film style, with low color saturation and an overall tone tending towards warm yellow-brown. The obvious film grain and soft diffuse light together create a visual atmosphere that is nostalgic, tranquil and full of respect for labor.", + "seed": 33187, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_6/index_2025_seed_33187_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06106568221002817, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06106568221002817, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06106568221002817, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer wearing a wide-brimmed straw hat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer bent deeply over while planting rice seedlings in a paddy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a faded retro film style with low color saturation and a warm yellow-brown tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by obvious film grain and soft diffuse light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2272738665342331 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6022738218307495 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2272738665342331, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2272738665342331, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15199539065361023, + 0.03900241106748581, + 0.06914231926202774, + 0.021853702142834663, + 0.30269697308540344, + 0.12182504683732986, + 0.0778554379940033, + 0.13039244711399078, + 0.06588741391897202, + 0.019348949193954468 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2272738665342331 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer wearing a wide-brimmed straw hat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer bent deeply over while planting rice seedlings in a paddy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a faded retro film style with low color saturation and a warm yellow-brown tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by obvious film grain and soft diffuse light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014228325337171555 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264228343963623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014228325337171555, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014228325337171555, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2382640838623047, + 0.11172227561473846, + 0.07942108064889908, + 0.08623629808425903, + 0.13880039751529694, + 0.11791889369487762, + 0.10467814654111862, + 0.04281584545969963, + 0.04763174429535866, + 0.032511189579963684 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014228325337171555 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer wearing a wide-brimmed straw hat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer bent deeply over while planting rice seedlings in a paddy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a faded retro film style with low color saturation and a warm yellow-brown tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by obvious film grain and soft diffuse light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048650916665792465 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486509799957275 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048650916665792465, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048650916665792465, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17515696585178375, + 0.1608574390411377, + 0.06325595080852509, + 0.04750336706638336, + 0.08680222928524017, + 0.07431860268115997, + 0.03784465044736862, + 0.06486248970031738, + 0.14456355571746826, + 0.1448347568511963 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048650916665792465 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer wearing a wide-brimmed straw hat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer bent deeply over while planting rice seedlings in a paddy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a faded retro film style with low color saturation and a warm yellow-brown tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by obvious film grain and soft diffuse light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011081226170063019 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511081218719482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011081226170063019, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011081226170063019, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3995932638645172, + 0.19464834034442902, + 0.04488610103726387, + 0.023019228130578995, + 0.07796742767095566, + 0.04266117885708809, + 0.0522736981511116, + 0.023797931149601936, + 0.08271794021129608, + 0.05843491852283478 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011081226170063019 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer wearing a wide-brimmed straw hat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer bent deeply over while planting rice seedlings in a paddy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a faded retro film style with low color saturation and a warm yellow-brown tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by obvious film grain and soft diffuse light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004094076342880726 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504094123840332 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004094076342880726, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004094076342880726, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32752662897109985, + 0.11534382402896881, + 0.07337427884340286, + 0.03883061558008194, + 0.07038971036672592, + 0.09584198147058487, + 0.1049249991774559, + 0.04127030819654465, + 0.050225742161273956, + 0.08227191865444183 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004094076342880726 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static medium shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, focuses on an elderly farmer wearing a wide-brimmed straw hat, bent deeply over, intently planting rice in a vast paddy field. The hat, bleached and frayed at the edges by years of sun, frames his weathered, deeply wrinkled face, an expression of serene concentration. He wears a plain, light-colored shirt, soaked with sweat and mud, his trouser legs rolled up to his knees, his bare feet firmly planted in the muddy field. In his left hand, he holds a small bundle of fresh, emerald green seedlings, while his right hand expertly separates a few from among them. Carefully and rhythmically, he inserts them, row by row, ankle-deep into the murky water, reflecting the grayish-white sunlight. Each insertion creates a subtle ripple on the calm surface. In the distance, endless rice paddies stretch to a hazy horizon where they meet the sky. The entire picture presents a distinct faded retro film style, with low color saturation and an overall tone tending towards warm yellow-brown. The obvious film grain and soft diffuse light together create a visual atmosphere that is nostalgic, tranquil and full of respect for labor.", + "seed": 33188, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_6/index_2025_seed_33188_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06184952603653073, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06184952603653073, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06184952603653073, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer wearing a wide-brimmed straw hat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer bent deeply over while planting rice seedlings in a paddy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a faded retro film style with low color saturation and a warm yellow-brown tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by obvious film grain and soft diffuse light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22768577933311462 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.602685809135437 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22768577933311462, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22768577933311462, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.332885205745697, + 0.10126662254333496, + 0.036199841648340225, + 0.02706458792090416, + 0.13883058726787567, + 0.08279816061258316, + 0.06452752649784088, + 0.08261125534772873, + 0.08742217719554901, + 0.04639403894543648 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22768577933311462 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer wearing a wide-brimmed straw hat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer bent deeply over while planting rice seedlings in a paddy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a faded retro film style with low color saturation and a warm yellow-brown tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by obvious film grain and soft diffuse light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011107044294476509 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511106967926025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011107044294476509, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011107044294476509, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12217472493648529, + 0.07583297044038773, + 0.03546419367194176, + 0.04128359258174896, + 0.031604208052158356, + 0.36928921937942505, + 0.08569895476102829, + 0.11092405766248703, + 0.08372759073972702, + 0.04400043189525604 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011107044294476509 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer wearing a wide-brimmed straw hat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer bent deeply over while planting rice seedlings in a paddy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a faded retro film style with low color saturation and a warm yellow-brown tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by obvious film grain and soft diffuse light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048649441450834274 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048649549484253 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048649441450834274, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048649441450834274, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22823165357112885, + 0.043510474264621735, + 0.03180093318223953, + 0.05050667002797127, + 0.08532135933637619, + 0.08782890439033508, + 0.2047262042760849, + 0.05534423515200615, + 0.07840380072593689, + 0.1343257576227188 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048649441450834274 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer wearing a wide-brimmed straw hat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer bent deeply over while planting rice seedlings in a paddy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a faded retro film style with low color saturation and a warm yellow-brown tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by obvious film grain and soft diffuse light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018191635608673096 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018191814422607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018191635608673096, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018191635608673096, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4597826302051544, + 0.05264768376946449, + 0.024856355041265488, + 0.02244366891682148, + 0.03476893529295921, + 0.14034052193164825, + 0.053553659468889236, + 0.13080854713916779, + 0.04367658868432045, + 0.037121403962373734 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018191635608673096 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an elderly farmer wearing a wide-brimmed straw hat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the farmer bent deeply over while planting rice seedlings in a paddy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a static medium shot from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a faded retro film style with low color saturation and a warm yellow-brown tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene characterized by obvious film grain and soft diffuse light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036137294955551624 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.6286139488220215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036137294955551624, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036137294955551624, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3419170379638672, + 0.04140845313668251, + 0.02331593632698059, + 0.027324432507157326, + 0.13447318971157074, + 0.16591723263263702, + 0.12428850680589676, + 0.07120011001825333, + 0.03493822365999222, + 0.0352167934179306 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036137294955551624 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_7/index_tensor([2474, 2474])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_7/index_tensor([2474, 2474])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9d8195f3d45bfbb8bba8269010d93142da11356d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_7/index_tensor([2474, 2474])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, graceful tracking shot begins from a low angle, circling an ancient statue bathed in the warm, golden afternoon sunlight. Carved from weathered white marble, the statue depicts a female figure with an elegant pose and a serene, timeless expression. The traces of time have left fine cracks and patches of soft green moss on its surface, imbuing it with a solemn, historic air. The statue sits in the center of a forgotten courtyard, its backdrop a crumbling stone archway and the ruins of a wall covered in ivy. As the camera smoothly pans, a brilliant anamorphic lens flare, tinged with warm orange and lavender, gently washes across the frame as the camera track intersects the harsh sunlight, briefly blurring the statue's outline and creating a dreamy, ethereal effect. The warm tones of the scene, interweaving light and shadow, create a tranquil, contemplative, and slightly melancholic romantic atmosphere.", + "seed": 30123, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_7/index_2474_seed_30123_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.029826956614851952, + "vlm_logprob": -0.029826956614851952, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.029826956614851952, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a weathered white marble statue of a female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the statue show fine cracks and patches of soft green moss on its surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a forgotten courtyard with a crumbling stone archway and ivy-covered ruins in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful tracking shot that circles the statue from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant anamorphic lens flare tinged with warm orange and lavender that briefly blurs the statue's outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06602263450622559 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8160226345062256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06602263450622559, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06602263450622559, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1363741010427475, + 0.027696460485458374, + 0.026529336348176003, + 0.05624006316065788, + 0.1080072745680809, + 0.028222883120179176, + 0.04596821591258049, + 0.34015458822250366, + 0.07982582598924637, + 0.15098129212856293 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06602263450622559 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a weathered white marble statue of a female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the statue show fine cracks and patches of soft green moss on its surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a forgotten courtyard with a crumbling stone archway and ivy-covered ruins in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful tracking shot that circles the statue from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant anamorphic lens flare tinged with warm orange and lavender that briefly blurs the statue's outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00979274045675993 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634792804718018 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00979274045675993, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00979274045675993, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22972385585308075, + 0.12983833253383636, + 0.19713562726974487, + 0.03148730471730232, + 0.05820082873106003, + 0.025499729439616203, + 0.04327632859349251, + 0.10607104748487473, + 0.06665712594985962, + 0.11210976541042328 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00979274045675993 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a weathered white marble statue of a female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the statue show fine cracks and patches of soft green moss on its surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a forgotten courtyard with a crumbling stone archway and ivy-covered ruins in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful tracking shot that circles the statue from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant anamorphic lens flare tinged with warm orange and lavender that briefly blurs the statue's outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014193654991686344 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264193534851074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014193654991686344, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014193654991686344, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08081677556037903, + 0.055797677487134933, + 0.058592844754457474, + 0.47721490263938904, + 0.05355864390730858, + 0.03893411159515381, + 0.05586443841457367, + 0.07268502563238144, + 0.01942707598209381, + 0.08710850030183792 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014193654991686344 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a weathered white marble statue of a female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the statue show fine cracks and patches of soft green moss on its surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a forgotten courtyard with a crumbling stone archway and ivy-covered ruins in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful tracking shot that circles the statue from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant anamorphic lens flare tinged with warm orange and lavender that briefly blurs the statue's outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016065435484051704 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14106559753418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016065435484051704, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016065435484051704, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.058280013501644135, + 0.06005236133933067, + 0.10505370050668716, + 0.19614499807357788, + 0.0606653168797493, + 0.056973930448293686, + 0.024189412593841553, + 0.08496922254562378, + 0.17196165025234222, + 0.1817094087600708 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016065435484051704 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a weathered white marble statue of a female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the statue show fine cracks and patches of soft green moss on its surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a forgotten courtyard with a crumbling stone archway and ivy-covered ruins in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful tracking shot that circles the statue from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant anamorphic lens flare tinged with warm orange and lavender that briefly blurs the statue's outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043060317635536194 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168060302734375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043060317635536194, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043060317635536194, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.043402981013059616, + 0.044166360050439835, + 0.030424123629927635, + 0.11305894702672958, + 0.06169784814119339, + 0.1844724714756012, + 0.01674431376159191, + 0.07838987559080124, + 0.01667914353311062, + 0.41096383333206177 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043060317635536194 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, graceful tracking shot begins from a low angle, circling an ancient statue bathed in the warm, golden afternoon sunlight. Carved from weathered white marble, the statue depicts a female figure with an elegant pose and a serene, timeless expression. The traces of time have left fine cracks and patches of soft green moss on its surface, imbuing it with a solemn, historic air. The statue sits in the center of a forgotten courtyard, its backdrop a crumbling stone archway and the ruins of a wall covered in ivy. As the camera smoothly pans, a brilliant anamorphic lens flare, tinged with warm orange and lavender, gently washes across the frame as the camera track intersects the harsh sunlight, briefly blurring the statue's outline and creating a dreamy, ethereal effect. The warm tones of the scene, interweaving light and shadow, create a tranquil, contemplative, and slightly melancholic romantic atmosphere.", + "seed": 30124, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_7/index_2474_seed_30124_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03716215267777443, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03716215267777443, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03716215267777443, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a weathered white marble statue of a female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the statue show fine cracks and patches of soft green moss on its surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a forgotten courtyard with a crumbling stone archway and ivy-covered ruins in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful tracking shot that circles the statue from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant anamorphic lens flare tinged with warm orange and lavender that briefly blurs the statue's outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05737956240773201 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9323794841766357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05737956240773201, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05737956240773201, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09984235465526581, + 0.09112576395273209, + 0.1645258665084839, + 0.1285838633775711, + 0.04365352913737297, + 0.027784299105405807, + 0.0834219828248024, + 0.0406544953584671, + 0.20167884230613708, + 0.11872901022434235 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05737956240773201 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a weathered white marble statue of a female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the statue show fine cracks and patches of soft green moss on its surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a forgotten courtyard with a crumbling stone archway and ivy-covered ruins in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful tracking shot that circles the statue from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant anamorphic lens flare tinged with warm orange and lavender that briefly blurs the statue's outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02981116622686386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529811143875122 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02981116622686386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02981116622686386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23810337483882904, + 0.1370450258255005, + 0.046594925224781036, + 0.035212837159633636, + 0.041883066296577454, + 0.02977743372321129, + 0.08031372725963593, + 0.07628533989191055, + 0.25545573234558105, + 0.05932852253317833 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02981116622686386 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a weathered white marble statue of a female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the statue show fine cracks and patches of soft green moss on its surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a forgotten courtyard with a crumbling stone archway and ivy-covered ruins in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful tracking shot that circles the statue from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant anamorphic lens flare tinged with warm orange and lavender that briefly blurs the statue's outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016066139563918114 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141066074371338 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016066139563918114, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016066139563918114, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11892250180244446, + 0.08871085196733475, + 0.31246480345726013, + 0.10030648857355118, + 0.03311359882354736, + 0.038808178156614304, + 0.06738947331905365, + 0.08090174943208694, + 0.11183852702379227, + 0.04754377901554108 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016066139563918114 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a weathered white marble statue of a female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the statue show fine cracks and patches of soft green moss on its surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a forgotten courtyard with a crumbling stone archway and ivy-covered ruins in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful tracking shot that circles the statue from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant anamorphic lens flare tinged with warm orange and lavender that briefly blurs the statue's outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012534411624073982 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875346183776855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012534411624073982, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012534411624073982, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14957088232040405, + 0.11698024719953537, + 0.2417505830526352, + 0.03805067017674446, + 0.09145653247833252, + 0.07028194516897202, + 0.06603550165891647, + 0.08358810842037201, + 0.09934575110673904, + 0.042939770966768265 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012534411624073982 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a weathered white marble statue of a female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the statue show fine cracks and patches of soft green moss on its surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a forgotten courtyard with a crumbling stone archway and ivy-covered ruins in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful tracking shot that circles the statue from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant anamorphic lens flare tinged with warm orange and lavender that briefly blurs the statue's outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07001948356628418 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695019483566284 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07001948356628418, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07001948356628418, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1731034815311432, + 0.27334481477737427, + 0.2164548635482788, + 0.028331473469734192, + 0.03342201188206673, + 0.044119060039520264, + 0.0470486544072628, + 0.023648777976632118, + 0.12567102909088135, + 0.03485585376620293 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07001948356628418 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, graceful tracking shot begins from a low angle, circling an ancient statue bathed in the warm, golden afternoon sunlight. Carved from weathered white marble, the statue depicts a female figure with an elegant pose and a serene, timeless expression. The traces of time have left fine cracks and patches of soft green moss on its surface, imbuing it with a solemn, historic air. The statue sits in the center of a forgotten courtyard, its backdrop a crumbling stone archway and the ruins of a wall covered in ivy. As the camera smoothly pans, a brilliant anamorphic lens flare, tinged with warm orange and lavender, gently washes across the frame as the camera track intersects the harsh sunlight, briefly blurring the statue's outline and creating a dreamy, ethereal effect. The warm tones of the scene, interweaving light and shadow, create a tranquil, contemplative, and slightly melancholic romantic atmosphere.", + "seed": 30125, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_7/index_2474_seed_30125_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04618838001042604, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04618838001042604, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04618838001042604, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a weathered white marble statue of a female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the statue show fine cracks and patches of soft green moss on its surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a forgotten courtyard with a crumbling stone archway and ivy-covered ruins in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful tracking shot that circles the statue from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant anamorphic lens flare tinged with warm orange and lavender that briefly blurs the statue's outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10374779254198074 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.353747844696045 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10374779254198074, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10374779254198074, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.055051401257514954, + 0.03620316460728645, + 0.11913185566663742, + 0.03381401300430298, + 0.027139626443386078, + 0.02967616729438305, + 0.2007230818271637, + 0.08050321042537689, + 0.3464966416358948, + 0.07126087695360184 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10374779254198074 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a weathered white marble statue of a female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the statue show fine cracks and patches of soft green moss on its surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a forgotten courtyard with a crumbling stone archway and ivy-covered ruins in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful tracking shot that circles the statue from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant anamorphic lens flare tinged with warm orange and lavender that briefly blurs the statue's outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048665907233953476 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048666000366211 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048665907233953476, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048665907233953476, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08970724046230316, + 0.07425368577241898, + 0.08891066908836365, + 0.0666477307677269, + 0.04066598415374756, + 0.09386501461267471, + 0.15648120641708374, + 0.23888710141181946, + 0.09063153713941574, + 0.05994988605380058 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048665907233953476 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a weathered white marble statue of a female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the statue show fine cracks and patches of soft green moss on its surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a forgotten courtyard with a crumbling stone archway and ivy-covered ruins in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful tracking shot that circles the statue from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant anamorphic lens flare tinged with warm orange and lavender that briefly blurs the statue's outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0336964875459671 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408696413040161 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0336964875459671, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0336964875459671, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08146422356367111, + 0.09353896975517273, + 0.10527195781469345, + 0.07854006439447403, + 0.07980707287788391, + 0.1349899023771286, + 0.1021769568324089, + 0.10373764485120773, + 0.12857431173324585, + 0.09189886599779129 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0336964875459671 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a weathered white marble statue of a female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the statue show fine cracks and patches of soft green moss on its surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a forgotten courtyard with a crumbling stone archway and ivy-covered ruins in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful tracking shot that circles the statue from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant anamorphic lens flare tinged with warm orange and lavender that briefly blurs the statue's outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006734413094818592 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006734371185303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006734413094818592, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006734413094818592, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1271839737892151, + 0.0741930827498436, + 0.37800225615501404, + 0.028706304728984833, + 0.029567895457148552, + 0.02018994651734829, + 0.08603981882333755, + 0.05683721601963043, + 0.08631303906440735, + 0.11296651512384415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006734413094818592 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a weathered white marble statue of a female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the statue show fine cracks and patches of soft green moss on its surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a forgotten courtyard with a crumbling stone archway and ivy-covered ruins in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful tracking shot that circles the statue from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant anamorphic lens flare tinged with warm orange and lavender that briefly blurs the statue's outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809729963541031 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288097381591797 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809729963541031, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809729963541031, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04109941050410271, + 0.1764814406633377, + 0.09087454527616501, + 0.010435530915856361, + 0.022795768454670906, + 0.02351132407784462, + 0.04777099937200546, + 0.06666886061429977, + 0.3220101296901703, + 0.19835199415683746 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809729963541031 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, graceful tracking shot begins from a low angle, circling an ancient statue bathed in the warm, golden afternoon sunlight. Carved from weathered white marble, the statue depicts a female figure with an elegant pose and a serene, timeless expression. The traces of time have left fine cracks and patches of soft green moss on its surface, imbuing it with a solemn, historic air. The statue sits in the center of a forgotten courtyard, its backdrop a crumbling stone archway and the ruins of a wall covered in ivy. As the camera smoothly pans, a brilliant anamorphic lens flare, tinged with warm orange and lavender, gently washes across the frame as the camera track intersects the harsh sunlight, briefly blurring the statue's outline and creating a dreamy, ethereal effect. The warm tones of the scene, interweaving light and shadow, create a tranquil, contemplative, and slightly melancholic romantic atmosphere.", + "seed": 30126, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_7/index_2474_seed_30126_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.11855547949671745, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11855547949671745, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11855547949671745, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a weathered white marble statue of a female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the statue show fine cracks and patches of soft green moss on its surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a forgotten courtyard with a crumbling stone archway and ivy-covered ruins in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful tracking shot that circles the statue from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant anamorphic lens flare tinged with warm orange and lavender that briefly blurs the statue's outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4761196970939636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9761196970939636 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4761196970939636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4761196970939636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15514931082725525, + 0.08598390221595764, + 0.08897631615400314, + 0.12228843569755554, + 0.3005717992782593, + 0.02450772561132908, + 0.10289967805147171, + 0.04486216977238655, + 0.019807012751698494, + 0.054953694343566895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4761196970939636 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a weathered white marble statue of a female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the statue show fine cracks and patches of soft green moss on its surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a forgotten courtyard with a crumbling stone archway and ivy-covered ruins in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful tracking shot that circles the statue from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant anamorphic lens flare tinged with warm orange and lavender that briefly blurs the statue's outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0337250716984272 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087250232696533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0337250716984272, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0337250716984272, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1657574325799942, + 0.07727954536676407, + 0.06716201454401016, + 0.11114905029535294, + 0.2494741827249527, + 0.027605224400758743, + 0.143638014793396, + 0.03120669536292553, + 0.06574543565511703, + 0.060982417315244675 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0337250716984272 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a weathered white marble statue of a female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the statue show fine cracks and patches of soft green moss on its surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a forgotten courtyard with a crumbling stone archway and ivy-covered ruins in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful tracking shot that circles the statue from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant anamorphic lens flare tinged with warm orange and lavender that briefly blurs the statue's outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819128356873989 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018191337585449 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819128356873989, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819128356873989, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06361833959817886, + 0.08877527713775635, + 0.23373106122016907, + 0.13499951362609863, + 0.19791129231452942, + 0.029472576454281807, + 0.11318294703960419, + 0.06950998306274414, + 0.03153688833117485, + 0.037262119352817535 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819128356873989 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a weathered white marble statue of a female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the statue show fine cracks and patches of soft green moss on its surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a forgotten courtyard with a crumbling stone archway and ivy-covered ruins in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful tracking shot that circles the statue from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant anamorphic lens flare tinged with warm orange and lavender that briefly blurs the statue's outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009781407192349434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634781360626221 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009781407192349434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009781407192349434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10563534498214722, + 0.0789019763469696, + 0.06897327303886414, + 0.08079089969396591, + 0.0812358409166336, + 0.09495766460895538, + 0.1640511155128479, + 0.05581383779644966, + 0.1595369577407837, + 0.1101030707359314 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009781407192349434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a weathered white marble statue of a female figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the statue show fine cracks and patches of soft green moss on its surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a forgotten courtyard with a crumbling stone archway and ivy-covered ruins in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, graceful tracking shot that circles the statue from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant anamorphic lens flare tinged with warm orange and lavender that briefly blurs the statue's outline?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495993793010712 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929960012435913 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495993793010712, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495993793010712, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3224027156829834, + 0.1205567941069603, + 0.0658622533082962, + 0.05208770930767059, + 0.034531496465206146, + 0.039577074348926544, + 0.21225722134113312, + 0.036488939076662064, + 0.049491140991449356, + 0.06674470752477646 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495993793010712 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_8/index_tensor([8156, 8156])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_8/index_tensor([8156, 8156])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..596dada80a8cd65923e1bdec2151baf1e742c61d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_8/index_tensor([8156, 8156])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a seamless 360-degree sweep, the camera, from a slightly upward wide-angle perspective, captures the surreal scene of devastating floodwaters pounding Kinkaku-ji Temple. The turbulent torrent, a thick, dark brown hue mingled with mud, sand, and broken branches, crashes against the temple's base with thunderous force. As the murky waves crash against the structure, they create a massive, frothy splash of white water, creating a stark and brutal contrast with the temple's majestic gold-leafed facade. The iconic Kinkaku-ji facade, though scratched and dented in places by the floodwaters, still reflects a damp, poignant golden sheen against the cold, diffused light of the gloomy sky. As the camera pans steadily and smoothly, we can see the temple's exquisite Japanese architectural details: the superstructure and curved roof remain untouched, while the iconic golden phoenix statue atop it remains motionless in the fierce wind, staring down impassively at the apocalyptic scene below. The entire image presents the unique cinematic animation texture in the style of Love, Death & Robots. Every splash of water droplets, every texture of gold foil, and every tumbling debris in the water are all surreal in detail. The use of light and shadow is extremely sophisticated. Under the cloudy sky, the interplay of light and shadow between the floodwaters and the golden buildings is complex and dramatic, creating an atmosphere that is both grand and heart-pounding, full of tragic beauty.", + "seed": 19864, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_8/index_8156_seed_19864_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.13059155754745005, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13059155754745005, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13059155754745005, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene depicting the Kinkaku-ji Temple being hit by floodwaters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floodwater thick, dark brown, and mixed with mud, sand, and broken branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a seamless 360-degree sweep from a slightly upward wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the golden phoenix statue atop the temple visible and motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with the cinematic animation texture of Love, Death & Robots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12883679568767548 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1288368701934814 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12883679568767548, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12883679568767548, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29088371992111206, + 0.12839338183403015, + 0.05867135524749756, + 0.06580574810504913, + 0.12173696607351303, + 0.060794051736593246, + 0.04345192387700081, + 0.03030179627239704, + 0.06716813147068024, + 0.1327929049730301 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12883679568767548 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene depicting the Kinkaku-ji Temple being hit by floodwaters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floodwater thick, dark brown, and mixed with mud, sand, and broken branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a seamless 360-degree sweep from a slightly upward wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the golden phoenix statue atop the temple visible and motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with the cinematic animation texture of Love, Death & Robots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048679985105991364 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048680067062378 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048679985105991364, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048679985105991364, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25774985551834106, + 0.18210332095623016, + 0.055594928562641144, + 0.15197215974330902, + 0.09839242696762085, + 0.03297000378370285, + 0.04361085593700409, + 0.04461092874407768, + 0.06338590383529663, + 0.06960964947938919 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048679985105991364 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene depicting the Kinkaku-ji Temple being hit by floodwaters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floodwater thick, dark brown, and mixed with mud, sand, and broken branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a seamless 360-degree sweep from a slightly upward wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the golden phoenix statue atop the temple visible and motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with the cinematic animation texture of Love, Death & Robots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4288506507873535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0538506507873535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4288506507873535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4288506507873535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25067707896232605, + 0.06582983583211899, + 0.06874262541532516, + 0.046133171766996384, + 0.1951693445444107, + 0.1814468801021576, + 0.03596428409218788, + 0.04175025597214699, + 0.05702480673789978, + 0.05726174637675285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4288506507873535 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene depicting the Kinkaku-ji Temple being hit by floodwaters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floodwater thick, dark brown, and mixed with mud, sand, and broken branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a seamless 360-degree sweep from a slightly upward wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the golden phoenix statue atop the temple visible and motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with the cinematic animation texture of Love, Death & Robots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023305194452404976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733051776885986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023305194452404976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023305194452404976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10801032185554504, + 0.065004862844944, + 0.12528075277805328, + 0.08806048333644867, + 0.0989210307598114, + 0.09995029121637344, + 0.060366299003362656, + 0.0292967576533556, + 0.09729484468698502, + 0.22781437635421753 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023305194452404976 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene depicting the Kinkaku-ji Temple being hit by floodwaters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floodwater thick, dark brown, and mixed with mud, sand, and broken branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a seamless 360-degree sweep from a slightly upward wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the golden phoenix statue atop the temple visible and motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with the cinematic animation texture of Love, Death & Robots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023285161703824997 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773285150527954 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023285161703824997, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023285161703824997, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1585790067911148, + 0.043333906680345535, + 0.06342728435993195, + 0.06354716420173645, + 0.08995340764522552, + 0.0813569575548172, + 0.12867037951946259, + 0.08244132250547409, + 0.20826512575149536, + 0.08042549341917038 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023285161703824997 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a seamless 360-degree sweep, the camera, from a slightly upward wide-angle perspective, captures the surreal scene of devastating floodwaters pounding Kinkaku-ji Temple. The turbulent torrent, a thick, dark brown hue mingled with mud, sand, and broken branches, crashes against the temple's base with thunderous force. As the murky waves crash against the structure, they create a massive, frothy splash of white water, creating a stark and brutal contrast with the temple's majestic gold-leafed facade. The iconic Kinkaku-ji facade, though scratched and dented in places by the floodwaters, still reflects a damp, poignant golden sheen against the cold, diffused light of the gloomy sky. As the camera pans steadily and smoothly, we can see the temple's exquisite Japanese architectural details: the superstructure and curved roof remain untouched, while the iconic golden phoenix statue atop it remains motionless in the fierce wind, staring down impassively at the apocalyptic scene below. The entire image presents the unique cinematic animation texture in the style of Love, Death & Robots. Every splash of water droplets, every texture of gold foil, and every tumbling debris in the water are all surreal in detail. The use of light and shadow is extremely sophisticated. Under the cloudy sky, the interplay of light and shadow between the floodwaters and the golden buildings is complex and dramatic, creating an atmosphere that is both grand and heart-pounding, full of tragic beauty.", + "seed": 19865, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_8/index_8156_seed_19865_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.1588207997381687, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1588207997381687, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1588207997381687, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene depicting the Kinkaku-ji Temple being hit by floodwaters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floodwater thick, dark brown, and mixed with mud, sand, and broken branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a seamless 360-degree sweep from a slightly upward wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the golden phoenix statue atop the temple visible and motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with the cinematic animation texture of Love, Death & Robots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5776771306991577 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8276771306991577 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5776771306991577, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5776771306991577, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06724102050065994, + 0.04707189276814461, + 0.4882648289203644, + 0.0466294102370739, + 0.04145492985844612, + 0.0317666158080101, + 0.024592796340584755, + 0.04942116141319275, + 0.09992503374814987, + 0.10363230854272842 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5776771306991577 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene depicting the Kinkaku-ji Temple being hit by floodwaters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floodwater thick, dark brown, and mixed with mud, sand, and broken branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a seamless 360-degree sweep from a slightly upward wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the golden phoenix statue atop the temple visible and motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with the cinematic animation texture of Love, Death & Robots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10035485774278641 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503549098968506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10035485774278641, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10035485774278641, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15361163020133972, + 0.20121949911117554, + 0.304334819316864, + 0.06618460267782211, + 0.0375322550535202, + 0.05327167361974716, + 0.02847079560160637, + 0.04329628869891167, + 0.029679369181394577, + 0.08239910751581192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10035485774278641 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene depicting the Kinkaku-ji Temple being hit by floodwaters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floodwater thick, dark brown, and mixed with mud, sand, and broken branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a seamless 360-degree sweep from a slightly upward wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the golden phoenix statue atop the temple visible and motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with the cinematic animation texture of Love, Death & Robots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048651259392499924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486512184143066 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048651259392499924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048651259392499924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25039422512054443, + 0.3879013657569885, + 0.12147780507802963, + 0.04870115593075752, + 0.05673006549477577, + 0.03366931527853012, + 0.01577899046242237, + 0.030646707862615585, + 0.03154546022415161, + 0.02315494231879711 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048651259392499924 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene depicting the Kinkaku-ji Temple being hit by floodwaters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floodwater thick, dark brown, and mixed with mud, sand, and broken branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a seamless 360-degree sweep from a slightly upward wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the golden phoenix statue atop the temple visible and motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with the cinematic animation texture of Love, Death & Robots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033721037209033966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087209701538086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033721037209033966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033721037209033966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14344128966331482, + 0.4195156693458557, + 0.15607492625713348, + 0.06216074526309967, + 0.028257012367248535, + 0.031298134475946426, + 0.029899731278419495, + 0.04553750529885292, + 0.030223101377487183, + 0.05359182879328728 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033721037209033966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene depicting the Kinkaku-ji Temple being hit by floodwaters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floodwater thick, dark brown, and mixed with mud, sand, and broken branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a seamless 360-degree sweep from a slightly upward wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the golden phoenix statue atop the temple visible and motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with the cinematic animation texture of Love, Death & Robots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369971364736557 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086997509002686 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369971364736557, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369971364736557, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15870608389377594, + 0.1842862069606781, + 0.10038155317306519, + 0.08718746155500412, + 0.12509700655937195, + 0.047489624470472336, + 0.11626778542995453, + 0.0669991597533226, + 0.039319079369306564, + 0.0742659866809845 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369971364736557 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a seamless 360-degree sweep, the camera, from a slightly upward wide-angle perspective, captures the surreal scene of devastating floodwaters pounding Kinkaku-ji Temple. The turbulent torrent, a thick, dark brown hue mingled with mud, sand, and broken branches, crashes against the temple's base with thunderous force. As the murky waves crash against the structure, they create a massive, frothy splash of white water, creating a stark and brutal contrast with the temple's majestic gold-leafed facade. The iconic Kinkaku-ji facade, though scratched and dented in places by the floodwaters, still reflects a damp, poignant golden sheen against the cold, diffused light of the gloomy sky. As the camera pans steadily and smoothly, we can see the temple's exquisite Japanese architectural details: the superstructure and curved roof remain untouched, while the iconic golden phoenix statue atop it remains motionless in the fierce wind, staring down impassively at the apocalyptic scene below. The entire image presents the unique cinematic animation texture in the style of Love, Death & Robots. Every splash of water droplets, every texture of gold foil, and every tumbling debris in the water are all surreal in detail. The use of light and shadow is extremely sophisticated. Under the cloudy sky, the interplay of light and shadow between the floodwaters and the golden buildings is complex and dramatic, creating an atmosphere that is both grand and heart-pounding, full of tragic beauty.", + "seed": 19866, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_8/index_8156_seed_19866_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.23222332056611777, + "vlm_logprob": -0.23222332056611777, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.23222332056611777, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene depicting the Kinkaku-ji Temple being hit by floodwaters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floodwater thick, dark brown, and mixed with mud, sand, and broken branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a seamless 360-degree sweep from a slightly upward wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the golden phoenix statue atop the temple visible and motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with the cinematic animation texture of Love, Death & Robots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.389463871717453 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1394639015197754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.389463871717453, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.389463871717453, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24841944873332977, + 0.1273651272058487, + 0.0832863450050354, + 0.18897083401679993, + 0.11741981655359268, + 0.022397514432668686, + 0.03806465491652489, + 0.08399209380149841, + 0.059315115213394165, + 0.03076898120343685 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.389463871717453 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene depicting the Kinkaku-ji Temple being hit by floodwaters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floodwater thick, dark brown, and mixed with mud, sand, and broken branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a seamless 360-degree sweep from a slightly upward wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the golden phoenix statue atop the temple visible and motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with the cinematic animation texture of Love, Death & Robots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08908209949731827 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640820026397705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08908209949731827, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08908209949731827, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4404444694519043, + 0.1425948292016983, + 0.08079984784126282, + 0.08652658015489578, + 0.04286811128258705, + 0.016250615939497948, + 0.025826264172792435, + 0.03959843888878822, + 0.08135116100311279, + 0.043739646673202515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08908209949731827 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene depicting the Kinkaku-ji Temple being hit by floodwaters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floodwater thick, dark brown, and mixed with mud, sand, and broken branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a seamless 360-degree sweep from a slightly upward wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the golden phoenix statue atop the temple visible and motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with the cinematic animation texture of Love, Death & Robots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6327711939811707 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7577711939811707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6327711939811707, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6327711939811707, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11791594326496124, + 0.09453090280294418, + 0.13319678604602814, + 0.12112004309892654, + 0.16184112429618835, + 0.15486374497413635, + 0.0823156088590622, + 0.024456122890114784, + 0.029013561084866524, + 0.08074616640806198 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6327711939811707 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene depicting the Kinkaku-ji Temple being hit by floodwaters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floodwater thick, dark brown, and mixed with mud, sand, and broken branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a seamless 360-degree sweep from a slightly upward wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the golden phoenix statue atop the temple visible and motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with the cinematic animation texture of Love, Death & Robots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006747911684215069 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006747722625732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006747911684215069, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006747911684215069, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32797971367836, + 0.09720613807439804, + 0.07910212874412537, + 0.14444153010845184, + 0.07909119129180908, + 0.053435180336236954, + 0.05588580667972565, + 0.0360589437186718, + 0.04008479043841362, + 0.08671454340219498 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006747911684215069 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene depicting the Kinkaku-ji Temple being hit by floodwaters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floodwater thick, dark brown, and mixed with mud, sand, and broken branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a seamless 360-degree sweep from a slightly upward wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the golden phoenix statue atop the temple visible and motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with the cinematic animation texture of Love, Death & Robots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043051525950431824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680514812469482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043051525950431824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043051525950431824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5043575167655945, + 0.07607986032962799, + 0.10602444410324097, + 0.05956118181347847, + 0.065140500664711, + 0.03328867256641388, + 0.03926585614681244, + 0.033759113401174545, + 0.05086745694279671, + 0.0316554494202137 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043051525950431824 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a seamless 360-degree sweep, the camera, from a slightly upward wide-angle perspective, captures the surreal scene of devastating floodwaters pounding Kinkaku-ji Temple. The turbulent torrent, a thick, dark brown hue mingled with mud, sand, and broken branches, crashes against the temple's base with thunderous force. As the murky waves crash against the structure, they create a massive, frothy splash of white water, creating a stark and brutal contrast with the temple's majestic gold-leafed facade. The iconic Kinkaku-ji facade, though scratched and dented in places by the floodwaters, still reflects a damp, poignant golden sheen against the cold, diffused light of the gloomy sky. As the camera pans steadily and smoothly, we can see the temple's exquisite Japanese architectural details: the superstructure and curved roof remain untouched, while the iconic golden phoenix statue atop it remains motionless in the fierce wind, staring down impassively at the apocalyptic scene below. The entire image presents the unique cinematic animation texture in the style of Love, Death & Robots. Every splash of water droplets, every texture of gold foil, and every tumbling debris in the water are all surreal in detail. The use of light and shadow is extremely sophisticated. Under the cloudy sky, the interplay of light and shadow between the floodwaters and the golden buildings is complex and dramatic, creating an atmosphere that is both grand and heart-pounding, full of tragic beauty.", + "seed": 19867, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_8/index_8156_seed_19867_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.20124278031289577, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20124278031289577, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20124278031289577, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene depicting the Kinkaku-ji Temple being hit by floodwaters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floodwater thick, dark brown, and mixed with mud, sand, and broken branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a seamless 360-degree sweep from a slightly upward wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the golden phoenix statue atop the temple visible and motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with the cinematic animation texture of Love, Death & Robots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8271669149398804 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5771669149398804 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8271669149398804, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8271669149398804, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08829956501722336, + 0.05185449868440628, + 0.026389865204691887, + 0.03714622184634209, + 0.028875920921564102, + 0.10422142595052719, + 0.1872556060552597, + 0.025474989786744118, + 0.37577202916145325, + 0.0747099369764328 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8271669149398804 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene depicting the Kinkaku-ji Temple being hit by floodwaters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floodwater thick, dark brown, and mixed with mud, sand, and broken branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a seamless 360-degree sweep from a slightly upward wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the golden phoenix statue atop the temple visible and motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with the cinematic animation texture of Love, Death & Robots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02331754006445408 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773317575454712 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02331754006445408, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02331754006445408, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2956225574016571, + 0.03519283980131149, + 0.05069948360323906, + 0.03162150830030441, + 0.01709146797657013, + 0.12974348664283752, + 0.10966864973306656, + 0.0657169446349144, + 0.2024189829826355, + 0.062224097549915314 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02331754006445408 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene depicting the Kinkaku-ji Temple being hit by floodwaters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floodwater thick, dark brown, and mixed with mud, sand, and broken branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a seamless 360-degree sweep from a slightly upward wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the golden phoenix statue atop the temple visible and motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with the cinematic animation texture of Love, Death & Robots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04304889962077141 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168048858642578 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04304889962077141, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04304889962077141, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03911943361163139, + 0.04270916059613228, + 0.03974245488643646, + 0.03201134130358696, + 0.502407431602478, + 0.18131178617477417, + 0.06296263635158539, + 0.020358996465802193, + 0.014023907482624054, + 0.06535288691520691 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04304889962077141 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene depicting the Kinkaku-ji Temple being hit by floodwaters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floodwater thick, dark brown, and mixed with mud, sand, and broken branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a seamless 360-degree sweep from a slightly upward wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the golden phoenix statue atop the temple visible and motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with the cinematic animation texture of Love, Death & Robots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07899109274148941 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578991174697876 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07899109274148941, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07899109274148941, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06540484726428986, + 0.0545630119740963, + 0.040178414434194565, + 0.014621025882661343, + 0.06042212247848511, + 0.036757003515958786, + 0.20664677023887634, + 0.041904266923666, + 0.4372546672821045, + 0.04224786162376404 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07899109274148941 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene depicting the Kinkaku-ji Temple being hit by floodwaters?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floodwater thick, dark brown, and mixed with mud, sand, and broken branches?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a seamless 360-degree sweep from a slightly upward wide-angle perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the golden phoenix statue atop the temple visible and motionless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with the cinematic animation texture of Love, Death & Robots?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033689454197883606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408689498901367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033689454197883606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033689454197883606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1649664044380188, + 0.0405549518764019, + 0.03587385267019272, + 0.037403326481580734, + 0.24165049195289612, + 0.11822326481342316, + 0.13085897266864777, + 0.02641487307846546, + 0.14345134794712067, + 0.06060250476002693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033689454197883606 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_9/index_tensor([736, 736])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_9/index_tensor([736, 736])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6c882dc883c30d0c315699a64168d814a4efa284 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_9/index_tensor([736, 736])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, slightly high-angled medium shot captures a pristine sheet of white paper, precariously resting, one-third of its length dangling over the sharp edge of a dark, polished oak table. Under the even, diffuse glow of the invisible room lights overhead, the rich, dark brown veins of the table's surface are clearly visible. A faint, almost imperceptible vibration sweeps through the table, causing the paper to begin a slow, deliberate slide. It hesitates for a fraction of a second before tipping over the precipice and beginning its descent. The sheet immediately catches the still air, fluttering and swaying unpredictably; first tumbling from end to end in a silent, chaotic dance, then momentarily flattening, gliding sideways, and twisting again, its path a mesmerizing ballet of instability. Finally, its momentum running out, the paper performs one final, gentle rotation, resting perfectly flat on the dark hardwood floor below. The stark white rectangle comes to a sudden and complete stillness, creating a quiet, contemplative atmosphere, completely focused on the simple, elegant physics of autumn.", + "seed": 16501, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_9/index_736_seed_16501_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03450937913730741, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03450937913730741, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03450937913730741, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a pristine white paper sheet shown resting precariously over the edge of a dark, polished oak table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the paper slide, hesitate, tip over the edge, and then flutter and tumble down to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper come to a final rest flat on the dark hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and diffuse, revealing the dark brown veins of the table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03154747560620308 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.9065475463867188 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03154747560620308, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03154747560620308, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14998649060726166, + 0.3117510676383972, + 0.058480821549892426, + 0.04646853357553482, + 0.0915716141462326, + 0.05094490945339203, + 0.0618593730032444, + 0.1537492722272873, + 0.029866434633731842, + 0.045321494340896606 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03154747560620308 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a pristine white paper sheet shown resting precariously over the edge of a dark, polished oak table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the paper slide, hesitate, tip over the edge, and then flutter and tumble down to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper come to a final rest flat on the dark hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and diffuse, revealing the dark brown veins of the table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02062072791159153 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895620822906494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02062072791159153, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02062072791159153, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11844711750745773, + 0.2395152747631073, + 0.2383096069097519, + 0.05059371143579483, + 0.16076697409152985, + 0.06000904738903046, + 0.03165680915117264, + 0.0413849800825119, + 0.038738008588552475, + 0.020578427240252495 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02062072791159153 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a pristine white paper sheet shown resting precariously over the edge of a dark, polished oak table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the paper slide, hesitate, tip over the edge, and then flutter and tumble down to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper come to a final rest flat on the dark hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and diffuse, revealing the dark brown veins of the table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002822346519678831 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877822399139404 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002822346519678831, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002822346519678831, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10640863329172134, + 0.17596155405044556, + 0.14671958982944489, + 0.07973185181617737, + 0.1159968450665474, + 0.12538108229637146, + 0.1232193261384964, + 0.07270648330450058, + 0.02152298390865326, + 0.03235164284706116 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002822346519678831 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a pristine white paper sheet shown resting precariously over the edge of a dark, polished oak table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the paper slide, hesitate, tip over the edge, and then flutter and tumble down to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper come to a final rest flat on the dark hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and diffuse, revealing the dark brown veins of the table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004634116776287556 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379633903503418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004634116776287556, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004634116776287556, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15329547226428986, + 0.0895848423242569, + 0.11152289062738419, + 0.03918188437819481, + 0.1318567395210266, + 0.09877599775791168, + 0.08850601315498352, + 0.22322909533977509, + 0.03225582465529442, + 0.03179120644927025 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004634116776287556 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a pristine white paper sheet shown resting precariously over the edge of a dark, polished oak table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the paper slide, hesitate, tip over the edge, and then flutter and tumble down to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper come to a final rest flat on the dark hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and diffuse, revealing the dark brown veins of the table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11292222887277603 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237922191619873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11292222887277603, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11292222887277603, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11554649472236633, + 0.050990812480449677, + 0.17577631771564484, + 0.0340832956135273, + 0.09443749487400055, + 0.11402362585067749, + 0.10156508535146713, + 0.2589785158634186, + 0.032962389290332794, + 0.02163592167198658 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11292222887277603 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly high-angled medium shot captures a pristine sheet of white paper, precariously resting, one-third of its length dangling over the sharp edge of a dark, polished oak table. Under the even, diffuse glow of the invisible room lights overhead, the rich, dark brown veins of the table's surface are clearly visible. A faint, almost imperceptible vibration sweeps through the table, causing the paper to begin a slow, deliberate slide. It hesitates for a fraction of a second before tipping over the precipice and beginning its descent. The sheet immediately catches the still air, fluttering and swaying unpredictably; first tumbling from end to end in a silent, chaotic dance, then momentarily flattening, gliding sideways, and twisting again, its path a mesmerizing ballet of instability. Finally, its momentum running out, the paper performs one final, gentle rotation, resting perfectly flat on the dark hardwood floor below. The stark white rectangle comes to a sudden and complete stillness, creating a quiet, contemplative atmosphere, completely focused on the simple, elegant physics of autumn.", + "seed": 16502, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_9/index_736_seed_16502_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03663943288847804, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03663943288847804, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03663943288847804, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a pristine white paper sheet shown resting precariously over the edge of a dark, polished oak table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the paper slide, hesitate, tip over the edge, and then flutter and tumble down to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper come to a final rest flat on the dark hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and diffuse, revealing the dark brown veins of the table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09718739241361618 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4721872806549072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09718739241361618, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09718739241361618, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31363028287887573, + 0.23646025359630585, + 0.11156310141086578, + 0.06878993660211563, + 0.08200736343860626, + 0.08414216339588165, + 0.0357510931789875, + 0.017536912113428116, + 0.034503091126680374, + 0.015615737996995449 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09718739241361618 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a pristine white paper sheet shown resting precariously over the edge of a dark, polished oak table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the paper slide, hesitate, tip over the edge, and then flutter and tumble down to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper come to a final rest flat on the dark hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and diffuse, revealing the dark brown veins of the table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023316724225878716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733166217803955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023316724225878716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023316724225878716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30560368299484253, + 0.06941643357276917, + 0.04391574487090111, + 0.06150650978088379, + 0.1195431798696518, + 0.10103616863489151, + 0.11923074722290039, + 0.03202984854578972, + 0.10679993033409119, + 0.04091776907444 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023316724225878716 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a pristine white paper sheet shown resting precariously over the edge of a dark, polished oak table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the paper slide, hesitate, tip over the edge, and then flutter and tumble down to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper come to a final rest flat on the dark hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and diffuse, revealing the dark brown veins of the table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012541946023702621 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387541770935059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012541946023702621, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012541946023702621, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33456021547317505, + 0.1388421505689621, + 0.04704565554857254, + 0.06906425207853317, + 0.1574418842792511, + 0.0947493314743042, + 0.041041284799575806, + 0.02978241629898548, + 0.058677006512880325, + 0.028795728459954262 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012541946023702621 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a pristine white paper sheet shown resting precariously over the edge of a dark, polished oak table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the paper slide, hesitate, tip over the edge, and then flutter and tumble down to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper come to a final rest flat on the dark hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and diffuse, revealing the dark brown veins of the table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015098373405635357 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501509666442871 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015098373405635357, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015098373405635357, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22963188588619232, + 0.17568852007389069, + 0.049015823751688004, + 0.09181002527475357, + 0.10283495485782623, + 0.09987899661064148, + 0.06247993931174278, + 0.09808827936649323, + 0.03987978771328926, + 0.050691742449998856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015098373405635357 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a pristine white paper sheet shown resting precariously over the edge of a dark, polished oak table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the paper slide, hesitate, tip over the edge, and then flutter and tumble down to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper come to a final rest flat on the dark hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and diffuse, revealing the dark brown veins of the table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864126443862915 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486412048339844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864126443862915, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864126443862915, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24187223613262177, + 0.11667892336845398, + 0.07786539942026138, + 0.05835219472646713, + 0.1474185436964035, + 0.18381480872631073, + 0.0454629510641098, + 0.04867144674062729, + 0.040936700999736786, + 0.038926862180233 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864126443862915 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly high-angled medium shot captures a pristine sheet of white paper, precariously resting, one-third of its length dangling over the sharp edge of a dark, polished oak table. Under the even, diffuse glow of the invisible room lights overhead, the rich, dark brown veins of the table's surface are clearly visible. A faint, almost imperceptible vibration sweeps through the table, causing the paper to begin a slow, deliberate slide. It hesitates for a fraction of a second before tipping over the precipice and beginning its descent. The sheet immediately catches the still air, fluttering and swaying unpredictably; first tumbling from end to end in a silent, chaotic dance, then momentarily flattening, gliding sideways, and twisting again, its path a mesmerizing ballet of instability. Finally, its momentum running out, the paper performs one final, gentle rotation, resting perfectly flat on the dark hardwood floor below. The stark white rectangle comes to a sudden and complete stillness, creating a quiet, contemplative atmosphere, completely focused on the simple, elegant physics of autumn.", + "seed": 16503, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_9/index_736_seed_16503_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.01254109914880246, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01254109914880246, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01254109914880246, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a pristine white paper sheet shown resting precariously over the edge of a dark, polished oak table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the paper slide, hesitate, tip over the edge, and then flutter and tumble down to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper come to a final rest flat on the dark hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and diffuse, revealing the dark brown veins of the table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.030841708183288574 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.780841827392578 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.030841708183288574, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.030841708183288574, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09057874977588654, + 0.05577671527862549, + 0.15568822622299194, + 0.11567492038011551, + 0.14637339115142822, + 0.10909567773342133, + 0.0477285273373127, + 0.16422444581985474, + 0.0869101881980896, + 0.02794915810227394 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.030841708183288574 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a pristine white paper sheet shown resting precariously over the edge of a dark, polished oak table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the paper slide, hesitate, tip over the edge, and then flutter and tumble down to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper come to a final rest flat on the dark hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and diffuse, revealing the dark brown veins of the table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006760699674487114 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006760597229004 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006760699674487114, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006760699674487114, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07343708723783493, + 0.09990600496530533, + 0.049856998026371, + 0.2714124619960785, + 0.06652504950761795, + 0.04468412324786186, + 0.07362617552280426, + 0.06608210504055023, + 0.11255554854869843, + 0.1419144868850708 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006760699674487114 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a pristine white paper sheet shown resting precariously over the edge of a dark, polished oak table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the paper slide, hesitate, tip over the edge, and then flutter and tumble down to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper come to a final rest flat on the dark hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and diffuse, revealing the dark brown veins of the table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002820919966325164 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.87782096862793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002820919966325164, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002820919966325164, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07093339413404465, + 0.058320190757513046, + 0.040152207016944885, + 0.41654840111732483, + 0.04341955855488777, + 0.062265101820230484, + 0.02557985670864582, + 0.20232871174812317, + 0.024497803300619125, + 0.05595473572611809 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002820919966325164 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a pristine white paper sheet shown resting precariously over the edge of a dark, polished oak table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the paper slide, hesitate, tip over the edge, and then flutter and tumble down to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper come to a final rest flat on the dark hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and diffuse, revealing the dark brown veins of the table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001709786825813353 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376709938049316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001709786825813353, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001709786825813353, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05428066849708557, + 0.04935576021671295, + 0.03907408192753792, + 0.18435530364513397, + 0.0991145595908165, + 0.04991457238793373, + 0.02992849424481392, + 0.2730036675930023, + 0.06341417878866196, + 0.15755867958068848 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001709786825813353 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a pristine white paper sheet shown resting precariously over the edge of a dark, polished oak table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the paper slide, hesitate, tip over the edge, and then flutter and tumble down to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper come to a final rest flat on the dark hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and diffuse, revealing the dark brown veins of the table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057238109409809 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955724239349365 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057238109409809, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057238109409809, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0606863833963871, + 0.05045575648546219, + 0.18745842576026917, + 0.3182750940322876, + 0.07863801717758179, + 0.03786885738372803, + 0.031495898962020874, + 0.04891705513000488, + 0.09492497146129608, + 0.09127947688102722 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057238109409809 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, slightly high-angled medium shot captures a pristine sheet of white paper, precariously resting, one-third of its length dangling over the sharp edge of a dark, polished oak table. Under the even, diffuse glow of the invisible room lights overhead, the rich, dark brown veins of the table's surface are clearly visible. A faint, almost imperceptible vibration sweeps through the table, causing the paper to begin a slow, deliberate slide. It hesitates for a fraction of a second before tipping over the precipice and beginning its descent. The sheet immediately catches the still air, fluttering and swaying unpredictably; first tumbling from end to end in a silent, chaotic dance, then momentarily flattening, gliding sideways, and twisting again, its path a mesmerizing ballet of instability. Finally, its momentum running out, the paper performs one final, gentle rotation, resting perfectly flat on the dark hardwood floor below. The stark white rectangle comes to a sudden and complete stillness, creating a quiet, contemplative atmosphere, completely focused on the simple, elegant physics of autumn.", + "seed": 16504, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000234/group_9/index_736_seed_16504_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.009618374519050121, + "vlm_logprob": -0.009618374519050121, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.009618374519050121, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a pristine white paper sheet shown resting precariously over the edge of a dark, polished oak table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the paper slide, hesitate, tip over the edge, and then flutter and tumble down to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper come to a final rest flat on the dark hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and diffuse, revealing the dark brown veins of the table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.021125074476003647 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.396124839782715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.021125074476003647, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.021125074476003647, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19264136254787445, + 0.1032000482082367, + 0.13046549260616302, + 0.09149675816297531, + 0.08416052162647247, + 0.10680767148733139, + 0.057635482400655746, + 0.08072718232870102, + 0.0652402713894844, + 0.08762520551681519 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.021125074476003647 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a pristine white paper sheet shown resting precariously over the edge of a dark, polished oak table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the paper slide, hesitate, tip over the edge, and then flutter and tumble down to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper come to a final rest flat on the dark hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and diffuse, revealing the dark brown veins of the table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006764133460819721 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006763935089111 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006764133460819721, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006764133460819721, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1314256340265274, + 0.10754135251045227, + 0.21267880499362946, + 0.12442687898874283, + 0.06703668087720871, + 0.13388939201831818, + 0.034055911004543304, + 0.06744050234556198, + 0.05451388284564018, + 0.06699100136756897 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006764133460819721 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a pristine white paper sheet shown resting precariously over the edge of a dark, polished oak table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the paper slide, hesitate, tip over the edge, and then flutter and tumble down to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper come to a final rest flat on the dark hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and diffuse, revealing the dark brown veins of the table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031969649717211723 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753197193145752 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031969649717211723, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031969649717211723, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20404382050037384, + 0.08939507603645325, + 0.10496403276920319, + 0.12626872956752777, + 0.08055070042610168, + 0.08944972604513168, + 0.09208066016435623, + 0.12080327421426773, + 0.04526990279555321, + 0.047174084931612015 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031969649717211723 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a pristine white paper sheet shown resting precariously over the edge of a dark, polished oak table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the paper slide, hesitate, tip over the edge, and then flutter and tumble down to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper come to a final rest flat on the dark hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and diffuse, revealing the dark brown veins of the table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002815570682287216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778157234191895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002815570682287216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002815570682287216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17689459025859833, + 0.08862192183732986, + 0.1504276692867279, + 0.05925324186682701, + 0.07334093749523163, + 0.06993108242750168, + 0.08527393639087677, + 0.12994159758090973, + 0.05978003144264221, + 0.10653496533632278 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002815570682287216 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static, slightly high-angled medium shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a pristine white paper sheet shown resting precariously over the edge of a dark, polished oak table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the paper slide, hesitate, tip over the edge, and then flutter and tumble down to the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the paper come to a final rest flat on the dark hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting even and diffuse, revealing the dark brown veins of the table surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01419012900441885 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264190196990967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01419012900441885, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01419012900441885, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2310047447681427, + 0.18881051242351532, + 0.09622904658317566, + 0.029698649421334267, + 0.0630999207496643, + 0.07564804702997208, + 0.09013103693723679, + 0.08857882022857666, + 0.05353076383471489, + 0.08326847106218338 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01419012900441885 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_0/index_tensor([4558, 4558])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_0/index_tensor([4558, 4558])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fa4f19f671b452803729f98ed48084a25d5ea4e9 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_0/index_tensor([4558, 4558])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle shot, moving rapidly and close to the ground, follows a spherical smart pet toy. Slightly larger than a tennis ball, its shell is crafted from sleek, polished chrome that perfectly reflects its surroundings. Vibrant cyan light pulses from the seams of its surface. It frantically chases a virtual red dot of light across a retro cyberpunk-style apartment. The dark, polished concrete floor, shimmering with a damp sheen, distorts the magenta and electric blue neon lights of the giant holographic billboard flashing outside the window and the glowing orange data cables snaking along the walls into vibrant, flowing reflections. The smart toy zips, swerves, and drifts across the floor with astonishing speed and agility, its internal micro-motor humming audibly. As it pounces on the elusive red light, the camera also rushes forward, capturing its every swift and precise capture movement from an extremely low angle - its metal body falls heavily on the place where the light spot just was, stirring up a circle of tiny splashes, and the light spot always appears a few feet away in an instant at the millisecond level. The whole scene, with chaotic colors and humid air, creates a game atmosphere that is a mixture of high technology and decadence, full of tension, movement and futile pursuit.", + "seed": 13493, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_0/index_4558_seed_13493_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0358794922940433, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0358794922940433, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0358794922940433, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a spherical smart pet toy slightly larger than a tennis ball with a polished chrome shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the toy emit vibrant cyan light pulses from its seams and chase a virtual red dot of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a retro cyberpunk-style apartment with dark polished concrete floors reflecting magenta and electric blue neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move rapidly from an extremely low angle, following the toy as it zips, swerves, and drifts across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the toy collide with the floor, creating tiny splashes, while the red light spot instantly reappears a few feet away?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01671464927494526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141714572906494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01671464927494526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01671464927494526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3275707960128784, + 0.26611706614494324, + 0.049261096864938736, + 0.13467758893966675, + 0.0301295705139637, + 0.04138348251581192, + 0.04741969332098961, + 0.048400964587926865, + 0.028682617470622063, + 0.026357149705290794 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01671464927494526 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a spherical smart pet toy slightly larger than a tennis ball with a polished chrome shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the toy emit vibrant cyan light pulses from its seams and chase a virtual red dot of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a retro cyberpunk-style apartment with dark polished concrete floors reflecting magenta and electric blue neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move rapidly from an extremely low angle, following the toy as it zips, swerves, and drifts across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the toy collide with the floor, creating tiny splashes, while the red light spot instantly reappears a few feet away?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007638176903128624 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882637977600098 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007638176903128624, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007638176903128624, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.355981707572937, + 0.14887262880802155, + 0.12674705684185028, + 0.10262367129325867, + 0.039203863590955734, + 0.040434885770082474, + 0.03894287347793579, + 0.04678861051797867, + 0.07108546793460846, + 0.02931925840675831 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007638176903128624 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a spherical smart pet toy slightly larger than a tennis ball with a polished chrome shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the toy emit vibrant cyan light pulses from its seams and chase a virtual red dot of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a retro cyberpunk-style apartment with dark polished concrete floors reflecting magenta and electric blue neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move rapidly from an extremely low angle, following the toy as it zips, swerves, and drifts across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the toy collide with the floor, creating tiny splashes, while the red light spot instantly reappears a few feet away?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00762906763702631 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882628917694092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00762906763702631, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00762906763702631, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.41251760721206665, + 0.09446753561496735, + 0.02462928555905819, + 0.13023005425930023, + 0.0631043091416359, + 0.08001922070980072, + 0.0492699071764946, + 0.06273787468671799, + 0.04903572425246239, + 0.033988457173109055 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00762906763702631 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a spherical smart pet toy slightly larger than a tennis ball with a polished chrome shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the toy emit vibrant cyan light pulses from its seams and chase a virtual red dot of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a retro cyberpunk-style apartment with dark polished concrete floors reflecting magenta and electric blue neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move rapidly from an extremely low angle, following the toy as it zips, swerves, and drifts across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the toy collide with the floor, creating tiny splashes, while the red light spot instantly reappears a few feet away?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004637439269572496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379637241363525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004637439269572496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004637439269572496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35252463817596436, + 0.09199588745832443, + 0.07375433295965195, + 0.11723299324512482, + 0.10279174894094467, + 0.03125398978590965, + 0.02943894825875759, + 0.059894707053899765, + 0.0739591047167778, + 0.06715360283851624 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004637439269572496 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a spherical smart pet toy slightly larger than a tennis ball with a polished chrome shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the toy emit vibrant cyan light pulses from its seams and chase a virtual red dot of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a retro cyberpunk-style apartment with dark polished concrete floors reflecting magenta and electric blue neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move rapidly from an extremely low angle, following the toy as it zips, swerves, and drifts across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the toy collide with the floor, creating tiny splashes, while the red light spot instantly reappears a few feet away?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14277812838554382 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017778158187866 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14277812838554382, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14277812838554382, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35041868686676025, + 0.1108846664428711, + 0.09640230238437653, + 0.0726337879896164, + 0.04281552881002426, + 0.04163515940308571, + 0.04076404124498367, + 0.09748530387878418, + 0.07099924981594086, + 0.07596126198768616 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14277812838554382 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle shot, moving rapidly and close to the ground, follows a spherical smart pet toy. Slightly larger than a tennis ball, its shell is crafted from sleek, polished chrome that perfectly reflects its surroundings. Vibrant cyan light pulses from the seams of its surface. It frantically chases a virtual red dot of light across a retro cyberpunk-style apartment. The dark, polished concrete floor, shimmering with a damp sheen, distorts the magenta and electric blue neon lights of the giant holographic billboard flashing outside the window and the glowing orange data cables snaking along the walls into vibrant, flowing reflections. The smart toy zips, swerves, and drifts across the floor with astonishing speed and agility, its internal micro-motor humming audibly. As it pounces on the elusive red light, the camera also rushes forward, capturing its every swift and precise capture movement from an extremely low angle - its metal body falls heavily on the place where the light spot just was, stirring up a circle of tiny splashes, and the light spot always appears a few feet away in an instant at the millisecond level. The whole scene, with chaotic colors and humid air, creates a game atmosphere that is a mixture of high technology and decadence, full of tension, movement and futile pursuit.", + "seed": 13494, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_0/index_4558_seed_13494_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.028188561089336872, + "vlm_logprob": -0.028188561089336872, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.028188561089336872, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a spherical smart pet toy slightly larger than a tennis ball with a polished chrome shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the toy emit vibrant cyan light pulses from its seams and chase a virtual red dot of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a retro cyberpunk-style apartment with dark polished concrete floors reflecting magenta and electric blue neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move rapidly from an extremely low angle, following the toy as it zips, swerves, and drifts across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the toy collide with the floor, creating tiny splashes, while the red light spot instantly reappears a few feet away?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023865457624197006 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7738654613494873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023865457624197006, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023865457624197006, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18209336698055267, + 0.14065851271152496, + 0.035520654171705246, + 0.1679922640323639, + 0.02752103842794895, + 0.027163339778780937, + 0.05182937905192375, + 0.052116043865680695, + 0.15874120593070984, + 0.15636423230171204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023865457624197006 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a spherical smart pet toy slightly larger than a tennis ball with a polished chrome shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the toy emit vibrant cyan light pulses from its seams and chase a virtual red dot of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a retro cyberpunk-style apartment with dark polished concrete floors reflecting magenta and electric blue neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move rapidly from an extremely low angle, following the toy as it zips, swerves, and drifts across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the toy collide with the floor, creating tiny splashes, while the red light spot instantly reappears a few feet away?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059578209184110165 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.13095760345459 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059578209184110165, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059578209184110165, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07247099280357361, + 0.0769224688410759, + 0.05665537342429161, + 0.07878222316503525, + 0.3927847146987915, + 0.0662260428071022, + 0.016996992751955986, + 0.027991820126771927, + 0.04992218315601349, + 0.1612471640110016 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059578209184110165 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a spherical smart pet toy slightly larger than a tennis ball with a polished chrome shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the toy emit vibrant cyan light pulses from its seams and chase a virtual red dot of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a retro cyberpunk-style apartment with dark polished concrete floors reflecting magenta and electric blue neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move rapidly from an extremely low angle, following the toy as it zips, swerves, and drifts across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the toy collide with the floor, creating tiny splashes, while the red light spot instantly reappears a few feet away?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004095738288015127 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504095554351807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004095738288015127, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004095738288015127, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06513206660747528, + 0.10448460280895233, + 0.0477306954562664, + 0.05808061361312866, + 0.36876529455184937, + 0.03105759061872959, + 0.07227186858654022, + 0.036619700491428375, + 0.07257961481809616, + 0.14327800273895264 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004095738288015127 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a spherical smart pet toy slightly larger than a tennis ball with a polished chrome shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the toy emit vibrant cyan light pulses from its seams and chase a virtual red dot of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a retro cyberpunk-style apartment with dark polished concrete floors reflecting magenta and electric blue neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move rapidly from an extremely low angle, following the toy as it zips, swerves, and drifts across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the toy collide with the floor, creating tiny splashes, while the red light spot instantly reappears a few feet away?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006735360249876976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006735324859619 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006735360249876976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006735360249876976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12291567027568817, + 0.0829029381275177, + 0.04152786731719971, + 0.04503662511706352, + 0.05844299495220184, + 0.07825589925050735, + 0.35073623061180115, + 0.053981713950634, + 0.08415238559246063, + 0.08204768598079681 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006735360249876976 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a spherical smart pet toy slightly larger than a tennis ball with a polished chrome shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the toy emit vibrant cyan light pulses from its seams and chase a virtual red dot of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a retro cyberpunk-style apartment with dark polished concrete floors reflecting magenta and electric blue neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move rapidly from an extremely low angle, following the toy as it zips, swerves, and drifts across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the toy collide with the floor, creating tiny splashes, while the red light spot instantly reappears a few feet away?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10028842836618423 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3502883911132812 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10028842836618423, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10028842836618423, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08575230091810226, + 0.10891591012477875, + 0.04961472004652023, + 0.07462996989488602, + 0.124137282371521, + 0.09195947647094727, + 0.11620362102985382, + 0.06561650335788727, + 0.15477043390274048, + 0.1283998340368271 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10028842836618423 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle shot, moving rapidly and close to the ground, follows a spherical smart pet toy. Slightly larger than a tennis ball, its shell is crafted from sleek, polished chrome that perfectly reflects its surroundings. Vibrant cyan light pulses from the seams of its surface. It frantically chases a virtual red dot of light across a retro cyberpunk-style apartment. The dark, polished concrete floor, shimmering with a damp sheen, distorts the magenta and electric blue neon lights of the giant holographic billboard flashing outside the window and the glowing orange data cables snaking along the walls into vibrant, flowing reflections. The smart toy zips, swerves, and drifts across the floor with astonishing speed and agility, its internal micro-motor humming audibly. As it pounces on the elusive red light, the camera also rushes forward, capturing its every swift and precise capture movement from an extremely low angle - its metal body falls heavily on the place where the light spot just was, stirring up a circle of tiny splashes, and the light spot always appears a few feet away in an instant at the millisecond level. The whole scene, with chaotic colors and humid air, creates a game atmosphere that is a mixture of high technology and decadence, full of tension, movement and futile pursuit.", + "seed": 13495, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_0/index_4558_seed_13495_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.039696391019970176, + "vlm_logprob": -0.039696391019970176, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.039696391019970176, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a spherical smart pet toy slightly larger than a tennis ball with a polished chrome shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the toy emit vibrant cyan light pulses from its seams and chase a virtual red dot of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a retro cyberpunk-style apartment with dark polished concrete floors reflecting magenta and electric blue neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move rapidly from an extremely low angle, following the toy as it zips, swerves, and drifts across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the toy collide with the floor, creating tiny splashes, while the red light spot instantly reappears a few feet away?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.049597349017858505 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0495972633361816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.049597349017858505, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.049597349017858505, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.035588234663009644, + 0.024268625304102898, + 0.011135689914226532, + 0.013573640026152134, + 0.013276705518364906, + 0.112460657954216, + 0.01314548123627901, + 0.43427154421806335, + 0.040565941482782364, + 0.3017135262489319 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.049597349017858505 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a spherical smart pet toy slightly larger than a tennis ball with a polished chrome shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the toy emit vibrant cyan light pulses from its seams and chase a virtual red dot of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a retro cyberpunk-style apartment with dark polished concrete floors reflecting magenta and electric blue neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move rapidly from an extremely low angle, following the toy as it zips, swerves, and drifts across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the toy collide with the floor, creating tiny splashes, while the red light spot instantly reappears a few feet away?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059725485742092 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895597219467163 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059725485742092, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059725485742092, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10775593668222427, + 0.09869574010372162, + 0.041611626744270325, + 0.05416161194443703, + 0.05034854635596275, + 0.054840635508298874, + 0.02869531325995922, + 0.2126973420381546, + 0.07788336277008057, + 0.2733098864555359 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059725485742092 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a spherical smart pet toy slightly larger than a tennis ball with a polished chrome shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the toy emit vibrant cyan light pulses from its seams and chase a virtual red dot of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a retro cyberpunk-style apartment with dark polished concrete floors reflecting magenta and electric blue neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move rapidly from an extremely low angle, following the toy as it zips, swerves, and drifts across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the toy collide with the floor, creating tiny splashes, while the red light spot instantly reappears a few feet away?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006735833827406168 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006735801696777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006735833827406168, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006735833827406168, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10044268518686295, + 0.0819840058684349, + 0.02767951600253582, + 0.02336268126964569, + 0.0430196113884449, + 0.07223258912563324, + 0.029980570077896118, + 0.3853154480457306, + 0.044614024460315704, + 0.19136887788772583 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006735833827406168 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a spherical smart pet toy slightly larger than a tennis ball with a polished chrome shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the toy emit vibrant cyan light pulses from its seams and chase a virtual red dot of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a retro cyberpunk-style apartment with dark polished concrete floors reflecting magenta and electric blue neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move rapidly from an extremely low angle, following the toy as it zips, swerves, and drifts across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the toy collide with the floor, creating tiny splashes, while the red light spot instantly reappears a few feet away?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008637804538011551 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75863790512085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008637804538011551, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008637804538011551, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06290055811405182, + 0.04335147887468338, + 0.02900872565805912, + 0.044255103915929794, + 0.02002675272524357, + 0.02599302865564823, + 0.02833581529557705, + 0.6089572906494141, + 0.034984663128852844, + 0.10218654572963715 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008637804538011551 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a spherical smart pet toy slightly larger than a tennis ball with a polished chrome shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the toy emit vibrant cyan light pulses from its seams and chase a virtual red dot of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a retro cyberpunk-style apartment with dark polished concrete floors reflecting magenta and electric blue neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move rapidly from an extremely low angle, following the toy as it zips, swerves, and drifts across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the toy collide with the floor, creating tiny splashes, while the red light spot instantly reappears a few feet away?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11291371285915375 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379136085510254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11291371285915375, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11291371285915375, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03654223680496216, + 0.03140980750322342, + 0.008836759254336357, + 0.04613833874464035, + 0.015453387051820755, + 0.018353275954723358, + 0.04652180150151253, + 0.5958962440490723, + 0.03713332116603851, + 0.16371487081050873 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11291371285915375 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle shot, moving rapidly and close to the ground, follows a spherical smart pet toy. Slightly larger than a tennis ball, its shell is crafted from sleek, polished chrome that perfectly reflects its surroundings. Vibrant cyan light pulses from the seams of its surface. It frantically chases a virtual red dot of light across a retro cyberpunk-style apartment. The dark, polished concrete floor, shimmering with a damp sheen, distorts the magenta and electric blue neon lights of the giant holographic billboard flashing outside the window and the glowing orange data cables snaking along the walls into vibrant, flowing reflections. The smart toy zips, swerves, and drifts across the floor with astonishing speed and agility, its internal micro-motor humming audibly. As it pounces on the elusive red light, the camera also rushes forward, capturing its every swift and precise capture movement from an extremely low angle - its metal body falls heavily on the place where the light spot just was, stirring up a circle of tiny splashes, and the light spot always appears a few feet away in an instant at the millisecond level. The whole scene, with chaotic colors and humid air, creates a game atmosphere that is a mixture of high technology and decadence, full of tension, movement and futile pursuit.", + "seed": 13496, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_0/index_4558_seed_13496_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06369257066398859, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06369257066398859, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.174999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06369257066398859, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a spherical smart pet toy slightly larger than a tennis ball with a polished chrome shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the toy emit vibrant cyan light pulses from its seams and chase a virtual red dot of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a retro cyberpunk-style apartment with dark polished concrete floors reflecting magenta and electric blue neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move rapidly from an extremely low angle, following the toy as it zips, swerves, and drifts across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the toy collide with the floor, creating tiny splashes, while the red light spot instantly reappears a few feet away?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11511533707380295 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2401154041290283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11511533707380295, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11511533707380295, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.058377452194690704, + 0.043403998017311096, + 0.06592482328414917, + 0.08822452276945114, + 0.035044774413108826, + 0.07591978460550308, + 0.027294203639030457, + 0.44665616750717163, + 0.036749500781297684, + 0.12240476161241531 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11511533707380295 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a spherical smart pet toy slightly larger than a tennis ball with a polished chrome shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the toy emit vibrant cyan light pulses from its seams and chase a virtual red dot of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a retro cyberpunk-style apartment with dark polished concrete floors reflecting magenta and electric blue neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move rapidly from an extremely low angle, following the toy as it zips, swerves, and drifts across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the toy collide with the floor, creating tiny splashes, while the red light spot instantly reappears a few feet away?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02982505038380623 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.52982497215271 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02982505038380623, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02982505038380623, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11119101941585541, + 0.10009255260229111, + 0.07505107671022415, + 0.13029736280441284, + 0.02966250851750374, + 0.047833651304244995, + 0.06450335681438446, + 0.14566457271575928, + 0.060558170080184937, + 0.2351457178592682 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02982505038380623 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a spherical smart pet toy slightly larger than a tennis ball with a polished chrome shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the toy emit vibrant cyan light pulses from its seams and chase a virtual red dot of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a retro cyberpunk-style apartment with dark polished concrete floors reflecting magenta and electric blue neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move rapidly from an extremely low angle, following the toy as it zips, swerves, and drifts across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the toy collide with the floor, creating tiny splashes, while the red light spot instantly reappears a few feet away?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018192220479249954 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018192291259766 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018192220479249954, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018192220479249954, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20842643082141876, + 0.07500116527080536, + 0.0593724250793457, + 0.11721445620059967, + 0.04610736668109894, + 0.15361806750297546, + 0.07236099988222122, + 0.18992078304290771, + 0.019166234880685806, + 0.05881210416555405 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018192220479249954 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a spherical smart pet toy slightly larger than a tennis ball with a polished chrome shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the toy emit vibrant cyan light pulses from its seams and chase a virtual red dot of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a retro cyberpunk-style apartment with dark polished concrete floors reflecting magenta and electric blue neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move rapidly from an extremely low angle, following the toy as it zips, swerves, and drifts across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the toy collide with the floor, creating tiny splashes, while the red light spot instantly reappears a few feet away?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01253888476639986 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387538909912109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01253888476639986, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01253888476639986, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14629203081130981, + 0.03371502831578255, + 0.04691020026803017, + 0.028137575834989548, + 0.08158256858587265, + 0.05608290061354637, + 0.17949366569519043, + 0.34432709217071533, + 0.03969985619187355, + 0.043759074062108994 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01253888476639986 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a spherical smart pet toy slightly larger than a tennis ball with a polished chrome shell?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the toy emit vibrant cyan light pulses from its seams and chase a virtual red dot of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a retro cyberpunk-style apartment with dark polished concrete floors reflecting magenta and electric blue neon lights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera move rapidly from an extremely low angle, following the toy as it zips, swerves, and drifts across the floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the toy collide with the floor, creating tiny splashes, while the red light spot instantly reappears a few feet away?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14279136061668396 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017791271209717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14279136061668396, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14279136061668396, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15504729747772217, + 0.09687864035367966, + 0.024323446676135063, + 0.21231672167778015, + 0.02988664247095585, + 0.048912208527326584, + 0.10231070220470428, + 0.08686981350183487, + 0.08479993045330048, + 0.1586546152830124 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14279136061668396 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_1/index_tensor([9766, 9766])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_1/index_tensor([9766, 9766])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..43346ffd3e405a7f1e9832b30aebdc9fb6cace6a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_1/index_tensor([9766, 9766])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, steady tracking shot at eye level follows a solitary figure, rendered in a high-contrast, black-and-white, dark anime style. This slender figure, their features completely obscured by the deep shadow of their hood, walks along a dirt road at a leisurely pace. They are wrapped in a heavy, flowing cloak, its tattered hems billowing delicately in the unseen wind. The fabric is pure black, highlighting the scene's few bright spots. The camera pans with the figure as they pass a desolate, empty moon-viewing platform. Dark shadows from the platform's wooden pillars stretch like long fingers across the weathered, crumbling planks. The sole source of illumination is a desolate, brilliant white full moon, hanging isolated in the solid black, cloudless sky. This single, harsh light gleams from the figure's shoulder, drawing silver lines along the edge of the cloak while casting long, twisted shadows behind them. Below the platform, the perfect reflection of the moon on the dark, choppy lake surface was violently shattered into a thousand glittering, dancing fragments, creating an unforgettable atmosphere of profound loneliness.", + "seed": 13292, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_1/index_9766_seed_13292_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.02757052853703499, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02757052853703499, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02757052853703499, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, black-and-white, dark anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender figure wearing a heavy, pure black cloak with a hood that obscures their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady tracking shot at eye level following the figure past a desolate moon-viewing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single brilliant white full moon in a solid black, cloudless sky, casting long shadows and silver highlights on the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the reflection of the moon on the dark, choppy lake surface below the platform shattered into glittering fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008147811517119408 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.133147716522217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008147811517119408, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008147811517119408, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08154207468032837, + 0.3008871376514435, + 0.06394173204898834, + 0.060822658240795135, + 0.022204328328371048, + 0.3019208014011383, + 0.035375166684389114, + 0.057951945811510086, + 0.027252132073044777, + 0.04810203239321709 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008147811517119408 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, black-and-white, dark anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender figure wearing a heavy, pure black cloak with a hood that obscures their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady tracking shot at eye level following the figure past a desolate moon-viewing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single brilliant white full moon in a solid black, cloudless sky, casting long shadows and silver highlights on the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the reflection of the moon on the dark, choppy lake surface below the platform shattered into glittering fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06209130585193634 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.81209135055542 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06209130585193634, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06209130585193634, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0847632884979248, + 0.12128060311079025, + 0.08264772593975067, + 0.0912187397480011, + 0.04179122671484947, + 0.25512778759002686, + 0.06572975963354111, + 0.022822575643658638, + 0.02657422423362732, + 0.20804406702518463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06209130585193634 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, black-and-white, dark anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender figure wearing a heavy, pure black cloak with a hood that obscures their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady tracking shot at eye level following the figure past a desolate moon-viewing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single brilliant white full moon in a solid black, cloudless sky, casting long shadows and silver highlights on the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the reflection of the moon on the dark, choppy lake surface below the platform shattered into glittering fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033705130219459534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408705234527588 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033705130219459534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033705130219459534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10393846035003662, + 0.2619190514087677, + 0.07173774391412735, + 0.03788960725069046, + 0.03700290620326996, + 0.3293515145778656, + 0.046200595796108246, + 0.021313320845365524, + 0.037933193147182465, + 0.05271364748477936 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033705130219459534 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, black-and-white, dark anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender figure wearing a heavy, pure black cloak with a hood that obscures their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady tracking shot at eye level following the figure past a desolate moon-viewing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single brilliant white full moon in a solid black, cloudless sky, casting long shadows and silver highlights on the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the reflection of the moon on the dark, choppy lake surface below the platform shattered into glittering fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004099775105714798 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5040998458862305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004099775105714798, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004099775105714798, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05192403867840767, + 0.46082744002342224, + 0.0622890405356884, + 0.0356498546898365, + 0.04426739737391472, + 0.1793348640203476, + 0.07982181757688522, + 0.01823166385293007, + 0.04278721660375595, + 0.024866735562682152 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004099775105714798 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, black-and-white, dark anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender figure wearing a heavy, pure black cloak with a hood that obscures their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady tracking shot at eye level following the figure past a desolate moon-viewing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single brilliant white full moon in a solid black, cloudless sky, casting long shadows and silver highlights on the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the reflection of the moon on the dark, choppy lake surface below the platform shattered into glittering fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029808619990944862 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529808521270752 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029808619990944862, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029808619990944862, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1245778277516365, + 0.0621829479932785, + 0.03762352839112282, + 0.026302017271518707, + 0.02469201199710369, + 0.4101199507713318, + 0.06408914923667908, + 0.06041419133543968, + 0.15663683414459229, + 0.03336150944232941 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029808619990944862 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, steady tracking shot at eye level follows a solitary figure, rendered in a high-contrast, black-and-white, dark anime style. This slender figure, their features completely obscured by the deep shadow of their hood, walks along a dirt road at a leisurely pace. They are wrapped in a heavy, flowing cloak, its tattered hems billowing delicately in the unseen wind. The fabric is pure black, highlighting the scene's few bright spots. The camera pans with the figure as they pass a desolate, empty moon-viewing platform. Dark shadows from the platform's wooden pillars stretch like long fingers across the weathered, crumbling planks. The sole source of illumination is a desolate, brilliant white full moon, hanging isolated in the solid black, cloudless sky. This single, harsh light gleams from the figure's shoulder, drawing silver lines along the edge of the cloak while casting long, twisted shadows behind them. Below the platform, the perfect reflection of the moon on the dark, choppy lake surface was violently shattered into a thousand glittering, dancing fragments, creating an unforgettable atmosphere of profound loneliness.", + "seed": 13293, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_1/index_9766_seed_13293_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.025847744988277556, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025847744988277556, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025847744988277556, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, black-and-white, dark anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender figure wearing a heavy, pure black cloak with a hood that obscures their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady tracking shot at eye level following the figure past a desolate moon-viewing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single brilliant white full moon in a solid black, cloudless sky, casting long shadows and silver highlights on the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the reflection of the moon on the dark, choppy lake surface below the platform shattered into glittering fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0038329721428453922 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.003832817077637 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0038329721428453922, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0038329721428453922, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1561586558818817, + 0.19660310447216034, + 0.06913769245147705, + 0.07027930021286011, + 0.02872292883694172, + 0.07976742833852768, + 0.09954405575990677, + 0.08018472045660019, + 0.06329289823770523, + 0.15630921721458435 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0038329721428453922 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, black-and-white, dark anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender figure wearing a heavy, pure black cloak with a hood that obscures their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady tracking shot at eye level following the figure past a desolate moon-viewing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single brilliant white full moon in a solid black, cloudless sky, casting long shadows and silver highlights on the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the reflection of the moon on the dark, choppy lake surface below the platform shattered into glittering fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020615939050912857 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895616054534912 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020615939050912857, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020615939050912857, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12428136169910431, + 0.4266570210456848, + 0.13384249806404114, + 0.03331379592418671, + 0.03812653198838234, + 0.029921092092990875, + 0.0776519924402237, + 0.05482557415962219, + 0.035966724157333374, + 0.045413363724946976 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020615939050912857 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, black-and-white, dark anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender figure wearing a heavy, pure black cloak with a hood that obscures their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady tracking shot at eye level following the figure past a desolate moon-viewing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single brilliant white full moon in a solid black, cloudless sky, casting long shadows and silver highlights on the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the reflection of the moon on the dark, choppy lake surface below the platform shattered into glittering fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329086884856224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732908725738525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329086884856224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329086884856224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1434161365032196, + 0.1790911853313446, + 0.09748334437608719, + 0.076982282102108, + 0.04471982270479202, + 0.07441472262144089, + 0.0667102262377739, + 0.11100587993860245, + 0.12787993252277374, + 0.07829643785953522 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329086884856224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, black-and-white, dark anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender figure wearing a heavy, pure black cloak with a hood that obscures their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady tracking shot at eye level following the figure past a desolate moon-viewing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single brilliant white full moon in a solid black, cloudless sky, casting long shadows and silver highlights on the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the reflection of the moon on the dark, choppy lake surface below the platform shattered into glittering fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002494083484634757 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002493858337402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002494083484634757, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002494083484634757, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20130297541618347, + 0.2796429991722107, + 0.04944561421871185, + 0.070832759141922, + 0.034944720566272736, + 0.07957098633050919, + 0.061331696808338165, + 0.06434264779090881, + 0.07124409824609756, + 0.08734159171581268 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002494083484634757 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, black-and-white, dark anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender figure wearing a heavy, pure black cloak with a hood that obscures their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady tracking shot at eye level following the figure past a desolate moon-viewing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single brilliant white full moon in a solid black, cloudless sky, casting long shadows and silver highlights on the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the reflection of the moon on the dark, choppy lake surface below the platform shattered into glittering fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900486141443253 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790047645568848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900486141443253, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900486141443253, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11409008502960205, + 0.18732497096061707, + 0.0892639085650444, + 0.061276186257600784, + 0.055301450192928314, + 0.13086557388305664, + 0.06750600785017014, + 0.08282412588596344, + 0.15350040793418884, + 0.05804729461669922 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900486141443253 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, steady tracking shot at eye level follows a solitary figure, rendered in a high-contrast, black-and-white, dark anime style. This slender figure, their features completely obscured by the deep shadow of their hood, walks along a dirt road at a leisurely pace. They are wrapped in a heavy, flowing cloak, its tattered hems billowing delicately in the unseen wind. The fabric is pure black, highlighting the scene's few bright spots. The camera pans with the figure as they pass a desolate, empty moon-viewing platform. Dark shadows from the platform's wooden pillars stretch like long fingers across the weathered, crumbling planks. The sole source of illumination is a desolate, brilliant white full moon, hanging isolated in the solid black, cloudless sky. This single, harsh light gleams from the figure's shoulder, drawing silver lines along the edge of the cloak while casting long, twisted shadows behind them. Below the platform, the perfect reflection of the moon on the dark, choppy lake surface was violently shattered into a thousand glittering, dancing fragments, creating an unforgettable atmosphere of profound loneliness.", + "seed": 13294, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_1/index_9766_seed_13294_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03566649230197072, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03566649230197072, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03566649230197072, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, black-and-white, dark anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender figure wearing a heavy, pure black cloak with a hood that obscures their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady tracking shot at eye level following the figure past a desolate moon-viewing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single brilliant white full moon in a solid black, cloudless sky, casting long shadows and silver highlights on the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the reflection of the moon on the dark, choppy lake surface below the platform shattered into glittering fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008150885812938213 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.133151054382324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008150885812938213, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008150885812938213, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33770856261253357, + 0.10740608721971512, + 0.11063846945762634, + 0.08276642113924026, + 0.06714547425508499, + 0.11730065941810608, + 0.05181993544101715, + 0.029625888913869858, + 0.05649594962596893, + 0.03909256309270859 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008150885812938213 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, black-and-white, dark anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender figure wearing a heavy, pure black cloak with a hood that obscures their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady tracking shot at eye level following the figure past a desolate moon-viewing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single brilliant white full moon in a solid black, cloudless sky, casting long shadows and silver highlights on the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the reflection of the moon on the dark, choppy lake surface below the platform shattered into glittering fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05499762296676636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929997682571411 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05499762296676636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05499762296676636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31508371233940125, + 0.13967716693878174, + 0.07661784440279007, + 0.10798858106136322, + 0.07697266340255737, + 0.10330042243003845, + 0.09793725609779358, + 0.022519206628203392, + 0.03966951742768288, + 0.02023361064493656 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05499762296676636 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, black-and-white, dark anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender figure wearing a heavy, pure black cloak with a hood that obscures their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady tracking shot at eye level following the figure past a desolate moon-viewing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single brilliant white full moon in a solid black, cloudless sky, casting long shadows and silver highlights on the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the reflection of the moon on the dark, choppy lake surface below the platform shattered into glittering fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329564467072487 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732956409454346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329564467072487, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329564467072487, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22540563344955444, + 0.07340042293071747, + 0.1912849247455597, + 0.15219591557979584, + 0.0678885281085968, + 0.1180424913764, + 0.09382683783769608, + 0.04014350846409798, + 0.025118138641119003, + 0.012693550437688828 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329564467072487 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, black-and-white, dark anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender figure wearing a heavy, pure black cloak with a hood that obscures their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady tracking shot at eye level following the figure past a desolate moon-viewing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single brilliant white full moon in a solid black, cloudless sky, casting long shadows and silver highlights on the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the reflection of the moon on the dark, choppy lake surface below the platform shattered into glittering fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028249616734683514 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877824783325195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028249616734683514, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028249616734683514, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1481182724237442, + 0.05253208056092262, + 0.11797511577606201, + 0.10054691880941391, + 0.0693368911743164, + 0.2735799551010132, + 0.035592034459114075, + 0.03414205461740494, + 0.12095524370670319, + 0.0472213551402092 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028249616734683514 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, black-and-white, dark anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender figure wearing a heavy, pure black cloak with a hood that obscures their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady tracking shot at eye level following the figure past a desolate moon-viewing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single brilliant white full moon in a solid black, cloudless sky, casting long shadows and silver highlights on the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the reflection of the moon on the dark, choppy lake surface below the platform shattered into glittering fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08906334638595581 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640634059906006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08906334638595581, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08906334638595581, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31624892354011536, + 0.08446893095970154, + 0.17947247624397278, + 0.07026999443769455, + 0.05792294070124626, + 0.09533965587615967, + 0.06138338893651962, + 0.07560092955827713, + 0.03818753361701965, + 0.02110527642071247 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08906334638595581 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, steady tracking shot at eye level follows a solitary figure, rendered in a high-contrast, black-and-white, dark anime style. This slender figure, their features completely obscured by the deep shadow of their hood, walks along a dirt road at a leisurely pace. They are wrapped in a heavy, flowing cloak, its tattered hems billowing delicately in the unseen wind. The fabric is pure black, highlighting the scene's few bright spots. The camera pans with the figure as they pass a desolate, empty moon-viewing platform. Dark shadows from the platform's wooden pillars stretch like long fingers across the weathered, crumbling planks. The sole source of illumination is a desolate, brilliant white full moon, hanging isolated in the solid black, cloudless sky. This single, harsh light gleams from the figure's shoulder, drawing silver lines along the edge of the cloak while casting long, twisted shadows behind them. Below the platform, the perfect reflection of the moon on the dark, choppy lake surface was violently shattered into a thousand glittering, dancing fragments, creating an unforgettable atmosphere of profound loneliness.", + "seed": 13295, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_1/index_9766_seed_13295_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.022097594663500787, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022097594663500787, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022097594663500787, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, black-and-white, dark anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender figure wearing a heavy, pure black cloak with a hood that obscures their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady tracking shot at eye level following the figure past a desolate moon-viewing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single brilliant white full moon in a solid black, cloudless sky, casting long shadows and silver highlights on the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the reflection of the moon on the dark, choppy lake surface below the platform shattered into glittering fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009979946538805962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.759979724884033 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009979946538805962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009979946538805962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17796443402767181, + 0.05287308990955353, + 0.20727013051509857, + 0.09791163355112076, + 0.04278142377734184, + 0.058736324310302734, + 0.06403551995754242, + 0.09675633162260056, + 0.0353909395635128, + 0.16628018021583557 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009979946538805962 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, black-and-white, dark anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender figure wearing a heavy, pure black cloak with a hood that obscures their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady tracking shot at eye level following the figure past a desolate moon-viewing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single brilliant white full moon in a solid black, cloudless sky, casting long shadows and silver highlights on the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the reflection of the moon on the dark, choppy lake surface below the platform shattered into glittering fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06209971010684967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120996952056885 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06209971010684967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06209971010684967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19621048867702484, + 0.0751534178853035, + 0.14595533907413483, + 0.11583645641803741, + 0.04008094221353531, + 0.034660469740629196, + 0.052402313798666, + 0.10713885724544525, + 0.08299017697572708, + 0.14957156777381897 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06209971010684967 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, black-and-white, dark anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender figure wearing a heavy, pure black cloak with a hood that obscures their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady tracking shot at eye level following the figure past a desolate moon-viewing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single brilliant white full moon in a solid black, cloudless sky, casting long shadows and silver highlights on the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the reflection of the moon on the dark, choppy lake surface below the platform shattered into glittering fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020586861297488213 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955869674682617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020586861297488213, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020586861297488213, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11309321969747543, + 0.03402692452073097, + 0.10556627810001373, + 0.07732895761728287, + 0.18431320786476135, + 0.0822470560669899, + 0.08564621955156326, + 0.051883943378925323, + 0.10252021253108978, + 0.1633739471435547 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020586861297488213 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, black-and-white, dark anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender figure wearing a heavy, pure black cloak with a hood that obscures their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady tracking shot at eye level following the figure past a desolate moon-viewing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single brilliant white full moon in a solid black, cloudless sky, casting long shadows and silver highlights on the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the reflection of the moon on the dark, choppy lake surface below the platform shattered into glittering fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006743649020791054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006743431091309 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006743649020791054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006743649020791054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2213781625032425, + 0.1374378800392151, + 0.0713951513171196, + 0.10198353976011276, + 0.08997441083192825, + 0.06601021438837051, + 0.09179572761058807, + 0.0690436139702797, + 0.0531194806098938, + 0.09786177426576614 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006743649020791054 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a high-contrast, black-and-white, dark anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender figure wearing a heavy, pure black cloak with a hood that obscures their features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, steady tracking shot at eye level following the figure past a desolate moon-viewing platform?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a single brilliant white full moon in a solid black, cloudless sky, casting long shadows and silver highlights on the figure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the reflection of the moon on the dark, choppy lake surface below the platform shattered into glittering fragments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107780635356903 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511077880859375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107780635356903, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107780635356903, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04941105097532272, + 0.03556352108716965, + 0.05113760381937027, + 0.022755563259124756, + 0.0473114550113678, + 0.03149929270148277, + 0.04006224125623703, + 0.054611653089523315, + 0.09693152457475662, + 0.5707160830497742 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107780635356903 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_10/index_tensor([9018, 9018])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_10/index_tensor([9018, 9018])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..35fde01e3af257d31c0a3eae793ad721c9ea59a8 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_10/index_tensor([9018, 9018])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a darkly Eastern fantasy, a low-angle, medium-long shot, shot upward from the turbulent river, slowly and steadily zooms in on the subject, capturing the half-human, half-snake form of Kiyohime in a central, devastating pose. Her soaked, tattered white garment clings to her human upper body, creating a stark and stark visual contrast with the massive, inky-black scales that extend from the waist down. Each damp scale reflects a cold, obsidian-like luster under the gloomy sky, while every fiber of the tattered white garment, rendered transparent by the water, flutters desperately in the wind. Her pale face is contorted with utter agony and rage, her long, dark hair dancing wildly in the wind, obscuring her eyes that shone with an inhuman coldness. Her serpentine tail churns and slaps the murky river water with thunderous force, stirring up a series of all-consuming, monstrous waves. The murky yellow crests rise skyward, transforming into a misty haze. The entire scene is shrouded in the oppressive atmosphere before a storm, with dark clouds and dim light, only the splashing water droplets and the reflections of her scales bring a sharp flicker. The exquisitely detailed 8K high-definition digital video vividly depicts a magnificent moment of destructive power and endless despair.", + "seed": 13357, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_10/index_9018_seed_13357_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.010401568445377051, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010401568445377051, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010401568445377051, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a half-human, half-snake form resembling Kiyohime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a soaked, tattered white garment on her upper body with massive inky-black scales extending from the waist down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character's face contorted with agony and rage, with long dark hair obscuring eyes that appear cold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the serpentine tail churning and slapping the murky river water to create large, misty waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, medium-long shot shot upward from the river with a slow, steady zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02698262222111225 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651982545852661 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02698262222111225, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02698262222111225, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10795252025127411, + 0.11103736609220505, + 0.047380149364471436, + 0.059573184698820114, + 0.1765022873878479, + 0.0484810508787632, + 0.27224308252334595, + 0.05710204318165779, + 0.03915661945939064, + 0.08057165890932083 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02698262222111225 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a half-human, half-snake form resembling Kiyohime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a soaked, tattered white garment on her upper body with massive inky-black scales extending from the waist down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character's face contorted with agony and rage, with long dark hair obscuring eyes that appear cold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the serpentine tail churning and slapping the murky river water to create large, misty waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, medium-long shot shot upward from the river with a slow, steady zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011937642702832818 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751194000244141 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011937642702832818, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011937642702832818, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06758861988782883, + 0.06639315187931061, + 0.04949736222624779, + 0.04611169174313545, + 0.41644802689552307, + 0.0393390916287899, + 0.1776789277791977, + 0.025297220796346664, + 0.04359162598848343, + 0.06805434077978134 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011937642702832818 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a half-human, half-snake form resembling Kiyohime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a soaked, tattered white garment on her upper body with massive inky-black scales extending from the waist down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character's face contorted with agony and rage, with long dark hair obscuring eyes that appear cold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the serpentine tail churning and slapping the murky river water to create large, misty waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, medium-long shot shot upward from the river with a slow, steady zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002824367256835103 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877824306488037 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002824367256835103, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002824367256835103, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10308137536048889, + 0.07109804451465607, + 0.10796265304088593, + 0.14762651920318604, + 0.20470492541790009, + 0.04446978494524956, + 0.15847885608673096, + 0.04799778014421463, + 0.023944715037941933, + 0.09063532203435898 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002824367256835103 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a half-human, half-snake form resembling Kiyohime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a soaked, tattered white garment on her upper body with massive inky-black scales extending from the waist down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character's face contorted with agony and rage, with long dark hair obscuring eyes that appear cold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the serpentine tail churning and slapping the murky river water to create large, misty waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, medium-long shot shot upward from the river with a slow, steady zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.000436925794929266 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.750436782836914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.000436925794929266, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.000436925794929266, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12398838251829147, + 0.03100762702524662, + 0.02812208980321884, + 0.033712971955537796, + 0.4986945688724518, + 0.027200568467378616, + 0.05511878803372383, + 0.08955860137939453, + 0.028016412630677223, + 0.08458002656698227 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.000436925794929266 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a half-human, half-snake form resembling Kiyohime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a soaked, tattered white garment on her upper body with massive inky-black scales extending from the waist down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character's face contorted with agony and rage, with long dark hair obscuring eyes that appear cold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the serpentine tail churning and slapping the murky river water to create large, misty waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, medium-long shot shot upward from the river with a slow, steady zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020570162683725357 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955702781677246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020570162683725357, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020570162683725357, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12376978993415833, + 0.08718061447143555, + 0.0755598172545433, + 0.07440183311700821, + 0.2356492280960083, + 0.09881408512592316, + 0.12125059962272644, + 0.0775017961859703, + 0.05960468202829361, + 0.04626750573515892 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020570162683725357 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a darkly Eastern fantasy, a low-angle, medium-long shot, shot upward from the turbulent river, slowly and steadily zooms in on the subject, capturing the half-human, half-snake form of Kiyohime in a central, devastating pose. Her soaked, tattered white garment clings to her human upper body, creating a stark and stark visual contrast with the massive, inky-black scales that extend from the waist down. Each damp scale reflects a cold, obsidian-like luster under the gloomy sky, while every fiber of the tattered white garment, rendered transparent by the water, flutters desperately in the wind. Her pale face is contorted with utter agony and rage, her long, dark hair dancing wildly in the wind, obscuring her eyes that shone with an inhuman coldness. Her serpentine tail churns and slaps the murky river water with thunderous force, stirring up a series of all-consuming, monstrous waves. The murky yellow crests rise skyward, transforming into a misty haze. The entire scene is shrouded in the oppressive atmosphere before a storm, with dark clouds and dim light, only the splashing water droplets and the reflections of her scales bring a sharp flicker. The exquisitely detailed 8K high-definition digital video vividly depicts a magnificent moment of destructive power and endless despair.", + "seed": 13358, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_10/index_9018_seed_13358_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.011015859595499933, + "vlm_logprob": -0.011015859595499933, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.011015859595499933, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a half-human, half-snake form resembling Kiyohime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a soaked, tattered white garment on her upper body with massive inky-black scales extending from the waist down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character's face contorted with agony and rage, with long dark hair obscuring eyes that appear cold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the serpentine tail churning and slapping the murky river water to create large, misty waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, medium-long shot shot upward from the river with a slow, steady zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02150491625070572 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8965048789978027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02150491625070572, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02150491625070572, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20552153885364532, + 0.12386985123157501, + 0.0494229756295681, + 0.052375681698322296, + 0.1089458093047142, + 0.09631645679473877, + 0.08475373685359955, + 0.042207393795251846, + 0.13790611922740936, + 0.09868038445711136 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02150491625070572 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a half-human, half-snake form resembling Kiyohime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a soaked, tattered white garment on her upper body with massive inky-black scales extending from the waist down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character's face contorted with agony and rage, with long dark hair obscuring eyes that appear cold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the serpentine tail churning and slapping the murky river water to create large, misty waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, medium-long shot shot upward from the river with a slow, steady zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013496108585968614 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626349449157715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013496108585968614, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013496108585968614, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17326100170612335, + 0.15439876914024353, + 0.056272491812705994, + 0.06845614314079285, + 0.13663773238658905, + 0.07393363118171692, + 0.06693190336227417, + 0.05116705968976021, + 0.11200182884931564, + 0.10693944245576859 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013496108585968614 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a half-human, half-snake form resembling Kiyohime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a soaked, tattered white garment on her upper body with massive inky-black scales extending from the waist down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character's face contorted with agony and rage, with long dark hair obscuring eyes that appear cold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the serpentine tail churning and slapping the murky river water to create large, misty waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, medium-long shot shot upward from the river with a slow, steady zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052567594684660435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255256652832031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052567594684660435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052567594684660435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20902924239635468, + 0.10686694085597992, + 0.04484608769416809, + 0.052848801016807556, + 0.14317309856414795, + 0.08279617130756378, + 0.05412917211651802, + 0.06442906707525253, + 0.1238742545247078, + 0.11800715327262878 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052567594684660435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a half-human, half-snake form resembling Kiyohime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a soaked, tattered white garment on her upper body with massive inky-black scales extending from the waist down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character's face contorted with agony and rage, with long dark hair obscuring eyes that appear cold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the serpentine tail churning and slapping the murky river water to create large, misty waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, medium-long shot shot upward from the river with a slow, steady zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0006345880683511496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.375634670257568 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0006345880683511496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0006345880683511496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06683845818042755, + 0.0546821691095829, + 0.019625771790742874, + 0.019562263041734695, + 0.36304688453674316, + 0.039857178926467896, + 0.09004530310630798, + 0.056365761905908585, + 0.2048916071653366, + 0.08508458733558655 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0006345880683511496 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a half-human, half-snake form resembling Kiyohime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a soaked, tattered white garment on her upper body with massive inky-black scales extending from the waist down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character's face contorted with agony and rage, with long dark hair obscuring eyes that appear cold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the serpentine tail churning and slapping the murky river water to create large, misty waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, medium-long shot shot upward from the river with a slow, steady zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02633342333137989 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513333320617676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02633342333137989, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02633342333137989, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12814626097679138, + 0.06864839047193527, + 0.036394111812114716, + 0.07931871712207794, + 0.19446104764938354, + 0.11695737391710281, + 0.10486795753240585, + 0.14544905722141266, + 0.052452731877565384, + 0.07330439984798431 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02633342333137989 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a darkly Eastern fantasy, a low-angle, medium-long shot, shot upward from the turbulent river, slowly and steadily zooms in on the subject, capturing the half-human, half-snake form of Kiyohime in a central, devastating pose. Her soaked, tattered white garment clings to her human upper body, creating a stark and stark visual contrast with the massive, inky-black scales that extend from the waist down. Each damp scale reflects a cold, obsidian-like luster under the gloomy sky, while every fiber of the tattered white garment, rendered transparent by the water, flutters desperately in the wind. Her pale face is contorted with utter agony and rage, her long, dark hair dancing wildly in the wind, obscuring her eyes that shone with an inhuman coldness. Her serpentine tail churns and slaps the murky river water with thunderous force, stirring up a series of all-consuming, monstrous waves. The murky yellow crests rise skyward, transforming into a misty haze. The entire scene is shrouded in the oppressive atmosphere before a storm, with dark clouds and dim light, only the splashing water droplets and the reflections of her scales bring a sharp flicker. The exquisitely detailed 8K high-definition digital video vividly depicts a magnificent moment of destructive power and endless despair.", + "seed": 13359, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_10/index_9018_seed_13359_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.016527351993136107, + "vlm_logprob": -0.016527351993136107, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.016527351993136107, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a half-human, half-snake form resembling Kiyohime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a soaked, tattered white garment on her upper body with massive inky-black scales extending from the waist down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character's face contorted with agony and rage, with long dark hair obscuring eyes that appear cold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the serpentine tail churning and slapping the murky river water to create large, misty waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, medium-long shot shot upward from the river with a slow, steady zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02826550230383873 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6532654762268066 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02826550230383873, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02826550230383873, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1430550515651703, + 0.07019228488206863, + 0.046912360936403275, + 0.23559929430484772, + 0.057834796607494354, + 0.08804864436388016, + 0.1361226886510849, + 0.023488415405154228, + 0.10278691351413727, + 0.09595951437950134 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02826550230383873 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a half-human, half-snake form resembling Kiyohime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a soaked, tattered white garment on her upper body with massive inky-black scales extending from the waist down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character's face contorted with agony and rage, with long dark hair obscuring eyes that appear cold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the serpentine tail churning and slapping the murky river water to create large, misty waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, medium-long shot shot upward from the river with a slow, steady zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0025118011981248856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002511978149414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0025118011981248856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0025118011981248856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19073963165283203, + 0.08178762346506119, + 0.03973783925175667, + 0.1673354208469391, + 0.061375051736831665, + 0.059261590242385864, + 0.14617031812667847, + 0.048068009316921234, + 0.1030353233218193, + 0.10248920321464539 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0025118011981248856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a half-human, half-snake form resembling Kiyohime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a soaked, tattered white garment on her upper body with massive inky-black scales extending from the waist down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character's face contorted with agony and rage, with long dark hair obscuring eyes that appear cold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the serpentine tail churning and slapping the murky river water to create large, misty waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, medium-long shot shot upward from the river with a slow, steady zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007638768292963505 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882638931274414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007638768292963505, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007638768292963505, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32574254274368286, + 0.03842609375715256, + 0.04148319736123085, + 0.08568312972784042, + 0.048001352697610855, + 0.25006285309791565, + 0.03814706578850746, + 0.012236161157488823, + 0.05801967903971672, + 0.10219800472259521 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007638768292963505 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a half-human, half-snake form resembling Kiyohime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a soaked, tattered white garment on her upper body with massive inky-black scales extending from the waist down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character's face contorted with agony and rage, with long dark hair obscuring eyes that appear cold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the serpentine tail churning and slapping the murky river water to create large, misty waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, medium-long shot shot upward from the river with a slow, steady zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011813811725005507 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751181602478027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011813811725005507, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011813811725005507, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.018209686502814293, + 0.04150213301181793, + 0.011147365905344486, + 0.09496042132377625, + 0.024423809722065926, + 0.17570285499095917, + 0.5094294548034668, + 0.02381792850792408, + 0.04519141465425491, + 0.05561501905322075 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011813811725005507 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a half-human, half-snake form resembling Kiyohime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a soaked, tattered white garment on her upper body with massive inky-black scales extending from the waist down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character's face contorted with agony and rage, with long dark hair obscuring eyes that appear cold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the serpentine tail churning and slapping the murky river water to create large, misty waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, medium-long shot shot upward from the river with a slow, steady zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04303930699825287 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168039321899414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04303930699825287, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04303930699825287, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08439439535140991, + 0.06332530826330185, + 0.03669709712266922, + 0.1403886079788208, + 0.04786192998290062, + 0.1490478366613388, + 0.19243186712265015, + 0.05928771197795868, + 0.09154526144266129, + 0.13502000272274017 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04303930699825287 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a darkly Eastern fantasy, a low-angle, medium-long shot, shot upward from the turbulent river, slowly and steadily zooms in on the subject, capturing the half-human, half-snake form of Kiyohime in a central, devastating pose. Her soaked, tattered white garment clings to her human upper body, creating a stark and stark visual contrast with the massive, inky-black scales that extend from the waist down. Each damp scale reflects a cold, obsidian-like luster under the gloomy sky, while every fiber of the tattered white garment, rendered transparent by the water, flutters desperately in the wind. Her pale face is contorted with utter agony and rage, her long, dark hair dancing wildly in the wind, obscuring her eyes that shone with an inhuman coldness. Her serpentine tail churns and slaps the murky river water with thunderous force, stirring up a series of all-consuming, monstrous waves. The murky yellow crests rise skyward, transforming into a misty haze. The entire scene is shrouded in the oppressive atmosphere before a storm, with dark clouds and dim light, only the splashing water droplets and the reflections of her scales bring a sharp flicker. The exquisitely detailed 8K high-definition digital video vividly depicts a magnificent moment of destructive power and endless despair.", + "seed": 13360, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_10/index_9018_seed_13360_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.012752746295882389, + "vlm_logprob": -0.012752746295882389, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.012752746295882389, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a half-human, half-snake form resembling Kiyohime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a soaked, tattered white garment on her upper body with massive inky-black scales extending from the waist down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character's face contorted with agony and rage, with long dark hair obscuring eyes that appear cold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the serpentine tail churning and slapping the murky river water to create large, misty waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, medium-long shot shot upward from the river with a slow, steady zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.027377065271139145 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.652377128601074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.027377065271139145, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.027377065271139145, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6175599694252014, + 0.18928907811641693, + 0.029546311125159264, + 0.023700611665844917, + 0.016861269250512123, + 0.00800714548677206, + 0.036485254764556885, + 0.019664332270622253, + 0.021186919882893562, + 0.03769905865192413 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.027377065271139145 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a half-human, half-snake form resembling Kiyohime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a soaked, tattered white garment on her upper body with massive inky-black scales extending from the waist down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character's face contorted with agony and rage, with long dark hair obscuring eyes that appear cold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the serpentine tail churning and slapping the murky river water to create large, misty waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, medium-long shot shot upward from the river with a slow, steady zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001527334563434124 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501527309417725 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001527334563434124, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001527334563434124, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4435882270336151, + 0.08820859342813492, + 0.053740259259939194, + 0.09599077701568604, + 0.02924639917910099, + 0.03778810799121857, + 0.05106308311223984, + 0.04772398993372917, + 0.08342169970273972, + 0.06922886520624161 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001527334563434124 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a half-human, half-snake form resembling Kiyohime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a soaked, tattered white garment on her upper body with massive inky-black scales extending from the waist down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character's face contorted with agony and rage, with long dark hair obscuring eyes that appear cold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the serpentine tail churning and slapping the murky river water to create large, misty waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, medium-long shot shot upward from the river with a slow, steady zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004640998784452677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379641056060791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004640998784452677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004640998784452677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.44514867663383484, + 0.05119192227721214, + 0.03916432335972786, + 0.1507197916507721, + 0.03768463805317879, + 0.022275997325778008, + 0.05090095475316048, + 0.054111186414957047, + 0.09992210566997528, + 0.04888041317462921 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004640998784452677 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a half-human, half-snake form resembling Kiyohime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a soaked, tattered white garment on her upper body with massive inky-black scales extending from the waist down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character's face contorted with agony and rage, with long dark hair obscuring eyes that appear cold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the serpentine tail churning and slapping the murky river water to create large, misty waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, medium-long shot shot upward from the river with a slow, steady zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0004362108593340963 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.750436305999756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0004362108593340963, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0004362108593340963, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3734318017959595, + 0.21737821400165558, + 0.024748070165514946, + 0.04924633726477623, + 0.030408406630158424, + 0.03148030862212181, + 0.020703407004475594, + 0.09357379376888275, + 0.06969838589429855, + 0.08933136612176895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0004362108593340963 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a half-human, half-snake form resembling Kiyohime?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing a soaked, tattered white garment on her upper body with massive inky-black scales extending from the waist down?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character's face contorted with agony and rage, with long dark hair obscuring eyes that appear cold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the serpentine tail churning and slapping the murky river water to create large, misty waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, medium-long shot shot upward from the river with a slow, steady zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029782122001051903 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297820568084717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029782122001051903, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029782122001051903, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4006291925907135, + 0.28440847992897034, + 0.04243451729416847, + 0.08321314305067062, + 0.016507159918546677, + 0.017968226224184036, + 0.04968424513936043, + 0.03440388664603233, + 0.052415866404771805, + 0.018335258588194847 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029782122001051903 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_11/index_tensor([2038, 2038])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_11/index_tensor([2038, 2038])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..04a233c4cddde63a90b811de3033b2e57cea185a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_11/index_tensor([2038, 2038])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a photorealistic documentary-style shot, the camera slowly zooms in from a low, ground-level perspective, creating an unsettling sense of oppression as it confronts the prehistoric Titanoboa. The beast, defensive against an unknown, off-screen threat, its massive, tree-like frame coiled like a muscular rampart against the damp, primeval jungle floor, a backdrop of ancient ferns blotting out the sun, their massive fronds drooping like palms. Dappled sunlight filtering through the dense forest canopy casts shifting patterns across its form, highlighting each shimmering scale in the stunning 8K ultra-high-definition quality. These scales, a deep olive green and earthy brown with an iridescent sheen, resemble tiny shields, each one adorned with glistening dewdrops. Its huge head is raised high, facing the camera, a pair of ruthless, amber-glittering reptilian eyes are fixed on the threat, and the huge jaws suddenly open, and a low and intimidating roar is emitted. The sound waves seem to vibrate the surrounding air and make the nearby fern leaves tremble slightly. The whole scene is full of primitive, tense confrontation atmosphere and awe-inspiring biological power.", + "seed": 12402, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_11/index_2038_seed_12402_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.23620159644633532, + "vlm_logprob": -0.23620159644633532, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.23620159644633532, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a prehistoric Titanoboa with a massive, tree-like frame coiled on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's scales deep olive green and earthy brown with an iridescent sheen and glistening dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snake's huge head raised high facing the camera with amber-glittering reptilian eyes and suddenly open jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a damp primeval jungle floor with ancient ferns blotting out the sun and dappled sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in from a low, ground-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0548443794250488 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42984437942504883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0548443794250488, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0548443794250488, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20168812572956085, + 0.03345232829451561, + 0.07189101725816727, + 0.1185845136642456, + 0.1738433837890625, + 0.06864584982395172, + 0.049880772829055786, + 0.08146747201681137, + 0.025211535394191742, + 0.17533506453037262 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0548443794250488 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a prehistoric Titanoboa with a massive, tree-like frame coiled on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's scales deep olive green and earthy brown with an iridescent sheen and glistening dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snake's huge head raised high facing the camera with amber-glittering reptilian eyes and suddenly open jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a damp primeval jungle floor with ancient ferns blotting out the sun and dappled sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in from a low, ground-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02985316701233387 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529853105545044 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02985316701233387, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02985316701233387, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2826352119445801, + 0.0648924931883812, + 0.06542138755321503, + 0.0784209817647934, + 0.14227163791656494, + 0.09614027291536331, + 0.05715285241603851, + 0.051810938864946365, + 0.02106410451233387, + 0.14019007980823517 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02985316701233387 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a prehistoric Titanoboa with a massive, tree-like frame coiled on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's scales deep olive green and earthy brown with an iridescent sheen and glistening dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snake's huge head raised high facing the camera with amber-glittering reptilian eyes and suddenly open jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a damp primeval jungle floor with ancient ferns blotting out the sun and dappled sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in from a low, ground-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0549890510737896 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299890995025635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0549890510737896, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0549890510737896, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10595505684614182, + 0.05501898005604744, + 0.07571541517972946, + 0.050149161368608475, + 0.18487389385700226, + 0.05893854796886444, + 0.05757034569978714, + 0.07195828855037689, + 0.0725172609090805, + 0.26730307936668396 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0549890510737896 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a prehistoric Titanoboa with a massive, tree-like frame coiled on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's scales deep olive green and earthy brown with an iridescent sheen and glistening dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snake's huge head raised high facing the camera with amber-glittering reptilian eyes and suddenly open jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a damp primeval jungle floor with ancient ferns blotting out the sun and dappled sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in from a low, ground-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007632735185325146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882632732391357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007632735185325146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007632735185325146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42543500661849976, + 0.03797587752342224, + 0.036192480474710464, + 0.10131394118070602, + 0.07439209520816803, + 0.02012297324836254, + 0.048122454434633255, + 0.08949333429336548, + 0.028780581429600716, + 0.1381712555885315 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007632735185325146 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a prehistoric Titanoboa with a massive, tree-like frame coiled on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's scales deep olive green and earthy brown with an iridescent sheen and glistening dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snake's huge head raised high facing the camera with amber-glittering reptilian eyes and suddenly open jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a damp primeval jungle floor with ancient ferns blotting out the sun and dappled sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in from a low, ground-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368864953517914 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408688545227051 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368864953517914, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368864953517914, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40729162096977234, + 0.05745600908994675, + 0.08157281577587128, + 0.06891664117574692, + 0.08964023739099503, + 0.08035259693861008, + 0.060646072030067444, + 0.022447317838668823, + 0.07199687510728836, + 0.059679899364709854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368864953517914 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a photorealistic documentary-style shot, the camera slowly zooms in from a low, ground-level perspective, creating an unsettling sense of oppression as it confronts the prehistoric Titanoboa. The beast, defensive against an unknown, off-screen threat, its massive, tree-like frame coiled like a muscular rampart against the damp, primeval jungle floor, a backdrop of ancient ferns blotting out the sun, their massive fronds drooping like palms. Dappled sunlight filtering through the dense forest canopy casts shifting patterns across its form, highlighting each shimmering scale in the stunning 8K ultra-high-definition quality. These scales, a deep olive green and earthy brown with an iridescent sheen, resemble tiny shields, each one adorned with glistening dewdrops. Its huge head is raised high, facing the camera, a pair of ruthless, amber-glittering reptilian eyes are fixed on the threat, and the huge jaws suddenly open, and a low and intimidating roar is emitted. The sound waves seem to vibrate the surrounding air and make the nearby fern leaves tremble slightly. The whole scene is full of primitive, tense confrontation atmosphere and awe-inspiring biological power.", + "seed": 12403, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_11/index_2038_seed_12403_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02186125610023737, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02186125610023737, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02186125610023737, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a prehistoric Titanoboa with a massive, tree-like frame coiled on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's scales deep olive green and earthy brown with an iridescent sheen and glistening dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snake's huge head raised high facing the camera with amber-glittering reptilian eyes and suddenly open jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a damp primeval jungle floor with ancient ferns blotting out the sun and dappled sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in from a low, ground-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06293085962533951 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8129308223724365 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06293085962533951, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06293085962533951, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06545141339302063, + 0.01789328269660473, + 0.012806860730051994, + 0.02589527517557144, + 0.031169705092906952, + 0.037448104470968246, + 0.022478308528661728, + 0.11355720460414886, + 0.24180613458156586, + 0.43149369955062866 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06293085962533951 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a prehistoric Titanoboa with a massive, tree-like frame coiled on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's scales deep olive green and earthy brown with an iridescent sheen and glistening dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snake's huge head raised high facing the camera with amber-glittering reptilian eyes and suddenly open jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a damp primeval jungle floor with ancient ferns blotting out the sun and dappled sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in from a low, ground-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016082679852843285 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141082763671875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016082679852843285, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016082679852843285, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13965058326721191, + 0.08510977774858475, + 0.06359497457742691, + 0.0564541257917881, + 0.03966602683067322, + 0.05724579840898514, + 0.04819177836179733, + 0.05677112191915512, + 0.25267696380615234, + 0.2006388008594513 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016082679852843285 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a prehistoric Titanoboa with a massive, tree-like frame coiled on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's scales deep olive green and earthy brown with an iridescent sheen and glistening dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snake's huge head raised high facing the camera with amber-glittering reptilian eyes and suddenly open jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a damp primeval jungle floor with ancient ferns blotting out the sun and dappled sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in from a low, ground-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107992883771658 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511079788208008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107992883771658, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107992883771658, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05375239625573158, + 0.028140651062130928, + 0.02984338253736496, + 0.043710172176361084, + 0.0613165982067585, + 0.08569258451461792, + 0.07001134753227234, + 0.1261349618434906, + 0.4460636079311371, + 0.05533428117632866 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107992883771658 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a prehistoric Titanoboa with a massive, tree-like frame coiled on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's scales deep olive green and earthy brown with an iridescent sheen and glistening dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snake's huge head raised high facing the camera with amber-glittering reptilian eyes and suddenly open jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a damp primeval jungle floor with ancient ferns blotting out the sun and dappled sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in from a low, ground-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001039203256368637 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876039028167725 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001039203256368637, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001039203256368637, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18499699234962463, + 0.036567557603120804, + 0.02626548893749714, + 0.02927391789853573, + 0.07623874396085739, + 0.08265908062458038, + 0.07387645542621613, + 0.06500811874866486, + 0.14708811044692993, + 0.2780255973339081 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001039203256368637 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a prehistoric Titanoboa with a massive, tree-like frame coiled on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's scales deep olive green and earthy brown with an iridescent sheen and glistening dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snake's huge head raised high facing the camera with amber-glittering reptilian eyes and suddenly open jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a damp primeval jungle floor with ancient ferns blotting out the sun and dappled sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in from a low, ground-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01817360892891884 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018173694610596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01817360892891884, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01817360892891884, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08199714124202728, + 0.040776174515485764, + 0.03898294270038605, + 0.17619693279266357, + 0.09069263190031052, + 0.08787628263235092, + 0.04402751103043556, + 0.19109775125980377, + 0.18927575647830963, + 0.05907683074474335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01817360892891884 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a photorealistic documentary-style shot, the camera slowly zooms in from a low, ground-level perspective, creating an unsettling sense of oppression as it confronts the prehistoric Titanoboa. The beast, defensive against an unknown, off-screen threat, its massive, tree-like frame coiled like a muscular rampart against the damp, primeval jungle floor, a backdrop of ancient ferns blotting out the sun, their massive fronds drooping like palms. Dappled sunlight filtering through the dense forest canopy casts shifting patterns across its form, highlighting each shimmering scale in the stunning 8K ultra-high-definition quality. These scales, a deep olive green and earthy brown with an iridescent sheen, resemble tiny shields, each one adorned with glistening dewdrops. Its huge head is raised high, facing the camera, a pair of ruthless, amber-glittering reptilian eyes are fixed on the threat, and the huge jaws suddenly open, and a low and intimidating roar is emitted. The sound waves seem to vibrate the surrounding air and make the nearby fern leaves tremble slightly. The whole scene is full of primitive, tense confrontation atmosphere and awe-inspiring biological power.", + "seed": 12404, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_11/index_2038_seed_12404_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05809128291439265, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05809128291439265, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05809128291439265, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a prehistoric Titanoboa with a massive, tree-like frame coiled on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's scales deep olive green and earthy brown with an iridescent sheen and glistening dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snake's huge head raised high facing the camera with amber-glittering reptilian eyes and suddenly open jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a damp primeval jungle floor with ancient ferns blotting out the sun and dappled sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in from a low, ground-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10144858807325363 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3514485359191895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10144858807325363, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10144858807325363, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25888770818710327, + 0.14750035107135773, + 0.06995834410190582, + 0.10600277036428452, + 0.03562355041503906, + 0.15659013390541077, + 0.07634849846363068, + 0.048604656010866165, + 0.049236420542001724, + 0.05124756693840027 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10144858807325363 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a prehistoric Titanoboa with a massive, tree-like frame coiled on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's scales deep olive green and earthy brown with an iridescent sheen and glistening dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snake's huge head raised high facing the camera with amber-glittering reptilian eyes and suddenly open jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a damp primeval jungle floor with ancient ferns blotting out the sun and dappled sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in from a low, ground-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026373015716671944 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513729095458984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026373015716671944, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026373015716671944, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22117893397808075, + 0.14564859867095947, + 0.08772602677345276, + 0.13875459134578705, + 0.1155833974480629, + 0.09755194187164307, + 0.04612386226654053, + 0.04432995989918709, + 0.056489042937755585, + 0.04661373049020767 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026373015716671944 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a prehistoric Titanoboa with a massive, tree-like frame coiled on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's scales deep olive green and earthy brown with an iridescent sheen and glistening dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snake's huge head raised high facing the camera with amber-glittering reptilian eyes and suddenly open jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a damp primeval jungle floor with ancient ferns blotting out the sun and dappled sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in from a low, ground-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11295609176158905 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379560470581055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11295609176158905, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11295609176158905, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20531293749809265, + 0.14946672320365906, + 0.057527899742126465, + 0.08925506472587585, + 0.04152771458029747, + 0.13530568778514862, + 0.12681499123573303, + 0.0480831116437912, + 0.06844630092382431, + 0.07825957983732224 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11295609176158905 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a prehistoric Titanoboa with a massive, tree-like frame coiled on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's scales deep olive green and earthy brown with an iridescent sheen and glistening dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snake's huge head raised high facing the camera with amber-glittering reptilian eyes and suddenly open jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a damp primeval jungle floor with ancient ferns blotting out the sun and dappled sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in from a low, ground-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010406322544440627 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876040458679199 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010406322544440627, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010406322544440627, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3762294352054596, + 0.14437177777290344, + 0.09239094704389572, + 0.04228935390710831, + 0.07020678371191025, + 0.09539536386728287, + 0.058100949972867966, + 0.030826982110738754, + 0.058543525636196136, + 0.031644877046346664 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010406322544440627 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a prehistoric Titanoboa with a massive, tree-like frame coiled on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's scales deep olive green and earthy brown with an iridescent sheen and glistening dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snake's huge head raised high facing the camera with amber-glittering reptilian eyes and suddenly open jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a damp primeval jungle floor with ancient ferns blotting out the sun and dappled sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in from a low, ground-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04863808676600456 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048638105392456 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04863808676600456, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04863808676600456, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35974955558776855, + 0.17473967373371124, + 0.037137582898139954, + 0.09210142493247986, + 0.05144686996936798, + 0.06377022713422775, + 0.05102970823645592, + 0.08760466426610947, + 0.051982175558805466, + 0.030438048765063286 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04863808676600456 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a photorealistic documentary-style shot, the camera slowly zooms in from a low, ground-level perspective, creating an unsettling sense of oppression as it confronts the prehistoric Titanoboa. The beast, defensive against an unknown, off-screen threat, its massive, tree-like frame coiled like a muscular rampart against the damp, primeval jungle floor, a backdrop of ancient ferns blotting out the sun, their massive fronds drooping like palms. Dappled sunlight filtering through the dense forest canopy casts shifting patterns across its form, highlighting each shimmering scale in the stunning 8K ultra-high-definition quality. These scales, a deep olive green and earthy brown with an iridescent sheen, resemble tiny shields, each one adorned with glistening dewdrops. Its huge head is raised high, facing the camera, a pair of ruthless, amber-glittering reptilian eyes are fixed on the threat, and the huge jaws suddenly open, and a low and intimidating roar is emitted. The sound waves seem to vibrate the surrounding air and make the nearby fern leaves tremble slightly. The whole scene is full of primitive, tense confrontation atmosphere and awe-inspiring biological power.", + "seed": 12405, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_11/index_2038_seed_12405_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10414078263565898, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10414078263565898, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10414078263565898, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a prehistoric Titanoboa with a massive, tree-like frame coiled on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's scales deep olive green and earthy brown with an iridescent sheen and glistening dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snake's huge head raised high facing the camera with amber-glittering reptilian eyes and suddenly open jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a damp primeval jungle floor with ancient ferns blotting out the sun and dappled sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in from a low, ground-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4300107955932617 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0550107955932617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4300107955932617, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4300107955932617, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09280500560998917, + 0.05478624999523163, + 0.028022099286317825, + 0.06275548785924911, + 0.09050224721431732, + 0.062244076281785965, + 0.22007720172405243, + 0.10770030319690704, + 0.21964026987552643, + 0.0614670068025589 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4300107955932617 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a prehistoric Titanoboa with a massive, tree-like frame coiled on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's scales deep olive green and earthy brown with an iridescent sheen and glistening dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snake's huge head raised high facing the camera with amber-glittering reptilian eyes and suddenly open jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a damp primeval jungle floor with ancient ferns blotting out the sun and dappled sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in from a low, ground-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029825512319803238 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529825448989868 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029825512319803238, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029825512319803238, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.45323655009269714, + 0.04033035784959793, + 0.019232740625739098, + 0.05509880930185318, + 0.04972642660140991, + 0.04052610695362091, + 0.12940311431884766, + 0.10590042173862457, + 0.05794261768460274, + 0.0486028827726841 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029825512319803238 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a prehistoric Titanoboa with a massive, tree-like frame coiled on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's scales deep olive green and earthy brown with an iridescent sheen and glistening dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snake's huge head raised high facing the camera with amber-glittering reptilian eyes and suddenly open jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a damp primeval jungle floor with ancient ferns blotting out the sun and dappled sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in from a low, ground-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059200033545494 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895591974258423 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059200033545494, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059200033545494, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2957846224308014, + 0.03638236224651337, + 0.04924951121211052, + 0.05393298342823982, + 0.11544492095708847, + 0.12281329929828644, + 0.15625359117984772, + 0.04688074439764023, + 0.05246235430240631, + 0.07079558074474335 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059200033545494 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a prehistoric Titanoboa with a massive, tree-like frame coiled on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's scales deep olive green and earthy brown with an iridescent sheen and glistening dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snake's huge head raised high facing the camera with amber-glittering reptilian eyes and suddenly open jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a damp primeval jungle floor with ancient ferns blotting out the sun and dappled sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in from a low, ground-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021941415034234524 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127193927764893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021941415034234524, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021941415034234524, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5585994124412537, + 0.06307949125766754, + 0.018013767898082733, + 0.029130354523658752, + 0.046338021755218506, + 0.0353742390871048, + 0.0946202352643013, + 0.07984503358602524, + 0.059183117002248764, + 0.015816353261470795 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021941415034234524 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a prehistoric Titanoboa with a massive, tree-like frame coiled on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the snake's scales deep olive green and earthy brown with an iridescent sheen and glistening dewdrops?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the snake's huge head raised high facing the camera with amber-glittering reptilian eyes and suddenly open jaws?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a damp primeval jungle floor with ancient ferns blotting out the sun and dappled sunlight filtering through the canopy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom in from a low, ground-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03808146342635155 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288081407546997 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03808146342635155, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03808146342635155, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1500343680381775, + 0.08686622977256775, + 0.08454165607690811, + 0.13728755712509155, + 0.15465818345546722, + 0.17462150752544403, + 0.08205658942461014, + 0.06232386454939842, + 0.019596800208091736, + 0.048013247549533844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03808146342635155 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_12/index_tensor([9653, 9653])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_12/index_tensor([9653, 9653])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..31b706d6e556ee6a578081c204c5257a424e7921 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_12/index_tensor([9653, 9653])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, doll-like shot begins, steadily progressing from a medium shot to a medium close-up at eye level, focusing entirely on a young Southeast Asian man standing in a dimly lit room. He has thick, slightly tousled black hair and sharp features. His jaw is clenched, a muscle in his cheek visibly pulses, and his dark, expressive eyes nervously shift from side to side, scanning the invisible space around him. He wears a simple, fitted charcoal-gray cotton T-shirt. As the camera moves closer, he quickly raises one hand, fingers spread, and anxiously runs it through his hair in a repetitive, self-soothing gesture. The scene is illuminated by a warm, off-camera light source, which carves his face out of the darkness, accentuating the subtle sheen of sweat on his forehead and casting the other side into deep, dramatic shadow against a plain, out-of-focus wall. The deliberate camera movement and stark, low-key lighting echo his agitated state, creating an atmosphere of claustrophobia and intense suspense, drawing the viewer directly into the moment of private turmoil.", + "seed": 1589, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_12/index_9653_seed_1589_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.10501079759560525, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10501079759560525, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10501079759560525, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young Southeast Asian man with thick, slightly tousled black hair and sharp features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, fitted charcoal-gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform the action of raising one hand with fingers spread to run it through his hair in a repetitive, self-soothing gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm, off-camera light source that creates deep shadows on one side of the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily progress from a medium shot to a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20340795814990997 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7034080028533936 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20340795814990997, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20340795814990997, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06278800964355469, + 0.2589227855205536, + 0.02378065697848797, + 0.12889885902404785, + 0.037456028163433075, + 0.020382177084684372, + 0.04131946712732315, + 0.23820504546165466, + 0.064181387424469, + 0.12406560778617859 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20340795814990997 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young Southeast Asian man with thick, slightly tousled black hair and sharp features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, fitted charcoal-gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform the action of raising one hand with fingers spread to run it through his hair in a repetitive, self-soothing gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm, off-camera light source that creates deep shadows on one side of the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily progress from a medium shot to a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25210127234458923 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021013021469116 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25210127234458923, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25210127234458923, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04386023432016373, + 0.23162385821342468, + 0.023586934432387352, + 0.09183328598737717, + 0.01768592931330204, + 0.036290910094976425, + 0.026914279907941818, + 0.29195186495780945, + 0.05961260572075844, + 0.17664001882076263 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25210127234458923 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young Southeast Asian man with thick, slightly tousled black hair and sharp features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, fitted charcoal-gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform the action of raising one hand with fingers spread to run it through his hair in a repetitive, self-soothing gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm, off-camera light source that creates deep shadows on one side of the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily progress from a medium shot to a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329809032380581 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732980251312256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329809032380581, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329809032380581, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06781159341335297, + 0.04433887451887131, + 0.06389015913009644, + 0.0771535336971283, + 0.0479423850774765, + 0.4580470621585846, + 0.041835132986307144, + 0.13744166493415833, + 0.0136494692414999, + 0.04789011925458908 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329809032380581 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young Southeast Asian man with thick, slightly tousled black hair and sharp features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, fitted charcoal-gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform the action of raising one hand with fingers spread to run it through his hair in a repetitive, self-soothing gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm, off-camera light source that creates deep shadows on one side of the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily progress from a medium shot to a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003194113029167056 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753194332122803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003194113029167056, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003194113029167056, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06312312930822372, + 0.4358845055103302, + 0.057546038180589676, + 0.11481963843107224, + 0.054804857820272446, + 0.1155586689710617, + 0.019517021253705025, + 0.041820790618658066, + 0.03268435597419739, + 0.06424103677272797 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003194113029167056 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young Southeast Asian man with thick, slightly tousled black hair and sharp features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, fitted charcoal-gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform the action of raising one hand with fingers spread to run it through his hair in a repetitive, self-soothing gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm, off-camera light source that creates deep shadows on one side of the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily progress from a medium shot to a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0430525541305542 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680526733398438 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0430525541305542, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0430525541305542, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06182527542114258, + 0.15055236220359802, + 0.03738785162568092, + 0.049941662698984146, + 0.018008580431342125, + 0.10748608410358429, + 0.0540730319917202, + 0.17999793589115143, + 0.284108966588974, + 0.056618303060531616 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0430525541305542 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, doll-like shot begins, steadily progressing from a medium shot to a medium close-up at eye level, focusing entirely on a young Southeast Asian man standing in a dimly lit room. He has thick, slightly tousled black hair and sharp features. His jaw is clenched, a muscle in his cheek visibly pulses, and his dark, expressive eyes nervously shift from side to side, scanning the invisible space around him. He wears a simple, fitted charcoal-gray cotton T-shirt. As the camera moves closer, he quickly raises one hand, fingers spread, and anxiously runs it through his hair in a repetitive, self-soothing gesture. The scene is illuminated by a warm, off-camera light source, which carves his face out of the darkness, accentuating the subtle sheen of sweat on his forehead and casting the other side into deep, dramatic shadow against a plain, out-of-focus wall. The deliberate camera movement and stark, low-key lighting echo his agitated state, creating an atmosphere of claustrophobia and intense suspense, drawing the viewer directly into the moment of private turmoil.", + "seed": 1590, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_12/index_9653_seed_1590_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02699832716025412, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02699832716025412, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02699832716025412, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young Southeast Asian man with thick, slightly tousled black hair and sharp features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, fitted charcoal-gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform the action of raising one hand with fingers spread to run it through his hair in a repetitive, self-soothing gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm, off-camera light source that creates deep shadows on one side of the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily progress from a medium shot to a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.053224507719278336 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.053224563598633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.053224507719278336, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.053224507719278336, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12588734924793243, + 0.09097829461097717, + 0.052836786955595016, + 0.11541184037923813, + 0.11706096678972244, + 0.06712673604488373, + 0.17657126486301422, + 0.06655515730381012, + 0.11361650377511978, + 0.07395509630441666 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.053224507719278336 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young Southeast Asian man with thick, slightly tousled black hair and sharp features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, fitted charcoal-gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform the action of raising one hand with fingers spread to run it through his hair in a repetitive, self-soothing gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm, off-camera light source that creates deep shadows on one side of the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily progress from a medium shot to a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020604144781827927 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895604133605957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020604144781827927, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020604144781827927, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09314321726560593, + 0.4169505536556244, + 0.1795893907546997, + 0.0542168989777565, + 0.11550095677375793, + 0.046295784413814545, + 0.01698235608637333, + 0.02721990831196308, + 0.022011322900652885, + 0.028089573606848717 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020604144781827927 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young Southeast Asian man with thick, slightly tousled black hair and sharp features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, fitted charcoal-gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform the action of raising one hand with fingers spread to run it through his hair in a repetitive, self-soothing gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm, off-camera light source that creates deep shadows on one side of the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily progress from a medium shot to a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020585928112268448 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955860137939453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020585928112268448, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020585928112268448, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06325995177030563, + 0.15625034272670746, + 0.07925617694854736, + 0.07771036028862, + 0.08747102320194244, + 0.06142358109354973, + 0.06478560715913773, + 0.20084917545318604, + 0.09908268600702286, + 0.10991102457046509 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020585928112268448 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young Southeast Asian man with thick, slightly tousled black hair and sharp features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, fitted charcoal-gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform the action of raising one hand with fingers spread to run it through his hair in a repetitive, self-soothing gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm, off-camera light source that creates deep shadows on one side of the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily progress from a medium shot to a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002491229446604848 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002490997314453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002491229446604848, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002491229446604848, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18223153054714203, + 0.06886618584394455, + 0.100813128054142, + 0.03592950850725174, + 0.056046582758426666, + 0.06314209848642349, + 0.029976148158311844, + 0.3399779200553894, + 0.05215681344270706, + 0.07086014747619629 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002491229446604848 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young Southeast Asian man with thick, slightly tousled black hair and sharp features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, fitted charcoal-gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform the action of raising one hand with fingers spread to run it through his hair in a repetitive, self-soothing gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm, off-camera light source that creates deep shadows on one side of the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily progress from a medium shot to a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038085825741291046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880859375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038085825741291046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038085825741291046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04309463128447533, + 0.37824705243110657, + 0.16836486756801605, + 0.025212572887539864, + 0.048116907477378845, + 0.10726671665906906, + 0.09454004466533661, + 0.05843738466501236, + 0.05806330218911171, + 0.018656529486179352 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038085825741291046 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, doll-like shot begins, steadily progressing from a medium shot to a medium close-up at eye level, focusing entirely on a young Southeast Asian man standing in a dimly lit room. He has thick, slightly tousled black hair and sharp features. His jaw is clenched, a muscle in his cheek visibly pulses, and his dark, expressive eyes nervously shift from side to side, scanning the invisible space around him. He wears a simple, fitted charcoal-gray cotton T-shirt. As the camera moves closer, he quickly raises one hand, fingers spread, and anxiously runs it through his hair in a repetitive, self-soothing gesture. The scene is illuminated by a warm, off-camera light source, which carves his face out of the darkness, accentuating the subtle sheen of sweat on his forehead and casting the other side into deep, dramatic shadow against a plain, out-of-focus wall. The deliberate camera movement and stark, low-key lighting echo his agitated state, creating an atmosphere of claustrophobia and intense suspense, drawing the viewer directly into the moment of private turmoil.", + "seed": 1591, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_12/index_9653_seed_1591_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.025103507190942766, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025103507190942766, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025103507190942766, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young Southeast Asian man with thick, slightly tousled black hair and sharp features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, fitted charcoal-gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform the action of raising one hand with fingers spread to run it through his hair in a repetitive, self-soothing gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm, off-camera light source that creates deep shadows on one side of the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily progress from a medium shot to a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.021922286599874496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8969223499298096 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.021922286599874496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.021922286599874496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25870588421821594, + 0.07774088531732559, + 0.04801151528954506, + 0.01771426759660244, + 0.048022232949733734, + 0.06654755026102066, + 0.03384372219443321, + 0.08075281977653503, + 0.2745058238506317, + 0.09415536373853683 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.021922286599874496 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young Southeast Asian man with thick, slightly tousled black hair and sharp features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, fitted charcoal-gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform the action of raising one hand with fingers spread to run it through his hair in a repetitive, self-soothing gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm, off-camera light source that creates deep shadows on one side of the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily progress from a medium shot to a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023294946178793907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732949256896973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023294946178793907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023294946178793907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.279800146818161, + 0.06287728995084763, + 0.08873853087425232, + 0.053229738026857376, + 0.17146475613117218, + 0.10836438089609146, + 0.02686327137053013, + 0.04598433896899223, + 0.12183059006929398, + 0.04084702953696251 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023294946178793907 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young Southeast Asian man with thick, slightly tousled black hair and sharp features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, fitted charcoal-gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform the action of raising one hand with fingers spread to run it through his hair in a repetitive, self-soothing gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm, off-camera light source that creates deep shadows on one side of the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily progress from a medium shot to a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016074350103735924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141074180603027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016074350103735924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016074350103735924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02398524433374405, + 0.2276829481124878, + 0.02222246117889881, + 0.018671372905373573, + 0.03686882555484772, + 0.023709949105978012, + 0.027718735858798027, + 0.02693338319659233, + 0.5609039664268494, + 0.031303055584430695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016074350103735924 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young Southeast Asian man with thick, slightly tousled black hair and sharp features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, fitted charcoal-gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform the action of raising one hand with fingers spread to run it through his hair in a repetitive, self-soothing gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm, off-camera light source that creates deep shadows on one side of the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily progress from a medium shot to a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021998509764671326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127199649810791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021998509764671326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021998509764671326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02951670065522194, + 0.20980852842330933, + 0.07734987884759903, + 0.04652569815516472, + 0.10786271840333939, + 0.026217015460133553, + 0.01621897518634796, + 0.03308412805199623, + 0.38649967312812805, + 0.06691674888134003 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021998509764671326 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young Southeast Asian man with thick, slightly tousled black hair and sharp features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, fitted charcoal-gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform the action of raising one hand with fingers spread to run it through his hair in a repetitive, self-soothing gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm, off-camera light source that creates deep shadows on one side of the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily progress from a medium shot to a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06202610209584236 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812026023864746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06202610209584236, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06202610209584236, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03311580792069435, + 0.17870263755321503, + 0.021418048068881035, + 0.013101868331432343, + 0.05328783020377159, + 0.02449878305196762, + 0.035519711673259735, + 0.03281594440340996, + 0.5346059799194336, + 0.07293336093425751 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06202610209584236 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, doll-like shot begins, steadily progressing from a medium shot to a medium close-up at eye level, focusing entirely on a young Southeast Asian man standing in a dimly lit room. He has thick, slightly tousled black hair and sharp features. His jaw is clenched, a muscle in his cheek visibly pulses, and his dark, expressive eyes nervously shift from side to side, scanning the invisible space around him. He wears a simple, fitted charcoal-gray cotton T-shirt. As the camera moves closer, he quickly raises one hand, fingers spread, and anxiously runs it through his hair in a repetitive, self-soothing gesture. The scene is illuminated by a warm, off-camera light source, which carves his face out of the darkness, accentuating the subtle sheen of sweat on his forehead and casting the other side into deep, dramatic shadow against a plain, out-of-focus wall. The deliberate camera movement and stark, low-key lighting echo his agitated state, creating an atmosphere of claustrophobia and intense suspense, drawing the viewer directly into the moment of private turmoil.", + "seed": 1592, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_12/index_9653_seed_1592_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03271132567897439, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03271132567897439, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03271132567897439, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young Southeast Asian man with thick, slightly tousled black hair and sharp features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, fitted charcoal-gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform the action of raising one hand with fingers spread to run it through his hair in a repetitive, self-soothing gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm, off-camera light source that creates deep shadows on one side of the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily progress from a medium shot to a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.057116132229566574 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9321160316467285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.057116132229566574, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.057116132229566574, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21215516328811646, + 0.058219537138938904, + 0.02678588777780533, + 0.034310389310121536, + 0.09871155023574829, + 0.035994891077280045, + 0.1047820895910263, + 0.18099172413349152, + 0.11085714399814606, + 0.13719163835048676 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.057116132229566574 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young Southeast Asian man with thick, slightly tousled black hair and sharp features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, fitted charcoal-gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform the action of raising one hand with fingers spread to run it through his hair in a repetitive, self-soothing gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm, off-camera light source that creates deep shadows on one side of the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily progress from a medium shot to a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0381055623292923 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881054878234863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0381055623292923, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0381055623292923, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2702351212501526, + 0.10086619108915329, + 0.020679647102952003, + 0.032125234603881836, + 0.23734283447265625, + 0.09711962193250656, + 0.06905955821275711, + 0.048788055777549744, + 0.029974915087223053, + 0.09380882978439331 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0381055623292923 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young Southeast Asian man with thick, slightly tousled black hair and sharp features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, fitted charcoal-gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform the action of raising one hand with fingers spread to run it through his hair in a repetitive, self-soothing gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm, off-camera light source that creates deep shadows on one side of the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily progress from a medium shot to a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018187889829277992 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187999725342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018187889829277992, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018187889829277992, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03762529417872429, + 0.018270274624228477, + 0.02279774472117424, + 0.021120158955454826, + 0.0978143960237503, + 0.24436111748218536, + 0.07953369617462158, + 0.034884799271821976, + 0.055799320340156555, + 0.38779324293136597 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018187889829277992 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young Southeast Asian man with thick, slightly tousled black hair and sharp features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, fitted charcoal-gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform the action of raising one hand with fingers spread to run it through his hair in a repetitive, self-soothing gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm, off-camera light source that creates deep shadows on one side of the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily progress from a medium shot to a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001512932125478983 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.5015130043029785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001512932125478983, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001512932125478983, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15534637868404388, + 0.09378248453140259, + 0.04225374758243561, + 0.04030512273311615, + 0.04209402948617935, + 0.15762582421302795, + 0.10099635273218155, + 0.060170501470565796, + 0.17832249402999878, + 0.12910306453704834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001512932125478983 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young Southeast Asian man with thick, slightly tousled black hair and sharp features?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a simple, fitted charcoal-gray cotton T-shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man perform the action of raising one hand with fingers spread to run it through his hair in a repetitive, self-soothing gesture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by a warm, off-camera light source that creates deep shadows on one side of the man's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera steadily progress from a medium shot to a medium close-up at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048634111881256104 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486340522766113 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048634111881256104, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048634111881256104, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07528571039438248, + 0.05874884873628616, + 0.037433329969644547, + 0.047610100358724594, + 0.07522104680538177, + 0.15381737053394318, + 0.11962434649467468, + 0.13204270601272583, + 0.08793697506189346, + 0.2122795730829239 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048634111881256104 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_13/index_tensor([7033, 7033])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_13/index_tensor([7033, 7033])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a464d829d53e96f8ef0b31b9bc1821cc7219eb4f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_13/index_tensor([7033, 7033])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, full-body tracking shot follows a revered warrior as he moves forward with a determined stride, the camera keeping pace with his relentless advance. Rendered in the signature Todd McFarlane art style, the scene is a symphony of extreme contrasts. The warrior's long, flowing white beard cascades across his chest like a tangled, windswept waterfall, his weathered features a roadmap of ancient conflict, defined by deep-set, shadowed eyes and a steely jaw. His ancient armor is a masterpiece of intricate, pointed detail, with jagged amulets and demonic greaves, its dark, pitted metal capturing harsh, electric-white highlights at every edge while mired in deep, inky shadows within its crevices. With one gloved hand, he grasps the hilt of a massive, ornate broadsword, its massive blade so heavy it scrapes the ground, sending sparks flying. A tattered, impossibly long cape, the color of dried blood, billowed dramatically behind him, its fragmented ends whipping like living tendrils in the turbulent air. He traversed a desolate landscape, streaked with jagged black volcanic rock, ripping the sky apart, all shrouded in a blood-red sky, swirling clouds, and an oppressive, monochrome glow. Drifting embers rose from unseen cracks in the ground and swirled around his legs in chaotic, glowing vortices, creating a grim, apocalyptic atmosphere of heroic defiance against a dying world.", + "seed": 15010, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_13/index_7033_seed_15010_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.10917142834514379, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10917142834514379, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5999999165534975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10917142834514379, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a warrior with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing dark, pitted armor with jagged amulets and demonic greaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior holding a massive broadsword that scrapes the ground and sends sparks flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desolate landscape with jagged black volcanic rock under a blood-red sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.13329441845417023 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1332943439483643 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.13329441845417023, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.13329441845417023, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26350340247154236, + 0.14810757339000702, + 0.09413225948810577, + 0.08077376335859299, + 0.13352586328983307, + 0.08899862319231033, + 0.05014726147055626, + 0.05828947201371193, + 0.041584696620702744, + 0.04093708097934723 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.13329441845417023 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a warrior with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing dark, pitted armor with jagged amulets and demonic greaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior holding a massive broadsword that scrapes the ground and sends sparks flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desolate landscape with jagged black volcanic rock under a blood-red sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38708263635635376 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137082576751709 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38708263635635376, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38708263635635376, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2213282436132431, + 0.10492563247680664, + 0.07015793025493622, + 0.06811129301786423, + 0.17643523216247559, + 0.08768818527460098, + 0.07496672123670578, + 0.03481066972017288, + 0.07089530676603317, + 0.09068083763122559 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38708263635635376 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a warrior with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing dark, pitted armor with jagged amulets and demonic greaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior holding a massive broadsword that scrapes the ground and sends sparks flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desolate landscape with jagged black volcanic rock under a blood-red sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004101199563592672 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504101276397705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004101199563592672, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004101199563592672, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1822493076324463, + 0.12467948347330093, + 0.0909702479839325, + 0.1538843810558319, + 0.08454908430576324, + 0.0865587666630745, + 0.06021761894226074, + 0.04790768027305603, + 0.08229149878025055, + 0.08669200539588928 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004101199563592672 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a warrior with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing dark, pitted armor with jagged amulets and demonic greaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior holding a massive broadsword that scrapes the ground and sends sparks flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desolate landscape with jagged black volcanic rock under a blood-red sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018189646303653717 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018189430236816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018189646303653717, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018189646303653717, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2123333215713501, + 0.11437077820301056, + 0.07748144865036011, + 0.1843835413455963, + 0.07398419827222824, + 0.0640864148736, + 0.048579540103673935, + 0.0514194630086422, + 0.09560921043157578, + 0.07775207608938217 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018189646303653717 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a warrior with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing dark, pitted armor with jagged amulets and demonic greaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior holding a massive broadsword that scrapes the ground and sends sparks flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desolate landscape with jagged black volcanic rock under a blood-red sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003189241047948599 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531890869140625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003189241047948599, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003189241047948599, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10795176029205322, + 0.1352672129869461, + 0.09616534411907196, + 0.17993250489234924, + 0.17284570634365082, + 0.12263818085193634, + 0.029176969081163406, + 0.02921939827501774, + 0.05803284794092178, + 0.06877004355192184 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003189241047948599 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, full-body tracking shot follows a revered warrior as he moves forward with a determined stride, the camera keeping pace with his relentless advance. Rendered in the signature Todd McFarlane art style, the scene is a symphony of extreme contrasts. The warrior's long, flowing white beard cascades across his chest like a tangled, windswept waterfall, his weathered features a roadmap of ancient conflict, defined by deep-set, shadowed eyes and a steely jaw. His ancient armor is a masterpiece of intricate, pointed detail, with jagged amulets and demonic greaves, its dark, pitted metal capturing harsh, electric-white highlights at every edge while mired in deep, inky shadows within its crevices. With one gloved hand, he grasps the hilt of a massive, ornate broadsword, its massive blade so heavy it scrapes the ground, sending sparks flying. A tattered, impossibly long cape, the color of dried blood, billowed dramatically behind him, its fragmented ends whipping like living tendrils in the turbulent air. He traversed a desolate landscape, streaked with jagged black volcanic rock, ripping the sky apart, all shrouded in a blood-red sky, swirling clouds, and an oppressive, monochrome glow. Drifting embers rose from unseen cracks in the ground and swirled around his legs in chaotic, glowing vortices, creating a grim, apocalyptic atmosphere of heroic defiance against a dying world.", + "seed": 15011, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_13/index_7033_seed_15011_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.14950546491891145, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14950546491891145, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14950546491891145, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a warrior with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing dark, pitted armor with jagged amulets and demonic greaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior holding a massive broadsword that scrapes the ground and sends sparks flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desolate landscape with jagged black volcanic rock under a blood-red sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.23629426956176758 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6112942695617676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.23629426956176758, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.23629426956176758, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29690787196159363, + 0.08689715713262558, + 0.06906979531049728, + 0.039661336690187454, + 0.24490338563919067, + 0.03937208279967308, + 0.049249738454818726, + 0.07814880460500717, + 0.06500965356826782, + 0.030780129134655 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.23629426956176758 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a warrior with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing dark, pitted armor with jagged amulets and demonic greaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior holding a massive broadsword that scrapes the ground and sends sparks flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desolate landscape with jagged black volcanic rock under a blood-red sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4742845892906189 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742845892906189 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4742845892906189, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4742845892906189, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17575475573539734, + 0.15834924578666687, + 0.0942922979593277, + 0.057437337934970856, + 0.11025127023458481, + 0.047712162137031555, + 0.05024214833974838, + 0.06498371809720993, + 0.06880102306604385, + 0.17217609286308289 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4742845892906189 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a warrior with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing dark, pitted armor with jagged amulets and demonic greaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior holding a massive broadsword that scrapes the ground and sends sparks flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desolate landscape with jagged black volcanic rock under a blood-red sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004649067297577858 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.3796491622924805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004649067297577858, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004649067297577858, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3084023594856262, + 0.1160808652639389, + 0.06993454694747925, + 0.05523302033543587, + 0.1488087922334671, + 0.06628841161727905, + 0.04360632598400116, + 0.0364200621843338, + 0.09518856555223465, + 0.06003708019852638 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004649067297577858 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a warrior with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing dark, pitted armor with jagged amulets and demonic greaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior holding a massive broadsword that scrapes the ground and sends sparks flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desolate landscape with jagged black volcanic rock under a blood-red sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026351768523454666 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513516902923584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026351768523454666, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026351768523454666, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2310011088848114, + 0.11482128500938416, + 0.0961189791560173, + 0.05080891400575638, + 0.08959512412548065, + 0.06986851990222931, + 0.11655261367559433, + 0.06838229298591614, + 0.08888769894838333, + 0.073963463306427 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026351768523454666 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a warrior with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing dark, pitted armor with jagged amulets and demonic greaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior holding a massive broadsword that scrapes the ground and sends sparks flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desolate landscape with jagged black volcanic rock under a blood-red sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005947629921138287 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130947589874268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005947629921138287, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005947629921138287, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16455760598182678, + 0.05778294429183006, + 0.11409468203783035, + 0.06818729639053345, + 0.16844674944877625, + 0.16571906208992004, + 0.06671037524938583, + 0.0745709165930748, + 0.06832043826580048, + 0.05160991847515106 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005947629921138287 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, full-body tracking shot follows a revered warrior as he moves forward with a determined stride, the camera keeping pace with his relentless advance. Rendered in the signature Todd McFarlane art style, the scene is a symphony of extreme contrasts. The warrior's long, flowing white beard cascades across his chest like a tangled, windswept waterfall, his weathered features a roadmap of ancient conflict, defined by deep-set, shadowed eyes and a steely jaw. His ancient armor is a masterpiece of intricate, pointed detail, with jagged amulets and demonic greaves, its dark, pitted metal capturing harsh, electric-white highlights at every edge while mired in deep, inky shadows within its crevices. With one gloved hand, he grasps the hilt of a massive, ornate broadsword, its massive blade so heavy it scrapes the ground, sending sparks flying. A tattered, impossibly long cape, the color of dried blood, billowed dramatically behind him, its fragmented ends whipping like living tendrils in the turbulent air. He traversed a desolate landscape, streaked with jagged black volcanic rock, ripping the sky apart, all shrouded in a blood-red sky, swirling clouds, and an oppressive, monochrome glow. Drifting embers rose from unseen cracks in the ground and swirled around his legs in chaotic, glowing vortices, creating a grim, apocalyptic atmosphere of heroic defiance against a dying world.", + "seed": 15012, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_13/index_7033_seed_15012_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1311428805347532, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1311428805347532, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1311428805347532, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a warrior with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing dark, pitted armor with jagged amulets and demonic greaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior holding a massive broadsword that scrapes the ground and sends sparks flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desolate landscape with jagged black volcanic rock under a blood-red sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.15435650944709778 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0293564796447754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.15435650944709778, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.15435650944709778, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31044822931289673, + 0.09948290139436722, + 0.06204891577363014, + 0.05013730004429817, + 0.1780329942703247, + 0.08405056595802307, + 0.06974653154611588, + 0.03017580695450306, + 0.05356883257627487, + 0.06230785697698593 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.15435650944709778 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a warrior with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing dark, pitted armor with jagged amulets and demonic greaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior holding a massive broadsword that scrapes the ground and sends sparks flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desolate landscape with jagged black volcanic rock under a blood-red sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47429490089416504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.974294900894165 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47429490089416504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47429490089416504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21961410343647003, + 0.2550644874572754, + 0.08490455895662308, + 0.07210102677345276, + 0.09537038952112198, + 0.04032742977142334, + 0.04039733111858368, + 0.08345871418714523, + 0.050355710089206696, + 0.05840631201863289 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47429490089416504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a warrior with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing dark, pitted armor with jagged amulets and demonic greaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior holding a massive broadsword that scrapes the ground and sends sparks flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desolate landscape with jagged black volcanic rock under a blood-red sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003623825730755925 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628623962402344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003623825730755925, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003623825730755925, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23106853663921356, + 0.11980048567056656, + 0.11363436281681061, + 0.05725734308362007, + 0.11377173662185669, + 0.06602022051811218, + 0.05150782689452171, + 0.06141463667154312, + 0.06065770238637924, + 0.12486709654331207 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003623825730755925 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a warrior with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing dark, pitted armor with jagged amulets and demonic greaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior holding a massive broadsword that scrapes the ground and sends sparks flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desolate landscape with jagged black volcanic rock under a blood-red sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018189996480941772 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018189907073975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018189996480941772, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018189996480941772, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1932394951581955, + 0.13397200405597687, + 0.12532679736614227, + 0.06455712765455246, + 0.12847945094108582, + 0.0883210077881813, + 0.06963856518268585, + 0.05047731101512909, + 0.0345851294696331, + 0.11140307039022446 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018189996480941772 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a warrior with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing dark, pitted armor with jagged amulets and demonic greaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior holding a massive broadsword that scrapes the ground and sends sparks flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desolate landscape with jagged black volcanic rock under a blood-red sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005249170120805502 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.2552490234375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005249170120805502, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005249170120805502, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19514025747776031, + 0.10103322565555573, + 0.06283371150493622, + 0.06262513995170593, + 0.16434961557388306, + 0.15652325749397278, + 0.06368827074766159, + 0.06225685775279999, + 0.035572342574596405, + 0.0959773138165474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005249170120805502 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, full-body tracking shot follows a revered warrior as he moves forward with a determined stride, the camera keeping pace with his relentless advance. Rendered in the signature Todd McFarlane art style, the scene is a symphony of extreme contrasts. The warrior's long, flowing white beard cascades across his chest like a tangled, windswept waterfall, his weathered features a roadmap of ancient conflict, defined by deep-set, shadowed eyes and a steely jaw. His ancient armor is a masterpiece of intricate, pointed detail, with jagged amulets and demonic greaves, its dark, pitted metal capturing harsh, electric-white highlights at every edge while mired in deep, inky shadows within its crevices. With one gloved hand, he grasps the hilt of a massive, ornate broadsword, its massive blade so heavy it scrapes the ground, sending sparks flying. A tattered, impossibly long cape, the color of dried blood, billowed dramatically behind him, its fragmented ends whipping like living tendrils in the turbulent air. He traversed a desolate landscape, streaked with jagged black volcanic rock, ripping the sky apart, all shrouded in a blood-red sky, swirling clouds, and an oppressive, monochrome glow. Drifting embers rose from unseen cracks in the ground and swirled around his legs in chaotic, glowing vortices, creating a grim, apocalyptic atmosphere of heroic defiance against a dying world.", + "seed": 15013, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_13/index_7033_seed_15013_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.14699865598231554, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14699865598231554, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14699865598231554, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a warrior with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing dark, pitted armor with jagged amulets and demonic greaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior holding a massive broadsword that scrapes the ground and sends sparks flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desolate landscape with jagged black volcanic rock under a blood-red sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08724970370531082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.587249755859375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08724970370531082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08724970370531082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2961293160915375, + 0.1257786899805069, + 0.0551399290561676, + 0.061178404837846756, + 0.07484721392393112, + 0.0546896867454052, + 0.21289990842342377, + 0.050409041345119476, + 0.03505504131317139, + 0.033872757107019424 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08724970370531082 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a warrior with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing dark, pitted armor with jagged amulets and demonic greaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior holding a massive broadsword that scrapes the ground and sends sparks flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desolate landscape with jagged black volcanic rock under a blood-red sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328029632568359 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578029632568359 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6328029632568359, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6328029632568359, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3426799476146698, + 0.13479410111904144, + 0.0964062511920929, + 0.05209141969680786, + 0.08754753321409225, + 0.09916655719280243, + 0.03957333043217659, + 0.03898110240697861, + 0.057495128363370895, + 0.05126456916332245 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6328029632568359 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a warrior with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing dark, pitted armor with jagged amulets and demonic greaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior holding a massive broadsword that scrapes the ground and sends sparks flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desolate landscape with jagged black volcanic rock under a blood-red sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004104167688637972 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504104137420654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004104167688637972, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004104167688637972, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31435686349868774, + 0.15396073460578918, + 0.10539662837982178, + 0.05386984720826149, + 0.0682544857263565, + 0.06148805841803551, + 0.09630756825208664, + 0.05887092649936676, + 0.05000484734773636, + 0.0374901220202446 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004104167688637972 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a warrior with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing dark, pitted armor with jagged amulets and demonic greaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior holding a massive broadsword that scrapes the ground and sends sparks flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desolate landscape with jagged black volcanic rock under a blood-red sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008640995249152184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758640766143799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008640995249152184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008640995249152184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18055199086666107, + 0.32834553718566895, + 0.08573562651872635, + 0.04080137610435486, + 0.05984706059098244, + 0.05351943522691727, + 0.12086071074008942, + 0.044502031058073044, + 0.05466844514012337, + 0.031167777255177498 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008640995249152184 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the character a warrior with a long, flowing white beard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing dark, pitted armor with jagged amulets and demonic greaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior holding a massive broadsword that scrapes the ground and sends sparks flying?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desolate landscape with jagged black volcanic rock under a blood-red sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002195450011640787 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127195358276367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002195450011640787, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002195450011640787, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20994222164154053, + 0.2773103415966034, + 0.17153717577457428, + 0.09007832407951355, + 0.04623829573392868, + 0.04201994836330414, + 0.06617671251296997, + 0.036059532314538956, + 0.03132446110248566, + 0.029313014820218086 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002195450011640787 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_14/index_tensor([824, 824])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_14/index_tensor([824, 824])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6511ab96a46611bcb06cb8a382751508d33b6abc --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_14/index_tensor([824, 824])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low, upward-angled, long shot captures an epic confrontation with nature. On the edge of a rocky coast, a weathered, ancient pine tree stands tenaciously. Its twisted, thick trunk, a deep, sea-soaked dark brown, is riddled with deep cracks, and its exposed roots cling to the slippery rocks like iron claws. Against a gloomy, overcast sky, a mighty wave, carrying deep blue, almost black water, crashes fiercely toward it. The moment the wave impacts the tree's base and the rocks, it explodes with a thunderous bang, sending up a cloud of white spray. In the cold sunlight, these sprays resemble countless shimmering pearls, blasting outward with force, instantly engulfing the pine tree's deep green needles and part of its trunk in a hazy mist. Despite enduring the relentless impact of the waves, the ancient pine tree remains motionless. The entire picture, rendered in cold colors, conveys a tragic, solemn and indomitable tranquil atmosphere.", + "seed": 3790, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_14/index_824_seed_3790_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0814476169180125, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0814476169180125, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0814476169180125, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the edge of a rocky coast with an ancient pine tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk deep dark brown, twisted, and riddled with deep cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a mighty wave with deep blue, almost black water crash toward the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave impact cause an explosion of white spray that engulfs the tree in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the ancient pine tree remain motionless despite the wave impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006077144294977188 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.256077289581299 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006077144294977188, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006077144294977188, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21977633237838745, + 0.05616959556937218, + 0.07089905440807343, + 0.03347030654549599, + 0.2845149636268616, + 0.041204310953617096, + 0.057399969547986984, + 0.09176509082317352, + 0.059215374290943146, + 0.08558497577905655 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006077144294977188 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the edge of a rocky coast with an ancient pine tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk deep dark brown, twisted, and riddled with deep cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a mighty wave with deep blue, almost black water crash toward the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave impact cause an explosion of white spray that engulfs the tree in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the ancient pine tree remain motionless despite the wave impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011095372959971428 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110955238342285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011095372959971428, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011095372959971428, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14179302752017975, + 0.08452912420034409, + 0.07426539808511734, + 0.05280965939164162, + 0.06681419163942337, + 0.10649800300598145, + 0.09427615255117416, + 0.09736492484807968, + 0.12551727890968323, + 0.15613219141960144 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011095372959971428 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the edge of a rocky coast with an ancient pine tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk deep dark brown, twisted, and riddled with deep cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a mighty wave with deep blue, almost black water crash toward the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave impact cause an explosion of white spray that engulfs the tree in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the ancient pine tree remain motionless despite the wave impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00220104050822556 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127201080322266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00220104050822556, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00220104050822556, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05226428806781769, + 0.03564247861504555, + 0.07314886897802353, + 0.02070743218064308, + 0.04580477252602577, + 0.045632071793079376, + 0.4779689610004425, + 0.08578337728977203, + 0.039207685738801956, + 0.12384004890918732 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00220104050822556 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the edge of a rocky coast with an ancient pine tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk deep dark brown, twisted, and riddled with deep cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a mighty wave with deep blue, almost black water crash toward the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave impact cause an explosion of white spray that engulfs the tree in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the ancient pine tree remain motionless despite the wave impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0008136299438774586 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.1258134841918945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0008136299438774586, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0008136299438774586, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04413297027349472, + 0.01738368533551693, + 0.02774457447230816, + 0.030872903764247894, + 0.029851606115698814, + 0.04386980086565018, + 0.4376946687698364, + 0.08715814352035522, + 0.021271253004670143, + 0.26002037525177 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0008136299438774586 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the edge of a rocky coast with an ancient pine tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk deep dark brown, twisted, and riddled with deep cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a mighty wave with deep blue, almost black water crash toward the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave impact cause an explosion of white spray that engulfs the tree in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the ancient pine tree remain motionless despite the wave impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38705089688301086 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370508670806885 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38705089688301086, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38705089688301086, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06484052538871765, + 0.033619705587625504, + 0.05577738955616951, + 0.033536918461322784, + 0.04429130256175995, + 0.028775474056601524, + 0.3843808174133301, + 0.13795746862888336, + 0.03315040096640587, + 0.1836700141429901 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38705089688301086 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low, upward-angled, long shot captures an epic confrontation with nature. On the edge of a rocky coast, a weathered, ancient pine tree stands tenaciously. Its twisted, thick trunk, a deep, sea-soaked dark brown, is riddled with deep cracks, and its exposed roots cling to the slippery rocks like iron claws. Against a gloomy, overcast sky, a mighty wave, carrying deep blue, almost black water, crashes fiercely toward it. The moment the wave impacts the tree's base and the rocks, it explodes with a thunderous bang, sending up a cloud of white spray. In the cold sunlight, these sprays resemble countless shimmering pearls, blasting outward with force, instantly engulfing the pine tree's deep green needles and part of its trunk in a hazy mist. Despite enduring the relentless impact of the waves, the ancient pine tree remains motionless. The entire picture, rendered in cold colors, conveys a tragic, solemn and indomitable tranquil atmosphere.", + "seed": 3791, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_14/index_824_seed_3791_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06123909885063768, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06123909885063768, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06123909885063768, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the edge of a rocky coast with an ancient pine tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk deep dark brown, twisted, and riddled with deep cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a mighty wave with deep blue, almost black water crash toward the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave impact cause an explosion of white spray that engulfs the tree in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the ancient pine tree remain motionless despite the wave impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005706448573619127 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255706310272217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005706448573619127, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005706448573619127, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16267690062522888, + 0.14380964636802673, + 0.16706474125385284, + 0.13855326175689697, + 0.053221333771944046, + 0.0408603735268116, + 0.06432206928730011, + 0.08026345074176788, + 0.07347302883863449, + 0.07575520128011703 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005706448573619127 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the edge of a rocky coast with an ancient pine tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk deep dark brown, twisted, and riddled with deep cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a mighty wave with deep blue, almost black water crash toward the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave impact cause an explosion of white spray that engulfs the tree in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the ancient pine tree remain motionless despite the wave impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014221743680536747 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264221668243408 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014221743680536747, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014221743680536747, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18458838760852814, + 0.08431033790111542, + 0.13573671877384186, + 0.11535978317260742, + 0.06637727469205856, + 0.03722374886274338, + 0.1282283067703247, + 0.08858224749565125, + 0.05922836810350418, + 0.1003648117184639 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014221743680536747 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the edge of a rocky coast with an ancient pine tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk deep dark brown, twisted, and riddled with deep cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a mighty wave with deep blue, almost black water crash toward the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave impact cause an explosion of white spray that engulfs the tree in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the ancient pine tree remain motionless despite the wave impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036213314160704613 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.6286211013793945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036213314160704613, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036213314160704613, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11769140511751175, + 0.13727378845214844, + 0.35794398188591003, + 0.11133933812379837, + 0.07248900830745697, + 0.030947880819439888, + 0.09371913969516754, + 0.03623543307185173, + 0.027418890967965126, + 0.014941100962460041 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036213314160704613 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the edge of a rocky coast with an ancient pine tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk deep dark brown, twisted, and riddled with deep cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a mighty wave with deep blue, almost black water crash toward the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave impact cause an explosion of white spray that engulfs the tree in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the ancient pine tree remain motionless despite the wave impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013368725776672363 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626337051391602 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013368725776672363, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013368725776672363, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10737470537424088, + 0.20679238438606262, + 0.18067896366119385, + 0.10125084221363068, + 0.12724709510803223, + 0.07753168046474457, + 0.08968464285135269, + 0.04385745897889137, + 0.01830744370818138, + 0.04727478697896004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013368725776672363 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the edge of a rocky coast with an ancient pine tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk deep dark brown, twisted, and riddled with deep cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a mighty wave with deep blue, almost black water crash toward the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave impact cause an explosion of white spray that engulfs the tree in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the ancient pine tree remain motionless despite the wave impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813090980052948 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063091278076172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813090980052948, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813090980052948, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13737882673740387, + 0.08843842893838882, + 0.11347977072000504, + 0.1904129981994629, + 0.12769755721092224, + 0.03949780389666557, + 0.08868900686502457, + 0.11496501415967941, + 0.059138353914022446, + 0.04030219838023186 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813090980052948 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low, upward-angled, long shot captures an epic confrontation with nature. On the edge of a rocky coast, a weathered, ancient pine tree stands tenaciously. Its twisted, thick trunk, a deep, sea-soaked dark brown, is riddled with deep cracks, and its exposed roots cling to the slippery rocks like iron claws. Against a gloomy, overcast sky, a mighty wave, carrying deep blue, almost black water, crashes fiercely toward it. The moment the wave impacts the tree's base and the rocks, it explodes with a thunderous bang, sending up a cloud of white spray. In the cold sunlight, these sprays resemble countless shimmering pearls, blasting outward with force, instantly engulfing the pine tree's deep green needles and part of its trunk in a hazy mist. Despite enduring the relentless impact of the waves, the ancient pine tree remains motionless. The entire picture, rendered in cold colors, conveys a tragic, solemn and indomitable tranquil atmosphere.", + "seed": 3792, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_14/index_824_seed_3792_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.056598954787477854, + "vlm_logprob": -0.056598954787477854, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.056598954787477854, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the edge of a rocky coast with an ancient pine tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk deep dark brown, twisted, and riddled with deep cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a mighty wave with deep blue, almost black water crash toward the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave impact cause an explosion of white spray that engulfs the tree in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the ancient pine tree remain motionless despite the wave impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004268107935786247 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.629268169403076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004268107935786247, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004268107935786247, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2075737565755844, + 0.10563333332538605, + 0.09517605602741241, + 0.15615078806877136, + 0.06855570524930954, + 0.03425479680299759, + 0.03134264051914215, + 0.039598483592271805, + 0.12003745138645172, + 0.14167702198028564 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004268107935786247 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the edge of a rocky coast with an ancient pine tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk deep dark brown, twisted, and riddled with deep cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a mighty wave with deep blue, almost black water crash toward the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave impact cause an explosion of white spray that engulfs the tree in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the ancient pine tree remain motionless despite the wave impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020618392154574394 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895618438720703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020618392154574394, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020618392154574394, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17513501644134521, + 0.06353392452001572, + 0.08217743039131165, + 0.1360800415277481, + 0.16147653758525848, + 0.07111753523349762, + 0.021677609533071518, + 0.05371728166937828, + 0.12781059741973877, + 0.10727408528327942 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020618392154574394 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the edge of a rocky coast with an ancient pine tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk deep dark brown, twisted, and riddled with deep cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a mighty wave with deep blue, almost black water crash toward the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave impact cause an explosion of white spray that engulfs the tree in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the ancient pine tree remain motionless despite the wave impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031983908265829086 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753198623657227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031983908265829086, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031983908265829086, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21901360154151917, + 0.05110709369182587, + 0.08187731355428696, + 0.05913587659597397, + 0.23710475862026215, + 0.05432036891579628, + 0.08932814747095108, + 0.0285187978297472, + 0.14129376411437988, + 0.03830026835203171 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031983908265829086 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the edge of a rocky coast with an ancient pine tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk deep dark brown, twisted, and riddled with deep cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a mighty wave with deep blue, almost black water crash toward the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave impact cause an explosion of white spray that engulfs the tree in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the ancient pine tree remain motionless despite the wave impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028212766628712416 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877821445465088 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028212766628712416, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028212766628712416, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07303919643163681, + 0.06426026672124863, + 0.08235889673233032, + 0.07528135925531387, + 0.4636358916759491, + 0.034173622727394104, + 0.03309774026274681, + 0.05576392263174057, + 0.07168813794851303, + 0.04670096933841705 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028212766628712416 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the edge of a rocky coast with an ancient pine tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk deep dark brown, twisted, and riddled with deep cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a mighty wave with deep blue, almost black water crash toward the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave impact cause an explosion of white spray that engulfs the tree in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the ancient pine tree remain motionless despite the wave impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25208860635757446 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020885467529297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25208860635757446, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25208860635757446, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14196020364761353, + 0.07505737990140915, + 0.08964136242866516, + 0.05057597905397415, + 0.09379453957080841, + 0.05096645653247833, + 0.0533272959291935, + 0.06643105298280716, + 0.05166087672114372, + 0.32658490538597107 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25208860635757446 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low, upward-angled, long shot captures an epic confrontation with nature. On the edge of a rocky coast, a weathered, ancient pine tree stands tenaciously. Its twisted, thick trunk, a deep, sea-soaked dark brown, is riddled with deep cracks, and its exposed roots cling to the slippery rocks like iron claws. Against a gloomy, overcast sky, a mighty wave, carrying deep blue, almost black water, crashes fiercely toward it. The moment the wave impacts the tree's base and the rocks, it explodes with a thunderous bang, sending up a cloud of white spray. In the cold sunlight, these sprays resemble countless shimmering pearls, blasting outward with force, instantly engulfing the pine tree's deep green needles and part of its trunk in a hazy mist. Despite enduring the relentless impact of the waves, the ancient pine tree remains motionless. The entire picture, rendered in cold colors, conveys a tragic, solemn and indomitable tranquil atmosphere.", + "seed": 3793, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_14/index_824_seed_3793_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.055659995716996494, + "vlm_logprob": -0.055659995716996494, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.055659995716996494, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the edge of a rocky coast with an ancient pine tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk deep dark brown, twisted, and riddled with deep cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a mighty wave with deep blue, almost black water crash toward the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave impact cause an explosion of white spray that engulfs the tree in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the ancient pine tree remain motionless despite the wave impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002644139574840665 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127644062042236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002644139574840665, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002644139574840665, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11062181740999222, + 0.2774638235569, + 0.09934090822935104, + 0.09799246490001678, + 0.04082155227661133, + 0.04036172106862068, + 0.2065495401620865, + 0.04183553159236908, + 0.047675106674432755, + 0.037337444722652435 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002644139574840665 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the edge of a rocky coast with an ancient pine tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk deep dark brown, twisted, and riddled with deep cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a mighty wave with deep blue, almost black water crash toward the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave impact cause an explosion of white spray that engulfs the tree in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the ancient pine tree remain motionless despite the wave impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01609816402196884 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410980224609375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01609816402196884, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01609816402196884, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1700524538755417, + 0.08146881312131882, + 0.12210175395011902, + 0.1851823478937149, + 0.11373825371265411, + 0.04725469648838043, + 0.09792809188365936, + 0.08760327845811844, + 0.057980429381132126, + 0.036689870059490204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01609816402196884 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the edge of a rocky coast with an ancient pine tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk deep dark brown, twisted, and riddled with deep cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a mighty wave with deep blue, almost black water crash toward the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave impact cause an explosion of white spray that engulfs the tree in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the ancient pine tree remain motionless despite the wave impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005954977124929428 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130954742431641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005954977124929428, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005954977124929428, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13478879630565643, + 0.0472230538725853, + 0.2469639778137207, + 0.10074488818645477, + 0.08515471965074539, + 0.03151525929570198, + 0.1569889485836029, + 0.042883049696683884, + 0.08020668476819992, + 0.07353061437606812 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005954977124929428 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the edge of a rocky coast with an ancient pine tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk deep dark brown, twisted, and riddled with deep cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a mighty wave with deep blue, almost black water crash toward the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave impact cause an explosion of white spray that engulfs the tree in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the ancient pine tree remain motionless despite the wave impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015148365637287498 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501514911651611 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015148365637287498, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015148365637287498, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07273104786872864, + 0.08333766460418701, + 0.16775168478488922, + 0.16987209022045135, + 0.1933811902999878, + 0.07281207293272018, + 0.1067614033818245, + 0.054601892828941345, + 0.03706509992480278, + 0.04168581962585449 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015148365637287498 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the edge of a rocky coast with an ancient pine tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the pine tree's trunk deep dark brown, twisted, and riddled with deep cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a mighty wave with deep blue, almost black water crash toward the tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave impact cause an explosion of white spray that engulfs the tree in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the ancient pine tree remain motionless despite the wave impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25208786129951477 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020878314971924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25208786129951477, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25208786129951477, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06543051451444626, + 0.06265284866094589, + 0.037727851420640945, + 0.04289750009775162, + 0.04456084221601486, + 0.03607429936528206, + 0.2350209355354309, + 0.3130674958229065, + 0.12344614416360855, + 0.03912157192826271 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25208786129951477 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_15/index_tensor([703, 703])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_15/index_tensor([703, 703])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e9c2290960e65481db423016f062795f7b39431f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_15/index_tensor([703, 703])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "smooth, steady 360-degree orbiting camera slowly pans across a vast, three-dimensional holographic supercell storm model suspended in the center of a futuristic, dimly lit, high-tech control room. Composed of translucent, shimmering blue light, the model evokes the classic anvil-shaped cloud form. Its vast volume nearly touches the ceiling, casting a shifting pattern of light and shadow across the polished dark floor. Within the holographic model, a visually agonizing conflict unfolds: vortices of fiery crimson energy spiral and churn at breakneck speed, colliding and ripping into countless turbulent blue streams of luminescent data code. Each collision unleashes brief, dazzling bursts of white energy, as if two opposing forces are locked in a desperate struggle. The dynamic, surround-viewing perspective imbues the scene with the epic, gripping, and tense atmosphere of a top-tier sporting final, imbued with the precision of advanced technology and the wildness of raw power.", + "seed": 21519, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_15/index_703_seed_21519_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08661168664693833, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08661168664693833, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08661168664693833, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a futuristic, dimly lit, high-tech control room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast, three-dimensional holographic supercell storm model suspended in the center of the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic model composed of translucent, shimmering blue light in an anvil-shaped cloud form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do vortices of fiery crimson energy spiral and collide with turbulent blue streams of luminescent data code within the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady 360-degree orbiting pan around the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.034013744443655014 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4090137481689453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.034013744443655014, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.034013744443655014, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33001285791397095, + 0.07251961529254913, + 0.051542166620492935, + 0.04510486125946045, + 0.026005791500210762, + 0.20129962265491486, + 0.09953483939170837, + 0.019957687705755234, + 0.12722888588905334, + 0.026793792843818665 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.034013744443655014 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a futuristic, dimly lit, high-tech control room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast, three-dimensional holographic supercell storm model suspended in the center of the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic model composed of translucent, shimmering blue light in an anvil-shaped cloud form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do vortices of fiery crimson energy spiral and collide with turbulent blue streams of luminescent data code within the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady 360-degree orbiting pan around the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002493607811629772 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002493381500244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002493607811629772, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002493607811629772, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.48352208733558655, + 0.09905992448329926, + 0.07414650917053223, + 0.05510372295975685, + 0.03865613415837288, + 0.0865333303809166, + 0.07993535697460175, + 0.03574281185865402, + 0.02667594514787197, + 0.020624127238988876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002493607811629772 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a futuristic, dimly lit, high-tech control room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast, three-dimensional holographic supercell storm model suspended in the center of the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic model composed of translucent, shimmering blue light in an anvil-shaped cloud form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do vortices of fiery crimson energy spiral and collide with turbulent blue streams of luminescent data code within the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady 360-degree orbiting pan around the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004098587669432163 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504098415374756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004098587669432163, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004098587669432163, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.452450156211853, + 0.11403574049472809, + 0.0774202048778534, + 0.05860775336623192, + 0.04652728885412216, + 0.08570210635662079, + 0.07657325267791748, + 0.03397992253303528, + 0.03559216484427452, + 0.019111420959234238 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004098587669432163 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a futuristic, dimly lit, high-tech control room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast, three-dimensional holographic supercell storm model suspended in the center of the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic model composed of translucent, shimmering blue light in an anvil-shaped cloud form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do vortices of fiery crimson energy spiral and collide with turbulent blue streams of luminescent data code within the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady 360-degree orbiting pan around the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134908080101013 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.313490867614746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134908080101013, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134908080101013, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5335138440132141, + 0.07270670682191849, + 0.07492370903491974, + 0.06178365275263786, + 0.05119364336133003, + 0.04954409599304199, + 0.07501673698425293, + 0.02662469632923603, + 0.030040215700864792, + 0.024652700871229172 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134908080101013 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a futuristic, dimly lit, high-tech control room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast, three-dimensional holographic supercell storm model suspended in the center of the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic model composed of translucent, shimmering blue light in an anvil-shaped cloud form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do vortices of fiery crimson energy spiral and collide with turbulent blue streams of luminescent data code within the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady 360-degree orbiting pan around the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07896168529987335 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789616107940674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07896168529987335, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07896168529987335, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21725204586982727, + 0.03398067131638527, + 0.04368811100721359, + 0.0711025670170784, + 0.05371474474668503, + 0.3443354070186615, + 0.04981366544961929, + 0.03946404531598091, + 0.08351019024848938, + 0.06313850730657578 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07896168529987335 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "smooth, steady 360-degree orbiting camera slowly pans across a vast, three-dimensional holographic supercell storm model suspended in the center of a futuristic, dimly lit, high-tech control room. Composed of translucent, shimmering blue light, the model evokes the classic anvil-shaped cloud form. Its vast volume nearly touches the ceiling, casting a shifting pattern of light and shadow across the polished dark floor. Within the holographic model, a visually agonizing conflict unfolds: vortices of fiery crimson energy spiral and churn at breakneck speed, colliding and ripping into countless turbulent blue streams of luminescent data code. Each collision unleashes brief, dazzling bursts of white energy, as if two opposing forces are locked in a desperate struggle. The dynamic, surround-viewing perspective imbues the scene with the epic, gripping, and tense atmosphere of a top-tier sporting final, imbued with the precision of advanced technology and the wildness of raw power.", + "seed": 21520, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_15/index_703_seed_21520_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.12180077694356442, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12180077694356442, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12180077694356442, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a futuristic, dimly lit, high-tech control room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast, three-dimensional holographic supercell storm model suspended in the center of the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic model composed of translucent, shimmering blue light in an anvil-shaped cloud form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do vortices of fiery crimson energy spiral and collide with turbulent blue streams of luminescent data code within the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady 360-degree orbiting pan around the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16123412549495697 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9112341403961182 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16123412549495697, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16123412549495697, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10691413283348083, + 0.04123479127883911, + 0.033231060951948166, + 0.04671161249279976, + 0.49070051312446594, + 0.09328631311655045, + 0.08198875933885574, + 0.03522321209311485, + 0.03202548995614052, + 0.038684096187353134 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16123412549495697 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a futuristic, dimly lit, high-tech control room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast, three-dimensional holographic supercell storm model suspended in the center of the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic model composed of translucent, shimmering blue light in an anvil-shaped cloud form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do vortices of fiery crimson energy spiral and collide with turbulent blue streams of luminescent data code within the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady 360-degree orbiting pan around the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01109018549323082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511090278625488 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01109018549323082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01109018549323082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07461973279714584, + 0.04566756263375282, + 0.031192878261208534, + 0.06818321347236633, + 0.40793636441230774, + 0.037431370466947556, + 0.2827073633670807, + 0.016625724732875824, + 0.014454750344157219, + 0.021181076765060425 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01109018549323082 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a futuristic, dimly lit, high-tech control room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast, three-dimensional holographic supercell storm model suspended in the center of the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic model composed of translucent, shimmering blue light in an anvil-shaped cloud form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do vortices of fiery crimson energy spiral and collide with turbulent blue streams of luminescent data code within the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady 360-degree orbiting pan around the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046443212777376175 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379644393920898 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046443212777376175, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046443212777376175, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10241412371397018, + 0.0555848591029644, + 0.0343581885099411, + 0.08227350562810898, + 0.3485753834247589, + 0.09621653705835342, + 0.2345980405807495, + 0.01485336571931839, + 0.0159812793135643, + 0.015144675970077515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046443212777376175 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a futuristic, dimly lit, high-tech control room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast, three-dimensional holographic supercell storm model suspended in the center of the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic model composed of translucent, shimmering blue light in an anvil-shaped cloud form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do vortices of fiery crimson energy spiral and collide with turbulent blue streams of luminescent data code within the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady 360-degree orbiting pan around the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17994453012943268 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049445152282715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17994453012943268, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17994453012943268, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0817851647734642, + 0.04162290692329407, + 0.03603749722242355, + 0.08113863319158554, + 0.3857453465461731, + 0.10085248947143555, + 0.22594629228115082, + 0.01393917016685009, + 0.019408419728279114, + 0.01352414209395647 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17994453012943268 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a futuristic, dimly lit, high-tech control room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast, three-dimensional holographic supercell storm model suspended in the center of the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic model composed of translucent, shimmering blue light in an anvil-shaped cloud form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do vortices of fiery crimson energy spiral and collide with turbulent blue streams of luminescent data code within the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady 360-degree orbiting pan around the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.252090722322464 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020906925201416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.252090722322464, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.252090722322464, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06592188775539398, + 0.0362563282251358, + 0.08308285474777222, + 0.041775140911340714, + 0.11427021771669388, + 0.06385862827301025, + 0.5010936856269836, + 0.05324888601899147, + 0.02220917120575905, + 0.018283220008015633 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.252090722322464 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "smooth, steady 360-degree orbiting camera slowly pans across a vast, three-dimensional holographic supercell storm model suspended in the center of a futuristic, dimly lit, high-tech control room. Composed of translucent, shimmering blue light, the model evokes the classic anvil-shaped cloud form. Its vast volume nearly touches the ceiling, casting a shifting pattern of light and shadow across the polished dark floor. Within the holographic model, a visually agonizing conflict unfolds: vortices of fiery crimson energy spiral and churn at breakneck speed, colliding and ripping into countless turbulent blue streams of luminescent data code. Each collision unleashes brief, dazzling bursts of white energy, as if two opposing forces are locked in a desperate struggle. The dynamic, surround-viewing perspective imbues the scene with the epic, gripping, and tense atmosphere of a top-tier sporting final, imbued with the precision of advanced technology and the wildness of raw power.", + "seed": 21521, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_15/index_703_seed_21521_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03373075823765248, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03373075823765248, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03373075823765248, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a futuristic, dimly lit, high-tech control room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast, three-dimensional holographic supercell storm model suspended in the center of the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic model composed of translucent, shimmering blue light in an anvil-shaped cloud form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do vortices of fiery crimson energy spiral and collide with turbulent blue streams of luminescent data code within the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady 360-degree orbiting pan around the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0492914654314518 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0492913722991943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0492914654314518, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0492914654314518, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1623908281326294, + 0.06993067264556885, + 0.030467338860034943, + 0.04374336823821068, + 0.08248542994260788, + 0.1006402000784874, + 0.03540400415658951, + 0.0431760810315609, + 0.14840048551559448, + 0.28336161375045776 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0492914654314518 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a futuristic, dimly lit, high-tech control room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast, three-dimensional holographic supercell storm model suspended in the center of the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic model composed of translucent, shimmering blue light in an anvil-shaped cloud form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do vortices of fiery crimson energy spiral and collide with turbulent blue streams of luminescent data code within the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady 360-degree orbiting pan around the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011859057703986764 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751185894012451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011859057703986764, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011859057703986764, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14850331842899323, + 0.06352636963129044, + 0.04578493908047676, + 0.04491240158677101, + 0.19432473182678223, + 0.09345237910747528, + 0.047971583902835846, + 0.0905841812491417, + 0.10096597671508789, + 0.1699741631746292 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011859057703986764 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a futuristic, dimly lit, high-tech control room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast, three-dimensional holographic supercell storm model suspended in the center of the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic model composed of translucent, shimmering blue light in an anvil-shaped cloud form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do vortices of fiery crimson energy spiral and collide with turbulent blue streams of luminescent data code within the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady 360-degree orbiting pan around the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011826909612864256 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751182556152344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011826909612864256, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011826909612864256, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08582420647144318, + 0.047887761145830154, + 0.07042157649993896, + 0.058169279247522354, + 0.23036080598831177, + 0.08774479478597641, + 0.042356930673122406, + 0.08248454332351685, + 0.03654969856142998, + 0.25820037722587585 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011826909612864256 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a futuristic, dimly lit, high-tech control room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast, three-dimensional holographic supercell storm model suspended in the center of the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic model composed of translucent, shimmering blue light in an anvil-shaped cloud form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do vortices of fiery crimson energy spiral and collide with turbulent blue streams of luminescent data code within the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady 360-degree orbiting pan around the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620557926595211 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812055826187134 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620557926595211, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620557926595211, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10073788464069366, + 0.04491658881306648, + 0.05347944796085358, + 0.05572457239031792, + 0.2637519836425781, + 0.08032914996147156, + 0.06760456413030624, + 0.10540399700403214, + 0.024815186858177185, + 0.2032366394996643 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620557926595211 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a futuristic, dimly lit, high-tech control room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast, three-dimensional holographic supercell storm model suspended in the center of the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic model composed of translucent, shimmering blue light in an anvil-shaped cloud form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do vortices of fiery crimson energy spiral and collide with turbulent blue streams of luminescent data code within the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady 360-degree orbiting pan around the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0549379363656044 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299378395080566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0549379363656044, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0549379363656044, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1937607079744339, + 0.06174546480178833, + 0.044189028441905975, + 0.04085737466812134, + 0.06437735259532928, + 0.05576322227716446, + 0.059262506663799286, + 0.16792641580104828, + 0.0324663408100605, + 0.27965158224105835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0549379363656044 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "smooth, steady 360-degree orbiting camera slowly pans across a vast, three-dimensional holographic supercell storm model suspended in the center of a futuristic, dimly lit, high-tech control room. Composed of translucent, shimmering blue light, the model evokes the classic anvil-shaped cloud form. Its vast volume nearly touches the ceiling, casting a shifting pattern of light and shadow across the polished dark floor. Within the holographic model, a visually agonizing conflict unfolds: vortices of fiery crimson energy spiral and churn at breakneck speed, colliding and ripping into countless turbulent blue streams of luminescent data code. Each collision unleashes brief, dazzling bursts of white energy, as if two opposing forces are locked in a desperate struggle. The dynamic, surround-viewing perspective imbues the scene with the epic, gripping, and tense atmosphere of a top-tier sporting final, imbued with the precision of advanced technology and the wildness of raw power.", + "seed": 21522, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_15/index_703_seed_21522_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.3012098386883736, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3012098386883736, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3012098386883736, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a futuristic, dimly lit, high-tech control room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast, three-dimensional holographic supercell storm model suspended in the center of the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic model composed of translucent, shimmering blue light in an anvil-shaped cloud form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do vortices of fiery crimson energy spiral and collide with turbulent blue streams of luminescent data code within the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady 360-degree orbiting pan around the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9748504757881165 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47485047578811646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9748504757881165, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9748504757881165, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08352091163396835, + 0.18957845866680145, + 0.09293819218873978, + 0.027215102687478065, + 0.04519454762339592, + 0.015552854165434837, + 0.07966692745685577, + 0.025180302560329437, + 0.40224698185920715, + 0.03890569135546684 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9748504757881165 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a futuristic, dimly lit, high-tech control room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast, three-dimensional holographic supercell storm model suspended in the center of the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic model composed of translucent, shimmering blue light in an anvil-shaped cloud form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do vortices of fiery crimson energy spiral and collide with turbulent blue streams of luminescent data code within the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady 360-degree orbiting pan around the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011087710037827492 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511087894439697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011087710037827492, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011087710037827492, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07356230169534683, + 0.07568730413913727, + 0.060846805572509766, + 0.04054088518023491, + 0.06753342598676682, + 0.03317946568131447, + 0.04582574963569641, + 0.018690941855311394, + 0.5515316724777222, + 0.03260152414441109 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011087710037827492 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a futuristic, dimly lit, high-tech control room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast, three-dimensional holographic supercell storm model suspended in the center of the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic model composed of translucent, shimmering blue light in an anvil-shaped cloud form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do vortices of fiery crimson energy spiral and collide with turbulent blue streams of luminescent data code within the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady 360-degree orbiting pan around the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005954621359705925 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130954742431641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005954621359705925, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005954621359705925, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05046086758375168, + 0.02562015876173973, + 0.03912435099482536, + 0.04592689871788025, + 0.07326988130807877, + 0.028129419311881065, + 0.03633624687790871, + 0.014232435263693333, + 0.6621687412261963, + 0.024731062352657318 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005954621359705925 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a futuristic, dimly lit, high-tech control room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast, three-dimensional holographic supercell storm model suspended in the center of the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic model composed of translucent, shimmering blue light in an anvil-shaped cloud form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do vortices of fiery crimson energy spiral and collide with turbulent blue streams of luminescent data code within the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady 360-degree orbiting pan around the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38711872696876526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1371186971664429 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38711872696876526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38711872696876526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04867373779416084, + 0.03752446547150612, + 0.02058299072086811, + 0.02209058403968811, + 0.07046180963516235, + 0.023815184831619263, + 0.02754189446568489, + 0.0179105456918478, + 0.7018731832504272, + 0.02952554263174534 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38711872696876526 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a futuristic, dimly lit, high-tech control room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a vast, three-dimensional holographic supercell storm model suspended in the center of the room?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the holographic model composed of translucent, shimmering blue light in an anvil-shaped cloud form?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do vortices of fiery crimson energy spiral and collide with turbulent blue streams of luminescent data code within the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady 360-degree orbiting pan around the model?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270376592874527 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127037763595581 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270376592874527, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270376592874527, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04300536587834358, + 0.14139437675476074, + 0.09948340803384781, + 0.052651192992925644, + 0.0364120714366436, + 0.03771447017788887, + 0.029151706025004387, + 0.024731075391173363, + 0.4828668236732483, + 0.052589524537324905 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270376592874527 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_2/index_tensor([6595, 6595])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_2/index_tensor([6595, 6595])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..75c3ee11311ba9b1af132375eb673d2c440c29e2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_2/index_tensor([6595, 6595])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "wide, static shot, shot from an extremely low angle just above the sea, captures a massive wave, like a liquid mountain, crashing with unstoppable force against a weathered, angular black volcanic reef. The wave's base is a deep turquoise, gradually transitioning to a translucent emerald green. Its curving crest begins to tear into white foam. At the moment of impact, the massive wave's main body explodes, disintegrating into a whirlwind of white foam and mist. This vast cloud of white mist is hurled tens of meters into the air, its millions of crystalline droplets gleaming silver in the dramatic diffuse light of the overcast sky before cascading down like a torrential rain. The wet black reef shimmers beneath the impact, creating a stark contrast with the raging whitewater. The entire scene, set against the leaden sky, is imbued with a raw, majestic, and awe-inspiring sense of natural power, creating an atmosphere of tension and grandeur.", + "seed": 6824, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_2/index_6595_seed_6824_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.3308624842669815, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3308624842669815, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5249999523162843, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3308624842669815, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an extremely low angle just above the sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static without any movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive wave with a deep turquoise base transitioning to translucent emerald green visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave crash against a weathered, angular black volcanic reef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wave explode into a whirlwind of white foam and mist that is hurled tens of meters into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026771297678351402 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.026771068572998 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026771297678351402, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026771297678351402, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14611507952213287, + 0.04238524287939072, + 0.04281438887119293, + 0.1679004579782486, + 0.1910681277513504, + 0.10676692426204681, + 0.07851029187440872, + 0.08214697241783142, + 0.033714521676301956, + 0.10857801139354706 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026771297678351402 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an extremely low angle just above the sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static without any movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive wave with a deep turquoise base transitioning to translucent emerald green visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave crash against a weathered, angular black volcanic reef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wave explode into a whirlwind of white foam and mist that is hurled tens of meters into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005373001098633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2255372703075409 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.6005373001098633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.6005373001098633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1622312217950821, + 0.07256446778774261, + 0.11738281697034836, + 0.07047431915998459, + 0.07866696268320084, + 0.13325642049312592, + 0.04302439093589783, + 0.13342957198619843, + 0.04092928394675255, + 0.1480405628681183 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.6005373001098633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an extremely low angle just above the sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static without any movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive wave with a deep turquoise base transitioning to translucent emerald green visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave crash against a weathered, angular black volcanic reef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wave explode into a whirlwind of white foam and mist that is hurled tens of meters into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028481415938585997 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877848148345947 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028481415938585997, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028481415938585997, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12235426902770996, + 0.08749065548181534, + 0.09910310804843903, + 0.089478500187397, + 0.05165091156959534, + 0.0742310881614685, + 0.08910824358463287, + 0.06992700695991516, + 0.08744478970766068, + 0.22921140491962433 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028481415938585997 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an extremely low angle just above the sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static without any movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive wave with a deep turquoise base transitioning to translucent emerald green visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave crash against a weathered, angular black volcanic reef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wave explode into a whirlwind of white foam and mist that is hurled tens of meters into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00595959834754467 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130959510803223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00595959834754467, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00595959834754467, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08929891139268875, + 0.11085149645805359, + 0.1500140279531479, + 0.08441124111413956, + 0.05630763620138168, + 0.047043222934007645, + 0.0829448252916336, + 0.07574654370546341, + 0.1507539302110672, + 0.15262818336486816 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00595959834754467 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an extremely low angle just above the sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static without any movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive wave with a deep turquoise base transitioning to translucent emerald green visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave crash against a weathered, angular black volcanic reef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wave explode into a whirlwind of white foam and mist that is hurled tens of meters into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819608360528946 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018196105957031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819608360528946, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819608360528946, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3156241476535797, + 0.04404266178607941, + 0.028029855340719223, + 0.03673454374074936, + 0.052364058792591095, + 0.08753631263971329, + 0.08478991687297821, + 0.12880824506282806, + 0.13444508612155914, + 0.0876251757144928 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819608360528946 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, static shot, shot from an extremely low angle just above the sea, captures a massive wave, like a liquid mountain, crashing with unstoppable force against a weathered, angular black volcanic reef. The wave's base is a deep turquoise, gradually transitioning to a translucent emerald green. Its curving crest begins to tear into white foam. At the moment of impact, the massive wave's main body explodes, disintegrating into a whirlwind of white foam and mist. This vast cloud of white mist is hurled tens of meters into the air, its millions of crystalline droplets gleaming silver in the dramatic diffuse light of the overcast sky before cascading down like a torrential rain. The wet black reef shimmers beneath the impact, creating a stark contrast with the raging whitewater. The entire scene, set against the leaden sky, is imbued with a raw, majestic, and awe-inspiring sense of natural power, creating an atmosphere of tension and grandeur.", + "seed": 6825, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_2/index_6595_seed_6825_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.34159957645460964, + "vlm_logprob": -0.34159957645460964, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.34159957645460964, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an extremely low angle just above the sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static without any movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive wave with a deep turquoise base transitioning to translucent emerald green visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave crash against a weathered, angular black volcanic reef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wave explode into a whirlwind of white foam and mist that is hurled tens of meters into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05148889124393463 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1764888763427734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05148889124393463, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05148889124393463, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15504494309425354, + 0.08598502725362778, + 0.10421226173639297, + 0.0672227144241333, + 0.053401120007038116, + 0.07417674362659454, + 0.1097729280591011, + 0.13382941484451294, + 0.055901333689689636, + 0.16045351326465607 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05148889124393463 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an extremely low angle just above the sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static without any movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive wave with a deep turquoise base transitioning to translucent emerald green visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave crash against a weathered, angular black volcanic reef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wave explode into a whirlwind of white foam and mist that is hurled tens of meters into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005539894104004 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22555401921272278 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.6005539894104004, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.6005539894104004, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12593337893486023, + 0.06843209266662598, + 0.06332751363515854, + 0.20340155065059662, + 0.07395371049642563, + 0.10983426868915558, + 0.034182723611593246, + 0.12153419852256775, + 0.06011437997221947, + 0.13928622007369995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.6005539894104004 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an extremely low angle just above the sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static without any movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive wave with a deep turquoise base transitioning to translucent emerald green visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave crash against a weathered, angular black volcanic reef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wave explode into a whirlwind of white foam and mist that is hurled tens of meters into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005281898658722639 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255281925201416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005281898658722639, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005281898658722639, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14752717316150665, + 0.06971818953752518, + 0.04047776013612747, + 0.21281267702579498, + 0.06721540540456772, + 0.030437691137194633, + 0.06263169646263123, + 0.13344523310661316, + 0.05713555961847305, + 0.17859865725040436 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005281898658722639 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an extremely low angle just above the sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static without any movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive wave with a deep turquoise base transitioning to translucent emerald green visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave crash against a weathered, angular black volcanic reef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wave explode into a whirlwind of white foam and mist that is hurled tens of meters into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812633082270622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288126230239868 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812633082270622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812633082270622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1310959905385971, + 0.0715067982673645, + 0.03582051023840904, + 0.17121773958206177, + 0.057809632271528244, + 0.07083053141832352, + 0.11946054548025131, + 0.09109533578157425, + 0.03137454763054848, + 0.21978837251663208 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812633082270622 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an extremely low angle just above the sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static without any movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive wave with a deep turquoise base transitioning to translucent emerald green visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave crash against a weathered, angular black volcanic reef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wave explode into a whirlwind of white foam and mist that is hurled tens of meters into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012546772137284279 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387546539306641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012546772137284279, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012546772137284279, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0646950975060463, + 0.04840175062417984, + 0.03341897577047348, + 0.16125686466693878, + 0.06585503369569778, + 0.041419655084609985, + 0.029022682458162308, + 0.16785010695457458, + 0.027691688388586044, + 0.3603881597518921 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012546772137284279 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, static shot, shot from an extremely low angle just above the sea, captures a massive wave, like a liquid mountain, crashing with unstoppable force against a weathered, angular black volcanic reef. The wave's base is a deep turquoise, gradually transitioning to a translucent emerald green. Its curving crest begins to tear into white foam. At the moment of impact, the massive wave's main body explodes, disintegrating into a whirlwind of white foam and mist. This vast cloud of white mist is hurled tens of meters into the air, its millions of crystalline droplets gleaming silver in the dramatic diffuse light of the overcast sky before cascading down like a torrential rain. The wet black reef shimmers beneath the impact, creating a stark contrast with the raging whitewater. The entire scene, set against the leaden sky, is imbued with a raw, majestic, and awe-inspiring sense of natural power, creating an atmosphere of tension and grandeur.", + "seed": 6826, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_2/index_6595_seed_6826_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.252946912124753, + "vlm_logprob": -0.252946912124753, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.252946912124753, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an extremely low angle just above the sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static without any movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive wave with a deep turquoise base transitioning to translucent emerald green visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave crash against a weathered, angular black volcanic reef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wave explode into a whirlwind of white foam and mist that is hurled tens of meters into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1023925393819809 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4773924350738525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1023925393819809, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1023925393819809, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17905904352664948, + 0.08357221633195877, + 0.48997944593429565, + 0.03129442781209946, + 0.03908815607428551, + 0.022825906053185463, + 0.03977527841925621, + 0.017101364210247993, + 0.026471830904483795, + 0.0708322748541832 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1023925393819809 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an extremely low angle just above the sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static without any movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive wave with a deep turquoise base transitioning to translucent emerald green visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave crash against a weathered, angular black volcanic reef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wave explode into a whirlwind of white foam and mist that is hurled tens of meters into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370726823806763 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38707268238067627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.1370726823806763, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.1370726823806763, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16170205175876617, + 0.04290451854467392, + 0.1830615997314453, + 0.025294072926044464, + 0.04039715230464935, + 0.030414054170250893, + 0.03398112580180168, + 0.03287477418780327, + 0.03320341929793358, + 0.416167289018631 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.1370726823806763 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an extremely low angle just above the sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static without any movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive wave with a deep turquoise base transitioning to translucent emerald green visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave crash against a weathered, angular black volcanic reef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wave explode into a whirlwind of white foam and mist that is hurled tens of meters into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005977965891361237 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130978107452393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005977965891361237, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005977965891361237, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12122401595115662, + 0.12395107001066208, + 0.29850849509239197, + 0.04517621919512749, + 0.034254517406225204, + 0.03315423056483269, + 0.06508583575487137, + 0.04517189785838127, + 0.059624407440423965, + 0.17384926974773407 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005977965891361237 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an extremely low angle just above the sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static without any movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive wave with a deep turquoise base transitioning to translucent emerald green visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave crash against a weathered, angular black volcanic reef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wave explode into a whirlwind of white foam and mist that is hurled tens of meters into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006745306774973869 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006745338439941 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006745306774973869, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006745306774973869, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10237864404916763, + 0.20287489891052246, + 0.12373559176921844, + 0.036656416952610016, + 0.061975229531526566, + 0.026152722537517548, + 0.032865893095731735, + 0.0816085934638977, + 0.07893751561641693, + 0.25281450152397156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006745306774973869 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an extremely low angle just above the sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static without any movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive wave with a deep turquoise base transitioning to translucent emerald green visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave crash against a weathered, angular black volcanic reef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wave explode into a whirlwind of white foam and mist that is hurled tens of meters into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01254606619477272 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387546062469482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01254606619477272, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01254606619477272, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14377455413341522, + 0.058278344571590424, + 0.27478131651878357, + 0.021985992789268494, + 0.04989554360508919, + 0.024555465206503868, + 0.034357406198978424, + 0.0987406075000763, + 0.037405338138341904, + 0.25622546672821045 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01254606619477272 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide, static shot, shot from an extremely low angle just above the sea, captures a massive wave, like a liquid mountain, crashing with unstoppable force against a weathered, angular black volcanic reef. The wave's base is a deep turquoise, gradually transitioning to a translucent emerald green. Its curving crest begins to tear into white foam. At the moment of impact, the massive wave's main body explodes, disintegrating into a whirlwind of white foam and mist. This vast cloud of white mist is hurled tens of meters into the air, its millions of crystalline droplets gleaming silver in the dramatic diffuse light of the overcast sky before cascading down like a torrential rain. The wet black reef shimmers beneath the impact, creating a stark contrast with the raging whitewater. The entire scene, set against the leaden sky, is imbued with a raw, majestic, and awe-inspiring sense of natural power, creating an atmosphere of tension and grandeur.", + "seed": 6827, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_2/index_6595_seed_6827_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.3193140727933496, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3193140727933496, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.074999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3193140727933496, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an extremely low angle just above the sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static without any movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive wave with a deep turquoise base transitioning to translucent emerald green visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave crash against a weathered, angular black volcanic reef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wave explode into a whirlwind of white foam and mist that is hurled tens of meters into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05445532873272896 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.054455280303955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05445532873272896, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05445532873272896, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20624776184558868, + 0.1420956254005432, + 0.07695648819208145, + 0.06549809873104095, + 0.11516937613487244, + 0.09681807458400726, + 0.05317350849509239, + 0.1040143221616745, + 0.04139336198568344, + 0.09863344579935074 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05445532873272896 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an extremely low angle just above the sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static without any movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive wave with a deep turquoise base transitioning to translucent emerald green visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave crash against a weathered, angular black volcanic reef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wave explode into a whirlwind of white foam and mist that is hurled tens of meters into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020811557769775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520811855792999 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5020811557769775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5020811557769775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27413952350616455, + 0.0755426287651062, + 0.0931912213563919, + 0.02881312184035778, + 0.03590136393904686, + 0.0961390882730484, + 0.03728904575109482, + 0.057084549218416214, + 0.12244311720132828, + 0.17945635318756104 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5020811557769775 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an extremely low angle just above the sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static without any movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive wave with a deep turquoise base transitioning to translucent emerald green visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave crash against a weathered, angular black volcanic reef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wave explode into a whirlwind of white foam and mist that is hurled tens of meters into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036383166443556547 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.62863826751709 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036383166443556547, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036383166443556547, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23242776095867157, + 0.09064020216464996, + 0.1064336821436882, + 0.05394722521305084, + 0.07337449491024017, + 0.02970612235367298, + 0.14319150149822235, + 0.07268230617046356, + 0.054529186338186264, + 0.14306746423244476 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036383166443556547 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an extremely low angle just above the sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static without any movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive wave with a deep turquoise base transitioning to translucent emerald green visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave crash against a weathered, angular black volcanic reef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wave explode into a whirlwind of white foam and mist that is hurled tens of meters into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018202640116214752 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018202781677246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018202640116214752, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018202640116214752, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26864326000213623, + 0.05892476812005043, + 0.14644855260849, + 0.10810813307762146, + 0.05349096283316612, + 0.07106059044599533, + 0.03836672380566597, + 0.0909508541226387, + 0.06507181376218796, + 0.09893438965082169 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018202640116214752 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from an extremely low angle just above the sea?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static without any movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive wave with a deep turquoise base transitioning to translucent emerald green visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the wave crash against a weathered, angular black volcanic reef?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the wave explode into a whirlwind of white foam and mist that is hurled tens of meters into the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018192922696471214 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018192768096924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018192922696471214, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018192922696471214, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22152191400527954, + 0.08370709419250488, + 0.13234570622444153, + 0.031592149287462234, + 0.04673454537987709, + 0.02321554347872734, + 0.06359325349330902, + 0.07774946093559265, + 0.07496077567338943, + 0.24457956850528717 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018192922696471214 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_3/index_tensor([6804, 6804])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_3/index_tensor([6804, 6804])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4a44853fbb285dc332a3cb37c01f64f6bb3ba9a5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_3/index_tensor([6804, 6804])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, shot upward from the ground, the camera held still, captured a flaming meteor streaking across the dusky sky at breakneck speed. The meteorite's surface, jagged and obsidian-black, was enveloped in a layer of white-hot plasma, trailing a fiery trail of orange and yellow sparks, its tip a dazzling blue-white glow from its intense friction with the atmosphere. As it violently impacted the vast, cracked desert floor, it erupted in a silent but visually devastating orb of energy. Immediately afterwards, a distinct, circular shockwave expanded outward at supersonic speed, distorting the distant horizon and instantly shredding the sparse, withered shrubbery on the ground. Simultaneously, a massive mushroom cloud of pulverized rock and superheated dust tumbled skyward, its interior lit in a chaotic haze by the blazing glow of the impact crater, hurling countless flaming fragments in all directions. The entire scene was dominated by the dazzling light generated by the collision, casting long and violently swaying shadows. Against the dark blue and dark purple night sky, it created a tense atmosphere like the coming of the end of the world, full of primitive power and awe.", + "seed": 19123, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_3/index_6804_seed_19123_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.26815125346183777, + "vlm_logprob": -0.26815125346183777, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.26815125346183777, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a jagged, obsidian-black meteor with white-hot plasma and a blue-white tip visible streaking across the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the meteor impact a vast, cracked desert floor creating a circular shockwave and a mushroom cloud of pulverized rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark blue and dark purple night sky with sparse, withered shrubbery on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04326183348894119 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.293261766433716 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04326183348894119, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04326183348894119, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24085262417793274, + 0.18072794377803802, + 0.11330593377351761, + 0.10283296555280685, + 0.16807684302330017, + 0.03125918656587601, + 0.04103968292474747, + 0.030352666974067688, + 0.06765684485435486, + 0.023895252496004105 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04326183348894119 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a jagged, obsidian-black meteor with white-hot plasma and a blue-white tip visible streaking across the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the meteor impact a vast, cracked desert floor creating a circular shockwave and a mushroom cloud of pulverized rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark blue and dark purple night sky with sparse, withered shrubbery on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236454486846924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34864547848701477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2236454486846924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2236454486846924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.159388929605484, + 0.07812962681055069, + 0.10906674712896347, + 0.1274908483028412, + 0.13854436576366425, + 0.048413559794425964, + 0.059196602553129196, + 0.07141412049531937, + 0.05454559624195099, + 0.15380960702896118 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2236454486846924 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a jagged, obsidian-black meteor with white-hot plasma and a blue-white tip visible streaking across the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the meteor impact a vast, cracked desert floor creating a circular shockwave and a mushroom cloud of pulverized rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark blue and dark purple night sky with sparse, withered shrubbery on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02983037196099758 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298304557800293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02983037196099758, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02983037196099758, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3266695439815521, + 0.17332260310649872, + 0.14017680287361145, + 0.10550514608621597, + 0.057090967893600464, + 0.02746826969087124, + 0.030312106013298035, + 0.04103933274745941, + 0.06255530565977097, + 0.03585989400744438 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02983037196099758 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a jagged, obsidian-black meteor with white-hot plasma and a blue-white tip visible streaking across the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the meteor impact a vast, cracked desert floor creating a circular shockwave and a mushroom cloud of pulverized rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark blue and dark purple night sky with sparse, withered shrubbery on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014202704653143883 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26420259475708 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014202704653143883, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014202704653143883, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2200222909450531, + 0.1399516761302948, + 0.1020326167345047, + 0.10814116895198822, + 0.1874261498451233, + 0.07132301479578018, + 0.03146742656826973, + 0.031138695776462555, + 0.08224165439605713, + 0.02625533565878868 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014202704653143883 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a jagged, obsidian-black meteor with white-hot plasma and a blue-white tip visible streaking across the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the meteor impact a vast, cracked desert floor creating a circular shockwave and a mushroom cloud of pulverized rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark blue and dark purple night sky with sparse, withered shrubbery on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029815908521413803 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529815912246704 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029815908521413803, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029815908521413803, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1812049001455307, + 0.06489137560129166, + 0.143376424908638, + 0.22514817118644714, + 0.10416243970394135, + 0.0947599858045578, + 0.03792795538902283, + 0.07463661581277847, + 0.04137692227959633, + 0.03251517564058304 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029815908521413803 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, shot upward from the ground, the camera held still, captured a flaming meteor streaking across the dusky sky at breakneck speed. The meteorite's surface, jagged and obsidian-black, was enveloped in a layer of white-hot plasma, trailing a fiery trail of orange and yellow sparks, its tip a dazzling blue-white glow from its intense friction with the atmosphere. As it violently impacted the vast, cracked desert floor, it erupted in a silent but visually devastating orb of energy. Immediately afterwards, a distinct, circular shockwave expanded outward at supersonic speed, distorting the distant horizon and instantly shredding the sparse, withered shrubbery on the ground. Simultaneously, a massive mushroom cloud of pulverized rock and superheated dust tumbled skyward, its interior lit in a chaotic haze by the blazing glow of the impact crater, hurling countless flaming fragments in all directions. The entire scene was dominated by the dazzling light generated by the collision, casting long and violently swaying shadows. Against the dark blue and dark purple night sky, it created a tense atmosphere like the coming of the end of the world, full of primitive power and awe.", + "seed": 19124, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_3/index_6804_seed_19124_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.39416754301637413, + "vlm_logprob": -0.39416754301637413, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.39416754301637413, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a jagged, obsidian-black meteor with white-hot plasma and a blue-white tip visible streaking across the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the meteor impact a vast, cracked desert floor creating a circular shockwave and a mushroom cloud of pulverized rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark blue and dark purple night sky with sparse, withered shrubbery on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08468595147132874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.584686040878296 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08468595147132874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08468595147132874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3034823536872864, + 0.10969147831201553, + 0.11851035058498383, + 0.041959498077631, + 0.047456417232751846, + 0.02645055390894413, + 0.0318380631506443, + 0.038894906640052795, + 0.08683724701404572, + 0.1948791891336441 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08468595147132874 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a jagged, obsidian-black meteor with white-hot plasma and a blue-white tip visible streaking across the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the meteor impact a vast, cracked desert floor creating a circular shockwave and a mushroom cloud of pulverized rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark blue and dark purple night sky with sparse, withered shrubbery on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.13709557056427 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870956003665924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.13709557056427, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.13709557056427, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25513923168182373, + 0.14880461990833282, + 0.19071654975414276, + 0.07717326283454895, + 0.036983806639909744, + 0.0308355912566185, + 0.038542695343494415, + 0.046940188854932785, + 0.053639668971300125, + 0.12122443318367004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.13709557056427 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a jagged, obsidian-black meteor with white-hot plasma and a blue-white tip visible streaking across the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the meteor impact a vast, cracked desert floor creating a circular shockwave and a mushroom cloud of pulverized rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark blue and dark purple night sky with sparse, withered shrubbery on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6934136748313904 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6934136748313904 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6934136748313904, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6934136748313904, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5031957030296326, + 0.11160089820623398, + 0.1145472377538681, + 0.042319104075431824, + 0.042799871414899826, + 0.014629091136157513, + 0.024417389184236526, + 0.021938201040029526, + 0.04535236954689026, + 0.07920020073652267 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6934136748313904 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a jagged, obsidian-black meteor with white-hot plasma and a blue-white tip visible streaking across the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the meteor impact a vast, cracked desert floor creating a circular shockwave and a mushroom cloud of pulverized rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark blue and dark purple night sky with sparse, withered shrubbery on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309845343232155 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680984497070312 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309845343232155, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309845343232155, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3762897253036499, + 0.12051337957382202, + 0.10859347879886627, + 0.058968693017959595, + 0.044968023896217346, + 0.01301805954426527, + 0.021030409261584282, + 0.031172731891274452, + 0.07511727511882782, + 0.15032823383808136 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309845343232155 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a jagged, obsidian-black meteor with white-hot plasma and a blue-white tip visible streaking across the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the meteor impact a vast, cracked desert floor creating a circular shockwave and a mushroom cloud of pulverized rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark blue and dark purple night sky with sparse, withered shrubbery on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012544064782559872 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38754415512085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012544064782559872, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012544064782559872, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2616186738014221, + 0.12236375361680984, + 0.1100677102804184, + 0.07191827148199081, + 0.0712716355919838, + 0.02659638598561287, + 0.028409581631422043, + 0.035031821578741074, + 0.07500918209552765, + 0.19771303236484528 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012544064782559872 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, shot upward from the ground, the camera held still, captured a flaming meteor streaking across the dusky sky at breakneck speed. The meteorite's surface, jagged and obsidian-black, was enveloped in a layer of white-hot plasma, trailing a fiery trail of orange and yellow sparks, its tip a dazzling blue-white glow from its intense friction with the atmosphere. As it violently impacted the vast, cracked desert floor, it erupted in a silent but visually devastating orb of energy. Immediately afterwards, a distinct, circular shockwave expanded outward at supersonic speed, distorting the distant horizon and instantly shredding the sparse, withered shrubbery on the ground. Simultaneously, a massive mushroom cloud of pulverized rock and superheated dust tumbled skyward, its interior lit in a chaotic haze by the blazing glow of the impact crater, hurling countless flaming fragments in all directions. The entire scene was dominated by the dazzling light generated by the collision, casting long and violently swaying shadows. Against the dark blue and dark purple night sky, it created a tense atmosphere like the coming of the end of the world, full of primitive power and awe.", + "seed": 19125, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_3/index_6804_seed_19125_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.2910305678844452, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2910305678844452, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2910305678844452, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a jagged, obsidian-black meteor with white-hot plasma and a blue-white tip visible streaking across the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the meteor impact a vast, cracked desert floor creating a circular shockwave and a mushroom cloud of pulverized rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark blue and dark purple night sky with sparse, withered shrubbery on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12221457064151764 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3722145557403564 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12221457064151764, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12221457064151764, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2128266990184784, + 0.15042540431022644, + 0.2279038280248642, + 0.06628693640232086, + 0.03655683621764183, + 0.04505619406700134, + 0.06781686842441559, + 0.06555744260549545, + 0.05449030548334122, + 0.07307952642440796 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12221457064151764 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a jagged, obsidian-black meteor with white-hot plasma and a blue-white tip visible streaking across the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the meteor impact a vast, cracked desert floor creating a circular shockwave and a mushroom cloud of pulverized rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark blue and dark purple night sky with sparse, withered shrubbery on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.757859468460083 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.632859468460083 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.757859468460083, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.757859468460083, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.287280410528183, + 0.09750129282474518, + 0.13189184665679932, + 0.12994474172592163, + 0.1516304910182953, + 0.01820533163845539, + 0.03504098951816559, + 0.07130096852779388, + 0.04425017908215523, + 0.032953787595033646 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.757859468460083 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a jagged, obsidian-black meteor with white-hot plasma and a blue-white tip visible streaking across the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the meteor impact a vast, cracked desert floor creating a circular shockwave and a mushroom cloud of pulverized rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark blue and dark purple night sky with sparse, withered shrubbery on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233515501022339 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983515501022339 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233515501022339, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233515501022339, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4774153530597687, + 0.10360043495893478, + 0.15462544560432434, + 0.033878475427627563, + 0.03491511568427086, + 0.028882533311843872, + 0.028082789853215218, + 0.0573333315551281, + 0.040897827595472336, + 0.040368713438510895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233515501022339 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a jagged, obsidian-black meteor with white-hot plasma and a blue-white tip visible streaking across the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the meteor impact a vast, cracked desert floor creating a circular shockwave and a mushroom cloud of pulverized rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark blue and dark purple night sky with sparse, withered shrubbery on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308566451072693 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680855751037598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308566451072693, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308566451072693, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24174058437347412, + 0.11180881410837173, + 0.18651628494262695, + 0.040001824498176575, + 0.0690237358212471, + 0.060098446905612946, + 0.0936654582619667, + 0.08745621889829636, + 0.045109398663043976, + 0.06457926332950592 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308566451072693 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a jagged, obsidian-black meteor with white-hot plasma and a blue-white tip visible streaking across the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the meteor impact a vast, cracked desert floor creating a circular shockwave and a mushroom cloud of pulverized rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark blue and dark purple night sky with sparse, withered shrubbery on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00864158570766449 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758641719818115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00864158570766449, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00864158570766449, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35719650983810425, + 0.08671090006828308, + 0.13937318325042725, + 0.06338173151016235, + 0.05201028659939766, + 0.11823348701000214, + 0.056724365800619125, + 0.03953307121992111, + 0.03563879430294037, + 0.051197633147239685 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00864158570766449 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot, shot upward from the ground, the camera held still, captured a flaming meteor streaking across the dusky sky at breakneck speed. The meteorite's surface, jagged and obsidian-black, was enveloped in a layer of white-hot plasma, trailing a fiery trail of orange and yellow sparks, its tip a dazzling blue-white glow from its intense friction with the atmosphere. As it violently impacted the vast, cracked desert floor, it erupted in a silent but visually devastating orb of energy. Immediately afterwards, a distinct, circular shockwave expanded outward at supersonic speed, distorting the distant horizon and instantly shredding the sparse, withered shrubbery on the ground. Simultaneously, a massive mushroom cloud of pulverized rock and superheated dust tumbled skyward, its interior lit in a chaotic haze by the blazing glow of the impact crater, hurling countless flaming fragments in all directions. The entire scene was dominated by the dazzling light generated by the collision, casting long and violently swaying shadows. Against the dark blue and dark purple night sky, it created a tense atmosphere like the coming of the end of the world, full of primitive power and awe.", + "seed": 19126, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_3/index_6804_seed_19126_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.33280379716306924, + "vlm_logprob": -0.33280379716306924, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1499999523162843, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.33280379716306924, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a jagged, obsidian-black meteor with white-hot plasma and a blue-white tip visible streaking across the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the meteor impact a vast, cracked desert floor creating a circular shockwave and a mushroom cloud of pulverized rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark blue and dark purple night sky with sparse, withered shrubbery on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019421767443418503 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.269421577453613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019421767443418503, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019421767443418503, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2414141744375229, + 0.055431436747312546, + 0.09292494505643845, + 0.040824826806783676, + 0.1401156634092331, + 0.013821995817124844, + 0.05569464713335037, + 0.09954465925693512, + 0.20098821818828583, + 0.059239499270915985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019421767443418503 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a jagged, obsidian-black meteor with white-hot plasma and a blue-white tip visible streaking across the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the meteor impact a vast, cracked desert floor creating a circular shockwave and a mushroom cloud of pulverized rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark blue and dark purple night sky with sparse, withered shrubbery on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005572080612183 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22555725276470184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.6005572080612183, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.6005572080612183, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1371379792690277, + 0.14258015155792236, + 0.10783621668815613, + 0.06427016109228134, + 0.02654372714459896, + 0.03462087735533714, + 0.06774310022592545, + 0.08875857293605804, + 0.1351875364780426, + 0.19532166421413422 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.6005572080612183 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a jagged, obsidian-black meteor with white-hot plasma and a blue-white tip visible streaking across the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the meteor impact a vast, cracked desert floor creating a circular shockwave and a mushroom cloud of pulverized rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark blue and dark purple night sky with sparse, withered shrubbery on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01821446232497692 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018214225769043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01821446232497692, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01821446232497692, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42904287576675415, + 0.07089198380708694, + 0.10683057457208633, + 0.03404277190566063, + 0.020540734753012657, + 0.015770385041832924, + 0.041465118527412415, + 0.10732515156269073, + 0.10877123475074768, + 0.0653192326426506 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01821446232497692 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a jagged, obsidian-black meteor with white-hot plasma and a blue-white tip visible streaking across the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the meteor impact a vast, cracked desert floor creating a circular shockwave and a mushroom cloud of pulverized rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark blue and dark purple night sky with sparse, withered shrubbery on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007633444853127003 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882633209228516 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007633444853127003, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007633444853127003, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1977553516626358, + 0.17578887939453125, + 0.2011670470237732, + 0.026033321395516396, + 0.14546848833560944, + 0.03264535963535309, + 0.03106323443353176, + 0.08866114914417267, + 0.05820837616920471, + 0.04320875555276871 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007633444853127003 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot from a low angle looking upward from the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a jagged, obsidian-black meteor with white-hot plasma and a blue-white tip visible streaking across the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the meteor impact a vast, cracked desert floor creating a circular shockwave and a mushroom cloud of pulverized rock?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark blue and dark purple night sky with sparse, withered shrubbery on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018192103132605553 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018192291259766 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018192103132605553, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018192103132605553, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33329638838768005, + 0.06228940933942795, + 0.08071013540029526, + 0.09605609625577927, + 0.06689269840717316, + 0.02439739927649498, + 0.02864152006804943, + 0.057218343019485474, + 0.16229526698589325, + 0.08820271492004395 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018192103132605553 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_4/index_tensor([2515, 2515])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_4/index_tensor([2515, 2515])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..28ca20f7c05df4fe5ca5d0699e64950ca11dbd7c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_4/index_tensor([2515, 2515])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "This low-angle, static close-up, filmed at a crisp high frame rate, capturing the action in satisfying slow motion, focuses on a tiny fiddler crab resting on a sun-drenched, damp beach. The crab's carapace, speckled with sandy brown and cream, gleams in the bright sunlight, while its small, sturdy eyes gaze forward. Its most striking feature is a comically oversized right claw, a vibrant, saturated orange that contrasts sharply with its body and the golden sand. Firmly anchored in the shimmering, crowded sand, the crab enthusiastically waves this massive claw back and forth in a wide, rhythmic arc. The slow-motion capture highlights every detail of this absurdly joyful pose, mimicking a happy dog wagging its tail. The claw swings smoothly from side to side, its immense weight causing the crab's body to sway slightly with the effort. The shallow depth of field blurs the background into a beautiful, shimmering sunbeam, casting a shadow on the gentle turquoise waves lapping against the shore. Strong, direct sunlight casts the sharp, dark shadows of the dancing crabs across the sand, creating a vibrant scene that perfectly encapsulates nature’s moments of lightheartedness, charm, and comedy.", + "seed": 5040, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_4/index_2515_seed_5040_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.029829333210363983, + "vlm_logprob": -0.029829333210363983, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.029829333210363983, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static close-up of a tiny fiddler crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's right claw vibrant orange and comically oversized compared to its body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace speckled with sandy brown and cream colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab wave its massive claw back and forth in a wide, rhythmic arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field while turquoise waves lap against the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010576740838587284 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7605767250061035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010576740838587284, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010576740838587284, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0875735729932785, + 0.047490984201431274, + 0.5573012828826904, + 0.05707262456417084, + 0.046328749507665634, + 0.024196172133088112, + 0.026849431917071342, + 0.08039171248674393, + 0.032939061522483826, + 0.03985646367073059 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010576740838587284 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static close-up of a tiny fiddler crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's right claw vibrant orange and comically oversized compared to its body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace speckled with sandy brown and cream colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab wave its massive claw back and forth in a wide, rhythmic arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field while turquoise waves lap against the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016083618625998497 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141083717346191 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016083618625998497, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016083618625998497, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13930006325244904, + 0.11855610460042953, + 0.19415943324565887, + 0.06158661097288132, + 0.08835545927286148, + 0.034622132778167725, + 0.03745758906006813, + 0.04834246635437012, + 0.09242737293243408, + 0.1851927489042282 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016083618625998497 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static close-up of a tiny fiddler crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's right claw vibrant orange and comically oversized compared to its body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace speckled with sandy brown and cream colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab wave its massive claw back and forth in a wide, rhythmic arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field while turquoise waves lap against the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059457337483763695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130945682525635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059457337483763695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059457337483763695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14133967459201813, + 0.08711443841457367, + 0.31123462319374084, + 0.10400417447090149, + 0.10013022273778915, + 0.03406643867492676, + 0.04404861852526665, + 0.058744799345731735, + 0.04056095331907272, + 0.07875602692365646 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059457337483763695 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static close-up of a tiny fiddler crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's right claw vibrant orange and comically oversized compared to its body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace speckled with sandy brown and cream colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab wave its massive claw back and forth in a wide, rhythmic arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field while turquoise waves lap against the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11292755603790283 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379274368286133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11292755603790283, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11292755603790283, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12496388703584671, + 0.04129955545067787, + 0.491857647895813, + 0.04531719535589218, + 0.08099434524774551, + 0.037235625088214874, + 0.02467501163482666, + 0.057562217116355896, + 0.02294163964688778, + 0.07315284013748169 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11292755603790283 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static close-up of a tiny fiddler crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's right claw vibrant orange and comically oversized compared to its body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace speckled with sandy brown and cream colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab wave its massive claw back and forth in a wide, rhythmic arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field while turquoise waves lap against the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003613016800954938 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628612995147705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003613016800954938, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003613016800954938, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08512893319129944, + 0.043802984058856964, + 0.5046210289001465, + 0.0635443925857544, + 0.07671463489532471, + 0.022825563326478004, + 0.0370648093521595, + 0.0436159111559391, + 0.08399826288223267, + 0.0386834517121315 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003613016800954938 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This low-angle, static close-up, filmed at a crisp high frame rate, capturing the action in satisfying slow motion, focuses on a tiny fiddler crab resting on a sun-drenched, damp beach. The crab's carapace, speckled with sandy brown and cream, gleams in the bright sunlight, while its small, sturdy eyes gaze forward. Its most striking feature is a comically oversized right claw, a vibrant, saturated orange that contrasts sharply with its body and the golden sand. Firmly anchored in the shimmering, crowded sand, the crab enthusiastically waves this massive claw back and forth in a wide, rhythmic arc. The slow-motion capture highlights every detail of this absurdly joyful pose, mimicking a happy dog wagging its tail. The claw swings smoothly from side to side, its immense weight causing the crab's body to sway slightly with the effort. The shallow depth of field blurs the background into a beautiful, shimmering sunbeam, casting a shadow on the gentle turquoise waves lapping against the shore. Strong, direct sunlight casts the sharp, dark shadows of the dancing crabs across the sand, creating a vibrant scene that perfectly encapsulates nature’s moments of lightheartedness, charm, and comedy.", + "seed": 5041, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_4/index_2515_seed_5041_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02902918476611376, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02902918476611376, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02902918476611376, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static close-up of a tiny fiddler crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's right claw vibrant orange and comically oversized compared to its body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace speckled with sandy brown and cream colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab wave its massive claw back and forth in a wide, rhythmic arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field while turquoise waves lap against the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015010149218142033 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.390010356903076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015010149218142033, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015010149218142033, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11926310509443283, + 0.0755571722984314, + 0.4482715427875519, + 0.028633033856749535, + 0.029162965714931488, + 0.16348133981227875, + 0.05206260457634926, + 0.03911503404378891, + 0.025532253086566925, + 0.018920965492725372 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015010149218142033 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static close-up of a tiny fiddler crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's right claw vibrant orange and comically oversized compared to its body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace speckled with sandy brown and cream colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab wave its massive claw back and forth in a wide, rhythmic arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field while turquoise waves lap against the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02330368012189865 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773303747177124 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02330368012189865, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02330368012189865, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09351041913032532, + 0.18686626851558685, + 0.5102584958076477, + 0.055727824568748474, + 0.02231815829873085, + 0.032308321446180344, + 0.010662159882485867, + 0.02593117207288742, + 0.028458619490265846, + 0.033958613872528076 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02330368012189865 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static close-up of a tiny fiddler crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's right claw vibrant orange and comically oversized compared to its body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace speckled with sandy brown and cream colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab wave its massive claw back and forth in a wide, rhythmic arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field while turquoise waves lap against the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011073208414018154 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511073112487793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011073208414018154, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011073208414018154, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16533559560775757, + 0.20443420112133026, + 0.18344072997570038, + 0.06626123189926147, + 0.12902730703353882, + 0.04377961903810501, + 0.04412328824400902, + 0.06889311969280243, + 0.025101523846387863, + 0.06960335373878479 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011073208414018154 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static close-up of a tiny fiddler crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's right claw vibrant orange and comically oversized compared to its body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace speckled with sandy brown and cream colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab wave its massive claw back and forth in a wide, rhythmic arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field while turquoise waves lap against the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08902506530284882 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640250205993652 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08902506530284882, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08902506530284882, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07319362461566925, + 0.042220063507556915, + 0.4271010458469391, + 0.026678819209337234, + 0.28040164709091187, + 0.03987043350934982, + 0.018854821100831032, + 0.024638798087835312, + 0.014678049832582474, + 0.052362702786922455 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08902506530284882 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static close-up of a tiny fiddler crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's right claw vibrant orange and comically oversized compared to its body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace speckled with sandy brown and cream colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab wave its massive claw back and forth in a wide, rhythmic arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field while turquoise waves lap against the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006733820773661137 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067338943481445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006733820773661137, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006733820773661137, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0821601152420044, + 0.17270717024803162, + 0.5041788220405579, + 0.011025110259652138, + 0.10517210513353348, + 0.033928945660591125, + 0.026691311970353127, + 0.025778306648135185, + 0.018361929804086685, + 0.019996143877506256 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006733820773661137 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This low-angle, static close-up, filmed at a crisp high frame rate, capturing the action in satisfying slow motion, focuses on a tiny fiddler crab resting on a sun-drenched, damp beach. The crab's carapace, speckled with sandy brown and cream, gleams in the bright sunlight, while its small, sturdy eyes gaze forward. Its most striking feature is a comically oversized right claw, a vibrant, saturated orange that contrasts sharply with its body and the golden sand. Firmly anchored in the shimmering, crowded sand, the crab enthusiastically waves this massive claw back and forth in a wide, rhythmic arc. The slow-motion capture highlights every detail of this absurdly joyful pose, mimicking a happy dog wagging its tail. The claw swings smoothly from side to side, its immense weight causing the crab's body to sway slightly with the effort. The shallow depth of field blurs the background into a beautiful, shimmering sunbeam, casting a shadow on the gentle turquoise waves lapping against the shore. Strong, direct sunlight casts the sharp, dark shadows of the dancing crabs across the sand, creating a vibrant scene that perfectly encapsulates nature’s moments of lightheartedness, charm, and comedy.", + "seed": 5042, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_4/index_2515_seed_5042_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.019484869111329316, + "vlm_logprob": -0.019484869111329316, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.019484869111329316, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static close-up of a tiny fiddler crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's right claw vibrant orange and comically oversized compared to its body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace speckled with sandy brown and cream colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab wave its massive claw back and forth in a wide, rhythmic arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field while turquoise waves lap against the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.025458840653300285 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.775458812713623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.025458840653300285, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.025458840653300285, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03589700907468796, + 0.03461536020040512, + 0.06440205872058868, + 0.05706155672669411, + 0.07647240906953812, + 0.015750199556350708, + 0.04709922894835472, + 0.0481618195772171, + 0.14254847168922424, + 0.4779919385910034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.025458840653300285 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static close-up of a tiny fiddler crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's right claw vibrant orange and comically oversized compared to its body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace speckled with sandy brown and cream colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab wave its massive claw back and forth in a wide, rhythmic arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field while turquoise waves lap against the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020601458847522736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895601511001587 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020601458847522736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020601458847522736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06705942004919052, + 0.08198931813240051, + 0.12453342974185944, + 0.04307574778795242, + 0.08793603628873825, + 0.01789860613644123, + 0.023772206157445908, + 0.033206257969141006, + 0.2160949409008026, + 0.30443406105041504 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020601458847522736 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static close-up of a tiny fiddler crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's right claw vibrant orange and comically oversized compared to its body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace speckled with sandy brown and cream colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab wave its massive claw back and forth in a wide, rhythmic arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field while turquoise waves lap against the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00863721314817667 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758637428283691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00863721314817667, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00863721314817667, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08220109343528748, + 0.049311693757772446, + 0.08568460494279861, + 0.02567901648581028, + 0.06677909940481186, + 0.028146641328930855, + 0.018817847594618797, + 0.0635814294219017, + 0.06437913328409195, + 0.5154194235801697 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00863721314817667 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static close-up of a tiny fiddler crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's right claw vibrant orange and comically oversized compared to its body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace speckled with sandy brown and cream colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab wave its massive claw back and forth in a wide, rhythmic arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field while turquoise waves lap against the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0380924791097641 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880923748016357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0380924791097641, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0380924791097641, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10772345960140228, + 0.06913205236196518, + 0.03794081509113312, + 0.08479364961385727, + 0.04623394459486008, + 0.038425296545028687, + 0.05459386855363846, + 0.04658028855919838, + 0.05141713097691536, + 0.4631595313549042 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0380924791097641 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static close-up of a tiny fiddler crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's right claw vibrant orange and comically oversized compared to its body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace speckled with sandy brown and cream colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab wave its massive claw back and forth in a wide, rhythmic arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field while turquoise waves lap against the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004634353797882795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379634380340576 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004634353797882795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004634353797882795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03649161383509636, + 0.048148345202207565, + 0.02958996780216694, + 0.020633460953831673, + 0.018111316487193108, + 0.022509651258587837, + 0.010700729675590992, + 0.005103272385895252, + 0.416459858417511, + 0.39225172996520996 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004634353797882795 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This low-angle, static close-up, filmed at a crisp high frame rate, capturing the action in satisfying slow motion, focuses on a tiny fiddler crab resting on a sun-drenched, damp beach. The crab's carapace, speckled with sandy brown and cream, gleams in the bright sunlight, while its small, sturdy eyes gaze forward. Its most striking feature is a comically oversized right claw, a vibrant, saturated orange that contrasts sharply with its body and the golden sand. Firmly anchored in the shimmering, crowded sand, the crab enthusiastically waves this massive claw back and forth in a wide, rhythmic arc. The slow-motion capture highlights every detail of this absurdly joyful pose, mimicking a happy dog wagging its tail. The claw swings smoothly from side to side, its immense weight causing the crab's body to sway slightly with the effort. The shallow depth of field blurs the background into a beautiful, shimmering sunbeam, casting a shadow on the gentle turquoise waves lapping against the shore. Strong, direct sunlight casts the sharp, dark shadows of the dancing crabs across the sand, creating a vibrant scene that perfectly encapsulates nature’s moments of lightheartedness, charm, and comedy.", + "seed": 5043, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_4/index_2515_seed_5043_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.021068037394434212, + "vlm_logprob": -0.021068037394434212, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.021068037394434212, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static close-up of a tiny fiddler crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's right claw vibrant orange and comically oversized compared to its body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace speckled with sandy brown and cream colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab wave its massive claw back and forth in a wide, rhythmic arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field while turquoise waves lap against the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012967661023139954 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.637967586517334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012967661023139954, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012967661023139954, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1653526872396469, + 0.053204528987407684, + 0.04628748446702957, + 0.07671207934617996, + 0.20354464650154114, + 0.12426701188087463, + 0.14160600304603577, + 0.05316759645938873, + 0.06684380769729614, + 0.06901415437459946 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012967661023139954 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static close-up of a tiny fiddler crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's right claw vibrant orange and comically oversized compared to its body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace speckled with sandy brown and cream colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab wave its massive claw back and forth in a wide, rhythmic arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field while turquoise waves lap against the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01255748514086008 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387557506561279 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01255748514086008, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01255748514086008, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.152667835354805, + 0.1920720636844635, + 0.10933318734169006, + 0.08350203186273575, + 0.16558325290679932, + 0.13251595199108124, + 0.02251993864774704, + 0.06420296430587769, + 0.035762351006269455, + 0.04184040427207947 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01255748514086008 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static close-up of a tiny fiddler crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's right claw vibrant orange and comically oversized compared to its body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace speckled with sandy brown and cream colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab wave its massive claw back and forth in a wide, rhythmic arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field while turquoise waves lap against the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01253464724868536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875346183776855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01253464724868536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01253464724868536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2050018310546875, + 0.13876794278621674, + 0.06107337400317192, + 0.08530548214912415, + 0.20590142905712128, + 0.08193064481019974, + 0.03406447917222977, + 0.049646276980638504, + 0.0480252206325531, + 0.09028340131044388 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01253464724868536 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static close-up of a tiny fiddler crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's right claw vibrant orange and comically oversized compared to its body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace speckled with sandy brown and cream colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab wave its massive claw back and forth in a wide, rhythmic arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field while turquoise waves lap against the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620318166911602 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120317459106445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620318166911602, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620318166911602, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1612119823694229, + 0.06318971514701843, + 0.04900068789720535, + 0.0743461549282074, + 0.12421601265668869, + 0.19100460410118103, + 0.08119303733110428, + 0.09380335360765457, + 0.09506621956825256, + 0.06696824729442596 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620318166911602 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a low-angle, static close-up of a tiny fiddler crab?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's right claw vibrant orange and comically oversized compared to its body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the crab's carapace speckled with sandy brown and cream colors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the crab wave its massive claw back and forth in a wide, rhythmic arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred by a shallow depth of field while turquoise waves lap against the shore?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005248576868325472 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255248546600342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005248576868325472, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005248576868325472, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1642199456691742, + 0.07123780995607376, + 0.09974547475576401, + 0.057204023003578186, + 0.12800313532352448, + 0.11055854707956314, + 0.033720530569553375, + 0.11537779867649078, + 0.18716281652450562, + 0.03276991844177246 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005248576868325472 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_5/index_tensor([9987, 9987])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_5/index_tensor([9987, 9987])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8f6f8ca51f0c0fe03d95965d455e2f3d2acff542 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_5/index_tensor([9987, 9987])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, static shot from a slightly elevated angle captures a quiet moment of destruction. A single candle flame, its core a brilliant whitish-yellow tapering to a soft orange halo, gently licks the corner of a thick stack of old documents on a dark, polished wood surface. The paper, yellowed and brittle with age, reveals its fibrous texture and frayed edges in the intimate glow. When the flame makes contact, the corner of the paper doesn't suddenly burst into flame, but rather begins a slow, inexorable transformation. A deliberately dark line of char spreads from the point of contact, and the paper curls inward like a dying leaf. The heat causes the fibers to blacken, transforming into brittle gray ash, while thin, ethereal smoke rises gracefully into the surrounding darkness. The scene is illuminated entirely by the candle's warm, flickering light, creating a dramatic black-and-white contrast with deep, soft shadows, evoking a tense, secretive, and irreversible ending.", + "seed": 30370, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_5/index_9987_seed_30370_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.24215690353885294, + "vlm_logprob": -0.24215690353885294, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.24215690353885294, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single candle flame and a stack of documents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and positioned at a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the flame slowly charring the paper corner into gray ash without suddenly bursting into fire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated entirely by the candle's warm light, creating deep shadows and a high-contrast look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does thin, ethereal smoke rise gracefully from the burning paper into the surrounding darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9010766744613647 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5260766744613647 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9010766744613647, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9010766744613647, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42519253492355347, + 0.06702117621898651, + 0.04580186679959297, + 0.043119389563798904, + 0.05390544235706329, + 0.09944713115692139, + 0.07002122700214386, + 0.04531428962945938, + 0.033333636820316315, + 0.1168433427810669 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9010766744613647 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single candle flame and a stack of documents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and positioned at a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the flame slowly charring the paper corner into gray ash without suddenly bursting into fire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated entirely by the candle's warm light, creating deep shadows and a high-contrast look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does thin, ethereal smoke rise gracefully from the burning paper into the surrounding darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016102856025099754 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1411027908325195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016102856025099754, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016102856025099754, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04929936304688454, + 0.04460952430963516, + 0.018804026767611504, + 0.0246258694678545, + 0.043985746800899506, + 0.7066887617111206, + 0.03197006508708, + 0.021672504022717476, + 0.03557597100734711, + 0.02276817336678505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016102856025099754 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single candle flame and a stack of documents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and positioned at a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the flame slowly charring the paper corner into gray ash without suddenly bursting into fire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated entirely by the candle's warm light, creating deep shadows and a high-contrast look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does thin, ethereal smoke rise gracefully from the burning paper into the surrounding darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28133413195610046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063341617584229 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28133413195610046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28133413195610046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12197674810886383, + 0.04663943499326706, + 0.023777717724442482, + 0.05358206853270531, + 0.0374506413936615, + 0.4446856379508972, + 0.07052778452634811, + 0.05188978463411331, + 0.10077504068613052, + 0.048695143312215805 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28133413195610046 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single candle flame and a stack of documents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and positioned at a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the flame slowly charring the paper corner into gray ash without suddenly bursting into fire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated entirely by the candle's warm light, creating deep shadows and a high-contrast look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does thin, ethereal smoke rise gracefully from the burning paper into the surrounding darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00248968368396163 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.0024895668029785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00248968368396163, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00248968368396163, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08902543783187866, + 0.007710386533290148, + 0.008354098536074162, + 0.01272389106452465, + 0.013494132086634636, + 0.8337012529373169, + 0.010790633969008923, + 0.007754235062748194, + 0.0066781905479729176, + 0.009767690673470497 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00248968368396163 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single candle flame and a stack of documents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and positioned at a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the flame slowly charring the paper corner into gray ash without suddenly bursting into fire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated entirely by the candle's warm light, creating deep shadows and a high-contrast look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does thin, ethereal smoke rise gracefully from the burning paper into the surrounding darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009781171567738056 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634781360626221 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009781171567738056, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009781171567738056, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5363218784332275, + 0.0480409599840641, + 0.030916163697838783, + 0.028856346383690834, + 0.021620597690343857, + 0.2344948649406433, + 0.01805403269827366, + 0.02506229653954506, + 0.01907365582883358, + 0.03755907714366913 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009781171567738056 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, static shot from a slightly elevated angle captures a quiet moment of destruction. A single candle flame, its core a brilliant whitish-yellow tapering to a soft orange halo, gently licks the corner of a thick stack of old documents on a dark, polished wood surface. The paper, yellowed and brittle with age, reveals its fibrous texture and frayed edges in the intimate glow. When the flame makes contact, the corner of the paper doesn't suddenly burst into flame, but rather begins a slow, inexorable transformation. A deliberately dark line of char spreads from the point of contact, and the paper curls inward like a dying leaf. The heat causes the fibers to blacken, transforming into brittle gray ash, while thin, ethereal smoke rises gracefully into the surrounding darkness. The scene is illuminated entirely by the candle's warm, flickering light, creating a dramatic black-and-white contrast with deep, soft shadows, evoking a tense, secretive, and irreversible ending.", + "seed": 30371, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_5/index_9987_seed_30371_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.05768653065897524, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05768653065897524, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.624999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05768653065897524, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single candle flame and a stack of documents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and positioned at a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the flame slowly charring the paper corner into gray ash without suddenly bursting into fire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated entirely by the candle's warm light, creating deep shadows and a high-contrast look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does thin, ethereal smoke rise gracefully from the burning paper into the surrounding darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14402972161769867 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0190296173095703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14402972161769867, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14402972161769867, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14125001430511475, + 0.1385115385055542, + 0.3962481915950775, + 0.039442822337150574, + 0.01855825074017048, + 0.03338970988988876, + 0.010113045573234558, + 0.04233825206756592, + 0.028241222724318504, + 0.15190696716308594 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14402972161769867 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single candle flame and a stack of documents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and positioned at a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the flame slowly charring the paper corner into gray ash without suddenly bursting into fire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated entirely by the candle's warm light, creating deep shadows and a high-contrast look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does thin, ethereal smoke rise gracefully from the burning paper into the surrounding darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033730488270521164 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087305068969727 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033730488270521164, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033730488270521164, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08521325886249542, + 0.17224149405956268, + 0.2512228488922119, + 0.15853486955165863, + 0.031169308349490166, + 0.012754334136843681, + 0.01987762190401554, + 0.07707975804805756, + 0.056245118379592896, + 0.13566143810749054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033730488270521164 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single candle flame and a stack of documents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and positioned at a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the flame slowly charring the paper corner into gray ash without suddenly bursting into fire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated entirely by the candle's warm light, creating deep shadows and a high-contrast look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does thin, ethereal smoke rise gracefully from the burning paper into the surrounding darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10032002627849579 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503201007843018 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10032002627849579, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10032002627849579, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09923292696475983, + 0.2830696403980255, + 0.13407081365585327, + 0.051513250917196274, + 0.04986260458827019, + 0.0312095545232296, + 0.015203055925667286, + 0.07099603116512299, + 0.04748167470097542, + 0.21736054122447968 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10032002627849579 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single candle flame and a stack of documents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and positioned at a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the flame slowly charring the paper corner into gray ash without suddenly bursting into fire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated entirely by the candle's warm light, creating deep shadows and a high-contrast look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does thin, ethereal smoke rise gracefully from the burning paper into the surrounding darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003617530455812812 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628617763519287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003617530455812812, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003617530455812812, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08311492204666138, + 0.08406110107898712, + 0.3395857810974121, + 0.10047893226146698, + 0.027596181258559227, + 0.03506208956241608, + 0.016130942851305008, + 0.05638947710394859, + 0.031150221824645996, + 0.22643035650253296 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003617530455812812 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single candle flame and a stack of documents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and positioned at a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the flame slowly charring the paper corner into gray ash without suddenly bursting into fire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated entirely by the candle's warm light, creating deep shadows and a high-contrast look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does thin, ethereal smoke rise gracefully from the burning paper into the surrounding darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006734886672347784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006734848022461 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006734886672347784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006734886672347784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08532677590847015, + 0.3413868248462677, + 0.15971942245960236, + 0.10845668613910675, + 0.019906139001250267, + 0.016285328194499016, + 0.012085524387657642, + 0.07908102869987488, + 0.028308210894465446, + 0.14944405853748322 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006734886672347784 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, static shot from a slightly elevated angle captures a quiet moment of destruction. A single candle flame, its core a brilliant whitish-yellow tapering to a soft orange halo, gently licks the corner of a thick stack of old documents on a dark, polished wood surface. The paper, yellowed and brittle with age, reveals its fibrous texture and frayed edges in the intimate glow. When the flame makes contact, the corner of the paper doesn't suddenly burst into flame, but rather begins a slow, inexorable transformation. A deliberately dark line of char spreads from the point of contact, and the paper curls inward like a dying leaf. The heat causes the fibers to blacken, transforming into brittle gray ash, while thin, ethereal smoke rises gracefully into the surrounding darkness. The scene is illuminated entirely by the candle's warm, flickering light, creating a dramatic black-and-white contrast with deep, soft shadows, evoking a tense, secretive, and irreversible ending.", + "seed": 30372, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_5/index_9987_seed_30372_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10609247870743274, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10609247870743274, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.324999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10609247870743274, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single candle flame and a stack of documents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and positioned at a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the flame slowly charring the paper corner into gray ash without suddenly bursting into fire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated entirely by the candle's warm light, creating deep shadows and a high-contrast look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does thin, ethereal smoke rise gracefully from the burning paper into the surrounding darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.35087114572525024 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2258710861206055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.35087114572525024, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8749999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.35087114572525024, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14493682980537415, + 0.09077170491218567, + 0.14640970528125763, + 0.07314755767583847, + 0.02963031269609928, + 0.06864825636148453, + 0.09837283194065094, + 0.13332410156726837, + 0.07642700523138046, + 0.13833172619342804 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.35087114572525024 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single candle flame and a stack of documents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and positioned at a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the flame slowly charring the paper corner into gray ash without suddenly bursting into fire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated entirely by the candle's warm light, creating deep shadows and a high-contrast look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does thin, ethereal smoke rise gracefully from the burning paper into the surrounding darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020618274807929993 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895618200302124 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020618274807929993, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020618274807929993, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23691432178020477, + 0.040637142956256866, + 0.07626403868198395, + 0.03739957883954048, + 0.07568444311618805, + 0.12039478868246078, + 0.11989232152700424, + 0.126312717795372, + 0.023442070931196213, + 0.14305859804153442 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020618274807929993 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single candle flame and a stack of documents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and positioned at a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the flame slowly charring the paper corner into gray ash without suddenly bursting into fire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated entirely by the candle's warm light, creating deep shadows and a high-contrast look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does thin, ethereal smoke rise gracefully from the burning paper into the surrounding darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14281100034713745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178110599517822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14281100034713745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14281100034713745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2567153573036194, + 0.18288776278495789, + 0.09325700998306274, + 0.07317787408828735, + 0.03452758491039276, + 0.13193407654762268, + 0.0860469788312912, + 0.05803241208195686, + 0.032579123973846436, + 0.05084182694554329 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14281100034713745 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single candle flame and a stack of documents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and positioned at a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the flame slowly charring the paper corner into gray ash without suddenly bursting into fire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated entirely by the candle's warm light, creating deep shadows and a high-contrast look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does thin, ethereal smoke rise gracefully from the burning paper into the surrounding darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036202622577548027 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628620147705078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036202622577548027, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036202622577548027, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26501861214637756, + 0.044062089174985886, + 0.06703222543001175, + 0.13679492473602295, + 0.059129830449819565, + 0.17535869777202606, + 0.06347373872995377, + 0.06333030015230179, + 0.029431121423840523, + 0.0963684692978859 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036202622577548027 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single candle flame and a stack of documents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and positioned at a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the flame slowly charring the paper corner into gray ash without suddenly bursting into fire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated entirely by the candle's warm light, creating deep shadows and a high-contrast look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does thin, ethereal smoke rise gracefully from the burning paper into the surrounding darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012541710399091244 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387541770935059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012541710399091244, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012541710399091244, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.309409499168396, + 0.12128519266843796, + 0.04621579125523567, + 0.24285896122455597, + 0.0423370897769928, + 0.05337711423635483, + 0.029181482270359993, + 0.08579933643341064, + 0.025295119732618332, + 0.04424037039279938 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012541710399091244 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, static shot from a slightly elevated angle captures a quiet moment of destruction. A single candle flame, its core a brilliant whitish-yellow tapering to a soft orange halo, gently licks the corner of a thick stack of old documents on a dark, polished wood surface. The paper, yellowed and brittle with age, reveals its fibrous texture and frayed edges in the intimate glow. When the flame makes contact, the corner of the paper doesn't suddenly burst into flame, but rather begins a slow, inexorable transformation. A deliberately dark line of char spreads from the point of contact, and the paper curls inward like a dying leaf. The heat causes the fibers to blacken, transforming into brittle gray ash, while thin, ethereal smoke rises gracefully into the surrounding darkness. The scene is illuminated entirely by the candle's warm, flickering light, creating a dramatic black-and-white contrast with deep, soft shadows, evoking a tense, secretive, and irreversible ending.", + "seed": 30373, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_5/index_9987_seed_30373_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.13014676715247334, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13014676715247334, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13014676715247334, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single candle flame and a stack of documents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and positioned at a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the flame slowly charring the paper corner into gray ash without suddenly bursting into fire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated entirely by the candle's warm light, creating deep shadows and a high-contrast look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does thin, ethereal smoke rise gracefully from the burning paper into the surrounding darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.025000857189297676 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.775000810623169 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.025000857189297676, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.025000857189297676, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.43911033868789673, + 0.11737730354070663, + 0.03466776758432388, + 0.03671088069677353, + 0.0353897400200367, + 0.056285444647073746, + 0.0757799819111824, + 0.05196545273065567, + 0.06306389719247818, + 0.08964917063713074 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.025000857189297676 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single candle flame and a stack of documents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and positioned at a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the flame slowly charring the paper corner into gray ash without suddenly bursting into fire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated entirely by the candle's warm light, creating deep shadows and a high-contrast look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does thin, ethereal smoke rise gracefully from the burning paper into the surrounding darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01609957218170166 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141099452972412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01609957218170166, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01609957218170166, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10077404975891113, + 0.05284104868769646, + 0.029845083132386208, + 0.031395550817251205, + 0.041011206805706024, + 0.0631764829158783, + 0.05311542749404907, + 0.14078384637832642, + 0.057812631130218506, + 0.429244726896286 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01609957218170166 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single candle flame and a stack of documents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and positioned at a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the flame slowly charring the paper corner into gray ash without suddenly bursting into fire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated entirely by the candle's warm light, creating deep shadows and a high-contrast look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does thin, ethereal smoke rise gracefully from the burning paper into the surrounding darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5762149691581726 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8262149691581726 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5762149691581726, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5762149691581726, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10679491609334946, + 0.03680242970585823, + 0.057224396616220474, + 0.06357879191637039, + 0.06225934252142906, + 0.0735664814710617, + 0.08434287458658218, + 0.06757071614265442, + 0.04866856336593628, + 0.3991915285587311 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5762149691581726 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single candle flame and a stack of documents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and positioned at a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the flame slowly charring the paper corner into gray ash without suddenly bursting into fire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated entirely by the candle's warm light, creating deep shadows and a high-contrast look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does thin, ethereal smoke rise gracefully from the burning paper into the surrounding darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036190745886415243 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628619194030762 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036190745886415243, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036190745886415243, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28631043434143066, + 0.08227460831403732, + 0.03505254164338112, + 0.047731924802064896, + 0.054529011249542236, + 0.043740157037973404, + 0.14661899209022522, + 0.10473756492137909, + 0.08419369906187057, + 0.11481109261512756 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036190745886415243 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single candle flame and a stack of documents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static and positioned at a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show the flame slowly charring the paper corner into gray ash without suddenly bursting into fire?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated entirely by the candle's warm light, creating deep shadows and a high-contrast look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does thin, ethereal smoke rise gracefully from the burning paper into the surrounding darkness?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029799362644553185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529799461364746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029799362644553185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029799362644553185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24363915622234344, + 0.13706143200397491, + 0.07501181960105896, + 0.03030489757657051, + 0.05637583136558533, + 0.08599819988012314, + 0.0405595488846302, + 0.1174129769206047, + 0.05970825254917145, + 0.15392792224884033 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029799362644553185 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_6/index_tensor([3111, 3111])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_6/index_tensor([3111, 3111])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..933ae641871d04a7ae8287956a877c344fbb558b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_6/index_tensor([3111, 3111])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, extreme wide shot slowly zooms in on a vast, mythical battlefield stretching to a jagged horizon. Swirls of purplish purple and black storm clouds seethe overhead, pierced by silent, inner lightning, casting an eerie, ominous green glow across the desolate landscape. At the center of the frame stands the central figure, Ravana, a towering, menacing figure whose sheer scale dominates the scene. His ten heads are arranged atop a formidable crown, each bearing a unique, malevolent expression—from roaring rage to a cold, calculating sneer—all adorned with ornate, dark-gold helmets. His powerful body is clad in intricately carved black-gold armor draped with crimson silk, and his posture is one of supreme arrogance. As he gains his footing, the barren, rocky ground not only cracks but violently splits beneath his feet, deep fissures spreading outward like a web, emitting a hellish, magmatic orange glow from within. With deliberate, contemptuous slowness, he swings his formidable sword – a massive, crescent-bladed weapon of polished obsidian that seems to absorb the faintest light in the air. The entire scene is immersed in a high-contrast black and white lighting style, creating deep shadows that accentuate his terrifying form and establish a tense, ominous atmosphere filled with the prospect of catastrophic battle.", + "seed": 4631, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_6/index_3111_seed_4631_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.7796848114579916, + "vlm_logprob": -0.7796848114579916, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.7796848114579916, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle extreme wide shot that slowly zooms in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure Ravana depicted with ten heads wearing ornate dark-gold helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is Ravana's armor black-gold with crimson silk and is he holding a massive obsidian crescent-bladed sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ground beneath Ravana's feet crack and split with deep fissures emitting a magmatic orange glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white lighting style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.32261383533477783 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3226138353347778 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.32261383533477783, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.32261383533477783, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17195841670036316, + 0.06571497768163681, + 0.09404955804347992, + 0.027446387335658073, + 0.061656802892684937, + 0.044091805815696716, + 0.18821190297603607, + 0.10553579777479172, + 0.1817842423915863, + 0.05955011397600174 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.32261383533477783 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle extreme wide shot that slowly zooms in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure Ravana depicted with ten heads wearing ornate dark-gold helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is Ravana's armor black-gold with crimson silk and is he holding a massive obsidian crescent-bladed sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ground beneath Ravana's feet crack and split with deep fissures emitting a magmatic orange glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white lighting style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11297706514596939 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379770278930664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11297706514596939, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11297706514596939, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42628684639930725, + 0.0793914943933487, + 0.04855884611606598, + 0.02501978911459446, + 0.021583788096904755, + 0.05420669913291931, + 0.08564721792936325, + 0.028792493045330048, + 0.11985517293214798, + 0.11065763980150223 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11297706514596939 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle extreme wide shot that slowly zooms in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure Ravana depicted with ten heads wearing ornate dark-gold helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is Ravana's armor black-gold with crimson silk and is he holding a massive obsidian crescent-bladed sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ground beneath Ravana's feet crack and split with deep fissures emitting a magmatic orange glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white lighting style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011087002232670784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511086940765381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011087002232670784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011087002232670784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24352066218852997, + 0.05026891827583313, + 0.043340787291526794, + 0.03538651019334793, + 0.04552113264799118, + 0.04161045327782631, + 0.03615579381585121, + 0.12710601091384888, + 0.24406373500823975, + 0.13302598893642426 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011087002232670784 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle extreme wide shot that slowly zooms in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure Ravana depicted with ten heads wearing ornate dark-gold helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is Ravana's armor black-gold with crimson silk and is he holding a massive obsidian crescent-bladed sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ground beneath Ravana's feet crack and split with deep fissures emitting a magmatic orange glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white lighting style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043059516698122025 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680595874786377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043059516698122025, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043059516698122025, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15615208446979523, + 0.045066531747579575, + 0.0577460415661335, + 0.035273559391498566, + 0.04216381907463074, + 0.03459247574210167, + 0.037884533405303955, + 0.13317283987998962, + 0.22468052804470062, + 0.23326760530471802 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043059516698122025 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle extreme wide shot that slowly zooms in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure Ravana depicted with ten heads wearing ornate dark-gold helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is Ravana's armor black-gold with crimson silk and is he holding a massive obsidian crescent-bladed sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ground beneath Ravana's feet crack and split with deep fissures emitting a magmatic orange glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white lighting style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408686637878418 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368669003248215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -3.408686637878418, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -3.408686637878418, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.39905548095703125, + 0.19585970044136047, + 0.054604724049568176, + 0.04257148131728172, + 0.03584388270974159, + 0.022333212196826935, + 0.04331107810139656, + 0.029023313894867897, + 0.09611529111862183, + 0.0812818631529808 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -3.408686637878418 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, extreme wide shot slowly zooms in on a vast, mythical battlefield stretching to a jagged horizon. Swirls of purplish purple and black storm clouds seethe overhead, pierced by silent, inner lightning, casting an eerie, ominous green glow across the desolate landscape. At the center of the frame stands the central figure, Ravana, a towering, menacing figure whose sheer scale dominates the scene. His ten heads are arranged atop a formidable crown, each bearing a unique, malevolent expression—from roaring rage to a cold, calculating sneer—all adorned with ornate, dark-gold helmets. His powerful body is clad in intricately carved black-gold armor draped with crimson silk, and his posture is one of supreme arrogance. As he gains his footing, the barren, rocky ground not only cracks but violently splits beneath his feet, deep fissures spreading outward like a web, emitting a hellish, magmatic orange glow from within. With deliberate, contemptuous slowness, he swings his formidable sword – a massive, crescent-bladed weapon of polished obsidian that seems to absorb the faintest light in the air. The entire scene is immersed in a high-contrast black and white lighting style, creating deep shadows that accentuate his terrifying form and establish a tense, ominous atmosphere filled with the prospect of catastrophic battle.", + "seed": 4632, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_6/index_3111_seed_4632_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.46698355209082365, + "vlm_logprob": -0.46698355209082365, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.46698355209082365, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle extreme wide shot that slowly zooms in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure Ravana depicted with ten heads wearing ornate dark-gold helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is Ravana's armor black-gold with crimson silk and is he holding a massive obsidian crescent-bladed sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ground beneath Ravana's feet crack and split with deep fissures emitting a magmatic orange glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white lighting style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.028512079268693924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7785120010375977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.028512079268693924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.028512079268693924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.048109270632267, + 0.18439671397209167, + 0.041955918073654175, + 0.0501924492418766, + 0.08196456730365753, + 0.4895384609699249, + 0.01838282123208046, + 0.0420432910323143, + 0.029919173568487167, + 0.013497323729097843 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.028512079268693924 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle extreme wide shot that slowly zooms in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure Ravana depicted with ten heads wearing ornate dark-gold helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is Ravana's armor black-gold with crimson silk and is he holding a massive obsidian crescent-bladed sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ground beneath Ravana's feet crack and split with deep fissures emitting a magmatic orange glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white lighting style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270732581615448 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127073287963867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270732581615448, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270732581615448, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.031142912805080414, + 0.09463635087013245, + 0.02035089023411274, + 0.028785614296793938, + 0.30251678824424744, + 0.4498021602630615, + 0.01584490016102791, + 0.010382931679487228, + 0.018789175897836685, + 0.027748245745897293 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270732581615448 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle extreme wide shot that slowly zooms in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure Ravana depicted with ten heads wearing ornate dark-gold helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is Ravana's armor black-gold with crimson silk and is he holding a massive obsidian crescent-bladed sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ground beneath Ravana's feet crack and split with deep fissures emitting a magmatic orange glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white lighting style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01420446764677763 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264204502105713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01420446764677763, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01420446764677763, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.023760905489325523, + 0.07641391456127167, + 0.012517844326794147, + 0.022406205534934998, + 0.2963807284832001, + 0.44423750042915344, + 0.04256538301706314, + 0.03364039212465286, + 0.019120005890727043, + 0.028957098722457886 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01420446764677763 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle extreme wide shot that slowly zooms in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure Ravana depicted with ten heads wearing ornate dark-gold helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is Ravana's armor black-gold with crimson silk and is he holding a massive obsidian crescent-bladed sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ground beneath Ravana's feet crack and split with deep fissures emitting a magmatic orange glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white lighting style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809615224599838 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880961894989014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809615224599838, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809615224599838, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.034535448998212814, + 0.13818411529064178, + 0.023952443152666092, + 0.03618472069501877, + 0.046333324164152145, + 0.15816877782344818, + 0.18774700164794922, + 0.3181604743003845, + 0.013069972395896912, + 0.04366372898221016 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809615224599838 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle extreme wide shot that slowly zooms in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure Ravana depicted with ten heads wearing ornate dark-gold helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is Ravana's armor black-gold with crimson silk and is he holding a massive obsidian crescent-bladed sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ground beneath Ravana's feet crack and split with deep fissures emitting a magmatic orange glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white lighting style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270318031311035 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12703168392181396 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.1270318031311035, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -2.1270318031311035, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09865102171897888, + 0.021699899807572365, + 0.06082047522068024, + 0.0804077610373497, + 0.20422124862670898, + 0.3482525944709778, + 0.060034360736608505, + 0.05686502531170845, + 0.02207249216735363, + 0.046975065022706985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.1270318031311035 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, extreme wide shot slowly zooms in on a vast, mythical battlefield stretching to a jagged horizon. Swirls of purplish purple and black storm clouds seethe overhead, pierced by silent, inner lightning, casting an eerie, ominous green glow across the desolate landscape. At the center of the frame stands the central figure, Ravana, a towering, menacing figure whose sheer scale dominates the scene. His ten heads are arranged atop a formidable crown, each bearing a unique, malevolent expression—from roaring rage to a cold, calculating sneer—all adorned with ornate, dark-gold helmets. His powerful body is clad in intricately carved black-gold armor draped with crimson silk, and his posture is one of supreme arrogance. As he gains his footing, the barren, rocky ground not only cracks but violently splits beneath his feet, deep fissures spreading outward like a web, emitting a hellish, magmatic orange glow from within. With deliberate, contemptuous slowness, he swings his formidable sword – a massive, crescent-bladed weapon of polished obsidian that seems to absorb the faintest light in the air. The entire scene is immersed in a high-contrast black and white lighting style, creating deep shadows that accentuate his terrifying form and establish a tense, ominous atmosphere filled with the prospect of catastrophic battle.", + "seed": 4633, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_6/index_3111_seed_4633_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.3374677630141377, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3374677630141377, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3374677630141377, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle extreme wide shot that slowly zooms in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure Ravana depicted with ten heads wearing ornate dark-gold helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is Ravana's armor black-gold with crimson silk and is he holding a massive obsidian crescent-bladed sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ground beneath Ravana's feet crack and split with deep fissures emitting a magmatic orange glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white lighting style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06864408403635025 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8186440467834473 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06864408403635025, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06864408403635025, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09551937878131866, + 0.019885661080479622, + 0.023138243705034256, + 0.05057600140571594, + 0.05394177883863449, + 0.09929098188877106, + 0.04321411997079849, + 0.34518614411354065, + 0.22402456402778625, + 0.04522307217121124 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06864408403635025 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle extreme wide shot that slowly zooms in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure Ravana depicted with ten heads wearing ornate dark-gold helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is Ravana's armor black-gold with crimson silk and is he holding a massive obsidian crescent-bladed sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ground beneath Ravana's feet crack and split with deep fissures emitting a magmatic orange glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white lighting style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1799469143152237 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049468994140625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1799469143152237, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1799469143152237, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07624954730272293, + 0.03403512015938759, + 0.047977905720472336, + 0.08247468620538712, + 0.026341479271650314, + 0.03702368959784508, + 0.06723034381866455, + 0.2802424728870392, + 0.11011964082717896, + 0.23830504715442657 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1799469143152237 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle extreme wide shot that slowly zooms in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure Ravana depicted with ten heads wearing ornate dark-gold helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is Ravana's armor black-gold with crimson silk and is he holding a massive obsidian crescent-bladed sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ground beneath Ravana's feet crack and split with deep fissures emitting a magmatic orange glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white lighting style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018207555636763573 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018207550048828 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018207555636763573, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018207555636763573, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08891947567462921, + 0.02544603869318962, + 0.03281191736459732, + 0.08030391484498978, + 0.044010259211063385, + 0.06642893701791763, + 0.07735633850097656, + 0.23569676280021667, + 0.13094943761825562, + 0.2180769294500351 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018207555636763573 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle extreme wide shot that slowly zooms in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure Ravana depicted with ten heads wearing ornate dark-gold helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is Ravana's armor black-gold with crimson silk and is he holding a massive obsidian crescent-bladed sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ground beneath Ravana's feet crack and split with deep fissures emitting a magmatic orange glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white lighting style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014198708347976208 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2641987800598145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014198708347976208, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014198708347976208, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03706275299191475, + 0.024774566292762756, + 0.01268437784165144, + 0.022960936650633812, + 0.01853158511221409, + 0.03690056502819061, + 0.028049426153302193, + 0.09442666918039322, + 0.15159769356250763, + 0.5730113983154297 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014198708347976208 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle extreme wide shot that slowly zooms in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure Ravana depicted with ten heads wearing ornate dark-gold helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is Ravana's armor black-gold with crimson silk and is he holding a massive obsidian crescent-bladed sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ground beneath Ravana's feet crack and split with deep fissures emitting a magmatic orange glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white lighting style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.406341552734375 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813414931297302 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.406341552734375, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -1.406341552734375, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1240018978714943, + 0.09840566664934158, + 0.06013010814785957, + 0.19791433215141296, + 0.05093144252896309, + 0.07682236284017563, + 0.05739925056695938, + 0.09344284981489182, + 0.12648458778858185, + 0.11446752399206161 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.406341552734375 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, extreme wide shot slowly zooms in on a vast, mythical battlefield stretching to a jagged horizon. Swirls of purplish purple and black storm clouds seethe overhead, pierced by silent, inner lightning, casting an eerie, ominous green glow across the desolate landscape. At the center of the frame stands the central figure, Ravana, a towering, menacing figure whose sheer scale dominates the scene. His ten heads are arranged atop a formidable crown, each bearing a unique, malevolent expression—from roaring rage to a cold, calculating sneer—all adorned with ornate, dark-gold helmets. His powerful body is clad in intricately carved black-gold armor draped with crimson silk, and his posture is one of supreme arrogance. As he gains his footing, the barren, rocky ground not only cracks but violently splits beneath his feet, deep fissures spreading outward like a web, emitting a hellish, magmatic orange glow from within. With deliberate, contemptuous slowness, he swings his formidable sword – a massive, crescent-bladed weapon of polished obsidian that seems to absorb the faintest light in the air. The entire scene is immersed in a high-contrast black and white lighting style, creating deep shadows that accentuate his terrifying form and establish a tense, ominous atmosphere filled with the prospect of catastrophic battle.", + "seed": 4634, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_6/index_3111_seed_4634_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.5898905904963613, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5898905904963613, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5898905904963613, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle extreme wide shot that slowly zooms in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure Ravana depicted with ten heads wearing ornate dark-gold helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is Ravana's armor black-gold with crimson silk and is he holding a massive obsidian crescent-bladed sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ground beneath Ravana's feet crack and split with deep fissures emitting a magmatic orange glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white lighting style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.030000213533639908 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7800002098083496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.030000213533639908, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.030000213533639908, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08343585580587387, + 0.06293945759534836, + 0.07332856953144073, + 0.05360211804509163, + 0.11152253299951553, + 0.06030582636594772, + 0.2709912657737732, + 0.13245685398578644, + 0.05856499820947647, + 0.09285257011651993 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.030000213533639908 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle extreme wide shot that slowly zooms in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure Ravana depicted with ten heads wearing ornate dark-gold helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is Ravana's armor black-gold with crimson silk and is he holding a massive obsidian crescent-bladed sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ground beneath Ravana's feet crack and split with deep fissures emitting a magmatic orange glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white lighting style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015959620475769 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015960216522217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2015959620475769, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2015959620475769, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12688249349594116, + 0.07356996089220047, + 0.08225174248218536, + 0.07281387597322464, + 0.1402965486049652, + 0.04626672342419624, + 0.06785139441490173, + 0.1948290914297104, + 0.12170424312353134, + 0.07353398203849792 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2015959620475769 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle extreme wide shot that slowly zooms in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure Ravana depicted with ten heads wearing ornate dark-gold helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is Ravana's armor black-gold with crimson silk and is he holding a massive obsidian crescent-bladed sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ground beneath Ravana's feet crack and split with deep fissures emitting a magmatic orange glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white lighting style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01421046070754528 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264210224151611 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01421046070754528, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01421046070754528, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1563117951154709, + 0.050547607243061066, + 0.040508776903152466, + 0.04551045969128609, + 0.0699700266122818, + 0.03413994610309601, + 0.0695199966430664, + 0.24231861531734467, + 0.21972398459911346, + 0.07144872099161148 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01421046070754528 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle extreme wide shot that slowly zooms in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure Ravana depicted with ten heads wearing ornate dark-gold helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is Ravana's armor black-gold with crimson silk and is he holding a massive obsidian crescent-bladed sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ground beneath Ravana's feet crack and split with deep fissures emitting a magmatic orange glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white lighting style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008638276718556881 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758638381958008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008638276718556881, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008638276718556881, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06164014711976051, + 0.030575085431337357, + 0.018365910276770592, + 0.0222550630569458, + 0.0276828333735466, + 0.03768910840153694, + 0.06552615761756897, + 0.19204767048358917, + 0.23184439539909363, + 0.31237363815307617 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008638276718556881 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle extreme wide shot that slowly zooms in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the central figure Ravana depicted with ten heads wearing ornate dark-gold helmets?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is Ravana's armor black-gold with crimson silk and is he holding a massive obsidian crescent-bladed sword?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the ground beneath Ravana's feet crack and split with deep fissures emitting a magmatic orange glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene rendered in a high-contrast black and white lighting style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950080394744873 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000814378261566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.6950080394744873, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -2.6950080394744873, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1220088005065918, + 0.08878263831138611, + 0.041398320347070694, + 0.02806154079735279, + 0.04715743660926819, + 0.15986794233322144, + 0.18302837014198303, + 0.09098758548498154, + 0.10030330717563629, + 0.13840416073799133 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.6950080394744873 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_7/index_tensor([4214, 4214])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_7/index_tensor([4214, 4214])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bc34bafe1325269ae1f5a290294beb66a3cf737a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_7/index_tensor([4214, 4214])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow and steady eye-level media shot unfolds, revealing a wider scene, initially depicting two figures locked in a tight embrace. A man in his thirties, with wind-torn short brown hair and a stubbled beard, wears a worn dark green canvas jacket over a gray shirt. He holds a woman tightly, his eyes closed, his expression filled with deep relief and tenderness. The woman, her face hidden by her brow, presses against his shoulder, her long black hair spilling out from a loose tie, and she wears an oversized cream-colored sweater. Her hands clenched into fists, gripping the fabric at his back as if anchoring her. As the camera continues its deliberate retreat, the vast, imposing backdrop of the industrial power plant dominates the frame. Two massive cylindrical concrete cooling towers tower above them, their surfaces stained with the marks of age and weather. Thick plumes of white steam slowly rise from their vast mouths into the overcast sky. The scene is bathed in the cool, unfocused light of the afternoon, creating a desaturated palette of industrial greys and muted earth tones that makes these small slices of human connection feel both fragile and profoundly important. The overall atmosphere is one of poignant intimacy, a silent, emotional reunion that contrasts sharply with the overwhelming and indifferent scale of industry.", + "seed": 22601, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_7/index_4214_seed_22601_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06495543224737048, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06495543224737048, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06495543224737048, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two figures shown locked in a tight embrace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn dark green canvas jacket over a gray shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an oversized cream-colored sweater with long black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature massive cylindrical concrete cooling towers with white steam rising from them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a deliberate retreat to reveal a wider scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22694794833660126 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6019479036331177 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22694794833660126, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22694794833660126, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6677291989326477, + 0.0353136882185936, + 0.04874293506145477, + 0.061907291412353516, + 0.03848477825522423, + 0.016942130401730537, + 0.0453803725540638, + 0.0584980808198452, + 0.01652739755809307, + 0.010474059730768204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22694794833660126 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two figures shown locked in a tight embrace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn dark green canvas jacket over a gray shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an oversized cream-colored sweater with long black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature massive cylindrical concrete cooling towers with white steam rising from them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a deliberate retreat to reveal a wider scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04873437434434891 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048734426498413 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04873437434434891, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04873437434434891, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.9450498223304749, + 0.006369748618453741, + 0.006586818490177393, + 0.007109739817678928, + 0.004663389641791582, + 0.002685775514692068, + 0.004786338657140732, + 0.01774817891418934, + 0.002697175834327936, + 0.0023030659649521112 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04873437434434891 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two figures shown locked in a tight embrace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn dark green canvas jacket over a gray shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an oversized cream-colored sweater with long black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature massive cylindrical concrete cooling towers with white steam rising from them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a deliberate retreat to reveal a wider scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012559369206428528 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387559413909912 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012559369206428528, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012559369206428528, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.8729065656661987, + 0.01900506019592285, + 0.009343243204057217, + 0.010931684635579586, + 0.023767728358507156, + 0.00802155863493681, + 0.010500085540115833, + 0.02707158587872982, + 0.010357202030718327, + 0.00809530820697546 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012559369206428528 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two figures shown locked in a tight embrace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn dark green canvas jacket over a gray shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an oversized cream-colored sweater with long black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature massive cylindrical concrete cooling towers with white steam rising from them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a deliberate retreat to reveal a wider scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00673760985955596 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00673770904541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00673760985955596, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00673760985955596, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14398324489593506, + 0.10629303008317947, + 0.03246434032917023, + 0.033561669290065765, + 0.032463863492012024, + 0.057957686483860016, + 0.21234914660453796, + 0.07361150532960892, + 0.07064387947320938, + 0.236671581864357 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00673760985955596 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two figures shown locked in a tight embrace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn dark green canvas jacket over a gray shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an oversized cream-colored sweater with long black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature massive cylindrical concrete cooling towers with white steam rising from them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a deliberate retreat to reveal a wider scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029797859489917755 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297977924346924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029797859489917755, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029797859489917755, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5531188249588013, + 0.07242137938737869, + 0.036397747695446014, + 0.019933534786105156, + 0.05165473744273186, + 0.0967298373579979, + 0.055234842002391815, + 0.031298473477363586, + 0.055692192167043686, + 0.027518440037965775 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029797859489917755 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow and steady eye-level media shot unfolds, revealing a wider scene, initially depicting two figures locked in a tight embrace. A man in his thirties, with wind-torn short brown hair and a stubbled beard, wears a worn dark green canvas jacket over a gray shirt. He holds a woman tightly, his eyes closed, his expression filled with deep relief and tenderness. The woman, her face hidden by her brow, presses against his shoulder, her long black hair spilling out from a loose tie, and she wears an oversized cream-colored sweater. Her hands clenched into fists, gripping the fabric at his back as if anchoring her. As the camera continues its deliberate retreat, the vast, imposing backdrop of the industrial power plant dominates the frame. Two massive cylindrical concrete cooling towers tower above them, their surfaces stained with the marks of age and weather. Thick plumes of white steam slowly rise from their vast mouths into the overcast sky. The scene is bathed in the cool, unfocused light of the afternoon, creating a desaturated palette of industrial greys and muted earth tones that makes these small slices of human connection feel both fragile and profoundly important. The overall atmosphere is one of poignant intimacy, a silent, emotional reunion that contrasts sharply with the overwhelming and indifferent scale of industry.", + "seed": 22602, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_7/index_4214_seed_22602_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.010996829788200557, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010996829788200557, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010996829788200557, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two figures shown locked in a tight embrace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn dark green canvas jacket over a gray shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an oversized cream-colored sweater with long black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature massive cylindrical concrete cooling towers with white steam rising from them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a deliberate retreat to reveal a wider scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.022091377526521683 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8970913887023926 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.022091377526521683, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.022091377526521683, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2433389127254486, + 0.07533496618270874, + 0.11721684038639069, + 0.12627427279949188, + 0.08000441640615463, + 0.03443087264895439, + 0.15930050611495972, + 0.03481712564826012, + 0.050110381096601486, + 0.07917172461748123 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.022091377526521683 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two figures shown locked in a tight embrace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn dark green canvas jacket over a gray shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an oversized cream-colored sweater with long black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature massive cylindrical concrete cooling towers with white steam rising from them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a deliberate retreat to reveal a wider scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0182165689766407 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018216609954834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0182165689766407, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0182165689766407, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11712309718132019, + 0.06540915369987488, + 0.3697446882724762, + 0.06565247476100922, + 0.035447970032691956, + 0.0288833174854517, + 0.1865689754486084, + 0.06357555091381073, + 0.04903782531619072, + 0.018556972965598106 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0182165689766407 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two figures shown locked in a tight embrace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn dark green canvas jacket over a gray shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an oversized cream-colored sweater with long black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature massive cylindrical concrete cooling towers with white steam rising from them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a deliberate retreat to reveal a wider scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004099775105714798 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5040998458862305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004099775105714798, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004099775105714798, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11762212216854095, + 0.04942062124609947, + 0.2485387921333313, + 0.052250929176807404, + 0.063013955950737, + 0.03484170138835907, + 0.249629944562912, + 0.07898236066102982, + 0.056515853852033615, + 0.04918372258543968 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004099775105714798 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two figures shown locked in a tight embrace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn dark green canvas jacket over a gray shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an oversized cream-colored sweater with long black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature massive cylindrical concrete cooling towers with white steam rising from them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a deliberate retreat to reveal a wider scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019408691441640258 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251940727233887 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019408691441640258, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019408691441640258, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04876654967665672, + 0.027265639975667, + 0.027528828009963036, + 0.027979997918009758, + 0.058166828006505966, + 0.04492808133363724, + 0.20735900104045868, + 0.24823534488677979, + 0.142708420753479, + 0.16706128418445587 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019408691441640258 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two figures shown locked in a tight embrace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn dark green canvas jacket over a gray shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an oversized cream-colored sweater with long black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature massive cylindrical concrete cooling towers with white steam rising from them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a deliberate retreat to reveal a wider scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008635558187961578 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758635520935059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008635558187961578, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008635558187961578, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.046029429882764816, + 0.021915728226304054, + 0.04076692461967468, + 0.03701549023389816, + 0.06646363437175751, + 0.07329954952001572, + 0.45825740694999695, + 0.05361747369170189, + 0.11523880064487457, + 0.08739553391933441 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008635558187961578 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow and steady eye-level media shot unfolds, revealing a wider scene, initially depicting two figures locked in a tight embrace. A man in his thirties, with wind-torn short brown hair and a stubbled beard, wears a worn dark green canvas jacket over a gray shirt. He holds a woman tightly, his eyes closed, his expression filled with deep relief and tenderness. The woman, her face hidden by her brow, presses against his shoulder, her long black hair spilling out from a loose tie, and she wears an oversized cream-colored sweater. Her hands clenched into fists, gripping the fabric at his back as if anchoring her. As the camera continues its deliberate retreat, the vast, imposing backdrop of the industrial power plant dominates the frame. Two massive cylindrical concrete cooling towers tower above them, their surfaces stained with the marks of age and weather. Thick plumes of white steam slowly rise from their vast mouths into the overcast sky. The scene is bathed in the cool, unfocused light of the afternoon, creating a desaturated palette of industrial greys and muted earth tones that makes these small slices of human connection feel both fragile and profoundly important. The overall atmosphere is one of poignant intimacy, a silent, emotional reunion that contrasts sharply with the overwhelming and indifferent scale of industry.", + "seed": 22603, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_7/index_4214_seed_22603_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.039165738481096925, + "vlm_logprob": -0.039165738481096925, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.039165738481096925, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two figures shown locked in a tight embrace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn dark green canvas jacket over a gray shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an oversized cream-colored sweater with long black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature massive cylindrical concrete cooling towers with white steam rising from them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a deliberate retreat to reveal a wider scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16268087923526764 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9126808643341064 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16268087923526764, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16268087923526764, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20085740089416504, + 0.09273409098386765, + 0.04657667502760887, + 0.036379024386405945, + 0.1217932254076004, + 0.14994628727436066, + 0.10451734811067581, + 0.03415274620056152, + 0.1130642294883728, + 0.099978968501091 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16268087923526764 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two figures shown locked in a tight embrace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn dark green canvas jacket over a gray shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an oversized cream-colored sweater with long black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature massive cylindrical concrete cooling towers with white steam rising from them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a deliberate retreat to reveal a wider scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014238549396395683 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264238357543945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014238549396395683, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014238549396395683, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23633259534835815, + 0.1959635317325592, + 0.11727084219455719, + 0.028685633093118668, + 0.06685809046030045, + 0.028650566935539246, + 0.13922451436519623, + 0.04280102998018265, + 0.03736438974738121, + 0.10684877634048462 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014238549396395683 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two figures shown locked in a tight embrace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn dark green canvas jacket over a gray shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an oversized cream-colored sweater with long black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature massive cylindrical concrete cooling towers with white steam rising from them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a deliberate retreat to reveal a wider scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032024311367422342 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753202438354492 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032024311367422342, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032024311367422342, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21116772294044495, + 0.19806089997291565, + 0.03352547064423561, + 0.03410353511571884, + 0.03417009487748146, + 0.049600496888160706, + 0.10439615696668625, + 0.10801586508750916, + 0.05316488444805145, + 0.1737949252128601 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032024311367422342 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two figures shown locked in a tight embrace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn dark green canvas jacket over a gray shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an oversized cream-colored sweater with long black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature massive cylindrical concrete cooling towers with white steam rising from them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a deliberate retreat to reveal a wider scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015137653099372983 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501513957977295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015137653099372983, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015137653099372983, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12494952231645584, + 0.04786151647567749, + 0.04147590696811676, + 0.055398959666490555, + 0.051422230899333954, + 0.12468255311250687, + 0.1679818481206894, + 0.15035060048103333, + 0.13996189832687378, + 0.0959150642156601 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015137653099372983 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two figures shown locked in a tight embrace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn dark green canvas jacket over a gray shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an oversized cream-colored sweater with long black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature massive cylindrical concrete cooling towers with white steam rising from them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a deliberate retreat to reveal a wider scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014193067327141762 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264193058013916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014193067327141762, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014193067327141762, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0511796809732914, + 0.021649722009897232, + 0.03133836016058922, + 0.03880556300282478, + 0.07759194076061249, + 0.09057385474443436, + 0.2412102371454239, + 0.08340281993150711, + 0.26189109683036804, + 0.10235676169395447 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014193067327141762 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow and steady eye-level media shot unfolds, revealing a wider scene, initially depicting two figures locked in a tight embrace. A man in his thirties, with wind-torn short brown hair and a stubbled beard, wears a worn dark green canvas jacket over a gray shirt. He holds a woman tightly, his eyes closed, his expression filled with deep relief and tenderness. The woman, her face hidden by her brow, presses against his shoulder, her long black hair spilling out from a loose tie, and she wears an oversized cream-colored sweater. Her hands clenched into fists, gripping the fabric at his back as if anchoring her. As the camera continues its deliberate retreat, the vast, imposing backdrop of the industrial power plant dominates the frame. Two massive cylindrical concrete cooling towers tower above them, their surfaces stained with the marks of age and weather. Thick plumes of white steam slowly rise from their vast mouths into the overcast sky. The scene is bathed in the cool, unfocused light of the afternoon, creating a desaturated palette of industrial greys and muted earth tones that makes these small slices of human connection feel both fragile and profoundly important. The overall atmosphere is one of poignant intimacy, a silent, emotional reunion that contrasts sharply with the overwhelming and indifferent scale of industry.", + "seed": 22604, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_7/index_4214_seed_22604_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.01575087779201567, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01575087779201567, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01575087779201567, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two figures shown locked in a tight embrace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn dark green canvas jacket over a gray shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an oversized cream-colored sweater with long black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature massive cylindrical concrete cooling towers with white steam rising from them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a deliberate retreat to reveal a wider scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01937955990433693 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.019379615783691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01937955990433693, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01937955990433693, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16390101611614227, + 0.24337710440158844, + 0.15156619250774384, + 0.07024914026260376, + 0.07840746641159058, + 0.0663943886756897, + 0.12745673954486847, + 0.01576644368469715, + 0.02316787838935852, + 0.059713590890169144 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01937955990433693 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two figures shown locked in a tight embrace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn dark green canvas jacket over a gray shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an oversized cream-colored sweater with long black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature massive cylindrical concrete cooling towers with white steam rising from them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a deliberate retreat to reveal a wider scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03816477209329605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881648540496826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03816477209329605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03816477209329605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30099523067474365, + 0.2583341896533966, + 0.09437133371829987, + 0.033193837851285934, + 0.1047293022274971, + 0.027499593794345856, + 0.08816217631101608, + 0.012831278145313263, + 0.019159097224473953, + 0.06072394549846649 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03816477209329605 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two figures shown locked in a tight embrace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn dark green canvas jacket over a gray shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an oversized cream-colored sweater with long black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature massive cylindrical concrete cooling towers with white steam rising from them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a deliberate retreat to reveal a wider scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007648114114999771 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88264799118042 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007648114114999771, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007648114114999771, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2198280245065689, + 0.10172279179096222, + 0.17984826862812042, + 0.0466797836124897, + 0.22224131226539612, + 0.05281848460435867, + 0.06725886464118958, + 0.03098308853805065, + 0.03303111344575882, + 0.04558822885155678 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007648114114999771 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two figures shown locked in a tight embrace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn dark green canvas jacket over a gray shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an oversized cream-colored sweater with long black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature massive cylindrical concrete cooling towers with white steam rising from them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a deliberate retreat to reveal a wider scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024889700580388308 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.00248908996582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024889700580388308, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024889700580388308, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06923077255487442, + 0.08339587599039078, + 0.05274291709065437, + 0.032218705862760544, + 0.05648193135857582, + 0.10925841331481934, + 0.14334730803966522, + 0.06252982467412949, + 0.054410841315984726, + 0.3363833725452423 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024889700580388308 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two figures shown locked in a tight embrace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a worn dark green canvas jacket over a gray shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing an oversized cream-colored sweater with long black hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature massive cylindrical concrete cooling towers with white steam rising from them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a deliberate retreat to reveal a wider scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011072972789406776 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511073112487793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011072972789406776, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011072972789406776, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12514202296733856, + 0.0997001901268959, + 0.059025052934885025, + 0.06948207318782806, + 0.08983209729194641, + 0.07218185067176819, + 0.16819624602794647, + 0.08086287975311279, + 0.10708416253328323, + 0.12849339842796326 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011072972789406776 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_8/index_tensor([8734, 8734])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_8/index_tensor([8734, 8734])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..056d16067904d35c70ceb8352578aca99e47a6d3 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_8/index_tensor([8734, 8734])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, rendered in cinematic slow motion, begins static, then steadily tracks a lone soap bubble as it floats serenely through the air. The bubble is a perfect, shimmering sphere, its gossamer membrane swirling in an enchanting dance of iridescent hues—pink, blue, and gold—catching the warm, low-angle afternoon light. Its delicate surface reflects a distorted, fish-eye image of the dark, richly textured asphalt road below and the rough, rough brick wall in front. Gently propelled by an unseen air current, the bubble begins its relentless drift, its spherical form wobbling slightly as it moves toward the rough, weathered red brick wall. The camera follows its trajectory until the leading edge of the iridescent membrane delicately contacts the abraded surface of a single brick. In a silent, instantaneous burst, the sphere rapidly collapses inward, shattering into a tiny spray of soap mist that hangs suspended in the air for a moment. A small, dark, circular wet patch remains on the brick's porous surface, a fleeting testament to the bubble's fleeting existence, creating a concentrated yet poignant atmosphere of fleeting beauty.", + "seed": 10573, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_8/index_8734_seed_10573_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.24501097556203605, + "vlm_logprob": -0.24501097556203605, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.24501097556203605, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single soap bubble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble display iridescent hues of pink, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a dark asphalt road and a rough red brick wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then steadily track the bubble until it hits the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble burst into a spray of mist leaving a small wet patch on the brick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.138893961906433 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3888939619064331 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.138893961906433, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.138893961906433, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21544241905212402, + 0.07390353083610535, + 0.2006746083498001, + 0.08368538320064545, + 0.07207383960485458, + 0.03717846795916557, + 0.029598703607916832, + 0.1657537817955017, + 0.038310207426548004, + 0.08337908238172531 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.138893961906433 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single soap bubble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble display iridescent hues of pink, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a dark asphalt road and a rough red brick wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then steadily track the bubble until it hits the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble burst into a spray of mist leaving a small wet patch on the brick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02334490790963173 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733449935913086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02334490790963173, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02334490790963173, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.259794145822525, + 0.068013995885849, + 0.14570854604244232, + 0.11258073896169662, + 0.06399212777614594, + 0.05085167661309242, + 0.06815265864133835, + 0.08666425198316574, + 0.06723842024803162, + 0.07700338959693909 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02334490790963173 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single soap bubble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble display iridescent hues of pink, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a dark asphalt road and a rough red brick wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then steadily track the bubble until it hits the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble burst into a spray of mist leaving a small wet patch on the brick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008646431379020214 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758646488189697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008646431379020214, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008646431379020214, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1592078059911728, + 0.09857168048620224, + 0.12700167298316956, + 0.12709064781665802, + 0.08649159967899323, + 0.12083544582128525, + 0.09797543287277222, + 0.039925865828990936, + 0.08464842289686203, + 0.05825139582157135 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008646431379020214 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single soap bubble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble display iridescent hues of pink, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a dark asphalt road and a rough red brick wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then steadily track the bubble until it hits the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble burst into a spray of mist leaving a small wet patch on the brick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607927680015564 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141079425811768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607927680015564, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607927680015564, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1829385906457901, + 0.06723260134458542, + 0.23880818486213684, + 0.07652558386325836, + 0.035888005048036575, + 0.14449183642864227, + 0.0758495032787323, + 0.07157287001609802, + 0.05184264853596687, + 0.054850202053785324 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607927680015564 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single soap bubble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble display iridescent hues of pink, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a dark asphalt road and a rough red brick wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then steadily track the bubble until it hits the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble burst into a spray of mist leaving a small wet patch on the brick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0380902998149395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288090229034424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0380902998149395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0380902998149395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09549520909786224, + 0.05926669016480446, + 0.13914357125759125, + 0.23217971622943878, + 0.055808115750551224, + 0.16192735731601715, + 0.06664343178272247, + 0.06688815355300903, + 0.07554361969232559, + 0.04710403084754944 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0380902998149395 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, rendered in cinematic slow motion, begins static, then steadily tracks a lone soap bubble as it floats serenely through the air. The bubble is a perfect, shimmering sphere, its gossamer membrane swirling in an enchanting dance of iridescent hues—pink, blue, and gold—catching the warm, low-angle afternoon light. Its delicate surface reflects a distorted, fish-eye image of the dark, richly textured asphalt road below and the rough, rough brick wall in front. Gently propelled by an unseen air current, the bubble begins its relentless drift, its spherical form wobbling slightly as it moves toward the rough, weathered red brick wall. The camera follows its trajectory until the leading edge of the iridescent membrane delicately contacts the abraded surface of a single brick. In a silent, instantaneous burst, the sphere rapidly collapses inward, shattering into a tiny spray of soap mist that hangs suspended in the air for a moment. A small, dark, circular wet patch remains on the brick's porous surface, a fleeting testament to the bubble's fleeting existence, creating a concentrated yet poignant atmosphere of fleeting beauty.", + "seed": 10574, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_8/index_8734_seed_10574_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02535953875631094, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02535953875631094, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02535953875631094, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single soap bubble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble display iridescent hues of pink, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a dark asphalt road and a rough red brick wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then steadily track the bubble until it hits the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble burst into a spray of mist leaving a small wet patch on the brick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04354069381952286 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1685407161712646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04354069381952286, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04354069381952286, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.210229754447937, + 0.10693120211362839, + 0.10315406322479248, + 0.04121535271406174, + 0.330444872379303, + 0.06848225742578506, + 0.019319046288728714, + 0.03350129351019859, + 0.04971184954047203, + 0.037010304629802704 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04354069381952286 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single soap bubble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble display iridescent hues of pink, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a dark asphalt road and a rough red brick wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then steadily track the bubble until it hits the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble burst into a spray of mist leaving a small wet patch on the brick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011097141541540623 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511096954345703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011097141541540623, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011097141541540623, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2721981704235077, + 0.2359199970960617, + 0.05710986629128456, + 0.03180116042494774, + 0.09608987718820572, + 0.09316745400428772, + 0.06893394142389297, + 0.036010656505823135, + 0.06800197809934616, + 0.04076689854264259 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011097141541540623 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single soap bubble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble display iridescent hues of pink, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a dark asphalt road and a rough red brick wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then steadily track the bubble until it hits the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble burst into a spray of mist leaving a small wet patch on the brick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029823893681168556 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298237800598145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029823893681168556, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029823893681168556, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21553830802440643, + 0.11560259759426117, + 0.03664544224739075, + 0.06477292627096176, + 0.10287342965602875, + 0.2643378973007202, + 0.022018490359187126, + 0.04658697918057442, + 0.07347817718982697, + 0.058145713061094284 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029823893681168556 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single soap bubble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble display iridescent hues of pink, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a dark asphalt road and a rough red brick wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then steadily track the bubble until it hits the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble burst into a spray of mist leaving a small wet patch on the brick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029802024364471436 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529802083969116 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029802024364471436, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029802024364471436, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08016160875558853, + 0.12239229679107666, + 0.06625119596719742, + 0.06527599692344666, + 0.21829122304916382, + 0.22401903569698334, + 0.03642650693655014, + 0.04296422004699707, + 0.10695403814315796, + 0.03726394101977348 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029802024364471436 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single soap bubble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble display iridescent hues of pink, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a dark asphalt road and a rough red brick wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then steadily track the bubble until it hits the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble burst into a spray of mist leaving a small wet patch on the brick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012533940374851227 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387534141540527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012533940374851227, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012533940374851227, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13664069771766663, + 0.04128663241863251, + 0.07068990916013718, + 0.04518719017505646, + 0.15495027601718903, + 0.3353339731693268, + 0.028165023773908615, + 0.05831814929842949, + 0.03671230375766754, + 0.09271584451198578 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012533940374851227 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, rendered in cinematic slow motion, begins static, then steadily tracks a lone soap bubble as it floats serenely through the air. The bubble is a perfect, shimmering sphere, its gossamer membrane swirling in an enchanting dance of iridescent hues—pink, blue, and gold—catching the warm, low-angle afternoon light. Its delicate surface reflects a distorted, fish-eye image of the dark, richly textured asphalt road below and the rough, rough brick wall in front. Gently propelled by an unseen air current, the bubble begins its relentless drift, its spherical form wobbling slightly as it moves toward the rough, weathered red brick wall. The camera follows its trajectory until the leading edge of the iridescent membrane delicately contacts the abraded surface of a single brick. In a silent, instantaneous burst, the sphere rapidly collapses inward, shattering into a tiny spray of soap mist that hangs suspended in the air for a moment. A small, dark, circular wet patch remains on the brick's porous surface, a fleeting testament to the bubble's fleeting existence, creating a concentrated yet poignant atmosphere of fleeting beauty.", + "seed": 10575, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_8/index_8734_seed_10575_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.023591260612010955, + "vlm_logprob": -0.023591260612010955, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.023591260612010955, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single soap bubble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble display iridescent hues of pink, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a dark asphalt road and a rough red brick wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then steadily track the bubble until it hits the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble burst into a spray of mist leaving a small wet patch on the brick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04408254846930504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1690826416015625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04408254846930504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04408254846930504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11410748958587646, + 0.19453787803649902, + 0.08220672607421875, + 0.07789144665002823, + 0.0729755312204361, + 0.05336422845721245, + 0.059731170535087585, + 0.18384434282779694, + 0.1321774423122406, + 0.02916380763053894 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04408254846930504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single soap bubble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble display iridescent hues of pink, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a dark asphalt road and a rough red brick wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then steadily track the bubble until it hits the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble burst into a spray of mist leaving a small wet patch on the brick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016097811982035637 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410980224609375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016097811982035637, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016097811982035637, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21121034026145935, + 0.1541885882616043, + 0.07283460348844528, + 0.21029934287071228, + 0.11326377093791962, + 0.03486305847764015, + 0.08095409721136093, + 0.060876745730638504, + 0.03324490785598755, + 0.028264561668038368 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016097811982035637 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single soap bubble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble display iridescent hues of pink, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a dark asphalt road and a rough red brick wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then steadily track the bubble until it hits the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble burst into a spray of mist leaving a small wet patch on the brick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029811743646860123 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298118591308594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029811743646860123, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029811743646860123, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10477439314126968, + 0.20747244358062744, + 0.06404706090688705, + 0.10488289594650269, + 0.23623578250408173, + 0.05659744516015053, + 0.07012276351451874, + 0.05184789001941681, + 0.06093154475092888, + 0.04308781400322914 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029811743646860123 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single soap bubble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble display iridescent hues of pink, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a dark asphalt road and a rough red brick wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then steadily track the bubble until it hits the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble burst into a spray of mist leaving a small wet patch on the brick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0097875464707613 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634787559509277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0097875464707613, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0097875464707613, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10514653474092484, + 0.14933273196220398, + 0.19467484951019287, + 0.060224030166864395, + 0.0637187734246254, + 0.04111863300204277, + 0.17518505454063416, + 0.09462300688028336, + 0.09109224379062653, + 0.02488410845398903 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0097875464707613 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single soap bubble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble display iridescent hues of pink, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a dark asphalt road and a rough red brick wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then steadily track the bubble until it hits the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble burst into a spray of mist leaving a small wet patch on the brick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018176652491092682 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018176555633545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018176652491092682, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018176652491092682, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061174262315034866, + 0.06020655483007431, + 0.0931391641497612, + 0.3630298674106598, + 0.1276431381702423, + 0.0554233156144619, + 0.07589177042245865, + 0.07409554719924927, + 0.06147587671875954, + 0.027920491993427277 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018176652491092682 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up, rendered in cinematic slow motion, begins static, then steadily tracks a lone soap bubble as it floats serenely through the air. The bubble is a perfect, shimmering sphere, its gossamer membrane swirling in an enchanting dance of iridescent hues—pink, blue, and gold—catching the warm, low-angle afternoon light. Its delicate surface reflects a distorted, fish-eye image of the dark, richly textured asphalt road below and the rough, rough brick wall in front. Gently propelled by an unseen air current, the bubble begins its relentless drift, its spherical form wobbling slightly as it moves toward the rough, weathered red brick wall. The camera follows its trajectory until the leading edge of the iridescent membrane delicately contacts the abraded surface of a single brick. In a silent, instantaneous burst, the sphere rapidly collapses inward, shattering into a tiny spray of soap mist that hangs suspended in the air for a moment. A small, dark, circular wet patch remains on the brick's porous surface, a fleeting testament to the bubble's fleeting existence, creating a concentrated yet poignant atmosphere of fleeting beauty.", + "seed": 10576, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_8/index_8734_seed_10576_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04531463179737329, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04531463179737329, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04531463179737329, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single soap bubble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble display iridescent hues of pink, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a dark asphalt road and a rough red brick wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then steadily track the bubble until it hits the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble burst into a spray of mist leaving a small wet patch on the brick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16168348491191864 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.911683440208435 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16168348491191864, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16168348491191864, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15996462106704712, + 0.02851688489317894, + 0.3271756172180176, + 0.13088791072368622, + 0.11068441718816757, + 0.05833975598216057, + 0.048191457986831665, + 0.048942483961582184, + 0.05834456533193588, + 0.02895226702094078 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16168348491191864 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single soap bubble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble display iridescent hues of pink, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a dark asphalt road and a rough red brick wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then steadily track the bubble until it hits the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble burst into a spray of mist leaving a small wet patch on the brick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011104568839073181 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511104583740234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011104568839073181, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011104568839073181, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2717062830924988, + 0.040815435349941254, + 0.2945309281349182, + 0.15470153093338013, + 0.029786691069602966, + 0.043699901551008224, + 0.03542793169617653, + 0.05795149505138397, + 0.030252184718847275, + 0.04112759977579117 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011104568839073181 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single soap bubble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble display iridescent hues of pink, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a dark asphalt road and a rough red brick wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then steadily track the bubble until it hits the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble burst into a spray of mist leaving a small wet patch on the brick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029809430241584778 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298094749450684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029809430241584778, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029809430241584778, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09309595823287964, + 0.04249026998877525, + 0.2894963026046753, + 0.35302305221557617, + 0.021825719624757767, + 0.04763166978955269, + 0.021356502547860146, + 0.03961106389760971, + 0.02437443658709526, + 0.0670950636267662 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029809430241584778 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single soap bubble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble display iridescent hues of pink, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a dark asphalt road and a rough red brick wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then steadily track the bubble until it hits the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble burst into a spray of mist leaving a small wet patch on the brick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009787074290215969 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634787082672119 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009787074290215969, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009787074290215969, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16063997149467468, + 0.10022038221359253, + 0.21845774352550507, + 0.1555020958185196, + 0.08445963263511658, + 0.08724534511566162, + 0.04475148022174835, + 0.058932624757289886, + 0.0444137267768383, + 0.04537700116634369 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009787074290215969 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a single soap bubble?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble display iridescent hues of pink, blue, and gold?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the background show a dark asphalt road and a rough red brick wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start static and then steadily track the bubble until it hits the wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the bubble burst into a spray of mist leaving a small wet patch on the brick?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014188600704073906 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264188766479492 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014188600704073906, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014188600704073906, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08545256406068802, + 0.03745303675532341, + 0.41203799843788147, + 0.12510697543621063, + 0.029889177531003952, + 0.15531088411808014, + 0.03584984317421913, + 0.030326778069138527, + 0.03034217655658722, + 0.05823057144880295 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014188600704073906 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_9/index_tensor([3571, 3571])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_9/index_tensor([3571, 3571])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5a2ae460c087a43120f22f6191b0493feb411484 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_9/index_tensor([3571, 3571])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, overhead close-up, gradually zooming out, focuses on an acceptance letter resting on a dark, richly textured wooden table. Warm afternoon sunlight streams in from the side, casting soft, elongated shadows on the polished wood. Tiny particles of dust drift slowly in the air, shrouded in golden shafts of light. The letter, initially scroll-like, composed of thick, finely textured off-white parchment, begins to carefully and almost animately unroll. As the paper slides smoothly and silently across the table, the ornate, slightly raised gold script engraved within is revealed line by line, each letter gleaming with a dazzling, warm glow in the sunlight. The dominant tones of warm browns and golds create an atmosphere of tranquility, hope, and ritual, as if a pivotal moment in life is frozen before our eyes.", + "seed": 33429, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_9/index_3571_seed_33429_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.21165615506470203, + "vlm_logprob": -0.21165615506470203, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.21165615506470203, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera gradually zooming out during the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an acceptance letter resting on a dark, richly textured wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the letter unroll smoothly and silently from a scroll-like state?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is warm afternoon sunlight streaming in from the side, casting soft, elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023525284603238106 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.523525238037109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023525284603238106, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023525284603238106, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1632540076971054, + 0.09548775851726532, + 0.07689138501882553, + 0.061023514717817307, + 0.049161117523908615, + 0.03144346922636032, + 0.06374036520719528, + 0.14709366858005524, + 0.25883615016937256, + 0.05306859686970711 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023525284603238106 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera gradually zooming out during the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an acceptance letter resting on a dark, richly textured wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the letter unroll smoothly and silently from a scroll-like state?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is warm afternoon sunlight streaming in from the side, casting soft, elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742163419723511 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4742163419723511 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9742163419723511, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9742163419723511, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07258261740207672, + 0.11157931387424469, + 0.14114679396152496, + 0.11505795270204544, + 0.04059368744492531, + 0.046789348125457764, + 0.044268928468227386, + 0.11618022620677948, + 0.2517660856246948, + 0.060034990310668945 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9742163419723511 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera gradually zooming out during the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an acceptance letter resting on a dark, richly textured wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the letter unroll smoothly and silently from a scroll-like state?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is warm afternoon sunlight streaming in from the side, casting soft, elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008648676797747612 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758648872375488 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008648676797747612, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008648676797747612, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09251126646995544, + 0.05208795890212059, + 0.08408355712890625, + 0.03770219162106514, + 0.02574518881738186, + 0.06768003106117249, + 0.04273628816008568, + 0.11389300972223282, + 0.21226337552070618, + 0.2712971568107605 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008648676797747612 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera gradually zooming out during the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an acceptance letter resting on a dark, richly textured wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the letter unroll smoothly and silently from a scroll-like state?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is warm afternoon sunlight streaming in from the side, casting soft, elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018194561824202538 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018194675445557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018194561824202538, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018194561824202538, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.053721968084573746, + 0.031271301209926605, + 0.07041993737220764, + 0.07602809369564056, + 0.03315652161836624, + 0.022334186360239983, + 0.018307657912373543, + 0.14922110736370087, + 0.4816175699234009, + 0.06392176449298859 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018194561824202538 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera gradually zooming out during the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an acceptance letter resting on a dark, richly textured wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the letter unroll smoothly and silently from a scroll-like state?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is warm afternoon sunlight streaming in from the side, casting soft, elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369591012597084 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408695936203003 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369591012597084, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369591012597084, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22369341552257538, + 0.07310621440410614, + 0.058455999940633774, + 0.10770946741104126, + 0.021252715960144997, + 0.032079730182886124, + 0.036046262830495834, + 0.22322136163711548, + 0.1345059722661972, + 0.08992889523506165 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369591012597084 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, overhead close-up, gradually zooming out, focuses on an acceptance letter resting on a dark, richly textured wooden table. Warm afternoon sunlight streams in from the side, casting soft, elongated shadows on the polished wood. Tiny particles of dust drift slowly in the air, shrouded in golden shafts of light. The letter, initially scroll-like, composed of thick, finely textured off-white parchment, begins to carefully and almost animately unroll. As the paper slides smoothly and silently across the table, the ornate, slightly raised gold script engraved within is revealed line by line, each letter gleaming with a dazzling, warm glow in the sunlight. The dominant tones of warm browns and golds create an atmosphere of tranquility, hope, and ritual, as if a pivotal moment in life is frozen before our eyes.", + "seed": 33430, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_9/index_3571_seed_33430_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.20005215592682363, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20005215592682363, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3749999523162844, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20005215592682363, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera gradually zooming out during the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an acceptance letter resting on a dark, richly textured wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the letter unroll smoothly and silently from a scroll-like state?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is warm afternoon sunlight streaming in from the side, casting soft, elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03853510320186615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.038535118103027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03853510320186615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03853510320186615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1261170357465744, + 0.046294357627630234, + 0.1370258629322052, + 0.25838205218315125, + 0.059649545699357986, + 0.103420689702034, + 0.1224273145198822, + 0.05274317413568497, + 0.048600830137729645, + 0.045339103788137436 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03853510320186615 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera gradually zooming out during the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an acceptance letter resting on a dark, richly textured wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the letter unroll smoothly and silently from a scroll-like state?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is warm afternoon sunlight streaming in from the side, casting soft, elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8982635736465454 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5232635736465454 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8982635736465454, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8982635736465454, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03665115684270859, + 0.028398215770721436, + 0.09134520590305328, + 0.3184494078159332, + 0.19855055212974548, + 0.09287383407354355, + 0.11891493201255798, + 0.017167501151561737, + 0.00733099365606904, + 0.09031815081834793 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8982635736465454 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera gradually zooming out during the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an acceptance letter resting on a dark, richly textured wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the letter unroll smoothly and silently from a scroll-like state?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is warm afternoon sunlight streaming in from the side, casting soft, elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022066310048103333 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127206802368164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022066310048103333, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022066310048103333, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.026173492893576622, + 0.015451050363481045, + 0.0705544501543045, + 0.29643064737319946, + 0.1405281275510788, + 0.10090555250644684, + 0.25368818640708923, + 0.03863026574254036, + 0.025020385161042213, + 0.03261789679527283 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022066310048103333 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera gradually zooming out during the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an acceptance letter resting on a dark, richly textured wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the letter unroll smoothly and silently from a scroll-like state?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is warm afternoon sunlight streaming in from the side, casting soft, elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0181953813880682 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018195152282715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0181953813880682, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0181953813880682, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03927372768521309, + 0.04440048709511757, + 0.1796494871377945, + 0.5906105637550354, + 0.026026228442788124, + 0.031008314341306686, + 0.019907884299755096, + 0.023585312068462372, + 0.009468250907957554, + 0.036069825291633606 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0181953813880682 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera gradually zooming out during the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an acceptance letter resting on a dark, richly textured wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the letter unroll smoothly and silently from a scroll-like state?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is warm afternoon sunlight streaming in from the side, casting soft, elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306009039282799 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168060064315796 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306009039282799, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306009039282799, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.054502278566360474, + 0.04828972741961479, + 0.0480223074555397, + 0.3054143488407135, + 0.2005642056465149, + 0.11486944556236267, + 0.10982004553079605, + 0.01873045414686203, + 0.017403537407517433, + 0.08238360285758972 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306009039282799 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, overhead close-up, gradually zooming out, focuses on an acceptance letter resting on a dark, richly textured wooden table. Warm afternoon sunlight streams in from the side, casting soft, elongated shadows on the polished wood. Tiny particles of dust drift slowly in the air, shrouded in golden shafts of light. The letter, initially scroll-like, composed of thick, finely textured off-white parchment, begins to carefully and almost animately unroll. As the paper slides smoothly and silently across the table, the ornate, slightly raised gold script engraved within is revealed line by line, each letter gleaming with a dazzling, warm glow in the sunlight. The dominant tones of warm browns and golds create an atmosphere of tranquility, hope, and ritual, as if a pivotal moment in life is frozen before our eyes.", + "seed": 33431, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_9/index_3571_seed_33431_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.2962485458701849, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2962485458701849, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2962485458701849, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera gradually zooming out during the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an acceptance letter resting on a dark, richly textured wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the letter unroll smoothly and silently from a scroll-like state?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is warm afternoon sunlight streaming in from the side, casting soft, elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08183653652667999 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.831836462020874 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08183653652667999, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08183653652667999, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2381039410829544, + 0.056029412895441055, + 0.0801786556839943, + 0.09417898207902908, + 0.19178403913974762, + 0.08497172594070435, + 0.08878540992736816, + 0.04825891554355621, + 0.06602530926465988, + 0.05168362334370613 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08183653652667999 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera gradually zooming out during the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an acceptance letter resting on a dark, richly textured wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the letter unroll smoothly and silently from a scroll-like state?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is warm afternoon sunlight streaming in from the side, casting soft, elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3133931159973145 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3133930563926697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.3133931159973145, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.3133931159973145, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30550673604011536, + 0.1036023274064064, + 0.08342902362346649, + 0.050526004284620285, + 0.08257627487182617, + 0.059517934918403625, + 0.18209867179393768, + 0.04302065819501877, + 0.03623536601662636, + 0.05348702147603035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.3133931159973145 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera gradually zooming out during the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an acceptance letter resting on a dark, richly textured wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the letter unroll smoothly and silently from a scroll-like state?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is warm afternoon sunlight streaming in from the side, casting soft, elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026380563154816628 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513805389404297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026380563154816628, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026380563154816628, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.054835595190525055, + 0.09746620059013367, + 0.1308020055294037, + 0.08373307436704636, + 0.07093503326177597, + 0.17514322698116302, + 0.030248260125517845, + 0.208072230219841, + 0.038954492658376694, + 0.10980986803770065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026380563154816628 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera gradually zooming out during the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an acceptance letter resting on a dark, richly textured wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the letter unroll smoothly and silently from a scroll-like state?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is warm afternoon sunlight streaming in from the side, casting soft, elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029818454757332802 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529818534851074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029818454757332802, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029818454757332802, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2318556159734726, + 0.08424144238233566, + 0.06473352015018463, + 0.07919330149888992, + 0.10157886892557144, + 0.033240675926208496, + 0.07440084964036942, + 0.23057794570922852, + 0.06497149169445038, + 0.03520622104406357 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029818454757332802 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera gradually zooming out during the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an acceptance letter resting on a dark, richly textured wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the letter unroll smoothly and silently from a scroll-like state?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is warm afternoon sunlight streaming in from the side, casting soft, elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029814058914780617 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298140048980713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029814058914780617, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029814058914780617, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13016071915626526, + 0.03293444588780403, + 0.08161625266075134, + 0.06558258831501007, + 0.20997461676597595, + 0.20421536266803741, + 0.052431441843509674, + 0.08359130471944809, + 0.04700107127428055, + 0.09249221533536911 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029814058914780617 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, overhead close-up, gradually zooming out, focuses on an acceptance letter resting on a dark, richly textured wooden table. Warm afternoon sunlight streams in from the side, casting soft, elongated shadows on the polished wood. Tiny particles of dust drift slowly in the air, shrouded in golden shafts of light. The letter, initially scroll-like, composed of thick, finely textured off-white parchment, begins to carefully and almost animately unroll. As the paper slides smoothly and silently across the table, the ornate, slightly raised gold script engraved within is revealed line by line, each letter gleaming with a dazzling, warm glow in the sunlight. The dominant tones of warm browns and golds create an atmosphere of tranquility, hope, and ritual, as if a pivotal moment in life is frozen before our eyes.", + "seed": 33432, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000243/group_9/index_3571_seed_33432_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.27668746970593927, + "vlm_logprob": -0.27668746970593927, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.27668746970593927, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera gradually zooming out during the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an acceptance letter resting on a dark, richly textured wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the letter unroll smoothly and silently from a scroll-like state?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is warm afternoon sunlight streaming in from the side, casting soft, elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02913983352482319 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.529139995574951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02913983352482319, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02913983352482319, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15380798280239105, + 0.09831060469150543, + 0.13598763942718506, + 0.07769013941287994, + 0.05340731889009476, + 0.026283498853445053, + 0.1950194537639618, + 0.07209231704473495, + 0.07730590552091599, + 0.11009516566991806 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02913983352482319 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera gradually zooming out during the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an acceptance letter resting on a dark, richly textured wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the letter unroll smoothly and silently from a scroll-like state?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is warm afternoon sunlight streaming in from the side, casting soft, elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3133691549301147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31336918473243713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.3133691549301147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.3133691549301147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17865170538425446, + 0.11832265555858612, + 0.06916071474552155, + 0.11211714148521423, + 0.1049368605017662, + 0.017061028629541397, + 0.18108516931533813, + 0.10539216548204422, + 0.07399044930934906, + 0.03928210213780403 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.3133691549301147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera gradually zooming out during the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an acceptance letter resting on a dark, richly textured wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the letter unroll smoothly and silently from a scroll-like state?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is warm afternoon sunlight streaming in from the side, casting soft, elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013438966125249863 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626343727111816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013438966125249863, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013438966125249863, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27206239104270935, + 0.12617677450180054, + 0.05753118544816971, + 0.2447533756494522, + 0.023975303396582603, + 0.02820155955851078, + 0.05579879879951477, + 0.05758301168680191, + 0.10048579424619675, + 0.03343184292316437 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013438966125249863 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera gradually zooming out during the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an acceptance letter resting on a dark, richly textured wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the letter unroll smoothly and silently from a scroll-like state?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is warm afternoon sunlight streaming in from the side, casting soft, elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978671945631504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634786605834961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978671945631504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978671945631504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17538495361804962, + 0.19661599397659302, + 0.05904528126120567, + 0.19307097792625427, + 0.0533440075814724, + 0.03723546862602234, + 0.09921025484800339, + 0.0665203109383583, + 0.07650206238031387, + 0.04307066276669502 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978671945631504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot from an overhead close-up perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera gradually zooming out during the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is an acceptance letter resting on a dark, richly textured wooden table visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the letter unroll smoothly and silently from a scroll-like state?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is warm afternoon sunlight streaming in from the side, casting soft, elongated shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029797744005918503 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297977924346924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029797744005918503, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029797744005918503, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4539502263069153, + 0.3346884250640869, + 0.058300282806158066, + 0.05773647129535675, + 0.020449448376893997, + 0.017352990806102753, + 0.024110866710543633, + 0.014449276961386204, + 0.011592822149395943, + 0.007369124796241522 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029797744005918503 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_0/index_tensor([6603, 6603])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_0/index_tensor([6603, 6603])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a6d0ce5da3c5011ba3ce863cb9d8b8ed04ec3b8b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_0/index_tensor([6603, 6603])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "macro close-up, with the camera tracking the action, captures a mesmerizing physics on the dark, perfectly smooth, non-porous surface of what appears to be polished black glass. Two small, distinctive droplets of liquid mercury rest on this surface, their silvery, mirror-like surfaces catching the faint ambient light. A slight, deliberate tilt of the plane prompts one droplet to begin a slow roll, its spherical shape maintaining perfect surface tension as it moves toward the stationary droplet. The moment they touch, they converge in a rapid, fluid motion, instantly becoming a larger droplet that sways energetically, its surface rippling with liquid energy before settling. As the combined mass settles into a larger hemisphere, the camera remains steady, revealing a breathtaking reflection on its highly polished convex surface: a brightly lit train speeds by, its illuminated windows streaking across the mercury. The motion blur of the warm, yellow light contrasts sharply with the surrounding dark reflections, creating an atmosphere of focused, scientific, and visually captivating beauty.", + "seed": 20511, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_0/index_6603_seed_20511_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.040650676283985374, + "vlm_logprob": -0.040650676283985374, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.040650676283985374, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a macro close-up of two small droplets of liquid mercury on a dark, smooth, non-porous surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does one mercury droplet roll slowly toward the stationary droplet due to a slight tilt of the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two droplets merge instantly into a larger droplet that sways and ripples upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the final combined droplet settle into a larger hemisphere shape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady while revealing a reflection of a brightly lit train with streaking yellow windows on the mercury surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.052272677421569824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0522727966308594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.052272677421569824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.052272677421569824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11484032869338989, + 0.05743212252855301, + 0.11754672974348068, + 0.08600889891386032, + 0.23617573082447052, + 0.07769547402858734, + 0.025019902735948563, + 0.03004765510559082, + 0.1477200984954834, + 0.10751312971115112 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.052272677421569824 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a macro close-up of two small droplets of liquid mercury on a dark, smooth, non-porous surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does one mercury droplet roll slowly toward the stationary droplet due to a slight tilt of the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two droplets merge instantly into a larger droplet that sways and ripples upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the final combined droplet settle into a larger hemisphere shape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady while revealing a reflection of a brightly lit train with streaking yellow windows on the mercury surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05500676482915878 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.930006742477417 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05500676482915878, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05500676482915878, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06538371741771698, + 0.06979875266551971, + 0.1094193086028099, + 0.08610007911920547, + 0.3025455176830292, + 0.07886767387390137, + 0.039940543472766876, + 0.068299300968647, + 0.06544928252696991, + 0.11419586092233658 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05500676482915878 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a macro close-up of two small droplets of liquid mercury on a dark, smooth, non-porous surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does one mercury droplet roll slowly toward the stationary droplet due to a slight tilt of the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two droplets merge instantly into a larger droplet that sways and ripples upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the final combined droplet settle into a larger hemisphere shape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady while revealing a reflection of a brightly lit train with streaking yellow windows on the mercury surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620511993765831 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812051296234131 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620511993765831, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620511993765831, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.036194391548633575, + 0.04192953556776047, + 0.09296650439500809, + 0.026183217763900757, + 0.49675971269607544, + 0.17964200675487518, + 0.026095109060406685, + 0.023122645914554596, + 0.05597134307026863, + 0.021135510876774788 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620511993765831 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a macro close-up of two small droplets of liquid mercury on a dark, smooth, non-porous surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does one mercury droplet roll slowly toward the stationary droplet due to a slight tilt of the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two droplets merge instantly into a larger droplet that sways and ripples upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the final combined droplet settle into a larger hemisphere shape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady while revealing a reflection of a brightly lit train with streaking yellow windows on the mercury surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040996563620865345 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5040998458862305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040996563620865345, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040996563620865345, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05623450502753258, + 0.044421859085559845, + 0.062517449259758, + 0.049168672412633896, + 0.10839460790157318, + 0.09799777716398239, + 0.05353591591119766, + 0.0918319970369339, + 0.054535262286663055, + 0.3813619613647461 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040996563620865345 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a macro close-up of two small droplets of liquid mercury on a dark, smooth, non-porous surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does one mercury droplet roll slowly toward the stationary droplet due to a slight tilt of the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two droplets merge instantly into a larger droplet that sways and ripples upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the final combined droplet settle into a larger hemisphere shape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady while revealing a reflection of a brightly lit train with streaking yellow windows on the mercury surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02982308343052864 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529823064804077 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02982308343052864, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02982308343052864, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.049054715782403946, + 0.02638893947005272, + 0.07769142091274261, + 0.0824674665927887, + 0.15812669694423676, + 0.14529530704021454, + 0.03867636248469353, + 0.1924261897802353, + 0.06476110219955444, + 0.16511176526546478 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02982308343052864 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "macro close-up, with the camera tracking the action, captures a mesmerizing physics on the dark, perfectly smooth, non-porous surface of what appears to be polished black glass. Two small, distinctive droplets of liquid mercury rest on this surface, their silvery, mirror-like surfaces catching the faint ambient light. A slight, deliberate tilt of the plane prompts one droplet to begin a slow roll, its spherical shape maintaining perfect surface tension as it moves toward the stationary droplet. The moment they touch, they converge in a rapid, fluid motion, instantly becoming a larger droplet that sways energetically, its surface rippling with liquid energy before settling. As the combined mass settles into a larger hemisphere, the camera remains steady, revealing a breathtaking reflection on its highly polished convex surface: a brightly lit train speeds by, its illuminated windows streaking across the mercury. The motion blur of the warm, yellow light contrasts sharply with the surrounding dark reflections, creating an atmosphere of focused, scientific, and visually captivating beauty.", + "seed": 20512, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_0/index_6603_seed_20512_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06423668712377548, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06423668712377548, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06423668712377548, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a macro close-up of two small droplets of liquid mercury on a dark, smooth, non-porous surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does one mercury droplet roll slowly toward the stationary droplet due to a slight tilt of the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two droplets merge instantly into a larger droplet that sways and ripples upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the final combined droplet settle into a larger hemisphere shape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady while revealing a reflection of a brightly lit train with streaking yellow windows on the mercury surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.041322510689496994 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2913224697113037 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.041322510689496994, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.041322510689496994, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12921038269996643, + 0.07372770458459854, + 0.036508556455373764, + 0.24759168922901154, + 0.055118072777986526, + 0.09217876940965652, + 0.08189418911933899, + 0.0998876541852951, + 0.03806791454553604, + 0.14581508934497833 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.041322510689496994 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a macro close-up of two small droplets of liquid mercury on a dark, smooth, non-porous surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does one mercury droplet roll slowly toward the stationary droplet due to a slight tilt of the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two droplets merge instantly into a larger droplet that sways and ripples upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the final combined droplet settle into a larger hemisphere shape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady while revealing a reflection of a brightly lit train with streaking yellow windows on the mercury surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048723358660936356 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0487234592437744 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048723358660936356, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048723358660936356, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17639079689979553, + 0.07163015753030777, + 0.0640629380941391, + 0.17995575070381165, + 0.03174212947487831, + 0.04313420504331589, + 0.02885337732732296, + 0.284250944852829, + 0.026846203953027725, + 0.09313355386257172 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048723358660936356 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a macro close-up of two small droplets of liquid mercury on a dark, smooth, non-porous surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does one mercury droplet roll slowly toward the stationary droplet due to a slight tilt of the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two droplets merge instantly into a larger droplet that sways and ripples upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the final combined droplet settle into a larger hemisphere shape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady while revealing a reflection of a brightly lit train with streaking yellow windows on the mercury surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06206139177083969 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812061309814453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06206139177083969, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06206139177083969, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08503168076276779, + 0.25471505522727966, + 0.04653887078166008, + 0.09086564183235168, + 0.02954655885696411, + 0.16941122710704803, + 0.06965172290802002, + 0.092474564909935, + 0.04021475836634636, + 0.12154999375343323 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06206139177083969 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a macro close-up of two small droplets of liquid mercury on a dark, smooth, non-porous surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does one mercury droplet roll slowly toward the stationary droplet due to a slight tilt of the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two droplets merge instantly into a larger droplet that sways and ripples upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the final combined droplet settle into a larger hemisphere shape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady while revealing a reflection of a brightly lit train with streaking yellow windows on the mercury surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008645012974739075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758645057678223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008645012974739075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008645012974739075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1364852339029312, + 0.08860737830400467, + 0.05880902335047722, + 0.09945668280124664, + 0.03833291307091713, + 0.12550701200962067, + 0.1620013266801834, + 0.1567942202091217, + 0.07289046794176102, + 0.061115775257349014 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008645012974739075 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a macro close-up of two small droplets of liquid mercury on a dark, smooth, non-porous surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does one mercury droplet roll slowly toward the stationary droplet due to a slight tilt of the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two droplets merge instantly into a larger droplet that sways and ripples upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the final combined droplet settle into a larger hemisphere shape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady while revealing a reflection of a brightly lit train with streaking yellow windows on the mercury surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1604311615228653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910431146621704 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1604311615228653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1604311615228653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09439947456121445, + 0.037385642528533936, + 0.03720938041806221, + 0.08881673216819763, + 0.08009913563728333, + 0.11778037995100021, + 0.20663660764694214, + 0.22925367951393127, + 0.08871446549892426, + 0.019704487174749374 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1604311615228653 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "macro close-up, with the camera tracking the action, captures a mesmerizing physics on the dark, perfectly smooth, non-porous surface of what appears to be polished black glass. Two small, distinctive droplets of liquid mercury rest on this surface, their silvery, mirror-like surfaces catching the faint ambient light. A slight, deliberate tilt of the plane prompts one droplet to begin a slow roll, its spherical shape maintaining perfect surface tension as it moves toward the stationary droplet. The moment they touch, they converge in a rapid, fluid motion, instantly becoming a larger droplet that sways energetically, its surface rippling with liquid energy before settling. As the combined mass settles into a larger hemisphere, the camera remains steady, revealing a breathtaking reflection on its highly polished convex surface: a brightly lit train speeds by, its illuminated windows streaking across the mercury. The motion blur of the warm, yellow light contrasts sharply with the surrounding dark reflections, creating an atmosphere of focused, scientific, and visually captivating beauty.", + "seed": 20513, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_0/index_6603_seed_20513_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.0283911410253495, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0283911410253495, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0283911410253495, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a macro close-up of two small droplets of liquid mercury on a dark, smooth, non-porous surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does one mercury droplet roll slowly toward the stationary droplet due to a slight tilt of the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two droplets merge instantly into a larger droplet that sways and ripples upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the final combined droplet settle into a larger hemisphere shape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady while revealing a reflection of a brightly lit train with streaking yellow windows on the mercury surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0373339019715786 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4123339653015137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0373339019715786, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0373339019715786, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061440739780664444, + 0.3432108163833618, + 0.21190661191940308, + 0.0366889163851738, + 0.05464481562376022, + 0.11051815003156662, + 0.02002798393368721, + 0.06636219471693039, + 0.0777214914560318, + 0.01747826859354973 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0373339019715786 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a macro close-up of two small droplets of liquid mercury on a dark, smooth, non-porous surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does one mercury droplet roll slowly toward the stationary droplet due to a slight tilt of the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two droplets merge instantly into a larger droplet that sways and ripples upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the final combined droplet settle into a larger hemisphere shape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady while revealing a reflection of a brightly lit train with streaking yellow windows on the mercury surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02639809437096119 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651398181915283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02639809437096119, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02639809437096119, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05915657430887222, + 0.4007946252822876, + 0.0991319939494133, + 0.02329826168715954, + 0.13889744877815247, + 0.04666415974497795, + 0.028081050142645836, + 0.032021455466747284, + 0.1487879902124405, + 0.02316633239388466 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02639809437096119 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a macro close-up of two small droplets of liquid mercury on a dark, smooth, non-porous surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does one mercury droplet roll slowly toward the stationary droplet due to a slight tilt of the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two droplets merge instantly into a larger droplet that sways and ripples upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the final combined droplet settle into a larger hemisphere shape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady while revealing a reflection of a brightly lit train with streaking yellow windows on the mercury surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866442829370499 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486643314361572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866442829370499, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866442829370499, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07200584560632706, + 0.18365617096424103, + 0.04348461329936981, + 0.05723658949136734, + 0.050598256289958954, + 0.05944554880261421, + 0.028058109804987907, + 0.023202434182167053, + 0.4535454213619232, + 0.028767012059688568 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866442829370499 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a macro close-up of two small droplets of liquid mercury on a dark, smooth, non-porous surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does one mercury droplet roll slowly toward the stationary droplet due to a slight tilt of the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two droplets merge instantly into a larger droplet that sways and ripples upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the final combined droplet settle into a larger hemisphere shape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady while revealing a reflection of a brightly lit train with streaking yellow windows on the mercury surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003196133067831397 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531962394714355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003196133067831397, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003196133067831397, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0716451033949852, + 0.2821311950683594, + 0.07911524921655655, + 0.038368429988622665, + 0.3130076825618744, + 0.037962380796670914, + 0.018164856359362602, + 0.03947986289858818, + 0.047702640295028687, + 0.07242260873317719 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003196133067831397 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a macro close-up of two small droplets of liquid mercury on a dark, smooth, non-porous surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does one mercury droplet roll slowly toward the stationary droplet due to a slight tilt of the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two droplets merge instantly into a larger droplet that sways and ripples upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the final combined droplet settle into a larger hemisphere shape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady while revealing a reflection of a brightly lit train with streaking yellow windows on the mercury surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026363147422671318 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513631343841553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026363147422671318, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026363147422671318, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10309327393770218, + 0.18430164456367493, + 0.22635002434253693, + 0.019421733915805817, + 0.05927227810025215, + 0.056030914187431335, + 0.033438555896282196, + 0.04636344686150551, + 0.1937587857246399, + 0.07796937972307205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026363147422671318 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "macro close-up, with the camera tracking the action, captures a mesmerizing physics on the dark, perfectly smooth, non-porous surface of what appears to be polished black glass. Two small, distinctive droplets of liquid mercury rest on this surface, their silvery, mirror-like surfaces catching the faint ambient light. A slight, deliberate tilt of the plane prompts one droplet to begin a slow roll, its spherical shape maintaining perfect surface tension as it moves toward the stationary droplet. The moment they touch, they converge in a rapid, fluid motion, instantly becoming a larger droplet that sways energetically, its surface rippling with liquid energy before settling. As the combined mass settles into a larger hemisphere, the camera remains steady, revealing a breathtaking reflection on its highly polished convex surface: a brightly lit train speeds by, its illuminated windows streaking across the mercury. The motion blur of the warm, yellow light contrasts sharply with the surrounding dark reflections, creating an atmosphere of focused, scientific, and visually captivating beauty.", + "seed": 20514, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_0/index_6603_seed_20514_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.029521232843399046, + "vlm_logprob": -0.029521232843399046, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.029521232843399046, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a macro close-up of two small droplets of liquid mercury on a dark, smooth, non-porous surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does one mercury droplet roll slowly toward the stationary droplet due to a slight tilt of the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two droplets merge instantly into a larger droplet that sways and ripples upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the final combined droplet settle into a larger hemisphere shape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady while revealing a reflection of a brightly lit train with streaking yellow windows on the mercury surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02882322482764721 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.653823137283325 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02882322482764721, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02882322482764721, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.059817492961883545, + 0.06815752387046814, + 0.21342574059963226, + 0.04207834601402283, + 0.02851126156747341, + 0.26729467511177063, + 0.10205522179603577, + 0.034517060965299606, + 0.10829879343509674, + 0.07584384828805923 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02882322482764721 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a macro close-up of two small droplets of liquid mercury on a dark, smooth, non-porous surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does one mercury droplet roll slowly toward the stationary droplet due to a slight tilt of the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two droplets merge instantly into a larger droplet that sways and ripples upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the final combined droplet settle into a larger hemisphere shape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady while revealing a reflection of a brightly lit train with streaking yellow windows on the mercury surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01610402949154377 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141104221343994 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01610402949154377, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01610402949154377, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09197647124528885, + 0.06544798612594604, + 0.1292237937450409, + 0.04300994053483009, + 0.06430336087942123, + 0.11458756029605865, + 0.06791342794895172, + 0.0852721631526947, + 0.06573009490966797, + 0.27253520488739014 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01610402949154377 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a macro close-up of two small droplets of liquid mercury on a dark, smooth, non-porous surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does one mercury droplet roll slowly toward the stationary droplet due to a slight tilt of the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two droplets merge instantly into a larger droplet that sways and ripples upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the final combined droplet settle into a larger hemisphere shape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady while revealing a reflection of a brightly lit train with streaking yellow windows on the mercury surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0549577958881855 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929957866668701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0549577958881855, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0549577958881855, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07348965108394623, + 0.04391529783606529, + 0.13183525204658508, + 0.03234488144516945, + 0.09971486777067184, + 0.052125234156847, + 0.06009746342897415, + 0.020581437274813652, + 0.12818151712417603, + 0.35771438479423523 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0549577958881855 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a macro close-up of two small droplets of liquid mercury on a dark, smooth, non-porous surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does one mercury droplet roll slowly toward the stationary droplet due to a slight tilt of the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two droplets merge instantly into a larger droplet that sways and ripples upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the final combined droplet settle into a larger hemisphere shape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady while revealing a reflection of a brightly lit train with streaking yellow windows on the mercury surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004639100283384323 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379639148712158 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004639100283384323, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004639100283384323, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.043279923498630524, + 0.03691355511546135, + 0.05630955472588539, + 0.028021281585097313, + 0.04713451862335205, + 0.12029104679822922, + 0.058325719088315964, + 0.06464319676160812, + 0.1491917371749878, + 0.3958894908428192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004639100283384323 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a macro close-up of two small droplets of liquid mercury on a dark, smooth, non-porous surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does one mercury droplet roll slowly toward the stationary droplet due to a slight tilt of the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the two droplets merge instantly into a larger droplet that sways and ripples upon contact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the final combined droplet settle into a larger hemisphere shape?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera steady while revealing a reflection of a brightly lit train with streaking yellow windows on the mercury surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043082013726234436 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680819988250732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043082013726234436, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043082013726234436, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04456815868616104, + 0.049990009516477585, + 0.06273813545703888, + 0.04265386238694191, + 0.14494791626930237, + 0.05735817179083824, + 0.0748882070183754, + 0.050019070506095886, + 0.2089177668094635, + 0.2639186978340149 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043082013726234436 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_1/index_tensor([4569, 4569])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_1/index_tensor([4569, 4569])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..dec1b7464b9f4e8b457b3613cbf250f5f074f7fb --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_1/index_tensor([4569, 4569])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "powerful Hitchcockian zoom shot, beginning from a low, ground-level angle, rapidly zooms out while simultaneously zooming in, locking onto an empty metal shopping cart. The cart hurtles uncontrollably down a steep, cracked asphalt descent. The glaring afternoon sun reflects sharp, shaky spots of light off the cart's shiny chrome basket, its red plastic handles slightly faded and worn from constant use. Driven by gravity, its four small, black, hard rubber wheels spin wildly, one front wheel, damaged, lurching violently from side to side. The cart's high-speed progress emits a creaking metallic shudder and stirs up a fine cloud of dust and gravel. As the camera continues to move, the size of the shopping cart remains unchanged in the frame, but the background behind it - distant suburban houses, telephone poles and sparse trees - is visually compressed and rushed forward, creating a strong sense of spatial distortion and dizziness, vividly rendering the fury of speed and the sense of danger of losing control. The whole picture presents a heart-pounding, hyper-realistic dynamic tension.", + "seed": 12351, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_1/index_4569_seed_12351_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06316705616191029, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06316705616191029, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06316705616191029, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an empty metal shopping cart with red plastic handles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cart moving down a steep, cracked asphalt descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the cart have one damaged front wheel lurching violently from side to side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show distant suburban houses, telephone poles, and sparse trees being compressed and rushed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a simultaneous zoom out and zoom in while maintaining the cart's size in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.030831536278128624 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5308315753936768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.030831536278128624, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.030831536278128624, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2633638083934784, + 0.05329534411430359, + 0.037680868059396744, + 0.04458185285329819, + 0.11900515109300613, + 0.04292897507548332, + 0.07997720688581467, + 0.03971368819475174, + 0.11606137454509735, + 0.20339170098304749 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.030831536278128624 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an empty metal shopping cart with red plastic handles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cart moving down a steep, cracked asphalt descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the cart have one damaged front wheel lurching violently from side to side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show distant suburban houses, telephone poles, and sparse trees being compressed and rushed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a simultaneous zoom out and zoom in while maintaining the cart's size in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02635919861495495 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513590812683105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02635919861495495, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02635919861495495, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11430736631155014, + 0.11945968121290207, + 0.1630556434392929, + 0.20274293422698975, + 0.10461582243442535, + 0.09457296878099442, + 0.08354880660772324, + 0.039548277854919434, + 0.03221391513943672, + 0.045934583991765976 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02635919861495495 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an empty metal shopping cart with red plastic handles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cart moving down a steep, cracked asphalt descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the cart have one damaged front wheel lurching violently from side to side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show distant suburban houses, telephone poles, and sparse trees being compressed and rushed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a simultaneous zoom out and zoom in while maintaining the cart's size in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026346195489168167 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651346206665039 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026346195489168167, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026346195489168167, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1931263506412506, + 0.11138385534286499, + 0.04514136537909508, + 0.1293129026889801, + 0.1345502734184265, + 0.060481034219264984, + 0.0770181342959404, + 0.06664835661649704, + 0.05032264068722725, + 0.1320151388645172 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026346195489168167 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an empty metal shopping cart with red plastic handles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cart moving down a steep, cracked asphalt descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the cart have one damaged front wheel lurching violently from side to side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show distant suburban houses, telephone poles, and sparse trees being compressed and rushed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a simultaneous zoom out and zoom in while maintaining the cart's size in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067374915815889835 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00673770904541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067374915815889835, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067374915815889835, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2126660794019699, + 0.04707551375031471, + 0.053807709366083145, + 0.08889464288949966, + 0.12564966082572937, + 0.1328144669532776, + 0.1184888556599617, + 0.10049845278263092, + 0.03907158598303795, + 0.08103301376104355 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067374915815889835 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an empty metal shopping cart with red plastic handles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cart moving down a steep, cracked asphalt descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the cart have one damaged front wheel lurching violently from side to side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show distant suburban houses, telephone poles, and sparse trees being compressed and rushed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a simultaneous zoom out and zoom in while maintaining the cart's size in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22556085884571075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005609035491943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22556085884571075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22556085884571075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08208764344453812, + 0.11863983422517776, + 0.06514289230108261, + 0.08127649128437042, + 0.10580670833587646, + 0.08327146619558334, + 0.16499997675418854, + 0.14704035222530365, + 0.07310361415147781, + 0.07863105088472366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22556085884571075 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful Hitchcockian zoom shot, beginning from a low, ground-level angle, rapidly zooms out while simultaneously zooming in, locking onto an empty metal shopping cart. The cart hurtles uncontrollably down a steep, cracked asphalt descent. The glaring afternoon sun reflects sharp, shaky spots of light off the cart's shiny chrome basket, its red plastic handles slightly faded and worn from constant use. Driven by gravity, its four small, black, hard rubber wheels spin wildly, one front wheel, damaged, lurching violently from side to side. The cart's high-speed progress emits a creaking metallic shudder and stirs up a fine cloud of dust and gravel. As the camera continues to move, the size of the shopping cart remains unchanged in the frame, but the background behind it - distant suburban houses, telephone poles and sparse trees - is visually compressed and rushed forward, creating a strong sense of spatial distortion and dizziness, vividly rendering the fury of speed and the sense of danger of losing control. The whole picture presents a heart-pounding, hyper-realistic dynamic tension.", + "seed": 12352, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_1/index_4569_seed_12352_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.09811461577191949, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09811461577191949, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09811461577191949, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an empty metal shopping cart with red plastic handles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cart moving down a steep, cracked asphalt descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the cart have one damaged front wheel lurching violently from side to side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show distant suburban houses, telephone poles, and sparse trees being compressed and rushed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a simultaneous zoom out and zoom in while maintaining the cart's size in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009355632588267326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.759355545043945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009355632588267326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009355632588267326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21754887700080872, + 0.09617187827825546, + 0.06221408769488335, + 0.10169003158807755, + 0.07889491319656372, + 0.15824440121650696, + 0.10815678536891937, + 0.08601951599121094, + 0.04747205972671509, + 0.04358750209212303 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009355632588267326 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an empty metal shopping cart with red plastic handles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cart moving down a steep, cracked asphalt descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the cart have one damaged front wheel lurching violently from side to side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show distant suburban houses, telephone poles, and sparse trees being compressed and rushed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a simultaneous zoom out and zoom in while maintaining the cart's size in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002459466457367 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950244903564453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002459466457367, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002459466457367, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19727963209152222, + 0.13174737989902496, + 0.09482944756746292, + 0.14138200879096985, + 0.061018213629722595, + 0.04094463214278221, + 0.16828198730945587, + 0.0861024409532547, + 0.047442223876714706, + 0.030972115695476532 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002459466457367 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an empty metal shopping cart with red plastic handles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cart moving down a steep, cracked asphalt descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the cart have one damaged front wheel lurching violently from side to side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show distant suburban houses, telephone poles, and sparse trees being compressed and rushed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a simultaneous zoom out and zoom in while maintaining the cart's size in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054944366216659546 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299442768096924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054944366216659546, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054944366216659546, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1700504869222641, + 0.1167730912566185, + 0.09636294841766357, + 0.17498791217803955, + 0.040928471833467484, + 0.08094868063926697, + 0.09566149115562439, + 0.1281065195798874, + 0.050025589764118195, + 0.04615483060479164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054944366216659546 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an empty metal shopping cart with red plastic handles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cart moving down a steep, cracked asphalt descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the cart have one damaged front wheel lurching violently from side to side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show distant suburban houses, telephone poles, and sparse trees being compressed and rushed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a simultaneous zoom out and zoom in while maintaining the cart's size in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00763084227219224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882630825042725 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00763084227219224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00763084227219224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2404738813638687, + 0.17551472783088684, + 0.08996548503637314, + 0.12697507441043854, + 0.043476082384586334, + 0.07395622879266739, + 0.04285254329442978, + 0.10188011825084686, + 0.07181845605373383, + 0.033087391406297684 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00763084227219224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an empty metal shopping cart with red plastic handles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cart moving down a steep, cracked asphalt descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the cart have one damaged front wheel lurching violently from side to side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show distant suburban houses, telephone poles, and sparse trees being compressed and rushed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a simultaneous zoom out and zoom in while maintaining the cart's size in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34861764311790466 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223617672920227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34861764311790466, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34861764311790466, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.117607481777668, + 0.1344260573387146, + 0.11703906208276749, + 0.15103159844875336, + 0.11373305320739746, + 0.04619738832116127, + 0.07043229788541794, + 0.09410352259874344, + 0.10961689054965973, + 0.04581265524029732 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34861764311790466 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful Hitchcockian zoom shot, beginning from a low, ground-level angle, rapidly zooms out while simultaneously zooming in, locking onto an empty metal shopping cart. The cart hurtles uncontrollably down a steep, cracked asphalt descent. The glaring afternoon sun reflects sharp, shaky spots of light off the cart's shiny chrome basket, its red plastic handles slightly faded and worn from constant use. Driven by gravity, its four small, black, hard rubber wheels spin wildly, one front wheel, damaged, lurching violently from side to side. The cart's high-speed progress emits a creaking metallic shudder and stirs up a fine cloud of dust and gravel. As the camera continues to move, the size of the shopping cart remains unchanged in the frame, but the background behind it - distant suburban houses, telephone poles and sparse trees - is visually compressed and rushed forward, creating a strong sense of spatial distortion and dizziness, vividly rendering the fury of speed and the sense of danger of losing control. The whole picture presents a heart-pounding, hyper-realistic dynamic tension.", + "seed": 12353, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_1/index_4569_seed_12353_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.07192515777423977, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07192515777423977, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07192515777423977, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an empty metal shopping cart with red plastic handles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cart moving down a steep, cracked asphalt descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the cart have one damaged front wheel lurching violently from side to side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show distant suburban houses, telephone poles, and sparse trees being compressed and rushed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a simultaneous zoom out and zoom in while maintaining the cart's size in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01459340937435627 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264593601226807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01459340937435627, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01459340937435627, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04131969437003136, + 0.011787195689976215, + 0.027462689206004143, + 0.010455572977662086, + 0.016683897003531456, + 0.02642665058374405, + 0.024180445820093155, + 0.7638020515441895, + 0.029070768505334854, + 0.04881100729107857 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01459340937435627 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an empty metal shopping cart with red plastic handles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cart moving down a steep, cracked asphalt descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the cart have one damaged front wheel lurching violently from side to side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show distant suburban houses, telephone poles, and sparse trees being compressed and rushed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a simultaneous zoom out and zoom in while maintaining the cart's size in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029811859130859375 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298118591308594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029811859130859375, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029811859130859375, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.050614695996046066, + 0.016906635835766792, + 0.04043794423341751, + 0.015989305451512337, + 0.01924014650285244, + 0.12070366740226746, + 0.030375676229596138, + 0.493289589881897, + 0.0698409155011177, + 0.14260141551494598 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029811859130859375 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an empty metal shopping cart with red plastic handles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cart moving down a steep, cracked asphalt descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the cart have one damaged front wheel lurching violently from side to side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show distant suburban houses, telephone poles, and sparse trees being compressed and rushed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a simultaneous zoom out and zoom in while maintaining the cart's size in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029805611819028854 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298056602478027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029805611819028854, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029805611819028854, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.027141131460666656, + 0.007029951550066471, + 0.021524319425225258, + 0.011999919079244137, + 0.016084369271993637, + 0.038890961557626724, + 0.019870741292834282, + 0.7515095472335815, + 0.013870708644390106, + 0.09207823872566223 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029805611819028854 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an empty metal shopping cart with red plastic handles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cart moving down a steep, cracked asphalt descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the cart have one damaged front wheel lurching violently from side to side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show distant suburban houses, telephone poles, and sparse trees being compressed and rushed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a simultaneous zoom out and zoom in while maintaining the cart's size in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004095975775271654 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504096031188965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004095975775271654, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004095975775271654, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08957825601100922, + 0.020870555192232132, + 0.029111163690686226, + 0.042040158063173294, + 0.03854309767484665, + 0.455768883228302, + 0.026698723435401917, + 0.17574144899845123, + 0.05448191985487938, + 0.06716585159301758 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004095975775271654 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an empty metal shopping cart with red plastic handles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cart moving down a steep, cracked asphalt descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the cart have one damaged front wheel lurching violently from side to side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show distant suburban houses, telephone poles, and sparse trees being compressed and rushed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a simultaneous zoom out and zoom in while maintaining the cart's size in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28131893277168274 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063189029693604 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28131893277168274, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28131893277168274, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06880892813205719, + 0.034726567566394806, + 0.11192578822374344, + 0.06771795451641083, + 0.09449109435081482, + 0.11060268431901932, + 0.03284212201833725, + 0.07541092485189438, + 0.09087380021810532, + 0.3126000761985779 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28131893277168274 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful Hitchcockian zoom shot, beginning from a low, ground-level angle, rapidly zooms out while simultaneously zooming in, locking onto an empty metal shopping cart. The cart hurtles uncontrollably down a steep, cracked asphalt descent. The glaring afternoon sun reflects sharp, shaky spots of light off the cart's shiny chrome basket, its red plastic handles slightly faded and worn from constant use. Driven by gravity, its four small, black, hard rubber wheels spin wildly, one front wheel, damaged, lurching violently from side to side. The cart's high-speed progress emits a creaking metallic shudder and stirs up a fine cloud of dust and gravel. As the camera continues to move, the size of the shopping cart remains unchanged in the frame, but the background behind it - distant suburban houses, telephone poles and sparse trees - is visually compressed and rushed forward, creating a strong sense of spatial distortion and dizziness, vividly rendering the fury of speed and the sense of danger of losing control. The whole picture presents a heart-pounding, hyper-realistic dynamic tension.", + "seed": 12354, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_1/index_4569_seed_12354_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.117018548771739, + "vlm_logprob": -0.117018548771739, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.6499999880790712, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.117018548771739, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an empty metal shopping cart with red plastic handles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cart moving down a steep, cracked asphalt descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the cart have one damaged front wheel lurching violently from side to side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show distant suburban houses, telephone poles, and sparse trees being compressed and rushed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a simultaneous zoom out and zoom in while maintaining the cart's size in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05628103390336037 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.931281089782715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05628103390336037, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05628103390336037, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03886988013982773, + 0.03029397875070572, + 0.015725301578640938, + 0.055204007774591446, + 0.059908002614974976, + 0.028047794476151466, + 0.3589152693748474, + 0.29192548990249634, + 0.058196116238832474, + 0.06291420757770538 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05628103390336037 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an empty metal shopping cart with red plastic handles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cart moving down a steep, cracked asphalt descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the cart have one damaged front wheel lurching violently from side to side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show distant suburban houses, telephone poles, and sparse trees being compressed and rushed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a simultaneous zoom out and zoom in while maintaining the cart's size in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10034256428480148 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503425121307373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10034256428480148, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10034256428480148, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13917230069637299, + 0.11790116131305695, + 0.016693437471985817, + 0.036496542394161224, + 0.0384962297976017, + 0.03373205289244652, + 0.32058557868003845, + 0.11381625384092331, + 0.09441832453012466, + 0.08868807554244995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10034256428480148 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an empty metal shopping cart with red plastic handles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cart moving down a steep, cracked asphalt descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the cart have one damaged front wheel lurching violently from side to side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show distant suburban houses, telephone poles, and sparse trees being compressed and rushed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a simultaneous zoom out and zoom in while maintaining the cart's size in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003704458475113 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950371265411377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003704458475113, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003704458475113, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05856769159436226, + 0.06539157778024673, + 0.02469714917242527, + 0.1095946729183197, + 0.031133558601140976, + 0.051910899579524994, + 0.4219028353691101, + 0.09328499436378479, + 0.09002555906772614, + 0.05349107086658478 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003704458475113 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an empty metal shopping cart with red plastic handles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cart moving down a steep, cracked asphalt descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the cart have one damaged front wheel lurching violently from side to side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show distant suburban houses, telephone poles, and sparse trees being compressed and rushed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a simultaneous zoom out and zoom in while maintaining the cart's size in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0097875464707613 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634787559509277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0097875464707613, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0097875464707613, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15420374274253845, + 0.07688938826322556, + 0.04993906989693642, + 0.05104947090148926, + 0.02685568481683731, + 0.042606789618730545, + 0.23915307223796844, + 0.2294733226299286, + 0.07921073585748672, + 0.05061865970492363 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0097875464707613 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an empty metal shopping cart with red plastic handles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the cart moving down a steep, cracked asphalt descent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the cart have one damaged front wheel lurching violently from side to side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background show distant suburban houses, telephone poles, and sparse trees being compressed and rushed forward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a simultaneous zoom out and zoom in while maintaining the cart's size in the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34864455461502075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223644495010376 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34864455461502075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8749999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34864455461502075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.539943516254425, + 0.025992292910814285, + 0.016894903033971786, + 0.027814459055662155, + 0.025365497916936874, + 0.03680364787578583, + 0.1719340980052948, + 0.05255245789885521, + 0.029103944078087807, + 0.07359511405229568 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34864455461502075 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_10/index_tensor([2596, 2596])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_10/index_tensor([2596, 2596])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0918e31250a6451fb036bea3a561599936c1b735 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_10/index_tensor([2596, 2596])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic shot, beginning in close-up and rapidly zooming out, initially focuses on the interior of a modern, minimalist wardrobe dryer, where a freshly washed, immaculately white, lightweight cotton shirt hangs. Built-in warm yellow LED lighting softly illuminates the space, and the hems and cuffs of the shirt gently undulate and flutter in the warm air. The camera then quickly and smoothly pulls back, revealing the matte white dryer, which blends seamlessly into its surroundings, standing quietly in a corner of the bedroom. As the camera continues to pull back, the warm and tidy bedroom is fully captured: a large bed covered in an off-white knitted blanket, a nightstand stocked with a small lamp and a few books, and polished light-colored wood floors. The light from within the room complements the light from the dryer, creating a warm and tranquil effect. The scene, dominated by off-white, light wood, and warm yellow tones, ultimately creates a homely atmosphere of ultimate comfort, comfort, and a sense of life.", + "seed": 20603, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_10/index_2596_seed_20603_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.016339288093149662, + "vlm_logprob": -0.016339288093149662, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.016339288093149662, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot inside a modern, minimalist wardrobe dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly washed, immaculately white, lightweight cotton shirt hanging inside the dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the hems and cuffs of the shirt gently undulate and flutter in the warm air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom out from the close-up to reveal a matte white dryer and a tidy bedroom with a large bed, nightstand, and light-colored wood floors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm yellow LED lighting and dominated by off-white, light wood, and warm yellow tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.027690652757883072 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6526906490325928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.027690652757883072, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.027690652757883072, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17270347476005554, + 0.03635271638631821, + 0.03033735416829586, + 0.04773963615298271, + 0.06948380917310715, + 0.35374584794044495, + 0.05946791172027588, + 0.02725200355052948, + 0.16618019342422485, + 0.036737002432346344 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.027690652757883072 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot inside a modern, minimalist wardrobe dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly washed, immaculately white, lightweight cotton shirt hanging inside the dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the hems and cuffs of the shirt gently undulate and flutter in the warm air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom out from the close-up to reveal a matte white dryer and a tidy bedroom with a large bed, nightstand, and light-colored wood floors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm yellow LED lighting and dominated by off-white, light wood, and warm yellow tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016103560104966164 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141103744506836 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016103560104966164, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016103560104966164, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04193645715713501, + 0.031702544540166855, + 0.026475315913558006, + 0.04943236708641052, + 0.024736348539590836, + 0.28846707940101624, + 0.03640925511717796, + 0.011320549063384533, + 0.4519958794116974, + 0.03752421960234642 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016103560104966164 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot inside a modern, minimalist wardrobe dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly washed, immaculately white, lightweight cotton shirt hanging inside the dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the hems and cuffs of the shirt gently undulate and flutter in the warm air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom out from the close-up to reveal a matte white dryer and a tidy bedroom with a large bed, nightstand, and light-colored wood floors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm yellow LED lighting and dominated by off-white, light wood, and warm yellow tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023305309936404228 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733054161071777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023305309936404228, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023305309936404228, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.098222516477108, + 0.05110366269946098, + 0.06792067736387253, + 0.0735248476266861, + 0.0719921737909317, + 0.4290527105331421, + 0.06772550195455551, + 0.019169388338923454, + 0.07738654315471649, + 0.04390201345086098 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023305309936404228 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot inside a modern, minimalist wardrobe dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly washed, immaculately white, lightweight cotton shirt hanging inside the dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the hems and cuffs of the shirt gently undulate and flutter in the warm air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom out from the close-up to reveal a matte white dryer and a tidy bedroom with a large bed, nightstand, and light-colored wood floors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm yellow LED lighting and dominated by off-white, light wood, and warm yellow tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005954977124929428 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130954742431641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005954977124929428, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005954977124929428, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03149319440126419, + 0.015971487388014793, + 0.050353825092315674, + 0.022082161158323288, + 0.07551494985818863, + 0.24811145663261414, + 0.057606570422649384, + 0.022173093631863594, + 0.43613219261169434, + 0.04056110233068466 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005954977124929428 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot inside a modern, minimalist wardrobe dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly washed, immaculately white, lightweight cotton shirt hanging inside the dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the hems and cuffs of the shirt gently undulate and flutter in the warm air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom out from the close-up to reveal a matte white dryer and a tidy bedroom with a large bed, nightstand, and light-colored wood floors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm yellow LED lighting and dominated by off-white, light wood, and warm yellow tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008641940541565418 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758641719818115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008641940541565418, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008641940541565418, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1516539752483368, + 0.05935169756412506, + 0.03354811295866966, + 0.025373846292495728, + 0.060254912823438644, + 0.06613434106111526, + 0.10134689509868622, + 0.05003910884261131, + 0.24352878332138062, + 0.2087683528661728 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008641940541565418 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic shot, beginning in close-up and rapidly zooming out, initially focuses on the interior of a modern, minimalist wardrobe dryer, where a freshly washed, immaculately white, lightweight cotton shirt hangs. Built-in warm yellow LED lighting softly illuminates the space, and the hems and cuffs of the shirt gently undulate and flutter in the warm air. The camera then quickly and smoothly pulls back, revealing the matte white dryer, which blends seamlessly into its surroundings, standing quietly in a corner of the bedroom. As the camera continues to pull back, the warm and tidy bedroom is fully captured: a large bed covered in an off-white knitted blanket, a nightstand stocked with a small lamp and a few books, and polished light-colored wood floors. The light from within the room complements the light from the dryer, creating a warm and tranquil effect. The scene, dominated by off-white, light wood, and warm yellow tones, ultimately creates a homely atmosphere of ultimate comfort, comfort, and a sense of life.", + "seed": 20604, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_10/index_2596_seed_20604_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03549287971109152, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03549287971109152, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03549287971109152, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot inside a modern, minimalist wardrobe dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly washed, immaculately white, lightweight cotton shirt hanging inside the dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the hems and cuffs of the shirt gently undulate and flutter in the warm air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom out from the close-up to reveal a matte white dryer and a tidy bedroom with a large bed, nightstand, and light-colored wood floors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm yellow LED lighting and dominated by off-white, light wood, and warm yellow tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06353190541267395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8135318756103516 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06353190541267395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06353190541267395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29352715611457825, + 0.11460677534341812, + 0.07108124345541, + 0.09217743575572968, + 0.10271675884723663, + 0.11793974041938782, + 0.03791727498173714, + 0.033414606004953384, + 0.06298580020666122, + 0.07363317906856537 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06353190541267395 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot inside a modern, minimalist wardrobe dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly washed, immaculately white, lightweight cotton shirt hanging inside the dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the hems and cuffs of the shirt gently undulate and flutter in the warm air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom out from the close-up to reveal a matte white dryer and a tidy bedroom with a large bed, nightstand, and light-colored wood floors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm yellow LED lighting and dominated by off-white, light wood, and warm yellow tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04871416091918945 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0487141609191895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04871416091918945, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04871416091918945, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4042961299419403, + 0.09620307385921478, + 0.09878852218389511, + 0.14643076062202454, + 0.07220344990491867, + 0.05390189588069916, + 0.015773411840200424, + 0.028673289343714714, + 0.03368069976568222, + 0.05004873126745224 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04871416091918945 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot inside a modern, minimalist wardrobe dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly washed, immaculately white, lightweight cotton shirt hanging inside the dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the hems and cuffs of the shirt gently undulate and flutter in the warm air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom out from the close-up to reveal a matte white dryer and a tidy bedroom with a large bed, nightstand, and light-colored wood floors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm yellow LED lighting and dominated by off-white, light wood, and warm yellow tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048684414476156235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486843585968018 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048684414476156235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048684414476156235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3489220142364502, + 0.1124434620141983, + 0.11272834986448288, + 0.11565263569355011, + 0.09729333966970444, + 0.031101051717996597, + 0.02122610993683338, + 0.03096052072942257, + 0.07053264230489731, + 0.05913986265659332 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048684414476156235 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot inside a modern, minimalist wardrobe dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly washed, immaculately white, lightweight cotton shirt hanging inside the dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the hems and cuffs of the shirt gently undulate and flutter in the warm air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom out from the close-up to reveal a matte white dryer and a tidy bedroom with a large bed, nightstand, and light-colored wood floors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm yellow LED lighting and dominated by off-white, light wood, and warm yellow tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006746135652065277 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006746292114258 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006746135652065277, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006746135652065277, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15831300616264343, + 0.11715573072433472, + 0.10837341845035553, + 0.04537263512611389, + 0.31565502285957336, + 0.05788876488804817, + 0.034525252878665924, + 0.0735030546784401, + 0.039104487746953964, + 0.05010870471596718 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006746135652065277 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot inside a modern, minimalist wardrobe dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly washed, immaculately white, lightweight cotton shirt hanging inside the dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the hems and cuffs of the shirt gently undulate and flutter in the warm air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom out from the close-up to reveal a matte white dryer and a tidy bedroom with a large bed, nightstand, and light-colored wood floors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm yellow LED lighting and dominated by off-white, light wood, and warm yellow tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009787782095372677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634787559509277 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009787782095372677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009787782095372677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23704136908054352, + 0.1762874871492386, + 0.1609494388103485, + 0.09121331572532654, + 0.08329150080680847, + 0.046543095260858536, + 0.0265531986951828, + 0.0504060760140419, + 0.05636066570878029, + 0.07135387510061264 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009787782095372677 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic shot, beginning in close-up and rapidly zooming out, initially focuses on the interior of a modern, minimalist wardrobe dryer, where a freshly washed, immaculately white, lightweight cotton shirt hangs. Built-in warm yellow LED lighting softly illuminates the space, and the hems and cuffs of the shirt gently undulate and flutter in the warm air. The camera then quickly and smoothly pulls back, revealing the matte white dryer, which blends seamlessly into its surroundings, standing quietly in a corner of the bedroom. As the camera continues to pull back, the warm and tidy bedroom is fully captured: a large bed covered in an off-white knitted blanket, a nightstand stocked with a small lamp and a few books, and polished light-colored wood floors. The light from within the room complements the light from the dryer, creating a warm and tranquil effect. The scene, dominated by off-white, light wood, and warm yellow tones, ultimately creates a homely atmosphere of ultimate comfort, comfort, and a sense of life.", + "seed": 20605, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_10/index_2596_seed_20605_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.015462431870400906, + "vlm_logprob": -0.015462431870400906, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.015462431870400906, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot inside a modern, minimalist wardrobe dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly washed, immaculately white, lightweight cotton shirt hanging inside the dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the hems and cuffs of the shirt gently undulate and flutter in the warm air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom out from the close-up to reveal a matte white dryer and a tidy bedroom with a large bed, nightstand, and light-colored wood floors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm yellow LED lighting and dominated by off-white, light wood, and warm yellow tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02785065583884716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.65285062789917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02785065583884716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02785065583884716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15807701647281647, + 0.06482104957103729, + 0.06433866918087006, + 0.04770142212510109, + 0.19980254769325256, + 0.055240631103515625, + 0.11624359339475632, + 0.06573634594678879, + 0.14395762979984283, + 0.08408111333847046 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02785065583884716 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot inside a modern, minimalist wardrobe dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly washed, immaculately white, lightweight cotton shirt hanging inside the dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the hems and cuffs of the shirt gently undulate and flutter in the warm air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom out from the close-up to reveal a matte white dryer and a tidy bedroom with a large bed, nightstand, and light-colored wood floors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm yellow LED lighting and dominated by off-white, light wood, and warm yellow tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01422679703682661 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264226913452148 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01422679703682661, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01422679703682661, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0645546019077301, + 0.052040357142686844, + 0.04681048169732094, + 0.035240065306425095, + 0.2605855166912079, + 0.11073562502861023, + 0.07597782462835312, + 0.11726003140211105, + 0.1906009167432785, + 0.04619460552930832 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01422679703682661 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot inside a modern, minimalist wardrobe dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly washed, immaculately white, lightweight cotton shirt hanging inside the dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the hems and cuffs of the shirt gently undulate and flutter in the warm air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom out from the close-up to reveal a matte white dryer and a tidy bedroom with a large bed, nightstand, and light-colored wood floors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm yellow LED lighting and dominated by off-white, light wood, and warm yellow tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018203342333436012 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018203258514404 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018203342333436012, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018203342333436012, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03946559503674507, + 0.07385467737913132, + 0.05000787973403931, + 0.06076877564191818, + 0.238702192902565, + 0.14359891414642334, + 0.03554175794124603, + 0.08863971382379532, + 0.24066045880317688, + 0.028760002925992012 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018203342333436012 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot inside a modern, minimalist wardrobe dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly washed, immaculately white, lightweight cotton shirt hanging inside the dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the hems and cuffs of the shirt gently undulate and flutter in the warm air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom out from the close-up to reveal a matte white dryer and a tidy bedroom with a large bed, nightstand, and light-colored wood floors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm yellow LED lighting and dominated by off-white, light wood, and warm yellow tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059540290385484695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130954265594482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059540290385484695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059540290385484695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07771395146846771, + 0.07804360240697861, + 0.025881005451083183, + 0.037616487592458725, + 0.19824548065662384, + 0.04139898344874382, + 0.09518858045339584, + 0.03611934930086136, + 0.3281543552875519, + 0.08163824677467346 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059540290385484695 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot inside a modern, minimalist wardrobe dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly washed, immaculately white, lightweight cotton shirt hanging inside the dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the hems and cuffs of the shirt gently undulate and flutter in the warm air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom out from the close-up to reveal a matte white dryer and a tidy bedroom with a large bed, nightstand, and light-colored wood floors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm yellow LED lighting and dominated by off-white, light wood, and warm yellow tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011077335104346275 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511077404022217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011077335104346275, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011077335104346275, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18188832700252533, + 0.05971911922097206, + 0.0867624431848526, + 0.12826387584209442, + 0.1733836829662323, + 0.10667400807142258, + 0.1006086990237236, + 0.03431887924671173, + 0.07748664170503616, + 0.05089437589049339 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011077335104346275 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic shot, beginning in close-up and rapidly zooming out, initially focuses on the interior of a modern, minimalist wardrobe dryer, where a freshly washed, immaculately white, lightweight cotton shirt hangs. Built-in warm yellow LED lighting softly illuminates the space, and the hems and cuffs of the shirt gently undulate and flutter in the warm air. The camera then quickly and smoothly pulls back, revealing the matte white dryer, which blends seamlessly into its surroundings, standing quietly in a corner of the bedroom. As the camera continues to pull back, the warm and tidy bedroom is fully captured: a large bed covered in an off-white knitted blanket, a nightstand stocked with a small lamp and a few books, and polished light-colored wood floors. The light from within the room complements the light from the dryer, creating a warm and tranquil effect. The scene, dominated by off-white, light wood, and warm yellow tones, ultimately creates a homely atmosphere of ultimate comfort, comfort, and a sense of life.", + "seed": 20606, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_10/index_2596_seed_20606_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.023889303393661975, + "vlm_logprob": -0.023889303393661975, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.023889303393661975, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot inside a modern, minimalist wardrobe dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly washed, immaculately white, lightweight cotton shirt hanging inside the dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the hems and cuffs of the shirt gently undulate and flutter in the warm air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom out from the close-up to reveal a matte white dryer and a tidy bedroom with a large bed, nightstand, and light-colored wood floors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm yellow LED lighting and dominated by off-white, light wood, and warm yellow tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05687842518091202 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9318783283233643 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05687842518091202, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05687842518091202, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3381975591182709, + 0.13265018165111542, + 0.07110830396413803, + 0.1140926331281662, + 0.061501629650592804, + 0.15572790801525116, + 0.04544670879840851, + 0.017467306926846504, + 0.039866164326667786, + 0.02394164726138115 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05687842518091202 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot inside a modern, minimalist wardrobe dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly washed, immaculately white, lightweight cotton shirt hanging inside the dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the hems and cuffs of the shirt gently undulate and flutter in the warm air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom out from the close-up to reveal a matte white dryer and a tidy bedroom with a large bed, nightstand, and light-colored wood floors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm yellow LED lighting and dominated by off-white, light wood, and warm yellow tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016103794798254967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141103744506836 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016103794798254967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016103794798254967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06954383105039597, + 0.10045051574707031, + 0.1944941133260727, + 0.08790437877178192, + 0.03907328471541405, + 0.3104521334171295, + 0.04004621133208275, + 0.01445399783551693, + 0.05300815403461456, + 0.09057343751192093 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016103794798254967 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot inside a modern, minimalist wardrobe dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly washed, immaculately white, lightweight cotton shirt hanging inside the dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the hems and cuffs of the shirt gently undulate and flutter in the warm air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom out from the close-up to reveal a matte white dryer and a tidy bedroom with a large bed, nightstand, and light-colored wood floors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm yellow LED lighting and dominated by off-white, light wood, and warm yellow tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020599590614438057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895599603652954 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020599590614438057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020599590614438057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24201267957687378, + 0.09494861960411072, + 0.1800544559955597, + 0.07918594032526016, + 0.08722923696041107, + 0.07126413285732269, + 0.1298021823167801, + 0.021288443356752396, + 0.03616541624069214, + 0.05804885923862457 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020599590614438057 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot inside a modern, minimalist wardrobe dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly washed, immaculately white, lightweight cotton shirt hanging inside the dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the hems and cuffs of the shirt gently undulate and flutter in the warm air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom out from the close-up to reveal a matte white dryer and a tidy bedroom with a large bed, nightstand, and light-colored wood floors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm yellow LED lighting and dominated by off-white, light wood, and warm yellow tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016078222543001175 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141077995300293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016078222543001175, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016078222543001175, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09680910408496857, + 0.10905178636312485, + 0.07498742640018463, + 0.09371209144592285, + 0.05422439053654671, + 0.2063612937927246, + 0.18107277154922485, + 0.04527483507990837, + 0.07632429897785187, + 0.0621819905936718 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016078222543001175 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a close-up shot inside a modern, minimalist wardrobe dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a freshly washed, immaculately white, lightweight cotton shirt hanging inside the dryer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the hems and cuffs of the shirt gently undulate and flutter in the warm air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rapidly zoom out from the close-up to reveal a matte white dryer and a tidy bedroom with a large bed, nightstand, and light-colored wood floors?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm yellow LED lighting and dominated by off-white, light wood, and warm yellow tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009786483831703663 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634786605834961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009786483831703663, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009786483831703663, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16314978897571564, + 0.10021807998418808, + 0.07721797376871109, + 0.04921058565378189, + 0.042057935148477554, + 0.3396700620651245, + 0.0986105427145958, + 0.027305210009217262, + 0.030992541462183, + 0.07156722247600555 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009786483831703663 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_11/index_tensor([350, 350])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_11/index_tensor([350, 350])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6a0f5c5fa343e13c5581bedc5d5ec3ee2fe686ca --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_11/index_tensor([350, 350])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "sweeping, high-angle, panoramic shot slowly slides across a vast, three-dimensional tactical map of ancient China, rendered in a stark, high-contrast digital look and suspended in an infinite, matte-black void. Complex, glowing cyan lines form a wireframe grid against the darkness, a topographical grid, with major rivers depicted as flowing bands of pale blue light. The Great Wall is the most prominent feature, a brilliant white glowing line winding through the digital landscape, punctuated by distinct nodes of watchtowers. The action begins when a blinding bright spot, representing a signal flare, materializes at one end of the wall. Moving at incredible speed, it is a white-hot core, trailing a trail of golden energy particles, swiftly and decisively tracing the glowing path. As it reaches each watchtower, the node momentarily erupts with concentric pulses of golden-white light, and the signal then continues its unstoppable journey, connecting tower to tower in a rapid chain reaction that illuminates the strategic arteries of the ancient empire and creates a tense and urgent atmosphere of high-stakes communication.", + "seed": 93, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_11/index_350_seed_93_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.11885604155249893, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11885604155249893, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11885604155249893, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle panoramic shot of a three-dimensional tactical map of ancient China?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background an infinite matte-black void with a stark, high-contrast digital look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible as a brilliant white glowing line with distinct watchtower nodes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright white-hot signal flare travel rapidly along the wall, triggering golden-white light pulses at each watchtower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly slide across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.21116577088832855 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7111657857894897 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.21116577088832855, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.21116577088832855, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3052380084991455, + 0.15501344203948975, + 0.04319636523723602, + 0.047269124537706375, + 0.17060628533363342, + 0.08284921944141388, + 0.06330466270446777, + 0.05755362659692764, + 0.036352306604385376, + 0.038616910576820374 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.21116577088832855 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle panoramic shot of a three-dimensional tactical map of ancient China?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background an infinite matte-black void with a stark, high-contrast digital look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible as a brilliant white glowing line with distinct watchtower nodes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright white-hot signal flare travel rapidly along the wall, triggering golden-white light pulses at each watchtower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly slide across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14284871518611908 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178487300872803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14284871518611908, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14284871518611908, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09481325000524521, + 0.5140300393104553, + 0.10643354803323746, + 0.060757603496313095, + 0.05836144834756851, + 0.021453766152262688, + 0.03351183235645294, + 0.06612551212310791, + 0.03255363181233406, + 0.011959396302700043 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14284871518611908 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle panoramic shot of a three-dimensional tactical map of ancient China?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background an infinite matte-black void with a stark, high-contrast digital look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible as a brilliant white glowing line with distinct watchtower nodes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright white-hot signal flare travel rapidly along the wall, triggering golden-white light pulses at each watchtower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly slide across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011092543601989746 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511092662811279 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011092543601989746, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011092543601989746, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2013416588306427, + 0.3172122538089752, + 0.06397099792957306, + 0.09393230080604553, + 0.16577227413654327, + 0.0326266884803772, + 0.02231626585125923, + 0.03628275915980339, + 0.027012474834918976, + 0.039532389491796494 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011092543601989746 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle panoramic shot of a three-dimensional tactical map of ancient China?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background an infinite matte-black void with a stark, high-contrast digital look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible as a brilliant white glowing line with distinct watchtower nodes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright white-hot signal flare travel rapidly along the wall, triggering golden-white light pulses at each watchtower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly slide across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036204999778419733 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628620624542236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036204999778419733, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036204999778419733, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20218868553638458, + 0.1882210522890091, + 0.07918228954076767, + 0.18671876192092896, + 0.12171398103237152, + 0.05104643478989601, + 0.033747002482414246, + 0.027277417480945587, + 0.05944591388106346, + 0.05045836791396141 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036204999778419733 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle panoramic shot of a three-dimensional tactical map of ancient China?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background an infinite matte-black void with a stark, high-contrast digital look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible as a brilliant white glowing line with distinct watchtower nodes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright white-hot signal flare travel rapidly along the wall, triggering golden-white light pulses at each watchtower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly slide across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22555267810821533 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005526781082153 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22555267810821533, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22555267810821533, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07866118848323822, + 0.2529639005661011, + 0.0973161831498146, + 0.15045735239982605, + 0.20913861691951752, + 0.046166159212589264, + 0.061599552631378174, + 0.04205814749002457, + 0.0203254371881485, + 0.04131338372826576 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22555267810821533 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping, high-angle, panoramic shot slowly slides across a vast, three-dimensional tactical map of ancient China, rendered in a stark, high-contrast digital look and suspended in an infinite, matte-black void. Complex, glowing cyan lines form a wireframe grid against the darkness, a topographical grid, with major rivers depicted as flowing bands of pale blue light. The Great Wall is the most prominent feature, a brilliant white glowing line winding through the digital landscape, punctuated by distinct nodes of watchtowers. The action begins when a blinding bright spot, representing a signal flare, materializes at one end of the wall. Moving at incredible speed, it is a white-hot core, trailing a trail of golden energy particles, swiftly and decisively tracing the glowing path. As it reaches each watchtower, the node momentarily erupts with concentric pulses of golden-white light, and the signal then continues its unstoppable journey, connecting tower to tower in a rapid chain reaction that illuminates the strategic arteries of the ancient empire and creates a tense and urgent atmosphere of high-stakes communication.", + "seed": 94, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_11/index_350_seed_94_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.11879712715744972, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11879712715744972, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11879712715744972, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle panoramic shot of a three-dimensional tactical map of ancient China?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background an infinite matte-black void with a stark, high-contrast digital look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible as a brilliant white glowing line with distinct watchtower nodes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright white-hot signal flare travel rapidly along the wall, triggering golden-white light pulses at each watchtower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly slide across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020124537870287895 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.270124435424805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020124537870287895, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020124537870287895, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23272378742694855, + 0.12455030530691147, + 0.07229122519493103, + 0.0912235826253891, + 0.023366007953882217, + 0.024825748056173325, + 0.23052220046520233, + 0.05523785576224327, + 0.08776436746120453, + 0.05749483406543732 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020124537870287895 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle panoramic shot of a three-dimensional tactical map of ancient China?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background an infinite matte-black void with a stark, high-contrast digital look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible as a brilliant white glowing line with distinct watchtower nodes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright white-hot signal flare travel rapidly along the wall, triggering golden-white light pulses at each watchtower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly slide across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08906705677509308 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464066982269287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08906705677509308, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08906705677509308, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3767043948173523, + 0.2159348875284195, + 0.14151133596897125, + 0.03693482652306557, + 0.0452408492565155, + 0.05681665614247322, + 0.0489826537668705, + 0.028083467856049538, + 0.016824377700686455, + 0.032966554164886475 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08906705677509308 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle panoramic shot of a three-dimensional tactical map of ancient China?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background an infinite matte-black void with a stark, high-contrast digital look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible as a brilliant white glowing line with distinct watchtower nodes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright white-hot signal flare travel rapidly along the wall, triggering golden-white light pulses at each watchtower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly slide across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005264822859317064 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255264759063721 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005264822859317064, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005264822859317064, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20742084085941315, + 0.20326350629329681, + 0.1220296323299408, + 0.06609886139631271, + 0.028917286545038223, + 0.04693061113357544, + 0.11357473582029343, + 0.09769967198371887, + 0.03310857713222504, + 0.0809563547372818 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005264822859317064 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle panoramic shot of a three-dimensional tactical map of ancient China?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background an infinite matte-black void with a stark, high-contrast digital look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible as a brilliant white glowing line with distinct watchtower nodes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright white-hot signal flare travel rapidly along the wall, triggering golden-white light pulses at each watchtower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly slide across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00525687774643302 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255256652832031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00525687774643302, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00525687774643302, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08904378861188889, + 0.05075645446777344, + 0.030199434608221054, + 0.08724623173475266, + 0.037122052162885666, + 0.04096114635467529, + 0.1257798671722412, + 0.35301661491394043, + 0.05635591596364975, + 0.12951844930648804 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00525687774643302 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle panoramic shot of a three-dimensional tactical map of ancient China?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background an infinite matte-black void with a stark, high-contrast digital look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible as a brilliant white glowing line with distinct watchtower nodes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright white-hot signal flare travel rapidly along the wall, triggering golden-white light pulses at each watchtower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly slide across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47427234053611755 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742723703384399 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47427234053611755, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47427234053611755, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10415735095739365, + 0.08117572218179703, + 0.04202805086970329, + 0.1161392480134964, + 0.029204925522208214, + 0.09349758177995682, + 0.10947946459054947, + 0.29215559363365173, + 0.07485420256853104, + 0.05730779469013214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47427234053611755 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping, high-angle, panoramic shot slowly slides across a vast, three-dimensional tactical map of ancient China, rendered in a stark, high-contrast digital look and suspended in an infinite, matte-black void. Complex, glowing cyan lines form a wireframe grid against the darkness, a topographical grid, with major rivers depicted as flowing bands of pale blue light. The Great Wall is the most prominent feature, a brilliant white glowing line winding through the digital landscape, punctuated by distinct nodes of watchtowers. The action begins when a blinding bright spot, representing a signal flare, materializes at one end of the wall. Moving at incredible speed, it is a white-hot core, trailing a trail of golden energy particles, swiftly and decisively tracing the glowing path. As it reaches each watchtower, the node momentarily erupts with concentric pulses of golden-white light, and the signal then continues its unstoppable journey, connecting tower to tower in a rapid chain reaction that illuminates the strategic arteries of the ancient empire and creates a tense and urgent atmosphere of high-stakes communication.", + "seed": 95, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_11/index_350_seed_95_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.13735535733867438, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13735535733867438, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13735535733867438, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle panoramic shot of a three-dimensional tactical map of ancient China?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background an infinite matte-black void with a stark, high-contrast digital look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible as a brilliant white glowing line with distinct watchtower nodes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright white-hot signal flare travel rapidly along the wall, triggering golden-white light pulses at each watchtower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly slide across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03732471168041229 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5373246669769287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03732471168041229, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03732471168041229, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6683493852615356, + 0.07270693778991699, + 0.04773905128240585, + 0.03693070635199547, + 0.017961809411644936, + 0.03964132443070412, + 0.044722478836774826, + 0.01608544960618019, + 0.040227413177490234, + 0.01563538983464241 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03732471168041229 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle panoramic shot of a three-dimensional tactical map of ancient China?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background an infinite matte-black void with a stark, high-contrast digital look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible as a brilliant white glowing line with distinct watchtower nodes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright white-hot signal flare travel rapidly along the wall, triggering golden-white light pulses at each watchtower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly slide across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011096552014350891 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511096477508545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011096552014350891, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011096552014350891, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0948147177696228, + 0.24706049263477325, + 0.015270048752427101, + 0.038835491985082626, + 0.15225067734718323, + 0.1874060183763504, + 0.15400183200836182, + 0.060430943965911865, + 0.0074394866824150085, + 0.04249042645096779 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011096552014350891 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle panoramic shot of a three-dimensional tactical map of ancient China?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background an infinite matte-black void with a stark, high-contrast digital look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible as a brilliant white glowing line with distinct watchtower nodes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright white-hot signal flare travel rapidly along the wall, triggering golden-white light pulses at each watchtower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly slide across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003630477236583829 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628630638122559 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003630477236583829, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003630477236583829, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5413478016853333, + 0.17896990478038788, + 0.05494621768593788, + 0.09568356722593307, + 0.021205246448516846, + 0.0731087177991867, + 0.008902336470782757, + 0.007020685356110334, + 0.011508823372423649, + 0.0073067727498710155 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003630477236583829 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle panoramic shot of a three-dimensional tactical map of ancient China?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background an infinite matte-black void with a stark, high-contrast digital look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible as a brilliant white glowing line with distinct watchtower nodes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright white-hot signal flare travel rapidly along the wall, triggering golden-white light pulses at each watchtower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly slide across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001946580014191568 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251946449279785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001946580014191568, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001946580014191568, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17474400997161865, + 0.19735030829906464, + 0.03846622258424759, + 0.10310280323028564, + 0.10086020082235336, + 0.19899843633174896, + 0.04846971482038498, + 0.021303817629814148, + 0.0571012981235981, + 0.05960317328572273 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001946580014191568 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle panoramic shot of a three-dimensional tactical map of ancient China?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background an infinite matte-black void with a stark, high-contrast digital look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible as a brilliant white glowing line with distinct watchtower nodes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright white-hot signal flare travel rapidly along the wall, triggering golden-white light pulses at each watchtower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly slide across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6327784657478333 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7577784657478333 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6327784657478333, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6327784657478333, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06908499449491501, + 0.28695085644721985, + 0.03363210707902908, + 0.05012594163417816, + 0.11717937886714935, + 0.21110799908638, + 0.032767441123723984, + 0.018526550382375717, + 0.06315799057483673, + 0.11746669560670853 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6327784657478333 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping, high-angle, panoramic shot slowly slides across a vast, three-dimensional tactical map of ancient China, rendered in a stark, high-contrast digital look and suspended in an infinite, matte-black void. Complex, glowing cyan lines form a wireframe grid against the darkness, a topographical grid, with major rivers depicted as flowing bands of pale blue light. The Great Wall is the most prominent feature, a brilliant white glowing line winding through the digital landscape, punctuated by distinct nodes of watchtowers. The action begins when a blinding bright spot, representing a signal flare, materializes at one end of the wall. Moving at incredible speed, it is a white-hot core, trailing a trail of golden energy particles, swiftly and decisively tracing the glowing path. As it reaches each watchtower, the node momentarily erupts with concentric pulses of golden-white light, and the signal then continues its unstoppable journey, connecting tower to tower in a rapid chain reaction that illuminates the strategic arteries of the ancient empire and creates a tense and urgent atmosphere of high-stakes communication.", + "seed": 96, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_11/index_350_seed_96_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.05239398377016187, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05239398377016187, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05239398377016187, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle panoramic shot of a three-dimensional tactical map of ancient China?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background an infinite matte-black void with a stark, high-contrast digital look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible as a brilliant white glowing line with distinct watchtower nodes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright white-hot signal flare travel rapidly along the wall, triggering golden-white light pulses at each watchtower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly slide across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0739295706152916 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.69892954826355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0739295706152916, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0739295706152916, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3502116799354553, + 0.12867261469364166, + 0.14756111800670624, + 0.19837497174739838, + 0.0733226090669632, + 0.02376587688922882, + 0.0224479828029871, + 0.0137373311445117, + 0.022665828466415405, + 0.019239960238337517 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0739295706152916 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle panoramic shot of a three-dimensional tactical map of ancient China?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background an infinite matte-black void with a stark, high-contrast digital look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible as a brilliant white glowing line with distinct watchtower nodes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright white-hot signal flare travel rapidly along the wall, triggering golden-white light pulses at each watchtower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly slide across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812897205352783 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881288528442383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812897205352783, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812897205352783, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17591018974781036, + 0.1679685264825821, + 0.06976926326751709, + 0.19692517817020416, + 0.24202336370944977, + 0.04308515787124634, + 0.024477548897266388, + 0.04222838580608368, + 0.0266705434769392, + 0.010941836051642895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812897205352783 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle panoramic shot of a three-dimensional tactical map of ancient China?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background an infinite matte-black void with a stark, high-contrast digital look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible as a brilliant white glowing line with distinct watchtower nodes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright white-hot signal flare travel rapidly along the wall, triggering golden-white light pulses at each watchtower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly slide across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046457452699542046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379645824432373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046457452699542046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046457452699542046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40470051765441895, + 0.08805202692747116, + 0.12565544247627258, + 0.16808855533599854, + 0.08871208131313324, + 0.0371423214673996, + 0.021794434636831284, + 0.021962620317935944, + 0.024725254625082016, + 0.019166722893714905 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046457452699542046 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle panoramic shot of a three-dimensional tactical map of ancient China?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background an infinite matte-black void with a stark, high-contrast digital look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible as a brilliant white glowing line with distinct watchtower nodes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright white-hot signal flare travel rapidly along the wall, triggering golden-white light pulses at each watchtower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly slide across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002491943072527647 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.0024919509887695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002491943072527647, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002491943072527647, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32663315534591675, + 0.06523124873638153, + 0.28160950541496277, + 0.04448206350207329, + 0.09641916304826736, + 0.041875727474689484, + 0.02967638336122036, + 0.05036482959985733, + 0.0331474244594574, + 0.030560536310076714 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002491943072527647 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a high-angle panoramic shot of a three-dimensional tactical map of ancient China?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background an infinite matte-black void with a stark, high-contrast digital look?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the Great Wall visible as a brilliant white glowing line with distinct watchtower nodes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a bright white-hot signal flare travel rapidly along the wall, triggering golden-white light pulses at each watchtower?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly slide across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14277368783950806 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0177736282348633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14277368783950806, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14277368783950806, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15985730290412903, + 0.1331048309803009, + 0.2689436972141266, + 0.0737970769405365, + 0.1326752007007599, + 0.0568912997841835, + 0.050116974860429764, + 0.0619606077671051, + 0.02710932120680809, + 0.035543665289878845 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14277368783950806 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_12/index_tensor([1122, 1122])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_12/index_tensor([1122, 1122])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..469a157d1c5f3b3b299c2e19d6a71252ba5ddbed --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_12/index_tensor([1122, 1122])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "violently shaky, low-angle wide shot depicts the scene of an abandoned hazardous waste treatment plant, imbued with a Tim Burton-esque eerie aesthetic. The rough, oil- and rust-stained concrete floor slowly and relentlessly cracks, a spiderweb of cracks spreading from the center of the frame. From deep within the crevices, a sickly, pulsing, eerie green light seeps upward. This ominous glow illuminates the jagged edges of the cracks and casts long, eerie, dancing shadows across the corroded, twisted metal scaffolding and the massive, grotesquely shaped storage tanks in the background. As the ground continues to shake, the unstable frame violently pitches up and down, simulating a dizzying sense of chaos, with tiny concrete fragments bouncing and falling in the tremors. The scene is shrouded in a bleak, industrial gray and rust palette, with the otherworldly green glow serving as the sole bright spot, creating a tense, surreal atmosphere of pre-apocalyptic terror.", + "seed": 8559, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_12/index_1122_seed_8559_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06867756927385926, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06867756927385926, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06867756927385926, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an abandoned hazardous waste treatment plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of rough, oil- and rust-stained concrete that is cracking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sickly, pulsing, eerie green light seeping upward from the cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are corroded, twisted metal scaffolding and massive storage tanks visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shaking with a pitch up and down motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07569058239459991 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.700690507888794 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07569058239459991, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07569058239459991, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05821278318762779, + 0.017576878890395164, + 0.028440866619348526, + 0.07583532482385635, + 0.06256573647260666, + 0.08242666721343994, + 0.16832789778709412, + 0.06221411004662514, + 0.41575849056243896, + 0.02864125929772854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07569058239459991 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an abandoned hazardous waste treatment plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of rough, oil- and rust-stained concrete that is cracking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sickly, pulsing, eerie green light seeping upward from the cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are corroded, twisted metal scaffolding and massive storage tanks visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shaking with a pitch up and down motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028435057029128075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877843379974365 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028435057029128075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028435057029128075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08727934211492538, + 0.05151502043008804, + 0.11103975772857666, + 0.07495619356632233, + 0.04128256440162659, + 0.05489775538444519, + 0.14863310754299164, + 0.06014518439769745, + 0.3310331106185913, + 0.0392179861664772 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028435057029128075 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an abandoned hazardous waste treatment plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of rough, oil- and rust-stained concrete that is cracking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sickly, pulsing, eerie green light seeping upward from the cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are corroded, twisted metal scaffolding and massive storage tanks visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shaking with a pitch up and down motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011074505746364594 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511074542999268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011074505746364594, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011074505746364594, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.037779100239276886, + 0.029245510697364807, + 0.060069646686315536, + 0.027489488944411278, + 0.12277717888355255, + 0.09704790264368057, + 0.060914382338523865, + 0.039198584854602814, + 0.5137876272201538, + 0.011690557934343815 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011074505746364594 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an abandoned hazardous waste treatment plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of rough, oil- and rust-stained concrete that is cracking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sickly, pulsing, eerie green light seeping upward from the cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are corroded, twisted metal scaffolding and massive storage tanks visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shaking with a pitch up and down motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017141900025308132 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.37671422958374 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017141900025308132, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017141900025308132, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0572398379445076, + 0.01312388014048338, + 0.03904668614268303, + 0.027974236756563187, + 0.01678205281496048, + 0.06526133418083191, + 0.10982584208250046, + 0.11779876053333282, + 0.4980078637599945, + 0.05493949353694916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017141900025308132 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an abandoned hazardous waste treatment plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of rough, oil- and rust-stained concrete that is cracking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sickly, pulsing, eerie green light seeping upward from the cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are corroded, twisted metal scaffolding and massive storage tanks visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shaking with a pitch up and down motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520650625228882 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020650625228882 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520650625228882, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520650625228882, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06724347919225693, + 0.027241548523306847, + 0.04024161398410797, + 0.04667339473962784, + 0.08009559661149979, + 0.0867614671587944, + 0.23028677701950073, + 0.1167709231376648, + 0.24969454109668732, + 0.054990705102682114 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520650625228882 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "violently shaky, low-angle wide shot depicts the scene of an abandoned hazardous waste treatment plant, imbued with a Tim Burton-esque eerie aesthetic. The rough, oil- and rust-stained concrete floor slowly and relentlessly cracks, a spiderweb of cracks spreading from the center of the frame. From deep within the crevices, a sickly, pulsing, eerie green light seeps upward. This ominous glow illuminates the jagged edges of the cracks and casts long, eerie, dancing shadows across the corroded, twisted metal scaffolding and the massive, grotesquely shaped storage tanks in the background. As the ground continues to shake, the unstable frame violently pitches up and down, simulating a dizzying sense of chaos, with tiny concrete fragments bouncing and falling in the tremors. The scene is shrouded in a bleak, industrial gray and rust palette, with the otherworldly green glow serving as the sole bright spot, creating a tense, surreal atmosphere of pre-apocalyptic terror.", + "seed": 8560, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_12/index_1122_seed_8560_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.11492385792080313, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11492385792080313, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11492385792080313, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an abandoned hazardous waste treatment plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of rough, oil- and rust-stained concrete that is cracking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sickly, pulsing, eerie green light seeping upward from the cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are corroded, twisted metal scaffolding and massive storage tanks visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shaking with a pitch up and down motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08057232946157455 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.7055723667144775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08057232946157455, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08057232946157455, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.471540242433548, + 0.07384877651929855, + 0.039781179279088974, + 0.09509073197841644, + 0.031904708594083786, + 0.053255341947078705, + 0.03759906440973282, + 0.04151526838541031, + 0.058497291058301926, + 0.0969674214720726 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08057232946157455 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an abandoned hazardous waste treatment plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of rough, oil- and rust-stained concrete that is cracking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sickly, pulsing, eerie green light seeping upward from the cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are corroded, twisted metal scaffolding and massive storage tanks visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shaking with a pitch up and down motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014234554022550583 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26423454284668 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014234554022550583, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014234554022550583, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4460664689540863, + 0.13675980269908905, + 0.03195549547672272, + 0.07779497653245926, + 0.05307166278362274, + 0.06718919426202774, + 0.03540636599063873, + 0.05052619054913521, + 0.027044588699936867, + 0.07418525964021683 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014234554022550583 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an abandoned hazardous waste treatment plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of rough, oil- and rust-stained concrete that is cracking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sickly, pulsing, eerie green light seeping upward from the cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are corroded, twisted metal scaffolding and massive storage tanks visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shaking with a pitch up and down motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036178866866976023 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628617763519287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036178866866976023, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036178866866976023, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3962089717388153, + 0.060972798615694046, + 0.07884228974580765, + 0.10002529621124268, + 0.13043969869613647, + 0.06306615471839905, + 0.03967907279729843, + 0.048263080418109894, + 0.03039163164794445, + 0.05211098864674568 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036178866866976023 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an abandoned hazardous waste treatment plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of rough, oil- and rust-stained concrete that is cracking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sickly, pulsing, eerie green light seeping upward from the cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are corroded, twisted metal scaffolding and massive storage tanks visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shaking with a pitch up and down motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001943010720424354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251943111419678 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001943010720424354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001943010720424354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29123491048812866, + 0.10137316584587097, + 0.02477334998548031, + 0.05086140334606171, + 0.06381839513778687, + 0.03976592794060707, + 0.10266788303852081, + 0.05492022633552551, + 0.047619253396987915, + 0.22296549379825592 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001943010720424354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an abandoned hazardous waste treatment plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of rough, oil- and rust-stained concrete that is cracking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sickly, pulsing, eerie green light seeping upward from the cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are corroded, twisted metal scaffolding and massive storage tanks visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shaking with a pitch up and down motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47425150871276855 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742515087127686 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47425150871276855, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47425150871276855, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.63142991065979, + 0.027227409183979034, + 0.030693305656313896, + 0.06173564866185188, + 0.06805445998907089, + 0.021096935495734215, + 0.03470848873257637, + 0.046245358884334564, + 0.01448783092200756, + 0.06432068347930908 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47425150871276855 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "violently shaky, low-angle wide shot depicts the scene of an abandoned hazardous waste treatment plant, imbued with a Tim Burton-esque eerie aesthetic. The rough, oil- and rust-stained concrete floor slowly and relentlessly cracks, a spiderweb of cracks spreading from the center of the frame. From deep within the crevices, a sickly, pulsing, eerie green light seeps upward. This ominous glow illuminates the jagged edges of the cracks and casts long, eerie, dancing shadows across the corroded, twisted metal scaffolding and the massive, grotesquely shaped storage tanks in the background. As the ground continues to shake, the unstable frame violently pitches up and down, simulating a dizzying sense of chaos, with tiny concrete fragments bouncing and falling in the tremors. The scene is shrouded in a bleak, industrial gray and rust palette, with the otherworldly green glow serving as the sole bright spot, creating a tense, surreal atmosphere of pre-apocalyptic terror.", + "seed": 8561, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_12/index_1122_seed_8561_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1344995484687388, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1344995484687388, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1344995484687388, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an abandoned hazardous waste treatment plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of rough, oil- and rust-stained concrete that is cracking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sickly, pulsing, eerie green light seeping upward from the cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are corroded, twisted metal scaffolding and massive storage tanks visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shaking with a pitch up and down motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0805613324046135 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.705561399459839 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0805613324046135, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0805613324046135, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21042099595069885, + 0.05175374448299408, + 0.0882662758231163, + 0.11832291632890701, + 0.06754930317401886, + 0.11332949250936508, + 0.06338953971862793, + 0.09287531673908234, + 0.04209132492542267, + 0.1520010381937027 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0805613324046135 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an abandoned hazardous waste treatment plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of rough, oil- and rust-stained concrete that is cracking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sickly, pulsing, eerie green light seeping upward from the cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are corroded, twisted metal scaffolding and massive storage tanks visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shaking with a pitch up and down motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002849211450666189 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877849102020264 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002849211450666189, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002849211450666189, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25789812207221985, + 0.08523225784301758, + 0.12835073471069336, + 0.11023754626512527, + 0.05732831358909607, + 0.06160470098257065, + 0.04526655748486519, + 0.08068961650133133, + 0.07480504363775253, + 0.0985870435833931 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002849211450666189 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an abandoned hazardous waste treatment plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of rough, oil- and rust-stained concrete that is cracking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sickly, pulsing, eerie green light seeping upward from the cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are corroded, twisted metal scaffolding and massive storage tanks visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shaking with a pitch up and down motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009781171567738056 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634781360626221 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009781171567738056, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009781171567738056, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42417606711387634, + 0.04777136445045471, + 0.12382188439369202, + 0.051372937858104706, + 0.06679992377758026, + 0.027154887095093727, + 0.02596176415681839, + 0.04477827250957489, + 0.028409166261553764, + 0.1597536951303482 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009781171567738056 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an abandoned hazardous waste treatment plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of rough, oil- and rust-stained concrete that is cracking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sickly, pulsing, eerie green light seeping upward from the cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are corroded, twisted metal scaffolding and massive storage tanks visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shaking with a pitch up and down motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003193756565451622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531938552856445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003193756565451622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003193756565451622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4555092751979828, + 0.03679335489869118, + 0.0962454229593277, + 0.05787643790245056, + 0.03836798667907715, + 0.10440848022699356, + 0.02743425779044628, + 0.07056830078363419, + 0.02622324414551258, + 0.08657326549291611 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003193756565451622 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an abandoned hazardous waste treatment plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of rough, oil- and rust-stained concrete that is cracking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sickly, pulsing, eerie green light seeping upward from the cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are corroded, twisted metal scaffolding and massive storage tanks visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shaking with a pitch up and down motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761122703552246 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261122703552246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761122703552246, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761122703552246, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3543466031551361, + 0.06012311950325966, + 0.17506328225135803, + 0.0368630513548851, + 0.07706096768379211, + 0.052874449640512466, + 0.09046806395053864, + 0.06596994400024414, + 0.03531745821237564, + 0.05191300809383392 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761122703552246 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "violently shaky, low-angle wide shot depicts the scene of an abandoned hazardous waste treatment plant, imbued with a Tim Burton-esque eerie aesthetic. The rough, oil- and rust-stained concrete floor slowly and relentlessly cracks, a spiderweb of cracks spreading from the center of the frame. From deep within the crevices, a sickly, pulsing, eerie green light seeps upward. This ominous glow illuminates the jagged edges of the cracks and casts long, eerie, dancing shadows across the corroded, twisted metal scaffolding and the massive, grotesquely shaped storage tanks in the background. As the ground continues to shake, the unstable frame violently pitches up and down, simulating a dizzying sense of chaos, with tiny concrete fragments bouncing and falling in the tremors. The scene is shrouded in a bleak, industrial gray and rust palette, with the otherworldly green glow serving as the sole bright spot, creating a tense, surreal atmosphere of pre-apocalyptic terror.", + "seed": 8562, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_12/index_1122_seed_8562_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10760559970512987, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10760559970512987, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10760559970512987, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an abandoned hazardous waste treatment plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of rough, oil- and rust-stained concrete that is cracking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sickly, pulsing, eerie green light seeping upward from the cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are corroded, twisted metal scaffolding and massive storage tanks visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shaking with a pitch up and down motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3170871436595917 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.317087173461914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3170871436595917, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3170871436595917, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12194789946079254, + 0.05534246936440468, + 0.038769565522670746, + 0.03418314456939697, + 0.0343647375702858, + 0.05866090953350067, + 0.021576421335339546, + 0.04257707670331001, + 0.06721872091293335, + 0.5253590941429138 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3170871436595917 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an abandoned hazardous waste treatment plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of rough, oil- and rust-stained concrete that is cracking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sickly, pulsing, eerie green light seeping upward from the cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are corroded, twisted metal scaffolding and massive storage tanks visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shaking with a pitch up and down motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007664321456104517 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882664203643799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007664321456104517, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007664321456104517, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06823992729187012, + 0.1098531186580658, + 0.13317319750785828, + 0.06895556300878525, + 0.07187575101852417, + 0.11441264301538467, + 0.026453698053956032, + 0.06128847226500511, + 0.021903157234191895, + 0.32384446263313293 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007664321456104517 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an abandoned hazardous waste treatment plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of rough, oil- and rust-stained concrete that is cracking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sickly, pulsing, eerie green light seeping upward from the cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are corroded, twisted metal scaffolding and massive storage tanks visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shaking with a pitch up and down motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004098706413060427 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504098892211914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004098706413060427, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004098706413060427, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09964191913604736, + 0.08857686817646027, + 0.05901776999235153, + 0.02802257053554058, + 0.03857845440506935, + 0.07593251019716263, + 0.03739544376730919, + 0.08498392254114151, + 0.11725343763828278, + 0.3705971837043762 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004098706413060427 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an abandoned hazardous waste treatment plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of rough, oil- and rust-stained concrete that is cracking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sickly, pulsing, eerie green light seeping upward from the cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are corroded, twisted metal scaffolding and massive storage tanks visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shaking with a pitch up and down motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007630487438291311 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882630348205566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007630487438291311, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007630487438291311, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06321985274553299, + 0.15021760761737823, + 0.09275837242603302, + 0.04908835515379906, + 0.11444457620382309, + 0.14491845667362213, + 0.046592243015766144, + 0.06934329122304916, + 0.024487297981977463, + 0.2449299544095993 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007630487438291311 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an abandoned hazardous waste treatment plant?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the floor made of rough, oil- and rust-stained concrete that is cracking?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a sickly, pulsing, eerie green light seeping upward from the cracks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are corroded, twisted metal scaffolding and massive storage tanks visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit violent shaking with a pitch up and down motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20154733955860138 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.701547384262085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20154733955860138, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20154733955860138, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06090189144015312, + 0.053290124982595444, + 0.055024292320013046, + 0.08052385598421097, + 0.03785986825823784, + 0.4501250386238098, + 0.04137875512242317, + 0.03014814294874668, + 0.018864955753087997, + 0.17188312113285065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20154733955860138 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_13/index_tensor([1230, 1230])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_13/index_tensor([1230, 1230])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2c6d68bf96d4c5116923da5ce474971f3c65bb12 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_13/index_tensor([1230, 1230])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera slowly pans forward, locking the viewer's gaze on a dimly lit room, late at night, where a young man sits at his laptop. The dense, relentlessly scrolling code on the screen casts a cold, bluish-white glow, the sole source of light mercilessly carving the contours of his pained face, highlighting his furrowed brow, his bloodshot eyes from extreme fatigue, and the greasy sheen that coats his face. His fingers dig deep into his tousled dark brown hair, grasping his scalp, his elbows weakly resting on the table. His entire posture conveys a sense of silent despair and despair. He wears a slightly worn, dark gray cotton hooded sweatshirt. The background is almost completely engulfed in darkness, with only the faint outlines of books and an empty coffee cup hinting at a space permanently occupied by work. The dominant tones of the image are icy blue and deep black, creating a stark contrast between light and shadow, creating a suffocating atmosphere of frustration, technological anxiety, and late-night loneliness.", + "seed": 23776, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_13/index_1230_seed_23776_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.19671622556634247, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19671622556634247, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19671622556634247, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young man sitting at a laptop with dense scrolling code visible on the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by a cold, bluish-white glow from the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a slightly worn, dark gray cotton hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0854068323969841 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.58540678024292 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0854068323969841, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0854068323969841, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1973666399717331, + 0.042954616248607635, + 0.018621832132339478, + 0.025046417489647865, + 0.05538294464349747, + 0.10686259716749191, + 0.4132360816001892, + 0.09977927058935165, + 0.0249671321362257, + 0.015782419592142105 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0854068323969841 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young man sitting at a laptop with dense scrolling code visible on the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by a cold, bluish-white glow from the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a slightly worn, dark gray cotton hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261282444000244 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761282444000244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8261282444000244, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8261282444000244, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0738493800163269, + 0.06437911838293076, + 0.045395396649837494, + 0.07262542098760605, + 0.05430837348103523, + 0.0399826355278492, + 0.4692830741405487, + 0.11302603036165237, + 0.04371113330125809, + 0.023439401760697365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8261282444000244 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young man sitting at a laptop with dense scrolling code visible on the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by a cold, bluish-white glow from the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a slightly worn, dark gray cotton hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058662846684456 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955867290496826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058662846684456, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058662846684456, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2344037890434265, + 0.08513797074556351, + 0.0492241270840168, + 0.06200903654098511, + 0.12375388294458389, + 0.11842526495456696, + 0.07812285423278809, + 0.10574253648519516, + 0.06892392784357071, + 0.07425664365291595 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058662846684456 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young man sitting at a laptop with dense scrolling code visible on the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by a cold, bluish-white glow from the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a slightly worn, dark gray cotton hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002820087829604745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877820014953613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002820087829604745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002820087829604745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4096924364566803, + 0.04817742481827736, + 0.027489278465509415, + 0.16051074862480164, + 0.055400408804416656, + 0.04561929777264595, + 0.05197170749306679, + 0.09486658126115799, + 0.051435235887765884, + 0.05483686923980713 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002820087829604745 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young man sitting at a laptop with dense scrolling code visible on the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by a cold, bluish-white glow from the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a slightly worn, dark gray cotton hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04863933473825455 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486392974853516 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04863933473825455, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04863933473825455, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2223512828350067, + 0.05658388510346413, + 0.034174636006355286, + 0.05820396915078163, + 0.06100531667470932, + 0.0631168782711029, + 0.1369801163673401, + 0.10754680633544922, + 0.081734299659729, + 0.17830274999141693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04863933473825455 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera slowly pans forward, locking the viewer's gaze on a dimly lit room, late at night, where a young man sits at his laptop. The dense, relentlessly scrolling code on the screen casts a cold, bluish-white glow, the sole source of light mercilessly carving the contours of his pained face, highlighting his furrowed brow, his bloodshot eyes from extreme fatigue, and the greasy sheen that coats his face. His fingers dig deep into his tousled dark brown hair, grasping his scalp, his elbows weakly resting on the table. His entire posture conveys a sense of silent despair and despair. He wears a slightly worn, dark gray cotton hooded sweatshirt. The background is almost completely engulfed in darkness, with only the faint outlines of books and an empty coffee cup hinting at a space permanently occupied by work. The dominant tones of the image are icy blue and deep black, creating a stark contrast between light and shadow, creating a suffocating atmosphere of frustration, technological anxiety, and late-night loneliness.", + "seed": 23777, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_13/index_1230_seed_23777_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07572964155115187, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07572964155115187, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.850000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07572964155115187, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young man sitting at a laptop with dense scrolling code visible on the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by a cold, bluish-white glow from the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a slightly worn, dark gray cotton hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.15171663463115692 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.026716709136963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.15171663463115692, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.15171663463115692, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13462869822978973, + 0.0660969540476799, + 0.1556997001171112, + 0.05627523362636566, + 0.04483702778816223, + 0.06684903800487518, + 0.1717941164970398, + 0.0663004145026207, + 0.14840352535247803, + 0.08911526203155518 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.15171663463115692 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young man sitting at a laptop with dense scrolling code visible on the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by a cold, bluish-white glow from the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a slightly worn, dark gray cotton hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17988228797912598 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804882287979126 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17988228797912598, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17988228797912598, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08880673348903656, + 0.09371330589056015, + 0.04064273089170456, + 0.0354192890226841, + 0.05199145898222923, + 0.05722924321889877, + 0.26471948623657227, + 0.10152266174554825, + 0.1917552798986435, + 0.07419975847005844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17988228797912598 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young man sitting at a laptop with dense scrolling code visible on the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by a cold, bluish-white glow from the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a slightly worn, dark gray cotton hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011815002653747797 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751181602478027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011815002653747797, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011815002653747797, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1563069373369217, + 0.26044920086860657, + 0.10323399305343628, + 0.06371090561151505, + 0.04588804394006729, + 0.057744741439819336, + 0.1146521344780922, + 0.0522090382874012, + 0.07898987084627151, + 0.06681513041257858 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011815002653747797 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young man sitting at a laptop with dense scrolling code visible on the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by a cold, bluish-white glow from the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a slightly worn, dark gray cotton hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002818542532622814 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877818584442139 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002818542532622814, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002818542532622814, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17730407416820526, + 0.14056767523288727, + 0.08579283207654953, + 0.04910038784146309, + 0.09735561162233353, + 0.03294483199715614, + 0.0751415342092514, + 0.03998951613903046, + 0.1644960194826126, + 0.13730746507644653 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002818542532622814 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young man sitting at a laptop with dense scrolling code visible on the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by a cold, bluish-white glow from the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a slightly worn, dark gray cotton hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04304924234747887 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680493354797363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04304924234747887, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04304924234747887, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1302441507577896, + 0.07494575530290604, + 0.07701132446527481, + 0.04726375266909599, + 0.07833512872457504, + 0.049440689384937286, + 0.10765953361988068, + 0.04413652420043945, + 0.2670602798461914, + 0.12390287220478058 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04304924234747887 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera slowly pans forward, locking the viewer's gaze on a dimly lit room, late at night, where a young man sits at his laptop. The dense, relentlessly scrolling code on the screen casts a cold, bluish-white glow, the sole source of light mercilessly carving the contours of his pained face, highlighting his furrowed brow, his bloodshot eyes from extreme fatigue, and the greasy sheen that coats his face. His fingers dig deep into his tousled dark brown hair, grasping his scalp, his elbows weakly resting on the table. His entire posture conveys a sense of silent despair and despair. He wears a slightly worn, dark gray cotton hooded sweatshirt. The background is almost completely engulfed in darkness, with only the faint outlines of books and an empty coffee cup hinting at a space permanently occupied by work. The dominant tones of the image are icy blue and deep black, creating a stark contrast between light and shadow, creating a suffocating atmosphere of frustration, technological anxiety, and late-night loneliness.", + "seed": 23778, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_13/index_1230_seed_23778_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1081800602376461, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1081800602376461, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.799999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1081800602376461, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young man sitting at a laptop with dense scrolling code visible on the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by a cold, bluish-white glow from the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a slightly worn, dark gray cotton hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.13732178509235382 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.137321710586548 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.13732178509235382, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.13732178509235382, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19763906300067902, + 0.12219805270433426, + 0.06316599994897842, + 0.06501784175634384, + 0.04317023977637291, + 0.0576685331761837, + 0.09035192430019379, + 0.07513606548309326, + 0.13037227094173431, + 0.15528002381324768 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.13732178509235382 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young man sitting at a laptop with dense scrolling code visible on the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by a cold, bluish-white glow from the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a slightly worn, dark gray cotton hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813345789909363 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.406334638595581 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813345789909363, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813345789909363, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16190975904464722, + 0.11545658111572266, + 0.05464528128504753, + 0.045848388224840164, + 0.06269637495279312, + 0.047383058816194534, + 0.08942548930644989, + 0.10197842121124268, + 0.17446225881576538, + 0.14619441330432892 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813345789909363 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young man sitting at a laptop with dense scrolling code visible on the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by a cold, bluish-white glow from the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a slightly worn, dark gray cotton hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062046606093645096 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812046527862549 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062046606093645096, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062046606093645096, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20820613205432892, + 0.09067793190479279, + 0.10303322970867157, + 0.08410422503948212, + 0.060759276151657104, + 0.18726414442062378, + 0.040005169808864594, + 0.04418494179844856, + 0.09096425026655197, + 0.09080071747303009 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062046606093645096 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young man sitting at a laptop with dense scrolling code visible on the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by a cold, bluish-white glow from the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a slightly worn, dark gray cotton hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005252964794635773 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255252838134766 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005252964794635773, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005252964794635773, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14741839468479156, + 0.057398345321416855, + 0.11363588273525238, + 0.06361059099435806, + 0.047739796340465546, + 0.06088654696941376, + 0.10180418938398361, + 0.2199665904045105, + 0.06815014034509659, + 0.11938945204019547 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005252964794635773 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young man sitting at a laptop with dense scrolling code visible on the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by a cold, bluish-white glow from the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a slightly worn, dark gray cotton hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054944366216659546 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299442768096924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054944366216659546, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054944366216659546, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3563491702079773, + 0.10356292873620987, + 0.053005609661340714, + 0.044081542640924454, + 0.04529296234250069, + 0.04305223375558853, + 0.07225193828344345, + 0.037653956562280655, + 0.10841193050146103, + 0.1363377720117569 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054944366216659546 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera slowly pans forward, locking the viewer's gaze on a dimly lit room, late at night, where a young man sits at his laptop. The dense, relentlessly scrolling code on the screen casts a cold, bluish-white glow, the sole source of light mercilessly carving the contours of his pained face, highlighting his furrowed brow, his bloodshot eyes from extreme fatigue, and the greasy sheen that coats his face. His fingers dig deep into his tousled dark brown hair, grasping his scalp, his elbows weakly resting on the table. His entire posture conveys a sense of silent despair and despair. He wears a slightly worn, dark gray cotton hooded sweatshirt. The background is almost completely engulfed in darkness, with only the faint outlines of books and an empty coffee cup hinting at a space permanently occupied by work. The dominant tones of the image are icy blue and deep black, creating a stark contrast between light and shadow, creating a suffocating atmosphere of frustration, technological anxiety, and late-night loneliness.", + "seed": 23779, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_13/index_1230_seed_23779_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07164069411810488, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07164069411810488, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07164069411810488, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young man sitting at a laptop with dense scrolling code visible on the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by a cold, bluish-white glow from the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a slightly worn, dark gray cotton hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05268238112330437 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.177682399749756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05268238112330437, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05268238112330437, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14152589440345764, + 0.06199317425489426, + 0.0523284450173378, + 0.13253897428512573, + 0.07492725551128387, + 0.04997861385345459, + 0.08948099613189697, + 0.10713043808937073, + 0.24183440208435059, + 0.0482618622481823 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05268238112330437 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young man sitting at a laptop with dense scrolling code visible on the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by a cold, bluish-white glow from the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a slightly worn, dark gray cotton hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22557379305362701 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005737781524658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22557379305362701, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22557379305362701, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08505405485630035, + 0.08067365735769272, + 0.10755127668380737, + 0.15432097017765045, + 0.11617904156446457, + 0.05170859023928642, + 0.16614297032356262, + 0.11741844564676285, + 0.07613169401884079, + 0.044819269329309464 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22557379305362701 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young man sitting at a laptop with dense scrolling code visible on the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by a cold, bluish-white glow from the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a slightly worn, dark gray cotton hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029794272035360336 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529794216156006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029794272035360336, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029794272035360336, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.39437076449394226, + 0.16084802150726318, + 0.12148530036211014, + 0.051898837089538574, + 0.10691007226705551, + 0.034098830074071884, + 0.020496683195233345, + 0.05021984130144119, + 0.03421235829591751, + 0.025459323078393936 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029794272035360336 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young man sitting at a laptop with dense scrolling code visible on the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by a cold, bluish-white glow from the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a slightly worn, dark gray cotton hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015120989410206676 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501512050628662 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015120989410206676, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015120989410206676, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16158972680568695, + 0.12475281208753586, + 0.23395957052707672, + 0.10090749710798264, + 0.05760987475514412, + 0.04666360095143318, + 0.04838014021515846, + 0.05810564011335373, + 0.04751516878604889, + 0.12051596492528915 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015120989410206676 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pan forward throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a young man sitting at a laptop with dense scrolling code visible on the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit primarily by a cold, bluish-white glow from the screen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a slightly worn, dark gray cotton hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864092543721199 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486409664154053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864092543721199, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864092543721199, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16616041958332062, + 0.06988801807165146, + 0.1819399744272232, + 0.08947644382715225, + 0.06862273812294006, + 0.11951518058776855, + 0.07493707537651062, + 0.08438316732645035, + 0.08026578277349472, + 0.06481108069419861 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864092543721199 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_14/index_tensor([4423, 4423])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_14/index_tensor([4423, 4423])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2b3478f1fe03596c148bafcfa021d492f0c26d5a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_14/index_tensor([4423, 4423])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "strikingly artistic close-up, captured from a steady, horizontal angle, captures the dynamic moment of two kittens fiercely fighting over a feather toy. A unique visual style dominates the image, transforming their fur and movements into intense, swirling Van Gogh-esque brushstrokes. Each hair resembles a thick, impastoed brushstroke, creating a dynamic vortex of flaming orange, creamy white, and deep black. One kitten, its body tense, its paws firmly grasping the ground, pulls back with all its might at the feather toy it holds in its jaws. The other leans forward, front paws extended, attempting to wrest the prize from its rival's grasp. Their eyes flicker with concentration and a touch of feral ferocity as they clash. The extremely shallow depth of field allows the background behind them to melt into a vibrant, blurred storm of color. Abstract swathes of warm yellow, aquamarine, and emerald green intertwine to form a dreamlike backdrop composed purely of light and color. A bright side light illuminates this little fight, making the \"oil painting\"-like texture on the cats more three-dimensional. Light and shadow flow on their constantly twisting bodies, freezing this energetic and vital play into a passionate and dynamic, living Impressionist painting.", + "seed": 28520, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_14/index_4423_seed_28520_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07878973060287535, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07878973060287535, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07878973060287535, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two kittens visible in the scene fighting over a feather toy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque brushstrokes with an impasto texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the kittens' fur and the scene contain swirling colors of flaming orange, creamy white, and deep black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred, abstract mix of warm yellow, aquamarine, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a steady, horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25407806038856506 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5040780305862427 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25407806038856506, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25407806038856506, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10211525112390518, + 0.05284324660897255, + 0.09544801712036133, + 0.027183061465620995, + 0.129451721906662, + 0.039816733449697495, + 0.05876275897026062, + 0.088621124625206, + 0.045674219727516174, + 0.36008384823799133 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25407806038856506 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two kittens visible in the scene fighting over a feather toy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque brushstrokes with an impasto texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the kittens' fur and the scene contain swirling colors of flaming orange, creamy white, and deep black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred, abstract mix of warm yellow, aquamarine, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a steady, horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018204746767878532 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018204689025879 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018204746767878532, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018204746767878532, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07629280537366867, + 0.2388540357351303, + 0.09263890981674194, + 0.025446370244026184, + 0.07346907258033752, + 0.09656590223312378, + 0.06818021833896637, + 0.03398101031780243, + 0.05454935133457184, + 0.24002228677272797 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018204746767878532 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two kittens visible in the scene fighting over a feather toy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque brushstrokes with an impasto texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the kittens' fur and the scene contain swirling colors of flaming orange, creamy white, and deep black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred, abstract mix of warm yellow, aquamarine, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a steady, horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10029608756303787 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3502960205078125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10029608756303787, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10029608756303787, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12161105126142502, + 0.08174391090869904, + 0.27272024750709534, + 0.04360827058553696, + 0.06857544183731079, + 0.14727933704853058, + 0.045573845505714417, + 0.042126260697841644, + 0.06394986063241959, + 0.11281181126832962 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10029608756303787 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two kittens visible in the scene fighting over a feather toy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque brushstrokes with an impasto texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the kittens' fur and the scene contain swirling colors of flaming orange, creamy white, and deep black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred, abstract mix of warm yellow, aquamarine, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a steady, horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003189360024407506 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753189563751221 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003189360024407506, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003189360024407506, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17760467529296875, + 0.11461435258388519, + 0.10383523255586624, + 0.04232556000351906, + 0.13281503319740295, + 0.09758735448122025, + 0.05651585012674332, + 0.06878268718719482, + 0.1290341317653656, + 0.0768851563334465 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003189360024407506 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two kittens visible in the scene fighting over a feather toy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque brushstrokes with an impasto texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the kittens' fur and the scene contain swirling colors of flaming orange, creamy white, and deep black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred, abstract mix of warm yellow, aquamarine, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a steady, horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018180398270487785 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0181803703308105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018180398270487785, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018180398270487785, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06711450964212418, + 0.039675187319517136, + 0.10384833812713623, + 0.046324558556079865, + 0.2384706288576126, + 0.22697989642620087, + 0.03868676722049713, + 0.048307858407497406, + 0.04602872580289841, + 0.14456352591514587 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018180398270487785 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "strikingly artistic close-up, captured from a steady, horizontal angle, captures the dynamic moment of two kittens fiercely fighting over a feather toy. A unique visual style dominates the image, transforming their fur and movements into intense, swirling Van Gogh-esque brushstrokes. Each hair resembles a thick, impastoed brushstroke, creating a dynamic vortex of flaming orange, creamy white, and deep black. One kitten, its body tense, its paws firmly grasping the ground, pulls back with all its might at the feather toy it holds in its jaws. The other leans forward, front paws extended, attempting to wrest the prize from its rival's grasp. Their eyes flicker with concentration and a touch of feral ferocity as they clash. The extremely shallow depth of field allows the background behind them to melt into a vibrant, blurred storm of color. Abstract swathes of warm yellow, aquamarine, and emerald green intertwine to form a dreamlike backdrop composed purely of light and color. A bright side light illuminates this little fight, making the \"oil painting\"-like texture on the cats more three-dimensional. Light and shadow flow on their constantly twisting bodies, freezing this energetic and vital play into a passionate and dynamic, living Impressionist painting.", + "seed": 28521, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_14/index_4423_seed_28521_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.1333289460046217, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1333289460046217, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1333289460046217, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two kittens visible in the scene fighting over a feather toy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque brushstrokes with an impasto texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the kittens' fur and the scene contain swirling colors of flaming orange, creamy white, and deep black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred, abstract mix of warm yellow, aquamarine, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a steady, horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6340547800064087 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7590547800064087 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6340547800064087, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6340547800064087, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23207464814186096, + 0.03559626266360283, + 0.02725849114358425, + 0.07202509045600891, + 0.2729171812534332, + 0.05968252941966057, + 0.04639875888824463, + 0.151937797665596, + 0.03386448323726654, + 0.06824478507041931 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6340547800064087 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two kittens visible in the scene fighting over a feather toy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque brushstrokes with an impasto texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the kittens' fur and the scene contain swirling colors of flaming orange, creamy white, and deep black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred, abstract mix of warm yellow, aquamarine, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a steady, horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007644565310329199 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826446533203125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007644565310329199, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007644565310329199, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22308968007564545, + 0.17577211558818817, + 0.05000541731715202, + 0.09421221911907196, + 0.0959806889295578, + 0.0385795496404171, + 0.06710359454154968, + 0.13272258639335632, + 0.055507563054561615, + 0.06702661514282227 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007644565310329199 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two kittens visible in the scene fighting over a feather toy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque brushstrokes with an impasto texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the kittens' fur and the scene contain swirling colors of flaming orange, creamy white, and deep black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred, abstract mix of warm yellow, aquamarine, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a steady, horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012542416341602802 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387542247772217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012542416341602802, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012542416341602802, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16522866487503052, + 0.19642393290996552, + 0.052886705845594406, + 0.0962822362780571, + 0.0926104187965393, + 0.0495871938765049, + 0.11687643080949783, + 0.1254708468914032, + 0.052273742854595184, + 0.05235987901687622 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012542416341602802 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two kittens visible in the scene fighting over a feather toy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque brushstrokes with an impasto texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the kittens' fur and the scene contain swirling colors of flaming orange, creamy white, and deep black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred, abstract mix of warm yellow, aquamarine, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a steady, horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013328249333426356 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626332759857178 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013328249333426356, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013328249333426356, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1989719569683075, + 0.09483915567398071, + 0.06248605623841286, + 0.03728427365422249, + 0.21112295985221863, + 0.06613114476203918, + 0.044605955481529236, + 0.16565799713134766, + 0.06844465434551239, + 0.050455838441848755 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013328249333426356 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two kittens visible in the scene fighting over a feather toy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque brushstrokes with an impasto texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the kittens' fur and the scene contain swirling colors of flaming orange, creamy white, and deep black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred, abstract mix of warm yellow, aquamarine, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a steady, horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011070143431425095 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511070251464844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011070143431425095, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011070143431425095, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15255104005336761, + 0.052550241351127625, + 0.07845067977905273, + 0.049352023750543594, + 0.1783001720905304, + 0.0490611232817173, + 0.06439991295337677, + 0.09324604272842407, + 0.17717619240283966, + 0.10491260141134262 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011070143431425095 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "strikingly artistic close-up, captured from a steady, horizontal angle, captures the dynamic moment of two kittens fiercely fighting over a feather toy. A unique visual style dominates the image, transforming their fur and movements into intense, swirling Van Gogh-esque brushstrokes. Each hair resembles a thick, impastoed brushstroke, creating a dynamic vortex of flaming orange, creamy white, and deep black. One kitten, its body tense, its paws firmly grasping the ground, pulls back with all its might at the feather toy it holds in its jaws. The other leans forward, front paws extended, attempting to wrest the prize from its rival's grasp. Their eyes flicker with concentration and a touch of feral ferocity as they clash. The extremely shallow depth of field allows the background behind them to melt into a vibrant, blurred storm of color. Abstract swathes of warm yellow, aquamarine, and emerald green intertwine to form a dreamlike backdrop composed purely of light and color. A bright side light illuminates this little fight, making the \"oil painting\"-like texture on the cats more three-dimensional. Light and shadow flow on their constantly twisting bodies, freezing this energetic and vital play into a passionate and dynamic, living Impressionist painting.", + "seed": 28522, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_14/index_4423_seed_28522_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.08454018668271601, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08454018668271601, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08454018668271601, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two kittens visible in the scene fighting over a feather toy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque brushstrokes with an impasto texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the kittens' fur and the scene contain swirling colors of flaming orange, creamy white, and deep black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred, abstract mix of warm yellow, aquamarine, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a steady, horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38941749930381775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1394175291061401 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38941749930381775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38941749930381775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07408282905817032, + 0.2713123857975006, + 0.023621108382940292, + 0.08608797192573547, + 0.08721356093883514, + 0.07191473245620728, + 0.05604030564427376, + 0.09979990124702454, + 0.14585711061954498, + 0.0840701088309288 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38941749930381775 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two kittens visible in the scene fighting over a feather toy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque brushstrokes with an impasto texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the kittens' fur and the scene contain swirling colors of flaming orange, creamy white, and deep black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred, abstract mix of warm yellow, aquamarine, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a steady, horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007653083186596632 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88265323638916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007653083186596632, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007653083186596632, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08296641707420349, + 0.27815350890159607, + 0.03585484251379967, + 0.03782614693045616, + 0.3396718204021454, + 0.0433550588786602, + 0.03617631271481514, + 0.05095422640442848, + 0.03777746483683586, + 0.057264216244220734 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007653083186596632 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two kittens visible in the scene fighting over a feather toy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque brushstrokes with an impasto texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the kittens' fur and the scene contain swirling colors of flaming orange, creamy white, and deep black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred, abstract mix of warm yellow, aquamarine, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a steady, horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0052567594684660435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255256652832031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0052567594684660435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0052567594684660435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1601603627204895, + 0.4072006046772003, + 0.03922703117132187, + 0.05525583401322365, + 0.07186708599328995, + 0.04951925203204155, + 0.03293883800506592, + 0.1066109910607338, + 0.022893406450748444, + 0.054326582700014114 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0052567594684660435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two kittens visible in the scene fighting over a feather toy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque brushstrokes with an impasto texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the kittens' fur and the scene contain swirling colors of flaming orange, creamy white, and deep black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred, abstract mix of warm yellow, aquamarine, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a steady, horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021934278775006533 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127193450927734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021934278775006533, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021934278775006533, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12404348701238632, + 0.3704802393913269, + 0.05276653170585632, + 0.06213103607296944, + 0.09259194880723953, + 0.06660182029008865, + 0.09545157104730606, + 0.02796301059424877, + 0.05794423446059227, + 0.05002610385417938 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021934278775006533 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two kittens visible in the scene fighting over a feather toy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque brushstrokes with an impasto texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the kittens' fur and the scene contain swirling colors of flaming orange, creamy white, and deep black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred, abstract mix of warm yellow, aquamarine, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a steady, horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018180163577198982 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0181803703308105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018180163577198982, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018180163577198982, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13163655996322632, + 0.3023281693458557, + 0.05200473964214325, + 0.04345197603106499, + 0.1005699411034584, + 0.06425397098064423, + 0.07945255935192108, + 0.07316679507493973, + 0.06275369226932526, + 0.09038165211677551 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018180163577198982 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "strikingly artistic close-up, captured from a steady, horizontal angle, captures the dynamic moment of two kittens fiercely fighting over a feather toy. A unique visual style dominates the image, transforming their fur and movements into intense, swirling Van Gogh-esque brushstrokes. Each hair resembles a thick, impastoed brushstroke, creating a dynamic vortex of flaming orange, creamy white, and deep black. One kitten, its body tense, its paws firmly grasping the ground, pulls back with all its might at the feather toy it holds in its jaws. The other leans forward, front paws extended, attempting to wrest the prize from its rival's grasp. Their eyes flicker with concentration and a touch of feral ferocity as they clash. The extremely shallow depth of field allows the background behind them to melt into a vibrant, blurred storm of color. Abstract swathes of warm yellow, aquamarine, and emerald green intertwine to form a dreamlike backdrop composed purely of light and color. A bright side light illuminates this little fight, making the \"oil painting\"-like texture on the cats more three-dimensional. Light and shadow flow on their constantly twisting bodies, freezing this energetic and vital play into a passionate and dynamic, living Impressionist painting.", + "seed": 28523, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_14/index_4423_seed_28523_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1680954040493816, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1680954040493816, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1680954040493816, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two kittens visible in the scene fighting over a feather toy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque brushstrokes with an impasto texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the kittens' fur and the scene contain swirling colors of flaming orange, creamy white, and deep black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred, abstract mix of warm yellow, aquamarine, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a steady, horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6945582032203674 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6945582032203674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6945582032203674, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6945582032203674, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14305131137371063, + 0.03832618147134781, + 0.018663212656974792, + 0.11738239973783493, + 0.04158987104892731, + 0.26076647639274597, + 0.09937988966703415, + 0.05617765709757805, + 0.0870116576552391, + 0.13765136897563934 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6945582032203674 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two kittens visible in the scene fighting over a feather toy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque brushstrokes with an impasto texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the kittens' fur and the scene contain swirling colors of flaming orange, creamy white, and deep black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred, abstract mix of warm yellow, aquamarine, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a steady, horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016090890392661095 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410908699035645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016090890392661095, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016090890392661095, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09262910485267639, + 0.1416221559047699, + 0.16971814632415771, + 0.0681249275803566, + 0.06847124546766281, + 0.1962965428829193, + 0.07537416368722916, + 0.11184879392385483, + 0.04076381027698517, + 0.035151101648807526 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016090890392661095 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two kittens visible in the scene fighting over a feather toy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque brushstrokes with an impasto texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the kittens' fur and the scene contain swirling colors of flaming orange, creamy white, and deep black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred, abstract mix of warm yellow, aquamarine, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a steady, horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898349314928055 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789835453033447 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898349314928055, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898349314928055, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2687421441078186, + 0.04924623295664787, + 0.047613319009542465, + 0.06445299088954926, + 0.1003456637263298, + 0.12864316999912262, + 0.07332833111286163, + 0.06800293922424316, + 0.05784082040190697, + 0.1417844295501709 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898349314928055 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two kittens visible in the scene fighting over a feather toy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque brushstrokes with an impasto texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the kittens' fur and the scene contain swirling colors of flaming orange, creamy white, and deep black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred, abstract mix of warm yellow, aquamarine, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a steady, horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00219533103518188 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127195358276367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00219533103518188, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00219533103518188, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24181783199310303, + 0.05517726391553879, + 0.20626692473888397, + 0.03427307307720184, + 0.04213913530111313, + 0.1930258870124817, + 0.06601608544588089, + 0.019160356372594833, + 0.030498867854475975, + 0.11162455379962921 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00219533103518188 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two kittens visible in the scene fighting over a feather toy?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque brushstrokes with an impasto texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the kittens' fur and the scene contain swirling colors of flaming orange, creamy white, and deep black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a blurred, abstract mix of warm yellow, aquamarine, and emerald green?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up captured from a steady, horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048649102449417114 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486490726470947 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048649102449417114, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048649102449417114, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06523369252681732, + 0.057765744626522064, + 0.4089934825897217, + 0.07762625068426132, + 0.0712880864739418, + 0.04898946359753609, + 0.08560390770435333, + 0.04565292224287987, + 0.09298275411128998, + 0.045863665640354156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048649102449417114 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_15/index_tensor([6193, 6193])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_15/index_tensor([6193, 6193])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3bda9304b8d29975c0c5958fd4650fbe74b36d4f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_15/index_tensor([6193, 6193])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "long, fixed shot captures a slender, human-like figure standing quietly before a massive, weathered, gray rock face covered in deep cracks and mottled with moss. Under the soft, evenly diffused light of an overcast day, his body is covered in dense, interwoven dark green scales, reflecting a dark, moist, snake-like sheen. His figure stands tall, his features blurred in the distance, and a light mist hangs in the air around him. As he slowly and calmly raised one arm, as if receiving a silent command, countless thick dark green vines on the ground instantly broke out of the ground, growing and extending wildly at a speed visible to the naked eye like a group of frightened snakes. The tips of these vines were like conscious tentacles, searching for grip points on the rock surface, and then tightly wrapped around the protrusions of the rock, firmly clinging to and quickly covering the entire vertical cliff. The whole picture was presented from a calm and objective perspective, without dramatic emotional rendering, as if recording a strange and spectacular natural phenomenon, full of the texture and mystery of a natural documentary.", + "seed": 13617, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_15/index_6193_seed_13617_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1519939389079809, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1519939389079809, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1519939389079809, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, human-like figure covered in dense, interwoven dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a massive, weathered, gray rock face covered in deep cracks and mottled with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless thick dark green vines instantly break out of the ground and rapidly grow to cover the rock face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and evenly diffused, consistent with an overcast day?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long, fixed shot presented from a calm and objective perspective without camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06394685804843903 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8139469623565674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06394685804843903, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06394685804843903, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09666053205728531, + 0.04320171847939491, + 0.3065193295478821, + 0.21403393149375916, + 0.04718650504946709, + 0.05056176707148552, + 0.08449789881706238, + 0.040021561086177826, + 0.02758430503308773, + 0.08973241597414017 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06394685804843903 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, human-like figure covered in dense, interwoven dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a massive, weathered, gray rock face covered in deep cracks and mottled with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless thick dark green vines instantly break out of the ground and rapidly grow to cover the rock face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and evenly diffused, consistent with an overcast day?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long, fixed shot presented from a calm and objective perspective without camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018202288076281548 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018202304840088 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018202288076281548, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018202288076281548, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21396701037883759, + 0.0629391148686409, + 0.03422347456216812, + 0.18347974121570587, + 0.11026562005281448, + 0.10438182950019836, + 0.1269029974937439, + 0.04499537870287895, + 0.03642619401216507, + 0.08241862803697586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018202288076281548 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, human-like figure covered in dense, interwoven dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a massive, weathered, gray rock face covered in deep cracks and mottled with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless thick dark green vines instantly break out of the ground and rapidly grow to cover the rock face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and evenly diffused, consistent with an overcast day?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long, fixed shot presented from a calm and objective perspective without camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890541821718216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640541076660156 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0890541821718216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0890541821718216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05510936304926872, + 0.03973102197051048, + 0.17986705899238586, + 0.2596118748188019, + 0.03581062704324722, + 0.07356211543083191, + 0.16992266476154327, + 0.0515890046954155, + 0.04239894077181816, + 0.09239738434553146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0890541821718216 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, human-like figure covered in dense, interwoven dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a massive, weathered, gray rock face covered in deep cracks and mottled with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless thick dark green vines instantly break out of the ground and rapidly grow to cover the rock face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and evenly diffused, consistent with an overcast day?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long, fixed shot presented from a calm and objective perspective without camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20168307423591614 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016830444335938 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20168307423591614, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20168307423591614, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16643397510051727, + 0.046380188316106796, + 0.05123783275485039, + 0.11654409021139145, + 0.042071856558322906, + 0.1340446174144745, + 0.180366650223732, + 0.05890549719333649, + 0.031596578657627106, + 0.1724187135696411 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20168307423591614 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, human-like figure covered in dense, interwoven dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a massive, weathered, gray rock face covered in deep cracks and mottled with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless thick dark green vines instantly break out of the ground and rapidly grow to cover the rock face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and evenly diffused, consistent with an overcast day?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long, fixed shot presented from a calm and objective perspective without camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3870832920074463 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370832920074463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3870832920074463, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3870832920074463, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03436438739299774, + 0.04964984953403473, + 0.04961768537759781, + 0.18329402804374695, + 0.029269810765981674, + 0.06624839454889297, + 0.3379623293876648, + 0.0515693761408329, + 0.03233158588409424, + 0.165692538022995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3870832920074463 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "long, fixed shot captures a slender, human-like figure standing quietly before a massive, weathered, gray rock face covered in deep cracks and mottled with moss. Under the soft, evenly diffused light of an overcast day, his body is covered in dense, interwoven dark green scales, reflecting a dark, moist, snake-like sheen. His figure stands tall, his features blurred in the distance, and a light mist hangs in the air around him. As he slowly and calmly raised one arm, as if receiving a silent command, countless thick dark green vines on the ground instantly broke out of the ground, growing and extending wildly at a speed visible to the naked eye like a group of frightened snakes. The tips of these vines were like conscious tentacles, searching for grip points on the rock surface, and then tightly wrapped around the protrusions of the rock, firmly clinging to and quickly covering the entire vertical cliff. The whole picture was presented from a calm and objective perspective, without dramatic emotional rendering, as if recording a strange and spectacular natural phenomenon, full of the texture and mystery of a natural documentary.", + "seed": 13618, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_15/index_6193_seed_13618_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2597579272463918, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2597579272463918, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2597579272463918, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, human-like figure covered in dense, interwoven dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a massive, weathered, gray rock face covered in deep cracks and mottled with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless thick dark green vines instantly break out of the ground and rapidly grow to cover the rock face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and evenly diffused, consistent with an overcast day?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long, fixed shot presented from a calm and objective perspective without camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10241933166980743 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.352419376373291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10241933166980743, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10241933166980743, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23516245186328888, + 0.05967133119702339, + 0.07030564546585083, + 0.03733081370592117, + 0.07429260015487671, + 0.0326501689851284, + 0.06491726636886597, + 0.11602699756622314, + 0.11695145070552826, + 0.19269132614135742 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10241933166980743 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, human-like figure covered in dense, interwoven dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a massive, weathered, gray rock face covered in deep cracks and mottled with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless thick dark green vines instantly break out of the ground and rapidly grow to cover the rock face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and evenly diffused, consistent with an overcast day?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long, fixed shot presented from a calm and objective perspective without camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01608971692621708 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141089916229248 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01608971692621708, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01608971692621708, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06434081494808197, + 0.07107032090425491, + 0.06887432932853699, + 0.03949381411075592, + 0.029827283695340157, + 0.08725769817829132, + 0.0775555744767189, + 0.14565788209438324, + 0.27242013812065125, + 0.14350208640098572 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01608971692621708 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, human-like figure covered in dense, interwoven dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a massive, weathered, gray rock face covered in deep cracks and mottled with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless thick dark green vines instantly break out of the ground and rapidly grow to cover the rock face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and evenly diffused, consistent with an overcast day?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long, fixed shot presented from a calm and objective perspective without camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47432345151901245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9743234515190125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47432345151901245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47432345151901245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08431753516197205, + 0.0511886402964592, + 0.044966116547584534, + 0.030502233654260635, + 0.04044995456933975, + 0.055912088602781296, + 0.04159219563007355, + 0.3380112648010254, + 0.24435128271579742, + 0.06870871037244797 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47432345151901245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, human-like figure covered in dense, interwoven dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a massive, weathered, gray rock face covered in deep cracks and mottled with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless thick dark green vines instantly break out of the ground and rapidly grow to cover the rock face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and evenly diffused, consistent with an overcast day?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long, fixed shot presented from a calm and objective perspective without camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01255407091230154 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387554168701172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01255407091230154, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01255407091230154, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10045838356018066, + 0.05010009557008743, + 0.19639554619789124, + 0.018773850053548813, + 0.03732811287045479, + 0.03734385967254639, + 0.12919239699840546, + 0.10946139693260193, + 0.16004551947116852, + 0.1609007567167282 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01255407091230154 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, human-like figure covered in dense, interwoven dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a massive, weathered, gray rock face covered in deep cracks and mottled with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless thick dark green vines instantly break out of the ground and rapidly grow to cover the rock face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and evenly diffused, consistent with an overcast day?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long, fixed shot presented from a calm and objective perspective without camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6934030652046204 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6934030652046204 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6934030652046204, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6934030652046204, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03626932576298714, + 0.03475285694003105, + 0.012577914632856846, + 0.02024645172059536, + 0.024285363033413887, + 0.17937196791172028, + 0.06932932883501053, + 0.10024482011795044, + 0.4604979157447815, + 0.062424078583717346 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6934030652046204 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "long, fixed shot captures a slender, human-like figure standing quietly before a massive, weathered, gray rock face covered in deep cracks and mottled with moss. Under the soft, evenly diffused light of an overcast day, his body is covered in dense, interwoven dark green scales, reflecting a dark, moist, snake-like sheen. His figure stands tall, his features blurred in the distance, and a light mist hangs in the air around him. As he slowly and calmly raised one arm, as if receiving a silent command, countless thick dark green vines on the ground instantly broke out of the ground, growing and extending wildly at a speed visible to the naked eye like a group of frightened snakes. The tips of these vines were like conscious tentacles, searching for grip points on the rock surface, and then tightly wrapped around the protrusions of the rock, firmly clinging to and quickly covering the entire vertical cliff. The whole picture was presented from a calm and objective perspective, without dramatic emotional rendering, as if recording a strange and spectacular natural phenomenon, full of the texture and mystery of a natural documentary.", + "seed": 13619, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_15/index_6193_seed_13619_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.047591286897659305, + "vlm_logprob": -0.047591286897659305, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.047591286897659305, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, human-like figure covered in dense, interwoven dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a massive, weathered, gray rock face covered in deep cracks and mottled with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless thick dark green vines instantly break out of the ground and rapidly grow to cover the rock face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and evenly diffused, consistent with an overcast day?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long, fixed shot presented from a calm and objective perspective without camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.040262069553136826 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.29026198387146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.040262069553136826, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.040262069553136826, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15083979070186615, + 0.03962892293930054, + 0.09196512401103973, + 0.10274217277765274, + 0.07910316437482834, + 0.17862169444561005, + 0.21720096468925476, + 0.06534342467784882, + 0.027136774733662605, + 0.047417908906936646 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.040262069553136826 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, human-like figure covered in dense, interwoven dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a massive, weathered, gray rock face covered in deep cracks and mottled with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless thick dark green vines instantly break out of the ground and rapidly grow to cover the rock face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and evenly diffused, consistent with an overcast day?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long, fixed shot presented from a calm and objective perspective without camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016077518463134766 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141077518463135 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016077518463134766, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016077518463134766, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1688288003206253, + 0.05676184594631195, + 0.09441924095153809, + 0.15079054236412048, + 0.13862305879592896, + 0.1060478687286377, + 0.10526173561811447, + 0.05238354951143265, + 0.07447581738233566, + 0.05240752547979355 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016077518463134766 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, human-like figure covered in dense, interwoven dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a massive, weathered, gray rock face covered in deep cracks and mottled with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless thick dark green vines instantly break out of the ground and rapidly grow to cover the rock face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and evenly diffused, consistent with an overcast day?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long, fixed shot presented from a calm and objective perspective without camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02635316178202629 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651353120803833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02635316178202629, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02635316178202629, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08727946877479553, + 0.04960453882813454, + 0.148763507604599, + 0.06659096479415894, + 0.07604468613862991, + 0.15639613568782806, + 0.13173270225524902, + 0.06304992735385895, + 0.12524262070655823, + 0.09529545158147812 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02635316178202629 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, human-like figure covered in dense, interwoven dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a massive, weathered, gray rock face covered in deep cracks and mottled with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless thick dark green vines instantly break out of the ground and rapidly grow to cover the rock face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and evenly diffused, consistent with an overcast day?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long, fixed shot presented from a calm and objective perspective without camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05497460812330246 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299745559692383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05497460812330246, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05497460812330246, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2049424946308136, + 0.20627690851688385, + 0.10723065584897995, + 0.04592422395944595, + 0.09895206987857819, + 0.06124109402298927, + 0.13315877318382263, + 0.05222596228122711, + 0.03299222141504288, + 0.05705559253692627 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05497460812330246 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, human-like figure covered in dense, interwoven dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a massive, weathered, gray rock face covered in deep cracks and mottled with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless thick dark green vines instantly break out of the ground and rapidly grow to cover the rock face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and evenly diffused, consistent with an overcast day?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long, fixed shot presented from a calm and objective perspective without camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10028907656669617 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3502891063690186 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10028907656669617, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10028907656669617, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.059373922646045685, + 0.04448474943637848, + 0.08491906523704529, + 0.1569427102804184, + 0.061753738671541214, + 0.21735675632953644, + 0.25027230381965637, + 0.03136374428868294, + 0.04678492248058319, + 0.04674806445837021 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10028907656669617 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "long, fixed shot captures a slender, human-like figure standing quietly before a massive, weathered, gray rock face covered in deep cracks and mottled with moss. Under the soft, evenly diffused light of an overcast day, his body is covered in dense, interwoven dark green scales, reflecting a dark, moist, snake-like sheen. His figure stands tall, his features blurred in the distance, and a light mist hangs in the air around him. As he slowly and calmly raised one arm, as if receiving a silent command, countless thick dark green vines on the ground instantly broke out of the ground, growing and extending wildly at a speed visible to the naked eye like a group of frightened snakes. The tips of these vines were like conscious tentacles, searching for grip points on the rock surface, and then tightly wrapped around the protrusions of the rock, firmly clinging to and quickly covering the entire vertical cliff. The whole picture was presented from a calm and objective perspective, without dramatic emotional rendering, as if recording a strange and spectacular natural phenomenon, full of the texture and mystery of a natural documentary.", + "seed": 13620, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_15/index_6193_seed_13620_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10129847042262555, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10129847042262555, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7249999403953553, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10129847042262555, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, human-like figure covered in dense, interwoven dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a massive, weathered, gray rock face covered in deep cracks and mottled with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless thick dark green vines instantly break out of the ground and rapidly grow to cover the rock face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and evenly diffused, consistent with an overcast day?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long, fixed shot presented from a calm and objective perspective without camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05771899223327637 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9327189922332764 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05771899223327637, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05771899223327637, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12514445185661316, + 0.08050619065761566, + 0.05858270451426506, + 0.04529239609837532, + 0.053346458822488785, + 0.07215850055217743, + 0.1661224067211151, + 0.07781042158603668, + 0.176455557346344, + 0.1445809006690979 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05771899223327637 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, human-like figure covered in dense, interwoven dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a massive, weathered, gray rock face covered in deep cracks and mottled with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless thick dark green vines instantly break out of the ground and rapidly grow to cover the rock face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and evenly diffused, consistent with an overcast day?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long, fixed shot presented from a calm and objective perspective without camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018200064077973366 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018199920654297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018200064077973366, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018200064077973366, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15790902078151703, + 0.2302611619234085, + 0.07974603027105331, + 0.03413446620106697, + 0.04176552966237068, + 0.08283186703920364, + 0.08967553079128265, + 0.07397354394197464, + 0.12615621089935303, + 0.08354666829109192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018200064077973366 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, human-like figure covered in dense, interwoven dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a massive, weathered, gray rock face covered in deep cracks and mottled with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless thick dark green vines instantly break out of the ground and rapidly grow to cover the rock face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and evenly diffused, consistent with an overcast day?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long, fixed shot presented from a calm and objective perspective without camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810567781329155 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881057262420654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810567781329155, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810567781329155, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06240498647093773, + 0.04116082936525345, + 0.05394960567355156, + 0.032336167991161346, + 0.04412712901830673, + 0.059265293180942535, + 0.1049022451043129, + 0.08887283504009247, + 0.2783523499965668, + 0.2346286028623581 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810567781329155 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, human-like figure covered in dense, interwoven dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a massive, weathered, gray rock face covered in deep cracks and mottled with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless thick dark green vines instantly break out of the ground and rapidly grow to cover the rock face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and evenly diffused, consistent with an overcast day?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long, fixed shot presented from a calm and objective perspective without camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07903438806533813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790343284606934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07903438806533813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07903438806533813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24325618147850037, + 0.22432854771614075, + 0.0559951588511467, + 0.023277312517166138, + 0.06118236854672432, + 0.03247702494263649, + 0.1246933788061142, + 0.0352582111954689, + 0.10210175812244415, + 0.09743007272481918 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07903438806533813 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, human-like figure covered in dense, interwoven dark green scales?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a massive, weathered, gray rock face covered in deep cracks and mottled with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless thick dark green vines instantly break out of the ground and rapidly grow to cover the rock face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and evenly diffused, consistent with an overcast day?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a long, fixed shot presented from a calm and objective perspective without camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134332299232483 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134331703186035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134332299232483, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.9999999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134332299232483, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08164279907941818, + 0.04265519976615906, + 0.04682976007461548, + 0.061314716935157776, + 0.13425080478191376, + 0.20579245686531067, + 0.16141031682491302, + 0.04776499420404434, + 0.0700669214129448, + 0.14827196300029755 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134332299232483 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_2/index_tensor([8061, 8061])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_2/index_tensor([8061, 8061])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0685568f13b7cbc2dcd0253245a675c9d157ed1c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_2/index_tensor([8061, 8061])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot shot in high-contrast, grainy black-and-white film triggers a slow, deliberate upward tilt, revealing the ancient stone battlements of Christ Church Cathedral. A light flurry of snow falls from a flat, leaden sky, sending delicate flakes swirling and drifting in the cold air. The camera's movement follows these swirling flakes as they gently dust the iconic Templar fortress, sinking into the deep crevices between the massive, rough-hewn stones and coating the jagged structure with a thin layer of white. The black-and-white cinematography emphasizes the stark raw textures of the medieval architecture, rendering the weathered stone in rich grays and deep blacks that contrast sharply with the bright, fresh snow. The scene is shrouded in a majestic silence, creating a somber and timeless atmosphere that is both melancholic and enduring, as if capturing a moment in time beyond history.", + "seed": 32070, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_2/index_8061_seed_32070_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.019588397443294527, + "vlm_logprob": -0.019588397443294527, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.019588397443294527, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black-and-white with high-contrast, grainy film aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate upward tilt to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ancient stone battlements of a cathedral visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a light flurry of snow falling and swirling in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement follow the swirling snowflakes as they coat the stone structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003239861223846674 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.878239631652832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003239861223846674, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003239861223846674, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09366592019796371, + 0.05894376337528229, + 0.014553487300872803, + 0.2926574945449829, + 0.030857626348733902, + 0.42007672786712646, + 0.013508130796253681, + 0.024081801995635033, + 0.02323421835899353, + 0.02842087112367153 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003239861223846674 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black-and-white with high-contrast, grainy film aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate upward tilt to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ancient stone battlements of a cathedral visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a light flurry of snow falling and swirling in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement follow the swirling snowflakes as they coat the stone structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029813941568136215 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298140048980713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029813941568136215, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029813941568136215, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05510498583316803, + 0.11811495572328568, + 0.06917601823806763, + 0.09677539020776749, + 0.040849462151527405, + 0.15757398307323456, + 0.020851925015449524, + 0.02582087554037571, + 0.15397430956363678, + 0.26175805926322937 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029813941568136215 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black-and-white with high-contrast, grainy film aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate upward tilt to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ancient stone battlements of a cathedral visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a light flurry of snow falling and swirling in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement follow the swirling snowflakes as they coat the stone structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007625637110322714 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882625579833984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007625637110322714, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007625637110322714, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14605417847633362, + 0.056274183094501495, + 0.09624265134334564, + 0.01913238875567913, + 0.016231942921876907, + 0.5226306319236755, + 0.009964642114937305, + 0.037936918437480927, + 0.04417405650019646, + 0.051358412951231 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007625637110322714 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black-and-white with high-contrast, grainy film aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate upward tilt to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ancient stone battlements of a cathedral visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a light flurry of snow falling and swirling in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement follow the swirling snowflakes as they coat the stone structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014198120683431625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264198303222656 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014198120683431625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014198120683431625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05612138286232948, + 0.0520504005253315, + 0.01622345671057701, + 0.0360526517033577, + 0.03391941636800766, + 0.6609851121902466, + 0.032394394278526306, + 0.05136512592434883, + 0.028926493600010872, + 0.031961604952812195 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014198120683431625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black-and-white with high-contrast, grainy film aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate upward tilt to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ancient stone battlements of a cathedral visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a light flurry of snow falling and swirling in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement follow the swirling snowflakes as they coat the stone structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0430644266307354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680643558502197 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0430644266307354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0430644266307354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04195354878902435, + 0.07061206549406052, + 0.08696523308753967, + 0.05085945874452591, + 0.037798695266246796, + 0.40917113423347473, + 0.03851335868239403, + 0.038616079837083817, + 0.096805639564991, + 0.12870481610298157 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0430644266307354 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot shot in high-contrast, grainy black-and-white film triggers a slow, deliberate upward tilt, revealing the ancient stone battlements of Christ Church Cathedral. A light flurry of snow falls from a flat, leaden sky, sending delicate flakes swirling and drifting in the cold air. The camera's movement follows these swirling flakes as they gently dust the iconic Templar fortress, sinking into the deep crevices between the massive, rough-hewn stones and coating the jagged structure with a thin layer of white. The black-and-white cinematography emphasizes the stark raw textures of the medieval architecture, rendering the weathered stone in rich grays and deep blacks that contrast sharply with the bright, fresh snow. The scene is shrouded in a majestic silence, creating a somber and timeless atmosphere that is both melancholic and enduring, as if capturing a moment in time beyond history.", + "seed": 32071, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_2/index_8061_seed_32071_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.046087816916406156, + "vlm_logprob": -0.046087816916406156, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.046087816916406156, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black-and-white with high-contrast, grainy film aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate upward tilt to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ancient stone battlements of a cathedral visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a light flurry of snow falling and swirling in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement follow the swirling snowflakes as they coat the stone structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008688267320394516 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.008688449859619 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008688267320394516, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008688267320394516, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7062023878097534, + 0.02480313368141651, + 0.013026369735598564, + 0.017985591664910316, + 0.06990105658769608, + 0.00903383456170559, + 0.016682855784893036, + 0.007423502393066883, + 0.08929857611656189, + 0.04564273729920387 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008688267320394516 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black-and-white with high-contrast, grainy film aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate upward tilt to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ancient stone battlements of a cathedral visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a light flurry of snow falling and swirling in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement follow the swirling snowflakes as they coat the stone structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14280128479003906 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017801284790039 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14280128479003906, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14280128479003906, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2561987340450287, + 0.03752251714468002, + 0.054449599236249924, + 0.13469131290912628, + 0.14720095694065094, + 0.04522746428847313, + 0.05914962291717529, + 0.02873041480779648, + 0.10021740943193436, + 0.1366119682788849 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14280128479003906 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black-and-white with high-contrast, grainy film aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate upward tilt to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ancient stone battlements of a cathedral visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a light flurry of snow falling and swirling in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement follow the swirling snowflakes as they coat the stone structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978152547031641 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634781360626221 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978152547031641, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978152547031641, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13962006568908691, + 0.07554120570421219, + 0.033101972192525864, + 0.025712210685014725, + 0.04433819279074669, + 0.0330246202647686, + 0.04578831046819687, + 0.04337657243013382, + 0.5175220966339111, + 0.041974786669015884 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978152547031641 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black-and-white with high-contrast, grainy film aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate upward tilt to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ancient stone battlements of a cathedral visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a light flurry of snow falling and swirling in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement follow the swirling snowflakes as they coat the stone structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014204232022166252 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264204025268555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014204232022166252, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014204232022166252, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28807005286216736, + 0.03300413861870766, + 0.023212237283587456, + 0.025830674916505814, + 0.3049730360507965, + 0.0824793204665184, + 0.08917734771966934, + 0.025627505034208298, + 0.07246797531843185, + 0.055157631635665894 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014204232022166252 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black-and-white with high-contrast, grainy film aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate upward tilt to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ancient stone battlements of a cathedral visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a light flurry of snow falling and swirling in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement follow the swirling snowflakes as they coat the stone structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496377497911453 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299638271331787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496377497911453, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496377497911453, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.363393634557724, + 0.024762768298387527, + 0.04929507523775101, + 0.08548986166715622, + 0.1072193831205368, + 0.07505449652671814, + 0.06334931403398514, + 0.03472660481929779, + 0.16730183362960815, + 0.029406975954771042 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496377497911453 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot shot in high-contrast, grainy black-and-white film triggers a slow, deliberate upward tilt, revealing the ancient stone battlements of Christ Church Cathedral. A light flurry of snow falls from a flat, leaden sky, sending delicate flakes swirling and drifting in the cold air. The camera's movement follows these swirling flakes as they gently dust the iconic Templar fortress, sinking into the deep crevices between the massive, rough-hewn stones and coating the jagged structure with a thin layer of white. The black-and-white cinematography emphasizes the stark raw textures of the medieval architecture, rendering the weathered stone in rich grays and deep blacks that contrast sharply with the bright, fresh snow. The scene is shrouded in a majestic silence, creating a somber and timeless atmosphere that is both melancholic and enduring, as if capturing a moment in time beyond history.", + "seed": 32072, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_2/index_8061_seed_32072_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.02272669319063425, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02272669319063425, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02272669319063425, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black-and-white with high-contrast, grainy film aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate upward tilt to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ancient stone battlements of a cathedral visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a light flurry of snow falling and swirling in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement follow the swirling snowflakes as they coat the stone structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005020155571401119 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.1300201416015625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005020155571401119, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005020155571401119, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15936028957366943, + 0.05013089254498482, + 0.04838845133781433, + 0.08965811133384705, + 0.07379277050495148, + 0.053206976503133774, + 0.07815302163362503, + 0.3847714364528656, + 0.021075820550322533, + 0.04146227985620499 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005020155571401119 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black-and-white with high-contrast, grainy film aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate upward tilt to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ancient stone battlements of a cathedral visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a light flurry of snow falling and swirling in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement follow the swirling snowflakes as they coat the stone structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020596671849489212 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895596742630005 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020596671849489212, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020596671849489212, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11974416673183441, + 0.09832250326871872, + 0.038190796971321106, + 0.09602629393339157, + 0.07725610584020615, + 0.12381082773208618, + 0.12834401428699493, + 0.11461778730154037, + 0.14542727172374725, + 0.058260228484869 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020596671849489212 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black-and-white with high-contrast, grainy film aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate upward tilt to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ancient stone battlements of a cathedral visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a light flurry of snow falling and swirling in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement follow the swirling snowflakes as they coat the stone structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606367528438568 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141063690185547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606367528438568, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606367528438568, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18011784553527832, + 0.059121545404195786, + 0.06936734914779663, + 0.2584017813205719, + 0.06263178586959839, + 0.06966538727283478, + 0.06852750480175018, + 0.06813883781433105, + 0.061755403876304626, + 0.10227257013320923 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606367528438568 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black-and-white with high-contrast, grainy film aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate upward tilt to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ancient stone battlements of a cathedral visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a light flurry of snow falling and swirling in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement follow the swirling snowflakes as they coat the stone structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329273335635662 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732927799224854 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329273335635662, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329273335635662, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0732765719294548, + 0.07383061200380325, + 0.1052461490035057, + 0.11729492992162704, + 0.07456189393997192, + 0.08268280327320099, + 0.33060556650161743, + 0.06447172164916992, + 0.028802843764424324, + 0.04922689124941826 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329273335635662 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black-and-white with high-contrast, grainy film aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate upward tilt to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ancient stone battlements of a cathedral visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a light flurry of snow falling and swirling in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement follow the swirling snowflakes as they coat the stone structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866022989153862 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486602783203125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866022989153862, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866022989153862, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05634533241391182, + 0.06099472567439079, + 0.044485703110694885, + 0.10092248022556305, + 0.12134604901075363, + 0.053968314081430435, + 0.21707989275455475, + 0.17673814296722412, + 0.09967821091413498, + 0.06844114512205124 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866022989153862 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "wide-angle shot shot in high-contrast, grainy black-and-white film triggers a slow, deliberate upward tilt, revealing the ancient stone battlements of Christ Church Cathedral. A light flurry of snow falls from a flat, leaden sky, sending delicate flakes swirling and drifting in the cold air. The camera's movement follows these swirling flakes as they gently dust the iconic Templar fortress, sinking into the deep crevices between the massive, rough-hewn stones and coating the jagged structure with a thin layer of white. The black-and-white cinematography emphasizes the stark raw textures of the medieval architecture, rendering the weathered stone in rich grays and deep blacks that contrast sharply with the bright, fresh snow. The scene is shrouded in a majestic silence, creating a somber and timeless atmosphere that is both melancholic and enduring, as if capturing a moment in time beyond history.", + "seed": 32073, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_2/index_8061_seed_32073_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0554531155154109, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0554531155154109, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0554531155154109, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black-and-white with high-contrast, grainy film aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate upward tilt to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ancient stone battlements of a cathedral visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a light flurry of snow falling and swirling in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement follow the swirling snowflakes as they coat the stone structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010586530901491642 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.760586738586426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010586530901491642, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010586530901491642, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.010681875981390476, + 0.004895849619060755, + 0.030470404773950577, + 0.3246794044971466, + 0.10093574970960617, + 0.007424072828143835, + 0.02109207771718502, + 0.017825450748205185, + 0.44519346952438354, + 0.03680166229605675 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010586530901491642 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black-and-white with high-contrast, grainy film aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate upward tilt to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ancient stone battlements of a cathedral visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a light flurry of snow falling and swirling in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement follow the swirling snowflakes as they coat the stone structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17989781498908997 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048977851867676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17989781498908997, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17989781498908997, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.010688945651054382, + 0.009139247238636017, + 0.07732733339071274, + 0.7346040606498718, + 0.031538043171167374, + 0.016883397474884987, + 0.012371781282126904, + 0.04328427463769913, + 0.0560830794274807, + 0.008079842664301395 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17989781498908997 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black-and-white with high-contrast, grainy film aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate upward tilt to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ancient stone battlements of a cathedral visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a light flurry of snow falling and swirling in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement follow the swirling snowflakes as they coat the stone structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008637567982077599 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758637428283691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008637567982077599, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008637567982077599, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.031077437102794647, + 0.015040935948491096, + 0.12674111127853394, + 0.5623391270637512, + 0.08901605010032654, + 0.04481694474816322, + 0.021530993282794952, + 0.026880284771323204, + 0.06549534201622009, + 0.017061810940504074 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008637567982077599 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black-and-white with high-contrast, grainy film aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate upward tilt to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ancient stone battlements of a cathedral visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a light flurry of snow falling and swirling in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement follow the swirling snowflakes as they coat the stone structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607857272028923 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141078472137451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607857272028923, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607857272028923, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.040869228541851044, + 0.01876307837665081, + 0.4694116711616516, + 0.26680606603622437, + 0.07431570440530777, + 0.009230160154402256, + 0.011644487269222736, + 0.02894398756325245, + 0.0671469122171402, + 0.012868686579167843 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607857272028923 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in black-and-white with high-contrast, grainy film aesthetics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, deliberate upward tilt to reveal the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are ancient stone battlements of a cathedral visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a light flurry of snow falling and swirling in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement follow the swirling snowflakes as they coat the stone structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062065090984106064 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120651245117188 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062065090984106064, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062065090984106064, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.010131893679499626, + 0.0067086778581142426, + 0.11735492199659348, + 0.7385446429252625, + 0.020733125507831573, + 0.00874242465943098, + 0.008740812540054321, + 0.030097315087914467, + 0.04863644391298294, + 0.010309756733477116 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062065090984106064 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_3/index_tensor([8251, 8251])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_3/index_tensor([8251, 8251])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..892d2843707d450f6cccda744741ef090c990847 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_3/index_tensor([8251, 8251])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, long shot captures a rigorously symmetrical room from afar. On a central wooden table, a delicate silver tray with an antique-carved rim takes center stage. A hand clad in a flawless white cotton glove manipulates it with intense concentration. Carefully, with its fingertips, it lifts and places several small glass vials filled with a crimson liquid that gleams like a jewel, arranging them in an impeccably straight line, the spacing between each vial precisely measured, as if performing a sacred ritual. The background features a wall meticulously painted a soft mint green, flanked by two identical vintage paintings of botanical specimens, symmetrically hanging on either side, reinforcing the composition's exquisite balance. Soft, even frontal light permeates the scene, eliminating nearly all shadows and imbuing the image with a flat, diorama-like quality. The entire scene, with its vibrant color contrast of crimson, mint green, and silver, perfectly presents a Wes Anderson-esque grotesque aesthetic, imbued with an obsessive sense of order and an ineffable, cool humor.", + "seed": 9807, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_3/index_8251_seed_9807_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05672982595860958, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05672982595860958, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.049999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05672982595860958, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static long shot capturing a room from afar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a central wooden table visible with a delicate silver tray featuring an antique-carved rim on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand wearing a flawless white cotton glove seen manipulating the tray and lifting/placing small glass vials filled with crimson liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the glass vials arranged in an impeccably straight line with precisely measured spacing against a soft mint green wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and even with frontal illumination that eliminates nearly all shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1292962282896042 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.12929630279541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1292962282896042, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1292962282896042, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.152706578373909, + 0.04067300632596016, + 0.03863115236163139, + 0.6181875467300415, + 0.05980892851948738, + 0.023166188970208168, + 0.011665287427604198, + 0.018500469624996185, + 0.02238067239522934, + 0.014280125498771667 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1292962282896042 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static long shot capturing a room from afar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a central wooden table visible with a delicate silver tray featuring an antique-carved rim on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand wearing a flawless white cotton glove seen manipulating the tray and lifting/placing small glass vials filled with crimson liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the glass vials arranged in an impeccably straight line with precisely measured spacing against a soft mint green wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and even with frontal illumination that eliminates nearly all shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018210599198937416 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018210411071777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018210599198937416, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018210599198937416, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23073899745941162, + 0.07941645383834839, + 0.04522839933633804, + 0.23033209145069122, + 0.13552050292491913, + 0.05738571658730507, + 0.044795166701078415, + 0.09517793357372284, + 0.05055810511112213, + 0.03084666095674038 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018210599198937416 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static long shot capturing a room from afar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a central wooden table visible with a delicate silver tray featuring an antique-carved rim on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand wearing a flawless white cotton glove seen manipulating the tray and lifting/placing small glass vials filled with crimson liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the glass vials arranged in an impeccably straight line with precisely measured spacing against a soft mint green wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and even with frontal illumination that eliminates nearly all shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308372363448143 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168083667755127 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308372363448143, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308372363448143, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13102754950523376, + 0.06859026849269867, + 0.056317396461963654, + 0.42533138394355774, + 0.10569646209478378, + 0.05043664947152138, + 0.02702006697654724, + 0.05935993790626526, + 0.049802280962467194, + 0.026418006047606468 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308372363448143 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static long shot capturing a room from afar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a central wooden table visible with a delicate silver tray featuring an antique-carved rim on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand wearing a flawless white cotton glove seen manipulating the tray and lifting/placing small glass vials filled with crimson liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the glass vials arranged in an impeccably straight line with precisely measured spacing against a soft mint green wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and even with frontal illumination that eliminates nearly all shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054968852549791336 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.92996883392334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054968852549791336, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054968852549791336, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12916862964630127, + 0.0678197368979454, + 0.08556506782770157, + 0.4500087797641754, + 0.0847080871462822, + 0.05075613781809807, + 0.029215184971690178, + 0.05387294664978981, + 0.031437285244464874, + 0.017448175698518753 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054968852549791336 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static long shot capturing a room from afar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a central wooden table visible with a delicate silver tray featuring an antique-carved rim on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand wearing a flawless white cotton glove seen manipulating the tray and lifting/placing small glass vials filled with crimson liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the glass vials arranged in an impeccably straight line with precisely measured spacing against a soft mint green wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and even with frontal illumination that eliminates nearly all shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038089726120233536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880897521972656 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038089726120233536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038089726120233536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13542309403419495, + 0.055084049701690674, + 0.07843141257762909, + 0.34324485063552856, + 0.09340249001979828, + 0.0669216439127922, + 0.030813956633210182, + 0.10280466824769974, + 0.06691721826791763, + 0.026956647634506226 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038089726120233536 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, long shot captures a rigorously symmetrical room from afar. On a central wooden table, a delicate silver tray with an antique-carved rim takes center stage. A hand clad in a flawless white cotton glove manipulates it with intense concentration. Carefully, with its fingertips, it lifts and places several small glass vials filled with a crimson liquid that gleams like a jewel, arranging them in an impeccably straight line, the spacing between each vial precisely measured, as if performing a sacred ritual. The background features a wall meticulously painted a soft mint green, flanked by two identical vintage paintings of botanical specimens, symmetrically hanging on either side, reinforcing the composition's exquisite balance. Soft, even frontal light permeates the scene, eliminating nearly all shadows and imbuing the image with a flat, diorama-like quality. The entire scene, with its vibrant color contrast of crimson, mint green, and silver, perfectly presents a Wes Anderson-esque grotesque aesthetic, imbued with an obsessive sense of order and an ineffable, cool humor.", + "seed": 9808, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_3/index_8251_seed_9808_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03460874762386083, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03460874762386083, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03460874762386083, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static long shot capturing a room from afar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a central wooden table visible with a delicate silver tray featuring an antique-carved rim on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand wearing a flawless white cotton glove seen manipulating the tray and lifting/placing small glass vials filled with crimson liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the glass vials arranged in an impeccably straight line with precisely measured spacing against a soft mint green wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and even with frontal illumination that eliminates nearly all shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07078389078378677 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695783853530884 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07078389078378677, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07078389078378677, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4540816843509674, + 0.06227327883243561, + 0.053041230887174606, + 0.03748258203268051, + 0.06530171632766724, + 0.04140208289027214, + 0.04840095713734627, + 0.08377289026975632, + 0.08907365053892136, + 0.06516993790864944 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07078389078378677 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static long shot capturing a room from afar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a central wooden table visible with a delicate silver tray featuring an antique-carved rim on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand wearing a flawless white cotton glove seen manipulating the tray and lifting/placing small glass vials filled with crimson liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the glass vials arranged in an impeccably straight line with precisely measured spacing against a soft mint green wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and even with frontal illumination that eliminates nearly all shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02331451140344143 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733144760131836 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02331451140344143, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02331451140344143, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2831920087337494, + 0.10556232929229736, + 0.10752168297767639, + 0.04033377766609192, + 0.10269846022129059, + 0.07508006691932678, + 0.05257517471909523, + 0.07283959537744522, + 0.09987980127334595, + 0.0603170171380043 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02331451140344143 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static long shot capturing a room from afar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a central wooden table visible with a delicate silver tray featuring an antique-carved rim on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand wearing a flawless white cotton glove seen manipulating the tray and lifting/placing small glass vials filled with crimson liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the glass vials arranged in an impeccably straight line with precisely measured spacing against a soft mint green wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and even with frontal illumination that eliminates nearly all shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048682596534490585 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048682689666748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048682596534490585, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048682596534490585, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21372684836387634, + 0.08049435168504715, + 0.08003471046686172, + 0.058567680418491364, + 0.0638774111866951, + 0.06525016576051712, + 0.03154512494802475, + 0.15412954986095428, + 0.0521099828183651, + 0.2002640962600708 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048682596534490585 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static long shot capturing a room from afar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a central wooden table visible with a delicate silver tray featuring an antique-carved rim on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand wearing a flawless white cotton glove seen manipulating the tray and lifting/placing small glass vials filled with crimson liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the glass vials arranged in an impeccably straight line with precisely measured spacing against a soft mint green wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and even with frontal illumination that eliminates nearly all shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014200941659510136 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2642011642456055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014200941659510136, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014200941659510136, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5745595693588257, + 0.02855316363275051, + 0.07179005444049835, + 0.02507139928638935, + 0.11358208954334259, + 0.047899290919303894, + 0.017201965674757957, + 0.06311696022748947, + 0.029358351603150368, + 0.028867123648524284 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014200941659510136 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static long shot capturing a room from afar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a central wooden table visible with a delicate silver tray featuring an antique-carved rim on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand wearing a flawless white cotton glove seen manipulating the tray and lifting/placing small glass vials filled with crimson liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the glass vials arranged in an impeccably straight line with precisely measured spacing against a soft mint green wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and even with frontal illumination that eliminates nearly all shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016061797738075256 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141061782836914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016061797738075256, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016061797738075256, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5244902968406677, + 0.0499391183257103, + 0.019480854272842407, + 0.029720202088356018, + 0.10933852195739746, + 0.03891303390264511, + 0.03714276850223541, + 0.09046391397714615, + 0.017890024930238724, + 0.08262120932340622 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016061797738075256 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, long shot captures a rigorously symmetrical room from afar. On a central wooden table, a delicate silver tray with an antique-carved rim takes center stage. A hand clad in a flawless white cotton glove manipulates it with intense concentration. Carefully, with its fingertips, it lifts and places several small glass vials filled with a crimson liquid that gleams like a jewel, arranging them in an impeccably straight line, the spacing between each vial precisely measured, as if performing a sacred ritual. The background features a wall meticulously painted a soft mint green, flanked by two identical vintage paintings of botanical specimens, symmetrically hanging on either side, reinforcing the composition's exquisite balance. Soft, even frontal light permeates the scene, eliminating nearly all shadows and imbuing the image with a flat, diorama-like quality. The entire scene, with its vibrant color contrast of crimson, mint green, and silver, perfectly presents a Wes Anderson-esque grotesque aesthetic, imbued with an obsessive sense of order and an ineffable, cool humor.", + "seed": 9809, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_3/index_8251_seed_9809_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.037920054607093336, + "vlm_logprob": -0.037920054607093336, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.037920054607093336, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static long shot capturing a room from afar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a central wooden table visible with a delicate silver tray featuring an antique-carved rim on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand wearing a flawless white cotton glove seen manipulating the tray and lifting/placing small glass vials filled with crimson liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the glass vials arranged in an impeccably straight line with precisely measured spacing against a soft mint green wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and even with frontal illumination that eliminates nearly all shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08007586747407913 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.580075979232788 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08007586747407913, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08007586747407913, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12589457631111145, + 0.11280655115842819, + 0.0701310932636261, + 0.1369558423757553, + 0.23247164487838745, + 0.16073063015937805, + 0.08675619959831238, + 0.03826528787612915, + 0.02085450477898121, + 0.01513361930847168 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08007586747407913 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static long shot capturing a room from afar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a central wooden table visible with a delicate silver tray featuring an antique-carved rim on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand wearing a flawless white cotton glove seen manipulating the tray and lifting/placing small glass vials filled with crimson liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the glass vials arranged in an impeccably straight line with precisely measured spacing against a soft mint green wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and even with frontal illumination that eliminates nearly all shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011093604378402233 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511093616485596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011093604378402233, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011093604378402233, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21129724383354187, + 0.35719212889671326, + 0.05746223405003548, + 0.07211806625127792, + 0.05307837203145027, + 0.036299705505371094, + 0.03737678378820419, + 0.12188732624053955, + 0.023220250383019447, + 0.030067944899201393 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011093604378402233 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static long shot capturing a room from afar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a central wooden table visible with a delicate silver tray featuring an antique-carved rim on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand wearing a flawless white cotton glove seen manipulating the tray and lifting/placing small glass vials filled with crimson liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the glass vials arranged in an impeccably straight line with precisely measured spacing against a soft mint green wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and even with frontal illumination that eliminates nearly all shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016082562506198883 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141082763671875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016082562506198883, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016082562506198883, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2587455213069916, + 0.34236064553260803, + 0.06099340319633484, + 0.05563821271061897, + 0.04430116340517998, + 0.030634256079792976, + 0.0433158203959465, + 0.07467225193977356, + 0.048071056604385376, + 0.041267648339271545 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016082562506198883 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static long shot capturing a room from afar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a central wooden table visible with a delicate silver tray featuring an antique-carved rim on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand wearing a flawless white cotton glove seen manipulating the tray and lifting/placing small glass vials filled with crimson liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the glass vials arranged in an impeccably straight line with precisely measured spacing against a soft mint green wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and even with frontal illumination that eliminates nearly all shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048656709492206573 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048656702041626 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048656709492206573, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048656709492206573, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22072598338127136, + 0.2860736846923828, + 0.06661821901798248, + 0.09007526189088821, + 0.10204042494297028, + 0.031108172610402107, + 0.07789048552513123, + 0.07844319194555283, + 0.01630847156047821, + 0.03071608953177929 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048656709492206573 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static long shot capturing a room from afar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a central wooden table visible with a delicate silver tray featuring an antique-carved rim on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand wearing a flawless white cotton glove seen manipulating the tray and lifting/placing small glass vials filled with crimson liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the glass vials arranged in an impeccably straight line with precisely measured spacing against a soft mint green wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and even with frontal illumination that eliminates nearly all shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369152918457985 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408691644668579 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369152918457985, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369152918457985, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2517624497413635, + 0.2571689784526825, + 0.05970985069870949, + 0.06624472886323929, + 0.07005881518125534, + 0.09206472337245941, + 0.06414878368377686, + 0.07026417553424835, + 0.02623768337070942, + 0.042339883744716644 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369152918457985 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, long shot captures a rigorously symmetrical room from afar. On a central wooden table, a delicate silver tray with an antique-carved rim takes center stage. A hand clad in a flawless white cotton glove manipulates it with intense concentration. Carefully, with its fingertips, it lifts and places several small glass vials filled with a crimson liquid that gleams like a jewel, arranging them in an impeccably straight line, the spacing between each vial precisely measured, as if performing a sacred ritual. The background features a wall meticulously painted a soft mint green, flanked by two identical vintage paintings of botanical specimens, symmetrically hanging on either side, reinforcing the composition's exquisite balance. Soft, even frontal light permeates the scene, eliminating nearly all shadows and imbuing the image with a flat, diorama-like quality. The entire scene, with its vibrant color contrast of crimson, mint green, and silver, perfectly presents a Wes Anderson-esque grotesque aesthetic, imbued with an obsessive sense of order and an ineffable, cool humor.", + "seed": 9810, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_3/index_8251_seed_9810_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.025383280217647554, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025383280217647554, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025383280217647554, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static long shot capturing a room from afar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a central wooden table visible with a delicate silver tray featuring an antique-carved rim on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand wearing a flawless white cotton glove seen manipulating the tray and lifting/placing small glass vials filled with crimson liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the glass vials arranged in an impeccably straight line with precisely measured spacing against a soft mint green wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and even with frontal illumination that eliminates nearly all shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06440847367048264 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.814408540725708 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06440847367048264, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06440847367048264, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08943329006433487, + 0.034478046000003815, + 0.02986409142613411, + 0.20868414640426636, + 0.12383897602558136, + 0.15072238445281982, + 0.19612672924995422, + 0.08608006685972214, + 0.04271673783659935, + 0.038055479526519775 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06440847367048264 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static long shot capturing a room from afar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a central wooden table visible with a delicate silver tray featuring an antique-carved rim on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand wearing a flawless white cotton glove seen manipulating the tray and lifting/placing small glass vials filled with crimson liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the glass vials arranged in an impeccably straight line with precisely measured spacing against a soft mint green wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and even with frontal illumination that eliminates nearly all shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012553482316434383 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387553691864014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012553482316434383, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012553482316434383, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.229840949177742, + 0.06472622603178024, + 0.06484533101320267, + 0.12936002016067505, + 0.09479599446058273, + 0.061340976506471634, + 0.14130538702011108, + 0.06603196263313293, + 0.08756794780492783, + 0.06018521636724472 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012553482316434383 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static long shot capturing a room from afar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a central wooden table visible with a delicate silver tray featuring an antique-carved rim on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand wearing a flawless white cotton glove seen manipulating the tray and lifting/placing small glass vials filled with crimson liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the glass vials arranged in an impeccably straight line with precisely measured spacing against a soft mint green wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and even with frontal illumination that eliminates nearly all shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026351768523454666 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513516902923584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026351768523454666, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026351768523454666, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14371845126152039, + 0.07497818768024445, + 0.03529778867959976, + 0.07669930160045624, + 0.0596453920006752, + 0.1641116589307785, + 0.22293215990066528, + 0.07163131237030029, + 0.11604533344507217, + 0.034940414130687714 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026351768523454666 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static long shot capturing a room from afar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a central wooden table visible with a delicate silver tray featuring an antique-carved rim on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand wearing a flawless white cotton glove seen manipulating the tray and lifting/placing small glass vials filled with crimson liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the glass vials arranged in an impeccably straight line with precisely measured spacing against a soft mint green wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and even with frontal illumination that eliminates nearly all shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011073562316596508 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511073589324951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011073562316596508, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011073562316596508, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10974113643169403, + 0.11543995141983032, + 0.03147035837173462, + 0.09554779529571533, + 0.07364007830619812, + 0.062026944011449814, + 0.05421114340424538, + 0.30595800280570984, + 0.06258479505777359, + 0.08937976509332657 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011073562316596508 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static long shot capturing a room from afar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a central wooden table visible with a delicate silver tray featuring an antique-carved rim on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a hand wearing a flawless white cotton glove seen manipulating the tray and lifting/placing small glass vials filled with crimson liquid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are the glass vials arranged in an impeccably straight line with precisely measured spacing against a soft mint green wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and even with frontal illumination that eliminates nearly all shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01252911426126957 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387528896331787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01252911426126957, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01252911426126957, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07093650102615356, + 0.03420574963092804, + 0.01963658444583416, + 0.18248796463012695, + 0.06253262609243393, + 0.1571054458618164, + 0.26487284898757935, + 0.17122536897659302, + 0.026453480124473572, + 0.010543398559093475 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01252911426126957 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_4/index_tensor([8038, 8038])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_4/index_tensor([8038, 8038])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..81c8ab112a8b8bf3a992d0c441f823def21114ce --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_4/index_tensor([8038, 8038])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "This static, eye-level extreme close-up, rendered with stark photorealism, captures a sleek, silver aluminum aerosol can, perfectly upright, on a dark, richly textured wooden surface. The can features a minimalist design, with a smooth matte finish, no label, and a simple black plastic nozzle on top. A sudden, subtle vibration sends ripples through the wooden surface, causing the can to tremble erratically. It loses its balance and begins to topple in a slow-motion arc, its metal body catching the sharp flash of light from a single, cold-toned overhead light source. The can is deliberately dropped so that the top and its black plastic nozzle impact the surface first. Upon impact, the force instantly and decisively compresses the actuator, releasing a brief, explosive burst of fine, translucent aerosol mist that emanates from the nozzle in a rapidly expanding, conical plume. Each microdroplet in the spray is sharply defined, illuminated by the overhead light, briefly flickering against the dark, out-of-focus backdrop of the workshop before dissipating, creating a tense and highly detailed moment of cause and effect.", + "seed": 8649, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_4/index_8038_seed_8649_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.20857102945446968, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20857102945446968, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20857102945446968, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, silver aluminum aerosol can with a matte finish and no label?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the can positioned upright on a dark, richly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the can topple over in a slow-motion arc after losing its balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the can impact the surface with its top and black plastic nozzle first, releasing a conical plume of translucent aerosol mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8989376425743103 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5239376425743103 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8989376425743103, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8989376425743103, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4118858873844147, + 0.07917557656764984, + 0.1851215958595276, + 0.07461089640855789, + 0.09709013253450394, + 0.033439893275499344, + 0.027950286865234375, + 0.019403038546442986, + 0.02603197656571865, + 0.04529061168432236 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8989376425743103 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, silver aluminum aerosol can with a matte finish and no label?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the can positioned upright on a dark, richly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the can topple over in a slow-motion arc after losing its balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the can impact the surface with its top and black plastic nozzle first, releasing a conical plume of translucent aerosol mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012560781091451645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387560844421387 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012560781091451645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012560781091451645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.49787184596061707, + 0.049548085778951645, + 0.051577966660261154, + 0.05242268741130829, + 0.044567082077264786, + 0.07545990496873856, + 0.0809740424156189, + 0.04752061143517494, + 0.06717754155397415, + 0.03288029506802559 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012560781091451645 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, silver aluminum aerosol can with a matte finish and no label?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the can positioned upright on a dark, richly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the can topple over in a slow-motion arc after losing its balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the can impact the surface with its top and black plastic nozzle first, releasing a conical plume of translucent aerosol mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008647849783301353 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758647918701172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008647849783301353, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008647849783301353, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.49959489703178406, + 0.08785902708768845, + 0.03735458105802536, + 0.04385839402675629, + 0.05426272004842758, + 0.07055609673261642, + 0.08441893756389618, + 0.025140509009361267, + 0.04058678075671196, + 0.056367989629507065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008647849783301353 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, silver aluminum aerosol can with a matte finish and no label?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the can positioned upright on a dark, richly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the can topple over in a slow-motion arc after losing its balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the can impact the surface with its top and black plastic nozzle first, releasing a conical plume of translucent aerosol mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009783769026398659 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634783744812012 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009783769026398659, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009783769026398659, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16846080124378204, + 0.42660120129585266, + 0.09273987263441086, + 0.04601294547319412, + 0.07686648517847061, + 0.06306220591068268, + 0.03442768007516861, + 0.03073790855705738, + 0.02458450198173523, + 0.036506470292806625 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009783769026398659 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, silver aluminum aerosol can with a matte finish and no label?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the can positioned upright on a dark, richly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the can topple over in a slow-motion arc after losing its balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the can impact the surface with its top and black plastic nozzle first, releasing a conical plume of translucent aerosol mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11292510479688644 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379250526428223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11292510479688644, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11292510479688644, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19845232367515564, + 0.14252273738384247, + 0.09048976004123688, + 0.07149288803339005, + 0.0530259944498539, + 0.11554495245218277, + 0.0700576901435852, + 0.04811340197920799, + 0.0828702449798584, + 0.1274300068616867 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11292510479688644 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This static, eye-level extreme close-up, rendered with stark photorealism, captures a sleek, silver aluminum aerosol can, perfectly upright, on a dark, richly textured wooden surface. The can features a minimalist design, with a smooth matte finish, no label, and a simple black plastic nozzle on top. A sudden, subtle vibration sends ripples through the wooden surface, causing the can to tremble erratically. It loses its balance and begins to topple in a slow-motion arc, its metal body catching the sharp flash of light from a single, cold-toned overhead light source. The can is deliberately dropped so that the top and its black plastic nozzle impact the surface first. Upon impact, the force instantly and decisively compresses the actuator, releasing a brief, explosive burst of fine, translucent aerosol mist that emanates from the nozzle in a rapidly expanding, conical plume. Each microdroplet in the spray is sharply defined, illuminated by the overhead light, briefly flickering against the dark, out-of-focus backdrop of the workshop before dissipating, creating a tense and highly detailed moment of cause and effect.", + "seed": 8650, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_4/index_8038_seed_8650_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.036283993255347015, + "vlm_logprob": -0.036283993255347015, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.036283993255347015, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, silver aluminum aerosol can with a matte finish and no label?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the can positioned upright on a dark, richly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the can topple over in a slow-motion arc after losing its balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the can impact the surface with its top and black plastic nozzle first, releasing a conical plume of translucent aerosol mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07062416523694992 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6956241130828857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07062416523694992, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07062416523694992, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09731176495552063, + 0.05568217858672142, + 0.04934236407279968, + 0.031474173069000244, + 0.036703046411275864, + 0.09179332107305527, + 0.4865199029445648, + 0.08144737035036087, + 0.03427973389625549, + 0.035446058958768845 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07062416523694992 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, silver aluminum aerosol can with a matte finish and no label?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the can positioned upright on a dark, richly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the can topple over in a slow-motion arc after losing its balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the can impact the surface with its top and black plastic nozzle first, releasing a conical plume of translucent aerosol mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012549009174108505 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387548923492432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012549009174108505, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012549009174108505, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10018069297075272, + 0.17446430027484894, + 0.26796501874923706, + 0.08264567703008652, + 0.0694006085395813, + 0.04434386268258095, + 0.02445506490767002, + 0.16425292193889618, + 0.039188202470541, + 0.033103663474321365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012549009174108505 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, silver aluminum aerosol can with a matte finish and no label?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the can positioned upright on a dark, richly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the can topple over in a slow-motion arc after losing its balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the can impact the surface with its top and black plastic nozzle first, releasing a conical plume of translucent aerosol mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006740925367921591 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006741046905518 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006740925367921591, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006740925367921591, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1784256547689438, + 0.09812553972005844, + 0.08551232516765594, + 0.07895210385322571, + 0.13155518472194672, + 0.046855438500642776, + 0.10043585300445557, + 0.10741011798381805, + 0.0529138520359993, + 0.11981382220983505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006740925367921591 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, silver aluminum aerosol can with a matte finish and no label?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the can positioned upright on a dark, richly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the can topple over in a slow-motion arc after losing its balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the can impact the surface with its top and black plastic nozzle first, releasing a conical plume of translucent aerosol mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012540768831968307 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387540817260742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012540768831968307, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012540768831968307, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07998128235340118, + 0.06287351995706558, + 0.09882427006959915, + 0.1041785404086113, + 0.06050518527626991, + 0.03581836074590683, + 0.12467159330844879, + 0.09667713940143585, + 0.10721080750226974, + 0.22925931215286255 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012540768831968307 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, silver aluminum aerosol can with a matte finish and no label?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the can positioned upright on a dark, richly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the can topple over in a slow-motion arc after losing its balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the can impact the surface with its top and black plastic nozzle first, releasing a conical plume of translucent aerosol mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07896509766578674 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578965187072754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07896509766578674, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07896509766578674, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12675246596336365, + 0.04270118847489357, + 0.11358840763568878, + 0.08254149556159973, + 0.03517612814903259, + 0.05375618487596512, + 0.24870683252811432, + 0.08816476911306381, + 0.029272839426994324, + 0.17933966219425201 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07896509766578674 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This static, eye-level extreme close-up, rendered with stark photorealism, captures a sleek, silver aluminum aerosol can, perfectly upright, on a dark, richly textured wooden surface. The can features a minimalist design, with a smooth matte finish, no label, and a simple black plastic nozzle on top. A sudden, subtle vibration sends ripples through the wooden surface, causing the can to tremble erratically. It loses its balance and begins to topple in a slow-motion arc, its metal body catching the sharp flash of light from a single, cold-toned overhead light source. The can is deliberately dropped so that the top and its black plastic nozzle impact the surface first. Upon impact, the force instantly and decisively compresses the actuator, releasing a brief, explosive burst of fine, translucent aerosol mist that emanates from the nozzle in a rapidly expanding, conical plume. Each microdroplet in the spray is sharply defined, illuminated by the overhead light, briefly flickering against the dark, out-of-focus backdrop of the workshop before dissipating, creating a tense and highly detailed moment of cause and effect.", + "seed": 8651, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_4/index_8038_seed_8651_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03708313778042793, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03708313778042793, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03708313778042793, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, silver aluminum aerosol can with a matte finish and no label?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the can positioned upright on a dark, richly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the can topple over in a slow-motion arc after losing its balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the can impact the surface with its top and black plastic nozzle first, releasing a conical plume of translucent aerosol mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07967327535152435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5796732902526855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07967327535152435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07967327535152435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18116290867328644, + 0.039016980677843094, + 0.030833518132567406, + 0.021393105387687683, + 0.05007513612508774, + 0.017659105360507965, + 0.4315364956855774, + 0.14074930548667908, + 0.0587538443505764, + 0.0288196112960577 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07967327535152435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, silver aluminum aerosol can with a matte finish and no label?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the can positioned upright on a dark, richly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the can topple over in a slow-motion arc after losing its balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the can impact the surface with its top and black plastic nozzle first, releasing a conical plume of translucent aerosol mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008647494949400425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758647441864014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008647494949400425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008647494949400425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12086497247219086, + 0.11517146974802017, + 0.1379549354314804, + 0.02495068870484829, + 0.04716556519269943, + 0.039850521832704544, + 0.33378905057907104, + 0.04569334164261818, + 0.10712119191884995, + 0.027438204735517502 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008647494949400425 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, silver aluminum aerosol can with a matte finish and no label?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the can positioned upright on a dark, richly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the can topple over in a slow-motion arc after losing its balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the can impact the surface with its top and black plastic nozzle first, releasing a conical plume of translucent aerosol mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028232974000275135 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877823352813721 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028232974000275135, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028232974000275135, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0900922417640686, + 0.04134942218661308, + 0.20804646611213684, + 0.24221555888652802, + 0.0887267142534256, + 0.07520319521427155, + 0.16994136571884155, + 0.0327092744410038, + 0.034577835351228714, + 0.017137877643108368 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028232974000275135 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, silver aluminum aerosol can with a matte finish and no label?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the can positioned upright on a dark, richly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the can topple over in a slow-motion arc after losing its balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the can impact the surface with its top and black plastic nozzle first, releasing a conical plume of translucent aerosol mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005254624877125025 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255254745483398 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005254624877125025, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005254624877125025, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10895819216966629, + 0.021987902000546455, + 0.10703418403863907, + 0.05149342864751816, + 0.11125089228153229, + 0.02980438433587551, + 0.2946135997772217, + 0.19537071883678436, + 0.03994973003864288, + 0.039537008851766586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005254624877125025 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, silver aluminum aerosol can with a matte finish and no label?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the can positioned upright on a dark, richly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the can topple over in a slow-motion arc after losing its balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the can impact the surface with its top and black plastic nozzle first, releasing a conical plume of translucent aerosol mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08901699632406235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464016914367676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08901699632406235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08901699632406235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18565033376216888, + 0.04395558685064316, + 0.08485043793916702, + 0.04119694232940674, + 0.0692913755774498, + 0.06517455726861954, + 0.19314785301685333, + 0.10375994443893433, + 0.1652308702468872, + 0.04774205759167671 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08901699632406235 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This static, eye-level extreme close-up, rendered with stark photorealism, captures a sleek, silver aluminum aerosol can, perfectly upright, on a dark, richly textured wooden surface. The can features a minimalist design, with a smooth matte finish, no label, and a simple black plastic nozzle on top. A sudden, subtle vibration sends ripples through the wooden surface, causing the can to tremble erratically. It loses its balance and begins to topple in a slow-motion arc, its metal body catching the sharp flash of light from a single, cold-toned overhead light source. The can is deliberately dropped so that the top and its black plastic nozzle impact the surface first. Upon impact, the force instantly and decisively compresses the actuator, releasing a brief, explosive burst of fine, translucent aerosol mist that emanates from the nozzle in a rapidly expanding, conical plume. Each microdroplet in the spray is sharply defined, illuminated by the overhead light, briefly flickering against the dark, out-of-focus backdrop of the workshop before dissipating, creating a tense and highly detailed moment of cause and effect.", + "seed": 8652, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_4/index_8038_seed_8652_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.049649626458995046, + "vlm_logprob": -0.049649626458995046, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.049649626458995046, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, silver aluminum aerosol can with a matte finish and no label?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the can positioned upright on a dark, richly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the can topple over in a slow-motion arc after losing its balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the can impact the surface with its top and black plastic nozzle first, releasing a conical plume of translucent aerosol mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08962785452604294 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464627742767334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08962785452604294, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08962785452604294, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.38754144310951233, + 0.0869172066450119, + 0.07891610264778137, + 0.09725707769393921, + 0.06036396697163582, + 0.08848301321268082, + 0.04456520080566406, + 0.05141286179423332, + 0.02775011584162712, + 0.07679295539855957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08962785452604294 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, silver aluminum aerosol can with a matte finish and no label?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the can positioned upright on a dark, richly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the can topple over in a slow-motion arc after losing its balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the can impact the surface with its top and black plastic nozzle first, releasing a conical plume of translucent aerosol mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009792149998247623 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634792327880859 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009792149998247623, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009792149998247623, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29562366008758545, + 0.06894798576831818, + 0.05332773178815842, + 0.23303399980068207, + 0.032045718282461166, + 0.09759998321533203, + 0.019230516627430916, + 0.018791748210787773, + 0.0762873962521553, + 0.10511120408773422 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009792149998247623 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, silver aluminum aerosol can with a matte finish and no label?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the can positioned upright on a dark, richly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the can topple over in a slow-motion arc after losing its balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the can impact the surface with its top and black plastic nozzle first, releasing a conical plume of translucent aerosol mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019463420612737536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251946449279785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019463420612737536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019463420612737536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1365898996591568, + 0.040472134947776794, + 0.10076989978551865, + 0.10405929386615753, + 0.05238909274339676, + 0.0983315259218216, + 0.050150323659181595, + 0.14739593863487244, + 0.1719401776790619, + 0.09790164977312088 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019463420612737536 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, silver aluminum aerosol can with a matte finish and no label?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the can positioned upright on a dark, richly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the can topple over in a slow-motion arc after losing its balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the can impact the surface with its top and black plastic nozzle first, releasing a conical plume of translucent aerosol mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004097756464034319 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504097938537598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004097756464034319, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004097756464034319, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08787653595209122, + 0.04520957171916962, + 0.0678199827671051, + 0.4330126941204071, + 0.04914071410894394, + 0.07676591724157333, + 0.03941701725125313, + 0.042537860572338104, + 0.07282193750143051, + 0.08539776504039764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004097756464034319 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, silver aluminum aerosol can with a matte finish and no label?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the can positioned upright on a dark, richly textured wooden surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the can topple over in a slow-motion arc after losing its balance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the can impact the surface with its top and black plastic nozzle first, releasing a conical plume of translucent aerosol mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up taken from an eye-level perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1427840292453766 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0177841186523438 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1427840292453766, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1427840292453766, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17777949571609497, + 0.05716292932629585, + 0.11012852936983109, + 0.15571175515651703, + 0.08944252133369446, + 0.12169305980205536, + 0.11356983333826065, + 0.039663493633270264, + 0.019344618543982506, + 0.11550380289554596 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1427840292453766 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_5/index_tensor([8318, 8318])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_5/index_tensor([8318, 8318])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..0e832ea1187ab109df6079ba8d8230f27459ecce --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_5/index_tensor([8318, 8318])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, top-down macro shot offers a bird's-eye view of the dense, miniature cityscape of a complex circuit board. Under the even, cool-white intensity of a clinical light source, the deep green substrate becomes a maze of gleaming copper paths, their metallic orange shimmering with mirrored highlights. This intricate network connects a variety of components: sleek black microchips, tiny cylindrical capacitors, and gleaming, perfectly round silver solder joints. Suddenly, the pristine order is shattered, a hairline crack suddenly appearing and violently tearing across the surface, forming a jagged, unstoppable line. The dark chasm spreads with catastrophic speed, relentlessly severing the fragile copper traces, which then break and peel away from the fracture as their conductive sheen vanishes. The action is swift and decisive, transforming the meticulously designed landscape into a scene of irreparable destruction, creating a tense and dramatic atmosphere of catastrophic failure within the silent, hyper-detailed imagery.", + "seed": 24608, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_5/index_8318_seed_24608_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03802065858617425, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03802065858617425, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03802065858617425, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static top-down macro shot providing a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dense miniature cityscape resembling a complex circuit board with a deep green substrate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are visible components including sleek black microchips, tiny cylindrical capacitors, and silver solder joints present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a hairline crack appear and violently tear across the surface, severing the copper traces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the copper traces break and peel away from the fracture as the crack spreads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10267432034015656 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3526742458343506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10267432034015656, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10267432034015656, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19657109677791595, + 0.13555501401424408, + 0.09461288899183273, + 0.1594034731388092, + 0.027896497398614883, + 0.03362276032567024, + 0.010612081736326218, + 0.03150951489806175, + 0.03373454883694649, + 0.2764821946620941 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10267432034015656 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static top-down macro shot providing a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dense miniature cityscape resembling a complex circuit board with a deep green substrate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are visible components including sleek black microchips, tiny cylindrical capacitors, and silver solder joints present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a hairline crack appear and violently tear across the surface, severing the copper traces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the copper traces break and peel away from the fracture as the crack spreads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003213957417756319 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753213882446289 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003213957417756319, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003213957417756319, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06521856039762497, + 0.6202700734138489, + 0.03288045898079872, + 0.024025989696383476, + 0.023426255211234093, + 0.023127447813749313, + 0.017637129873037338, + 0.033171672374010086, + 0.041104745119810104, + 0.1191377192735672 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003213957417756319 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static top-down macro shot providing a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dense miniature cityscape resembling a complex circuit board with a deep green substrate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are visible components including sleek black microchips, tiny cylindrical capacitors, and silver solder joints present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a hairline crack appear and violently tear across the surface, severing the copper traces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the copper traces break and peel away from the fracture as the crack spreads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011084172874689102 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511084079742432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011084172874689102, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011084172874689102, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20828264951705933, + 0.49823516607284546, + 0.06326587498188019, + 0.04378688707947731, + 0.020674459636211395, + 0.021722912788391113, + 0.01804226078093052, + 0.026992641389369965, + 0.0316346138715744, + 0.06736250966787338 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011084172874689102 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static top-down macro shot providing a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dense miniature cityscape resembling a complex circuit board with a deep green substrate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are visible components including sleek black microchips, tiny cylindrical capacitors, and silver solder joints present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a hairline crack appear and violently tear across the surface, severing the copper traces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the copper traces break and peel away from the fracture as the crack spreads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05494775250554085 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929947853088379 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05494775250554085, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05494775250554085, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09592694789171219, + 0.6821935772895813, + 0.03730868920683861, + 0.030020136386156082, + 0.032261401414871216, + 0.023656023666262627, + 0.029662569984793663, + 0.025864046066999435, + 0.027685895562171936, + 0.015420685522258282 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05494775250554085 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static top-down macro shot providing a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dense miniature cityscape resembling a complex circuit board with a deep green substrate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are visible components including sleek black microchips, tiny cylindrical capacitors, and silver solder joints present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a hairline crack appear and violently tear across the surface, severing the copper traces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the copper traces break and peel away from the fracture as the crack spreads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018183089792728424 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01818323135376 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018183089792728424, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018183089792728424, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05858893692493439, + 0.6153781414031982, + 0.0610315203666687, + 0.032573819160461426, + 0.03949935361742973, + 0.044405508786439896, + 0.034350164234638214, + 0.04814177379012108, + 0.044030413031578064, + 0.022000424563884735 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018183089792728424 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, top-down macro shot offers a bird's-eye view of the dense, miniature cityscape of a complex circuit board. Under the even, cool-white intensity of a clinical light source, the deep green substrate becomes a maze of gleaming copper paths, their metallic orange shimmering with mirrored highlights. This intricate network connects a variety of components: sleek black microchips, tiny cylindrical capacitors, and gleaming, perfectly round silver solder joints. Suddenly, the pristine order is shattered, a hairline crack suddenly appearing and violently tearing across the surface, forming a jagged, unstoppable line. The dark chasm spreads with catastrophic speed, relentlessly severing the fragile copper traces, which then break and peel away from the fracture as their conductive sheen vanishes. The action is swift and decisive, transforming the meticulously designed landscape into a scene of irreparable destruction, creating a tense and dramatic atmosphere of catastrophic failure within the silent, hyper-detailed imagery.", + "seed": 24609, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_5/index_8318_seed_24609_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.028778273356147112, + "vlm_logprob": -0.028778273356147112, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.028778273356147112, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static top-down macro shot providing a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dense miniature cityscape resembling a complex circuit board with a deep green substrate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are visible components including sleek black microchips, tiny cylindrical capacitors, and silver solder joints present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a hairline crack appear and violently tear across the surface, severing the copper traces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the copper traces break and peel away from the fracture as the crack spreads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016985539346933365 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1419854164123535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016985539346933365, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016985539346933365, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07922074943780899, + 0.09241218119859695, + 0.07608488947153091, + 0.03849031776189804, + 0.038382600992918015, + 0.20847129821777344, + 0.2426994889974594, + 0.06808175146579742, + 0.12644430994987488, + 0.029712436720728874 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016985539346933365 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static top-down macro shot providing a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dense miniature cityscape resembling a complex circuit board with a deep green substrate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are visible components including sleek black microchips, tiny cylindrical capacitors, and silver solder joints present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a hairline crack appear and violently tear across the surface, severing the copper traces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the copper traces break and peel away from the fracture as the crack spreads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002218644367530942 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127218723297119 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002218644367530942, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002218644367530942, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15911537408828735, + 0.1000078022480011, + 0.04743164777755737, + 0.12116935849189758, + 0.0278803501278162, + 0.09173152595758438, + 0.3048742413520813, + 0.04021383821964264, + 0.05725591257214546, + 0.0503198578953743 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002218644367530942 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static top-down macro shot providing a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dense miniature cityscape resembling a complex circuit board with a deep green substrate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are visible components including sleek black microchips, tiny cylindrical capacitors, and silver solder joints present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a hairline crack appear and violently tear across the surface, severing the copper traces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the copper traces break and peel away from the fracture as the crack spreads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019470559200271964 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251946926116943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019470559200271964, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019470559200271964, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10729175060987473, + 0.053908783942461014, + 0.06710466742515564, + 0.1867368072271347, + 0.034039512276649475, + 0.2628920376300812, + 0.13607171177864075, + 0.018272893503308296, + 0.05317055433988571, + 0.08051122725009918 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019470559200271964 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static top-down macro shot providing a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dense miniature cityscape resembling a complex circuit board with a deep green substrate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are visible components including sleek black microchips, tiny cylindrical capacitors, and silver solder joints present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a hairline crack appear and violently tear across the surface, severing the copper traces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the copper traces break and peel away from the fracture as the crack spreads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890389159321785 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464038848876953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0890389159321785, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0890389159321785, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1046035885810852, + 0.07328861206769943, + 0.06342167407274246, + 0.05010354891419411, + 0.06581766158342361, + 0.11066180467605591, + 0.2743775546550751, + 0.03937872126698494, + 0.1888754814863205, + 0.029471365734934807 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0890389159321785 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static top-down macro shot providing a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dense miniature cityscape resembling a complex circuit board with a deep green substrate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are visible components including sleek black microchips, tiny cylindrical capacitors, and silver solder joints present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a hairline crack appear and violently tear across the surface, severing the copper traces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the copper traces break and peel away from the fracture as the crack spreads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370121121406555 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408701181411743 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370121121406555, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370121121406555, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13071979582309723, + 0.08701513707637787, + 0.03834899887442589, + 0.06857352703809738, + 0.082027867436409, + 0.10227476805448532, + 0.23294173181056976, + 0.050965119153261185, + 0.1808161586523056, + 0.026316912844777107 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370121121406555 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, top-down macro shot offers a bird's-eye view of the dense, miniature cityscape of a complex circuit board. Under the even, cool-white intensity of a clinical light source, the deep green substrate becomes a maze of gleaming copper paths, their metallic orange shimmering with mirrored highlights. This intricate network connects a variety of components: sleek black microchips, tiny cylindrical capacitors, and gleaming, perfectly round silver solder joints. Suddenly, the pristine order is shattered, a hairline crack suddenly appearing and violently tearing across the surface, forming a jagged, unstoppable line. The dark chasm spreads with catastrophic speed, relentlessly severing the fragile copper traces, which then break and peel away from the fracture as their conductive sheen vanishes. The action is swift and decisive, transforming the meticulously designed landscape into a scene of irreparable destruction, creating a tense and dramatic atmosphere of catastrophic failure within the silent, hyper-detailed imagery.", + "seed": 24610, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_5/index_8318_seed_24610_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.033765833196230235, + "vlm_logprob": -0.033765833196230235, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.033765833196230235, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static top-down macro shot providing a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dense miniature cityscape resembling a complex circuit board with a deep green substrate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are visible components including sleek black microchips, tiny cylindrical capacitors, and silver solder joints present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a hairline crack appear and violently tear across the surface, severing the copper traces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the copper traces break and peel away from the fracture as the crack spreads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06369868665933609 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8136987686157227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06369868665933609, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06369868665933609, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10609720647335052, + 0.09392068535089493, + 0.12108923494815826, + 0.14789147675037384, + 0.11006806790828705, + 0.13707686960697174, + 0.06498908996582031, + 0.1173190325498581, + 0.07173522561788559, + 0.029813146218657494 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06369868665933609 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static top-down macro shot providing a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dense miniature cityscape resembling a complex circuit board with a deep green substrate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are visible components including sleek black microchips, tiny cylindrical capacitors, and silver solder joints present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a hairline crack appear and violently tear across the surface, severing the copper traces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the copper traces break and peel away from the fracture as the crack spreads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0041178204119205475 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504117965698242 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0041178204119205475, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0041178204119205475, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11739599704742432, + 0.13321296870708466, + 0.03265484422445297, + 0.21033364534378052, + 0.14894476532936096, + 0.12919838726520538, + 0.025478504598140717, + 0.044531967490911484, + 0.04796672612428665, + 0.11028225719928741 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0041178204119205475 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static top-down macro shot providing a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dense miniature cityscape resembling a complex circuit board with a deep green substrate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are visible components including sleek black microchips, tiny cylindrical capacitors, and silver solder joints present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a hairline crack appear and violently tear across the surface, severing the copper traces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the copper traces break and peel away from the fracture as the crack spreads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011843579122796655 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751184463500977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011843579122796655, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011843579122796655, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29917359352111816, + 0.057544536888599396, + 0.04168720915913582, + 0.19370588660240173, + 0.03208742290735245, + 0.06930658221244812, + 0.03368072211742401, + 0.04427865147590637, + 0.056624628603458405, + 0.17191079258918762 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011843579122796655 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static top-down macro shot providing a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dense miniature cityscape resembling a complex circuit board with a deep green substrate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are visible components including sleek black microchips, tiny cylindrical capacitors, and silver solder joints present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a hairline crack appear and violently tear across the surface, severing the copper traces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the copper traces break and peel away from the fracture as the crack spreads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002870738506317 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695028781890869 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002870738506317, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002870738506317, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07744189351797104, + 0.04875710979104042, + 0.07370170950889587, + 0.2326839119195938, + 0.04583871364593506, + 0.11972886323928833, + 0.036033228039741516, + 0.053815048187971115, + 0.11040616780519485, + 0.20159336924552917 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002870738506317 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static top-down macro shot providing a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dense miniature cityscape resembling a complex circuit board with a deep green substrate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are visible components including sleek black microchips, tiny cylindrical capacitors, and silver solder joints present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a hairline crack appear and violently tear across the surface, severing the copper traces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the copper traces break and peel away from the fracture as the crack spreads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02979959361255169 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529799699783325 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02979959361255169, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02979959361255169, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10118811577558517, + 0.06899459660053253, + 0.08149407058954239, + 0.09132423251867294, + 0.1321393996477127, + 0.150665283203125, + 0.02517712675035, + 0.02693486586213112, + 0.04789497330784798, + 0.2741873264312744 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02979959361255169 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, top-down macro shot offers a bird's-eye view of the dense, miniature cityscape of a complex circuit board. Under the even, cool-white intensity of a clinical light source, the deep green substrate becomes a maze of gleaming copper paths, their metallic orange shimmering with mirrored highlights. This intricate network connects a variety of components: sleek black microchips, tiny cylindrical capacitors, and gleaming, perfectly round silver solder joints. Suddenly, the pristine order is shattered, a hairline crack suddenly appearing and violently tearing across the surface, forming a jagged, unstoppable line. The dark chasm spreads with catastrophic speed, relentlessly severing the fragile copper traces, which then break and peel away from the fracture as their conductive sheen vanishes. The action is swift and decisive, transforming the meticulously designed landscape into a scene of irreparable destruction, creating a tense and dramatic atmosphere of catastrophic failure within the silent, hyper-detailed imagery.", + "seed": 24611, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_5/index_8318_seed_24611_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.02369290995411575, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02369290995411575, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02369290995411575, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static top-down macro shot providing a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dense miniature cityscape resembling a complex circuit board with a deep green substrate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are visible components including sleek black microchips, tiny cylindrical capacitors, and silver solder joints present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a hairline crack appear and violently tear across the surface, severing the copper traces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the copper traces break and peel away from the fracture as the crack spreads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020666852593421936 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.02066707611084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020666852593421936, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020666852593421936, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11234930157661438, + 0.07740452140569687, + 0.09539458155632019, + 0.039793070405721664, + 0.027162974700331688, + 0.1321379542350769, + 0.14404618740081787, + 0.2099529504776001, + 0.04319629818201065, + 0.11856214702129364 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020666852593421936 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static top-down macro shot providing a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dense miniature cityscape resembling a complex circuit board with a deep green substrate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are visible components including sleek black microchips, tiny cylindrical capacitors, and silver solder joints present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a hairline crack appear and violently tear across the surface, severing the copper traces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the copper traces break and peel away from the fracture as the crack spreads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019555033650249243 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251955509185791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019555033650249243, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019555033650249243, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3728463351726532, + 0.08091435581445694, + 0.06526821106672287, + 0.03551140055060387, + 0.06108077988028526, + 0.09256380796432495, + 0.10468170791864395, + 0.027868585661053658, + 0.07496451586484909, + 0.08430032432079315 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019555033650249243 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static top-down macro shot providing a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dense miniature cityscape resembling a complex circuit board with a deep green substrate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are visible components including sleek black microchips, tiny cylindrical capacitors, and silver solder joints present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a hairline crack appear and violently tear across the surface, severing the copper traces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the copper traces break and peel away from the fracture as the crack spreads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011084172874689102 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511084079742432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011084172874689102, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011084172874689102, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32525211572647095, + 0.04129774123430252, + 0.04021424800157547, + 0.043898820877075195, + 0.2429714947938919, + 0.047964368015527725, + 0.07018532603979111, + 0.0282544307410717, + 0.08321404457092285, + 0.07674741744995117 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011084172874689102 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static top-down macro shot providing a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dense miniature cityscape resembling a complex circuit board with a deep green substrate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are visible components including sleek black microchips, tiny cylindrical capacitors, and silver solder joints present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a hairline crack appear and violently tear across the surface, severing the copper traces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the copper traces break and peel away from the fracture as the crack spreads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495565012097359 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299557209014893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495565012097359, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495565012097359, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17397475242614746, + 0.10422541201114655, + 0.045779842883348465, + 0.0478847362101078, + 0.051442623138427734, + 0.09546931087970734, + 0.2536492645740509, + 0.029590170830488205, + 0.07830456644296646, + 0.11967930197715759 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495565012097359 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle a static top-down macro shot providing a bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene a dense miniature cityscape resembling a complex circuit board with a deep green substrate?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are visible components including sleek black microchips, tiny cylindrical capacitors, and silver solder joints present?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a hairline crack appear and violently tear across the surface, severing the copper traces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the copper traces break and peel away from the fracture as the crack spreads?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029802370816469193 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298023223876953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029802370816469193, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029802370816469193, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11727238446474075, + 0.06550095230340958, + 0.07569685578346252, + 0.06145801767706871, + 0.03424723818898201, + 0.17824099957942963, + 0.27168700098991394, + 0.03694133087992668, + 0.03980694338679314, + 0.11914826929569244 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029802370816469193 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_6/index_tensor([2453, 2453])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_6/index_tensor([2453, 2453])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..107ec71d9b62821e011fd3382584eef2459b4979 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_6/index_tensor([2453, 2453])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "sweeping, high-angle drone shot slowly slices across a whimsical cityscape, rendered in a vibrant, Pixar-esque style. The first rays of early morning sunlight bathe the scene in a warm golden glow, casting long, softly edged purple shadows that stretch dramatically across the clean cobblestone streets and buildings. The architecture is playful and imaginative, with rounded shapes and exaggerated proportions painted in a vibrant palette of soft pink, sunny yellow, and sky blue, featuring oversized windows and whimsical spiral roofs. Thick plumes of white steam billow upward from circular manhole covers and roof vents with remarkably smooth clarity. The steam's movement is captured in surreal detail, swirling and curling in intricate, elegant patterns caught in the morning light, appearing almost luminous before gently dissipating into the cool, crisp air, creating an atmosphere of magical tranquility. The city is just beginning to wake up.", + "seed": 3913, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_6/index_2453_seed_3913_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07144206191878766, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07144206191878766, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07144206191878766, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle drone shot that slices across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in a vibrant, Pixar-esque style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings and streets painted in a palette of soft pink, sunny yellow, and sky blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do thick plumes of white steam billow upward from circular manhole covers and roof vents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature long, softly edged purple shadows cast by early morning sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1276801973581314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1276803016662598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1276801973581314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1276801973581314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18102708458900452, + 0.07985945045948029, + 0.08744002133607864, + 0.0964197963476181, + 0.2184358388185501, + 0.11903657019138336, + 0.03004848212003708, + 0.09472381323575974, + 0.07450000941753387, + 0.018509000539779663 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1276801973581314 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle drone shot that slices across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in a vibrant, Pixar-esque style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings and streets painted in a palette of soft pink, sunny yellow, and sky blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do thick plumes of white steam billow upward from circular manhole covers and roof vents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature long, softly edged purple shadows cast by early morning sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012542887590825558 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387542724609375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012542887590825558, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012542887590825558, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14944805204868317, + 0.14974480867385864, + 0.1964585781097412, + 0.07405423372983932, + 0.07989483326673508, + 0.10577577352523804, + 0.07398027926683426, + 0.08690184354782104, + 0.05389072000980377, + 0.02985094115138054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012542887590825558 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle drone shot that slices across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in a vibrant, Pixar-esque style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings and streets painted in a palette of soft pink, sunny yellow, and sky blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do thick plumes of white steam billow upward from circular manhole covers and roof vents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature long, softly edged purple shadows cast by early morning sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017137139802798629 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376713752746582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017137139802798629, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017137139802798629, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11220228672027588, + 0.08553604781627655, + 0.15525105595588684, + 0.06028704345226288, + 0.15912066400051117, + 0.07157797366380692, + 0.08010520786046982, + 0.14802893996238708, + 0.09390415996313095, + 0.03398667275905609 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017137139802798629 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle drone shot that slices across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in a vibrant, Pixar-esque style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings and streets painted in a palette of soft pink, sunny yellow, and sky blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do thick plumes of white steam billow upward from circular manhole covers and roof vents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature long, softly edged purple shadows cast by early morning sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054944705218076706 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299447536468506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054944705218076706, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054944705218076706, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21544791758060455, + 0.12292710691690445, + 0.0998469740152359, + 0.03499250113964081, + 0.07271544635295868, + 0.07532761991024017, + 0.09359613060951233, + 0.15827789902687073, + 0.09444309771060944, + 0.03242527320981026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054944705218076706 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle drone shot that slices across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in a vibrant, Pixar-esque style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings and streets painted in a palette of soft pink, sunny yellow, and sky blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do thick plumes of white steam billow upward from circular manhole covers and roof vents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature long, softly edged purple shadows cast by early morning sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16032880544662476 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103288650512695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16032880544662476, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16032880544662476, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2725542187690735, + 0.10637585818767548, + 0.07693494111299515, + 0.09002801030874252, + 0.2012394219636917, + 0.0687776729464531, + 0.0398617684841156, + 0.05176536366343498, + 0.03754330798983574, + 0.05491942912340164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16032880544662476 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping, high-angle drone shot slowly slices across a whimsical cityscape, rendered in a vibrant, Pixar-esque style. The first rays of early morning sunlight bathe the scene in a warm golden glow, casting long, softly edged purple shadows that stretch dramatically across the clean cobblestone streets and buildings. The architecture is playful and imaginative, with rounded shapes and exaggerated proportions painted in a vibrant palette of soft pink, sunny yellow, and sky blue, featuring oversized windows and whimsical spiral roofs. Thick plumes of white steam billow upward from circular manhole covers and roof vents with remarkably smooth clarity. The steam's movement is captured in surreal detail, swirling and curling in intricate, elegant patterns caught in the morning light, appearing almost luminous before gently dissipating into the cool, crisp air, creating an atmosphere of magical tranquility. The city is just beginning to wake up.", + "seed": 3914, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_6/index_2453_seed_3914_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07662615654990076, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07662615654990076, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07662615654990076, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle drone shot that slices across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in a vibrant, Pixar-esque style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings and streets painted in a palette of soft pink, sunny yellow, and sky blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do thick plumes of white steam billow upward from circular manhole covers and roof vents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature long, softly edged purple shadows cast by early morning sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08023276180028915 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.580232858657837 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08023276180028915, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08023276180028915, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.190311998128891, + 0.05600910261273384, + 0.05326276645064354, + 0.09818898141384125, + 0.08686408400535583, + 0.09450852870941162, + 0.14649558067321777, + 0.08708038926124573, + 0.0992003083229065, + 0.08807815611362457 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08023276180028915 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle drone shot that slices across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in a vibrant, Pixar-esque style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings and streets painted in a palette of soft pink, sunny yellow, and sky blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do thick plumes of white steam billow upward from circular manhole covers and roof vents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature long, softly edged purple shadows cast by early morning sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809947893023491 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288099527359009 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809947893023491, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809947893023491, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10979651659727097, + 0.18447604775428772, + 0.21946671605110168, + 0.11910801380872726, + 0.051943790167570114, + 0.040588513016700745, + 0.046191561967134476, + 0.03796996921300888, + 0.06863903254270554, + 0.12181980162858963 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809947893023491 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle drone shot that slices across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in a vibrant, Pixar-esque style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings and streets painted in a palette of soft pink, sunny yellow, and sky blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do thick plumes of white steam billow upward from circular manhole covers and roof vents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature long, softly edged purple shadows cast by early morning sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004097756464034319 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504097938537598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004097756464034319, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004097756464034319, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14159485697746277, + 0.06476277858018875, + 0.13433612883090973, + 0.18990544974803925, + 0.08425707370042801, + 0.051507458090782166, + 0.10198432207107544, + 0.04693347215652466, + 0.04955087974667549, + 0.13516759872436523 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004097756464034319 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle drone shot that slices across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in a vibrant, Pixar-esque style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings and streets painted in a palette of soft pink, sunny yellow, and sky blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do thick plumes of white steam billow upward from circular manhole covers and roof vents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature long, softly edged purple shadows cast by early morning sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00863721314817667 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758637428283691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00863721314817667, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00863721314817667, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.026522133499383926, + 0.029199112206697464, + 0.043013524264097214, + 0.4274977147579193, + 0.0347745344042778, + 0.11750859767198563, + 0.1351330727338791, + 0.07223839312791824, + 0.08323141187429428, + 0.030881498008966446 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00863721314817667 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle drone shot that slices across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in a vibrant, Pixar-esque style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings and streets painted in a palette of soft pink, sunny yellow, and sky blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do thick plumes of white steam billow upward from circular manhole covers and roof vents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature long, softly edged purple shadows cast by early morning sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520635724067688 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502063512802124 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520635724067688, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520635724067688, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1368987262248993, + 0.10300411283969879, + 0.11417491734027863, + 0.10303335636854172, + 0.08192580193281174, + 0.23268701136112213, + 0.036428242921829224, + 0.054898981004953384, + 0.0689460039138794, + 0.0680028423666954 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520635724067688 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping, high-angle drone shot slowly slices across a whimsical cityscape, rendered in a vibrant, Pixar-esque style. The first rays of early morning sunlight bathe the scene in a warm golden glow, casting long, softly edged purple shadows that stretch dramatically across the clean cobblestone streets and buildings. The architecture is playful and imaginative, with rounded shapes and exaggerated proportions painted in a vibrant palette of soft pink, sunny yellow, and sky blue, featuring oversized windows and whimsical spiral roofs. Thick plumes of white steam billow upward from circular manhole covers and roof vents with remarkably smooth clarity. The steam's movement is captured in surreal detail, swirling and curling in intricate, elegant patterns caught in the morning light, appearing almost luminous before gently dissipating into the cool, crisp air, creating an atmosphere of magical tranquility. The city is just beginning to wake up.", + "seed": 3915, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_6/index_2453_seed_3915_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.16760310484096408, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16760310484096408, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16760310484096408, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle drone shot that slices across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in a vibrant, Pixar-esque style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings and streets painted in a palette of soft pink, sunny yellow, and sky blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do thick plumes of white steam billow upward from circular manhole covers and roof vents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature long, softly edged purple shadows cast by early morning sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3496769964694977 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2246769666671753 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3496769964694977, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3496769964694977, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5813368558883667, + 0.08661631494760513, + 0.0387859046459198, + 0.05127763748168945, + 0.11364702135324478, + 0.029990432783961296, + 0.011437827721238136, + 0.029181677848100662, + 0.016736449673771858, + 0.04098992049694061 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3496769964694977 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle drone shot that slices across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in a vibrant, Pixar-esque style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings and streets painted in a palette of soft pink, sunny yellow, and sky blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do thick plumes of white steam billow upward from circular manhole covers and roof vents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature long, softly edged purple shadows cast by early morning sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062058255076408386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812058210372925 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062058255076408386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062058255076408386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5114462375640869, + 0.047767236828804016, + 0.04805537313222885, + 0.03217950463294983, + 0.14130504429340363, + 0.023180868476629257, + 0.03538829833269119, + 0.0946633368730545, + 0.044870324432849884, + 0.02114374376833439 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062058255076408386 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle drone shot that slices across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in a vibrant, Pixar-esque style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings and streets painted in a palette of soft pink, sunny yellow, and sky blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do thick plumes of white steam billow upward from circular manhole covers and roof vents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature long, softly edged purple shadows cast by early morning sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007631433662027121 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882631301879883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007631433662027121, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007631433662027121, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5785633325576782, + 0.2178763598203659, + 0.0078102764673531055, + 0.01806904934346676, + 0.04030918329954147, + 0.017987370491027832, + 0.02622390165925026, + 0.02101469784975052, + 0.025973163545131683, + 0.04617270827293396 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007631433662027121 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle drone shot that slices across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in a vibrant, Pixar-esque style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings and streets painted in a palette of soft pink, sunny yellow, and sky blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do thick plumes of white steam billow upward from circular manhole covers and roof vents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature long, softly edged purple shadows cast by early morning sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002481818199158 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950247287750244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002481818199158, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002481818199158, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.44463229179382324, + 0.10883672535419464, + 0.03310777619481087, + 0.0861445888876915, + 0.07403115928173065, + 0.024454491212964058, + 0.029830502346158028, + 0.0489392913877964, + 0.019713087007403374, + 0.1303100436925888 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002481818199158 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle drone shot that slices across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in a vibrant, Pixar-esque style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings and streets painted in a palette of soft pink, sunny yellow, and sky blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do thick plumes of white steam billow upward from circular manhole covers and roof vents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature long, softly edged purple shadows cast by early morning sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34862402081489563 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236239910125732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34862402081489563, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34862402081489563, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3507236838340759, + 0.03294761851429939, + 0.027863001450896263, + 0.1029285192489624, + 0.1243266761302948, + 0.03681980445981026, + 0.0676548033952713, + 0.12284183502197266, + 0.054463792592287064, + 0.0794302374124527 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34862402081489563 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping, high-angle drone shot slowly slices across a whimsical cityscape, rendered in a vibrant, Pixar-esque style. The first rays of early morning sunlight bathe the scene in a warm golden glow, casting long, softly edged purple shadows that stretch dramatically across the clean cobblestone streets and buildings. The architecture is playful and imaginative, with rounded shapes and exaggerated proportions painted in a vibrant palette of soft pink, sunny yellow, and sky blue, featuring oversized windows and whimsical spiral roofs. Thick plumes of white steam billow upward from circular manhole covers and roof vents with remarkably smooth clarity. The steam's movement is captured in surreal detail, swirling and curling in intricate, elegant patterns caught in the morning light, appearing almost luminous before gently dissipating into the cool, crisp air, creating an atmosphere of magical tranquility. The city is just beginning to wake up.", + "seed": 3916, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_6/index_2453_seed_3916_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.05701298215426505, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05701298215426505, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05701298215426505, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle drone shot that slices across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in a vibrant, Pixar-esque style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings and streets painted in a palette of soft pink, sunny yellow, and sky blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do thick plumes of white steam billow upward from circular manhole covers and roof vents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature long, softly edged purple shadows cast by early morning sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18183590471744537 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8068358898162842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18183590471744537, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18183590471744537, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.458755761384964, + 0.10103601962327957, + 0.07220277935266495, + 0.05459161475300789, + 0.0902135893702507, + 0.0914289727807045, + 0.01629434898495674, + 0.02617613784968853, + 0.028541337698698044, + 0.06075936183333397 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18183590471744537 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle drone shot that slices across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in a vibrant, Pixar-esque style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings and streets painted in a palette of soft pink, sunny yellow, and sky blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do thick plumes of white steam billow upward from circular manhole covers and roof vents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature long, softly edged purple shadows cast by early morning sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012547126039862633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387547016143799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012547126039862633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012547126039862633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4941052794456482, + 0.04136459901928902, + 0.02678314596414566, + 0.03438558429479599, + 0.06511949002742767, + 0.15072140097618103, + 0.01347762905061245, + 0.021185433492064476, + 0.06774042546749115, + 0.08511704206466675 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012547126039862633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle drone shot that slices across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in a vibrant, Pixar-esque style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings and streets painted in a palette of soft pink, sunny yellow, and sky blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do thick plumes of white steam billow upward from circular manhole covers and roof vents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature long, softly edged purple shadows cast by early morning sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024927754420787096 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002492904663086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024927754420787096, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024927754420787096, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3328768312931061, + 0.10753392428159714, + 0.05020318180322647, + 0.05217880755662918, + 0.030037371441721916, + 0.13299351930618286, + 0.02474186010658741, + 0.05932936817407608, + 0.0769074484705925, + 0.13319778442382812 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024927754420787096 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle drone shot that slices across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in a vibrant, Pixar-esque style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings and streets painted in a palette of soft pink, sunny yellow, and sky blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do thick plumes of white steam billow upward from circular manhole covers and roof vents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature long, softly edged purple shadows cast by early morning sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818707026541233 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187046051025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818707026541233, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818707026541233, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07762385904788971, + 0.2501973509788513, + 0.08791699260473251, + 0.06578319519758224, + 0.12903182208538055, + 0.14151285588741302, + 0.03644035756587982, + 0.03381277620792389, + 0.04256877675652504, + 0.1351119726896286 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818707026541233 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a high-angle drone shot that slices across the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style rendered in a vibrant, Pixar-esque style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the buildings and streets painted in a palette of soft pink, sunny yellow, and sky blue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do thick plumes of white steam billow upward from circular manhole covers and roof vents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature long, softly edged purple shadows cast by early morning sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000203430652618 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950020790100098 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000203430652618, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000203430652618, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11296771466732025, + 0.05210838094353676, + 0.05489666014909744, + 0.03018934652209282, + 0.040330205112695694, + 0.10715640336275101, + 0.009507796727120876, + 0.03371509537100792, + 0.14170585572719574, + 0.4174225926399231 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000203430652618 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_7/index_tensor([389, 389])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_7/index_tensor([389, 389])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8a64298575d8b9c7dd03acfc6abaa54c74911fa0 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_7/index_tensor([389, 389])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "shot shot entirely from a first-person perspective places the viewer in a dark, uncharted realm of fantasy and fantasy. Directly in front of them, an ancient bronze box engraved with flowing runes hovers in the void. The box's surface, mottled with the patina of age, has a deep, bluish-brown hue. Yet, countless intricate runes inscribed within it radiate an uncanny, luminous golden light, like living veins of energy, slowly flowing across the bronze surface. As I watch, the bronze box begins to spin in a steady, deliberate rhythm, slowly and irresistibly, drawn by an invisible force into a bottomless, chaotic vortex of light behind it. That vortex is a chaotic maelstrom of deep purple, ominous indigo, and raging magenta. It churns silently, devouring all surrounding light, except for the runic light on the box, which is pulled and twisted into thin strands as it approaches. As the box sank deeper and deeper, the main light source of the entire picture gradually changed from the warm gold of the runes to the cold and grotesque colorful light emitted by the vortex, casting distorted and changing shadows at the edge of my vision, creating a grand, mysterious, yet awe-inspiring sense of oppression, as if I was the only witness to an ancient ritual that was incomprehensible to mortals.", + "seed": 31813, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_7/index_389_seed_31813_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0658442116342485, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0658442116342485, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0658442116342485, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective placing the viewer directly in front of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze box engraved with flowing runes visible hovering in the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box have a deep bluish-brown hue with a mottled patina of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box spin in a steady rhythm while being pulled into a chaotic vortex of deep purple, indigo, and magenta light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows at the edge of the vision change from warm gold to cold, grotesque colors as the box sinks into the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16416288912296295 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9141628742218018 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16416288912296295, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16416288912296295, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19079498946666718, + 0.13218674063682556, + 0.053449977189302444, + 0.03224113583564758, + 0.027004754170775414, + 0.07081767916679382, + 0.04877129942178726, + 0.03298051655292511, + 0.3922034502029419, + 0.019549353048205376 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16416288912296295 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective placing the viewer directly in front of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze box engraved with flowing runes visible hovering in the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box have a deep bluish-brown hue with a mottled patina of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box spin in a steady rhythm while being pulled into a chaotic vortex of deep purple, indigo, and magenta light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows at the edge of the vision change from warm gold to cold, grotesque colors as the box sinks into the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004149258136749 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950414180755615 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004149258136749, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004149258136749, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29756486415863037, + 0.12797445058822632, + 0.09790307283401489, + 0.03705499321222305, + 0.05739476904273033, + 0.2030191570520401, + 0.02585178054869175, + 0.03135879337787628, + 0.0718880146741867, + 0.04999018460512161 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004149258136749 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective placing the viewer directly in front of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze box engraved with flowing runes visible hovering in the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box have a deep bluish-brown hue with a mottled patina of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box spin in a steady rhythm while being pulled into a chaotic vortex of deep purple, indigo, and magenta light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows at the edge of the vision change from warm gold to cold, grotesque colors as the box sinks into the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07001636922359467 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695016384124756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07001636922359467, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07001636922359467, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26333165168762207, + 0.13953794538974762, + 0.12483207881450653, + 0.054197851568460464, + 0.039886534214019775, + 0.17782564461231232, + 0.0523468442261219, + 0.0420934334397316, + 0.08152450621128082, + 0.02442348562180996 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07001636922359467 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective placing the viewer directly in front of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze box engraved with flowing runes visible hovering in the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box have a deep bluish-brown hue with a mottled patina of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box spin in a steady rhythm while being pulled into a chaotic vortex of deep purple, indigo, and magenta light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows at the edge of the vision change from warm gold to cold, grotesque colors as the box sinks into the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001715261023491621 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376715183258057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001715261023491621, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001715261023491621, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12178143858909607, + 0.13697533309459686, + 0.08138563483953476, + 0.04280388355255127, + 0.06122593954205513, + 0.19507864117622375, + 0.034096237272024155, + 0.054321322590112686, + 0.24406258761882782, + 0.028268985450267792 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001715261023491621 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective placing the viewer directly in front of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze box engraved with flowing runes visible hovering in the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box have a deep bluish-brown hue with a mottled patina of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box spin in a steady rhythm while being pulled into a chaotic vortex of deep purple, indigo, and magenta light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows at the edge of the vision change from warm gold to cold, grotesque colors as the box sinks into the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023285046219825745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773285150527954 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023285046219825745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023285046219825745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23553866147994995, + 0.08294250816106796, + 0.2036871612071991, + 0.08237891644239426, + 0.03650644049048424, + 0.1300840973854065, + 0.06318146735429764, + 0.0536019466817379, + 0.0894799530506134, + 0.0225988682359457 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023285046219825745 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shot shot entirely from a first-person perspective places the viewer in a dark, uncharted realm of fantasy and fantasy. Directly in front of them, an ancient bronze box engraved with flowing runes hovers in the void. The box's surface, mottled with the patina of age, has a deep, bluish-brown hue. Yet, countless intricate runes inscribed within it radiate an uncanny, luminous golden light, like living veins of energy, slowly flowing across the bronze surface. As I watch, the bronze box begins to spin in a steady, deliberate rhythm, slowly and irresistibly, drawn by an invisible force into a bottomless, chaotic vortex of light behind it. That vortex is a chaotic maelstrom of deep purple, ominous indigo, and raging magenta. It churns silently, devouring all surrounding light, except for the runic light on the box, which is pulled and twisted into thin strands as it approaches. As the box sank deeper and deeper, the main light source of the entire picture gradually changed from the warm gold of the runes to the cold and grotesque colorful light emitted by the vortex, casting distorted and changing shadows at the edge of my vision, creating a grand, mysterious, yet awe-inspiring sense of oppression, as if I was the only witness to an ancient ritual that was incomprehensible to mortals.", + "seed": 31814, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_7/index_389_seed_31814_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04241136205382645, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04241136205382645, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04241136205382645, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective placing the viewer directly in front of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze box engraved with flowing runes visible hovering in the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box have a deep bluish-brown hue with a mottled patina of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box spin in a steady rhythm while being pulled into a chaotic vortex of deep purple, indigo, and magenta light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows at the edge of the vision change from warm gold to cold, grotesque colors as the box sinks into the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14709824323654175 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0220983028411865 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14709824323654175, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14709824323654175, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19191129505634308, + 0.054760608822107315, + 0.06850791722536087, + 0.022166837006807327, + 0.039131492376327515, + 0.04886610060930252, + 0.3908693194389343, + 0.07497317343950272, + 0.07261870056390762, + 0.03619455173611641 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14709824323654175 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective placing the viewer directly in front of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze box engraved with flowing runes visible hovering in the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box have a deep bluish-brown hue with a mottled patina of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box spin in a steady rhythm while being pulled into a chaotic vortex of deep purple, indigo, and magenta light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows at the edge of the vision change from warm gold to cold, grotesque colors as the box sinks into the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004104642663151026 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5041046142578125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004104642663151026, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004104642663151026, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09508742392063141, + 0.08090565353631973, + 0.033366020768880844, + 0.03669179603457451, + 0.012944210320711136, + 0.05035341903567314, + 0.5679003000259399, + 0.07641173154115677, + 0.03537830337882042, + 0.010961120948195457 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004104642663151026 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective placing the viewer directly in front of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze box engraved with flowing runes visible hovering in the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box have a deep bluish-brown hue with a mottled patina of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box spin in a steady rhythm while being pulled into a chaotic vortex of deep purple, indigo, and magenta light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows at the edge of the vision change from warm gold to cold, grotesque colors as the box sinks into the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014187660999596119 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264187812805176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014187660999596119, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014187660999596119, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08726958930492401, + 0.14302508533000946, + 0.09151531010866165, + 0.03085220418870449, + 0.04007994383573532, + 0.15805061161518097, + 0.33644914627075195, + 0.049048181623220444, + 0.03485271334648132, + 0.028857257217168808 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014187660999596119 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective placing the viewer directly in front of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze box engraved with flowing runes visible hovering in the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box have a deep bluish-brown hue with a mottled patina of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box spin in a steady rhythm while being pulled into a chaotic vortex of deep purple, indigo, and magenta light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows at the edge of the vision change from warm gold to cold, grotesque colors as the box sinks into the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036162238102406263 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.6286163330078125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036162238102406263, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036162238102406263, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1417998969554901, + 0.09086346626281738, + 0.14145776629447937, + 0.02659306675195694, + 0.025841092690825462, + 0.040382660925388336, + 0.36039867997169495, + 0.03813984617590904, + 0.055868253111839294, + 0.07865525037050247 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036162238102406263 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective placing the viewer directly in front of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze box engraved with flowing runes visible hovering in the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box have a deep bluish-brown hue with a mottled patina of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box spin in a steady rhythm while being pulled into a chaotic vortex of deep purple, indigo, and magenta light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows at the edge of the vision change from warm gold to cold, grotesque colors as the box sinks into the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305003955960274 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680500507354736 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305003955960274, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305003955960274, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07903091609477997, + 0.09440912306308746, + 0.05227410048246384, + 0.018802432343363762, + 0.016920067369937897, + 0.03130759671330452, + 0.5828334093093872, + 0.05382582172751427, + 0.03082239255309105, + 0.03977413848042488 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305003955960274 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shot shot entirely from a first-person perspective places the viewer in a dark, uncharted realm of fantasy and fantasy. Directly in front of them, an ancient bronze box engraved with flowing runes hovers in the void. The box's surface, mottled with the patina of age, has a deep, bluish-brown hue. Yet, countless intricate runes inscribed within it radiate an uncanny, luminous golden light, like living veins of energy, slowly flowing across the bronze surface. As I watch, the bronze box begins to spin in a steady, deliberate rhythm, slowly and irresistibly, drawn by an invisible force into a bottomless, chaotic vortex of light behind it. That vortex is a chaotic maelstrom of deep purple, ominous indigo, and raging magenta. It churns silently, devouring all surrounding light, except for the runic light on the box, which is pulled and twisted into thin strands as it approaches. As the box sank deeper and deeper, the main light source of the entire picture gradually changed from the warm gold of the runes to the cold and grotesque colorful light emitted by the vortex, casting distorted and changing shadows at the edge of my vision, creating a grand, mysterious, yet awe-inspiring sense of oppression, as if I was the only witness to an ancient ritual that was incomprehensible to mortals.", + "seed": 31815, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_7/index_389_seed_31815_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06433323943056166, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06433323943056166, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06433323943056166, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective placing the viewer directly in front of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze box engraved with flowing runes visible hovering in the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box have a deep bluish-brown hue with a mottled patina of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box spin in a steady rhythm while being pulled into a chaotic vortex of deep purple, indigo, and magenta light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows at the edge of the vision change from warm gold to cold, grotesque colors as the box sinks into the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.13088864088058472 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1308887004852295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.13088864088058472, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.13088864088058472, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2168450504541397, + 0.13827073574066162, + 0.1715906858444214, + 0.1011732742190361, + 0.04471422731876373, + 0.05267452448606491, + 0.0802745446562767, + 0.05223027616739273, + 0.03150544688105583, + 0.11072123795747757 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.13088864088058472 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective placing the viewer directly in front of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze box engraved with flowing runes visible hovering in the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box have a deep bluish-brown hue with a mottled patina of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box spin in a steady rhythm while being pulled into a chaotic vortex of deep purple, indigo, and magenta light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows at the edge of the vision change from warm gold to cold, grotesque colors as the box sinks into the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11295885592699051 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379589080810547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11295885592699051, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11295885592699051, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25290194153785706, + 0.05098350718617439, + 0.13923126459121704, + 0.11452218145132065, + 0.04862925037741661, + 0.04021726921200752, + 0.08362407237291336, + 0.06892605125904083, + 0.10576651990413666, + 0.09519792348146439 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11295885592699051 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective placing the viewer directly in front of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze box engraved with flowing runes visible hovering in the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box have a deep bluish-brown hue with a mottled patina of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box spin in a steady rhythm while being pulled into a chaotic vortex of deep purple, indigo, and magenta light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows at the edge of the vision change from warm gold to cold, grotesque colors as the box sinks into the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865682125091553 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048656940460205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865682125091553, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865682125091553, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.296142041683197, + 0.050025954842567444, + 0.14958207309246063, + 0.07602754235267639, + 0.10907392203807831, + 0.06100212782621384, + 0.039118967950344086, + 0.04614625126123428, + 0.0755370706319809, + 0.09734407067298889 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865682125091553 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective placing the viewer directly in front of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze box engraved with flowing runes visible hovering in the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box have a deep bluish-brown hue with a mottled patina of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box spin in a steady rhythm while being pulled into a chaotic vortex of deep purple, indigo, and magenta light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows at the edge of the vision change from warm gold to cold, grotesque colors as the box sinks into the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028204445261508226 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778204917907715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028204445261508226, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028204445261508226, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17251203954219818, + 0.17896680533885956, + 0.09482672810554504, + 0.07672890275716782, + 0.051632110029459, + 0.08077472448348999, + 0.1460343599319458, + 0.08767135441303253, + 0.0407169945538044, + 0.07013598829507828 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028204445261508226 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective placing the viewer directly in front of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze box engraved with flowing runes visible hovering in the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box have a deep bluish-brown hue with a mottled patina of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box spin in a steady rhythm while being pulled into a chaotic vortex of deep purple, indigo, and magenta light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows at the edge of the vision change from warm gold to cold, grotesque colors as the box sinks into the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026341434568166733 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651341438293457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026341434568166733, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026341434568166733, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21395190060138702, + 0.09760791063308716, + 0.10146758705377579, + 0.22013936936855316, + 0.039075080305337906, + 0.09754680842161179, + 0.03414490818977356, + 0.03502008318901062, + 0.03978007286787033, + 0.12126629054546356 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026341434568166733 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shot shot entirely from a first-person perspective places the viewer in a dark, uncharted realm of fantasy and fantasy. Directly in front of them, an ancient bronze box engraved with flowing runes hovers in the void. The box's surface, mottled with the patina of age, has a deep, bluish-brown hue. Yet, countless intricate runes inscribed within it radiate an uncanny, luminous golden light, like living veins of energy, slowly flowing across the bronze surface. As I watch, the bronze box begins to spin in a steady, deliberate rhythm, slowly and irresistibly, drawn by an invisible force into a bottomless, chaotic vortex of light behind it. That vortex is a chaotic maelstrom of deep purple, ominous indigo, and raging magenta. It churns silently, devouring all surrounding light, except for the runic light on the box, which is pulled and twisted into thin strands as it approaches. As the box sank deeper and deeper, the main light source of the entire picture gradually changed from the warm gold of the runes to the cold and grotesque colorful light emitted by the vortex, casting distorted and changing shadows at the edge of my vision, creating a grand, mysterious, yet awe-inspiring sense of oppression, as if I was the only witness to an ancient ritual that was incomprehensible to mortals.", + "seed": 31816, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_7/index_389_seed_31816_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0971674277447164, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0971674277447164, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.774999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0971674277447164, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective placing the viewer directly in front of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze box engraved with flowing runes visible hovering in the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box have a deep bluish-brown hue with a mottled patina of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box spin in a steady rhythm while being pulled into a chaotic vortex of deep purple, indigo, and magenta light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows at the edge of the vision change from warm gold to cold, grotesque colors as the box sinks into the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18521617352962494 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8102161884307861 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18521617352962494, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18521617352962494, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08377140015363693, + 0.1577768474817276, + 0.09103807061910629, + 0.07516807317733765, + 0.06686308234930038, + 0.05092988535761833, + 0.15651173889636993, + 0.0845855101943016, + 0.15851403772830963, + 0.07484143227338791 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18521617352962494 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective placing the viewer directly in front of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze box engraved with flowing runes visible hovering in the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box have a deep bluish-brown hue with a mottled patina of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box spin in a steady rhythm while being pulled into a chaotic vortex of deep purple, indigo, and magenta light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows at the edge of the vision change from warm gold to cold, grotesque colors as the box sinks into the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14283403754234314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017833948135376 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14283403754234314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14283403754234314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06698824465274811, + 0.2894618511199951, + 0.07712627947330475, + 0.0424177348613739, + 0.20883704721927643, + 0.027768805623054504, + 0.09445910900831223, + 0.045944225043058395, + 0.09084440767765045, + 0.05615226924419403 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14283403754234314 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective placing the viewer directly in front of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze box engraved with flowing runes visible hovering in the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box have a deep bluish-brown hue with a mottled patina of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box spin in a steady rhythm while being pulled into a chaotic vortex of deep purple, indigo, and magenta light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows at the edge of the vision change from warm gold to cold, grotesque colors as the box sinks into the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11294224858283997 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379422187805176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11294224858283997, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11294224858283997, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11082521826028824, + 0.26430103182792664, + 0.13410881161689758, + 0.0540415421128273, + 0.1783648282289505, + 0.03085680492222309, + 0.06394928693771362, + 0.045205436646938324, + 0.06498779356479645, + 0.053359225392341614 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11294224858283997 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective placing the viewer directly in front of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze box engraved with flowing runes visible hovering in the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box have a deep bluish-brown hue with a mottled patina of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box spin in a steady rhythm while being pulled into a chaotic vortex of deep purple, indigo, and magenta light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows at the edge of the vision change from warm gold to cold, grotesque colors as the box sinks into the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006741754245012999 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006741523742676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006741754245012999, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006741754245012999, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08791670203208923, + 0.17785988748073578, + 0.1856633424758911, + 0.05222540348768234, + 0.08311373740434647, + 0.053995635360479355, + 0.08879292756319046, + 0.0316929966211319, + 0.033769700676202774, + 0.2049696147441864 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006741754245012999 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot from a first-person perspective placing the viewer directly in front of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze box engraved with flowing runes visible hovering in the void?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box have a deep bluish-brown hue with a mottled patina of age?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the bronze box spin in a steady rhythm while being pulled into a chaotic vortex of deep purple, indigo, and magenta light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the shadows at the edge of the vision change from warm gold to cold, grotesque colors as the box sinks into the vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038102924823760986 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288102865219116 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038102924823760986, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038102924823760986, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.057431675493717194, + 0.09610921889543533, + 0.10812258720397949, + 0.053801558911800385, + 0.02248339354991913, + 0.025823889300227165, + 0.3760049343109131, + 0.029367754235863686, + 0.057113900780677795, + 0.17374108731746674 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038102924823760986 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_8/index_tensor([7635, 7635])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_8/index_tensor([7635, 7635])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..292cba0f9cfd52b3e165da78aee9fc01f68a0bce --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_8/index_tensor([7635, 7635])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "Shot at eye level, the camera steadily and slowly zooms in on the subject's face, focusing on a man in a dimly lit, aging room where the air seems to hang thick with dust. His face is pale, his cheeks slightly sunken, his tousled dark hair cascading over his forehead, and his deep eyes are filled with a lingering, eternal sorrow. Wearing a rough, dark gray turtleneck sweater, he uses his bony, slender fingers, with a slow, almost ritualistic heft, to straighten a slender white candle. Then, he carefully brings a freshly lit match to the wick, the faint sulfur glow of the matchhead briefly illuminating his focused, mournful expression. As the wick ignites, a small, warm, orange-yellow flame rises steadily, momentarily becoming the only vivid color in the frame. This light casts deep, flickering shadows across his face, highlighting his pursed lips and sunken eye sockets. Most importantly, the flickering flame is clearly reflected in the depths of his pupils, which stare into the void, where light and sadness intertwine and flicker. The entire painting is processed in a faded and highly desaturated color scheme, dominated by cold grays and dark browns, with the candlelight as the only warm color embellishment, creating an atmosphere of extreme melancholy, tranquility, and contemplative despair.", + "seed": 13450, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_8/index_7635_seed_13450_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.010873983427882195, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010873983427882195, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010873983427882195, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with pale skin, sunken cheeks, tousled dark hair, and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a rough, dark gray turtleneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man use his slender fingers to straighten a slender white candle and then light it with a match?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, aging room with dust in the air, shot at eye level with a slow camera zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color scheme highly desaturated with cold grays and dark browns, featuring only a small warm orange-yellow flame as a vivid color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02995370700955391 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.654953718185425 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02995370700955391, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02995370700955391, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04909089580178261, + 0.022667085751891136, + 0.22759787738323212, + 0.025854846462607384, + 0.039839670062065125, + 0.2691388428211212, + 0.22418338060379028, + 0.02359156124293804, + 0.04246663302183151, + 0.07556921243667603 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02995370700955391 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with pale skin, sunken cheeks, tousled dark hair, and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a rough, dark gray turtleneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man use his slender fingers to straighten a slender white candle and then light it with a match?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, aging room with dust in the air, shot at eye level with a slow camera zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color scheme highly desaturated with cold grays and dark browns, featuring only a small warm orange-yellow flame as a vivid color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009795455262064934 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634795665740967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009795455262064934, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009795455262064934, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06759361177682877, + 0.046620290726423264, + 0.39782068133354187, + 0.08992514759302139, + 0.056925300508737564, + 0.13085642457008362, + 0.1290399134159088, + 0.019871525466442108, + 0.03880440816283226, + 0.02254270389676094 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009795455262064934 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with pale skin, sunken cheeks, tousled dark hair, and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a rough, dark gray turtleneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man use his slender fingers to straighten a slender white candle and then light it with a match?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, aging room with dust in the air, shot at eye level with a slow camera zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color scheme highly desaturated with cold grays and dark browns, featuring only a small warm orange-yellow flame as a vivid color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008644422516226768 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586445808410645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008644422516226768, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008644422516226768, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09311061352491379, + 0.0355912521481514, + 0.031333211809396744, + 0.01871486008167267, + 0.034173499792814255, + 0.5608509182929993, + 0.02292102947831154, + 0.06322042644023895, + 0.07478276640176773, + 0.06530145555734634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008644422516226768 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with pale skin, sunken cheeks, tousled dark hair, and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a rough, dark gray turtleneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man use his slender fingers to straighten a slender white candle and then light it with a match?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, aging room with dust in the air, shot at eye level with a slow camera zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color scheme highly desaturated with cold grays and dark browns, featuring only a small warm orange-yellow flame as a vivid color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00463838828727603 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379638195037842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00463838828727603, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00463838828727603, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.040938977152109146, + 0.023461319506168365, + 0.4737188220024109, + 0.05579246208071709, + 0.012257528491318226, + 0.13524360954761505, + 0.11545922607183456, + 0.04323135316371918, + 0.06883774697780609, + 0.031059015542268753 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00463838828727603 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with pale skin, sunken cheeks, tousled dark hair, and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a rough, dark gray turtleneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man use his slender fingers to straighten a slender white candle and then light it with a match?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, aging room with dust in the air, shot at eye level with a slow camera zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color scheme highly desaturated with cold grays and dark browns, featuring only a small warm orange-yellow flame as a vivid color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013379440642893314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626338005065918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013379440642893314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013379440642893314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08290719240903854, + 0.03901191055774689, + 0.2870936095714569, + 0.07632327079772949, + 0.04045359045267105, + 0.23258653283119202, + 0.09493867307901382, + 0.022792918607592583, + 0.043661799281835556, + 0.08023048937320709 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013379440642893314 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Shot at eye level, the camera steadily and slowly zooms in on the subject's face, focusing on a man in a dimly lit, aging room where the air seems to hang thick with dust. His face is pale, his cheeks slightly sunken, his tousled dark hair cascading over his forehead, and his deep eyes are filled with a lingering, eternal sorrow. Wearing a rough, dark gray turtleneck sweater, he uses his bony, slender fingers, with a slow, almost ritualistic heft, to straighten a slender white candle. Then, he carefully brings a freshly lit match to the wick, the faint sulfur glow of the matchhead briefly illuminating his focused, mournful expression. As the wick ignites, a small, warm, orange-yellow flame rises steadily, momentarily becoming the only vivid color in the frame. This light casts deep, flickering shadows across his face, highlighting his pursed lips and sunken eye sockets. Most importantly, the flickering flame is clearly reflected in the depths of his pupils, which stare into the void, where light and sadness intertwine and flicker. The entire painting is processed in a faded and highly desaturated color scheme, dominated by cold grays and dark browns, with the candlelight as the only warm color embellishment, creating an atmosphere of extreme melancholy, tranquility, and contemplative despair.", + "seed": 13451, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_8/index_7635_seed_13451_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.01918376856483519, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01918376856483519, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01918376856483519, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with pale skin, sunken cheeks, tousled dark hair, and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a rough, dark gray turtleneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man use his slender fingers to straighten a slender white candle and then light it with a match?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, aging room with dust in the air, shot at eye level with a slow camera zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color scheme highly desaturated with cold grays and dark browns, featuring only a small warm orange-yellow flame as a vivid color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05002686008810997 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0500268936157227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05002686008810997, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05002686008810997, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2249724268913269, + 0.18402846157550812, + 0.06503815948963165, + 0.2292497158050537, + 0.05100933834910393, + 0.02711373381316662, + 0.05370130017399788, + 0.04471161216497421, + 0.056665658950805664, + 0.06350961327552795 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05002686008810997 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with pale skin, sunken cheeks, tousled dark hair, and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a rough, dark gray turtleneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man use his slender fingers to straighten a slender white candle and then light it with a match?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, aging room with dust in the air, shot at eye level with a slow camera zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color scheme highly desaturated with cold grays and dark browns, featuring only a small warm orange-yellow flame as a vivid color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059386856853962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955938816070557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059386856853962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059386856853962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6847367882728577, + 0.04552930220961571, + 0.027731861919164658, + 0.10862567275762558, + 0.032190944999456406, + 0.011815040372312069, + 0.008762595243752003, + 0.030773209407925606, + 0.024531617760658264, + 0.025302913039922714 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059386856853962 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with pale skin, sunken cheeks, tousled dark hair, and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a rough, dark gray turtleneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man use his slender fingers to straighten a slender white candle and then light it with a match?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, aging room with dust in the air, shot at eye level with a slow camera zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color scheme highly desaturated with cold grays and dark browns, featuring only a small warm orange-yellow flame as a vivid color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607259176671505 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141072750091553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607259176671505, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607259176671505, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33853256702423096, + 0.03663065284490585, + 0.04163282737135887, + 0.01707405410706997, + 0.1302572637796402, + 0.12467498332262039, + 0.022174928337335587, + 0.194905623793602, + 0.058958496898412704, + 0.03515861555933952 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607259176671505 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with pale skin, sunken cheeks, tousled dark hair, and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a rough, dark gray turtleneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man use his slender fingers to straighten a slender white candle and then light it with a match?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, aging room with dust in the air, shot at eye level with a slow camera zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color scheme highly desaturated with cold grays and dark browns, featuring only a small warm orange-yellow flame as a vivid color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006734649650752544 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006734848022461 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006734649650752544, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006734649650752544, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5148472189903259, + 0.05005588009953499, + 0.04463725537061691, + 0.056963615119457245, + 0.07225241512060165, + 0.028660746291279793, + 0.06651408970355988, + 0.06288288533687592, + 0.04914860427379608, + 0.05403728410601616 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006734649650752544 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with pale skin, sunken cheeks, tousled dark hair, and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a rough, dark gray turtleneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man use his slender fingers to straighten a slender white candle and then light it with a match?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, aging room with dust in the air, shot at eye level with a slow camera zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color scheme highly desaturated with cold grays and dark browns, featuring only a small warm orange-yellow flame as a vivid color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00249087275005877 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002490997314453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00249087275005877, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00249087275005877, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2804733216762543, + 0.06431004405021667, + 0.08093268424272537, + 0.06523195654153824, + 0.2906246483325958, + 0.03551037237048149, + 0.033216580748558044, + 0.052536699920892715, + 0.043098267167806625, + 0.05406540259718895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00249087275005877 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Shot at eye level, the camera steadily and slowly zooms in on the subject's face, focusing on a man in a dimly lit, aging room where the air seems to hang thick with dust. His face is pale, his cheeks slightly sunken, his tousled dark hair cascading over his forehead, and his deep eyes are filled with a lingering, eternal sorrow. Wearing a rough, dark gray turtleneck sweater, he uses his bony, slender fingers, with a slow, almost ritualistic heft, to straighten a slender white candle. Then, he carefully brings a freshly lit match to the wick, the faint sulfur glow of the matchhead briefly illuminating his focused, mournful expression. As the wick ignites, a small, warm, orange-yellow flame rises steadily, momentarily becoming the only vivid color in the frame. This light casts deep, flickering shadows across his face, highlighting his pursed lips and sunken eye sockets. Most importantly, the flickering flame is clearly reflected in the depths of his pupils, which stare into the void, where light and sadness intertwine and flicker. The entire painting is processed in a faded and highly desaturated color scheme, dominated by cold grays and dark browns, with the candlelight as the only warm color embellishment, creating an atmosphere of extreme melancholy, tranquility, and contemplative despair.", + "seed": 13452, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_8/index_7635_seed_13452_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.018840408138930797, + "vlm_logprob": -0.018840408138930797, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.018840408138930797, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with pale skin, sunken cheeks, tousled dark hair, and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a rough, dark gray turtleneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man use his slender fingers to straighten a slender white candle and then light it with a match?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, aging room with dust in the air, shot at eye level with a slow camera zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color scheme highly desaturated with cold grays and dark browns, featuring only a small warm orange-yellow flame as a vivid color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.045264169573783875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.17026424407959 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.045264169573783875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.045264169573783875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2360306829214096, + 0.2381611466407776, + 0.07476966828107834, + 0.0321146585047245, + 0.032297104597091675, + 0.018461113795638084, + 0.18370498716831207, + 0.08258374035358429, + 0.05842409282922745, + 0.04345274716615677 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.045264169573783875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with pale skin, sunken cheeks, tousled dark hair, and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a rough, dark gray turtleneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man use his slender fingers to straighten a slender white candle and then light it with a match?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, aging room with dust in the air, shot at eye level with a slow camera zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color scheme highly desaturated with cold grays and dark browns, featuring only a small warm orange-yellow flame as a vivid color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02060052566230297 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956005573272705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02060052566230297, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02060052566230297, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1518535017967224, + 0.11341960728168488, + 0.06518709659576416, + 0.03541189432144165, + 0.042901862412691116, + 0.02932261861860752, + 0.13332103192806244, + 0.3256494700908661, + 0.04517974704504013, + 0.057753149420022964 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02060052566230297 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with pale skin, sunken cheeks, tousled dark hair, and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a rough, dark gray turtleneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man use his slender fingers to straighten a slender white candle and then light it with a match?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, aging room with dust in the air, shot at eye level with a slow camera zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color scheme highly desaturated with cold grays and dark browns, featuring only a small warm orange-yellow flame as a vivid color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607787050306797 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141077995300293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607787050306797, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607787050306797, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1117691919207573, + 0.02831912413239479, + 0.04247819632291794, + 0.05756261944770813, + 0.045569561421871185, + 0.0686519593000412, + 0.22280114889144897, + 0.08379023522138596, + 0.11711149662733078, + 0.22194641828536987 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607787050306797 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with pale skin, sunken cheeks, tousled dark hair, and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a rough, dark gray turtleneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man use his slender fingers to straighten a slender white candle and then light it with a match?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, aging room with dust in the air, shot at eye level with a slow camera zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color scheme highly desaturated with cold grays and dark browns, featuring only a small warm orange-yellow flame as a vivid color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008641231805086136 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758641242980957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008641231805086136, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008641231805086136, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10874255001544952, + 0.20637555420398712, + 0.05452520772814751, + 0.05221661552786827, + 0.020785756409168243, + 0.03949807584285736, + 0.3759962320327759, + 0.06223764643073082, + 0.02794712595641613, + 0.05167515203356743 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008641231805086136 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with pale skin, sunken cheeks, tousled dark hair, and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a rough, dark gray turtleneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man use his slender fingers to straighten a slender white candle and then light it with a match?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, aging room with dust in the air, shot at eye level with a slow camera zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color scheme highly desaturated with cold grays and dark browns, featuring only a small warm orange-yellow flame as a vivid color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036182431504130363 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628618240356445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036182431504130363, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036182431504130363, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17967581748962402, + 0.0881255567073822, + 0.0418834388256073, + 0.047767385840415955, + 0.025934606790542603, + 0.020417695865035057, + 0.28940629959106445, + 0.08505871146917343, + 0.12695017457008362, + 0.094780333340168 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036182431504130363 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Shot at eye level, the camera steadily and slowly zooms in on the subject's face, focusing on a man in a dimly lit, aging room where the air seems to hang thick with dust. His face is pale, his cheeks slightly sunken, his tousled dark hair cascading over his forehead, and his deep eyes are filled with a lingering, eternal sorrow. Wearing a rough, dark gray turtleneck sweater, he uses his bony, slender fingers, with a slow, almost ritualistic heft, to straighten a slender white candle. Then, he carefully brings a freshly lit match to the wick, the faint sulfur glow of the matchhead briefly illuminating his focused, mournful expression. As the wick ignites, a small, warm, orange-yellow flame rises steadily, momentarily becoming the only vivid color in the frame. This light casts deep, flickering shadows across his face, highlighting his pursed lips and sunken eye sockets. Most importantly, the flickering flame is clearly reflected in the depths of his pupils, which stare into the void, where light and sadness intertwine and flicker. The entire painting is processed in a faded and highly desaturated color scheme, dominated by cold grays and dark browns, with the candlelight as the only warm color embellishment, creating an atmosphere of extreme melancholy, tranquility, and contemplative despair.", + "seed": 13453, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_8/index_7635_seed_13453_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03704108903184533, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03704108903184533, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03704108903184533, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with pale skin, sunken cheeks, tousled dark hair, and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a rough, dark gray turtleneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man use his slender fingers to straighten a slender white candle and then light it with a match?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, aging room with dust in the air, shot at eye level with a slow camera zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color scheme highly desaturated with cold grays and dark browns, featuring only a small warm orange-yellow flame as a vivid color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08172789961099625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.581727981567383 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08172789961099625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08172789961099625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10975871235132217, + 0.026377953588962555, + 0.03127603605389595, + 0.03461252152919769, + 0.013323512859642506, + 0.2705162763595581, + 0.0984780564904213, + 0.09339561313390732, + 0.018320292234420776, + 0.3039410710334778 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08172789961099625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with pale skin, sunken cheeks, tousled dark hair, and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a rough, dark gray turtleneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man use his slender fingers to straighten a slender white candle and then light it with a match?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, aging room with dust in the air, shot at eye level with a slow camera zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color scheme highly desaturated with cold grays and dark browns, featuring only a small warm orange-yellow flame as a vivid color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043079499155282974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680796146392822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043079499155282974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043079499155282974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20730483531951904, + 0.07093211263418198, + 0.022528352215886116, + 0.01979786716401577, + 0.020957941189408302, + 0.19762223958969116, + 0.04278184473514557, + 0.041920293122529984, + 0.02716291882097721, + 0.34899166226387024 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043079499155282974 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with pale skin, sunken cheeks, tousled dark hair, and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a rough, dark gray turtleneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man use his slender fingers to straighten a slender white candle and then light it with a match?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, aging room with dust in the air, shot at eye level with a slow camera zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color scheme highly desaturated with cold grays and dark browns, featuring only a small warm orange-yellow flame as a vivid color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048671696335077286 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486717224121094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048671696335077286, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048671696335077286, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05762297660112381, + 0.022863738238811493, + 0.018448079004883766, + 0.02260158769786358, + 0.026926714926958084, + 0.4802985191345215, + 0.02594331093132496, + 0.2116789072751999, + 0.02851080894470215, + 0.10510534048080444 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048671696335077286 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with pale skin, sunken cheeks, tousled dark hair, and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a rough, dark gray turtleneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man use his slender fingers to straighten a slender white candle and then light it with a match?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, aging room with dust in the air, shot at eye level with a slow camera zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color scheme highly desaturated with cold grays and dark browns, featuring only a small warm orange-yellow flame as a vivid color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007628949359059334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882628917694092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007628949359059334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007628949359059334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17253175377845764, + 0.05126401409506798, + 0.06957478076219559, + 0.039108455181121826, + 0.01467782910913229, + 0.0786803811788559, + 0.02074080891907215, + 0.05774785205721855, + 0.06624358892440796, + 0.4294305443763733 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007628949359059334 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a man with pale skin, sunken cheeks, tousled dark hair, and deep eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a rough, dark gray turtleneck sweater?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man use his slender fingers to straighten a slender white candle and then light it with a match?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a dimly lit, aging room with dust in the air, shot at eye level with a slow camera zoom in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color scheme highly desaturated with cold grays and dark browns, featuring only a small warm orange-yellow flame as a vivid color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004097400698810816 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5040974617004395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004097400698810816, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004097400698810816, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20311766862869263, + 0.042515937238931656, + 0.05200428515672684, + 0.03320900350809097, + 0.05164448916912079, + 0.37086033821105957, + 0.05971689149737358, + 0.06718967109918594, + 0.04922337830066681, + 0.07051829993724823 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004097400698810816 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_9/index_tensor([2396, 2396])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_9/index_tensor([2396, 2396])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f418b0c51ae894e7a9d2606ab1aef6c9d8c9ff83 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_9/index_tensor([2396, 2396])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, medium shot frames a quietly enchanting scene in a deep, twilight forest. Dominating the upper portion of the frame is a thick, gnarled branch, its ancient bark deeply fissured and adorned with a veil of silvery-white lichen. From its tip, a delicate branch magically forms a luminous orb of pure golden light, pulsing with a soft inner energy. With deliberate grace, the orb separates and drifts downward, casting a warm, radiant glow that illuminates the intricate, velvety textures of the emerald moss covering the forest floor. Upon contact with the ground, the orb does not dissipate but gently compresses, its light flickering momentarily before rebounding upward in a slow, rhythmic bouncing pattern, returning to the branches as if playfully controlled by an unseen force. The stark contrast between the orb's brilliant warmth and the cool, deep shadows of the surrounding woods creates a stunning black-and-white effect. Dust motes dance like tiny stars in its light, creating an atmosphere of tranquil, sacred magic.", + "seed": 1906, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_9/index_2396_seed_1906_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05099915731698275, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05099915731698275, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.950000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05099915731698275, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep forest during twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, gnarled branch with silvery-white lichen visible in the upper portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a luminous golden orb separate from the branch and drift downward to the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the orb compress upon contact with the ground and bounce upward in a slow, rhythmic pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09396201372146606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4689619541168213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09396201372146606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09396201372146606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3540570139884949, + 0.11263231933116913, + 0.03670493885874748, + 0.1658245176076889, + 0.09528778493404388, + 0.04273764789104462, + 0.048539064824581146, + 0.041860222816467285, + 0.024010252207517624, + 0.07834628969430923 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09396201372146606 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep forest during twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, gnarled branch with silvery-white lichen visible in the upper portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a luminous golden orb separate from the branch and drift downward to the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the orb compress upon contact with the ground and bounce upward in a slow, rhythmic pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003642592579126358 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628642559051514 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003642592579126358, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003642592579126358, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30274075269699097, + 0.22062592208385468, + 0.046775657683610916, + 0.07162749767303467, + 0.07088641077280045, + 0.07716687768697739, + 0.06814654171466827, + 0.04173155874013901, + 0.02595224790275097, + 0.07434651255607605 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003642592579126358 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep forest during twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, gnarled branch with silvery-white lichen visible in the upper portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a luminous golden orb separate from the branch and drift downward to the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the orb compress upon contact with the ground and bounce upward in a slow, rhythmic pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005959124304354191 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309590339660645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005959124304354191, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005959124304354191, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1875036507844925, + 0.1312801092863083, + 0.06938352435827255, + 0.11477724462747574, + 0.1582033932209015, + 0.13377811014652252, + 0.09142846614122391, + 0.03393597900867462, + 0.031162841245532036, + 0.04854671284556389 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005959124304354191 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep forest during twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, gnarled branch with silvery-white lichen visible in the upper portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a luminous golden orb separate from the branch and drift downward to the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the orb compress upon contact with the ground and bounce upward in a slow, rhythmic pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008639458566904068 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758639335632324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008639458566904068, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008639458566904068, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14450883865356445, + 0.14008785784244537, + 0.03314816579222679, + 0.13985301554203033, + 0.07681149989366531, + 0.1441657543182373, + 0.1922239363193512, + 0.04419061169028282, + 0.024055613204836845, + 0.060954730957746506 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008639458566904068 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep forest during twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, gnarled branch with silvery-white lichen visible in the upper portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a luminous golden orb separate from the branch and drift downward to the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the orb compress upon contact with the ground and bounce upward in a slow, rhythmic pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14279259741306305 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0177927017211914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14279259741306305, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14279259741306305, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17962072789669037, + 0.14726455509662628, + 0.0489121675491333, + 0.05977353826165199, + 0.10981027036905289, + 0.02764493227005005, + 0.04299839958548546, + 0.07266368716955185, + 0.07418244332075119, + 0.23712937533855438 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14279259741306305 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, medium shot frames a quietly enchanting scene in a deep, twilight forest. Dominating the upper portion of the frame is a thick, gnarled branch, its ancient bark deeply fissured and adorned with a veil of silvery-white lichen. From its tip, a delicate branch magically forms a luminous orb of pure golden light, pulsing with a soft inner energy. With deliberate grace, the orb separates and drifts downward, casting a warm, radiant glow that illuminates the intricate, velvety textures of the emerald moss covering the forest floor. Upon contact with the ground, the orb does not dissipate but gently compresses, its light flickering momentarily before rebounding upward in a slow, rhythmic bouncing pattern, returning to the branches as if playfully controlled by an unseen force. The stark contrast between the orb's brilliant warmth and the cool, deep shadows of the surrounding woods creates a stunning black-and-white effect. Dust motes dance like tiny stars in its light, creating an atmosphere of tranquil, sacred magic.", + "seed": 1907, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_9/index_2396_seed_1907_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08076764032011852, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08076764032011852, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08076764032011852, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep forest during twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, gnarled branch with silvery-white lichen visible in the upper portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a luminous golden orb separate from the branch and drift downward to the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the orb compress upon contact with the ground and bounce upward in a slow, rhythmic pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.23282156884670258 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6078215837478638 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.23282156884670258, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.23282156884670258, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2527244985103607, + 0.10877609252929688, + 0.0815768614411354, + 0.1075863316655159, + 0.04678979516029358, + 0.09529231488704681, + 0.10358874499797821, + 0.07786528021097183, + 0.03326446935534477, + 0.09253565222024918 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.23282156884670258 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep forest during twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, gnarled branch with silvery-white lichen visible in the upper portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a luminous golden orb separate from the branch and drift downward to the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the orb compress upon contact with the ground and bounce upward in a slow, rhythmic pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0008394769974984229 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.125839710235596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0008394769974984229, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0008394769974984229, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3072628676891327, + 0.19349424540996552, + 0.0890430137515068, + 0.05275549367070198, + 0.0319882370531559, + 0.06978479027748108, + 0.04656965658068657, + 0.05182168260216713, + 0.10152410715818405, + 0.05575587972998619 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0008394769974984229 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep forest during twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, gnarled branch with silvery-white lichen visible in the upper portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a luminous golden orb separate from the branch and drift downward to the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the orb compress upon contact with the ground and bounce upward in a slow, rhythmic pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011874536285176873 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751187324523926 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011874536285176873, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011874536285176873, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16203096508979797, + 0.058762889355421066, + 0.280754417181015, + 0.05121304467320442, + 0.09487749636173248, + 0.08659319579601288, + 0.08074222505092621, + 0.054851893335580826, + 0.09040697664022446, + 0.03976684436202049 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011874536285176873 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep forest during twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, gnarled branch with silvery-white lichen visible in the upper portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a luminous golden orb separate from the branch and drift downward to the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the orb compress upon contact with the ground and bounce upward in a slow, rhythmic pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008636622689664364 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758636474609375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008636622689664364, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008636622689664364, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1810491979122162, + 0.08700727671384811, + 0.21344734728336334, + 0.045426804572343826, + 0.05746857821941376, + 0.08156424760818481, + 0.09466405212879181, + 0.13117091357707977, + 0.06324230134487152, + 0.04495930299162865 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008636622689664364 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep forest during twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, gnarled branch with silvery-white lichen visible in the upper portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a luminous golden orb separate from the branch and drift downward to the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the orb compress upon contact with the ground and bounce upward in a slow, rhythmic pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16035307943820953 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103530645370483 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16035307943820953, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16035307943820953, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3684444725513458, + 0.08502662181854248, + 0.11440471559762955, + 0.060502126812934875, + 0.07666828483343124, + 0.08348043262958527, + 0.052843689918518066, + 0.03344300389289856, + 0.08158029615879059, + 0.04360633343458176 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16035307943820953 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, medium shot frames a quietly enchanting scene in a deep, twilight forest. Dominating the upper portion of the frame is a thick, gnarled branch, its ancient bark deeply fissured and adorned with a veil of silvery-white lichen. From its tip, a delicate branch magically forms a luminous orb of pure golden light, pulsing with a soft inner energy. With deliberate grace, the orb separates and drifts downward, casting a warm, radiant glow that illuminates the intricate, velvety textures of the emerald moss covering the forest floor. Upon contact with the ground, the orb does not dissipate but gently compresses, its light flickering momentarily before rebounding upward in a slow, rhythmic bouncing pattern, returning to the branches as if playfully controlled by an unseen force. The stark contrast between the orb's brilliant warmth and the cool, deep shadows of the surrounding woods creates a stunning black-and-white effect. Dust motes dance like tiny stars in its light, creating an atmosphere of tranquil, sacred magic.", + "seed": 1908, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_9/index_2396_seed_1908_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.031254842737689616, + "vlm_logprob": -0.031254842737689616, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.031254842737689616, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep forest during twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, gnarled branch with silvery-white lichen visible in the upper portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a luminous golden orb separate from the branch and drift downward to the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the orb compress upon contact with the ground and bounce upward in a slow, rhythmic pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05315781757235527 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0531578063964844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05315781757235527, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05315781757235527, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3930101990699768, + 0.13791637122631073, + 0.06972293555736542, + 0.08799726516008377, + 0.07286472618579865, + 0.03863111138343811, + 0.0518183559179306, + 0.06409870088100433, + 0.04546977952122688, + 0.0384705625474453 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05315781757235527 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep forest during twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, gnarled branch with silvery-white lichen visible in the upper portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a luminous golden orb separate from the branch and drift downward to the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the orb compress upon contact with the ground and bounce upward in a slow, rhythmic pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001961809117347002 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251961708068848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001961809117347002, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001961809117347002, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18554967641830444, + 0.039803918451070786, + 0.6618298888206482, + 0.023854583501815796, + 0.01088754367083311, + 0.019785158336162567, + 0.01418560091406107, + 0.015152297914028168, + 0.008189966902136803, + 0.020761385560035706 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001961809117347002 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep forest during twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, gnarled branch with silvery-white lichen visible in the upper portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a luminous golden orb separate from the branch and drift downward to the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the orb compress upon contact with the ground and bounce upward in a slow, rhythmic pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00105015910230577 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876049995422363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00105015910230577, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00105015910230577, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0656975656747818, + 0.030302874743938446, + 0.6868749260902405, + 0.017764287069439888, + 0.023188993334770203, + 0.06150243058800697, + 0.029430439695715904, + 0.048122648149728775, + 0.021406110376119614, + 0.015709692612290382 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00105015910230577 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep forest during twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, gnarled branch with silvery-white lichen visible in the upper portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a luminous golden orb separate from the branch and drift downward to the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the orb compress upon contact with the ground and bounce upward in a slow, rhythmic pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011075212620198727 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511075019836426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011075212620198727, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011075212620198727, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.048478398472070694, + 0.05993169546127319, + 0.5583416223526001, + 0.039943549782037735, + 0.034333255141973495, + 0.06439945846796036, + 0.034091487526893616, + 0.07980898022651672, + 0.04989095404744148, + 0.0307806134223938 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011075212620198727 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep forest during twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, gnarled branch with silvery-white lichen visible in the upper portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a luminous golden orb separate from the branch and drift downward to the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the orb compress upon contact with the ground and bounce upward in a slow, rhythmic pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890292152762413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464029312133789 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0890292152762413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0890292152762413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10310123860836029, + 0.07133051753044128, + 0.4335111081600189, + 0.08719360828399658, + 0.03801354393362999, + 0.05839688703417778, + 0.04538481682538986, + 0.07386323064565659, + 0.069045789539814, + 0.020159250125288963 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0890292152762413 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, low-angle, medium shot frames a quietly enchanting scene in a deep, twilight forest. Dominating the upper portion of the frame is a thick, gnarled branch, its ancient bark deeply fissured and adorned with a veil of silvery-white lichen. From its tip, a delicate branch magically forms a luminous orb of pure golden light, pulsing with a soft inner energy. With deliberate grace, the orb separates and drifts downward, casting a warm, radiant glow that illuminates the intricate, velvety textures of the emerald moss covering the forest floor. Upon contact with the ground, the orb does not dissipate but gently compresses, its light flickering momentarily before rebounding upward in a slow, rhythmic bouncing pattern, returning to the branches as if playfully controlled by an unseen force. The stark contrast between the orb's brilliant warmth and the cool, deep shadows of the surrounding woods creates a stunning black-and-white effect. Dust motes dance like tiny stars in its light, creating an atmosphere of tranquil, sacred magic.", + "seed": 1909, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000249/group_9/index_2396_seed_1909_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04669772833585739, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04669772833585739, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04669772833585739, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep forest during twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, gnarled branch with silvery-white lichen visible in the upper portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a luminous golden orb separate from the branch and drift downward to the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the orb compress upon contact with the ground and bounce upward in a slow, rhythmic pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09338875859975815 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.468388795852661 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09338875859975815, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09338875859975815, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1842344105243683, + 0.08997698128223419, + 0.11032423377037048, + 0.06959416717290878, + 0.0915619283914566, + 0.17722353339195251, + 0.04239029437303543, + 0.04029730707406998, + 0.08191996067762375, + 0.11247728019952774 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09338875859975815 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep forest during twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, gnarled branch with silvery-white lichen visible in the upper portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a luminous golden orb separate from the branch and drift downward to the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the orb compress upon contact with the ground and bounce upward in a slow, rhythmic pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022261380217969418 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.12722635269165 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022261380217969418, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022261380217969418, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13572967052459717, + 0.0979844406247139, + 0.15483763813972473, + 0.19484484195709229, + 0.09942422807216644, + 0.06882134079933167, + 0.07431822270154953, + 0.05954441800713539, + 0.03276091068983078, + 0.08173429220914841 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022261380217969418 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep forest during twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, gnarled branch with silvery-white lichen visible in the upper portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a luminous golden orb separate from the branch and drift downward to the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the orb compress upon contact with the ground and bounce upward in a slow, rhythmic pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022050845436751842 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127204895019531 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022050845436751842, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022050845436751842, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09918135404586792, + 0.09039373695850372, + 0.08918459713459015, + 0.11588231474161148, + 0.1694345474243164, + 0.1504083275794983, + 0.12664440274238586, + 0.04962420091032982, + 0.030358612537384033, + 0.07888786494731903 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022050845436751842 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep forest during twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, gnarled branch with silvery-white lichen visible in the upper portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a luminous golden orb separate from the branch and drift downward to the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the orb compress upon contact with the ground and bounce upward in a slow, rhythmic pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008636976592242718 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758636951446533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008636976592242718, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008636976592242718, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11561990529298782, + 0.07590460777282715, + 0.03038136474788189, + 0.09471142292022705, + 0.345702201128006, + 0.06836918741464615, + 0.11579328775405884, + 0.08098390698432922, + 0.032307423651218414, + 0.04022664949297905 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008636976592242718 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep forest during twilight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a thick, gnarled branch with silvery-white lichen visible in the upper portion of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a luminous golden orb separate from the branch and drift downward to the forest floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the orb compress upon contact with the ground and bounce upward in a slow, rhythmic pattern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12703168392181396 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270318031311035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12703168392181396, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12703168392181396, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11958753317594528, + 0.04624400660395622, + 0.03126784414052963, + 0.04810713231563568, + 0.4256739318370819, + 0.08066786080598831, + 0.06374973058700562, + 0.048110246658325195, + 0.054319363087415695, + 0.08227237313985825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12703168392181396 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_0/index_tensor([2027, 2027])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_0/index_tensor([2027, 2027])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1efb56d4f38e59ca05e576aba90b7cc5e784cfe5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_0/index_tensor([2027, 2027])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle shot, zooming in at an almost imperceptible pace, captures a solitary, androgynous figure writhing against the damp, dark earth of a vast wheat field. The sky above is a turbulent, brooding canvas of dark gray and bruised purple clouds, allowing only a wisp of cold, feeble light to filter through, casting the scene in a desaturated, oppressive gloom. The figure, dressed in simple, earthy, tattered linen clothing stained with dirt, contorts their body in a silent, desperate struggle. Their backs arch spasmodically, lifting their torsos from the ground, their fingers digging painfully into the soil and broken golden stalks. Their matted black hair clings to their pale, sweating faces, a mask of pure agony, their jaws clenched and their eyes squeezed shut. The camera's slow zoom in intensifies their isolation and the futility of their struggle, their bodies twisting and struggling futilely against the vast, indifferent landscape, creating an atmosphere of intense tension and desolation.", + "seed": 2605, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_0/index_2027_seed_2605_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1484469411894679, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1484469411894679, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.775000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1484469411894679, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow zoom-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure dressed in tattered, earthy linen clothing visible writhing on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast wheat field with dark gray and bruised purple clouds in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure's face visible with matted black hair, pale skin, and eyes squeezed shut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.23470914363861084 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7347091436386108 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.23470914363861084, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.23470914363861084, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3747396767139435, + 0.08547309041023254, + 0.09837715327739716, + 0.08279792964458466, + 0.04710923880338669, + 0.04084886237978935, + 0.033944617956876755, + 0.1028924286365509, + 0.07938656955957413, + 0.05443040281534195 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.23470914363861084 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow zoom-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure dressed in tattered, earthy linen clothing visible writhing on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast wheat field with dark gray and bruised purple clouds in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure's face visible with matted black hair, pale skin, and eyes squeezed shut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38705796003341675 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370580196380615 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38705796003341675, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7500000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38705796003341675, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1299046128988266, + 0.4601718783378601, + 0.03969939053058624, + 0.028062205761671066, + 0.031479962170124054, + 0.0743037685751915, + 0.10991983115673065, + 0.06203608214855194, + 0.040600769221782684, + 0.02382151409983635 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38705796003341675 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow zoom-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure dressed in tattered, earthy linen clothing visible writhing on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast wheat field with dark gray and bruised purple clouds in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure's face visible with matted black hair, pale skin, and eyes squeezed shut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014202469028532505 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26420259475708 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014202469028532505, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014202469028532505, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15004542469978333, + 0.41696178913116455, + 0.04102586954832077, + 0.05026239901781082, + 0.12046671658754349, + 0.024360956624150276, + 0.013599801808595657, + 0.0301633533090353, + 0.06121594458818436, + 0.09189780056476593 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014202469028532505 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow zoom-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure dressed in tattered, earthy linen clothing visible writhing on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast wheat field with dark gray and bruised purple clouds in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure's face visible with matted black hair, pale skin, and eyes squeezed shut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005947155877947807 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130947113037109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005947155877947807, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005947155877947807, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13131864368915558, + 0.2150765061378479, + 0.07472289353609085, + 0.048471711575984955, + 0.07176683843135834, + 0.05723738670349121, + 0.04729938134551048, + 0.13594841957092285, + 0.18020634353160858, + 0.037951912730932236 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005947155877947807 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow zoom-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure dressed in tattered, earthy linen clothing visible writhing on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast wheat field with dark gray and bruised purple clouds in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure's face visible with matted black hair, pale skin, and eyes squeezed shut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10031797736883163 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.35031795501709 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10031797736883163, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10031797736883163, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2159828245639801, + 0.347715824842453, + 0.03370023891329765, + 0.060158539563417435, + 0.06908169388771057, + 0.03490345552563667, + 0.03614986315369606, + 0.029981428757309914, + 0.08481130003929138, + 0.08751486241817474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10031797736883163 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle shot, zooming in at an almost imperceptible pace, captures a solitary, androgynous figure writhing against the damp, dark earth of a vast wheat field. The sky above is a turbulent, brooding canvas of dark gray and bruised purple clouds, allowing only a wisp of cold, feeble light to filter through, casting the scene in a desaturated, oppressive gloom. The figure, dressed in simple, earthy, tattered linen clothing stained with dirt, contorts their body in a silent, desperate struggle. Their backs arch spasmodically, lifting their torsos from the ground, their fingers digging painfully into the soil and broken golden stalks. Their matted black hair clings to their pale, sweating faces, a mask of pure agony, their jaws clenched and their eyes squeezed shut. The camera's slow zoom in intensifies their isolation and the futility of their struggle, their bodies twisting and struggling futilely against the vast, indifferent landscape, creating an atmosphere of intense tension and desolation.", + "seed": 2606, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_0/index_2027_seed_2606_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.12297163819894194, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12297163819894194, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12297163819894194, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow zoom-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure dressed in tattered, earthy linen clothing visible writhing on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast wheat field with dark gray and bruised purple clouds in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure's face visible with matted black hair, pale skin, and eyes squeezed shut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16673442721366882 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.041734457015991 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16673442721366882, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16673442721366882, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19732756912708282, + 0.06849892437458038, + 0.06416033953428268, + 0.13538987934589386, + 0.09851991385221481, + 0.07810115814208984, + 0.0392412468791008, + 0.061111196875572205, + 0.04740418493747711, + 0.21024559438228607 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16673442721366882 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow zoom-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure dressed in tattered, earthy linen clothing visible writhing on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast wheat field with dark gray and bruised purple clouds in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure's face visible with matted black hair, pale skin, and eyes squeezed shut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34861770272254944 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223617672920227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34861770272254944, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34861770272254944, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1316273808479309, + 0.042023926973342896, + 0.06183600425720215, + 0.15043774247169495, + 0.08835504949092865, + 0.04793655127286911, + 0.13742412626743317, + 0.02809520810842514, + 0.040657397359609604, + 0.27160653471946716 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34861770272254944 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow zoom-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure dressed in tattered, earthy linen clothing visible writhing on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast wheat field with dark gray and bruised purple clouds in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure's face visible with matted black hair, pale skin, and eyes squeezed shut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007638058625161648 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882637977600098 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007638058625161648, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007638058625161648, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36435383558273315, + 0.0297299362719059, + 0.07501886039972305, + 0.052472516894340515, + 0.06093696132302284, + 0.12951186299324036, + 0.04305358976125717, + 0.13080939650535583, + 0.06964477896690369, + 0.04446827992796898 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007638058625161648 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow zoom-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure dressed in tattered, earthy linen clothing visible writhing on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast wheat field with dark gray and bruised purple clouds in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure's face visible with matted black hair, pale skin, and eyes squeezed shut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002818067092448473 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778181076049805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002818067092448473, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002818067092448473, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4623495936393738, + 0.029537411406636238, + 0.027892911806702614, + 0.12567158043384552, + 0.05446001514792442, + 0.07079029083251953, + 0.037129323929548264, + 0.018421553075313568, + 0.017603596672415733, + 0.1561436802148819 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002818067092448473 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow zoom-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure dressed in tattered, earthy linen clothing visible writhing on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast wheat field with dark gray and bruised purple clouds in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure's face visible with matted black hair, pale skin, and eyes squeezed shut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08904993534088135 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464049816131592 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08904993534088135, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08904993534088135, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2730030417442322, + 0.030992422252893448, + 0.041804056614637375, + 0.1879088431596756, + 0.1509888470172882, + 0.05736220255494118, + 0.05715353041887283, + 0.02850634790956974, + 0.03601493313908577, + 0.1362657994031906 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08904993534088135 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle shot, zooming in at an almost imperceptible pace, captures a solitary, androgynous figure writhing against the damp, dark earth of a vast wheat field. The sky above is a turbulent, brooding canvas of dark gray and bruised purple clouds, allowing only a wisp of cold, feeble light to filter through, casting the scene in a desaturated, oppressive gloom. The figure, dressed in simple, earthy, tattered linen clothing stained with dirt, contorts their body in a silent, desperate struggle. Their backs arch spasmodically, lifting their torsos from the ground, their fingers digging painfully into the soil and broken golden stalks. Their matted black hair clings to their pale, sweating faces, a mask of pure agony, their jaws clenched and their eyes squeezed shut. The camera's slow zoom in intensifies their isolation and the futility of their struggle, their bodies twisting and struggling futilely against the vast, indifferent landscape, creating an atmosphere of intense tension and desolation.", + "seed": 2607, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_0/index_2027_seed_2607_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06949792401865125, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06949792401865125, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06949792401865125, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow zoom-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure dressed in tattered, earthy linen clothing visible writhing on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast wheat field with dark gray and bruised purple clouds in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure's face visible with matted black hair, pale skin, and eyes squeezed shut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08734365552663803 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.712343692779541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08734365552663803, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08734365552663803, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07185689359903336, + 0.06612849235534668, + 0.06887305527925491, + 0.021690091118216515, + 0.02823658473789692, + 0.037972837686538696, + 0.03743024542927742, + 0.2016633003950119, + 0.4191647469997406, + 0.046983785927295685 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08734365552663803 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow zoom-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure dressed in tattered, earthy linen clothing visible writhing on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast wheat field with dark gray and bruised purple clouds in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure's face visible with matted black hair, pale skin, and eyes squeezed shut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16035276651382446 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103527069091797 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16035276651382446, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16035276651382446, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03639933094382286, + 0.07721564173698425, + 0.06499826908111572, + 0.027629442512989044, + 0.02364829182624817, + 0.018762268126010895, + 0.03941168263554573, + 0.2711575925350189, + 0.42805764079093933, + 0.012719821184873581 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16035276651382446 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow zoom-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure dressed in tattered, earthy linen clothing visible writhing on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast wheat field with dark gray and bruised purple clouds in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure's face visible with matted black hair, pale skin, and eyes squeezed shut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038098447024822235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880983352661133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038098447024822235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038098447024822235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06523691862821579, + 0.10209334641695023, + 0.027374545112252235, + 0.021910162642598152, + 0.03693697229027748, + 0.04253561794757843, + 0.05043654143810272, + 0.1905450075864792, + 0.2555435597896576, + 0.2073872685432434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038098447024822235 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow zoom-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure dressed in tattered, earthy linen clothing visible writhing on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast wheat field with dark gray and bruised purple clouds in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure's face visible with matted black hair, pale skin, and eyes squeezed shut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006738083902746439 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006738185882568 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006738083902746439, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006738083902746439, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11313415318727493, + 0.0746333971619606, + 0.26538699865341187, + 0.043951258063316345, + 0.056567639112472534, + 0.05619385465979576, + 0.040699396282434464, + 0.08915803581476212, + 0.0605485737323761, + 0.1997266709804535 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006738083902746439 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow zoom-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure dressed in tattered, earthy linen clothing visible writhing on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast wheat field with dark gray and bruised purple clouds in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure's face visible with matted black hair, pale skin, and eyes squeezed shut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495666712522507 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299566745758057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495666712522507, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495666712522507, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08469259738922119, + 0.09835898131132126, + 0.03970211744308472, + 0.03418579697608948, + 0.04490594565868378, + 0.04957098886370659, + 0.061797939240932465, + 0.15695106983184814, + 0.31335312128067017, + 0.11648143827915192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495666712522507 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, wide-angle shot, zooming in at an almost imperceptible pace, captures a solitary, androgynous figure writhing against the damp, dark earth of a vast wheat field. The sky above is a turbulent, brooding canvas of dark gray and bruised purple clouds, allowing only a wisp of cold, feeble light to filter through, casting the scene in a desaturated, oppressive gloom. The figure, dressed in simple, earthy, tattered linen clothing stained with dirt, contorts their body in a silent, desperate struggle. Their backs arch spasmodically, lifting their torsos from the ground, their fingers digging painfully into the soil and broken golden stalks. Their matted black hair clings to their pale, sweating faces, a mask of pure agony, their jaws clenched and their eyes squeezed shut. The camera's slow zoom in intensifies their isolation and the futility of their struggle, their bodies twisting and struggling futilely against the vast, indifferent landscape, creating an atmosphere of intense tension and desolation.", + "seed": 2608, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_0/index_2027_seed_2608_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1361529788002372, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1361529788002372, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.949999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1361529788002372, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow zoom-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure dressed in tattered, earthy linen clothing visible writhing on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast wheat field with dark gray and bruised purple clouds in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure's face visible with matted black hair, pale skin, and eyes squeezed shut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17895612120628357 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.928956151008606 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17895612120628357, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17895612120628357, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1426638513803482, + 0.06852816045284271, + 0.0947485864162445, + 0.07091110199689865, + 0.05611615628004074, + 0.1914578676223755, + 0.07247637957334518, + 0.046968527138233185, + 0.13620203733444214, + 0.11992734670639038 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17895612120628357 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow zoom-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure dressed in tattered, earthy linen clothing visible writhing on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast wheat field with dark gray and bruised purple clouds in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure's face visible with matted black hair, pale skin, and eyes squeezed shut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38705211877822876 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137052059173584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38705211877822876, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38705211877822876, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09428492188453674, + 0.1207083910703659, + 0.05567197874188423, + 0.08553667366504669, + 0.09750742465257645, + 0.06454218924045563, + 0.08657333254814148, + 0.043898340314626694, + 0.2542684078216553, + 0.09700831025838852 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38705211877822876 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow zoom-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure dressed in tattered, earthy linen clothing visible writhing on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast wheat field with dark gray and bruised purple clouds in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure's face visible with matted black hair, pale skin, and eyes squeezed shut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978849083185196 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634788513183594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978849083185196, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978849083185196, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11504203826189041, + 0.10227123647928238, + 0.015252458862960339, + 0.016296109184622765, + 0.05681083723902702, + 0.4779023826122284, + 0.08536534011363983, + 0.015900544822216034, + 0.021989645436406136, + 0.09316939115524292 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978849083185196 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow zoom-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure dressed in tattered, earthy linen clothing visible writhing on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast wheat field with dark gray and bruised purple clouds in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure's face visible with matted black hair, pale skin, and eyes squeezed shut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004637676291167736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379637718200684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004637676291167736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004637676291167736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06534525752067566, + 0.05858122929930687, + 0.12748895585536957, + 0.1123509407043457, + 0.04228036850690842, + 0.3807888925075531, + 0.041144948452711105, + 0.06350426375865936, + 0.0750395804643631, + 0.03347557410597801 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004637676291167736 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot taken from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera performing a slow zoom-in movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a solitary figure dressed in tattered, earthy linen clothing visible writhing on the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a vast wheat field with dark gray and bruised purple clouds in the sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure's face visible with matted black hair, pale skin, and eyes squeezed shut?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10033048689365387 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503305912017822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10033048689365387, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10033048689365387, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06364952027797699, + 0.0651729628443718, + 0.024462325498461723, + 0.053280677646398544, + 0.036843642592430115, + 0.4397542178630829, + 0.07252747565507889, + 0.028392324224114418, + 0.05013645440340042, + 0.1657804250717163 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10033048689365387 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_1/index_tensor([3833, 3833])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_1/index_tensor([3833, 3833])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..787bb5d47014e0e3dbf928504659518db81fe98f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_1/index_tensor([3833, 3833])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, medium-shot profile captures a young Asian woman immersed in a tranquil moment of artistic creation. Her raven black hair is elegantly tied into a low bun, secured with an antique wooden hairpin, with strands gently falling against her smooth face. She wears an elegant lake-blue silk cheongsam, its high stand-up collar and delicate buttons emphasizing her slender neck. The cheongsam is embroidered with a faint orchid pattern in silver thread. She sits at a large mahogany drawing table, spread with a sheet of pristine white rice paper. Soft sidelight filters in through a paper window, illuminating her focused profile and the painting she's working on. Her right hand, steady and composed, holds a slender wolf-hair brush vertically, her fingers slender yet powerful. With breathless concentration, her wrist suspended lightly, she delicately moves the tip of her brush, coloring a previously outlined koi carp pattern on rice paper. Dipping the brush in vermilion pigment, each stroke is precise, her movements slow and fluid, as if performing a sacred ritual. The painting is meticulously composed, with vibrant colors and a blurred background, revealing only a shelf displaying celadon vases. This creates a sense of intense concentration and a classical aesthetic. The clean lines and meticulous attention to detail perfectly embody the exquisite refinement of Chinese gongbi painting.", + "seed": 26844, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_1/index_3833_seed_26844_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.016302445251494647, + "vlm_logprob": -0.016302445251494647, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.016302445251494647, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young Asian woman with raven black hair tied in a low bun secured by an antique wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a lake-blue silk cheongsam with a high stand-up collar, silver thread orchid embroidery, and delicate buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting at a large mahogany drawing table with a sheet of white rice paper spread on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a slender wolf-hair brush vertically and moving it to color a koi carp pattern on the rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to reveal only a shelf displaying celadon vases while soft sidelight filters in through a paper window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02139453776180744 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8963944911956787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02139453776180744, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02139453776180744, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31188899278640747, + 0.10238005965948105, + 0.11909087002277374, + 0.06618907302618027, + 0.05372556298971176, + 0.06599245965480804, + 0.03719650208950043, + 0.1266144961118698, + 0.050893038511276245, + 0.0660289078950882 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02139453776180744 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young Asian woman with raven black hair tied in a low bun secured by an antique wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a lake-blue silk cheongsam with a high stand-up collar, silver thread orchid embroidery, and delicate buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting at a large mahogany drawing table with a sheet of white rice paper spread on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a slender wolf-hair brush vertically and moving it to color a koi carp pattern on the rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to reveal only a shelf displaying celadon vases while soft sidelight filters in through a paper window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007636402267962694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882636547088623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007636402267962694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007636402267962694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2683379650115967, + 0.11082062870264053, + 0.14708374440670013, + 0.08068372309207916, + 0.0843663364648819, + 0.060038868337869644, + 0.050543997436761856, + 0.08286143839359283, + 0.054181650280952454, + 0.0610816590487957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007636402267962694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young Asian woman with raven black hair tied in a low bun secured by an antique wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a lake-blue silk cheongsam with a high stand-up collar, silver thread orchid embroidery, and delicate buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting at a large mahogany drawing table with a sheet of white rice paper spread on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a slender wolf-hair brush vertically and moving it to color a koi carp pattern on the rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to reveal only a shelf displaying celadon vases while soft sidelight filters in through a paper window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008632130920886993 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758632183074951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008632130920886993, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008632130920886993, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29189619421958923, + 0.16113457083702087, + 0.05682232975959778, + 0.027798296883702278, + 0.043721746653318405, + 0.038561638444662094, + 0.057141467928886414, + 0.07521669566631317, + 0.1397039294242859, + 0.10800310969352722 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008632130920886993 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young Asian woman with raven black hair tied in a low bun secured by an antique wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a lake-blue silk cheongsam with a high stand-up collar, silver thread orchid embroidery, and delicate buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting at a large mahogany drawing table with a sheet of white rice paper spread on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a slender wolf-hair brush vertically and moving it to color a koi carp pattern on the rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to reveal only a shelf displaying celadon vases while soft sidelight filters in through a paper window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023277241736650467 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732772827148438 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023277241736650467, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023277241736650467, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25505954027175903, + 0.048610176891088486, + 0.07386470586061478, + 0.04334929585456848, + 0.06807650625705719, + 0.0901460349559784, + 0.13673381507396698, + 0.11049599200487137, + 0.11817776411771774, + 0.05548616126179695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023277241736650467 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young Asian woman with raven black hair tied in a low bun secured by an antique wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a lake-blue silk cheongsam with a high stand-up collar, silver thread orchid embroidery, and delicate buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting at a large mahogany drawing table with a sheet of white rice paper spread on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a slender wolf-hair brush vertically and moving it to color a koi carp pattern on the rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to reveal only a shelf displaying celadon vases while soft sidelight filters in through a paper window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020571913570165634 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955719470977783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020571913570165634, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020571913570165634, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2899739742279053, + 0.105527862906456, + 0.052173931151628494, + 0.040495116263628006, + 0.045052122324705124, + 0.12590642273426056, + 0.05556561052799225, + 0.13616697490215302, + 0.058500200510025024, + 0.09063779562711716 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020571913570165634 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, medium-shot profile captures a young Asian woman immersed in a tranquil moment of artistic creation. Her raven black hair is elegantly tied into a low bun, secured with an antique wooden hairpin, with strands gently falling against her smooth face. She wears an elegant lake-blue silk cheongsam, its high stand-up collar and delicate buttons emphasizing her slender neck. The cheongsam is embroidered with a faint orchid pattern in silver thread. She sits at a large mahogany drawing table, spread with a sheet of pristine white rice paper. Soft sidelight filters in through a paper window, illuminating her focused profile and the painting she's working on. Her right hand, steady and composed, holds a slender wolf-hair brush vertically, her fingers slender yet powerful. With breathless concentration, her wrist suspended lightly, she delicately moves the tip of her brush, coloring a previously outlined koi carp pattern on rice paper. Dipping the brush in vermilion pigment, each stroke is precise, her movements slow and fluid, as if performing a sacred ritual. The painting is meticulously composed, with vibrant colors and a blurred background, revealing only a shelf displaying celadon vases. This creates a sense of intense concentration and a classical aesthetic. The clean lines and meticulous attention to detail perfectly embody the exquisite refinement of Chinese gongbi painting.", + "seed": 26845, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_1/index_3833_seed_26845_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03159982413053512, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03159982413053512, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03159982413053512, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young Asian woman with raven black hair tied in a low bun secured by an antique wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a lake-blue silk cheongsam with a high stand-up collar, silver thread orchid embroidery, and delicate buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting at a large mahogany drawing table with a sheet of white rice paper spread on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a slender wolf-hair brush vertically and moving it to color a koi carp pattern on the rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to reveal only a shelf displaying celadon vases while soft sidelight filters in through a paper window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.049686964601278305 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.049686908721924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.049686964601278305, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.049686964601278305, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2514430284500122, + 0.08397387713193893, + 0.05906423553824425, + 0.02830296941101551, + 0.13729186356067657, + 0.04106159880757332, + 0.1445179134607315, + 0.05840187519788742, + 0.08527276664972305, + 0.11066984385251999 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.049686964601278305 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young Asian woman with raven black hair tied in a low bun secured by an antique wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a lake-blue silk cheongsam with a high stand-up collar, silver thread orchid embroidery, and delicate buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting at a large mahogany drawing table with a sheet of white rice paper spread on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a slender wolf-hair brush vertically and moving it to color a koi carp pattern on the rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to reveal only a shelf displaying celadon vases while soft sidelight filters in through a paper window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018202170729637146 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018202304840088 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018202170729637146, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018202170729637146, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16284336149692535, + 0.1077037900686264, + 0.052356429398059845, + 0.038648828864097595, + 0.10471760481595993, + 0.048065342009067535, + 0.14951477944850922, + 0.05174272134900093, + 0.15349847078323364, + 0.13090871274471283 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018202170729637146 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young Asian woman with raven black hair tied in a low bun secured by an antique wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a lake-blue silk cheongsam with a high stand-up collar, silver thread orchid embroidery, and delicate buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting at a large mahogany drawing table with a sheet of white rice paper spread on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a slender wolf-hair brush vertically and moving it to color a koi carp pattern on the rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to reveal only a shelf displaying celadon vases while soft sidelight filters in through a paper window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023282716050744057 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773282766342163 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023282716050744057, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023282716050744057, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.181282639503479, + 0.10425349324941635, + 0.0491044782102108, + 0.08625088632106781, + 0.20814399421215057, + 0.04513191059231758, + 0.03954703360795975, + 0.01906014233827591, + 0.2013523429632187, + 0.0658731758594513 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023282716050744057 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young Asian woman with raven black hair tied in a low bun secured by an antique wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a lake-blue silk cheongsam with a high stand-up collar, silver thread orchid embroidery, and delicate buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting at a large mahogany drawing table with a sheet of white rice paper spread on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a slender wolf-hair brush vertically and moving it to color a koi carp pattern on the rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to reveal only a shelf displaying celadon vases while soft sidelight filters in through a paper window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0181779395788908 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0181779861450195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0181779395788908, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0181779395788908, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3292420208454132, + 0.047525376081466675, + 0.05726170912384987, + 0.06398334354162216, + 0.06634149700403214, + 0.10992762446403503, + 0.062803715467453, + 0.04335523024201393, + 0.1348424106836319, + 0.08471700549125671 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0181779395788908 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young Asian woman with raven black hair tied in a low bun secured by an antique wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a lake-blue silk cheongsam with a high stand-up collar, silver thread orchid embroidery, and delicate buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting at a large mahogany drawing table with a sheet of white rice paper spread on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a slender wolf-hair brush vertically and moving it to color a koi carp pattern on the rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to reveal only a shelf displaying celadon vases while soft sidelight filters in through a paper window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864932969212532 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048649311065674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864932969212532, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864932969212532, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2304094433784485, + 0.09600187838077545, + 0.07707880437374115, + 0.09183194488286972, + 0.12880995869636536, + 0.06590865552425385, + 0.02696813829243183, + 0.07484228163957596, + 0.13439823687076569, + 0.07375064492225647 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864932969212532 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, medium-shot profile captures a young Asian woman immersed in a tranquil moment of artistic creation. Her raven black hair is elegantly tied into a low bun, secured with an antique wooden hairpin, with strands gently falling against her smooth face. She wears an elegant lake-blue silk cheongsam, its high stand-up collar and delicate buttons emphasizing her slender neck. The cheongsam is embroidered with a faint orchid pattern in silver thread. She sits at a large mahogany drawing table, spread with a sheet of pristine white rice paper. Soft sidelight filters in through a paper window, illuminating her focused profile and the painting she's working on. Her right hand, steady and composed, holds a slender wolf-hair brush vertically, her fingers slender yet powerful. With breathless concentration, her wrist suspended lightly, she delicately moves the tip of her brush, coloring a previously outlined koi carp pattern on rice paper. Dipping the brush in vermilion pigment, each stroke is precise, her movements slow and fluid, as if performing a sacred ritual. The painting is meticulously composed, with vibrant colors and a blurred background, revealing only a shelf displaying celadon vases. This creates a sense of intense concentration and a classical aesthetic. The clean lines and meticulous attention to detail perfectly embody the exquisite refinement of Chinese gongbi painting.", + "seed": 26846, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_1/index_3833_seed_26846_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.02445215843617916, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02445215843617916, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02445215843617916, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young Asian woman with raven black hair tied in a low bun secured by an antique wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a lake-blue silk cheongsam with a high stand-up collar, silver thread orchid embroidery, and delicate buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting at a large mahogany drawing table with a sheet of white rice paper spread on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a slender wolf-hair brush vertically and moving it to color a koi carp pattern on the rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to reveal only a shelf displaying celadon vases while soft sidelight filters in through a paper window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03914777189493179 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2891478538513184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03914777189493179, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03914777189493179, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3613436818122864, + 0.08072569221258163, + 0.04997049644589424, + 0.023809285834431648, + 0.21858705580234528, + 0.026216190308332443, + 0.04564813897013664, + 0.03838380426168442, + 0.017583342269062996, + 0.13773228228092194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03914777189493179 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young Asian woman with raven black hair tied in a low bun secured by an antique wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a lake-blue silk cheongsam with a high stand-up collar, silver thread orchid embroidery, and delicate buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting at a large mahogany drawing table with a sheet of white rice paper spread on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a slender wolf-hair brush vertically and moving it to color a koi carp pattern on the rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to reveal only a shelf displaying celadon vases while soft sidelight filters in through a paper window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00979179609566927 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634791851043701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00979179609566927, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00979179609566927, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2825835943222046, + 0.07087423652410507, + 0.039960939437150955, + 0.025955837219953537, + 0.2500402629375458, + 0.02370343916118145, + 0.033791035413742065, + 0.03796255588531494, + 0.020230980589985847, + 0.21489712595939636 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00979179609566927 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young Asian woman with raven black hair tied in a low bun secured by an antique wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a lake-blue silk cheongsam with a high stand-up collar, silver thread orchid embroidery, and delicate buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting at a large mahogany drawing table with a sheet of white rice paper spread on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a slender wolf-hair brush vertically and moving it to color a koi carp pattern on the rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to reveal only a shelf displaying celadon vases while soft sidelight filters in through a paper window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005942889489233494 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309428215026855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005942889489233494, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005942889489233494, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2884575128555298, + 0.06309285759925842, + 0.06363726407289505, + 0.03398447483778, + 0.2579067349433899, + 0.0230718944221735, + 0.027094440534710884, + 0.03971970081329346, + 0.03478856384754181, + 0.1682465672492981 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005942889489233494 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young Asian woman with raven black hair tied in a low bun secured by an antique wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a lake-blue silk cheongsam with a high stand-up collar, silver thread orchid embroidery, and delicate buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting at a large mahogany drawing table with a sheet of white rice paper spread on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a slender wolf-hair brush vertically and moving it to color a koi carp pattern on the rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to reveal only a shelf displaying celadon vases while soft sidelight filters in through a paper window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368669003248215 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408686637878418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368669003248215, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368669003248215, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08381835371255875, + 0.017089931294322014, + 0.014135305769741535, + 0.029072405770421028, + 0.6529608964920044, + 0.00984579510986805, + 0.025902558118104935, + 0.02263523079454899, + 0.01119116973131895, + 0.13334837555885315 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368669003248215 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young Asian woman with raven black hair tied in a low bun secured by an antique wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a lake-blue silk cheongsam with a high stand-up collar, silver thread orchid embroidery, and delicate buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting at a large mahogany drawing table with a sheet of white rice paper spread on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a slender wolf-hair brush vertically and moving it to color a koi carp pattern on the rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to reveal only a shelf displaying celadon vases while soft sidelight filters in through a paper window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0336916446685791 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408691644668579 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0336916446685791, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0336916446685791, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4073176085948944, + 0.08403262495994568, + 0.04167795553803444, + 0.02778846211731434, + 0.20208777487277985, + 0.02621103823184967, + 0.02467964217066765, + 0.05279460549354553, + 0.024894194677472115, + 0.10851605981588364 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0336916446685791 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, medium-shot profile captures a young Asian woman immersed in a tranquil moment of artistic creation. Her raven black hair is elegantly tied into a low bun, secured with an antique wooden hairpin, with strands gently falling against her smooth face. She wears an elegant lake-blue silk cheongsam, its high stand-up collar and delicate buttons emphasizing her slender neck. The cheongsam is embroidered with a faint orchid pattern in silver thread. She sits at a large mahogany drawing table, spread with a sheet of pristine white rice paper. Soft sidelight filters in through a paper window, illuminating her focused profile and the painting she's working on. Her right hand, steady and composed, holds a slender wolf-hair brush vertically, her fingers slender yet powerful. With breathless concentration, her wrist suspended lightly, she delicately moves the tip of her brush, coloring a previously outlined koi carp pattern on rice paper. Dipping the brush in vermilion pigment, each stroke is precise, her movements slow and fluid, as if performing a sacred ritual. The painting is meticulously composed, with vibrant colors and a blurred background, revealing only a shelf displaying celadon vases. This creates a sense of intense concentration and a classical aesthetic. The clean lines and meticulous attention to detail perfectly embody the exquisite refinement of Chinese gongbi painting.", + "seed": 26847, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_1/index_3833_seed_26847_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.016486474173143507, + "vlm_logprob": -0.016486474173143507, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.016486474173143507, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young Asian woman with raven black hair tied in a low bun secured by an antique wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a lake-blue silk cheongsam with a high stand-up collar, silver thread orchid embroidery, and delicate buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting at a large mahogany drawing table with a sheet of white rice paper spread on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a slender wolf-hair brush vertically and moving it to color a koi carp pattern on the rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to reveal only a shelf displaying celadon vases while soft sidelight filters in through a paper window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03083951212465763 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.530839443206787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03083951212465763, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03083951212465763, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2115156352519989, + 0.09144676476716995, + 0.07190295308828354, + 0.07733892649412155, + 0.33430156111717224, + 0.039173420518636703, + 0.04126628115773201, + 0.03702670708298683, + 0.042362749576568604, + 0.05366500839591026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03083951212465763 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young Asian woman with raven black hair tied in a low bun secured by an antique wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a lake-blue silk cheongsam with a high stand-up collar, silver thread orchid embroidery, and delicate buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting at a large mahogany drawing table with a sheet of white rice paper spread on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a slender wolf-hair brush vertically and moving it to color a koi carp pattern on the rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to reveal only a shelf displaying celadon vases while soft sidelight filters in through a paper window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007635456044226885 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882635593414307 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007635456044226885, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007635456044226885, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14208653569221497, + 0.06793543696403503, + 0.12601453065872192, + 0.030627276748418808, + 0.09375905245542526, + 0.3692479133605957, + 0.02989439107477665, + 0.05051475390791893, + 0.030102862045168877, + 0.059817228466272354 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007635456044226885 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young Asian woman with raven black hair tied in a low bun secured by an antique wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a lake-blue silk cheongsam with a high stand-up collar, silver thread orchid embroidery, and delicate buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting at a large mahogany drawing table with a sheet of white rice paper spread on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a slender wolf-hair brush vertically and moving it to color a koi carp pattern on the rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to reveal only a shelf displaying celadon vases while soft sidelight filters in through a paper window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002814976265653968 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877814769744873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002814976265653968, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002814976265653968, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1473567634820938, + 0.13922430574893951, + 0.06125451624393463, + 0.05863597244024277, + 0.2945776581764221, + 0.0933428481221199, + 0.06750349700450897, + 0.05741284787654877, + 0.038904137909412384, + 0.04178744554519653 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002814976265653968 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young Asian woman with raven black hair tied in a low bun secured by an antique wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a lake-blue silk cheongsam with a high stand-up collar, silver thread orchid embroidery, and delicate buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting at a large mahogany drawing table with a sheet of white rice paper spread on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a slender wolf-hair brush vertically and moving it to color a koi carp pattern on the rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to reveal only a shelf displaying celadon vases while soft sidelight filters in through a paper window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020572030916810036 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955719470977783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020572030916810036, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020572030916810036, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12274949252605438, + 0.09570810943841934, + 0.056738778948783875, + 0.0382465235888958, + 0.35584351420402527, + 0.15674038231372833, + 0.022029541432857513, + 0.10028526932001114, + 0.02405022643506527, + 0.027608241885900497 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020572030916810036 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a young Asian woman with raven black hair tied in a low bun secured by an antique wooden hairpin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a lake-blue silk cheongsam with a high stand-up collar, silver thread orchid embroidery, and delicate buttons?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman sitting at a large mahogany drawing table with a sheet of white rice paper spread on it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the woman holding a slender wolf-hair brush vertically and moving it to color a koi carp pattern on the rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to reveal only a shelf displaying celadon vases while soft sidelight filters in through a paper window?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057039551436901 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955702781677246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057039551436901, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057039551436901, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27251356840133667, + 0.245162233710289, + 0.0879727303981781, + 0.03361411765217781, + 0.14099739491939545, + 0.09632398188114166, + 0.0241115503013134, + 0.04696415737271309, + 0.023011106997728348, + 0.029329141601920128 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057039551436901 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_10/index_tensor([2823, 2823])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_10/index_tensor([2823, 2823])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d89bd1b2041314778537ba44f489e46cb448a315 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_10/index_tensor([2823, 2823])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The shot begins with an extreme close-up, focusing on an open scroll of ancient Buddhist scriptures. Handwritten Tibetan script is written in deep, powerful ink on the yellowed, fibrous paper. A rich golden ray of sunlight filters through the frame, illuminating a few lines of text with pinpoint precision. The camera then begins a slow, smooth upward tilt, countless tiny dust particles in the light drifting and flickering as if imbued with life. The camera sweeps across the bony fingers holding the scroll, finally settling on a close-up of the face of a young lama. His shaved head glows softly in the halo, his face serene and tranquil, his eyes slightly closed, his long eyelashes casting a subtle shadow on his cheeks, as if completely absorbed in the wisdom of the scriptures and the peace of the moment. He wears a heavy, traditional monk's robe of a deep ochre, its folds shimmering with rich gradations of light and shadow. The background is a dark corner of the temple. The ancient wooden walls and the blurred outline of the Buddha statue in the distance form a sharp contrast with the dramatic beam of light passing through the carved wooden window. The whole scene flows with a deep concentration and humanistic warmth in the silence, creating a spiritual and tranquil atmosphere that transcends time.", + "seed": 31034, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_10/index_2823_seed_31034_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03732386808842421, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03732386808842421, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03732386808842421, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of an open scroll containing handwritten Tibetan script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper of the scroll yellowed and fibrous, with text written in deep ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, smooth upward tilt revealing bony fingers holding the scroll and then the face of a young lama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lama wearing a heavy traditional monk's robe of deep ochre color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark temple corner featuring ancient wooden walls and a blurred Buddha statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1433674544095993 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0183675289154053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1433674544095993, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1433674544095993, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5812236666679382, + 0.04976169019937515, + 0.14815737307071686, + 0.028169918805360794, + 0.025470321998000145, + 0.04609860107302666, + 0.04745662957429886, + 0.015033125877380371, + 0.019718892872333527, + 0.038909781724214554 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1433674544095993 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of an open scroll containing handwritten Tibetan script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper of the scroll yellowed and fibrous, with text written in deep ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, smooth upward tilt revealing bony fingers holding the scroll and then the face of a young lama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lama wearing a heavy traditional monk's robe of deep ochre color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark temple corner featuring ancient wooden walls and a blurred Buddha statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009809266775846481 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634809494018555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009809266775846481, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009809266775846481, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24689200520515442, + 0.10461954772472382, + 0.04635277017951012, + 0.05843634158372879, + 0.0466974638402462, + 0.07567008584737778, + 0.16438037157058716, + 0.09079815447330475, + 0.10391370952129364, + 0.062239523977041245 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009809266775846481 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of an open scroll containing handwritten Tibetan script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper of the scroll yellowed and fibrous, with text written in deep ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, smooth upward tilt revealing bony fingers holding the scroll and then the face of a young lama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lama wearing a heavy traditional monk's robe of deep ochre color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark temple corner featuring ancient wooden walls and a blurred Buddha statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031931623816490173 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753193378448486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031931623816490173, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031931623816490173, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05572417750954628, + 0.06875339895486832, + 0.06936332583427429, + 0.07374535501003265, + 0.04751432314515114, + 0.09687391668558121, + 0.23437058925628662, + 0.07951538264751434, + 0.12739138305187225, + 0.1467481404542923 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031931623816490173 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of an open scroll containing handwritten Tibetan script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper of the scroll yellowed and fibrous, with text written in deep ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, smooth upward tilt revealing bony fingers holding the scroll and then the face of a young lama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lama wearing a heavy traditional monk's robe of deep ochre color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark temple corner featuring ancient wooden walls and a blurred Buddha statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606273651123047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410627365112305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606273651123047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606273651123047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2533229887485504, + 0.062264248728752136, + 0.04944470897316933, + 0.03456366807222366, + 0.05825424566864967, + 0.06903287023305893, + 0.16860534250736237, + 0.12962408363819122, + 0.082488514482975, + 0.09239935874938965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606273651123047 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of an open scroll containing handwritten Tibetan script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper of the scroll yellowed and fibrous, with text written in deep ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, smooth upward tilt revealing bony fingers holding the scroll and then the face of a young lama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lama wearing a heavy traditional monk's robe of deep ochre color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark temple corner featuring ancient wooden walls and a blurred Buddha statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014186720363795757 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264186859130859 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014186720363795757, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014186720363795757, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29550689458847046, + 0.02418369986116886, + 0.10924572497606277, + 0.020162345841526985, + 0.04286445677280426, + 0.11075287312269211, + 0.12074469774961472, + 0.08529476821422577, + 0.03971663489937782, + 0.15152786672115326 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014186720363795757 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The shot begins with an extreme close-up, focusing on an open scroll of ancient Buddhist scriptures. Handwritten Tibetan script is written in deep, powerful ink on the yellowed, fibrous paper. A rich golden ray of sunlight filters through the frame, illuminating a few lines of text with pinpoint precision. The camera then begins a slow, smooth upward tilt, countless tiny dust particles in the light drifting and flickering as if imbued with life. The camera sweeps across the bony fingers holding the scroll, finally settling on a close-up of the face of a young lama. His shaved head glows softly in the halo, his face serene and tranquil, his eyes slightly closed, his long eyelashes casting a subtle shadow on his cheeks, as if completely absorbed in the wisdom of the scriptures and the peace of the moment. He wears a heavy, traditional monk's robe of a deep ochre, its folds shimmering with rich gradations of light and shadow. The background is a dark corner of the temple. The ancient wooden walls and the blurred outline of the Buddha statue in the distance form a sharp contrast with the dramatic beam of light passing through the carved wooden window. The whole scene flows with a deep concentration and humanistic warmth in the silence, creating a spiritual and tranquil atmosphere that transcends time.", + "seed": 31035, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_10/index_2823_seed_31035_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.018836873094551267, + "vlm_logprob": -0.018836873094551267, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.018836873094551267, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of an open scroll containing handwritten Tibetan script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper of the scroll yellowed and fibrous, with text written in deep ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, smooth upward tilt revealing bony fingers holding the scroll and then the face of a young lama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lama wearing a heavy traditional monk's robe of deep ochre color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark temple corner featuring ancient wooden walls and a blurred Buddha statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.049209874123334885 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0492098331451416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.049209874123334885, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.049209874123334885, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17493586242198944, + 0.0727224200963974, + 0.15140356123447418, + 0.215618297457695, + 0.03184150531888008, + 0.04600095748901367, + 0.04496391862630844, + 0.10846439749002457, + 0.11153227835893631, + 0.042516812682151794 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.049209874123334885 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of an open scroll containing handwritten Tibetan script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper of the scroll yellowed and fibrous, with text written in deep ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, smooth upward tilt revealing bony fingers holding the scroll and then the face of a young lama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lama wearing a heavy traditional monk's robe of deep ochre color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark temple corner featuring ancient wooden walls and a blurred Buddha statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008666994981467724 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586669921875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008666994981467724, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008666994981467724, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11965752393007278, + 0.0724690854549408, + 0.15112897753715515, + 0.20747250318527222, + 0.05957707017660141, + 0.0768284946680069, + 0.09519115835428238, + 0.08628293871879578, + 0.08906994014978409, + 0.04232223704457283 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008666994981467724 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of an open scroll containing handwritten Tibetan script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper of the scroll yellowed and fibrous, with text written in deep ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, smooth upward tilt revealing bony fingers holding the scroll and then the face of a young lama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lama wearing a heavy traditional monk's robe of deep ochre color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark temple corner featuring ancient wooden walls and a blurred Buddha statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013380631571635604 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626338005065918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013380631571635604, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013380631571635604, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11369412392377853, + 0.08622629195451736, + 0.05395559221506119, + 0.08552148193120956, + 0.12358734756708145, + 0.10405983030796051, + 0.09392493963241577, + 0.155709907412529, + 0.1052606925368309, + 0.07805975526571274 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013380631571635604 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of an open scroll containing handwritten Tibetan script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper of the scroll yellowed and fibrous, with text written in deep ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, smooth upward tilt revealing bony fingers holding the scroll and then the face of a young lama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lama wearing a heavy traditional monk's robe of deep ochre color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark temple corner featuring ancient wooden walls and a blurred Buddha statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008634849451482296 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586350440979 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008634849451482296, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008634849451482296, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06940434128046036, + 0.062980055809021, + 0.0734255313873291, + 0.08242175728082657, + 0.15892980992794037, + 0.11103861778974533, + 0.0575982965528965, + 0.14971007406711578, + 0.18164481222629547, + 0.05284667760133743 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008634849451482296 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of an open scroll containing handwritten Tibetan script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper of the scroll yellowed and fibrous, with text written in deep ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, smooth upward tilt revealing bony fingers holding the scroll and then the face of a young lama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lama wearing a heavy traditional monk's robe of deep ochre color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark temple corner featuring ancient wooden walls and a blurred Buddha statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02633458375930786 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651334524154663 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02633458375930786, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02633458375930786, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11803868412971497, + 0.03635173290967941, + 0.06498352438211441, + 0.05874817445874214, + 0.0611286424100399, + 0.08690395951271057, + 0.12880529463291168, + 0.18765106797218323, + 0.208639994263649, + 0.04874894395470619 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02633458375930786 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The shot begins with an extreme close-up, focusing on an open scroll of ancient Buddhist scriptures. Handwritten Tibetan script is written in deep, powerful ink on the yellowed, fibrous paper. A rich golden ray of sunlight filters through the frame, illuminating a few lines of text with pinpoint precision. The camera then begins a slow, smooth upward tilt, countless tiny dust particles in the light drifting and flickering as if imbued with life. The camera sweeps across the bony fingers holding the scroll, finally settling on a close-up of the face of a young lama. His shaved head glows softly in the halo, his face serene and tranquil, his eyes slightly closed, his long eyelashes casting a subtle shadow on his cheeks, as if completely absorbed in the wisdom of the scriptures and the peace of the moment. He wears a heavy, traditional monk's robe of a deep ochre, its folds shimmering with rich gradations of light and shadow. The background is a dark corner of the temple. The ancient wooden walls and the blurred outline of the Buddha statue in the distance form a sharp contrast with the dramatic beam of light passing through the carved wooden window. The whole scene flows with a deep concentration and humanistic warmth in the silence, creating a spiritual and tranquil atmosphere that transcends time.", + "seed": 31036, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_10/index_2823_seed_31036_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.01094225631095469, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01094225631095469, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01094225631095469, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of an open scroll containing handwritten Tibetan script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper of the scroll yellowed and fibrous, with text written in deep ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, smooth upward tilt revealing bony fingers holding the scroll and then the face of a young lama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lama wearing a heavy traditional monk's robe of deep ochre color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark temple corner featuring ancient wooden walls and a blurred Buddha statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016884388402104378 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1418843269348145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016884388402104378, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016884388402104378, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1351592093706131, + 0.055955324321985245, + 0.04840710014104843, + 0.12230280786752701, + 0.10116200149059296, + 0.34769827127456665, + 0.05439674109220505, + 0.06779918074607849, + 0.050471290946006775, + 0.016648100689053535 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016884388402104378 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of an open scroll containing handwritten Tibetan script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper of the scroll yellowed and fibrous, with text written in deep ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, smooth upward tilt revealing bony fingers holding the scroll and then the face of a young lama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lama wearing a heavy traditional monk's robe of deep ochre color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark temple corner featuring ancient wooden walls and a blurred Buddha statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005276206880807877 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255276203155518 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005276206880807877, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005276206880807877, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12845319509506226, + 0.042157258838415146, + 0.044808950275182724, + 0.1295362114906311, + 0.05691732466220856, + 0.199333056807518, + 0.1944611817598343, + 0.08362177759408951, + 0.04433416947722435, + 0.07637687027454376 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005276206880807877 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of an open scroll containing handwritten Tibetan script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper of the scroll yellowed and fibrous, with text written in deep ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, smooth upward tilt revealing bony fingers holding the scroll and then the face of a young lama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lama wearing a heavy traditional monk's robe of deep ochre color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark temple corner featuring ancient wooden walls and a blurred Buddha statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022005646023899317 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127200603485107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022005646023899317, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022005646023899317, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09039930254220963, + 0.06008034199476242, + 0.0644918903708458, + 0.14588455855846405, + 0.052670832723379135, + 0.19983583688735962, + 0.21540305018424988, + 0.05498107522726059, + 0.07209740579128265, + 0.044155705720186234 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022005646023899317 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of an open scroll containing handwritten Tibetan script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper of the scroll yellowed and fibrous, with text written in deep ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, smooth upward tilt revealing bony fingers holding the scroll and then the face of a young lama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lama wearing a heavy traditional monk's robe of deep ochre color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark temple corner featuring ancient wooden walls and a blurred Buddha statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009777040220797062 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634777069091797 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009777040220797062, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009777040220797062, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05089404433965683, + 0.04983203858137131, + 0.021408341825008392, + 0.03514840453863144, + 0.05626707524061203, + 0.14373581111431122, + 0.13883109390735626, + 0.09216789901256561, + 0.04382822662591934, + 0.36788707971572876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009777040220797062 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of an open scroll containing handwritten Tibetan script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper of the scroll yellowed and fibrous, with text written in deep ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, smooth upward tilt revealing bony fingers holding the scroll and then the face of a young lama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lama wearing a heavy traditional monk's robe of deep ochre color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark temple corner featuring ancient wooden walls and a blurred Buddha statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020573081448674202 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895573139190674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020573081448674202, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020573081448674202, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12651683390140533, + 0.026727819815278053, + 0.01211378164589405, + 0.036318350583314896, + 0.02992483787238598, + 0.15313366055488586, + 0.4228992462158203, + 0.07491309940814972, + 0.062321506440639496, + 0.05513084679841995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020573081448674202 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The shot begins with an extreme close-up, focusing on an open scroll of ancient Buddhist scriptures. Handwritten Tibetan script is written in deep, powerful ink on the yellowed, fibrous paper. A rich golden ray of sunlight filters through the frame, illuminating a few lines of text with pinpoint precision. The camera then begins a slow, smooth upward tilt, countless tiny dust particles in the light drifting and flickering as if imbued with life. The camera sweeps across the bony fingers holding the scroll, finally settling on a close-up of the face of a young lama. His shaved head glows softly in the halo, his face serene and tranquil, his eyes slightly closed, his long eyelashes casting a subtle shadow on his cheeks, as if completely absorbed in the wisdom of the scriptures and the peace of the moment. He wears a heavy, traditional monk's robe of a deep ochre, its folds shimmering with rich gradations of light and shadow. The background is a dark corner of the temple. The ancient wooden walls and the blurred outline of the Buddha statue in the distance form a sharp contrast with the dramatic beam of light passing through the carved wooden window. The whole scene flows with a deep concentration and humanistic warmth in the silence, creating a spiritual and tranquil atmosphere that transcends time.", + "seed": 31037, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_10/index_2823_seed_31037_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.033863567747175694, + "vlm_logprob": -0.033863567747175694, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.033863567747175694, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of an open scroll containing handwritten Tibetan script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper of the scroll yellowed and fibrous, with text written in deep ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, smooth upward tilt revealing bony fingers holding the scroll and then the face of a young lama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lama wearing a heavy traditional monk's robe of deep ochre color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark temple corner featuring ancient wooden walls and a blurred Buddha statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07986776530742645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5798678398132324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07986776530742645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07986776530742645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23176635801792145, + 0.07271693646907806, + 0.0573788583278656, + 0.055565230548381805, + 0.08037984371185303, + 0.21409942209720612, + 0.12730258703231812, + 0.07412248849868774, + 0.04083504527807236, + 0.045833274722099304 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07986776530742645 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of an open scroll containing handwritten Tibetan script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper of the scroll yellowed and fibrous, with text written in deep ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, smooth upward tilt revealing bony fingers holding the scroll and then the face of a young lama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lama wearing a heavy traditional monk's robe of deep ochre color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark temple corner featuring ancient wooden walls and a blurred Buddha statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01610919088125229 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141108989715576 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01610919088125229, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01610919088125229, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12982462346553802, + 0.0731508880853653, + 0.0569101944565773, + 0.0999486893415451, + 0.19137108325958252, + 0.20794330537319183, + 0.04666227847337723, + 0.042032863944768906, + 0.09568940103054047, + 0.05646669492125511 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01610919088125229 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of an open scroll containing handwritten Tibetan script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper of the scroll yellowed and fibrous, with text written in deep ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, smooth upward tilt revealing bony fingers holding the scroll and then the face of a young lama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lama wearing a heavy traditional monk's robe of deep ochre color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark temple corner featuring ancient wooden walls and a blurred Buddha statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008640640415251255 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758640766143799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008640640415251255, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008640640415251255, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1331438273191452, + 0.05631976202130318, + 0.030242057517170906, + 0.03346427157521248, + 0.3049582540988922, + 0.05691099166870117, + 0.1062416210770607, + 0.11686833202838898, + 0.10136425495147705, + 0.0604865737259388 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008640640415251255 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of an open scroll containing handwritten Tibetan script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper of the scroll yellowed and fibrous, with text written in deep ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, smooth upward tilt revealing bony fingers holding the scroll and then the face of a young lama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lama wearing a heavy traditional monk's robe of deep ochre color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark temple corner featuring ancient wooden walls and a blurred Buddha statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016062267124652863 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141062259674072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016062267124652863, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016062267124652863, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08263976126909256, + 0.02823965810239315, + 0.013163707219064236, + 0.01686513051390648, + 0.397786945104599, + 0.16972379386425018, + 0.11180132627487183, + 0.07039246708154678, + 0.06980200111865997, + 0.03958521783351898 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016062267124652863 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with an extreme close-up of an open scroll containing handwritten Tibetan script?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the paper of the scroll yellowed and fibrous, with text written in deep ink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow, smooth upward tilt revealing bony fingers holding the scroll and then the face of a young lama?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the lama wearing a heavy traditional monk's robe of deep ochre color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a dark temple corner featuring ancient wooden walls and a blurred Buddha statue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04863797500729561 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048637866973877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04863797500729561, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04863797500729561, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04419485107064247, + 0.02547033503651619, + 0.016574863344430923, + 0.016013843938708305, + 0.3510534465312958, + 0.17182624340057373, + 0.13696439564228058, + 0.1021798774600029, + 0.10621076822280884, + 0.029511429369449615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04863797500729561 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_11/index_tensor([6992, 6992])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_11/index_tensor([6992, 6992])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9e0bbcbfaf2cbe72896afa907ea598bf40e48f36 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_11/index_tensor([6992, 6992])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle tracking shot follows a herd of majestic wild horses, each galloping at the same pace across a vast, sun-drenched prairie. The camera gently shakes, simulating the vibrations of the ground beneath the horses' hooves. The camera closely follows the lead stallion, a powerful, dark-colored beast, its obsidian-smooth coat gleaming in the low, golden afternoon sun, highlighting every inch of its bulging muscles. Its eyes widen with unwavering determination, its nostrils flaring, its powerful leg muscles rhythmically contracting and releasing as it gallops with an earth-devouring momentum, its wild, unruly manes and long tails whipped back fiercely by the strong wind. Behind it, the entire herd—a blend of dark browns, rich chestnuts, and earthy grays—rushes forward in a powerful, unified gesture, their long manes and tails billowing wildly in the wind like silk banners. Thundering hooves thump across the dry ground, kicking up clouds of golden dust that swirls in the light, creating a luminous, ethereal mist around the horses, a stark contrast to the vast blue sky overhead. The entire scene is a magnificent spectacle of raw power and unfettered freedom, imbued with epic movement and untamed vitality, framed by warm tones and a powerful, solemn atmosphere.", + "seed": 11756, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_11/index_6992_seed_11756_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07897140868008137, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07897140868008137, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07897140868008137, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched prairie with a blue sky overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a herd of wild horses galloping across the prairie at the same pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lead horse a dark-colored stallion with an obsidian-smooth coat and bulging muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a low-angle tracking shot that closely follows the lead stallion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a gentle shake simulating ground vibrations while golden dust swirls around the horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.027518099173903465 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6525180339813232 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.027518099173903465, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.027518099173903465, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1371607631444931, + 0.044229451566934586, + 0.3355241119861603, + 0.019549813121557236, + 0.03832143545150757, + 0.09453848004341125, + 0.040904268622398376, + 0.22259950637817383, + 0.03448078781366348, + 0.03269137069582939 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.027518099173903465 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched prairie with a blue sky overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a herd of wild horses galloping across the prairie at the same pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lead horse a dark-colored stallion with an obsidian-smooth coat and bulging muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a low-angle tracking shot that closely follows the lead stallion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a gentle shake simulating ground vibrations while golden dust swirls around the horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2256004363298416 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006004810333252 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2256004363298416, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2256004363298416, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1362573206424713, + 0.08210007101297379, + 0.1351875364780426, + 0.03492738679051399, + 0.07672398537397385, + 0.08198780566453934, + 0.15744179487228394, + 0.11394092440605164, + 0.10867217183113098, + 0.07276099920272827 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2256004363298416 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched prairie with a blue sky overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a herd of wild horses galloping across the prairie at the same pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lead horse a dark-colored stallion with an obsidian-smooth coat and bulging muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a low-angle tracking shot that closely follows the lead stallion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a gentle shake simulating ground vibrations while golden dust swirls around the horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054977767169475555 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299776554107666 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054977767169475555, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054977767169475555, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26393434405326843, + 0.07119433581829071, + 0.12553678452968597, + 0.04940315708518028, + 0.06784747540950775, + 0.05067066848278046, + 0.09156246483325958, + 0.10613533109426498, + 0.08642587065696716, + 0.08728964626789093 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054977767169475555 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched prairie with a blue sky overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a herd of wild horses galloping across the prairie at the same pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lead horse a dark-colored stallion with an obsidian-smooth coat and bulging muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a low-angle tracking shot that closely follows the lead stallion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a gentle shake simulating ground vibrations while golden dust swirls around the horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864978417754173 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048649787902832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864978417754173, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864978417754173, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2014279067516327, + 0.09419040381908417, + 0.10725948959589005, + 0.07511495798826218, + 0.03563345968723297, + 0.06479930877685547, + 0.06919814646244049, + 0.1293942928314209, + 0.06901267170906067, + 0.1539693921804428 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864978417754173 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched prairie with a blue sky overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a herd of wild horses galloping across the prairie at the same pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lead horse a dark-colored stallion with an obsidian-smooth coat and bulging muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a low-angle tracking shot that closely follows the lead stallion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a gentle shake simulating ground vibrations while golden dust swirls around the horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811095654964447 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881109714508057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811095654964447, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811095654964447, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3508056402206421, + 0.09754984080791473, + 0.08015985041856766, + 0.030042627826333046, + 0.08108539134263992, + 0.019973961636424065, + 0.047443412244319916, + 0.10668748617172241, + 0.11798914521932602, + 0.06826263666152954 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811095654964447 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle tracking shot follows a herd of majestic wild horses, each galloping at the same pace across a vast, sun-drenched prairie. The camera gently shakes, simulating the vibrations of the ground beneath the horses' hooves. The camera closely follows the lead stallion, a powerful, dark-colored beast, its obsidian-smooth coat gleaming in the low, golden afternoon sun, highlighting every inch of its bulging muscles. Its eyes widen with unwavering determination, its nostrils flaring, its powerful leg muscles rhythmically contracting and releasing as it gallops with an earth-devouring momentum, its wild, unruly manes and long tails whipped back fiercely by the strong wind. Behind it, the entire herd—a blend of dark browns, rich chestnuts, and earthy grays—rushes forward in a powerful, unified gesture, their long manes and tails billowing wildly in the wind like silk banners. Thundering hooves thump across the dry ground, kicking up clouds of golden dust that swirls in the light, creating a luminous, ethereal mist around the horses, a stark contrast to the vast blue sky overhead. The entire scene is a magnificent spectacle of raw power and unfettered freedom, imbued with epic movement and untamed vitality, framed by warm tones and a powerful, solemn atmosphere.", + "seed": 11757, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_11/index_6992_seed_11757_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04771850053220987, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04771850053220987, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04771850053220987, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched prairie with a blue sky overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a herd of wild horses galloping across the prairie at the same pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lead horse a dark-colored stallion with an obsidian-smooth coat and bulging muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a low-angle tracking shot that closely follows the lead stallion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a gentle shake simulating ground vibrations while golden dust swirls around the horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012972132302820683 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387972354888916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012972132302820683, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012972132302820683, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14396587014198303, + 0.06461013108491898, + 0.10472074151039124, + 0.04184496030211449, + 0.21383064985275269, + 0.16317303478717804, + 0.022304192185401917, + 0.08020428568124771, + 0.07392860949039459, + 0.09141752868890762 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012972132302820683 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched prairie with a blue sky overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a herd of wild horses galloping across the prairie at the same pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lead horse a dark-colored stallion with an obsidian-smooth coat and bulging muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a low-angle tracking shot that closely follows the lead stallion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a gentle shake simulating ground vibrations while golden dust swirls around the horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11294714361429214 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379472255706787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11294714361429214, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11294714361429214, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09313621371984482, + 0.052465979009866714, + 0.17093908786773682, + 0.04696263000369072, + 0.08414604514837265, + 0.14402474462985992, + 0.051966242492198944, + 0.059456948190927505, + 0.10212533921003342, + 0.1947767287492752 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11294714361429214 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched prairie with a blue sky overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a herd of wild horses galloping across the prairie at the same pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lead horse a dark-colored stallion with an obsidian-smooth coat and bulging muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a low-angle tracking shot that closely follows the lead stallion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a gentle shake simulating ground vibrations while golden dust swirls around the horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038104645907878876 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.28810453414917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038104645907878876, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038104645907878876, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07239825278520584, + 0.13638421893119812, + 0.115375816822052, + 0.14011071622371674, + 0.09363117814064026, + 0.16335956752300262, + 0.03290548920631409, + 0.08413378149271011, + 0.026847967877984047, + 0.13485297560691833 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038104645907878876 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched prairie with a blue sky overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a herd of wild horses galloping across the prairie at the same pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lead horse a dark-colored stallion with an obsidian-smooth coat and bulging muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a low-angle tracking shot that closely follows the lead stallion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a gentle shake simulating ground vibrations while golden dust swirls around the horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620272234082222 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120272159576416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620272234082222, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620272234082222, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10840672999620438, + 0.15280911326408386, + 0.15338556468486786, + 0.031614091247320175, + 0.10928905755281448, + 0.08924879133701324, + 0.07126560062170029, + 0.17803040146827698, + 0.040256332606077194, + 0.06569431722164154 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620272234082222 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched prairie with a blue sky overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a herd of wild horses galloping across the prairie at the same pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lead horse a dark-colored stallion with an obsidian-smooth coat and bulging muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a low-angle tracking shot that closely follows the lead stallion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a gentle shake simulating ground vibrations while golden dust swirls around the horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012541357427835464 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875412940979 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012541357427835464, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012541357427835464, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03711090609431267, + 0.07316741347312927, + 0.03699284791946411, + 0.016370248049497604, + 0.04762236773967743, + 0.021121736615896225, + 0.02517802082002163, + 0.08071058988571167, + 0.033444371074438095, + 0.6282815337181091 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012541357427835464 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle tracking shot follows a herd of majestic wild horses, each galloping at the same pace across a vast, sun-drenched prairie. The camera gently shakes, simulating the vibrations of the ground beneath the horses' hooves. The camera closely follows the lead stallion, a powerful, dark-colored beast, its obsidian-smooth coat gleaming in the low, golden afternoon sun, highlighting every inch of its bulging muscles. Its eyes widen with unwavering determination, its nostrils flaring, its powerful leg muscles rhythmically contracting and releasing as it gallops with an earth-devouring momentum, its wild, unruly manes and long tails whipped back fiercely by the strong wind. Behind it, the entire herd—a blend of dark browns, rich chestnuts, and earthy grays—rushes forward in a powerful, unified gesture, their long manes and tails billowing wildly in the wind like silk banners. Thundering hooves thump across the dry ground, kicking up clouds of golden dust that swirls in the light, creating a luminous, ethereal mist around the horses, a stark contrast to the vast blue sky overhead. The entire scene is a magnificent spectacle of raw power and unfettered freedom, imbued with epic movement and untamed vitality, framed by warm tones and a powerful, solemn atmosphere.", + "seed": 11758, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_11/index_6992_seed_11758_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.039703100174665454, + "vlm_logprob": -0.039703100174665454, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.039703100174665454, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched prairie with a blue sky overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a herd of wild horses galloping across the prairie at the same pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lead horse a dark-colored stallion with an obsidian-smooth coat and bulging muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a low-angle tracking shot that closely follows the lead stallion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a gentle shake simulating ground vibrations while golden dust swirls around the horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04436859115958214 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1693685054779053 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04436859115958214, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04436859115958214, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21603812277317047, + 0.1041179671883583, + 0.0703304335474968, + 0.06825951486825943, + 0.054625771939754486, + 0.1468522995710373, + 0.02838737703859806, + 0.04916023463010788, + 0.11511694639921188, + 0.14711135625839233 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04436859115958214 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched prairie with a blue sky overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a herd of wild horses galloping across the prairie at the same pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lead horse a dark-colored stallion with an obsidian-smooth coat and bulging muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a low-angle tracking shot that closely follows the lead stallion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a gentle shake simulating ground vibrations while golden dust swirls around the horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890413150191307 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464041233062744 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0890413150191307, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0890413150191307, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09132302552461624, + 0.08494404703378677, + 0.04382826015353203, + 0.24428343772888184, + 0.06854501366615295, + 0.11392366141080856, + 0.12890496850013733, + 0.05102201923727989, + 0.03815722092986107, + 0.13506829738616943 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0890413150191307 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched prairie with a blue sky overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a herd of wild horses galloping across the prairie at the same pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lead horse a dark-colored stallion with an obsidian-smooth coat and bulging muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a low-angle tracking shot that closely follows the lead stallion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a gentle shake simulating ground vibrations while golden dust swirls around the horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020583124831318855 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895583152770996 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020583124831318855, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020583124831318855, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07866927236318588, + 0.05699777603149414, + 0.16531504690647125, + 0.059196412563323975, + 0.27871474623680115, + 0.06952996551990509, + 0.04970163479447365, + 0.029273157939314842, + 0.09989839047193527, + 0.11270356923341751 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020583124831318855 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched prairie with a blue sky overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a herd of wild horses galloping across the prairie at the same pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lead horse a dark-colored stallion with an obsidian-smooth coat and bulging muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a low-angle tracking shot that closely follows the lead stallion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a gentle shake simulating ground vibrations while golden dust swirls around the horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026334932073950768 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513350009918213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026334932073950768, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026334932073950768, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16762323677539825, + 0.03907444328069687, + 0.03158710151910782, + 0.0681966245174408, + 0.09792038798332214, + 0.1326112151145935, + 0.08515124022960663, + 0.07954771816730499, + 0.17751629650592804, + 0.12077174335718155 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026334932073950768 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched prairie with a blue sky overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a herd of wild horses galloping across the prairie at the same pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lead horse a dark-colored stallion with an obsidian-smooth coat and bulging muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a low-angle tracking shot that closely follows the lead stallion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a gentle shake simulating ground vibrations while golden dust swirls around the horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018187537789344788 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187522888184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018187537789344788, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018187537789344788, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11886044591665268, + 0.04500756785273552, + 0.04315125569701195, + 0.1268444061279297, + 0.08533541858196259, + 0.24947360157966614, + 0.05585181340575218, + 0.11740472912788391, + 0.056840505450963974, + 0.10123027861118317 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018187537789344788 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, low-angle tracking shot follows a herd of majestic wild horses, each galloping at the same pace across a vast, sun-drenched prairie. The camera gently shakes, simulating the vibrations of the ground beneath the horses' hooves. The camera closely follows the lead stallion, a powerful, dark-colored beast, its obsidian-smooth coat gleaming in the low, golden afternoon sun, highlighting every inch of its bulging muscles. Its eyes widen with unwavering determination, its nostrils flaring, its powerful leg muscles rhythmically contracting and releasing as it gallops with an earth-devouring momentum, its wild, unruly manes and long tails whipped back fiercely by the strong wind. Behind it, the entire herd—a blend of dark browns, rich chestnuts, and earthy grays—rushes forward in a powerful, unified gesture, their long manes and tails billowing wildly in the wind like silk banners. Thundering hooves thump across the dry ground, kicking up clouds of golden dust that swirls in the light, creating a luminous, ethereal mist around the horses, a stark contrast to the vast blue sky overhead. The entire scene is a magnificent spectacle of raw power and unfettered freedom, imbued with epic movement and untamed vitality, framed by warm tones and a powerful, solemn atmosphere.", + "seed": 11759, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_11/index_6992_seed_11759_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.05771000683307648, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05771000683307648, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.049999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05771000683307648, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched prairie with a blue sky overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a herd of wild horses galloping across the prairie at the same pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lead horse a dark-colored stallion with an obsidian-smooth coat and bulging muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a low-angle tracking shot that closely follows the lead stallion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a gentle shake simulating ground vibrations while golden dust swirls around the horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04966983571648598 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0496697425842285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04966983571648598, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04966983571648598, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21745531260967255, + 0.13198594748973846, + 0.07095436006784439, + 0.0689370334148407, + 0.2476247400045395, + 0.03870600461959839, + 0.05461219698190689, + 0.046233803033828735, + 0.028261248022317886, + 0.0952293649315834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04966983571648598 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched prairie with a blue sky overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a herd of wild horses galloping across the prairie at the same pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lead horse a dark-colored stallion with an obsidian-smooth coat and bulging muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a low-angle tracking shot that closely follows the lead stallion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a gentle shake simulating ground vibrations while golden dust swirls around the horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12706002593040466 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270599365234375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12706002593040466, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12706002593040466, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09545036405324936, + 0.07650312036275864, + 0.0772925317287445, + 0.047522179782390594, + 0.2805493474006653, + 0.054474979639053345, + 0.09641404449939728, + 0.04565686732530594, + 0.1759202927350998, + 0.05021623149514198 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12706002593040466 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched prairie with a blue sky overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a herd of wild horses galloping across the prairie at the same pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lead horse a dark-colored stallion with an obsidian-smooth coat and bulging muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a low-angle tracking shot that closely follows the lead stallion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a gentle shake simulating ground vibrations while golden dust swirls around the horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370928019285202 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087092876434326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370928019285202, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370928019285202, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11166049540042877, + 0.06662001460790634, + 0.04897800460457802, + 0.2148372232913971, + 0.06332996487617493, + 0.04888158664107323, + 0.07525523751974106, + 0.25157734751701355, + 0.04220028221607208, + 0.07665981352329254 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370928019285202 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched prairie with a blue sky overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a herd of wild horses galloping across the prairie at the same pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lead horse a dark-colored stallion with an obsidian-smooth coat and bulging muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a low-angle tracking shot that closely follows the lead stallion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a gentle shake simulating ground vibrations while golden dust swirls around the horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06203360855579376 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120336532592773 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06203360855579376, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06203360855579376, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11553967744112015, + 0.08725941926240921, + 0.09292005747556686, + 0.04516948387026787, + 0.27461859583854675, + 0.08028517663478851, + 0.0522947758436203, + 0.09775117039680481, + 0.0823008194565773, + 0.07186079770326614 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06203360855579376 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a vast, sun-drenched prairie with a blue sky overhead?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a herd of wild horses galloping across the prairie at the same pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lead horse a dark-colored stallion with an obsidian-smooth coat and bulging muscles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use a low-angle tracking shot that closely follows the lead stallion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a gentle shake simulating ground vibrations while golden dust swirls around the horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016077283769845963 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141077518463135 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016077283769845963, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016077283769845963, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2666708827018738, + 0.08771612495183945, + 0.03957664221525192, + 0.028026051819324493, + 0.20338982343673706, + 0.08090294897556305, + 0.04533849284052849, + 0.08333522826433182, + 0.040950700640678406, + 0.12409316003322601 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016077283769845963 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_12/index_tensor([2790, 2790])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_12/index_tensor([2790, 2790])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1bb9c7f73ff4ae90bafe4bf8482188b38586bbd9 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_12/index_tensor([2790, 2790])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level close-up initially focuses on a stack of official tax documents resting on a cold, heavily scratched metal table in a dark industrial office. A single, intense overhead light source casts a pool of high-contrast brilliance onto the scene, causing deep grooves to shimmer across the table's surface and cast deep shadows into the surrounding space. Suddenly, a powerful gust of air from an off-screen fan bursts into the frame, causing the topmost document to whip violently forward, directly toward the viewer. As this single form, replete with intricate, densely packed black ink sheets and the distinctive markings of red and blue customs stamps, begins to tumble chaotically through the air, the camera initiates a smooth, steady dolly to the right. The camera perfectly tracks the document's erratic flight path, allowing it to flip and twist against the desolate, shadowy backdrop of a bare concrete wall, keeping it centered, its edges trembling wildly, creating a tense and dramatic atmosphere of sudden bureaucratic upheaval.", + "seed": 19715, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_12/index_2790_seed_19715_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.16083916686475278, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16083916686475278, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.4999999523162844, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16083916686475278, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static, eye-level close-up of a stack of official tax documents on a heavily scratched metal table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single intense overhead light source creating high contrast, shimmering grooves, and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a gust of air cause the top document to whip forward and tumble chaotically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly to the right to track the document's flight path against a bare concrete wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the documents visibly marked with intricate black ink and distinctive red and blue customs stamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3519555628299713 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.226955533027649 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3519555628299713, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3519555628299713, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09165694564580917, + 0.02270861342549324, + 0.015300733968615532, + 0.07182848453521729, + 0.012331278063356876, + 0.03425447270274162, + 0.521582305431366, + 0.1381485015153885, + 0.01570146158337593, + 0.07648729532957077 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3519555628299713 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static, eye-level close-up of a stack of official tax documents on a heavily scratched metal table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single intense overhead light source creating high contrast, shimmering grooves, and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a gust of air cause the top document to whip forward and tumble chaotically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly to the right to track the document's flight path against a bare concrete wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the documents visibly marked with intricate black ink and distinctive red and blue customs stamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009813634678721428 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6348137855529785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009813634678721428, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009813634678721428, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11818219721317291, + 0.07002194225788116, + 0.012431151233613491, + 0.03976740315556526, + 0.06269805878400803, + 0.10415052622556686, + 0.4270716607570648, + 0.01931755430996418, + 0.01012772973626852, + 0.13623180985450745 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009813634678721428 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static, eye-level close-up of a stack of official tax documents on a heavily scratched metal table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single intense overhead light source creating high contrast, shimmering grooves, and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a gust of air cause the top document to whip forward and tumble chaotically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly to the right to track the document's flight path against a bare concrete wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the documents visibly marked with intricate black ink and distinctive red and blue customs stamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018200531601905823 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018200397491455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018200531601905823, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018200531601905823, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.036683786660432816, + 0.1483110934495926, + 0.14444158971309662, + 0.046160969883203506, + 0.02988007664680481, + 0.0322849377989769, + 0.3055456876754761, + 0.05806993320584297, + 0.027763819321990013, + 0.17085808515548706 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018200531601905823 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static, eye-level close-up of a stack of official tax documents on a heavily scratched metal table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single intense overhead light source creating high contrast, shimmering grooves, and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a gust of air cause the top document to whip forward and tumble chaotically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly to the right to track the document's flight path against a bare concrete wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the documents visibly marked with intricate black ink and distinctive red and blue customs stamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14279839396476746 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.01779842376709 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14279839396476746, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14279839396476746, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04600534215569496, + 0.035736143589019775, + 0.014181932434439659, + 0.04465553164482117, + 0.05439218878746033, + 0.03501611575484276, + 0.48931166529655457, + 0.042755354195833206, + 0.08357106894254684, + 0.15437467396259308 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14279839396476746 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static, eye-level close-up of a stack of official tax documents on a heavily scratched metal table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single intense overhead light source creating high contrast, shimmering grooves, and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a gust of air cause the top document to whip forward and tumble chaotically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly to the right to track the document's flight path against a bare concrete wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the documents visibly marked with intricate black ink and distinctive red and blue customs stamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2814277112483978 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4064277410507202 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2814277112483978, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2814277112483978, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.059082210063934326, + 0.03968184441328049, + 0.020648473873734474, + 0.02443169243633747, + 0.026072412729263306, + 0.03246822953224182, + 0.5182867646217346, + 0.07950221002101898, + 0.00975495669990778, + 0.1900712251663208 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2814277112483978 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level close-up initially focuses on a stack of official tax documents resting on a cold, heavily scratched metal table in a dark industrial office. A single, intense overhead light source casts a pool of high-contrast brilliance onto the scene, causing deep grooves to shimmer across the table's surface and cast deep shadows into the surrounding space. Suddenly, a powerful gust of air from an off-screen fan bursts into the frame, causing the topmost document to whip violently forward, directly toward the viewer. As this single form, replete with intricate, densely packed black ink sheets and the distinctive markings of red and blue customs stamps, begins to tumble chaotically through the air, the camera initiates a smooth, steady dolly to the right. The camera perfectly tracks the document's erratic flight path, allowing it to flip and twist against the desolate, shadowy backdrop of a bare concrete wall, keeping it centered, its edges trembling wildly, creating a tense and dramatic atmosphere of sudden bureaucratic upheaval.", + "seed": 19716, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_12/index_2790_seed_19716_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.3731332667171955, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3731332667171955, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3731332667171955, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static, eye-level close-up of a stack of official tax documents on a heavily scratched metal table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single intense overhead light source creating high contrast, shimmering grooves, and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a gust of air cause the top document to whip forward and tumble chaotically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly to the right to track the document's flight path against a bare concrete wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the documents visibly marked with intricate black ink and distinctive red and blue customs stamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.978222131729126 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.478222131729126 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.978222131729126, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.978222131729126, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17912611365318298, + 0.09941735118627548, + 0.06684712320566177, + 0.0617140494287014, + 0.14605069160461426, + 0.08364227414131165, + 0.07137742638587952, + 0.18359531462192535, + 0.05236325040459633, + 0.05586647987365723 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.978222131729126 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static, eye-level close-up of a stack of official tax documents on a heavily scratched metal table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single intense overhead light source creating high contrast, shimmering grooves, and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a gust of air cause the top document to whip forward and tumble chaotically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly to the right to track the document's flight path against a bare concrete wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the documents visibly marked with intricate black ink and distinctive red and blue customs stamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020636841654777527 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895636796951294 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020636841654777527, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020636841654777527, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21123115718364716, + 0.06936769187450409, + 0.07918954640626907, + 0.04237142577767372, + 0.04447617009282112, + 0.04254939407110214, + 0.12327199429273605, + 0.26965466141700745, + 0.04611421376466751, + 0.07177378982305527 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020636841654777527 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static, eye-level close-up of a stack of official tax documents on a heavily scratched metal table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single intense overhead light source creating high contrast, shimmering grooves, and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a gust of air cause the top document to whip forward and tumble chaotically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly to the right to track the document's flight path against a bare concrete wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the documents visibly marked with intricate black ink and distinctive red and blue customs stamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02982505038380623 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.52982497215271 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02982505038380623, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02982505038380623, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18437041342258453, + 0.0973752811551094, + 0.06285782158374786, + 0.0633622258901596, + 0.05435428395867348, + 0.02844376303255558, + 0.19066046178340912, + 0.14210090041160583, + 0.028412163257598877, + 0.14806270599365234 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02982505038380623 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static, eye-level close-up of a stack of official tax documents on a heavily scratched metal table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single intense overhead light source creating high contrast, shimmering grooves, and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a gust of air cause the top document to whip forward and tumble chaotically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly to the right to track the document's flight path against a bare concrete wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the documents visibly marked with intricate black ink and distinctive red and blue customs stamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134734034538269 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134734630584717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134734034538269, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134734034538269, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13419878482818604, + 0.07093557715415955, + 0.061751894652843475, + 0.07985405623912811, + 0.11886635422706604, + 0.03809898719191551, + 0.27726852893829346, + 0.05604226887226105, + 0.03866104409098625, + 0.12432248890399933 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134734034538269 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static, eye-level close-up of a stack of official tax documents on a heavily scratched metal table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single intense overhead light source creating high contrast, shimmering grooves, and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a gust of air cause the top document to whip forward and tumble chaotically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly to the right to track the document's flight path against a bare concrete wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the documents visibly marked with intricate black ink and distinctive red and blue customs stamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5235089063644409 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8985089063644409 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5235089063644409, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5235089063644409, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17044907808303833, + 0.06823676824569702, + 0.08724493533372879, + 0.11422060430049896, + 0.05845347046852112, + 0.09236735850572586, + 0.18047644197940826, + 0.06269203126430511, + 0.09162481874227524, + 0.07423453778028488 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5235089063644409 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level close-up initially focuses on a stack of official tax documents resting on a cold, heavily scratched metal table in a dark industrial office. A single, intense overhead light source casts a pool of high-contrast brilliance onto the scene, causing deep grooves to shimmer across the table's surface and cast deep shadows into the surrounding space. Suddenly, a powerful gust of air from an off-screen fan bursts into the frame, causing the topmost document to whip violently forward, directly toward the viewer. As this single form, replete with intricate, densely packed black ink sheets and the distinctive markings of red and blue customs stamps, begins to tumble chaotically through the air, the camera initiates a smooth, steady dolly to the right. The camera perfectly tracks the document's erratic flight path, allowing it to flip and twist against the desolate, shadowy backdrop of a bare concrete wall, keeping it centered, its edges trembling wildly, creating a tense and dramatic atmosphere of sudden bureaucratic upheaval.", + "seed": 19717, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_12/index_2790_seed_19717_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.20544204972684382, + "vlm_logprob": -0.20544204972684382, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.20544204972684382, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static, eye-level close-up of a stack of official tax documents on a heavily scratched metal table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single intense overhead light source creating high contrast, shimmering grooves, and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a gust of air cause the top document to whip forward and tumble chaotically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly to the right to track the document's flight path against a bare concrete wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the documents visibly marked with intricate black ink and distinctive red and blue customs stamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3519764244556427 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2269763946533203 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3519764244556427, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3519764244556427, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36966633796691895, + 0.09222869575023651, + 0.028650229796767235, + 0.19089297950267792, + 0.0643705353140831, + 0.05344678834080696, + 0.06532865762710571, + 0.0402192585170269, + 0.02682160586118698, + 0.06837491691112518 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3519764244556427 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static, eye-level close-up of a stack of official tax documents on a heavily scratched metal table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single intense overhead light source creating high contrast, shimmering grooves, and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a gust of air cause the top document to whip forward and tumble chaotically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly to the right to track the document's flight path against a bare concrete wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the documents visibly marked with intricate black ink and distinctive red and blue customs stamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01822616718709469 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018226146697998 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01822616718709469, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01822616718709469, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29773929715156555, + 0.04264693707227707, + 0.048463013023138046, + 0.03981519117951393, + 0.11312363296747208, + 0.06203353777527809, + 0.10072428733110428, + 0.2015971839427948, + 0.019436929374933243, + 0.07441997528076172 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01822616718709469 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static, eye-level close-up of a stack of official tax documents on a heavily scratched metal table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single intense overhead light source creating high contrast, shimmering grooves, and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a gust of air cause the top document to whip forward and tumble chaotically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly to the right to track the document's flight path against a bare concrete wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the documents visibly marked with intricate black ink and distinctive red and blue customs stamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02060180902481079 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895601749420166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02060180902481079, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02060180902481079, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09012399613857269, + 0.2049361914396286, + 0.240691676735878, + 0.08960527926683426, + 0.0476621612906456, + 0.06694705039262772, + 0.0878867506980896, + 0.07222337275743484, + 0.03626257926225662, + 0.06366095691919327 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02060180902481079 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static, eye-level close-up of a stack of official tax documents on a heavily scratched metal table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single intense overhead light source creating high contrast, shimmering grooves, and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a gust of air cause the top document to whip forward and tumble chaotically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly to the right to track the document's flight path against a bare concrete wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the documents visibly marked with intricate black ink and distinctive red and blue customs stamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11293032020330429 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379302978515625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11293032020330429, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11293032020330429, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16132374107837677, + 0.2525395154953003, + 0.04509684443473816, + 0.05663539841771126, + 0.06052784249186516, + 0.09611338376998901, + 0.10874411463737488, + 0.06897921860218048, + 0.09055358916521072, + 0.059486404061317444 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11293032020330429 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static, eye-level close-up of a stack of official tax documents on a heavily scratched metal table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single intense overhead light source creating high contrast, shimmering grooves, and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a gust of air cause the top document to whip forward and tumble chaotically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly to the right to track the document's flight path against a bare concrete wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the documents visibly marked with intricate black ink and distinctive red and blue customs stamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5234755277633667 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8984755277633667 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5234755277633667, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5234755277633667, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3955686688423157, + 0.06800094991922379, + 0.07316754758358002, + 0.08932890743017197, + 0.04069772735238075, + 0.04685962200164795, + 0.1187686175107956, + 0.054058726876974106, + 0.03833296522498131, + 0.07521629333496094 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5234755277633667 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level close-up initially focuses on a stack of official tax documents resting on a cold, heavily scratched metal table in a dark industrial office. A single, intense overhead light source casts a pool of high-contrast brilliance onto the scene, causing deep grooves to shimmer across the table's surface and cast deep shadows into the surrounding space. Suddenly, a powerful gust of air from an off-screen fan bursts into the frame, causing the topmost document to whip violently forward, directly toward the viewer. As this single form, replete with intricate, densely packed black ink sheets and the distinctive markings of red and blue customs stamps, begins to tumble chaotically through the air, the camera initiates a smooth, steady dolly to the right. The camera perfectly tracks the document's erratic flight path, allowing it to flip and twist against the desolate, shadowy backdrop of a bare concrete wall, keeping it centered, its edges trembling wildly, creating a tense and dramatic atmosphere of sudden bureaucratic upheaval.", + "seed": 19718, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_12/index_2790_seed_19718_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2523975994437933, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2523975994437933, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2523975994437933, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static, eye-level close-up of a stack of official tax documents on a heavily scratched metal table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single intense overhead light source creating high contrast, shimmering grooves, and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a gust of air cause the top document to whip forward and tumble chaotically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly to the right to track the document's flight path against a bare concrete wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the documents visibly marked with intricate black ink and distinctive red and blue customs stamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7605893015861511 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6355893015861511 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7605893015861511, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7605893015861511, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2149900645017624, + 0.24019582569599152, + 0.20727594196796417, + 0.05062152445316315, + 0.02287399210035801, + 0.03298136964440346, + 0.03479621559381485, + 0.04040456935763359, + 0.01759244315326214, + 0.1382681429386139 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7605893015861511 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static, eye-level close-up of a stack of official tax documents on a heavily scratched metal table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single intense overhead light source creating high contrast, shimmering grooves, and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a gust of air cause the top document to whip forward and tumble chaotically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly to the right to track the document's flight path against a bare concrete wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the documents visibly marked with intricate black ink and distinctive red and blue customs stamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014230793341994286 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264230728149414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014230793341994286, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014230793341994286, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10417988896369934, + 0.3238110840320587, + 0.07180555909872055, + 0.042673151940107346, + 0.03047718107700348, + 0.04190445318818092, + 0.038015130907297134, + 0.12473369389772415, + 0.020009273663163185, + 0.2023906260728836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014230793341994286 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static, eye-level close-up of a stack of official tax documents on a heavily scratched metal table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single intense overhead light source creating high contrast, shimmering grooves, and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a gust of air cause the top document to whip forward and tumble chaotically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly to the right to track the document's flight path against a bare concrete wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the documents visibly marked with intricate black ink and distinctive red and blue customs stamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811095654964447 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881109714508057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811095654964447, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811095654964447, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12706150114536285, + 0.19733837246894836, + 0.19109858572483063, + 0.0578114353120327, + 0.06961613148450851, + 0.05037227272987366, + 0.034931033849716187, + 0.027454759925603867, + 0.02644122950732708, + 0.2178746461868286 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811095654964447 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static, eye-level close-up of a stack of official tax documents on a heavily scratched metal table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single intense overhead light source creating high contrast, shimmering grooves, and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a gust of air cause the top document to whip forward and tumble chaotically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly to the right to track the document's flight path against a bare concrete wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the documents visibly marked with intricate black ink and distinctive red and blue customs stamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10030525177717209 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503053188323975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10030525177717209, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10030525177717209, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11614642292261124, + 0.06893035769462585, + 0.11221534013748169, + 0.04064156860113144, + 0.04823805019259453, + 0.06248471885919571, + 0.09119930118322372, + 0.042305707931518555, + 0.079111248254776, + 0.33872729539871216 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10030525177717209 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the initial shot a static, eye-level close-up of a stack of official tax documents on a heavily scratched metal table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a single intense overhead light source creating high contrast, shimmering grooves, and deep shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a gust of air cause the top document to whip forward and tumble chaotically through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a smooth, steady dolly to the right to track the document's flight path against a bare concrete wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the documents visibly marked with intricate black ink and distinctive red and blue customs stamps?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3487516939640045 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2237516641616821 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3487516939640045, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3487516939640045, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13359816372394562, + 0.1978336125612259, + 0.2950612008571625, + 0.05901246890425682, + 0.030751820653676987, + 0.028471462428569794, + 0.03273775801062584, + 0.04896952956914902, + 0.05036821588873863, + 0.12319576740264893 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3487516939640045 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_13/index_tensor([8669, 8669])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_13/index_tensor([8669, 8669])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..02303644e6dfe08544e41e28c3644f271b1d40a4 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_13/index_tensor([8669, 8669])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic low-angle tracking shot, rendered in a vibrant anime or manga art style with sharp electronic shadows, captures a sleek, bullet-shaped, ultra-high-speed maglev train hurtling forward at incredible acceleration speeds. The train's chassis, constructed of a pearlescent white composite material, gleams under the city lights, with thin cyan light strips running lengthwise, symbolizing its magnetic levitation. At night, it traverses a dense, futuristic cityscape, hovering above a dark, minimalist approach road weaving between towering skyscrapers adorned with giant, luminous holographic advertisements. As the train accelerates, crisp white and blue dynamic speed lines violently streak across its massive, tinted panoramic windows, emphasizing the powerful linear motion and transforming the complex urban background into a beautiful, abstract blur of saturated neon. At the climactic moment, as the train passes a particularly bright fuchsia neon sign, a brilliant horizontal anamorphic lens flare blazes across the screen, creating an atmosphere of pure, overwhelming power and excitement.", + "seed": 29157, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_13/index_8669_seed_29157_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06456952607259155, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06456952607259155, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06456952607259155, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a vibrant anime or manga art style with sharp electronic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, bullet-shaped maglev train with a pearlescent white composite chassis and thin cyan light strips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train shown moving at incredible acceleration speeds through a dense, futuristic cityscape at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot with crisp white and blue dynamic speed lines streaking across the train's windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant horizontal anamorphic lens flare appearing as the train passes a bright fuchsia neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07130374759435654 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6963038444519043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07130374759435654, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07130374759435654, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08353342860937119, + 0.06776300072669983, + 0.029298972338438034, + 0.02029052935540676, + 0.21574008464813232, + 0.05707541108131409, + 0.06033266708254814, + 0.11188269406557083, + 0.1488931030035019, + 0.20519012212753296 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07130374759435654 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a vibrant anime or manga art style with sharp electronic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, bullet-shaped maglev train with a pearlescent white composite chassis and thin cyan light strips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train shown moving at incredible acceleration speeds through a dense, futuristic cityscape at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot with crisp white and blue dynamic speed lines streaking across the train's windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant horizontal anamorphic lens flare appearing as the train passes a bright fuchsia neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006741044111549854 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006741046905518 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006741044111549854, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006741044111549854, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18627573549747467, + 0.050591323524713516, + 0.2181643545627594, + 0.10078424215316772, + 0.09582675248384476, + 0.044360172003507614, + 0.05834008380770683, + 0.12032074481248856, + 0.034853365272283554, + 0.09048321098089218 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006741044111549854 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a vibrant anime or manga art style with sharp electronic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, bullet-shaped maglev train with a pearlescent white composite chassis and thin cyan light strips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train shown moving at incredible acceleration speeds through a dense, futuristic cityscape at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot with crisp white and blue dynamic speed lines streaking across the train's windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant horizontal anamorphic lens flare appearing as the train passes a bright fuchsia neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22554649412631989 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005464792251587 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22554649412631989, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22554649412631989, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11316277086734772, + 0.057060662657022476, + 0.025419678539037704, + 0.08101415634155273, + 0.03601231053471565, + 0.08768288791179657, + 0.11134633421897888, + 0.13171279430389404, + 0.09678421169519424, + 0.2598041892051697 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22554649412631989 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a vibrant anime or manga art style with sharp electronic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, bullet-shaped maglev train with a pearlescent white composite chassis and thin cyan light strips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train shown moving at incredible acceleration speeds through a dense, futuristic cityscape at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot with crisp white and blue dynamic speed lines streaking across the train's windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant horizontal anamorphic lens flare appearing as the train passes a bright fuchsia neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00319126108661294 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531914710998535 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00319126108661294, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00319126108661294, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09311583638191223, + 0.04829184710979462, + 0.030040673911571503, + 0.03796452656388283, + 0.08059032261371613, + 0.05810967832803726, + 0.12478431314229965, + 0.09049620479345322, + 0.0538097620010376, + 0.3827967941761017 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00319126108661294 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a vibrant anime or manga art style with sharp electronic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, bullet-shaped maglev train with a pearlescent white composite chassis and thin cyan light strips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train shown moving at incredible acceleration speeds through a dense, futuristic cityscape at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot with crisp white and blue dynamic speed lines streaking across the train's windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant horizontal anamorphic lens flare appearing as the train passes a bright fuchsia neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0160650834441185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410651206970215 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0160650834441185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0160650834441185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03190262243151665, + 0.027051016688346863, + 0.009179572574794292, + 0.031076602637767792, + 0.08144378662109375, + 0.01866176538169384, + 0.04247623682022095, + 0.19126982986927032, + 0.03410147875547409, + 0.5328370332717896 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0160650834441185 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic low-angle tracking shot, rendered in a vibrant anime or manga art style with sharp electronic shadows, captures a sleek, bullet-shaped, ultra-high-speed maglev train hurtling forward at incredible acceleration speeds. The train's chassis, constructed of a pearlescent white composite material, gleams under the city lights, with thin cyan light strips running lengthwise, symbolizing its magnetic levitation. At night, it traverses a dense, futuristic cityscape, hovering above a dark, minimalist approach road weaving between towering skyscrapers adorned with giant, luminous holographic advertisements. As the train accelerates, crisp white and blue dynamic speed lines violently streak across its massive, tinted panoramic windows, emphasizing the powerful linear motion and transforming the complex urban background into a beautiful, abstract blur of saturated neon. At the climactic moment, as the train passes a particularly bright fuchsia neon sign, a brilliant horizontal anamorphic lens flare blazes across the screen, creating an atmosphere of pure, overwhelming power and excitement.", + "seed": 29158, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_13/index_8669_seed_29158_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06644588867202401, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06644588867202401, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06644588867202401, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a vibrant anime or manga art style with sharp electronic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, bullet-shaped maglev train with a pearlescent white composite chassis and thin cyan light strips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train shown moving at incredible acceleration speeds through a dense, futuristic cityscape at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot with crisp white and blue dynamic speed lines streaking across the train's windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant horizontal anamorphic lens flare appearing as the train passes a bright fuchsia neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28258463740348816 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4075846672058105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28258463740348816, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28258463740348816, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05856643244624138, + 0.022980492562055588, + 0.02696390077471733, + 0.018300501629710197, + 0.01732749491930008, + 0.23504312336444855, + 0.08483962714672089, + 0.03615982457995415, + 0.04461956396698952, + 0.45519909262657166 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28258463740348816 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a vibrant anime or manga art style with sharp electronic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, bullet-shaped maglev train with a pearlescent white composite chassis and thin cyan light strips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train shown moving at incredible acceleration speeds through a dense, futuristic cityscape at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot with crisp white and blue dynamic speed lines streaking across the train's windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant horizontal anamorphic lens flare appearing as the train passes a bright fuchsia neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005959243047982454 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309590339660645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005959243047982454, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005959243047982454, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05284968763589859, + 0.02919687144458294, + 0.018385078758001328, + 0.039480529725551605, + 0.025098474696278572, + 0.21182754635810852, + 0.09214957058429718, + 0.08041813969612122, + 0.0762082040309906, + 0.3743859827518463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005959243047982454 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a vibrant anime or manga art style with sharp electronic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, bullet-shaped maglev train with a pearlescent white composite chassis and thin cyan light strips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train shown moving at incredible acceleration speeds through a dense, futuristic cityscape at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot with crisp white and blue dynamic speed lines streaking across the train's windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant horizontal anamorphic lens flare appearing as the train passes a bright fuchsia neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029797164723277092 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529797077178955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029797164723277092, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029797164723277092, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19925224781036377, + 0.021370787173509598, + 0.01733243092894554, + 0.02142883464694023, + 0.020038198679685593, + 0.05012008547782898, + 0.10088202357292175, + 0.09037009626626968, + 0.33389416337013245, + 0.1453111171722412 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029797164723277092 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a vibrant anime or manga art style with sharp electronic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, bullet-shaped maglev train with a pearlescent white composite chassis and thin cyan light strips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train shown moving at incredible acceleration speeds through a dense, futuristic cityscape at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot with crisp white and blue dynamic speed lines streaking across the train's windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant horizontal anamorphic lens flare appearing as the train passes a bright fuchsia neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008637449704110622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758637428283691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008637449704110622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008637449704110622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.043065764009952545, + 0.03766990080475807, + 0.02977008745074272, + 0.04932069405913353, + 0.03598061949014664, + 0.21912339329719543, + 0.09373266249895096, + 0.043699465692043304, + 0.07126380503177643, + 0.37637364864349365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008637449704110622 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a vibrant anime or manga art style with sharp electronic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, bullet-shaped maglev train with a pearlescent white composite chassis and thin cyan light strips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train shown moving at incredible acceleration speeds through a dense, futuristic cityscape at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot with crisp white and blue dynamic speed lines streaking across the train's windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant horizontal anamorphic lens flare appearing as the train passes a bright fuchsia neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00525094848126173 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255250930786133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00525094848126173, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00525094848126173, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07761280983686447, + 0.024271294474601746, + 0.024845661595463753, + 0.019569510594010353, + 0.031795404851436615, + 0.11566434055566788, + 0.0688195452094078, + 0.048423442989587784, + 0.11838386207818985, + 0.47061413526535034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00525094848126173 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic low-angle tracking shot, rendered in a vibrant anime or manga art style with sharp electronic shadows, captures a sleek, bullet-shaped, ultra-high-speed maglev train hurtling forward at incredible acceleration speeds. The train's chassis, constructed of a pearlescent white composite material, gleams under the city lights, with thin cyan light strips running lengthwise, symbolizing its magnetic levitation. At night, it traverses a dense, futuristic cityscape, hovering above a dark, minimalist approach road weaving between towering skyscrapers adorned with giant, luminous holographic advertisements. As the train accelerates, crisp white and blue dynamic speed lines violently streak across its massive, tinted panoramic windows, emphasizing the powerful linear motion and transforming the complex urban background into a beautiful, abstract blur of saturated neon. At the climactic moment, as the train passes a particularly bright fuchsia neon sign, a brilliant horizontal anamorphic lens flare blazes across the screen, creating an atmosphere of pure, overwhelming power and excitement.", + "seed": 29159, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_13/index_8669_seed_29159_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06692356001585723, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06692356001585723, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.649999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06692356001585723, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a vibrant anime or manga art style with sharp electronic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, bullet-shaped maglev train with a pearlescent white composite chassis and thin cyan light strips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train shown moving at incredible acceleration speeds through a dense, futuristic cityscape at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot with crisp white and blue dynamic speed lines streaking across the train's windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant horizontal anamorphic lens flare appearing as the train passes a bright fuchsia neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1618986576795578 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9118986129760742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1618986576795578, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1618986576795578, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07676742225885391, + 0.05376388505101204, + 0.02787725441157818, + 0.046066559851169586, + 0.015119080431759357, + 0.2918619215488434, + 0.12169208377599716, + 0.11137396842241287, + 0.16060061752796173, + 0.09487718343734741 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1618986576795578 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a vibrant anime or manga art style with sharp electronic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, bullet-shaped maglev train with a pearlescent white composite chassis and thin cyan light strips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train shown moving at incredible acceleration speeds through a dense, futuristic cityscape at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot with crisp white and blue dynamic speed lines streaking across the train's windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant horizontal anamorphic lens flare appearing as the train passes a bright fuchsia neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005260079633444548 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255259990692139 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005260079633444548, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005260079633444548, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08089598268270493, + 0.03657650947570801, + 0.022631976753473282, + 0.07605057954788208, + 0.06655453145503998, + 0.19073091447353363, + 0.2065870612859726, + 0.11905387043952942, + 0.13707928359508514, + 0.06383927911520004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005260079633444548 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a vibrant anime or manga art style with sharp electronic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, bullet-shaped maglev train with a pearlescent white composite chassis and thin cyan light strips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train shown moving at incredible acceleration speeds through a dense, futuristic cityscape at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot with crisp white and blue dynamic speed lines streaking across the train's windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant horizontal anamorphic lens flare appearing as the train passes a bright fuchsia neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14278805255889893 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0177879333496094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14278805255889893, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14278805255889893, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0785876139998436, + 0.05285494029521942, + 0.0333959236741066, + 0.19875821471214294, + 0.032907385379076004, + 0.12051284313201904, + 0.2641409933567047, + 0.05776601284742355, + 0.09181473404169083, + 0.06926131248474121 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14278805255889893 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a vibrant anime or manga art style with sharp electronic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, bullet-shaped maglev train with a pearlescent white composite chassis and thin cyan light strips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train shown moving at incredible acceleration speeds through a dense, futuristic cityscape at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot with crisp white and blue dynamic speed lines streaking across the train's windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant horizontal anamorphic lens flare appearing as the train passes a bright fuchsia neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004093957599252462 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504094123840332 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004093957599252462, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004093957599252462, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08089035004377365, + 0.0330633781850338, + 0.0681300237774849, + 0.17976604402065277, + 0.04622821509838104, + 0.02062743902206421, + 0.2607737183570862, + 0.12917430698871613, + 0.12166252732276917, + 0.05968400463461876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004093957599252462 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a vibrant anime or manga art style with sharp electronic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, bullet-shaped maglev train with a pearlescent white composite chassis and thin cyan light strips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train shown moving at incredible acceleration speeds through a dense, futuristic cityscape at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot with crisp white and blue dynamic speed lines streaking across the train's windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant horizontal anamorphic lens flare appearing as the train passes a bright fuchsia neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020577052608132362 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955769538879395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020577052608132362, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020577052608132362, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0452856682240963, + 0.037260811775922775, + 0.024836717173457146, + 0.045651406049728394, + 0.05561093986034393, + 0.04281793162226677, + 0.15001296997070312, + 0.17043200135231018, + 0.28785398602485657, + 0.14023758471012115 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020577052608132362 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic low-angle tracking shot, rendered in a vibrant anime or manga art style with sharp electronic shadows, captures a sleek, bullet-shaped, ultra-high-speed maglev train hurtling forward at incredible acceleration speeds. The train's chassis, constructed of a pearlescent white composite material, gleams under the city lights, with thin cyan light strips running lengthwise, symbolizing its magnetic levitation. At night, it traverses a dense, futuristic cityscape, hovering above a dark, minimalist approach road weaving between towering skyscrapers adorned with giant, luminous holographic advertisements. As the train accelerates, crisp white and blue dynamic speed lines violently streak across its massive, tinted panoramic windows, emphasizing the powerful linear motion and transforming the complex urban background into a beautiful, abstract blur of saturated neon. At the climactic moment, as the train passes a particularly bright fuchsia neon sign, a brilliant horizontal anamorphic lens flare blazes across the screen, creating an atmosphere of pure, overwhelming power and excitement.", + "seed": 29160, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_13/index_8669_seed_29160_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.024136726907454432, + "vlm_logprob": -0.024136726907454432, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.024136726907454432, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a vibrant anime or manga art style with sharp electronic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, bullet-shaped maglev train with a pearlescent white composite chassis and thin cyan light strips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train shown moving at incredible acceleration speeds through a dense, futuristic cityscape at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot with crisp white and blue dynamic speed lines streaking across the train's windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant horizontal anamorphic lens flare appearing as the train passes a bright fuchsia neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.017118437215685844 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.142118453979492 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.017118437215685844, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.017118437215685844, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.048119232058525085, + 0.11524483561515808, + 0.02760974131524563, + 0.040950097143650055, + 0.1898677796125412, + 0.017350487411022186, + 0.04897240921854973, + 0.08074229210615158, + 0.3462148904800415, + 0.08492819964885712 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.017118437215685844 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a vibrant anime or manga art style with sharp electronic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, bullet-shaped maglev train with a pearlescent white composite chassis and thin cyan light strips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train shown moving at incredible acceleration speeds through a dense, futuristic cityscape at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot with crisp white and blue dynamic speed lines streaking across the train's windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant horizontal anamorphic lens flare appearing as the train passes a bright fuchsia neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019453902496024966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251945495605469 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019453902496024966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019453902496024966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1412460207939148, + 0.16414625942707062, + 0.0676875188946724, + 0.0778573602437973, + 0.05889652296900749, + 0.12986385822296143, + 0.07879407703876495, + 0.08461795002222061, + 0.0643305703997612, + 0.1325598508119583 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019453902496024966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a vibrant anime or manga art style with sharp electronic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, bullet-shaped maglev train with a pearlescent white composite chassis and thin cyan light strips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train shown moving at incredible acceleration speeds through a dense, futuristic cityscape at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot with crisp white and blue dynamic speed lines streaking across the train's windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant horizontal anamorphic lens flare appearing as the train passes a bright fuchsia neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08902376145124435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640238285064697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08902376145124435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08902376145124435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.088384248316288, + 0.2525337338447571, + 0.07678075134754181, + 0.05936913564801216, + 0.06538273394107819, + 0.060267187654972076, + 0.042722154408693314, + 0.06297510117292404, + 0.2608358561992645, + 0.03074904903769493 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08902376145124435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a vibrant anime or manga art style with sharp electronic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, bullet-shaped maglev train with a pearlescent white composite chassis and thin cyan light strips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train shown moving at incredible acceleration speeds through a dense, futuristic cityscape at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot with crisp white and blue dynamic speed lines streaking across the train's windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant horizontal anamorphic lens flare appearing as the train passes a bright fuchsia neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002817234955728054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877817153930664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002817234955728054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002817234955728054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11660539358854294, + 0.05224195495247841, + 0.03484296426177025, + 0.0470598004758358, + 0.15268589556217194, + 0.0323745496571064, + 0.04761210083961487, + 0.09498284757137299, + 0.2996003329753876, + 0.12199418246746063 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002817234955728054 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a vibrant anime or manga art style with sharp electronic shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek, bullet-shaped maglev train with a pearlescent white composite chassis and thin cyan light strips?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the train shown moving at incredible acceleration speeds through a dense, futuristic cityscape at night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot with crisp white and blue dynamic speed lines streaking across the train's windows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is there a brilliant horizontal anamorphic lens flare appearing as the train passes a bright fuchsia neon sign?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009778810665011406 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63477897644043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009778810665011406, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009778810665011406, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.018286030739545822, + 0.02190450020134449, + 0.007629669737070799, + 0.006796050351113081, + 0.014279848895967007, + 0.021114211529493332, + 0.009472759440541267, + 0.03017621859908104, + 0.8355527520179749, + 0.034787923097610474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009778810665011406 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_14/index_tensor([7513, 7513])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_14/index_tensor([7513, 7513])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d23770f6d2133ca8e89966ac3b40252da473be98 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_14/index_tensor([7513, 7513])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium-long shot, shot from ground level, pans steadily to the right, patiently tracking two large, lushly furred adult giant pandas in a documentary style. They are nestled deep in a dense bamboo forest. Sunlight filters through the gaps between the towering, emerald green leaves, casting dappled shadows on the withered, yellow, fallen ground. One panda is slightly ahead, clumsily twisting its chubby body as it scurries forward on all fours, glancing back frequently. The other, closely behind, pursues with equal clumsiness but enthusiasm, their signature black and white fur stained with dust and grass, lending it a strikingly realistic presence. The chase culminates in a lovable misstep, and the two pandas tumble violently into each other, tumbling into a pile of soft fallen leaves. They gently pat each other's cheeks with their thick paws, silently biting each other, their bodies intertwined in a slow, awkward tumble. The entire picture is painted in natural bright green and warm ochre tones, with soft and layered light, perfectly capturing this non-aggressive, purely playful frolic, creating a tranquil, authentic, and joyful atmosphere of outdoor observation.", + "seed": 23396, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_14/index_7513_seed_23396_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08919198913499712, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08919198913499712, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08919198913499712, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two large adult giant pandas with black and white fur visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense bamboo forest with emerald green leaves and dappled sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the pandas engage in a clumsy chase that ends with them tumbling into a pile of soft fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a medium-long shot filmed from ground level with a steady pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by natural bright green and warm ochre tones with soft, layered lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12784354388713837 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1278436183929443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12784354388713837, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12784354388713837, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17397964000701904, + 0.03341398388147354, + 0.14999939501285553, + 0.040960535407066345, + 0.03636721894145012, + 0.07520820945501328, + 0.13637644052505493, + 0.10404063761234283, + 0.20062896609306335, + 0.0490250289440155 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12784354388713837 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two large adult giant pandas with black and white fur visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense bamboo forest with emerald green leaves and dappled sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the pandas engage in a clumsy chase that ends with them tumbling into a pile of soft fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a medium-long shot filmed from ground level with a steady pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by natural bright green and warm ochre tones with soft, layered lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10033328831195831 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503332138061523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10033328831195831, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10033328831195831, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1545122116804123, + 0.03083496168255806, + 0.1366630494594574, + 0.060377612709999084, + 0.11440231651067734, + 0.0750991478562355, + 0.10063622891902924, + 0.15138743817806244, + 0.13353249430656433, + 0.04255449399352074 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10033328831195831 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two large adult giant pandas with black and white fur visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense bamboo forest with emerald green leaves and dappled sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the pandas engage in a clumsy chase that ends with them tumbling into a pile of soft fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a medium-long shot filmed from ground level with a steady pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by natural bright green and warm ochre tones with soft, layered lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16034048795700073 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103405475616455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16034048795700073, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16034048795700073, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07747916877269745, + 0.051472991704940796, + 0.038381800055503845, + 0.05118878185749054, + 0.14950807392597198, + 0.03992307931184769, + 0.12236995249986649, + 0.2755023241043091, + 0.10349875688552856, + 0.09067512303590775 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16034048795700073 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two large adult giant pandas with black and white fur visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense bamboo forest with emerald green leaves and dappled sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the pandas engage in a clumsy chase that ends with them tumbling into a pile of soft fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a medium-long shot filmed from ground level with a steady pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by natural bright green and warm ochre tones with soft, layered lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054952941834926605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.92995285987854 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054952941834926605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054952941834926605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15150271356105804, + 0.09145988523960114, + 0.10374649614095688, + 0.07356899976730347, + 0.20442891120910645, + 0.09792187809944153, + 0.07449076324701309, + 0.058611538261175156, + 0.06976625323295593, + 0.07450249791145325 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054952941834926605 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two large adult giant pandas with black and white fur visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense bamboo forest with emerald green leaves and dappled sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the pandas engage in a clumsy chase that ends with them tumbling into a pile of soft fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a medium-long shot filmed from ground level with a steady pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by natural bright green and warm ochre tones with soft, layered lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00248968368396163 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.0024895668029785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00248968368396163, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00248968368396163, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24486035108566284, + 0.07223059237003326, + 0.10046900063753128, + 0.07467852532863617, + 0.08386414498090744, + 0.04972060024738312, + 0.16145841777324677, + 0.11141197383403778, + 0.04263097047805786, + 0.058675408363342285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00248968368396163 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium-long shot, shot from ground level, pans steadily to the right, patiently tracking two large, lushly furred adult giant pandas in a documentary style. They are nestled deep in a dense bamboo forest. Sunlight filters through the gaps between the towering, emerald green leaves, casting dappled shadows on the withered, yellow, fallen ground. One panda is slightly ahead, clumsily twisting its chubby body as it scurries forward on all fours, glancing back frequently. The other, closely behind, pursues with equal clumsiness but enthusiasm, their signature black and white fur stained with dust and grass, lending it a strikingly realistic presence. The chase culminates in a lovable misstep, and the two pandas tumble violently into each other, tumbling into a pile of soft fallen leaves. They gently pat each other's cheeks with their thick paws, silently biting each other, their bodies intertwined in a slow, awkward tumble. The entire picture is painted in natural bright green and warm ochre tones, with soft and layered light, perfectly capturing this non-aggressive, purely playful frolic, creating a tranquil, authentic, and joyful atmosphere of outdoor observation.", + "seed": 23397, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_14/index_7513_seed_23397_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.039474262041039765, + "vlm_logprob": -0.039474262041039765, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.039474262041039765, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two large adult giant pandas with black and white fur visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense bamboo forest with emerald green leaves and dappled sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the pandas engage in a clumsy chase that ends with them tumbling into a pile of soft fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a medium-long shot filmed from ground level with a steady pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by natural bright green and warm ochre tones with soft, layered lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12808436155319214 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.128084421157837 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12808436155319214, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12808436155319214, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11553674191236496, + 0.10593076795339584, + 0.13817091286182404, + 0.06302906572818756, + 0.08747556805610657, + 0.05396718531847, + 0.1025189459323883, + 0.0746859684586525, + 0.064944326877594, + 0.19374053180217743 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12808436155319214 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two large adult giant pandas with black and white fur visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense bamboo forest with emerald green leaves and dappled sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the pandas engage in a clumsy chase that ends with them tumbling into a pile of soft fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a medium-long shot filmed from ground level with a steady pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by natural bright green and warm ochre tones with soft, layered lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008649976924061775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758649826049805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008649976924061775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008649976924061775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19235628843307495, + 0.12753835320472717, + 0.08152540773153305, + 0.05340801551938057, + 0.14171940088272095, + 0.054714497178792953, + 0.058458421379327774, + 0.1424361914396286, + 0.07681994885206223, + 0.07102352380752563 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008649976924061775 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two large adult giant pandas with black and white fur visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense bamboo forest with emerald green leaves and dappled sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the pandas engage in a clumsy chase that ends with them tumbling into a pile of soft fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a medium-long shot filmed from ground level with a steady pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by natural bright green and warm ochre tones with soft, layered lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029797280207276344 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529797315597534 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029797280207276344, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029797280207276344, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23165298998355865, + 0.07912896573543549, + 0.15547330677509308, + 0.077738918364048, + 0.056083060801029205, + 0.12106427550315857, + 0.049840591847896576, + 0.06812606006860733, + 0.07414984703063965, + 0.08674197643995285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029797280207276344 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two large adult giant pandas with black and white fur visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense bamboo forest with emerald green leaves and dappled sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the pandas engage in a clumsy chase that ends with them tumbling into a pile of soft fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a medium-long shot filmed from ground level with a steady pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by natural bright green and warm ochre tones with soft, layered lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02979751117527485 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297975540161133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02979751117527485, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02979751117527485, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27645623683929443, + 0.14827734231948853, + 0.11973724514245987, + 0.07119807600975037, + 0.09724726527929306, + 0.03850182145833969, + 0.049976397305727005, + 0.08394286781549454, + 0.05066781863570213, + 0.06399494409561157 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02979751117527485 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two large adult giant pandas with black and white fur visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense bamboo forest with emerald green leaves and dappled sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the pandas engage in a clumsy chase that ends with them tumbling into a pile of soft fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a medium-long shot filmed from ground level with a steady pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by natural bright green and warm ochre tones with soft, layered lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010421803453937173 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876042366027832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010421803453937173, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010421803453937173, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19174429774284363, + 0.13712143898010254, + 0.06684449315071106, + 0.052782900631427765, + 0.07938317209482193, + 0.05332772061228752, + 0.05212627351284027, + 0.09771562367677689, + 0.18344278633594513, + 0.08551132678985596 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010421803453937173 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium-long shot, shot from ground level, pans steadily to the right, patiently tracking two large, lushly furred adult giant pandas in a documentary style. They are nestled deep in a dense bamboo forest. Sunlight filters through the gaps between the towering, emerald green leaves, casting dappled shadows on the withered, yellow, fallen ground. One panda is slightly ahead, clumsily twisting its chubby body as it scurries forward on all fours, glancing back frequently. The other, closely behind, pursues with equal clumsiness but enthusiasm, their signature black and white fur stained with dust and grass, lending it a strikingly realistic presence. The chase culminates in a lovable misstep, and the two pandas tumble violently into each other, tumbling into a pile of soft fallen leaves. They gently pat each other's cheeks with their thick paws, silently biting each other, their bodies intertwined in a slow, awkward tumble. The entire picture is painted in natural bright green and warm ochre tones, with soft and layered light, perfectly capturing this non-aggressive, purely playful frolic, creating a tranquil, authentic, and joyful atmosphere of outdoor observation.", + "seed": 23398, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_14/index_7513_seed_23398_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10322167612612247, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10322167612612247, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10322167612612247, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two large adult giant pandas with black and white fur visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense bamboo forest with emerald green leaves and dappled sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the pandas engage in a clumsy chase that ends with them tumbling into a pile of soft fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a medium-long shot filmed from ground level with a steady pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by natural bright green and warm ochre tones with soft, layered lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14343024790287018 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.018430233001709 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14343024790287018, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14343024790287018, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12106241285800934, + 0.03928160294890404, + 0.17376843094825745, + 0.06806648522615433, + 0.09646742045879364, + 0.11450356245040894, + 0.0777338445186615, + 0.06158794090151787, + 0.035015713423490524, + 0.21251262724399567 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14343024790287018 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two large adult giant pandas with black and white fur visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense bamboo forest with emerald green leaves and dappled sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the pandas engage in a clumsy chase that ends with them tumbling into a pile of soft fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a medium-long shot filmed from ground level with a steady pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by natural bright green and warm ochre tones with soft, layered lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0486648827791214 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486648082733154 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0486648827791214, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0486648827791214, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15728962421417236, + 0.02614780142903328, + 0.05047723278403282, + 0.062045879662036896, + 0.16745424270629883, + 0.07266931235790253, + 0.10336486250162125, + 0.10985583811998367, + 0.05827765911817551, + 0.19241756200790405 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0486648827791214 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two large adult giant pandas with black and white fur visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense bamboo forest with emerald green leaves and dappled sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the pandas engage in a clumsy chase that ends with them tumbling into a pile of soft fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a medium-long shot filmed from ground level with a steady pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by natural bright green and warm ochre tones with soft, layered lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520667314529419 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502066731452942 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520667314529419, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520667314529419, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14851847290992737, + 0.10905301570892334, + 0.11424554884433746, + 0.03304090350866318, + 0.04236800596117973, + 0.08160567283630371, + 0.15631383657455444, + 0.09252508729696274, + 0.04481625556945801, + 0.17751316726207733 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520667314529419 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two large adult giant pandas with black and white fur visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense bamboo forest with emerald green leaves and dappled sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the pandas engage in a clumsy chase that ends with them tumbling into a pile of soft fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a medium-long shot filmed from ground level with a steady pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by natural bright green and warm ochre tones with soft, layered lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000648230314255 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950063705444336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000648230314255, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000648230314255, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07513155788183212, + 0.05766488239169121, + 0.08066753298044205, + 0.10499855875968933, + 0.13906538486480713, + 0.09796508401632309, + 0.17645813524723053, + 0.08730486780405045, + 0.04500101879239082, + 0.1357429176568985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000648230314255 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two large adult giant pandas with black and white fur visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense bamboo forest with emerald green leaves and dappled sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the pandas engage in a clumsy chase that ends with them tumbling into a pile of soft fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a medium-long shot filmed from ground level with a steady pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by natural bright green and warm ochre tones with soft, layered lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001940036192536354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.2519402503967285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001940036192536354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001940036192536354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17526081204414368, + 0.06482817977666855, + 0.04940688982605934, + 0.059649672359228134, + 0.11186259239912033, + 0.057383209466934204, + 0.07939036190509796, + 0.09990760684013367, + 0.09674744307994843, + 0.20556330680847168 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001940036192536354 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium-long shot, shot from ground level, pans steadily to the right, patiently tracking two large, lushly furred adult giant pandas in a documentary style. They are nestled deep in a dense bamboo forest. Sunlight filters through the gaps between the towering, emerald green leaves, casting dappled shadows on the withered, yellow, fallen ground. One panda is slightly ahead, clumsily twisting its chubby body as it scurries forward on all fours, glancing back frequently. The other, closely behind, pursues with equal clumsiness but enthusiasm, their signature black and white fur stained with dust and grass, lending it a strikingly realistic presence. The chase culminates in a lovable misstep, and the two pandas tumble violently into each other, tumbling into a pile of soft fallen leaves. They gently pat each other's cheeks with their thick paws, silently biting each other, their bodies intertwined in a slow, awkward tumble. The entire picture is painted in natural bright green and warm ochre tones, with soft and layered light, perfectly capturing this non-aggressive, purely playful frolic, creating a tranquil, authentic, and joyful atmosphere of outdoor observation.", + "seed": 23399, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_14/index_7513_seed_23399_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10047175781801343, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10047175781801343, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10047175781801343, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two large adult giant pandas with black and white fur visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense bamboo forest with emerald green leaves and dappled sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the pandas engage in a clumsy chase that ends with them tumbling into a pile of soft fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a medium-long shot filmed from ground level with a steady pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by natural bright green and warm ochre tones with soft, layered lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18066450953483582 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8056645393371582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18066450953483582, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18066450953483582, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14246343076229095, + 0.07311690598726273, + 0.07510171085596085, + 0.04093308746814728, + 0.08600528538227081, + 0.30797111988067627, + 0.04796946793794632, + 0.06738254427909851, + 0.049945905804634094, + 0.1091105192899704 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18066450953483582 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two large adult giant pandas with black and white fur visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense bamboo forest with emerald green leaves and dappled sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the pandas engage in a clumsy chase that ends with them tumbling into a pile of soft fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a medium-long shot filmed from ground level with a steady pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by natural bright green and warm ochre tones with soft, layered lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428365260362625 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017836570739746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428365260362625, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428365260362625, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11541984975337982, + 0.16083982586860657, + 0.20556823909282684, + 0.04865172132849693, + 0.13964416086673737, + 0.12878145277500153, + 0.029132047668099403, + 0.06219534948468208, + 0.028147928416728973, + 0.08161943405866623 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428365260362625 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two large adult giant pandas with black and white fur visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense bamboo forest with emerald green leaves and dappled sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the pandas engage in a clumsy chase that ends with them tumbling into a pile of soft fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a medium-long shot filmed from ground level with a steady pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by natural bright green and warm ochre tones with soft, layered lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12701603770256042 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127016067504883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12701603770256042, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12701603770256042, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10656281560659409, + 0.08716098219156265, + 0.21940724551677704, + 0.0395643375813961, + 0.10363629460334778, + 0.06394661962985992, + 0.03675196319818497, + 0.14361290633678436, + 0.10234103351831436, + 0.09701577574014664 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12701603770256042 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two large adult giant pandas with black and white fur visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense bamboo forest with emerald green leaves and dappled sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the pandas engage in a clumsy chase that ends with them tumbling into a pile of soft fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a medium-long shot filmed from ground level with a steady pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by natural bright green and warm ochre tones with soft, layered lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864807799458504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486481189727783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864807799458504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864807799458504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14969496428966522, + 0.0650126114487648, + 0.0969727411866188, + 0.08626441657543182, + 0.15564213693141937, + 0.1671360433101654, + 0.05347505584359169, + 0.10074160993099213, + 0.06733553111553192, + 0.05772490054368973 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864807799458504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two large adult giant pandas with black and white fur visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a dense bamboo forest with emerald green leaves and dappled sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the pandas engage in a clumsy chase that ends with them tumbling into a pile of soft fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video feature a medium-long shot filmed from ground level with a steady pan to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the color palette dominated by natural bright green and warm ochre tones with soft, layered lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031936378218233585 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531938552856445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031936378218233585, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031936378218233585, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08391527086496353, + 0.10635008662939072, + 0.14417664706707, + 0.04867732524871826, + 0.12939181923866272, + 0.12091222405433655, + 0.03776811808347702, + 0.08939704298973083, + 0.14126981794834137, + 0.0981416255235672 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031936378218233585 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_15/index_tensor([2479, 2479])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_15/index_tensor([2479, 2479])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9e5b3c3a9f2473af5ab8805c6a0ad4d5d7eff95c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_15/index_tensor([2479, 2479])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "majestic wide-angle shot, rendered in the beautiful Ghibli animation style with rich, hand-painted textures, reveals the heart of a vast underground cavern. At the center of this subterranean world, a vast, multi-faceted crystal heart shimmers with a slow, rhythmic, ethereal glow, its light cycling through soft hues of rose, lavender, and warm gold. Surrounding the heart, countless smaller, glowing crystal fragments drift and dance along slow, graceful celestial orbits, weaving intricate paths and leaving faint, shimmering trails in their wake. The camera begins a slow, steady push-in, moving smoothly toward the group of floating gems. As the camera draws closer, the focus gently shifts, causing the magnificent cavern and the heart in the background to melt into a beautiful, blurred tapestry of color and light. The foreground fragments, now in sharp focus, reveal their intricate crystalline structure and the soft inner glow they emit. Their gentle light washes over the scene in ever-changing patterns, imbuing the entire sequence with a tranquil, wondrous, and dreamlike atmosphere.", + "seed": 3897, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_15/index_2479_seed_3897_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.156044410308823, + "vlm_logprob": -0.156044410308823, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.524999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.156044410308823, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast underground cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large multi-faceted crystal heart visible at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless smaller glowing crystal fragments drift and orbit around the central heart?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow steady push-in movement toward the floating gems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background blur while the foreground fragments come into sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6342208385467529 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7592208385467529 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6342208385467529, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6342208385467529, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1832173466682434, + 0.14144903421401978, + 0.03318293020129204, + 0.40826305747032166, + 0.02646990306675434, + 0.02260417491197586, + 0.02819788083434105, + 0.05114743858575821, + 0.032877568155527115, + 0.0725906565785408 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6342208385467529 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast underground cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large multi-faceted crystal heart visible at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless smaller glowing crystal fragments drift and orbit around the central heart?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow steady push-in movement toward the floating gems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background blur while the foreground fragments come into sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032083725091069937 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753208160400391 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032083725091069937, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032083725091069937, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10402757674455643, + 0.06003992259502411, + 0.03365762159228325, + 0.05242055654525757, + 0.034128107130527496, + 0.05629022791981697, + 0.16462713479995728, + 0.08908864110708237, + 0.2715325355529785, + 0.13418763875961304 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032083725091069937 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast underground cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large multi-faceted crystal heart visible at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless smaller glowing crystal fragments drift and orbit around the central heart?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow steady push-in movement toward the floating gems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background blur while the foreground fragments come into sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005955095402896404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130955219268799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005955095402896404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005955095402896404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30541956424713135, + 0.10637924820184708, + 0.024711599573493004, + 0.11055253446102142, + 0.05924112722277641, + 0.07086976617574692, + 0.06779224425554276, + 0.10235413163900375, + 0.08341676741838455, + 0.06926298886537552 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005955095402896404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast underground cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large multi-faceted crystal heart visible at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless smaller glowing crystal fragments drift and orbit around the central heart?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow steady push-in movement toward the floating gems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background blur while the foreground fragments come into sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009782234206795692 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634782314300537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009782234206795692, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009782234206795692, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13022218644618988, + 0.029021499678492546, + 0.05051698163151741, + 0.05559428781270981, + 0.03940986096858978, + 0.05008472874760628, + 0.1384880393743515, + 0.16419675946235657, + 0.12139084190130234, + 0.22107475996017456 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009782234206795692 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast underground cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large multi-faceted crystal heart visible at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless smaller glowing crystal fragments drift and orbit around the central heart?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow steady push-in movement toward the floating gems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background blur while the foreground fragments come into sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12705551087856293 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270554065704346 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12705551087856293, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12705551087856293, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05836521461606026, + 0.021705521270632744, + 0.0386040024459362, + 0.06325922161340714, + 0.05625881254673004, + 0.03894161060452461, + 0.13950133323669434, + 0.1372554749250412, + 0.09869194030761719, + 0.34741687774658203 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12705551087856293 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "majestic wide-angle shot, rendered in the beautiful Ghibli animation style with rich, hand-painted textures, reveals the heart of a vast underground cavern. At the center of this subterranean world, a vast, multi-faceted crystal heart shimmers with a slow, rhythmic, ethereal glow, its light cycling through soft hues of rose, lavender, and warm gold. Surrounding the heart, countless smaller, glowing crystal fragments drift and dance along slow, graceful celestial orbits, weaving intricate paths and leaving faint, shimmering trails in their wake. The camera begins a slow, steady push-in, moving smoothly toward the group of floating gems. As the camera draws closer, the focus gently shifts, causing the magnificent cavern and the heart in the background to melt into a beautiful, blurred tapestry of color and light. The foreground fragments, now in sharp focus, reveal their intricate crystalline structure and the soft inner glow they emit. Their gentle light washes over the scene in ever-changing patterns, imbuing the entire sequence with a tranquil, wondrous, and dreamlike atmosphere.", + "seed": 3898, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_15/index_2479_seed_3898_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.331037962064147, + "vlm_logprob": -0.331037962064147, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.331037962064147, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast underground cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large multi-faceted crystal heart visible at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless smaller glowing crystal fragments drift and orbit around the central heart?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow steady push-in movement toward the floating gems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background blur while the foreground fragments come into sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6008199453353882 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22581997513771057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.6008199453353882, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.6008199453353882, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11121821403503418, + 0.060421429574489594, + 0.012822720222175121, + 0.04036177694797516, + 0.03278443589806557, + 0.43875956535339355, + 0.1278323531150818, + 0.09967252612113953, + 0.04948035255074501, + 0.026646573096513748 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.6008199453353882 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast underground cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large multi-faceted crystal heart visible at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless smaller glowing crystal fragments drift and orbit around the central heart?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow steady push-in movement toward the floating gems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background blur while the foreground fragments come into sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0059665897861123085 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130966663360596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0059665897861123085, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0059665897861123085, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10747426003217697, + 0.05217025801539421, + 0.017252055928111076, + 0.04176124185323715, + 0.08905239403247833, + 0.3931402862071991, + 0.07545237988233566, + 0.11491573601961136, + 0.05632627382874489, + 0.052455127239227295 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0059665897861123085 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast underground cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large multi-faceted crystal heart visible at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless smaller glowing crystal fragments drift and orbit around the central heart?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow steady push-in movement toward the floating gems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background blur while the foreground fragments come into sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036200247704982758 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628620147705078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036200247704982758, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036200247704982758, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14772914350032806, + 0.0607697032392025, + 0.030321795493364334, + 0.03813133016228676, + 0.08551473170518875, + 0.2603835165500641, + 0.1206098422408104, + 0.10706786811351776, + 0.09660433977842331, + 0.05286774784326553 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036200247704982758 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast underground cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large multi-faceted crystal heart visible at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless smaller glowing crystal fragments drift and orbit around the central heart?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow steady push-in movement toward the floating gems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background blur while the foreground fragments come into sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107639167457819 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110764503479 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107639167457819, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107639167457819, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11153391003608704, + 0.038319606333971024, + 0.020572783425450325, + 0.06484521925449371, + 0.09183802455663681, + 0.3568207621574402, + 0.12006855756044388, + 0.10414286702871323, + 0.06376136094331741, + 0.028096962720155716 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107639167457819 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast underground cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large multi-faceted crystal heart visible at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless smaller glowing crystal fragments drift and orbit around the central heart?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow steady push-in movement toward the floating gems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background blur while the foreground fragments come into sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370685875415802 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087069034576416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370685875415802, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370685875415802, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06198960170149803, + 0.06738529354333878, + 0.017705615609884262, + 0.06317991763353348, + 0.07834392040967941, + 0.19659002125263214, + 0.08892007917165756, + 0.3696487843990326, + 0.024638555943965912, + 0.031598176807165146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370685875415802 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "majestic wide-angle shot, rendered in the beautiful Ghibli animation style with rich, hand-painted textures, reveals the heart of a vast underground cavern. At the center of this subterranean world, a vast, multi-faceted crystal heart shimmers with a slow, rhythmic, ethereal glow, its light cycling through soft hues of rose, lavender, and warm gold. Surrounding the heart, countless smaller, glowing crystal fragments drift and dance along slow, graceful celestial orbits, weaving intricate paths and leaving faint, shimmering trails in their wake. The camera begins a slow, steady push-in, moving smoothly toward the group of floating gems. As the camera draws closer, the focus gently shifts, causing the magnificent cavern and the heart in the background to melt into a beautiful, blurred tapestry of color and light. The foreground fragments, now in sharp focus, reveal their intricate crystalline structure and the soft inner glow they emit. Their gentle light washes over the scene in ever-changing patterns, imbuing the entire sequence with a tranquil, wondrous, and dreamlike atmosphere.", + "seed": 3899, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_15/index_2479_seed_3899_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.0708035625051707, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0708035625051707, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0708035625051707, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast underground cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large multi-faceted crystal heart visible at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless smaller glowing crystal fragments drift and orbit around the central heart?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow steady push-in movement toward the floating gems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background blur while the foreground fragments come into sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20236538350582123 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7023653984069824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20236538350582123, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20236538350582123, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4011535048484802, + 0.039817165583372116, + 0.025963449850678444, + 0.040491532534360886, + 0.019316406920552254, + 0.037576936185359955, + 0.3096942901611328, + 0.03256521373987198, + 0.03360077738761902, + 0.059820741415023804 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20236538350582123 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast underground cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large multi-faceted crystal heart visible at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless smaller glowing crystal fragments drift and orbit around the central heart?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow steady push-in movement toward the floating gems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background blur while the foreground fragments come into sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002499910071492195 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002500057220459 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002499910071492195, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002499910071492195, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05053412541747093, + 0.037620481103658676, + 0.022771373391151428, + 0.04772435128688812, + 0.035166751593351364, + 0.06507482379674911, + 0.3378911316394806, + 0.07803747802972794, + 0.185890793800354, + 0.13928861916065216 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002499910071492195 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast underground cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large multi-faceted crystal heart visible at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless smaller glowing crystal fragments drift and orbit around the central heart?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow steady push-in movement toward the floating gems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background blur while the foreground fragments come into sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015170981641858816 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501517295837402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015170981641858816, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015170981641858816, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13399910926818848, + 0.0767810195684433, + 0.06996975094079971, + 0.06241999566555023, + 0.02419731393456459, + 0.13704368472099304, + 0.2227865606546402, + 0.1317773461341858, + 0.0538463220000267, + 0.08717892318964005 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015170981641858816 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast underground cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large multi-faceted crystal heart visible at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless smaller glowing crystal fragments drift and orbit around the central heart?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow steady push-in movement toward the floating gems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background blur while the foreground fragments come into sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058148942887783 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955814838409424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058148942887783, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058148942887783, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08359690755605698, + 0.0849275290966034, + 0.03586405888199806, + 0.13625897467136383, + 0.04825960472226143, + 0.19645196199417114, + 0.09181798249483109, + 0.06727709621191025, + 0.031136224046349525, + 0.22440968453884125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058148942887783 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast underground cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large multi-faceted crystal heart visible at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless smaller glowing crystal fragments drift and orbit around the central heart?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow steady push-in movement toward the floating gems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background blur while the foreground fragments come into sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12705393135547638 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.12705397605896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12705393135547638, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12705393135547638, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11881619691848755, + 0.021219654008746147, + 0.023100998252630234, + 0.09426821768283844, + 0.08950679749250412, + 0.24197447299957275, + 0.24085058271884918, + 0.06538327783346176, + 0.022162187844514847, + 0.08271760493516922 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12705393135547638 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "majestic wide-angle shot, rendered in the beautiful Ghibli animation style with rich, hand-painted textures, reveals the heart of a vast underground cavern. At the center of this subterranean world, a vast, multi-faceted crystal heart shimmers with a slow, rhythmic, ethereal glow, its light cycling through soft hues of rose, lavender, and warm gold. Surrounding the heart, countless smaller, glowing crystal fragments drift and dance along slow, graceful celestial orbits, weaving intricate paths and leaving faint, shimmering trails in their wake. The camera begins a slow, steady push-in, moving smoothly toward the group of floating gems. As the camera draws closer, the focus gently shifts, causing the magnificent cavern and the heart in the background to melt into a beautiful, blurred tapestry of color and light. The foreground fragments, now in sharp focus, reveal their intricate crystalline structure and the soft inner glow they emit. Their gentle light washes over the scene in ever-changing patterns, imbuing the entire sequence with a tranquil, wondrous, and dreamlike atmosphere.", + "seed": 3900, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_15/index_2479_seed_3900_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10621120687574148, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10621120687574148, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10621120687574148, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast underground cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large multi-faceted crystal heart visible at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless smaller glowing crystal fragments drift and orbit around the central heart?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow steady push-in movement toward the floating gems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background blur while the foreground fragments come into sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38800767064094543 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.138007640838623 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38800767064094543, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38800767064094543, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1291106790304184, + 0.2787861227989197, + 0.06497123837471008, + 0.05237031728029251, + 0.09090536087751389, + 0.1653018295764923, + 0.01853981427848339, + 0.03030475415289402, + 0.015822168439626694, + 0.1538877636194229 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38800767064094543 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast underground cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large multi-faceted crystal heart visible at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless smaller glowing crystal fragments drift and orbit around the central heart?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow steady push-in movement toward the floating gems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background blur while the foreground fragments come into sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015255491016432643 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501525402069092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015255491016432643, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015255491016432643, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12109000235795975, + 0.11070919781923294, + 0.05243922024965286, + 0.0964769721031189, + 0.12230552732944489, + 0.20919184386730194, + 0.04792439565062523, + 0.06816045194864273, + 0.0512649230659008, + 0.12043746560811996 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015255491016432643 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast underground cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large multi-faceted crystal heart visible at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless smaller glowing crystal fragments drift and orbit around the central heart?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow steady push-in movement toward the floating gems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background blur while the foreground fragments come into sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019433676498010755 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251943588256836 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019433676498010755, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019433676498010755, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08858282119035721, + 0.09542110562324524, + 0.04220493510365486, + 0.13589568436145782, + 0.12166909873485565, + 0.22891804575920105, + 0.01822282001376152, + 0.028793055564165115, + 0.0218545813113451, + 0.21843786537647247 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019433676498010755 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast underground cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large multi-faceted crystal heart visible at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless smaller glowing crystal fragments drift and orbit around the central heart?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow steady push-in movement toward the floating gems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background blur while the foreground fragments come into sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012535588815808296 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387535572052002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012535588815808296, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012535588815808296, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05259624496102333, + 0.056049149483442307, + 0.04118218272924423, + 0.056230444461107254, + 0.15441648662090302, + 0.08754760771989822, + 0.02863926813006401, + 0.029833387583494186, + 0.01930970326066017, + 0.47419553995132446 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012535588815808296 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set inside a vast underground cavern?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a large multi-faceted crystal heart visible at the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do countless smaller glowing crystal fragments drift and orbit around the central heart?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow steady push-in movement toward the floating gems?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background blur while the foreground fragments come into sharp focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12704385817050934 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270439624786377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12704385817050934, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12704385817050934, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04119231924414635, + 0.07037080824375153, + 0.0370507650077343, + 0.025697149336338043, + 0.09190774708986282, + 0.23567910492420197, + 0.03877900913357735, + 0.0362708754837513, + 0.04919296130537987, + 0.3738592565059662 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12704385817050934 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_2/index_tensor([9623, 9623])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_2/index_tensor([9623, 9623])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..299eab8123301e7c0b0bd31a5e52df5978a94ce1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_2/index_tensor([9623, 9623])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "high-angle, wide-angle lens tilts slowly from left to right, revealing the bustling open-air vegetable market crammed into the town's dilapidated streets. The sidewalk is cracked and uneven, coated in a fine dust that sways into a faint cloud as footsteps sway. The narrow avenue is lined with weathered, two-story buildings with peeling paint and faded awnings, casting deep shadows that contrast starkly with the bright, direct sunlight. Along either side of the road, vendors perch on low wooden benches or sit directly on woven mats, presiding over their wares. Before them, vibrant rows of fresh produce are arranged in tarps and wicker baskets: piles of dark green leafy vegetables, mounds of dirt-caked potatoes and carrots, and pyramids of glistening red tomatoes. A steady, dense stream of people flows purposefully through the market's central artery, their movement creating a continuous, fluid motion. Some stop, stand, or squat to carefully examine the vegetables, while others, carrying woven bags on their backs, weave through the crowds. The event was a lively micro-event: vendors weighed produce on old-fashioned scales, customers pointed decisively at piles of herbs, and small groups momentarily blocked the flow while haggling. The scene was bathed in the hazy morning light, creating a palette of soft earthy tones from the dirt and buildings, dramatically punctuated by the saturated, natural colors of the produce. The overall atmosphere was vibrant, chaotic, yet authentic to daily life—a raw and immersive slice of community commerce.", + "seed": 15038, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_2/index_9623_seed_15038_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.33823026737663897, + "vlm_logprob": -0.33823026737663897, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.250000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.33823026737663897, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vendors visible sitting on low wooden benches or woven mats selling produce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene populated by a dense stream of people moving purposefully through the market?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant rows of fresh produce, including dark green leafy vegetables, potatoes, carrots, and red tomatoes, visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4364742636680603 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.061474323272705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4364742636680603, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.6250000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4364742636680603, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17591027915477753, + 0.07402615249156952, + 0.21574413776397705, + 0.08529125154018402, + 0.1398313045501709, + 0.06702752411365509, + 0.028663380071520805, + 0.09982164204120636, + 0.06516679376363754, + 0.04851757735013962 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4364742636680603 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vendors visible sitting on low wooden benches or woven mats selling produce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene populated by a dense stream of people moving purposefully through the market?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant rows of fresh produce, including dark green leafy vegetables, potatoes, carrots, and red tomatoes, visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521154582500458 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021154880523682 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521154582500458, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521154582500458, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16888469457626343, + 0.06415559351444244, + 0.21580082178115845, + 0.12158235907554626, + 0.13171052932739258, + 0.05645206570625305, + 0.056250013411045074, + 0.03959910571575165, + 0.05707912892103195, + 0.08848568797111511 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521154582500458 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vendors visible sitting on low wooden benches or woven mats selling produce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene populated by a dense stream of people moving purposefully through the market?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant rows of fresh produce, including dark green leafy vegetables, potatoes, carrots, and red tomatoes, visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02635827101767063 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513583660125732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02635827101767063, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02635827101767063, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08925063163042068, + 0.10181030631065369, + 0.08952353149652481, + 0.09559054672718048, + 0.3419860601425171, + 0.059525199234485626, + 0.04716559872031212, + 0.08952347189188004, + 0.04276891052722931, + 0.042855728417634964 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02635827101767063 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vendors visible sitting on low wooden benches or woven mats selling produce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene populated by a dense stream of people moving purposefully through the market?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant rows of fresh produce, including dark green leafy vegetables, potatoes, carrots, and red tomatoes, visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742618799209595 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4742618799209595 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9742618799209595, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9742618799209595, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13094712793827057, + 0.2734311819076538, + 0.1252230852842331, + 0.10183748602867126, + 0.04746915027499199, + 0.049539707601070404, + 0.039696790277957916, + 0.03312695771455765, + 0.09455399960279465, + 0.10417454689741135 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9742618799209595 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vendors visible sitting on low wooden benches or woven mats selling produce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene populated by a dense stream of people moving purposefully through the market?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant rows of fresh produce, including dark green leafy vegetables, potatoes, carrots, and red tomatoes, visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019414640264585614 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251941680908203 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019414640264585614, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019414640264585614, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1358930915594101, + 0.3360334038734436, + 0.0805811807513237, + 0.1188468337059021, + 0.03466567024588585, + 0.06460238993167877, + 0.05750088393688202, + 0.06010904535651207, + 0.05712614953517914, + 0.054641373455524445 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019414640264585614 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-angle, wide-angle lens tilts slowly from left to right, revealing the bustling open-air vegetable market crammed into the town's dilapidated streets. The sidewalk is cracked and uneven, coated in a fine dust that sways into a faint cloud as footsteps sway. The narrow avenue is lined with weathered, two-story buildings with peeling paint and faded awnings, casting deep shadows that contrast starkly with the bright, direct sunlight. Along either side of the road, vendors perch on low wooden benches or sit directly on woven mats, presiding over their wares. Before them, vibrant rows of fresh produce are arranged in tarps and wicker baskets: piles of dark green leafy vegetables, mounds of dirt-caked potatoes and carrots, and pyramids of glistening red tomatoes. A steady, dense stream of people flows purposefully through the market's central artery, their movement creating a continuous, fluid motion. Some stop, stand, or squat to carefully examine the vegetables, while others, carrying woven bags on their backs, weave through the crowds. The event was a lively micro-event: vendors weighed produce on old-fashioned scales, customers pointed decisively at piles of herbs, and small groups momentarily blocked the flow while haggling. The scene was bathed in the hazy morning light, creating a palette of soft earthy tones from the dirt and buildings, dramatically punctuated by the saturated, natural colors of the produce. The overall atmosphere was vibrant, chaotic, yet authentic to daily life—a raw and immersive slice of community commerce.", + "seed": 15039, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_2/index_9623_seed_15039_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.25307172872126105, + "vlm_logprob": -0.25307172872126105, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.25307172872126105, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vendors visible sitting on low wooden benches or woven mats selling produce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene populated by a dense stream of people moving purposefully through the market?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant rows of fresh produce, including dark green leafy vegetables, potatoes, carrots, and red tomatoes, visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09717895835638046 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4721789360046387 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09717895835638046, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09717895835638046, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7992631196975708, + 0.01892254315316677, + 0.020160943269729614, + 0.05342194437980652, + 0.011868128553032875, + 0.013140485621988773, + 0.010141737759113312, + 0.009352358058094978, + 0.012923767790198326, + 0.05080506578087807 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09717895835638046 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vendors visible sitting on low wooden benches or woven mats selling produce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene populated by a dense stream of people moving purposefully through the market?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant rows of fresh produce, including dark green leafy vegetables, potatoes, carrots, and red tomatoes, visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520906329154968 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020906925201416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520906329154968, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520906329154968, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.38707461953163147, + 0.06976248323917389, + 0.06901151686906815, + 0.07100816071033478, + 0.05016910657286644, + 0.06592633575201035, + 0.049959879368543625, + 0.063679039478302, + 0.06299332529306412, + 0.11041554808616638 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520906329154968 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vendors visible sitting on low wooden benches or woven mats selling produce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene populated by a dense stream of people moving purposefully through the market?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant rows of fresh produce, including dark green leafy vegetables, potatoes, carrots, and red tomatoes, visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016075406223535538 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141075611114502 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016075406223535538, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016075406223535538, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6951789259910583, + 0.05056217312812805, + 0.047781988978385925, + 0.02441379241645336, + 0.08003492653369904, + 0.019696999341249466, + 0.01638021133840084, + 0.02024976536631584, + 0.012531117536127567, + 0.03317013010382652 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016075406223535538 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vendors visible sitting on low wooden benches or woven mats selling produce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene populated by a dense stream of people moving purposefully through the market?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant rows of fresh produce, including dark green leafy vegetables, potatoes, carrots, and red tomatoes, visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8982996940612793 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5232996940612793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8982996940612793, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8982996940612793, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6736180782318115, + 0.05538817495107651, + 0.06638617813587189, + 0.021937783807516098, + 0.08119222521781921, + 0.015144630335271358, + 0.014460688456892967, + 0.02307320572435856, + 0.025180811062455177, + 0.023618174716830254 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8982996940612793 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vendors visible sitting on low wooden benches or woven mats selling produce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene populated by a dense stream of people moving purposefully through the market?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant rows of fresh produce, including dark green leafy vegetables, potatoes, carrots, and red tomatoes, visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001713952049612999 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376713752746582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001713952049612999, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001713952049612999, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7520105838775635, + 0.055673748254776, + 0.039127178490161896, + 0.02164349891245365, + 0.05163951590657234, + 0.012496087700128555, + 0.01065367553383112, + 0.01944868639111519, + 0.01591387763619423, + 0.021393178030848503 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001713952049612999 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-angle, wide-angle lens tilts slowly from left to right, revealing the bustling open-air vegetable market crammed into the town's dilapidated streets. The sidewalk is cracked and uneven, coated in a fine dust that sways into a faint cloud as footsteps sway. The narrow avenue is lined with weathered, two-story buildings with peeling paint and faded awnings, casting deep shadows that contrast starkly with the bright, direct sunlight. Along either side of the road, vendors perch on low wooden benches or sit directly on woven mats, presiding over their wares. Before them, vibrant rows of fresh produce are arranged in tarps and wicker baskets: piles of dark green leafy vegetables, mounds of dirt-caked potatoes and carrots, and pyramids of glistening red tomatoes. A steady, dense stream of people flows purposefully through the market's central artery, their movement creating a continuous, fluid motion. Some stop, stand, or squat to carefully examine the vegetables, while others, carrying woven bags on their backs, weave through the crowds. The event was a lively micro-event: vendors weighed produce on old-fashioned scales, customers pointed decisively at piles of herbs, and small groups momentarily blocked the flow while haggling. The scene was bathed in the hazy morning light, creating a palette of soft earthy tones from the dirt and buildings, dramatically punctuated by the saturated, natural colors of the produce. The overall atmosphere was vibrant, chaotic, yet authentic to daily life—a raw and immersive slice of community commerce.", + "seed": 15040, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_2/index_9623_seed_15040_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.45611331341788175, + "vlm_logprob": -0.45611331341788175, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.949999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.45611331341788175, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vendors visible sitting on low wooden benches or woven mats selling produce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene populated by a dense stream of people moving purposefully through the market?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant rows of fresh produce, including dark green leafy vegetables, potatoes, carrots, and red tomatoes, visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3193904161453247 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3193904161453247 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.3193904161453247, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.3193904161453247, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22986270487308502, + 0.07708180695772171, + 0.06528627127408981, + 0.036176569759845734, + 0.07137981057167053, + 0.09598894417285919, + 0.2073124498128891, + 0.0829310268163681, + 0.09348426759243011, + 0.040496114641427994 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.3193904161453247 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vendors visible sitting on low wooden benches or woven mats selling produce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene populated by a dense stream of people moving purposefully through the market?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant rows of fresh produce, including dark green leafy vegetables, potatoes, carrots, and red tomatoes, visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17993704974651337 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049370050430298 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17993704974651337, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17993704974651337, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07253284752368927, + 0.10421368479728699, + 0.08374381810426712, + 0.08599461615085602, + 0.1409948170185089, + 0.07039774954319, + 0.19594840705394745, + 0.086612269282341, + 0.1301308125257492, + 0.029430938884615898 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17993704974651337 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vendors visible sitting on low wooden benches or woven mats selling produce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene populated by a dense stream of people moving purposefully through the market?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant rows of fresh produce, including dark green leafy vegetables, potatoes, carrots, and red tomatoes, visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018200531601905823 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018200397491455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018200531601905823, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018200531601905823, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2305292934179306, + 0.09430284798145294, + 0.12928666174411774, + 0.05148588865995407, + 0.07692841440439224, + 0.03378882259130478, + 0.10513513535261154, + 0.04574662819504738, + 0.17294149100780487, + 0.05985478684306145 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018200531601905823 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vendors visible sitting on low wooden benches or woven mats selling produce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene populated by a dense stream of people moving purposefully through the market?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant rows of fresh produce, including dark green leafy vegetables, potatoes, carrots, and red tomatoes, visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7577831149101257 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6327831149101257 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7577831149101257, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7577831149101257, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1951896846294403, + 0.07786666601896286, + 0.08911853283643723, + 0.04453293979167938, + 0.08920326828956604, + 0.08392991125583649, + 0.10734681785106659, + 0.07661138474941254, + 0.1367645263671875, + 0.0994361937046051 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7577831149101257 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vendors visible sitting on low wooden benches or woven mats selling produce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene populated by a dense stream of people moving purposefully through the market?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant rows of fresh produce, including dark green leafy vegetables, potatoes, carrots, and red tomatoes, visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005255454685539007 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255255222320557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005255454685539007, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005255454685539007, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.251932293176651, + 0.08208689838647842, + 0.14316526055335999, + 0.05214926600456238, + 0.07342920452356339, + 0.08619316667318344, + 0.07674162089824677, + 0.06465449184179306, + 0.08482484519481659, + 0.08482301980257034 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005255454685539007 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "high-angle, wide-angle lens tilts slowly from left to right, revealing the bustling open-air vegetable market crammed into the town's dilapidated streets. The sidewalk is cracked and uneven, coated in a fine dust that sways into a faint cloud as footsteps sway. The narrow avenue is lined with weathered, two-story buildings with peeling paint and faded awnings, casting deep shadows that contrast starkly with the bright, direct sunlight. Along either side of the road, vendors perch on low wooden benches or sit directly on woven mats, presiding over their wares. Before them, vibrant rows of fresh produce are arranged in tarps and wicker baskets: piles of dark green leafy vegetables, mounds of dirt-caked potatoes and carrots, and pyramids of glistening red tomatoes. A steady, dense stream of people flows purposefully through the market's central artery, their movement creating a continuous, fluid motion. Some stop, stand, or squat to carefully examine the vegetables, while others, carrying woven bags on their backs, weave through the crowds. The event was a lively micro-event: vendors weighed produce on old-fashioned scales, customers pointed decisively at piles of herbs, and small groups momentarily blocked the flow while haggling. The scene was bathed in the hazy morning light, creating a palette of soft earthy tones from the dirt and buildings, dramatically punctuated by the saturated, natural colors of the produce. The overall atmosphere was vibrant, chaotic, yet authentic to daily life—a raw and immersive slice of community commerce.", + "seed": 15041, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_2/index_9623_seed_15041_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1985462846234441, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1985462846234441, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1985462846234441, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vendors visible sitting on low wooden benches or woven mats selling produce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene populated by a dense stream of people moving purposefully through the market?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant rows of fresh produce, including dark green leafy vegetables, potatoes, carrots, and red tomatoes, visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5863756537437439 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8363756537437439 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5863756537437439, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5863756537437439, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21557888388633728, + 0.13413932919502258, + 0.07773300260305405, + 0.08367730677127838, + 0.052433524280786514, + 0.057837191969156265, + 0.05911991000175476, + 0.13206353783607483, + 0.13438138365745544, + 0.05303593724966049 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5863756537437439 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vendors visible sitting on low wooden benches or woven mats selling produce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene populated by a dense stream of people moving purposefully through the market?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant rows of fresh produce, including dark green leafy vegetables, potatoes, carrots, and red tomatoes, visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0790141150355339 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790140628814697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0790141150355339, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0790141150355339, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27951890230178833, + 0.15437141060829163, + 0.03826144337654114, + 0.1416684091091156, + 0.1455657035112381, + 0.08320876210927963, + 0.040903594344854355, + 0.032696910202503204, + 0.029678162187337875, + 0.05412667989730835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0790141150355339 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vendors visible sitting on low wooden benches or woven mats selling produce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene populated by a dense stream of people moving purposefully through the market?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant rows of fresh produce, including dark green leafy vegetables, potatoes, carrots, and red tomatoes, visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009795336984097958 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634795188903809 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009795336984097958, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009795336984097958, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14584290981292725, + 0.14257968962192535, + 0.07366065680980682, + 0.05569416657090187, + 0.13121524453163147, + 0.0865892544388771, + 0.11354281008243561, + 0.11809559911489487, + 0.05867820605635643, + 0.0741015151143074 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009795336984097958 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vendors visible sitting on low wooden benches or woven mats selling produce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene populated by a dense stream of people moving purposefully through the market?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant rows of fresh produce, including dark green leafy vegetables, potatoes, carrots, and red tomatoes, visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31345152854919434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134515285491943 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31345152854919434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31345152854919434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1769971400499344, + 0.1338391900062561, + 0.03915485739707947, + 0.08197056502103806, + 0.06095258146524429, + 0.141484797000885, + 0.11371022462844849, + 0.09144023805856705, + 0.07920068502426147, + 0.08124973624944687 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31345152854919434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at a high angle looking down at the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt slowly from left to right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are vendors visible sitting on low wooden benches or woven mats selling produce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene populated by a dense stream of people moving purposefully through the market?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are vibrant rows of fresh produce, including dark green leafy vegetables, potatoes, carrots, and red tomatoes, visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004094788804650307 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.50409460067749 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004094788804650307, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004094788804650307, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.221329003572464, + 0.19614318013191223, + 0.049100760370492935, + 0.056253790855407715, + 0.16647116839885712, + 0.06834245473146439, + 0.05857570841908455, + 0.07662828266620636, + 0.05413539707660675, + 0.053020279854536057 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004094788804650307 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_3/index_tensor([7906, 7906])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_3/index_tensor([7906, 7906])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a2625ba32e09b0f3cfc3495da04bcb2f99077b74 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_3/index_tensor([7906, 7906])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up, overhead macro shot sweeps smoothly from left to right across the surface of a fluffy, creamy white wool quilt in a slow, steady rhythm. Illuminated by bright, even, and shadowless studio lighting, the image exudes the pure, high-end aesthetic of an e-commerce main image. Countless delicate, curly wool fibers are magnified to the utmost, interwoven to create a soft, three-dimensional, fluffy, cloud-like texture, each fiber radiating a subtle, natural sheen. As the camera gracefully glides, the quilt's delicate texture and the depth of its pile are gradually revealed. The background is a pure white, slightly blurred backdrop, focusing the entire visual experience on the tactile feel of the wool. The scene's warm, soft tones, devoid of a hint of color, create a tranquil, pure, and alluring atmosphere through the meticulous attention to detail, visually conveying the ultimate in comfort and luxurious softness.", + "seed": 23749, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_3/index_7906_seed_23749_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04157362231053412, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04157362231053412, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04157362231053412, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a fluffy, creamy white wool quilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless delicate, curly wool fibers visible in a magnified macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, even, and shadowless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep smoothly from left to right across the quilt surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure white, slightly blurred backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.031318049877882004 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.531317949295044 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.031318049877882004, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.031318049877882004, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09209451824426651, + 0.14945465326309204, + 0.19842924177646637, + 0.03360941261053085, + 0.0868978276848793, + 0.03551002964377403, + 0.06750982254743576, + 0.06497004628181458, + 0.11941921710968018, + 0.1521051824092865 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.031318049877882004 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a fluffy, creamy white wool quilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless delicate, curly wool fibers visible in a magnified macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, even, and shadowless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep smoothly from left to right across the quilt surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure white, slightly blurred backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036239444743841887 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628623962402344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036239444743841887, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036239444743841887, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15008710324764252, + 0.17025750875473022, + 0.16808484494686127, + 0.050969138741493225, + 0.03232346847653389, + 0.03351207077503204, + 0.10977517068386078, + 0.034519683569669724, + 0.15665291249752045, + 0.09381812810897827 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036239444743841887 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a fluffy, creamy white wool quilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless delicate, curly wool fibers visible in a magnified macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, even, and shadowless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep smoothly from left to right across the quilt surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure white, slightly blurred backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978105328977108 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347808837890625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978105328977108, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978105328977108, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11398742347955704, + 0.10409974306821823, + 0.1251593381166458, + 0.12088634073734283, + 0.08714804798364639, + 0.031067688018083572, + 0.1539214849472046, + 0.06087230145931244, + 0.12458870559930801, + 0.07826896756887436 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978105328977108 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a fluffy, creamy white wool quilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless delicate, curly wool fibers visible in a magnified macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, even, and shadowless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep smoothly from left to right across the quilt surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure white, slightly blurred backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16033032536506653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103302955627441 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16033032536506653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16033032536506653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05039732903242111, + 0.10441287606954575, + 0.06336001306772232, + 0.015608876012265682, + 0.04022717475891113, + 0.020502537488937378, + 0.2673584222793579, + 0.03659980371594429, + 0.35198235511779785, + 0.049550555646419525 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16033032536506653 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a fluffy, creamy white wool quilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless delicate, curly wool fibers visible in a magnified macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, even, and shadowless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep smoothly from left to right across the quilt surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure white, slightly blurred backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028147385455667973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877814769744873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028147385455667973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028147385455667973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09980428963899612, + 0.09086424112319946, + 0.0831562876701355, + 0.143605038523674, + 0.14204399287700653, + 0.03812330216169357, + 0.1214895024895668, + 0.07399266213178635, + 0.12039191275835037, + 0.08652879297733307 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028147385455667973 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, overhead macro shot sweeps smoothly from left to right across the surface of a fluffy, creamy white wool quilt in a slow, steady rhythm. Illuminated by bright, even, and shadowless studio lighting, the image exudes the pure, high-end aesthetic of an e-commerce main image. Countless delicate, curly wool fibers are magnified to the utmost, interwoven to create a soft, three-dimensional, fluffy, cloud-like texture, each fiber radiating a subtle, natural sheen. As the camera gracefully glides, the quilt's delicate texture and the depth of its pile are gradually revealed. The background is a pure white, slightly blurred backdrop, focusing the entire visual experience on the tactile feel of the wool. The scene's warm, soft tones, devoid of a hint of color, create a tranquil, pure, and alluring atmosphere through the meticulous attention to detail, visually conveying the ultimate in comfort and luxurious softness.", + "seed": 23750, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_3/index_7906_seed_23750_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0329849534900859, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0329849534900859, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0329849534900859, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a fluffy, creamy white wool quilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless delicate, curly wool fibers visible in a magnified macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, even, and shadowless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep smoothly from left to right across the quilt surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure white, slightly blurred backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04587125405669212 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1708712577819824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04587125405669212, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04587125405669212, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13656958937644958, + 0.05630858242511749, + 0.11003009974956512, + 0.08729135245084763, + 0.1297779530286789, + 0.021912911906838417, + 0.11109541356563568, + 0.16554872691631317, + 0.06500834971666336, + 0.1164570227265358 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04587125405669212 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a fluffy, creamy white wool quilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless delicate, curly wool fibers visible in a magnified macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, even, and shadowless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep smoothly from left to right across the quilt surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure white, slightly blurred backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007643973920494318 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882644176483154 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007643973920494318, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007643973920494318, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3775410056114197, + 0.07796784490346909, + 0.11446306109428406, + 0.05387991666793823, + 0.07881893217563629, + 0.01841968111693859, + 0.057725321501493454, + 0.06516581028699875, + 0.020628297701478004, + 0.13539016246795654 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007643973920494318 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a fluffy, creamy white wool quilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless delicate, curly wool fibers visible in a magnified macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, even, and shadowless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep smoothly from left to right across the quilt surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure white, slightly blurred backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009784004651010036 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63478422164917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009784004651010036, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009784004651010036, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1345135122537613, + 0.08607705682516098, + 0.07906389981508255, + 0.0637161135673523, + 0.3722712993621826, + 0.0370902381837368, + 0.12843389809131622, + 0.018579717725515366, + 0.017842963337898254, + 0.062411267310380936 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009784004651010036 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a fluffy, creamy white wool quilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless delicate, curly wool fibers visible in a magnified macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, even, and shadowless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep smoothly from left to right across the quilt surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure white, slightly blurred backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10029080510139465 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3502907752990723 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10029080510139465, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10029080510139465, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3440972864627838, + 0.1055460199713707, + 0.10166829079389572, + 0.0366988442838192, + 0.19979119300842285, + 0.02064109779894352, + 0.03169943392276764, + 0.0340559259057045, + 0.09751257300376892, + 0.0282893106341362 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10029080510139465 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a fluffy, creamy white wool quilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless delicate, curly wool fibers visible in a magnified macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, even, and shadowless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep smoothly from left to right across the quilt surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure white, slightly blurred backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001334729720838368 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.6263346672058105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001334729720838368, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001334729720838368, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21701984107494354, + 0.03634178638458252, + 0.021383466199040413, + 0.011679094284772873, + 0.4766746163368225, + 0.028051426634192467, + 0.10966994613409042, + 0.03628591448068619, + 0.012606075964868069, + 0.05028780549764633 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001334729720838368 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, overhead macro shot sweeps smoothly from left to right across the surface of a fluffy, creamy white wool quilt in a slow, steady rhythm. Illuminated by bright, even, and shadowless studio lighting, the image exudes the pure, high-end aesthetic of an e-commerce main image. Countless delicate, curly wool fibers are magnified to the utmost, interwoven to create a soft, three-dimensional, fluffy, cloud-like texture, each fiber radiating a subtle, natural sheen. As the camera gracefully glides, the quilt's delicate texture and the depth of its pile are gradually revealed. The background is a pure white, slightly blurred backdrop, focusing the entire visual experience on the tactile feel of the wool. The scene's warm, soft tones, devoid of a hint of color, create a tranquil, pure, and alluring atmosphere through the meticulous attention to detail, visually conveying the ultimate in comfort and luxurious softness.", + "seed": 23751, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_3/index_7906_seed_23751_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.11017677267082035, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11017677267082035, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11017677267082035, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a fluffy, creamy white wool quilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless delicate, curly wool fibers visible in a magnified macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, even, and shadowless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep smoothly from left to right across the quilt surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure white, slightly blurred backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014267224818468094 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.389267444610596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014267224818468094, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014267224818468094, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1661383956670761, + 0.07257305085659027, + 0.22781260311603546, + 0.021979622542858124, + 0.052544575184583664, + 0.07566555589437485, + 0.05540283024311066, + 0.05928685888648033, + 0.21024061739444733, + 0.058355867862701416 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014267224818468094 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a fluffy, creamy white wool quilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless delicate, curly wool fibers visible in a magnified macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, even, and shadowless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep smoothly from left to right across the quilt surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure white, slightly blurred backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004648237023502588 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379648208618164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004648237023502588, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004648237023502588, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05087339133024216, + 0.02337932586669922, + 0.3705383241176605, + 0.09897956997156143, + 0.07077432423830032, + 0.0827675461769104, + 0.023788297548890114, + 0.12124697864055634, + 0.10622192919254303, + 0.051430340856313705 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004648237023502588 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a fluffy, creamy white wool quilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless delicate, curly wool fibers visible in a magnified macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, even, and shadowless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep smoothly from left to right across the quilt surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure white, slightly blurred backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00673760985955596 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00673770904541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00673760985955596, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00673760985955596, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1793144792318344, + 0.17963807284832, + 0.19018113613128662, + 0.034767020493745804, + 0.03166981413960457, + 0.027696723118424416, + 0.021719055250287056, + 0.2273520529270172, + 0.07011658698320389, + 0.03754505515098572 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00673760985955596 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a fluffy, creamy white wool quilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless delicate, curly wool fibers visible in a magnified macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, even, and shadowless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep smoothly from left to right across the quilt surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure white, slightly blurred backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.523291826248169 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.898291826248169 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.523291826248169, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.523291826248169, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07450053095817566, + 0.30748188495635986, + 0.21762576699256897, + 0.02486564591526985, + 0.03917771205306053, + 0.029164087027311325, + 0.017378663644194603, + 0.22227898240089417, + 0.04152943566441536, + 0.025997281074523926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.523291826248169 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a fluffy, creamy white wool quilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless delicate, curly wool fibers visible in a magnified macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, even, and shadowless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep smoothly from left to right across the quilt surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure white, slightly blurred backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00193896540440619 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251938819885254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00193896540440619, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00193896540440619, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04500233381986618, + 0.08879438787698746, + 0.47882986068725586, + 0.042402759194374084, + 0.044340893626213074, + 0.026716262102127075, + 0.04185163229703903, + 0.11745665967464447, + 0.08554533869028091, + 0.029059892520308495 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00193896540440619 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up, overhead macro shot sweeps smoothly from left to right across the surface of a fluffy, creamy white wool quilt in a slow, steady rhythm. Illuminated by bright, even, and shadowless studio lighting, the image exudes the pure, high-end aesthetic of an e-commerce main image. Countless delicate, curly wool fibers are magnified to the utmost, interwoven to create a soft, three-dimensional, fluffy, cloud-like texture, each fiber radiating a subtle, natural sheen. As the camera gracefully glides, the quilt's delicate texture and the depth of its pile are gradually revealed. The background is a pure white, slightly blurred backdrop, focusing the entire visual experience on the tactile feel of the wool. The scene's warm, soft tones, devoid of a hint of color, create a tranquil, pure, and alluring atmosphere through the meticulous attention to detail, visually conveying the ultimate in comfort and luxurious softness.", + "seed": 23752, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_3/index_7906_seed_23752_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.08007904635742306, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08007904635742306, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08007904635742306, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a fluffy, creamy white wool quilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless delicate, curly wool fibers visible in a magnified macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, even, and shadowless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep smoothly from left to right across the quilt surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure white, slightly blurred backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05810160934925079 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9331016540527344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05810160934925079, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05810160934925079, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14821258187294006, + 0.08659043163061142, + 0.04966332018375397, + 0.10437622666358948, + 0.1899442970752716, + 0.0800444707274437, + 0.07658936083316803, + 0.08399466425180435, + 0.10749299824237823, + 0.07309161871671677 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05810160934925079 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a fluffy, creamy white wool quilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless delicate, curly wool fibers visible in a magnified macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, even, and shadowless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep smoothly from left to right across the quilt surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure white, slightly blurred backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01255571935325861 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875555992126465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01255571935325861, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01255571935325861, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1870296746492386, + 0.07783184945583344, + 0.052573177963495255, + 0.07487650215625763, + 0.2137996405363083, + 0.06854762136936188, + 0.08369816839694977, + 0.054867301136255264, + 0.08201209455728531, + 0.104763925075531 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01255571935325861 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a fluffy, creamy white wool quilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless delicate, curly wool fibers visible in a magnified macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, even, and shadowless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep smoothly from left to right across the quilt surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure white, slightly blurred backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011079221963882446 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51107931137085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011079221963882446, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011079221963882446, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2186528891324997, + 0.0696684718132019, + 0.08626274764537811, + 0.15154342353343964, + 0.049423642456531525, + 0.08363144844770432, + 0.08191205561161041, + 0.07072892785072327, + 0.1077686995267868, + 0.08040770143270493 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011079221963882446 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a fluffy, creamy white wool quilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless delicate, curly wool fibers visible in a magnified macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, even, and shadowless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep smoothly from left to right across the quilt surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure white, slightly blurred backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.313410222530365 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134102821350098 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.313410222530365, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.313410222530365, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14881792664527893, + 0.13067609071731567, + 0.0809650793671608, + 0.0862833634018898, + 0.058565039187669754, + 0.07406763732433319, + 0.09714002907276154, + 0.08318320661783218, + 0.10300327837467194, + 0.13729830086231232 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.313410222530365 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a fluffy, creamy white wool quilt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are countless delicate, curly wool fibers visible in a magnified macro view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, even, and shadowless?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera sweep smoothly from left to right across the quilt surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a pure white, slightly blurred backdrop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005248458590358496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255248546600342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005248458590358496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005248458590358496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1949959695339203, + 0.16385525465011597, + 0.15529733896255493, + 0.09237468987703323, + 0.08858998864889145, + 0.039757706224918365, + 0.046181682497262955, + 0.12667854130268097, + 0.046181973069906235, + 0.04608679562807083 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005248458590358496 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_4/index_tensor([6571, 6571])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_4/index_tensor([6571, 6571])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e25610cc8bd569467d5500bfa830c67928c12a0a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_4/index_tensor([6571, 6571])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatic, low-angle extreme close-up shot, captured with the precision of macro photography and a shallow depth of field, frames a photorealistic miniature collision on a polished, dark wood Chinese chessboard. Two ornate pieces, a regal General carved from rich, red-lacquered wood with its 'will' character filled with gleaming gold leaf, and a dark, ebony-like Cannon with its 'gun' character etched in stark white, clash with immense, hyper-realistic force. At the exact moment of impact, a visible shockwave ripples across the board's glossy surface, and a violent shower of tiny, sharp wood splinters explodes from the Cannon piece. The entire scene is bathed in the stark, high-contrast light of a single overhead source, which carves out deep, dramatic shadows that stretch across the board. monumental, collision.", + "seed": 11086, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_4/index_6571_seed_11086_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.014134430978447198, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014134430978447198, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014134430978447198, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a low-angle extreme close-up with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a polished, dark wood Chinese chessboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a red-lacquered General piece with gold leaf on its 'will' character visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a dark ebony-like Cannon piece with white 'gun' character etching visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a visible shockwave and exploding wood splinters at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023556141182780266 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.398556232452393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023556141182780266, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023556141182780266, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23391032218933105, + 0.41187921166419983, + 0.03624400123953819, + 0.03306753933429718, + 0.05425388738512993, + 0.05485478416085243, + 0.0771372839808464, + 0.023810751736164093, + 0.042488425970077515, + 0.03235381096601486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023556141182780266 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a low-angle extreme close-up with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a polished, dark wood Chinese chessboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a red-lacquered General piece with gold leaf on its 'will' character visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a dark ebony-like Cannon piece with white 'gun' character etching visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a visible shockwave and exploding wood splinters at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014214809983968735 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264214992523193 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014214809983968735, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014214809983968735, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27563467621803284, + 0.17502708733081818, + 0.09349268674850464, + 0.13185997307300568, + 0.0713791474699974, + 0.038257479667663574, + 0.08773425966501236, + 0.0110954400151968, + 0.013011614792048931, + 0.10250764340162277 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014214809983968735 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a low-angle extreme close-up with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a polished, dark wood Chinese chessboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a red-lacquered General piece with gold leaf on its 'will' character visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a dark ebony-like Cannon piece with white 'gun' character etching visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a visible shockwave and exploding wood splinters at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014201881363987923 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264202117919922 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014201881363987923, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014201881363987923, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0833788588643074, + 0.3964061737060547, + 0.06730911135673523, + 0.20244285464286804, + 0.050940170884132385, + 0.03136472776532173, + 0.07489234209060669, + 0.022884467616677284, + 0.03213151916861534, + 0.038249701261520386 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014201881363987923 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a low-angle extreme close-up with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a polished, dark wood Chinese chessboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a red-lacquered General piece with gold leaf on its 'will' character visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a dark ebony-like Cannon piece with white 'gun' character etching visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a visible shockwave and exploding wood splinters at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00762729300186038 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882627487182617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00762729300186038, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00762729300186038, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15054862201213837, + 0.2057560831308365, + 0.02961057610809803, + 0.14786387979984283, + 0.06641512364149094, + 0.17552101612091064, + 0.10957878082990646, + 0.04056273400783539, + 0.03938082233071327, + 0.03476233035326004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00762729300186038 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a low-angle extreme close-up with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a polished, dark wood Chinese chessboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a red-lacquered General piece with gold leaf on its 'will' character visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a dark ebony-like Cannon piece with white 'gun' character etching visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a visible shockwave and exploding wood splinters at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011072029359638691 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511072158813477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011072029359638691, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011072029359638691, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28478819131851196, + 0.18741776049137115, + 0.06033075600862503, + 0.04598943889141083, + 0.03105635568499565, + 0.3026571273803711, + 0.01572606898844242, + 0.0386367030441761, + 0.023417741060256958, + 0.00997985526919365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011072029359638691 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic, low-angle extreme close-up shot, captured with the precision of macro photography and a shallow depth of field, frames a photorealistic miniature collision on a polished, dark wood Chinese chessboard. Two ornate pieces, a regal General carved from rich, red-lacquered wood with its 'will' character filled with gleaming gold leaf, and a dark, ebony-like Cannon with its 'gun' character etched in stark white, clash with immense, hyper-realistic force. At the exact moment of impact, a visible shockwave ripples across the board's glossy surface, and a violent shower of tiny, sharp wood splinters explodes from the Cannon piece. The entire scene is bathed in the stark, high-contrast light of a single overhead source, which carves out deep, dramatic shadows that stretch across the board. monumental, collision.", + "seed": 11087, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_4/index_6571_seed_11087_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06720895823091269, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06720895823091269, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06720895823091269, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a low-angle extreme close-up with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a polished, dark wood Chinese chessboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a red-lacquered General piece with gold leaf on its 'will' character visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a dark ebony-like Cannon piece with white 'gun' character etching visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a visible shockwave and exploding wood splinters at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04074561968445778 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.540745735168457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04074561968445778, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04074561968445778, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20437435805797577, + 0.025082433596253395, + 0.12064136564731598, + 0.449663370847702, + 0.013278758153319359, + 0.06377837806940079, + 0.017920395359396935, + 0.045035213232040405, + 0.021157920360565186, + 0.03906780853867531 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04074561968445778 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a low-angle extreme close-up with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a polished, dark wood Chinese chessboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a red-lacquered General piece with gold leaf on its 'will' character visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a dark ebony-like Cannon piece with white 'gun' character etching visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a visible shockwave and exploding wood splinters at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011097495444118977 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511097431182861 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011097495444118977, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011097495444118977, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1354447901248932, + 0.14310063421726227, + 0.12340126186609268, + 0.26247406005859375, + 0.06065709888935089, + 0.08214864879846573, + 0.053402531892061234, + 0.03585381433367729, + 0.05392127484083176, + 0.049595825374126434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011097495444118977 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a low-angle extreme close-up with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a polished, dark wood Chinese chessboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a red-lacquered General piece with gold leaf on its 'will' character visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a dark ebony-like Cannon piece with white 'gun' character etching visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a visible shockwave and exploding wood splinters at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607481949031353 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410746574401855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607481949031353, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607481949031353, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1378541886806488, + 0.07209494709968567, + 0.32772305607795715, + 0.11905955523252487, + 0.049659207463264465, + 0.04987240582704544, + 0.06677564233541489, + 0.06574080884456635, + 0.04405675455927849, + 0.06716347485780716 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607481949031353 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a low-angle extreme close-up with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a polished, dark wood Chinese chessboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a red-lacquered General piece with gold leaf on its 'will' character visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a dark ebony-like Cannon piece with white 'gun' character etching visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a visible shockwave and exploding wood splinters at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606578752398491 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14106559753418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606578752398491, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606578752398491, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1512698531150818, + 0.07484883815050125, + 0.08727435767650604, + 0.13761727511882782, + 0.10828603059053421, + 0.11276751011610031, + 0.03770441934466362, + 0.09765347838401794, + 0.06077934056520462, + 0.1317988634109497 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606578752398491 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a low-angle extreme close-up with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a polished, dark wood Chinese chessboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a red-lacquered General piece with gold leaf on its 'will' character visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a dark ebony-like Cannon piece with white 'gun' character etching visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a visible shockwave and exploding wood splinters at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25206106901168823 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502061128616333 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25206106901168823, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25206106901168823, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16673506796360016, + 0.051114216446876526, + 0.2161245197057724, + 0.1940343976020813, + 0.04389268532395363, + 0.05096837878227234, + 0.026948077604174614, + 0.13838328421115875, + 0.031561657786369324, + 0.08023776113986969 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25206106901168823 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic, low-angle extreme close-up shot, captured with the precision of macro photography and a shallow depth of field, frames a photorealistic miniature collision on a polished, dark wood Chinese chessboard. Two ornate pieces, a regal General carved from rich, red-lacquered wood with its 'will' character filled with gleaming gold leaf, and a dark, ebony-like Cannon with its 'gun' character etched in stark white, clash with immense, hyper-realistic force. At the exact moment of impact, a visible shockwave ripples across the board's glossy surface, and a violent shower of tiny, sharp wood splinters explodes from the Cannon piece. The entire scene is bathed in the stark, high-contrast light of a single overhead source, which carves out deep, dramatic shadows that stretch across the board. monumental, collision.", + "seed": 11088, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_4/index_6571_seed_11088_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.16267712451517582, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16267712451517582, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16267712451517582, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a low-angle extreme close-up with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a polished, dark wood Chinese chessboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a red-lacquered General piece with gold leaf on its 'will' character visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a dark ebony-like Cannon piece with white 'gun' character etching visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a visible shockwave and exploding wood splinters at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6455797553062439 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7705797553062439 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6455797553062439, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6455797553062439, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1879844218492508, + 0.04157232865691185, + 0.029419394209980965, + 0.06318987905979156, + 0.24485330283641815, + 0.22227396070957184, + 0.0752408429980278, + 0.043505746871232986, + 0.04198051989078522, + 0.04997958615422249 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6455797553062439 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a low-angle extreme close-up with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a polished, dark wood Chinese chessboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a red-lacquered General piece with gold leaf on its 'will' character visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a dark ebony-like Cannon piece with white 'gun' character etching visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a visible shockwave and exploding wood splinters at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016110247001051903 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141110420227051 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016110247001051903, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016110247001051903, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2082148641347885, + 0.05460049584507942, + 0.07290098071098328, + 0.0770144909620285, + 0.23734818398952484, + 0.20567038655281067, + 0.04718373715877533, + 0.02731228433549404, + 0.02883504517376423, + 0.04091956093907356 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016110247001051903 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a low-angle extreme close-up with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a polished, dark wood Chinese chessboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a red-lacquered General piece with gold leaf on its 'will' character visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a dark ebony-like Cannon piece with white 'gun' character etching visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a visible shockwave and exploding wood splinters at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020588263869285583 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955881595611572 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020588263869285583, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020588263869285583, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13774533569812775, + 0.05083899945020676, + 0.047536760568618774, + 0.027937956154346466, + 0.566081702709198, + 0.04340125992894173, + 0.03009663335978985, + 0.017540423199534416, + 0.03062286227941513, + 0.04819813743233681 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020588263869285583 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a low-angle extreme close-up with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a polished, dark wood Chinese chessboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a red-lacquered General piece with gold leaf on its 'will' character visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a dark ebony-like Cannon piece with white 'gun' character etching visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a visible shockwave and exploding wood splinters at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018179696053266525 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018179893493652 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018179696053266525, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018179696053266525, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06835297495126724, + 0.042884163558483124, + 0.059772979468107224, + 0.02000751532614231, + 0.7142643332481384, + 0.03631506860256195, + 0.025198888033628464, + 0.007238579913973808, + 0.008794624358415604, + 0.01717083528637886 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018179696053266525 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a low-angle extreme close-up with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a polished, dark wood Chinese chessboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a red-lacquered General piece with gold leaf on its 'will' character visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a dark ebony-like Cannon piece with white 'gun' character etching visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a visible shockwave and exploding wood splinters at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11292766034603119 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379276752471924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11292766034603119, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11292766034603119, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.045997194945812225, + 0.014656378887593746, + 0.030541572719812393, + 0.03421589359641075, + 0.8450121879577637, + 0.006784617435187101, + 0.01400402095168829, + 0.003576281713321805, + 0.00204324908554554, + 0.003168574534356594 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11292766034603119 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic, low-angle extreme close-up shot, captured with the precision of macro photography and a shallow depth of field, frames a photorealistic miniature collision on a polished, dark wood Chinese chessboard. Two ornate pieces, a regal General carved from rich, red-lacquered wood with its 'will' character filled with gleaming gold leaf, and a dark, ebony-like Cannon with its 'gun' character etched in stark white, clash with immense, hyper-realistic force. At the exact moment of impact, a visible shockwave ripples across the board's glossy surface, and a violent shower of tiny, sharp wood splinters explodes from the Cannon piece. The entire scene is bathed in the stark, high-contrast light of a single overhead source, which carves out deep, dramatic shadows that stretch across the board. monumental, collision.", + "seed": 11089, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_4/index_6571_seed_11089_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1782416045665741, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1782416045665741, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1782416045665741, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a low-angle extreme close-up with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a polished, dark wood Chinese chessboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a red-lacquered General piece with gold leaf on its 'will' character visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a dark ebony-like Cannon piece with white 'gun' character etching visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a visible shockwave and exploding wood splinters at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008443963713943958 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.383443832397461 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008443963713943958, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008443963713943958, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.059884343296289444, + 0.08241936564445496, + 0.08097761124372482, + 0.05119328200817108, + 0.2982152998447418, + 0.08154711127281189, + 0.20289447903633118, + 0.05614781752228737, + 0.06335326284170151, + 0.02336740866303444 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008443963713943958 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a low-angle extreme close-up with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a polished, dark wood Chinese chessboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a red-lacquered General piece with gold leaf on its 'will' character visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a dark ebony-like Cannon piece with white 'gun' character etching visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a visible shockwave and exploding wood splinters at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008655649609863758 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758655548095703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008655649609863758, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008655649609863758, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2432480752468109, + 0.062246013432741165, + 0.05300040915608406, + 0.06546393781900406, + 0.1976105272769928, + 0.03635600954294205, + 0.17976601421833038, + 0.09003296494483948, + 0.05406366288661957, + 0.01821230724453926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008655649609863758 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a low-angle extreme close-up with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a polished, dark wood Chinese chessboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a red-lacquered General piece with gold leaf on its 'will' character visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a dark ebony-like Cannon piece with white 'gun' character etching visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a visible shockwave and exploding wood splinters at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02981533110141754 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529815435409546 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02981533110141754, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02981533110141754, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04254917427897453, + 0.04007668048143387, + 0.05231146141886711, + 0.0642533153295517, + 0.127069890499115, + 0.07904496788978577, + 0.3706364631652832, + 0.08271073549985886, + 0.07855403423309326, + 0.06279324740171432 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02981533110141754 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a low-angle extreme close-up with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a polished, dark wood Chinese chessboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a red-lacquered General piece with gold leaf on its 'will' character visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a dark ebony-like Cannon piece with white 'gun' character etching visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a visible shockwave and exploding wood splinters at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018187304958701134 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187522888184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018187304958701134, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018187304958701134, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05380775034427643, + 0.01988796889781952, + 0.05613793432712555, + 0.08823444694280624, + 0.32017484307289124, + 0.07081955671310425, + 0.23289741575717926, + 0.047962211072444916, + 0.06799288094043732, + 0.04208506643772125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018187304958701134 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a low-angle extreme close-up with shallow depth of field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on a polished, dark wood Chinese chessboard?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a red-lacquered General piece with gold leaf on its 'will' character visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a dark ebony-like Cannon piece with white 'gun' character etching visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene show a visible shockwave and exploding wood splinters at the moment of impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261057734489441 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761057734489441 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8261057734489441, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8261057734489441, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07814323902130127, + 0.02900107391178608, + 0.07180153578519821, + 0.1308360993862152, + 0.14134518802165985, + 0.20391151309013367, + 0.14568905532360077, + 0.06303895264863968, + 0.04518581181764603, + 0.09104758501052856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8261057734489441 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_5/index_tensor([1404, 1404])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_5/index_tensor([1404, 1404])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fad0cf06683484fefecb3c43e699606f7a5c3f8e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_5/index_tensor([1404, 1404])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "Ultra-slow motion, static extreme close-ups capture the mesmerizing pivot of a clockwork ballerina's single foot, creating an atmosphere of profound tranquility and focused wonder. The camera closely monitors the joint of her ankle, where meticulously crafted, polished brass gears and cogs spin with impossible, frictionless smoothness within an intricately hollowed housing. Warm, dusty light filters in from an unseen window, slanting across the scene in a brilliant axis, creating a golden glow and causing countless motes of dust to swirl languidly in the still air. The ballerina's figure, a delicate amalgam of ancient painted porcelain legs and a faded copper-mesh tutu, twirls gracefully on a dark wooden surface. A perfectly smooth black metal sphere hovers silently behind her, slightly out of focus, its matte surface absorbing the light and contrasting sharply with the ballerina's gleaming mechanism. The shallow depth of field blurs the background into a soft image of a quiet room, suggesting wooden shelves and forgotten treasures, highlighting the silent and intricate beauty of the mechanical performance.", + "seed": 11983, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_5/index_1404_seed_11983_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.02943268032395281, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02943268032395281, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02943268032395281, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a clockwork ballerina with porcelain legs and a copper-mesh tutu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on an extreme close-up of the ballerina's ankle joint showing brass gears and cogs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, dusty light creating a golden glow with visible swirling dust motes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly smooth black metal sphere visible hovering behind the ballerina, slightly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing a soft image of a quiet room with wooden shelves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08084581792354584 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.580845832824707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08084581792354584, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08084581792354584, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22609259188175201, + 0.06464235484600067, + 0.07970033586025238, + 0.17798423767089844, + 0.04131174460053444, + 0.03123530186712742, + 0.054801423102617264, + 0.03562932088971138, + 0.18197523057460785, + 0.10662747919559479 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08084581792354584 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a clockwork ballerina with porcelain legs and a copper-mesh tutu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on an extreme close-up of the ballerina's ankle joint showing brass gears and cogs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, dusty light creating a golden glow with visible swirling dust motes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly smooth black metal sphere visible hovering behind the ballerina, slightly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing a soft image of a quiet room with wooden shelves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018195733428001404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018195629119873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018195733428001404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018195733428001404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07820392400026321, + 0.10727804899215698, + 0.0660187229514122, + 0.0702177956700325, + 0.09208933264017105, + 0.06610700488090515, + 0.17881421744823456, + 0.08503121137619019, + 0.12313713878393173, + 0.13310259580612183 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018195733428001404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a clockwork ballerina with porcelain legs and a copper-mesh tutu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on an extreme close-up of the ballerina's ankle joint showing brass gears and cogs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, dusty light creating a golden glow with visible swirling dust motes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly smooth black metal sphere visible hovering behind the ballerina, slightly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing a soft image of a quiet room with wooden shelves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00043847484630532563 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.750438690185547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00043847484630532563, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00043847484630532563, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20955173671245575, + 0.0866008847951889, + 0.031097080558538437, + 0.0587921105325222, + 0.031271785497665405, + 0.015227345749735832, + 0.05468788743019104, + 0.028335832059383392, + 0.08750305324792862, + 0.3969323933124542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00043847484630532563 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a clockwork ballerina with porcelain legs and a copper-mesh tutu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on an extreme close-up of the ballerina's ankle joint showing brass gears and cogs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, dusty light creating a golden glow with visible swirling dust motes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly smooth black metal sphere visible hovering behind the ballerina, slightly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing a soft image of a quiet room with wooden shelves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043048784136772156 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168048858642578 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043048784136772156, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043048784136772156, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10204491019248962, + 0.06544716656208038, + 0.04871159419417381, + 0.03431953489780426, + 0.02624945528805256, + 0.03769152611494064, + 0.060618627816438675, + 0.0860273614525795, + 0.06762447953224182, + 0.47126537561416626 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043048784136772156 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a clockwork ballerina with porcelain legs and a copper-mesh tutu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on an extreme close-up of the ballerina's ankle joint showing brass gears and cogs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, dusty light creating a golden glow with visible swirling dust motes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly smooth black metal sphere visible hovering behind the ballerina, slightly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing a soft image of a quiet room with wooden shelves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004634591285139322 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379634380340576 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004634591285139322, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004634591285139322, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19333694875240326, + 0.18067863583564758, + 0.019947828724980354, + 0.027305694296956062, + 0.04640563204884529, + 0.02511618658900261, + 0.03728059306740761, + 0.024005156010389328, + 0.041279926896095276, + 0.4046434462070465 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004634591285139322 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Ultra-slow motion, static extreme close-ups capture the mesmerizing pivot of a clockwork ballerina's single foot, creating an atmosphere of profound tranquility and focused wonder. The camera closely monitors the joint of her ankle, where meticulously crafted, polished brass gears and cogs spin with impossible, frictionless smoothness within an intricately hollowed housing. Warm, dusty light filters in from an unseen window, slanting across the scene in a brilliant axis, creating a golden glow and causing countless motes of dust to swirl languidly in the still air. The ballerina's figure, a delicate amalgam of ancient painted porcelain legs and a faded copper-mesh tutu, twirls gracefully on a dark wooden surface. A perfectly smooth black metal sphere hovers silently behind her, slightly out of focus, its matte surface absorbing the light and contrasting sharply with the ballerina's gleaming mechanism. The shallow depth of field blurs the background into a soft image of a quiet room, suggesting wooden shelves and forgotten treasures, highlighting the silent and intricate beauty of the mechanical performance.", + "seed": 11984, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_5/index_1404_seed_11984_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.1067236821167171, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1067236821167171, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.574999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1067236821167171, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a clockwork ballerina with porcelain legs and a copper-mesh tutu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on an extreme close-up of the ballerina's ankle joint showing brass gears and cogs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, dusty light creating a golden glow with visible swirling dust motes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly smooth black metal sphere visible hovering behind the ballerina, slightly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing a soft image of a quiet room with wooden shelves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16156704723834991 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9115670919418335 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16156704723834991, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16156704723834991, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2661638557910919, + 0.06326402723789215, + 0.022011958062648773, + 0.0646614208817482, + 0.1724119633436203, + 0.031964533030986786, + 0.2327686846256256, + 0.040330927819013596, + 0.04852740466594696, + 0.057895269244909286 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16156704723834991 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a clockwork ballerina with porcelain legs and a copper-mesh tutu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on an extreme close-up of the ballerina's ankle joint showing brass gears and cogs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, dusty light creating a golden glow with visible swirling dust motes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly smooth black metal sphere visible hovering behind the ballerina, slightly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing a soft image of a quiet room with wooden shelves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014208933338522911 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264208793640137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014208933338522911, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014208933338522911, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24431848526000977, + 0.051503028720617294, + 0.09099064022302628, + 0.08058825880289078, + 0.13717930018901825, + 0.0690680593252182, + 0.09226329624652863, + 0.07341374456882477, + 0.08617998659610748, + 0.07449523359537125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014208933338522911 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a clockwork ballerina with porcelain legs and a copper-mesh tutu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on an extreme close-up of the ballerina's ankle joint showing brass gears and cogs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, dusty light creating a golden glow with visible swirling dust motes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly smooth black metal sphere visible hovering behind the ballerina, slightly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing a soft image of a quiet room with wooden shelves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00248968368396163 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.0024895668029785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00248968368396163, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00248968368396163, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.41835787892341614, + 0.10488639771938324, + 0.04254397004842758, + 0.031235160306096077, + 0.04794563353061676, + 0.03321787342429161, + 0.06453775614500046, + 0.17258185148239136, + 0.021725188940763474, + 0.06296827644109726 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00248968368396163 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a clockwork ballerina with porcelain legs and a copper-mesh tutu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on an extreme close-up of the ballerina's ankle joint showing brass gears and cogs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, dusty light creating a golden glow with visible swirling dust motes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly smooth black metal sphere visible hovering behind the ballerina, slightly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing a soft image of a quiet room with wooden shelves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486190438270569 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223618984222412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486190438270569, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8749999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486190438270569, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27916771173477173, + 0.05334961414337158, + 0.07076806575059891, + 0.053871527314186096, + 0.09828203171491623, + 0.09070352464914322, + 0.14641915261745453, + 0.09269526600837708, + 0.0814964771270752, + 0.033246684819459915 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486190438270569 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a clockwork ballerina with porcelain legs and a copper-mesh tutu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on an extreme close-up of the ballerina's ankle joint showing brass gears and cogs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, dusty light creating a golden glow with visible swirling dust motes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly smooth black metal sphere visible hovering behind the ballerina, slightly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing a soft image of a quiet room with wooden shelves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067337024956941605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067338943481445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067337024956941605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067337024956941605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3977985382080078, + 0.19814015924930573, + 0.025882869958877563, + 0.01719316653907299, + 0.05764422193169594, + 0.08733220398426056, + 0.050242744386196136, + 0.0776594877243042, + 0.028232110664248466, + 0.059874508529901505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067337024956941605 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Ultra-slow motion, static extreme close-ups capture the mesmerizing pivot of a clockwork ballerina's single foot, creating an atmosphere of profound tranquility and focused wonder. The camera closely monitors the joint of her ankle, where meticulously crafted, polished brass gears and cogs spin with impossible, frictionless smoothness within an intricately hollowed housing. Warm, dusty light filters in from an unseen window, slanting across the scene in a brilliant axis, creating a golden glow and causing countless motes of dust to swirl languidly in the still air. The ballerina's figure, a delicate amalgam of ancient painted porcelain legs and a faded copper-mesh tutu, twirls gracefully on a dark wooden surface. A perfectly smooth black metal sphere hovers silently behind her, slightly out of focus, its matte surface absorbing the light and contrasting sharply with the ballerina's gleaming mechanism. The shallow depth of field blurs the background into a soft image of a quiet room, suggesting wooden shelves and forgotten treasures, highlighting the silent and intricate beauty of the mechanical performance.", + "seed": 11985, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_5/index_1404_seed_11985_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.047519139747601004, + "vlm_logprob": -0.047519139747601004, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.099999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.047519139747601004, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a clockwork ballerina with porcelain legs and a copper-mesh tutu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on an extreme close-up of the ballerina's ankle joint showing brass gears and cogs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, dusty light creating a golden glow with visible swirling dust motes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly smooth black metal sphere visible hovering behind the ballerina, slightly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing a soft image of a quiet room with wooden shelves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14434655010700226 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0193464756011963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14434655010700226, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14434655010700226, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21011102199554443, + 0.0992385670542717, + 0.170988067984581, + 0.04857305437326431, + 0.07308342307806015, + 0.04214692488312721, + 0.0986371636390686, + 0.12325072288513184, + 0.05890422686934471, + 0.07506685703992844 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14434655010700226 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a clockwork ballerina with porcelain legs and a copper-mesh tutu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on an extreme close-up of the ballerina's ankle joint showing brass gears and cogs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, dusty light creating a golden glow with visible swirling dust motes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly smooth black metal sphere visible hovering behind the ballerina, slightly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing a soft image of a quiet room with wooden shelves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012545713223516941 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387545585632324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012545713223516941, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012545713223516941, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1846671998500824, + 0.08841636776924133, + 0.22526146471500397, + 0.07586559653282166, + 0.038831524550914764, + 0.10733714699745178, + 0.06084326282143593, + 0.07863448560237885, + 0.09122046083211899, + 0.04892248287796974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012545713223516941 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a clockwork ballerina with porcelain legs and a copper-mesh tutu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on an extreme close-up of the ballerina's ankle joint showing brass gears and cogs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, dusty light creating a golden glow with visible swirling dust motes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly smooth black metal sphere visible hovering behind the ballerina, slightly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing a soft image of a quiet room with wooden shelves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0009195152088068426 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.000919342041016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0009195152088068426, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0009195152088068426, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29086044430732727, + 0.09039945900440216, + 0.1303037852048874, + 0.05700701102614403, + 0.04207301884889603, + 0.04562627896666527, + 0.04071938619017601, + 0.12193691730499268, + 0.05748385190963745, + 0.12358985841274261 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0009195152088068426 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a clockwork ballerina with porcelain legs and a copper-mesh tutu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on an extreme close-up of the ballerina's ankle joint showing brass gears and cogs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, dusty light creating a golden glow with visible swirling dust motes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly smooth black metal sphere visible hovering behind the ballerina, slightly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing a soft image of a quiet room with wooden shelves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000947743654251 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695009469985962 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000947743654251, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000947743654251, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2778244912624359, + 0.09625294059515, + 0.16049641370773315, + 0.057413943111896515, + 0.04999185726046562, + 0.06775553524494171, + 0.06387516856193542, + 0.05265798419713974, + 0.05900949984788895, + 0.11472209542989731 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000947743654251 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a clockwork ballerina with porcelain legs and a copper-mesh tutu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on an extreme close-up of the ballerina's ankle joint showing brass gears and cogs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, dusty light creating a golden glow with visible swirling dust motes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly smooth black metal sphere visible hovering behind the ballerina, slightly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing a soft image of a quiet room with wooden shelves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00977444276213646 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634774208068848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00977444276213646, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00977444276213646, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2489461451768875, + 0.1345214545726776, + 0.14255927503108978, + 0.061176568269729614, + 0.05175713449716568, + 0.0450080931186676, + 0.05233747139573097, + 0.1520376205444336, + 0.03439796715974808, + 0.07725825905799866 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00977444276213646 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Ultra-slow motion, static extreme close-ups capture the mesmerizing pivot of a clockwork ballerina's single foot, creating an atmosphere of profound tranquility and focused wonder. The camera closely monitors the joint of her ankle, where meticulously crafted, polished brass gears and cogs spin with impossible, frictionless smoothness within an intricately hollowed housing. Warm, dusty light filters in from an unseen window, slanting across the scene in a brilliant axis, creating a golden glow and causing countless motes of dust to swirl languidly in the still air. The ballerina's figure, a delicate amalgam of ancient painted porcelain legs and a faded copper-mesh tutu, twirls gracefully on a dark wooden surface. A perfectly smooth black metal sphere hovers silently behind her, slightly out of focus, its matte surface absorbing the light and contrasting sharply with the ballerina's gleaming mechanism. The shallow depth of field blurs the background into a soft image of a quiet room, suggesting wooden shelves and forgotten treasures, highlighting the silent and intricate beauty of the mechanical performance.", + "seed": 11986, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_5/index_1404_seed_11986_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.19093999350443483, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19093999350443483, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19093999350443483, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a clockwork ballerina with porcelain legs and a copper-mesh tutu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on an extreme close-up of the ballerina's ankle joint showing brass gears and cogs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, dusty light creating a golden glow with visible swirling dust motes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly smooth black metal sphere visible hovering behind the ballerina, slightly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing a soft image of a quiet room with wooden shelves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.524040699005127 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.899040699005127 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.524040699005127, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.524040699005127, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1425577849149704, + 0.04440702870488167, + 0.09477739781141281, + 0.07832950353622437, + 0.040278125554323196, + 0.1739131659269333, + 0.07596638053655624, + 0.16681353747844696, + 0.0572490356862545, + 0.1257079839706421 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.524040699005127 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a clockwork ballerina with porcelain legs and a copper-mesh tutu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on an extreme close-up of the ballerina's ankle joint showing brass gears and cogs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, dusty light creating a golden glow with visible swirling dust motes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly smooth black metal sphere visible hovering behind the ballerina, slightly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing a soft image of a quiet room with wooden shelves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04307892918586731 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168078899383545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04307892918586731, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04307892918586731, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12359953671693802, + 0.16121000051498413, + 0.04383597895503044, + 0.08561630547046661, + 0.05508946254849434, + 0.12086296826601028, + 0.08590541034936905, + 0.09151538461446762, + 0.01864119991660118, + 0.21372371912002563 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04307892918586731 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a clockwork ballerina with porcelain legs and a copper-mesh tutu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on an extreme close-up of the ballerina's ankle joint showing brass gears and cogs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, dusty light creating a golden glow with visible swirling dust motes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly smooth black metal sphere visible hovering behind the ballerina, slightly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing a soft image of a quiet room with wooden shelves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005251422990113497 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255251407623291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005251422990113497, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005251422990113497, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2070004791021347, + 0.09578776359558105, + 0.17263466119766235, + 0.09915652871131897, + 0.034483373165130615, + 0.04673691466450691, + 0.03806618973612785, + 0.07655303180217743, + 0.039453767240047455, + 0.19012734293937683 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005251422990113497 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a clockwork ballerina with porcelain legs and a copper-mesh tutu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on an extreme close-up of the ballerina's ankle joint showing brass gears and cogs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, dusty light creating a golden glow with visible swirling dust motes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly smooth black metal sphere visible hovering behind the ballerina, slightly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing a soft image of a quiet room with wooden shelves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34863772988319397 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236377000808716 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34863772988319397, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34863772988319397, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10206937789916992, + 0.060996416956186295, + 0.0697169303894043, + 0.044664155691862106, + 0.1448943167924881, + 0.07032995671033859, + 0.050197090953588486, + 0.061073970049619675, + 0.04668692871928215, + 0.3493708372116089 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34863772988319397 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a clockwork ballerina with porcelain legs and a copper-mesh tutu?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on an extreme close-up of the ballerina's ankle joint showing brass gears and cogs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm, dusty light creating a golden glow with visible swirling dust motes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a perfectly smooth black metal sphere visible hovering behind the ballerina, slightly out of focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred with a shallow depth of field, revealing a soft image of a quiet room with wooden shelves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369118645787239 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408691167831421 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369118645787239, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369118645787239, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16704294085502625, + 0.14292965829372406, + 0.20325732231140137, + 0.09821652621030807, + 0.1018904447555542, + 0.05728350207209587, + 0.06099116429686546, + 0.04944860562682152, + 0.02590671181678772, + 0.09303309768438339 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369118645787239 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_6/index_tensor([6289, 6289])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_6/index_tensor([6289, 6289])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c97f10430237e4495d35da2ca56f45a7d0b99501 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_6/index_tensor([6289, 6289])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static macro close-up, rendered in a Ghibli-inspired art style, captures a tender moment of parental care. The camera remains perfectly still, focused on a large, fluffy bag moth, its body a beautiful, soft tapestry of intricately woven silk, dotted with tiny, vibrant petals in soft pinks and pale yellows. The moth nestles in a cozy teardrop-shaped cocoon, suspended from the delicate, unfurled fronds of a dew-covered fern. The cocoon itself is a masterpiece of natural structure, reflecting the parent's composition. The entire scene is illuminated by soft, dappled sunlight filtering through the lush, out-of-focus forest canopy, creating ever-changing patterns of warm gold on the subject and causing the spherical dewdrops on the fern to shimmer like tiny jewels. Slowly and carefully, the mother moth adds another vibrant, tiny green leaf to its intricate nest, her movements deliberate and purposeful. Its large, dark, shiny eyes, reflecting the soft forest light, are full of deep warmth and affection, embodying Miyazaki's classic aesthetic of respecting nature and gentle emotions, and creating a peaceful and warm atmosphere.", + "seed": 7194, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_6/index_6289_seed_7194_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.42088091671466826, + "vlm_logprob": -0.42088091671466826, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.2749999642372132, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.42088091671466826, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, fluffy bag moth with a body made of intricately woven silk dotted with tiny pink and yellow petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the moth nesting in a teardrop-shaped cocoon suspended from dew-covered fern fronds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mother moth slowly and carefully add a tiny green leaf to its nest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1288543939590454 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.128854274749756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1288543939590454, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1288543939590454, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.45629507303237915, + 0.12434878945350647, + 0.05975395813584328, + 0.04727739840745926, + 0.07456246763467789, + 0.06362710893154144, + 0.038555022329092026, + 0.032467689365148544, + 0.02337518148124218, + 0.07973732054233551 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1288543939590454 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, fluffy bag moth with a body made of intricately woven silk dotted with tiny pink and yellow petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the moth nesting in a teardrop-shaped cocoon suspended from dew-covered fern fronds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mother moth slowly and carefully add a tiny green leaf to its nest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12708701193332672 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127087116241455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12708701193332672, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12708701193332672, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22528131306171417, + 0.1049308255314827, + 0.11764300614595413, + 0.13162289559841156, + 0.10568688809871674, + 0.03404567390680313, + 0.05836862325668335, + 0.05849485099315643, + 0.025553911924362183, + 0.13837198913097382 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12708701193332672 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, fluffy bag moth with a body made of intricately woven silk dotted with tiny pink and yellow petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the moth nesting in a teardrop-shaped cocoon suspended from dew-covered fern fronds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mother moth slowly and carefully add a tiny green leaf to its nest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048655688762664795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486557483673096 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048655688762664795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048655688762664795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21439145505428314, + 0.16624116897583008, + 0.12056052684783936, + 0.042775191366672516, + 0.09755070507526398, + 0.15820717811584473, + 0.06265157461166382, + 0.02397182211279869, + 0.0340009480714798, + 0.07964946329593658 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048655688762664795 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, fluffy bag moth with a body made of intricately woven silk dotted with tiny pink and yellow petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the moth nesting in a teardrop-shaped cocoon suspended from dew-covered fern fronds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mother moth slowly and carefully add a tiny green leaf to its nest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761634707450867 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261634707450867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761634707450867, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761634707450867, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3219630718231201, + 0.06034683808684349, + 0.06518470495939255, + 0.04553632810711861, + 0.21158559620380402, + 0.06716614216566086, + 0.0454949215054512, + 0.06560482829809189, + 0.060378096997737885, + 0.05673948675394058 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761634707450867 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, fluffy bag moth with a body made of intricately woven silk dotted with tiny pink and yellow petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the moth nesting in a teardrop-shaped cocoon suspended from dew-covered fern fronds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mother moth slowly and carefully add a tiny green leaf to its nest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236440181732178 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.348643958568573 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2236440181732178, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.8750000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2236440181732178, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2238783985376358, + 0.06373795121908188, + 0.07339833676815033, + 0.14051656424999237, + 0.06258582323789597, + 0.05873527750372887, + 0.07721954584121704, + 0.09638518840074539, + 0.14895296096801758, + 0.054590024054050446 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2236440181732178 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static macro close-up, rendered in a Ghibli-inspired art style, captures a tender moment of parental care. The camera remains perfectly still, focused on a large, fluffy bag moth, its body a beautiful, soft tapestry of intricately woven silk, dotted with tiny, vibrant petals in soft pinks and pale yellows. The moth nestles in a cozy teardrop-shaped cocoon, suspended from the delicate, unfurled fronds of a dew-covered fern. The cocoon itself is a masterpiece of natural structure, reflecting the parent's composition. The entire scene is illuminated by soft, dappled sunlight filtering through the lush, out-of-focus forest canopy, creating ever-changing patterns of warm gold on the subject and causing the spherical dewdrops on the fern to shimmer like tiny jewels. Slowly and carefully, the mother moth adds another vibrant, tiny green leaf to its intricate nest, her movements deliberate and purposeful. Its large, dark, shiny eyes, reflecting the soft forest light, are full of deep warmth and affection, embodying Miyazaki's classic aesthetic of respecting nature and gentle emotions, and creating a peaceful and warm atmosphere.", + "seed": 7195, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_6/index_6289_seed_7195_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.4433042585849762, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4433042585849762, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4433042585849762, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, fluffy bag moth with a body made of intricately woven silk dotted with tiny pink and yellow petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the moth nesting in a teardrop-shaped cocoon suspended from dew-covered fern fronds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mother moth slowly and carefully add a tiny green leaf to its nest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5246766805648804 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8996766805648804 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5246766805648804, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5246766805648804, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13193613290786743, + 0.09856801480054855, + 0.04488195478916168, + 0.07865279912948608, + 0.3619474470615387, + 0.05246177315711975, + 0.14766138792037964, + 0.031177528202533722, + 0.028939614072442055, + 0.02377333492040634 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5246766805648804 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, fluffy bag moth with a body made of intricately woven silk dotted with tiny pink and yellow petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the moth nesting in a teardrop-shaped cocoon suspended from dew-covered fern fronds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mother moth slowly and carefully add a tiny green leaf to its nest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16038556396961212 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103856086730957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16038556396961212, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16038556396961212, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08727523684501648, + 0.08187638223171234, + 0.10301193594932556, + 0.1433373987674713, + 0.0654076635837555, + 0.03408725932240486, + 0.20970776677131653, + 0.02890598215162754, + 0.20826603472232819, + 0.03812432661652565 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16038556396961212 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, fluffy bag moth with a body made of intricately woven silk dotted with tiny pink and yellow petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the moth nesting in a teardrop-shaped cocoon suspended from dew-covered fern fronds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mother moth slowly and carefully add a tiny green leaf to its nest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810521960258484 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881052494049072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810521960258484, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810521960258484, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10067997127771378, + 0.05928418040275574, + 0.15984894335269928, + 0.022930294275283813, + 0.3236317038536072, + 0.04818887636065483, + 0.06790981441736221, + 0.03852071985602379, + 0.1653306931257248, + 0.013674811460077763 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810521960258484 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, fluffy bag moth with a body made of intricately woven silk dotted with tiny pink and yellow petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the moth nesting in a teardrop-shaped cocoon suspended from dew-covered fern fronds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mother moth slowly and carefully add a tiny green leaf to its nest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17991016805171967 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049101829528809 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17991016805171967, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17991016805171967, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0333826020359993, + 0.009626542218029499, + 0.10662443190813065, + 0.01232833694666624, + 0.30095499753952026, + 0.013585579581558704, + 0.1246459037065506, + 0.025740984827280045, + 0.3685210943222046, + 0.004589471034705639 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17991016805171967 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, fluffy bag moth with a body made of intricately woven silk dotted with tiny pink and yellow petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the moth nesting in a teardrop-shaped cocoon suspended from dew-covered fern fronds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mother moth slowly and carefully add a tiny green leaf to its nest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.313443660736084 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31344369053840637 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.313443660736084, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.313443660736084, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.034401003271341324, + 0.05439196154475212, + 0.038603994995355606, + 0.04083013907074928, + 0.4927559494972229, + 0.017186952754855156, + 0.20592384040355682, + 0.07957671582698822, + 0.022118790075182915, + 0.014210635796189308 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.313443660736084 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static macro close-up, rendered in a Ghibli-inspired art style, captures a tender moment of parental care. The camera remains perfectly still, focused on a large, fluffy bag moth, its body a beautiful, soft tapestry of intricately woven silk, dotted with tiny, vibrant petals in soft pinks and pale yellows. The moth nestles in a cozy teardrop-shaped cocoon, suspended from the delicate, unfurled fronds of a dew-covered fern. The cocoon itself is a masterpiece of natural structure, reflecting the parent's composition. The entire scene is illuminated by soft, dappled sunlight filtering through the lush, out-of-focus forest canopy, creating ever-changing patterns of warm gold on the subject and causing the spherical dewdrops on the fern to shimmer like tiny jewels. Slowly and carefully, the mother moth adds another vibrant, tiny green leaf to its intricate nest, her movements deliberate and purposeful. Its large, dark, shiny eyes, reflecting the soft forest light, are full of deep warmth and affection, embodying Miyazaki's classic aesthetic of respecting nature and gentle emotions, and creating a peaceful and warm atmosphere.", + "seed": 7196, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_6/index_6289_seed_7196_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.40821466967463493, + "vlm_logprob": -0.40821466967463493, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.40821466967463493, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, fluffy bag moth with a body made of intricately woven silk dotted with tiny pink and yellow petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the moth nesting in a teardrop-shaped cocoon suspended from dew-covered fern fronds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mother moth slowly and carefully add a tiny green leaf to its nest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12908345460891724 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1290833950042725 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12908345460891724, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12908345460891724, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.376482754945755, + 0.18228743970394135, + 0.04416761174798012, + 0.051824651658535004, + 0.11362730711698532, + 0.034443192183971405, + 0.041483309119939804, + 0.020777812227606773, + 0.025422019883990288, + 0.10948389768600464 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12908345460891724 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, fluffy bag moth with a body made of intricately woven silk dotted with tiny pink and yellow petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the moth nesting in a teardrop-shaped cocoon suspended from dew-covered fern fronds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mother moth slowly and carefully add a tiny green leaf to its nest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07006794214248657 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695067882537842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07006794214248657, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07006794214248657, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29743313789367676, + 0.2854782044887543, + 0.10090243071317673, + 0.13514834642410278, + 0.0324174165725708, + 0.03513944521546364, + 0.032209672033786774, + 0.022541940212249756, + 0.03387679159641266, + 0.02485261671245098 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07006794214248657 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, fluffy bag moth with a body made of intricately woven silk dotted with tiny pink and yellow petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the moth nesting in a teardrop-shaped cocoon suspended from dew-covered fern fronds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mother moth slowly and carefully add a tiny green leaf to its nest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026348169893026352 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651348114013672 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026348169893026352, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026348169893026352, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18946687877178192, + 0.2448354959487915, + 0.2226438969373703, + 0.09155329316854477, + 0.049099601805210114, + 0.056078966706991196, + 0.03583637997508049, + 0.02286073938012123, + 0.03234031796455383, + 0.05528445541858673 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026348169893026352 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, fluffy bag moth with a body made of intricately woven silk dotted with tiny pink and yellow petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the moth nesting in a teardrop-shaped cocoon suspended from dew-covered fern fronds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mother moth slowly and carefully add a tiny green leaf to its nest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134807050228119 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134807348251343 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134807050228119, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134807050228119, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14333784580230713, + 0.1678507775068283, + 0.057677675038576126, + 0.060065679252147675, + 0.10273082554340363, + 0.060722872614860535, + 0.04765446484088898, + 0.06769681721925735, + 0.113435298204422, + 0.17882771790027618 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134807050228119 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, fluffy bag moth with a body made of intricately woven silk dotted with tiny pink and yellow petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the moth nesting in a teardrop-shaped cocoon suspended from dew-covered fern fronds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mother moth slowly and carefully add a tiny green leaf to its nest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020930767059326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520931363105774 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5020930767059326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5020930767059326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07124334573745728, + 0.06487032771110535, + 0.11504770070314407, + 0.1616298258304596, + 0.3278731107711792, + 0.06358592957258224, + 0.01498731691390276, + 0.04582485556602478, + 0.04479994252324104, + 0.09013768285512924 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5020930767059326 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static macro close-up, rendered in a Ghibli-inspired art style, captures a tender moment of parental care. The camera remains perfectly still, focused on a large, fluffy bag moth, its body a beautiful, soft tapestry of intricately woven silk, dotted with tiny, vibrant petals in soft pinks and pale yellows. The moth nestles in a cozy teardrop-shaped cocoon, suspended from the delicate, unfurled fronds of a dew-covered fern. The cocoon itself is a masterpiece of natural structure, reflecting the parent's composition. The entire scene is illuminated by soft, dappled sunlight filtering through the lush, out-of-focus forest canopy, creating ever-changing patterns of warm gold on the subject and causing the spherical dewdrops on the fern to shimmer like tiny jewels. Slowly and carefully, the mother moth adds another vibrant, tiny green leaf to its intricate nest, her movements deliberate and purposeful. Its large, dark, shiny eyes, reflecting the soft forest light, are full of deep warmth and affection, embodying Miyazaki's classic aesthetic of respecting nature and gentle emotions, and creating a peaceful and warm atmosphere.", + "seed": 7197, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_6/index_6289_seed_7197_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.3680908136069775, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3680908136069775, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3680908136069775, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, fluffy bag moth with a body made of intricately woven silk dotted with tiny pink and yellow petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the moth nesting in a teardrop-shaped cocoon suspended from dew-covered fern fronds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mother moth slowly and carefully add a tiny green leaf to its nest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11632295697927475 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2413229942321777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11632295697927475, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11632295697927475, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4953838884830475, + 0.07313989847898483, + 0.03974355384707451, + 0.029512517154216766, + 0.039293866604566574, + 0.05237830430269241, + 0.04417111724615097, + 0.11855058372020721, + 0.03683297708630562, + 0.07099329680204391 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11632295697927475 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, fluffy bag moth with a body made of intricately woven silk dotted with tiny pink and yellow petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the moth nesting in a teardrop-shaped cocoon suspended from dew-covered fern fronds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mother moth slowly and carefully add a tiny green leaf to its nest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05498295649886131 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929982900619507 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05498295649886131, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05498295649886131, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34508728981018066, + 0.05748189240694046, + 0.1766018122434616, + 0.06142712011933327, + 0.031837787479162216, + 0.05523315444588661, + 0.08005394786596298, + 0.10490181297063828, + 0.05385575070977211, + 0.03351940959692001 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05498295649886131 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, fluffy bag moth with a body made of intricately woven silk dotted with tiny pink and yellow petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the moth nesting in a teardrop-shaped cocoon suspended from dew-covered fern fronds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mother moth slowly and carefully add a tiny green leaf to its nest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062040217220783234 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812040328979492 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062040217220783234, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062040217220783234, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2748323082923889, + 0.06977968662977219, + 0.2768813669681549, + 0.16995283961296082, + 0.023982342332601547, + 0.04209890589118004, + 0.04782789200544357, + 0.034323688596487045, + 0.011233138851821423, + 0.04908783361315727 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062040217220783234 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, fluffy bag moth with a body made of intricately woven silk dotted with tiny pink and yellow petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the moth nesting in a teardrop-shaped cocoon suspended from dew-covered fern fronds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mother moth slowly and carefully add a tiny green leaf to its nest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328136920928955 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578136920928955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6328136920928955, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6328136920928955, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14914295077323914, + 0.049977369606494904, + 0.12455777078866959, + 0.10083121061325073, + 0.04240069538354874, + 0.08685728162527084, + 0.1416734904050827, + 0.08552396297454834, + 0.08167612552642822, + 0.137359157204628 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6328136920928955 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video rendered in a Ghibli-inspired art style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, fluffy bag moth with a body made of intricately woven silk dotted with tiny pink and yellow petals?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the moth nesting in a teardrop-shaped cocoon suspended from dew-covered fern fronds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the mother moth slowly and carefully add a tiny green leaf to its nest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera perfectly still throughout the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742942452430725 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4742942452430725 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9742942452430725, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9742942452430725, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20058485865592957, + 0.051929179579019547, + 0.07423732429742813, + 0.16059504449367523, + 0.047919776290655136, + 0.025478553026914597, + 0.09531591832637787, + 0.12113415449857712, + 0.06867939233779907, + 0.15412575006484985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9742942452430725 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_7/index_tensor([4213, 4213])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_7/index_tensor([4213, 4213])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4262cf4242c84b0764f55db1f5a12875dc64eaf1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_7/index_tensor([4213, 4213])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An epic wide-angle, long shot, captured with a slight, unsteady handheld feel, seems to subtly tremble. From a slightly bird's-eye view, the camera captures an apocalyptic scene reminiscent of ancient Chinese mythology: the vast expanse of earth is a deeply cracked ochre, with dried-up riverbeds winding across it like vast scars. Once-fertile soil is being devoured by the encroaching sands. Scattered across the frame are twisted, charred, withered trees, their branches desperately reaching toward the sky. The few remaining blades of withered grass shiver in the parched wind. The sky is dominated by massive, inky cumulonimbus clouds. These clouds, far from static, roll and swirl with a slow, purposeful motion, as if stirred by invisible hands. Their edges flicker with eerie flashes of purple and crimson lightning. The ever-shifting forms of the clouds vaguely outline the silhouettes of mythical beasts or gods, creating an ominous, dynamic celestial scene. Sunlight barely penetrates the thick cloud cover, shrouding the world in a dim and oppressive light. Only the flashes of lightning between the clouds cast fleeting, eerie shadows across this dead landscape. The entire scene is filled with the grandeur and deathly silence of the apocalypse. An ancient, heavy sense of despair hangs over this crumbling world.", + "seed": 14807, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_7/index_4213_seed_14807_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.14627195037901403, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14627195037901403, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14627195037901403, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide-angle long shot from a slightly bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a slight, unsteady handheld feel with subtle trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground deeply cracked ochre with dried-up riverbeds winding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there twisted, charred, withered trees with branches reaching toward the sky and withered grass shivering in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky dominated by massive, inky cumulonimbus clouds rolling and swirling with purple and crimson lightning flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020362267270684242 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.020362377166748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020362267270684242, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020362267270684242, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08417971432209015, + 0.11058790236711502, + 0.10109680891036987, + 0.07296321541070938, + 0.03945289924740791, + 0.16329848766326904, + 0.09585577994585037, + 0.10869776457548141, + 0.15041397511959076, + 0.07345347106456757 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020362267270684242 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide-angle long shot from a slightly bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a slight, unsteady handheld feel with subtle trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground deeply cracked ochre with dried-up riverbeds winding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there twisted, charred, withered trees with branches reaching toward the sky and withered grass shivering in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky dominated by massive, inky cumulonimbus clouds rolling and swirling with purple and crimson lightning flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34862756729125977 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236275672912598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34862756729125977, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34862756729125977, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13390839099884033, + 0.08813009411096573, + 0.08416053652763367, + 0.12494705617427826, + 0.036339808255434036, + 0.11988900601863861, + 0.058227840811014175, + 0.0786605253815651, + 0.15104970335960388, + 0.12468703091144562 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34862756729125977 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide-angle long shot from a slightly bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a slight, unsteady handheld feel with subtle trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground deeply cracked ochre with dried-up riverbeds winding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there twisted, charred, withered trees with branches reaching toward the sky and withered grass shivering in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky dominated by massive, inky cumulonimbus clouds rolling and swirling with purple and crimson lightning flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11294597387313843 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237946033477783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11294597387313843, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11294597387313843, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06117914617061615, + 0.04113868996500969, + 0.13992542028427124, + 0.5161877274513245, + 0.01669641211628914, + 0.03985079377889633, + 0.03616282343864441, + 0.08611371368169785, + 0.026870569214224815, + 0.03587472438812256 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11294597387313843 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide-angle long shot from a slightly bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a slight, unsteady handheld feel with subtle trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground deeply cracked ochre with dried-up riverbeds winding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there twisted, charred, withered trees with branches reaching toward the sky and withered grass shivering in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky dominated by massive, inky cumulonimbus clouds rolling and swirling with purple and crimson lightning flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16041065752506256 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104106426239014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16041065752506256, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16041065752506256, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07807658612728119, + 0.2264663130044937, + 0.13689853250980377, + 0.19731758534908295, + 0.06399020552635193, + 0.03848700970411301, + 0.0943058580160141, + 0.05154673010110855, + 0.040452755987644196, + 0.07245838642120361 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16041065752506256 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide-angle long shot from a slightly bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a slight, unsteady handheld feel with subtle trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground deeply cracked ochre with dried-up riverbeds winding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there twisted, charred, withered trees with branches reaching toward the sky and withered grass shivering in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky dominated by massive, inky cumulonimbus clouds rolling and swirling with purple and crimson lightning flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08901328593492508 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640133380889893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08901328593492508, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08901328593492508, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07547944039106369, + 0.0923355370759964, + 0.1350637823343277, + 0.09221133589744568, + 0.11156416684389114, + 0.04476693272590637, + 0.16289852559566498, + 0.14529304206371307, + 0.05202595889568329, + 0.0883612111210823 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08901328593492508 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic wide-angle, long shot, captured with a slight, unsteady handheld feel, seems to subtly tremble. From a slightly bird's-eye view, the camera captures an apocalyptic scene reminiscent of ancient Chinese mythology: the vast expanse of earth is a deeply cracked ochre, with dried-up riverbeds winding across it like vast scars. Once-fertile soil is being devoured by the encroaching sands. Scattered across the frame are twisted, charred, withered trees, their branches desperately reaching toward the sky. The few remaining blades of withered grass shiver in the parched wind. The sky is dominated by massive, inky cumulonimbus clouds. These clouds, far from static, roll and swirl with a slow, purposeful motion, as if stirred by invisible hands. Their edges flicker with eerie flashes of purple and crimson lightning. The ever-shifting forms of the clouds vaguely outline the silhouettes of mythical beasts or gods, creating an ominous, dynamic celestial scene. Sunlight barely penetrates the thick cloud cover, shrouding the world in a dim and oppressive light. Only the flashes of lightning between the clouds cast fleeting, eerie shadows across this dead landscape. The entire scene is filled with the grandeur and deathly silence of the apocalypse. An ancient, heavy sense of despair hangs over this crumbling world.", + "seed": 14808, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_7/index_4213_seed_14808_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.21036792509257793, + "vlm_logprob": -0.21036792509257793, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.21036792509257793, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide-angle long shot from a slightly bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a slight, unsteady handheld feel with subtle trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground deeply cracked ochre with dried-up riverbeds winding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there twisted, charred, withered trees with branches reaching toward the sky and withered grass shivering in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky dominated by massive, inky cumulonimbus clouds rolling and swirling with purple and crimson lightning flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019883012399077415 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.019883155822754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019883012399077415, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019883012399077415, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15213920176029205, + 0.04656835272908211, + 0.05721694603562355, + 0.059237051755189896, + 0.04719841480255127, + 0.043071962893009186, + 0.0540473535656929, + 0.37814387679100037, + 0.12008192390203476, + 0.0422949343919754 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019883012399077415 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide-angle long shot from a slightly bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a slight, unsteady handheld feel with subtle trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground deeply cracked ochre with dried-up riverbeds winding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there twisted, charred, withered trees with branches reaching toward the sky and withered grass shivering in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky dominated by massive, inky cumulonimbus clouds rolling and swirling with purple and crimson lightning flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233190655708313 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983190655708313 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233190655708313, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233190655708313, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11818138509988785, + 0.09057113528251648, + 0.1111602783203125, + 0.1623050421476364, + 0.0938057079911232, + 0.089454285800457, + 0.03462885692715645, + 0.22806516289710999, + 0.04127180576324463, + 0.03055633045732975 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233190655708313 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide-angle long shot from a slightly bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a slight, unsteady handheld feel with subtle trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground deeply cracked ochre with dried-up riverbeds winding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there twisted, charred, withered trees with branches reaching toward the sky and withered grass shivering in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky dominated by massive, inky cumulonimbus clouds rolling and swirling with purple and crimson lightning flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496072769165039 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299607276916504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496072769165039, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496072769165039, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21633388102054596, + 0.07929064333438873, + 0.07397089898586273, + 0.0339510515332222, + 0.0466732531785965, + 0.09342765063047409, + 0.08296965062618256, + 0.23933245241641998, + 0.09831159561872482, + 0.0357389897108078 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496072769165039 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide-angle long shot from a slightly bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a slight, unsteady handheld feel with subtle trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground deeply cracked ochre with dried-up riverbeds winding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there twisted, charred, withered trees with branches reaching toward the sky and withered grass shivering in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky dominated by massive, inky cumulonimbus clouds rolling and swirling with purple and crimson lightning flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20161008834838867 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016100883483887 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20161008834838867, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20161008834838867, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4257957637310028, + 0.025210481137037277, + 0.033409565687179565, + 0.04668300971388817, + 0.019301559776067734, + 0.05514654517173767, + 0.051903534680604935, + 0.2812303304672241, + 0.04093676432967186, + 0.020382408052682877 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20161008834838867 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide-angle long shot from a slightly bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a slight, unsteady handheld feel with subtle trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground deeply cracked ochre with dried-up riverbeds winding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there twisted, charred, withered trees with branches reaching toward the sky and withered grass shivering in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky dominated by massive, inky cumulonimbus clouds rolling and swirling with purple and crimson lightning flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520667314529419 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502066731452942 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520667314529419, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520667314529419, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18133819103240967, + 0.07010946422815323, + 0.0161930862814188, + 0.02796531468629837, + 0.06789020448923111, + 0.07691662758588791, + 0.04558907076716423, + 0.23918043076992035, + 0.19843219220638275, + 0.07638533413410187 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520667314529419 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic wide-angle, long shot, captured with a slight, unsteady handheld feel, seems to subtly tremble. From a slightly bird's-eye view, the camera captures an apocalyptic scene reminiscent of ancient Chinese mythology: the vast expanse of earth is a deeply cracked ochre, with dried-up riverbeds winding across it like vast scars. Once-fertile soil is being devoured by the encroaching sands. Scattered across the frame are twisted, charred, withered trees, their branches desperately reaching toward the sky. The few remaining blades of withered grass shiver in the parched wind. The sky is dominated by massive, inky cumulonimbus clouds. These clouds, far from static, roll and swirl with a slow, purposeful motion, as if stirred by invisible hands. Their edges flicker with eerie flashes of purple and crimson lightning. The ever-shifting forms of the clouds vaguely outline the silhouettes of mythical beasts or gods, creating an ominous, dynamic celestial scene. Sunlight barely penetrates the thick cloud cover, shrouding the world in a dim and oppressive light. Only the flashes of lightning between the clouds cast fleeting, eerie shadows across this dead landscape. The entire scene is filled with the grandeur and deathly silence of the apocalypse. An ancient, heavy sense of despair hangs over this crumbling world.", + "seed": 14809, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_7/index_4213_seed_14809_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.14496898800134658, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14496898800134658, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14496898800134658, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide-angle long shot from a slightly bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a slight, unsteady handheld feel with subtle trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground deeply cracked ochre with dried-up riverbeds winding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there twisted, charred, withered trees with branches reaching toward the sky and withered grass shivering in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky dominated by massive, inky cumulonimbus clouds rolling and swirling with purple and crimson lightning flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.051737844944000244 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0517377853393555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.051737844944000244, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.051737844944000244, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16039079427719116, + 0.48149654269218445, + 0.03650074079632759, + 0.025210190564393997, + 0.035203538835048676, + 0.0164114311337471, + 0.07725078612565994, + 0.08942828327417374, + 0.014670194126665592, + 0.06343749165534973 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.051737844944000244 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide-angle long shot from a slightly bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a slight, unsteady handheld feel with subtle trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground deeply cracked ochre with dried-up riverbeds winding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there twisted, charred, withered trees with branches reaching toward the sky and withered grass shivering in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky dominated by massive, inky cumulonimbus clouds rolling and swirling with purple and crimson lightning flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520820200443268 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020819902420044 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520820200443268, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520820200443268, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1445116251707077, + 0.282520055770874, + 0.06864840537309647, + 0.045713841915130615, + 0.0366269089281559, + 0.05781048536300659, + 0.1310480684041977, + 0.10009786486625671, + 0.037118230015039444, + 0.09590449929237366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520820200443268 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide-angle long shot from a slightly bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a slight, unsteady handheld feel with subtle trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground deeply cracked ochre with dried-up riverbeds winding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there twisted, charred, withered trees with branches reaching toward the sky and withered grass shivering in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky dominated by massive, inky cumulonimbus clouds rolling and swirling with purple and crimson lightning flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10030115395784378 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503012657165527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10030115395784378, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10030115395784378, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03171812742948532, + 0.7319737076759338, + 0.00732972240075469, + 0.009699497371912003, + 0.015481939539313316, + 0.0192165095359087, + 0.007784443441778421, + 0.1220841258764267, + 0.026931002736091614, + 0.027780981734395027 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10030115395784378 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide-angle long shot from a slightly bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a slight, unsteady handheld feel with subtle trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground deeply cracked ochre with dried-up riverbeds winding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there twisted, charred, withered trees with branches reaching toward the sky and withered grass shivering in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky dominated by massive, inky cumulonimbus clouds rolling and swirling with purple and crimson lightning flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603955179452896 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103955030441284 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603955179452896, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603955179452896, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04362110793590546, + 0.4116002023220062, + 0.019639678299427032, + 0.043774984776973724, + 0.02426130138337612, + 0.09056799858808517, + 0.03171977773308754, + 0.2394225001335144, + 0.05511573702096939, + 0.04027668759226799 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603955179452896 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide-angle long shot from a slightly bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a slight, unsteady handheld feel with subtle trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground deeply cracked ochre with dried-up riverbeds winding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there twisted, charred, withered trees with branches reaching toward the sky and withered grass shivering in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky dominated by massive, inky cumulonimbus clouds rolling and swirling with purple and crimson lightning flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16032840311527252 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103283882141113 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16032840311527252, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16032840311527252, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06727711111307144, + 0.10479222983121872, + 0.03583599254488945, + 0.01962067373096943, + 0.05923528969287872, + 0.07318044453859329, + 0.05334039777517319, + 0.4497447907924652, + 0.06196877360343933, + 0.0750042200088501 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16032840311527252 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic wide-angle, long shot, captured with a slight, unsteady handheld feel, seems to subtly tremble. From a slightly bird's-eye view, the camera captures an apocalyptic scene reminiscent of ancient Chinese mythology: the vast expanse of earth is a deeply cracked ochre, with dried-up riverbeds winding across it like vast scars. Once-fertile soil is being devoured by the encroaching sands. Scattered across the frame are twisted, charred, withered trees, their branches desperately reaching toward the sky. The few remaining blades of withered grass shiver in the parched wind. The sky is dominated by massive, inky cumulonimbus clouds. These clouds, far from static, roll and swirl with a slow, purposeful motion, as if stirred by invisible hands. Their edges flicker with eerie flashes of purple and crimson lightning. The ever-shifting forms of the clouds vaguely outline the silhouettes of mythical beasts or gods, creating an ominous, dynamic celestial scene. Sunlight barely penetrates the thick cloud cover, shrouding the world in a dim and oppressive light. Only the flashes of lightning between the clouds cast fleeting, eerie shadows across this dead landscape. The entire scene is filled with the grandeur and deathly silence of the apocalypse. An ancient, heavy sense of despair hangs over this crumbling world.", + "seed": 14810, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_7/index_4213_seed_14810_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.05611635856330395, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05611635856330395, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05611635856330395, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide-angle long shot from a slightly bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a slight, unsteady handheld feel with subtle trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground deeply cracked ochre with dried-up riverbeds winding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there twisted, charred, withered trees with branches reaching toward the sky and withered grass shivering in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky dominated by massive, inky cumulonimbus clouds rolling and swirling with purple and crimson lightning flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015689387917518616 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.515689373016357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015689387917518616, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015689387917518616, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10857845097780228, + 0.04774581268429756, + 0.07033524662256241, + 0.1484866589307785, + 0.12604279816150665, + 0.19260497391223907, + 0.15733207762241364, + 0.051472049206495285, + 0.059087708592414856, + 0.03831417113542557 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015689387917518616 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide-angle long shot from a slightly bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a slight, unsteady handheld feel with subtle trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground deeply cracked ochre with dried-up riverbeds winding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there twisted, charred, withered trees with branches reaching toward the sky and withered grass shivering in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky dominated by massive, inky cumulonimbus clouds rolling and swirling with purple and crimson lightning flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1798819899559021 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048820495605469 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1798819899559021, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1798819899559021, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1514260470867157, + 0.0685705617070198, + 0.10538917034864426, + 0.08213764429092407, + 0.13109497725963593, + 0.17413383722305298, + 0.08503207564353943, + 0.05986122414469719, + 0.11463163793087006, + 0.027722805738449097 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1798819899559021 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide-angle long shot from a slightly bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a slight, unsteady handheld feel with subtle trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground deeply cracked ochre with dried-up riverbeds winding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there twisted, charred, withered trees with branches reaching toward the sky and withered grass shivering in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky dominated by massive, inky cumulonimbus clouds rolling and swirling with purple and crimson lightning flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020578453317284584 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895578384399414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020578453317284584, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020578453317284584, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15397894382476807, + 0.1029355376958847, + 0.08414100110530853, + 0.052130043506622314, + 0.19282372295856476, + 0.26857951283454895, + 0.045442719012498856, + 0.05289746820926666, + 0.025254972279071808, + 0.02181607484817505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020578453317284584 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide-angle long shot from a slightly bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a slight, unsteady handheld feel with subtle trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground deeply cracked ochre with dried-up riverbeds winding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there twisted, charred, withered trees with branches reaching toward the sky and withered grass shivering in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky dominated by massive, inky cumulonimbus clouds rolling and swirling with purple and crimson lightning flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026351071894168854 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651350975036621 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026351071894168854, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026351071894168854, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0993407741189003, + 0.18374887108802795, + 0.05514378473162651, + 0.036873169243335724, + 0.13090087473392487, + 0.2933121919631958, + 0.04493573680520058, + 0.08347756415605545, + 0.055283624678850174, + 0.016983402892947197 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026351071894168854 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a wide-angle long shot from a slightly bird's-eye view?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera exhibit a slight, unsteady handheld feel with subtle trembling?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the ground deeply cracked ochre with dried-up riverbeds winding across it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are there twisted, charred, withered trees with branches reaching toward the sky and withered grass shivering in the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the sky dominated by massive, inky cumulonimbus clouds rolling and swirling with purple and crimson lightning flashes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038080889731645584 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288080930709839 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038080889731645584, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038080889731645584, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09740796685218811, + 0.04929116368293762, + 0.04218028858304024, + 0.06542045623064041, + 0.19198614358901978, + 0.19564767181873322, + 0.13500285148620605, + 0.1536676585674286, + 0.03276097774505615, + 0.03663482144474983 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038080889731645584 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_8/index_tensor([3763, 3763])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_8/index_tensor([3763, 3763])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d11d99b5151cd671c890e5e7c3949acd3c845a77 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_8/index_tensor([3763, 3763])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a lovely anime style, a static medium shot reveals the breathtaking interior of a vast, cavernous underground power station. From invisible vents in the vast, porous concrete ceiling, a sudden, gentle snowflake begins to fall, the flakes taking on a soft, stylized quality. Each delicate flake shimmers with a magical, crystalline light as it filters through the uniquely luminous light cast by the array of glowing blue and green control panels lining the distant wall. The air grows noticeably colder, and a thin layer of pristine white snow steadily and quietly coats the surfaces of the massive, silent turbines, their black, matte metal forms sharply outlined. The stark contrast between the cold industrial architecture and the whimsical, falling snow creates an unexpected atmosphere of quiet magic. The cool palette of grays and blues, punctuated by a soft, radiant technological glow and shimmering snow, evokes a profound sense of quiet wonder.", + "seed": 20620, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_8/index_3763_seed_20620_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.5818754676729441, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5818754676729441, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5818754676729441, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in an anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glowing blue and green control panels visible lining a distant wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive black matte metal turbines visible with a thin layer of white snow coating them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do stylized snowflakes fall from the porous concrete ceiling with a soft, crystalline shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9016159176826477 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5266159176826477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9016159176826477, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9016159176826477, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23403966426849365, + 0.054026272147893906, + 0.035682402551174164, + 0.08031024783849716, + 0.08087439835071564, + 0.06105943024158478, + 0.25304919481277466, + 0.05201498046517372, + 0.0831245556473732, + 0.06581883877515793 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9016159176826477 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in an anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glowing blue and green control panels visible lining a distant wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive black matte metal turbines visible with a thin layer of white snow coating them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do stylized snowflakes fall from the porous concrete ceiling with a soft, crystalline shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103424549102783 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603425145149231 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.9103424549102783, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.9103424549102783, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1673925668001175, + 0.09384746849536896, + 0.1780817061662674, + 0.11370395869016647, + 0.09551534056663513, + 0.09074873477220535, + 0.03927354887127876, + 0.041467536240816116, + 0.10614021867513657, + 0.07382894307374954 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.9103424549102783 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in an anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glowing blue and green control panels visible lining a distant wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive black matte metal turbines visible with a thin layer of white snow coating them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do stylized snowflakes fall from the porous concrete ceiling with a soft, crystalline shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04310861602425575 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1681087017059326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04310861602425575, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04310861602425575, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2273719757795334, + 0.05516543611884117, + 0.06412098556756973, + 0.12287295609712601, + 0.18003712594509125, + 0.10917772352695465, + 0.035013504326343536, + 0.03505900502204895, + 0.07801993191242218, + 0.09316141903400421 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04310861602425575 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in an anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glowing blue and green control panels visible lining a distant wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive black matte metal turbines visible with a thin layer of white snow coating them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do stylized snowflakes fall from the porous concrete ceiling with a soft, crystalline shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03372115269303322 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087212085723877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03372115269303322, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03372115269303322, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11377944052219391, + 0.04400216042995453, + 0.07750607281923294, + 0.0916193276643753, + 0.0966259315609932, + 0.052292678505182266, + 0.10801287740468979, + 0.09101767838001251, + 0.2157818228006363, + 0.10936201363801956 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03372115269303322 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in an anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glowing blue and green control panels visible lining a distant wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive black matte metal turbines visible with a thin layer of white snow coating them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do stylized snowflakes fall from the porous concrete ceiling with a soft, crystalline shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020589197054505348 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955891132354736 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020589197054505348, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020589197054505348, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3911838233470917, + 0.1389201283454895, + 0.04700853303074837, + 0.06647266447544098, + 0.04686351493000984, + 0.06155836209654808, + 0.14479461312294006, + 0.037709783762693405, + 0.03655393794178963, + 0.028934651985764503 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020589197054505348 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a lovely anime style, a static medium shot reveals the breathtaking interior of a vast, cavernous underground power station. From invisible vents in the vast, porous concrete ceiling, a sudden, gentle snowflake begins to fall, the flakes taking on a soft, stylized quality. Each delicate flake shimmers with a magical, crystalline light as it filters through the uniquely luminous light cast by the array of glowing blue and green control panels lining the distant wall. The air grows noticeably colder, and a thin layer of pristine white snow steadily and quietly coats the surfaces of the massive, silent turbines, their black, matte metal forms sharply outlined. The stark contrast between the cold industrial architecture and the whimsical, falling snow creates an unexpected atmosphere of quiet magic. The cool palette of grays and blues, punctuated by a soft, radiant technological glow and shimmering snow, evokes a profound sense of quiet wonder.", + "seed": 20621, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_8/index_3763_seed_20621_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.48447300493717194, + "vlm_logprob": -0.48447300493717194, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.48447300493717194, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in an anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glowing blue and green control panels visible lining a distant wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive black matte metal turbines visible with a thin layer of white snow coating them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do stylized snowflakes fall from the porous concrete ceiling with a soft, crystalline shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47917890548706055 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9791789054870605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47917890548706055, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47917890548706055, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23685240745544434, + 0.07994347810745239, + 0.1438216269016266, + 0.07133776694536209, + 0.08197344839572906, + 0.0913524180650711, + 0.047488193958997726, + 0.05511537566781044, + 0.04453152045607567, + 0.1475837230682373 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47917890548706055 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in an anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glowing blue and green control panels visible lining a distant wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive black matte metal turbines visible with a thin layer of white snow coating them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do stylized snowflakes fall from the porous concrete ceiling with a soft, crystalline shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015506029129028 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015506476163864 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.7015506029129028, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -1.7015506029129028, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17205746471881866, + 0.19839777052402496, + 0.08238936215639114, + 0.041523538529872894, + 0.05066885054111481, + 0.076825350522995, + 0.046697407960891724, + 0.1335880309343338, + 0.1430090367794037, + 0.054843150079250336 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.7015506029129028 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in an anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glowing blue and green control panels visible lining a distant wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive black matte metal turbines visible with a thin layer of white snow coating them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do stylized snowflakes fall from the porous concrete ceiling with a soft, crystalline shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16042974591255188 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104297161102295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16042974591255188, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16042974591255188, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5260963439941406, + 0.1052946150302887, + 0.12343084067106247, + 0.06746838986873627, + 0.0666150376200676, + 0.01602199114859104, + 0.007225402165204287, + 0.04176298528909683, + 0.013093783520162106, + 0.03299062326550484 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16042974591255188 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in an anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glowing blue and green control panels visible lining a distant wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive black matte metal turbines visible with a thin layer of white snow coating them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do stylized snowflakes fall from the porous concrete ceiling with a soft, crystalline shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309160262346268 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680915355682373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309160262346268, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309160262346268, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4389016330242157, + 0.09891433268785477, + 0.1859809011220932, + 0.03278060257434845, + 0.0893523097038269, + 0.05765777826309204, + 0.02373715676367283, + 0.030646948143839836, + 0.018756365403532982, + 0.02327198162674904 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309160262346268 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in an anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glowing blue and green control panels visible lining a distant wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive black matte metal turbines visible with a thin layer of white snow coating them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do stylized snowflakes fall from the porous concrete ceiling with a soft, crystalline shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038114167749881744 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288114070892334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038114167749881744, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038114167749881744, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37372466921806335, + 0.21900801360607147, + 0.10138285160064697, + 0.060656387358903885, + 0.03257431834936142, + 0.06499672681093216, + 0.02129209227859974, + 0.022653939202427864, + 0.03899243846535683, + 0.06471849232912064 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038114167749881744 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a lovely anime style, a static medium shot reveals the breathtaking interior of a vast, cavernous underground power station. From invisible vents in the vast, porous concrete ceiling, a sudden, gentle snowflake begins to fall, the flakes taking on a soft, stylized quality. Each delicate flake shimmers with a magical, crystalline light as it filters through the uniquely luminous light cast by the array of glowing blue and green control panels lining the distant wall. The air grows noticeably colder, and a thin layer of pristine white snow steadily and quietly coats the surfaces of the massive, silent turbines, their black, matte metal forms sharply outlined. The stark contrast between the cold industrial architecture and the whimsical, falling snow creates an unexpected atmosphere of quiet magic. The cool palette of grays and blues, punctuated by a soft, radiant technological glow and shimmering snow, evokes a profound sense of quiet wonder.", + "seed": 20622, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_8/index_3763_seed_20622_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.5932376723736524, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5932376723736524, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5932376723736524, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in an anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glowing blue and green control panels visible lining a distant wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive black matte metal turbines visible with a thin layer of white snow coating them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do stylized snowflakes fall from the porous concrete ceiling with a soft, crystalline shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25716641545295715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5071663856506348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25716641545295715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25716641545295715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05133642256259918, + 0.09481716901063919, + 0.23527589440345764, + 0.05334969237446785, + 0.11603483557701111, + 0.10869159549474716, + 0.05678056553006172, + 0.05543317273259163, + 0.06037520617246628, + 0.16790542006492615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25716641545295715 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in an anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glowing blue and green control panels visible lining a distant wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive black matte metal turbines visible with a thin layer of white snow coating them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do stylized snowflakes fall from the porous concrete ceiling with a soft, crystalline shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789613723754883 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07896146178245544 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.5789613723754883, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -2.5789613723754883, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.059247735887765884, + 0.2019403874874115, + 0.4544108510017395, + 0.028048668056726456, + 0.06945490092039108, + 0.016650443896651268, + 0.013669976964592934, + 0.046935733407735825, + 0.04449286311864853, + 0.06514842063188553 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.5789613723754883 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in an anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glowing blue and green control panels visible lining a distant wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive black matte metal turbines visible with a thin layer of white snow coating them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do stylized snowflakes fall from the porous concrete ceiling with a soft, crystalline shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026395076885819435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651395082473755 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026395076885819435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026395076885819435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.029405897483229637, + 0.15949979424476624, + 0.3533187508583069, + 0.03651346638798714, + 0.11733943969011307, + 0.05752744898200035, + 0.05515681207180023, + 0.016130665317177773, + 0.08811020851135254, + 0.08699754625558853 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026395076885819435 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in an anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glowing blue and green control panels visible lining a distant wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive black matte metal turbines visible with a thin layer of white snow coating them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do stylized snowflakes fall from the porous concrete ceiling with a soft, crystalline shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05499175563454628 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299917221069336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05499175563454628, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05499175563454628, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.029540754854679108, + 0.027572790160775185, + 0.5024724006652832, + 0.049743589013814926, + 0.09658129513263702, + 0.034064825624227524, + 0.04351479932665825, + 0.035617101937532425, + 0.04781182110309601, + 0.1330806314945221 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05499175563454628 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in an anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glowing blue and green control panels visible lining a distant wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive black matte metal turbines visible with a thin layer of white snow coating them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do stylized snowflakes fall from the porous concrete ceiling with a soft, crystalline shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867374151945114 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048673629760742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867374151945114, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867374151945114, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.035959392786026, + 0.09980805218219757, + 0.29463765025138855, + 0.04944129288196564, + 0.3146652579307556, + 0.09045030176639557, + 0.01921948418021202, + 0.016610415652394295, + 0.03826506808400154, + 0.040943071246147156 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867374151945114 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a lovely anime style, a static medium shot reveals the breathtaking interior of a vast, cavernous underground power station. From invisible vents in the vast, porous concrete ceiling, a sudden, gentle snowflake begins to fall, the flakes taking on a soft, stylized quality. Each delicate flake shimmers with a magical, crystalline light as it filters through the uniquely luminous light cast by the array of glowing blue and green control panels lining the distant wall. The air grows noticeably colder, and a thin layer of pristine white snow steadily and quietly coats the surfaces of the massive, silent turbines, their black, matte metal forms sharply outlined. The stark contrast between the cold industrial architecture and the whimsical, falling snow creates an unexpected atmosphere of quiet magic. The cool palette of grays and blues, punctuated by a soft, radiant technological glow and shimmering snow, evokes a profound sense of quiet wonder.", + "seed": 20623, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_8/index_3763_seed_20623_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.49560155514627696, + "vlm_logprob": -0.49560155514627696, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.49560155514627696, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in an anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glowing blue and green control panels visible lining a distant wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive black matte metal turbines visible with a thin layer of white snow coating them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do stylized snowflakes fall from the porous concrete ceiling with a soft, crystalline shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.13249219954013824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1324923038482666 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.13249219954013824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.13249219954013824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1682864874601364, + 0.06754057854413986, + 0.042866844683885574, + 0.09243802726268768, + 0.04282054677605629, + 0.05949478968977928, + 0.08166743814945221, + 0.07858283817768097, + 0.23522014915943146, + 0.13108237087726593 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.13249219954013824 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in an anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glowing blue and green control panels visible lining a distant wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive black matte metal turbines visible with a thin layer of white snow coating them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do stylized snowflakes fall from the porous concrete ceiling with a soft, crystalline shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379095554351807 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11290945112705231 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.2379095554351807, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -2.2379095554351807, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35302767157554626, + 0.09807740151882172, + 0.08374684303998947, + 0.08354327827692032, + 0.030092470347881317, + 0.0281353946775198, + 0.041405681520700455, + 0.06422965973615646, + 0.04284672439098358, + 0.17489488422870636 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.2379095554351807 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in an anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glowing blue and green control panels visible lining a distant wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive black matte metal turbines visible with a thin layer of white snow coating them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do stylized snowflakes fall from the porous concrete ceiling with a soft, crystalline shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07008739560842514 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695087432861328 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07008739560842514, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07008739560842514, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09609290212392807, + 0.05570579692721367, + 0.08233894407749176, + 0.21978913247585297, + 0.08725984394550323, + 0.038960523903369904, + 0.03923746943473816, + 0.1020536720752716, + 0.16144077479839325, + 0.11712094396352768 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07008739560842514 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in an anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glowing blue and green control panels visible lining a distant wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive black matte metal turbines visible with a thin layer of white snow coating them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do stylized snowflakes fall from the porous concrete ceiling with a soft, crystalline shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014216807670891285 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264216899871826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014216807670891285, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014216807670891285, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20891332626342773, + 0.09527987241744995, + 0.06604326516389847, + 0.0326191671192646, + 0.04491211473941803, + 0.06740251928567886, + 0.10929916799068451, + 0.047078970819711685, + 0.168826162815094, + 0.15962538123130798 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014216807670891285 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot in an anime style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera static in a medium shot framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are glowing blue and green control panels visible lining a distant wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are massive black matte metal turbines visible with a thin layer of white snow coating them?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do stylized snowflakes fall from the porous concrete ceiling with a soft, crystalline shimmer?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02330181747674942 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773301839828491 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02330181747674942, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02330181747674942, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18988199532032013, + 0.1621224731206894, + 0.08850283175706863, + 0.1013646051287651, + 0.07529628276824951, + 0.05702543258666992, + 0.046889591962099075, + 0.06786147505044937, + 0.12095224112272263, + 0.09010306745767593 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02330181747674942 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_9/index_tensor([7766, 7766])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_9/index_tensor([7766, 7766])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..76eb79ff373bd564326db73060071299e31e8254 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_9/index_tensor([7766, 7766])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "stunning close-up shot from a sideways angle, the camera held absolutely still, focusing the viewer's attention squarely on the creative process unfolding before their eyes. Illuminated by a soft, warm light, as if from a morning window, a clean, knuckled hand hovers over a plump, perfectly risen ball of dough, its wrist peeked out from the neat cuff of a crisp, white cotton chef's jacket. The dough, resting on a sturdy, weathered wooden board, is evenly dusted with a thin layer of dry flour. Then, the hand's owner carefully bends their fingers and rhythmically, gently yet firmly, taps the dough's elastic surface with their knuckles. Each precise tap creates a brief, soft indentation in the dough, as if breathing; simultaneously, a cloud of minute flour particles is stirred up, dancing and swirling gracefully in the slanting beam of light, like dust motes, before slowly drifting down. The light accurately outlines the texture of the skin on the hands and the soft contours of the dough, and forms fleeting flickering highlights on each bouncing dust. The entire picture is dominated by beige, warm brown and pure white, creating an extremely tranquil, focused and healing atmosphere, conveying infinite love and respect for handmade baking.", + "seed": 31399, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_9/index_7766_seed_31399_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.12791072577238083, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12791072577238083, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12791072577238083, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a hand hovering over a ball of dough on a wooden board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand wearing a crisp white cotton chef's jacket cuff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dough plump, perfectly risen, and dusted with a thin layer of dry flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand rhythmically tap the dough's surface with knuckles, creating indentations and stirring up flour particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held absolutely still from a sideways angle with soft warm lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.025025390088558197 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7750253677368164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.025025390088558197, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.025025390088558197, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3462795615196228, + 0.05045176297426224, + 0.06177361682057381, + 0.16137854754924774, + 0.036993008106946945, + 0.050660569220781326, + 0.030350971966981888, + 0.02132263407111168, + 0.11894674599170685, + 0.12184250354766846 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.025025390088558197 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a hand hovering over a ball of dough on a wooden board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand wearing a crisp white cotton chef's jacket cuff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dough plump, perfectly risen, and dusted with a thin layer of dry flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand rhythmically tap the dough's surface with knuckles, creating indentations and stirring up flour particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held absolutely still from a sideways angle with soft warm lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08911198377609253 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4641120433807373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08911198377609253, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08911198377609253, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4529947340488434, + 0.04387418180704117, + 0.049979209899902344, + 0.23527924716472626, + 0.014457070268690586, + 0.01980513148009777, + 0.046860918402671814, + 0.01784922182559967, + 0.08731142431497574, + 0.031588830053806305 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08911198377609253 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a hand hovering over a ball of dough on a wooden board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand wearing a crisp white cotton chef's jacket cuff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dough plump, perfectly risen, and dusted with a thin layer of dry flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand rhythmically tap the dough's surface with knuckles, creating indentations and stirring up flour particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held absolutely still from a sideways angle with soft warm lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07009072601795197 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950907707214355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07009072601795197, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07009072601795197, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34442487359046936, + 0.1346045583486557, + 0.07486485689878464, + 0.07684508711099625, + 0.07969940453767776, + 0.08757027238607407, + 0.03622839227318764, + 0.022067321464419365, + 0.11983554810285568, + 0.023859651759266853 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07009072601795197 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a hand hovering over a ball of dough on a wooden board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand wearing a crisp white cotton chef's jacket cuff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dough plump, perfectly risen, and dusted with a thin layer of dry flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand rhythmically tap the dough's surface with knuckles, creating indentations and stirring up flour particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held absolutely still from a sideways angle with soft warm lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026369765400886536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.65136981010437 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026369765400886536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026369765400886536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17650064826011658, + 0.09147454053163528, + 0.05841974541544914, + 0.057058751583099365, + 0.1983603835105896, + 0.10138798505067825, + 0.05036277696490288, + 0.0379922091960907, + 0.16187335550785065, + 0.06656966358423233 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026369765400886536 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a hand hovering over a ball of dough on a wooden board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand wearing a crisp white cotton chef's jacket cuff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dough plump, perfectly risen, and dusted with a thin layer of dry flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand rhythmically tap the dough's surface with knuckles, creating indentations and stirring up flour particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held absolutely still from a sideways angle with soft warm lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289557635784149 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539557933807373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4289557635784149, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4289557635784149, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09959635883569717, + 0.059344734996557236, + 0.07167738676071167, + 0.05432162061333656, + 0.05017484724521637, + 0.05948701873421669, + 0.09074395895004272, + 0.04102946072816849, + 0.43003976345062256, + 0.04358478635549545 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4289557635784149 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning close-up shot from a sideways angle, the camera held absolutely still, focusing the viewer's attention squarely on the creative process unfolding before their eyes. Illuminated by a soft, warm light, as if from a morning window, a clean, knuckled hand hovers over a plump, perfectly risen ball of dough, its wrist peeked out from the neat cuff of a crisp, white cotton chef's jacket. The dough, resting on a sturdy, weathered wooden board, is evenly dusted with a thin layer of dry flour. Then, the hand's owner carefully bends their fingers and rhythmically, gently yet firmly, taps the dough's elastic surface with their knuckles. Each precise tap creates a brief, soft indentation in the dough, as if breathing; simultaneously, a cloud of minute flour particles is stirred up, dancing and swirling gracefully in the slanting beam of light, like dust motes, before slowly drifting down. The light accurately outlines the texture of the skin on the hands and the soft contours of the dough, and forms fleeting flickering highlights on each bouncing dust. The entire picture is dominated by beige, warm brown and pure white, creating an extremely tranquil, focused and healing atmosphere, conveying infinite love and respect for handmade baking.", + "seed": 31400, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_9/index_7766_seed_31400_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.14445230644196272, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14445230644196272, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.724999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14445230644196272, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a hand hovering over a ball of dough on a wooden board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand wearing a crisp white cotton chef's jacket cuff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dough plump, perfectly risen, and dusted with a thin layer of dry flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand rhythmically tap the dough's surface with knuckles, creating indentations and stirring up flour particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held absolutely still from a sideways angle with soft warm lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.025236966088414192 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7752370834350586 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.025236966088414192, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.025236966088414192, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11842872947454453, + 0.11827221512794495, + 0.12336640059947968, + 0.2282787710428238, + 0.11324483156204224, + 0.07404457777738571, + 0.04987630620598793, + 0.07315950095653534, + 0.019227972254157066, + 0.08210068941116333 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.025236966088414192 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a hand hovering over a ball of dough on a wooden board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand wearing a crisp white cotton chef's jacket cuff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dough plump, perfectly risen, and dusted with a thin layer of dry flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand rhythmically tap the dough's surface with knuckles, creating indentations and stirring up flour particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held absolutely still from a sideways angle with soft warm lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42899924516677856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539991855621338 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42899924516677856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.6249999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42899924516677856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16322705149650574, + 0.10714763402938843, + 0.2570134699344635, + 0.20472273230552673, + 0.04422151297330856, + 0.02170645445585251, + 0.01675085537135601, + 0.14388620853424072, + 0.021822014823555946, + 0.019502056762576103 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42899924516677856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a hand hovering over a ball of dough on a wooden board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand wearing a crisp white cotton chef's jacket cuff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dough plump, perfectly risen, and dusted with a thin layer of dry flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand rhythmically tap the dough's surface with knuckles, creating indentations and stirring up flour particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held absolutely still from a sideways angle with soft warm lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029847843572497368 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298478603363037 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029847843572497368, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029847843572497368, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17631253600120544, + 0.07134713977575302, + 0.06399678438901901, + 0.337080717086792, + 0.10494891554117203, + 0.1052103266119957, + 0.021344617009162903, + 0.06403463333845139, + 0.026608694344758987, + 0.029115648940205574 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029847843572497368 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a hand hovering over a ball of dough on a wooden board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand wearing a crisp white cotton chef's jacket cuff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dough plump, perfectly risen, and dusted with a thin layer of dry flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand rhythmically tap the dough's surface with knuckles, creating indentations and stirring up flour particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held absolutely still from a sideways angle with soft warm lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01255230512470007 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387552261352539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01255230512470007, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01255230512470007, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11781030893325806, + 0.08093515038490295, + 0.12085238844156265, + 0.22013460099697113, + 0.07426337897777557, + 0.045166246592998505, + 0.07860473543405533, + 0.11003995686769485, + 0.09163035452365875, + 0.06056292727589607 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01255230512470007 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a hand hovering over a ball of dough on a wooden board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand wearing a crisp white cotton chef's jacket cuff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dough plump, perfectly risen, and dusted with a thin layer of dry flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand rhythmically tap the dough's surface with knuckles, creating indentations and stirring up flour particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held absolutely still from a sideways angle with soft warm lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2256251722574234 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006251573562622 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2256251722574234, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2256251722574234, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12967035174369812, + 0.13464446365833282, + 0.0940614640712738, + 0.34808409214019775, + 0.047760579735040665, + 0.07761524617671967, + 0.032438669353723526, + 0.06363680213689804, + 0.027182994410395622, + 0.044905394315719604 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2256251722574234 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning close-up shot from a sideways angle, the camera held absolutely still, focusing the viewer's attention squarely on the creative process unfolding before their eyes. Illuminated by a soft, warm light, as if from a morning window, a clean, knuckled hand hovers over a plump, perfectly risen ball of dough, its wrist peeked out from the neat cuff of a crisp, white cotton chef's jacket. The dough, resting on a sturdy, weathered wooden board, is evenly dusted with a thin layer of dry flour. Then, the hand's owner carefully bends their fingers and rhythmically, gently yet firmly, taps the dough's elastic surface with their knuckles. Each precise tap creates a brief, soft indentation in the dough, as if breathing; simultaneously, a cloud of minute flour particles is stirred up, dancing and swirling gracefully in the slanting beam of light, like dust motes, before slowly drifting down. The light accurately outlines the texture of the skin on the hands and the soft contours of the dough, and forms fleeting flickering highlights on each bouncing dust. The entire picture is dominated by beige, warm brown and pure white, creating an extremely tranquil, focused and healing atmosphere, conveying infinite love and respect for handmade baking.", + "seed": 31401, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_9/index_7766_seed_31401_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10238424595445395, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10238424595445395, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10238424595445395, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a hand hovering over a ball of dough on a wooden board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand wearing a crisp white cotton chef's jacket cuff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dough plump, perfectly risen, and dusted with a thin layer of dry flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand rhythmically tap the dough's surface with knuckles, creating indentations and stirring up flour particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held absolutely still from a sideways angle with soft warm lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03130846098065376 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.53130841255188 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03130846098065376, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03130846098065376, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23622803390026093, + 0.09032480418682098, + 0.10194894671440125, + 0.16880391538143158, + 0.0773845985531807, + 0.03208572790026665, + 0.07629270851612091, + 0.04797901213169098, + 0.0969650074839592, + 0.07198727875947952 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03130846098065376 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a hand hovering over a ball of dough on a wooden board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand wearing a crisp white cotton chef's jacket cuff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dough plump, perfectly risen, and dusted with a thin layer of dry flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand rhythmically tap the dough's surface with knuckles, creating indentations and stirring up flour particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held absolutely still from a sideways angle with soft warm lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521438002586365 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021438598632812 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521438002586365, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521438002586365, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3461310863494873, + 0.1071840450167656, + 0.16007757186889648, + 0.1293339729309082, + 0.06207043305039406, + 0.04712095484137535, + 0.055064793676137924, + 0.03735753893852234, + 0.025209438055753708, + 0.030450182035565376 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521438002586365 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a hand hovering over a ball of dough on a wooden board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand wearing a crisp white cotton chef's jacket cuff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dough plump, perfectly risen, and dusted with a thin layer of dry flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand rhythmically tap the dough's surface with knuckles, creating indentations and stirring up flour particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held absolutely still from a sideways angle with soft warm lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018219027668237686 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018218994140625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018219027668237686, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018219027668237686, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1888970136642456, + 0.09551431983709335, + 0.391079306602478, + 0.0788206234574318, + 0.043886661529541016, + 0.03210543468594551, + 0.0605982281267643, + 0.05605708807706833, + 0.025697657838463783, + 0.027343707159161568 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018219027668237686 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a hand hovering over a ball of dough on a wooden board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand wearing a crisp white cotton chef's jacket cuff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dough plump, perfectly risen, and dusted with a thin layer of dry flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand rhythmically tap the dough's surface with knuckles, creating indentations and stirring up flour particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held absolutely still from a sideways angle with soft warm lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008645604364573956 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758645534515381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008645604364573956, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008645604364573956, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1153101846575737, + 0.09194616973400116, + 0.49872010946273804, + 0.04783729836344719, + 0.04256868362426758, + 0.043096963316202164, + 0.03052859753370285, + 0.04530874639749527, + 0.030037490651011467, + 0.05464573949575424 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008645604364573956 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a hand hovering over a ball of dough on a wooden board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand wearing a crisp white cotton chef's jacket cuff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dough plump, perfectly risen, and dusted with a thin layer of dry flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand rhythmically tap the dough's surface with knuckles, creating indentations and stirring up flour particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held absolutely still from a sideways angle with soft warm lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20160433650016785 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016043663024902 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20160433650016785, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20160433650016785, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3264874517917633, + 0.1052921861410141, + 0.15649090707302094, + 0.08723799139261246, + 0.052872300148010254, + 0.049649905413389206, + 0.06116487830877304, + 0.030943455174565315, + 0.10641320049762726, + 0.023447640240192413 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20160433650016785 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning close-up shot from a sideways angle, the camera held absolutely still, focusing the viewer's attention squarely on the creative process unfolding before their eyes. Illuminated by a soft, warm light, as if from a morning window, a clean, knuckled hand hovers over a plump, perfectly risen ball of dough, its wrist peeked out from the neat cuff of a crisp, white cotton chef's jacket. The dough, resting on a sturdy, weathered wooden board, is evenly dusted with a thin layer of dry flour. Then, the hand's owner carefully bends their fingers and rhythmically, gently yet firmly, taps the dough's elastic surface with their knuckles. Each precise tap creates a brief, soft indentation in the dough, as if breathing; simultaneously, a cloud of minute flour particles is stirred up, dancing and swirling gracefully in the slanting beam of light, like dust motes, before slowly drifting down. The light accurately outlines the texture of the skin on the hands and the soft contours of the dough, and forms fleeting flickering highlights on each bouncing dust. The entire picture is dominated by beige, warm brown and pure white, creating an extremely tranquil, focused and healing atmosphere, conveying infinite love and respect for handmade baking.", + "seed": 31402, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000271/group_9/index_7766_seed_31402_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.4543975744396448, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4543975744396448, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.4500000119209289, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4543975744396448, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a hand hovering over a ball of dough on a wooden board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand wearing a crisp white cotton chef's jacket cuff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dough plump, perfectly risen, and dusted with a thin layer of dry flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand rhythmically tap the dough's surface with knuckles, creating indentations and stirring up flour particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held absolutely still from a sideways angle with soft warm lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5025054216384888 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25250542163848877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.5025054216384888, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -1.5025054216384888, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29347318410873413, + 0.16586725413799286, + 0.22818110883235931, + 0.029434219002723694, + 0.06700298190116882, + 0.037607960402965546, + 0.05188528820872307, + 0.045338477939367294, + 0.0364740751683712, + 0.044735465198755264 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.5025054216384888 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a hand hovering over a ball of dough on a wooden board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand wearing a crisp white cotton chef's jacket cuff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dough plump, perfectly risen, and dusted with a thin layer of dry flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand rhythmically tap the dough's surface with knuckles, creating indentations and stirring up flour particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held absolutely still from a sideways angle with soft warm lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34878063201904297 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223780632019043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34878063201904297, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34878063201904297, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30575981736183167, + 0.11111767590045929, + 0.09855635464191437, + 0.08036720752716064, + 0.05039377138018608, + 0.05203322693705559, + 0.10388252139091492, + 0.0974792018532753, + 0.042278699576854706, + 0.05813147500157356 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34878063201904297 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a hand hovering over a ball of dough on a wooden board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand wearing a crisp white cotton chef's jacket cuff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dough plump, perfectly risen, and dusted with a thin layer of dry flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand rhythmically tap the dough's surface with knuckles, creating indentations and stirring up flour particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held absolutely still from a sideways angle with soft warm lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023336639627814293 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.77333664894104 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023336639627814293, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023336639627814293, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2287682741880417, + 0.23258088529109955, + 0.16657613217830658, + 0.05071894824504852, + 0.05153847858309746, + 0.05828069522976875, + 0.032241251319646835, + 0.1425762176513672, + 0.02191631682217121, + 0.014802766963839531 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023336639627814293 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a hand hovering over a ball of dough on a wooden board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand wearing a crisp white cotton chef's jacket cuff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dough plump, perfectly risen, and dusted with a thin layer of dry flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand rhythmically tap the dough's surface with knuckles, creating indentations and stirring up flour particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held absolutely still from a sideways angle with soft warm lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048677828162908554 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048677921295166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048677828162908554, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048677828162908554, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.49497896432876587, + 0.0655936598777771, + 0.1271214634180069, + 0.05388275533914566, + 0.05301447585225105, + 0.054093729704618454, + 0.053283922374248505, + 0.02918868698179722, + 0.03256012499332428, + 0.036282263696193695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048677828162908554 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a hand hovering over a ball of dough on a wooden board?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the hand wearing a crisp white cotton chef's jacket cuff?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the dough plump, perfectly risen, and dusted with a thin layer of dry flour?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the hand rhythmically tap the dough's surface with knuckles, creating indentations and stirring up flour particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held absolutely still from a sideways angle with soft warm lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486873507499695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236874103546143 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486873507499695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8750000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486873507499695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3940710127353668, + 0.12168695777654648, + 0.07920785248279572, + 0.04350282996892929, + 0.05764223635196686, + 0.05771204084157944, + 0.03358255326747894, + 0.07767411321401596, + 0.08745311200618744, + 0.047467272728681564 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486873507499695 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_0/index_tensor([6722, 6722])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_0/index_tensor([6722, 6722])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..dd4c32f8c59292fff286c588e3c2ab58f7333aa9 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_0/index_tensor([6722, 6722])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, extremely low-angle shot, almost touching the surface of an ancient desk, captures a sheet of slightly yellowed rice paper, caught by an invisible breeze and gently drifting through the air. The dark lacquered wood surface, smooth with age, is dotted with minute cracks and a deep patina. The delicate, translucent rice paper, freshly freed from a heavy brass paperweight, gracefully tumbles and unfurls in mid-air, its edges softly defined by the light, as if performing a silent, slow-motion dance. A soft, dusty beam of afternoon sunlight slants through the window lattice just beyond the frame, illuminating the area and casting a golden glow on the floating rice paper and the fine dust suspended in the air. In the background, a dim corner of the study reveals the faint outlines of a bamboo brush holder and an inkstone, stained with ink. The entire picture is full of tranquility and poetry. The interweaving of light and shadow and the light movement of paper together create an oriental aesthetic atmosphere of frozen time and quiet contemplation.", + "seed": 22497, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_0/index_6722_seed_22497_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1612312875688076, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1612312875688076, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1612312875688076, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sheet of slightly yellowed rice paper visible drifting in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background surface dark lacquered wood with visible minute cracks and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, dusty beam of afternoon sunlight slanting through a window lattice visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are faint outlines of a bamboo brush holder and an inkstone visible in the background corner?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.590281069278717 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.840281069278717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.590281069278717, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.590281069278717, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23413203656673431, + 0.11019395291805267, + 0.23804157972335815, + 0.07029672712087631, + 0.0989607721567154, + 0.05339035764336586, + 0.025244463235139847, + 0.02726113423705101, + 0.10784979909658432, + 0.03462919220328331 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.590281069278717 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sheet of slightly yellowed rice paper visible drifting in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background surface dark lacquered wood with visible minute cracks and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, dusty beam of afternoon sunlight slanting through a window lattice visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are faint outlines of a bamboo brush holder and an inkstone visible in the background corner?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309731349349022 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680972576141357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309731349349022, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309731349349022, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19187209010124207, + 0.19283761084079742, + 0.1450107991695404, + 0.20594052970409393, + 0.04139525443315506, + 0.013567444868385792, + 0.0258420929312706, + 0.029366187751293182, + 0.12821921706199646, + 0.025948774069547653 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309731349349022 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sheet of slightly yellowed rice paper visible drifting in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background surface dark lacquered wood with visible minute cracks and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, dusty beam of afternoon sunlight slanting through a window lattice visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are faint outlines of a bamboo brush holder and an inkstone visible in the background corner?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205355003476143 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120534420013428 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205355003476143, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205355003476143, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17601262032985687, + 0.1062985509634018, + 0.202029749751091, + 0.07623966038227081, + 0.15521040558815002, + 0.09082099795341492, + 0.027432456612586975, + 0.03771865367889404, + 0.05675729736685753, + 0.07147961109876633 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205355003476143 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sheet of slightly yellowed rice paper visible drifting in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background surface dark lacquered wood with visible minute cracks and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, dusty beam of afternoon sunlight slanting through a window lattice visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are faint outlines of a bamboo brush holder and an inkstone visible in the background corner?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048674989491701126 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048675060272217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048674989491701126, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048674989491701126, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12045255303382874, + 0.08155494928359985, + 0.31363970041275024, + 0.07324746251106262, + 0.07190325111150742, + 0.07695440948009491, + 0.0482952781021595, + 0.017498398199677467, + 0.11443951725959778, + 0.08201447874307632 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048674989491701126 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sheet of slightly yellowed rice paper visible drifting in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background surface dark lacquered wood with visible minute cracks and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, dusty beam of afternoon sunlight slanting through a window lattice visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are faint outlines of a bamboo brush holder and an inkstone visible in the background corner?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062049515545368195 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812049627304077 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062049515545368195, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062049515545368195, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2612127959728241, + 0.11718322336673737, + 0.09891282767057419, + 0.07325663417577744, + 0.06284840404987335, + 0.05347590520977974, + 0.06245919689536095, + 0.07636753469705582, + 0.11251457035541534, + 0.08176888525485992 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062049515545368195 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, extremely low-angle shot, almost touching the surface of an ancient desk, captures a sheet of slightly yellowed rice paper, caught by an invisible breeze and gently drifting through the air. The dark lacquered wood surface, smooth with age, is dotted with minute cracks and a deep patina. The delicate, translucent rice paper, freshly freed from a heavy brass paperweight, gracefully tumbles and unfurls in mid-air, its edges softly defined by the light, as if performing a silent, slow-motion dance. A soft, dusty beam of afternoon sunlight slants through the window lattice just beyond the frame, illuminating the area and casting a golden glow on the floating rice paper and the fine dust suspended in the air. In the background, a dim corner of the study reveals the faint outlines of a bamboo brush holder and an inkstone, stained with ink. The entire picture is full of tranquility and poetry. The interweaving of light and shadow and the light movement of paper together create an oriental aesthetic atmosphere of frozen time and quiet contemplation.", + "seed": 22498, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_0/index_6722_seed_22498_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.10114476848393679, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10114476848393679, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10114476848393679, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sheet of slightly yellowed rice paper visible drifting in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background surface dark lacquered wood with visible minute cracks and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, dusty beam of afternoon sunlight slanting through a window lattice visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are faint outlines of a bamboo brush holder and an inkstone visible in the background corner?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3446643650531769 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3446643352508545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3446643650531769, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3446643650531769, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21157485246658325, + 0.04886196553707123, + 0.18370896577835083, + 0.04782849922776222, + 0.1583632230758667, + 0.1276955008506775, + 0.08557877689599991, + 0.04299938678741455, + 0.07692799717187881, + 0.016460860148072243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3446643650531769 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sheet of slightly yellowed rice paper visible drifting in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background surface dark lacquered wood with visible minute cracks and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, dusty beam of afternoon sunlight slanting through a window lattice visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are faint outlines of a bamboo brush holder and an inkstone visible in the background corner?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029845530167222023 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298454761505127 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029845530167222023, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029845530167222023, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04618656635284424, + 0.03593438118696213, + 0.02427382953464985, + 0.030704179778695107, + 0.19847504794597626, + 0.41319161653518677, + 0.05459258332848549, + 0.11937367171049118, + 0.04350724443793297, + 0.0337609238922596 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029845530167222023 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sheet of slightly yellowed rice paper visible drifting in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background surface dark lacquered wood with visible minute cracks and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, dusty beam of afternoon sunlight slanting through a window lattice visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are faint outlines of a bamboo brush holder and an inkstone visible in the background corner?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062054894864559174 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120548725128174 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062054894864559174, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062054894864559174, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08936416357755661, + 0.03475799411535263, + 0.47595417499542236, + 0.046715397387742996, + 0.07672805339097977, + 0.11366336792707443, + 0.0414651520550251, + 0.019917987287044525, + 0.047330088913440704, + 0.05410361289978027 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062054894864559174 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sheet of slightly yellowed rice paper visible drifting in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background surface dark lacquered wood with visible minute cracks and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, dusty beam of afternoon sunlight slanting through a window lattice visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are faint outlines of a bamboo brush holder and an inkstone visible in the background corner?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0142059950158 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2642059326171875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0142059950158, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0142059950158, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2524898648262024, + 0.1295926719903946, + 0.16908717155456543, + 0.05386058986186981, + 0.060728248208761215, + 0.0986514613032341, + 0.02039751224219799, + 0.05627082288265228, + 0.04761899262666702, + 0.11130265146493912 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0142059950158 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sheet of slightly yellowed rice paper visible drifting in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background surface dark lacquered wood with visible minute cracks and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, dusty beam of afternoon sunlight slanting through a window lattice visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are faint outlines of a bamboo brush holder and an inkstone visible in the background corner?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495305731892586 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929953098297119 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495305731892586, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495305731892586, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19759894907474518, + 0.02840038575232029, + 0.3570600152015686, + 0.01977221481502056, + 0.0565788634121418, + 0.1105789914727211, + 0.02727266028523445, + 0.028840746730566025, + 0.06438246369361877, + 0.10951472073793411 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495305731892586 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, extremely low-angle shot, almost touching the surface of an ancient desk, captures a sheet of slightly yellowed rice paper, caught by an invisible breeze and gently drifting through the air. The dark lacquered wood surface, smooth with age, is dotted with minute cracks and a deep patina. The delicate, translucent rice paper, freshly freed from a heavy brass paperweight, gracefully tumbles and unfurls in mid-air, its edges softly defined by the light, as if performing a silent, slow-motion dance. A soft, dusty beam of afternoon sunlight slants through the window lattice just beyond the frame, illuminating the area and casting a golden glow on the floating rice paper and the fine dust suspended in the air. In the background, a dim corner of the study reveals the faint outlines of a bamboo brush holder and an inkstone, stained with ink. The entire picture is full of tranquility and poetry. The interweaving of light and shadow and the light movement of paper together create an oriental aesthetic atmosphere of frozen time and quiet contemplation.", + "seed": 22499, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_0/index_6722_seed_22499_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04630002602934837, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04630002602934837, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04630002602934837, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sheet of slightly yellowed rice paper visible drifting in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background surface dark lacquered wood with visible minute cracks and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, dusty beam of afternoon sunlight slanting through a window lattice visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are faint outlines of a bamboo brush holder and an inkstone visible in the background corner?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10857736319303513 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.483577251434326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10857736319303513, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10857736319303513, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30180269479751587, + 0.08155878633260727, + 0.0590604804456234, + 0.16178035736083984, + 0.0798032358288765, + 0.05299888551235199, + 0.08573875576257706, + 0.030497342348098755, + 0.037585411220788956, + 0.109173983335495 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10857736319303513 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sheet of slightly yellowed rice paper visible drifting in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background surface dark lacquered wood with visible minute cracks and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, dusty beam of afternoon sunlight slanting through a window lattice visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are faint outlines of a bamboo brush holder and an inkstone visible in the background corner?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016100509092211723 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1411004066467285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016100509092211723, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016100509092211723, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.059590697288513184, + 0.1296512484550476, + 0.0827869102358818, + 0.5084621906280518, + 0.08362714946269989, + 0.0188293419778347, + 0.061871908605098724, + 0.018536778166890144, + 0.012054606340825558, + 0.024589212611317635 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016100509092211723 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sheet of slightly yellowed rice paper visible drifting in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background surface dark lacquered wood with visible minute cracks and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, dusty beam of afternoon sunlight slanting through a window lattice visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are faint outlines of a bamboo brush holder and an inkstone visible in the background corner?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370547667145729 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408705472946167 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370547667145729, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370547667145729, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21045218408107758, + 0.157823845744133, + 0.06373337656259537, + 0.12339707463979721, + 0.10319630056619644, + 0.05444098263978958, + 0.18920035660266876, + 0.019811540842056274, + 0.028155295178294182, + 0.04978902265429497 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370547667145729 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sheet of slightly yellowed rice paper visible drifting in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background surface dark lacquered wood with visible minute cracks and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, dusty beam of afternoon sunlight slanting through a window lattice visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are faint outlines of a bamboo brush holder and an inkstone visible in the background corner?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011082051321864128 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511082172393799 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011082051321864128, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011082051321864128, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5274871587753296, + 0.09743086993694305, + 0.04217785224318504, + 0.0584009625017643, + 0.039707403630018234, + 0.03082256205379963, + 0.07235539704561234, + 0.02201801910996437, + 0.029202062636613846, + 0.08039774745702744 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011082051321864128 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sheet of slightly yellowed rice paper visible drifting in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background surface dark lacquered wood with visible minute cracks and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, dusty beam of afternoon sunlight slanting through a window lattice visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are faint outlines of a bamboo brush holder and an inkstone visible in the background corner?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620347298681736 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812034845352173 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620347298681736, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620347298681736, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09225474298000336, + 0.049067504703998566, + 0.02423015423119068, + 0.06233985349535942, + 0.05863352492451668, + 0.06535199284553528, + 0.550616979598999, + 0.027481572702527046, + 0.03026309795677662, + 0.03976061940193176 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620347298681736 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, extremely low-angle shot, almost touching the surface of an ancient desk, captures a sheet of slightly yellowed rice paper, caught by an invisible breeze and gently drifting through the air. The dark lacquered wood surface, smooth with age, is dotted with minute cracks and a deep patina. The delicate, translucent rice paper, freshly freed from a heavy brass paperweight, gracefully tumbles and unfurls in mid-air, its edges softly defined by the light, as if performing a silent, slow-motion dance. A soft, dusty beam of afternoon sunlight slants through the window lattice just beyond the frame, illuminating the area and casting a golden glow on the floating rice paper and the fine dust suspended in the air. In the background, a dim corner of the study reveals the faint outlines of a bamboo brush holder and an inkstone, stained with ink. The entire picture is full of tranquility and poetry. The interweaving of light and shadow and the light movement of paper together create an oriental aesthetic atmosphere of frozen time and quiet contemplation.", + "seed": 22500, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_0/index_6722_seed_22500_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10663711577653885, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10663711577653885, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.699999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10663711577653885, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sheet of slightly yellowed rice paper visible drifting in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background surface dark lacquered wood with visible minute cracks and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, dusty beam of afternoon sunlight slanting through a window lattice visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are faint outlines of a bamboo brush holder and an inkstone visible in the background corner?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3322414755821228 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3322415351867676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3322414755821228, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3322414755821228, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1928892284631729, + 0.10944203287363052, + 0.07003258168697357, + 0.07560185343027115, + 0.07206199318170547, + 0.03915676102042198, + 0.09240028262138367, + 0.10851524770259857, + 0.10311117768287659, + 0.13678881525993347 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3322414755821228 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sheet of slightly yellowed rice paper visible drifting in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background surface dark lacquered wood with visible minute cracks and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, dusty beam of afternoon sunlight slanting through a window lattice visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are faint outlines of a bamboo brush holder and an inkstone visible in the background corner?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07005415856838226 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695054054260254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07005415856838226, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07005415856838226, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12756487727165222, + 0.15219387412071228, + 0.0709465816617012, + 0.05459403246641159, + 0.0699336975812912, + 0.03592047095298767, + 0.14907196164131165, + 0.16678880155086517, + 0.09753648936748505, + 0.07544922828674316 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07005415856838226 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sheet of slightly yellowed rice paper visible drifting in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background surface dark lacquered wood with visible minute cracks and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, dusty beam of afternoon sunlight slanting through a window lattice visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are faint outlines of a bamboo brush holder and an inkstone visible in the background corner?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370974212884903 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408709764480591 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370974212884903, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370974212884903, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29670414328575134, + 0.1679915189743042, + 0.043606314808130264, + 0.07314721494913101, + 0.09737272560596466, + 0.024401886388659477, + 0.13333173096179962, + 0.037007514387369156, + 0.04123442620038986, + 0.08520247787237167 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370974212884903 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sheet of slightly yellowed rice paper visible drifting in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background surface dark lacquered wood with visible minute cracks and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, dusty beam of afternoon sunlight slanting through a window lattice visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are faint outlines of a bamboo brush holder and an inkstone visible in the background corner?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01820100098848343 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018200874328613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01820100098848343, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01820100098848343, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08651634305715561, + 0.054199352860450745, + 0.040651317685842514, + 0.07631050795316696, + 0.04056370630860329, + 0.03647591546177864, + 0.07479754090309143, + 0.08746988326311111, + 0.19914738833904266, + 0.30386802554130554 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01820100098848343 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot taken from an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a sheet of slightly yellowed rice paper visible drifting in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the background surface dark lacquered wood with visible minute cracks and patina?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a soft, dusty beam of afternoon sunlight slanting through a window lattice visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are faint outlines of a bamboo brush holder and an inkstone visible in the background corner?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897920161485672 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578979253768921 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897920161485672, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897920161485672, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14304997026920319, + 0.12372557073831558, + 0.13001883029937744, + 0.039157357066869736, + 0.08789466321468353, + 0.048824772238731384, + 0.17065797746181488, + 0.06788931787014008, + 0.10197038948535919, + 0.08681115508079529 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897920161485672 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_1/index_tensor([8844, 8844])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_1/index_tensor([8844, 8844])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8f88a0f01c3f434f4babcf0f1a356f50d9b57573 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_1/index_tensor([8844, 8844])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "stunning macro close-up closely tracks a vibrantly colored tree frog, its vibrant green skin shimmering with a wet sheen, seemingly composed of layers of thick, textured oil paint. It rests on a broad, moist green leaf, its glistening water droplets and distinct veins distorted by Van Gogh-esque swirling brushstrokes, set against a blurred backdrop of dark greens and browns. The frog's large, bulging scarlet eyes fixate on its target, its pupils constricted to pinpoints of concentration. Its entire body remains absolutely still in the moment before bursting forth, its muscular hind legs tightly curled, gathering incredible power. Suddenly, it launches itself from the leaf, its entire movement captured in frenzied brushstrokes. Its body unfurls in the air, the surrounding air seemingly transformed into a visible, swirling current of yellow-green lines. The entire scene is imbued with the intense visual impact of thick oil paint and the raw dynamism of life.", + "seed": 7974, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_1/index_8844_seed_7974_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04081743832211941, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04081743832211941, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04081743832211941, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tree frog with vibrant green skin and large bulging scarlet eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture visually rendered to resemble thick, textured oil paint layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a broad, moist green leaf with glistening water droplets and distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque swirling brushstrokes, particularly distorting the leaf veins and the frog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the frog launching from the leaf with its body unfurling in a swirl of yellow-green lines representing air currents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06305813044309616 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8130581378936768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06305813044309616, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06305813044309616, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0784512534737587, + 0.2727908492088318, + 0.26055169105529785, + 0.07453753799200058, + 0.0753546878695488, + 0.048434045165777206, + 0.04501834511756897, + 0.021180445328354836, + 0.02106831967830658, + 0.10261284559965134 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06305813044309616 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tree frog with vibrant green skin and large bulging scarlet eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture visually rendered to resemble thick, textured oil paint layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a broad, moist green leaf with glistening water droplets and distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque swirling brushstrokes, particularly distorting the leaf veins and the frog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the frog launching from the leaf with its body unfurling in a swirl of yellow-green lines representing air currents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270611733198166 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127061128616333 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270611733198166, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270611733198166, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0675538182258606, + 0.286182165145874, + 0.28045654296875, + 0.02181442268192768, + 0.05072866380214691, + 0.05739738419651985, + 0.07176869362592697, + 0.02103123627603054, + 0.02492920309305191, + 0.11813786625862122 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270611733198166 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tree frog with vibrant green skin and large bulging scarlet eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture visually rendered to resemble thick, textured oil paint layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a broad, moist green leaf with glistening water droplets and distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque swirling brushstrokes, particularly distorting the leaf veins and the frog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the frog launching from the leaf with its body unfurling in a swirl of yellow-green lines representing air currents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00362038123421371 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628620147705078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00362038123421371, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00362038123421371, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.056098975241184235, + 0.24966643750667572, + 0.38649481534957886, + 0.021364042535424232, + 0.024687131866812706, + 0.09977826476097107, + 0.03006509505212307, + 0.0174007099121809, + 0.022643588483333588, + 0.09180089086294174 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00362038123421371 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tree frog with vibrant green skin and large bulging scarlet eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture visually rendered to resemble thick, textured oil paint layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a broad, moist green leaf with glistening water droplets and distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque swirling brushstrokes, particularly distorting the leaf veins and the frog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the frog launching from the leaf with its body unfurling in a swirl of yellow-green lines representing air currents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017146660247817636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376714706420898 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017146660247817636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017146660247817636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05938117206096649, + 0.30572402477264404, + 0.2407331019639969, + 0.028157616034150124, + 0.04898509383201599, + 0.03556297346949577, + 0.10805658996105194, + 0.02736671455204487, + 0.027301790192723274, + 0.11873084306716919 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017146660247817636 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tree frog with vibrant green skin and large bulging scarlet eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture visually rendered to resemble thick, textured oil paint layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a broad, moist green leaf with glistening water droplets and distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque swirling brushstrokes, particularly distorting the leaf veins and the frog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the frog launching from the leaf with its body unfurling in a swirl of yellow-green lines representing air currents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00863284058868885 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758632659912109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00863284058868885, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00863284058868885, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0786481574177742, + 0.26713883876800537, + 0.047964032739400864, + 0.02658187784254551, + 0.09771350771188736, + 0.06912308186292648, + 0.11891210824251175, + 0.09314826130867004, + 0.048573367297649384, + 0.15219677984714508 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00863284058868885 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning macro close-up closely tracks a vibrantly colored tree frog, its vibrant green skin shimmering with a wet sheen, seemingly composed of layers of thick, textured oil paint. It rests on a broad, moist green leaf, its glistening water droplets and distinct veins distorted by Van Gogh-esque swirling brushstrokes, set against a blurred backdrop of dark greens and browns. The frog's large, bulging scarlet eyes fixate on its target, its pupils constricted to pinpoints of concentration. Its entire body remains absolutely still in the moment before bursting forth, its muscular hind legs tightly curled, gathering incredible power. Suddenly, it launches itself from the leaf, its entire movement captured in frenzied brushstrokes. Its body unfurls in the air, the surrounding air seemingly transformed into a visible, swirling current of yellow-green lines. The entire scene is imbued with the intense visual impact of thick oil paint and the raw dynamism of life.", + "seed": 7975, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_1/index_8844_seed_7975_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.061170541774481536, + "vlm_logprob": -0.061170541774481536, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.061170541774481536, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tree frog with vibrant green skin and large bulging scarlet eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture visually rendered to resemble thick, textured oil paint layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a broad, moist green leaf with glistening water droplets and distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque swirling brushstrokes, particularly distorting the leaf veins and the frog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the frog launching from the leaf with its body unfurling in a swirl of yellow-green lines representing air currents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22669900953769684 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6016989946365356 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22669900953769684, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22669900953769684, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33355408906936646, + 0.015398416668176651, + 0.08613220602273941, + 0.09530487656593323, + 0.04234364628791809, + 0.030192900449037552, + 0.12318923324346542, + 0.153226837515831, + 0.05868512764573097, + 0.06197264418005943 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22669900953769684 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tree frog with vibrant green skin and large bulging scarlet eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture visually rendered to resemble thick, textured oil paint layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a broad, moist green leaf with glistening water droplets and distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque swirling brushstrokes, particularly distorting the leaf veins and the frog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the frog launching from the leaf with its body unfurling in a swirl of yellow-green lines representing air currents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308292642235756 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680829524993896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308292642235756, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308292642235756, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06492887437343597, + 0.05260757356882095, + 0.12208595126867294, + 0.17862777411937714, + 0.05154535546898842, + 0.14122582972049713, + 0.044642124325037, + 0.13535547256469727, + 0.07549785822629929, + 0.1334831416606903 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308292642235756 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tree frog with vibrant green skin and large bulging scarlet eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture visually rendered to resemble thick, textured oil paint layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a broad, moist green leaf with glistening water droplets and distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque swirling brushstrokes, particularly distorting the leaf veins and the frog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the frog launching from the leaf with its body unfurling in a swirl of yellow-green lines representing air currents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01108134351670742 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511081218719482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01108134351670742, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01108134351670742, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18995581567287445, + 0.05960492417216301, + 0.08936405181884766, + 0.18552841246128082, + 0.03540070354938507, + 0.11777624487876892, + 0.06967546790838242, + 0.06112973019480705, + 0.09119727462530136, + 0.10036735981702805 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01108134351670742 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tree frog with vibrant green skin and large bulging scarlet eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture visually rendered to resemble thick, textured oil paint layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a broad, moist green leaf with glistening water droplets and distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque swirling brushstrokes, particularly distorting the leaf veins and the frog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the frog launching from the leaf with its body unfurling in a swirl of yellow-green lines representing air currents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017131189815700054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376713275909424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017131189815700054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017131189815700054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2322486937046051, + 0.036227352917194366, + 0.03847818821668625, + 0.08867190778255463, + 0.03196996450424194, + 0.05964245647192001, + 0.049575839191675186, + 0.09537150710821152, + 0.14065442979335785, + 0.22715961933135986 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017131189815700054 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tree frog with vibrant green skin and large bulging scarlet eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture visually rendered to resemble thick, textured oil paint layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a broad, moist green leaf with glistening water droplets and distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque swirling brushstrokes, particularly distorting the leaf veins and the frog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the frog launching from the leaf with its body unfurling in a swirl of yellow-green lines representing air currents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02327631041407585 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732763290405273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02327631041407585, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02327631041407585, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1592477411031723, + 0.02318425290286541, + 0.046411000192165375, + 0.06169760599732399, + 0.08091923594474792, + 0.015462743118405342, + 0.06224158778786659, + 0.08899006247520447, + 0.16526271402835846, + 0.29658302664756775 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02327631041407585 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning macro close-up closely tracks a vibrantly colored tree frog, its vibrant green skin shimmering with a wet sheen, seemingly composed of layers of thick, textured oil paint. It rests on a broad, moist green leaf, its glistening water droplets and distinct veins distorted by Van Gogh-esque swirling brushstrokes, set against a blurred backdrop of dark greens and browns. The frog's large, bulging scarlet eyes fixate on its target, its pupils constricted to pinpoints of concentration. Its entire body remains absolutely still in the moment before bursting forth, its muscular hind legs tightly curled, gathering incredible power. Suddenly, it launches itself from the leaf, its entire movement captured in frenzied brushstrokes. Its body unfurls in the air, the surrounding air seemingly transformed into a visible, swirling current of yellow-green lines. The entire scene is imbued with the intense visual impact of thick oil paint and the raw dynamism of life.", + "seed": 7976, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_1/index_8844_seed_7976_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.046651300182566045, + "vlm_logprob": -0.046651300182566045, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.046651300182566045, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tree frog with vibrant green skin and large bulging scarlet eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture visually rendered to resemble thick, textured oil paint layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a broad, moist green leaf with glistening water droplets and distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque swirling brushstrokes, particularly distorting the leaf veins and the frog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the frog launching from the leaf with its body unfurling in a swirl of yellow-green lines representing air currents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03890162706375122 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2889015674591064 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03890162706375122, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03890162706375122, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0856684222817421, + 0.039279792457818985, + 0.031715624034404755, + 0.23691898584365845, + 0.03464921936392784, + 0.12028063833713531, + 0.03535785526037216, + 0.07597995549440384, + 0.2537480592727661, + 0.08640139549970627 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03890162706375122 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tree frog with vibrant green skin and large bulging scarlet eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture visually rendered to resemble thick, textured oil paint layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a broad, moist green leaf with glistening water droplets and distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque swirling brushstrokes, particularly distorting the leaf veins and the frog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the frog launching from the leaf with its body unfurling in a swirl of yellow-green lines representing air currents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17989134788513184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048913478851318 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17989134788513184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17989134788513184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05698160454630852, + 0.030715974047780037, + 0.09529177844524384, + 0.08627617359161377, + 0.021331802010536194, + 0.04938851669430733, + 0.024908915162086487, + 0.060633908957242966, + 0.44837307929992676, + 0.12609823048114777 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17989134788513184 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tree frog with vibrant green skin and large bulging scarlet eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture visually rendered to resemble thick, textured oil paint layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a broad, moist green leaf with glistening water droplets and distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque swirling brushstrokes, particularly distorting the leaf veins and the frog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the frog launching from the leaf with its body unfurling in a swirl of yellow-green lines representing air currents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004639693535864353 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379639625549316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004639693535864353, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004639693535864353, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10279303789138794, + 0.05686996877193451, + 0.09232577681541443, + 0.18179534375667572, + 0.07135424017906189, + 0.06817542016506195, + 0.06317181885242462, + 0.05794784426689148, + 0.16678476333618164, + 0.13878178596496582 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004639693535864353 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tree frog with vibrant green skin and large bulging scarlet eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture visually rendered to resemble thick, textured oil paint layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a broad, moist green leaf with glistening water droplets and distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque swirling brushstrokes, particularly distorting the leaf veins and the frog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the frog launching from the leaf with its body unfurling in a swirl of yellow-green lines representing air currents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021999699529260397 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127200126647949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021999699529260397, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021999699529260397, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05870132893323898, + 0.035139117389917374, + 0.04778728261590004, + 0.03709567338228226, + 0.04453521966934204, + 0.09965380281209946, + 0.06884289532899857, + 0.1692180633544922, + 0.273929238319397, + 0.16509734094142914 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021999699529260397 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tree frog with vibrant green skin and large bulging scarlet eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture visually rendered to resemble thick, textured oil paint layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a broad, moist green leaf with glistening water droplets and distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque swirling brushstrokes, particularly distorting the leaf veins and the frog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the frog launching from the leaf with its body unfurling in a swirl of yellow-green lines representing air currents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007623862475156784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882623672485352 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007623862475156784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007623862475156784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.028262073174118996, + 0.01307282131165266, + 0.03846130892634392, + 0.07782270014286041, + 0.037077825516462326, + 0.14104601740837097, + 0.08638393878936768, + 0.08764570206403732, + 0.42836102843284607, + 0.061866555362939835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007623862475156784 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning macro close-up closely tracks a vibrantly colored tree frog, its vibrant green skin shimmering with a wet sheen, seemingly composed of layers of thick, textured oil paint. It rests on a broad, moist green leaf, its glistening water droplets and distinct veins distorted by Van Gogh-esque swirling brushstrokes, set against a blurred backdrop of dark greens and browns. The frog's large, bulging scarlet eyes fixate on its target, its pupils constricted to pinpoints of concentration. Its entire body remains absolutely still in the moment before bursting forth, its muscular hind legs tightly curled, gathering incredible power. Suddenly, it launches itself from the leaf, its entire movement captured in frenzied brushstrokes. Its body unfurls in the air, the surrounding air seemingly transformed into a visible, swirling current of yellow-green lines. The entire scene is imbued with the intense visual impact of thick oil paint and the raw dynamism of life.", + "seed": 7977, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_1/index_8844_seed_7977_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04171981853432953, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04171981853432953, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04171981853432953, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tree frog with vibrant green skin and large bulging scarlet eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture visually rendered to resemble thick, textured oil paint layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a broad, moist green leaf with glistening water droplets and distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque swirling brushstrokes, particularly distorting the leaf veins and the frog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the frog launching from the leaf with its body unfurling in a swirl of yellow-green lines representing air currents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03461571782827377 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4096157550811768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03461571782827377, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03461571782827377, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07786447554826736, + 0.032933346927165985, + 0.04609106481075287, + 0.05866805091500282, + 0.06381689012050629, + 0.1678534895181656, + 0.07548728585243225, + 0.06947264820337296, + 0.16234809160232544, + 0.24546457827091217 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03461571782827377 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tree frog with vibrant green skin and large bulging scarlet eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture visually rendered to resemble thick, textured oil paint layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a broad, moist green leaf with glistening water droplets and distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque swirling brushstrokes, particularly distorting the leaf veins and the frog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the frog launching from the leaf with its body unfurling in a swirl of yellow-green lines representing air currents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14281636476516724 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178163051605225 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14281636476516724, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14281636476516724, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08353187888860703, + 0.054812368005514145, + 0.04775218665599823, + 0.045746512711048126, + 0.14866489171981812, + 0.31940382719039917, + 0.0401090607047081, + 0.0969293937087059, + 0.07468011975288391, + 0.08836973458528519 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14281636476516724 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tree frog with vibrant green skin and large bulging scarlet eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture visually rendered to resemble thick, textured oil paint layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a broad, moist green leaf with glistening water droplets and distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque swirling brushstrokes, particularly distorting the leaf veins and the frog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the frog launching from the leaf with its body unfurling in a swirl of yellow-green lines representing air currents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018195616081357002 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018195629119873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018195616081357002, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018195616081357002, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10040551424026489, + 0.08253578096628189, + 0.05747475475072861, + 0.10532008111476898, + 0.08988064527511597, + 0.05889630317687988, + 0.065074123442173, + 0.04790465906262398, + 0.14877726137638092, + 0.24373085796833038 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018195616081357002 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tree frog with vibrant green skin and large bulging scarlet eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture visually rendered to resemble thick, textured oil paint layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a broad, moist green leaf with glistening water droplets and distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque swirling brushstrokes, particularly distorting the leaf veins and the frog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the frog launching from the leaf with its body unfurling in a swirl of yellow-green lines representing air currents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031948259565979242 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753194808959961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031948259565979242, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031948259565979242, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09902340173721313, + 0.025645194575190544, + 0.02781699411571026, + 0.024613812565803528, + 0.11534462124109268, + 0.24351154267787933, + 0.03807717189192772, + 0.11728935688734055, + 0.20783281326293945, + 0.10084506869316101 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031948259565979242 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a tree frog with vibrant green skin and large bulging scarlet eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the frog's skin texture visually rendered to resemble thick, textured oil paint layers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature a broad, moist green leaf with glistening water droplets and distinct veins?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style characterized by Van Gogh-esque swirling brushstrokes, particularly distorting the leaf veins and the frog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the frog launching from the leaf with its body unfurling in a swirl of yellow-green lines representing air currents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009776568040251732 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634776592254639 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009776568040251732, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009776568040251732, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04650801792740822, + 0.029538581147789955, + 0.03430378437042236, + 0.03416569158434868, + 0.039021797478199005, + 0.07713009417057037, + 0.049983732402324677, + 0.2361718863248825, + 0.3060368597507477, + 0.1471395194530487 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009776568040251732 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_10/index_tensor([1389, 1389])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_10/index_tensor([1389, 1389])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..40830754bdc5d70fab610e30ae13ee86046a64c3 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_10/index_tensor([1389, 1389])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "shaky, unstable, handheld camera low-angle close-up captures the chaotic city night with the raw urgency of a live news broadcast. Dazzling red and blue police lights flash frantically, smearing the rough asphalt and the surrounding landscape with unstable, rapid-fire swathes of color. At the center of the frame, a suspect in a dark hoodie is forcibly pinned to the ground, his cheek pressed against the cold ground, his expression a mixture of pain and resignation. An officer in a dark blue uniform and black tactical gloves presses his knee firmly against the suspect's back, decisively and swiftly clamping his arms behind his back. The officer's other hand precisely manipulates a pair of metal handcuffs, which gleam piercingly and intermittently in the red and blue light. With a crisp, decisive \"click,\" the cuffs' teeth snap shut, securing the suspect's struggling wrists. This moment, captured with unwavering clarity, is imbued with a raw, tense documentary quality, conveying a sense of chaos and disorder, and the urgent need for legal intervention.", + "seed": 2296, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_10/index_1389_seed_2296_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.036219647713005544, + "vlm_logprob": -0.036219647713005544, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.036219647713005544, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up with a shaky, unstable, handheld appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dazzling red and blue police lights flashing frantically and smearing the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a suspect in a dark hoodie pinned to the ground with their cheek pressed against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an officer in a dark blue uniform pressing their knee against the suspect's back and clamping their arms behind the back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the officer using metal handcuffs that gleam in the light and snap shut to secure the suspect's wrists?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020849933847784996 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.520849704742432 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020849933847784996, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020849933847784996, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23474328219890594, + 0.05615313723683357, + 0.08750028163194656, + 0.04711794853210449, + 0.1328205168247223, + 0.07160139828920364, + 0.057236120104789734, + 0.08950436115264893, + 0.08322872966527939, + 0.14009420573711395 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020849933847784996 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up with a shaky, unstable, handheld appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dazzling red and blue police lights flashing frantically and smearing the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a suspect in a dark hoodie pinned to the ground with their cheek pressed against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an officer in a dark blue uniform pressing their knee against the suspect's back and clamping their arms behind the back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the officer using metal handcuffs that gleam in the light and snap shut to secure the suspect's wrists?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026387877762317657 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651387929916382 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026387877762317657, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026387877762317657, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14100538194179535, + 0.1635669618844986, + 0.057033587247133255, + 0.0450124517083168, + 0.15307629108428955, + 0.05357818305492401, + 0.05836530402302742, + 0.044689469039440155, + 0.1089949831366539, + 0.1746772974729538 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026387877762317657 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up with a shaky, unstable, handheld appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dazzling red and blue police lights flashing frantically and smearing the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a suspect in a dark hoodie pinned to the ground with their cheek pressed against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an officer in a dark blue uniform pressing their knee against the suspect's back and clamping their arms behind the back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the officer using metal handcuffs that gleam in the light and snap shut to secure the suspect's wrists?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009801357984542847 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634801387786865 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009801357984542847, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009801357984542847, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11064054071903229, + 0.06971735507249832, + 0.08700644224882126, + 0.05558260902762413, + 0.10958150774240494, + 0.17205506563186646, + 0.08005229383707047, + 0.10677991062402725, + 0.08976908773183823, + 0.11881518363952637 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009801357984542847 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up with a shaky, unstable, handheld appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dazzling red and blue police lights flashing frantically and smearing the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a suspect in a dark hoodie pinned to the ground with their cheek pressed against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an officer in a dark blue uniform pressing their knee against the suspect's back and clamping their arms behind the back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the officer using metal handcuffs that gleam in the light and snap shut to secure the suspect's wrists?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011090303771197796 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511090278625488 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011090303771197796, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011090303771197796, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09164967387914658, + 0.07942388951778412, + 0.06015453487634659, + 0.07592805474996567, + 0.05673057958483696, + 0.13470423221588135, + 0.1513320505619049, + 0.08596311509609222, + 0.15927596390247345, + 0.10483787953853607 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011090303771197796 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up with a shaky, unstable, handheld appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dazzling red and blue police lights flashing frantically and smearing the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a suspect in a dark hoodie pinned to the ground with their cheek pressed against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an officer in a dark blue uniform pressing their knee against the suspect's back and clamping their arms behind the back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the officer using metal handcuffs that gleam in the light and snap shut to secure the suspect's wrists?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11296876519918442 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237968683242798 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11296876519918442, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11296876519918442, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09002245962619781, + 0.0449637733399868, + 0.039830464869737625, + 0.02427758276462555, + 0.1516527682542801, + 0.05065930262207985, + 0.09108062833547592, + 0.07532169669866562, + 0.2579714059829712, + 0.17421986162662506 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11296876519918442 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shaky, unstable, handheld camera low-angle close-up captures the chaotic city night with the raw urgency of a live news broadcast. Dazzling red and blue police lights flash frantically, smearing the rough asphalt and the surrounding landscape with unstable, rapid-fire swathes of color. At the center of the frame, a suspect in a dark hoodie is forcibly pinned to the ground, his cheek pressed against the cold ground, his expression a mixture of pain and resignation. An officer in a dark blue uniform and black tactical gloves presses his knee firmly against the suspect's back, decisively and swiftly clamping his arms behind his back. The officer's other hand precisely manipulates a pair of metal handcuffs, which gleam piercingly and intermittently in the red and blue light. With a crisp, decisive \"click,\" the cuffs' teeth snap shut, securing the suspect's struggling wrists. This moment, captured with unwavering clarity, is imbued with a raw, tense documentary quality, conveying a sense of chaos and disorder, and the urgent need for legal intervention.", + "seed": 2297, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_10/index_1389_seed_2297_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04796509426087141, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04796509426087141, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04796509426087141, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up with a shaky, unstable, handheld appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dazzling red and blue police lights flashing frantically and smearing the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a suspect in a dark hoodie pinned to the ground with their cheek pressed against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an officer in a dark blue uniform pressing their knee against the suspect's back and clamping their arms behind the back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the officer using metal handcuffs that gleam in the light and snap shut to secure the suspect's wrists?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026103032752871513 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7761030197143555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026103032752871513, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026103032752871513, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10964460670948029, + 0.07112464308738708, + 0.0580168291926384, + 0.31431061029434204, + 0.14444690942764282, + 0.02802048623561859, + 0.027283623814582825, + 0.1448889672756195, + 0.03356067091226578, + 0.06870263814926147 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026103032752871513 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up with a shaky, unstable, handheld appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dazzling red and blue police lights flashing frantically and smearing the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a suspect in a dark hoodie pinned to the ground with their cheek pressed against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an officer in a dark blue uniform pressing their knee against the suspect's back and clamping their arms behind the back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the officer using metal handcuffs that gleam in the light and snap shut to secure the suspect's wrists?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04869906231760979 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048699140548706 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04869906231760979, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04869906231760979, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18771159648895264, + 0.12250292301177979, + 0.0815993919968605, + 0.14910496771335602, + 0.16088038682937622, + 0.056463416665792465, + 0.026300504803657532, + 0.12248024344444275, + 0.0265339482575655, + 0.06642260402441025 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04869906231760979 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up with a shaky, unstable, handheld appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dazzling red and blue police lights flashing frantically and smearing the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a suspect in a dark hoodie pinned to the ground with their cheek pressed against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an officer in a dark blue uniform pressing their knee against the suspect's back and clamping their arms behind the back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the officer using metal handcuffs that gleam in the light and snap shut to secure the suspect's wrists?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011096552014350891 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511096477508545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011096552014350891, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011096552014350891, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06965094804763794, + 0.08039840310811996, + 0.03493226692080498, + 0.2528691291809082, + 0.14156709611415863, + 0.16151952743530273, + 0.1485360711812973, + 0.03646838292479515, + 0.03694992512464523, + 0.03710826113820076 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011096552014350891 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up with a shaky, unstable, handheld appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dazzling red and blue police lights flashing frantically and smearing the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a suspect in a dark hoodie pinned to the ground with their cheek pressed against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an officer in a dark blue uniform pressing their knee against the suspect's back and clamping their arms behind the back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the officer using metal handcuffs that gleam in the light and snap shut to secure the suspect's wrists?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011089478619396687 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511089324951172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011089478619396687, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011089478619396687, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11232016235589981, + 0.08001647144556046, + 0.0485592857003212, + 0.13724984228610992, + 0.07894724607467651, + 0.05411278083920479, + 0.09340890496969223, + 0.18331968784332275, + 0.12736675143241882, + 0.084698885679245 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011089478619396687 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up with a shaky, unstable, handheld appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dazzling red and blue police lights flashing frantically and smearing the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a suspect in a dark hoodie pinned to the ground with their cheek pressed against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an officer in a dark blue uniform pressing their knee against the suspect's back and clamping their arms behind the back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the officer using metal handcuffs that gleam in the light and snap shut to secure the suspect's wrists?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14283734560012817 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178372859954834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14283734560012817, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14283734560012817, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.050153326243162155, + 0.028029434382915497, + 0.028028074651956558, + 0.38305553793907166, + 0.05261480435729027, + 0.025324812158942223, + 0.032402608543634415, + 0.18335485458374023, + 0.13132619857788086, + 0.08571035414934158 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14283734560012817 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shaky, unstable, handheld camera low-angle close-up captures the chaotic city night with the raw urgency of a live news broadcast. Dazzling red and blue police lights flash frantically, smearing the rough asphalt and the surrounding landscape with unstable, rapid-fire swathes of color. At the center of the frame, a suspect in a dark hoodie is forcibly pinned to the ground, his cheek pressed against the cold ground, his expression a mixture of pain and resignation. An officer in a dark blue uniform and black tactical gloves presses his knee firmly against the suspect's back, decisively and swiftly clamping his arms behind his back. The officer's other hand precisely manipulates a pair of metal handcuffs, which gleam piercingly and intermittently in the red and blue light. With a crisp, decisive \"click,\" the cuffs' teeth snap shut, securing the suspect's struggling wrists. This moment, captured with unwavering clarity, is imbued with a raw, tense documentary quality, conveying a sense of chaos and disorder, and the urgent need for legal intervention.", + "seed": 2298, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_10/index_1389_seed_2298_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.023960230499505998, + "vlm_logprob": -0.023960230499505998, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.023960230499505998, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up with a shaky, unstable, handheld appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dazzling red and blue police lights flashing frantically and smearing the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a suspect in a dark hoodie pinned to the ground with their cheek pressed against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an officer in a dark blue uniform pressing their knee against the suspect's back and clamping their arms behind the back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the officer using metal handcuffs that gleam in the light and snap shut to secure the suspect's wrists?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008451174013316631 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.258450984954834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008451174013316631, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008451174013316631, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1771501749753952, + 0.09852983057498932, + 0.08893326669931412, + 0.06847751885652542, + 0.056503843516111374, + 0.10446173697710037, + 0.09856415539979935, + 0.10060587525367737, + 0.07565849274396896, + 0.13111507892608643 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008451174013316631 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up with a shaky, unstable, handheld appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dazzling red and blue police lights flashing frantically and smearing the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a suspect in a dark hoodie pinned to the ground with their cheek pressed against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an officer in a dark blue uniform pressing their knee against the suspect's back and clamping their arms behind the back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the officer using metal handcuffs that gleam in the light and snap shut to secure the suspect's wrists?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00865730457007885 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758657455444336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00865730457007885, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00865730457007885, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17690251767635345, + 0.06867232918739319, + 0.05697709694504738, + 0.1335001289844513, + 0.05091474577784538, + 0.07513212412595749, + 0.05050119385123253, + 0.17951233685016632, + 0.04640979692339897, + 0.1614777147769928 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00865730457007885 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up with a shaky, unstable, handheld appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dazzling red and blue police lights flashing frantically and smearing the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a suspect in a dark hoodie pinned to the ground with their cheek pressed against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an officer in a dark blue uniform pressing their knee against the suspect's back and clamping their arms behind the back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the officer using metal handcuffs that gleam in the light and snap shut to secure the suspect's wrists?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007644092198461294 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882644176483154 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007644092198461294, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007644092198461294, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18793612718582153, + 0.05881873145699501, + 0.06307599693536758, + 0.05947548523545265, + 0.048735834658145905, + 0.0889073982834816, + 0.05373011529445648, + 0.2898510992527008, + 0.04027547687292099, + 0.10919379442930222 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007644092198461294 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up with a shaky, unstable, handheld appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dazzling red and blue police lights flashing frantically and smearing the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a suspect in a dark hoodie pinned to the ground with their cheek pressed against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an officer in a dark blue uniform pressing their knee against the suspect's back and clamping their arms behind the back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the officer using metal handcuffs that gleam in the light and snap shut to secure the suspect's wrists?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005959717091172934 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130959510803223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005959717091172934, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005959717091172934, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13645030558109283, + 0.08960475772619247, + 0.06567797809839249, + 0.03674071654677391, + 0.08121351897716522, + 0.11482784152030945, + 0.06337863206863403, + 0.15836423635482788, + 0.09772803634405136, + 0.15601392090320587 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005959717091172934 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up with a shaky, unstable, handheld appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dazzling red and blue police lights flashing frantically and smearing the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a suspect in a dark hoodie pinned to the ground with their cheek pressed against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an officer in a dark blue uniform pressing their knee against the suspect's back and clamping their arms behind the back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the officer using metal handcuffs that gleam in the light and snap shut to secure the suspect's wrists?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08908886462450027 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640889167785645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08908886462450027, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08908886462450027, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07136089354753494, + 0.053910993039608, + 0.03785885125398636, + 0.060706935822963715, + 0.07709896564483643, + 0.12563569843769073, + 0.07810340821743011, + 0.25244444608688354, + 0.16396406292915344, + 0.07891576737165451 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08908886462450027 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shaky, unstable, handheld camera low-angle close-up captures the chaotic city night with the raw urgency of a live news broadcast. Dazzling red and blue police lights flash frantically, smearing the rough asphalt and the surrounding landscape with unstable, rapid-fire swathes of color. At the center of the frame, a suspect in a dark hoodie is forcibly pinned to the ground, his cheek pressed against the cold ground, his expression a mixture of pain and resignation. An officer in a dark blue uniform and black tactical gloves presses his knee firmly against the suspect's back, decisively and swiftly clamping his arms behind his back. The officer's other hand precisely manipulates a pair of metal handcuffs, which gleam piercingly and intermittently in the red and blue light. With a crisp, decisive \"click,\" the cuffs' teeth snap shut, securing the suspect's struggling wrists. This moment, captured with unwavering clarity, is imbued with a raw, tense documentary quality, conveying a sense of chaos and disorder, and the urgent need for legal intervention.", + "seed": 2299, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_10/index_1389_seed_2299_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.029092776775360107, + "vlm_logprob": -0.029092776775360107, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.029092776775360107, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up with a shaky, unstable, handheld appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dazzling red and blue police lights flashing frantically and smearing the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a suspect in a dark hoodie pinned to the ground with their cheek pressed against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an officer in a dark blue uniform pressing their knee against the suspect's back and clamping their arms behind the back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the officer using metal handcuffs that gleam in the light and snap shut to secure the suspect's wrists?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013586314395070076 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.138586521148682 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013586314395070076, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013586314395070076, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12482493370771408, + 0.09453798085451126, + 0.07325340807437897, + 0.03441844508051872, + 0.03699177876114845, + 0.04223974421620369, + 0.36572933197021484, + 0.09060302376747131, + 0.10571714490652084, + 0.03168419748544693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013586314395070076 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up with a shaky, unstable, handheld appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dazzling red and blue police lights flashing frantically and smearing the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a suspect in a dark hoodie pinned to the ground with their cheek pressed against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an officer in a dark blue uniform pressing their knee against the suspect's back and clamping their arms behind the back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the officer using metal handcuffs that gleam in the light and snap shut to secure the suspect's wrists?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014221156015992165 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26422119140625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014221156015992165, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014221156015992165, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26580607891082764, + 0.08682055026292801, + 0.05264465510845184, + 0.07920152693986893, + 0.06194280460476875, + 0.11148271709680557, + 0.08772798627614975, + 0.14055825769901276, + 0.06424131244421005, + 0.04957401007413864 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014221156015992165 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up with a shaky, unstable, handheld appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dazzling red and blue police lights flashing frantically and smearing the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a suspect in a dark hoodie pinned to the ground with their cheek pressed against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an officer in a dark blue uniform pressing their knee against the suspect's back and clamping their arms behind the back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the officer using metal handcuffs that gleam in the light and snap shut to secure the suspect's wrists?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008654586039483547 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758654594421387 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008654586039483547, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008654586039483547, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1047515794634819, + 0.058085836470127106, + 0.0980488508939743, + 0.10466137528419495, + 0.0533171147108078, + 0.22516770660877228, + 0.24045884609222412, + 0.05926528945565224, + 0.03257052227854729, + 0.023672815412282944 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008654586039483547 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up with a shaky, unstable, handheld appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dazzling red and blue police lights flashing frantically and smearing the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a suspect in a dark hoodie pinned to the ground with their cheek pressed against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an officer in a dark blue uniform pressing their knee against the suspect's back and clamping their arms behind the back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the officer using metal handcuffs that gleam in the light and snap shut to secure the suspect's wrists?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008651395328342915 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758651256561279 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008651395328342915, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008651395328342915, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1666487753391266, + 0.0502888523042202, + 0.08593833446502686, + 0.08056359738111496, + 0.15790210664272308, + 0.12498126924037933, + 0.18993066251277924, + 0.07046032696962357, + 0.03183811530470848, + 0.041447997093200684 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008651395328342915 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle close-up with a shaky, unstable, handheld appearance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are dazzling red and blue police lights flashing frantically and smearing the asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a suspect in a dark hoodie pinned to the ground with their cheek pressed against the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is an officer in a dark blue uniform pressing their knee against the suspect's back and clamping their arms behind the back?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the officer using metal handcuffs that gleam in the light and snap shut to secure the suspect's wrists?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10035043209791183 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503503799438477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10035043209791183, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10035043209791183, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08755814284086227, + 0.07985273748636246, + 0.15645937621593475, + 0.022230766713619232, + 0.0848856270313263, + 0.07103108614683151, + 0.3036949038505554, + 0.0626978725194931, + 0.0697707012295723, + 0.061818741261959076 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10035043209791183 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_11/index_tensor([3089, 3089])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_11/index_tensor([3089, 3089])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c5e633fab949c57802850364b322dca02c4112ba --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_11/index_tensor([3089, 3089])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle tracking shot sweeps above cracked asphalt, perfectly capturing the scene of a Formula One car blazing down a desolate stretch of Route 66, hurtling towards the horizon. The car's chassis, a masterpiece of sleek, fiery-red carbon fiber, reflects the vibrant hue of the setting sun, its intricate aerodynamic wings and low-slung silhouette cutting sharply through the desert air. Its wide, sleek tires appear dazzling on the weathered asphalt, and visible heat haze shimmers from the engine exhaust as it slices through the landscape. The scene is set against the vast, arid expanse of the American Southwest, with towering cacti and distant mesas rendered in stark, elongated silhouettes. The sky is a stunning gradient of deep orange, magenta, and violet, and the sunset's low, golden light casts a long, twisting shadow over the car, creating a surreal and thrilling atmosphere where ultimate speed meets epic natural beauty on the open road to Las Vegas.", + "seed": 15014, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_11/index_3089_seed_15014_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.14060619994997978, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14060619994997978, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14060619994997978, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Formula One car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's chassis red and made of carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving at high speed towards the horizon on cracked asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desert landscape with cacti, mesas, and a sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10191938281059265 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.351919412612915 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10191938281059265, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10191938281059265, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15691518783569336, + 0.07024187594652176, + 0.1528196632862091, + 0.12507441639900208, + 0.05948132649064064, + 0.10656934231519699, + 0.13359390199184418, + 0.03912336379289627, + 0.04499168321490288, + 0.11118922382593155 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10191938281059265 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Formula One car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's chassis red and made of carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving at high speed towards the horizon on cracked asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desert landscape with cacti, mesas, and a sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34892335534095764 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2239233255386353 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34892335534095764, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34892335534095764, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14854489266872406, + 0.06559417396783829, + 0.1602173149585724, + 0.09258825331926346, + 0.0625782236456871, + 0.09944534301757812, + 0.11884558945894241, + 0.07103424519300461, + 0.104337178170681, + 0.07681476324796677 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34892335534095764 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Formula One car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's chassis red and made of carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving at high speed towards the horizon on cracked asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desert landscape with cacti, mesas, and a sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20156137645244598 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015613317489624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20156137645244598, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20156137645244598, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19673606753349304, + 0.07794059067964554, + 0.12921889126300812, + 0.20499876141548157, + 0.03850024193525314, + 0.04855114966630936, + 0.043990202248096466, + 0.06682516634464264, + 0.15003371238708496, + 0.04320526868104935 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20156137645244598 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Formula One car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's chassis red and made of carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving at high speed towards the horizon on cracked asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desert landscape with cacti, mesas, and a sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03808823600411415 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288088321685791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03808823600411415, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03808823600411415, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12825492024421692, + 0.062086451798677444, + 0.11449991911649704, + 0.20167315006256104, + 0.06053617596626282, + 0.06633061915636063, + 0.06252577155828476, + 0.1140303909778595, + 0.14805737137794495, + 0.0420052707195282 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03808823600411415 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Formula One car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's chassis red and made of carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving at high speed towards the horizon on cracked asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desert landscape with cacti, mesas, and a sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012538649141788483 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387538433074951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012538649141788483, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012538649141788483, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2511294186115265, + 0.08469321578741074, + 0.22504697740077972, + 0.09673483669757843, + 0.13888302445411682, + 0.024728573858737946, + 0.0354124940931797, + 0.05764560028910637, + 0.03661491721868515, + 0.049110934138298035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012538649141788483 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle tracking shot sweeps above cracked asphalt, perfectly capturing the scene of a Formula One car blazing down a desolate stretch of Route 66, hurtling towards the horizon. The car's chassis, a masterpiece of sleek, fiery-red carbon fiber, reflects the vibrant hue of the setting sun, its intricate aerodynamic wings and low-slung silhouette cutting sharply through the desert air. Its wide, sleek tires appear dazzling on the weathered asphalt, and visible heat haze shimmers from the engine exhaust as it slices through the landscape. The scene is set against the vast, arid expanse of the American Southwest, with towering cacti and distant mesas rendered in stark, elongated silhouettes. The sky is a stunning gradient of deep orange, magenta, and violet, and the sunset's low, golden light casts a long, twisting shadow over the car, creating a surreal and thrilling atmosphere where ultimate speed meets epic natural beauty on the open road to Las Vegas.", + "seed": 15015, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_11/index_3089_seed_15015_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.1447744093835354, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1447744093835354, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1447744093835354, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Formula One car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's chassis red and made of carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving at high speed towards the horizon on cracked asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desert landscape with cacti, mesas, and a sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2838521897792816 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.408852219581604 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2838521897792816, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2838521897792816, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6292122602462769, + 0.10802488774061203, + 0.03481869399547577, + 0.027038294821977615, + 0.04917065426707268, + 0.047114115208387375, + 0.021289022639393806, + 0.023379622027277946, + 0.020933818072080612, + 0.03901861608028412 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2838521897792816 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Formula One car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's chassis red and made of carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving at high speed towards the horizon on cracked asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desert landscape with cacti, mesas, and a sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3489626348018646 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.223962664604187 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3489626348018646, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3489626348018646, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.46075326204299927, + 0.0713604986667633, + 0.04827047139406204, + 0.050391413271427155, + 0.04390507563948631, + 0.05661959573626518, + 0.029798824340105057, + 0.029319578781723976, + 0.02263433113694191, + 0.18694700300693512 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3489626348018646 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Formula One car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's chassis red and made of carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving at high speed towards the horizon on cracked asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desert landscape with cacti, mesas, and a sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054948993027210236 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299490451812744 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054948993027210236, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054948993027210236, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23340962827205658, + 0.11439643055200577, + 0.06951101869344711, + 0.20215459167957306, + 0.05809886381030083, + 0.05553993582725525, + 0.03920910879969597, + 0.038239844143390656, + 0.056794796139001846, + 0.13264583051204681 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054948993027210236 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Formula One car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's chassis red and made of carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving at high speed towards the horizon on cracked asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desert landscape with cacti, mesas, and a sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02633284218609333 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513328552246094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02633284218609333, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02633284218609333, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11126967519521713, + 0.08707428723573685, + 0.03856319561600685, + 0.07848763465881348, + 0.06402954459190369, + 0.03665008768439293, + 0.0357772596180439, + 0.05304107815027237, + 0.05454683676362038, + 0.44056037068367004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02633284218609333 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Formula One car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's chassis red and made of carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving at high speed towards the horizon on cracked asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desert landscape with cacti, mesas, and a sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00977538712322712 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634775161743164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00977538712322712, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00977538712322712, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25123143196105957, + 0.0678914487361908, + 0.10457886010408401, + 0.1873636096715927, + 0.21494166553020477, + 0.04875875636935234, + 0.021627139300107956, + 0.02066732570528984, + 0.02417651377618313, + 0.05876326933503151 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00977538712322712 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle tracking shot sweeps above cracked asphalt, perfectly capturing the scene of a Formula One car blazing down a desolate stretch of Route 66, hurtling towards the horizon. The car's chassis, a masterpiece of sleek, fiery-red carbon fiber, reflects the vibrant hue of the setting sun, its intricate aerodynamic wings and low-slung silhouette cutting sharply through the desert air. Its wide, sleek tires appear dazzling on the weathered asphalt, and visible heat haze shimmers from the engine exhaust as it slices through the landscape. The scene is set against the vast, arid expanse of the American Southwest, with towering cacti and distant mesas rendered in stark, elongated silhouettes. The sky is a stunning gradient of deep orange, magenta, and violet, and the sunset's low, golden light casts a long, twisting shadow over the car, creating a surreal and thrilling atmosphere where ultimate speed meets epic natural beauty on the open road to Las Vegas.", + "seed": 15016, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_11/index_3089_seed_15016_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.24216823130846024, + "vlm_logprob": -0.24216823130846024, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.24216823130846024, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Formula One car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's chassis red and made of carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving at high speed towards the horizon on cracked asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desert landscape with cacti, mesas, and a sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5784968137741089 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8284968137741089 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5784968137741089, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5784968137741089, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4537575840950012, + 0.2816638946533203, + 0.08670466393232346, + 0.013205592520534992, + 0.01605859212577343, + 0.008310696110129356, + 0.06568177044391632, + 0.02407064102590084, + 0.035338908433914185, + 0.015207632444798946 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5784968137741089 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Formula One car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's chassis red and made of carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving at high speed towards the horizon on cracked asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desert landscape with cacti, mesas, and a sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5236292481422424 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8986292481422424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5236292481422424, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5236292481422424, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5151181817054749, + 0.1841774433851242, + 0.08495144546031952, + 0.014041632413864136, + 0.024706928059458733, + 0.08217155188322067, + 0.0254132691770792, + 0.02149747684597969, + 0.017682751640677452, + 0.030239367857575417 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5236292481422424 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Formula One car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's chassis red and made of carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving at high speed towards the horizon on cracked asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desert landscape with cacti, mesas, and a sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048673853278160095 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486738681793213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048673853278160095, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048673853278160095, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5473525524139404, + 0.03981740027666092, + 0.04402758181095123, + 0.07118804007768631, + 0.103783018887043, + 0.02750135213136673, + 0.045959290117025375, + 0.06929956376552582, + 0.023336494341492653, + 0.02773473970592022 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048673853278160095 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Formula One car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's chassis red and made of carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving at high speed towards the horizon on cracked asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desert landscape with cacti, mesas, and a sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02633853256702423 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651338577270508 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02633853256702423, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02633853256702423, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42819347977638245, + 0.2462076097726822, + 0.03485233709216118, + 0.0400528758764267, + 0.0360826812684536, + 0.03358404338359833, + 0.062179528176784515, + 0.04386432468891144, + 0.05577850714325905, + 0.0192046407610178 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02633853256702423 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Formula One car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's chassis red and made of carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving at high speed towards the horizon on cracked asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desert landscape with cacti, mesas, and a sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370270878076553 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087026119232178 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370270878076553, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370270878076553, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7433160543441772, + 0.11365117132663727, + 0.008726450614631176, + 0.004905523266643286, + 0.019898487254977226, + 0.0182675551623106, + 0.05496836453676224, + 0.009122295305132866, + 0.015178668312728405, + 0.011965415440499783 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370270878076553 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle tracking shot sweeps above cracked asphalt, perfectly capturing the scene of a Formula One car blazing down a desolate stretch of Route 66, hurtling towards the horizon. The car's chassis, a masterpiece of sleek, fiery-red carbon fiber, reflects the vibrant hue of the setting sun, its intricate aerodynamic wings and low-slung silhouette cutting sharply through the desert air. Its wide, sleek tires appear dazzling on the weathered asphalt, and visible heat haze shimmers from the engine exhaust as it slices through the landscape. The scene is set against the vast, arid expanse of the American Southwest, with towering cacti and distant mesas rendered in stark, elongated silhouettes. The sky is a stunning gradient of deep orange, magenta, and violet, and the sunset's low, golden light casts a long, twisting shadow over the car, creating a surreal and thrilling atmosphere where ultimate speed meets epic natural beauty on the open road to Las Vegas.", + "seed": 15017, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_11/index_3089_seed_15017_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.09820798365399241, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09820798365399241, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09820798365399241, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Formula One car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's chassis red and made of carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving at high speed towards the horizon on cracked asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desert landscape with cacti, mesas, and a sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05105695128440857 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0510568618774414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05105695128440857, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05105695128440857, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10352984070777893, + 0.5077990889549255, + 0.044161368161439896, + 0.05838729813694954, + 0.10261130332946777, + 0.030602775514125824, + 0.04799046367406845, + 0.0220698993653059, + 0.04887375235557556, + 0.03397425264120102 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05105695128440857 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Formula One car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's chassis red and made of carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving at high speed towards the horizon on cracked asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desert landscape with cacti, mesas, and a sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3873745799064636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1373746395111084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3873745799064636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7500000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3873745799064636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.031391337513923645, + 0.7590233683586121, + 0.025492532178759575, + 0.02556545101106167, + 0.04619128257036209, + 0.012565743178129196, + 0.018985167145729065, + 0.03462287783622742, + 0.024955280125141144, + 0.021206937730312347 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3873745799064636 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Formula One car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's chassis red and made of carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving at high speed towards the horizon on cracked asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desert landscape with cacti, mesas, and a sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029798205941915512 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297982692718506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029798205941915512, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029798205941915512, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06864042580127716, + 0.5917651057243347, + 0.05951501801609993, + 0.013432662934064865, + 0.01672283187508583, + 0.03480225056409836, + 0.035407405346632004, + 0.03206417337059975, + 0.12932121753692627, + 0.018328839913010597 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029798205941915512 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Formula One car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's chassis red and made of carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving at high speed towards the horizon on cracked asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desert landscape with cacti, mesas, and a sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018176183104515076 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018176078796387 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018176183104515076, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018176183104515076, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09051923453807831, + 0.5364880561828613, + 0.0498163104057312, + 0.029965495690703392, + 0.03911298140883446, + 0.0974404588341713, + 0.01924862526357174, + 0.08027756214141846, + 0.04841237887740135, + 0.008718856610357761 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018176183104515076 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Formula One car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car's chassis red and made of carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving at high speed towards the horizon on cracked asphalt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene include a low-angle tracking shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a desert landscape with cacti, mesas, and a sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004633998032659292 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379633903503418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004633998032659292, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004633998032659292, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.020792780444025993, + 0.8116186261177063, + 0.06487444043159485, + 0.010315101593732834, + 0.020139921456575394, + 0.007728722877800465, + 0.00661225663498044, + 0.017876438796520233, + 0.03358083218336105, + 0.006460953038185835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004633998032659292 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_12/index_tensor([4942, 4942])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_12/index_tensor([4942, 4942])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b92a6fbb5ec95a07d045dcfc8b8db2e4893845d1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_12/index_tensor([4942, 4942])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium shot, filmed in ethereal super-slow motion, smoothly pans sideways, tracking a cuddly, happy Corgi playing in a lush green park at the height of a warm sunset. The dog has a plump, fluffy tail, bright, expressive large black eyes that sparkle with joy, and a classic reddish-brown and white coat that appears incredibly soft, each strand catching the light. The low-hanging sun casts a brilliant golden glow across the scene, creating a bright rim light around the dog's silhouette and painting the background sky a stunning gradient of vibrant orange and soft pink. The Corgi happily leaps across the manicured grass, its mouth open in a blissful canine smile, tongue slightly drooping. Each leap is a graceful movement; its short, powerful legs lift off the ground, its long body arcs through the air, and its large, triangular ears flap with exaggerated, balletic grace. In the background, the leaves of mature trees sway gently in the warm breeze. The super slow-motion effect emphasizes every micro-movement, from the kick of individual blades of grass to the gentle sway of their tails, making the pure, unadulterated joy of each jump pause for a moment and creating a tranquil and welcoming atmosphere.", + "seed": 11388, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_12/index_4942_seed_11388_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.033644920121878384, + "vlm_logprob": -0.033644920121878384, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.049999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.033644920121878384, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Corgi with a reddish-brown and white coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush green park with manicured grass and mature trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a warm sunset with a golden glow and a sky gradient of orange and pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the Corgi perform a leaping motion across the grass with its body arcing through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan sideways to track the dog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018812330439686775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01881217956543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018812330439686775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018812330439686775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09298408776521683, + 0.03572413697838783, + 0.3234526515007019, + 0.015220887959003448, + 0.05284354090690613, + 0.021101366728544235, + 0.013172406703233719, + 0.19019131362438202, + 0.20156042277812958, + 0.05374915525317192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018812330439686775 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Corgi with a reddish-brown and white coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush green park with manicured grass and mature trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a warm sunset with a golden glow and a sky gradient of orange and pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the Corgi perform a leaping motion across the grass with its body arcing through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan sideways to track the dog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005255692172795534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255255699157715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005255692172795534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005255692172795534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5184692740440369, + 0.16093137860298157, + 0.04521667957305908, + 0.04774341732263565, + 0.027174267917871475, + 0.016502000391483307, + 0.023262646049261093, + 0.09485562890768051, + 0.03671856224536896, + 0.029126135632395744 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005255692172795534 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Corgi with a reddish-brown and white coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush green park with manicured grass and mature trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a warm sunset with a golden glow and a sky gradient of orange and pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the Corgi perform a leaping motion across the grass with its body arcing through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan sideways to track the dog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031911423429846764 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753190994262695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031911423429846764, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031911423429846764, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20449523627758026, + 0.05687134340405464, + 0.051796380430459976, + 0.02475915662944317, + 0.0301396194845438, + 0.023793691769242287, + 0.0695987194776535, + 0.15889063477516174, + 0.29684358835220337, + 0.08281166851520538 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031911423429846764 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Corgi with a reddish-brown and white coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush green park with manicured grass and mature trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a warm sunset with a golden glow and a sky gradient of orange and pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the Corgi perform a leaping motion across the grass with its body arcing through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan sideways to track the dog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06202016398310661 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120200634002686 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06202016398310661, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06202016398310661, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26737529039382935, + 0.2092141956090927, + 0.09332457184791565, + 0.03236479312181473, + 0.06363343447446823, + 0.052680522203445435, + 0.10864228010177612, + 0.04023098573088646, + 0.10314710438251495, + 0.02938685193657875 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06202016398310661 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Corgi with a reddish-brown and white coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush green park with manicured grass and mature trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a warm sunset with a golden glow and a sky gradient of orange and pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the Corgi perform a leaping motion across the grass with its body arcing through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan sideways to track the dog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07894527167081833 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789451599121094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07894527167081833, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07894527167081833, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1902562379837036, + 0.15159602463245392, + 0.10053163021802902, + 0.07384707033634186, + 0.11290635913610458, + 0.02735885977745056, + 0.05406002700328827, + 0.055539634078741074, + 0.18706348538398743, + 0.04684067517518997 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07894527167081833 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, filmed in ethereal super-slow motion, smoothly pans sideways, tracking a cuddly, happy Corgi playing in a lush green park at the height of a warm sunset. The dog has a plump, fluffy tail, bright, expressive large black eyes that sparkle with joy, and a classic reddish-brown and white coat that appears incredibly soft, each strand catching the light. The low-hanging sun casts a brilliant golden glow across the scene, creating a bright rim light around the dog's silhouette and painting the background sky a stunning gradient of vibrant orange and soft pink. The Corgi happily leaps across the manicured grass, its mouth open in a blissful canine smile, tongue slightly drooping. Each leap is a graceful movement; its short, powerful legs lift off the ground, its long body arcs through the air, and its large, triangular ears flap with exaggerated, balletic grace. In the background, the leaves of mature trees sway gently in the warm breeze. The super slow-motion effect emphasizes every micro-movement, from the kick of individual blades of grass to the gentle sway of their tails, making the pure, unadulterated joy of each jump pause for a moment and creating a tranquil and welcoming atmosphere.", + "seed": 11389, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_12/index_4942_seed_11389_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.4463432965800166, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4463432965800166, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4463432965800166, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Corgi with a reddish-brown and white coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush green park with manicured grass and mature trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a warm sunset with a golden glow and a sky gradient of orange and pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the Corgi perform a leaping motion across the grass with its body arcing through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan sideways to track the dog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.030349524691700935 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5303494930267334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.030349524691700935, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.030349524691700935, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5094137787818909, + 0.04031297191977501, + 0.1105085238814354, + 0.030771594494581223, + 0.01542761828750372, + 0.07730414718389511, + 0.044138792902231216, + 0.019616790115833282, + 0.06407895684242249, + 0.08842682093381882 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.030349524691700935 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Corgi with a reddish-brown and white coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush green park with manicured grass and mature trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a warm sunset with a golden glow and a sky gradient of orange and pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the Corgi perform a leaping motion across the grass with its body arcing through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan sideways to track the dog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103419780731201 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603420078754425 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.9103419780731201, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -1.9103419780731201, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26536139845848083, + 0.19744867086410522, + 0.04895125702023506, + 0.1001928299665451, + 0.016235727816820145, + 0.05394866317510605, + 0.06329140067100525, + 0.033768776804208755, + 0.024129565805196762, + 0.19667160511016846 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.9103419780731201 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Corgi with a reddish-brown and white coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush green park with manicured grass and mature trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a warm sunset with a golden glow and a sky gradient of orange and pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the Corgi perform a leaping motion across the grass with its body arcing through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan sideways to track the dog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012563842348754406 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387563705444336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012563842348754406, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012563842348754406, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2801738381385803, + 0.20881357789039612, + 0.047873709350824356, + 0.13643723726272583, + 0.022099651396274567, + 0.05172246694564819, + 0.05185233801603317, + 0.0388094037771225, + 0.01980653777718544, + 0.1424112766981125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012563842348754406 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Corgi with a reddish-brown and white coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush green park with manicured grass and mature trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a warm sunset with a golden glow and a sky gradient of orange and pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the Corgi perform a leaping motion across the grass with its body arcing through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan sideways to track the dog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026348749175667763 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651348829269409 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026348749175667763, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026348749175667763, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30512189865112305, + 0.12774617969989777, + 0.04871816188097, + 0.06725822389125824, + 0.023788562044501305, + 0.05129541829228401, + 0.1128477230668068, + 0.0747843086719513, + 0.020944660529494286, + 0.16749484837055206 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026348749175667763 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Corgi with a reddish-brown and white coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush green park with manicured grass and mature trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a warm sunset with a golden glow and a sky gradient of orange and pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the Corgi perform a leaping motion across the grass with its body arcing through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan sideways to track the dog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25211238861083984 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021123886108398 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25211238861083984, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25211238861083984, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5012528896331787, + 0.08456441015005112, + 0.04851965233683586, + 0.052933305501937866, + 0.039816904813051224, + 0.07656332105398178, + 0.025952810421586037, + 0.04364663362503052, + 0.03031979128718376, + 0.09643027931451797 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25211238861083984 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, filmed in ethereal super-slow motion, smoothly pans sideways, tracking a cuddly, happy Corgi playing in a lush green park at the height of a warm sunset. The dog has a plump, fluffy tail, bright, expressive large black eyes that sparkle with joy, and a classic reddish-brown and white coat that appears incredibly soft, each strand catching the light. The low-hanging sun casts a brilliant golden glow across the scene, creating a bright rim light around the dog's silhouette and painting the background sky a stunning gradient of vibrant orange and soft pink. The Corgi happily leaps across the manicured grass, its mouth open in a blissful canine smile, tongue slightly drooping. Each leap is a graceful movement; its short, powerful legs lift off the ground, its long body arcs through the air, and its large, triangular ears flap with exaggerated, balletic grace. In the background, the leaves of mature trees sway gently in the warm breeze. The super slow-motion effect emphasizes every micro-movement, from the kick of individual blades of grass to the gentle sway of their tails, making the pure, unadulterated joy of each jump pause for a moment and creating a tranquil and welcoming atmosphere.", + "seed": 11390, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_12/index_4942_seed_11390_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03806405449286103, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03806405449286103, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03806405449286103, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Corgi with a reddish-brown and white coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush green park with manicured grass and mature trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a warm sunset with a golden glow and a sky gradient of orange and pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the Corgi perform a leaping motion across the grass with its body arcing through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan sideways to track the dog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023832866922020912 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7738327980041504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023832866922020912, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023832866922020912, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.46060240268707275, + 0.03800487145781517, + 0.013596526347100735, + 0.0541105642914772, + 0.10615530610084534, + 0.025132562965154648, + 0.14934025704860687, + 0.053297024220228195, + 0.02402597665786743, + 0.0757344514131546 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023832866922020912 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Corgi with a reddish-brown and white coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush green park with manicured grass and mature trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a warm sunset with a golden glow and a sky gradient of orange and pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the Corgi perform a leaping motion across the grass with its body arcing through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan sideways to track the dog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029809776693582535 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298097133636475 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029809776693582535, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029809776693582535, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5636661052703857, + 0.05392730236053467, + 0.010960815474390984, + 0.037049923092126846, + 0.1451634019613266, + 0.07190902531147003, + 0.031118011102080345, + 0.03295188024640083, + 0.016239391639828682, + 0.03701404109597206 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029809776693582535 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Corgi with a reddish-brown and white coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush green park with manicured grass and mature trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a warm sunset with a golden glow and a sky gradient of orange and pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the Corgi perform a leaping motion across the grass with its body arcing through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan sideways to track the dog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046369642950594425 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379636764526367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046369642950594425, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046369642950594425, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6284490823745728, + 0.019575677812099457, + 0.010794410482048988, + 0.016459017992019653, + 0.07940175384283066, + 0.033655282109975815, + 0.08695677667856216, + 0.06576892733573914, + 0.026156403124332428, + 0.0327826589345932 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046369642950594425 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Corgi with a reddish-brown and white coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush green park with manicured grass and mature trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a warm sunset with a golden glow and a sky gradient of orange and pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the Corgi perform a leaping motion across the grass with its body arcing through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan sideways to track the dog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04303827881813049 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680383682250977 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04303827881813049, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04303827881813049, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08838026225566864, + 0.05825638025999069, + 0.020729495212435722, + 0.12657107412815094, + 0.25850653648376465, + 0.15439486503601074, + 0.10602609068155289, + 0.05308881774544716, + 0.05221056193113327, + 0.08183591067790985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04303827881813049 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Corgi with a reddish-brown and white coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush green park with manicured grass and mature trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a warm sunset with a golden glow and a sky gradient of orange and pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the Corgi perform a leaping motion across the grass with its body arcing through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan sideways to track the dog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08900238573551178 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640023708343506 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08900238573551178, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08900238573551178, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3832536041736603, + 0.06983551383018494, + 0.028046896681189537, + 0.0891125425696373, + 0.08926361054182053, + 0.06935054808855057, + 0.08796261996030807, + 0.08839581161737442, + 0.03928496688604355, + 0.05549389123916626 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08900238573551178 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, filmed in ethereal super-slow motion, smoothly pans sideways, tracking a cuddly, happy Corgi playing in a lush green park at the height of a warm sunset. The dog has a plump, fluffy tail, bright, expressive large black eyes that sparkle with joy, and a classic reddish-brown and white coat that appears incredibly soft, each strand catching the light. The low-hanging sun casts a brilliant golden glow across the scene, creating a bright rim light around the dog's silhouette and painting the background sky a stunning gradient of vibrant orange and soft pink. The Corgi happily leaps across the manicured grass, its mouth open in a blissful canine smile, tongue slightly drooping. Each leap is a graceful movement; its short, powerful legs lift off the ground, its long body arcs through the air, and its large, triangular ears flap with exaggerated, balletic grace. In the background, the leaves of mature trees sway gently in the warm breeze. The super slow-motion effect emphasizes every micro-movement, from the kick of individual blades of grass to the gentle sway of their tails, making the pure, unadulterated joy of each jump pause for a moment and creating a tranquil and welcoming atmosphere.", + "seed": 11391, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_12/index_4942_seed_11391_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.314302206132561, + "vlm_logprob": -0.314302206132561, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.350000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.314302206132561, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Corgi with a reddish-brown and white coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush green park with manicured grass and mature trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a warm sunset with a golden glow and a sky gradient of orange and pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the Corgi perform a leaping motion across the grass with its body arcing through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan sideways to track the dog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07047775387763977 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6954777240753174 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07047775387763977, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07047775387763977, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1092655211687088, + 0.2114182412624359, + 0.05935234948992729, + 0.15676553547382355, + 0.06589449197053909, + 0.08243900537490845, + 0.08869300037622452, + 0.11477011442184448, + 0.05120358616113663, + 0.060198165476322174 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07047775387763977 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Corgi with a reddish-brown and white coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush green park with manicured grass and mature trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a warm sunset with a golden glow and a sky gradient of orange and pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the Corgi perform a leaping motion across the grass with its body arcing through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan sideways to track the dog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134099245071411 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134099543094635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.3134099245071411, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.3134099245071411, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.048784300684928894, + 0.18979999423027039, + 0.04859748110175133, + 0.35232409834861755, + 0.025700559839606285, + 0.23685356974601746, + 0.01860576868057251, + 0.03207405284047127, + 0.031036389991641045, + 0.016223736107349396 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.3134099245071411 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Corgi with a reddish-brown and white coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush green park with manicured grass and mature trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a warm sunset with a golden glow and a sky gradient of orange and pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the Corgi perform a leaping motion across the grass with its body arcing through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan sideways to track the dog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006744359154254198 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006744384765625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006744359154254198, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006744359154254198, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04816446080803871, + 0.15603530406951904, + 0.07123556733131409, + 0.3592318892478943, + 0.02370443567633629, + 0.19054462015628815, + 0.03911520540714264, + 0.06208059564232826, + 0.03651297464966774, + 0.013374989852309227 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006744359154254198 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Corgi with a reddish-brown and white coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush green park with manicured grass and mature trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a warm sunset with a golden glow and a sky gradient of orange and pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the Corgi perform a leaping motion across the grass with its body arcing through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan sideways to track the dog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809569403529167 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288095712661743 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809569403529167, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809569403529167, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02343354932963848, + 0.0962945744395256, + 0.06817866861820221, + 0.22391149401664734, + 0.05070033669471741, + 0.40666964650154114, + 0.028548073023557663, + 0.06166617572307587, + 0.025965746492147446, + 0.014631696976721287 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809569403529167 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a Corgi with a reddish-brown and white coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a lush green park with manicured grass and mature trees?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting characterized by a warm sunset with a golden glow and a sky gradient of orange and pink?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the Corgi perform a leaping motion across the grass with its body arcing through the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera smoothly pan sideways to track the dog's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1427832990884781 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0177834033966064 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1427832990884781, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1427832990884781, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05757661536335945, + 0.08235990256071091, + 0.10319915413856506, + 0.21476826071739197, + 0.04687948152422905, + 0.31785085797309875, + 0.05447030067443848, + 0.03248637542128563, + 0.06733386963605881, + 0.023075196892023087 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1427832990884781 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_13/index_tensor([4501, 4501])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_13/index_tensor([4501, 4501])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c54f6ae1f82710c4029bee2a10937e28fb864f79 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_13/index_tensor([4501, 4501])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up shot from a bird's-eye perspective focuses on a hand, its knuckles thick with age marks, trembling slightly with uncontrollable tension and reluctance. Its fingers clenched convulsively around a yellowed sheet of letter paper, its edges frayed from repeated rubbing. In the cold, diffuse light of the overcast sky, the texture of the fingers and the wrinkles of the paper appear remarkably distinct. With an almost imperceptible, determined breath, the tense fingers, as if drained of all their strength, slowly and feebly release their grip. Just as the paper threatens to slip from its fingers, a sudden, sharp gust of wind snatches it away. The camera tilts upward and zooms out, following the \"fateful\" piece of paper as it is swept into the air. It spun wildly against the gray sky, folding and unfurling, like a white butterfly with broken wings, tumbling helplessly. The background gradually reveals the desolate cliff edge and the turbulent gray ocean in the distance. The entire picture is cold in tone, filled with a fatalistic sense of loss and an irreversible, heavy atmosphere. In the end, the piece of paper turns into a smaller and smaller white dot, disappearing at the junction of the rolling clouds and the sea and sky.", + "seed": 4233, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_13/index_4501_seed_4233_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.14856914193369447, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14856914193369447, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.8999999880790712, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14856914193369447, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up from a bird's-eye perspective focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hand's knuckles thick with age marks and trembling with tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hand holding a yellowed sheet of letter paper with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and zoom out as the paper is snatched away by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a desolate cliff edge and a turbulent gray ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31432804465293884 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3143280744552612 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31432804465293884, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31432804465293884, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0637294203042984, + 0.26636338233947754, + 0.059551093727350235, + 0.07689187675714493, + 0.038680896162986755, + 0.027111150324344635, + 0.044753070920705795, + 0.33810853958129883, + 0.03427223488688469, + 0.05053830146789551 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31432804465293884 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up from a bird's-eye perspective focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hand's knuckles thick with age marks and trembling with tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hand holding a yellowed sheet of letter paper with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and zoom out as the paper is snatched away by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a desolate cliff edge and a turbulent gray ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486691117286682 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236690521240234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486691117286682, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8749999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486691117286682, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09507908672094345, + 0.12655547261238098, + 0.02197781205177307, + 0.1179332435131073, + 0.053707778453826904, + 0.021479053422808647, + 0.019138459116220474, + 0.4907321035861969, + 0.03122859261929989, + 0.02216840162873268 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486691117286682 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up from a bird's-eye perspective focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hand's knuckles thick with age marks and trembling with tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hand holding a yellowed sheet of letter paper with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and zoom out as the paper is snatched away by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a desolate cliff edge and a turbulent gray ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620497427880764 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812049627304077 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620497427880764, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620497427880764, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07442997395992279, + 0.3443261384963989, + 0.07591722905635834, + 0.14047324657440186, + 0.10197417438030243, + 0.031172899529337883, + 0.056713104248046875, + 0.09756236523389816, + 0.014641874469816685, + 0.06278900057077408 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620497427880764 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up from a bird's-eye perspective focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hand's knuckles thick with age marks and trembling with tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hand holding a yellowed sheet of letter paper with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and zoom out as the paper is snatched away by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a desolate cliff edge and a turbulent gray ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036143234465271235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.62861442565918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036143234465271235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036143234465271235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03379608318209648, + 0.012518494389951229, + 0.0176156684756279, + 0.017595324665308, + 0.06279046833515167, + 0.014295749366283417, + 0.033655572682619095, + 0.7587356567382812, + 0.019952038303017616, + 0.029044946655631065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036143234465271235 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up from a bird's-eye perspective focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hand's knuckles thick with age marks and trembling with tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hand holding a yellowed sheet of letter paper with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and zoom out as the paper is snatched away by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a desolate cliff edge and a turbulent gray ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01418448705226183 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264184474945068 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01418448705226183, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01418448705226183, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06990820169448853, + 0.11244495213031769, + 0.04262571036815643, + 0.056310802698135376, + 0.05123089626431465, + 0.019766077399253845, + 0.03648604825139046, + 0.09637605398893356, + 0.05822398513555527, + 0.45662721991539 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01418448705226183 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up shot from a bird's-eye perspective focuses on a hand, its knuckles thick with age marks, trembling slightly with uncontrollable tension and reluctance. Its fingers clenched convulsively around a yellowed sheet of letter paper, its edges frayed from repeated rubbing. In the cold, diffuse light of the overcast sky, the texture of the fingers and the wrinkles of the paper appear remarkably distinct. With an almost imperceptible, determined breath, the tense fingers, as if drained of all their strength, slowly and feebly release their grip. Just as the paper threatens to slip from its fingers, a sudden, sharp gust of wind snatches it away. The camera tilts upward and zooms out, following the \"fateful\" piece of paper as it is swept into the air. It spun wildly against the gray sky, folding and unfurling, like a white butterfly with broken wings, tumbling helplessly. The background gradually reveals the desolate cliff edge and the turbulent gray ocean in the distance. The entire picture is cold in tone, filled with a fatalistic sense of loss and an irreversible, heavy atmosphere. In the end, the piece of paper turns into a smaller and smaller white dot, disappearing at the junction of the rolling clouds and the sea and sky.", + "seed": 4234, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_13/index_4501_seed_4234_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08894557012245059, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08894557012245059, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08894557012245059, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up from a bird's-eye perspective focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hand's knuckles thick with age marks and trembling with tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hand holding a yellowed sheet of letter paper with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and zoom out as the paper is snatched away by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a desolate cliff edge and a turbulent gray ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09136930108070374 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.466369390487671 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09136930108070374, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09136930108070374, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07055000215768814, + 0.07469978928565979, + 0.13666851818561554, + 0.13424882292747498, + 0.036694321781396866, + 0.034910012036561966, + 0.07338906824588776, + 0.11209792643785477, + 0.29670894145965576, + 0.030032586306333542 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09136930108070374 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up from a bird's-eye perspective focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hand's knuckles thick with age marks and trembling with tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hand holding a yellowed sheet of letter paper with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and zoom out as the paper is snatched away by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a desolate cliff edge and a turbulent gray ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31344011425971985 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134400844573975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31344011425971985, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31344011425971985, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09904082119464874, + 0.4102795422077179, + 0.1823621392250061, + 0.060002971440553665, + 0.01762341894209385, + 0.040094438940286636, + 0.034578587859869, + 0.02668396197259426, + 0.08211784809827805, + 0.047216255217790604 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31344011425971985 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up from a bird's-eye perspective focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hand's knuckles thick with age marks and trembling with tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hand holding a yellowed sheet of letter paper with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and zoom out as the paper is snatched away by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a desolate cliff edge and a turbulent gray ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980642206966877 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.52980637550354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980642206966877, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980642206966877, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04465147480368614, + 0.02555317059159279, + 0.5612268447875977, + 0.06802939623594284, + 0.05169267952442169, + 0.058835454285144806, + 0.029546920210123062, + 0.027341080829501152, + 0.10293076187372208, + 0.030192209407687187 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980642206966877 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up from a bird's-eye perspective focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hand's knuckles thick with age marks and trembling with tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hand holding a yellowed sheet of letter paper with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and zoom out as the paper is snatched away by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a desolate cliff edge and a turbulent gray ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002490753773599863 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002490520477295 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002490753773599863, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002490753773599863, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05079130083322525, + 0.04248810559511185, + 0.21281807124614716, + 0.031063903123140335, + 0.016390139237046242, + 0.07294292002916336, + 0.08397034555673599, + 0.040474943816661835, + 0.41062936186790466, + 0.038430918008089066 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002490753773599863 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up from a bird's-eye perspective focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hand's knuckles thick with age marks and trembling with tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hand holding a yellowed sheet of letter paper with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and zoom out as the paper is snatched away by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a desolate cliff edge and a turbulent gray ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007621259428560734 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826212882995605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007621259428560734, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007621259428560734, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07039183378219604, + 0.06127682328224182, + 0.18584366142749786, + 0.03374520316720009, + 0.024056894704699516, + 0.02719257026910782, + 0.10373898595571518, + 0.12475276738405228, + 0.30253154039382935, + 0.06646965444087982 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007621259428560734 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up shot from a bird's-eye perspective focuses on a hand, its knuckles thick with age marks, trembling slightly with uncontrollable tension and reluctance. Its fingers clenched convulsively around a yellowed sheet of letter paper, its edges frayed from repeated rubbing. In the cold, diffuse light of the overcast sky, the texture of the fingers and the wrinkles of the paper appear remarkably distinct. With an almost imperceptible, determined breath, the tense fingers, as if drained of all their strength, slowly and feebly release their grip. Just as the paper threatens to slip from its fingers, a sudden, sharp gust of wind snatches it away. The camera tilts upward and zooms out, following the \"fateful\" piece of paper as it is swept into the air. It spun wildly against the gray sky, folding and unfurling, like a white butterfly with broken wings, tumbling helplessly. The background gradually reveals the desolate cliff edge and the turbulent gray ocean in the distance. The entire picture is cold in tone, filled with a fatalistic sense of loss and an irreversible, heavy atmosphere. In the end, the piece of paper turns into a smaller and smaller white dot, disappearing at the junction of the rolling clouds and the sea and sky.", + "seed": 4235, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_13/index_4501_seed_4235_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.18736605318263172, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18736605318263172, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.674999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18736605318263172, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up from a bird's-eye perspective focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hand's knuckles thick with age marks and trembling with tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hand holding a yellowed sheet of letter paper with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and zoom out as the paper is snatched away by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a desolate cliff edge and a turbulent gray ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4768868088722229 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9768868088722229 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4768868088722229, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4768868088722229, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06628930568695068, + 0.030856803059577942, + 0.013184919953346252, + 0.18898066878318787, + 0.01844519004225731, + 0.12434974312782288, + 0.04085181653499603, + 0.448394238948822, + 0.04065602272748947, + 0.027991261333227158 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4768868088722229 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up from a bird's-eye perspective focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hand's knuckles thick with age marks and trembling with tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hand holding a yellowed sheet of letter paper with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and zoom out as the paper is snatched away by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a desolate cliff edge and a turbulent gray ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3871473968029022 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1371474266052246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3871473968029022, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3871473968029022, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06045031175017357, + 0.06493556499481201, + 0.0593782514333725, + 0.4190957844257355, + 0.01924106851220131, + 0.15116330981254578, + 0.047984883189201355, + 0.10970187932252884, + 0.0205734483897686, + 0.04747556895017624 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3871473968029022 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up from a bird's-eye perspective focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hand's knuckles thick with age marks and trembling with tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hand holding a yellowed sheet of letter paper with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and zoom out as the paper is snatched away by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a desolate cliff edge and a turbulent gray ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048666588962078094 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048666477203369 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048666588962078094, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048666588962078094, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03105814754962921, + 0.023710643872618675, + 0.02373439632356167, + 0.5491658449172974, + 0.028083326295018196, + 0.060506682842969894, + 0.012967179529368877, + 0.2025633007287979, + 0.0392647460103035, + 0.0289456769824028 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048666588962078094 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up from a bird's-eye perspective focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hand's knuckles thick with age marks and trembling with tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hand holding a yellowed sheet of letter paper with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and zoom out as the paper is snatched away by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a desolate cliff edge and a turbulent gray ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005950829479843378 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130950927734375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005950829479843378, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005950829479843378, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02472575195133686, + 0.022100772708654404, + 0.0086188530549407, + 0.2503328025341034, + 0.03339062258601189, + 0.3044706881046295, + 0.013872157782316208, + 0.1995852142572403, + 0.059338316321372986, + 0.08356476575136185 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005950829479843378 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up from a bird's-eye perspective focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hand's knuckles thick with age marks and trembling with tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hand holding a yellowed sheet of letter paper with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and zoom out as the paper is snatched away by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a desolate cliff edge and a turbulent gray ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01817864179611206 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018178462982178 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01817864179611206, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01817864179611206, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.019177138805389404, + 0.00966342817991972, + 0.0064915018156170845, + 0.05664316937327385, + 0.006025629583746195, + 0.1746056079864502, + 0.03821083903312683, + 0.4466586709022522, + 0.1291598081588745, + 0.11336421221494675 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01817864179611206 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up shot from a bird's-eye perspective focuses on a hand, its knuckles thick with age marks, trembling slightly with uncontrollable tension and reluctance. Its fingers clenched convulsively around a yellowed sheet of letter paper, its edges frayed from repeated rubbing. In the cold, diffuse light of the overcast sky, the texture of the fingers and the wrinkles of the paper appear remarkably distinct. With an almost imperceptible, determined breath, the tense fingers, as if drained of all their strength, slowly and feebly release their grip. Just as the paper threatens to slip from its fingers, a sudden, sharp gust of wind snatches it away. The camera tilts upward and zooms out, following the \"fateful\" piece of paper as it is swept into the air. It spun wildly against the gray sky, folding and unfurling, like a white butterfly with broken wings, tumbling helplessly. The background gradually reveals the desolate cliff edge and the turbulent gray ocean in the distance. The entire picture is cold in tone, filled with a fatalistic sense of loss and an irreversible, heavy atmosphere. In the end, the piece of paper turns into a smaller and smaller white dot, disappearing at the junction of the rolling clouds and the sea and sky.", + "seed": 4236, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_13/index_4501_seed_4236_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.17265441408380866, + "vlm_logprob": -0.17265441408380866, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.17265441408380866, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up from a bird's-eye perspective focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hand's knuckles thick with age marks and trembling with tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hand holding a yellowed sheet of letter paper with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and zoom out as the paper is snatched away by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a desolate cliff edge and a turbulent gray ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.476282000541687 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.976282000541687 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.476282000541687, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.476282000541687, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13609381020069122, + 0.07252363860607147, + 0.1720016747713089, + 0.10225477069616318, + 0.055973801761865616, + 0.07422413676977158, + 0.20471878349781036, + 0.043579526245594025, + 0.07994586229324341, + 0.058683935552835464 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.476282000541687 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up from a bird's-eye perspective focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hand's knuckles thick with age marks and trembling with tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hand holding a yellowed sheet of letter paper with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and zoom out as the paper is snatched away by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a desolate cliff edge and a turbulent gray ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34865573048591614 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236557006835938 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34865573048591614, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34865573048591614, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22722820937633514, + 0.1407637894153595, + 0.2758236825466156, + 0.0895291119813919, + 0.03904169425368309, + 0.04639936238527298, + 0.02424083836376667, + 0.05440882220864296, + 0.06678749620914459, + 0.035776957869529724 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34865573048591614 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up from a bird's-eye perspective focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hand's knuckles thick with age marks and trembling with tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hand holding a yellowed sheet of letter paper with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and zoom out as the paper is snatched away by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a desolate cliff edge and a turbulent gray ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026349445804953575 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513495445251465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026349445804953575, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026349445804953575, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22884508967399597, + 0.11865543574094772, + 0.10470565408468246, + 0.13214218616485596, + 0.13088084757328033, + 0.04178791865706444, + 0.10233020037412643, + 0.035212695598602295, + 0.052843671292066574, + 0.052596315741539 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026349445804953575 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up from a bird's-eye perspective focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hand's knuckles thick with age marks and trembling with tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hand holding a yellowed sheet of letter paper with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and zoom out as the paper is snatched away by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a desolate cliff edge and a turbulent gray ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005254387855529785 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.25525426864624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005254387855529785, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005254387855529785, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05315261706709862, + 0.04415501281619072, + 0.07161407917737961, + 0.20397652685642242, + 0.03675951436161995, + 0.043613240122795105, + 0.2266216278076172, + 0.09466017782688141, + 0.1812421828508377, + 0.044205013662576675 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005254387855529785 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up from a bird's-eye perspective focusing on a hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the hand's knuckles thick with age marks and trembling with tension?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the hand holding a yellowed sheet of letter paper with frayed edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera tilt upward and zoom out as the paper is snatched away by the wind?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the background reveal a desolate cliff edge and a turbulent gray ocean?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006730505730956793 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006730556488037 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006730505730956793, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006730505730956793, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.088923878967762, + 0.03938410058617592, + 0.07291967421770096, + 0.07547187060117722, + 0.051722560077905655, + 0.0737827718257904, + 0.09918848425149918, + 0.10229430347681046, + 0.18513527512550354, + 0.21117709577083588 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006730505730956793 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_14/index_tensor([6124, 6124])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_14/index_tensor([6124, 6124])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d9e258e4951a6a6fd8b7ffa19f52b00a3eadb404 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_14/index_tensor([6124, 6124])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot begins at eye level, then slowly and steadily pans forward, imbued with the refined quality of a high-end advertisement. A soft, warm light cast from above and sideways reveals a slender, bony male hand with neatly manicured nails. On this wrist rests a refined Rolex watch, its stainless steel bracelet and Oyster case reflecting a subtle, yet luxurious metallic sheen. The hand gracefully hovers at the cuff of a dark gray, worsted wool haute couture suit. Then, with an incredibly gentle, almost ritualistic gesture, the tips of his index and middle fingers delicately brush away the barely perceptible dust from the cuff. As the camera silently zooms in, the focus gradually shifts from the overall movement of the hand, passing over the delicate texture of the suit's fabric, and finally locking onto the deep black dial of the watch with an extremely shallow depth of field, allowing the audience to clearly see the golden second hand sweeping across the scale in an impeccable, continuous and smooth manner. The whole scene, in extreme tranquility, conveys an atmosphere of concentration on time, precision and extraordinary taste.", + "seed": 11966, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_14/index_6124_seed_11966_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.2552181972190738, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2552181972190738, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2552181972190738, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, bony male hand with neatly manicured nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Rolex watch with a stainless steel bracelet and Oyster case visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand perform a gentle gesture of brushing dust off the cuff of a dark gray worsted wool suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the final shot focus on the deep black dial of the watch with a shallow depth of field showing a golden second hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20630022883415222 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7063002586364746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20630022883415222, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20630022883415222, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1705082207918167, + 0.08998994529247284, + 0.0762588307261467, + 0.09523799270391464, + 0.11530448496341705, + 0.17293116450309753, + 0.07008721679449081, + 0.06169732287526131, + 0.05417148023843765, + 0.09381334483623505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20630022883415222 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, bony male hand with neatly manicured nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Rolex watch with a stainless steel bracelet and Oyster case visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand perform a gentle gesture of brushing dust off the cuff of a dark gray worsted wool suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the final shot focus on the deep black dial of the watch with a shallow depth of field showing a golden second hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026374060660600662 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651374101638794 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026374060660600662, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026374060660600662, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04087544232606888, + 0.041273459792137146, + 0.08288885653018951, + 0.03079361468553543, + 0.023946154862642288, + 0.021369216963648796, + 0.020233308896422386, + 0.0323837548494339, + 0.5245551466941833, + 0.18168096244335175 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026374060660600662 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, bony male hand with neatly manicured nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Rolex watch with a stainless steel bracelet and Oyster case visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand perform a gentle gesture of brushing dust off the cuff of a dark gray worsted wool suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the final shot focus on the deep black dial of the watch with a shallow depth of field showing a golden second hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054975736886262894 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929975748062134 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054975736886262894, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054975736886262894, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13347023725509644, + 0.10202597826719284, + 0.04921417310833931, + 0.06393424421548843, + 0.061554428189992905, + 0.051877785474061966, + 0.08473726361989975, + 0.052344176918268204, + 0.3183472454547882, + 0.08249448239803314 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054975736886262894 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, bony male hand with neatly manicured nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Rolex watch with a stainless steel bracelet and Oyster case visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand perform a gentle gesture of brushing dust off the cuff of a dark gray worsted wool suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the final shot focus on the deep black dial of the watch with a shallow depth of field showing a golden second hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742409586906433 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4742409586906433 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.9742409586906433, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.9742409586906433, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08085087686777115, + 0.05603403225541115, + 0.059934522956609726, + 0.038651201874017715, + 0.07549474388360977, + 0.028880540281534195, + 0.024680903181433678, + 0.03736501559615135, + 0.5204399228096008, + 0.0776682049036026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.9742409586906433 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, bony male hand with neatly manicured nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Rolex watch with a stainless steel bracelet and Oyster case visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand perform a gentle gesture of brushing dust off the cuff of a dark gray worsted wool suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the final shot focus on the deep black dial of the watch with a shallow depth of field showing a golden second hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014200001023709774 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264200210571289 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014200001023709774, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014200001023709774, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10997852683067322, + 0.05017957463860512, + 0.0715649351477623, + 0.04236014559864998, + 0.05844041705131531, + 0.02848854288458824, + 0.04239668324589729, + 0.15900348126888275, + 0.12173173576593399, + 0.31585603952407837 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014200001023709774 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot begins at eye level, then slowly and steadily pans forward, imbued with the refined quality of a high-end advertisement. A soft, warm light cast from above and sideways reveals a slender, bony male hand with neatly manicured nails. On this wrist rests a refined Rolex watch, its stainless steel bracelet and Oyster case reflecting a subtle, yet luxurious metallic sheen. The hand gracefully hovers at the cuff of a dark gray, worsted wool haute couture suit. Then, with an incredibly gentle, almost ritualistic gesture, the tips of his index and middle fingers delicately brush away the barely perceptible dust from the cuff. As the camera silently zooms in, the focus gradually shifts from the overall movement of the hand, passing over the delicate texture of the suit's fabric, and finally locking onto the deep black dial of the watch with an extremely shallow depth of field, allowing the audience to clearly see the golden second hand sweeping across the scale in an impeccable, continuous and smooth manner. The whole scene, in extreme tranquility, conveys an atmosphere of concentration on time, precision and extraordinary taste.", + "seed": 11967, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_14/index_6124_seed_11967_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.34336830452084544, + "vlm_logprob": -0.34336830452084544, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.34336830452084544, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, bony male hand with neatly manicured nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Rolex watch with a stainless steel bracelet and Oyster case visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand perform a gentle gesture of brushing dust off the cuff of a dark gray worsted wool suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the final shot focus on the deep black dial of the watch with a shallow depth of field showing a golden second hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.26295992732048035 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5129599571228027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.26295992732048035, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.26295992732048035, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11507012695074081, + 0.049066245555877686, + 0.0769873857498169, + 0.039033565670251846, + 0.1065845638513565, + 0.15400436520576477, + 0.07060209661722183, + 0.1513078659772873, + 0.10674307495355606, + 0.13060063123703003 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.26295992732048035 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, bony male hand with neatly manicured nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Rolex watch with a stainless steel bracelet and Oyster case visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand perform a gentle gesture of brushing dust off the cuff of a dark gray worsted wool suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the final shot focus on the deep black dial of the watch with a shallow depth of field showing a golden second hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04870893806219101 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048708915710449 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04870893806219101, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04870893806219101, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08983583748340607, + 0.05833758786320686, + 0.09785287827253342, + 0.16661545634269714, + 0.03854791447520256, + 0.03381672129034996, + 0.1930636763572693, + 0.09888841956853867, + 0.09350951761007309, + 0.12953199446201324 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04870893806219101 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, bony male hand with neatly manicured nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Rolex watch with a stainless steel bracelet and Oyster case visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand perform a gentle gesture of brushing dust off the cuff of a dark gray worsted wool suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the final shot focus on the deep black dial of the watch with a shallow depth of field showing a golden second hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867544397711754 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048675537109375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867544397711754, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867544397711754, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1646231859922409, + 0.07963785529136658, + 0.1120411679148674, + 0.10217887908220291, + 0.08699027448892593, + 0.07851796597242355, + 0.09139660000801086, + 0.1006292849779129, + 0.05973261594772339, + 0.12425209581851959 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867544397711754 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, bony male hand with neatly manicured nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Rolex watch with a stainless steel bracelet and Oyster case visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand perform a gentle gesture of brushing dust off the cuff of a dark gray worsted wool suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the final shot focus on the deep black dial of the watch with a shallow depth of field showing a golden second hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134158849716187 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31341588497161865 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.3134158849716187, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.3134158849716187, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1287802755832672, + 0.06940293312072754, + 0.10064120590686798, + 0.04109148681163788, + 0.06502844393253326, + 0.1186155304312706, + 0.11481841653585434, + 0.13086824119091034, + 0.07736309617757797, + 0.1533903330564499 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.3134158849716187 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, bony male hand with neatly manicured nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Rolex watch with a stainless steel bracelet and Oyster case visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand perform a gentle gesture of brushing dust off the cuff of a dark gray worsted wool suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the final shot focus on the deep black dial of the watch with a shallow depth of field showing a golden second hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308132827281952 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168081283569336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308132827281952, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308132827281952, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08518430590629578, + 0.05773519352078438, + 0.10178280621767044, + 0.03542513772845268, + 0.03288741037249565, + 0.1358095407485962, + 0.15044531226158142, + 0.1054689809679985, + 0.15503548085689545, + 0.14022581279277802 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308132827281952 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot begins at eye level, then slowly and steadily pans forward, imbued with the refined quality of a high-end advertisement. A soft, warm light cast from above and sideways reveals a slender, bony male hand with neatly manicured nails. On this wrist rests a refined Rolex watch, its stainless steel bracelet and Oyster case reflecting a subtle, yet luxurious metallic sheen. The hand gracefully hovers at the cuff of a dark gray, worsted wool haute couture suit. Then, with an incredibly gentle, almost ritualistic gesture, the tips of his index and middle fingers delicately brush away the barely perceptible dust from the cuff. As the camera silently zooms in, the focus gradually shifts from the overall movement of the hand, passing over the delicate texture of the suit's fabric, and finally locking onto the deep black dial of the watch with an extremely shallow depth of field, allowing the audience to clearly see the golden second hand sweeping across the scale in an impeccable, continuous and smooth manner. The whole scene, in extreme tranquility, conveys an atmosphere of concentration on time, precision and extraordinary taste.", + "seed": 11968, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_14/index_6124_seed_11968_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.35917371325194836, + "vlm_logprob": -0.35917371325194836, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.35917371325194836, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, bony male hand with neatly manicured nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Rolex watch with a stainless steel bracelet and Oyster case visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand perform a gentle gesture of brushing dust off the cuff of a dark gray worsted wool suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the final shot focus on the deep black dial of the watch with a shallow depth of field showing a golden second hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09353272616863251 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4685328006744385 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09353272616863251, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09353272616863251, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.708410918712616, + 0.027675403282046318, + 0.01797308214008808, + 0.037788812071084976, + 0.03212059661746025, + 0.12423532456159592, + 0.012475190684199333, + 0.014995034784078598, + 0.007674397435039282, + 0.016651269048452377 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09353272616863251 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, bony male hand with neatly manicured nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Rolex watch with a stainless steel bracelet and Oyster case visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand perform a gentle gesture of brushing dust off the cuff of a dark gray worsted wool suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the final shot focus on the deep black dial of the watch with a shallow depth of field showing a golden second hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02331276424229145 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.77331280708313 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02331276424229145, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02331276424229145, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1623167246580124, + 0.09927539527416229, + 0.07317263633012772, + 0.05227641388773918, + 0.07207069545984268, + 0.04119404777884483, + 0.07604588568210602, + 0.043563082814216614, + 0.04349365457892418, + 0.3365914821624756 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02331276424229145 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, bony male hand with neatly manicured nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Rolex watch with a stainless steel bracelet and Oyster case visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand perform a gentle gesture of brushing dust off the cuff of a dark gray worsted wool suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the final shot focus on the deep black dial of the watch with a shallow depth of field showing a golden second hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867033287882805 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486702919006348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867033287882805, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867033287882805, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7063977718353271, + 0.06927920132875443, + 0.029195282608270645, + 0.014875435270369053, + 0.021832533180713654, + 0.1013868972659111, + 0.012880804017186165, + 0.005830963607877493, + 0.0184720940887928, + 0.01984904706478119 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867033287882805 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, bony male hand with neatly manicured nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Rolex watch with a stainless steel bracelet and Oyster case visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand perform a gentle gesture of brushing dust off the cuff of a dark gray worsted wool suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the final shot focus on the deep black dial of the watch with a shallow depth of field showing a golden second hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005332469940186 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22553327679634094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.6005332469940186, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.6005332469940186, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07279279828071594, + 0.12052343785762787, + 0.06853200495243073, + 0.06380070745944977, + 0.023472383618354797, + 0.462704598903656, + 0.0738048329949379, + 0.037223972380161285, + 0.03862772509455681, + 0.03851762413978577 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.6005332469940186 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, bony male hand with neatly manicured nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Rolex watch with a stainless steel bracelet and Oyster case visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand perform a gentle gesture of brushing dust off the cuff of a dark gray worsted wool suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the final shot focus on the deep black dial of the watch with a shallow depth of field showing a golden second hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029819495975971222 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298194885253906 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029819495975971222, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029819495975971222, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23720873892307281, + 0.11730361729860306, + 0.060380835086107254, + 0.04140849784016609, + 0.0453755259513855, + 0.21687570214271545, + 0.033284373581409454, + 0.031129298731684685, + 0.03607964143157005, + 0.1809537559747696 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029819495975971222 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot begins at eye level, then slowly and steadily pans forward, imbued with the refined quality of a high-end advertisement. A soft, warm light cast from above and sideways reveals a slender, bony male hand with neatly manicured nails. On this wrist rests a refined Rolex watch, its stainless steel bracelet and Oyster case reflecting a subtle, yet luxurious metallic sheen. The hand gracefully hovers at the cuff of a dark gray, worsted wool haute couture suit. Then, with an incredibly gentle, almost ritualistic gesture, the tips of his index and middle fingers delicately brush away the barely perceptible dust from the cuff. As the camera silently zooms in, the focus gradually shifts from the overall movement of the hand, passing over the delicate texture of the suit's fabric, and finally locking onto the deep black dial of the watch with an extremely shallow depth of field, allowing the audience to clearly see the golden second hand sweeping across the scale in an impeccable, continuous and smooth manner. The whole scene, in extreme tranquility, conveys an atmosphere of concentration on time, precision and extraordinary taste.", + "seed": 11969, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_14/index_6124_seed_11969_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.13946854332461953, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13946854332461953, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13946854332461953, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, bony male hand with neatly manicured nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Rolex watch with a stainless steel bracelet and Oyster case visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand perform a gentle gesture of brushing dust off the cuff of a dark gray worsted wool suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the final shot focus on the deep black dial of the watch with a shallow depth of field showing a golden second hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07317099720239639 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6981709003448486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07317099720239639, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07317099720239639, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13010016083717346, + 0.07283294200897217, + 0.07876148074865341, + 0.0619451068341732, + 0.1363479197025299, + 0.11455965042114258, + 0.15612594783306122, + 0.10166948288679123, + 0.08598550409078598, + 0.061671797186136246 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07317099720239639 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, bony male hand with neatly manicured nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Rolex watch with a stainless steel bracelet and Oyster case visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand perform a gentle gesture of brushing dust off the cuff of a dark gray worsted wool suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the final shot focus on the deep black dial of the watch with a shallow depth of field showing a golden second hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014227384701371193 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264227390289307 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014227384701371193, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014227384701371193, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06026214733719826, + 0.04249688610434532, + 0.03152558207511902, + 0.09601478278636932, + 0.16387256979942322, + 0.14982761442661285, + 0.0898820087313652, + 0.19626908004283905, + 0.06186775490641594, + 0.10798156261444092 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014227384701371193 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, bony male hand with neatly manicured nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Rolex watch with a stainless steel bracelet and Oyster case visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand perform a gentle gesture of brushing dust off the cuff of a dark gray worsted wool suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the final shot focus on the deep black dial of the watch with a shallow depth of field showing a golden second hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900849729776382 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790085792541504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900849729776382, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900849729776382, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1250753402709961, + 0.08557470142841339, + 0.054709047079086304, + 0.29564809799194336, + 0.1260688155889511, + 0.09229399263858795, + 0.09511911869049072, + 0.059685807675123215, + 0.03489628806710243, + 0.030928732827305794 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900849729776382 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, bony male hand with neatly manicured nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Rolex watch with a stainless steel bracelet and Oyster case visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand perform a gentle gesture of brushing dust off the cuff of a dark gray worsted wool suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the final shot focus on the deep black dial of the watch with a shallow depth of field showing a golden second hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233045220375061 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983045220375061 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233045220375061, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233045220375061, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08350304514169693, + 0.0393228679895401, + 0.11611749976873398, + 0.08959861099720001, + 0.3962946832180023, + 0.03830325976014137, + 0.09703030437231064, + 0.07889996469020844, + 0.031185580417513847, + 0.029744258150458336 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233045220375061 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a slender, bony male hand with neatly manicured nails?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a Rolex watch with a stainless steel bracelet and Oyster case visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the hand perform a gentle gesture of brushing dust off the cuff of a dark gray worsted wool suit?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at eye level and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the final shot focus on the deep black dial of the watch with a shallow depth of field showing a golden second hand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007631315384060144 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882631301879883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007631315384060144, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007631315384060144, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10489494353532791, + 0.0572749599814415, + 0.05925820395350456, + 0.33291271328926086, + 0.16700169444084167, + 0.04794515296816826, + 0.06088624522089958, + 0.08830781280994415, + 0.044153932482004166, + 0.03736436367034912 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007631315384060144 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_15/index_tensor([1324, 1324])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_15/index_tensor([1324, 1324])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..10c2d6c9b21f11091585978865488c2bf317d08b --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_15/index_tensor([1324, 1324])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a meticulously crafted, futuristic digitally rendered scene, created in Blender, a dynamic rotating camera begins at a low angle, smoothly moving upwards along the underside of a matte black hovercar, capturing the eerie blue glow of its repulsor thrusters. As the car's doors silently swing upward, S.H.I.E.L.D. agents, clad in futuristic, metallic armor, begin to gracefully exit. Their suits are a blend of polished chrome and matte carbon fiber, with thin blue LEDs glimmering at the joints. The S.H.I.E.L.D. emblem is subtly embossed on the shoulder pads, and a faint data glow shimmers beneath the dark visor of their full-face helmets. The first agent lands firmly, knees bent slightly to absorb the impact, and quickly assumes a defensive stance. Immediately afterwards, the rest of the team lands with millisecond precision, their movements synchronized, swiftly and decisively forming a perfect fan-shaped tactical formation around the hovercar, their pulse rifles steadily pointed at their respective defense zones. The camera continuously circles and slowly rises, taking in the entire scene: they are in a vast, empty hangar. Cold white strip lights overhead cast sharp, elongated shadows on the highly polished black floor, which perfectly reflects the icy sheen of the agents' metal armor and the blue halo of the hovercraft's underside. The entire scene, as it rotates, exudes a sense of orderly tension and ultimate professionalism. The precise capture of light and shadow highlights the surreal quality and cold technological atmosphere brought by digital rendering.", + "seed": 7242, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_15/index_1324_seed_7242_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03323824591934681, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03323824591934681, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03323824591934681, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a matte black hovercar visible with repulsor thrusters emitting an eerie blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do S.H.I.E.L.D. agents wearing metallic armor with blue LEDs exit the car and form a fan-shaped tactical formation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, empty hangar with cold white strip lights overhead casting sharp shadows on a highly polished black floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle, smoothly move upwards along the car's underside, and continuously circle while rising?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the agents land with knees bent to absorb impact and assume a defensive stance with pulse rifles pointed at defense zones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03858442232012749 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2885844707489014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03858442232012749, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03858442232012749, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08408743888139725, + 0.06141909956932068, + 0.5821152329444885, + 0.048497121781110764, + 0.058707211166620255, + 0.07570517063140869, + 0.016230659559369087, + 0.02505045011639595, + 0.02327156811952591, + 0.024916009977459908 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03858442232012749 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a matte black hovercar visible with repulsor thrusters emitting an eerie blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do S.H.I.E.L.D. agents wearing metallic armor with blue LEDs exit the car and form a fan-shaped tactical formation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, empty hangar with cold white strip lights overhead casting sharp shadows on a highly polished black floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle, smoothly move upwards along the car's underside, and continuously circle while rising?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the agents land with knees bent to absorb impact and assume a defensive stance with pulse rifles pointed at defense zones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016088780015707016 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141088962554932 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016088780015707016, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016088780015707016, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09160347282886505, + 0.04242722690105438, + 0.37636247277259827, + 0.038124099373817444, + 0.06165342777967453, + 0.07175203412771225, + 0.03488898277282715, + 0.08702646195888519, + 0.0385984405875206, + 0.15756343305110931 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016088780015707016 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a matte black hovercar visible with repulsor thrusters emitting an eerie blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do S.H.I.E.L.D. agents wearing metallic armor with blue LEDs exit the car and form a fan-shaped tactical formation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, empty hangar with cold white strip lights overhead casting sharp shadows on a highly polished black floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle, smoothly move upwards along the car's underside, and continuously circle while rising?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the agents land with knees bent to absorb impact and assume a defensive stance with pulse rifles pointed at defense zones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004882395267487 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950488090515137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004882395267487, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004882395267487, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.040650103241205215, + 0.11922626197338104, + 0.29546695947647095, + 0.09285180270671844, + 0.11037500202655792, + 0.2712390422821045, + 0.011630775406956673, + 0.022308610379695892, + 0.020666545256972313, + 0.015584859997034073 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004882395267487 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a matte black hovercar visible with repulsor thrusters emitting an eerie blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do S.H.I.E.L.D. agents wearing metallic armor with blue LEDs exit the car and form a fan-shaped tactical formation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, empty hangar with cold white strip lights overhead casting sharp shadows on a highly polished black floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle, smoothly move upwards along the car's underside, and continuously circle while rising?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the agents land with knees bent to absorb impact and assume a defensive stance with pulse rifles pointed at defense zones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02328236773610115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773282289505005 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02328236773610115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02328236773610115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05857233330607414, + 0.030839407816529274, + 0.4008135199546814, + 0.027168795466423035, + 0.057665370404720306, + 0.297601580619812, + 0.009413720108568668, + 0.04138233885169029, + 0.04452352970838547, + 0.03201944753527641 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02328236773610115 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a matte black hovercar visible with repulsor thrusters emitting an eerie blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do S.H.I.E.L.D. agents wearing metallic armor with blue LEDs exit the car and form a fan-shaped tactical formation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, empty hangar with cold white strip lights overhead casting sharp shadows on a highly polished black floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle, smoothly move upwards along the car's underside, and continuously circle while rising?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the agents land with knees bent to absorb impact and assume a defensive stance with pulse rifles pointed at defense zones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018186835572123528 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187046051025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018186835572123528, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018186835572123528, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.042630910873413086, + 0.04809267073869705, + 0.2344125360250473, + 0.06258135288953781, + 0.049425773322582245, + 0.17247247695922852, + 0.029186759144067764, + 0.0749712735414505, + 0.12293660640716553, + 0.1632896214723587 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018186835572123528 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a meticulously crafted, futuristic digitally rendered scene, created in Blender, a dynamic rotating camera begins at a low angle, smoothly moving upwards along the underside of a matte black hovercar, capturing the eerie blue glow of its repulsor thrusters. As the car's doors silently swing upward, S.H.I.E.L.D. agents, clad in futuristic, metallic armor, begin to gracefully exit. Their suits are a blend of polished chrome and matte carbon fiber, with thin blue LEDs glimmering at the joints. The S.H.I.E.L.D. emblem is subtly embossed on the shoulder pads, and a faint data glow shimmers beneath the dark visor of their full-face helmets. The first agent lands firmly, knees bent slightly to absorb the impact, and quickly assumes a defensive stance. Immediately afterwards, the rest of the team lands with millisecond precision, their movements synchronized, swiftly and decisively forming a perfect fan-shaped tactical formation around the hovercar, their pulse rifles steadily pointed at their respective defense zones. The camera continuously circles and slowly rises, taking in the entire scene: they are in a vast, empty hangar. Cold white strip lights overhead cast sharp, elongated shadows on the highly polished black floor, which perfectly reflects the icy sheen of the agents' metal armor and the blue halo of the hovercraft's underside. The entire scene, as it rotates, exudes a sense of orderly tension and ultimate professionalism. The precise capture of light and shadow highlights the surreal quality and cold technological atmosphere brought by digital rendering.", + "seed": 7243, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_15/index_1324_seed_7243_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.019594364706426858, + "vlm_logprob": -0.019594364706426858, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.019594364706426858, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a matte black hovercar visible with repulsor thrusters emitting an eerie blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do S.H.I.E.L.D. agents wearing metallic armor with blue LEDs exit the car and form a fan-shaped tactical formation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, empty hangar with cold white strip lights overhead casting sharp shadows on a highly polished black floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle, smoothly move upwards along the car's underside, and continuously circle while rising?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the agents land with knees bent to absorb impact and assume a defensive stance with pulse rifles pointed at defense zones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.027082987129688263 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.652082920074463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.027082987129688263, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.027082987129688263, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.175575390458107, + 0.21275120973587036, + 0.1500811129808426, + 0.11607946455478668, + 0.06186845526099205, + 0.042453471571207047, + 0.05265207588672638, + 0.047061581164598465, + 0.057275474071502686, + 0.08420172333717346 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.027082987129688263 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a matte black hovercar visible with repulsor thrusters emitting an eerie blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do S.H.I.E.L.D. agents wearing metallic armor with blue LEDs exit the car and form a fan-shaped tactical formation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, empty hangar with cold white strip lights overhead casting sharp shadows on a highly polished black floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle, smoothly move upwards along the car's underside, and continuously circle while rising?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the agents land with knees bent to absorb impact and assume a defensive stance with pulse rifles pointed at defense zones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005263281520456076 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255263328552246 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005263281520456076, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005263281520456076, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12363255769014359, + 0.07501071691513062, + 0.1474066972732544, + 0.09512707591056824, + 0.07384971529245377, + 0.08173876255750656, + 0.06255383789539337, + 0.12680654227733612, + 0.10916393250226974, + 0.10471007972955704 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005263281520456076 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a matte black hovercar visible with repulsor thrusters emitting an eerie blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do S.H.I.E.L.D. agents wearing metallic armor with blue LEDs exit the car and form a fan-shaped tactical formation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, empty hangar with cold white strip lights overhead casting sharp shadows on a highly polished black floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle, smoothly move upwards along the car's underside, and continuously circle while rising?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the agents land with knees bent to absorb impact and assume a defensive stance with pulse rifles pointed at defense zones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029808619990944862 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529808521270752 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029808619990944862, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029808619990944862, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06422272324562073, + 0.06471000611782074, + 0.08199440687894821, + 0.20909826457500458, + 0.05646504834294319, + 0.06078584864735603, + 0.22808116674423218, + 0.13428795337677002, + 0.0604775995016098, + 0.03987697511911392 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029808619990944862 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a matte black hovercar visible with repulsor thrusters emitting an eerie blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do S.H.I.E.L.D. agents wearing metallic armor with blue LEDs exit the car and form a fan-shaped tactical formation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, empty hangar with cold white strip lights overhead casting sharp shadows on a highly polished black floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle, smoothly move upwards along the car's underside, and continuously circle while rising?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the agents land with knees bent to absorb impact and assume a defensive stance with pulse rifles pointed at defense zones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02327875606715679 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732787132263184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02327875606715679, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02327875606715679, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0812438577413559, + 0.13845187425613403, + 0.09234385192394257, + 0.1714346706867218, + 0.1649201363325119, + 0.09230844676494598, + 0.09118254482746124, + 0.05341607332229614, + 0.06895691156387329, + 0.045741643756628036 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02327875606715679 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a matte black hovercar visible with repulsor thrusters emitting an eerie blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do S.H.I.E.L.D. agents wearing metallic armor with blue LEDs exit the car and form a fan-shaped tactical formation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, empty hangar with cold white strip lights overhead casting sharp shadows on a highly polished black floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle, smoothly move upwards along the car's underside, and continuously circle while rising?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the agents land with knees bent to absorb impact and assume a defensive stance with pulse rifles pointed at defense zones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012538178823888302 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387537956237793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012538178823888302, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012538178823888302, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16702231764793396, + 0.04873034730553627, + 0.11281511932611465, + 0.07953816652297974, + 0.05427025631070137, + 0.10055089741945267, + 0.03820404037833214, + 0.20546060800552368, + 0.08308175206184387, + 0.11032642424106598 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012538178823888302 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a meticulously crafted, futuristic digitally rendered scene, created in Blender, a dynamic rotating camera begins at a low angle, smoothly moving upwards along the underside of a matte black hovercar, capturing the eerie blue glow of its repulsor thrusters. As the car's doors silently swing upward, S.H.I.E.L.D. agents, clad in futuristic, metallic armor, begin to gracefully exit. Their suits are a blend of polished chrome and matte carbon fiber, with thin blue LEDs glimmering at the joints. The S.H.I.E.L.D. emblem is subtly embossed on the shoulder pads, and a faint data glow shimmers beneath the dark visor of their full-face helmets. The first agent lands firmly, knees bent slightly to absorb the impact, and quickly assumes a defensive stance. Immediately afterwards, the rest of the team lands with millisecond precision, their movements synchronized, swiftly and decisively forming a perfect fan-shaped tactical formation around the hovercar, their pulse rifles steadily pointed at their respective defense zones. The camera continuously circles and slowly rises, taking in the entire scene: they are in a vast, empty hangar. Cold white strip lights overhead cast sharp, elongated shadows on the highly polished black floor, which perfectly reflects the icy sheen of the agents' metal armor and the blue halo of the hovercraft's underside. The entire scene, as it rotates, exudes a sense of orderly tension and ultimate professionalism. The precise capture of light and shadow highlights the surreal quality and cold technological atmosphere brought by digital rendering.", + "seed": 7244, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_15/index_1324_seed_7244_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.029924355447292328, + "vlm_logprob": -0.029924355447292328, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.029924355447292328, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a matte black hovercar visible with repulsor thrusters emitting an eerie blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do S.H.I.E.L.D. agents wearing metallic armor with blue LEDs exit the car and form a fan-shaped tactical formation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, empty hangar with cold white strip lights overhead casting sharp shadows on a highly polished black floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle, smoothly move upwards along the car's underside, and continuously circle while rising?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the agents land with knees bent to absorb impact and assume a defensive stance with pulse rifles pointed at defense zones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04930916801095009 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.049309253692627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04930916801095009, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04930916801095009, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08682373911142349, + 0.0836520716547966, + 0.20259349048137665, + 0.06452806293964386, + 0.16249199211597443, + 0.20143112540245056, + 0.04392128065228462, + 0.05990152433514595, + 0.03097633644938469, + 0.06368044018745422 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04930916801095009 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a matte black hovercar visible with repulsor thrusters emitting an eerie blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do S.H.I.E.L.D. agents wearing metallic armor with blue LEDs exit the car and form a fan-shaped tactical formation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, empty hangar with cold white strip lights overhead casting sharp shadows on a highly polished black floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle, smoothly move upwards along the car's underside, and continuously circle while rising?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the agents land with knees bent to absorb impact and assume a defensive stance with pulse rifles pointed at defense zones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018205681815743446 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018205642700195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018205681815743446, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018205681815743446, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15476791560649872, + 0.1309124082326889, + 0.0888681560754776, + 0.06110456958413124, + 0.056702621281147, + 0.0993710607290268, + 0.05792328342795372, + 0.08446570485830307, + 0.0789499580860138, + 0.18693429231643677 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018205681815743446 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a matte black hovercar visible with repulsor thrusters emitting an eerie blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do S.H.I.E.L.D. agents wearing metallic armor with blue LEDs exit the car and form a fan-shaped tactical formation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, empty hangar with cold white strip lights overhead casting sharp shadows on a highly polished black floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle, smoothly move upwards along the car's underside, and continuously circle while rising?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the agents land with knees bent to absorb impact and assume a defensive stance with pulse rifles pointed at defense zones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038112908601760864 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881128787994385 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038112908601760864, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038112908601760864, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1289292573928833, + 0.06932032108306885, + 0.08260355144739151, + 0.06123003363609314, + 0.059407442808151245, + 0.1046377643942833, + 0.3238692879676819, + 0.03371691703796387, + 0.06745968014001846, + 0.06882573664188385 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038112908601760864 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a matte black hovercar visible with repulsor thrusters emitting an eerie blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do S.H.I.E.L.D. agents wearing metallic armor with blue LEDs exit the car and form a fan-shaped tactical formation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, empty hangar with cold white strip lights overhead casting sharp shadows on a highly polished black floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle, smoothly move upwards along the car's underside, and continuously circle while rising?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the agents land with knees bent to absorb impact and assume a defensive stance with pulse rifles pointed at defense zones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014191068708896637 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264191150665283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014191068708896637, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014191068708896637, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09995149821043015, + 0.10296042263507843, + 0.10751160979270935, + 0.14939215779304504, + 0.11736813187599182, + 0.08089657127857208, + 0.061168696731328964, + 0.05395817011594772, + 0.07802848517894745, + 0.1487642377614975 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014191068708896637 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a matte black hovercar visible with repulsor thrusters emitting an eerie blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do S.H.I.E.L.D. agents wearing metallic armor with blue LEDs exit the car and form a fan-shaped tactical formation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, empty hangar with cold white strip lights overhead casting sharp shadows on a highly polished black floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle, smoothly move upwards along the car's underside, and continuously circle while rising?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the agents land with knees bent to absorb impact and assume a defensive stance with pulse rifles pointed at defense zones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029802950099110603 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298030376434326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029802950099110603, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029802950099110603, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06462985277175903, + 0.0956188514828682, + 0.08220423012971878, + 0.03880145400762558, + 0.06537146866321564, + 0.101262666285038, + 0.03734861686825752, + 0.11016714572906494, + 0.12279669940471649, + 0.2817990183830261 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029802950099110603 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a meticulously crafted, futuristic digitally rendered scene, created in Blender, a dynamic rotating camera begins at a low angle, smoothly moving upwards along the underside of a matte black hovercar, capturing the eerie blue glow of its repulsor thrusters. As the car's doors silently swing upward, S.H.I.E.L.D. agents, clad in futuristic, metallic armor, begin to gracefully exit. Their suits are a blend of polished chrome and matte carbon fiber, with thin blue LEDs glimmering at the joints. The S.H.I.E.L.D. emblem is subtly embossed on the shoulder pads, and a faint data glow shimmers beneath the dark visor of their full-face helmets. The first agent lands firmly, knees bent slightly to absorb the impact, and quickly assumes a defensive stance. Immediately afterwards, the rest of the team lands with millisecond precision, their movements synchronized, swiftly and decisively forming a perfect fan-shaped tactical formation around the hovercar, their pulse rifles steadily pointed at their respective defense zones. The camera continuously circles and slowly rises, taking in the entire scene: they are in a vast, empty hangar. Cold white strip lights overhead cast sharp, elongated shadows on the highly polished black floor, which perfectly reflects the icy sheen of the agents' metal armor and the blue halo of the hovercraft's underside. The entire scene, as it rotates, exudes a sense of orderly tension and ultimate professionalism. The precise capture of light and shadow highlights the surreal quality and cold technological atmosphere brought by digital rendering.", + "seed": 7245, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_15/index_1324_seed_7245_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03558159526437521, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03558159526437521, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03558159526437521, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a matte black hovercar visible with repulsor thrusters emitting an eerie blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do S.H.I.E.L.D. agents wearing metallic armor with blue LEDs exit the car and form a fan-shaped tactical formation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, empty hangar with cold white strip lights overhead casting sharp shadows on a highly polished black floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle, smoothly move upwards along the car's underside, and continuously circle while rising?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the agents land with knees bent to absorb impact and assume a defensive stance with pulse rifles pointed at defense zones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03877365589141846 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288773536682129 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03877365589141846, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03877365589141846, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2445412129163742, + 0.07837036997079849, + 0.17797882854938507, + 0.077161505818367, + 0.05058576539158821, + 0.08382167667150497, + 0.09965009242296219, + 0.06080149859189987, + 0.055868346244096756, + 0.07122070342302322 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03877365589141846 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a matte black hovercar visible with repulsor thrusters emitting an eerie blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do S.H.I.E.L.D. agents wearing metallic armor with blue LEDs exit the car and form a fan-shaped tactical formation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, empty hangar with cold white strip lights overhead casting sharp shadows on a highly polished black floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle, smoothly move upwards along the car's underside, and continuously circle while rising?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the agents land with knees bent to absorb impact and assume a defensive stance with pulse rifles pointed at defense zones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048697810620069504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486977100372314 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048697810620069504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048697810620069504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18865156173706055, + 0.031016767024993896, + 0.04209867864847183, + 0.12518547475337982, + 0.055195000022649765, + 0.11067036539316177, + 0.11495271325111389, + 0.07971128076314926, + 0.10441187024116516, + 0.14810633659362793 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048697810620069504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a matte black hovercar visible with repulsor thrusters emitting an eerie blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do S.H.I.E.L.D. agents wearing metallic armor with blue LEDs exit the car and form a fan-shaped tactical formation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, empty hangar with cold white strip lights overhead casting sharp shadows on a highly polished black floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle, smoothly move upwards along the car's underside, and continuously circle while rising?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the agents land with knees bent to absorb impact and assume a defensive stance with pulse rifles pointed at defense zones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811967745423317 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881197929382324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811967745423317, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811967745423317, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08656774461269379, + 0.0271226167678833, + 0.21871644258499146, + 0.09494441747665405, + 0.10474858433008194, + 0.18567684292793274, + 0.08160382509231567, + 0.02857954241335392, + 0.02065940573811531, + 0.15138061344623566 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811967745423317 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a matte black hovercar visible with repulsor thrusters emitting an eerie blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do S.H.I.E.L.D. agents wearing metallic armor with blue LEDs exit the car and form a fan-shaped tactical formation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, empty hangar with cold white strip lights overhead casting sharp shadows on a highly polished black floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle, smoothly move upwards along the car's underside, and continuously circle while rising?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the agents land with knees bent to absorb impact and assume a defensive stance with pulse rifles pointed at defense zones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014196122996509075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264195919036865 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014196122996509075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014196122996509075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12787356972694397, + 0.04783741012215614, + 0.0592937208712101, + 0.07521925121545792, + 0.08444352447986603, + 0.05643576383590698, + 0.11358823627233505, + 0.16783024370670319, + 0.0554594025015831, + 0.21201889216899872 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014196122996509075 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a matte black hovercar visible with repulsor thrusters emitting an eerie blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do S.H.I.E.L.D. agents wearing metallic armor with blue LEDs exit the car and form a fan-shaped tactical formation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, empty hangar with cold white strip lights overhead casting sharp shadows on a highly polished black floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at a low angle, smoothly move upwards along the car's underside, and continuously circle while rising?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the agents land with knees bent to absorb impact and assume a defensive stance with pulse rifles pointed at defense zones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038120709359645844 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288120746612549 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038120709359645844, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038120709359645844, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22495883703231812, + 0.03829781338572502, + 0.09095360338687897, + 0.11325205117464066, + 0.11604972928762436, + 0.07657166570425034, + 0.10577233135700226, + 0.06932336837053299, + 0.06738222390413284, + 0.09743835031986237 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038120709359645844 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_2/index_tensor([6418, 6418])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_2/index_tensor([6418, 6418])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7912b51f75e63dbc2e07b38a52364680c47e97da --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_2/index_tensor([6418, 6418])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle camera slowly tilts right, capturing a pristine, silent scene on the smooth, muddy banks of a river deep within a humid swamp. Dim predawn light filters through a canopy of cypress trees draped with Spanish moss, and a massive alligator begins to move. Its massive body, a fortress of dark olive-green scales caked with sticky mud, deliberately unfolds from its resting position. Its immense weight shifts with an unstoppable, silent grace, its armored form beginning to slide down the riverbank. The movement is fluid and stealthy, as its powerful legs and underbelly glide over the wet earth, leading it down into the dark, murky waters below. The entrance is almost silent, replacing the opaque black-green water with slow, heavy waves that silently lap against the gnarled tree roots at the water's edge, leaving only faint ripples to mark its silent descent into the depths. The atmosphere is rich, imbued with a quiet, ancient tension, rendered in a cool, desaturated palette of browns, greens, and blacks.", + "seed": 21697, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_2/index_6418_seed_21697_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.027686776500195263, + "vlm_logprob": -0.027686776500195263, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.027686776500195263, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and does it tilt slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the smooth, muddy banks of a river within a humid swamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive alligator visible with dark olive-green scales caked in sticky mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the alligator move with fluid, stealthy grace, sliding down the riverbank into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual palette cool and desaturated, featuring browns, greens, and blacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06297978013753891 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4379796981811523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06297978013753891, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06297978013753891, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10081518441438675, + 0.060711536556482315, + 0.04775432497262955, + 0.08333426713943481, + 0.31594935059547424, + 0.15540096163749695, + 0.04397667199373245, + 0.040310315787792206, + 0.06973094493150711, + 0.08201650530099869 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06297978013753891 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and does it tilt slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the smooth, muddy banks of a river within a humid swamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive alligator visible with dark olive-green scales caked in sticky mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the alligator move with fluid, stealthy grace, sliding down the riverbank into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual palette cool and desaturated, featuring browns, greens, and blacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0263705775141716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513705253601074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0263705775141716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0263705775141716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15744826197624207, + 0.13642917573451996, + 0.09280316531658173, + 0.14746132493019104, + 0.07558921724557877, + 0.10151808708906174, + 0.06632445752620697, + 0.04672430828213692, + 0.11601600050926208, + 0.05968595668673515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0263705775141716 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and does it tilt slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the smooth, muddy banks of a river within a humid swamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive alligator visible with dark olive-green scales caked in sticky mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the alligator move with fluid, stealthy grace, sliding down the riverbank into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual palette cool and desaturated, featuring browns, greens, and blacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029804106801748276 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529803991317749 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029804106801748276, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029804106801748276, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05799344182014465, + 0.051664505153894424, + 0.024676358327269554, + 0.15155275166034698, + 0.3780391812324524, + 0.1288866400718689, + 0.03215918689966202, + 0.054147668182849884, + 0.05578037351369858, + 0.06509995460510254 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029804106801748276 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and does it tilt slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the smooth, muddy banks of a river within a humid swamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive alligator visible with dark olive-green scales caked in sticky mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the alligator move with fluid, stealthy grace, sliding down the riverbank into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual palette cool and desaturated, featuring browns, greens, and blacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012545360252261162 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387545585632324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012545360252261162, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012545360252261162, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09369255602359772, + 0.06776446849107742, + 0.03787817060947418, + 0.17387689650058746, + 0.28666552901268005, + 0.16260159015655518, + 0.048328645527362823, + 0.05219390243291855, + 0.036667924374341965, + 0.04033031687140465 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012545360252261162 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and does it tilt slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the smooth, muddy banks of a river within a humid swamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive alligator visible with dark olive-green scales caked in sticky mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the alligator move with fluid, stealthy grace, sliding down the riverbank into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual palette cool and desaturated, featuring browns, greens, and blacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006734057795256376 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067338943481445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006734057795256376, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006734057795256376, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22330011427402496, + 0.23447750508785248, + 0.026388686150312424, + 0.06143828108906746, + 0.047662876546382904, + 0.09421133249998093, + 0.10266497731208801, + 0.037492040544748306, + 0.04690707102417946, + 0.12545715272426605 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006734057795256376 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle camera slowly tilts right, capturing a pristine, silent scene on the smooth, muddy banks of a river deep within a humid swamp. Dim predawn light filters through a canopy of cypress trees draped with Spanish moss, and a massive alligator begins to move. Its massive body, a fortress of dark olive-green scales caked with sticky mud, deliberately unfolds from its resting position. Its immense weight shifts with an unstoppable, silent grace, its armored form beginning to slide down the riverbank. The movement is fluid and stealthy, as its powerful legs and underbelly glide over the wet earth, leading it down into the dark, murky waters below. The entrance is almost silent, replacing the opaque black-green water with slow, heavy waves that silently lap against the gnarled tree roots at the water's edge, leaving only faint ripples to mark its silent descent into the depths. The atmosphere is rich, imbued with a quiet, ancient tension, rendered in a cool, desaturated palette of browns, greens, and blacks.", + "seed": 21698, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_2/index_6418_seed_21698_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.0945622380822897, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0945622380822897, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.824999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0945622380822897, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and does it tilt slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the smooth, muddy banks of a river within a humid swamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive alligator visible with dark olive-green scales caked in sticky mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the alligator move with fluid, stealthy grace, sliding down the riverbank into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual palette cool and desaturated, featuring browns, greens, and blacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16230474412441254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.162304639816284 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16230474412441254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16230474412441254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.43976980447769165, + 0.06081179529428482, + 0.09299489110708237, + 0.03905460610985756, + 0.0257261972874403, + 0.047888822853565216, + 0.04024343192577362, + 0.06874492019414902, + 0.10162406414747238, + 0.0831415131688118 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16230474412441254 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and does it tilt slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the smooth, muddy banks of a river within a humid swamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive alligator visible with dark olive-green scales caked in sticky mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the alligator move with fluid, stealthy grace, sliding down the riverbank into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual palette cool and desaturated, featuring browns, greens, and blacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0700417086482048 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950416564941406 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0700417086482048, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0700417086482048, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25973549485206604, + 0.12462249398231506, + 0.05739617720246315, + 0.03645516559481621, + 0.08445582538843155, + 0.06148253753781319, + 0.015074698254466057, + 0.07260304689407349, + 0.03212165832519531, + 0.25605297088623047 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0700417086482048 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and does it tilt slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the smooth, muddy banks of a river within a humid swamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive alligator visible with dark olive-green scales caked in sticky mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the alligator move with fluid, stealthy grace, sliding down the riverbank into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual palette cool and desaturated, featuring browns, greens, and blacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20156468451023102 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015646696090698 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20156468451023102, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20156468451023102, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21659044921398163, + 0.05000089854001999, + 0.06084055081009865, + 0.1029665544629097, + 0.16222906112670898, + 0.14938654005527496, + 0.03311966732144356, + 0.0501914918422699, + 0.0568276010453701, + 0.11784720420837402 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20156468451023102 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and does it tilt slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the smooth, muddy banks of a river within a humid swamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive alligator visible with dark olive-green scales caked in sticky mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the alligator move with fluid, stealthy grace, sliding down the riverbank into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual palette cool and desaturated, featuring browns, greens, and blacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02636152133345604 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513614654541016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02636152133345604, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02636152133345604, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2746223509311676, + 0.08604415506124496, + 0.06933014839887619, + 0.12318272888660431, + 0.11533177644014359, + 0.12845221161842346, + 0.02333977445960045, + 0.06404489278793335, + 0.038314417004585266, + 0.07733747363090515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02636152133345604 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and does it tilt slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the smooth, muddy banks of a river within a humid swamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive alligator visible with dark olive-green scales caked in sticky mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the alligator move with fluid, stealthy grace, sliding down the riverbank into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual palette cool and desaturated, featuring browns, greens, and blacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012538531795144081 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387538433074951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012538531795144081, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012538531795144081, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09917009621858597, + 0.09259992837905884, + 0.3530234098434448, + 0.05796869471669197, + 0.15216852724552155, + 0.0825556144118309, + 0.019911091774702072, + 0.03662821277976036, + 0.01947898417711258, + 0.08649548888206482 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012538531795144081 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle camera slowly tilts right, capturing a pristine, silent scene on the smooth, muddy banks of a river deep within a humid swamp. Dim predawn light filters through a canopy of cypress trees draped with Spanish moss, and a massive alligator begins to move. Its massive body, a fortress of dark olive-green scales caked with sticky mud, deliberately unfolds from its resting position. Its immense weight shifts with an unstoppable, silent grace, its armored form beginning to slide down the riverbank. The movement is fluid and stealthy, as its powerful legs and underbelly glide over the wet earth, leading it down into the dark, murky waters below. The entrance is almost silent, replacing the opaque black-green water with slow, heavy waves that silently lap against the gnarled tree roots at the water's edge, leaving only faint ripples to mark its silent descent into the depths. The atmosphere is rich, imbued with a quiet, ancient tension, rendered in a cool, desaturated palette of browns, greens, and blacks.", + "seed": 21699, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_2/index_6418_seed_21699_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.0910974407568574, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0910974407568574, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0910974407568574, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and does it tilt slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the smooth, muddy banks of a river within a humid swamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive alligator visible with dark olive-green scales caked in sticky mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the alligator move with fluid, stealthy grace, sliding down the riverbank into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual palette cool and desaturated, featuring browns, greens, and blacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.273652583360672 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6486525535583496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.273652583360672, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.273652583360672, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14492493867874146, + 0.10039485991001129, + 0.04926732927560806, + 0.1023760512471199, + 0.04448163881897926, + 0.1176939606666565, + 0.1409556120634079, + 0.11563953012228012, + 0.06908603012561798, + 0.11517997831106186 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.273652583360672 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and does it tilt slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the smooth, muddy banks of a river within a humid swamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive alligator visible with dark olive-green scales caked in sticky mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the alligator move with fluid, stealthy grace, sliding down the riverbank into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual palette cool and desaturated, featuring browns, greens, and blacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308532178401947 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680853366851807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308532178401947, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308532178401947, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14270687103271484, + 0.2022213637828827, + 0.10038892179727554, + 0.09699656069278717, + 0.07228129357099533, + 0.12542347609996796, + 0.08498822897672653, + 0.06502630561590195, + 0.07775885611772537, + 0.032208170741796494 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308532178401947 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and does it tilt slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the smooth, muddy banks of a river within a humid swamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive alligator visible with dark olive-green scales caked in sticky mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the alligator move with fluid, stealthy grace, sliding down the riverbank into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual palette cool and desaturated, featuring browns, greens, and blacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10030093789100647 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503010272979736 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10030093789100647, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10030093789100647, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13915029168128967, + 0.1842847615480423, + 0.05623310059309006, + 0.0756731629371643, + 0.07853282243013382, + 0.25579628348350525, + 0.04244463890790939, + 0.06514003127813339, + 0.058161355555057526, + 0.0445835255086422 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10030093789100647 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and does it tilt slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the smooth, muddy banks of a river within a humid swamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive alligator visible with dark olive-green scales caked in sticky mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the alligator move with fluid, stealthy grace, sliding down the riverbank into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual palette cool and desaturated, featuring browns, greens, and blacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029811974614858627 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298118591308594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029811974614858627, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029811974614858627, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06402549147605896, + 0.08683644980192184, + 0.04252322390675545, + 0.11775805056095123, + 0.16709579527378082, + 0.289016455411911, + 0.057385120540857315, + 0.05954272300004959, + 0.030701475217938423, + 0.08511516451835632 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029811974614858627 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and does it tilt slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the smooth, muddy banks of a river within a humid swamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive alligator visible with dark olive-green scales caked in sticky mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the alligator move with fluid, stealthy grace, sliding down the riverbank into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual palette cool and desaturated, featuring browns, greens, and blacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008636386133730412 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758636474609375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008636386133730412, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008636386133730412, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1060466393828392, + 0.04492240026593208, + 0.12800803780555725, + 0.046838391572237015, + 0.3854805827140808, + 0.09025441855192184, + 0.04306396096944809, + 0.05643081292510033, + 0.07204775512218475, + 0.02690701372921467 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008636386133730412 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle camera slowly tilts right, capturing a pristine, silent scene on the smooth, muddy banks of a river deep within a humid swamp. Dim predawn light filters through a canopy of cypress trees draped with Spanish moss, and a massive alligator begins to move. Its massive body, a fortress of dark olive-green scales caked with sticky mud, deliberately unfolds from its resting position. Its immense weight shifts with an unstoppable, silent grace, its armored form beginning to slide down the riverbank. The movement is fluid and stealthy, as its powerful legs and underbelly glide over the wet earth, leading it down into the dark, murky waters below. The entrance is almost silent, replacing the opaque black-green water with slow, heavy waves that silently lap against the gnarled tree roots at the water's edge, leaving only faint ripples to mark its silent descent into the depths. The atmosphere is rich, imbued with a quiet, ancient tension, rendered in a cool, desaturated palette of browns, greens, and blacks.", + "seed": 21700, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_2/index_6418_seed_21700_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03609668780118227, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03609668780118227, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03609668780118227, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and does it tilt slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the smooth, muddy banks of a river within a humid swamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive alligator visible with dark olive-green scales caked in sticky mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the alligator move with fluid, stealthy grace, sliding down the riverbank into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual palette cool and desaturated, featuring browns, greens, and blacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08569541573524475 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.085695505142212 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08569541573524475, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08569541573524475, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09042522311210632, + 0.027405694127082825, + 0.04405587911605835, + 0.09865637123584747, + 0.05146358162164688, + 0.12786655128002167, + 0.08034227788448334, + 0.28464531898498535, + 0.10957949608564377, + 0.08555962890386581 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08569541573524475 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and does it tilt slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the smooth, muddy banks of a river within a humid swamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive alligator visible with dark olive-green scales caked in sticky mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the alligator move with fluid, stealthy grace, sliding down the riverbank into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual palette cool and desaturated, featuring browns, greens, and blacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023306475952267647 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773306369781494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023306475952267647, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023306475952267647, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13756360113620758, + 0.09892891347408295, + 0.06046582758426666, + 0.12780849635601044, + 0.037688177078962326, + 0.18043199181556702, + 0.08823440223932266, + 0.15259505808353424, + 0.03275226801633835, + 0.0835312157869339 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023306475952267647 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and does it tilt slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the smooth, muddy banks of a river within a humid swamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive alligator visible with dark olive-green scales caked in sticky mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the alligator move with fluid, stealthy grace, sliding down the riverbank into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual palette cool and desaturated, featuring browns, greens, and blacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865068942308426 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486507415771484 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865068942308426, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865068942308426, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0912756472826004, + 0.033768218010663986, + 0.05471077933907509, + 0.12633073329925537, + 0.05636594817042351, + 0.267465740442276, + 0.16656547784805298, + 0.11321566998958588, + 0.03599020466208458, + 0.054311543703079224 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865068942308426 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and does it tilt slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the smooth, muddy banks of a river within a humid swamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive alligator visible with dark olive-green scales caked in sticky mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the alligator move with fluid, stealthy grace, sliding down the riverbank into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual palette cool and desaturated, featuring browns, greens, and blacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014195535331964493 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264195442199707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014195535331964493, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014195535331964493, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0369383879005909, + 0.018879184499382973, + 0.03289596363902092, + 0.10732418298721313, + 0.0522073432803154, + 0.28078293800354004, + 0.09401655197143555, + 0.23087093234062195, + 0.08612900972366333, + 0.059955496340990067 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014195535331964493 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera angle low and does it tilt slowly to the right?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set on the smooth, muddy banks of a river within a humid swamp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive alligator visible with dark olive-green scales caked in sticky mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the alligator move with fluid, stealthy grace, sliding down the riverbank into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual palette cool and desaturated, featuring browns, greens, and blacks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0086353225633502 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758635520935059 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0086353225633502, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0086353225633502, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12243475764989853, + 0.026885509490966797, + 0.034958161413669586, + 0.03240538761019707, + 0.0714254304766655, + 0.15175002813339233, + 0.045211270451545715, + 0.30447205901145935, + 0.08962874859571457, + 0.12082868069410324 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0086353225633502 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_3/index_tensor([6895, 6895])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_3/index_tensor([6895, 6895])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..435ed0154307c45ef6a0a05539538f05932d7609 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_3/index_tensor([6895, 6895])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a stunningly surreal close-up, the camera remains absolutely still, focused on the mirror-like concave surface of a warm, translucent jade spoon. Within this small, curved world, the entire process of rejuvenation is vividly reflected: a white-haired, withered Tang Dynasty scholar undergoes a process of rejuvenation. Clad in a faded, ink-colored robe, he carefully places a humanoid piece of Polygonum multiflorum into his mouth. As he swallows, the wrinkles on his face smooth like ripples, and his cloudy eyes regain clarity. Most strikingly, his silver hair transforms from its roots to a lustrous black at a visible speed. In this moment of transformation, wisps of mysterious, neon-like purple mist rise from his hair. The vast background beyond the spoon is blurred, revealing Meng Po's face, wrinkled like deep canyons, each crevices a fluid, ever-shifting stream of light and shadow flowing from the Well of Samsara. Across the edges of the painting, fragments of the Book of Life and Death, their edges ablaze with blue digital flames, slowly drift down, adding a sense of fate to this scene that blends classical mythology with futurism. The overall visual style adheres closely to cyberpunk ink-wash rendering, using the varying shades of ink, dryness, and wetness to depict the contours and textures of figures and backgrounds, punctuated by highly saturated purple and blue neon lighting effects, creating a unique atmosphere that is both classical and avant-garde, sacred and eerie.", + "seed": 30280, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_3/index_6895_seed_30280_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.054267676919698714, + "vlm_logprob": -0.054267676919698714, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.054267676919698714, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on a close-up of a warm, translucent jade spoon with a mirror-like concave surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white-haired, withered Tang Dynasty scholar in a faded ink-colored robe visible within the reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar swallow a humanoid piece of Polygonum multiflorum while his wrinkles smooth and silver hair turns black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do wisps of neon-like purple mist rise from the scholar's hair during the transformation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to show Meng Po's face and fragments of the Book of Life and Death with blue digital flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.022123675793409348 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8971235752105713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.022123675793409348, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.022123675793409348, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5327719449996948, + 0.06035176292061806, + 0.04584643989801407, + 0.023593518882989883, + 0.09656720608472824, + 0.06293695420026779, + 0.06440714001655579, + 0.047759804874658585, + 0.03634938225150108, + 0.029415937140583992 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.022123675793409348 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on a close-up of a warm, translucent jade spoon with a mirror-like concave surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white-haired, withered Tang Dynasty scholar in a faded ink-colored robe visible within the reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar swallow a humanoid piece of Polygonum multiflorum while his wrinkles smooth and silver hair turns black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do wisps of neon-like purple mist rise from the scholar's hair during the transformation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to show Meng Po's face and fragments of the Book of Life and Death with blue digital flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10032790154218674 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350327968597412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10032790154218674, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10032790154218674, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7698056697845459, + 0.019577965140342712, + 0.02833406627178192, + 0.009435674175620079, + 0.04791271314024925, + 0.016822267323732376, + 0.0405287966132164, + 0.026935135945677757, + 0.013320371508598328, + 0.027327358722686768 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10032790154218674 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on a close-up of a warm, translucent jade spoon with a mirror-like concave surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white-haired, withered Tang Dynasty scholar in a faded ink-colored robe visible within the reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar swallow a humanoid piece of Polygonum multiflorum while his wrinkles smooth and silver hair turns black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do wisps of neon-like purple mist rise from the scholar's hair during the transformation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to show Meng Po's face and fragments of the Book of Life and Death with blue digital flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06210441514849663 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8121044635772705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06210441514849663, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06210441514849663, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5453674793243408, + 0.04103006795048714, + 0.05044344812631607, + 0.01909424550831318, + 0.056611549109220505, + 0.027674395591020584, + 0.08034148812294006, + 0.08135675638914108, + 0.04396276921033859, + 0.054117728024721146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06210441514849663 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on a close-up of a warm, translucent jade spoon with a mirror-like concave surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white-haired, withered Tang Dynasty scholar in a faded ink-colored robe visible within the reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar swallow a humanoid piece of Polygonum multiflorum while his wrinkles smooth and silver hair turns black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do wisps of neon-like purple mist rise from the scholar's hair during the transformation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to show Meng Po's face and fragments of the Book of Life and Death with blue digital flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866386204957962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048663854598999 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866386204957962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866386204957962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3662254512310028, + 0.03268556296825409, + 0.025570368394255638, + 0.038693372160196304, + 0.04087121784687042, + 0.05070441588759422, + 0.1166558787226677, + 0.09516974538564682, + 0.11136557906866074, + 0.12205838412046432 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866386204957962 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on a close-up of a warm, translucent jade spoon with a mirror-like concave surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white-haired, withered Tang Dynasty scholar in a faded ink-colored robe visible within the reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar swallow a humanoid piece of Polygonum multiflorum while his wrinkles smooth and silver hair turns black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do wisps of neon-like purple mist rise from the scholar's hair during the transformation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to show Meng Po's face and fragments of the Book of Life and Death with blue digital flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811853006482124 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288118600845337 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811853006482124, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811853006482124, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23933497071266174, + 0.033087991178035736, + 0.051988385617733, + 0.042806945741176605, + 0.123977430164814, + 0.07101324945688248, + 0.10076996684074402, + 0.11031287163496017, + 0.12375547736883163, + 0.10295266658067703 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811853006482124 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a stunningly surreal close-up, the camera remains absolutely still, focused on the mirror-like concave surface of a warm, translucent jade spoon. Within this small, curved world, the entire process of rejuvenation is vividly reflected: a white-haired, withered Tang Dynasty scholar undergoes a process of rejuvenation. Clad in a faded, ink-colored robe, he carefully places a humanoid piece of Polygonum multiflorum into his mouth. As he swallows, the wrinkles on his face smooth like ripples, and his cloudy eyes regain clarity. Most strikingly, his silver hair transforms from its roots to a lustrous black at a visible speed. In this moment of transformation, wisps of mysterious, neon-like purple mist rise from his hair. The vast background beyond the spoon is blurred, revealing Meng Po's face, wrinkled like deep canyons, each crevices a fluid, ever-shifting stream of light and shadow flowing from the Well of Samsara. Across the edges of the painting, fragments of the Book of Life and Death, their edges ablaze with blue digital flames, slowly drift down, adding a sense of fate to this scene that blends classical mythology with futurism. The overall visual style adheres closely to cyberpunk ink-wash rendering, using the varying shades of ink, dryness, and wetness to depict the contours and textures of figures and backgrounds, punctuated by highly saturated purple and blue neon lighting effects, creating a unique atmosphere that is both classical and avant-garde, sacred and eerie.", + "seed": 30281, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_3/index_6895_seed_30281_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03209530301392079, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03209530301392079, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03209530301392079, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on a close-up of a warm, translucent jade spoon with a mirror-like concave surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white-haired, withered Tang Dynasty scholar in a faded ink-colored robe visible within the reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar swallow a humanoid piece of Polygonum multiflorum while his wrinkles smooth and silver hair turns black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do wisps of neon-like purple mist rise from the scholar's hair during the transformation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to show Meng Po's face and fragments of the Book of Life and Death with blue digital flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04444168508052826 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1694416999816895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04444168508052826, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04444168508052826, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2230612188577652, + 0.03373197093605995, + 0.023831771686673164, + 0.04065612703561783, + 0.044716477394104004, + 0.08361860364675522, + 0.3025834858417511, + 0.0843992531299591, + 0.04904509335756302, + 0.11435601860284805 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04444168508052826 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on a close-up of a warm, translucent jade spoon with a mirror-like concave surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white-haired, withered Tang Dynasty scholar in a faded ink-colored robe visible within the reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar swallow a humanoid piece of Polygonum multiflorum while his wrinkles smooth and silver hair turns black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do wisps of neon-like purple mist rise from the scholar's hair during the transformation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to show Meng Po's face and fragments of the Book of Life and Death with blue digital flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014215044677257538 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264214992523193 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014215044677257538, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014215044677257538, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23222129046916962, + 0.048703163862228394, + 0.05486857146024704, + 0.043493036180734634, + 0.030125750228762627, + 0.1198439672589302, + 0.21006286144256592, + 0.06301909685134888, + 0.08850336819887161, + 0.10915891081094742 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014215044677257538 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on a close-up of a warm, translucent jade spoon with a mirror-like concave surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white-haired, withered Tang Dynasty scholar in a faded ink-colored robe visible within the reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar swallow a humanoid piece of Polygonum multiflorum while his wrinkles smooth and silver hair turns black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do wisps of neon-like purple mist rise from the scholar's hair during the transformation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to show Meng Po's face and fragments of the Book of Life and Death with blue digital flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048709508031606674 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0487093925476074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048709508031606674, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048709508031606674, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18521083891391754, + 0.04496258497238159, + 0.033205755054950714, + 0.03720700368285179, + 0.04438488557934761, + 0.058468569070100784, + 0.142775297164917, + 0.06497889012098312, + 0.12752792239189148, + 0.26127827167510986 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048709508031606674 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on a close-up of a warm, translucent jade spoon with a mirror-like concave surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white-haired, withered Tang Dynasty scholar in a faded ink-colored robe visible within the reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar swallow a humanoid piece of Polygonum multiflorum while his wrinkles smooth and silver hair turns black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do wisps of neon-like purple mist rise from the scholar's hair during the transformation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to show Meng Po's face and fragments of the Book of Life and Death with blue digital flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329506166279316 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732951641082764 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329506166279316, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329506166279316, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13205546140670776, + 0.03677867725491524, + 0.020713871344923973, + 0.016066651791334152, + 0.04290815815329552, + 0.05306427925825119, + 0.13549484312534332, + 0.1332288384437561, + 0.1848582625389099, + 0.244830921292305 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329506166279316 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on a close-up of a warm, translucent jade spoon with a mirror-like concave surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white-haired, withered Tang Dynasty scholar in a faded ink-colored robe visible within the reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar swallow a humanoid piece of Polygonum multiflorum while his wrinkles smooth and silver hair turns black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do wisps of neon-like purple mist rise from the scholar's hair during the transformation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to show Meng Po's face and fragments of the Book of Life and Death with blue digital flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02981521561741829 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529815196990967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02981521561741829, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02981521561741829, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1142105981707573, + 0.08088667690753937, + 0.04164176061749458, + 0.029845410957932472, + 0.047989293932914734, + 0.10318960249423981, + 0.23387420177459717, + 0.14279747009277344, + 0.10848718881607056, + 0.09707780927419662 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02981521561741829 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a stunningly surreal close-up, the camera remains absolutely still, focused on the mirror-like concave surface of a warm, translucent jade spoon. Within this small, curved world, the entire process of rejuvenation is vividly reflected: a white-haired, withered Tang Dynasty scholar undergoes a process of rejuvenation. Clad in a faded, ink-colored robe, he carefully places a humanoid piece of Polygonum multiflorum into his mouth. As he swallows, the wrinkles on his face smooth like ripples, and his cloudy eyes regain clarity. Most strikingly, his silver hair transforms from its roots to a lustrous black at a visible speed. In this moment of transformation, wisps of mysterious, neon-like purple mist rise from his hair. The vast background beyond the spoon is blurred, revealing Meng Po's face, wrinkled like deep canyons, each crevices a fluid, ever-shifting stream of light and shadow flowing from the Well of Samsara. Across the edges of the painting, fragments of the Book of Life and Death, their edges ablaze with blue digital flames, slowly drift down, adding a sense of fate to this scene that blends classical mythology with futurism. The overall visual style adheres closely to cyberpunk ink-wash rendering, using the varying shades of ink, dryness, and wetness to depict the contours and textures of figures and backgrounds, punctuated by highly saturated purple and blue neon lighting effects, creating a unique atmosphere that is both classical and avant-garde, sacred and eerie.", + "seed": 30282, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_3/index_6895_seed_30282_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.029607072472572327, + "vlm_logprob": -0.029607072472572327, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.029607072472572327, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on a close-up of a warm, translucent jade spoon with a mirror-like concave surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white-haired, withered Tang Dynasty scholar in a faded ink-colored robe visible within the reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar swallow a humanoid piece of Polygonum multiflorum while his wrinkles smooth and silver hair turns black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do wisps of neon-like purple mist rise from the scholar's hair during the transformation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to show Meng Po's face and fragments of the Book of Life and Death with blue digital flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009849637746810913 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.759849548339844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009849637746810913, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009849637746810913, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16037917137145996, + 0.08171436190605164, + 0.03666263818740845, + 0.07544181495904922, + 0.10301216691732407, + 0.07827631384134293, + 0.23861974477767944, + 0.03565442934632301, + 0.10115286707878113, + 0.08908654749393463 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009849637746810913 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on a close-up of a warm, translucent jade spoon with a mirror-like concave surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white-haired, withered Tang Dynasty scholar in a faded ink-colored robe visible within the reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar swallow a humanoid piece of Polygonum multiflorum while his wrinkles smooth and silver hair turns black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do wisps of neon-like purple mist rise from the scholar's hair during the transformation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to show Meng Po's face and fragments of the Book of Life and Death with blue digital flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06207394227385521 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120739459991455 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06207394227385521, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06207394227385521, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12878191471099854, + 0.09704601764678955, + 0.036070890724658966, + 0.04565581679344177, + 0.06880959123373032, + 0.14700476825237274, + 0.2182910144329071, + 0.05261589214205742, + 0.11448106169700623, + 0.09124299883842468 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06207394227385521 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on a close-up of a warm, translucent jade spoon with a mirror-like concave surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white-haired, withered Tang Dynasty scholar in a faded ink-colored robe visible within the reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar swallow a humanoid piece of Polygonum multiflorum while his wrinkles smooth and silver hair turns black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do wisps of neon-like purple mist rise from the scholar's hair during the transformation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to show Meng Po's face and fragments of the Book of Life and Death with blue digital flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03375307843089104 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087531566619873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03375307843089104, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03375307843089104, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12626148760318756, + 0.05859249085187912, + 0.03386833518743515, + 0.04669056832790375, + 0.06038445979356766, + 0.18997304141521454, + 0.12312678247690201, + 0.047705668956041336, + 0.22932274639606476, + 0.08407442271709442 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03375307843089104 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on a close-up of a warm, translucent jade spoon with a mirror-like concave surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white-haired, withered Tang Dynasty scholar in a faded ink-colored robe visible within the reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar swallow a humanoid piece of Polygonum multiflorum while his wrinkles smooth and silver hair turns black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do wisps of neon-like purple mist rise from the scholar's hair during the transformation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to show Meng Po's face and fragments of the Book of Life and Death with blue digital flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00864158570766449 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758641719818115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00864158570766449, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00864158570766449, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.098040372133255, + 0.025646420195698738, + 0.027042854577302933, + 0.0297885462641716, + 0.03738396242260933, + 0.1686176359653473, + 0.1104382798075676, + 0.11373213678598404, + 0.18024080991744995, + 0.20906902849674225 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00864158570766449 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on a close-up of a warm, translucent jade spoon with a mirror-like concave surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white-haired, withered Tang Dynasty scholar in a faded ink-colored robe visible within the reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar swallow a humanoid piece of Polygonum multiflorum while his wrinkles smooth and silver hair turns black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do wisps of neon-like purple mist rise from the scholar's hair during the transformation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to show Meng Po's face and fragments of the Book of Life and Death with blue digital flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033717118203639984 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408717155456543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033717118203639984, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033717118203639984, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12741830945014954, + 0.07606300711631775, + 0.021789425984025, + 0.04554241523146629, + 0.06665491312742233, + 0.11025478690862656, + 0.2528427839279175, + 0.05688466131687164, + 0.12255404889583588, + 0.1199956163764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033717118203639984 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a stunningly surreal close-up, the camera remains absolutely still, focused on the mirror-like concave surface of a warm, translucent jade spoon. Within this small, curved world, the entire process of rejuvenation is vividly reflected: a white-haired, withered Tang Dynasty scholar undergoes a process of rejuvenation. Clad in a faded, ink-colored robe, he carefully places a humanoid piece of Polygonum multiflorum into his mouth. As he swallows, the wrinkles on his face smooth like ripples, and his cloudy eyes regain clarity. Most strikingly, his silver hair transforms from its roots to a lustrous black at a visible speed. In this moment of transformation, wisps of mysterious, neon-like purple mist rise from his hair. The vast background beyond the spoon is blurred, revealing Meng Po's face, wrinkled like deep canyons, each crevices a fluid, ever-shifting stream of light and shadow flowing from the Well of Samsara. Across the edges of the painting, fragments of the Book of Life and Death, their edges ablaze with blue digital flames, slowly drift down, adding a sense of fate to this scene that blends classical mythology with futurism. The overall visual style adheres closely to cyberpunk ink-wash rendering, using the varying shades of ink, dryness, and wetness to depict the contours and textures of figures and backgrounds, punctuated by highly saturated purple and blue neon lighting effects, creating a unique atmosphere that is both classical and avant-garde, sacred and eerie.", + "seed": 30283, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_3/index_6895_seed_30283_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07931437902152538, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07931437902152538, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07931437902152538, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on a close-up of a warm, translucent jade spoon with a mirror-like concave surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white-haired, withered Tang Dynasty scholar in a faded ink-colored robe visible within the reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar swallow a humanoid piece of Polygonum multiflorum while his wrinkles smooth and silver hair turns black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do wisps of neon-like purple mist rise from the scholar's hair during the transformation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to show Meng Po's face and fragments of the Book of Life and Death with blue digital flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04837121069431305 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1733713150024414 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04837121069431305, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04837121069431305, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2443113625049591, + 0.1656200885772705, + 0.10549315810203552, + 0.0932077094912529, + 0.0366978645324707, + 0.10905041545629501, + 0.09939708560705185, + 0.06610368937253952, + 0.03837290033698082, + 0.041745640337467194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04837121069431305 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on a close-up of a warm, translucent jade spoon with a mirror-like concave surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white-haired, withered Tang Dynasty scholar in a faded ink-colored robe visible within the reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar swallow a humanoid piece of Polygonum multiflorum while his wrinkles smooth and silver hair turns black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do wisps of neon-like purple mist rise from the scholar's hair during the transformation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to show Meng Po's face and fragments of the Book of Life and Death with blue digital flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05500755459070206 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9300074577331543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05500755459070206, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05500755459070206, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19661295413970947, + 0.1906900256872177, + 0.07503440231084824, + 0.15420879423618317, + 0.07297692447900772, + 0.07992954552173615, + 0.08144991844892502, + 0.07509204000234604, + 0.03047225810587406, + 0.043533165007829666 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05500755459070206 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on a close-up of a warm, translucent jade spoon with a mirror-like concave surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white-haired, withered Tang Dynasty scholar in a faded ink-colored robe visible within the reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar swallow a humanoid piece of Polygonum multiflorum while his wrinkles smooth and silver hair turns black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do wisps of neon-like purple mist rise from the scholar's hair during the transformation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to show Meng Po's face and fragments of the Book of Life and Death with blue digital flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02985362894833088 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529853582382202 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02985362894833088, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02985362894833088, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.178728848695755, + 0.07813043892383575, + 0.08419401198625565, + 0.10813143849372864, + 0.1300612837076187, + 0.09411309659481049, + 0.09862440079450607, + 0.08981633186340332, + 0.08258102834224701, + 0.055619072169065475 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02985362894833088 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on a close-up of a warm, translucent jade spoon with a mirror-like concave surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white-haired, withered Tang Dynasty scholar in a faded ink-colored robe visible within the reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar swallow a humanoid piece of Polygonum multiflorum while his wrinkles smooth and silver hair turns black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do wisps of neon-like purple mist rise from the scholar's hair during the transformation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to show Meng Po's face and fragments of the Book of Life and Death with blue digital flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011088889092206955 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511088848114014 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011088889092206955, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011088889092206955, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18818561732769012, + 0.08719172328710556, + 0.04657595604658127, + 0.04478619247674942, + 0.04245574027299881, + 0.07097417861223221, + 0.07317262887954712, + 0.18571282923221588, + 0.1280447542667389, + 0.1329004466533661 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011088889092206955 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on a close-up of a warm, translucent jade spoon with a mirror-like concave surface?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a white-haired, withered Tang Dynasty scholar in a faded ink-colored robe visible within the reflection?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the scholar swallow a humanoid piece of Polygonum multiflorum while his wrinkles smooth and silver hair turns black?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do wisps of neon-like purple mist rise from the scholar's hair during the transformation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background blurred to show Meng Po's face and fragments of the Book of Life and Death with blue digital flames?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.252250611782074 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5022506713867188 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.252250611782074, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.252250611782074, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2102411985397339, + 0.10699744522571564, + 0.05583886429667473, + 0.04621068015694618, + 0.043607987463474274, + 0.13015465438365936, + 0.11621220409870148, + 0.1310511827468872, + 0.10000389814376831, + 0.05968189612030983 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.252250611782074 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_4/index_tensor([1985, 1985])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_4/index_tensor([1985, 1985])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e9413f97c202a8229cf24649aeaf919aa5f65bcc --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_4/index_tensor([1985, 1985])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "cinematic camera slowly zooms in, deep into a tranquil forest shrouded in morning mist, finally focusing on an ancient cherry tree with twisted, deeply veined branches. From a deep, smooth-edged natural hollow mid-trunk, a sacred white fox cautiously and slowly emerges its immaculate head. Its soft, fluffy white fur seems to glow, its amber eyes sparkle with wisdom and curiosity, and its nose is delicately moistened with moisture. A soft, ethereal glow emanates naturally from its form, softly illuminating its alertly pointed ears and the ancient bark surrounding the cave's entrance. It also shimmers at the tips of its nine magnificent tails, gracefully unfurling behind it, barely visible within the cavern. The moment it peeks out, a few delicate pink cherry blossom petals are blown by the breeze and gently fall in front of it like snow. The whole picture presents the delicate hand-painted texture of Studio Ghibli animation, and each frame is covered with a layer of subtle and realistic film grain, creating a tranquil atmosphere that is both dreamy and sacred and full of nostalgic reality.", + "seed": 31409, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_4/index_1985_seed_31409_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0914387296885252, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0914387296885252, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7499999523162844, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0914387296885252, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a tranquil forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white fox with nine tails emerge from a hollow in an ancient cherry tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pink cherry blossom petals falling in front of the fox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a Studio Ghibli hand-painted texture with film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07051863521337509 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.820518732070923 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07051863521337509, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07051863521337509, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13460195064544678, + 0.08817403763532639, + 0.16437044739723206, + 0.19892483949661255, + 0.14464537799358368, + 0.08753607422113419, + 0.03837860748171806, + 0.05308550223708153, + 0.05424429848790169, + 0.03603891655802727 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07051863521337509 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a tranquil forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white fox with nine tails emerge from a hollow in an ancient cherry tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pink cherry blossom petals falling in front of the fox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a Studio Ghibli hand-painted texture with film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22566646337509155 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006665229797363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22566646337509155, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22566646337509155, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1909647136926651, + 0.15128090977668762, + 0.15281924605369568, + 0.15243546664714813, + 0.12460602074861526, + 0.04416099190711975, + 0.03729824721813202, + 0.04069950059056282, + 0.07538189738988876, + 0.030353080481290817 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22566646337509155 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a tranquil forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white fox with nine tails emerge from a hollow in an ancient cherry tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pink cherry blossom petals falling in front of the fox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a Studio Ghibli hand-painted texture with film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029832223430275917 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529832124710083 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029832223430275917, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029832223430275917, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15622089803218842, + 0.06004868820309639, + 0.04039996489882469, + 0.1272735595703125, + 0.0843084529042244, + 0.049075525254011154, + 0.08628068119287491, + 0.09312983602285385, + 0.1312907487154007, + 0.17197167873382568 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029832223430275917 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a tranquil forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white fox with nine tails emerge from a hollow in an ancient cherry tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pink cherry blossom petals falling in front of the fox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a Studio Ghibli hand-painted texture with film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11296865344047546 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.237968683242798 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11296865344047546, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11296865344047546, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2915268838405609, + 0.13984084129333496, + 0.18195581436157227, + 0.05560700222849846, + 0.04909466952085495, + 0.06073496863245964, + 0.059971872717142105, + 0.08387336134910583, + 0.03744283318519592, + 0.039951715618371964 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11296865344047546 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a tranquil forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white fox with nine tails emerge from a hollow in an ancient cherry tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pink cherry blossom petals falling in front of the fox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a Studio Ghibli hand-painted texture with film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018207672983407974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018207550048828 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018207672983407974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018207672983407974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1347656100988388, + 0.10195615887641907, + 0.14818595349788666, + 0.16558097302913666, + 0.0691417008638382, + 0.04416032135486603, + 0.05422208458185196, + 0.12869970500469208, + 0.0747273787856102, + 0.07856012135744095 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018207672983407974 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematic camera slowly zooms in, deep into a tranquil forest shrouded in morning mist, finally focusing on an ancient cherry tree with twisted, deeply veined branches. From a deep, smooth-edged natural hollow mid-trunk, a sacred white fox cautiously and slowly emerges its immaculate head. Its soft, fluffy white fur seems to glow, its amber eyes sparkle with wisdom and curiosity, and its nose is delicately moistened with moisture. A soft, ethereal glow emanates naturally from its form, softly illuminating its alertly pointed ears and the ancient bark surrounding the cave's entrance. It also shimmers at the tips of its nine magnificent tails, gracefully unfurling behind it, barely visible within the cavern. The moment it peeks out, a few delicate pink cherry blossom petals are blown by the breeze and gently fall in front of it like snow. The whole picture presents the delicate hand-painted texture of Studio Ghibli animation, and each frame is covered with a layer of subtle and realistic film grain, creating a tranquil atmosphere that is both dreamy and sacred and full of nostalgic reality.", + "seed": 31410, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_4/index_1985_seed_31410_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.10750966034829616, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10750966034829616, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10750966034829616, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a tranquil forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white fox with nine tails emerge from a hollow in an ancient cherry tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pink cherry blossom petals falling in front of the fox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a Studio Ghibli hand-painted texture with film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2545824944972992 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5045825242996216 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2545824944972992, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2545824944972992, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5283834934234619, + 0.16431541740894318, + 0.11401688307523727, + 0.018243761733174324, + 0.011050364002585411, + 0.046024058014154434, + 0.005602151621133089, + 0.029045097529888153, + 0.07976019382476807, + 0.0035585046280175447 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2545824944972992 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a tranquil forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white fox with nine tails emerge from a hollow in an ancient cherry tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pink cherry blossom petals falling in front of the fox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a Studio Ghibli hand-painted texture with film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521531581878662 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021531581878662 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521531581878662, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521531581878662, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4513172209262848, + 0.2935047745704651, + 0.16880396008491516, + 0.008884531445801258, + 0.00563541566953063, + 0.018883930519223213, + 0.009990504942834377, + 0.01170289795845747, + 0.02328728698194027, + 0.007989405654370785 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521531581878662 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a tranquil forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white fox with nine tails emerge from a hollow in an ancient cherry tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pink cherry blossom petals falling in front of the fox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a Studio Ghibli hand-painted texture with film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01108712051063776 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511086940765381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01108712051063776, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01108712051063776, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4642450213432312, + 0.19890497624874115, + 0.07530667632818222, + 0.016857929527759552, + 0.010088070295751095, + 0.09758570045232773, + 0.039302192628383636, + 0.013658072799444199, + 0.05614633485674858, + 0.027905065566301346 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01108712051063776 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a tranquil forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white fox with nine tails emerge from a hollow in an ancient cherry tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pink cherry blossom petals falling in front of the fox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a Studio Ghibli hand-painted texture with film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011081697419285774 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511081695556641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011081697419285774, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011081697419285774, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.45366987586021423, + 0.368977814912796, + 0.10172128677368164, + 0.011500891298055649, + 0.0032642497681081295, + 0.02118011750280857, + 0.004293204750865698, + 0.011534716002643108, + 0.020237641409039497, + 0.003620116040110588 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011081697419285774 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a tranquil forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white fox with nine tails emerge from a hollow in an ancient cherry tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pink cherry blossom petals falling in front of the fox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a Studio Ghibli hand-painted texture with film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008643831126391888 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758643627166748 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008643831126391888, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008643831126391888, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3347361087799072, + 0.39612314105033875, + 0.13048915565013885, + 0.03149963542819023, + 0.013676288537681103, + 0.01374843344092369, + 0.016623210161924362, + 0.0283818356692791, + 0.024658355861902237, + 0.01006376463919878 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008643831126391888 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematic camera slowly zooms in, deep into a tranquil forest shrouded in morning mist, finally focusing on an ancient cherry tree with twisted, deeply veined branches. From a deep, smooth-edged natural hollow mid-trunk, a sacred white fox cautiously and slowly emerges its immaculate head. Its soft, fluffy white fur seems to glow, its amber eyes sparkle with wisdom and curiosity, and its nose is delicately moistened with moisture. A soft, ethereal glow emanates naturally from its form, softly illuminating its alertly pointed ears and the ancient bark surrounding the cave's entrance. It also shimmers at the tips of its nine magnificent tails, gracefully unfurling behind it, barely visible within the cavern. The moment it peeks out, a few delicate pink cherry blossom petals are blown by the breeze and gently fall in front of it like snow. The whole picture presents the delicate hand-painted texture of Studio Ghibli animation, and each frame is covered with a layer of subtle and realistic film grain, creating a tranquil atmosphere that is both dreamy and sacred and full of nostalgic reality.", + "seed": 31411, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_4/index_1985_seed_31411_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.0603264098521322, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0603264098521322, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0603264098521322, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a tranquil forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white fox with nine tails emerge from a hollow in an ancient cherry tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pink cherry blossom petals falling in front of the fox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a Studio Ghibli hand-painted texture with film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11799240112304688 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.242992401123047 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11799240112304688, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11799240112304688, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2847570776939392, + 0.1635189652442932, + 0.13391940295696259, + 0.20921307802200317, + 0.046966150403022766, + 0.039212167263031006, + 0.04594691842794418, + 0.03370169177651405, + 0.024808861315250397, + 0.017955726012587547 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11799240112304688 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a tranquil forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white fox with nine tails emerge from a hollow in an ancient cherry tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pink cherry blossom petals falling in front of the fox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a Studio Ghibli hand-painted texture with film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12711483240127563 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127114772796631 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12711483240127563, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12711483240127563, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27520251274108887, + 0.19091272354125977, + 0.08626458048820496, + 0.04815823957324028, + 0.09296855330467224, + 0.17521248757839203, + 0.02213520184159279, + 0.06603144854307175, + 0.029230263084173203, + 0.013883991166949272 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12711483240127563 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a tranquil forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white fox with nine tails emerge from a hollow in an ancient cherry tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pink cherry blossom petals falling in front of the fox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a Studio Ghibli hand-painted texture with film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032004110980778933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753200531005859 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032004110980778933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032004110980778933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14680975675582886, + 0.19855687022209167, + 0.03854462876915932, + 0.02128833904862404, + 0.0439264290034771, + 0.17327585816383362, + 0.0420149601995945, + 0.21054604649543762, + 0.07521271705627441, + 0.049824390560388565 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032004110980778933 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a tranquil forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white fox with nine tails emerge from a hollow in an ancient cherry tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pink cherry blossom petals falling in front of the fox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a Studio Ghibli hand-painted texture with film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048680439591407776 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048680543899536 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048680439591407776, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048680439591407776, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2216491848230362, + 0.1493867039680481, + 0.244657963514328, + 0.014325949363410473, + 0.08162926137447357, + 0.04305102676153183, + 0.06002651900053024, + 0.10554417222738266, + 0.03990868851542473, + 0.039820559322834015 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048680439591407776 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a tranquil forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white fox with nine tails emerge from a hollow in an ancient cherry tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pink cherry blossom petals falling in front of the fox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a Studio Ghibli hand-painted texture with film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004643965046852827 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.37964391708374 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004643965046852827, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004643965046852827, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25130873918533325, + 0.08264712989330292, + 0.0461806021630764, + 0.034329578280448914, + 0.09275884926319122, + 0.19560012221336365, + 0.038017939776182175, + 0.08679194748401642, + 0.14146757125854492, + 0.03089747205376625 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004643965046852827 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "cinematic camera slowly zooms in, deep into a tranquil forest shrouded in morning mist, finally focusing on an ancient cherry tree with twisted, deeply veined branches. From a deep, smooth-edged natural hollow mid-trunk, a sacred white fox cautiously and slowly emerges its immaculate head. Its soft, fluffy white fur seems to glow, its amber eyes sparkle with wisdom and curiosity, and its nose is delicately moistened with moisture. A soft, ethereal glow emanates naturally from its form, softly illuminating its alertly pointed ears and the ancient bark surrounding the cave's entrance. It also shimmers at the tips of its nine magnificent tails, gracefully unfurling behind it, barely visible within the cavern. The moment it peeks out, a few delicate pink cherry blossom petals are blown by the breeze and gently fall in front of it like snow. The whole picture presents the delicate hand-painted texture of Studio Ghibli animation, and each frame is covered with a layer of subtle and realistic film grain, creating a tranquil atmosphere that is both dreamy and sacred and full of nostalgic reality.", + "seed": 31412, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_4/index_1985_seed_31412_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.11611784342676401, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11611784342676401, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11611784342676401, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a tranquil forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white fox with nine tails emerge from a hollow in an ancient cherry tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pink cherry blossom petals falling in front of the fox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a Studio Ghibli hand-painted texture with film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06861147284507751 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8186113834381104 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06861147284507751, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06861147284507751, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1393010914325714, + 0.036433059722185135, + 0.06426423788070679, + 0.02096288464963436, + 0.2282206416130066, + 0.05559747293591499, + 0.41185328364372253, + 0.02255837805569172, + 0.013382918201386929, + 0.007426037453114986 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06861147284507751 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a tranquil forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white fox with nine tails emerge from a hollow in an ancient cherry tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pink cherry blossom petals falling in front of the fox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a Studio Ghibli hand-painted texture with film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42896950244903564 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539695024490356 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42896950244903564, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42896950244903564, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18361502885818481, + 0.12220750749111176, + 0.12079542875289917, + 0.0777515172958374, + 0.052586980164051056, + 0.06788141280412674, + 0.12554803490638733, + 0.12544938921928406, + 0.07879013568162918, + 0.04537447541952133 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42896950244903564 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a tranquil forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white fox with nine tails emerge from a hollow in an ancient cherry tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pink cherry blossom petals falling in front of the fox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a Studio Ghibli hand-painted texture with film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038136087357997894 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881360054016113 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038136087357997894, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038136087357997894, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1531612128019333, + 0.0967978984117508, + 0.04959975183010101, + 0.02816828340291977, + 0.06952772289514542, + 0.047761112451553345, + 0.3820461928844452, + 0.06787095963954926, + 0.06545303761959076, + 0.039613910019397736 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038136087357997894 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a tranquil forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white fox with nine tails emerge from a hollow in an ancient cherry tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pink cherry blossom petals falling in front of the fox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a Studio Ghibli hand-painted texture with film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812507167458534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881250381469727 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812507167458534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812507167458534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20260877907276154, + 0.08151855319738388, + 0.10491062700748444, + 0.05568675324320793, + 0.1401834487915039, + 0.038506146520376205, + 0.2891990542411804, + 0.03578062728047371, + 0.034812603145837784, + 0.016793515533208847 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812507167458534 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a slow zoom-in motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a tranquil forest shrouded in morning mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a white fox with nine tails emerge from a hollow in an ancient cherry tree?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are pink cherry blossom petals falling in front of the fox?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video exhibit a Studio Ghibli hand-painted texture with film grain?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006747082807123661 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006747245788574 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006747082807123661, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006747082807123661, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10435324907302856, + 0.1203581839799881, + 0.12302689254283905, + 0.09260614216327667, + 0.11412238329648972, + 0.1126793697476387, + 0.19372539222240448, + 0.033549945801496506, + 0.05146847665309906, + 0.05410996451973915 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006747082807123661 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_5/index_tensor([8323, 8323])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_5/index_tensor([8323, 8323])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..80f7a74fe37c951d49ec38f2fa4d917db1cc552e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_5/index_tensor([8323, 8323])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, majestic tracking shot glides across a deep, ethereal blue ocean, following a gorgeous, dreamlike submarine as it drifts almost silently through the waters. Its hull is a masterpiece of polished bronze and burnished brass, covered in intricate swirling filigree and intricate, non-functional gears, reminiscent of the works of Jules Verne. A series of circular, illuminated hatches emit a warm golden light that pierces the surrounding darkness. The ship navigates among the ghostly ruins of a sunken city, its crumbling arches and shadowy domes barely visible against the hazy background, while particles of marine snow drift lazily across the camera. Steadily and deliberately, it moves toward a massive marble column rising from the ocean floor, its ancient, textured surface almost completely obscured by a thick carpet of velvety green moss and cladded kelp. The submarine's forward drift slows until its curved bow gently bumps against the ancient pillars; the contact is a soft, muffled thud that causes the vessel to shudder slightly and expel a fragile cloud of silt and moss particles, which slowly blooms into the calm water before coming to rest. The entire scene is immersed in a cool, deep-sea palette of blues and cyans, dramatically penetrated by the shimmering divine light filtering down from the distant surface, creating a profound atmosphere of ancient mystery and tranquil discovery.", + "seed": 478, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_5/index_8323_seed_478_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.034322592942044136, + "vlm_logprob": -0.034322592942044136, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.499999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.034322592942044136, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a submarine with a hull made of polished bronze and burnished brass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the submarine covered in intricate swirling filigree and non-functional gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do circular illuminated hatches on the submarine emit a warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the submarine drift slowly and bump against ancient pillars covered in green moss and kelp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep blue ocean with ghostly sunken city ruins and marine snow particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14400061964988708 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.01900053024292 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14400061964988708, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14400061964988708, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07750164717435837, + 0.09062478691339493, + 0.036388006061315536, + 0.0699714943766594, + 0.05875607579946518, + 0.28812429308891296, + 0.16016854345798492, + 0.06961160153150558, + 0.09848782420158386, + 0.050365712493658066 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14400061964988708 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a submarine with a hull made of polished bronze and burnished brass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the submarine covered in intricate swirling filigree and non-functional gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do circular illuminated hatches on the submarine emit a warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the submarine drift slowly and bump against ancient pillars covered in green moss and kelp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep blue ocean with ghostly sunken city ruins and marine snow particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007635456044226885 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882635593414307 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007635456044226885, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007635456044226885, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10567618161439896, + 0.053972624242305756, + 0.04428362846374512, + 0.07838548719882965, + 0.06441174447536469, + 0.16762511432170868, + 0.0824652686715126, + 0.10578358918428421, + 0.09792432188987732, + 0.19947205483913422 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007635456044226885 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a submarine with a hull made of polished bronze and burnished brass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the submarine covered in intricate swirling filigree and non-functional gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do circular illuminated hatches on the submarine emit a warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the submarine drift slowly and bump against ancient pillars covered in green moss and kelp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep blue ocean with ghostly sunken city ruins and marine snow particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005251067224889994 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255250930786133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005251067224889994, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005251067224889994, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08454548567533493, + 0.06221047788858414, + 0.0669434666633606, + 0.12590093910694122, + 0.11162325739860535, + 0.25832244753837585, + 0.14003072679042816, + 0.04014132544398308, + 0.04780957102775574, + 0.062472306191921234 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005251067224889994 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a submarine with a hull made of polished bronze and burnished brass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the submarine covered in intricate swirling filigree and non-functional gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do circular illuminated hatches on the submarine emit a warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the submarine drift slowly and bump against ancient pillars covered in green moss and kelp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep blue ocean with ghostly sunken city ruins and marine snow particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012533940374851227 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387534141540527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012533940374851227, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012533940374851227, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07568884640932083, + 0.08092942088842392, + 0.034192848950624466, + 0.06259767711162567, + 0.06005688011646271, + 0.16656409204006195, + 0.3064218759536743, + 0.06161768361926079, + 0.0664459690451622, + 0.08548468351364136 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012533940374851227 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a submarine with a hull made of polished bronze and burnished brass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the submarine covered in intricate swirling filigree and non-functional gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do circular illuminated hatches on the submarine emit a warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the submarine drift slowly and bump against ancient pillars covered in green moss and kelp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep blue ocean with ghostly sunken city ruins and marine snow particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021918814163655043 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.12719202041626 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021918814163655043, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021918814163655043, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10912701487541199, + 0.03721469268202782, + 0.042741041630506516, + 0.0877087339758873, + 0.0490042120218277, + 0.1677330881357193, + 0.12574951350688934, + 0.05499592423439026, + 0.10440684854984283, + 0.22131893038749695 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021918814163655043 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, majestic tracking shot glides across a deep, ethereal blue ocean, following a gorgeous, dreamlike submarine as it drifts almost silently through the waters. Its hull is a masterpiece of polished bronze and burnished brass, covered in intricate swirling filigree and intricate, non-functional gears, reminiscent of the works of Jules Verne. A series of circular, illuminated hatches emit a warm golden light that pierces the surrounding darkness. The ship navigates among the ghostly ruins of a sunken city, its crumbling arches and shadowy domes barely visible against the hazy background, while particles of marine snow drift lazily across the camera. Steadily and deliberately, it moves toward a massive marble column rising from the ocean floor, its ancient, textured surface almost completely obscured by a thick carpet of velvety green moss and cladded kelp. The submarine's forward drift slows until its curved bow gently bumps against the ancient pillars; the contact is a soft, muffled thud that causes the vessel to shudder slightly and expel a fragile cloud of silt and moss particles, which slowly blooms into the calm water before coming to rest. The entire scene is immersed in a cool, deep-sea palette of blues and cyans, dramatically penetrated by the shimmering divine light filtering down from the distant surface, creating a profound atmosphere of ancient mystery and tranquil discovery.", + "seed": 479, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_5/index_8323_seed_479_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07707184376195073, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07707184376195073, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07707184376195073, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a submarine with a hull made of polished bronze and burnished brass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the submarine covered in intricate swirling filigree and non-functional gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do circular illuminated hatches on the submarine emit a warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the submarine drift slowly and bump against ancient pillars covered in green moss and kelp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep blue ocean with ghostly sunken city ruins and marine snow particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28195035457611084 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4069503545761108 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28195035457611084, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28195035457611084, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04821031913161278, + 0.03409668058156967, + 0.07640837877988815, + 0.012097089551389217, + 0.041628893464803696, + 0.08015787601470947, + 0.05355583503842354, + 0.07755866646766663, + 0.5252265334129333, + 0.051059789955616 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28195035457611084 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a submarine with a hull made of polished bronze and burnished brass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the submarine covered in intricate swirling filigree and non-functional gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do circular illuminated hatches on the submarine emit a warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the submarine drift slowly and bump against ancient pillars covered in green moss and kelp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep blue ocean with ghostly sunken city ruins and marine snow particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02636268176138401 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651362657546997 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02636268176138401, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02636268176138401, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07477384805679321, + 0.05207440257072449, + 0.06436149030923843, + 0.025255754590034485, + 0.12099576741456985, + 0.06801160424947739, + 0.0688217282295227, + 0.0829126387834549, + 0.31831076741218567, + 0.12448198348283768 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02636268176138401 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a submarine with a hull made of polished bronze and burnished brass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the submarine covered in intricate swirling filigree and non-functional gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do circular illuminated hatches on the submarine emit a warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the submarine drift slowly and bump against ancient pillars covered in green moss and kelp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep blue ocean with ghostly sunken city ruins and marine snow particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370386362075806 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087038040161133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370386362075806, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370386362075806, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08393001556396484, + 0.04933793842792511, + 0.10748591274023056, + 0.018922118470072746, + 0.1152276024222374, + 0.05679643899202347, + 0.11221281439065933, + 0.126165509223938, + 0.22242805361747742, + 0.10749359428882599 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370386362075806 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a submarine with a hull made of polished bronze and burnished brass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the submarine covered in intricate swirling filigree and non-functional gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do circular illuminated hatches on the submarine emit a warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the submarine drift slowly and bump against ancient pillars covered in green moss and kelp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep blue ocean with ghostly sunken city ruins and marine snow particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809729963541031 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288097381591797 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809729963541031, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809729963541031, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.038371361792087555, + 0.022556455805897713, + 0.03561624884605408, + 0.02648227848112583, + 0.0393478199839592, + 0.053068216890096664, + 0.11983708292245865, + 0.025927580893039703, + 0.5893310904502869, + 0.04946180060505867 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809729963541031 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a submarine with a hull made of polished bronze and burnished brass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the submarine covered in intricate swirling filigree and non-functional gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do circular illuminated hatches on the submarine emit a warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the submarine drift slowly and bump against ancient pillars covered in green moss and kelp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep blue ocean with ghostly sunken city ruins and marine snow particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005245019216090441 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255245208740234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005245019216090441, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005245019216090441, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.056994177401065826, + 0.030353019014000893, + 0.0631994903087616, + 0.02478477917611599, + 0.03145169839262962, + 0.06314830482006073, + 0.10717350244522095, + 0.05523333325982094, + 0.531501829624176, + 0.03615981340408325 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005245019216090441 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, majestic tracking shot glides across a deep, ethereal blue ocean, following a gorgeous, dreamlike submarine as it drifts almost silently through the waters. Its hull is a masterpiece of polished bronze and burnished brass, covered in intricate swirling filigree and intricate, non-functional gears, reminiscent of the works of Jules Verne. A series of circular, illuminated hatches emit a warm golden light that pierces the surrounding darkness. The ship navigates among the ghostly ruins of a sunken city, its crumbling arches and shadowy domes barely visible against the hazy background, while particles of marine snow drift lazily across the camera. Steadily and deliberately, it moves toward a massive marble column rising from the ocean floor, its ancient, textured surface almost completely obscured by a thick carpet of velvety green moss and cladded kelp. The submarine's forward drift slows until its curved bow gently bumps against the ancient pillars; the contact is a soft, muffled thud that causes the vessel to shudder slightly and expel a fragile cloud of silt and moss particles, which slowly blooms into the calm water before coming to rest. The entire scene is immersed in a cool, deep-sea palette of blues and cyans, dramatically penetrated by the shimmering divine light filtering down from the distant surface, creating a profound atmosphere of ancient mystery and tranquil discovery.", + "seed": 480, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_5/index_8323_seed_480_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04626557221636176, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04626557221636176, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.099999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04626557221636176, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a submarine with a hull made of polished bronze and burnished brass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the submarine covered in intricate swirling filigree and non-functional gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do circular illuminated hatches on the submarine emit a warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the submarine drift slowly and bump against ancient pillars covered in green moss and kelp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep blue ocean with ghostly sunken city ruins and marine snow particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18028521537780762 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8052852153778076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18028521537780762, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18028521537780762, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24825982749462128, + 0.08056830614805222, + 0.18299482762813568, + 0.1346617341041565, + 0.045630767941474915, + 0.06592228263616562, + 0.017613325268030167, + 0.0850600153207779, + 0.09132558107376099, + 0.047963403165340424 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18028521537780762 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a submarine with a hull made of polished bronze and burnished brass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the submarine covered in intricate swirling filigree and non-functional gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do circular illuminated hatches on the submarine emit a warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the submarine drift slowly and bump against ancient pillars covered in green moss and kelp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep blue ocean with ghostly sunken city ruins and marine snow particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007637703791260719 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826375007629395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007637703791260719, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007637703791260719, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11243963986635208, + 0.05797037482261658, + 0.12069028615951538, + 0.05808160826563835, + 0.0188719742000103, + 0.05939372628927231, + 0.025523705407977104, + 0.41523757576942444, + 0.09019409120082855, + 0.04159693792462349 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007637703791260719 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a submarine with a hull made of polished bronze and burnished brass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the submarine covered in intricate swirling filigree and non-functional gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do circular illuminated hatches on the submarine emit a warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the submarine drift slowly and bump against ancient pillars covered in green moss and kelp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep blue ocean with ghostly sunken city ruins and marine snow particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023284580558538437 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773284673690796 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023284580558538437, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023284580558538437, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15920455753803253, + 0.04748418554663658, + 0.16615509986877441, + 0.05241056904196739, + 0.0468793548643589, + 0.05909402668476105, + 0.02009672299027443, + 0.17780697345733643, + 0.16747526824474335, + 0.10339329391717911 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023284580558538437 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a submarine with a hull made of polished bronze and burnished brass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the submarine covered in intricate swirling filigree and non-functional gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do circular illuminated hatches on the submarine emit a warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the submarine drift slowly and bump against ancient pillars covered in green moss and kelp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep blue ocean with ghostly sunken city ruins and marine snow particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818484626710415 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018184661865234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818484626710415, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818484626710415, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10917560011148453, + 0.059541940689086914, + 0.10014770925045013, + 0.1469765305519104, + 0.07922067493200302, + 0.0464550144970417, + 0.032996635884046555, + 0.20981307327747345, + 0.15497590601444244, + 0.06069689989089966 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818484626710415 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a submarine with a hull made of polished bronze and burnished brass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the submarine covered in intricate swirling filigree and non-functional gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do circular illuminated hatches on the submarine emit a warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the submarine drift slowly and bump against ancient pillars covered in green moss and kelp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep blue ocean with ghostly sunken city ruins and marine snow particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019355150870978832 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.2519354820251465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019355150870978832, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019355150870978832, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17338204383850098, + 0.044816501438617706, + 0.2816627621650696, + 0.06968299299478531, + 0.04828711599111557, + 0.05561404675245285, + 0.0357687771320343, + 0.2048545777797699, + 0.057545196264982224, + 0.028385968878865242 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019355150870978832 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, majestic tracking shot glides across a deep, ethereal blue ocean, following a gorgeous, dreamlike submarine as it drifts almost silently through the waters. Its hull is a masterpiece of polished bronze and burnished brass, covered in intricate swirling filigree and intricate, non-functional gears, reminiscent of the works of Jules Verne. A series of circular, illuminated hatches emit a warm golden light that pierces the surrounding darkness. The ship navigates among the ghostly ruins of a sunken city, its crumbling arches and shadowy domes barely visible against the hazy background, while particles of marine snow drift lazily across the camera. Steadily and deliberately, it moves toward a massive marble column rising from the ocean floor, its ancient, textured surface almost completely obscured by a thick carpet of velvety green moss and cladded kelp. The submarine's forward drift slows until its curved bow gently bumps against the ancient pillars; the contact is a soft, muffled thud that causes the vessel to shudder slightly and expel a fragile cloud of silt and moss particles, which slowly blooms into the calm water before coming to rest. The entire scene is immersed in a cool, deep-sea palette of blues and cyans, dramatically penetrated by the shimmering divine light filtering down from the distant surface, creating a profound atmosphere of ancient mystery and tranquil discovery.", + "seed": 481, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_5/index_8323_seed_481_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10728397117927671, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10728397117927671, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10728397117927671, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a submarine with a hull made of polished bronze and burnished brass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the submarine covered in intricate swirling filigree and non-functional gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do circular illuminated hatches on the submarine emit a warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the submarine drift slowly and bump against ancient pillars covered in green moss and kelp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep blue ocean with ghostly sunken city ruins and marine snow particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4745439887046814 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9745439887046814 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4745439887046814, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4745439887046814, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17024222016334534, + 0.05799977108836174, + 0.17050302028656006, + 0.20238232612609863, + 0.026562774553894997, + 0.05153902247548103, + 0.06032630056142807, + 0.14401651918888092, + 0.01757730543613434, + 0.09885076433420181 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4745439887046814 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a submarine with a hull made of polished bronze and burnished brass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the submarine covered in intricate swirling filigree and non-functional gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do circular illuminated hatches on the submarine emit a warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the submarine drift slowly and bump against ancient pillars covered in green moss and kelp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep blue ocean with ghostly sunken city ruins and marine snow particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016082679852843285 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141082763671875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016082679852843285, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016082679852843285, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1435021162033081, + 0.04910004511475563, + 0.19079668819904327, + 0.19451037049293518, + 0.028926242142915726, + 0.05786937102675438, + 0.05806237831711769, + 0.1008286327123642, + 0.033606018871068954, + 0.14279811084270477 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016082679852843285 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a submarine with a hull made of polished bronze and burnished brass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the submarine covered in intricate swirling filigree and non-functional gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do circular illuminated hatches on the submarine emit a warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the submarine drift slowly and bump against ancient pillars covered in green moss and kelp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep blue ocean with ghostly sunken city ruins and marine snow particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020581373944878578 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955814838409424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020581373944878578, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020581373944878578, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16580702364444733, + 0.040423110127449036, + 0.1734951138496399, + 0.26397472620010376, + 0.04129224643111229, + 0.06024555116891861, + 0.05524172633886337, + 0.10329977422952652, + 0.024305038154125214, + 0.07191567122936249 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020581373944878578 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a submarine with a hull made of polished bronze and burnished brass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the submarine covered in intricate swirling filigree and non-functional gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do circular illuminated hatches on the submarine emit a warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the submarine drift slowly and bump against ancient pillars covered in green moss and kelp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep blue ocean with ghostly sunken city ruins and marine snow particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020581256598234177 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955812454223633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020581256598234177, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020581256598234177, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06328367441892624, + 0.04515474662184715, + 0.19532443583011627, + 0.21103931963443756, + 0.04173809289932251, + 0.06069710850715637, + 0.06848037242889404, + 0.1742289513349533, + 0.03846973553299904, + 0.10158362984657288 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020581256598234177 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a submarine with a hull made of polished bronze and burnished brass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the submarine covered in intricate swirling filigree and non-functional gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do circular illuminated hatches on the submarine emit a warm golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the submarine drift slowly and bump against ancient pillars covered in green moss and kelp?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a deep blue ocean with ghostly sunken city ruins and marine snow particles?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004630556795746088 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.3796305656433105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004630556795746088, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004630556795746088, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09989580512046814, + 0.07751414179801941, + 0.1325015425682068, + 0.11654514074325562, + 0.046998634934425354, + 0.09620087593793869, + 0.07135935872793198, + 0.09833019971847534, + 0.02912946045398712, + 0.23152486979961395 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004630556795746088 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_6/index_tensor([9094, 9094])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_6/index_tensor([9094, 9094])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fd66b820a5da30e5f2b96d14b85866776c098fc2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_6/index_tensor([9094, 9094])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "This cinematic, first-person shot, rendered in extreme macro detail, captures the moment a shimmering tear begins its journey. The camera is static, maintaining a very close perspective, with the lower eyelashes a soft, out-of-focus blur at the top of the frame. The tear wells up, distorting the view with its perfect, clear curve, before parting and slowly tracing a wet, shimmering path along the visible cheek skin. The skin itself takes on a hyper-realistic texture, revealing fine pores and subtle contours under the soft, cool-toned ambient light. When the tear ceases, a magical transformation begins; it visibly solidifies, its liquid form miraculously and deliberately frozen from the inside out. Intricate frosted facets begin to form, catching the light and refracting it into tiny rainbows. The process completes, leaving a tiny, perfect, multi-faceted crystal delicately resting on the skin. Its sharp, geometric edges contrast starkly with the soft, organic surface beneath, creating a poignant and surreal atmosphere of serene, frozen emotion.", + "seed": 19946, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_6/index_9094_seed_19946_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.43195677995681764, + "vlm_logprob": -0.43195677995681764, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.099999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.43195677995681764, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a first-person perspective with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are lower eyelashes visible as a soft, out-of-focus blur at the top of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tear well up, distort the view with a clear curve, and then trace a wet path along the cheek skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear visibly solidify from the inside out into a multi-faceted crystal with frosted edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final crystal resting on hyper-realistic skin showing fine pores and subtle contours?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5437860488891602 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9187860488891602 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5437860488891602, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5437860488891602, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4380139708518982, + 0.07409466803073883, + 0.04861747473478317, + 0.10566870868206024, + 0.07089429348707199, + 0.0728783831000328, + 0.040068600326776505, + 0.050617024302482605, + 0.06091465428471565, + 0.03823229297995567 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5437860488891602 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a first-person perspective with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are lower eyelashes visible as a soft, out-of-focus blur at the top of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tear well up, distort the view with a clear curve, and then trace a wet path along the cheek skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear visibly solidify from the inside out into a multi-faceted crystal with frosted edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final crystal resting on hyper-realistic skin showing fine pores and subtle contours?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.142887681722641 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017887592315674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.142887681722641, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.142887681722641, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3348033130168915, + 0.12309590727090836, + 0.10234706103801727, + 0.1019340381026268, + 0.14094772934913635, + 0.03513888269662857, + 0.024955933913588524, + 0.09341948479413986, + 0.019415801391005516, + 0.023941898718476295 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.142887681722641 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a first-person perspective with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are lower eyelashes visible as a soft, out-of-focus blur at the top of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tear well up, distort the view with a clear curve, and then trace a wet path along the cheek skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear visibly solidify from the inside out into a multi-faceted crystal with frosted edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final crystal resting on hyper-realistic skin showing fine pores and subtle contours?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16041146218776703 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104114770889282 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16041146218776703, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16041146218776703, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16599048674106598, + 0.23901484906673431, + 0.11713501811027527, + 0.17527316510677338, + 0.11567483842372894, + 0.07537893205881119, + 0.013292382471263409, + 0.03974267095327377, + 0.040109921246767044, + 0.01838776469230652 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16041146218776703 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a first-person perspective with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are lower eyelashes visible as a soft, out-of-focus blur at the top of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tear well up, distort the view with a clear curve, and then trace a wet path along the cheek skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear visibly solidify from the inside out into a multi-faceted crystal with frosted edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final crystal resting on hyper-realistic skin showing fine pores and subtle contours?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236179113388062 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34861788153648376 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2236179113388062, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2236179113388062, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14948226511478424, + 0.3115982413291931, + 0.043436985462903976, + 0.18547873198986053, + 0.04161817207932472, + 0.04425404593348503, + 0.07362914085388184, + 0.056396856904029846, + 0.04947822913527489, + 0.04462737962603569 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2236179113388062 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a first-person perspective with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are lower eyelashes visible as a soft, out-of-focus blur at the top of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tear well up, distort the view with a clear curve, and then trace a wet path along the cheek skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear visibly solidify from the inside out into a multi-faceted crystal with frosted edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final crystal resting on hyper-realistic skin showing fine pores and subtle contours?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890807956457138 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464080810546875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0890807956457138, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0890807956457138, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10676886886358261, + 0.11013850569725037, + 0.08206424862146378, + 0.13862937688827515, + 0.08754786849021912, + 0.09214916080236435, + 0.06972252577543259, + 0.0925394743680954, + 0.07024575024843216, + 0.1501941829919815 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0890807956457138 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This cinematic, first-person shot, rendered in extreme macro detail, captures the moment a shimmering tear begins its journey. The camera is static, maintaining a very close perspective, with the lower eyelashes a soft, out-of-focus blur at the top of the frame. The tear wells up, distorting the view with its perfect, clear curve, before parting and slowly tracing a wet, shimmering path along the visible cheek skin. The skin itself takes on a hyper-realistic texture, revealing fine pores and subtle contours under the soft, cool-toned ambient light. When the tear ceases, a magical transformation begins; it visibly solidifies, its liquid form miraculously and deliberately frozen from the inside out. Intricate frosted facets begin to form, catching the light and refracting it into tiny rainbows. The process completes, leaving a tiny, perfect, multi-faceted crystal delicately resting on the skin. Its sharp, geometric edges contrast starkly with the soft, organic surface beneath, creating a poignant and surreal atmosphere of serene, frozen emotion.", + "seed": 19947, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_6/index_9094_seed_19947_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.45344689935445787, + "vlm_logprob": -0.45344689935445787, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.45344689935445787, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a first-person perspective with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are lower eyelashes visible as a soft, out-of-focus blur at the top of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tear well up, distort the view with a clear curve, and then trace a wet path along the cheek skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear visibly solidify from the inside out into a multi-faceted crystal with frosted edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final crystal resting on hyper-realistic skin showing fine pores and subtle contours?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7702370882034302 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6452370882034302 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7702370882034302, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7702370882034302, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16602933406829834, + 0.18278980255126953, + 0.20594681799411774, + 0.058340784162282944, + 0.06764509528875351, + 0.06789792329072952, + 0.0475584901869297, + 0.08387967944145203, + 0.05783871188759804, + 0.062073346227407455 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7702370882034302 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a first-person perspective with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are lower eyelashes visible as a soft, out-of-focus blur at the top of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tear well up, distort the view with a clear curve, and then trace a wet path along the cheek skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear visibly solidify from the inside out into a multi-faceted crystal with frosted edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final crystal resting on hyper-realistic skin showing fine pores and subtle contours?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04871018975973129 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0487101078033447 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04871018975973129, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04871018975973129, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1366036981344223, + 0.13459675014019012, + 0.2879112660884857, + 0.05879068747162819, + 0.05959903821349144, + 0.03404183313250542, + 0.11500245332717896, + 0.0743265151977539, + 0.04761353135108948, + 0.051514215767383575 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04871018975973129 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a first-person perspective with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are lower eyelashes visible as a soft, out-of-focus blur at the top of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tear well up, distort the view with a clear curve, and then trace a wet path along the cheek skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear visibly solidify from the inside out into a multi-faceted crystal with frosted edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final crystal resting on hyper-realistic skin showing fine pores and subtle contours?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2814079821109772 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4064079523086548 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2814079821109772, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2814079821109772, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5672578811645508, + 0.03728571534156799, + 0.10322773456573486, + 0.016586661338806152, + 0.034566570073366165, + 0.07745121419429779, + 0.03380856662988663, + 0.06841234862804413, + 0.03271849453449249, + 0.02868482656776905 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2814079821109772 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a first-person perspective with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are lower eyelashes visible as a soft, out-of-focus blur at the top of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tear well up, distort the view with a clear curve, and then trace a wet path along the cheek skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear visibly solidify from the inside out into a multi-faceted crystal with frosted edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final crystal resting on hyper-realistic skin showing fine pores and subtle contours?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0538923740386963 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4288923442363739 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0538923740386963, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0538923740386963, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25189444422721863, + 0.08970596641302109, + 0.15240107476711273, + 0.029363485053181648, + 0.08424386382102966, + 0.0601445809006691, + 0.08170497417449951, + 0.1388244777917862, + 0.043972328305244446, + 0.06774481385946274 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0538923740386963 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a first-person perspective with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are lower eyelashes visible as a soft, out-of-focus blur at the top of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tear well up, distort the view with a clear curve, and then trace a wet path along the cheek skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear visibly solidify from the inside out into a multi-faceted crystal with frosted edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final crystal resting on hyper-realistic skin showing fine pores and subtle contours?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11298686265945435 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379868030548096 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11298686265945435, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11298686265945435, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11340003460645676, + 0.15041379630565643, + 0.1668723076581955, + 0.021906312555074692, + 0.1624249517917633, + 0.04849753901362419, + 0.12852276861667633, + 0.09243539720773697, + 0.024420280009508133, + 0.09110666811466217 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11298686265945435 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This cinematic, first-person shot, rendered in extreme macro detail, captures the moment a shimmering tear begins its journey. The camera is static, maintaining a very close perspective, with the lower eyelashes a soft, out-of-focus blur at the top of the frame. The tear wells up, distorting the view with its perfect, clear curve, before parting and slowly tracing a wet, shimmering path along the visible cheek skin. The skin itself takes on a hyper-realistic texture, revealing fine pores and subtle contours under the soft, cool-toned ambient light. When the tear ceases, a magical transformation begins; it visibly solidifies, its liquid form miraculously and deliberately frozen from the inside out. Intricate frosted facets begin to form, catching the light and refracting it into tiny rainbows. The process completes, leaving a tiny, perfect, multi-faceted crystal delicately resting on the skin. Its sharp, geometric edges contrast starkly with the soft, organic surface beneath, creating a poignant and surreal atmosphere of serene, frozen emotion.", + "seed": 19948, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_6/index_9094_seed_19948_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.10854379162192344, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10854379162192344, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10854379162192344, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a first-person perspective with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are lower eyelashes visible as a soft, out-of-focus blur at the top of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tear well up, distort the view with a clear curve, and then trace a wet path along the cheek skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear visibly solidify from the inside out into a multi-faceted crystal with frosted edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final crystal resting on hyper-realistic skin showing fine pores and subtle contours?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.43635496497154236 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0613549947738647 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.43635496497154236, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.43635496497154236, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1817152351140976, + 0.05877065286040306, + 0.04442676901817322, + 0.09562256187200546, + 0.12085048109292984, + 0.14273744821548462, + 0.1650775521993637, + 0.09033358842134476, + 0.06108395755290985, + 0.039381805807352066 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.43635496497154236 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a first-person perspective with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are lower eyelashes visible as a soft, out-of-focus blur at the top of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tear well up, distort the view with a clear curve, and then trace a wet path along the cheek skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear visibly solidify from the inside out into a multi-faceted crystal with frosted edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final crystal resting on hyper-realistic skin showing fine pores and subtle contours?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043105874210596085 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1681058406829834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043105874210596085, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043105874210596085, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17538708448410034, + 0.19115039706230164, + 0.0811849907040596, + 0.1684301495552063, + 0.07112040370702744, + 0.05694860219955444, + 0.07909909635782242, + 0.038523998111486435, + 0.05777841433882713, + 0.08037684112787247 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043105874210596085 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a first-person perspective with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are lower eyelashes visible as a soft, out-of-focus blur at the top of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tear well up, distort the view with a clear curve, and then trace a wet path along the cheek skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear visibly solidify from the inside out into a multi-faceted crystal with frosted edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final crystal resting on hyper-realistic skin showing fine pores and subtle contours?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308931902050972 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680893898010254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308931902050972, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308931902050972, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16302768886089325, + 0.049487050622701645, + 0.06606201082468033, + 0.22587186098098755, + 0.0718599259853363, + 0.13839706778526306, + 0.08483196794986725, + 0.06497524678707123, + 0.05454323813319206, + 0.08094391971826553 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308931902050972 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a first-person perspective with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are lower eyelashes visible as a soft, out-of-focus blur at the top of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tear well up, distort the view with a clear curve, and then trace a wet path along the cheek skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear visibly solidify from the inside out into a multi-faceted crystal with frosted edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final crystal resting on hyper-realistic skin showing fine pores and subtle contours?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007633799687027931 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882633686065674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007633799687027931, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007633799687027931, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2322537899017334, + 0.05738084763288498, + 0.060304492712020874, + 0.07251665741205215, + 0.07804998010396957, + 0.1054769828915596, + 0.12997420132160187, + 0.14360108971595764, + 0.0579555481672287, + 0.0624864436686039 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007633799687027931 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a first-person perspective with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are lower eyelashes visible as a soft, out-of-focus blur at the top of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tear well up, distort the view with a clear curve, and then trace a wet path along the cheek skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear visibly solidify from the inside out into a multi-faceted crystal with frosted edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final crystal resting on hyper-realistic skin showing fine pores and subtle contours?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01253500021994114 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387535095214844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01253500021994114, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01253500021994114, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07082574814558029, + 0.050685349851846695, + 0.059812504798173904, + 0.03825267776846886, + 0.16326159238815308, + 0.06727171689271927, + 0.09131941199302673, + 0.09239231795072556, + 0.0866527259349823, + 0.27952584624290466 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01253500021994114 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "This cinematic, first-person shot, rendered in extreme macro detail, captures the moment a shimmering tear begins its journey. The camera is static, maintaining a very close perspective, with the lower eyelashes a soft, out-of-focus blur at the top of the frame. The tear wells up, distorting the view with its perfect, clear curve, before parting and slowly tracing a wet, shimmering path along the visible cheek skin. The skin itself takes on a hyper-realistic texture, revealing fine pores and subtle contours under the soft, cool-toned ambient light. When the tear ceases, a magical transformation begins; it visibly solidifies, its liquid form miraculously and deliberately frozen from the inside out. Intricate frosted facets begin to form, catching the light and refracting it into tiny rainbows. The process completes, leaving a tiny, perfect, multi-faceted crystal delicately resting on the skin. Its sharp, geometric edges contrast starkly with the soft, organic surface beneath, creating a poignant and surreal atmosphere of serene, frozen emotion.", + "seed": 19949, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_6/index_9094_seed_19949_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.40359710454940795, + "vlm_logprob": -0.40359710454940795, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.225000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.40359710454940795, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a first-person perspective with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are lower eyelashes visible as a soft, out-of-focus blur at the top of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tear well up, distort the view with a clear curve, and then trace a wet path along the cheek skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear visibly solidify from the inside out into a multi-faceted crystal with frosted edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final crystal resting on hyper-realistic skin showing fine pores and subtle contours?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.36709707975387573 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2420971393585205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.36709707975387573, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8750000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.36709707975387573, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19031807780265808, + 0.05342290922999382, + 0.03876122459769249, + 0.04871407523751259, + 0.2832208573818207, + 0.1116153672337532, + 0.06733746081590652, + 0.08956225216388702, + 0.08818560093641281, + 0.028862176463007927 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.36709707975387573 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a first-person perspective with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are lower eyelashes visible as a soft, out-of-focus blur at the top of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tear well up, distort the view with a clear curve, and then trace a wet path along the cheek skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear visibly solidify from the inside out into a multi-faceted crystal with frosted edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final crystal resting on hyper-realistic skin showing fine pores and subtle contours?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11301635205745697 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.238016366958618 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11301635205745697, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11301635205745697, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2134832739830017, + 0.126695454120636, + 0.09704757481813431, + 0.10938625782728195, + 0.15221674740314484, + 0.11664951592683792, + 0.06891116499900818, + 0.06172286346554756, + 0.0365682952105999, + 0.017318852245807648 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11301635205745697 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a first-person perspective with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are lower eyelashes visible as a soft, out-of-focus blur at the top of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tear well up, distort the view with a clear curve, and then trace a wet path along the cheek skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear visibly solidify from the inside out into a multi-faceted crystal with frosted edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final crystal resting on hyper-realistic skin showing fine pores and subtle contours?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25215595960617065 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021560192108154 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25215595960617065, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25215595960617065, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08637546747922897, + 0.06585264205932617, + 0.14055274426937103, + 0.27328938245773315, + 0.08894332498311996, + 0.09085245430469513, + 0.04423018544912338, + 0.09060732275247574, + 0.05272868275642395, + 0.0665678158402443 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25215595960617065 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a first-person perspective with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are lower eyelashes visible as a soft, out-of-focus blur at the top of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tear well up, distort the view with a clear curve, and then trace a wet path along the cheek skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear visibly solidify from the inside out into a multi-faceted crystal with frosted edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final crystal resting on hyper-realistic skin showing fine pores and subtle contours?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236285209655762 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34862855076789856 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2236285209655762, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2236285209655762, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10528645664453506, + 0.04985987767577171, + 0.06523267924785614, + 0.19360284507274628, + 0.06279050558805466, + 0.2227868139743805, + 0.08543874323368073, + 0.10542311519384384, + 0.05190465599298477, + 0.05767436698079109 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2236285209655762 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a first-person perspective with a static camera?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are lower eyelashes visible as a soft, out-of-focus blur at the top of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a tear well up, distort the view with a clear curve, and then trace a wet path along the cheek skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the tear visibly solidify from the inside out into a multi-faceted crystal with frosted edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the final crystal resting on hyper-realistic skin showing fine pores and subtle contours?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062087610363960266 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120875358581543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062087610363960266, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062087610363960266, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10104963928461075, + 0.09169872850179672, + 0.23088206350803375, + 0.10394592583179474, + 0.08369526267051697, + 0.09923800826072693, + 0.08628062903881073, + 0.05819295719265938, + 0.0698874294757843, + 0.07512933015823364 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062087610363960266 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_7/index_tensor([1343, 1343])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_7/index_tensor([1343, 1343])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ba0da604165ec9311794e30b604c46c93c2d5d9a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_7/index_tensor([1343, 1343])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "realistic, extreme close-up, static shot captures a captivating process within a simple, transparent, cylindrical glass filled with pure, still water, resting on a polished, subtly textured granite kitchen counter. A drop of ultra-saturated crimson food coloring enters the frame from above, piercing the water's surface with minimal disturbance and beginning to sink gracefully. As it descends, it stretches and elongates, transforming from a cohesive globule into a delicate, sinuous tendril of pure color. This tendril then begins to slowly unfurl and blossom outward, its sharp edges softening into a complex, smoky plume that diffuses into the surrounding clear liquid. Bright, clean light from an off-camera source illuminates the glass, causing the red to glow from within and casting subtle, shimmering caustics on the counter. The vibrant crimson gradually fades in a captivating, fluid dynamic, transitioning to shades of scarlet and rose before fading to a pale, almost imperceptible pink that gently merges with the water, creating an atmosphere of focus, tranquility, and contemplation.", + "seed": 6845, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_7/index_1343_seed_6845_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.025852449331432582, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025852449331432582, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.099999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025852449331432582, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a transparent cylindrical glass filled with still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the glass resting on a polished, subtly textured granite kitchen counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a drop of ultra-saturated crimson food coloring enter the frame from above and sink into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the red coloring transform into a sinuous tendril that unfurls and diffuses into a smoky plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, clean light causing the red to glow and casting shimmering caustics on the counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06613265722990036 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8161325454711914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06613265722990036, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06613265722990036, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36239534616470337, + 0.09989848732948303, + 0.06221369653940201, + 0.1483527570962906, + 0.0630723312497139, + 0.048363097012043, + 0.04409985616803169, + 0.058123305439949036, + 0.07849285006523132, + 0.03498829901218414 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06613265722990036 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a transparent cylindrical glass filled with still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the glass resting on a polished, subtly textured granite kitchen counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a drop of ultra-saturated crimson food coloring enter the frame from above and sink into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the red coloring transform into a sinuous tendril that unfurls and diffuses into a smoky plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, clean light causing the red to glow and casting shimmering caustics on the counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03372703120112419 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408726930618286 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03372703120112419, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03372703120112419, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18748588860034943, + 0.11323173344135284, + 0.06636917591094971, + 0.10292242467403412, + 0.08899224549531937, + 0.049800075590610504, + 0.058477457612752914, + 0.0585826076567173, + 0.11491670459508896, + 0.15922173857688904 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03372703120112419 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a transparent cylindrical glass filled with still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the glass resting on a polished, subtly textured granite kitchen counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a drop of ultra-saturated crimson food coloring enter the frame from above and sink into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the red coloring transform into a sinuous tendril that unfurls and diffuses into a smoky plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, clean light causing the red to glow and casting shimmering caustics on the counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005261621437966824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255261421203613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005261621437966824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005261621437966824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23631928861141205, + 0.2768241763114929, + 0.15338627994060516, + 0.06854809820652008, + 0.02805597335100174, + 0.03941548615694046, + 0.051715731620788574, + 0.03837050870060921, + 0.06028924137353897, + 0.047075144946575165 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005261621437966824 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a transparent cylindrical glass filled with still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the glass resting on a polished, subtly textured granite kitchen counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a drop of ultra-saturated crimson food coloring enter the frame from above and sink into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the red coloring transform into a sinuous tendril that unfurls and diffuses into a smoky plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, clean light causing the red to glow and casting shimmering caustics on the counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819058135151863 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018190383911133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819058135151863, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819058135151863, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22524671256542206, + 0.2263949066400528, + 0.07207222282886505, + 0.1019580289721489, + 0.08155926316976547, + 0.07569465041160583, + 0.04873061925172806, + 0.06450381129980087, + 0.044723257422447205, + 0.05911659076809883 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819058135151863 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a transparent cylindrical glass filled with still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the glass resting on a polished, subtly textured granite kitchen counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a drop of ultra-saturated crimson food coloring enter the frame from above and sink into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the red coloring transform into a sinuous tendril that unfurls and diffuses into a smoky plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, clean light causing the red to glow and casting shimmering caustics on the counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005950355436652899 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130950450897217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005950355436652899, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005950355436652899, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.297073096036911, + 0.11482095718383789, + 0.07051646709442139, + 0.09859458357095718, + 0.07199861854314804, + 0.05365503951907158, + 0.06395825743675232, + 0.0710001215338707, + 0.04499753564596176, + 0.11338523775339127 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005950355436652899 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "realistic, extreme close-up, static shot captures a captivating process within a simple, transparent, cylindrical glass filled with pure, still water, resting on a polished, subtly textured granite kitchen counter. A drop of ultra-saturated crimson food coloring enters the frame from above, piercing the water's surface with minimal disturbance and beginning to sink gracefully. As it descends, it stretches and elongates, transforming from a cohesive globule into a delicate, sinuous tendril of pure color. This tendril then begins to slowly unfurl and blossom outward, its sharp edges softening into a complex, smoky plume that diffuses into the surrounding clear liquid. Bright, clean light from an off-camera source illuminates the glass, causing the red to glow from within and casting subtle, shimmering caustics on the counter. The vibrant crimson gradually fades in a captivating, fluid dynamic, transitioning to shades of scarlet and rose before fading to a pale, almost imperceptible pink that gently merges with the water, creating an atmosphere of focus, tranquility, and contemplation.", + "seed": 6846, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_7/index_1343_seed_6846_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.033714621281251314, + "vlm_logprob": -0.033714621281251314, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.033714621281251314, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a transparent cylindrical glass filled with still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the glass resting on a polished, subtly textured granite kitchen counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a drop of ultra-saturated crimson food coloring enter the frame from above and sink into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the red coloring transform into a sinuous tendril that unfurls and diffuses into a smoky plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, clean light causing the red to glow and casting shimmering caustics on the counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05055059492588043 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.300550699234009 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05055059492588043, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05055059492588043, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1639341115951538, + 0.16521115601062775, + 0.05495317652821541, + 0.04730440303683281, + 0.04797150567173958, + 0.05447186902165413, + 0.034711506217718124, + 0.11476043611764908, + 0.24580562114715576, + 0.07087615132331848 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05055059492588043 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a transparent cylindrical glass filled with still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the glass resting on a polished, subtly textured granite kitchen counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a drop of ultra-saturated crimson food coloring enter the frame from above and sink into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the red coloring transform into a sinuous tendril that unfurls and diffuses into a smoky plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, clean light causing the red to glow and casting shimmering caustics on the counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08915123343467712 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.46415114402771 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08915123343467712, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08915123343467712, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1915954053401947, + 0.18789589405059814, + 0.20869991183280945, + 0.0815049409866333, + 0.03719200938940048, + 0.05253002420067787, + 0.0733957514166832, + 0.03700259327888489, + 0.05360153317451477, + 0.07658195495605469 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08915123343467712 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a transparent cylindrical glass filled with still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the glass resting on a polished, subtly textured granite kitchen counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a drop of ultra-saturated crimson food coloring enter the frame from above and sink into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the red coloring transform into a sinuous tendril that unfurls and diffuses into a smoky plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, clean light causing the red to glow and casting shimmering caustics on the counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004652508534491062 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379652500152588 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004652508534491062, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004652508534491062, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17787614464759827, + 0.16912750899791718, + 0.2206396460533142, + 0.12726131081581116, + 0.09558521956205368, + 0.052002955228090286, + 0.03318791463971138, + 0.039187826216220856, + 0.046185124665498734, + 0.03894633799791336 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004652508534491062 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a transparent cylindrical glass filled with still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the glass resting on a polished, subtly textured granite kitchen counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a drop of ultra-saturated crimson food coloring enter the frame from above and sink into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the red coloring transform into a sinuous tendril that unfurls and diffuses into a smoky plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, clean light causing the red to glow and casting shimmering caustics on the counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020593518391251564 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955934047698975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020593518391251564, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020593518391251564, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07841353118419647, + 0.09437671303749084, + 0.18083259463310242, + 0.18058329820632935, + 0.11387194693088531, + 0.04769289866089821, + 0.025337733328342438, + 0.04426142945885658, + 0.18702751398086548, + 0.0476023331284523 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020593518391251564 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a transparent cylindrical glass filled with still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the glass resting on a polished, subtly textured granite kitchen counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a drop of ultra-saturated crimson food coloring enter the frame from above and sink into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the red coloring transform into a sinuous tendril that unfurls and diffuses into a smoky plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, clean light causing the red to glow and casting shimmering caustics on the counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003625251119956374 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628625392913818 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003625251119956374, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003625251119956374, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1343139261007309, + 0.25186091661453247, + 0.07137925177812576, + 0.07845360040664673, + 0.07987546175718307, + 0.048810411244630814, + 0.13830696046352386, + 0.04816025495529175, + 0.047375183552503586, + 0.10146401077508926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003625251119956374 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "realistic, extreme close-up, static shot captures a captivating process within a simple, transparent, cylindrical glass filled with pure, still water, resting on a polished, subtly textured granite kitchen counter. A drop of ultra-saturated crimson food coloring enters the frame from above, piercing the water's surface with minimal disturbance and beginning to sink gracefully. As it descends, it stretches and elongates, transforming from a cohesive globule into a delicate, sinuous tendril of pure color. This tendril then begins to slowly unfurl and blossom outward, its sharp edges softening into a complex, smoky plume that diffuses into the surrounding clear liquid. Bright, clean light from an off-camera source illuminates the glass, causing the red to glow from within and casting subtle, shimmering caustics on the counter. The vibrant crimson gradually fades in a captivating, fluid dynamic, transitioning to shades of scarlet and rose before fading to a pale, almost imperceptible pink that gently merges with the water, creating an atmosphere of focus, tranquility, and contemplation.", + "seed": 6847, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_7/index_1343_seed_6847_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04285635338164866, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04285635338164866, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04285635338164866, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a transparent cylindrical glass filled with still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the glass resting on a polished, subtly textured granite kitchen counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a drop of ultra-saturated crimson food coloring enter the frame from above and sink into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the red coloring transform into a sinuous tendril that unfurls and diffuses into a smoky plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, clean light causing the red to glow and casting shimmering caustics on the counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04775950685143471 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.297759532928467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04775950685143471, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04775950685143471, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3714027404785156, + 0.2439855933189392, + 0.055028658360242844, + 0.06624837964773178, + 0.07103647291660309, + 0.03847051039338112, + 0.021035848185420036, + 0.032992638647556305, + 0.061438556760549545, + 0.03836061805486679 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04775950685143471 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a transparent cylindrical glass filled with still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the glass resting on a polished, subtly textured granite kitchen counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a drop of ultra-saturated crimson food coloring enter the frame from above and sink into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the red coloring transform into a sinuous tendril that unfurls and diffuses into a smoky plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, clean light causing the red to glow and casting shimmering caustics on the counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1271466314792633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1271467208862305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1271466314792633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1271466314792633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21577952802181244, + 0.065187007188797, + 0.1927485167980194, + 0.10208018869161606, + 0.03356393054127693, + 0.04177166521549225, + 0.047455839812755585, + 0.0660145953297615, + 0.19349148869514465, + 0.04190722852945328 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1271466314792633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a transparent cylindrical glass filled with still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the glass resting on a polished, subtly textured granite kitchen counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a drop of ultra-saturated crimson food coloring enter the frame from above and sink into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the red coloring transform into a sinuous tendril that unfurls and diffuses into a smoky plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, clean light causing the red to glow and casting shimmering caustics on the counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00282817124389112 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877828121185303 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00282817124389112, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00282817124389112, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27763816714286804, + 0.12972772121429443, + 0.09907609224319458, + 0.10999356955289841, + 0.07959403097629547, + 0.07635243982076645, + 0.07313222438097, + 0.0410410575568676, + 0.07983113080263138, + 0.03361355513334274 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00282817124389112 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a transparent cylindrical glass filled with still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the glass resting on a polished, subtly textured granite kitchen counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a drop of ultra-saturated crimson food coloring enter the frame from above and sink into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the red coloring transform into a sinuous tendril that unfurls and diffuses into a smoky plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, clean light causing the red to glow and casting shimmering caustics on the counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029806768521666527 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298068523406982 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029806768521666527, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029806768521666527, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16419868171215057, + 0.1932903528213501, + 0.07978750765323639, + 0.10139446705579758, + 0.0840165987610817, + 0.22444234788417816, + 0.044264379888772964, + 0.041322216391563416, + 0.02834034338593483, + 0.0389430858194828 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029806768521666527 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a transparent cylindrical glass filled with still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the glass resting on a polished, subtly textured granite kitchen counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a drop of ultra-saturated crimson food coloring enter the frame from above and sink into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the red coloring transform into a sinuous tendril that unfurls and diffuses into a smoky plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, clean light causing the red to glow and casting shimmering caustics on the counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067406888119876385 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006740570068359 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067406888119876385, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067406888119876385, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30893492698669434, + 0.08505755662918091, + 0.09912388771772385, + 0.10432714223861694, + 0.04102353751659393, + 0.05345974490046501, + 0.0623086616396904, + 0.05645175278186798, + 0.15386515855789185, + 0.03544759377837181 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067406888119876385 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "realistic, extreme close-up, static shot captures a captivating process within a simple, transparent, cylindrical glass filled with pure, still water, resting on a polished, subtly textured granite kitchen counter. A drop of ultra-saturated crimson food coloring enters the frame from above, piercing the water's surface with minimal disturbance and beginning to sink gracefully. As it descends, it stretches and elongates, transforming from a cohesive globule into a delicate, sinuous tendril of pure color. This tendril then begins to slowly unfurl and blossom outward, its sharp edges softening into a complex, smoky plume that diffuses into the surrounding clear liquid. Bright, clean light from an off-camera source illuminates the glass, causing the red to glow from within and casting subtle, shimmering caustics on the counter. The vibrant crimson gradually fades in a captivating, fluid dynamic, transitioning to shades of scarlet and rose before fading to a pale, almost imperceptible pink that gently merges with the water, creating an atmosphere of focus, tranquility, and contemplation.", + "seed": 6848, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_7/index_1343_seed_6848_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06325248964130878, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06325248964130878, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06325248964130878, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a transparent cylindrical glass filled with still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the glass resting on a polished, subtly textured granite kitchen counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a drop of ultra-saturated crimson food coloring enter the frame from above and sink into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the red coloring transform into a sinuous tendril that unfurls and diffuses into a smoky plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, clean light causing the red to glow and casting shimmering caustics on the counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0644797831773758 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0644798278808594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0644797831773758, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0644797831773758, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23870736360549927, + 0.20371796190738678, + 0.09295668452978134, + 0.05849999561905861, + 0.08663850277662277, + 0.06829188019037247, + 0.12619532644748688, + 0.0382438488304615, + 0.06668618321418762, + 0.020062267780303955 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0644797831773758 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a transparent cylindrical glass filled with still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the glass resting on a polished, subtly textured granite kitchen counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a drop of ultra-saturated crimson food coloring enter the frame from above and sink into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the red coloring transform into a sinuous tendril that unfurls and diffuses into a smoky plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, clean light causing the red to glow and casting shimmering caustics on the counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20177972316741943 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7017797231674194 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20177972316741943, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20177972316741943, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.41106775403022766, + 0.0822877511382103, + 0.06386177241802216, + 0.036914873868227005, + 0.16852226853370667, + 0.054683867841959, + 0.09446502476930618, + 0.04647844657301903, + 0.013699944131076336, + 0.02801828272640705 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20177972316741943 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a transparent cylindrical glass filled with still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the glass resting on a polished, subtly textured granite kitchen counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a drop of ultra-saturated crimson food coloring enter the frame from above and sink into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the red coloring transform into a sinuous tendril that unfurls and diffuses into a smoky plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, clean light causing the red to glow and casting shimmering caustics on the counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004107492044568062 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504107475280762 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004107492044568062, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004107492044568062, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33789002895355225, + 0.1747865527868271, + 0.1175185889005661, + 0.053895607590675354, + 0.1304091364145279, + 0.048284176737070084, + 0.050367094576358795, + 0.056791409850120544, + 0.007692170795053244, + 0.022365223616361618 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004107492044568062 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a transparent cylindrical glass filled with still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the glass resting on a polished, subtly textured granite kitchen counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a drop of ultra-saturated crimson food coloring enter the frame from above and sink into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the red coloring transform into a sinuous tendril that unfurls and diffuses into a smoky plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, clean light causing the red to glow and casting shimmering caustics on the counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980538085103035 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298054218292236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980538085103035, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980538085103035, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4053665101528168, + 0.1377529501914978, + 0.12154090404510498, + 0.08101899921894073, + 0.046178799122571945, + 0.05711456015706062, + 0.06742700189352036, + 0.05459805577993393, + 0.011976300738751888, + 0.017025873064994812 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980538085103035 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a transparent cylindrical glass filled with still water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the glass resting on a polished, subtly textured granite kitchen counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a drop of ultra-saturated crimson food coloring enter the frame from above and sink into the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the red coloring transform into a sinuous tendril that unfurls and diffuses into a smoky plume?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by bright, clean light causing the red to glow and casting shimmering caustics on the counter?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016090068966150284 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141089916229248 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016090068966150284, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016090068966150284, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.37021690607070923, + 0.2335635870695114, + 0.05477415397763252, + 0.04265137389302254, + 0.06412304192781448, + 0.05434710904955864, + 0.05619634687900543, + 0.0468992181122303, + 0.017606358975172043, + 0.0596218965947628 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016090068966150284 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_8/index_tensor([8435, 8435])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_8/index_tensor([8435, 8435])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8cd105b5f5a0cb8800f1684227ae5ef108e27d51 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_8/index_tensor([8435, 8435])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "fixed camera close-up focuses on a pizza box carelessly discarded on a concrete staircase on a street corner. Bright, warm afternoon sunlight beats down on the rough cardboard surface. A striking, stylized, bright red rooftop logo is printed in the center of the lid. Some oil stains have seeped through the cardboard, gleaming faintly in the sunlight. Under the continued influence of heat, the once-flat lid begins to slowly and persistently deform. First, the four corners tilt upward, almost imperceptibly, and then the entire surface of the lid gradually arches upward, forming a gentle arc, subtly distorting the shadow it casts. The background is shot with a shallow depth of field, barely perceptible, revealing only the scuffed asphalt and the hurried steps of pedestrians, lending the image a rich sense of urban life. The entire process is captured steadily, without a trace of shake. The shifting light and shadows, combined with the subtle movements of the cardboard, create a casual, tranquil, and lifelike moment.", + "seed": 12311, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_8/index_8435_seed_12311_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.31696671843528745, + "vlm_logprob": -0.31696671843528745, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.8749999940395354, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.31696671843528745, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pizza box carelessly discarded on a concrete staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a bright red rooftop logo printed in the center of the pizza box lid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pizza box lid slowly and persistently deform, starting with corners tilting upward and then arching into a gentle arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background shot with a shallow depth of field, showing only scuffed asphalt and the hurried steps of pedestrians?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot steadily without any visible shake throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7602804899215698 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6352804899215698 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7602804899215698, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7602804899215698, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1734801083803177, + 0.10636717081069946, + 0.07136832177639008, + 0.0821906104683876, + 0.08307251334190369, + 0.040414538234472275, + 0.07241848111152649, + 0.07048682868480682, + 0.07945551723241806, + 0.22074593603610992 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7602804899215698 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pizza box carelessly discarded on a concrete staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a bright red rooftop logo printed in the center of the pizza box lid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pizza box lid slowly and persistently deform, starting with corners tilting upward and then arching into a gentle arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background shot with a shallow depth of field, showing only scuffed asphalt and the hurried steps of pedestrians?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot steadily without any visible shake throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020619560033082962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956196308135986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020619560033082962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020619560033082962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21297335624694824, + 0.06569325923919678, + 0.0464349128305912, + 0.028660057112574577, + 0.0525611937046051, + 0.05948697775602341, + 0.0570145919919014, + 0.0671369731426239, + 0.19226357340812683, + 0.21777509152889252 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020619560033082962 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pizza box carelessly discarded on a concrete staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a bright red rooftop logo printed in the center of the pizza box lid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pizza box lid slowly and persistently deform, starting with corners tilting upward and then arching into a gentle arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background shot with a shallow depth of field, showing only scuffed asphalt and the hurried steps of pedestrians?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot steadily without any visible shake throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01608232781291008 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141082286834717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01608232781291008, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01608232781291008, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1856013387441635, + 0.05263866111636162, + 0.14292021095752716, + 0.033482275903224945, + 0.04890797659754753, + 0.0474727600812912, + 0.05709456652402878, + 0.09852107614278793, + 0.14200028777122498, + 0.19136090576648712 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01608232781291008 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pizza box carelessly discarded on a concrete staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a bright red rooftop logo printed in the center of the pizza box lid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pizza box lid slowly and persistently deform, starting with corners tilting upward and then arching into a gentle arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background shot with a shallow depth of field, showing only scuffed asphalt and the hurried steps of pedestrians?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot steadily without any visible shake throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47436144948005676 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9743614196777344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47436144948005676, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.4999999701976776, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47436144948005676, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2588593661785126, + 0.08107481151819229, + 0.11357809603214264, + 0.0516803152859211, + 0.04985041171312332, + 0.055658720433712006, + 0.17047877609729767, + 0.04639774560928345, + 0.024969344958662987, + 0.14745235443115234 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47436144948005676 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pizza box carelessly discarded on a concrete staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a bright red rooftop logo printed in the center of the pizza box lid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pizza box lid slowly and persistently deform, starting with corners tilting upward and then arching into a gentle arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background shot with a shallow depth of field, showing only scuffed asphalt and the hurried steps of pedestrians?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot steadily without any visible shake throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31348976492881775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134897947311401 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31348976492881775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31348976492881775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14258937537670135, + 0.037772372364997864, + 0.05430898815393448, + 0.04724287614226341, + 0.06059657782316208, + 0.02165965922176838, + 0.044999659061431885, + 0.14920182526111603, + 0.1430385857820511, + 0.29859012365341187 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31348976492881775 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "fixed camera close-up focuses on a pizza box carelessly discarded on a concrete staircase on a street corner. Bright, warm afternoon sunlight beats down on the rough cardboard surface. A striking, stylized, bright red rooftop logo is printed in the center of the lid. Some oil stains have seeped through the cardboard, gleaming faintly in the sunlight. Under the continued influence of heat, the once-flat lid begins to slowly and persistently deform. First, the four corners tilt upward, almost imperceptibly, and then the entire surface of the lid gradually arches upward, forming a gentle arc, subtly distorting the shadow it casts. The background is shot with a shallow depth of field, barely perceptible, revealing only the scuffed asphalt and the hurried steps of pedestrians, lending the image a rich sense of urban life. The entire process is captured steadily, without a trace of shake. The shifting light and shadows, combined with the subtle movements of the cardboard, create a casual, tranquil, and lifelike moment.", + "seed": 12312, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_8/index_8435_seed_12312_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.4383485453203321, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4383485453203321, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.749999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4383485453203321, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pizza box carelessly discarded on a concrete staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a bright red rooftop logo printed in the center of the pizza box lid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pizza box lid slowly and persistently deform, starting with corners tilting upward and then arching into a gentle arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background shot with a shallow depth of field, showing only scuffed asphalt and the hurried steps of pedestrians?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot steadily without any visible shake throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8277177810668945 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5777177810668945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8277177810668945, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8277177810668945, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06059972941875458, + 0.034970950335264206, + 0.07795016467571259, + 0.4222981929779053, + 0.050281181931495667, + 0.20044444501399994, + 0.0619145929813385, + 0.020931340754032135, + 0.03334817290306091, + 0.03726126253604889 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8277177810668945 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pizza box carelessly discarded on a concrete staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a bright red rooftop logo printed in the center of the pizza box lid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pizza box lid slowly and persistently deform, starting with corners tilting upward and then arching into a gentle arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background shot with a shallow depth of field, showing only scuffed asphalt and the hurried steps of pedestrians?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot steadily without any visible shake throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016091125085949898 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141091346740723 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016091125085949898, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016091125085949898, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23350824415683746, + 0.12183500081300735, + 0.06665816903114319, + 0.17089474201202393, + 0.05564911291003227, + 0.13620612025260925, + 0.04708156734704971, + 0.0273855309933424, + 0.09470723569393158, + 0.04607431963086128 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016091125085949898 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pizza box carelessly discarded on a concrete staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a bright red rooftop logo printed in the center of the pizza box lid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pizza box lid slowly and persistently deform, starting with corners tilting upward and then arching into a gentle arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background shot with a shallow depth of field, showing only scuffed asphalt and the hurried steps of pedestrians?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot steadily without any visible shake throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012551716528832912 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387551784515381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012551716528832912, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012551716528832912, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08329825848340988, + 0.032413024455308914, + 0.06574682146310806, + 0.22247594594955444, + 0.059361256659030914, + 0.09076742827892303, + 0.08836635947227478, + 0.07322429120540619, + 0.1895223706960678, + 0.09482428431510925 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012551716528832912 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pizza box carelessly discarded on a concrete staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a bright red rooftop logo printed in the center of the pizza box lid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pizza box lid slowly and persistently deform, starting with corners tilting upward and then arching into a gentle arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background shot with a shallow depth of field, showing only scuffed asphalt and the hurried steps of pedestrians?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot steadily without any visible shake throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539677143096924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289676547050476 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0539677143096924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.6250000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0539677143096924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0666024312376976, + 0.09246931225061417, + 0.06785010546445847, + 0.19608457386493683, + 0.06105034053325653, + 0.2092161476612091, + 0.12104547023773193, + 0.0258525051176548, + 0.05976923182606697, + 0.10005979239940643 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0539677143096924 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pizza box carelessly discarded on a concrete staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a bright red rooftop logo printed in the center of the pizza box lid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pizza box lid slowly and persistently deform, starting with corners tilting upward and then arching into a gentle arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background shot with a shallow depth of field, showing only scuffed asphalt and the hurried steps of pedestrians?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot steadily without any visible shake throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2814143896102905 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4064143896102905 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2814143896102905, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2814143896102905, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07021790742874146, + 0.025538641959428787, + 0.0686279907822609, + 0.1012364998459816, + 0.06496135890483856, + 0.14550146460533142, + 0.1323913335800171, + 0.07101365178823471, + 0.12949813902378082, + 0.19101303815841675 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2814143896102905 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "fixed camera close-up focuses on a pizza box carelessly discarded on a concrete staircase on a street corner. Bright, warm afternoon sunlight beats down on the rough cardboard surface. A striking, stylized, bright red rooftop logo is printed in the center of the lid. Some oil stains have seeped through the cardboard, gleaming faintly in the sunlight. Under the continued influence of heat, the once-flat lid begins to slowly and persistently deform. First, the four corners tilt upward, almost imperceptibly, and then the entire surface of the lid gradually arches upward, forming a gentle arc, subtly distorting the shadow it casts. The background is shot with a shallow depth of field, barely perceptible, revealing only the scuffed asphalt and the hurried steps of pedestrians, lending the image a rich sense of urban life. The entire process is captured steadily, without a trace of shake. The shifting light and shadows, combined with the subtle movements of the cardboard, create a casual, tranquil, and lifelike moment.", + "seed": 12313, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_8/index_8435_seed_12313_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.4784140452742577, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4784140452742577, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.474999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4784140452742577, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.6, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pizza box carelessly discarded on a concrete staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a bright red rooftop logo printed in the center of the pizza box lid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pizza box lid slowly and persistently deform, starting with corners tilting upward and then arching into a gentle arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background shot with a shallow depth of field, showing only scuffed asphalt and the hurried steps of pedestrians?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot steadily without any visible shake throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6948463916778564 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6948463916778564 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6948463916778564, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6948463916778564, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22281022369861603, + 0.10197220742702484, + 0.04487410560250282, + 0.04041595011949539, + 0.06369654834270477, + 0.11176741123199463, + 0.17529110610485077, + 0.07173052430152893, + 0.029368717223405838, + 0.13807323575019836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6948463916778564 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pizza box carelessly discarded on a concrete staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a bright red rooftop logo printed in the center of the pizza box lid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pizza box lid slowly and persistently deform, starting with corners tilting upward and then arching into a gentle arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background shot with a shallow depth of field, showing only scuffed asphalt and the hurried steps of pedestrians?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot steadily without any visible shake throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026372551918029785 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513724327087402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026372551918029785, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026372551918029785, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11208488792181015, + 0.0788496807217598, + 0.07781990617513657, + 0.06665905565023422, + 0.1180986687541008, + 0.10940989851951599, + 0.1454007476568222, + 0.0724070817232132, + 0.05486331135034561, + 0.16440673172473907 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026372551918029785 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pizza box carelessly discarded on a concrete staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a bright red rooftop logo printed in the center of the pizza box lid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pizza box lid slowly and persistently deform, starting with corners tilting upward and then arching into a gentle arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background shot with a shallow depth of field, showing only scuffed asphalt and the hurried steps of pedestrians?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot steadily without any visible shake throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01820661872625351 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018206596374512 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01820661872625351, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01820661872625351, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06774307042360306, + 0.029396958649158478, + 0.028241772204637527, + 0.03947873041033745, + 0.06391933560371399, + 0.020326541736721992, + 0.052978526800870895, + 0.11496499180793762, + 0.0480029433965683, + 0.5349470973014832 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01820661872625351 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pizza box carelessly discarded on a concrete staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a bright red rooftop logo printed in the center of the pizza box lid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pizza box lid slowly and persistently deform, starting with corners tilting upward and then arching into a gentle arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background shot with a shallow depth of field, showing only scuffed asphalt and the hurried steps of pedestrians?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot steadily without any visible shake throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236714363098145 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486713767051697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.2236714363098145, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.8750000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -1.2236714363098145, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1269543319940567, + 0.08426428586244583, + 0.037541504949331284, + 0.027971412986516953, + 0.08846371620893478, + 0.0715145543217659, + 0.10532093793153763, + 0.11323165893554688, + 0.11345434188842773, + 0.2312832474708557 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.2236714363098145 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pizza box carelessly discarded on a concrete staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a bright red rooftop logo printed in the center of the pizza box lid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pizza box lid slowly and persistently deform, starting with corners tilting upward and then arching into a gentle arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background shot with a shallow depth of field, showing only scuffed asphalt and the hurried steps of pedestrians?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot steadily without any visible shake throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289732277393341 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539731979370117 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4289732277393341, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4289732277393341, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06076729670166969, + 0.04612079635262489, + 0.06922133266925812, + 0.08834455907344818, + 0.06718938052654266, + 0.08108150213956833, + 0.03797174245119095, + 0.11039131134748459, + 0.03296520933508873, + 0.40594685077667236 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4289732277393341 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "fixed camera close-up focuses on a pizza box carelessly discarded on a concrete staircase on a street corner. Bright, warm afternoon sunlight beats down on the rough cardboard surface. A striking, stylized, bright red rooftop logo is printed in the center of the lid. Some oil stains have seeped through the cardboard, gleaming faintly in the sunlight. Under the continued influence of heat, the once-flat lid begins to slowly and persistently deform. First, the four corners tilt upward, almost imperceptibly, and then the entire surface of the lid gradually arches upward, forming a gentle arc, subtly distorting the shadow it casts. The background is shot with a shallow depth of field, barely perceptible, revealing only the scuffed asphalt and the hurried steps of pedestrians, lending the image a rich sense of urban life. The entire process is captured steadily, without a trace of shake. The shifting light and shadows, combined with the subtle movements of the cardboard, create a casual, tranquil, and lifelike moment.", + "seed": 12314, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_8/index_8435_seed_12314_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.3323869802057743, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3323869802057743, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3323869802057743, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pizza box carelessly discarded on a concrete staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a bright red rooftop logo printed in the center of the pizza box lid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pizza box lid slowly and persistently deform, starting with corners tilting upward and then arching into a gentle arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background shot with a shallow depth of field, showing only scuffed asphalt and the hurried steps of pedestrians?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot steadily without any visible shake throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7590675950050354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6340675950050354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7590675950050354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7590675950050354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.322027325630188, + 0.04356493055820465, + 0.07903830707073212, + 0.2783307433128357, + 0.06488066166639328, + 0.044999416917562485, + 0.020465761423110962, + 0.045921746641397476, + 0.031094921752810478, + 0.06967614591121674 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7590675950050354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pizza box carelessly discarded on a concrete staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a bright red rooftop logo printed in the center of the pizza box lid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pizza box lid slowly and persistently deform, starting with corners tilting upward and then arching into a gentle arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background shot with a shallow depth of field, showing only scuffed asphalt and the hurried steps of pedestrians?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot steadily without any visible shake throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012566667050123215 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387566566467285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012566667050123215, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012566667050123215, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.088060662150383, + 0.04522786661982536, + 0.08969394117593765, + 0.36135774850845337, + 0.12973561882972717, + 0.01747114583849907, + 0.013102434575557709, + 0.028332728892564774, + 0.12037099897861481, + 0.1066468209028244 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012566667050123215 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pizza box carelessly discarded on a concrete staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a bright red rooftop logo printed in the center of the pizza box lid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pizza box lid slowly and persistently deform, starting with corners tilting upward and then arching into a gentle arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background shot with a shallow depth of field, showing only scuffed asphalt and the hurried steps of pedestrians?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot steadily without any visible shake throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018199361860752106 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018199443817139 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018199361860752106, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018199361860752106, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10734301805496216, + 0.04295096546411514, + 0.15484361350536346, + 0.24620237946510315, + 0.19866758584976196, + 0.05848492681980133, + 0.02265203185379505, + 0.04847561940550804, + 0.07532346993684769, + 0.04505639895796776 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018199361860752106 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pizza box carelessly discarded on a concrete staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a bright red rooftop logo printed in the center of the pizza box lid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pizza box lid slowly and persistently deform, starting with corners tilting upward and then arching into a gentle arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background shot with a shallow depth of field, showing only scuffed asphalt and the hurried steps of pedestrians?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot steadily without any visible shake throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3487088978290558 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2237088680267334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3487088978290558, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3487088978290558, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40318137407302856, + 0.04725435748696327, + 0.060279399156570435, + 0.26839834451675415, + 0.00936107523739338, + 0.007767616305500269, + 0.012682134285569191, + 0.03751366585493088, + 0.04968501254916191, + 0.10387703776359558 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3487088978290558 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a pizza box carelessly discarded on a concrete staircase?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is there a bright red rooftop logo printed in the center of the pizza box lid?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the pizza box lid slowly and persistently deform, starting with corners tilting upward and then arching into a gentle arc?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background shot with a shallow depth of field, showing only scuffed asphalt and the hurried steps of pedestrians?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot steadily without any visible shake throughout the video?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.523392379283905 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.898392379283905 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.523392379283905, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.523392379283905, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35666802525520325, + 0.04494955763220787, + 0.04652494192123413, + 0.22386591136455536, + 0.04947953298687935, + 0.022251781076192856, + 0.03743297979235649, + 0.04605189710855484, + 0.07197638601064682, + 0.10079897195100784 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.523392379283905 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_9/index_tensor([7060, 7060])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_9/index_tensor([7060, 7060])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7183d087795e3cb9f1ff0aa105b4675f57898004 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_9/index_tensor([7060, 7060])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a medium shot shot from a low angle, a dramatic beam of light, like a stage spotlight, slants down from the water's surface, piercing the murky, yellowish water and precisely illuminating an epic confrontation at the bottom of the riverbed. A European catfish, a massive, behemoth, its sleek skin, mottled with olive green and dark brown, appears slick and powerful in the light. Its broad, flat head, long, tentacle-like whiskers sway gently in the current, its massive mouth slightly open, its small, piercing eyes flashing with primal aggression. Opposite it, an equally massive black fish, its body slender and powerful, covered in darkly patterned scales as fine as snakeskin. Its dorsal and pectoral fins are fully extended, like a warrior's drawn weapons. Two giants stand in a tense standoff between rotting leaves and smooth pebbles, their bodies tensely arched. Every subtle movement stirs up clouds of fine mud and organic debris, forming swirling clouds in the water, creating an atmosphere of imminent tension. Suddenly, with a swift and decisive push, the camera plunges into the tense, narrow expanse of water between them, focusing instantly on their heads and gaping maws about to collide, freezing this primal and untamed collision with cinematic impact.", + "seed": 16106, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_9/index_7060_seed_16106_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.012212276924401522, + "vlm_logprob": -0.012212276924401522, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.012212276924401522, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with murky, yellowish water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a European catfish with olive green and dark brown mottled skin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive black fish with darkly patterned scales visible opposite the catfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot and then plunge forward between the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dramatic beam of light slanting down from the water's surface visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001674322527833283 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751674175262451 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001674322527833283, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001674322527833283, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09874244034290314, + 0.04962926730513573, + 0.03193414956331253, + 0.02648790366947651, + 0.0478227399289608, + 0.32852616906166077, + 0.0358278751373291, + 0.26987898349761963, + 0.06921916455030441, + 0.04193127900362015 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001674322527833283 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with murky, yellowish water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a European catfish with olive green and dark brown mottled skin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive black fish with darkly patterned scales visible opposite the catfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot and then plunge forward between the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dramatic beam of light slanting down from the water's surface visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978860817849636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634788513183594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978860817849636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978860817849636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23636457324028015, + 0.13150593638420105, + 0.031415700912475586, + 0.03872236981987953, + 0.028102464973926544, + 0.08882397413253784, + 0.09464796632528305, + 0.06955725699663162, + 0.1813722401857376, + 0.09948747605085373 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978860817849636 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with murky, yellowish water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a European catfish with olive green and dark brown mottled skin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive black fish with darkly patterned scales visible opposite the catfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot and then plunge forward between the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dramatic beam of light slanting down from the water's surface visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03369026258587837 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086902141571045 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03369026258587837, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03369026258587837, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05095827579498291, + 0.044626634567976, + 0.02005910314619541, + 0.030001366510987282, + 0.046054501086473465, + 0.12427330762147903, + 0.05704238638281822, + 0.23131750524044037, + 0.3234492242336273, + 0.07221765071153641 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03369026258587837 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with murky, yellowish water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a European catfish with olive green and dark brown mottled skin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive black fish with darkly patterned scales visible opposite the catfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot and then plunge forward between the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dramatic beam of light slanting down from the water's surface visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01419447734951973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264194488525391 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01419447734951973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01419447734951973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13984937965869904, + 0.04371171072125435, + 0.03837411850690842, + 0.040496230125427246, + 0.05528884753584862, + 0.23618435859680176, + 0.07274945080280304, + 0.08151046186685562, + 0.20283527672290802, + 0.08900018036365509 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01419447734951973 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with murky, yellowish water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a European catfish with olive green and dark brown mottled skin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive black fish with darkly patterned scales visible opposite the catfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot and then plunge forward between the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dramatic beam of light slanting down from the water's surface visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017137139802798629 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376713752746582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017137139802798629, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017137139802798629, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16030557453632355, + 0.07505297660827637, + 0.049970969557762146, + 0.0689859688282013, + 0.040299009531736374, + 0.19893571734428406, + 0.0638444721698761, + 0.14916661381721497, + 0.13078849017620087, + 0.06265022605657578 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017137139802798629 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a medium shot shot from a low angle, a dramatic beam of light, like a stage spotlight, slants down from the water's surface, piercing the murky, yellowish water and precisely illuminating an epic confrontation at the bottom of the riverbed. A European catfish, a massive, behemoth, its sleek skin, mottled with olive green and dark brown, appears slick and powerful in the light. Its broad, flat head, long, tentacle-like whiskers sway gently in the current, its massive mouth slightly open, its small, piercing eyes flashing with primal aggression. Opposite it, an equally massive black fish, its body slender and powerful, covered in darkly patterned scales as fine as snakeskin. Its dorsal and pectoral fins are fully extended, like a warrior's drawn weapons. Two giants stand in a tense standoff between rotting leaves and smooth pebbles, their bodies tensely arched. Every subtle movement stirs up clouds of fine mud and organic debris, forming swirling clouds in the water, creating an atmosphere of imminent tension. Suddenly, with a swift and decisive push, the camera plunges into the tense, narrow expanse of water between them, focusing instantly on their heads and gaping maws about to collide, freezing this primal and untamed collision with cinematic impact.", + "seed": 16107, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_9/index_7060_seed_16107_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.016626001219265163, + "vlm_logprob": -0.016626001219265163, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.016626001219265163, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with murky, yellowish water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a European catfish with olive green and dark brown mottled skin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive black fish with darkly patterned scales visible opposite the catfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot and then plunge forward between the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dramatic beam of light slanting down from the water's surface visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0018974411068484187 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.25189733505249 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0018974411068484187, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0018974411068484187, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11297158896923065, + 0.04837089776992798, + 0.3056183159351349, + 0.06416252255439758, + 0.03337456285953522, + 0.022653527557849884, + 0.04422956705093384, + 0.04205217584967613, + 0.059518247842788696, + 0.2670486271381378 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0018974411068484187 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with murky, yellowish water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a European catfish with olive green and dark brown mottled skin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive black fish with darkly patterned scales visible opposite the catfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot and then plunge forward between the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dramatic beam of light slanting down from the water's surface visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009789552539587021 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.63478946685791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009789552539587021, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009789552539587021, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09767460823059082, + 0.028959039598703384, + 0.15827058255672455, + 0.04951847344636917, + 0.0378352627158165, + 0.05770228058099747, + 0.15344668924808502, + 0.06738320738077164, + 0.22699621319770813, + 0.12221366167068481 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009789552539587021 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with murky, yellowish water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a European catfish with olive green and dark brown mottled skin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive black fish with darkly patterned scales visible opposite the catfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot and then plunge forward between the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dramatic beam of light slanting down from the water's surface visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048640813678503036 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048640727996826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048640813678503036, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048640813678503036, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14537592232227325, + 0.08217453211545944, + 0.09733829647302628, + 0.12052441388368607, + 0.04824957996606827, + 0.05556162819266319, + 0.06632581353187561, + 0.2619117796421051, + 0.03985460847616196, + 0.08268345892429352 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048640813678503036 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with murky, yellowish water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a European catfish with olive green and dark brown mottled skin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive black fish with darkly patterned scales visible opposite the catfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot and then plunge forward between the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dramatic beam of light slanting down from the water's surface visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606719382107258 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141067028045654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606719382107258, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606719382107258, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07647985965013504, + 0.06670024991035461, + 0.2025326043367386, + 0.06474559009075165, + 0.019216828048229218, + 0.029632167890667915, + 0.07845612615346909, + 0.054891809821128845, + 0.132792666554451, + 0.27455219626426697 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606719382107258 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with murky, yellowish water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a European catfish with olive green and dark brown mottled skin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive black fish with darkly patterned scales visible opposite the catfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot and then plunge forward between the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dramatic beam of light slanting down from the water's surface visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00673500495031476 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006734848022461 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00673500495031476, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00673500495031476, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15754511952400208, + 0.03219126909971237, + 0.5950375199317932, + 0.015042170882225037, + 0.018030080944299698, + 0.01727255806326866, + 0.026215331628918648, + 0.017474591732025146, + 0.0329352505505085, + 0.08825608342885971 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00673500495031476 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a medium shot shot from a low angle, a dramatic beam of light, like a stage spotlight, slants down from the water's surface, piercing the murky, yellowish water and precisely illuminating an epic confrontation at the bottom of the riverbed. A European catfish, a massive, behemoth, its sleek skin, mottled with olive green and dark brown, appears slick and powerful in the light. Its broad, flat head, long, tentacle-like whiskers sway gently in the current, its massive mouth slightly open, its small, piercing eyes flashing with primal aggression. Opposite it, an equally massive black fish, its body slender and powerful, covered in darkly patterned scales as fine as snakeskin. Its dorsal and pectoral fins are fully extended, like a warrior's drawn weapons. Two giants stand in a tense standoff between rotting leaves and smooth pebbles, their bodies tensely arched. Every subtle movement stirs up clouds of fine mud and organic debris, forming swirling clouds in the water, creating an atmosphere of imminent tension. Suddenly, with a swift and decisive push, the camera plunges into the tense, narrow expanse of water between them, focusing instantly on their heads and gaping maws about to collide, freezing this primal and untamed collision with cinematic impact.", + "seed": 16108, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_9/index_7060_seed_16108_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.009062800416722893, + "vlm_logprob": -0.009062800416722893, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 5.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.009062800416722893, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with murky, yellowish water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a European catfish with olive green and dark brown mottled skin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive black fish with darkly patterned scales visible opposite the catfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot and then plunge forward between the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dramatic beam of light slanting down from the water's surface visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0020703088957816362 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.502070426940918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0020703088957816362, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0020703088957816362, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24583891034126282, + 0.0647236779332161, + 0.08828908205032349, + 0.08400418609380722, + 0.0510752834379673, + 0.07709050923585892, + 0.07772769033908844, + 0.08983320742845535, + 0.06245209649205208, + 0.1589653044939041 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0020703088957816362 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with murky, yellowish water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a European catfish with olive green and dark brown mottled skin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive black fish with darkly patterned scales visible opposite the catfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot and then plunge forward between the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dramatic beam of light slanting down from the water's surface visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006743649020791054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006743431091309 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006743649020791054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006743649020791054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1817779690027237, + 0.06967721879482269, + 0.06375334411859512, + 0.033899519592523575, + 0.0672217532992363, + 0.11756807565689087, + 0.11987580358982086, + 0.07330919057130814, + 0.0963142067193985, + 0.1766028255224228 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006743649020791054 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with murky, yellowish water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a European catfish with olive green and dark brown mottled skin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive black fish with darkly patterned scales visible opposite the catfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot and then plunge forward between the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dramatic beam of light slanting down from the water's surface visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012534293346107006 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387534141540527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012534293346107006, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012534293346107006, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09442473202943802, + 0.11495553702116013, + 0.1247161477804184, + 0.033731523901224136, + 0.0459546223282814, + 0.06200924888253212, + 0.04141833260655403, + 0.05863400921225548, + 0.11219430714845657, + 0.31196147203445435 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012534293346107006 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with murky, yellowish water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a European catfish with olive green and dark brown mottled skin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive black fish with darkly patterned scales visible opposite the catfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot and then plunge forward between the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dramatic beam of light slanting down from the water's surface visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014190363697707653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264190196990967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014190363697707653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014190363697707653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14242351055145264, + 0.060272008180618286, + 0.07086563855409622, + 0.06558910012245178, + 0.07224569469690323, + 0.051241353154182434, + 0.05264700949192047, + 0.26776471734046936, + 0.06269106268882751, + 0.1542598307132721 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014190363697707653 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with murky, yellowish water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a European catfish with olive green and dark brown mottled skin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive black fish with darkly patterned scales visible opposite the catfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot and then plunge forward between the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dramatic beam of light slanting down from the water's surface visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00977538712322712 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634775161743164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00977538712322712, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00977538712322712, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.48722246289253235, + 0.03590648993849754, + 0.10056343674659729, + 0.027996554970741272, + 0.024005332961678505, + 0.050901465117931366, + 0.02156377024948597, + 0.06822868436574936, + 0.11483930796384811, + 0.06877246499061584 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00977538712322712 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a medium shot shot from a low angle, a dramatic beam of light, like a stage spotlight, slants down from the water's surface, piercing the murky, yellowish water and precisely illuminating an epic confrontation at the bottom of the riverbed. A European catfish, a massive, behemoth, its sleek skin, mottled with olive green and dark brown, appears slick and powerful in the light. Its broad, flat head, long, tentacle-like whiskers sway gently in the current, its massive mouth slightly open, its small, piercing eyes flashing with primal aggression. Opposite it, an equally massive black fish, its body slender and powerful, covered in darkly patterned scales as fine as snakeskin. Its dorsal and pectoral fins are fully extended, like a warrior's drawn weapons. Two giants stand in a tense standoff between rotting leaves and smooth pebbles, their bodies tensely arched. Every subtle movement stirs up clouds of fine mud and organic debris, forming swirling clouds in the water, creating an atmosphere of imminent tension. Suddenly, with a swift and decisive push, the camera plunges into the tense, narrow expanse of water between them, focusing instantly on their heads and gaping maws about to collide, freezing this primal and untamed collision with cinematic impact.", + "seed": 16109, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000276/group_9/index_7060_seed_16109_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.015763218025676907, + "vlm_logprob": -0.015763218025676907, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.015763218025676907, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with murky, yellowish water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a European catfish with olive green and dark brown mottled skin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive black fish with darkly patterned scales visible opposite the catfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot and then plunge forward between the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dramatic beam of light slanting down from the water's surface visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017326356610283256 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.12673282623291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017326356610283256, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017326356610283256, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14665517210960388, + 0.11176036298274994, + 0.19648805260658264, + 0.08869138360023499, + 0.0342327356338501, + 0.06097830832004547, + 0.03997041657567024, + 0.02379620634019375, + 0.18720826506614685, + 0.1102190762758255 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017326356610283256 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with murky, yellowish water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a European catfish with olive green and dark brown mottled skin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive black fish with darkly patterned scales visible opposite the catfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot and then plunge forward between the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dramatic beam of light slanting down from the water's surface visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978849083185196 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634788513183594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978849083185196, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978849083185196, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1372610181570053, + 0.0687580332159996, + 0.09836051613092422, + 0.1507020890712738, + 0.03547185659408569, + 0.13491319119930267, + 0.09619353711605072, + 0.026470495387911797, + 0.05150647461414337, + 0.20036280155181885 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978849083185196 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with murky, yellowish water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a European catfish with olive green and dark brown mottled skin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive black fish with darkly patterned scales visible opposite the catfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot and then plunge forward between the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dramatic beam of light slanting down from the water's surface visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020572146400809288 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955721855163574 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020572146400809288, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020572146400809288, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.119218610227108, + 0.0498974435031414, + 0.0596170537173748, + 0.07746052742004395, + 0.0966615378856659, + 0.2922664284706116, + 0.033264048397541046, + 0.05036946013569832, + 0.04819084703922272, + 0.17305408418178558 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020572146400809288 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with murky, yellowish water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a European catfish with olive green and dark brown mottled skin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive black fish with darkly patterned scales visible opposite the catfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot and then plunge forward between the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dramatic beam of light slanting down from the water's surface visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008637449704110622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758637428283691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008637449704110622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008637449704110622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07746761292219162, + 0.02300354465842247, + 0.05717841163277626, + 0.20995207130908966, + 0.04802463576197624, + 0.07307415455579758, + 0.0339985191822052, + 0.03237462043762207, + 0.1429254114627838, + 0.3020009398460388 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008637449704110622 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set underwater with murky, yellowish water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a European catfish with olive green and dark brown mottled skin visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a massive black fish with darkly patterned scales visible opposite the catfish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle medium shot and then plunge forward between the fish?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a dramatic beam of light slanting down from the water's surface visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038085367530584335 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288085460662842 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038085367530584335, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038085367530584335, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05515431612730026, + 0.0407690703868866, + 0.03925379738211632, + 0.06432262808084488, + 0.0656285285949707, + 0.046661242842674255, + 0.026881521567702293, + 0.040513698011636734, + 0.5245259404182434, + 0.09628931432962418 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038085367530584335 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_0/index_tensor([9710, 9710])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_0/index_tensor([9710, 9710])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5d4d08799f786b44a1865b1ba601d58d2157b93d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_0/index_tensor([9710, 9710])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle wide shot captures a massive, complex structure of interlocking geometric solids—cubes, tetrahedrons, and multifaceted polyhedra—as the camera steadily tilts upward, following its majestic ascent. The structure's surface is a mosaic of matte black, non-reflective coatings, and polished chrome panels, capturing the dim ambient light of a faint alien twilight. Complex, glowing cyan circuitry pulses energy along the seams connecting the shapes, their positions constantly and silently reconfiguring. As the machine begins to rise from the barren, shattered desert earth, a low, inaudible hum rises, and the ground directly beneath it begins to tremble. Fine particles of metallic dust and larger fragments of rust-colored metal are meticulously pulled from the ground and drawn into a powerful, swirling vortex, imagining immense magnetic forces. Glittering arcs of electric blue energy thread through this debris tornado, violently churning the fragments as the structure rises with deliberate, unstoppable force, creating an atmosphere of awe-inspiring and overwhelming technological power.", + "seed": 29807, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_0/index_9710_seed_29807_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.13461874658241868, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13461874658241868, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13461874658241868, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive structure composed of interlocking geometric solids like cubes, tetrahedrons, and polyhedra?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the structure's surface a mosaic of matte black non-reflective coatings and polished chrome panels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there glowing cyan circuitry lines pulsing along the seams connecting the shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a steady upward tilt to follow the structure's ascent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the structure rising from a barren, shattered desert environment while pulling metallic dust and rust-colored fragments into a swirling vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013713079504668713 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3887128829956055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013713079504668713, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013713079504668713, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2737843990325928, + 0.07700178772211075, + 0.05504003167152405, + 0.30058902502059937, + 0.037795212119817734, + 0.05192616209387779, + 0.045276328921318054, + 0.0828438401222229, + 0.03731030598282814, + 0.038432974368333817 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013713079504668713 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive structure composed of interlocking geometric solids like cubes, tetrahedrons, and polyhedra?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the structure's surface a mosaic of matte black non-reflective coatings and polished chrome panels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there glowing cyan circuitry lines pulsing along the seams connecting the shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a steady upward tilt to follow the structure's ascent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the structure rising from a barren, shattered desert environment while pulling metallic dust and rust-colored fragments into a swirling vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761070251464844 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261070251464844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761070251464844, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761070251464844, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15945908427238464, + 0.2126462757587433, + 0.1588829755783081, + 0.11161458492279053, + 0.04783894121646881, + 0.0521744042634964, + 0.0621841698884964, + 0.07680393755435944, + 0.07120825350284576, + 0.0471874363720417 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761070251464844 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive structure composed of interlocking geometric solids like cubes, tetrahedrons, and polyhedra?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the structure's surface a mosaic of matte black non-reflective coatings and polished chrome panels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there glowing cyan circuitry lines pulsing along the seams connecting the shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a steady upward tilt to follow the structure's ascent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the structure rising from a barren, shattered desert environment while pulling metallic dust and rust-colored fragments into a swirling vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008643949404358864 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758644104003906 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008643949404358864, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008643949404358864, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16080991923809052, + 0.09951639175415039, + 0.12435857206583023, + 0.1435053050518036, + 0.05614117905497551, + 0.172535240650177, + 0.10478699952363968, + 0.05152334272861481, + 0.054483167827129364, + 0.03233984857797623 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008643949404358864 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive structure composed of interlocking geometric solids like cubes, tetrahedrons, and polyhedra?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the structure's surface a mosaic of matte black non-reflective coatings and polished chrome panels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there glowing cyan circuitry lines pulsing along the seams connecting the shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a steady upward tilt to follow the structure's ascent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the structure rising from a barren, shattered desert environment while pulling metallic dust and rust-colored fragments into a swirling vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06999769806861877 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.694997787475586 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06999769806861877, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06999769806861877, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24445518851280212, + 0.10288091003894806, + 0.03886944800615311, + 0.0516430139541626, + 0.06193262338638306, + 0.045194730162620544, + 0.08340871334075928, + 0.11466840654611588, + 0.14779344201087952, + 0.10915348678827286 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06999769806861877 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive structure composed of interlocking geometric solids like cubes, tetrahedrons, and polyhedra?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the structure's surface a mosaic of matte black non-reflective coatings and polished chrome panels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there glowing cyan circuitry lines pulsing along the seams connecting the shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a steady upward tilt to follow the structure's ascent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the structure rising from a barren, shattered desert environment while pulling metallic dust and rust-colored fragments into a swirling vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004631980787962675 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379631996154785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004631980787962675, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004631980787962675, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16174621880054474, + 0.052743323147296906, + 0.034027013927698135, + 0.03653827682137489, + 0.059553906321525574, + 0.08459160476922989, + 0.18065756559371948, + 0.0695362389087677, + 0.14240682125091553, + 0.17819906771183014 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004631980787962675 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle wide shot captures a massive, complex structure of interlocking geometric solids—cubes, tetrahedrons, and multifaceted polyhedra—as the camera steadily tilts upward, following its majestic ascent. The structure's surface is a mosaic of matte black, non-reflective coatings, and polished chrome panels, capturing the dim ambient light of a faint alien twilight. Complex, glowing cyan circuitry pulses energy along the seams connecting the shapes, their positions constantly and silently reconfiguring. As the machine begins to rise from the barren, shattered desert earth, a low, inaudible hum rises, and the ground directly beneath it begins to tremble. Fine particles of metallic dust and larger fragments of rust-colored metal are meticulously pulled from the ground and drawn into a powerful, swirling vortex, imagining immense magnetic forces. Glittering arcs of electric blue energy thread through this debris tornado, violently churning the fragments as the structure rises with deliberate, unstoppable force, creating an atmosphere of awe-inspiring and overwhelming technological power.", + "seed": 29808, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_0/index_9710_seed_29808_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.19522955026477576, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19522955026477576, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19522955026477576, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive structure composed of interlocking geometric solids like cubes, tetrahedrons, and polyhedra?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the structure's surface a mosaic of matte black non-reflective coatings and polished chrome panels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there glowing cyan circuitry lines pulsing along the seams connecting the shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a steady upward tilt to follow the structure's ascent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the structure rising from a barren, shattered desert environment while pulling metallic dust and rust-colored fragments into a swirling vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.027679288759827614 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.652679204940796 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.027679288759827614, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.027679288759827614, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26784637570381165, + 0.26412397623062134, + 0.054949842393398285, + 0.03638550639152527, + 0.06862062960863113, + 0.07105909287929535, + 0.040506135672330856, + 0.06198681890964508, + 0.08048275858163834, + 0.05403889715671539 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.027679288759827614 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive structure composed of interlocking geometric solids like cubes, tetrahedrons, and polyhedra?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the structure's surface a mosaic of matte black non-reflective coatings and polished chrome panels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there glowing cyan circuitry lines pulsing along the seams connecting the shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a steady upward tilt to follow the structure's ascent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the structure rising from a barren, shattered desert environment while pulling metallic dust and rust-colored fragments into a swirling vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7577757835388184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6327757835388184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7577757835388184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7577757835388184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1678776890039444, + 0.30063530802726746, + 0.07628477364778519, + 0.04136598855257034, + 0.14400333166122437, + 0.08507241308689117, + 0.057177845388650894, + 0.03557770326733589, + 0.0522678978741169, + 0.0397370345890522 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7577757835388184 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive structure composed of interlocking geometric solids like cubes, tetrahedrons, and polyhedra?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the structure's surface a mosaic of matte black non-reflective coatings and polished chrome panels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there glowing cyan circuitry lines pulsing along the seams connecting the shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a steady upward tilt to follow the structure's ascent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the structure rising from a barren, shattered desert environment while pulling metallic dust and rust-colored fragments into a swirling vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004101437050849199 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504101276397705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004101437050849199, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004101437050849199, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21829655766487122, + 0.18236143887043, + 0.1400403529405594, + 0.04597370699048042, + 0.0886770710349083, + 0.11136035621166229, + 0.05365839973092079, + 0.05258934199810028, + 0.047129999846220016, + 0.059912797063589096 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004101437050849199 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive structure composed of interlocking geometric solids like cubes, tetrahedrons, and polyhedra?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the structure's surface a mosaic of matte black non-reflective coatings and polished chrome panels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there glowing cyan circuitry lines pulsing along the seams connecting the shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a steady upward tilt to follow the structure's ascent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the structure rising from a barren, shattered desert environment while pulling metallic dust and rust-colored fragments into a swirling vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17985789477825165 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804857850074768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17985789477825165, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17985789477825165, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22071656584739685, + 0.12265707552433014, + 0.0731484591960907, + 0.04574931040406227, + 0.04605180397629738, + 0.10391082614660263, + 0.037343233823776245, + 0.11406809836626053, + 0.18011632561683655, + 0.056238286197185516 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17985789477825165 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive structure composed of interlocking geometric solids like cubes, tetrahedrons, and polyhedra?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the structure's surface a mosaic of matte black non-reflective coatings and polished chrome panels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there glowing cyan circuitry lines pulsing along the seams connecting the shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a steady upward tilt to follow the structure's ascent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the structure rising from a barren, shattered desert environment while pulling metallic dust and rust-colored fragments into a swirling vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006733347196131945 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006733417510986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006733347196131945, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006733347196131945, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18133540451526642, + 0.15276247262954712, + 0.03143559396266937, + 0.0642901062965393, + 0.04970529302954674, + 0.07541309297084808, + 0.060901619493961334, + 0.07588517665863037, + 0.2082025110721588, + 0.10006876289844513 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006733347196131945 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle wide shot captures a massive, complex structure of interlocking geometric solids—cubes, tetrahedrons, and multifaceted polyhedra—as the camera steadily tilts upward, following its majestic ascent. The structure's surface is a mosaic of matte black, non-reflective coatings, and polished chrome panels, capturing the dim ambient light of a faint alien twilight. Complex, glowing cyan circuitry pulses energy along the seams connecting the shapes, their positions constantly and silently reconfiguring. As the machine begins to rise from the barren, shattered desert earth, a low, inaudible hum rises, and the ground directly beneath it begins to tremble. Fine particles of metallic dust and larger fragments of rust-colored metal are meticulously pulled from the ground and drawn into a powerful, swirling vortex, imagining immense magnetic forces. Glittering arcs of electric blue energy thread through this debris tornado, violently churning the fragments as the structure rises with deliberate, unstoppable force, creating an atmosphere of awe-inspiring and overwhelming technological power.", + "seed": 29809, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_0/index_9710_seed_29809_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.15258368737995626, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15258368737995626, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15258368737995626, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive structure composed of interlocking geometric solids like cubes, tetrahedrons, and polyhedra?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the structure's surface a mosaic of matte black non-reflective coatings and polished chrome panels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there glowing cyan circuitry lines pulsing along the seams connecting the shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a steady upward tilt to follow the structure's ascent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the structure rising from a barren, shattered desert environment while pulling metallic dust and rust-colored fragments into a swirling vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.031134450808167458 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5311343669891357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.031134450808167458, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.031134450808167458, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11348435282707214, + 0.08247515559196472, + 0.15189193189144135, + 0.2909790575504303, + 0.09994601458311081, + 0.03968876600265503, + 0.020380357280373573, + 0.12115515023469925, + 0.04063572362065315, + 0.03936350345611572 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.031134450808167458 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive structure composed of interlocking geometric solids like cubes, tetrahedrons, and polyhedra?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the structure's surface a mosaic of matte black non-reflective coatings and polished chrome panels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there glowing cyan circuitry lines pulsing along the seams connecting the shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a steady upward tilt to follow the structure's ascent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the structure rising from a barren, shattered desert environment while pulling metallic dust and rust-colored fragments into a swirling vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761189460754395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261189460754395 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761189460754395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761189460754395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11243626475334167, + 0.06659425795078278, + 0.15340673923492432, + 0.4635051190853119, + 0.042635299265384674, + 0.05497068539261818, + 0.02366809733211994, + 0.022750869393348694, + 0.02899811789393425, + 0.03103456273674965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761189460754395 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive structure composed of interlocking geometric solids like cubes, tetrahedrons, and polyhedra?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the structure's surface a mosaic of matte black non-reflective coatings and polished chrome panels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there glowing cyan circuitry lines pulsing along the seams connecting the shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a steady upward tilt to follow the structure's ascent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the structure rising from a barren, shattered desert environment while pulling metallic dust and rust-colored fragments into a swirling vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016091007739305496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410908699035645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016091007739305496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016091007739305496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03730885311961174, + 0.12243080884218216, + 0.1038656160235405, + 0.07013256847858429, + 0.060417838394641876, + 0.08243563771247864, + 0.08502595126628876, + 0.34902140498161316, + 0.03855282440781593, + 0.05080845579504967 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016091007739305496 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive structure composed of interlocking geometric solids like cubes, tetrahedrons, and polyhedra?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the structure's surface a mosaic of matte black non-reflective coatings and polished chrome panels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there glowing cyan circuitry lines pulsing along the seams connecting the shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a steady upward tilt to follow the structure's ascent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the structure rising from a barren, shattered desert environment while pulling metallic dust and rust-colored fragments into a swirling vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12703797221183777 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.12703800201416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12703797221183777, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12703797221183777, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04001040384173393, + 0.06187630444765091, + 0.10135238617658615, + 0.3569701611995697, + 0.05891735851764679, + 0.06482584029436111, + 0.18352912366390228, + 0.06021817401051521, + 0.046818528324365616, + 0.025481706485152245 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12703797221183777 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive structure composed of interlocking geometric solids like cubes, tetrahedrons, and polyhedra?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the structure's surface a mosaic of matte black non-reflective coatings and polished chrome panels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there glowing cyan circuitry lines pulsing along the seams connecting the shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a steady upward tilt to follow the structure's ascent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the structure rising from a barren, shattered desert environment while pulling metallic dust and rust-colored fragments into a swirling vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012536060065031052 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38753604888916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012536060065031052, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012536060065031052, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04141531512141228, + 0.09645621478557587, + 0.07787391543388367, + 0.3218880593776703, + 0.0594337172806263, + 0.04585599899291992, + 0.139812171459198, + 0.09624870866537094, + 0.08928476274013519, + 0.03173111006617546 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012536060065031052 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic low-angle wide shot captures a massive, complex structure of interlocking geometric solids—cubes, tetrahedrons, and multifaceted polyhedra—as the camera steadily tilts upward, following its majestic ascent. The structure's surface is a mosaic of matte black, non-reflective coatings, and polished chrome panels, capturing the dim ambient light of a faint alien twilight. Complex, glowing cyan circuitry pulses energy along the seams connecting the shapes, their positions constantly and silently reconfiguring. As the machine begins to rise from the barren, shattered desert earth, a low, inaudible hum rises, and the ground directly beneath it begins to tremble. Fine particles of metallic dust and larger fragments of rust-colored metal are meticulously pulled from the ground and drawn into a powerful, swirling vortex, imagining immense magnetic forces. Glittering arcs of electric blue energy thread through this debris tornado, violently churning the fragments as the structure rises with deliberate, unstoppable force, creating an atmosphere of awe-inspiring and overwhelming technological power.", + "seed": 29810, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_0/index_9710_seed_29810_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06974918935447931, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06974918935447931, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06974918935447931, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive structure composed of interlocking geometric solids like cubes, tetrahedrons, and polyhedra?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the structure's surface a mosaic of matte black non-reflective coatings and polished chrome panels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there glowing cyan circuitry lines pulsing along the seams connecting the shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a steady upward tilt to follow the structure's ascent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the structure rising from a barren, shattered desert environment while pulling metallic dust and rust-colored fragments into a swirling vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00666620722040534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.13166618347168 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00666620722040534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00666620722040534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.41798314452171326, + 0.06560944765806198, + 0.09504780918359756, + 0.021300051361322403, + 0.06323593854904175, + 0.04136941581964493, + 0.044475339353084564, + 0.07717161625623703, + 0.09740938991308212, + 0.07639796286821365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00666620722040534 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive structure composed of interlocking geometric solids like cubes, tetrahedrons, and polyhedra?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the structure's surface a mosaic of matte black non-reflective coatings and polished chrome panels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there glowing cyan circuitry lines pulsing along the seams connecting the shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a steady upward tilt to follow the structure's ascent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the structure rising from a barren, shattered desert environment while pulling metallic dust and rust-colored fragments into a swirling vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134057819843292 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134057521820068 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134057819843292, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134057819843292, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16721296310424805, + 0.16361728310585022, + 0.21674500405788422, + 0.05576690658926964, + 0.04027075320482254, + 0.0697995275259018, + 0.05748620629310608, + 0.0873999297618866, + 0.0685383528470993, + 0.07316312193870544 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134057819843292 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive structure composed of interlocking geometric solids like cubes, tetrahedrons, and polyhedra?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the structure's surface a mosaic of matte black non-reflective coatings and polished chrome panels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there glowing cyan circuitry lines pulsing along the seams connecting the shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a steady upward tilt to follow the structure's ascent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the structure rising from a barren, shattered desert environment while pulling metallic dust and rust-colored fragments into a swirling vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005254506133496761 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.25525426864624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005254506133496761, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005254506133496761, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19281145930290222, + 0.1209140345454216, + 0.051972951740026474, + 0.03873803839087486, + 0.05677236244082451, + 0.1351158320903778, + 0.04892082139849663, + 0.14163662493228912, + 0.12739752233028412, + 0.08572032302618027 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005254506133496761 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive structure composed of interlocking geometric solids like cubes, tetrahedrons, and polyhedra?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the structure's surface a mosaic of matte black non-reflective coatings and polished chrome panels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there glowing cyan circuitry lines pulsing along the seams connecting the shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a steady upward tilt to follow the structure's ascent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the structure rising from a barren, shattered desert environment while pulling metallic dust and rust-colored fragments into a swirling vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018174076452851295 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018174171447754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018174076452851295, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018174076452851295, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2465074360370636, + 0.06278719007968903, + 0.12343055009841919, + 0.043124791234731674, + 0.03029547445476055, + 0.043741483241319656, + 0.07266601175069809, + 0.061464838683605194, + 0.1801501363515854, + 0.1358320713043213 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018174076452851295 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a massive structure composed of interlocking geometric solids like cubes, tetrahedrons, and polyhedra?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the structure's surface a mosaic of matte black non-reflective coatings and polished chrome panels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are there glowing cyan circuitry lines pulsing along the seams connecting the shapes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a steady upward tilt to follow the structure's ascent?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the structure rising from a barren, shattered desert environment while pulling metallic dust and rust-colored fragments into a swirling vortex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005245374981313944 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255245208740234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005245374981313944, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005245374981313944, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14629942178726196, + 0.10932336747646332, + 0.09967239201068878, + 0.04170648753643036, + 0.03208521753549576, + 0.03224720060825348, + 0.08707834035158157, + 0.14822110533714294, + 0.12574425339698792, + 0.17762230336666107 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005245374981313944 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_1/index_tensor([2506, 2506])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_1/index_tensor([2506, 2506])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1d436c0643f0fd0f723fd964d145a136179e8887 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_1/index_tensor([2506, 2506])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "rotating camera lens captures a medium-wide field of dreamlike, non-Euclidean space, evoking the Symbolist art of Odilon Redon, where a hazy void of velvety charcoal and deep indigo serves as the backdrop. At the center, two androgynous figures twirl in a hypnotic, synchronized dance. Their expressive faces are painted with intricate, mask-like designs—one with swirls of cobalt and gold, the other with patterns of crimson and shadow—giving them a mysterious, otherworldly appearance. They wear voluminous, intricate robes of shimmering amethyst and sapphire silk, embroidered with subtle golden celestial motifs. As they twirl with endless grace, their incredibly long, flowing sleeves billow and trail behind them like vibrant, ethereal clouds in the void. The only light comes from abstract, fluorescent bursts of color that drift in the background, casting a soft, otherworldly glow on the dancers and causing the silk to shimmer. The camera's continuous, smooth rotation perfectly mirrors the dancers' pirouettes, amplifying the dizzying yet captivating movements and immersing the audience in a visually rich, surreal, and mysterious trance.", + "seed": 6120, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_1/index_2506_seed_6120_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08065035194158554, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08065035194158554, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08065035194158554, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two androgynous figures visible in the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the figures wear voluminous robes of shimmering amethyst and sapphire silk with golden celestial motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the figures have faces painted with intricate, mask-like designs featuring swirls of cobalt and gold on one and crimson and shadow on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the figures twirl in a synchronized dance with incredibly long, flowing sleeves that billow like ethereal clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, smooth rotation that mirrors the dancers' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2532535791397095 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5032535791397095 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2532535791397095, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2532535791397095, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05092323198914528, + 0.033608391880989075, + 0.07677548378705978, + 0.08959430456161499, + 0.02599138766527176, + 0.02578677609562874, + 0.10616493970155716, + 0.2587777376174927, + 0.052873361855745316, + 0.27950435876846313 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2532535791397095 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two androgynous figures visible in the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the figures wear voluminous robes of shimmering amethyst and sapphire silk with golden celestial motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the figures have faces painted with intricate, mask-like designs featuring swirls of cobalt and gold on one and crimson and shadow on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the figures twirl in a synchronized dance with incredibly long, flowing sleeves that billow like ethereal clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, smooth rotation that mirrors the dancers' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371758013963699 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408717632293701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371758013963699, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371758013963699, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06310515850782394, + 0.06441967934370041, + 0.05486305430531502, + 0.08796554058790207, + 0.021009374409914017, + 0.02738417498767376, + 0.18068481981754303, + 0.31654638051986694, + 0.11205035448074341, + 0.07197147607803345 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371758013963699 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two androgynous figures visible in the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the figures wear voluminous robes of shimmering amethyst and sapphire silk with golden celestial motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the figures have faces painted with intricate, mask-like designs featuring swirls of cobalt and gold on one and crimson and shadow on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the figures twirl in a synchronized dance with incredibly long, flowing sleeves that billow like ethereal clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, smooth rotation that mirrors the dancers' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0700579360127449 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950578689575195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0700579360127449, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0700579360127449, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09313967823982239, + 0.09858627617359161, + 0.053625255823135376, + 0.13345451653003693, + 0.03238664194941521, + 0.050149086862802505, + 0.1339418590068817, + 0.23287461698055267, + 0.0559440441429615, + 0.1158980056643486 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0700579360127449 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two androgynous figures visible in the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the figures wear voluminous robes of shimmering amethyst and sapphire silk with golden celestial motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the figures have faces painted with intricate, mask-like designs featuring swirls of cobalt and gold on one and crimson and shadow on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the figures twirl in a synchronized dance with incredibly long, flowing sleeves that billow like ethereal clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, smooth rotation that mirrors the dancers' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012537471950054169 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387537479400635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012537471950054169, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012537471950054169, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0703892931342125, + 0.07844478636980057, + 0.08083178848028183, + 0.08844239264726639, + 0.07559879124164581, + 0.04132300615310669, + 0.04190331697463989, + 0.19406758248806, + 0.11226388067007065, + 0.2167351096868515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012537471950054169 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two androgynous figures visible in the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the figures wear voluminous robes of shimmering amethyst and sapphire silk with golden celestial motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the figures have faces painted with intricate, mask-like designs featuring swirls of cobalt and gold on one and crimson and shadow on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the figures twirl in a synchronized dance with incredibly long, flowing sleeves that billow like ethereal clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, smooth rotation that mirrors the dancers' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033685192465782166 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086852073669434 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033685192465782166, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033685192465782166, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10046693682670593, + 0.0605553463101387, + 0.0670817494392395, + 0.1264590173959732, + 0.052104245871305466, + 0.16980993747711182, + 0.07953459024429321, + 0.18641328811645508, + 0.07937585562467575, + 0.07819902896881104 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033685192465782166 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "rotating camera lens captures a medium-wide field of dreamlike, non-Euclidean space, evoking the Symbolist art of Odilon Redon, where a hazy void of velvety charcoal and deep indigo serves as the backdrop. At the center, two androgynous figures twirl in a hypnotic, synchronized dance. Their expressive faces are painted with intricate, mask-like designs—one with swirls of cobalt and gold, the other with patterns of crimson and shadow—giving them a mysterious, otherworldly appearance. They wear voluminous, intricate robes of shimmering amethyst and sapphire silk, embroidered with subtle golden celestial motifs. As they twirl with endless grace, their incredibly long, flowing sleeves billow and trail behind them like vibrant, ethereal clouds in the void. The only light comes from abstract, fluorescent bursts of color that drift in the background, casting a soft, otherworldly glow on the dancers and causing the silk to shimmer. The camera's continuous, smooth rotation perfectly mirrors the dancers' pirouettes, amplifying the dizzying yet captivating movements and immersing the audience in a visually rich, surreal, and mysterious trance.", + "seed": 6121, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_1/index_2506_seed_6121_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.020557339396327735, + "vlm_logprob": -0.020557339396327735, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.099999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.020557339396327735, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two androgynous figures visible in the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the figures wear voluminous robes of shimmering amethyst and sapphire silk with golden celestial motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the figures have faces painted with intricate, mask-like designs featuring swirls of cobalt and gold on one and crimson and shadow on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the figures twirl in a synchronized dance with incredibly long, flowing sleeves that billow like ethereal clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, smooth rotation that mirrors the dancers' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.034040823578834534 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.409040927886963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.034040823578834534, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.034040823578834534, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29851749539375305, + 0.08416984975337982, + 0.03399278223514557, + 0.08527404814958572, + 0.11324329674243927, + 0.07478722929954529, + 0.03907647356390953, + 0.07409048825502396, + 0.03254320099949837, + 0.164305180311203 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.034040823578834534 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two androgynous figures visible in the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the figures wear voluminous robes of shimmering amethyst and sapphire silk with golden celestial motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the figures have faces painted with intricate, mask-like designs featuring swirls of cobalt and gold on one and crimson and shadow on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the figures twirl in a synchronized dance with incredibly long, flowing sleeves that billow like ethereal clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, smooth rotation that mirrors the dancers' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01820100098848343 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018200874328613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01820100098848343, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01820100098848343, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.47543346881866455, + 0.09896639734506607, + 0.04635696858167648, + 0.08033660799264908, + 0.05124615877866745, + 0.03438326716423035, + 0.03518624231219292, + 0.06932418793439865, + 0.029158122837543488, + 0.07960855960845947 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01820100098848343 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two androgynous figures visible in the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the figures wear voluminous robes of shimmering amethyst and sapphire silk with golden celestial motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the figures have faces painted with intricate, mask-like designs featuring swirls of cobalt and gold on one and crimson and shadow on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the figures twirl in a synchronized dance with incredibly long, flowing sleeves that billow like ethereal clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, smooth rotation that mirrors the dancers' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020598189905285835 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955981731414795 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020598189905285835, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020598189905285835, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.39835023880004883, + 0.08347896486520767, + 0.06776267290115356, + 0.10731580853462219, + 0.05198366940021515, + 0.040188711136579514, + 0.03671426326036453, + 0.08998697996139526, + 0.025552591308951378, + 0.09866609424352646 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020598189905285835 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two androgynous figures visible in the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the figures wear voluminous robes of shimmering amethyst and sapphire silk with golden celestial motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the figures have faces painted with intricate, mask-like designs featuring swirls of cobalt and gold on one and crimson and shadow on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the figures twirl in a synchronized dance with incredibly long, flowing sleeves that billow like ethereal clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, smooth rotation that mirrors the dancers' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036134920082986355 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628613471984863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036134920082986355, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036134920082986355, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1386396586894989, + 0.08848230540752411, + 0.04996693134307861, + 0.07299283146858215, + 0.08080720901489258, + 0.17374369502067566, + 0.09748934954404831, + 0.07341773808002472, + 0.05785861611366272, + 0.16660167276859283 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036134920082986355 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two androgynous figures visible in the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the figures wear voluminous robes of shimmering amethyst and sapphire silk with golden celestial motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the figures have faces painted with intricate, mask-like designs featuring swirls of cobalt and gold on one and crimson and shadow on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the figures twirl in a synchronized dance with incredibly long, flowing sleeves that billow like ethereal clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, smooth rotation that mirrors the dancers' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026333190500736237 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513330936431885 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026333190500736237, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026333190500736237, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26726093888282776, + 0.14912495017051697, + 0.0772726759314537, + 0.05192776024341583, + 0.04752161726355553, + 0.09312069416046143, + 0.07316021621227264, + 0.12152041494846344, + 0.044143788516521454, + 0.07494696229696274 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026333190500736237 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "rotating camera lens captures a medium-wide field of dreamlike, non-Euclidean space, evoking the Symbolist art of Odilon Redon, where a hazy void of velvety charcoal and deep indigo serves as the backdrop. At the center, two androgynous figures twirl in a hypnotic, synchronized dance. Their expressive faces are painted with intricate, mask-like designs—one with swirls of cobalt and gold, the other with patterns of crimson and shadow—giving them a mysterious, otherworldly appearance. They wear voluminous, intricate robes of shimmering amethyst and sapphire silk, embroidered with subtle golden celestial motifs. As they twirl with endless grace, their incredibly long, flowing sleeves billow and trail behind them like vibrant, ethereal clouds in the void. The only light comes from abstract, fluorescent bursts of color that drift in the background, casting a soft, otherworldly glow on the dancers and causing the silk to shimmer. The camera's continuous, smooth rotation perfectly mirrors the dancers' pirouettes, amplifying the dizzying yet captivating movements and immersing the audience in a visually rich, surreal, and mysterious trance.", + "seed": 6122, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_1/index_2506_seed_6122_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.0289410125464201, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0289410125464201, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0289410125464201, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two androgynous figures visible in the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the figures wear voluminous robes of shimmering amethyst and sapphire silk with golden celestial motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the figures have faces painted with intricate, mask-like designs featuring swirls of cobalt and gold on one and crimson and shadow on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the figures twirl in a synchronized dance with incredibly long, flowing sleeves that billow like ethereal clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, smooth rotation that mirrors the dancers' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08932699263095856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464327096939087 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08932699263095856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08932699263095856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13169428706169128, + 0.12757499516010284, + 0.07546444982290268, + 0.08480951189994812, + 0.09561993926763535, + 0.04487213119864464, + 0.06247323006391525, + 0.18882295489311218, + 0.025072695687413216, + 0.16359588503837585 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08932699263095856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two androgynous figures visible in the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the figures wear voluminous robes of shimmering amethyst and sapphire silk with golden celestial motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the figures have faces painted with intricate, mask-like designs featuring swirls of cobalt and gold on one and crimson and shadow on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the figures twirl in a synchronized dance with incredibly long, flowing sleeves that billow like ethereal clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, smooth rotation that mirrors the dancers' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009786956012248993 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634787082672119 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009786956012248993, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009786956012248993, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1339499056339264, + 0.06843063235282898, + 0.07292990386486053, + 0.16634415090084076, + 0.04720161482691765, + 0.059765808284282684, + 0.01950005814433098, + 0.11460450291633606, + 0.2616289556026459, + 0.05564451962709427 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009786956012248993 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two androgynous figures visible in the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the figures wear voluminous robes of shimmering amethyst and sapphire silk with golden celestial motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the figures have faces painted with intricate, mask-like designs featuring swirls of cobalt and gold on one and crimson and shadow on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the figures twirl in a synchronized dance with incredibly long, flowing sleeves that billow like ethereal clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, smooth rotation that mirrors the dancers' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016075288876891136 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141075134277344 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016075288876891136, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016075288876891136, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1685539335012436, + 0.06633365899324417, + 0.047591228038072586, + 0.21937976777553558, + 0.05062834545969963, + 0.1206776350736618, + 0.04924643784761429, + 0.13059835135936737, + 0.10214095562696457, + 0.044849734753370285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016075288876891136 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two androgynous figures visible in the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the figures wear voluminous robes of shimmering amethyst and sapphire silk with golden celestial motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the figures have faces painted with intricate, mask-like designs featuring swirls of cobalt and gold on one and crimson and shadow on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the figures twirl in a synchronized dance with incredibly long, flowing sleeves that billow like ethereal clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, smooth rotation that mirrors the dancers' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00318971648812294 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753189563751221 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00318971648812294, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00318971648812294, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18775531649589539, + 0.09806223958730698, + 0.09753483533859253, + 0.11872875690460205, + 0.07735702395439148, + 0.062422625720500946, + 0.0336715392768383, + 0.1904609650373459, + 0.05906309559941292, + 0.07494357973337173 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00318971648812294 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two androgynous figures visible in the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the figures wear voluminous robes of shimmering amethyst and sapphire silk with golden celestial motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the figures have faces painted with intricate, mask-like designs featuring swirls of cobalt and gold on one and crimson and shadow on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the figures twirl in a synchronized dance with incredibly long, flowing sleeves that billow like ethereal clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, smooth rotation that mirrors the dancers' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02632610872387886 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513261795043945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02632610872387886, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02632610872387886, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08142250031232834, + 0.1311461180448532, + 0.0864720493555069, + 0.12022522836923599, + 0.025775937363505363, + 0.07316090911626816, + 0.03887265920639038, + 0.15265445411205292, + 0.20930545032024384, + 0.08096460998058319 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02632610872387886 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "rotating camera lens captures a medium-wide field of dreamlike, non-Euclidean space, evoking the Symbolist art of Odilon Redon, where a hazy void of velvety charcoal and deep indigo serves as the backdrop. At the center, two androgynous figures twirl in a hypnotic, synchronized dance. Their expressive faces are painted with intricate, mask-like designs—one with swirls of cobalt and gold, the other with patterns of crimson and shadow—giving them a mysterious, otherworldly appearance. They wear voluminous, intricate robes of shimmering amethyst and sapphire silk, embroidered with subtle golden celestial motifs. As they twirl with endless grace, their incredibly long, flowing sleeves billow and trail behind them like vibrant, ethereal clouds in the void. The only light comes from abstract, fluorescent bursts of color that drift in the background, casting a soft, otherworldly glow on the dancers and causing the silk to shimmer. The camera's continuous, smooth rotation perfectly mirrors the dancers' pirouettes, amplifying the dizzying yet captivating movements and immersing the audience in a visually rich, surreal, and mysterious trance.", + "seed": 6123, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_1/index_2506_seed_6123_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.02032003104686737, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02032003104686737, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.224999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02032003104686737, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two androgynous figures visible in the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the figures wear voluminous robes of shimmering amethyst and sapphire silk with golden celestial motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the figures have faces painted with intricate, mask-like designs featuring swirls of cobalt and gold on one and crimson and shadow on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the figures twirl in a synchronized dance with incredibly long, flowing sleeves that billow like ethereal clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, smooth rotation that mirrors the dancers' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04344641789793968 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1684463024139404 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04344641789793968, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04344641789793968, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24294190108776093, + 0.23629076778888702, + 0.1138109564781189, + 0.06464513391256332, + 0.07783912122249603, + 0.040348462760448456, + 0.017254022881388664, + 0.10912320017814636, + 0.0604817196726799, + 0.037264686077833176 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04344641789793968 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two androgynous figures visible in the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the figures wear voluminous robes of shimmering amethyst and sapphire silk with golden celestial motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the figures have faces painted with intricate, mask-like designs featuring swirls of cobalt and gold on one and crimson and shadow on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the figures twirl in a synchronized dance with incredibly long, flowing sleeves that billow like ethereal clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, smooth rotation that mirrors the dancers' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014201059006154537 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2642011642456055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014201059006154537, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014201059006154537, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11443740129470825, + 0.1252867877483368, + 0.13915391266345978, + 0.18992474675178528, + 0.07287956774234772, + 0.06490979343652725, + 0.03570069000124931, + 0.11912156641483307, + 0.09406639635562897, + 0.044519197195768356 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014201059006154537 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two androgynous figures visible in the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the figures wear voluminous robes of shimmering amethyst and sapphire silk with golden celestial motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the figures have faces painted with intricate, mask-like designs featuring swirls of cobalt and gold on one and crimson and shadow on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the figures twirl in a synchronized dance with incredibly long, flowing sleeves that billow like ethereal clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, smooth rotation that mirrors the dancers' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329506166279316 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732951641082764 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329506166279316, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329506166279316, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2423715889453888, + 0.11966358125209808, + 0.08525122702121735, + 0.10566578060388565, + 0.04783783480525017, + 0.15766233205795288, + 0.07437270879745483, + 0.0688595175743103, + 0.058604005724191666, + 0.03971139341592789 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329506166279316 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two androgynous figures visible in the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the figures wear voluminous robes of shimmering amethyst and sapphire silk with golden celestial motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the figures have faces painted with intricate, mask-like designs featuring swirls of cobalt and gold on one and crimson and shadow on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the figures twirl in a synchronized dance with incredibly long, flowing sleeves that billow like ethereal clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, smooth rotation that mirrors the dancers' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024861162528395653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002486228942871 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024861162528395653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024861162528395653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09521178156137466, + 0.06865530461072922, + 0.32976552844047546, + 0.04362589493393898, + 0.051258791238069534, + 0.05945084989070892, + 0.03706193342804909, + 0.19296051561832428, + 0.07664404064416885, + 0.04536532983183861 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024861162528395653 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are two androgynous figures visible in the center of the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do the figures wear voluminous robes of shimmering amethyst and sapphire silk with golden celestial motifs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Do the figures have faces painted with intricate, mask-like designs featuring swirls of cobalt and gold on one and crimson and shadow on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the figures twirl in a synchronized dance with incredibly long, flowing sleeves that billow like ethereal clouds?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a continuous, smooth rotation that mirrors the dancers' movements?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01817150041460991 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018171310424805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01817150041460991, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01817150041460991, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14258123934268951, + 0.13940054178237915, + 0.20526055991649628, + 0.17850683629512787, + 0.12915736436843872, + 0.04929620027542114, + 0.033165715634822845, + 0.043051786720752716, + 0.05267075076699257, + 0.02690899185836315 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01817150041460991 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_10/index_tensor([2155, 2155])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_10/index_tensor([2155, 2155])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..afe95321a98dbd02396fe6defbb9cf0718704e81 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_10/index_tensor([2155, 2155])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "Using high-speed sports documentary-style close-ups, head-tracking technology locks the camera on the focused face of a white-haired warrior, his chiseled features furrowed with brows, his piercing blue eyes burning with intense concentration. His flowing silver-white hair traces sharp arcs through the air, while his heavy, crimson trench coat whips wildly with his body's violent movements. As he unleashes a dazzling flurry of multi-axial attacks, his steady, resolute facial expression remains remarkably clear, while the rest of his body—his flailing arms, spinning torso, and kicking legs—and the surrounding environment, along with it, becomes a whirlpool of motion blur, a swirl of light and color. His body seamlessly switches between spinning, tilting and charging at a speed that is difficult to capture with the naked eye. The crimson hem of his clothes and his arms turn into countless afterimages, creating a strong visual impact against the blurred background. The entire picture, with its extreme contrast between movement and stillness, creates a breathtaking sense of speed, power and a highly concentrated combat atmosphere.", + "seed": 10325, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_10/index_2155_seed_10325_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03374497905606404, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03374497905606404, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03374497905606404, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a warrior with white hair and piercing blue eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing a heavy crimson trench coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to keep the warrior's face in focus while the rest of the scene blurs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background and the warrior's limbs rendered as a motion blur swirl of light and color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the warrior performing rapid multi-axial attacks including spinning, tilting, and charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11856633424758911 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2435662746429443 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11856633424758911, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11856633424758911, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23580288887023926, + 0.0635879635810852, + 0.136935293674469, + 0.18278081715106964, + 0.09784882515668869, + 0.02114695869386196, + 0.0736648291349411, + 0.044742122292518616, + 0.024445025250315666, + 0.11904522031545639 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11856633424758911 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a warrior with white hair and piercing blue eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing a heavy crimson trench coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to keep the warrior's face in focus while the rest of the scene blurs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background and the warrior's limbs rendered as a motion blur swirl of light and color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the warrior performing rapid multi-axial attacks including spinning, tilting, and charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009798642247915268 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634798526763916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009798642247915268, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009798642247915268, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2275070995092392, + 0.04004203900694847, + 0.041656527668237686, + 0.16017894446849823, + 0.08421271294355392, + 0.047610990703105927, + 0.050971824675798416, + 0.0542258694767952, + 0.062475405633449554, + 0.2311186045408249 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009798642247915268 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a warrior with white hair and piercing blue eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing a heavy crimson trench coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to keep the warrior's face in focus while the rest of the scene blurs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background and the warrior's limbs rendered as a motion blur swirl of light and color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the warrior performing rapid multi-axial attacks including spinning, tilting, and charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00595379201695323 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130953788757324 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00595379201695323, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00595379201695323, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22655253112316132, + 0.08418561518192291, + 0.1172548308968544, + 0.08690348267555237, + 0.06639915704727173, + 0.08682601898908615, + 0.16397717595100403, + 0.040926285088062286, + 0.06733281910419464, + 0.05964208021759987 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00595379201695323 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a warrior with white hair and piercing blue eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing a heavy crimson trench coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to keep the warrior's face in focus while the rest of the scene blurs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background and the warrior's limbs rendered as a motion blur swirl of light and color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the warrior performing rapid multi-axial attacks including spinning, tilting, and charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0007203606073744595 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.250720500946045 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0007203606073744595, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0007203606073744595, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2311263084411621, + 0.07478105276823044, + 0.08060631155967712, + 0.10182682424783707, + 0.044157423079013824, + 0.047891221940517426, + 0.2139078974723816, + 0.04290089011192322, + 0.03498505800962448, + 0.12781699001789093 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0007203606073744595 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a warrior with white hair and piercing blue eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing a heavy crimson trench coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to keep the warrior's face in focus while the rest of the scene blurs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background and the warrior's limbs rendered as a motion blur swirl of light and color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the warrior performing rapid multi-axial attacks including spinning, tilting, and charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368576616048813 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086856842041016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368576616048813, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368576616048813, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20639874041080475, + 0.07865037769079208, + 0.08881254494190216, + 0.11415970325469971, + 0.04073665663599968, + 0.07031308859586716, + 0.1559997946023941, + 0.08688334375619888, + 0.07307091355323792, + 0.08497487753629684 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368576616048813 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Using high-speed sports documentary-style close-ups, head-tracking technology locks the camera on the focused face of a white-haired warrior, his chiseled features furrowed with brows, his piercing blue eyes burning with intense concentration. His flowing silver-white hair traces sharp arcs through the air, while his heavy, crimson trench coat whips wildly with his body's violent movements. As he unleashes a dazzling flurry of multi-axial attacks, his steady, resolute facial expression remains remarkably clear, while the rest of his body—his flailing arms, spinning torso, and kicking legs—and the surrounding environment, along with it, becomes a whirlpool of motion blur, a swirl of light and color. His body seamlessly switches between spinning, tilting and charging at a speed that is difficult to capture with the naked eye. The crimson hem of his clothes and his arms turn into countless afterimages, creating a strong visual impact against the blurred background. The entire picture, with its extreme contrast between movement and stillness, creates a breathtaking sense of speed, power and a highly concentrated combat atmosphere.", + "seed": 10326, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_10/index_2155_seed_10326_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.028269265545532107, + "vlm_logprob": -0.028269265545532107, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.028269265545532107, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a warrior with white hair and piercing blue eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing a heavy crimson trench coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to keep the warrior's face in focus while the rest of the scene blurs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background and the warrior's limbs rendered as a motion blur swirl of light and color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the warrior performing rapid multi-axial attacks including spinning, tilting, and charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07401924580335617 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.699019193649292 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07401924580335617, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07401924580335617, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18954484164714813, + 0.10182270407676697, + 0.03367279842495918, + 0.0355689562857151, + 0.26264888048171997, + 0.05275765806436539, + 0.009892942383885384, + 0.1398831605911255, + 0.13194803893566132, + 0.04226009547710419 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07401924580335617 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a warrior with white hair and piercing blue eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing a heavy crimson trench coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to keep the warrior's face in focus while the rest of the scene blurs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background and the warrior's limbs rendered as a motion blur swirl of light and color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the warrior performing rapid multi-axial attacks including spinning, tilting, and charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043076761066913605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168076753616333 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043076761066913605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043076761066913605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03792491927742958, + 0.06966809183359146, + 0.019707096740603447, + 0.013640237040817738, + 0.1110096424818039, + 0.04938771203160286, + 0.013797972351312637, + 0.6122061014175415, + 0.04429120942950249, + 0.028366968035697937 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043076761066913605 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a warrior with white hair and piercing blue eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing a heavy crimson trench coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to keep the warrior's face in focus while the rest of the scene blurs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background and the warrior's limbs rendered as a motion blur swirl of light and color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the warrior performing rapid multi-axial attacks including spinning, tilting, and charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007632025051862001 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882632255554199 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007632025051862001, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007632025051862001, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.041093360632658005, + 0.08662721514701843, + 0.061750758439302444, + 0.028020348399877548, + 0.037794191390275955, + 0.05387796834111214, + 0.026467695832252502, + 0.5952592492103577, + 0.036535028368234634, + 0.032574158161878586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007632025051862001 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a warrior with white hair and piercing blue eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing a heavy crimson trench coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to keep the warrior's face in focus while the rest of the scene blurs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background and the warrior's limbs rendered as a motion blur swirl of light and color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the warrior performing rapid multi-axial attacks including spinning, tilting, and charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0005606033373624086 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.500560760498047 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0005606033373624086, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0005606033373624086, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09550421684980392, + 0.22679533064365387, + 0.06413238495588303, + 0.027218062430620193, + 0.07144012302160263, + 0.03545260801911354, + 0.06412290036678314, + 0.23288428783416748, + 0.09835749864578247, + 0.08409253507852554 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0005606033373624086 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a warrior with white hair and piercing blue eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing a heavy crimson trench coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to keep the warrior's face in focus while the rest of the scene blurs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background and the warrior's limbs rendered as a motion blur swirl of light and color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the warrior performing rapid multi-axial attacks including spinning, tilting, and charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01605769246816635 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14105749130249 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01605769246816635, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01605769246816635, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08824581652879715, + 0.12344461679458618, + 0.10488290339708328, + 0.030580909922719002, + 0.05670645087957382, + 0.042103227227926254, + 0.10102630406618118, + 0.266631156206131, + 0.09455589205026627, + 0.09182275831699371 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01605769246816635 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Using high-speed sports documentary-style close-ups, head-tracking technology locks the camera on the focused face of a white-haired warrior, his chiseled features furrowed with brows, his piercing blue eyes burning with intense concentration. His flowing silver-white hair traces sharp arcs through the air, while his heavy, crimson trench coat whips wildly with his body's violent movements. As he unleashes a dazzling flurry of multi-axial attacks, his steady, resolute facial expression remains remarkably clear, while the rest of his body—his flailing arms, spinning torso, and kicking legs—and the surrounding environment, along with it, becomes a whirlpool of motion blur, a swirl of light and color. His body seamlessly switches between spinning, tilting and charging at a speed that is difficult to capture with the naked eye. The crimson hem of his clothes and his arms turn into countless afterimages, creating a strong visual impact against the blurred background. The entire picture, with its extreme contrast between movement and stillness, creates a breathtaking sense of speed, power and a highly concentrated combat atmosphere.", + "seed": 10327, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_10/index_2155_seed_10327_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.044025022187270224, + "vlm_logprob": -0.044025022187270224, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.225000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.044025022187270224, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a warrior with white hair and piercing blue eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing a heavy crimson trench coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to keep the warrior's face in focus while the rest of the scene blurs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background and the warrior's limbs rendered as a motion blur swirl of light and color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the warrior performing rapid multi-axial attacks including spinning, tilting, and charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.055757585912942886 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.930757522583008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.055757585912942886, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.055757585912942886, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11136005818843842, + 0.18187329173088074, + 0.044625502079725266, + 0.2675013244152069, + 0.05708006024360657, + 0.04482889920473099, + 0.025442661717534065, + 0.034671906381845474, + 0.1984652727842331, + 0.034150995314121246 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.055757585912942886 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a warrior with white hair and piercing blue eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing a heavy crimson trench coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to keep the warrior's face in focus while the rest of the scene blurs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background and the warrior's limbs rendered as a motion blur swirl of light and color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the warrior performing rapid multi-axial attacks including spinning, tilting, and charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14280354976654053 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.01780366897583 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14280354976654053, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14280354976654053, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04444226250052452, + 0.13722458481788635, + 0.03922447934746742, + 0.057276833802461624, + 0.12699441611766815, + 0.015690885484218597, + 0.023738306015729904, + 0.04118950664997101, + 0.24857796728610992, + 0.26564064621925354 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14280354976654053 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a warrior with white hair and piercing blue eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing a heavy crimson trench coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to keep the warrior's face in focus while the rest of the scene blurs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background and the warrior's limbs rendered as a motion blur swirl of light and color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the warrior performing rapid multi-axial attacks including spinning, tilting, and charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009781407192349434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634781360626221 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009781407192349434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009781407192349434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17375916242599487, + 0.06347998976707458, + 0.08029455691576004, + 0.10578840970993042, + 0.06815027445554733, + 0.21695882081985474, + 0.06650196760892868, + 0.09889166802167892, + 0.09050127863883972, + 0.03567388653755188 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009781407192349434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a warrior with white hair and piercing blue eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing a heavy crimson trench coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to keep the warrior's face in focus while the rest of the scene blurs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background and the warrior's limbs rendered as a motion blur swirl of light and color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the warrior performing rapid multi-axial attacks including spinning, tilting, and charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0007167869480326772 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.250716686248779 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0007167869480326772, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0007167869480326772, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10645578801631927, + 0.07508756220340729, + 0.06521320343017578, + 0.09616792947053909, + 0.18262876570224762, + 0.06160083785653114, + 0.04141370952129364, + 0.11586781591176987, + 0.14620432257652283, + 0.10936006903648376 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0007167869480326772 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a warrior with white hair and piercing blue eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing a heavy crimson trench coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to keep the warrior's face in focus while the rest of the scene blurs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background and the warrior's limbs rendered as a motion blur swirl of light and color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the warrior performing rapid multi-axial attacks including spinning, tilting, and charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011065781116485596 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51106595993042 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011065781116485596, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011065781116485596, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09070905297994614, + 0.057197846472263336, + 0.07105027884244919, + 0.08840115368366241, + 0.24091340601444244, + 0.12523114681243896, + 0.053059857338666916, + 0.05917015299201012, + 0.16867052018642426, + 0.04559654742479324 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011065781116485596 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "Using high-speed sports documentary-style close-ups, head-tracking technology locks the camera on the focused face of a white-haired warrior, his chiseled features furrowed with brows, his piercing blue eyes burning with intense concentration. His flowing silver-white hair traces sharp arcs through the air, while his heavy, crimson trench coat whips wildly with his body's violent movements. As he unleashes a dazzling flurry of multi-axial attacks, his steady, resolute facial expression remains remarkably clear, while the rest of his body—his flailing arms, spinning torso, and kicking legs—and the surrounding environment, along with it, becomes a whirlpool of motion blur, a swirl of light and color. His body seamlessly switches between spinning, tilting and charging at a speed that is difficult to capture with the naked eye. The crimson hem of his clothes and his arms turn into countless afterimages, creating a strong visual impact against the blurred background. The entire picture, with its extreme contrast between movement and stillness, creates a breathtaking sense of speed, power and a highly concentrated combat atmosphere.", + "seed": 10328, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_10/index_2155_seed_10328_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.05141836442053318, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05141836442053318, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05141836442053318, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a warrior with white hair and piercing blue eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing a heavy crimson trench coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to keep the warrior's face in focus while the rest of the scene blurs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background and the warrior's limbs rendered as a motion blur swirl of light and color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the warrior performing rapid multi-axial attacks including spinning, tilting, and charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2268843948841095 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.601884365081787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2268843948841095, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2268843948841095, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1792605221271515, + 0.1545555591583252, + 0.07410694658756256, + 0.07685500383377075, + 0.032489631325006485, + 0.02464091219007969, + 0.13728883862495422, + 0.18344855308532715, + 0.06231975555419922, + 0.07503430545330048 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2268843948841095 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a warrior with white hair and piercing blue eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing a heavy crimson trench coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to keep the warrior's face in focus while the rest of the scene blurs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background and the warrior's limbs rendered as a motion blur swirl of light and color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the warrior performing rapid multi-axial attacks including spinning, tilting, and charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01108134351670742 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511081218719482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01108134351670742, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01108134351670742, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05550432950258255, + 0.26718470454216003, + 0.05474625900387764, + 0.09258855879306793, + 0.03145899623632431, + 0.025314901024103165, + 0.12954571843147278, + 0.07036007940769196, + 0.0647650733590126, + 0.20853136479854584 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01108134351670742 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a warrior with white hair and piercing blue eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing a heavy crimson trench coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to keep the warrior's face in focus while the rest of the scene blurs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background and the warrior's limbs rendered as a motion blur swirl of light and color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the warrior performing rapid multi-axial attacks including spinning, tilting, and charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008637567982077599 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758637428283691 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008637567982077599, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008637567982077599, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11066174507141113, + 0.07949339598417282, + 0.0866817831993103, + 0.11691682785749435, + 0.07053842395544052, + 0.07179641723632812, + 0.0926227793097496, + 0.10997439920902252, + 0.18951919674873352, + 0.07179509103298187 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008637567982077599 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a warrior with white hair and piercing blue eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing a heavy crimson trench coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to keep the warrior's face in focus while the rest of the scene blurs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background and the warrior's limbs rendered as a motion blur swirl of light and color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the warrior performing rapid multi-axial attacks including spinning, tilting, and charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0007169060409069061 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.250716686248779 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0007169060409069061, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0007169060409069061, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13631142675876617, + 0.10501489043235779, + 0.12824736535549164, + 0.07450404763221741, + 0.08111788332462311, + 0.05077258124947548, + 0.07722026109695435, + 0.173344224691391, + 0.07305773347616196, + 0.10040950775146484 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0007169060409069061 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a warrior with white hair and piercing blue eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing a heavy crimson trench coat?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera use head-tracking to keep the warrior's face in focus while the rest of the scene blurs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background and the warrior's limbs rendered as a motion blur swirl of light and color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the warrior performing rapid multi-axial attacks including spinning, tilting, and charging?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009771609678864479 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634771823883057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009771609678864479, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009771609678864479, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10056260228157043, + 0.14509740471839905, + 0.07907391339540482, + 0.07062572240829468, + 0.08114778995513916, + 0.04967580363154411, + 0.06161724030971527, + 0.1899002343416214, + 0.06552403420209885, + 0.15677529573440552 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009771609678864479 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_11/index_tensor([9198, 9198])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_11/index_tensor([9198, 9198])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..813377d2117202c294e6849b6e55362df51c440f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_11/index_tensor([9198, 9198])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a horizontal angle focuses on an old-fashioned globe mounted on an intricately carved dark walnut stand. A warm, focused light softly shines from the side of the frame, precisely illuminating the sphere's curved surface and creating a brilliant highlight on its brass arc of longitude. The globe's surface has the yellowed hue of parchment, and the continental plates depicted therein are soft ochres and faded greens, imbued with a vintage texture. The globe rotates slowly with a steady and leisurely rhythm, allowing light and shadow to flow smoothly across the ancient map, passing over the blurred markings of national borders and ocean currents. In the background, out-of-focus bookshelves reveal the faint outlines of heavy books, and the entire scene is shrouded in a tranquil, nostalgic, and scholarly atmosphere.", + "seed": 17840, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_11/index_9198_seed_17840_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07923891805112362, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07923891805112362, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07923891805112362, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old-fashioned globe mounted on a dark walnut stand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the globe's surface yellowed like parchment with soft ochre and faded green continental plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, focused light shining from the side that creates a brilliant highlight on the brass arc of longitude?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly with a steady rhythm while the background bookshelves remain out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a close-up from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011731443926692009 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8867316246032715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011731443926692009, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011731443926692009, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35290050506591797, + 0.06809817254543304, + 0.02659752033650875, + 0.0239725261926651, + 0.04337592050433159, + 0.039967264980077744, + 0.05050857365131378, + 0.19585934281349182, + 0.14337867498397827, + 0.055341556668281555 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011731443926692009 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old-fashioned globe mounted on a dark walnut stand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the globe's surface yellowed like parchment with soft ochre and faded green continental plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, focused light shining from the side that creates a brilliant highlight on the brass arc of longitude?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly with a steady rhythm while the background bookshelves remain out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a close-up from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01608983427286148 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141089916229248 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01608983427286148, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01608983427286148, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11012165248394012, + 0.06956205517053604, + 0.07794685661792755, + 0.011656232178211212, + 0.04534364864230156, + 0.03684445843100548, + 0.027768155559897423, + 0.5105931162834167, + 0.08367937803268433, + 0.026484468951821327 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01608983427286148 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old-fashioned globe mounted on a dark walnut stand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the globe's surface yellowed like parchment with soft ochre and faded green continental plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, focused light shining from the side that creates a brilliant highlight on the brass arc of longitude?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly with a steady rhythm while the background bookshelves remain out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a close-up from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01108264084905386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511082649230957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01108264084905386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01108264084905386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1842578947544098, + 0.11388683319091797, + 0.028352433815598488, + 0.12095658481121063, + 0.10281399637460709, + 0.12761709094047546, + 0.08717624843120575, + 0.09486714005470276, + 0.05925881490111351, + 0.08081290870904922 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01108264084905386 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old-fashioned globe mounted on a dark walnut stand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the globe's surface yellowed like parchment with soft ochre and faded green continental plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, focused light shining from the side that creates a brilliant highlight on the brass arc of longitude?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly with a steady rhythm while the background bookshelves remain out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a close-up from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486526310443878 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236526012420654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486526310443878, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486526310443878, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1862219274044037, + 0.18030326068401337, + 0.0839754119515419, + 0.0709913969039917, + 0.03765711933374405, + 0.04461228847503662, + 0.027443626895546913, + 0.17471016943454742, + 0.05328749120235443, + 0.14079727232456207 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486526310443878 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old-fashioned globe mounted on a dark walnut stand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the globe's surface yellowed like parchment with soft ochre and faded green continental plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, focused light shining from the side that creates a brilliant highlight on the brass arc of longitude?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly with a steady rhythm while the background bookshelves remain out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a close-up from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008638040162622929 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75863790512085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008638040162622929, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008638040162622929, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22955845296382904, + 0.10217257589101791, + 0.07355880737304688, + 0.06545699387788773, + 0.08690803498029709, + 0.06640178710222244, + 0.10082366317510605, + 0.1325550377368927, + 0.10921027511358261, + 0.03335436061024666 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008638040162622929 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a horizontal angle focuses on an old-fashioned globe mounted on an intricately carved dark walnut stand. A warm, focused light softly shines from the side of the frame, precisely illuminating the sphere's curved surface and creating a brilliant highlight on its brass arc of longitude. The globe's surface has the yellowed hue of parchment, and the continental plates depicted therein are soft ochres and faded greens, imbued with a vintage texture. The globe rotates slowly with a steady and leisurely rhythm, allowing light and shadow to flow smoothly across the ancient map, passing over the blurred markings of national borders and ocean currents. In the background, out-of-focus bookshelves reveal the faint outlines of heavy books, and the entire scene is shrouded in a tranquil, nostalgic, and scholarly atmosphere.", + "seed": 17841, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_11/index_9198_seed_17841_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03493977254256606, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03493977254256606, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.099999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03493977254256606, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old-fashioned globe mounted on a dark walnut stand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the globe's surface yellowed like parchment with soft ochre and faded green continental plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, focused light shining from the side that creates a brilliant highlight on the brass arc of longitude?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly with a steady rhythm while the background bookshelves remain out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a close-up from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011129207909107208 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.761129379272461 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011129207909107208, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011129207909107208, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21029478311538696, + 0.11108823865652084, + 0.04716586694121361, + 0.10292158275842667, + 0.13345980644226074, + 0.11452152580022812, + 0.10702062398195267, + 0.09411653131246567, + 0.0370294451713562, + 0.0423816442489624 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011129207909107208 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old-fashioned globe mounted on a dark walnut stand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the globe's surface yellowed like parchment with soft ochre and faded green continental plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, focused light shining from the side that creates a brilliant highlight on the brass arc of longitude?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly with a steady rhythm while the background bookshelves remain out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a close-up from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014217512682080269 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264217376708984 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014217512682080269, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014217512682080269, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15738484263420105, + 0.1377953439950943, + 0.03391135111451149, + 0.10352178663015366, + 0.07812650501728058, + 0.16361239552497864, + 0.1476295441389084, + 0.12147799879312515, + 0.021498484537005424, + 0.03504170849919319 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014217512682080269 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old-fashioned globe mounted on a dark walnut stand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the globe's surface yellowed like parchment with soft ochre and faded green continental plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, focused light shining from the side that creates a brilliant highlight on the brass arc of longitude?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly with a steady rhythm while the background bookshelves remain out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a close-up from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040998938493430614 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.5040998458862305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040998938493430614, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040998938493430614, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23628857731819153, + 0.14636990427970886, + 0.14184127748012543, + 0.06126793473958969, + 0.05336790531873703, + 0.1013200432062149, + 0.0703425407409668, + 0.1081550121307373, + 0.031088201329112053, + 0.049958594143390656 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040998938493430614 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old-fashioned globe mounted on a dark walnut stand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the globe's surface yellowed like parchment with soft ochre and faded green continental plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, focused light shining from the side that creates a brilliant highlight on the brass arc of longitude?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly with a steady rhythm while the background bookshelves remain out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a close-up from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12706412374973297 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270642280578613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12706412374973297, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12706412374973297, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2400781363248825, + 0.2056860625743866, + 0.13473165035247803, + 0.064496248960495, + 0.06473780423402786, + 0.11057385057210922, + 0.045200932770967484, + 0.03147655352950096, + 0.05272365361452103, + 0.050295133143663406 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12706412374973297 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old-fashioned globe mounted on a dark walnut stand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the globe's surface yellowed like parchment with soft ochre and faded green continental plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, focused light shining from the side that creates a brilliant highlight on the brass arc of longitude?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly with a steady rhythm while the background bookshelves remain out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a close-up from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018188124522566795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187999725342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018188124522566795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018188124522566795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21205028891563416, + 0.08080172538757324, + 0.07906556129455566, + 0.05721656233072281, + 0.10353385657072067, + 0.14724436402320862, + 0.07988332957029343, + 0.11475914716720581, + 0.06108005344867706, + 0.06436511874198914 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018188124522566795 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a horizontal angle focuses on an old-fashioned globe mounted on an intricately carved dark walnut stand. A warm, focused light softly shines from the side of the frame, precisely illuminating the sphere's curved surface and creating a brilliant highlight on its brass arc of longitude. The globe's surface has the yellowed hue of parchment, and the continental plates depicted therein are soft ochres and faded greens, imbued with a vintage texture. The globe rotates slowly with a steady and leisurely rhythm, allowing light and shadow to flow smoothly across the ancient map, passing over the blurred markings of national borders and ocean currents. In the background, out-of-focus bookshelves reveal the faint outlines of heavy books, and the entire scene is shrouded in a tranquil, nostalgic, and scholarly atmosphere.", + "seed": 17842, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_11/index_9198_seed_17842_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.013008206151425838, + "vlm_logprob": -0.013008206151425838, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.013008206151425838, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old-fashioned globe mounted on a dark walnut stand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the globe's surface yellowed like parchment with soft ochre and faded green continental plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, focused light shining from the side that creates a brilliant highlight on the brass arc of longitude?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly with a steady rhythm while the background bookshelves remain out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a close-up from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.017005931586027145 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.267005920410156 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.017005931586027145, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.017005931586027145, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09138834476470947, + 0.12288837134838104, + 0.02876785397529602, + 0.0897425040602684, + 0.20489642024040222, + 0.08498142659664154, + 0.09159529209136963, + 0.03594744950532913, + 0.03274707868695259, + 0.21704521775245667 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.017005931586027145 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old-fashioned globe mounted on a dark walnut stand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the globe's surface yellowed like parchment with soft ochre and faded green continental plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, focused light shining from the side that creates a brilliant highlight on the brass arc of longitude?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly with a steady rhythm while the background bookshelves remain out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a close-up from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005960309412330389 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130960464477539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005960309412330389, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005960309412330389, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0844162181019783, + 0.05106698349118233, + 0.032520607113838196, + 0.08825331926345825, + 0.08387917280197144, + 0.2631677985191345, + 0.02945704758167267, + 0.019283892586827278, + 0.03177976980805397, + 0.3161751627922058 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005960309412330389 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old-fashioned globe mounted on a dark walnut stand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the globe's surface yellowed like parchment with soft ochre and faded green continental plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, focused light shining from the side that creates a brilliant highlight on the brass arc of longitude?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly with a steady rhythm while the background bookshelves remain out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a close-up from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004641473293304443 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379641532897949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004641473293304443, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004641473293304443, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06218790262937546, + 0.11100086569786072, + 0.02070990391075611, + 0.30987587571144104, + 0.19594547152519226, + 0.12744848430156708, + 0.027704009786248207, + 0.031964901834726334, + 0.018118606880307198, + 0.09504399448633194 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004641473293304443 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old-fashioned globe mounted on a dark walnut stand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the globe's surface yellowed like parchment with soft ochre and faded green continental plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, focused light shining from the side that creates a brilliant highlight on the brass arc of longitude?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly with a steady rhythm while the background bookshelves remain out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a close-up from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029803065583109856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298030376434326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029803065583109856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029803065583109856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08175491541624069, + 0.17371812462806702, + 0.022843139246106148, + 0.1299930363893509, + 0.11679954081773758, + 0.16528178751468658, + 0.07050308585166931, + 0.04837995022535324, + 0.015249334275722504, + 0.17547708749771118 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029803065583109856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old-fashioned globe mounted on a dark walnut stand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the globe's surface yellowed like parchment with soft ochre and faded green continental plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, focused light shining from the side that creates a brilliant highlight on the brass arc of longitude?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly with a steady rhythm while the background bookshelves remain out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a close-up from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007630250882357359 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882630348205566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007630250882357359, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007630250882357359, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04408979415893555, + 0.4467468857765198, + 0.01940019428730011, + 0.13568370044231415, + 0.12285429239273071, + 0.030421767383813858, + 0.05694393441081047, + 0.01533812377601862, + 0.03443796932697296, + 0.09408324956893921 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007630250882357359 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a horizontal angle focuses on an old-fashioned globe mounted on an intricately carved dark walnut stand. A warm, focused light softly shines from the side of the frame, precisely illuminating the sphere's curved surface and creating a brilliant highlight on its brass arc of longitude. The globe's surface has the yellowed hue of parchment, and the continental plates depicted therein are soft ochres and faded greens, imbued with a vintage texture. The globe rotates slowly with a steady and leisurely rhythm, allowing light and shadow to flow smoothly across the ancient map, passing over the blurred markings of national borders and ocean currents. In the background, out-of-focus bookshelves reveal the faint outlines of heavy books, and the entire scene is shrouded in a tranquil, nostalgic, and scholarly atmosphere.", + "seed": 17843, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_11/index_9198_seed_17843_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.025909089948982, + "vlm_logprob": -0.025909089948982, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.025909089948982, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old-fashioned globe mounted on a dark walnut stand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the globe's surface yellowed like parchment with soft ochre and faded green continental plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, focused light shining from the side that creates a brilliant highlight on the brass arc of longitude?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly with a steady rhythm while the background bookshelves remain out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a close-up from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.028825657442212105 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6538257598876953 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.028825657442212105, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.028825657442212105, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14169712364673615, + 0.3364979922771454, + 0.04290420189499855, + 0.11477730423212051, + 0.06797215342521667, + 0.0710097998380661, + 0.0411648266017437, + 0.026914190500974655, + 0.12647895514965057, + 0.03058347851037979 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.028825657442212105 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old-fashioned globe mounted on a dark walnut stand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the globe's surface yellowed like parchment with soft ochre and faded green continental plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, focused light shining from the side that creates a brilliant highlight on the brass arc of longitude?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly with a steady rhythm while the background bookshelves remain out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a close-up from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01608983427286148 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141089916229248 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01608983427286148, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01608983427286148, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06843748688697815, + 0.6118949055671692, + 0.09194973856210709, + 0.021038653329014778, + 0.04158201813697815, + 0.023727742955088615, + 0.026468101888895035, + 0.02232617326080799, + 0.05507031828165054, + 0.037504903972148895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01608983427286148 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old-fashioned globe mounted on a dark walnut stand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the globe's surface yellowed like parchment with soft ochre and faded green continental plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, focused light shining from the side that creates a brilliant highlight on the brass arc of longitude?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly with a steady rhythm while the background bookshelves remain out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a close-up from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005956872832030058 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130956649780273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005956872832030058, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005956872832030058, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09386902302503586, + 0.4720555543899536, + 0.038885004818439484, + 0.01885322295129299, + 0.03858771175146103, + 0.0541544035077095, + 0.028617849573493004, + 0.08761508017778397, + 0.04012833535671234, + 0.1272338181734085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005956872832030058 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old-fashioned globe mounted on a dark walnut stand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the globe's surface yellowed like parchment with soft ochre and faded green continental plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, focused light shining from the side that creates a brilliant highlight on the brass arc of longitude?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly with a steady rhythm while the background bookshelves remain out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a close-up from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003126293420792 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.69503116607666 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003126293420792, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003126293420792, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08753908425569534, + 0.22947698831558228, + 0.08745325356721878, + 0.061448030173778534, + 0.04503476992249489, + 0.1757209450006485, + 0.036998599767684937, + 0.042480260133743286, + 0.056656986474990845, + 0.17719107866287231 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003126293420792 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an old-fashioned globe mounted on a dark walnut stand?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the globe's surface yellowed like parchment with soft ochre and faded green continental plates?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a warm, focused light shining from the side that creates a brilliant highlight on the brass arc of longitude?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the globe rotate slowly with a steady rhythm while the background bookshelves remain out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene shot as a close-up from a horizontal angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008641822263598442 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758641719818115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008641822263598442, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008641822263598442, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12249283492565155, + 0.13584579527378082, + 0.051047008484601974, + 0.056520309299230576, + 0.03207019343972206, + 0.07816805690526962, + 0.044538453221321106, + 0.07094435393810272, + 0.29164302349090576, + 0.1167299821972847 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008641822263598442 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_12/index_tensor([4757, 4757])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_12/index_tensor([4757, 4757])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e0f853ebf509b958d7f4c31bc385cb6dd0efe2cb --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_12/index_tensor([4757, 4757])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slowly zooming drone shot captures the majestic spectacle of an eagle soaring atop a mountaintop, captured in the distinctive aesthetic of traditional Chinese ink painting. The eagle takes center stage, its wings, deep as burnt ink, fully extended. Each steady, powerful flap spurs air, and the distinct feathers on its wingtips resemble the most powerful brushstrokes of a calligrapher. The feathers on its abdomen fade from dark to light, transitioning to a subtle ochre hue. Its sharp, hooked beak and gleaming amber eyes imbue the ink wash palette with a vibrant, vibrant focus. The eagle deftly rides the mountain's updrafts, stretching its legs and gliding gracefully through the air. The camera slowly pulls back, revealing the rolling hills below. Distant peaks are vaguely outlined with a few strokes of light ink, dissolving into the horizon. Nearer, vigorous brushstrokes depict the texture and structure of the rock. A thin haze of mist lingers like a veil around the mountainside, adding an ethereal and layered quality to the image. The entire scene appears as if painted on a sheet of damp rice paper, its primary colors composed of varying shades of black, white, and gray. The lighting is soft, diffuse skylight. The absence of a distinct light source imbues the world with a sense of transparency and tranquility, creating a tranquil atmosphere that is both majestic and imbued with the Zen spirit of Eastern philosophy.", + "seed": 14435, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_12/index_4757_seed_14435_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04379547010175884, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04379547010175884, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04379547010175884, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an eagle soaring on a mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a traditional Chinese ink painting on damp rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the eagle's wings deep black (burnt ink) with feathers resembling calligrapher brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eagle's abdomen transition from dark to a subtle ochre hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal rolling hills and distant peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.030852803960442543 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.530852794647217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.030852803960442543, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.030852803960442543, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05652112513780594, + 0.021685222163796425, + 0.05421476438641548, + 0.49304309487342834, + 0.03601035475730896, + 0.03148733079433441, + 0.05133165419101715, + 0.17245693504810333, + 0.059641819447278976, + 0.023607667535543442 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.030852803960442543 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an eagle soaring on a mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a traditional Chinese ink painting on damp rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the eagle's wings deep black (burnt ink) with feathers resembling calligrapher brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eagle's abdomen transition from dark to a subtle ochre hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal rolling hills and distant peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011089714244008064 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51108980178833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011089714244008064, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011089714244008064, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.042179401963949203, + 0.011074468493461609, + 0.013470511883497238, + 0.8590966463088989, + 0.023805251345038414, + 0.005651725456118584, + 0.007951830513775349, + 0.0174644086509943, + 0.010473722591996193, + 0.008832092396914959 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011089714244008064 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an eagle soaring on a mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a traditional Chinese ink painting on damp rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the eagle's wings deep black (burnt ink) with feathers resembling calligrapher brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eagle's abdomen transition from dark to a subtle ochre hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal rolling hills and distant peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024974129628390074 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.00249719619751 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024974129628390074, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024974129628390074, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2880517542362213, + 0.08096174895763397, + 0.11095058917999268, + 0.2072048932313919, + 0.061355844140052795, + 0.03572472557425499, + 0.02494114078581333, + 0.0817476436495781, + 0.07290448993444443, + 0.03615717217326164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024974129628390074 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an eagle soaring on a mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a traditional Chinese ink painting on damp rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the eagle's wings deep black (burnt ink) with feathers resembling calligrapher brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eagle's abdomen transition from dark to a subtle ochre hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal rolling hills and distant peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01419165637344122 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264191627502441 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01419165637344122, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01419165637344122, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23715253174304962, + 0.05192665010690689, + 0.04163637012243271, + 0.2756737470626831, + 0.0574088953435421, + 0.04082531854510307, + 0.018448222428560257, + 0.16916729509830475, + 0.058195412158966064, + 0.049565549939870834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01419165637344122 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an eagle soaring on a mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a traditional Chinese ink painting on damp rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the eagle's wings deep black (burnt ink) with feathers resembling calligrapher brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eagle's abdomen transition from dark to a subtle ochre hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal rolling hills and distant peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16034576296806335 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103457927703857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16034576296806335, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16034576296806335, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3432658612728119, + 0.01638968475162983, + 0.021163025870919228, + 0.3896001875400543, + 0.04317516088485718, + 0.030933719128370285, + 0.010691814124584198, + 0.08740601688623428, + 0.03274399787187576, + 0.02463052235543728 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16034576296806335 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly zooming drone shot captures the majestic spectacle of an eagle soaring atop a mountaintop, captured in the distinctive aesthetic of traditional Chinese ink painting. The eagle takes center stage, its wings, deep as burnt ink, fully extended. Each steady, powerful flap spurs air, and the distinct feathers on its wingtips resemble the most powerful brushstrokes of a calligrapher. The feathers on its abdomen fade from dark to light, transitioning to a subtle ochre hue. Its sharp, hooked beak and gleaming amber eyes imbue the ink wash palette with a vibrant, vibrant focus. The eagle deftly rides the mountain's updrafts, stretching its legs and gliding gracefully through the air. The camera slowly pulls back, revealing the rolling hills below. Distant peaks are vaguely outlined with a few strokes of light ink, dissolving into the horizon. Nearer, vigorous brushstrokes depict the texture and structure of the rock. A thin haze of mist lingers like a veil around the mountainside, adding an ethereal and layered quality to the image. The entire scene appears as if painted on a sheet of damp rice paper, its primary colors composed of varying shades of black, white, and gray. The lighting is soft, diffuse skylight. The absence of a distinct light source imbues the world with a sense of transparency and tranquility, creating a tranquil atmosphere that is both majestic and imbued with the Zen spirit of Eastern philosophy.", + "seed": 14436, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_12/index_4757_seed_14436_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.02362871482037008, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02362871482037008, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02362871482037008, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an eagle soaring on a mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a traditional Chinese ink painting on damp rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the eagle's wings deep black (burnt ink) with feathers resembling calligrapher brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eagle's abdomen transition from dark to a subtle ochre hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal rolling hills and distant peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02039041742682457 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.020390510559082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02039041742682457, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02039041742682457, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06724844872951508, + 0.12789380550384521, + 0.07015515863895416, + 0.18268544971942902, + 0.11160936206579208, + 0.10602845251560211, + 0.12765581905841827, + 0.06740294396877289, + 0.04583819955587387, + 0.09348238259553909 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02039041742682457 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an eagle soaring on a mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a traditional Chinese ink painting on damp rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the eagle's wings deep black (burnt ink) with feathers resembling calligrapher brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eagle's abdomen transition from dark to a subtle ochre hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal rolling hills and distant peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009801593609154224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634801387786865 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009801593609154224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009801593609154224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09648697823286057, + 0.10495295375585556, + 0.08480466157197952, + 0.1720276027917862, + 0.09805890917778015, + 0.056452151387929916, + 0.08547012507915497, + 0.2075994610786438, + 0.04119711369276047, + 0.05295006185770035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009801593609154224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an eagle soaring on a mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a traditional Chinese ink painting on damp rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the eagle's wings deep black (burnt ink) with feathers resembling calligrapher brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eagle's abdomen transition from dark to a subtle ochre hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal rolling hills and distant peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0032043324317783117 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753204345703125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0032043324317783117, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0032043324317783117, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08651474118232727, + 0.10870130360126495, + 0.04680398479104042, + 0.1301223784685135, + 0.15446405112743378, + 0.1474367380142212, + 0.10551325976848602, + 0.08909577131271362, + 0.022981328889727592, + 0.1083664745092392 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0032043324317783117 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an eagle soaring on a mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a traditional Chinese ink painting on damp rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the eagle's wings deep black (burnt ink) with feathers resembling calligrapher brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eagle's abdomen transition from dark to a subtle ochre hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal rolling hills and distant peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029799478128552437 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529799461364746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029799478128552437, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029799478128552437, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05326966568827629, + 0.07131379097700119, + 0.09200993180274963, + 0.12743854522705078, + 0.1205533891916275, + 0.14237667620182037, + 0.10766478627920151, + 0.08602257817983627, + 0.05497431010007858, + 0.14437629282474518 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029799478128552437 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an eagle soaring on a mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a traditional Chinese ink painting on damp rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the eagle's wings deep black (burnt ink) with feathers resembling calligrapher brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eagle's abdomen transition from dark to a subtle ochre hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal rolling hills and distant peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05494775250554085 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929947853088379 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05494775250554085, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05494775250554085, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15606960654258728, + 0.13000355660915375, + 0.035414937883615494, + 0.11632577329874039, + 0.10287309437990189, + 0.24434760212898254, + 0.06576347351074219, + 0.04299909994006157, + 0.05261820927262306, + 0.05358467623591423 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05494775250554085 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly zooming drone shot captures the majestic spectacle of an eagle soaring atop a mountaintop, captured in the distinctive aesthetic of traditional Chinese ink painting. The eagle takes center stage, its wings, deep as burnt ink, fully extended. Each steady, powerful flap spurs air, and the distinct feathers on its wingtips resemble the most powerful brushstrokes of a calligrapher. The feathers on its abdomen fade from dark to light, transitioning to a subtle ochre hue. Its sharp, hooked beak and gleaming amber eyes imbue the ink wash palette with a vibrant, vibrant focus. The eagle deftly rides the mountain's updrafts, stretching its legs and gliding gracefully through the air. The camera slowly pulls back, revealing the rolling hills below. Distant peaks are vaguely outlined with a few strokes of light ink, dissolving into the horizon. Nearer, vigorous brushstrokes depict the texture and structure of the rock. A thin haze of mist lingers like a veil around the mountainside, adding an ethereal and layered quality to the image. The entire scene appears as if painted on a sheet of damp rice paper, its primary colors composed of varying shades of black, white, and gray. The lighting is soft, diffuse skylight. The absence of a distinct light source imbues the world with a sense of transparency and tranquility, creating a tranquil atmosphere that is both majestic and imbued with the Zen spirit of Eastern philosophy.", + "seed": 14437, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_12/index_4757_seed_14437_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.01368607897311449, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01368607897311449, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.549999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01368607897311449, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an eagle soaring on a mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a traditional Chinese ink painting on damp rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the eagle's wings deep black (burnt ink) with feathers resembling calligrapher brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eagle's abdomen transition from dark to a subtle ochre hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal rolling hills and distant peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005031305365264416 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.505031108856201 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005031305365264416, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005031305365264416, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11196692287921906, + 0.07063652575016022, + 0.1010478213429451, + 0.06032867729663849, + 0.11668940633535385, + 0.05109233781695366, + 0.13266457617282867, + 0.2606091797351837, + 0.04334433376789093, + 0.05162021890282631 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005031305365264416 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an eagle soaring on a mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a traditional Chinese ink painting on damp rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the eagle's wings deep black (burnt ink) with feathers resembling calligrapher brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eagle's abdomen transition from dark to a subtle ochre hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal rolling hills and distant peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01422045100480318 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264220237731934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01422045100480318, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01422045100480318, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1467619389295578, + 0.08475115895271301, + 0.08249599486589432, + 0.11374641209840775, + 0.07384278625249863, + 0.08874604851007462, + 0.12542909383773804, + 0.07437430322170258, + 0.12282200157642365, + 0.08703027665615082 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01422045100480318 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an eagle soaring on a mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a traditional Chinese ink painting on damp rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the eagle's wings deep black (burnt ink) with feathers resembling calligrapher brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eagle's abdomen transition from dark to a subtle ochre hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal rolling hills and distant peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004650491289794445 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379650592803955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004650491289794445, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004650491289794445, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12545321881771088, + 0.17721246182918549, + 0.23782336711883545, + 0.08493107557296753, + 0.05085113272070885, + 0.07473035156726837, + 0.08517596125602722, + 0.07436222583055496, + 0.043419599533081055, + 0.04604063183069229 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004650491289794445 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an eagle soaring on a mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a traditional Chinese ink painting on damp rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the eagle's wings deep black (burnt ink) with feathers resembling calligrapher brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eagle's abdomen transition from dark to a subtle ochre hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal rolling hills and distant peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018185783177614212 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018185615539551 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018185783177614212, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018185783177614212, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08504818379878998, + 0.07392283529043198, + 0.0880010575056076, + 0.090749092400074, + 0.08180004358291626, + 0.1863948255777359, + 0.13831835985183716, + 0.09425026178359985, + 0.08617030829191208, + 0.07534506171941757 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018185783177614212 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an eagle soaring on a mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a traditional Chinese ink painting on damp rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the eagle's wings deep black (burnt ink) with feathers resembling calligrapher brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eagle's abdomen transition from dark to a subtle ochre hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal rolling hills and distant peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0263423640280962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513423919677734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0263423640280962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0263423640280962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07398633658885956, + 0.03574736416339874, + 0.06378547847270966, + 0.07462430745363235, + 0.08548880368471146, + 0.15866267681121826, + 0.1520405113697052, + 0.07922837138175964, + 0.16184015572071075, + 0.11459598690271378 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0263423640280962 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slowly zooming drone shot captures the majestic spectacle of an eagle soaring atop a mountaintop, captured in the distinctive aesthetic of traditional Chinese ink painting. The eagle takes center stage, its wings, deep as burnt ink, fully extended. Each steady, powerful flap spurs air, and the distinct feathers on its wingtips resemble the most powerful brushstrokes of a calligrapher. The feathers on its abdomen fade from dark to light, transitioning to a subtle ochre hue. Its sharp, hooked beak and gleaming amber eyes imbue the ink wash palette with a vibrant, vibrant focus. The eagle deftly rides the mountain's updrafts, stretching its legs and gliding gracefully through the air. The camera slowly pulls back, revealing the rolling hills below. Distant peaks are vaguely outlined with a few strokes of light ink, dissolving into the horizon. Nearer, vigorous brushstrokes depict the texture and structure of the rock. A thin haze of mist lingers like a veil around the mountainside, adding an ethereal and layered quality to the image. The entire scene appears as if painted on a sheet of damp rice paper, its primary colors composed of varying shades of black, white, and gray. The lighting is soft, diffuse skylight. The absence of a distinct light source imbues the world with a sense of transparency and tranquility, creating a tranquil atmosphere that is both majestic and imbued with the Zen spirit of Eastern philosophy.", + "seed": 14438, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_12/index_4757_seed_14438_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0366549716796726, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0366549716796726, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0366549716796726, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an eagle soaring on a mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a traditional Chinese ink painting on damp rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the eagle's wings deep black (burnt ink) with feathers resembling calligrapher brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eagle's abdomen transition from dark to a subtle ochre hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal rolling hills and distant peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019905099645256996 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.019905090332031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019905099645256996, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019905099645256996, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0970502570271492, + 0.05217161029577255, + 0.03119768016040325, + 0.05177268385887146, + 0.05343146622180939, + 0.27675896883010864, + 0.06826002895832062, + 0.10699442774057388, + 0.23662374913692474, + 0.025739086791872978 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019905099645256996 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an eagle soaring on a mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a traditional Chinese ink painting on damp rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the eagle's wings deep black (burnt ink) with feathers resembling calligrapher brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eagle's abdomen transition from dark to a subtle ochre hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal rolling hills and distant peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012557249516248703 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387557029724121 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012557249516248703, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012557249516248703, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09837318956851959, + 0.04094850271940231, + 0.029107511043548584, + 0.047065816819667816, + 0.022851677611470222, + 0.5612183213233948, + 0.05735085532069206, + 0.02886972390115261, + 0.03731762245297432, + 0.0768967866897583 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012557249516248703 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an eagle soaring on a mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a traditional Chinese ink painting on damp rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the eagle's wings deep black (burnt ink) with feathers resembling calligrapher brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eagle's abdomen transition from dark to a subtle ochre hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal rolling hills and distant peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003199935657903552 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753200054168701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003199935657903552, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003199935657903552, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09110171347856522, + 0.07515068352222443, + 0.06034623086452484, + 0.10846902430057526, + 0.062018126249313354, + 0.1752239465713501, + 0.23134583234786987, + 0.057451121509075165, + 0.0799187645316124, + 0.058974601328372955 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003199935657903552 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an eagle soaring on a mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a traditional Chinese ink painting on damp rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the eagle's wings deep black (burnt ink) with feathers resembling calligrapher brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eagle's abdomen transition from dark to a subtle ochre hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal rolling hills and distant peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020576702430844307 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955767154693604 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020576702430844307, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020576702430844307, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04187842831015587, + 0.02188766561448574, + 0.01700621284544468, + 0.03031780943274498, + 0.022896256297826767, + 0.7682158946990967, + 0.024903830140829086, + 0.018105698749423027, + 0.026428479701280594, + 0.02835972048342228 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020576702430844307 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an eagle soaring on a mountaintop?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style that of a traditional Chinese ink painting on damp rice paper?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the eagle's wings deep black (burnt ink) with feathers resembling calligrapher brushstrokes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the eagle's abdomen transition from dark to a subtle ochre hue?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal rolling hills and distant peaks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12703587114810944 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270358562469482 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12703587114810944, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12703587114810944, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.033331479877233505, + 0.014732078649103642, + 0.016390476375818253, + 0.018857304006814957, + 0.023155560716986656, + 0.7724660634994507, + 0.03501643240451813, + 0.019755741581320763, + 0.023288626223802567, + 0.04300621896982193 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12703587114810944 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_13/index_tensor([7603, 7603])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_13/index_tensor([7603, 7603])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..acefae51b0d873c46ab547c42a119429ef31112e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_13/index_tensor([7603, 7603])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "At dawn, a fluid, low-angle tracking shot glides across the water of a tranquil Venetian canal. The first soft, golden rays of sunlight illuminate the ancient, crumbling facades of historic buildings, painting them in a subtle palette of soft pink, pale ochre, and muted terracotta. The camera's movement is synchronized with a lone traditional gondola, its sleek, black-painted hue gleaming as it silently slices through the dark, calm waters, reflecting the awakening sky. At the stern, a gondolier in a classic blue-and-white striped shirt and straw hat propels the vessel forward with the long, graceful, and rhythmic strokes of a single oar. As the gondola steadily approaches a low, arched bridge constructed of weathered, moss-colored stone, the camera subtly tilts upward to capture a secondary action: a pair of dark green wooden shutters on an upper floor deliberately creak open. An unseen resident’s hand casts a trail of breadcrumbs from a shaded window, which drift down like confetti, prompting a flock of gray pigeons perched on the bridge to burst into a flurry of circling and swooping movements, their wings catching the morning light and creating a tranquil yet vibrant atmosphere of a city just beginning to wake up.", + "seed": 21071, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_13/index_7603_seed_21071_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08939163340255618, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08939163340255618, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.549999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08939163340255618, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dawn in a Venetian canal with ancient, crumbling facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone traditional gondola with a black-painted hull visible moving through the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gondolier wearing a blue-and-white striped shirt and a straw hat propelling the gondola with a single oar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a fluid low-angle tracking shot that tilts upward as the gondola approaches a low, arched bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark green wooden shutters on an upper floor shown creaking open while breadcrumbs fall and gray pigeons take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.35280275344848633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2278027534484863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.35280275344848633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.35280275344848633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4095275104045868, + 0.14955228567123413, + 0.0870518907904625, + 0.03421874716877937, + 0.045389506965875626, + 0.06737508624792099, + 0.07313323020935059, + 0.07638024538755417, + 0.032845381647348404, + 0.024526158347725868 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.35280275344848633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dawn in a Venetian canal with ancient, crumbling facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone traditional gondola with a black-painted hull visible moving through the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gondolier wearing a blue-and-white striped shirt and a straw hat propelling the gondola with a single oar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a fluid low-angle tracking shot that tilts upward as the gondola approaches a low, arched bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark green wooden shutters on an upper floor shown creaking open while breadcrumbs fall and gray pigeons take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009806079789996147 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634806156158447 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009806079789996147, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009806079789996147, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10409912467002869, + 0.031778234988451004, + 0.04806135967373848, + 0.023342108353972435, + 0.18038102984428406, + 0.16685591638088226, + 0.19811345636844635, + 0.08952150493860245, + 0.13754083216190338, + 0.020306332036852837 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009806079789996147 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dawn in a Venetian canal with ancient, crumbling facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone traditional gondola with a black-painted hull visible moving through the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gondolier wearing a blue-and-white striped shirt and a straw hat propelling the gondola with a single oar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a fluid low-angle tracking shot that tilts upward as the gondola approaches a low, arched bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark green wooden shutters on an upper floor shown creaking open while breadcrumbs fall and gray pigeons take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004102980252355337 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504103183746338 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004102980252355337, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004102980252355337, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.188460111618042, + 0.046395193785429, + 0.07479715347290039, + 0.025968601927161217, + 0.031838126480579376, + 0.10361341387033463, + 0.1431598663330078, + 0.27959248423576355, + 0.05829029157757759, + 0.047884758561849594 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004102980252355337 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dawn in a Venetian canal with ancient, crumbling facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone traditional gondola with a black-painted hull visible moving through the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gondolier wearing a blue-and-white striped shirt and a straw hat propelling the gondola with a single oar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a fluid low-angle tracking shot that tilts upward as the gondola approaches a low, arched bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark green wooden shutters on an upper floor shown creaking open while breadcrumbs fall and gray pigeons take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018190113827586174 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018189907073975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018190113827586174, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018190113827586174, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06169784069061279, + 0.13220776617527008, + 0.02913033217191696, + 0.017706971615552902, + 0.09930617362260818, + 0.037097081542015076, + 0.07489621639251709, + 0.06160574406385422, + 0.3917258083820343, + 0.0946260541677475 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018190113827586174 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dawn in a Venetian canal with ancient, crumbling facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone traditional gondola with a black-painted hull visible moving through the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gondolier wearing a blue-and-white striped shirt and a straw hat propelling the gondola with a single oar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a fluid low-angle tracking shot that tilts upward as the gondola approaches a low, arched bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark green wooden shutters on an upper floor shown creaking open while breadcrumbs fall and gray pigeons take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205623969435692 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812056303024292 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205623969435692, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205623969435692, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20451326668262482, + 0.024531880393624306, + 0.07762399315834045, + 0.021368930116295815, + 0.023274919018149376, + 0.07701906561851501, + 0.10346806049346924, + 0.06060051545500755, + 0.19116707146167755, + 0.21643230319023132 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205623969435692 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "At dawn, a fluid, low-angle tracking shot glides across the water of a tranquil Venetian canal. The first soft, golden rays of sunlight illuminate the ancient, crumbling facades of historic buildings, painting them in a subtle palette of soft pink, pale ochre, and muted terracotta. The camera's movement is synchronized with a lone traditional gondola, its sleek, black-painted hue gleaming as it silently slices through the dark, calm waters, reflecting the awakening sky. At the stern, a gondolier in a classic blue-and-white striped shirt and straw hat propels the vessel forward with the long, graceful, and rhythmic strokes of a single oar. As the gondola steadily approaches a low, arched bridge constructed of weathered, moss-colored stone, the camera subtly tilts upward to capture a secondary action: a pair of dark green wooden shutters on an upper floor deliberately creak open. An unseen resident’s hand casts a trail of breadcrumbs from a shaded window, which drift down like confetti, prompting a flock of gray pigeons perched on the bridge to burst into a flurry of circling and swooping movements, their wings catching the morning light and creating a tranquil yet vibrant atmosphere of a city just beginning to wake up.", + "seed": 21072, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_13/index_7603_seed_21072_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07504908144474029, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07504908144474029, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.875000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07504908144474029, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dawn in a Venetian canal with ancient, crumbling facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone traditional gondola with a black-painted hull visible moving through the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gondolier wearing a blue-and-white striped shirt and a straw hat propelling the gondola with a single oar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a fluid low-angle tracking shot that tilts upward as the gondola approaches a low, arched bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark green wooden shutters on an upper floor shown creaking open while breadcrumbs fall and gray pigeons take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1470443159341812 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0220444202423096 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1470443159341812, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1470443159341812, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21120615303516388, + 0.18289555609226227, + 0.07194133847951889, + 0.06143616884946823, + 0.13193634152412415, + 0.04117586463689804, + 0.10514416545629501, + 0.025853293016552925, + 0.10409700125455856, + 0.06431414186954498 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1470443159341812 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dawn in a Venetian canal with ancient, crumbling facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone traditional gondola with a black-painted hull visible moving through the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gondolier wearing a blue-and-white striped shirt and a straw hat propelling the gondola with a single oar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a fluid low-angle tracking shot that tilts upward as the gondola approaches a low, arched bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark green wooden shutters on an upper floor shown creaking open while breadcrumbs fall and gray pigeons take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02060507982969284 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956050872802734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02060507982969284, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02060507982969284, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07562576234340668, + 0.06636905670166016, + 0.02049982361495495, + 0.19359804689884186, + 0.14365164935588837, + 0.05605557933449745, + 0.299437940120697, + 0.033712033182382584, + 0.07219294458627701, + 0.03885713592171669 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02060507982969284 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dawn in a Venetian canal with ancient, crumbling facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone traditional gondola with a black-painted hull visible moving through the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gondolier wearing a blue-and-white striped shirt and a straw hat propelling the gondola with a single oar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a fluid low-angle tracking shot that tilts upward as the gondola approaches a low, arched bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark green wooden shutters on an upper floor shown creaking open while breadcrumbs fall and gray pigeons take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10035765916109085 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503577709198 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10035765916109085, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10035765916109085, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08500707149505615, + 0.04996513947844505, + 0.09700901061296463, + 0.1268152892589569, + 0.09415409713983536, + 0.028509607538580894, + 0.18750156462192535, + 0.05397335812449455, + 0.19432120025157928, + 0.08274365961551666 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10035765916109085 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dawn in a Venetian canal with ancient, crumbling facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone traditional gondola with a black-painted hull visible moving through the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gondolier wearing a blue-and-white striped shirt and a straw hat propelling the gondola with a single oar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a fluid low-angle tracking shot that tilts upward as the gondola approaches a low, arched bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark green wooden shutters on an upper floor shown creaking open while breadcrumbs fall and gray pigeons take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018190816044807434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018190860748291 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018190816044807434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018190816044807434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20529836416244507, + 0.03822866827249527, + 0.044861629605293274, + 0.14379611611366272, + 0.08001160621643066, + 0.03148501738905907, + 0.08319804072380066, + 0.03948667645454407, + 0.2317071408033371, + 0.10192672163248062 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018190816044807434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dawn in a Venetian canal with ancient, crumbling facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone traditional gondola with a black-painted hull visible moving through the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gondolier wearing a blue-and-white striped shirt and a straw hat propelling the gondola with a single oar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a fluid low-angle tracking shot that tilts upward as the gondola approaches a low, arched bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark green wooden shutters on an upper floor shown creaking open while breadcrumbs fall and gray pigeons take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08904753625392914 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464047431945801 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08904753625392914, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08904753625392914, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09169776737689972, + 0.09139367192983627, + 0.04879605770111084, + 0.03432472422719002, + 0.06470983475446701, + 0.02407658100128174, + 0.034771744161844254, + 0.07759071886539459, + 0.1696903109550476, + 0.36294856667518616 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08904753625392914 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "At dawn, a fluid, low-angle tracking shot glides across the water of a tranquil Venetian canal. The first soft, golden rays of sunlight illuminate the ancient, crumbling facades of historic buildings, painting them in a subtle palette of soft pink, pale ochre, and muted terracotta. The camera's movement is synchronized with a lone traditional gondola, its sleek, black-painted hue gleaming as it silently slices through the dark, calm waters, reflecting the awakening sky. At the stern, a gondolier in a classic blue-and-white striped shirt and straw hat propels the vessel forward with the long, graceful, and rhythmic strokes of a single oar. As the gondola steadily approaches a low, arched bridge constructed of weathered, moss-colored stone, the camera subtly tilts upward to capture a secondary action: a pair of dark green wooden shutters on an upper floor deliberately creak open. An unseen resident’s hand casts a trail of breadcrumbs from a shaded window, which drift down like confetti, prompting a flock of gray pigeons perched on the bridge to burst into a flurry of circling and swooping movements, their wings catching the morning light and creating a tranquil yet vibrant atmosphere of a city just beginning to wake up.", + "seed": 21073, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_13/index_7603_seed_21073_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1563080970197916, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1563080970197916, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1563080970197916, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dawn in a Venetian canal with ancient, crumbling facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone traditional gondola with a black-painted hull visible moving through the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gondolier wearing a blue-and-white striped shirt and a straw hat propelling the gondola with a single oar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a fluid low-angle tracking shot that tilts upward as the gondola approaches a low, arched bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark green wooden shutters on an upper floor shown creaking open while breadcrumbs fall and gray pigeons take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5805790424346924 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8305790424346924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5805790424346924, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5805790424346924, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.047807157039642334, + 0.3911404311656952, + 0.04188880696892738, + 0.017652535811066628, + 0.3809737265110016, + 0.01851707510650158, + 0.024177419021725655, + 0.040759969502687454, + 0.02556605078279972, + 0.011516851373016834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5805790424346924 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dawn in a Venetian canal with ancient, crumbling facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone traditional gondola with a black-painted hull visible moving through the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gondolier wearing a blue-and-white striped shirt and a straw hat propelling the gondola with a single oar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a fluid low-angle tracking shot that tilts upward as the gondola approaches a low, arched bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark green wooden shutters on an upper floor shown creaking open while breadcrumbs fall and gray pigeons take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03373359888792038 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408733606338501 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03373359888792038, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03373359888792038, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3506585657596588, + 0.0871279314160347, + 0.03692973777651787, + 0.040292415767908096, + 0.13061226904392242, + 0.09783057123422623, + 0.09528964012861252, + 0.06749594956636429, + 0.03138279914855957, + 0.062380097806453705 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03373359888792038 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dawn in a Venetian canal with ancient, crumbling facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone traditional gondola with a black-painted hull visible moving through the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gondolier wearing a blue-and-white striped shirt and a straw hat propelling the gondola with a single oar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a fluid low-angle tracking shot that tilts upward as the gondola approaches a low, arched bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark green wooden shutters on an upper floor shown creaking open while breadcrumbs fall and gray pigeons take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04869667813181877 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048696756362915 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04869667813181877, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04869667813181877, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11748231202363968, + 0.3859321177005768, + 0.008682535029947758, + 0.013840198516845703, + 0.28517594933509827, + 0.02635197341442108, + 0.030116001144051552, + 0.058835841715335846, + 0.018707841634750366, + 0.054875265806913376 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04869667813181877 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dawn in a Venetian canal with ancient, crumbling facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone traditional gondola with a black-painted hull visible moving through the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gondolier wearing a blue-and-white striped shirt and a straw hat propelling the gondola with a single oar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a fluid low-angle tracking shot that tilts upward as the gondola approaches a low, arched bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark green wooden shutters on an upper floor shown creaking open while breadcrumbs fall and gray pigeons take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018194211646914482 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018194198608398 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018194211646914482, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018194211646914482, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.016502873972058296, + 0.1281287670135498, + 0.010895981453359127, + 0.049772828817367554, + 0.7265386581420898, + 0.01232223305851221, + 0.008002993650734425, + 0.017331000417470932, + 0.014706826768815517, + 0.015797818079590797 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018194211646914482 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dawn in a Venetian canal with ancient, crumbling facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone traditional gondola with a black-painted hull visible moving through the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gondolier wearing a blue-and-white striped shirt and a straw hat propelling the gondola with a single oar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a fluid low-angle tracking shot that tilts upward as the gondola approaches a low, arched bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark green wooden shutters on an upper floor shown creaking open while breadcrumbs fall and gray pigeons take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.100336953997612 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350337028503418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.100336953997612, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.100336953997612, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07499034702777863, + 0.06936890631914139, + 0.015764890238642693, + 0.018405845388770103, + 0.5296601057052612, + 0.01522757951170206, + 0.027698319405317307, + 0.04462713748216629, + 0.060992028564214706, + 0.14326483011245728 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.100336953997612 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "At dawn, a fluid, low-angle tracking shot glides across the water of a tranquil Venetian canal. The first soft, golden rays of sunlight illuminate the ancient, crumbling facades of historic buildings, painting them in a subtle palette of soft pink, pale ochre, and muted terracotta. The camera's movement is synchronized with a lone traditional gondola, its sleek, black-painted hue gleaming as it silently slices through the dark, calm waters, reflecting the awakening sky. At the stern, a gondolier in a classic blue-and-white striped shirt and straw hat propels the vessel forward with the long, graceful, and rhythmic strokes of a single oar. As the gondola steadily approaches a low, arched bridge constructed of weathered, moss-colored stone, the camera subtly tilts upward to capture a secondary action: a pair of dark green wooden shutters on an upper floor deliberately creak open. An unseen resident’s hand casts a trail of breadcrumbs from a shaded window, which drift down like confetti, prompting a flock of gray pigeons perched on the bridge to burst into a flurry of circling and swooping movements, their wings catching the morning light and creating a tranquil yet vibrant atmosphere of a city just beginning to wake up.", + "seed": 21074, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_13/index_7603_seed_21074_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.11362126171588897, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11362126171588897, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11362126171588897, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dawn in a Venetian canal with ancient, crumbling facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone traditional gondola with a black-painted hull visible moving through the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gondolier wearing a blue-and-white striped shirt and a straw hat propelling the gondola with a single oar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a fluid low-angle tracking shot that tilts upward as the gondola approaches a low, arched bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark green wooden shutters on an upper floor shown creaking open while breadcrumbs fall and gray pigeons take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25517433881759644 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5051743984222412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25517433881759644, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25517433881759644, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11940095573663712, + 0.09019434452056885, + 0.1878749132156372, + 0.06428171694278717, + 0.06906326860189438, + 0.09987131506204605, + 0.2536109685897827, + 0.018491419032216072, + 0.02663233131170273, + 0.07057879120111465 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25517433881759644 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dawn in a Venetian canal with ancient, crumbling facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone traditional gondola with a black-painted hull visible moving through the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gondolier wearing a blue-and-white striped shirt and a straw hat propelling the gondola with a single oar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a fluid low-angle tracking shot that tilts upward as the gondola approaches a low, arched bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark green wooden shutters on an upper floor shown creaking open while breadcrumbs fall and gray pigeons take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038138497620821 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881383895874023 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038138497620821, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038138497620821, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.166671484708786, + 0.1442955881357193, + 0.058808982372283936, + 0.21774187684059143, + 0.07881926745176315, + 0.05444004014134407, + 0.1341789960861206, + 0.035835567861795425, + 0.04680082947015762, + 0.062407441437244415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038138497620821 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dawn in a Venetian canal with ancient, crumbling facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone traditional gondola with a black-painted hull visible moving through the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gondolier wearing a blue-and-white striped shirt and a straw hat propelling the gondola with a single oar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a fluid low-angle tracking shot that tilts upward as the gondola approaches a low, arched bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark green wooden shutters on an upper floor shown creaking open while breadcrumbs fall and gray pigeons take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054995931684970856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299960136413574 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054995931684970856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054995931684970856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11284855008125305, + 0.10654560476541519, + 0.08731307834386826, + 0.16472670435905457, + 0.03908525034785271, + 0.12234661728143692, + 0.16960468888282776, + 0.03895046189427376, + 0.09354028105735779, + 0.06503879278898239 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054995931684970856 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dawn in a Venetian canal with ancient, crumbling facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone traditional gondola with a black-painted hull visible moving through the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gondolier wearing a blue-and-white striped shirt and a straw hat propelling the gondola with a single oar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a fluid low-angle tracking shot that tilts upward as the gondola approaches a low, arched bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark green wooden shutters on an upper floor shown creaking open while breadcrumbs fall and gray pigeons take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018192220479249954 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018192291259766 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018192220479249954, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018192220479249954, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03981129452586174, + 0.07283683866262436, + 0.07207517325878143, + 0.04911191761493683, + 0.04977311193943024, + 0.08279145509004593, + 0.5104874968528748, + 0.019002573564648628, + 0.04727078229188919, + 0.05683942511677742 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018192220479249954 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set at dawn in a Venetian canal with ancient, crumbling facades?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone traditional gondola with a black-painted hull visible moving through the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a gondolier wearing a blue-and-white striped shirt and a straw hat propelling the gondola with a single oar?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a fluid low-angle tracking shot that tilts upward as the gondola approaches a low, arched bridge?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are dark green wooden shutters on an upper floor shown creaking open while breadcrumbs fall and gray pigeons take flight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20160531997680664 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016053199768066 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20160531997680664, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20160531997680664, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11062702536582947, + 0.07899117469787598, + 0.03622331842780113, + 0.08343946933746338, + 0.07501840591430664, + 0.10284533351659775, + 0.23086883127689362, + 0.04473128169775009, + 0.08741148561239243, + 0.14984369277954102 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20160531997680664 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_14/index_tensor([3196, 3196])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_14/index_tensor([3196, 3196])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6aaf973a7c8179b3a033b8044f496fdb483cc353 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_14/index_tensor([3196, 3196])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a photorealistic documentary-style scene, a gently shaky, handheld, close-up tracking shot follows a rare black stork as it stands gracefully on one leg on a shallow riverbank strewn with smooth pebbles and moist mud. Its long, bright red beak stands out against the bright afternoon sun, its jet-black feathers covering its body, its posture erect and majestic. The clear river flows slowly in the background, reflecting the shimmering waters and creating a tranquil natural scene alongside the lush green reeds on the opposite bank. Suddenly, the black stork seemed to feel a certain call. It first bent its body slightly to gather strength, and then in an instant, it suddenly and smoothly spread its huge wings. The camera captured the ultimate details at this moment: the wide wingspan almost filled the entire screen, and each individual flight feather was clearly visible. Under the direct sunlight, these feathers were not pure black, but had a deep, almost purple-green metallic luster, flickering, full of amazing power and beauty of life. The whole process was truly recorded in the slight breathing of the handheld lens, creating an atmosphere of concentration and awe as if holding your breath and witnessing the miracle of nature with your own eyes.", + "seed": 6404, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_14/index_3196_seed_6404_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.2502614680677652, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2502614680677652, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2502614680677652, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black stork standing on one leg?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a shallow riverbank with smooth pebbles and moist mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stork spread its huge wings suddenly and smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the stork's feathers show a deep purple-green metallic luster under sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a gentle shake and close-up framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06292963027954102 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812929630279541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06292963027954102, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06292963027954102, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6194462776184082, + 0.04218731075525284, + 0.048799335956573486, + 0.014279386028647423, + 0.0591600239276886, + 0.03996254503726959, + 0.06646464020013809, + 0.02436242438852787, + 0.042543500661849976, + 0.04279453679919243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06292963027954102 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black stork standing on one leg?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a shallow riverbank with smooth pebbles and moist mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stork spread its huge wings suddenly and smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the stork's feathers show a deep purple-green metallic luster under sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a gentle shake and close-up framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026343176141381264 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513431072235107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026343176141381264, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026343176141381264, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5517627000808716, + 0.08447859436273575, + 0.08825051039457321, + 0.06124158576130867, + 0.045282717794179916, + 0.021184252575039864, + 0.03474932163953781, + 0.056121110916137695, + 0.038004618138074875, + 0.018924564123153687 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026343176141381264 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black stork standing on one leg?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a shallow riverbank with smooth pebbles and moist mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stork spread its huge wings suddenly and smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the stork's feathers show a deep purple-green metallic luster under sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a gentle shake and close-up framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811956197023392 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881195545196533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811956197023392, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811956197023392, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5820078253746033, + 0.033303819596767426, + 0.025741951540112495, + 0.02233324572443962, + 0.09283317625522614, + 0.016696365550160408, + 0.0740068107843399, + 0.06913585215806961, + 0.07043120265007019, + 0.013509753160178661 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811956197023392 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black stork standing on one leg?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a shallow riverbank with smooth pebbles and moist mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stork spread its huge wings suddenly and smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the stork's feathers show a deep purple-green metallic luster under sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a gentle shake and close-up framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002581655979156 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.69502592086792 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002581655979156, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002581655979156, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5815183520317078, + 0.07604533433914185, + 0.08694804459810257, + 0.03290862217545509, + 0.03856118395924568, + 0.055094704031944275, + 0.022920625284314156, + 0.03314337506890297, + 0.05469713732600212, + 0.018162542954087257 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002581655979156 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black stork standing on one leg?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a shallow riverbank with smooth pebbles and moist mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stork spread its huge wings suddenly and smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the stork's feathers show a deep purple-green metallic luster under sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a gentle shake and close-up framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0538891553878784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4288891553878784 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0538891553878784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0538891553878784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7418269515037537, + 0.034128524363040924, + 0.02990635856986046, + 0.02834511734545231, + 0.046508580446243286, + 0.02183576673269272, + 0.026206938549876213, + 0.02397407963871956, + 0.030517220497131348, + 0.016750454902648926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0538891553878784 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a photorealistic documentary-style scene, a gently shaky, handheld, close-up tracking shot follows a rare black stork as it stands gracefully on one leg on a shallow riverbank strewn with smooth pebbles and moist mud. Its long, bright red beak stands out against the bright afternoon sun, its jet-black feathers covering its body, its posture erect and majestic. The clear river flows slowly in the background, reflecting the shimmering waters and creating a tranquil natural scene alongside the lush green reeds on the opposite bank. Suddenly, the black stork seemed to feel a certain call. It first bent its body slightly to gather strength, and then in an instant, it suddenly and smoothly spread its huge wings. The camera captured the ultimate details at this moment: the wide wingspan almost filled the entire screen, and each individual flight feather was clearly visible. Under the direct sunlight, these feathers were not pure black, but had a deep, almost purple-green metallic luster, flickering, full of amazing power and beauty of life. The whole process was truly recorded in the slight breathing of the handheld lens, creating an atmosphere of concentration and awe as if holding your breath and witnessing the miracle of nature with your own eyes.", + "seed": 6405, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_14/index_3196_seed_6405_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.12437660582363605, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12437660582363605, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12437660582363605, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black stork standing on one leg?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a shallow riverbank with smooth pebbles and moist mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stork spread its huge wings suddenly and smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the stork's feathers show a deep purple-green metallic luster under sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a gentle shake and close-up framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0716666728258133 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.696666717529297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0716666728258133, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0716666728258133, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.326310396194458, + 0.02339455857872963, + 0.05539213865995407, + 0.13320641219615936, + 0.038926564157009125, + 0.0333574116230011, + 0.09423830360174179, + 0.08440016955137253, + 0.13510727882385254, + 0.07566677033901215 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0716666728258133 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black stork standing on one leg?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a shallow riverbank with smooth pebbles and moist mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stork spread its huge wings suddenly and smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the stork's feathers show a deep purple-green metallic luster under sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a gentle shake and close-up framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023289354518055916 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773289442062378 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023289354518055916, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023289354518055916, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16340714693069458, + 0.051691871136426926, + 0.052663739770650864, + 0.12433144450187683, + 0.12641282379627228, + 0.043967410922050476, + 0.11396905779838562, + 0.094349205493927, + 0.08778078109025955, + 0.14142657816410065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023289354518055916 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black stork standing on one leg?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a shallow riverbank with smooth pebbles and moist mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stork spread its huge wings suddenly and smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the stork's feathers show a deep purple-green metallic luster under sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a gentle shake and close-up framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05497957020998001 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299795627593994 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05497957020998001, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05497957020998001, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0836256742477417, + 0.037807244807481766, + 0.03783643618226051, + 0.06326121091842651, + 0.10298100113868713, + 0.06199410557746887, + 0.22272856533527374, + 0.09494486451148987, + 0.17802472412586212, + 0.11679613590240479 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05497957020998001 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black stork standing on one leg?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a shallow riverbank with smooth pebbles and moist mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stork spread its huge wings suddenly and smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the stork's feathers show a deep purple-green metallic luster under sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a gentle shake and close-up framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306533932685852 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168065309524536 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306533932685852, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306533932685852, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11418420076370239, + 0.11148804426193237, + 0.04827931150794029, + 0.06823305040597916, + 0.031561464071273804, + 0.016301780939102173, + 0.15782859921455383, + 0.14513178169727325, + 0.0750594362616539, + 0.23193229734897614 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306533932685852 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black stork standing on one leg?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a shallow riverbank with smooth pebbles and moist mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stork spread its huge wings suddenly and smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the stork's feathers show a deep purple-green metallic luster under sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a gentle shake and close-up framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42888209223747253 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.053882122039795 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42888209223747253, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42888209223747253, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11656864732503891, + 0.04589288681745529, + 0.09875478595495224, + 0.04794628918170929, + 0.09824864566326141, + 0.1305147260427475, + 0.12383532524108887, + 0.056276507675647736, + 0.19017115235328674, + 0.0917910560965538 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42888209223747253 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a photorealistic documentary-style scene, a gently shaky, handheld, close-up tracking shot follows a rare black stork as it stands gracefully on one leg on a shallow riverbank strewn with smooth pebbles and moist mud. Its long, bright red beak stands out against the bright afternoon sun, its jet-black feathers covering its body, its posture erect and majestic. The clear river flows slowly in the background, reflecting the shimmering waters and creating a tranquil natural scene alongside the lush green reeds on the opposite bank. Suddenly, the black stork seemed to feel a certain call. It first bent its body slightly to gather strength, and then in an instant, it suddenly and smoothly spread its huge wings. The camera captured the ultimate details at this moment: the wide wingspan almost filled the entire screen, and each individual flight feather was clearly visible. Under the direct sunlight, these feathers were not pure black, but had a deep, almost purple-green metallic luster, flickering, full of amazing power and beauty of life. The whole process was truly recorded in the slight breathing of the handheld lens, creating an atmosphere of concentration and awe as if holding your breath and witnessing the miracle of nature with your own eyes.", + "seed": 6406, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_14/index_3196_seed_6406_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.23471521064639092, + "vlm_logprob": -0.23471521064639092, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.23471521064639092, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black stork standing on one leg?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a shallow riverbank with smooth pebbles and moist mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stork spread its huge wings suddenly and smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the stork's feathers show a deep purple-green metallic luster under sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a gentle shake and close-up framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20256876945495605 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.702568769454956 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20256876945495605, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20256876945495605, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1084604412317276, + 0.06156880781054497, + 0.19779536128044128, + 0.10977733135223389, + 0.1310173124074936, + 0.0521618127822876, + 0.09898931533098221, + 0.046268101781606674, + 0.0827965959906578, + 0.1111648827791214 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20256876945495605 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black stork standing on one leg?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a shallow riverbank with smooth pebbles and moist mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stork spread its huge wings suddenly and smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the stork's feathers show a deep purple-green metallic luster under sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a gentle shake and close-up framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018186016008257866 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018186092376709 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018186016008257866, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018186016008257866, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.161073699593544, + 0.06911370903253555, + 0.14541403949260712, + 0.06980693340301514, + 0.0926993116736412, + 0.08985462784767151, + 0.042805641889572144, + 0.057977527379989624, + 0.1069745123386383, + 0.1642799973487854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018186016008257866 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black stork standing on one leg?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a shallow riverbank with smooth pebbles and moist mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stork spread its huge wings suddenly and smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the stork's feathers show a deep purple-green metallic luster under sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a gentle shake and close-up framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026370113715529442 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651370048522949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026370113715529442, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026370113715529442, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06214054301381111, + 0.03187508136034012, + 0.07991831749677658, + 0.03155779093503952, + 0.13872766494750977, + 0.08188249170780182, + 0.16114436089992523, + 0.04079569876194, + 0.32410648465156555, + 0.04785158857703209 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026370113715529442 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black stork standing on one leg?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a shallow riverbank with smooth pebbles and moist mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stork spread its huge wings suddenly and smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the stork's feathers show a deep purple-green metallic luster under sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a gentle shake and close-up framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10031754523515701 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503174781799316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10031754523515701, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10031754523515701, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061106979846954346, + 0.03879423066973686, + 0.11987695097923279, + 0.06386619061231613, + 0.2284475862979889, + 0.09413626790046692, + 0.11400391161441803, + 0.09964509308338165, + 0.14586156606674194, + 0.03426123037934303 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10031754523515701 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black stork standing on one leg?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a shallow riverbank with smooth pebbles and moist mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stork spread its huge wings suddenly and smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the stork's feathers show a deep purple-green metallic luster under sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a gentle shake and close-up framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261336088180542 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761336088180542 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8261336088180542, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8261336088180542, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12403780966997147, + 0.057269852608442307, + 0.053807951509952545, + 0.06839488446712494, + 0.112179696559906, + 0.2085622102022171, + 0.10311101377010345, + 0.0452667735517025, + 0.12094982713460922, + 0.10641995817422867 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8261336088180542 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a photorealistic documentary-style scene, a gently shaky, handheld, close-up tracking shot follows a rare black stork as it stands gracefully on one leg on a shallow riverbank strewn with smooth pebbles and moist mud. Its long, bright red beak stands out against the bright afternoon sun, its jet-black feathers covering its body, its posture erect and majestic. The clear river flows slowly in the background, reflecting the shimmering waters and creating a tranquil natural scene alongside the lush green reeds on the opposite bank. Suddenly, the black stork seemed to feel a certain call. It first bent its body slightly to gather strength, and then in an instant, it suddenly and smoothly spread its huge wings. The camera captured the ultimate details at this moment: the wide wingspan almost filled the entire screen, and each individual flight feather was clearly visible. Under the direct sunlight, these feathers were not pure black, but had a deep, almost purple-green metallic luster, flickering, full of amazing power and beauty of life. The whole process was truly recorded in the slight breathing of the handheld lens, creating an atmosphere of concentration and awe as if holding your breath and witnessing the miracle of nature with your own eyes.", + "seed": 6407, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_14/index_3196_seed_6407_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.18001365512609482, + "vlm_logprob": -0.18001365512609482, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.18001365512609482, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black stork standing on one leg?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a shallow riverbank with smooth pebbles and moist mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stork spread its huge wings suddenly and smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the stork's feathers show a deep purple-green metallic luster under sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a gentle shake and close-up framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03112555295228958 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.531125545501709 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03112555295228958, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03112555295228958, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1130743995308876, + 0.06715838611125946, + 0.17435044050216675, + 0.11654038727283478, + 0.10864356905221939, + 0.1220807358622551, + 0.05050535500049591, + 0.18223387002944946, + 0.031245002523064613, + 0.0341678112745285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03112555295228958 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black stork standing on one leg?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a shallow riverbank with smooth pebbles and moist mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stork spread its huge wings suddenly and smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the stork's feathers show a deep purple-green metallic luster under sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a gentle shake and close-up framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634805254638195 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651348114013672 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634805254638195, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634805254638195, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20151355862617493, + 0.041856467723846436, + 0.19326072931289673, + 0.11398543417453766, + 0.05743604898452759, + 0.07926985621452332, + 0.09890451282262802, + 0.09064549207687378, + 0.0698680505156517, + 0.05325984209775925 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634805254638195 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black stork standing on one leg?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a shallow riverbank with smooth pebbles and moist mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stork spread its huge wings suddenly and smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the stork's feathers show a deep purple-green metallic luster under sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a gentle shake and close-up framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02982828952372074 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298283100128174 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02982828952372074, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02982828952372074, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0798267051577568, + 0.0523761548101902, + 0.049821093678474426, + 0.09552596509456635, + 0.04978179931640625, + 0.07292826473712921, + 0.14910297095775604, + 0.2556310296058655, + 0.0807572454214096, + 0.11424881219863892 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02982828952372074 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black stork standing on one leg?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a shallow riverbank with smooth pebbles and moist mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stork spread its huge wings suddenly and smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the stork's feathers show a deep purple-green metallic luster under sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a gentle shake and close-up framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495847016572952 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299585819244385 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495847016572952, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495847016572952, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03707512095570564, + 0.023948442190885544, + 0.037228334695100784, + 0.1595027893781662, + 0.01956918090581894, + 0.0259015504270792, + 0.03729768842458725, + 0.6150911450386047, + 0.020750967785716057, + 0.02363484911620617 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495847016572952 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a black stork standing on one leg?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a shallow riverbank with smooth pebbles and moist mud?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the stork spread its huge wings suddenly and smoothly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the stork's feathers show a deep purple-green metallic luster under sunlight?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot handheld with a gentle shake and close-up framing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578079104423523 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328079104423523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7578079104423523, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7578079104423523, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2105606496334076, + 0.06707440316677094, + 0.277841180562973, + 0.05621645227074623, + 0.07139671593904495, + 0.043674174696207047, + 0.056618768721818924, + 0.12053695321083069, + 0.053350478410720825, + 0.04273029789328575 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7578079104423523 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_15/index_tensor([7965, 7965])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_15/index_tensor([7965, 7965])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ff32c8bb183e795cec2b3b811223de02a524393d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_15/index_tensor([7965, 7965])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from a slightly elevated angle, the camera slowly and steadily tilts downward, following the athlete's movements, as if capturing this powerful moment with bated breath. At the center of the frame is a muscular Asian male athlete with a clean-shaven head, positioned in the center of a heavy black metal squat rack. A soft, broad, diffuse overhead light falls evenly from directly above, precisely outlining the muscles of his face, neck, and shoulders. Beads of sweat drip from his furrowed brow and temples, reflecting highlights on his skin. He wears a dark gray, moisture-wicking sleeveless athletic tank top, clinging to his back and shoulders, flexed with exertion, and black, knee-length professional athletic shorts. He carries an Olympic-standard barbell loaded with heavy plates on his shoulders. His lips pursed, his gaze fixed firmly on a point in the void ahead. Steadily and deliberately, he bends his knees, his core braced, and descends with textbook form. The background is a modern gym with an industrial style. You can see neatly arranged dumbbell racks and the blurry figures of other fitness enthusiasts in the distance. The whole picture has a cold tone, mainly dark gray and black, creating an interview atmosphere of extreme focus, full of power and static beauty.", + "seed": 13042, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_15/index_7965_seed_13042_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.02009865576401353, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02009865576401353, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02009865576401353, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a muscular Asian male athlete with a clean-shaven head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray sleeveless tank top and black knee-length athletic shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete performing a squatting motion with an Olympic-standard barbell loaded with heavy plates on his shoulders?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern gym with an industrial style featuring dumbbell racks and blurry figures in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward while maintaining a medium shot from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016567861661314964 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141567707061768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016567861661314964, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016567861661314964, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09966570883989334, + 0.016001923009753227, + 0.03292915225028992, + 0.047106292098760605, + 0.044910531491041183, + 0.017645232379436493, + 0.045044999569654465, + 0.6063244938850403, + 0.04813152551651001, + 0.04224023595452309 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016567861661314964 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a muscular Asian male athlete with a clean-shaven head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray sleeveless tank top and black knee-length athletic shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete performing a squatting motion with an Olympic-standard barbell loaded with heavy plates on his shoulders?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern gym with an industrial style featuring dumbbell racks and blurry figures in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward while maintaining a medium shot from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006744714453816414 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006744861602783 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006744714453816414, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006744714453816414, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.024451252073049545, + 0.013307535089552402, + 0.013384005054831505, + 0.012075898237526417, + 0.010583795607089996, + 0.018196864053606987, + 0.07351639121770859, + 0.7268998622894287, + 0.08684974163770676, + 0.02073460817337036 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006744714453816414 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a muscular Asian male athlete with a clean-shaven head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray sleeveless tank top and black knee-length athletic shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete performing a squatting motion with an Olympic-standard barbell loaded with heavy plates on his shoulders?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern gym with an industrial style featuring dumbbell racks and blurry figures in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward while maintaining a medium shot from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01106967218220234 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110697746276855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01106967218220234, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01106967218220234, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.028441736474633217, + 0.019858747720718384, + 0.31972676515579224, + 0.02611810714006424, + 0.019466418772935867, + 0.02980975992977619, + 0.06833407282829285, + 0.3489958643913269, + 0.10851556807756424, + 0.030732914805412292 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01106967218220234 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a muscular Asian male athlete with a clean-shaven head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray sleeveless tank top and black knee-length athletic shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete performing a squatting motion with an Olympic-standard barbell loaded with heavy plates on his shoulders?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern gym with an industrial style featuring dumbbell racks and blurry figures in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward while maintaining a medium shot from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004092770162969828 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504092693328857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004092770162969828, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004092770162969828, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12860207259655, + 0.06619439274072647, + 0.0937308669090271, + 0.06945502758026123, + 0.03397136181592941, + 0.16833294928073883, + 0.1264297515153885, + 0.03055584989488125, + 0.152935191988945, + 0.12979255616664886 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004092770162969828 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a muscular Asian male athlete with a clean-shaven head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray sleeveless tank top and black knee-length athletic shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete performing a squatting motion with an Olympic-standard barbell loaded with heavy plates on his shoulders?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern gym with an industrial style featuring dumbbell racks and blurry figures in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward while maintaining a medium shot from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620182603597641 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120181560516357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620182603597641, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620182603597641, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.024152986705303192, + 0.008996046148240566, + 0.007554343901574612, + 0.035047631710767746, + 0.010783212259411812, + 0.018764300271868706, + 0.02827155403792858, + 0.7483393549919128, + 0.07539376616477966, + 0.0426967516541481 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620182603597641 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from a slightly elevated angle, the camera slowly and steadily tilts downward, following the athlete's movements, as if capturing this powerful moment with bated breath. At the center of the frame is a muscular Asian male athlete with a clean-shaven head, positioned in the center of a heavy black metal squat rack. A soft, broad, diffuse overhead light falls evenly from directly above, precisely outlining the muscles of his face, neck, and shoulders. Beads of sweat drip from his furrowed brow and temples, reflecting highlights on his skin. He wears a dark gray, moisture-wicking sleeveless athletic tank top, clinging to his back and shoulders, flexed with exertion, and black, knee-length professional athletic shorts. He carries an Olympic-standard barbell loaded with heavy plates on his shoulders. His lips pursed, his gaze fixed firmly on a point in the void ahead. Steadily and deliberately, he bends his knees, his core braced, and descends with textbook form. The background is a modern gym with an industrial style. You can see neatly arranged dumbbell racks and the blurry figures of other fitness enthusiasts in the distance. The whole picture has a cold tone, mainly dark gray and black, creating an interview atmosphere of extreme focus, full of power and static beauty.", + "seed": 13043, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_15/index_7965_seed_13043_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.017338904552161694, + "vlm_logprob": -0.017338904552161694, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.017338904552161694, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a muscular Asian male athlete with a clean-shaven head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray sleeveless tank top and black knee-length athletic shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete performing a squatting motion with an Olympic-standard barbell loaded with heavy plates on his shoulders?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern gym with an industrial style featuring dumbbell racks and blurry figures in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward while maintaining a medium shot from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.030246248468756676 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5302462577819824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.030246248468756676, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.030246248468756676, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03291831910610199, + 0.016504580155014992, + 0.6640800833702087, + 0.017370307818055153, + 0.007968487218022346, + 0.14808623492717743, + 0.011377246119081974, + 0.019668465480208397, + 0.027330895885825157, + 0.054695405066013336 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.030246248468756676 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a muscular Asian male athlete with a clean-shaven head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray sleeveless tank top and black knee-length athletic shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete performing a squatting motion with an Olympic-standard barbell loaded with heavy plates on his shoulders?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern gym with an industrial style featuring dumbbell racks and blurry figures in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward while maintaining a medium shot from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031989850103855133 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753199100494385 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031989850103855133, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031989850103855133, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04535997286438942, + 0.027227355167269707, + 0.45452675223350525, + 0.05407198518514633, + 0.017688637599349022, + 0.09096524864435196, + 0.04368187487125397, + 0.07301180064678192, + 0.10504721105098724, + 0.08841913193464279 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031989850103855133 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a muscular Asian male athlete with a clean-shaven head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray sleeveless tank top and black knee-length athletic shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete performing a squatting motion with an Olympic-standard barbell loaded with heavy plates on his shoulders?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern gym with an industrial style featuring dumbbell racks and blurry figures in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward while maintaining a medium shot from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011072265915572643 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511072158813477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011072265915572643, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011072265915572643, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06214866042137146, + 0.025011597201228142, + 0.12325344234704971, + 0.06069176644086838, + 0.052233610302209854, + 0.17325042188167572, + 0.05087660625576973, + 0.1831008493900299, + 0.17840248346328735, + 0.09103047847747803 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011072265915572643 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a muscular Asian male athlete with a clean-shaven head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray sleeveless tank top and black knee-length athletic shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete performing a squatting motion with an Olympic-standard barbell loaded with heavy plates on his shoulders?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern gym with an industrial style featuring dumbbell racks and blurry figures in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward while maintaining a medium shot from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004093838855624199 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504093647003174 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004093838855624199, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004093838855624199, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.022371619939804077, + 0.03201863914728165, + 0.2963908910751343, + 0.03487309813499451, + 0.01454398687928915, + 0.12165874242782593, + 0.051670778542757034, + 0.2964170277118683, + 0.06579137593507767, + 0.06426388770341873 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004093838855624199 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a muscular Asian male athlete with a clean-shaven head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray sleeveless tank top and black knee-length athletic shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete performing a squatting motion with an Olympic-standard barbell loaded with heavy plates on his shoulders?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern gym with an industrial style featuring dumbbell racks and blurry figures in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward while maintaining a medium shot from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03808318451046944 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288083076477051 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03808318451046944, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03808318451046944, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02702852338552475, + 0.025367215275764465, + 0.23101788759231567, + 0.03350164368748665, + 0.04628240317106247, + 0.08077464252710342, + 0.12804783880710602, + 0.1437438428401947, + 0.1909913271665573, + 0.09324467182159424 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03808318451046944 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from a slightly elevated angle, the camera slowly and steadily tilts downward, following the athlete's movements, as if capturing this powerful moment with bated breath. At the center of the frame is a muscular Asian male athlete with a clean-shaven head, positioned in the center of a heavy black metal squat rack. A soft, broad, diffuse overhead light falls evenly from directly above, precisely outlining the muscles of his face, neck, and shoulders. Beads of sweat drip from his furrowed brow and temples, reflecting highlights on his skin. He wears a dark gray, moisture-wicking sleeveless athletic tank top, clinging to his back and shoulders, flexed with exertion, and black, knee-length professional athletic shorts. He carries an Olympic-standard barbell loaded with heavy plates on his shoulders. His lips pursed, his gaze fixed firmly on a point in the void ahead. Steadily and deliberately, he bends his knees, his core braced, and descends with textbook form. The background is a modern gym with an industrial style. You can see neatly arranged dumbbell racks and the blurry figures of other fitness enthusiasts in the distance. The whole picture has a cold tone, mainly dark gray and black, creating an interview atmosphere of extreme focus, full of power and static beauty.", + "seed": 13044, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_15/index_7965_seed_13044_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.020391090866178276, + "vlm_logprob": -0.020391090866178276, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.020391090866178276, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a muscular Asian male athlete with a clean-shaven head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray sleeveless tank top and black knee-length athletic shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete performing a squatting motion with an Olympic-standard barbell loaded with heavy plates on his shoulders?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern gym with an industrial style featuring dumbbell racks and blurry figures in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward while maintaining a medium shot from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026740308851003647 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651740312576294 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026740308851003647, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026740308851003647, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20145563781261444, + 0.19465352594852448, + 0.10013609379529953, + 0.181810200214386, + 0.13774043321609497, + 0.04528699070215225, + 0.037195321172475815, + 0.03697551414370537, + 0.025028739124536514, + 0.03971753269433975 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026740308851003647 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a muscular Asian male athlete with a clean-shaven head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray sleeveless tank top and black knee-length athletic shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete performing a squatting motion with an Olympic-standard barbell loaded with heavy plates on his shoulders?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern gym with an industrial style featuring dumbbell racks and blurry figures in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward while maintaining a medium shot from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005259249359369278 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255259037017822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005259249359369278, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005259249359369278, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20381075143814087, + 0.16973473131656647, + 0.050109222531318665, + 0.06805869191884995, + 0.09518328309059143, + 0.07082197815179825, + 0.05461793765425682, + 0.21263232827186584, + 0.04213780537247658, + 0.03289327397942543 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005259249359369278 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a muscular Asian male athlete with a clean-shaven head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray sleeveless tank top and black knee-length athletic shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete performing a squatting motion with an Olympic-standard barbell loaded with heavy plates on his shoulders?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern gym with an industrial style featuring dumbbell racks and blurry figures in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward while maintaining a medium shot from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009776213206350803 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347761154174805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009776213206350803, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009776213206350803, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09928317368030548, + 0.14335960149765015, + 0.0750664621591568, + 0.08325956761837006, + 0.08441182971000671, + 0.08556012064218521, + 0.11006130278110504, + 0.1872519552707672, + 0.07812320441007614, + 0.0536227785050869 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009776213206350803 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a muscular Asian male athlete with a clean-shaven head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray sleeveless tank top and black knee-length athletic shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete performing a squatting motion with an Olympic-standard barbell loaded with heavy plates on his shoulders?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern gym with an industrial style featuring dumbbell racks and blurry figures in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward while maintaining a medium shot from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005249644163995981 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255249500274658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005249644163995981, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005249644163995981, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08585666865110397, + 0.1904822587966919, + 0.27975592017173767, + 0.16038867831230164, + 0.06510594487190247, + 0.017036134377121925, + 0.10314156115055084, + 0.04493439942598343, + 0.031683873385190964, + 0.021614598110318184 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005249644163995981 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a muscular Asian male athlete with a clean-shaven head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray sleeveless tank top and black knee-length athletic shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete performing a squatting motion with an Olympic-standard barbell loaded with heavy plates on his shoulders?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern gym with an industrial style featuring dumbbell racks and blurry figures in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward while maintaining a medium shot from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05493003875017166 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299299716949463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05493003875017166, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05493003875017166, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16423778235912323, + 0.0327799953520298, + 0.17551103234291077, + 0.10316424071788788, + 0.18641068041324615, + 0.05781262740492821, + 0.07750042527914047, + 0.1590656340122223, + 0.027182115241885185, + 0.01633547618985176 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05493003875017166 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, shot from a slightly elevated angle, the camera slowly and steadily tilts downward, following the athlete's movements, as if capturing this powerful moment with bated breath. At the center of the frame is a muscular Asian male athlete with a clean-shaven head, positioned in the center of a heavy black metal squat rack. A soft, broad, diffuse overhead light falls evenly from directly above, precisely outlining the muscles of his face, neck, and shoulders. Beads of sweat drip from his furrowed brow and temples, reflecting highlights on his skin. He wears a dark gray, moisture-wicking sleeveless athletic tank top, clinging to his back and shoulders, flexed with exertion, and black, knee-length professional athletic shorts. He carries an Olympic-standard barbell loaded with heavy plates on his shoulders. His lips pursed, his gaze fixed firmly on a point in the void ahead. Steadily and deliberately, he bends his knees, his core braced, and descends with textbook form. The background is a modern gym with an industrial style. You can see neatly arranged dumbbell racks and the blurry figures of other fitness enthusiasts in the distance. The whole picture has a cold tone, mainly dark gray and black, creating an interview atmosphere of extreme focus, full of power and static beauty.", + "seed": 13045, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_15/index_7965_seed_13045_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04104759497568011, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04104759497568011, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04104759497568011, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a muscular Asian male athlete with a clean-shaven head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray sleeveless tank top and black knee-length athletic shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete performing a squatting motion with an Olympic-standard barbell loaded with heavy plates on his shoulders?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern gym with an industrial style featuring dumbbell racks and blurry figures in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward while maintaining a medium shot from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043867964297533035 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168868064880371 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043867964297533035, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043867964297533035, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2540995478630066, + 0.14428330957889557, + 0.051485996693372726, + 0.07018942385911942, + 0.051990993320941925, + 0.10080814361572266, + 0.09578892588615417, + 0.07167942076921463, + 0.10601361095905304, + 0.05366067215800285 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043867964297533035 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a muscular Asian male athlete with a clean-shaven head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray sleeveless tank top and black knee-length athletic shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete performing a squatting motion with an Olympic-standard barbell loaded with heavy plates on his shoulders?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern gym with an industrial style featuring dumbbell racks and blurry figures in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward while maintaining a medium shot from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014209873043000698 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264209747314453 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014209873043000698, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014209873043000698, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1662812978029251, + 0.11211715638637543, + 0.04306325688958168, + 0.038046304136514664, + 0.02750900201499462, + 0.06385403126478195, + 0.19390743970870972, + 0.10681726038455963, + 0.20158536732196808, + 0.046818967908620834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014209873043000698 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a muscular Asian male athlete with a clean-shaven head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray sleeveless tank top and black knee-length athletic shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete performing a squatting motion with an Olympic-standard barbell loaded with heavy plates on his shoulders?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern gym with an industrial style featuring dumbbell racks and blurry figures in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward while maintaining a medium shot from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606203243136406 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141062259674072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606203243136406, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606203243136406, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1731199324131012, + 0.16090652346611023, + 0.04462526738643646, + 0.04697487875819206, + 0.044995397329330444, + 0.08356829732656479, + 0.19354566931724548, + 0.06992490589618683, + 0.10778352618217468, + 0.07455567270517349 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606203243136406 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a muscular Asian male athlete with a clean-shaven head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray sleeveless tank top and black knee-length athletic shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete performing a squatting motion with an Olympic-standard barbell loaded with heavy plates on his shoulders?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern gym with an industrial style featuring dumbbell racks and blurry figures in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward while maintaining a medium shot from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040937201119959354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504093647003174 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040937201119959354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040937201119959354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1518443524837494, + 0.11570978164672852, + 0.05228825658559799, + 0.07118620723485947, + 0.036219120025634766, + 0.12696543335914612, + 0.07687592506408691, + 0.1735781729221344, + 0.10629894584417343, + 0.0890338271856308 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040937201119959354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a muscular Asian male athlete with a clean-shaven head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete wearing a dark gray sleeveless tank top and black knee-length athletic shorts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the athlete performing a squatting motion with an Olympic-standard barbell loaded with heavy plates on his shoulders?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a modern gym with an industrial style featuring dumbbell racks and blurry figures in the distance?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and steadily tilt downward while maintaining a medium shot from a slightly elevated angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12700438499450684 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127004384994507 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12700438499450684, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12700438499450684, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.060436543077230453, + 0.19469130039215088, + 0.09884648025035858, + 0.05815688148140907, + 0.031623922288417816, + 0.13134680688381195, + 0.14017629623413086, + 0.12913230061531067, + 0.08067750185728073, + 0.07491190731525421 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12700438499450684 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_2/index_tensor([1167, 1167])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_2/index_tensor([1167, 1167])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bfddc132f990957f7260e1297d58294310c86313 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_2/index_tensor([1167, 1167])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, close-up macro shot transports the viewer into the inner workings of a fine watch. Under a bright, focused, cold light, layers of golden gears of varying sizes, gleaming with a warm metallic sheen, form a complex and orderly maze of microscopic mechanics. Several crystalline, pigeon-blood-colored ruby bearings, precisely set into a bridge adorned with Geneva waves, contrast strikingly with the pale blued screws. At the focal point, a central gear engages in a silent and precise mechanical ballet. Its sharp, smooth teeth mesh seamlessly with the adjacent gears, rotating smoothly and unimpeded in a steady, deliberate rhythm. The gear's axis rotates virtually frictionlessly within the ruby bearing, driving the entire complex transmission system in coordinated operation. Light reflects dazzling highlights on the polished metal surface, while casting deep and sharp shadows between the layered structures, highlighting the three-dimensionality and ultimate craftsmanship of each tiny component. The whole picture is full of tranquility, concentration and mechanical beauty, creating a magnificent atmosphere of the eternal passage of time under precise control.", + "seed": 31850, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_2/index_1167_seed_31850_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.655806809477508, + "vlm_logprob": -0.655806809477508, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.655806809477508, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, close-up macro view of a watch's internal mechanics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are golden gears of varying sizes visible with a warm metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are crystalline, pigeon-blood-colored ruby bearings visible set into a bridge with Geneva waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a central gear visible rotating smoothly and meshing with adjacent gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, focused, and cold, creating deep shadows on the metal surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019535403698682785 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.019535541534424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019535403698682785, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019535403698682785, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10360419750213623, + 0.29815077781677246, + 0.2862282991409302, + 0.05284878984093666, + 0.0638887956738472, + 0.039957333356142044, + 0.041935380548238754, + 0.04009554535150528, + 0.04662773385643959, + 0.026663141325116158 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019535403698682785 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, close-up macro view of a watch's internal mechanics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are golden gears of varying sizes visible with a warm metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are crystalline, pigeon-blood-colored ruby bearings visible set into a bridge with Geneva waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a central gear visible rotating smoothly and meshing with adjacent gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, focused, and cold, creating deep shadows on the metal surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005279527045786381 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255279541015625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005279527045786381, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005279527045786381, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22063587605953217, + 0.20140521228313446, + 0.17074212431907654, + 0.03670414164662361, + 0.1670074313879013, + 0.06090860441327095, + 0.045274052768945694, + 0.040286485105752945, + 0.028159093111753464, + 0.028876952826976776 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005279527045786381 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, close-up macro view of a watch's internal mechanics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are golden gears of varying sizes visible with a warm metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are crystalline, pigeon-blood-colored ruby bearings visible set into a bridge with Geneva waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a central gear visible rotating smoothly and meshing with adjacent gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, focused, and cold, creating deep shadows on the metal surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07006916403770447 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950690746307373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07006916403770447, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07006916403770447, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1788697987794876, + 0.13038484752178192, + 0.2505130469799042, + 0.03472604230046272, + 0.16182930767536163, + 0.05768765136599541, + 0.039458051323890686, + 0.03782551363110542, + 0.05024087801575661, + 0.05846488103270531 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07006916403770447 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, close-up macro view of a watch's internal mechanics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are golden gears of varying sizes visible with a warm metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are crystalline, pigeon-blood-colored ruby bearings visible set into a bridge with Geneva waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a central gear visible rotating smoothly and meshing with adjacent gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, focused, and cold, creating deep shadows on the metal surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016086550429463387 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141086578369141 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016086550429463387, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016086550429463387, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.331857293844223, + 0.23346607387065887, + 0.053121887147426605, + 0.06745228916406631, + 0.10737626999616623, + 0.08083104342222214, + 0.026255061849951744, + 0.041900038719177246, + 0.02510189637541771, + 0.03263818100094795 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016086550429463387 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, close-up macro view of a watch's internal mechanics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are golden gears of varying sizes visible with a warm metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are crystalline, pigeon-blood-colored ruby bearings visible set into a bridge with Geneva waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a central gear visible rotating smoothly and meshing with adjacent gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, focused, and cold, creating deep shadows on the metal surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680634021759033 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306328669190407 + ], + "logprob_reward": -3.1680634021759033, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -3.1680634021759033, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.47661837935447693, + 0.2591571509838104, + 0.05520385876297951, + 0.04374174028635025, + 0.05297959968447685, + 0.027627190575003624, + 0.021790798753499985, + 0.01778491958975792, + 0.02015719935297966, + 0.024939190596342087 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -3.1680634021759033 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, close-up macro shot transports the viewer into the inner workings of a fine watch. Under a bright, focused, cold light, layers of golden gears of varying sizes, gleaming with a warm metallic sheen, form a complex and orderly maze of microscopic mechanics. Several crystalline, pigeon-blood-colored ruby bearings, precisely set into a bridge adorned with Geneva waves, contrast strikingly with the pale blued screws. At the focal point, a central gear engages in a silent and precise mechanical ballet. Its sharp, smooth teeth mesh seamlessly with the adjacent gears, rotating smoothly and unimpeded in a steady, deliberate rhythm. The gear's axis rotates virtually frictionlessly within the ruby bearing, driving the entire complex transmission system in coordinated operation. Light reflects dazzling highlights on the polished metal surface, while casting deep and sharp shadows between the layered structures, highlighting the three-dimensionality and ultimate craftsmanship of each tiny component. The whole picture is full of tranquility, concentration and mechanical beauty, creating a magnificent atmosphere of the eternal passage of time under precise control.", + "seed": 31851, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_2/index_1167_seed_31851_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.7650418111705222, + "vlm_logprob": -0.7650418111705222, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.7650418111705222, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, close-up macro view of a watch's internal mechanics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are golden gears of varying sizes visible with a warm metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are crystalline, pigeon-blood-colored ruby bearings visible set into a bridge with Geneva waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a central gear visible rotating smoothly and meshing with adjacent gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, focused, and cold, creating deep shadows on the metal surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01639162003993988 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.266391754150391 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01639162003993988, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01639162003993988, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.45374035835266113, + 0.15064789354801178, + 0.042642563581466675, + 0.07665702700614929, + 0.043118853121995926, + 0.07876943051815033, + 0.039515603333711624, + 0.03243738040328026, + 0.03294379264116287, + 0.04952714964747429 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01639162003993988 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, close-up macro view of a watch's internal mechanics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are golden gears of varying sizes visible with a warm metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are crystalline, pigeon-blood-colored ruby bearings visible set into a bridge with Geneva waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a central gear visible rotating smoothly and meshing with adjacent gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, focused, and cold, creating deep shadows on the metal surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0007313199457712471 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.250731468200684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0007313199457712471, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0007313199457712471, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19049786031246185, + 0.12056552618741989, + 0.19922225177288055, + 0.053910333663225174, + 0.03868826851248741, + 0.06197009235620499, + 0.08397020399570465, + 0.06677133589982986, + 0.07639120519161224, + 0.10801292210817337 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0007313199457712471 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, close-up macro view of a watch's internal mechanics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are golden gears of varying sizes visible with a warm metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are crystalline, pigeon-blood-colored ruby bearings visible set into a bridge with Geneva waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a central gear visible rotating smoothly and meshing with adjacent gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, focused, and cold, creating deep shadows on the metal surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014213869348168373 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264214038848877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014213869348168373, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014213869348168373, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2217867225408554, + 0.12855292856693268, + 0.10206211358308792, + 0.24136535823345184, + 0.06459934264421463, + 0.04161566123366356, + 0.047357674688100815, + 0.04123114421963692, + 0.05630982667207718, + 0.05511917173862457 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014213869348168373 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, close-up macro view of a watch's internal mechanics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are golden gears of varying sizes visible with a warm metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are crystalline, pigeon-blood-colored ruby bearings visible set into a bridge with Geneva waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a central gear visible rotating smoothly and meshing with adjacent gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, focused, and cold, creating deep shadows on the metal surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020592818036675453 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955929279327393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020592818036675453, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020592818036675453, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21724404394626617, + 0.12245035916566849, + 0.14794351160526276, + 0.11496315896511078, + 0.09657678008079529, + 0.06336206942796707, + 0.04636885225772858, + 0.05602000653743744, + 0.08426976203918457, + 0.05080148205161095 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020592818036675453 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, close-up macro view of a watch's internal mechanics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are golden gears of varying sizes visible with a warm metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are crystalline, pigeon-blood-colored ruby bearings visible set into a bridge with Geneva waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a central gear visible rotating smoothly and meshing with adjacent gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, focused, and cold, creating deep shadows on the metal surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732794284820557 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0232793390750885 + ], + "logprob_reward": -3.7732794284820557, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -3.7732794284820557, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22003969550132751, + 0.1834624856710434, + 0.17103789746761322, + 0.09048201143741608, + 0.11438104510307312, + 0.07105602324008942, + 0.02626735158264637, + 0.029609080404043198, + 0.02866961807012558, + 0.06499481946229935 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -3.7732794284820557 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, close-up macro shot transports the viewer into the inner workings of a fine watch. Under a bright, focused, cold light, layers of golden gears of varying sizes, gleaming with a warm metallic sheen, form a complex and orderly maze of microscopic mechanics. Several crystalline, pigeon-blood-colored ruby bearings, precisely set into a bridge adorned with Geneva waves, contrast strikingly with the pale blued screws. At the focal point, a central gear engages in a silent and precise mechanical ballet. Its sharp, smooth teeth mesh seamlessly with the adjacent gears, rotating smoothly and unimpeded in a steady, deliberate rhythm. The gear's axis rotates virtually frictionlessly within the ruby bearing, driving the entire complex transmission system in coordinated operation. Light reflects dazzling highlights on the polished metal surface, while casting deep and sharp shadows between the layered structures, highlighting the three-dimensionality and ultimate craftsmanship of each tiny component. The whole picture is full of tranquility, concentration and mechanical beauty, creating a magnificent atmosphere of the eternal passage of time under precise control.", + "seed": 31852, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_2/index_1167_seed_31852_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.6674869659123942, + "vlm_logprob": -0.6674869659123942, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.6674869659123942, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, close-up macro view of a watch's internal mechanics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are golden gears of varying sizes visible with a warm metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are crystalline, pigeon-blood-colored ruby bearings visible set into a bridge with Geneva waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a central gear visible rotating smoothly and meshing with adjacent gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, focused, and cold, creating deep shadows on the metal surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012601629830896854 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.637601852416992 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012601629830896854, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012601629830896854, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18679900467395782, + 0.048616524785757065, + 0.12249390035867691, + 0.08259515464305878, + 0.040621284395456314, + 0.05786455050110817, + 0.062005721032619476, + 0.1209758073091507, + 0.10282281786203384, + 0.175205260515213 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012601629830896854 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, close-up macro view of a watch's internal mechanics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are golden gears of varying sizes visible with a warm metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are crystalline, pigeon-blood-colored ruby bearings visible set into a bridge with Geneva waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a central gear visible rotating smoothly and meshing with adjacent gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, focused, and cold, creating deep shadows on the metal surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00173049361910671 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376730442047119 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00173049361910671, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00173049361910671, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1830829679965973, + 0.17443491518497467, + 0.03374144807457924, + 0.05787712708115578, + 0.07219675928354263, + 0.01740274950861931, + 0.06585398316383362, + 0.1547299027442932, + 0.08281095325946808, + 0.1578691452741623 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00173049361910671 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, close-up macro view of a watch's internal mechanics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are golden gears of varying sizes visible with a warm metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are crystalline, pigeon-blood-colored ruby bearings visible set into a bridge with Geneva waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a central gear visible rotating smoothly and meshing with adjacent gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, focused, and cold, creating deep shadows on the metal surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008652458898723125 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758652687072754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008652458898723125, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008652458898723125, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21282179653644562, + 0.2771814465522766, + 0.12634317576885223, + 0.060485661029815674, + 0.03337599337100983, + 0.020587872713804245, + 0.04942872375249863, + 0.08683210611343384, + 0.06379998475313187, + 0.06914317607879639 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008652458898723125 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, close-up macro view of a watch's internal mechanics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are golden gears of varying sizes visible with a warm metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are crystalline, pigeon-blood-colored ruby bearings visible set into a bridge with Geneva waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a central gear visible rotating smoothly and meshing with adjacent gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, focused, and cold, creating deep shadows on the metal surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02635977976024151 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651359796524048 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02635977976024151, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02635977976024151, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11819438636302948, + 0.20927175879478455, + 0.12361031025648117, + 0.08829256892204285, + 0.09957174956798553, + 0.03537709265947342, + 0.06991949677467346, + 0.06272613257169724, + 0.07409348338842392, + 0.11894302815198898 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02635977976024151 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, close-up macro view of a watch's internal mechanics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are golden gears of varying sizes visible with a warm metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are crystalline, pigeon-blood-colored ruby bearings visible set into a bridge with Geneva waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a central gear visible rotating smoothly and meshing with adjacent gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, focused, and cold, creating deep shadows on the metal surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288090467453003 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809041529893875 + ], + "logprob_reward": -3.288090467453003, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -3.288090467453003, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3486889600753784, + 0.0504012405872345, + 0.05956311151385307, + 0.04210689663887024, + 0.04169617220759392, + 0.04398982971906662, + 0.029732676222920418, + 0.09991209954023361, + 0.06075708568096161, + 0.22315198183059692 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -3.288090467453003 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, close-up macro shot transports the viewer into the inner workings of a fine watch. Under a bright, focused, cold light, layers of golden gears of varying sizes, gleaming with a warm metallic sheen, form a complex and orderly maze of microscopic mechanics. Several crystalline, pigeon-blood-colored ruby bearings, precisely set into a bridge adorned with Geneva waves, contrast strikingly with the pale blued screws. At the focal point, a central gear engages in a silent and precise mechanical ballet. Its sharp, smooth teeth mesh seamlessly with the adjacent gears, rotating smoothly and unimpeded in a steady, deliberate rhythm. The gear's axis rotates virtually frictionlessly within the ruby bearing, driving the entire complex transmission system in coordinated operation. Light reflects dazzling highlights on the polished metal surface, while casting deep and sharp shadows between the layered structures, highlighting the three-dimensionality and ultimate craftsmanship of each tiny component. The whole picture is full of tranquility, concentration and mechanical beauty, creating a magnificent atmosphere of the eternal passage of time under precise control.", + "seed": 31853, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_2/index_1167_seed_31853_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.6178600655402988, + "vlm_logprob": -0.6178600655402988, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.6178600655402988, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, close-up macro view of a watch's internal mechanics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are golden gears of varying sizes visible with a warm metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are crystalline, pigeon-blood-colored ruby bearings visible set into a bridge with Geneva waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a central gear visible rotating smoothly and meshing with adjacent gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, focused, and cold, creating deep shadows on the metal surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.013396958820521832 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.638396739959717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.013396958820521832, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.013396958820521832, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07285581529140472, + 0.15679945051670074, + 0.0471375547349453, + 0.0338861346244812, + 0.1793632209300995, + 0.05835694074630737, + 0.3151901960372925, + 0.07134242355823517, + 0.039399873465299606, + 0.02566833235323429 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.013396958820521832 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, close-up macro view of a watch's internal mechanics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are golden gears of varying sizes visible with a warm metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are crystalline, pigeon-blood-colored ruby bearings visible set into a bridge with Geneva waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a central gear visible rotating smoothly and meshing with adjacent gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, focused, and cold, creating deep shadows on the metal surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001962641952559352 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251962661743164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001962641952559352, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001962641952559352, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2605878412723541, + 0.14256973564624786, + 0.07069126516580582, + 0.03290209546685219, + 0.25975582003593445, + 0.09431269764900208, + 0.04381681606173515, + 0.040580444037914276, + 0.02525296062231064, + 0.02953033335506916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001962641952559352 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, close-up macro view of a watch's internal mechanics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are golden gears of varying sizes visible with a warm metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are crystalline, pigeon-blood-colored ruby bearings visible set into a bridge with Geneva waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a central gear visible rotating smoothly and meshing with adjacent gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, focused, and cold, creating deep shadows on the metal surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011093368753790855 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110931396484375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011093368753790855, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011093368753790855, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1368579864501953, + 0.3429082930088043, + 0.016215436160564423, + 0.06782510131597519, + 0.20963948965072632, + 0.0658944696187973, + 0.09790569543838501, + 0.02155909687280655, + 0.022922245785593987, + 0.01827220618724823 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011093368753790855 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, close-up macro view of a watch's internal mechanics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are golden gears of varying sizes visible with a warm metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are crystalline, pigeon-blood-colored ruby bearings visible set into a bridge with Geneva waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a central gear visible rotating smoothly and meshing with adjacent gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, focused, and cold, creating deep shadows on the metal surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014203292317688465 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264203071594238 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014203292317688465, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014203292317688465, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15277165174484253, + 0.07407043874263763, + 0.10460785776376724, + 0.06287357956171036, + 0.07195313274860382, + 0.06695084273815155, + 0.1423521339893341, + 0.0734933540225029, + 0.11582190543413162, + 0.13510508835315704 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014203292317688465 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a slow, close-up macro view of a watch's internal mechanics?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are golden gears of varying sizes visible with a warm metallic sheen?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are crystalline, pigeon-blood-colored ruby bearings visible set into a bridge with Geneva waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a central gear visible rotating smoothly and meshing with adjacent gears?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting bright, focused, and cold, creating deep shadows on the metal surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486440658569336 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864410310983658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -3.0486440658569336, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -3.0486440658569336, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08145122230052948, + 0.10312317311763763, + 0.037430454045534134, + 0.05834409222006798, + 0.1669987589120865, + 0.16206099092960358, + 0.12567296624183655, + 0.14566649496555328, + 0.05538219213485718, + 0.06386958062648773 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -3.0486440658569336 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_3/index_tensor([9114, 9114])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_3/index_tensor([9114, 9114])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..59639bafdd4c4af333d77a26481e558f2185b388 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_3/index_tensor([9114, 9114])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a seamless single shot imbued with a dark, mythical quality, a camera begins at an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface of a roaring flood of turbid, swirling black mud and crumbling building debris, slowly zooming upward and backward. The sky is shrouded in thick, inky clouds, illuminated only by streaks of purple lightning that tear through the sky, each flash reflecting an eerie luster on the surging waters below. The focal point is a peacock beast, as massive as a mountain, standing proudly at the center of the apocalyptic torrent. Its feathers, shimmering in metallic deep blue and dark green, each like a sharp blade of obsidian, pierce the air. With an inhuman shriek, a blend of metallic grinding and thunder, its massive, furled tail feathers begin to rise in a majestic, slow rhythm. Then, with a fluidity that defies the laws of physics, the feather fans unfold, layer by layer, to the sides, forming a magnificent barrier that obscures the sky. As each feather stretched, the center of the seemingly decorative golden ring pattern on it suddenly opened, transforming into thousands of evil eyes with vertical pupils flashing an ominous scarlet light and full of malicious intent. These eyes stared down at the world below being swallowed by the flood, releasing an invisible, mind-shattering pressure. The entire picture created an unstoppable, doomsday-like fear in the epic scene of destruction.", + "seed": 7514, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_3/index_9114_seed_7514_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04110394422896206, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04110394422896206, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04110394422896206, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface of the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom upward and backward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a roaring flood of turbid, swirling black mud and crumbling building debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive peacock beast visible at the center of the scene with metallic deep blue and dark green feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the peacock's tail feathers unfold to reveal a golden ring pattern transforming into thousands of evil eyes with vertical pupils flashing scarlet light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11783146113157272 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2428314685821533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11783146113157272, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11783146113157272, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10386624187231064, + 0.1173076406121254, + 0.11550167948007584, + 0.08749078959226608, + 0.07867436110973358, + 0.1390754133462906, + 0.09234713017940521, + 0.12903554737567902, + 0.05199853703379631, + 0.08470271527767181 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11783146113157272 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface of the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom upward and backward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a roaring flood of turbid, swirling black mud and crumbling building debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive peacock beast visible at the center of the scene with metallic deep blue and dark green feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the peacock's tail feathers unfold to reveal a golden ring pattern transforming into thousands of evil eyes with vertical pupils flashing scarlet light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204481050372124 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812044858932495 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204481050372124, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204481050372124, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05088460072875023, + 0.16390471160411835, + 0.0818280354142189, + 0.02173728123307228, + 0.06951529532670975, + 0.11259680986404419, + 0.2644251585006714, + 0.07854107022285461, + 0.07390201836824417, + 0.08266497403383255 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204481050372124 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface of the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom upward and backward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a roaring flood of turbid, swirling black mud and crumbling building debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive peacock beast visible at the center of the scene with metallic deep blue and dark green feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the peacock's tail feathers unfold to reveal a golden ring pattern transforming into thousands of evil eyes with vertical pupils flashing scarlet light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818426139652729 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018184185028076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818426139652729, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818426139652729, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14785999059677124, + 0.25280389189720154, + 0.12921643257141113, + 0.04890132322907448, + 0.103337362408638, + 0.044626858085393906, + 0.11456894129514694, + 0.06568052619695663, + 0.037135131657123566, + 0.05586950108408928 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818426139652729 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface of the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom upward and backward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a roaring flood of turbid, swirling black mud and crumbling building debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive peacock beast visible at the center of the scene with metallic deep blue and dark green feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the peacock's tail feathers unfold to reveal a golden ring pattern transforming into thousands of evil eyes with vertical pupils flashing scarlet light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004639100283384323 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379639148712158 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004639100283384323, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004639100283384323, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12327529489994049, + 0.09919631481170654, + 0.213094562292099, + 0.07067219913005829, + 0.07177281379699707, + 0.0529785230755806, + 0.11407153308391571, + 0.06843559443950653, + 0.09943254292011261, + 0.08707059174776077 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004639100283384323 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface of the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom upward and backward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a roaring flood of turbid, swirling black mud and crumbling building debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive peacock beast visible at the center of the scene with metallic deep blue and dark green feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the peacock's tail feathers unfold to reveal a golden ring pattern transforming into thousands of evil eyes with vertical pupils flashing scarlet light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002820087829604745 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877820014953613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002820087829604745, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002820087829604745, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05434117093682289, + 0.08376847952604294, + 0.06651053577661514, + 0.10646013170480728, + 0.046477265655994415, + 0.06383080035448074, + 0.12049911171197891, + 0.07198097556829453, + 0.10864526033401489, + 0.27748632431030273 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002820087829604745 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a seamless single shot imbued with a dark, mythical quality, a camera begins at an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface of a roaring flood of turbid, swirling black mud and crumbling building debris, slowly zooming upward and backward. The sky is shrouded in thick, inky clouds, illuminated only by streaks of purple lightning that tear through the sky, each flash reflecting an eerie luster on the surging waters below. The focal point is a peacock beast, as massive as a mountain, standing proudly at the center of the apocalyptic torrent. Its feathers, shimmering in metallic deep blue and dark green, each like a sharp blade of obsidian, pierce the air. With an inhuman shriek, a blend of metallic grinding and thunder, its massive, furled tail feathers begin to rise in a majestic, slow rhythm. Then, with a fluidity that defies the laws of physics, the feather fans unfold, layer by layer, to the sides, forming a magnificent barrier that obscures the sky. As each feather stretched, the center of the seemingly decorative golden ring pattern on it suddenly opened, transforming into thousands of evil eyes with vertical pupils flashing an ominous scarlet light and full of malicious intent. These eyes stared down at the world below being swallowed by the flood, releasing an invisible, mind-shattering pressure. The entire picture created an unstoppable, doomsday-like fear in the epic scene of destruction.", + "seed": 7515, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_3/index_9114_seed_7515_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.11719914027489722, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11719914027489722, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11719914027489722, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface of the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom upward and backward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a roaring flood of turbid, swirling black mud and crumbling building debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive peacock beast visible at the center of the scene with metallic deep blue and dark green feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the peacock's tail feathers unfold to reveal a golden ring pattern transforming into thousands of evil eyes with vertical pupils flashing scarlet light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4782290458679199 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9782290458679199 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4782290458679199, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4782290458679199, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1358075737953186, + 0.08371559530496597, + 0.06243118271231651, + 0.07899013161659241, + 0.06819148361682892, + 0.05344347283244133, + 0.17242608964443207, + 0.06874395906925201, + 0.0835498496890068, + 0.19270069897174835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4782290458679199 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface of the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom upward and backward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a roaring flood of turbid, swirling black mud and crumbling building debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive peacock beast visible at the center of the scene with metallic deep blue and dark green feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the peacock's tail feathers unfold to reveal a golden ring pattern transforming into thousands of evil eyes with vertical pupils flashing scarlet light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866749420762062 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486674308776855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866749420762062, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866749420762062, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1491086632013321, + 0.05956576392054558, + 0.04360669106245041, + 0.06417904794216156, + 0.05984504520893097, + 0.09199018776416779, + 0.1992991864681244, + 0.10500103235244751, + 0.16173842549324036, + 0.06566605716943741 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866749420762062 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface of the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom upward and backward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a roaring flood of turbid, swirling black mud and crumbling building debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive peacock beast visible at the center of the scene with metallic deep blue and dark green feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the peacock's tail feathers unfold to reveal a golden ring pattern transforming into thousands of evil eyes with vertical pupils flashing scarlet light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05495903640985489 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299590587615967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05495903640985489, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05495903640985489, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21660937368869781, + 0.15146419405937195, + 0.10988932847976685, + 0.06817430257797241, + 0.1124626100063324, + 0.04530707001686096, + 0.05874694883823395, + 0.06626281887292862, + 0.0731702446937561, + 0.09791318327188492 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05495903640985489 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface of the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom upward and backward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a roaring flood of turbid, swirling black mud and crumbling building debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive peacock beast visible at the center of the scene with metallic deep blue and dark green feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the peacock's tail feathers unfold to reveal a golden ring pattern transforming into thousands of evil eyes with vertical pupils flashing scarlet light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002200921531766653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127201080322266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002200921531766653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002200921531766653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09052159637212753, + 0.09207752346992493, + 0.06655915826559067, + 0.10922896862030029, + 0.16396361589431763, + 0.07321074604988098, + 0.07413946092128754, + 0.11608995497226715, + 0.09284219890832901, + 0.12136673927307129 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002200921531766653 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface of the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom upward and backward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a roaring flood of turbid, swirling black mud and crumbling building debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive peacock beast visible at the center of the scene with metallic deep blue and dark green feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the peacock's tail feathers unfold to reveal a golden ring pattern transforming into thousands of evil eyes with vertical pupils flashing scarlet light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019392033573240042 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251939296722412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019392033573240042, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019392033573240042, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08432450890541077, + 0.04629338160157204, + 0.05564827099442482, + 0.048889290541410446, + 0.11536338180303574, + 0.05263388901948929, + 0.12147488445043564, + 0.1600373238325119, + 0.10912894457578659, + 0.20620609819889069 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019392033573240042 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a seamless single shot imbued with a dark, mythical quality, a camera begins at an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface of a roaring flood of turbid, swirling black mud and crumbling building debris, slowly zooming upward and backward. The sky is shrouded in thick, inky clouds, illuminated only by streaks of purple lightning that tear through the sky, each flash reflecting an eerie luster on the surging waters below. The focal point is a peacock beast, as massive as a mountain, standing proudly at the center of the apocalyptic torrent. Its feathers, shimmering in metallic deep blue and dark green, each like a sharp blade of obsidian, pierce the air. With an inhuman shriek, a blend of metallic grinding and thunder, its massive, furled tail feathers begin to rise in a majestic, slow rhythm. Then, with a fluidity that defies the laws of physics, the feather fans unfold, layer by layer, to the sides, forming a magnificent barrier that obscures the sky. As each feather stretched, the center of the seemingly decorative golden ring pattern on it suddenly opened, transforming into thousands of evil eyes with vertical pupils flashing an ominous scarlet light and full of malicious intent. These eyes stared down at the world below being swallowed by the flood, releasing an invisible, mind-shattering pressure. The entire picture created an unstoppable, doomsday-like fear in the epic scene of destruction.", + "seed": 7516, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_3/index_9114_seed_7516_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.2112212327774614, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2112212327774614, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2112212327774614, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface of the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom upward and backward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a roaring flood of turbid, swirling black mud and crumbling building debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive peacock beast visible at the center of the scene with metallic deep blue and dark green feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the peacock's tail feathers unfold to reveal a golden ring pattern transforming into thousands of evil eyes with vertical pupils flashing scarlet light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4794871509075165 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9794871807098389 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4794871509075165, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4794871509075165, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08328703045845032, + 0.04775772616267204, + 0.02843346633017063, + 0.31177669763565063, + 0.052327875047922134, + 0.05504130199551582, + 0.16075992584228516, + 0.04466056823730469, + 0.10927954316139221, + 0.106675885617733 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4794871509075165 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface of the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom upward and backward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a roaring flood of turbid, swirling black mud and crumbling building debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive peacock beast visible at the center of the scene with metallic deep blue and dark green feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the peacock's tail feathers unfold to reveal a golden ring pattern transforming into thousands of evil eyes with vertical pupils flashing scarlet light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25207728147506714 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502077341079712 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25207728147506714, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25207728147506714, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06962879747152328, + 0.07070482522249222, + 0.06180326268076897, + 0.16384738683700562, + 0.10967337340116501, + 0.12474052608013153, + 0.09676468372344971, + 0.09081047028303146, + 0.10559685528278351, + 0.10642985999584198 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25207728147506714 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface of the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom upward and backward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a roaring flood of turbid, swirling black mud and crumbling building debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive peacock beast visible at the center of the scene with metallic deep blue and dark green feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the peacock's tail feathers unfold to reveal a golden ring pattern transforming into thousands of evil eyes with vertical pupils flashing scarlet light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134075105190277 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.31340754032135 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134075105190277, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134075105190277, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10037373751401901, + 0.04705549776554108, + 0.07023543119430542, + 0.287396103143692, + 0.02765279822051525, + 0.06296809017658234, + 0.17848725616931915, + 0.04167046397924423, + 0.08964785933494568, + 0.09451271593570709 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134075105190277 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface of the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom upward and backward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a roaring flood of turbid, swirling black mud and crumbling building debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive peacock beast visible at the center of the scene with metallic deep blue and dark green feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the peacock's tail feathers unfold to reveal a golden ring pattern transforming into thousands of evil eyes with vertical pupils flashing scarlet light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008645012974739075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758645057678223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008645012974739075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008645012974739075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09120415896177292, + 0.18517059087753296, + 0.1569199413061142, + 0.07605263590812683, + 0.05002083256840706, + 0.046866513788700104, + 0.11163698136806488, + 0.09579687565565109, + 0.07858806103467941, + 0.10774335265159607 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008645012974739075 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface of the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom upward and backward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a roaring flood of turbid, swirling black mud and crumbling building debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive peacock beast visible at the center of the scene with metallic deep blue and dark green feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the peacock's tail feathers unfold to reveal a golden ring pattern transforming into thousands of evil eyes with vertical pupils flashing scarlet light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002489208010956645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.00248908996582 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002489208010956645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002489208010956645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05994868651032448, + 0.05920364707708359, + 0.03198663145303726, + 0.16692854464054108, + 0.06129356473684311, + 0.06860719621181488, + 0.08048932254314423, + 0.08432629704475403, + 0.21168601512908936, + 0.1755300611257553 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002489208010956645 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a seamless single shot imbued with a dark, mythical quality, a camera begins at an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface of a roaring flood of turbid, swirling black mud and crumbling building debris, slowly zooming upward and backward. The sky is shrouded in thick, inky clouds, illuminated only by streaks of purple lightning that tear through the sky, each flash reflecting an eerie luster on the surging waters below. The focal point is a peacock beast, as massive as a mountain, standing proudly at the center of the apocalyptic torrent. Its feathers, shimmering in metallic deep blue and dark green, each like a sharp blade of obsidian, pierce the air. With an inhuman shriek, a blend of metallic grinding and thunder, its massive, furled tail feathers begin to rise in a majestic, slow rhythm. Then, with a fluidity that defies the laws of physics, the feather fans unfold, layer by layer, to the sides, forming a magnificent barrier that obscures the sky. As each feather stretched, the center of the seemingly decorative golden ring pattern on it suddenly opened, transforming into thousands of evil eyes with vertical pupils flashing an ominous scarlet light and full of malicious intent. These eyes stared down at the world below being swallowed by the flood, releasing an invisible, mind-shattering pressure. The entire picture created an unstoppable, doomsday-like fear in the epic scene of destruction.", + "seed": 7517, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_3/index_9114_seed_7517_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.09798199248034507, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09798199248034507, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09798199248034507, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface of the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom upward and backward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a roaring flood of turbid, swirling black mud and crumbling building debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive peacock beast visible at the center of the scene with metallic deep blue and dark green feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the peacock's tail feathers unfold to reveal a golden ring pattern transforming into thousands of evil eyes with vertical pupils flashing scarlet light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4341108500957489 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0591108798980713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4341108500957489, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4341108500957489, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25488337874412537, + 0.12440713495016098, + 0.04648647457361221, + 0.08428197354078293, + 0.06103094667196274, + 0.1117371916770935, + 0.13068296015262604, + 0.09333439916372299, + 0.06328850984573364, + 0.02986704185605049 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4341108500957489 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface of the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom upward and backward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a roaring flood of turbid, swirling black mud and crumbling building debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive peacock beast visible at the center of the scene with metallic deep blue and dark green feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the peacock's tail feathers unfold to reveal a golden ring pattern transforming into thousands of evil eyes with vertical pupils flashing scarlet light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02330239862203598 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733023166656494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02330239862203598, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02330239862203598, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10213503241539001, + 0.07103236764669418, + 0.03637468069791794, + 0.07520385086536407, + 0.06355641782283783, + 0.10634636878967285, + 0.16269607841968536, + 0.14670714735984802, + 0.13566678762435913, + 0.10028131306171417 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02330239862203598 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface of the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom upward and backward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a roaring flood of turbid, swirling black mud and crumbling building debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive peacock beast visible at the center of the scene with metallic deep blue and dark green feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the peacock's tail feathers unfold to reveal a golden ring pattern transforming into thousands of evil eyes with vertical pupils flashing scarlet light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634515054523945 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513452529907227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634515054523945, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634515054523945, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40874239802360535, + 0.18250930309295654, + 0.09479738771915436, + 0.04755119979381561, + 0.039966411888599396, + 0.029651854187250137, + 0.04004605486989021, + 0.08270317316055298, + 0.03435241058468819, + 0.0396798774600029 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634515054523945 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface of the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom upward and backward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a roaring flood of turbid, swirling black mud and crumbling building debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive peacock beast visible at the center of the scene with metallic deep blue and dark green feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the peacock's tail feathers unfold to reveal a golden ring pattern transforming into thousands of evil eyes with vertical pupils flashing scarlet light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0015147175872698426 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.501514911651611 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0015147175872698426, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0015147175872698426, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21349647641181946, + 0.06156042963266373, + 0.09451091289520264, + 0.050202950835227966, + 0.12928788363933563, + 0.09659943729639053, + 0.08445151150226593, + 0.10595604032278061, + 0.08850851655006409, + 0.07542583346366882 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0015147175872698426 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned at an extremely low angle, almost touching the surface of the water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly zoom upward and backward during the shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a roaring flood of turbid, swirling black mud and crumbling building debris?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a massive peacock beast visible at the center of the scene with metallic deep blue and dark green feathers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the peacock's tail feathers unfold to reveal a golden ring pattern transforming into thousands of evil eyes with vertical pupils flashing scarlet light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004636845551431179 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379636764526367 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004636845551431179, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004636845551431179, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11203532665967941, + 0.05039114132523537, + 0.04192192479968071, + 0.09408596158027649, + 0.03522011265158653, + 0.13243214786052704, + 0.062382813543081284, + 0.13980156183242798, + 0.1727089136838913, + 0.1590200811624527 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004636845551431179 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_4/index_tensor([5002, 5002])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_4/index_tensor([5002, 5002])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7b5215d40e5f8c45c015ba93f0d92351ece7b37d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_4/index_tensor([5002, 5002])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An epic medium-long shot, filmed from a slightly upward angle, slowly and steadily pans forward, the imagery rendered with exquisite 3D effects. The scene is set atop a mist-shrouded fairy mountain. Dawn's faint light penetrates the thin morning mist, gilding the ancient pines, cypresses, and unusual rocks with a soft golden edge. In the center of the frame, a massive fairy stone, covered in ancient moss and weathered cracks, vibrates violently. The energy contained within causes it to emit an increasingly dazzling golden glow, and mysterious runes appear faintly within the stone. Suddenly, the fairy stone explodes with a bang, sending countless fragments of varying sizes, edges shimmering with energy, flying in all directions in slow motion. A dazzling column of light shoots skyward, swirling the surrounding mist into a vast vortex. At the center of the explosion, the light gradually fades, revealing a curled-up stone monkey. Its body, not rough rock, is composed of a translucent material, as smooth as jade and imbued with natural stone veins, creating a photorealistic texture. Rays of golden light, emanating from the fissures within its body, illuminate its tightly closed eyes and the contours of its nascent, slightly curious face. As the camera zooms in, this ethereal stone monkey slowly stretches its limbs and cautiously opens its eyes. These golden pupils, gleaming with pure wisdom and playfulness, curiously survey this new world. The radiant light envelops it in a sacred and vibrant aura.", + "seed": 20776, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_4/index_5002_seed_20776_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.020326432725414633, + "vlm_logprob": -0.020326432725414633, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.349999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.020326432725414633, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a mist-shrouded mountain with ancient pines, cypresses, and unusual rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive fairy stone visible in the center of the frame, covered in moss and cracks, emitting a golden glow before exploding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a translucent stone monkey with jade-like texture and stone veins appear after the explosion, revealing a curious face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the stone monkey stretching its limbs and opening its eyes with golden pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium-long shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01891866698861122 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018918514251709 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01891866698861122, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01891866698861122, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18857426941394806, + 0.2586061656475067, + 0.03407202661037445, + 0.04685511812567711, + 0.09898880869150162, + 0.06294145435094833, + 0.1540755182504654, + 0.06527068465948105, + 0.02711545117199421, + 0.06350050121545792 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01891866698861122 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a mist-shrouded mountain with ancient pines, cypresses, and unusual rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive fairy stone visible in the center of the frame, covered in moss and cracks, emitting a golden glow before exploding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a translucent stone monkey with jade-like texture and stone veins appear after the explosion, revealing a curious face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the stone monkey stretching its limbs and opening its eyes with golden pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium-long shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004105948377400637 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504106044769287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004105948377400637, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004105948377400637, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12560109794139862, + 0.2918129563331604, + 0.04072587564587593, + 0.06112782284617424, + 0.06478990614414215, + 0.0666065365076065, + 0.05766793712973595, + 0.14346937835216522, + 0.06838768720626831, + 0.07981079071760178 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004105948377400637 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a mist-shrouded mountain with ancient pines, cypresses, and unusual rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive fairy stone visible in the center of the frame, covered in moss and cracks, emitting a golden glow before exploding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a translucent stone monkey with jade-like texture and stone veins appear after the explosion, revealing a curious face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the stone monkey stretching its limbs and opening its eyes with golden pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium-long shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036178866866976023 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628617763519287 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036178866866976023, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036178866866976023, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07301215082406998, + 0.05349687859416008, + 0.03228268027305603, + 0.05525824800133705, + 0.09762527048587799, + 0.0376092866063118, + 0.084694504737854, + 0.10156238824129105, + 0.22850912809371948, + 0.23594948649406433 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036178866866976023 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a mist-shrouded mountain with ancient pines, cypresses, and unusual rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive fairy stone visible in the center of the frame, covered in moss and cracks, emitting a golden glow before exploding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a translucent stone monkey with jade-like texture and stone veins appear after the explosion, revealing a curious face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the stone monkey stretching its limbs and opening its eyes with golden pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium-long shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026353277266025543 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651353359222412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026353277266025543, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026353277266025543, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0384046696126461, + 0.02638944610953331, + 0.053832314908504486, + 0.04781715199351311, + 0.04133782535791397, + 0.053635068237781525, + 0.09222150593996048, + 0.24865692853927612, + 0.3006734848022461, + 0.0970316231250763 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026353277266025543 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a mist-shrouded mountain with ancient pines, cypresses, and unusual rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive fairy stone visible in the center of the frame, covered in moss and cracks, emitting a golden glow before exploding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a translucent stone monkey with jade-like texture and stone veins appear after the explosion, revealing a curious face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the stone monkey stretching its limbs and opening its eyes with golden pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium-long shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048636384308338165 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486364364624023 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048636384308338165, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048636384308338165, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12243902683258057, + 0.0599958598613739, + 0.0736132264137268, + 0.13184788823127747, + 0.07418282330036163, + 0.05559741333127022, + 0.08608939498662949, + 0.2569107413291931, + 0.06581024825572968, + 0.0735134407877922 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048636384308338165 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic medium-long shot, filmed from a slightly upward angle, slowly and steadily pans forward, the imagery rendered with exquisite 3D effects. The scene is set atop a mist-shrouded fairy mountain. Dawn's faint light penetrates the thin morning mist, gilding the ancient pines, cypresses, and unusual rocks with a soft golden edge. In the center of the frame, a massive fairy stone, covered in ancient moss and weathered cracks, vibrates violently. The energy contained within causes it to emit an increasingly dazzling golden glow, and mysterious runes appear faintly within the stone. Suddenly, the fairy stone explodes with a bang, sending countless fragments of varying sizes, edges shimmering with energy, flying in all directions in slow motion. A dazzling column of light shoots skyward, swirling the surrounding mist into a vast vortex. At the center of the explosion, the light gradually fades, revealing a curled-up stone monkey. Its body, not rough rock, is composed of a translucent material, as smooth as jade and imbued with natural stone veins, creating a photorealistic texture. Rays of golden light, emanating from the fissures within its body, illuminate its tightly closed eyes and the contours of its nascent, slightly curious face. As the camera zooms in, this ethereal stone monkey slowly stretches its limbs and cautiously opens its eyes. These golden pupils, gleaming with pure wisdom and playfulness, curiously survey this new world. The radiant light envelops it in a sacred and vibrant aura.", + "seed": 20777, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_4/index_5002_seed_20777_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.022965666931122543, + "vlm_logprob": -0.022965666931122543, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.022965666931122543, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a mist-shrouded mountain with ancient pines, cypresses, and unusual rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive fairy stone visible in the center of the frame, covered in moss and cracks, emitting a golden glow before exploding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a translucent stone monkey with jade-like texture and stone veins appear after the explosion, revealing a curious face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the stone monkey stretching its limbs and opening its eyes with golden pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium-long shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010357792489230633 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.635357856750488 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010357792489230633, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010357792489230633, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42029640078544617, + 0.058644749224185944, + 0.025992928072810173, + 0.030042920261621475, + 0.016552580520510674, + 0.02404434233903885, + 0.017528269439935684, + 0.2930605411529541, + 0.03288794308900833, + 0.08094927668571472 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010357792489230633 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a mist-shrouded mountain with ancient pines, cypresses, and unusual rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive fairy stone visible in the center of the frame, covered in moss and cracks, emitting a golden glow before exploding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a translucent stone monkey with jade-like texture and stone veins appear after the explosion, revealing a curious face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the stone monkey stretching its limbs and opening its eyes with golden pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium-long shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004649067297577858 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.3796491622924805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004649067297577858, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004649067297577858, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2059965878725052, + 0.061247263103723526, + 0.0703483372926712, + 0.03605160117149353, + 0.04116002842783928, + 0.0352635383605957, + 0.0801808312535286, + 0.3580436408519745, + 0.038743022829294205, + 0.0729651004076004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004649067297577858 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a mist-shrouded mountain with ancient pines, cypresses, and unusual rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive fairy stone visible in the center of the frame, covered in moss and cracks, emitting a golden glow before exploding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a translucent stone monkey with jade-like texture and stone veins appear after the explosion, revealing a curious face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the stone monkey stretching its limbs and opening its eyes with golden pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium-long shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004095145035535097 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504095077514648 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004095145035535097, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004095145035535097, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7497323751449585, + 0.030257226899266243, + 0.011036945506930351, + 0.014490492641925812, + 0.012842389754951, + 0.007611463312059641, + 0.018271498382091522, + 0.05617501959204674, + 0.042045094072818756, + 0.057537518441677094 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004095145035535097 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a mist-shrouded mountain with ancient pines, cypresses, and unusual rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive fairy stone visible in the center of the frame, covered in moss and cracks, emitting a golden glow before exploding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a translucent stone monkey with jade-like texture and stone veins appear after the explosion, revealing a curious face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the stone monkey stretching its limbs and opening its eyes with golden pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium-long shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370605409145355 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408705949783325 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370605409145355, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370605409145355, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2775774300098419, + 0.01697627082467079, + 0.018633121624588966, + 0.030402839183807373, + 0.008715375326573849, + 0.015267856419086456, + 0.01936672441661358, + 0.43617942929267883, + 0.07870224118232727, + 0.09817864745855331 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370605409145355 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a mist-shrouded mountain with ancient pines, cypresses, and unusual rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive fairy stone visible in the center of the frame, covered in moss and cracks, emitting a golden glow before exploding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a translucent stone monkey with jade-like texture and stone veins appear after the explosion, revealing a curious face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the stone monkey stretching its limbs and opening its eyes with golden pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium-long shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06202027574181557 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120203018188477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06202027574181557, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06202027574181557, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3060419261455536, + 0.039436765015125275, + 0.0251011960208416, + 0.05177164822816849, + 0.022406429052352905, + 0.05316557735204697, + 0.02784254588186741, + 0.36391276121139526, + 0.05067499727010727, + 0.05964616686105728 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06202027574181557 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic medium-long shot, filmed from a slightly upward angle, slowly and steadily pans forward, the imagery rendered with exquisite 3D effects. The scene is set atop a mist-shrouded fairy mountain. Dawn's faint light penetrates the thin morning mist, gilding the ancient pines, cypresses, and unusual rocks with a soft golden edge. In the center of the frame, a massive fairy stone, covered in ancient moss and weathered cracks, vibrates violently. The energy contained within causes it to emit an increasingly dazzling golden glow, and mysterious runes appear faintly within the stone. Suddenly, the fairy stone explodes with a bang, sending countless fragments of varying sizes, edges shimmering with energy, flying in all directions in slow motion. A dazzling column of light shoots skyward, swirling the surrounding mist into a vast vortex. At the center of the explosion, the light gradually fades, revealing a curled-up stone monkey. Its body, not rough rock, is composed of a translucent material, as smooth as jade and imbued with natural stone veins, creating a photorealistic texture. Rays of golden light, emanating from the fissures within its body, illuminate its tightly closed eyes and the contours of its nascent, slightly curious face. As the camera zooms in, this ethereal stone monkey slowly stretches its limbs and cautiously opens its eyes. These golden pupils, gleaming with pure wisdom and playfulness, curiously survey this new world. The radiant light envelops it in a sacred and vibrant aura.", + "seed": 20778, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_4/index_5002_seed_20778_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.013532246090471744, + "vlm_logprob": -0.013532246090471744, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.013532246090471744, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a mist-shrouded mountain with ancient pines, cypresses, and unusual rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive fairy stone visible in the center of the frame, covered in moss and cracks, emitting a golden glow before exploding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a translucent stone monkey with jade-like texture and stone veins appear after the explosion, revealing a curious face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the stone monkey stretching its limbs and opening its eyes with golden pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium-long shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007905268110334873 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.88290548324585 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007905268110334873, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007905268110334873, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2601235806941986, + 0.04184743016958237, + 0.0910654067993164, + 0.03894510492682457, + 0.0336504764854908, + 0.050880830734968185, + 0.22945965826511383, + 0.17588604986667633, + 0.035929687321186066, + 0.04221175238490105 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007905268110334873 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a mist-shrouded mountain with ancient pines, cypresses, and unusual rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive fairy stone visible in the center of the frame, covered in moss and cracks, emitting a golden glow before exploding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a translucent stone monkey with jade-like texture and stone veins appear after the explosion, revealing a curious face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the stone monkey stretching its limbs and opening its eyes with golden pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium-long shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004648949019610882 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.3796491622924805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004648949019610882, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004648949019610882, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22574128210544586, + 0.15282464027404785, + 0.1380005031824112, + 0.10548356920480728, + 0.1027480959892273, + 0.08731245994567871, + 0.06392210721969604, + 0.04118211567401886, + 0.05301383510231972, + 0.029771383851766586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004648949019610882 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a mist-shrouded mountain with ancient pines, cypresses, and unusual rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive fairy stone visible in the center of the frame, covered in moss and cracks, emitting a golden glow before exploding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a translucent stone monkey with jade-like texture and stone veins appear after the explosion, revealing a curious face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the stone monkey stretching its limbs and opening its eyes with golden pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium-long shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005947155877947807 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130947113037109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005947155877947807, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005947155877947807, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08127903193235397, + 0.05654115229845047, + 0.05999712273478508, + 0.03464970737695694, + 0.034033454954624176, + 0.04159850999712944, + 0.20666281878948212, + 0.36838990449905396, + 0.056811414659023285, + 0.06003683805465698 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005947155877947807 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a mist-shrouded mountain with ancient pines, cypresses, and unusual rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive fairy stone visible in the center of the frame, covered in moss and cracks, emitting a golden glow before exploding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a translucent stone monkey with jade-like texture and stone veins appear after the explosion, revealing a curious face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the stone monkey stretching its limbs and opening its eyes with golden pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium-long shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107827853411436 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511078357696533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107827853411436, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107827853411436, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06622342765331268, + 0.05049671232700348, + 0.04860556870698929, + 0.05134674161672592, + 0.03344624862074852, + 0.06045158952474594, + 0.28576749563217163, + 0.27795130014419556, + 0.08588667213916779, + 0.039824239909648895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107827853411436 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a mist-shrouded mountain with ancient pines, cypresses, and unusual rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive fairy stone visible in the center of the frame, covered in moss and cracks, emitting a golden glow before exploding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a translucent stone monkey with jade-like texture and stone veins appear after the explosion, revealing a curious face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the stone monkey stretching its limbs and opening its eyes with golden pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium-long shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0380815789103508 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288081645965576 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0380815789103508, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0380815789103508, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09650136530399323, + 0.25707411766052246, + 0.057716306298971176, + 0.05871063843369484, + 0.12899334728717804, + 0.08293039351701736, + 0.17410066723823547, + 0.04119877517223358, + 0.04533764347434044, + 0.057436756789684296 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0380815789103508 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An epic medium-long shot, filmed from a slightly upward angle, slowly and steadily pans forward, the imagery rendered with exquisite 3D effects. The scene is set atop a mist-shrouded fairy mountain. Dawn's faint light penetrates the thin morning mist, gilding the ancient pines, cypresses, and unusual rocks with a soft golden edge. In the center of the frame, a massive fairy stone, covered in ancient moss and weathered cracks, vibrates violently. The energy contained within causes it to emit an increasingly dazzling golden glow, and mysterious runes appear faintly within the stone. Suddenly, the fairy stone explodes with a bang, sending countless fragments of varying sizes, edges shimmering with energy, flying in all directions in slow motion. A dazzling column of light shoots skyward, swirling the surrounding mist into a vast vortex. At the center of the explosion, the light gradually fades, revealing a curled-up stone monkey. Its body, not rough rock, is composed of a translucent material, as smooth as jade and imbued with natural stone veins, creating a photorealistic texture. Rays of golden light, emanating from the fissures within its body, illuminate its tightly closed eyes and the contours of its nascent, slightly curious face. As the camera zooms in, this ethereal stone monkey slowly stretches its limbs and cautiously opens its eyes. These golden pupils, gleaming with pure wisdom and playfulness, curiously survey this new world. The radiant light envelops it in a sacred and vibrant aura.", + "seed": 20779, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_4/index_5002_seed_20779_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.02624013153836131, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02624013153836131, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02624013153836131, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a mist-shrouded mountain with ancient pines, cypresses, and unusual rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive fairy stone visible in the center of the frame, covered in moss and cracks, emitting a golden glow before exploding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a translucent stone monkey with jade-like texture and stone veins appear after the explosion, revealing a curious face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the stone monkey stretching its limbs and opening its eyes with golden pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium-long shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.034273192286491394 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.409273147583008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.034273192286491394, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.034273192286491394, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07905048131942749, + 0.03045620024204254, + 0.03705252334475517, + 0.015475469641387463, + 0.022439178079366684, + 0.15916021168231964, + 0.6169533133506775, + 0.014640254899859428, + 0.008680428378283978, + 0.01609191857278347 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.034273192286491394 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a mist-shrouded mountain with ancient pines, cypresses, and unusual rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive fairy stone visible in the center of the frame, covered in moss and cracks, emitting a golden glow before exploding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a translucent stone monkey with jade-like texture and stone veins appear after the explosion, revealing a curious face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the stone monkey stretching its limbs and opening its eyes with golden pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium-long shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014204584993422031 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264204502105713 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014204584993422031, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014204584993422031, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09795098006725311, + 0.016597552224993706, + 0.022798258811235428, + 0.03136271983385086, + 0.08941756188869476, + 0.38854894042015076, + 0.23113895952701569, + 0.04768281430006027, + 0.03325112909078598, + 0.04125114530324936 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014204584993422031 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a mist-shrouded mountain with ancient pines, cypresses, and unusual rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive fairy stone visible in the center of the frame, covered in moss and cracks, emitting a golden glow before exploding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a translucent stone monkey with jade-like texture and stone veins appear after the explosion, revealing a curious face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the stone monkey stretching its limbs and opening its eyes with golden pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium-long shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004634947050362825 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379634857177734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004634947050362825, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004634947050362825, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04727962240576744, + 0.029911955818533897, + 0.01715274527668953, + 0.01925193890929222, + 0.0334242545068264, + 0.45809802412986755, + 0.24413931369781494, + 0.0415094792842865, + 0.06602947413921356, + 0.0432032011449337 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004634947050362825 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a mist-shrouded mountain with ancient pines, cypresses, and unusual rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive fairy stone visible in the center of the frame, covered in moss and cracks, emitting a golden glow before exploding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a translucent stone monkey with jade-like texture and stone veins appear after the explosion, revealing a curious face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the stone monkey stretching its limbs and opening its eyes with golden pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium-long shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016067545861005783 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410675048828125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016067545861005783, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016067545861005783, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.01492930855602026, + 0.006515785586088896, + 0.011184596456587315, + 0.008674397133290768, + 0.03420959785580635, + 0.025609886273741722, + 0.8187054991722107, + 0.039967361837625504, + 0.023126814514398575, + 0.01707668974995613 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016067545861005783 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set atop a mist-shrouded mountain with ancient pines, cypresses, and unusual rocks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a massive fairy stone visible in the center of the frame, covered in moss and cracks, emitting a golden glow before exploding?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does a translucent stone monkey with jade-like texture and stone veins appear after the explosion, revealing a curious face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the video show the stone monkey stretching its limbs and opening its eyes with golden pupils?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a medium-long shot from a slightly upward angle and slowly pan forward before zooming in?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06202038750052452 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120203018188477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06202038750052452, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06202038750052452, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.048663195222616196, + 0.021267689764499664, + 0.030513502657413483, + 0.018536236137151718, + 0.10245949774980545, + 0.05142991989850998, + 0.6577236652374268, + 0.022604946047067642, + 0.019633784890174866, + 0.027167508378624916 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06202038750052452 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_5/index_tensor([4612, 4612])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_5/index_tensor([4612, 4612])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5ed412c6f2c8aa37aceac3bb5da4df6304010a5a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_5/index_tensor([4612, 4612])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "stunning close-up, captured in the immersive style of cyberpunk animation, employs sharp focus and a shallow depth of field to capture a ritualistic moment. The scene begins with a pair of precision-engineered prosthetic limbs constructed of polished chrome and black carbon fiber. Within their intricate internal structure, tiny arcs of blue electricity dance through exposed wiring. Steady and deliberate, these hands manipulate a pair of black alloy chopsticks, gripping a crystalline dumpling, its filling barely visible. As the camera slowly tilts downward, a wet asphalt alley reflects the hazy glow of the magenta and cyan neon billboards blazing from the surrounding skyscrapers. Rain forms a thin mist in the air. Carefully, the chopsticks precisely place the tip of the dumpling into a rough, dark ceramic bowl filled with crimson fermented broad bean paste. The sauce's surface, far from static, shimmers with the faint glow of a data stream, composed of microscopic binary codes and digital matrices. At the moment the dumpling touches the sauce, the camera locks on, clearly capturing the sticky sauce being gently stirred, forming a brief depression under the slight pressure of the chopsticks, and then slowly and tensioningly wrapping around the tip of the dumpling. Its rich texture and the glimmer of data are intertwined, creating a unique atmosphere of focus and alienation that blends high technology and traditional food.", + "seed": 15492, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_5/index_4612_seed_15492_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.4773245878517628, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4773245878517628, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.599999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4773245878517628, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown as precision-engineered prosthetic limbs made of polished chrome and black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do tiny arcs of blue electricity dance through the exposed wiring inside the prosthetic limbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward to reveal a wet asphalt alley reflecting magenta and cyan neon billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the chopsticks place a crystalline dumpling into a dark ceramic bowl filled with crimson fermented broad bean paste?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the sauce surface shimmer with a data stream of microscopic binary codes and digital matrices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0180776119232178 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14307759702205658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.0180776119232178, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -2.0180776119232178, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17710942029953003, + 0.1257983148097992, + 0.10910744220018387, + 0.07188070565462112, + 0.0813157707452774, + 0.06755679845809937, + 0.08959588408470154, + 0.08545845001935959, + 0.054980918765068054, + 0.13719627261161804 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.0180776119232178 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown as precision-engineered prosthetic limbs made of polished chrome and black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do tiny arcs of blue electricity dance through the exposed wiring inside the prosthetic limbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward to reveal a wet asphalt alley reflecting magenta and cyan neon billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the chopsticks place a crystalline dumpling into a dark ceramic bowl filled with crimson fermented broad bean paste?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the sauce surface shimmer with a data stream of microscopic binary codes and digital matrices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07905079424381256 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790507793426514 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07905079424381256, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07905079424381256, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16248424351215363, + 0.14802217483520508, + 0.10174454003572464, + 0.06581450253725052, + 0.06282959878444672, + 0.04435078054666519, + 0.0705629289150238, + 0.15395601093769073, + 0.0541820153594017, + 0.13605323433876038 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07905079424381256 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown as precision-engineered prosthetic limbs made of polished chrome and black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do tiny arcs of blue electricity dance through the exposed wiring inside the prosthetic limbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward to reveal a wet asphalt alley reflecting magenta and cyan neon billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the chopsticks place a crystalline dumpling into a dark ceramic bowl filled with crimson fermented broad bean paste?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the sauce surface shimmer with a data stream of microscopic binary codes and digital matrices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428287774324417 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178287029266357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428287774324417, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428287774324417, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.125952810049057, + 0.03608395531773567, + 0.36524730920791626, + 0.17829549312591553, + 0.09864557534456253, + 0.08259071409702301, + 0.024965139105916023, + 0.04035831615328789, + 0.0261196568608284, + 0.021741000935435295 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428287774324417 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown as precision-engineered prosthetic limbs made of polished chrome and black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do tiny arcs of blue electricity dance through the exposed wiring inside the prosthetic limbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward to reveal a wet asphalt alley reflecting magenta and cyan neon billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the chopsticks place a crystalline dumpling into a dark ceramic bowl filled with crimson fermented broad bean paste?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the sauce surface shimmer with a data stream of microscopic binary codes and digital matrices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033710088580846786 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.40871000289917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033710088580846786, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033710088580846786, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08332235366106033, + 0.04219404608011246, + 0.11550261825323105, + 0.056891437619924545, + 0.05468739941716194, + 0.06967743486166, + 0.09796496480703354, + 0.28133392333984375, + 0.047226160764694214, + 0.15119969844818115 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033710088580846786 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown as precision-engineered prosthetic limbs made of polished chrome and black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do tiny arcs of blue electricity dance through the exposed wiring inside the prosthetic limbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward to reveal a wet asphalt alley reflecting magenta and cyan neon billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the chopsticks place a crystalline dumpling into a dark ceramic bowl filled with crimson fermented broad bean paste?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the sauce surface shimmer with a data stream of microscopic binary codes and digital matrices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11295566707849503 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379555702209473 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11295566707849503, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11295566707849503, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10096633434295654, + 0.05330590531229973, + 0.07268635928630829, + 0.07165765017271042, + 0.05501921474933624, + 0.08467002213001251, + 0.08795968443155289, + 0.17473289370536804, + 0.05263439938426018, + 0.24636748433113098 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11295566707849503 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning close-up, captured in the immersive style of cyberpunk animation, employs sharp focus and a shallow depth of field to capture a ritualistic moment. The scene begins with a pair of precision-engineered prosthetic limbs constructed of polished chrome and black carbon fiber. Within their intricate internal structure, tiny arcs of blue electricity dance through exposed wiring. Steady and deliberate, these hands manipulate a pair of black alloy chopsticks, gripping a crystalline dumpling, its filling barely visible. As the camera slowly tilts downward, a wet asphalt alley reflects the hazy glow of the magenta and cyan neon billboards blazing from the surrounding skyscrapers. Rain forms a thin mist in the air. Carefully, the chopsticks precisely place the tip of the dumpling into a rough, dark ceramic bowl filled with crimson fermented broad bean paste. The sauce's surface, far from static, shimmers with the faint glow of a data stream, composed of microscopic binary codes and digital matrices. At the moment the dumpling touches the sauce, the camera locks on, clearly capturing the sticky sauce being gently stirred, forming a brief depression under the slight pressure of the chopsticks, and then slowly and tensioningly wrapping around the tip of the dumpling. Its rich texture and the glimmer of data are intertwined, creating a unique atmosphere of focus and alienation that blends high technology and traditional food.", + "seed": 15493, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_5/index_4612_seed_15493_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.9666671171784401, + "vlm_logprob": -0.9666671171784401, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 0.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.9666671171784401, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown as precision-engineered prosthetic limbs made of polished chrome and black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do tiny arcs of blue electricity dance through the exposed wiring inside the prosthetic limbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward to reveal a wet asphalt alley reflecting magenta and cyan neon billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the chopsticks place a crystalline dumpling into a dark ceramic bowl filled with crimson fermented broad bean paste?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the sauce surface shimmer with a data stream of microscopic binary codes and digital matrices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264374256134033 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01437439862638712 + ], + "logprob_reward": -4.264374256134033, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -4.264374256134033, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18483462929725647, + 0.09484931081533432, + 0.07007557153701782, + 0.0925227478146553, + 0.08331869542598724, + 0.10408534109592438, + 0.06025483459234238, + 0.13607630133628845, + 0.1310638040304184, + 0.042918797582387924 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -4.264374256134033 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown as precision-engineered prosthetic limbs made of polished chrome and black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do tiny arcs of blue electricity dance through the exposed wiring inside the prosthetic limbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward to reveal a wet asphalt alley reflecting magenta and cyan neon billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the chopsticks place a crystalline dumpling into a dark ceramic bowl filled with crimson fermented broad bean paste?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the sauce surface shimmer with a data stream of microscopic binary codes and digital matrices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22605469822883606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6010546684265137 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22605469822883606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22605469822883606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10541491955518723, + 0.15378443896770477, + 0.19029533863067627, + 0.06491119414567947, + 0.05203394591808319, + 0.20591232180595398, + 0.0340016707777977, + 0.10510282963514328, + 0.04842852056026459, + 0.04011479392647743 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22605469822883606 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown as precision-engineered prosthetic limbs made of polished chrome and black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do tiny arcs of blue electricity dance through the exposed wiring inside the prosthetic limbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward to reveal a wet asphalt alley reflecting magenta and cyan neon billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the chopsticks place a crystalline dumpling into a dark ceramic bowl filled with crimson fermented broad bean paste?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the sauce surface shimmer with a data stream of microscopic binary codes and digital matrices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06213679164648056 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8121368885040283 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06213679164648056, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06213679164648056, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17521469295024872, + 0.17336316406726837, + 0.30620405077934265, + 0.07050107419490814, + 0.05269008129835129, + 0.055331040173769, + 0.03404499962925911, + 0.0807662308216095, + 0.030341072008013725, + 0.021543623879551888 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06213679164648056 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown as precision-engineered prosthetic limbs made of polished chrome and black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do tiny arcs of blue electricity dance through the exposed wiring inside the prosthetic limbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward to reveal a wet asphalt alley reflecting magenta and cyan neon billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the chopsticks place a crystalline dumpling into a dark ceramic bowl filled with crimson fermented broad bean paste?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the sauce surface shimmer with a data stream of microscopic binary codes and digital matrices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07907965779304504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790796279907227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07907965779304504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07907965779304504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15856744349002838, + 0.0752193033695221, + 0.07671244442462921, + 0.052427154034376144, + 0.05441294237971306, + 0.21795225143432617, + 0.06272503733634949, + 0.12648524343967438, + 0.07442068308591843, + 0.10107742249965668 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07907965779304504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown as precision-engineered prosthetic limbs made of polished chrome and black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do tiny arcs of blue electricity dance through the exposed wiring inside the prosthetic limbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward to reveal a wet asphalt alley reflecting magenta and cyan neon billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the chopsticks place a crystalline dumpling into a dark ceramic bowl filled with crimson fermented broad bean paste?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the sauce surface shimmer with a data stream of microscopic binary codes and digital matrices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2016901820898056 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016901969909668 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2016901820898056, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2016901820898056, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22901472449302673, + 0.05739365890622139, + 0.047206662595272064, + 0.07867380976676941, + 0.08596521615982056, + 0.13979105651378632, + 0.0833243876695633, + 0.13071505725383759, + 0.0914498046040535, + 0.056465666741132736 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2016901820898056 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning close-up, captured in the immersive style of cyberpunk animation, employs sharp focus and a shallow depth of field to capture a ritualistic moment. The scene begins with a pair of precision-engineered prosthetic limbs constructed of polished chrome and black carbon fiber. Within their intricate internal structure, tiny arcs of blue electricity dance through exposed wiring. Steady and deliberate, these hands manipulate a pair of black alloy chopsticks, gripping a crystalline dumpling, its filling barely visible. As the camera slowly tilts downward, a wet asphalt alley reflects the hazy glow of the magenta and cyan neon billboards blazing from the surrounding skyscrapers. Rain forms a thin mist in the air. Carefully, the chopsticks precisely place the tip of the dumpling into a rough, dark ceramic bowl filled with crimson fermented broad bean paste. The sauce's surface, far from static, shimmers with the faint glow of a data stream, composed of microscopic binary codes and digital matrices. At the moment the dumpling touches the sauce, the camera locks on, clearly capturing the sticky sauce being gently stirred, forming a brief depression under the slight pressure of the chopsticks, and then slowly and tensioningly wrapping around the tip of the dumpling. Its rich texture and the glimmer of data are intertwined, creating a unique atmosphere of focus and alienation that blends high technology and traditional food.", + "seed": 15494, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_5/index_4612_seed_15494_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.520457175374031, + "vlm_logprob": -0.520457175374031, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.520457175374031, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown as precision-engineered prosthetic limbs made of polished chrome and black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do tiny arcs of blue electricity dance through the exposed wiring inside the prosthetic limbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward to reveal a wet asphalt alley reflecting magenta and cyan neon billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the chopsticks place a crystalline dumpling into a dark ceramic bowl filled with crimson fermented broad bean paste?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the sauce surface shimmer with a data stream of microscopic binary codes and digital matrices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1272318363189697 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12723186612129211 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.1272318363189697, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -2.1272318363189697, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04342404380440712, + 0.032505203038454056, + 0.06993478536605835, + 0.025217223912477493, + 0.6213141679763794, + 0.02443547733128071, + 0.0565829873085022, + 0.026433171704411507, + 0.03521323949098587, + 0.06493969261646271 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.1272318363189697 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown as precision-engineered prosthetic limbs made of polished chrome and black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do tiny arcs of blue electricity dance through the exposed wiring inside the prosthetic limbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward to reveal a wet asphalt alley reflecting magenta and cyan neon billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the chopsticks place a crystalline dumpling into a dark ceramic bowl filled with crimson fermented broad bean paste?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the sauce surface shimmer with a data stream of microscopic binary codes and digital matrices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10039906203746796 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503990173339844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10039906203746796, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10039906203746796, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.055815041065216064, + 0.11091303080320358, + 0.11207648366689682, + 0.048214253038167953, + 0.2595224976539612, + 0.046583764255046844, + 0.10419072210788727, + 0.07767079770565033, + 0.09327202290296555, + 0.09174136072397232 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10039906203746796 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown as precision-engineered prosthetic limbs made of polished chrome and black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do tiny arcs of blue electricity dance through the exposed wiring inside the prosthetic limbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward to reveal a wet asphalt alley reflecting magenta and cyan neon billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the chopsticks place a crystalline dumpling into a dark ceramic bowl filled with crimson fermented broad bean paste?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the sauce surface shimmer with a data stream of microscopic binary codes and digital matrices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003270834684372 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950325965881348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003270834684372, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003270834684372, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09212204068899155, + 0.10611996799707413, + 0.2154979109764099, + 0.06596953421831131, + 0.1860833317041397, + 0.07139548659324646, + 0.04989491403102875, + 0.10969938337802887, + 0.06508118659257889, + 0.038136307150125504 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003270834684372 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown as precision-engineered prosthetic limbs made of polished chrome and black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do tiny arcs of blue electricity dance through the exposed wiring inside the prosthetic limbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward to reveal a wet asphalt alley reflecting magenta and cyan neon billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the chopsticks place a crystalline dumpling into a dark ceramic bowl filled with crimson fermented broad bean paste?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the sauce surface shimmer with a data stream of microscopic binary codes and digital matrices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07901973277330399 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579019784927368 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07901973277330399, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07901973277330399, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.055216412991285324, + 0.03240542113780975, + 0.09042815864086151, + 0.05736537650227547, + 0.2432098537683487, + 0.0596344955265522, + 0.05561123043298721, + 0.08486777544021606, + 0.18598157167434692, + 0.13527965545654297 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07901973277330399 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown as precision-engineered prosthetic limbs made of polished chrome and black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do tiny arcs of blue electricity dance through the exposed wiring inside the prosthetic limbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward to reveal a wet asphalt alley reflecting magenta and cyan neon billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the chopsticks place a crystalline dumpling into a dark ceramic bowl filled with crimson fermented broad bean paste?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the sauce surface shimmer with a data stream of microscopic binary codes and digital matrices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22560253739356995 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6006025075912476 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22560253739356995, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22560253739356995, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07598531991243362, + 0.02866770327091217, + 0.12981638312339783, + 0.0378742478787899, + 0.3396480083465576, + 0.04325797036290169, + 0.08322138339281082, + 0.06204593926668167, + 0.07600008696317673, + 0.12348289787769318 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22560253739356995 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning close-up, captured in the immersive style of cyberpunk animation, employs sharp focus and a shallow depth of field to capture a ritualistic moment. The scene begins with a pair of precision-engineered prosthetic limbs constructed of polished chrome and black carbon fiber. Within their intricate internal structure, tiny arcs of blue electricity dance through exposed wiring. Steady and deliberate, these hands manipulate a pair of black alloy chopsticks, gripping a crystalline dumpling, its filling barely visible. As the camera slowly tilts downward, a wet asphalt alley reflects the hazy glow of the magenta and cyan neon billboards blazing from the surrounding skyscrapers. Rain forms a thin mist in the air. Carefully, the chopsticks precisely place the tip of the dumpling into a rough, dark ceramic bowl filled with crimson fermented broad bean paste. The sauce's surface, far from static, shimmers with the faint glow of a data stream, composed of microscopic binary codes and digital matrices. At the moment the dumpling touches the sauce, the camera locks on, clearly capturing the sticky sauce being gently stirred, forming a brief depression under the slight pressure of the chopsticks, and then slowly and tensioningly wrapping around the tip of the dumpling. Its rich texture and the glimmer of data are intertwined, creating a unique atmosphere of focus and alienation that blends high technology and traditional food.", + "seed": 15495, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_5/index_4612_seed_15495_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.40304836481809614, + "vlm_logprob": -0.40304836481809614, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.40304836481809614, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown as precision-engineered prosthetic limbs made of polished chrome and black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do tiny arcs of blue electricity dance through the exposed wiring inside the prosthetic limbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward to reveal a wet asphalt alley reflecting magenta and cyan neon billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the chopsticks place a crystalline dumpling into a dark ceramic bowl filled with crimson fermented broad bean paste?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the sauce surface shimmer with a data stream of microscopic binary codes and digital matrices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.702109456062317 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2021094560623169 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.702109456062317, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -1.702109456062317, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12677554786205292, + 0.022475114092230797, + 0.016483565792441368, + 0.015149514190852642, + 0.03797975182533264, + 0.018369974568486214, + 0.019635995849967003, + 0.6936294436454773, + 0.01716867834329605, + 0.0323324054479599 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.702109456062317 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown as precision-engineered prosthetic limbs made of polished chrome and black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do tiny arcs of blue electricity dance through the exposed wiring inside the prosthetic limbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward to reveal a wet asphalt alley reflecting magenta and cyan neon billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the chopsticks place a crystalline dumpling into a dark ceramic bowl filled with crimson fermented broad bean paste?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the sauce surface shimmer with a data stream of microscopic binary codes and digital matrices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08911895751953125 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4641189575195312 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08911895751953125, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08911895751953125, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13222888112068176, + 0.03243529424071312, + 0.030019473284482956, + 0.0246351920068264, + 0.037024639546871185, + 0.021294541656970978, + 0.014091151766479015, + 0.6726180911064148, + 0.013333798386156559, + 0.022318875417113304 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08911895751953125 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown as precision-engineered prosthetic limbs made of polished chrome and black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do tiny arcs of blue electricity dance through the exposed wiring inside the prosthetic limbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward to reveal a wet asphalt alley reflecting magenta and cyan neon billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the chopsticks place a crystalline dumpling into a dark ceramic bowl filled with crimson fermented broad bean paste?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the sauce surface shimmer with a data stream of microscopic binary codes and digital matrices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043074704706668854 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168074607849121 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043074704706668854, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043074704706668854, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19830147922039032, + 0.08099187910556793, + 0.026638509705662727, + 0.018747741356492043, + 0.04849974066019058, + 0.029558522626757622, + 0.023332294076681137, + 0.5245003700256348, + 0.019743377342820168, + 0.029686059802770615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043074704706668854 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown as precision-engineered prosthetic limbs made of polished chrome and black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do tiny arcs of blue electricity dance through the exposed wiring inside the prosthetic limbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward to reveal a wet asphalt alley reflecting magenta and cyan neon billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the chopsticks place a crystalline dumpling into a dark ceramic bowl filled with crimson fermented broad bean paste?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the sauce surface shimmer with a data stream of microscopic binary codes and digital matrices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038112103939056396 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288112163543701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038112103939056396, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038112103939056396, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05004013702273369, + 0.01286461390554905, + 0.012725482694804668, + 0.013829153962433338, + 0.033246997743844986, + 0.024572312831878662, + 0.03372924029827118, + 0.6809622049331665, + 0.03764980658888817, + 0.10038001835346222 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038112103939056396 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the hands shown as precision-engineered prosthetic limbs made of polished chrome and black carbon fiber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Do tiny arcs of blue electricity dance through the exposed wiring inside the prosthetic limbs?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward to reveal a wet asphalt alley reflecting magenta and cyan neon billboards?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the chopsticks place a crystalline dumpling into a dark ceramic bowl filled with crimson fermented broad bean paste?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the sauce surface shimmer with a data stream of microscopic binary codes and digital matrices?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428266018629074 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017826557159424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428266018629074, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428266018629074, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03894973546266556, + 0.014908510260283947, + 0.013169568032026291, + 0.006993196904659271, + 0.019161343574523926, + 0.01963237300515175, + 0.020912181586027145, + 0.8262916803359985, + 0.016688460484147072, + 0.02329293265938759 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428266018629074 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_6/index_tensor([8867, 8867])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_6/index_tensor([8867, 8867])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2dc70b79d70d6dc1f4276bb4c1f9ace062b190aa --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_6/index_tensor([8867, 8867])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The film begins with a powerful close-up shot from a slightly upward angle. A heavy, weathered woodcutter's axe descends with thunderous force, its blade gleaming with a cold, metallic sheen, striking the very center of a massive, deep-grained, deep-orange pumpkin. The moment the axe strikes, the pumpkin splits in two, sending a cascade of vibrant orange flesh and seeds, mixed with juice, splattering violently in slow motion. Each drop of sap gleams in the soft, slanting golden light of the evening sun. At the climax moment when the pumpkin flesh splashes, the camera begins to pull back at an extremely fast speed, quickly expanding from the violent contact point between the axe and the pumpkin to a wider picture, revealing that the whole pumpkin is placed on a rough wooden stake, and the surrounding ground is covered with golden fallen leaves. The whole scene is full of primitive power and a destructive aesthetic unique to the harvest season, and finally freezes in a medium and long shot showing the dynamic results of destruction. The atmosphere is both wild and poetic.", + "seed": 12752, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_6/index_8867_seed_12752_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.033267786260694265, + "vlm_logprob": -0.033267786260694265, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.033267786260694265, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, weathered woodcutter's axe visible striking a massive, deep-orange pumpkin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pumpkin split in two, sending orange flesh, seeds, and juice splattering in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, slanting golden light of the evening sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back at an extremely fast speed from the impact point to reveal the pumpkin on a rough wooden stake surrounded by golden fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video freeze in a medium and long shot showing the dynamic results of the destruction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.090019591152668 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.465019702911377 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.090019591152668, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.090019591152668, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11837288737297058, + 0.029527034610509872, + 0.2721298336982727, + 0.1478312462568283, + 0.028532899916172028, + 0.028077004477381706, + 0.14368808269500732, + 0.06495627760887146, + 0.05723210796713829, + 0.10965266823768616 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.090019591152668 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, weathered woodcutter's axe visible striking a massive, deep-orange pumpkin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pumpkin split in two, sending orange flesh, seeds, and juice splattering in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, slanting golden light of the evening sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back at an extremely fast speed from the impact point to reveal the pumpkin on a rough wooden stake surrounded by golden fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video freeze in a medium and long shot showing the dynamic results of the destruction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018212120980024338 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01821231842041 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018212120980024338, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018212120980024338, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0673045665025711, + 0.04431711882352829, + 0.5295224189758301, + 0.1165633499622345, + 0.018697556108236313, + 0.01525405328720808, + 0.059988636523485184, + 0.03637847676873207, + 0.045752763748168945, + 0.06622111797332764 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018212120980024338 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, weathered woodcutter's axe visible striking a massive, deep-orange pumpkin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pumpkin split in two, sending orange flesh, seeds, and juice splattering in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, slanting golden light of the evening sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back at an extremely fast speed from the impact point to reveal the pumpkin on a rough wooden stake surrounded by golden fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video freeze in a medium and long shot showing the dynamic results of the destruction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024922997690737247 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002492427825928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024922997690737247, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024922997690737247, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05858910083770752, + 0.039139628410339355, + 0.042665883898735046, + 0.07365969568490982, + 0.06671497225761414, + 0.06201450526714325, + 0.16923679411411285, + 0.3319584131240845, + 0.10542547702789307, + 0.050595473498106 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024922997690737247 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, weathered woodcutter's axe visible striking a massive, deep-orange pumpkin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pumpkin split in two, sending orange flesh, seeds, and juice splattering in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, slanting golden light of the evening sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back at an extremely fast speed from the impact point to reveal the pumpkin on a rough wooden stake surrounded by golden fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video freeze in a medium and long shot showing the dynamic results of the destruction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306979477405548 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168069839477539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306979477405548, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306979477405548, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.061870962381362915, + 0.02099027670919895, + 0.11884450167417526, + 0.03558427095413208, + 0.10894913226366043, + 0.04995978996157646, + 0.1588716208934784, + 0.3187553584575653, + 0.09225225448608398, + 0.033921848982572556 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306979477405548 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, weathered woodcutter's axe visible striking a massive, deep-orange pumpkin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pumpkin split in two, sending orange flesh, seeds, and juice splattering in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, slanting golden light of the evening sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back at an extremely fast speed from the impact point to reveal the pumpkin on a rough wooden stake surrounded by golden fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video freeze in a medium and long shot showing the dynamic results of the destruction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012545124627649784 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387545108795166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012545124627649784, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012545124627649784, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05900906026363373, + 0.02448807656764984, + 0.07817713916301727, + 0.06051144376397133, + 0.03229653090238571, + 0.03083464503288269, + 0.0798700824379921, + 0.29549527168273926, + 0.11270906031131744, + 0.22660869359970093 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012545124627649784 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with a powerful close-up shot from a slightly upward angle. A heavy, weathered woodcutter's axe descends with thunderous force, its blade gleaming with a cold, metallic sheen, striking the very center of a massive, deep-grained, deep-orange pumpkin. The moment the axe strikes, the pumpkin splits in two, sending a cascade of vibrant orange flesh and seeds, mixed with juice, splattering violently in slow motion. Each drop of sap gleams in the soft, slanting golden light of the evening sun. At the climax moment when the pumpkin flesh splashes, the camera begins to pull back at an extremely fast speed, quickly expanding from the violent contact point between the axe and the pumpkin to a wider picture, revealing that the whole pumpkin is placed on a rough wooden stake, and the surrounding ground is covered with golden fallen leaves. The whole scene is full of primitive power and a destructive aesthetic unique to the harvest season, and finally freezes in a medium and long shot showing the dynamic results of destruction. The atmosphere is both wild and poetic.", + "seed": 12753, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_6/index_8867_seed_12753_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.1872885486111045, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1872885486111045, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1872885486111045, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, weathered woodcutter's axe visible striking a massive, deep-orange pumpkin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pumpkin split in two, sending orange flesh, seeds, and juice splattering in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, slanting golden light of the evening sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back at an extremely fast speed from the impact point to reveal the pumpkin on a rough wooden stake surrounded by golden fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video freeze in a medium and long shot showing the dynamic results of the destruction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7587751150131226 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6337751150131226 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7587751150131226, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7587751150131226, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06190793216228485, + 0.1170358657836914, + 0.13835129141807556, + 0.2708359360694885, + 0.05488407611846924, + 0.12294133752584457, + 0.02588917501270771, + 0.04514683410525322, + 0.09546229988336563, + 0.06754524260759354 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7587751150131226 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, weathered woodcutter's axe visible striking a massive, deep-orange pumpkin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pumpkin split in two, sending orange flesh, seeds, and juice splattering in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, slanting golden light of the evening sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back at an extremely fast speed from the impact point to reveal the pumpkin on a rough wooden stake surrounded by golden fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video freeze in a medium and long shot showing the dynamic results of the destruction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07903515547513962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790350437164307 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07903515547513962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07903515547513962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05028661713004112, + 0.1532045304775238, + 0.20304399728775024, + 0.15721026062965393, + 0.04997461289167404, + 0.06359526515007019, + 0.08068645000457764, + 0.05245457962155342, + 0.15367256104946136, + 0.03587114065885544 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07903515547513962 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, weathered woodcutter's axe visible striking a massive, deep-orange pumpkin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pumpkin split in two, sending orange flesh, seeds, and juice splattering in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, slanting golden light of the evening sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back at an extremely fast speed from the impact point to reveal the pumpkin on a rough wooden stake surrounded by golden fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video freeze in a medium and long shot showing the dynamic results of the destruction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006747082807123661 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006747245788574 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006747082807123661, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006747082807123661, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09091830253601074, + 0.07085279375314713, + 0.19046086072921753, + 0.061546459794044495, + 0.10397011786699295, + 0.2224598377943039, + 0.048961251974105835, + 0.026390068233013153, + 0.09034218639135361, + 0.09409807622432709 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006747082807123661 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, weathered woodcutter's axe visible striking a massive, deep-orange pumpkin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pumpkin split in two, sending orange flesh, seeds, and juice splattering in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, slanting golden light of the evening sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back at an extremely fast speed from the impact point to reveal the pumpkin on a rough wooden stake surrounded by golden fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video freeze in a medium and long shot showing the dynamic results of the destruction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06207237392663956 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812072277069092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06207237392663956, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06207237392663956, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.02590220235288143, + 0.05274876207113266, + 0.1813553273677826, + 0.08344719558954239, + 0.04731167107820511, + 0.38859474658966064, + 0.09709636121988297, + 0.03469342738389969, + 0.04709875211119652, + 0.041751548647880554 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06207237392663956 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, weathered woodcutter's axe visible striking a massive, deep-orange pumpkin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pumpkin split in two, sending orange flesh, seeds, and juice splattering in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, slanting golden light of the evening sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back at an extremely fast speed from the impact point to reveal the pumpkin on a rough wooden stake surrounded by golden fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video freeze in a medium and long shot showing the dynamic results of the destruction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029813015833497047 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529813051223755 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029813015833497047, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029813015833497047, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10102054476737976, + 0.09551016986370087, + 0.07288748770952225, + 0.3453447222709656, + 0.029959464445710182, + 0.14098306000232697, + 0.06733351945877075, + 0.03636479750275612, + 0.07767096906900406, + 0.032925285398960114 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029813015833497047 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with a powerful close-up shot from a slightly upward angle. A heavy, weathered woodcutter's axe descends with thunderous force, its blade gleaming with a cold, metallic sheen, striking the very center of a massive, deep-grained, deep-orange pumpkin. The moment the axe strikes, the pumpkin splits in two, sending a cascade of vibrant orange flesh and seeds, mixed with juice, splattering violently in slow motion. Each drop of sap gleams in the soft, slanting golden light of the evening sun. At the climax moment when the pumpkin flesh splashes, the camera begins to pull back at an extremely fast speed, quickly expanding from the violent contact point between the axe and the pumpkin to a wider picture, revealing that the whole pumpkin is placed on a rough wooden stake, and the surrounding ground is covered with golden fallen leaves. The whole scene is full of primitive power and a destructive aesthetic unique to the harvest season, and finally freezes in a medium and long shot showing the dynamic results of destruction. The atmosphere is both wild and poetic.", + "seed": 12754, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_6/index_8867_seed_12754_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.32903937362134456, + "vlm_logprob": -0.32903937362134456, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.32903937362134456, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, weathered woodcutter's axe visible striking a massive, deep-orange pumpkin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pumpkin split in two, sending orange flesh, seeds, and juice splattering in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, slanting golden light of the evening sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back at an extremely fast speed from the impact point to reveal the pumpkin on a rough wooden stake surrounded by golden fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video freeze in a medium and long shot showing the dynamic results of the destruction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3143413066864014 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.314341276884079 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.3143413066864014, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -1.3143413066864014, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2948353588581085, + 0.0973513051867485, + 0.10898233205080032, + 0.09249322861433029, + 0.22922731935977936, + 0.014327517710626125, + 0.05510803312063217, + 0.01957707665860653, + 0.06818042695522308, + 0.019917387515306473 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.3143413066864014 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, weathered woodcutter's axe visible striking a massive, deep-orange pumpkin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pumpkin split in two, sending orange flesh, seeds, and juice splattering in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, slanting golden light of the evening sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back at an extremely fast speed from the impact point to reveal the pumpkin on a rough wooden stake surrounded by golden fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video freeze in a medium and long shot showing the dynamic results of the destruction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20164769887924194 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016477584838867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20164769887924194, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20164769887924194, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2060394585132599, + 0.10208052396774292, + 0.1841781586408615, + 0.07508131116628647, + 0.3106796443462372, + 0.016335802152752876, + 0.017706530168652534, + 0.015616952441632748, + 0.0553242526948452, + 0.016957376152276993 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20164769887924194 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, weathered woodcutter's axe visible striking a massive, deep-orange pumpkin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pumpkin split in two, sending orange flesh, seeds, and juice splattering in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, slanting golden light of the evening sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back at an extremely fast speed from the impact point to reveal the pumpkin on a rough wooden stake surrounded by golden fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video freeze in a medium and long shot showing the dynamic results of the destruction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016089601442217827 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14108943939209 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016089601442217827, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016089601442217827, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26847949624061584, + 0.06956961750984192, + 0.05745260789990425, + 0.07077187299728394, + 0.2418285608291626, + 0.041474148631095886, + 0.13415928184986115, + 0.0419386588037014, + 0.041355304419994354, + 0.03297053277492523 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016089601442217827 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, weathered woodcutter's axe visible striking a massive, deep-orange pumpkin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pumpkin split in two, sending orange flesh, seeds, and juice splattering in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, slanting golden light of the evening sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back at an extremely fast speed from the impact point to reveal the pumpkin on a rough wooden stake surrounded by golden fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video freeze in a medium and long shot showing the dynamic results of the destruction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308977723121643 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680898666381836 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308977723121643, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308977723121643, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2596583664417267, + 0.02613605372607708, + 0.11787223815917969, + 0.055578380823135376, + 0.16412925720214844, + 0.018002813681960106, + 0.20275627076625824, + 0.02616354264318943, + 0.031809378415346146, + 0.097893625497818 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308977723121643 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, weathered woodcutter's axe visible striking a massive, deep-orange pumpkin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pumpkin split in two, sending orange flesh, seeds, and juice splattering in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, slanting golden light of the evening sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back at an extremely fast speed from the impact point to reveal the pumpkin on a rough wooden stake surrounded by golden fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video freeze in a medium and long shot showing the dynamic results of the destruction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002848386764526 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.69502854347229 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002848386764526, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002848386764526, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35792458057403564, + 0.08031883090734482, + 0.10877002775669098, + 0.03434594348073006, + 0.07536915689706802, + 0.03185242787003517, + 0.13988755643367767, + 0.042892131954431534, + 0.039879169315099716, + 0.08876018226146698 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002848386764526 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The film begins with a powerful close-up shot from a slightly upward angle. A heavy, weathered woodcutter's axe descends with thunderous force, its blade gleaming with a cold, metallic sheen, striking the very center of a massive, deep-grained, deep-orange pumpkin. The moment the axe strikes, the pumpkin splits in two, sending a cascade of vibrant orange flesh and seeds, mixed with juice, splattering violently in slow motion. Each drop of sap gleams in the soft, slanting golden light of the evening sun. At the climax moment when the pumpkin flesh splashes, the camera begins to pull back at an extremely fast speed, quickly expanding from the violent contact point between the axe and the pumpkin to a wider picture, revealing that the whole pumpkin is placed on a rough wooden stake, and the surrounding ground is covered with golden fallen leaves. The whole scene is full of primitive power and a destructive aesthetic unique to the harvest season, and finally freezes in a medium and long shot showing the dynamic results of destruction. The atmosphere is both wild and poetic.", + "seed": 12755, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_6/index_8867_seed_12755_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04312900379300118, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04312900379300118, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04312900379300118, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, weathered woodcutter's axe visible striking a massive, deep-orange pumpkin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pumpkin split in two, sending orange flesh, seeds, and juice splattering in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, slanting golden light of the evening sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back at an extremely fast speed from the impact point to reveal the pumpkin on a rough wooden stake surrounded by golden fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video freeze in a medium and long shot showing the dynamic results of the destruction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03866184130311012 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2886619567871094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03866184130311012, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03866184130311012, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12449926882982254, + 0.0287591814994812, + 0.07315827161073685, + 0.02561134286224842, + 0.12242476642131805, + 0.4814436435699463, + 0.01344632264226675, + 0.04202316328883171, + 0.06430232524871826, + 0.024331651628017426 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03866184130311012 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, weathered woodcutter's axe visible striking a massive, deep-orange pumpkin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pumpkin split in two, sending orange flesh, seeds, and juice splattering in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, slanting golden light of the evening sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back at an extremely fast speed from the impact point to reveal the pumpkin on a rough wooden stake surrounded by golden fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video freeze in a medium and long shot showing the dynamic results of the destruction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062080997973680496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120810985565186 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062080997973680496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062080997973680496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16829077899456024, + 0.04930509626865387, + 0.23286840319633484, + 0.03681739792227745, + 0.08256567269563675, + 0.09885364770889282, + 0.04772896692156792, + 0.08422092348337173, + 0.15597766637802124, + 0.04337145760655403 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062080997973680496 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, weathered woodcutter's axe visible striking a massive, deep-orange pumpkin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pumpkin split in two, sending orange flesh, seeds, and juice splattering in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, slanting golden light of the evening sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back at an extremely fast speed from the impact point to reveal the pumpkin on a rough wooden stake surrounded by golden fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video freeze in a medium and long shot showing the dynamic results of the destruction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016080215573310852 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141080379486084 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016080215573310852, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016080215573310852, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15177127718925476, + 0.10285649448633194, + 0.08481250703334808, + 0.06011999025940895, + 0.2614925503730774, + 0.20046399533748627, + 0.03775501251220703, + 0.026791656389832497, + 0.05223308503627777, + 0.02170342020690441 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016080215573310852 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, weathered woodcutter's axe visible striking a massive, deep-orange pumpkin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pumpkin split in two, sending orange flesh, seeds, and juice splattering in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, slanting golden light of the evening sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back at an extremely fast speed from the impact point to reveal the pumpkin on a rough wooden stake surrounded by golden fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video freeze in a medium and long shot showing the dynamic results of the destruction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08903618901968002 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464036226272583 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08903618901968002, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08903618901968002, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15836729109287262, + 0.04019438102841377, + 0.0848858579993248, + 0.037992119789123535, + 0.058408912271261215, + 0.4728158712387085, + 0.029113586992025375, + 0.028254663571715355, + 0.06591298431158066, + 0.024054354056715965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08903618901968002 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, weathered woodcutter's axe visible striking a massive, deep-orange pumpkin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the pumpkin split in two, sending orange flesh, seeds, and juice splattering in slow motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by soft, slanting golden light of the evening sun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pull back at an extremely fast speed from the impact point to reveal the pumpkin on a rough wooden stake surrounded by golden fallen leaves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the video freeze in a medium and long shot showing the dynamic results of the destruction?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978577509522438 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347856521606445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978577509522438, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978577509522438, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0951600894331932, + 0.07363210618495941, + 0.06663323938846588, + 0.043566327542066574, + 0.09245633333921432, + 0.46795639395713806, + 0.045635852962732315, + 0.029355742037296295, + 0.05573143810033798, + 0.029872477054595947 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978577509522438 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_7/index_tensor([5005, 5005])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_7/index_tensor([5005, 5005])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e409ef26a99f330162824c60b02d3d3d2fd59422 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_7/index_tensor([5005, 5005])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "sweeping, cinematic shot begins with a medium shot, the camera circling steadily around a small, black, cast-iron coffee table on a busy city sidewalk. The image focuses on a figure with an expression of profound tranquility, their eyes gently closed in pure bliss. They are striking, with wavy chestnut hair, and clad in a thick, forest-green wool coat, draped with a simple gray scarf. Their hands, with clean, unadorned fingers, lovingly wrap around a large, white ceramic cup, from which a delicate puff of steam curls into the cool air. The figure slowly raises the cup, tilting their head slightly back, and takes a slow, deliberate sip, a subtle smile playing on their lips. The soft, diffuse light of late afternoon illuminates the scene, casting a warm, inviting glow on the subject while the background remains vibrant. A blur of movement emanates from the city sidewalk, blurred pedestrian figures moving briskly, and the soft-focus lights of passing vehicles creating a beautiful bokeh. The overall color palette blends the warm, earthy tones of people’s clothing with the cool, neutral grays of the city’s sidewalks, creating a powerful atmosphere of quiet solitude amidst the city’s relentless energy.", + "seed": 24971, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_7/index_5005_seed_24971_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -1.4109424963593482, + "vlm_logprob": -1.4109424963593482, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 0.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -1.4109424963593482, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera circle steadily around a small, black, cast-iron coffee table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a thick, forest-green wool coat with a simple gray scarf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a large, white ceramic cup with visible steam curling from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the figure perform the action of slowly raising the cup, tilting their head back, and taking a deliberate sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a busy city sidewalk with blurred pedestrian figures and passing vehicles creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.502167701721191 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002167496830224991 + ], + "logprob_reward": -6.502167701721191, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -6.502167701721191, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14343522489070892, + 0.0621199905872345, + 0.0695139467716217, + 0.07012806087732315, + 0.04375462979078293, + 0.04310581088066101, + 0.11881525069475174, + 0.2322710156440735, + 0.15140508115291595, + 0.06545103341341019 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -6.502167701721191 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera circle steadily around a small, black, cast-iron coffee table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a thick, forest-green wool coat with a simple gray scarf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a large, white ceramic cup with visible steam curling from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the figure perform the action of slowly raising the cup, tilting their head back, and taking a deliberate sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a busy city sidewalk with blurred pedestrian figures and passing vehicles creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1610146462917328 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9110146760940552 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1610146462917328, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1610146462917328, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13929274678230286, + 0.061476126313209534, + 0.16731080412864685, + 0.0646645799279213, + 0.0425669401884079, + 0.05274459347128868, + 0.12236983329057693, + 0.14105363190174103, + 0.116238534450531, + 0.0922822505235672 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1610146462917328 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera circle steadily around a small, black, cast-iron coffee table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a thick, forest-green wool coat with a simple gray scarf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a large, white ceramic cup with visible steam curling from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the figure perform the action of slowly raising the cup, tilting their head back, and taking a deliberate sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a busy city sidewalk with blurred pedestrian figures and passing vehicles creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2018403261899948 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7018402814865112 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2018403261899948, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2018403261899948, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13108812272548676, + 0.07358509302139282, + 0.25558891892433167, + 0.05938037484884262, + 0.10239575058221817, + 0.05088863894343376, + 0.05042639747262001, + 0.15770323574543, + 0.037718676030635834, + 0.08122474700212479 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2018403261899948 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera circle steadily around a small, black, cast-iron coffee table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a thick, forest-green wool coat with a simple gray scarf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a large, white ceramic cup with visible steam curling from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the figure perform the action of slowly raising the cup, tilting their head back, and taking a deliberate sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a busy city sidewalk with blurred pedestrian figures and passing vehicles creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10052952170372009 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350529432296753 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10052952170372009, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10052952170372009, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10412129759788513, + 0.08125152438879013, + 0.09085249900817871, + 0.0340455137193203, + 0.059945035725831985, + 0.06134011968970299, + 0.12028378993272781, + 0.2835094928741455, + 0.0764564648270607, + 0.08819427341222763 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10052952170372009 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera circle steadily around a small, black, cast-iron coffee table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a thick, forest-green wool coat with a simple gray scarf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a large, white ceramic cup with visible steam curling from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the figure perform the action of slowly raising the cup, tilting their head back, and taking a deliberate sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a busy city sidewalk with blurred pedestrian figures and passing vehicles creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08916028589010239 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464160203933716 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08916028589010239, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08916028589010239, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3035673201084137, + 0.08925920724868774, + 0.03861267864704132, + 0.05317682400345802, + 0.12790943682193756, + 0.17295873165130615, + 0.08897623419761658, + 0.07931731641292572, + 0.026831941679120064, + 0.01939033716917038 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08916028589010239 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping, cinematic shot begins with a medium shot, the camera circling steadily around a small, black, cast-iron coffee table on a busy city sidewalk. The image focuses on a figure with an expression of profound tranquility, their eyes gently closed in pure bliss. They are striking, with wavy chestnut hair, and clad in a thick, forest-green wool coat, draped with a simple gray scarf. Their hands, with clean, unadorned fingers, lovingly wrap around a large, white ceramic cup, from which a delicate puff of steam curls into the cool air. The figure slowly raises the cup, tilting their head slightly back, and takes a slow, deliberate sip, a subtle smile playing on their lips. The soft, diffuse light of late afternoon illuminates the scene, casting a warm, inviting glow on the subject while the background remains vibrant. A blur of movement emanates from the city sidewalk, blurred pedestrian figures moving briskly, and the soft-focus lights of passing vehicles creating a beautiful bokeh. The overall color palette blends the warm, earthy tones of people’s clothing with the cool, neutral grays of the city’s sidewalks, creating a powerful atmosphere of quiet solitude amidst the city’s relentless energy.", + "seed": 24972, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_7/index_5005_seed_24972_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -1.5932453095912933, + "vlm_logprob": -1.5932453095912933, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 0.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -1.5932453095912933, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera circle steadily around a small, black, cast-iron coffee table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a thick, forest-green wool coat with a simple gray scarf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a large, white ceramic cup with visible steam curling from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the figure perform the action of slowly raising the cup, tilting their head back, and taking a deliberate sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a busy city sidewalk with blurred pedestrian figures and passing vehicles creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.501140594482422 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011406589765101671 + ], + "logprob_reward": -7.501140594482422, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -7.5, + "token_credit_reward": -7.501140594482422, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26695576310157776, + 0.08017465472221375, + 0.06162476912140846, + 0.03250492364168167, + 0.05651966109871864, + 0.03914181515574455, + 0.19864310324192047, + 0.07377799600362778, + 0.09872701019048691, + 0.09193036705255508 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -7.501140594482422 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera circle steadily around a small, black, cast-iron coffee table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a thick, forest-green wool coat with a simple gray scarf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a large, white ceramic cup with visible steam curling from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the figure perform the action of slowly raising the cup, tilting their head back, and taking a deliberate sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a busy city sidewalk with blurred pedestrian figures and passing vehicles creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2023358792066574 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7023358345031738 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2023358792066574, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2023358792066574, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3640100061893463, + 0.051289938390254974, + 0.040404874831438065, + 0.015273567289113998, + 0.05008012056350708, + 0.05926411226391792, + 0.08272362500429153, + 0.2350139021873474, + 0.06356040388345718, + 0.03837946429848671 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2023358792066574 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera circle steadily around a small, black, cast-iron coffee table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a thick, forest-green wool coat with a simple gray scarf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a large, white ceramic cup with visible steam curling from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the figure perform the action of slowly raising the cup, tilting their head back, and taking a deliberate sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a busy city sidewalk with blurred pedestrian figures and passing vehicles creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18016894161701202 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8051689863204956 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18016894161701202, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18016894161701202, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25323230028152466, + 0.06711604446172714, + 0.05699726566672325, + 0.053820446133613586, + 0.041515398770570755, + 0.024572262540459633, + 0.19054485857486725, + 0.04462996497750282, + 0.14338372647762299, + 0.12418768554925919 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18016894161701202 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera circle steadily around a small, black, cast-iron coffee table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a thick, forest-green wool coat with a simple gray scarf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a large, white ceramic cup with visible steam curling from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the figure perform the action of slowly raising the cup, tilting their head back, and taking a deliberate sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a busy city sidewalk with blurred pedestrian figures and passing vehicles creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04880408197641373 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0488040447235107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04880408197641373, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04880408197641373, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1358644813299179, + 0.022065725177526474, + 0.038285039365291595, + 0.04203667864203453, + 0.03685827925801277, + 0.08620139211416245, + 0.23036251962184906, + 0.10844440758228302, + 0.13643822073936462, + 0.16344323754310608 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04880408197641373 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera circle steadily around a small, black, cast-iron coffee table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a thick, forest-green wool coat with a simple gray scarf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a large, white ceramic cup with visible steam curling from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the figure perform the action of slowly raising the cup, tilting their head back, and taking a deliberate sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a busy city sidewalk with blurred pedestrian figures and passing vehicles creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03377705067396164 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087769985198975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03377705067396164, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03377705067396164, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13688057661056519, + 0.06934240460395813, + 0.023189246654510498, + 0.05801432207226753, + 0.049242738634347916, + 0.02118426002562046, + 0.06113950535655022, + 0.46703413128852844, + 0.06089501082897186, + 0.05307779833674431 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03377705067396164 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping, cinematic shot begins with a medium shot, the camera circling steadily around a small, black, cast-iron coffee table on a busy city sidewalk. The image focuses on a figure with an expression of profound tranquility, their eyes gently closed in pure bliss. They are striking, with wavy chestnut hair, and clad in a thick, forest-green wool coat, draped with a simple gray scarf. Their hands, with clean, unadorned fingers, lovingly wrap around a large, white ceramic cup, from which a delicate puff of steam curls into the cool air. The figure slowly raises the cup, tilting their head slightly back, and takes a slow, deliberate sip, a subtle smile playing on their lips. The soft, diffuse light of late afternoon illuminates the scene, casting a warm, inviting glow on the subject while the background remains vibrant. A blur of movement emanates from the city sidewalk, blurred pedestrian figures moving briskly, and the soft-focus lights of passing vehicles creating a beautiful bokeh. The overall color palette blends the warm, earthy tones of people’s clothing with the cool, neutral grays of the city’s sidewalks, creating a powerful atmosphere of quiet solitude amidst the city’s relentless energy.", + "seed": 24973, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_7/index_5005_seed_24973_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.7861371584236622, + "vlm_logprob": -0.7861371584236622, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.274999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.7861371584236622, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera circle steadily around a small, black, cast-iron coffee table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a thick, forest-green wool coat with a simple gray scarf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a large, white ceramic cup with visible steam curling from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the figure perform the action of slowly raising the cup, tilting their head back, and taking a deliberate sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a busy city sidewalk with blurred pedestrian figures and passing vehicles creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5313103199005127 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0313103124499321 + ], + "logprob_reward": -3.5313103199005127, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -3.5313103199005127, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1641107052564621, + 0.07868187874555588, + 0.029288645833730698, + 0.15354180335998535, + 0.07089682668447495, + 0.015105240978300571, + 0.07470805943012238, + 0.15178465843200684, + 0.1732962429523468, + 0.08858592063188553 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -3.5313103199005127 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera circle steadily around a small, black, cast-iron coffee table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a thick, forest-green wool coat with a simple gray scarf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a large, white ceramic cup with visible steam curling from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the figure perform the action of slowly raising the cup, tilting their head back, and taking a deliberate sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a busy city sidewalk with blurred pedestrian figures and passing vehicles creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1273866891860962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1273865699768066 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1273866891860962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.9999998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1273866891860962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14052750170230865, + 0.08682423084974289, + 0.053133539855480194, + 0.134463831782341, + 0.08891715854406357, + 0.04872408136725426, + 0.04905031621456146, + 0.14703728258609772, + 0.18440212309360504, + 0.06691994518041611 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1273866891860962 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera circle steadily around a small, black, cast-iron coffee table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a thick, forest-green wool coat with a simple gray scarf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a large, white ceramic cup with visible steam curling from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the figure perform the action of slowly raising the cup, tilting their head back, and taking a deliberate sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a busy city sidewalk with blurred pedestrian figures and passing vehicles creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062153369188308716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8121533393859863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062153369188308716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062153369188308716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15896980464458466, + 0.09560927748680115, + 0.21052393317222595, + 0.05864190682768822, + 0.07052928954362869, + 0.013387326151132584, + 0.08683647960424423, + 0.07845224440097809, + 0.09353508055210114, + 0.1335146278142929 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062153369188308716 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera circle steadily around a small, black, cast-iron coffee table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a thick, forest-green wool coat with a simple gray scarf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a large, white ceramic cup with visible steam curling from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the figure perform the action of slowly raising the cup, tilting their head back, and taking a deliberate sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a busy city sidewalk with blurred pedestrian figures and passing vehicles creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029846686869859695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529846668243408 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029846686869859695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029846686869859695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14323405921459198, + 0.08804235607385635, + 0.09238498657941818, + 0.07255081087350845, + 0.06905122101306915, + 0.05293571203947067, + 0.08682631701231003, + 0.11582840234041214, + 0.17598678171634674, + 0.1031593382358551 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029846686869859695 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera circle steadily around a small, black, cast-iron coffee table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a thick, forest-green wool coat with a simple gray scarf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a large, white ceramic cup with visible steam curling from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the figure perform the action of slowly raising the cup, tilting their head back, and taking a deliberate sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a busy city sidewalk with blurred pedestrian figures and passing vehicles creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17998872697353363 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049887418746948 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17998872697353363, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17998872697353363, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10003244876861572, + 0.06374764442443848, + 0.05807621777057648, + 0.02198813296854496, + 0.1870286762714386, + 0.16726799309253693, + 0.10334093123674393, + 0.06627456843852997, + 0.2050863355398178, + 0.02715708129107952 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17998872697353363 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping, cinematic shot begins with a medium shot, the camera circling steadily around a small, black, cast-iron coffee table on a busy city sidewalk. The image focuses on a figure with an expression of profound tranquility, their eyes gently closed in pure bliss. They are striking, with wavy chestnut hair, and clad in a thick, forest-green wool coat, draped with a simple gray scarf. Their hands, with clean, unadorned fingers, lovingly wrap around a large, white ceramic cup, from which a delicate puff of steam curls into the cool air. The figure slowly raises the cup, tilting their head slightly back, and takes a slow, deliberate sip, a subtle smile playing on their lips. The soft, diffuse light of late afternoon illuminates the scene, casting a warm, inviting glow on the subject while the background remains vibrant. A blur of movement emanates from the city sidewalk, blurred pedestrian figures moving briskly, and the soft-focus lights of passing vehicles creating a beautiful bokeh. The overall color palette blends the warm, earthy tones of people’s clothing with the cool, neutral grays of the city’s sidewalks, creating a powerful atmosphere of quiet solitude amidst the city’s relentless energy.", + "seed": 24974, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_7/index_5005_seed_24974_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -1.4875192992389201, + "vlm_logprob": -1.4875192992389201, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 0.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -1.4875192992389201, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera circle steadily around a small, black, cast-iron coffee table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a thick, forest-green wool coat with a simple gray scarf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a large, white ceramic cup with visible steam curling from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the figure perform the action of slowly raising the cup, tilting their head back, and taking a deliberate sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a busy city sidewalk with blurred pedestrian figures and passing vehicles creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876994609832764 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019944077357649803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -6.876994609832764, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -6.876994609832764, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25254198908805847, + 0.06480512022972107, + 0.06602970510721207, + 0.0646207258105278, + 0.05209597200155258, + 0.07599009573459625, + 0.05177796632051468, + 0.21502116322517395, + 0.05453307926654816, + 0.10258416831493378 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -6.876994609832764 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera circle steadily around a small, black, cast-iron coffee table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a thick, forest-green wool coat with a simple gray scarf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a large, white ceramic cup with visible steam curling from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the figure perform the action of slowly raising the cup, tilting their head back, and taking a deliberate sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a busy city sidewalk with blurred pedestrian figures and passing vehicles creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22628962993621826 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6012896299362183 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22628962993621826, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22628962993621826, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10927446186542511, + 0.042044688016176224, + 0.03962966427206993, + 0.04393859952688217, + 0.11109808087348938, + 0.10676678270101547, + 0.10377266258001328, + 0.15055754780769348, + 0.10096003115177155, + 0.1919575333595276 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22628962993621826 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera circle steadily around a small, black, cast-iron coffee table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a thick, forest-green wool coat with a simple gray scarf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a large, white ceramic cup with visible steam curling from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the figure perform the action of slowly raising the cup, tilting their head back, and taking a deliberate sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a busy city sidewalk with blurred pedestrian figures and passing vehicles creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20188766717910767 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.701887607574463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20188766717910767, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20188766717910767, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14596320688724518, + 0.09251639991998672, + 0.040355220437049866, + 0.04591559246182442, + 0.149916872382164, + 0.07225503772497177, + 0.0654834434390068, + 0.16159406304359436, + 0.07362333685159683, + 0.15237677097320557 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20188766717910767 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera circle steadily around a small, black, cast-iron coffee table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a thick, forest-green wool coat with a simple gray scarf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a large, white ceramic cup with visible steam curling from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the figure perform the action of slowly raising the cup, tilting their head back, and taking a deliberate sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a busy city sidewalk with blurred pedestrian figures and passing vehicles creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08927030116319656 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4642703533172607 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08927030116319656, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08927030116319656, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04431280493736267, + 0.0454765148460865, + 0.03286842629313469, + 0.04502422735095024, + 0.16309833526611328, + 0.40543562173843384, + 0.04450058937072754, + 0.051258690655231476, + 0.025508474558591843, + 0.1425163894891739 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08927030116319656 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the camera circle steadily around a small, black, cast-iron coffee table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the figure wearing a thick, forest-green wool coat with a simple gray scarf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the figure holding a large, white ceramic cup with visible steam curling from it?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the figure perform the action of slowly raising the cup, tilting their head back, and taking a deliberate sip?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a busy city sidewalk with blurred pedestrian figures and passing vehicles creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043154288083314896 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168154239654541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043154288083314896, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043154288083314896, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3301282823085785, + 0.057013969868421555, + 0.07767928391695023, + 0.036097295582294464, + 0.025431610643863678, + 0.06539923697710037, + 0.06829526275396347, + 0.28616222739219666, + 0.013515922240912914, + 0.040276944637298584 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043154288083314896 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_8/index_tensor([1386, 1386])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_8/index_tensor([1386, 1386])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..cc459a5238a611a7646c0ba940b8edbac8177a7f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_8/index_tensor([1386, 1386])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "stunning macro close-up, advancing at an almost imperceptible speed, locks the viewer's gaze firmly on a quantum ship composed entirely of a luminous energy field. The ship takes on an asymmetrical, polyhedral, crystalline form. At its core, a translucent energy stream, a blend of deep cosmic blue and fiery purple, flows like liquid crystal, emanating a steady and powerful inner glow. The ship's surface is coated in an incredibly complex, mirror-polished geometric lattice structure. Sharp edges seamlessly blend with smooth curves, and every tiny detail is rendered with pinpoint CGI realism, so clear that even the slightest ripples of energy flowing through it can be seen. Surrounding it is a deep, boundless black void, dotted with pinpoint distant stars and a barely perceptible, hazy wisp of nebula dust. The spacecraft is rotating slowly, steadily, and gracefully around its geometric center. Each rotation subtly refracts and reflects the energy flow on its surface, creating dynamic, ever-changing light and shadows through physically precise ray tracing. It's like a silent ballet of light taking place in the silent universe. The entire scene is filled with solemn technological beauty and awe-inspiring mystery in absolute silence.", + "seed": 30633, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_8/index_1386_seed_30633_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.03630111906677484, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03630111906677484, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03630111906677484, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ship composed entirely of a luminous energy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the ship have an asymmetrical, polyhedral, crystalline form with a mirror-polished geometric lattice structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a translucent energy stream at the ship's core blending deep cosmic blue and fiery purple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep black void dotted with distant stars and a hazy wisp of nebula dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the ship rotating slowly and steadily around its geometric center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06285261362791061 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812852621078491 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06285261362791061, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06285261362791061, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2152891308069229, + 0.21873190999031067, + 0.19196680188179016, + 0.06366948783397675, + 0.0935167744755745, + 0.03768156096339226, + 0.053204119205474854, + 0.02019367925822735, + 0.06488511711359024, + 0.040861379355192184 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06285261362791061 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ship composed entirely of a luminous energy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the ship have an asymmetrical, polyhedral, crystalline form with a mirror-polished geometric lattice structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a translucent energy stream at the ship's core blending deep cosmic blue and fiery purple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep black void dotted with distant stars and a hazy wisp of nebula dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the ship rotating slowly and steadily around its geometric center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08908024430274963 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464080333709717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08908024430274963, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08908024430274963, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10011240094900131, + 0.2939152121543884, + 0.25105369091033936, + 0.09147054702043533, + 0.061808738857507706, + 0.05972735211253166, + 0.013792703859508038, + 0.01116164680570364, + 0.09187698364257812, + 0.02508074790239334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08908024430274963 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ship composed entirely of a luminous energy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the ship have an asymmetrical, polyhedral, crystalline form with a mirror-polished geometric lattice structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a translucent energy stream at the ship's core blending deep cosmic blue and fiery purple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep black void dotted with distant stars and a hazy wisp of nebula dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the ship rotating slowly and steadily around its geometric center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005956517532467842 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130956649780273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005956517532467842, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005956517532467842, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14289933443069458, + 0.09684775769710541, + 0.10656515508890152, + 0.21001657843589783, + 0.07345546036958694, + 0.025419896468520164, + 0.0687522441148758, + 0.08744339644908905, + 0.1476946771144867, + 0.04090544581413269 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005956517532467842 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ship composed entirely of a luminous energy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the ship have an asymmetrical, polyhedral, crystalline form with a mirror-polished geometric lattice structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a translucent energy stream at the ship's core blending deep cosmic blue and fiery purple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep black void dotted with distant stars and a hazy wisp of nebula dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the ship rotating slowly and steadily around its geometric center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012539003044366837 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387538909912109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012539003044366837, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012539003044366837, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31749632954597473, + 0.06763618439435959, + 0.03944644704461098, + 0.029856286942958832, + 0.02041596546769142, + 0.0681207925081253, + 0.248890683054924, + 0.19263489544391632, + 0.007206839509308338, + 0.008295589126646519 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012539003044366837 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ship composed entirely of a luminous energy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the ship have an asymmetrical, polyhedral, crystalline form with a mirror-polished geometric lattice structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a translucent energy stream at the ship's core blending deep cosmic blue and fiery purple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep black void dotted with distant stars and a hazy wisp of nebula dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the ship rotating slowly and steadily around its geometric center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0110772168263793 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511077404022217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0110772168263793, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0110772168263793, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3314419984817505, + 0.08204170316457748, + 0.08312362432479858, + 0.06146211922168732, + 0.03745456784963608, + 0.08511278033256531, + 0.15637178719043732, + 0.07210074365139008, + 0.07000532746315002, + 0.020885378122329712 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0110772168263793 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning macro close-up, advancing at an almost imperceptible speed, locks the viewer's gaze firmly on a quantum ship composed entirely of a luminous energy field. The ship takes on an asymmetrical, polyhedral, crystalline form. At its core, a translucent energy stream, a blend of deep cosmic blue and fiery purple, flows like liquid crystal, emanating a steady and powerful inner glow. The ship's surface is coated in an incredibly complex, mirror-polished geometric lattice structure. Sharp edges seamlessly blend with smooth curves, and every tiny detail is rendered with pinpoint CGI realism, so clear that even the slightest ripples of energy flowing through it can be seen. Surrounding it is a deep, boundless black void, dotted with pinpoint distant stars and a barely perceptible, hazy wisp of nebula dust. The spacecraft is rotating slowly, steadily, and gracefully around its geometric center. Each rotation subtly refracts and reflects the energy flow on its surface, creating dynamic, ever-changing light and shadows through physically precise ray tracing. It's like a silent ballet of light taking place in the silent universe. The entire scene is filled with solemn technological beauty and awe-inspiring mystery in absolute silence.", + "seed": 30634, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_8/index_1386_seed_30634_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.028630123101174833, + "vlm_logprob": -0.028630123101174833, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.028630123101174833, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ship composed entirely of a luminous energy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the ship have an asymmetrical, polyhedral, crystalline form with a mirror-polished geometric lattice structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a translucent energy stream at the ship's core blending deep cosmic blue and fiery purple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep black void dotted with distant stars and a hazy wisp of nebula dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the ship rotating slowly and steadily around its geometric center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07986127585172653 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5798611640930176 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07986127585172653, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07986127585172653, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14244355261325836, + 0.04509669914841652, + 0.061368562281131744, + 0.06544331461191177, + 0.05146732181310654, + 0.1839372217655182, + 0.07100881636142731, + 0.28903546929359436, + 0.04055594280362129, + 0.04964306950569153 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07986127585172653 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ship composed entirely of a luminous energy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the ship have an asymmetrical, polyhedral, crystalline form with a mirror-polished geometric lattice structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a translucent energy stream at the ship's core blending deep cosmic blue and fiery purple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep black void dotted with distant stars and a hazy wisp of nebula dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the ship rotating slowly and steadily around its geometric center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011094666086137295 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511094570159912 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011094666086137295, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011094666086137295, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1788710206747055, + 0.027668513357639313, + 0.06131099537014961, + 0.09546421468257904, + 0.03738952800631523, + 0.09346677362918854, + 0.04525511711835861, + 0.2859983444213867, + 0.08010601997375488, + 0.09446949511766434 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011094666086137295 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ship composed entirely of a luminous energy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the ship have an asymmetrical, polyhedral, crystalline form with a mirror-polished geometric lattice structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a translucent energy stream at the ship's core blending deep cosmic blue and fiery purple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep black void dotted with distant stars and a hazy wisp of nebula dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the ship rotating slowly and steadily around its geometric center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634631097316742 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651346206665039 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634631097316742, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634631097316742, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17748625576496124, + 0.14216074347496033, + 0.04680555686354637, + 0.24275772273540497, + 0.07496602088212967, + 0.10701635479927063, + 0.0591297373175621, + 0.06561247259378433, + 0.03539741784334183, + 0.04866780713200569 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634631097316742 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ship composed entirely of a luminous energy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the ship have an asymmetrical, polyhedral, crystalline form with a mirror-polished geometric lattice structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a translucent energy stream at the ship's core blending deep cosmic blue and fiery purple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep black void dotted with distant stars and a hazy wisp of nebula dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the ship rotating slowly and steadily around its geometric center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009780699387192726 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347808837890625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009780699387192726, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009780699387192726, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31598198413848877, + 0.14158746600151062, + 0.03321855887770653, + 0.06424817442893982, + 0.1975567489862442, + 0.027315964922308922, + 0.04730422422289848, + 0.06891343742609024, + 0.051482606679201126, + 0.05239081010222435 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009780699387192726 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ship composed entirely of a luminous energy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the ship have an asymmetrical, polyhedral, crystalline form with a mirror-polished geometric lattice structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a translucent energy stream at the ship's core blending deep cosmic blue and fiery purple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep black void dotted with distant stars and a hazy wisp of nebula dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the ship rotating slowly and steadily around its geometric center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016067663207650185 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410675048828125 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016067663207650185, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016067663207650185, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15081076323986053, + 0.08616580069065094, + 0.040781471878290176, + 0.05424118414521217, + 0.14141052961349487, + 0.1552148312330246, + 0.11168630421161652, + 0.11668626964092255, + 0.10790882259607315, + 0.0350940115749836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016067663207650185 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning macro close-up, advancing at an almost imperceptible speed, locks the viewer's gaze firmly on a quantum ship composed entirely of a luminous energy field. The ship takes on an asymmetrical, polyhedral, crystalline form. At its core, a translucent energy stream, a blend of deep cosmic blue and fiery purple, flows like liquid crystal, emanating a steady and powerful inner glow. The ship's surface is coated in an incredibly complex, mirror-polished geometric lattice structure. Sharp edges seamlessly blend with smooth curves, and every tiny detail is rendered with pinpoint CGI realism, so clear that even the slightest ripples of energy flowing through it can be seen. Surrounding it is a deep, boundless black void, dotted with pinpoint distant stars and a barely perceptible, hazy wisp of nebula dust. The spacecraft is rotating slowly, steadily, and gracefully around its geometric center. Each rotation subtly refracts and reflects the energy flow on its surface, creating dynamic, ever-changing light and shadows through physically precise ray tracing. It's like a silent ballet of light taking place in the silent universe. The entire scene is filled with solemn technological beauty and awe-inspiring mystery in absolute silence.", + "seed": 30635, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_8/index_1386_seed_30635_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.07972043864428997, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07972043864428997, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07972043864428997, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ship composed entirely of a luminous energy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the ship have an asymmetrical, polyhedral, crystalline form with a mirror-polished geometric lattice structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a translucent energy stream at the ship's core blending deep cosmic blue and fiery purple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep black void dotted with distant stars and a hazy wisp of nebula dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the ship rotating slowly and steadily around its geometric center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22750547528266907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6025054454803467 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22750547528266907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22750547528266907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18568749725818634, + 0.09286733716726303, + 0.06337802857160568, + 0.08824802190065384, + 0.04296064004302025, + 0.0736238956451416, + 0.15192030370235443, + 0.11851539462804794, + 0.03799359127879143, + 0.14480526745319366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22750547528266907 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ship composed entirely of a luminous energy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the ship have an asymmetrical, polyhedral, crystalline form with a mirror-polished geometric lattice structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a translucent energy stream at the ship's core blending deep cosmic blue and fiery purple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep black void dotted with distant stars and a hazy wisp of nebula dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the ship rotating slowly and steadily around its geometric center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062098030000925064 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120980262756348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062098030000925064, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062098030000925064, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16367948055267334, + 0.039601001888513565, + 0.08649295568466187, + 0.18967074155807495, + 0.057458747178316116, + 0.06998690962791443, + 0.0822066217660904, + 0.1089305579662323, + 0.0720500722527504, + 0.12992297112941742 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062098030000925064 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ship composed entirely of a luminous energy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the ship have an asymmetrical, polyhedral, crystalline form with a mirror-polished geometric lattice structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a translucent energy stream at the ship's core blending deep cosmic blue and fiery purple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep black void dotted with distant stars and a hazy wisp of nebula dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the ship rotating slowly and steadily around its geometric center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205982342362404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120598793029785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205982342362404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205982342362404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12956102192401886, + 0.09472048282623291, + 0.2420722097158432, + 0.05024668946862221, + 0.04308207333087921, + 0.05040569603443146, + 0.044126659631729126, + 0.16603036224842072, + 0.11716591566801071, + 0.06258891522884369 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205982342362404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ship composed entirely of a luminous energy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the ship have an asymmetrical, polyhedral, crystalline form with a mirror-polished geometric lattice structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a translucent energy stream at the ship's core blending deep cosmic blue and fiery purple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep black void dotted with distant stars and a hazy wisp of nebula dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the ship rotating slowly and steadily around its geometric center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026351653039455414 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513516902923584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026351653039455414, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026351653039455414, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07331578433513641, + 0.13170534372329712, + 0.05876733362674713, + 0.21813248097896576, + 0.01715359464287758, + 0.015688398852944374, + 0.02625044621527195, + 0.3244953155517578, + 0.041874293237924576, + 0.09261700510978699 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026351653039455414 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ship composed entirely of a luminous energy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the ship have an asymmetrical, polyhedral, crystalline form with a mirror-polished geometric lattice structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a translucent energy stream at the ship's core blending deep cosmic blue and fiery purple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep black void dotted with distant stars and a hazy wisp of nebula dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the ship rotating slowly and steadily around its geometric center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020587211474776268 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895587205886841 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020587211474776268, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020587211474776268, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13793917000293732, + 0.18605086207389832, + 0.09160294383764267, + 0.04473406821489334, + 0.1519971638917923, + 0.10011152178049088, + 0.04202388972043991, + 0.10117072612047195, + 0.0335068441927433, + 0.11086281388998032 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020587211474776268 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning macro close-up, advancing at an almost imperceptible speed, locks the viewer's gaze firmly on a quantum ship composed entirely of a luminous energy field. The ship takes on an asymmetrical, polyhedral, crystalline form. At its core, a translucent energy stream, a blend of deep cosmic blue and fiery purple, flows like liquid crystal, emanating a steady and powerful inner glow. The ship's surface is coated in an incredibly complex, mirror-polished geometric lattice structure. Sharp edges seamlessly blend with smooth curves, and every tiny detail is rendered with pinpoint CGI realism, so clear that even the slightest ripples of energy flowing through it can be seen. Surrounding it is a deep, boundless black void, dotted with pinpoint distant stars and a barely perceptible, hazy wisp of nebula dust. The spacecraft is rotating slowly, steadily, and gracefully around its geometric center. Each rotation subtly refracts and reflects the energy flow on its surface, creating dynamic, ever-changing light and shadows through physically precise ray tracing. It's like a silent ballet of light taking place in the silent universe. The entire scene is filled with solemn technological beauty and awe-inspiring mystery in absolute silence.", + "seed": 30636, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_8/index_1386_seed_30636_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.22060513151809574, + "vlm_logprob": -0.22060513151809574, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.22060513151809574, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ship composed entirely of a luminous energy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the ship have an asymmetrical, polyhedral, crystalline form with a mirror-polished geometric lattice structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a translucent energy stream at the ship's core blending deep cosmic blue and fiery purple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep black void dotted with distant stars and a hazy wisp of nebula dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the ship rotating slowly and steadily around its geometric center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22622869908809662 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6012287139892578 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22622869908809662, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22622869908809662, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10249224305152893, + 0.038429442793130875, + 0.37649503350257874, + 0.10097908228635788, + 0.06931942701339722, + 0.038558267056941986, + 0.04523823782801628, + 0.028411585837602615, + 0.04926629364490509, + 0.15081042051315308 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22622869908809662 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ship composed entirely of a luminous energy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the ship have an asymmetrical, polyhedral, crystalline form with a mirror-polished geometric lattice structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a translucent energy stream at the ship's core blending deep cosmic blue and fiery purple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep black void dotted with distant stars and a hazy wisp of nebula dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the ship rotating slowly and steadily around its geometric center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.826165497303009 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.576165497303009 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.826165497303009, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.826165497303009, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18693740665912628, + 0.09569055587053299, + 0.166936993598938, + 0.05949170142412186, + 0.13891910016536713, + 0.15509241819381714, + 0.022915195673704147, + 0.04541425406932831, + 0.044651806354522705, + 0.08395056426525116 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.826165497303009 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ship composed entirely of a luminous energy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the ship have an asymmetrical, polyhedral, crystalline form with a mirror-polished geometric lattice structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a translucent energy stream at the ship's core blending deep cosmic blue and fiery purple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep black void dotted with distant stars and a hazy wisp of nebula dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the ship rotating slowly and steadily around its geometric center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006747792940586805 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006747722625732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006747792940586805, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006747792940586805, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13925229012966156, + 0.1460750699043274, + 0.21868161857128143, + 0.042540401220321655, + 0.08212220668792725, + 0.08833669126033783, + 0.13497576117515564, + 0.0588388629257679, + 0.043848153203725815, + 0.04532894492149353 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006747792940586805 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ship composed entirely of a luminous energy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the ship have an asymmetrical, polyhedral, crystalline form with a mirror-polished geometric lattice structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a translucent energy stream at the ship's core blending deep cosmic blue and fiery purple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep black void dotted with distant stars and a hazy wisp of nebula dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the ship rotating slowly and steadily around its geometric center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020586160942912102 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955862522125244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020586160942912102, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020586160942912102, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1804126352071762, + 0.043343350291252136, + 0.5217586755752563, + 0.026430312544107437, + 0.060061439871788025, + 0.064697265625, + 0.014494374394416809, + 0.020811252295970917, + 0.023201504722237587, + 0.04478919506072998 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020586160942912102 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a ship composed entirely of a luminous energy field?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the ship have an asymmetrical, polyhedral, crystalline form with a mirror-polished geometric lattice structure?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is there a translucent energy stream at the ship's core blending deep cosmic blue and fiery purple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a deep black void dotted with distant stars and a hazy wisp of nebula dust?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the ship rotating slowly and steadily around its geometric center?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0232975073158741 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732975482940674 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0232975073158741, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0232975073158741, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22939960658550262, + 0.09231020510196686, + 0.16399632394313812, + 0.08358357846736908, + 0.058238301426172256, + 0.09513307362794876, + 0.03456590697169304, + 0.06402189284563065, + 0.06879690289497375, + 0.10995429754257202 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0232975073158741 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_9/index_tensor([485, 485])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_9/index_tensor([485, 485])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..74e52bc9023d1ee5684df91ed109f5a97fcd5dbe --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_9/index_tensor([485, 485])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic low-angle shot begins just behind the carriage, parallel to the rapidly spinning wheels. A richly decorated, inky-black classical carriage gallops frantically along a rain-soaked, muddy dirt road. Four muscular, glossy-coated black horses pull the carriage with all their might, their hooves splashing muddy water with every thump, and hot white steam emanating from their snouts. Massive wooden wheels, edged with iron bars, roll through deeply rutted paths, sending clumps of sticky black mud violently into the air, arcing across the intricately carved carriage and the surrounding bare tree trunks. The camera then rapidly zooms out, shifting from a chaotic, dynamic close-up to a sweeping aerial perspective, revealing a vast, desolate scene: the carriage a tiny, hurried speck on the lonely road winding through a gloomy forest. Shrouded by a heavy gray sky, the weak diffuse light of the afternoon can hardly penetrate the thick clouds. The entire picture presents a low-saturation cinematic tone, full of urgency, struggle and epic loneliness.", + "seed": 3458, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_9/index_485_seed_3458_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1645861219149083, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1645861219149083, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1645861219149083, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a richly decorated, inky-black classical carriage being pulled by four muscular black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the horses shown with hot white steam emanating from their snouts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carriage travel along a rain-soaked, muddy dirt road with massive wooden wheels edged with iron bars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot behind the carriage and then rapidly zoom out to a sweeping aerial perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a gloomy forest with bare tree trunks under a heavy gray sky with low-saturation lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08025388419628143 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.580253839492798 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08025388419628143, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08025388419628143, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1331692785024643, + 0.16373801231384277, + 0.06997188180685043, + 0.15004806220531464, + 0.09598101675510406, + 0.053064215928316116, + 0.08589984476566315, + 0.10701904445886612, + 0.08430835604667664, + 0.05680030956864357 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08025388419628143 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a richly decorated, inky-black classical carriage being pulled by four muscular black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the horses shown with hot white steam emanating from their snouts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carriage travel along a rain-soaked, muddy dirt road with massive wooden wheels edged with iron bars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot behind the carriage and then rapidly zoom out to a sweeping aerial perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a gloomy forest with bare tree trunks under a heavy gray sky with low-saturation lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14281275868415833 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017812728881836 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14281275868415833, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14281275868415833, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0881887674331665, + 0.06897667795419693, + 0.28028276562690735, + 0.1801285743713379, + 0.018479811027646065, + 0.08312404155731201, + 0.06098981574177742, + 0.0617794543504715, + 0.13505752384662628, + 0.022992579266428947 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14281275868415833 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a richly decorated, inky-black classical carriage being pulled by four muscular black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the horses shown with hot white steam emanating from their snouts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carriage travel along a rain-soaked, muddy dirt road with massive wooden wheels edged with iron bars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot behind the carriage and then rapidly zoom out to a sweeping aerial perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a gloomy forest with bare tree trunks under a heavy gray sky with low-saturation lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058802917599678 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895587921142578 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058802917599678, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058802917599678, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04655350744724274, + 0.08002178370952606, + 0.41217130422592163, + 0.10247626155614853, + 0.02176857739686966, + 0.05869586765766144, + 0.03376200050115585, + 0.06357701867818832, + 0.12715579569339752, + 0.05381784960627556 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058802917599678 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a richly decorated, inky-black classical carriage being pulled by four muscular black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the horses shown with hot white steam emanating from their snouts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carriage travel along a rain-soaked, muddy dirt road with massive wooden wheels edged with iron bars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot behind the carriage and then rapidly zoom out to a sweeping aerial perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a gloomy forest with bare tree trunks under a heavy gray sky with low-saturation lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.57608562707901 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.82608562707901 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.57608562707901, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.57608562707901, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09348951280117035, + 0.054789457470178604, + 0.20478084683418274, + 0.16160964965820312, + 0.04782519489526749, + 0.042953282594680786, + 0.02658514678478241, + 0.08902697265148163, + 0.23245911300182343, + 0.04648081585764885 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.57608562707901 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a richly decorated, inky-black classical carriage being pulled by four muscular black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the horses shown with hot white steam emanating from their snouts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carriage travel along a rain-soaked, muddy dirt road with massive wooden wheels edged with iron bars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot behind the carriage and then rapidly zoom out to a sweeping aerial perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a gloomy forest with bare tree trunks under a heavy gray sky with low-saturation lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003190310439094901 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753190517425537 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003190310439094901, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003190310439094901, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14072290062904358, + 0.08075624704360962, + 0.1185205727815628, + 0.22405262291431427, + 0.03252072632312775, + 0.05077015236020088, + 0.07698684185743332, + 0.09205490350723267, + 0.11119884252548218, + 0.07241617143154144 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003190310439094901 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic low-angle shot begins just behind the carriage, parallel to the rapidly spinning wheels. A richly decorated, inky-black classical carriage gallops frantically along a rain-soaked, muddy dirt road. Four muscular, glossy-coated black horses pull the carriage with all their might, their hooves splashing muddy water with every thump, and hot white steam emanating from their snouts. Massive wooden wheels, edged with iron bars, roll through deeply rutted paths, sending clumps of sticky black mud violently into the air, arcing across the intricately carved carriage and the surrounding bare tree trunks. The camera then rapidly zooms out, shifting from a chaotic, dynamic close-up to a sweeping aerial perspective, revealing a vast, desolate scene: the carriage a tiny, hurried speck on the lonely road winding through a gloomy forest. Shrouded by a heavy gray sky, the weak diffuse light of the afternoon can hardly penetrate the thick clouds. The entire picture presents a low-saturation cinematic tone, full of urgency, struggle and epic loneliness.", + "seed": 3459, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_9/index_485_seed_3459_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.3755106910131872, + "vlm_logprob": -0.3755106910131872, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.6749999880790711, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.3755106910131872, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a richly decorated, inky-black classical carriage being pulled by four muscular black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the horses shown with hot white steam emanating from their snouts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carriage travel along a rain-soaked, muddy dirt road with massive wooden wheels edged with iron bars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot behind the carriage and then rapidly zoom out to a sweeping aerial perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a gloomy forest with bare tree trunks under a heavy gray sky with low-saturation lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.975872278213501 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.475872278213501 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.975872278213501, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.975872278213501, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5893107652664185, + 0.10088521242141724, + 0.02460954338312149, + 0.029449012130498886, + 0.049593716859817505, + 0.03687654435634613, + 0.060427192598581314, + 0.050065819174051285, + 0.023062951862812042, + 0.03571922332048416 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.975872278213501 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a richly decorated, inky-black classical carriage being pulled by four muscular black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the horses shown with hot white steam emanating from their snouts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carriage travel along a rain-soaked, muddy dirt road with massive wooden wheels edged with iron bars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot behind the carriage and then rapidly zoom out to a sweeping aerial perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a gloomy forest with bare tree trunks under a heavy gray sky with low-saturation lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42891865968704224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539186000823975 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42891865968704224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.6249999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42891865968704224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7958034873008728, + 0.024424700066447258, + 0.03981556370854378, + 0.018283627927303314, + 0.011713620275259018, + 0.041255101561546326, + 0.013023477979004383, + 0.02769951894879341, + 0.012105240486562252, + 0.015875615179538727 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42891865968704224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a richly decorated, inky-black classical carriage being pulled by four muscular black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the horses shown with hot white steam emanating from their snouts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carriage travel along a rain-soaked, muddy dirt road with massive wooden wheels edged with iron bars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot behind the carriage and then rapidly zoom out to a sweeping aerial perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a gloomy forest with bare tree trunks under a heavy gray sky with low-saturation lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07899472862482071 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789947509765625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07899472862482071, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07899472862482071, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5190518498420715, + 0.062287572771310806, + 0.01962857134640217, + 0.030351027846336365, + 0.08860243856906891, + 0.07916634529829025, + 0.07584454864263535, + 0.03516969829797745, + 0.06747130304574966, + 0.02242671698331833 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07899472862482071 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a richly decorated, inky-black classical carriage being pulled by four muscular black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the horses shown with hot white steam emanating from their snouts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carriage travel along a rain-soaked, muddy dirt road with massive wooden wheels edged with iron bars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot behind the carriage and then rapidly zoom out to a sweeping aerial perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a gloomy forest with bare tree trunks under a heavy gray sky with low-saturation lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38703373074531555 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370337009429932 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38703373074531555, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38703373074531555, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06480299681425095, + 0.07534261792898178, + 0.0912357047200203, + 0.06931412220001221, + 0.046384066343307495, + 0.0454896055161953, + 0.17310182750225067, + 0.13337799906730652, + 0.2696015536785126, + 0.03134947642683983 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38703373074531555 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a richly decorated, inky-black classical carriage being pulled by four muscular black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the horses shown with hot white steam emanating from their snouts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carriage travel along a rain-soaked, muddy dirt road with massive wooden wheels edged with iron bars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot behind the carriage and then rapidly zoom out to a sweeping aerial perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a gloomy forest with bare tree trunks under a heavy gray sky with low-saturation lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006734057795256376 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067338943481445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006734057795256376, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006734057795256376, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35982152819633484, + 0.02538023702800274, + 0.052528996020555496, + 0.022330638021230698, + 0.02774040214717388, + 0.02229161746799946, + 0.036666497588157654, + 0.2954760193824768, + 0.0782276913523674, + 0.07953638583421707 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006734057795256376 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic low-angle shot begins just behind the carriage, parallel to the rapidly spinning wheels. A richly decorated, inky-black classical carriage gallops frantically along a rain-soaked, muddy dirt road. Four muscular, glossy-coated black horses pull the carriage with all their might, their hooves splashing muddy water with every thump, and hot white steam emanating from their snouts. Massive wooden wheels, edged with iron bars, roll through deeply rutted paths, sending clumps of sticky black mud violently into the air, arcing across the intricately carved carriage and the surrounding bare tree trunks. The camera then rapidly zooms out, shifting from a chaotic, dynamic close-up to a sweeping aerial perspective, revealing a vast, desolate scene: the carriage a tiny, hurried speck on the lonely road winding through a gloomy forest. Shrouded by a heavy gray sky, the weak diffuse light of the afternoon can hardly penetrate the thick clouds. The entire picture presents a low-saturation cinematic tone, full of urgency, struggle and epic loneliness.", + "seed": 3460, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_9/index_485_seed_3460_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.19119922784157098, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19119922784157098, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19119922784157098, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a richly decorated, inky-black classical carriage being pulled by four muscular black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the horses shown with hot white steam emanating from their snouts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carriage travel along a rain-soaked, muddy dirt road with massive wooden wheels edged with iron bars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot behind the carriage and then rapidly zoom out to a sweeping aerial perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a gloomy forest with bare tree trunks under a heavy gray sky with low-saturation lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5776476860046387 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8276476860046387 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5776476860046387, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5776476860046387, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2688996195793152, + 0.07994432747364044, + 0.17613941431045532, + 0.040764641016721725, + 0.21288107335567474, + 0.034384846687316895, + 0.060415118932724, + 0.027284685522317886, + 0.050560712814331055, + 0.048725567758083344 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5776476860046387 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a richly decorated, inky-black classical carriage being pulled by four muscular black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the horses shown with hot white steam emanating from their snouts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carriage travel along a rain-soaked, muddy dirt road with massive wooden wheels edged with iron bars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot behind the carriage and then rapidly zoom out to a sweeping aerial perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a gloomy forest with bare tree trunks under a heavy gray sky with low-saturation lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20160453021526337 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016044855117798 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20160453021526337, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20160453021526337, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1862224042415619, + 0.12742069363594055, + 0.26315635442733765, + 0.12908712029457092, + 0.10309342294931412, + 0.05268531292676926, + 0.05735421180725098, + 0.030989114195108414, + 0.020352276042103767, + 0.029639117419719696 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20160453021526337 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a richly decorated, inky-black classical carriage being pulled by four muscular black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the horses shown with hot white steam emanating from their snouts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carriage travel along a rain-soaked, muddy dirt road with massive wooden wheels edged with iron bars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot behind the carriage and then rapidly zoom out to a sweeping aerial perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a gloomy forest with bare tree trunks under a heavy gray sky with low-saturation lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014203174039721489 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264203071594238 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014203174039721489, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014203174039721489, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1876855045557022, + 0.06318193674087524, + 0.07060619443655014, + 0.084161676466465, + 0.13195718824863434, + 0.1081177219748497, + 0.1336803138256073, + 0.06197161599993706, + 0.0750398188829422, + 0.08359798043966293 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014203174039721489 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a richly decorated, inky-black classical carriage being pulled by four muscular black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the horses shown with hot white steam emanating from their snouts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carriage travel along a rain-soaked, muddy dirt road with massive wooden wheels edged with iron bars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot behind the carriage and then rapidly zoom out to a sweeping aerial perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a gloomy forest with bare tree trunks under a heavy gray sky with low-saturation lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16034434735774994 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103443622589111 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16034434735774994, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16034434735774994, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36544570326805115, + 0.04638577997684479, + 0.05558040365576744, + 0.06966902315616608, + 0.03965136781334877, + 0.117823526263237, + 0.06882375478744507, + 0.08452780544757843, + 0.12215197831392288, + 0.029940705746412277 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16034434735774994 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a richly decorated, inky-black classical carriage being pulled by four muscular black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the horses shown with hot white steam emanating from their snouts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carriage travel along a rain-soaked, muddy dirt road with massive wooden wheels edged with iron bars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot behind the carriage and then rapidly zoom out to a sweeping aerial perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a gloomy forest with bare tree trunks under a heavy gray sky with low-saturation lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021964015904814005 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127196311950684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021964015904814005, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021964015904814005, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36071062088012695, + 0.054530300199985504, + 0.0851660966873169, + 0.11824793368577957, + 0.03542168438434601, + 0.043406061828136444, + 0.10418670624494553, + 0.04524979740381241, + 0.0818735733628273, + 0.07120728492736816 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021964015904814005 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic low-angle shot begins just behind the carriage, parallel to the rapidly spinning wheels. A richly decorated, inky-black classical carriage gallops frantically along a rain-soaked, muddy dirt road. Four muscular, glossy-coated black horses pull the carriage with all their might, their hooves splashing muddy water with every thump, and hot white steam emanating from their snouts. Massive wooden wheels, edged with iron bars, roll through deeply rutted paths, sending clumps of sticky black mud violently into the air, arcing across the intricately carved carriage and the surrounding bare tree trunks. The camera then rapidly zooms out, shifting from a chaotic, dynamic close-up to a sweeping aerial perspective, revealing a vast, desolate scene: the carriage a tiny, hurried speck on the lonely road winding through a gloomy forest. Shrouded by a heavy gray sky, the weak diffuse light of the afternoon can hardly penetrate the thick clouds. The entire picture presents a low-saturation cinematic tone, full of urgency, struggle and epic loneliness.", + "seed": 3461, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000292/group_9/index_485_seed_3461_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.13964068628847598, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13964068628847598, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13964068628847598, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a richly decorated, inky-black classical carriage being pulled by four muscular black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the horses shown with hot white steam emanating from their snouts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carriage travel along a rain-soaked, muddy dirt road with massive wooden wheels edged with iron bars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot behind the carriage and then rapidly zoom out to a sweeping aerial perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a gloomy forest with bare tree trunks under a heavy gray sky with low-saturation lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4307434856891632 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0557434558868408 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4307434856891632, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4307434856891632, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09642105549573898, + 0.04339871555566788, + 0.1431771218776703, + 0.0713835060596466, + 0.1849956512451172, + 0.03468502312898636, + 0.29033684730529785, + 0.034189458936452866, + 0.05255670100450516, + 0.04885594919323921 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4307434856891632 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a richly decorated, inky-black classical carriage being pulled by four muscular black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the horses shown with hot white steam emanating from their snouts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carriage travel along a rain-soaked, muddy dirt road with massive wooden wheels edged with iron bars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot behind the carriage and then rapidly zoom out to a sweeping aerial perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a gloomy forest with bare tree trunks under a heavy gray sky with low-saturation lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1799151450395584 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804915189743042 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1799151450395584, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1799151450395584, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.036655377596616745, + 0.03068883903324604, + 0.17117173969745636, + 0.09284808486700058, + 0.5309555530548096, + 0.014870843850076199, + 0.044297732412815094, + 0.02835013158619404, + 0.029475679621100426, + 0.020686032250523567 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1799151450395584 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a richly decorated, inky-black classical carriage being pulled by four muscular black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the horses shown with hot white steam emanating from their snouts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carriage travel along a rain-soaked, muddy dirt road with massive wooden wheels edged with iron bars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot behind the carriage and then rapidly zoom out to a sweeping aerial perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a gloomy forest with bare tree trunks under a heavy gray sky with low-saturation lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866636171936989 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048666477203369 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866636171936989, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866636171936989, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04223528876900673, + 0.020311454311013222, + 0.026547599583864212, + 0.08417918533086777, + 0.38918882608413696, + 0.02156815491616726, + 0.28087344765663147, + 0.045522771775722504, + 0.04964958503842354, + 0.039923712611198425 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866636171936989 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a richly decorated, inky-black classical carriage being pulled by four muscular black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the horses shown with hot white steam emanating from their snouts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carriage travel along a rain-soaked, muddy dirt road with massive wooden wheels edged with iron bars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot behind the carriage and then rapidly zoom out to a sweeping aerial perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a gloomy forest with bare tree trunks under a heavy gray sky with low-saturation lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634120173752308 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651341199874878 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634120173752308, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634120173752308, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05768314376473427, + 0.015492715872824192, + 0.1000552549958229, + 0.0444457083940506, + 0.22937849164009094, + 0.03833130747079849, + 0.40083712339401245, + 0.04375716671347618, + 0.011288759298622608, + 0.058730341494083405 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634120173752308 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene featuring a richly decorated, inky-black classical carriage being pulled by four muscular black horses?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the horses shown with hot white steam emanating from their snouts?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the carriage travel along a rain-soaked, muddy dirt road with massive wooden wheels edged with iron bars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a low-angle shot behind the carriage and then rapidly zoom out to a sweeping aerial perspective?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment a gloomy forest with bare tree trunks under a heavy gray sky with low-saturation lighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012537237256765366 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387537002563477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012537237256765366, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012537237256765366, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08352398127317429, + 0.012426157481968403, + 0.030857807025313377, + 0.0248173289000988, + 0.14982005953788757, + 0.058521121740341187, + 0.4912779629230499, + 0.06406132131814957, + 0.05867649242281914, + 0.026017773896455765 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012537237256765366 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_0/index_tensor([8064, 8064])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_0/index_tensor([8064, 8064])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7c54763fdd92bd22941519e18c52dd60fb0987a2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_0/index_tensor([8064, 8064])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, horizontal medium shot captures a room steeped in retro charm. Warm afternoon sunlight filters through the cracks in the wooden blinds, casting streaks of light and dark across the dark wood floor and a dark brown Chesterfield leather sofa. Motes of dust drifting in the air are clearly visible in the beams of light. A young woman with slightly wavy brown shoulder-length hair, wearing an off-white knit sweater and wide-leg ochre corduroy pants, slowly rises from the worn sofa. Her movements are steady and deliberate. She carefully places her palms on the cushions, delicately cracked and wrinkled by age, then slowly rises from the deep seat, a languid, pensive expression on her face. As she rises, the streaks of light and shadow cast upon her body flow and shift, sliding across her off-white sweater. In the background, a yellowed old magazine rests casually on a low teak coffee table. In the corner, the broad leaves of a potted Monstera appear strikingly verdant in the light and shadow. The entire scene, dominated by warm browns and ochres, features a striking play of light and shadow, creating a tranquil, nostalgic, and cinematic atmosphere for an afternoon.", + "seed": 13841, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_0/index_8064_seed_13841_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.030093753710389137, + "vlm_logprob": -0.030093753710389137, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.030093753710389137, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with a dark wood floor and a dark brown Chesterfield leather sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with wavy brown shoulder-length hair wearing an off-white knit sweater and ochre corduroy pants visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly rise from the sofa while placing her palms on the cushions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are warm afternoon sunlight streaks visible through wooden blinds, illuminating dust motes in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a yellowed old magazine on a low teak coffee table and a potted Monstera plant visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010499595664441586 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.635499477386475 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010499595664441586, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010499595664441586, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3890656530857086, + 0.07675811648368835, + 0.059188541024923325, + 0.043433044105768204, + 0.10873334109783173, + 0.05451957508921623, + 0.02942134253680706, + 0.11087901890277863, + 0.053627531975507736, + 0.07437383383512497 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010499595664441586 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with a dark wood floor and a dark brown Chesterfield leather sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with wavy brown shoulder-length hair wearing an off-white knit sweater and ochre corduroy pants visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly rise from the sofa while placing her palms on the cushions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are warm afternoon sunlight streaks visible through wooden blinds, illuminating dust motes in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a yellowed old magazine on a low teak coffee table and a potted Monstera plant visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011086766608059406 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511086940765381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011086766608059406, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011086766608059406, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5226436853408813, + 0.06280163675546646, + 0.11781812459230423, + 0.0378761887550354, + 0.028337780386209488, + 0.07152058184146881, + 0.04660768434405327, + 0.03306354209780693, + 0.01791922189295292, + 0.0614115446805954 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011086766608059406 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with a dark wood floor and a dark brown Chesterfield leather sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with wavy brown shoulder-length hair wearing an off-white knit sweater and ochre corduroy pants visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly rise from the sofa while placing her palms on the cushions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are warm afternoon sunlight streaks visible through wooden blinds, illuminating dust motes in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a yellowed old magazine on a low teak coffee table and a potted Monstera plant visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864592105150223 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486459732055664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864592105150223, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864592105150223, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6510738730430603, + 0.04820701479911804, + 0.02657269313931465, + 0.01879248209297657, + 0.016339953988790512, + 0.050355829298496246, + 0.026982488110661507, + 0.030111832544207573, + 0.008273821324110031, + 0.12329000979661942 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864592105150223 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with a dark wood floor and a dark brown Chesterfield leather sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with wavy brown shoulder-length hair wearing an off-white knit sweater and ochre corduroy pants visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly rise from the sofa while placing her palms on the cushions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are warm afternoon sunlight streaks visible through wooden blinds, illuminating dust motes in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a yellowed old magazine on a low teak coffee table and a potted Monstera plant visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018187304958701134 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187522888184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018187304958701134, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018187304958701134, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29377517104148865, + 0.08540192991495132, + 0.07555736601352692, + 0.04299037531018257, + 0.03454658016562462, + 0.07145130634307861, + 0.03748846799135208, + 0.0894327238202095, + 0.03034224733710289, + 0.23901385068893433 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018187304958701134 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with a dark wood floor and a dark brown Chesterfield leather sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with wavy brown shoulder-length hair wearing an off-white knit sweater and ochre corduroy pants visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly rise from the sofa while placing her palms on the cushions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are warm afternoon sunlight streaks visible through wooden blinds, illuminating dust motes in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a yellowed old magazine on a low teak coffee table and a potted Monstera plant visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204918026924133 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812049150466919 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204918026924133, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204918026924133, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2517646849155426, + 0.053331032395362854, + 0.0756911039352417, + 0.0937117412686348, + 0.1316956728696823, + 0.11902932077646255, + 0.12202206254005432, + 0.07035382091999054, + 0.022012516856193542, + 0.060388047248125076 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204918026924133 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, horizontal medium shot captures a room steeped in retro charm. Warm afternoon sunlight filters through the cracks in the wooden blinds, casting streaks of light and dark across the dark wood floor and a dark brown Chesterfield leather sofa. Motes of dust drifting in the air are clearly visible in the beams of light. A young woman with slightly wavy brown shoulder-length hair, wearing an off-white knit sweater and wide-leg ochre corduroy pants, slowly rises from the worn sofa. Her movements are steady and deliberate. She carefully places her palms on the cushions, delicately cracked and wrinkled by age, then slowly rises from the deep seat, a languid, pensive expression on her face. As she rises, the streaks of light and shadow cast upon her body flow and shift, sliding across her off-white sweater. In the background, a yellowed old magazine rests casually on a low teak coffee table. In the corner, the broad leaves of a potted Monstera appear strikingly verdant in the light and shadow. The entire scene, dominated by warm browns and ochres, features a striking play of light and shadow, creating a tranquil, nostalgic, and cinematic atmosphere for an afternoon.", + "seed": 13842, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_0/index_8064_seed_13842_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.032597149908542636, + "vlm_logprob": -0.032597149908542636, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.032597149908542636, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with a dark wood floor and a dark brown Chesterfield leather sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with wavy brown shoulder-length hair wearing an off-white knit sweater and ochre corduroy pants visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly rise from the sofa while placing her palms on the cushions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are warm afternoon sunlight streaks visible through wooden blinds, illuminating dust motes in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a yellowed old magazine on a low teak coffee table and a potted Monstera plant visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.024461355060338974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.774461269378662 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.024461355060338974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.024461355060338974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3432984948158264, + 0.07504976540803909, + 0.09802553057670593, + 0.10968136042356491, + 0.07616570591926575, + 0.06483413279056549, + 0.03577635809779167, + 0.06842426210641861, + 0.07319852709770203, + 0.05554591864347458 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.024461355060338974 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with a dark wood floor and a dark brown Chesterfield leather sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with wavy brown shoulder-length hair wearing an off-white knit sweater and ochre corduroy pants visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly rise from the sofa while placing her palms on the cushions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are warm afternoon sunlight streaks visible through wooden blinds, illuminating dust motes in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a yellowed old magazine on a low teak coffee table and a potted Monstera plant visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01608150638639927 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410813331604 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01608150638639927, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01608150638639927, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24415388703346252, + 0.08578307926654816, + 0.0716450959444046, + 0.08871130645275116, + 0.16586458683013916, + 0.05124550312757492, + 0.052846308797597885, + 0.0663900300860405, + 0.05489525571465492, + 0.11846491694450378 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01608150638639927 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with a dark wood floor and a dark brown Chesterfield leather sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with wavy brown shoulder-length hair wearing an off-white knit sweater and ochre corduroy pants visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly rise from the sofa while placing her palms on the cushions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are warm afternoon sunlight streaks visible through wooden blinds, illuminating dust motes in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a yellowed old magazine on a low teak coffee table and a potted Monstera plant visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.054941773414611816 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299416542053223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.054941773414611816, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.054941773414611816, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1406005620956421, + 0.07711110264062881, + 0.06585495173931122, + 0.10952011495828629, + 0.055176425725221634, + 0.04432195425033569, + 0.052650149911642075, + 0.08676828444004059, + 0.08472549915313721, + 0.28327101469039917 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.054941773414611816 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with a dark wood floor and a dark brown Chesterfield leather sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with wavy brown shoulder-length hair wearing an off-white knit sweater and ochre corduroy pants visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly rise from the sofa while placing her palms on the cushions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are warm afternoon sunlight streaks visible through wooden blinds, illuminating dust motes in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a yellowed old magazine on a low teak coffee table and a potted Monstera plant visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012539708986878395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387539863586426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012539708986878395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012539708986878395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36798006296157837, + 0.05832076445221901, + 0.03513459861278534, + 0.03523954004049301, + 0.04604075103998184, + 0.03443252667784691, + 0.03286419063806534, + 0.060009829699993134, + 0.2690773606300354, + 0.060900382697582245 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012539708986878395 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with a dark wood floor and a dark brown Chesterfield leather sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with wavy brown shoulder-length hair wearing an off-white knit sweater and ochre corduroy pants visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly rise from the sofa while placing her palms on the cushions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are warm afternoon sunlight streaks visible through wooden blinds, illuminating dust motes in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a yellowed old magazine on a low teak coffee table and a potted Monstera plant visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496140569448471 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299614429473877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496140569448471, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496140569448471, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17907367646694183, + 0.28883621096611023, + 0.21630297601222992, + 0.04385927692055702, + 0.05088069662451744, + 0.029303215444087982, + 0.030440781265497208, + 0.07284235954284668, + 0.03180355578660965, + 0.05665726214647293 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496140569448471 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, horizontal medium shot captures a room steeped in retro charm. Warm afternoon sunlight filters through the cracks in the wooden blinds, casting streaks of light and dark across the dark wood floor and a dark brown Chesterfield leather sofa. Motes of dust drifting in the air are clearly visible in the beams of light. A young woman with slightly wavy brown shoulder-length hair, wearing an off-white knit sweater and wide-leg ochre corduroy pants, slowly rises from the worn sofa. Her movements are steady and deliberate. She carefully places her palms on the cushions, delicately cracked and wrinkled by age, then slowly rises from the deep seat, a languid, pensive expression on her face. As she rises, the streaks of light and shadow cast upon her body flow and shift, sliding across her off-white sweater. In the background, a yellowed old magazine rests casually on a low teak coffee table. In the corner, the broad leaves of a potted Monstera appear strikingly verdant in the light and shadow. The entire scene, dominated by warm browns and ochres, features a striking play of light and shadow, creating a tranquil, nostalgic, and cinematic atmosphere for an afternoon.", + "seed": 13843, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_0/index_8064_seed_13843_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.03669226095080376, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03669226095080376, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03669226095080376, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with a dark wood floor and a dark brown Chesterfield leather sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with wavy brown shoulder-length hair wearing an off-white knit sweater and ochre corduroy pants visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly rise from the sofa while placing her palms on the cushions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are warm afternoon sunlight streaks visible through wooden blinds, illuminating dust motes in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a yellowed old magazine on a low teak coffee table and a potted Monstera plant visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.034418441355228424 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4094183444976807 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.034418441355228424, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.034418441355228424, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05064680799841881, + 0.02591259405016899, + 0.025539269670844078, + 0.1368630826473236, + 0.043914612382650375, + 0.06979698687791824, + 0.04307565093040466, + 0.3602522313594818, + 0.033793266862630844, + 0.21020551025867462 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.034418441355228424 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with a dark wood floor and a dark brown Chesterfield leather sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with wavy brown shoulder-length hair wearing an off-white knit sweater and ochre corduroy pants visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly rise from the sofa while placing her palms on the cushions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are warm afternoon sunlight streaks visible through wooden blinds, illuminating dust motes in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a yellowed old magazine on a low teak coffee table and a potted Monstera plant visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900706678628922 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.579007148742676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900706678628922, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900706678628922, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.033815447241067886, + 0.0304734967648983, + 0.014820786193013191, + 0.06763359159231186, + 0.020179374143481255, + 0.05058397352695465, + 0.01724894903600216, + 0.47995686531066895, + 0.013298872858285904, + 0.2719886600971222 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900706678628922 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with a dark wood floor and a dark brown Chesterfield leather sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with wavy brown shoulder-length hair wearing an off-white knit sweater and ochre corduroy pants visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly rise from the sofa while placing her palms on the cushions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are warm afternoon sunlight streaks visible through wooden blinds, illuminating dust motes in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a yellowed old magazine on a low teak coffee table and a potted Monstera plant visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329075336456299 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732906341552734 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329075336456299, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329075336456299, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.018062487244606018, + 0.05528649687767029, + 0.014072097837924957, + 0.09054309874773026, + 0.03904244303703308, + 0.021749645471572876, + 0.027188226580619812, + 0.5878782272338867, + 0.018089694902300835, + 0.1280875951051712 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329075336456299 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with a dark wood floor and a dark brown Chesterfield leather sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with wavy brown shoulder-length hair wearing an off-white knit sweater and ochre corduroy pants visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly rise from the sofa while placing her palms on the cushions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are warm afternoon sunlight streaks visible through wooden blinds, illuminating dust motes in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a yellowed old magazine on a low teak coffee table and a potted Monstera plant visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008640285581350327 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758640289306641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008640285581350327, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008640285581350327, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04112972319126129, + 0.023681391030550003, + 0.10670559108257294, + 0.052903059870004654, + 0.11841906607151031, + 0.040004465728998184, + 0.02879607491195202, + 0.12619586288928986, + 0.03479951247572899, + 0.4273652136325836 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008640285581350327 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with a dark wood floor and a dark brown Chesterfield leather sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with wavy brown shoulder-length hair wearing an off-white knit sweater and ochre corduroy pants visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly rise from the sofa while placing her palms on the cushions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are warm afternoon sunlight streaks visible through wooden blinds, illuminating dust motes in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a yellowed old magazine on a low teak coffee table and a potted Monstera plant visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810475766658783 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288104772567749 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810475766658783, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810475766658783, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09357024729251862, + 0.043221984058618546, + 0.06573788076639175, + 0.08088492602109909, + 0.07038316875696182, + 0.07087420672178268, + 0.06919194757938385, + 0.1512237936258316, + 0.01923896186053753, + 0.33567288517951965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810475766658783 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, horizontal medium shot captures a room steeped in retro charm. Warm afternoon sunlight filters through the cracks in the wooden blinds, casting streaks of light and dark across the dark wood floor and a dark brown Chesterfield leather sofa. Motes of dust drifting in the air are clearly visible in the beams of light. A young woman with slightly wavy brown shoulder-length hair, wearing an off-white knit sweater and wide-leg ochre corduroy pants, slowly rises from the worn sofa. Her movements are steady and deliberate. She carefully places her palms on the cushions, delicately cracked and wrinkled by age, then slowly rises from the deep seat, a languid, pensive expression on her face. As she rises, the streaks of light and shadow cast upon her body flow and shift, sliding across her off-white sweater. In the background, a yellowed old magazine rests casually on a low teak coffee table. In the corner, the broad leaves of a potted Monstera appear strikingly verdant in the light and shadow. The entire scene, dominated by warm browns and ochres, features a striking play of light and shadow, creating a tranquil, nostalgic, and cinematic atmosphere for an afternoon.", + "seed": 13844, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_0/index_8064_seed_13844_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.031164438091218473, + "vlm_logprob": -0.031164438091218473, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.6499999523162843, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.031164438091218473, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with a dark wood floor and a dark brown Chesterfield leather sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with wavy brown shoulder-length hair wearing an off-white knit sweater and ochre corduroy pants visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly rise from the sofa while placing her palms on the cushions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are warm afternoon sunlight streaks visible through wooden blinds, illuminating dust motes in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a yellowed old magazine on a low teak coffee table and a potted Monstera plant visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.021389169618487358 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8963892459869385 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.021389169618487358, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.021389169618487358, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32510849833488464, + 0.08795028924942017, + 0.0438046008348465, + 0.12444377690553665, + 0.05581057444214821, + 0.024878624826669693, + 0.056150343269109726, + 0.1468864232301712, + 0.07497210800647736, + 0.05999470129609108 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.021389169618487358 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with a dark wood floor and a dark brown Chesterfield leather sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with wavy brown shoulder-length hair wearing an off-white knit sweater and ochre corduroy pants visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly rise from the sofa while placing her palms on the cushions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are warm afternoon sunlight streaks visible through wooden blinds, illuminating dust motes in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a yellowed old magazine on a low teak coffee table and a potted Monstera plant visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012546301819384098 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387546539306641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012546301819384098, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012546301819384098, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18606825172901154, + 0.06852079927921295, + 0.11005476117134094, + 0.15149010717868805, + 0.07192892581224442, + 0.0427701473236084, + 0.11561252176761627, + 0.12514197826385498, + 0.03581356629729271, + 0.09259895235300064 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012546301819384098 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with a dark wood floor and a dark brown Chesterfield leather sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with wavy brown shoulder-length hair wearing an off-white knit sweater and ochre corduroy pants visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly rise from the sofa while placing her palms on the cushions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are warm afternoon sunlight streaks visible through wooden blinds, illuminating dust motes in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a yellowed old magazine on a low teak coffee table and a potted Monstera plant visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000192254781723 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950018405914307 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000192254781723, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000192254781723, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21289986371994019, + 0.0731840580701828, + 0.11750003695487976, + 0.17000271379947662, + 0.05123298242688179, + 0.056684501469135284, + 0.06127863749861717, + 0.14859645068645477, + 0.03662591055035591, + 0.07199486345052719 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000192254781723 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with a dark wood floor and a dark brown Chesterfield leather sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with wavy brown shoulder-length hair wearing an off-white knit sweater and ochre corduroy pants visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly rise from the sofa while placing her palms on the cushions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are warm afternoon sunlight streaks visible through wooden blinds, illuminating dust motes in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a yellowed old magazine on a low teak coffee table and a potted Monstera plant visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018185313791036606 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018185138702393 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018185313791036606, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018185313791036606, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22598661482334137, + 0.04382826387882233, + 0.05391359701752663, + 0.08212614059448242, + 0.07831134647130966, + 0.05415087565779686, + 0.09092140942811966, + 0.08478272706270218, + 0.1683131605386734, + 0.11766588687896729 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018185313791036606 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a room with a dark wood floor and a dark brown Chesterfield leather sofa?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young woman with wavy brown shoulder-length hair wearing an off-white knit sweater and ochre corduroy pants visible?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly rise from the sofa while placing her palms on the cushions?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are warm afternoon sunlight streaks visible through wooden blinds, illuminating dust motes in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a yellowed old magazine on a low teak coffee table and a potted Monstera plant visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033699482679367065 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4086995124816895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033699482679367065, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033699482679367065, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40246322751045227, + 0.041431866586208344, + 0.03661733865737915, + 0.0633409321308136, + 0.03079487569630146, + 0.06289982795715332, + 0.12919728457927704, + 0.16073937714099884, + 0.03264092281460762, + 0.03987431153655052 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033699482679367065 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_1/index_tensor([8577, 8577])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_1/index_tensor([8577, 8577])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..707238f631a84948db382f7e25ba6fe6f30be182 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_1/index_tensor([8577, 8577])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slightly shaky handheld close-up, rendered in a gritty, desaturated style, immerses the viewer in the murky riverbed setting. A large, majestic flathead catfish, its scaleless skin camouflaged in dark brown and dusky brown spots, prowls in the pristine silence. Its broad, flat head protrudes, its long, sensitive barbs twitching delicately in the gentle current. A dense mass of globular golden eggs, securely nestled in the dark, algae-filled cavity of a hollow log, glows with a soft, warm glow that contrasts sharply with the cool, muted tones of the scene. The catfish maintains a defensive posture, directly over its young, its small, beady eyes fixed and alert. With a steady and deliberate rhythm, it executes delicate protective movements, methodically fanning its large pectoral and caudal fins to gently circulate the sediment-laden water and ensure oxygenation of the eggs. The camera follows these small yet powerful movements, its slight instability enhancing the raw documentary feel and emphasizing the tense, focused atmosphere of the parents' vigilance in the quiet underwater depths.", + "seed": 26328, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_1/index_8577_seed_26328_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.045737269520759585, + "vlm_logprob": -0.045737269520759585, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.175, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.045737269520759585, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large flathead catfish with scaleless, dark brown and dusky brown spotted skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are there dense globular golden eggs nestled in a hollow log within the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the catfish performing protective movements by fanning its pectoral and caudal fins to circulate water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky riverbed with a hollow log containing algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slightly shaky handheld close-up with a gritty, desaturated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05709293857216835 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9320929050445557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05709293857216835, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05709293857216835, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1441059410572052, + 0.2172202318906784, + 0.04034816101193428, + 0.06058692932128906, + 0.07536846399307251, + 0.1088140457868576, + 0.05749702453613281, + 0.05314366891980171, + 0.17371688783168793, + 0.06919869780540466 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05709293857216835 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large flathead catfish with scaleless, dark brown and dusky brown spotted skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are there dense globular golden eggs nestled in a hollow log within the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the catfish performing protective movements by fanning its pectoral and caudal fins to circulate water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky riverbed with a hollow log containing algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slightly shaky handheld close-up with a gritty, desaturated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023308105766773224 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773308038711548 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023308105766773224, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023308105766773224, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07077482342720032, + 0.2066529542207718, + 0.07280734181404114, + 0.05645385757088661, + 0.05186285078525543, + 0.16627824306488037, + 0.06078358367085457, + 0.03293945640325546, + 0.12415029108524323, + 0.15729667246341705 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023308105766773224 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large flathead catfish with scaleless, dark brown and dusky brown spotted skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are there dense globular golden eggs nestled in a hollow log within the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the catfish performing protective movements by fanning its pectoral and caudal fins to circulate water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky riverbed with a hollow log containing algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slightly shaky handheld close-up with a gritty, desaturated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496400222182274 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929964065551758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496400222182274, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496400222182274, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14929522573947906, + 0.0932670310139656, + 0.040582265704870224, + 0.03787039965391159, + 0.03671661391854286, + 0.10256090760231018, + 0.03419719263911247, + 0.10033097863197327, + 0.24498458206653595, + 0.16019482910633087 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496400222182274 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large flathead catfish with scaleless, dark brown and dusky brown spotted skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are there dense globular golden eggs nestled in a hollow log within the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the catfish performing protective movements by fanning its pectoral and caudal fins to circulate water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky riverbed with a hollow log containing algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slightly shaky handheld close-up with a gritty, desaturated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002425938844681 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695024251937866 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002425938844681, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002425938844681, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1002792939543724, + 0.3399987518787384, + 0.09226854145526886, + 0.034410759806632996, + 0.02630613185465336, + 0.05572960525751114, + 0.15387621521949768, + 0.025097832083702087, + 0.08903276920318604, + 0.0830000638961792 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002425938844681 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large flathead catfish with scaleless, dark brown and dusky brown spotted skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are there dense globular golden eggs nestled in a hollow log within the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the catfish performing protective movements by fanning its pectoral and caudal fins to circulate water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky riverbed with a hollow log containing algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slightly shaky handheld close-up with a gritty, desaturated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023297041654586792 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773297071456909 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023297041654586792, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023297041654586792, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09475747495889664, + 0.08275306969881058, + 0.06685533374547958, + 0.04918207228183746, + 0.19618530571460724, + 0.07215449959039688, + 0.05348515510559082, + 0.031422797590494156, + 0.2860857844352722, + 0.06711851805448532 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023297041654586792 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slightly shaky handheld close-up, rendered in a gritty, desaturated style, immerses the viewer in the murky riverbed setting. A large, majestic flathead catfish, its scaleless skin camouflaged in dark brown and dusky brown spots, prowls in the pristine silence. Its broad, flat head protrudes, its long, sensitive barbs twitching delicately in the gentle current. A dense mass of globular golden eggs, securely nestled in the dark, algae-filled cavity of a hollow log, glows with a soft, warm glow that contrasts sharply with the cool, muted tones of the scene. The catfish maintains a defensive posture, directly over its young, its small, beady eyes fixed and alert. With a steady and deliberate rhythm, it executes delicate protective movements, methodically fanning its large pectoral and caudal fins to gently circulate the sediment-laden water and ensure oxygenation of the eggs. The camera follows these small yet powerful movements, its slight instability enhancing the raw documentary feel and emphasizing the tense, focused atmosphere of the parents' vigilance in the quiet underwater depths.", + "seed": 26329, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_1/index_8577_seed_26329_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04938692338764668, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04938692338764668, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04938692338764668, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large flathead catfish with scaleless, dark brown and dusky brown spotted skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are there dense globular golden eggs nestled in a hollow log within the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the catfish performing protective movements by fanning its pectoral and caudal fins to circulate water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky riverbed with a hollow log containing algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slightly shaky handheld close-up with a gritty, desaturated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05610150843858719 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9311015605926514 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05610150843858719, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05610150843858719, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15123845636844635, + 0.1663523018360138, + 0.06607739627361298, + 0.1597924381494522, + 0.035065677016973495, + 0.23397797346115112, + 0.03527442738413811, + 0.04941166192293167, + 0.0573987178504467, + 0.04541096091270447 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05610150843858719 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large flathead catfish with scaleless, dark brown and dusky brown spotted skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are there dense globular golden eggs nestled in a hollow log within the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the catfish performing protective movements by fanning its pectoral and caudal fins to circulate water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky riverbed with a hollow log containing algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slightly shaky handheld close-up with a gritty, desaturated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029823198914527893 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298233032226562 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029823198914527893, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029823198914527893, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19617575407028198, + 0.27622464299201965, + 0.10205230116844177, + 0.0583433136343956, + 0.03319467976689339, + 0.11186331510543823, + 0.02197929285466671, + 0.03776588290929794, + 0.06439831852912903, + 0.09800252318382263 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029823198914527893 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large flathead catfish with scaleless, dark brown and dusky brown spotted skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are there dense globular golden eggs nestled in a hollow log within the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the catfish performing protective movements by fanning its pectoral and caudal fins to circulate water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky riverbed with a hollow log containing algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slightly shaky handheld close-up with a gritty, desaturated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0486685186624527 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048668622970581 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0486685186624527, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0486685186624527, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11875426769256592, + 0.2832646071910858, + 0.08069101721048355, + 0.08052688837051392, + 0.03451617434620857, + 0.06415408849716187, + 0.06701884418725967, + 0.1538899689912796, + 0.04465571045875549, + 0.0725284218788147 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0486685186624527 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large flathead catfish with scaleless, dark brown and dusky brown spotted skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are there dense globular golden eggs nestled in a hollow log within the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the catfish performing protective movements by fanning its pectoral and caudal fins to circulate water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky riverbed with a hollow log containing algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slightly shaky handheld close-up with a gritty, desaturated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890498235821724 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464049816131592 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0890498235821724, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0890498235821724, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23016764223575592, + 0.07819776982069016, + 0.06598590314388275, + 0.029076367616653442, + 0.04636373743414879, + 0.41161826252937317, + 0.03261076658964157, + 0.03480757772922516, + 0.048792991787195206, + 0.022378981113433838 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0890498235821724 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large flathead catfish with scaleless, dark brown and dusky brown spotted skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are there dense globular golden eggs nestled in a hollow log within the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the catfish performing protective movements by fanning its pectoral and caudal fins to circulate water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky riverbed with a hollow log containing algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slightly shaky handheld close-up with a gritty, desaturated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023291567340493202 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.77329158782959 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023291567340493202, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023291567340493202, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10917863994836807, + 0.1596885472536087, + 0.05070967227220535, + 0.06027631834149361, + 0.08396976441144943, + 0.2411445528268814, + 0.03803376480937004, + 0.11696697771549225, + 0.05490424484014511, + 0.0851275771856308 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023291567340493202 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slightly shaky handheld close-up, rendered in a gritty, desaturated style, immerses the viewer in the murky riverbed setting. A large, majestic flathead catfish, its scaleless skin camouflaged in dark brown and dusky brown spots, prowls in the pristine silence. Its broad, flat head protrudes, its long, sensitive barbs twitching delicately in the gentle current. A dense mass of globular golden eggs, securely nestled in the dark, algae-filled cavity of a hollow log, glows with a soft, warm glow that contrasts sharply with the cool, muted tones of the scene. The catfish maintains a defensive posture, directly over its young, its small, beady eyes fixed and alert. With a steady and deliberate rhythm, it executes delicate protective movements, methodically fanning its large pectoral and caudal fins to gently circulate the sediment-laden water and ensure oxygenation of the eggs. The camera follows these small yet powerful movements, its slight instability enhancing the raw documentary feel and emphasizing the tense, focused atmosphere of the parents' vigilance in the quiet underwater depths.", + "seed": 26330, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_1/index_8577_seed_26330_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04191177301108837, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04191177301108837, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04191177301108837, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large flathead catfish with scaleless, dark brown and dusky brown spotted skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are there dense globular golden eggs nestled in a hollow log within the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the catfish performing protective movements by fanning its pectoral and caudal fins to circulate water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky riverbed with a hollow log containing algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slightly shaky handheld close-up with a gritty, desaturated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09065575152635574 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.46565580368042 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09065575152635574, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09065575152635574, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20555871725082397, + 0.18844975531101227, + 0.057491425424814224, + 0.16533735394477844, + 0.07525680214166641, + 0.1171640008687973, + 0.04100286588072777, + 0.04989832267165184, + 0.049045078456401825, + 0.05079571530222893 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09065575152635574 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large flathead catfish with scaleless, dark brown and dusky brown spotted skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are there dense globular golden eggs nestled in a hollow log within the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the catfish performing protective movements by fanning its pectoral and caudal fins to circulate water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky riverbed with a hollow log containing algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slightly shaky handheld close-up with a gritty, desaturated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0233067087829113 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733066082000732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0233067087829113, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0233067087829113, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1713571697473526, + 0.07328470796346664, + 0.05721502751111984, + 0.15304520726203918, + 0.03851758688688278, + 0.10504575818777084, + 0.06384549289941788, + 0.11067361384630203, + 0.13242803514003754, + 0.09458746016025543 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0233067087829113 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large flathead catfish with scaleless, dark brown and dusky brown spotted skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are there dense globular golden eggs nestled in a hollow log within the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the catfish performing protective movements by fanning its pectoral and caudal fins to circulate water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky riverbed with a hollow log containing algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slightly shaky handheld close-up with a gritty, desaturated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866522550582886 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486652851104736 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866522550582886, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866522550582886, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1290641576051712, + 0.055873043835163116, + 0.060705989599227905, + 0.09121858328580856, + 0.04437736049294472, + 0.2892642021179199, + 0.05923847109079361, + 0.1436447948217392, + 0.0526588037610054, + 0.07395467907190323 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866522550582886 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large flathead catfish with scaleless, dark brown and dusky brown spotted skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are there dense globular golden eggs nestled in a hollow log within the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the catfish performing protective movements by fanning its pectoral and caudal fins to circulate water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky riverbed with a hollow log containing algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slightly shaky handheld close-up with a gritty, desaturated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026347937062382698 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513478755950928 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026347937062382698, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026347937062382698, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.419487863779068, + 0.043093953281641006, + 0.12108369916677475, + 0.11228781193494797, + 0.0612148717045784, + 0.030212190002202988, + 0.04443284124135971, + 0.05395939201116562, + 0.07805773615837097, + 0.036169618368148804 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026347937062382698 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large flathead catfish with scaleless, dark brown and dusky brown spotted skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are there dense globular golden eggs nestled in a hollow log within the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the catfish performing protective movements by fanning its pectoral and caudal fins to circulate water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky riverbed with a hollow log containing algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slightly shaky handheld close-up with a gritty, desaturated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020583242177963257 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895583152770996 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020583242177963257, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020583242177963257, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5287578701972961, + 0.04478401318192482, + 0.07778562605381012, + 0.07935529947280884, + 0.07016662508249283, + 0.04449738189578056, + 0.023364311084151268, + 0.05719148367643356, + 0.04240337014198303, + 0.03169405832886696 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020583242177963257 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slightly shaky handheld close-up, rendered in a gritty, desaturated style, immerses the viewer in the murky riverbed setting. A large, majestic flathead catfish, its scaleless skin camouflaged in dark brown and dusky brown spots, prowls in the pristine silence. Its broad, flat head protrudes, its long, sensitive barbs twitching delicately in the gentle current. A dense mass of globular golden eggs, securely nestled in the dark, algae-filled cavity of a hollow log, glows with a soft, warm glow that contrasts sharply with the cool, muted tones of the scene. The catfish maintains a defensive posture, directly over its young, its small, beady eyes fixed and alert. With a steady and deliberate rhythm, it executes delicate protective movements, methodically fanning its large pectoral and caudal fins to gently circulate the sediment-laden water and ensure oxygenation of the eggs. The camera follows these small yet powerful movements, its slight instability enhancing the raw documentary feel and emphasizing the tense, focused atmosphere of the parents' vigilance in the quiet underwater depths.", + "seed": 26331, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_1/index_8577_seed_26331_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.039776856824755666, + "vlm_logprob": -0.039776856824755666, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.039776856824755666, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large flathead catfish with scaleless, dark brown and dusky brown spotted skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are there dense globular golden eggs nestled in a hollow log within the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the catfish performing protective movements by fanning its pectoral and caudal fins to circulate water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky riverbed with a hollow log containing algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slightly shaky handheld close-up with a gritty, desaturated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.057676006108522415 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.932676076889038 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.057676006108522415, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.057676006108522415, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1872159093618393, + 0.04580416530370712, + 0.30373823642730713, + 0.11247628927230835, + 0.07390027493238449, + 0.043183740228414536, + 0.028452452272176743, + 0.03676455467939377, + 0.06821981072425842, + 0.10024459660053253 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.057676006108522415 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large flathead catfish with scaleless, dark brown and dusky brown spotted skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are there dense globular golden eggs nestled in a hollow log within the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the catfish performing protective movements by fanning its pectoral and caudal fins to circulate water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky riverbed with a hollow log containing algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slightly shaky handheld close-up with a gritty, desaturated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023305194452404976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733051776885986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023305194452404976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023305194452404976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13094420731067657, + 0.04407881945371628, + 0.28066354990005493, + 0.03760094195604324, + 0.03883945196866989, + 0.03099437989294529, + 0.030536159873008728, + 0.07682251185178757, + 0.22074851393699646, + 0.10877149552106857 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023305194452404976 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large flathead catfish with scaleless, dark brown and dusky brown spotted skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are there dense globular golden eggs nestled in a hollow log within the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the catfish performing protective movements by fanning its pectoral and caudal fins to circulate water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky riverbed with a hollow log containing algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slightly shaky handheld close-up with a gritty, desaturated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866749420762062 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486674308776855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866749420762062, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866749420762062, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14249441027641296, + 0.08568232506513596, + 0.22567641735076904, + 0.09447093307971954, + 0.11415886878967285, + 0.06611960381269455, + 0.03816075250506401, + 0.05634716898202896, + 0.06351938098669052, + 0.11337017267942429 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866749420762062 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large flathead catfish with scaleless, dark brown and dusky brown spotted skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are there dense globular golden eggs nestled in a hollow log within the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the catfish performing protective movements by fanning its pectoral and caudal fins to circulate water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky riverbed with a hollow log containing algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slightly shaky handheld close-up with a gritty, desaturated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864989593625069 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048649787902832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864989593625069, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864989593625069, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15521495044231415, + 0.06497791409492493, + 0.39898422360420227, + 0.03890155628323555, + 0.03692755475640297, + 0.03905198350548744, + 0.019235651940107346, + 0.0401046946644783, + 0.09586620330810547, + 0.11073524504899979 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864989593625069 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large flathead catfish with scaleless, dark brown and dusky brown spotted skin?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are there dense globular golden eggs nestled in a hollow log within the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the catfish performing protective movements by fanning its pectoral and caudal fins to circulate water?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a murky riverbed with a hollow log containing algae?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the video shot as a slightly shaky handheld close-up with a gritty, desaturated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020585693418979645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895585775375366 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020585693418979645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020585693418979645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13961608707904816, + 0.051705751568078995, + 0.3328045904636383, + 0.03720267117023468, + 0.0808793157339096, + 0.03124365769326687, + 0.04763568937778473, + 0.06032506749033928, + 0.05248529836535454, + 0.16610188782215118 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020585693418979645 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_10/index_tensor([4128, 4128])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_10/index_tensor([4128, 4128])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d6f962396a7f323af8a4e151f65d5a537faa2ff4 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_10/index_tensor([4128, 4128])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "powerful, low-angle, panning shot follows a sleek sports car painted a vibrant cherry red as it thunders into the frame from the lower left corner. The midnight city streets, fresh from a heavy rain, are as slippery as a mirror, greedily reflecting the flickering blue and purple neon signs atop the surrounding skyscrapers. The car cuts across the frame diagonally and decisively, its wide tires kicking up a cloud of white spray and a distinct hissing sound. Its twin, eagle-like LED headlights, high beams on high, cast two long, haloed white beams through the humid air, instantly illuminating the mist ahead and casting long, dynamic streaks of reflected light across the slippery road. As the camera pans rapidly, the car body's smooth red surface reflects the flowing, distorted city lights as it passes through the center of the screen. As it whizzes past and gradually disappears from the upper right corner of the screen, its ruby-like taillights leave two short and fiery red light trails behind it, and finally melt into the deep night of the city. The whole scene is full of a sense of speed and a tense atmosphere of adrenaline rush, presenting a cold and gorgeous modern urban film aesthetic.", + "seed": 6358, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_10/index_4128_seed_6358_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06559494137763977, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06559494137763977, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06559494137763977, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek sports car painted a vibrant cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving diagonally from the lower left corner to the upper right corner of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment show a wet city street with reflections of blue and purple neon signs from skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid pan shot following the car's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights leave two short, fiery red light trails as it disappears into the night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023625999689102173 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7736260890960693 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023625999689102173, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023625999689102173, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.051927417516708374, + 0.031961292028427124, + 0.22366933524608612, + 0.07013311982154846, + 0.15337921679019928, + 0.1049899235367775, + 0.03908345848321915, + 0.23782990872859955, + 0.04503616690635681, + 0.04199012741446495 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023625999689102173 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek sports car painted a vibrant cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving diagonally from the lower left corner to the upper right corner of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment show a wet city street with reflections of blue and purple neon signs from skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid pan shot following the car's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights leave two short, fiery red light trails as it disappears into the night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20155395567417145 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015539407730103 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20155395567417145, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20155395567417145, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07644936442375183, + 0.05667053163051605, + 0.22076041996479034, + 0.07265870273113251, + 0.11517640203237534, + 0.06478482484817505, + 0.17069904506206512, + 0.14042192697525024, + 0.03913374990224838, + 0.04324497655034065 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20155395567417145 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek sports car painted a vibrant cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving diagonally from the lower left corner to the upper right corner of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment show a wet city street with reflections of blue and purple neon signs from skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid pan shot following the car's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights leave two short, fiery red light trails as it disappears into the night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606578752398491 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.14106559753418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606578752398491, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606578752398491, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3849642276763916, + 0.05761118233203888, + 0.1221432015299797, + 0.08454114198684692, + 0.03754822164773941, + 0.06147898733615875, + 0.08847136050462723, + 0.0687994509935379, + 0.046685509383678436, + 0.04775676503777504 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606578752398491 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek sports car painted a vibrant cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving diagonally from the lower left corner to the upper right corner of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment show a wet city street with reflections of blue and purple neon signs from skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid pan shot following the car's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights leave two short, fiery red light trails as it disappears into the night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03808031603693962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880802154541016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03808031603693962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03808031603693962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.059273041784763336, + 0.09057922661304474, + 0.05076437443494797, + 0.047782547771930695, + 0.20329540967941284, + 0.08771228790283203, + 0.05013800784945488, + 0.053239695727825165, + 0.2619776427745819, + 0.09523775428533554 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03808031603693962 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek sports car painted a vibrant cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving diagonally from the lower left corner to the upper right corner of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment show a wet city street with reflections of blue and purple neon signs from skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid pan shot following the car's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights leave two short, fiery red light trails as it disappears into the night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0486486479640007 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486485958099365 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0486486479640007, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0486486479640007, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10690611600875854, + 0.026429785415530205, + 0.2747049033641815, + 0.033127229660749435, + 0.09535255283117294, + 0.0928664430975914, + 0.16221390664577484, + 0.06879685819149017, + 0.040178604423999786, + 0.09942368417978287 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0486486479640007 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful, low-angle, panning shot follows a sleek sports car painted a vibrant cherry red as it thunders into the frame from the lower left corner. The midnight city streets, fresh from a heavy rain, are as slippery as a mirror, greedily reflecting the flickering blue and purple neon signs atop the surrounding skyscrapers. The car cuts across the frame diagonally and decisively, its wide tires kicking up a cloud of white spray and a distinct hissing sound. Its twin, eagle-like LED headlights, high beams on high, cast two long, haloed white beams through the humid air, instantly illuminating the mist ahead and casting long, dynamic streaks of reflected light across the slippery road. As the camera pans rapidly, the car body's smooth red surface reflects the flowing, distorted city lights as it passes through the center of the screen. As it whizzes past and gradually disappears from the upper right corner of the screen, its ruby-like taillights leave two short and fiery red light trails behind it, and finally melt into the deep night of the city. The whole scene is full of a sense of speed and a tense atmosphere of adrenaline rush, presenting a cold and gorgeous modern urban film aesthetic.", + "seed": 6359, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_10/index_4128_seed_6359_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.1016010164283216, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1016010164283216, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1016010164283216, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek sports car painted a vibrant cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving diagonally from the lower left corner to the upper right corner of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment show a wet city street with reflections of blue and purple neon signs from skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid pan shot following the car's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights leave two short, fiery red light trails as it disappears into the night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01287904940545559 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387878894805908 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01287904940545559, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01287904940545559, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05087060108780861, + 0.05777708813548088, + 0.08669774979352951, + 0.08854100853204727, + 0.267364501953125, + 0.16714534163475037, + 0.036947477608919144, + 0.1005648747086525, + 0.10280857235193253, + 0.041282765567302704 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01287904940545559 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek sports car painted a vibrant cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving diagonally from the lower left corner to the upper right corner of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment show a wet city street with reflections of blue and purple neon signs from skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid pan shot following the car's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights leave two short, fiery red light trails as it disappears into the night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22556228935718536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600562334060669 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22556228935718536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22556228935718536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08536588400602341, + 0.01684635505080223, + 0.18229752779006958, + 0.0786963477730751, + 0.10984630882740021, + 0.06043023616075516, + 0.0385710708796978, + 0.18655720353126526, + 0.20936539769172668, + 0.032023653388023376 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22556228935718536 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek sports car painted a vibrant cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving diagonally from the lower left corner to the upper right corner of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment show a wet city street with reflections of blue and purple neon signs from skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid pan shot following the car's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights leave two short, fiery red light trails as it disappears into the night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005945970769971609 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130946159362793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005945970769971609, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005945970769971609, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17461837828159332, + 0.10867264121770859, + 0.07330674678087234, + 0.11852958053350449, + 0.11830513179302216, + 0.10301824659109116, + 0.043375469744205475, + 0.11915034055709839, + 0.09988371282815933, + 0.04113975912332535 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005945970769971609 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek sports car painted a vibrant cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving diagonally from the lower left corner to the upper right corner of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment show a wet city street with reflections of blue and purple neon signs from skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid pan shot following the car's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights leave two short, fiery red light trails as it disappears into the night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2255229949951172 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005229949951172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2255229949951172, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2255229949951172, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07160908728837967, + 0.056683249771595, + 0.038086287677288055, + 0.24622470140457153, + 0.12339732050895691, + 0.2403741180896759, + 0.02469818666577339, + 0.08185666054487228, + 0.08104899525642395, + 0.03602136671543121 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2255229949951172 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek sports car painted a vibrant cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving diagonally from the lower left corner to the upper right corner of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment show a wet city street with reflections of blue and purple neon signs from skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid pan shot following the car's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights leave two short, fiery red light trails as it disappears into the night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809477761387825 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880947589874268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809477761387825, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809477761387825, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11379313468933105, + 0.05662216618657112, + 0.046865783631801605, + 0.1653730422258377, + 0.10814232379198074, + 0.13268692791461945, + 0.047899290919303894, + 0.08504170924425125, + 0.05439721420407295, + 0.18917836248874664 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809477761387825 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful, low-angle, panning shot follows a sleek sports car painted a vibrant cherry red as it thunders into the frame from the lower left corner. The midnight city streets, fresh from a heavy rain, are as slippery as a mirror, greedily reflecting the flickering blue and purple neon signs atop the surrounding skyscrapers. The car cuts across the frame diagonally and decisively, its wide tires kicking up a cloud of white spray and a distinct hissing sound. Its twin, eagle-like LED headlights, high beams on high, cast two long, haloed white beams through the humid air, instantly illuminating the mist ahead and casting long, dynamic streaks of reflected light across the slippery road. As the camera pans rapidly, the car body's smooth red surface reflects the flowing, distorted city lights as it passes through the center of the screen. As it whizzes past and gradually disappears from the upper right corner of the screen, its ruby-like taillights leave two short and fiery red light trails behind it, and finally melt into the deep night of the city. The whole scene is full of a sense of speed and a tense atmosphere of adrenaline rush, presenting a cold and gorgeous modern urban film aesthetic.", + "seed": 6360, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_10/index_4128_seed_6360_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05192620195448398, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05192620195448398, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05192620195448398, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek sports car painted a vibrant cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving diagonally from the lower left corner to the upper right corner of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment show a wet city street with reflections of blue and purple neon signs from skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid pan shot following the car's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights leave two short, fiery red light trails as it disappears into the night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010123573243618011 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6351237297058105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010123573243618011, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010123573243618011, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10884099453687668, + 0.04402780532836914, + 0.11678242683410645, + 0.07837513089179993, + 0.0877700001001358, + 0.12814635038375854, + 0.15618199110031128, + 0.10790868103504181, + 0.07593575865030289, + 0.09603085368871689 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010123573243618011 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek sports car painted a vibrant cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving diagonally from the lower left corner to the upper right corner of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment show a wet city street with reflections of blue and purple neon signs from skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid pan shot following the car's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights leave two short, fiery red light trails as it disappears into the night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603444516658783 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103444814682007 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603444516658783, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603444516658783, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14581748843193054, + 0.10314645618200302, + 0.0447850339114666, + 0.02106783166527748, + 0.11394186317920685, + 0.07330983132123947, + 0.09437406808137894, + 0.2468469887971878, + 0.08090130239725113, + 0.07580915838479996 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603444516658783 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek sports car painted a vibrant cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving diagonally from the lower left corner to the upper right corner of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment show a wet city street with reflections of blue and purple neon signs from skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid pan shot following the car's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights leave two short, fiery red light trails as it disappears into the night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011073680594563484 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511073589324951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011073680594563484, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011073680594563484, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19800260663032532, + 0.16389724612236023, + 0.0707225501537323, + 0.07012533396482468, + 0.05100094899535179, + 0.06477800756692886, + 0.08795792609453201, + 0.1264163851737976, + 0.11187102645635605, + 0.05522798001766205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011073680594563484 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek sports car painted a vibrant cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving diagonally from the lower left corner to the upper right corner of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment show a wet city street with reflections of blue and purple neon signs from skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid pan shot following the car's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights leave two short, fiery red light trails as it disappears into the night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016058161854743958 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141057968139648 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016058161854743958, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016058161854743958, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11152666062116623, + 0.05455836281180382, + 0.047221750020980835, + 0.05860721692442894, + 0.11929342150688171, + 0.2201550006866455, + 0.09423353523015976, + 0.09245875477790833, + 0.08415063470602036, + 0.11779467761516571 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016058161854743958 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek sports car painted a vibrant cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving diagonally from the lower left corner to the upper right corner of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment show a wet city street with reflections of blue and purple neon signs from skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid pan shot following the car's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights leave two short, fiery red light trails as it disappears into the night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06203114241361618 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120310306549072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06203114241361618, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06203114241361618, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09774821251630783, + 0.028961578384041786, + 0.04785340279340744, + 0.06986521929502487, + 0.06159130111336708, + 0.055590223520994186, + 0.055552370846271515, + 0.24716892838478088, + 0.10392308235168457, + 0.23174571990966797 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06203114241361618 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "powerful, low-angle, panning shot follows a sleek sports car painted a vibrant cherry red as it thunders into the frame from the lower left corner. The midnight city streets, fresh from a heavy rain, are as slippery as a mirror, greedily reflecting the flickering blue and purple neon signs atop the surrounding skyscrapers. The car cuts across the frame diagonally and decisively, its wide tires kicking up a cloud of white spray and a distinct hissing sound. Its twin, eagle-like LED headlights, high beams on high, cast two long, haloed white beams through the humid air, instantly illuminating the mist ahead and casting long, dynamic streaks of reflected light across the slippery road. As the camera pans rapidly, the car body's smooth red surface reflects the flowing, distorted city lights as it passes through the center of the screen. As it whizzes past and gradually disappears from the upper right corner of the screen, its ruby-like taillights leave two short and fiery red light trails behind it, and finally melt into the deep night of the city. The whole scene is full of a sense of speed and a tense atmosphere of adrenaline rush, presenting a cold and gorgeous modern urban film aesthetic.", + "seed": 6361, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_10/index_4128_seed_6361_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.08087242711335421, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08087242711335421, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08087242711335421, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek sports car painted a vibrant cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving diagonally from the lower left corner to the upper right corner of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment show a wet city street with reflections of blue and purple neon signs from skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid pan shot following the car's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights leave two short, fiery red light trails as it disappears into the night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009135116823017597 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7591352462768555 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009135116823017597, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009135116823017597, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2874293327331543, + 0.08158870041370392, + 0.09283118695020676, + 0.0667460709810257, + 0.07692800462245941, + 0.10823826491832733, + 0.08728611469268799, + 0.057921044528484344, + 0.06503999978303909, + 0.07599128037691116 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009135116823017597 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek sports car painted a vibrant cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving diagonally from the lower left corner to the upper right corner of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment show a wet city street with reflections of blue and purple neon signs from skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid pan shot following the car's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights leave two short, fiery red light trails as it disappears into the night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2520880401134491 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5020880699157715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2520880401134491, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2520880401134491, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2061648964881897, + 0.04797428101301193, + 0.14927351474761963, + 0.05866743251681328, + 0.08383060991764069, + 0.1307939738035202, + 0.1752059906721115, + 0.058262899518013, + 0.06278237700462341, + 0.027044042944908142 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2520880401134491 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek sports car painted a vibrant cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving diagonally from the lower left corner to the upper right corner of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment show a wet city street with reflections of blue and purple neon signs from skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid pan shot following the car's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights leave two short, fiery red light trails as it disappears into the night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011074859648942947 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511075019836426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011074859648942947, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011074859648942947, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30537721514701843, + 0.07989487797021866, + 0.09045452624559402, + 0.052330382168293, + 0.052299611270427704, + 0.06651006639003754, + 0.07945360988378525, + 0.0784756988286972, + 0.1302746683359146, + 0.0649292916059494 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011074859648942947 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek sports car painted a vibrant cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving diagonally from the lower left corner to the upper right corner of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment show a wet city street with reflections of blue and purple neon signs from skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid pan shot following the car's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights leave two short, fiery red light trails as it disappears into the night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890038013458252 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464003801345825 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0890038013458252, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0890038013458252, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04038611799478531, + 0.09441481530666351, + 0.11854766309261322, + 0.0551292784512043, + 0.09655233472585678, + 0.1485942304134369, + 0.07162556052207947, + 0.04363809525966644, + 0.309711754322052, + 0.021400151774287224 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0890038013458252 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sleek sports car painted a vibrant cherry red?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the car moving diagonally from the lower left corner to the upper right corner of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the environment show a wet city street with reflections of blue and purple neon signs from skyscrapers?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a rapid pan shot following the car's movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the car's taillights leave two short, fiery red light trails as it disappears into the night?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043060317635536194 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168060302734375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043060317635536194, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043060317635536194, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12234055995941162, + 0.06685703247785568, + 0.05642407760024071, + 0.0901453047990799, + 0.07292614877223969, + 0.05972405523061752, + 0.08585846424102783, + 0.10817428678274155, + 0.18542128801345825, + 0.15212878584861755 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043060317635536194 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_11/index_tensor([22, 22])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_11/index_tensor([22, 22])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..24f8fbf691a95b80f517d411b1bb23977681cb2a --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_11/index_tensor([22, 22])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium shot, slowly tilting downward and advancing, focuses on a pristine stone path, damp after the rain. The bluish-gray slabs, eroded by time, are uneven and covered with a thin layer of moss. The cracks between the slabs are filled with dark, damp soil. Within these cracks in the hard stone, several sprouts, brimming with life, slowly and tenaciously break through the earth, visibly capturing the unique charm of Chinese ink painting: The base of the roots is a rich, inky color, gradually transitioning to a translucent, moist jade green. Newly formed leaves curl at the top, like miniature scrolls poised to unfold, their tips smudged with a deeper shade of ink. Glistening dewdrops hang from them, reflecting the soft, diffuse light from the sky. The entire scene, shrouded in cool, elegant tones, creates a tranquil, Zen-like atmosphere, silently showcasing the tenacious power of life.", + "seed": 593, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_11/index_22_seed_593_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05249348124489188, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05249348124489188, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05249348124489188, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot focusing on a stone path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and advance while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone slabs bluish-gray, eroded, uneven, and covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do sprouts with inky-colored roots and jade-green leaves break through the cracks in the stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Chinese ink painting featuring cool, elegant tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22695478796958923 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6019548177719116 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22695478796958923, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22695478796958923, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1574963927268982, + 0.09373991191387177, + 0.18243099749088287, + 0.02332545816898346, + 0.08175643533468246, + 0.1298082023859024, + 0.1572042554616928, + 0.10567206889390945, + 0.036220744252204895, + 0.03234550729393959 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22695478796958923 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot focusing on a stone path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and advance while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone slabs bluish-gray, eroded, uneven, and covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do sprouts with inky-colored roots and jade-green leaves break through the cracks in the stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Chinese ink painting featuring cool, elegant tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012551716528832912 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387551784515381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012551716528832912, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012551716528832912, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10921413451433182, + 0.056528229266405106, + 0.1407068967819214, + 0.052970919758081436, + 0.045812297612428665, + 0.0644436851143837, + 0.20556586980819702, + 0.2486133873462677, + 0.0576702356338501, + 0.018474286422133446 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012551716528832912 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot focusing on a stone path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and advance while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone slabs bluish-gray, eroded, uneven, and covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do sprouts with inky-colored roots and jade-green leaves break through the cracks in the stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Chinese ink painting featuring cool, elegant tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00594964437186718 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.1309494972229 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00594964437186718, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00594964437186718, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2506439983844757, + 0.06782174110412598, + 0.22742903232574463, + 0.07011806964874268, + 0.04638262093067169, + 0.09180149435997009, + 0.06562764942646027, + 0.06878625601530075, + 0.05750903859734535, + 0.05388006940484047 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00594964437186718 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot focusing on a stone path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and advance while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone slabs bluish-gray, eroded, uneven, and covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do sprouts with inky-colored roots and jade-green leaves break through the cracks in the stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Chinese ink painting featuring cool, elegant tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01106978952884674 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110697746276855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01106978952884674, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01106978952884674, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11552636325359344, + 0.03168732672929764, + 0.2835935652256012, + 0.04492005333304405, + 0.03307347372174263, + 0.06551302969455719, + 0.08989167958498001, + 0.18739080429077148, + 0.07879069447517395, + 0.06961292028427124 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01106978952884674 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot focusing on a stone path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and advance while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone slabs bluish-gray, eroded, uneven, and covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do sprouts with inky-colored roots and jade-green leaves break through the cracks in the stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Chinese ink painting featuring cool, elegant tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005941467825323343 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130941390991211 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005941467825323343, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005941467825323343, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09518946707248688, + 0.02710762619972229, + 0.24032916128635406, + 0.02271002158522606, + 0.044221725314855576, + 0.07791008055210114, + 0.05564011633396149, + 0.364078164100647, + 0.05442361161112785, + 0.018390029668807983 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005941467825323343 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, slowly tilting downward and advancing, focuses on a pristine stone path, damp after the rain. The bluish-gray slabs, eroded by time, are uneven and covered with a thin layer of moss. The cracks between the slabs are filled with dark, damp soil. Within these cracks in the hard stone, several sprouts, brimming with life, slowly and tenaciously break through the earth, visibly capturing the unique charm of Chinese ink painting: The base of the roots is a rich, inky color, gradually transitioning to a translucent, moist jade green. Newly formed leaves curl at the top, like miniature scrolls poised to unfold, their tips smudged with a deeper shade of ink. Glistening dewdrops hang from them, reflecting the soft, diffuse light from the sky. The entire scene, shrouded in cool, elegant tones, creates a tranquil, Zen-like atmosphere, silently showcasing the tenacious power of life.", + "seed": 594, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_11/index_22_seed_594_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.014545134687796234, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014545134687796234, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014545134687796234, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot focusing on a stone path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and advance while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone slabs bluish-gray, eroded, uneven, and covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do sprouts with inky-colored roots and jade-green leaves break through the cracks in the stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Chinese ink painting featuring cool, elegant tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03956460580229759 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.289564609527588 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03956460580229759, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03956460580229759, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16198213398456573, + 0.12771616876125336, + 0.10557716339826584, + 0.22377675771713257, + 0.07158816605806351, + 0.0772690549492836, + 0.041818007826805115, + 0.03913623467087746, + 0.09740611910820007, + 0.05373019352555275 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03956460580229759 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot focusing on a stone path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and advance while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone slabs bluish-gray, eroded, uneven, and covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do sprouts with inky-colored roots and jade-green leaves break through the cracks in the stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Chinese ink painting featuring cool, elegant tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01608678512275219 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141086578369141 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01608678512275219, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01608678512275219, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29728639125823975, + 0.07438832521438599, + 0.1362895667552948, + 0.06386922299861908, + 0.06644312292337418, + 0.07554493099451065, + 0.10752230882644653, + 0.055747777223587036, + 0.0552266426384449, + 0.06768174469470978 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01608678512275219 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot focusing on a stone path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and advance while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone slabs bluish-gray, eroded, uneven, and covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do sprouts with inky-colored roots and jade-green leaves break through the cracks in the stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Chinese ink painting featuring cool, elegant tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003193756565451622 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.7531938552856445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003193756565451622, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003193756565451622, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28993508219718933, + 0.18647973239421844, + 0.1115478128194809, + 0.07898509502410889, + 0.03650672361254692, + 0.04462993144989014, + 0.03404437005519867, + 0.047587137669324875, + 0.09771233797073364, + 0.07257166504859924 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003193756565451622 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot focusing on a stone path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and advance while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone slabs bluish-gray, eroded, uneven, and covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do sprouts with inky-colored roots and jade-green leaves break through the cracks in the stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Chinese ink painting featuring cool, elegant tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002815451705828309 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877815246582031 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002815451705828309, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002815451705828309, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12853553891181946, + 0.08532556891441345, + 0.13600747287273407, + 0.08639002591371536, + 0.06296540796756744, + 0.0753389298915863, + 0.07087033241987228, + 0.08602543920278549, + 0.16411840915679932, + 0.10442286729812622 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002815451705828309 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot focusing on a stone path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and advance while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone slabs bluish-gray, eroded, uneven, and covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do sprouts with inky-colored roots and jade-green leaves break through the cracks in the stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Chinese ink painting featuring cool, elegant tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011065074242651463 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.5110650062561035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011065074242651463, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011065074242651463, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10378865152597427, + 0.0620386078953743, + 0.3322477340698242, + 0.0321757048368454, + 0.04478740692138672, + 0.14173226058483124, + 0.052161313593387604, + 0.030559349805116653, + 0.10032188892364502, + 0.10018714517354965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011065074242651463 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, slowly tilting downward and advancing, focuses on a pristine stone path, damp after the rain. The bluish-gray slabs, eroded by time, are uneven and covered with a thin layer of moss. The cracks between the slabs are filled with dark, damp soil. Within these cracks in the hard stone, several sprouts, brimming with life, slowly and tenaciously break through the earth, visibly capturing the unique charm of Chinese ink painting: The base of the roots is a rich, inky color, gradually transitioning to a translucent, moist jade green. Newly formed leaves curl at the top, like miniature scrolls poised to unfold, their tips smudged with a deeper shade of ink. Glistening dewdrops hang from them, reflecting the soft, diffuse light from the sky. The entire scene, shrouded in cool, elegant tones, creates a tranquil, Zen-like atmosphere, silently showcasing the tenacious power of life.", + "seed": 595, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_11/index_22_seed_595_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.01660721548832953, + "vlm_logprob": -0.01660721548832953, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.01660721548832953, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot focusing on a stone path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and advance while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone slabs bluish-gray, eroded, uneven, and covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do sprouts with inky-colored roots and jade-green leaves break through the cracks in the stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Chinese ink painting featuring cool, elegant tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04419182240962982 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.169191837310791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04419182240962982, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04419182240962982, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.096013143658638, + 0.3343452215194702, + 0.03394738957285881, + 0.05959919095039368, + 0.20945967733860016, + 0.09044219553470612, + 0.04007263481616974, + 0.036705516278743744, + 0.025791209191083908, + 0.07362376153469086 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04419182240962982 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot focusing on a stone path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and advance while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone slabs bluish-gray, eroded, uneven, and covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do sprouts with inky-colored roots and jade-green leaves break through the cracks in the stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Chinese ink painting featuring cool, elegant tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023305194452404976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733051776885986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023305194452404976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023305194452404976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10081621259450912, + 0.4013517498970032, + 0.05480010807514191, + 0.04052902013063431, + 0.1071038767695427, + 0.07633057981729507, + 0.0892636850476265, + 0.03072844073176384, + 0.05682815983891487, + 0.042248133569955826 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023305194452404976 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot focusing on a stone path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and advance while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone slabs bluish-gray, eroded, uneven, and covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do sprouts with inky-colored roots and jade-green leaves break through the cracks in the stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Chinese ink painting featuring cool, elegant tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002818423556163907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877818584442139 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002818423556163907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002818423556163907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10626406967639923, + 0.33172807097435, + 0.07665358483791351, + 0.09023948758840561, + 0.1734946072101593, + 0.047570034861564636, + 0.018039856106042862, + 0.02953939698636532, + 0.04401392489671707, + 0.08245699107646942 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002818423556163907 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot focusing on a stone path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and advance while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone slabs bluish-gray, eroded, uneven, and covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do sprouts with inky-colored roots and jade-green leaves break through the cracks in the stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Chinese ink painting featuring cool, elegant tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040906332433223724 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504090785980225 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040906332433223724, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040906332433223724, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29721033573150635, + 0.061409592628479004, + 0.10307160764932632, + 0.05688509717583656, + 0.19018451869487762, + 0.035605330020189285, + 0.07738877832889557, + 0.03830147162079811, + 0.04577147588133812, + 0.09417179971933365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040906332433223724 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot focusing on a stone path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and advance while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone slabs bluish-gray, eroded, uneven, and covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do sprouts with inky-colored roots and jade-green leaves break through the cracks in the stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Chinese ink painting featuring cool, elegant tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008630003780126572 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75862979888916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008630003780126572, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008630003780126572, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16691787540912628, + 0.08613679558038712, + 0.11704329401254654, + 0.09895211458206177, + 0.12861546874046326, + 0.08535630255937576, + 0.041999734938144684, + 0.04013635963201523, + 0.09521891921758652, + 0.13962315022945404 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008630003780126572 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium shot, slowly tilting downward and advancing, focuses on a pristine stone path, damp after the rain. The bluish-gray slabs, eroded by time, are uneven and covered with a thin layer of moss. The cracks between the slabs are filled with dark, damp soil. Within these cracks in the hard stone, several sprouts, brimming with life, slowly and tenaciously break through the earth, visibly capturing the unique charm of Chinese ink painting: The base of the roots is a rich, inky color, gradually transitioning to a translucent, moist jade green. Newly formed leaves curl at the top, like miniature scrolls poised to unfold, their tips smudged with a deeper shade of ink. Glistening dewdrops hang from them, reflecting the soft, diffuse light from the sky. The entire scene, shrouded in cool, elegant tones, creates a tranquil, Zen-like atmosphere, silently showcasing the tenacious power of life.", + "seed": 596, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_11/index_22_seed_596_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03312915712594986, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03312915712594986, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03312915712594986, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot focusing on a stone path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and advance while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone slabs bluish-gray, eroded, uneven, and covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do sprouts with inky-colored roots and jade-green leaves break through the cracks in the stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Chinese ink painting featuring cool, elegant tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11582949012517929 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2408294677734375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11582949012517929, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11582949012517929, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22373762726783752, + 0.0527755469083786, + 0.05587230622768402, + 0.2529889941215515, + 0.030990462750196457, + 0.0705125480890274, + 0.19469448924064636, + 0.04300384595990181, + 0.04521770775318146, + 0.030206503346562386 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11582949012517929 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot focusing on a stone path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and advance while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone slabs bluish-gray, eroded, uneven, and covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do sprouts with inky-colored roots and jade-green leaves break through the cracks in the stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Chinese ink painting featuring cool, elegant tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029823314398527145 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298233032226562 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029823314398527145, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029823314398527145, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14307282865047455, + 0.04507720097899437, + 0.09810933470726013, + 0.1053028330206871, + 0.12393301725387573, + 0.062743179500103, + 0.19276143610477448, + 0.12098873406648636, + 0.0859684869647026, + 0.022042904049158096 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029823314398527145 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot focusing on a stone path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and advance while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone slabs bluish-gray, eroded, uneven, and covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do sprouts with inky-colored roots and jade-green leaves break through the cracks in the stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Chinese ink painting featuring cool, elegant tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021996130235493183 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127199649810791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021996130235493183, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021996130235493183, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.337210476398468, + 0.09312069416046143, + 0.03826691955327988, + 0.10542687773704529, + 0.11107762157917023, + 0.06317587196826935, + 0.1214650422334671, + 0.05394658446311951, + 0.045410752296447754, + 0.03089914470911026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021996130235493183 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot focusing on a stone path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and advance while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone slabs bluish-gray, eroded, uneven, and covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do sprouts with inky-colored roots and jade-green leaves break through the cracks in the stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Chinese ink painting featuring cool, elegant tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036108787171542645 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628611087799072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036108787171542645, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036108787171542645, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16599132120609283, + 0.05438961833715439, + 0.03515354543924332, + 0.21291793882846832, + 0.1830185353755951, + 0.05530227720737457, + 0.13034968078136444, + 0.08466358482837677, + 0.03198525682091713, + 0.0462283194065094 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036108787171542645 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as a medium shot focusing on a stone path?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly tilt downward and advance while moving?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the stone slabs bluish-gray, eroded, uneven, and covered with moss?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do sprouts with inky-colored roots and jade-green leaves break through the cracks in the stone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style consistent with Chinese ink painting featuring cool, elegant tones?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01418248936533928 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2641825675964355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01418248936533928, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01418248936533928, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2270158976316452, + 0.058156345039606094, + 0.04698343575000763, + 0.19845862686634064, + 0.10594354569911957, + 0.03671184182167053, + 0.11604553461074829, + 0.11443720757961273, + 0.04725520685315132, + 0.0489923320710659 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01418248936533928 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_12/index_tensor([9012, 9012])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_12/index_tensor([9012, 9012])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..08102e472212e3cfb62154a1511436a7d4046ec5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_12/index_tensor([9012, 9012])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "deeply intimate first-person point-of-view shot, its frame steady, as if we're gazing through someone's eyes. A slender, pale, bony hand slowly reaches in from the lower right of the frame, its fingertips rounded and neatly manicured, a faint pink hue. With a loving, tender gesture, the hand gently caresses the surface of the camera lens, its movements slow and lingering, as if touching the cheek of a cherished person. As the hand moves, a delicate wrist peeks out from beneath a wide sleeve. Crafted from a delicate, cherry-pink brocade, the sleeve is delicately embroidered with lifelike phoenixes and peonies intricately in gold and silver thread, shimmering with a subtle yet luxurious luster under the soft, diffused light. The backdrop is a freehand ink painting of a landscape painting with a profound artistic conception. Distant mountains appear and disappear amidst the lingering mist, their outlines rendered with vigorous, powerful brushstrokes, the ink color richly varying in shade, dryness, and wetness. Nearby, the twisted branches of an ancient pine tree reach toward the vast expanse of blank sky, imbuing the entire space with the unique texture of rice paper. The overall palette is cool yet elegant, with the soft colors of the hands and the ornate garments serving as the only warm accents against the monochrome ink background, creating an intimate atmosphere of tranquility, dreaminess, and a profoundly classical poetic quality.", + "seed": 9743, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_12/index_9012_seed_9743_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.024845912447199227, + "vlm_logprob": -0.024845912447199227, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.024845912447199227, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady first-person point-of-view looking through someone's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, pale, bony hand with rounded, neatly manicured fingertips reach in from the lower right to caress the camera lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a wide sleeve made of cherry-pink brocade embroidered with gold and silver phoenixes and peonies visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a freehand ink painting landscape featuring distant mountains in mist and twisted pine branches on a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffused, creating a cool palette where the hand and sleeve are the only warm accents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07220181822776794 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.697201728820801 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07220181822776794, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07220181822776794, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10279380530118942, + 0.3215659260749817, + 0.0510416105389595, + 0.047636423259973526, + 0.08445403724908829, + 0.024751685559749603, + 0.050561610609292984, + 0.09414795786142349, + 0.12237394601106644, + 0.10067296028137207 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07220181822776794 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady first-person point-of-view looking through someone's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, pale, bony hand with rounded, neatly manicured fingertips reach in from the lower right to caress the camera lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a wide sleeve made of cherry-pink brocade embroidered with gold and silver phoenixes and peonies visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a freehand ink painting landscape featuring distant mountains in mist and twisted pine branches on a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffused, creating a cool palette where the hand and sleeve are the only warm accents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005959480069577694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130959510803223 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005959480069577694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005959480069577694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13935282826423645, + 0.2819007635116577, + 0.09471305459737778, + 0.04834718629717827, + 0.11037007719278336, + 0.01619834452867508, + 0.032757699489593506, + 0.08138274401426315, + 0.1019623875617981, + 0.0930149033665657 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005959480069577694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady first-person point-of-view looking through someone's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, pale, bony hand with rounded, neatly manicured fingertips reach in from the lower right to caress the camera lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a wide sleeve made of cherry-pink brocade embroidered with gold and silver phoenixes and peonies visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a freehand ink painting landscape featuring distant mountains in mist and twisted pine branches on a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffused, creating a cool palette where the hand and sleeve are the only warm accents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02057553455233574 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895575523376465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02057553455233574, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02057553455233574, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10540810227394104, + 0.2964681386947632, + 0.19679930806159973, + 0.0324026383459568, + 0.08236000686883926, + 0.02497265860438347, + 0.03733066841959953, + 0.08834175020456314, + 0.07662658393383026, + 0.05929012969136238 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02057553455233574 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady first-person point-of-view looking through someone's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, pale, bony hand with rounded, neatly manicured fingertips reach in from the lower right to caress the camera lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a wide sleeve made of cherry-pink brocade embroidered with gold and silver phoenixes and peonies visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a freehand ink painting landscape featuring distant mountains in mist and twisted pine branches on a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffused, creating a cool palette where the hand and sleeve are the only warm accents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021956877317279577 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127195835113525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021956877317279577, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021956877317279577, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20831400156021118, + 0.16872571408748627, + 0.06859797239303589, + 0.0757569968700409, + 0.12107276916503906, + 0.020186571404337883, + 0.05074276402592659, + 0.08448691666126251, + 0.10756687074899673, + 0.09454941749572754 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021956877317279577 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady first-person point-of-view looking through someone's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, pale, bony hand with rounded, neatly manicured fingertips reach in from the lower right to caress the camera lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a wide sleeve made of cherry-pink brocade embroidered with gold and silver phoenixes and peonies visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a freehand ink painting landscape featuring distant mountains in mist and twisted pine branches on a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffused, creating a cool palette where the hand and sleeve are the only warm accents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023297041654586792 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773297071456909 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023297041654586792, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023297041654586792, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18220272660255432, + 0.2737322449684143, + 0.1210344210267067, + 0.041749391704797745, + 0.07320081442594528, + 0.03312472999095917, + 0.0173962265253067, + 0.14057904481887817, + 0.05872882157564163, + 0.058251623064279556 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023297041654586792 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "deeply intimate first-person point-of-view shot, its frame steady, as if we're gazing through someone's eyes. A slender, pale, bony hand slowly reaches in from the lower right of the frame, its fingertips rounded and neatly manicured, a faint pink hue. With a loving, tender gesture, the hand gently caresses the surface of the camera lens, its movements slow and lingering, as if touching the cheek of a cherished person. As the hand moves, a delicate wrist peeks out from beneath a wide sleeve. Crafted from a delicate, cherry-pink brocade, the sleeve is delicately embroidered with lifelike phoenixes and peonies intricately in gold and silver thread, shimmering with a subtle yet luxurious luster under the soft, diffused light. The backdrop is a freehand ink painting of a landscape painting with a profound artistic conception. Distant mountains appear and disappear amidst the lingering mist, their outlines rendered with vigorous, powerful brushstrokes, the ink color richly varying in shade, dryness, and wetness. Nearby, the twisted branches of an ancient pine tree reach toward the vast expanse of blank sky, imbuing the entire space with the unique texture of rice paper. The overall palette is cool yet elegant, with the soft colors of the hands and the ornate garments serving as the only warm accents against the monochrome ink background, creating an intimate atmosphere of tranquility, dreaminess, and a profoundly classical poetic quality.", + "seed": 9744, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_12/index_9012_seed_9744_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.11842678524553776, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11842678524553776, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11842678524553776, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady first-person point-of-view looking through someone's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, pale, bony hand with rounded, neatly manicured fingertips reach in from the lower right to caress the camera lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a wide sleeve made of cherry-pink brocade embroidered with gold and silver phoenixes and peonies visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a freehand ink painting landscape featuring distant mountains in mist and twisted pine branches on a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffused, creating a cool palette where the hand and sleeve are the only warm accents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.431146502494812 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.056146502494812 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.431146502494812, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.431146502494812, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2112741321325302, + 0.09908853471279144, + 0.08698183298110962, + 0.08515505492687225, + 0.07278653979301453, + 0.17406457662582397, + 0.05152473971247673, + 0.13821600377559662, + 0.051539309322834015, + 0.029369279742240906 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.431146502494812 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady first-person point-of-view looking through someone's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, pale, bony hand with rounded, neatly manicured fingertips reach in from the lower right to caress the camera lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a wide sleeve made of cherry-pink brocade embroidered with gold and silver phoenixes and peonies visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a freehand ink painting landscape featuring distant mountains in mist and twisted pine branches on a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffused, creating a cool palette where the hand and sleeve are the only warm accents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020600641146302223 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956005573272705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020600641146302223, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020600641146302223, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13198933005332947, + 0.11423324793577194, + 0.06296741962432861, + 0.03742910921573639, + 0.059628333896398544, + 0.14569346606731415, + 0.054348643869161606, + 0.09484121948480606, + 0.03557266667485237, + 0.26329654455184937 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020600641146302223 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady first-person point-of-view looking through someone's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, pale, bony hand with rounded, neatly manicured fingertips reach in from the lower right to caress the camera lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a wide sleeve made of cherry-pink brocade embroidered with gold and silver phoenixes and peonies visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a freehand ink painting landscape featuring distant mountains in mist and twisted pine branches on a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffused, creating a cool palette where the hand and sleeve are the only warm accents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305848851799965 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168058395385742 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305848851799965, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305848851799965, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13340641558170319, + 0.09226370602846146, + 0.09448681026697159, + 0.0565178245306015, + 0.06644698977470398, + 0.12322183698415756, + 0.06268437951803207, + 0.1329841911792755, + 0.062362346798181534, + 0.17562542855739594 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305848851799965 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady first-person point-of-view looking through someone's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, pale, bony hand with rounded, neatly manicured fingertips reach in from the lower right to caress the camera lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a wide sleeve made of cherry-pink brocade embroidered with gold and silver phoenixes and peonies visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a freehand ink painting landscape featuring distant mountains in mist and twisted pine branches on a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffused, creating a cool palette where the hand and sleeve are the only warm accents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866760969161987 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486676692962646 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866760969161987, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866760969161987, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26198339462280273, + 0.046138860285282135, + 0.08371059596538544, + 0.04931269586086273, + 0.16946806013584137, + 0.1245119720697403, + 0.05626918375492096, + 0.07411512732505798, + 0.047091223299503326, + 0.08739881217479706 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866760969161987 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady first-person point-of-view looking through someone's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, pale, bony hand with rounded, neatly manicured fingertips reach in from the lower right to caress the camera lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a wide sleeve made of cherry-pink brocade embroidered with gold and silver phoenixes and peonies visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a freehand ink painting landscape featuring distant mountains in mist and twisted pine branches on a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffused, creating a cool palette where the hand and sleeve are the only warm accents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866068437695503 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486607551574707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866068437695503, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866068437695503, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14313893020153046, + 0.18268674612045288, + 0.049727652221918106, + 0.06571219861507416, + 0.16195517778396606, + 0.061414334923028946, + 0.07723671197891235, + 0.0723814070224762, + 0.039730943739414215, + 0.14601591229438782 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866068437695503 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "deeply intimate first-person point-of-view shot, its frame steady, as if we're gazing through someone's eyes. A slender, pale, bony hand slowly reaches in from the lower right of the frame, its fingertips rounded and neatly manicured, a faint pink hue. With a loving, tender gesture, the hand gently caresses the surface of the camera lens, its movements slow and lingering, as if touching the cheek of a cherished person. As the hand moves, a delicate wrist peeks out from beneath a wide sleeve. Crafted from a delicate, cherry-pink brocade, the sleeve is delicately embroidered with lifelike phoenixes and peonies intricately in gold and silver thread, shimmering with a subtle yet luxurious luster under the soft, diffused light. The backdrop is a freehand ink painting of a landscape painting with a profound artistic conception. Distant mountains appear and disappear amidst the lingering mist, their outlines rendered with vigorous, powerful brushstrokes, the ink color richly varying in shade, dryness, and wetness. Nearby, the twisted branches of an ancient pine tree reach toward the vast expanse of blank sky, imbuing the entire space with the unique texture of rice paper. The overall palette is cool yet elegant, with the soft colors of the hands and the ornate garments serving as the only warm accents against the monochrome ink background, creating an intimate atmosphere of tranquility, dreaminess, and a profoundly classical poetic quality.", + "seed": 9745, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_12/index_9012_seed_9745_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1940293432213366, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1940293432213366, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1940293432213366, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady first-person point-of-view looking through someone's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, pale, bony hand with rounded, neatly manicured fingertips reach in from the lower right to caress the camera lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a wide sleeve made of cherry-pink brocade embroidered with gold and silver phoenixes and peonies visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a freehand ink painting landscape featuring distant mountains in mist and twisted pine branches on a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffused, creating a cool palette where the hand and sleeve are the only warm accents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.827439546585083 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.577439546585083 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.827439546585083, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.827439546585083, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3643680512905121, + 0.06289490312337875, + 0.03208310529589653, + 0.1024448350071907, + 0.05033334717154503, + 0.09590866416692734, + 0.06157534942030907, + 0.02005235105752945, + 0.10878287255764008, + 0.10155642032623291 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.827439546585083 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady first-person point-of-view looking through someone's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, pale, bony hand with rounded, neatly manicured fingertips reach in from the lower right to caress the camera lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a wide sleeve made of cherry-pink brocade embroidered with gold and silver phoenixes and peonies visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a freehand ink painting landscape featuring distant mountains in mist and twisted pine branches on a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffused, creating a cool palette where the hand and sleeve are the only warm accents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867396876215935 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486738681793213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867396876215935, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867396876215935, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2544941306114197, + 0.06539149582386017, + 0.030465327203273773, + 0.04332229122519493, + 0.09496608376502991, + 0.1742476373910904, + 0.06491632759571075, + 0.02591232769191265, + 0.08958963304758072, + 0.15669472515583038 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867396876215935 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady first-person point-of-view looking through someone's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, pale, bony hand with rounded, neatly manicured fingertips reach in from the lower right to caress the camera lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a wide sleeve made of cherry-pink brocade embroidered with gold and silver phoenixes and peonies visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a freehand ink painting landscape featuring distant mountains in mist and twisted pine branches on a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffused, creating a cool palette where the hand and sleeve are the only warm accents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620332732796669 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812033176422119 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620332732796669, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620332732796669, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1810392141342163, + 0.05510597676038742, + 0.11278532445430756, + 0.042235855013132095, + 0.1707213968038559, + 0.09437708556652069, + 0.08679288625717163, + 0.049531858414411545, + 0.09969848394393921, + 0.10771192610263824 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620332732796669 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady first-person point-of-view looking through someone's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, pale, bony hand with rounded, neatly manicured fingertips reach in from the lower right to caress the camera lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a wide sleeve made of cherry-pink brocade embroidered with gold and silver phoenixes and peonies visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a freehand ink painting landscape featuring distant mountains in mist and twisted pine branches on a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffused, creating a cool palette where the hand and sleeve are the only warm accents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021962826140224934 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127196311950684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021962826140224934, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021962826140224934, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18510094285011292, + 0.10192334651947021, + 0.06706342846155167, + 0.04886141046881676, + 0.12086520344018936, + 0.26194673776626587, + 0.08970136940479279, + 0.03222421929240227, + 0.04698560759425163, + 0.04532775655388832 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021962826140224934 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady first-person point-of-view looking through someone's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, pale, bony hand with rounded, neatly manicured fingertips reach in from the lower right to caress the camera lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a wide sleeve made of cherry-pink brocade embroidered with gold and silver phoenixes and peonies visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a freehand ink painting landscape featuring distant mountains in mist and twisted pine branches on a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffused, creating a cool palette where the hand and sleeve are the only warm accents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029803644865751266 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.52980375289917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029803644865751266, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029803644865751266, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20238365232944489, + 0.09385024756193161, + 0.04397205635905266, + 0.021439068019390106, + 0.06556330621242523, + 0.23043210804462433, + 0.11469234526157379, + 0.03658350929617882, + 0.1067003682255745, + 0.08438338339328766 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029803644865751266 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "deeply intimate first-person point-of-view shot, its frame steady, as if we're gazing through someone's eyes. A slender, pale, bony hand slowly reaches in from the lower right of the frame, its fingertips rounded and neatly manicured, a faint pink hue. With a loving, tender gesture, the hand gently caresses the surface of the camera lens, its movements slow and lingering, as if touching the cheek of a cherished person. As the hand moves, a delicate wrist peeks out from beneath a wide sleeve. Crafted from a delicate, cherry-pink brocade, the sleeve is delicately embroidered with lifelike phoenixes and peonies intricately in gold and silver thread, shimmering with a subtle yet luxurious luster under the soft, diffused light. The backdrop is a freehand ink painting of a landscape painting with a profound artistic conception. Distant mountains appear and disappear amidst the lingering mist, their outlines rendered with vigorous, powerful brushstrokes, the ink color richly varying in shade, dryness, and wetness. Nearby, the twisted branches of an ancient pine tree reach toward the vast expanse of blank sky, imbuing the entire space with the unique texture of rice paper. The overall palette is cool yet elegant, with the soft colors of the hands and the ornate garments serving as the only warm accents against the monochrome ink background, creating an intimate atmosphere of tranquility, dreaminess, and a profoundly classical poetic quality.", + "seed": 9746, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_12/index_9012_seed_9746_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.09701359318569303, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09701359318569303, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09701359318569303, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady first-person point-of-view looking through someone's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, pale, bony hand with rounded, neatly manicured fingertips reach in from the lower right to caress the camera lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a wide sleeve made of cherry-pink brocade embroidered with gold and silver phoenixes and peonies visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a freehand ink painting landscape featuring distant mountains in mist and twisted pine branches on a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffused, creating a cool palette where the hand and sleeve are the only warm accents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.43036651611328125 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0553665161132812 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.43036651611328125, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.43036651611328125, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09782207012176514, + 0.05467892438173294, + 0.05725167691707611, + 0.050410281866788864, + 0.19392329454421997, + 0.15360607206821442, + 0.07456889748573303, + 0.12937051057815552, + 0.05729549378156662, + 0.1310727596282959 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.43036651611328125 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady first-person point-of-view looking through someone's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, pale, bony hand with rounded, neatly manicured fingertips reach in from the lower right to caress the camera lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a wide sleeve made of cherry-pink brocade embroidered with gold and silver phoenixes and peonies visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a freehand ink painting landscape featuring distant mountains in mist and twisted pine branches on a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffused, creating a cool palette where the hand and sleeve are the only warm accents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006745543330907822 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006745338439941 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006745543330907822, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006745543330907822, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12522545456886292, + 0.09020274132490158, + 0.05638214573264122, + 0.06078299880027771, + 0.15862157940864563, + 0.0999080091714859, + 0.14649397134780884, + 0.08106821775436401, + 0.08891715854406357, + 0.09239766001701355 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006745543330907822 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady first-person point-of-view looking through someone's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, pale, bony hand with rounded, neatly manicured fingertips reach in from the lower right to caress the camera lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a wide sleeve made of cherry-pink brocade embroidered with gold and silver phoenixes and peonies visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a freehand ink painting landscape featuring distant mountains in mist and twisted pine branches on a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffused, creating a cool palette where the hand and sleeve are the only warm accents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020575184375047684 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955752849578857 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020575184375047684, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020575184375047684, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09025780856609344, + 0.07400403171777725, + 0.1285494714975357, + 0.043774865567684174, + 0.10954704135656357, + 0.043923430144786835, + 0.09665752202272415, + 0.29301491379737854, + 0.06475267559289932, + 0.055518221110105515 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020575184375047684 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady first-person point-of-view looking through someone's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, pale, bony hand with rounded, neatly manicured fingertips reach in from the lower right to caress the camera lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a wide sleeve made of cherry-pink brocade embroidered with gold and silver phoenixes and peonies visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a freehand ink painting landscape featuring distant mountains in mist and twisted pine branches on a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffused, creating a cool palette where the hand and sleeve are the only warm accents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0040924143977463245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504092216491699 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0040924143977463245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0040924143977463245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18317416310310364, + 0.10514821857213974, + 0.1341526359319687, + 0.07891382277011871, + 0.10944749414920807, + 0.08982125669717789, + 0.06462834775447845, + 0.07074245065450668, + 0.07202242314815521, + 0.09194924682378769 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0040924143977463245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a steady first-person point-of-view looking through someone's eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does a slender, pale, bony hand with rounded, neatly manicured fingertips reach in from the lower right to caress the camera lens?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a wide sleeve made of cherry-pink brocade embroidered with gold and silver phoenixes and peonies visible on the wrist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a freehand ink painting landscape featuring distant mountains in mist and twisted pine branches on a rice paper texture?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting soft and diffused, creating a cool palette where the hand and sleeve are the only warm accents?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023288307711482048 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732882499694824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023288307711482048, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023288307711482048, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2507593631744385, + 0.09105898439884186, + 0.20376965403556824, + 0.050560932606458664, + 0.08289218693971634, + 0.05849282443523407, + 0.06587408483028412, + 0.04188557341694832, + 0.06936457008123398, + 0.08534184098243713 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023288307711482048 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_13/index_tensor([9214, 9214])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_13/index_tensor([9214, 9214])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..643e58061f5420f07c45d2eae7d4139c504268a9 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_13/index_tensor([9214, 9214])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "stunning macro close-up captures a mantis, vibrant emerald green, perched like a finely sculpted jade stone on a broad, emerald bamboo leaf. Soft morning sunlight filters through the bamboo forest, casting dappled shadows on the leaves, their edges shimmering with dewdrops, creating a tranquil yet vibrant atmosphere. Atop its triangular head, a pair of large, deep-set compound eyes gleam with a calm and focused gaze. Its signature sickle-shaped forelimbs are tucked against its chest in a classic, alert stance. Suddenly, with a light, almost instantaneous swerve, it swerves sideways, deftly ducking beneath the edge of another bamboo leaf with the dexterity of a martial arts master. Then, the camera panned to the right at an extremely fast speed, closely following its swift pounce - its hind legs suddenly exerted force, and its entire body rushed forward like a green arrow from a string with a swift and precise posture, its sickle-shaped front legs fully extended in the air, with a clear target. The whole picture, outlined by the sunlight, was full of focus, elegance and explosive power.", + "seed": 20705, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_13/index_9214_seed_20705_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.09655109494924545, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09655109494924545, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09655109494924545, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mantis with vibrant emerald green coloration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis initially perched on a broad emerald bamboo leaf with dewdrops visible on the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis perform a swift sideways swerve to duck beneath another bamboo leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan to the right at an extremely fast speed to follow the mantis's pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the mantis's sickle-shaped front legs fully extended in the air during the pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008014662191271782 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.883014678955078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008014662191271782, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008014662191271782, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10094260424375534, + 0.09652397781610489, + 0.030138690024614334, + 0.04319537431001663, + 0.03311952203512192, + 0.10757720470428467, + 0.019451804459095, + 0.3488609790802002, + 0.18187405169010162, + 0.038315802812576294 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008014662191271782 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mantis with vibrant emerald green coloration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis initially perched on a broad emerald bamboo leaf with dewdrops visible on the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis perform a swift sideways swerve to duck beneath another bamboo leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan to the right at an extremely fast speed to follow the mantis's pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the mantis's sickle-shaped front legs fully extended in the air during the pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023299837484955788 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732999324798584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023299837484955788, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023299837484955788, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07093678414821625, + 0.1595848798751831, + 0.06525386869907379, + 0.028496215119957924, + 0.024400483816862106, + 0.06327741593122482, + 0.021831391379237175, + 0.45026370882987976, + 0.09110336005687714, + 0.024851856753230095 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023299837484955788 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mantis with vibrant emerald green coloration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis initially perched on a broad emerald bamboo leaf with dewdrops visible on the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis perform a swift sideways swerve to duck beneath another bamboo leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan to the right at an extremely fast speed to follow the mantis's pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the mantis's sickle-shaped front legs fully extended in the air during the pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000225782394409 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695002317428589 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000225782394409, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000225782394409, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10988333821296692, + 0.10262338817119598, + 0.08349193632602692, + 0.09113029390573502, + 0.14670461416244507, + 0.18249592185020447, + 0.10437175631523132, + 0.0963687002658844, + 0.03304130956530571, + 0.04988874867558479 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000225782394409 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mantis with vibrant emerald green coloration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis initially perched on a broad emerald bamboo leaf with dewdrops visible on the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis perform a swift sideways swerve to duck beneath another bamboo leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan to the right at an extremely fast speed to follow the mantis's pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the mantis's sickle-shaped front legs fully extended in the air during the pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1798742264509201 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048741817474365 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1798742264509201, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1798742264509201, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0479654036462307, + 0.02064448781311512, + 0.034455444663763046, + 0.02963067591190338, + 0.08530585467815399, + 0.20376884937286377, + 0.14792419970035553, + 0.3518809378147125, + 0.058725789189338684, + 0.019698360934853554 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1798742264509201 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mantis with vibrant emerald green coloration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis initially perched on a broad emerald bamboo leaf with dewdrops visible on the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis perform a swift sideways swerve to duck beneath another bamboo leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan to the right at an extremely fast speed to follow the mantis's pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the mantis's sickle-shaped front legs fully extended in the air during the pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015644907951355 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015645503997803 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2015644907951355, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2015644907951355, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06456682085990906, + 0.15127913653850555, + 0.042490553110837936, + 0.04020554572343826, + 0.11228252947330475, + 0.09318273514509201, + 0.05146169289946556, + 0.19429750740528107, + 0.20768848061561584, + 0.04254494607448578 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2015644907951355 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning macro close-up captures a mantis, vibrant emerald green, perched like a finely sculpted jade stone on a broad, emerald bamboo leaf. Soft morning sunlight filters through the bamboo forest, casting dappled shadows on the leaves, their edges shimmering with dewdrops, creating a tranquil yet vibrant atmosphere. Atop its triangular head, a pair of large, deep-set compound eyes gleam with a calm and focused gaze. Its signature sickle-shaped forelimbs are tucked against its chest in a classic, alert stance. Suddenly, with a light, almost instantaneous swerve, it swerves sideways, deftly ducking beneath the edge of another bamboo leaf with the dexterity of a martial arts master. Then, the camera panned to the right at an extremely fast speed, closely following its swift pounce - its hind legs suddenly exerted force, and its entire body rushed forward like a green arrow from a string with a swift and precise posture, its sickle-shaped front legs fully extended in the air, with a clear target. The whole picture, outlined by the sunlight, was full of focus, elegance and explosive power.", + "seed": 20706, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_13/index_9214_seed_20706_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.14032653346657753, + "vlm_logprob": -0.14032653346657753, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.14032653346657753, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mantis with vibrant emerald green coloration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis initially perched on a broad emerald bamboo leaf with dewdrops visible on the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis perform a swift sideways swerve to duck beneath another bamboo leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan to the right at an extremely fast speed to follow the mantis's pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the mantis's sickle-shaped front legs fully extended in the air during the pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0055944304913282394 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255594253540039 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0055944304913282394, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0055944304913282394, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1521785408258438, + 0.11882460862398148, + 0.0806979313492775, + 0.16106145083904266, + 0.06466343998908997, + 0.04567267745733261, + 0.13868999481201172, + 0.05264553800225258, + 0.14314229786396027, + 0.042423512786626816 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0055944304913282394 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mantis with vibrant emerald green coloration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis initially perched on a broad emerald bamboo leaf with dewdrops visible on the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis perform a swift sideways swerve to duck beneath another bamboo leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan to the right at an extremely fast speed to follow the mantis's pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the mantis's sickle-shaped front legs fully extended in the air during the pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329867146909237 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773298740386963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329867146909237, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329867146909237, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1405637264251709, + 0.14758218824863434, + 0.025914490222930908, + 0.056581128388643265, + 0.09918105602264404, + 0.03854262828826904, + 0.21553005278110504, + 0.03931187465786934, + 0.2130301296710968, + 0.023762760683894157 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329867146909237 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mantis with vibrant emerald green coloration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis initially perched on a broad emerald bamboo leaf with dewdrops visible on the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis perform a swift sideways swerve to duck beneath another bamboo leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan to the right at an extremely fast speed to follow the mantis's pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the mantis's sickle-shaped front legs fully extended in the air during the pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809213638305664 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2880921363830566 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809213638305664, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809213638305664, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08971504867076874, + 0.43192362785339355, + 0.033905260264873505, + 0.03651784360408783, + 0.09895054250955582, + 0.01773289404809475, + 0.03736553341150284, + 0.06091921776533127, + 0.1635454148054123, + 0.02942459098994732 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809213638305664 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mantis with vibrant emerald green coloration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis initially perched on a broad emerald bamboo leaf with dewdrops visible on the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis perform a swift sideways swerve to duck beneath another bamboo leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan to the right at an extremely fast speed to follow the mantis's pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the mantis's sickle-shaped front legs fully extended in the air during the pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47427403926849365 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742740392684937 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47427403926849365, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47427403926849365, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06553251296281815, + 0.3768177628517151, + 0.023268582299351692, + 0.09313195198774338, + 0.04243317246437073, + 0.01761299930512905, + 0.04464512690901756, + 0.03580586612224579, + 0.22413475811481476, + 0.07661730796098709 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47427403926849365 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mantis with vibrant emerald green coloration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis initially perched on a broad emerald bamboo leaf with dewdrops visible on the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis perform a swift sideways swerve to duck beneath another bamboo leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan to the right at an extremely fast speed to follow the mantis's pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the mantis's sickle-shaped front legs fully extended in the air during the pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16037338972091675 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103734493255615 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16037338972091675, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16037338972091675, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10597814619541168, + 0.15255425870418549, + 0.05928695946931839, + 0.04682524874806404, + 0.09604649990797043, + 0.016541004180908203, + 0.0710296779870987, + 0.21354049444198608, + 0.17625238001346588, + 0.06194527819752693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16037338972091675 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning macro close-up captures a mantis, vibrant emerald green, perched like a finely sculpted jade stone on a broad, emerald bamboo leaf. Soft morning sunlight filters through the bamboo forest, casting dappled shadows on the leaves, their edges shimmering with dewdrops, creating a tranquil yet vibrant atmosphere. Atop its triangular head, a pair of large, deep-set compound eyes gleam with a calm and focused gaze. Its signature sickle-shaped forelimbs are tucked against its chest in a classic, alert stance. Suddenly, with a light, almost instantaneous swerve, it swerves sideways, deftly ducking beneath the edge of another bamboo leaf with the dexterity of a martial arts master. Then, the camera panned to the right at an extremely fast speed, closely following its swift pounce - its hind legs suddenly exerted force, and its entire body rushed forward like a green arrow from a string with a swift and precise posture, its sickle-shaped front legs fully extended in the air, with a clear target. The whole picture, outlined by the sunlight, was full of focus, elegance and explosive power.", + "seed": 20707, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_13/index_9214_seed_20707_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.12941528838127853, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12941528838127853, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.6499999880790712, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12941528838127853, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mantis with vibrant emerald green coloration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis initially perched on a broad emerald bamboo leaf with dewdrops visible on the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis perform a swift sideways swerve to duck beneath another bamboo leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan to the right at an extremely fast speed to follow the mantis's pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the mantis's sickle-shaped front legs fully extended in the air during the pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.010167825035750866 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.635167598724365 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.010167825035750866, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.010167825035750866, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4688800871372223, + 0.33675527572631836, + 0.02756238728761673, + 0.08860834687948227, + 0.014531940221786499, + 0.025772575289011, + 0.016686253249645233, + 0.005927304737269878, + 0.010524814948439598, + 0.004750975873321295 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.010167825035750866 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mantis with vibrant emerald green coloration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis initially perched on a broad emerald bamboo leaf with dewdrops visible on the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis perform a swift sideways swerve to duck beneath another bamboo leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan to the right at an extremely fast speed to follow the mantis's pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the mantis's sickle-shaped front legs fully extended in the air during the pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810475766658783 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288104772567749 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810475766658783, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810475766658783, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3255334198474884, + 0.4568058252334595, + 0.04467545822262764, + 0.03313339129090309, + 0.027817517518997192, + 0.03506038710474968, + 0.01845882274210453, + 0.02031897008419037, + 0.028644604608416557, + 0.009551534429192543 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810475766658783 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mantis with vibrant emerald green coloration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis initially perched on a broad emerald bamboo leaf with dewdrops visible on the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis perform a swift sideways swerve to duck beneath another bamboo leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan to the right at an extremely fast speed to follow the mantis's pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the mantis's sickle-shaped front legs fully extended in the air during the pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864047095179558 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048640489578247 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864047095179558, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864047095179558, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2835742235183716, + 0.3336281478404999, + 0.07276809960603714, + 0.07472006231546402, + 0.0685633048415184, + 0.0783214122056961, + 0.03994618356227875, + 0.017245829105377197, + 0.01420732494443655, + 0.017025409266352654 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864047095179558 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mantis with vibrant emerald green coloration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis initially perched on a broad emerald bamboo leaf with dewdrops visible on the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis perform a swift sideways swerve to duck beneath another bamboo leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan to the right at an extremely fast speed to follow the mantis's pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the mantis's sickle-shaped front legs fully extended in the air during the pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34859567880630493 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2235956192016602 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34859567880630493, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8749999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34859567880630493, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.317680299282074, + 0.14509521424770355, + 0.03419296443462372, + 0.06201628968119621, + 0.12091119587421417, + 0.20326292514801025, + 0.049450844526290894, + 0.036885883659124374, + 0.015489756129682064, + 0.015014552511274815 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34859567880630493 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mantis with vibrant emerald green coloration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis initially perched on a broad emerald bamboo leaf with dewdrops visible on the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis perform a swift sideways swerve to duck beneath another bamboo leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan to the right at an extremely fast speed to follow the mantis's pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the mantis's sickle-shaped front legs fully extended in the air during the pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20156770944595337 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015676498413086 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20156770944595337, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20156770944595337, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1781606823205948, + 0.19358302652835846, + 0.03760034218430519, + 0.1310160756111145, + 0.06704907864332199, + 0.18791459500789642, + 0.09481170028448105, + 0.022821703925728798, + 0.06787995994091034, + 0.019162822514772415 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20156770944595337 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "stunning macro close-up captures a mantis, vibrant emerald green, perched like a finely sculpted jade stone on a broad, emerald bamboo leaf. Soft morning sunlight filters through the bamboo forest, casting dappled shadows on the leaves, their edges shimmering with dewdrops, creating a tranquil yet vibrant atmosphere. Atop its triangular head, a pair of large, deep-set compound eyes gleam with a calm and focused gaze. Its signature sickle-shaped forelimbs are tucked against its chest in a classic, alert stance. Suddenly, with a light, almost instantaneous swerve, it swerves sideways, deftly ducking beneath the edge of another bamboo leaf with the dexterity of a martial arts master. Then, the camera panned to the right at an extremely fast speed, closely following its swift pounce - its hind legs suddenly exerted force, and its entire body rushed forward like a green arrow from a string with a swift and precise posture, its sickle-shaped front legs fully extended in the air, with a clear target. The whole picture, outlined by the sunlight, was full of focus, elegance and explosive power.", + "seed": 20708, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_13/index_9214_seed_20708_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10927436091005802, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10927436091005802, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10927436091005802, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mantis with vibrant emerald green coloration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis initially perched on a broad emerald bamboo leaf with dewdrops visible on the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis perform a swift sideways swerve to duck beneath another bamboo leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan to the right at an extremely fast speed to follow the mantis's pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the mantis's sickle-shaped front legs fully extended in the air during the pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014577431604266167 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264577388763428 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014577431604266167, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014577431604266167, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27036502957344055, + 0.036069851368665695, + 0.05576484650373459, + 0.10807869583368301, + 0.04477478563785553, + 0.14722450077533722, + 0.2059604674577713, + 0.025520818307995796, + 0.05800249055027962, + 0.04823848977684975 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014577431604266167 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mantis with vibrant emerald green coloration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis initially perched on a broad emerald bamboo leaf with dewdrops visible on the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis perform a swift sideways swerve to duck beneath another bamboo leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan to the right at an extremely fast speed to follow the mantis's pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the mantis's sickle-shaped front legs fully extended in the air during the pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026352697983384132 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651352643966675 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026352697983384132, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026352697983384132, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17904150485992432, + 0.10156181454658508, + 0.06064976379275322, + 0.18521563708782196, + 0.062196627259254456, + 0.15020060539245605, + 0.054127320647239685, + 0.04775414988398552, + 0.1353982836008072, + 0.023854298517107964 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026352697983384132 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mantis with vibrant emerald green coloration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis initially perched on a broad emerald bamboo leaf with dewdrops visible on the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis perform a swift sideways swerve to duck beneath another bamboo leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan to the right at an extremely fast speed to follow the mantis's pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the mantis's sickle-shaped front legs fully extended in the air during the pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02979334630072117 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297932624816895 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02979334630072117, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02979334630072117, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12516166269779205, + 0.2759743332862854, + 0.1199856847524643, + 0.16772767901420593, + 0.06896939873695374, + 0.05214435234665871, + 0.04935478791594505, + 0.0616169236600399, + 0.04669945314526558, + 0.03236576169729233 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02979334630072117 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mantis with vibrant emerald green coloration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis initially perched on a broad emerald bamboo leaf with dewdrops visible on the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis perform a swift sideways swerve to duck beneath another bamboo leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan to the right at an extremely fast speed to follow the mantis's pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the mantis's sickle-shaped front legs fully extended in the air during the pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486054241657257 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236053943634033 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486054241657257, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486054241657257, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10513463616371155, + 0.10119134187698364, + 0.03582581505179405, + 0.015772981569170952, + 0.08330567181110382, + 0.14165449142456055, + 0.10706755518913269, + 0.04308434575796127, + 0.10938695073127747, + 0.2575761377811432 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486054241657257 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a mantis with vibrant emerald green coloration?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the mantis initially perched on a broad emerald bamboo leaf with dewdrops visible on the edges?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the mantis perform a swift sideways swerve to duck beneath another bamboo leaf?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera pan to the right at an extremely fast speed to follow the mantis's pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Are the mantis's sickle-shaped front legs fully extended in the air during the pounce?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12704290449619293 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270430088043213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12704290449619293, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12704290449619293, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05334646999835968, + 0.35587480664253235, + 0.22558718919754028, + 0.044630397111177444, + 0.08130476623773575, + 0.03556454926729202, + 0.0843183770775795, + 0.03630540892481804, + 0.032028742134571075, + 0.05103937163949013 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12704290449619293 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_14/index_tensor([7986, 7986])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_14/index_tensor([7986, 7986])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..715090594f106a1ce1aba6b0685b09d6b0fc97f7 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_14/index_tensor([7986, 7986])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "tracking shot, taken at eye level from the center of the back seat, follows a modern car as it steadily drives along a sun-drenched highway. Inside, the driver is a man in his 30s with short, dark hair and a light stubble, wearing a navy polo shirt. To his right, the passenger is a slightly younger man, clean-shaven, with brown hair, wearing a simple gray hooded sweatshirt. The car's interior, composed of black leather seats and a sleek, dark dashboard, is bathed in the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun, casting sharp highlights and long shadows. The driver, with one hand on the steering wheel, momentarily turns his head toward the passenger in a smooth, thoughtful manner and begins to speak, his expression open and engaging. The passenger listens intently, then nods slowly and thoughtfully in understanding. Then, the passenger turns his head to the right, his gaze out the passenger-side window, taking in the blurry scenery of trees and fields passing by. He begins to speak, his profile silhouetted against the bright exterior, creating an atmosphere of contemplation and conversation within the moving vehicle.", + "seed": 1500, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_14/index_7986_seed_1500_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.12543310108594596, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12543310108594596, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12543310108594596, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the back seat looking forward at the driver and passenger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the driver a man in his 30s with short dark hair, light stubble, and a navy polo shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the passenger a slightly younger man with brown hair, clean-shaven, wearing a gray hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature black leather seats and a dark dashboard bathed in warm golden sunlight with sharp highlights and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the passenger turn his head to the right to look out the window at blurry scenery of trees and fields?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3722308576107025 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.247230887413025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3722308576107025, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3722308576107025, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1370922327041626, + 0.48040831089019775, + 0.04694996774196625, + 0.024851815775036812, + 0.016805456951260567, + 0.09510026127099991, + 0.03959242254495621, + 0.05555650591850281, + 0.07287374883890152, + 0.030769292265176773 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3722308576107025 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the back seat looking forward at the driver and passenger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the driver a man in his 30s with short dark hair, light stubble, and a navy polo shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the passenger a slightly younger man with brown hair, clean-shaven, wearing a gray hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature black leather seats and a dark dashboard bathed in warm golden sunlight with sharp highlights and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the passenger turn his head to the right to look out the window at blurry scenery of trees and fields?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07007583230733871 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695075750350952 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07007583230733871, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07007583230733871, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15799592435359955, + 0.2666836380958557, + 0.04596486687660217, + 0.04322883114218712, + 0.06948290765285492, + 0.08547719568014145, + 0.059416454285383224, + 0.1651482880115509, + 0.058521371334791183, + 0.04808048531413078 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07007583230733871 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the back seat looking forward at the driver and passenger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the driver a man in his 30s with short dark hair, light stubble, and a navy polo shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the passenger a slightly younger man with brown hair, clean-shaven, wearing a gray hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature black leather seats and a dark dashboard bathed in warm golden sunlight with sharp highlights and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the passenger turn his head to the right to look out the window at blurry scenery of trees and fields?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05496625602245331 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299662113189697 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05496625602245331, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05496625602245331, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10825289040803909, + 0.37517502903938293, + 0.051560178399086, + 0.027040474116802216, + 0.07476593554019928, + 0.08558812737464905, + 0.05862310901284218, + 0.13435684144496918, + 0.04097471386194229, + 0.043662648648023605 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05496625602245331 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the back seat looking forward at the driver and passenger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the driver a man in his 30s with short dark hair, light stubble, and a navy polo shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the passenger a slightly younger man with brown hair, clean-shaven, wearing a gray hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature black leather seats and a dark dashboard bathed in warm golden sunlight with sharp highlights and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the passenger turn his head to the right to look out the window at blurry scenery of trees and fields?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028242485132068396 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877824306488037 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028242485132068396, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028242485132068396, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19202646613121033, + 0.0581950843334198, + 0.044936131685972214, + 0.029527701437473297, + 0.04712432622909546, + 0.04324887692928314, + 0.10625305771827698, + 0.325423926115036, + 0.09104286879301071, + 0.062221553176641464 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028242485132068396 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the back seat looking forward at the driver and passenger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the driver a man in his 30s with short dark hair, light stubble, and a navy polo shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the passenger a slightly younger man with brown hair, clean-shaven, wearing a gray hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature black leather seats and a dark dashboard bathed in warm golden sunlight with sharp highlights and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the passenger turn his head to the right to look out the window at blurry scenery of trees and fields?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12706831097602844 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.127068281173706 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12706831097602844, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12706831097602844, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.038767531514167786, + 0.49877774715423584, + 0.03337547555565834, + 0.014982767403125763, + 0.017414109781384468, + 0.02565065585076809, + 0.02411193586885929, + 0.30450937151908875, + 0.025780610740184784, + 0.016629764810204506 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12706831097602844 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "tracking shot, taken at eye level from the center of the back seat, follows a modern car as it steadily drives along a sun-drenched highway. Inside, the driver is a man in his 30s with short, dark hair and a light stubble, wearing a navy polo shirt. To his right, the passenger is a slightly younger man, clean-shaven, with brown hair, wearing a simple gray hooded sweatshirt. The car's interior, composed of black leather seats and a sleek, dark dashboard, is bathed in the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun, casting sharp highlights and long shadows. The driver, with one hand on the steering wheel, momentarily turns his head toward the passenger in a smooth, thoughtful manner and begins to speak, his expression open and engaging. The passenger listens intently, then nods slowly and thoughtfully in understanding. Then, the passenger turns his head to the right, his gaze out the passenger-side window, taking in the blurry scenery of trees and fields passing by. He begins to speak, his profile silhouetted against the bright exterior, creating an atmosphere of contemplation and conversation within the moving vehicle.", + "seed": 1501, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_14/index_7986_seed_1501_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.10127052790485322, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10127052790485322, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10127052790485322, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the back seat looking forward at the driver and passenger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the driver a man in his 30s with short dark hair, light stubble, and a navy polo shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the passenger a slightly younger man with brown hair, clean-shaven, wearing a gray hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature black leather seats and a dark dashboard bathed in warm golden sunlight with sharp highlights and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the passenger turn his head to the right to look out the window at blurry scenery of trees and fields?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1196841225028038 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3696842193603516 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1196841225028038, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1196841225028038, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1872522085905075, + 0.07112246006727219, + 0.2833201289176941, + 0.11036232113838196, + 0.03124709241092205, + 0.05235603451728821, + 0.044974010437726974, + 0.08428274840116501, + 0.08996156603097916, + 0.045121487230062485 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1196841225028038 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the back seat looking forward at the driver and passenger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the driver a man in his 30s with short dark hair, light stubble, and a navy polo shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the passenger a slightly younger man with brown hair, clean-shaven, wearing a gray hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature black leather seats and a dark dashboard bathed in warm golden sunlight with sharp highlights and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the passenger turn his head to the right to look out the window at blurry scenery of trees and fields?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14294719696044922 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017947196960449 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14294719696044922, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14294719696044922, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16461093723773956, + 0.2739589214324951, + 0.12415358424186707, + 0.1229734942317009, + 0.05237998068332672, + 0.03586910292506218, + 0.036045435816049576, + 0.05967681109905243, + 0.06998057663440704, + 0.06035112589597702 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14294719696044922 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the back seat looking forward at the driver and passenger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the driver a man in his 30s with short dark hair, light stubble, and a navy polo shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the passenger a slightly younger man with brown hair, clean-shaven, wearing a gray hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature black leather seats and a dark dashboard bathed in warm golden sunlight with sharp highlights and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the passenger turn his head to the right to look out the window at blurry scenery of trees and fields?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620722621679306 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812072277069092 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620722621679306, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620722621679306, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15026064217090607, + 0.23811663687229156, + 0.12529721856117249, + 0.15164333581924438, + 0.0803321972489357, + 0.031961966305971146, + 0.06632192432880402, + 0.055246345698833466, + 0.061662718653678894, + 0.0391569621860981 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620722621679306 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the back seat looking forward at the driver and passenger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the driver a man in his 30s with short dark hair, light stubble, and a navy polo shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the passenger a slightly younger man with brown hair, clean-shaven, wearing a gray hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature black leather seats and a dark dashboard bathed in warm golden sunlight with sharp highlights and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the passenger turn his head to the right to look out the window at blurry scenery of trees and fields?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017178792040795088 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376718044281006 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017178792040795088, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017178792040795088, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17134469747543335, + 0.19205674529075623, + 0.15053944289684296, + 0.07366184145212173, + 0.07578917592763901, + 0.05048061162233353, + 0.04319025203585625, + 0.05167846009135246, + 0.13551560044288635, + 0.05574316531419754 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017178792040795088 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the back seat looking forward at the driver and passenger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the driver a man in his 30s with short dark hair, light stubble, and a navy polo shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the passenger a slightly younger man with brown hair, clean-shaven, wearing a gray hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature black leather seats and a dark dashboard bathed in warm golden sunlight with sharp highlights and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the passenger turn his head to the right to look out the window at blurry scenery of trees and fields?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.179931178689003 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8049311637878418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.179931178689003, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.179931178689003, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10841013491153717, + 0.13264277577400208, + 0.13078522682189941, + 0.08492936939001083, + 0.08372807502746582, + 0.03209409490227699, + 0.08383553475141525, + 0.0410258024930954, + 0.24862612783908844, + 0.053922805935144424 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.179931178689003 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "tracking shot, taken at eye level from the center of the back seat, follows a modern car as it steadily drives along a sun-drenched highway. Inside, the driver is a man in his 30s with short, dark hair and a light stubble, wearing a navy polo shirt. To his right, the passenger is a slightly younger man, clean-shaven, with brown hair, wearing a simple gray hooded sweatshirt. The car's interior, composed of black leather seats and a sleek, dark dashboard, is bathed in the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun, casting sharp highlights and long shadows. The driver, with one hand on the steering wheel, momentarily turns his head toward the passenger in a smooth, thoughtful manner and begins to speak, his expression open and engaging. The passenger listens intently, then nods slowly and thoughtfully in understanding. Then, the passenger turns his head to the right, his gaze out the passenger-side window, taking in the blurry scenery of trees and fields passing by. He begins to speak, his profile silhouetted against the bright exterior, creating an atmosphere of contemplation and conversation within the moving vehicle.", + "seed": 1502, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_14/index_7986_seed_1502_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.12384477918967604, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12384477918967604, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.8999999880790712, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12384477918967604, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the back seat looking forward at the driver and passenger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the driver a man in his 30s with short dark hair, light stubble, and a navy polo shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the passenger a slightly younger man with brown hair, clean-shaven, wearing a gray hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature black leather seats and a dark dashboard bathed in warm golden sunlight with sharp highlights and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the passenger turn his head to the right to look out the window at blurry scenery of trees and fields?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.32168060541152954 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3216805458068848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.32168060541152954, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.9999999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.32168060541152954, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36997854709625244, + 0.0495661236345768, + 0.04194068908691406, + 0.06112771853804588, + 0.04420823976397514, + 0.044313978403806686, + 0.0387616902589798, + 0.2443270981311798, + 0.06609886884689331, + 0.03967712074518204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.32168060541152954 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the back seat looking forward at the driver and passenger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the driver a man in his 30s with short dark hair, light stubble, and a navy polo shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the passenger a slightly younger man with brown hair, clean-shaven, wearing a gray hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature black leather seats and a dark dashboard bathed in warm golden sunlight with sharp highlights and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the passenger turn his head to the right to look out the window at blurry scenery of trees and fields?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05500642582774162 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.930006504058838 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05500642582774162, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05500642582774162, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.304460734128952, + 0.11023011058568954, + 0.04382001981139183, + 0.06615611165761948, + 0.04045429453253746, + 0.03514488786458969, + 0.03753533959388733, + 0.22019706666469574, + 0.07820957899093628, + 0.0637919157743454 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05500642582774162 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the back seat looking forward at the driver and passenger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the driver a man in his 30s with short dark hair, light stubble, and a navy polo shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the passenger a slightly younger man with brown hair, clean-shaven, wearing a gray hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature black leather seats and a dark dashboard bathed in warm golden sunlight with sharp highlights and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the passenger turn his head to the right to look out the window at blurry scenery of trees and fields?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03811095654964447 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881109714508057 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03811095654964447, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03811095654964447, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2366330623626709, + 0.1058945432305336, + 0.07354158908128738, + 0.10771564394235611, + 0.06869621574878693, + 0.04204929247498512, + 0.07483742386102676, + 0.11521197110414505, + 0.07233745604753494, + 0.10308278352022171 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03811095654964447 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the back seat looking forward at the driver and passenger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the driver a man in his 30s with short dark hair, light stubble, and a navy polo shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the passenger a slightly younger man with brown hair, clean-shaven, wearing a gray hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature black leather seats and a dark dashboard bathed in warm golden sunlight with sharp highlights and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the passenger turn his head to the right to look out the window at blurry scenery of trees and fields?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002822346519678831 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877822399139404 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002822346519678831, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002822346519678831, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22374385595321655, + 0.12396695464849472, + 0.09190123528242111, + 0.1095767468214035, + 0.07414723932743073, + 0.07353837788105011, + 0.0676923543214798, + 0.11072688549757004, + 0.0431741401553154, + 0.08153215050697327 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002822346519678831 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the back seat looking forward at the driver and passenger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the driver a man in his 30s with short dark hair, light stubble, and a navy polo shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the passenger a slightly younger man with brown hair, clean-shaven, wearing a gray hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature black leather seats and a dark dashboard bathed in warm golden sunlight with sharp highlights and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the passenger turn his head to the right to look out the window at blurry scenery of trees and fields?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20160356163978577 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7016035318374634 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20160356163978577, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20160356163978577, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15312406420707703, + 0.09982864558696747, + 0.07719913125038147, + 0.0807068794965744, + 0.08460929989814758, + 0.06121324375271797, + 0.09932548552751541, + 0.11173448711633682, + 0.13287748396396637, + 0.09938124567270279 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20160356163978577 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "tracking shot, taken at eye level from the center of the back seat, follows a modern car as it steadily drives along a sun-drenched highway. Inside, the driver is a man in his 30s with short, dark hair and a light stubble, wearing a navy polo shirt. To his right, the passenger is a slightly younger man, clean-shaven, with brown hair, wearing a simple gray hooded sweatshirt. The car's interior, composed of black leather seats and a sleek, dark dashboard, is bathed in the warm golden glow of the afternoon sun, casting sharp highlights and long shadows. The driver, with one hand on the steering wheel, momentarily turns his head toward the passenger in a smooth, thoughtful manner and begins to speak, his expression open and engaging. The passenger listens intently, then nods slowly and thoughtfully in understanding. Then, the passenger turns his head to the right, his gaze out the passenger-side window, taking in the blurry scenery of trees and fields passing by. He begins to speak, his profile silhouetted against the bright exterior, creating an atmosphere of contemplation and conversation within the moving vehicle.", + "seed": 1503, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_14/index_7986_seed_1503_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1614647889509797, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1614647889509797, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.749999988079071, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1614647889509797, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the back seat looking forward at the driver and passenger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the driver a man in his 30s with short dark hair, light stubble, and a navy polo shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the passenger a slightly younger man with brown hair, clean-shaven, wearing a gray hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature black leather seats and a dark dashboard bathed in warm golden sunlight with sharp highlights and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the passenger turn his head to the right to look out the window at blurry scenery of trees and fields?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3353568911552429 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3353569507598877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3353568911552429, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3353568911552429, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6293979287147522, + 0.07796131074428558, + 0.03164413571357727, + 0.042059872299432755, + 0.015436425805091858, + 0.035337988287210464, + 0.015283322893083096, + 0.040572501718997955, + 0.05859770625829697, + 0.053708747029304504 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3353568911552429 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the back seat looking forward at the driver and passenger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the driver a man in his 30s with short dark hair, light stubble, and a navy polo shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the passenger a slightly younger man with brown hair, clean-shaven, wearing a gray hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature black leather seats and a dark dashboard bathed in warm golden sunlight with sharp highlights and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the passenger turn his head to the right to look out the window at blurry scenery of trees and fields?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03813367709517479 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881336212158203 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03813367709517479, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03813367709517479, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32948923110961914, + 0.20125800371170044, + 0.030021071434020996, + 0.06432385742664337, + 0.031273432075977325, + 0.13508282601833344, + 0.032776277512311935, + 0.04755522310733795, + 0.016484718769788742, + 0.11173539608716965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03813367709517479 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the back seat looking forward at the driver and passenger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the driver a man in his 30s with short dark hair, light stubble, and a navy polo shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the passenger a slightly younger man with brown hair, clean-shaven, wearing a gray hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature black leather seats and a dark dashboard bathed in warm golden sunlight with sharp highlights and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the passenger turn his head to the right to look out the window at blurry scenery of trees and fields?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306967929005623 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.16806960105896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306967929005623, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306967929005623, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.245726078748703, + 0.10549448430538177, + 0.05814504995942116, + 0.04479948803782463, + 0.03942437097430229, + 0.18341869115829468, + 0.028456727042794228, + 0.046582385897636414, + 0.09744767844676971, + 0.15050503611564636 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306967929005623 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the back seat looking forward at the driver and passenger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the driver a man in his 30s with short dark hair, light stubble, and a navy polo shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the passenger a slightly younger man with brown hair, clean-shaven, wearing a gray hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature black leather seats and a dark dashboard bathed in warm golden sunlight with sharp highlights and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the passenger turn his head to the right to look out the window at blurry scenery of trees and fields?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003619787283241749 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.62861967086792 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003619787283241749, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003619787283241749, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5338264107704163, + 0.2043493390083313, + 0.03961983323097229, + 0.022483214735984802, + 0.014319797046482563, + 0.027472667396068573, + 0.02240350842475891, + 0.021459326148033142, + 0.0773036852478981, + 0.036762237548828125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003619787283241749 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera positioned inside the back seat looking forward at the driver and passenger?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the driver a man in his 30s with short dark hair, light stubble, and a navy polo shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the passenger a slightly younger man with brown hair, clean-shaven, wearing a gray hooded sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the scene feature black leather seats and a dark dashboard bathed in warm golden sunlight with sharp highlights and long shadows?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the passenger turn his head to the right to look out the window at blurry scenery of trees and fields?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38714390993118286 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.137143850326538 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38714390993118286, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.7499999403953552, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38714390993118286, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1844918429851532, + 0.1281471699476242, + 0.054184772074222565, + 0.06525027006864548, + 0.10788814723491669, + 0.11188817024230957, + 0.043138451874256134, + 0.03395254909992218, + 0.1508949249982834, + 0.12016373127698898 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38714390993118286 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_15/index_tensor([8376, 8376])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_15/index_tensor([8376, 8376])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f8c33f0ec3b116af2b1438866ac1213ce9237d4e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_15/index_tensor([8376, 8376])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In the distinctive style of traditional Chinese landscape painting, a slow, sweeping panoramic shot begins, like the unrolling of a long scroll, revealing a vast automobile manufacturing plant engulfed in thick smoke from a distant forest fire. The massive rooftops, chimneys, and angular industrial structures are rendered not with metallic precision but with the subtle, fluid elegance of calligraphic line and ink technique. Their solid forms are softly softened and subtly obscured by the atmospheric ochre and gray haze, creating a profound sense of depth and distance against the pale, paper-textured sky. Flickering embers, shimmering like tiny bright orange blossoms, float lazily in the air, their vibrant colors contrasting starkly and beautifully against the muted, monochromatic palette of the mist. As the camera continues its deliberate panning around the silent, deserted complex, it captures a profound and eerie silence, transforming the industrial landscape into a beautiful yet unsettling vision of desolation, where the power of modern industry becomes fragile and ephemeral against the overwhelming painterly force of nature.", + "seed": 10865, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_15/index_8376_seed_10865_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.09841040335595608, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09841040335595608, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09841040335595608, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with traditional Chinese landscape painting, featuring calligraphic lines and ink techniques?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an automobile manufacturing plant with visible massive rooftops, chimneys, and angular industrial structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the industrial complex engulfed in thick smoke from a distant forest fire, with the forms softened by an atmospheric ochre and gray haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are flickering embers visible floating in the air, appearing as tiny bright orange blossoms against a muted, monochromatic palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping panoramic shot that pans around the deserted complex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.351127952337265 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2261279821395874 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.351127952337265, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.351127952337265, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2922625243663788, + 0.08390486985445023, + 0.17752905189990997, + 0.044382091611623764, + 0.028152231127023697, + 0.08174815773963928, + 0.0484342947602272, + 0.09617982059717178, + 0.0729251503944397, + 0.0744817852973938 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.351127952337265 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with traditional Chinese landscape painting, featuring calligraphic lines and ink techniques?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an automobile manufacturing plant with visible massive rooftops, chimneys, and angular industrial structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the industrial complex engulfed in thick smoke from a distant forest fire, with the forms softened by an atmospheric ochre and gray haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are flickering embers visible floating in the air, appearing as tiny bright orange blossoms against a muted, monochromatic palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping panoramic shot that pans around the deserted complex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05498329550027847 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929983377456665 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05498329550027847, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05498329550027847, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04798498749732971, + 0.04608238860964775, + 0.5575517416000366, + 0.039711374789476395, + 0.008787940256297588, + 0.08296702802181244, + 0.04163074493408203, + 0.035269297659397125, + 0.10455106198787689, + 0.0354633592069149 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05498329550027847 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with traditional Chinese landscape painting, featuring calligraphic lines and ink techniques?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an automobile manufacturing plant with visible massive rooftops, chimneys, and angular industrial structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the industrial complex engulfed in thick smoke from a distant forest fire, with the forms softened by an atmospheric ochre and gray haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are flickering embers visible floating in the air, appearing as tiny bright orange blossoms against a muted, monochromatic palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping panoramic shot that pans around the deserted complex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634979411959648 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513497829437256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634979411959648, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634979411959648, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07741837203502655, + 0.055139537900686264, + 0.5437251925468445, + 0.03945476561784744, + 0.02919355034828186, + 0.07680527865886688, + 0.03427779674530029, + 0.05920922011137009, + 0.046289071440696716, + 0.03848718851804733 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634979411959648 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with traditional Chinese landscape painting, featuring calligraphic lines and ink techniques?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an automobile manufacturing plant with visible massive rooftops, chimneys, and angular industrial structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the industrial complex engulfed in thick smoke from a distant forest fire, with the forms softened by an atmospheric ochre and gray haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are flickering embers visible floating in the air, appearing as tiny bright orange blossoms against a muted, monochromatic palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping panoramic shot that pans around the deserted complex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029804455116391182 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298044681549072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029804455116391182, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029804455116391182, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29346683621406555, + 0.07529336959123611, + 0.19939015805721283, + 0.04343655705451965, + 0.029823491349816322, + 0.05085498094558716, + 0.04503246396780014, + 0.09622882306575775, + 0.09658364951610565, + 0.06988964974880219 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029804455116391182 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with traditional Chinese landscape painting, featuring calligraphic lines and ink techniques?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an automobile manufacturing plant with visible massive rooftops, chimneys, and angular industrial structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the industrial complex engulfed in thick smoke from a distant forest fire, with the forms softened by an atmospheric ochre and gray haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are flickering embers visible floating in the air, appearing as tiny bright orange blossoms against a muted, monochromatic palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping panoramic shot that pans around the deserted complex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029786519706249237 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5297865867614746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029786519706249237, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029786519706249237, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09248610585927963, + 0.06770104169845581, + 0.28817489743232727, + 0.0214085653424263, + 0.020370859652757645, + 0.021812105551362038, + 0.1731260120868683, + 0.06073027104139328, + 0.21490933001041412, + 0.03928079828619957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029786519706249237 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the distinctive style of traditional Chinese landscape painting, a slow, sweeping panoramic shot begins, like the unrolling of a long scroll, revealing a vast automobile manufacturing plant engulfed in thick smoke from a distant forest fire. The massive rooftops, chimneys, and angular industrial structures are rendered not with metallic precision but with the subtle, fluid elegance of calligraphic line and ink technique. Their solid forms are softly softened and subtly obscured by the atmospheric ochre and gray haze, creating a profound sense of depth and distance against the pale, paper-textured sky. Flickering embers, shimmering like tiny bright orange blossoms, float lazily in the air, their vibrant colors contrasting starkly and beautifully against the muted, monochromatic palette of the mist. As the camera continues its deliberate panning around the silent, deserted complex, it captures a profound and eerie silence, transforming the industrial landscape into a beautiful yet unsettling vision of desolation, where the power of modern industry becomes fragile and ephemeral against the overwhelming painterly force of nature.", + "seed": 10866, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_15/index_8376_seed_10866_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08892260156571866, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08892260156571866, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08892260156571866, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with traditional Chinese landscape painting, featuring calligraphic lines and ink techniques?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an automobile manufacturing plant with visible massive rooftops, chimneys, and angular industrial structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the industrial complex engulfed in thick smoke from a distant forest fire, with the forms softened by an atmospheric ochre and gray haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are flickering embers visible floating in the air, appearing as tiny bright orange blossoms against a muted, monochromatic palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping panoramic shot that pans around the deserted complex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2833459675312042 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4083459377288818 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2833459675312042, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2833459675312042, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15483354032039642, + 0.2658180594444275, + 0.10702653974294662, + 0.07703708112239838, + 0.10068263113498688, + 0.011841965839266777, + 0.03512589633464813, + 0.027743171900510788, + 0.034651633352041245, + 0.18523955345153809 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2833459675312042 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with traditional Chinese landscape painting, featuring calligraphic lines and ink techniques?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an automobile manufacturing plant with visible massive rooftops, chimneys, and angular industrial structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the industrial complex engulfed in thick smoke from a distant forest fire, with the forms softened by an atmospheric ochre and gray haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are flickering embers visible floating in the air, appearing as tiny bright orange blossoms against a muted, monochromatic palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping panoramic shot that pans around the deserted complex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06206789240241051 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812067985534668 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06206789240241051, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06206789240241051, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07133190333843231, + 0.4038586914539337, + 0.05664973333477974, + 0.07809893786907196, + 0.08158277720212936, + 0.026166535913944244, + 0.06299443542957306, + 0.020770035684108734, + 0.08762577921152115, + 0.11092115938663483 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06206789240241051 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with traditional Chinese landscape painting, featuring calligraphic lines and ink techniques?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an automobile manufacturing plant with visible massive rooftops, chimneys, and angular industrial structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the industrial complex engulfed in thick smoke from a distant forest fire, with the forms softened by an atmospheric ochre and gray haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are flickering embers visible floating in the air, appearing as tiny bright orange blossoms against a muted, monochromatic palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping panoramic shot that pans around the deserted complex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029803991317749023 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529803991317749 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029803991317749023, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029803991317749023, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1223348081111908, + 0.15651477873325348, + 0.055566538125276566, + 0.1767456978559494, + 0.02658820152282715, + 0.024231363087892532, + 0.052263081073760986, + 0.017749549821019173, + 0.05415225028991699, + 0.3138537108898163 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029803991317749023 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with traditional Chinese landscape painting, featuring calligraphic lines and ink techniques?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an automobile manufacturing plant with visible massive rooftops, chimneys, and angular industrial structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the industrial complex engulfed in thick smoke from a distant forest fire, with the forms softened by an atmospheric ochre and gray haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are flickering embers visible floating in the air, appearing as tiny bright orange blossoms against a muted, monochromatic palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping panoramic shot that pans around the deserted complex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305883124470711 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680588722229004 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305883124470711, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305883124470711, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12950322031974792, + 0.047871291637420654, + 0.08280187100172043, + 0.5591943264007568, + 0.030739298090338707, + 0.015535051003098488, + 0.03327435627579689, + 0.013873935677111149, + 0.02620968036353588, + 0.06099698320031166 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305883124470711 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with traditional Chinese landscape painting, featuring calligraphic lines and ink techniques?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an automobile manufacturing plant with visible massive rooftops, chimneys, and angular industrial structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the industrial complex engulfed in thick smoke from a distant forest fire, with the forms softened by an atmospheric ochre and gray haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are flickering embers visible floating in the air, appearing as tiny bright orange blossoms against a muted, monochromatic palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping panoramic shot that pans around the deserted complex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026336325332522392 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651336431503296 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026336325332522392, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026336325332522392, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18373264372348785, + 0.17485810816287994, + 0.14449720084667206, + 0.1325015425682068, + 0.031944192945957184, + 0.02140522375702858, + 0.10136151313781738, + 0.01775422878563404, + 0.08939211070537567, + 0.10255333036184311 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026336325332522392 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the distinctive style of traditional Chinese landscape painting, a slow, sweeping panoramic shot begins, like the unrolling of a long scroll, revealing a vast automobile manufacturing plant engulfed in thick smoke from a distant forest fire. The massive rooftops, chimneys, and angular industrial structures are rendered not with metallic precision but with the subtle, fluid elegance of calligraphic line and ink technique. Their solid forms are softly softened and subtly obscured by the atmospheric ochre and gray haze, creating a profound sense of depth and distance against the pale, paper-textured sky. Flickering embers, shimmering like tiny bright orange blossoms, float lazily in the air, their vibrant colors contrasting starkly and beautifully against the muted, monochromatic palette of the mist. As the camera continues its deliberate panning around the silent, deserted complex, it captures a profound and eerie silence, transforming the industrial landscape into a beautiful yet unsettling vision of desolation, where the power of modern industry becomes fragile and ephemeral against the overwhelming painterly force of nature.", + "seed": 10867, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_15/index_8376_seed_10867_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05663781296461821, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05663781296461821, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05663781296461821, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with traditional Chinese landscape painting, featuring calligraphic lines and ink techniques?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an automobile manufacturing plant with visible massive rooftops, chimneys, and angular industrial structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the industrial complex engulfed in thick smoke from a distant forest fire, with the forms softened by an atmospheric ochre and gray haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are flickering embers visible floating in the air, appearing as tiny bright orange blossoms against a muted, monochromatic palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping panoramic shot that pans around the deserted complex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1450812816619873 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0200812816619873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1450812816619873, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1450812816619873, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1880025863647461, + 0.09548729658126831, + 0.09084182977676392, + 0.06246219575405121, + 0.1231355369091034, + 0.026049263775348663, + 0.01723521016538143, + 0.04008513316512108, + 0.3187545835971832, + 0.03794635459780693 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1450812816619873 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with traditional Chinese landscape painting, featuring calligraphic lines and ink techniques?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an automobile manufacturing plant with visible massive rooftops, chimneys, and angular industrial structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the industrial complex engulfed in thick smoke from a distant forest fire, with the forms softened by an atmospheric ochre and gray haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are flickering embers visible floating in the air, appearing as tiny bright orange blossoms against a muted, monochromatic palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping panoramic shot that pans around the deserted complex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07003926485776901 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950392723083496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07003926485776901, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07003926485776901, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35973989963531494, + 0.1076495498418808, + 0.05753563344478607, + 0.04369034990668297, + 0.0667012631893158, + 0.023816410452127457, + 0.044344812631607056, + 0.10529820621013641, + 0.08072756230831146, + 0.11049634218215942 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07003926485776901 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with traditional Chinese landscape painting, featuring calligraphic lines and ink techniques?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an automobile manufacturing plant with visible massive rooftops, chimneys, and angular industrial structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the industrial complex engulfed in thick smoke from a distant forest fire, with the forms softened by an atmospheric ochre and gray haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are flickering embers visible floating in the air, appearing as tiny bright orange blossoms against a muted, monochromatic palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping panoramic shot that pans around the deserted complex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023297391831874847 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7732973098754883 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023297391831874847, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023297391831874847, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17035473883152008, + 0.11696834117174149, + 0.03737965226173401, + 0.0589577741920948, + 0.12490701675415039, + 0.03531911224126816, + 0.029544930905103683, + 0.046462468802928925, + 0.3038646876811981, + 0.07624127715826035 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023297391831874847 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with traditional Chinese landscape painting, featuring calligraphic lines and ink techniques?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an automobile manufacturing plant with visible massive rooftops, chimneys, and angular industrial structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the industrial complex engulfed in thick smoke from a distant forest fire, with the forms softened by an atmospheric ochre and gray haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are flickering embers visible floating in the air, appearing as tiny bright orange blossoms against a muted, monochromatic palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping panoramic shot that pans around the deserted complex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033700864762067795 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408700942993164 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033700864762067795, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033700864762067795, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20865413546562195, + 0.06378206610679626, + 0.0414501428604126, + 0.04446341469883919, + 0.11975981295108795, + 0.10554500669240952, + 0.11451523751020432, + 0.03994249552488327, + 0.1881091445684433, + 0.07377853244543076 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033700864762067795 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with traditional Chinese landscape painting, featuring calligraphic lines and ink techniques?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an automobile manufacturing plant with visible massive rooftops, chimneys, and angular industrial structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the industrial complex engulfed in thick smoke from a distant forest fire, with the forms softened by an atmospheric ochre and gray haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are flickering embers visible floating in the air, appearing as tiny bright orange blossoms against a muted, monochromatic palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping panoramic shot that pans around the deserted complex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107026170939207 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511070251464844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107026170939207, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107026170939207, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3026062548160553, + 0.23515596985816956, + 0.03930506482720375, + 0.06803010404109955, + 0.05764349550008774, + 0.04818706959486008, + 0.043011393398046494, + 0.15008874237537384, + 0.03341703116893768, + 0.022554874420166016 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107026170939207 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In the distinctive style of traditional Chinese landscape painting, a slow, sweeping panoramic shot begins, like the unrolling of a long scroll, revealing a vast automobile manufacturing plant engulfed in thick smoke from a distant forest fire. The massive rooftops, chimneys, and angular industrial structures are rendered not with metallic precision but with the subtle, fluid elegance of calligraphic line and ink technique. Their solid forms are softly softened and subtly obscured by the atmospheric ochre and gray haze, creating a profound sense of depth and distance against the pale, paper-textured sky. Flickering embers, shimmering like tiny bright orange blossoms, float lazily in the air, their vibrant colors contrasting starkly and beautifully against the muted, monochromatic palette of the mist. As the camera continues its deliberate panning around the silent, deserted complex, it captures a profound and eerie silence, transforming the industrial landscape into a beautiful yet unsettling vision of desolation, where the power of modern industry becomes fragile and ephemeral against the overwhelming painterly force of nature.", + "seed": 10868, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_15/index_8376_seed_10868_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.08728886395692825, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08728886395692825, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08728886395692825, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with traditional Chinese landscape painting, featuring calligraphic lines and ink techniques?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an automobile manufacturing plant with visible massive rooftops, chimneys, and angular industrial structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the industrial complex engulfed in thick smoke from a distant forest fire, with the forms softened by an atmospheric ochre and gray haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are flickering embers visible floating in the air, appearing as tiny bright orange blossoms against a muted, monochromatic palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping panoramic shot that pans around the deserted complex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2296220064163208 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6046220064163208 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2296220064163208, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2296220064163208, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30500948429107666, + 0.3400161862373352, + 0.02240743115544319, + 0.07558932155370712, + 0.058776892721652985, + 0.029318910092115402, + 0.05189761891961098, + 0.026491623371839523, + 0.03499255329370499, + 0.05549998581409454 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2296220064163208 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with traditional Chinese landscape painting, featuring calligraphic lines and ink techniques?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an automobile manufacturing plant with visible massive rooftops, chimneys, and angular industrial structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the industrial complex engulfed in thick smoke from a distant forest fire, with the forms softened by an atmospheric ochre and gray haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are flickering embers visible floating in the air, appearing as tiny bright orange blossoms against a muted, monochromatic palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping panoramic shot that pans around the deserted complex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05497866868972778 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929978609085083 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05497866868972778, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05497866868972778, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1175793930888176, + 0.08846231549978256, + 0.03669830411672592, + 0.15806522965431213, + 0.12349014729261398, + 0.057330284267663956, + 0.06451981514692307, + 0.09061349928379059, + 0.10772640258073807, + 0.15551462769508362 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05497866868972778 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with traditional Chinese landscape painting, featuring calligraphic lines and ink techniques?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an automobile manufacturing plant with visible massive rooftops, chimneys, and angular industrial structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the industrial complex engulfed in thick smoke from a distant forest fire, with the forms softened by an atmospheric ochre and gray haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are flickering embers visible floating in the air, appearing as tiny bright orange blossoms against a muted, monochromatic palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping panoramic shot that pans around the deserted complex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02980804070830345 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298080444335938 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02980804070830345, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02980804070830345, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1939331293106079, + 0.19663555920124054, + 0.05528547614812851, + 0.13665920495986938, + 0.0347413495182991, + 0.03636377304792404, + 0.04026831313967705, + 0.06440943479537964, + 0.08942103385925293, + 0.15228271484375 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02980804070830345 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with traditional Chinese landscape painting, featuring calligraphic lines and ink techniques?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an automobile manufacturing plant with visible massive rooftops, chimneys, and angular industrial structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the industrial complex engulfed in thick smoke from a distant forest fire, with the forms softened by an atmospheric ochre and gray haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are flickering embers visible floating in the air, appearing as tiny bright orange blossoms against a muted, monochromatic palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping panoramic shot that pans around the deserted complex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898636162281036 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578986406326294 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898636162281036, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898636162281036, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18757964670658112, + 0.21841025352478027, + 0.04789886623620987, + 0.2522176504135132, + 0.03192241117358208, + 0.04188716784119606, + 0.08430547267198563, + 0.04124722257256508, + 0.035068392753601074, + 0.05946294590830803 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898636162281036 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the visual style of the video consistent with traditional Chinese landscape painting, featuring calligraphic lines and ink techniques?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an automobile manufacturing plant with visible massive rooftops, chimneys, and angular industrial structures?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the industrial complex engulfed in thick smoke from a distant forest fire, with the forms softened by an atmospheric ochre and gray haze?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are flickering embers visible floating in the air, appearing as tiny bright orange blossoms against a muted, monochromatic palette?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, sweeping panoramic shot that pans around the deserted complex?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04304924234747887 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680493354797363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04304924234747887, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04304924234747887, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12683625519275665, + 0.24174675345420837, + 0.0697602704167366, + 0.13236987590789795, + 0.06497436761856079, + 0.12521320581436157, + 0.09099780768156052, + 0.02541731297969818, + 0.06208959221839905, + 0.06059456989169121 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04304924234747887 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_2/index_tensor([9817, 9817])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_2/index_tensor([9817, 9817])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..914f5754081df3f6b395bc136cb06ca0a8dd2c48 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_2/index_tensor([9817, 9817])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "low-angle, medium shot slowly circles around a lone warrior, capturing them at the center of a vast, dark dojo, its polished wooden floor reflecting a sea of golden light. Hundreds of candles line the floor, providing the scene's sole illumination. The warrior's face, a mask of serene concentration, partially concealed by a wisp of long, dark hair, is clad in traditional black hakama and deep indigo keikogi, heavy fabrics swirling around their powerful forms. They meticulously perform a whirling sword dance, their bodies the low, grounded fulcrums of controlled energy. In their hands, a highly polished katana transforms into a continuous silver arc, a ribbon of pure light that cuts through the thick, warm air. The air powerfully expelled from the fluid, relentlessly spinning, slicing blade causes the hundreds of surrounding candle flames to flicker wildly, bending and stretching in a chaotic ballet, casting long, frantic shadows that dance and wriggle across the walls and floor, creating a scene of profound atmosphere and intense meditation, a deadly grace.", + "seed": 17902, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_2/index_9817_seed_17902_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.11278296858072281, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11278296858072281, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11278296858072281, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that circles around the central subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, dark dojo with a polished wooden floor reflecting golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing traditional black hakama and deep indigo keikogi with long dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a whirling sword dance with a highly polished katana creating a silver arc of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do hundreds of surrounding candle flames flicker wildly and cast long, frantic shadows on the walls and floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05444979667663574 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0544497966766357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05444979667663574, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05444979667663574, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14426067471504211, + 0.044332996010780334, + 0.07616894692182541, + 0.06755181401968002, + 0.13051997125148773, + 0.06684275716543198, + 0.12646420300006866, + 0.20342247188091278, + 0.06992997229099274, + 0.07050620019435883 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05444979667663574 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that circles around the central subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, dark dojo with a polished wooden floor reflecting golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing traditional black hakama and deep indigo keikogi with long dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a whirling sword dance with a highly polished katana creating a silver arc of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do hundreds of surrounding candle flames flicker wildly and cast long, frantic shadows on the walls and floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008647849783301353 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758647918701172 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008647849783301353, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008647849783301353, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2527967691421509, + 0.08759398013353348, + 0.08079851418733597, + 0.07051178067922592, + 0.04710130766034126, + 0.057458728551864624, + 0.07174736261367798, + 0.08095791190862656, + 0.069747693836689, + 0.18128587305545807 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008647849783301353 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that circles around the central subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, dark dojo with a polished wooden floor reflecting golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing traditional black hakama and deep indigo keikogi with long dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a whirling sword dance with a highly polished katana creating a silver arc of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do hundreds of surrounding candle flames flicker wildly and cast long, frantic shadows on the walls and floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02058744616806507 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.89558744430542 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02058744616806507, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02058744616806507, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1483220010995865, + 0.09846977144479752, + 0.07618362456560135, + 0.08214852213859558, + 0.2157861441373825, + 0.11238866299390793, + 0.07470465451478958, + 0.10347384959459305, + 0.04337121546268463, + 0.045151542872190475 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02058744616806507 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that circles around the central subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, dark dojo with a polished wooden floor reflecting golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing traditional black hakama and deep indigo keikogi with long dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a whirling sword dance with a highly polished katana creating a silver arc of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do hundreds of surrounding candle flames flicker wildly and cast long, frantic shadows on the walls and floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005946800112724304 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130946636199951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005946800112724304, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005946800112724304, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22023805975914001, + 0.05856955796480179, + 0.09961643815040588, + 0.09068065136671066, + 0.1461644172668457, + 0.07300378382205963, + 0.12365139275789261, + 0.050134897232055664, + 0.07312767207622528, + 0.06481312215328217 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005946800112724304 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that circles around the central subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, dark dojo with a polished wooden floor reflecting golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing traditional black hakama and deep indigo keikogi with long dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a whirling sword dance with a highly polished katana creating a silver arc of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do hundreds of surrounding candle flames flicker wildly and cast long, frantic shadows on the walls and floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4742829501628876 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.97428297996521 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4742829501628876, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4742829501628876, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14836440980434418, + 0.04134666919708252, + 0.3121676743030548, + 0.07153335213661194, + 0.03681561350822449, + 0.06654264032840729, + 0.0638178139925003, + 0.10979314893484116, + 0.04705755040049553, + 0.10256113111972809 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4742829501628876 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, medium shot slowly circles around a lone warrior, capturing them at the center of a vast, dark dojo, its polished wooden floor reflecting a sea of golden light. Hundreds of candles line the floor, providing the scene's sole illumination. The warrior's face, a mask of serene concentration, partially concealed by a wisp of long, dark hair, is clad in traditional black hakama and deep indigo keikogi, heavy fabrics swirling around their powerful forms. They meticulously perform a whirling sword dance, their bodies the low, grounded fulcrums of controlled energy. In their hands, a highly polished katana transforms into a continuous silver arc, a ribbon of pure light that cuts through the thick, warm air. The air powerfully expelled from the fluid, relentlessly spinning, slicing blade causes the hundreds of surrounding candle flames to flicker wildly, bending and stretching in a chaotic ballet, casting long, frantic shadows that dance and wriggle across the walls and floor, creating a scene of profound atmosphere and intense meditation, a deadly grace.", + "seed": 17903, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_2/index_9817_seed_17903_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06964590242132544, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06964590242132544, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06964590242132544, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that circles around the central subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, dark dojo with a polished wooden floor reflecting golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing traditional black hakama and deep indigo keikogi with long dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a whirling sword dance with a highly polished katana creating a silver arc of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do hundreds of surrounding candle flames flicker wildly and cast long, frantic shadows on the walls and floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.036021213978528976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6610212326049805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.036021213978528976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.036021213978528976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17792461812496185, + 0.07728797197341919, + 0.13023273646831512, + 0.062015414237976074, + 0.23707535862922668, + 0.05549132078886032, + 0.0642700120806694, + 0.04088549315929413, + 0.12130666524171829, + 0.03351045399904251 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.036021213978528976 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that circles around the central subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, dark dojo with a polished wooden floor reflecting golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing traditional black hakama and deep indigo keikogi with long dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a whirling sword dance with a highly polished katana creating a silver arc of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do hundreds of surrounding candle flames flicker wildly and cast long, frantic shadows on the walls and floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005956872832030058 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130956649780273 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005956872832030058, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005956872832030058, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36609789729118347, + 0.09146703779697418, + 0.06783398240804672, + 0.06494363397359848, + 0.07152987271547318, + 0.10362214595079422, + 0.07173555344343185, + 0.05824841931462288, + 0.07616259157657623, + 0.028358813375234604 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005956872832030058 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that circles around the central subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, dark dojo with a polished wooden floor reflecting golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing traditional black hakama and deep indigo keikogi with long dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a whirling sword dance with a highly polished katana creating a silver arc of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do hundreds of surrounding candle flames flicker wildly and cast long, frantic shadows on the walls and floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01819268986582756 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018192768096924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01819268986582756, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01819268986582756, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2763124108314514, + 0.10280706733465195, + 0.09341007471084595, + 0.12464439123868942, + 0.15208327770233154, + 0.1368885338306427, + 0.024739986285567284, + 0.01946214959025383, + 0.035104185342788696, + 0.034547943621873856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01819268986582756 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that circles around the central subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, dark dojo with a polished wooden floor reflecting golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing traditional black hakama and deep indigo keikogi with long dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a whirling sword dance with a highly polished katana creating a silver arc of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do hundreds of surrounding candle flames flicker wildly and cast long, frantic shadows on the walls and floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006735123693943024 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006735324859619 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006735123693943024, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006735123693943024, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2243698239326477, + 0.10078918188810349, + 0.07033876329660416, + 0.08735081553459167, + 0.16807137429714203, + 0.056892458349466324, + 0.0563075914978981, + 0.029434651136398315, + 0.15502573549747467, + 0.05141959711909294 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006735123693943024 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that circles around the central subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, dark dojo with a polished wooden floor reflecting golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing traditional black hakama and deep indigo keikogi with long dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a whirling sword dance with a highly polished katana creating a silver arc of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do hundreds of surrounding candle flames flicker wildly and cast long, frantic shadows on the walls and floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813236117362976 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063236713409424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813236117362976, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813236117362976, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25193309783935547, + 0.11448012292385101, + 0.04763820022344589, + 0.07827293872833252, + 0.07670436054468155, + 0.09657535701990128, + 0.059564825147390366, + 0.05467002093791962, + 0.15044790506362915, + 0.06971322745084763 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813236117362976 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, medium shot slowly circles around a lone warrior, capturing them at the center of a vast, dark dojo, its polished wooden floor reflecting a sea of golden light. Hundreds of candles line the floor, providing the scene's sole illumination. The warrior's face, a mask of serene concentration, partially concealed by a wisp of long, dark hair, is clad in traditional black hakama and deep indigo keikogi, heavy fabrics swirling around their powerful forms. They meticulously perform a whirling sword dance, their bodies the low, grounded fulcrums of controlled energy. In their hands, a highly polished katana transforms into a continuous silver arc, a ribbon of pure light that cuts through the thick, warm air. The air powerfully expelled from the fluid, relentlessly spinning, slicing blade causes the hundreds of surrounding candle flames to flicker wildly, bending and stretching in a chaotic ballet, casting long, frantic shadows that dance and wriggle across the walls and floor, creating a scene of profound atmosphere and intense meditation, a deadly grace.", + "seed": 17904, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_2/index_9817_seed_17904_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.09834633562713861, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09834633562713861, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09834633562713861, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that circles around the central subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, dark dojo with a polished wooden floor reflecting golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing traditional black hakama and deep indigo keikogi with long dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a whirling sword dance with a highly polished katana creating a silver arc of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do hundreds of surrounding candle flames flicker wildly and cast long, frantic shadows on the walls and floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02727220393717289 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.9022722244262695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02727220393717289, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02727220393717289, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1845431625843048, + 0.06492435187101364, + 0.04671280458569527, + 0.047680117189884186, + 0.05244457721710205, + 0.06272770464420319, + 0.131975919008255, + 0.0805279016494751, + 0.23969748616218567, + 0.08876602351665497 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02727220393717289 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that circles around the central subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, dark dojo with a polished wooden floor reflecting golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing traditional black hakama and deep indigo keikogi with long dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a whirling sword dance with a highly polished katana creating a silver arc of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do hundreds of surrounding candle flames flicker wildly and cast long, frantic shadows on the walls and floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007636283989995718 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882636070251465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007636283989995718, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007636283989995718, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21164965629577637, + 0.1551426202058792, + 0.06905335932970047, + 0.07757549732923508, + 0.03763860836625099, + 0.19649122655391693, + 0.04392973706126213, + 0.060360029339790344, + 0.09025827050209045, + 0.057901039719581604 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007636283989995718 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that circles around the central subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, dark dojo with a polished wooden floor reflecting golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing traditional black hakama and deep indigo keikogi with long dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a whirling sword dance with a highly polished katana creating a silver arc of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do hundreds of surrounding candle flames flicker wildly and cast long, frantic shadows on the walls and floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02329447865486145 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773294448852539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02329447865486145, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02329447865486145, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1730964183807373, + 0.09343411773443222, + 0.07831855118274689, + 0.04505624622106552, + 0.08538022637367249, + 0.17771601676940918, + 0.0951496958732605, + 0.07573342323303223, + 0.09618353098630905, + 0.07993180304765701 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02329447865486145 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that circles around the central subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, dark dojo with a polished wooden floor reflecting golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing traditional black hakama and deep indigo keikogi with long dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a whirling sword dance with a highly polished katana creating a silver arc of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do hundreds of surrounding candle flames flicker wildly and cast long, frantic shadows on the walls and floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046372017823159695 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379637241363525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046372017823159695, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046372017823159695, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2250070869922638, + 0.038675326853990555, + 0.056049369275569916, + 0.03374043107032776, + 0.049072425812482834, + 0.07404126971960068, + 0.3163969814777374, + 0.040988124907016754, + 0.12264297157526016, + 0.043386030942201614 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046372017823159695 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that circles around the central subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, dark dojo with a polished wooden floor reflecting golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing traditional black hakama and deep indigo keikogi with long dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a whirling sword dance with a highly polished katana creating a silver arc of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do hundreds of surrounding candle flames flicker wildly and cast long, frantic shadows on the walls and floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42889150977134705 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0538915395736694 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.42889150977134705, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.42889150977134705, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2000276744365692, + 0.07897826284170151, + 0.15284153819084167, + 0.029240699484944344, + 0.04866766929626465, + 0.04851672053337097, + 0.11442691087722778, + 0.12053196132183075, + 0.1138523742556572, + 0.09291621297597885 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.42889150977134705 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "low-angle, medium shot slowly circles around a lone warrior, capturing them at the center of a vast, dark dojo, its polished wooden floor reflecting a sea of golden light. Hundreds of candles line the floor, providing the scene's sole illumination. The warrior's face, a mask of serene concentration, partially concealed by a wisp of long, dark hair, is clad in traditional black hakama and deep indigo keikogi, heavy fabrics swirling around their powerful forms. They meticulously perform a whirling sword dance, their bodies the low, grounded fulcrums of controlled energy. In their hands, a highly polished katana transforms into a continuous silver arc, a ribbon of pure light that cuts through the thick, warm air. The air powerfully expelled from the fluid, relentlessly spinning, slicing blade causes the hundreds of surrounding candle flames to flicker wildly, bending and stretching in a chaotic ballet, casting long, frantic shadows that dance and wriggle across the walls and floor, creating a scene of profound atmosphere and intense meditation, a deadly grace.", + "seed": 17905, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_2/index_9817_seed_17905_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.11822360446676612, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11822360446676612, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11822360446676612, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that circles around the central subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, dark dojo with a polished wooden floor reflecting golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing traditional black hakama and deep indigo keikogi with long dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a whirling sword dance with a highly polished katana creating a silver arc of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do hundreds of surrounding candle flames flicker wildly and cast long, frantic shadows on the walls and floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033015649765729904 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.908015727996826 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033015649765729904, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033015649765729904, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27761295437812805, + 0.04254988580942154, + 0.17220434546470642, + 0.09400637447834015, + 0.059219688177108765, + 0.0730852261185646, + 0.09162478148937225, + 0.09504087269306183, + 0.03493941202759743, + 0.059716470539569855 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033015649765729904 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that circles around the central subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, dark dojo with a polished wooden floor reflecting golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing traditional black hakama and deep indigo keikogi with long dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a whirling sword dance with a highly polished katana creating a silver arc of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do hundreds of surrounding candle flames flicker wildly and cast long, frantic shadows on the walls and floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007639951538294554 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8826398849487305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007639951538294554, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007639951538294554, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.215882807970047, + 0.0745491310954094, + 0.24660025537014008, + 0.04305201768875122, + 0.07048570364713669, + 0.0749661922454834, + 0.04574844241142273, + 0.10192538797855377, + 0.06972209364175797, + 0.057067979127168655 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007639951538294554 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that circles around the central subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, dark dojo with a polished wooden floor reflecting golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing traditional black hakama and deep indigo keikogi with long dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a whirling sword dance with a highly polished katana creating a silver arc of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do hundreds of surrounding candle flames flicker wildly and cast long, frantic shadows on the walls and floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016075406223535538 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141075611114502 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016075406223535538, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016075406223535538, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1970161497592926, + 0.1146366074681282, + 0.1391807645559311, + 0.07666179537773132, + 0.15644492208957672, + 0.06141715124249458, + 0.022155551239848137, + 0.09888376295566559, + 0.06572189927101135, + 0.06788147985935211 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016075406223535538 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that circles around the central subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, dark dojo with a polished wooden floor reflecting golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing traditional black hakama and deep indigo keikogi with long dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a whirling sword dance with a highly polished katana creating a silver arc of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do hundreds of surrounding candle flames flicker wildly and cast long, frantic shadows on the walls and floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011074505746364594 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511074542999268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011074505746364594, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011074505746364594, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14081989228725433, + 0.08303476870059967, + 0.21124817430973053, + 0.07366906851530075, + 0.07421940565109253, + 0.1014178916811943, + 0.0687946006655693, + 0.07849539816379547, + 0.09592391550540924, + 0.07237686961889267 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011074505746364594 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a low-angle medium shot that circles around the central subject?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a vast, dark dojo with a polished wooden floor reflecting golden light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior wearing traditional black hakama and deep indigo keikogi with long dark hair?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the warrior performing a whirling sword dance with a highly polished katana creating a silver arc of light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do hundreds of surrounding candle flames flicker wildly and cast long, frantic shadows on the walls and floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.523312509059906 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.898312509059906 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.523312509059906, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.523312509059906, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14802764356136322, + 0.07693618535995483, + 0.16072945296764374, + 0.10007607191801071, + 0.06867456436157227, + 0.12272552400827408, + 0.057787422090768814, + 0.0648176521062851, + 0.15722006559371948, + 0.04300539195537567 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.523312509059906 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_3/index_tensor([1831, 1831])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_3/index_tensor([1831, 1831])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d934f1dfca482c1bbb79be02be339e6e09c140d5 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_3/index_tensor([1831, 1831])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatic, overhead Dutch-angle shot captures a sharpshooter, composed entirely of rough, sharply defined pixels, poised atop the gray stone battlements of a vintage castle. Clad in a hooded coat composed of dark green and brown pixels, his pixelated face, composed of only a few blocks of color, conveys intense focus. His body tenses, legs spread apart to stabilize his center of gravity, his arms straining to draw a longbow, also constructed from pixels, to full length. The bow, bent to its limit, a slender string composed of a single row of pixels is steadily drawn to his face, its arrow gleaming with a bright white pixelated glow, poised for release. Against the backdrop of a classic castle tower, also rendered in an 8-bit style, and a gloomy, blocky sky, the tilted composition and the fully drawn bowstring create an atmosphere of dynamic tension and tantalizing urgency, reminiscent of a frozen moment before the decisive blow in a classic video game.", + "seed": 2087, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_3/index_1831_seed_2087_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05799912419170141, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05799912419170141, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05799912419170141, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sharpshooter wearing a hooded coat of dark green and brown pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter positioned atop gray stone battlements of a vintage castle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter drawing a longbow to full length with an arrow that has a bright white pixelated glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a rough, sharply defined 8-bit pixelated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an overhead Dutch-angle shot with a tilted composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.030595358461141586 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.530595302581787 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.030595358461141586, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.030595358461141586, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11056143045425415, + 0.05993787199258804, + 0.046428974717855453, + 0.028192132711410522, + 0.07550501823425293, + 0.057902924716472626, + 0.06352679431438446, + 0.12124315649271011, + 0.1613837331533432, + 0.275317907333374 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.030595358461141586 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sharpshooter wearing a hooded coat of dark green and brown pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter positioned atop gray stone battlements of a vintage castle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter drawing a longbow to full length with an arrow that has a bright white pixelated glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a rough, sharply defined 8-bit pixelated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an overhead Dutch-angle shot with a tilted composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004641473293304443 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379641532897949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004641473293304443, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004641473293304443, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12671133875846863, + 0.07143335789442062, + 0.04732250049710274, + 0.02781275473535061, + 0.02541903778910637, + 0.01639593206346035, + 0.07724310457706451, + 0.34430840611457825, + 0.07053139805793762, + 0.1928221583366394 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004641473293304443 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sharpshooter wearing a hooded coat of dark green and brown pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter positioned atop gray stone battlements of a vintage castle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter drawing a longbow to full length with an arrow that has a bright white pixelated glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a rough, sharply defined 8-bit pixelated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an overhead Dutch-angle shot with a tilted composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020581139251589775 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955812454223633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020581139251589775, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020581139251589775, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17280755937099457, + 0.0839494839310646, + 0.05066942796111107, + 0.04718359559774399, + 0.029472138732671738, + 0.07042639702558517, + 0.05809961259365082, + 0.13851554691791534, + 0.1827138215303421, + 0.1661624163389206 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020581139251589775 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sharpshooter wearing a hooded coat of dark green and brown pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter positioned atop gray stone battlements of a vintage castle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter drawing a longbow to full length with an arrow that has a bright white pixelated glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a rough, sharply defined 8-bit pixelated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an overhead Dutch-angle shot with a tilted composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008632958866655827 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758633136749268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008632958866655827, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008632958866655827, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.054508790373802185, + 0.08495410531759262, + 0.03340724855661392, + 0.027984201908111572, + 0.02598317340016365, + 0.018616896122694016, + 0.04732027277350426, + 0.19596318900585175, + 0.4552459418773651, + 0.056016162037849426 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008632958866655827 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sharpshooter wearing a hooded coat of dark green and brown pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter positioned atop gray stone battlements of a vintage castle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter drawing a longbow to full length with an arrow that has a bright white pixelated glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a rough, sharply defined 8-bit pixelated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an overhead Dutch-angle shot with a tilted composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22554469108581543 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005446910858154 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22554469108581543, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22554469108581543, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12073071300983429, + 0.1161293312907219, + 0.17678344249725342, + 0.05070957913994789, + 0.05653565376996994, + 0.04155886545777321, + 0.06349273771047592, + 0.09284106642007828, + 0.15100282430648804, + 0.13021579384803772 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22554469108581543 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic, overhead Dutch-angle shot captures a sharpshooter, composed entirely of rough, sharply defined pixels, poised atop the gray stone battlements of a vintage castle. Clad in a hooded coat composed of dark green and brown pixels, his pixelated face, composed of only a few blocks of color, conveys intense focus. His body tenses, legs spread apart to stabilize his center of gravity, his arms straining to draw a longbow, also constructed from pixels, to full length. The bow, bent to its limit, a slender string composed of a single row of pixels is steadily drawn to his face, its arrow gleaming with a bright white pixelated glow, poised for release. Against the backdrop of a classic castle tower, also rendered in an 8-bit style, and a gloomy, blocky sky, the tilted composition and the fully drawn bowstring create an atmosphere of dynamic tension and tantalizing urgency, reminiscent of a frozen moment before the decisive blow in a classic video game.", + "seed": 2088, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_3/index_1831_seed_2088_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06480114171281456, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06480114171281456, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.975, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06480114171281456, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sharpshooter wearing a hooded coat of dark green and brown pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter positioned atop gray stone battlements of a vintage castle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter drawing a longbow to full length with an arrow that has a bright white pixelated glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a rough, sharply defined 8-bit pixelated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an overhead Dutch-angle shot with a tilted composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01880987361073494 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018809795379639 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01880987361073494, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01880987361073494, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06345760077238083, + 0.2590021789073944, + 0.15729105472564697, + 0.09817464649677277, + 0.11373630911111832, + 0.07415860891342163, + 0.03442787379026413, + 0.11402437835931778, + 0.0638870820403099, + 0.0218402910977602 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01880987361073494 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sharpshooter wearing a hooded coat of dark green and brown pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter positioned atop gray stone battlements of a vintage castle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter drawing a longbow to full length with an arrow that has a bright white pixelated glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a rough, sharply defined 8-bit pixelated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an overhead Dutch-angle shot with a tilted composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006739622913300991 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006739616394043 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006739622913300991, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006739622913300991, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11689570546150208, + 0.18773379921913147, + 0.16964702308177948, + 0.10240127146244049, + 0.09693758934736252, + 0.03972424939274788, + 0.058821044862270355, + 0.1345740556716919, + 0.0689096748828888, + 0.024355590343475342 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006739622913300991 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sharpshooter wearing a hooded coat of dark green and brown pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter positioned atop gray stone battlements of a vintage castle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter drawing a longbow to full length with an arrow that has a bright white pixelated glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a rough, sharply defined 8-bit pixelated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an overhead Dutch-angle shot with a tilted composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012535824440419674 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38753604888916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012535824440419674, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012535824440419674, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05253157392144203, + 0.0964120402932167, + 0.08207055926322937, + 0.045846980065107346, + 0.12495487928390503, + 0.44566774368286133, + 0.03886457905173302, + 0.07175661623477936, + 0.0235461238771677, + 0.01834888942539692 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012535824440419674 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sharpshooter wearing a hooded coat of dark green and brown pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter positioned atop gray stone battlements of a vintage castle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter drawing a longbow to full length with an arrow that has a bright white pixelated glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a rough, sharply defined 8-bit pixelated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an overhead Dutch-angle shot with a tilted composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004633760545402765 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379633903503418 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004633760545402765, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004633760545402765, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1482556164264679, + 0.15424147248268127, + 0.18115584552288055, + 0.1701568067073822, + 0.049527741968631744, + 0.0504184290766716, + 0.046930402517318726, + 0.10426938533782959, + 0.05402395874261856, + 0.04102030768990517 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004633760545402765 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sharpshooter wearing a hooded coat of dark green and brown pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter positioned atop gray stone battlements of a vintage castle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter drawing a longbow to full length with an arrow that has a bright white pixelated glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a rough, sharply defined 8-bit pixelated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an overhead Dutch-angle shot with a tilted composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2812866270542145 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.406286597251892 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2812866270542145, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2812866270542145, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21064351499080658, + 0.21885442733764648, + 0.15024584531784058, + 0.0676213949918747, + 0.1096804067492485, + 0.06776553392410278, + 0.051366083323955536, + 0.048864662647247314, + 0.03845591843128204, + 0.036502283066511154 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2812866270542145 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic, overhead Dutch-angle shot captures a sharpshooter, composed entirely of rough, sharply defined pixels, poised atop the gray stone battlements of a vintage castle. Clad in a hooded coat composed of dark green and brown pixels, his pixelated face, composed of only a few blocks of color, conveys intense focus. His body tenses, legs spread apart to stabilize his center of gravity, his arms straining to draw a longbow, also constructed from pixels, to full length. The bow, bent to its limit, a slender string composed of a single row of pixels is steadily drawn to his face, its arrow gleaming with a bright white pixelated glow, poised for release. Against the backdrop of a classic castle tower, also rendered in an 8-bit style, and a gloomy, blocky sky, the tilted composition and the fully drawn bowstring create an atmosphere of dynamic tension and tantalizing urgency, reminiscent of a frozen moment before the decisive blow in a classic video game.", + "seed": 2089, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_3/index_1831_seed_2089_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.22841693945229052, + "vlm_logprob": -0.22841693945229052, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.22841693945229052, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sharpshooter wearing a hooded coat of dark green and brown pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter positioned atop gray stone battlements of a vintage castle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter drawing a longbow to full length with an arrow that has a bright white pixelated glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a rough, sharply defined 8-bit pixelated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an overhead Dutch-angle shot with a tilted composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20347604155540466 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.703476071357727 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20347604155540466, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20347604155540466, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2084084451198578, + 0.07961048185825348, + 0.051600728183984756, + 0.041295092552900314, + 0.037468064576387405, + 0.03268922120332718, + 0.043640319257974625, + 0.14314809441566467, + 0.25779616832733154, + 0.10434336960315704 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20347604155540466 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sharpshooter wearing a hooded coat of dark green and brown pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter positioned atop gray stone battlements of a vintage castle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter drawing a longbow to full length with an arrow that has a bright white pixelated glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a rough, sharply defined 8-bit pixelated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an overhead Dutch-angle shot with a tilted composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026358501985669136 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513586044311523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026358501985669136, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026358501985669136, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06439129263162613, + 0.017875470221042633, + 0.031032659113407135, + 0.021064147353172302, + 0.01870042271912098, + 0.01887299120426178, + 0.02281026728451252, + 0.6386549472808838, + 0.05994415283203125, + 0.10665357857942581 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026358501985669136 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sharpshooter wearing a hooded coat of dark green and brown pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter positioned atop gray stone battlements of a vintage castle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter drawing a longbow to full length with an arrow that has a bright white pixelated glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a rough, sharply defined 8-bit pixelated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an overhead Dutch-angle shot with a tilted composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0430685393512249 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680686473846436 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0430685393512249, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0430685393512249, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1356971710920334, + 0.08437646925449371, + 0.1346486210823059, + 0.3257830739021301, + 0.08962136507034302, + 0.036575667560100555, + 0.03596494719386101, + 0.07918986678123474, + 0.03958563134074211, + 0.038557179272174835 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0430685393512249 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sharpshooter wearing a hooded coat of dark green and brown pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter positioned atop gray stone battlements of a vintage castle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter drawing a longbow to full length with an arrow that has a bright white pixelated glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a rough, sharply defined 8-bit pixelated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an overhead Dutch-angle shot with a tilted composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04305563494563103 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168055534362793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04305563494563103, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04305563494563103, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08484348654747009, + 0.11890770494937897, + 0.3934336006641388, + 0.06832756102085114, + 0.04741042107343674, + 0.028961151838302612, + 0.04477931559085846, + 0.1327032446861267, + 0.047466933727264404, + 0.033166609704494476 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04305563494563103 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sharpshooter wearing a hooded coat of dark green and brown pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter positioned atop gray stone battlements of a vintage castle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter drawing a longbow to full length with an arrow that has a bright white pixelated glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a rough, sharply defined 8-bit pixelated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an overhead Dutch-angle shot with a tilted composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.826125979423523 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.576125979423523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.826125979423523, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.826125979423523, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2327108085155487, + 0.045147985219955444, + 0.20820151269435883, + 0.11112727969884872, + 0.045489560812711716, + 0.06395628303289413, + 0.07672901451587677, + 0.0870308056473732, + 0.06585977971553802, + 0.06374698877334595 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.826125979423523 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic, overhead Dutch-angle shot captures a sharpshooter, composed entirely of rough, sharply defined pixels, poised atop the gray stone battlements of a vintage castle. Clad in a hooded coat composed of dark green and brown pixels, his pixelated face, composed of only a few blocks of color, conveys intense focus. His body tenses, legs spread apart to stabilize his center of gravity, his arms straining to draw a longbow, also constructed from pixels, to full length. The bow, bent to its limit, a slender string composed of a single row of pixels is steadily drawn to his face, its arrow gleaming with a bright white pixelated glow, poised for release. Against the backdrop of a classic castle tower, also rendered in an 8-bit style, and a gloomy, blocky sky, the tilted composition and the fully drawn bowstring create an atmosphere of dynamic tension and tantalizing urgency, reminiscent of a frozen moment before the decisive blow in a classic video game.", + "seed": 2090, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_3/index_1831_seed_2090_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.13197490125894545, + "vlm_logprob": -0.13197490125894545, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3999999523162843, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.13197490125894545, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sharpshooter wearing a hooded coat of dark green and brown pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter positioned atop gray stone battlements of a vintage castle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter drawing a longbow to full length with an arrow that has a bright white pixelated glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a rough, sharply defined 8-bit pixelated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an overhead Dutch-angle shot with a tilted composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0437600277364254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168760061264038 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0437600277364254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0437600277364254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24141478538513184, + 0.09560156613588333, + 0.07333993166685104, + 0.039759013801813126, + 0.05175073444843292, + 0.047323375940322876, + 0.044604528695344925, + 0.06590870767831802, + 0.06968120485544205, + 0.27061617374420166 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0437600277364254 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sharpshooter wearing a hooded coat of dark green and brown pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter positioned atop gray stone battlements of a vintage castle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter drawing a longbow to full length with an arrow that has a bright white pixelated glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a rough, sharply defined 8-bit pixelated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an overhead Dutch-angle shot with a tilted composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018192922696471214 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018192768096924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018192922696471214, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018192922696471214, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3588525056838989, + 0.11343806236982346, + 0.16585727035999298, + 0.05231795459985733, + 0.07742145657539368, + 0.035116396844387054, + 0.013996260240674019, + 0.0540081188082695, + 0.05153218284249306, + 0.07745981961488724 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018192922696471214 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sharpshooter wearing a hooded coat of dark green and brown pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter positioned atop gray stone battlements of a vintage castle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter drawing a longbow to full length with an arrow that has a bright white pixelated glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a rough, sharply defined 8-bit pixelated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an overhead Dutch-angle shot with a tilted composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018189411610364914 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018189430236816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018189411610364914, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018189411610364914, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05156547948718071, + 0.6908738017082214, + 0.06030617281794548, + 0.029109271243214607, + 0.01236026082187891, + 0.00953400693833828, + 0.019168635830283165, + 0.022320173680782318, + 0.07897816598415375, + 0.025784077122807503 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018189411610364914 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sharpshooter wearing a hooded coat of dark green and brown pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter positioned atop gray stone battlements of a vintage castle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter drawing a longbow to full length with an arrow that has a bright white pixelated glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a rough, sharply defined 8-bit pixelated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an overhead Dutch-angle shot with a tilted composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036123041063547134 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628612518310547 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036123041063547134, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036123041063547134, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15914644300937653, + 0.3169812858104706, + 0.19324146211147308, + 0.05508716031908989, + 0.053164247423410416, + 0.037570253014564514, + 0.02358342707157135, + 0.06257031112909317, + 0.030524739995598793, + 0.06813061237335205 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036123041063547134 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a sharpshooter wearing a hooded coat of dark green and brown pixels?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter positioned atop gray stone battlements of a vintage castle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the sharpshooter drawing a longbow to full length with an arrow that has a bright white pixelated glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the entire scene rendered in a rough, sharply defined 8-bit pixelated style?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot an overhead Dutch-angle shot with a tilted composition?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761198401451111 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261198401451111 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761198401451111, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761198401451111, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17092488706111908, + 0.18247710168361664, + 0.18365833163261414, + 0.08898921310901642, + 0.04370444640517235, + 0.07258156687021255, + 0.025505999103188515, + 0.021038344129920006, + 0.08748473972082138, + 0.12363535165786743 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761198401451111 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_4/index_tensor([2455, 2455])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_4/index_tensor([2455, 2455])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f927efe8a9433e9b7f2aaec91f9ddfe20e77c0f2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_4/index_tensor([2455, 2455])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up macro shot, the camera held still, focused at eye level on a portion of the surface of a vibrant green cucumber, creates a rich, rich, oil-painted feel. The cucumber's deep green skin is covered in subtle, uneven textures and tiny bumps, as if composed of layers of thick, applied paint. Illuminated by a single, soft, and clearly directed light source from the side of the painting, these raised grains reflect oily highlights, while the recesses are immersed in a rich blend of ochre and dark brown. A shimmering, voluptuous drop of water clings to its curved surface, like a perfect glass bead, its interior clearly reflecting the cucumber's twisted green veins. Pulled by gravity, the drop begins its incredibly slow, steady, and deliberate downward slide, leaving behind a fleeting, wet, shimmering trail. Its movement causes the light to shift across its rolling sphere, creating highlights as bright as pure white paint scraped with a palette knife. The dark, almost integrated blurred background further highlights the vivid texture and color of the subject. The whole scene exudes a focused and primitive vitality in extreme tranquility, and the interweaving of light and shadow is full of the artistic beauty of classical still life paintings.", + "seed": 12851, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_4/index_2455_seed_12851_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1017061123624444, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1017061123624444, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1017061123624444, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view focused on the surface of a vibrant green cucumber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still at eye level with a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cucumber's skin textured with tiny bumps and raised grains reflecting oily highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a single, soft, clearly directed light source illuminating the scene from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop slide slowly and deliberately downward, leaving a wet shimmering trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004910196177661419 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.754909992218018 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004910196177661419, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004910196177661419, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2003404200077057, + 0.16864964365959167, + 0.05880488455295563, + 0.05361419916152954, + 0.15345895290374756, + 0.15963906049728394, + 0.052872009575366974, + 0.05771969258785248, + 0.05565110966563225, + 0.039250005036592484 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004910196177661419 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view focused on the surface of a vibrant green cucumber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still at eye level with a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cucumber's skin textured with tiny bumps and raised grains reflecting oily highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a single, soft, clearly directed light source illuminating the scene from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop slide slowly and deliberately downward, leaving a wet shimmering trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1604439616203308 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104440212249756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1604439616203308, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1604439616203308, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.46678870916366577, + 0.130247563123703, + 0.025344915688037872, + 0.07454641163349152, + 0.05730050429701805, + 0.0715908333659172, + 0.05192426219582558, + 0.031634699553251266, + 0.06104234233498573, + 0.029579779133200645 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1604439616203308 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view focused on the surface of a vibrant green cucumber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still at eye level with a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cucumber's skin textured with tiny bumps and raised grains reflecting oily highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a single, soft, clearly directed light source illuminating the scene from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop slide slowly and deliberately downward, leaving a wet shimmering trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046426597982645035 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379642486572266 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046426597982645035, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046426597982645035, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2419164776802063, + 0.15261024236679077, + 0.05539897829294205, + 0.047715503722429276, + 0.2020334154367447, + 0.1644352227449417, + 0.01618015021085739, + 0.05315418541431427, + 0.034980859607458115, + 0.03157499060034752 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046426597982645035 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view focused on the surface of a vibrant green cucumber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still at eye level with a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cucumber's skin textured with tiny bumps and raised grains reflecting oily highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a single, soft, clearly directed light source illuminating the scene from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop slide slowly and deliberately downward, leaving a wet shimmering trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22558702528476715 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.600587010383606 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22558702528476715, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22558702528476715, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27411842346191406, + 0.17490574717521667, + 0.09991694241762161, + 0.06243221461772919, + 0.09151002019643784, + 0.08038116246461868, + 0.03978307917714119, + 0.07692226767539978, + 0.03601517155766487, + 0.06401490420103073 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22558702528476715 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view focused on the surface of a vibrant green cucumber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still at eye level with a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cucumber's skin textured with tiny bumps and raised grains reflecting oily highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a single, soft, clearly directed light source illuminating the scene from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop slide slowly and deliberately downward, leaving a wet shimmering trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11294671893119812 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379467487335205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11294671893119812, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11294671893119812, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18486084043979645, + 0.06473103910684586, + 0.07140466570854187, + 0.052609920501708984, + 0.17077288031578064, + 0.23990800976753235, + 0.02896774746477604, + 0.04676210880279541, + 0.09389393776655197, + 0.046088844537734985 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11294671893119812 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up macro shot, the camera held still, focused at eye level on a portion of the surface of a vibrant green cucumber, creates a rich, rich, oil-painted feel. The cucumber's deep green skin is covered in subtle, uneven textures and tiny bumps, as if composed of layers of thick, applied paint. Illuminated by a single, soft, and clearly directed light source from the side of the painting, these raised grains reflect oily highlights, while the recesses are immersed in a rich blend of ochre and dark brown. A shimmering, voluptuous drop of water clings to its curved surface, like a perfect glass bead, its interior clearly reflecting the cucumber's twisted green veins. Pulled by gravity, the drop begins its incredibly slow, steady, and deliberate downward slide, leaving behind a fleeting, wet, shimmering trail. Its movement causes the light to shift across its rolling sphere, creating highlights as bright as pure white paint scraped with a palette knife. The dark, almost integrated blurred background further highlights the vivid texture and color of the subject. The whole scene exudes a focused and primitive vitality in extreme tranquility, and the interweaving of light and shadow is full of the artistic beauty of classical still life paintings.", + "seed": 12852, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_4/index_2455_seed_12852_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06000296901911497, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06000296901911497, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06000296901911497, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view focused on the surface of a vibrant green cucumber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still at eye level with a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cucumber's skin textured with tiny bumps and raised grains reflecting oily highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a single, soft, clearly directed light source illuminating the scene from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop slide slowly and deliberately downward, leaving a wet shimmering trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011835826560854912 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.761836051940918 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011835826560854912, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011835826560854912, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07739056646823883, + 0.11885791271924973, + 0.06018238514661789, + 0.19544006884098053, + 0.12377268075942993, + 0.056478679180145264, + 0.10651296377182007, + 0.06723826378583908, + 0.1580495685338974, + 0.03607689216732979 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011835826560854912 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view focused on the surface of a vibrant green cucumber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still at eye level with a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cucumber's skin textured with tiny bumps and raised grains reflecting oily highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a single, soft, clearly directed light source illuminating the scene from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop slide slowly and deliberately downward, leaving a wet shimmering trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07903240621089935 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790324211120605 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07903240621089935, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07903240621089935, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15347178280353546, + 0.09896954149007797, + 0.06672264635562897, + 0.23965153098106384, + 0.21635407209396362, + 0.10146191716194153, + 0.04191690310835838, + 0.025632621720433235, + 0.037548765540122986, + 0.018270231783390045 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07903240621089935 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view focused on the surface of a vibrant green cucumber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still at eye level with a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cucumber's skin textured with tiny bumps and raised grains reflecting oily highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a single, soft, clearly directed light source illuminating the scene from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop slide slowly and deliberately downward, leaving a wet shimmering trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008645367808640003 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758645534515381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008645367808640003, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008645367808640003, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3054295480251312, + 0.026005379855632782, + 0.05798277258872986, + 0.15394733846187592, + 0.11524895578622818, + 0.08469726890325546, + 0.08554423600435257, + 0.08201458305120468, + 0.05087605118751526, + 0.03825381025671959 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008645367808640003 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view focused on the surface of a vibrant green cucumber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still at eye level with a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cucumber's skin textured with tiny bumps and raised grains reflecting oily highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a single, soft, clearly directed light source illuminating the scene from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop slide slowly and deliberately downward, leaving a wet shimmering trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020588379353284836 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955883979797363 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020588379353284836, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020588379353284836, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14885036647319794, + 0.1244264766573906, + 0.0905068889260292, + 0.1555228978395462, + 0.10320302844047546, + 0.09260717779397964, + 0.07967464625835419, + 0.12459157407283783, + 0.03939690440893173, + 0.0412200428545475 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020588379353284836 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view focused on the surface of a vibrant green cucumber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still at eye level with a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cucumber's skin textured with tiny bumps and raised grains reflecting oily highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a single, soft, clearly directed light source illuminating the scene from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop slide slowly and deliberately downward, leaving a wet shimmering trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17991286516189575 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804912805557251 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17991286516189575, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17991286516189575, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2749680280685425, + 0.03179573640227318, + 0.05526895821094513, + 0.26090964674949646, + 0.15994758903980255, + 0.06159818917512894, + 0.05959063023328781, + 0.04695960879325867, + 0.03069235011935234, + 0.018269319087266922 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17991286516189575 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up macro shot, the camera held still, focused at eye level on a portion of the surface of a vibrant green cucumber, creates a rich, rich, oil-painted feel. The cucumber's deep green skin is covered in subtle, uneven textures and tiny bumps, as if composed of layers of thick, applied paint. Illuminated by a single, soft, and clearly directed light source from the side of the painting, these raised grains reflect oily highlights, while the recesses are immersed in a rich blend of ochre and dark brown. A shimmering, voluptuous drop of water clings to its curved surface, like a perfect glass bead, its interior clearly reflecting the cucumber's twisted green veins. Pulled by gravity, the drop begins its incredibly slow, steady, and deliberate downward slide, leaving behind a fleeting, wet, shimmering trail. Its movement causes the light to shift across its rolling sphere, creating highlights as bright as pure white paint scraped with a palette knife. The dark, almost integrated blurred background further highlights the vivid texture and color of the subject. The whole scene exudes a focused and primitive vitality in extreme tranquility, and the interweaving of light and shadow is full of the artistic beauty of classical still life paintings.", + "seed": 12853, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_4/index_2455_seed_12853_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1267469679005444, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1267469679005444, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.55, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1267469679005444, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view focused on the surface of a vibrant green cucumber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still at eye level with a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cucumber's skin textured with tiny bumps and raised grains reflecting oily highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a single, soft, clearly directed light source illuminating the scene from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop slide slowly and deliberately downward, leaving a wet shimmering trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031226943247020245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.128122806549072 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031226943247020245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031226943247020245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14995098114013672, + 0.11631766706705093, + 0.055141255259513855, + 0.061721257865428925, + 0.04431574046611786, + 0.05545252561569214, + 0.0781586542725563, + 0.02150144800543785, + 0.06883049011230469, + 0.34860995411872864 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031226943247020245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view focused on the surface of a vibrant green cucumber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still at eye level with a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cucumber's skin textured with tiny bumps and raised grains reflecting oily highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a single, soft, clearly directed light source illuminating the scene from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop slide slowly and deliberately downward, leaving a wet shimmering trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233984589576721 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983984589576721 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5233984589576721, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5233984589576721, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07997551560401917, + 0.04440426826477051, + 0.0704028308391571, + 0.24425099790096283, + 0.08022607117891312, + 0.2163182944059372, + 0.030728038400411606, + 0.027256065979599953, + 0.04340299591422081, + 0.16303500533103943 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5233984589576721 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view focused on the surface of a vibrant green cucumber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still at eye level with a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cucumber's skin textured with tiny bumps and raised grains reflecting oily highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a single, soft, clearly directed light source illuminating the scene from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop slide slowly and deliberately downward, leaving a wet shimmering trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00763415452092886 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882634162902832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00763415452092886, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00763415452092886, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11914373189210892, + 0.05909178406000137, + 0.06743862479925156, + 0.1322270929813385, + 0.05160858854651451, + 0.046545762568712234, + 0.0361064076423645, + 0.050084732472896576, + 0.06184704229235649, + 0.3759061396121979 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00763415452092886 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view focused on the surface of a vibrant green cucumber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still at eye level with a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cucumber's skin textured with tiny bumps and raised grains reflecting oily highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a single, soft, clearly directed light source illuminating the scene from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop slide slowly and deliberately downward, leaving a wet shimmering trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059129998087883 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955912590026855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059129998087883, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059129998087883, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08826029300689697, + 0.09135204553604126, + 0.04737390950322151, + 0.05356433987617493, + 0.1399047076702118, + 0.17480796575546265, + 0.04113844409584999, + 0.052356064319610596, + 0.12978395819664001, + 0.1814582645893097 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059129998087883 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view focused on the surface of a vibrant green cucumber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still at eye level with a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cucumber's skin textured with tiny bumps and raised grains reflecting oily highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a single, soft, clearly directed light source illuminating the scene from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop slide slowly and deliberately downward, leaving a wet shimmering trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07898823171854019 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789883136749268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07898823171854019, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07898823171854019, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07480878382921219, + 0.048946578055620193, + 0.03474536910653114, + 0.14081062376499176, + 0.038642723113298416, + 0.1150568351149559, + 0.04138553515076637, + 0.040830980986356735, + 0.09075218439102173, + 0.37402039766311646 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07898823171854019 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up macro shot, the camera held still, focused at eye level on a portion of the surface of a vibrant green cucumber, creates a rich, rich, oil-painted feel. The cucumber's deep green skin is covered in subtle, uneven textures and tiny bumps, as if composed of layers of thick, applied paint. Illuminated by a single, soft, and clearly directed light source from the side of the painting, these raised grains reflect oily highlights, while the recesses are immersed in a rich blend of ochre and dark brown. A shimmering, voluptuous drop of water clings to its curved surface, like a perfect glass bead, its interior clearly reflecting the cucumber's twisted green veins. Pulled by gravity, the drop begins its incredibly slow, steady, and deliberate downward slide, leaving behind a fleeting, wet, shimmering trail. Its movement causes the light to shift across its rolling sphere, creating highlights as bright as pure white paint scraped with a palette knife. The dark, almost integrated blurred background further highlights the vivid texture and color of the subject. The whole scene exudes a focused and primitive vitality in extreme tranquility, and the interweaving of light and shadow is full of the artistic beauty of classical still life paintings.", + "seed": 12854, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_4/index_2455_seed_12854_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04585963326971978, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04585963326971978, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04585963326971978, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view focused on the surface of a vibrant green cucumber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still at eye level with a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cucumber's skin textured with tiny bumps and raised grains reflecting oily highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a single, soft, clearly directed light source illuminating the scene from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop slide slowly and deliberately downward, leaving a wet shimmering trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002851232187822461 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.6278510093688965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002851232187822461, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002851232187822461, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11967277526855469, + 0.09673218429088593, + 0.035359449684619904, + 0.029926715418696404, + 0.06542486697435379, + 0.0974268689751625, + 0.23155491054058075, + 0.09372422844171524, + 0.07737745344638824, + 0.1528005599975586 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002851232187822461 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view focused on the surface of a vibrant green cucumber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still at eye level with a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cucumber's skin textured with tiny bumps and raised grains reflecting oily highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a single, soft, clearly directed light source illuminating the scene from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop slide slowly and deliberately downward, leaving a wet shimmering trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10039021819829941 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503901958465576 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10039021819829941, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10039021819829941, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16484709084033966, + 0.06187700480222702, + 0.053947098553180695, + 0.029510879889130592, + 0.22589094936847687, + 0.14285412430763245, + 0.08675844967365265, + 0.10410745441913605, + 0.04491657018661499, + 0.08529046177864075 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10039021819829941 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view focused on the surface of a vibrant green cucumber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still at eye level with a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cucumber's skin textured with tiny bumps and raised grains reflecting oily highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a single, soft, clearly directed light source illuminating the scene from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop slide slowly and deliberately downward, leaving a wet shimmering trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001944795367307961 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.2519450187683105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001944795367307961, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001944795367307961, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10534731298685074, + 0.1256643384695053, + 0.04687986522912979, + 0.04635816067457199, + 0.047907691448926926, + 0.08231581002473831, + 0.37518566846847534, + 0.040296562016010284, + 0.0607641264796257, + 0.0692804753780365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001944795367307961 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view focused on the surface of a vibrant green cucumber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still at eye level with a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cucumber's skin textured with tiny bumps and raised grains reflecting oily highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a single, soft, clearly directed light source illuminating the scene from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop slide slowly and deliberately downward, leaving a wet shimmering trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620587058365345 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812058687210083 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620587058365345, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620587058365345, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1581258773803711, + 0.09502872079610825, + 0.03498039022088051, + 0.012689424678683281, + 0.11902457475662231, + 0.04556223005056381, + 0.24674081802368164, + 0.11166106164455414, + 0.079521045088768, + 0.0966658815741539 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620587058365345 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up macro view focused on the surface of a vibrant green cucumber?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still at eye level with a dark, blurred background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the cucumber's skin textured with tiny bumps and raised grains reflecting oily highlights?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is a single, soft, clearly directed light source illuminating the scene from the side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does a water drop slide slowly and deliberately downward, leaving a wet shimmering trail?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06205321475863457 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120532035827637 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06205321475863457, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06205321475863457, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07023250311613083, + 0.03803391382098198, + 0.02919733338057995, + 0.027477987110614777, + 0.1374443620443344, + 0.060095347464084625, + 0.5611834526062012, + 0.028513047844171524, + 0.018312184140086174, + 0.029509790241718292 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06205321475863457 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_5/index_tensor([7208, 7208])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_5/index_tensor([7208, 7208])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..494a5c6fe078786803466e244e87cd9037c56296 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_5/index_tensor([7208, 7208])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up shot from a slightly low angle tracks a bullet casing as it ricochets upward in mesmerizing, extreme slow motion. The polished brass casing, a brilliant golden yellow, gleams in the ambient light, its smooth cylindrical surface capturing and reflecting a kaleidoscope of colors while tumbling slowly and deliberately end-to-end through the air. A delicate, ethereal plume of gray smoke gracefully snakes out from a dark, circular opening, wisps curling and unfurling against the backdrop. The background itself dissolves into a beautiful, bokeh-filled tapestry of defocused city lights—vibrant orbs of neon pink, electric blue, and warm molybdenum orange—creating a striking artistic contrast to the sharp focus of the foreground subject. The interplay of these distant lights creates dazzling specular highlights that dance across the casing's swirling form while backlit against the translucent smoke, imbuing the entire scene with a dramatic, almost balletic atmosphere, suspending the moment of the violent act as a tranquil and hypnotic visual spectacle.", + "seed": 18630, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_5/index_7208_seed_18630_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.035423243045806886, + "vlm_logprob": -0.035423243045806886, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.035423243045806886, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a bullet casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the casing moving in extreme slow motion while ricocheting upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the casing polished brass with a brilliant golden yellow color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate plume of gray smoke snaking out from a dark circular opening on the casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a defocused city with vibrant orbs of neon pink, electric blue, and warm orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06276014447212219 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8127601146698 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06276014447212219, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06276014447212219, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21676717698574066, + 0.009501666761934757, + 0.0214126855134964, + 0.02141508460044861, + 0.2604656517505646, + 0.023490428924560547, + 0.15265104174613953, + 0.16244001686573029, + 0.033382657915353775, + 0.09847364574670792 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06276014447212219 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a bullet casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the casing moving in extreme slow motion while ricocheting upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the casing polished brass with a brilliant golden yellow color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate plume of gray smoke snaking out from a dark circular opening on the casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a defocused city with vibrant orbs of neon pink, electric blue, and warm orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059328556060791 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955931663513184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059328556060791, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059328556060791, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.029104316607117653, + 0.010608768090605736, + 0.02979464828968048, + 0.027022037655115128, + 0.400419145822525, + 0.007342265918850899, + 0.0739903450012207, + 0.2432788610458374, + 0.08832230418920517, + 0.09011732041835785 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059328556060791 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a bullet casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the casing moving in extreme slow motion while ricocheting upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the casing polished brass with a brilliant golden yellow color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate plume of gray smoke snaking out from a dark circular opening on the casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a defocused city with vibrant orbs of neon pink, electric blue, and warm orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033713314682245255 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087133407592773 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033713314682245255, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033713314682245255, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2676548659801483, + 0.042776256799697876, + 0.037457745522260666, + 0.039753805845975876, + 0.11937020719051361, + 0.013542355969548225, + 0.04388497769832611, + 0.18210472166538239, + 0.04046874865889549, + 0.21298639476299286 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033713314682245255 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a bullet casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the casing moving in extreme slow motion while ricocheting upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the casing polished brass with a brilliant golden yellow color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate plume of gray smoke snaking out from a dark circular opening on the casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a defocused city with vibrant orbs of neon pink, electric blue, and warm orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033704668283462524 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087047576904297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033704668283462524, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033704668283462524, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2006247639656067, + 0.00971588958054781, + 0.015526857227087021, + 0.09873346239328384, + 0.11513065546751022, + 0.012258181348443031, + 0.05316973105072975, + 0.21770836412906647, + 0.06645156443119049, + 0.21068045496940613 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033704668283462524 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a bullet casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the casing moving in extreme slow motion while ricocheting upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the casing polished brass with a brilliant golden yellow color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate plume of gray smoke snaking out from a dark circular opening on the casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a defocused city with vibrant orbs of neon pink, electric blue, and warm orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026344802230596542 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513447761535645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026344802230596542, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026344802230596542, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3161391615867615, + 0.01206763181835413, + 0.05782907083630562, + 0.017786549404263496, + 0.13738733530044556, + 0.02969106286764145, + 0.26444581151008606, + 0.06339230388402939, + 0.033963777124881744, + 0.06729736924171448 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026344802230596542 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up shot from a slightly low angle tracks a bullet casing as it ricochets upward in mesmerizing, extreme slow motion. The polished brass casing, a brilliant golden yellow, gleams in the ambient light, its smooth cylindrical surface capturing and reflecting a kaleidoscope of colors while tumbling slowly and deliberately end-to-end through the air. A delicate, ethereal plume of gray smoke gracefully snakes out from a dark, circular opening, wisps curling and unfurling against the backdrop. The background itself dissolves into a beautiful, bokeh-filled tapestry of defocused city lights—vibrant orbs of neon pink, electric blue, and warm molybdenum orange—creating a striking artistic contrast to the sharp focus of the foreground subject. The interplay of these distant lights creates dazzling specular highlights that dance across the casing's swirling form while backlit against the translucent smoke, imbuing the entire scene with a dramatic, almost balletic atmosphere, suspending the moment of the violent act as a tranquil and hypnotic visual spectacle.", + "seed": 18631, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_5/index_7208_seed_18631_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03970647687092423, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03970647687092423, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03970647687092423, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a bullet casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the casing moving in extreme slow motion while ricocheting upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the casing polished brass with a brilliant golden yellow color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate plume of gray smoke snaking out from a dark circular opening on the casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a defocused city with vibrant orbs of neon pink, electric blue, and warm orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11417780071496964 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.239177703857422 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11417780071496964, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11417780071496964, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08724135160446167, + 0.06801540404558182, + 0.05421661585569382, + 0.09674368798732758, + 0.20102600753307343, + 0.22125820815563202, + 0.13244259357452393, + 0.03160078451037407, + 0.0648966133594513, + 0.04255872964859009 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11417780071496964 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a bullet casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the casing moving in extreme slow motion while ricocheting upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the casing polished brass with a brilliant golden yellow color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate plume of gray smoke snaking out from a dark circular opening on the casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a defocused city with vibrant orbs of neon pink, electric blue, and warm orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020587095990777016 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895587205886841 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020587095990777016, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020587095990777016, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07403495162725449, + 0.060304317623376846, + 0.042747002094984055, + 0.04648451879620552, + 0.08109214156866074, + 0.15939711034297943, + 0.11324337869882584, + 0.07345281541347504, + 0.3045722246170044, + 0.04467155039310455 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020587095990777016 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a bullet casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the casing moving in extreme slow motion while ricocheting upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the casing polished brass with a brilliant golden yellow color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate plume of gray smoke snaking out from a dark circular opening on the casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a defocused city with vibrant orbs of neon pink, electric blue, and warm orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306533932685852 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168065309524536 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306533932685852, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306533932685852, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12522830069065094, + 0.04180043190717697, + 0.07680384069681168, + 0.04519405588507652, + 0.17330770194530487, + 0.1941775530576706, + 0.0772552490234375, + 0.06371832638978958, + 0.0748266726732254, + 0.12768776714801788 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306533932685852 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a bullet casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the casing moving in extreme slow motion while ricocheting upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the casing polished brass with a brilliant golden yellow color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate plume of gray smoke snaking out from a dark circular opening on the casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a defocused city with vibrant orbs of neon pink, electric blue, and warm orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606672629714012 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141066551208496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606672629714012, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606672629714012, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2517494261264801, + 0.12343578785657883, + 0.07287287712097168, + 0.07096607238054276, + 0.13685452938079834, + 0.04128193110227585, + 0.10943447053432465, + 0.1172516867518425, + 0.037865132093429565, + 0.038288094103336334 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606672629714012 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a bullet casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the casing moving in extreme slow motion while ricocheting upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the casing polished brass with a brilliant golden yellow color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate plume of gray smoke snaking out from a dark circular opening on the casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a defocused city with vibrant orbs of neon pink, electric blue, and warm orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004635422024875879 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379635334014893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004635422024875879, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004635422024875879, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22680681943893433, + 0.1164429783821106, + 0.09459557384252548, + 0.05569574609398842, + 0.13616415858268738, + 0.1047106683254242, + 0.04917988181114197, + 0.02247549220919609, + 0.09758667647838593, + 0.09634191542863846 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004635422024875879 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up shot from a slightly low angle tracks a bullet casing as it ricochets upward in mesmerizing, extreme slow motion. The polished brass casing, a brilliant golden yellow, gleams in the ambient light, its smooth cylindrical surface capturing and reflecting a kaleidoscope of colors while tumbling slowly and deliberately end-to-end through the air. A delicate, ethereal plume of gray smoke gracefully snakes out from a dark, circular opening, wisps curling and unfurling against the backdrop. The background itself dissolves into a beautiful, bokeh-filled tapestry of defocused city lights—vibrant orbs of neon pink, electric blue, and warm molybdenum orange—creating a striking artistic contrast to the sharp focus of the foreground subject. The interplay of these distant lights creates dazzling specular highlights that dance across the casing's swirling form while backlit against the translucent smoke, imbuing the entire scene with a dramatic, almost balletic atmosphere, suspending the moment of the violent act as a tranquil and hypnotic visual spectacle.", + "seed": 18632, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_5/index_7208_seed_18632_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.029653222858905794, + "vlm_logprob": -0.029653222858905794, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.7, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.029653222858905794, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a bullet casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the casing moving in extreme slow motion while ricocheting upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the casing polished brass with a brilliant golden yellow color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate plume of gray smoke snaking out from a dark circular opening on the casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a defocused city with vibrant orbs of neon pink, electric blue, and warm orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015009209513664246 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26500940322876 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015009209513664246, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015009209513664246, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05671343207359314, + 0.050583433359861374, + 0.08479348570108414, + 0.13048027455806732, + 0.07642574608325958, + 0.08310484886169434, + 0.22015371918678284, + 0.14581379294395447, + 0.03453914821147919, + 0.11739212274551392 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015009209513664246 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a bullet casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the casing moving in extreme slow motion while ricocheting upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the casing polished brass with a brilliant golden yellow color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate plume of gray smoke snaking out from a dark circular opening on the casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a defocused city with vibrant orbs of neon pink, electric blue, and warm orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809775784611702 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288097858428955 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809775784611702, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809775784611702, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1532411426305771, + 0.05135200545191765, + 0.09339571744203568, + 0.14798592031002045, + 0.0651470199227333, + 0.1290404051542282, + 0.10588935017585754, + 0.07989756762981415, + 0.05830192565917969, + 0.11574891954660416 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809775784611702 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a bullet casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the casing moving in extreme slow motion while ricocheting upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the casing polished brass with a brilliant golden yellow color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate plume of gray smoke snaking out from a dark circular opening on the casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a defocused city with vibrant orbs of neon pink, electric blue, and warm orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012541357427835464 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.3875412940979 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012541357427835464, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012541357427835464, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09945186972618103, + 0.07874499261379242, + 0.0543069988489151, + 0.21704034507274628, + 0.10523626208305359, + 0.10340359061956406, + 0.11562873423099518, + 0.061565689742565155, + 0.04395023733377457, + 0.12067131698131561 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012541357427835464 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a bullet casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the casing moving in extreme slow motion while ricocheting upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the casing polished brass with a brilliant golden yellow color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate plume of gray smoke snaking out from a dark circular opening on the casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a defocused city with vibrant orbs of neon pink, electric blue, and warm orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020584292709827423 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955843448638916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020584292709827423, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020584292709827423, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09806542843580246, + 0.02679552510380745, + 0.05884689465165138, + 0.2947535216808319, + 0.043012380599975586, + 0.19738413393497467, + 0.15826843678951263, + 0.043217189610004425, + 0.022488512098789215, + 0.05716801807284355 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020584292709827423 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a bullet casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the casing moving in extreme slow motion while ricocheting upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the casing polished brass with a brilliant golden yellow color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate plume of gray smoke snaking out from a dark circular opening on the casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a defocused city with vibrant orbs of neon pink, electric blue, and warm orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06203349679708481 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120334148406982 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06203349679708481, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06203349679708481, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09030750393867493, + 0.09763647615909576, + 0.09366308897733688, + 0.19196124374866486, + 0.04788072779774666, + 0.051175881177186966, + 0.10216314345598221, + 0.037262484431266785, + 0.12900708615779877, + 0.1589423269033432 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06203349679708481 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up shot from a slightly low angle tracks a bullet casing as it ricochets upward in mesmerizing, extreme slow motion. The polished brass casing, a brilliant golden yellow, gleams in the ambient light, its smooth cylindrical surface capturing and reflecting a kaleidoscope of colors while tumbling slowly and deliberately end-to-end through the air. A delicate, ethereal plume of gray smoke gracefully snakes out from a dark, circular opening, wisps curling and unfurling against the backdrop. The background itself dissolves into a beautiful, bokeh-filled tapestry of defocused city lights—vibrant orbs of neon pink, electric blue, and warm molybdenum orange—creating a striking artistic contrast to the sharp focus of the foreground subject. The interplay of these distant lights creates dazzling specular highlights that dance across the casing's swirling form while backlit against the translucent smoke, imbuing the entire scene with a dramatic, almost balletic atmosphere, suspending the moment of the violent act as a tranquil and hypnotic visual spectacle.", + "seed": 18633, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_5/index_7208_seed_18633_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.055944827198982236, + "vlm_logprob": -0.055944827198982236, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.1499999523162843, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.055944827198982236, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a bullet casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the casing moving in extreme slow motion while ricocheting upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the casing polished brass with a brilliant golden yellow color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate plume of gray smoke snaking out from a dark circular opening on the casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a defocused city with vibrant orbs of neon pink, electric blue, and warm orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11526768654584885 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.240267753601074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11526768654584885, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11526768654584885, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19909852743148804, + 0.07705391943454742, + 0.07284252345561981, + 0.11624791473150253, + 0.05930071696639061, + 0.13630545139312744, + 0.03674390912055969, + 0.030356386676430702, + 0.014159762300550938, + 0.25789088010787964 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11526768654584885 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a bullet casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the casing moving in extreme slow motion while ricocheting upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the casing polished brass with a brilliant golden yellow color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate plume of gray smoke snaking out from a dark circular opening on the casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a defocused city with vibrant orbs of neon pink, electric blue, and warm orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07002159208059311 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695021629333496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07002159208059311, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07002159208059311, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.059656258672475815, + 0.2256881594657898, + 0.04281258210539818, + 0.02255328744649887, + 0.03537263721227646, + 0.2323475480079651, + 0.12124093621969223, + 0.1552334725856781, + 0.04867662861943245, + 0.05641850456595421 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07002159208059311 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a bullet casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the casing moving in extreme slow motion while ricocheting upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the casing polished brass with a brilliant golden yellow color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate plume of gray smoke snaking out from a dark circular opening on the casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a defocused city with vibrant orbs of neon pink, electric blue, and warm orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06204850971698761 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120484352111816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06204850971698761, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06204850971698761, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06579569727182388, + 0.07592348009347916, + 0.06264428794384003, + 0.11942758411169052, + 0.06201313063502312, + 0.06742317229509354, + 0.03578871488571167, + 0.10975177586078644, + 0.05226346477866173, + 0.3489687144756317 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06204850971698761 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a bullet casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the casing moving in extreme slow motion while ricocheting upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the casing polished brass with a brilliant golden yellow color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate plume of gray smoke snaking out from a dark circular opening on the casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a defocused city with vibrant orbs of neon pink, electric blue, and warm orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018191518262028694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018191337585449 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018191518262028694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018191518262028694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09923756122589111, + 0.17558428645133972, + 0.12179490923881531, + 0.12905637919902802, + 0.11950144916772842, + 0.08359870314598083, + 0.05814449116587639, + 0.0708102434873581, + 0.032976552844047546, + 0.10929542034864426 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018191518262028694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an extreme close-up of a bullet casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the casing moving in extreme slow motion while ricocheting upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the casing polished brass with a brilliant golden yellow color?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is there a delicate plume of gray smoke snaking out from a dark circular opening on the casing?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a defocused city with vibrant orbs of neon pink, electric blue, and warm orange?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014194829389452934 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264194965362549 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014194829389452934, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014194829389452934, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2746651768684387, + 0.07182769477367401, + 0.04866822436451912, + 0.14714711904525757, + 0.08971627056598663, + 0.08043567091226578, + 0.06016179919242859, + 0.041923146694898605, + 0.03811926394701004, + 0.14733566343784332 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014194829389452934 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_6/index_tensor([6682, 6682])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_6/index_tensor([6682, 6682])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..3677fcbd21fbb1a052c88e023d74e3c8f97f91e1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_6/index_tensor([6682, 6682])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "sweeping long shot, captured from a slightly upward angle, slowly and steadily pulls back to reveal an ancient bronze inkstone suspended above a swirling sea of clouds. Illuminated by a divine, soft golden light emanating from the heavens, the massive inkstone, its surface mottled with a patina and dark veins etched by time, reflects a solemn radiance. Within, ink, as thick as the night sky, shimmers with a profound luster. As the inkstone tilts silently, a stream of ink, mingled with tiny silver specks like billions of stars, pours forth magnificently like a miniature Milky Way, leaving a winding black streak in the air. As it falls, the ink stream rapidly disintegrates and recomposes, transforming into ancient and mysterious oracle bone inscriptions shimmering with silver light. These symbols briefly pause and swirl in the air, imbued with a sense of ancient wisdom. The oracle bone symbols then continued to fall at an accelerating pace, their form shifting again before converging into seven precisely aligned, brilliant points of light, forming the Big Dipper. These trailed clear geometric light trails behind them, as if tracing the lines of the constellations through the void. Ultimately, they plunged together and dissipated into the endless sea of clouds below. The entire composition, executed in a realistic style that strives for photorealism and physically accurate lighting and shadow effects, creates a grand, majestic, and cosmically poetic atmosphere imbued with the richness of Eastern mythology.", + "seed": 16573, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_6/index_6682_seed_16573_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.023312273994088174, + "vlm_logprob": -0.023312273994088174, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.15, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.023312273994088174, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping long shot that slowly pulls back from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze inkstone suspended above a swirling sea of clouds visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the inkstone tilt silently while a stream of ink mixed with tiny silver specks pours forth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling ink symbols transform into seven aligned points of light forming the Big Dipper constellation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the seven points of light leave clear geometric light trails before plunging into the clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.028061287477612495 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6530613899230957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.028061287477612495, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.028061287477612495, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15455025434494019, + 0.1253429800271988, + 0.11874625831842422, + 0.09571279585361481, + 0.059463951736688614, + 0.08106409758329391, + 0.04712505638599396, + 0.057983435690402985, + 0.18711760640144348, + 0.0728936567902565 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.028061287477612495 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping long shot that slowly pulls back from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze inkstone suspended above a swirling sea of clouds visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the inkstone tilt silently while a stream of ink mixed with tiny silver specks pours forth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling ink symbols transform into seven aligned points of light forming the Big Dipper constellation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the seven points of light leave clear geometric light trails before plunging into the clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0025054989382624626 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002505302429199 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0025054989382624626, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0025054989382624626, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3843993842601776, + 0.1834476739168167, + 0.04942813888192177, + 0.03469998016953468, + 0.03953729197382927, + 0.05854620784521103, + 0.06233009696006775, + 0.021442696452140808, + 0.11470197886228561, + 0.05146655812859535 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0025054989382624626 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping long shot that slowly pulls back from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze inkstone suspended above a swirling sea of clouds visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the inkstone tilt silently while a stream of ink mixed with tiny silver specks pours forth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling ink symbols transform into seven aligned points of light forming the Big Dipper constellation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the seven points of light leave clear geometric light trails before plunging into the clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00978908035904169 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634788990020752 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00978908035904169, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00978908035904169, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11724986881017685, + 0.13425536453723907, + 0.06290873140096664, + 0.09389296919107437, + 0.04602363333106041, + 0.0420432984828949, + 0.052815236151218414, + 0.042527295649051666, + 0.24416865408420563, + 0.16411493718624115 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00978908035904169 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping long shot that slowly pulls back from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze inkstone suspended above a swirling sea of clouds visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the inkstone tilt silently while a stream of ink mixed with tiny silver specks pours forth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling ink symbols transform into seven aligned points of light forming the Big Dipper constellation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the seven points of light leave clear geometric light trails before plunging into the clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03810395672917366 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881040573120117 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03810395672917366, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03810395672917366, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1419164091348648, + 0.16602522134780884, + 0.056648414582014084, + 0.06338748335838318, + 0.04994070529937744, + 0.031025463715195656, + 0.06368839740753174, + 0.028263619169592857, + 0.20131130516529083, + 0.1977929323911667 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03810395672917366 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping long shot that slowly pulls back from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze inkstone suspended above a swirling sea of clouds visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the inkstone tilt silently while a stream of ink mixed with tiny silver specks pours forth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling ink symbols transform into seven aligned points of light forming the Big Dipper constellation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the seven points of light leave clear geometric light trails before plunging into the clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038101546466350555 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881014347076416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038101546466350555, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038101546466350555, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17852991819381714, + 0.2200711965560913, + 0.07457337528467178, + 0.07245749980211258, + 0.05760210007429123, + 0.04755588620901108, + 0.04544300213456154, + 0.04855172708630562, + 0.11039969325065613, + 0.144815593957901 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038101546466350555 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping long shot, captured from a slightly upward angle, slowly and steadily pulls back to reveal an ancient bronze inkstone suspended above a swirling sea of clouds. Illuminated by a divine, soft golden light emanating from the heavens, the massive inkstone, its surface mottled with a patina and dark veins etched by time, reflects a solemn radiance. Within, ink, as thick as the night sky, shimmers with a profound luster. As the inkstone tilts silently, a stream of ink, mingled with tiny silver specks like billions of stars, pours forth magnificently like a miniature Milky Way, leaving a winding black streak in the air. As it falls, the ink stream rapidly disintegrates and recomposes, transforming into ancient and mysterious oracle bone inscriptions shimmering with silver light. These symbols briefly pause and swirl in the air, imbued with a sense of ancient wisdom. The oracle bone symbols then continued to fall at an accelerating pace, their form shifting again before converging into seven precisely aligned, brilliant points of light, forming the Big Dipper. These trailed clear geometric light trails behind them, as if tracing the lines of the constellations through the void. Ultimately, they plunged together and dissipated into the endless sea of clouds below. The entire composition, executed in a realistic style that strives for photorealism and physically accurate lighting and shadow effects, creates a grand, majestic, and cosmically poetic atmosphere imbued with the richness of Eastern mythology.", + "seed": 16574, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_6/index_6682_seed_16574_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.06734457518905401, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06734457518905401, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.05, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06734457518905401, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping long shot that slowly pulls back from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze inkstone suspended above a swirling sea of clouds visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the inkstone tilt silently while a stream of ink mixed with tiny silver specks pours forth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling ink symbols transform into seven aligned points of light forming the Big Dipper constellation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the seven points of light leave clear geometric light trails before plunging into the clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0505652129650116 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.050565242767334 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0505652129650116, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0505652129650116, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4782370328903198, + 0.051745787262916565, + 0.031124336645007133, + 0.01770642213523388, + 0.13455455005168915, + 0.03931977227330208, + 0.04902017489075661, + 0.16377630829811096, + 0.021151533350348473, + 0.013364092446863651 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0505652129650116 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping long shot that slowly pulls back from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze inkstone suspended above a swirling sea of clouds visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the inkstone tilt silently while a stream of ink mixed with tiny silver specks pours forth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling ink symbols transform into seven aligned points of light forming the Big Dipper constellation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the seven points of light leave clear geometric light trails before plunging into the clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008667468093335629 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758667469024658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008667468093335629, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008667468093335629, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3651387691497803, + 0.0489768348634243, + 0.04348606988787651, + 0.03564784675836563, + 0.09029567241668701, + 0.34232956171035767, + 0.023257698863744736, + 0.02399885281920433, + 0.014906656928360462, + 0.011962038464844227 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008667468093335629 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping long shot that slowly pulls back from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze inkstone suspended above a swirling sea of clouds visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the inkstone tilt silently while a stream of ink mixed with tiny silver specks pours forth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling ink symbols transform into seven aligned points of light forming the Big Dipper constellation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the seven points of light leave clear geometric light trails before plunging into the clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038111645728349686 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288111686706543 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038111645728349686, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038111645728349686, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.42408064007759094, + 0.07635129988193512, + 0.0342540368437767, + 0.032836541533470154, + 0.2338431477546692, + 0.05789793282747269, + 0.06669329106807709, + 0.02870238944888115, + 0.016375355422496796, + 0.028965333476662636 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038111645728349686 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping long shot that slowly pulls back from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze inkstone suspended above a swirling sea of clouds visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the inkstone tilt silently while a stream of ink mixed with tiny silver specks pours forth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling ink symbols transform into seven aligned points of light forming the Big Dipper constellation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the seven points of light leave clear geometric light trails before plunging into the clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16037511825561523 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9103751182556152 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16037511825561523, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16037511825561523, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3570408821105957, + 0.04018236696720123, + 0.03955654799938202, + 0.01542602013796568, + 0.08600617945194244, + 0.28486695885658264, + 0.013887383975088596, + 0.04919598624110222, + 0.038879573345184326, + 0.07495813071727753 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16037511825561523 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping long shot that slowly pulls back from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze inkstone suspended above a swirling sea of clouds visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the inkstone tilt silently while a stream of ink mixed with tiny silver specks pours forth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling ink symbols transform into seven aligned points of light forming the Big Dipper constellation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the seven points of light leave clear geometric light trails before plunging into the clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900343090295792 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.57900333404541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900343090295792, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900343090295792, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26996156573295593, + 0.07134504616260529, + 0.10398771613836288, + 0.07753713428974152, + 0.08823487907648087, + 0.12489177286624908, + 0.09277856349945068, + 0.04292183741927147, + 0.06417777389287949, + 0.06416381150484085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900343090295792 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping long shot, captured from a slightly upward angle, slowly and steadily pulls back to reveal an ancient bronze inkstone suspended above a swirling sea of clouds. Illuminated by a divine, soft golden light emanating from the heavens, the massive inkstone, its surface mottled with a patina and dark veins etched by time, reflects a solemn radiance. Within, ink, as thick as the night sky, shimmers with a profound luster. As the inkstone tilts silently, a stream of ink, mingled with tiny silver specks like billions of stars, pours forth magnificently like a miniature Milky Way, leaving a winding black streak in the air. As it falls, the ink stream rapidly disintegrates and recomposes, transforming into ancient and mysterious oracle bone inscriptions shimmering with silver light. These symbols briefly pause and swirl in the air, imbued with a sense of ancient wisdom. The oracle bone symbols then continued to fall at an accelerating pace, their form shifting again before converging into seven precisely aligned, brilliant points of light, forming the Big Dipper. These trailed clear geometric light trails behind them, as if tracing the lines of the constellations through the void. Ultimately, they plunged together and dissipated into the endless sea of clouds below. The entire composition, executed in a realistic style that strives for photorealism and physically accurate lighting and shadow effects, creates a grand, majestic, and cosmically poetic atmosphere imbued with the richness of Eastern mythology.", + "seed": 16575, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_6/index_6682_seed_16575_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06824630871415138, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06824630871415138, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06824630871415138, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping long shot that slowly pulls back from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze inkstone suspended above a swirling sea of clouds visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the inkstone tilt silently while a stream of ink mixed with tiny silver specks pours forth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling ink symbols transform into seven aligned points of light forming the Big Dipper constellation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the seven points of light leave clear geometric light trails before plunging into the clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03040665201842785 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6554067134857178 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03040665201842785, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03040665201842785, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08421101421117783, + 0.3371051549911499, + 0.07148571312427521, + 0.04557476565241814, + 0.10198941826820374, + 0.15814635157585144, + 0.05340095981955528, + 0.03978384658694267, + 0.03739031404256821, + 0.0709124207496643 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03040665201842785 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping long shot that slowly pulls back from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze inkstone suspended above a swirling sea of clouds visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the inkstone tilt silently while a stream of ink mixed with tiny silver specks pours forth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling ink symbols transform into seven aligned points of light forming the Big Dipper constellation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the seven points of light leave clear geometric light trails before plunging into the clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005969434045255184 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130969524383545 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005969434045255184, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005969434045255184, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19126346707344055, + 0.322632372379303, + 0.07723735272884369, + 0.061847370117902756, + 0.05835266411304474, + 0.1054779514670372, + 0.04324667528271675, + 0.0385700985789299, + 0.05387064442038536, + 0.047501418739557266 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005969434045255184 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping long shot that slowly pulls back from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze inkstone suspended above a swirling sea of clouds visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the inkstone tilt silently while a stream of ink mixed with tiny silver specks pours forth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling ink symbols transform into seven aligned points of light forming the Big Dipper constellation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the seven points of light leave clear geometric light trails before plunging into the clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014202586375176907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.26420259475708 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014202586375176907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014202586375176907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14939703047275543, + 0.14589866995811462, + 0.09350286424160004, + 0.06497889012098312, + 0.17853623628616333, + 0.15899592638015747, + 0.09493323415517807, + 0.035179171711206436, + 0.03919070214033127, + 0.0393872931599617 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014202586375176907 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping long shot that slowly pulls back from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze inkstone suspended above a swirling sea of clouds visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the inkstone tilt silently while a stream of ink mixed with tiny silver specks pours forth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling ink symbols transform into seven aligned points of light forming the Big Dipper constellation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the seven points of light leave clear geometric light trails before plunging into the clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2015959620475769 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015960216522217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2015959620475769, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2015959620475769, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1080147922039032, + 0.09991546720266342, + 0.06734880805015564, + 0.0530160628259182, + 0.09271473437547684, + 0.39215171337127686, + 0.035433780401945114, + 0.053523946553468704, + 0.05429081618785858, + 0.04358989745378494 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2015959620475769 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping long shot that slowly pulls back from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze inkstone suspended above a swirling sea of clouds visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the inkstone tilt silently while a stream of ink mixed with tiny silver specks pours forth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling ink symbols transform into seven aligned points of light forming the Big Dipper constellation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the seven points of light leave clear geometric light trails before plunging into the clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08905690908432007 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464056968688965 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08905690908432007, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08905690908432007, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14391906559467316, + 0.1307084858417511, + 0.05925121158361435, + 0.06044097989797592, + 0.14727042615413666, + 0.17893542349338531, + 0.07104551047086716, + 0.04518672451376915, + 0.05793089047074318, + 0.10531119257211685 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08905690908432007 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sweeping long shot, captured from a slightly upward angle, slowly and steadily pulls back to reveal an ancient bronze inkstone suspended above a swirling sea of clouds. Illuminated by a divine, soft golden light emanating from the heavens, the massive inkstone, its surface mottled with a patina and dark veins etched by time, reflects a solemn radiance. Within, ink, as thick as the night sky, shimmers with a profound luster. As the inkstone tilts silently, a stream of ink, mingled with tiny silver specks like billions of stars, pours forth magnificently like a miniature Milky Way, leaving a winding black streak in the air. As it falls, the ink stream rapidly disintegrates and recomposes, transforming into ancient and mysterious oracle bone inscriptions shimmering with silver light. These symbols briefly pause and swirl in the air, imbued with a sense of ancient wisdom. The oracle bone symbols then continued to fall at an accelerating pace, their form shifting again before converging into seven precisely aligned, brilliant points of light, forming the Big Dipper. These trailed clear geometric light trails behind them, as if tracing the lines of the constellations through the void. Ultimately, they plunged together and dissipated into the endless sea of clouds below. The entire composition, executed in a realistic style that strives for photorealism and physically accurate lighting and shadow effects, creates a grand, majestic, and cosmically poetic atmosphere imbued with the richness of Eastern mythology.", + "seed": 16576, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_6/index_6682_seed_16576_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.07941656224429608, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07941656224429608, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07941656224429608, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping long shot that slowly pulls back from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze inkstone suspended above a swirling sea of clouds visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the inkstone tilt silently while a stream of ink mixed with tiny silver specks pours forth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling ink symbols transform into seven aligned points of light forming the Big Dipper constellation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the seven points of light leave clear geometric light trails before plunging into the clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03942720964550972 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2894272804260254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03942720964550972, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03942720964550972, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2572447657585144, + 0.11442291736602783, + 0.034509189426898956, + 0.16857188940048218, + 0.14182651042938232, + 0.13675524294376373, + 0.04704713448882103, + 0.03780088573694229, + 0.036398887634277344, + 0.02542249858379364 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03942720964550972 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping long shot that slowly pulls back from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze inkstone suspended above a swirling sea of clouds visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the inkstone tilt silently while a stream of ink mixed with tiny silver specks pours forth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling ink symbols transform into seven aligned points of light forming the Big Dipper constellation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the seven points of light leave clear geometric light trails before plunging into the clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005265297368168831 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255265235900879 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005265297368168831, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005265297368168831, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2023070752620697, + 0.420138418674469, + 0.06639222055673599, + 0.04854677617549896, + 0.05452077090740204, + 0.08032883703708649, + 0.0399475134909153, + 0.03778626024723053, + 0.027021445333957672, + 0.0230106171220541 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005265297368168831 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping long shot that slowly pulls back from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze inkstone suspended above a swirling sea of clouds visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the inkstone tilt silently while a stream of ink mixed with tiny silver specks pours forth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling ink symbols transform into seven aligned points of light forming the Big Dipper constellation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the seven points of light leave clear geometric light trails before plunging into the clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016069423407316208 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141069412231445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016069423407316208, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016069423407316208, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27276867628097534, + 0.0642935186624527, + 0.06575488299131393, + 0.05151151120662689, + 0.10060818493366241, + 0.1859341859817505, + 0.13434721529483795, + 0.055928684771060944, + 0.04413847625255585, + 0.02471466176211834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016069423407316208 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping long shot that slowly pulls back from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze inkstone suspended above a swirling sea of clouds visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the inkstone tilt silently while a stream of ink mixed with tiny silver specks pours forth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling ink symbols transform into seven aligned points of light forming the Big Dipper constellation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the seven points of light leave clear geometric light trails before plunging into the clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.281356543302536 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063565731048584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.281356543302536, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.281356543302536, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17747753858566284, + 0.0763254463672638, + 0.051648885011672974, + 0.08368012309074402, + 0.08221100270748138, + 0.1692318469285965, + 0.16687250137329102, + 0.09542139619588852, + 0.062160782516002655, + 0.03497052565217018 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.281356543302536 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot a sweeping long shot that slowly pulls back from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is an ancient bronze inkstone suspended above a swirling sea of clouds visible in the scene?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the inkstone tilt silently while a stream of ink mixed with tiny silver specks pours forth?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do the falling ink symbols transform into seven aligned points of light forming the Big Dipper constellation?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Do the seven points of light leave clear geometric light trails before plunging into the clouds below?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0549643374979496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929964303970337 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0549643374979496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0549643374979496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25233691930770874, + 0.14635692536830902, + 0.038318365812301636, + 0.0723458081483841, + 0.1342831254005432, + 0.0792018473148346, + 0.11554659157991409, + 0.10010694712400436, + 0.025089697912335396, + 0.0364137701690197 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0549643374979496 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_7/index_tensor([6498, 6498])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_7/index_tensor([6498, 6498])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..a16c484dd34c4986a92e8823a73d5df1ec3e8f1f --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_7/index_tensor([6498, 6498])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "strikingly dynamic, low-angle, high-speed tracking shot zooms across the weathered brickwork of the ancient Great Wall. Each dark gray stone bears the marks of time, its rough, uneven surface dotted with dark green moss and white salt frost left by weathering. Even a few clumps of tenacious grass tremble in the fine cracks, quivering in the morning breeze. On the other side of the camera, rolling dark green mountains are shrouded in a milky, morning mist, like a veil. Peaks appear faintly through the haze, and the skyline is just beginning to turn pale. The soft, cool, diffuse light of the morning penetrates the mist, reflecting a faint, icy luster off the damp masonry. As the camera rapidly pans, the texture of the wall rapidly recedes before our eyes, creating a strong motion blur. The entire scene is imbued with a vast, desolate, and cold hue, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and mystery that transcends history.", + "seed": 18720, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_7/index_6498_seed_18720_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.11038029445335269, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11038029445335269, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11038029445335269, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the weathered brickwork of the ancient Great Wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stones dark gray with visible dark green moss and white salt frost?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, high-speed tracking shot that pans rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rolling dark green mountains shrouded in a milky morning mist visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit strong motion blur on the wall texture due to the rapid camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5238450169563293 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8988450169563293 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5238450169563293, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5238450169563293, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11206559091806412, + 0.05092319846153259, + 0.18308620154857635, + 0.1271330565214157, + 0.09359041601419449, + 0.0533660352230072, + 0.06872282177209854, + 0.054023001343011856, + 0.09428153187036514, + 0.16280817985534668 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5238450169563293 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the weathered brickwork of the ancient Great Wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stones dark gray with visible dark green moss and white salt frost?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, high-speed tracking shot that pans rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rolling dark green mountains shrouded in a milky morning mist visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit strong motion blur on the wall texture due to the rapid camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00979510135948658 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634795188903809 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00979510135948658, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00979510135948658, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06174249202013016, + 0.04313939809799194, + 0.0749206393957138, + 0.04430136829614639, + 0.05420287698507309, + 0.03896136209368706, + 0.27621495723724365, + 0.11405215412378311, + 0.10331496596336365, + 0.18914979696273804 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00979510135948658 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the weathered brickwork of the ancient Great Wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stones dark gray with visible dark green moss and white salt frost?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, high-speed tracking shot that pans rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rolling dark green mountains shrouded in a milky morning mist visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit strong motion blur on the wall texture due to the rapid camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005253320559859276 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255253314971924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005253320559859276, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005253320559859276, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05480671301484108, + 0.09763333946466446, + 0.06380171328783035, + 0.16402488946914673, + 0.0668608620762825, + 0.10961151868104935, + 0.2477540820837021, + 0.0379108302295208, + 0.037767503410577774, + 0.1198284775018692 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005253320559859276 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the weathered brickwork of the ancient Great Wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stones dark gray with visible dark green moss and white salt frost?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, high-speed tracking shot that pans rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rolling dark green mountains shrouded in a milky morning mist visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit strong motion blur on the wall texture due to the rapid camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107061468064785 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511070728302002 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107061468064785, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107061468064785, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08915507793426514, + 0.04650502651929855, + 0.15948601067066193, + 0.05756378918886185, + 0.04523942247033119, + 0.04679733142256737, + 0.2911040484905243, + 0.07035089284181595, + 0.09735102951526642, + 0.09644730389118195 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107061468064785 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the weathered brickwork of the ancient Great Wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stones dark gray with visible dark green moss and white salt frost?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, high-speed tracking shot that pans rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rolling dark green mountains shrouded in a milky morning mist visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit strong motion blur on the wall texture due to the rapid camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0019374187104403973 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.251937389373779 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0019374187104403973, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0019374187104403973, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09012526273727417, + 0.06296782195568085, + 0.14566904306411743, + 0.18695072829723358, + 0.07250922173261642, + 0.04176757112145424, + 0.23373857140541077, + 0.01904725469648838, + 0.05702921375632286, + 0.09019537270069122 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0019374187104403973 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "strikingly dynamic, low-angle, high-speed tracking shot zooms across the weathered brickwork of the ancient Great Wall. Each dark gray stone bears the marks of time, its rough, uneven surface dotted with dark green moss and white salt frost left by weathering. Even a few clumps of tenacious grass tremble in the fine cracks, quivering in the morning breeze. On the other side of the camera, rolling dark green mountains are shrouded in a milky, morning mist, like a veil. Peaks appear faintly through the haze, and the skyline is just beginning to turn pale. The soft, cool, diffuse light of the morning penetrates the mist, reflecting a faint, icy luster off the damp masonry. As the camera rapidly pans, the texture of the wall rapidly recedes before our eyes, creating a strong motion blur. The entire scene is imbued with a vast, desolate, and cold hue, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and mystery that transcends history.", + "seed": 18721, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_7/index_6498_seed_18721_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.05436321389861405, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05436321389861405, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05436321389861405, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the weathered brickwork of the ancient Great Wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stones dark gray with visible dark green moss and white salt frost?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, high-speed tracking shot that pans rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rolling dark green mountains shrouded in a milky morning mist visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit strong motion blur on the wall texture due to the rapid camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22639600932598114 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6013959646224976 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22639600932598114, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22639600932598114, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05616389960050583, + 0.04105444252490997, + 0.09412068128585815, + 0.3275253474712372, + 0.061331216245889664, + 0.036311618983745575, + 0.020088210701942444, + 0.056328658014535904, + 0.22445562481880188, + 0.08262035250663757 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22639600932598114 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the weathered brickwork of the ancient Great Wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stones dark gray with visible dark green moss and white salt frost?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, high-speed tracking shot that pans rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rolling dark green mountains shrouded in a milky morning mist visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit strong motion blur on the wall texture due to the rapid camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014219745993614197 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264219760894775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014219745993614197, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014219745993614197, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03775967285037041, + 0.02674434706568718, + 0.18346542119979858, + 0.2770468294620514, + 0.1944989264011383, + 0.03280371427536011, + 0.04463789239525795, + 0.06911063939332962, + 0.04210188612341881, + 0.09183067083358765 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014219745993614197 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the weathered brickwork of the ancient Great Wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stones dark gray with visible dark green moss and white salt frost?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, high-speed tracking shot that pans rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rolling dark green mountains shrouded in a milky morning mist visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit strong motion blur on the wall texture due to the rapid camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01107780635356903 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511077880859375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01107780635356903, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01107780635356903, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03173227980732918, + 0.05827097222208977, + 0.036490924656391144, + 0.14561903476715088, + 0.31428787112236023, + 0.0746694803237915, + 0.06891001760959625, + 0.031606193631887436, + 0.1352650225162506, + 0.10314827412366867 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01107780635356903 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the weathered brickwork of the ancient Great Wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stones dark gray with visible dark green moss and white salt frost?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, high-speed tracking shot that pans rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rolling dark green mountains shrouded in a milky morning mist visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit strong motion blur on the wall texture due to the rapid camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018184494227170944 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018184661865234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018184494227170944, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018184494227170944, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.04307695850729942, + 0.07283640652894974, + 0.09455883502960205, + 0.3235470950603485, + 0.17010442912578583, + 0.032464731484651566, + 0.02680951915681362, + 0.08862867206335068, + 0.06907448917627335, + 0.07889892160892487 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018184494227170944 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the weathered brickwork of the ancient Great Wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stones dark gray with visible dark green moss and white salt frost?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, high-speed tracking shot that pans rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rolling dark green mountains shrouded in a milky morning mist visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit strong motion blur on the wall texture due to the rapid camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001938013592734933 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.2519378662109375 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001938013592734933, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001938013592734933, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.057580191642045975, + 0.02348860166966915, + 0.24891714751720428, + 0.23072855174541473, + 0.1688186377286911, + 0.053487762808799744, + 0.054096706211566925, + 0.019166791811585426, + 0.09070151299238205, + 0.053014107048511505 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 3, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001938013592734933 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "strikingly dynamic, low-angle, high-speed tracking shot zooms across the weathered brickwork of the ancient Great Wall. Each dark gray stone bears the marks of time, its rough, uneven surface dotted with dark green moss and white salt frost left by weathering. Even a few clumps of tenacious grass tremble in the fine cracks, quivering in the morning breeze. On the other side of the camera, rolling dark green mountains are shrouded in a milky, morning mist, like a veil. Peaks appear faintly through the haze, and the skyline is just beginning to turn pale. The soft, cool, diffuse light of the morning penetrates the mist, reflecting a faint, icy luster off the damp masonry. As the camera rapidly pans, the texture of the wall rapidly recedes before our eyes, creating a strong motion blur. The entire scene is imbued with a vast, desolate, and cold hue, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and mystery that transcends history.", + "seed": 18722, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_7/index_6498_seed_18722_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.040006605559028685, + "vlm_logprob": -0.040006605559028685, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.040006605559028685, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the weathered brickwork of the ancient Great Wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stones dark gray with visible dark green moss and white salt frost?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, high-speed tracking shot that pans rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rolling dark green mountains shrouded in a milky morning mist visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit strong motion blur on the wall texture due to the rapid camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1811620146036148 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8061619997024536 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1811620146036148, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1811620146036148, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11603792756795883, + 0.05987019091844559, + 0.19940513372421265, + 0.32439759373664856, + 0.09476862847805023, + 0.042125143110752106, + 0.04030449315905571, + 0.04225998371839523, + 0.0348580963909626, + 0.045972831547260284 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1811620146036148 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the weathered brickwork of the ancient Great Wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stones dark gray with visible dark green moss and white salt frost?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, high-speed tracking shot that pans rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rolling dark green mountains shrouded in a milky morning mist visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit strong motion blur on the wall texture due to the rapid camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00979935098439455 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634799480438232 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00979935098439455, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00979935098439455, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09981133043766022, + 0.05561983585357666, + 0.11790969222784042, + 0.08241260796785355, + 0.07902323454618454, + 0.26909491419792175, + 0.13100849092006683, + 0.043168433010578156, + 0.049572791904211044, + 0.07237868756055832 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00979935098439455 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the weathered brickwork of the ancient Great Wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stones dark gray with visible dark green moss and white salt frost?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, high-speed tracking shot that pans rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rolling dark green mountains shrouded in a milky morning mist visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit strong motion blur on the wall texture due to the rapid camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024915861431509256 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.002491474151611 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024915861431509256, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024915861431509256, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24172969162464142, + 0.030022291466593742, + 0.35199466347694397, + 0.05218973383307457, + 0.12017658352851868, + 0.09119615703821182, + 0.01769980788230896, + 0.05264623835682869, + 0.025107210502028465, + 0.01723763719201088 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024915861431509256 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the weathered brickwork of the ancient Great Wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stones dark gray with visible dark green moss and white salt frost?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, high-speed tracking shot that pans rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rolling dark green mountains shrouded in a milky morning mist visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit strong motion blur on the wall texture due to the rapid camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005947155877947807 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130947113037109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005947155877947807, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005947155877947807, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09582845866680145, + 0.13848164677619934, + 0.10783576965332031, + 0.16586221754550934, + 0.05368312448263168, + 0.11309023201465607, + 0.06793242692947388, + 0.028893768787384033, + 0.061723385006189346, + 0.1666688770055771 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005947155877947807 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the weathered brickwork of the ancient Great Wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stones dark gray with visible dark green moss and white salt frost?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, high-speed tracking shot that pans rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rolling dark green mountains shrouded in a milky morning mist visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit strong motion blur on the wall texture due to the rapid camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0006329201860353351 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.3756327629089355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0006329201860353351, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0006329201860353351, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16058558225631714, + 0.071916863322258, + 0.31669923663139343, + 0.11897604167461395, + 0.0768473744392395, + 0.043212760239839554, + 0.039940547198057175, + 0.07673856616020203, + 0.027093760669231415, + 0.0679892748594284 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0006329201860353351 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "strikingly dynamic, low-angle, high-speed tracking shot zooms across the weathered brickwork of the ancient Great Wall. Each dark gray stone bears the marks of time, its rough, uneven surface dotted with dark green moss and white salt frost left by weathering. Even a few clumps of tenacious grass tremble in the fine cracks, quivering in the morning breeze. On the other side of the camera, rolling dark green mountains are shrouded in a milky, morning mist, like a veil. Peaks appear faintly through the haze, and the skyline is just beginning to turn pale. The soft, cool, diffuse light of the morning penetrates the mist, reflecting a faint, icy luster off the damp masonry. As the camera rapidly pans, the texture of the wall rapidly recedes before our eyes, creating a strong motion blur. The entire scene is imbued with a vast, desolate, and cold hue, creating an atmosphere of tranquility and mystery that transcends history.", + "seed": 18723, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_7/index_6498_seed_18723_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.11183845663908869, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11183845663908869, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11183845663908869, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the weathered brickwork of the ancient Great Wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stones dark gray with visible dark green moss and white salt frost?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, high-speed tracking shot that pans rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rolling dark green mountains shrouded in a milky morning mist visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit strong motion blur on the wall texture due to the rapid camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5247637629508972 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8997637629508972 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5247637629508972, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5247637629508972, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10822252929210663, + 0.03487035632133484, + 0.12904731929302216, + 0.14787715673446655, + 0.270915150642395, + 0.06789306551218033, + 0.0450594499707222, + 0.016727743670344353, + 0.10091114044189453, + 0.07847611606121063 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5247637629508972 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the weathered brickwork of the ancient Great Wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stones dark gray with visible dark green moss and white salt frost?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, high-speed tracking shot that pans rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rolling dark green mountains shrouded in a milky morning mist visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit strong motion blur on the wall texture due to the rapid camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012569492682814598 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387569427490234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012569492682814598, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012569492682814598, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14822618663311005, + 0.08340983092784882, + 0.05669979006052017, + 0.12998247146606445, + 0.16909100115299225, + 0.08054470270872116, + 0.04104461520910263, + 0.0457860603928566, + 0.07162594050168991, + 0.17358937859535217 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012569492682814598 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the weathered brickwork of the ancient Great Wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stones dark gray with visible dark green moss and white salt frost?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, high-speed tracking shot that pans rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rolling dark green mountains shrouded in a milky morning mist visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit strong motion blur on the wall texture due to the rapid camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005952251143753529 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.13095235824585 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005952251143753529, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005952251143753529, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03468828275799751, + 0.03187490254640579, + 0.11002170294523239, + 0.3176915943622589, + 0.21229752898216248, + 0.13745459914207458, + 0.0739826038479805, + 0.03266111761331558, + 0.019936546683311462, + 0.02939106523990631 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005952251143753529 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the weathered brickwork of the ancient Great Wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stones dark gray with visible dark green moss and white salt frost?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, high-speed tracking shot that pans rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rolling dark green mountains shrouded in a milky morning mist visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit strong motion blur on the wall texture due to the rapid camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014193419367074966 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264193534851074 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014193419367074966, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014193419367074966, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20321471989154816, + 0.15196013450622559, + 0.1273198425769806, + 0.09761682897806168, + 0.09825539588928223, + 0.06259158998727798, + 0.045863181352615356, + 0.03685903921723366, + 0.058576762676239014, + 0.11774244159460068 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014193419367074966 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject the weathered brickwork of the ancient Great Wall?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Are the stones dark gray with visible dark green moss and white salt frost?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the camera executing a low-angle, high-speed tracking shot that pans rapidly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are rolling dark green mountains shrouded in a milky morning mist visible in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the scene exhibit strong motion blur on the wall texture due to the rapid camera movement?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017133570509031415 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376713275909424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017133570509031415, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017133570509031415, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11596179753541946, + 0.05334020033478737, + 0.07230439782142639, + 0.2458651065826416, + 0.06702560931444168, + 0.14562752842903137, + 0.0811372697353363, + 0.05397048965096474, + 0.07444038987159729, + 0.09032727032899857 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017133570509031415 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_8/index_tensor([3891, 3891])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_8/index_tensor([3891, 3891])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..829a80d5ee8184373a5b024b671d2ca43d5af646 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_8/index_tensor([3891, 3891])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot depicts a weary figure slumped over a cluttered wooden desk. The subject, a woman in her twenties, has messy dark brown hair pulled back in a loose, untidy bun, her weary head resting on the palm of her left hand. Her face is pale and drawn, outlined by deep, shadowy hollows beneath her eyes. She wears a simple, oversized charcoal-gray sweatshirt, the soft fabric wrinkled. The desk is a chaotic scene of overwork, littered with scattered papers, an open but idle laptop casting a faint, cool glow, and a half-empty ceramic coffee cup. The scene is plunged into near-total darkness, penetrated only by the solitary, harsh glow of an adjustable metal desk lamp, which casts a focused beam of warm yellow light onto her and the workspace before her. This dramatic chiaroscuro lighting sculpts her exhausted features and creates deep, cavernous shadows that engulf the background. Slowly and heavily, she raises her right hand, her fingers barely grasping the pen, trying to drag it across a sheet of paper, but the movement is heavy and unsuccessful, and finally her hand falls to the table with a soft thud that perfectly captures an oppressive atmosphere of isolation and mental fatigue.", + "seed": 12554, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_8/index_3891_seed_12554_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.07098697060719132, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07098697060719132, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07098697060719132, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a woman in her twenties with messy dark brown hair in a loose bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple, oversized charcoal-gray sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a solitary metal desk lamp casting warm yellow light against a near-total dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the desk cluttered with scattered papers, an open idle laptop, and a half-empty ceramic coffee cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly raise her right hand to drag a pen across paper before letting it fall to the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18138247728347778 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.806382417678833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18138247728347778, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18138247728347778, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3955652117729187, + 0.07106712460517883, + 0.04466843232512474, + 0.05561098828911781, + 0.030699510127305984, + 0.03312930837273598, + 0.04790113866329193, + 0.06049269065260887, + 0.09232015907764435, + 0.1685454249382019 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18138247728347778 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a woman in her twenties with messy dark brown hair in a loose bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple, oversized charcoal-gray sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a solitary metal desk lamp casting warm yellow light against a near-total dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the desk cluttered with scattered papers, an open idle laptop, and a half-empty ceramic coffee cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly raise her right hand to drag a pen across paper before letting it fall to the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.043085210025310516 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680850982666016 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.043085210025310516, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.043085210025310516, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33854609727859497, + 0.10362021625041962, + 0.07656512409448624, + 0.06287144869565964, + 0.03961295634508133, + 0.04414769262075424, + 0.035387009382247925, + 0.07307109981775284, + 0.11178743839263916, + 0.11439095437526703 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.043085210025310516 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a woman in her twenties with messy dark brown hair in a loose bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple, oversized charcoal-gray sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a solitary metal desk lamp casting warm yellow light against a near-total dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the desk cluttered with scattered papers, an open idle laptop, and a half-empty ceramic coffee cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly raise her right hand to drag a pen across paper before letting it fall to the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028206822462379932 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.8778204917907715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028206822462379932, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028206822462379932, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2880176603794098, + 0.1029844805598259, + 0.09922317415475845, + 0.0726206824183464, + 0.049513254314661026, + 0.05379839986562729, + 0.03787359222769737, + 0.061413317918777466, + 0.15247954428195953, + 0.08207588642835617 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028206822462379932 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a woman in her twenties with messy dark brown hair in a loose bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple, oversized charcoal-gray sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a solitary metal desk lamp casting warm yellow light against a near-total dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the desk cluttered with scattered papers, an open idle laptop, and a half-empty ceramic coffee cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly raise her right hand to drag a pen across paper before letting it fall to the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04867510497570038 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048675060272217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04867510497570038, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04867510497570038, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15185008943080902, + 0.06697671115398407, + 0.19734631478786469, + 0.08218546211719513, + 0.07589521259069443, + 0.04446043446660042, + 0.05233015492558479, + 0.17361149191856384, + 0.11429835855960846, + 0.04104571044445038 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04867510497570038 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a woman in her twenties with messy dark brown hair in a loose bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple, oversized charcoal-gray sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a solitary metal desk lamp casting warm yellow light against a near-total dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the desk cluttered with scattered papers, an open idle laptop, and a half-empty ceramic coffee cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly raise her right hand to drag a pen across paper before letting it fall to the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897137850522995 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789713859558105 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897137850522995, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897137850522995, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2501256763935089, + 0.08449890464544296, + 0.07298966497182846, + 0.04422009363770485, + 0.03886789456009865, + 0.04584023356437683, + 0.04915712773799896, + 0.10649341344833374, + 0.22385866940021515, + 0.08394833654165268 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897137850522995 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot depicts a weary figure slumped over a cluttered wooden desk. The subject, a woman in her twenties, has messy dark brown hair pulled back in a loose, untidy bun, her weary head resting on the palm of her left hand. Her face is pale and drawn, outlined by deep, shadowy hollows beneath her eyes. She wears a simple, oversized charcoal-gray sweatshirt, the soft fabric wrinkled. The desk is a chaotic scene of overwork, littered with scattered papers, an open but idle laptop casting a faint, cool glow, and a half-empty ceramic coffee cup. The scene is plunged into near-total darkness, penetrated only by the solitary, harsh glow of an adjustable metal desk lamp, which casts a focused beam of warm yellow light onto her and the workspace before her. This dramatic chiaroscuro lighting sculpts her exhausted features and creates deep, cavernous shadows that engulf the background. Slowly and heavily, she raises her right hand, her fingers barely grasping the pen, trying to drag it across a sheet of paper, but the movement is heavy and unsuccessful, and finally her hand falls to the table with a soft thud that perfectly captures an oppressive atmosphere of isolation and mental fatigue.", + "seed": 12555, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_8/index_3891_seed_12555_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.08526154516730458, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08526154516730458, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08526154516730458, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a woman in her twenties with messy dark brown hair in a loose bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple, oversized charcoal-gray sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a solitary metal desk lamp casting warm yellow light against a near-total dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the desk cluttered with scattered papers, an open idle laptop, and a half-empty ceramic coffee cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly raise her right hand to drag a pen across paper before letting it fall to the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.25475308299064636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5047531127929688 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.25475308299064636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.25475308299064636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3668668270111084, + 0.10423129051923752, + 0.06804763525724411, + 0.06618641316890717, + 0.043987393379211426, + 0.02356416918337345, + 0.025157708674669266, + 0.03575620800256729, + 0.11792098730802536, + 0.14828138053417206 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.25475308299064636 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a woman in her twenties with messy dark brown hair in a loose bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple, oversized charcoal-gray sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a solitary metal desk lamp casting warm yellow light against a near-total dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the desk cluttered with scattered papers, an open idle laptop, and a half-empty ceramic coffee cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly raise her right hand to drag a pen across paper before letting it fall to the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309616982936859 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680960655212402 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309616982936859, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309616982936859, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33878427743911743, + 0.15232206881046295, + 0.10281853377819061, + 0.05542195960879326, + 0.06594325602054596, + 0.023787178099155426, + 0.0316338874399662, + 0.07126065343618393, + 0.05400813743472099, + 0.10402011126279831 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309616982936859 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a woman in her twenties with messy dark brown hair in a loose bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple, oversized charcoal-gray sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a solitary metal desk lamp casting warm yellow light against a near-total dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the desk cluttered with scattered papers, an open idle laptop, and a half-empty ceramic coffee cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly raise her right hand to drag a pen across paper before letting it fall to the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0008151783840730786 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.125815391540527 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0008151783840730786, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0008151783840730786, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24788981676101685, + 0.14012399315834045, + 0.08278165757656097, + 0.06744872033596039, + 0.05577343329787254, + 0.034270454198122025, + 0.037215836346149445, + 0.07491523027420044, + 0.11839412897825241, + 0.14118674397468567 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0008151783840730786 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a woman in her twenties with messy dark brown hair in a loose bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple, oversized charcoal-gray sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a solitary metal desk lamp casting warm yellow light against a near-total dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the desk cluttered with scattered papers, an open idle laptop, and a half-empty ceramic coffee cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly raise her right hand to drag a pen across paper before letting it fall to the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048668064177036285 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048668146133423 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048668064177036285, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048668064177036285, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24925114214420319, + 0.183030903339386, + 0.07067503035068512, + 0.04934815689921379, + 0.0511200986802578, + 0.028432223945856094, + 0.024640172719955444, + 0.03574167937040329, + 0.09697113931179047, + 0.2107895463705063 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048668064177036285 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a woman in her twenties with messy dark brown hair in a loose bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple, oversized charcoal-gray sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a solitary metal desk lamp casting warm yellow light against a near-total dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the desk cluttered with scattered papers, an open idle laptop, and a half-empty ceramic coffee cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly raise her right hand to drag a pen across paper before letting it fall to the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897523045539856 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578975200653076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897523045539856, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897523045539856, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11974163353443146, + 0.036915089935064316, + 0.04940822720527649, + 0.09578847140073776, + 0.058786842972040176, + 0.07067756354808807, + 0.055787861347198486, + 0.05586422607302666, + 0.06308218836784363, + 0.39394789934158325 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897523045539856 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot depicts a weary figure slumped over a cluttered wooden desk. The subject, a woman in her twenties, has messy dark brown hair pulled back in a loose, untidy bun, her weary head resting on the palm of her left hand. Her face is pale and drawn, outlined by deep, shadowy hollows beneath her eyes. She wears a simple, oversized charcoal-gray sweatshirt, the soft fabric wrinkled. The desk is a chaotic scene of overwork, littered with scattered papers, an open but idle laptop casting a faint, cool glow, and a half-empty ceramic coffee cup. The scene is plunged into near-total darkness, penetrated only by the solitary, harsh glow of an adjustable metal desk lamp, which casts a focused beam of warm yellow light onto her and the workspace before her. This dramatic chiaroscuro lighting sculpts her exhausted features and creates deep, cavernous shadows that engulf the background. Slowly and heavily, she raises her right hand, her fingers barely grasping the pen, trying to drag it across a sheet of paper, but the movement is heavy and unsuccessful, and finally her hand falls to the table with a soft thud that perfectly captures an oppressive atmosphere of isolation and mental fatigue.", + "seed": 12556, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_8/index_3891_seed_12556_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.051486498094163835, + "vlm_logprob": -0.051486498094163835, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.051486498094163835, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a woman in her twenties with messy dark brown hair in a loose bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple, oversized charcoal-gray sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a solitary metal desk lamp casting warm yellow light against a near-total dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the desk cluttered with scattered papers, an open idle laptop, and a half-empty ceramic coffee cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly raise her right hand to drag a pen across paper before letting it fall to the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16277752816677094 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9127775430679321 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16277752816677094, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16277752816677094, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13221682608127594, + 0.05450933054089546, + 0.03816058114171028, + 0.045077238231897354, + 0.031610339879989624, + 0.021039243787527084, + 0.020173916593194008, + 0.3014895021915436, + 0.14448410272598267, + 0.21123898029327393 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16277752816677094 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a woman in her twenties with messy dark brown hair in a loose bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple, oversized charcoal-gray sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a solitary metal desk lamp casting warm yellow light against a near-total dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the desk cluttered with scattered papers, an open idle laptop, and a half-empty ceramic coffee cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly raise her right hand to drag a pen across paper before letting it fall to the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029821347445249557 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298213958740234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029821347445249557, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029821347445249557, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27392295002937317, + 0.06019917130470276, + 0.03744089603424072, + 0.059036657214164734, + 0.010998605750501156, + 0.025463489815592766, + 0.00715658301487565, + 0.24020250141620636, + 0.07456517964601517, + 0.2110140472650528 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029821347445249557 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a woman in her twenties with messy dark brown hair in a loose bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple, oversized charcoal-gray sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a solitary metal desk lamp casting warm yellow light against a near-total dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the desk cluttered with scattered papers, an open idle laptop, and a half-empty ceramic coffee cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly raise her right hand to drag a pen across paper before letting it fall to the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0013384203193709254 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.626338481903076 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0013384203193709254, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0013384203193709254, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2078534960746765, + 0.18899984657764435, + 0.09439380466938019, + 0.05415504798293114, + 0.011785535141825676, + 0.06633134931325912, + 0.024100186303257942, + 0.2187166064977646, + 0.0460762158036232, + 0.08758794516324997 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0013384203193709254 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a woman in her twenties with messy dark brown hair in a loose bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple, oversized charcoal-gray sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a solitary metal desk lamp casting warm yellow light against a near-total dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the desk cluttered with scattered papers, an open idle laptop, and a half-empty ceramic coffee cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly raise her right hand to drag a pen across paper before letting it fall to the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029808850958943367 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529808759689331 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029808850958943367, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029808850958943367, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16649466753005981, + 0.06499916315078735, + 0.03645223379135132, + 0.0786689892411232, + 0.010007813572883606, + 0.011394653469324112, + 0.007044382393360138, + 0.41376757621765137, + 0.048231083899736404, + 0.1629394292831421 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029808850958943367 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a woman in her twenties with messy dark brown hair in a loose bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple, oversized charcoal-gray sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a solitary metal desk lamp casting warm yellow light against a near-total dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the desk cluttered with scattered papers, an open idle laptop, and a half-empty ceramic coffee cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly raise her right hand to drag a pen across paper before letting it fall to the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03368634358048439 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408686399459839 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03368634358048439, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03368634358048439, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11660207808017731, + 0.05086825042963028, + 0.1015581414103508, + 0.02980824001133442, + 0.030578846111893654, + 0.03883281722664833, + 0.008909161202609539, + 0.1714581698179245, + 0.0346999391913414, + 0.4166843295097351 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03368634358048439 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, eye-level medium shot depicts a weary figure slumped over a cluttered wooden desk. The subject, a woman in her twenties, has messy dark brown hair pulled back in a loose, untidy bun, her weary head resting on the palm of her left hand. Her face is pale and drawn, outlined by deep, shadowy hollows beneath her eyes. She wears a simple, oversized charcoal-gray sweatshirt, the soft fabric wrinkled. The desk is a chaotic scene of overwork, littered with scattered papers, an open but idle laptop casting a faint, cool glow, and a half-empty ceramic coffee cup. The scene is plunged into near-total darkness, penetrated only by the solitary, harsh glow of an adjustable metal desk lamp, which casts a focused beam of warm yellow light onto her and the workspace before her. This dramatic chiaroscuro lighting sculpts her exhausted features and creates deep, cavernous shadows that engulf the background. Slowly and heavily, she raises her right hand, her fingers barely grasping the pen, trying to drag it across a sheet of paper, but the movement is heavy and unsuccessful, and finally her hand falls to the table with a soft thud that perfectly captures an oppressive atmosphere of isolation and mental fatigue.", + "seed": 12557, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_8/index_3891_seed_12557_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1677048838697374, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1677048838697374, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1677048838697374, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a woman in her twenties with messy dark brown hair in a loose bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple, oversized charcoal-gray sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a solitary metal desk lamp casting warm yellow light against a near-total dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the desk cluttered with scattered papers, an open idle laptop, and a half-empty ceramic coffee cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly raise her right hand to drag a pen across paper before letting it fall to the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47547030448913574 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9754703044891357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47547030448913574, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47547030448913574, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16338656842708588, + 0.06368936598300934, + 0.03183659911155701, + 0.031019484624266624, + 0.09350833296775818, + 0.09619880467653275, + 0.04858409985899925, + 0.03640385717153549, + 0.342481404542923, + 0.09289143234491348 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47547030448913574 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a woman in her twenties with messy dark brown hair in a loose bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple, oversized charcoal-gray sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a solitary metal desk lamp casting warm yellow light against a near-total dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the desk cluttered with scattered papers, an open idle laptop, and a half-empty ceramic coffee cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly raise her right hand to drag a pen across paper before letting it fall to the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08906792849302292 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640679359436035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08906792849302292, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08906792849302292, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.32798922061920166, + 0.04218624159693718, + 0.03302711993455887, + 0.03528814762830734, + 0.10514777153730392, + 0.037723198533058167, + 0.040850136429071426, + 0.041132040321826935, + 0.12198880314826965, + 0.21466730535030365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08906792849302292 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a woman in her twenties with messy dark brown hair in a loose bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple, oversized charcoal-gray sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a solitary metal desk lamp casting warm yellow light against a near-total dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the desk cluttered with scattered papers, an open idle laptop, and a half-empty ceramic coffee cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly raise her right hand to drag a pen across paper before letting it fall to the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004097993951290846 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504097938537598 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004097993951290846, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004097993951290846, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18672405183315277, + 0.08129698038101196, + 0.11547897756099701, + 0.09513906389474869, + 0.08936339616775513, + 0.2008647918701172, + 0.04666931927204132, + 0.01923564076423645, + 0.0938553512096405, + 0.07137240469455719 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004097993951290846 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a woman in her twenties with messy dark brown hair in a loose bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple, oversized charcoal-gray sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a solitary metal desk lamp casting warm yellow light against a near-total dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the desk cluttered with scattered papers, an open idle laptop, and a half-empty ceramic coffee cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly raise her right hand to drag a pen across paper before letting it fall to the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12708164751529694 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270816326141357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12708164751529694, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12708164751529694, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17126314342021942, + 0.055288974195718765, + 0.05007269233465195, + 0.03698526695370674, + 0.1205742135643959, + 0.1592189520597458, + 0.06652893871068954, + 0.03859905153512955, + 0.23914101719856262, + 0.062327660620212555 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12708164751529694 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the subject a woman in her twenties with messy dark brown hair in a loose bun?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a simple, oversized charcoal-gray sweatshirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the scene lit by a solitary metal desk lamp casting warm yellow light against a near-total dark background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the desk cluttered with scattered papers, an open idle laptop, and a half-empty ceramic coffee cup?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the woman slowly raise her right hand to drag a pen across paper before letting it fall to the table?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428065448999405 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178065299987793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428065448999405, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428065448999405, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24369892477989197, + 0.07653792947530746, + 0.043392546474933624, + 0.03308040648698807, + 0.08928880095481873, + 0.23355059325695038, + 0.04135338217020035, + 0.03926496207714081, + 0.15189802646636963, + 0.04793444275856018 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428065448999405 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_9/index_tensor([7448, 7448])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_9/index_tensor([7448, 7448])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..e640d02adb1faec4bafc734a4b4e8fccc84113fd --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_9/index_tensor([7448, 7448])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "shot shot from an extremely low angle, the camera slowly and steadily tilts upward, as if tracking the soaring trajectory of a mythical bird. The entire scene is imbued with the rich aesthetic of Chinese ink painting. Atop a vast, yellowed rice paper scroll imbued with classical charm, a mythical phoenix, its magnificent wings stretched with all its might, soaring toward the top of the scroll. Its form is outlined in fluid, powerful, burnt-ink lines, its long neck held high, its crest sharp as a brushstroke, its eyes solemn and spiritual. Its wings are the absolute focal point of the painting, each feather seemingly ablaze. Layers of mineral pigments, including cinnabar, crimson, and brilliant gold, blend naturally onto the rice paper, creating a texture both fiery and translucent. The white-washed brushstrokes add an unparalleled sense of movement. Slender tail feathers flow behind it like wild cursive calligraphy, the ink fading from thick to light, blending seamlessly with the light, inky mist in the background. The background is a piece of rice paper with a slightly beige texture and a large amount of white space. In the distance, only a few hazy mountain outlines are rubbed with minimalist light ink, creating an infinite and profound sense of space. The whole scene shows magnificent vitality in the static painting, creating a sacred, solemn and magnificent atmosphere full of oriental mythological power.", + "seed": 29427, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_9/index_7448_seed_29427_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.09191515631973743, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09191515631973743, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.375, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09191515631973743, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented as a Chinese ink painting on a yellowed rice paper scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical phoenix visible with its wings stretched wide and soaring upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's features outlined in fluid, powerful burnt-ink lines with cinnabar, crimson, and gold pigments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature hazy mountain outlines in light ink with a large amount of white space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extremely low angle and slowly tilt upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015025767497718334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.265025615692139 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015025767497718334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015025767497718334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08796737343072891, + 0.1351201981306076, + 0.12617117166519165, + 0.10294734686613083, + 0.0911908894777298, + 0.12234161049127579, + 0.17091500759124756, + 0.10719621181488037, + 0.02616513893008232, + 0.029985062777996063 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015025767497718334 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented as a Chinese ink painting on a yellowed rice paper scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical phoenix visible with its wings stretched wide and soaring upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's features outlined in fluid, powerful burnt-ink lines with cinnabar, crimson, and gold pigments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature hazy mountain outlines in light ink with a large amount of white space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extremely low angle and slowly tilt upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07005004584789276 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695050001144409 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07005004584789276, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07005004584789276, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10642515867948532, + 0.26881155371665955, + 0.034632183611392975, + 0.20011667907238007, + 0.06314277648925781, + 0.1337030678987503, + 0.05368573218584061, + 0.07202348858118057, + 0.03815643861889839, + 0.029302973300218582 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07005004584789276 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented as a Chinese ink painting on a yellowed rice paper scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical phoenix visible with its wings stretched wide and soaring upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's features outlined in fluid, powerful burnt-ink lines with cinnabar, crimson, and gold pigments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature hazy mountain outlines in light ink with a large amount of white space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extremely low angle and slowly tilt upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020626800134778023 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956267833709717 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020626800134778023, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020626800134778023, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19031159579753876, + 0.08034604042768478, + 0.19128535687923431, + 0.1215718612074852, + 0.08976844698190689, + 0.11772669851779938, + 0.06143064424395561, + 0.05770818889141083, + 0.0647929459810257, + 0.025058254599571228 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020626800134778023 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented as a Chinese ink painting on a yellowed rice paper scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical phoenix visible with its wings stretched wide and soaring upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's features outlined in fluid, powerful burnt-ink lines with cinnabar, crimson, and gold pigments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature hazy mountain outlines in light ink with a large amount of white space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extremely low angle and slowly tilt upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005253438837826252 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255253314971924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005253438837826252, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005253438837826252, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08333276212215424, + 0.17968644201755524, + 0.31996992230415344, + 0.10663297772407532, + 0.09224367141723633, + 0.08019024133682251, + 0.03225962072610855, + 0.04380350932478905, + 0.03331374377012253, + 0.0285671204328537 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005253438837826252 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented as a Chinese ink painting on a yellowed rice paper scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical phoenix visible with its wings stretched wide and soaring upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's features outlined in fluid, powerful burnt-ink lines with cinnabar, crimson, and gold pigments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature hazy mountain outlines in light ink with a large amount of white space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extremely low angle and slowly tilt upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486197292804718 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236196994781494 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486197292804718, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486197292804718, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23563747107982635, + 0.24941180646419525, + 0.18647325038909912, + 0.10840689390897751, + 0.04571639001369476, + 0.05287035182118416, + 0.035619787871837616, + 0.0545918270945549, + 0.012471350841224194, + 0.018800949677824974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486197292804718 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shot shot from an extremely low angle, the camera slowly and steadily tilts upward, as if tracking the soaring trajectory of a mythical bird. The entire scene is imbued with the rich aesthetic of Chinese ink painting. Atop a vast, yellowed rice paper scroll imbued with classical charm, a mythical phoenix, its magnificent wings stretched with all its might, soaring toward the top of the scroll. Its form is outlined in fluid, powerful, burnt-ink lines, its long neck held high, its crest sharp as a brushstroke, its eyes solemn and spiritual. Its wings are the absolute focal point of the painting, each feather seemingly ablaze. Layers of mineral pigments, including cinnabar, crimson, and brilliant gold, blend naturally onto the rice paper, creating a texture both fiery and translucent. The white-washed brushstrokes add an unparalleled sense of movement. Slender tail feathers flow behind it like wild cursive calligraphy, the ink fading from thick to light, blending seamlessly with the light, inky mist in the background. The background is a piece of rice paper with a slightly beige texture and a large amount of white space. In the distance, only a few hazy mountain outlines are rubbed with minimalist light ink, creating an infinite and profound sense of space. The whole scene shows magnificent vitality in the static painting, creating a sacred, solemn and magnificent atmosphere full of oriental mythological power.", + "seed": 29428, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_9/index_7448_seed_29428_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07444989113137127, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07444989113137127, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.475000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07444989113137127, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented as a Chinese ink painting on a yellowed rice paper scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical phoenix visible with its wings stretched wide and soaring upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's features outlined in fluid, powerful burnt-ink lines with cinnabar, crimson, and gold pigments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature hazy mountain outlines in light ink with a large amount of white space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extremely low angle and slowly tilt upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012010401114821434 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51201057434082 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012010401114821434, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012010401114821434, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07020342350006104, + 0.1120164766907692, + 0.04331263527274132, + 0.034223947674036026, + 0.0544152669608593, + 0.15912684798240662, + 0.25153452157974243, + 0.16776442527770996, + 0.06617607176303864, + 0.041226424276828766 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012010401114821434 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented as a Chinese ink painting on a yellowed rice paper scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical phoenix visible with its wings stretched wide and soaring upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's features outlined in fluid, powerful burnt-ink lines with cinnabar, crimson, and gold pigments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature hazy mountain outlines in light ink with a large amount of white space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extremely low angle and slowly tilt upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017239484004676342 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376723766326904 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017239484004676342, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017239484004676342, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03802389279007912, + 0.10269005596637726, + 0.08302329480648041, + 0.10627900063991547, + 0.21036586165428162, + 0.1714656800031662, + 0.047199420630931854, + 0.03714151680469513, + 0.058006756007671356, + 0.14580455422401428 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017239484004676342 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented as a Chinese ink painting on a yellowed rice paper scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical phoenix visible with its wings stretched wide and soaring upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's features outlined in fluid, powerful burnt-ink lines with cinnabar, crimson, and gold pigments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature hazy mountain outlines in light ink with a large amount of white space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extremely low angle and slowly tilt upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004653457552194595 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379653453826904 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004653457552194595, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004653457552194595, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15659889578819275, + 0.08736124634742737, + 0.07433627545833588, + 0.04844503849744797, + 0.19314727187156677, + 0.10626246780157089, + 0.091459721326828, + 0.09700393676757812, + 0.06814459711313248, + 0.07724052667617798 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004653457552194595 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented as a Chinese ink painting on a yellowed rice paper scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical phoenix visible with its wings stretched wide and soaring upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's features outlined in fluid, powerful burnt-ink lines with cinnabar, crimson, and gold pigments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature hazy mountain outlines in light ink with a large amount of white space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extremely low angle and slowly tilt upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005250830203294754 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255250930786133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005250830203294754, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005250830203294754, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1223919466137886, + 0.08798860013484955, + 0.1224081814289093, + 0.10394290089607239, + 0.12374711781740189, + 0.08252859860658646, + 0.09785722196102142, + 0.06186671927571297, + 0.05632568523287773, + 0.14094309508800507 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005250830203294754 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented as a Chinese ink painting on a yellowed rice paper scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical phoenix visible with its wings stretched wide and soaring upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's features outlined in fluid, powerful burnt-ink lines with cinnabar, crimson, and gold pigments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature hazy mountain outlines in light ink with a large amount of white space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extremely low angle and slowly tilt upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3486108183860779 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236108779907227 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3486108183860779, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.8750000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3486108183860779, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05347645655274391, + 0.07954656332731247, + 0.06070316582918167, + 0.06005723401904106, + 0.0810696929693222, + 0.08897250145673752, + 0.09214133769273758, + 0.103558748960495, + 0.1129898652434349, + 0.2674843668937683 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3486108183860779 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shot shot from an extremely low angle, the camera slowly and steadily tilts upward, as if tracking the soaring trajectory of a mythical bird. The entire scene is imbued with the rich aesthetic of Chinese ink painting. Atop a vast, yellowed rice paper scroll imbued with classical charm, a mythical phoenix, its magnificent wings stretched with all its might, soaring toward the top of the scroll. Its form is outlined in fluid, powerful, burnt-ink lines, its long neck held high, its crest sharp as a brushstroke, its eyes solemn and spiritual. Its wings are the absolute focal point of the painting, each feather seemingly ablaze. Layers of mineral pigments, including cinnabar, crimson, and brilliant gold, blend naturally onto the rice paper, creating a texture both fiery and translucent. The white-washed brushstrokes add an unparalleled sense of movement. Slender tail feathers flow behind it like wild cursive calligraphy, the ink fading from thick to light, blending seamlessly with the light, inky mist in the background. The background is a piece of rice paper with a slightly beige texture and a large amount of white space. In the distance, only a few hazy mountain outlines are rubbed with minimalist light ink, creating an infinite and profound sense of space. The whole scene shows magnificent vitality in the static painting, creating a sacred, solemn and magnificent atmosphere full of oriental mythological power.", + "seed": 29429, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_9/index_7448_seed_29429_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.07128415862098336, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07128415862098336, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.574999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07128415862098336, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented as a Chinese ink painting on a yellowed rice paper scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical phoenix visible with its wings stretched wide and soaring upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's features outlined in fluid, powerful burnt-ink lines with cinnabar, crimson, and gold pigments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature hazy mountain outlines in light ink with a large amount of white space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extremely low angle and slowly tilt upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.019122768193483353 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.01912260055542 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.019122768193483353, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.019122768193483353, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2163780778646469, + 0.08160265535116196, + 0.12610387802124023, + 0.19050486385822296, + 0.24340888857841492, + 0.021605439484119415, + 0.04302692413330078, + 0.017887156456708908, + 0.03337123617529869, + 0.0261108186095953 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.019122768193483353 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented as a Chinese ink painting on a yellowed rice paper scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical phoenix visible with its wings stretched wide and soaring upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's features outlined in fluid, powerful burnt-ink lines with cinnabar, crimson, and gold pigments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature hazy mountain outlines in light ink with a large amount of white space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extremely low angle and slowly tilt upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011093487031757832 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511093616485596 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011093487031757832, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011093487031757832, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07084643095731735, + 0.051644112914800644, + 0.06677983701229095, + 0.25263863801956177, + 0.2909046411514282, + 0.1073840856552124, + 0.04294441640377045, + 0.06526326388120651, + 0.031062137335538864, + 0.020532449707388878 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011093487031757832 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented as a Chinese ink painting on a yellowed rice paper scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical phoenix visible with its wings stretched wide and soaring upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's features outlined in fluid, powerful burnt-ink lines with cinnabar, crimson, and gold pigments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature hazy mountain outlines in light ink with a large amount of white space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extremely low angle and slowly tilt upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03815260902047157 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881526947021484 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03815260902047157, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03815260902047157, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.47531142830848694, + 0.05219697207212448, + 0.11731843650341034, + 0.09288141131401062, + 0.11646246910095215, + 0.02263937145471573, + 0.025810588151216507, + 0.031805045902729034, + 0.030010825023055077, + 0.03556350991129875 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03815260902047157 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented as a Chinese ink painting on a yellowed rice paper scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical phoenix visible with its wings stretched wide and soaring upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's features outlined in fluid, powerful burnt-ink lines with cinnabar, crimson, and gold pigments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature hazy mountain outlines in light ink with a large amount of white space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extremely low angle and slowly tilt upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006736780982464552 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006736755371094 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006736780982464552, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006736780982464552, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2520809769630432, + 0.10249289125204086, + 0.19967515766620636, + 0.1362033635377884, + 0.16571596264839172, + 0.06803722679615021, + 0.03165564686059952, + 0.012945697642862797, + 0.017837317660450935, + 0.013355807401239872 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006736780982464552 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented as a Chinese ink painting on a yellowed rice paper scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical phoenix visible with its wings stretched wide and soaring upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's features outlined in fluid, powerful burnt-ink lines with cinnabar, crimson, and gold pigments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature hazy mountain outlines in light ink with a large amount of white space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extremely low angle and slowly tilt upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2813151478767395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4063150882720947 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2813151478767395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2813151478767395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12209701538085938, + 0.07989251613616943, + 0.14400255680084229, + 0.3746304512023926, + 0.13452382385730743, + 0.06240169703960419, + 0.03282250836491585, + 0.024514872580766678, + 0.011527071706950665, + 0.013587530702352524 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2813151478767395 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shot shot from an extremely low angle, the camera slowly and steadily tilts upward, as if tracking the soaring trajectory of a mythical bird. The entire scene is imbued with the rich aesthetic of Chinese ink painting. Atop a vast, yellowed rice paper scroll imbued with classical charm, a mythical phoenix, its magnificent wings stretched with all its might, soaring toward the top of the scroll. Its form is outlined in fluid, powerful, burnt-ink lines, its long neck held high, its crest sharp as a brushstroke, its eyes solemn and spiritual. Its wings are the absolute focal point of the painting, each feather seemingly ablaze. Layers of mineral pigments, including cinnabar, crimson, and brilliant gold, blend naturally onto the rice paper, creating a texture both fiery and translucent. The white-washed brushstrokes add an unparalleled sense of movement. Slender tail feathers flow behind it like wild cursive calligraphy, the ink fading from thick to light, blending seamlessly with the light, inky mist in the background. The background is a piece of rice paper with a slightly beige texture and a large amount of white space. In the distance, only a few hazy mountain outlines are rubbed with minimalist light ink, creating an infinite and profound sense of space. The whole scene shows magnificent vitality in the static painting, creating a sacred, solemn and magnificent atmosphere full of oriental mythological power.", + "seed": 29430, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000295/group_9/index_7448_seed_29430_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.10350988316349685, + "vlm_logprob": -0.10350988316349685, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.10350988316349685, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented as a Chinese ink painting on a yellowed rice paper scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical phoenix visible with its wings stretched wide and soaring upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's features outlined in fluid, powerful burnt-ink lines with cinnabar, crimson, and gold pigments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature hazy mountain outlines in light ink with a large amount of white space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extremely low angle and slowly tilt upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.017399759963154793 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.142399787902832 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.017399759963154793, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.017399759963154793, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19102567434310913, + 0.4171680212020874, + 0.08245576173067093, + 0.10740064084529877, + 0.041379887610673904, + 0.02556374855339527, + 0.0511905699968338, + 0.025959456339478493, + 0.03259381279349327, + 0.025262370705604553 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.017399759963154793 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented as a Chinese ink painting on a yellowed rice paper scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical phoenix visible with its wings stretched wide and soaring upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's features outlined in fluid, powerful burnt-ink lines with cinnabar, crimson, and gold pigments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature hazy mountain outlines in light ink with a large amount of white space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extremely low angle and slowly tilt upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002204370917752385 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127204418182373 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002204370917752385, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002204370917752385, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10229675471782684, + 0.44835636019706726, + 0.07694128900766373, + 0.1427876204252243, + 0.05011387914419174, + 0.035192955285310745, + 0.045343298465013504, + 0.0647357627749443, + 0.016548138111829758, + 0.017683926969766617 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002204370917752385 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented as a Chinese ink painting on a yellowed rice paper scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical phoenix visible with its wings stretched wide and soaring upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's features outlined in fluid, powerful burnt-ink lines with cinnabar, crimson, and gold pigments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature hazy mountain outlines in light ink with a large amount of white space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extremely low angle and slowly tilt upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00764421047642827 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882644176483154 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00764421047642827, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00764421047642827, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07486184686422348, + 0.674069881439209, + 0.02001260407269001, + 0.05070970579981804, + 0.026601718738675117, + 0.017038628458976746, + 0.0270247720181942, + 0.04701685532927513, + 0.03327406942844391, + 0.0293900053948164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00764421047642827 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented as a Chinese ink painting on a yellowed rice paper scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical phoenix visible with its wings stretched wide and soaring upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's features outlined in fluid, powerful burnt-ink lines with cinnabar, crimson, and gold pigments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature hazy mountain outlines in light ink with a large amount of white space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extremely low angle and slowly tilt upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016062619164586067 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410627365112305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016062619164586067, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016062619164586067, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1752343773841858, + 0.367391973733902, + 0.17296543717384338, + 0.08062930405139923, + 0.07124516367912292, + 0.04130079224705696, + 0.03191820904612541, + 0.0172125194221735, + 0.028020888566970825, + 0.014081394299864769 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016062619164586067 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene presented as a Chinese ink painting on a yellowed rice paper scroll?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a mythical phoenix visible with its wings stretched wide and soaring upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Are the phoenix's features outlined in fluid, powerful burnt-ink lines with cinnabar, crimson, and gold pigments?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the background feature hazy mountain outlines in light ink with a large amount of white space?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start at an extremely low angle and slowly tilt upward?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47423845529556274 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742384552955627 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47423845529556274, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47423845529556274, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11949143558740616, + 0.28524351119995117, + 0.042589884251356125, + 0.22048161923885345, + 0.06096629425883293, + 0.033758167177438736, + 0.08175572007894516, + 0.07160744071006775, + 0.07788091152906418, + 0.0062250737100839615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47423845529556274 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_0/index_tensor([9447, 9447])_group_0_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_0/index_tensor([9447, 9447])_group_0_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f65778c02151440e639e1183b16e19041370bfe7 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_0/index_tensor([9447, 9447])_group_0_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, medium close-up shot at eye level depicts an elderly couple, their faces a beautiful reflection of a lifetime together, deep smile lines etched around their eyes and mouths. The man, with a wisp of silvery hair, wears a soft, beige knit cardigan over a simple white shirt. He gently holds his wife, his hand firmly resting on her back. Her soft, white hair is pulled back loosely as she contentedly rests her head on his shoulder, eyes closed, a state of tranquil bliss. Her hand, adorned with a simple wedding ring, rests gently on his chest. They stand in a lush, sun-dappled garden, with blurred pink and yellow rose bushes creating a soft, painterly bokeh in the background. The entire scene is bathed in the soft, warm golden light of the afternoon sun, which filters through the leaves, casting a soft, hazy glow that illuminates their wrinkled skin and soft woolen clothing, creating an atmosphere of profound peace, contentment, and everlasting love.", + "seed": 29206, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_0/index_9447_seed_29206_dp_0_rank_0_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.010380054917186498, + "vlm_logprob": -0.010380054917186498, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.010380054917186498, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects an elderly man and an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a beige knit cardigan over a white shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white top and has her white hair pulled back loosely?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding the woman with his hand resting on her back while she rests her head on his shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lush garden with blurred pink and yellow rose bushes creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014819419011473656 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264819622039795 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014819419011473656, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014819419011473656, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27533575892448425, + 0.15444253385066986, + 0.023118672892451286, + 0.06442242860794067, + 0.07146797329187393, + 0.06088375672698021, + 0.11271396279335022, + 0.021029334515333176, + 0.07912289351224899, + 0.13746267557144165 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014819419011473656 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects an elderly man and an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a beige knit cardigan over a white shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white top and has her white hair pulled back loosely?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding the woman with his hand resting on her back while she rests her head on his shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lush garden with blurred pink and yellow rose bushes creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005278222728520632 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.25527811050415 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005278222728520632, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005278222728520632, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1560794711112976, + 0.16821156442165375, + 0.08071228116750717, + 0.0953744575381279, + 0.12460637092590332, + 0.05397617071866989, + 0.0490674190223217, + 0.051658809185028076, + 0.029556769877672195, + 0.19075670838356018 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005278222728520632 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects an elderly man and an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a beige knit cardigan over a white shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white top and has her white hair pulled back loosely?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding the woman with his hand resting on her back while she rests her head on his shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lush garden with blurred pink and yellow rose bushes creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005956043489277363 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130956172943115 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005956043489277363, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005956043489277363, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26197078824043274, + 0.07657115161418915, + 0.08557015657424927, + 0.03458879515528679, + 0.06410384178161621, + 0.13618101179599762, + 0.030816949903964996, + 0.02832614816725254, + 0.044199138879776, + 0.23767200112342834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005956043489277363 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects an elderly man and an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a beige knit cardigan over a white shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white top and has her white hair pulled back loosely?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding the woman with his hand resting on her back while she rests her head on his shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lush garden with blurred pink and yellow rose bushes creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606813259422779 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141067981719971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606813259422779, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606813259422779, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1327219009399414, + 0.21779406070709229, + 0.08237249404191971, + 0.08984474092721939, + 0.05759846046566963, + 0.059047192335128784, + 0.04545455798506737, + 0.08693936467170715, + 0.07886999845504761, + 0.14935711026191711 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606813259422779 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects an elderly man and an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a beige knit cardigan over a white shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white top and has her white hair pulled back loosely?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding the woman with his hand resting on her back while she rests her head on his shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lush garden with blurred pink and yellow rose bushes creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009778456762433052 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.6347784996032715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009778456762433052, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009778456762433052, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3057060241699219, + 0.05366561561822891, + 0.09070076048374176, + 0.09857593476772308, + 0.17706362903118134, + 0.11101536452770233, + 0.051316678524017334, + 0.02524534985423088, + 0.028177527710795403, + 0.058533087372779846 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009778456762433052 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, medium close-up shot at eye level depicts an elderly couple, their faces a beautiful reflection of a lifetime together, deep smile lines etched around their eyes and mouths. The man, with a wisp of silvery hair, wears a soft, beige knit cardigan over a simple white shirt. He gently holds his wife, his hand firmly resting on her back. Her soft, white hair is pulled back loosely as she contentedly rests her head on his shoulder, eyes closed, a state of tranquil bliss. Her hand, adorned with a simple wedding ring, rests gently on his chest. They stand in a lush, sun-dappled garden, with blurred pink and yellow rose bushes creating a soft, painterly bokeh in the background. The entire scene is bathed in the soft, warm golden light of the afternoon sun, which filters through the leaves, casting a soft, hazy glow that illuminates their wrinkled skin and soft woolen clothing, creating an atmosphere of profound peace, contentment, and everlasting love.", + "seed": 29207, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_0/index_9447_seed_29207_dp_0_rank_0_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.035999628715217113, + "vlm_logprob": -0.035999628715217113, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.149999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.035999628715217113, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects an elderly man and an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a beige knit cardigan over a white shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white top and has her white hair pulled back loosely?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding the woman with his hand resting on her back while she rests her head on his shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lush garden with blurred pink and yellow rose bushes creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14398109912872314 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0189809799194336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14398109912872314, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14398109912872314, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08042296767234802, + 0.030663928017020226, + 0.11957843601703644, + 0.109881691634655, + 0.16725461184978485, + 0.08969495445489883, + 0.02929512783885002, + 0.06809069216251373, + 0.23674163222312927, + 0.06837598234415054 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14398109912872314 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects an elderly man and an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a beige knit cardigan over a white shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white top and has her white hair pulled back loosely?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding the woman with his hand resting on her back while she rests her head on his shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lush garden with blurred pink and yellow rose bushes creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011104687117040157 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511104583740234 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011104687117040157, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011104687117040157, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08996348828077316, + 0.04002774506807327, + 0.0344245582818985, + 0.06338772177696228, + 0.07607576251029968, + 0.056924015283584595, + 0.06778325140476227, + 0.1566266119480133, + 0.10339047014713287, + 0.31139639019966125 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011104687117040157 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects an elderly man and an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a beige knit cardigan over a white shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white top and has her white hair pulled back loosely?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding the woman with his hand resting on her back while she rests her head on his shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lush garden with blurred pink and yellow rose bushes creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008650686591863632 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758650779724121 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008650686591863632, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008650686591863632, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18083468079566956, + 0.06498595327138901, + 0.09546150267124176, + 0.04172401875257492, + 0.0767446905374527, + 0.12582840025424957, + 0.03256463631987572, + 0.027829721570014954, + 0.17288602888584137, + 0.18114031851291656 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008650686591863632 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects an elderly man and an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a beige knit cardigan over a white shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white top and has her white hair pulled back loosely?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding the woman with his hand resting on her back while she rests her head on his shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lush garden with blurred pink and yellow rose bushes creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0076280031353235245 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882627964019775 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0076280031353235245, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0076280031353235245, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10205575823783875, + 0.05151427909731865, + 0.06179959326982498, + 0.13582761585712433, + 0.23525306582450867, + 0.06558212637901306, + 0.0445641465485096, + 0.06687217950820923, + 0.14299358427524567, + 0.09353760629892349 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0076280031353235245 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects an elderly man and an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a beige knit cardigan over a white shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white top and has her white hair pulled back loosely?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding the woman with his hand resting on her back while she rests her head on his shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lush garden with blurred pink and yellow rose bushes creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008633667603135109 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758633613586426 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008633667603135109, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008633667603135109, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16033804416656494, + 0.06919898837804794, + 0.08893848210573196, + 0.04940714314579964, + 0.07600214332342148, + 0.1669374704360962, + 0.058308299630880356, + 0.02487429976463318, + 0.09486385434865952, + 0.21113121509552002 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008633667603135109 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, medium close-up shot at eye level depicts an elderly couple, their faces a beautiful reflection of a lifetime together, deep smile lines etched around their eyes and mouths. The man, with a wisp of silvery hair, wears a soft, beige knit cardigan over a simple white shirt. He gently holds his wife, his hand firmly resting on her back. Her soft, white hair is pulled back loosely as she contentedly rests her head on his shoulder, eyes closed, a state of tranquil bliss. Her hand, adorned with a simple wedding ring, rests gently on his chest. They stand in a lush, sun-dappled garden, with blurred pink and yellow rose bushes creating a soft, painterly bokeh in the background. The entire scene is bathed in the soft, warm golden light of the afternoon sun, which filters through the leaves, casting a soft, hazy glow that illuminates their wrinkled skin and soft woolen clothing, creating an atmosphere of profound peace, contentment, and everlasting love.", + "seed": 29208, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_0/index_9447_seed_29208_dp_1_rank_2_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.012030598055571318, + "vlm_logprob": -0.012030598055571318, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.012030598055571318, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects an elderly man and an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a beige knit cardigan over a white shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white top and has her white hair pulled back loosely?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding the woman with his hand resting on her back while she rests her head on his shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lush garden with blurred pink and yellow rose bushes creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026717793196439743 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6517179012298584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026717793196439743, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026717793196439743, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4128626585006714, + 0.07938982546329498, + 0.08071710169315338, + 0.05631966143846512, + 0.09751375019550323, + 0.057480525225400925, + 0.03984601050615311, + 0.0319843627512455, + 0.07372378557920456, + 0.07016231119632721 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026717793196439743 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects an elderly man and an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a beige knit cardigan over a white shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white top and has her white hair pulled back loosely?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding the woman with his hand resting on her back while she rests her head on his shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lush garden with blurred pink and yellow rose bushes creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005968011915683746 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.13096809387207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005968011915683746, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005968011915683746, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33268821239471436, + 0.2061464488506317, + 0.032614562660455704, + 0.040776029229164124, + 0.08195193856954575, + 0.05686471238732338, + 0.03314760699868202, + 0.02300809696316719, + 0.035447608679533005, + 0.15735474228858948 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005968011915683746 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects an elderly man and an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a beige knit cardigan over a white shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white top and has her white hair pulled back loosely?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding the woman with his hand resting on her back while she rests her head on his shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lush garden with blurred pink and yellow rose bushes creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004643846768885851 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.37964391708374 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004643846768885851, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004643846768885851, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3352082669734955, + 0.14574626088142395, + 0.06036707013845444, + 0.07358244806528091, + 0.11002691835165024, + 0.07848142832517624, + 0.03572983294725418, + 0.02054821141064167, + 0.062177225947380066, + 0.07813238352537155 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004643846768885851 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects an elderly man and an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a beige knit cardigan over a white shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white top and has her white hair pulled back loosely?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding the woman with his hand resting on her back while she rests her head on his shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lush garden with blurred pink and yellow rose bushes creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008635913021862507 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758635997772217 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008635913021862507, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008635913021862507, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22381983697414398, + 0.22382931411266327, + 0.06275790184736252, + 0.15242019295692444, + 0.10736766457557678, + 0.04258497804403305, + 0.024015871807932854, + 0.027263859286904335, + 0.04530381038784981, + 0.09063662588596344 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008635913021862507 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects an elderly man and an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a beige knit cardigan over a white shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white top and has her white hair pulled back loosely?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding the woman with his hand resting on her back while she rests her head on his shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lush garden with blurred pink and yellow rose bushes creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014187425374984741 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264187335968018 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014187425374984741, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014187425374984741, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5592294931411743, + 0.032379377633333206, + 0.045038461685180664, + 0.11126276105642319, + 0.1286463588476181, + 0.049138143658638, + 0.010171648114919662, + 0.02337867021560669, + 0.016454916447401047, + 0.024300122633576393 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014187425374984741 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, medium close-up shot at eye level depicts an elderly couple, their faces a beautiful reflection of a lifetime together, deep smile lines etched around their eyes and mouths. The man, with a wisp of silvery hair, wears a soft, beige knit cardigan over a simple white shirt. He gently holds his wife, his hand firmly resting on her back. Her soft, white hair is pulled back loosely as she contentedly rests her head on his shoulder, eyes closed, a state of tranquil bliss. Her hand, adorned with a simple wedding ring, rests gently on his chest. They stand in a lush, sun-dappled garden, with blurred pink and yellow rose bushes creating a soft, painterly bokeh in the background. The entire scene is bathed in the soft, warm golden light of the afternoon sun, which filters through the leaves, casting a soft, hazy glow that illuminates their wrinkled skin and soft woolen clothing, creating an atmosphere of profound peace, contentment, and everlasting love.", + "seed": 29209, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_0/index_9447_seed_29209_dp_1_rank_2_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 0, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.026766897551715373, + "vlm_logprob": -0.026766897551715373, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.026766897551715373, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects an elderly man and an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a beige knit cardigan over a white shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white top and has her white hair pulled back loosely?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding the woman with his hand resting on her back while she rests her head on his shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lush garden with blurred pink and yellow rose bushes creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.09013114869594574 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4651310443878174 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.09013114869594574, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.09013114869594574, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.027387164533138275, + 0.011812221258878708, + 0.05253209173679352, + 0.1533249467611313, + 0.09446096420288086, + 0.04769349470734596, + 0.0978441834449768, + 0.07174258679151535, + 0.4307444989681244, + 0.012457829900085926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.09013114869594574 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects an elderly man and an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a beige knit cardigan over a white shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white top and has her white hair pulled back loosely?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding the woman with his hand resting on her back while she rests her head on his shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lush garden with blurred pink and yellow rose bushes creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009812572039663792 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634812355041504 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009812572039663792, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009812572039663792, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10033522546291351, + 0.03898046165704727, + 0.052467215806245804, + 0.16613729298114777, + 0.2852456867694855, + 0.05850647762417793, + 0.07009623199701309, + 0.07133204489946365, + 0.09065186232328415, + 0.06624753773212433 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009812572039663792 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects an elderly man and an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a beige knit cardigan over a white shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white top and has her white hair pulled back loosely?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding the woman with his hand resting on her back while she rests her head on his shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lush garden with blurred pink and yellow rose bushes creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006746964529156685 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006746768951416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006746964529156685, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006746964529156685, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07101035118103027, + 0.024327466264367104, + 0.040988437831401825, + 0.08432509005069733, + 0.4861774146556854, + 0.05404141545295715, + 0.07876988500356674, + 0.08430205285549164, + 0.04085835814476013, + 0.035199545323848724 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006746964529156685 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects an elderly man and an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a beige knit cardigan over a white shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white top and has her white hair pulled back loosely?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding the woman with his hand resting on her back while she rests her head on his shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lush garden with blurred pink and yellow rose bushes creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607118360698223 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141071319580078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607118360698223, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607118360698223, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15766692161560059, + 0.07845154404640198, + 0.09221307188272476, + 0.07245244830846786, + 0.14955468475818634, + 0.0922451764345169, + 0.07733377069234848, + 0.03919385001063347, + 0.1889612078666687, + 0.051927387714385986 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607118360698223 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Are the main subjects an elderly man and an elderly woman?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the man wearing a beige knit cardigan over a white shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing a white top and has her white hair pulled back loosely?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the man holding the woman with his hand resting on her back while she rests her head on his shoulder?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background a lush garden with blurred pink and yellow rose bushes creating a bokeh effect?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011072618886828423 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511072635650635 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011072618886828423, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011072618886828423, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1759169101715088, + 0.02284553460776806, + 0.045900847762823105, + 0.07876761257648468, + 0.43440741300582886, + 0.04027080535888672, + 0.026575492694973946, + 0.019093967974185944, + 0.11361882835626602, + 0.042602647095918655 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011072618886828423 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_1/index_tensor([5349, 5349])_group_1_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_1/index_tensor([5349, 5349])_group_1_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f5fa65132e489d9bdcda356f8cc73fdb3bfcadfa --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_1/index_tensor([5349, 5349])_group_1_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "In a stunning close-up shot, employing a cinematic shallow depth of field, the camera inched forward at an almost imperceptible pace, focusing on the long-sealed face of the Monkey King. He clad himself in a magnificent golden mail armor intricately carved with dragons and auspicious cloud patterns, and crowned with his signature phoenix-winged purple-gold crown. Fine dust accumulated between the crevices of the armor and the crown, yet in the dramatic, shimmering light slanting down from above, it still reflected a deep, rich metallic luster. The gloomy cavernous background was completely blurred, with only the dust particles floating in the air clearly visible in the light. His tightly closed eyelids began to tremble slightly, as if bearing the weight of millennia. With incredibly slow and determined precision, they lifted upward, a sharp golden light emanating from the slits before finally opening fully, revealing a pair of fiery eyes burning with an unyielding flame, pupils as sharp as lightning. Their gaze was filled with the confusion of awakening, suppressed anger, and boundless majesty. The entire picture has a strong contrast between light and shadow, and the tones are solemn and brilliant, creating an epic and shocking awakening moment when a legendary hero finally wakes up after sleeping for thousands of years.", + "seed": 19217, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_1/index_5349_seed_19217_dp_2_rank_4_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.04661080604419112, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04661080604419112, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.475, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04661080604419112, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of the Monkey King's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy cavernous environment that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing golden mail armor with dragon and cloud patterns and a purple-gold phoenix-winged crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's eyelids tremble slightly before lifting upward to reveal fiery eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera inch forward at an almost imperceptible pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02576536312699318 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7757654190063477 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02576536312699318, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02576536312699318, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17655017971992493, + 0.030118456110358238, + 0.051375679671764374, + 0.17924310266971588, + 0.11166082322597504, + 0.1613083779811859, + 0.1406005322933197, + 0.036085255444049835, + 0.05781054124236107, + 0.05524706840515137 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02576536312699318 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of the Monkey King's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy cavernous environment that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing golden mail armor with dragon and cloud patterns and a purple-gold phoenix-winged crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's eyelids tremble slightly before lifting upward to reveal fiery eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera inch forward at an almost imperceptible pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02331090159714222 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773310899734497 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02331090159714222, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02331090159714222, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1929166615009308, + 0.15509533882141113, + 0.13281254470348358, + 0.15089303255081177, + 0.04488343745470047, + 0.09654366225004196, + 0.04157496243715286, + 0.05359206721186638, + 0.043216951191425323, + 0.08847131580114365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02331090159714222 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of the Monkey King's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy cavernous environment that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing golden mail armor with dragon and cloud patterns and a purple-gold phoenix-winged crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's eyelids tremble slightly before lifting upward to reveal fiery eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera inch forward at an almost imperceptible pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005948459263890982 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130948543548584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005948459263890982, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005948459263890982, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11648780107498169, + 0.05882298946380615, + 0.06724513322114944, + 0.07665207237005234, + 0.19529569149017334, + 0.12267547100782394, + 0.10137007385492325, + 0.15819025039672852, + 0.06039842590689659, + 0.04286203905940056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005948459263890982 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of the Monkey King's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy cavernous environment that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing golden mail armor with dragon and cloud patterns and a purple-gold phoenix-winged crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's eyelids tremble slightly before lifting upward to reveal fiery eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera inch forward at an almost imperceptible pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08902212232351303 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464022159576416 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08902212232351303, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08902212232351303, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14330071210861206, + 0.05207934230566025, + 0.048622313886880875, + 0.05489829182624817, + 0.10813035815954208, + 0.16113413870334625, + 0.2043154537677765, + 0.0702429935336113, + 0.0618247464299202, + 0.09545160084962845 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08902212232351303 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of the Monkey King's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy cavernous environment that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing golden mail armor with dragon and cloud patterns and a purple-gold phoenix-winged crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's eyelids tremble slightly before lifting upward to reveal fiery eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera inch forward at an almost imperceptible pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0890071839094162 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640071392059326 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0890071839094162, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0890071839094162, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21025854349136353, + 0.09021499007940292, + 0.06670612841844559, + 0.18426509201526642, + 0.05370483547449112, + 0.0913010761141777, + 0.10097083449363708, + 0.08295423537492752, + 0.03949515148997307, + 0.08012908697128296 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0890071839094162 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a stunning close-up shot, employing a cinematic shallow depth of field, the camera inched forward at an almost imperceptible pace, focusing on the long-sealed face of the Monkey King. He clad himself in a magnificent golden mail armor intricately carved with dragons and auspicious cloud patterns, and crowned with his signature phoenix-winged purple-gold crown. Fine dust accumulated between the crevices of the armor and the crown, yet in the dramatic, shimmering light slanting down from above, it still reflected a deep, rich metallic luster. The gloomy cavernous background was completely blurred, with only the dust particles floating in the air clearly visible in the light. His tightly closed eyelids began to tremble slightly, as if bearing the weight of millennia. With incredibly slow and determined precision, they lifted upward, a sharp golden light emanating from the slits before finally opening fully, revealing a pair of fiery eyes burning with an unyielding flame, pupils as sharp as lightning. Their gaze was filled with the confusion of awakening, suppressed anger, and boundless majesty. The entire picture has a strong contrast between light and shadow, and the tones are solemn and brilliant, creating an epic and shocking awakening moment when a legendary hero finally wakes up after sleeping for thousands of years.", + "seed": 19218, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_1/index_5349_seed_19218_dp_2_rank_4_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.05161457248032093, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05161457248032093, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05161457248032093, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of the Monkey King's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy cavernous environment that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing golden mail armor with dragon and cloud patterns and a purple-gold phoenix-winged crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's eyelids tremble slightly before lifting upward to reveal fiery eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera inch forward at an almost imperceptible pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.047738708555698395 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.297738790512085 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.047738708555698395, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.047738708555698395, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7100538611412048, + 0.032254546880722046, + 0.02535804733633995, + 0.019971245899796486, + 0.04341728240251541, + 0.04355382174253464, + 0.044318512082099915, + 0.031291984021663666, + 0.028687141835689545, + 0.0210935790091753 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.047738708555698395 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of the Monkey King's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy cavernous environment that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing golden mail armor with dragon and cloud patterns and a purple-gold phoenix-winged crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's eyelids tremble slightly before lifting upward to reveal fiery eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera inch forward at an almost imperceptible pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023321963846683502 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733218669891357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023321963846683502, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023321963846683502, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36228764057159424, + 0.4502991735935211, + 0.00791401881724596, + 0.00720124039798975, + 0.018613651394844055, + 0.014358687214553356, + 0.008513340726494789, + 0.014302865602076054, + 0.09679368138313293, + 0.019715672358870506 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023321963846683502 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of the Monkey King's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy cavernous environment that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing golden mail armor with dragon and cloud patterns and a purple-gold phoenix-winged crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's eyelids tremble slightly before lifting upward to reveal fiery eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera inch forward at an almost imperceptible pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004100250080227852 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504100322723389 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004100250080227852, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004100250080227852, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15935535728931427, + 0.030194289982318878, + 0.03187134489417076, + 0.033323921263217926, + 0.046107467263936996, + 0.06628203392028809, + 0.06891973316669464, + 0.025852899998426437, + 0.2606147527694702, + 0.2774781286716461 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004100250080227852 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of the Monkey King's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy cavernous environment that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing golden mail armor with dragon and cloud patterns and a purple-gold phoenix-winged crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's eyelids tremble slightly before lifting upward to reveal fiery eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera inch forward at an almost imperceptible pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07000525295734406 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695005178451538 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07000525295734406, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07000525295734406, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20220553874969482, + 0.07428804039955139, + 0.03081243298947811, + 0.014638727530837059, + 0.03990097716450691, + 0.03646950423717499, + 0.059188660234212875, + 0.02564597874879837, + 0.4879266023635864, + 0.02892346866428852 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07000525295734406 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of the Monkey King's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy cavernous environment that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing golden mail armor with dragon and cloud patterns and a purple-gold phoenix-winged crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's eyelids tremble slightly before lifting upward to reveal fiery eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera inch forward at an almost imperceptible pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11290668696165085 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379066944122314 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11290668696165085, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11290668696165085, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3383427560329437, + 0.2568725049495697, + 0.02474132366478443, + 0.023292120546102524, + 0.05329703912138939, + 0.02011520229279995, + 0.04368053004145622, + 0.042920779436826706, + 0.17037463188171387, + 0.026363076642155647 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11290668696165085 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a stunning close-up shot, employing a cinematic shallow depth of field, the camera inched forward at an almost imperceptible pace, focusing on the long-sealed face of the Monkey King. He clad himself in a magnificent golden mail armor intricately carved with dragons and auspicious cloud patterns, and crowned with his signature phoenix-winged purple-gold crown. Fine dust accumulated between the crevices of the armor and the crown, yet in the dramatic, shimmering light slanting down from above, it still reflected a deep, rich metallic luster. The gloomy cavernous background was completely blurred, with only the dust particles floating in the air clearly visible in the light. His tightly closed eyelids began to tremble slightly, as if bearing the weight of millennia. With incredibly slow and determined precision, they lifted upward, a sharp golden light emanating from the slits before finally opening fully, revealing a pair of fiery eyes burning with an unyielding flame, pupils as sharp as lightning. Their gaze was filled with the confusion of awakening, suppressed anger, and boundless majesty. The entire picture has a strong contrast between light and shadow, and the tones are solemn and brilliant, creating an epic and shocking awakening moment when a legendary hero finally wakes up after sleeping for thousands of years.", + "seed": 19219, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_1/index_5349_seed_19219_dp_3_rank_6_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06845621950924397, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06845621950924397, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.0, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06845621950924397, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of the Monkey King's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy cavernous environment that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing golden mail armor with dragon and cloud patterns and a purple-gold phoenix-winged crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's eyelids tremble slightly before lifting upward to reveal fiery eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera inch forward at an almost imperceptible pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.021014070138335228 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.021014213562012 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.021014070138335228, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.021014070138335228, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10664099454879761, + 0.051362086087465286, + 0.03153779357671738, + 0.04772091656923294, + 0.3247765004634857, + 0.053340163081884384, + 0.25566428899765015, + 0.04548979923129082, + 0.03687288239598274, + 0.04659454524517059 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.021014070138335228 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of the Monkey King's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy cavernous environment that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing golden mail armor with dragon and cloud patterns and a purple-gold phoenix-winged crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's eyelids tremble slightly before lifting upward to reveal fiery eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera inch forward at an almost imperceptible pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10037695616483688 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350376844406128 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10037695616483688, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10037695616483688, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.35040801763534546, + 0.04163685813546181, + 0.04084085300564766, + 0.09256809949874878, + 0.05383230745792389, + 0.11818142980337143, + 0.22558428347110748, + 0.027115454897284508, + 0.027703437954187393, + 0.022129284217953682 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10037695616483688 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of the Monkey King's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy cavernous environment that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing golden mail armor with dragon and cloud patterns and a purple-gold phoenix-winged crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's eyelids tremble slightly before lifting upward to reveal fiery eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera inch forward at an almost imperceptible pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01607177034020424 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141071796417236 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01607177034020424, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01607177034020424, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1824420690536499, + 0.14485003054141998, + 0.11406058073043823, + 0.06752881407737732, + 0.08162308484315872, + 0.07646284997463226, + 0.109800785779953, + 0.09197477251291275, + 0.06651652604341507, + 0.06474052369594574 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01607177034020424 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of the Monkey King's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy cavernous environment that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing golden mail armor with dragon and cloud patterns and a purple-gold phoenix-winged crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's eyelids tremble slightly before lifting upward to reveal fiery eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera inch forward at an almost imperceptible pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14278671145439148 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017786741256714 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14278671145439148, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14278671145439148, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20083636045455933, + 0.06205892190337181, + 0.1487734168767929, + 0.13264614343643188, + 0.029131710529327393, + 0.12726272642612457, + 0.19888313114643097, + 0.052311576902866364, + 0.028745390474796295, + 0.01935061626136303 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14278671145439148 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of the Monkey King's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy cavernous environment that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing golden mail armor with dragon and cloud patterns and a purple-gold phoenix-winged crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's eyelids tremble slightly before lifting upward to reveal fiery eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera inch forward at an almost imperceptible pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062031589448451996 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120315074920654 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062031589448451996, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062031589448451996, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1222178265452385, + 0.044079236686229706, + 0.09841370582580566, + 0.08691305667161942, + 0.22559210658073425, + 0.0753779262304306, + 0.2964205741882324, + 0.02209610305726528, + 0.015031185001134872, + 0.013858223333954811 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062031589448451996 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "In a stunning close-up shot, employing a cinematic shallow depth of field, the camera inched forward at an almost imperceptible pace, focusing on the long-sealed face of the Monkey King. He clad himself in a magnificent golden mail armor intricately carved with dragons and auspicious cloud patterns, and crowned with his signature phoenix-winged purple-gold crown. Fine dust accumulated between the crevices of the armor and the crown, yet in the dramatic, shimmering light slanting down from above, it still reflected a deep, rich metallic luster. The gloomy cavernous background was completely blurred, with only the dust particles floating in the air clearly visible in the light. His tightly closed eyelids began to tremble slightly, as if bearing the weight of millennia. With incredibly slow and determined precision, they lifted upward, a sharp golden light emanating from the slits before finally opening fully, revealing a pair of fiery eyes burning with an unyielding flame, pupils as sharp as lightning. Their gaze was filled with the confusion of awakening, suppressed anger, and boundless majesty. The entire picture has a strong contrast between light and shadow, and the tones are solemn and brilliant, creating an epic and shocking awakening moment when a legendary hero finally wakes up after sleeping for thousands of years.", + "seed": 19220, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_1/index_5349_seed_19220_dp_3_rank_6_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 1, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.06811559218913317, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06811559218913317, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06811559218913317, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of the Monkey King's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy cavernous environment that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing golden mail armor with dragon and cloud patterns and a purple-gold phoenix-winged crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's eyelids tremble slightly before lifting upward to reveal fiery eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera inch forward at an almost imperceptible pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.028523780405521393 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7785236835479736 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.028523780405521393, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.028523780405521393, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19151224195957184, + 0.11444423347711563, + 0.13749909400939941, + 0.06390441954135895, + 0.06547193974256516, + 0.037354111671447754, + 0.07096850126981735, + 0.1096237301826477, + 0.07602234929800034, + 0.13319940865039825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.028523780405521393 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of the Monkey King's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy cavernous environment that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing golden mail armor with dragon and cloud patterns and a purple-gold phoenix-winged crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's eyelids tremble slightly before lifting upward to reveal fiery eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera inch forward at an almost imperceptible pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14286483824253082 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017864942550659 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14286483824253082, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14286483824253082, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.31486377120018005, + 0.07737987488508224, + 0.06687808781862259, + 0.02687191776931286, + 0.0793212503194809, + 0.020684663206338882, + 0.154266357421875, + 0.09900087863206863, + 0.0894765704870224, + 0.0712566152215004 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14286483824253082 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of the Monkey King's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy cavernous environment that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing golden mail armor with dragon and cloud patterns and a purple-gold phoenix-winged crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's eyelids tremble slightly before lifting upward to reveal fiery eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera inch forward at an almost imperceptible pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007632498629391193 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882632732391357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007632498629391193, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007632498629391193, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19794878363609314, + 0.1374184638261795, + 0.05068165808916092, + 0.0744447335600853, + 0.13238468766212463, + 0.026549607515335083, + 0.04791821911931038, + 0.10466556996107101, + 0.11212573200464249, + 0.11586261540651321 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007632498629391193 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of the Monkey King's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy cavernous environment that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing golden mail armor with dragon and cloud patterns and a purple-gold phoenix-winged crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's eyelids tremble slightly before lifting upward to reveal fiery eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera inch forward at an almost imperceptible pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1129164844751358 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2379164695739746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1129164844751358, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1129164844751358, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10113630443811417, + 0.05511842295527458, + 0.07166792452335358, + 0.056851036846637726, + 0.11323189735412598, + 0.08127467334270477, + 0.23995061218738556, + 0.06197189539670944, + 0.12432598322629929, + 0.09447129815816879 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 8, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1129164844751358 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of the Monkey King's face?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the background a gloomy cavernous environment that is completely blurred?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the character wearing golden mail armor with dragon and cloud patterns and a purple-gold phoenix-winged crown?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character's eyelids tremble slightly before lifting upward to reveal fiery eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera inch forward at an almost imperceptible pace?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048640359193086624 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048640251159668 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048640359193086624, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048640359193086624, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11633540689945221, + 0.0259699746966362, + 0.1144079938530922, + 0.025840792804956436, + 0.10485134273767471, + 0.04539300501346588, + 0.07918544858694077, + 0.0418260283768177, + 0.06114394590258598, + 0.3850460648536682 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048640359193086624 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_10/index_tensor([1111, 1111])_group_10_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_10/index_tensor([1111, 1111])_group_10_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..6fd08a02dc8402ca4caee6aca59fd9a8e264374c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_10/index_tensor([1111, 1111])_group_10_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "From a slightly elevated wide angle, the camera slowly and deliberately pans to the right, gliding across the vast, empty expanse of a professional football stadium at night. Under the intense, austere glare of towering floodlights, the perfectly manicured green grass appears almost unnaturally vibrant against the inky darkness of the abandoned stands. A lone figure, a male player with sweat-soaked black hair, stands isolated near the center circle, wearing a red jersey and white shorts stained with grass. His posture is one of utter exhaustion. Suddenly, without warning, his knees buckle uncontrollably, and his entire body collapses bonelessly to the ground. As his torso collapses forward, his arms fail to break his fall, and he lands heavily on the pristine grass, his long, stark shadow stretching out behind him in the harsh, unblinking light. As the camera continues its steady rightward motion, the figure remains completely still, creating a powerful and somber atmosphere on the vast, silent stage, one filled with profound isolation and sudden crisis.", + "seed": 16474, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_10/index_1111_seed_16474_dp_20_rank_40_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.1618727885186672, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1618727885186672, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1618727885186672, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a professional football stadium at night with empty stands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone male figure wearing a red jersey and white shorts visible near the center circle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure's knees buckle and his body collapse bonelessly to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately pan to the right from a slightly elevated wide angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure completely still on the ground while the camera continues its rightward motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6365171074867249 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7615171074867249 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6365171074867249, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6365171074867249, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14576895534992218, + 0.08209790289402008, + 0.03273220360279083, + 0.07843756675720215, + 0.03513963520526886, + 0.4144148528575897, + 0.09967829287052155, + 0.010424913838505745, + 0.07201746851205826, + 0.029288215562701225 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6365171074867249 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a professional football stadium at night with empty stands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone male figure wearing a red jersey and white shorts visible near the center circle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure's knees buckle and his body collapse bonelessly to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately pan to the right from a slightly elevated wide angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure completely still on the ground while the camera continues its rightward motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026369649916887283 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651369571685791 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026369649916887283, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026369649916887283, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21124935150146484, + 0.06422946602106094, + 0.03116336464881897, + 0.05049200356006622, + 0.048104360699653625, + 0.3372831344604492, + 0.03595268353819847, + 0.03716395050287247, + 0.08325102925300598, + 0.10111074149608612 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026369649916887283 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a professional football stadium at night with empty stands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone male figure wearing a red jersey and white shorts visible near the center circle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure's knees buckle and his body collapse bonelessly to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately pan to the right from a slightly elevated wide angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure completely still on the ground while the camera continues its rightward motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07901620864868164 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790162086486816 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07901620864868164, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07901620864868164, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1315585970878601, + 0.07879893481731415, + 0.06424755603075027, + 0.03970947861671448, + 0.05352244898676872, + 0.23096396028995514, + 0.03219149261713028, + 0.1100207269191742, + 0.11546088010072708, + 0.1435258984565735 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07901620864868164 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a professional football stadium at night with empty stands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone male figure wearing a red jersey and white shorts visible near the center circle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure's knees buckle and his body collapse bonelessly to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately pan to the right from a slightly elevated wide angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure completely still on the ground while the camera continues its rightward motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371734917163849 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408717393875122 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371734917163849, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371734917163849, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09289122372865677, + 0.021807469427585602, + 0.03581216186285019, + 0.0410614088177681, + 0.040606386959552765, + 0.6640504598617554, + 0.029727289453148842, + 0.01668202131986618, + 0.04379938170313835, + 0.013562224805355072 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371734917163849 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a professional football stadium at night with empty stands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone male figure wearing a red jersey and white shorts visible near the center circle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure's knees buckle and his body collapse bonelessly to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately pan to the right from a slightly elevated wide angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure completely still on the ground while the camera continues its rightward motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03374362736940384 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087436199188232 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03374362736940384, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03374362736940384, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10026424378156662, + 0.026008522137999535, + 0.042175933718681335, + 0.031977228820323944, + 0.049974165856838226, + 0.5389329195022583, + 0.0391041524708271, + 0.059201594442129135, + 0.07188204675912857, + 0.040479205548763275 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03374362736940384 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "From a slightly elevated wide angle, the camera slowly and deliberately pans to the right, gliding across the vast, empty expanse of a professional football stadium at night. Under the intense, austere glare of towering floodlights, the perfectly manicured green grass appears almost unnaturally vibrant against the inky darkness of the abandoned stands. A lone figure, a male player with sweat-soaked black hair, stands isolated near the center circle, wearing a red jersey and white shorts stained with grass. His posture is one of utter exhaustion. Suddenly, without warning, his knees buckle uncontrollably, and his entire body collapses bonelessly to the ground. As his torso collapses forward, his arms fail to break his fall, and he lands heavily on the pristine grass, his long, stark shadow stretching out behind him in the harsh, unblinking light. As the camera continues its steady rightward motion, the figure remains completely still, creating a powerful and somber atmosphere on the vast, silent stage, one filled with profound isolation and sudden crisis.", + "seed": 16475, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_10/index_1111_seed_16475_dp_20_rank_40_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.05124255456030369, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05124255456030369, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05124255456030369, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a professional football stadium at night with empty stands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone male figure wearing a red jersey and white shorts visible near the center circle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure's knees buckle and his body collapse bonelessly to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately pan to the right from a slightly elevated wide angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure completely still on the ground while the camera continues its rightward motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.071683868765831 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.696683883666992 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.071683868765831, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.071683868765831, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.8980921506881714, + 0.02927890606224537, + 0.0030676366295665503, + 0.0028570492286235094, + 0.0045122443698346615, + 0.0022860770113766193, + 0.0037839263677597046, + 0.04972565174102783, + 0.003911409992724657, + 0.0024849188048392534 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.071683868765831 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a professional football stadium at night with empty stands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone male figure wearing a red jersey and white shorts visible near the center circle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure's knees buckle and his body collapse bonelessly to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately pan to the right from a slightly elevated wide angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure completely still on the ground while the camera continues its rightward motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0298262070864439 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298261642456055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0298262070864439, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0298262070864439, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2434413880109787, + 0.09577976912260056, + 0.11503487080335617, + 0.08776751160621643, + 0.06717830151319504, + 0.046996839344501495, + 0.03912770003080368, + 0.11031524091959, + 0.03668734058737755, + 0.15767104923725128 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0298262070864439 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a professional football stadium at night with empty stands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone male figure wearing a red jersey and white shorts visible near the center circle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure's knees buckle and his body collapse bonelessly to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately pan to the right from a slightly elevated wide angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure completely still on the ground while the camera continues its rightward motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10035442560911179 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3503544330596924 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10035442560911179, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10035442560911179, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11103685200214386, + 0.36926916241645813, + 0.11505674570798874, + 0.04557531327009201, + 0.03383983299136162, + 0.03249657526612282, + 0.037453897297382355, + 0.09907545149326324, + 0.020552203059196472, + 0.13564401865005493 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10035442560911179 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a professional football stadium at night with empty stands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone male figure wearing a red jersey and white shorts visible near the center circle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure's knees buckle and his body collapse bonelessly to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately pan to the right from a slightly elevated wide angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure completely still on the ground while the camera continues its rightward motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02059842273592949 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955984115600586 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02059842273592949, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02059842273592949, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22409068048000336, + 0.11718527227640152, + 0.06258589774370193, + 0.07864384353160858, + 0.08029743283987045, + 0.026470014825463295, + 0.04960161820054054, + 0.20423825085163116, + 0.06023245304822922, + 0.09665454179048538 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02059842273592949 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a professional football stadium at night with empty stands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone male figure wearing a red jersey and white shorts visible near the center circle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure's knees buckle and his body collapse bonelessly to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately pan to the right from a slightly elevated wide angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure completely still on the ground while the camera continues its rightward motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03374984860420227 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.40874981880188 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03374984860420227, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03374984860420227, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7298799753189087, + 0.0622795894742012, + 0.02234814502298832, + 0.017172852531075478, + 0.011600458063185215, + 0.009600609540939331, + 0.009082213044166565, + 0.0507480651140213, + 0.028723975643515587, + 0.05856415256857872 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03374984860420227 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "From a slightly elevated wide angle, the camera slowly and deliberately pans to the right, gliding across the vast, empty expanse of a professional football stadium at night. Under the intense, austere glare of towering floodlights, the perfectly manicured green grass appears almost unnaturally vibrant against the inky darkness of the abandoned stands. A lone figure, a male player with sweat-soaked black hair, stands isolated near the center circle, wearing a red jersey and white shorts stained with grass. His posture is one of utter exhaustion. Suddenly, without warning, his knees buckle uncontrollably, and his entire body collapses bonelessly to the ground. As his torso collapses forward, his arms fail to break his fall, and he lands heavily on the pristine grass, his long, stark shadow stretching out behind him in the harsh, unblinking light. As the camera continues its steady rightward motion, the figure remains completely still, creating a powerful and somber atmosphere on the vast, silent stage, one filled with profound isolation and sudden crisis.", + "seed": 16476, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_10/index_1111_seed_16476_dp_21_rank_42_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1651507370173931, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1651507370173931, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.9, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1651507370173931, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a professional football stadium at night with empty stands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone male figure wearing a red jersey and white shorts visible near the center circle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure's knees buckle and his body collapse bonelessly to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately pan to the right from a slightly elevated wide angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure completely still on the ground while the camera continues its rightward motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6984099745750427 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6984099745750427 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6984099745750427, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6984099745750427, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12505069375038147, + 0.3301470875740051, + 0.07398702204227448, + 0.18477001786231995, + 0.06341137737035751, + 0.0395030602812767, + 0.10368328541517258, + 0.02617177926003933, + 0.027103876695036888, + 0.026171814650297165 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6984099745750427 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a professional football stadium at night with empty stands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone male figure wearing a red jersey and white shorts visible near the center circle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure's knees buckle and his body collapse bonelessly to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately pan to the right from a slightly elevated wide angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure completely still on the ground while the camera continues its rightward motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020613020285964012 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895612955093384 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020613020285964012, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020613020285964012, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24202856421470642, + 0.21417924761772156, + 0.0670095905661583, + 0.15073633193969727, + 0.09537443518638611, + 0.057979144155979156, + 0.06102384254336357, + 0.031729817390441895, + 0.027088996022939682, + 0.052850063890218735 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020613020285964012 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a professional football stadium at night with empty stands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone male figure wearing a red jersey and white shorts visible near the center circle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure's knees buckle and his body collapse bonelessly to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately pan to the right from a slightly elevated wide angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure completely still on the ground while the camera continues its rightward motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07004371285438538 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950438022613525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07004371285438538, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07004371285438538, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10530441999435425, + 0.1194445788860321, + 0.10972553491592407, + 0.26925474405288696, + 0.052234578877687454, + 0.029111769050359726, + 0.08182619512081146, + 0.048747364431619644, + 0.03819316625595093, + 0.14615759253501892 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07004371285438538 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a professional football stadium at night with empty stands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone male figure wearing a red jersey and white shorts visible near the center circle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure's knees buckle and his body collapse bonelessly to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately pan to the right from a slightly elevated wide angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure completely still on the ground while the camera continues its rightward motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020596086978912354 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8955960273742676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020596086978912354, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020596086978912354, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05833342671394348, + 0.03543209284543991, + 0.08624619245529175, + 0.5324543714523315, + 0.11797352880239487, + 0.07437959313392639, + 0.026241492480039597, + 0.014727454632520676, + 0.02902384102344513, + 0.025188023224473 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020596086978912354 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a professional football stadium at night with empty stands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone male figure wearing a red jersey and white shorts visible near the center circle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure's knees buckle and his body collapse bonelessly to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately pan to the right from a slightly elevated wide angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure completely still on the ground while the camera continues its rightward motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016090890392661095 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410908699035645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016090890392661095, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016090890392661095, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14411267638206482, + 0.06681342422962189, + 0.046922940760850906, + 0.4714249074459076, + 0.04949665442109108, + 0.02788073569536209, + 0.04253336787223816, + 0.038959041237831116, + 0.06508561223745346, + 0.04677069932222366 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016090890392661095 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "From a slightly elevated wide angle, the camera slowly and deliberately pans to the right, gliding across the vast, empty expanse of a professional football stadium at night. Under the intense, austere glare of towering floodlights, the perfectly manicured green grass appears almost unnaturally vibrant against the inky darkness of the abandoned stands. A lone figure, a male player with sweat-soaked black hair, stands isolated near the center circle, wearing a red jersey and white shorts stained with grass. His posture is one of utter exhaustion. Suddenly, without warning, his knees buckle uncontrollably, and his entire body collapses bonelessly to the ground. As his torso collapses forward, his arms fail to break his fall, and he lands heavily on the pristine grass, his long, stark shadow stretching out behind him in the harsh, unblinking light. As the camera continues its steady rightward motion, the figure remains completely still, creating a powerful and somber atmosphere on the vast, silent stage, one filled with profound isolation and sudden crisis.", + "seed": 16477, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_10/index_1111_seed_16477_dp_21_rank_42_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 10, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04216108731925487, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04216108731925487, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04216108731925487, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a professional football stadium at night with empty stands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone male figure wearing a red jersey and white shorts visible near the center circle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure's knees buckle and his body collapse bonelessly to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately pan to the right from a slightly elevated wide angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure completely still on the ground while the camera continues its rightward motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07190654426813126 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.696906566619873 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07190654426813126, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07190654426813126, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2752624452114105, + 0.12363729625940323, + 0.13729248940944672, + 0.05771828442811966, + 0.1145685687661171, + 0.06245109811425209, + 0.038654666393995285, + 0.029921695590019226, + 0.11000405997037888, + 0.050489410758018494 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07190654426813126 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a professional football stadium at night with empty stands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone male figure wearing a red jersey and white shorts visible near the center circle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure's knees buckle and his body collapse bonelessly to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately pan to the right from a slightly elevated wide angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure completely still on the ground while the camera continues its rightward motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029823893681168556 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298237800598145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029823893681168556, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029823893681168556, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1909434050321579, + 0.23304712772369385, + 0.08276107907295227, + 0.03443031758069992, + 0.058065395802259445, + 0.039245881140232086, + 0.049351442605257034, + 0.04773808643221855, + 0.18568263947963715, + 0.07873460650444031 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029823893681168556 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a professional football stadium at night with empty stands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone male figure wearing a red jersey and white shorts visible near the center circle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure's knees buckle and his body collapse bonelessly to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately pan to the right from a slightly elevated wide angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure completely still on the ground while the camera continues its rightward motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06208973750472069 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812089681625366 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06208973750472069, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06208973750472069, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08100895583629608, + 0.07608135044574738, + 0.06984412670135498, + 0.0358145646750927, + 0.046543050557374954, + 0.047226712107658386, + 0.049645934253931046, + 0.08008473366498947, + 0.3915722370147705, + 0.12217829376459122 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06208973750472069 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a professional football stadium at night with empty stands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone male figure wearing a red jersey and white shorts visible near the center circle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure's knees buckle and his body collapse bonelessly to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately pan to the right from a slightly elevated wide angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure completely still on the ground while the camera continues its rightward motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026365701109170914 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513657569885254 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026365701109170914, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026365701109170914, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14567023515701294, + 0.09081663191318512, + 0.10154784470796585, + 0.10903371125459671, + 0.11573430895805359, + 0.08302024006843567, + 0.06533967703580856, + 0.0461256168782711, + 0.163332000374794, + 0.07937970012426376 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026365701109170914 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a professional football stadium at night with empty stands?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a lone male figure wearing a red jersey and white shorts visible near the center circle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the figure's knees buckle and his body collapse bonelessly to the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly and deliberately pan to the right from a slightly elevated wide angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the figure completely still on the ground while the camera continues its rightward motion?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020619560033082962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956196308135986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020619560033082962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020619560033082962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1844366043806076, + 0.13160057365894318, + 0.04255487769842148, + 0.0704711452126503, + 0.09616582095623016, + 0.10770221799612045, + 0.05356675013899803, + 0.05710601061582565, + 0.13070689141750336, + 0.12568911910057068 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020619560033082962 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_11/index_tensor([9156, 9156])_group_11_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_11/index_tensor([9156, 9156])_group_11_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..08295dd88ce69ad6eeb6bedfd9556644ca221639 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_11/index_tensor([9156, 9156])_group_11_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "shaky, handheld medium close-up shot, filmed from water level, draws the viewer into this struggle for survival. The camera rises and falls with the waves, capturing a man's desperate struggle for survival in the turbulent, dark waters. His soaked, dark hair clings to his forehead and scalp, his face a picture of pure terror—eyes wide and bloodshot with terror, brow furrowed, mouth gaping as if in a silent scream or desperate gasp for air, salty water constantly pouring in and being coughed out. A tattered, dark gray T-shirt, soaking wet, clings tightly to his body, strained by the exertion. Under a storm-ravaged, moonless sky, he is mercilessly tossed up and down by massive, black waves churning with white foam. His arms flail futilely, then desperately paddle, each struggle swallowed by the powerful, icy current, causing his body to heave violently through the water. The only illumination comes from intermittent, blinding flashes of lightning that streak across the sky. Each flash freezes the horrific scene into a painting of intense chiaroscuro, momentarily illuminating his pale face and the chaotic splashes of water around him. The entire scene is permeated with a suffocating sense of despair and humanity's insignificance and helplessness in the face of violent nature, creating an atmosphere of extreme tension and horror.", + "seed": 18393, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_11/index_9156_seed_18393_dp_22_rank_44_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.0646004119887948, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0646004119887948, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.825, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0646004119887948, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a shaky, handheld medium close-up filmed from water level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a man visible struggling in turbulent, dark waters with massive black waves churning with white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man have soaked dark hair clinging to his forehead and a tattered dark gray T-shirt soaking wet and clinging to his body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated only by intermittent, blinding flashes of lightning under a storm-ravaged, moonless sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise and fall with the waves while the man's arms flail and paddle futilely in the current?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07736917585134506 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.702369213104248 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07736917585134506, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07736917585134506, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2457912117242813, + 0.15069100260734558, + 0.09154871106147766, + 0.06598318368196487, + 0.04685118794441223, + 0.10363632440567017, + 0.08509039878845215, + 0.046951279044151306, + 0.06847460567951202, + 0.09498205035924911 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07736917585134506 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a shaky, handheld medium close-up filmed from water level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a man visible struggling in turbulent, dark waters with massive black waves churning with white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man have soaked dark hair clinging to his forehead and a tattered dark gray T-shirt soaking wet and clinging to his body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated only by intermittent, blinding flashes of lightning under a storm-ravaged, moonless sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise and fall with the waves while the man's arms flail and paddle futilely in the current?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006758213043212891 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006758213043213 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006758213043212891, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006758213043212891, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2652314603328705, + 0.09540461748838425, + 0.11240940541028976, + 0.08189272880554199, + 0.061432432383298874, + 0.07598984241485596, + 0.06888727843761444, + 0.14140348136425018, + 0.05582248046994209, + 0.04152624309062958 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006758213043212891 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a shaky, handheld medium close-up filmed from water level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a man visible struggling in turbulent, dark waters with massive black waves churning with white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man have soaked dark hair clinging to his forehead and a tattered dark gray T-shirt soaking wet and clinging to his body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated only by intermittent, blinding flashes of lightning under a storm-ravaged, moonless sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise and fall with the waves while the man's arms flail and paddle futilely in the current?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008640522137284279 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758640289306641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008640522137284279, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008640522137284279, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24549049139022827, + 0.1372014880180359, + 0.1723632514476776, + 0.05568232014775276, + 0.09194888919591904, + 0.05084614083170891, + 0.05660445615649223, + 0.09396494925022125, + 0.05813882127404213, + 0.037759196013212204 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008640522137284279 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a shaky, handheld medium close-up filmed from water level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a man visible struggling in turbulent, dark waters with massive black waves churning with white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man have soaked dark hair clinging to his forehead and a tattered dark gray T-shirt soaking wet and clinging to his body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated only by intermittent, blinding flashes of lightning under a storm-ravaged, moonless sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise and fall with the waves while the man's arms flail and paddle futilely in the current?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2255900651216507 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005901098251343 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2255900651216507, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2255900651216507, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.133652925491333, + 0.16620559990406036, + 0.09769298881292343, + 0.06560338288545609, + 0.05854830890893936, + 0.09955247491598129, + 0.07052913308143616, + 0.14714685082435608, + 0.1226794570684433, + 0.03838885948061943 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2255900651216507 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a shaky, handheld medium close-up filmed from water level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a man visible struggling in turbulent, dark waters with massive black waves churning with white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man have soaked dark hair clinging to his forehead and a tattered dark gray T-shirt soaking wet and clinging to his body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated only by intermittent, blinding flashes of lightning under a storm-ravaged, moonless sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise and fall with the waves while the man's arms flail and paddle futilely in the current?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046440837904810905 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.37964391708374 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046440837904810905, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046440837904810905, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20285287499427795, + 0.11194358021020889, + 0.10492284595966339, + 0.04574531316757202, + 0.04970754683017731, + 0.0758703202009201, + 0.08957923948764801, + 0.06437867134809494, + 0.16697214543819427, + 0.08802736550569534 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046440837904810905 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shaky, handheld medium close-up shot, filmed from water level, draws the viewer into this struggle for survival. The camera rises and falls with the waves, capturing a man's desperate struggle for survival in the turbulent, dark waters. His soaked, dark hair clings to his forehead and scalp, his face a picture of pure terror—eyes wide and bloodshot with terror, brow furrowed, mouth gaping as if in a silent scream or desperate gasp for air, salty water constantly pouring in and being coughed out. A tattered, dark gray T-shirt, soaking wet, clings tightly to his body, strained by the exertion. Under a storm-ravaged, moonless sky, he is mercilessly tossed up and down by massive, black waves churning with white foam. His arms flail futilely, then desperately paddle, each struggle swallowed by the powerful, icy current, causing his body to heave violently through the water. The only illumination comes from intermittent, blinding flashes of lightning that streak across the sky. Each flash freezes the horrific scene into a painting of intense chiaroscuro, momentarily illuminating his pale face and the chaotic splashes of water around him. The entire scene is permeated with a suffocating sense of despair and humanity's insignificance and helplessness in the face of violent nature, creating an atmosphere of extreme tension and horror.", + "seed": 18394, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_11/index_9156_seed_18394_dp_22_rank_44_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07586937686428427, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07586937686428427, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.2, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07586937686428427, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a shaky, handheld medium close-up filmed from water level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a man visible struggling in turbulent, dark waters with massive black waves churning with white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man have soaked dark hair clinging to his forehead and a tattered dark gray T-shirt soaking wet and clinging to his body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated only by intermittent, blinding flashes of lightning under a storm-ravaged, moonless sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise and fall with the waves while the man's arms flail and paddle futilely in the current?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12330679595470428 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2483067512512207 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12330679595470428, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12330679595470428, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1132953092455864, + 0.047170620411634445, + 0.0799056813120842, + 0.05880995839834213, + 0.028171207755804062, + 0.03525792062282562, + 0.13255591690540314, + 0.17983321845531464, + 0.025821717455983162, + 0.29917845129966736 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12330679595470428 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a shaky, handheld medium close-up filmed from water level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a man visible struggling in turbulent, dark waters with massive black waves churning with white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man have soaked dark hair clinging to his forehead and a tattered dark gray T-shirt soaking wet and clinging to his body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated only by intermittent, blinding flashes of lightning under a storm-ravaged, moonless sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise and fall with the waves while the man's arms flail and paddle futilely in the current?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048697471618652344 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486974716186523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048697471618652344, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048697471618652344, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07809165865182877, + 0.04876170679926872, + 0.15565501153469086, + 0.028050368651747704, + 0.04001764953136444, + 0.026464710012078285, + 0.10669542104005814, + 0.04138980060815811, + 0.05094471573829651, + 0.4239289164543152 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048697471618652344 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a shaky, handheld medium close-up filmed from water level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a man visible struggling in turbulent, dark waters with massive black waves churning with white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man have soaked dark hair clinging to his forehead and a tattered dark gray T-shirt soaking wet and clinging to his body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated only by intermittent, blinding flashes of lightning under a storm-ravaged, moonless sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise and fall with the waves while the man's arms flail and paddle futilely in the current?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023325109854340553 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773325204849243 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023325109854340553, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023325109854340553, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07876624912023544, + 0.045884810388088226, + 0.11718706041574478, + 0.028417598456144333, + 0.05124058946967125, + 0.013441954739391804, + 0.18240125477313995, + 0.039526231586933136, + 0.05413156375288963, + 0.38900265097618103 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023325109854340553 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a shaky, handheld medium close-up filmed from water level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a man visible struggling in turbulent, dark waters with massive black waves churning with white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man have soaked dark hair clinging to his forehead and a tattered dark gray T-shirt soaking wet and clinging to his body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated only by intermittent, blinding flashes of lightning under a storm-ravaged, moonless sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise and fall with the waves while the man's arms flail and paddle futilely in the current?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17990906536579132 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.804909110069275 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17990906536579132, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17990906536579132, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08304223418235779, + 0.030281970277428627, + 0.17554320394992828, + 0.2689056694507599, + 0.024897096678614616, + 0.06902293115854263, + 0.06898012012243271, + 0.08496222645044327, + 0.08660375326871872, + 0.10776083916425705 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17990906536579132 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a shaky, handheld medium close-up filmed from water level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a man visible struggling in turbulent, dark waters with massive black waves churning with white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man have soaked dark hair clinging to his forehead and a tattered dark gray T-shirt soaking wet and clinging to his body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated only by intermittent, blinding flashes of lightning under a storm-ravaged, moonless sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise and fall with the waves while the man's arms flail and paddle futilely in the current?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004108441527932882 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504108428955078 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004108441527932882, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004108441527932882, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10508504509925842, + 0.0476449579000473, + 0.11612962931394577, + 0.05014100670814514, + 0.051885418593883514, + 0.04168911650776863, + 0.14715665578842163, + 0.07771909981966019, + 0.048369187861680984, + 0.314179927110672 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004108441527932882 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shaky, handheld medium close-up shot, filmed from water level, draws the viewer into this struggle for survival. The camera rises and falls with the waves, capturing a man's desperate struggle for survival in the turbulent, dark waters. His soaked, dark hair clings to his forehead and scalp, his face a picture of pure terror—eyes wide and bloodshot with terror, brow furrowed, mouth gaping as if in a silent scream or desperate gasp for air, salty water constantly pouring in and being coughed out. A tattered, dark gray T-shirt, soaking wet, clings tightly to his body, strained by the exertion. Under a storm-ravaged, moonless sky, he is mercilessly tossed up and down by massive, black waves churning with white foam. His arms flail futilely, then desperately paddle, each struggle swallowed by the powerful, icy current, causing his body to heave violently through the water. The only illumination comes from intermittent, blinding flashes of lightning that streak across the sky. Each flash freezes the horrific scene into a painting of intense chiaroscuro, momentarily illuminating his pale face and the chaotic splashes of water around him. The entire scene is permeated with a suffocating sense of despair and humanity's insignificance and helplessness in the face of violent nature, creating an atmosphere of extreme tension and horror.", + "seed": 18395, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_11/index_9156_seed_18395_dp_23_rank_46_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04105030666105449, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04105030666105449, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.274999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04105030666105449, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a shaky, handheld medium close-up filmed from water level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a man visible struggling in turbulent, dark waters with massive black waves churning with white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man have soaked dark hair clinging to his forehead and a tattered dark gray T-shirt soaking wet and clinging to his body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated only by intermittent, blinding flashes of lightning under a storm-ravaged, moonless sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise and fall with the waves while the man's arms flail and paddle futilely in the current?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04889581352472305 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.173895835876465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04889581352472305, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04889581352472305, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13768014311790466, + 0.24161307513713837, + 0.023295866325497627, + 0.2685513198375702, + 0.08244549483060837, + 0.029897494241595268, + 0.06906069815158844, + 0.06746581941843033, + 0.03865090757608414, + 0.04133914038538933 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04889581352472305 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a shaky, handheld medium close-up filmed from water level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a man visible struggling in turbulent, dark waters with massive black waves churning with white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man have soaked dark hair clinging to his forehead and a tattered dark gray T-shirt soaking wet and clinging to his body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated only by intermittent, blinding flashes of lightning under a storm-ravaged, moonless sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise and fall with the waves while the man's arms flail and paddle futilely in the current?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003206471214070916 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753206253051758 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003206471214070916, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003206471214070916, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13185814023017883, + 0.19173270463943481, + 0.03143684193491936, + 0.2247462421655655, + 0.06079641729593277, + 0.06887046992778778, + 0.1132306456565857, + 0.060793519020080566, + 0.051158368587493896, + 0.06537668406963348 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003206471214070916 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a shaky, handheld medium close-up filmed from water level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a man visible struggling in turbulent, dark waters with massive black waves churning with white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man have soaked dark hair clinging to his forehead and a tattered dark gray T-shirt soaking wet and clinging to his body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated only by intermittent, blinding flashes of lightning under a storm-ravaged, moonless sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise and fall with the waves while the man's arms flail and paddle futilely in the current?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006736189126968384 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067362785339355 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006736189126968384, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006736189126968384, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15331405401229858, + 0.05647191032767296, + 0.028155094012618065, + 0.4025065004825592, + 0.08115708082914352, + 0.05995155870914459, + 0.05117300525307655, + 0.06157946214079857, + 0.05962366238236427, + 0.0460677370429039 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006736189126968384 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a shaky, handheld medium close-up filmed from water level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a man visible struggling in turbulent, dark waters with massive black waves churning with white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man have soaked dark hair clinging to his forehead and a tattered dark gray T-shirt soaking wet and clinging to his body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated only by intermittent, blinding flashes of lightning under a storm-ravaged, moonless sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise and fall with the waves while the man's arms flail and paddle futilely in the current?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14279446005821228 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017794370651245 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14279446005821228, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14279446005821228, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3465600907802582, + 0.1268598735332489, + 0.05533552169799805, + 0.2867220640182495, + 0.046858951449394226, + 0.03260285034775734, + 0.03707294538617134, + 0.024574607610702515, + 0.023762863129377365, + 0.019650176167488098 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14279446005821228 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a shaky, handheld medium close-up filmed from water level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a man visible struggling in turbulent, dark waters with massive black waves churning with white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man have soaked dark hair clinging to his forehead and a tattered dark gray T-shirt soaking wet and clinging to his body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated only by intermittent, blinding flashes of lightning under a storm-ravaged, moonless sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise and fall with the waves while the man's arms flail and paddle futilely in the current?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036185993812978268 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.6286187171936035 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036185993812978268, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036185993812978268, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07740467041730881, + 0.12139102816581726, + 0.016504455357789993, + 0.42484721541404724, + 0.054936353117227554, + 0.061466190963983536, + 0.032254409044981, + 0.034355368465185165, + 0.09992605447769165, + 0.0769142135977745 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036185993812978268 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "shaky, handheld medium close-up shot, filmed from water level, draws the viewer into this struggle for survival. The camera rises and falls with the waves, capturing a man's desperate struggle for survival in the turbulent, dark waters. His soaked, dark hair clings to his forehead and scalp, his face a picture of pure terror—eyes wide and bloodshot with terror, brow furrowed, mouth gaping as if in a silent scream or desperate gasp for air, salty water constantly pouring in and being coughed out. A tattered, dark gray T-shirt, soaking wet, clings tightly to his body, strained by the exertion. Under a storm-ravaged, moonless sky, he is mercilessly tossed up and down by massive, black waves churning with white foam. His arms flail futilely, then desperately paddle, each struggle swallowed by the powerful, icy current, causing his body to heave violently through the water. The only illumination comes from intermittent, blinding flashes of lightning that streak across the sky. Each flash freezes the horrific scene into a painting of intense chiaroscuro, momentarily illuminating his pale face and the chaotic splashes of water around him. The entire scene is permeated with a suffocating sense of despair and humanity's insignificance and helplessness in the face of violent nature, creating an atmosphere of extreme tension and horror.", + "seed": 18396, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_11/index_9156_seed_18396_dp_23_rank_46_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 11, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.0875524716451764, + "vlm_logprob": -0.0875524716451764, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.0875524716451764, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a shaky, handheld medium close-up filmed from water level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a man visible struggling in turbulent, dark waters with massive black waves churning with white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man have soaked dark hair clinging to his forehead and a tattered dark gray T-shirt soaking wet and clinging to his body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated only by intermittent, blinding flashes of lightning under a storm-ravaged, moonless sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise and fall with the waves while the man's arms flail and paddle futilely in the current?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06723502278327942 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.942234992980957 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06723502278327942, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06723502278327942, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1320374757051468, + 0.10098233073949814, + 0.09924560785293579, + 0.06484931707382202, + 0.20819973945617676, + 0.03809017688035965, + 0.12503786385059357, + 0.08643519133329391, + 0.03445807471871376, + 0.11066421866416931 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06723502278327942 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a shaky, handheld medium close-up filmed from water level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a man visible struggling in turbulent, dark waters with massive black waves churning with white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man have soaked dark hair clinging to his forehead and a tattered dark gray T-shirt soaking wet and clinging to his body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated only by intermittent, blinding flashes of lightning under a storm-ravaged, moonless sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise and fall with the waves while the man's arms flail and paddle futilely in the current?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03813666105270386 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881367206573486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03813666105270386, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03813666105270386, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11167307198047638, + 0.12093088775873184, + 0.04782034456729889, + 0.11283741891384125, + 0.20008094608783722, + 0.032442715018987656, + 0.11335303634405136, + 0.117958202958107, + 0.03629458695650101, + 0.10660885274410248 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03813666105270386 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a shaky, handheld medium close-up filmed from water level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a man visible struggling in turbulent, dark waters with massive black waves churning with white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man have soaked dark hair clinging to his forehead and a tattered dark gray T-shirt soaking wet and clinging to his body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated only by intermittent, blinding flashes of lightning under a storm-ravaged, moonless sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise and fall with the waves while the man's arms flail and paddle futilely in the current?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016076579689979553 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141076564788818 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016076579689979553, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016076579689979553, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07401793450117111, + 0.10410311073064804, + 0.07993147522211075, + 0.18058981001377106, + 0.09448979049921036, + 0.044782593846321106, + 0.15861691534519196, + 0.09420953691005707, + 0.046771686524152756, + 0.12248711287975311 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016076579689979553 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a shaky, handheld medium close-up filmed from water level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a man visible struggling in turbulent, dark waters with massive black waves churning with white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man have soaked dark hair clinging to his forehead and a tattered dark gray T-shirt soaking wet and clinging to his body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated only by intermittent, blinding flashes of lightning under a storm-ravaged, moonless sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise and fall with the waves while the man's arms flail and paddle futilely in the current?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.3134869933128357 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134870529174805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.3134869933128357, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.3134869933128357, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08871231228113174, + 0.09580295532941818, + 0.11476647853851318, + 0.09951140731573105, + 0.13549374043941498, + 0.056874413043260574, + 0.0934344008564949, + 0.10151000320911407, + 0.058558154851198196, + 0.15533611178398132 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.3134869933128357 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a shaky, handheld medium close-up filmed from water level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a man visible struggling in turbulent, dark waters with massive black waves churning with white foam?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the man have soaked dark hair clinging to his forehead and a tattered dark gray T-shirt soaking wet and clinging to his body?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated only by intermittent, blinding flashes of lightning under a storm-ravaged, moonless sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera rise and fall with the waves while the man's arms flail and paddle futilely in the current?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028271013870835304 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877827167510986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028271013870835304, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028271013870835304, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15767166018486023, + 0.10442416369915009, + 0.05262713506817818, + 0.0861864686012268, + 0.12085924297571182, + 0.0358632393181324, + 0.18112969398498535, + 0.053613804280757904, + 0.048231203109025955, + 0.1593933403491974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028271013870835304 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_12/index_tensor([8010, 8010])_group_12_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_12/index_tensor([8010, 8010])_group_12_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c9df991f778f1986ab363f2c4e9f33740ee49801 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_12/index_tensor([8010, 8010])_group_12_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static shot, shot from an extremely low angle, captures a majestic, mountain-like, dark gray basalt stele, standing alone on a desolate plain shrouded in mist. Its weathered surface is densely engraved with ancient, intricate hieroglyphs and runes, appearing hazy and mysterious in the cold, diffuse light beneath the gloomy sky. Suddenly, a low, resonating vibration begins to emanate from the very center of the stele, and a tiny crack appears, emanating from within a faint, unnatural blue glow. This luminous crack steadily and inexorably expands towards the top and bottom of the stele, scattering tiny stone chips and dust as the crack widens. The inner light grows increasingly intense, tinting the surrounding mist with an eerie, cold hue. The entire scene is shrouded in an atmosphere of ancient, solemnity, and an untold power, foreshadowing the revelation of an ancient secret.", + "seed": 29106, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_12/index_8010_seed_29106_dp_24_rank_48_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.09075453206896782, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09075453206896782, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09075453206896782, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark gray basalt stele with weathered surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stele standing alone on a desolate plain shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the stele densely engraved with ancient hieroglyphs and runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a crack appear in the center of the stele and expand while emitting a faint unnatural blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009688970632851124 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.759688854217529 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009688970632851124, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009688970632851124, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14394184947013855, + 0.04556933790445328, + 0.11871910095214844, + 0.02847050130367279, + 0.05464191734790802, + 0.07997611910104752, + 0.038937658071517944, + 0.32500210404396057, + 0.07958807051181793, + 0.08515334129333496 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009688970632851124 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark gray basalt stele with weathered surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stele standing alone on a desolate plain shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the stele densely engraved with ancient hieroglyphs and runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a crack appear in the center of the stele and expand while emitting a faint unnatural blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016095934435725212 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141096115112305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016095934435725212, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016095934435725212, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2484663426876068, + 0.2414637953042984, + 0.0661986917257309, + 0.04715616628527641, + 0.05401568487286568, + 0.02990829013288021, + 0.046442627906799316, + 0.05551080033183098, + 0.1713564693927765, + 0.03948108106851578 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016095934435725212 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark gray basalt stele with weathered surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stele standing alone on a desolate plain shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the stele densely engraved with ancient hieroglyphs and runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a crack appear in the center of the stele and expand while emitting a faint unnatural blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812667727470398 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2881267070770264 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812667727470398, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812667727470398, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12082019448280334, + 0.08803734928369522, + 0.159124493598938, + 0.05692203342914581, + 0.09065540879964828, + 0.15045756101608276, + 0.032515592873096466, + 0.17516659200191498, + 0.05321945995092392, + 0.07308131456375122 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812667727470398 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark gray basalt stele with weathered surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stele standing alone on a desolate plain shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the stele densely engraved with ancient hieroglyphs and runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a crack appear in the center of the stele and expand while emitting a faint unnatural blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00282448623329401 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.877824306488037 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00282448623329401, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00282448623329401, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09124955534934998, + 0.07730824500322342, + 0.1041550263762474, + 0.07321157306432724, + 0.06044059619307518, + 0.07351118326187134, + 0.03018062189221382, + 0.19661496579647064, + 0.06077136471867561, + 0.23255686461925507 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00282448623329401 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark gray basalt stele with weathered surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stele standing alone on a desolate plain shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the stele densely engraved with ancient hieroglyphs and runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a crack appear in the center of the stele and expand while emitting a faint unnatural blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38703659176826477 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1370365619659424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38703659176826477, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38703659176826477, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21875137090682983, + 0.11885391920804977, + 0.2601909637451172, + 0.14047978818416595, + 0.04008692130446434, + 0.030964624136686325, + 0.05938497185707092, + 0.06263758987188339, + 0.02725553885102272, + 0.04139429330825806 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38703659176826477 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static shot, shot from an extremely low angle, captures a majestic, mountain-like, dark gray basalt stele, standing alone on a desolate plain shrouded in mist. Its weathered surface is densely engraved with ancient, intricate hieroglyphs and runes, appearing hazy and mysterious in the cold, diffuse light beneath the gloomy sky. Suddenly, a low, resonating vibration begins to emanate from the very center of the stele, and a tiny crack appears, emanating from within a faint, unnatural blue glow. This luminous crack steadily and inexorably expands towards the top and bottom of the stele, scattering tiny stone chips and dust as the crack widens. The inner light grows increasingly intense, tinting the surrounding mist with an eerie, cold hue. The entire scene is shrouded in an atmosphere of ancient, solemnity, and an untold power, foreshadowing the revelation of an ancient secret.", + "seed": 29107, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_12/index_8010_seed_29107_dp_24_rank_48_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.39011632893234494, + "vlm_logprob": -0.39011632893234494, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.39011632893234494, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark gray basalt stele with weathered surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stele standing alone on a desolate plain shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the stele densely engraved with ancient hieroglyphs and runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a crack appear in the center of the stele and expand while emitting a faint unnatural blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.28427553176879883 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.4092755317687988 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.28427553176879883, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.28427553176879883, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18985219299793243, + 0.07092158496379852, + 0.05581488087773323, + 0.041929733008146286, + 0.09764732420444489, + 0.04994804784655571, + 0.03145813196897507, + 0.14678633213043213, + 0.2038011997938156, + 0.1118406355381012 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.28427553176879883 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark gray basalt stele with weathered surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stele standing alone on a desolate plain shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the stele densely engraved with ancient hieroglyphs and runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a crack appear in the center of the stele and expand while emitting a faint unnatural blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026391245424747467 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513912677764893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026391245424747467, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026391245424747467, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3345625102519989, + 0.12736983597278595, + 0.07077978551387787, + 0.0346217043697834, + 0.03381653502583504, + 0.03310771286487579, + 0.04241281747817993, + 0.10080646723508835, + 0.15180052816867828, + 0.0707220807671547 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026391245424747467 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark gray basalt stele with weathered surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stele standing alone on a desolate plain shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the stele densely engraved with ancient hieroglyphs and runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a crack appear in the center of the stele and expand while emitting a faint unnatural blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.0539450645446777 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.42894506454467773 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.0539450645446777, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.0539450645446777, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2174968421459198, + 0.15186630189418793, + 0.06268826127052307, + 0.03640079125761986, + 0.06951940804719925, + 0.04353133589029312, + 0.035213153809309006, + 0.13208548724651337, + 0.12983135879039764, + 0.12136701494455338 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.0539450645446777 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark gray basalt stele with weathered surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stele standing alone on a desolate plain shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the stele densely engraved with ancient hieroglyphs and runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a crack appear in the center of the stele and expand while emitting a faint unnatural blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.009804663248360157 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634804725646973 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.009804663248360157, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.009804663248360157, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10245717316865921, + 0.03648023307323456, + 0.025229809805750847, + 0.025716334581375122, + 0.08276074379682541, + 0.029779361560940742, + 0.03882649540901184, + 0.14466643333435059, + 0.42821547389030457, + 0.08586791902780533 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.009804663248360157 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark gray basalt stele with weathered surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stele standing alone on a desolate plain shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the stele densely engraved with ancient hieroglyphs and runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a crack appear in the center of the stele and expand while emitting a faint unnatural blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5761651396751404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8261651396751404 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.5761651396751404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.5761651396751404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26338374614715576, + 0.0881890133023262, + 0.06284789741039276, + 0.038038961589336395, + 0.04000584036111832, + 0.01952693797647953, + 0.04391220957040787, + 0.15402637422084808, + 0.10925308614969254, + 0.1808159500360489 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.5761651396751404 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static shot, shot from an extremely low angle, captures a majestic, mountain-like, dark gray basalt stele, standing alone on a desolate plain shrouded in mist. Its weathered surface is densely engraved with ancient, intricate hieroglyphs and runes, appearing hazy and mysterious in the cold, diffuse light beneath the gloomy sky. Suddenly, a low, resonating vibration begins to emanate from the very center of the stele, and a tiny crack appears, emanating from within a faint, unnatural blue glow. This luminous crack steadily and inexorably expands towards the top and bottom of the stele, scattering tiny stone chips and dust as the crack widens. The inner light grows increasingly intense, tinting the surrounding mist with an eerie, cold hue. The entire scene is shrouded in an atmosphere of ancient, solemnity, and an untold power, foreshadowing the revelation of an ancient secret.", + "seed": 29108, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_12/index_8010_seed_29108_dp_25_rank_50_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.1278689025202766, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1278689025202766, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.425, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1278689025202766, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark gray basalt stele with weathered surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stele standing alone on a desolate plain shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the stele densely engraved with ancient hieroglyphs and runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a crack appear in the center of the stele and expand while emitting a faint unnatural blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.024999229237437248 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7749991416931152 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.024999229237437248, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.024999229237437248, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3792767822742462, + 0.19348196685314178, + 0.041097842156887054, + 0.054533764719963074, + 0.05956299230456352, + 0.033652596175670624, + 0.05609673634171486, + 0.07502808421850204, + 0.03587162122130394, + 0.07139759510755539 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.024999229237437248 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark gray basalt stele with weathered surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stele standing alone on a desolate plain shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the stele densely engraved with ancient hieroglyphs and runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a crack appear in the center of the stele and expand while emitting a faint unnatural blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012559722177684307 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.38755989074707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012559722177684307, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012559722177684307, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23158803582191467, + 0.06211837753653526, + 0.028634710237383842, + 0.05570916831493378, + 0.034861866384744644, + 0.03570915013551712, + 0.14407937228679657, + 0.28335511684417725, + 0.05973178520798683, + 0.06421243399381638 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012559722177684307 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark gray basalt stele with weathered surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stele standing alone on a desolate plain shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the stele densely engraved with ancient hieroglyphs and runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a crack appear in the center of the stele and expand while emitting a faint unnatural blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521396279335022 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021395683288574 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521396279335022, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521396279335022, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19452188909053802, + 0.07766378670930862, + 0.030720988288521767, + 0.030688149854540825, + 0.03571636602282524, + 0.0866282507777214, + 0.12613211572170258, + 0.18186452984809875, + 0.09072006493806839, + 0.14534389972686768 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521396279335022 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark gray basalt stele with weathered surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stele standing alone on a desolate plain shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the stele densely engraved with ancient hieroglyphs and runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a crack appear in the center of the stele and expand while emitting a faint unnatural blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0010444429935887456 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.876044273376465 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0010444429935887456, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0010444429935887456, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11639942228794098, + 0.04551571607589722, + 0.03825024142861366, + 0.04601360484957695, + 0.02385793626308441, + 0.05913877487182617, + 0.08414188772439957, + 0.12753117084503174, + 0.2064833641052246, + 0.25266793370246887 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0010444429935887456 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark gray basalt stele with weathered surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stele standing alone on a desolate plain shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the stele densely engraved with ancient hieroglyphs and runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a crack appear in the center of the stele and expand while emitting a faint unnatural blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.34860149025917053 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.2236014604568481 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.34860149025917053, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.34860149025917053, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24706584215164185, + 0.05929853394627571, + 0.06111122667789459, + 0.04989389330148697, + 0.053078535944223404, + 0.06410792469978333, + 0.07919050753116608, + 0.19684743881225586, + 0.10467331111431122, + 0.08473281562328339 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.34860149025917053 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static shot, shot from an extremely low angle, captures a majestic, mountain-like, dark gray basalt stele, standing alone on a desolate plain shrouded in mist. Its weathered surface is densely engraved with ancient, intricate hieroglyphs and runes, appearing hazy and mysterious in the cold, diffuse light beneath the gloomy sky. Suddenly, a low, resonating vibration begins to emanate from the very center of the stele, and a tiny crack appears, emanating from within a faint, unnatural blue glow. This luminous crack steadily and inexorably expands towards the top and bottom of the stele, scattering tiny stone chips and dust as the crack widens. The inner light grows increasingly intense, tinting the surrounding mist with an eerie, cold hue. The entire scene is shrouded in an atmosphere of ancient, solemnity, and an untold power, foreshadowing the revelation of an ancient secret.", + "seed": 29109, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_12/index_8010_seed_29109_dp_25_rank_50_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 12, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.2590729295276105, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2590729295276105, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.5, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2590729295276105, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark gray basalt stele with weathered surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stele standing alone on a desolate plain shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the stele densely engraved with ancient hieroglyphs and runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a crack appear in the center of the stele and expand while emitting a faint unnatural blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03501729294657707 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.410017251968384 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03501729294657707, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03501729294657707, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16474144160747528, + 0.061657972633838654, + 0.05613846704363823, + 0.06760912388563156, + 0.02369000017642975, + 0.050654031336307526, + 0.03899409621953964, + 0.07614891976118088, + 0.3559773564338684, + 0.104388527572155 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03501729294657707 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark gray basalt stele with weathered surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stele standing alone on a desolate plain shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the stele densely engraved with ancient hieroglyphs and runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a crack appear in the center of the stele and expand while emitting a faint unnatural blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020613953471183777 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956139087677 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020613953471183777, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020613953471183777, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2577967643737793, + 0.10925321280956268, + 0.06356234103441238, + 0.05071293190121651, + 0.039676178246736526, + 0.03948257118463516, + 0.039941802620887756, + 0.14990267157554626, + 0.16212280094623566, + 0.08754875510931015 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020613953471183777 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark gray basalt stele with weathered surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stele standing alone on a desolate plain shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the stele densely engraved with ancient hieroglyphs and runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a crack appear in the center of the stele and expand while emitting a faint unnatural blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578502297401428 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328502297401428 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.7578502297401428, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.7578502297401428, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19030089676380157, + 0.1216566413640976, + 0.04405956715345383, + 0.0470258966088295, + 0.03250616788864136, + 0.050310708582401276, + 0.044132672250270844, + 0.08164244145154953, + 0.22171449661254883, + 0.16665053367614746 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.7578502297401428 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark gray basalt stele with weathered surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stele standing alone on a desolate plain shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the stele densely engraved with ancient hieroglyphs and runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a crack appear in the center of the stele and expand while emitting a faint unnatural blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007640424650162458 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882640361785889 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007640424650162458, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007640424650162458, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07431776821613312, + 0.04575890302658081, + 0.0197887159883976, + 0.023462245240807533, + 0.04949141666293144, + 0.0334700308740139, + 0.05463523790240288, + 0.1699928343296051, + 0.24181073904037476, + 0.2872720956802368 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007640424650162458 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a dark gray basalt stele with weathered surfaces?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the stele standing alone on a desolate plain shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the stele densely engraved with ancient hieroglyphs and runes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a crack appear in the center of the stele and expand while emitting a faint unnatural blue glow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot captured from an extremely low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4742427468299866 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742427468299866 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4742427468299866, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4742427468299866, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0985875204205513, + 0.05908806622028351, + 0.04914561286568642, + 0.06781207770109177, + 0.02927878126502037, + 0.04056166857481003, + 0.0621316097676754, + 0.21564914286136627, + 0.16027511656284332, + 0.21747034788131714 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4742427468299866 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_13/index_tensor([970, 970])_group_13_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_13/index_tensor([970, 970])_group_13_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b1f492212ed4f27341da5c17ec8f59f9505d9bab --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_13/index_tensor([970, 970])_group_13_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera held still, its focus fixed squarely on a pitch-black crow. It perched securely on a weathered, cracked branch, against a backdrop of a leaden, oppressive sky shrouded in mist. The soft, yet cold, diffuse light precisely outlined each of the crow's feathers, giving them a dark, almost metallic, bluish-purple sheen in the cold light. Its small, obsidian eyes gleamed with a piercing, almost contemptuous intelligence. Suddenly, with a quick, mechanical movement, it tilted its head to one side, as if examining an invisible joke. Then, its throat feathers trembled slightly, its sharp, slightly curved beak opened slightly, and a short, rough, scraping, hoarse cry pierced the bleak silence. Throughout the process, its mocking eyes never leave the camera, creating a gothic, quiet atmosphere full of mystery and foreboding.", + "seed": 30290, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_13/index_970_seed_30290_dp_26_rank_52_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.19727894067764282, + "vlm_logprob": -0.19727894067764282, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 1.925, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.19727894067764282, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pitch-black crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crow perched on a weathered, cracked branch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow exhibit a quick, mechanical head tilt to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a leaden, oppressive sky shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still with a fixed focus on the crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05847002565860748 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9334700107574463 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05847002565860748, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05847002565860748, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21704144775867462, + 0.018783506006002426, + 0.02642250433564186, + 0.026207974180579185, + 0.024937376379966736, + 0.1439334899187088, + 0.11722934991121292, + 0.17042505741119385, + 0.10759977996349335, + 0.14741960167884827 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05847002565860748 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pitch-black crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crow perched on a weathered, cracked branch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow exhibit a quick, mechanical head tilt to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a leaden, oppressive sky shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still with a fixed focus on the crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07007016241550446 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695070266723633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07007016241550446, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07007016241550446, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25671735405921936, + 0.10827232152223587, + 0.07013959437608719, + 0.04907909035682678, + 0.02864115498960018, + 0.10805986821651459, + 0.06788354367017746, + 0.08357823640108109, + 0.0900002121925354, + 0.13762862980365753 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07007016241550446 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pitch-black crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crow perched on a weathered, cracked branch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow exhibit a quick, mechanical head tilt to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a leaden, oppressive sky shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still with a fixed focus on the crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31349918246269226 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134992122650146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31349918246269226, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31349918246269226, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10644454509019852, + 0.044893063604831696, + 0.02605137974023819, + 0.02765435166656971, + 0.024952081963419914, + 0.12533773481845856, + 0.06963688880205154, + 0.3393400311470032, + 0.11286727339029312, + 0.12282261252403259 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31349918246269226 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pitch-black crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crow perched on a weathered, cracked branch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow exhibit a quick, mechanical head tilt to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a leaden, oppressive sky shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still with a fixed focus on the crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07005605101585388 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950559616088867 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07005605101585388, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07005605101585388, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20301270484924316, + 0.09684255719184875, + 0.16982348263263702, + 0.06585022807121277, + 0.09640879929065704, + 0.1197771281003952, + 0.07003208994865417, + 0.08396045118570328, + 0.03443504124879837, + 0.059857506304979324 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07005605101585388 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pitch-black crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crow perched on a weathered, cracked branch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow exhibit a quick, mechanical head tilt to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a leaden, oppressive sky shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still with a fixed focus on the crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47429928183555603 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742993116378784 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47429928183555603, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47429928183555603, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13579122722148895, + 0.053924039006233215, + 0.08376102894544601, + 0.07264579832553864, + 0.03923094645142555, + 0.09084298461675644, + 0.12275931239128113, + 0.1906072050333023, + 0.11899027973413467, + 0.09144718945026398 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47429928183555603 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera held still, its focus fixed squarely on a pitch-black crow. It perched securely on a weathered, cracked branch, against a backdrop of a leaden, oppressive sky shrouded in mist. The soft, yet cold, diffuse light precisely outlined each of the crow's feathers, giving them a dark, almost metallic, bluish-purple sheen in the cold light. Its small, obsidian eyes gleamed with a piercing, almost contemptuous intelligence. Suddenly, with a quick, mechanical movement, it tilted its head to one side, as if examining an invisible joke. Then, its throat feathers trembled slightly, its sharp, slightly curved beak opened slightly, and a short, rough, scraping, hoarse cry pierced the bleak silence. Throughout the process, its mocking eyes never leave the camera, creating a gothic, quiet atmosphere full of mystery and foreboding.", + "seed": 30291, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_13/index_970_seed_30291_dp_26_rank_52_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.2411531570367515, + "vlm_logprob": -0.2411531570367515, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.275000011920929, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.2411531570367515, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pitch-black crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crow perched on a weathered, cracked branch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow exhibit a quick, mechanical head tilt to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a leaden, oppressive sky shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still with a fixed focus on the crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03685064986348152 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.411850690841675 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03685064986348152, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03685064986348152, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22987677156925201, + 0.08702347427606583, + 0.2218146175146103, + 0.06308889389038086, + 0.07411560416221619, + 0.12192343920469284, + 0.03458001837134361, + 0.037452224642038345, + 0.08208699524402618, + 0.048037998378276825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03685064986348152 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pitch-black crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crow perched on a weathered, cracked branch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow exhibit a quick, mechanical head tilt to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a leaden, oppressive sky shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still with a fixed focus on the crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10036499053239822 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350364923477173 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.10036499053239822, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.10036499053239822, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30605971813201904, + 0.08378122001886368, + 0.0697203055024147, + 0.17247220873832703, + 0.08799712359905243, + 0.09525710344314575, + 0.05044197291135788, + 0.0356488898396492, + 0.05689447373151779, + 0.041726987808942795 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.10036499053239822 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pitch-black crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crow perched on a weathered, cracked branch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow exhibit a quick, mechanical head tilt to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a leaden, oppressive sky shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still with a fixed focus on the crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6328721046447754 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.7578721046447754 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6328721046447754, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6328721046447754, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2576645016670227, + 0.09837236255407333, + 0.04494572430849075, + 0.14660459756851196, + 0.2708697021007538, + 0.045433834195137024, + 0.045301422476768494, + 0.030053172260522842, + 0.03758151829242706, + 0.02317313477396965 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6328721046447754 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pitch-black crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crow perched on a weathered, cracked branch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow exhibit a quick, mechanical head tilt to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a leaden, oppressive sky shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still with a fixed focus on the crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006744240876287222 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006744384765625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006744240876287222, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006744240876287222, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1117563545703888, + 0.20029371976852417, + 0.1207929253578186, + 0.03577734902501106, + 0.18206575512886047, + 0.18886956572532654, + 0.04828397557139397, + 0.03480521962046623, + 0.03529658913612366, + 0.042058609426021576 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006744240876287222 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pitch-black crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crow perched on a weathered, cracked branch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow exhibit a quick, mechanical head tilt to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a leaden, oppressive sky shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still with a fixed focus on the crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4289337992668152 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.05393385887146 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4289337992668152, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.6250000596046448, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4289337992668152, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20796504616737366, + 0.0970558449625969, + 0.0800909698009491, + 0.1339447796344757, + 0.05794703960418701, + 0.22727376222610474, + 0.050580792129039764, + 0.021819043904542923, + 0.08734552562236786, + 0.03597716987133026 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4289337992668152 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera held still, its focus fixed squarely on a pitch-black crow. It perched securely on a weathered, cracked branch, against a backdrop of a leaden, oppressive sky shrouded in mist. The soft, yet cold, diffuse light precisely outlined each of the crow's feathers, giving them a dark, almost metallic, bluish-purple sheen in the cold light. Its small, obsidian eyes gleamed with a piercing, almost contemptuous intelligence. Suddenly, with a quick, mechanical movement, it tilted its head to one side, as if examining an invisible joke. Then, its throat feathers trembled slightly, its sharp, slightly curved beak opened slightly, and a short, rough, scraping, hoarse cry pierced the bleak silence. Throughout the process, its mocking eyes never leave the camera, creating a gothic, quiet atmosphere full of mystery and foreboding.", + "seed": 30292, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_13/index_970_seed_30292_dp_27_rank_54_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.22421232536435126, + "vlm_logprob": -0.22421232536435126, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.22421232536435126, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pitch-black crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crow perched on a weathered, cracked branch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow exhibit a quick, mechanical head tilt to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a leaden, oppressive sky shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still with a fixed focus on the crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06478742510080338 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8147873878479004 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06478742510080338, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06478742510080338, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18536598980426788, + 0.17163880169391632, + 0.31559279561042786, + 0.11463683843612671, + 0.05524367466568947, + 0.037360429763793945, + 0.03558281809091568, + 0.05949041619896889, + 0.012418774887919426, + 0.012669486925005913 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06478742510080338 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pitch-black crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crow perched on a weathered, cracked branch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow exhibit a quick, mechanical head tilt to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a leaden, oppressive sky shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still with a fixed focus on the crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03372783586382866 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087278842926025 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03372783586382866, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03372783586382866, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.38235703110694885, + 0.22712503373622894, + 0.11812445521354675, + 0.04430206120014191, + 0.02582903392612934, + 0.06978648900985718, + 0.03457808867096901, + 0.020727932453155518, + 0.011202406138181686, + 0.06596741080284119 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03372783586382866 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pitch-black crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crow perched on a weathered, cracked branch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow exhibit a quick, mechanical head tilt to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a leaden, oppressive sky shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still with a fixed focus on the crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.8983821272850037 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.5233821272850037 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.8983821272850037, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -0.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.8983821272850037, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29371440410614014, + 0.11546498537063599, + 0.14406324923038483, + 0.043447647243738174, + 0.031619079411029816, + 0.054049812257289886, + 0.041405919939279556, + 0.08223282545804977, + 0.13703109323978424, + 0.05697097256779671 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.8983821272850037 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pitch-black crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crow perched on a weathered, cracked branch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow exhibit a quick, mechanical head tilt to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a leaden, oppressive sky shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still with a fixed focus on the crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0620916411280632 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812091588973999 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0620916411280632, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0620916411280632, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3688851296901703, + 0.27848106622695923, + 0.15582633018493652, + 0.03681036829948425, + 0.030471256002783775, + 0.0316559262573719, + 0.038623761385679245, + 0.022412220016121864, + 0.015626320615410805, + 0.02120763063430786 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0620916411280632 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pitch-black crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crow perched on a weathered, cracked branch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow exhibit a quick, mechanical head tilt to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a leaden, oppressive sky shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still with a fixed focus on the crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062072597444057465 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.812072515487671 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062072597444057465, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062072597444057465, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4400191605091095, + 0.10714665800333023, + 0.08733968436717987, + 0.05040720850229263, + 0.0391850508749485, + 0.02170611545443535, + 0.06025955080986023, + 0.0371769480407238, + 0.12757468223571777, + 0.029184922575950623 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062072597444057465 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, the camera held still, its focus fixed squarely on a pitch-black crow. It perched securely on a weathered, cracked branch, against a backdrop of a leaden, oppressive sky shrouded in mist. The soft, yet cold, diffuse light precisely outlined each of the crow's feathers, giving them a dark, almost metallic, bluish-purple sheen in the cold light. Its small, obsidian eyes gleamed with a piercing, almost contemptuous intelligence. Suddenly, with a quick, mechanical movement, it tilted its head to one side, as if examining an invisible joke. Then, its throat feathers trembled slightly, its sharp, slightly curved beak opened slightly, and a short, rough, scraping, hoarse cry pierced the bleak silence. Throughout the process, its mocking eyes never leave the camera, creating a gothic, quiet atmosphere full of mystery and foreboding.", + "seed": 30293, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_13/index_970_seed_30293_dp_27_rank_54_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 13, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.1897644843906164, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1897644843906164, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.45, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1897644843906164, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pitch-black crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crow perched on a weathered, cracked branch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow exhibit a quick, mechanical head tilt to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a leaden, oppressive sky shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still with a fixed focus on the crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.034370411187410355 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5343704223632812 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.034370411187410355, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.034370411187410355, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17565426230430603, + 0.10885956883430481, + 0.0803195908665657, + 0.07377520203590393, + 0.12065782397985458, + 0.13159231841564178, + 0.0853642001748085, + 0.06483635306358337, + 0.10656115412712097, + 0.05237950384616852 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.034370411187410355 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pitch-black crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crow perched on a weathered, cracked branch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow exhibit a quick, mechanical head tilt to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a leaden, oppressive sky shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still with a fixed focus on the crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.062098030000925064 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.8120980262756348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.062098030000925064, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.062098030000925064, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08060135692358017, + 0.052130505442619324, + 0.08672346919775009, + 0.13194912672042847, + 0.03783984109759331, + 0.20375975966453552, + 0.06570395082235336, + 0.11590909212827682, + 0.11026947945356369, + 0.11511342227458954 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.062098030000925064 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pitch-black crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crow perched on a weathered, cracked branch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow exhibit a quick, mechanical head tilt to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a leaden, oppressive sky shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still with a fixed focus on the crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6934213042259216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6934213042259216 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6934213042259216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6934213042259216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0717834010720253, + 0.03844672814011574, + 0.047950379550457, + 0.056799158453941345, + 0.0444839745759964, + 0.06033262610435486, + 0.09989520162343979, + 0.099236398935318, + 0.4020634591579437, + 0.07900863885879517 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6934213042259216 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pitch-black crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crow perched on a weathered, cracked branch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow exhibit a quick, mechanical head tilt to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a leaden, oppressive sky shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still with a fixed focus on the crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016089951619505882 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141089916229248 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016089951619505882, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016089951619505882, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2797924876213074, + 0.29158347845077515, + 0.12445645034313202, + 0.044954899698495865, + 0.050003837794065475, + 0.01948496326804161, + 0.02370612323284149, + 0.0693235844373703, + 0.06910189241170883, + 0.02759220078587532 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016089951619505882 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up of a pitch-black crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the crow perched on a weathered, cracked branch?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the crow exhibit a quick, mechanical head tilt to one side?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the background a leaden, oppressive sky shrouded in mist?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the camera held still with a fixed focus on the crow?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14284272491931915 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178427696228027 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14284272491931915, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14284272491931915, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14517244696617126, + 0.04983428120613098, + 0.05599061772227287, + 0.06363308429718018, + 0.06759133189916611, + 0.04558733478188515, + 0.04488278180360794, + 0.14392024278640747, + 0.21676036715507507, + 0.16662757098674774 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14284272491931915 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_14/index_tensor([858, 858])_group_14_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_14/index_tensor([858, 858])_group_14_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..848d158c17e3b10d4f4415e8e997cdad7b399876 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_14/index_tensor([858, 858])_group_14_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly and majestically pulling back, reveals the full body of a divine phoenix. Perched atop a mysterious, mist-shrouded mountain, at the magical moment between dawn and dusk, its backdrop a deep indigo sky dotted with shimmering stars. The phoenix's core is a ball of blazing golden light, each feather seemingly woven from pure light, creating a vibrant, shimmering display of color. From fiery crimson and liquid gold to deep emerald and sapphire, the colors flow across its wings like an aurora. As its massive wings gracefully unfold, every tiny barb and feather is captured with breathtaking clarity, as if sculpted by divine hand. Then, it slowly raised its long neck, turned its head decorated with gorgeous feathers towards the sky, opened its beak shining with light, and let out a clear and distant cry - this sound was not an ordinary cry, but a pure, visible energy ripple, spreading out from it as the center, making the whole space tremble, creating an extremely sacred, solemn and awe-inspiring epic atmosphere.", + "seed": 20932, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_14/index_858_seed_20932_dp_28_rank_56_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.030512596480548382, + "vlm_logprob": -0.030512596480548382, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.030512596480548382, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up that starts from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the full body of a divine phoenix?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix perched atop a mist-shrouded mountain with a deep indigo sky and stars in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix's core appear as a ball of blazing golden light with feathers woven from pure light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix unfold its massive wings, raise its neck, turn its head, open its beak, and emit a visible energy ripple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04966972395777702 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1746697425842285 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04966972395777702, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04966972395777702, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19996315240859985, + 0.03969893977046013, + 0.03208872303366661, + 0.051067471504211426, + 0.05647158622741699, + 0.038207393139600754, + 0.23677180707454681, + 0.02572314627468586, + 0.02522161230444908, + 0.2947861850261688 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04966972395777702 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up that starts from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the full body of a divine phoenix?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix perched atop a mist-shrouded mountain with a deep indigo sky and stars in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix's core appear as a ball of blazing golden light with feathers woven from pure light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix unfold its massive wings, raise its neck, turn its head, open its beak, and emit a visible energy ripple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01255195215344429 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387551784515381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01255195215344429, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01255195215344429, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0983174666762352, + 0.0433504544198513, + 0.01924462616443634, + 0.0136627908796072, + 0.01930726133286953, + 0.03483658656477928, + 0.0649125799536705, + 0.033844999969005585, + 0.020827868953347206, + 0.6516953110694885 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01255195215344429 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up that starts from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the full body of a divine phoenix?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix perched atop a mist-shrouded mountain with a deep indigo sky and stars in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix's core appear as a ball of blazing golden light with feathers woven from pure light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix unfold its massive wings, raise its neck, turn its head, open its beak, and emit a visible energy ripple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897016406059265 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578970193862915 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897016406059265, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897016406059265, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.33057528734207153, + 0.0648672953248024, + 0.03265204653143883, + 0.08650125563144684, + 0.08877339214086533, + 0.03798341378569603, + 0.03904946520924568, + 0.016741495579481125, + 0.04889895021915436, + 0.2539573311805725 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897016406059265 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up that starts from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the full body of a divine phoenix?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix perched atop a mist-shrouded mountain with a deep indigo sky and stars in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix's core appear as a ball of blazing golden light with feathers woven from pure light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix unfold its massive wings, raise its neck, turn its head, open its beak, and emit a visible energy ripple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0046377950347959995 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379637718200684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0046377950347959995, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0046377950347959995, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3066030442714691, + 0.05251942574977875, + 0.06180231645703316, + 0.06517044454813004, + 0.06919163465499878, + 0.03378947824239731, + 0.043405111879110336, + 0.03708589822053909, + 0.03930576518177986, + 0.29112693667411804 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0046377950347959995 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up that starts from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the full body of a divine phoenix?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix perched atop a mist-shrouded mountain with a deep indigo sky and stars in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix's core appear as a ball of blazing golden light with feathers woven from pure light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix unfold its massive wings, raise its neck, turn its head, open its beak, and emit a visible energy ripple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006733347196131945 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006733417510986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006733347196131945, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006733347196131945, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.027701381593942642, + 0.022451860830187798, + 0.02647254802286625, + 0.018013928085565567, + 0.0369844064116478, + 0.04934713989496231, + 0.08375108987092972, + 0.04947620630264282, + 0.045647505670785904, + 0.6401540040969849 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006733347196131945 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly and majestically pulling back, reveals the full body of a divine phoenix. Perched atop a mysterious, mist-shrouded mountain, at the magical moment between dawn and dusk, its backdrop a deep indigo sky dotted with shimmering stars. The phoenix's core is a ball of blazing golden light, each feather seemingly woven from pure light, creating a vibrant, shimmering display of color. From fiery crimson and liquid gold to deep emerald and sapphire, the colors flow across its wings like an aurora. As its massive wings gracefully unfold, every tiny barb and feather is captured with breathtaking clarity, as if sculpted by divine hand. Then, it slowly raised its long neck, turned its head decorated with gorgeous feathers towards the sky, opened its beak shining with light, and let out a clear and distant cry - this sound was not an ordinary cry, but a pure, visible energy ripple, spreading out from it as the center, making the whole space tremble, creating an extremely sacred, solemn and awe-inspiring epic atmosphere.", + "seed": 20933, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_14/index_858_seed_20933_dp_28_rank_56_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04553552595898509, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04553552595898509, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.774999976158142, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04553552595898509, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up that starts from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the full body of a divine phoenix?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix perched atop a mist-shrouded mountain with a deep indigo sky and stars in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix's core appear as a ball of blazing golden light with feathers woven from pure light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix unfold its massive wings, raise its neck, turn its head, open its beak, and emit a visible energy ripple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04828715696930885 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1732871532440186 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04828715696930885, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04828715696930885, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09365954995155334, + 0.11329016089439392, + 0.026616333052515984, + 0.0947253629565239, + 0.03962714970111847, + 0.08389884233474731, + 0.04702549800276756, + 0.0443582683801651, + 0.2561807334423065, + 0.20061804354190826 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04828715696930885 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up that starts from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the full body of a divine phoenix?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix perched atop a mist-shrouded mountain with a deep indigo sky and stars in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix's core appear as a ball of blazing golden light with feathers woven from pure light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix unfold its massive wings, raise its neck, turn its head, open its beak, and emit a visible energy ripple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023302165791392326 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733020782470703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023302165791392326, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023302165791392326, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1311081051826477, + 0.0788298174738884, + 0.07906237244606018, + 0.13905735313892365, + 0.07815235108137131, + 0.14766263961791992, + 0.06767012923955917, + 0.06860016286373138, + 0.16104069352149963, + 0.04881637915968895 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023302165791392326 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up that starts from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the full body of a divine phoenix?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix perched atop a mist-shrouded mountain with a deep indigo sky and stars in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix's core appear as a ball of blazing golden light with feathers woven from pure light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix unfold its massive wings, raise its neck, turn its head, open its beak, and emit a visible energy ripple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14281068742275238 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.017810583114624 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14281068742275238, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8749998807907104, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14281068742275238, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09745001047849655, + 0.33647048473358154, + 0.0318806916475296, + 0.055201206356287, + 0.06480678170919418, + 0.050781480967998505, + 0.3008754253387451, + 0.019131449982523918, + 0.008936319500207901, + 0.03446623310446739 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14281068742275238 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up that starts from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the full body of a divine phoenix?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix perched atop a mist-shrouded mountain with a deep indigo sky and stars in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix's core appear as a ball of blazing golden light with feathers woven from pure light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix unfold its massive wings, raise its neck, turn its head, open its beak, and emit a visible energy ripple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00464076129719615 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379640579223633 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00464076129719615, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00464076129719615, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07199372351169586, + 0.05692363157868385, + 0.026021497324109077, + 0.03679513931274414, + 0.05240560322999954, + 0.23417408764362335, + 0.3490137755870819, + 0.010833561420440674, + 0.1321919560432434, + 0.02964702434837818 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00464076129719615 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up that starts from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the full body of a divine phoenix?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix perched atop a mist-shrouded mountain with a deep indigo sky and stars in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix's core appear as a ball of blazing golden light with feathers woven from pure light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix unfold its massive wings, raise its neck, turn its head, open its beak, and emit a visible energy ripple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008636858314275742 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758636951446533 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008636858314275742, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008636858314275742, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09112980961799622, + 0.0946921557188034, + 0.07236209511756897, + 0.09255986660718918, + 0.05594354122877121, + 0.2108594924211502, + 0.034979257732629776, + 0.10737757384777069, + 0.03286844119429588, + 0.20722775161266327 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008636858314275742 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly and majestically pulling back, reveals the full body of a divine phoenix. Perched atop a mysterious, mist-shrouded mountain, at the magical moment between dawn and dusk, its backdrop a deep indigo sky dotted with shimmering stars. The phoenix's core is a ball of blazing golden light, each feather seemingly woven from pure light, creating a vibrant, shimmering display of color. From fiery crimson and liquid gold to deep emerald and sapphire, the colors flow across its wings like an aurora. As its massive wings gracefully unfold, every tiny barb and feather is captured with breathtaking clarity, as if sculpted by divine hand. Then, it slowly raised its long neck, turned its head decorated with gorgeous feathers towards the sky, opened its beak shining with light, and let out a clear and distant cry - this sound was not an ordinary cry, but a pure, visible energy ripple, spreading out from it as the center, making the whole space tremble, creating an extremely sacred, solemn and awe-inspiring epic atmosphere.", + "seed": 20934, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_14/index_858_seed_20934_dp_29_rank_58_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.06219651056453586, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06219651056453586, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06219651056453586, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up that starts from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the full body of a divine phoenix?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix perched atop a mist-shrouded mountain with a deep indigo sky and stars in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix's core appear as a ball of blazing golden light with feathers woven from pure light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix unfold its massive wings, raise its neck, turn its head, open its beak, and emit a visible energy ripple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03689545765519142 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.411895513534546 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03689545765519142, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03689545765519142, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20520004630088806, + 0.0556831881403923, + 0.21438537538051605, + 0.08010358363389969, + 0.07006414979696274, + 0.07833217084407806, + 0.11270587891340256, + 0.03706855699419975, + 0.09065663814544678, + 0.055800486356019974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03689545765519142 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up that starts from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the full body of a divine phoenix?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix perched atop a mist-shrouded mountain with a deep indigo sky and stars in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix's core appear as a ball of blazing golden light with feathers woven from pure light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix unfold its massive wings, raise its neck, turn its head, open its beak, and emit a visible energy ripple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029810702428221703 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529810667037964 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029810702428221703, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029810702428221703, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14244168996810913, + 0.061517708003520966, + 0.28179681301116943, + 0.1172395870089531, + 0.03993311896920204, + 0.027178585529327393, + 0.05153926834464073, + 0.09406836330890656, + 0.06843554973602295, + 0.1158493161201477 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029810702428221703 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up that starts from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the full body of a divine phoenix?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix perched atop a mist-shrouded mountain with a deep indigo sky and stars in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix's core appear as a ball of blazing golden light with feathers woven from pure light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix unfold its massive wings, raise its neck, turn its head, open its beak, and emit a visible energy ripple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22557009756565094 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005700826644897 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22557009756565094, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22557009756565094, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17215026915073395, + 0.023386254906654358, + 0.44615188241004944, + 0.08323266357183456, + 0.017191709950566292, + 0.012905248440802097, + 0.05482521653175354, + 0.03155515342950821, + 0.015318785794079304, + 0.14328281581401825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22557009756565094 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up that starts from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the full body of a divine phoenix?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix perched atop a mist-shrouded mountain with a deep indigo sky and stars in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix's core appear as a ball of blazing golden light with feathers woven from pure light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix unfold its massive wings, raise its neck, turn its head, open its beak, and emit a visible energy ripple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007632025051862001 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882632255554199 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007632025051862001, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007632025051862001, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3676187992095947, + 0.18620449304580688, + 0.1529245376586914, + 0.09117252379655838, + 0.027318039909005165, + 0.020373933017253876, + 0.05248099938035011, + 0.02317626401782036, + 0.02625565230846405, + 0.052474770694971085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007632025051862001 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up that starts from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the full body of a divine phoenix?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix perched atop a mist-shrouded mountain with a deep indigo sky and stars in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix's core appear as a ball of blazing golden light with feathers woven from pure light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix unfold its massive wings, raise its neck, turn its head, open its beak, and emit a visible energy ripple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011074270121753216 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511074066162109 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011074270121753216, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011074270121753216, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24581746757030487, + 0.07154301553964615, + 0.10860168188810349, + 0.04072723537683487, + 0.1318410336971283, + 0.04205131158232689, + 0.0741652101278305, + 0.14446455240249634, + 0.05844089761376381, + 0.08234763145446777 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011074270121753216 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "close-up shot from a slightly upward angle, slowly and majestically pulling back, reveals the full body of a divine phoenix. Perched atop a mysterious, mist-shrouded mountain, at the magical moment between dawn and dusk, its backdrop a deep indigo sky dotted with shimmering stars. The phoenix's core is a ball of blazing golden light, each feather seemingly woven from pure light, creating a vibrant, shimmering display of color. From fiery crimson and liquid gold to deep emerald and sapphire, the colors flow across its wings like an aurora. As its massive wings gracefully unfold, every tiny barb and feather is captured with breathtaking clarity, as if sculpted by divine hand. Then, it slowly raised its long neck, turned its head decorated with gorgeous feathers towards the sky, opened its beak shining with light, and let out a clear and distant cry - this sound was not an ordinary cry, but a pure, visible energy ripple, spreading out from it as the center, making the whole space tremble, creating an extremely sacred, solemn and awe-inspiring epic atmosphere.", + "seed": 20935, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_14/index_858_seed_20935_dp_29_rank_58_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 14, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.02784645278006792, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02784645278006792, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.725, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02784645278006792, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up that starts from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the full body of a divine phoenix?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix perched atop a mist-shrouded mountain with a deep indigo sky and stars in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix's core appear as a ball of blazing golden light with feathers woven from pure light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix unfold its massive wings, raise its neck, turn its head, open its beak, and emit a visible energy ripple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.038888439536094666 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.413888454437256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.038888439536094666, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.038888439536094666, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07818622887134552, + 0.07366492599248886, + 0.03009333834052086, + 0.033237162977457047, + 0.025674471631646156, + 0.26455366611480713, + 0.21262629330158234, + 0.2330164760351181, + 0.024649739265441895, + 0.02429768070578575 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.038888439536094666 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up that starts from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the full body of a divine phoenix?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix perched atop a mist-shrouded mountain with a deep indigo sky and stars in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix's core appear as a ball of blazing golden light with feathers woven from pure light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix unfold its massive wings, raise its neck, turn its head, open its beak, and emit a visible energy ripple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023301467299461365 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773301362991333 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023301467299461365, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023301467299461365, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21011397242546082, + 0.12448291480541229, + 0.0819488987326622, + 0.04051215946674347, + 0.09091869741678238, + 0.10086797177791595, + 0.08422752469778061, + 0.07363727688789368, + 0.0912291556596756, + 0.10206148773431778 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023301467299461365 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up that starts from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the full body of a divine phoenix?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix perched atop a mist-shrouded mountain with a deep indigo sky and stars in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix's core appear as a ball of blazing golden light with feathers woven from pure light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix unfold its massive wings, raise its neck, turn its head, open its beak, and emit a visible energy ripple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865375533699989 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486538410186768 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865375533699989, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865375533699989, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09768259525299072, + 0.18510226905345917, + 0.0679880678653717, + 0.10811038315296173, + 0.19470104575157166, + 0.08124805241823196, + 0.04368492215871811, + 0.03878536447882652, + 0.04929659888148308, + 0.13340066373348236 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865375533699989 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up that starts from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the full body of a divine phoenix?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix perched atop a mist-shrouded mountain with a deep indigo sky and stars in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix's core appear as a ball of blazing golden light with feathers woven from pure light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix unfold its massive wings, raise its neck, turn its head, open its beak, and emit a visible energy ripple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014196592383086681 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264196395874023 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014196592383086681, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014196592383086681, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13059304654598236, + 0.10349332541227341, + 0.07006379216909409, + 0.04449821636080742, + 0.09026211500167847, + 0.076090008020401, + 0.06287507712841034, + 0.08340933173894882, + 0.27612319588661194, + 0.06259196251630783 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014196592383086681 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a close-up that starts from a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Does the camera slowly pull back to reveal the full body of a divine phoenix?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the phoenix perched atop a mist-shrouded mountain with a deep indigo sky and stars in the background?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix's core appear as a ball of blazing golden light with feathers woven from pure light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the phoenix unfold its massive wings, raise its neck, turn its head, open its beak, and emit a visible energy ripple?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014192009344696999 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2641921043396 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014192009344696999, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014192009344696999, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09726029634475708, + 0.05653919652104378, + 0.06407605111598969, + 0.08446059376001358, + 0.05948128551244736, + 0.11061280220746994, + 0.1403125524520874, + 0.1126360073685646, + 0.09082675725221634, + 0.18379443883895874 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014192009344696999 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_15/index_tensor([4525, 4525])_group_15_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_15/index_tensor([4525, 4525])_group_15_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..447a4584b4101e06578045dbb996d2962435d187 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_15/index_tensor([4525, 4525])_group_15_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "static, medium shot, held at eye level, frames a large, portly beanbag chair, its rich, dark teal corduroy fabric catching the soft, diffuse light from an unseen window. The chair sits in the center of a cozy, minimalist living room, nestled amidst polished light oak hardwood floors. Initially perfectly upright and charmingly pear-shaped, a subtle tear appears along a prominent, double-stitched seam near the base. A small, almost imperceptible stream of white polystyrene beads begins to escape, quickly escalating into a steady, silent waterfall, forming a growing, snow-like puddle on the floor. With its internal support lost, the chair begins to sag inexorably; gravity pulls downward on the textured fabric, causing it to wrinkle and fold in a slow, deliberate, and almost mournful manner. The chair continues its graceful demise, slowly collapsing into a deflated, crumpled heap, its once-proud form lost in the sprawling white padding, transformed into a formless pile, creating a quiet, almost melancholic atmosphere of inevitable decay.", + "seed": 5078, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_15/index_4525_seed_5078_dp_30_rank_60_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.048071097349748015, + "vlm_logprob": -0.048071097349748015, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.85, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.048071097349748015, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium shot held at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, portly beanbag chair with rich dark teal corduroy fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair start upright and pear-shaped before a tear appears near the base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do white polystyrene beads escape from the tear and form a growing puddle on the light oak hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the chair slowly sag, wrinkle, and collapse into a deflated, crumpled heap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.21145246922969818 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7114524841308594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.21145246922969818, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.21145246922969818, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09054725617170334, + 0.09679731726646423, + 0.042969007045030594, + 0.023163555189967155, + 0.10503270477056503, + 0.1021885797381401, + 0.06196901574730873, + 0.14444591104984283, + 0.19305320084095, + 0.1398334801197052 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.21145246922969818 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium shot held at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, portly beanbag chair with rich dark teal corduroy fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair start upright and pear-shaped before a tear appears near the base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do white polystyrene beads escape from the tear and form a growing puddle on the light oak hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the chair slowly sag, wrinkle, and collapse into a deflated, crumpled heap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022217370569705963 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127221584320068 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022217370569705963, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022217370569705963, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19820363819599152, + 0.04984993860125542, + 0.04436524584889412, + 0.027749836444854736, + 0.08006327599287033, + 0.02573280595242977, + 0.12184727191925049, + 0.13027609884738922, + 0.08214456588029861, + 0.23976729810237885 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022217370569705963 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium shot held at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, portly beanbag chair with rich dark teal corduroy fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair start upright and pear-shaped before a tear appears near the base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do white polystyrene beads escape from the tear and form a growing puddle on the light oak hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the chair slowly sag, wrinkle, and collapse into a deflated, crumpled heap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0233065914362669 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7733066082000732 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0233065914362669, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0233065914362669, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14342248439788818, + 0.019838938489556313, + 0.026782557368278503, + 0.015122604556381702, + 0.04054328054189682, + 0.04202792048454285, + 0.03314078599214554, + 0.06038191542029381, + 0.08126933872699738, + 0.5374701619148254 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0233065914362669 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium shot held at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, portly beanbag chair with rich dark teal corduroy fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair start upright and pear-shaped before a tear appears near the base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do white polystyrene beads escape from the tear and form a growing puddle on the light oak hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the chair slowly sag, wrinkle, and collapse into a deflated, crumpled heap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0011803095694631338 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.751180171966553 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0011803095694631338, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0011803095694631338, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07568524777889252, + 0.020079411566257477, + 0.019629068672657013, + 0.010994920507073402, + 0.05067482218146324, + 0.018439698964357376, + 0.032977763563394547, + 0.035049062222242355, + 0.07160502672195435, + 0.6648649573326111 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0011803095694631338 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium shot held at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, portly beanbag chair with rich dark teal corduroy fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair start upright and pear-shaped before a tear appears near the base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do white polystyrene beads escape from the tear and form a growing puddle on the light oak hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the chair slowly sag, wrinkle, and collapse into a deflated, crumpled heap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021943794563412666 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127194404602051 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021943794563412666, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021943794563412666, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11293522268533707, + 0.05699511989951134, + 0.028971366584300995, + 0.022774025797843933, + 0.041282735764980316, + 0.02033388242125511, + 0.04167845472693443, + 0.12344646453857422, + 0.21100933849811554, + 0.34057340025901794 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021943794563412666 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, medium shot, held at eye level, frames a large, portly beanbag chair, its rich, dark teal corduroy fabric catching the soft, diffuse light from an unseen window. The chair sits in the center of a cozy, minimalist living room, nestled amidst polished light oak hardwood floors. Initially perfectly upright and charmingly pear-shaped, a subtle tear appears along a prominent, double-stitched seam near the base. A small, almost imperceptible stream of white polystyrene beads begins to escape, quickly escalating into a steady, silent waterfall, forming a growing, snow-like puddle on the floor. With its internal support lost, the chair begins to sag inexorably; gravity pulls downward on the textured fabric, causing it to wrinkle and fold in a slow, deliberate, and almost mournful manner. The chair continues its graceful demise, slowly collapsing into a deflated, crumpled heap, its once-proud form lost in the sprawling white padding, transformed into a formless pile, creating a quiet, almost melancholic atmosphere of inevitable decay.", + "seed": 5079, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_15/index_4525_seed_5079_dp_30_rank_60_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.04081581374630332, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04081581374630332, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.225, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04081581374630332, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium shot held at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, portly beanbag chair with rich dark teal corduroy fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair start upright and pear-shaped before a tear appears near the base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do white polystyrene beads escape from the tear and form a growing puddle on the light oak hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the chair slowly sag, wrinkle, and collapse into a deflated, crumpled heap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.13510243594646454 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1351025104522705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.13510243594646454, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.13510243594646454, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17209410667419434, + 0.01714460924267769, + 0.13715636730194092, + 0.13001956045627594, + 0.03576517105102539, + 0.028016986325383186, + 0.25538045167922974, + 0.029817814007401466, + 0.05913173779845238, + 0.13547323644161224 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.13510243594646454 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium shot held at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, portly beanbag chair with rich dark teal corduroy fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair start upright and pear-shaped before a tear appears near the base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do white polystyrene beads escape from the tear and form a growing puddle on the light oak hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the chair slowly sag, wrinkle, and collapse into a deflated, crumpled heap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003642830066382885 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628643035888672 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003642830066382885, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003642830066382885, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4272467792034149, + 0.06987584382295609, + 0.019804541021585464, + 0.08796486258506775, + 0.09367312490940094, + 0.025562632828950882, + 0.1336851716041565, + 0.023120924830436707, + 0.05347432196140289, + 0.06559183448553085 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003642830066382885 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium shot held at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, portly beanbag chair with rich dark teal corduroy fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair start upright and pear-shaped before a tear appears near the base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do white polystyrene beads escape from the tear and form a growing puddle on the light oak hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the chair slowly sag, wrinkle, and collapse into a deflated, crumpled heap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05498351901769638 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.929983615875244 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05498351901769638, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05498351901769638, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28620558977127075, + 0.043706014752388, + 0.08994987607002258, + 0.11522571742534637, + 0.036333292722702026, + 0.02717183157801628, + 0.16984683275222778, + 0.02153155766427517, + 0.06798625737428665, + 0.1420430988073349 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05498351901769638 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium shot held at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, portly beanbag chair with rich dark teal corduroy fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair start upright and pear-shaped before a tear appears near the base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do white polystyrene beads escape from the tear and form a growing puddle on the light oak hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the chair slowly sag, wrinkle, and collapse into a deflated, crumpled heap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036168177612125874 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628616809844971 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036168177612125874, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036168177612125874, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1127619817852974, + 0.19730278849601746, + 0.09992150217294693, + 0.05745325982570648, + 0.05499841272830963, + 0.03911390155553818, + 0.25627627968788147, + 0.024695882573723793, + 0.05953070893883705, + 0.09794522821903229 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036168177612125874 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium shot held at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, portly beanbag chair with rich dark teal corduroy fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair start upright and pear-shaped before a tear appears near the base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do white polystyrene beads escape from the tear and form a growing puddle on the light oak hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the chair slowly sag, wrinkle, and collapse into a deflated, crumpled heap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006733465939760208 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006733417510986 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006733465939760208, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006733465939760208, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11414164304733276, + 0.09152518212795258, + 0.17371419072151184, + 0.07611381262540817, + 0.07391343265771866, + 0.05675007402896881, + 0.22940568625926971, + 0.0358879379928112, + 0.04754538834095001, + 0.10100263357162476 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006733465939760208 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, medium shot, held at eye level, frames a large, portly beanbag chair, its rich, dark teal corduroy fabric catching the soft, diffuse light from an unseen window. The chair sits in the center of a cozy, minimalist living room, nestled amidst polished light oak hardwood floors. Initially perfectly upright and charmingly pear-shaped, a subtle tear appears along a prominent, double-stitched seam near the base. A small, almost imperceptible stream of white polystyrene beads begins to escape, quickly escalating into a steady, silent waterfall, forming a growing, snow-like puddle on the floor. With its internal support lost, the chair begins to sag inexorably; gravity pulls downward on the textured fabric, causing it to wrinkle and fold in a slow, deliberate, and almost mournful manner. The chair continues its graceful demise, slowly collapsing into a deflated, crumpled heap, its once-proud form lost in the sprawling white padding, transformed into a formless pile, creating a quiet, almost melancholic atmosphere of inevitable decay.", + "seed": 5080, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_15/index_4525_seed_5080_dp_31_rank_62_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.04624245241284371, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04624245241284371, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04624245241284371, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium shot held at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, portly beanbag chair with rich dark teal corduroy fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair start upright and pear-shaped before a tear appears near the base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do white polystyrene beads escape from the tear and form a growing puddle on the light oak hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the chair slowly sag, wrinkle, and collapse into a deflated, crumpled heap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18852287530899048 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8135228157043457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18852287530899048, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18852287530899048, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14940199255943298, + 0.11992959678173065, + 0.07255736738443375, + 0.02731987088918686, + 0.19253747165203094, + 0.041318558156490326, + 0.049803271889686584, + 0.08284303545951843, + 0.1030031219124794, + 0.16128575801849365 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18852287530899048 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium shot held at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, portly beanbag chair with rich dark teal corduroy fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair start upright and pear-shaped before a tear appears near the base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do white polystyrene beads escape from the tear and form a growing puddle on the light oak hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the chair slowly sag, wrinkle, and collapse into a deflated, crumpled heap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007655567489564419 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882655620574951 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007655567489564419, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007655567489564419, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1556105762720108, + 0.3084411919116974, + 0.15998142957687378, + 0.07958938181400299, + 0.0493357814848423, + 0.03523401916027069, + 0.09594014286994934, + 0.00889082346111536, + 0.048075687140226364, + 0.058900993317365646 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007655567489564419 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium shot held at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, portly beanbag chair with rich dark teal corduroy fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair start upright and pear-shaped before a tear appears near the base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do white polystyrene beads escape from the tear and form a growing puddle on the light oak hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the chair slowly sag, wrinkle, and collapse into a deflated, crumpled heap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023310784250497818 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.773310899734497 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023310784250497818, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023310784250497818, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23320691287517548, + 0.10741490870714188, + 0.03766733407974243, + 0.06758754700422287, + 0.05418078228831291, + 0.07134393602609634, + 0.044248975813388824, + 0.02206808514893055, + 0.1467829942703247, + 0.21549846231937408 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023310784250497818 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium shot held at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, portly beanbag chair with rich dark teal corduroy fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair start upright and pear-shaped before a tear appears near the base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do white polystyrene beads escape from the tear and form a growing puddle on the light oak hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the chair slowly sag, wrinkle, and collapse into a deflated, crumpled heap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004096688237041235 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504096508026123 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004096688237041235, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004096688237041235, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15275034308433533, + 0.14290884137153625, + 0.074367456138134, + 0.020794624462723732, + 0.00991878006607294, + 0.22279997169971466, + 0.05995737388730049, + 0.024767359718680382, + 0.030207814648747444, + 0.26152747869491577 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004096688237041235 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium shot held at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, portly beanbag chair with rich dark teal corduroy fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair start upright and pear-shaped before a tear appears near the base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do white polystyrene beads escape from the tear and form a growing puddle on the light oak hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the chair slowly sag, wrinkle, and collapse into a deflated, crumpled heap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007626346778124571 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882626533508301 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007626346778124571, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007626346778124571, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1173391118645668, + 0.07115326076745987, + 0.0719456672668457, + 0.11111355572938919, + 0.018821191042661667, + 0.1003095880150795, + 0.08677264302968979, + 0.04755137115716934, + 0.29460129141807556, + 0.08039228618144989 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007626346778124571 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "static, medium shot, held at eye level, frames a large, portly beanbag chair, its rich, dark teal corduroy fabric catching the soft, diffuse light from an unseen window. The chair sits in the center of a cozy, minimalist living room, nestled amidst polished light oak hardwood floors. Initially perfectly upright and charmingly pear-shaped, a subtle tear appears along a prominent, double-stitched seam near the base. A small, almost imperceptible stream of white polystyrene beads begins to escape, quickly escalating into a steady, silent waterfall, forming a growing, snow-like puddle on the floor. With its internal support lost, the chair begins to sag inexorably; gravity pulls downward on the textured fabric, causing it to wrinkle and fold in a slow, deliberate, and almost mournful manner. The chair continues its graceful demise, slowly collapsing into a deflated, crumpled heap, its once-proud form lost in the sprawling white padding, transformed into a formless pile, creating a quiet, almost melancholic atmosphere of inevitable decay.", + "seed": 5081, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_15/index_4525_seed_5081_dp_31_rank_62_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 15, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04605567986145616, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04605567986145616, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04605567986145616, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium shot held at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, portly beanbag chair with rich dark teal corduroy fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair start upright and pear-shaped before a tear appears near the base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do white polystyrene beads escape from the tear and form a growing puddle on the light oak hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the chair slowly sag, wrinkle, and collapse into a deflated, crumpled heap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20757198333740234 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7075719833374023 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20757198333740234, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20757198333740234, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05520380660891533, + 0.09194698929786682, + 0.034315578639507294, + 0.2527424395084381, + 0.22892031073570251, + 0.05381251871585846, + 0.03328507021069527, + 0.11355972290039062, + 0.05435638129711151, + 0.08185722678899765 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 4, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20757198333740234 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium shot held at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, portly beanbag chair with rich dark teal corduroy fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair start upright and pear-shaped before a tear appears near the base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do white polystyrene beads escape from the tear and form a growing puddle on the light oak hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the chair slowly sag, wrinkle, and collapse into a deflated, crumpled heap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002221499104052782 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127221584320068 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002221499104052782, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002221499104052782, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12396437674760818, + 0.05993364378809929, + 0.05053238570690155, + 0.12582455575466156, + 0.25703391432762146, + 0.052780456840991974, + 0.08889342844486237, + 0.14845235645771027, + 0.03233418986201286, + 0.06025069206953049 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002221499104052782 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium shot held at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, portly beanbag chair with rich dark teal corduroy fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair start upright and pear-shaped before a tear appears near the base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do white polystyrene beads escape from the tear and form a growing puddle on the light oak hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the chair slowly sag, wrinkle, and collapse into a deflated, crumpled heap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016088545322418213 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141088485717773 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016088545322418213, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016088545322418213, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1292228400707245, + 0.13939543068408966, + 0.024515442550182343, + 0.04745778813958168, + 0.092390276491642, + 0.09556129574775696, + 0.0781511589884758, + 0.3346084654331207, + 0.03515704721212387, + 0.023540247231721878 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016088545322418213 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium shot held at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, portly beanbag chair with rich dark teal corduroy fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair start upright and pear-shaped before a tear appears near the base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do white polystyrene beads escape from the tear and form a growing puddle on the light oak hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the chair slowly sag, wrinkle, and collapse into a deflated, crumpled heap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002200207905843854 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127200126647949 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002200207905843854, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002200207905843854, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15024785697460175, + 0.057572875171899796, + 0.029616832733154297, + 0.0705346092581749, + 0.0504995696246624, + 0.1799328625202179, + 0.03967541456222534, + 0.3377639353275299, + 0.04865539073944092, + 0.035500720143318176 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002200207905843854 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot a static medium shot held at eye level?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large, portly beanbag chair with rich dark teal corduroy fabric?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the chair start upright and pear-shaped before a tear appears near the base?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Do white polystyrene beads escape from the tear and form a growing puddle on the light oak hardwood floor?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the chair slowly sag, wrinkle, and collapse into a deflated, crumpled heap?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0021961636375635862 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127196311950684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0021961636375635862, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0021961636375635862, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08753260970115662, + 0.052414920181035995, + 0.018675198778510094, + 0.017610881477594376, + 0.0685461163520813, + 0.02509056031703949, + 0.041235700249671936, + 0.5628086924552917, + 0.05069976672530174, + 0.07538560777902603 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0021961636375635862 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_2/index_tensor([8831, 8831])_group_2_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_2/index_tensor([8831, 8831])_group_2_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8b4bbaea3001db3701ebb8e2eef6385cd4894890 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_2/index_tensor([8831, 8831])_group_2_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dramatic, low-angle, 360-degree pan shot sweeps across an ancient overlord, towering atop a windswept mountain. He clad in a heavy suit of black iron armor intricately carved with dragon patterns. Each plate was meticulously polished, its edges bearing the wear and tear of battle. Under the smoky, dark red sunset sky, the metal gleamed with a deep, dark metallic sheen. A ferocious, beast-faced helmet adorned his head, revealing only his resolute jaw and a pair of hawk-like eyes piercing through the shadows. As the camera panned steadily and continuously, his right hand, clad in a fully metal gauntlet, grasped the hilt of the greatsword hanging from his waist with a swift and decisive gesture, his knuckles tensing with the force. Then, with a sudden, piercing, clanking sound, he unsheathed the vast, heavy sword. With ultra-realistic rendering, the newly unsheathed sword instantly captures and reflects the last ray of light from the horizon, emitting a chilling glint. The sharpness of the blade and the weight of the sword are vividly portrayed. Finally, he raises the sword high above his head, then points the tip forward with a steady and deliberate movement. The entire movement is filled with a sense of unparalleled power and the deterrent power that will sweep across the battlefield, creating an epic and tense atmosphere.", + "seed": 13639, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_2/index_8831_seed_13639_dp_4_rank_8_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.36813309146091344, + "vlm_logprob": -0.36813309146091344, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.36813309146091344, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient overlord wearing black iron armor with dragon patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a windswept mountain under a smoky dark red sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character unsheathe a greatsword and raise it high above his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light from the horizon with a visible glint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.18759390711784363 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.812593936920166 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.18759390711784363, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.18759390711784363, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07926949113607407, + 0.12459346652030945, + 0.07163137197494507, + 0.054449599236249924, + 0.053786396980285645, + 0.02405749261379242, + 0.05950178578495979, + 0.13834406435489655, + 0.10194578766822815, + 0.29242056608200073 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.18759390711784363 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient overlord wearing black iron armor with dragon patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a windswept mountain under a smoky dark red sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character unsheathe a greatsword and raise it high above his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light from the horizon with a visible glint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004647406283766031 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379647254943848 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004647406283766031, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004647406283766031, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05836114659905434, + 0.08635066449642181, + 0.04521481320261955, + 0.05169689282774925, + 0.030291955918073654, + 0.03753130882978439, + 0.07121588289737701, + 0.06867684423923492, + 0.11961430311203003, + 0.43104618787765503 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004647406283766031 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient overlord wearing black iron armor with dragon patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a windswept mountain under a smoky dark red sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character unsheathe a greatsword and raise it high above his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light from the horizon with a visible glint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005057096481323 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22550567984580994 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.6005057096481323, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -1.6005057096481323, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.031774092465639114, + 0.01139413844794035, + 0.023823192343115807, + 0.022484326735138893, + 0.025993941351771355, + 0.013878784142434597, + 0.04946577548980713, + 0.019055716693401337, + 0.04955873265862465, + 0.7525713443756104 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.6005057096481323 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient overlord wearing black iron armor with dragon patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a windswept mountain under a smoky dark red sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character unsheathe a greatsword and raise it high above his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light from the horizon with a visible glint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.014208345673978329 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.2642083168029785 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.014208345673978329, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.014208345673978329, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.013570064678788185, + 0.020705197006464005, + 0.01446940004825592, + 0.023744191974401474, + 0.010961349122226238, + 0.007230023387819529, + 0.009643970988690853, + 0.012746650725603104, + 0.053226325660943985, + 0.833702802658081 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.014208345673978329 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient overlord wearing black iron armor with dragon patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a windswept mountain under a smoky dark red sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character unsheathe a greatsword and raise it high above his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light from the horizon with a visible glint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033710088580846786 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.40871000289917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033710088580846786, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033710088580846786, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.020178895443677902, + 0.015655040740966797, + 0.010314173065125942, + 0.016225188970565796, + 0.012854892760515213, + 0.01528561394661665, + 0.028056152164936066, + 0.011400148272514343, + 0.012707808054983616, + 0.8573220372200012 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033710088580846786 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic, low-angle, 360-degree pan shot sweeps across an ancient overlord, towering atop a windswept mountain. He clad in a heavy suit of black iron armor intricately carved with dragon patterns. Each plate was meticulously polished, its edges bearing the wear and tear of battle. Under the smoky, dark red sunset sky, the metal gleamed with a deep, dark metallic sheen. A ferocious, beast-faced helmet adorned his head, revealing only his resolute jaw and a pair of hawk-like eyes piercing through the shadows. As the camera panned steadily and continuously, his right hand, clad in a fully metal gauntlet, grasped the hilt of the greatsword hanging from his waist with a swift and decisive gesture, his knuckles tensing with the force. Then, with a sudden, piercing, clanking sound, he unsheathed the vast, heavy sword. With ultra-realistic rendering, the newly unsheathed sword instantly captures and reflects the last ray of light from the horizon, emitting a chilling glint. The sharpness of the blade and the weight of the sword are vividly portrayed. Finally, he raises the sword high above his head, then points the tip forward with a steady and deliberate movement. The entire movement is filled with a sense of unparalleled power and the deterrent power that will sweep across the battlefield, creating an epic and tense atmosphere.", + "seed": 13640, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_2/index_8831_seed_13640_dp_4_rank_8_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.4053897579200566, + "vlm_logprob": -0.4053897579200566, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.775, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.4053897579200566, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient overlord wearing black iron armor with dragon patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a windswept mountain under a smoky dark red sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character unsheathe a greatsword and raise it high above his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light from the horizon with a visible glint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16409286856651306 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9140928983688354 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16409286856651306, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16409286856651306, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24279826879501343, + 0.11964992433786392, + 0.10961586236953735, + 0.13902197778224945, + 0.03870531544089317, + 0.0663062334060669, + 0.07173171639442444, + 0.08716706931591034, + 0.08465737104415894, + 0.04034626856446266 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16409286856651306 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient overlord wearing black iron armor with dragon patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a windswept mountain under a smoky dark red sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character unsheathe a greatsword and raise it high above his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light from the horizon with a visible glint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00409882515668869 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504098892211914 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00409882515668869, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00409882515668869, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34749242663383484, + 0.09077107906341553, + 0.08408152312040329, + 0.03433819115161896, + 0.053122181445360184, + 0.05096206068992615, + 0.12776309251785278, + 0.07640599459409714, + 0.07264919579029083, + 0.0624142624437809 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00409882515668869 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient overlord wearing black iron armor with dragon patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a windswept mountain under a smoky dark red sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character unsheathe a greatsword and raise it high above his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light from the horizon with a visible glint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8048303127288818 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17983029782772064 + ], + "logprob_reward": -1.8048303127288818, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -1.8048303127288818, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11961085349321365, + 0.09638487547636032, + 0.0634705126285553, + 0.21725644171237946, + 0.030208876356482506, + 0.04887866973876953, + 0.05874371901154518, + 0.06227058917284012, + 0.25320935249328613, + 0.049966126680374146 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -1.8048303127288818 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient overlord wearing black iron armor with dragon patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a windswept mountain under a smoky dark red sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character unsheathe a greatsword and raise it high above his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light from the horizon with a visible glint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00525747099891305 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255257606506348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00525747099891305, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00525747099891305, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.11770185083150864, + 0.11540354788303375, + 0.15751606225967407, + 0.08736336976289749, + 0.03322160989046097, + 0.04944511130452156, + 0.037548333406448364, + 0.06664629280567169, + 0.1914982944726944, + 0.1436554491519928 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00525747099891305 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient overlord wearing black iron armor with dragon patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a windswept mountain under a smoky dark red sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character unsheathe a greatsword and raise it high above his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light from the horizon with a visible glint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04866931214928627 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486693382263184 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04866931214928627, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04866931214928627, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09733106940984726, + 0.09107507020235062, + 0.1051953136920929, + 0.11594558507204056, + 0.07881143689155579, + 0.0736636370420456, + 0.08215659856796265, + 0.06298426538705826, + 0.10208285599946976, + 0.19075419008731842 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04866931214928627 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic, low-angle, 360-degree pan shot sweeps across an ancient overlord, towering atop a windswept mountain. He clad in a heavy suit of black iron armor intricately carved with dragon patterns. Each plate was meticulously polished, its edges bearing the wear and tear of battle. Under the smoky, dark red sunset sky, the metal gleamed with a deep, dark metallic sheen. A ferocious, beast-faced helmet adorned his head, revealing only his resolute jaw and a pair of hawk-like eyes piercing through the shadows. As the camera panned steadily and continuously, his right hand, clad in a fully metal gauntlet, grasped the hilt of the greatsword hanging from his waist with a swift and decisive gesture, his knuckles tensing with the force. Then, with a sudden, piercing, clanking sound, he unsheathed the vast, heavy sword. With ultra-realistic rendering, the newly unsheathed sword instantly captures and reflects the last ray of light from the horizon, emitting a chilling glint. The sharpness of the blade and the weight of the sword are vividly portrayed. Finally, he raises the sword high above his head, then points the tip forward with a steady and deliberate movement. The entire movement is filled with a sense of unparalleled power and the deterrent power that will sweep across the battlefield, creating an epic and tense atmosphere.", + "seed": 13641, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_2/index_8831_seed_13641_dp_5_rank_10_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.5413354767486454, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5413354767486454, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.025, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5413354767486454, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient overlord wearing black iron armor with dragon patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a windswept mountain under a smoky dark red sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character unsheathe a greatsword and raise it high above his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light from the horizon with a visible glint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2565547227859497 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5065547227859497 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2565547227859497, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2565547227859497, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14995300769805908, + 0.08871452510356903, + 0.07950546592473984, + 0.06937071681022644, + 0.21948882937431335, + 0.05288121476769447, + 0.06770691275596619, + 0.1764303594827652, + 0.04488025978207588, + 0.05106871575117111 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2565547227859497 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient overlord wearing black iron armor with dragon patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a windswept mountain under a smoky dark red sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character unsheathe a greatsword and raise it high above his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light from the horizon with a visible glint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006741280667483807 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006741046905518 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006741280667483807, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006741280667483807, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13863249123096466, + 0.0902642235159874, + 0.13848866522312164, + 0.05489812418818474, + 0.17256376147270203, + 0.08129854500293732, + 0.09055247902870178, + 0.07137148827314377, + 0.04789657145738602, + 0.11403359472751617 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006741280667483807 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient overlord wearing black iron armor with dragon patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a windswept mountain under a smoky dark red sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character unsheathe a greatsword and raise it high above his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light from the horizon with a visible glint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350271463394165 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10027139633893967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.350271463394165, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -2.350271463394165, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08500891178846359, + 0.07141514122486115, + 0.14565104246139526, + 0.02763422206044197, + 0.1638883650302887, + 0.09107830375432968, + 0.03886215388774872, + 0.09460373967885971, + 0.09415846318006516, + 0.18769961595535278 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.350271463394165 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient overlord wearing black iron armor with dragon patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a windswept mountain under a smoky dark red sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character unsheathe a greatsword and raise it high above his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light from the horizon with a visible glint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05498645454645157 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299864768981934 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05498645454645157, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05498645454645157, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05172939598560333, + 0.08925819396972656, + 0.08358674496412277, + 0.041707128286361694, + 0.1290171891450882, + 0.04978489503264427, + 0.0466328002512455, + 0.3877597749233246, + 0.0481124147772789, + 0.07241141051054001 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 4, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05498645454645157 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient overlord wearing black iron armor with dragon patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a windswept mountain under a smoky dark red sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character unsheathe a greatsword and raise it high above his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light from the horizon with a visible glint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812346234917641 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288123369216919 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812346234917641, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812346234917641, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1149708703160286, + 0.07260988652706146, + 0.1306610405445099, + 0.03774629160761833, + 0.04819858819246292, + 0.13140682876110077, + 0.04726938530802727, + 0.2051934450864792, + 0.09967249631881714, + 0.11227112263441086 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812346234917641 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dramatic, low-angle, 360-degree pan shot sweeps across an ancient overlord, towering atop a windswept mountain. He clad in a heavy suit of black iron armor intricately carved with dragon patterns. Each plate was meticulously polished, its edges bearing the wear and tear of battle. Under the smoky, dark red sunset sky, the metal gleamed with a deep, dark metallic sheen. A ferocious, beast-faced helmet adorned his head, revealing only his resolute jaw and a pair of hawk-like eyes piercing through the shadows. As the camera panned steadily and continuously, his right hand, clad in a fully metal gauntlet, grasped the hilt of the greatsword hanging from his waist with a swift and decisive gesture, his knuckles tensing with the force. Then, with a sudden, piercing, clanking sound, he unsheathed the vast, heavy sword. With ultra-realistic rendering, the newly unsheathed sword instantly captures and reflects the last ray of light from the horizon, emitting a chilling glint. The sharpness of the blade and the weight of the sword are vividly portrayed. Finally, he raises the sword high above his head, then points the tip forward with a steady and deliberate movement. The entire movement is filled with a sense of unparalleled power and the deterrent power that will sweep across the battlefield, creating an epic and tense atmosphere.", + "seed": 13642, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_2/index_8831_seed_13642_dp_5_rank_10_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 2, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.5057265806011856, + "vlm_logprob": -0.5057265806011856, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.625, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.5057265806011856, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient overlord wearing black iron armor with dragon patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a windswept mountain under a smoky dark red sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character unsheathe a greatsword and raise it high above his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light from the horizon with a visible glint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.13189589977264404 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1318960189819336 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.13189589977264404, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.13189589977264404, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1967877298593521, + 0.139771968126297, + 0.038958098739385605, + 0.08155806362628937, + 0.03455640748143196, + 0.043209124356508255, + 0.08541413396596909, + 0.1206551343202591, + 0.07410968840122223, + 0.184979647397995 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.13189589977264404 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient overlord wearing black iron armor with dragon patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a windswept mountain under a smoky dark red sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character unsheathe a greatsword and raise it high above his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light from the horizon with a visible glint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004098231438547373 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504098415374756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004098231438547373, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004098231438547373, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09311006963253021, + 0.12727664411067963, + 0.116184763610363, + 0.11384974420070648, + 0.06757199764251709, + 0.05113852024078369, + 0.06632937490940094, + 0.23651714622974396, + 0.05770634487271309, + 0.07031535357236862 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004098231438547373 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient overlord wearing black iron armor with dragon patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a windswept mountain under a smoky dark red sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character unsheathe a greatsword and raise it high above his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light from the horizon with a visible glint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.350264310836792 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.10026427358388901 + ], + "logprob_reward": -2.350264310836792, + "yes_no_margin_reward": -2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -2.350264310836792, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06557401269674301, + 0.1565931886434555, + 0.08934638649225235, + 0.07522732019424438, + 0.0389644019305706, + 0.03484953194856644, + 0.03681481257081032, + 0.17761565744876862, + 0.17690254747867584, + 0.14811211824417114 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -2.350264310836792 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient overlord wearing black iron armor with dragon patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a windswept mountain under a smoky dark red sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character unsheathe a greatsword and raise it high above his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light from the horizon with a visible glint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012552187778055668 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387552261352539 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012552187778055668, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012552187778055668, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07955799251794815, + 0.15141327679157257, + 0.06094813346862793, + 0.0711551085114479, + 0.04173150658607483, + 0.06327670812606812, + 0.05154184252023697, + 0.07261881232261658, + 0.1657225787639618, + 0.24203403294086456 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012552187778055668 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject an ancient overlord wearing black iron armor with dragon patterns?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a windswept mountain under a smoky dark red sunset sky?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera perform a 360-degree pan shot?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the character unsheathe a greatsword and raise it high above his head?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the unsheathed sword reflect light from the horizon with a visible glint?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029822273179888725 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.52982234954834 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029822273179888725, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029822273179888725, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0885053277015686, + 0.040003452450037, + 0.044769756495952606, + 0.03530782461166382, + 0.054069437086582184, + 0.06805107742547989, + 0.05675056204199791, + 0.23402182757854462, + 0.12236043810844421, + 0.25616028904914856 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029822273179888725 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_3/index_tensor([9372, 9372])_group_3_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_3/index_tensor([9372, 9372])_group_3_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..46021d303f89ff1d9fa488b77527c9c3ed5aa144 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_3/index_tensor([9372, 9372])_group_3_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "dynamic, ultra-wide-angle drone shot, captured from a slightly low angle, follows a vintage red convertible sports car as it speeds along a winding coastal asphalt road. Inside, a young Asian woman holds the steering wheel steadily, her classic aviator sunglasses reflecting the endless road and azure sky. Her long, lustrous black hair flows wildly in the strong ocean breeze, strands occasionally brushing against her face, a smile radiating freedom. She wears a simple white linen shirt, its cuffs slightly puffed by the wind. The brilliant afternoon sun casts a warm golden filter over the entire scene, casting flowing specks of light across the sleek exterior of the sports car. On one side of the road lie jagged cliffs; on the other, a vast, shimmering azure sea, its white waves rhythmically lapping against the rocks below. The camera follows the vehicle in a smooth trajectory as it smoothly passes through each bend, capturing the perfect combination of speed and beautiful scenery. The entire scene is filled with highly saturated colors and an unrestrained, exhilarating sense of escape and adventure.", + "seed": 20473, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_3/index_9372_seed_20473_dp_6_rank_12_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.045948947034776214, + "vlm_logprob": -0.045948947034776214, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.045948947034776214, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage red convertible sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young Asian woman visible inside the car holding the steering wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing classic aviator sunglasses and a white linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding coastal asphalt road with jagged cliffs on one side and a vast azure sea on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an ultra-wide-angle drone view captured from a slightly low angle following the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012595037929713726 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.512595176696777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012595037929713726, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012595037929713726, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25434115529060364, + 0.08223391324281693, + 0.1845073252916336, + 0.03583279997110367, + 0.04017861187458038, + 0.030038096010684967, + 0.046032097190618515, + 0.04408351704478264, + 0.1988753229379654, + 0.08387723565101624 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012595037929713726 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage red convertible sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young Asian woman visible inside the car holding the steering wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing classic aviator sunglasses and a white linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding coastal asphalt road with jagged cliffs on one side and a vast azure sea on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an ultra-wide-angle drone view captured from a slightly low angle following the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309731349349022 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680972576141357 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309731349349022, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309731349349022, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.050136785954236984, + 0.03056369721889496, + 0.10589530318975449, + 0.05073055252432823, + 0.2925463616847992, + 0.05951809510588646, + 0.10990200191736221, + 0.2219509482383728, + 0.04604459926486015, + 0.032711613923311234 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309731349349022 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage red convertible sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young Asian woman visible inside the car holding the steering wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing classic aviator sunglasses and a white linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding coastal asphalt road with jagged cliffs on one side and a vast azure sea on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an ultra-wide-angle drone view captured from a slightly low angle following the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016091007739305496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410908699035645 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016091007739305496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016091007739305496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12132825702428818, + 0.09809638559818268, + 0.12547582387924194, + 0.0454169325530529, + 0.12612825632095337, + 0.018070565536618233, + 0.1311298906803131, + 0.09695753455162048, + 0.206085667014122, + 0.03131067752838135 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016091007739305496 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage red convertible sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young Asian woman visible inside the car holding the steering wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing classic aviator sunglasses and a white linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding coastal asphalt road with jagged cliffs on one side and a vast azure sea on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an ultra-wide-angle drone view captured from a slightly low angle following the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07899197936058044 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789918899536133 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07899197936058044, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07899197936058044, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5150012969970703, + 0.08760903775691986, + 0.0989915058016777, + 0.03215769678354263, + 0.026053793728351593, + 0.13400237262248993, + 0.033233024179935455, + 0.022140825167298317, + 0.030133476480841637, + 0.020676925778388977 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07899197936058044 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage red convertible sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young Asian woman visible inside the car holding the steering wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing classic aviator sunglasses and a white linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding coastal asphalt road with jagged cliffs on one side and a vast azure sea on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an ultra-wide-angle drone view captured from a slightly low angle following the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07896939665079117 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789694786071777 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07896939665079117, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07896939665079117, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20501483976840973, + 0.2026701420545578, + 0.12014288455247879, + 0.049099236726760864, + 0.0632644072175026, + 0.03879527747631073, + 0.045390285551548004, + 0.03000696375966072, + 0.19785284996032715, + 0.04776305332779884 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07896939665079117 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, ultra-wide-angle drone shot, captured from a slightly low angle, follows a vintage red convertible sports car as it speeds along a winding coastal asphalt road. Inside, a young Asian woman holds the steering wheel steadily, her classic aviator sunglasses reflecting the endless road and azure sky. Her long, lustrous black hair flows wildly in the strong ocean breeze, strands occasionally brushing against her face, a smile radiating freedom. She wears a simple white linen shirt, its cuffs slightly puffed by the wind. The brilliant afternoon sun casts a warm golden filter over the entire scene, casting flowing specks of light across the sleek exterior of the sports car. On one side of the road lie jagged cliffs; on the other, a vast, shimmering azure sea, its white waves rhythmically lapping against the rocks below. The camera follows the vehicle in a smooth trajectory as it smoothly passes through each bend, capturing the perfect combination of speed and beautiful scenery. The entire scene is filled with highly saturated colors and an unrestrained, exhilarating sense of escape and adventure.", + "seed": 20474, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_3/index_9372_seed_20474_dp_6_rank_12_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.05413222461938858, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05413222461938858, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3249999046325684, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05413222461938858, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage red convertible sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young Asian woman visible inside the car holding the steering wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing classic aviator sunglasses and a white linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding coastal asphalt road with jagged cliffs on one side and a vast azure sea on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an ultra-wide-angle drone view captured from a slightly low angle following the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.023434342816472054 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.023434162139893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.023434342816472054, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.023434342816472054, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3315410614013672, + 0.07104244828224182, + 0.09872224181890488, + 0.07852545380592346, + 0.05600336194038391, + 0.05179588869214058, + 0.10824096947908401, + 0.04452178627252579, + 0.09179645031690598, + 0.06781035661697388 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.023434342816472054 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage red convertible sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young Asian woman visible inside the car holding the steering wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing classic aviator sunglasses and a white linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding coastal asphalt road with jagged cliffs on one side and a vast azure sea on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an ultra-wide-angle drone view captured from a slightly low angle following the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016117636114358902 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141117572784424 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016117636114358902, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016117636114358902, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21821236610412598, + 0.04481939598917961, + 0.06360653042793274, + 0.04146907478570938, + 0.053963497281074524, + 0.16168725490570068, + 0.10285764932632446, + 0.08880044519901276, + 0.0952068343758583, + 0.12937693297863007 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016117636114358902 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage red convertible sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young Asian woman visible inside the car holding the steering wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing classic aviator sunglasses and a white linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding coastal asphalt road with jagged cliffs on one side and a vast azure sea on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an ultra-wide-angle drone view captured from a slightly low angle following the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018227221444249153 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0182271003723145 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018227221444249153, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018227221444249153, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2347731590270996, + 0.04450896009802818, + 0.06660518050193787, + 0.05787692219018936, + 0.14159584045410156, + 0.1345384269952774, + 0.07699260115623474, + 0.08062691986560822, + 0.06267081946134567, + 0.09981121867895126 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018227221444249153 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage red convertible sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young Asian woman visible inside the car holding the steering wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing classic aviator sunglasses and a white linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding coastal asphalt road with jagged cliffs on one side and a vast azure sea on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an ultra-wide-angle drone view captured from a slightly low angle following the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07007060945034027 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695070505142212 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07007060945034027, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07007060945034027, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.4817752242088318, + 0.053921304643154144, + 0.04117565229535103, + 0.07280471175909042, + 0.12689203023910522, + 0.0640493705868721, + 0.05041210725903511, + 0.04759982228279114, + 0.044377412647008896, + 0.016992392018437386 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07007060945034027 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage red convertible sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young Asian woman visible inside the car holding the steering wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing classic aviator sunglasses and a white linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding coastal asphalt road with jagged cliffs on one side and a vast azure sea on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an ultra-wide-angle drone view captured from a slightly low angle following the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14281131327152252 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178112983703613 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14281131327152252, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14281131327152252, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27715426683425903, + 0.08955305069684982, + 0.06740473955869675, + 0.12870757281780243, + 0.10418418794870377, + 0.05919750779867172, + 0.08151915669441223, + 0.03948674723505974, + 0.12545889616012573, + 0.02733387053012848 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14281131327152252 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, ultra-wide-angle drone shot, captured from a slightly low angle, follows a vintage red convertible sports car as it speeds along a winding coastal asphalt road. Inside, a young Asian woman holds the steering wheel steadily, her classic aviator sunglasses reflecting the endless road and azure sky. Her long, lustrous black hair flows wildly in the strong ocean breeze, strands occasionally brushing against her face, a smile radiating freedom. She wears a simple white linen shirt, its cuffs slightly puffed by the wind. The brilliant afternoon sun casts a warm golden filter over the entire scene, casting flowing specks of light across the sleek exterior of the sports car. On one side of the road lie jagged cliffs; on the other, a vast, shimmering azure sea, its white waves rhythmically lapping against the rocks below. The camera follows the vehicle in a smooth trajectory as it smoothly passes through each bend, capturing the perfect combination of speed and beautiful scenery. The entire scene is filled with highly saturated colors and an unrestrained, exhilarating sense of escape and adventure.", + "seed": 20475, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_3/index_9372_seed_20475_dp_7_rank_14_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.07595404088497162, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07595404088497162, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.125, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07595404088497162, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage red convertible sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young Asian woman visible inside the car holding the steering wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing classic aviator sunglasses and a white linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding coastal asphalt road with jagged cliffs on one side and a vast azure sea on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an ultra-wide-angle drone view captured from a slightly low angle following the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02014206349849701 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.270142078399658 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02014206349849701, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02014206349849701, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21734078228473663, + 0.22239714860916138, + 0.05695416405797005, + 0.03191055729985237, + 0.025896551087498665, + 0.2780378758907318, + 0.03375505656003952, + 0.05637054890394211, + 0.020028872415423393, + 0.05730849876999855 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02014206349849701 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage red convertible sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young Asian woman visible inside the car holding the steering wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing classic aviator sunglasses and a white linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding coastal asphalt road with jagged cliffs on one side and a vast azure sea on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an ultra-wide-angle drone view captured from a slightly low angle following the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018227923661470413 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018228054046631 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018227923661470413, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018227923661470413, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18604764342308044, + 0.2116866409778595, + 0.12388139963150024, + 0.030801450833678246, + 0.03676967695355415, + 0.21038606762886047, + 0.03738192841410637, + 0.036650400608778, + 0.0253565963357687, + 0.10103821009397507 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018227923661470413 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage red convertible sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young Asian woman visible inside the car holding the steering wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing classic aviator sunglasses and a white linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding coastal asphalt road with jagged cliffs on one side and a vast azure sea on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an ultra-wide-angle drone view captured from a slightly low angle following the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020616289228200912 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.895616292953491 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020616289228200912, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020616289228200912, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2570970356464386, + 0.1476748138666153, + 0.0686478242278099, + 0.026962032541632652, + 0.0306578166782856, + 0.35143354535102844, + 0.020218053832650185, + 0.03026983141899109, + 0.013906228356063366, + 0.053132783621549606 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020616289228200912 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage red convertible sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young Asian woman visible inside the car holding the steering wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing classic aviator sunglasses and a white linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding coastal asphalt road with jagged cliffs on one side and a vast azure sea on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an ultra-wide-angle drone view captured from a slightly low angle following the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16043268144130707 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9104326963424683 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16043268144130707, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16043268144130707, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1680470108985901, + 0.2547617554664612, + 0.04032754525542259, + 0.017884358763694763, + 0.058448728173971176, + 0.2872636318206787, + 0.03942688927054405, + 0.036195557564496994, + 0.028553040698170662, + 0.06909147650003433 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16043268144130707 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage red convertible sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young Asian woman visible inside the car holding the steering wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing classic aviator sunglasses and a white linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding coastal asphalt road with jagged cliffs on one side and a vast azure sea on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an ultra-wide-angle drone view captured from a slightly low angle following the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1603512465953827 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.910351276397705 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1603512465953827, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1603512465953827, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2293420433998108, + 0.2438216209411621, + 0.08270037919282913, + 0.027470694854855537, + 0.1218106672167778, + 0.11170730739831924, + 0.07098361104726791, + 0.054943352937698364, + 0.01121313963085413, + 0.04600716009736061 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1603512465953827 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "dynamic, ultra-wide-angle drone shot, captured from a slightly low angle, follows a vintage red convertible sports car as it speeds along a winding coastal asphalt road. Inside, a young Asian woman holds the steering wheel steadily, her classic aviator sunglasses reflecting the endless road and azure sky. Her long, lustrous black hair flows wildly in the strong ocean breeze, strands occasionally brushing against her face, a smile radiating freedom. She wears a simple white linen shirt, its cuffs slightly puffed by the wind. The brilliant afternoon sun casts a warm golden filter over the entire scene, casting flowing specks of light across the sleek exterior of the sports car. On one side of the road lie jagged cliffs; on the other, a vast, shimmering azure sea, its white waves rhythmically lapping against the rocks below. The camera follows the vehicle in a smooth trajectory as it smoothly passes through each bend, capturing the perfect combination of speed and beautiful scenery. The entire scene is filled with highly saturated colors and an unrestrained, exhilarating sense of escape and adventure.", + "seed": 20476, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_3/index_9372_seed_20476_dp_7_rank_14_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 3, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.023381965607404707, + "vlm_logprob": -0.023381965607404707, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.799999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.023381965607404707, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage red convertible sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young Asian woman visible inside the car holding the steering wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing classic aviator sunglasses and a white linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding coastal asphalt road with jagged cliffs on one side and a vast azure sea on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an ultra-wide-angle drone view captured from a slightly low angle following the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02013411931693554 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.020133972167969 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02013411931693554, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02013411931693554, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.7654082775115967, + 0.04153832793235779, + 0.04162206873297691, + 0.011000888422131538, + 0.011512168683111668, + 0.020688507705926895, + 0.023086925968527794, + 0.015987936407327652, + 0.023370446637272835, + 0.04578457400202751 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02013411931693554 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage red convertible sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young Asian woman visible inside the car holding the steering wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing classic aviator sunglasses and a white linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding coastal asphalt road with jagged cliffs on one side and a vast azure sea on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an ultra-wide-angle drone view captured from a slightly low angle following the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03374351188540459 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087436199188232 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03374351188540459, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03374351188540459, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.862861156463623, + 0.017454182729125023, + 0.030047515407204628, + 0.010502558201551437, + 0.008825143799185753, + 0.01506253145635128, + 0.010709923692047596, + 0.009064787067472935, + 0.010778352618217468, + 0.024693800136446953 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03374351188540459 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage red convertible sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young Asian woman visible inside the car holding the steering wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing classic aviator sunglasses and a white linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding coastal asphalt road with jagged cliffs on one side and a vast azure sea on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an ultra-wide-angle drone view captured from a slightly low angle following the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02061430551111698 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956143856048584 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02061430551111698, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02061430551111698, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.8362988829612732, + 0.02527722343802452, + 0.051952116191387177, + 0.008909564465284348, + 0.008661524392664433, + 0.020647695288062096, + 0.008432494476437569, + 0.008066683076322079, + 0.012832148931920528, + 0.018921755254268646 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02061430551111698 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage red convertible sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young Asian woman visible inside the car holding the steering wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing classic aviator sunglasses and a white linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding coastal asphalt road with jagged cliffs on one side and a vast azure sea on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an ultra-wide-angle drone view captured from a slightly low angle following the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026353277266025543 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651353359222412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026353277266025543, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026353277266025543, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.6855892539024353, + 0.023641828447580338, + 0.04093121737241745, + 0.16540873050689697, + 0.022589292377233505, + 0.011596208438277245, + 0.010186105035245419, + 0.011415648274123669, + 0.01420421153306961, + 0.014437448233366013 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026353277266025543 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a vintage red convertible sports car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a young Asian woman visible inside the car holding the steering wheel?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the woman wearing classic aviator sunglasses and a white linen shirt?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the setting a winding coastal asphalt road with jagged cliffs on one side and a vast azure sea on the other?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the shot an ultra-wide-angle drone view captured from a slightly low angle following the car?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016064614057540894 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141064643859863 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016064614057540894, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016064614057540894, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5351955890655518, + 0.06912887841463089, + 0.10763334482908249, + 0.122407466173172, + 0.025436721742153168, + 0.030700763687491417, + 0.032257888466119766, + 0.023192252963781357, + 0.02478013001382351, + 0.0292669665068388 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016064614057540894 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_4/index_tensor([408, 408])_group_4_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_4/index_tensor([408, 408])_group_4_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..2cfa2e230ef8c88c99c19fdc83af89c09d4e9267 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_4/index_tensor([408, 408])_group_4_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "sports documentary-style shot begins from a bird's-eye view. The camera slowly and steadily descends through the damp, misty air, gradually focusing on the ruins of an ancient city completely submerged by floodwaters. In the frame, a determined female explorer struggles through waist-deep, murky rapids. Her hair is tucked into a tight, damp, dark ponytail, her cheeks stained with mud, her jaw set, and her gaze fixed intently ahead. She wears a black, multi-pocket tactical vest, tightly fastened over a dark gray, long-sleeved, quick-drying jacket. Attached to the vest are carabiners and a short length of coiled rope. Each step is cautious yet powerful. Her left hand grips a carbon fiber trekking pole, digging deep into the invisible underwater ground for balance, and she leans forward to resist the relentless onslaught of the current. The murky brown-gray water slams violently against the surrounding, mossy, ruined walls and stone pillars, half-submerged in the water, sending up bursts of white spray. Under the diffuse light of the gloomy sky, the entire scene presents a cold, desaturated tone. Only the dynamic movement of the flowing water and the unyielding figure of the explorer form a sharp contrast, creating a tense and focused atmosphere of man's struggle against the forces of nature.", + "seed": 28525, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_4/index_408_seed_28525_dp_8_rank_16_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.08985938839614391, + "vlm_logprob": -0.08985938839614391, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.199999952316284, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.08985938839614391, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a bird's-eye view that slowly descends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient city submerged by floodwaters with mossy ruined walls and stone pillars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a female explorer visible wearing a black tactical vest over a dark gray long-sleeved jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the explorer holding a carbon fiber trekking pole in her left hand while navigating waist-deep murky rapids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting diffuse and gloomy with a cold, desaturated tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.351625919342041 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.226625919342041 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.351625919342041, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.351625919342041, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3361224830150604, + 0.13567385077476501, + 0.06281793117523193, + 0.17071866989135742, + 0.07090143859386444, + 0.11544818431138992, + 0.021941926330327988, + 0.026608705520629883, + 0.0240279883146286, + 0.035738810896873474 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.351625919342041 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a bird's-eye view that slowly descends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient city submerged by floodwaters with mossy ruined walls and stone pillars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a female explorer visible wearing a black tactical vest over a dark gray long-sleeved jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the explorer holding a carbon fiber trekking pole in her left hand while navigating waist-deep murky rapids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting diffuse and gloomy with a cold, desaturated tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01821013167500496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018209934234619 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01821013167500496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.999999761581421, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01821013167500496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22721725702285767, + 0.15417887270450592, + 0.14426635205745697, + 0.06126595661044121, + 0.11569476872682571, + 0.06200304627418518, + 0.049443211406469345, + 0.07633428275585175, + 0.04947022348642349, + 0.06012602522969246 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01821013167500496 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a bird's-eye view that slowly descends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient city submerged by floodwaters with mossy ruined walls and stone pillars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a female explorer visible wearing a black tactical vest over a dark gray long-sleeved jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the explorer holding a carbon fiber trekking pole in her left hand while navigating waist-deep murky rapids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting diffuse and gloomy with a cold, desaturated tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01818847469985485 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.0181884765625 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01818847469985485, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01818847469985485, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2677953541278839, + 0.07503050565719604, + 0.07581784576177597, + 0.1561805158853531, + 0.06514418870210648, + 0.042684637010097504, + 0.11594358831644058, + 0.06509147584438324, + 0.09303433448076248, + 0.0432775616645813 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01818847469985485 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a bird's-eye view that slowly descends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient city submerged by floodwaters with mossy ruined walls and stone pillars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a female explorer visible wearing a black tactical vest over a dark gray long-sleeved jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the explorer holding a carbon fiber trekking pole in her left hand while navigating waist-deep murky rapids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting diffuse and gloomy with a cold, desaturated tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04308440908789635 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1680843830108643 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04308440908789635, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04308440908789635, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12439343333244324, + 0.06258763372898102, + 0.05111543461680412, + 0.09074307978153229, + 0.2260308861732483, + 0.05666892230510712, + 0.07601051777601242, + 0.12152811884880066, + 0.13999733328819275, + 0.050924669951200485 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04308440908789635 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a bird's-eye view that slowly descends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient city submerged by floodwaters with mossy ruined walls and stone pillars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a female explorer visible wearing a black tactical vest over a dark gray long-sleeved jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the explorer holding a carbon fiber trekking pole in her left hand while navigating waist-deep murky rapids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting diffuse and gloomy with a cold, desaturated tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018188007175922394 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018187999725342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018188007175922394, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018188007175922394, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29399603605270386, + 0.08952851593494415, + 0.0915607362985611, + 0.06656694412231445, + 0.05016951262950897, + 0.03966088965535164, + 0.07955709844827652, + 0.06737801432609558, + 0.10796985775232315, + 0.11361245810985565 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018188007175922394 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sports documentary-style shot begins from a bird's-eye view. The camera slowly and steadily descends through the damp, misty air, gradually focusing on the ruins of an ancient city completely submerged by floodwaters. In the frame, a determined female explorer struggles through waist-deep, murky rapids. Her hair is tucked into a tight, damp, dark ponytail, her cheeks stained with mud, her jaw set, and her gaze fixed intently ahead. She wears a black, multi-pocket tactical vest, tightly fastened over a dark gray, long-sleeved, quick-drying jacket. Attached to the vest are carabiners and a short length of coiled rope. Each step is cautious yet powerful. Her left hand grips a carbon fiber trekking pole, digging deep into the invisible underwater ground for balance, and she leans forward to resist the relentless onslaught of the current. The murky brown-gray water slams violently against the surrounding, mossy, ruined walls and stone pillars, half-submerged in the water, sending up bursts of white spray. Under the diffuse light of the gloomy sky, the entire scene presents a cold, desaturated tone. Only the dynamic movement of the flowing water and the unyielding figure of the explorer form a sharp contrast, creating a tense and focused atmosphere of man's struggle against the forces of nature.", + "seed": 28526, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_4/index_408_seed_28526_dp_8_rank_16_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.15486239101737737, + "vlm_logprob": -0.15486239101737737, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.25, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.15486239101737737, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 0.8, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a bird's-eye view that slowly descends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient city submerged by floodwaters with mossy ruined walls and stone pillars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a female explorer visible wearing a black tactical vest over a dark gray long-sleeved jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the explorer holding a carbon fiber trekking pole in her left hand while navigating waist-deep murky rapids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting diffuse and gloomy with a cold, desaturated tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "No", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "No" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6964687705039978 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.6964687705039978 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.6964687705039978, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.6964687705039978, + "yes_ratio_reward": 0.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24500715732574463, + 0.08201413601636887, + 0.0649159699678421, + 0.04813031107187271, + 0.26197049021720886, + 0.08875443041324615, + 0.10422450304031372, + 0.03027593344449997, + 0.042459480464458466, + 0.03224756196141243 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.6964687705039978 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a bird's-eye view that slowly descends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient city submerged by floodwaters with mossy ruined walls and stone pillars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a female explorer visible wearing a black tactical vest over a dark gray long-sleeved jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the explorer holding a carbon fiber trekking pole in her left hand while navigating waist-deep murky rapids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting diffuse and gloomy with a cold, desaturated tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01610250398516655 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141102313995361 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01610250398516655, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01610250398516655, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24184228479862213, + 0.11231818795204163, + 0.13691751658916473, + 0.06087129935622215, + 0.11864012479782104, + 0.045623015612363815, + 0.07515580952167511, + 0.09723947942256927, + 0.043143581598997116, + 0.06824865937232971 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01610250398516655 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a bird's-eye view that slowly descends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient city submerged by floodwaters with mossy ruined walls and stone pillars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a female explorer visible wearing a black tactical vest over a dark gray long-sleeved jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the explorer holding a carbon fiber trekking pole in her left hand while navigating waist-deep murky rapids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting diffuse and gloomy with a cold, desaturated tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.011079693213105202 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.511079788208008 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.011079693213105202, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.011079693213105202, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13713401556015015, + 0.040594231337308884, + 0.0358554981648922, + 0.0367705263197422, + 0.23915190994739532, + 0.0887371152639389, + 0.07556638866662979, + 0.06434791535139084, + 0.22549423575401306, + 0.05634809285402298 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.011079693213105202 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a bird's-eye view that slowly descends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient city submerged by floodwaters with mossy ruined walls and stone pillars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a female explorer visible wearing a black tactical vest over a dark gray long-sleeved jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the explorer holding a carbon fiber trekking pole in her left hand while navigating waist-deep murky rapids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting diffuse and gloomy with a cold, desaturated tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03812151402235031 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288121461868286 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03812151402235031, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03812151402235031, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20177887380123138, + 0.09965682774782181, + 0.05422593653202057, + 0.0672934427857399, + 0.1177038624882698, + 0.20797954499721527, + 0.04451901465654373, + 0.03884436562657356, + 0.12979179620742798, + 0.03820638358592987 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03812151402235031 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a bird's-eye view that slowly descends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient city submerged by floodwaters with mossy ruined walls and stone pillars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a female explorer visible wearing a black tactical vest over a dark gray long-sleeved jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the explorer holding a carbon fiber trekking pole in her left hand while navigating waist-deep murky rapids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting diffuse and gloomy with a cold, desaturated tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012539473362267017 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387539386749268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012539473362267017, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012539473362267017, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16095608472824097, + 0.06089920550584793, + 0.03559563308954239, + 0.0408107154071331, + 0.18949301540851593, + 0.12522748112678528, + 0.07564833015203476, + 0.16938956081867218, + 0.06130944564938545, + 0.08067049831151962 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012539473362267017 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "No", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sports documentary-style shot begins from a bird's-eye view. The camera slowly and steadily descends through the damp, misty air, gradually focusing on the ruins of an ancient city completely submerged by floodwaters. In the frame, a determined female explorer struggles through waist-deep, murky rapids. Her hair is tucked into a tight, damp, dark ponytail, her cheeks stained with mud, her jaw set, and her gaze fixed intently ahead. She wears a black, multi-pocket tactical vest, tightly fastened over a dark gray, long-sleeved, quick-drying jacket. Attached to the vest are carabiners and a short length of coiled rope. Each step is cautious yet powerful. Her left hand grips a carbon fiber trekking pole, digging deep into the invisible underwater ground for balance, and she leans forward to resist the relentless onslaught of the current. The murky brown-gray water slams violently against the surrounding, mossy, ruined walls and stone pillars, half-submerged in the water, sending up bursts of white spray. Under the diffuse light of the gloomy sky, the entire scene presents a cold, desaturated tone. Only the dynamic movement of the flowing water and the unyielding figure of the explorer form a sharp contrast, creating a tense and focused atmosphere of man's struggle against the forces of nature.", + "seed": 28527, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_4/index_408_seed_28527_dp_9_rank_18_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.09643726721405983, + "vlm_logprob": -0.09643726721405983, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.325, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.09643726721405983, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a bird's-eye view that slowly descends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient city submerged by floodwaters with mossy ruined walls and stone pillars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a female explorer visible wearing a black tactical vest over a dark gray long-sleeved jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the explorer holding a carbon fiber trekking pole in her left hand while navigating waist-deep murky rapids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting diffuse and gloomy with a cold, desaturated tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.39130160212516785 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1413016319274902 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.39130160212516785, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.39130160212516785, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.5799621343612671, + 0.10964246839284897, + 0.06814541667699814, + 0.07295854389667511, + 0.04425669088959694, + 0.015162202529609203, + 0.037522587925195694, + 0.028805378824472427, + 0.016669733449816704, + 0.026874931529164314 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.39130160212516785 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a bird's-eye view that slowly descends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient city submerged by floodwaters with mossy ruined walls and stone pillars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a female explorer visible wearing a black tactical vest over a dark gray long-sleeved jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the explorer holding a carbon fiber trekking pole in her left hand while navigating waist-deep murky rapids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting diffuse and gloomy with a cold, desaturated tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01422879472374916 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.264228820800781 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01422879472374916, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01422879472374916, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25925904512405396, + 0.14118337631225586, + 0.10406029969453812, + 0.07294528186321259, + 0.0655064508318901, + 0.030116666108369827, + 0.039397791028022766, + 0.02533838525414467, + 0.21730321645736694, + 0.04488943889737129 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01422879472374916 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a bird's-eye view that slowly descends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient city submerged by floodwaters with mossy ruined walls and stone pillars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a female explorer visible wearing a black tactical vest over a dark gray long-sleeved jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the explorer holding a carbon fiber trekking pole in her left hand while navigating waist-deep murky rapids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting diffuse and gloomy with a cold, desaturated tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.018192103132605553 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.018192291259766 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.018192103132605553, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.018192103132605553, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19680887460708618, + 0.0799427330493927, + 0.07558199018239975, + 0.09508218616247177, + 0.06392567604780197, + 0.06294816732406616, + 0.0678355023264885, + 0.20695385336875916, + 0.08983609825372696, + 0.061084989458322525 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 7, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.018192103132605553 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a bird's-eye view that slowly descends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient city submerged by floodwaters with mossy ruined walls and stone pillars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a female explorer visible wearing a black tactical vest over a dark gray long-sleeved jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the explorer holding a carbon fiber trekking pole in her left hand while navigating waist-deep murky rapids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting diffuse and gloomy with a cold, desaturated tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04868089407682419 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486807823181152 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04868089407682419, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04868089407682419, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2706243395805359, + 0.11585335433483124, + 0.10339158773422241, + 0.07546152174472809, + 0.054080188274383545, + 0.056687820702791214, + 0.03386605530977249, + 0.08099891990423203, + 0.1382250040769577, + 0.07081124186515808 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04868089407682419 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a bird's-eye view that slowly descends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient city submerged by floodwaters with mossy ruined walls and stone pillars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a female explorer visible wearing a black tactical vest over a dark gray long-sleeved jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the explorer holding a carbon fiber trekking pole in her left hand while navigating waist-deep murky rapids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting diffuse and gloomy with a cold, desaturated tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0097829420119524 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.634782791137695 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0097829420119524, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0097829420119524, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.40054094791412354, + 0.12114719301462173, + 0.047311052680015564, + 0.03152257204055786, + 0.04697898030281067, + 0.019090551882982254, + 0.020912043750286102, + 0.06051228567957878, + 0.18167570233345032, + 0.0703086331486702 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0097829420119524 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "sports documentary-style shot begins from a bird's-eye view. The camera slowly and steadily descends through the damp, misty air, gradually focusing on the ruins of an ancient city completely submerged by floodwaters. In the frame, a determined female explorer struggles through waist-deep, murky rapids. Her hair is tucked into a tight, damp, dark ponytail, her cheeks stained with mud, her jaw set, and her gaze fixed intently ahead. She wears a black, multi-pocket tactical vest, tightly fastened over a dark gray, long-sleeved, quick-drying jacket. Attached to the vest are carabiners and a short length of coiled rope. Each step is cautious yet powerful. Her left hand grips a carbon fiber trekking pole, digging deep into the invisible underwater ground for balance, and she leans forward to resist the relentless onslaught of the current. The murky brown-gray water slams violently against the surrounding, mossy, ruined walls and stone pillars, half-submerged in the water, sending up bursts of white spray. Under the diffuse light of the gloomy sky, the entire scene presents a cold, desaturated tone. Only the dynamic movement of the flowing water and the unyielding figure of the explorer form a sharp contrast, creating a tense and focused atmosphere of man's struggle against the forces of nature.", + "seed": 28528, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_4/index_408_seed_28528_dp_9_rank_18_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 4, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04125174954533577, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04125174954533577, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.875, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04125174954533577, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a bird's-eye view that slowly descends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient city submerged by floodwaters with mossy ruined walls and stone pillars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a female explorer visible wearing a black tactical vest over a dark gray long-sleeved jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the explorer holding a carbon fiber trekking pole in her left hand while navigating waist-deep murky rapids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting diffuse and gloomy with a cold, desaturated tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.14460685849189758 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.019606828689575 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.14460685849189758, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.14460685849189758, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30221453309059143, + 0.0945761576294899, + 0.0790560320019722, + 0.12302228063344955, + 0.08472053706645966, + 0.09379013627767563, + 0.05089591443538666, + 0.06584595143795013, + 0.08352629095315933, + 0.022352179512381554 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.14460685849189758 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a bird's-eye view that slowly descends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient city submerged by floodwaters with mossy ruined walls and stone pillars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a female explorer visible wearing a black tactical vest over a dark gray long-sleeved jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the explorer holding a carbon fiber trekking pole in her left hand while navigating waist-deep murky rapids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting diffuse and gloomy with a cold, desaturated tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006754779256880283 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.0067548751831055 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006754779256880283, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006754779256880283, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19140997529029846, + 0.12358898669481277, + 0.08059673011302948, + 0.09448332339525223, + 0.05841894820332527, + 0.07987719029188156, + 0.05003099516034126, + 0.03846198692917824, + 0.12957070767879486, + 0.15356117486953735 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006754779256880283 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a bird's-eye view that slowly descends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient city submerged by floodwaters with mossy ruined walls and stone pillars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a female explorer visible wearing a black tactical vest over a dark gray long-sleeved jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the explorer holding a carbon fiber trekking pole in her left hand while navigating waist-deep murky rapids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting diffuse and gloomy with a cold, desaturated tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008640522137284279 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.758640289306641 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008640522137284279, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008640522137284279, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.057989202439785004, + 0.037852827459573746, + 0.04795099422335625, + 0.10157584398984909, + 0.050465840846300125, + 0.041574228554964066, + 0.07430696487426758, + 0.03441983833909035, + 0.18120130896568298, + 0.3726629316806793 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008640522137284279 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a bird's-eye view that slowly descends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient city submerged by floodwaters with mossy ruined walls and stone pillars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a female explorer visible wearing a black tactical vest over a dark gray long-sleeved jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the explorer holding a carbon fiber trekking pole in her left hand while navigating waist-deep murky rapids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting diffuse and gloomy with a cold, desaturated tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371734917163849 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.408717393875122 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371734917163849, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371734917163849, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08033647388219833, + 0.054720547050237656, + 0.07034866511821747, + 0.2592986822128296, + 0.07058507204055786, + 0.0855707898736, + 0.09603793919086456, + 0.0677211657166481, + 0.07332256436347961, + 0.14205807447433472 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 3, + 9, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371734917163849 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Does the video begin with a bird's-eye view that slowly descends?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in an ancient city submerged by floodwaters with mossy ruined walls and stone pillars?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a female explorer visible wearing a black tactical vest over a dark gray long-sleeved jacket?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the explorer holding a carbon fiber trekking pole in her left hand while navigating waist-deep murky rapids?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the lighting diffuse and gloomy with a cold, desaturated tone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.012539238668978214 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387539386749268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.012539238668978214, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.012539238668978214, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15360227227210999, + 0.05650695040822029, + 0.07178272306919098, + 0.07695453613996506, + 0.09922146797180176, + 0.051874253898859024, + 0.03562675416469574, + 0.09563042968511581, + 0.061771370470523834, + 0.29702919721603394 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.012539238668978214 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_5/index_tensor([9246, 9246])_group_5_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_5/index_tensor([9246, 9246])_group_5_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..9a545b92db4576b13eb06d1e27e14f2085f08b0e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_5/index_tensor([9246, 9246])_group_5_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "The scene begins with a soft, gentle style, a medium close-up shot from a slightly low angle, focusing on a lone male traveler standing in a contemplative pose before a vast terminal window. The camera begins with a slow, deliberate crane shot, gracefully lifting upward. The traveler is a young man with slightly tousled black hair, seen from back and profile, wearing a comfortable dark travel jacket. He holds his passport and paper boarding pass loosely in one hand, his posture still, gazing outward. Warm, golden morning light filters through the expansive glass, casting a soft-focus glow over the scene and illuminating the captivating dance of dust particles suspended in the air. As the camera continues its steady ascent, rising high above the silhouettes of the passengers, it reveals the breathtaking grandeur of the airport tarmac below. Multiple planes can be seen, patiently waiting on the runway and at the gate, their metallic fuselages catching the dawn light. The entire landscape is enveloped by a hazy, pale sky, creating a tranquil and poignant atmosphere filled with quiet anticipation for the journey to come.", + "seed": 16255, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_5/index_9246_seed_16255_dp_10_rank_20_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.11736242026090622, + "vlm_logprob": -0.11736242026090622, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.6, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.11736242026090622, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young male traveler with slightly tousled black hair seen from the back and profile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing a dark travel jacket and holding a passport and paper boarding pass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate crane shot that lifts upward from a medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multiple planes visible on the airport tarmac below with metallic fuselages catching the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden morning light with visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.06310983747243881 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.813109874725342 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.06310983747243881, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.06310983747243881, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08433331549167633, + 0.020424991846084595, + 0.033770084381103516, + 0.017988882958889008, + 0.009310283698141575, + 0.021295299753546715, + 0.04153883457183838, + 0.03789769485592842, + 0.6979526877403259, + 0.03548796847462654 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.06310983747243881 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young male traveler with slightly tousled black hair seen from the back and profile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing a dark travel jacket and holding a passport and paper boarding pass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate crane shot that lifts upward from a medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multiple planes visible on the airport tarmac below with metallic fuselages catching the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden morning light with visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.16051198542118073 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9105119705200195 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.16051198542118073, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.16051198542118073, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03174075484275818, + 0.01496143825352192, + 0.03757833316922188, + 0.013363207690417767, + 0.007890831679105759, + 0.019386136904358864, + 0.026810813695192337, + 0.05156482383608818, + 0.7681223750114441, + 0.028581276535987854 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 7, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.16051198542118073 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young male traveler with slightly tousled black hair seen from the back and profile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing a dark travel jacket and holding a passport and paper boarding pass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate crane shot that lifts upward from a medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multiple planes visible on the airport tarmac below with metallic fuselages catching the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden morning light with visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.31341642141342163 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.3134164810180664 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.31341642141342163, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.31341642141342163, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.023995349183678627, + 0.009926822036504745, + 0.020951101556420326, + 0.014911963604390621, + 0.038818567991256714, + 0.0039454009383916855, + 0.02625325135886669, + 0.01736496388912201, + 0.7906531095504761, + 0.05317940190434456 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.31341642141342163 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young male traveler with slightly tousled black hair seen from the back and profile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing a dark travel jacket and holding a passport and paper boarding pass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate crane shot that lifts upward from a medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multiple planes visible on the airport tarmac below with metallic fuselages catching the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden morning light with visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.033704668283462524 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087047576904297 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.033704668283462524, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.033704668283462524, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08449586480855942, + 0.03555230423808098, + 0.08267446607351303, + 0.018477829173207283, + 0.018112557008862495, + 0.02746073342859745, + 0.0496344231069088, + 0.0736013799905777, + 0.5918965339660645, + 0.018093865364789963 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.033704668283462524 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young male traveler with slightly tousled black hair seen from the back and profile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing a dark travel jacket and holding a passport and paper boarding pass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate crane shot that lifts upward from a medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multiple planes visible on the airport tarmac below with metallic fuselages catching the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden morning light with visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016069188714027405 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141069412231445 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016069188714027405, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016069188714027405, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08318845927715302, + 0.010423101484775543, + 0.018896041437983513, + 0.021803850308060646, + 0.06313253194093704, + 0.03837011381983757, + 0.06514827907085419, + 0.024060577154159546, + 0.6413137912750244, + 0.033663202077150345 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016069188714027405 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene begins with a soft, gentle style, a medium close-up shot from a slightly low angle, focusing on a lone male traveler standing in a contemplative pose before a vast terminal window. The camera begins with a slow, deliberate crane shot, gracefully lifting upward. The traveler is a young man with slightly tousled black hair, seen from back and profile, wearing a comfortable dark travel jacket. He holds his passport and paper boarding pass loosely in one hand, his posture still, gazing outward. Warm, golden morning light filters through the expansive glass, casting a soft-focus glow over the scene and illuminating the captivating dance of dust particles suspended in the air. As the camera continues its steady ascent, rising high above the silhouettes of the passengers, it reveals the breathtaking grandeur of the airport tarmac below. Multiple planes can be seen, patiently waiting on the runway and at the gate, their metallic fuselages catching the dawn light. The entire landscape is enveloped by a hazy, pale sky, creating a tranquil and poignant atmosphere filled with quiet anticipation for the journey to come.", + "seed": 16256, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_5/index_9246_seed_16256_dp_10_rank_20_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.03814667128026485, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03814667128026485, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03814667128026485, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young male traveler with slightly tousled black hair seen from the back and profile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing a dark travel jacket and holding a passport and paper boarding pass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate crane shot that lifts upward from a medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multiple planes visible on the airport tarmac below with metallic fuselages catching the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden morning light with visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0240116436034441 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.7740116119384766 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0240116436034441, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0240116436034441, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.30507656931877136, + 0.19379228353500366, + 0.11906929314136505, + 0.0783865749835968, + 0.046470146626234055, + 0.10517618060112, + 0.06998568773269653, + 0.029466979205608368, + 0.028413139283657074, + 0.024163128808140755 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0240116436034441 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young male traveler with slightly tousled black hair seen from the back and profile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing a dark travel jacket and holding a passport and paper boarding pass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate crane shot that lifts upward from a medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multiple planes visible on the airport tarmac below with metallic fuselages catching the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden morning light with visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04309822618961334 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168098211288452 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04309822618961334, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04309822618961334, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19981956481933594, + 0.18564513325691223, + 0.2695392668247223, + 0.08498663455247879, + 0.05399291217327118, + 0.043390657752752304, + 0.04888813570141792, + 0.02663600444793701, + 0.04310157522559166, + 0.044000089168548584 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04309822618961334 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young male traveler with slightly tousled black hair seen from the back and profile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing a dark travel jacket and holding a passport and paper boarding pass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate crane shot that lifts upward from a medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multiple planes visible on the airport tarmac below with metallic fuselages catching the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden morning light with visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864013195037842 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048640251159668 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864013195037842, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864013195037842, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20067355036735535, + 0.4208076298236847, + 0.16109341382980347, + 0.03617577999830246, + 0.048931654542684555, + 0.05183068662881851, + 0.01783689670264721, + 0.013684668578207493, + 0.04064403101801872, + 0.008321648463606834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864013195037842 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young male traveler with slightly tousled black hair seen from the back and profile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing a dark travel jacket and holding a passport and paper boarding pass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate crane shot that lifts upward from a medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multiple planes visible on the airport tarmac below with metallic fuselages catching the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden morning light with visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04864319786429405 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.048643112182617 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04864319786429405, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04864319786429405, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14919570088386536, + 0.3614223897457123, + 0.09461319446563721, + 0.041062936186790466, + 0.04053471237421036, + 0.10347816348075867, + 0.09452623128890991, + 0.07122506946325302, + 0.01507525984197855, + 0.02886630967259407 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04864319786429405 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young male traveler with slightly tousled black hair seen from the back and profile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing a dark travel jacket and holding a passport and paper boarding pass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate crane shot that lifts upward from a medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multiple planes visible on the airport tarmac below with metallic fuselages catching the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden morning light with visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634015679359436 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513402462005615 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634015679359436, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634015679359436, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1874120831489563, + 0.3920932710170746, + 0.11740560084581375, + 0.04167620837688446, + 0.06199377775192261, + 0.08201412856578827, + 0.04029906168580055, + 0.04414784535765648, + 0.013894535601139069, + 0.019063537940382957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634015679359436 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene begins with a soft, gentle style, a medium close-up shot from a slightly low angle, focusing on a lone male traveler standing in a contemplative pose before a vast terminal window. The camera begins with a slow, deliberate crane shot, gracefully lifting upward. The traveler is a young man with slightly tousled black hair, seen from back and profile, wearing a comfortable dark travel jacket. He holds his passport and paper boarding pass loosely in one hand, his posture still, gazing outward. Warm, golden morning light filters through the expansive glass, casting a soft-focus glow over the scene and illuminating the captivating dance of dust particles suspended in the air. As the camera continues its steady ascent, rising high above the silhouettes of the passengers, it reveals the breathtaking grandeur of the airport tarmac below. Multiple planes can be seen, patiently waiting on the runway and at the gate, their metallic fuselages catching the dawn light. The entire landscape is enveloped by a hazy, pale sky, creating a tranquil and poignant atmosphere filled with quiet anticipation for the journey to come.", + "seed": 16257, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_5/index_9246_seed_16257_dp_11_rank_22_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.12951677069067954, + "vlm_logprob": -0.12951677069067954, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.12951677069067954, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young male traveler with slightly tousled black hair seen from the back and profile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing a dark travel jacket and holding a passport and paper boarding pass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate crane shot that lifts upward from a medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multiple planes visible on the airport tarmac below with metallic fuselages catching the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden morning light with visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0344524160027504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.409452438354492 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0344524160027504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0344524160027504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.29973846673965454, + 0.05845753848552704, + 0.08927441388368607, + 0.022313689813017845, + 0.024202415719628334, + 0.03861513361334801, + 0.04962597042322159, + 0.017511049285531044, + 0.014323164708912373, + 0.3859381675720215 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0344524160027504 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young male traveler with slightly tousled black hair seen from the back and profile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing a dark travel jacket and holding a passport and paper boarding pass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate crane shot that lifts upward from a medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multiple planes visible on the airport tarmac below with metallic fuselages catching the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden morning light with visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08912822604179382 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464128255844116 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08912822604179382, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08912822604179382, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12337832897901535, + 0.041045304387807846, + 0.14177970588207245, + 0.020436808466911316, + 0.027726713567972183, + 0.021054070442914963, + 0.044701460748910904, + 0.023849736899137497, + 0.020945308730006218, + 0.5350826382637024 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08912822604179382 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young male traveler with slightly tousled black hair seen from the back and profile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing a dark travel jacket and holding a passport and paper boarding pass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate crane shot that lifts upward from a medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multiple planes visible on the airport tarmac below with metallic fuselages catching the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden morning light with visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.47423630952835083 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9742363095283508 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.47423630952835083, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.47423630952835083, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.34044310450553894, + 0.11736225336790085, + 0.04666338488459587, + 0.012432091869413853, + 0.016490960493683815, + 0.02450944297015667, + 0.021525394171476364, + 0.011159844696521759, + 0.010179292410612106, + 0.3992342948913574 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.47423630952835083 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young male traveler with slightly tousled black hair seen from the back and profile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing a dark travel jacket and holding a passport and paper boarding pass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate crane shot that lifts upward from a medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multiple planes visible on the airport tarmac below with metallic fuselages catching the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden morning light with visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03370017558336258 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087002277374268 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03370017558336258, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03370017558336258, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.36228108406066895, + 0.03330674022436142, + 0.011302577331662178, + 0.014733037911355495, + 0.08675328642129898, + 0.027570560574531555, + 0.018529020249843597, + 0.0059483107179403305, + 0.006778330076485872, + 0.43279704451560974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03370017558336258 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young male traveler with slightly tousled black hair seen from the back and profile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing a dark travel jacket and holding a passport and paper boarding pass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate crane shot that lifts upward from a medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multiple planes visible on the airport tarmac below with metallic fuselages catching the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden morning light with visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01606672629714012 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.141066551208496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01606672629714012, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01606672629714012, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15198656916618347, + 0.10135514289140701, + 0.032557420432567596, + 0.028902046382427216, + 0.057471152395009995, + 0.14968404173851013, + 0.09811445325613022, + 0.017409786581993103, + 0.01114810910075903, + 0.35137125849723816 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01606672629714012 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "The scene begins with a soft, gentle style, a medium close-up shot from a slightly low angle, focusing on a lone male traveler standing in a contemplative pose before a vast terminal window. The camera begins with a slow, deliberate crane shot, gracefully lifting upward. The traveler is a young man with slightly tousled black hair, seen from back and profile, wearing a comfortable dark travel jacket. He holds his passport and paper boarding pass loosely in one hand, his posture still, gazing outward. Warm, golden morning light filters through the expansive glass, casting a soft-focus glow over the scene and illuminating the captivating dance of dust particles suspended in the air. As the camera continues its steady ascent, rising high above the silhouettes of the passengers, it reveals the breathtaking grandeur of the airport tarmac below. Multiple planes can be seen, patiently waiting on the runway and at the gate, their metallic fuselages catching the dawn light. The entire landscape is enveloped by a hazy, pale sky, creating a tranquil and poignant atmosphere filled with quiet anticipation for the journey to come.", + "seed": 16258, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_5/index_9246_seed_16258_dp_11_rank_22_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 5, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.039986474066972734, + "vlm_logprob": -0.039986474066972734, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.275, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.039986474066972734, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young male traveler with slightly tousled black hair seen from the back and profile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing a dark travel jacket and holding a passport and paper boarding pass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate crane shot that lifts upward from a medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multiple planes visible on the airport tarmac below with metallic fuselages catching the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden morning light with visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03903542459011078 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.2890353202819824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03903542459011078, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03903542459011078, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1378328502178192, + 0.04721977934241295, + 0.0450797975063324, + 0.07626281678676605, + 0.24886468052864075, + 0.053610119968652725, + 0.032473400235176086, + 0.09337339550256729, + 0.07248912006616592, + 0.192794069647789 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03903542459011078 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young male traveler with slightly tousled black hair seen from the back and profile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing a dark travel jacket and holding a passport and paper boarding pass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate crane shot that lifts upward from a medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multiple planes visible on the airport tarmac below with metallic fuselages catching the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden morning light with visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07011762261390686 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695117712020874 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07011762261390686, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07011762261390686, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10889872163534164, + 0.050188783556222916, + 0.07305940985679626, + 0.1075642853975296, + 0.21422125399112701, + 0.10566284507513046, + 0.03603888675570488, + 0.05814225971698761, + 0.09864864498376846, + 0.14757488667964935 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07011762261390686 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young male traveler with slightly tousled black hair seen from the back and profile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing a dark travel jacket and holding a passport and paper boarding pass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate crane shot that lifts upward from a medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multiple planes visible on the airport tarmac below with metallic fuselages catching the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden morning light with visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03809041529893875 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.288090467453003 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03809041529893875, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03809041529893875, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.03818144276738167, + 0.015933020040392876, + 0.012381533160805702, + 0.0145879490301013, + 0.017609069123864174, + 0.014723122119903564, + 0.02359587326645851, + 0.041177812963724136, + 0.07185100018978119, + 0.7499591708183289 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03809041529893875 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young male traveler with slightly tousled black hair seen from the back and profile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing a dark travel jacket and holding a passport and paper boarding pass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate crane shot that lifts upward from a medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multiple planes visible on the airport tarmac below with metallic fuselages catching the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden morning light with visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634689211845398 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513469219207764 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634689211845398, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634689211845398, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08989139646291733, + 0.07269569486379623, + 0.09660845994949341, + 0.06941439211368561, + 0.07061437517404556, + 0.1169014573097229, + 0.04925024136900902, + 0.07519751042127609, + 0.105523481965065, + 0.25390300154685974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 5, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634689211845398 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a young male traveler with slightly tousled black hair seen from the back and profile?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the traveler wearing a dark travel jacket and holding a passport and paper boarding pass?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the camera execute a slow, deliberate crane shot that lifts upward from a medium close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Are multiple planes visible on the airport tarmac below with metallic fuselages catching the light?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the scene illuminated by warm golden morning light with visible dust particles in the air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026342015713453293 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.6513419151306152 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026342015713453293, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026342015713453293, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12230689823627472, + 0.02711799554526806, + 0.04745662212371826, + 0.06651975959539413, + 0.03973998501896858, + 0.031172849237918854, + 0.12056957930326462, + 0.09999626129865646, + 0.11019279807806015, + 0.33492720127105713 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026342015713453293 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_6/index_tensor([871, 871])_group_6_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_6/index_tensor([871, 871])_group_6_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..44d0343561dd1f8a21e9f261edf73493abcd892e --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_6/index_tensor([871, 871])_group_6_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "medium, static shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, focuses on a large, adorable giant panda, sitting steadily deep in a vibrant, emerald bamboo forest. Countless tall, slender, emerald-green bamboo stalks densely surround it, forming a natural green barrier. Soft natural light filters through the lush leaves, casting dappled, dancing light across its thick, fluffy black and white fur. It slowly raises one of its front paws and, with its broad, thick black pad, gently, if slightly clumsily, rubs its chubby cheek. The movement causes the soft white fur on its cheek to ripple slightly, and its eyes narrow into slits of contentment, revealing pure contentment. The scene, dominated by vibrant emerald green and stark black and white, is shrouded in a tranquil and soothing atmosphere, imbued with the harmony of nature and the pure beauty of life.", + "seed": 33411, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_6/index_871_seed_33411_dp_12_rank_24_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05488520672079176, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05488520672079176, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05488520672079176, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large panda with black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the panda sitting steadily in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the panda slowly raise a front paw to rub its cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment dominated by vibrant emerald green bamboo stalks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0024081061128526926 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127408027648926 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0024081061128526926, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0024081061128526926, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.27061793208122253, + 0.1360478550195694, + 0.08110617101192474, + 0.06503473222255707, + 0.10250435024499893, + 0.09013380110263824, + 0.02508842758834362, + 0.04359263926744461, + 0.07986760884523392, + 0.10600647330284119 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0024081061128526926 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large panda with black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the panda sitting steadily in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the panda slowly raise a front paw to rub its cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment dominated by vibrant emerald green bamboo stalks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029811859130859375 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.5298118591308594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029811859130859375, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029811859130859375, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19274087250232697, + 0.1396477222442627, + 0.11003278195858002, + 0.07353000342845917, + 0.052397675812244415, + 0.05500199273228645, + 0.14518588781356812, + 0.04428206384181976, + 0.06807321310043335, + 0.11910781264305115 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029811859130859375 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large panda with black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the panda sitting steadily in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the panda slowly raise a front paw to rub its cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment dominated by vibrant emerald green bamboo stalks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.22557370364665985 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.6005736589431763 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.22557370364665985, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.22557370364665985, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1282181292772293, + 0.0816655158996582, + 0.33654284477233887, + 0.03874894976615906, + 0.10630408674478531, + 0.03196408599615097, + 0.0836590826511383, + 0.03571584075689316, + 0.038193296641111374, + 0.11898810416460037 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.22557370364665985 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large panda with black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the panda sitting steadily in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the panda slowly raise a front paw to rub its cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment dominated by vibrant emerald green bamboo stalks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.016072357073426247 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.1410722732543945 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.016072357073426247, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.016072357073426247, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.0906372144818306, + 0.06097398325800896, + 0.34548333287239075, + 0.05214684084057808, + 0.12228842079639435, + 0.04160551354289055, + 0.15130795538425446, + 0.03513859584927559, + 0.04211270064115524, + 0.058305442333221436 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 6, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.016072357073426247 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large panda with black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the panda sitting steadily in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the panda slowly raise a front paw to rub its cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment dominated by vibrant emerald green bamboo stalks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0005600076401606202 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.5005598068237305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0005600076401606202, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0005600076401606202, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1210910975933075, + 0.16811472177505493, + 0.44472405314445496, + 0.048408713191747665, + 0.033560387790203094, + 0.04437656328082085, + 0.03457038104534149, + 0.035381756722927094, + 0.03804328292608261, + 0.031729064881801605 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0005600076401606202 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium, static shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, focuses on a large, adorable giant panda, sitting steadily deep in a vibrant, emerald bamboo forest. Countless tall, slender, emerald-green bamboo stalks densely surround it, forming a natural green barrier. Soft natural light filters through the lush leaves, casting dappled, dancing light across its thick, fluffy black and white fur. It slowly raises one of its front paws and, with its broad, thick black pad, gently, if slightly clumsily, rubs its chubby cheek. The movement causes the soft white fur on its cheek to ripple slightly, and its eyes narrow into slits of contentment, revealing pure contentment. The scene, dominated by vibrant emerald green and stark black and white, is shrouded in a tranquil and soothing atmosphere, imbued with the harmony of nature and the pure beauty of life.", + "seed": 33412, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_6/index_871_seed_33412_dp_12_rank_24_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.035543023329228166, + "vlm_logprob": -0.035543023329228166, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.075, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.035543023329228166, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large panda with black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the panda sitting steadily in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the panda slowly raise a front paw to rub its cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment dominated by vibrant emerald green bamboo stalks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005276799667626619 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.380276679992676 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005276799667626619, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005276799667626619, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21479272842407227, + 0.32947781682014465, + 0.10748074948787689, + 0.07276306301355362, + 0.03338704630732536, + 0.03245651721954346, + 0.037250813096761703, + 0.025841552764177322, + 0.02265859581530094, + 0.12389112263917923 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005276799667626619 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large panda with black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the panda sitting steadily in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the panda slowly raise a front paw to rub its cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment dominated by vibrant emerald green bamboo stalks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07900123298168182 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5790011882781982 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07900123298168182, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07900123298168182, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2421681135892868, + 0.19869722425937653, + 0.1391502022743225, + 0.0991348847746849, + 0.06843655556440353, + 0.018217621371150017, + 0.07812190055847168, + 0.06159655377268791, + 0.04675162583589554, + 0.04772531986236572 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07900123298168182 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large panda with black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the panda sitting steadily in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the panda slowly raise a front paw to rub its cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment dominated by vibrant emerald green bamboo stalks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04306933656334877 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168069362640381 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04306933656334877, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04306933656334877, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20013785362243652, + 0.19092421233654022, + 0.07972212880849838, + 0.13131174445152283, + 0.10047797858715057, + 0.18105199933052063, + 0.04932263121008873, + 0.034168630838394165, + 0.009050833061337471, + 0.023831946775317192 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04306933656334877 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large panda with black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the panda sitting steadily in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the panda slowly raise a front paw to rub its cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment dominated by vibrant emerald green bamboo stalks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.04865546151995659 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486555099487305 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.04865546151995659, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.04865546151995659, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17971092462539673, + 0.24165229499340057, + 0.0905420333147049, + 0.12447396665811539, + 0.12402348965406418, + 0.056700266897678375, + 0.057502757757902145, + 0.042721666395664215, + 0.022863125428557396, + 0.05980950966477394 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.04865546151995659 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large panda with black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the panda sitting steadily in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the panda slowly raise a front paw to rub its cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment dominated by vibrant emerald green bamboo stalks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017122859135270119 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.376712322235107 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017122859135270119, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017122859135270119, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18323580920696259, + 0.39330053329467773, + 0.12294477969408035, + 0.07765475660562515, + 0.08356423676013947, + 0.02655159682035446, + 0.024781297892332077, + 0.04096988961100578, + 0.02051229029893875, + 0.026484819129109383 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017122859135270119 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium, static shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, focuses on a large, adorable giant panda, sitting steadily deep in a vibrant, emerald bamboo forest. Countless tall, slender, emerald-green bamboo stalks densely surround it, forming a natural green barrier. Soft natural light filters through the lush leaves, casting dappled, dancing light across its thick, fluffy black and white fur. It slowly raises one of its front paws and, with its broad, thick black pad, gently, if slightly clumsily, rubs its chubby cheek. The movement causes the soft white fur on its cheek to ripple slightly, and its eyes narrow into slits of contentment, revealing pure contentment. The scene, dominated by vibrant emerald green and stark black and white, is shrouded in a tranquil and soothing atmosphere, imbued with the harmony of nature and the pure beauty of life.", + "seed": 33413, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_6/index_871_seed_33413_dp_13_rank_26_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.026869119284674524, + "vlm_logprob": -0.026869119284674524, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.675, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.026869119284674524, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large panda with black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the panda sitting steadily in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the panda slowly raise a front paw to rub its cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment dominated by vibrant emerald green bamboo stalks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.001854725182056427 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.50185489654541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.001854725182056427, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.001854725182056427, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1948864609003067, + 0.08817158639431, + 0.08379443734884262, + 0.0613785982131958, + 0.26553812623023987, + 0.0534239299595356, + 0.09315084666013718, + 0.08532232791185379, + 0.030498690903186798, + 0.04383496567606926 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.001854725182056427 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large panda with black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the panda sitting steadily in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the panda slowly raise a front paw to rub its cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment dominated by vibrant emerald green bamboo stalks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026357805356383324 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651357889175415 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026357805356383324, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026357805356383324, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.15477466583251953, + 0.12621581554412842, + 0.03115425631403923, + 0.0324723944067955, + 0.2570118010044098, + 0.11347834020853043, + 0.11235548555850983, + 0.13362433016300201, + 0.022046666592359543, + 0.01686624437570572 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026357805356383324 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large panda with black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the panda sitting steadily in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the panda slowly raise a front paw to rub its cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment dominated by vibrant emerald green bamboo stalks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07897710800170898 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578977108001709 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07897710800170898, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07897710800170898, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.058340396732091904, + 0.09784037619829178, + 0.056282516568899155, + 0.061895690858364105, + 0.2167491316795349, + 0.1512390375137329, + 0.1532873958349228, + 0.15138979256153107, + 0.01785827986896038, + 0.03511738404631615 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 6, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07897710800170898 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large panda with black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the panda sitting steadily in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the panda slowly raise a front paw to rub its cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment dominated by vibrant emerald green bamboo stalks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.026343757286667824 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651343822479248 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.026343757286667824, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.026343757286667824, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.06353016942739487, + 0.0748523399233818, + 0.043278470635414124, + 0.052886150777339935, + 0.18452885746955872, + 0.18225204944610596, + 0.04672474041581154, + 0.1009557843208313, + 0.06645294278860092, + 0.18453845381736755 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 4, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.026343757286667824 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large panda with black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the panda sitting steadily in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the panda slowly raise a front paw to rub its cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment dominated by vibrant emerald green bamboo stalks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0008122005965560675 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.12581205368042 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0008122005965560675, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0008122005965560675, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13497671484947205, + 0.2384817898273468, + 0.06286194920539856, + 0.05482623353600502, + 0.24781528115272522, + 0.07785734534263611, + 0.033547136932611465, + 0.08322703838348389, + 0.027585344389081, + 0.038821130990982056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0008122005965560675 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "medium, static shot, shot from a slightly upward angle, focuses on a large, adorable giant panda, sitting steadily deep in a vibrant, emerald bamboo forest. Countless tall, slender, emerald-green bamboo stalks densely surround it, forming a natural green barrier. Soft natural light filters through the lush leaves, casting dappled, dancing light across its thick, fluffy black and white fur. It slowly raises one of its front paws and, with its broad, thick black pad, gently, if slightly clumsily, rubs its chubby cheek. The movement causes the soft white fur on its cheek to ripple slightly, and its eyes narrow into slits of contentment, revealing pure contentment. The scene, dominated by vibrant emerald green and stark black and white, is shrouded in a tranquil and soothing atmosphere, imbued with the harmony of nature and the pure beauty of life.", + "seed": 33414, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_6/index_871_seed_33414_dp_13_rank_26_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 6, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.03719500832958147, + "vlm_logprob": -0.03719500832958147, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.03719500832958147, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large panda with black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the panda sitting steadily in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the panda slowly raise a front paw to rub its cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment dominated by vibrant emerald green bamboo stalks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0022101993672549725 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.2522101402282715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0022101993672549725, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0022101993672549725, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.161997452378273, + 0.3284178674221039, + 0.05001961439847946, + 0.08124814927577972, + 0.13457004725933075, + 0.05565749481320381, + 0.05739978328347206, + 0.04747063294053078, + 0.036644332110881805, + 0.04657457023859024 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0022101993672549725 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large panda with black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the panda sitting steadily in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the panda slowly raise a front paw to rub its cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment dominated by vibrant emerald green bamboo stalks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.029818108305335045 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.529818058013916 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.029818108305335045, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.029818108305335045, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19739466905593872, + 0.07710427045822144, + 0.07167891412973404, + 0.058797985315322876, + 0.10345692187547684, + 0.13079701364040375, + 0.15678395330905914, + 0.07314660400152206, + 0.07277154922485352, + 0.05806810036301613 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.029818108305335045 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large panda with black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the panda sitting steadily in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the panda slowly raise a front paw to rub its cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment dominated by vibrant emerald green bamboo stalks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1270393431186676 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1270394325256348 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1270393431186676, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1270393431186676, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.05064644664525986, + 0.4755311906337738, + 0.0775168240070343, + 0.04615657776594162, + 0.08309486508369446, + 0.11405659466981888, + 0.0433916337788105, + 0.028889857232570648, + 0.028903717175126076, + 0.05181235820055008 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1270393431186676 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large panda with black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the panda sitting steadily in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the panda slowly raise a front paw to rub its cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment dominated by vibrant emerald green bamboo stalks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.02634631097316742 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.651346206665039 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.02634631097316742, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.02634631097316742, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10915789753198624, + 0.12040269374847412, + 0.04389650374650955, + 0.0983753502368927, + 0.17400632798671722, + 0.11586250364780426, + 0.06335287541151047, + 0.11632063239812851, + 0.11241012066602707, + 0.046215079724788666 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 1, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.02634631097316742 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the main subject a large panda with black and white fur?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the panda sitting steadily in a dense bamboo forest?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the panda slowly raise a front paw to rub its cheek?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Is the camera shot static with a slightly upward angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the environment dominated by vibrant emerald green bamboo stalks?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0005610798834823072 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -7.500561237335205 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0005610798834823072, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 7.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0005610798834823072, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10989869385957718, + 0.1813683658838272, + 0.05316165089607239, + 0.13523700833320618, + 0.09911574423313141, + 0.0698331668972969, + 0.10048270225524902, + 0.0688207596540451, + 0.08506692200899124, + 0.09701493382453918 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0005610798834823072 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_7/index_tensor([7833, 7833])_group_7_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_7/index_tensor([7833, 7833])_group_7_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..21ec673f8f639c04a4f048603a231a47745d0be0 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_7/index_tensor([7833, 7833])_group_7_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "long, static shot, filmed from a low angle, focuses on the back of a man, sprinting along a dry, dirt road stained golden by the setting sun. A heavy, well-worn canvas carpentry tool bag on his back bounces violently with his pace, its opening revealing the faint outlines of several wooden-handled tools. A gray cotton T-shirt, soaked with sweat and clinging to his back, and frayed overalls frame his forward-leaning, powerful posture. Each step of his work boots smacks the soft earth, stirring a cloud of fine, yellow-brown dust behind him. This dust cloud, illuminated by the low, backlit sky, instantly ignites into a floating golden halo. Knee-high, withered grass swaying gently in the breeze flares on either side of the road. A few solitary trees cast long shadows against the distant skyline. The warm tones of the entire scene imbue the scene with a sense of dynamic power and the urgency and determination of a man racing towards his goal across a vast landscape.", + "seed": 18317, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_7/index_7833_seed_18317_dp_14_rank_28_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06085051819682121, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06085051819682121, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06085051819682121, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on the back of a man sprinting along a dry, dirt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, well-worn canvas carpentry tool bag visible on the man's back with wooden-handled tools inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a gray cotton T-shirt soaked with sweat and frayed overalls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a cloud of fine, yellow-brown dust kicked up by his boots that appears as a floating golden halo due to backlighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.13454823195934296 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.2595481872558594 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.13454823195934296, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.13454823195934296, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25799936056137085, + 0.091917984187603, + 0.04488097503781319, + 0.0596611388027668, + 0.1988266110420227, + 0.07507438212633133, + 0.1056879535317421, + 0.08869162201881409, + 0.05098075792193413, + 0.02627924084663391 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.13454823195934296 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on the back of a man sprinting along a dry, dirt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, well-worn canvas carpentry tool bag visible on the man's back with wooden-handled tools inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a gray cotton T-shirt soaked with sweat and frayed overalls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a cloud of fine, yellow-brown dust kicked up by his boots that appears as a floating golden halo due to backlighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005987801123410463 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130987644195557 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005987801123410463, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005987801123410463, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.3017447292804718, + 0.16032250225543976, + 0.0731247141957283, + 0.04579481482505798, + 0.08523481339216232, + 0.03569049388170242, + 0.10755961388349533, + 0.062403980642557144, + 0.048351190984249115, + 0.07977311313152313 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005987801123410463 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on the back of a man sprinting along a dry, dirt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, well-worn canvas carpentry tool bag visible on the man's back with wooden-handled tools inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a gray cotton T-shirt soaked with sweat and frayed overalls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a cloud of fine, yellow-brown dust kicked up by his boots that appears as a floating golden halo due to backlighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0700363740324974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950364112854004 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0700363740324974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0700363740324974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19439244270324707, + 0.1245543509721756, + 0.1485775262117386, + 0.04423145949840546, + 0.10715083032846451, + 0.043071623891592026, + 0.10970727354288101, + 0.0808408260345459, + 0.04651591181755066, + 0.10095777362585068 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0700363740324974 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on the back of a man sprinting along a dry, dirt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, well-worn canvas carpentry tool bag visible on the man's back with wooden-handled tools inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a gray cotton T-shirt soaked with sweat and frayed overalls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a cloud of fine, yellow-brown dust kicked up by his boots that appears as a floating golden halo due to backlighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08904262632131577 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4640426635742188 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08904262632131577, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08904262632131577, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.22112077474594116, + 0.11404592543840408, + 0.08330082893371582, + 0.046159446239471436, + 0.22183914482593536, + 0.03350456431508064, + 0.07836262881755829, + 0.09154403954744339, + 0.026715906336903572, + 0.0834067165851593 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08904262632131577 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on the back of a man sprinting along a dry, dirt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, well-worn canvas carpentry tool bag visible on the man's back with wooden-handled tools inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a gray cotton T-shirt soaked with sweat and frayed overalls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a cloud of fine, yellow-brown dust kicked up by his boots that appears as a floating golden halo due to backlighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004637557547539473 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379637718200684 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004637557547539473, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004637557547539473, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14159832894802094, + 0.0736885517835617, + 0.041976287961006165, + 0.0318780243396759, + 0.19319629669189453, + 0.04243125766515732, + 0.16660431027412415, + 0.18310599029064178, + 0.024947915226221085, + 0.1005731001496315 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 7, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004637557547539473 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "long, static shot, filmed from a low angle, focuses on the back of a man, sprinting along a dry, dirt road stained golden by the setting sun. A heavy, well-worn canvas carpentry tool bag on his back bounces violently with his pace, its opening revealing the faint outlines of several wooden-handled tools. A gray cotton T-shirt, soaked with sweat and clinging to his back, and frayed overalls frame his forward-leaning, powerful posture. Each step of his work boots smacks the soft earth, stirring a cloud of fine, yellow-brown dust behind him. This dust cloud, illuminated by the low, backlit sky, instantly ignites into a floating golden halo. Knee-high, withered grass swaying gently in the breeze flares on either side of the road. A few solitary trees cast long shadows against the distant skyline. The warm tones of the entire scene imbue the scene with a sense of dynamic power and the urgency and determination of a man racing towards his goal across a vast landscape.", + "seed": 18318, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_7/index_7833_seed_18318_dp_14_rank_28_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.07538906168192624, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07538906168192624, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.4, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07538906168192624, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on the back of a man sprinting along a dry, dirt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, well-worn canvas carpentry tool bag visible on the man's back with wooden-handled tools inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a gray cotton T-shirt soaked with sweat and frayed overalls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a cloud of fine, yellow-brown dust kicked up by his boots that appears as a floating golden halo due to backlighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20640972256660461 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.8314096927642822 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20640972256660461, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20640972256660461, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2611677348613739, + 0.0919916033744812, + 0.03836967423558235, + 0.08064686506986618, + 0.0448618158698082, + 0.04778829216957092, + 0.029667459428310394, + 0.06274130195379257, + 0.21013106405735016, + 0.13263417780399323 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 8, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20640972256660461 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on the back of a man sprinting along a dry, dirt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, well-worn canvas carpentry tool bag visible on the man's back with wooden-handled tools inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a gray cotton T-shirt soaked with sweat and frayed overalls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a cloud of fine, yellow-brown dust kicked up by his boots that appears as a floating golden halo due to backlighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004692494869232178 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379692554473877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004692494869232178, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004692494869232178, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2907632887363434, + 0.11568642407655716, + 0.04230482876300812, + 0.05687003582715988, + 0.045623891055583954, + 0.024365415796637535, + 0.043564897030591965, + 0.14667654037475586, + 0.11939533799886703, + 0.11474929749965668 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 7, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004692494869232178 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on the back of a man sprinting along a dry, dirt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, well-worn canvas carpentry tool bag visible on the man's back with wooden-handled tools inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a gray cotton T-shirt soaked with sweat and frayed overalls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a cloud of fine, yellow-brown dust kicked up by his boots that appears as a floating golden halo due to backlighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07005438208580017 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.695054292678833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07005438208580017, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07005438208580017, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1558636873960495, + 0.22489775717258453, + 0.053214430809020996, + 0.03873062878847122, + 0.06333527714014053, + 0.01720570959150791, + 0.11823033541440964, + 0.1545921266078949, + 0.11625035107135773, + 0.0576796792447567 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07005438208580017 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on the back of a man sprinting along a dry, dirt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, well-worn canvas carpentry tool bag visible on the man's back with wooden-handled tools inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a gray cotton T-shirt soaked with sweat and frayed overalls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a cloud of fine, yellow-brown dust kicked up by his boots that appears as a floating golden halo due to backlighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08905015140771866 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464050054550171 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08905015140771866, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08905015140771866, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16623619198799133, + 0.13023920357227325, + 0.028294585645198822, + 0.03053550235927105, + 0.04708433523774147, + 0.031910646706819534, + 0.061402834951877594, + 0.10708784312009811, + 0.3370831310749054, + 0.06012571603059769 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08905015140771866 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on the back of a man sprinting along a dry, dirt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, well-worn canvas carpentry tool bag visible on the man's back with wooden-handled tools inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a gray cotton T-shirt soaked with sweat and frayed overalls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a cloud of fine, yellow-brown dust kicked up by his boots that appears as a floating golden halo due to backlighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006738557480275631 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006738662719727 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006738557480275631, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006738557480275631, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09666108340024948, + 0.035709962248802185, + 0.013547885231673717, + 0.023056887090206146, + 0.017736753448843956, + 0.0323522724211216, + 0.062074244022369385, + 0.057639963924884796, + 0.5423904657363892, + 0.11883045732975006 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006738557480275631 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "long, static shot, filmed from a low angle, focuses on the back of a man, sprinting along a dry, dirt road stained golden by the setting sun. A heavy, well-worn canvas carpentry tool bag on his back bounces violently with his pace, its opening revealing the faint outlines of several wooden-handled tools. A gray cotton T-shirt, soaked with sweat and clinging to his back, and frayed overalls frame his forward-leaning, powerful posture. Each step of his work boots smacks the soft earth, stirring a cloud of fine, yellow-brown dust behind him. This dust cloud, illuminated by the low, backlit sky, instantly ignites into a floating golden halo. Knee-high, withered grass swaying gently in the breeze flares on either side of the road. A few solitary trees cast long shadows against the distant skyline. The warm tones of the entire scene imbue the scene with a sense of dynamic power and the urgency and determination of a man racing towards his goal across a vast landscape.", + "seed": 18319, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_7/index_7833_seed_18319_dp_15_rank_30_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.05954241389408708, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05954241389408708, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.525, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05954241389408708, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on the back of a man sprinting along a dry, dirt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, well-worn canvas carpentry tool bag visible on the man's back with wooden-handled tools inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a gray cotton T-shirt soaked with sweat and frayed overalls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a cloud of fine, yellow-brown dust kicked up by his boots that appears as a floating golden halo due to backlighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.15141955018043518 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1514196395874023 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.15141955018043518, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.15141955018043518, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2146967649459839, + 0.1191505491733551, + 0.26520976424217224, + 0.07980932295322418, + 0.07936029881238937, + 0.03379882872104645, + 0.05205368250608444, + 0.041023995727300644, + 0.07487374544143677, + 0.0400230698287487 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.15141955018043518 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on the back of a man sprinting along a dry, dirt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, well-worn canvas carpentry tool bag visible on the man's back with wooden-handled tools inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a gray cotton T-shirt soaked with sweat and frayed overalls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a cloud of fine, yellow-brown dust kicked up by his boots that appears as a floating golden halo due to backlighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007679108530282974 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.882678985595703 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007679108530282974, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007679108530282974, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2437669038772583, + 0.16275809705257416, + 0.35413751006126404, + 0.08819018304347992, + 0.03657839819788933, + 0.02293000929057598, + 0.015919221565127373, + 0.01934587024152279, + 0.03299887478351593, + 0.02337494306266308 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007679108530282974 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on the back of a man sprinting along a dry, dirt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, well-worn canvas carpentry tool bag visible on the man's back with wooden-handled tools inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a gray cotton T-shirt soaked with sweat and frayed overalls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a cloud of fine, yellow-brown dust kicked up by his boots that appears as a floating golden halo due to backlighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0549825057387352 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9299824237823486 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0549825057387352, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0549825057387352, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20156842470169067, + 0.19095772504806519, + 0.3178134560585022, + 0.038046468049287796, + 0.04835943505167961, + 0.02466699294745922, + 0.06470634043216705, + 0.05204629525542259, + 0.026735788211226463, + 0.03509905934333801 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0549825057387352 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on the back of a man sprinting along a dry, dirt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, well-worn canvas carpentry tool bag visible on the man's back with wooden-handled tools inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a gray cotton T-shirt soaked with sweat and frayed overalls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a cloud of fine, yellow-brown dust kicked up by his boots that appears as a floating golden halo due to backlighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07899109274148941 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.578991174697876 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07899109274148941, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07899109274148941, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18660642206668854, + 0.15399828553199768, + 0.38890430331230164, + 0.04023734852671623, + 0.0301626268774271, + 0.01741531863808632, + 0.060096077620983124, + 0.06855324655771255, + 0.024228323251008987, + 0.029797997325658798 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07899109274148941 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on the back of a man sprinting along a dry, dirt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, well-worn canvas carpentry tool bag visible on the man's back with wooden-handled tools inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a gray cotton T-shirt soaked with sweat and frayed overalls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a cloud of fine, yellow-brown dust kicked up by his boots that appears as a floating golden halo due to backlighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004639812279492617 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379639625549316 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004639812279492617, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004639812279492617, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10493390262126923, + 0.1726657748222351, + 0.237884983420372, + 0.07548978924751282, + 0.053939204663038254, + 0.05488305166363716, + 0.10473322123289108, + 0.06286259740591049, + 0.03751083463430405, + 0.09509658813476562 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004639812279492617 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "long, static shot, filmed from a low angle, focuses on the back of a man, sprinting along a dry, dirt road stained golden by the setting sun. A heavy, well-worn canvas carpentry tool bag on his back bounces violently with his pace, its opening revealing the faint outlines of several wooden-handled tools. A gray cotton T-shirt, soaked with sweat and clinging to his back, and frayed overalls frame his forward-leaning, powerful posture. Each step of his work boots smacks the soft earth, stirring a cloud of fine, yellow-brown dust behind him. This dust cloud, illuminated by the low, backlit sky, instantly ignites into a floating golden halo. Knee-high, withered grass swaying gently in the breeze flares on either side of the road. A few solitary trees cast long shadows against the distant skyline. The warm tones of the entire scene imbue the scene with a sense of dynamic power and the urgency and determination of a man racing towards his goal across a vast landscape.", + "seed": 18320, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_7/index_7833_seed_18320_dp_15_rank_30_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 7, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.04250127486884594, + "vlm_logprob": -0.04250127486884594, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.8, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.04250127486884594, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on the back of a man sprinting along a dry, dirt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, well-worn canvas carpentry tool bag visible on the man's back with wooden-handled tools inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a gray cotton T-shirt soaked with sweat and frayed overalls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a cloud of fine, yellow-brown dust kicked up by his boots that appears as a floating golden halo due to backlighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07745755463838577 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.9524576663970947 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07745755463838577, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07745755463838577, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2150459587574005, + 0.08122511953115463, + 0.08417613059282303, + 0.06647093594074249, + 0.041543833911418915, + 0.08441023528575897, + 0.06109675392508507, + 0.0907277911901474, + 0.134978249669075, + 0.14032508432865143 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 9, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07745755463838577 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on the back of a man sprinting along a dry, dirt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, well-worn canvas carpentry tool bag visible on the man's back with wooden-handled tools inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a gray cotton T-shirt soaked with sweat and frayed overalls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a cloud of fine, yellow-brown dust kicked up by his boots that appears as a floating golden halo due to backlighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008677276782691479 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.7586774826049805 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008677276782691479, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008677276782691479, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2236500382423401, + 0.14758238196372986, + 0.08668918907642365, + 0.17100238800048828, + 0.056944962590932846, + 0.10994412750005722, + 0.05903683602809906, + 0.04092153534293175, + 0.06829898804426193, + 0.035929612815380096 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008677276782691479 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on the back of a man sprinting along a dry, dirt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, well-worn canvas carpentry tool bag visible on the man's back with wooden-handled tools inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a gray cotton T-shirt soaked with sweat and frayed overalls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a cloud of fine, yellow-brown dust kicked up by his boots that appears as a floating golden halo due to backlighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.03371550515294075 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.4087154865264893 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.03371550515294075, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.03371550515294075, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.26736071705818176, + 0.09031739830970764, + 0.05802958831191063, + 0.1268566995859146, + 0.04820830747485161, + 0.19475466012954712, + 0.06509154289960861, + 0.06563577800989151, + 0.04766477271914482, + 0.036080554127693176 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.03371550515294075 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on the back of a man sprinting along a dry, dirt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, well-worn canvas carpentry tool bag visible on the man's back with wooden-handled tools inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a gray cotton T-shirt soaked with sweat and frayed overalls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a cloud of fine, yellow-brown dust kicked up by his boots that appears as a floating golden halo due to backlighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08904088288545609 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464040994644165 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08904088288545609, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08904088288545609, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23887887597084045, + 0.10380855202674866, + 0.07160507142543793, + 0.0784258097410202, + 0.11016983538866043, + 0.15305493772029877, + 0.05597860366106033, + 0.04417809844017029, + 0.0937473475933075, + 0.05015284940600395 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 5, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08904088288545609 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot filmed from a low angle?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the camera focused on the back of a man sprinting along a dry, dirt road?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is a heavy, well-worn canvas carpentry tool bag visible on the man's back with wooden-handled tools inside?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the man wear a gray cotton T-shirt soaked with sweat and frayed overalls?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is a cloud of fine, yellow-brown dust kicked up by his boots that appears as a floating golden halo due to backlighting?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0036151548847556114 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.628615379333496 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0036151548847556114, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0036151548847556114, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13873086869716644, + 0.08703666180372238, + 0.09219668805599213, + 0.04631369560956955, + 0.03718499466776848, + 0.11481288075447083, + 0.14820276200771332, + 0.12280096113681793, + 0.1669354885816574, + 0.045785024762153625 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 6, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0036151548847556114 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_8/index_tensor([1542, 1542])_group_8_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_8/index_tensor([1542, 1542])_group_8_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..d12187e103e84039d3cee384f3e3945c1a100a60 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_8/index_tensor([1542, 1542])_group_8_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up static shot, rendered with pristine mechanical realism, captures the pivotal moment of impact. An anti-tank missile, its frame adorned with an olive-drab, jagged nose cone, hurtles towards a plate of dark gray reinforced steel. At the moment of contact, the missile's warhead catastrophically collapses, its thin metal shell curling and collapsing inward under the immense force. This deformation instantly triggers the internal shaped charge, which explodes with a dazzling flash, propelling a jet of superheated, hypervelocity-laden molten copper forward. With a searing white intensity, the blazing stream strikes the steel plate and begins to penetrate it with ferocious precision. The point of impact instantly glows white-hot, heat radiating outward in waves of cherry red and orange, while the thick plate recoils visibly and violently. Sparks and droplets of molten metal erupt from the entry point, creating a brutal yet captivating spectacle of physics against the desolate, out-of-focus background, conveying an atmosphere of pure, unadulterated kinetic violence.", + "seed": 32463, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_8/index_1542_seed_32463_dp_16_rank_32_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.06978249419480562, + "vlm_logprob": -0.06978249419480562, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.35, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.06978249419480562, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the missile olive-drab with a jagged nose cone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the missile's warhead collapse and curl inward upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of molten copper strike the steel plate and cause it to glow white-hot with cherry red and orange heat waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background desolate and out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11941460520029068 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.3694145679473877 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11941460520029068, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11941460520029068, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12996867299079895, + 0.03664054349064827, + 0.04302508011460304, + 0.2129608392715454, + 0.10452874004840851, + 0.023574447259306908, + 0.025350799784064293, + 0.03918341174721718, + 0.027508102357387543, + 0.3572593033313751 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11941460520029068 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the missile olive-drab with a jagged nose cone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the missile's warhead collapse and curl inward upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of molten copper strike the steel plate and cause it to glow white-hot with cherry red and orange heat waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background desolate and out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.12710264325141907 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.1271026134490967 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.12710264325141907, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.12710264325141907, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07870050519704819, + 0.05034991726279259, + 0.11578438431024551, + 0.20942889153957367, + 0.05391146242618561, + 0.15935006737709045, + 0.01854967698454857, + 0.0211033932864666, + 0.02252264693379402, + 0.2702990472316742 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.12710264325141907 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the missile olive-drab with a jagged nose cone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the missile's warhead collapse and curl inward upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of molten copper strike the steel plate and cause it to glow white-hot with cherry red and orange heat waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background desolate and out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.089090496301651 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.464090585708618 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.089090496301651, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.089090496301651, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.041605446487665176, + 0.01670951209962368, + 0.05646909400820732, + 0.3174135982990265, + 0.07389567047357559, + 0.3448944389820099, + 0.030206050723791122, + 0.020202577114105225, + 0.015621422789990902, + 0.08298218995332718 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 3, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.089090496301651 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the missile olive-drab with a jagged nose cone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the missile's warhead collapse and curl inward upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of molten copper strike the steel plate and cause it to glow white-hot with cherry red and orange heat waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background desolate and out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00865340419113636 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.75865364074707 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00865340419113636, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00865340419113636, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.028109127655625343, + 0.016306376084685326, + 0.0451800562441349, + 0.2038387954235077, + 0.09173131734132767, + 0.1088593453168869, + 0.024543408304452896, + 0.02913549914956093, + 0.04448947310447693, + 0.4078066349029541 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00865340419113636 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the missile olive-drab with a jagged nose cone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the missile's warhead collapse and curl inward upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of molten copper strike the steel plate and cause it to glow white-hot with cherry red and orange heat waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background desolate and out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004651322029531002 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.3796515464782715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004651322029531002, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004651322029531002, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07106635719537735, + 0.029812080785632133, + 0.0513419583439827, + 0.1858716458082199, + 0.3114420175552368, + 0.06059582158923149, + 0.026836315169930458, + 0.014535486698150635, + 0.01999642141163349, + 0.22850185632705688 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004651322029531002 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up static shot, rendered with pristine mechanical realism, captures the pivotal moment of impact. An anti-tank missile, its frame adorned with an olive-drab, jagged nose cone, hurtles towards a plate of dark gray reinforced steel. At the moment of contact, the missile's warhead catastrophically collapses, its thin metal shell curling and collapsing inward under the immense force. This deformation instantly triggers the internal shaped charge, which explodes with a dazzling flash, propelling a jet of superheated, hypervelocity-laden molten copper forward. With a searing white intensity, the blazing stream strikes the steel plate and begins to penetrate it with ferocious precision. The point of impact instantly glows white-hot, heat radiating outward in waves of cherry red and orange, while the thick plate recoils visibly and violently. Sparks and droplets of molten metal erupt from the entry point, creating a brutal yet captivating spectacle of physics against the desolate, out-of-focus background, conveying an atmosphere of pure, unadulterated kinetic violence.", + "seed": 32464, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_8/index_1542_seed_32464_dp_16_rank_32_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.1461387125775218, + "vlm_logprob": -0.1461387125775218, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.075000023841858, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.1461387125775218, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the missile olive-drab with a jagged nose cone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the missile's warhead collapse and curl inward upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of molten copper strike the steel plate and cause it to glow white-hot with cherry red and orange heat waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background desolate and out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.4888169467449188 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.9888169765472412 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.4888169467449188, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.4888169467449188, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19714288413524628, + 0.19720394909381866, + 0.05364619195461273, + 0.04495619237422943, + 0.1000174880027771, + 0.0366249717772007, + 0.24427975714206696, + 0.02478078380227089, + 0.050812333822250366, + 0.05053548142313957 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.4888169467449188 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the missile olive-drab with a jagged nose cone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the missile's warhead collapse and curl inward upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of molten copper strike the steel plate and cause it to glow white-hot with cherry red and orange heat waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background desolate and out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.1428602933883667 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.0178604125976562 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.1428602933883667, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.8750001192092896, + "token_credit_reward": -0.1428602933883667, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2171274721622467, + 0.10624715685844421, + 0.19699905812740326, + 0.06962904334068298, + 0.06832247972488403, + 0.03897299990057945, + 0.07691621780395508, + 0.021244075149297714, + 0.1557660698890686, + 0.04877549409866333 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 2, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.1428602933883667 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the missile olive-drab with a jagged nose cone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the missile's warhead collapse and curl inward upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of molten copper strike the steel plate and cause it to glow white-hot with cherry red and orange heat waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background desolate and out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.08910053223371506 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.4641005992889404 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.08910053223371506, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.08910053223371506, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1658225655555725, + 0.12351227551698685, + 0.04409247636795044, + 0.04458584636449814, + 0.12427108734846115, + 0.04354037716984749, + 0.06433262676000595, + 0.12600462138652802, + 0.20584160089492798, + 0.057996541261672974 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 8, + 0, + 7 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.08910053223371506 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the missile olive-drab with a jagged nose cone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the missile's warhead collapse and curl inward upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of molten copper strike the steel plate and cause it to glow white-hot with cherry red and orange heat waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background desolate and out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004653101786971092 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379652976989746 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004653101786971092, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004653101786971092, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.18759100139141083, + 0.04986551031470299, + 0.048897188156843185, + 0.04393870756030083, + 0.06475115567445755, + 0.07531087845563889, + 0.27214816212654114, + 0.04012202471494675, + 0.11175680160522461, + 0.10561854392290115 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004653101786971092 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the missile olive-drab with a jagged nose cone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the missile's warhead collapse and curl inward upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of molten copper strike the steel plate and cause it to glow white-hot with cherry red and orange heat waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background desolate and out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005262688733637333 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.255262851715088 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005262688733637333, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005262688733637333, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2156497836112976, + 0.2133159339427948, + 0.03965798765420914, + 0.0476343147456646, + 0.18924006819725037, + 0.04935107380151749, + 0.08775539696216583, + 0.016669809818267822, + 0.11047393828630447, + 0.030251603573560715 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 1, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005262688733637333 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up static shot, rendered with pristine mechanical realism, captures the pivotal moment of impact. An anti-tank missile, its frame adorned with an olive-drab, jagged nose cone, hurtles towards a plate of dark gray reinforced steel. At the moment of contact, the missile's warhead catastrophically collapses, its thin metal shell curling and collapsing inward under the immense force. This deformation instantly triggers the internal shaped charge, which explodes with a dazzling flash, propelling a jet of superheated, hypervelocity-laden molten copper forward. With a searing white intensity, the blazing stream strikes the steel plate and begins to penetrate it with ferocious precision. The point of impact instantly glows white-hot, heat radiating outward in waves of cherry red and orange, while the thick plate recoils visibly and violently. Sparks and droplets of molten metal erupt from the entry point, creating a brutal yet captivating spectacle of physics against the desolate, out-of-focus background, conveying an atmosphere of pure, unadulterated kinetic violence.", + "seed": 32465, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_8/index_1542_seed_32465_dp_17_rank_34_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.07936703180894256, + "vlm_logprob": -0.07936703180894256, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 3.3, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.07936703180894256, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the missile olive-drab with a jagged nose cone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the missile's warhead collapse and curl inward upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of molten copper strike the steel plate and cause it to glow white-hot with cherry red and orange heat waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background desolate and out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.05680634826421738 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.1818063259124756 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.05680634826421738, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.05680634826421738, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20109085738658905, + 0.06424486637115479, + 0.280575692653656, + 0.1255272924900055, + 0.08692705631256104, + 0.021443666890263557, + 0.010598151944577694, + 0.03308447450399399, + 0.1541951447725296, + 0.02231278456747532 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.05680634826421738 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the missile olive-drab with a jagged nose cone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the missile's warhead collapse and curl inward upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of molten copper strike the steel plate and cause it to glow white-hot with cherry red and orange heat waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background desolate and out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.2521289885044098 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.5021289587020874 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.2521289885044098, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.2521289885044098, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13373669981956482, + 0.12486458569765091, + 0.30149325728416443, + 0.06514403969049454, + 0.06917013972997665, + 0.18124032020568848, + 0.032264113426208496, + 0.01852998696267605, + 0.06655135005712509, + 0.007005489431321621 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 5, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.2521289885044098 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the missile olive-drab with a jagged nose cone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the missile's warhead collapse and curl inward upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of molten copper strike the steel plate and cause it to glow white-hot with cherry red and orange heat waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background desolate and out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07005982846021652 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.6950597763061523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07005982846021652, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.625, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07005982846021652, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.13089916110038757, + 0.0545397512614727, + 0.3531695604324341, + 0.04445784166455269, + 0.10275960713624954, + 0.03894408419728279, + 0.0308055616915226, + 0.07628288865089417, + 0.13132444024085999, + 0.036817096173763275 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07005982846021652 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the missile olive-drab with a jagged nose cone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the missile's warhead collapse and curl inward upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of molten copper strike the steel plate and cause it to glow white-hot with cherry red and orange heat waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background desolate and out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0067501612938940525 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.006750106811523 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0067501612938940525, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0067501612938940525, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19739380478858948, + 0.03929835930466652, + 0.11460194736719131, + 0.036950595676898956, + 0.07513903081417084, + 0.23045538365840912, + 0.031516335904598236, + 0.023235270753502846, + 0.21523946523666382, + 0.036169733852148056 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 8, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0067501612938940525 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the missile olive-drab with a jagged nose cone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the missile's warhead collapse and curl inward upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of molten copper strike the steel plate and cause it to glow white-hot with cherry red and orange heat waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background desolate and out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01108983252197504 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.51108980178833 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01108983252197504, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01108983252197504, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.25877439975738525, + 0.020636800676584244, + 0.10554051399230957, + 0.035472508519887924, + 0.04456363990902901, + 0.35189104080200195, + 0.04323757812380791, + 0.04328778386116028, + 0.08889096975326538, + 0.007704735733568668 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01108983252197504 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "An extreme close-up static shot, rendered with pristine mechanical realism, captures the pivotal moment of impact. An anti-tank missile, its frame adorned with an olive-drab, jagged nose cone, hurtles towards a plate of dark gray reinforced steel. At the moment of contact, the missile's warhead catastrophically collapses, its thin metal shell curling and collapsing inward under the immense force. This deformation instantly triggers the internal shaped charge, which explodes with a dazzling flash, propelling a jet of superheated, hypervelocity-laden molten copper forward. With a searing white intensity, the blazing stream strikes the steel plate and begins to penetrate it with ferocious precision. The point of impact instantly glows white-hot, heat radiating outward in waves of cherry red and orange, while the thick plate recoils visibly and violently. Sparks and droplets of molten metal erupt from the entry point, creating a brutal yet captivating spectacle of physics against the desolate, out-of-focus background, conveying an atmosphere of pure, unadulterated kinetic violence.", + "seed": 32466, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_8/index_1542_seed_32466_dp_17_rank_34_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 8, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.16874631699174641, + "vlm_logprob": -0.16874631699174641, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 2.575, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.16874631699174641, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the missile olive-drab with a jagged nose cone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the missile's warhead collapse and curl inward upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of molten copper strike the steel plate and cause it to glow white-hot with cherry red and orange heat waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background desolate and out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.17856502532958984 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.9285650253295898 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.17856502532958984, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.17856502532958984, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.256454199552536, + 0.09342734515666962, + 0.06769616156816483, + 0.05098157003521919, + 0.28025883436203003, + 0.03514043986797333, + 0.07802419364452362, + 0.05668922886252403, + 0.041100043803453445, + 0.040227942168712616 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.17856502532958984 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the missile olive-drab with a jagged nose cone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the missile's warhead collapse and curl inward upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of molten copper strike the steel plate and cause it to glow white-hot with cherry red and orange heat waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background desolate and out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.38714608550071716 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.1371461153030396 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.38714608550071716, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 0.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.38714608550071716, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.38450732827186584, + 0.0820188894867897, + 0.1101607158780098, + 0.07492087036371231, + 0.1363832801580429, + 0.04993939772248268, + 0.0484963096678257, + 0.0360250324010849, + 0.03285808488726616, + 0.04469002038240433 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.38714608550071716 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the missile olive-drab with a jagged nose cone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the missile's warhead collapse and curl inward upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of molten copper strike the steel plate and cause it to glow white-hot with cherry red and orange heat waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background desolate and out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.252150297164917 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.502150297164917 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.252150297164917, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.252150297164917, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.07215884327888489, + 0.057579778134822845, + 0.04252537339925766, + 0.1294523924589157, + 0.2895286977291107, + 0.12922163307666779, + 0.09083735942840576, + 0.08314719051122665, + 0.03942372277379036, + 0.06612496823072433 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 3, + 5 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.252150297164917 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the missile olive-drab with a jagged nose cone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the missile's warhead collapse and curl inward upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of molten copper strike the steel plate and cause it to glow white-hot with cherry red and orange heat waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background desolate and out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005267550237476826 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.25526762008667 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005267550237476826, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005267550237476826, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09633717685937881, + 0.0826018825173378, + 0.18478861451148987, + 0.03725551441311836, + 0.11785467714071274, + 0.04708763211965561, + 0.06725944578647614, + 0.10139036178588867, + 0.0911194235086441, + 0.174305260181427 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 9, + 4 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005267550237476826 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the shot framed as an extreme close-up?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is the missile olive-drab with a jagged nose cone?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Does the missile's warhead collapse and curl inward upon impact?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does a jet of molten copper strike the steel plate and cause it to glow white-hot with cherry red and orange heat waves?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Is the background desolate and out-of-focus?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.020602626726031303 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.8956027030944824 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.020602626726031303, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.020602626726031303, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.23145538568496704, + 0.10882366448640823, + 0.16099606454372406, + 0.031447477638721466, + 0.23136869072914124, + 0.07202254235744476, + 0.025117982178926468, + 0.08516345918178558, + 0.03109923005104065, + 0.022505497559905052 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 4, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.020602626726031303 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_9/index_tensor([1485, 1485])_group_9_rewards.json b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_9/index_tensor([1485, 1485])_group_9_rewards.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..8c386bee5d996ef9b16e3c5d1f92ff31fa900f65 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_9/index_tensor([1485, 1485])_group_9_rewards.json @@ -0,0 +1,882 @@ +[ + { + "prompt": "slow, horizontal camera cuts across a tranquil, lush, verdant bamboo forest. Sunlight filters through the towering bamboo leaves, casting soft shafts of light in the misty air and casting dappled, swaying shadows on the ground. At the center of the frame, a swordsman, clad in a flowing, pure white silk robe, stands. His features are handsome, his long, dark hair held back by a simple white headband. He wields a thin, gleaming sword in his hand, performing a flowing, flowing dance. His movements are not meant for combat, but rather imbued with the rhythmic quality of dance. Sometimes he spins gracefully, his wide sleeves tracing elegant arcs through the air; sometimes he descends steadily, the tip of his sword lightly touching the ground, stirring up a cloud of fine dust. With each swing, the thin blade precisely captures and reflects the scattered light from the forest, leaving behind trails of silver light, like ripples on water. As the camera moves closer steadily and calmly, the picture gradually passes through the bamboo shadows in the foreground, narrowing the focus from his dancing posture to his well-defined face. His sharp and focused eyes are clearly visible, and the cold light of the sword is reflected in his pupils, as if the whole world is left with only him and the sword in his hand. The whole scene is filled with an ultimate tranquility and restrained sense of power in the classical oriental aesthetics.", + "seed": 25741, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_9/index_1485_seed_25741_dp_18_rank_36_sample_0_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 0, + "avg": -0.05325471628457308, + "vlm_logprob": -0.05325471628457308, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.1, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.05325471628457308, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush, verdant bamboo forest with misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a swordsman wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe and a white headband visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a flowing dance with a thin, gleaming sword, including actions like spinning and the sword tip touching the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a horizontal cut across the scene and then move closer steadily and calmly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement eventually narrow the focus to the swordsman's well-defined face and sharp, focused eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.008262262679636478 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.8832621574401855 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.008262262679636478, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.008262262679636478, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2658856511116028, + 0.10864858329296112, + 0.10868743062019348, + 0.15317311882972717, + 0.04438377171754837, + 0.10137010365724564, + 0.044092852622270584, + 0.02679303102195263, + 0.07311100512742996, + 0.0738544911146164 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 3, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.008262262679636478 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush, verdant bamboo forest with misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a swordsman wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe and a white headband visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a flowing dance with a thin, gleaming sword, including actions like spinning and the sword tip touching the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a horizontal cut across the scene and then move closer steadily and calmly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement eventually narrow the focus to the swordsman's well-defined face and sharp, focused eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.003200292121618986 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753200054168701 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.003200292121618986, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.003200292121618986, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.14784985780715942, + 0.060029298067092896, + 0.13633662462234497, + 0.06901770830154419, + 0.15585875511169434, + 0.04360310733318329, + 0.17862728238105774, + 0.056151386350393295, + 0.03439946845173836, + 0.11812654882669449 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 6, + 4, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.003200292121618986 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush, verdant bamboo forest with misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a swordsman wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe and a white headband visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a flowing dance with a thin, gleaming sword, including actions like spinning and the sword tip touching the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a horizontal cut across the scene and then move closer steadily and calmly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement eventually narrow the focus to the swordsman's well-defined face and sharp, focused eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004637439269572496 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.379637241363525 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004637439269572496, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004637439269572496, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.21816426515579224, + 0.08295750617980957, + 0.10960039496421814, + 0.08315658569335938, + 0.10650349408388138, + 0.09176184237003326, + 0.11297699809074402, + 0.052339620888233185, + 0.030892999842762947, + 0.11164630204439163 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004637439269572496 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush, verdant bamboo forest with misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a swordsman wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe and a white headband visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a flowing dance with a thin, gleaming sword, including actions like spinning and the sword tip touching the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a horizontal cut across the scene and then move closer steadily and calmly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement eventually narrow the focus to the swordsman's well-defined face and sharp, focused eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.20153027772903442 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -1.7015302181243896 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.20153027772903442, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 1.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.20153027772903442, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.17837916314601898, + 0.04578667879104614, + 0.07179882377386093, + 0.07211331278085709, + 0.24843475222587585, + 0.04906740039587021, + 0.06363188475370407, + 0.059282466769218445, + 0.04416817054152489, + 0.16733738780021667 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.20153027772903442 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush, verdant bamboo forest with misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a swordsman wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe and a white headband visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a flowing dance with a thin, gleaming sword, including actions like spinning and the sword tip touching the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a horizontal cut across the scene and then move closer steadily and calmly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement eventually narrow the focus to the swordsman's well-defined face and sharp, focused eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.048643309623003006 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.0486433506011963 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.048643309623003006, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.048643309623003006, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12985457479953766, + 0.04271300137042999, + 0.11832093447446823, + 0.05014200508594513, + 0.25673985481262207, + 0.036973100155591965, + 0.10326134413480759, + 0.05782420188188553, + 0.02989569492638111, + 0.17427530884742737 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 4, + 9, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.048643309623003006 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, horizontal camera cuts across a tranquil, lush, verdant bamboo forest. Sunlight filters through the towering bamboo leaves, casting soft shafts of light in the misty air and casting dappled, swaying shadows on the ground. At the center of the frame, a swordsman, clad in a flowing, pure white silk robe, stands. His features are handsome, his long, dark hair held back by a simple white headband. He wields a thin, gleaming sword in his hand, performing a flowing, flowing dance. His movements are not meant for combat, but rather imbued with the rhythmic quality of dance. Sometimes he spins gracefully, his wide sleeves tracing elegant arcs through the air; sometimes he descends steadily, the tip of his sword lightly touching the ground, stirring up a cloud of fine dust. With each swing, the thin blade precisely captures and reflects the scattered light from the forest, leaving behind trails of silver light, like ripples on water. As the camera moves closer steadily and calmly, the picture gradually passes through the bamboo shadows in the foreground, narrowing the focus from his dancing posture to his well-defined face. His sharp and focused eyes are clearly visible, and the cold light of the sword is reflected in his pupils, as if the whole world is left with only him and the sword in his hand. The whole scene is filled with an ultimate tranquility and restrained sense of power in the classical oriental aesthetics.", + "seed": 25742, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_9/index_1485_seed_25742_dp_18_rank_36_sample_1_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 0, + "sample_idx_in_group": 1, + "avg": -0.014365490432828665, + "vlm_logprob": -0.014365490432828665, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.75, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.014365490432828665, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush, verdant bamboo forest with misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a swordsman wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe and a white headband visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a flowing dance with a thin, gleaming sword, including actions like spinning and the sword tip touching the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a horizontal cut across the scene and then move closer steadily and calmly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement eventually narrow the focus to the swordsman's well-defined face and sharp, focused eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.015115716494619846 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.265115737915039 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.015115716494619846, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.25, + "token_credit_reward": -0.015115716494619846, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.28928422927856445, + 0.07932237535715103, + 0.03996166214346886, + 0.0501132570207119, + 0.05104856938123703, + 0.062268879264593124, + 0.22349056601524353, + 0.03845631703734398, + 0.11538922041654587, + 0.050664953887462616 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.015115716494619846 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush, verdant bamboo forest with misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a swordsman wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe and a white headband visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a flowing dance with a thin, gleaming sword, including actions like spinning and the sword tip touching the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a horizontal cut across the scene and then move closer steadily and calmly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement eventually narrow the focus to the swordsman's well-defined face and sharp, focused eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0028313808143138885 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.87783145904541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0028313808143138885, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.875, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0028313808143138885, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24870893359184265, + 0.09039187431335449, + 0.04284759983420372, + 0.03993658721446991, + 0.04066472500562668, + 0.29134103655815125, + 0.058269206434488297, + 0.06746899336576462, + 0.024957701563835144, + 0.09541331231594086 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0028313808143138885 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush, verdant bamboo forest with misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a swordsman wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe and a white headband visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a flowing dance with a thin, gleaming sword, including actions like spinning and the sword tip touching the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a horizontal cut across the scene and then move closer steadily and calmly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement eventually narrow the focus to the swordsman's well-defined face and sharp, focused eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.006737728603184223 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.00673770904541 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.006737728603184223, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.006737728603184223, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.1188230887055397, + 0.13693426549434662, + 0.08180610835552216, + 0.035139985382556915, + 0.02220708690583706, + 0.3898922801017761, + 0.02626616880297661, + 0.10326499491930008, + 0.03071320615708828, + 0.05495283752679825 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.006737728603184223 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush, verdant bamboo forest with misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a swordsman wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe and a white headband visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a flowing dance with a thin, gleaming sword, including actions like spinning and the sword tip touching the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a horizontal cut across the scene and then move closer steadily and calmly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement eventually narrow the focus to the swordsman's well-defined face and sharp, focused eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0430486686527729 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -3.168048620223999 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0430486686527729, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 3.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0430486686527729, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.10866667330265045, + 0.042641859501600266, + 0.038364067673683167, + 0.12327904999256134, + 0.0699566900730133, + 0.26439011096954346, + 0.028229249641299248, + 0.057486750185489655, + 0.12108245491981506, + 0.14590299129486084 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 5, + 9, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0430486686527729 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush, verdant bamboo forest with misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a swordsman wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe and a white headband visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a flowing dance with a thin, gleaming sword, including actions like spinning and the sword tip touching the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a horizontal cut across the scene and then move closer steadily and calmly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement eventually narrow the focus to the swordsman's well-defined face and sharp, focused eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004093957599252462 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504094123840332 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004093957599252462, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004093957599252462, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.12853215634822845, + 0.07792305946350098, + 0.08200891315937042, + 0.09414397180080414, + 0.044077351689338684, + 0.10769408196210861, + 0.06349088996648788, + 0.05211811140179634, + 0.11810451745986938, + 0.23190690577030182 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004093957599252462 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, horizontal camera cuts across a tranquil, lush, verdant bamboo forest. Sunlight filters through the towering bamboo leaves, casting soft shafts of light in the misty air and casting dappled, swaying shadows on the ground. At the center of the frame, a swordsman, clad in a flowing, pure white silk robe, stands. His features are handsome, his long, dark hair held back by a simple white headband. He wields a thin, gleaming sword in his hand, performing a flowing, flowing dance. His movements are not meant for combat, but rather imbued with the rhythmic quality of dance. Sometimes he spins gracefully, his wide sleeves tracing elegant arcs through the air; sometimes he descends steadily, the tip of his sword lightly touching the ground, stirring up a cloud of fine dust. With each swing, the thin blade precisely captures and reflects the scattered light from the forest, leaving behind trails of silver light, like ripples on water. As the camera moves closer steadily and calmly, the picture gradually passes through the bamboo shadows in the foreground, narrowing the focus from his dancing posture to his well-defined face. His sharp and focused eyes are clearly visible, and the cold light of the sword is reflected in his pupils, as if the whole world is left with only him and the sword in his hand. The whole scene is filled with an ultimate tranquility and restrained sense of power in the classical oriental aesthetics.", + "seed": 25743, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_9/index_1485_seed_25743_dp_19_rank_38_sample_2_slot_0.mp4", + "sample_idx": 0, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 2, + "avg": -0.02765350271947682, + "vlm_logprob": -0.02765350271947682, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.65, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.02765350271947682, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush, verdant bamboo forest with misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a swordsman wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe and a white headband visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a flowing dance with a thin, gleaming sword, including actions like spinning and the sword tip touching the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a horizontal cut across the scene and then move closer steadily and calmly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement eventually narrow the focus to the swordsman's well-defined face and sharp, focused eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.00651450315490365 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.131514549255371 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.00651450315490365, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.00651450315490365, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24545133113861084, + 0.16457964479923248, + 0.07780954241752625, + 0.04462570324540138, + 0.044686175882816315, + 0.04745643585920334, + 0.031142570078372955, + 0.03887328878045082, + 0.05190549045801163, + 0.2534697949886322 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 0, + 1 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.00651450315490365 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush, verdant bamboo forest with misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a swordsman wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe and a white headband visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a flowing dance with a thin, gleaming sword, including actions like spinning and the sword tip touching the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a horizontal cut across the scene and then move closer steadily and calmly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement eventually narrow the focus to the swordsman's well-defined face and sharp, focused eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.002208653138950467 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.127208709716797 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.002208653138950467, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.002208653138950467, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.08457069098949432, + 0.05948522686958313, + 0.3124505579471588, + 0.0626210942864418, + 0.03458796441555023, + 0.038700636476278305, + 0.026548543944954872, + 0.022037900984287262, + 0.0360247902572155, + 0.3229725658893585 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.002208653138950467 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush, verdant bamboo forest with misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a swordsman wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe and a white headband visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a flowing dance with a thin, gleaming sword, including actions like spinning and the sword tip touching the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a horizontal cut across the scene and then move closer steadily and calmly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement eventually narrow the focus to the swordsman's well-defined face and sharp, focused eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.004096925724297762 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.504096984863281 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.004096925724297762, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.004096925724297762, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.16162200272083282, + 0.08341802656650543, + 0.26980623602867126, + 0.07570473849773407, + 0.06784825026988983, + 0.03848600387573242, + 0.0602605864405632, + 0.038635533303022385, + 0.04545270651578903, + 0.15876591205596924 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 2, + 0, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.004096925724297762 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush, verdant bamboo forest with misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a swordsman wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe and a white headband visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a flowing dance with a thin, gleaming sword, including actions like spinning and the sword tip touching the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a horizontal cut across the scene and then move closer steadily and calmly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement eventually narrow the focus to the swordsman's well-defined face and sharp, focused eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.11291243135929108 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.23791241645813 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.11291243135929108, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.11291243135929108, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.19578398764133453, + 0.16452690958976746, + 0.2141330987215042, + 0.06502629071474075, + 0.02845419943332672, + 0.027662374079227448, + 0.024323362857103348, + 0.014751303941011429, + 0.050844982266426086, + 0.2144935578107834 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 2, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.11291243135929108 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush, verdant bamboo forest with misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a swordsman wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe and a white headband visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a flowing dance with a thin, gleaming sword, including actions like spinning and the sword tip touching the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a horizontal cut across the scene and then move closer steadily and calmly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement eventually narrow the focus to the swordsman's well-defined face and sharp, focused eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.01253500021994114 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -4.387535095214844 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.01253500021994114, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 4.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.01253500021994114, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.049372777342796326, + 0.05704580247402191, + 0.07713583111763, + 0.02889340929687023, + 0.030830733478069305, + 0.016089623793959618, + 0.01467826310545206, + 0.02081448584794998, + 0.08096618205308914, + 0.6241729259490967 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 8, + 2 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.01253500021994114 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + }, + { + "prompt": "slow, horizontal camera cuts across a tranquil, lush, verdant bamboo forest. Sunlight filters through the towering bamboo leaves, casting soft shafts of light in the misty air and casting dappled, swaying shadows on the ground. At the center of the frame, a swordsman, clad in a flowing, pure white silk robe, stands. His features are handsome, his long, dark hair held back by a simple white headband. He wields a thin, gleaming sword in his hand, performing a flowing, flowing dance. His movements are not meant for combat, but rather imbued with the rhythmic quality of dance. Sometimes he spins gracefully, his wide sleeves tracing elegant arcs through the air; sometimes he descends steadily, the tip of his sword lightly touching the ground, stirring up a cloud of fine dust. With each swing, the thin blade precisely captures and reflects the scattered light from the forest, leaving behind trails of silver light, like ripples on water. As the camera moves closer steadily and calmly, the picture gradually passes through the bamboo shadows in the foreground, narrowing the focus from his dancing posture to his well-defined face. His sharp and focused eyes are clearly visible, and the cold light of the sword is reflected in his pupils, as if the whole world is left with only him and the sword in his hand. The whole scene is filled with an ultimate tranquility and restrained sense of power in the classical oriental aesthetics.", + "seed": 25744, + "video_path": "./outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/rl_samples/0000298/group_9/index_1485_seed_25744_dp_19_rank_38_sample_3_slot_1.mp4", + "sample_idx": 1, + "ranks_per_group": 2, + "group_idx": 9, + "rank_in_group": 1, + "sample_idx_in_group": 3, + "avg": -0.019424570444971322, + "vlm_logprob": -0.019424570444971322, + "vlm_yes_no_margin": 4.95, + "vlm_token_credit": -0.019424570444971322, + "vlm_yes_ratio": 1.0, + "vlm_num_questions": 5.0, + "reward_records": [ + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q1", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush, verdant bamboo forest with misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a swordsman wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe and a white headband visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a flowing dance with a thin, gleaming sword, including actions like spinning and the sword tip touching the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a horizontal cut across the scene and then move closer steadily and calmly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement eventually narrow the focus to the swordsman's well-defined face and sharp, focused eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.007298473734408617 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.007298469543457 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.007298473734408617, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.0, + "token_credit_reward": -0.007298473734408617, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.2612467408180237, + 0.09388705343008041, + 0.062370024621486664, + 0.12011541426181793, + 0.05077377334237099, + 0.06088403984904289, + 0.14878802001476288, + 0.06244843825697899, + 0.07076509296894073, + 0.06872142851352692 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 3 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.007298473734408617 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q2", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush, verdant bamboo forest with misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a swordsman wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe and a white headband visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a flowing dance with a thin, gleaming sword, including actions like spinning and the sword tip touching the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a horizontal cut across the scene and then move closer steadily and calmly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement eventually narrow the focus to the swordsman's well-defined face and sharp, focused eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0017216873820871115 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -6.3767218589782715 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0017216873820871115, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 6.375, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0017216873820871115, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.24271827936172485, + 0.2533259987831116, + 0.028952492401003838, + 0.04605076462030411, + 0.016954315826296806, + 0.022510206326842308, + 0.20913264155387878, + 0.04395391047000885, + 0.039226874709129333, + 0.0971745103597641 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 1, + 0, + 6 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0017216873820871115 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q3", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush, verdant bamboo forest with misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a swordsman wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe and a white headband visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a flowing dance with a thin, gleaming sword, including actions like spinning and the sword tip touching the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a horizontal cut across the scene and then move closer steadily and calmly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement eventually narrow the focus to the swordsman's well-defined face and sharp, focused eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.0031947072129696608 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.753194808959961 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.0031947072129696608, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.75, + "token_credit_reward": -0.0031947072129696608, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.20835289359092712, + 0.11365967988967896, + 0.07128023356199265, + 0.0414494052529335, + 0.05794209614396095, + 0.04746429994702339, + 0.17328514158725739, + 0.08982837945222855, + 0.07428250461816788, + 0.12245538085699081 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 0, + 6, + 9 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.0031947072129696608 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q4", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush, verdant bamboo forest with misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a swordsman wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe and a white headband visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a flowing dance with a thin, gleaming sword, including actions like spinning and the sword tip touching the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a horizontal cut across the scene and then move closer steadily and calmly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement eventually narrow the focus to the swordsman's well-defined face and sharp, focused eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.07896201312541962 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -2.5789620876312256 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.07896201312541962, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 2.5, + "token_credit_reward": -0.07896201312541962, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.09889934211969376, + 0.17119476199150085, + 0.022776728495955467, + 0.028119241818785667, + 0.01813361980021, + 0.02304498292505741, + 0.08417342603206635, + 0.0337657704949379, + 0.05863388255238533, + 0.46125826239585876 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 1, + 0 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.07896201312541962 + }, + { + "sample_idx": 0, + "question_id": "q5", + "question": "You are a careful video question-answering assistant.\nUse only visually grounded evidence from the video, and do not guess unseen details.\n\nGiven an AI generated video, answer the following atomic visual questions using only evidence from the video.\n\nRules:\n- Answer each question independently.\n- Use concise canonical phrases.\n- Do not add explanations.\n- For \"yes_no\" questions, answer with \"Yes\" or \"No\" only.\n- Return valid JSON only.\n\nOutput format:\n{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"...\"}]}\n\nSub-questions:\n- {\"id\": \"q1\", \"question\": \"Is the scene set in a lush, verdant bamboo forest with misty air?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q2\", \"question\": \"Is a swordsman wearing a flowing, pure white silk robe and a white headband visible at the center of the frame?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q3\", \"question\": \"Is the swordsman performing a flowing dance with a thin, gleaming sword, including actions like spinning and the sword tip touching the ground?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q4\", \"question\": \"Does the camera start with a horizontal cut across the scene and then move closer steadily and calmly?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}\n- {\"id\": \"q5\", \"question\": \"Does the camera movement eventually narrow the focus to the swordsman's well-defined face and sharp, focused eyes?\", \"answer_type\": \"yes_no\"}", + "ref_answer": "{\"sub_answers\": [{\"id\": \"q1\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q2\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q3\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q4\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}, {\"id\": \"q5\", \"answer\": \"Yes\"}]}", + "target_answer": "Yes", + "pred_sentence": "Yes", + "normalized_pred_keywords": [ + "Yes" + ], + "target_logprob_tokens": [ + -0.005945970769971609 + ], + "opposite_logprob_tokens": [ + -5.130946159362793 + ], + "logprob_reward": -0.005945970769971609, + "yes_no_margin_reward": 5.125, + "token_credit_reward": -0.005945970769971609, + "yes_ratio_reward": 1.0, + "frame_importance": [ + 0.096686452627182, + 0.042874809354543686, + 0.0320998840034008, + 0.03665192425251007, + 0.020628932863473892, + 0.02063157968223095, + 0.11723839491605759, + 0.02421625889837742, + 0.10162970423698425, + 0.5073420405387878 + ], + "top_frames": [ + 9, + 6, + 8 + ], + "selected_reward": -0.005945970769971609 + } + ], + "vlm_decoded_outputs": [ + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes", + "Yes" + ] + } +] \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A dog is sitting in the yard, then it suddenly starts running in circles.-12.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A dog is sitting in the yard, then it suddenly starts running in circles.-12.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..35556cfd6516bd6dd6fe51d9d7a8a75962991a8d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A dog is sitting in the yard, then it suddenly starts running in circles.-12.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:7aeb874c5d9f66b17dbad66584623fb6a19c9209f1506c004a44fed0a718ad4f +size 988743 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A dog is sitting in the yard, then it suddenly starts running in circles.-15.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A dog is sitting in the yard, then it suddenly starts running in circles.-15.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ee7dc8bed228f4092daa24c2fdb889fcfd6a45dc --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A dog is sitting in the yard, then it suddenly starts running in circles.-15.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:fcd659f35a089a1fa5ef381c129c9d4d2d4a629b522a79783914daa6c34e36f6 +size 916842 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A person is eating ice cream.-0.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A person is eating ice cream.-0.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..29508e641fc3ae9a50838953b52cd653c7aa262d --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A person is eating ice cream.-0.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:edd2eba9960a96547afe35797d9567ecdfe8b62028b31334c482c0a84a40fd45 +size 738825 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A person is eating ice cream.-15.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A person is eating ice cream.-15.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5b50e842969c61ec47f9994a5740361b85ef3ff2 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A person is eating ice cream.-15.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:ac802aea320d32838cc768a0b15cfbc9a6a4248900d00a4fa9420d5a7ca1554c +size 507161 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A person is eating ice cream.-7.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A person is eating ice cream.-7.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..7f3aded5a578c9fb4efbe363cd19a5dd45eace91 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A person is eating ice cream.-7.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:a4cdaf6c488856424621d950c415022e1a10b8b8f624e045ede2f3005d040721 +size 551147 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A person is eating ice cream.-9.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A person is eating ice cream.-9.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..31008795fd1be41d821da1ad5c6f72357e752512 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A person is eating ice cream.-9.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:659a21a3c7e3565e1ac48127285a3daa56c4b830659b7dde9c390f9809096ef6 +size 562989 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A river changes from blue to brown.-13.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A river changes from blue to brown.-13.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..5399b234e9ea67760150292adce4ac911d4201af --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A river changes from blue to brown.-13.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:8d2664a732bd21c1695f1e2c135048aa1f0e402e19dee638c11e9232f8baee52 +size 911702 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A river changes from blue to brown.-2.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A river changes from blue to brown.-2.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f7d55d65a0c954dc9069c20caac39771bd3072d3 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A river changes from blue to brown.-2.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:565e5566f42767bfbab737ca4c6bfbc86d6bf96937571e3d0ac083c7445fdc14 +size 1102036 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A wooden toy is placed gently on the surface of a small bowl of water.-18.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A wooden toy is placed gently on the surface of a small bowl of water.-18.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..1c01742eab2ddf1327f8b1d385048365a7741407 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/A wooden toy is placed gently on the surface of a small bowl of water.-18.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:ca6c8a1d50872f10fd21e890d6a3aa9098f7c9ced1c9f16460d5bcc91da39849 +size 334811 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/One person picks out clothes for another person.-13.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/One person picks out clothes for another person.-13.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..ac75774f81c845c36951b630276f8a173145359c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/One person picks out clothes for another person.-13.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:d90c9b16dc9527cedc88feaf5463c20b380604f9f86ee6bf6c4c99f49db349b2 +size 665060 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/One person picks out clothes for another person.-14.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/One person picks out clothes for another person.-14.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..87a8dd720e6462c109fe549df2e44f29b272a648 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/One person picks out clothes for another person.-14.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:dc9b6faffd3d17c2cfbf8e5474ea371d689ad724acbd57a0921a46a9d146955e +size 708502 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/One person picks out clothes for another person.-9.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/One person picks out clothes for another person.-9.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f9df50853bc34d413a2a761a43d1981e2c6808ed --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/One person picks out clothes for another person.-9.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:1fbc6ae47fae046e19a3fa14c99a5bf491fe1db9f75087b9f45ad00256d250c1 +size 724100 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/The camera circles around. Garden.-11.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/The camera circles around. Garden.-11.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..f20b58957583f15f64937e69101f8ac34bea4fcc --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/The camera circles around. Garden.-11.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:cace647fd388b5fb492c1c21369806a4319c1f94d4931b693743109105c13e24 +size 1536876 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/The camera circles around. Garden.-16.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/The camera circles around. Garden.-16.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..fc7e54104df18692d3799746d605a734fd6e57d1 --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/The camera circles around. Garden.-16.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:5e18ce475c5f3ea7231ea7f911fb6d8d5a42d1b46b0582213a32024af8b1b647 +size 1591582 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/The camera circles around. Garden.-18.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/The camera circles around. Garden.-18.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..bd5a1d1ed5ae68f058c5dff43ea4d88751cdbb5c --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/The camera circles around. Garden.-18.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:54448dad591c6660b10de4e85411cd75daed3bee34a064ccb560ffeb2e3d38af +size 1711776 diff --git a/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/The camera circles around. Garden.-4.mp4 b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/The camera circles around. Garden.-4.mp4 new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..14c31ad3d50265e13af288d5b79d265256dc6abf --- /dev/null +++ b/outputs/yw006-4-sage-qwen35-9b-token-credit-video-adv-2/vbench2_eval/step_100/videos/Diversity/The camera circles around. Garden.-4.mp4 @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1 +oid sha256:c359031a8923bca986215a54f8d5cec20e0c2d059239dd366eeb3c5523292a7b +size 1422615